id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11457v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11457v2 | When Do LLMs Need Retrieval Augmentation? Mitigating LLMs' Overconfidence Helps Retrieval Augmentation | 2024-02-18T04:57:19 | 2024-06-11T08:08:47 | Shiyu Ni, Keping Bi, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have been found to have difficulty knowing they
do not possess certain knowledge and tend to provide specious answers in such
cases. Retrieval Augmentation (RA) has been extensively studied to mitigate
LLMs' hallucinations. However, due to the extra overhead and unassured quality
of retrieval, it may not be optimal to conduct RA all the time. A
straightforward idea is to only conduct retrieval when LLMs are uncertain about
a question. This motivates us to enhance the LLMs' ability to perceive their
knowledge boundaries to help RA. In this paper, we first quantitatively measure
LLMs' such ability and confirm their overconfidence. Then, we study how LLMs'
certainty about a question correlates with their dependence on external
retrieved information. We propose several methods to enhance LLMs' perception
of knowledge boundaries and show that they are effective in reducing
overconfidence. Additionally, equipped with these methods, LLMs can achieve
comparable or even better performance of RA with much fewer retrieval calls. | [
-0.703252375125885,
-0.6896535754203796,
0.9315469264984131,
0.0002182631433242932,
-0.10909412801265717,
0.21657045185565948,
-0.2398795783519745,
-0.8405879735946655,
0.08374778181314468,
0.4016389548778534,
-0.43075522780418396,
-0.16419249773025513,
-0.6233059167861938,
0.11965780705213547,
-0.15164567530155182,
0.5892122983932495,
0.1339421272277832,
0.09334365278482437,
-0.7124643325805664,
0.0532829724252224,
-0.5009132623672485,
-0.5055896043777466,
-0.5665197968482971,
-0.5821607112884521,
0.34553927183151245,
0.4185768961906433,
0.8457911610603333,
0.3584367334842682,
0.6531912684440613,
0.31656065583229065,
-0.2851826250553131,
0.5843920111656189,
-0.5223751068115234,
0.3355664014816284,
-0.26309898495674133,
-0.9673406481742859,
-0.0957525297999382,
-0.23444589972496033,
0.58303302526474,
0.8620375394821167,
-0.13597235083580017,
-0.11028856784105301,
0.054773468524217606,
0.7985000610351562,
-1.113812804222107,
-0.039516936987638474,
-0.7317935228347778,
0.049915947020053864,
-0.06498027592897415,
-0.3894873857498169,
-0.2004610002040863,
-0.4550151228904724,
0.25520461797714233,
-0.6171461343765259,
-0.10346360504627228,
0.2653704583644867,
0.6229047179222107,
0.4793406128883362,
-0.5116661190986633,
-0.126198872923851,
-0.8734425902366638,
0.7610321044921875,
-0.49087581038475037,
0.6626802682876587,
0.8126304745674133,
0.20916901528835297,
-0.2996889650821686,
-0.5216091871261597,
-0.36138421297073364,
-0.5243934392929077,
-0.1790565699338913,
0.0686289370059967,
-0.1310632824897766,
0.21088191866874695,
0.5201830267906189,
0.5575854182243347,
-0.21859432756900787,
0.012717261910438538,
-0.4374961256980896,
-0.29725363850593567,
0.49484410881996155,
0.10773705691099167,
0.00936359167098999,
-0.05073649808764458,
-0.4561273455619812,
0.09224370121955872,
-0.8003404140472412,
-0.05933477729558945,
0.2666034996509552,
-0.1660832017660141,
0.5394703149795532,
0.9065666198730469,
-0.21565529704093933,
0.548899233341217,
0.09387718886137009,
-0.0036390821915119886,
0.20733974874019623,
-0.21787254512310028,
-0.0006012420053593814,
0.10703857988119125,
0.25575023889541626,
0.24793361127376556,
0.28015264868736267,
-0.17825232446193695,
-0.4287050664424896,
-0.03830322250723839,
0.4325184226036072,
-0.7908557057380676,
0.10393187403678894,
0.3196709454059601,
-0.12259340286254883,
0.11955723166465759,
0.03909721598029137,
-0.3469959795475006,
-0.6493421196937561,
-0.36449718475341797,
0.8216367363929749,
-0.596823513507843,
-0.20937256515026093,
0.17101868987083435,
-0.28532645106315613,
0.13406966626644135,
0.49330785870552063,
-0.6196030378341675,
0.3276858627796173,
0.655501663684845,
0.6952059268951416,
-0.16622720658779144,
-0.0031720648985356092,
-0.5387548804283142,
0.14539270102977753,
-0.5748732686042786,
0.736077070236206,
-0.6352207064628601,
-0.5469199419021606,
-0.08763159811496735,
-0.22292137145996094,
0.0440032072365284,
-0.7284344434738159,
0.5757026076316833,
-0.841422975063324,
0.2324339747428894,
-0.6947009563446045,
-0.8947680592536926,
-0.31118831038475037,
0.3408959209918976,
-0.48358508944511414,
1.025774598121643,
0.019530050456523895,
-0.7174781560897827,
0.247909814119339,
-0.3063587546348572,
-0.5065416693687439,
0.07175993919372559,
-0.2515886723995209,
-0.07076838612556458,
0.4060463607311249,
0.38143259286880493,
0.09965021908283234,
-0.03812622278928757,
-0.15609019994735718,
-0.22582286596298218,
-0.5046513080596924,
0.6535229086875916,
-0.3904452323913574,
0.34599241614341736,
0.2099391669034958,
0.10670582205057144,
-0.2704354524612427,
-0.48730626702308655,
0.17582111060619354,
-0.30389392375946045,
-0.21810106933116913,
-0.7152727246284485,
0.030810603871941566,
-0.6311507821083069,
-0.0713106021285057,
0.514390766620636,
-0.6535218358039856,
0.017328647896647453,
-0.7744719386100769,
0.045386798679828644,
0.6391782164573669,
0.26371893286705017,
0.4657737910747528,
-0.6678457260131836,
0.48648199439048767,
-0.10156798362731934,
0.12651494145393372,
0.13231779634952545,
-0.34444567561149597,
-0.8101913332939148,
-0.02096223272383213,
-0.004968933295458555,
0.5895082950592041,
-0.8604389429092407,
0.33445805311203003,
0.017862984910607338,
-0.4783739447593689,
-0.6283787488937378,
0.3110063970088959,
0.2597302794456482,
0.4286491572856903,
0.6552501916885376,
-0.1642390787601471,
-0.8155505061149597,
-0.6867839694023132,
-0.08452847599983215,
-0.1582430899143219,
-0.038655687123537064,
0.49481630325317383,
0.3665902316570282,
-0.09040086716413498,
0.9125036001205444,
-0.6925586462020874,
-0.4770820438861847,
-0.20322081446647644,
-0.07135692238807678,
-0.00024684271193109453,
0.34760215878486633,
0.22092391550540924,
-0.9454990029335022,
-0.04736442491412163,
0.013099664822220802,
-0.7386040091514587,
0.012209230102598667,
-0.04064659774303436,
-0.027482951059937477,
0.272673100233078,
0.6567049622535706,
-0.8913927674293518,
0.25955167412757874,
0.18247760832309723,
0.14114290475845337,
0.41466081142425537,
-0.5263797640800476,
0.11989912390708923,
-0.7100347876548767,
-0.08416737616062164,
-0.14195604622364044,
-0.1954752802848816,
-0.34282824397087097,
0.19014766812324524,
0.04182891175150871,
0.3671641945838928,
-0.20636826753616333,
0.5186915397644043,
-0.7081459164619446,
-0.20347853004932404,
-0.4315716028213501,
0.4791121184825897,
0.18404246866703033,
-0.018358467146754265,
-0.053120385855436325,
0.875911295413971,
0.555953860282898,
-0.7421008944511414,
0.36778926849365234,
0.24147634208202362,
-0.40068042278289795,
0.6648749113082886,
-0.42476701736450195,
0.1344473958015442,
-0.44569265842437744,
0.15565459430217743,
-1.1849819421768188,
-0.14867277443408966,
0.1100626066327095,
-0.6539730429649353,
0.4408201575279236,
-0.010179471224546432,
-0.23851674795150757,
-0.41377055644989014,
-0.4895471930503845,
0.3021292984485626,
0.4611704647541046,
-0.4940628409385681,
0.6589795351028442,
0.2651723623275757,
-0.02486775442957878,
-0.8163883686065674,
-0.8290318250656128,
0.11423896253108978,
-0.055757660418748856,
-0.47633159160614014,
0.41570737957954407,
-0.29097530245780945,
-0.4093499481678009,
-0.023880640044808388,
-0.40202197432518005,
0.10650964081287384,
0.0925651341676712,
0.149940624833107,
0.26041465997695923,
-0.13566534221172333,
0.5632691979408264,
-0.08598947525024414,
-0.07144726812839508,
0.28983771800994873,
-0.19230476021766663,
0.46687760949134827,
0.06984780728816986,
-0.6810541152954102,
-0.026370041072368622,
0.07374155521392822,
0.27983734011650085,
-0.3541531264781952,
0.8210256099700928,
0.5380077362060547,
-0.556288480758667,
0.01894407533109188,
-1.2266926765441895,
-0.6001743078231812,
-0.508395791053772,
0.31399571895599365,
-0.33089718222618103,
-0.9260546565055847,
0.6486319303512573,
0.011883515864610672,
-0.3602958023548126,
0.27281466126441956,
0.3401166796684265,
-0.10445723682641983,
0.9808701276779175,
0.4395284354686737,
-0.06113964691758156,
0.46630287170410156,
-0.06359457224607468,
-0.03171958029270172,
-1.0902339220046997,
-0.4766729474067688,
-0.49167677760124207,
-0.1500135064125061,
-0.5950501561164856,
-0.46422070264816284,
0.5437098145484924,
0.1087835282087326,
0.06391792744398117,
-0.09895115345716476,
-0.34086132049560547,
0.622334897518158,
0.4374052584171295,
0.6037503480911255,
0.5322653651237488,
-0.05588425323367119,
0.013667835853993893,
-0.2660282850265503,
-0.48335400223731995,
-0.034992314875125885,
0.9902492165565491,
0.30918532609939575,
1.0704913139343262,
0.0926978811621666,
0.5112038850784302,
0.1571328490972519,
0.019699901342391968,
-0.8691174387931824,
0.5691426396369934,
0.20543259382247925,
-0.7420459389686584,
-0.40623506903648376,
-0.6700731515884399,
-0.8576493859291077,
0.2118963599205017,
-0.45003852248191833,
-0.735027015209198,
0.35154104232788086,
0.04095643013715744,
-0.58253413438797,
0.05687110871076584,
-0.5127997994422913,
0.13748550415039062,
-0.21659670770168304,
-0.4712379276752472,
-0.39507827162742615,
-0.5765601396560669,
0.39025741815567017,
-0.17381905019283295,
0.0011595492251217365,
0.22384513914585114,
-0.41481122374534607,
0.3923685848712921,
-0.40871554613113403,
0.7168623208999634,
-0.023103229701519012,
-0.17876292765140533,
0.3044235110282898,
0.11221607029438019,
0.8602554798126221,
-0.014719050377607346,
-0.2235817313194275,
-0.33647435903549194,
-0.08456245809793472,
-0.03249020129442215,
-1.002984881401062,
0.7081145644187927,
-0.6194486021995544,
-1.0140784978866577,
-0.3547317385673523,
-0.53629070520401,
-0.45075708627700806,
-0.008304738439619541,
0.29598093032836914,
0.21842361986637115,
0.11024773865938187,
0.3239191472530365,
0.9999802112579346,
-0.12062811106443405,
0.04686222970485687,
0.4675542116165161,
-0.3939918875694275,
-0.3387385904788971,
0.7104776501655579,
0.4939032196998596,
0.4031815528869629,
0.4173106849193573,
0.1520882099866867,
-0.7257227301597595,
-0.7071472406387329,
-0.017003344371914864,
0.24932032823562622,
-0.8564803600311279,
-0.36447906494140625,
-0.7167887091636658,
-0.5388445258140564,
-0.3463251292705536,
0.18488192558288574,
-0.18916133046150208,
-0.4969049394130707,
-0.2797771692276001,
-0.40242573618888855,
0.7577334046363831,
0.628566563129425,
-0.28617697954177856,
0.17047157883644104,
-0.7805884480476379,
0.23100635409355164,
0.3722499907016754,
0.24325421452522278,
0.04948200285434723,
-0.7917329668998718,
-0.25407493114471436,
0.17533569037914276,
-0.14193041622638702,
-0.7474819421768188,
0.2577808201313019,
0.20916996896266937,
0.852844774723053,
0.3269880712032318,
0.41402333974838257,
0.8545006513595581,
-0.09693657606840134,
0.44153109192848206,
-0.2746208608150482,
-0.852375864982605,
0.529269278049469,
0.0680936649441719,
0.0711962878704071,
0.40303274989128113,
0.58531653881073,
-0.26231709122657776,
-0.6377968192100525,
-0.3675621449947357,
-0.97084641456604,
0.3454234302043915,
0.2116335928440094,
0.27227747440338135,
-0.02527593821287155,
0.6263561248779297,
-0.19323508441448212,
0.38855281472206116,
-0.44216063618659973,
-0.1458066999912262,
0.1341855376958847,
0.22389252483844757,
0.0028376271948218346,
-0.5039128065109253,
-0.23232252895832062,
-0.20002608001232147,
0.6076078414916992,
-0.026619544252753258,
0.026454081758856773,
0.542230486869812,
-0.224775031208992,
-0.5104137063026428,
0.29428014159202576,
0.6529265642166138,
0.8351736664772034,
-0.4325837790966034,
0.28445106744766235,
0.6480662822723389,
-0.4429837465286255,
-0.040270641446113586,
0.09272931516170502,
-0.01549054216593504,
-0.3045274019241333,
0.27526310086250305,
0.6636954545974731,
-0.025139911100268364,
-0.5961816906929016,
0.44111010432243347,
0.28566405177116394,
0.11716587096452713,
-0.44628772139549255,
0.18185000121593475,
0.004748018924146891,
0.5868082642555237,
0.6974824070930481,
0.1093413457274437,
0.29600417613983154,
-0.5472148060798645,
0.30684855580329895,
0.8169907927513123,
-0.30731087923049927,
0.15564265847206116,
0.37718382477760315,
-0.2209702581167221,
-0.11838845908641815,
0.5274755954742432,
-0.19458045065402985,
-0.6246906518936157,
0.36101430654525757,
0.6538470387458801,
0.4611177146434784,
-0.3157435953617096,
-0.07163327187299728,
0.2803669571876526,
0.550885021686554,
-0.29238182306289673,
0.30167409777641296,
0.06326540559530258,
-0.8800642490386963,
-0.719542384147644,
-0.3014530837535858,
-0.5136287808418274,
0.04287169501185417,
-0.7949425578117371,
-0.0007528553251177073,
-0.413501113653183,
-0.3597666025161743,
-0.48873171210289,
0.1998511701822281,
-0.3205757439136505,
0.34019315242767334,
0.02890213020145893,
0.9431186318397522,
-0.4504922330379486,
0.5882236361503601,
0.5173132419586182,
-0.4405937194824219,
-0.4865949749946594,
-0.02422618865966797,
-0.19223353266716003,
-1.0515624284744263,
0.5683826208114624,
0.08991038799285889,
-0.24970950186252594,
0.06058696657419205,
-0.5106503367424011,
-0.8331128358840942,
0.8575165867805481,
0.3119865655899048,
-0.4939624071121216,
-0.01339012011885643,
0.06678204238414764,
0.6545498371124268,
-0.12432897090911865,
0.5449764728546143,
0.5290334224700928,
0.6644527912139893,
0.5283547043800354,
-0.7020137310028076,
0.2040063440799713,
0.13139168918132782,
-0.07282272726297379,
0.243732288479805,
-0.4289535582065582,
0.7487446069717407,
-0.6808410286903381,
-0.11974728852510452,
0.10055247694253922,
0.6710730195045471,
0.33844104409217834,
0.24192802608013153,
0.5257458090782166,
0.4254034459590912,
1.00310218334198,
-0.037410806864500046,
1.020941138267517,
-0.11869759857654572,
0.08117552846670151,
1.134818434715271,
-0.21813401579856873,
1.0562561750411987,
0.6911993622779846,
-0.1267300397157669,
0.2104562371969223,
0.5306144952774048,
0.052812863141298294,
0.37800467014312744,
0.2674718499183655,
-0.32834556698799133,
-0.6610682606697083,
-0.5171114802360535,
-0.6375722289085388,
0.2981593906879425,
0.7615705132484436,
-0.17552891373634338,
-0.12012700736522675,
0.21031758189201355,
-0.08747981488704681,
0.19533276557922363,
-0.2977418303489685,
0.8115316033363342,
0.3130999505519867,
-0.7028083205223083,
0.6654403209686279,
-0.3679477572441101,
0.5538782477378845,
-0.5957590937614441,
0.06091877073049545,
-0.37008053064346313,
0.2003633677959442,
-0.507095217704773,
-1.1038275957107544,
0.25411146879196167,
-0.5215038657188416,
-0.07019201666116714,
0.2016163468360901,
0.9322364330291748,
-0.5335996150970459,
-0.49926361441612244,
0.5481126308441162,
0.7734594941139221,
0.10930393636226654,
-0.5476118922233582,
-0.3915776014328003,
0.03475736826658249,
-0.10221637040376663,
-0.27611982822418213,
0.20953509211540222,
0.6929327845573425,
0.007762795314192772,
1.2140552997589111,
0.6605327129364014,
0.45459097623825073,
-0.03995133936405182,
0.056788764894008636,
1.0300313234329224,
-0.46828243136405945,
-0.003580742049962282,
-0.9962185025215149,
0.2609630823135376,
-0.13132219016551971,
0.04685894772410393,
0.9301961064338684,
0.5209074020385742,
0.7069613337516785,
0.2443581074476242,
0.7366446852684021,
0.19517549872398376,
0.5930854678153992,
-0.7695573568344116,
0.47193363308906555,
-0.8537750244140625,
0.6007106304168701,
-0.08476487547159195,
-0.991054117679596,
-0.24429409205913544,
0.6629770994186401,
-0.5689040422439575,
0.32315048575401306,
0.5228325724601746,
1.1198731660842896,
0.1152227446436882,
-0.016588084399700165,
0.5737818479537964,
0.2937706410884857,
0.06623586267232895,
0.5500043034553528,
1.2755610942840576,
-0.3074195086956024,
0.763314425945282,
-0.24545063078403473,
0.04350166395306587,
-0.2968657314777374,
-0.652292013168335,
-0.8205363154411316,
-0.38939565420150757,
-0.1182788833975792,
-0.39295804500579834,
0.2605595290660858,
1.0952095985412598,
0.4436400830745697,
-0.5686540007591248,
-0.010360153391957283,
0.1563623547554016,
0.413534939289093,
0.0997157171368599,
-0.22954201698303223,
0.06987504661083221,
-0.6500588655471802,
-0.48214319348335266,
0.4853563904762268,
0.17061038315296173,
0.39562445878982544,
-0.41432347893714905,
0.02312287501990795,
-0.17515680193901062,
0.18797491490840912,
0.4607580006122589,
0.15754318237304688,
-0.5909825563430786,
-0.5474683046340942,
0.28716179728507996,
-0.18479450047016144,
0.27142947912216187,
0.4668331444263458,
-0.8081733584403992,
0.4423375725746155,
0.5773445963859558,
0.7852078676223755,
0.4218907952308655,
0.2994697391986847,
0.6745190024375916,
-0.9399986863136292,
-0.09021208435297012,
0.23542222380638123,
0.3285262882709503,
0.4959714710712433,
-0.6822260022163391,
0.4436401426792145,
0.12934021651744843,
-0.614938497543335,
-0.8396293520927429,
0.23515604436397552,
-0.6917726397514343,
-0.22045233845710754,
1.209614872932434,
0.0698317289352417,
-0.02869928441941738,
-0.25552093982696533,
-0.49225232005119324,
0.0705803856253624,
-0.39521512389183044,
0.8368688821792603,
0.8167666792869568,
-0.0742693692445755,
-0.3362080454826355,
-0.5248315930366516,
0.6133505702018738,
0.5671293139457703,
-0.7453520894050598,
-0.04830840602517128,
0.32914990186691284,
0.06756310164928436,
0.43894335627555847,
0.41164371371269226,
0.10467122495174408,
0.14396710693836212,
-0.2234230786561966,
-0.17270055413246155,
-0.07735996693372726,
-0.2075602263212204,
-0.1263294368982315,
0.02546318806707859,
0.5033220052719116,
-0.18305198848247528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11456v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11456v2 | FactPICO: Factuality Evaluation for Plain Language Summarization of Medical Evidence | 2024-02-18T04:45:01 | 2024-06-05T01:27:00 | Sebastian Antony Joseph, Lily Chen, Jan Trienes, Hannah Louisa Göke, Monika Coers, Wei Xu, Byron C Wallace, Junyi Jessy Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Plain language summarization with LLMs can be useful for improving textual
accessibility of technical content. But how factual are these summaries in a
high-stakes domain like medicine? This paper presents FactPICO, a factuality
benchmark for plain language summarization of medical texts describing
randomized controlled trials (RCTs), which are the basis of evidence-based
medicine and can directly inform patient treatment. FactPICO consists of 345
plain language summaries of RCT abstracts generated from three LLMs (i.e.,
GPT-4, Llama-2, and Alpaca), with fine-grained evaluation and natural language
rationales from experts. We assess the factuality of critical elements of RCTs
in those summaries: Populations, Interventions, Comparators, Outcomes (PICO),
as well as the reported findings concerning these. We also evaluate the
correctness of the extra information (e.g., explanations) added by LLMs. Using
FactPICO, we benchmark a range of existing factuality metrics, including the
newly devised ones based on LLMs. We find that plain language summarization of
medical evidence is still challenging, especially when balancing between
simplicity and factuality, and that existing metrics correlate poorly with
expert judgments on the instance level. | [
0.019449176266789436,
-0.4729483723640442,
0.904605507850647,
0.4044114351272583,
-0.4534546136856079,
-0.19614185392856598,
-0.4481295645236969,
-0.36359819769859314,
0.2804255485534668,
0.32342445850372314,
-0.11737699061632156,
-0.7750484943389893,
-0.9064760804176331,
0.3372124135494232,
-0.1489076465368271,
1.6269724369049072,
-0.09293067455291748,
0.318142831325531,
-0.329780638217926,
-0.5145537257194519,
-0.16633859276771545,
-0.3261151611804962,
-0.129235178232193,
0.017269600182771683,
0.5689324140548706,
0.38405364751815796,
0.6277264356613159,
0.6740657687187195,
0.800624668598175,
0.3209063410758972,
-0.08608539402484894,
0.21722714602947235,
-0.3891615569591522,
0.061437152326107025,
-0.2254372090101242,
-0.676843523979187,
-0.45594334602355957,
0.16600632667541504,
0.3524252772331238,
0.5996050834655762,
-0.2615285813808441,
0.019259393215179443,
-0.2246263027191162,
0.7170894742012024,
-0.6421334743499756,
0.22511954605579376,
-0.5497957468032837,
0.09518853574991226,
-0.06699980050325394,
-0.3526116609573364,
-0.2601569890975952,
-0.9562218189239502,
0.19630299508571625,
-0.7223671674728394,
0.5365246534347534,
0.33263128995895386,
0.8629574775695801,
0.30330073833465576,
-0.47490304708480835,
-0.6371001601219177,
-0.40460720658302307,
0.5375491380691528,
-0.8422738313674927,
0.10276944190263748,
-0.040002789348363876,
0.3231287896633148,
-0.2776436507701874,
-0.7237828969955444,
-0.44628775119781494,
-0.4166576862335205,
-0.37749025225639343,
0.4195042848587036,
0.08668296784162521,
0.10057836025953293,
0.39546167850494385,
0.5157672166824341,
-0.4828296899795532,
-0.12346892058849335,
-0.4144331216812134,
-0.5301358699798584,
0.4746485650539398,
-0.004653083626180887,
0.3972871005535126,
-0.1486528217792511,
-0.45088544487953186,
0.22139911353588104,
-0.7935029864311218,
-0.09764297306537628,
-0.12374838441610336,
0.031952451914548874,
-0.513847827911377,
0.7895569801330566,
-0.19644318521022797,
0.23209261894226074,
-0.11379294842481613,
-0.7381470799446106,
0.1562008112668991,
-0.5400503873825073,
-0.024122508242726326,
0.16671599447727203,
0.7854056358337402,
0.7787283062934875,
0.024514080956578255,
-0.10900525748729706,
0.039881426841020584,
-0.14812710881233215,
-0.060251105576753616,
-0.7782119512557983,
-0.15750223398208618,
0.49296748638153076,
-0.4668186902999878,
-0.32563701272010803,
-0.06638843566179276,
-0.3725535273551941,
-0.39187008142471313,
-0.028337731957435608,
0.08386216312646866,
-0.41441768407821655,
0.02254643104970455,
0.06496225297451019,
-0.2603917419910431,
-0.08789178729057312,
0.7339692711830139,
-0.4713452160358429,
0.5104376673698425,
0.5667847394943237,
0.9378225803375244,
-0.40755632519721985,
-0.1737240105867386,
-0.46478790044784546,
0.037260036915540695,
-0.41307497024536133,
1.1968700885772705,
0.0009530198876745999,
-0.28448885679244995,
-0.09557005017995834,
-0.09858796000480652,
-0.18700551986694336,
-0.49410396814346313,
1.0638564825057983,
-0.2241319715976715,
0.3539322316646576,
-0.4418400824069977,
-0.7476434707641602,
-0.08754213154315948,
0.4217905104160309,
-0.5433543920516968,
0.6132183074951172,
-0.26425901055336,
-0.8365969061851501,
0.7674399614334106,
-0.45812782645225525,
-0.7068681120872498,
-0.042871929705142975,
-0.46571534872055054,
-0.5023419857025146,
0.2448638528585434,
0.0655592530965805,
0.29661017656326294,
-0.4166533648967743,
0.6348477005958557,
-0.19817456603050232,
-0.2850654721260071,
0.44296127557754517,
-0.29582077264785767,
0.4376656711101532,
0.2961358428001404,
-0.21116407215595245,
0.04477265104651451,
-0.6888887286186218,
-0.3111266791820526,
-0.10268542915582657,
-0.5891961455345154,
-0.3066004514694214,
0.17640843987464905,
-0.03710490092635155,
0.3282868564128876,
0.1597372591495514,
-0.5280190110206604,
0.05516168475151062,
-0.3722345530986786,
-0.05264383181929588,
0.281463086605072,
0.2344868779182434,
-0.11994718760251999,
-0.5444051623344421,
0.0937606543302536,
-0.1648247241973877,
0.20509058237075806,
0.035422515124082565,
-0.7121174931526184,
-0.45177161693573,
-0.8143590092658997,
0.4510158598423004,
0.48331570625305176,
-0.6471089720726013,
0.4686957895755768,
-0.45457231998443604,
-0.12314750999212265,
-0.234429270029068,
-0.13150042295455933,
0.5987027287483215,
0.8686094880104065,
0.21841003000736237,
-0.25760963559150696,
-0.39041292667388916,
-1.0457370281219482,
-0.42937740683555603,
-0.20799018442630768,
-0.14387674629688263,
0.13162456452846527,
0.7221523523330688,
0.2560465931892395,
0.6856171488761902,
-0.5670984387397766,
-0.2672305107116699,
-0.21615800261497498,
0.5244389772415161,
0.2697192132472992,
0.0435781329870224,
0.5107712745666504,
-0.5862981677055359,
-0.15190385282039642,
-0.014767740853130817,
-0.8786419630050659,
-0.20135603845119476,
-0.12164606153964996,
0.2683073580265045,
0.09711074829101562,
0.19741347432136536,
-0.620238721370697,
0.38880759477615356,
0.34909531474113464,
0.0067728240974247456,
0.47719091176986694,
-0.5679019093513489,
0.6130734086036682,
-0.6576457023620605,
0.24614369869232178,
0.052303023636341095,
-0.1256335824728012,
-0.4999088644981384,
-0.11636112630367279,
0.04890761524438858,
0.19419826567173004,
-0.4755954444408417,
0.329235702753067,
-0.30745041370391846,
-0.004481625743210316,
-0.23914262652397156,
0.3679848313331604,
-0.02178964950144291,
0.2527823746204376,
0.09010230749845505,
0.713050365447998,
0.13689741492271423,
-0.4340319037437439,
0.11422692239284515,
0.13479025661945343,
-0.3979005813598633,
0.588728666305542,
-0.7217647433280945,
-0.3187218904495239,
-0.016448264941573143,
0.3918311893939972,
-0.8199237585067749,
-0.3679644465446472,
0.051440052688121796,
-0.43221741914749146,
0.0738958865404129,
-0.4246164560317993,
-0.4004135727882385,
-0.08652737736701965,
-0.6840554475784302,
0.1910567432641983,
0.2180020958185196,
-0.150615856051445,
0.17880208790302277,
0.3769831657409668,
-0.3414386510848999,
-0.6399864554405212,
-0.34824854135513306,
0.4555947184562683,
0.1530674248933792,
-0.37474924325942993,
0.1261415034532547,
0.024862101301550865,
-0.38349649310112,
-0.02913602441549301,
-0.2974936068058014,
-0.06626655906438828,
-0.030929988250136375,
0.06553355604410172,
0.2999482750892639,
-0.2191365659236908,
0.1359470933675766,
0.30490103363990784,
0.10262120515108109,
0.34798580408096313,
0.367141455411911,
0.059835124760866165,
-0.020368503406643867,
-0.4091874063014984,
-0.26186153292655945,
0.11362454295158386,
0.499679297208786,
0.184950590133667,
0.37552347779273987,
-0.004562987480312586,
-0.3574117422103882,
0.148685023188591,
-0.5823184847831726,
0.0008825397817417979,
-0.30587249994277954,
0.09291104972362518,
-0.19354861974716187,
-0.6925499439239502,
0.40966638922691345,
-0.20724591612815857,
0.19079512357711792,
0.6412338018417358,
0.6705135703086853,
-0.29462307691574097,
0.6592905521392822,
0.15415780246257782,
0.19832423329353333,
-0.18999716639518738,
0.02067752368748188,
0.049762994050979614,
-0.45511946082115173,
-0.37657228112220764,
-0.41792747378349304,
0.039008595049381256,
-0.7475596070289612,
-0.5772542953491211,
0.6652049422264099,
-0.3444971442222595,
0.36691734194755554,
0.017324384301900864,
-0.13583634793758392,
0.4396952986717224,
0.2847316563129425,
0.25930163264274597,
0.8275877237319946,
-0.16325391829013824,
-0.16019567847251892,
-0.17340441048145294,
-0.8253687620162964,
-0.6011274456977844,
1.2544090747833252,
0.22188185155391693,
0.44081079959869385,
0.07642393559217453,
0.5804365277290344,
0.47462451457977295,
0.8424821496009827,
-0.9911234974861145,
0.45290958881378174,
-0.0572507306933403,
-0.8741865754127502,
-0.011729146353900433,
-0.4162709712982178,
-0.5565172433853149,
0.2421666979789734,
-0.6507798433303833,
-0.22812765836715698,
0.16224288940429688,
0.1386227160692215,
-0.4333730936050415,
0.09171929955482483,
-0.6723727583885193,
0.32030075788497925,
-0.3159383535385132,
-0.20833228528499603,
-0.25040534138679504,
-0.7496798634529114,
0.8184360861778259,
0.06992685049772263,
0.49542415142059326,
-0.2968737781047821,
-0.4140481948852539,
0.7533890604972839,
-0.7860413193702698,
0.603061318397522,
0.14823153614997864,
0.004332404583692551,
0.01624753326177597,
-0.187843456864357,
0.36810705065727234,
0.503692626953125,
0.19293586909770966,
0.22758230566978455,
0.06851989775896072,
-0.5480690598487854,
-0.7299819588661194,
0.7709438800811768,
-0.37722674012184143,
-0.519056499004364,
-0.8930305242538452,
-0.49843695759773254,
-0.24701659381389618,
0.17429623007774353,
0.32244768738746643,
0.516346275806427,
-0.6565316319465637,
-0.0895448625087738,
0.7702226042747498,
-0.0930001512169838,
-0.032389771193265915,
0.7475345134735107,
0.31375402212142944,
-0.61227947473526,
0.6639465689659119,
0.1012130156159401,
-0.02480754442512989,
0.5524012446403503,
0.36214596033096313,
-0.1692558079957962,
-1.1196303367614746,
-0.38474440574645996,
0.3917028307914734,
-0.6309830546379089,
-0.06587589532136917,
-0.5691116452217102,
-0.01146052684634924,
-0.29426202178001404,
0.04334859177470207,
-0.3474685847759247,
-0.7377576231956482,
0.43298906087875366,
-0.20711806416511536,
0.39296916127204895,
0.7427230477333069,
-0.09965668618679047,
-0.018532073125243187,
-0.5955110788345337,
0.6880601644515991,
0.0574699267745018,
0.38155925273895264,
-0.5721099972724915,
-0.453002393245697,
-0.293200820684433,
-0.26111456751823425,
-0.011071992106735706,
-0.5862569212913513,
0.04192808270454407,
-0.01681290939450264,
0.4961435794830322,
0.6338759064674377,
0.330310583114624,
0.37464773654937744,
-0.4919758439064026,
0.4815636873245239,
0.4561486542224884,
-0.5718402862548828,
0.643598735332489,
-0.4211803078651428,
-0.05887963995337486,
0.8588910698890686,
0.5105350613594055,
-0.3963305652141571,
-0.5172990560531616,
-0.6378911137580872,
-0.785639762878418,
0.6064035892486572,
0.47603487968444824,
-0.46308523416519165,
-0.049423638731241226,
0.2784551978111267,
0.28775280714035034,
0.3445914387702942,
-0.31836435198783875,
-0.46029651165008545,
-0.08124314248561859,
-0.3990745544433594,
0.14264553785324097,
-0.40732529759407043,
-1.0155216455459595,
0.02708273008465767,
0.44331127405166626,
-0.13787949085235596,
0.02170378901064396,
0.48141178488731384,
-0.261561781167984,
0.10876545310020447,
0.470280259847641,
1.059814691543579,
0.902919590473175,
-0.6624799370765686,
0.38805294036865234,
0.2525244653224945,
-0.8506685495376587,
-0.027757102623581886,
0.22692108154296875,
-0.23179753124713898,
0.17393963038921356,
1.0240402221679688,
0.3775770366191864,
0.5167649984359741,
-0.7260120511054993,
0.709478497505188,
-0.36481332778930664,
-0.22853241860866547,
0.07155077159404755,
0.12906083464622498,
-0.2513708770275116,
-0.18960456550121307,
0.36455902457237244,
0.38603439927101135,
0.5372609496116638,
-0.5702387690544128,
0.26999202370643616,
0.08989298343658447,
-0.2533356547355652,
-0.30770888924598694,
0.41127264499664307,
0.4859633445739746,
0.1635187715291977,
-0.08186522126197815,
0.08428383618593216,
-0.05762531980872154,
0.7290445566177368,
0.25851696729660034,
0.6775840520858765,
0.3183479309082031,
0.1385749876499176,
0.4317874312400818,
0.4354618489742279,
-0.2662711441516876,
0.21630257368087769,
0.11312109977006912,
-0.45304369926452637,
-0.6100252270698547,
0.13565900921821594,
-0.9182130098342896,
0.16908882558345795,
-0.4151129424571991,
0.2168283313512802,
-0.6179787516593933,
-0.04795338958501816,
0.01857716031372547,
0.025945689529180527,
-0.22644338011741638,
0.4366461932659149,
-0.3039790093898773,
0.9602354764938354,
-0.9773378968238831,
0.5571497082710266,
0.6711981296539307,
-0.33423325419425964,
-0.42352864146232605,
0.14665330946445465,
0.2048099935054779,
-0.8702516555786133,
0.2803329527378082,
-0.14801503717899323,
-0.3067421615123749,
-0.6943584084510803,
-0.7095075845718384,
-0.709153413772583,
1.0877913236618042,
0.2642286717891693,
-0.3527697026729584,
0.18843598663806915,
-0.01785021275281906,
0.7178057432174683,
-0.23967920243740082,
0.48542705178260803,
0.4141489565372467,
0.5168678760528564,
0.14106592535972595,
-0.7017253637313843,
0.35113024711608887,
-0.09437797963619232,
-0.37440043687820435,
-0.24065591394901276,
-0.5769057869911194,
0.2469819039106369,
-0.5526307821273804,
-0.24428972601890564,
-0.04261782765388489,
0.6441448926925659,
0.5236397385597229,
0.7949488162994385,
0.29784271121025085,
0.39565789699554443,
0.6840975880622864,
-0.4466092884540558,
1.1644139289855957,
-0.5510818958282471,
0.2737925052642822,
1.0226740837097168,
-0.27581822872161865,
0.3663381040096283,
0.5648643970489502,
-0.4122677743434906,
0.16200338304042816,
0.36779549717903137,
0.3384971618652344,
0.45598646998405457,
0.014525909908115864,
-0.19427576661109924,
0.028531529009342194,
-0.11874841153621674,
-0.39046916365623474,
-0.01229668129235506,
0.29810553789138794,
-0.09453602135181427,
-0.32158684730529785,
-0.3203297257423401,
0.5417885184288025,
0.2718753218650818,
-0.04045270010828972,
0.6636107563972473,
0.12433557957410812,
-0.6596212983131409,
0.4841749966144562,
0.008399922400712967,
0.4886566400527954,
-0.7946532964706421,
-0.09927018731832504,
-0.5488232970237732,
-0.19546456634998322,
-0.4640929400920868,
-0.7583531141281128,
0.2276187390089035,
0.3342140018939972,
-0.222372904419899,
0.40479615330696106,
0.4014902710914612,
-0.0648103728890419,
-0.5491930842399597,
-0.07078202813863754,
0.35255905985832214,
0.2850005030632019,
0.34437817335128784,
-0.5386075973510742,
-0.030488397926092148,
-0.352863073348999,
-0.21931879222393036,
0.18194645643234253,
0.6890119910240173,
-0.17163284122943878,
0.6646286249160767,
0.7050304412841797,
0.5805678963661194,
-0.33976003527641296,
0.2309819757938385,
0.772365391254425,
-0.6020628809928894,
-0.08412287384271622,
-0.6199726462364197,
0.13265152275562286,
-0.39389652013778687,
-0.6684545278549194,
0.8952245116233826,
0.9268202185630798,
0.24227090179920197,
-0.05708110332489014,
0.8699485659599304,
-0.06810257583856583,
0.47547727823257446,
-0.8735812902450562,
0.8178309798240662,
-0.24912481009960175,
0.335157573223114,
-0.08782894164323807,
-0.4592758119106293,
-0.5380877256393433,
0.11930191516876221,
-0.5205649733543396,
-0.1261371374130249,
1.0328047275543213,
0.4932478666305542,
0.012995533645153046,
-0.1831223964691162,
0.19445455074310303,
0.6058984994888306,
0.018843159079551697,
0.0860196053981781,
0.6204065680503845,
-0.48191753029823303,
0.5687577724456787,
-0.18803052604198456,
-0.540167510509491,
-0.5406768321990967,
-1.0199615955352783,
-0.6854800581932068,
-0.07479202747344971,
-0.45418214797973633,
-0.21545031666755676,
0.3818684220314026,
1.0313595533370972,
0.5386351943016052,
-1.0299837589263916,
-0.10739822685718536,
0.16582320630550385,
0.597180962562561,
-0.2995588183403015,
-0.18827906250953674,
0.582976758480072,
-0.22754569351673126,
-0.491066575050354,
0.3387489318847656,
0.6153194904327393,
-0.1413870006799698,
0.3096381425857544,
0.02574857696890831,
-0.20762114226818085,
0.22111856937408447,
0.5399208068847656,
0.3833961486816406,
-0.5504957437515259,
-0.22789624333381653,
-0.1692851483821869,
-0.3371717631816864,
0.3141718804836273,
1.112294316291809,
-0.38242220878601074,
0.37290552258491516,
0.6136529445648193,
0.1176949068903923,
0.33396732807159424,
0.06930617243051529,
0.5231153964996338,
-0.5397143959999084,
0.0018499260768294334,
0.14571480453014374,
0.5255334973335266,
0.23214547336101532,
-0.14961270987987518,
0.4420410692691803,
0.5618830323219299,
-0.29629844427108765,
-0.5668876767158508,
-0.03315333276987076,
-1.2195740938186646,
-0.16556912660598755,
0.9550594091415405,
-0.24848119914531708,
-0.29286056756973267,
-0.5304372906684875,
-0.2761409282684326,
0.2431793212890625,
-0.4914890229701996,
1.1273804903030396,
0.5059377551078796,
-0.2662774622440338,
0.1614808738231659,
-0.6554881930351257,
0.7683519124984741,
0.14467957615852356,
-0.8629484176635742,
-0.09870217740535736,
0.5939276218414307,
0.5493802428245544,
0.1451747566461563,
0.9340085387229919,
-0.3477274775505066,
0.47861677408218384,
-0.1738174855709076,
0.2620912492275238,
0.08065041899681091,
-0.21212808787822723,
-0.2242719978094101,
-0.003414890728890896,
0.12402410060167313,
0.05820998176932335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11455v1 | LoRA-Flow: Dynamic LoRA Fusion for Large Language Models in Generative Tasks | 2024-02-18T04:41:25 | 2024-02-18T04:41:25 | Hanqing Wang, Bowen Ping, Shuo Wang, Xu Han, Yun Chen, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | LoRA employs lightweight modules to customize large language models (LLMs)
for each downstream task or domain, where different learned additional modules
represent diverse skills. Combining existing LoRAs to address new tasks can
enhance the reusability of learned LoRAs, particularly beneficial for tasks
with limited annotated data. Most prior works on LoRA combination primarily
rely on task-level weights for each involved LoRA, making different examples
and tokens share the same LoRA weights. However, in generative tasks, different
tokens may necessitate diverse skills to manage. Taking the Chinese math task
as an example, understanding the problem description may depend more on the
Chinese LoRA, while the calculation part may rely more on the math LoRA. To
this end, we propose LoRA-Flow, which utilizes dynamic weights to adjust the
impact of different LoRAs. The weights at each step are determined by a fusion
gate with extremely few parameters, which can be learned with only 200 training
examples. Experiments across six generative tasks demonstrate that our method
consistently outperforms baselines with task-level fusion weights. This
underscores the necessity of introducing dynamic fusion weights for LoRA
combination. | [
-0.1588032841682434,
-0.8563210964202881,
0.40352874994277954,
0.13780750334262848,
-0.34196794033050537,
0.4165050983428955,
-0.14919798076152802,
-0.5467117428779602,
0.47925227880477905,
0.6589499711990356,
-0.6905415058135986,
-0.39971569180488586,
-0.653348445892334,
-0.13376808166503906,
-0.7233796119689941,
0.9048520922660828,
-0.355317622423172,
-0.25944143533706665,
-0.06734072417020798,
-0.3110229969024658,
-0.3787823021411896,
-0.033267758786678314,
-0.45312151312828064,
-0.7703558206558228,
1.098900318145752,
0.28539323806762695,
0.6822858452796936,
0.6030246615409851,
0.5721580386161804,
0.4659688472747803,
-0.17028340697288513,
0.2476753294467926,
-0.390245258808136,
0.3203153610229492,
-0.08591018617153168,
-0.5088420510292053,
-0.513149619102478,
-0.3134019672870636,
0.8189328908920288,
0.93489009141922,
-0.33775871992111206,
0.0728609636425972,
0.08581199496984482,
0.5808588266372681,
-0.6548619270324707,
-0.00920160673558712,
-0.6812910437583923,
0.22446751594543457,
-0.42990007996559143,
-0.011655258014798164,
-0.03397552669048309,
-0.16081920266151428,
-0.001925955293700099,
-0.6403505206108093,
-0.22934824228286743,
-0.285782128572464,
0.7211923003196716,
0.6685724854469299,
-0.41618356108665466,
-0.007889343425631523,
-0.8395451307296753,
0.6948072910308838,
-0.6050346493721008,
-0.002186165191233158,
-0.02638617530465126,
0.5908130407333374,
0.0443376749753952,
-0.702756941318512,
-0.5693567991256714,
0.07209961116313934,
0.2757702171802521,
0.004009324591606855,
-0.17664603888988495,
-0.0500069297850132,
0.27406930923461914,
0.358951598405838,
-0.23575401306152344,
0.46853411197662354,
-0.34638524055480957,
0.10858163982629776,
0.6452897787094116,
0.3517153561115265,
0.39574843645095825,
0.06183822825551033,
-0.32804033160209656,
-0.10565071552991867,
-0.8703604936599731,
-0.1899729073047638,
0.423137366771698,
0.4794155955314636,
-0.4166959524154663,
0.665607750415802,
-0.45117560029029846,
1.012277364730835,
0.038066960871219635,
-0.4416556656360626,
0.49536702036857605,
-0.29844844341278076,
-0.2694005072116852,
-0.017966095358133316,
0.8705551028251648,
-0.43246737122535706,
-0.0094416793435812,
0.02529330365359783,
-0.30890601873397827,
-0.010639945976436138,
0.023815521970391273,
-0.5559563040733337,
0.08246046304702759,
0.02824198454618454,
-0.21511434018611908,
-0.5329006910324097,
-0.09960777312517166,
-0.6659905910491943,
-0.7199073433876038,
-0.29133865237236023,
0.7579719424247742,
-0.2460092306137085,
-0.16184265911579132,
0.01911180652678013,
-0.10509990155696869,
0.3171781897544861,
0.5710839629173279,
-0.8802241086959839,
0.21549676358699799,
0.609287440776825,
0.7162651419639587,
-0.40583834052085876,
-0.5714446902275085,
-0.9522848725318909,
0.14262805879116058,
0.09274360537528992,
0.9380287528038025,
-0.5226650834083557,
-0.07471989095211029,
0.12538199126720428,
-0.36340653896331787,
-0.07416196912527084,
-0.7140954732894897,
0.2266121208667755,
-0.49103954434394836,
0.07701993733644485,
-0.3428039848804474,
-0.3784686326980591,
-0.07901092618703842,
-0.04347469285130501,
-0.913432240486145,
0.782715380191803,
0.4109566807746887,
-0.6738527417182922,
0.15751518309116364,
-0.7397385835647583,
-0.804228663444519,
0.4590483605861664,
-0.44296276569366455,
-0.2870219349861145,
0.016424566507339478,
-0.14007852971553802,
0.29093310236930847,
-0.2982252538204193,
-0.03291155397891998,
-0.18690447509288788,
-0.49497362971305847,
0.17760545015335083,
-0.2682916522026062,
0.831802248954773,
0.14798256754875183,
-0.4018188416957855,
0.3367982506752014,
-0.8095915913581848,
-0.06616859883069992,
0.26478731632232666,
-0.7254987955093384,
-0.15301916003227234,
0.046015772968530655,
-0.1826384961605072,
0.014865153469145298,
0.35261738300323486,
-0.2740783989429474,
0.2451697736978531,
-0.41548317670822144,
0.3621106743812561,
0.6741340756416321,
-0.28506678342819214,
0.25710901618003845,
-0.30457210540771484,
0.5728484988212585,
-0.10190223902463913,
-0.16757094860076904,
0.012372002005577087,
-0.49373817443847656,
-1.056471824645996,
-0.3600134253501892,
0.25677573680877686,
0.598012387752533,
-1.1941781044006348,
0.506008505821228,
-0.19261549413204193,
-0.6195430755615234,
-0.42972007393836975,
0.7342644929885864,
0.2793128192424774,
0.3335016071796417,
0.08804275095462799,
-0.08845106512308121,
-0.4391142725944519,
-0.6238979697227478,
-0.0431385338306427,
-0.012340775690972805,
0.17011716961860657,
-0.1766544133424759,
0.5560296177864075,
-0.12480410188436508,
0.8035727143287659,
-0.7321341633796692,
-0.4859539270401001,
-0.6432257294654846,
0.38522347807884216,
0.31224092841148376,
0.36699697375297546,
0.4076903462409973,
-0.7240921854972839,
-0.4266575276851654,
0.13200151920318604,
-0.7063695788383484,
-0.25959035754203796,
-0.09653683751821518,
-0.2821519076824188,
-0.012358148582279682,
0.39409640431404114,
-0.6087718605995178,
0.07796116918325424,
0.9784205555915833,
-0.40804538130760193,
0.2744602859020233,
-0.29378795623779297,
-0.33826693892478943,
-1.2512614727020264,
0.006019089370965958,
-0.15903916954994202,
-0.16989946365356445,
-0.6470490097999573,
0.3691105246543884,
-0.1540772169828415,
-0.12839196622371674,
-0.7918415665626526,
0.7101842164993286,
-0.3036011755466461,
-0.10458584129810333,
-0.5511729121208191,
0.3198910653591156,
-0.11924045532941818,
0.5061560273170471,
-0.053385261446237564,
0.42437395453453064,
0.6884340047836304,
-0.5716599225997925,
1.008292555809021,
0.023518769070506096,
-0.6970766186714172,
0.597423791885376,
-0.5561572909355164,
0.061270128935575485,
-0.043920278549194336,
0.23238009214401245,
-0.7231736183166504,
-0.4107096493244171,
0.1101929247379303,
-0.002351106144487858,
0.07186605781316757,
0.17360703647136688,
-0.6020395159721375,
-0.3027317225933075,
-0.081533282995224,
0.5154620409011841,
0.8188989162445068,
-0.529668390750885,
1.1100329160690308,
0.3023165762424469,
0.059046030044555664,
-0.5816713571548462,
-0.810651957988739,
-0.059238251298666,
-0.3574090301990509,
-0.5359139442443848,
0.5756462216377258,
0.05157269164919853,
-0.31657302379608154,
0.20811402797698975,
0.12310244143009186,
-0.08685161918401718,
0.23114027082920074,
0.3449716866016388,
0.2803121507167816,
-0.05424811318516731,
0.05463189259171486,
0.11260516941547394,
-0.1655048280954361,
-0.2498561143875122,
-0.09257753193378448,
0.8595227599143982,
0.21757826209068298,
-0.7744931578636169,
-0.4468352794647217,
0.26775163412094116,
0.625742495059967,
-0.33098021149635315,
1.042803168296814,
0.8849953413009644,
-0.5430249571800232,
-0.376627117395401,
-0.44073769450187683,
0.22503241896629333,
-0.5532385110855103,
0.43460723757743835,
-0.39365631341934204,
-0.9113816022872925,
0.7218548059463501,
0.14230263233184814,
0.3008631467819214,
0.5375875234603882,
0.702358603477478,
-0.2303924858570099,
0.6748446822166443,
0.620682954788208,
-0.24612218141555786,
0.7895832061767578,
-0.3107471764087677,
0.1564967930316925,
-0.6480962038040161,
-0.24937774240970612,
-0.379427969455719,
-0.746065080165863,
-0.3475440442562103,
-0.6587935090065002,
0.4943367838859558,
-0.09090380370616913,
-0.21424776315689087,
0.2849132716655731,
-0.012896893545985222,
0.42407745122909546,
0.5449758768081665,
-0.006602752488106489,
0.4959603548049927,
0.18639534711837769,
0.1231059730052948,
0.5014894604682922,
-0.6890350580215454,
0.010407013818621635,
0.6734274625778198,
0.15014812350273132,
1.1829023361206055,
0.2574407160282135,
0.8205177187919617,
0.18782714009284973,
0.2768480181694031,
-0.8826276659965515,
0.8693526983261108,
-0.5494983792304993,
-0.24532486498355865,
-0.43001678586006165,
-0.6035917401313782,
-1.108124852180481,
0.34448549151420593,
-0.3676256835460663,
-0.5613930225372314,
-0.3230402171611786,
0.23980340361595154,
-0.6546646952629089,
0.5898783206939697,
-0.43944525718688965,
0.4529047906398773,
-0.29652366042137146,
-0.07264599949121475,
-0.4527013599872589,
-0.2200566828250885,
0.5213293433189392,
-0.42613843083381653,
-0.005164403468370438,
-0.21925988793373108,
-0.187003955245018,
0.7468442320823669,
-0.6636398434638977,
1.052803874015808,
0.029593780636787415,
-0.5827186107635498,
0.3787345290184021,
-0.1256708949804306,
0.6202815175056458,
-0.5026677250862122,
0.0877496525645256,
-0.018412381410598755,
-0.3363220691680908,
-0.27325302362442017,
-0.7765657901763916,
0.9053860306739807,
-0.7578160762786865,
-0.626096785068512,
-0.24406838417053223,
-0.7152480483055115,
-0.1546499878168106,
0.18627753853797913,
0.14626511931419373,
0.345661461353302,
0.1509578675031662,
0.22322671115398407,
0.6767240166664124,
-0.2558503746986389,
0.3722292482852936,
0.3805144131183624,
-0.18999649584293365,
-0.3639301061630249,
0.9913110136985779,
0.08094321936368942,
0.5363978147506714,
0.6507283449172974,
0.27498486638069153,
0.05513159930706024,
-0.41603079438209534,
-0.46731266379356384,
0.4117051959037781,
-0.7999938130378723,
-0.30649247765541077,
-0.4791569411754608,
-0.4572686553001404,
-0.0793987363576889,
-0.13730314373970032,
-0.4172779321670532,
-0.2687336802482605,
-0.19407851994037628,
0.1797046661376953,
0.5092074275016785,
0.6963397860527039,
0.18209633231163025,
0.3454250693321228,
-0.8102973103523254,
0.5032275915145874,
0.7716448307037354,
0.37412944436073303,
0.07148455083370209,
-0.5228570699691772,
-0.28835657238960266,
-0.16515658795833588,
-0.2017246037721634,
-0.7399463653564453,
0.14952410757541656,
0.18728753924369812,
0.47694340348243713,
0.5374547839164734,
-0.09581591933965683,
0.7151193022727966,
-0.4095175266265869,
0.6309062242507935,
0.45424315333366394,
-1.0473341941833496,
0.48043516278266907,
-0.4130299389362335,
0.6029840111732483,
0.2372998744249344,
-0.033741939812898636,
-0.5645790100097656,
-0.265402615070343,
-0.2470782995223999,
-0.7388350367546082,
0.43509641289711,
0.16783735156059265,
0.31177085638046265,
0.4856697618961334,
0.2540906071662903,
0.021017558872699738,
0.08109734207391739,
-0.6305323243141174,
-0.21578525006771088,
0.18366526067256927,
-0.5890911221504211,
0.09985256940126419,
0.12856000661849976,
-0.23580223321914673,
-0.17013521492481232,
0.3605751693248749,
-0.24165762960910797,
0.11626597493886948,
-0.41177940368652344,
0.06590859591960907,
-0.26541444659233093,
0.02805657498538494,
0.4551592469215393,
0.48377224802970886,
0.1880768984556198,
0.12199614942073822,
0.5454145669937134,
-0.38978826999664307,
0.05861019715666771,
0.16232483088970184,
-0.2704150676727295,
-0.2044638991355896,
0.6479738354682922,
1.01079261302948,
0.2825187146663666,
-1.0924537181854248,
0.19163651764392853,
0.28457242250442505,
-0.2930406332015991,
-0.24958685040473938,
0.5727834701538086,
0.2445794939994812,
0.4392237663269043,
0.2443527728319168,
-0.13811303675174713,
-0.3017766773700714,
-0.6665794849395752,
-0.1445954442024231,
0.6022909283638,
-0.13615509867668152,
-0.3145197629928589,
0.398483544588089,
0.4898746907711029,
-0.16610324382781982,
0.46337488293647766,
-0.004766345489770174,
-0.3826875686645508,
0.41493552923202515,
0.4475942850112915,
0.8280360102653503,
-0.19852329790592194,
0.1543164998292923,
0.032388731837272644,
-0.1544332504272461,
-0.11914617568254471,
0.4087584316730499,
0.001199368853121996,
-0.9072191715240479,
-0.8502627015113831,
-0.6452632546424866,
-0.40921974182128906,
0.1682843118906021,
-0.3164796531200409,
0.4327230751514435,
-0.3530248999595642,
-0.05658292770385742,
-0.12569692730903625,
-0.08019359409809113,
-0.5830293297767639,
0.03954000025987625,
0.44473594427108765,
0.8174358606338501,
-0.805233895778656,
0.9966313242912292,
0.8256703019142151,
-0.3294256329536438,
-0.6588755249977112,
-0.14197272062301636,
0.06166161224246025,
-0.9483854174613953,
0.8773807883262634,
-0.2982538044452667,
-0.4591354429721832,
-0.11393345892429352,
-0.25900235772132874,
-1.2757418155670166,
1.2607979774475098,
0.41331830620765686,
-0.36893129348754883,
-0.2952483296394348,
0.26995715498924255,
0.38458460569381714,
-0.31438666582107544,
-0.4609525799751282,
0.3109937608242035,
0.3627986013889313,
0.5773202180862427,
-1.0030052661895752,
-0.06545541435480118,
-0.13996249437332153,
-0.17144030332565308,
0.3752278983592987,
-0.7733150720596313,
0.9620146751403809,
-0.28599318861961365,
-0.1696401983499527,
0.2646923363208771,
0.7545880675315857,
0.41098713874816895,
-0.08646860718727112,
0.9076697826385498,
0.6975446939468384,
0.8674269914627075,
-0.19529466331005096,
0.8085294365882874,
-0.08035018295049667,
0.026594366878271103,
1.148820161819458,
-0.5286662578582764,
0.9902395009994507,
0.3464318513870239,
-0.14006903767585754,
0.8107755184173584,
0.17348015308380127,
0.08552463352680206,
0.3945121765136719,
0.36572524905204773,
-0.5428973436355591,
-0.19005563855171204,
-0.2247493714094162,
-0.26621177792549133,
0.7444356679916382,
0.214479461312294,
-0.05466426536440849,
-0.22811079025268555,
0.14779901504516602,
0.07923755049705505,
-0.2001887857913971,
-0.3458777964115143,
0.539587140083313,
0.0820985957980156,
-0.7408523559570312,
0.49554917216300964,
-0.005491375457495451,
0.853998601436615,
-0.9834417104721069,
0.11324639618396759,
-0.2648601233959198,
0.2431771457195282,
-0.3206210136413574,
-0.8098978400230408,
0.15837185084819794,
0.29610487818717957,
0.1280127316713333,
-0.26925167441368103,
0.7034682035446167,
-0.5006453990936279,
-0.6188652515411377,
0.13473905622959137,
0.7496851086616516,
-0.10614284127950668,
0.05760709568858147,
-0.5014135837554932,
0.4881996214389801,
0.009281151928007603,
-0.11148267984390259,
0.4895811378955841,
0.30663353204727173,
0.209189310669899,
0.980658233165741,
0.436047226190567,
0.31474003195762634,
0.015255930833518505,
0.4840910732746124,
1.0387649536132812,
-0.7248237133026123,
-0.3385111689567566,
-0.7834937572479248,
0.5255995988845825,
0.027022838592529297,
-0.1351538598537445,
0.5346971154212952,
0.10187828540802002,
0.546681821346283,
0.16075706481933594,
0.7681177258491516,
-0.24652794003486633,
0.36282607913017273,
-0.7897183895111084,
0.6462916731834412,
-0.7984048128128052,
0.17861343920230865,
-0.25595623254776,
-1.078490138053894,
-0.18844448029994965,
0.44318097829818726,
0.08795707672834396,
0.14133320748806,
0.693084180355072,
0.33333921432495117,
0.055585771799087524,
-0.4171145260334015,
0.2925143837928772,
0.061026256531476974,
0.29643115401268005,
0.8648437261581421,
0.8214907050132751,
-0.2171008139848709,
0.6153736114501953,
-0.1186855360865593,
-0.03602033108472824,
-0.15482334792613983,
-0.9801733493804932,
-0.7483171820640564,
-0.6511620283126831,
-0.7208078503608704,
-0.2695905566215515,
-0.24454131722450256,
0.9516634345054626,
0.7317301034927368,
-0.46884721517562866,
-0.3534068763256073,
0.19072997570037842,
0.23279674351215363,
-0.39633792638778687,
-0.1445097029209137,
0.2203959822654724,
-0.26933789253234863,
-1.0420798063278198,
0.4464417099952698,
0.2640068829059601,
0.20550201833248138,
-0.7329102158546448,
-0.13466615974903107,
0.14089486002922058,
0.020121747627854347,
0.643660306930542,
0.3007931113243103,
-0.6880272030830383,
-0.02308453805744648,
-0.2783668041229248,
-0.051306385546922684,
-0.15558123588562012,
0.8083474040031433,
-0.9792680144309998,
0.07331611961126328,
0.830093264579773,
0.756020724773407,
0.27595847845077515,
-0.1895090639591217,
0.45848220586776733,
-0.5636922717094421,
0.10577797144651413,
-0.12974746525287628,
0.6069837212562561,
0.20959743857383728,
0.03755804896354675,
0.32413846254348755,
0.3019736111164093,
-0.03408125042915344,
-0.7666013240814209,
0.47551488876342773,
-1.2663862705230713,
-0.2365330010652542,
1.2497764825820923,
0.015317978337407112,
-0.10001567751169205,
0.17162509262561798,
-0.03239653259515762,
0.1997869312763214,
-0.11817358434200287,
0.6240320205688477,
0.4896336495876312,
-0.1934376209974289,
-0.13364964723587036,
-0.27774983644485474,
0.24179981648921967,
0.3863109350204468,
-1.10467529296875,
-0.12013077735900879,
0.21230177581310272,
0.12921041250228882,
0.18455246090888977,
0.4439811110496521,
0.19887498021125793,
-0.009270927868783474,
-0.17566652595996857,
-0.08554583787918091,
0.0016178300138562918,
-0.13231806457042694,
-0.19012945890426636,
0.27980417013168335,
0.1719053089618683,
0.01818583905696869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11453v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11453v3 | MatPlotAgent: Method and Evaluation for LLM-Based Agentic Scientific Data Visualization | 2024-02-18T04:28:28 | 2024-03-19T14:44:22 | Zhiyu Yang, Zihan Zhou, Shuo Wang, Xin Cong, Xu Han, Yukun Yan, Zhenghao Liu, Zhixing Tan, Pengyuan Liu, Dong Yu, Zhiyuan Liu, Xiaodong Shi, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scientific data visualization plays a crucial role in research by enabling
the direct display of complex information and assisting researchers in
identifying implicit patterns. Despite its importance, the use of Large
Language Models (LLMs) for scientific data visualization remains rather
unexplored. In this study, we introduce MatPlotAgent, an efficient
model-agnostic LLM agent framework designed to automate scientific data
visualization tasks. Leveraging the capabilities of both code LLMs and
multi-modal LLMs, MatPlotAgent consists of three core modules: query
understanding, code generation with iterative debugging, and a visual feedback
mechanism for error correction. To address the lack of benchmarks in this
field, we present MatPlotBench, a high-quality benchmark consisting of 100
human-verified test cases. Additionally, we introduce a scoring approach that
utilizes GPT-4V for automatic evaluation. Experimental results demonstrate that
MatPlotAgent can improve the performance of various LLMs, including both
commercial and open-source models. Furthermore, the proposed evaluation method
shows a strong correlation with human-annotated scores. | [
-0.16844595968723297,
-0.4107150435447693,
0.6965998411178589,
0.43171215057373047,
-0.45154887437820435,
0.42712539434432983,
-0.3490399420261383,
-0.16144995391368866,
0.20793810486793518,
0.21356777846813202,
-0.2617441415786743,
-1.0043493509292603,
-0.420475035905838,
0.23036529123783112,
-0.2860758602619171,
0.747458815574646,
-0.216278076171875,
0.2691999673843384,
-0.7152134776115417,
-0.08159536123275757,
-0.2680715322494507,
-0.24470195174217224,
-0.5208154916763306,
-0.3549172282218933,
0.2934635877609253,
0.22859753668308258,
0.6914460062980652,
0.8617241382598877,
0.747603178024292,
0.34097903966903687,
0.32430487871170044,
0.30330273509025574,
-0.535909116268158,
0.3433394730091095,
-0.013175991363823414,
-0.4520352780818939,
-0.47190016508102417,
0.2607860863208771,
0.5141451358795166,
0.5652551054954529,
-0.12374961376190186,
0.24842147529125214,
-0.26135602593421936,
0.26374343037605286,
-0.30298104882240295,
0.9013316631317139,
-0.31881970167160034,
0.11582712084054947,
0.07282854616641998,
-0.3307231068611145,
-0.49773457646369934,
-0.3356814980506897,
-0.16744542121887207,
-0.9608915448188782,
0.09322980046272278,
0.11706029623746872,
0.2902512550354004,
0.7057814002037048,
-0.39507153630256653,
-0.038621023297309875,
-0.26621222496032715,
0.8318197131156921,
-0.5864245295524597,
0.04530530422925949,
0.38576772809028625,
0.6409721374511719,
-0.2280253767967224,
-0.9639988541603088,
-0.45288193225860596,
-0.7600101232528687,
-0.06279441714286804,
0.3250214457511902,
-0.06976020336151123,
-0.0009269178262911737,
0.2397671788930893,
-0.13599132001399994,
-0.696545422077179,
-0.017974229529500008,
-0.13793928921222687,
-0.2998111844062805,
0.891031801700592,
0.39096230268478394,
0.35129693150520325,
-0.15389440953731537,
-0.3668910264968872,
-0.4190187156200409,
-0.5369277000427246,
-0.17972081899642944,
0.15608304738998413,
0.14080810546875,
-0.03901505097746849,
0.7228435277938843,
-0.024802712723612785,
0.473527193069458,
-0.5459084510803223,
-0.0071763331070542336,
0.3878144323825836,
-0.20379403233528137,
0.08993751555681229,
0.039532359689474106,
0.8559404015541077,
0.6008728742599487,
0.09593448042869568,
-0.12744128704071045,
-0.21895597875118256,
0.20877480506896973,
0.1045423299074173,
-1.0807690620422363,
-0.3488770127296448,
0.3215331435203552,
-0.32262784242630005,
-0.4156198501586914,
0.04157014191150665,
-0.8398943543434143,
-0.855762779712677,
-0.36262333393096924,
0.2742425501346588,
-0.3438276946544647,
-0.28565675020217896,
-0.08091402053833008,
-0.15614433586597443,
-0.08030668646097183,
0.8351545929908752,
-0.2779858112335205,
0.21356841921806335,
0.9316879510879517,
1.1541132926940918,
-0.5878691673278809,
-0.4859495759010315,
-0.5364269018173218,
0.1678074449300766,
-0.498576283454895,
0.6550851464271545,
-0.8417282700538635,
-0.6362124681472778,
-0.4102783203125,
0.03097917139530182,
-0.10413247346878052,
-0.2915703058242798,
0.5526971817016602,
-0.1966748833656311,
-0.19392791390419006,
-0.2562766671180725,
-0.658987820148468,
-0.2675180435180664,
0.13086824119091034,
-0.7693583965301514,
0.8374634385108948,
-0.04427335411310196,
-0.6691882610321045,
0.35891422629356384,
-1.1420536041259766,
-0.1372629702091217,
0.38963189721107483,
-0.5416089296340942,
-0.4677138030529022,
-0.241606205701828,
0.10187074542045593,
0.640062689781189,
-0.27324989438056946,
0.42167502641677856,
-0.3260439336299896,
-0.4659883379936218,
0.31154897809028625,
-0.31776583194732666,
0.3636195957660675,
0.21258628368377686,
-0.45099008083343506,
0.5289267897605896,
-0.8971852660179138,
-0.14189326763153076,
0.4092661440372467,
-0.11397399008274078,
-0.20158825814723969,
0.14705803990364075,
0.13118377327919006,
-0.08604735881090164,
0.0296173058450222,
-0.6518728733062744,
0.5671319365501404,
0.187094047665596,
0.6251766085624695,
0.6335620880126953,
-0.17164824903011322,
0.27651503682136536,
-0.16991524398326874,
0.7359870672225952,
-0.3874875009059906,
0.004993606824427843,
-0.2395000159740448,
-0.5650373697280884,
-0.41432511806488037,
-0.8521153330802917,
0.288725346326828,
0.27097445726394653,
-0.6731516122817993,
0.012792135588824749,
-0.47622519731521606,
-0.686249315738678,
-0.43515321612358093,
-0.13253971934318542,
0.07113516330718994,
0.5082077980041504,
0.32142436504364014,
0.029815122485160828,
-0.3189084827899933,
-0.6276939511299133,
0.1825222671031952,
-0.14463458955287933,
-0.07476363331079483,
0.3230232298374176,
0.7942379713058472,
-0.4413854777812958,
0.9650174379348755,
-0.5858431458473206,
-0.02405630052089691,
-0.1486199051141739,
0.48860546946525574,
0.06204739212989807,
0.38081422448158264,
0.5004708766937256,
-0.5904432535171509,
-0.3864755928516388,
0.17462927103042603,
-0.758220911026001,
-0.47078827023506165,
-0.08627431839704514,
-0.05112525448203087,
0.05879920721054077,
0.5118421316146851,
-0.8677253723144531,
0.48204296827316284,
0.3741826117038727,
-0.3623064160346985,
0.60561203956604,
-0.33713382482528687,
0.2845381796360016,
-0.562944233417511,
0.26408568024635315,
-0.1303069144487381,
-0.43845415115356445,
-0.6333857774734497,
-0.07955839484930038,
0.180830180644989,
-0.24036255478858948,
-0.232302725315094,
0.542955219745636,
-0.2948322594165802,
-0.24516233801841736,
-0.33927106857299805,
0.10043174028396606,
0.17593933641910553,
0.11016158759593964,
0.12701529264450073,
0.9395872950553894,
0.36950504779815674,
0.05309813469648361,
0.5957185626029968,
0.17493972182273865,
-0.06317400187253952,
0.2730597257614136,
-0.6800183653831482,
0.06232907250523567,
-0.2791454792022705,
0.48471537232398987,
-1.0962892770767212,
-0.3319033980369568,
0.20208953320980072,
-0.16720929741859436,
0.14620062708854675,
-0.1844450980424881,
-0.5951506495475769,
-0.10651499032974243,
-0.5539826154708862,
0.35580307245254517,
0.2551842927932739,
-0.6378980278968811,
0.8027946352958679,
0.10504593700170517,
-0.18621943891048431,
-0.5352790355682373,
-0.5177563428878784,
0.23708845674991608,
-0.21888914704322815,
-0.6352131366729736,
0.22017057240009308,
-0.3142591714859009,
-0.37664708495140076,
-0.15390558540821075,
-0.1637163907289505,
0.3515032231807709,
0.21623271703720093,
0.7043517231941223,
0.31752920150756836,
0.06759767234325409,
0.25462886691093445,
-0.1875360757112503,
-0.2757005989551544,
0.2211250513792038,
0.10027145594358444,
0.6345930695533752,
-0.44630375504493713,
-0.669692873954773,
-0.1993759125471115,
-0.02040066383779049,
0.5877349972724915,
-0.28621506690979004,
0.27964264154434204,
0.5945131182670593,
-0.02376396209001541,
-0.5024383068084717,
-0.41100144386291504,
-0.0812339335680008,
-0.4183831810951233,
0.39491498470306396,
-0.28844767808914185,
-0.53572678565979,
0.5173072218894958,
-0.3404941260814667,
-0.29358309507369995,
0.32751843333244324,
0.6246053576469421,
0.13627512753009796,
1.1211854219436646,
0.30130818486213684,
0.20725464820861816,
0.013414430432021618,
-0.415474534034729,
-0.10066378861665726,
-0.3777099549770355,
-0.2958343029022217,
-0.2936142385005951,
0.0902608260512352,
-0.3432233929634094,
-0.8295853734016418,
0.3647056221961975,
-0.18256177008152008,
-0.10562340170145035,
-0.05142856016755104,
-0.6537048816680908,
0.566071093082428,
0.2365906536579132,
-0.3889823257923126,
0.4340704679489136,
-0.22401338815689087,
-0.1344340741634369,
0.08257030695676804,
-0.47294458746910095,
-0.7132416367530823,
1.3048086166381836,
0.4609377682209015,
0.888676643371582,
-0.09181627631187439,
0.6462154984474182,
0.5230799913406372,
0.5983103513717651,
-0.6256170868873596,
0.7485077977180481,
0.2413831204175949,
-0.02249656617641449,
-0.3171554207801819,
-0.4908544421195984,
-0.9008626937866211,
0.7294155955314636,
-0.051283761858940125,
-0.43375682830810547,
0.13455207645893097,
-0.06342221051454544,
-0.06895380467176437,
0.0037937816232442856,
-0.796991229057312,
0.9523202776908875,
-0.5019128918647766,
-0.45016804337501526,
-0.13115280866622925,
-0.550548255443573,
0.2321866899728775,
-0.3035038709640503,
0.2891148030757904,
-0.4551256597042084,
-0.37650930881500244,
0.6914055347442627,
-0.4852161407470703,
0.7658066749572754,
-0.3717699646949768,
0.18768806755542755,
-0.05251901224255562,
0.2632056772708893,
0.5623849034309387,
0.3867083191871643,
-0.13246086239814758,
0.20547641813755035,
0.17259016633033752,
-0.2245943397283554,
-0.4962315559387207,
0.8242635130882263,
-0.8248843550682068,
-0.46443524956703186,
-0.6983888149261475,
-0.8387165665626526,
0.09979227185249329,
0.07921862602233887,
-0.3882283866405487,
0.0031462095212191343,
-0.09167955070734024,
-0.055130258202552795,
0.11211129277944565,
-0.23975084722042084,
0.5416921377182007,
0.6080606579780579,
-0.6431330442428589,
-0.33486875891685486,
1.0198639631271362,
-0.08714200556278229,
-0.04544784128665924,
-0.19831308722496033,
0.20454168319702148,
-0.23110748827457428,
-0.719437301158905,
-0.4036143720149994,
0.31441041827201843,
-0.8472788333892822,
-0.3339986205101013,
-0.4871129095554352,
0.07696103304624557,
-0.037181928753852844,
-0.06369034945964813,
-0.2776530086994171,
-0.5686489939689636,
-0.206356480717659,
-0.2026403844356537,
0.5921010971069336,
0.7934717535972595,
-0.027568269520998,
0.14889204502105713,
-0.23132102191448212,
0.13975799083709717,
0.14917771518230438,
0.30614280700683594,
-0.24344906210899353,
0.16353364288806915,
-0.02042083628475666,
-0.1543385535478592,
0.04642404243350029,
-0.6464758515357971,
0.6138033866882324,
0.2272389978170395,
0.7182703018188477,
0.2702808678150177,
-0.08683890104293823,
0.3755815625190735,
-0.5109796524047852,
0.710824191570282,
-0.014528514817357063,
-0.9403923153877258,
0.4972965121269226,
-0.3201069235801697,
-0.009458055719733238,
0.506496787071228,
0.2979237735271454,
-0.1367070972919464,
-0.3142763376235962,
-0.21334928274154663,
-0.8567122220993042,
0.5794697999954224,
0.16948750615119934,
-0.356334388256073,
0.20274320244789124,
0.20001031458377838,
0.401572048664093,
0.46791335940361023,
-0.5915622711181641,
-0.0993528887629509,
-0.8019284009933472,
-0.3325464427471161,
-0.42966172099113464,
0.16113197803497314,
-0.5034475326538086,
-0.2631596624851227,
0.46863579750061035,
-0.5164387822151184,
0.06732377409934998,
0.20959506928920746,
-0.5018494725227356,
-0.02501174435019493,
-0.016555732116103172,
0.7636846303939819,
0.986787736415863,
-0.5216245055198669,
0.28324389457702637,
-0.055409856140613556,
-0.6178978085517883,
0.15478162467479706,
0.6312218904495239,
-0.04909486696124077,
0.03557387366890907,
0.5015788078308105,
0.7582587003707886,
-0.16138407588005066,
-0.9396688342094421,
0.8628373146057129,
-0.2468932569026947,
-0.11527971923351288,
-0.24273045361042023,
-0.06590623408555984,
0.12463343888521194,
0.4151468575000763,
0.44221898913383484,
-0.16881532967090607,
0.22125932574272156,
-0.02274741791188717,
0.04022106155753136,
0.6272475123405457,
0.05994848906993866,
-0.222114697098732,
0.8097670078277588,
0.03020709939301014,
0.019461020827293396,
0.17643135786056519,
-0.23348969221115112,
-0.42781203985214233,
0.7117835879325867,
0.24986238777637482,
0.4966546893119812,
-0.2960350215435028,
0.5987152457237244,
-0.07259240001440048,
0.29554638266563416,
0.04519108682870865,
0.2743985652923584,
-0.10064173489809036,
-0.3154168426990509,
-0.7330229878425598,
-0.5628699660301208,
-0.7650392055511475,
-0.21047230064868927,
-0.21105211973190308,
0.16725456714630127,
-0.4124912917613983,
-0.16919828951358795,
0.24872039258480072,
0.1270308643579483,
-0.43820860981941223,
-0.14137035608291626,
0.17589008808135986,
0.7449480295181274,
-0.878900408744812,
0.8537096977233887,
0.7786789536476135,
-0.6546896696090698,
-0.39796510338783264,
-0.45555198192596436,
0.06396521627902985,
-0.8890684247016907,
0.9219362735748291,
0.3033348321914673,
-0.038393862545490265,
-0.12612128257751465,
-0.7107061147689819,
-0.752670407295227,
1.4743430614471436,
0.5156518220901489,
-0.4221765100955963,
0.5427150130271912,
0.5569263100624084,
0.8080156445503235,
-0.6937662363052368,
0.7259442806243896,
0.506445586681366,
0.9008218050003052,
0.11581975966691971,
-0.5549852848052979,
0.2764800190925598,
-0.48581209778785706,
0.027392931282520294,
-0.19309847056865692,
-0.5292121767997742,
0.7945193648338318,
0.03614872694015503,
-0.08433130383491516,
-0.20822711288928986,
0.38020339608192444,
0.3876895308494568,
0.4484652280807495,
0.46331217885017395,
0.3409283757209778,
0.8398260474205017,
-0.26547518372535706,
0.972854733467102,
-0.44996780157089233,
0.5066231489181519,
0.8841090798377991,
-0.6813642382621765,
0.474932998418808,
0.45415833592414856,
-0.10473046451807022,
0.18656913936138153,
0.5008832812309265,
-0.6610777378082275,
0.4279729127883911,
0.5084140300750732,
0.00918490719050169,
-0.22499963641166687,
-0.19110426306724548,
-0.2812041640281677,
0.39198043942451477,
0.29230451583862305,
-0.24024489521980286,
-0.23463504016399384,
0.24095574021339417,
0.1088721826672554,
-0.051448751240968704,
-0.2393546998500824,
0.39569100737571716,
-0.049048010259866714,
-0.25347453355789185,
0.5655751824378967,
-0.159922257065773,
0.2540692687034607,
-0.45658332109451294,
-0.41114264726638794,
-0.1747640073299408,
-0.08731674402952194,
-0.29196861386299133,
-0.6234261989593506,
-0.045168813318014145,
-0.13808131217956543,
0.24733088910579681,
-0.040757916867733,
0.6550450921058655,
-0.35646024346351624,
-0.535627007484436,
0.3556481897830963,
0.5099976062774658,
0.33728325366973877,
0.03928152099251747,
-0.6624792218208313,
0.48049455881118774,
-0.22695913910865784,
-0.4104921817779541,
0.0582023486495018,
0.01953393965959549,
-0.3094971179962158,
1.0012004375457764,
0.8568949699401855,
0.19482384622097015,
0.028458375483751297,
0.4887947142124176,
0.8983963131904602,
-0.4839487671852112,
-0.18301545083522797,
-0.7697792649269104,
0.5272648930549622,
-0.3234342634677887,
0.2693111300468445,
0.7759923338890076,
0.7130396366119385,
0.163713276386261,
-0.08899310976266861,
0.9019734263420105,
0.3493107557296753,
0.3499871790409088,
-0.20690040290355682,
0.8491566777229309,
-0.30939340591430664,
0.516291081905365,
-0.15637733042240143,
-0.9724448919296265,
-0.7045297622680664,
0.603061854839325,
-0.4623830318450928,
-0.014547589235007763,
0.6429112553596497,
0.7880796790122986,
-0.016060303896665573,
0.11039767414331436,
0.28510135412216187,
0.4056756794452667,
0.6748178601264954,
-0.015285906381905079,
1.1201517581939697,
0.30592840909957886,
0.38851234316825867,
-0.21744316816329956,
-0.47239211201667786,
-0.26140204071998596,
-1.1056609153747559,
-1.0516818761825562,
-0.2579053044319153,
-0.39437443017959595,
-0.09160981327295303,
0.06512697041034698,
1.0812742710113525,
0.5252443552017212,
-0.6049107313156128,
-0.26612588763237,
-0.04205654561519623,
-0.06508543342351913,
0.08863186836242676,
-0.1998743861913681,
0.7950146794319153,
-0.23414088785648346,
-0.5761107206344604,
0.6369529962539673,
0.37317991256713867,
-0.04075110703706741,
-0.4710191488265991,
-0.20376378297805786,
0.19200552999973297,
0.04237803816795349,
0.4273686408996582,
-0.04297192022204399,
-0.6483867168426514,
-0.04403798282146454,
-0.29668357968330383,
-0.03635719045996666,
0.1774127185344696,
0.5781840085983276,
-0.6458664536476135,
0.5832008719444275,
0.36990493535995483,
0.5357933640480042,
0.8509584069252014,
0.1614743173122406,
0.35829970240592957,
-0.4700262248516083,
0.13769331574440002,
0.4099882245063782,
0.5816951394081116,
0.5041223168373108,
-0.1610451638698578,
0.934311032295227,
0.1494113653898239,
-0.7774618268013,
-1.0621798038482666,
-0.20775406062602997,
-1.3052321672439575,
-0.2644605338573456,
1.1812838315963745,
-0.26722005009651184,
-0.2765950560569763,
0.17394888401031494,
-0.4462660253047943,
0.002369785448536277,
-0.5703338980674744,
0.6078291535377502,
0.42136138677597046,
-0.3724900186061859,
-0.0357678048312664,
-0.7825287580490112,
0.44620102643966675,
0.21572449803352356,
-1.0782767534255981,
0.05471530556678772,
0.5340670347213745,
0.2595399022102356,
0.21750019490718842,
0.14700597524642944,
0.05254610627889633,
0.1115560233592987,
-0.09989121556282043,
0.477448970079422,
-0.7518061399459839,
-0.010485083796083927,
-0.48269179463386536,
0.2602418065071106,
0.04267054423689842,
0.12643566727638245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11452v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11452v1 | AutoPRM: Automating Procedural Supervision for Multi-Step Reasoning via Controllable Question Decomposition | 2024-02-18T04:28:16 | 2024-02-18T04:28:16 | Zhaorun Chen, Zhuokai Zhao, Zhihong Zhu, Ruiqi Zhang, Xiang Li, Bhiksha Raj, Huaxiu Yao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have shown promise in
multi-step reasoning tasks, yet their reliance on extensive manual labeling to
provide procedural feedback remains a significant impediment. To address this
challenge, in this paper, we propose a novel self-supervised framework AutoPRM
that efficiently enhances the fine-tuning of LLMs for intricate reasoning
challenges. Specifically, AutoPRM first decomposes complex problems into more
manageable subquestions with a controllable granularity switch, then
sequentially apply reinforcement learning to iteratively improve the
subquestion solver. Additionally, we propose context-guided-decoding to avoid
reward tampering and guide the subquestion solver towards the solution of the
holistic problem. Extensive experiments show that AutoPRM significantly
improves performance on mathematical and commonsense reasoning tasks over SOTA.
More encouragingly, AutoPRM can be easily integrated with other orthogonal
reasoning pipelines. | [
-0.4438437819480896,
-0.9372440576553345,
0.5591080784797668,
0.49961915612220764,
0.11465976387262344,
0.0800565630197525,
-0.19473275542259216,
0.12183310836553574,
-0.06056910380721092,
0.8040216565132141,
-0.7290853261947632,
-0.44043397903442383,
-0.5219981074333191,
0.17851267755031586,
-0.17725935578346252,
0.7366726994514465,
-0.3213063180446625,
-0.05302341654896736,
-0.3130299150943756,
0.09887532144784927,
-0.06231975182890892,
-0.570837676525116,
-0.8665913939476013,
-0.4322124719619751,
0.350902795791626,
0.4085219204425812,
0.523465633392334,
0.9855096936225891,
0.3667076528072357,
0.40964779257774353,
0.04196206480264664,
0.6891310811042786,
-0.17699207365512848,
0.3666640818119049,
-0.5765599608421326,
-0.2317146211862564,
-0.421940416097641,
-0.12871861457824707,
0.4031433165073395,
0.5666308999061584,
-0.45446741580963135,
0.010112146846950054,
-0.022695869207382202,
0.2521229684352875,
-0.6356131434440613,
0.649575412273407,
-0.38093313574790955,
0.010490619577467442,
0.2069438397884369,
-0.5428178310394287,
-0.340029239654541,
-0.07707291841506958,
-0.17195972800254822,
-0.6362999677658081,
0.15157674252986908,
0.0878058522939682,
0.4038985073566437,
0.9392729997634888,
-0.3666011393070221,
-0.4281821548938751,
-0.6201410293579102,
0.8086445331573486,
-0.46329814195632935,
0.042296767234802246,
0.2720296382904053,
0.27998027205467224,
-0.38279667496681213,
-0.5739547610282898,
-0.3416137397289276,
-0.004743173718452454,
-0.13338793814182281,
0.07083240896463394,
0.04149915277957916,
0.31266865134239197,
0.15695524215698242,
0.43642041087150574,
-0.5277411937713623,
0.008512216620147228,
0.08838257938623428,
-0.3808649778366089,
0.7194902300834656,
0.5131238698959351,
0.2184891402721405,
-0.1577151119709015,
-0.37371402978897095,
-0.24640542268753052,
-0.3624041974544525,
0.06567835807800293,
0.09984425455331802,
0.26397693157196045,
0.4022964835166931,
0.29999294877052307,
-0.34312188625335693,
0.8159931302070618,
0.22575338184833527,
-0.11556408554315567,
-0.0802396610379219,
-0.4123842418193817,
-0.27871668338775635,
-0.17197461426258087,
0.8242538571357727,
-0.07626782357692719,
0.25338464975357056,
0.12576696276664734,
-0.2005179226398468,
-0.18959492444992065,
0.17972905933856964,
-0.7388609647750854,
-0.5550134778022766,
0.19898998737335205,
-0.2046375572681427,
-0.035580892115831375,
-0.18038496375083923,
-0.32903215289115906,
-0.04011893272399902,
-0.6441985964775085,
0.22824744880199432,
-0.3537391722202301,
-0.1987655907869339,
0.4618774652481079,
0.246059849858284,
0.3072325885295868,
0.668946385383606,
-0.8425313830375671,
0.37564998865127563,
0.7959096431732178,
0.38525450229644775,
-0.27115511894226074,
-0.4300738573074341,
-0.7746309638023376,
0.3283921480178833,
-0.5100000500679016,
0.6762831807136536,
-0.6144150495529175,
-0.29257526993751526,
-0.19168850779533386,
0.19185341894626617,
-0.22506411373615265,
-0.7005212903022766,
0.10272220522165298,
-0.3585675358772278,
0.16248659789562225,
-0.052117154002189636,
-0.6026884317398071,
-0.015931444242596626,
0.5943677425384521,
-0.23044508695602417,
1.0328038930892944,
0.059035126119852066,
-0.14223498106002808,
0.14931301772594452,
-0.5521649122238159,
-0.42286837100982666,
0.08805610984563828,
-0.2146136611700058,
-0.3175687789916992,
-0.23923128843307495,
0.5041012763977051,
0.4211403727531433,
-0.03186555579304695,
0.5685608983039856,
-0.24307560920715332,
-0.05207790434360504,
-0.11292754858732224,
-0.17518197000026703,
0.6793493628501892,
0.30262818932533264,
-0.49033790826797485,
0.35694780945777893,
-0.4849305748939514,
0.19924233853816986,
-0.10014157742261887,
-0.15107466280460358,
-0.14468780159950256,
-0.09064216166734695,
-0.40559813380241394,
0.43420806527137756,
0.3012089431285858,
-0.18549565970897675,
0.42946743965148926,
-0.24065420031547546,
0.42645275592803955,
0.6821436285972595,
0.20813386142253876,
0.5949788689613342,
-0.12657621502876282,
0.7573888301849365,
0.14977946877479553,
0.33655044436454773,
-0.4124991297721863,
-0.09493821859359741,
-1.0305979251861572,
-0.4215575158596039,
0.11758270859718323,
0.7001057267189026,
-0.7860962748527527,
0.5205244421958923,
0.38992008566856384,
-0.10269206017255783,
-0.38012975454330444,
0.3183758556842804,
0.6732403039932251,
0.5421379804611206,
0.7981880307197571,
-0.04206332936882973,
-0.16971969604492188,
-0.8554324507713318,
-0.42294397950172424,
-0.022924480959773064,
-0.00873288419097662,
0.42850399017333984,
0.5133129954338074,
-0.3866584599018097,
0.7697610259056091,
-0.5593988299369812,
-0.7795843482017517,
-0.16645674407482147,
0.6194335222244263,
-0.03769851103425026,
0.8835077285766602,
-0.054234087467193604,
-0.4854416847229004,
-0.3896655738353729,
-0.35847488045692444,
-0.6616116166114807,
-0.41083019971847534,
-0.5328012704849243,
-0.14541050791740417,
0.07418137788772583,
1.004549264907837,
-0.5496351718902588,
0.30489450693130493,
0.008245689794421196,
-0.22484786808490753,
0.4632747173309326,
-0.6137080788612366,
-0.008832697756588459,
-0.6368361115455627,
-0.39747685194015503,
-0.03615977242588997,
-0.40987369418144226,
-0.09265328198671341,
0.12499246001243591,
0.20015747845172882,
0.07611465454101562,
-0.21123917400836945,
0.5135961771011353,
-0.6305732131004333,
0.17379574477672577,
-0.34659579396247864,
-0.13378626108169556,
0.033259835094213486,
0.7210593223571777,
0.3323228657245636,
0.553700864315033,
0.6687779426574707,
-0.7016098499298096,
0.4896864891052246,
0.32173141837120056,
-0.0015629964182153344,
0.44488033652305603,
-0.6508036851882935,
0.04325719550251961,
-0.16668929159641266,
0.44936057925224304,
-0.9407234191894531,
-0.2700863778591156,
0.29588863253593445,
-0.2797203063964844,
0.3329344093799591,
-0.29582104086875916,
-0.653476893901825,
-0.046326056122779846,
0.050218287855386734,
0.5425337553024292,
0.2635546624660492,
-0.4862250089645386,
0.8464155793190002,
0.3405556082725525,
-0.40179702639579773,
-0.41890066862106323,
-0.6415691375732422,
0.07606242597103119,
0.09307236224412918,
-0.22214840352535248,
0.2579818069934845,
-0.2503546476364136,
-0.31028106808662415,
-0.06863340735435486,
-0.14280785620212555,
-0.19382743537425995,
-0.06631302833557129,
0.10789711028337479,
-0.08109299093484879,
0.19588159024715424,
0.07380461692810059,
0.4696177542209625,
-0.4652167856693268,
0.5007755160331726,
-0.46598321199417114,
0.36063817143440247,
-0.2836146950721741,
-0.5880976915359497,
-0.28629443049430847,
0.36160987615585327,
0.23617975413799286,
-0.4813821017742157,
0.25634774565696716,
0.3702922761440277,
-0.098915234208107,
-0.8619650602340698,
-0.42802080512046814,
-0.21492289006710052,
-0.5263906717300415,
0.024310244247317314,
-0.5297512412071228,
-1.0706679821014404,
0.3581361174583435,
-0.23139667510986328,
0.027392324060201645,
0.1640397012233734,
0.7582648396492004,
-0.1276230365037918,
1.2914273738861084,
0.16500002145767212,
0.10608559101819992,
0.20442147552967072,
-0.4599754512310028,
0.03342314437031746,
-0.5665580034255981,
-0.5119533538818359,
-0.13545577228069305,
0.013030988164246082,
-0.2953420877456665,
-0.9006661772727966,
0.3894308805465698,
0.01422844547778368,
-0.25883451104164124,
0.14019402861595154,
-0.7377461791038513,
0.5757068395614624,
0.535542368888855,
-0.02052481099963188,
0.43298327922821045,
-0.45860975980758667,
-0.1727844923734665,
0.11252698302268982,
-0.8843623995780945,
-0.21338056027889252,
0.6202116012573242,
0.2958625853061676,
1.072638750076294,
-0.307110071182251,
0.8492382168769836,
0.34578514099121094,
0.09386899322271347,
-0.8438181281089783,
0.6660817861557007,
0.0518825389444828,
-0.541506290435791,
-0.5873150825500488,
-0.5731372237205505,
-0.7404240369796753,
0.4703584611415863,
0.3497072458267212,
-0.17145702242851257,
0.1474553346633911,
0.49536532163619995,
-0.5549560785293579,
-0.008013879880309105,
-0.42532598972320557,
0.8118525147438049,
-0.3022882044315338,
-0.3752206265926361,
-0.1610572189092636,
-0.6561237573623657,
0.3022477328777313,
0.2436480075120926,
0.36392366886138916,
-0.1796969175338745,
-0.04432637244462967,
0.3644273579120636,
-0.8927635550498962,
0.8514417409896851,
-0.3159262537956238,
-0.3407565653324127,
0.3676844537258148,
0.5615524649620056,
0.4470716416835785,
0.46610400080680847,
0.4507925510406494,
-0.19748422503471375,
0.1754211038351059,
-0.4536662697792053,
-0.81770259141922,
0.7226054668426514,
-0.39292147755622864,
-0.8229292631149292,
-0.5942534804344177,
-0.9365323185920715,
-0.24478796124458313,
0.24308381974697113,
-0.06911032646894455,
0.5911223888397217,
0.28390809893608093,
-0.03568070009350777,
1.1582512855529785,
-0.12606538832187653,
0.40372762084007263,
0.576691210269928,
-0.27447056770324707,
-0.33552151918411255,
0.7576266527175903,
-0.12937834858894348,
0.1578553169965744,
0.378558874130249,
0.11354886740446091,
-0.5791681408882141,
-0.5552023649215698,
-0.35087472200393677,
0.18762224912643433,
-0.7300708293914795,
-0.27541396021842957,
-0.7939815521240234,
-0.10017964243888855,
-0.41445857286453247,
-0.014438264071941376,
-0.5045390725135803,
-0.236627459526062,
-0.2434978187084198,
0.004770217463374138,
0.08956313133239746,
0.45382556319236755,
-0.2876172363758087,
0.12365473061800003,
-0.4125266671180725,
0.728394091129303,
0.6594385504722595,
0.26663321256637573,
-0.31799280643463135,
-0.5556353330612183,
0.09116875380277634,
-0.16441500186920166,
0.06381053477525711,
-0.34703439474105835,
0.5252342224121094,
0.10508778691291809,
0.5240432024002075,
0.148855522274971,
0.3598830997943878,
0.7853617668151855,
-0.4449097514152527,
0.4173416197299957,
-0.1472998708486557,
-1.0312001705169678,
0.6851386427879333,
-0.48270362615585327,
0.5670119524002075,
0.6389308571815491,
0.34659960865974426,
-0.15168960392475128,
-0.6182428002357483,
-0.5148955583572388,
-0.8747918009757996,
0.7259962558746338,
-0.11689484119415283,
-0.1370481252670288,
-0.30531591176986694,
0.37606969475746155,
-0.0015988113591447473,
-0.03683887794613838,
-0.46765217185020447,
-0.13762778043746948,
-0.32914015650749207,
-0.16360680758953094,
0.07235326617956161,
-0.208650603890419,
-0.22601354122161865,
-0.522076427936554,
0.6664645075798035,
-0.4360668957233429,
-0.06419672816991806,
0.5172149538993835,
-0.4133807122707367,
-0.09197250753641129,
0.1789446324110031,
0.3211364448070526,
0.6044232249259949,
0.11894435435533524,
0.33283084630966187,
0.15383028984069824,
0.07575201988220215,
0.1561509221792221,
0.08614472299814224,
-0.12962907552719116,
-0.20579949021339417,
0.30122700333595276,
0.42728763818740845,
0.24424892663955688,
-0.7074220776557922,
0.35241392254829407,
-0.07952919602394104,
-0.5381563305854797,
-0.4815484881401062,
0.4050479233264923,
-0.0606347993016243,
0.3490920662879944,
0.3478180468082428,
-0.1816108673810959,
0.2243068665266037,
-0.34519490599632263,
0.3780103325843811,
0.3079630434513092,
-0.25457748770713806,
0.049325816333293915,
0.6541697382926941,
0.025624675676226616,
-0.2828512191772461,
0.5258280038833618,
-0.49548619985580444,
-0.577998161315918,
0.7010505199432373,
0.3531220257282257,
0.6196640729904175,
-0.31468671560287476,
0.33287709951400757,
0.3106395900249481,
0.23063601553440094,
-0.26431283354759216,
0.3409353196620941,
-0.4781729280948639,
-0.5478448271751404,
-0.8976590037345886,
-0.5251006484031677,
-0.7325495481491089,
0.18126201629638672,
-0.8243576288223267,
-0.14933530986309052,
-0.760353147983551,
0.38716140389442444,
-0.3025742173194885,
-0.2783297896385193,
-0.25953617691993713,
0.49208107590675354,
-0.053165651857852936,
0.7325529456138611,
-0.5346761345863342,
0.8835602402687073,
0.5363581776618958,
-0.2679663598537445,
-0.931664764881134,
-0.1822422742843628,
-0.14162109792232513,
-0.6800209283828735,
0.717230498790741,
-0.08281391113996506,
-0.5408269762992859,
0.22246195375919342,
-0.6151036024093628,
-0.7805028557777405,
0.6760340929031372,
0.17789970338344574,
-0.3795236051082611,
0.016431381925940514,
0.3100641369819641,
0.578701376914978,
-0.3670700788497925,
0.30918681621551514,
0.6792277693748474,
0.5025011301040649,
0.2009028196334839,
-0.9606453776359558,
-0.008960065431892872,
-0.17604482173919678,
-0.06714417785406113,
0.24162283539772034,
-0.8131341338157654,
0.7957353591918945,
-0.0345313586294651,
0.13636282086372375,
-0.1315835416316986,
0.6842677593231201,
0.4311303198337555,
0.23510167002677917,
0.6501656174659729,
0.6080247759819031,
0.4986954927444458,
-0.10002244263887405,
0.6894180178642273,
-0.4823591411113739,
0.46622928977012634,
1.4418656826019287,
-0.024082999676465988,
0.262710839509964,
0.3652472496032715,
0.06071905791759491,
0.4737115204334259,
0.6928349733352661,
0.036722730845212936,
0.5087408423423767,
0.44661256670951843,
-0.03513075038790703,
-0.8785786628723145,
-0.0337691605091095,
-0.125070258975029,
0.6112247109413147,
0.5552398562431335,
-0.20987153053283691,
-0.48540225625038147,
0.07497197389602661,
-0.13753706216812134,
0.3494197428226471,
-0.46455034613609314,
0.8412522077560425,
0.07578369230031967,
-1.009514331817627,
0.7141539454460144,
-0.09121273458003998,
0.4125087261199951,
-0.6090198755264282,
-0.20459884405136108,
-0.4010472595691681,
0.36587849259376526,
-0.24841047823429108,
-0.63868647813797,
0.5016990900039673,
-0.2690961956977844,
0.00807788223028183,
-0.9934065937995911,
0.7434477210044861,
-0.7465143799781799,
-0.2541657090187073,
0.29429709911346436,
0.554836630821228,
0.0851311981678009,
-0.32386812567710876,
-0.9480689167976379,
-0.1998324990272522,
-0.2137582004070282,
-0.3553658425807953,
0.2722296118736267,
0.7543517351150513,
-0.19036392867565155,
1.1645822525024414,
0.5205808877944946,
-0.09671112895011902,
0.1249576285481453,
0.13395340740680695,
1.0062239170074463,
-0.7893348336219788,
-0.5659318566322327,
-0.7908565402030945,
0.19220466911792755,
0.09400571137666702,
-0.1972818523645401,
0.873030424118042,
0.5825430750846863,
0.9900100827217102,
-0.08130468428134918,
0.7375142574310303,
0.13105474412441254,
0.6335771679878235,
-0.4754822850227356,
0.2950448989868164,
-0.41236674785614014,
0.2857142984867096,
0.016793236136436462,
-0.5778865814208984,
-0.36666569113731384,
0.7896651029586792,
-0.4066033661365509,
-0.026874573901295662,
0.598724901676178,
0.7990957498550415,
-0.03400284796953201,
-0.37401244044303894,
0.07286606729030609,
0.03828500211238861,
0.38378629088401794,
0.5985784530639648,
0.9721186757087708,
0.13060487806797028,
0.6556023955345154,
-0.47420617938041687,
-0.26375675201416016,
-0.0855456218123436,
-0.8074314594268799,
-1.0164024829864502,
-0.30265340209007263,
-0.5738756060600281,
-0.12590213119983673,
-0.21389536559581757,
0.9076675772666931,
0.8460230231285095,
-1.0162055492401123,
-0.16554580628871918,
-0.540590763092041,
0.11087395995855331,
-0.24781538546085358,
-0.31601500511169434,
0.2186821550130844,
-0.9662890434265137,
-0.747376561164856,
0.6855936646461487,
0.6716593503952026,
-0.3870980143547058,
-0.5584962368011475,
-0.05710073560476303,
-0.10150350630283356,
0.029996812343597412,
0.4385095536708832,
0.3614276945590973,
-0.7749676704406738,
0.0898890346288681,
0.0428919680416584,
-0.16620370745658875,
-0.01572454534471035,
1.0141205787658691,
-0.7294777631759644,
0.5752261281013489,
0.43062663078308105,
0.7404389977455139,
0.8643403649330139,
0.30612125992774963,
0.5538831353187561,
-0.5866432785987854,
-0.05413836985826492,
0.7157893180847168,
0.2831440269947052,
-0.03687656298279762,
-0.37857070565223694,
0.4633820056915283,
0.11649239808320999,
-0.701144814491272,
-0.5869180560112,
0.4192068576812744,
-0.864158570766449,
-0.542553722858429,
1.2393808364868164,
-0.3768045902252197,
-0.23585225641727448,
-0.44306182861328125,
-0.23010049760341644,
0.08031485229730606,
-0.30143195390701294,
0.8443390727043152,
0.48839184641838074,
-0.6249724626541138,
-0.5351182222366333,
-0.1435508280992508,
0.8004956245422363,
0.8839690089225769,
-0.940653920173645,
0.1725594699382782,
0.6696227192878723,
0.2970684766769409,
-0.06969508528709412,
0.6372883915901184,
-0.18857695162296295,
0.17192059755325317,
-0.2960246205329895,
-0.08370531350374222,
-0.6775872111320496,
-0.6361565589904785,
-0.29857853055000305,
0.3242676258087158,
-0.18068227171897888,
-0.07845732569694519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11451v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11451v2 | SciAgent: Tool-augmented Language Models for Scientific Reasoning | 2024-02-18T04:19:44 | 2024-02-21T03:04:49 | Yubo Ma, Zhibin Gou, Junheng Hao, Ruochen Xu, Shuohang Wang, Liangming Pan, Yujiu Yang, Yixin Cao, Aixin Sun, Hany Awadalla, Weizhu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Scientific reasoning poses an excessive challenge for even the most advanced
Large Language Models (LLMs). To make this task more practical and solvable for
LLMs, we introduce a new task setting named tool-augmented scientific
reasoning. This setting supplements LLMs with scalable toolsets, and shifts the
focus from pursuing an omniscient problem solver to a proficient tool-user. To
facilitate the research of such setting, we construct a tool-augmented training
corpus named MathFunc which encompasses over 30,000 samples and roughly 6,000
tools. Building on MathFunc, we develop SciAgent to retrieve, understand and,
if necessary, use tools for scientific problem solving. Additionally, we craft
a benchmark, SciToolBench, spanning five scientific domains to evaluate LLMs'
abilities with tool assistance. Extensive experiments on SciToolBench confirm
the effectiveness of SciAgent. Notably, SciAgent-Mistral-7B surpasses other
LLMs with the same size by more than 13% in absolute accuracy. Furthermore,
SciAgent-DeepMath-7B shows much superior performance than ChatGPT. | [
-0.06503203511238098,
-0.6179046630859375,
0.530437171459198,
0.6276573538780212,
-0.1538790762424469,
0.566957414150238,
-0.3242991864681244,
-0.4225791394710541,
0.07639031857252121,
0.29755493998527527,
-0.34042465686798096,
-0.30075207352638245,
-0.6121338605880737,
0.4664883315563202,
-0.33934783935546875,
0.7643762230873108,
0.049564387649297714,
0.4614742696285248,
-0.6096561551094055,
0.05506621673703194,
-0.290701299905777,
-0.3696058392524719,
-0.5544668436050415,
-0.4691373109817505,
0.623221755027771,
0.3862445652484894,
0.6718031764030457,
0.6114994883537292,
0.8772026896476746,
0.3968316316604614,
-0.09797246754169464,
0.18691106140613556,
-0.34313637018203735,
0.20659102499485016,
-0.40083619952201843,
-0.6202487349510193,
-0.5086355805397034,
0.0038960566744208336,
0.32854363322257996,
0.9674999117851257,
0.0883389413356781,
0.0132205905392766,
-0.3853927552700043,
0.04012086242437363,
-0.4208149015903473,
0.23506882786750793,
-0.6112125515937805,
-0.09050042927265167,
-0.1456717550754547,
0.0008961212006397545,
-0.48263439536094666,
-0.19532759487628937,
0.010466807521879673,
-0.9346693754196167,
0.42446476221084595,
0.13737690448760986,
0.32660993933677673,
0.4883386194705963,
-0.29698804020881653,
-0.020881084725260735,
-0.5587034821510315,
0.8118355870246887,
-0.5722832679748535,
0.608622670173645,
0.33262771368026733,
0.2219819873571396,
-0.5354008078575134,
-0.8759338855743408,
-0.515963613986969,
-0.4924980700016022,
0.18733762204647064,
-0.005215160083025694,
-0.10310051590204239,
-0.11188281327486038,
0.7242041230201721,
0.06156420707702637,
-0.5704032182693481,
0.04208528622984886,
-0.6469704508781433,
-0.2915266752243042,
0.599833607673645,
0.027670271694660187,
0.056723885238170624,
0.06346110999584198,
-0.03536049649119377,
-0.09661635011434555,
-0.7340660095214844,
-0.29988446831703186,
-0.1882607489824295,
0.03447416424751282,
0.40697088837623596,
0.8010519742965698,
0.10632095485925674,
0.5915207862854004,
-0.10752099007368088,
-0.2485521286725998,
0.19004349410533905,
-0.0953386053442955,
-0.1774894893169403,
0.36179932951927185,
0.5695286393165588,
-0.028305718675255775,
0.1532454788684845,
0.05407169088721275,
-0.07215553522109985,
0.04521680623292923,
0.1292714774608612,
-0.95743328332901,
-0.5602686405181885,
0.09541740268468857,
0.21911285817623138,
-0.37520238757133484,
-0.28262656927108765,
-0.21382305026054382,
-0.7275987863540649,
-0.20913217961788177,
0.19044122099876404,
-0.5518101453781128,
-0.20278964936733246,
0.09362872689962387,
-0.18695275485515594,
-0.2319604903459549,
0.7406841516494751,
-0.43191200494766235,
0.1973646879196167,
0.7845211029052734,
1.018822431564331,
-0.15122193098068237,
-0.37896981835365295,
-0.7575956583023071,
0.09357092529535294,
-0.3567016124725342,
1.0716453790664673,
-0.7620474696159363,
-0.726824164390564,
-0.6061570048332214,
0.05770034343004227,
0.29954755306243896,
-0.346233993768692,
0.44415685534477234,
-0.32529664039611816,
0.13487310707569122,
-0.4344877302646637,
-0.43660441040992737,
-0.0994388535618782,
0.03579099848866463,
-0.728471577167511,
1.2526973485946655,
0.10302972793579102,
-0.6656734347343445,
0.3525841534137726,
-0.9064513444900513,
-0.4042980670928955,
0.5385318398475647,
-0.09777943789958954,
-0.13267451524734497,
0.09909608960151672,
0.16518175601959229,
0.3064848482608795,
-0.4190405011177063,
0.3562772870063782,
-0.5841320753097534,
-0.44015470147132874,
0.3588532507419586,
-0.3905661106109619,
0.5578173398971558,
0.3555951416492462,
-0.0918443575501442,
0.17552803456783295,
-0.6560216546058655,
-0.10342270135879517,
0.17385752499103546,
-0.03200855106115341,
-0.33977797627449036,
-0.014601891860365868,
0.05567752942442894,
0.1347302794456482,
0.3103228211402893,
-0.965839147567749,
0.3416557013988495,
-0.5745037198066711,
0.7120092511177063,
0.538642168045044,
-0.3901774287223816,
0.22708366811275482,
0.07021471112966537,
0.4233323633670807,
-0.20376725494861603,
-0.16092544794082642,
-0.062211450189352036,
-0.3476247787475586,
-0.5799177289009094,
-0.36259976029396057,
0.3798939287662506,
0.45780614018440247,
-0.740933895111084,
0.16530698537826538,
-0.19372497498989105,
-0.7757534384727478,
-0.44902893900871277,
0.026277925819158554,
0.14267297089099884,
0.5253507494926453,
0.2660689651966095,
0.1756017953157425,
-0.528282642364502,
-0.6528083086013794,
-0.2865215837955475,
0.04494382068514824,
-0.17573438584804535,
0.16470079123973846,
0.797836184501648,
0.09244580566883087,
1.016507863998413,
-0.5799422264099121,
0.17591673135757446,
-0.21445341408252716,
0.11115437746047974,
0.26210618019104004,
0.27720341086387634,
0.311073899269104,
-0.8906318545341492,
-0.3507220447063446,
0.30920907855033875,
-0.675649106502533,
-0.47390618920326233,
0.11457286030054092,
0.26399460434913635,
0.048395365476608276,
0.671030580997467,
-0.638818085193634,
0.23083366453647614,
0.2932087182998657,
-0.38958054780960083,
0.8101242184638977,
-0.2744864821434021,
0.09029050916433334,
-0.8456524610519409,
0.34119701385498047,
-0.0031038771849125624,
-0.2612968981266022,
-0.6435815095901489,
-0.1280876100063324,
0.10827060788869858,
-0.2713862955570221,
-0.6069313883781433,
0.7678162455558777,
-0.24081486463546753,
-0.12185823172330856,
-0.5255970358848572,
0.19789230823516846,
0.11533786356449127,
0.00033842941047623754,
0.15154998004436493,
1.2144256830215454,
0.38123729825019836,
-0.08457232266664505,
0.6833210587501526,
0.11231652647256851,
-0.14524328708648682,
0.5307364463806152,
-1.1335159540176392,
0.0429103821516037,
-0.053418587893247604,
0.3704493045806885,
-0.5235984921455383,
-0.3768962621688843,
-0.057175423949956894,
-0.38195446133613586,
0.04513505846261978,
0.11423955857753754,
-0.680425763130188,
-0.4402674436569214,
-0.005365128628909588,
0.35394087433815,
0.3127277195453644,
-0.5744460821151733,
0.7034940123558044,
-0.02025364711880684,
-0.41957253217697144,
-0.771670937538147,
-0.41569986939430237,
0.08217661827802658,
-0.10464926809072495,
-0.5649489164352417,
0.15290136635303497,
-0.25853922963142395,
-0.38416820764541626,
0.025982944294810295,
-0.42465171217918396,
0.08578607439994812,
0.0917426273226738,
0.34338584542274475,
0.25783637166023254,
-0.09079752117395401,
0.35767629742622375,
0.13392050564289093,
-0.15436355769634247,
0.3090161979198456,
-0.031067879870533943,
0.34845662117004395,
-0.5030380487442017,
-0.6175157427787781,
0.4381129741668701,
0.3249768912792206,
0.5535248517990112,
-0.3626181185245514,
0.3982805907726288,
0.6006514430046082,
-0.3550538420677185,
-0.02366252802312374,
-0.6509472727775574,
-0.24064497649669647,
-0.5236301422119141,
0.7140660881996155,
-0.5648549795150757,
-1.065569281578064,
0.39219674468040466,
-0.4327344596385956,
0.24201145768165588,
0.33337071537971497,
0.6167927384376526,
-0.06594520062208176,
1.3559504747390747,
0.37848472595214844,
0.23583275079727173,
0.09905730932950974,
-0.06182607635855675,
0.1932329386472702,
-0.5882627367973328,
-0.41867920756340027,
-0.5256677269935608,
-0.00030067827901802957,
-0.02524661459028721,
-0.5490201711654663,
0.5618968605995178,
0.14592790603637695,
-0.4162982702255249,
0.4607382118701935,
-0.6902373433113098,
0.8601760268211365,
0.40072932839393616,
-0.19609437882900238,
0.39121830463409424,
-0.02693670243024826,
-0.3605886995792389,
0.0305020734667778,
-0.8449341058731079,
-0.40266549587249756,
0.8306542038917542,
0.21865108609199524,
0.7223299741744995,
-0.13530796766281128,
0.36885106563568115,
0.08837299048900604,
0.5826298594474792,
-0.7312976717948914,
0.7038721442222595,
0.006797194480895996,
-0.5780068635940552,
-0.17349658906459808,
-0.3216279447078705,
-0.815046489238739,
0.45961615443229675,
-0.03995997831225395,
-0.5170743465423584,
-0.05779382959008217,
0.10124224424362183,
-0.13884693384170532,
0.05902368575334549,
-0.7993141412734985,
0.7814518213272095,
-0.39720022678375244,
-0.49600735306739807,
-0.1866980791091919,
-0.566517174243927,
0.2751292884349823,
-0.21970397233963013,
0.32329827547073364,
-0.2964933216571808,
0.019114764407277107,
0.6329472064971924,
-0.5697748064994812,
0.715484619140625,
0.038029007613658905,
0.006611959543079138,
-0.014904756098985672,
0.2785113453865051,
0.4615333676338196,
0.16913731396198273,
-0.06395090371370316,
0.025020113214850426,
0.33851924538612366,
-0.4305642247200012,
-0.7596178650856018,
0.9998621344566345,
-0.6403159499168396,
-0.9518104195594788,
-0.8403463959693909,
-1.0214861631393433,
-0.17944233119487762,
0.35525551438331604,
0.02863537147641182,
0.2829362750053406,
-0.1104954183101654,
0.3135099709033966,
0.78810054063797,
0.0401187464594841,
0.22941602766513824,
0.5364283323287964,
-0.2678077816963196,
-0.28000608086586,
0.9154121279716492,
-0.10360826551914215,
0.2997378408908844,
0.1119949147105217,
0.376278281211853,
-0.27168747782707214,
-0.3114062547683716,
-0.31259411573410034,
0.3324609100818634,
-0.7845737338066101,
-0.35283172130584717,
-0.6342794895172119,
-0.27288347482681274,
-0.2849591076374054,
-0.3175041079521179,
-0.203457772731781,
-0.5226031541824341,
-0.2042635828256607,
0.03538885340094566,
0.9311991333961487,
0.5079582333564758,
-0.1184530258178711,
0.21019364893436432,
-0.61698979139328,
-0.05943630263209343,
0.0869036316871643,
0.15937288105487823,
-0.47153913974761963,
-0.3933764398097992,
-0.16478274762630463,
0.12737472355365753,
-0.1099427118897438,
-0.6801820397377014,
0.39674773812294006,
0.10768580436706543,
0.42339465022087097,
0.1470164954662323,
-0.2471928745508194,
0.6146853566169739,
-0.6234093904495239,
0.6098441481590271,
0.14363567531108856,
-0.7670443654060364,
0.6074249744415283,
-0.263654887676239,
0.3706648349761963,
0.20298492908477783,
0.5082165598869324,
-0.37816980481147766,
-0.40777868032455444,
-0.6912655234336853,
-0.47292909026145935,
0.4255079925060272,
0.1233801543712616,
-0.28485724329948425,
0.06675887107849121,
0.19019709527492523,
0.06129451468586922,
0.1624676138162613,
-0.4143378436565399,
0.27013590931892395,
-0.5830959677696228,
-0.12239120900630951,
-0.12112338095903397,
0.2179693877696991,
-0.31524163484573364,
-0.4421161115169525,
0.6711550951004028,
-0.3144226372241974,
0.0388985201716423,
0.18283773958683014,
-0.2009112536907196,
-0.09595900774002075,
0.29101184010505676,
0.7289557456970215,
0.6971532702445984,
-0.12956471741199493,
0.3551255762577057,
0.5102745890617371,
-0.8363070487976074,
0.01063525304198265,
0.5009297728538513,
0.2565775513648987,
-0.06335137784481049,
0.43563732504844666,
0.5021799802780151,
0.1660594791173935,
-1.0643125772476196,
0.2514030635356903,
0.22222603857517242,
-0.3296024203300476,
-0.19634123146533966,
0.27172666788101196,
0.3608979284763336,
0.2782558500766754,
0.35724031925201416,
0.07922423630952835,
0.10902781039476395,
-0.11064163595438004,
0.04595860838890076,
0.43441325426101685,
-0.22486037015914917,
-0.14363804459571838,
0.6095266938209534,
0.09497937560081482,
-0.3701292872428894,
0.36618369817733765,
-0.16619417071342468,
-0.6463819742202759,
0.6772484183311462,
0.7813570499420166,
0.3806970715522766,
-0.34600043296813965,
0.06410913169384003,
0.02462543360888958,
0.2561139464378357,
-0.12812985479831696,
0.4410184919834137,
0.1980888396501541,
-0.4918556809425354,
-1.0115703344345093,
-0.5263126492500305,
-0.650266706943512,
0.0695667564868927,
-0.12451066821813583,
0.2652810513973236,
-0.40523067116737366,
-0.02100016549229622,
0.3889111578464508,
0.17158876359462738,
-0.5001111030578613,
-0.06443623453378677,
-0.4573209583759308,
1.198011040687561,
-0.7688044309616089,
0.8112257122993469,
0.9708400368690491,
-0.2073114812374115,
-0.7562214136123657,
-0.8898112177848816,
0.16707143187522888,
-0.7511522769927979,
0.83797287940979,
-0.06121940538287163,
-0.20553061366081238,
0.08304452151060104,
-0.8866351842880249,
-0.9037224054336548,
1.1199723482131958,
0.44529208540916443,
-0.6299243569374084,
0.2110794633626938,
0.07237313687801361,
0.5841770172119141,
-0.25843673944473267,
0.42141833901405334,
0.6245977282524109,
0.6205432415008545,
0.6878812909126282,
-1.0824695825576782,
0.05254986882209778,
-0.5290023684501648,
-0.3545423448085785,
0.23252300918102264,
-0.3544244170188904,
0.6405233144760132,
-0.4093649089336395,
0.15700897574424744,
-0.1001141294836998,
0.67236328125,
0.8889619708061218,
0.32661569118499756,
0.42524200677871704,
0.3156746029853821,
0.6422141790390015,
-0.23698614537715912,
0.7142149806022644,
0.02389349974691868,
0.013129295781254768,
0.9560105800628662,
-0.5699336528778076,
0.5288634300231934,
0.5491644740104675,
-0.18175378441810608,
0.33237069845199585,
0.5220678448677063,
-0.4064297378063202,
0.09426764398813248,
0.30858156085014343,
-0.4917308986186981,
-0.5731082558631897,
-0.48430827260017395,
-0.4158540964126587,
0.3452107906341553,
0.7165455222129822,
-0.008281524293124676,
-0.32714495062828064,
0.2961026132106781,
0.23304270207881927,
0.031144071370363235,
-0.2619856595993042,
0.2522144913673401,
0.22152580320835114,
-0.328498899936676,
0.3686636984348297,
-0.06096789985895157,
0.3334568440914154,
-0.6524597406387329,
-0.2989674508571625,
0.049255624413490295,
0.1669052243232727,
-0.329973429441452,
-0.8129034638404846,
0.02058057300746441,
0.059513505548238754,
-0.035848572850227356,
-0.004256153013557196,
0.9895378947257996,
-0.45320752263069153,
-0.8335126042366028,
-0.39852818846702576,
0.4965296983718872,
0.4294700622558594,
-0.04720224812626839,
-0.6052626967430115,
0.23160985112190247,
-0.26485955715179443,
-0.1876361221075058,
0.21333996951580048,
0.44608402252197266,
-0.34714680910110474,
0.9762136936187744,
1.0153409242630005,
0.26729530096054077,
-0.17181739211082458,
0.1868061125278473,
1.0233948230743408,
-0.4565833508968353,
-0.20680782198905945,
-0.5610419511795044,
0.18549726903438568,
-0.4107506573200226,
-0.17418324947357178,
0.8798701167106628,
0.4750564992427826,
0.6325334310531616,
-0.07102663069963455,
0.8197768926620483,
-0.12666338682174683,
0.5339126586914062,
-0.1307811737060547,
0.49239858984947205,
-0.34232714772224426,
0.3288826048374176,
-0.17087383568286896,
-0.8964353203773499,
-0.4916330873966217,
0.8321118354797363,
-0.4376866817474365,
0.15095922350883484,
0.7947292923927307,
0.7649757862091064,
-0.26609039306640625,
0.27191588282585144,
0.17350980639457703,
0.25594568252563477,
0.5810767412185669,
0.5105254650115967,
0.8520579934120178,
0.049101125448942184,
0.5055156350135803,
-0.21305949985980988,
-0.2719191014766693,
-0.11609049886465073,
-1.1544924974441528,
-1.0456938743591309,
-0.2470962107181549,
-0.2715223729610443,
-0.19902870059013367,
-0.06008128821849823,
1.126328706741333,
0.5550506711006165,
-0.5999557971954346,
-0.11937311291694641,
-0.1960245966911316,
0.010807419195771217,
-0.20395740866661072,
-0.23987361788749695,
0.3702843487262726,
-0.18814006447792053,
-0.6009758710861206,
0.7840942740440369,
0.3583320677280426,
-0.10719843953847885,
-0.5784457325935364,
-0.023110566660761833,
-0.03956850245594978,
0.029494913294911385,
0.7485109567642212,
0.3657144010066986,
-0.7769176363945007,
-0.42026957869529724,
0.503476619720459,
0.16876760125160217,
-0.23739686608314514,
0.9901465177536011,
-0.9596850872039795,
0.4157584011554718,
0.38351041078567505,
0.5822791457176208,
0.5545543432235718,
-0.3062417209148407,
0.5146281719207764,
-0.7576693296432495,
0.14350023865699768,
0.5054934024810791,
0.4355092942714691,
0.3524147868156433,
-0.23297710716724396,
0.7091556787490845,
0.31393173336982727,
-0.6071114540100098,
-1.1541857719421387,
0.08889002352952957,
-1.0230916738510132,
-0.3414216637611389,
1.178195595741272,
0.011159677058458328,
-0.19823655486106873,
-0.20909598469734192,
-0.4204273223876953,
0.07703392207622528,
-0.46521058678627014,
0.46950244903564453,
0.7759080529212952,
-0.21590815484523773,
-0.24188488721847534,
-0.46553823351860046,
0.37193766236305237,
0.5270234942436218,
-0.893896758556366,
0.027567755430936813,
0.5286827683448792,
0.4686466455459595,
0.4144582748413086,
0.19135607779026031,
-0.04897331818938255,
0.6069828271865845,
0.025246761739253998,
0.13521745800971985,
-0.7478427886962891,
-0.4326925277709961,
0.0006512239924632013,
0.004238673485815525,
0.09074899554252625,
0.6069232821464539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11447v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11447v1 | In-Context Example Ordering Guided by Label Distributions | 2024-02-18T04:08:10 | 2024-02-18T04:08:10 | Zhichao Xu, Daniel Cohen, Bei Wang, Vivek Srikumar | cs.CL | cs.CL | By allowing models to predict without task-specific training, in-context
learning (ICL) with pretrained LLMs has enormous potential in NLP. However, a
number of problems persist in ICL. In particular, its performance is sensitive
to the choice and order of in-context examples. Given the same set of
in-context examples with different orderings, model performance may vary
between near random to near state-of-the-art. In this work, we formulate
in-context example ordering as an optimization problem. We examine three
problem settings that differ in the assumptions they make about what is known
about the task. Inspired by the idea of learning from label proportions, we
propose two principles for in-context example ordering guided by model's
probability predictions. We apply our proposed principles to thirteen text
classification datasets and nine different autoregressive LLMs with 700M to 13B
parameters. We demonstrate that our approach outperforms the baselines by
improving the classification accuracy, reducing model miscalibration, and also
by selecting better in-context examples. | [
-0.27905046939849854,
-0.33915621042251587,
0.6379777789115906,
0.3581938147544861,
-0.38853076100349426,
-0.37901899218559265,
0.02122078649699688,
-0.47396695613861084,
-0.27425891160964966,
0.5504702925682068,
-0.40126529335975647,
-0.533913791179657,
-0.6217644214630127,
0.2212439626455307,
-0.41808420419692993,
1.247109293937683,
0.10389479249715805,
0.23473583161830902,
-0.5521901249885559,
-0.2612227201461792,
-0.3085768520832062,
-0.7963929176330566,
-0.6761535406112671,
-0.36660653352737427,
0.39140066504478455,
0.4379129707813263,
0.4224625527858734,
0.8599622249603271,
0.4158303439617157,
0.2981618344783783,
-0.07809681445360184,
0.18713746964931488,
-0.2842232584953308,
0.11640690267086029,
0.05826283618807793,
-0.5929049849510193,
-0.08548225462436676,
0.28463318943977356,
0.35583218932151794,
0.7002975344657898,
-0.28845053911209106,
0.03518189117312431,
0.1128951907157898,
0.37626227736473083,
-0.6724675893783569,
-0.001585611724294722,
-0.5799347758293152,
0.16778965294361115,
0.2515304684638977,
-0.3323865532875061,
-0.8385502696037292,
-0.19841159880161285,
0.5503352284431458,
-0.4781584143638611,
0.058472562581300735,
0.49964001774787903,
0.449616014957428,
0.3308123052120209,
-0.3943576514720917,
-0.5036532878875732,
-0.4646793305873871,
0.9417435526847839,
-0.8421394228935242,
0.287298321723938,
0.4054323732852936,
0.20253044366836548,
-0.34654444456100464,
-0.8708846569061279,
-0.21730783581733704,
0.17175783216953278,
-0.2950715124607086,
0.07917185127735138,
0.001805915031582117,
0.09718168526887894,
0.316119909286499,
-0.042266495525836945,
-0.5916422605514526,
0.4918980300426483,
0.02243999019265175,
0.25533387064933777,
0.3931829035282135,
-0.012113112956285477,
0.07435483485460281,
0.010589489713311195,
-0.4938242733478546,
-0.35229161381721497,
-0.7225378751754761,
0.15325696766376495,
0.12620671093463898,
0.2732340097427368,
-0.10771621018648148,
0.47505274415016174,
-0.1383213847875595,
1.0851937532424927,
0.19835320115089417,
-0.37872329354286194,
0.24158206582069397,
-0.05516340956091881,
-0.444707989692688,
0.3544689416885376,
0.6251955628395081,
0.37605494260787964,
-0.03903135657310486,
-0.15970568358898163,
-0.31513485312461853,
-0.2778971791267395,
0.24982653558254242,
-0.8192464709281921,
-0.13670246303081512,
0.175361767411232,
-0.28463035821914673,
-0.3047329783439636,
-0.04617684334516525,
-0.4515756666660309,
-0.1129421666264534,
-0.44493168592453003,
0.5841108560562134,
-0.2737497091293335,
0.4172860085964203,
0.16897113621234894,
0.1853860467672348,
-0.027217227965593338,
0.29387685656547546,
-1.007550835609436,
0.25045472383499146,
0.6473861932754517,
0.5088746547698975,
-0.3255407214164734,
-0.08475549519062042,
-0.41294875741004944,
0.27112773060798645,
-0.29512906074523926,
0.6456831693649292,
-0.3417821526527405,
-0.21810483932495117,
-0.07712427526712418,
-0.3595721423625946,
0.011364270001649857,
-0.45667827129364014,
0.6337817311286926,
-0.47726625204086304,
0.5664232969284058,
-0.017384978011250496,
-0.8910224437713623,
-0.2658807039260864,
-0.09675488620996475,
-0.17531134188175201,
0.8816666007041931,
-0.23783688247203827,
-0.8332358002662659,
0.6573291420936584,
-0.36923640966415405,
-0.35388869047164917,
0.004283626563847065,
-0.35998862981796265,
-0.39487481117248535,
0.20985181629657745,
0.29028019309043884,
0.941593587398529,
-0.08819051831960678,
0.24621236324310303,
-0.2294449806213379,
-0.31377118825912476,
0.21742235124111176,
-0.37261873483657837,
0.8796477913856506,
0.29243794083595276,
-0.34768053889274597,
-0.06722893565893173,
-0.5732887983322144,
0.13589492440223694,
-0.19580310583114624,
-0.2646603286266327,
-0.8288547396659851,
0.3887903392314911,
-0.20605964958667755,
0.31655752658843994,
-0.0597120076417923,
-0.24142193794250488,
0.011682434938848019,
-0.7873654961585999,
0.25091516971588135,
0.6650562882423401,
0.27566203474998474,
0.906731903553009,
-0.2432633936405182,
0.2825024127960205,
-0.06374015659093857,
0.320926696062088,
0.1957017034292221,
-0.520745038986206,
-0.7217063307762146,
-0.16670989990234375,
0.1209336668252945,
0.5203989148139954,
-0.4939489960670471,
0.398190975189209,
-0.07861924916505814,
-0.3110334277153015,
-0.11859800666570663,
0.026358895003795624,
0.5749726891517639,
0.8651469349861145,
0.42732030153274536,
-0.08658244460821152,
-0.2507285475730896,
-0.9229592680931091,
-0.13372986018657684,
-0.2667716145515442,
-0.10713626444339752,
0.4229060411453247,
0.08513868600130081,
-0.06000297889113426,
0.9112118482589722,
-0.6006830334663391,
0.0015228638658300042,
-0.10468272119760513,
0.21887405216693878,
0.4868100583553314,
0.3860592544078827,
0.646062970161438,
-1.1842888593673706,
-0.5134574174880981,
-0.126640185713768,
-0.6595807671546936,
-0.2835312485694885,
0.03903595730662346,
-0.33191803097724915,
0.24467918276786804,
0.8576269149780273,
-0.20481249690055847,
0.28045520186424255,
0.36857473850250244,
0.043547019362449646,
0.19830702245235443,
-0.43495702743530273,
-0.4400164484977722,
-1.210495948791504,
-0.7312361598014832,
0.17963430285453796,
-0.17745092511177063,
-0.6469289064407349,
-0.1476055383682251,
0.14084206521511078,
0.13154877722263336,
-0.4497435688972473,
0.5022655129432678,
-0.41285666823387146,
-0.09622371941804886,
-0.10672546923160553,
-0.037988778203725815,
0.011308005079627037,
0.36613214015960693,
0.1945478618144989,
0.47664257884025574,
0.38944199681282043,
-0.8732799291610718,
-0.305842787027359,
0.16038164496421814,
-0.8126641511917114,
0.43027254939079285,
-0.44398507475852966,
-0.1112452819943428,
-0.3221355974674225,
0.24855971336364746,
-1.0904515981674194,
0.04291091486811638,
0.06437429785728455,
-0.187967449426651,
0.59471595287323,
-0.07037046551704407,
-0.6442173719406128,
-0.09984773397445679,
0.1266057938337326,
0.4194176495075226,
0.5019956231117249,
-0.7548047304153442,
0.3180091977119446,
0.26146939396858215,
0.0233047716319561,
-0.8552829027175903,
-0.3591688573360443,
-0.3611888885498047,
-0.6419631242752075,
-0.010179257951676846,
0.7312262654304504,
-0.4925994575023651,
-0.3000926077365875,
-0.36808937788009644,
-0.177912175655365,
0.0024614515714347363,
0.09369094669818878,
0.17222119867801666,
-0.02072831243276596,
-0.020223179832100868,
0.2537602186203003,
0.20701102912425995,
0.06445471942424774,
-0.03689458966255188,
-0.4526820778846741,
0.1555611938238144,
0.13271135091781616,
-0.053067028522491455,
-0.10422581434249878,
0.23842041194438934,
0.20574721693992615,
0.14067140221595764,
0.5163057446479797,
0.21581099927425385,
-0.19076886773109436,
-0.6834462285041809,
-0.468254953622818,
-0.09440896660089493,
-0.5582787394523621,
0.3289443850517273,
-0.22777879238128662,
-0.47702503204345703,
0.001344463904388249,
0.13954003155231476,
0.36190590262413025,
-0.05493941158056259,
0.5087205767631531,
-0.7298346757888794,
1.008102297782898,
0.8780627846717834,
-0.11167463660240173,
0.7128633856773376,
-0.23271968960762024,
0.1345963180065155,
-0.5501853823661804,
-0.02486712485551834,
-0.3330751061439514,
-0.20270749926567078,
-0.6312943696975708,
-0.3276800513267517,
0.5363259315490723,
0.22951260209083557,
-0.35353884100914,
0.3856286108493805,
-0.7099147439002991,
0.799687385559082,
0.5973318219184875,
0.36960160732269287,
0.1873164027929306,
0.3831859529018402,
-0.42062443494796753,
-0.024587741121649742,
-1.0894410610198975,
-0.3579282760620117,
0.7616345286369324,
-0.02679213508963585,
0.6419758796691895,
0.06410643458366394,
0.9450289607048035,
0.08977525681257248,
0.7191281318664551,
-0.660092294216156,
0.458076149225235,
-0.42438337206840515,
-0.5007144212722778,
-0.3212943375110626,
-0.18668457865715027,
-1.0201512575149536,
0.5471965074539185,
-0.09677061438560486,
-0.9005478024482727,
0.28985103964805603,
0.0991159975528717,
-0.22596439719200134,
-0.130166158080101,
-0.8903358578681946,
0.6311983466148376,
-0.3155648112297058,
0.15105539560317993,
0.23430202901363373,
-0.8806488513946533,
0.18839260935783386,
-0.01611528918147087,
0.44510024785995483,
0.06846777349710464,
-0.16854524612426758,
0.6599597334861755,
-0.3997962772846222,
0.814570426940918,
0.04217947646975517,
0.01772582158446312,
0.3172350823879242,
0.029789907857775688,
0.457916796207428,
-0.08820121735334396,
-0.2273675948381424,
-0.3425058126449585,
-0.14071236550807953,
-0.09640619903802872,
-0.7941421866416931,
0.48758578300476074,
-0.8549846410751343,
-0.5248141288757324,
-0.30818891525268555,
-0.5485687851905823,
-0.42546024918556213,
-0.10729342699050903,
0.9642912149429321,
0.7122179269790649,
0.40954849123954773,
0.3064478039741516,
0.6215659976005554,
-0.17388631403446198,
0.94004887342453,
0.3813207447528839,
-0.00750353466719389,
-0.40658363699913025,
0.7691085338592529,
0.3070177733898163,
0.44074106216430664,
0.9658315777778625,
0.3040933907032013,
-0.516790509223938,
-0.9255117177963257,
-0.17486073076725006,
0.16930608451366425,
-1.156630277633667,
-0.3307173252105713,
-0.7463850378990173,
0.11659889668226242,
-0.1960476040840149,
-0.5193768739700317,
0.06570356339216232,
-0.16358019411563873,
-0.6441087126731873,
-0.10267023742198944,
0.06295859813690186,
0.5860258936882019,
0.3846331238746643,
0.6048712730407715,
-0.34737974405288696,
0.06321169435977936,
0.18580809235572815,
0.1132655218243599,
0.05595563352108002,
-0.6710730195045471,
-0.18004226684570312,
-0.2506110668182373,
-0.2699868977069855,
-0.7890467643737793,
0.6670626997947693,
0.19695013761520386,
0.8522816896438599,
0.4637436866760254,
0.37706878781318665,
0.7448351383209229,
-0.7296220660209656,
0.2412135899066925,
0.2086144983768463,
-0.6341606378555298,
0.5154003500938416,
-0.22897738218307495,
0.10091707110404968,
0.5894954800605774,
0.7280578017234802,
-0.1993059515953064,
-0.46820878982543945,
-0.7204957008361816,
-1.0633543729782104,
0.6932722330093384,
0.3175564408302307,
-0.045908112078905106,
-0.1287688910961151,
0.60191410779953,
0.1905928999185562,
0.25316935777664185,
-1.1541459560394287,
-0.46452006697654724,
0.019433097913861275,
-0.3853878974914551,
-0.5312510132789612,
-0.24184942245483398,
0.07221844792366028,
-0.3833458721637726,
0.6691097617149353,
-0.17360904812812805,
0.15306346118450165,
0.2157592922449112,
-0.3011246919631958,
0.33277183771133423,
-0.08732066303491592,
0.6986750364303589,
0.7233660221099854,
-0.3695153594017029,
0.07473193854093552,
0.14815092086791992,
-0.13214056193828583,
0.3847399652004242,
-0.10511529445648193,
-0.28191113471984863,
-0.04142145812511444,
0.2397766262292862,
0.6122243404388428,
0.3769817650318146,
-0.4368855953216553,
0.48659801483154297,
0.05326840281486511,
-0.03429744765162468,
-0.30196934938430786,
0.02311614528298378,
-0.03981746360659599,
0.3339560329914093,
0.5522559881210327,
-0.2334902137517929,
0.40487274527549744,
-0.1324784755706787,
0.32067370414733887,
0.3989827334880829,
-0.27219125628471375,
0.17874757945537567,
0.38641810417175293,
-0.2599542737007141,
-0.4566033184528351,
0.44041794538497925,
-0.19892039895057678,
-0.2820723354816437,
0.772866427898407,
0.7088255286216736,
0.7073893547058105,
0.03455890342593193,
0.20062999427318573,
0.1936800330877304,
0.1283755600452423,
-0.3763827979564667,
-0.17866967618465424,
-0.2048826962709427,
-0.8667885065078735,
-0.2896784842014313,
-0.8332781195640564,
-0.51519775390625,
-0.10144095122814178,
-0.745879590511322,
0.3457821309566498,
-0.3339409828186035,
-0.18543556332588196,
0.20740295946598053,
-0.13871616125106812,
-0.4230910837650299,
0.5671733617782593,
0.0737384781241417,
0.5376892685890198,
-0.6888017654418945,
0.8171873688697815,
0.5034822225570679,
0.009002366103231907,
-0.650001049041748,
0.04917570576071739,
-0.23301471769809723,
-0.546446681022644,
0.8951600193977356,
0.26524975895881653,
0.13330703973770142,
0.18214356899261475,
-0.7651222944259644,
-1.067082166671753,
1.0575989484786987,
0.29208698868751526,
-0.23437154293060303,
-0.08258621394634247,
-0.3008888363838196,
0.519869863986969,
-0.8299726843833923,
0.2827080190181732,
-0.12273018807172775,
-0.061627719551324844,
-0.027609890326857567,
-0.5395146608352661,
-0.2507084310054779,
0.23575685918331146,
0.317792683839798,
0.022884879261255264,
-0.4464707672595978,
0.5741475820541382,
-0.15748704969882965,
-0.0669415146112442,
-0.03053359128534794,
0.6955586075782776,
0.4246988594532013,
0.34753960371017456,
0.6483883261680603,
0.34065720438957214,
0.4632164537906647,
0.08854267746210098,
1.281028151512146,
0.07539457082748413,
0.24950647354125977,
1.3929028511047363,
-0.014716628938913345,
0.8397815823554993,
0.5128563642501831,
-0.19216424226760864,
0.46025559306144714,
1.2457071542739868,
0.14069764316082,
0.86885005235672,
0.22187308967113495,
-0.02532774768769741,
-0.06811925768852234,
-0.055785659700632095,
-0.09929542988538742,
0.4361104667186737,
0.5027145743370056,
-0.6037033200263977,
-0.28769585490226746,
0.11245429515838623,
-0.2142942249774933,
-0.11296345293521881,
-0.1893196403980255,
0.9259179830551147,
0.22900107502937317,
-0.5450359582901001,
0.6551659107208252,
-0.1383967250585556,
0.7534796595573425,
-0.32380208373069763,
0.0003521063772495836,
-0.24546119570732117,
0.02889322116971016,
0.02654404379427433,
-0.41219374537467957,
-0.09020056575536728,
-0.4499130845069885,
-0.465763121843338,
-0.6783139705657959,
0.22416631877422333,
-0.27864697575569153,
-0.6592913866043091,
0.3564414381980896,
0.27170759439468384,
0.3554070293903351,
0.264586478471756,
-0.7170500159263611,
-0.4484395682811737,
-0.05317707359790802,
-0.4619021713733673,
0.6943290829658508,
0.49013784527778625,
-0.1803782731294632,
0.7670419216156006,
0.3424254357814789,
-0.2322285771369934,
0.16700120270252228,
-0.22527892887592316,
0.31977716088294983,
-0.18762196600437164,
-0.6395794749259949,
-0.9251859188079834,
0.18058861792087555,
-0.06694652885198593,
-0.2903655767440796,
0.6441053152084351,
0.40422526001930237,
1.059491753578186,
-0.029830146580934525,
0.30247852206230164,
0.28133687376976013,
0.29375702142715454,
-0.6100441217422485,
0.4509691894054413,
-0.7375777959823608,
0.2573609948158264,
-0.5315211415290833,
-1.0276507139205933,
-0.551581621170044,
0.7769848704338074,
-0.35297253727912903,
-0.004096252378076315,
0.6592983603477478,
0.6108503341674805,
-0.05814306065440178,
-0.10047980397939682,
0.49903830885887146,
-0.030009184032678604,
0.10789632797241211,
0.39598527550697327,
0.4788344204425812,
-0.3316121995449066,
0.5009796023368835,
-0.747071385383606,
-0.1087580993771553,
-0.24588239192962646,
-1.15106201171875,
-0.7613061666488647,
-0.7338560223579407,
-0.3095047175884247,
-0.18069912493228912,
-0.10233590751886368,
1.1111016273498535,
0.918901801109314,
-0.5360355377197266,
-0.5122278332710266,
-0.148478701710701,
0.35754796862602234,
-0.21646741032600403,
-0.18153399229049683,
0.34967339038848877,
-0.5274956226348877,
-0.8999066948890686,
0.38087841868400574,
0.21336707472801208,
0.5200796723365784,
0.4499189853668213,
0.17429883778095245,
-0.28517836332321167,
-0.05531006678938866,
0.858544647693634,
0.07957155257463455,
-0.8574084639549255,
-0.129185289144516,
-0.22736887633800507,
-0.2334446758031845,
0.0829380452632904,
0.5908910632133484,
-0.6236271262168884,
0.31941014528274536,
0.4786016047000885,
0.6129189729690552,
0.5964428782463074,
0.1571281999349594,
0.5796189904212952,
-0.9813981652259827,
0.17908746004104614,
0.39717933535575867,
0.33048591017723083,
0.08008518069982529,
-0.4540787637233734,
0.6088938117027283,
-0.09927868843078613,
-0.5848709940910339,
-0.937309205532074,
0.2802966237068176,
-0.9366002082824707,
-0.5503005385398865,
1.1536463499069214,
-0.15533430874347687,
-0.013726183213293552,
-0.026290690526366234,
0.10271629691123962,
0.07072111964225769,
-0.2751287817955017,
0.6387906074523926,
0.7652437090873718,
-0.5993800759315491,
-0.09715060889720917,
-0.6650736331939697,
0.6929078102111816,
0.7093850374221802,
-0.5287908911705017,
-0.18443085253238678,
0.369219034910202,
0.13672025501728058,
0.05332370847463608,
0.5448869466781616,
0.16246601939201355,
-0.13626913726329803,
-0.5628477931022644,
-0.19492724537849426,
0.4261218011379242,
-0.4743015468120575,
-0.2567020654678345,
0.24549762904644012,
-0.08534637838602066,
-0.03948919102549553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11443v1 | Benchmark Self-Evolving: A Multi-Agent Framework for Dynamic LLM Evaluation | 2024-02-18T03:40:06 | 2024-02-18T03:40:06 | Siyuan Wang, Zhuohan Long, Zhihao Fan, Zhongyu Wei, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents a benchmark self-evolving framework to dynamically
evaluate rapidly advancing Large Language Models (LLMs), aiming for a more
accurate assessment of their capabilities and limitations. We utilize a
multi-agent system to manipulate the context or question of original instances,
reframing new evolving instances with high confidence that dynamically extend
existing benchmarks. Towards a more scalable, robust and fine-grained
evaluation, we implement six reframing operations to construct evolving
instances testing LLMs against diverse queries, data noise and probing their
problem-solving sub-abilities. With this framework, we extend benchmark
datasets of four tasks. Experimental results show a general performance decline
in most LLMs against their original results. This decline under our scalable
and robust evaluations, alongside our fine-grained evaluation, more accurately
reflect models' capabilities. Besides, our framework widens performance
discrepancies both between different models and within the same model across
various tasks, facilitating more informed model selection for specific tasks
(Code and data are available at
https://github.com/NanshineLoong/Self-Evolving-Benchmark). | [
-0.2231922298669815,
-0.9278096556663513,
0.6131433844566345,
0.23089303076267242,
0.0185487512499094,
0.4559929072856903,
-0.4552820920944214,
-0.47857263684272766,
-0.09575334936380386,
0.36489173769950867,
-0.652532696723938,
-0.28593024611473083,
-0.4982420802116394,
0.16531933844089508,
-0.5612446665763855,
0.5690038204193115,
-0.015539406798779964,
-0.055353179574012756,
-0.37676647305488586,
-0.4034324288368225,
-0.4930892586708069,
-0.18667614459991455,
-0.44805940985679626,
-0.4563887417316437,
0.15772897005081177,
0.42817777395248413,
0.5376702547073364,
0.8166966438293457,
0.4465366005897522,
0.465410977602005,
0.08494873344898224,
0.2622793912887573,
-0.5392518639564514,
0.6007874608039856,
-0.36706113815307617,
-0.29068613052368164,
-0.5187796354293823,
-0.11790622770786285,
0.7730200290679932,
0.387423574924469,
-0.2837790548801422,
0.4945005178451538,
-0.027752846479415894,
0.2725561857223511,
-0.6187810301780701,
0.27924779057502747,
-0.8858835697174072,
-0.15782535076141357,
-0.10225893557071686,
0.05606295168399811,
-0.18158644437789917,
-0.10309344530105591,
0.08023254573345184,
-0.35474640130996704,
0.07071872055530548,
-0.09726370871067047,
0.5160481929779053,
0.4560052454471588,
-0.21491967141628265,
-0.20049729943275452,
-0.5658342838287354,
0.8013892769813538,
-0.6640104055404663,
0.4088127315044403,
-0.17656750977039337,
0.7296783924102783,
-0.2698248326778412,
-1.0804375410079956,
-0.35373246669769287,
-0.6254529356956482,
0.43124625086784363,
0.022695103660225868,
-0.20768825709819794,
-0.34914129972457886,
0.008828291669487953,
0.3537689745426178,
-0.2852429747581482,
0.3984321057796478,
0.0007673115469515324,
0.06500391662120819,
0.6710535287857056,
0.3981587290763855,
0.15779073536396027,
0.15128354728221893,
-0.44334277510643005,
-0.18912747502326965,
-0.45146071910858154,
-0.15759477019309998,
0.2566157579421997,
0.46680524945259094,
-0.07968978583812714,
0.23960989713668823,
-0.35396647453308105,
0.33644989132881165,
0.16822077333927155,
-0.08828295767307281,
0.5469380021095276,
-0.45610588788986206,
-0.1501009166240692,
-0.32379618287086487,
0.7772518992424011,
0.18485841155052185,
0.16928631067276,
-0.21080511808395386,
-0.4529969394207001,
-0.14820513129234314,
0.4431438744068146,
-0.8020386695861816,
-0.05341797694563866,
0.1061675176024437,
-0.42650601267814636,
-0.4509367346763611,
-0.3296118676662445,
-0.9856191873550415,
-0.5300434827804565,
-0.034579094499349594,
0.37238049507141113,
-0.2641529142856598,
-0.3880208134651184,
0.15991033613681793,
0.2026270627975464,
0.10589569061994553,
0.33941033482551575,
-0.6907106041908264,
0.3989439308643341,
0.5723042488098145,
0.5362011790275574,
-0.43314892053604126,
-0.6479759812355042,
-0.5053839087486267,
0.0062795947305858135,
-0.2251586765050888,
0.9478010535240173,
-0.6108652949333191,
-0.2627306878566742,
-0.060001131147146225,
0.14936289191246033,
0.022530056536197662,
-0.8090803623199463,
0.5060605406761169,
-0.4574176073074341,
-0.11248304694890976,
-0.056969497352838516,
-0.43503373861312866,
0.017343832179903984,
0.29220616817474365,
-0.6158533692359924,
1.337488055229187,
0.30343446135520935,
-0.25249266624450684,
0.2671806216239929,
-0.7438710927963257,
-0.19321654736995697,
0.29606884717941284,
-0.3285778760910034,
-0.46971824765205383,
0.25456053018569946,
0.219321608543396,
0.3915148079395294,
-0.6656802892684937,
0.2679711580276489,
-0.7454245686531067,
-0.1713513284921646,
0.34901759028434753,
-0.463296502828598,
0.40605634450912476,
0.29336613416671753,
-0.4930163621902466,
0.31927746534347534,
-0.9576584696769714,
0.31170621514320374,
0.29516860842704773,
-0.2780531644821167,
0.022411460056900978,
0.215945303440094,
-0.12107665091753006,
0.19322682917118073,
0.6591384410858154,
-0.33930104970932007,
0.4104554057121277,
-0.02083030343055725,
0.4393548369407654,
0.7592892646789551,
-0.0629071295261383,
0.12273331731557846,
-0.40338343381881714,
0.643872082233429,
-0.08603857457637787,
0.262358695268631,
-0.1754988729953766,
-0.14070042967796326,
-0.7715075016021729,
-0.17708858847618103,
0.134032741189003,
0.3006017208099365,
-0.5658183097839355,
0.2803918123245239,
-0.41113054752349854,
-0.6443678140640259,
-0.5279310345649719,
0.36643555760383606,
0.32550880312919617,
0.16535289585590363,
0.5433035492897034,
-0.2950221300125122,
-0.29968148469924927,
-1.0111770629882812,
-0.25401192903518677,
-0.31385278701782227,
0.17926202714443207,
0.26332199573516846,
0.46107831597328186,
-0.620029628276825,
0.6937019228935242,
-0.19880026578903198,
0.11944963783025742,
-0.24086858332157135,
0.21938221156597137,
0.001212049857713282,
0.3474504351615906,
0.6164329648017883,
-0.28485405445098877,
-0.289316326379776,
0.05000494420528412,
-0.7062849402427673,
-0.6160331964492798,
-0.1994251310825348,
0.16714394092559814,
-0.01879723183810711,
0.5165842771530151,
-0.2874593436717987,
-0.0038630811031907797,
0.6597751379013062,
-0.17642639577388763,
0.81707763671875,
-0.2827613055706024,
0.08452863991260529,
-0.953478217124939,
-0.13824240863323212,
-0.16210874915122986,
-0.3164130449295044,
-0.4350146949291229,
0.4898812770843506,
0.19181998074054718,
0.21990874409675598,
-0.1661001443862915,
0.7359134554862976,
-0.7899240851402283,
-0.3318771421909332,
-0.5340004563331604,
0.22500616312026978,
-0.14006485044956207,
0.22149640321731567,
-0.3912962079048157,
0.9439037442207336,
0.7162928581237793,
-0.5518829822540283,
0.5983232855796814,
-0.14823973178863525,
-0.5997403860092163,
0.39944905042648315,
-0.4304514229297638,
0.2738145887851715,
0.14576642215251923,
-0.2556855380535126,
-0.7694183588027954,
0.13254788517951965,
-0.10895658284425735,
-0.039585258811712265,
0.23636788129806519,
-0.027233367785811424,
-0.6678866147994995,
-0.33806467056274414,
-0.20357288420200348,
0.466742604970932,
0.2539588510990143,
-0.5329199433326721,
0.6515201926231384,
0.26806071400642395,
-0.13640576601028442,
-0.45793625712394714,
-0.534112811088562,
0.1177889034152031,
-0.2565169334411621,
-0.5198200941085815,
0.31620046496391296,
-0.3093525767326355,
-0.3156387209892273,
-0.07114256173372269,
-0.2750358283519745,
-0.034745194017887115,
0.3370085656642914,
0.029145430773496628,
-0.23121394217014313,
-0.3187945783138275,
0.24672912061214447,
0.028039103373885155,
0.06020589917898178,
0.11177365481853485,
-0.09629900008440018,
0.6733231544494629,
-0.4772050976753235,
-0.47793182730674744,
-0.21290706098079681,
-0.06994489580392838,
0.8983988761901855,
-0.39070990681648254,
0.4240168631076813,
0.5717002153396606,
-0.1289874017238617,
-0.5985174179077148,
-0.8155667781829834,
-0.17204248905181885,
-0.5346141457557678,
0.6649668216705322,
-0.6935720443725586,
-0.8507664203643799,
0.8011431097984314,
-0.5053406953811646,
-0.01848403736948967,
0.423957884311676,
0.768284261226654,
0.2985335886478424,
0.6661243438720703,
0.6096628904342651,
0.075144924223423,
0.5658838152885437,
-0.09631895273923874,
-0.21672698855400085,
-0.8451480269432068,
-0.12256792932748795,
-0.3467485308647156,
-0.08744709938764572,
-0.7778949737548828,
-0.6876006722450256,
0.10823488235473633,
0.10530904680490494,
-0.15196505188941956,
0.4056590795516968,
-0.3698621392250061,
0.34405356645584106,
-0.012278169393539429,
-0.1573864370584488,
0.3009738028049469,
-0.21854041516780853,
-0.25693050026893616,
0.1801602989435196,
-0.5343114137649536,
-0.594352126121521,
1.2136656045913696,
0.5736960768699646,
0.8552790284156799,
0.29133689403533936,
0.4802199602127075,
0.5401923656463623,
0.5401095151901245,
-0.4401376247406006,
0.6957572102546692,
0.020474154502153397,
-0.48641079664230347,
-0.39761075377464294,
-0.4497219920158386,
-1.0701608657836914,
0.6182774305343628,
-0.24667391180992126,
-0.6775637865066528,
0.16977021098136902,
-0.2473306953907013,
-0.31786924600601196,
0.14542457461357117,
-0.5125604271888733,
0.8685444593429565,
-0.6435821652412415,
-0.5485429167747498,
-0.3814369738101959,
-0.1929522305727005,
0.20698809623718262,
-0.5299063920974731,
0.18573786318302155,
-0.5321927666664124,
-0.43236440420150757,
0.3800136148929596,
-0.19594033062458038,
0.5872023105621338,
-0.014789290726184845,
-0.2495908886194229,
0.305014431476593,
0.12046103179454803,
0.43909722566604614,
0.10084859281778336,
-0.6056204438209534,
0.0726238489151001,
0.12027906626462936,
-0.2777857780456543,
-0.7905606627464294,
0.741887092590332,
-0.7105997204780579,
-0.7040191292762756,
-0.29114222526550293,
-0.4992629885673523,
-0.27296262979507446,
0.3119337558746338,
-0.46330222487449646,
0.40786340832710266,
-0.31010428071022034,
0.303723007440567,
0.10338608920574188,
-0.09894858300685883,
0.42040836811065674,
1.0569911003112793,
-0.40781164169311523,
-0.2991970181465149,
0.5554246306419373,
0.09396672993898392,
0.25538477301597595,
0.02663494274020195,
0.3539574146270752,
-0.4382663369178772,
-0.9850170612335205,
-0.3784133195877075,
0.08044014126062393,
-0.7232356071472168,
-0.16113141179084778,
-0.3521621525287628,
0.03527745604515076,
-0.48289206624031067,
0.2398039698600769,
-0.7045769095420837,
-0.04555612429976463,
-0.06547689437866211,
0.0694466233253479,
0.1360202431678772,
0.8662669062614441,
0.036716341972351074,
0.2979206144809723,
-0.5344579219818115,
0.018113188445568085,
0.3741390109062195,
0.4855789840221405,
0.03413695842027664,
-0.7492111921310425,
-0.3100678026676178,
-0.15884582698345184,
-0.3671211004257202,
-0.8257575035095215,
0.31003960967063904,
0.1466868668794632,
0.9949174523353577,
0.2720302641391754,
0.07520914822816849,
0.781658947467804,
-0.5615451335906982,
0.49312886595726013,
-0.1953086256980896,
-0.9323225617408752,
0.19621695578098297,
-0.3852526843547821,
0.5453221797943115,
0.8307005167007446,
-0.12074122577905655,
-0.1745544672012329,
-0.2902996838092804,
-0.5029756426811218,
-0.6120273470878601,
0.4774617850780487,
0.08239659667015076,
0.1568925827741623,
0.0730934739112854,
0.7029238939285278,
0.12248596549034119,
0.26997265219688416,
-0.8446901440620422,
-0.2892166078090668,
-0.04329774156212807,
-0.02504674904048443,
-0.06990278512239456,
-0.3077198565006256,
-0.0002338086487725377,
-0.15561850368976593,
0.4620485305786133,
-0.49188733100891113,
0.21203914284706116,
-0.11322607845067978,
-0.19700878858566284,
-0.06502816081047058,
0.35706040263175964,
0.5674789547920227,
0.8681920766830444,
-0.13378922641277313,
0.079217828810215,
0.6778093576431274,
-0.10465484112501144,
0.2287115454673767,
0.24657997488975525,
0.17783966660499573,
-0.3530692160129547,
0.4775365889072418,
0.7259125113487244,
0.5302119851112366,
-0.8368203639984131,
0.38840922713279724,
-0.203360453248024,
0.07023409754037857,
-0.23857301473617554,
0.22278696298599243,
0.061619602143764496,
0.5989710092544556,
0.3601086735725403,
-0.3154236376285553,
0.07305433601140976,
-0.7777240872383118,
0.3929064869880676,
0.4259288012981415,
-0.05946457013487816,
-0.3033195734024048,
0.386106938123703,
0.17227570712566376,
-0.40770596265792847,
0.2192901372909546,
-0.43426787853240967,
-0.30650025606155396,
0.5873704552650452,
0.6711551547050476,
1.1100965738296509,
-0.5026300549507141,
0.12615667283535004,
0.06327080726623535,
0.41743969917297363,
-0.1216653510928154,
0.11907017976045609,
-0.14408385753631592,
-0.8006483316421509,
-0.3069773316383362,
-0.7049365043640137,
-0.5070295929908752,
0.4082825779914856,
-0.5313760042190552,
0.18564356863498688,
-0.33393776416778564,
-0.25738024711608887,
-0.07710519433021545,
0.26797226071357727,
-0.4361247420310974,
0.0929310992360115,
-0.08022243529558182,
0.8828549981117249,
-0.33469998836517334,
1.1184463500976562,
0.8213603496551514,
-0.10683760046958923,
-0.3060467839241028,
0.1546291559934616,
-0.12437725812196732,
-0.9670860767364502,
0.5010965466499329,
0.21309152245521545,
-0.48940062522888184,
-0.15249985456466675,
-0.37879830598831177,
-1.2574917078018188,
1.2195566892623901,
0.5247747302055359,
-0.6250615119934082,
0.26679912209510803,
0.08119376748800278,
0.8644025325775146,
-0.775689423084259,
0.5575716495513916,
0.5464497208595276,
0.4321085214614868,
-0.1288420855998993,
-0.9248980283737183,
0.10665812343358994,
-0.2776143550872803,
0.015118395909667015,
0.019794171676039696,
-0.9732738137245178,
0.911224365234375,
0.03844079002737999,
-0.3603300154209137,
0.24378377199172974,
0.6558243632316589,
0.1953788697719574,
0.1490039974451065,
0.6638380289077759,
0.4234105944633484,
0.718688428401947,
0.024155791848897934,
0.8384734988212585,
-0.7543846368789673,
0.3726021945476532,
1.3302758932113647,
-0.6024273633956909,
0.8383389711380005,
0.11362503468990326,
-0.026194972917437553,
0.7468050122261047,
0.39765000343322754,
-0.27907130122184753,
0.285902738571167,
0.4750573933124542,
-0.19345587491989136,
-0.4052916169166565,
0.1823340356349945,
-0.25702622532844543,
0.7695915699005127,
0.223860502243042,
-0.14925041794776917,
-0.41228336095809937,
-0.3048536777496338,
-0.15356963872909546,
0.22927290201187134,
-0.0578489787876606,
0.6370294690132141,
-0.15515746176242828,
-0.681881844997406,
0.5486934781074524,
0.2841530740261078,
0.5864419937133789,
-0.5521302223205566,
0.2539401054382324,
-0.22210991382598877,
0.3722594976425171,
0.11940110474824905,
-0.5233933329582214,
0.09522093087434769,
-0.13137947022914886,
-0.019460512325167656,
-0.26951122283935547,
0.675820529460907,
-0.35888004302978516,
-0.4298754036426544,
0.7142773866653442,
0.8334749341011047,
0.1681683212518692,
0.1747545748949051,
-1.1893600225448608,
0.5167500972747803,
-0.2163567990064621,
-0.31940731406211853,
0.3347863554954529,
0.5220363140106201,
-0.1283479630947113,
1.1437110900878906,
0.49024808406829834,
0.022810664027929306,
0.17020924389362335,
0.25577613711357117,
0.8013092279434204,
-0.5931103229522705,
-0.19562876224517822,
-0.9496546387672424,
0.11709963530302048,
-0.18458320200443268,
-0.34764307737350464,
0.8496898412704468,
0.5017120838165283,
0.5613608360290527,
0.10077164322137833,
0.5508502125740051,
0.34984710812568665,
0.39523956179618835,
-0.3128148913383484,
0.7022314071655273,
-0.6869143843650818,
0.4401475191116333,
-0.16591021418571472,
-1.0143656730651855,
0.09223387390375137,
0.4987300932407379,
-0.3010844886302948,
0.4322948157787323,
0.6309438943862915,
0.6950122714042664,
0.11913108825683594,
-0.2833150327205658,
0.46405455470085144,
0.438152015209198,
0.4193485677242279,
0.24484898149967194,
0.977633535861969,
-0.32051196694374084,
0.3107653558254242,
-0.007467908784747124,
-0.27926358580589294,
-0.1461327075958252,
-1.0865542888641357,
-0.7977458238601685,
-0.4545764625072479,
-0.6210756897926331,
-0.06880345195531845,
0.16061778366565704,
0.8558444976806641,
0.9222351908683777,
-0.6328999400138855,
-0.5926162004470825,
0.04338288679718971,
0.012108649127185345,
-0.30858704447746277,
-0.21787188947200775,
0.024771803990006447,
-0.6958456039428711,
-0.7876524925231934,
0.9348207712173462,
0.33868202567100525,
0.020985564216971397,
-0.7106227874755859,
-0.10325271636247635,
-0.11107508838176727,
0.2438548505306244,
0.607775092124939,
0.2609308958053589,
-0.6633672118186951,
-0.3760232925415039,
-0.20017597079277039,
0.00165352423209697,
0.050042569637298584,
0.5112447142601013,
-0.7084846496582031,
0.6277646422386169,
0.13572794198989868,
0.8595223426818848,
0.6278712749481201,
-0.05250372365117073,
0.4913448393344879,
-0.454633504152298,
-0.1601550579071045,
0.015945110470056534,
0.35707375407218933,
0.3266174793243408,
-0.019375823438167572,
0.524897575378418,
0.1346401870250702,
-0.7422382831573486,
-1.1432511806488037,
0.27563220262527466,
-0.8466004729270935,
-0.3395775258541107,
1.098096251487732,
-0.04330893233418465,
-0.06887838244438171,
-0.06940903514623642,
0.31257399916648865,
0.0835983082652092,
-0.38035666942596436,
0.872207760810852,
0.7025579214096069,
-0.2595106065273285,
-0.3707142472267151,
-0.497949481010437,
0.36484864354133606,
0.5035028457641602,
-1.1577630043029785,
0.30855512619018555,
0.3571907877922058,
0.5622045397758484,
0.19835056364536285,
0.41110172867774963,
-0.03552784025669098,
0.06135520339012146,
-0.07526805996894836,
0.19133903086185455,
-0.18902066349983215,
-0.3182547688484192,
-0.579069197177887,
0.37995314598083496,
0.3417212665081024,
-0.020753031596541405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11442v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11442v3 | Can LLMs Reason with Rules? Logic Scaffolding for Stress-Testing and Improving LLMs | 2024-02-18T03:38:51 | 2024-06-21T02:36:55 | Siyuan Wang, Zhongyu Wei, Yejin Choi, Xiang Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive human-like performance
across various reasoning tasks. However, their mastery of underlying
inferential rules still falls short of human capabilities. To investigate this,
we propose a logic scaffolding inferential rule generation framework, to
construct an inferential rule base, ULogic, comprising both primitive and
compositional rules across five domains. Our analysis of GPT-series models over
a rule subset reveals significant gaps in LLMs' logic understanding compared to
human performance, especially in compositional and structural complex rules
with certain bias patterns. We further distill these rules into a smaller-scale
inference engine for flexible rule generation and enhancing downstream
reasoning. Through a multi-judger evaluation, our inference engine proves
effective in generating accurate, complex and abstract conclusions and
premises, and improve various commonsense reasoning tasks. Overall, our work
sheds light on LLMs' limitations in grasping inferential rule and suggests ways
to enhance their logical reasoning abilities~\footnote{Code and data are
available at \url{https://github.com/SiyuanWangw/ULogic}.}. | [
-0.11515241861343384,
-0.6425600051879883,
0.9175878167152405,
0.04548845440149307,
-0.4199882745742798,
-0.15608200430870056,
-0.1235342025756836,
-0.37097984552383423,
-0.3215453624725342,
0.7238118648529053,
-0.6480174660682678,
-0.28240272402763367,
-0.3688584864139557,
0.11650753021240234,
-0.18838529288768768,
0.9627308249473572,
0.11238060891628265,
-0.05292702838778496,
-0.6874569654464722,
0.04431324452161789,
-0.37485697865486145,
-0.5192263722419739,
-0.20144566893577576,
-0.8215106129646301,
0.1008395403623581,
0.6734806299209595,
0.46310314536094666,
0.6361366510391235,
0.3640609383583069,
0.2512143552303314,
-0.13927146792411804,
0.5769287347793579,
-0.2218906134366989,
0.2858196198940277,
-0.297559529542923,
-0.47532135248184204,
-0.43544521927833557,
-0.12026655673980713,
0.37976565957069397,
0.603976309299469,
-0.34682366251945496,
0.05228051915764809,
0.15060627460479736,
0.5656640529632568,
-0.4154032766819,
0.1322382390499115,
-0.8364068865776062,
-0.20367924869060516,
-0.270832359790802,
-0.1275668740272522,
-0.5255762934684753,
-0.21493719518184662,
-0.22086156904697418,
-0.4614909887313843,
-0.028328685089945793,
0.20587968826293945,
0.9778146147727966,
0.4960820972919464,
-0.691040575504303,
-0.2029760181903839,
-0.42473235726356506,
0.5367720723152161,
-1.025983452796936,
0.4430009126663208,
0.18739743530750275,
0.2952127456665039,
-0.4755290746688843,
-0.767491340637207,
-0.3780965805053711,
-0.29309576749801636,
-0.18191654980182648,
-0.027102062478661537,
-0.14293751120567322,
0.25280699133872986,
0.656606912612915,
0.18798545002937317,
-0.44684967398643494,
-0.007917724549770355,
-0.24523739516735077,
-0.040485866367816925,
0.7484782934188843,
0.2267530858516693,
0.12503379583358765,
-0.20367799699306488,
-0.38714858889579773,
0.14870135486125946,
-1.1276488304138184,
0.024689259007573128,
0.27221864461898804,
0.31515371799468994,
0.2347598671913147,
0.6285618543624878,
-0.37761780619621277,
0.5379778742790222,
0.14940299093723297,
-0.38603582978248596,
0.06844327598810196,
-0.04103495180606842,
-0.5748440623283386,
0.02214285358786583,
0.37708431482315063,
0.48904404044151306,
0.40155690908432007,
-0.16080236434936523,
-0.22818809747695923,
0.28507524728775024,
0.10284952819347382,
-0.9562394618988037,
-0.19231097400188446,
0.019741350784897804,
-0.40098512172698975,
-0.04307088628411293,
-0.010370470583438873,
-0.6063655614852905,
-0.6185663342475891,
-0.4214962124824524,
0.17569272220134735,
-0.5074371695518494,
-0.12882189452648163,
0.47136446833610535,
-0.0456230528652668,
0.27724117040634155,
0.27971121668815613,
-0.7636997699737549,
0.5677750706672668,
0.5414759516716003,
0.44248878955841064,
0.03168020024895668,
-0.1377791464328766,
-0.6087855100631714,
0.23182347416877747,
-0.12925270199775696,
1.0500845909118652,
-0.5053107738494873,
-0.23955883085727692,
-0.12321097403764725,
-0.3486085534095764,
-0.07539402693510056,
-0.726001501083374,
0.8294419646263123,
-0.367323637008667,
-0.04751553386449814,
-0.22872185707092285,
-0.9258403778076172,
-0.16741196811199188,
0.064977265894413,
-0.3174063563346863,
1.0314799547195435,
-0.006490160245448351,
-0.5474852323532104,
0.4267880320549011,
-0.6735273599624634,
-0.6098487973213196,
0.16789428889751434,
-0.3967972993850708,
-0.058977801352739334,
0.17545366287231445,
0.11538862437009811,
0.4677741825580597,
-0.648682713508606,
0.3325400650501251,
-0.4995937645435333,
-0.26534825563430786,
0.24728965759277344,
-0.1510700136423111,
0.7077343463897705,
0.28456681966781616,
-0.5511180758476257,
0.19326205551624298,
-0.6517451405525208,
0.17947962880134583,
0.10299871116876602,
-0.4212728440761566,
-0.10804317891597748,
0.3814590871334076,
-0.1325579136610031,
0.4294242560863495,
-0.3238321840763092,
-0.3497826159000397,
0.3118559420108795,
-0.11443021148443222,
0.4594680964946747,
0.9805342555046082,
-0.05311683565378189,
0.2556415796279907,
-0.3952605724334717,
0.33458462357521057,
-0.007173929829150438,
-0.04095154628157616,
-0.04431948438286781,
-0.4386294186115265,
-0.779640257358551,
-0.46959447860717773,
0.048924993723630905,
0.5545801520347595,
-0.4316924214363098,
0.3952260911464691,
-0.2364627718925476,
-0.2650704085826874,
-0.20686709880828857,
0.42302563786506653,
0.2916159927845001,
0.538016676902771,
0.25594091415405273,
-0.1418842226266861,
-0.5822543501853943,
-0.6980708241462708,
-0.4214041829109192,
-0.19868819415569305,
-0.18856455385684967,
0.1392374038696289,
0.6300147175788879,
-0.2224608063697815,
0.8424308896064758,
-0.3830220103263855,
-0.16308893263339996,
-0.4338326156139374,
-0.15757372975349426,
0.3199376165866852,
0.21765486896038055,
0.3884430229663849,
-0.4750879406929016,
-0.050492338836193085,
-0.15795835852622986,
-0.8666648268699646,
-0.42744261026382446,
-0.04098857194185257,
-0.18944816291332245,
0.14708462357521057,
0.8925278186798096,
-0.81135094165802,
0.3851855397224426,
0.1335071325302124,
-0.7666831016540527,
0.7180982232093811,
-0.02635967917740345,
-0.23651720583438873,
-0.6431300044059753,
-0.32440727949142456,
-0.06976921856403351,
-0.3809751570224762,
-0.4727284610271454,
0.08191098272800446,
-0.11576265096664429,
0.21182656288146973,
-0.2504986822605133,
0.5008962750434875,
-0.3440493941307068,
0.06485620141029358,
-0.3121982216835022,
0.12868952751159668,
0.06946700811386108,
0.4359295070171356,
-0.17984946072101593,
0.34788474440574646,
0.5644263625144958,
-0.6569092869758606,
0.366592139005661,
-0.04708294942975044,
-0.5105722546577454,
0.8170265555381775,
-0.7572741508483887,
0.033843111246824265,
-0.0397082082927227,
0.4756537973880768,
-0.9053205847740173,
-0.5134550333023071,
0.16729862987995148,
0.06287048757076263,
0.05458381772041321,
-0.27064454555511475,
-0.8680512309074402,
-0.2394292801618576,
-0.013888722285628319,
0.2207559496164322,
0.7203563451766968,
-0.6029729247093201,
0.9028032422065735,
0.1539200246334076,
0.10105101764202118,
-0.21566428244113922,
-0.5960925817489624,
-0.034851327538490295,
-0.5224987268447876,
-0.7873348593711853,
0.15063583850860596,
-0.2715722620487213,
-0.8362721800804138,
0.08628233522176743,
-0.32246696949005127,
-0.007020183373242617,
0.22051160037517548,
0.5593222379684448,
0.09795226156711578,
-0.21648603677749634,
0.25035715103149414,
0.03567292168736458,
0.24213023483753204,
0.3052133321762085,
-0.5261655449867249,
0.2873917520046234,
-0.5164304375648499,
-0.6434969305992126,
-0.13015151023864746,
0.31607145071029663,
0.5985117554664612,
-0.11940819770097733,
0.08139324188232422,
0.014738999307155609,
-0.4567142724990845,
-0.6249345541000366,
-0.5980985164642334,
-0.3811419904232025,
-0.49003979563713074,
-0.07870073616504669,
-0.6031748652458191,
-0.8804188370704651,
0.3105520009994507,
-0.360093355178833,
-0.03289125859737396,
0.526435136795044,
0.5200328230857849,
-0.1743108332157135,
0.824302613735199,
0.5150697231292725,
0.282098650932312,
0.00529307359829545,
0.0827576294541359,
0.09400675445795059,
-0.5966525673866272,
-0.13210850954055786,
-0.12923474609851837,
-0.07497908174991608,
-0.4529530704021454,
-0.275771826505661,
0.30053603649139404,
0.21168959140777588,
-0.4032351076602936,
-0.10386087745428085,
-0.22533488273620605,
0.8038702607154846,
0.49997636675834656,
0.22255262732505798,
0.4078742265701294,
-0.0960599035024643,
-0.5947529077529907,
0.19006851315498352,
-0.592062771320343,
-0.5648350715637207,
0.8307746052742004,
0.1268376111984253,
0.8279474973678589,
0.19378414750099182,
0.5121757984161377,
0.4237157702445984,
0.43282550573349,
-0.6288982033729553,
0.715592086315155,
-0.009137994609773159,
-0.8305765390396118,
-0.1739884465932846,
-0.46346238255500793,
-0.5790131092071533,
0.5012708902359009,
-0.13885369896888733,
-0.8022505640983582,
-0.06483113765716553,
0.18421214818954468,
-0.34312549233436584,
0.5216986536979675,
-0.5615434646606445,
0.7537679076194763,
-0.47164323925971985,
-0.338578462600708,
-0.16994012892246246,
-0.5954814553260803,
0.6551511287689209,
0.171669140458107,
0.19591984152793884,
-0.4944850206375122,
0.3079087436199188,
0.4492062032222748,
-0.5893998146057129,
1.1277436017990112,
-0.08053747564554214,
-0.1598605066537857,
0.4480389654636383,
0.2289663851261139,
0.4628137946128845,
0.08694847673177719,
-0.15466547012329102,
-0.24853353202342987,
-0.2044932097196579,
-0.565818190574646,
-0.686665415763855,
0.42347878217697144,
-0.38316771388053894,
-0.763647198677063,
-0.3914449214935303,
-0.6276354193687439,
-0.38147208094596863,
0.26057666540145874,
0.1490662544965744,
0.23049432039260864,
0.06909279525279999,
0.11273844540119171,
0.7011054158210754,
0.5047821998596191,
0.26162976026535034,
0.2582225501537323,
-0.05506448447704315,
-0.17516875267028809,
0.47849392890930176,
-0.04757362976670265,
0.14628705382347107,
-0.058809794485569,
0.2738635838031769,
-0.34855011105537415,
-0.5942405462265015,
-0.4323318302631378,
0.3003832697868347,
-1.0366932153701782,
-0.2635234594345093,
-0.11085009574890137,
-0.06328548491001129,
-0.3473532199859619,
-0.11628083139657974,
0.02011566422879696,
-0.3710097670555115,
0.047414787113666534,
-0.25562387704849243,
0.512183427810669,
0.9449467062950134,
0.02062789537012577,
0.19690275192260742,
-0.4616750478744507,
0.10836175829172134,
0.506117045879364,
0.3569982647895813,
-0.16767503321170807,
-0.6389200091362,
0.004197129048407078,
-0.19953781366348267,
-0.2937122881412506,
-0.7311437129974365,
-0.17600569128990173,
0.25237929821014404,
0.7327303290367126,
0.6800334453582764,
0.10072691738605499,
0.6163280010223389,
-0.5657933354377747,
0.49772581458091736,
0.05786461755633354,
-1.069911003112793,
0.467433363199234,
-0.5299614667892456,
-0.027621157467365265,
0.49156761169433594,
-0.023107601329684258,
-0.45521461963653564,
-0.25281232595443726,
-0.8229935169219971,
-0.8956634402275085,
0.3797747492790222,
0.16361907124519348,
-0.1595498025417328,
0.13752105832099915,
0.6268096566200256,
0.02170536108314991,
0.15837666392326355,
-0.7054112553596497,
0.07312457263469696,
-0.162568598985672,
-0.1927817016839981,
0.11120740324258804,
-0.12616389989852905,
-0.338511198759079,
-0.3138389587402344,
0.635744571685791,
-0.4892711639404297,
-0.016839997842907906,
0.20875997841358185,
-0.25917407870292664,
-0.007650017272680998,
0.3497702479362488,
0.5913457870483398,
0.7013968229293823,
-0.2599155902862549,
0.4244171380996704,
0.45853719115257263,
-0.013119052164256573,
0.24162791669368744,
0.31507936120033264,
-0.14684909582138062,
-0.38037869334220886,
0.5192092657089233,
0.6611184477806091,
0.03242030367255211,
-0.985395610332489,
0.2895360589027405,
0.10022584348917007,
-0.503566324710846,
-0.18207186460494995,
0.29355815052986145,
0.1734922081232071,
0.5486354231834412,
0.23409883677959442,
-0.10140318423509598,
0.028199149295687675,
-0.5464891195297241,
0.4847917854785919,
0.28044238686561584,
-0.16463983058929443,
-0.1815757304430008,
0.7434267401695251,
0.19729503989219666,
0.18673546612262726,
0.5352973937988281,
-0.29300713539123535,
-0.5618297457695007,
0.411674827337265,
0.7324386239051819,
0.7393642067909241,
0.04967549070715904,
0.047839172184467316,
-0.2028130143880844,
0.42671167850494385,
-0.21170231699943542,
0.3891630470752716,
-0.15105053782463074,
-0.765802800655365,
-0.4718267023563385,
-0.36278724670410156,
-0.5575171113014221,
0.05361303314566612,
-0.300628125667572,
-0.004666567780077457,
-0.614288330078125,
0.09792999923229218,
-0.16560091078281403,
-0.051995813846588135,
-0.5405067801475525,
0.40852487087249756,
0.35050445795059204,
1.0085148811340332,
-0.8946669697761536,
0.7222803235054016,
0.8460512757301331,
-0.40882059931755066,
-0.7117540836334229,
0.029950691387057304,
0.30881986021995544,
-0.6534026861190796,
0.6956068873405457,
0.2695058286190033,
-0.5213286280632019,
-0.4138697385787964,
-0.7573743462562561,
-0.5785545706748962,
1.007813811302185,
0.6162436008453369,
-0.19249749183654785,
-0.01731959357857704,
0.1633864790201187,
0.42178529500961304,
-0.6672402620315552,
0.3062891364097595,
0.821704089641571,
0.6178397536277771,
0.15226703882217407,
-0.5107816457748413,
0.5044869184494019,
-0.46415841579437256,
-0.341347336769104,
0.021459970623254776,
-0.7516640424728394,
0.7420560717582703,
-0.48869025707244873,
-0.16964340209960938,
-0.0929858535528183,
0.7477086186408997,
0.5504603981971741,
0.40496107935905457,
0.8549593091011047,
0.7957194447517395,
1.1541770696640015,
-0.14302514493465424,
1.0641725063323975,
-0.00023011845769360662,
-0.03249550983309746,
1.3004320859909058,
-0.6548756957054138,
0.6313400864601135,
0.43363627791404724,
0.10286728292703629,
0.9056901335716248,
0.7898603677749634,
0.01850905828177929,
0.20931971073150635,
0.6850932836532593,
-0.30372142791748047,
-0.7839874029159546,
-0.35321956872940063,
0.011180761270225048,
0.4969923794269562,
0.41553640365600586,
-0.1383853405714035,
-0.23450012505054474,
-0.359173983335495,
0.34084418416023254,
0.0586845837533474,
-0.2360362857580185,
0.4709060788154602,
0.17127317190170288,
-0.5495221614837646,
0.5868850946426392,
-0.09372995793819427,
0.3998410403728485,
-0.5232689380645752,
-0.03418398275971413,
-0.31523633003234863,
0.5172480940818787,
-0.2958402931690216,
-0.7657703757286072,
-0.03972287476062775,
0.04012579470872879,
-0.06052546575665474,
-0.21882463991641998,
0.9638233780860901,
-0.18377730250358582,
-0.4303748309612274,
0.39485231041908264,
0.6923208832740784,
0.1896340399980545,
-0.11432350426912308,
-0.3579961955547333,
-0.3135983943939209,
-0.10058825463056564,
-0.36096513271331787,
0.1352836638689041,
0.7648760080337524,
-0.4444705843925476,
0.7901648879051208,
0.7016990184783936,
0.02732541784644127,
-0.048253998160362244,
0.18130668997764587,
1.0214643478393555,
-0.698535680770874,
-0.21866025030612946,
-1.063367247581482,
0.6568589210510254,
-0.16951237618923187,
-0.3864796757698059,
0.6447520852088928,
0.4446587562561035,
0.6874547004699707,
0.11359886080026627,
0.9481337666511536,
0.03841102868318558,
0.12566162645816803,
-0.7318425178527832,
0.34276512265205383,
-0.6888502240180969,
0.11521026492118835,
-0.07799029350280762,
-0.5675249099731445,
-0.5937869548797607,
0.3689481317996979,
0.000019808223441941664,
-0.027522103860974312,
0.7609215378761292,
0.6575919389724731,
-0.17582543194293976,
0.05742878094315529,
0.32938888669013977,
0.2691972851753235,
0.45362961292266846,
0.6314893364906311,
0.9992674589157104,
-0.042679980397224426,
0.7037680745124817,
0.02260121889412403,
-0.2579016089439392,
-0.3109729588031769,
-1.1437937021255493,
-1.1124725341796875,
-0.2645602822303772,
-0.024491434916853905,
-0.42852121591567993,
0.03762604668736458,
1.0422791242599487,
0.7410057187080383,
-0.5529240369796753,
-0.477449506521225,
-0.1726439893245697,
0.36565065383911133,
-0.3387942910194397,
-0.18942877650260925,
0.22676227986812592,
-0.4873514175415039,
-0.19284415245056152,
0.628198504447937,
0.16714699566364288,
-0.016645045951008797,
0.24305398762226105,
-0.2544986605644226,
-0.09673082828521729,
0.5588933229446411,
0.6776961088180542,
0.1862560510635376,
-0.7630714774131775,
-0.385654479265213,
0.002991969231516123,
0.07789117097854614,
-0.04026862978935242,
1.0848122835159302,
-0.5950635075569153,
0.08996816724538803,
0.4070913791656494,
0.5383120179176331,
0.3298499882221222,
-0.011452308855950832,
0.3250662684440613,
-0.5642497539520264,
-0.06186937168240547,
0.034284379333257675,
0.814923882484436,
0.2268238663673401,
-0.22720737755298615,
0.7278779745101929,
0.46299299597740173,
-0.6712214350700378,
-0.8286244869232178,
0.6209311485290527,
-0.8457132577896118,
-0.3404884338378906,
1.3796755075454712,
-0.021219726651906967,
-0.13856393098831177,
-0.012358508072793484,
-0.1670253872871399,
0.04429072514176369,
-0.40684938430786133,
0.6872870922088623,
0.7323904633522034,
-0.6863731741905212,
-0.043307334184646606,
-0.46181413531303406,
0.7119489312171936,
0.48900744318962097,
-1.1917475461959839,
0.38566532731056213,
0.6451377272605896,
0.3640938401222229,
-0.07499689608812332,
0.5280343294143677,
0.09768889844417572,
0.24300381541252136,
-0.13378477096557617,
-0.009269249625504017,
0.0015429717022925615,
-0.4073431193828583,
-0.07886666059494019,
0.01044336799532175,
0.1359323412179947,
0.22862976789474487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11441v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11441v1 | InfuserKI: Enhancing Large Language Models with Knowledge Graphs via Infuser-Guided Knowledge Integration | 2024-02-18T03:36:26 | 2024-02-18T03:36:26 | Fali Wang, Runxue Bao, Suhang Wang, Wenchao Yu, Yanchi Liu, Wei Cheng, Haifeng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Though Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable open-generation
capabilities across diverse domains, they struggle with knowledge-intensive
tasks. To alleviate this issue, knowledge integration methods have been
proposed to enhance LLMs with domain-specific knowledge graphs using external
modules. However, they suffer from data inefficiency as they require both known
and unknown knowledge for fine-tuning. Thus, we study a novel problem of
integrating unknown knowledge into LLMs efficiently without unnecessary overlap
of known knowledge. Injecting new knowledge poses the risk of forgetting
previously acquired knowledge. To tackle this, we propose a novel
Infuser-Guided Knowledge Integration (InfuserKI) framework that utilizes
transformer internal states to determine whether to enhance the original LLM
output with additional information, thereby effectively mitigating knowledge
forgetting. Evaluations on the UMLS-2.5k and MetaQA domain knowledge graphs
demonstrate that InfuserKI can effectively acquire new knowledge and outperform
state-of-the-art baselines by 9% and 6%, respectively, in reducing knowledge
forgetting. | [
-0.2449035942554474,
-0.528388261795044,
0.670322060585022,
-0.1557963490486145,
-0.061847005039453506,
0.4526054561138153,
-0.18263019621372223,
-0.18915660679340363,
-0.06351738423109055,
0.6748703718185425,
-0.3181471824645996,
-0.2332579493522644,
-0.5808133482933044,
-0.31802430748939514,
-0.36245131492614746,
0.8533788919448853,
-0.3112817108631134,
0.14272694289684296,
-0.7079662680625916,
0.1613667607307434,
-0.4667651951313019,
-0.22488103806972504,
-0.5544989109039307,
-0.9002349972724915,
0.01656731590628624,
0.7638490200042725,
0.5025124549865723,
-0.07364138960838318,
0.3185870945453644,
0.2338588386774063,
-0.12415452301502228,
0.7437934875488281,
-0.7805551290512085,
-0.037871986627578735,
-0.18767821788787842,
-0.5267188549041748,
-0.17359143495559692,
-0.4431549310684204,
0.9995806217193604,
0.7963941097259521,
-0.06255543231964111,
0.08128707855939865,
0.46347397565841675,
0.72504723072052,
-0.7135946750640869,
0.22125253081321716,
-0.6718894839286804,
-0.0020842552185058594,
-0.3106386363506317,
-0.11002500355243683,
-0.5379222631454468,
-0.34025803208351135,
0.14581431448459625,
-0.5172664523124695,
-0.24253806471824646,
-0.0317365787923336,
0.6530523300170898,
0.28488844633102417,
-0.3423430025577545,
-0.19224236905574799,
-0.9028802514076233,
0.5425607562065125,
-0.8644506335258484,
0.601474404335022,
0.3757080137729645,
0.3527713418006897,
-0.6081899404525757,
-0.673707902431488,
-0.857669472694397,
0.0012127126101404428,
-0.2736310064792633,
0.07093595713376999,
-0.24649310111999512,
-0.10471239686012268,
0.1759186089038849,
0.3046618103981018,
-0.3507629632949829,
0.09723574668169022,
-0.04529659450054169,
-0.022478077560663223,
0.20319221913814545,
0.19371190667152405,
0.28070640563964844,
0.03105773963034153,
-0.23671558499336243,
0.20971842110157013,
-0.9671850204467773,
-0.007339040748775005,
0.39130857586860657,
0.11476317048072815,
0.015032460913062096,
0.5598285794258118,
-0.2260308563709259,
0.6919224262237549,
-0.009718515910208225,
-0.3058135211467743,
0.13387562334537506,
-0.1984153538942337,
-0.14630910754203796,
-0.004010229371488094,
0.6417905688285828,
-0.014030632562935352,
0.3017204999923706,
-0.49660569429397583,
0.053303733468055725,
-0.43005508184432983,
0.018783273175358772,
-0.8973190784454346,
-0.3305375874042511,
0.11742734163999557,
-0.12977741658687592,
-0.09316416829824448,
0.08913912624120712,
-0.7317843437194824,
-0.5809270739555359,
0.013004911132156849,
0.5360236167907715,
-0.7605493664741516,
-0.404984712600708,
0.0052779484540224075,
-0.3610643148422241,
0.17700065672397614,
0.15614382922649384,
-0.7589353322982788,
0.438079833984375,
0.5460923314094543,
0.6917180418968201,
-0.13777129352092743,
-0.33061838150024414,
-0.21528670191764832,
0.6678363084793091,
-0.1882125735282898,
0.7354467511177063,
-0.559444785118103,
-0.3526774048805237,
0.116207554936409,
-0.11269155144691467,
0.0703393965959549,
-0.5459067821502686,
0.1247837245464325,
-0.7807064056396484,
0.07427696883678436,
-0.10894687473773956,
-1.0774205923080444,
-0.27031928300857544,
0.18709209561347961,
-0.4747808277606964,
1.1265528202056885,
0.5444899797439575,
-0.6480303406715393,
0.38914355635643005,
-0.749258279800415,
-0.4462585747241974,
0.31594353914260864,
0.0840882733464241,
-0.3117468059062958,
-0.027559958398342133,
0.1994129866361618,
0.2719578146934509,
-0.4754955470561981,
0.2553882598876953,
-0.36689698696136475,
-0.34401702880859375,
0.5001461505889893,
-0.26950299739837646,
0.6190479397773743,
-0.031537048518657684,
0.03937394917011261,
0.023932354524731636,
-0.6688297986984253,
0.044973842799663544,
0.1297016143798828,
-0.24357295036315918,
-0.5203784704208374,
-0.1513400375843048,
-0.3540830910205841,
0.0013353466056287289,
0.3021182417869568,
-0.6498183012008667,
0.2862611413002014,
-0.5717788338661194,
0.431551069021225,
0.6581231951713562,
0.39306649565696716,
0.8363727331161499,
-0.16650059819221497,
0.2411496937274933,
0.2614768147468567,
0.3202778995037079,
-0.14202463626861572,
-0.6108139157295227,
-1.0138652324676514,
-0.06097492203116417,
0.16566826403141022,
0.294072687625885,
-1.1231435537338257,
0.34888967871665955,
-0.43070679903030396,
-0.6567009091377258,
-0.4109109044075012,
0.33892884850502014,
0.19520840048789978,
0.7697141170501709,
0.3963312804698944,
-0.05555110424757004,
-0.21637140214443207,
-0.6822065114974976,
-0.3260388970375061,
0.03154643252491951,
0.042032673954963684,
0.11787993460893631,
0.5199933052062988,
-0.3774138391017914,
1.1144226789474487,
-0.7682287693023682,
-0.4374184310436249,
-0.31215593218803406,
-0.3592739403247833,
0.40244150161743164,
0.39068952202796936,
0.12604659795761108,
-0.5164308547973633,
-0.7315364480018616,
0.36362341046333313,
-0.7111549377441406,
0.21426787972450256,
0.11579520255327225,
-0.34443026781082153,
0.05907585471868515,
0.4848547577857971,
-0.656585156917572,
0.2275397926568985,
0.4645111858844757,
-0.3358006179332733,
0.21891780197620392,
-0.30863896012306213,
-0.10902831703424454,
-1.1719560623168945,
-0.10101138055324554,
-0.32238641381263733,
-0.1576141119003296,
-0.8449566960334778,
-0.07642070949077606,
0.5814109444618225,
-0.13294203579425812,
-0.3501812815666199,
0.8283513188362122,
-0.36312854290008545,
0.4260543882846832,
-0.2758183777332306,
0.20691022276878357,
-0.013405263423919678,
0.5975243449211121,
-0.43225499987602234,
0.5025521516799927,
0.5439419150352478,
-0.6090632081031799,
0.26314687728881836,
0.3117433488368988,
-0.5123786926269531,
0.5242127776145935,
-0.086231529712677,
0.2738105356693268,
-0.23974953591823578,
0.12095406651496887,
-0.8823983073234558,
-0.3139854073524475,
0.4033750295639038,
-0.17478300631046295,
0.7009912133216858,
-0.29339590668678284,
-0.8072675466537476,
-0.345376580953598,
-0.003728423733264208,
0.4488908648490906,
0.549167275428772,
-0.8377998471260071,
0.9598821401596069,
0.5628378391265869,
0.23287606239318848,
-0.5691784620285034,
-0.6568959951400757,
-0.0000628018460702151,
-0.23301000893115997,
-0.5549384355545044,
0.38676005601882935,
0.013065590523183346,
-0.09819156676530838,
0.37078872323036194,
0.058957621455192566,
-0.11533606797456741,
-0.29327765107154846,
0.12503133714199066,
0.12515507638454437,
0.11210338771343231,
0.4796803593635559,
0.3762410879135132,
-0.10420005023479462,
-0.16812866926193237,
-0.8604443073272705,
0.5533920526504517,
0.15638750791549683,
-0.6198087334632874,
-0.3167075216770172,
0.38728728890419006,
0.6022760272026062,
-0.20397929847240448,
0.981850266456604,
0.2545304000377655,
-0.5687822103500366,
-0.5531948208808899,
-0.6511088609695435,
-0.15729238092899323,
-0.48520228266716003,
0.36132916808128357,
-0.35891327261924744,
-0.9240109324455261,
0.3969058692455292,
-0.49417418241500854,
-0.09614135324954987,
0.3760545253753662,
0.36600765585899353,
-0.3006177842617035,
0.7060956954956055,
0.8209607601165771,
-0.2434581220149994,
0.5034377574920654,
-0.4410480260848999,
0.5005849599838257,
-0.9420801997184753,
-0.30809444189071655,
-0.09612488746643066,
-0.24202623963356018,
-0.24735768139362335,
-0.44345149397850037,
0.5014052987098694,
0.06252136081457138,
-0.26940202713012695,
0.2216852456331253,
-0.2427651584148407,
0.6310935616493225,
0.3748317062854767,
0.2709607779979706,
0.5025179386138916,
-0.17470867931842804,
-0.0309519711881876,
0.16551609337329865,
-1.106162428855896,
-0.08460164815187454,
1.2216362953186035,
0.30263984203338623,
0.8385226726531982,
0.18013866245746613,
0.589627206325531,
-0.02345474250614643,
0.4719070494174957,
-0.691376268863678,
0.27200061082839966,
-0.15871483087539673,
-0.2238733023405075,
-0.5128539800643921,
-0.4758079946041107,
-0.6256669759750366,
0.03803468495607376,
-0.09793665260076523,
-0.5931226015090942,
0.04133853316307068,
0.3011610209941864,
-0.27127525210380554,
0.6319684386253357,
-0.7692040205001831,
0.6473050713539124,
-0.07977808266878128,
0.0450221449136734,
-0.17465384304523468,
-0.23638471961021423,
0.47197315096855164,
-0.39311617612838745,
0.3221113681793213,
0.06961781531572342,
0.11475442349910736,
0.5791603922843933,
-0.41174596548080444,
0.9444592595100403,
-0.25012895464897156,
-0.08764257282018661,
0.3430996239185333,
-0.021580329164862633,
0.9067419767379761,
0.039827968925237656,
0.07352378219366074,
0.2623599171638489,
-0.3056066930294037,
-0.20737165212631226,
-1.0370502471923828,
0.7465419769287109,
-0.5908510088920593,
-0.4046113193035126,
0.08004095405340195,
-0.7568925023078918,
-0.5085057020187378,
0.2955258786678314,
0.2938520014286041,
0.39582598209381104,
-0.1825684756040573,
0.019601808860898018,
1.0211341381072998,
-0.08690184354782104,
0.1901032030582428,
0.5311375856399536,
-0.27977633476257324,
-0.5868639945983887,
1.1534761190414429,
0.3518712520599365,
0.4995615482330322,
0.6385082006454468,
0.3068525195121765,
-0.08427198231220245,
-0.4736127257347107,
-0.46859011054039,
0.4457128643989563,
-0.928758442401886,
-0.5740888714790344,
-0.606149435043335,
-0.33183205127716064,
-0.3081529140472412,
0.09296377003192902,
-0.22075530886650085,
-0.3066950738430023,
-0.19850462675094604,
0.056298382580280304,
0.5201340913772583,
0.9271035194396973,
0.48698511719703674,
0.4548753798007965,
-0.6918122172355652,
0.03115927241742611,
0.3100005090236664,
0.655184268951416,
0.19233448803424835,
-0.6658556461334229,
-0.6838069558143616,
-0.12291663885116577,
-0.3089941442012787,
-0.9914458990097046,
0.10544097423553467,
0.209551140666008,
0.7682042717933655,
0.5489758253097534,
-0.10730352997779846,
0.7665863037109375,
-0.4853503108024597,
0.49225544929504395,
0.14263242483139038,
-0.9608884453773499,
0.346659392118454,
0.010786868631839752,
0.6315039992332458,
0.24662664532661438,
0.2976914644241333,
-0.6162254810333252,
-0.7034804821014404,
-0.586435079574585,
-0.7388680577278137,
0.44106030464172363,
-0.03417091816663742,
0.11972647160291672,
0.24766384065151215,
0.4198700189590454,
0.12531931698322296,
0.045837633311748505,
-0.3881034553050995,
-0.27159613370895386,
0.048295069485902786,
-0.22493599355220795,
0.006712669041007757,
-0.3944903016090393,
-0.1036098450422287,
-0.38164064288139343,
0.8858059048652649,
-0.2585429549217224,
0.11195327341556549,
-0.14576929807662964,
-0.4497371315956116,
-0.2188270092010498,
0.00871302094310522,
0.20038969814777374,
0.44426867365837097,
0.2340017557144165,
0.2089157998561859,
0.7330165505409241,
-0.38085758686065674,
-0.030094776302576065,
-0.1526678502559662,
-0.358593225479126,
-0.2100248783826828,
0.26598283648490906,
0.6897572875022888,
0.5575240254402161,
-0.46792522072792053,
0.30438709259033203,
0.09146282076835632,
0.02414378896355629,
-0.41345229744911194,
0.08321064710617065,
0.4031299352645874,
0.4080617427825928,
0.22691982984542847,
0.10698305815458298,
-0.07814871519804001,
-0.30156275629997253,
0.1375419646501541,
0.614653468132019,
-0.5099808573722839,
0.05201549082994461,
0.22880686819553375,
-0.05325663834810257,
-0.26463043689727783,
0.7054246068000793,
-0.11949144303798676,
-0.45392197370529175,
0.04292447492480278,
0.8034504055976868,
0.7932285666465759,
-0.3303549289703369,
-0.12075292319059372,
0.338317334651947,
0.3084893226623535,
-0.0011927782325074077,
0.1245158389210701,
-0.013256050646305084,
-1.0294166803359985,
-0.3383398950099945,
-0.517089307308197,
-0.3969174921512604,
-0.03703617677092552,
-0.14516469836235046,
0.39697569608688354,
-0.10437659174203873,
-0.04397473856806755,
-0.47866904735565186,
-0.30311357975006104,
-0.6568595767021179,
-0.18114306032657623,
-0.20690979063510895,
1.0279269218444824,
-0.6858056783676147,
1.2083687782287598,
0.2221783846616745,
-0.4006892740726471,
-0.7592265605926514,
0.10714184492826462,
-0.23028045892715454,
-0.6195580363273621,
0.327720046043396,
-0.22621172666549683,
-0.1501230150461197,
0.20280492305755615,
-0.36643505096435547,
-1.1731635332107544,
1.1752930879592896,
0.5611416697502136,
-0.1360599547624588,
0.06597338616847992,
0.40636855363845825,
0.2424243688583374,
-0.27994683384895325,
0.1728202849626541,
0.8016288876533508,
0.6068845391273499,
0.18140335381031036,
-0.6787738800048828,
-0.011234425008296967,
-0.2195914387702942,
-0.060149095952510834,
0.7486667633056641,
-0.5022269487380981,
0.5815311074256897,
-0.21256938576698303,
-0.23213200271129608,
-0.23892523348331451,
0.8122618794441223,
-0.1967531144618988,
-0.12149299681186676,
0.40499475598335266,
0.655947744846344,
1.0283491611480713,
0.035770002752542496,
0.794371485710144,
-0.23180927336215973,
0.16839301586151123,
1.1556823253631592,
0.06540527939796448,
0.7065852284431458,
0.6249855160713196,
-0.12722787261009216,
0.7008206248283386,
0.06836643069982529,
0.03512296825647354,
0.4439094662666321,
0.0673169195652008,
-0.427647203207016,
-0.07874765992164612,
-0.02644006907939911,
-0.17155608534812927,
0.2766343355178833,
0.5223779678344727,
-0.18680809438228607,
-0.119864821434021,
0.11752743273973465,
0.1623723804950714,
-0.10198594629764557,
-0.05570990964770317,
0.9380884170532227,
0.16035255789756775,
-0.6638342142105103,
0.4264700710773468,
-0.30395257472991943,
0.42862245440483093,
-1.0203827619552612,
-0.22878780961036682,
-0.1866387128829956,
0.3813953101634979,
-0.32056891918182373,
-0.9650769233703613,
0.21883133053779602,
-0.15331201255321503,
-0.2462577372789383,
-0.2046348601579666,
0.8591510057449341,
-0.8377522826194763,
-0.4462338089942932,
0.3338022232055664,
0.4226100742816925,
-0.1107802763581276,
-0.16212274134159088,
-0.10180056840181351,
-0.24671368300914764,
-0.06160719320178032,
0.013067161664366722,
0.4497459828853607,
0.5001564621925354,
-0.017065882682800293,
0.8589925169944763,
0.5557923316955566,
0.020319556817412376,
-0.023602010682225227,
0.14857323467731476,
1.0580775737762451,
-0.26565319299697876,
-0.4009225070476532,
-0.9201896786689758,
0.6306139230728149,
-0.316815048456192,
-0.21495598554611206,
0.960054337978363,
0.5485938191413879,
0.9921851754188538,
-0.05846382677555084,
0.8124127984046936,
0.1633048802614212,
0.3005255460739136,
-0.5519919991493225,
1.1707632541656494,
-0.5193696618080139,
0.012664739042520523,
-0.2818772494792938,
-0.7089465856552124,
-0.3356722891330719,
0.04624592140316963,
-0.12069134414196014,
-0.2236616164445877,
0.7643204927444458,
0.8489739894866943,
0.044958386570215225,
-0.08280009776353836,
0.42957672476768494,
0.17226432263851166,
0.49108967185020447,
0.6936715841293335,
0.8789992332458496,
-0.31211212277412415,
0.58896803855896,
-0.424355149269104,
-0.4978315234184265,
0.005505386274307966,
-0.7172795534133911,
-0.8787297606468201,
-0.7666317224502563,
-0.07395297288894653,
-0.1995728611946106,
-0.34476298093795776,
0.6891998052597046,
0.46241965889930725,
-0.7260832190513611,
-0.36406850814819336,
0.08554164320230484,
0.44928303360939026,
-0.3491950035095215,
-0.16611845791339874,
0.24972780048847198,
-0.5039785504341125,
-0.6168988347053528,
0.5950742363929749,
0.41171252727508545,
-0.007497130893170834,
-0.39900171756744385,
-0.18893855810165405,
0.06259790062904358,
0.012217785231769085,
0.5860251784324646,
0.0778600424528122,
-0.5169855952262878,
-0.2121618539094925,
-0.13441497087478638,
0.2573009431362152,
-0.01263176929205656,
1.0082776546478271,
-0.8349727392196655,
0.6579532623291016,
0.44240012764930725,
0.5425935387611389,
0.6945486664772034,
-0.5012030601501465,
0.6324942708015442,
-0.6167816519737244,
-0.060995474457740784,
0.11811649054288864,
0.5859172344207764,
0.3621756136417389,
-0.4818554222583771,
0.19869783520698547,
0.1403461992740631,
-0.44354912638664246,
-0.7572401762008667,
0.4334465265274048,
-0.4805859923362732,
-0.3040841817855835,
1.0251233577728271,
0.041211917996406555,
-0.05873112753033638,
-0.3117506802082062,
-0.05907932668924332,
0.4677561819553375,
-0.19584664702415466,
0.5681726932525635,
0.6320651173591614,
-0.17125794291496277,
-0.06238315999507904,
-0.28134554624557495,
0.7065579295158386,
-0.0324711948633194,
-0.8835268616676331,
0.0489233024418354,
-0.008888915181159973,
0.24583853781223297,
0.049255937337875366,
0.48949334025382996,
-0.10870296508073807,
-0.14686109125614166,
-0.07570153474807739,
0.03934231400489807,
-0.22379153966903687,
-0.39495792984962463,
-0.17677007615566254,
0.2719070017337799,
0.1729668825864792,
0.16675181686878204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11436v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11436v2 | Pride and Prejudice: LLM Amplifies Self-Bias in Self-Refinement | 2024-02-18T03:10:39 | 2024-06-18T04:41:07 | Wenda Xu, Guanglei Zhu, Xuandong Zhao, Liangming Pan, Lei Li, William Yang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent studies show that large language models (LLMs) improve their
performance through self-feedback on certain tasks while degrade on others. We
discovered that such a contrary is due to LLM's bias in evaluating their own
output. In this paper, we formally define LLM's self-bias - the tendency to
favor its own generation - using two statistics. We analyze six LLMs (GPT-4,
GPT-3.5, Gemini, LLaMA2, Mixtral and DeepSeek) on translation, constrained text
generation, and mathematical reasoning tasks. We find that self-bias is
prevalent in all examined LLMs across multiple languages and tasks. Our
analysis reveals that while the self-refine pipeline improves the fluency and
understandability of model outputs, it further amplifies self-bias. To mitigate
such biases, we discover that larger model size and external feedback with
accurate assessment can significantly reduce bias in the self-refine pipeline,
leading to actual performance improvement in downstream tasks. The code and
data are released at https://github.com/xu1998hz/llm_self_bias. | [
-0.3532123267650604,
-0.38793879747390747,
0.601704478263855,
0.4760608375072479,
0.026469409465789795,
-0.18540452420711517,
-0.07137060165405273,
-0.16771653294563293,
0.2537941038608551,
0.6364517211914062,
-0.6579421162605286,
-0.07157135754823685,
-0.5391588807106018,
0.31059277057647705,
-0.3652050495147705,
1.2187505960464478,
0.02930249087512493,
0.5956370830535889,
-0.3676001727581024,
0.03915791213512421,
-0.5881555080413818,
-0.6622781753540039,
-0.030946403741836548,
-0.5538658499717712,
0.5903708934783936,
0.2703707218170166,
0.490987092256546,
0.704745352268219,
0.3881152272224426,
0.2768784761428833,
0.19760683178901672,
-0.07127122581005096,
-0.7662778496742249,
0.8432390689849854,
-0.5834100842475891,
-0.30728891491889954,
-0.2306794673204422,
0.06858941912651062,
0.5165798664093018,
0.10262686014175415,
0.38451340794563293,
0.3540149927139282,
0.5263028144836426,
0.9150806069374084,
-0.648189902305603,
0.08999183028936386,
-0.5301895141601562,
-0.12590910494327545,
-0.3692445456981659,
0.20845060050487518,
-0.14748112857341766,
-0.0722215324640274,
-0.1612616777420044,
-0.12670442461967468,
0.6295114159584045,
-0.17895016074180603,
0.6081742644309998,
0.5550407767295837,
-0.4583187997341156,
-0.46911633014678955,
-0.5928310751914978,
0.9299704432487488,
-0.48925507068634033,
0.19456766545772552,
0.05703090876340866,
-0.05860728397965431,
-0.10933319479227066,
-0.4657054841518402,
-0.42068564891815186,
-0.13675516843795776,
-0.06048924848437309,
0.293495237827301,
0.1661461740732193,
0.07205864042043686,
0.30412864685058594,
0.7203266620635986,
-0.4417476952075958,
0.1958393156528473,
-0.35982003808021545,
-0.13407428562641144,
0.8568304777145386,
0.10693386197090149,
-0.02035205438733101,
-0.484505295753479,
-0.28462257981300354,
0.030496278777718544,
-0.833787202835083,
-0.3910026252269745,
0.4763362407684326,
0.11692403256893158,
0.3358670473098755,
0.7518330216407776,
-0.12650679051876068,
0.140091672539711,
0.32487913966178894,
0.03435336798429489,
0.07466673851013184,
-0.2582350969314575,
-0.2447437047958374,
-0.07142872363328934,
0.777165412902832,
0.13270732760429382,
0.5278973579406738,
0.10719215869903564,
-0.2986115515232086,
0.15798154473304749,
0.3451986312866211,
-0.7269274592399597,
-0.2627880871295929,
0.09386983513832092,
-0.3276909589767456,
-0.07541922479867935,
-0.36386802792549133,
-0.6400002241134644,
-0.6512506008148193,
-0.13021479547023773,
0.4749811291694641,
-0.011402411386370659,
0.10449714213609695,
-0.1593037247657776,
-0.12111040204763412,
0.055844806134700775,
0.2813877761363983,
-1.0114389657974243,
-0.2692897915840149,
0.6046638488769531,
0.4861387610435486,
-0.4834991693496704,
-0.2798464894294739,
-0.2702895998954773,
0.1886286586523056,
-0.354199081659317,
0.7168351411819458,
-0.0849853903055191,
-0.5888869762420654,
-0.03694579750299454,
-0.25857216119766235,
0.06611158698797226,
-0.5538383722305298,
0.7787818908691406,
-0.11168446391820908,
0.3266928195953369,
-0.6141785383224487,
-0.4028487503528595,
0.18220201134681702,
0.09108369052410126,
-0.6281237006187439,
1.045148253440857,
-0.22339986264705658,
-0.7935276031494141,
0.4396025538444519,
-0.25479045510292053,
-0.45331481099128723,
-0.2913009226322174,
-0.6424076557159424,
-0.4132951498031616,
0.4126339554786682,
0.39661869406700134,
0.4924693703651428,
-0.54304438829422,
0.28029629588127136,
-0.5618199706077576,
-0.24869078397750854,
0.1957038789987564,
-0.4644099771976471,
0.43367302417755127,
0.4785507917404175,
-0.5747758746147156,
-0.0724995955824852,
-0.43509340286254883,
-0.26419439911842346,
0.2282649576663971,
-0.24069850146770477,
-0.24258582293987274,
-0.06675324589014053,
-0.5883308053016663,
0.43373605608940125,
0.4832218289375305,
-0.4462769329547882,
0.20272745192050934,
-0.29395169019699097,
0.11295079439878464,
1.0710214376449585,
-0.16540983319282532,
0.4447673559188843,
-0.4402037262916565,
0.445689857006073,
-0.1266033798456192,
0.08735297620296478,
-0.18346112966537476,
-0.3704703152179718,
-1.1137527227401733,
-0.1987062394618988,
0.09391559660434723,
0.06769423186779022,
-0.405573308467865,
-0.08412685990333557,
-0.08819367736577988,
-0.29951149225234985,
-0.6151828765869141,
0.5239603519439697,
0.5662634372711182,
0.41038429737091064,
0.28178170323371887,
-0.49688810110092163,
-0.5135877728462219,
-1.243363857269287,
-0.7434350252151489,
-0.2978767454624176,
-0.023370783776044846,
0.24510352313518524,
0.33736926317214966,
-0.26552310585975647,
1.0210314989089966,
-0.29297247529029846,
-0.5573156476020813,
-0.2707754075527191,
0.16248589754104614,
0.268277108669281,
0.4314252436161041,
0.2745392918586731,
-0.11183974146842957,
-0.41809767484664917,
-0.5319731831550598,
-0.7831612825393677,
-0.702877938747406,
-0.1585933268070221,
-0.22960518300533295,
0.2043130248785019,
0.29354262351989746,
-0.4240807592868805,
0.27727487683296204,
0.5828532576560974,
-0.4096831977367401,
0.8518627285957336,
0.09038610756397247,
-0.050819382071495056,
-0.672563910484314,
-0.48939478397369385,
0.13419237732887268,
-0.06442264467477798,
-0.21543453633785248,
0.11100038141012192,
0.045583367347717285,
0.32908761501312256,
-0.06435469537973404,
0.6286392211914062,
-0.6596844792366028,
-0.16536404192447662,
-0.4117201566696167,
0.32250937819480896,
0.27441057562828064,
0.2193627506494522,
-0.19428123533725739,
0.9325606822967529,
0.4088803231716156,
-0.52388995885849,
0.04972328990697861,
0.09121501445770264,
-0.04546753317117691,
0.384907990694046,
-0.39430129528045654,
0.14393234252929688,
-0.11445029824972153,
0.027914199978113174,
-1.2343859672546387,
-0.052334461361169815,
0.0117582306265831,
-0.4277724027633667,
0.30228447914123535,
-0.13481923937797546,
-0.2748469412326813,
-0.4705218970775604,
-0.30329152941703796,
0.20374299585819244,
0.4944058060646057,
-0.8286131620407104,
0.631262481212616,
0.2946174144744873,
-0.2273801565170288,
-0.8083344101905823,
-1.1002154350280762,
-0.21710114181041718,
-0.19337905943393707,
-0.6472079157829285,
0.23070834577083588,
-0.17248034477233887,
-0.5228700041770935,
-0.44512075185775757,
-0.4019027054309845,
0.15142874419689178,
-0.2713046669960022,
0.4073430895805359,
0.030833322554826736,
0.057576969265937805,
0.3333663046360016,
0.003246536012738943,
0.19150838255882263,
0.49962252378463745,
-0.11897267401218414,
0.4090944826602936,
0.13668671250343323,
-0.42149972915649414,
0.014284900389611721,
0.10690204054117203,
0.3535768985748291,
0.08458523452281952,
0.2565351724624634,
0.3521249294281006,
0.34329745173454285,
-0.4530378580093384,
-1.0051171779632568,
-0.48152345418930054,
-0.485740602016449,
0.2828828990459442,
-0.633472204208374,
-1.095502257347107,
0.37271395325660706,
0.10287962108850479,
0.04970592260360718,
0.8538477420806885,
0.8654341697692871,
-0.1277124285697937,
1.045226812362671,
0.4887722134590149,
-0.1675453931093216,
0.3118462860584259,
-0.1107293963432312,
0.09979952126741409,
-0.844866156578064,
0.08803406357765198,
-0.5983878374099731,
-0.3210955262184143,
-0.7672531604766846,
-0.43387094140052795,
0.06313472986221313,
-0.06403493881225586,
-0.3044179379940033,
-0.09881466627120972,
-0.5950155258178711,
0.3843114972114563,
0.7172425985336304,
-0.2828432619571686,
0.3512127101421356,
-0.10755493491888046,
-0.5129290223121643,
-0.5368724465370178,
-0.7386387586593628,
-0.4713495373725891,
1.2881864309310913,
0.5617435574531555,
1.2951385974884033,
0.04849052429199219,
0.9005122184753418,
0.43482041358947754,
0.4461883306503296,
-0.33223775029182434,
0.4564986824989319,
-0.14225801825523376,
-1.0690209865570068,
-0.09672980010509491,
-0.47196581959724426,
-0.7536807656288147,
0.39404359459877014,
0.11195053905248642,
-0.3400629162788391,
0.4296938478946686,
0.41627126932144165,
0.03366217017173767,
-0.02878250926733017,
-0.7326806783676147,
0.7819053530693054,
-0.5393339991569519,
-0.9813705682754517,
-0.4426547586917877,
-0.13243688642978668,
0.6883208751678467,
-0.18265989422798157,
0.16262364387512207,
-0.2876364588737488,
0.21743349730968475,
0.5324112772941589,
-0.1551200896501541,
0.9862617254257202,
0.03161826729774475,
-0.4195379316806793,
0.2827799618244171,
0.5203618407249451,
0.5993725657463074,
0.2627279758453369,
-0.1804874688386917,
0.24365301430225372,
-0.36436039209365845,
-0.24355989694595337,
-0.4418792724609375,
1.0405299663543701,
-0.8430944681167603,
-1.2197136878967285,
-0.6904625296592712,
-0.38590341806411743,
-0.1894129514694214,
-0.09912938624620438,
0.33836302161216736,
0.018260715529322624,
-0.17882251739501953,
-0.09877033531665802,
0.3925599157810211,
-0.1719624549150467,
0.47154298424720764,
0.5175043940544128,
-0.5762855410575867,
-0.3200410008430481,
0.5293906331062317,
0.24619197845458984,
0.3250094950199127,
-0.07617735117673874,
0.16924649477005005,
-0.6101866364479065,
-0.30883872509002686,
-0.31343987584114075,
0.5643507838249207,
-0.9153878688812256,
-0.0946367159485817,
-0.5459170937538147,
-0.11640720814466476,
-0.8632498979568481,
0.10386885702610016,
-0.5937677025794983,
-0.7113790512084961,
-0.25084781646728516,
-0.0806858018040657,
-0.02569049969315529,
1.1415719985961914,
-0.2528918385505676,
0.2700478434562683,
-0.22338993847370148,
0.12452099472284317,
0.7908163666725159,
0.15528132021427155,
-0.1378612220287323,
-0.9257984161376953,
-0.30154484510421753,
-0.3094522953033447,
-0.7836647629737854,
-0.8726218342781067,
0.48040643334388733,
-0.04955017566680908,
0.48824450373649597,
0.47427889704704285,
0.04993162676692009,
0.5856932997703552,
-0.3017274737358093,
0.9238570332527161,
0.052981480956077576,
-0.9714981913566589,
0.28101029992103577,
-0.19156451523303986,
0.5402237772941589,
0.33441656827926636,
0.15365149080753326,
-0.26760658621788025,
-0.6944002509117126,
-0.529664158821106,
-0.6486992835998535,
0.4798309803009033,
0.2655961811542511,
0.17919707298278809,
-0.2435738742351532,
0.2814826965332031,
0.12734216451644897,
0.25631293654441833,
-1.2730035781860352,
-0.3300401568412781,
-0.284471720457077,
0.043131642043590546,
-0.07301318645477295,
-0.7812671065330505,
-0.03764911741018295,
0.023730292916297913,
0.9351157546043396,
-0.21573388576507568,
0.2919347882270813,
0.5881059765815735,
-0.22080481052398682,
-0.07853933423757553,
0.29729366302490234,
0.23538152873516083,
0.6028068661689758,
0.12439439445734024,
0.25346097350120544,
0.2615446448326111,
-0.31091031432151794,
0.09696292132139206,
-0.06328718364238739,
-0.18151448667049408,
0.16286994516849518,
0.18146352469921112,
0.4727307856082916,
-0.37110427021980286,
-0.4013487994670868,
0.4100578725337982,
0.008778023533523083,
0.12276684492826462,
-0.37896305322647095,
0.2445027083158493,
-0.19981765747070312,
0.3524797558784485,
0.5139864087104797,
-0.20706945657730103,
0.35116106271743774,
-0.3990800082683563,
0.11268607527017593,
0.583591103553772,
-0.3279930055141449,
-0.07649201899766922,
0.8201633095741272,
0.24412769079208374,
0.08423669636249542,
0.3123888373374939,
-0.16512995958328247,
-0.4454271197319031,
0.32052376866340637,
0.651016116142273,
1.1268495321273804,
-0.535842776298523,
0.06790447235107422,
0.4600328505039215,
0.4803805649280548,
-0.0375494658946991,
0.1445750743150711,
-0.008236057125031948,
-0.7752867937088013,
-0.8017879128456116,
-0.7287859916687012,
-0.07868191599845886,
0.1482204794883728,
-0.23643387854099274,
0.2532706558704376,
-0.28809651732444763,
-0.3309766352176666,
-0.488508015871048,
-0.09866094589233398,
-0.4856398105621338,
0.3335907757282257,
0.15691275894641876,
0.544987142086029,
-0.5635555386543274,
0.8152311444282532,
0.3480396568775177,
-0.307391881942749,
-0.5386139154434204,
0.17774273455142975,
0.0925862267613411,
-0.9255784749984741,
0.8908360600471497,
0.20714938640594482,
-0.07284125685691833,
-0.22619955241680145,
-0.24540749192237854,
-1.101636290550232,
0.7722307443618774,
0.5162445306777954,
-0.8893231749534607,
-0.03391718119382858,
0.33128219842910767,
0.5375794172286987,
-0.4219520092010498,
0.4477017819881439,
0.5738388299942017,
0.3983832597732544,
-0.13894318044185638,
-0.9521067142486572,
-0.07818178832530975,
-0.015965064987540245,
0.07134406268596649,
-0.003958734218031168,
-0.8416821360588074,
0.8566358685493469,
-0.22766850888729095,
-0.06644462049007416,
-0.10416601598262787,
0.8252372741699219,
0.3826923072338104,
0.07893574982881546,
0.274814248085022,
0.5473655462265015,
0.4210071861743927,
-0.21270591020584106,
0.9477330446243286,
-0.38769182562828064,
0.2622882127761841,
1.2933778762817383,
-0.29619744420051575,
0.29723286628723145,
0.5981044173240662,
-0.024601371958851814,
0.5145397186279297,
0.3734673857688904,
-0.05917556956410408,
0.2972578704357147,
0.3483068346977234,
-0.11274404078722,
-0.32324227690696716,
0.07032007724046707,
-0.35660383105278015,
0.3050611615180969,
0.20221148431301117,
-0.8632903695106506,
-0.05513666570186615,
-0.1353355348110199,
0.1250186413526535,
0.1286701261997223,
-0.4418700635433197,
0.6261534094810486,
0.20380531251430511,
-1.002032995223999,
0.4415176808834076,
-0.055550508201122284,
0.7026646137237549,
-0.46271514892578125,
0.2811567485332489,
-0.6087775230407715,
0.4188688397407532,
-0.17844250798225403,
-0.755021870136261,
0.22291330993175507,
0.02161950245499611,
-0.3094082772731781,
-0.4526587426662445,
0.8690623641014099,
-0.30001941323280334,
-0.22953839600086212,
0.5287841558456421,
0.673181414604187,
0.1273108869791031,
-0.2851128578186035,
-0.8495275974273682,
0.1137731745839119,
0.3966045379638672,
-0.3759307265281677,
0.37595057487487793,
0.5313759446144104,
0.05534632131457329,
0.8502861857414246,
0.24863150715827942,
0.10645652562379837,
0.32995057106018066,
0.14545899629592896,
0.7297881841659546,
-0.7107998728752136,
-0.2837057411670685,
-1.0484517812728882,
0.3146756589412689,
-0.009318480268120766,
-0.35846999287605286,
1.3970905542373657,
0.7004159688949585,
0.8546966314315796,
-0.24554140865802765,
0.8767592310905457,
0.1782674342393875,
0.6469894051551819,
-0.3070090115070343,
0.48522132635116577,
-0.5014306902885437,
0.4452982246875763,
-0.3544453978538513,
-1.0217171907424927,
0.09417390823364258,
0.5440102815628052,
-0.6147639155387878,
0.44373026490211487,
0.6194057464599609,
0.8594265580177307,
0.31273290514945984,
-0.18037593364715576,
0.33711808919906616,
0.6330423355102539,
0.1951979249715805,
0.18453370034694672,
0.9875297546386719,
-0.04950323328375816,
0.6403480768203735,
-0.18552452325820923,
-0.1035722866654396,
-0.13585823774337769,
-0.7498807311058044,
-1.0400264263153076,
-0.31051105260849,
-0.323171466588974,
-0.5710015892982483,
0.19550278782844543,
0.5917789340019226,
0.6631370186805725,
-0.6708495020866394,
-0.6106592416763306,
-0.161695659160614,
0.25938040018081665,
0.0942753255367279,
-0.21705269813537598,
0.0053450437262654305,
-0.8818771243095398,
-0.8339251279830933,
0.33372876048088074,
0.237396702170372,
-0.03054565005004406,
-0.8309459090232849,
-0.19496621191501617,
0.09054839611053467,
0.30586254596710205,
0.36182495951652527,
0.060715388506650925,
-0.7631834149360657,
-0.035558801144361496,
-0.13662658631801605,
-0.28273144364356995,
0.18986184895038605,
0.8350637555122375,
-0.8766395449638367,
0.636739194393158,
0.5800290703773499,
0.32141727209091187,
0.7415003776550293,
0.019180281087756157,
0.8086502552032471,
-0.761496901512146,
-0.31102871894836426,
0.11622066795825958,
0.5084240436553955,
0.3715173900127411,
-0.4930833578109741,
0.6688810586929321,
0.35622289776802063,
-1.0932729244232178,
-0.5419319868087769,
0.44290292263031006,
-0.23157109320163727,
-0.41330111026763916,
1.143694519996643,
0.13409365713596344,
-0.2257862091064453,
0.029616650193929672,
-0.1910373717546463,
0.1509399265050888,
-0.43676304817199707,
1.1190675497055054,
0.8949214816093445,
-0.41237661242485046,
-0.08504628390073776,
-0.33259260654449463,
0.6520220041275024,
1.0109708309173584,
-0.2642287313938141,
0.19186703860759735,
0.7272550463676453,
0.2514871060848236,
0.3238953649997711,
0.4139798581600189,
-0.18702909350395203,
-0.04936547577381134,
-0.30897217988967896,
0.429186075925827,
0.32523447275161743,
-0.36139926314353943,
-0.5189475417137146,
0.16212421655654907,
0.3375067114830017,
0.16796359419822693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11432v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11432v2 | Can Deception Detection Go Deeper? Dataset, Evaluation, and Benchmark for Deception Reasoning | 2024-02-18T02:52:54 | 2024-06-17T02:57:09 | Kang Chen, Zheng Lian, Haiyang Sun, Bin Liu, Jianhua Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Deception detection has attracted increasing attention due to its importance
in real-world scenarios. Its main goal is to detect deceptive behaviors from
multimodal clues such as gestures, facial expressions, prosody, etc. However,
these bases are usually subjective and related to personal habits. Therefore,
we extend deception detection to deception reasoning, further providing
objective evidence to support subjective judgment. Specifically, we provide
potential lies and basic facts and then analyze why this sentence may be a lie
by combining factual inconsistencies and intent behind them. Compared with
deception detection, this task is more applicable to real-world scenarios. For
example, in interrogation, the police should judge whether a person is lying
based on solid evidence. This paper presents our initial attempts at this task,
including constructing a dataset and defining evaluation metrics. Meanwhile,
this task can serve as a benchmark for evaluating the complex reasoning
capability of large language models. Code and data will be made publicly
available. | [
-0.5000682473182678,
-0.6274308562278748,
0.7869343161582947,
0.10608300566673279,
-0.12589135766029358,
-0.004345227964222431,
-0.22540488839149475,
-0.5866660475730896,
-0.3639725148677826,
0.6265223026275635,
-0.6828399300575256,
-0.49298328161239624,
-0.36514443159103394,
-0.11825492233037949,
-0.26574939489364624,
0.6719434857368469,
0.14746084809303284,
0.2268439084291458,
-0.4388108253479004,
-0.21817395091056824,
-0.5476492643356323,
-0.5307514667510986,
-0.3559388816356659,
-0.3637281656265259,
0.13111063838005066,
0.6032490730285645,
0.44358983635902405,
0.31993162631988525,
0.49885863065719604,
0.29796427488327026,
0.41912463307380676,
0.2281169593334198,
-0.48310285806655884,
0.16646036505699158,
-0.22657544910907745,
-0.6400975584983826,
-0.02197246439754963,
0.1527814120054245,
0.2744545042514801,
0.7282401323318481,
0.13734062016010284,
0.17652527987957,
-0.4123704433441162,
0.4505918025970459,
-0.6925966739654541,
0.15136761963367462,
-0.15415766835212708,
-0.04675234481692314,
-0.10139212757349014,
0.13137823343276978,
-0.4623187780380249,
-0.42221367359161377,
0.19150137901306152,
-0.3548734784126282,
0.3004815876483917,
-0.009313177317380905,
0.7670379281044006,
0.1908423900604248,
-0.5728854537010193,
-0.4018374979496002,
-0.8710901737213135,
0.7156511545181274,
-0.4940919876098633,
0.46682313084602356,
0.312385231256485,
0.49277767539024353,
0.16216695308685303,
-0.7335020303726196,
-0.5959850549697876,
-0.7990090847015381,
-0.19951100647449493,
0.10407514870166779,
-0.2073662132024765,
-0.08628373593091965,
0.5782483816146851,
0.4196013808250427,
-0.6104069352149963,
-0.1922542005777359,
0.025307701900601387,
-0.33778315782546997,
0.6609436869621277,
0.270450621843338,
0.13035815954208374,
0.13078252971172333,
-0.25506407022476196,
-0.36706453561782837,
-0.33127617835998535,
0.18713654577732086,
0.637985110282898,
0.0424659363925457,
-0.18847964704036713,
0.49688613414764404,
-0.5204849243164062,
0.33290842175483704,
0.15008185803890228,
-0.039749860763549805,
0.44288215041160583,
-0.4626135230064392,
-0.13143953680992126,
0.05008057877421379,
0.3273184597492218,
0.44482120871543884,
0.35688361525535583,
0.04059981554746628,
-0.2090909332036972,
0.7934867739677429,
0.19322118163108826,
-0.7824506163597107,
-0.3539283275604248,
0.16152991354465485,
-0.7619720697402954,
-0.38844820857048035,
0.29302269220352173,
-0.5697819590568542,
-0.74659264087677,
-0.4939120411872864,
0.1978030651807785,
-0.457841157913208,
-0.5357033610343933,
0.5066930651664734,
-0.1860945075750351,
0.40232616662979126,
0.286795973777771,
-0.10575472563505173,
0.5776874423027039,
0.9126176238059998,
0.45186150074005127,
-0.03918737173080444,
-0.09391415119171143,
-0.5568349957466125,
-0.21385802328586578,
-0.28192266821861267,
0.6700994372367859,
-0.7077522277832031,
-0.037398386746644974,
-0.003620404051616788,
0.09663593769073486,
0.2787599265575409,
-0.5298108458518982,
1.2101296186447144,
-0.2482253760099411,
0.37111419439315796,
-0.24429069459438324,
-0.5479098558425903,
-0.3665073812007904,
0.5321524739265442,
-0.7044084668159485,
0.7217950820922852,
0.06721602380275726,
-0.39200302958488464,
0.34657540917396545,
-0.6099914908409119,
-0.6841990947723389,
0.0652727410197258,
-0.1208295151591301,
-0.6133992075920105,
0.21735495328903198,
0.2361212521791458,
0.3906218707561493,
-0.5140494704246521,
0.4302951395511627,
-0.4015325903892517,
-0.48348164558410645,
0.8134673237800598,
-0.8004847168922424,
0.8595712780952454,
0.25344762206077576,
-0.47209811210632324,
-0.3126471936702728,
-0.6645873785018921,
0.021608829498291016,
-0.004096546210348606,
-0.1097971573472023,
-0.3205578327178955,
-0.22982636094093323,
-0.029611453413963318,
-0.09569834917783737,
0.10012632608413696,
-0.7323601245880127,
0.19387800991535187,
-0.20662611722946167,
-0.08342450112104416,
0.3951154053211212,
0.04468917101621628,
0.22776199877262115,
-0.1850876808166504,
0.4576128125190735,
0.205518439412117,
0.4144480228424072,
-0.146511048078537,
-0.337382972240448,
-0.8202773332595825,
-0.2631917893886566,
0.5281025767326355,
0.5281656384468079,
-0.5863919854164124,
0.5745478272438049,
-0.311910480260849,
-0.34885430335998535,
-0.5053337812423706,
-0.3845963478088379,
0.7027750611305237,
0.5104855298995972,
0.2506486177444458,
-0.14469729363918304,
-0.5013368725776672,
-1.0635721683502197,
-0.552239716053009,
-0.061768945306539536,
-0.23064389824867249,
0.0954359695315361,
0.7904089689254761,
-0.01601356826722622,
0.6781132221221924,
-0.7737340927124023,
-0.39568740129470825,
-0.020173989236354828,
0.26549914479255676,
0.21501189470291138,
0.4991276264190674,
0.44619354605674744,
-1.1238571405410767,
-0.20758017897605896,
-0.21777495741844177,
-0.7587908506393433,
-0.182125985622406,
-0.21308258175849915,
0.13637249171733856,
-0.1478220373392105,
0.41521453857421875,
-0.5249155759811401,
0.42826229333877563,
0.2642412781715393,
-0.6268326044082642,
0.7998307347297668,
0.2319452464580536,
0.362872838973999,
-0.39727234840393066,
-0.05011473968625069,
0.07902763038873672,
-0.24783922731876373,
-0.862499475479126,
-0.013325031846761703,
-0.056125491857528687,
-0.009697947651147842,
-0.27344346046447754,
0.4051814079284668,
-0.4280550479888916,
-0.10111399739980698,
-0.07324975728988647,
-0.19574713706970215,
0.07528132945299149,
0.3855498433113098,
0.14822247624397278,
0.3138006031513214,
0.7232961654663086,
-0.531303882598877,
0.651552140712738,
-0.024474114179611206,
-0.8355671763420105,
1.1413015127182007,
-0.4930986166000366,
-0.024269163608551025,
-0.1478482484817505,
0.36449170112609863,
-0.9791035652160645,
-0.44537267088890076,
0.5434961318969727,
-0.7023637890815735,
0.04512259364128113,
-0.17158403992652893,
-0.3873841166496277,
-0.14859485626220703,
-0.40238815546035767,
0.2704898715019226,
0.282854288816452,
-0.5425852537155151,
0.7210018634796143,
0.11658508330583572,
0.40909308195114136,
-0.6467941999435425,
-0.81021648645401,
0.20202329754829407,
-0.13388235867023468,
-0.623799204826355,
0.19578346610069275,
-0.051445938646793365,
-0.5052774548530579,
-0.002913141855970025,
-0.18527868390083313,
0.0028703762218356133,
0.052848901599645615,
0.31769901514053345,
-0.03153836354613304,
-0.13146592676639557,
0.2250450700521469,
-0.25630614161491394,
-0.24266661703586578,
0.3212503492832184,
0.017190510407090187,
0.44739821553230286,
-0.5508933067321777,
-0.6794763207435608,
-0.7062070369720459,
0.35065537691116333,
0.4273853600025177,
-0.23576824367046356,
0.34396594762802124,
0.7527649998664856,
-0.4770045280456543,
-0.07068125158548355,
-0.8122118711471558,
-0.4120401442050934,
-0.45261240005493164,
0.10049499571323395,
-0.7195194363594055,
-0.5613932013511658,
0.40806469321250916,
-0.3978046476840973,
-0.31087127327919006,
-0.009146329946815968,
0.3579101264476776,
-0.03074859268963337,
1.204615592956543,
0.3538011610507965,
0.11371399462223053,
0.16429519653320312,
-0.22945056855678558,
0.31929144263267517,
-0.5627431273460388,
-0.33841681480407715,
-0.3714725077152252,
-0.2817651033401489,
-0.6726247668266296,
-0.33486172556877136,
0.25529199838638306,
-0.2286214828491211,
-0.10741691291332245,
0.007315364666283131,
-0.394618421792984,
0.6007072925567627,
0.43151628971099854,
0.40483561158180237,
0.2869158387184143,
-0.1966167390346527,
0.2713199257850647,
0.027880359441041946,
-0.10292510688304901,
-0.4615636467933655,
0.9092786312103271,
0.4407908618450165,
0.6692612171173096,
0.15454022586345673,
0.25012314319610596,
0.5045570135116577,
0.3288000524044037,
-0.8418781757354736,
0.7615995407104492,
-0.07423648983240128,
-0.7053414583206177,
-0.23126888275146484,
-0.3151527941226959,
-0.7381059527397156,
0.23880897462368011,
0.01253539975732565,
-0.29963552951812744,
0.4316141605377197,
-0.21232952177524567,
-0.0013861703919246793,
-0.16784845292568207,
-0.7754940986633301,
0.8370289206504822,
-0.4661325514316559,
-0.31422728300094604,
-0.2203972041606903,
-0.8315868973731995,
0.7199394106864929,
0.362862229347229,
0.0992952510714531,
-0.32248738408088684,
-0.1354358047246933,
0.5810235738754272,
-0.03337159752845764,
0.9181976914405823,
-0.5864830613136292,
-0.11192747205495834,
0.11605499684810638,
0.11847779899835587,
0.3615800440311432,
0.18644210696220398,
0.025750411674380302,
0.07152263075113297,
-0.1794167459011078,
-0.22798636555671692,
-0.8781922459602356,
0.5013986229896545,
-0.2677101194858551,
-0.3259166181087494,
-0.37160512804985046,
-0.34827426075935364,
-0.5746264457702637,
0.0951874628663063,
0.09871284663677216,
0.5438453555107117,
-0.33600369095802307,
0.42672306299209595,
0.9598366618156433,
0.03713228181004524,
-0.024722890928387642,
0.6181098818778992,
-0.0406368151307106,
-0.11052634567022324,
0.8337101936340332,
-0.3075394630432129,
-0.03712886571884155,
0.37679702043533325,
0.5881567001342773,
-0.5720896124839783,
-0.48249632120132446,
-0.029896780848503113,
0.26979413628578186,
-0.8545927405357361,
-0.2255629003047943,
-0.11170797049999237,
0.173745796084404,
-0.31682828068733215,
0.11171913146972656,
-0.18206332623958588,
-0.1632930040359497,
0.034549012780189514,
-0.031498417258262634,
0.026511628180742264,
0.42130792140960693,
-0.08778491616249084,
0.19568297266960144,
-0.3803325295448303,
0.7103211283683777,
0.38725990056991577,
0.3585183918476105,
-0.2567223310470581,
-0.3441905677318573,
0.05482443422079086,
0.2955065369606018,
0.1386541873216629,
-0.7078749537467957,
0.07375822961330414,
-0.09236384183168411,
0.407478392124176,
0.4781031012535095,
0.2223152369260788,
0.4934800863265991,
0.0197434164583683,
0.6066862344741821,
0.1474648267030716,
-0.9755104780197144,
0.4607986807823181,
-0.10581397265195847,
0.17910827696323395,
0.679446280002594,
0.4660254716873169,
-0.5170552134513855,
-0.06118720397353172,
-0.5982016324996948,
-0.04810565337538719,
0.5973720550537109,
0.2713702619075775,
0.08124972879886627,
0.4958351254463196,
0.3186396062374115,
0.216449573636055,
0.3612034320831299,
-0.6676003336906433,
-0.2238892763853073,
-0.05568934604525566,
-0.3486638367176056,
-0.038726743310689926,
-0.015267743729054928,
-0.42998644709587097,
-0.367524653673172,
0.3207516372203827,
-0.4040374159812927,
0.38525301218032837,
0.037737783044576645,
-0.19310617446899414,
0.22102656960487366,
0.10498251765966415,
0.5304532647132874,
0.6212399005889893,
-0.03738422691822052,
0.24428336322307587,
0.0317242331802845,
-0.49980300664901733,
0.13768136501312256,
0.03334394469857216,
-0.07571449875831604,
-0.15956903994083405,
0.7369456887245178,
0.6889467835426331,
-0.02947346866130829,
-0.8819278478622437,
1.0197428464889526,
-0.31703275442123413,
-0.36103981733322144,
-0.402329683303833,
0.09078668057918549,
-0.08169029653072357,
0.4643068313598633,
0.26253825426101685,
0.11059219390153885,
0.4980778098106384,
-0.893742024898529,
0.2670833468437195,
0.49074238538742065,
-0.3918974697589874,
-0.20881199836730957,
0.0571465864777565,
0.16616907715797424,
-0.12468472868204117,
0.677341103553772,
-0.20575517416000366,
-0.8664781451225281,
0.5900929570198059,
0.26336532831192017,
0.7439531683921814,
-0.3323754668235779,
0.31329086422920227,
-0.09870724380016327,
0.4284156560897827,
-0.08513758331537247,
0.5541451573371887,
-0.2390516698360443,
-0.9061794877052307,
-0.3112719655036926,
-0.2653995752334595,
-0.39444389939308167,
0.4428517520427704,
-0.6873218417167664,
0.1914498209953308,
-0.33196738362312317,
0.06987453252077103,
0.06823526322841644,
0.19898700714111328,
-0.6352170705795288,
0.6251324415206909,
0.3864738345146179,
0.7305383086204529,
-0.9317325353622437,
0.4929523766040802,
0.2530454695224762,
-0.23714421689510345,
-0.14592190086841583,
0.1976357102394104,
-0.03298217058181763,
-0.7630898356437683,
0.5188082456588745,
0.520270586013794,
-0.42403459548950195,
-0.39687874913215637,
-1.0939359664916992,
-0.37101927399635315,
0.6130186915397644,
0.40040159225463867,
-0.5709661245346069,
0.2599031925201416,
0.29366207122802734,
0.8345633745193481,
-0.67559415102005,
0.08892224729061127,
1.0013227462768555,
0.9400319457054138,
0.0733482837677002,
-0.4726891815662384,
0.2892221212387085,
-0.07948512583971024,
-0.24754230678081512,
-0.0323571115732193,
-0.5132619142532349,
0.8081761002540588,
0.01329744327813387,
-0.32800474762916565,
-0.04105692356824875,
0.4922657608985901,
0.024845125153660774,
0.5036842823028564,
0.7514572739601135,
0.6158674955368042,
0.8735512495040894,
-0.38158291578292847,
1.0723999738693237,
0.18130135536193848,
0.0699167475104332,
1.1849188804626465,
-0.4916369318962097,
0.40092307329177856,
0.0265444815158844,
-0.08854088187217712,
0.7524850964546204,
0.4124015271663666,
-0.35366058349609375,
0.6183575391769409,
0.33654502034187317,
-0.28687989711761475,
-0.5744670629501343,
-0.3233402669429779,
-0.18943734467029572,
0.7180508375167847,
0.798814058303833,
-0.08131984621286392,
0.01097218506038189,
0.33883652091026306,
-0.07541505992412567,
0.06615869700908661,
-0.2787654399871826,
0.5830880999565125,
-0.2502864897251129,
-0.7060149908065796,
0.40747037529945374,
-0.03226974606513977,
0.4497312009334564,
-0.2804013192653656,
-0.22997047007083893,
0.0031475231517106295,
0.5285939574241638,
-0.39426207542419434,
-1.2119184732437134,
0.07188541442155838,
-0.21844162046909332,
0.17192719876766205,
-0.18681758642196655,
1.0898771286010742,
-0.27577322721481323,
-0.17934435606002808,
0.04697278514504433,
0.36869487166404724,
0.19685503840446472,
-0.524264931678772,
-0.832991898059845,
0.18417033553123474,
-0.07616749405860901,
-0.25177422165870667,
-0.08670765906572342,
0.3424438238143921,
0.0025973638985306025,
0.7957977652549744,
0.9177563190460205,
-0.2585437297821045,
-0.17960232496261597,
0.48246634006500244,
0.7873634099960327,
-0.4878448247909546,
-0.4054826498031616,
-0.671127438545227,
0.4858291745185852,
-0.5417795777320862,
-0.2822885513305664,
0.8387405276298523,
0.7154418230056763,
0.8757256865501404,
-0.1652592271566391,
0.8741000890731812,
-0.03540082648396492,
0.6134767532348633,
-0.5554196238517761,
0.12099474668502808,
-0.2513592541217804,
0.04706607386469841,
0.10559654235839844,
-0.698771595954895,
-0.34236380457878113,
0.6517313122749329,
-0.3607081472873688,
-0.0168082807213068,
0.6887863278388977,
0.6628117561340332,
-0.3063724637031555,
0.34404492378234863,
0.2809787392616272,
0.09460972249507904,
0.35986608266830444,
0.5675636529922485,
1.2182749509811401,
-0.5920983552932739,
0.5702489018440247,
-0.2953028380870819,
-0.2801719307899475,
-0.40881475806236267,
-0.7806767821311951,
-0.9589770436286926,
-0.47394028306007385,
-0.3284308612346649,
-0.33970290422439575,
-0.22835402190685272,
0.32584863901138306,
0.6373611092567444,
-0.7496221661567688,
-0.10196434706449509,
-0.12979137897491455,
0.10033465921878815,
-0.4434072971343994,
-0.2970198392868042,
0.09932836890220642,
0.1319134533405304,
-0.5890102982521057,
0.5075544118881226,
0.07152830809354782,
-0.021624045446515083,
-0.614317774772644,
-0.13027970492839813,
-0.14621256291866302,
0.11788433790206909,
0.5603749752044678,
0.0630810484290123,
-0.5535947680473328,
-0.3771459758281708,
-0.04326878488063812,
0.08592557162046432,
0.10203211009502411,
1.133607029914856,
-0.835318922996521,
0.37259963154792786,
0.5066923499107361,
0.4539203643798828,
0.7858763337135315,
0.09431370347738266,
0.32786253094673157,
-0.858822762966156,
-0.09449544548988342,
0.6972697377204895,
0.07087920606136322,
0.37451857328414917,
-0.3832171559333801,
0.711714506149292,
0.2468446046113968,
-0.2963307201862335,
-1.1271746158599854,
0.5558151006698608,
-0.8840342164039612,
-0.42598825693130493,
0.8632510304450989,
-0.08282700926065445,
-0.20880718529224396,
-0.5234277248382568,
-0.2573529779911041,
0.008405093103647232,
-0.26465538144111633,
0.5339577198028564,
0.7831538319587708,
-0.42328914999961853,
-0.11951965093612671,
-0.200726717710495,
0.5911431312561035,
0.11761493980884552,
-1.1317435503005981,
0.3378584384918213,
0.6768489480018616,
0.28704941272735596,
0.48776859045028687,
0.33829936385154724,
0.08401348441839218,
0.5481496453285217,
0.21200419962406158,
-0.27792397141456604,
-0.07780642062425613,
-0.45474955439567566,
-0.48926231265068054,
0.23196059465408325,
-0.45820900797843933,
-0.15324710309505463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11430v1 | EventRL: Enhancing Event Extraction with Outcome Supervision for Large Language Models | 2024-02-18T02:41:06 | 2024-02-18T02:41:06 | Jun Gao, Huan Zhao, Wei Wang, Changlong Yu, Ruifeng Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study, we present EventRL, a reinforcement learning approach
developed to enhance event extraction for large language models (LLMs). EventRL
utilizes outcome supervision with specific reward functions to tackle prevalent
challenges in LLMs, such as instruction following and hallucination, manifested
as the mismatch of event structure and the generation of undefined event types.
We evaluate EventRL against existing methods like Few-Shot Prompting (FSP)
(based on GPT4) and Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) across various LLMs, including
GPT-4, LLaMa, and CodeLLaMa models. Our findings show that EventRL
significantly outperforms these conventional approaches by improving the
performance in identifying and structuring events, particularly in handling
novel event types. The study emphasizes the critical role of reward function
selection and demonstrates the benefits of incorporating code data for better
event extraction. While increasing model size leads to higher accuracy,
maintaining the ability to generalize is essential to avoid overfitting. | [
-0.08985072374343872,
-0.7993544340133667,
0.5595342516899109,
0.1367175132036209,
-0.111516572535038,
0.10462407767772675,
-0.5452783703804016,
-0.43176737427711487,
-0.035435061901807785,
0.3348267674446106,
-0.456265926361084,
-0.5178900361061096,
-0.5462170243263245,
-0.04209303855895996,
-0.2991884648799896,
1.3669328689575195,
-0.1784987896680832,
-0.08117911964654922,
0.01665329560637474,
0.3485797941684723,
-0.18973608314990997,
-0.6524617671966553,
-1.3168398141860962,
-0.480629026889801,
0.8001838326454163,
0.43600237369537354,
0.15118750929832458,
0.38074755668640137,
0.48579856753349304,
0.19844499230384827,
-0.21162854135036469,
0.4806284010410309,
-0.6807959079742432,
0.08288345485925674,
-0.1001514419913292,
-0.3144834339618683,
-0.3869084417819977,
-0.3056914508342743,
0.5443530678749084,
0.26322370767593384,
-0.5059801340103149,
0.02466876432299614,
0.09183400124311447,
0.42508694529533386,
-0.7030274271965027,
0.4279835820198059,
-0.5359846949577332,
0.2945714294910431,
-0.16807027161121368,
-0.5545411705970764,
-0.7790340781211853,
-0.3277910053730011,
-0.09370289742946625,
-0.4704630374908447,
0.04668648540973663,
0.03357437998056412,
0.6378945708274841,
0.24107585847377777,
-0.3755144774913788,
-0.4125564992427826,
-0.7949028611183167,
0.8215256333351135,
-0.7020430564880371,
0.24804793298244476,
0.36068278551101685,
0.37393420934677124,
-0.3664024770259857,
-0.6940302848815918,
-0.4286252558231354,
-0.3020332455635071,
-0.007890176959335804,
0.049839578568935394,
0.044867996126413345,
0.20741543173789978,
0.40717095136642456,
-0.057145118713378906,
-0.5840542316436768,
0.4361151158809662,
-0.29300978779792786,
-0.002944251289591193,
0.746751070022583,
0.4156401753425598,
0.16977716982364655,
-0.11665765196084976,
-0.17924481630325317,
-0.18524911999702454,
-0.9572761058807373,
0.2610577940940857,
0.2737126052379608,
0.4624972343444824,
-0.015116479247808456,
0.4361128509044647,
-0.1920447051525116,
0.4660768210887909,
-0.06295787543058395,
-0.015427185222506523,
0.06174590438604355,
-0.21993565559387207,
-0.18731403350830078,
0.34661945700645447,
0.6142364144325256,
-0.025392800569534302,
0.34181898832321167,
-0.2066914141178131,
-0.3061026930809021,
-0.3265295922756195,
0.24191002547740936,
-0.8007915019989014,
-0.34593260288238525,
0.2208629697561264,
-0.48066258430480957,
-0.6102622151374817,
0.08273087441921234,
-0.8098316192626953,
-0.38021084666252136,
-0.2257738709449768,
0.33821338415145874,
-0.39616453647613525,
-0.23153777420520782,
0.08944781869649887,
-0.04627423360943794,
0.5045242309570312,
0.5983858704566956,
-0.9725369215011597,
0.20587846636772156,
0.922237753868103,
0.6148890256881714,
-0.8193493485450745,
-0.1773744523525238,
-1.3699747323989868,
0.12098008394241333,
-0.40013259649276733,
0.6071358919143677,
-0.5525326728820801,
-0.24403606355190277,
0.0669264942407608,
-0.052401650696992874,
-0.006680611986666918,
-0.4768277704715729,
0.5279935002326965,
-0.8152783513069153,
-0.034229911863803864,
0.08941329270601273,
-0.6408863663673401,
0.06609033048152924,
0.11271966248750687,
-0.5017760396003723,
1.080283761024475,
-0.0756152868270874,
-0.3437671363353729,
0.3879091143608093,
-0.6987119317054749,
-0.5631421804428101,
0.18824425339698792,
-0.41210436820983887,
-0.5368849039077759,
0.20008544623851776,
0.3194347023963928,
0.5048658847808838,
0.1523149013519287,
0.42796215415000916,
-0.23238518834114075,
-0.20737583935260773,
0.3917621076107025,
-0.4097437560558319,
0.2524448037147522,
0.1850106418132782,
-0.3434145152568817,
0.4836680591106415,
-0.8153021335601807,
0.01025297213345766,
0.04346686601638794,
-0.5941824913024902,
-0.16689112782478333,
0.34382468461990356,
0.19927869737148285,
0.3392813801765442,
0.22428740561008453,
-0.3507232367992401,
0.3377874791622162,
-0.455739289522171,
0.1053958311676979,
0.8476144075393677,
0.28205907344818115,
0.2309482991695404,
-0.09123494476079941,
0.7308714985847473,
0.0016521284123882651,
0.14711758494377136,
-0.22296439111232758,
-0.21743294596672058,
-0.6032730937004089,
-0.27800634503364563,
0.25426000356674194,
0.42312535643577576,
-0.938820481300354,
0.2860155999660492,
0.09770683199167252,
-0.04484863951802254,
-0.2134195864200592,
0.06549317389726639,
0.6257963180541992,
0.23041759431362152,
0.24227720499038696,
-0.04451476037502289,
-0.9177019596099854,
-0.4034384489059448,
0.03756239637732506,
-0.17596182227134705,
0.13569201529026031,
-0.026635777205228806,
0.3840535283088684,
0.024049535393714905,
0.7522278428077698,
-0.3834117352962494,
-0.2976391315460205,
-0.6695606112480164,
0.35482436418533325,
0.21185646951198578,
0.35589346289634705,
0.1908065676689148,
-0.6922588348388672,
-0.2799297571182251,
0.4650355875492096,
-0.6665394306182861,
-0.007474953308701515,
-0.28415367007255554,
0.18519191443920135,
0.6867456436157227,
0.5776859521865845,
-0.3298778831958771,
0.5107448697090149,
0.4112658202648163,
-0.44878292083740234,
0.7357891201972961,
-0.15631979703903198,
0.14548924565315247,
-0.667711079120636,
-0.02536522038280964,
-0.17397458851337433,
-0.4502360224723816,
-0.5632650852203369,
-0.013952216133475304,
0.0810266062617302,
0.23017126321792603,
-0.6279634833335876,
0.6066466569900513,
-0.2334083467721939,
-0.3865111768245697,
-0.46595510840415955,
0.059193190187215805,
-0.25147363543510437,
0.5641883611679077,
0.40645894408226013,
0.5677980184555054,
0.17108476161956787,
-0.6593140363693237,
0.37562811374664307,
0.2812320590019226,
-0.4179646968841553,
0.0022634679917246103,
-0.4975295066833496,
0.0181717649102211,
0.14264872670173645,
0.11496610939502716,
-0.610711932182312,
-0.1653870791196823,
-0.016975868493318558,
-0.5108504891395569,
0.38622385263442993,
-0.15386754274368286,
-0.3933027386665344,
-0.005437844432890415,
-0.27121615409851074,
-0.051176153123378754,
0.623916745185852,
-0.7818131446838379,
0.3791281282901764,
0.11655402183532715,
-0.34893345832824707,
-0.5146849751472473,
-0.3628281056880951,
-0.12049967050552368,
-0.2392711043357849,
0.0904514268040657,
0.05989408865571022,
0.11073436588048935,
-0.17980749905109406,
0.02806093916296959,
-0.1500336229801178,
0.027595963329076767,
0.1319468915462494,
0.09481614083051682,
0.2893424928188324,
-0.14035958051681519,
0.22882604598999023,
-0.06302456557750702,
-0.041601356118917465,
-0.05399632826447487,
-0.06127329170703888,
0.5786210894584656,
-0.029722994193434715,
-0.5672567486763,
-0.4847322404384613,
0.21476778388023376,
0.023891672492027283,
-0.24755509197711945,
0.633966326713562,
0.8403428792953491,
-0.2609756886959076,
-0.5103058218955994,
-0.3826175332069397,
-0.3554432988166809,
-0.4526183009147644,
0.6003608107566833,
-0.33517900109291077,
-1.2864799499511719,
0.3245537281036377,
0.07420191913843155,
0.03840776905417442,
0.17953889071941376,
0.6225789189338684,
-0.07708888500928879,
1.2984323501586914,
0.5982047915458679,
-0.13276927173137665,
0.9081017374992371,
0.0443694069981575,
0.04340321198105812,
-0.899293839931488,
-0.3312879204750061,
-0.379440575838089,
-0.12245941907167435,
-0.3323494791984558,
-0.39447757601737976,
0.22465349733829498,
0.3302440643310547,
-0.1994924545288086,
0.11212588101625443,
-0.23384058475494385,
0.45584556460380554,
0.40058526396751404,
-0.13303007185459137,
0.47717684507369995,
-0.1478414535522461,
0.22199484705924988,
-0.13114234805107117,
-0.820113480091095,
-0.4260527789592743,
0.9995661973953247,
0.2687552273273468,
0.9175621271133423,
0.07818873226642609,
1.0672129392623901,
0.3316909968852997,
0.2026900351047516,
-0.6286452412605286,
0.35563763976097107,
0.015811165794730186,
-0.13099439442157745,
-0.6212797164916992,
-0.5638687014579773,
-1.0310717821121216,
0.24181394279003143,
-0.06850394606590271,
-1.1333824396133423,
0.06596434861421585,
0.17419110238552094,
-0.35939979553222656,
0.11741383373737335,
-0.39526164531707764,
0.8324660062789917,
-0.27984607219696045,
-0.21813802421092987,
-0.32840704917907715,
-0.2621372938156128,
0.3818677067756653,
-0.06355680525302887,
0.3757580816745758,
0.06806692481040955,
0.08258106559515,
0.749591052532196,
-0.08960258960723877,
0.9434201717376709,
-0.014735923148691654,
-0.21757006645202637,
0.1173044815659523,
0.31293460726737976,
1.1246565580368042,
0.19376610219478607,
0.0054907179437577724,
-0.4133661985397339,
0.04972570762038231,
0.08531320840120316,
-0.754123330116272,
0.5423670411109924,
-0.623854398727417,
-0.21071340143680573,
-0.1856878101825714,
-0.334452360868454,
-0.12388092279434204,
-0.2678297162055969,
-0.015828317031264305,
0.6365377306938171,
-0.23675891757011414,
0.14460083842277527,
0.8417811393737793,
-0.44120821356773376,
0.6495397090911865,
0.7423688769340515,
-0.540003776550293,
-0.28460484743118286,
1.128978967666626,
-0.38561031222343445,
0.1926366686820984,
0.555324375629425,
0.03903380036354065,
-0.2187419980764389,
-0.6686591506004333,
-0.20868688821792603,
-0.0715608149766922,
-0.6572374701499939,
-0.29703289270401,
-0.723960816860199,
-0.29443955421447754,
-0.39905717968940735,
-0.25116488337516785,
-0.44189372658729553,
-0.4490542709827423,
-0.447426438331604,
-0.3671044409275055,
0.4359768033027649,
0.7625442743301392,
-0.19016118347644806,
0.3207162022590637,
-0.7468834519386292,
0.19970369338989258,
0.0482512041926384,
0.11008143424987793,
0.05318579077720642,
-0.6331073641777039,
-0.33092573285102844,
-0.5999796390533447,
-0.3198520243167877,
-0.7280473709106445,
0.6275517344474792,
0.3780721127986908,
0.7527225613594055,
0.3854234516620636,
0.032042134553194046,
0.6007328033447266,
-0.6792658567428589,
0.7167018055915833,
0.2712567150592804,
-0.9478775262832642,
0.8220227956771851,
-0.27670443058013916,
0.13636350631713867,
0.21098646521568298,
0.19469912350177765,
-0.7804287075996399,
-0.6548970341682434,
-0.8846067786216736,
-0.9033973217010498,
1.0718367099761963,
0.02243002876639366,
-0.290755033493042,
-0.1460782140493393,
0.17612820863723755,
0.03616299852728844,
0.22567355632781982,
-0.9231392741203308,
0.13798047602176666,
0.36126279830932617,
-0.4173276722431183,
-0.261718213558197,
-0.21966552734375,
0.026692574843764305,
-0.049695633351802826,
0.7244952917098999,
-0.2604008913040161,
0.07620283216238022,
0.04134850576519966,
-0.2905970513820648,
-0.17619046568870544,
0.3582111597061157,
0.6793251037597656,
0.6479418277740479,
-0.031019777059555054,
0.10156168043613434,
0.46158885955810547,
-0.02352803573012352,
-0.13712191581726074,
-0.015262353233993053,
0.15302111208438873,
-0.19475410878658295,
0.8290736675262451,
1.0168315172195435,
0.636289119720459,
-1.0554882287979126,
0.4224233329296112,
0.07161739468574524,
-0.16515754163265228,
-0.2898337244987488,
0.3676249384880066,
-0.1634812206029892,
0.7328682541847229,
0.36851465702056885,
-0.7523689270019531,
0.27849841117858887,
-0.4114527106285095,
0.646952211856842,
0.2608441412448883,
-0.5396413207054138,
-0.3563561737537384,
0.5200438499450684,
0.05227336660027504,
-0.27924516797065735,
0.49191904067993164,
-0.47136616706848145,
-0.5722016096115112,
0.8765131235122681,
0.6709157824516296,
0.6759582161903381,
-0.15880389511585236,
0.4406122863292694,
0.37425267696380615,
0.26588207483291626,
-0.158537358045578,
0.2806656062602997,
-0.05111662298440933,
-0.601944625377655,
-1.00836980342865,
-0.9207248687744141,
-0.5899651646614075,
0.2419942319393158,
-0.7346147298812866,
0.26248255372047424,
-0.19757433235645294,
0.3526122570037842,
-0.1822529435157776,
-0.02661302499473095,
-0.3891080915927887,
-0.13548749685287476,
0.397203654050827,
0.7517666220664978,
-0.7297608256340027,
1.0367850065231323,
0.5845590233802795,
-0.48189541697502136,
-0.9605124592781067,
-0.3429741859436035,
0.15267623960971832,
-0.5602359771728516,
1.1567107439041138,
-0.1695978045463562,
0.1700376719236374,
0.1309397667646408,
-0.3336518108844757,
-0.7556131482124329,
0.8060650825500488,
0.012791939079761505,
-0.6260608434677124,
-0.09622444957494736,
-0.1373445838689804,
0.6021672487258911,
-0.4649609327316284,
0.28869014978408813,
0.698161244392395,
0.2816828787326813,
0.29703500866889954,
-0.8288304209709167,
-0.04128875210881233,
0.24561578035354614,
0.10340384393930435,
0.38879871368408203,
-0.15683916211128235,
0.5849888324737549,
-0.22532591223716736,
-0.04409589245915413,
-0.10997331887483597,
0.6486868858337402,
0.5758168697357178,
0.20029354095458984,
0.22019371390342712,
0.17060363292694092,
0.6778926849365234,
-0.029345544055104256,
1.026119351387024,
0.3441297113895416,
0.559088945388794,
1.410962700843811,
-0.5066875219345093,
1.0252095460891724,
0.5336578488349915,
-0.13760723173618317,
0.23734985291957855,
0.6905057430267334,
0.22976051270961761,
0.8284907937049866,
0.28996604681015015,
-0.1510086953639984,
-0.4567570984363556,
0.17112790048122406,
-0.190236434340477,
0.3765510618686676,
0.44098231196403503,
-0.07110100239515305,
-0.42526930570602417,
0.30662035942077637,
-0.1526799499988556,
-0.13190780580043793,
-0.3509853482246399,
1.1965198516845703,
0.18288654088974,
-0.6367696523666382,
0.2392578125,
-0.05818966403603554,
0.5833731889724731,
-0.6965813040733337,
-0.279483437538147,
-0.17473377287387848,
0.3238179683685303,
-0.15547555685043335,
-0.6748121976852417,
0.38101157546043396,
0.14718841016292572,
0.11961148679256439,
-0.22266417741775513,
0.705167829990387,
-0.6309547424316406,
-0.12201657891273499,
0.464836984872818,
0.2986597716808319,
0.17633062601089478,
0.14172659814357758,
-0.5116372108459473,
0.5055355429649353,
0.082711361348629,
-0.6789492964744568,
0.5762699246406555,
0.6589949727058411,
-0.16824856400489807,
0.5917909145355225,
0.6425268650054932,
0.39110541343688965,
0.052692752331495285,
0.2275603860616684,
0.6068509221076965,
-0.6815992593765259,
-0.522055983543396,
-1.0405694246292114,
0.42742669582366943,
-0.29039230942726135,
-0.29335132241249084,
0.386452317237854,
0.5374966263771057,
0.8670554161071777,
0.0014610328944399953,
0.7230024337768555,
-0.09468457102775574,
0.2959239184856415,
-0.8744166493415833,
0.3233930766582489,
-0.4615185856819153,
0.21126119792461395,
-0.18156008422374725,
-0.6223767399787903,
-0.29226770997047424,
0.6034768223762512,
-0.43895062804222107,
-0.24616596102714539,
0.708977460861206,
0.6689908504486084,
0.1285201460123062,
0.047417543828487396,
0.5240925550460815,
-0.07472804188728333,
0.7011173963546753,
0.7367534041404724,
1.1980665922164917,
0.02279384806752205,
0.5884407758712769,
0.2782765328884125,
-0.24548844993114471,
-0.6236499547958374,
-1.0100122690200806,
-0.8083671927452087,
-0.5903613567352295,
-0.47501182556152344,
-0.021530045196413994,
0.5201675891876221,
1.1646448373794556,
0.5892772674560547,
-1.090334177017212,
-0.23587599396705627,
-0.018263226374983788,
0.30458617210388184,
-0.36917707324028015,
-0.2330217957496643,
0.33183616399765015,
-1.08046555519104,
-0.640021026134491,
0.5479249954223633,
0.2618643045425415,
-0.2550625205039978,
0.15466026961803436,
-0.33991333842277527,
-0.04444264993071556,
-0.19602617621421814,
0.8196872472763062,
0.4510899782180786,
-0.5649251937866211,
-0.5124712586402893,
-0.408570259809494,
-0.11384637653827667,
-0.0920068770647049,
0.7399206161499023,
-0.5288224220275879,
-0.04593773931264877,
0.26865535974502563,
0.9237928986549377,
0.9502981305122375,
-0.318148672580719,
0.6070088148117065,
-1.0535460710525513,
0.10959792882204056,
0.15005268156528473,
0.2496238350868225,
-0.09456077963113785,
-0.48629334568977356,
0.7027375102043152,
-0.16705872118473053,
-0.6232059597969055,
-0.9862270355224609,
0.36965903639793396,
-0.9188897013664246,
-0.2576034963130951,
1.462372064590454,
0.032905105501413345,
-0.15852588415145874,
0.09263066947460175,
-0.25996172428131104,
0.3082033097743988,
-0.4447963833808899,
0.7393541932106018,
0.6876791715621948,
-0.5110900402069092,
-0.5053301453590393,
-0.8411412239074707,
0.8893517255783081,
0.22874456644058228,
-1.1988937854766846,
0.2723124027252197,
0.5145274996757507,
0.06422387063503265,
-0.2657806873321533,
0.6511725783348083,
-0.15424147248268127,
0.4377003610134125,
-0.5549167990684509,
0.42074519395828247,
-0.04290361702442169,
-0.5046870708465576,
-0.7070388197898865,
0.11938031017780304,
0.23509059846401215,
-0.08876190334558487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11422v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11422v1 | Mitigating Catastrophic Forgetting in Multi-domain Chinese Spelling Correction by Multi-stage Knowledge Transfer Framework | 2024-02-18T01:46:46 | 2024-02-18T01:46:46 | Peng Xing, Yinghui Li, Shirong Ma, Xinnian Liang, Haojing Huang, Yangning Li, Hai-Tao Zheng, Wenhao Jiang, Ying Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chinese Spelling Correction (CSC) aims to detect and correct spelling errors
in given sentences. Recently, multi-domain CSC has gradually attracted the
attention of researchers because it is more practicable. In this paper, we
focus on the key flaw of the CSC model when adapting to multi-domain scenarios:
the tendency to forget previously acquired knowledge upon learning new
domain-specific knowledge (i.e., catastrophic forgetting). To address this, we
propose a novel model-agnostic Multi-stage Knowledge Transfer (MKT) framework,
which utilizes a continuously evolving teacher model for knowledge transfer in
each domain, rather than focusing solely on new domain knowledge. It deserves
to be mentioned that we are the first to apply continual learning methods to
the multi-domain CSC task. Experiments prove the effectiveness of our proposed
method, and further analyses demonstrate the importance of overcoming
catastrophic forgetting for improving the model performance. | [
0.2090897113084793,
-0.5497124791145325,
0.4966032803058624,
0.21573993563652039,
0.24753674864768982,
0.46548888087272644,
-0.08426038175821304,
-0.12372392416000366,
-0.21508024632930756,
0.18167270720005035,
-0.805609405040741,
-0.42871978878974915,
-0.5311137437820435,
-0.00607430562376976,
-0.17752091586589813,
0.6733120083808899,
-0.22782056033611298,
-0.09534688293933868,
-0.10488134622573853,
-0.10916886478662491,
-0.7568142414093018,
-0.6716122627258301,
-1.2642663717269897,
-0.2564334571361542,
0.7115718722343445,
0.6477628350257874,
0.3627954125404358,
0.23003476858139038,
0.21849170327186584,
0.16875609755516052,
-0.07424887269735336,
0.6044558882713318,
-0.502432107925415,
-0.1850893348455429,
-0.29939553141593933,
-0.35263705253601074,
-0.4164954423904419,
-0.19848217070102692,
0.9578646421432495,
0.8376091122627258,
-0.42455700039863586,
-0.19032983481884003,
0.4281381666660309,
0.7168479561805725,
-0.8060570359230042,
0.04677015542984009,
-0.8906712532043457,
0.23910894989967346,
0.012553418055176735,
-0.23868092894554138,
-0.8017669916152954,
-0.23080039024353027,
0.22418813407421112,
-0.906798779964447,
0.4707357883453369,
-0.11266074329614639,
0.6301258206367493,
-0.11352960765361786,
-0.47881707549095154,
-0.3843446671962738,
-1.0025800466537476,
0.7564806342124939,
-0.5760775804519653,
0.3460827171802521,
0.35131582617759705,
0.35365939140319824,
-0.21233077347278595,
-0.6336013078689575,
-0.6710119843482971,
-0.22483627498149872,
0.3413124084472656,
0.40871328115463257,
0.33085060119628906,
0.07317617535591125,
0.0192765761166811,
0.12751106917858124,
-0.5590679049491882,
-0.10000749677419662,
-0.281217098236084,
-0.4601879417896271,
0.06481950730085373,
0.1682298630475998,
0.40009552240371704,
0.11851272732019424,
-0.33418846130371094,
0.1504361480474472,
-0.7355768084526062,
0.0032799665350466967,
-0.004139285534620285,
0.471231073141098,
0.30088409781455994,
-0.03342524915933609,
-0.05073772743344307,
0.30922931432724,
0.05699754133820534,
-0.22038701176643372,
0.0029019881039857864,
-0.2568907141685486,
0.12197770923376083,
0.0481102429330349,
0.09894568473100662,
-0.07491665333509445,
0.2488853484392166,
-0.2569950222969055,
0.004069908056408167,
-0.07638338953256607,
0.5525874495506287,
-0.28754547238349915,
-0.5560758113861084,
-0.008957522921264172,
-0.2029923051595688,
-0.11298037320375443,
-0.04981732740998268,
-0.2958010733127594,
-0.3128739297389984,
-0.199945330619812,
0.748774528503418,
-0.6506062150001526,
-0.1746651828289032,
-0.013091321103274822,
0.11897944658994675,
-0.13494598865509033,
0.4320933520793915,
-0.9096834063529968,
0.06928249448537827,
0.5242968797683716,
1.0222134590148926,
-0.13860319554805756,
-0.989310622215271,
-0.11285022646188736,
0.39856627583503723,
-0.4745881259441376,
1.0170114040374756,
-0.22948309779167175,
-0.3583660125732422,
0.17515313625335693,
0.21460622549057007,
-0.7803357243537903,
-0.5496044754981995,
0.5256850719451904,
-0.36406296491622925,
0.13293243944644928,
-0.6047822833061218,
-0.4961094260215759,
-0.3780841529369354,
0.3948635458946228,
-0.477740615606308,
1.01999831199646,
0.0876106470823288,
-0.5376489758491516,
0.4020921587944031,
-0.4134228527545929,
-0.5830370783805847,
-0.07551280409097672,
0.6790135502815247,
-0.5802679657936096,
-0.20836055278778076,
0.1153179332613945,
0.40979182720184326,
0.14173321425914764,
0.2651212513446808,
-0.3672007620334625,
-0.36538225412368774,
0.3147611916065216,
-0.5270573496818542,
0.5473683476448059,
-0.06804269552230835,
-0.20372062921524048,
-0.1016940250992775,
-0.9266334176063538,
-0.04585711285471916,
-0.014722815714776516,
-0.3900115191936493,
-0.5140089392662048,
0.17527900636196136,
-0.24992692470550537,
0.6483187079429626,
0.07096263766288757,
-0.2517407238483429,
0.303192675113678,
-0.1614411175251007,
0.5130079388618469,
1.0922828912734985,
0.07238088548183441,
0.4992833137512207,
-0.5999684929847717,
0.2720657289028168,
0.4443071782588959,
0.513171911239624,
-0.34885790944099426,
-0.25378918647766113,
-1.0912266969680786,
0.1287863403558731,
0.31902259588241577,
0.6403730511665344,
-1.1567045450210571,
-0.10039720684289932,
-0.14355477690696716,
-0.5200070142745972,
-0.2791106700897217,
-0.13207823038101196,
0.2794681191444397,
0.6226380467414856,
0.46035122871398926,
-0.34262070059776306,
-0.3708304464817047,
-0.39288559556007385,
-0.3638356029987335,
-0.18882060050964355,
0.3257647752761841,
0.12966765463352203,
0.4826025068759918,
-0.14915108680725098,
0.4394051432609558,
-0.4730646014213562,
-0.7067610621452332,
-0.02747718058526516,
0.1790875941514969,
-0.2733820974826813,
0.5087935328483582,
0.3731125593185425,
-0.6074672937393188,
-0.571734607219696,
0.04131157323718071,
-0.5447154641151428,
0.19294226169586182,
-0.5708545446395874,
-0.36609822511672974,
0.5119303464889526,
0.12152513116598129,
-0.32964634895324707,
0.40904700756073,
0.36266592144966125,
-0.22498719394207,
1.2126672267913818,
-0.5056987404823303,
0.5000251531600952,
-1.0330677032470703,
0.02945169061422348,
-0.17696820199489594,
0.022790301591157913,
-0.9222158789634705,
-0.01512464601546526,
0.5781282782554626,
0.2074642926454544,
-0.4540137052536011,
0.2652706503868103,
-0.46781641244888306,
0.4433339536190033,
-0.38685524463653564,
0.17822088301181793,
-0.0805986076593399,
0.7286314964294434,
-0.18233264982700348,
0.7517894506454468,
0.4759265184402466,
-0.9308000206947327,
0.02107553370296955,
0.22663037478923798,
0.136439248919487,
0.8463072180747986,
0.1607237011194229,
0.12853382527828217,
0.12004052847623825,
0.3542432487010956,
-0.9223579168319702,
0.12503398954868317,
0.3317718505859375,
-0.5517747402191162,
0.17999805510044098,
0.06793718039989471,
-0.5833572149276733,
-0.8318725824356079,
-0.035528574138879776,
0.24341343343257904,
0.0743279680609703,
-0.7215999364852905,
0.553764283657074,
-0.1195840835571289,
-0.11577878147363663,
-0.6328603625297546,
-0.6263294816017151,
0.1258363276720047,
-0.01643511839210987,
-0.46715548634529114,
0.5083862543106079,
-0.41309309005737305,
0.6203855276107788,
-0.00770154781639576,
-0.30226242542266846,
-0.48196250200271606,
0.0843433290719986,
0.038548681885004044,
0.3533889651298523,
-0.1574409157037735,
0.07923562079668045,
0.22284647822380066,
-0.029660996049642563,
-0.16261453926563263,
-0.7319344878196716,
0.0929611548781395,
0.3922128975391388,
-0.3754209876060486,
-0.2733110785484314,
0.21627171337604523,
0.66292804479599,
0.012570937164127827,
0.9566521048545837,
0.35480576753616333,
-0.732355535030365,
-0.5836935043334961,
-0.6964680552482605,
-0.04605443775653839,
-0.40274953842163086,
0.4077572226524353,
-0.2748698890209198,
-0.7846606373786926,
0.8726291060447693,
-0.5041002035140991,
-0.062250468879938126,
0.5363467931747437,
0.22352764010429382,
0.14986781775951385,
0.7684972882270813,
0.9965238571166992,
-0.1343897581100464,
0.1378621757030487,
-0.06353186070919037,
0.4038063585758209,
-0.871655285358429,
-0.15230587124824524,
-0.27358683943748474,
0.05170470103621483,
-0.0015975716523826122,
-0.24361896514892578,
0.256256103515625,
0.0952453687787056,
-0.37770071625709534,
0.404524028301239,
-0.3622684180736542,
0.2962101101875305,
0.5350454449653625,
0.21004913747310638,
0.4294544756412506,
-0.080044224858284,
-0.5892349481582642,
-0.1381336897611618,
-0.9319382309913635,
0.018441494554281235,
0.9062669277191162,
-0.10523422807455063,
0.11943110078573227,
-0.03308224305510521,
0.29648715257644653,
0.10020801424980164,
0.15153484046459198,
-0.4190237522125244,
0.2437840849161148,
-0.42860954999923706,
-0.5286890864372253,
-0.15220040082931519,
-0.36967045068740845,
-0.5084790587425232,
0.32078036665916443,
-0.16929899156093597,
-0.5044340491294861,
0.16452659666538239,
0.36709824204444885,
-0.654460608959198,
0.79204261302948,
-0.46884429454803467,
0.8205677270889282,
-0.05150597169995308,
-0.22481581568717957,
-0.401086688041687,
-0.4205361604690552,
0.4524294435977936,
-0.6407626867294312,
0.402715802192688,
0.1354215145111084,
0.4387247562408447,
0.5370316505432129,
-0.40649738907814026,
0.7973656058311462,
-0.16268673539161682,
-0.06779701262712479,
0.36268967390060425,
0.13437774777412415,
0.474739670753479,
-0.36711183190345764,
-0.09616711735725403,
0.060114335268735886,
-0.0665285736322403,
-0.41375479102134705,
-0.45635101199150085,
0.7027645707130432,
-0.5855157375335693,
-0.16793765127658844,
-0.5412673950195312,
-0.5278701782226562,
-0.2745550870895386,
0.2554490268230438,
0.20354151725769043,
0.20320522785186768,
-0.3975352346897125,
-0.3984512686729431,
0.712777316570282,
-0.42508912086486816,
0.29611751437187195,
0.7890278100967407,
0.14237932860851288,
-0.335312157869339,
1.2313802242279053,
0.705507755279541,
0.6081569790840149,
0.24387456476688385,
0.11214696615934372,
0.07087858766317368,
-0.528693675994873,
-0.42813658714294434,
0.13109521567821503,
-0.9298074841499329,
-0.2222587913274765,
-0.7300177812576294,
-0.5677827000617981,
-0.6584534645080566,
-0.3677198886871338,
-0.47709760069847107,
-0.23766855895519257,
-0.38397225737571716,
0.14099347591400146,
0.13078272342681885,
0.5535747408866882,
-0.3751819133758545,
0.43596214056015015,
-0.7411646842956543,
0.31807440519332886,
0.19507980346679688,
0.40323567390441895,
0.6006786227226257,
-0.8205609917640686,
-0.6102021336555481,
0.10987430810928345,
-0.7626838684082031,
-0.5167900323867798,
0.5082005858421326,
0.5332337021827698,
0.5662610530853271,
0.2686030864715576,
0.013796764425933361,
1.1030348539352417,
-0.8146515488624573,
0.8894031643867493,
0.13901874423027039,
-0.9610249996185303,
0.3595496416091919,
-0.15188626945018768,
0.5495039820671082,
0.39440497756004333,
0.30559030175209045,
-1.4108446836471558,
-0.39135003089904785,
-0.5230801701545715,
-1.0109199285507202,
0.8362757563591003,
-0.12150277197360992,
-0.08761601150035858,
0.09201139211654663,
0.7009745836257935,
0.25311020016670227,
0.003840642049908638,
-0.6664942502975464,
-0.4349619448184967,
-0.06035922095179558,
0.026660632342100143,
0.09943687170743942,
-0.4877575933933258,
0.3417286276817322,
-0.2125895619392395,
1.2755721807479858,
-0.1511637568473816,
0.10197360813617706,
0.12757113575935364,
-0.4486377239227295,
-0.17480477690696716,
0.19646960496902466,
0.8459888696670532,
0.6637030243873596,
0.33196789026260376,
-0.01909775473177433,
0.6728634834289551,
-0.8943974375724792,
0.08257056027650833,
-0.05523652583360672,
-0.19437988102436066,
-0.2676495313644409,
0.286850243806839,
0.4902918338775635,
0.744584321975708,
-0.06881281733512878,
0.38822412490844727,
0.18814711272716522,
-0.5524886250495911,
-0.5592243075370789,
-0.2968592643737793,
0.17981839179992676,
0.03389253094792366,
0.6361831426620483,
0.6473638415336609,
0.10806682705879211,
-0.23065802454948425,
0.3835045397281647,
0.03554283827543259,
-0.4098719656467438,
-0.3251306414604187,
0.680778980255127,
-0.19564807415008545,
0.075050488114357,
0.7339908480644226,
-0.13287299871444702,
-1.0013121366500854,
0.5719015598297119,
0.6588075757026672,
0.8514859676361084,
-0.9444947838783264,
0.468531996011734,
0.6083875894546509,
0.39720815420150757,
-0.6701493263244629,
-0.11255689710378647,
0.25600942969322205,
-0.6844751834869385,
-0.45345428586006165,
-0.28230229020118713,
-0.4885939359664917,
-0.16346675157546997,
-0.39301133155822754,
0.33969414234161377,
-0.5678884983062744,
0.20392188429832458,
-0.30194517970085144,
-0.16543731093406677,
-0.40301454067230225,
0.15273815393447876,
0.2685125768184662,
0.5366330146789551,
-0.8058318495750427,
1.102060317993164,
0.2666110098361969,
-0.28396153450012207,
-1.2692983150482178,
0.040034350007772446,
0.2806903123855591,
-0.8205767869949341,
0.2880377173423767,
0.08355814963579178,
-0.15254069864749908,
0.10590355098247528,
-0.3040810227394104,
-0.8703800439834595,
1.2446821928024292,
-0.07491113245487213,
-0.5063811540603638,
-0.13392646610736847,
0.3485162854194641,
0.3387318551540375,
-0.1714780330657959,
-0.007235162425786257,
0.4346470832824707,
0.45120713114738464,
0.4660678803920746,
-1.0670998096466064,
-0.16072697937488556,
0.07605597376823425,
0.030759040266275406,
-0.1363700032234192,
-0.7908502221107483,
1.000946283340454,
-0.38305068016052246,
-0.3875083923339844,
0.22569358348846436,
0.6293637156486511,
0.14713850617408752,
0.46011629700660706,
0.4274560809135437,
0.5639575719833374,
1.0311802625656128,
0.026134593412280083,
0.3623884320259094,
-0.18083696067333221,
0.5826449394226074,
0.8995879888534546,
-0.3394913077354431,
0.7517067193984985,
-0.0202424805611372,
-0.1795721799135208,
0.5543496608734131,
0.6880987286567688,
0.0939849391579628,
0.48071199655532837,
0.07926731556653976,
-0.4021073281764984,
-0.3174361288547516,
0.27800649404525757,
-0.2620622515678406,
0.08204177021980286,
0.26261216402053833,
0.053439266979694366,
-0.10602430254220963,
0.5505234003067017,
0.17697052657604218,
0.18663005530834198,
-0.5604188442230225,
0.5694015622138977,
0.21280589699745178,
-0.570283830165863,
0.6417625546455383,
0.018196487799286842,
0.8568313717842102,
-0.5885518193244934,
-0.12189766019582748,
-0.18180163204669952,
0.5559449195861816,
-0.09436148405075073,
-0.3054284155368805,
0.32974138855934143,
-0.4276486337184906,
-0.4790211617946625,
0.016735123470425606,
0.8181679844856262,
-0.718253493309021,
-0.6199591755867004,
0.3351685106754303,
0.13745775818824768,
-0.22382119297981262,
-0.4813780188560486,
-0.9521699547767639,
-0.17134791612625122,
-0.03571202605962753,
0.23378944396972656,
0.2664310932159424,
0.6759881973266602,
-0.1750510185956955,
0.8421559929847717,
0.6147840023040771,
0.07073661684989929,
0.32636138796806335,
0.1970643401145935,
0.5630481243133545,
-0.7066752314567566,
-0.5943485498428345,
-0.6436524987220764,
0.4946802854537964,
0.3370265066623688,
-0.08715853840112686,
0.7332208752632141,
0.273052841424942,
0.8055505752563477,
-0.2572442889213562,
0.9964479207992554,
0.3148558437824249,
0.6768748760223389,
-0.28949397802352905,
1.079480767250061,
-0.4586702585220337,
-0.019489582628011703,
-0.5971351861953735,
-0.7545018196105957,
-0.71788489818573,
0.44893378019332886,
-0.12278501689434052,
-0.005200950428843498,
1.309630036354065,
0.691908597946167,
0.19585837423801422,
0.08174788951873779,
0.5647222995758057,
0.3190211057662964,
0.18867599964141846,
1.1282644271850586,
0.7034562826156616,
-0.7355167865753174,
0.6705225110054016,
-0.40171828866004944,
-0.1942470371723175,
-0.09006614238023758,
-0.6433818340301514,
-0.6400943994522095,
-0.9393047094345093,
-0.4892757534980774,
-0.5167276263237,
0.49588659405708313,
0.5064536333084106,
0.4560643434524536,
-0.8583276867866516,
0.1447264552116394,
0.09964428842067719,
0.12767045199871063,
-0.9141918420791626,
-0.1443106234073639,
0.6049630641937256,
-0.4636837840080261,
-0.5343082547187805,
0.18837116658687592,
0.3277474343776703,
-0.07834028452634811,
-0.07741548866033554,
0.033291637897491455,
-0.4522057771682739,
0.0590851791203022,
0.7895559668540955,
0.41905149817466736,
-0.6071950793266296,
-0.6962950229644775,
0.15469305217266083,
-0.04796939715743065,
0.09574615210294724,
0.8592237830162048,
-0.6140674948692322,
0.3860630691051483,
-0.12756694853305817,
0.5723863840103149,
-0.09447886794805527,
-0.42034512758255005,
0.3306805491447449,
-0.4826096296310425,
-0.16791747510433197,
-0.16533122956752777,
0.12192722409963608,
0.4636397361755371,
-0.6535715460777283,
0.1444232314825058,
0.8042934536933899,
-0.8512540459632874,
-0.4409523010253906,
-0.13487571477890015,
-0.831369936466217,
-0.40450388193130493,
0.975443422794342,
-0.2606967091560364,
-0.1866225004196167,
-0.2836894094944,
-0.32333722710609436,
0.43024691939353943,
0.033202286809682846,
1.093385100364685,
1.0107003450393677,
0.3437955975532532,
-0.018299613147974014,
-0.5942296981811523,
0.35723716020584106,
0.4035080671310425,
-0.3418186902999878,
0.3502287268638611,
0.3732931613922119,
0.5573671460151672,
-0.10744347423315048,
0.7870043516159058,
-0.15523643791675568,
0.4821375608444214,
0.0033379034139215946,
0.3570968508720398,
0.20142751932144165,
-0.6924697160720825,
-0.19219620525836945,
0.2459840029478073,
0.13925117254257202,
0.04182848706841469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11420v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11420v1 | Rethinking the Roles of Large Language Models in Chinese Grammatical Error Correction | 2024-02-18T01:40:34 | 2024-02-18T01:40:34 | Yinghui Li, Shang Qin, Jingheng Ye, Shirong Ma, Yangning Li, Libo Qin, Xuming Hu, Wenhao Jiang, Hai-Tao Zheng, Philip S. Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have been widely studied by
researchers for their roles in various downstream NLP tasks. As a fundamental
task in the NLP field, Chinese Grammatical Error Correction (CGEC) aims to
correct all potential grammatical errors in the input sentences. Previous
studies have shown that LLMs' performance as correctors on CGEC remains
unsatisfactory due to its challenging task focus. To promote the CGEC field to
better adapt to the era of LLMs, we rethink the roles of LLMs in the CGEC task
so that they can be better utilized and explored in CGEC. Considering the rich
grammatical knowledge stored in LLMs and their powerful semantic understanding
capabilities, we utilize LLMs as explainers to provide explanation information
for the CGEC small models during error correction to enhance performance. We
also use LLMs as evaluators to bring more reasonable CGEC evaluations, thus
alleviating the troubles caused by the subjectivity of the CGEC task. In
particular, our work is also an active exploration of how LLMs and small models
better collaborate in downstream tasks. Extensive experiments and detailed
analyses on widely used datasets verify the effectiveness of our thinking
intuition and the proposed methods. | [
0.11220141500234604,
-0.5967832803726196,
0.74674391746521,
0.1228034645318985,
-0.01061122864484787,
-0.25451716780662537,
-0.63359135389328,
-0.4280827045440674,
0.00699563417583704,
0.41498714685440063,
-0.6157121658325195,
-0.2770262360572815,
-0.5230183005332947,
0.31671297550201416,
-0.2036103755235672,
0.8308600783348083,
-0.08571422100067139,
0.36410149931907654,
-0.24197830259799957,
0.13969284296035767,
-0.5928658246994019,
-0.3938809931278229,
-1.0036648511886597,
-0.39026886224746704,
0.9322184920310974,
0.418728232383728,
0.7934626936912537,
0.5451181530952454,
0.3475697934627533,
0.3510568141937256,
-0.3328089714050293,
0.414896696805954,
-0.5719980597496033,
-0.14428450167179108,
-0.226005420088768,
-0.8293733596801758,
-0.7585635185241699,
-0.2782852351665497,
0.8363398313522339,
0.9633318781852722,
-0.26284027099609375,
-0.07192444801330566,
0.43230241537094116,
0.5177805423736572,
-0.5856532454490662,
0.295652836561203,
-0.6416783332824707,
0.14888136088848114,
-0.1409403532743454,
-0.03407413884997368,
-0.6306037306785583,
-0.12464991956949234,
-0.14119768142700195,
-0.6015819907188416,
0.40460309386253357,
-0.06893790513277054,
0.6133410930633545,
0.14910009503364563,
-0.2634294927120209,
-0.1279834359884262,
-0.7901475429534912,
0.676978349685669,
-1.093676209449768,
0.04109525308012962,
-0.02576329931616783,
0.07849477976560593,
-0.5766599774360657,
-0.5366520285606384,
-0.5078002214431763,
-0.2826419174671173,
-0.24578778445720673,
0.06894704699516296,
0.04495353624224663,
0.38333961367607117,
0.34310173988342285,
0.600219190120697,
-0.22879905998706818,
0.46456217765808105,
-0.17773883044719696,
-0.2572649121284485,
0.6270207762718201,
0.3918359875679016,
0.36095330119132996,
0.02806985378265381,
0.05950344353914261,
0.18935254216194153,
-0.8462330102920532,
0.07291670888662338,
-0.03642844408750534,
0.4553123116493225,
0.004149045329540968,
0.5485953688621521,
-0.14089997112751007,
0.7188233137130737,
0.10800354182720184,
-0.08643659204244614,
-0.11919062584638596,
-0.28341642022132874,
-0.4922041594982147,
0.07008105516433716,
0.4561549127101898,
0.307782918214798,
0.16272176802158356,
0.08697021007537842,
-0.4185314178466797,
-0.1291629523038864,
0.34824955463409424,
-0.5058267116546631,
0.032948993146419525,
-0.08428128808736801,
-0.5795823931694031,
-0.12505684792995453,
0.20683880150318146,
-0.5371145009994507,
-0.4713502824306488,
-0.621407151222229,
0.3080230951309204,
0.08807176351547241,
-0.17028792202472687,
0.1692163646221161,
0.22069348394870758,
0.14264927804470062,
0.6773678660392761,
-1.1424744129180908,
0.2938085198402405,
0.9185346961021423,
0.7133306860923767,
0.009022913873195648,
-0.6035842299461365,
-0.5186294913291931,
0.12027852982282639,
-0.5882298350334167,
0.5667694211006165,
-0.09011673927307129,
-0.31860220432281494,
0.29185232520103455,
0.3563920557498932,
-0.35378673672676086,
-0.4850645065307617,
0.4920769929885864,
-0.33675336837768555,
0.006829000543802977,
-0.5882734656333923,
-0.6149770021438599,
-0.3820822238922119,
0.2530026137828827,
-0.7423287034034729,
0.7607077360153198,
-0.12957227230072021,
-0.6075838208198547,
0.11244945228099823,
-0.5295062065124512,
-0.20929411053657532,
0.04375692829489708,
0.04886370897293091,
-0.20892280340194702,
0.37573686242103577,
0.29916611313819885,
0.6527655124664307,
-0.3605101704597473,
0.287345290184021,
-0.26061582565307617,
-0.5398226976394653,
0.2846467196941376,
-0.33621180057525635,
0.7258195877075195,
-0.00949085596948862,
-0.3320694863796234,
0.3305599093437195,
-0.3060151934623718,
-0.012672779150307178,
0.1652190238237381,
-0.41225337982177734,
-0.24361594021320343,
0.22696489095687866,
-0.35685232281684875,
0.03177390620112419,
0.018226182088255882,
-0.30217480659484863,
0.15111975371837616,
-0.5057198405265808,
0.39940211176872253,
0.9188874363899231,
-0.2990732192993164,
0.4870467483997345,
-0.3346281051635742,
0.4665328860282898,
-0.39784249663352966,
0.19396613538265228,
-0.15220578014850616,
-0.17984093725681305,
-1.1082837581634521,
0.0779309868812561,
0.3138149380683899,
0.4713226854801178,
-0.7452182769775391,
0.18439942598342896,
-0.17976100742816925,
-0.5101571083068848,
-0.4090399146080017,
0.26992297172546387,
0.23111198842525482,
0.3403845727443695,
0.07796797901391983,
0.044450096786022186,
-0.4872268736362457,
-0.5953218936920166,
-0.3393666446208954,
-0.44736039638519287,
0.0008611453231424093,
0.22175516188144684,
0.3417152762413025,
-0.10527815669775009,
0.5864772200584412,
-0.3720860779285431,
-0.27156150341033936,
-0.589427649974823,
-0.27817973494529724,
0.2602439224720001,
0.3025597929954529,
0.45279183983802795,
-0.49688956141471863,
-0.21329928934574127,
0.008403447456657887,
-0.7390486598014832,
-0.4778459072113037,
-0.3098035156726837,
-0.15881042182445526,
0.42761191725730896,
0.7112255096435547,
-0.6790509819984436,
0.21294043958187103,
0.7248795032501221,
-0.35048961639404297,
0.8180443644523621,
-0.26553335785865784,
0.10042190551757812,
-0.5741153955459595,
-0.17932891845703125,
-0.07379315048456192,
-0.015132862143218517,
-0.6575126647949219,
0.22150646150112152,
0.06591535359621048,
0.2629539668560028,
-0.39142972230911255,
0.28486353158950806,
-0.6907539963722229,
-0.1821945458650589,
-0.39749985933303833,
0.35501420497894287,
-0.055679261684417725,
0.2718309760093689,
-0.26845717430114746,
0.47610950469970703,
0.4568902254104614,
-0.6642997860908508,
0.4808003604412079,
-0.0717674046754837,
-0.08224878460168839,
0.1784611940383911,
-0.5131165385246277,
0.03609881177544594,
-0.15037944912910461,
0.3260536789894104,
-0.9949029088020325,
-0.10706675797700882,
0.3457867503166199,
-0.3619813024997711,
0.31784868240356445,
-0.09077869355678558,
-0.7646521329879761,
-0.26405754685401917,
-0.18117475509643555,
0.25619858503341675,
0.18341080844402313,
-0.8197946548461914,
0.8086957931518555,
0.09148762375116348,
-0.0740538015961647,
-0.46624675393104553,
-0.7823731303215027,
0.17662398517131805,
-0.08898547291755676,
-1.0368168354034424,
0.34332501888275146,
0.1398182511329651,
-0.4801161289215088,
-0.05002859979867935,
-0.03225460648536682,
0.40850281715393066,
0.2815952003002167,
0.15121009945869446,
0.5478492975234985,
-0.5838485360145569,
0.37463289499282837,
-0.26203009486198425,
0.10073062777519226,
0.24054215848445892,
-0.22457709908485413,
0.2965962886810303,
0.017439402639865875,
-0.44220322370529175,
-0.33511123061180115,
0.10423263162374496,
0.25502827763557434,
0.047330886125564575,
0.7984181642532349,
0.19351232051849365,
-0.4897286593914032,
-0.30038347840309143,
-0.6422635912895203,
-0.08307346701622009,
-0.4524722993373871,
0.5194685459136963,
-0.08972954750061035,
-0.962027370929718,
0.5567107200622559,
0.13310815393924713,
0.1759158819913864,
0.7115269303321838,
0.612940788269043,
-0.07450507581233978,
0.7521674036979675,
0.7434494495391846,
-0.24311292171478271,
0.36600518226623535,
0.03767174854874611,
0.3168160915374756,
-0.7617319226264954,
-0.14242984354496002,
-0.490063339471817,
-0.16899597644805908,
-0.6048117280006409,
-0.48783454298973083,
-0.01591734029352665,
0.08993598818778992,
-0.20796464383602142,
-0.010557384230196476,
-0.04654546454548836,
0.39030417799949646,
0.1373385339975357,
0.0016548809362575412,
0.23448534309864044,
-0.14248575270175934,
0.035824965685606,
-0.05776446685194969,
-0.8963990211486816,
-0.5368581414222717,
0.6606873273849487,
0.5014602541923523,
1.0215131044387817,
0.015107635408639908,
0.39484238624572754,
-0.05055222660303116,
0.28173497319221497,
-0.9717020392417908,
0.6314616799354553,
-0.4584449827671051,
-0.3436329960823059,
-0.25180065631866455,
-0.2504442632198334,
-0.6592338681221008,
0.6027960181236267,
-0.23254789412021637,
-0.43365684151649475,
-0.11039237678050995,
0.38051944971084595,
-0.43753135204315186,
0.5953595638275146,
-0.7181370258331299,
1.0227447748184204,
-0.30154165625572205,
-0.4480302929878235,
-0.2889251410961151,
-0.4204990565776825,
0.4332566261291504,
0.2570312023162842,
0.2821572422981262,
0.2198026031255722,
-0.05442308634519577,
0.5979142785072327,
-0.5004279613494873,
1.0943231582641602,
-0.22437046468257904,
-0.47568485140800476,
0.35802191495895386,
0.01803264021873474,
0.6201668977737427,
-0.1562933325767517,
-0.061560239642858505,
0.15802514553070068,
-0.33491212129592896,
-0.19554609060287476,
-0.5732591152191162,
0.754215657711029,
-0.5354675054550171,
-0.9441859126091003,
-0.3524784445762634,
-0.4253462851047516,
-0.03559839725494385,
-0.06904744356870651,
-0.03258006274700165,
-0.020998943597078323,
-0.24327869713306427,
0.1545647531747818,
0.43243762850761414,
-0.08737357705831528,
0.5440888404846191,
0.5129200220108032,
-0.21342900395393372,
0.06697623431682587,
0.38998115062713623,
0.13572514057159424,
0.48662319779396057,
0.3398032784461975,
0.17220713198184967,
0.0994541123509407,
-0.738126814365387,
-0.36783188581466675,
0.4802192747592926,
-0.9013310670852661,
0.07361889630556107,
-0.4926879107952118,
-0.2968262732028961,
-0.3638250529766083,
-0.18681511282920837,
-0.24239301681518555,
0.007314932532608509,
-0.5796353220939636,
-0.17006711661815643,
0.0514090359210968,
0.7540014386177063,
-0.10457499325275421,
0.541840672492981,
-0.9661561250686646,
-0.013217649422585964,
0.12422327697277069,
0.09535638242959976,
0.396858274936676,
-0.6516813635826111,
-0.47456735372543335,
0.1492737978696823,
-0.10890747606754303,
-0.6197549104690552,
0.25606822967529297,
-0.04861844331026077,
0.7396627068519592,
0.2321949452161789,
-0.5510618090629578,
0.8502863645553589,
-0.5654801726341248,
1.0561341047286987,
-0.049561165273189545,
-1.149622917175293,
0.3253801763057709,
-0.27738961577415466,
0.11651955544948578,
0.09159333258867264,
-0.20686575770378113,
-1.0468997955322266,
-0.23623721301555634,
-0.3980709910392761,
-0.7638306617736816,
0.8698311448097229,
0.057604361325502396,
-0.03093293122947216,
0.24181018769741058,
0.6702065467834473,
-0.10022739320993423,
-0.15934793651103973,
-0.9100943803787231,
0.018807021901011467,
0.19832444190979004,
-0.08922918885946274,
-0.259174644947052,
-0.6624342799186707,
0.010453280061483383,
0.04117145389318466,
0.9175112843513489,
-0.3359365165233612,
0.16329683363437653,
0.29144495725631714,
-0.17616021633148193,
-0.3963927924633026,
0.32999253273010254,
0.589723527431488,
0.7196066975593567,
0.37344613671302795,
0.09199512749910355,
0.5611083507537842,
-0.23834823071956635,
-0.1927175223827362,
-0.11757607012987137,
-0.1053757295012474,
0.0608268640935421,
0.7612965106964111,
0.7522305250167847,
0.19007238745689392,
-0.4957568645477295,
0.3501463532447815,
0.07763717323541641,
0.04872856289148331,
-0.5525475740432739,
0.13120412826538086,
0.4409354627132416,
0.25253939628601074,
0.1958814412355423,
-0.04866931214928627,
-0.07966504245996475,
-0.580460786819458,
-0.09861063212156296,
0.3951709270477295,
-0.1327546089887619,
-0.23602552711963654,
0.3738535940647125,
0.15222737193107605,
-0.11083189398050308,
0.5382449626922607,
0.02464265748858452,
-0.745328426361084,
0.9075417518615723,
0.5091000199317932,
0.7561233639717102,
-0.3946523070335388,
-0.03125187009572983,
0.4433611333370209,
0.5255579352378845,
-0.6332475543022156,
-0.14418406784534454,
0.4876467287540436,
-0.780775249004364,
-0.8646497130393982,
-0.12148375809192657,
-0.28347599506378174,
0.05606544017791748,
-0.43381160497665405,
0.5508105158805847,
-0.4466116726398468,
0.2072276622056961,
-0.09150911867618561,
-0.16216334700584412,
-0.2573089599609375,
0.2119886577129364,
0.5373883843421936,
0.7183175683021545,
-0.7678752541542053,
0.5974376797676086,
0.477483868598938,
-0.03470927104353905,
-1.197130799293518,
0.15881192684173584,
0.31584632396698,
-0.7292001247406006,
0.6976406574249268,
0.07473418861627579,
-0.2791026830673218,
-0.42108216881752014,
-0.6224370002746582,
-0.6809061765670776,
1.1457781791687012,
0.26268529891967773,
-0.9428703188896179,
-0.2281278818845749,
0.03142981231212616,
0.7288049459457397,
-0.5543778538703918,
0.038757387548685074,
0.5039991140365601,
0.48158854246139526,
0.02939748764038086,
-0.93963623046875,
0.28290724754333496,
-0.009574935771524906,
0.2373342216014862,
0.06048467010259628,
-0.8029982447624207,
1.112547755241394,
-0.4397382438182831,
-0.15437810122966766,
0.35225337743759155,
0.6740790009498596,
0.15748989582061768,
0.2098602056503296,
0.6742447018623352,
0.2228144258260727,
0.6444783806800842,
-0.17513501644134521,
1.048864722251892,
0.432460755109787,
0.4047028124332428,
1.113059639930725,
-0.2537825107574463,
0.6599501371383667,
0.5672487616539001,
-0.27130040526390076,
0.3458004593849182,
0.7714495658874512,
-0.31038087606430054,
-0.006689185742288828,
0.5026450157165527,
-0.13493527472019196,
-0.3840935528278351,
0.050184331834316254,
-0.08413723856210709,
0.4374900162220001,
0.38226252794265747,
-0.5136558413505554,
-0.12752507627010345,
-0.244193434715271,
0.24696041643619537,
0.2302381992340088,
-0.9323925971984863,
0.5976651310920715,
0.17913112044334412,
-0.7561172246932983,
0.4364362061023712,
0.23786452412605286,
0.8161713480949402,
-0.43113186955451965,
-0.07943785190582275,
-0.23612025380134583,
0.557309627532959,
-0.5044409036636353,
-0.6393659114837646,
0.25943201780319214,
-0.03622393310070038,
-0.20488131046295166,
0.009893340058624744,
0.9089637398719788,
-0.49833279848098755,
-0.44909313321113586,
0.5228367447853088,
0.2973380386829376,
-0.008705236949026585,
-0.19539916515350342,
-0.5390772819519043,
0.09488135576248169,
0.2643270492553711,
0.04470840096473694,
0.18375445902347565,
0.4769743084907532,
-0.12549595534801483,
0.5573572516441345,
0.459460973739624,
0.33044975996017456,
0.05769384652376175,
0.3525629937648773,
0.6616058349609375,
-0.8804488182067871,
-0.37280142307281494,
-1.1256386041641235,
0.48967182636260986,
0.16038541495800018,
0.02528097666800022,
0.8054347038269043,
0.19883453845977783,
1.0163124799728394,
-0.31529244780540466,
0.6308860182762146,
-0.036082345992326736,
0.3863220512866974,
-0.9350942373275757,
0.6978520154953003,
-0.5832700133323669,
0.5157073736190796,
-0.22056788206100464,
-0.7925187349319458,
-0.4466438293457031,
0.4363328218460083,
-0.1661994606256485,
0.13499805331230164,
0.866820752620697,
0.9491686820983887,
0.33845949172973633,
0.2879493236541748,
0.30949118733406067,
0.5200108289718628,
0.4737916886806488,
0.7546208500862122,
1.118028163909912,
-0.42353135347366333,
0.4492235481739044,
-0.23633746802806854,
-0.0064352136105299,
-0.36564144492149353,
-0.858466625213623,
-0.922482430934906,
-0.22560346126556396,
-0.246982604265213,
-0.2904358506202698,
0.049552273005247116,
1.102369785308838,
0.20470157265663147,
-0.6898816823959351,
-0.4546723961830139,
0.029075145721435547,
0.23450526595115662,
-0.43874478340148926,
-0.2082451581954956,
0.320791095495224,
-0.49603742361068726,
-0.8186582326889038,
0.20106059312820435,
0.11754672974348068,
-0.011702211573719978,
-0.1402161568403244,
-0.11569499969482422,
-0.15298698842525482,
-0.2289630025625229,
0.6728643178939819,
0.02843429334461689,
-1.0936139822006226,
-0.464083194732666,
0.09033388644456863,
-0.24105478823184967,
-0.04127661883831024,
1.193113088607788,
-0.3600112497806549,
0.10501141846179962,
0.49771252274513245,
0.740790843963623,
0.035466283559799194,
-0.25180384516716003,
0.6926092505455017,
-0.30435943603515625,
-0.027895433828234673,
0.02036413736641407,
0.7303513288497925,
0.5968313813209534,
-0.6013762354850769,
0.5677720308303833,
0.28951296210289,
-0.6787058711051941,
-0.6381818056106567,
-0.164174884557724,
-0.9937635064125061,
-0.2357696145772934,
1.3452298641204834,
-0.4341699481010437,
-0.3570844233036041,
0.16673380136489868,
-0.556121826171875,
0.2907651364803314,
-0.05622251704335213,
0.6415353417396545,
1.0422168970108032,
0.017791731283068657,
-0.22152197360992432,
-0.5648741722106934,
0.44614118337631226,
0.71184903383255,
-0.7183454632759094,
0.5339245796203613,
0.65082186460495,
0.30882713198661804,
-0.0211380273103714,
0.42897915840148926,
-0.15633322298526764,
0.3701092302799225,
-0.0880042165517807,
0.054475389420986176,
0.1369321495294571,
-0.20709878206253052,
-0.6312798857688904,
-0.17521359026432037,
0.46661362051963806,
0.03318530321121216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11417v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11417v1 | LoRETTA: Low-Rank Economic Tensor-Train Adaptation for Ultra-Low-Parameter Fine-Tuning of Large Language Models | 2024-02-18T01:20:00 | 2024-02-18T01:20:00 | Yifan Yang, Jiajun Zhou, Ngai Wong, Zheng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Various parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) techniques have been proposed
to enable computationally efficient fine-tuning while maintaining model
performance. However, existing PEFT methods are still limited by the growing
number of trainable parameters with the rapid deployment of Large Language
Models (LLMs). To address this challenge, we present LoRETTA, an
ultra-parameter-efficient framework that significantly reduces trainable
parameters through tensor-train decomposition. Specifically, we propose two
methods, named {LoRETTA}$_{adp}$ and {LoRETTA}$_{rep}$. The former employs
tensorized adapters, offering a high-performance yet lightweight approach for
the fine-tuning of LLMs. The latter emphasizes fine-tuning via weight
parameterization with a set of small tensor factors. LoRETTA achieves
comparable or better performance than most widely used PEFT methods with up to
$100\times$ fewer parameters on the LLaMA-2-7B models. Furthermore, empirical
results demonstrate that the proposed method effectively improves training
efficiency, enjoys better multi-task learning performance, and enhances the
anti-overfitting capability. Plug-and-play codes built upon the Huggingface
framework and PEFT library will be released. | [
-0.3670739531517029,
-0.6290498375892639,
0.3489540219306946,
0.31470414996147156,
-0.4818630814552307,
-0.16091544926166534,
-0.49599283933639526,
-0.12591317296028137,
-0.0954323410987854,
0.5653724670410156,
-0.3893283009529114,
-0.5354769229888916,
-0.4777336120605469,
-0.2370106428861618,
-0.20588111877441406,
0.8562866449356079,
-0.05538615211844444,
0.02686137892305851,
0.24027983844280243,
-0.1738942265510559,
-0.192220076918602,
-0.18527889251708984,
-0.9693650603294373,
-0.017039421945810318,
0.6928442120552063,
0.4051268994808197,
0.4319170117378235,
0.9744035005569458,
0.3136416971683502,
0.2721463441848755,
-0.04776709899306297,
0.341896653175354,
-0.6991495490074158,
0.02789534442126751,
0.027938103303313255,
-0.5680514574050903,
-0.7552752494812012,
0.008774974383413792,
0.9873251914978027,
0.6954874992370605,
-0.25570523738861084,
0.5357581377029419,
0.10370790213346481,
0.8433471322059631,
-0.8431829810142517,
0.11424406617879868,
-0.8536072969436646,
-0.0037149921990931034,
-0.07229699194431305,
-0.176963210105896,
-0.31368255615234375,
0.04234625771641731,
-0.3575746715068817,
-0.8190111517906189,
0.07090777903795242,
0.28833067417144775,
0.6472650766372681,
0.37213513255119324,
-0.3097614049911499,
0.3846755921840668,
-0.5451541543006897,
1.027030110359192,
-0.5198246836662292,
0.5417717695236206,
0.25828036665916443,
-0.023017844185233116,
-0.28766751289367676,
-0.6061147451400757,
-0.26138296723365784,
-0.08868429809808731,
0.17292344570159912,
0.02341059409081936,
-0.22908732295036316,
0.2426055669784546,
0.08394689857959747,
0.27386459708213806,
-0.3402252197265625,
0.4647875428199768,
-0.24583031237125397,
0.10592763125896454,
0.35171425342559814,
0.225406214594841,
0.010122423991560936,
0.057603366672992706,
-0.3958703577518463,
-0.16701829433441162,
-0.9206216335296631,
0.07437445223331451,
0.5849131941795349,
0.6164663434028625,
-0.25066468119621277,
0.20336227118968964,
-0.43843647837638855,
0.7139859199523926,
0.14158901572227478,
0.13017408549785614,
-0.13972799479961395,
0.18804143369197845,
-0.5978747606277466,
-0.07980634272098541,
0.6428507566452026,
0.1978655308485031,
0.03878159448504448,
-0.3381405472755432,
-0.16875919699668884,
-0.3065841794013977,
0.037239111959934235,
-1.012190818786621,
-0.14536570012569427,
0.10377117991447449,
-0.8867101669311523,
-0.5969557166099548,
-0.3524068295955658,
-0.652104377746582,
-0.5030238628387451,
-0.36653009057044983,
0.5150919556617737,
-0.1409723311662674,
-0.26836785674095154,
0.295129656791687,
0.09614188969135284,
0.4171404540538788,
0.4243790805339813,
-1.2114897966384888,
0.39307093620300293,
0.6827307343482971,
0.739167332649231,
0.009084767661988735,
-0.45643049478530884,
-1.0453767776489258,
0.03275652229785919,
-0.44243302941322327,
0.5790445804595947,
-0.42383018136024475,
-0.08878787606954575,
-0.18617792427539825,
0.19600504636764526,
-0.3661987781524658,
-0.519263744354248,
0.7157255411148071,
-0.49670282006263733,
0.07629961520433426,
-0.2104429304599762,
-0.07745897024869919,
-0.14247040450572968,
0.05291537567973137,
-0.3385685086250305,
1.1046359539031982,
0.51291823387146,
-0.4412457048892975,
0.4205630123615265,
-0.7964611649513245,
-0.19685956835746765,
-0.3114550709724426,
0.4496372640132904,
-0.4855264127254486,
0.3572661876678467,
0.1446676105260849,
0.7157719135284424,
-0.6738684773445129,
-0.11913250386714935,
-0.6318982243537903,
-0.5873556137084961,
-0.04740991070866585,
-0.45702317357063293,
0.7007505893707275,
0.35353654623031616,
-0.18515050411224365,
0.10873173922300339,
-1.1611299514770508,
-0.02135240100324154,
0.14438225328922272,
-0.48966312408447266,
-0.32180821895599365,
-0.1647295355796814,
0.40910789370536804,
0.0800776258111,
0.1055149957537651,
-0.4109419584274292,
0.25546082854270935,
-0.3512918949127197,
0.4588117003440857,
0.8650955557823181,
-0.4611169397830963,
0.5736792683601379,
-0.38284024596214294,
0.4572021961212158,
-0.02635093778371811,
0.22788384556770325,
0.10252449661493301,
0.04608163237571716,
-1.1323649883270264,
-0.6346803307533264,
0.7944257855415344,
0.1627017706632614,
-0.2776845395565033,
0.18924102187156677,
-0.061991795897483826,
-0.5509616732597351,
-0.6855018734931946,
0.1819310039281845,
0.3419151306152344,
0.6140086054801941,
0.5871079564094543,
-0.1343655288219452,
-0.5226158499717712,
-0.820620596408844,
-0.25323083996772766,
-0.30641406774520874,
-0.23063552379608154,
0.2421153038740158,
0.202569380402565,
0.15968893468379974,
0.40957286953926086,
-0.4163919985294342,
-0.424581915140152,
-0.009478665888309479,
0.15189583599567413,
0.17810912430286407,
0.7418051362037659,
0.9517509341239929,
-0.2861063480377197,
-0.5299957990646362,
0.047964759171009064,
-0.2551385462284088,
-0.010318652726709843,
0.011338092386722565,
-0.5055146217346191,
0.2341977059841156,
0.3450801968574524,
-0.4604171812534332,
-0.09697980433702469,
0.5915563106536865,
-0.40040987730026245,
0.13135655224323273,
-0.4187016189098358,
0.03467562422156334,
-1.0469551086425781,
0.16760613024234772,
-0.0028661401011049747,
-0.4110383689403534,
-0.3851158022880554,
0.08108382672071457,
0.1384902000427246,
-0.07659263163805008,
-0.29944169521331787,
0.45952746272087097,
-0.3621583878993988,
0.022996075451374054,
-0.10275710374116898,
-0.3756207823753357,
0.05587159842252731,
0.6037696003913879,
-0.09776371717453003,
0.7665090560913086,
0.5977742671966553,
-0.42998453974723816,
0.2036624401807785,
0.22529470920562744,
-0.215022474527359,
0.6708527207374573,
-0.57307368516922,
0.10150021314620972,
-0.2661449909210205,
-0.010804484598338604,
-0.8073618412017822,
0.07374396175146103,
0.13541091978549957,
-0.07870136201381683,
0.5485973954200745,
-0.9318774938583374,
-0.29631176590919495,
0.31311172246932983,
-0.5942780375480652,
0.06656652688980103,
0.8377723097801208,
-0.7653660774230957,
0.5188498497009277,
0.30967438220977783,
-0.20355740189552307,
-0.6044555306434631,
-0.4045455753803253,
0.011837519705295563,
-0.6358212232589722,
-0.3947402238845825,
0.48772352933883667,
0.015201699919998646,
0.04178725928068161,
-0.2725829482078552,
0.10593123733997345,
0.05014222487807274,
0.47358080744743347,
-0.18565572798252106,
0.17231979966163635,
-0.6066325902938843,
0.0705581083893776,
0.24436302483081818,
-0.3421318829059601,
-0.2517904043197632,
-0.5666010975837708,
0.49351996183395386,
-0.12734653055667877,
0.0356210395693779,
-0.13960790634155273,
0.2109469622373581,
0.9453993439674377,
-0.32928088307380676,
1.0460803508758545,
1.094652533531189,
-0.23092970252037048,
-0.4418308734893799,
-0.4570658206939697,
0.08181605488061905,
-0.47888171672821045,
0.5645303130149841,
-0.3319084048271179,
-0.656608521938324,
0.5596267580986023,
-0.3481358587741852,
0.08401601761579514,
0.46025311946868896,
0.6965847015380859,
-0.015366284176707268,
1.1894381046295166,
0.7591138482093811,
-0.1879855841398239,
0.7215912342071533,
-0.2740509808063507,
-0.14602749049663544,
-1.1638085842132568,
0.11766726523637772,
-0.6513605117797852,
-0.4926142394542694,
-0.6407790184020996,
-0.2726771831512451,
0.2919127643108368,
0.10178835690021515,
-0.546176552772522,
0.2714811861515045,
-0.407609760761261,
0.4701249599456787,
0.5104110240936279,
-0.0062722074799239635,
0.2583254873752594,
0.04727154225111008,
0.08047778159379959,
0.10923464596271515,
-0.8033819198608398,
-0.1896691471338272,
1.2861814498901367,
0.4474845826625824,
0.7617698907852173,
0.16564758121967316,
0.4386833608150482,
0.19769740104675293,
0.18681477010250092,
-0.8347787261009216,
0.27122217416763306,
-0.6278932094573975,
-0.21247638761997223,
-0.3587068021297455,
-0.5416213870048523,
-0.8624756336212158,
0.46653231978416443,
-0.6082153916358948,
-0.7293651103973389,
0.29379063844680786,
0.19508226215839386,
-0.5548995137214661,
0.32628417015075684,
-0.8041773438453674,
0.7846862077713013,
0.03865658491849899,
-0.7047638893127441,
-0.3039901852607727,
-0.22261016070842743,
0.17879343032836914,
-0.17217420041561127,
0.0433538444340229,
-0.5971160531044006,
-0.05099071189761162,
0.7932558059692383,
-0.4463599622249603,
0.5142862796783447,
-0.5128583908081055,
0.027771981433033943,
-0.1922161728143692,
0.10961861163377762,
0.8712515830993652,
0.09087663888931274,
-0.29023194313049316,
-0.0719309076666832,
0.20881643891334534,
-0.5912971496582031,
-0.47061482071876526,
0.9729282259941101,
-1.0394694805145264,
-0.2062479704618454,
0.1479848176240921,
-0.6654163002967834,
-0.49460238218307495,
0.19153478741645813,
-0.05017029866576195,
0.5721188187599182,
-0.1414736658334732,
0.3651760220527649,
0.5703955292701721,
-0.08665481954813004,
0.4457174837589264,
0.6390081644058228,
0.11571737378835678,
-0.3106634318828583,
0.9317421317100525,
0.22085903584957123,
-0.0730806514620781,
0.293621689081192,
0.27979469299316406,
-0.3851519525051117,
-1.018271565437317,
-0.7506042718887329,
0.2623394727706909,
-0.44028306007385254,
-0.29993492364883423,
-0.4163365066051483,
0.21665868163108826,
-0.09540358930826187,
-0.2554546892642975,
-0.839779257774353,
-0.6379374861717224,
-0.38464686274528503,
0.30196502804756165,
0.5518729090690613,
0.3751027584075928,
0.12293995171785355,
0.5694705843925476,
-0.5210835337638855,
0.254051148891449,
0.3607187569141388,
0.7653477191925049,
-0.0668792724609375,
-0.7494995594024658,
-0.5160479545593262,
-0.09519121050834656,
-0.02608070895075798,
-0.18405629694461823,
0.16119523346424103,
0.31835106015205383,
0.294598251581192,
0.1789841204881668,
0.34831345081329346,
0.8519366979598999,
-0.2589091956615448,
0.3532152771949768,
0.07069875299930573,
-0.8148710131645203,
-0.13348570466041565,
-0.7940904498100281,
-0.08961699157953262,
0.5513216853141785,
-0.10160071402788162,
-0.34582093358039856,
-0.026042727753520012,
-0.3619338572025299,
-0.9138455390930176,
0.9740617275238037,
0.03214115649461746,
0.3927508592605591,
0.468453049659729,
0.47332191467285156,
0.0563972145318985,
0.05576273053884506,
-0.24262657761573792,
-0.13564033806324005,
0.0968620553612709,
-0.3873426616191864,
0.07171008735895157,
-0.360164999961853,
-0.11614234745502472,
-0.38969871401786804,
0.9236426949501038,
-0.47355854511260986,
0.19617736339569092,
-0.19447118043899536,
-0.25053900480270386,
-0.4412539601325989,
0.16997632384300232,
0.5257030725479126,
0.41041818261146545,
-0.40712517499923706,
0.07486893981695175,
0.496946781873703,
-0.3801484704017639,
0.12299639731645584,
0.40440645813941956,
-0.0059272246435284615,
-0.4610362648963928,
-0.186625137925148,
0.7261531949043274,
0.24744813144207,
-0.2637518048286438,
0.2639417052268982,
-0.37710264325141907,
-0.3016970157623291,
-0.13874781131744385,
0.3459832966327667,
0.12037941813468933,
0.464805006980896,
0.1465616077184677,
0.21803371608257294,
-0.02067621238529682,
-0.22226861119270325,
-0.21586091816425323,
0.44508469104766846,
-0.5756812691688538,
-0.29724904894828796,
1.0167441368103027,
0.2970716953277588,
0.008224028162658215,
0.42922672629356384,
0.07443657517433167,
0.07829410582780838,
0.4682261645793915,
0.569583535194397,
0.800952672958374,
0.0006085768109187484,
0.12596511840820312,
0.15835176408290863,
0.1990973800420761,
-0.08428873866796494,
0.21755345165729523,
0.029930317774415016,
-0.5707798600196838,
-0.422905832529068,
-0.8561902046203613,
-0.27108508348464966,
0.4130571484565735,
-0.5161045789718628,
0.5951769351959229,
-0.6840324997901917,
-0.05089542269706726,
0.05314747616648674,
0.16070590913295746,
-0.5949169397354126,
0.09083791077136993,
0.21872086822986603,
0.7455571889877319,
-0.7588931322097778,
0.8317411541938782,
0.8246014714241028,
-0.1662769615650177,
-0.6584030985832214,
-0.17541877925395966,
-0.369501531124115,
-1.0415393114089966,
0.23091283440589905,
-0.3084813952445984,
-0.25319382548332214,
0.5879494547843933,
-0.24641354382038116,
-0.8762387037277222,
1.045577049255371,
1.0513978004455566,
-0.18262092769145966,
0.05965521186590195,
-0.04264668747782707,
0.23877334594726562,
-0.2124384641647339,
0.41701802611351013,
0.6772488951683044,
0.47879308462142944,
-0.17347946763038635,
-0.8946754932403564,
0.07958973199129105,
-0.18715360760688782,
0.12651658058166504,
0.3899419903755188,
-1.2734196186065674,
0.869887113571167,
0.16223005950450897,
0.3086218535900116,
0.17179074883460999,
0.413984090089798,
-0.003599755931645632,
-0.04271934926509857,
0.6171938180923462,
0.38026851415634155,
0.7525237798690796,
0.03920792415738106,
0.62122642993927,
-0.4892210066318512,
0.7187739610671997,
0.4706364870071411,
-0.03185836970806122,
0.759838342666626,
0.5634361505508423,
-0.5000382661819458,
0.28437748551368713,
0.5430536270141602,
-0.002080632373690605,
0.4411108195781708,
0.23709431290626526,
-0.04386186599731445,
-0.5363131165504456,
-0.25658920407295227,
-0.3071994483470917,
0.8108329772949219,
0.19666096568107605,
-0.5452360510826111,
-0.2550521790981293,
-0.34104952216148376,
0.34125998616218567,
-0.2833845019340515,
-0.5618929266929626,
0.47791093587875366,
-0.01871500536799431,
-0.3702428936958313,
1.0995385646820068,
0.5456915497779846,
0.608792781829834,
-0.5764789581298828,
0.05503254383802414,
-0.15362389385700226,
0.43527108430862427,
-0.1427055448293686,
0.016128063201904297,
0.12261052429676056,
-0.04481496661901474,
-0.21086089313030243,
-0.29765236377716064,
0.7753649353981018,
-0.5349931716918945,
-0.4548099935054779,
0.06995826214551926,
0.49809131026268005,
-0.15695996582508087,
-0.17040838301181793,
-0.7559545040130615,
-0.13840079307556152,
-0.37731656432151794,
-0.6193960905075073,
0.833885908126831,
0.12884096801280975,
0.11099641770124435,
0.37177491188049316,
0.8633209466934204,
0.11374359577894211,
-0.2534470856189728,
-0.08131540566682816,
0.926266610622406,
-0.31083545088768005,
-0.4956992566585541,
-0.7512491345405579,
0.5655210614204407,
0.28005796670913696,
-0.4952758252620697,
0.22947834432125092,
0.5629990696907043,
0.49561619758605957,
-0.03941458836197853,
0.6778064370155334,
0.1735812872648239,
0.3356875479221344,
-0.8579906225204468,
1.1088380813598633,
-0.9237704277038574,
0.24678894877433777,
-0.22895820438861847,
-0.9840195775032043,
-0.47975507378578186,
0.670841634273529,
-0.10881394892930984,
0.08515118807554245,
0.43766796588897705,
0.6792207956314087,
-0.49777737259864807,
-0.27312523126602173,
0.6347218751907349,
0.14847727119922638,
-0.06248084083199501,
0.4568403661251068,
0.7161156535148621,
-0.5571617484092712,
0.5083582401275635,
-0.17591047286987305,
-0.11370720714330673,
-0.3479064702987671,
-0.9200910925865173,
-0.9739404320716858,
-0.4115264415740967,
-0.2537094056606293,
-0.30084800720214844,
0.09060131758451462,
1.3150262832641602,
1.093479871749878,
-0.6797792911529541,
-0.12390149384737015,
-0.020693572238087654,
0.04651959612965584,
-0.1545322686433792,
-0.12059804797172546,
0.6778321266174316,
-0.3607392907142639,
-0.9588168859481812,
0.511253833770752,
0.2851313352584839,
-0.09042413532733917,
-0.18508850038051605,
-0.04853018373250961,
0.3296530246734619,
0.04672582074999809,
0.5307720303535461,
0.10089247673749924,
-0.2169485241174698,
-0.40081021189689636,
0.09792917966842651,
0.25397756695747375,
0.1038663312792778,
0.6999146938323975,
-0.6177836656570435,
0.28265079855918884,
0.4032053053379059,
0.471604585647583,
0.6795132160186768,
-0.09145881980657578,
0.650287926197052,
-0.6281399726867676,
0.4916684627532959,
-0.0283423513174057,
0.5261965394020081,
0.07720952481031418,
-0.445820152759552,
0.34151387214660645,
0.27183613181114197,
-0.4173484742641449,
-0.9933209419250488,
0.07017942517995834,
-0.848812997341156,
-0.026601046323776245,
1.0072414875030518,
-0.1376221776008606,
-0.3917123079299927,
-0.1993662714958191,
-0.24810762703418732,
0.28063151240348816,
-0.41139471530914307,
0.9333785176277161,
0.38471779227256775,
0.014955636113882065,
-0.32325321435928345,
-0.5019907355308533,
0.49936744570732117,
0.6421542167663574,
-0.5033178329467773,
0.4364335238933563,
-0.02158263511955738,
0.4220442473888397,
-0.5381810665130615,
0.5885269641876221,
-0.04949688911437988,
0.236589714884758,
0.05769719183444977,
0.02070169523358345,
-0.6412745714187622,
-0.10960401594638824,
-0.3645118474960327,
0.13515351712703705,
0.6744065284729004,
-0.29858848452568054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11414v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11414v1 | Fine-grained and Explainable Factuality Evaluation for Multimodal Summarization | 2024-02-18T01:03:25 | 2024-02-18T01:03:25 | Liqiang Jing, Jingxuan Zuo, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multimodal summarization aims to generate a concise summary based on the
input text and image. However, the existing methods potentially suffer from
unfactual output. To evaluate the factuality of multimodal summarization
models, we propose two fine-grained and explainable evaluation frameworks
(FALLACIOUS) for different application scenarios, i.e. reference-based
factuality evaluation framework and reference-free factuality evaluation
framework. Notably, the reference-free factuality evaluation framework doesn't
need ground truth and hence it has a wider application scenario. To evaluate
the effectiveness of the proposed frameworks, we compute the correlation
between our frameworks and the other metrics. The experimental results show the
effectiveness of our proposed method. We will release our code and dataset via
github. | [
-0.35691019892692566,
-0.6590359807014465,
0.56782466173172,
0.27758145332336426,
-0.3662688136100769,
-0.11479036509990692,
-0.17951923608779907,
-0.29461801052093506,
0.22709132730960846,
0.12357134371995926,
-0.44298243522644043,
-0.43132197856903076,
-0.5780336260795593,
-0.10114531219005585,
-0.5105251669883728,
1.3204433917999268,
-0.09880945831537247,
-0.13365820050239563,
-0.8080135583877563,
-0.6005418300628662,
-0.5618554949760437,
-0.12000247836112976,
-0.11713817715644836,
-0.33147311210632324,
0.38534167408943176,
0.5979665517807007,
0.8014030456542969,
0.3578341007232666,
0.8143672943115234,
0.3494679033756256,
0.04784878343343735,
0.359803169965744,
-0.5215829610824585,
-0.15851590037345886,
-0.4941733479499817,
-0.2194087654352188,
-0.4770796000957489,
-0.014325122348964214,
0.4511283338069916,
0.5291097164154053,
-0.1820129156112671,
0.37615013122558594,
-0.031730540096759796,
0.7223673462867737,
-0.8656756281852722,
0.2487073838710785,
-0.3012990653514862,
0.005957578308880329,
0.17484867572784424,
-0.3000595271587372,
-0.39973706007003784,
-0.5589876770973206,
0.07034400850534439,
-0.47639358043670654,
0.3405620753765106,
-0.011024454608559608,
0.7053941488265991,
0.028484797105193138,
-0.5826722979545593,
-0.4479718506336212,
-0.7344587445259094,
0.6686669588088989,
-0.851505696773529,
0.368622750043869,
0.035587068647146225,
0.591301679611206,
0.2738460302352905,
-0.9337975978851318,
-0.6537867188453674,
-0.40057826042175293,
-0.35854828357696533,
0.45500752329826355,
-0.2192433625459671,
0.014918778091669083,
0.02051839977502823,
0.6675023436546326,
-0.6598320007324219,
-0.24340985715389252,
-0.16353771090507507,
-0.2967253625392914,
0.3874361515045166,
0.2707546055316925,
0.18228541314601898,
-0.3366274833679199,
-0.5782249569892883,
0.13268952071666718,
-0.2648541033267975,
0.1331956535577774,
0.051856476813554764,
0.2480781376361847,
-0.6988595128059387,
0.6658646464347839,
-0.39738884568214417,
0.30414053797721863,
0.137201726436615,
-0.5035666823387146,
0.3379232585430145,
-0.9375056624412537,
-0.14700792729854584,
0.014961855486035347,
0.5532205700874329,
1.1286916732788086,
-0.05755563825368881,
-0.3439856469631195,
-0.10715028643608093,
0.19364798069000244,
0.052507370710372925,
-0.9683282375335693,
0.03488316386938095,
0.32182446122169495,
-0.9074501395225525,
-0.42275533080101013,
0.06325049698352814,
-1.0042850971221924,
-0.33806782960891724,
-0.18444891273975372,
0.3200545608997345,
-0.4714150130748749,
-0.3572947382926941,
-0.1062123030424118,
-0.4041944146156311,
-0.09791824966669083,
0.5744153261184692,
-0.8678069114685059,
0.10094770044088364,
0.22913937270641327,
0.9304224848747253,
-0.3424261808395386,
-0.1421593278646469,
-0.399749755859375,
0.16901259124279022,
-0.08959323167800903,
0.8841008543968201,
-0.40054523944854736,
-0.36418667435646057,
-0.03400754928588867,
-0.11895312368869781,
-0.2021665722131729,
-0.40830081701278687,
0.7397460341453552,
-0.36723601818084717,
0.13209214806556702,
-0.21430395543575287,
-0.310982882976532,
-0.5831544399261475,
0.4649829864501953,
-0.6642380356788635,
0.5563386082649231,
-0.1079665794968605,
-0.9224762916564941,
0.38012123107910156,
-0.7326246500015259,
-0.4030108153820038,
-0.2569962739944458,
0.11123798042535782,
-0.3419797420501709,
0.2593493163585663,
0.1432093232870102,
0.5941140651702881,
-0.22778530418872833,
0.5583344101905823,
-0.5219563841819763,
-0.288914293050766,
0.39986199140548706,
-0.8047921657562256,
0.263617604970932,
0.36636680364608765,
-0.13468031585216522,
0.20610842108726501,
-0.9630107283592224,
-0.13148950040340424,
-0.11530231684446335,
-0.35940203070640564,
-0.11634085327386856,
0.18138863146305084,
0.26801612973213196,
0.2046504020690918,
0.28726398944854736,
-0.2940843105316162,
-0.07531110942363739,
-0.2987479567527771,
0.06271679699420929,
0.36971017718315125,
0.06691160053014755,
0.35634902119636536,
-0.48122256994247437,
0.3813919425010681,
0.26176217198371887,
0.017488842830061913,
-0.5092383027076721,
-0.08205065131187439,
-0.5315262675285339,
-0.4228649139404297,
0.3466562330722809,
0.46788471937179565,
-0.9600669145584106,
-0.165342316031456,
-0.4346851408481598,
-0.5103082060813904,
0.16465386748313904,
-0.06511221826076508,
0.7154136896133423,
0.8051275014877319,
0.25743064284324646,
-0.43898361921310425,
-0.43469756841659546,
-1.084311604499817,
-0.20050546526908875,
-0.21136796474456787,
0.09697378426790237,
0.11234841495752335,
0.7003142237663269,
-0.23831072449684143,
1.0333876609802246,
-0.39006829261779785,
-0.0945897027850151,
-0.24998119473457336,
0.5249349474906921,
0.1809256374835968,
0.5199373960494995,
0.7455381155014038,
-0.9392099976539612,
0.0316927470266819,
-0.04503590241074562,
-0.93010413646698,
-0.012832727283239365,
-0.30879291892051697,
0.37109658122062683,
0.24644604325294495,
0.15061090886592865,
-0.6810033917427063,
0.49328261613845825,
0.42721885442733765,
-0.35105887055397034,
0.745180070400238,
-0.25335693359375,
0.670671284198761,
-1.06161630153656,
0.27462655305862427,
0.15781764686107635,
-0.39028483629226685,
-0.47329339385032654,
0.14727331697940826,
0.056977204978466034,
-0.11004731804132462,
-0.3773769736289978,
0.31834039092063904,
-0.11840929090976715,
-0.09872741997241974,
-0.12036996334791183,
0.43973755836486816,
0.2821817398071289,
0.42791324853897095,
-0.180199533700943,
0.6752141714096069,
0.036714617162942886,
-0.6281762719154358,
0.4862784445285797,
0.05569011718034744,
-0.29901695251464844,
0.6810669302940369,
-0.6525946259498596,
-0.43215617537498474,
-0.30943793058395386,
0.40036845207214355,
-1.1625133752822876,
-0.47515395283699036,
0.15035994350910187,
-0.5612865686416626,
0.16023221611976624,
0.023494821041822433,
-0.33819156885147095,
-0.04786437377333641,
-0.8220416903495789,
0.34156879782676697,
-0.0974733904004097,
-0.418003648519516,
0.5733864307403564,
0.0803167074918747,
-0.11429733037948608,
-0.5283636450767517,
-0.7006199955940247,
-0.04936475679278374,
-0.29260584712028503,
-0.6613756418228149,
0.3647269308567047,
-0.34487250447273254,
-0.4088262617588043,
0.07020656764507294,
-0.2608811855316162,
-0.1490054577589035,
-0.0694069042801857,
0.2816203832626343,
0.2868150770664215,
-0.35874229669570923,
0.08616819232702255,
0.10675807297229767,
-0.12032832205295563,
0.06434827297925949,
0.34525275230407715,
0.02439608797430992,
-0.3875110447406769,
-0.3945157527923584,
-0.5256184935569763,
0.3347076177597046,
0.8697497248649597,
-0.1279347538948059,
0.5003126263618469,
0.7630839347839355,
-0.2570960223674774,
0.37842217087745667,
-0.4574317932128906,
0.08676717430353165,
-0.3411501348018646,
0.4963493347167969,
-0.21236170828342438,
-0.4618336260318756,
0.6996080875396729,
-0.3003130257129669,
0.09861255437135696,
0.5394217371940613,
0.7070134878158569,
-0.1130710169672966,
0.7852759957313538,
0.5740419626235962,
0.38807982206344604,
0.16258209943771362,
-0.05883604660630226,
0.13725483417510986,
-0.4036198854446411,
-0.4361483156681061,
-0.28501835465431213,
0.034117311239242554,
-0.49009230732917786,
-0.16039106249809265,
0.37868958711624146,
0.054778508841991425,
0.4222189486026764,
-0.07189702987670898,
0.0265429075807333,
0.4155687987804413,
0.3359827697277069,
0.013587030582129955,
0.49394044280052185,
-0.02454500086605549,
-0.32985919713974,
-0.014943135902285576,
-0.42945966124534607,
-0.5612077713012695,
0.970191478729248,
0.32017138600349426,
0.6426005959510803,
0.39698007702827454,
0.18433211743831635,
0.6236439347267151,
0.11873464286327362,
-0.6711084246635437,
0.21840444207191467,
-0.04054590314626694,
-0.756938099861145,
-0.07919709384441376,
-0.3645183742046356,
-0.3770979940891266,
0.42486807703971863,
-0.5791124105453491,
-0.6246604323387146,
0.25710129737854004,
0.40692824125289917,
-0.4600904583930969,
0.028362393379211426,
-1.1155585050582886,
0.8461508750915527,
0.05288108438253403,
-0.37148016691207886,
-0.4765353798866272,
-0.7411273717880249,
0.7993513345718384,
-0.0014562152791768312,
0.4940217137336731,
-0.02855215035378933,
0.20222750306129456,
0.5908454656600952,
-0.4003768861293793,
0.7375551462173462,
-0.11968835443258286,
-0.02672370709478855,
0.2175649106502533,
0.06735692918300629,
0.18338222801685333,
0.5069839358329773,
0.04076846316456795,
0.18533945083618164,
0.3525916039943695,
-0.2108072191476822,
-0.9898474216461182,
0.6787540912628174,
-0.3417814373970032,
-0.14332418143749237,
-0.4087684452533722,
-0.6598415374755859,
-0.27622151374816895,
0.28231164813041687,
0.17958025634288788,
1.0464588403701782,
-0.4403553009033203,
0.16619855165481567,
0.4937170147895813,
-0.042922355234622955,
0.8492534756660461,
0.5222930312156677,
-0.3276503086090088,
-0.6508601307868958,
1.03207528591156,
-0.03161806985735893,
0.1865527480840683,
0.38839563727378845,
0.08700910955667496,
-0.33056706190109253,
-0.4676324725151062,
-0.6694319844245911,
-0.01811596378684044,
-0.7215118408203125,
-0.19786065816879272,
-0.26754850149154663,
0.17363965511322021,
-0.32876577973365784,
-0.22423504292964935,
-0.445046991109848,
-0.7573097944259644,
0.091654933989048,
0.044464193284511566,
-0.0036109453067183495,
0.5380627512931824,
-0.1812678426504135,
0.24726279079914093,
-0.9009609222412109,
0.7173175811767578,
0.24899154901504517,
0.494546502828598,
-0.06855372339487076,
-0.4118914008140564,
-0.44448891282081604,
0.2788952887058258,
-0.5509642958641052,
-0.5600173473358154,
-0.07861599326133728,
0.1676289141178131,
0.35676446557044983,
0.8691582679748535,
0.06189809739589691,
0.6401997804641724,
-0.41866737604141235,
0.8056535124778748,
0.606543779373169,
-0.9223712682723999,
0.4201827943325043,
-0.36912861466407776,
0.38609597086906433,
0.7693161368370056,
0.06799416244029999,
-0.23302532732486725,
-0.0703572928905487,
-0.4172208309173584,
-0.7081249356269836,
0.7874272465705872,
0.4987610876560211,
-0.08197856694459915,
0.31012681126594543,
0.11421801894903183,
0.35618916153907776,
0.36455005407333374,
-0.6700695157051086,
-0.5081070065498352,
-0.4816541373729706,
-0.24851848185062408,
-0.2193290740251541,
-0.6500977873802185,
-0.2700692117214203,
-0.028035178780555725,
0.6250033974647522,
-0.14928653836250305,
0.17875215411186218,
0.11360623687505722,
-0.32701078057289124,
0.09370709210634232,
0.45707160234451294,
0.995812714099884,
1.097732424736023,
-0.6768187880516052,
0.3275468647480011,
0.059523504227399826,
-0.47358325123786926,
-0.040267277508974075,
0.1503099650144577,
-0.18530899286270142,
0.32842305302619934,
0.7508979439735413,
0.6266935467720032,
0.39257916808128357,
-0.690016508102417,
0.7773585915565491,
-0.28542959690093994,
-0.17022085189819336,
-0.05549503490328789,
-0.08689484000205994,
0.010271507315337658,
0.259124755859375,
0.15225258469581604,
0.615898072719574,
0.5514968037605286,
-0.6391720771789551,
0.033910512924194336,
0.2938649654388428,
-0.16095604002475739,
-0.41058939695358276,
0.5492701530456543,
0.4237173795700073,
0.25092583894729614,
0.02245159074664116,
-0.1635250598192215,
-0.06150669604539871,
0.444144070148468,
0.6085144281387329,
0.5965627431869507,
0.07135402411222458,
0.48421987891197205,
0.15425939857959747,
0.2922378182411194,
0.28573888540267944,
-0.009294621646404266,
-0.22472725808620453,
-0.6310451626777649,
-0.48036614060401917,
-0.31198957562446594,
-0.5984746813774109,
-0.006223282311111689,
-0.7604133486747742,
0.14334793388843536,
-0.1412225365638733,
-0.05381178855895996,
0.32779964804649353,
-0.17917309701442719,
-0.024923386052250862,
0.4861639142036438,
0.07245351374149323,
0.7200421094894409,
-0.8340592384338379,
0.2252194732427597,
0.8567859530448914,
-0.5453445911407471,
-0.2708103358745575,
0.11877884715795517,
0.1985531747341156,
-0.4239051640033722,
0.34477415680885315,
0.22751370072364807,
-0.49155551195144653,
-0.5655208826065063,
-0.2849697172641754,
-0.726555347442627,
1.1068789958953857,
0.5990164279937744,
-0.15357476472854614,
0.011999056674540043,
-0.0076988209038972855,
0.21612690389156342,
-0.22910821437835693,
0.5467844009399414,
0.361420214176178,
0.5659967660903931,
0.2613969147205353,
-0.8267106413841248,
0.03859872743487358,
-0.41797077655792236,
0.05933564528822899,
-0.1818201243877411,
-0.664206862449646,
0.3891797959804535,
-0.3262230157852173,
-0.3310103118419647,
-0.1410510092973709,
0.8162257075309753,
0.06970454752445221,
0.973498523235321,
0.2813299000263214,
0.6032810211181641,
0.6087267398834229,
0.0737437978386879,
0.9242411851882935,
-0.2331574261188507,
0.6413125991821289,
1.1195476055145264,
-0.07007583975791931,
0.36670854687690735,
0.4732181429862976,
-0.04931933060288429,
0.4795481264591217,
0.40881869196891785,
0.09722572565078735,
0.6629793047904968,
-0.4122081696987152,
-0.06863659620285034,
-0.05165216326713562,
-0.15730449557304382,
-0.33799025416374207,
0.6337764859199524,
0.11292722076177597,
-0.2309444099664688,
-0.764340341091156,
0.01817583292722702,
0.15792953968048096,
0.14645354449748993,
-0.29148370027542114,
0.5294474363327026,
-0.09000691026449203,
-0.517113983631134,
0.6109732389450073,
0.3688019812107086,
0.494065523147583,
-0.4899754822254181,
-0.18720008432865143,
-0.25136470794677734,
0.2742902338504791,
-0.5109450221061707,
-0.4658099114894867,
0.48474791646003723,
0.17936012148857117,
-0.6794273257255554,
0.052779778838157654,
0.6433463096618652,
-0.1434750258922577,
-0.31727173924446106,
-0.15559661388397217,
0.33577296137809753,
0.10037172585725784,
0.24291670322418213,
-0.5020443797111511,
-0.12592564523220062,
-0.05575516074895859,
-0.14671245217323303,
0.10645892471075058,
0.44347071647644043,
-0.10438111424446106,
0.651877224445343,
0.4471200406551361,
-0.24137750267982483,
-0.22972038388252258,
0.058444999158382416,
0.7857574224472046,
-0.28200584650039673,
-0.37499290704727173,
-0.9710710048675537,
0.7072817087173462,
-0.1467948853969574,
-0.3277520537376404,
0.9248079061508179,
0.8566776514053345,
0.3492658734321594,
-0.3047862648963928,
0.6086717844009399,
-0.25647929310798645,
0.4307219982147217,
-0.8513175249099731,
0.7268965244293213,
-0.5734502077102661,
0.11122464388608932,
-0.5678414702415466,
-0.7686782479286194,
-0.34487298130989075,
0.28271448612213135,
-0.06307277083396912,
0.06278771162033081,
1.1433674097061157,
0.6394513845443726,
-0.33427467942237854,
0.2635531723499298,
0.26462361216545105,
0.14789171516895294,
-0.1046982854604721,
0.12473408877849579,
0.653115451335907,
-0.3122078478336334,
0.4947499930858612,
-0.2757241129875183,
-0.4384157657623291,
-0.39653897285461426,
-1.0623536109924316,
-0.8543233275413513,
-0.5363302826881409,
-0.4128222167491913,
-0.21627765893936157,
-0.12360373884439468,
0.6774983406066895,
0.6430244445800781,
-0.8373550772666931,
0.06174658238887787,
0.16800615191459656,
0.3642851710319519,
-0.12642960250377655,
-0.24754181504249573,
0.40495195984840393,
-0.1322840303182602,
-0.555916965007782,
0.23234713077545166,
0.400202214717865,
0.0641324445605278,
-0.023450657725334167,
0.03126000240445137,
-0.20559664070606232,
0.3338122069835663,
0.8220037221908569,
0.0810333788394928,
-0.5725461840629578,
-0.31988412141799927,
-0.46832072734832764,
0.14564847946166992,
0.03462710604071617,
0.6874772310256958,
-0.5003447532653809,
0.637347400188446,
0.3325352072715759,
0.3547731041908264,
0.29573097825050354,
0.34106919169425964,
0.35477736592292786,
-0.6918469071388245,
0.2509876787662506,
-0.3332025706768036,
0.35641375184059143,
0.22581782937049866,
-0.36148813366889954,
0.33098241686820984,
0.4075683653354645,
-0.2513262927532196,
-0.6980864405632019,
0.15466812252998352,
-1.1933647394180298,
-0.18266315758228302,
0.89040607213974,
-0.3458079397678375,
-0.031578730791807175,
0.027182888239622116,
-0.13344122469425201,
0.2732263505458832,
-0.37681883573532104,
0.8045097589492798,
0.7670813798904419,
-0.19939301908016205,
0.11387225985527039,
-0.46243318915367126,
0.17635183036327362,
0.21061022579669952,
-0.7831329703330994,
-0.03481416776776314,
0.8515651822090149,
0.2791490852832794,
0.4576338529586792,
0.4932916462421417,
-0.20916858315467834,
0.5037585496902466,
0.05986080318689346,
0.15465550124645233,
-0.37121155858039856,
-0.36530402302742004,
-0.3381939232349396,
0.36839592456817627,
-0.2517816126346588,
-0.31352540850639343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11411v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11411v1 | Aligning Modalities in Vision Large Language Models via Preference Fine-tuning | 2024-02-18T00:56:16 | 2024-02-18T00:56:16 | Yiyang Zhou, Chenhang Cui, Rafael Rafailov, Chelsea Finn, Huaxiu Yao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Instruction-following Vision Large Language Models (VLLMs) have achieved
significant progress recently on a variety of tasks. These approaches merge
strong pre-trained vision models and large language models (LLMs). Since these
components are trained separately, the learned representations need to be
aligned with joint training on additional image-language pairs. This procedure
is not perfect and can cause the model to hallucinate - provide answers that do
not accurately reflect the image, even when the core LLM is highly factual and
the vision backbone has sufficiently complete representations. In this work, we
frame the hallucination problem as an alignment issue, tackle it with
preference tuning. Specifically, we propose POVID to generate feedback data
with AI models. We use ground-truth instructions as the preferred response and
a two-stage approach to generate dispreferred data. First, we prompt GPT-4V to
inject plausible hallucinations into the correct answer. Second, we distort the
image to trigger the inherent hallucination behavior of the VLLM. This is an
automated approach, which does not rely on human data generation or require a
perfect expert, which makes it easily scalable. Finally, both of these
generation strategies are integrated into an RLHF pipeline via Direct
Preference Optimization. In experiments across broad benchmarks, we show that
we can not only reduce hallucinations, but improve model performance across
standard benchmarks, outperforming prior approaches. Our data and code are
available at https://github.com/YiyangZhou/POVID. | [
-0.5094271898269653,
-0.6817984580993652,
0.6612510681152344,
-0.2376728057861328,
-0.38171759247779846,
-0.5485196709632874,
-0.5276198387145996,
-0.3986656665802002,
0.193524569272995,
0.6845251321792603,
-0.4541768729686737,
-0.4947555959224701,
-0.4324018359184265,
-0.09855450689792633,
0.0346393883228302,
0.9475321173667908,
0.0011388342827558517,
0.25570961833000183,
-0.2835003137588501,
-0.1996338665485382,
-0.6744265556335449,
-0.5136039853096008,
-0.272673100233078,
-0.2956189811229706,
0.4130243957042694,
0.3126164972782135,
1.0834040641784668,
0.7976582050323486,
0.7431877255439758,
0.287290096282959,
0.301570326089859,
0.6190683841705322,
-0.4643697738647461,
0.1658916473388672,
-0.2684124708175659,
-0.11774350702762604,
-0.5337960124015808,
-0.20850926637649536,
0.42258456349372864,
0.5093070864677429,
-0.19321215152740479,
-0.0006593433790840209,
-0.045659009367227554,
0.6343895792961121,
-0.6641517877578735,
-0.12223798036575317,
-0.6798732280731201,
0.2022314816713333,
0.05121980980038643,
-0.44716814160346985,
-0.38115939497947693,
-0.32751452922821045,
0.2754969000816345,
-0.611729085445404,
0.19567778706550598,
0.15790477395057678,
0.9734755158424377,
0.851135790348053,
-0.03555015102028847,
-0.0020316941663622856,
-0.788337767124176,
0.745211660861969,
-0.6219472885131836,
0.40801766514778137,
0.5051671266555786,
0.21727073192596436,
-0.120670847594738,
-0.24192138016223907,
-0.5905385613441467,
-0.1978151947259903,
-0.07042168825864792,
0.030931392684578896,
0.2581459879875183,
0.16036297380924225,
0.21455056965351105,
0.34881287813186646,
-0.7091898322105408,
0.2025238573551178,
-0.23383797705173492,
-0.34210407733917236,
0.6056773066520691,
0.31082162261009216,
0.040824465453624725,
-0.03844277188181877,
-0.1793939471244812,
-0.25404974818229675,
-0.41965028643608093,
-0.17767372727394104,
0.4123985171318054,
0.2534755766391754,
0.15458787977695465,
0.8222272992134094,
0.0100612947717309,
1.0689301490783691,
0.7577382326126099,
-0.03275363892316818,
0.4887179136276245,
-0.05070866271853447,
-0.42278459668159485,
0.3085468113422394,
0.5984737277030945,
0.7831553220748901,
0.16332660615444183,
-0.12209860980510712,
-0.33706244826316833,
0.3964386582374573,
0.7246782183647156,
-0.7132821679115295,
-0.30597108602523804,
0.33582884073257446,
-0.30323249101638794,
-0.3251799941062927,
0.14190395176410675,
-0.7575627565383911,
-0.7666776180267334,
-0.7918152213096619,
0.7365262508392334,
-0.375057578086853,
-0.26664063334465027,
0.5392377972602844,
0.18323968350887299,
0.6483281254768372,
0.4286307096481323,
-1.1698660850524902,
0.01010827161371708,
0.6348074674606323,
0.5540816187858582,
-0.4095563590526581,
-0.3894179165363312,
-0.9246973991394043,
-0.032386913895606995,
-0.4819185733795166,
0.6546664237976074,
-0.6867454648017883,
-0.0759991928935051,
0.03866678848862648,
0.12991581857204437,
0.13472731411457062,
-0.799781322479248,
0.3332577049732208,
-0.2703772187232971,
0.3772609233856201,
-0.2534140646457672,
-0.42926713824272156,
-0.008460531011223793,
0.23309122025966644,
-0.4670032560825348,
0.8561919331550598,
-0.044682398438453674,
-0.7380541563034058,
0.3559500277042389,
-0.2878499925136566,
-0.3181712031364441,
-0.0864076018333435,
-0.6454454660415649,
-0.55140221118927,
0.3275837302207947,
0.4862302243709564,
0.43841123580932617,
-0.07994130998849869,
0.4456040859222412,
-0.18733428418636322,
-0.451355516910553,
0.03273080661892891,
-0.2591419219970703,
0.31253716349601746,
0.18635542690753937,
-0.7297464609146118,
0.5603986978530884,
-0.6249213814735413,
-0.1898096799850464,
0.06369015574455261,
0.17545080184936523,
-0.24345998466014862,
0.1861591935157776,
-0.03799653798341751,
-0.07242604345083237,
0.2551855146884918,
-0.1655682772397995,
0.33573606610298157,
-0.48803362250328064,
0.242629274725914,
0.9820542931556702,
-0.2808435261249542,
0.65627121925354,
-0.3595671057701111,
0.28455060720443726,
0.08881494402885437,
0.3694309592247009,
0.1535658836364746,
-0.25172168016433716,
-0.8209514617919922,
-0.09107626229524612,
-0.17225094139575958,
0.3194848597049713,
-0.6180694699287415,
0.6251017451286316,
-0.14129570126533508,
-0.12016499042510986,
-0.7322601675987244,
0.024576840922236443,
0.18238218128681183,
0.6929695010185242,
0.442262202501297,
-0.34861063957214355,
-0.5745094418525696,
-1.0222468376159668,
0.2725929319858551,
-0.11153915524482727,
0.029028888791799545,
0.38718393445014954,
0.07676709443330765,
-0.35105302929878235,
0.704680323600769,
-0.6358131170272827,
-0.5455676317214966,
0.14464519917964935,
-0.197363018989563,
0.01518931519240141,
0.43736696243286133,
0.4383687674999237,
-0.9416188597679138,
-0.10357452929019928,
0.3013785481452942,
-0.7711753249168396,
-0.007557069417089224,
0.013972814194858074,
-0.410102903842926,
0.44403067231178284,
0.3789966106414795,
-0.3949342668056488,
0.29753851890563965,
0.5006187558174133,
-0.21504336595535278,
0.5346254706382751,
-0.22530657052993774,
0.31991827487945557,
-1.0789434909820557,
-0.0571136474609375,
-0.052512433379888535,
-0.20974382758140564,
-0.48147502541542053,
0.08263342082500458,
-0.15837900340557098,
0.1340571790933609,
-0.4357379972934723,
0.34587809443473816,
-0.40968799591064453,
-0.040049657225608826,
-0.3540061116218567,
0.09641250967979431,
-0.02402271330356598,
0.5573287606239319,
0.5764245986938477,
0.6253229975700378,
0.7520678639411926,
-0.4540780484676361,
0.5070117115974426,
0.21745680272579193,
-0.23610307276248932,
0.538101851940155,
-0.49894261360168457,
0.31580525636672974,
-0.2857094705104828,
-0.1644584685564041,
-0.8241844177246094,
-0.5884005427360535,
0.47937700152397156,
-0.3224306106567383,
0.38152003288269043,
0.1117488369345665,
-0.06406953930854797,
-0.1440611332654953,
-0.334970086812973,
0.4715973734855652,
0.6125533580780029,
-0.6849446892738342,
0.69476318359375,
0.4552655816078186,
0.3254297971725464,
-0.6754888296127319,
-0.528676450252533,
-0.10896918177604675,
-0.2904170751571655,
-0.5149518251419067,
0.40851786732673645,
-0.14946810901165009,
-0.26304373145103455,
0.04804638773202896,
-0.21596182882785797,
0.15230050683021545,
-0.2897135019302368,
0.42460736632347107,
0.6231834292411804,
-0.38677969574928284,
0.11347850412130356,
-0.2978787422180176,
0.04940950870513916,
-0.2366090714931488,
-0.5693315267562866,
0.6813607811927795,
-0.30057305097579956,
-0.40174612402915955,
-0.4626407027244568,
0.15318943560123444,
0.7690783143043518,
-0.37896233797073364,
0.4921528697013855,
0.6536077260971069,
-0.3863525986671448,
-0.07092226296663284,
-0.7467285394668579,
-0.43596240878105164,
-0.4611085057258606,
0.3758494555950165,
-0.27944818139076233,
-0.9011563062667847,
0.26509541273117065,
0.2944430708885193,
0.00947573035955429,
0.25200480222702026,
0.816124439239502,
0.0700218677520752,
1.158747911453247,
0.5758126378059387,
-0.09758763015270233,
0.5232806205749512,
-0.058922067284584045,
0.3057302236557007,
-0.6631619334220886,
-0.29937639832496643,
-0.14569509029388428,
-0.44580063223838806,
-0.3335479199886322,
-0.4702588617801666,
0.31691840291023254,
-0.08031319081783295,
-0.2476716935634613,
0.10701297968626022,
-1.0120421648025513,
0.6242258548736572,
0.4220432639122009,
0.3082410991191864,
0.054000578820705414,
0.26592347025871277,
0.1137094497680664,
-0.1892528384923935,
-0.4254218339920044,
-0.49968287348747253,
0.920882523059845,
0.1646548956632614,
1.0807850360870361,
-0.08960229903459549,
0.572887122631073,
0.011445456184446812,
-0.14979000389575958,
-0.9159366488456726,
0.42958205938339233,
-0.26215386390686035,
-0.203619122505188,
-0.4128723740577698,
-0.14304879307746887,
-0.5826212167739868,
0.08628498017787933,
-0.3397315740585327,
-0.7068936824798584,
0.1975017935037613,
0.40791165828704834,
-0.6463543176651001,
0.1551058143377304,
-0.6479747295379639,
0.9304807782173157,
-0.4702063202857971,
-0.7842978835105896,
-0.098686084151268,
-0.7125522494316101,
0.31216445565223694,
0.055932629853487015,
-0.2836625576019287,
0.1921246349811554,
0.21957750618457794,
0.35433506965637207,
-0.36122286319732666,
0.7276079058647156,
-0.15931160748004913,
-0.25422438979148865,
0.0028963966760784388,
-0.07612191885709763,
0.5581154227256775,
0.03246523439884186,
0.0738869309425354,
0.0002230918762506917,
-0.21598300337791443,
-0.1597805917263031,
-0.5842509865760803,
0.8656359314918518,
-0.9761770963668823,
-0.8888009190559387,
-0.39725735783576965,
-0.6223552227020264,
-0.2797647714614868,
-0.055442556738853455,
0.5310487151145935,
0.5103862881660461,
0.09736140817403793,
0.021447351202368736,
0.9282231330871582,
-0.2716977298259735,
0.0530976876616478,
0.1693212389945984,
-0.5656747221946716,
-0.4187288284301758,
1.0353718996047974,
-0.10454360395669937,
0.2629733085632324,
0.39643722772598267,
0.13832764327526093,
-0.30028459429740906,
-0.6011821031570435,
-0.494932621717453,
0.2620212435722351,
-0.45734041929244995,
-0.10659737139940262,
-0.42508822679519653,
-0.2172502726316452,
-0.5089055299758911,
-0.34850236773490906,
-0.4789176881313324,
0.051185958087444305,
-0.41861215233802795,
-0.08551158756017685,
0.2968754172325134,
0.42225003242492676,
0.038553692400455475,
-0.05605515465140343,
-0.3832763433456421,
0.5763842463493347,
0.4070700705051422,
0.38236451148986816,
-0.20523272454738617,
-0.649291455745697,
-0.15656355023384094,
0.013271241448819637,
-0.2125243842601776,
-0.6350528001785278,
0.3248077630996704,
0.06863126903772354,
0.2951200008392334,
0.6195588111877441,
0.19207720458507538,
1.1483726501464844,
-0.5161909461021423,
0.8144919872283936,
0.26095062494277954,
-0.774692714214325,
0.6927579045295715,
-0.14722827076911926,
0.11856845766305923,
0.6065143346786499,
0.20809288322925568,
-0.317748486995697,
-0.42125794291496277,
-0.1667221486568451,
-0.6919535994529724,
0.6864866614341736,
-0.02483215741813183,
0.03542942926287651,
0.11555354297161102,
0.3941066265106201,
0.3246585726737976,
0.1354190558195114,
-0.4002620279788971,
-0.029356013983488083,
-0.5745607614517212,
-0.2767021954059601,
-0.06107145920395851,
-0.026230767369270325,
-0.2705725133419037,
-0.4841046929359436,
0.5702547430992126,
-0.20944806933403015,
0.14692239463329315,
0.3668615520000458,
-0.07812004536390305,
-0.3822964131832123,
-0.0946873128414154,
0.8668093085289001,
0.6981391310691833,
-0.35117149353027344,
0.3436286151409149,
-0.18863949179649353,
-0.4816320538520813,
0.14804969727993011,
-0.18731828033924103,
-0.23549224436283112,
-0.16714546084403992,
0.0911097526550293,
1.1782817840576172,
-0.2963584065437317,
-0.6611368656158447,
0.5149103999137878,
-0.13114604353904724,
-0.38383302092552185,
-0.26296624541282654,
0.2876524329185486,
-0.25772610306739807,
0.39986684918403625,
0.15264946222305298,
0.2402743101119995,
-0.05309493839740753,
-0.27513253688812256,
0.16441534459590912,
0.6182246804237366,
-0.44930750131607056,
-0.340162068605423,
0.7674031853675842,
0.10783680528402328,
-0.30548903346061707,
0.6719058752059937,
-0.037356581538915634,
-0.42455679178237915,
0.4162309765815735,
0.39092060923576355,
0.9602248072624207,
-0.2177753895521164,
0.32519084215164185,
0.4133520722389221,
0.21939662098884583,
-0.3196578025817871,
0.10746735334396362,
0.07444529980421066,
-0.9794050455093384,
-0.47318506240844727,
-0.7663941979408264,
-0.2444344311952591,
0.4800148904323578,
-0.7041172981262207,
0.5274873971939087,
-0.38415682315826416,
-0.1481979489326477,
-0.032033856958150864,
-0.2567480504512787,
-0.5184556841850281,
0.15161266922950745,
0.4715282917022705,
0.23351873457431793,
-0.7828000783920288,
0.9836809635162354,
0.7729935050010681,
-0.4063866138458252,
-0.9512522220611572,
0.28342410922050476,
0.005056335125118494,
-0.763987123966217,
0.3490864932537079,
0.23223035037517548,
-0.34467464685440063,
-0.07611053436994553,
-0.6275801658630371,
-0.5191263556480408,
0.784153401851654,
0.6435807347297668,
-0.906856894493103,
-0.01864342950284481,
-0.09828273206949234,
0.4994623064994812,
-0.5360242128372192,
-0.1186712458729744,
0.47353556752204895,
0.5401033759117126,
0.24125300347805023,
-0.854888379573822,
0.04174909368157387,
-0.1791951209306717,
-0.03321150317788124,
0.37029072642326355,
-0.46749335527420044,
0.4976002871990204,
-0.40691831707954407,
-0.06807544827461243,
-0.019117793068289757,
0.5539201498031616,
0.05113721638917923,
0.1707853376865387,
0.5726626515388489,
0.6868890523910522,
0.7555850744247437,
0.051756296306848526,
0.7543279528617859,
-0.2764451503753662,
0.1284560263156891,
1.3429092168807983,
-0.5178428888320923,
0.7687869668006897,
0.9449753761291504,
0.14571218192577362,
-0.008395540527999401,
0.717559278011322,
-0.14194045960903168,
0.8030112981796265,
0.02292507514357567,
0.04260878264904022,
-0.5456410050392151,
-0.22040528059005737,
-0.5897277593612671,
0.5011194348335266,
0.03168182075023651,
-0.27801159024238586,
0.18094933032989502,
0.17898966372013092,
-0.3776478171348572,
0.2005934715270996,
-0.32756558060646057,
0.8639055490493774,
-0.267390638589859,
-1.0431578159332275,
0.8977193236351013,
-0.32164138555526733,
0.6374345421791077,
-0.4601128101348877,
-0.10636518150568008,
-0.33814024925231934,
0.32247868180274963,
-0.4474021792411804,
-0.5703434348106384,
0.3622753620147705,
-0.11367689073085785,
-0.3122251033782959,
0.018005691468715668,
0.3619595170021057,
-0.6883872747421265,
-0.38131898641586304,
0.1032494306564331,
0.07146336138248444,
0.12772248685359955,
-0.07021037489175797,
-0.2225092500448227,
0.3538009226322174,
0.28952813148498535,
0.0019374756375327706,
0.34688982367515564,
0.20392870903015137,
-0.10660139471292496,
0.10576852411031723,
0.37898123264312744,
0.21048247814178467,
0.029144100844860077,
0.2745078206062317,
0.8352336287498474,
-0.451278418302536,
-0.10664568841457367,
-0.994507908821106,
0.36958637833595276,
0.07177466154098511,
-0.347771018743515,
0.47469305992126465,
0.4293140769004822,
0.940086841583252,
-0.23743639886379242,
0.5791765451431274,
0.07804641127586365,
-0.10315791517496109,
-0.7468904256820679,
0.4772765338420868,
-0.7582979798316956,
0.17381978034973145,
-0.29614707827568054,
-1.2684553861618042,
-0.4924788177013397,
0.937786877155304,
-0.42367222905158997,
-0.2934887409210205,
0.6321418881416321,
1.2709710597991943,
-0.13121843338012695,
-0.20319387316703796,
0.47794875502586365,
0.208095520734787,
0.16071996092796326,
0.694424033164978,
0.8562659025192261,
-0.18508104979991913,
0.2922300696372986,
-0.19118954241275787,
-0.2661327123641968,
-0.35633835196495056,
-0.7512239813804626,
-0.77732253074646,
-0.7577930092811584,
-0.43861886858940125,
-0.3845926523208618,
0.07114437222480774,
1.1322505474090576,
0.6971648335456848,
-0.8077767491340637,
-0.1200263574719429,
-0.13187621533870697,
-0.11841276288032532,
-0.23788508772850037,
-0.17719049751758575,
0.45913127064704895,
-0.42137670516967773,
-0.7959692478179932,
0.08876587450504303,
0.5530921816825867,
0.08416615426540375,
-0.47086507081985474,
-0.5215198993682861,
0.16302622854709625,
-0.11093298345804214,
0.46757185459136963,
-0.007322253193706274,
-1.108359932899475,
-0.5853924751281738,
0.33185485005378723,
-0.11358658224344254,
0.3609161972999573,
0.7253853678703308,
-0.6299486756324768,
0.765343189239502,
0.3556191325187683,
0.7915574908256531,
0.3639755845069885,
0.1440858244895935,
0.6187558770179749,
-0.32379379868507385,
0.21332380175590515,
0.29130473732948303,
0.18149015307426453,
0.48270246386528015,
-0.5349911451339722,
0.32595422863960266,
-0.044377490878105164,
-0.7049216032028198,
-0.8501594066619873,
0.19149909913539886,
-1.147194504737854,
-0.263050377368927,
1.1772643327713013,
0.40730300545692444,
-0.33556872606277466,
0.21160374581813812,
-0.7269142866134644,
0.09073533862829208,
-0.21379482746124268,
0.9965433478355408,
0.7346470952033997,
-0.12830369174480438,
-0.10384968668222427,
-0.26944097876548767,
0.7117360234260559,
0.6240293979644775,
-0.4402126669883728,
0.16011446714401245,
0.8983619809150696,
-0.021167008206248283,
0.21548783779144287,
0.48053503036499023,
-0.14361031353473663,
0.3210030794143677,
-0.3380771279335022,
0.11641792953014374,
-0.05772515386343002,
-0.61838299036026,
-0.5283998847007751,
0.13726606965065002,
0.19323818385601044,
-0.43427029252052307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11409v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11409v2 | Multi-dimensional Evaluation of Empathetic Dialog Responses | 2024-02-18T00:32:33 | 2024-04-16T16:34:02 | Zhichao Xu, Jiepu Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Empathy is critical for effective and satisfactory conversational
communication. Prior efforts to measure conversational empathy mostly focus on
expressed communicative intents -- that is, the way empathy is expressed. Yet,
these works ignore the fact that conversation is also a collaboration involving
both speakers and listeners. In contrast, we propose a multi-dimensional
empathy evaluation framework to measure both expressed intents from the
speaker's perspective and perceived empathy from the listener's perspective. We
apply our proposed framework to analyze our internal customer-service dialogue.
We find the two dimensions (expressed intent types and perceived empathy) are
inter-connected, and perceived empathy has a high correlation with dialogue
satisfaction levels.
To reduce the annotation cost, we explore different options to automatically
measure conversational empathy: prompting LLMs and training language
model-based classifiers. Our experiments show that prompting methods with even
popular models like GPT-4 and Flan family models perform relatively poorly on
both public and our internal datasets. In contrast, instruction-finetuned
classifiers based on Flan-T5 family models outperform prior works and
competitive baselines. We conduct a detailed ablation study to give more
insights into instruction finetuning method's strong performance. | [
-0.6787383556365967,
-0.887847363948822,
0.6465608477592468,
0.18870019912719727,
-0.033922240138053894,
-0.20564162731170654,
-0.12724435329437256,
-0.2991301417350769,
0.1345691978931427,
0.3025137484073639,
-0.5147698521614075,
-0.34904688596725464,
-0.6047835350036621,
0.2780441641807556,
0.03889015316963196,
0.6675814986228943,
0.04912331700325012,
0.4103047549724579,
-0.21814070641994476,
-0.24627237021923065,
-0.22667370736598969,
-0.5615536570549011,
-0.9580952525138855,
-0.44709494709968567,
0.578947901725769,
0.6997373700141907,
0.30994102358818054,
0.2289099544286728,
0.42076772451400757,
0.37828025221824646,
-0.03161979839205742,
0.2603589594364166,
-0.23174962401390076,
-0.06113569810986519,
0.3996695876121521,
-0.1567530781030655,
-0.7037501335144043,
0.19633285701274872,
0.19104927778244019,
0.6396756768226624,
-0.25838735699653625,
0.15838059782981873,
0.25918522477149963,
0.430372029542923,
-0.32320430874824524,
-0.055194757878780365,
-0.13820712268352509,
0.3256215453147888,
0.6285310983657837,
-0.33238381147384644,
-0.39876192808151245,
-0.44324395060539246,
0.43525275588035583,
-0.2887050211429596,
0.10949762910604477,
-0.04577619209885597,
0.29910531640052795,
0.07685568183660507,
-0.5184578895568848,
-0.44360363483428955,
-0.5413076877593994,
0.7360871434211731,
-0.5573346614837646,
0.33221355080604553,
0.5606780648231506,
0.1295529454946518,
0.35927820205688477,
-0.29296597838401794,
-0.4153796136379242,
-0.3517271876335144,
-0.08015602082014084,
0.5012470483779907,
-0.26700544357299805,
0.36847248673439026,
0.43737831711769104,
0.4766659736633301,
-0.3271273374557495,
0.1551768034696579,
-0.04231540486216545,
0.1560429334640503,
0.4902949035167694,
0.4730294942855835,
0.2670917510986328,
-0.01514996588230133,
-0.4379420280456543,
-0.10207504779100418,
0.0667002722620964,
0.27485939860343933,
0.49791568517684937,
0.23595041036605835,
-0.603147029876709,
0.6133635640144348,
0.12515144050121307,
0.452160120010376,
0.3473368287086487,
0.06356289237737656,
0.09506623446941376,
-0.09903109073638916,
-0.27239179611206055,
0.08090164512395859,
0.6182375550270081,
1.0351251363754272,
0.5236684679985046,
0.12675417959690094,
0.1944609135389328,
0.10017583519220352,
0.40375426411628723,
-0.978744387626648,
0.00651458278298378,
0.491216242313385,
-0.7276613116264343,
-0.18688014149665833,
-0.08567776530981064,
-1.1080354452133179,
-0.46202075481414795,
-0.5151908993721008,
0.04429629445075989,
-0.3882817327976227,
-0.3762974143028259,
-0.08748874068260193,
-0.26101651787757874,
0.2396099716424942,
0.2684425711631775,
-0.8789798617362976,
0.3812645673751831,
0.6167109608650208,
0.9498673677444458,
0.1718248575925827,
-0.351648211479187,
-0.6181701421737671,
-0.13006405532360077,
-0.02686353214085102,
0.9217182397842407,
-0.830641508102417,
-0.5250861048698425,
0.0752275288105011,
-0.25828924775123596,
-0.10318273305892944,
-0.3392298221588135,
0.6093396544456482,
0.18411299586296082,
0.20872187614440918,
-0.28781917691230774,
-0.6637156009674072,
-0.13145262002944946,
0.6115986108779907,
-0.28338971734046936,
0.4275531470775604,
0.4346984922885895,
-0.6583466529846191,
0.3152395188808441,
-0.8926531672477722,
-0.22516725957393646,
-0.2871086895465851,
0.012222588993608952,
-0.3582834005355835,
0.3317941129207611,
0.31017884612083435,
0.6160988211631775,
-0.21187157928943634,
-0.220195010304451,
-0.5175580382347107,
-0.28204259276390076,
0.2746918499469757,
-0.5659780502319336,
0.40558865666389465,
0.1293950229883194,
-0.11607079207897186,
0.09302151203155518,
-0.5697583556175232,
-0.012760267592966557,
-0.06090625002980232,
-0.17878887057304382,
-0.3110820949077606,
-0.42389431595802307,
-0.12975728511810303,
0.23527777194976807,
-0.007041726727038622,
-0.7432531714439392,
0.16268381476402283,
-0.5684318542480469,
0.19493146240711212,
0.7269859313964844,
0.26832523941993713,
0.5977484583854675,
-0.3013063967227936,
0.6924093961715698,
0.2204103171825409,
0.5876402258872986,
-0.3707144558429718,
-0.4744771420955658,
-0.6981059312820435,
-0.5104290843009949,
-0.4986305236816406,
0.42275381088256836,
-0.09855885803699493,
0.4999280273914337,
0.017525823786854744,
-0.5379646420478821,
-0.6479384303092957,
-0.1859642118215561,
0.5614832043647766,
0.4207628071308136,
0.33556926250457764,
-0.43469008803367615,
-0.1999419927597046,
-0.9354321956634521,
-0.40250730514526367,
0.01352617796510458,
-0.02541678585112095,
0.7219228744506836,
-0.07482802867889404,
-0.20454423129558563,
0.5666184425354004,
-0.3032234013080597,
-0.35177284479141235,
-0.2579774558544159,
0.29769617319107056,
-0.08973579108715057,
0.24721871316432953,
0.4681491553783417,
-0.44636744260787964,
-0.735852837562561,
0.23872631788253784,
-0.5614241361618042,
-0.12683752179145813,
-0.11722570657730103,
0.10616280138492584,
0.3108954429626465,
0.12917344272136688,
-0.509710967540741,
0.6029817461967468,
0.6455349326133728,
-0.4816162884235382,
0.04578879475593567,
-0.2497469037771225,
0.714061439037323,
-0.9843432307243347,
-0.1723555028438568,
0.16794314980506897,
0.37044110894203186,
-0.9325062036514282,
-0.6111321449279785,
-0.10875917226076126,
0.01662818342447281,
-0.40555939078330994,
0.682257890701294,
-0.17218713462352753,
-0.1547108143568039,
0.07069939374923706,
0.248470738530159,
0.11111551523208618,
0.586017906665802,
-0.010133896954357624,
0.4525260329246521,
0.4125709533691406,
-0.45677638053894043,
0.5418325662612915,
0.597119152545929,
-0.09521272778511047,
1.1075626611709595,
-0.5322693586349487,
0.1991720348596573,
-0.013265092857182026,
0.20635195076465607,
-0.9690502882003784,
-0.20491254329681396,
0.4639867842197418,
-0.5070359110832214,
0.060069408267736435,
-0.11038810014724731,
-0.11523770540952682,
-0.28908365964889526,
-0.2635361850261688,
0.3011709749698639,
0.39336976408958435,
-0.7218871712684631,
0.9218579530715942,
-0.0007442199857905507,
-0.30430442094802856,
-0.17453619837760925,
-0.7165619134902954,
-0.05390884354710579,
-0.48553037643432617,
-0.6554292440414429,
-0.3269042372703552,
-0.3483690619468689,
-0.4651753604412079,
-0.5532293319702148,
0.12534360587596893,
-0.21528899669647217,
-0.1004863828420639,
0.3578226566314697,
-0.06800206005573273,
0.010649111121892929,
-0.1201343685388565,
0.1784757673740387,
-0.353786438703537,
0.34385040402412415,
0.38308924436569214,
0.6080331206321716,
-0.24405346810817719,
-0.642272412776947,
-1.0768386125564575,
0.543826699256897,
0.5795674920082092,
-0.15164396166801453,
0.5612896680831909,
0.7036401033401489,
-0.018973464146256447,
0.21832674741744995,
-0.6953786611557007,
-0.5406800508499146,
-0.3733132481575012,
0.03358572721481323,
-0.4143294394016266,
-0.6691148281097412,
0.5481221079826355,
-0.0914125144481659,
0.05670837685465813,
-0.24040056765079498,
0.5790473222732544,
0.17570284008979797,
1.4959657192230225,
0.19679370522499084,
0.07353003323078156,
0.4544770419597626,
-0.18775251507759094,
0.8022698760032654,
-1.025646448135376,
-0.2406495064496994,
-0.4555746614933014,
-0.17374813556671143,
-0.3667328655719757,
0.012946387752890587,
0.30966997146606445,
-0.24757975339889526,
-0.34330102801322937,
-0.07177700102329254,
-0.4708070755004883,
0.14831948280334473,
0.34698331356048584,
0.24446678161621094,
0.11840087920427322,
0.00370592693798244,
0.0176041591912508,
-0.12065904587507248,
-0.4378470778465271,
-0.6279478073120117,
0.7955577373504639,
0.6904689073562622,
0.48901674151420593,
0.08065466582775116,
0.7587358951568604,
-0.11199788004159927,
0.689173698425293,
-1.0228664875030518,
0.31203997135162354,
0.03648819029331207,
-0.17775820195674896,
-0.3431762158870697,
-0.48316675424575806,
-0.7942785024642944,
0.28629356622695923,
0.06762398779392242,
-0.8898033499717712,
0.07370827347040176,
0.26574283838272095,
-0.5687599182128906,
0.14651688933372498,
-1.2149474620819092,
0.8142032623291016,
-0.34123629331588745,
-0.21626660227775574,
-0.23271189630031586,
-0.3984914720058441,
0.09787704795598984,
0.044758390635252,
0.30367276072502136,
-0.14004015922546387,
0.2132212072610855,
0.22034549713134766,
-0.17858508229255676,
0.9521418213844299,
-0.42207613587379456,
-0.22292263805866241,
0.05915147066116333,
0.21510694921016693,
0.20356084406375885,
0.05657988414168358,
-0.16810911893844604,
0.2976149320602417,
-0.02244485355913639,
-0.1780497282743454,
-0.8186243176460266,
0.5898339152336121,
-0.6282752156257629,
-0.351462721824646,
-0.20582665503025055,
-0.4280601441860199,
-0.39089760184288025,
-0.11086741834878922,
0.1430739313364029,
0.5642576813697815,
-0.46390390396118164,
0.1033136397600174,
0.3877750635147095,
-0.46139416098594666,
0.16786931455135345,
0.3125937581062317,
0.06824454665184021,
-0.3650813400745392,
0.6526651978492737,
-0.24474725127220154,
0.489544153213501,
0.16983383893966675,
0.6020189523696899,
-0.13278573751449585,
-0.029108254238963127,
-0.2739696204662323,
0.14180292189121246,
-0.6597732901573181,
-0.1643414944410324,
-0.8095499873161316,
0.06998781114816666,
-0.47440817952156067,
-0.5498185753822327,
-0.25480788946151733,
-0.011280275881290436,
-0.33310648798942566,
-0.2426777184009552,
0.41192230582237244,
0.8265916109085083,
-0.2478121817111969,
0.2835671305656433,
-0.9665094017982483,
0.1640642136335373,
0.24453473091125488,
0.5682429075241089,
0.2659034729003906,
-0.4435783326625824,
-0.0909157246351242,
0.31162726879119873,
-0.33890172839164734,
-0.5538407564163208,
0.49332261085510254,
0.040692392736673355,
0.3694462776184082,
0.7839979529380798,
-0.03119865618646145,
0.7583608627319336,
-0.3004874587059021,
0.8855717182159424,
0.4373108744621277,
-1.0013014078140259,
0.33787408471107483,
-0.3050541877746582,
0.19554901123046875,
0.3132782578468323,
0.24349825084209442,
-0.5229036808013916,
-0.4341573715209961,
-0.7417401075363159,
-0.6454968452453613,
0.756289541721344,
-0.02910781465470791,
0.47521644830703735,
-0.2741409242153168,
0.20373669266700745,
0.11192470043897629,
-0.11375820636749268,
-0.2076157033443451,
-0.25593483448028564,
-0.24552050232887268,
-0.3801881968975067,
-0.19374960660934448,
-0.47640252113342285,
-0.4050000309944153,
-0.16218264400959015,
0.033612191677093506,
-0.16063393652439117,
0.5327842831611633,
0.25212493538856506,
0.3626728355884552,
-0.45763707160949707,
0.1555459201335907,
0.6469177603721619,
0.3234420418739319,
-0.10980599373579025,
-0.10477667301893234,
0.45007026195526123,
-0.1861768215894699,
-0.20025873184204102,
-0.13461895287036896,
0.7339971661567688,
-0.2880805432796478,
0.44160205125808716,
0.6329478025436401,
0.2325582057237625,
-0.4137762188911438,
0.8341579437255859,
-0.42546895146369934,
-0.27770015597343445,
-0.3715366721153259,
-0.10407647490501404,
-0.04590132459998131,
0.5658901929855347,
-0.25989094376564026,
-0.15032003819942474,
0.31101375818252563,
-0.27009090781211853,
0.07373650372028351,
0.2830023467540741,
-0.5226918458938599,
-0.24723833799362183,
0.06002633646130562,
0.4101962149143219,
-0.5999378561973572,
0.8062980771064758,
0.32462459802627563,
-0.5230599641799927,
0.5250194668769836,
0.2839924395084381,
0.9524325728416443,
-0.6111990809440613,
0.25653085112571716,
0.392408162355423,
-0.023195018991827965,
0.2613447606563568,
0.2685720920562744,
-0.2748609483242035,
-0.7613189816474915,
0.16636526584625244,
-0.26502132415771484,
-0.6106552481651306,
-0.16181787848472595,
-1.2181674242019653,
-0.08898693323135376,
-0.37629958987236023,
-0.18881720304489136,
-0.030127570033073425,
-0.12693792581558228,
-0.8753034472465515,
0.10632283240556717,
-0.04844000190496445,
0.7498550415039062,
-0.8848907947540283,
0.20781762897968292,
0.42284178733825684,
-0.43667829036712646,
-0.6717751622200012,
0.0304315984249115,
0.16082850098609924,
-0.8767409920692444,
0.6009021401405334,
0.5466312766075134,
-0.3557773530483246,
0.025100192055106163,
-0.30398109555244446,
-0.3561290204524994,
0.9875112771987915,
0.08481619507074356,
-0.31930097937583923,
0.25069546699523926,
0.2239096611738205,
0.6736088395118713,
-0.6865573525428772,
0.6792109608650208,
0.7326549887657166,
0.7343329787254333,
-0.0972650796175003,
-0.7859176397323608,
-0.2604404091835022,
-0.1828991025686264,
-0.12396770715713501,
0.03751249611377716,
-0.8272374868392944,
0.4225831627845764,
-0.16740387678146362,
-0.052726175636053085,
0.24623431265354156,
0.0600777268409729,
0.1934320330619812,
0.6631840467453003,
0.5493525862693787,
0.46257591247558594,
0.39631718397140503,
-0.05054587498307228,
1.2163153886795044,
-0.3653135299682617,
0.14007583260536194,
0.8364364504814148,
-0.38427358865737915,
0.701344907283783,
0.7377042174339294,
0.11510896682739258,
0.09320062398910522,
0.5222002267837524,
0.06878215819597244,
0.09366850554943085,
-0.014656401239335537,
-0.30571913719177246,
-0.11913906037807465,
-0.44437557458877563,
-0.08658519387245178,
0.6047469973564148,
0.4625994563102722,
-0.4590708613395691,
-0.010289313271641731,
0.2401854246854782,
0.03706422820687294,
0.046504709869623184,
-0.12781743705272675,
1.0890673398971558,
0.3158705234527588,
-0.6164511442184448,
0.33146464824676514,
-0.4062570333480835,
0.2948181629180908,
-0.23537138104438782,
-0.2309686839580536,
-0.5109527111053467,
0.21660730242729187,
-0.3294711112976074,
-0.824619710445404,
0.19555002450942993,
0.22971627116203308,
0.12026592344045639,
-0.5196565985679626,
0.12180449813604355,
-0.4062693417072296,
-0.09568175673484802,
0.6683956384658813,
0.35524266958236694,
0.3260802924633026,
0.08335459232330322,
-0.7594914436340332,
0.3227884769439697,
-0.14831531047821045,
-0.7194809913635254,
0.2529187500476837,
0.626916766166687,
0.4745766222476959,
0.6242163181304932,
0.4638907313346863,
-0.18057404458522797,
-0.19501444697380066,
0.7441613078117371,
0.7153855562210083,
-0.3731362223625183,
-0.181703582406044,
-0.597721517086029,
0.7249363660812378,
-0.1663287878036499,
-0.45702096819877625,
0.7280263900756836,
0.21531836688518524,
0.686040997505188,
0.0251450352370739,
0.6867983937263489,
0.31693214178085327,
0.6544365882873535,
-0.4659040570259094,
0.25986993312835693,
-0.5328763127326965,
0.017666669562458992,
-0.3524235785007477,
-0.968235969543457,
-0.40859267115592957,
0.8983051180839539,
-0.4722595512866974,
0.4467718005180359,
0.6452434659004211,
0.7297775745391846,
-0.047480735927820206,
0.3970162272453308,
0.6803013682365417,
0.1644686460494995,
0.35367199778556824,
0.374210923910141,
1.2015674114227295,
-0.016158703714609146,
0.1523389369249344,
-0.3643084466457367,
-0.4881613850593567,
-0.2968369424343109,
-0.7147925496101379,
-1.1030973196029663,
-0.5205655694007874,
-0.08647043257951736,
-0.2735117971897125,
-0.3497430980205536,
1.1266522407531738,
0.34356316924095154,
-0.4247528612613678,
-0.26113131642341614,
0.08998226374387741,
-0.34703221917152405,
-0.07101336121559143,
-0.23967576026916504,
0.2715269923210144,
-0.29303887486457825,
-0.8957834243774414,
0.19608649611473083,
0.48787736892700195,
0.17977198958396912,
-0.2006802260875702,
-0.32255861163139343,
0.26364049315452576,
0.1523328274488449,
0.7922162413597107,
-0.17651133239269257,
-0.7404434680938721,
-0.5381574630737305,
0.04261260852217674,
0.12883444130420685,
0.23722092807292938,
0.9666262865066528,
0.007739422842860222,
0.6257845163345337,
0.12103457748889923,
0.5102986097335815,
0.049438100308179855,
0.3136356770992279,
0.6042647957801819,
-0.3920881152153015,
0.049193598330020905,
0.2790932059288025,
0.26915743947029114,
0.3568001389503479,
-0.5980669856071472,
0.23455703258514404,
-0.3781213164329529,
-0.7757681608200073,
-0.7016733288764954,
0.47596868872642517,
-0.9288889765739441,
0.05997786298394203,
1.1908270120620728,
-0.39390483498573303,
0.1561034619808197,
-0.16067147254943848,
-0.5705439448356628,
0.24358654022216797,
-0.6872244477272034,
0.8128665089607239,
0.5866889953613281,
-0.7297295928001404,
-0.45222365856170654,
-0.3608574867248535,
0.37855133414268494,
0.21542297303676605,
-0.7668598294258118,
0.22014188766479492,
0.6866740584373474,
-0.10225462913513184,
0.07751794159412384,
0.488477885723114,
0.08169442415237427,
0.05401094630360603,
0.07929501682519913,
0.10289737582206726,
0.09156002849340439,
-0.28721731901168823,
-0.6479045748710632,
-0.05517341196537018,
0.0277099646627903,
0.08387824147939682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11406v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11406v2 | Don't Go To Extremes: Revealing the Excessive Sensitivity and Calibration Limitations of LLMs in Implicit Hate Speech Detection | 2024-02-18T00:04:40 | 2024-02-26T16:43:37 | Min Zhang, Jianfeng He, Taoran Ji, Chang-Tien Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The fairness and trustworthiness of Large Language Models (LLMs) are
receiving increasing attention. Implicit hate speech, which employs indirect
language to convey hateful intentions, occupies a significant portion of
practice. However, the extent to which LLMs effectively address this issue
remains insufficiently examined. This paper delves into the capability of LLMs
to detect implicit hate speech (Classification Task) and express confidence in
their responses (Calibration Task). Our evaluation meticulously considers
various prompt patterns and mainstream uncertainty estimation methods. Our
findings highlight that LLMs exhibit two extremes: (1) LLMs display excessive
sensitivity towards groups or topics that may cause fairness issues, resulting
in misclassifying benign statements as hate speech. (2) LLMs' confidence scores
for each method excessively concentrate on a fixed range, remaining unchanged
regardless of the dataset's complexity. Consequently, the calibration
performance is heavily reliant on primary classification accuracy. These
discoveries unveil new limitations of LLMs, underscoring the need for caution
when optimizing models to ensure they do not veer towards extremes. This serves
as a reminder to carefully consider sensitivity and confidence in the pursuit
of model fairness. | [
-0.4550139605998993,
-0.6736879348754883,
0.7093462347984314,
-0.1352033019065857,
0.04948431998491287,
-0.07197736203670502,
-0.22541044652462006,
-0.5039011240005493,
-0.5402892231941223,
0.4588346481323242,
-0.5203183889389038,
-0.5652704834938049,
-1.0333304405212402,
-0.06209731474518776,
-0.4177303612232208,
1.2227752208709717,
0.173244908452034,
0.11923667043447495,
0.015916883945465088,
-0.24536144733428955,
-0.03716357424855232,
-0.49602770805358887,
-0.5393304228782654,
-0.18560193479061127,
0.545905590057373,
0.43131718039512634,
0.9180516004562378,
0.4740765392780304,
0.2098405510187149,
0.21659857034683228,
-0.07501223683357239,
0.011401363648474216,
-0.8224970698356628,
0.43375563621520996,
-0.14985382556915283,
-0.7061038613319397,
-0.16709628701210022,
0.149538055062294,
0.6136308908462524,
0.4314146935939789,
0.1255735456943512,
0.19716022908687592,
0.04855184629559517,
0.44873109459877014,
-0.8204145431518555,
-0.265625923871994,
-0.83839350938797,
-0.04449545592069626,
-0.2912154495716095,
0.019425472244620323,
-0.39281895756721497,
-0.33334892988204956,
-0.004172608256340027,
-0.2628622055053711,
0.1164683997631073,
0.19271887838840485,
0.2074917107820511,
0.427386611700058,
-0.4877103567123413,
-0.3582829535007477,
-0.7967576384544373,
1.1226098537445068,
-0.4815906584262848,
0.21805588901042938,
0.4657714366912842,
0.20299988985061646,
-0.11841035634279251,
-0.2270120531320572,
-0.6403483748435974,
-0.4161006510257721,
0.38633105158805847,
-0.13310497999191284,
-0.5629293918609619,
0.214121013879776,
0.5127283930778503,
0.22467456758022308,
-0.3836189806461334,
0.633647620677948,
-0.15138228237628937,
-0.32914265990257263,
0.6392924785614014,
0.32038408517837524,
-0.025452392175793648,
0.02099374681711197,
-0.38928335905075073,
0.007809788454324007,
-0.6460698246955872,
0.14535951614379883,
0.7056610584259033,
0.4043098986148834,
0.11812157928943634,
0.6704493761062622,
0.07877945899963379,
0.5655989050865173,
-0.020705461502075195,
-0.09594370424747467,
-0.07878153026103973,
0.30047398805618286,
-0.2023933231830597,
-0.02607979252934456,
0.6195249557495117,
0.7077811360359192,
0.36994510889053345,
-0.1314672976732254,
-0.2820989787578583,
0.4144832193851471,
0.2796001434326172,
-0.533302903175354,
0.2137444168329239,
0.18097932636737823,
-0.02193400450050831,
-0.4428955316543579,
-0.5623922348022461,
-0.7315493822097778,
-0.8175514936447144,
-0.27724456787109375,
0.35145992040634155,
-0.27142059803009033,
-0.12763458490371704,
-0.28610530495643616,
0.01947230100631714,
0.21611520648002625,
0.28199291229248047,
-0.42397549748420715,
0.45757856965065,
0.6536709070205688,
0.6342597603797913,
-0.3976067900657654,
0.07566684484481812,
-0.5854718089103699,
0.007275775074958801,
-0.3069423735141754,
0.42547354102134705,
-0.6090079545974731,
-0.45791420340538025,
-0.04455969110131264,
-0.30161550641059875,
0.15491683781147003,
-0.4175971448421478,
1.008862018585205,
-0.46549469232559204,
-0.19431693851947784,
-0.1577526330947876,
-0.48760372400283813,
-0.39957231283187866,
0.17655916512012482,
-0.29421576857566833,
0.9129006266593933,
0.07747791707515717,
-0.5890468955039978,
0.1822066605091095,
-0.2024591863155365,
-0.18848736584186554,
0.02172981947660446,
-0.3122520446777344,
-0.31174641847610474,
0.27947476506233215,
-0.1278209686279297,
0.3800690174102783,
-0.3359551429748535,
0.2781427204608917,
-0.7081403732299805,
-0.4238477647304535,
0.3705918788909912,
-0.7391713261604309,
0.6653520464897156,
0.2223537564277649,
-0.6985380053520203,
-0.03491930291056633,
-0.5397809147834778,
-0.08925537019968033,
-0.08212561905384064,
0.042025379836559296,
-0.38566824793815613,
0.03263414651155472,
0.19249343872070312,
0.37586700916290283,
0.014173462986946106,
-0.6281877756118774,
-0.5886964201927185,
-0.2999945878982544,
0.20937664806842804,
1.4532538652420044,
-0.5071710348129272,
0.36841532588005066,
-0.7686541676521301,
0.6927157640457153,
-0.06706477701663971,
0.18056218326091766,
0.48762863874435425,
-0.5478523969650269,
-0.7156246304512024,
0.0066152396611869335,
-0.3023211658000946,
0.6399030089378357,
-0.2471866011619568,
0.3908328115940094,
-0.2102433294057846,
-0.6039818525314331,
-0.23765929043293,
0.11814824491739273,
0.4810810387134552,
0.7359079718589783,
0.2395900934934616,
0.05694239214062691,
-0.5215365290641785,
-0.9491549730300903,
-0.5655180811882019,
-0.23784975707530975,
0.08196619153022766,
0.5652993321418762,
0.5110980272293091,
0.05154397711157799,
0.8317676782608032,
-0.14899814128875732,
-0.141962930560112,
0.07790178805589676,
0.058261215686798096,
-0.042754627764225006,
0.32108744978904724,
0.543743371963501,
-1.1297804117202759,
-0.4521123170852661,
-0.43339306116104126,
-0.2328685075044632,
-0.23859742283821106,
0.3999941647052765,
-0.027855701744556427,
0.37382498383522034,
0.35495173931121826,
-0.03961474075913429,
0.6052122116088867,
0.6534925699234009,
-0.10694172233343124,
0.44308778643608093,
0.3696906864643097,
0.10055632144212723,
-0.5273876190185547,
-0.09080000966787338,
0.25984033942222595,
-0.38209912180900574,
-0.7401844263076782,
-0.04403676465153694,
-0.17766274511814117,
0.3187617361545563,
-0.5526776909828186,
0.4718572795391083,
0.05830688029527664,
0.227789044380188,
-0.3787272870540619,
0.11706787347793579,
-0.35226160287857056,
0.2241916060447693,
-0.003433721140027046,
0.5643762350082397,
0.507808268070221,
-0.7148007154464722,
0.43011942505836487,
-0.26132920384407043,
-0.20856894552707672,
1.0577300786972046,
-0.18521268665790558,
0.18612657487392426,
-0.35329484939575195,
0.12421522289514542,
-1.3130532503128052,
-0.09393095970153809,
0.4637413024902344,
-0.4977348744869232,
0.15771473944187164,
-0.14988477528095245,
-0.20946528017520905,
-0.3611200749874115,
-0.5822803378105164,
0.3534526824951172,
0.644706666469574,
-0.3087330758571625,
0.7393380403518677,
0.6160342693328857,
-0.060603510588407516,
-0.9841310977935791,
-0.8810039758682251,
-0.032052118331193924,
-0.48852306604385376,
-0.4465691149234772,
0.14588624238967896,
-0.34559008479118347,
-0.539924681186676,
-0.3696284294128418,
-0.3581456243991852,
-0.06023937836289406,
0.054297130554914474,
0.8315515518188477,
0.11488322913646698,
0.12970158457756042,
0.03889761492609978,
-0.03601228445768356,
0.10223495960235596,
0.32998308539390564,
-0.0035021090880036354,
0.3253268599510193,
-0.09483472257852554,
-0.30800315737724304,
-0.09142766147851944,
0.45220524072647095,
0.5978258848190308,
0.5299245119094849,
0.4986136257648468,
0.6245875954627991,
-0.5422914624214172,
-0.22085919976234436,
-0.9543154835700989,
-0.031998880207538605,
-0.48952627182006836,
0.42817172408103943,
-0.294526606798172,
-1.115648627281189,
0.5196676254272461,
0.17903360724449158,
0.08689089119434357,
0.4243444800376892,
0.5336799621582031,
0.0434674434363842,
1.1862493753433228,
0.6749805212020874,
-0.20620429515838623,
0.24388523399829865,
0.3469514846801758,
0.18864035606384277,
-0.8146377205848694,
-0.22591686248779297,
-0.8760632276535034,
-0.2068554311990738,
-0.8029282689094543,
-0.4222641587257385,
0.5334559082984924,
-0.3678356409072876,
-0.5209752321243286,
-0.2053450644016266,
-0.4006909728050232,
0.521610677242279,
0.2851997911930084,
0.37501031160354614,
0.22471462190151215,
0.09926047176122665,
0.1577741503715515,
-0.5229454636573792,
-0.3985687494277954,
-0.5681341290473938,
1.3258275985717773,
0.5334468483924866,
0.9264063835144043,
0.13578230142593384,
0.21851232647895813,
0.38200893998146057,
0.5985099077224731,
-1.0381543636322021,
0.6491252183914185,
-0.23026786744594574,
-0.8752003908157349,
-0.3334902822971344,
-0.4984707534313202,
-0.40553513169288635,
-0.017389796674251556,
0.10819561779499054,
-0.7496235370635986,
0.18278785049915314,
0.07742174714803696,
-0.4032731056213379,
0.5456812977790833,
-0.3090168237686157,
0.2824135422706604,
-0.2193244844675064,
-0.4784121811389923,
-0.04395827651023865,
-0.6873299479484558,
0.40643787384033203,
-0.27750810980796814,
0.6032997369766235,
-0.4995250403881073,
-0.51572585105896,
0.8602011203765869,
0.02083609811961651,
1.0417951345443726,
-0.15334078669548035,
-0.39099782705307007,
0.12543757259845734,
0.3073963224887848,
0.5722630023956299,
-0.19809620082378387,
-0.42512235045433044,
0.14699988067150116,
-0.4569658637046814,
-0.3319872319698334,
-0.18953634798526764,
0.8697678446769714,
-0.6603842973709106,
-0.6959462761878967,
-0.5467958450317383,
-0.7862221598625183,
-0.4671356678009033,
0.04428964480757713,
0.4593523144721985,
0.003859681775793433,
-0.2032848298549652,
-0.07725861668586731,
0.9014491438865662,
-0.21122139692306519,
0.18681129813194275,
0.5806256532669067,
0.005981228780001402,
-0.1784966140985489,
0.6303690075874329,
0.3976415693759918,
0.5044651031494141,
0.008630077354609966,
0.07530365884304047,
-0.5201870203018188,
-0.7151544094085693,
-0.22589853405952454,
-0.02645469829440117,
-0.9654051661491394,
-0.1587579846382141,
-0.6752938628196716,
-0.11948851495981216,
-0.6783186197280884,
-0.2699143886566162,
-0.17709988355636597,
-0.26257970929145813,
-0.21761469542980194,
-0.10927088558673859,
0.5580062866210938,
0.7402107119560242,
-0.42384234070777893,
0.2776269316673279,
-0.21886582672595978,
0.28200358152389526,
0.35091039538383484,
0.1893317699432373,
-0.2918799817562103,
-1.196549415588379,
0.2854347229003906,
0.1527368426322937,
-0.1378820687532425,
-0.8898844122886658,
0.3364700675010681,
-0.015306814573705196,
0.5861161351203918,
0.3176898956298828,
0.46064993739128113,
0.5009410977363586,
-0.27533066272735596,
0.6341994404792786,
0.06865536421537399,
-0.8674075603485107,
0.371081680059433,
-0.3002548813819885,
-0.09819850325584412,
0.5310953855514526,
1.0016803741455078,
-0.4089317321777344,
-0.7433208227157593,
-0.4099747836589813,
-0.8213552832603455,
0.8739989995956421,
-0.055948857218027115,
0.44036799669265747,
0.1776115596294403,
0.30274397134780884,
0.14870218932628632,
0.1689666509628296,
-1.0278584957122803,
-0.7297623753547668,
0.0711807832121849,
-0.057241957634687424,
-0.30344152450561523,
-0.6048538684844971,
-0.5982125997543335,
-0.17557671666145325,
0.6051484942436218,
0.005746225826442242,
-0.018456120043992996,
-0.03533446043729782,
-0.17624333500862122,
-0.38200169801712036,
0.3512078821659088,
0.6131316423416138,
0.5408627390861511,
-0.17126305401325226,
0.2922629714012146,
0.40013715624809265,
-0.54146409034729,
0.28261369466781616,
0.0767122432589531,
-0.15143239498138428,
-0.12823861837387085,
-0.11178775876760483,
0.6748012900352478,
0.04954337701201439,
-0.7525442242622375,
0.7641429901123047,
0.043626587837934494,
-0.07670833170413971,
-0.5240788459777832,
0.23177199065685272,
-0.384635865688324,
0.17526954412460327,
0.38342127203941345,
0.16464924812316895,
0.3499538004398346,
-0.22339409589767456,
0.07082017511129379,
0.5833517909049988,
-0.545553982257843,
0.06360725313425064,
0.6178232431411743,
-0.05010272562503815,
-0.11339742690324783,
0.4742513597011566,
-0.026659617200493813,
-0.6123958230018616,
0.5367113947868347,
0.5731047987937927,
0.689283549785614,
-0.5395258665084839,
0.12498915195465088,
0.2170570194721222,
0.48748672008514404,
0.22898946702480316,
0.13628032803535461,
-0.062332723289728165,
-0.7983829975128174,
-0.28258442878723145,
-0.6170474886894226,
-0.7218518853187561,
0.27706849575042725,
-0.7160900831222534,
0.11489178240299225,
-0.6522261500358582,
-0.2954407334327698,
-0.031186837702989578,
-0.0873621478676796,
-0.5289759635925293,
0.25975584983825684,
0.7063474655151367,
0.7436048984527588,
-1.0633713006973267,
0.30043545365333557,
0.2742829918861389,
0.23322948813438416,
-0.5062546133995056,
-0.1901613175868988,
0.48232805728912354,
-1.1853582859039307,
0.5354136824607849,
0.3719152808189392,
-0.46791359782218933,
-0.02276425249874592,
-0.9463441371917725,
-0.456213116645813,
0.550960898399353,
0.5685142278671265,
-0.6178099513053894,
0.0025690505281090736,
0.35288554430007935,
0.3363622725009918,
-0.30590981245040894,
0.4480455219745636,
0.7481096982955933,
0.688300371170044,
0.2427360713481903,
-0.8411901593208313,
0.21483126282691956,
0.0799664631485939,
0.07978799194097519,
-0.17641396820545197,
-0.4805116653442383,
0.8796107769012451,
-0.190349280834198,
-0.1513938307762146,
0.019547924399375916,
0.236822247505188,
0.26541590690612793,
0.3963109254837036,
0.6706749200820923,
0.5269268751144409,
0.6997452974319458,
-0.09719745069742203,
1.0642998218536377,
0.14085417985916138,
-0.017260782420635223,
1.116808295249939,
-0.31087151169776917,
0.5209531784057617,
0.35212674736976624,
-0.17657315731048584,
0.2004835158586502,
0.5453994870185852,
0.19818416237831116,
0.18636468052864075,
0.44167613983154297,
-0.789146900177002,
-0.5345471501350403,
-0.5112698674201965,
-0.35784056782722473,
0.33297762274742126,
0.7317042946815491,
-0.3373759686946869,
-0.3134349286556244,
0.25563740730285645,
0.3395922780036926,
0.2127140313386917,
-0.6634110808372498,
0.39085525274276733,
0.218150332570076,
-0.433316707611084,
0.46626147627830505,
0.10353485494852066,
1.1117730140686035,
-0.36691752076148987,
0.33685502409935,
0.21180123090744019,
0.017674623057246208,
-0.3118641674518585,
-0.9106450080871582,
0.2219119817018509,
0.20432434976100922,
-0.09260890632867813,
-0.13243651390075684,
0.5835463404655457,
-0.08579584956169128,
-0.1782933920621872,
0.4009380340576172,
0.22444862127304077,
0.26686203479766846,
-0.3541673421859741,
-0.8540683388710022,
0.2505424916744232,
0.07052849233150482,
-0.41130656003952026,
0.33708518743515015,
0.3176422715187073,
0.0786176398396492,
0.7014651894569397,
0.6051158905029297,
0.07642365247011185,
0.3297852873802185,
-0.14182454347610474,
0.8389343619346619,
-0.4562733471393585,
-0.13697943091392517,
-1.0468772649765015,
0.30677247047424316,
0.07134705036878586,
-0.3258218467235565,
0.708250105381012,
0.3955872058868408,
0.8563255071640015,
0.39845263957977295,
0.8492154479026794,
0.11677344143390656,
0.7101718187332153,
-0.25510430335998535,
0.3535917401313782,
-0.31699278950691223,
0.17874668538570404,
-0.1861559897661209,
-0.7503123879432678,
-0.5693961977958679,
0.5676113963127136,
-0.8125169277191162,
0.3530707061290741,
0.3452991545200348,
1.0864156484603882,
0.24929092824459076,
0.11767713725566864,
0.570125162601471,
0.4862717092037201,
0.2942769229412079,
0.7073416709899902,
0.8988980650901794,
-0.2086070328950882,
0.7367419600486755,
-0.45150256156921387,
-0.5167754292488098,
-0.19976398348808289,
-0.8873470425605774,
-0.5788841843605042,
-0.24123308062553406,
-0.22192706167697906,
-0.6891184449195862,
-0.004288797732442617,
0.7484611868858337,
0.6777026057243347,
-0.7923460602760315,
-0.1580958366394043,
-0.028712671250104904,
0.23879066109657288,
0.2428787499666214,
-0.26256901025772095,
-0.09420125931501389,
-0.12019287049770355,
-1.0812034606933594,
0.1735438108444214,
0.20433205366134644,
0.2061004787683487,
-0.1765492558479309,
-0.18211793899536133,
0.006699782330542803,
0.12051616609096527,
0.37716397643089294,
0.3541199266910553,
-0.747052013874054,
-0.2775823175907135,
-0.18882735073566437,
-0.3795638084411621,
-0.07208474725484848,
0.4277971684932709,
-0.5936638116836548,
0.3820086121559143,
0.14292465150356293,
0.44964221119880676,
0.1764323115348816,
-0.20674030482769012,
0.39272522926330566,
-0.5235640406608582,
0.16187334060668945,
0.8114566802978516,
0.02569601871073246,
0.19334755837917328,
-0.507401168346405,
0.2858172059059143,
0.1550530195236206,
-0.6850558519363403,
-1.1928895711898804,
0.43367108702659607,
-0.876004695892334,
-0.12458816915750504,
1.2391259670257568,
-0.07286800444126129,
-0.25957125425338745,
-0.43047451972961426,
-0.12921079993247986,
0.08151781558990479,
-0.5204459428787231,
0.3719039857387543,
0.6842212677001953,
-0.24527333676815033,
0.011164503172039986,
-0.719169557094574,
0.5562487840652466,
0.6665627956390381,
-0.13233675062656403,
0.22729678452014923,
0.684670090675354,
0.39034414291381836,
0.06650988757610321,
0.5486553311347961,
-0.11619465798139572,
0.2895410358905792,
-0.12424322217702866,
-0.24382035434246063,
-0.010771714150905609,
-0.13619334995746613,
-0.7099949717521667,
0.1799437701702118,
0.15005381405353546,
0.11840768158435822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11399v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11399v2 | k-SemStamp: A Clustering-Based Semantic Watermark for Detection of Machine-Generated Text | 2024-02-17T22:50:38 | 2024-06-08T04:24:27 | Abe Bohan Hou, Jingyu Zhang, Yichen Wang, Daniel Khashabi, Tianxing He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CY, cs.LG | Recent watermarked generation algorithms inject detectable signatures during
language generation to facilitate post-hoc detection. While token-level
watermarks are vulnerable to paraphrase attacks, SemStamp (Hou et al., 2023)
applies watermark on the semantic representation of sentences and demonstrates
promising robustness. SemStamp employs locality-sensitive hashing (LSH) to
partition the semantic space with arbitrary hyperplanes, which results in a
suboptimal tradeoff between robustness and speed. We propose k-SemStamp, a
simple yet effective enhancement of SemStamp, utilizing k-means clustering as
an alternative of LSH to partition the embedding space with awareness of
inherent semantic structure. Experimental results indicate that k-SemStamp
saliently improves its robustness and sampling efficiency while preserving the
generation quality, advancing a more effective tool for machine-generated text
detection. | [
-0.4153083264827728,
-0.7837385535240173,
0.7013354897499084,
0.038780175149440765,
-0.7785269618034363,
0.06163087114691734,
0.06279689073562622,
-0.30268412828445435,
0.42789214849472046,
0.7189934253692627,
-0.46198755502700806,
-0.6506333947181702,
-0.9518507719039917,
0.04736308380961418,
-0.6505174040794373,
0.8404121994972229,
0.23290680348873138,
-0.42228904366493225,
-0.3587094247341156,
-0.14302478730678558,
-0.29953932762145996,
-0.557881236076355,
-0.2692861258983612,
0.01456053089350462,
0.4344533383846283,
0.3021452724933624,
0.5409249067306519,
0.8439729809761047,
0.5969166159629822,
0.2976749539375305,
-0.14866746962070465,
0.20001369714736938,
-0.0545678474009037,
0.7790359258651733,
-0.10019629448652267,
-0.1292281448841095,
0.07569622993469238,
-0.30145543813705444,
0.7502052187919617,
0.3549588918685913,
0.2832319736480713,
0.048594120889902115,
0.09573766589164734,
0.6764391660690308,
-1.1636559963226318,
-0.03115701861679554,
-0.9980489611625671,
-0.10910455137491226,
-0.5037932991981506,
-0.4184728264808655,
-0.29766058921813965,
-0.06583818048238754,
-0.19007812440395355,
-0.29206374287605286,
0.10364939272403717,
-0.024687079712748528,
0.9427294135093689,
0.5946097373962402,
-0.3693240284919739,
-0.34424763917922974,
-0.33192744851112366,
0.7484602928161621,
-0.7858197689056396,
0.22583125531673431,
0.42799198627471924,
0.3569554388523102,
-0.25014498829841614,
-0.8488782644271851,
-0.5494481325149536,
0.293988436460495,
0.0209304541349411,
0.011813001707196236,
-0.04179847612977028,
-0.2978873550891876,
0.24987077713012695,
0.18963727355003357,
-0.47418734431266785,
-0.17232078313827515,
0.13259688019752502,
-0.5121288895606995,
0.29660192131996155,
0.10321301221847534,
0.5769307613372803,
-0.33103635907173157,
-0.5070555210113525,
-0.14680582284927368,
-0.6699093580245972,
-0.17985185980796814,
0.2399737387895584,
0.4308379292488098,
0.27286496758461,
0.5013094544410706,
-0.5779517292976379,
0.5359587073326111,
-0.24812158942222595,
0.004063706379383802,
0.04495217651128769,
-0.15844760835170746,
-0.08723100274801254,
0.09236854314804077,
0.6589323878288269,
0.4878588020801544,
-0.1631433069705963,
-0.08615168184041977,
-0.03752830997109413,
0.5347037315368652,
0.05499818176031113,
-1.0910781621932983,
-0.014289065264165401,
0.07297217100858688,
-0.37887272238731384,
-0.5502681732177734,
0.2610878646373749,
-0.8371543288230896,
-0.6089085936546326,
-0.17718857526779175,
0.6284985542297363,
-0.2568078339099884,
-0.061184875667095184,
0.12025996297597885,
-0.5401524305343628,
0.1756437122821808,
-0.06489744037389755,
-0.7573502063751221,
0.33205828070640564,
0.808259129524231,
0.6558961272239685,
-0.5584119558334351,
-0.22860682010650635,
-0.713832437992096,
0.5164734125137329,
-0.19499191641807556,
1.3461828231811523,
-0.7525898218154907,
-0.3465055227279663,
-0.05000942200422287,
0.08354279398918152,
0.2029983401298523,
-0.7095891237258911,
0.4175594747066498,
-0.593032956123352,
0.16352739930152893,
-0.45643970370292664,
-0.7311782240867615,
0.24785085022449493,
0.20393431186676025,
-0.5600206851959229,
1.1792709827423096,
0.09081471711397171,
-1.0622957944869995,
0.8265771865844727,
-0.5277302265167236,
-0.485034704208374,
0.24295887351036072,
-0.13616631925106049,
-0.7444944977760315,
-0.08990603685379028,
0.4233553409576416,
0.6086286902427673,
0.1370447874069214,
0.14784234762191772,
-0.45623278617858887,
-0.229725182056427,
0.21487411856651306,
-0.13572846353054047,
0.47265833616256714,
0.24942390620708466,
-0.43238863348960876,
0.0550951212644577,
-0.8488677740097046,
0.49344614148139954,
0.1764916628599167,
-0.44305408000946045,
-0.6698919534683228,
-0.09980759769678116,
0.12044018507003784,
0.3454766571521759,
0.4006480872631073,
-0.5623962879180908,
-0.37988632917404175,
-0.25042009353637695,
0.45356109738349915,
0.7861006259918213,
0.4868696928024292,
0.36606618762016296,
-0.19194826483726501,
0.2877233326435089,
0.2789573073387146,
-0.07141435146331787,
-0.2564709484577179,
-0.4932536482810974,
-0.7893568873405457,
-0.42821428179740906,
0.5369522571563721,
0.32996249198913574,
-0.9068597555160522,
0.6828576326370239,
-0.2148822546005249,
-0.611677885055542,
-0.2658190131187439,
0.03981053829193115,
0.10724586993455887,
0.2714945375919342,
0.45419952273368835,
-0.14773701131343842,
-0.44851917028427124,
-0.9547899961471558,
-0.8173046708106995,
0.13735578954219818,
-0.06482946127653122,
0.06378386169672012,
0.676064670085907,
-0.24971845746040344,
0.8381614089012146,
-0.6181820631027222,
0.03178398311138153,
0.09054945409297943,
0.17246262729167938,
-0.3344114124774933,
0.5089151859283447,
0.4258030652999878,
-0.7210719585418701,
-0.8315483927726746,
-0.1304301768541336,
-0.4435688853263855,
-0.6520067453384399,
0.16540056467056274,
-0.3004305362701416,
0.24411384761333466,
0.788074791431427,
-0.4919820725917816,
0.5269885659217834,
0.3797879219055176,
-0.8164966702461243,
0.3494846522808075,
-0.04857514053583145,
0.40854525566101074,
-1.2609668970108032,
0.0679749920964241,
-0.6250779628753662,
-0.48896491527557373,
-0.3956476151943207,
0.2962343096733093,
0.18850421905517578,
-0.3922642171382904,
-0.27895116806030273,
0.31846264004707336,
-0.14722636342048645,
-0.20299217104911804,
-0.8141055107116699,
0.09520788490772247,
0.0839991420507431,
0.2671898603439331,
-0.011342030018568039,
0.5271531343460083,
0.30238258838653564,
-0.5528516173362732,
-0.08807706832885742,
-0.1359655261039734,
-0.1896807849407196,
0.9847022891044617,
-0.5151463150978088,
0.27363717555999756,
-0.15525585412979126,
0.14239627122879028,
-0.7257123589515686,
-0.07130725681781769,
0.03674303740262985,
-0.5827071666717529,
0.0390097014605999,
0.010881580412387848,
-0.663993239402771,
0.08493857085704803,
-0.5550485253334045,
0.026930207386612892,
0.4587291181087494,
-0.4278055429458618,
0.2888532876968384,
0.4206141531467438,
-0.3378430902957916,
-0.18747079372406006,
-0.458379864692688,
0.31147903203964233,
-0.4589937627315521,
-0.5458005666732788,
0.6262201070785522,
-0.023463768884539604,
-0.00778844952583313,
0.15138475596904755,
-0.12401048839092255,
-0.24358628690242767,
0.2606649100780487,
0.32936978340148926,
-0.14532379806041718,
0.019651412963867188,
-0.038427576422691345,
0.4320029020309448,
-0.7472900748252869,
-0.23733912408351898,
-0.1940412074327469,
0.7050941586494446,
0.03706296160817146,
-0.4063698947429657,
-0.45973435044288635,
0.7755590677261353,
0.6829574704170227,
-0.19639064371585846,
0.5482525825500488,
0.6833080649375916,
-0.6332240700721741,
-0.3374461531639099,
-0.28776270151138306,
-0.38381287455558777,
-0.45234790444374084,
0.09082891792058945,
-0.19753240048885345,
-1.2338225841522217,
0.2264932245016098,
-0.2910520136356354,
-0.117286317050457,
0.6940692067146301,
0.4646056890487671,
-0.1594686061143875,
0.942386269569397,
0.5002896189689636,
-0.24096864461898804,
0.561604917049408,
0.25463518500328064,
0.19828546047210693,
-0.48382920026779175,
0.10892920196056366,
-0.9717913269996643,
-0.1729845255613327,
-0.4954039454460144,
-0.444994181394577,
0.09075316786766052,
0.12072531133890152,
-0.2834564745426178,
0.5629766583442688,
-0.7336439490318298,
0.5847060680389404,
0.869543731212616,
0.07917112857103348,
0.2216538041830063,
0.18524189293384552,
0.06661146134138107,
-0.3837648630142212,
-0.4599994122982025,
-0.5540505647659302,
0.7675849199295044,
-0.22156010568141937,
0.08797555416822433,
-0.18804283440113068,
1.0016201734542847,
0.7302336096763611,
-0.2503518760204315,
-0.277791291475296,
0.6728760004043579,
0.10083401948213577,
-0.4659026563167572,
-0.3871232569217682,
-0.24149376153945923,
-1.066420316696167,
0.31876140832901,
-0.31371060013771057,
-0.5518701076507568,
-0.19235222041606903,
-0.2178158313035965,
0.03592052310705185,
0.15813957154750824,
-0.6248204708099365,
0.8070995807647705,
0.41189107298851013,
-0.11149699985980988,
-0.23204120993614197,
-0.5226532220840454,
-0.30559930205345154,
-0.17550261318683624,
0.2116377353668213,
-0.3347831070423126,
-0.3328741788864136,
0.7988833785057068,
-0.983955979347229,
0.6020786762237549,
-0.45556458830833435,
0.0782625824213028,
0.5291401743888855,
0.25869160890579224,
0.708656907081604,
-0.3023229241371155,
0.22977884113788605,
-0.04226566478610039,
0.21973128616809845,
-0.6386786103248596,
-0.6148721575737,
0.707145094871521,
-0.2252110242843628,
-0.3217329978942871,
-0.21256761252880096,
-0.30683237314224243,
-0.07996869832277298,
0.51132732629776,
0.28466206789016724,
0.0998014360666275,
0.2490631639957428,
0.4024737477302551,
0.28758564591407776,
-0.18776646256446838,
0.5313334465026855,
0.3856193423271179,
0.06147386133670807,
-0.7078221440315247,
1.083151936531067,
0.013555103912949562,
0.23302032053470612,
0.3609485626220703,
0.34257638454437256,
-0.3298080265522003,
-0.4339388310909271,
-0.2856366038322449,
-0.056949399411678314,
-0.9004659652709961,
-0.4031122326850891,
-0.8231658935546875,
-0.1428908258676529,
-0.38852134346961975,
-0.46767038106918335,
-0.20188643038272858,
-0.5921127796173096,
0.13129064440727234,
-0.00676394160836935,
0.4367186427116394,
0.2981993556022644,
-0.05190292000770569,
0.4103220999240875,
-0.6254090070724487,
0.3620067834854126,
0.4817728102207184,
0.17072226107120514,
-0.34404096007347107,
-0.4284214377403259,
-0.07753682136535645,
-0.23546531796455383,
-0.331630140542984,
-0.6346412897109985,
0.12719841301441193,
0.04369265213608742,
0.15163084864616394,
0.4287863075733185,
0.2943482995033264,
0.5884259343147278,
-0.505837619304657,
1.0355063676834106,
-0.028134537860751152,
-1.1150096654891968,
0.8566615581512451,
-0.3856050968170166,
0.5710844397544861,
0.6522681713104248,
-0.10984236001968384,
-0.5691646337509155,
-0.8248414397239685,
-0.7894445657730103,
-0.8334610462188721,
0.28313523530960083,
0.43182113766670227,
0.16461694240570068,
-0.29431435465812683,
0.0625670850276947,
0.06723398715257645,
0.23803773522377014,
-0.7368802428245544,
-0.07585706561803818,
-0.03321651369333267,
-0.280617892742157,
0.3087390661239624,
-0.5569419860839844,
0.2683436870574951,
0.10236270725727081,
0.8158854246139526,
0.01840292103588581,
0.23761233687400818,
0.14512303471565247,
-0.09798171371221542,
0.18604645133018494,
0.4498043656349182,
0.49790531396865845,
0.019108081236481667,
0.1694084256887436,
0.7515877485275269,
0.20391830801963806,
-0.5315850377082825,
0.09910890460014343,
-0.14357011020183563,
-0.501823902130127,
0.30014318227767944,
0.5348950028419495,
0.2301197499036789,
0.20214468240737915,
-0.5392853021621704,
0.6154721975326538,
0.25573569536209106,
-0.15272878110408783,
0.25843408703804016,
0.08479095250368118,
0.1855829656124115,
0.1840846985578537,
0.1401427537202835,
-0.10774651169776917,
0.37364017963409424,
-0.062185946851968765,
0.39148464798927307,
0.379265159368515,
-0.5167738199234009,
-0.10476038604974747,
0.7210922837257385,
0.046768903732299805,
-0.27247342467308044,
0.013220672495663166,
-0.18109281361103058,
-0.7030076384544373,
0.6342226266860962,
0.652863621711731,
0.8902189135551453,
-0.26880642771720886,
0.09495851397514343,
0.3154575228691101,
0.2827395498752594,
0.11859080940485,
0.45837143063545227,
-0.5822764039039612,
-0.6451197266578674,
-0.13323849439620972,
-0.6483490467071533,
-0.20289434492588043,
0.10437462478876114,
-0.37315309047698975,
0.2560533583164215,
-0.45528852939605713,
-0.26875928044319153,
0.12811483442783356,
-0.10778316855430603,
-0.17669932544231415,
0.23248273134231567,
-0.0024631123524159193,
0.5220866799354553,
-0.9327480792999268,
0.470567524433136,
0.6162953972816467,
0.05395312234759331,
-0.2090151011943817,
-0.03497552499175072,
-0.15126723051071167,
-0.6011877059936523,
0.12691138684749603,
0.4745250940322876,
-0.05686763674020767,
-0.05169260874390602,
-0.679268479347229,
-0.8224924206733704,
1.0410914421081543,
0.1286591738462448,
-0.04371483996510506,
0.6096521019935608,
0.6127164363861084,
0.33760371804237366,
-0.00566397700458765,
-0.5967950820922852,
0.4516350328922272,
0.5171302556991577,
-0.2194717973470688,
-0.31454890966415405,
0.4883933365345001,
-0.36167842149734497,
0.18670757114887238,
0.6947034597396851,
-0.3070894479751587,
0.3152500092983246,
0.3063691556453705,
-0.4251156747341156,
0.09883283078670502,
0.5272902846336365,
0.5627098083496094,
0.5710625648498535,
0.6652937531471252,
0.8455958962440491,
0.6696887016296387,
-0.06375105679035187,
0.6259710192680359,
-0.4442073702812195,
0.11443394422531128,
1.001301646232605,
-0.23075562715530396,
1.0392088890075684,
0.8698307871818542,
-0.19701765477657318,
0.5318899750709534,
0.38990554213523865,
0.07823590189218521,
0.8324542045593262,
0.19798585772514343,
-0.5649734139442444,
-0.385385662317276,
-0.38038966059684753,
-0.4720533788204193,
0.19786293804645538,
0.2758772373199463,
-0.45292505621910095,
-0.40147045254707336,
-0.18369321525096893,
0.24781829118728638,
0.3536664545536041,
-0.15679523348808289,
0.8622304201126099,
0.054810211062431335,
-0.44397109746932983,
0.08902982622385025,
0.19145914912223816,
0.6560385227203369,
-0.39534953236579895,
0.1038116067647934,
0.11570443958044052,
-0.07316164672374725,
-0.15291844308376312,
-0.557303786277771,
0.5490555763244629,
-0.0014442949322983623,
-0.210149347782135,
-0.19684523344039917,
1.4947510957717896,
-0.32128340005874634,
-0.3414376974105835,
0.027012240141630173,
0.33463889360427856,
0.3060373365879059,
-0.5457279682159424,
-0.5724348425865173,
0.040030304342508316,
-0.2611147463321686,
-0.12057015299797058,
0.3314584791660309,
0.7388554811477661,
-0.09251806139945984,
0.3836843967437744,
0.8550204634666443,
-0.13926814496517181,
0.05110158026218414,
0.0899273008108139,
0.6704831123352051,
-0.7494974732398987,
-0.7805259823799133,
-1.058962345123291,
0.3512686789035797,
-0.44249340891838074,
-0.0797186866402626,
0.8404693603515625,
0.5578303337097168,
0.6000490784645081,
-0.13445155322551727,
0.877642035484314,
-0.05226367339491844,
0.47827136516571045,
-0.5250158309936523,
0.8517614603042603,
-0.30963024497032166,
-0.1526719629764557,
-0.7321383953094482,
-0.9545636773109436,
-0.5489740371704102,
0.21944020688533783,
-0.13894377648830414,
-0.1102624386548996,
0.8135777711868286,
0.8954179883003235,
0.20263923704624176,
-0.0818709135055542,
0.6287670731544495,
-0.3617285192012787,
0.25660204887390137,
0.2610938251018524,
1.0134958028793335,
-0.4691378176212311,
0.528457760810852,
-0.2604471445083618,
-0.04454633593559265,
-0.17197518050670624,
-0.9790248870849609,
-0.8812471628189087,
-0.8543722629547119,
-0.47998136281967163,
-0.30522048473358154,
-0.24729716777801514,
0.45249834656715393,
0.5993687510490417,
-0.8141373991966248,
0.3985380530357361,
-0.23616047203540802,
0.07556086778640747,
-0.021574873477220535,
-0.2853640615940094,
0.7230238318443298,
-0.5387105345726013,
-0.4094139337539673,
0.19772961735725403,
0.70473712682724,
0.3482986092567444,
0.07042430341243744,
0.1324489712715149,
0.15001632273197174,
0.2456468641757965,
0.734150767326355,
-0.12132004648447037,
-0.2956027090549469,
-0.32743850350379944,
-0.1529635190963745,
-0.21496011316776276,
-0.2840661406517029,
0.7818244695663452,
-0.5735100507736206,
0.24151572585105896,
0.6109346151351929,
0.8612907528877258,
0.49611735343933105,
-0.09086831659078598,
0.06861505657434464,
-0.7304365634918213,
0.1895989626646042,
-0.05913768336176872,
0.3611382842063904,
0.3323015868663788,
-0.31117716431617737,
0.3402036428451538,
0.5875368118286133,
-0.5780301690101624,
-0.9176309704780579,
0.11218127608299255,
-0.6799161434173584,
-0.5484177470207214,
1.107048749923706,
0.033309098333120346,
-0.4307345747947693,
-0.2731838822364807,
-0.3025192618370056,
0.014895006082952023,
-0.31976765394210815,
0.8337565064430237,
0.7545840740203857,
0.46227920055389404,
0.23203225433826447,
-0.3452344238758087,
0.5703414678573608,
0.5249005556106567,
-1.2074108123779297,
0.03677539899945259,
0.3997138440608978,
0.2909284234046936,
0.0743618905544281,
0.7218268513679504,
-0.347401887178421,
0.30366379022598267,
0.2692924439907074,
0.00922639574855566,
0.25313839316368103,
-0.23183830082416534,
0.023023856803774834,
0.24663124978542328,
-0.09247928857803345,
-0.475104957818985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11398v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11398v2 | Reasoning before Comparison: LLM-Enhanced Semantic Similarity Metrics for Domain Specialized Text Analysis | 2024-02-17T22:46:44 | 2024-02-20T22:23:42 | Shaochen Xu, Zihao Wu, Huaqin Zhao, Peng Shu, Zhengliang Liu, Wenxiong Liao, Sheng Li, Andrea Sikora, Tianming Liu, Xiang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this study, we leverage LLM to enhance the semantic analysis and develop
similarity metrics for texts, addressing the limitations of traditional
unsupervised NLP metrics like ROUGE and BLEU. We develop a framework where LLMs
such as GPT-4 are employed for zero-shot text identification and label
generation for radiology reports, where the labels are then used as
measurements for text similarity. By testing the proposed framework on the
MIMIC data, we find that GPT-4 generated labels can significantly improve the
semantic similarity assessment, with scores more closely aligned with clinical
ground truth than traditional NLP metrics. Our work demonstrates the
possibility of conducting semantic analysis of the text data using
semi-quantitative reasoning results by the LLMs for highly specialized domains.
While the framework is implemented for radiology report similarity analysis,
its concept can be extended to other specialized domains as well. | [
-0.10906802117824554,
-0.5379303097724915,
1.1116347312927246,
-0.10881227254867554,
-0.2996332049369812,
0.18957076966762543,
0.0716792419552803,
-0.6923546195030212,
0.2494332492351532,
0.6922367811203003,
-0.4328329265117645,
-0.9281967878341675,
-0.5665197372436523,
0.4380720853805542,
-0.3335203230381012,
0.9398857951164246,
-0.0553816594183445,
0.16616089642047882,
-0.4801790714263916,
-0.29804787039756775,
-0.2016598880290985,
-0.42746785283088684,
-0.5862470865249634,
-0.5739486813545227,
0.5608903765678406,
0.09953109920024872,
0.8038613200187683,
0.5193451046943665,
0.8761299252510071,
0.3125951290130615,
0.18823419511318207,
0.1666746288537979,
-0.2955668568611145,
-0.022484203800559044,
-0.3076157867908478,
-0.20397324860095978,
-0.799473762512207,
0.09547096490859985,
0.5064866542816162,
0.6508194804191589,
0.23587912321090698,
-0.009357609786093235,
-0.07182919979095459,
0.5405116081237793,
-0.3991040289402008,
-0.06029612943530083,
-0.6230539083480835,
0.18625596165657043,
-0.17721877992153168,
-0.7535776495933533,
-0.267245352268219,
-0.37850359082221985,
0.2615937888622284,
-0.8150321841239929,
0.30600079894065857,
0.010733300819993019,
1.1904351711273193,
0.20377877354621887,
-0.5096677541732788,
-0.453688383102417,
-0.475079745054245,
0.8295190334320068,
-0.8425191044807434,
0.2400832176208496,
0.05620643496513367,
0.16771730780601501,
0.02211013436317444,
-1.1742480993270874,
-0.7115220427513123,
-0.2877049446105957,
-0.224578395485878,
0.46916839480400085,
-0.4823203682899475,
0.06205315887928009,
0.349569171667099,
0.2776815891265869,
-0.9788023233413696,
0.05987038090825081,
-0.06401142477989197,
-0.4152938425540924,
0.458958238363266,
0.3484399914741516,
0.3440031111240387,
-0.12803612649440765,
-0.7253462076187134,
0.04594242200255394,
-0.7086172103881836,
-0.7246871590614319,
0.13005922734737396,
-0.11487806588411331,
0.2571152150630951,
0.5090870261192322,
-0.45005202293395996,
0.7196200489997864,
-0.25108128786087036,
-0.40238699316978455,
0.796782374382019,
-0.34197553992271423,
-0.4857517182826996,
0.10304346680641174,
0.853888213634491,
0.8631259799003601,
0.29697397351264954,
-0.22994185984134674,
-0.12925422191619873,
0.3046371340751648,
0.21214868128299713,
-0.7793326377868652,
-0.08384419232606888,
0.1008390486240387,
-0.6815146803855896,
-0.37009570002555847,
-0.08225960284471512,
-0.5017455816268921,
-0.27496781945228577,
-0.4284359812736511,
0.6063192486763,
-0.335835337638855,
-0.16428086161613464,
0.42800208926200867,
-0.23654426634311676,
0.5143077969551086,
0.40876901149749756,
-0.5130548477172852,
0.5395326614379883,
0.7766926884651184,
0.9053410887718201,
-0.6659185886383057,
-0.10926397144794464,
-0.18323826789855957,
0.37052014470100403,
-0.31866514682769775,
1.1509144306182861,
-0.559208869934082,
-0.44426658749580383,
-0.21235375106334686,
-0.12792670726776123,
0.08238762617111206,
-0.7118477821350098,
0.6264142990112305,
-0.49764975905418396,
0.250639945268631,
0.04353165999054909,
-0.7392812967300415,
-0.1374419629573822,
0.6986480951309204,
-0.44939714670181274,
1.0870225429534912,
0.270734041929245,
-1.0303404331207275,
0.6457241773605347,
-0.29272833466529846,
-0.33121514320373535,
0.2433193475008011,
-0.45278698205947876,
-0.6017495393753052,
-0.1464674025774002,
0.04017362743616104,
0.4696700870990753,
-0.446912556886673,
-0.011389687657356262,
-0.32167181372642517,
-0.2620813846588135,
0.2709883749485016,
-0.16731001436710358,
0.483750581741333,
0.20641224086284637,
-0.11955245584249496,
0.3198436498641968,
-0.6570674180984497,
0.4565674364566803,
-0.04178178310394287,
0.08626455068588257,
-0.5141323804855347,
-0.3981815576553345,
-0.1744426041841507,
0.14864009618759155,
0.2643279433250427,
-0.6716203689575195,
0.0005818027420900762,
-0.42486095428466797,
-0.009217435494065285,
0.37024950981140137,
0.134687602519989,
0.36460572481155396,
-0.7201230525970459,
0.6370187401771545,
-0.19326381385326385,
0.024827225133776665,
0.03482437506318092,
-0.6940951347351074,
-0.49116310477256775,
-0.3798654079437256,
0.35958266258239746,
0.6889966726303101,
-0.5441680550575256,
0.26660966873168945,
-0.46355271339416504,
-0.4564579725265503,
-0.3722788393497467,
-0.21539148688316345,
0.4742734432220459,
0.9266841411590576,
0.4704821705818176,
-0.48397839069366455,
-0.4549768567085266,
-1.0699312686920166,
-0.4243738651275635,
-0.0358816534280777,
-0.29493066668510437,
0.3226044178009033,
0.33489978313446045,
-0.3704874813556671,
0.7175836563110352,
-0.8361050486564636,
-0.5641508102416992,
-0.18452665209770203,
0.08975863456726074,
0.17635878920555115,
0.08027014881372452,
0.5987266898155212,
-0.5610950589179993,
-0.7376912236213684,
0.17293982207775116,
-0.9286651611328125,
-0.4527508616447449,
-0.24422696232795715,
-0.12364891916513443,
0.11886963993310928,
0.6941120028495789,
-0.549637496471405,
0.5338695645332336,
0.3534733057022095,
-0.2782556414604187,
0.4589717388153076,
-0.4024629592895508,
0.6070333123207092,
-1.06822669506073,
0.0090182488784194,
-0.08077710121870041,
-0.37711361050605774,
-0.5773873329162598,
-0.11532818526029587,
-0.08185488730669022,
0.0742778331041336,
-0.3522985875606537,
0.785528302192688,
-0.3084053695201874,
-0.25217920541763306,
-0.4606291949748993,
0.36842861771583557,
0.2854924499988556,
-0.002365119755268097,
0.3933793902397156,
0.5829215049743652,
0.5999903678894043,
-0.37254127860069275,
0.3306671977043152,
0.29254016280174255,
-0.19240562617778778,
0.6593893766403198,
-0.6871199011802673,
0.15576785802841187,
0.22449776530265808,
0.17833136022090912,
-0.702360987663269,
0.10333685576915741,
0.15730145573616028,
-0.7297487258911133,
0.3095073103904724,
0.042351432144641876,
-0.4170624017715454,
-0.22451919317245483,
-0.48746806383132935,
0.33224207162857056,
0.5798342227935791,
-0.1438239961862564,
0.4030759334564209,
0.29797571897506714,
-0.2636566162109375,
-0.601255476474762,
-0.6827331781387329,
0.16039076447486877,
-0.33272767066955566,
-0.5884799957275391,
0.7761238217353821,
-0.031017016619443893,
-0.3377372622489929,
0.1419391930103302,
-0.08586078137159348,
-0.2379188984632492,
-0.1481419950723648,
-0.019312793388962746,
0.2597237825393677,
-0.5323677659034729,
0.07966231554746628,
0.05852008983492851,
-0.5544984936714172,
0.0347374826669693,
-0.3680819869041443,
0.17886239290237427,
-0.11848819255828857,
-0.3957095146179199,
-0.4444478750228882,
0.2591745853424072,
0.09317125380039215,
0.21114914119243622,
0.25479361414909363,
0.4533552825450897,
-0.26474812626838684,
0.048884641379117966,
-0.46834707260131836,
-0.14483101665973663,
-0.43666577339172363,
0.23515629768371582,
-0.4472513794898987,
-0.9928178787231445,
0.35356995463371277,
-0.2604197561740875,
-0.3544653058052063,
0.4834825098514557,
0.8436433672904968,
-0.1258210837841034,
0.6720338463783264,
0.44664716720581055,
0.2390836924314499,
-0.009716803207993507,
0.052795641124248505,
0.05088169872760773,
-0.580828070640564,
-0.28371772170066833,
-0.5050747394561768,
-0.06337521970272064,
-0.6646557450294495,
-0.6655356884002686,
0.37830594182014465,
-0.257641077041626,
-0.025496812537312508,
-0.004718825686722994,
-0.6215063333511353,
0.6337316036224365,
0.18092812597751617,
-0.054139964282512665,
0.62664794921875,
-0.025232678279280663,
-0.06608906388282776,
-0.357115775346756,
-0.4786779284477234,
-0.804159939289093,
1.268919587135315,
0.08792659640312195,
0.4507851004600525,
-0.07774259895086288,
0.8095166683197021,
0.33120453357696533,
0.4923822283744812,
-0.9262268543243408,
0.6417309641838074,
-0.1635684221982956,
-0.28926122188568115,
-0.16891656816005707,
-0.42439231276512146,
-1.1047053337097168,
0.3900240361690521,
-0.3041250705718994,
-0.4024381637573242,
-0.3778831660747528,
-0.2306527942419052,
-0.14397506415843964,
0.05686861276626587,
-0.3429208993911743,
0.6914549469947815,
-0.018976297229528427,
0.03552679717540741,
-0.1712532639503479,
-0.5520597696304321,
0.1917247772216797,
-0.3097449541091919,
0.04044144228100777,
-0.2516436278820038,
-0.4723811745643616,
0.7784281373023987,
-0.46563616394996643,
0.5145043730735779,
0.14388728141784668,
-0.04027639701962471,
0.25033777952194214,
0.152711421251297,
-0.038349829614162445,
0.1062944233417511,
-0.0784338116645813,
0.3096984922885895,
0.12254545092582703,
-0.3719511330127716,
-0.8329060077667236,
0.9783409237861633,
-0.5341169834136963,
-0.5572350025177002,
-0.6652039885520935,
-0.3581196069717407,
-0.3416128158569336,
0.5123088955879211,
0.18029165267944336,
0.4815147817134857,
-0.08461033552885056,
-0.10206708312034607,
0.7307544946670532,
-0.2945268750190735,
-0.0064410739578306675,
0.8326536417007446,
-0.05963975191116333,
-0.3280527591705322,
0.7507234215736389,
-0.21275511384010315,
0.27437588572502136,
0.7615202069282532,
0.3164728581905365,
-0.3428443670272827,
-0.9378219842910767,
-0.23786529898643494,
0.38896444439888,
-0.8154125809669495,
-0.5261062979698181,
-0.6855124235153198,
-0.17884516716003418,
-0.38504859805107117,
-0.28114768862724304,
-0.16069777309894562,
-0.48960044980049133,
-0.043818436563014984,
-0.18441040813922882,
0.41327258944511414,
0.7502325773239136,
-0.04491464048624039,
0.14441391825675964,
-0.9357151985168457,
0.29654330015182495,
-0.08964003622531891,
0.11907298862934113,
-0.3682827353477478,
-0.573485791683197,
0.04791564494371414,
-0.46645671129226685,
-0.34966039657592773,
-0.7288877964019775,
0.3758295178413391,
0.027623269706964493,
0.666714072227478,
0.219991534948349,
0.04126269370317459,
0.4175208508968353,
-0.5666558146476746,
0.7314898371696472,
0.31181424856185913,
-0.9422256946563721,
0.5612913370132446,
-0.4092598855495453,
0.13852861523628235,
0.4115249514579773,
0.5406064987182617,
-0.2063562422990799,
-0.5750890374183655,
-0.8525338768959045,
-0.7291398644447327,
0.25031784176826477,
0.350984662771225,
0.16303271055221558,
-0.19007553160190582,
0.48422160744667053,
0.28689301013946533,
-0.10319702327251434,
-0.5911343693733215,
-0.3197289705276489,
0.0009750630706548691,
-0.27503663301467896,
0.18267033994197845,
-0.12405665963888168,
-0.15536543726921082,
-0.12976135313510895,
0.396498441696167,
-0.32703810930252075,
0.4747617244720459,
0.4106648862361908,
-0.018288543447852135,
0.24379415810108185,
0.20749428868293762,
0.6093225479125977,
0.8492449522018433,
0.007232234347611666,
0.23757565021514893,
0.5809937119483948,
-0.5508868098258972,
0.02234271541237831,
-0.20727695524692535,
0.03521110489964485,
0.2356831580400467,
0.8964112401008606,
0.40873727202415466,
0.19788490235805511,
-0.5478066205978394,
0.7632690668106079,
-0.06197488307952881,
-0.559261679649353,
-0.1558765321969986,
0.015955153852701187,
0.08599153161048889,
0.09353046119213104,
0.04984046518802643,
-0.07922109216451645,
0.4475400447845459,
-0.26295900344848633,
0.7552390098571777,
0.4420969486236572,
-0.5161457061767578,
-0.13644883036613464,
0.3238600194454193,
-0.0004085772088728845,
-0.031024206429719925,
0.4373711347579956,
0.00016940783825702965,
-0.27127960324287415,
0.6541064977645874,
0.5175936818122864,
0.6373795866966248,
-0.0615679994225502,
0.4028639793395996,
0.35525891184806824,
-0.0036652670241892338,
0.12589319050312042,
0.3180454671382904,
0.06906577944755554,
-0.8276049494743347,
-0.5444060564041138,
-0.3931320607662201,
-0.4541769325733185,
0.10729749500751495,
-0.7765798568725586,
0.45116373896598816,
-0.47369152307510376,
-0.1517363041639328,
0.185914546251297,
0.11358582228422165,
-0.43741223216056824,
0.6462874412536621,
0.04843713343143463,
0.7559499740600586,
-0.6963121891021729,
0.9551175236701965,
0.5695477724075317,
-0.27687329053878784,
-0.6894184947013855,
0.09332611411809921,
0.10114795714616776,
-0.8720088005065918,
0.7227270603179932,
0.15047502517700195,
-0.4291667342185974,
-0.14343151450157166,
-0.12650635838508606,
-0.5132951140403748,
1.3166882991790771,
0.22061492502689362,
-0.42659395933151245,
0.06925197690725327,
0.27649980783462524,
0.8636359572410583,
-0.45985546708106995,
0.5318411588668823,
0.641339123249054,
0.3709729015827179,
0.41923993825912476,
-1.0434046983718872,
0.3062237501144409,
0.021149571985006332,
-0.27010205388069153,
0.18316586315631866,
-0.314664751291275,
0.48846668004989624,
-0.33439579606056213,
-0.18708299100399017,
0.1884213238954544,
0.6120859980583191,
0.181958869099617,
0.645801305770874,
0.16767911612987518,
0.7562716603279114,
0.8329959511756897,
0.06745721399784088,
1.1318939924240112,
0.05356711521744728,
0.45471522212028503,
1.0716649293899536,
-0.6251561045646667,
0.5440527200698853,
0.2836369574069977,
-0.19083765149116516,
0.5420730710029602,
0.4656042158603668,
-0.06922341138124466,
0.4711057245731354,
0.19586846232414246,
-0.273179829120636,
-0.29595649242401123,
-0.02853314019739628,
-0.5265635251998901,
0.3045181930065155,
0.32495105266571045,
-0.3768255412578583,
-0.40778955817222595,
-0.19090178608894348,
0.053588129580020905,
0.2668597400188446,
-0.19923484325408936,
1.0381946563720703,
0.3820328116416931,
-0.09335581213235855,
0.553796112537384,
-0.003684918163344264,
0.5201080441474915,
-0.6796045899391174,
0.04830307513475418,
-0.1087445542216301,
0.18194447457790375,
-0.34708669781684875,
-1.038704514503479,
0.8095781803131104,
-0.12213665246963501,
-0.11922448873519897,
-0.1609206348657608,
0.8469295501708984,
-0.09457051008939743,
-0.24831001460552216,
0.5463375449180603,
0.6353534460067749,
0.326136976480484,
0.08086521178483963,
-0.9600921869277954,
-0.023226168006658554,
-0.05209130048751831,
-0.20848865807056427,
0.5438535213470459,
0.680336058139801,
-0.19149988889694214,
0.7085044980049133,
0.42297083139419556,
0.27240654826164246,
-0.3416547179222107,
0.37690749764442444,
0.8440836668014526,
-0.7515803575515747,
-0.33600106835365295,
-0.8353655934333801,
0.025268809869885445,
-0.36154624819755554,
-0.40762364864349365,
0.757567822933197,
0.7787068486213684,
0.8949680328369141,
-0.10288942605257034,
0.7813907861709595,
0.3394382894039154,
0.8005178570747375,
-0.8223759531974792,
0.6452516913414001,
-0.5910933613777161,
0.2869223952293396,
-0.5223432779312134,
-0.903107762336731,
-0.8040143251419067,
0.5435225367546082,
-0.3658006489276886,
0.02122851274907589,
1.2589857578277588,
0.9944562315940857,
-0.050199806690216064,
-0.11005520075559616,
0.6777395606040955,
-0.02783661149442196,
0.22189787030220032,
0.6173195242881775,
0.8482003808021545,
-0.2979693114757538,
0.5705440640449524,
0.24958032369613647,
-0.2559385895729065,
0.08919564634561539,
-1.025780439376831,
-0.9145359992980957,
-0.4426479637622833,
-0.7237042784690857,
-0.5098965167999268,
-0.013114375062286854,
0.3667832911014557,
0.4715675711631775,
-0.6755676865577698,
0.29450640082359314,
0.18956731259822845,
0.02819412387907505,
0.08547047525644302,
-0.2608333230018616,
0.5973384380340576,
-0.18326415121555328,
-0.4948967397212982,
0.18757110834121704,
0.6604712605476379,
0.024788348004221916,
0.07481193542480469,
-0.19281451404094696,
0.28617388010025024,
0.24082742631435394,
0.5355551838874817,
-0.021835656836628914,
-0.7235801219940186,
-0.4201681315898895,
-0.09618739783763885,
-0.3634251654148102,
0.2281576544046402,
1.2054542303085327,
-1.0400588512420654,
0.33135056495666504,
0.5525362491607666,
0.6057681441307068,
0.3869943618774414,
-0.14377114176750183,
0.44534775614738464,
-0.41130661964416504,
0.07384732365608215,
0.5186741948127747,
0.006580258719623089,
0.4346284568309784,
-0.3911462128162384,
0.4840235114097595,
0.3536624312400818,
-0.5240326523780823,
-0.6709932088851929,
0.4442179203033447,
-1.3178249597549438,
-0.2778295576572418,
1.2529139518737793,
-0.4391506612300873,
0.047895174473524094,
-0.3384372889995575,
-0.20222708582878113,
0.045038893818855286,
-0.09525881707668304,
0.5201849341392517,
0.42650824785232544,
-0.6093428134918213,
-0.03989974036812782,
-0.35475772619247437,
0.730594277381897,
0.30113065242767334,
-0.9977082014083862,
-0.4590931534767151,
0.17614445090293884,
0.6720451712608337,
-0.01204598043113947,
1.1677149534225464,
-0.47965046763420105,
0.2342098504304886,
-0.034278977662324905,
-0.18550707399845123,
-0.003842930542305112,
0.013174328953027725,
-0.07186917215585709,
-0.032117921859025955,
0.007752175442874432,
0.05423332005739212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14833v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14833v1 | CliqueParcel: An Approach For Batching LLM Prompts That Jointly Optimizes Efficiency And Faithfulness | 2024-02-17T22:37:17 | 2024-02-17T22:37:17 | Jiayi Liu, Tinghan Yang, Jennifer Neville | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have become pivotal in recent research. However,
during the inference process, LLMs still require substantial resources. In this
paper, we propose CliqueParcel, a method designed to improve the efficiency of
LLMs via prompt batching. Existing strategies to optimize inference efficiency
often compromise on output quality, leading to a discounted output problem.
This issue might result in reduced accuracy or outputs that are less detailed.
CliqueParcel is our answer to this challenge. While ensuring accuracy and
minimizing deviations from the original outputs (i.e., faithfulness), our
method significantly improves efficiency during inference.
To lay the groundwork, we first redefine efficiency measurements by excluding
the reduction in running time due to shorter lengths. Then, we provide a
comprehensive trade-off between efficiency and faithfulness to clarify the
nature of the 'discounted output' problem. Within the CliqueParcel framework,
we suggest multiple batching sub-methods and discuss the specific scenarios in
which they can be applied. During evaluation, CliqueParcel is tested on eight
widely recognized datasets, which can be classified into three types: reading
comprehension, open-source question-answering, and reasoning. Our experiments
explore the performance of CliqueParcel, including efficiency, faithfulness,
and the trade-off between them. This work provides novel insights into
inference efficiency and demonstrates promising performance. | [
-0.16391940414905548,
-0.5632114410400391,
0.5123600959777832,
0.601058840751648,
-0.4406736195087433,
-0.11036844551563263,
-0.46783387660980225,
0.012793637812137604,
0.05931822583079338,
0.6462990045547485,
-0.6129489541053772,
-0.4604148268699646,
-0.4242953062057495,
0.27478328347206116,
-0.35865697264671326,
0.5105929970741272,
0.035193778574466705,
0.3636770248413086,
-0.42368084192276,
-0.05047226697206497,
-0.5056841373443604,
-0.2995963990688324,
-1.0535372495651245,
-0.22166092693805695,
0.4730990529060364,
0.39299675822257996,
0.5533238649368286,
0.9657624959945679,
0.19495368003845215,
0.28395166993141174,
0.002134124282747507,
0.6488217115402222,
-0.7597966194152832,
0.4200122654438019,
-0.236424058675766,
-0.6435143351554871,
-0.3536684215068817,
-0.18923012912273407,
0.6609734892845154,
0.6910844445228577,
-0.24491070210933685,
0.07615659385919571,
0.5018644332885742,
0.6621181964874268,
-0.538871705532074,
0.2819001078605652,
-0.6787405610084534,
-0.16455937922000885,
-0.13250912725925446,
-0.03817938640713692,
-0.7241257429122925,
-0.7115110754966736,
-0.5120256543159485,
-0.46715623140335083,
0.20923487842082977,
0.286144882440567,
0.418542742729187,
0.28548726439476013,
0.1405075490474701,
-0.4251604974269867,
-0.30799439549446106,
1.1850340366363525,
-0.8508696556091309,
0.43150636553764343,
0.11032614856958389,
0.23380818963050842,
-0.5356078743934631,
-0.969165027141571,
-0.41264843940734863,
-0.2289915829896927,
-0.12258920818567276,
0.07688283175230026,
-0.005782270338386297,
0.17434442043304443,
0.39574143290519714,
0.404366135597229,
-0.4456227719783783,
0.0682886615395546,
-0.08133427053689957,
-0.4767611622810364,
0.7043049931526184,
0.2555520534515381,
0.09094499796628952,
0.15850533545017242,
-0.21145622432231903,
-0.03802195563912392,
-0.6147702932357788,
0.062249619513750076,
0.198494091629982,
0.41019999980926514,
0.46038323640823364,
0.5527942180633545,
-0.2819386422634125,
0.7052612900733948,
-0.1605970561504364,
-0.4305504858493805,
-0.17388275265693665,
-0.5168429613113403,
-0.22216466069221497,
0.14655500650405884,
0.7324195504188538,
0.4013252854347229,
0.31016772985458374,
-0.05700717493891716,
-0.21280565857887268,
0.0776357501745224,
-0.08933575451374054,
-1.1790269613265991,
-0.39400848746299744,
0.4362020194530487,
-0.4192705452442169,
-0.059995364397764206,
-0.26154670119285583,
-0.8998599648475647,
-0.3641853928565979,
-0.5104256868362427,
0.026523463428020477,
-0.49037909507751465,
0.35054564476013184,
-0.21871531009674072,
-0.24030187726020813,
-0.17263111472129822,
0.705959141254425,
-0.6471333503723145,
0.3713155686855316,
0.6477082967758179,
1.038179874420166,
-0.3693188428878784,
-0.22588495910167694,
-0.8999758362770081,
0.10767721384763718,
-0.37124648690223694,
0.6835810542106628,
-0.49461665749549866,
-0.5847678184509277,
-0.12333010882139206,
0.01093707699328661,
0.10339869558811188,
-0.6012810468673706,
0.595441460609436,
-0.33480304479599,
-0.19497814774513245,
-0.5582070350646973,
-0.7969940900802612,
0.10487955808639526,
0.006821449380367994,
-0.6836457848548889,
0.8895804286003113,
-0.08091988414525986,
-0.5825427174568176,
0.33356910943984985,
-0.12751828134059906,
-0.4355807900428772,
0.06760003417730331,
-0.07272695004940033,
-0.1801094263792038,
0.08947834372520447,
0.5453627109527588,
0.4977108836174011,
-0.4338572323322296,
0.16548272967338562,
-0.34184667468070984,
-0.4824816882610321,
0.09767322242259979,
-0.5866286754608154,
0.7550171613693237,
0.22983670234680176,
-0.01443494949489832,
0.03687259554862976,
-0.4961259663105011,
0.19809845089912415,
-0.045409951359033585,
-0.4102732539176941,
-0.26947081089019775,
0.011068210005760193,
-0.44197338819503784,
-0.18846596777439117,
0.23472309112548828,
-0.4716147780418396,
0.3851325809955597,
-0.3192884624004364,
0.49188148975372314,
0.8590887784957886,
0.10346683859825134,
0.5514593720436096,
-0.40827056765556335,
0.3058755397796631,
-0.1333180069923401,
0.24043066799640656,
-0.4414502680301666,
-0.4573458135128021,
-0.6592845320701599,
-0.806395411491394,
0.28321075439453125,
0.48583805561065674,
-0.8710225820541382,
0.0071387761272490025,
-0.09694797545671463,
-0.3174211084842682,
-0.4337913990020752,
0.41997581720352173,
0.4257155954837799,
0.42620566487312317,
0.470976322889328,
-0.17571230232715607,
-0.24813993275165558,
-0.9159515500068665,
-0.7201155424118042,
0.07110607624053955,
-0.031063297763466835,
0.24147719144821167,
0.08004792034626007,
0.24183373153209686,
0.978655993938446,
-0.5880669951438904,
0.0827692449092865,
-0.5719768404960632,
-0.0015934060793370008,
0.632067859172821,
0.46885332465171814,
0.2905457615852356,
-0.45419934391975403,
-0.521409809589386,
-0.12224035710096359,
-0.3551422655582428,
-0.3975186049938202,
-0.25922447443008423,
-0.2708381712436676,
0.2455253154039383,
0.4742424488067627,
-0.42888355255126953,
0.314603716135025,
0.3883138597011566,
0.12524592876434326,
0.609233021736145,
-0.13513630628585815,
0.26586681604385376,
-0.9727767705917358,
-0.34207066893577576,
-0.1883620172739029,
-0.5212171673774719,
-0.5599545836448669,
-0.17943130433559418,
0.09684064239263535,
0.12120119482278824,
-0.539829671382904,
0.6777076721191406,
-0.5649264454841614,
-0.06403046101331711,
-0.2300994098186493,
0.16148124635219574,
0.22054503858089447,
0.4452599585056305,
-0.24020740389823914,
1.2540119886398315,
0.33527490496635437,
-0.7670894265174866,
0.39388206601142883,
0.12853147089481354,
-0.22533905506134033,
0.5209515690803528,
-0.63454669713974,
0.03461445868015289,
-0.2688581943511963,
0.4269532263278961,
-1.0934855937957764,
-0.40703529119491577,
0.22040635347366333,
-0.19684922695159912,
0.28033512830734253,
-0.1793067306280136,
-0.4319911301136017,
-0.4049600064754486,
-0.2892935276031494,
0.1997900903224945,
0.8135575652122498,
-0.7606418132781982,
0.6124281883239746,
-0.08263994008302689,
-0.2660025954246521,
-0.7250467538833618,
-0.9105580449104309,
-0.17799769341945648,
-0.008666236884891987,
-0.6364750266075134,
0.18302685022354126,
0.05279192328453064,
-0.2962189316749573,
-0.27810853719711304,
-0.18676379323005676,
-0.13879871368408203,
-0.15639013051986694,
0.012356300838291645,
-0.054163381457328796,
-0.05015220120549202,
0.06784828007221222,
0.42854106426239014,
0.14527897536754608,
-0.01318187452852726,
-0.676196277141571,
0.7261513471603394,
0.19874367117881775,
-0.3220393657684326,
-0.7474103569984436,
0.2562532126903534,
0.28436556458473206,
-0.11454017460346222,
0.8714601397514343,
0.22270797193050385,
-0.14560967683792114,
-0.8203778266906738,
-0.6746667623519897,
-0.38452640175819397,
-0.5119738578796387,
0.13745422661304474,
-0.22648265957832336,
-0.5736922025680542,
0.4578856825828552,
-0.3732180893421173,
0.31805095076560974,
-0.03867495432496071,
0.6163249015808105,
0.05648025497794151,
0.5101490616798401,
0.012870360165834427,
0.17047268152236938,
0.3389380872249603,
-0.17194367945194244,
0.2737496495246887,
-0.5671043395996094,
-0.23468205332756042,
-0.5845579504966736,
-0.07215853035449982,
-0.23420369625091553,
-0.8138232231140137,
0.09768763184547424,
0.3309684097766876,
-0.06796887516975403,
0.330265611410141,
-0.28390631079673767,
0.5724356174468994,
0.6310870051383972,
0.481011301279068,
0.5054996013641357,
0.09862824529409409,
-0.02089717797935009,
-0.1140333041548729,
-0.8938091993331909,
-0.5235065221786499,
0.8272170424461365,
0.051880113780498505,
0.826216459274292,
-0.1071217805147171,
0.7464494705200195,
0.31771329045295715,
0.5680739879608154,
-0.641069769859314,
0.693533182144165,
-0.15386998653411865,
-0.28965556621551514,
-0.29609107971191406,
-0.7381597757339478,
-0.6330867409706116,
0.3514775335788727,
0.21905232965946198,
-0.6903547644615173,
0.12133471667766571,
0.6890722513198853,
-0.22015072405338287,
0.3216904103755951,
-0.6257651448249817,
0.8093173503875732,
0.01576484739780426,
-0.8664802312850952,
-0.1544199436903,
-0.2881828546524048,
0.5765003561973572,
-0.07269950211048126,
0.2627148926258087,
-0.043883614242076874,
-0.057183101773262024,
0.38407987356185913,
-0.7885740995407104,
0.7073546648025513,
-0.2069743424654007,
0.10836672782897949,
0.6545261740684509,
0.17139828205108643,
0.8315244913101196,
0.3239099085330963,
-0.37061625719070435,
0.08547474443912506,
-0.10957132279872894,
-0.7256147265434265,
-0.7424034476280212,
0.7852770686149597,
-0.24257992208003998,
-0.6059563755989075,
-0.08938246220350266,
-0.7061881422996521,
-0.2611159086227417,
0.29152703285217285,
0.23652349412441254,
0.732887327671051,
-0.20455259084701538,
0.01994537189602852,
0.6700228452682495,
-0.42990854382514954,
0.6981879472732544,
-0.08977953344583511,
-0.28347083926200867,
-0.5338578224182129,
0.8525012731552124,
0.09953157603740692,
0.6604256629943848,
0.264712929725647,
0.16801029443740845,
-0.5526487231254578,
-0.6421580910682678,
-0.45905420184135437,
0.2323877364397049,
-0.7830875515937805,
-0.2721126973628998,
-0.6377267837524414,
0.2249567061662674,
-0.5550270676612854,
-0.20668795704841614,
-0.37617871165275574,
-0.31885430216789246,
-0.24077841639518738,
0.2625865638256073,
0.222839817404747,
0.3855675160884857,
0.08960932493209839,
0.5242515802383423,
-0.763565719127655,
0.019409189000725746,
0.32591021060943604,
0.04150046408176422,
0.1392114907503128,
-0.47233521938323975,
0.11567029356956482,
0.22112390398979187,
-0.12653955817222595,
-0.7838696241378784,
0.4267159700393677,
0.2555290162563324,
0.48766788840293884,
0.248928502202034,
0.268059104681015,
0.7855502367019653,
-0.5070928335189819,
0.8138993978500366,
0.1621560901403427,
-1.0554335117340088,
0.17561733722686768,
-0.2644762694835663,
0.01103551872074604,
0.6701882481575012,
0.20158751308918,
-0.23294799029827118,
-0.268482506275177,
-0.3570100963115692,
-0.7462218999862671,
0.5372887253761292,
0.5044128894805908,
-0.015590737573802471,
-0.1521405577659607,
0.4675730764865875,
0.09294746816158295,
0.5470556616783142,
-0.30251064896583557,
-0.13392274081707,
-0.13330474495887756,
-0.2655091881752014,
0.0438748262822628,
-0.2174982726573944,
0.09905539453029633,
-0.09493942558765411,
0.7877593040466309,
-0.1854085922241211,
0.0457925908267498,
0.4441543519496918,
-0.1378929167985916,
0.48537105321884155,
0.13099360466003418,
0.4489551782608032,
0.714024543762207,
0.13282199203968048,
0.06832404434680939,
0.5332918167114258,
-0.42955589294433594,
0.10263155400753021,
-0.2617589831352234,
0.10094604641199112,
0.18285129964351654,
0.445163756608963,
0.5046877264976501,
-0.09824405610561371,
-0.6247336864471436,
0.5060985684394836,
-0.020231904461979866,
0.04079756885766983,
-0.08082398027181625,
0.16576212644577026,
0.22887814044952393,
0.16161084175109863,
0.09623001515865326,
0.08827214688062668,
0.15086454153060913,
-0.5398799777030945,
0.27527621388435364,
0.3609827756881714,
-0.004557785578072071,
0.2409651130437851,
0.5722326636314392,
0.0654858872294426,
-0.26692745089530945,
0.7948338985443115,
-0.4329797923564911,
-0.37672993540763855,
0.8216898441314697,
0.5100597143173218,
0.5059055685997009,
-0.41554245352745056,
0.12358307093381882,
0.3728387951850891,
0.2667672634124756,
-0.563233494758606,
0.2110198438167572,
0.06434077024459839,
-0.46911129355430603,
-0.7747946381568909,
-0.779098391532898,
-0.44347187876701355,
-0.3060358464717865,
-0.6061293482780457,
0.295744925737381,
-0.4185650646686554,
0.10154064744710922,
-0.31499698758125305,
-0.16395172476768494,
-0.4666513204574585,
0.1026080921292305,
-0.23811675608158112,
1.1997250318527222,
-0.6232230067253113,
0.7504984736442566,
0.21874453127384186,
-0.09037843346595764,
-1.0474716424942017,
-0.04507823288440704,
-0.27804842591285706,
-0.8388310074806213,
0.4077453017234802,
0.2548235356807709,
-0.009400753304362297,
0.14954838156700134,
-0.5876166224479675,
-0.526833176612854,
1.215347170829773,
0.5108060240745544,
-0.9537271857261658,
0.32100823521614075,
0.0830073133111,
0.28982970118522644,
-0.4404522776603699,
0.3664971590042114,
0.7972498536109924,
0.6234275102615356,
0.36773309111595154,
-0.42469361424446106,
0.22953110933303833,
0.23568390309810638,
0.2397075593471527,
0.24796484410762787,
-0.7437001466751099,
0.7565116882324219,
-0.09219908714294434,
-0.2240414172410965,
0.2564673125743866,
0.8910850286483765,
0.4269873797893524,
0.5556824803352356,
0.3783114552497864,
0.4195633828639984,
1.1348611116409302,
-0.28535836935043335,
1.3567864894866943,
-0.19749097526073456,
0.3186894655227661,
1.1129822731018066,
-0.3086419999599457,
0.4204975664615631,
0.46933531761169434,
-0.34389254450798035,
0.19790023565292358,
0.6014618873596191,
0.02096549980342388,
0.34938478469848633,
0.5793607831001282,
-0.29692453145980835,
-0.4860476851463318,
-0.38482028245925903,
-0.038472168147563934,
-0.24239425361156464,
0.2831461727619171,
-0.3895440399646759,
-0.2099204808473587,
-0.17145349085330963,
0.37740764021873474,
0.156781867146492,
-0.6127500534057617,
0.3959423899650574,
0.2861401438713074,
-0.8577574491500854,
0.5151155591011047,
-0.27322328090667725,
0.2944534718990326,
-0.3684326410293579,
-0.10992732644081116,
-0.7472712993621826,
0.21067066490650177,
-0.2591352164745331,
-0.4348679184913635,
0.18975724279880524,
-0.20859785377979279,
-0.17502878606319427,
-0.24634119868278503,
0.5439474582672119,
-0.5333576798439026,
-0.5275440812110901,
0.021909233182668686,
0.3196662664413452,
0.375031441450119,
-0.11697807908058167,
-0.4385703504085541,
0.2948290705680847,
0.22258226573467255,
-0.1359582096338272,
0.1234901174902916,
0.38945451378822327,
-0.047353409230709076,
0.6165183782577515,
0.7495012283325195,
0.18735450506210327,
0.1205194890499115,
0.08459378778934479,
1.0032868385314941,
-0.23451440036296844,
-0.31961408257484436,
-1.163400650024414,
0.3770392835140228,
-0.5253652334213257,
-0.06262149661779404,
0.9079509973526001,
0.56743985414505,
0.5250840187072754,
0.001131950644776225,
0.7649461627006531,
0.20374472439289093,
0.36189135909080505,
-0.7937860488891602,
0.2803533375263214,
-0.36251068115234375,
0.4980395436286926,
-0.08452869951725006,
-1.218189001083374,
-0.1118975505232811,
0.3171533942222595,
-0.19057132303714752,
-0.09450743347406387,
0.9544382095336914,
0.9806908965110779,
-0.08934065699577332,
0.27179911732673645,
0.20348182320594788,
0.4075030982494354,
0.3566854000091553,
0.4543769061565399,
0.6613852381706238,
-0.09603232890367508,
0.4197022318840027,
-0.4170019030570984,
-0.29760485887527466,
0.054166678339242935,
-1.0206364393234253,
-1.2361657619476318,
-0.06203547120094299,
-0.15106438100337982,
-0.5980517268180847,
0.42381489276885986,
1.0789796113967896,
0.4800569713115692,
-0.8404245376586914,
-0.08778978884220123,
-0.4947352409362793,
0.12953703105449677,
-0.26888835430145264,
-0.20262649655342102,
0.34791886806488037,
-0.6814231872558594,
-0.9468074440956116,
0.46382254362106323,
0.176499605178833,
-0.1819482296705246,
-0.10586076229810715,
0.16441945731639862,
0.2496805638074875,
0.464685320854187,
0.43102535605430603,
-0.04836640506982803,
-0.5782784223556519,
0.032704342156648636,
-0.05945713445544243,
0.000613646931014955,
-0.13129985332489014,
0.9747815728187561,
-0.5025263428688049,
0.10956132411956787,
0.7539867162704468,
0.8261529207229614,
0.41590890288352966,
0.5062071681022644,
0.6419245004653931,
-0.6578020453453064,
0.3302280306816101,
0.26408448815345764,
0.411462664604187,
0.30892911553382874,
-0.39627984166145325,
0.3676868975162506,
0.35062888264656067,
-0.7343703508377075,
-0.796623170375824,
0.299137145280838,
-0.8429697751998901,
-0.5052006244659424,
1.2765309810638428,
-0.4462461471557617,
-0.6299366354942322,
0.0032773655839264393,
-0.4320206940174103,
0.1702674776315689,
-0.8949199318885803,
0.30246034264564514,
0.5915789008140564,
-0.1778721958398819,
0.016967182978987694,
-0.46634387969970703,
0.5149000287055969,
0.5273841023445129,
-0.8162193298339844,
0.20151011645793915,
0.5659046173095703,
0.2131277620792389,
-0.09555363655090332,
0.5672625303268433,
0.15206760168075562,
-0.05708117410540581,
0.04042808711528778,
-0.12208226323127747,
-0.1433042287826538,
-0.3561607897281647,
-0.19456538558006287,
0.3166511058807373,
-0.03227679058909416,
-0.09228683263063431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11359v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11359v3 | Offline Training of Language Model Agents with Functions as Learnable Weights | 2024-02-17T18:31:21 | 2024-06-07T23:49:18 | Shaokun Zhang, Jieyu Zhang, Jiale Liu, Linxin Song, Chi Wang, Ranjay Krishna, Qingyun Wu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Researchers and practitioners have recently reframed powerful Large Language
Models (LLMs) as agents, enabling them to automate complex tasks largely via
the use of specialized functions. To facilitate the development of LLM agents,
we present a novel paradigm of training LLM agents without modifying the LLM
weights, which is particularly useful when the LLMs are difficult or
inaccessible for modifications. Inspired by how humans continuously forge tools
to adapt to real-world tasks, rather than change our biological structure to
fit a static set of tools, we propose to progressively forge agent's functions
to better solve the downstream tasks instead of modifying the LLM weights. By
treating the functions as learnable `agent parameters' and leveraging the
fundamental idea of model training in artificial intelligence, we develop
AgentOptimizer that employs the LLM to update agents' functions and devise an
agent training algorithm with two strategies, roll-back, and early-stop, to
streamline the training process. With extensive experiments, we showcase that
the agent training paradigm could significantly improve the performance of
representative LLM agents in various downstream tasks. We also study the
behavior of the agent training regarding aspects like the learning curve and
domain transferability. | [
-0.21600617468357086,
-0.6170264482498169,
0.3961409628391266,
-0.2955736815929413,
-0.029942568391561508,
0.3473145067691803,
-0.36635634303092957,
-0.39845314621925354,
0.3168199956417084,
0.5161173343658447,
-0.6913521885871887,
0.06559794396162033,
-0.4106205403804779,
0.03157283738255501,
-0.2838139533996582,
1.0188257694244385,
-0.12433063983917236,
0.33674758672714233,
-0.09036824107170105,
-0.0763106420636177,
0.12502534687519073,
-0.4851933419704437,
-0.9579713940620422,
-0.6902859210968018,
0.48084017634391785,
0.31304076313972473,
0.5783004760742188,
0.810439944267273,
0.28219306468963623,
0.40091389417648315,
0.1863355040550232,
0.08470211178064346,
-0.7190194725990295,
0.14444661140441895,
-0.019377848133444786,
-0.8043410778045654,
-0.6907899379730225,
-0.05522793531417847,
0.6666524410247803,
0.7574899792671204,
-0.30143293738365173,
0.03698628023266792,
0.02045018970966339,
0.6153320670127869,
-0.31295791268348694,
0.3770715892314911,
-0.7973607182502747,
0.0017728173406794667,
-0.047774411737918854,
-0.398699551820755,
-0.4515511989593506,
-0.36659207940101624,
0.010807624086737633,
-0.6740830540657043,
0.19053098559379578,
-0.23707395792007446,
0.7129127383232117,
0.4362054765224457,
-0.16104376316070557,
-0.18307335674762726,
-0.7973661422729492,
0.5435512661933899,
-0.6599690318107605,
0.2715316414833069,
0.32640960812568665,
0.5842705965042114,
-0.20448139309883118,
-0.7457312345504761,
-0.2829912006855011,
-0.5680062770843506,
0.30119678378105164,
-0.1199399083852768,
0.250160813331604,
0.14649835228919983,
0.2683250606060028,
0.008678152225911617,
-0.273730605840683,
0.11652912944555283,
-0.1624365895986557,
-0.059778474271297455,
0.7061046361923218,
0.06844031810760498,
0.3715493679046631,
0.6592604517936707,
-0.1832856684923172,
-0.2767608165740967,
-0.8117278814315796,
0.17038172483444214,
0.5838686227798462,
0.46167516708374023,
0.08726649731397629,
0.24500904977321625,
-0.15608467161655426,
0.5261167883872986,
-0.019019607454538345,
-0.3500223159790039,
0.20129477977752686,
0.15599167346954346,
0.1615961492061615,
0.007900277152657509,
0.15190547704696655,
-0.1631382405757904,
0.4514629542827606,
-0.47937947511672974,
-0.5438411831855774,
-0.3804628551006317,
0.5432808995246887,
-0.8298458456993103,
-0.08849867433309555,
0.07848142832517624,
-0.25159838795661926,
-0.35958001017570496,
-0.10492300987243652,
-0.19534239172935486,
-0.3748677670955658,
-0.4255686402320862,
0.5658353567123413,
-0.31784045696258545,
-0.27661365270614624,
-0.24914565682411194,
-0.10724108666181564,
0.4017685651779175,
0.36725053191185,
-0.8476055860519409,
0.3467167019844055,
0.479727178812027,
0.7539951801300049,
-0.017955897375941277,
-0.5809550285339355,
-0.6622686982154846,
0.11003917455673218,
-0.3112908601760864,
0.8020225167274475,
-0.37604716420173645,
-0.10590286552906036,
0.13347291946411133,
0.0537225715816021,
-0.1841687262058258,
-0.4528678357601166,
-0.06999865919351578,
-0.8103442788124084,
-0.13983581960201263,
-0.1209401860833168,
-0.5535017848014832,
-0.17144885659217834,
0.38183411955833435,
-0.6671531200408936,
0.8742286562919617,
0.35405662655830383,
-0.3168184459209442,
0.24193449318408966,
-0.6740907430648804,
-0.3945987820625305,
0.19319792091846466,
0.08364171534776688,
-0.5666651725769043,
-0.1570800542831421,
-0.2145869880914688,
0.3877338171005249,
-0.16229020059108734,
0.03237805515527725,
-0.5761263370513916,
-0.32225871086120605,
0.2975902855396271,
-0.0713905319571495,
0.7161853313446045,
-0.08874169737100601,
-0.42776748538017273,
0.1730467528104782,
-0.7617289423942566,
0.10515723377466202,
0.3390237092971802,
-0.5450015664100647,
-0.1185099259018898,
0.2803492546081543,
-0.034813232719898224,
0.2528209090232849,
0.17496807873249054,
-0.4346257448196411,
0.3287506699562073,
-0.5675682425498962,
0.6667170524597168,
0.6632955074310303,
-0.2612769305706024,
0.6099573373794556,
-0.5682082772254944,
0.6483862400054932,
-0.6215620040893555,
0.09506409615278244,
-0.03417624905705452,
-0.2501875162124634,
-0.8636704087257385,
-0.6579388976097107,
-0.09398555010557175,
0.5231993794441223,
-1.0002225637435913,
0.44390982389450073,
-0.36599597334861755,
-0.6771596670150757,
-0.3148154616355896,
0.43109697103500366,
0.31861940026283264,
0.2790389060974121,
0.18851830065250397,
-0.23756301403045654,
-0.3330276608467102,
-0.34257617592811584,
-0.30973681807518005,
-0.07200346887111664,
0.05588166043162346,
0.04915883019566536,
0.6565752029418945,
-0.1077110692858696,
1.09736168384552,
-0.47284528613090515,
-0.35138407349586487,
-0.7590668201446533,
0.22725164890289307,
-0.31987863779067993,
0.12182347476482391,
0.36227649450302124,
-0.6917175650596619,
-0.40474048256874084,
-0.0509149432182312,
-0.6387216448783875,
-0.2605125904083252,
-0.152297705411911,
0.12046074867248535,
0.28447410464286804,
0.9299981594085693,
-0.5493239760398865,
0.14004848897457123,
0.15256954729557037,
-0.07068619877099991,
0.25719958543777466,
-0.4267594516277313,
-0.35938185453414917,
-0.907235860824585,
0.1138874888420105,
-0.4441787898540497,
-0.6219709515571594,
-0.9059655666351318,
0.2544425427913666,
-0.11637220531702042,
-0.1155017539858818,
-0.7366886138916016,
0.7820054888725281,
-0.6488681435585022,
-0.15939269959926605,
-0.6888428926467896,
0.1301194727420807,
-0.15014035999774933,
0.705301821231842,
0.126302570104599,
0.49172407388687134,
0.5442028045654297,
-0.5342767834663391,
0.41223520040512085,
-0.0129782073199749,
0.1723192036151886,
0.30466532707214355,
-0.5397894978523254,
0.3238559365272522,
-0.3644479811191559,
0.3431951701641083,
-0.6217771172523499,
-0.08232606947422028,
0.3244934678077698,
-0.15625353157520294,
0.4941444993019104,
-0.08902306109666824,
-0.28333401679992676,
0.001901235431432724,
-0.4727414548397064,
0.18420052528381348,
0.6000936627388,
-0.3000866770744324,
0.8183895349502563,
0.33654701709747314,
-0.10650414973497391,
-0.2526124119758606,
-0.4662229120731354,
-0.09394620358943939,
-0.21757212281227112,
-0.27694952487945557,
0.268233984708786,
0.0075459107756614685,
-0.1660335510969162,
-0.02378670684993267,
0.13215605914592743,
-0.21597614884376526,
0.21182745695114136,
0.2510393261909485,
0.018276171758770943,
0.02621982805430889,
0.229299858212471,
-0.19119811058044434,
-0.14956848323345184,
-0.03486965224146843,
-0.395546019077301,
0.6055035591125488,
-0.05536023527383804,
-0.2992008924484253,
-0.041885484009981155,
-0.043164223432540894,
0.5120265483856201,
-0.2792772650718689,
0.8227398991584778,
0.6658864617347717,
-0.32418856024742126,
-0.6667224764823914,
-0.3586081862449646,
-0.47244054079055786,
-0.4906405806541443,
0.6467357873916626,
-0.245132714509964,
-0.7055285573005676,
0.5498126149177551,
-0.12010760605335236,
0.15236137807369232,
0.0975613072514534,
0.7242960333824158,
0.10969365388154984,
0.9010173678398132,
0.8974776268005371,
0.14025390148162842,
0.7786030173301697,
-0.35123535990715027,
0.030886029824614525,
-0.4470241367816925,
-0.16407614946365356,
-0.3457060754299164,
-0.1837673932313919,
-0.33416008949279785,
-0.49936941266059875,
0.22057530283927917,
-0.06883551180362701,
-0.23332445323467255,
0.35941338539123535,
-0.22203867137432098,
0.3868471682071686,
0.3982306122779846,
0.10432742536067963,
0.13505814969539642,
-0.08396660536527634,
0.29896724224090576,
0.37452730536460876,
-0.706856369972229,
-0.48639172315597534,
1.2912758588790894,
0.4258262515068054,
0.8194808959960938,
-0.04982873052358627,
0.6607207655906677,
0.43673163652420044,
0.570941150188446,
-1.0325733423233032,
0.6207841634750366,
0.16813696920871735,
-0.5675323605537415,
-0.5920186042785645,
-0.40908172726631165,
-0.878101646900177,
0.2003706395626068,
0.031061282381415367,
-0.5855361223220825,
-0.18083684146404266,
0.24389493465423584,
-0.08462708443403244,
0.4553624987602234,
-0.5651832222938538,
0.600689172744751,
-0.45991310477256775,
-0.1844405233860016,
-0.14264488220214844,
-0.6509990096092224,
0.021430188789963722,
-0.44156613945961,
0.23643824458122253,
-0.1276365965604782,
-0.33572670817375183,
0.6551739573478699,
-0.841908872127533,
1.0540380477905273,
-0.29835841059684753,
-0.18795019388198853,
0.3091903328895569,
0.01577240228652954,
0.6532148718833923,
-0.1708073914051056,
0.08185242861509323,
-0.026311488822102547,
-0.062051720917224884,
-0.4594908356666565,
-0.7589735388755798,
0.29935768246650696,
-0.9081040024757385,
-0.521087646484375,
-0.3272422254085541,
-0.6909397840499878,
-0.17797167599201202,
0.3697250485420227,
0.1379856914281845,
0.40119391679763794,
-0.14958716928958893,
-0.04602156952023506,
0.540635347366333,
0.1961120069026947,
0.6883519291877747,
0.6617627143859863,
-0.038929861038923264,
-0.2935779094696045,
1.0582412481307983,
0.30408936738967896,
0.5671083331108093,
0.5910890698432922,
0.09047728031873703,
-0.2291317880153656,
-0.44643595814704895,
-0.2412554770708084,
0.08920042961835861,
-0.820185124874115,
0.10060759633779526,
-0.4418613612651825,
-0.29896581172943115,
-0.1394122838973999,
-0.309989333152771,
-0.580804705619812,
-0.4255436658859253,
-0.21987754106521606,
0.15346643328666687,
0.3329582214355469,
0.6429264545440674,
0.09639697521924973,
0.48710897564888,
-0.7152524590492249,
0.17781417071819305,
0.4516861140727997,
0.17340189218521118,
-0.08463142067193985,
-0.7020025849342346,
-0.4941382110118866,
0.18013815581798553,
-0.3734249472618103,
-0.776818037033081,
0.30427873134613037,
0.7852878570556641,
0.6449629664421082,
0.6587114930152893,
0.11468388140201569,
0.22992071509361267,
-0.622631847858429,
0.3226475119590759,
-0.18169373273849487,
-0.86602783203125,
0.23096492886543274,
-0.28995221853256226,
0.10428079217672348,
0.41143059730529785,
0.4144812524318695,
-0.30219531059265137,
-0.5224779844284058,
-0.22567200660705566,
-0.8339031934738159,
0.9868666529655457,
0.1964559108018875,
0.314454048871994,
0.5002355575561523,
0.5441527962684631,
0.19649547338485718,
0.36672553420066833,
-0.8690488338470459,
-0.048165105283260345,
-0.31814536452293396,
-0.10552437603473663,
-0.26134389638900757,
0.1486688107252121,
-0.180559441447258,
-0.08470476418733597,
0.7983876466751099,
-0.4860151708126068,
0.28497985005378723,
0.00773864658549428,
-0.506066620349884,
-0.2075931429862976,
0.1271546185016632,
0.51494300365448,
0.7731785774230957,
-0.3169059157371521,
0.025808319449424744,
0.2727007269859314,
-0.47837886214256287,
0.4587397873401642,
0.23109199106693268,
-0.17616158723831177,
-0.35733646154403687,
0.5860072374343872,
0.7176056504249573,
0.09253285825252533,
-0.9512633085250854,
0.33527812361717224,
0.0732479840517044,
-0.25703608989715576,
-0.5830747485160828,
0.29380038380622864,
0.03423161059617996,
0.40593475103378296,
0.37999168038368225,
-0.0622565783560276,
0.004717836622148752,
-0.6181737780570984,
0.19402053952217102,
0.5235579013824463,
-0.5439403653144836,
-0.49212393164634705,
0.4547635316848755,
0.2482595443725586,
-0.6796626448631287,
0.377282977104187,
-0.5380607843399048,
-0.6605542302131653,
0.5632023215293884,
0.4479152262210846,
0.994620144367218,
-0.1840234249830246,
0.36365389823913574,
-0.27326443791389465,
0.3631577491760254,
-0.23598285019397736,
0.07960700243711472,
-0.09239702671766281,
-0.8502291440963745,
-0.28753605484962463,
-0.42139559984207153,
-0.46356135606765747,
-0.048494093120098114,
-0.44825080037117004,
0.38700228929519653,
-0.4354998767375946,
-0.21505920588970184,
-0.14982721209526062,
-0.14893729984760284,
-0.3172416687011719,
0.13549433648586273,
0.2842293381690979,
0.6890435814857483,
-0.6994591951370239,
0.9631328582763672,
1.0981615781784058,
-0.5206705331802368,
-0.7741039395332336,
0.1439405232667923,
-0.05130394175648689,
-0.9449055194854736,
0.5846814513206482,
0.2485641986131668,
-0.3119930028915405,
0.38627079129219055,
-0.4816250801086426,
-0.8516191244125366,
1.1642688512802124,
0.69981849193573,
-0.15504033863544464,
-0.3479798138141632,
0.44222140312194824,
0.631079912185669,
-0.40068957209587097,
0.500298261642456,
0.43289613723754883,
0.17386505007743835,
0.1445489525794983,
-0.7478362917900085,
0.0888289138674736,
-0.34698063135147095,
-0.008549670688807964,
0.25314855575561523,
-0.746776819229126,
0.9079919457435608,
-0.22927111387252808,
0.1537608653306961,
-0.11222334206104279,
0.22382642328739166,
-0.00830972008407116,
0.13845224678516388,
0.5873839855194092,
0.3385821282863617,
0.5310239195823669,
-0.015281287021934986,
0.8489504456520081,
-0.45082494616508484,
0.4323975145816803,
0.9263126850128174,
-0.5358931422233582,
0.7494488954544067,
0.48880496621131897,
-0.06523871421813965,
0.36536985635757446,
0.40717265009880066,
0.06440248340368271,
0.42248445749282837,
0.41195258498191833,
-0.08354417979717255,
-0.4410445988178253,
-0.08787799626588821,
-0.1562758833169937,
0.607786238193512,
-0.05753852054476738,
-0.016720889136195183,
-0.36064115166664124,
0.32493624091148376,
0.18029026687145233,
-0.04403595253825188,
-0.42141035199165344,
0.7894716858863831,
0.18722392618656158,
-0.4828813374042511,
0.7300774455070496,
0.10097796469926834,
0.35233789682388306,
-0.9371480941772461,
-0.07256533205509186,
-0.11990557610988617,
0.5092383027076721,
-0.024127712473273277,
-0.17434751987457275,
0.2716068625450134,
-0.27841976284980774,
0.11289025098085403,
-0.4947004020214081,
0.7011323571205139,
-0.42112427949905396,
-0.30180418491363525,
0.41240155696868896,
0.6629502773284912,
0.10895126312971115,
-0.28546011447906494,
-0.7478554248809814,
-0.2484731674194336,
-0.24904392659664154,
-0.46388450264930725,
0.4096231460571289,
0.17749887704849243,
-0.10881883651018143,
1.2132234573364258,
0.6240108609199524,
0.39073464274406433,
-0.017859891057014465,
0.020530618727207184,
0.9529899954795837,
-0.41600534319877625,
-0.6337324380874634,
-0.774870753288269,
0.4135836064815521,
0.1586945503950119,
-0.08554454892873764,
0.4991437792778015,
0.15674245357513428,
0.9292367100715637,
-0.17456021904945374,
0.6981272101402283,
-0.12377842515707016,
0.2978948652744293,
-0.4938511550426483,
1.0590989589691162,
-0.7921351194381714,
0.20590023696422577,
0.046867020428180695,
-1.0075956583023071,
-0.12901565432548523,
0.34278857707977295,
-0.2884993851184845,
0.4345177114009857,
0.6673744916915894,
0.8556229472160339,
0.16679322719573975,
-0.38591524958610535,
0.3244614601135254,
0.0966283529996872,
0.39667201042175293,
0.3468407690525055,
0.8378125429153442,
-0.15235501527786255,
0.6729978919029236,
-0.20142392814159393,
-0.22774134576320648,
-0.37885501980781555,
-0.7839203476905823,
-1.3161062002182007,
-0.49782103300094604,
-0.36699870228767395,
-0.0761176124215126,
0.2624276578426361,
1.267329216003418,
0.9004020094871521,
-0.6702580451965332,
-0.41188889741897583,
-0.28414830565452576,
0.016132231801748276,
-0.3735707998275757,
-0.16852453351020813,
0.18222111463546753,
-0.656818151473999,
-0.6395309567451477,
0.30187273025512695,
0.22212111949920654,
0.026730285957455635,
-0.3564865291118622,
-0.40179768204689026,
-0.09499629586935043,
0.2590295970439911,
0.44975945353507996,
0.5414215922355652,
-0.4592457115650177,
-0.07819975167512894,
-0.06957734376192093,
-0.06110835820436478,
0.07668814063072205,
0.9167797565460205,
-0.5479706525802612,
0.3758799731731415,
0.3810592293739319,
0.7696496844291687,
0.21555042266845703,
-0.12138016521930695,
0.596088171005249,
-0.6265714168548584,
0.3592880964279175,
0.2249191254377365,
0.17933723330497742,
0.38117948174476624,
-0.21386682987213135,
0.22793424129486084,
0.3327236473560333,
-0.49913060665130615,
-0.8879178762435913,
0.16656437516212463,
-0.6452631950378418,
-0.26284924149513245,
1.1079462766647339,
-0.4053988754749298,
-0.2499515861272812,
-0.33798423409461975,
-0.22190119326114655,
0.5977245569229126,
-0.35214853286743164,
0.7779949307441711,
0.34636518359184265,
-0.18287405371665955,
-0.1871112585067749,
-0.465250164270401,
0.7834076881408691,
0.24900422990322113,
-1.1448237895965576,
-0.11022916436195374,
-0.05849926546216011,
0.3319615125656128,
-0.0645122230052948,
0.6744488477706909,
0.21276775002479553,
0.14913220703601837,
0.0972394347190857,
0.46847987174987793,
-0.48256805539131165,
-0.3871525526046753,
-0.3379671573638916,
-0.003924975637346506,
0.4941118061542511,
-0.057639818638563156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11355v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11355v3 | Natural Language Counterfactuals through Representation Surgery | 2024-02-17T18:12:02 | 2024-05-07T17:58:17 | Matan Avitan, Ryan Cotterell, Yoav Goldberg, Shauli Ravfogel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Interventions targeting the representation space of language models (LMs)
have emerged as an effective means to influence model behavior. Such methods
are employed, for example, to eliminate or alter the encoding of demographic
information such as gender within the model's representations and, in so doing,
create a counterfactual representation. However, because the intervention
operates within the representation space, understanding precisely what aspects
of the text it modifies poses a challenge. In this paper, we give a method to
convert representation counterfactuals into string counterfactuals. We
demonstrate that this approach enables us to analyze the linguistic alterations
corresponding to a given representation space intervention and to interpret the
features utilized to encode a specific concept. Moreover, the resulting
counterfactuals can be used to mitigate bias in classification through data
augmentation. | [
-0.6012706756591797,
-1.2107994556427002,
0.4488024115562439,
-0.2787005305290222,
-0.31237584352493286,
0.15563660860061646,
-0.1094837635755539,
-0.33271101117134094,
0.4265395402908325,
0.8731321096420288,
-0.7920430302619934,
-0.2269386351108551,
-0.5141947269439697,
0.023080306127667427,
-0.5017114877700806,
1.2371896505355835,
-0.1066998541355133,
0.42648354172706604,
-0.3274098038673401,
-0.25821471214294434,
-0.6123635172843933,
-0.782600462436676,
-0.22328995168209076,
-0.39296820759773254,
0.3015210032463074,
0.14469915628433228,
0.6859204769134521,
0.625216543674469,
0.31229597330093384,
0.3664627969264984,
0.00953061692416668,
0.22534900903701782,
-0.4564851224422455,
-0.09644867479801178,
-0.30632269382476807,
-0.5986820459365845,
0.007539833430200815,
0.3850805461406708,
0.6817833781242371,
0.8993505239486694,
-0.2605586349964142,
-0.026971042156219482,
0.023595118895173073,
0.6659132838249207,
-0.12894782423973083,
-0.00023074769705999643,
-0.7278909683227539,
0.08181016147136688,
-0.14625731110572815,
-0.3142853081226349,
-0.28653836250305176,
-0.6483656167984009,
0.17657940089702606,
-0.4243932068347931,
0.3718075752258301,
0.07457982748746872,
0.650115430355072,
0.2633926570415497,
-0.5642345547676086,
-0.35148441791534424,
-0.8745810389518738,
0.6917315125465393,
-0.6222755312919617,
0.3033459782600403,
0.4021925926208496,
0.10398829728364944,
-0.3753748834133148,
-0.24972184002399445,
-0.5473531484603882,
-0.13539865612983704,
-0.5801851153373718,
-0.33360034227371216,
-0.5817980170249939,
0.154474139213562,
0.5026700496673584,
0.19604426622390747,
-0.6967958807945251,
-0.12102539092302322,
-0.32783570885658264,
-0.3836602568626404,
0.5444991588592529,
-0.029517192393541336,
0.745453953742981,
-0.19774821400642395,
-0.11991068720817566,
-0.06475794315338135,
-0.9117459654808044,
-0.2716559171676636,
0.4791622757911682,
0.315102756023407,
0.11127261072397232,
0.7879677414894104,
0.23469221591949463,
0.5911628603935242,
0.32260408997535706,
0.3264901340007782,
0.18218761682510376,
-0.19055283069610596,
-0.4037363827228546,
0.3932865262031555,
0.4980088472366333,
0.13783155381679535,
0.1825585812330246,
0.22567112743854523,
-0.05286293104290962,
0.43576592206954956,
0.6199262142181396,
-0.6222386360168457,
0.04876430332660675,
-0.0159250907599926,
-0.4772304594516754,
-0.21324366331100464,
-0.24734506011009216,
-0.466540664434433,
-0.5188501477241516,
-0.23185744881629944,
0.2793995440006256,
-0.4851592779159546,
-0.12902851402759552,
-0.05987203121185303,
-0.20397505164146423,
-0.18594211339950562,
0.13328014314174652,
-0.9172835350036621,
0.3733546733856201,
0.6084190607070923,
0.5572434663772583,
0.47171884775161743,
0.4221063554286957,
-0.4418269991874695,
0.1355160027742386,
-0.6465945839881897,
0.6463088393211365,
-1.0327253341674805,
-0.591640055179596,
-0.0165563952177763,
0.2395378202199936,
-0.28353792428970337,
-0.6116671562194824,
0.35150593519210815,
-0.26356515288352966,
0.5328001379966736,
-0.4263824224472046,
-0.8544282913208008,
-0.5477869510650635,
0.2934962511062622,
-0.7637900710105896,
0.7744272351264954,
0.18804305791854858,
-0.6133072376251221,
0.20886549353599548,
-0.7858960032463074,
-0.3722158968448639,
-0.02981845661997795,
-0.4174644947052002,
-0.5251635909080505,
0.4405585527420044,
0.34738677740097046,
0.1162676215171814,
0.10801012814044952,
0.5684273838996887,
-0.2113947570323944,
-0.36094585061073303,
0.4691077768802643,
-0.5070585608482361,
0.5837782621383667,
-0.006765103433281183,
-0.11832946538925171,
0.23258841037750244,
-0.5637678503990173,
-0.5841036438941956,
0.037201642990112305,
0.028437567874789238,
-0.874395489692688,
-0.022933362051844597,
-0.165445476770401,
-0.05377902090549469,
0.09082552790641785,
-0.9030277729034424,
0.42862793803215027,
-0.8131475448608398,
0.31611210107803345,
0.3277643620967865,
0.1084919273853302,
0.5368753671646118,
-0.08002715557813644,
0.5183417201042175,
0.17394818365573883,
-0.029428355395793915,
-0.15607592463493347,
-0.6499252319335938,
-0.5739184021949768,
-0.01392463780939579,
0.13635201752185822,
0.425184965133667,
-1.3531075716018677,
0.22180993854999542,
-0.03755494952201843,
-0.4191058278083801,
-0.5314717292785645,
0.15940850973129272,
0.5778770446777344,
0.725049614906311,
0.3530958294868469,
-0.33320191502571106,
-1.0233750343322754,
-1.0831700563430786,
-0.7543779015541077,
-0.46219998598098755,
0.03548944741487503,
0.22467829287052155,
0.44815072417259216,
-0.29715991020202637,
1.076978087425232,
-0.6438015103340149,
-0.4043903350830078,
-0.09964218735694885,
0.6284610033035278,
0.3001166582107544,
0.8020530343055725,
0.9024167656898499,
-0.8289937973022461,
-0.023020364344120026,
-0.046674296259880066,
-0.6860039830207825,
-0.1535044014453888,
-0.2684600353240967,
0.2579058110713959,
0.4750603437423706,
0.7582008838653564,
-0.664782702922821,
0.6999230980873108,
0.5930702686309814,
-0.5261626839637756,
0.44849804043769836,
-0.34988269209861755,
0.40358853340148926,
-0.37886232137680054,
-0.012246154248714447,
0.1693011075258255,
-0.23999810218811035,
-1.0115954875946045,
0.0413176603615284,
0.086058609187603,
-0.04723368212580681,
-0.4190167188644409,
0.46221351623535156,
-0.17766501009464264,
0.021772930398583412,
0.00038265259354375303,
-0.15758539736270905,
-0.1282566487789154,
0.3666607737541199,
0.3082773983478546,
0.7257348895072937,
-0.02601180598139763,
-0.14698876440525055,
0.017933402210474014,
0.1428118795156479,
-0.17684222757816315,
0.7212653160095215,
-0.4550836980342865,
0.2916285991668701,
-0.5056520104408264,
0.3859644830226898,
-1.198379397392273,
0.006987716071307659,
0.6054967641830444,
-0.46342387795448303,
0.15853500366210938,
-0.37485837936401367,
-0.3408341407775879,
-0.4374752938747406,
-0.31685870885849,
0.23884548246860504,
0.24768345057964325,
-0.24085643887519836,
0.6659841537475586,
0.3595896363258362,
0.01532026194036007,
-0.3100222647190094,
-0.903399646282196,
0.25744685530662537,
-0.3669201731681824,
-0.11963340640068054,
0.18753460049629211,
-0.17857211828231812,
-0.1977437436580658,
0.07286030799150467,
-0.1054941862821579,
0.041680555790662766,
-0.01264260709285736,
0.05168949067592621,
0.4545785188674927,
-0.20787577331066132,
0.2995142936706543,
0.4808303117752075,
0.02776259556412697,
0.13902005553245544,
-0.2239423543214798,
0.3627449572086334,
0.32761380076408386,
-0.385629802942276,
-0.05334838479757309,
0.44109711050987244,
0.07763852924108505,
-0.01937260851264,
0.6953413486480713,
0.6667351722717285,
-0.6346951723098755,
0.0825243815779686,
-0.5640195608139038,
-0.37654873728752136,
-0.4802395701408386,
0.4282775819301605,
-0.2310018241405487,
-1.0172410011291504,
0.46755391359329224,
-0.09789677709341049,
0.02816368266940117,
0.3516983985900879,
0.12659558653831482,
-0.33349281549453735,
1.3295624256134033,
0.34808725118637085,
0.31303080916404724,
0.6477656364440918,
0.04155145213007927,
0.15556155145168304,
-0.7834645509719849,
-0.12642087042331696,
-0.6300309896469116,
-0.17508910596370697,
-0.6710050106048584,
-0.6115908026695251,
0.4011988639831543,
-0.11052761971950531,
-0.18109512329101562,
0.6202210187911987,
-0.410550057888031,
0.2850354313850403,
0.186033695936203,
0.2474304884672165,
-0.026881365105509758,
0.12652690708637238,
-0.12548886239528656,
-0.6167841553688049,
-0.6403177380561829,
-0.6358510851860046,
0.8851583003997803,
0.4804622530937195,
0.3867766261100769,
0.19295263290405273,
0.5276663899421692,
0.4523828327655792,
0.6664514541625977,
-0.6146588325500488,
0.6289997696876526,
-0.7694776058197021,
-0.6145951747894287,
-0.21845455467700958,
-0.45612069964408875,
-0.8544167280197144,
0.2868739664554596,
-0.40138813853263855,
-0.9945096969604492,
0.5141738653182983,
0.40568941831588745,
-0.07726383954286575,
0.4097987115383148,
-0.794420599937439,
0.7203642129898071,
0.04490400105714798,
-0.10890176892280579,
-0.440630704164505,
-0.22744949162006378,
0.42651328444480896,
-0.0637432336807251,
0.578331470489502,
0.334685742855072,
0.019790949299931526,
0.7984762191772461,
-0.4755576550960541,
1.20235013961792,
-0.39463549852371216,
-0.5494606494903564,
0.10382964462041855,
0.43384185433387756,
0.45612236857414246,
-0.03491423651576042,
-0.02462247759103775,
0.2582513689994812,
-0.13122078776359558,
-0.08450300246477127,
-1.0653831958770752,
0.5535864233970642,
-0.5149259567260742,
-0.8061568140983582,
-0.2353621870279312,
-0.5137358903884888,
-0.40283942222595215,
-0.07502295821905136,
-0.2714218497276306,
0.6537837386131287,
-0.6601040959358215,
0.06959883123636246,
0.807511031627655,
-0.5366696119308472,
0.4475634694099426,
0.45767658948898315,
-0.4344535171985626,
-0.24056382477283478,
0.8381211161613464,
0.2840014696121216,
0.041892725974321365,
0.3116292357444763,
0.325246661901474,
-0.6635157465934753,
-0.4449197053909302,
-0.6702511310577393,
0.02342691458761692,
-0.7461771965026855,
0.16315951943397522,
-0.6354163289070129,
-0.06910008192062378,
-0.36493757367134094,
0.10766724497079849,
-0.10866425186395645,
-0.3262505829334259,
-0.5026125907897949,
-0.02904662862420082,
0.15110601484775543,
0.90423583984375,
-0.04816542565822601,
0.5883872509002686,
-0.9115796089172363,
0.5774704813957214,
0.38205981254577637,
0.2660435736179352,
-0.19390064477920532,
-0.5175744891166687,
-0.1753472238779068,
0.2781074345111847,
0.09280940145254135,
-1.089401364326477,
0.6310563087463379,
0.12726843357086182,
0.5775918960571289,
0.2782241702079773,
-0.1318972110748291,
0.8415502309799194,
-0.5407288074493408,
0.8044607043266296,
0.2603214681148529,
-1.1518936157226562,
0.6551737785339355,
-0.3538700044155121,
0.4095225930213928,
0.07169152796268463,
0.2732984721660614,
-0.7867941856384277,
-0.41973599791526794,
-0.5884088277816772,
-0.47406625747680664,
0.7684072256088257,
0.15232005715370178,
0.4413175582885742,
0.040938474237918854,
0.2786560356616974,
0.16397686302661896,
0.4431048333644867,
-0.47780942916870117,
-0.1675168126821518,
-0.47469034790992737,
-0.36941394209861755,
-0.14426705241203308,
-0.334181547164917,
-0.3625546097755432,
-0.22019581496715546,
0.5483297109603882,
-0.2811875641345978,
0.024702003225684166,
0.25317826867103577,
-0.42538392543792725,
-0.267604261636734,
0.4799034297466278,
0.9901692271232605,
0.3853082060813904,
-0.278594434261322,
0.22719930112361908,
0.20686371624469757,
-0.5800716876983643,
0.14231941103935242,
0.027252275496721268,
-0.2713727653026581,
0.3148420453071594,
0.5429731011390686,
0.8997119665145874,
0.2995173931121826,
-0.46689099073410034,
0.0865984782576561,
-0.08363860845565796,
-0.09903834760189056,
0.05542854219675064,
-0.08635156601667404,
0.029950495809316635,
-0.0014488057931885123,
0.5240861773490906,
0.29295533895492554,
0.3554708957672119,
-0.8598548769950867,
0.29416176676750183,
0.4739990234375,
-0.8112324476242065,
-0.26010751724243164,
0.29837101697921753,
0.15913547575473785,
-0.42238089442253113,
0.2535369098186493,
-0.02199358120560646,
-0.7203560471534729,
0.5750086903572083,
0.5010601282119751,
0.837052047252655,
-0.5181339979171753,
0.5792968273162842,
0.4993213713169098,
0.5525625944137573,
0.27540600299835205,
0.2407097965478897,
0.2885563373565674,
-0.8089427351951599,
-0.4126640558242798,
-0.14366725087165833,
-0.028170224279165268,
0.11167503893375397,
-0.490373432636261,
-0.10319102555513382,
-0.5209874510765076,
-0.07260047644376755,
0.06862839311361313,
-0.2869051992893219,
-0.4278578460216522,
0.36875173449516296,
0.201629176735878,
0.46678099036216736,
-1.0936774015426636,
0.7834440469741821,
0.8773587942123413,
-0.2535743713378906,
-0.3567228317260742,
-0.019753409549593925,
0.34354954957962036,
-0.8185900449752808,
0.7286120653152466,
-0.10556396096944809,
0.030213693156838417,
-0.443926066160202,
-0.676323652267456,
-0.5819801092147827,
0.08861246705055237,
0.6155112981796265,
-1.1720285415649414,
0.18893636763095856,
0.4921718239784241,
0.8635569214820862,
-0.4844483435153961,
0.4526709318161011,
0.647544264793396,
0.5644014477729797,
-0.1562628597021103,
-0.9492677450180054,
0.38016262650489807,
0.03553099185228348,
0.2079700231552124,
0.1516871154308319,
0.0823577344417572,
0.7129358053207397,
0.11457087099552155,
-0.3399396538734436,
-0.26954883337020874,
0.5016971826553345,
0.16458959877490997,
-0.015988122671842575,
0.9499063491821289,
0.2212449312210083,
0.5545876622200012,
-0.26102757453918457,
0.9662361145019531,
0.05585985630750656,
0.31053152680397034,
0.8658091425895691,
0.03836881369352341,
0.5233168601989746,
0.9485626220703125,
-0.07506515085697174,
0.7648714184761047,
0.48662006855010986,
0.022341854870319366,
0.39993396401405334,
0.3764280080795288,
0.07871250808238983,
-0.40178611874580383,
-0.5193108916282654,
-0.15325713157653809,
0.5095529556274414,
0.7725182771682739,
-0.3116472661495209,
-0.203628808259964,
0.3230825662612915,
0.19437600672245026,
0.6108803749084473,
-0.40175768733024597,
0.8861134648323059,
0.10794271528720856,
-0.47073864936828613,
0.5112887024879456,
-0.16397139430046082,
0.6475353240966797,
-0.467647910118103,
-0.7763109803199768,
-0.05375143885612488,
-0.07312522083520889,
-0.3226355314254761,
-0.8500824570655823,
0.6280685663223267,
-0.20557068288326263,
-0.04455254599452019,
-0.3115997612476349,
0.770832896232605,
-0.8573632836341858,
-0.740322470664978,
0.1270289123058319,
0.3102591037750244,
-0.12031374871730804,
0.13525550067424774,
-0.7347229719161987,
0.27757224440574646,
0.12017826735973358,
-0.02107132412493229,
0.15124085545539856,
0.08842689543962479,
-0.5088899731636047,
0.5777572989463806,
0.703758180141449,
0.25797006487846375,
-0.5012024641036987,
0.356279581785202,
0.7675303816795349,
-0.7094093561172485,
-0.6493596434593201,
-0.8782448768615723,
0.22907358407974243,
-0.22263172268867493,
-0.04862794280052185,
0.6859351992607117,
0.23269641399383545,
0.8287011981010437,
-0.16943064332008362,
0.5990889072418213,
0.11242944747209549,
0.5973915457725525,
-0.531495988368988,
0.8095691204071045,
-0.519446074962616,
0.5520562529563904,
-0.5592597723007202,
-0.5242615342140198,
-0.2497655153274536,
0.46600258350372314,
-0.5498093366622925,
-0.05529370903968811,
0.5265032649040222,
0.7649116516113281,
0.05918515846133232,
0.2052733302116394,
0.22562377154827118,
0.3175571858882904,
0.3648108243942261,
0.24525292217731476,
0.7165899276733398,
-0.4691699147224426,
0.35684511065483093,
0.02457919903099537,
0.19460025429725647,
-0.032089561223983765,
-0.7515316009521484,
-0.9415488839149475,
-0.5874955654144287,
-0.488210529088974,
-0.03412695229053497,
0.15728531777858734,
0.905368447303772,
0.5407542586326599,
-0.9725044965744019,
-0.10205162316560745,
0.07876332104206085,
0.45605653524398804,
-0.15543191134929657,
-0.2082797735929489,
0.33770331740379333,
0.16339899599552155,
-0.7205485701560974,
0.5475994348526001,
0.1087174043059349,
0.14961954951286316,
-0.5274960994720459,
0.06415864080190659,
-0.3774603605270386,
0.34939369559288025,
0.47293606400489807,
0.0015794364735484123,
-0.9065890908241272,
-0.7250112295150757,
-0.19142653048038483,
0.1596480906009674,
0.09392908215522766,
1.1648995876312256,
-1.0224822759628296,
0.6492481827735901,
0.4607737064361572,
0.46141308546066284,
0.32429569959640503,
0.0058181933127343655,
1.080281376838684,
-1.1984537839889526,
0.09228846430778503,
0.08273276686668396,
0.3908118009567261,
0.518753707408905,
-0.5441301465034485,
0.3578774333000183,
0.3369390070438385,
0.2696780562400818,
-1.0456172227859497,
0.2770337760448456,
-0.519788920879364,
-0.703802764415741,
0.8367578387260437,
-0.15537278354167938,
-0.23665408790111542,
-0.49199923872947693,
-0.618541955947876,
0.40692970156669617,
-0.34486889839172363,
0.6083387732505798,
0.5710498690605164,
-0.03245965391397476,
-0.43687671422958374,
-0.25969675183296204,
0.6209458112716675,
0.5654817223548889,
-0.7361727356910706,
-0.02290225960314274,
0.4383489191532135,
0.22216735780239105,
0.2695613205432892,
0.3993981182575226,
-0.1940268576145172,
0.045309361070394516,
-0.0703236386179924,
0.05058727413415909,
0.09892433136701584,
0.20472776889801025,
-0.6393899917602539,
0.01181652769446373,
-0.397604763507843,
-0.06564592570066452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11353v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11353v1 | Understanding the Impact of Long-Term Memory on Self-Disclosure with Large Language Model-Driven Chatbots for Public Health Intervention | 2024-02-17T18:05:53 | 2024-02-17T18:05:53 | Eunkyung Jo, Yuin Jeong, SoHyun Park, Daniel A. Epstein, Young-Ho Kim | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, H.5.2; I.2.7 | Recent large language models (LLMs) offer the potential to support public
health monitoring by facilitating health disclosure through open-ended
conversations but rarely preserve the knowledge gained about individuals across
repeated interactions. Augmenting LLMs with long-term memory (LTM) presents an
opportunity to improve engagement and self-disclosure, but we lack an
understanding of how LTM impacts people's interaction with LLM-driven chatbots
in public health interventions. We examine the case of CareCall -- an
LLM-driven voice chatbot with LTM -- through the analysis of 1,252 call logs
and interviews with nine users. We found that LTM enhanced health disclosure
and fostered positive perceptions of the chatbot by offering familiarity.
However, we also observed challenges in promoting self-disclosure through LTM,
particularly around addressing chronic health conditions and privacy concerns.
We discuss considerations for LTM integration in LLM-driven chatbots for public
health monitoring, including carefully deciding what topics need to be
remembered in light of public health goals. | [
0.1416940540075302,
-0.7399280667304993,
0.8817018866539001,
0.14095859229564667,
0.05554908514022827,
-0.046918753534555435,
-0.3460274338722229,
-0.7297288179397583,
0.34329041838645935,
0.8179448246955872,
-0.2141377478837967,
-0.6742087006568909,
-0.3635064661502838,
-0.3105882704257965,
-0.278837651014328,
0.9269149899482727,
-0.025617476552724838,
-0.12642303109169006,
-0.2150329202413559,
0.0493684746325016,
-0.5845896005630493,
-0.9808680415153503,
-0.8744500279426575,
-0.42748522758483887,
1.0449764728546143,
0.2277412861585617,
0.5623189806938171,
0.3512756824493408,
0.3776324689388275,
0.1620553731918335,
-0.18276353180408478,
-0.08610169589519501,
-0.9319697618484497,
0.08953021466732025,
-0.2198891043663025,
-0.5794397592544556,
-0.5732429623603821,
-0.16437557339668274,
0.6267755031585693,
0.42319148778915405,
-0.27729928493499756,
0.1901448518037796,
0.07714319974184036,
0.7059763669967651,
-0.5558215379714966,
0.2829587757587433,
-0.2798069417476654,
0.19486302137374878,
-0.11003172397613525,
-0.2429487705230713,
-0.5844763517379761,
-0.18689070641994476,
0.2524678707122803,
-0.108355812728405,
-0.2256147265434265,
-0.26031333208084106,
0.3362467586994171,
0.378413587808609,
-0.49085450172424316,
-0.41922399401664734,
-1.1415841579437256,
0.7070261240005493,
-0.8119637370109558,
0.3299417495727539,
0.6965340375900269,
0.20885099470615387,
-0.4060039222240448,
-0.5346713066101074,
-0.19592508673667908,
-0.18555279076099396,
-0.10985582321882248,
0.2127077430486679,
-0.47241827845573425,
0.22577373683452606,
0.1134750097990036,
0.06727427244186401,
-0.3577308654785156,
0.2492177039384842,
-0.5563377737998962,
-0.21636135876178741,
0.5968830585479736,
0.19619356095790863,
0.2076546549797058,
-0.1706773042678833,
-0.3224673271179199,
0.4273192882537842,
-0.5548413991928101,
-0.10854799300432205,
-0.09082671254873276,
0.19336019456386566,
-0.30494552850723267,
0.4010269045829773,
0.05745803937315941,
0.29415255784988403,
-0.21797038614749908,
-0.24743066728115082,
0.20386949181556702,
-0.2396782636642456,
-0.12449386715888977,
0.25309211015701294,
0.8623195290565491,
0.4399775266647339,
0.27301543951034546,
-0.16757993400096893,
0.1441655158996582,
-0.1539306491613388,
0.3400646150112152,
-0.9064650535583496,
-0.1326644867658615,
0.47899129986763,
-0.7118234038352966,
0.04624047130346298,
-0.28809475898742676,
-0.6128543019294739,
-0.47040408849716187,
-0.13485369086265564,
0.44429540634155273,
-0.3064486086368561,
-0.32520776987075806,
0.5084235072135925,
0.2517433166503906,
-0.16078799962997437,
0.4537770450115204,
-0.7830801606178284,
0.539109468460083,
0.7430394887924194,
0.8404130935668945,
-0.3225420117378235,
0.08766696602106094,
-0.38527777791023254,
0.4088344871997833,
-0.166507750749588,
0.4297163486480713,
-0.3606264293193817,
-0.6360247731208801,
0.09793219715356827,
0.03929098695516586,
-0.10110324621200562,
-0.6829889416694641,
0.1117834597826004,
-0.23200763761997223,
0.2621375024318695,
-0.07795701920986176,
-0.5742682814598083,
0.11086215823888779,
0.10444343835115433,
-0.27605369687080383,
0.6395251154899597,
-0.07106511294841766,
-0.5602440237998962,
-0.06036347895860672,
-0.7170117497444153,
-0.4700723886489868,
0.11972679197788239,
-0.21981380879878998,
-0.4147147536277771,
0.10536342114210129,
0.08933057636022568,
0.6436858773231506,
-0.009082128293812275,
0.3173973262310028,
-0.2136458158493042,
-0.336860716342926,
0.48950085043907166,
-0.7254125475883484,
0.4641241133213043,
0.12825079262256622,
0.01007160171866417,
0.17946921288967133,
-0.2536775767803192,
-0.09066221117973328,
0.020256491377949715,
-0.30172282457351685,
-0.2651509642601013,
0.024306345731019974,
-0.12776309251785278,
0.012074760161340237,
0.5540292859077454,
-0.43902358412742615,
-0.03449443727731705,
-0.5357107520103455,
0.6327422857284546,
0.5683348178863525,
0.25804832577705383,
0.04754311963915825,
-0.5517646670341492,
0.4929102659225464,
0.05496875196695328,
0.6099575161933899,
-0.596514880657196,
-0.33046838641166687,
-0.25970444083213806,
-0.21236304938793182,
0.1743587702512741,
0.3285454511642456,
0.09752729535102844,
0.32014334201812744,
-0.27458852529525757,
-0.37273362278938293,
-0.4157860279083252,
0.07881578803062439,
0.22798384726047516,
0.38171297311782837,
0.305015504360199,
-0.12956325709819794,
-0.13623149693012238,
-1.014284372329712,
-0.12359907478094101,
-0.20513169467449188,
-0.017387783154845238,
0.8568037748336792,
0.3599030673503876,
-0.44813480973243713,
0.8598743677139282,
-0.5940847992897034,
-0.45760104060173035,
-0.29802441596984863,
-0.008782667107880116,
0.24136365950107574,
0.24364523589611053,
0.3550548851490021,
-0.6569428443908691,
-0.2880149185657501,
-0.2975091338157654,
-0.38415777683258057,
0.18611466884613037,
-0.25422635674476624,
0.2776584327220917,
-0.05137959495186806,
0.2896503210067749,
-0.631142795085907,
0.6765546202659607,
0.9406465888023376,
-0.026595639064908028,
0.4387410581111908,
-0.6494043469429016,
-0.0072965980507433414,
-1.2790563106536865,
0.09247568994760513,
-0.0335296168923378,
-0.3504575192928314,
-0.6897116303443909,
-0.5849637389183044,
0.02702980302274227,
-0.2110816091299057,
-0.7865467071533203,
0.8078988790512085,
-0.4072036147117615,
0.07864584028720856,
-0.3822118639945984,
0.0011455146595835686,
-0.23799492418766022,
0.07788144052028656,
-0.06159422546625137,
0.7693114280700684,
0.39484065771102905,
-0.42920202016830444,
-0.019661124795675278,
-0.08071228861808777,
-0.1208067312836647,
0.2170305997133255,
-0.5650553107261658,
0.3826645314693451,
-0.12906816601753235,
0.5078412294387817,
-0.9439959526062012,
-0.23483414947986603,
0.45376959443092346,
-0.2574078440666199,
0.06895959377288818,
-0.05643326789140701,
-0.5916857719421387,
-0.4987265169620514,
-0.06554988026618958,
0.37200653553009033,
0.475808709859848,
-0.3536948561668396,
0.43308329582214355,
0.7190413475036621,
-0.12399353832006454,
-0.03886310011148453,
-0.7609691023826599,
0.20263811945915222,
-0.40152299404144287,
-0.3598751127719879,
0.23908556997776031,
-0.1853565126657486,
-0.13974983990192413,
-0.11953793466091156,
-0.2089080810546875,
-0.022155266255140305,
0.0533129908144474,
0.5719456076622009,
0.12724106013774872,
0.06840046495199203,
0.683643639087677,
-0.30365073680877686,
-0.03941084444522858,
0.39663755893707275,
0.07930313795804977,
0.8341385722160339,
-0.07089435309171677,
-0.487909734249115,
-1.014536738395691,
0.42344626784324646,
0.519416093826294,
0.0604318268597126,
0.7904201149940491,
0.23135843873023987,
-0.3463513255119324,
0.21204529702663422,
-0.7011592984199524,
-0.35934561491012573,
-0.44040626287460327,
0.159772589802742,
0.14762026071548462,
-1.1211265325546265,
0.3714807629585266,
-0.30644533038139343,
-0.05879078805446625,
-0.09760306775569916,
0.5748106241226196,
-0.5028904676437378,
0.7853496074676514,
0.36713844537734985,
-0.6408524513244629,
0.36005863547325134,
0.20061078667640686,
0.07759268581867218,
-0.7560522556304932,
-0.0911693423986435,
-0.1271694451570511,
-0.22522751986980438,
-0.6175514459609985,
-0.7310387492179871,
0.4497183859348297,
-0.23351845145225525,
-0.15263506770133972,
-0.12861093878746033,
-0.22543689608573914,
0.21304571628570557,
0.28162819147109985,
0.6938155293464661,
0.2581348121166229,
-0.35185280442237854,
0.5166230797767639,
-0.1816355288028717,
-0.532467782497406,
-0.27241280674934387,
0.9544509649276733,
0.7252657413482666,
1.2983424663543701,
-0.04976648464798927,
1.151140570640564,
0.32214534282684326,
0.24264375865459442,
-0.8368018269538879,
0.3762842118740082,
-0.05759434774518013,
-0.34344613552093506,
-0.31217288970947266,
-0.40802711248397827,
-1.4363107681274414,
-0.3110886216163635,
0.08476603031158447,
-1.107348084449768,
-0.24539335072040558,
0.4765814542770386,
-0.661892831325531,
0.020180003717541695,
-0.5360431671142578,
0.544871985912323,
-0.637310802936554,
-0.16731666028499603,
-0.806099534034729,
-0.5787806510925293,
0.035005826503038406,
-0.11750184744596481,
0.3094026744365692,
-0.2682364583015442,
0.18436551094055176,
0.6943551898002625,
-0.10809699445962906,
1.4706079959869385,
0.10580522567033768,
-0.21422861516475677,
0.19538997113704681,
-0.2704865038394928,
0.4519839882850647,
0.15552237629890442,
0.18599088490009308,
0.30496448278427124,
-0.017402930185198784,
-0.15475153923034668,
-0.43912845849990845,
0.841593861579895,
-0.6928228139877319,
-1.146576166152954,
-0.29547762870788574,
-0.5562090277671814,
-0.3307921886444092,
0.20525847375392914,
-0.44761723279953003,
0.32382023334503174,
-0.3662022054195404,
0.358627051115036,
0.9737310409545898,
-0.629817545413971,
0.149346262216568,
0.5532670021057129,
-0.6599445343017578,
-0.06704208254814148,
0.49344196915626526,
0.03648753464221954,
0.5646216869354248,
0.39588284492492676,
0.7674750685691833,
-0.19217555224895477,
-0.13984009623527527,
0.2431839555501938,
0.6933867335319519,
-0.40234681963920593,
0.02191011980175972,
-0.8627736568450928,
-0.5839734077453613,
-0.38893604278564453,
0.11307748407125473,
-0.47714728116989136,
0.0070369793102145195,
-0.5612927079200745,
0.08181346207857132,
0.6394022107124329,
0.7729843854904175,
-0.188227578997612,
0.21394653618335724,
-0.8154617547988892,
0.45708778500556946,
0.3520432710647583,
0.3062305152416229,
0.06300266087055206,
-0.19809411466121674,
-0.32600992918014526,
0.22899770736694336,
-0.05866685137152672,
-0.9786949753761292,
0.33764970302581787,
-0.1028607189655304,
0.45758289098739624,
0.44051435589790344,
-0.03500806540250778,
0.5917640328407288,
-0.4280666410923004,
0.708236038684845,
0.36123985052108765,
-0.6310225129127502,
0.7213771343231201,
-0.47248539328575134,
0.8202626705169678,
0.26704999804496765,
0.3169001042842865,
-1.094243049621582,
-0.4063864052295685,
-0.49895593523979187,
-0.7495695948600769,
0.3066782057285309,
-0.13840578496456146,
0.5339917540550232,
-0.30108463764190674,
0.16511785984039307,
-0.136573925614357,
0.09652085602283478,
-0.5313052535057068,
-0.40366342663764954,
0.09835287928581238,
0.012576785869896412,
0.055222224444150925,
-0.6836220622062683,
-0.3659858703613281,
0.010088714770972729,
0.09993605315685272,
0.13051104545593262,
0.28515520691871643,
0.33083483576774597,
0.20726409554481506,
0.05386236682534218,
0.5895062685012817,
0.553750216960907,
0.6158764958381653,
-0.1260763704776764,
0.1427881121635437,
0.13612793385982513,
-0.30870938301086426,
-0.20306459069252014,
-0.23807267844676971,
0.13080236315727234,
-0.06723429262638092,
0.17784777283668518,
0.5038795471191406,
0.744804859161377,
-0.737762987613678,
0.43868690729141235,
0.20263615250587463,
0.07989641278982162,
-0.5025226473808289,
0.09623483568429947,
0.7920324206352234,
0.13566605746746063,
0.16641190648078918,
-0.5039631128311157,
0.0813511312007904,
-0.7075414657592773,
0.2666552662849426,
0.41849371790885925,
-0.5166406035423279,
-0.21566343307495117,
0.7266297936439514,
0.11590898036956787,
-0.39844536781311035,
0.4765167236328125,
0.48831912875175476,
-0.27484697103500366,
0.38399672508239746,
0.7405778765678406,
0.45954522490501404,
-0.5659376978874207,
0.1276218742132187,
0.25533366203308105,
-0.011704133823513985,
-0.058655671775341034,
0.23257668316364288,
0.0604056641459465,
-0.5791167616844177,
-0.47709041833877563,
-0.12212222814559937,
-0.4673590660095215,
0.3328808546066284,
-0.8174527287483215,
-0.08502563089132309,
-0.3842428922653198,
-0.5421046018600464,
-0.08242234587669373,
-0.16638341546058655,
-0.7881361842155457,
0.08359435200691223,
0.42116498947143555,
0.8535308241844177,
-0.5390148162841797,
0.9758837819099426,
0.050429705530405045,
-0.05075455084443092,
-0.6796321272850037,
0.17454279959201813,
0.2321869432926178,
-1.0103764533996582,
0.683556079864502,
0.4072129726409912,
-0.25988733768463135,
-0.2331257164478302,
-0.33630603551864624,
-0.8247374296188354,
1.0539802312850952,
0.20879791676998138,
-0.9954208135604858,
0.05976274982094765,
0.5157445073127747,
0.7968885898590088,
-0.2603107988834381,
0.09682056307792664,
0.20985926687717438,
0.476413369178772,
-0.05644337087869644,
-1.3161154985427856,
-0.07140322774648666,
0.3907282054424286,
0.09601102769374847,
0.24464012682437897,
-1.0957386493682861,
0.3494262993335724,
-0.3269815742969513,
-0.4380965232849121,
-0.19362130761146545,
0.5798677206039429,
0.00435052253305912,
0.22170346975326538,
0.3712960183620453,
0.2294616997241974,
0.9125136137008667,
0.4161684513092041,
0.8534855246543884,
-0.2896510660648346,
0.16776615381240845,
1.6052523851394653,
-0.3364218473434448,
1.0188171863555908,
0.5252357721328735,
-0.0877692773938179,
0.23528830707073212,
0.24226993322372437,
0.1834179162979126,
0.2760019898414612,
0.3559722900390625,
-0.5247927904129028,
-0.08192436397075653,
-0.3749487102031708,
-0.37744441628456116,
0.37740764021873474,
0.6799054741859436,
-0.6756125092506409,
-0.2632001042366028,
0.28425344824790955,
0.3211919963359833,
0.030808962881565094,
-0.30741041898727417,
0.8309881687164307,
0.28771036863327026,
-0.31824854016304016,
0.1923052966594696,
-0.6548460721969604,
0.5137841105461121,
-0.5887421369552612,
-0.16716614365577698,
0.0628875270485878,
0.002360915532335639,
-0.04513023421168327,
-1.0453394651412964,
0.30677127838134766,
-0.31435856223106384,
-0.31212475895881653,
-0.38256600499153137,
0.8602951169013977,
-0.5793554782867432,
-0.18676629662513733,
0.7194440960884094,
0.5902799367904663,
0.44439202547073364,
-0.15620598196983337,
-0.6945351958274841,
0.23801358044147491,
-0.11988377571105957,
-0.25714242458343506,
0.48304638266563416,
0.06269050389528275,
0.03437897190451622,
1.000932216644287,
0.6817799210548401,
0.3788844048976898,
-0.3028141260147095,
0.17949387431144714,
0.6557686924934387,
-0.8357338905334473,
-0.17096781730651855,
-0.9439697861671448,
0.08113672584295273,
0.09276214241981506,
-0.05251277983188629,
0.6445022225379944,
0.6705516576766968,
0.4465790390968323,
0.11201900988817215,
0.8745760321617126,
0.484567254781723,
0.7031556367874146,
-0.513364851474762,
0.9457129836082458,
-0.2997310161590576,
0.1404966115951538,
0.3556186258792877,
-0.13868339359760284,
-0.09868240356445312,
0.15616510808467865,
-0.5405279994010925,
-0.21572758257389069,
0.3628634214401245,
0.7850980162620544,
0.25985434651374817,
-0.2419823706150055,
0.6174483299255371,
0.541594922542572,
0.533621072769165,
0.6740040183067322,
0.6184672713279724,
0.09227564185857773,
0.4382597804069519,
-0.08520353585481644,
0.008502420969307423,
-0.33837661147117615,
-0.7612618803977966,
-0.9897845387458801,
-0.34079617261886597,
-0.25777095556259155,
-0.2462923228740692,
0.30015191435813904,
0.9740712642669678,
0.6260008215904236,
-0.5967037081718445,
-0.23287390172481537,
0.38597744703292847,
-0.06007353588938713,
0.14670094847679138,
-0.27845126390457153,
0.3347139060497284,
-0.015122955664992332,
-0.585695743560791,
0.5173190236091614,
0.7139058113098145,
0.04096929356455803,
-0.5513333082199097,
0.21987122297286987,
-0.008942765183746815,
-0.01659611240029335,
0.49185121059417725,
0.6139438152313232,
-0.9119462966918945,
-0.503364622592926,
-0.12261618673801422,
-0.38516247272491455,
0.5882015228271484,
0.707408607006073,
-0.8495254516601562,
0.6509395241737366,
0.007734533399343491,
0.5288771390914917,
0.6583390235900879,
-0.03096296265721321,
0.7254848480224609,
-0.31801825761795044,
-0.07032393664121628,
0.4359721541404724,
0.17410902678966522,
0.14424337446689606,
-0.7296003103256226,
0.2265292853116989,
-0.43246251344680786,
-0.7250345349311829,
-0.43275806307792664,
0.20327641069889069,
-1.0238146781921387,
-0.3274460732936859,
1.373712182044983,
-0.1299687922000885,
-0.2920016050338745,
-0.2876013517379761,
-0.3576395809650421,
0.07028000801801682,
-0.6290189027786255,
0.9443146586418152,
0.5317895412445068,
-0.42187783122062683,
-0.26195910573005676,
-0.8441853523254395,
0.5041716694831848,
0.15252718329429626,
-0.9539709687232971,
0.4094899296760559,
0.3974042534828186,
0.3742331862449646,
0.06444001942873001,
1.181387186050415,
-0.10859545320272446,
0.18030276894569397,
-0.5507504343986511,
-0.14080314338207245,
0.30126458406448364,
-0.07357084006071091,
-0.13751082122325897,
-0.14760242402553558,
-0.12224923074245453,
-0.026775384321808815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11349v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11349v2 | Language Models Don't Learn the Physical Manifestation of Language | 2024-02-17T17:52:24 | 2024-06-06T17:20:21 | Bruce W. Lee, JaeHyuk Lim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We argue that language-only models don't learn the physical manifestation of
language. We present an empirical investigation of visual-auditory properties
of language through a series of tasks, termed H-Test. These tasks highlight a
fundamental gap between human linguistic understanding and the sensory-deprived
linguistic understanding of LLMs. In support of our hypothesis, 1. deliberate
reasoning (Chain-of-Thought), 2. few-shot examples, or 3. stronger LLM from the
same model family (LLaMA 2 13B -> LLaMA 2 70B) has no significant effect on
H-Test performance.
We bring in the philosophical case of Mary, who learns about the world in a
sensory-deprived environment as a useful conceptual framework to understand how
language-only models learn about the world (Jackson, 1986). Our experiments
show that some of the strongest proprietary LLMs stay near random chance
baseline accuracy of 50%, highlighting the limitations of linguistic knowledge
acquired in the absence of sensory experience. Our code and data are available
at <github.com/brucewlee/h-test>. | [
-0.15276920795440674,
-1.0010251998901367,
0.6708100438117981,
0.2204388827085495,
-0.16556976735591888,
0.20004402101039886,
-0.22137939929962158,
-0.7426413893699646,
0.18887187540531158,
0.22716958820819855,
-0.4370866119861603,
-0.2943841218948364,
-0.45471158623695374,
0.016904156655073166,
-0.3653857707977295,
0.5120823383331299,
-0.0009725712588988245,
-0.17530590295791626,
-0.2157180905342102,
0.011567551642656326,
-0.049749862402677536,
-0.2905450165271759,
-0.22577743232250214,
-0.33647799491882324,
0.5977267622947693,
0.41522008180618286,
0.4575752317905426,
0.7705947756767273,
0.5069854259490967,
0.20204578340053558,
-0.27792882919311523,
-0.09754465520381927,
-0.46752163767814636,
0.04605080559849739,
-0.09307631105184555,
-0.5026980638504028,
-0.23637360334396362,
0.1668984442949295,
0.7129776477813721,
1.0879868268966675,
-0.015450556762516499,
0.18545368313789368,
-0.07653354853391647,
0.5247800946235657,
-0.676530659198761,
0.21638724207878113,
-0.8393450975418091,
0.18611152470111847,
-0.11742215603590012,
-0.12941214442253113,
-0.5024372935295105,
0.1098574623465538,
0.11042992025613785,
-0.42244693636894226,
0.2981010377407074,
0.35075679421424866,
1.2740519046783447,
0.3759550154209137,
-0.6776038408279419,
-0.07129193097352982,
-0.8030306696891785,
0.8354387879371643,
-0.4406844675540924,
0.8034179210662842,
0.6426490545272827,
-0.011477077379822731,
-0.026721740141510963,
-0.33752381801605225,
-0.692643404006958,
-0.8412925601005554,
0.2858559191226959,
0.17350153625011444,
-0.06464753299951553,
0.053178541362285614,
0.49797067046165466,
0.3345140218734741,
-0.5155491828918457,
0.18651461601257324,
-0.5804300308227539,
-0.06069205701351166,
0.4065324366092682,
0.00427278270944953,
0.30446574091911316,
-0.36634552478790283,
-0.564794659614563,
-0.1605624109506607,
-0.7800617218017578,
0.14957056939601898,
0.1889103353023529,
0.1066034734249115,
-0.39319977164268494,
0.7137951254844666,
0.08111792802810669,
0.6641086935997009,
-0.25752973556518555,
-0.541957437992096,
0.1706298440694809,
-0.010649202391505241,
-0.32333680987358093,
-0.3159237205982208,
0.6841339468955994,
-0.08278951793909073,
0.3234019875526428,
-0.17064063251018524,
-0.2430242896080017,
0.34339138865470886,
0.2145587056875229,
-0.39586299657821655,
-0.250436931848526,
-0.21466130018234253,
-0.38222736120224,
-0.17345751821994781,
-0.02921854704618454,
-0.39719438552856445,
-0.36113473773002625,
-0.2275543063879013,
0.35513636469841003,
-0.26555877923965454,
-0.5227953791618347,
0.0802624374628067,
-0.35199686884880066,
0.09182760119438171,
-0.015285785309970379,
-0.9070746302604675,
0.5870149731636047,
0.5042544007301331,
0.4043997526168823,
-0.19097045063972473,
-0.629244327545166,
-0.1654110699892044,
-0.22170062363147736,
-0.45023640990257263,
0.7833107113838196,
-0.4489702880382538,
-0.2993486225605011,
-0.25926607847213745,
-0.0331292487680912,
-0.1144942119717598,
-0.8816252946853638,
0.26484474539756775,
-0.2837735116481781,
-0.19350643455982208,
-0.5784101486206055,
-0.45223698019981384,
-0.21638727188110352,
-0.0934426560997963,
-0.317279577255249,
0.7625478506088257,
0.16652826964855194,
-0.47464486956596375,
0.6103639602661133,
-0.23877619206905365,
-0.25311097502708435,
0.0736778974533081,
-0.5436617136001587,
-0.13959163427352905,
0.5499551296234131,
-0.2055288851261139,
0.07761028409004211,
-0.17391839623451233,
0.29595598578453064,
-0.6499210596084595,
-0.6681850552558899,
0.4373573362827301,
-0.44035276770591736,
0.6617815494537354,
0.10256776958703995,
-0.4496755003929138,
-0.22414931654930115,
-0.8874240517616272,
-0.27950146794319153,
0.49447184801101685,
-0.4138637185096741,
-0.2665894329547882,
0.1861819177865982,
0.06595004349946976,
0.3052348792552948,
-0.015318221412599087,
-0.7072238326072693,
0.11405303329229355,
-0.4818284511566162,
0.09416227042675018,
0.7025455832481384,
-0.3330962359905243,
0.48388007283210754,
-0.390720933675766,
0.6202343702316284,
0.22266975045204163,
0.019945556297898293,
-0.11639583110809326,
-0.5924178957939148,
-1.132469654083252,
-0.2892422676086426,
0.011559744365513325,
0.4568694531917572,
-0.4376000165939331,
0.1225677952170372,
-0.03793875128030777,
-0.3668345808982849,
-0.5463539361953735,
0.38018348813056946,
0.5241667032241821,
0.6250792145729065,
0.07187256217002869,
-0.44878625869750977,
-0.5795307755470276,
-1.1218429803848267,
-0.4852044880390167,
-0.5930205583572388,
0.167444109916687,
0.3830341696739197,
0.7828366756439209,
-0.20490464568138123,
0.6725669503211975,
-0.26596567034721375,
0.06408154964447021,
-0.17048221826553345,
0.022409331053495407,
0.12323720753192902,
0.08814503997564316,
0.3974541127681732,
-0.49431681632995605,
0.13510571420192719,
-0.16182024776935577,
-1.0708941221237183,
-0.31724709272384644,
0.09168387949466705,
0.1784532070159912,
0.17768870294094086,
0.1912495642900467,
-0.618457019329071,
0.6533488035202026,
0.7163108587265015,
-0.6575248837471008,
0.6535999178886414,
-0.1538318693637848,
-0.22213268280029297,
-0.45038068294525146,
-0.21147030591964722,
0.11170187592506409,
0.12001153826713562,
-0.5071221590042114,
0.17395812273025513,
0.1766524463891983,
-0.07633808255195618,
-0.574029266834259,
1.002278208732605,
-0.4737248122692108,
-0.4018459618091583,
-0.5397601127624512,
0.01691611111164093,
0.002274793339893222,
0.7114010453224182,
0.23848913609981537,
0.5488138198852539,
0.5808829665184021,
-0.8658556938171387,
-0.07548951357603073,
0.027830814942717552,
-0.4370744526386261,
0.3549364507198334,
-0.528740644454956,
0.09280447661876678,
-0.10439466685056686,
-0.2807813584804535,
-0.808741569519043,
-0.2745721936225891,
0.3154442310333252,
-0.3114297389984131,
0.08500715345144272,
0.12500274181365967,
-0.4216287136077881,
-0.37802302837371826,
0.16595081984996796,
0.4193783104419708,
0.9534023404121399,
-0.5308061838150024,
0.3621590733528137,
0.4722018539905548,
0.09647417068481445,
-0.23582573235034943,
-0.8950386643409729,
0.03443553298711777,
-0.04685509204864502,
-0.47751885652542114,
-0.05922643840312958,
-0.11373580247163773,
-0.85680091381073,
-0.15484414994716644,
-0.4005173146724701,
-0.3198595941066742,
0.3696494698524475,
0.6241365671157837,
0.13266664743423462,
-0.29081258177757263,
0.284719854593277,
-0.18583375215530396,
0.13205033540725708,
0.29648712277412415,
-0.031112292781472206,
0.2610369622707367,
-0.16067425906658173,
-0.86806720495224,
-0.5819945931434631,
0.032799411565065384,
0.5908072590827942,
0.011908686719834805,
0.45914649963378906,
0.24537792801856995,
-0.3674274981021881,
-0.1450197547674179,
-0.5984190106391907,
-0.2119486927986145,
-0.4318176805973053,
0.37148624658584595,
-0.6159479022026062,
-0.728426992893219,
0.4081264138221741,
0.1619643121957779,
-0.4168676733970642,
0.2728366255760193,
0.5555264353752136,
-0.462731271982193,
0.7402234673500061,
0.6216100454330444,
0.17365914583206177,
0.4051891565322876,
-0.16329039633274078,
0.17392611503601074,
-0.8493668437004089,
-0.1776842325925827,
-0.45615071058273315,
-0.32601064443588257,
-0.5418990254402161,
-0.06041431799530983,
0.30831313133239746,
0.06902215629816055,
-0.39445415139198303,
0.1182476207613945,
-0.013638090342283249,
0.30380815267562866,
0.7447354793548584,
0.3338472843170166,
0.44824492931365967,
0.22111736238002777,
-0.21437998116016388,
-0.3063057065010071,
-0.6691226363182068,
-0.446306049823761,
0.8803843259811401,
0.4489066004753113,
0.9070953130722046,
-0.061994537711143494,
0.6396245360374451,
-0.09368351101875305,
0.08361177146434784,
-0.8603174686431885,
0.5965745449066162,
0.31410980224609375,
-0.5059665441513062,
-0.04843960702419281,
-0.4635377526283264,
-0.946489155292511,
0.48166337609291077,
-0.06649716198444366,
-0.6241547465324402,
0.3445833921432495,
0.12815113365650177,
-0.05235205963253975,
0.39671891927719116,
-0.6624608635902405,
0.6400441527366638,
-0.5113649964332581,
-0.32452836632728577,
0.09260546416044235,
-0.19618000090122223,
0.6958397030830383,
-0.15752016007900238,
0.5232688784599304,
-0.199011892080307,
0.0018829645123332739,
0.7640810012817383,
-0.14049696922302246,
0.9383100867271423,
-0.04441932588815689,
-0.34569379687309265,
0.20880556106567383,
0.37521892786026,
0.18320679664611816,
-0.11698810756206512,
0.1748696118593216,
0.03670584037899971,
-0.3789938986301422,
-0.7467885613441467,
-0.5238958597183228,
0.3593641519546509,
-0.625474750995636,
-0.6155315637588501,
-0.4405253231525421,
-0.6555978059768677,
-0.1463690549135208,
0.06589625775814056,
0.16725684702396393,
0.18895389139652252,
-0.29165807366371155,
-0.052877333015203476,
0.48012492060661316,
-0.34958791732788086,
0.22750991582870483,
0.7039988040924072,
-0.5477716326713562,
0.03474355489015579,
0.8534733653068542,
0.07838970422744751,
0.5030874013900757,
0.13120822608470917,
0.34860196709632874,
-0.03778516873717308,
-0.44411399960517883,
-0.028290553018450737,
0.5190709829330444,
-0.7032892107963562,
0.48373913764953613,
-0.49698081612586975,
-0.0570572130382061,
-0.18489307165145874,
0.183304563164711,
-0.2776816785335541,
-0.20927639305591583,
-0.22949862480163574,
-0.27590903639793396,
0.1372835487127304,
1.1194863319396973,
-0.08369234949350357,
0.14959141612052917,
-0.5731454491615295,
0.624431848526001,
0.46035242080688477,
0.08430663496255875,
0.08447068184614182,
-0.8688167333602905,
-0.1342734545469284,
0.3322215676307678,
-0.2885781526565552,
-0.8768516778945923,
0.3939586579799652,
0.272970050573349,
0.3967503607273102,
0.4813916087150574,
-0.2859334945678711,
0.8381623029708862,
-0.33425408601760864,
0.7690402865409851,
0.09695503115653992,
-1.0209649801254272,
0.578949511051178,
-0.3500586450099945,
0.4877278208732605,
0.2309081256389618,
0.11410792171955109,
-0.3439362347126007,
-0.6930115222930908,
-0.8621758222579956,
-0.46097493171691895,
0.43884599208831787,
0.03267040476202965,
0.16878382861614227,
-0.30562835931777954,
0.25996801257133484,
0.08702309429645538,
0.14070190489292145,
-0.9934698343276978,
-0.10970263183116913,
0.06460155546665192,
0.12771931290626526,
-0.2093321979045868,
-0.36284804344177246,
0.12521523237228394,
-0.744740903377533,
0.2646394670009613,
0.026777442544698715,
0.21585991978645325,
0.18608559668064117,
-0.4078247845172882,
-0.36393216252326965,
0.09428245574235916,
0.7019354104995728,
0.8776746392250061,
-0.24949106574058533,
0.47087523341178894,
0.23707561194896698,
-0.5032505393028259,
0.20416857302188873,
-0.4631746709346771,
-0.2175692766904831,
0.009395167231559753,
0.8202527761459351,
1.047311782836914,
0.6526749730110168,
-0.9656643271446228,
0.5268535614013672,
0.10962691903114319,
-0.3663153350353241,
-0.36308762431144714,
0.08390489965677261,
0.18765544891357422,
0.18781134486198425,
0.21943633258342743,
0.2233477234840393,
-0.12252932786941528,
-0.8292409181594849,
0.1460886001586914,
0.31347331404685974,
-0.5103191137313843,
-0.686725914478302,
0.6521756649017334,
-0.08361759036779404,
-0.40141797065734863,
0.7615109086036682,
-0.38453900814056396,
-0.5098770260810852,
0.7486515641212463,
0.6569420099258423,
0.6895185112953186,
-0.030792871490120888,
0.10942353308200836,
0.10556505620479584,
0.5792643427848816,
0.027082044631242752,
0.7366601824760437,
-0.1061982586979866,
-0.9693080186843872,
-0.33339205384254456,
-0.710449755191803,
-0.4151657521724701,
-0.055034078657627106,
-0.5573989748954773,
-0.0357307568192482,
-0.527785062789917,
-0.06074918434023857,
-0.385184109210968,
-0.16322322189807892,
-0.8960266709327698,
0.09864597022533417,
0.27702853083610535,
0.9146174192428589,
-1.0478935241699219,
0.7299948930740356,
0.28682708740234375,
-0.549996018409729,
-0.8496281504631042,
-0.20180727541446686,
-0.08085941523313522,
-1.0239375829696655,
1.2771992683410645,
-0.11059609800577164,
-0.02083764038980007,
-0.13198603689670563,
-0.5378503203392029,
-0.727191686630249,
0.6929292678833008,
0.6187889575958252,
-0.5996180176734924,
-0.009660379961133003,
0.17579366266727448,
0.5146704912185669,
-0.06687615811824799,
0.32895249128341675,
0.41007688641548157,
0.5761270523071289,
-0.06771979480981827,
-1.135036587715149,
-0.2420332133769989,
-0.14659975469112396,
-0.07165075838565826,
-0.0640350729227066,
-0.4798029363155365,
1.0295716524124146,
-0.5501002073287964,
-0.3172159492969513,
-0.013048983179032803,
0.5623859763145447,
0.5651085376739502,
0.36786413192749023,
0.39542508125305176,
0.9569126963615417,
0.7859812378883362,
-0.050629131495952606,
1.4278002977371216,
0.05369197949767113,
0.3391915261745453,
0.8629512786865234,
-0.5316810011863708,
0.9942880272865295,
0.6678981781005859,
-0.24984963238239288,
0.3903796374797821,
0.622850239276886,
0.1474887579679489,
0.386881560087204,
0.4615470767021179,
-0.14663900434970856,
-0.43666180968284607,
-0.2607838213443756,
-0.20103132724761963,
0.8342971205711365,
0.21039006114006042,
-0.4335242211818695,
0.0512617789208889,
0.13218066096305847,
-0.09561366587877274,
0.10958673804998398,
-0.0027361749671399593,
0.557562530040741,
0.6062235236167908,
-0.3648550510406494,
0.9836612343788147,
-0.3822864890098572,
0.6379233002662659,
-0.3152419924736023,
0.06351324170827866,
-0.17023152112960815,
0.01431935466825962,
-0.0076707471162080765,
-0.3875117003917694,
0.23413383960723877,
-0.018207399174571037,
-0.1001063659787178,
-0.28482311964035034,
0.6219550371170044,
-0.2809237241744995,
-0.5877479314804077,
0.5668250918388367,
1.067678451538086,
0.415892094373703,
-0.032254550606012344,
-0.5051569938659668,
0.30362987518310547,
-0.29627227783203125,
-0.2916874289512634,
0.24557819962501526,
0.3152778446674347,
0.15017715096473694,
0.8807855248451233,
0.6001407504081726,
0.48981720209121704,
0.28531408309936523,
0.21427766978740692,
0.38853463530540466,
-0.9971187114715576,
-0.04020991548895836,
-0.9406107068061829,
0.051502905786037445,
0.3541426360607147,
-0.39488109946250916,
0.6629313230514526,
0.38029077649116516,
1.0417753458023071,
-0.23188798129558563,
0.5929364562034607,
0.3331436812877655,
0.25654369592666626,
-0.6483287811279297,
0.6791943311691284,
-0.7674671411514282,
0.15561552345752716,
-0.24265001714229584,
-0.8383678197860718,
-0.1288791298866272,
0.694053053855896,
-0.28354108333587646,
0.12749925255775452,
1.0595707893371582,
0.7453297972679138,
-0.15798671543598175,
-0.1832255870103836,
0.7212002873420715,
0.5726981163024902,
0.004822460934519768,
0.6152786612510681,
1.3600045442581177,
-0.34899789094924927,
0.04054098203778267,
-0.2725814878940582,
-0.1937313824892044,
0.04143095389008522,
-0.5594419836997986,
-0.9731475114822388,
-0.504433810710907,
-0.24111059308052063,
-0.147755965590477,
0.03449612483382225,
0.8153283596038818,
0.7818214297294617,
-0.3693053424358368,
-0.6631168723106384,
-0.18148717284202576,
0.17702186107635498,
-0.1864934265613556,
-0.17646369338035583,
0.07165972143411636,
-0.25759655237197876,
-0.4698442816734314,
0.7351404428482056,
0.3889627754688263,
0.13079093396663666,
-0.38273322582244873,
-0.19815321266651154,
-0.09739861637353897,
-0.1479344666004181,
0.5496212840080261,
0.3812483847141266,
-1.2404959201812744,
-0.3168512284755707,
0.2830229699611664,
-0.06917456537485123,
0.09683217108249664,
0.5138033032417297,
-0.9595099091529846,
0.21664658188819885,
0.41040003299713135,
0.5335067510604858,
0.22548289597034454,
-0.3301710784435272,
0.29938018321990967,
-0.42313218116760254,
0.3732743561267853,
0.14153140783309937,
0.6342738270759583,
0.17191383242607117,
-0.0022282793652266264,
0.17323707044124603,
0.779274046421051,
-0.2756887972354889,
-0.8529843091964722,
0.5384104251861572,
-1.0529423952102661,
-0.3016098439693451,
1.2886337041854858,
0.17192214727401733,
-0.6330263614654541,
0.007414326071739197,
-0.059386979788541794,
0.16208088397979736,
-0.06705430150032043,
0.8433815240859985,
0.7226449251174927,
0.028996936976909637,
-0.3286607563495636,
-0.8948786854743958,
0.218041330575943,
0.6036593914031982,
-0.5232974886894226,
-0.22387535870075226,
0.2315850704908371,
0.341473788022995,
-0.005080354865640402,
0.8347092270851135,
0.2482217401266098,
0.303225040435791,
0.2003929316997528,
0.22661450505256653,
0.04067131131887436,
-0.5513373613357544,
-0.46371015906333923,
0.056406304240226746,
0.4455026686191559,
-0.10090422630310059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11347v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11347v1 | PhaseEvo: Towards Unified In-Context Prompt Optimization for Large Language Models | 2024-02-17T17:47:10 | 2024-02-17T17:47:10 | Wendi Cui, Jiaxin Zhang, Zhuohang Li, Hao Sun, Damien Lopez, Kamalika Das, Bradley Malin, Sricharan Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Crafting an ideal prompt for Large Language Models (LLMs) is a challenging
task that demands significant resources and expert human input. Existing work
treats the optimization of prompt instruction and in-context learning examples
as distinct problems, leading to sub-optimal prompt performance. This research
addresses this limitation by establishing a unified in-context prompt
optimization framework, which aims to achieve joint optimization of the prompt
instruction and examples. However, formulating such optimization in the
discrete and high-dimensional natural language space introduces challenges in
terms of convergence and computational efficiency. To overcome these issues, we
present PhaseEvo, an efficient automatic prompt optimization framework that
combines the generative capability of LLMs with the global search proficiency
of evolution algorithms. Our framework features a multi-phase design
incorporating innovative LLM-based mutation operators to enhance search
efficiency and accelerate convergence. We conduct an extensive evaluation of
our approach across 35 benchmark tasks. The results demonstrate that PhaseEvo
significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art baseline methods by a large
margin whilst maintaining good efficiency. | [
-0.24927859008312225,
-0.6387748718261719,
0.8454240560531616,
0.47365984320640564,
-0.44222292304039,
0.03695942461490631,
-0.18611674010753632,
0.10269391536712646,
-0.32220104336738586,
0.22019153833389282,
-0.9879369139671326,
-0.5226982831954956,
-0.15203876793384552,
0.6947227716445923,
-0.22637784481048584,
0.4800875186920166,
0.057907093316316605,
0.07828231155872345,
-0.39546334743499756,
0.06770258396863937,
-0.6758630275726318,
-0.03344130888581276,
-0.9354198575019836,
-0.2770622670650482,
0.2964369058609009,
0.688178300857544,
0.24133214354515076,
0.5139681696891785,
-0.21948133409023285,
0.40858563780784607,
-0.2786238193511963,
0.4199478328227997,
-0.35176464915275574,
0.7302018404006958,
0.09339600801467896,
-0.18867844343185425,
-0.031205035746097565,
-0.5874030590057373,
0.8078710436820984,
0.5251755714416504,
-0.16839328408241272,
-0.295560359954834,
0.1886323243379593,
0.46929147839546204,
-0.4552832543849945,
0.1239524856209755,
-0.5454632043838501,
0.026290258392691612,
0.1580020636320114,
-0.2948446571826935,
-0.44784319400787354,
-0.6278231143951416,
0.24986357986927032,
-1.08716881275177,
0.258453369140625,
0.3630960285663605,
0.3175841271877289,
0.24421600997447968,
-0.33570337295532227,
-0.4423731565475464,
-0.3588896095752716,
0.8075187802314758,
-0.635715126991272,
0.269662082195282,
-0.10494345426559448,
0.1839989423751831,
-0.7966200113296509,
-0.2935069799423218,
-0.6255939602851868,
-0.25802481174468994,
0.1764311045408249,
-0.1040126234292984,
0.09128481149673462,
0.2936164438724518,
0.09000314772129059,
0.13208916783332825,
-0.6683858633041382,
0.3196605443954468,
0.28961417078971863,
-0.09646822512149811,
0.27080610394477844,
0.2861221432685852,
0.5043864250183105,
-0.2966262996196747,
-0.18667742609977722,
-0.1466064304113388,
-0.5777618288993835,
0.17439983785152435,
0.14486391842365265,
0.41612565517425537,
-0.04419460520148277,
0.17064137756824493,
-0.256619930267334,
0.6948232650756836,
0.2273397296667099,
-0.26558586955070496,
0.03832198306918144,
-0.3300601840019226,
0.06577734649181366,
-0.0332583487033844,
0.7903751730918884,
0.19873200356960297,
-0.22291941940784454,
-0.17013031244277954,
-0.2996622323989868,
-0.46193334460258484,
0.03075975924730301,
-0.829602062702179,
0.3921145498752594,
0.4782162010669708,
0.11580915004014969,
-0.19165955483913422,
-0.3377968668937683,
-1.214106559753418,
-0.4791167080402374,
-0.45277345180511475,
0.38867083191871643,
-0.36412346363067627,
0.18145205080509186,
0.07402175664901733,
-0.024484897032380104,
0.16423925757408142,
0.6425207853317261,
-0.882348895072937,
-0.09196589887142181,
0.772782027721405,
0.8383021354675293,
-0.06196826696395874,
-0.2814796566963196,
-0.9404014945030212,
-0.09265972673892975,
-0.38002049922943115,
0.6702402830123901,
-0.7288479804992676,
-0.7965460419654846,
0.3301677703857422,
-0.04374469071626663,
-0.08022671937942505,
-0.3487142324447632,
0.7816010117530823,
-0.3988696038722992,
0.5176950693130493,
-0.47615647315979004,
-0.3737737834453583,
-0.02737213671207428,
0.014813586138188839,
-0.24848632514476776,
1.216696858406067,
0.33167266845703125,
-0.36243417859077454,
0.34438765048980713,
-0.761366069316864,
-0.5206120014190674,
0.5411760210990906,
-0.12651781737804413,
-0.25872620940208435,
0.24171334505081177,
0.4336172640323639,
0.4586864709854126,
-0.8482773303985596,
0.5499179363250732,
-0.02233586646616459,
-0.3039214611053467,
0.018846768885850906,
0.08840076625347137,
0.5989950895309448,
0.19401581585407257,
-0.6030448079109192,
0.504552960395813,
-0.6884065866470337,
-0.232577383518219,
0.15537305176258087,
-0.22160449624061584,
-0.528505802154541,
0.1326131522655487,
-0.38753214478492737,
0.034699946641922,
0.12493546307086945,
-0.5186735391616821,
0.365294873714447,
-0.5142989754676819,
0.4886709749698639,
0.8651151657104492,
0.046547096222639084,
0.6621197462081909,
-0.11323179304599762,
0.7987208962440491,
-0.23161183297634125,
0.4669465124607086,
-0.5682859420776367,
-0.37412363290786743,
-0.6861793994903564,
-0.4272508919239044,
-0.011773635633289814,
0.5869383811950684,
-0.9854316115379333,
0.7456530332565308,
-0.2030760794878006,
-0.033227209001779556,
-0.4767605662345886,
0.2943221926689148,
0.37111255526542664,
0.7734890580177307,
0.20085135102272034,
0.07294458895921707,
-0.2497074007987976,
-0.766880214214325,
0.04475899413228035,
0.1707926243543625,
-0.0348050519824028,
0.31633901596069336,
0.2946391999721527,
-0.35395026206970215,
1.006300926208496,
-0.22292514145374298,
0.19800764322280884,
-0.46690747141838074,
0.15382832288742065,
0.3152419924736023,
0.34398922324180603,
0.41716256737709045,
-0.5833719968795776,
-0.4581906497478485,
0.051853928714990616,
-0.7974832057952881,
-0.5910515189170837,
-0.29004043340682983,
-0.2965019941329956,
0.22579114139080048,
0.3965270519256592,
-0.3701430559158325,
-0.3010643720626831,
0.40264400839805603,
-0.21818159520626068,
0.2997170388698578,
-0.4100169539451599,
0.3405148386955261,
-1.2903428077697754,
-0.08263801783323288,
0.07379291206598282,
-0.061742041260004044,
-0.7717738747596741,
0.27905958890914917,
0.08209679275751114,
-0.5370606780052185,
-0.3849504590034485,
0.9403358697891235,
-0.572749674320221,
0.2426336258649826,
-0.07404772937297821,
0.38818925619125366,
0.04722800478339195,
0.3562676012516022,
-0.4459877014160156,
0.8112584352493286,
0.7702420949935913,
-0.6129331588745117,
0.2958995997905731,
0.20987705886363983,
-0.18593764305114746,
0.7444654703140259,
-0.7317577600479126,
0.37591853737831116,
-0.5504006743431091,
0.3368934392929077,
-0.967559278011322,
-0.2828221023082733,
0.25145894289016724,
0.06281542032957077,
0.42182642221450806,
-0.08024639636278152,
-0.606809139251709,
-0.4271107017993927,
-0.6687683463096619,
0.5038875341415405,
0.47341692447662354,
-0.822379469871521,
0.6893101930618286,
-0.0985972136259079,
-0.31371697783470154,
-0.5031536817550659,
0.1598387360572815,
0.024015847593545914,
-0.31830495595932007,
-0.6888206005096436,
0.06311599165201187,
-0.44856444001197815,
-0.11624930799007416,
-0.5511377453804016,
-0.07028932869434357,
0.3974314033985138,
0.10102786868810654,
0.02183930017054081,
0.17908421158790588,
0.09493105113506317,
0.007684942800551653,
0.5778521299362183,
-0.10233784466981888,
-0.12885428965091705,
-0.4547926187515259,
0.8417786955833435,
0.18977855145931244,
-0.060929812490940094,
-0.54487144947052,
0.5199714303016663,
0.42014071345329285,
0.04716781899333,
0.3466668725013733,
0.1362488865852356,
-0.04532726854085922,
-0.8428794741630554,
-0.4182700216770172,
-0.12770962715148926,
-0.6090953350067139,
0.2572898268699646,
-0.5008432269096375,
-0.9134988784790039,
0.38029569387435913,
-0.21336762607097626,
0.24910999834537506,
0.20302525162696838,
0.3292432427406311,
0.2639142572879791,
0.9579469561576843,
0.4619791805744171,
-0.004654378164559603,
0.5322345495223999,
-0.04140502214431763,
0.08543772250413895,
-0.784332275390625,
-0.38610705733299255,
-0.8122406601905823,
0.04607608541846275,
-0.2505289614200592,
-0.48221561312675476,
0.6847609877586365,
0.20616108179092407,
-0.16797053813934326,
0.27599188685417175,
-0.6038234829902649,
0.5289610624313354,
0.6664089560508728,
-0.02681848406791687,
0.1936759650707245,
-0.09089028835296631,
-0.32588303089141846,
0.01757107488811016,
-0.8742502331733704,
-0.29811397194862366,
0.8840259909629822,
0.004395443946123123,
0.4894886612892151,
-0.13032002747058868,
0.724612295627594,
0.21991413831710815,
0.025545407086610794,
-0.6868667006492615,
0.698106050491333,
0.004897648934274912,
-0.21442818641662598,
-0.40716901421546936,
-0.6148906946182251,
-1.0126514434814453,
0.4128032922744751,
-0.017287451773881912,
-0.564430296421051,
0.262310653924942,
0.2003743201494217,
-0.3110869228839874,
-0.16531386971473694,
-0.6179315447807312,
0.875886857509613,
-0.10373912006616592,
-0.12666009366512299,
-0.018185971304774284,
-0.5555514097213745,
0.16519422829151154,
-0.3896878659725189,
0.5361913442611694,
-0.20384806394577026,
-0.2348080575466156,
0.38265755772590637,
-0.4935263395309448,
0.6647124290466309,
-0.1305353194475174,
-0.24919529259204865,
0.1350974142551422,
0.17335596680641174,
0.6662542819976807,
0.3714003562927246,
-0.20756256580352783,
-0.2198931872844696,
-0.25970521569252014,
-0.38025087118148804,
-0.5337353348731995,
0.8322703242301941,
-0.4952414631843567,
-0.3612268269062042,
-0.31623372435569763,
-0.4604048728942871,
-0.29237595200538635,
0.2063780277967453,
0.4412022531032562,
1.0832977294921875,
-0.1989719271659851,
-0.14177961647510529,
0.8979480862617493,
-0.5709350109100342,
0.818816602230072,
0.5116792917251587,
-0.004101058468222618,
-0.5701025128364563,
0.7496284246444702,
-0.5860194563865662,
0.2808474600315094,
0.5744125843048096,
0.48349568247795105,
-0.3104650378227234,
-0.6358833312988281,
-0.7027327418327332,
0.3543761074542999,
-0.7225403785705566,
-0.21989591419696808,
-0.5552676320075989,
0.3899526000022888,
-0.4580266773700714,
-0.6004178524017334,
0.07463561743497849,
0.12185383588075638,
-0.4519839584827423,
0.4410681426525116,
0.19891846179962158,
0.4707007110118866,
0.15243081748485565,
0.38021594285964966,
-0.6276732087135315,
0.33265602588653564,
0.5525141358375549,
-0.03645850718021393,
-0.09870169311761856,
-0.5071622729301453,
0.09111443161964417,
-0.1032261922955513,
-0.21657468378543854,
-0.7448337078094482,
0.34340372681617737,
0.4139867126941681,
0.6161634922027588,
0.3127463757991791,
0.23385725915431976,
0.44059044122695923,
-0.630271852016449,
0.735734760761261,
0.1619929075241089,
-1.0951645374298096,
0.7323743104934692,
-0.5317598581314087,
0.774399995803833,
0.6450684070587158,
0.43219929933547974,
-0.7397845983505249,
-0.42276737093925476,
-0.27052319049835205,
-1.0527276992797852,
0.8546251058578491,
0.08933944255113602,
0.21223384141921997,
-0.0628933385014534,
0.6606230735778809,
0.36771249771118164,
0.3650968074798584,
-0.2988452911376953,
-0.28448477387428284,
0.11418374627828598,
-0.424751341342926,
-0.05976293236017227,
-0.3131730258464813,
-0.2371232509613037,
-0.25641676783561707,
0.6959760189056396,
-0.5329484343528748,
0.19177816808223724,
0.18572625517845154,
-0.18035125732421875,
-0.30574852228164673,
0.46960535645484924,
0.9055895209312439,
0.5283166766166687,
0.12113966047763824,
-0.30603551864624023,
0.2640437185764313,
-0.3193664848804474,
0.28389406204223633,
0.3329394459724426,
-0.635036289691925,
0.09679864346981049,
0.26279526948928833,
0.865295946598053,
0.6257984042167664,
-0.7970526218414307,
0.4744902551174164,
-0.14844584465026855,
-0.0828215628862381,
-0.11739038676023483,
0.232849583029747,
-0.3350638151168823,
0.359546959400177,
0.622467041015625,
-0.396401971578598,
0.2723885178565979,
-0.49796566367149353,
-0.1234373152256012,
0.4031302332878113,
0.0696609616279602,
-0.3543376326560974,
0.7901527285575867,
0.5196965932846069,
-0.6242020130157471,
0.4291653335094452,
-0.5630145072937012,
-0.6828874349594116,
0.4399360418319702,
0.4855334758758545,
1.2938398122787476,
-0.3719710111618042,
0.44956517219543457,
0.3521728813648224,
0.07177163660526276,
-0.3046388328075409,
0.3224286735057831,
-0.1925087422132492,
-0.4398449957370758,
-0.4519287943840027,
-0.8099209070205688,
-0.5291285514831543,
-0.14468364417552948,
-0.08371543139219284,
0.43030494451522827,
-0.5512189865112305,
0.3016408085823059,
-0.41404202580451965,
-0.07762722671031952,
-0.3986032009124756,
-0.08335592597723007,
0.04543786123394966,
0.5468840599060059,
-0.4292883276939392,
0.5707850456237793,
0.4848911464214325,
0.11170700192451477,
-0.43341532349586487,
-0.1826038360595703,
0.14983101189136505,
-0.7751573324203491,
0.3629852533340454,
0.28873541951179504,
-0.11511388421058655,
0.1796453446149826,
-0.454300194978714,
-0.7299331426620483,
1.0210766792297363,
0.5053284168243408,
-0.77913898229599,
-0.16444124281406403,
-0.03334302827715874,
0.27003541588783264,
-0.5412676930427551,
0.2521645724773407,
0.3431823253631592,
0.3572276532649994,
0.3788091540336609,
-0.8031882047653198,
0.15916700661182404,
0.0883801206946373,
0.3993121385574341,
0.5118699669837952,
-0.5785834193229675,
0.4550153613090515,
-0.03433537483215332,
-0.34715238213539124,
0.1678916960954666,
0.49952200055122375,
0.314006507396698,
0.220110222697258,
0.7214556932449341,
0.4049214720726013,
0.7032999396324158,
-0.17080672085285187,
1.0949651002883911,
-0.4170033633708954,
0.15496014058589935,
0.7633364200592041,
-0.19769781827926636,
0.2881740629673004,
0.2763589918613434,
0.11454670131206512,
0.44230082631111145,
0.6808077096939087,
0.4265829920768738,
0.5301891565322876,
0.23592913150787354,
-0.7227327823638916,
-0.09691131114959717,
-0.11493831872940063,
-0.1933504343032837,
-0.18110421299934387,
0.08810996264219284,
0.015333365648984909,
-0.31486669182777405,
0.17280440032482147,
0.28253117203712463,
0.006680421065539122,
-0.3267240822315216,
0.7098219990730286,
-0.023904073983430862,
-0.7705185413360596,
0.5958138108253479,
-0.20638824999332428,
0.7880951762199402,
-0.7177703976631165,
0.17392057180404663,
-0.6321737170219421,
-0.16671036183834076,
0.21142153441905975,
-0.12007450312376022,
-0.3296591639518738,
-0.13803730905056,
0.17530681192874908,
-0.5010080933570862,
0.16421560943126678,
-0.4562634229660034,
-0.29956182837486267,
0.1266711801290512,
0.08147259801626205,
-0.14738063514232635,
-0.0058144330978393555,
-0.6848022937774658,
0.1508844494819641,
-0.01727954111993313,
-0.20622576773166656,
0.22608187794685364,
0.6859679222106934,
0.13942034542560577,
0.7346017360687256,
0.5771273970603943,
-0.15430964529514313,
0.1457206755876541,
0.19119398295879364,
0.788634717464447,
-0.5127227306365967,
-0.42204636335372925,
-0.6552318334579468,
0.5306444764137268,
-0.15874284505844116,
-0.8635001182556152,
0.5617510676383972,
0.37697336077690125,
0.4174889922142029,
0.09036938846111298,
0.5338064432144165,
-0.006809578277170658,
0.2606410086154938,
-0.6747832894325256,
0.061813898384571075,
-0.8029038906097412,
0.18442586064338684,
-0.43886011838912964,
-1.304201602935791,
-0.14786572754383087,
0.255189448595047,
0.07104998081922531,
-0.12432440370321274,
0.8873814940452576,
0.8195956945419312,
0.23723849654197693,
0.06650762259960175,
0.2596941292285919,
0.08079121261835098,
0.36760976910591125,
0.5079031586647034,
0.6008577346801758,
-0.1730009764432907,
0.21388477087020874,
-0.21627219021320343,
-0.3755522072315216,
-0.32590270042419434,
-0.9673631191253662,
-0.96305912733078,
-0.8432823419570923,
-0.29248347878456116,
-0.010148082859814167,
0.13473989069461823,
1.2938158512115479,
0.559914231300354,
-0.666322648525238,
-0.3142903745174408,
-0.23576393723487854,
0.0981161892414093,
0.11845211684703827,
-0.19182993471622467,
0.06040409207344055,
-0.8727707266807556,
-1.055408000946045,
1.047554850578308,
0.4614352583885193,
0.0002462006523273885,
-0.3108621835708618,
-0.17739611864089966,
0.08227967470884323,
0.10634595155715942,
0.8188821077346802,
0.421238511800766,
-0.6104214787483215,
-0.19862596690654755,
0.18455860018730164,
-0.05567799508571625,
-0.1670464426279068,
1.0111900568008423,
-0.500903308391571,
0.7898253798484802,
0.7365891337394714,
0.7360625863075256,
0.23792871832847595,
0.08141904324293137,
0.9326606392860413,
-0.7034170627593994,
0.220788836479187,
0.3058491349220276,
0.38894563913345337,
0.45170438289642334,
-0.35589519143104553,
0.2091192603111267,
0.3050679862499237,
-0.6812777519226074,
-0.842829167842865,
0.16234154999256134,
-1.067807674407959,
-0.47421562671661377,
1.30768620967865,
0.24009498953819275,
-0.32118067145347595,
-0.1472005397081375,
-0.23906049132347107,
-0.029052749276161194,
-0.9606966972351074,
0.7303990125656128,
0.4859028458595276,
-0.029785819351673126,
-0.1942150890827179,
-0.6237280368804932,
0.5785527229309082,
0.5359414219856262,
-0.984408974647522,
-0.13864003121852875,
0.7026009559631348,
0.07926217466592789,
-0.20515845715999603,
0.5099633932113647,
0.3480277359485626,
0.10548558086156845,
-0.38933926820755005,
0.12738904356956482,
0.10622790455818176,
-0.43239882588386536,
-0.8800881505012512,
0.12506325542926788,
0.10380791872739792,
0.09005360305309296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11324v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11324v1 | EVEDIT: Event-based Knowledge Editing with Deductive Editing Boundaries | 2024-02-17T16:34:50 | 2024-02-17T16:34:50 | Jiateng Liu, Pengfei Yu, Yuji Zhang, Sha Li, Zixuan Zhang, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | The dynamic nature of real-world information necessitates efficient knowledge
editing (KE) in large language models (LLMs) for knowledge updating. However,
current KE approaches, which typically operate on (subject, relation, object)
triples, ignore the contextual information and the relation among different
knowledge. Such editing methods could thus encounter an uncertain editing
boundary, leaving a lot of relevant knowledge in ambiguity: Queries that could
be answered pre-edit cannot be reliably answered afterward. In this work, we
analyze this issue by introducing a theoretical framework for KE that
highlights an overlooked set of knowledge that remains unchanged and aids in
knowledge deduction during editing, which we name as the deduction anchor. We
further address this issue by proposing a novel task of event-based knowledge
editing that pairs facts with event descriptions. This task manifests not only
a closer simulation of real-world editing scenarios but also a more logically
sound setting, implicitly defining the deduction anchor to address the issue of
indeterminate editing boundaries. We empirically demonstrate the superiority of
event-based editing over the existing setting on resolving uncertainty in
edited models, and curate a new benchmark dataset EvEdit derived from the
CounterFact dataset. Moreover, while we observe that the event-based setting is
significantly challenging for existing approaches, we propose a novel approach
Self-Edit that showcases stronger performance, achieving 55.6% consistency
improvement while maintaining the naturalness of generation. | [
-0.12169404327869415,
-1.1680364608764648,
0.9007158279418945,
-0.08797936886548996,
-0.04875009134411812,
0.0609947144985199,
-0.261852890253067,
-0.6315199732780457,
0.050981130450963974,
0.13113810122013092,
-0.6365997195243835,
-0.5893030762672424,
-0.5601658225059509,
0.1174447163939476,
-0.1487443596124649,
0.5776965618133545,
-0.335856169462204,
-0.4646777808666229,
-0.5379711389541626,
-0.2806156873703003,
-0.5123046636581421,
-0.47524765133857727,
-0.6334573030471802,
-0.04705321043729782,
0.3438345491886139,
0.47090664505958557,
0.7662712335586548,
1.1040738821029663,
0.37770137190818787,
0.16774992644786835,
-0.438262939453125,
0.43885621428489685,
-0.2556332051753998,
0.25632497668266296,
-0.5855710506439209,
-0.4121769964694977,
-0.8552238345146179,
-0.037955064326524734,
0.6786250472068787,
0.6522695422172546,
0.11616360396146774,
0.1644349843263626,
0.13290897011756897,
0.6308350563049316,
-0.8559848070144653,
-0.08362070471048355,
-0.8095980286598206,
0.02286115288734436,
-0.20334850251674652,
0.13584798574447632,
-0.13438773155212402,
-0.11574436724185944,
-0.001316723763011396,
-0.8452200293540955,
0.023867720738053322,
-0.27131688594818115,
0.6441242694854736,
0.5795460939407349,
-0.3392053246498108,
-0.059452880173921585,
-0.8602999448776245,
0.4363802671432495,
-0.7421275973320007,
0.638663113117218,
0.3178631067276001,
-0.34940311312675476,
-0.3187488615512848,
-0.6374919414520264,
-0.7401572465896606,
0.3176201581954956,
0.22106708586215973,
-0.019246937707066536,
-0.3596732020378113,
0.11962049454450607,
0.42918306589126587,
-0.09180629253387451,
-0.14822952449321747,
0.17437569797039032,
-0.11928778886795044,
0.10146073251962662,
0.7713379859924316,
0.21655923128128052,
0.15589068830013275,
-0.18589220941066742,
-0.11340700089931488,
0.2295515537261963,
-1.1453105211257935,
0.04661018028855324,
0.33907976746559143,
-0.15226173400878906,
0.05091068521142006,
0.4743807911872864,
-0.4237724840641022,
0.6906952261924744,
0.3406602740287781,
0.07407728582620621,
-0.056109193712472916,
-0.24470515549182892,
-0.1554097682237625,
0.2531374990940094,
0.5168702602386475,
0.8170286417007446,
0.09257987141609192,
0.03787067532539368,
0.19997917115688324,
-0.12423128634691238,
-0.01611725613474846,
-0.46913444995880127,
-0.03873319923877716,
0.3453734517097473,
-0.3125230073928833,
-0.32485970854759216,
-0.32304874062538147,
-0.6081638336181641,
-0.47697511315345764,
-0.3560957610607147,
0.3447202444076538,
-0.3030649721622467,
-0.07620657235383987,
0.047505639493465424,
0.08103818446397781,
-0.1664545089006424,
0.5663319230079651,
-0.37432312965393066,
-0.03235398232936859,
0.6707093715667725,
0.4481421113014221,
0.13116510212421417,
-0.3644447326660156,
-0.5306880474090576,
0.485163152217865,
-0.33704903721809387,
0.6179017424583435,
-0.9190784692764282,
-0.17887134850025177,
-0.25939106941223145,
-0.19557136297225952,
0.07230124622583389,
-0.07602457702159882,
0.6130532622337341,
-0.6744411587715149,
-0.0858626440167427,
-0.3538374900817871,
-0.9942625761032104,
-0.11827050894498825,
0.28942081332206726,
-0.561135470867157,
0.9550855755805969,
-0.3644421100616455,
-0.7293040752410889,
0.5368500351905823,
-0.4955083131790161,
-0.31992679834365845,
-0.24021337926387787,
-0.09102993458509445,
-0.23801051080226898,
0.12099762260913849,
0.39622822403907776,
0.15721799433231354,
0.15977293252944946,
0.5822244882583618,
-0.3976353704929352,
-0.07716725021600723,
0.3500135838985443,
-0.380441814661026,
0.45770910382270813,
-0.041978154331445694,
-0.4271159768104553,
-0.12820130586624146,
-1.2499010562896729,
-0.19048850238323212,
-0.10893835872411728,
-0.15751338005065918,
-0.6966310739517212,
0.3429858088493347,
-0.5658458471298218,
0.31877297163009644,
0.3070126175880432,
-0.7572023272514343,
0.6174512505531311,
-0.25261327624320984,
0.25388801097869873,
0.725499153137207,
0.3851340413093567,
0.4244729280471802,
0.08245475590229034,
0.46451422572135925,
0.023221751675009727,
0.13019996881484985,
-0.17824769020080566,
-0.4298346936702728,
-0.6439512372016907,
0.12447307258844376,
0.5362691283226013,
0.6728324890136719,
-0.5207369327545166,
0.2804518938064575,
-0.010238442569971085,
-0.3931657671928406,
-0.696139931678772,
0.17167967557907104,
0.2661246955394745,
0.7847297191619873,
0.4118709862232208,
0.23432902991771698,
-0.8684828877449036,
-0.6845793128013611,
-0.7815803289413452,
-0.20098429918289185,
0.39098060131073,
0.02455317974090576,
0.2949593961238861,
-0.13254646956920624,
1.1210142374038696,
-0.6075548529624939,
-0.12195897847414017,
-0.1226111501455307,
0.19202148914337158,
0.1147569864988327,
0.5626838803291321,
0.22805644571781158,
-0.5849380493164062,
-0.2733941376209259,
-0.25708746910095215,
-0.774711012840271,
-0.39392638206481934,
-0.4438076317310333,
-0.14596694707870483,
0.3908188045024872,
0.7487758994102478,
-0.5263746380805969,
0.8827813863754272,
0.35930895805358887,
-0.6002222299575806,
0.48154857754707336,
-0.28526902198791504,
0.3295457065105438,
-0.7632926106452942,
-0.14750170707702637,
-0.3870640695095062,
-0.1339656114578247,
-0.5155545473098755,
-0.14009694755077362,
0.28269535303115845,
0.33394408226013184,
-0.3171074092388153,
0.7124654650688171,
-0.31514477729797363,
0.3939628601074219,
-0.24293267726898193,
0.35703548789024353,
0.27582502365112305,
0.3717043697834015,
0.108501136302948,
0.28020673990249634,
0.279771089553833,
-0.5748386979103088,
0.27273499965667725,
0.6796126961708069,
-0.21659612655639648,
0.8380380272865295,
-0.44445693492889404,
0.3080989420413971,
-0.2522945702075958,
0.2125357985496521,
-0.6685659289360046,
-0.011708805337548256,
0.2054361253976822,
-0.23308107256889343,
0.056300271302461624,
-0.39125707745552063,
-0.2658352255821228,
-0.043373722583055496,
-0.28704652190208435,
0.6264219284057617,
0.19231626391410828,
-0.4210658073425293,
0.5647497773170471,
0.19255173206329346,
-0.33729130029678345,
-0.8326019644737244,
-0.697006106376648,
0.43004271388053894,
-0.2242071032524109,
-0.7680146098136902,
0.4943199157714844,
-0.08062173426151276,
-0.7517551183700562,
0.46408185362815857,
-0.2862564027309418,
0.017456868663430214,
0.1860390305519104,
0.2044699639081955,
0.2120429277420044,
0.04601103812456131,
0.3511649966239929,
0.37937435507774353,
-0.08810984343290329,
-0.014408927410840988,
-0.28836196660995483,
-0.2794593870639801,
0.1655258983373642,
-0.5274735689163208,
-0.5075488090515137,
0.24487467110157013,
0.4178212583065033,
-0.36222928762435913,
0.7144913673400879,
0.23917503654956818,
-0.6335400342941284,
-0.12743635475635529,
-0.9366880655288696,
0.09555981308221817,
-0.36797478795051575,
0.3351868689060211,
-0.6356026530265808,
-0.8592049479484558,
0.7779724597930908,
0.125990092754364,
0.05008256062865257,
0.8111705780029297,
0.16676148772239685,
-0.191903218626976,
0.7429258823394775,
0.5465519428253174,
0.41539812088012695,
0.07227804511785507,
0.08325614035129547,
0.2000453621149063,
-1.2231075763702393,
-0.09328652918338776,
-0.27930748462677,
-0.5580806136131287,
-0.2976544201374054,
-0.4578472375869751,
0.4878063201904297,
0.5251529216766357,
0.05357380583882332,
0.15958204865455627,
-0.16761514544487,
0.5884785652160645,
0.46695005893707275,
0.03446732833981514,
0.8095501065254211,
-0.6300956606864929,
0.003077850444242358,
-0.31011828780174255,
-1.0047324895858765,
-0.4171193242073059,
1.119122862815857,
0.26771023869514465,
0.8095646500587463,
-0.10209471732378006,
0.7283720374107361,
0.35778066515922546,
-0.03177544102072716,
-0.15648135542869568,
0.3239555358886719,
0.25043314695358276,
-0.7111263871192932,
-0.5479264259338379,
-0.16469474136829376,
-0.5708445310592651,
-0.06927388161420822,
-0.2848204970359802,
-0.8896067142486572,
0.7347790002822876,
0.5157139897346497,
-0.6250549554824829,
0.7862188816070557,
-0.3627933859825134,
0.9714577198028564,
-0.1277526468038559,
-0.8423469066619873,
-0.2898752987384796,
-0.6300624012947083,
-0.008438657969236374,
-0.11857859045267105,
0.5981566905975342,
-0.1937181055545807,
0.025992389768362045,
0.7739134430885315,
-0.37515711784362793,
0.8631795048713684,
-0.1361161172389984,
-0.2974439859390259,
0.6590871810913086,
0.5785220861434937,
1.0555319786071777,
0.42142990231513977,
-0.20919537544250488,
0.003082896349951625,
0.04263461008667946,
0.18009765446186066,
-0.6886011958122253,
0.5223363041877747,
-0.4959448277950287,
-0.6845937371253967,
-0.04487444460391998,
-0.6141680479049683,
-0.27535396814346313,
-0.02880481630563736,
0.23375914990901947,
0.7545304298400879,
-0.46628257632255554,
-0.0815013125538826,
0.6353980898857117,
-0.2081841230392456,
0.5270758867263794,
0.43539658188819885,
0.008540858514606953,
-0.23624537885189056,
0.3408704996109009,
0.40401193499565125,
0.16516095399856567,
0.43846723437309265,
0.09368163347244263,
-0.16389138996601105,
-0.5119469165802002,
-0.6069187521934509,
-0.11595206707715988,
-0.915219247341156,
-0.30965739488601685,
-1.1042094230651855,
0.00634413119405508,
-0.32205671072006226,
-0.5592007040977478,
-0.5804959535598755,
-0.9371758103370667,
-0.12072896212339401,
-0.32988107204437256,
0.5528020262718201,
0.7514490485191345,
-0.820864737033844,
0.11966707557439804,
-0.9187277555465698,
0.32438039779663086,
0.3170119822025299,
0.566810131072998,
-0.08813092112541199,
-0.3850732445716858,
-0.3000980019569397,
0.15137319266796112,
-0.10504133254289627,
-1.0190690755844116,
-0.07849118113517761,
0.2570302188396454,
0.4830807149410248,
0.20883314311504364,
0.1802096664905548,
0.718142032623291,
-0.5802386403083801,
0.6667525768280029,
-0.3128843903541565,
-1.2995775938034058,
0.8259219527244568,
-0.404499888420105,
0.3441285490989685,
0.7321493029594421,
0.04949169605970383,
-0.8341771960258484,
-0.6604217886924744,
-1.1333961486816406,
-0.7945708632469177,
0.5479192733764648,
0.13989558815956116,
-0.23616017401218414,
-0.10158617049455643,
0.6545824408531189,
0.17636750638484955,
0.25944507122039795,
-0.5751652121543884,
-0.10093333572149277,
0.22158513963222504,
-0.18626001477241516,
0.37135615944862366,
-0.7166336178779602,
-0.0066636535339057446,
-0.42157962918281555,
0.9595104455947876,
0.150467649102211,
-0.14807097613811493,
0.7244167923927307,
-0.46567821502685547,
-0.3615274131298065,
0.4882398843765259,
0.5345848798751831,
1.190307855606079,
-0.3352324962615967,
0.33031171560287476,
0.6507956981658936,
-0.19394558668136597,
0.16308808326721191,
0.11247684061527252,
-0.42390352487564087,
-0.12017279863357544,
0.5905455350875854,
0.6978156566619873,
0.2863643169403076,
-0.4642413556575775,
0.35119712352752686,
0.1811264455318451,
-0.13244305551052094,
-0.0565033033490181,
-0.01986151561141014,
0.053135763853788376,
0.41661351919174194,
0.16735723614692688,
0.01607082225382328,
0.11216403543949127,
-0.22146020829677582,
0.3520549535751343,
0.18114107847213745,
-0.41379961371421814,
-0.3744378387928009,
1.0115032196044922,
0.4675011932849884,
-0.11041416972875595,
0.5170674920082092,
-0.40998244285583496,
-0.6367421746253967,
0.5703539848327637,
0.2555234730243683,
0.9352887272834778,
-0.2603864371776581,
-0.1280268281698227,
0.4990150034427643,
0.5303352475166321,
0.3890240788459778,
0.24238085746765137,
0.13522356748580933,
-0.9192447066307068,
-0.9136211276054382,
-0.42839863896369934,
-0.4102959930896759,
0.2697697877883911,
-0.32951879501342773,
0.3188025653362274,
-0.18941578269004822,
0.03628787770867348,
-0.16647425293922424,
-0.2905326783657074,
-0.7006189227104187,
0.19042499363422394,
0.33939090371131897,
1.1041828393936157,
-0.614273190498352,
0.5052292346954346,
0.7512400150299072,
0.06506127864122391,
-0.4816429316997528,
-0.22510361671447754,
0.16608136892318726,
-0.33334922790527344,
0.4204894006252289,
-0.19317008554935455,
-0.0386517159640789,
-0.027520520612597466,
-0.38599011301994324,
-1.0137691497802734,
0.7085996866226196,
0.05921992287039757,
-0.8158172369003296,
-0.17174696922302246,
0.11767236888408661,
0.29314032196998596,
-0.2632865011692047,
-0.08522606641054153,
0.7176886796951294,
0.7940352559089661,
-0.19192524254322052,
-0.814154326915741,
0.15753750503063202,
0.05107371136546135,
-0.4545130133628845,
0.2608572840690613,
-0.43142473697662354,
0.442839652299881,
-0.24675382673740387,
0.10535229742527008,
-0.3283326029777527,
0.6494486331939697,
-0.15789230167865753,
0.3484046161174774,
0.4687868058681488,
0.9120445251464844,
0.6739794611930847,
-0.020261790603399277,
0.5865284204483032,
-0.3793797492980957,
0.19474643468856812,
1.626623272895813,
-0.26738592982292175,
0.47565940022468567,
0.4209705591201782,
-0.0341716967523098,
0.6317139267921448,
0.31653672456741333,
0.15634019672870636,
0.2986486554145813,
-0.1755634844303131,
-0.11236447095870972,
-0.4760209918022156,
0.028968114405870438,
-0.21163621544837952,
0.7018084526062012,
0.3995189964771271,
-0.03769871965050697,
-0.2728475034236908,
0.035861410200595856,
0.4261454939842224,
0.15268361568450928,
-0.34391844272613525,
0.8026700019836426,
-0.05778326094150543,
-0.7356697916984558,
0.07240677624940872,
0.13398337364196777,
0.14757105708122253,
-0.3414158225059509,
-0.25122925639152527,
-0.011699279770255089,
0.14766477048397064,
-0.1637716293334961,
-0.986792266368866,
0.634802520275116,
0.098564513027668,
-0.23647210001945496,
-0.18399177491664886,
0.9834994077682495,
-0.5778899788856506,
-0.46980392932891846,
0.06407314538955688,
0.6431816816329956,
-0.41397640109062195,
-0.1935146301984787,
-0.47619113326072693,
0.33188095688819885,
0.049534961581230164,
-0.569344162940979,
-0.21131081879138947,
0.89788818359375,
-0.1736939698457718,
0.37317463755607605,
0.3992456793785095,
0.08565467596054077,
-0.09176023304462433,
-0.24653954803943634,
0.4741118550300598,
-0.7895374894142151,
-0.6778339743614197,
-1.160103440284729,
0.8585188388824463,
-0.17162932455539703,
-0.3451850712299347,
0.4956669807434082,
0.4208235740661621,
0.7363715767860413,
0.28081920742988586,
0.8944327235221863,
-0.2340405136346817,
0.3802665174007416,
-0.5337321162223816,
0.372869074344635,
-0.41206130385398865,
0.10412990301847458,
-0.4962364733219147,
-0.8513358235359192,
-0.29957666993141174,
0.29706740379333496,
-0.37254202365875244,
-0.47494789958000183,
0.5951685309410095,
0.3543129861354828,
0.0349087119102478,
0.09670040011405945,
0.11135780811309814,
0.5536184906959534,
0.18698595464229584,
0.556601881980896,
0.9950485229492188,
-0.3388337790966034,
0.2759818434715271,
-0.4258996546268463,
-0.2702869772911072,
-0.15248249471187592,
-1.4269746541976929,
-0.8155255317687988,
-0.6725354194641113,
-0.7516592144966125,
-0.21553434431552887,
0.3057180941104889,
1.1148114204406738,
0.23935164511203766,
-0.432361364364624,
0.2567411959171295,
0.04637995362281799,
0.48247766494750977,
-0.4255595803260803,
-0.15611769258975983,
0.6821780800819397,
-0.13312534987926483,
-0.5483201742172241,
0.5186092853546143,
0.43326565623283386,
-0.11249613016843796,
0.2918514609336853,
0.33966967463493347,
-0.569491446018219,
0.231744647026062,
0.4680657684803009,
0.22017331421375275,
-0.4180174171924591,
-0.7121232748031616,
-0.30405449867248535,
0.15577951073646545,
0.08689947426319122,
0.4759671986103058,
-1.0009355545043945,
0.6540769934654236,
0.36717674136161804,
0.8680636882781982,
0.4008100628852844,
0.01871219463646412,
0.6929938793182373,
-0.7917685508728027,
0.14808006584644318,
-0.027169862762093544,
0.37696579098701477,
0.20233362913131714,
-0.7590928077697754,
0.6903107762336731,
0.4013804793357849,
-0.4857623279094696,
-0.6606080532073975,
0.2983796000480652,
-0.7721031904220581,
-0.24805936217308044,
1.1219501495361328,
0.05660007521510124,
-0.12256039679050446,
-0.02480735443532467,
-0.1042524129152298,
0.4431625306606293,
0.056301314383745193,
0.7712903022766113,
0.8887690305709839,
-0.2934482991695404,
0.14039872586727142,
-0.4486026465892792,
0.784756064414978,
0.38087743520736694,
-0.6195917129516602,
0.41066059470176697,
0.6830490827560425,
0.14824937283992767,
-0.008078188635408878,
0.4197889566421509,
0.08172023296356201,
0.361222505569458,
-0.10266445577144623,
0.32830610871315,
-0.42645779252052307,
-0.49070635437965393,
-0.16795757412910461,
-0.026063906028866768,
0.03635036200284958,
0.08292170614004135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11297v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11297v1 | MMMModal -- Multi-Images Multi-Audio Multi-turn Multi-Modal | 2024-02-17T14:37:38 | 2024-02-17T14:37:38 | Husein Zolkepli, Aisyah Razak, Kamarul Adha, Ariff Nazhan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Our contribution introduces a groundbreaking multimodal large language model
designed to comprehend multi-images, multi-audio, and multi-images-multi-audio
within a single multiturn session. Leveraging state-of-the-art models, we
utilize the SigLIP encoder for visual inputs and the Whisper Encoder for audio
inputs. Notably, this multimodal large language model is bilingual, proficient
in understanding both English and Malay simultaneously. We proudly unveil two
versions of this model: TinyLlama with 1.1B parameters, and Mistral with 7B
parameters. With its ability to navigate diverse modalities and languages, our
model represents a significant advancement for the Malaysian context and
beyond.
All models released at
https://huggingface.co/collections/mesolitica/multimodal-malaysian-llm-65c6f893e03f78fa9e5c8859 | [
-0.518311619758606,
-0.8919718265533447,
0.47569817304611206,
0.5827516913414001,
-0.18402965366840363,
-0.37320026755332947,
-0.26254498958587646,
-0.6282764077186584,
0.27230963110923767,
0.40992841124534607,
-0.8320966362953186,
-0.3013134300708771,
-0.7962855696678162,
-0.032294124364852905,
-0.014225808903574944,
0.6140046715736389,
0.16222792863845825,
0.4741106927394867,
-0.09245190024375916,
-0.5342109799385071,
-0.5908740758895874,
-0.30062511563301086,
-0.5173420906066895,
-0.28997141122817993,
0.44284701347351074,
0.36730441451072693,
0.9914270639419556,
0.43697991967201233,
0.587935209274292,
0.32627424597740173,
-0.02909073792397976,
0.21293236315250397,
-0.21067233383655548,
-0.015174970962107182,
0.11174421012401581,
-0.5398123264312744,
-0.6720695495605469,
-0.2838155925273895,
0.8286687731742859,
0.7096785306930542,
-0.05015706643462181,
0.34105154871940613,
-0.1104811578989029,
0.3300858736038208,
-0.5082331895828247,
0.5497043132781982,
-0.2828976809978485,
-0.00009278807556256652,
-0.06763940304517746,
-0.2755368649959564,
-0.3749118149280548,
-0.07531507313251495,
0.011026674881577492,
-0.5779387354850769,
-0.4525202214717865,
-0.04918375983834267,
0.5374543070793152,
0.2671191394329071,
-1.0402474403381348,
-0.569437563419342,
-0.8115606307983398,
0.7785260677337646,
-0.7204034328460693,
0.836715042591095,
0.31096839904785156,
0.46828779578208923,
0.10385234653949738,
-0.714055061340332,
-0.6588513851165771,
-0.27284812927246094,
0.10564082860946655,
0.08177849650382996,
-0.01580698788166046,
0.033954497426748276,
0.11680299788713455,
0.3332635164260864,
-0.5121287703514099,
0.1638583093881607,
-0.4379330575466156,
-0.2562730312347412,
0.49899527430534363,
0.36374905705451965,
0.5622316002845764,
-0.41490429639816284,
-0.4669824242591858,
-0.07047736644744873,
-0.720501720905304,
0.09517717361450195,
0.1749618947505951,
0.28958308696746826,
-0.6411926746368408,
0.8774257898330688,
0.21166576445102692,
0.6437674164772034,
-0.11274921149015427,
-1.0516407489776611,
0.2607240080833435,
-0.5571300387382507,
-0.3240731954574585,
-0.0705314353108406,
0.9714229702949524,
0.5033254027366638,
-0.17321138083934784,
0.2803220748901367,
-0.16561897099018097,
0.14543473720550537,
-0.2229057103395462,
-0.8788390159606934,
0.06748919188976288,
0.1336384266614914,
-0.7502578496932983,
-0.04653831198811531,
-0.1893569380044937,
-0.7324416637420654,
-0.339809387922287,
-0.382547527551651,
0.7561255693435669,
-0.6086069941520691,
-0.850862979888916,
0.3781415820121765,
0.16750814020633698,
0.2725518047809601,
0.44016653299331665,
-0.9079504609107971,
0.12291327118873596,
0.3689331114292145,
0.8238582015037537,
0.11673344671726227,
-0.5012641549110413,
-0.18791809678077698,
0.2973901629447937,
-0.21180737018585205,
0.4660659432411194,
-0.6988492012023926,
-0.6386392712593079,
0.09205073863267899,
0.15768328309059143,
-0.17784331738948822,
-0.3876653015613556,
0.42178070545196533,
-0.49787139892578125,
0.3533516526222229,
-0.2041129767894745,
-0.0809071734547615,
-0.5741609930992126,
0.20175741612911224,
-0.9988005757331848,
0.8338190913200378,
-0.039607349783182144,
-0.5705332159996033,
0.3599109947681427,
-0.9025900363922119,
-0.3870788812637329,
-0.2616003453731537,
-0.10443348437547684,
-0.10852310806512833,
0.12281608581542969,
0.422717809677124,
0.6900550723075867,
-0.27497053146362305,
0.26656922698020935,
-0.3974246084690094,
-0.05390501394867897,
0.24363747239112854,
-0.5624838471412659,
0.7403083443641663,
0.22307837009429932,
-0.1309041529893875,
0.25521963834762573,
-0.7450194358825684,
-0.3250395655632019,
0.3457656502723694,
-0.4023025631904602,
-0.0991707593202591,
-0.2464808076620102,
0.7797611951828003,
0.6460303664207458,
0.3991873860359192,
-0.29179367423057556,
0.27141228318214417,
-0.17953479290008545,
0.45202764868736267,
0.6608487963676453,
-0.11408010870218277,
0.6260949373245239,
-0.35734447836875916,
0.7354937195777893,
0.354451447725296,
0.24304795265197754,
-0.8234645128250122,
-0.703571081161499,
-0.7064323425292969,
-0.6679834127426147,
0.08144335448741913,
0.24171686172485352,
-0.9050589799880981,
-0.2362552434206009,
-0.2810176610946655,
-0.4134942591190338,
-0.8572443723678589,
0.1788238137960434,
0.3433033525943756,
-0.011192506179213524,
0.21651171147823334,
-0.17290329933166504,
-0.6870460510253906,
-0.9826801419258118,
0.30974143743515015,
-0.3127025067806244,
0.09128759801387787,
0.5445440411567688,
0.45908984541893005,
-0.8249515295028687,
0.5308948755264282,
-0.1443965882062912,
-0.49561917781829834,
-0.40730395913124084,
0.16079695522785187,
0.12528902292251587,
0.35632002353668213,
0.8755443692207336,
-0.9953287243843079,
-0.26670971512794495,
0.13090336322784424,
-0.7627243995666504,
0.10494361817836761,
-0.18976342678070068,
0.2508578598499298,
0.18888427317142487,
0.5931581854820251,
-0.8422582149505615,
0.048109885305166245,
0.9278057217597961,
-0.2043217271566391,
0.6643601059913635,
-0.09280241280794144,
0.4516787827014923,
-1.3643622398376465,
-0.15332937240600586,
0.06480001658201218,
-0.270940899848938,
-0.34286725521087646,
0.6360613703727722,
0.1876080483198166,
-0.06585054099559784,
-0.6981256604194641,
0.5729100704193115,
-0.6461166143417358,
0.046434130519628525,
-0.3529537320137024,
-0.17726199328899384,
-0.09376231580972672,
0.5165977478027344,
0.09383028745651245,
0.7386583685874939,
0.8211405873298645,
-0.6268061399459839,
0.49928122758865356,
0.16972993314266205,
-0.20399555563926697,
0.5942877531051636,
-0.7810945510864258,
-0.14539209008216858,
-0.10606999695301056,
0.1067076250910759,
-1.146850347518921,
-0.49995407462120056,
0.034088946878910065,
-0.241305410861969,
0.5085667371749878,
-0.3470911383628845,
-0.685495138168335,
-0.24277208745479584,
-0.2588324546813965,
0.6363794803619385,
0.2778269946575165,
-0.6164300441741943,
0.9651758074760437,
0.5869719982147217,
-0.35743698477745056,
-0.24162819981575012,
-0.6385021805763245,
0.13319796323776245,
-0.2492343783378601,
-0.7232426404953003,
0.04436681419610977,
-0.2025735229253769,
-0.11209219694137573,
-0.21036523580551147,
0.14897829294204712,
-0.1848224252462387,
-0.28364065289497375,
0.720151960849762,
0.41692784428596497,
-0.6907374858856201,
-0.031401511281728745,
0.1702515333890915,
-0.05432075634598732,
0.037136852741241455,
0.025788702070713043,
0.7691993713378906,
-0.4448997378349304,
-0.5915544629096985,
-0.6420764923095703,
0.5649269223213196,
1.1335673332214355,
-0.1965199112892151,
0.7394300103187561,
1.0778065919876099,
-0.4511716961860657,
0.4060407876968384,
-0.5814039707183838,
-0.07453861087560654,
-0.5222700238227844,
0.5447463393211365,
-0.9004508256912231,
-1.078963279724121,
0.48637261986732483,
-0.08793774247169495,
-0.03696657344698906,
0.5378667712211609,
1.145592212677002,
-0.20621682703495026,
1.364428162574768,
1.0787482261657715,
-0.15686358511447906,
0.23794181644916534,
-0.17756561934947968,
0.042737025767564774,
-0.585803747177124,
-0.5171689987182617,
-0.14497169852256775,
-0.024457909166812897,
-0.6557901501655579,
-0.5551785230636597,
0.5800989270210266,
-0.12894944846630096,
0.0740693137049675,
0.2257780134677887,
-0.06086001172661781,
0.2374790459871292,
0.5355868935585022,
0.12832853198051453,
0.4923323392868042,
-0.24556982517242432,
-0.37659522891044617,
-0.4354703724384308,
-0.6660155057907104,
-0.5433813333511353,
1.130004644393921,
0.6832591891288757,
1.0631990432739258,
0.4626424312591553,
0.27917367219924927,
0.009676490910351276,
0.02373672090470791,
-1.0339951515197754,
0.6440853476524353,
0.27866101264953613,
-0.7439369559288025,
0.06150906905531883,
-0.16194309294223785,
-0.8125153183937073,
0.5820750594139099,
-0.2951173782348633,
-0.45440056920051575,
-0.004351294133812189,
-0.10928843915462494,
-0.16748212277889252,
0.27410122752189636,
-0.9133293628692627,
0.7826892137527466,
-0.11798039823770523,
-0.028289901092648506,
-0.455634206533432,
-0.5911935567855835,
0.8817108273506165,
-0.08638429641723633,
0.49236050248146057,
-0.12789352238178253,
-0.23566275835037231,
0.5440504550933838,
-0.06936339288949966,
0.712630569934845,
-0.11460743099451065,
-0.3085740804672241,
0.04041751101613045,
0.2964160740375519,
-0.18930429220199585,
0.20594632625579834,
0.36519914865493774,
0.24077583849430084,
0.37012743949890137,
-0.25634557008743286,
-0.27308833599090576,
0.7300717234611511,
-0.9258642792701721,
-0.2572610080242157,
-0.1908569037914276,
-0.6218865513801575,
-0.20735220611095428,
0.18531298637390137,
0.06592396646738052,
0.6481456756591797,
-0.35813507437705994,
0.22314050793647766,
0.42205333709716797,
-0.3142787218093872,
0.5836725831031799,
0.5874098539352417,
-0.7414118051528931,
-0.3659842312335968,
0.7522105574607849,
-0.1504673808813095,
0.2598380148410797,
0.3042044937610626,
-0.02707570791244507,
-0.5783615708351135,
-0.2556789815425873,
-0.5446796417236328,
0.4832296371459961,
-0.6809758543968201,
0.06493402272462845,
-0.9925962686538696,
-0.019930772483348846,
-0.44507840275764465,
0.10297834873199463,
-0.5801646113395691,
-0.3910849988460541,
-0.2731741964817047,
0.19311915338039398,
0.037704288959503174,
0.8905829191207886,
-0.22190138697624207,
0.518109917640686,
-0.8428913950920105,
0.8815070390701294,
0.6131645441055298,
0.08952563256025314,
0.0021879617124795914,
-0.7335029244422913,
-0.23939980566501617,
0.30011680722236633,
-0.30092915892601013,
-0.8024038076400757,
0.4124734699726105,
0.2979711592197418,
0.36970049142837524,
0.8258629441261292,
-0.6132239103317261,
0.9038582444190979,
-0.7673173546791077,
0.8111855983734131,
0.5400350689888,
-0.7631703019142151,
0.47679316997528076,
-0.48326390981674194,
0.5985692739486694,
0.08385983854532242,
0.6535462141036987,
-0.664939820766449,
-0.06346535682678223,
-0.3856130838394165,
-0.6313575506210327,
0.5726020932197571,
-0.22061128914356232,
0.13399070501327515,
0.24274219572544098,
-0.24116969108581543,
0.3511967360973358,
0.23914815485477448,
-0.9278522729873657,
-0.24480602145195007,
-0.23331503570079803,
-0.1266220062971115,
-0.021996822208166122,
-0.7189298868179321,
-0.10819412767887115,
-0.43476569652557373,
0.5759397745132446,
-0.2712171971797943,
0.5676208734512329,
-0.33397072553634644,
-0.4749341607093811,
-0.11891700327396393,
0.29393863677978516,
0.8150889277458191,
0.5274084210395813,
-0.18807756900787354,
0.18512076139450073,
-0.03661060705780983,
-0.661998450756073,
0.16679726541042328,
-0.08626136183738708,
0.31678396463394165,
0.19821758568286896,
0.4997791647911072,
0.772868812084198,
0.6161258220672607,
-0.7381759881973267,
0.6437969207763672,
-0.10757646709680557,
-0.056661490350961685,
-0.243480384349823,
-0.19029384851455688,
0.48325881361961365,
0.4432699978351593,
0.4370565116405487,
0.1701679825782776,
0.19962570071220398,
-0.7573021650314331,
0.023929884657263756,
0.42430323362350464,
-0.15069127082824707,
-0.6233038902282715,
0.9015835523605347,
-0.08025231212377548,
0.06721360236406326,
0.16543440520763397,
0.04852655157446861,
-0.3200289011001587,
0.303951233625412,
0.7698915600776672,
0.5909344553947449,
-0.43365371227264404,
0.20050233602523804,
0.42738789319992065,
0.6191800832748413,
-0.05763739347457886,
0.4487634301185608,
-0.05313977226614952,
-0.6768189072608948,
-0.548882782459259,
-0.6598697304725647,
-0.5384537577629089,
0.1794244349002838,
-0.818977952003479,
0.19577045738697052,
-0.3638930320739746,
-0.29521995782852173,
0.2808649241924286,
-0.29080018401145935,
-0.7944990396499634,
0.11789118498563766,
0.40617483854293823,
0.7368096113204956,
-0.9344837069511414,
0.9316686391830444,
0.922068178653717,
-0.5143752694129944,
-0.6188340783119202,
-0.3052847683429718,
0.32036179304122925,
-1.0084220170974731,
0.612896203994751,
0.3267015218734741,
-0.2528630197048187,
-0.2883959710597992,
-0.6081849336624146,
-0.8133522868156433,
0.9214228391647339,
0.30549588799476624,
-0.4505953788757324,
-0.01401519775390625,
0.25026485323905945,
0.3326878845691681,
-0.36918625235557556,
0.45832356810569763,
0.45932403206825256,
0.5397382378578186,
0.10245244204998016,
-1.395752191543579,
-0.30662280321121216,
-0.39285916090011597,
0.06204984337091446,
-0.003891194239258766,
-0.745323121547699,
0.7412618398666382,
-0.3950669765472412,
-0.14631889760494232,
0.13178201019763947,
0.7656763195991516,
0.21640855073928833,
0.2598687708377838,
0.4549843668937683,
0.4881591796875,
0.27941298484802246,
-0.09649812430143356,
0.9219961762428284,
-0.01716974750161171,
0.06566672772169113,
1.0471338033676147,
-0.05944519490003586,
0.9360553026199341,
0.6247550249099731,
-0.3060908019542694,
0.11249188333749771,
0.5698091387748718,
0.2942996323108673,
0.5003672242164612,
-0.7142001986503601,
-0.23414279520511627,
-0.1977638304233551,
-0.4138205349445343,
-0.6352820992469788,
0.94827800989151,
0.6399282813072205,
-0.14301222562789917,
-0.1409931629896164,
0.6170727610588074,
-0.05708044022321701,
-0.18311530351638794,
-0.43165603280067444,
0.6779751181602478,
0.21851518750190735,
-0.06082514673471451,
0.5485250353813171,
0.4428977370262146,
1.1563529968261719,
-0.6887850165367126,
0.11059252172708511,
0.09535785019397736,
-0.031232206150889397,
-0.08905967324972153,
-0.7556290030479431,
0.12600594758987427,
-0.48239466547966003,
-0.10813677310943604,
-0.20705436170101166,
0.7841690182685852,
-0.6320182681083679,
-0.628764808177948,
0.3143519461154938,
0.7368443608283997,
-0.06147143244743347,
-0.10897944867610931,
-0.8102636337280273,
0.3572444021701813,
-0.09169671684503555,
-0.11079344898462296,
0.14201204478740692,
0.44934794306755066,
0.18162846565246582,
0.8348191976547241,
0.5936570167541504,
-0.07063545286655426,
0.36394599080085754,
0.2844831943511963,
0.7194616198539734,
-0.6945701837539673,
-0.575874924659729,
-0.8663378357887268,
0.3740037679672241,
0.37523800134658813,
-0.24774056673049927,
0.7667705416679382,
0.5608288645744324,
0.6582808494567871,
-0.4288327693939209,
0.4041648209095001,
0.15303371846675873,
0.17055319249629974,
-0.6568976044654846,
0.7136361002922058,
-1.0558725595474243,
-0.16027221083641052,
-0.3855644762516022,
-0.830788254737854,
-0.16987302899360657,
0.6364277601242065,
0.07643973082304001,
0.10878907889127731,
0.5563033223152161,
0.9559997320175171,
-0.36461055278778076,
0.15612484514713287,
0.5552076697349548,
0.3514724373817444,
0.16699174046516418,
0.5810514688491821,
1.0512452125549316,
-0.5854297280311584,
0.3050364553928375,
-0.20240482687950134,
-0.14843618869781494,
-0.3978085517883301,
-0.6037537455558777,
-1.0010685920715332,
-0.9658437967300415,
-0.12065732479095459,
-0.13598927855491638,
-0.489238440990448,
1.0450185537338257,
0.9594482183456421,
-0.5968126058578491,
-0.3465390205383301,
0.7104262113571167,
-0.07483383268117905,
-0.001108817639760673,
-0.23594887554645538,
0.09456139802932739,
0.07319878786802292,
-1.009987473487854,
0.4416806697845459,
0.8469436764717102,
0.3011380136013031,
-0.7797936201095581,
-0.2201719880104065,
-0.3071034252643585,
0.07912862300872803,
1.0977447032928467,
0.08781832456588745,
-0.8471654057502747,
0.19614514708518982,
0.0012530193198472261,
-0.3790642321109772,
0.17597782611846924,
0.6854259967803955,
-0.48461610078811646,
0.498792439699173,
0.1128309890627861,
0.4630850851535797,
0.8256136775016785,
-0.7694111466407776,
0.3994942307472229,
-0.42234036326408386,
0.7663695812225342,
0.04603677615523338,
0.7750207781791687,
0.40901145339012146,
0.008643101900815964,
0.2188364416360855,
0.14796221256256104,
-0.23996229469776154,
-0.7947021722793579,
0.26174527406692505,
-1.5310580730438232,
-0.16137707233428955,
1.2114330530166626,
0.3220669627189636,
-0.2626313865184784,
-0.006490886677056551,
-0.5626432299613953,
-0.062365274876356125,
-0.12614662945270538,
0.45623326301574707,
0.8078777194023132,
0.4783168435096741,
-0.6693059206008911,
-0.726274311542511,
0.004381764214485884,
0.3572797179222107,
-0.6033867001533508,
-0.6273362040519714,
0.7352145910263062,
0.22962884604930878,
0.14554691314697266,
0.8791119456291199,
-0.45458686351776123,
0.5610917806625366,
0.08222828060388565,
0.015685632824897766,
-0.016407545655965805,
-0.5781722068786621,
-0.2778646945953369,
0.2792263925075531,
0.16027574241161346,
-0.24758629500865936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11296v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11296v1 | Dissecting Human and LLM Preferences | 2024-02-17T14:34:31 | 2024-02-17T14:34:31 | Junlong Li, Fan Zhou, Shichao Sun, Yikai Zhang, Hai Zhao, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As a relative quality comparison of model responses, human and Large Language
Model (LLM) preferences serve as common alignment goals in model fine-tuning
and criteria in evaluation. Yet, these preferences merely reflect broad
tendencies, resulting in less explainable and controllable models with
potential safety risks. In this work, we dissect the preferences of human and
32 different LLMs to understand their quantitative composition, using
annotations from real-world user-model conversations for a fine-grained,
scenario-wise analysis. We find that humans are less sensitive to errors, favor
responses that support their stances, and show clear dislike when models admit
their limits. On the contrary, advanced LLMs like GPT-4-Turbo emphasize
correctness, clarity, and harmlessness more. Additionally, LLMs of similar
sizes tend to exhibit similar preferences, regardless of their training
methods, and fine-tuning for alignment does not significantly alter the
preferences of pretrained-only LLMs. Finally, we show that preference-based
evaluation can be intentionally manipulated. In both training-free and
training-based settings, aligning a model with the preferences of judges boosts
scores, while injecting the least preferred properties lowers them. This
results in notable score shifts: up to 0.59 on MT-Bench (1-10 scale) and 31.94
on AlpacaEval 2.0 (0-100 scale), highlighting the significant impact of this
strategic adaptation. Interactive Demo:
https://huggingface.co/spaces/GAIR/Preference-Dissection-Visualization Dataset:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/GAIR/preference-dissection Code:
https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/Preference-Dissection | [
-0.7384763956069946,
-0.390101820230484,
0.5123394727706909,
-0.06600663810968399,
-0.08880250155925751,
0.13385923206806183,
-0.3738791346549988,
-0.5820634961128235,
0.06530050188302994,
0.2358042299747467,
-0.36169561743736267,
-0.33903512358665466,
-0.5422360301017761,
0.04276500642299652,
0.018771089613437653,
1.2163445949554443,
-0.04811236262321472,
0.045463934540748596,
-0.2060302197933197,
-0.3499600887298584,
-0.34519487619400024,
-0.7377867102622986,
-0.48712727427482605,
-0.6511995792388916,
0.8982060551643372,
0.4899790585041046,
1.0804786682128906,
0.6306896209716797,
0.42500054836273193,
0.24554583430290222,
-0.13960522413253784,
-0.0024672006256878376,
-0.5311828851699829,
-0.13728880882263184,
-0.38082194328308105,
-0.43218863010406494,
-0.7039616703987122,
0.3382393419742584,
0.2892605662345886,
0.6388952136039734,
-0.03709637001156807,
0.20978710055351257,
0.2060636579990387,
0.9292213916778564,
-0.5732150673866272,
-0.10153379291296005,
-0.5377787351608276,
-0.0141347860917449,
-0.0754503607749939,
-0.1896345019340515,
-0.26524868607521057,
-0.29874929785728455,
0.3681403696537018,
-0.4559158384799957,
0.04318036884069443,
0.11811989545822144,
1.0009591579437256,
0.3849966824054718,
-0.6729868054389954,
-0.06983514875173569,
-0.5578836798667908,
0.9069337248802185,
-0.5275323390960693,
0.30598199367523193,
0.4934143126010895,
0.2947714030742645,
-0.07921619713306427,
-0.14305642247200012,
-0.4382776618003845,
-0.18430252373218536,
-0.1405709832906723,
0.0659807100892067,
-0.16727221012115479,
0.20873047411441803,
0.1756621152162552,
0.255447119474411,
-0.640302300453186,
0.5059453845024109,
-0.12668268382549286,
-0.342316597700119,
0.8112832903862,
0.2578299641609192,
0.2087135761976242,
-0.23196017742156982,
-0.22409503161907196,
-0.3792775869369507,
-0.7489614486694336,
0.3332292139530182,
0.5654417276382446,
0.1670762002468109,
-0.19317752122879028,
0.5415892601013184,
-0.3149837255477905,
0.6610148549079895,
0.1825612336397171,
-0.21116790175437927,
0.25519171357154846,
-0.030826829373836517,
-0.2505035102367401,
-0.06980905681848526,
0.8803718090057373,
0.9008679986000061,
0.44925203919410706,
-0.06687334179878235,
-0.1683993935585022,
0.21300296485424042,
0.27985048294067383,
-0.5975738763809204,
-0.014944984577596188,
0.14951840043067932,
-0.45826637744903564,
-0.345676451921463,
-0.12349388003349304,
-0.5216037034988403,
-0.5472736358642578,
-0.737043023109436,
0.28546249866485596,
-0.18679684400558472,
0.1391317993402481,
0.45718449354171753,
-0.0571226105093956,
0.3771543800830841,
0.4102685749530792,
-1.1931229829788208,
0.3144107758998871,
0.7172331213951111,
0.6716616153717041,
-0.3675278127193451,
-0.22881610691547394,
-0.31472504138946533,
-0.047900520265102386,
-0.12794341146945953,
0.6925971508026123,
-0.34133192896842957,
-0.5027600526809692,
-0.5130831599235535,
-0.16540196537971497,
-0.008245659060776234,
-0.5095173120498657,
0.600394070148468,
-0.39406177401542664,
0.20667363703250885,
-0.5944435000419617,
-0.34832921624183655,
-0.21395641565322876,
0.29065245389938354,
-0.5396314263343811,
0.5809508562088013,
0.09824535250663757,
-0.6605173349380493,
0.601483941078186,
-0.6853880882263184,
-0.18097223341464996,
-0.3711346387863159,
-0.16886264085769653,
-0.2464890331029892,
-0.04834391549229622,
0.2847498059272766,
0.3412635326385498,
-0.22810445725917816,
0.25959429144859314,
-0.6875953078269958,
-0.3383530378341675,
0.45877784490585327,
-0.3390042781829834,
0.5925515294075012,
0.34567639231681824,
-0.19828489422798157,
0.41687408089637756,
-0.5653871297836304,
-0.07749246060848236,
0.14561598002910614,
-0.3681693375110626,
-0.2953318953514099,
0.06613747775554657,
-0.17997078597545624,
0.22353029251098633,
0.2508593201637268,
-0.2545127272605896,
0.21139277517795563,
-0.3995228409767151,
0.5090655088424683,
1.0840733051300049,
-0.0870889350771904,
0.7447904944419861,
-0.6078483462333679,
0.4540608823299408,
-0.21117272973060608,
0.409963458776474,
0.5084599852561951,
-0.14561493694782257,
-0.9123125672340393,
-0.2021026760339737,
0.20797701179981232,
0.2532270550727844,
0.019342247396707535,
0.4835835099220276,
-0.37315353751182556,
-0.3746669888496399,
-0.6015132069587708,
0.21134856343269348,
0.2588580846786499,
0.5614314675331116,
0.2528521418571472,
-0.29713886976242065,
-0.504944384098053,
-1.2433832883834839,
-0.19410757720470428,
-0.32634732127189636,
-0.14925460517406464,
0.4040985107421875,
0.2840615510940552,
-0.18375666439533234,
1.062095046043396,
-0.5726057887077332,
0.04818066209554672,
-0.12783131003379822,
-0.13803574442863464,
0.13729912042617798,
0.28641068935394287,
0.8666110634803772,
-0.7458081841468811,
-0.5572469830513,
0.058001551777124405,
-0.39020586013793945,
0.03968936949968338,
0.07009495049715042,
-0.4061345160007477,
0.1286795437335968,
-0.003909974358975887,
-0.4217458963394165,
0.29862847924232483,
0.459628701210022,
-0.14116725325584412,
0.5129838585853577,
-0.05225168168544769,
0.19685640931129456,
-0.7974331378936768,
0.07027706503868103,
0.18905512988567352,
-0.2844444811344147,
-0.35691866278648376,
0.01059927698224783,
-0.06737370789051056,
0.46716809272766113,
-0.43768349289894104,
0.643018901348114,
-0.19954629242420197,
-0.2770576477050781,
-0.20503604412078857,
0.048045963048934937,
0.2898561656475067,
0.4708971381187439,
0.2923319637775421,
0.7742346525192261,
0.12779593467712402,
-0.45034462213516235,
0.21585752069950104,
0.45565539598464966,
-0.23741599917411804,
0.3655014932155609,
-0.7244203090667725,
0.3951147496700287,
0.07154100388288498,
0.18928852677345276,
-0.8431313037872314,
-0.3983822166919708,
0.41070765256881714,
-0.3569023609161377,
0.11789946258068085,
-0.28112727403640747,
-0.2712791860103607,
-0.10731656849384308,
-0.606483519077301,
0.17368099093437195,
0.5769450664520264,
-0.47471076250076294,
0.2144695669412613,
0.38228365778923035,
-0.22331470251083374,
-0.6736835837364197,
-0.6324284672737122,
0.042029354721307755,
-0.610745906829834,
-0.5444358587265015,
0.2139231264591217,
-0.46707573533058167,
-0.5027922987937927,
-0.26839393377304077,
-0.14662128686904907,
0.23315320909023285,
0.3800104260444641,
0.45743995904922485,
0.7246735692024231,
-0.002878734841942787,
-0.009329264983534813,
-0.1129903495311737,
-0.1456226408481598,
-0.0663582906126976,
-0.027862489223480225,
0.5080655813217163,
-0.4669142961502075,
-0.43871909379959106,
-0.21327336132526398,
-0.02337869256734848,
0.5320970416069031,
-0.19857995212078094,
0.4662148058414459,
0.2805025577545166,
0.0057023074477910995,
0.29400989413261414,
-0.4349111020565033,
-0.24916666746139526,
-0.43596115708351135,
0.17307277023792267,
-0.2675468921661377,
-1.05958890914917,
0.34996750950813293,
0.22875267267227173,
0.0912896990776062,
0.3928428292274475,
0.7605898976325989,
-0.4170873463153839,
1.093271017074585,
0.3559134900569916,
-0.5200265645980835,
0.40510743856430054,
-0.0004137239884585142,
-0.06547865271568298,
-0.912043035030365,
-0.02531176060438156,
-0.49726250767707825,
-0.6845195293426514,
-0.5653096437454224,
-0.08357713371515274,
0.40434566140174866,
-0.0041046589612960815,
-0.4980265498161316,
0.010997450910508633,
-0.5091780424118042,
0.5350448489189148,
0.26551657915115356,
0.19123996794223785,
0.22796492278575897,
-0.017078008502721786,
-0.07484132796525955,
-0.07708512991666794,
-0.33990734815597534,
-0.8619789481163025,
1.1884331703186035,
0.517879843711853,
0.8466295599937439,
0.17342707514762878,
0.6412820219993591,
0.18793784081935883,
0.18497803807258606,
-0.9781220555305481,
0.37875640392303467,
-0.06815522164106369,
-0.59649658203125,
-0.43118491768836975,
-0.31151339411735535,
-0.8044459819793701,
0.3079946041107178,
-0.31716644763946533,
-0.8279359340667725,
0.2254466861486435,
0.35678836703300476,
-0.6649432182312012,
0.04733924940228462,
-0.6698437333106995,
0.7942087054252625,
-0.6821356415748596,
-0.463786244392395,
-0.23680375516414642,
-0.9210276007652283,
0.23424674570560455,
-0.12266881763935089,
0.14160200953483582,
-0.35845619440078735,
0.0931592807173729,
0.5617530941963196,
-0.17728960514068604,
0.8876204490661621,
0.039110079407691956,
0.04074077680706978,
-0.0006014939863234758,
0.08650743216276169,
0.27592259645462036,
0.088688425719738,
-0.316574364900589,
0.09927081316709518,
-0.03847690299153328,
-0.2546629309654236,
-0.5731318593025208,
0.5865971446037292,
-1.1221073865890503,
-0.7947421669960022,
-0.4193063974380493,
-0.521939218044281,
-0.3867027759552002,
0.015054956078529358,
0.05194507911801338,
0.1003456711769104,
-0.29908454418182373,
0.005941732320934534,
0.511907160282135,
-0.18325884640216827,
0.12229626625776291,
0.47703081369400024,
-0.2955497205257416,
-0.1310853213071823,
0.6587587594985962,
-0.1852744221687317,
0.5358597636222839,
0.2919332683086395,
0.48091840744018555,
-0.555761456489563,
-0.5303742289543152,
-0.3682047426700592,
0.1268821507692337,
-0.653637707233429,
0.023686910048127174,
-0.45211973786354065,
0.016013117507100105,
-0.16503176093101501,
-0.35008668899536133,
-0.22435535490512848,
-0.4182972013950348,
-0.4841826558113098,
-0.41724884510040283,
0.4056372344493866,
0.4967400133609772,
-0.05305979400873184,
0.3661216199398041,
-0.5538070797920227,
0.1921309381723404,
0.4048954248428345,
0.2574225068092346,
-0.09594521671533585,
-0.7634848356246948,
-0.04438948258757591,
0.3222410976886749,
-0.3205292522907257,
-0.4719673693180084,
0.3511563241481781,
0.04738376662135124,
0.521189272403717,
0.5428122282028198,
-0.008652441203594208,
0.7805078029632568,
-0.23991309106349945,
0.5452125668525696,
0.22059713304042816,
-0.8116292953491211,
0.3709634840488434,
-0.32744184136390686,
0.00008574536332162097,
0.8137461543083191,
0.518039345741272,
-0.6225593686103821,
0.01962500624358654,
-0.2583766281604767,
-0.552401602268219,
0.7235081195831299,
-0.24991723895072937,
0.05292073264718056,
0.17003069818019867,
0.4249345362186432,
0.3399621248245239,
-0.02981594204902649,
-0.6827731728553772,
-0.06686480343341827,
-0.2583998739719391,
-0.0757894292473793,
-0.2737884223461151,
-0.31456875801086426,
-0.5054225921630859,
-0.3008681833744049,
0.42218756675720215,
-0.20279768109321594,
-0.20066718757152557,
-0.054649073630571365,
-0.1869332492351532,
-0.052245721220970154,
0.6263633966445923,
0.6094816327095032,
0.6157395839691162,
-0.5903961062431335,
0.20283687114715576,
0.20210127532482147,
-0.11276622861623764,
0.4404524862766266,
-0.23678116500377655,
-0.016926532611250877,
-0.5626440644264221,
0.1662309318780899,
0.871576726436615,
0.1596979796886444,
-0.5355827808380127,
0.3644248843193054,
-0.14637576043605804,
-0.21432390809059143,
0.07994482666254044,
0.2547595500946045,
0.36935698986053467,
0.15773959457874298,
-0.06161434203386307,
0.2905781865119934,
0.2433338761329651,
-0.4611772894859314,
-0.09805946052074432,
0.4314323961734772,
-0.34650880098342896,
-0.4658161699771881,
0.46090176701545715,
0.1612798422574997,
0.0714254155755043,
0.3632822036743164,
-0.1944935917854309,
-0.3271942436695099,
0.28997665643692017,
0.16125789284706116,
0.6294322609901428,
0.07487783581018448,
0.24105380475521088,
0.12825928628444672,
0.03440319746732712,
-0.09071023017168045,
-0.04605555161833763,
0.06929843127727509,
-1.1013532876968384,
-0.21134912967681885,
-0.7212711572647095,
-0.4423585534095764,
0.020932026207447052,
-0.8778506517410278,
0.3266555666923523,
-0.5112671852111816,
-0.3574641942977905,
0.20796966552734375,
-0.06239936128258705,
-0.7187076210975647,
0.10862483084201813,
0.19648513197898865,
0.6012707352638245,
-0.6766594052314758,
0.7802731394767761,
0.7533196806907654,
-0.45436879992485046,
-0.8125942945480347,
-0.15625645220279694,
0.3863496482372284,
-0.9362522959709167,
0.633948802947998,
-0.03332307189702988,
-0.132221519947052,
-0.2799890339374542,
-0.41920235753059387,
-0.6268818974494934,
1.0082930326461792,
0.6970100998878479,
-0.794365406036377,
-0.08572133630514145,
0.3013124167919159,
0.6250496506690979,
-0.1964554786682129,
0.2781981825828552,
0.76126629114151,
0.5386847853660583,
0.0059213787317276,
-1.0014177560806274,
-0.11209343373775482,
0.17888440191745758,
-0.16561666131019592,
0.08193574845790863,
-0.8676441311836243,
0.6616209149360657,
-0.31772923469543457,
-0.042528703808784485,
-0.07234738767147064,
0.17071077227592468,
0.3424138128757477,
0.2222384214401245,
0.6674063205718994,
0.3983975946903229,
0.6349201202392578,
0.10796324163675308,
1.0174463987350464,
-0.11536075174808502,
0.26956823468208313,
1.2173348665237427,
-0.5515486598014832,
0.7320782542228699,
0.6955662965774536,
-0.3735846281051636,
0.27058297395706177,
0.9469298720359802,
0.18618059158325195,
0.427499383687973,
0.195356547832489,
-0.04545951634645462,
-0.3674734830856323,
-0.1860206574201584,
-0.20684705674648285,
0.7460494041442871,
0.06800442934036255,
-0.1325966864824295,
-0.06615551561117172,
-0.28035059571266174,
-0.00874222069978714,
0.06364738941192627,
-0.08603248745203018,
0.8078613877296448,
0.1218273937702179,
-0.6219420433044434,
0.5497724413871765,
-0.06240613013505936,
0.6808675527572632,
-0.5677473545074463,
0.25216370820999146,
-0.23761408030986786,
-0.08529327064752579,
-0.40977296233177185,
-0.886684238910675,
0.11645116657018661,
-0.003759735496714711,
-0.35067683458328247,
-0.24226731061935425,
0.615153431892395,
-0.10587511211633682,
-0.04140471667051315,
0.28486549854278564,
0.46378231048583984,
0.14055295288562775,
-0.12401110678911209,
-0.724484384059906,
0.13579994440078735,
0.27129891514778137,
-0.34575095772743225,
0.7691548466682434,
0.0264222864061594,
-0.40926265716552734,
0.6634153127670288,
0.6944471001625061,
0.06579156965017319,
-0.24632234871387482,
0.28002673387527466,
0.8672300577163696,
-0.5537571310997009,
-0.247028186917305,
-1.0198739767074585,
0.3906533420085907,
0.05885551869869232,
-0.2475476711988449,
0.5154827833175659,
0.5692633986473083,
0.7288357615470886,
-0.01355748437345028,
0.8632341623306274,
0.22955501079559326,
0.38248637318611145,
-0.5460556745529175,
0.8097353577613831,
-0.5061347484588623,
0.34052810072898865,
-0.16322758793830872,
-0.8423091173171997,
-0.07561367750167847,
0.5778290629386902,
-0.5571647882461548,
-0.032888736575841904,
0.3027578592300415,
0.6898878216743469,
0.01841065287590027,
-0.22617127001285553,
0.32679417729377747,
-0.19228748977184296,
0.4112299084663391,
0.5895127058029175,
1.061356544494629,
0.16852152347564697,
0.24388326704502106,
-0.18147514760494232,
-0.27221912145614624,
-0.3567752540111542,
-0.8870407938957214,
-0.7446922063827515,
-0.26602840423583984,
-0.17033997178077698,
-0.04364151135087013,
-0.06732035428285599,
1.235267996788025,
0.6908993124961853,
-0.7330067753791809,
-0.3181236982345581,
0.3151974380016327,
0.08948837965726852,
0.1943580061197281,
-0.1344841867685318,
0.20887763798236847,
-0.06986164301633835,
-0.5613772869110107,
0.1999480426311493,
0.2583440840244293,
0.24852046370506287,
-0.12791860103607178,
-0.525180459022522,
0.06624578684568405,
-0.021996036171913147,
0.46413934230804443,
0.32148808240890503,
-0.8124321103096008,
-0.7158710956573486,
0.10997185856103897,
-0.28676435351371765,
0.35145118832588196,
0.49986693263053894,
-0.4622684419155121,
0.4120693802833557,
0.28019994497299194,
0.5050376653671265,
0.478608638048172,
0.13338328897953033,
0.6197394728660583,
-0.4668351113796234,
0.13474434614181519,
0.0702686533331871,
0.5288919806480408,
0.32739531993865967,
-0.42513149976730347,
0.5376056432723999,
-0.06793151050806046,
-0.7439454793930054,
-0.5678227543830872,
0.2523943781852722,
-1.2052057981491089,
-0.11306239664554596,
1.0841838121414185,
-0.016990501433610916,
-0.024108631536364555,
0.1309395432472229,
-0.45690906047821045,
0.11535055190324783,
-0.5326418280601501,
0.8993690609931946,
0.8301304578781128,
-0.4622752070426941,
0.15779069066047668,
-0.5383286476135254,
0.53841632604599,
0.44609326124191284,
-0.6327406764030457,
-0.06946181505918503,
0.5774844288825989,
0.6618476510047913,
-0.060076553374528885,
0.4578492045402527,
-0.16989102959632874,
0.18363416194915771,
-0.5256527662277222,
0.31781095266342163,
-0.0504022091627121,
-0.037699002772569656,
-0.5119935870170593,
-0.2716433107852936,
0.6417145729064941,
-0.11458075791597366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11295v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11295v3 | OneBit: Towards Extremely Low-bit Large Language Models | 2024-02-17T14:26:57 | 2024-05-22T03:55:10 | Yuzhuang Xu, Xu Han, Zonghan Yang, Shuo Wang, Qingfu Zhu, Zhiyuan Liu, Weidong Liu, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL | Model quantification uses low bit-width values to represent the weight
matrices of existing models to be quantized, which is a promising approach to
reduce both storage and computational overheads of deploying highly anticipated
LLMs. However, current quantization methods suffer severe performance
degradation when the bit-width is extremely reduced, and thus focus on
utilizing 4-bit or 8-bit values to quantize models. This paper boldly quantizes
the weight matrices of LLMs to 1-bit, paving the way for the extremely low
bit-width deployment of LLMs. For this target, we introduce a 1-bit model
compressing framework named OneBit, including a novel 1-bit parameter
representation method to better quantize LLMs as well as an effective parameter
initialization method based on matrix decomposition to improve the convergence
speed of the quantization framework. Sufficient experimental results indicate
that OneBit achieves good performance (at least 81% of the non-quantized
performance on LLaMA models) with robust training processes when only using
1-bit weight matrices. | [
-0.631999135017395,
-0.6795791387557983,
0.5900176763534546,
0.20561248064041138,
-0.6662667989730835,
-0.006534359883517027,
0.09497274458408356,
-0.3069300353527069,
0.27444666624069214,
0.6183391809463501,
-0.48391345143318176,
-0.3900550603866577,
-0.46958571672439575,
-0.27551743388175964,
-0.5217793583869934,
0.3800950348377228,
0.2857515513896942,
0.08333895355463028,
-0.08726024627685547,
-0.12781071662902832,
0.08586837351322174,
-0.6553754210472107,
-0.6419984102249146,
-0.14069683849811554,
0.14857032895088196,
0.21321892738342285,
0.8587133288383484,
0.9215054512023926,
0.5953295230865479,
0.1785895824432373,
-0.30976414680480957,
-0.390390008687973,
-0.2704046368598938,
-0.1448380947113037,
0.2681843340396881,
-0.706885039806366,
-0.7536274194717407,
-0.0795358344912529,
0.9336211681365967,
0.9706987738609314,
-0.32692578434944153,
0.6397020220756531,
-0.3706382215023041,
0.7509359121322632,
-0.7247973680496216,
-0.2846626341342926,
-0.4418317973613739,
0.2006656378507614,
-0.07684748619794846,
-0.021610060706734657,
-0.39202532172203064,
-0.290538489818573,
-0.11939919739961624,
-0.4313795566558838,
0.1255701631307602,
0.4058554172515869,
0.6734674572944641,
0.24179458618164062,
-0.34946903586387634,
0.18786543607711792,
-0.7520814538002014,
0.8596468567848206,
-1.055731177330017,
0.5129250884056091,
0.251967191696167,
0.12282271683216095,
0.1320049911737442,
-0.4824505150318146,
-0.5154252648353577,
0.07121658325195312,
0.3416459858417511,
-0.5774253010749817,
-0.595618724822998,
0.37111642956733704,
0.27531012892723083,
0.3797070384025574,
-0.5624623894691467,
0.13831570744514465,
-0.4278910458087921,
-0.26848816871643066,
0.3691336214542389,
0.26902249455451965,
-0.1209334135055542,
0.10299692302942276,
-0.5464339256286621,
-0.06178335100412369,
-1.128774642944336,
-0.15065869688987732,
0.6441220641136169,
0.36279451847076416,
-0.02047775685787201,
0.2429356426000595,
-0.05967102199792862,
0.7746649980545044,
-0.06229156255722046,
-0.1866675764322281,
-0.1508151739835739,
-0.033651676028966904,
-0.47552841901779175,
0.2602927088737488,
0.7339972257614136,
-0.12228990346193314,
0.03217118978500366,
-0.06292837858200073,
-0.37918660044670105,
0.20064596831798553,
0.20257285237312317,
-1.2155773639678955,
-0.06553693115711212,
0.1374119520187378,
-0.9070194959640503,
-0.1698678433895111,
-0.3396383225917816,
-0.34601107239723206,
-0.3056860566139221,
-0.07117806375026703,
0.7360665798187256,
-0.4173749089241028,
-0.2907998561859131,
0.44677796959877014,
0.30380457639694214,
0.20814011991024017,
0.31926074624061584,
-0.8336867690086365,
0.629753053188324,
0.5500145554542542,
0.7999851107597351,
0.174125537276268,
0.2548639178276062,
-0.2228015512228012,
-0.03656617924571037,
-0.6035181879997253,
0.3851218521595001,
-0.398906946182251,
-0.21847069263458252,
-0.2831673324108124,
-0.47658178210258484,
0.6091935038566589,
-0.573882520198822,
0.0006153215654194355,
-0.6578516364097595,
-0.4204074740409851,
-0.05871984362602234,
-0.543834924697876,
-0.17280051112174988,
0.2544489800930023,
-0.9079492688179016,
0.5622596144676208,
0.20702441036701202,
-0.5454542636871338,
0.17608079314231873,
-0.43060407042503357,
-0.31606975197792053,
0.051738955080509186,
0.01722867041826248,
-0.41687479615211487,
0.5729561448097229,
0.04652075469493866,
0.48634493350982666,
-0.7026908993721008,
-0.10619249939918518,
-0.408368319272995,
-0.77739417552948,
0.15135347843170166,
-0.8794482946395874,
0.8817917108535767,
0.4561769664287567,
0.12043147534132004,
-0.29698827862739563,
-1.0726752281188965,
0.22887055575847626,
0.2534346282482147,
-0.5469407439231873,
-0.058033548295497894,
-0.15468226373195648,
-0.0659702941775322,
0.15412065386772156,
0.3636948764324188,
-0.7083963751792908,
0.3489616811275482,
-0.5480051040649414,
0.5384899377822876,
0.7273435592651367,
-0.07058137655258179,
0.4997948408126831,
-0.0803627148270607,
0.9651491045951843,
0.009756823070347309,
0.36026355624198914,
-0.30181917548179626,
-0.01219727098941803,
-0.9044017791748047,
-0.4033512473106384,
0.7172272205352783,
0.23319752514362335,
-0.4616479277610779,
0.26973459124565125,
-0.49234673380851746,
-0.30720391869544983,
-0.8185019493103027,
0.14799514412879944,
0.28158193826675415,
-0.117813341319561,
0.1418527066707611,
-0.30707305669784546,
-0.5560995936393738,
-1.08245050907135,
0.22492730617523193,
-0.4307437837123871,
-0.1677377074956894,
-0.1814728081226349,
0.32748180627822876,
0.0020602894946932793,
0.9445969462394714,
-0.29448574781417847,
-0.0023757333401590586,
-0.21138186752796173,
-0.014850644394755363,
0.09882720559835434,
0.6148741245269775,
0.3017011284828186,
-0.6397707462310791,
-0.22665467858314514,
-0.39423868060112,
-0.3143523931503296,
0.2991838753223419,
0.20455247163772583,
0.06436800956726074,
0.2758268415927887,
0.47427111864089966,
-0.2512180805206299,
0.5301347374916077,
0.766390860080719,
-0.2566004991531372,
0.2404453456401825,
-0.1271350383758545,
-0.1904403567314148,
-0.812833309173584,
-0.04921560734510422,
0.014555953443050385,
-0.696097731590271,
-0.39975690841674805,
0.035768210887908936,
0.0986545979976654,
-0.12718716263771057,
-0.7914780378341675,
0.44987624883651733,
-0.3340229392051697,
-0.12420598417520523,
-0.2360253483057022,
-0.19814568758010864,
0.07081656157970428,
0.4793429970741272,
-0.1671948879957199,
0.7825130820274353,
0.6006277799606323,
-0.7204378247261047,
0.34647712111473083,
0.10418039560317993,
-0.3962414860725403,
0.43760186433792114,
-0.6912612915039062,
0.036620937287807465,
-0.1556810736656189,
0.11583658307790756,
-0.9914736151695251,
0.23275935649871826,
-0.20840448141098022,
-0.39545154571533203,
0.43238115310668945,
-0.42269572615623474,
-1.0545371770858765,
-0.11070894449949265,
-0.5444511771202087,
0.5665410161018372,
0.6470641493797302,
-0.5063323974609375,
0.48671507835388184,
0.4010249376296997,
0.009816447272896767,
-0.21313580870628357,
-1.1112064123153687,
-0.04786919802427292,
-0.21774980425834656,
-0.5540332794189453,
0.1434229016304016,
-0.07882706075906754,
-0.07013330608606339,
-0.05996512994170189,
-0.305826336145401,
-0.11570896208286285,
0.20781557261943817,
0.10827171802520752,
0.28550395369529724,
-0.3456060588359833,
0.45781949162483215,
-0.0499737374484539,
-0.16312021017074585,
0.06901967525482178,
-0.37120771408081055,
0.6871017217636108,
-0.2636556327342987,
-0.2407931685447693,
-0.13751651346683502,
0.4151378273963928,
0.2854914665222168,
-0.2565511167049408,
0.8602703213691711,
0.5401899218559265,
-0.4805697202682495,
-0.21379512548446655,
-0.5040847063064575,
-0.17031988501548767,
-0.4883992075920105,
0.2971474826335907,
-0.4960726499557495,
-0.9698758721351624,
0.4867617189884186,
-0.36957621574401855,
-0.24301539361476898,
0.11855359375476837,
0.3379693925380707,
0.06120061129331589,
1.3324977159500122,
1.1607028245925903,
-0.17579759657382965,
0.4519925117492676,
-0.5334863662719727,
0.31108909845352173,
-0.9710612893104553,
0.30561399459838867,
-0.473785936832428,
-0.2862779498100281,
-0.6570788621902466,
-0.3031350374221802,
0.5188398957252502,
0.29736655950546265,
-0.5806986689567566,
0.44242045283317566,
-0.5614432692527771,
0.4740903377532959,
0.5965642333030701,
0.30452102422714233,
0.19682982563972473,
0.1309633105993271,
-0.0839678943157196,
0.1967412233352661,
-0.953252375125885,
-0.795634925365448,
1.1360054016113281,
0.6573134064674377,
1.1664848327636719,
0.34229815006256104,
0.7660488486289978,
0.15851493179798126,
-0.04157598316669464,
-0.6910258531570435,
0.7727522253990173,
-0.22557033598423004,
-0.8254095911979675,
-0.43791627883911133,
-0.5728068351745605,
-0.74127596616745,
0.1475326269865036,
-0.1816851794719696,
-0.9056947827339172,
0.030435437336564064,
0.20517772436141968,
-0.7710763812065125,
0.5125540494918823,
-0.5482369065284729,
0.7666919827461243,
0.0526573583483696,
-0.27843302488327026,
-0.18713130056858063,
-0.691374659538269,
0.34242361783981323,
0.03014276921749115,
0.2243121862411499,
-0.30057597160339355,
-0.39741671085357666,
0.932306170463562,
-0.5281557440757751,
0.791871964931488,
-0.11598692089319229,
-0.41405341029167175,
0.43390873074531555,
0.6305490136146545,
0.5336296558380127,
-0.019976800307631493,
-0.06838038563728333,
0.2023565024137497,
0.4408748745918274,
-0.6503797173500061,
-0.3968493640422821,
0.5550116300582886,
-0.571989119052887,
-0.38375306129455566,
-0.00874517671763897,
-0.40044713020324707,
-0.3522034287452698,
-0.10611247271299362,
0.27959492802619934,
0.5179615020751953,
0.1516384780406952,
0.0952770784497261,
1.145187497138977,
-0.23407161235809326,
0.5067477226257324,
0.4884727895259857,
-0.26749569177627563,
-0.2597951889038086,
1.0427453517913818,
0.16491059958934784,
0.4970438778400421,
0.6054892539978027,
0.08889016509056091,
-0.09833022952079773,
-0.635597288608551,
-0.30303955078125,
0.22859707474708557,
-0.9807442426681519,
-0.5083858370780945,
-0.29788705706596375,
0.022059191018342972,
-0.4534111022949219,
-0.10809612274169922,
-0.8520850539207458,
-0.754264235496521,
-0.2395290583372116,
0.06430693715810776,
0.1155000850558281,
0.5648049116134644,
-0.004243095871061087,
0.9377894997596741,
-0.8998438715934753,
0.1705724000930786,
0.20850837230682373,
0.7357404828071594,
0.1259322166442871,
-0.7589300870895386,
-0.5976437330245972,
-0.3135867118835449,
-0.28456196188926697,
-0.635033905506134,
0.28278782963752747,
-0.019125834107398987,
0.19877134263515472,
0.57743901014328,
-0.05892902985215187,
0.5594514012336731,
-0.3602791130542755,
0.7311328649520874,
0.26285940408706665,
-1.292191743850708,
0.47816815972328186,
0.18174543976783752,
0.41791701316833496,
0.5481410026550293,
0.642853319644928,
-0.2744907736778259,
0.03009108081459999,
-0.6070716977119446,
-0.9086726307868958,
0.664837658405304,
-0.16419218480587006,
0.3584679067134857,
0.12889720499515533,
0.31412363052368164,
0.07564224302768707,
0.5063737034797668,
-0.8000189065933228,
-0.49500226974487305,
0.2513895034790039,
-0.26156479120254517,
0.25648728013038635,
-0.5166584253311157,
0.25184616446495056,
-0.006992944050580263,
0.8278117775917053,
-0.1827010214328766,
0.655265212059021,
-0.1323757767677307,
-0.17244364321231842,
-0.31552672386169434,
0.24062195420265198,
0.26269134879112244,
0.6009116768836975,
-0.3834840655326843,
0.3002471327781677,
0.06928616762161255,
-0.28103017807006836,
0.5638589859008789,
-0.12398910522460938,
-0.06987134367227554,
-0.15286007523536682,
0.3868131935596466,
0.9163286685943604,
0.05558820068836212,
-0.7066130042076111,
0.6077852249145508,
0.025340206921100616,
0.0015574932331219316,
-0.1034349575638771,
0.05544522777199745,
-0.06628718227148056,
0.23319590091705322,
0.2468923181295395,
-0.3906877934932709,
0.3144954741001129,
-0.478488028049469,
-0.09615010768175125,
0.6539562344551086,
-0.34650304913520813,
-0.40464842319488525,
0.6172234416007996,
0.06913534551858902,
-0.03832486271858215,
0.5312108993530273,
-0.5932142734527588,
-0.44292357563972473,
0.4234953224658966,
0.4939028322696686,
0.6213449835777283,
-0.04143979027867317,
-0.09504188597202301,
0.3687768876552582,
0.5930843949317932,
-0.1381601095199585,
0.3157607316970825,
-0.19027192890644073,
-0.6233933568000793,
-0.6310229301452637,
-0.8720184564590454,
-0.35929733514785767,
0.04326608404517174,
-0.4863334596157074,
0.23893296718597412,
-0.7247824668884277,
-0.29269513487815857,
-0.13169480860233307,
0.263772189617157,
-0.6182793378829956,
0.3078538775444031,
0.6587911248207092,
1.0192238092422485,
-0.6418247222900391,
0.844116747379303,
0.6478026509284973,
-0.30872994661331177,
-0.7379903793334961,
-0.45296305418014526,
-0.19044919312000275,
-0.7015588879585266,
0.5254790186882019,
0.018507234752178192,
0.1373460739850998,
0.43605899810791016,
-0.9809877872467041,
-0.9897518754005432,
1.017015814781189,
0.8349881768226624,
-0.8971295356750488,
-0.1974451094865799,
0.3966382145881653,
0.1325228363275528,
-0.1256837546825409,
0.15287500619888306,
0.5576079487800598,
0.3302431106567383,
0.1326320469379425,
-0.7895984649658203,
0.17626149952411652,
0.2223382443189621,
0.36140963435173035,
0.5843710899353027,
-0.7297400832176208,
1.0701857805252075,
-0.10645045340061188,
-0.3389771282672882,
0.10536723583936691,
0.49942612648010254,
0.06760362535715103,
-0.1894247829914093,
0.40588343143463135,
0.7627495527267456,
0.43513593077659607,
0.15720152854919434,
0.9644757509231567,
-0.5581477284431458,
0.45741361379623413,
0.7706048488616943,
-0.1074468195438385,
0.8562520146369934,
0.695539653301239,
-0.7350285649299622,
0.15897077322006226,
0.3899465501308441,
0.21125157177448273,
0.24465565383434296,
0.6734122037887573,
-0.43780604004859924,
-0.6399930715560913,
-0.0025047692470252514,
0.21354977786540985,
0.40565189719200134,
0.24027754366397858,
-0.1540132462978363,
-0.24659541249275208,
0.24964122474193573,
-0.0596357062458992,
-0.19142067432403564,
-0.667007565498352,
0.49694329500198364,
0.046223223209381104,
0.11415518075227737,
0.8282873630523682,
0.3099844753742218,
0.9105741381645203,
-0.7028213739395142,
-0.10641536116600037,
-0.19568946957588196,
0.05139834061264992,
0.07308068126440048,
-0.3495411276817322,
-0.06598328053951263,
-0.11276190727949142,
-0.2215196043252945,
-0.11043988913297653,
0.6178562045097351,
-0.22788141667842865,
-0.6974819898605347,
-0.050631292164325714,
0.4279967248439789,
0.2100083827972412,
-0.5160724520683289,
-0.31665804982185364,
0.5943742990493774,
-0.17699576914310455,
-0.4419696033000946,
0.411596417427063,
0.46386629343032837,
0.043426379561424255,
0.9760684370994568,
0.31025999784469604,
0.3367007374763489,
0.26181793212890625,
-0.3548794686794281,
0.7644545435905457,
-0.8511181473731995,
-0.3103007972240448,
-0.9002564549446106,
0.16988366842269897,
0.6408121585845947,
0.009660124778747559,
0.40402722358703613,
0.5977131724357605,
0.7498913407325745,
0.18257246911525726,
0.5879594087600708,
0.046244893223047256,
0.32196688652038574,
-0.5481781959533691,
0.5198976397514343,
-0.624774694442749,
0.49726971983909607,
0.1187046468257904,
-0.7631587386131287,
-0.2576362192630768,
0.6720598340034485,
0.24211324751377106,
0.1364678293466568,
0.3641376197338104,
0.727883517742157,
0.02824273146688938,
-0.42687615752220154,
0.8493807315826416,
0.0506063811480999,
0.217099130153656,
0.7288042902946472,
0.49660980701446533,
-0.7169082164764404,
0.6680545210838318,
-0.49722054600715637,
-0.04835228621959686,
-0.1919981986284256,
-0.896013617515564,
-0.6664963364601135,
-0.42470458149909973,
-0.4602600038051605,
-0.1584453582763672,
-0.20922265946865082,
1.3081833124160767,
1.1546940803527832,
-0.4699484705924988,
-0.15370100736618042,
-0.05802121385931969,
-0.08800584077835083,
0.23266686499118805,
-0.18816156685352325,
0.1734033226966858,
-0.1656595915555954,
-0.5402941703796387,
0.14059554040431976,
0.3058488368988037,
0.3971467614173889,
-0.9375132918357849,
-0.03456087037920952,
-0.08960673213005066,
0.5363523364067078,
0.6183167099952698,
-0.03565051779150963,
-0.3766186237335205,
0.055791936814785004,
-0.201097771525383,
-0.13131333887577057,
0.1296713650226593,
0.6990265846252441,
-1.2337039709091187,
0.2083698809146881,
0.2254522293806076,
0.5005396008491516,
0.6217520236968994,
-0.21229775249958038,
0.11728832125663757,
-0.9828709363937378,
0.29200685024261475,
0.3331654965877533,
0.22592605650424957,
0.30878788232803345,
-0.15593014657497406,
0.4717826247215271,
-0.11593493819236755,
-0.3288886547088623,
-1.0107795000076294,
0.16717563569545746,
-0.8796528577804565,
-0.3591510057449341,
0.9556943774223328,
-0.16251905262470245,
-0.681162416934967,
0.5664278864860535,
-0.0049742949195206165,
0.0989099070429802,
-0.32628563046455383,
0.3151313066482544,
0.661806046962738,
0.07079936563968658,
-0.2513822913169861,
-0.5597066879272461,
0.03236407786607742,
0.2977285087108612,
-0.47028353810310364,
0.0416351780295372,
0.2934988737106323,
0.25254860520362854,
0.21512284874916077,
0.6442456841468811,
0.01141941174864769,
0.13039080798625946,
0.3734852075576782,
0.5895333886146545,
-0.1383412629365921,
-0.23432838916778564,
-0.8504622578620911,
0.12252812832593918,
0.49363863468170166,
-0.24368974566459656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11291v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11291v2 | Puzzle Solving using Reasoning of Large Language Models: A Survey | 2024-02-17T14:19:38 | 2024-04-20T07:04:28 | Panagiotis Giadikiaroglou, Maria Lymperaiou, Giorgos Filandrianos, Giorgos Stamou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Exploring the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) in puzzle solving
unveils critical insights into their potential and challenges in AI, marking a
significant step towards understanding their applicability in complex reasoning
tasks. This survey leverages a unique taxonomy -- dividing puzzles into
rule-based and rule-less categories -- to critically assess LLMs through
various methodologies, including prompting techniques, neuro-symbolic
approaches, and fine-tuning. Through a critical review of relevant datasets and
benchmarks, we assess LLMs' performance, identifying significant challenges in
complex puzzle scenarios. Our findings highlight the disparity between LLM
capabilities and human-like reasoning, particularly in those requiring advanced
logical inference. The survey underscores the necessity for novel strategies
and richer datasets to advance LLMs' puzzle-solving proficiency and contribute
to AI's logical reasoning and creative problem-solving advancements. | [
-0.28131672739982605,
-0.9922617673873901,
0.922697901725769,
0.1789773851633072,
-0.0007374815759249032,
0.26887959241867065,
-0.37754860520362854,
-0.42772114276885986,
-0.08664032816886902,
0.39466196298599243,
-0.8169277906417847,
-0.396633505821228,
-0.7808290719985962,
0.3713477849960327,
-0.39622434973716736,
0.43619266152381897,
-0.01501456554979086,
0.135716512799263,
-0.6005598902702332,
0.1689980924129486,
-0.5260451436042786,
-0.4991331994533539,
-0.7117821574211121,
-0.5057926774024963,
0.6505899429321289,
0.4762476980686188,
0.5176360607147217,
0.558505654335022,
0.6377755999565125,
0.3374779224395752,
-0.37964093685150146,
0.5291110277175903,
-0.42044007778167725,
0.26693812012672424,
-0.1506885588169098,
-1.043057918548584,
-0.2762766480445862,
0.05982936546206474,
0.3028571903705597,
0.7952836751937866,
-0.22047200798988342,
0.20036397874355316,
-0.37289121747016907,
0.5968113541603088,
-0.2741791009902954,
0.4557174742221832,
-0.7764487862586975,
0.22436179220676422,
-0.388316810131073,
-0.019334139302372932,
-0.38990235328674316,
-0.30574098229408264,
-0.021714553236961365,
-0.6536282300949097,
-0.06627944856882095,
0.2677706778049469,
0.3803738057613373,
0.5645864605903625,
-0.4729039669036865,
-0.4588598906993866,
-0.7784181833267212,
0.7142950296401978,
-0.7690749168395996,
0.1422255039215088,
0.27625155448913574,
0.09909235686063766,
-0.5374298691749573,
-0.3911212086677551,
-0.5542683005332947,
-0.3335573971271515,
0.22254477441310883,
-0.11364515125751495,
-0.2484494000673294,
-0.20474134385585785,
0.7516695857048035,
0.22182318568229675,
-0.5257117748260498,
0.41784361004829407,
-0.18594098091125488,
-0.0020436388440430164,
1.0285136699676514,
0.6072853207588196,
0.33679449558258057,
0.0171214509755373,
0.23478762805461884,
-0.037929095327854156,
-0.8663249611854553,
0.051424190402030945,
0.1954466700553894,
0.08923254162073135,
0.09282903373241425,
0.6855686902999878,
-0.14852690696716309,
0.7808103561401367,
-0.21945583820343018,
-0.1663104146718979,
0.07508233934640884,
-0.1663440465927124,
-0.028092732653021812,
-0.19277673959732056,
0.6687377095222473,
0.1763990819454193,
0.48664426803588867,
-0.05968132242560387,
-0.3670775294303894,
-0.07340822368860245,
-0.13258518278598785,
-0.38041964173316956,
-0.253335565328598,
0.10074428468942642,
-0.3602098226547241,
0.1012062057852745,
-0.35532376170158386,
-0.41238731145858765,
-0.8184147477149963,
-0.4468657076358795,
0.40256258845329285,
-0.13764306902885437,
-0.41176655888557434,
0.36088934540748596,
-0.2599383592605591,
0.31857311725616455,
0.6043872833251953,
-0.5952050089836121,
-0.006027865223586559,
0.9415484666824341,
0.5408117771148682,
-0.07958616316318512,
-0.023855386301875114,
-0.359619140625,
0.010419380851089954,
-0.526228129863739,
0.7854962944984436,
-0.7100932002067566,
-0.3403775691986084,
-0.07449223846197128,
-0.13004374504089355,
-0.005632263608276844,
-0.9372389912605286,
0.5905607342720032,
-0.3843643367290497,
-0.025647873058915138,
-0.4414841830730438,
-0.6145488619804382,
-0.28663724660873413,
0.5759642720222473,
-0.7685492634773254,
0.7439623475074768,
-0.24777278304100037,
-0.3843238353729248,
-0.10170520097017288,
-0.6930910348892212,
-0.6250028610229492,
0.15348875522613525,
-0.34836816787719727,
-0.24350909888744354,
0.38943982124328613,
0.2642904818058014,
0.5229936838150024,
-0.8221834301948547,
0.35028302669525146,
-0.27579858899116516,
-0.2429567277431488,
0.42424046993255615,
-0.3665153384208679,
0.7755770087242126,
0.23912383615970612,
-0.19727782905101776,
0.11056934297084808,
-0.605417013168335,
0.0005454542697407305,
0.5995442271232605,
-0.07590943574905396,
-0.12632404267787933,
0.465824156999588,
-0.290860116481781,
0.3527261018753052,
0.39275461435317993,
-0.37155652046203613,
0.562903642654419,
-0.15853053331375122,
0.6918670535087585,
0.6068379282951355,
-0.2181081920862198,
-0.02800656296312809,
-0.40321096777915955,
0.5989160537719727,
0.1494540572166443,
-0.09416141360998154,
-0.09608938544988632,
-0.68217933177948,
-0.785114586353302,
-0.12347909063100815,
0.17175649106502533,
0.7183753848075867,
-0.6721919178962708,
0.334909051656723,
-0.15664057433605194,
-0.6637688279151917,
-0.47928252816200256,
0.07217676937580109,
0.23838435113430023,
0.34214112162590027,
0.15722474455833435,
0.02912370301783085,
-0.49678894877433777,
-0.8346855640411377,
-0.33291178941726685,
-0.19019684195518494,
-0.1400085687637329,
0.4804081916809082,
0.7291238903999329,
-0.18770486116409302,
0.6963773965835571,
-0.5372963547706604,
-0.11376256495714188,
-0.3952171504497528,
0.2655567526817322,
0.3243124186992645,
0.24764886498451233,
0.033578041940927505,
-0.766107976436615,
-0.2222147434949875,
-0.14528144896030426,
-0.8555564284324646,
-0.20731860399246216,
-0.11611629277467728,
0.38008978962898254,
0.23599980771541595,
0.7478668689727783,
-0.8588102459907532,
0.2512277066707611,
0.32423827052116394,
-0.30060359835624695,
0.5773663520812988,
-0.10905449837446213,
0.06791620701551437,
-0.758588433265686,
-0.09417831897735596,
-0.035139936953783035,
0.12881311774253845,
-0.449146568775177,
0.13404624164104462,
-0.2532564699649811,
0.05016431212425232,
-0.11834234744310379,
0.2665507197380066,
-0.7198367118835449,
-0.018764419481158257,
-0.054267991334199905,
0.20528551936149597,
-0.35302987694740295,
0.20436939597129822,
0.11760807037353516,
0.49202972650527954,
0.5293706655502319,
-0.27850937843322754,
0.7048097848892212,
0.10580503940582275,
-0.5663365125656128,
0.3940262794494629,
-0.689847469329834,
0.300117552280426,
-0.34558579325675964,
0.2552112340927124,
-0.9939121603965759,
-0.22892174124717712,
0.1842714548110962,
-0.30864906311035156,
0.12985500693321228,
0.17848585546016693,
-1.0179686546325684,
-0.4787534475326538,
0.07699480652809143,
0.5733237862586975,
0.5340170860290527,
-0.18441903591156006,
0.6171775460243225,
0.3834296762943268,
-0.0811091959476471,
-0.41703322529792786,
-0.611548662185669,
0.4669294059276581,
-0.3224034309387207,
-0.67413729429245,
0.10840527713298798,
-0.3023230731487274,
-0.5381393432617188,
-0.14562004804611206,
-0.17287801206111908,
0.1299188733100891,
0.3217580318450928,
0.035468775779008865,
0.05469653382897377,
-0.129827618598938,
-0.017812667414546013,
-0.3163953125476837,
0.019510503858327866,
0.5294612050056458,
0.08887879550457001,
0.5070313811302185,
-0.17535853385925293,
-0.6748532056808472,
-0.23829783499240875,
0.48795586824417114,
0.6000164747238159,
-0.578948438167572,
0.5273947715759277,
0.23742248117923737,
-0.46046996116638184,
-0.20971077680587769,
-0.6607025265693665,
-0.16988633573055267,
-0.4122113883495331,
0.6305598616600037,
-0.47550714015960693,
-1.2639240026474,
0.6860455274581909,
-0.331461101770401,
0.015428049489855766,
0.1747370958328247,
0.8152832984924316,
-0.1368192434310913,
1.3151912689208984,
0.29797378182411194,
-0.15843114256858826,
-0.009754952974617481,
-0.10865192115306854,
0.5137039422988892,
-0.6460593342781067,
-0.6412094831466675,
-0.7199925184249878,
-0.4863874614238739,
-0.33850809931755066,
-0.6099134087562561,
0.4110208749771118,
0.04585842043161392,
-0.2720445394515991,
0.01123209297657013,
-0.4754624664783478,
0.5228180885314941,
0.4435127377510071,
-0.081122986972332,
0.5559174418449402,
-0.3047812581062317,
0.10321813076734543,
0.10112583637237549,
-0.7216631174087524,
-0.2856850028038025,
0.988008975982666,
0.2377784252166748,
0.8253049254417419,
0.24568411707878113,
0.4636054039001465,
0.05768485367298126,
0.025186141952872276,
-0.947119951248169,
0.8771229982376099,
0.09689734131097794,
-0.866765558719635,
-0.4143071174621582,
-0.574415922164917,
-1.0620187520980835,
0.14134733378887177,
-0.23541948199272156,
-0.8909542560577393,
-0.38015177845954895,
-0.033064115792512894,
-0.09862092137336731,
0.44858700037002563,
-0.379529744386673,
0.6590388417243958,
-0.4413357079029083,
0.10339975357055664,
-0.4605366885662079,
-0.5903524160385132,
0.5957419872283936,
0.0012409851187840104,
0.2928681969642639,
-0.22812557220458984,
-0.10817591845989227,
0.6345266103744507,
0.013792332261800766,
0.6969223618507385,
0.18956266343593597,
-0.4001852869987488,
0.2766377031803131,
0.30013972520828247,
0.5311263203620911,
0.014468241482973099,
0.03204423189163208,
0.10505316406488419,
-0.043574973940849304,
-0.2230883240699768,
-0.6656240224838257,
0.5470393300056458,
-0.6600487232208252,
-1.2553768157958984,
-0.5527375340461731,
-1.114357352256775,
-0.32688218355178833,
0.09016965329647064,
-0.040890883654356,
0.18671901524066925,
0.10445641726255417,
0.3341875672340393,
1.005588173866272,
-0.017142999917268753,
0.4182984530925751,
0.4802972972393036,
-0.16135193407535553,
0.02906820736825466,
0.8297990560531616,
0.2395826131105423,
-0.00992164108902216,
0.4150485694408417,
0.061788395047187805,
-0.22394567728042603,
-0.9823606610298157,
-0.13822023570537567,
0.24567364156246185,
-0.640896737575531,
-0.019960865378379822,
-0.31348174810409546,
-0.40393128991127014,
0.005162473767995834,
0.07720250636339188,
-0.2114643007516861,
-0.30998140573501587,
-0.2772293984889984,
0.2260277420282364,
0.20086298882961273,
0.8446458578109741,
0.19296568632125854,
-0.08361925184726715,
-0.7060473561286926,
0.31646090745925903,
0.4227268695831299,
0.10622387379407883,
0.13349974155426025,
-0.24445386230945587,
-0.04724075272679329,
0.014004873111844063,
-0.03322846069931984,
-0.8584818840026855,
0.03124668449163437,
-0.23089200258255005,
0.6817286610603333,
0.19882893562316895,
-0.02749343030154705,
0.596805989742279,
-0.5589801073074341,
0.8566895127296448,
0.0160357803106308,
-0.791002631187439,
0.3704078495502472,
-0.4845363199710846,
0.38721540570259094,
0.06224419176578522,
0.4469917416572571,
-0.6170768737792969,
-0.15858162939548492,
-0.35317564010620117,
-0.5908072590827942,
0.48989805579185486,
0.13667340576648712,
-0.19659361243247986,
0.049891356378793716,
0.5170566439628601,
-0.3051092326641083,
0.2754461467266083,
-0.5867117643356323,
-0.24209052324295044,
0.41960591077804565,
-0.26629212498664856,
-0.12704573571681976,
0.009062271565198898,
-0.29713743925094604,
-0.507338285446167,
0.4466218054294586,
-0.06811695545911789,
0.14871500432491302,
-0.10983439534902573,
-0.19294047355651855,
-0.2036927491426468,
0.2371615320444107,
0.7539215683937073,
0.7346528768539429,
0.09786860644817352,
0.00567939318716526,
0.2470872402191162,
-0.09331339597702026,
0.2555692493915558,
0.038141220808029175,
-0.036379702389240265,
-0.37688571214675903,
0.5439892411231995,
0.5751708745956421,
-0.29386991262435913,
-1.1665825843811035,
0.27870550751686096,
-0.12664015591144562,
-0.4444337487220764,
-0.29413843154907227,
0.3837847411632538,
0.6450559496879578,
0.5283694863319397,
0.44816452264785767,
-0.12407528609037399,
0.04870262369513512,
-0.5169030427932739,
-0.34130236506462097,
0.7813069820404053,
-0.0424717552959919,
-0.1919798105955124,
0.5693022012710571,
0.010497666895389557,
-0.6625399589538574,
0.9304410219192505,
-0.18499045073986053,
-0.4866521656513214,
1.0329113006591797,
0.6013555526733398,
0.7145391702651978,
0.06679848581552505,
0.03857225179672241,
0.04454943165183067,
0.6300896406173706,
-0.2900622487068176,
0.3886449635028839,
0.11553046852350235,
-0.8075965642929077,
-0.6536211967468262,
-0.16911044716835022,
-0.4666984975337982,
0.41719233989715576,
-0.34054315090179443,
0.042591795325279236,
-0.43881988525390625,
0.08357271552085876,
-0.08974432200193405,
0.05996190384030342,
-0.5393045544624329,
-0.013195047155022621,
0.6384061574935913,
1.1787060499191284,
-0.6585909128189087,
0.482555627822876,
1.0023071765899658,
-0.1883024424314499,
-0.8013791441917419,
-0.1522264927625656,
0.29778173565864563,
-0.6050768494606018,
0.5384780168533325,
0.09590810537338257,
-0.06452994793653488,
-0.10254503041505814,
-0.9393510818481445,
-0.8021178245544434,
1.020078420639038,
0.5296970009803772,
-0.7358843684196472,
-0.1981297731399536,
0.3656814396381378,
0.5325816869735718,
-0.4400203227996826,
0.32092276215553284,
0.8775659799575806,
0.6848276853561401,
0.10344679653644562,
-0.9554058909416199,
0.053051553666591644,
-0.3918602466583252,
0.0058550662361085415,
0.23382513225078583,
-0.8078001141548157,
0.8348535895347595,
-0.1323416531085968,
0.11943095922470093,
0.1596289873123169,
0.5977470874786377,
0.6091915965080261,
0.36368703842163086,
0.5872146487236023,
0.8697077035903931,
0.8037565350532532,
-0.28124576807022095,
0.608653724193573,
0.0064486125484108925,
0.10629450529813766,
0.8798299431800842,
-0.4517943263053894,
0.6776301860809326,
0.3706027567386627,
-0.14722144603729248,
0.5350833535194397,
0.656920850276947,
-0.12622374296188354,
0.08723793923854828,
0.7261828780174255,
-0.18056680262088776,
-0.8082491755485535,
-0.17596161365509033,
-0.24416407942771912,
0.6129987835884094,
0.7272486090660095,
0.15130212903022766,
-0.2274581342935562,
-0.2134827971458435,
0.07465663552284241,
0.21020379662513733,
-0.6213491559028625,
0.6868003606796265,
0.23881761729717255,
-0.8678723573684692,
0.4749186336994171,
0.09327420592308044,
0.5376237630844116,
-0.49876949191093445,
-0.16574104130268097,
-0.11418391019105911,
0.029188616201281548,
-0.147551491856575,
-1.0127816200256348,
0.10629036277532578,
0.021305322647094727,
-0.17517942190170288,
-0.09743630141019821,
0.439486563205719,
-0.39466020464897156,
-0.42212551832199097,
-0.012600643560290337,
0.7794903516769409,
0.09824177622795105,
-0.0658380389213562,
-0.7113245725631714,
0.20992831885814667,
-0.006538498681038618,
-0.22724799811840057,
0.30709150433540344,
0.6722765564918518,
-0.38713616132736206,
1.1854554414749146,
0.5091522336006165,
-0.08223861455917358,
0.002755326684564352,
-0.11931229382753372,
0.8024629950523376,
-0.9746831059455872,
-0.1700870543718338,
-0.9265183210372925,
0.46934962272644043,
-0.008242575451731682,
-0.3323018252849579,
0.6442010998725891,
0.476440966129303,
0.7364836931228638,
-0.13958843052387238,
0.6385951042175293,
0.0002344944077776745,
0.24379509687423706,
-0.5156625509262085,
0.5747869610786438,
-0.5649490356445312,
0.2561638355255127,
-0.1980339139699936,
-0.7717084288597107,
-0.4781810939311981,
0.4883696138858795,
-0.3034040033817291,
-0.05372457951307297,
0.5924564599990845,
0.9134987592697144,
0.12726753950119019,
0.22283180058002472,
0.17039580643177032,
0.39659440517425537,
0.43855705857276917,
1.1070871353149414,
1.2694746255874634,
0.022667914628982544,
0.3870986998081207,
0.1568571925163269,
-0.07183381170034409,
-0.14671196043491364,
-0.9528849720954895,
-1.193093180656433,
-0.601899266242981,
-0.3804178535938263,
0.03762258216738701,
-0.17124341428279877,
1.0491849184036255,
0.35813942551612854,
-0.660219132900238,
-0.33999571204185486,
-0.03007275052368641,
0.4209694266319275,
-0.17207157611846924,
-0.1538926362991333,
0.05986941233277321,
-0.25947868824005127,
-0.7367627620697021,
0.5833428502082825,
0.2373475283384323,
-0.27926695346832275,
-0.40764787793159485,
-0.014009754173457623,
-0.2964124381542206,
0.3564777672290802,
0.6532086730003357,
0.31573763489723206,
-0.9888581037521362,
-0.24489842355251312,
0.16746634244918823,
0.0740661770105362,
-0.1253940761089325,
0.845495879650116,
-0.6380089521408081,
0.2739547789096832,
0.6819901466369629,
0.8477607369422913,
0.44197383522987366,
-0.24767223000526428,
0.30080559849739075,
-0.3400135338306427,
0.0014884656993672252,
0.48428061604499817,
0.42766720056533813,
0.17371636629104614,
-0.2178906947374344,
0.47878608107566833,
0.2173856496810913,
-0.5828924775123596,
-0.9442415237426758,
0.4229617714881897,
-0.8896914124488831,
-0.40562334656715393,
0.9034857749938965,
0.024267658591270447,
-0.1880052387714386,
-0.023561017587780952,
-0.1090080514550209,
0.0008474822388961911,
-0.06458989530801773,
0.8025779724121094,
1.0415681600570679,
-0.4077591001987457,
-0.4385659396648407,
-0.4456061124801636,
0.3592904508113861,
0.580780565738678,
-0.8122111558914185,
-0.01120117399841547,
0.6559956669807434,
0.07729476690292358,
0.10607904195785522,
0.3682098090648651,
-0.060846153646707535,
0.2994380593299866,
-0.35857006907463074,
-0.16948096454143524,
-0.2827844023704529,
-0.4791543781757355,
-0.4405490458011627,
0.25533339381217957,
0.18891659379005432,
0.44139260053634644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11282v1 | Grammaticality illusion or ambiguous interpretation? Event-related potentials reveal the nature of the missing-NP effect in Mandarin centre-embedded structures | 2024-02-17T13:43:39 | 2024-02-17T13:43:39 | Qihang Yang, Caimei Yang, Yu Liao, Ziman Zhuang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In several languages, omitting a verb phrase (VP) in double centre-embedded
structures creates a grammaticality illusion. Similar illusion also exhibited
in Mandarin missing-NP double centre-embedded structures. However, there is no
consensus on its very nature. Instead of treating it as grammaticality
illusion, we argue that ambiguous interpretations of verbs can best account for
this phenomenon in Mandarin. To further support this hypothesis, we conducted
two electroencephalography (EEG) experiments on quasi double centre-embedded
structures whose complexity is reduced by placing the self-embedding relative
clauses into the sentence's subject position. Experiment 1 showed that similar
phenomenon even exhibited in this structure, evidenced by an absence of P600
effect and a presence of N400 effect. In Experiment 2, providing semantic cues
to reduce ambiguity dispelled this illusion, as evidenced by a P600 effect. We
interpret the results under garden-path theory and propose that word-order
difference may account for this cross-linguistic variation. | [
0.08705520629882812,
-0.9329713582992554,
0.618985116481781,
0.4221556484699249,
-0.3742321729660034,
-0.36723193526268005,
-0.04449240863323212,
-0.44552579522132874,
0.49505019187927246,
0.06731400638818741,
-0.30408716201782227,
0.03404374048113823,
-0.5596906542778015,
0.06937197595834732,
-0.27718836069107056,
0.2931655943393707,
0.1430412381887436,
0.1371208280324936,
-0.03973947837948799,
-0.08651899546384811,
-0.40085649490356445,
-0.6547273993492126,
-0.4095359444618225,
-0.40255868434906006,
0.29492998123168945,
0.08664144575595856,
1.0880318880081177,
0.47122281789779663,
0.06882484257221222,
0.2687883973121643,
-0.46837541460990906,
-0.020812861621379852,
0.10066664963960648,
-0.30039525032043457,
-0.23004189133644104,
-1.0212314128875732,
-0.4757474660873413,
-0.06519473344087601,
0.725168764591217,
0.9307038187980652,
0.04772017523646355,
-0.35819771885871887,
0.1132231280207634,
0.8674928545951843,
-0.7464038133621216,
0.15490251779556274,
-0.41392555832862854,
0.4724748432636261,
-0.04823571443557739,
-0.06536487489938736,
-0.32732781767845154,
0.21993066370487213,
0.2030368149280548,
-0.19604922831058502,
0.10769906640052795,
0.00740547850728035,
1.177039384841919,
0.045777346938848495,
-0.47562965750694275,
-0.01532792393118143,
-0.5489364266395569,
0.4366844594478607,
-0.5251801609992981,
0.2802489399909973,
0.15454354882240295,
-0.02595626935362816,
-0.37746596336364746,
-0.4173824191093445,
-0.9259724617004395,
-0.3747551143169403,
-0.45986008644104004,
0.33919811248779297,
-0.36495426297187805,
0.404177188873291,
0.14977498352527618,
0.39577850699424744,
-0.667130708694458,
-0.006358390673995018,
-0.15041770040988922,
0.05217421054840088,
0.2696252465248108,
-0.04740177094936371,
0.618659496307373,
-0.8657228350639343,
-0.34307315945625305,
0.2679682672023773,
-0.925632894039154,
0.24487654864788055,
0.4019087255001068,
0.2283797711133957,
0.037342626601457596,
0.7974351644515991,
-0.036516688764095306,
0.7345987558364868,
0.2655789852142334,
0.5116747617721558,
0.23830865323543549,
-0.2620711326599121,
-0.4215090274810791,
0.3588033616542816,
0.6901809573173523,
0.2467164248228073,
0.12977123260498047,
-0.023080023005604744,
0.03429196774959564,
0.309786319732666,
0.0577014684677124,
-0.04037729650735855,
-0.26062896847724915,
0.17813575267791748,
-0.45004338026046753,
-0.011112004518508911,
0.42469483613967896,
-0.5140764117240906,
-0.1512054055929184,
-0.10268647223711014,
0.27174416184425354,
-0.23908871412277222,
-0.7424792647361755,
0.3286946415901184,
-0.46185797452926636,
0.486873596906662,
0.09287457913160324,
-0.8005598783493042,
0.2722702920436859,
0.6492258310317993,
0.634579062461853,
0.07973702996969223,
-0.5575335025787354,
-0.12923195958137512,
0.06454690545797348,
-0.42487832903862,
0.6134440898895264,
-0.5332325100898743,
-0.2502806484699249,
-0.14374929666519165,
0.19715087115764618,
-0.39085641503334045,
-0.4942362606525421,
0.21791061758995056,
-0.19675561785697937,
0.6844780445098877,
-0.25497740507125854,
-0.4008394777774811,
-0.3517647087574005,
0.10493757575750351,
-0.5147501826286316,
1.057413101196289,
-0.024166753515601158,
-0.43268489837646484,
0.31232333183288574,
-0.22207172214984894,
-0.48340708017349243,
-0.04055652767419815,
-0.6855911612510681,
-0.23238088190555573,
0.5354601740837097,
0.04306168854236603,
0.26449471712112427,
0.22300221025943756,
0.1843174546957016,
0.07954517006874084,
-0.4832027852535248,
0.393810510635376,
-0.5725182890892029,
0.8864773511886597,
-0.27030375599861145,
-1.0213240385055542,
-0.16970127820968628,
-0.6452279686927795,
0.06350591778755188,
0.1808721423149109,
-0.10431530326604843,
-0.6576433181762695,
0.1944013237953186,
0.02374749258160591,
0.33808648586273193,
0.1658760905265808,
-0.4030931890010834,
0.15612827241420746,
-0.7643640637397766,
0.35383477807044983,
0.5355650186538696,
0.048753365874290466,
0.5802320241928101,
-0.16056306660175323,
0.4823196232318878,
0.29234933853149414,
0.10520005226135254,
0.20101040601730347,
-0.8633625507354736,
-0.7800325155258179,
0.20608767867088318,
-0.2170279622077942,
0.6570168137550354,
-0.5366434454917908,
0.43736499547958374,
-0.02526666224002838,
-0.08331575989723206,
-0.33085519075393677,
-0.3419276773929596,
0.6116033792495728,
0.17704418301582336,
0.1443493515253067,
-0.12912516295909882,
-0.44811317324638367,
-1.159948706626892,
-0.8203063607215881,
-0.43133604526519775,
0.16262763738632202,
0.24796146154403687,
0.23202919960021973,
0.17510801553726196,
0.8772627115249634,
-0.5521782040596008,
-0.13965806365013123,
-0.3442917764186859,
0.03020874783396721,
0.38884082436561584,
0.34598636627197266,
0.7463165521621704,
-1.2639487981796265,
-0.24352103471755981,
-0.13224436342716217,
-0.6239225268363953,
-0.08036425709724426,
-0.6280977725982666,
0.06818453967571259,
0.44193407893180847,
0.4077084958553314,
-0.9220496416091919,
0.7238112092018127,
0.19790346920490265,
-0.6144311428070068,
0.6214272379875183,
-0.3678804337978363,
0.19797733426094055,
-0.7131598591804504,
-0.29368752241134644,
-0.020581064745783806,
-0.06512846052646637,
-0.7743879556655884,
-0.050910159945487976,
0.3258289396762848,
0.3413484990596771,
-0.467919260263443,
0.19006620347499847,
-0.851500928401947,
-0.3090803623199463,
-0.3832957148551941,
0.5488276481628418,
0.26425713300704956,
0.5439612865447998,
0.12570525705814362,
0.46938368678092957,
0.4448135495185852,
-0.6089861989021301,
0.0465787872672081,
-0.045389674603939056,
-0.20432651042938232,
0.43335360288619995,
-0.49529728293418884,
-0.14924263954162598,
-0.5124654173851013,
-0.1653260886669159,
-1.0731303691864014,
0.07367008924484253,
0.6264013648033142,
-0.5960625410079956,
0.3390137851238251,
-0.12430300563573837,
-0.20643015205860138,
-0.19643977284431458,
-0.0633111447095871,
0.3620870113372803,
0.37011075019836426,
-0.46431735157966614,
0.5041021108627319,
0.09227342903614044,
0.3290437161922455,
-0.6131076812744141,
-1.0517690181732178,
0.2681184411048889,
-0.2523495554924011,
-0.4507831633090973,
0.4401839077472687,
0.2826574444770813,
-0.645171046257019,
0.25688421726226807,
-0.23945721983909607,
-0.11245326697826385,
0.17108316719532013,
0.36127597093582153,
0.1194135919213295,
-0.4215354323387146,
0.3236532509326935,
0.09164278954267502,
0.3580942749977112,
0.42174917459487915,
-0.22188572585582733,
0.35211145877838135,
-0.21613579988479614,
-0.3382883369922638,
-0.6368733644485474,
0.3768417239189148,
0.5828569531440735,
-0.006187306251376867,
0.7613527774810791,
0.04317202419042587,
-0.5513738393783569,
0.08951069414615631,
-0.19821858406066895,
0.2861795723438263,
-0.5149093866348267,
0.5116171836853027,
-0.6545329093933105,
-0.49996107816696167,
0.38929668068885803,
0.33590707182884216,
-0.40541404485702515,
0.7601401805877686,
0.1678645759820938,
-0.22788183391094208,
0.8228558301925659,
0.2608918845653534,
0.1441536396741867,
0.8060540556907654,
-0.0966300442814827,
0.33250483870506287,
-0.9852093458175659,
-0.391802042722702,
-0.31794533133506775,
-0.02775971032679081,
-0.5968456268310547,
-0.15186861157417297,
0.31028372049331665,
0.3828389048576355,
-0.05410413071513176,
0.2528446614742279,
-0.4155574142932892,
0.4861030876636505,
0.32447755336761475,
0.29132208228111267,
0.10178124159574509,
-0.21776366233825684,
-0.09642499685287476,
-0.2215857058763504,
-0.9551644325256348,
-0.35292309522628784,
0.5349439978599548,
-0.15464931726455688,
0.09740632027387619,
0.3983866572380066,
0.40503886342048645,
0.12248039990663528,
-0.3064943253993988,
-0.7236282229423523,
0.5654312372207642,
-0.12030591070652008,
-0.4471673369407654,
-0.22923330962657928,
-0.2647532820701599,
-1.2317156791687012,
0.7930537462234497,
-0.2748103439807892,
-0.909469485282898,
0.30323463678359985,
0.2826724946498871,
-0.263455331325531,
0.2275288701057434,
-0.86793452501297,
0.8889155983924866,
-0.42937323451042175,
-0.3645801544189453,
-0.24236297607421875,
-0.5434773564338684,
0.35396644473075867,
0.45813289284706116,
0.255659282207489,
0.07287845015525818,
0.09998492896556854,
0.3774784505367279,
-0.4294816553592682,
0.7614155411720276,
-0.26688554883003235,
0.16585826873779297,
0.37224406003952026,
0.05490841716527939,
0.44248685240745544,
-0.05386337265372276,
0.22925280034542084,
0.056280724704265594,
-0.3708609342575073,
-0.5823833346366882,
-0.9017492532730103,
0.545908510684967,
-0.6597979068756104,
-1.1316583156585693,
-0.6145517230033875,
-0.170505553483963,
0.10626502335071564,
0.3392012417316437,
0.4096001088619232,
0.41903674602508545,
-0.17034785449504852,
-0.34318676590919495,
0.42419180274009705,
-0.3560580909252167,
0.6064755916595459,
0.20164836943149567,
-0.12279292196035385,
-0.06332611292600632,
0.32123512029647827,
0.2997492253780365,
0.5486016869544983,
0.590380072593689,
0.35755279660224915,
-0.08512936532497406,
-0.2971602976322174,
-0.42234665155410767,
0.424652636051178,
-0.5232505202293396,
0.5874312520027161,
-0.5096242427825928,
-0.08361498266458511,
-0.6196950674057007,
-0.08241076022386551,
-0.3425886332988739,
-0.7720333933830261,
-0.5758459568023682,
-0.22243301570415497,
0.052319690585136414,
0.8111308217048645,
-0.07459502667188644,
0.3272126019001007,
-0.7447065114974976,
0.31113776564598083,
-0.08305788040161133,
0.04644521325826645,
0.11565890163183212,
-0.5515297651290894,
-0.07535813003778458,
0.22034570574760437,
0.13020206987857819,
-1.0724488496780396,
0.21906298398971558,
0.3195875883102417,
0.7134671807289124,
0.5709378123283386,
-0.23065289855003357,
0.9188733696937561,
-0.6577078104019165,
1.0691617727279663,
0.33419468998908997,
-1.0321993827819824,
0.6058469414710999,
-0.23982837796211243,
0.5717974901199341,
0.03822155296802521,
0.0019891553092747927,
-0.7275323271751404,
-0.500645101070404,
-0.8226760029792786,
-0.9969377517700195,
0.501867949962616,
0.39684391021728516,
0.0809207335114479,
-0.19357843697071075,
0.7422139644622803,
-0.09864641726016998,
0.023982146754860878,
-1.193163275718689,
-0.700556218624115,
-0.29356148838996887,
0.17424190044403076,
0.10585630685091019,
-0.391422301530838,
0.24726040661334991,
-0.19865116477012634,
0.3054810166358948,
0.34677115082740784,
0.4598541855812073,
0.7470961213111877,
-0.1307423710823059,
-0.046429719775915146,
0.21639885008335114,
0.5746189951896667,
0.6703538298606873,
-0.01593315787613392,
0.45135191082954407,
-0.14149819314479828,
-0.3970750868320465,
0.026524009183049202,
-0.3041510283946991,
-0.1051502525806427,
0.30487579107284546,
0.5640033483505249,
0.5877353549003601,
0.3780766725540161,
-0.22949612140655518,
0.682215690612793,
0.09887435287237167,
0.13845878839492798,
-0.6835915446281433,
0.1459231823682785,
-0.1203400045633316,
0.3319135904312134,
0.3605058789253235,
0.25139856338500977,
0.10118438303470612,
-0.8590653538703918,
0.07054134458303452,
0.4355180263519287,
-0.4629281163215637,
-0.5145218372344971,
0.6460715532302856,
-0.3175744116306305,
-0.5461146831512451,
0.5822259187698364,
-0.12956807017326355,
-0.9083458781242371,
0.9174413084983826,
0.38215556740760803,
0.9292629361152649,
-0.2578916847705841,
0.028153054416179657,
0.185506671667099,
0.7862529158592224,
-0.1484690010547638,
0.6221418976783752,
0.101599782705307,
-0.792087733745575,
-0.1824108213186264,
0.015073106624186039,
-0.03507112339138985,
-0.17921660840511322,
-0.9054914116859436,
-0.02856861799955368,
-0.09712257236242294,
0.06592757254838943,
-0.008798938244581223,
-0.5963543653488159,
-0.20900218188762665,
0.22222696244716644,
0.13752897083759308,
0.5029992461204529,
-1.1115974187850952,
0.8563917875289917,
0.8134750127792358,
-0.3031867742538452,
-0.7403943538665771,
0.23379677534103394,
-0.019244959577918053,
-0.4993627667427063,
0.38561445474624634,
0.18397703766822815,
-0.3209412395954132,
-0.46175089478492737,
-0.22421543300151825,
-0.9707695245742798,
0.7364108562469482,
0.06495056301355362,
-0.36879298090934753,
-0.155160591006279,
0.5388437509536743,
0.6945950388908386,
-0.026585653424263,
-0.045805394649505615,
0.4151379466056824,
0.38172128796577454,
-0.1696641594171524,
-0.9008356332778931,
0.09308656305074692,
-0.14473949372768402,
0.03540388494729996,
0.42853811383247375,
-0.7823451161384583,
1.0444321632385254,
-0.0021140938624739647,
-0.4867292046546936,
-0.09036214649677277,
0.6578850746154785,
-0.1239018440246582,
0.1776062697172165,
0.4764113128185272,
0.2567387521266937,
0.6272284984588623,
0.009900310076773167,
0.995315432548523,
-0.09485195577144623,
0.27828970551490784,
1.1537902355194092,
0.04215281829237938,
0.7240633964538574,
0.7666645050048828,
-0.3665834665298462,
0.5327448844909668,
0.4988751709461212,
0.32497549057006836,
0.5916706919670105,
0.2150162160396576,
0.021086128428578377,
-0.10274684429168701,
0.26824310421943665,
-0.2104814052581787,
0.7007544040679932,
0.5909403562545776,
-0.42096617817878723,
0.02324766479432583,
-0.06215692684054375,
0.07766730338335037,
0.2632191777229309,
-0.5146944522857666,
0.14770802855491638,
0.38905492424964905,
-0.6968371272087097,
0.4618813693523407,
-0.03131106495857239,
0.3638375401496887,
-0.32156628370285034,
-0.21676242351531982,
-0.25545212626457214,
0.13680361211299896,
-0.3938731849193573,
-0.6314631104469299,
0.5265467166900635,
-0.36903151869773865,
-0.0647035539150238,
-0.19362320005893707,
0.5530922412872314,
-0.33191022276878357,
-0.17114898562431335,
0.4155724346637726,
0.5569567084312439,
0.24612925946712494,
-0.21613261103630066,
-0.5625033974647522,
-0.5527667999267578,
0.008063627406954765,
-0.4204581081867218,
0.03696615621447563,
0.6572214365005493,
-0.03186199814081192,
0.11284299194812775,
-0.03546764329075813,
0.32391056418418884,
0.39587196707725525,
-0.19650547206401825,
0.46727892756462097,
-0.925133228302002,
-0.6950831413269043,
-1.0961939096450806,
0.3049771189689636,
0.013690727762877941,
-0.47158780694007874,
1.019283652305603,
0.4767409861087799,
0.831281840801239,
0.09032425284385681,
0.41996902227401733,
-0.16402064263820648,
-0.22982285916805267,
-0.6035566329956055,
0.624493420124054,
-0.6793307662010193,
0.2635025680065155,
-0.5512875914573669,
-0.8356896638870239,
-0.551116943359375,
0.7319316267967224,
-0.40320947766304016,
-0.1426192820072174,
1.0602272748947144,
0.7617071866989136,
0.09955187886953354,
0.18253369629383087,
0.47746971249580383,
0.604763925075531,
-0.14702628552913666,
0.6413227915763855,
0.9996694326400757,
-0.48360177874565125,
0.16030655801296234,
-0.17847558856010437,
-0.3271529972553253,
-0.038631659001111984,
-0.5596311688423157,
-0.7406362891197205,
-0.6159718632698059,
-0.29616138339042664,
-0.28813886642456055,
0.10499631613492966,
0.7607489228248596,
0.11740231513977051,
-0.4480341076850891,
-0.28285637497901917,
-0.5045400857925415,
0.3271607756614685,
-0.5536972284317017,
-0.29018545150756836,
0.8449350595474243,
0.1446792483329773,
-0.7276142835617065,
0.5293053388595581,
0.4413661062717438,
0.30414509773254395,
-0.08550214767456055,
0.4950023293495178,
-0.5628538131713867,
-0.07575090229511261,
0.5031962394714355,
0.28496047854423523,
-0.8959131836891174,
-0.5921350717544556,
0.0386229082942009,
-0.13099879026412964,
0.5058543682098389,
0.5648227334022522,
-0.7612707018852234,
0.39410242438316345,
0.3176334798336029,
0.09060362726449966,
0.25375622510910034,
-0.15255707502365112,
0.5851425528526306,
-0.6329180598258972,
0.3808296322822571,
0.02669866569340229,
0.6586453914642334,
0.0011515863006934524,
-0.8650778532028198,
0.2364933341741562,
0.5272688865661621,
-0.10342816263437271,
-0.6038082838058472,
0.46134430170059204,
-0.8986571431159973,
-0.689214289188385,
1.3410687446594238,
-0.07701190561056137,
-0.48334744572639465,
-0.17909064888954163,
-0.11447800695896149,
0.292982816696167,
0.15735970437526703,
0.987470269203186,
0.7935099005699158,
-0.5618242025375366,
-0.1396111398935318,
-0.28671228885650635,
0.2574089467525482,
0.9449095726013184,
-0.48194628953933716,
-0.13905663788318634,
0.679782509803772,
-0.03550088405609131,
0.108915776014328,
0.3562168776988983,
0.07953252643346786,
0.5274328589439392,
0.20029044151306152,
0.009332340210676193,
0.2320224940776825,
-0.28294187784194946,
-0.6587896347045898,
0.33682680130004883,
0.1570921242237091,
-0.432640016078949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11281v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11281v3 | Can Large Multimodal Models Uncover Deep Semantics Behind Images? | 2024-02-17T13:41:44 | 2024-06-20T13:12:31 | Yixin Yang, Zheng Li, Qingxiu Dong, Heming Xia, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding the deep semantics of images is essential in the era dominated
by social media. However, current research works primarily on the superficial
description of images, revealing a notable deficiency in the systematic
investigation of the inherent deep semantics. In this work, we introduce
DEEPEVAL, a comprehensive benchmark to assess Large Multimodal Models' (LMMs)
capacities of visual deep semantics. DEEPEVAL includes human-annotated dataset
and three progressive subtasks: fine-grained description selection, in-depth
title matching, and deep semantics understanding. Utilizing DEEPEVAL, we
evaluate 9 open-source LMMs and GPT-4V(ision). Our evaluation demonstrates a
substantial gap between the deep semantic comprehension capabilities of
existing LMMs and humans. For example, GPT-4V is 30% behind humans in
understanding deep semantics, even though it achieves human-comparable
performance in image description. Further analysis reveals that LMM performance
on DEEPEVAL varies according to the specific facets of deep semantics explored,
indicating the fundamental challenges remaining in developing LMMs. | [
-0.4994069039821625,
-0.5616722106933594,
0.717867374420166,
0.05204949900507927,
-0.25791624188423157,
0.05285479873418808,
-0.4202709496021271,
-0.6028825640678406,
-0.4833777844905853,
0.37700116634368896,
-0.7960071563720703,
-0.7253338098526001,
-0.693175733089447,
-0.08515360206365585,
-0.14103972911834717,
0.726962685585022,
-0.18646427989006042,
-0.03470255061984062,
-0.38774698972702026,
-0.2797167897224426,
-0.5088733434677124,
0.004124985542148352,
-0.09070269018411636,
-0.1280633509159088,
0.6064181923866272,
0.19895020127296448,
0.837741494178772,
0.4551633596420288,
1.0998561382293701,
0.30271732807159424,
0.06341294199228287,
0.11353884637355804,
-0.4467151165008545,
0.026568779721856117,
-0.32053372263908386,
-0.014695784077048302,
-0.3402290940284729,
-0.013101871125400066,
0.7540591955184937,
0.5663143992424011,
0.20150181651115417,
0.18496744334697723,
-0.12627986073493958,
0.85257887840271,
-0.9518395066261292,
0.34165671467781067,
-0.7165810465812683,
0.15863266587257385,
-0.3272865414619446,
0.03436997905373573,
-0.12767979502677917,
0.06496057659387589,
0.38444453477859497,
-0.4895904064178467,
0.21504761278629303,
-0.35063204169273376,
1.064404845237732,
0.5190858244895935,
-0.6086413264274597,
-0.03048105724155903,
-0.4708477556705475,
0.7386701107025146,
-0.6602296829223633,
0.6075695157051086,
0.27915966510772705,
0.658814549446106,
0.14224891364574432,
-0.9097302556037903,
-0.5990041494369507,
-0.408567875623703,
-0.03834906220436096,
0.12323768436908722,
-0.18730711936950684,
0.18225540220737457,
0.34650519490242004,
0.625029444694519,
-0.35712191462516785,
0.08292685449123383,
-0.33329254388809204,
-0.24418748915195465,
0.4367726445198059,
0.27990639209747314,
0.3181518614292145,
-0.3339138329029083,
-0.6113753914833069,
-0.13142874836921692,
-0.5759000778198242,
-0.02366666868329048,
-0.16050145030021667,
0.00018083621398545802,
-0.21619032323360443,
0.6861487030982971,
-0.4267933964729309,
0.24522380530834198,
-0.4796610176563263,
0.0840371772646904,
0.4806102216243744,
-0.7917242646217346,
-0.32829445600509644,
-0.36368879675865173,
0.6361158490180969,
0.8180223107337952,
0.4444350600242615,
-0.18559040129184723,
-0.16203342378139496,
0.31174755096435547,
0.14598888158798218,
-1.174282193183899,
-0.13140875101089478,
-0.08122143894433975,
-0.6477463841438293,
-0.05690256878733635,
-0.051698241382837296,
-0.6607446670532227,
-0.7203009724617004,
-0.36722227931022644,
0.5194143652915955,
-0.4207048714160919,
-0.4459231197834015,
0.06886649876832962,
-0.10057651251554489,
0.5972394943237305,
0.2987740933895111,
-0.37430018186569214,
0.1279967576265335,
0.7489285469055176,
0.8593558669090271,
0.1709195077419281,
-0.5311423540115356,
-0.26744210720062256,
-0.002912747673690319,
-0.5412847399711609,
0.6178019642829895,
-0.5515868663787842,
-0.05550320819020271,
-0.04026717320084572,
0.24585559964179993,
0.15565349161624908,
-0.28068238496780396,
0.6958032250404358,
-0.6014595031738281,
-0.27736127376556396,
-0.3506549000740051,
-0.5267015099525452,
-0.16102242469787598,
0.3794562816619873,
-0.6600468158721924,
0.4721040427684784,
-0.19000045955181122,
-0.8167198896408081,
0.6851083040237427,
-0.5299474596977234,
-0.28559166193008423,
0.15061642229557037,
-0.3258717954158783,
-0.117154560983181,
0.2584283947944641,
0.3730540871620178,
0.7449555993080139,
-0.35000404715538025,
0.20715069770812988,
-0.6160014271736145,
-0.3701876103878021,
0.5097644925117493,
-0.541804850101471,
0.21761871874332428,
0.22404612600803375,
-0.3679521977901459,
0.1518121361732483,
-0.521446168422699,
-0.027399824932217598,
-0.024034397676587105,
0.0014436300843954086,
-0.210011288523674,
0.05182880163192749,
0.08995160460472107,
0.3519517481327057,
0.11847715824842453,
-0.5684865117073059,
0.010233121924102306,
-0.011830992996692657,
0.6115623116493225,
0.8178792595863342,
-0.42025789618492126,
0.4100419282913208,
0.23037271201610565,
0.23266024887561798,
0.06267488747835159,
0.07372186332941055,
-0.532504141330719,
-0.21108794212341309,
-0.5415979027748108,
-0.46962079405784607,
0.23635078966617584,
0.13120140135288239,
-0.7719306945800781,
-0.01904437690973282,
-0.562602162361145,
-0.4536222815513611,
-0.7634021043777466,
0.225605770945549,
0.5711323618888855,
0.38434651494026184,
0.5134101510047913,
-0.2876149117946625,
-0.09174889326095581,
-1.49384343624115,
-0.155962735414505,
0.24841342866420746,
-0.07442215085029602,
0.4934203624725342,
0.8096475005149841,
-0.6721916794776917,
0.46008098125457764,
-0.18860019743442535,
-0.5603213906288147,
0.19084841012954712,
0.2391931563615799,
0.03898422047495842,
0.10226953029632568,
0.35302627086639404,
-0.6751312613487244,
-0.20043005049228668,
0.17778584361076355,
-0.869045615196228,
0.2647286057472229,
0.08880572766065598,
0.0023580242414027452,
0.07495588064193726,
0.44537997245788574,
-0.7604445815086365,
0.5681731104850769,
0.41153401136398315,
-0.3548884689807892,
0.2965366542339325,
-0.349165678024292,
0.40728560090065,
-0.6453987956047058,
-0.020650502294301987,
0.06637889891862869,
-0.04432651773095131,
-0.08409115672111511,
0.3747251629829407,
0.4195779263973236,
-0.03170132264494896,
-0.4275393486022949,
0.3396816849708557,
-0.7236132621765137,
-0.42781949043273926,
-0.22202026844024658,
0.12333787232637405,
0.04851622134447098,
0.18638156354427338,
0.15053780376911163,
0.5779857039451599,
0.8769801259040833,
-0.1629321277141571,
0.44941991567611694,
-0.05073576420545578,
-0.6237232089042664,
0.6216395497322083,
-0.7824861407279968,
0.09677272289991379,
-0.3406926393508911,
0.5641421675682068,
-1.231369972229004,
-0.6257333755493164,
-0.16991853713989258,
-0.3324609696865082,
0.1841961145401001,
-0.3092639744281769,
-0.533067524433136,
-0.36569443345069885,
-0.35329005122184753,
0.629368007183075,
0.4168934226036072,
-0.4410451650619507,
0.6722792983055115,
0.19109061360359192,
0.1690775454044342,
-0.6739226579666138,
-0.735833466053009,
0.45574742555618286,
-0.07543154060840607,
-0.9464126825332642,
0.3893771767616272,
0.18862640857696533,
-0.22862982749938965,
0.12753085792064667,
0.13407935202121735,
-0.0453474186360836,
-0.12988778948783875,
0.4245975911617279,
0.1464444100856781,
-0.43824756145477295,
0.41939300298690796,
-0.2899109423160553,
-0.10936616361141205,
0.02598004788160324,
-0.0748283863067627,
0.20994164049625397,
-0.6919430494308472,
-0.39576980471611023,
-0.6114396452903748,
0.18124662339687347,
0.7606794238090515,
-0.48512759804725647,
0.3886004388332367,
0.9845271110534668,
-0.29664966464042664,
0.16437338292598724,
-0.7244647145271301,
0.011342627927660942,
-0.4102376401424408,
0.5264126062393188,
-0.6229568719863892,
-0.7519898414611816,
0.3616682291030884,
0.08564453572034836,
-0.23197312653064728,
0.613213062286377,
0.5763564705848694,
-0.09900747984647751,
0.9398806095123291,
0.3416440486907959,
0.2794252038002014,
-0.043449144810438156,
-0.34342336654663086,
-0.32889971137046814,
-0.8348310589790344,
-0.39667314291000366,
0.010908813215792179,
-0.5357053279876709,
-0.7497988939285278,
-0.654008686542511,
0.10311703383922577,
-0.2885814607143402,
-0.27681177854537964,
0.1054098829627037,
-0.3680509328842163,
0.6696649193763733,
0.36425700783729553,
0.14558765292167664,
0.22861279547214508,
-0.0715341866016388,
0.09147141128778458,
-0.22706173360347748,
-0.06684362888336182,
-0.44740623235702515,
0.981431782245636,
0.6634225249290466,
0.9177767634391785,
0.1685629040002823,
0.17164695262908936,
0.21037448942661285,
0.12655246257781982,
-0.7089525461196899,
0.5284753441810608,
-0.43764495849609375,
-0.7493316531181335,
-0.023115431889891624,
-0.3461979627609253,
-0.9090357422828674,
0.4176689386367798,
-0.20780785381793976,
-0.42707425355911255,
0.05990424007177353,
0.09681392461061478,
-0.37377023696899414,
0.13270044326782227,
-0.6820161938667297,
1.207977056503296,
-0.46781760454177856,
-0.5332165360450745,
-0.5209537744522095,
-0.839560866355896,
0.47183188796043396,
0.21180275082588196,
0.3077342212200165,
-0.5643051862716675,
-0.33570799231529236,
0.4454089403152466,
-0.08967741578817368,
0.7712606191635132,
-0.24939662218093872,
0.03802536055445671,
-0.02287173457443714,
0.04392402619123459,
0.04242254048585892,
0.05954679474234581,
0.3391092121601105,
0.36019736528396606,
0.05326108634471893,
-0.5975266098976135,
-0.3866433799266815,
1.0004076957702637,
-0.7580864429473877,
-0.13116714358329773,
-0.12418008595705032,
-0.43175172805786133,
-0.22814726829528809,
0.06067440286278725,
0.2371378093957901,
0.612518846988678,
-0.19783541560173035,
0.6410532593727112,
0.45148563385009766,
-0.3670053780078888,
0.44804465770721436,
0.12150996923446655,
-0.09615791589021683,
-0.32806259393692017,
0.7162056565284729,
-0.06678889691829681,
0.16724427044391632,
0.36038273572921753,
0.23436200618743896,
-0.5399669408798218,
-0.6315917372703552,
-0.6420897841453552,
-0.022775378078222275,
-0.9657737612724304,
-0.13505882024765015,
-0.5645647048950195,
0.014489307068288326,
-0.24325785040855408,
0.07478398829698563,
-0.42960166931152344,
-0.15791942179203033,
0.054029423743486404,
-0.06240227445960045,
0.19152434170246124,
0.7311301827430725,
0.052069079130887985,
0.0022397241555154324,
-0.7139289379119873,
0.5547058582305908,
0.5393409729003906,
0.6274817585945129,
0.08419492840766907,
-0.3869158923625946,
0.07935009151697159,
0.1460983008146286,
-0.12750527262687683,
-0.5392864942550659,
0.002256578067317605,
0.39777377247810364,
0.4161994457244873,
0.49128350615501404,
-0.24250687658786774,
0.9773398041725159,
-0.5671209692955017,
0.7337876558303833,
0.18871428072452545,
-0.7329878211021423,
0.50182044506073,
-0.40200793743133545,
0.4329887628555298,
0.6828798055648804,
0.2924255132675171,
-0.38625067472457886,
0.10032867640256882,
-0.41741350293159485,
-0.9368088245391846,
0.1360020488500595,
0.27770036458969116,
0.5616286993026733,
-0.008772021159529686,
0.08537124842405319,
0.08109766989946365,
0.07333192974328995,
-0.6283097267150879,
0.39780524373054504,
-0.39511191844940186,
-0.06466089934110641,
-0.16272714734077454,
-0.16849038004875183,
-0.03308286517858505,
-0.29020023345947266,
0.09122681617736816,
-0.09337051957845688,
0.07645031809806824,
0.1621660441160202,
-0.3815302848815918,
0.1082259863615036,
0.2513465881347656,
0.4879300594329834,
0.7959047555923462,
-0.23979267477989197,
0.6008812785148621,
0.043742042034864426,
-0.17168019711971283,
-0.24204778671264648,
0.2766892611980438,
0.400837242603302,
-0.272080659866333,
0.9300472140312195,
0.9652009010314941,
0.2609858810901642,
-0.7921428084373474,
0.8793889284133911,
-0.25094956159591675,
-0.050026100128889084,
-0.2799479067325592,
-0.28044459223747253,
0.27029502391815186,
0.3791268467903137,
0.37611907720565796,
0.016504298895597458,
0.37941408157348633,
-0.7445666193962097,
0.19892890751361847,
0.7399769425392151,
-0.611320972442627,
-0.36753520369529724,
0.5068911910057068,
0.17096485197544098,
0.24303856492042542,
0.7190832495689392,
0.06107074022293091,
-0.24965335428714752,
0.5213231444358826,
-0.0860029086470604,
0.711948573589325,
0.30779382586479187,
0.055591750890016556,
0.13818694651126862,
0.3165281414985657,
0.21501260995864868,
0.07482253760099411,
-0.2698773443698883,
-0.5872913599014282,
-0.7722134590148926,
-0.5500055551528931,
-0.04035989195108414,
0.19888713955879211,
-0.39683443307876587,
-0.020863378420472145,
-0.18277868628501892,
-0.11376967281103134,
0.5745523571968079,
-0.33880189061164856,
-1.1569106578826904,
0.1859992891550064,
0.4390990734100342,
0.7931151390075684,
-0.4988137185573578,
0.5462613701820374,
0.5765909552574158,
-0.6086503267288208,
-0.5709980130195618,
-0.11709138751029968,
-0.03918140381574631,
-0.890450119972229,
1.065030813217163,
0.6004238128662109,
-0.1981814205646515,
-0.24026000499725342,
-0.6932390928268433,
-0.48459625244140625,
1.140690803527832,
0.2403494417667389,
-0.43872711062431335,
0.04183288663625717,
0.16718122363090515,
0.6247918009757996,
-0.27115705609321594,
0.4401282072067261,
0.2641621232032776,
0.6038904786109924,
0.35858556628227234,
-0.8896936774253845,
0.053842779248952866,
-0.2049485743045807,
0.14976245164871216,
0.011602979153394699,
-0.306317001581192,
0.8381578922271729,
-0.4885600507259369,
-0.29667311906814575,
0.20866695046424866,
0.46250417828559875,
-0.14074832201004028,
0.39313966035842896,
0.4225113093852997,
0.6185517907142639,
0.41746893525123596,
-0.10922037065029144,
1.316840410232544,
0.1794518083333969,
0.3165303170681,
0.9669617414474487,
-0.3596234917640686,
0.8679739832878113,
0.2444268763065338,
-0.11162590980529785,
0.35297858715057373,
0.685657799243927,
-0.02395627833902836,
0.5189656615257263,
0.1438172310590744,
-0.09901846945285797,
-0.6501888632774353,
-0.1459074318408966,
-0.6424983143806458,
0.5735751390457153,
0.358635276556015,
-0.5404184460639954,
-0.5280534029006958,
0.15394413471221924,
-0.3037957549095154,
-0.0485580675303936,
-0.4762369990348816,
0.8154672980308533,
0.09619595855474472,
-0.436917781829834,
0.5492739677429199,
-0.31159844994544983,
0.6101024746894836,
-0.25595057010650635,
-0.06141266971826553,
-0.131307914853096,
0.6615114212036133,
-0.13188011944293976,
-1.3263715505599976,
0.10670936852693558,
-0.19013874232769012,
0.045818425714969635,
0.02717158943414688,
1.0289738178253174,
-0.21776123344898224,
-0.46123459935188293,
0.3905033767223358,
0.39726540446281433,
0.12641024589538574,
-0.37525448203086853,
-0.6389381885528564,
0.0739801749587059,
-0.5832915306091309,
-0.03607434034347534,
0.2032005488872528,
0.6272250413894653,
-0.11313849687576294,
0.6455975770950317,
0.48555657267570496,
-0.3017806112766266,
0.08735553175210953,
0.24020059406757355,
0.8155941367149353,
-0.6491634845733643,
0.019247649237513542,
-1.1955496072769165,
0.584472119808197,
-0.31931939721107483,
-0.2909495234489441,
0.67444908618927,
0.30812180042266846,
0.7566536664962769,
-0.2568553686141968,
0.6470032930374146,
0.07342003285884857,
0.0015375702641904354,
-0.5570066571235657,
0.5028836131095886,
-0.8007603883743286,
-0.11874492466449738,
-0.5578694939613342,
-0.8270875215530396,
-0.2804918885231018,
0.4883759319782257,
-0.4256002604961395,
-0.02084430679678917,
0.5080398917198181,
0.7342829704284668,
-0.4246646761894226,
-0.10035154968500137,
0.4434989392757416,
0.210017591714859,
0.047327421605587006,
0.6140947937965393,
1.5753958225250244,
-0.14401152729988098,
0.5540515780448914,
-0.30323776602745056,
-0.2803484797477722,
-0.03925291448831558,
-1.1113746166229248,
-0.9160121083259583,
-0.5487502813339233,
-0.183600515127182,
-0.20792604982852936,
0.144400954246521,
0.5204470753669739,
0.8779745101928711,
-0.5075139999389648,
0.13895170390605927,
-0.04338129609823227,
-0.10683267563581467,
0.039625223726034164,
-0.1520843803882599,
0.4619750678539276,
-0.1815062165260315,
-0.3856375217437744,
0.1969500035047531,
0.35544246435165405,
-0.20296010375022888,
-0.45900362730026245,
-0.09916187822818756,
0.07846982032060623,
-0.11103257536888123,
0.8798251152038574,
-0.17625869810581207,
-0.9706581234931946,
-0.36412495374679565,
0.07787194848060608,
-0.08505178242921829,
-0.020029332488775253,
0.8261094689369202,
-0.6055305600166321,
0.513606607913971,
0.573307991027832,
0.8401984572410583,
0.6269030570983887,
-0.14330054819583893,
0.09634017199277878,
-0.7089290022850037,
0.012872811406850815,
0.08832702785730362,
0.5106379389762878,
0.6611372828483582,
0.13387154042720795,
0.5607605576515198,
0.1529376059770584,
-0.5735194087028503,
-0.6244020462036133,
0.41628775000572205,
-1.0970786809921265,
-0.5248016715049744,
1.2566200494766235,
-0.08197591453790665,
-0.1377161145210266,
0.27102628350257874,
-0.21546117961406708,
-0.116452656686306,
-0.20958201587200165,
0.44514450430870056,
0.6023858785629272,
0.12736764550209045,
-0.5144780874252319,
-0.819782555103302,
0.3323982059955597,
0.010630450211465359,
-0.5820006132125854,
0.22490978240966797,
0.897321343421936,
0.2284492403268814,
0.19008322060108185,
0.5505144000053406,
-0.20678485929965973,
0.42740359902381897,
-0.14921149611473083,
0.041716743260622025,
-0.09624184668064117,
-0.2227923423051834,
-0.06936632841825485,
0.15056872367858887,
-0.0482206828892231,
-0.3272732198238373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11279v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11279v1 | Multi-Perspective Consistency Enhances Confidence Estimation in Large Language Models | 2024-02-17T13:37:39 | 2024-02-17T13:37:39 | Pei Wang, Yejie Wang, Muxi Diao, Keqing He, Guanting Dong, Weiran Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the deployment of large language models (LLMs), accurate confidence
estimation is critical for assessing the credibility of model predictions.
However, existing methods often fail to overcome the issue of overconfidence on
incorrect answers. In this work, we focus on improving the confidence
estimation of large language models. Considering the fragility of
self-awareness in language models, we introduce a Multi-Perspective Consistency
(MPC) method. We leverage complementary insights from different perspectives
within models (MPC-Internal) and across different models (MPC-Across) to
mitigate the issue of overconfidence arising from a singular viewpoint. The
experimental results on eight publicly available datasets show that our MPC
achieves state-of-the-art performance. Further analyses indicate that MPC can
mitigate the problem of overconfidence and is effectively scalable to other
models. | [
-0.23245373368263245,
-0.3620423674583435,
1.0197231769561768,
0.5223467946052551,
0.1884082555770874,
0.1427631825208664,
-0.3597828447818756,
-0.33570775389671326,
0.028712615370750427,
0.08378089964389801,
-0.2268105149269104,
-0.6468472480773926,
-0.8628281354904175,
-0.030499732121825218,
-0.10330493748188019,
0.645515501499176,
-0.10346846282482147,
0.10683675110340118,
-0.49075064063072205,
-0.20637887716293335,
-0.128578320145607,
-0.6846475005149841,
-0.444561630487442,
-0.31084954738616943,
0.7152431607246399,
0.30010098218917847,
0.6436529755592346,
0.3699347674846649,
0.2790832817554474,
0.30225831270217896,
-0.0851396769285202,
0.5239672660827637,
-0.2891155779361725,
0.16442106664180756,
-0.2367713749408722,
-0.3483852744102478,
-0.47517722845077515,
0.14136292040348053,
1.140509843826294,
0.607698917388916,
-0.44313204288482666,
-0.17854762077331543,
0.4794199764728546,
0.6509037017822266,
-1.3841692209243774,
0.4753667116165161,
-0.5690668821334839,
-0.19333268702030182,
0.10132835805416107,
0.17500396072864532,
-0.7260434031486511,
-0.3062308728694916,
0.16122837364673615,
-0.33098873496055603,
-0.23184208571910858,
-0.3007541596889496,
0.4648171067237854,
0.2361236959695816,
-0.5919945240020752,
0.2948143184185028,
-0.8615615963935852,
1.046507716178894,
-0.8718995451927185,
0.7498400807380676,
0.4333980083465576,
0.08168304711580276,
-0.3506762683391571,
-0.0738631933927536,
-0.6664807200431824,
-0.16389745473861694,
0.07401179522275925,
0.33100882172584534,
0.20686593651771545,
0.055761922150850296,
-0.0044624353758990765,
0.020115578547120094,
-0.2326560765504837,
0.02919292449951172,
0.20378759503364563,
-0.3291535973548889,
0.4983430504798889,
-0.13987240195274353,
-0.2587242126464844,
-0.03391485661268234,
-0.27470508217811584,
0.03838800638914108,
-0.5821470022201538,
0.1688830703496933,
0.27890095114707947,
0.1853724718093872,
-0.016612965613603592,
0.45188942551612854,
-0.24894534051418304,
0.559816300868988,
-0.012762630358338356,
-0.7525736689567566,
0.41104862093925476,
-0.28637126088142395,
-0.16298499703407288,
-0.011540872044861317,
0.501175045967102,
0.36444830894470215,
0.21204541623592377,
0.16054882109165192,
0.07945267111063004,
-0.05211809277534485,
0.28911322355270386,
-0.5030210018157959,
-0.17234262824058533,
0.4857030212879181,
-0.13978666067123413,
-0.07605674117803574,
0.19769370555877686,
-0.5984846353530884,
-0.6956545114517212,
-0.24189099669456482,
0.4462456703186035,
-0.3177683651447296,
-0.6153550744056702,
-0.04319106042385101,
0.2604893445968628,
0.18768310546875,
0.5934092998504639,
-0.601260781288147,
-0.008912855759263039,
0.8842126727104187,
0.9748619794845581,
-0.17405028641223907,
-0.6844452619552612,
-0.31930211186408997,
0.4796571135520935,
-0.5292447209358215,
0.6080388426780701,
-0.35091882944107056,
-0.18064415454864502,
-0.06182149425148964,
-0.053971681743860245,
-0.3583156168460846,
-0.22239916026592255,
0.33559948205947876,
0.08412010967731476,
0.3183760643005371,
-0.37259238958358765,
-0.6218894124031067,
-0.17032739520072937,
0.8763858079910278,
-0.36389926075935364,
1.058596134185791,
-0.22524909675121307,
-0.9633007049560547,
0.33948513865470886,
-0.21574518084526062,
-0.1508956402540207,
-0.599462628364563,
-0.49298614263534546,
-0.5529211759567261,
0.22214478254318237,
0.4217427968978882,
0.41656288504600525,
0.0030608337838202715,
0.3268836736679077,
-0.5495057106018066,
0.040770482271909714,
0.38504597544670105,
-0.5583383440971375,
0.4688883423805237,
-0.08901457488536835,
-0.16944117844104767,
0.13893257081508636,
-0.6509052515029907,
0.16657790541648865,
-0.24589969217777252,
-0.33618566393852234,
-0.5386708378791809,
0.21627408266067505,
-0.45772209763526917,
0.48650529980659485,
0.35022997856140137,
-0.7236102819442749,
0.060204632580280304,
-0.40622684359550476,
0.11164135485887527,
0.9125416278839111,
-0.011329174041748047,
0.2059629112482071,
-0.12724366784095764,
0.23304562270641327,
0.5602110028266907,
0.2678464651107788,
-0.17703209817409515,
-0.5849641561508179,
-0.763740599155426,
-0.3685789406299591,
0.17581354081630707,
0.5204539895057678,
-0.3960871696472168,
0.5146120190620422,
-0.2189328819513321,
-0.45544883608818054,
-0.3938097357749939,
0.20195633172988892,
0.6250403523445129,
0.5298906564712524,
0.24908947944641113,
-0.42846018075942993,
-0.4559161067008972,
-1.0430091619491577,
-0.44621363282203674,
-0.36508363485336304,
0.002000667853280902,
0.272421658039093,
0.33208733797073364,
0.014728667214512825,
0.6852927803993225,
-0.38130971789360046,
-0.10442183166742325,
-0.09498162567615509,
0.16879962384700775,
0.09675249457359314,
0.8325227499008179,
0.44381025433540344,
-0.7501312494277954,
-0.661692202091217,
-0.0690593346953392,
-0.6849916577339172,
0.4887370765209198,
-0.04524974152445793,
-0.21750648319721222,
0.5084982514381409,
0.2756068706512451,
-0.49614009261131287,
0.23434816300868988,
0.8629500865936279,
0.03938596323132515,
0.32401224970817566,
-0.4260767698287964,
0.39081063866615295,
-1.2701531648635864,
-0.16482198238372803,
0.36641186475753784,
-0.2913264036178589,
-0.4775930643081665,
-0.14002566039562225,
0.42260003089904785,
0.5072317719459534,
-0.17101910710334778,
0.1779966801404953,
-0.5266384482383728,
0.1717124879360199,
0.016225146129727364,
0.2608562409877777,
0.2832668423652649,
0.5276133418083191,
0.09558292478322983,
0.6445838212966919,
0.8020841479301453,
-0.2881965935230255,
-0.0981377586722374,
-0.06854121387004852,
-0.33648285269737244,
0.8823608756065369,
-0.3142164349555969,
0.20051495730876923,
-0.48154711723327637,
0.4231201708316803,
-1.2376563549041748,
-0.3268885612487793,
0.19823762774467468,
-0.4802263379096985,
0.5288850665092468,
-0.28825005888938904,
-0.300157368183136,
-0.15907423198223114,
-0.41526153683662415,
0.21734030544757843,
0.11501085013151169,
-0.6162475347518921,
1.0836812257766724,
0.5490753054618835,
-0.1364077478647232,
-1.087842583656311,
-0.6976218819618225,
0.08509745448827744,
0.16010628640651703,
-0.5275152921676636,
-0.21274839341640472,
-0.24485047161579132,
-0.31265127658843994,
-0.4880947470664978,
-0.4134577214717865,
-0.16635222733020782,
-0.08793021738529205,
0.3484800159931183,
0.30114200711250305,
-0.12773635983467102,
0.1449335366487503,
-0.16869109869003296,
0.047360438853502274,
0.05188934504985809,
-0.5926613211631775,
0.339893639087677,
-0.24709907174110413,
-0.6574509143829346,
-0.5898306965827942,
0.3951611816883087,
0.7348477840423584,
-0.18439072370529175,
1.3299880027770996,
0.03310222178697586,
-0.41183415055274963,
0.11319781839847565,
-1.0594056844711304,
0.298155277967453,
-0.39875271916389465,
0.344578355550766,
-0.4098735749721527,
-0.660637617111206,
0.7161402702331543,
0.05771302059292793,
0.0567634217441082,
0.2331179678440094,
0.5368748307228088,
0.016797589138150215,
1.2301409244537354,
1.0167608261108398,
-0.4480706751346588,
0.2859500050544739,
0.07015476375818253,
0.2075338363647461,
-0.6873342990875244,
-0.6939588189125061,
-0.5863747000694275,
-0.11522864550352097,
-0.4358048141002655,
-0.5773398280143738,
0.5968106985092163,
-0.030227700248360634,
-0.36669108271598816,
0.11379505693912506,
-0.14145871996879578,
0.4840048849582672,
0.41741275787353516,
0.1028393879532814,
0.6223247051239014,
-0.10122985392808914,
-0.26731082797050476,
-0.2923472225666046,
-0.5104405879974365,
-0.2271377146244049,
1.0362106561660767,
0.5903129577636719,
0.7724602222442627,
0.3896561563014984,
0.5854834914207458,
-0.3751956820487976,
0.3522076904773712,
-0.617211103439331,
0.06850859522819519,
0.04036533832550049,
-0.8666830658912659,
-0.3337775766849518,
-0.6080598831176758,
-0.1513630449771881,
0.5914255976676941,
-0.18552900850772858,
-1.0040479898452759,
0.49875035881996155,
0.46302324533462524,
-0.49903061985969543,
0.38427749276161194,
-0.7579774260520935,
0.8362864255905151,
-0.10656405240297318,
-0.5445337295532227,
-0.22560639679431915,
-0.6999231576919556,
0.3863096535205841,
-0.23207800090312958,
0.0683717206120491,
-0.1969403624534607,
-0.06403937190771103,
0.19216658174991608,
-0.1409364491701126,
0.8890075087547302,
-0.1096612885594368,
-0.5490213632583618,
0.1207398921251297,
0.033460065722465515,
0.7854524254798889,
0.1936102956533432,
-0.27716824412345886,
0.15051016211509705,
-0.21189185976982117,
-0.4730994999408722,
-0.6910208463668823,
0.9516841173171997,
-0.7151588201522827,
-0.6164479851722717,
-0.44785213470458984,
-0.6617230176925659,
-0.7380334138870239,
0.08310170471668243,
0.12083331495523453,
0.3144106864929199,
-0.2608990967273712,
0.3691394329071045,
0.7871479392051697,
-0.08197817206382751,
0.31458744406700134,
0.47960394620895386,
-0.044354360550642014,
-0.3338235318660736,
0.3131352365016937,
0.32329660654067993,
0.603996217250824,
0.36786648631095886,
0.13592785596847534,
-0.4155748188495636,
-0.5065734386444092,
-0.3796224296092987,
-0.026267649605870247,
-0.5931551456451416,
-0.3274262249469757,
-0.853280246257782,
-0.41783469915390015,
-0.8131656050682068,
0.15877372026443481,
-1.0463650226593018,
-0.16751602292060852,
0.3393075466156006,
-0.0783841460943222,
0.20984813570976257,
0.5187198519706726,
-0.22170837223529816,
0.20627710223197937,
-0.6452682614326477,
0.11517808586359024,
0.2883245348930359,
0.6102684140205383,
0.08950585126876831,
-0.49226829409599304,
-0.19518187642097473,
0.24251540005207062,
-0.06523358821868896,
-0.5273725390434265,
0.22541077435016632,
0.20186088979244232,
0.6649199724197388,
0.3651755154132843,
-0.0469956137239933,
0.6831691265106201,
-0.378534734249115,
0.4995323121547699,
0.3430280089378357,
-1.117925763130188,
0.39494678378105164,
-0.31269872188568115,
0.4069089889526367,
0.7021486163139343,
0.5550200939178467,
-0.5647363066673279,
-0.6826162338256836,
-0.46668076515197754,
-0.6639232039451599,
0.3770093321800232,
0.15126372873783112,
-0.16104859113693237,
0.21350686252117157,
0.2588784992694855,
-0.1017661914229393,
0.4481179714202881,
-0.7925529479980469,
-0.24923668801784515,
-0.46791672706604004,
-0.3047165870666504,
-0.4250970482826233,
-0.47211867570877075,
-0.3583415150642395,
-0.23727639019489288,
0.7730032205581665,
-0.3294326066970825,
-0.38266876339912415,
0.4471849501132965,
0.17377597093582153,
-0.20301783084869385,
0.34817495942115784,
0.6858075261116028,
1.0068739652633667,
-0.17224617302417755,
0.5123003721237183,
0.2789417505264282,
-0.42633864283561707,
0.10515813529491425,
0.007658137008547783,
-0.18147478997707367,
-0.29572972655296326,
0.2520700991153717,
0.36582913994789124,
0.24046416580677032,
-0.3540235459804535,
0.7447412610054016,
0.08128227293491364,
0.04824254289269447,
-0.5555209517478943,
-0.17468686401844025,
0.28798848390579224,
0.3589470684528351,
0.11283504217863083,
0.4050818681716919,
-0.14733809232711792,
-0.6413974165916443,
0.043928734958171844,
0.5265807509422302,
-0.21399785578250885,
-0.02099072001874447,
0.3859339952468872,
-0.0925566554069519,
0.1539541482925415,
0.40317773818969727,
0.11267567425966263,
-0.5693656802177429,
0.4355396330356598,
0.45239755511283875,
0.6613578796386719,
-0.5704097747802734,
0.2145259976387024,
0.41475844383239746,
0.42677563428878784,
-0.751924991607666,
0.18643739819526672,
0.23248837888240814,
-1.2051385641098022,
-0.7717156410217285,
-0.456162691116333,
-0.5209619402885437,
-0.039611004292964935,
-0.5473505854606628,
-0.18960419297218323,
-0.6256891489028931,
-0.11387583613395691,
-0.16734488308429718,
0.04907272011041641,
-0.21313773095607758,
0.07646026462316513,
0.24877215921878815,
0.7209650278091431,
-0.8274994492530823,
1.3135647773742676,
0.3689936101436615,
-0.32432591915130615,
-1.2363390922546387,
0.2893397808074951,
0.3963215947151184,
-0.6108947992324829,
0.030303487554192543,
0.24398627877235413,
-0.6621328592300415,
-0.2594488561153412,
-0.7111306190490723,
-1.100592851638794,
0.7932244539260864,
0.4782349467277527,
-0.6643790006637573,
0.28436407446861267,
-0.06850216537714005,
0.5102657079696655,
-0.6250126361846924,
0.000721557589713484,
0.5266304016113281,
0.6954347491264343,
0.2014949917793274,
-1.0896966457366943,
-0.2763679623603821,
0.04752865806221962,
0.08461744338274002,
0.07794159650802612,
-0.6877398490905762,
0.8297653794288635,
-0.26594066619873047,
0.016866546124219894,
0.11469229310750961,
0.7746716141700745,
0.6084719300270081,
0.1355469524860382,
0.7311156392097473,
0.4564611315727234,
0.9338083267211914,
0.06498999893665314,
0.937488853931427,
-0.2427627295255661,
0.5489095449447632,
1.6513605117797852,
-0.4160887598991394,
1.1130146980285645,
0.6146534085273743,
-0.05257262662053108,
0.6316585540771484,
0.2885168492794037,
0.16373328864574432,
0.3557674288749695,
-0.262762188911438,
-0.26862215995788574,
-0.7657454013824463,
-0.15981978178024292,
-0.2257210910320282,
0.4836357533931732,
0.13616101443767548,
-0.3059297502040863,
0.006000986322760582,
-0.18400204181671143,
0.23129545152187347,
0.4613727331161499,
-0.34055495262145996,
0.49162399768829346,
0.14111293852329254,
-0.6486040949821472,
0.36562085151672363,
-0.06634275615215302,
0.6813546419143677,
-0.5168881416320801,
0.21700794994831085,
-0.14283518493175507,
0.7578204870223999,
-0.13852696120738983,
-0.9013298749923706,
0.08065418899059296,
-0.3333374857902527,
-0.36299583315849304,
-0.11317312717437744,
0.5636433362960815,
-0.8803481459617615,
-0.7731050252914429,
0.43169939517974854,
0.8031319975852966,
-0.02418314479291439,
-0.5119490027427673,
-0.45794957876205444,
0.04433458298444748,
-0.05000700056552887,
-0.08979181945323944,
0.26223504543304443,
0.5213451385498047,
0.14579816162586212,
0.7352006435394287,
0.30085405707359314,
0.09775041043758392,
-0.04275359958410263,
0.1750217229127884,
0.6026697158813477,
-0.36221206188201904,
-0.3768814504146576,
-0.9829718470573425,
0.5043691992759705,
-0.4402482807636261,
-0.264646053314209,
1.0894607305526733,
0.5704428553581238,
0.9456360936164856,
0.04979034885764122,
0.6403304934501648,
0.19890105724334717,
0.7782536745071411,
-0.2655716836452484,
0.7825438976287842,
-0.6085273623466492,
0.17730247974395752,
-0.5304305553436279,
-0.8026415705680847,
-0.506197452545166,
0.8518751263618469,
-0.1834871917963028,
0.08568058907985687,
0.6529685854911804,
0.8408883810043335,
-0.0382833369076252,
-0.06690065562725067,
0.4734548032283783,
0.5221683979034424,
0.16986079514026642,
0.45384541153907776,
0.8097666501998901,
-0.2638891935348511,
0.33758702874183655,
-0.6232098340988159,
-0.30991148948669434,
0.24513207376003265,
-1.2077207565307617,
-0.7966693639755249,
-0.49800726771354675,
-0.2981886863708496,
-0.574569821357727,
0.10112468153238297,
0.939653754234314,
0.9389047026634216,
-1.0344550609588623,
-0.173879936337471,
0.07859884947538376,
0.20992904901504517,
-0.407137930393219,
-0.10511337965726852,
0.11897356063127518,
-0.15739703178405762,
-0.791068434715271,
0.34935808181762695,
0.5879523754119873,
0.028661997988820076,
-0.7123245596885681,
-0.00014915205247234553,
-0.510962963104248,
0.15677952766418457,
0.49395719170570374,
0.16303366422653198,
-0.7991424202919006,
-0.8174899220466614,
-0.15983499586582184,
-0.2774437367916107,
0.4826805591583252,
0.7558380961418152,
-0.5003322958946228,
0.36478057503700256,
0.34280475974082947,
0.47489652037620544,
0.13762468099594116,
0.30797386169433594,
0.9006328582763672,
-1.0547562837600708,
0.4054170250892639,
-0.018955785781145096,
0.4877549111843109,
0.637695848941803,
-0.5977226495742798,
0.3200719356536865,
0.0880272164940834,
-0.35991910099983215,
-0.6653628945350647,
0.3224576711654663,
-0.9745222330093384,
-0.22261479496955872,
0.9122220873832703,
-0.546830415725708,
-0.10611198097467422,
-0.16879382729530334,
0.21543549001216888,
0.09502063691616058,
-0.5080090761184692,
0.9148046970367432,
1.0226396322250366,
0.004866808652877808,
-0.18966330587863922,
-0.45193883776664734,
0.36085230112075806,
0.49170443415641785,
-0.7670912742614746,
0.42845532298088074,
0.532146155834198,
0.46928420662879944,
0.5734704732894897,
0.5638654828071594,
-0.21016979217529297,
-0.23765841126441956,
-0.09843436628580093,
0.055984169244766235,
0.27359116077423096,
-0.9519233703613281,
-0.3453858196735382,
0.35675638914108276,
0.19938060641288757,
-0.01478030439466238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11271v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11271v2 | MONAL: Model Autophagy Analysis for Modeling Human-AI Interactions | 2024-02-17T13:02:54 | 2024-03-30T22:05:59 | Shu Yang, Muhammad Asif Ali, Lu Yu, Lijie Hu, Di Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | The increasing significance of large models and their multi-modal variants in
societal information processing has ignited debates on social safety and
ethics. However, there exists a paucity of comprehensive analysis for: (i) the
interactions between human and artificial intelligence systems, and (ii)
understanding and addressing the associated limitations. To bridge this gap, we
propose Model Autophagy Analysis (MONAL) for large models' self-consumption
explanation. MONAL employs two distinct autophagous loops (referred to as
``self-consumption loops'') to elucidate the suppression of human-generated
information in the exchange between human and AI systems. Through comprehensive
experiments on diverse datasets, we evaluate the capacities of generated models
as both creators and disseminators of information. Our key findings reveal (i)
A progressive prevalence of model-generated synthetic information over time
within training datasets compared to human-generated information; (ii) The
discernible tendency of large models, when acting as information transmitters
across multiple iterations, to selectively modify or prioritize specific
contents; and (iii) The potential for a reduction in the diversity of socially
or human-generated information, leading to bottlenecks in the performance
enhancement of large models and confining them to local optima. | [
-0.36115163564682007,
-0.8703384399414062,
0.4122222661972046,
-0.20578566193580627,
0.10532329976558685,
0.07661675661802292,
0.16535933315753937,
-0.6333704590797424,
0.22270579636096954,
0.4849013388156891,
-0.5951089262962341,
0.03446993976831436,
-0.44043177366256714,
-0.12415271252393723,
-0.5234314203262329,
0.8467917442321777,
0.26996105909347534,
-0.11746054142713547,
-0.20779339969158173,
-0.006230228580534458,
-0.36150243878364563,
-0.7841053605079651,
-0.5587331056594849,
-0.4186834394931793,
0.6948450207710266,
0.17300231754779816,
0.7839106917381287,
0.7902713418006897,
0.4059053361415863,
0.4294531047344208,
0.25668850541114807,
0.11389163881540298,
-0.4746586084365845,
0.26085594296455383,
-0.30688199400901794,
0.005136510357260704,
-0.5626016855239868,
0.39451780915260315,
0.6193457841873169,
0.758332371711731,
-0.16245509684085846,
0.48866161704063416,
0.35455065965652466,
0.8106889128684998,
-0.8177875280380249,
0.2682803273200989,
-0.5413596630096436,
0.11025790870189667,
-0.141383558511734,
-0.0008776991162449121,
-0.25234904885292053,
-0.016785230487585068,
0.1428346037864685,
-0.5509915351867676,
-0.16979718208312988,
0.2075808197259903,
0.49843430519104004,
0.6292991638183594,
-0.4083448350429535,
-0.3717936873435974,
-1.0494036674499512,
0.6461632251739502,
-0.7629143595695496,
-0.11332105100154877,
0.4656901955604553,
0.1745496690273285,
-0.07268700003623962,
-0.5032461881637573,
-0.5668842196464539,
-0.3274737596511841,
-0.18126431107521057,
0.11951207369565964,
-0.38969531655311584,
0.2294955849647522,
0.366301029920578,
0.27770745754241943,
-0.46013349294662476,
-0.0070257424376904964,
-0.6562739610671997,
-0.30330461263656616,
0.9468884468078613,
0.5031947493553162,
0.43546974658966064,
-0.47367343306541443,
-0.27729153633117676,
0.07667852938175201,
-0.27207982540130615,
-0.03795700520277023,
0.6979441046714783,
-0.20101039111614227,
-0.008728422224521637,
0.7339630722999573,
-0.18412116169929504,
0.5474423766136169,
0.11076559871435165,
0.3092748820781708,
0.0591447614133358,
-0.3545500636100769,
-0.470488578081131,
-0.22176235914230347,
0.9204398989677429,
0.2721606492996216,
0.20637136697769165,
0.20887406170368195,
-0.07709109038114548,
0.0059418645687401295,
0.4846293032169342,
-0.7340511083602905,
-0.6397388577461243,
0.18569202721118927,
-0.8784319162368774,
-0.554542601108551,
-0.01847146451473236,
-0.6054239273071289,
-0.5528632402420044,
-0.4952312111854553,
0.4345870614051819,
-0.2246875911951065,
-0.36966457962989807,
0.17044222354888916,
-0.11291085183620453,
0.1121167466044426,
-0.012577933259308338,
-0.7175652384757996,
0.2249276489019394,
0.24409756064414978,
0.6634001731872559,
-0.045615456998348236,
-0.4049398899078369,
-0.2914842367172241,
0.5033881068229675,
-0.18551023304462433,
0.5848987698554993,
-0.37850454449653625,
-0.25387081503868103,
-0.4065128266811371,
-0.06445223838090897,
-0.18216462433338165,
-0.6523958444595337,
0.038235872983932495,
-0.3993866443634033,
-0.05052546411752701,
-0.5096667408943176,
-0.6852892637252808,
-0.4075694680213928,
0.1303703784942627,
-0.8173243403434753,
0.6950119137763977,
-0.03838678449392319,
-0.7482435703277588,
0.1676035225391388,
-1.01798415184021,
-0.49072349071502686,
-0.02516772411763668,
-0.1462475061416626,
-0.31412985920906067,
0.019865626469254494,
-0.05510648712515831,
0.5025357007980347,
-0.29681944847106934,
0.5862599611282349,
-0.676812469959259,
0.15616025030612946,
0.43685126304626465,
-0.5974797606468201,
0.9394360780715942,
0.5268190503120422,
-0.3265649676322937,
0.2684897482395172,
-0.616494357585907,
-0.3040657341480255,
0.18507911264896393,
-0.10826944559812546,
-0.3299724757671356,
0.3743956983089447,
-0.17335574328899384,
0.2712232768535614,
0.34263572096824646,
-0.36108773946762085,
0.15360546112060547,
-0.02119813859462738,
0.9793711304664612,
0.8463128805160522,
-0.06234441697597504,
0.43266117572784424,
-0.5994576811790466,
0.42751798033714294,
0.10623835772275925,
0.5825300812721252,
-0.31669506430625916,
-0.37525033950805664,
-0.6994237899780273,
-0.10453538596630096,
0.09361578524112701,
0.42419981956481934,
-0.3437063694000244,
0.5015300512313843,
0.25427761673927307,
-0.1587774157524109,
-0.4090016186237335,
0.17878007888793945,
0.271733820438385,
0.47470623254776,
0.2953259348869324,
-0.44127848744392395,
-0.3459814190864563,
-1.2937216758728027,
-0.20266814529895782,
-0.23906674981117249,
0.022865956649184227,
0.4125605523586273,
0.6082213521003723,
-0.43242982029914856,
1.0179853439331055,
-0.21679817140102386,
0.049976326525211334,
-0.24850723147392273,
0.44244349002838135,
-0.36934342980384827,
0.7194558382034302,
0.6401623487472534,
-0.5077188611030579,
-0.07456071674823761,
-0.36336782574653625,
-1.0646578073501587,
-0.02954688109457493,
-0.20506510138511658,
-0.2532534599304199,
0.012487835250794888,
0.2796221375465393,
-0.4898790419101715,
0.686674952507019,
0.21817414462566376,
-0.3253328204154968,
0.6503294110298157,
-0.43584901094436646,
0.04121200367808342,
-0.6056819558143616,
0.3256920874118805,
-0.23937468230724335,
-0.2033384144306183,
-0.7211123108863831,
-0.014208843931555748,
-0.07523984462022781,
-0.3657529354095459,
-0.07388211041688919,
0.5635321140289307,
-0.576141357421875,
-0.3839004933834076,
-0.3070615828037262,
-0.1545713096857071,
0.20585763454437256,
0.24925871193408966,
-0.29486194252967834,
0.594338059425354,
0.3679277300834656,
-0.5366967916488647,
0.33913928270339966,
0.09008803963661194,
-0.2282017022371292,
0.17365510761737823,
-0.7985932230949402,
0.20108665525913239,
-0.24972082674503326,
0.36101627349853516,
-1.1970503330230713,
-0.5783329606056213,
0.6345109939575195,
-0.3592342138290405,
0.12153267115354538,
0.04827689006924629,
-0.4870770573616028,
-0.47336164116859436,
-0.09308968484401703,
0.7872084975242615,
0.4379856586456299,
-0.2696559429168701,
0.8778627514839172,
0.7328028678894043,
-0.23544946312904358,
-0.22856405377388,
-0.5353124141693115,
0.06884048134088516,
-0.34899279475212097,
-0.7896087169647217,
-0.11690658330917358,
-0.36715051531791687,
-0.495503693819046,
0.023387867957353592,
0.053977612406015396,
-0.06917043775320053,
0.28516438603401184,
0.3138796389102936,
0.45779693126678467,
0.10191114246845245,
0.022814873605966568,
0.09226629137992859,
-0.12419750541448593,
0.509356677532196,
-0.4799211323261261,
0.36335131525993347,
0.010279325768351555,
-0.3613598346710205,
-0.8650994896888733,
0.4255451261997223,
0.8115538358688354,
-0.36283963918685913,
0.6431373357772827,
0.48336759209632874,
-0.26250672340393066,
-0.03233969584107399,
-0.7007016539573669,
-0.133368119597435,
-0.5077531337738037,
0.038185980170965195,
-0.05192232131958008,
-0.47015923261642456,
0.6446821093559265,
0.16762225329875946,
0.045386333018541336,
0.5155937075614929,
0.570999026298523,
-0.2998087704181671,
1.0866237878799438,
0.30605247616767883,
-0.5202076435089111,
0.37049585580825806,
-0.5307100415229797,
0.04790371656417847,
-0.7573019862174988,
-0.057513732463121414,
-0.06958939135074615,
-0.5038409233093262,
-0.24262256920337677,
-0.392669141292572,
0.4027300477027893,
-0.23712803423404694,
-0.46285584568977356,
-0.10308485478162766,
-0.5713115334510803,
0.3730299472808838,
0.5278348326683044,
-0.04302053898572922,
0.08632297068834305,
-0.16670584678649902,
0.09247427433729172,
0.22961346805095673,
-0.8048837184906006,
-0.3277108669281006,
1.0323967933654785,
0.41381722688674927,
0.9307207465171814,
-0.26400265097618103,
0.45732223987579346,
0.7848255634307861,
0.0788940042257309,
-0.5563116669654846,
0.42362329363822937,
-0.08769474923610687,
-0.8783127665519714,
-0.2214966118335724,
-0.4975273609161377,
-0.9145002961158752,
0.10930714756250381,
-0.14536628127098083,
-0.5750261545181274,
0.291151762008667,
0.5008452534675598,
-0.7898410558700562,
0.2922857105731964,
-0.6291568875312805,
0.8901944756507874,
-0.424550861120224,
-0.49820613861083984,
-0.6586777567863464,
-0.6817046403884888,
0.6118190884590149,
-0.04705869033932686,
0.5108367204666138,
-0.2886655032634735,
0.3361789882183075,
0.6470362544059753,
-0.42016494274139404,
1.01035737991333,
-0.10657653212547302,
-0.061094850301742554,
0.6130412817001343,
0.225562185049057,
0.3925950229167938,
-0.026422739028930664,
-0.03314369544386864,
0.16353432834148407,
-0.007338520605117083,
-0.44195953011512756,
-0.3637884259223938,
0.4457223415374756,
-0.8667224049568176,
-0.5120987892150879,
-0.3655792772769928,
-0.7775530815124512,
0.30000391602516174,
-0.004511001519858837,
0.20251771807670593,
0.6340463757514954,
0.02401704341173172,
0.013344439677894115,
0.43540704250335693,
-0.37762588262557983,
0.4038473665714264,
0.27358493208885193,
-0.13139159977436066,
-0.226613387465477,
0.8510040640830994,
0.2936115562915802,
0.37010473012924194,
-0.35985615849494934,
0.36925002932548523,
-0.09621790051460266,
-0.3490380048751831,
-0.4712470769882202,
0.25508788228034973,
-0.3400875926017761,
0.008655179291963577,
-0.6289348602294922,
-0.5005662441253662,
-0.29910433292388916,
0.003512634662911296,
-0.43466639518737793,
-0.32941552996635437,
-0.38233059644699097,
0.10932133346796036,
-0.08789892494678497,
1.1187511682510376,
-0.4860098659992218,
0.24182452261447906,
-0.6914399862289429,
0.4958275556564331,
0.4037958085536957,
0.08236400783061981,
0.3814454972743988,
-0.21022938191890717,
-0.3007983863353729,
0.1929587423801422,
-0.3614257276058197,
-1.0735682249069214,
0.3598095774650574,
0.06264852732419968,
0.5811114311218262,
0.7047562003135681,
0.17685949802398682,
0.59212327003479,
-0.24002712965011597,
0.6887156367301941,
-0.028909143060445786,
-1.0274146795272827,
0.5366587042808533,
-0.7075179815292358,
0.14624357223510742,
0.32635030150413513,
0.1881265789270401,
-0.33087193965911865,
-0.2884993851184845,
-0.6564254760742188,
-0.8270346522331238,
0.7206458449363708,
0.4404575824737549,
-0.010779027827084064,
0.05662338063120842,
0.5917051434516907,
-0.056410372257232666,
0.38273802399635315,
-0.7338995337486267,
-0.23871992528438568,
-0.21037591993808746,
-0.04426542669534683,
0.274099200963974,
-0.402908056974411,
-0.16706734895706177,
-0.4076220989227295,
0.6167146563529968,
0.0891476571559906,
0.17618820071220398,
0.2340915948152542,
-0.12502768635749817,
-0.2614443898200989,
-0.1393115520477295,
0.19615304470062256,
0.49935421347618103,
-0.03997906669974327,
0.014354702085256577,
-0.2075861692428589,
-0.24403069913387299,
0.17654737830162048,
0.1332068294286728,
-0.19572243094444275,
-0.566382884979248,
0.20148570835590363,
0.47844380140304565,
0.0411161445081234,
-0.6688969731330872,
0.1741362363100052,
-0.07325443625450134,
-0.12165477126836777,
-0.7518998980522156,
0.30420708656311035,
-0.06604721397161484,
0.5230602025985718,
0.23464295268058777,
0.12336930632591248,
0.608669102191925,
-0.7555969953536987,
0.13989436626434326,
0.7103480696678162,
0.02490948513150215,
-0.4030665159225464,
0.8334187865257263,
0.29462701082229614,
-0.11654248833656311,
0.8009145259857178,
-0.3866913318634033,
-0.37452638149261475,
0.8923001885414124,
0.07859990000724792,
0.93620765209198,
-0.3645004630088806,
0.2306109517812729,
0.5243968367576599,
0.32502231001853943,
0.11354371160268784,
-0.03538565710186958,
-0.2882537245750427,
-0.7300263047218323,
-0.2657127380371094,
-0.5181679725646973,
-0.05880069360136986,
0.35474351048469543,
-0.867913544178009,
-0.18606196343898773,
-0.44493159651756287,
-0.2925354838371277,
0.2913625240325928,
-0.1616985946893692,
-0.5877427458763123,
-0.05739821121096611,
0.4507721960544586,
0.26878276467323303,
-0.7144328951835632,
0.8250725865364075,
0.45834773778915405,
-0.3496187925338745,
-0.7191460728645325,
-0.007461244706064463,
0.2561866343021393,
-0.5693115592002869,
0.5973328351974487,
0.17076405882835388,
-0.20224525034427643,
0.01241192128509283,
-0.6003454923629761,
-1.162739872932434,
1.0253208875656128,
0.1259949505329132,
-0.5809748768806458,
-0.34811821579933167,
0.12801985442638397,
0.29375287890434265,
-0.5920642614364624,
0.22623512148857117,
0.7406041622161865,
0.616507887840271,
-0.04535140469670296,
-0.6926479339599609,
-0.07206634432077408,
-0.4516619145870209,
-0.0445866733789444,
0.018480775877833366,
-0.8105349540710449,
0.99748694896698,
-0.13784193992614746,
-0.1952987164258957,
0.20911532640457153,
0.4208025634288788,
-0.13529559969902039,
0.46888646483421326,
0.7854471206665039,
0.39103397727012634,
0.7052579522132874,
0.5166510939598083,
0.8721638917922974,
-0.4917444884777069,
0.44805780053138733,
1.1334320306777954,
-0.4364017844200134,
0.2695806920528412,
-0.05861639976501465,
-0.08497118204832077,
0.41815927624702454,
0.6240983605384827,
-0.11418741196393967,
0.11940020322799683,
0.21099728345870972,
-0.022059209644794464,
-0.4053293466567993,
0.18183162808418274,
-0.09035006165504456,
0.6315646171569824,
0.5598918795585632,
-0.526151716709137,
-0.06865779310464859,
0.21611523628234863,
-0.16794966161251068,
-0.4180172085762024,
-0.1345808506011963,
0.8249632716178894,
-0.15727606415748596,
-0.530556857585907,
0.4781203866004944,
-0.20336908102035522,
0.11930735409259796,
-0.3361695408821106,
0.1636197417974472,
-0.10587719827890396,
0.002815194195136428,
-0.015436815097928047,
-0.3806712329387665,
0.565675675868988,
-0.08442306518554688,
-0.3131968677043915,
-0.047328319400548935,
1.0562522411346436,
-0.26714810729026794,
-0.46652600169181824,
0.6352416276931763,
0.5506208539009094,
0.16731460392475128,
0.000988714979030192,
-0.9746536612510681,
0.010377033613622189,
-0.02124832198023796,
-0.4092819094657898,
0.3058706223964691,
0.11872251331806183,
0.14896728098392487,
0.7986716628074646,
0.6569978594779968,
-0.15469855070114136,
0.1363256871700287,
-0.22348733246326447,
0.8899905681610107,
-0.7712807655334473,
-0.5120940208435059,
-0.9686924815177917,
0.5185582637786865,
-0.21145790815353394,
-0.006912332493811846,
0.5950968265533447,
0.5486679077148438,
0.5656070113182068,
0.13901081681251526,
1.16488778591156,
-0.15298710763454437,
0.2826481759548187,
-0.3327650725841522,
0.9559594392776489,
-0.7266238927841187,
0.29777058959007263,
-0.16550233960151672,
-0.6702768802642822,
0.46346810460090637,
0.703454852104187,
-0.35139498114585876,
0.04271618649363518,
0.3416179418563843,
0.4788963198661804,
-0.26615792512893677,
0.10964588820934296,
0.32309675216674805,
0.5760595798492432,
0.1358308345079422,
0.31236395239830017,
1.254502296447754,
0.00746918935328722,
0.16821198165416718,
-0.27649062871932983,
-0.3445958197116852,
-0.32308703660964966,
-0.5878031849861145,
-0.9626829028129578,
-0.6891219615936279,
-0.12360270321369171,
-0.2122935950756073,
0.08869999647140503,
0.8849627375602722,
1.0178461074829102,
-0.4251336455345154,
-0.5381757020950317,
0.0656210407614708,
-0.10220789909362793,
-0.005798897705972195,
-0.1766192764043808,
0.011510989628732204,
-0.5119771361351013,
-0.41313281655311584,
0.3137766718864441,
0.3616146445274353,
-0.035101454704999924,
-0.7925238013267517,
0.1853654980659485,
-0.07660927623510361,
0.46365323662757874,
0.7003626823425293,
0.349828839302063,
-0.6658275127410889,
-0.15157757699489594,
-0.21574153006076813,
0.09210014343261719,
0.04172438755631447,
1.1170783042907715,
-0.7658740282058716,
0.604436457157135,
0.2931927740573883,
0.40160417556762695,
0.4042804539203644,
0.3063264489173889,
0.6162633299827576,
-0.12270773947238922,
0.03179750591516495,
0.06412201374769211,
0.3799566924571991,
0.10658344626426697,
-0.6077269315719604,
0.3091776669025421,
0.20053644478321075,
-0.9949324131011963,
-0.5005223751068115,
0.495320200920105,
-0.6591816544532776,
-0.5323596000671387,
1.0174146890640259,
-0.10111159831285477,
-0.29713067412376404,
-0.23428232967853546,
-0.19992180168628693,
0.34801480174064636,
-0.3717806041240692,
1.194620132446289,
0.6422183513641357,
-0.4379928410053253,
0.10370241105556488,
-0.8450297713279724,
0.45346662402153015,
0.3567051589488983,
-0.9634395241737366,
0.432641863822937,
1.037740707397461,
0.4144245386123657,
0.07865727692842484,
0.6625484824180603,
0.1287180632352829,
0.12406071275472641,
-0.13508100807666779,
-0.09833091497421265,
-0.16140061616897583,
-0.631173312664032,
-0.26588743925094604,
0.01889978162944317,
-0.27208390831947327,
-0.09912002831697464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11260v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11260v1 | MoRAL: MoE Augmented LoRA for LLMs' Lifelong Learning | 2024-02-17T12:25:31 | 2024-02-17T12:25:31 | Shu Yang, Muhammad Asif Ali, Cheng-Long Wang, Lijie Hu, Di Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Adapting large language models (LLMs) to new domains/tasks and enabling them
to be efficient lifelong learners is a pivotal challenge. In this paper, we
propose MoRAL, i.e., Mixture-of-Experts augmented Low-Rank Adaptation for
Lifelong Learning. MoRAL combines the multi-tasking abilities of MoE with the
fine-tuning abilities of LoRA for effective life-long learning of LLMs. In
contrast to the conventional approaches that use factual triplets as inputs
MoRAL relies on simple question-answer pairs, which is a more practical and
effective strategy for robust and efficient learning. Owing to new data
settings, we introduce a new evaluation benchmark namely: Life Long Learning of
LLM (5L-bench) encompassing a newly curated dataset of question-answer pairs,
and a set of evaluation metrics for rigorous evaluation of MoRAL in open-book
and closed-book settings. Experimental evaluation shows (i) LLMs learn fast in
open-book settings with up to 30.15% improvement in "RA" for Phi-2-2.7B
compared to closed-book (for models fine-tuned with MoRAL); (ii) MoRAL shows
higher performance improvement for models with a greater number of parameters;
(iii) MoRAL is robust to catastrophic forgetting offering better knowledge
retention compared to baselines. | [
-0.13369150459766388,
-0.8688462376594543,
0.4104393422603607,
0.045257989317178726,
-0.34064462780952454,
0.3017939031124115,
-0.4494380056858063,
-0.34348174929618835,
-0.11197683960199356,
0.5943024158477783,
-0.3262742757797241,
-0.38814523816108704,
-0.6260133981704712,
-0.12829063832759857,
0.16658875346183777,
0.9673367142677307,
0.21540133655071259,
0.23589640855789185,
-0.24442711472511292,
-0.5630970597267151,
-0.6488847136497498,
-0.41435593366622925,
-0.8259294629096985,
-0.309705525636673,
0.7018414735794067,
0.5043870210647583,
0.4623571038246155,
0.40485548973083496,
0.2762041389942169,
0.2942781448364258,
-0.07793152332305908,
0.5860266089439392,
-1.0193921327590942,
0.2014712542295456,
-0.4123406708240509,
-0.5026498436927795,
-0.7811110615730286,
0.04527384415268898,
0.5735194087028503,
0.6582432985305786,
-0.2457294464111328,
0.20879895985126495,
0.3975503742694855,
1.005924940109253,
-0.8124123215675354,
0.03292214870452881,
-0.7185237407684326,
-0.07278333604335785,
0.15906617045402527,
-0.37040263414382935,
-0.5402392745018005,
-0.628825306892395,
-0.03361617401242256,
-0.6690609455108643,
-0.4883689284324646,
0.05579051375389099,
0.3166922628879547,
0.39207130670547485,
-0.49329403042793274,
-0.36642077565193176,
-0.6098077297210693,
1.2537119388580322,
-0.5450535416603088,
0.43827563524246216,
0.3722466826438904,
0.20077824592590332,
-0.17236357927322388,
-0.16146638989448547,
-0.28307291865348816,
-0.15149420499801636,
0.4622727632522583,
0.2952154874801636,
0.29119157791137695,
-0.13751468062400818,
-0.03439050912857056,
0.4015008807182312,
0.11480464786291122,
0.14062973856925964,
-0.3334105908870697,
0.07829011231660843,
0.7789317965507507,
0.1614995151758194,
0.04866693541407585,
-0.05736377462744713,
-0.5351994633674622,
0.04845789074897766,
-0.7441011071205139,
0.14345934987068176,
0.2955095171928406,
0.08158927410840988,
-0.1146983802318573,
0.4999895989894867,
0.08970145881175995,
0.5912894606590271,
0.13338789343833923,
-0.5827317237854004,
0.2103154957294464,
-0.16012054681777954,
0.07625284045934677,
-0.12528586387634277,
0.5202396512031555,
0.515608549118042,
0.796230673789978,
-0.002861469052731991,
-0.1905532330274582,
-0.42235442996025085,
0.13938795030117035,
-0.6130127906799316,
-0.08624260127544403,
0.005444926675409079,
-0.38887614011764526,
-0.25127682089805603,
-0.2124340832233429,
-0.6653790473937988,
-0.5138423442840576,
-0.5358848571777344,
0.6149094700813293,
-0.6974369883537292,
0.050699423998594284,
0.44758808612823486,
0.3124610185623169,
0.3077453672885895,
0.6146752238273621,
-0.7354141473770142,
0.1915881186723709,
0.6312470436096191,
0.720487654209137,
-0.461829274892807,
-0.23073936998844147,
-1.0871765613555908,
0.3628741204738617,
-0.25253328680992126,
0.6783819794654846,
-0.6358039379119873,
-0.5568658113479614,
-0.2193536013364792,
-0.15067417919635773,
-0.17351439595222473,
-0.5719935297966003,
0.618742823600769,
-0.5032917261123657,
0.07431954145431519,
-0.2873244285583496,
-0.5453857183456421,
-0.20874187350273132,
0.1477344036102295,
-0.5427371263504028,
1.146827220916748,
0.16491377353668213,
-0.4095700681209564,
0.36432144045829773,
-0.9017775654792786,
-0.3655696511268616,
-0.012666109949350357,
0.12176688015460968,
-0.3968554437160492,
0.10904259234666824,
0.14137843251228333,
0.6670969724655151,
-0.1480204463005066,
0.3787407875061035,
-0.5637805461883545,
-0.5278134346008301,
0.23609332740306854,
-0.5704907178878784,
0.8034511208534241,
-0.043236326426267624,
0.04221025109291077,
0.05492490157485008,
-0.9018166065216064,
-0.013300105929374695,
0.04847396910190582,
-0.8473142981529236,
-0.5551480054855347,
0.3436344563961029,
-0.17408569157123566,
-0.11434360593557358,
0.4626072347164154,
-0.48183369636535645,
0.2564171850681305,
-0.30762848258018494,
0.3469633460044861,
1.1843379735946655,
0.15414297580718994,
0.32302045822143555,
-0.5884811282157898,
0.2595042586326599,
0.019325485453009605,
0.30621829628944397,
0.18443697690963745,
-0.483185738325119,
-1.0577906370162964,
-0.3947635889053345,
0.08226883411407471,
0.7081044912338257,
-0.6855621337890625,
0.6169110536575317,
-0.4522704780101776,
-0.3678695857524872,
-0.31623414158821106,
0.5908085703849792,
0.283174067735672,
0.43950843811035156,
0.5469255447387695,
-0.2959374487400055,
-0.2368779331445694,
-0.39689773321151733,
-0.44101837277412415,
-0.2082429826259613,
0.21558649837970734,
0.5333672761917114,
0.6166217923164368,
-0.2293354868888855,
0.8218865394592285,
-0.34191474318504333,
-0.11260241270065308,
-0.082334965467453,
-0.05478179454803467,
0.3601158857345581,
0.4559463858604431,
0.4423118829727173,
-0.7431501150131226,
-0.5753452777862549,
0.029185866937041283,
-0.831902801990509,
0.21418388187885284,
0.13091035187244415,
-0.15651287138462067,
0.08126922696828842,
0.4109773337841034,
-0.040711935609579086,
0.08346392959356308,
0.3327556550502777,
-0.21701541543006897,
0.48914462327957153,
-0.42700210213661194,
-0.017391454428434372,
-1.16585111618042,
-0.19527669250965118,
-0.2571623921394348,
-0.47241532802581787,
-0.3187367022037506,
-0.009264974854886532,
0.056781768798828125,
0.08582226932048798,
-0.5933309197425842,
0.8216677904129028,
-0.27804073691368103,
-0.03610268235206604,
-0.1437838077545166,
0.20555345714092255,
-0.2419634908437729,
0.5118482112884521,
-0.24534961581230164,
0.9588686227798462,
0.535098135471344,
-0.7306023836135864,
0.4290977418422699,
0.3318789303302765,
-0.4258216321468353,
0.8876044154167175,
-0.54245525598526,
0.2626931369304657,
-0.029636165127158165,
0.12793217599391937,
-0.40554410219192505,
-0.11044903844594955,
0.13429458439350128,
-0.15458396077156067,
0.043569400906562805,
-0.01358485035598278,
-0.40186867117881775,
0.05075407028198242,
-0.5286222100257874,
0.39701899886131287,
0.7639304399490356,
-0.5688061714172363,
0.9389619827270508,
0.17962124943733215,
-0.26024317741394043,
-0.6954641342163086,
-0.4204255938529968,
-0.09464490413665771,
-0.368841290473938,
-0.4609564244747162,
0.03797980770468712,
-0.5034273266792297,
-0.2804522216320038,
-0.07842865586280823,
-0.0966225415468216,
0.12136204540729523,
0.43933236598968506,
0.15506450831890106,
0.2675122320652008,
-0.3494129776954651,
0.2426164299249649,
0.16337822377681732,
-0.21783524751663208,
-0.1509379893541336,
-0.19950811564922333,
0.31125205755233765,
-0.488249272108078,
-0.2975213825702667,
-0.06507797539234161,
0.245326966047287,
0.690735936164856,
-0.31880342960357666,
0.9080808162689209,
0.5440863966941833,
-0.16881315410137177,
-0.21388590335845947,
-0.605664074420929,
0.10840650647878647,
-0.4973170757293701,
0.25748515129089355,
-0.27976542711257935,
-1.0308810472488403,
0.4330897331237793,
-0.2335669994354248,
0.20619750022888184,
0.3712174892425537,
0.6079678535461426,
-0.38653692603111267,
0.3370002210140228,
0.7569833397865295,
-0.13940194249153137,
0.5186111330986023,
-0.13817159831523895,
0.13202926516532898,
-1.1446442604064941,
-0.1441044956445694,
0.016121309250593185,
-0.2312213033437729,
-0.5038244128227234,
-0.5911925435066223,
0.681581974029541,
0.5530553460121155,
-0.45970165729522705,
-0.052529361099004745,
-0.1062573567032814,
0.6761924624443054,
0.41594210267066956,
0.4941156804561615,
0.6357062458992004,
0.004050159361213446,
0.02035493403673172,
0.2164607048034668,
-0.6124776601791382,
-0.4514435827732086,
1.4941800832748413,
0.2533475160598755,
0.8655286431312561,
0.24269919097423553,
0.8154536485671997,
0.4641152620315552,
0.4729120433330536,
-0.8283061385154724,
0.6480402946472168,
-0.5170039534568787,
-0.3905677795410156,
-0.3076435923576355,
-0.3478530943393707,
-0.6416471004486084,
0.10454133152961731,
-0.30014365911483765,
-0.6147453784942627,
0.2096392959356308,
0.1073908805847168,
-0.5736782550811768,
0.3110765218734741,
-0.54915851354599,
0.3591799736022949,
-0.5652026534080505,
-0.7306963205337524,
-0.5499864220619202,
-0.4827896058559418,
0.23145842552185059,
-0.49920544028282166,
0.24387550354003906,
-0.35533925890922546,
-0.29839378595352173,
0.852881908416748,
-0.08037126064300537,
0.9498229026794434,
-0.08275380730628967,
-0.2483699768781662,
0.2703031599521637,
-0.18812839686870575,
0.5393112301826477,
0.13169051706790924,
-0.4096028208732605,
0.09368019551038742,
-0.040388427674770355,
-0.6571578979492188,
-0.4797523021697998,
0.7087147831916809,
-0.8204275369644165,
-0.5498263239860535,
-0.3599885404109955,
-0.7175798416137695,
-0.5911256074905396,
0.09334652870893478,
-0.16513240337371826,
0.37606915831565857,
-0.2240469753742218,
0.5607684254646301,
0.9113702774047852,
-0.4718784987926483,
0.263022243976593,
0.5536864995956421,
-0.1705092489719391,
-0.6672438383102417,
1.086138129234314,
-0.061577919870615005,
0.5733251571655273,
0.2616092562675476,
0.42453813552856445,
-0.21513861417770386,
-0.5134509801864624,
-0.23551486432552338,
0.38749760389328003,
-0.9562187194824219,
-0.07604899257421494,
-0.5595570206642151,
-0.16117437183856964,
0.05971070006489754,
-0.48535269498825073,
-0.3020037114620209,
-0.21067659556865692,
-0.41665118932724,
0.10326430201530457,
0.5918814539909363,
0.5912375450134277,
-0.13518047332763672,
0.15967293083667755,
-0.7741773128509521,
0.523188591003418,
0.612464427947998,
0.38662028312683105,
-0.11713223904371262,
-0.6550846695899963,
-0.21118298172950745,
0.1332499384880066,
-0.29097944498062134,
-0.3973378837108612,
-0.13354364037513733,
0.7256442904472351,
0.4743397831916809,
0.2769746780395508,
0.06842521578073502,
0.6385018229484558,
-0.5103722810745239,
0.5599731802940369,
0.15971550345420837,
-0.8908398747444153,
0.34285131096839905,
-0.5026243329048157,
-0.057552676647901535,
0.714359700679779,
0.283572256565094,
-0.16988348960876465,
-0.032876480370759964,
-0.2435830533504486,
-0.5963512659072876,
0.3858751952648163,
-0.045706551522016525,
0.3308424949645996,
0.18017032742500305,
0.5259209275245667,
0.46671196818351746,
0.10150717943906784,
-0.7707709670066833,
-0.08683255314826965,
-0.0024020604323595762,
-0.27516114711761475,
-0.30675557255744934,
-0.42050862312316895,
-0.0678761824965477,
-0.5227705240249634,
0.7273910641670227,
-0.44544634222984314,
0.09342996031045914,
-0.20003211498260498,
-0.25155699253082275,
0.03578682988882065,
0.39801904559135437,
0.39277464151382446,
0.7763447165489197,
-0.40916872024536133,
-0.19618597626686096,
0.48316526412963867,
-0.36827388405799866,
0.176722913980484,
-0.25511616468429565,
0.09428820013999939,
-0.5125965476036072,
0.44997578859329224,
0.6377565264701843,
0.546360969543457,
-0.6540997624397278,
0.39248135685920715,
0.23987263441085815,
0.025907229632139206,
-0.37606358528137207,
0.6038957238197327,
0.24307559430599213,
0.3034282624721527,
0.3401038348674774,
0.1412123143672943,
-0.3058788776397705,
-0.7222673296928406,
0.1712421476840973,
0.24006876349449158,
-0.2730039954185486,
-0.057154443114995956,
0.43143993616104126,
0.5564355254173279,
-0.20485122501850128,
0.37952184677124023,
-0.016230231150984764,
-0.4186655879020691,
0.2758640944957733,
0.4343220591545105,
0.6389245986938477,
-0.3629755973815918,
0.06762930005788803,
0.30232998728752136,
0.05201301351189613,
-0.041502054780721664,
0.47840362787246704,
-0.21329569816589355,
-0.827718198299408,
-0.5051057934761047,
-0.9052971005439758,
-0.47036105394363403,
-0.11428757011890411,
-0.8242854475975037,
0.25089532136917114,
-0.47145599126815796,
0.1753646433353424,
-0.4285494089126587,
-0.009584533981978893,
-0.4298083782196045,
0.21626649796962738,
-0.16378454864025116,
0.7592883110046387,
-0.6680875420570374,
0.9560514092445374,
0.4782068431377411,
-0.13880555331707,
-0.24663947522640228,
-0.024762392044067383,
-0.3315322995185852,
-1.0753300189971924,
0.5900545716285706,
-0.015083234757184982,
-0.5280285477638245,
0.3575824797153473,
-0.5543144345283508,
-0.6851627826690674,
1.2779102325439453,
0.5325090885162354,
-0.5258542895317078,
-0.014974881894886494,
-0.10085820406675339,
0.3792298436164856,
-0.4041038155555725,
-0.03277786448597908,
0.36119344830513,
0.43385663628578186,
-0.10711358487606049,
-0.6684122085571289,
-0.3709176182746887,
-0.015334014780819416,
-0.31652840971946716,
0.09250560402870178,
-0.8705544471740723,
0.7143403887748718,
-0.36081042885780334,
0.13849997520446777,
0.2581839859485626,
0.7433300614356995,
0.5452780723571777,
0.2688750624656677,
0.61380535364151,
0.38414132595062256,
0.9231137037277222,
0.07704713940620422,
0.9800036549568176,
-0.39463362097740173,
0.6091345548629761,
1.0647571086883545,
-0.3042028546333313,
1.0690985918045044,
0.4288069009780884,
-0.14351457357406616,
0.6153166890144348,
0.48538294434547424,
0.03718697652220726,
0.40078258514404297,
-0.14409995079040527,
-0.30145031213760376,
-0.7790606617927551,
-0.11684981733560562,
-0.3548014760017395,
0.3332364857196808,
0.5828734636306763,
-0.10451454669237137,
0.028715582564473152,
0.20441985130310059,
-0.06493730843067169,
0.1104089766740799,
-0.4546036124229431,
0.5693564414978027,
0.4150598645210266,
-0.36778512597084045,
0.7321316599845886,
-0.05524272099137306,
0.8104857206344604,
-0.5103862881660461,
0.01488849800080061,
-0.14321811497211456,
0.3231266438961029,
-0.07957462221384048,
-0.7438847422599792,
-0.016926312819123268,
0.07934272289276123,
-0.08683218061923981,
-0.15940219163894653,
0.5725951194763184,
-0.25526002049446106,
-0.6889945864677429,
0.45195749402046204,
0.6078795194625854,
0.041600875556468964,
0.20842602849006653,
-0.866287112236023,
-0.18668532371520996,
-0.16029445827007294,
-0.13365958631038666,
0.19555002450942993,
0.25347915291786194,
-0.06868796795606613,
1.101677656173706,
0.6964775919914246,
0.06779960542917252,
0.12064149230718613,
-0.1727285385131836,
0.8190880417823792,
-0.6792048215866089,
-0.33606037497520447,
-0.6844037771224976,
0.49872732162475586,
0.12585625052452087,
-0.3990584909915924,
0.5727072954177856,
0.43164530396461487,
0.7498680353164673,
-0.06677528470754623,
0.6726288795471191,
0.17486000061035156,
0.3777419924736023,
-1.0306415557861328,
0.7445871829986572,
-0.8473304510116577,
0.22638629376888275,
0.020069295540452003,
-1.1102567911148071,
-0.025977488607168198,
0.4275570511817932,
-0.5893992781639099,
0.3387705087661743,
0.7746341228485107,
0.3758324086666107,
-0.35427775979042053,
-0.1359047144651413,
0.5614436864852905,
0.34258586168289185,
0.1055770143866539,
0.8607254028320312,
0.8704328536987305,
-0.38014212250709534,
0.12815532088279724,
-0.09593284130096436,
-0.1300329566001892,
-0.35948413610458374,
-0.8899081945419312,
-1.0583473443984985,
-0.38596346974372864,
-0.30374494194984436,
-0.023817477747797966,
0.4638524651527405,
0.9368149042129517,
0.5267696380615234,
-0.7683393359184265,
-0.13354860246181488,
0.13421593606472015,
0.10958624631166458,
-0.10736316442489624,
-0.1252337247133255,
0.5291662216186523,
-0.1705717295408249,
-0.7290909886360168,
0.5600487589836121,
0.5251932740211487,
-0.2827702760696411,
-0.2606865167617798,
-0.4720475375652313,
-0.19668510556221008,
0.316983699798584,
0.8456048965454102,
0.05320187285542488,
-0.7895582318305969,
-0.530545175075531,
-0.17739076912403107,
0.08024172484874725,
0.25443655252456665,
0.5833621621131897,
-0.6098043918609619,
0.45424848794937134,
0.12597033381462097,
0.8910002112388611,
0.13288933038711548,
0.16255247592926025,
0.4170258045196533,
-0.2725903391838074,
-0.07933645695447922,
0.2833939790725708,
0.3545722961425781,
0.3556625247001648,
-0.3528006970882416,
0.5905815958976746,
0.3780336380004883,
-0.552039623260498,
-0.5775855183601379,
0.2446044385433197,
-1.233712911605835,
-0.06683295220136642,
1.274517297744751,
-0.28866565227508545,
-0.19529734551906586,
-0.24339699745178223,
-0.17167003452777863,
0.020876402035355568,
-0.4156961441040039,
0.6246122121810913,
0.6863400340080261,
-0.049927033483982086,
-0.06114523112773895,
-0.688209056854248,
-0.07690415531396866,
0.6488178968429565,
-0.8866720199584961,
-0.05850406363606453,
0.36420291662216187,
0.5637076497077942,
-0.11859873682260513,
0.3911415636539459,
-0.07970260828733444,
0.3340211510658264,
-0.5289457440376282,
-0.17899028956890106,
-0.18297378718852997,
-0.3416993021965027,
-0.328428715467453,
-0.0050117261707782745,
0.2161710113286972,
0.03119049407541752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11254v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11254v2 | C-ICL: Contrastive In-context Learning for Information Extraction | 2024-02-17T11:28:08 | 2024-06-24T08:34:56 | Ying Mo, Jiahao Liu, Jian Yang, Qifan Wang, Shun Zhang, Jingang Wang, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | There has been increasing interest in exploring the capabilities of advanced
large language models (LLMs) in the field of information extraction (IE),
specifically focusing on tasks related to named entity recognition (NER) and
relation extraction (RE). Although researchers are exploring the use of
few-shot information extraction through in-context learning with LLMs, they
tend to focus only on using correct or positive examples for demonstration,
neglecting the potential value of incorporating incorrect or negative examples
into the learning process. In this paper, we present c-ICL, a novel few-shot
technique that leverages both correct and incorrect sample constructions to
create in-context learning demonstrations. This approach enhances the ability
of LLMs to extract entities and relations by utilizing prompts that incorporate
not only the positive samples but also the reasoning behind them. This method
allows for the identification and correction of potential interface errors.
Specifically, our proposed method taps into the inherent contextual information
and valuable information in hard negative samples and the nearest positive
neighbors to the test and then applies the in-context learning demonstrations
based on LLMs. Our experiments on various datasets indicate that c-ICL
outperforms previous few-shot in-context learning methods, delivering
substantial enhancements in performance across a broad spectrum of related
tasks. These improvements are noteworthy, showcasing the versatility of our
approach in miscellaneous scenarios. | [
-0.5059816837310791,
-0.9665842056274414,
0.41284382343292236,
-0.1166701391339302,
-0.380747526884079,
0.23378312587738037,
-0.2846374809741974,
-0.5808335542678833,
-0.12505321204662323,
0.14438478648662567,
-0.4904567301273346,
-0.7305549383163452,
-0.25684988498687744,
0.10952391475439072,
-0.3652089834213257,
1.0124926567077637,
0.02734849415719509,
0.2986232340335846,
-0.22464720904827118,
-0.1315523386001587,
-0.2935601472854614,
-0.3436237573623657,
-0.6711686849594116,
-0.4060828983783722,
0.4506416916847229,
0.9472777247428894,
0.0905059427022934,
0.31010428071022034,
0.4622322916984558,
0.1434326469898224,
0.07840821146965027,
0.24649371206760406,
-0.5821403861045837,
-0.07438300549983978,
-0.2573949992656708,
-0.36473286151885986,
0.09364745020866394,
-0.06311477720737457,
0.668272852897644,
0.6358952522277832,
0.1551995426416397,
0.20779535174369812,
0.5801392793655396,
0.3596809506416321,
-0.7924062013626099,
0.19648927450180054,
-0.9735575914382935,
0.015841830521821976,
-0.3461616337299347,
-0.3586081266403198,
-0.583197832107544,
-0.13454921543598175,
0.18323004245758057,
-0.6135169863700867,
0.04857668653130531,
0.0921032577753067,
0.9364395141601562,
0.13615983724594116,
-0.4153807759284973,
-0.47868284583091736,
-0.4530889391899109,
0.9406819939613342,
-0.8638046383857727,
0.3511729836463928,
0.20023652911186218,
0.4704122543334961,
-0.13135726749897003,
-0.6888808608055115,
-0.7504569292068481,
-0.3633071184158325,
-0.32192161679267883,
0.10233502089977264,
0.1298842579126358,
-0.04409762844443321,
0.4593621790409088,
-0.0024896026588976383,
-0.13558252155780792,
0.3522087037563324,
-0.2655022442340851,
-0.026297368109226227,
0.2682790756225586,
0.1519300937652588,
0.20018397271633148,
-0.01119135320186615,
-0.5261288285255432,
-0.03572501987218857,
-1.2733421325683594,
0.19455215334892273,
0.06439570337533951,
0.6160790920257568,
-0.4353317320346832,
0.5403673052787781,
-0.12305235117673874,
0.502960741519928,
0.2892795205116272,
-0.3701622486114502,
0.18987306952476501,
0.02199537120759487,
-0.2741653025150299,
0.18855854868888855,
0.49327030777931213,
0.28737396001815796,
-0.1728106141090393,
-0.13211023807525635,
-0.06405662000179291,
-0.15515156090259552,
-0.26274484395980835,
-0.9253799319267273,
-0.15322145819664001,
0.02943301573395729,
-0.5013957023620605,
-0.08147459477186203,
0.0325838066637516,
-0.8662571310997009,
-0.2320997416973114,
-0.4639733135700226,
0.3438475728034973,
-0.4313235282897949,
0.05353321507573128,
-0.45494982600212097,
-0.07294289767742157,
0.553552508354187,
0.4435475468635559,
-0.4442998766899109,
0.4680419862270355,
0.4368251860141754,
0.6199169158935547,
-0.6142191886901855,
-0.16993223130702972,
-0.9642598628997803,
0.16677530109882355,
-0.20477472245693207,
0.786744236946106,
-0.5388135313987732,
-0.273933082818985,
-0.0019566703122109175,
-0.26135891675949097,
0.16789796948432922,
-0.8979485630989075,
0.29519131779670715,
-0.5346198678016663,
0.019956497475504875,
-0.23030641674995422,
-0.6698490381240845,
-0.07071416825056076,
0.5856659412384033,
-0.35524529218673706,
0.8240280151367188,
0.07944223284721375,
-0.8494967222213745,
0.3960872292518616,
-0.6431422829627991,
-0.28609606623649597,
0.2896603047847748,
-0.7183570265769958,
-0.4734119772911072,
-0.38520511984825134,
-0.028625458478927612,
0.5439661741256714,
-0.21175004541873932,
-0.048497557640075684,
-0.6431755423545837,
-0.653197169303894,
0.30596277117729187,
-0.328981876373291,
0.8798185586929321,
0.18532416224479675,
-0.5964949727058411,
-0.17886990308761597,
-0.8714432716369629,
-0.09345432370901108,
-0.08223618566989899,
-0.4492338001728058,
-0.42314672470092773,
-0.11102388799190521,
-0.09198018908500671,
0.5290866494178772,
-0.08010432869195938,
-0.5919730067253113,
0.09786508232355118,
-0.550571084022522,
-0.08184272795915604,
0.4511254131793976,
0.27738797664642334,
0.4835653007030487,
-0.16378355026245117,
0.4725608229637146,
0.4533989727497101,
-0.14506493508815765,
-0.187872976064682,
0.07155706733465195,
-0.7732508778572083,
-0.4163641333580017,
0.1404380351305008,
0.6654087901115417,
-1.2011220455169678,
0.06007911637425423,
0.0655190497636795,
-0.23205244541168213,
-0.22118741273880005,
0.29132264852523804,
0.6033530831336975,
1.1738966703414917,
0.5558096766471863,
-0.060496848076581955,
-0.4928980767726898,
-0.8556306958198547,
-0.20647485554218292,
-0.047325413674116135,
0.16018278896808624,
0.6763707399368286,
0.3631795644760132,
0.05057046189904213,
0.9840162992477417,
-0.4332197904586792,
-0.19262297451496124,
-0.32279151678085327,
0.12287205457687378,
0.2651587128639221,
0.4125407636165619,
0.3990805745124817,
-0.8563691973686218,
-0.7375211715698242,
-0.0587628111243248,
-0.7546489238739014,
-0.056092921644449234,
-0.2650648355484009,
0.06788717210292816,
-0.052387580275535583,
0.7808179259300232,
-0.2970241606235504,
0.4097263813018799,
0.07995069026947021,
0.06290183216333389,
0.6425147652626038,
0.1901460438966751,
0.026067055761814117,
-0.8928717970848083,
-0.10000908374786377,
0.2583725154399872,
-0.1997479647397995,
-0.4876154065132141,
0.21567082405090332,
0.27281108498573303,
0.07095177471637726,
-1.1050679683685303,
0.8098843693733215,
-0.6000639200210571,
-0.013730584643781185,
-0.19485440850257874,
0.3160276412963867,
-0.17944280803203583,
0.46389567852020264,
-0.03788220137357712,
0.7601292133331299,
0.6540286540985107,
-0.8722107410430908,
-0.06530177593231201,
0.14837931096553802,
-0.1981569528579712,
0.7314190864562988,
-0.043627817183732986,
0.16985484957695007,
-0.20145663619041443,
0.1493377387523651,
-0.8961016535758972,
-0.16448047757148743,
0.47609591484069824,
-0.16863663494586945,
0.5479411482810974,
-0.16544459760189056,
-0.3395831882953644,
0.10580804944038391,
-0.3958798348903656,
0.47273239493370056,
0.20770737528800964,
-1.0581016540527344,
0.37542906403541565,
0.1924232393503189,
-0.05255381762981415,
-0.78972989320755,
-0.7789437174797058,
0.03275027498602867,
-0.529604971408844,
-0.002990898909047246,
0.5757129192352295,
-0.38156068325042725,
-0.593165934085846,
-0.14737774431705475,
0.029569566249847412,
-0.3705196976661682,
0.29446229338645935,
0.17258533835411072,
0.4210411012172699,
-0.26237815618515015,
0.22761954367160797,
0.07176509499549866,
0.09441741555929184,
-0.2104923576116562,
0.13669686019420624,
0.19776812195777893,
-0.12600275874137878,
-0.48671817779541016,
-0.5993955731391907,
0.3536510765552521,
0.024555375799536705,
0.13847637176513672,
0.38696157932281494,
0.357766717672348,
-0.6115514039993286,
-0.3482610285282135,
-0.4283096492290497,
-0.2865525484085083,
-0.4118480682373047,
0.21940141916275024,
-0.47041210532188416,
-0.7243553400039673,
0.2704247832298279,
-0.3636496067047119,
0.017669886350631714,
0.21490293741226196,
0.15225034952163696,
-0.3459325432777405,
0.8124062418937683,
0.6127724051475525,
-0.09200401604175568,
0.6041911840438843,
-0.36164167523384094,
0.2363535761833191,
-0.8783336281776428,
-0.14188149571418762,
-0.5639253258705139,
-0.08102519065141678,
-0.3976357877254486,
-0.005203929729759693,
0.41837623715400696,
0.4435250759124756,
-0.29777029156684875,
0.10500319302082062,
-0.04928262159228325,
0.6869784593582153,
0.29890570044517517,
0.44223618507385254,
0.2754098176956177,
-0.010894594714045525,
-0.33682727813720703,
-0.20492668449878693,
-0.48152798414230347,
-0.6196194291114807,
0.7711407542228699,
-0.0032456321641802788,
0.7230623960494995,
0.1223345473408699,
1.0715301036834717,
0.05265846103429794,
0.8290831446647644,
-0.9033381938934326,
0.47461915016174316,
-0.2153349667787552,
-0.25232356786727905,
-0.1371995359659195,
-0.14759917557239532,
-0.6278504729270935,
0.22520692646503448,
-0.468572735786438,
-0.8943115472793579,
0.33975255489349365,
0.40226420760154724,
-0.3973686695098877,
0.21114927530288696,
-0.7413192987442017,
0.6136802434921265,
-0.17128275334835052,
-0.5724101662635803,
-0.07150419801473618,
-0.8196201920509338,
0.4796313941478729,
0.10199901461601257,
0.2505938410758972,
0.20979580283164978,
-0.07254660874605179,
0.23381143808364868,
-0.04827837646007538,
0.9945208430290222,
-0.17396441102027893,
0.15200279653072357,
0.3422309160232544,
0.25407159328460693,
0.6158261299133301,
0.07719286531209946,
-0.27926021814346313,
-0.07235021889209747,
-0.25641024112701416,
-0.20561128854751587,
-0.5815986394882202,
0.7117083668708801,
-0.3738561272621155,
-0.4312135875225067,
-0.13397231698036194,
-0.20321503281593323,
-0.18803346157073975,
0.18745394051074982,
0.3383411467075348,
0.6465975642204285,
-0.2577399015426636,
0.349331796169281,
0.5326123237609863,
-0.2730441093444824,
0.7253729701042175,
0.43755629658699036,
0.1435898095369339,
-0.24632172286510468,
0.8053150177001953,
-0.12459961324930191,
0.28727006912231445,
0.6871011853218079,
0.12405544519424438,
-0.24784697592258453,
-0.7352154850959778,
-0.2514914870262146,
0.0397912971675396,
-1.1405694484710693,
-0.427101194858551,
-0.577052891254425,
-0.163832426071167,
-0.15330031514167786,
-0.28288978338241577,
-0.033339109271764755,
-0.19417959451675415,
-0.7583849430084229,
-0.038914646953344345,
-0.39140722155570984,
0.3348549008369446,
0.17348633706569672,
0.29794979095458984,
-0.6482139229774475,
0.36879274249076843,
0.1565466672182083,
-0.1153445690870285,
-0.03199150040745735,
-0.31278133392333984,
-0.21727865934371948,
-0.1479550451040268,
-0.6013908386230469,
-0.968300998210907,
0.35961565375328064,
0.3695462644100189,
0.7742979526519775,
0.5071314573287964,
-0.022766439244151115,
0.8838847875595093,
-0.3031277060508728,
0.9274039268493652,
0.2345753312110901,
-0.845283031463623,
0.4724799394607544,
0.05318007990717888,
0.16186559200286865,
0.8404030203819275,
0.47852984070777893,
-0.2035263329744339,
-0.3401532769203186,
-0.808273434638977,
-0.7564782500267029,
0.5890403389930725,
-0.11324277520179749,
-0.14978475868701935,
-0.2609536647796631,
0.5388791561126709,
0.2686670124530792,
0.05875345692038536,
-1.0425398349761963,
-0.360630065202713,
0.09258866310119629,
-0.39809080958366394,
0.14736054837703705,
-0.13038785755634308,
0.02013299986720085,
-0.013219790533185005,
0.8898928761482239,
-0.5476546883583069,
-0.1846640408039093,
0.3789008557796478,
-0.5855478048324585,
0.137192502617836,
0.5344592928886414,
0.4391545355319977,
0.7737360000610352,
-0.10977914929389954,
0.46926602721214294,
0.64842289686203,
0.07148270308971405,
-0.02757198177278042,
0.09675748646259308,
-0.2965747117996216,
-0.10490760952234268,
0.3957234025001526,
0.39124584197998047,
0.370440810918808,
-0.7922291159629822,
0.7858494520187378,
0.005523398984223604,
0.15035654604434967,
-0.41275012493133545,
-0.0341593399643898,
-0.1089717298746109,
0.4347686767578125,
0.4445143938064575,
-0.08361107110977173,
0.5205406546592712,
-0.617202639579773,
0.42737555503845215,
0.5306010246276855,
-0.5521166324615479,
-0.096812404692173,
0.22610147297382355,
0.02661435306072235,
-0.3672688901424408,
0.630285382270813,
-0.4597768783569336,
-0.2531314194202423,
0.7228844165802002,
0.8802945017814636,
0.7575424313545227,
0.12872879207134247,
0.03286740556359291,
0.6175721287727356,
-0.12061715126037598,
0.2492993026971817,
0.056636445224285126,
-0.37179383635520935,
-0.83256596326828,
-0.14722135663032532,
-0.09411071240901947,
-0.4881870448589325,
0.249264657497406,
-0.6199110150337219,
0.71831214427948,
-0.4099419414997101,
0.29641133546829224,
-0.001421469496563077,
0.030114196240901947,
-0.9019119143486023,
0.23218876123428345,
0.19879619777202606,
0.9898326396942139,
-0.6907263398170471,
0.9586102366447449,
0.47207948565483093,
-0.43707600235939026,
-0.7484997510910034,
0.3200882077217102,
0.25902259349823,
-0.4418502151966095,
1.1425164937973022,
0.29713231325149536,
-0.32780706882476807,
-0.012048306874930859,
-0.924106240272522,
-0.48631909489631653,
1.1806620359420776,
0.49985983967781067,
-0.8337060809135437,
0.12484347820281982,
-0.2846434414386749,
0.37089961767196655,
-0.8445705771446228,
0.48539358377456665,
0.36803674697875977,
0.17966219782829285,
0.08440589904785156,
-0.4622287452220917,
0.027396131306886673,
0.06728778779506683,
-0.3364922106266022,
-0.09627737104892731,
-0.5399091839790344,
0.626002848148346,
-0.320247083902359,
-0.43980610370635986,
0.0789717510342598,
0.6359962821006775,
0.6317607164382935,
0.5363853573799133,
0.7039177417755127,
0.16486172378063202,
0.6392800211906433,
0.23403269052505493,
0.8622913360595703,
-0.0043454221449792385,
0.2551756203174591,
1.6454559564590454,
-0.5202221274375916,
0.9687148928642273,
0.8002459406852722,
0.10754366219043732,
0.564529538154602,
0.6812887787818909,
0.2086644470691681,
0.634905993938446,
0.2511099874973297,
-0.5455033183097839,
-0.2019103765487671,
-0.2481697052717209,
0.10968856513500214,
0.416517436504364,
0.5579073429107666,
-0.22389660775661469,
-0.5430657863616943,
0.017711792141199112,
-0.17667467892169952,
0.17957495152950287,
-0.16015119850635529,
0.9820090532302856,
0.2539050877094269,
-0.571166455745697,
0.371198832988739,
-0.3101116120815277,
0.7423739433288574,
-0.3364250361919403,
-0.8052207827568054,
-0.09924464672803879,
0.05640549212694168,
-0.24413372576236725,
-0.5758163332939148,
0.14115098118782043,
-0.05481569841504097,
0.04969232529401779,
0.020347412675619125,
0.8202459216117859,
-0.6038707494735718,
-0.07552964985370636,
0.4314272999763489,
0.27586784958839417,
0.37863093614578247,
0.23766925930976868,
-0.8481875658035278,
-0.27054670453071594,
-0.012097788974642754,
0.22108452022075653,
0.2860170006752014,
0.21205191314220428,
-0.055259522050619125,
0.5039483308792114,
0.3401332497596741,
0.07830444723367691,
-0.12941953539848328,
0.15657243132591248,
0.8882117867469788,
-0.7217527031898499,
-0.40426746010780334,
-0.9969748854637146,
0.6728634238243103,
-0.3277326226234436,
-0.29828956723213196,
0.48353278636932373,
0.8048759698867798,
1.1240850687026978,
0.08489824831485748,
0.8494259119033813,
0.0720091164112091,
0.6600207686424255,
-0.7837811708450317,
0.08673226088285446,
-0.4443177580833435,
0.5325677990913391,
-0.2992960512638092,
-0.8193331360816956,
-0.5213488340377808,
0.25226297974586487,
-0.0652647539973259,
-0.23829154670238495,
0.9537892937660217,
1.028724193572998,
-0.30299434065818787,
-0.3196490705013275,
0.4342241585254669,
0.2513696253299713,
0.5535739660263062,
0.5483778715133667,
0.9425551295280457,
-0.39566248655319214,
0.639866828918457,
-0.5086913704872131,
-0.23118358850479126,
-0.17523856461048126,
-1.192440152168274,
-0.7925899028778076,
-0.4483741223812103,
-0.4872177839279175,
-0.2822754979133606,
0.033780332654714584,
1.341760516166687,
0.7592203617095947,
-0.8330914974212646,
-0.16186192631721497,
0.024915844202041626,
0.35966524481773376,
-0.1121031641960144,
-0.2849281430244446,
0.3807066082954407,
-0.47720855474472046,
-0.6590740084648132,
0.6880108118057251,
0.36198973655700684,
0.13190288841724396,
0.03787684068083763,
-0.10522985458374023,
-0.31939712166786194,
-0.3138527274131775,
0.5404137372970581,
0.42328664660453796,
-0.7296860814094543,
-0.459762305021286,
-0.35879185795783997,
-0.12669600546360016,
0.4434707462787628,
0.8303775787353516,
-0.791702926158905,
0.33782848715782166,
0.3925246000289917,
0.7248751521110535,
0.6809954047203064,
-0.025202559307217598,
0.1358715444803238,
-0.9392733573913574,
0.16522878408432007,
0.2297280728816986,
0.43043282628059387,
0.5778943300247192,
-0.6167474389076233,
0.2646922767162323,
0.05189864709973335,
-0.25105521082878113,
-0.5632091164588928,
0.3064708709716797,
-1.0511411428451538,
-0.356854647397995,
1.2304632663726807,
-0.34302616119384766,
-0.11825317144393921,
-0.16383536159992218,
-0.37182626128196716,
0.3379453718662262,
-0.281735360622406,
0.7586875557899475,
0.5065699815750122,
-0.39779502153396606,
-0.2909410893917084,
-0.35829809308052063,
0.40575239062309265,
0.020545773208141327,
-1.080226182937622,
-0.3427089750766754,
0.4931142032146454,
0.4765789210796356,
-0.028741300106048584,
0.5559238791465759,
-0.1826944500207901,
0.3008251488208771,
-0.34487247467041016,
-0.02402285300195217,
0.253009170293808,
-0.2989998161792755,
-0.5712507963180542,
0.2253836989402771,
0.3480287790298462,
-0.17146465182304382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11253v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11253v3 | Aligning Large Language Models by On-Policy Self-Judgment | 2024-02-17T11:25:26 | 2024-06-25T13:39:52 | Sangkyu Lee, Sungdong Kim, Ashkan Yousefpour, Minjoon Seo, Kang Min Yoo, Youngjae Yu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Existing approaches for aligning large language models with human preferences
face a trade-off that requires a separate reward model (RM) for on-policy
learning. In this paper, we present a novel alignment framework, SELF-JUDGE
that (1) does on-policy learning and 2) is parameter efficient, as it does not
require an additional RM for evaluating the samples for on-policy learning. To
this end, we propose Judge-augmented Supervised Fine-Tuning (JSFT) to train a
single model to act as both a policy and a judge. Specifically, we view the
pairwise judgment task, choosing the better response from a response pair, as a
special case of the instruction-following task. The resulting model can judge
preferences of on-the-fly responses from current policy initialized from
itself. Experimental results show the efficacy of SELF-JUDGE, outperforming
baselines in preference benchmarks. We also show that the rejecting sampling by
itself can improve performance further without an additional evaluator. | [
-0.4014124870300293,
-0.386940598487854,
0.5819888114929199,
0.10941935330629349,
0.12934088706970215,
-0.17411606013774872,
-0.6071627736091614,
-0.011451257392764091,
0.2706861197948456,
0.6507327556610107,
-0.5030767917633057,
-0.03630726784467697,
-0.5007390975952148,
-0.28780823945999146,
-0.009503571316599846,
1.2028958797454834,
0.12906377017498016,
0.040585048496723175,
-0.23873083293437958,
-0.21963746845722198,
-0.47615846991539,
-0.23193903267383575,
-0.656497597694397,
-0.4412042200565338,
0.5459583401679993,
0.6115967631340027,
0.8905507922172546,
0.8734764456748962,
0.2913077175617218,
0.37632957100868225,
0.14278951287269592,
0.17380017042160034,
-0.2644076645374298,
-0.01815548911690712,
-0.7537912726402283,
-0.201955646276474,
-0.45336633920669556,
0.11365147680044174,
0.4387471079826355,
0.5608075261116028,
-0.32533565163612366,
-0.047454651445150375,
0.12314445525407791,
0.6564763188362122,
-0.698838472366333,
0.018176782876253128,
-0.5166926383972168,
-0.1107594296336174,
0.09053417295217514,
-0.09194488078355789,
-0.4421815872192383,
-0.28312331438064575,
0.28459224104881287,
-0.6991045475006104,
-0.06624718010425568,
0.12952367961406708,
0.8425808548927307,
0.5112519860267639,
-0.5345802307128906,
0.025275833904743195,
-0.3272247910499573,
0.9424365162849426,
-0.634670615196228,
0.4561675190925598,
0.5573219656944275,
0.35813596844673157,
-0.05618641898036003,
-0.29764294624328613,
-0.509200930595398,
-0.24832600355148315,
-0.3576066493988037,
0.1474694311618805,
0.14838062226772308,
0.23846150934696198,
-0.04717348515987396,
0.19928327202796936,
-0.5534952282905579,
0.5416145324707031,
0.03604783117771149,
-0.1295263171195984,
0.6942390203475952,
-0.07976355403661728,
-0.0002436158829368651,
-0.18377481400966644,
-0.48225921392440796,
-0.33515316247940063,
-0.4224492013454437,
0.15369288623332977,
0.598786473274231,
0.7334893345832825,
-0.050104882568120956,
0.4033435881137848,
-0.6573600172996521,
0.8602885007858276,
0.5793467164039612,
0.12733498215675354,
0.21717588603496552,
0.047960273921489716,
-0.221358984708786,
0.2462610900402069,
0.8438538312911987,
0.42118188738822937,
0.1894262135028839,
-0.17608685791492462,
-0.37616413831710815,
0.0952356606721878,
0.5347396731376648,
-0.6740047335624695,
-0.2936745285987854,
0.03699897229671478,
-0.3848012387752533,
-0.46170774102211,
-0.1088370755314827,
-0.72335284948349,
-0.40263834595680237,
-0.6748648881912231,
0.6222716569900513,
0.06719952076673508,
-0.1728001981973648,
0.2473634034395218,
0.09123880416154861,
0.1490606963634491,
0.3562832176685333,
-1.4907375574111938,
0.28102150559425354,
0.8094881176948547,
0.43495336174964905,
-0.23747952282428741,
-0.46323853731155396,
-0.828760027885437,
0.04725979268550873,
-0.30556929111480713,
0.7418200969696045,
-0.6341190338134766,
-0.11582344770431519,
-0.1354464739561081,
-0.008473364636301994,
0.08312967419624329,
-0.2782151699066162,
0.3748086392879486,
-0.45303574204444885,
0.3111953139305115,
-0.4256739616394043,
-0.5447231531143188,
0.06885841488838196,
0.41283151507377625,
-0.5748112201690674,
0.9336579442024231,
0.168625146150589,
-0.4983963668346405,
0.6871967315673828,
-0.5536386370658875,
-0.42348042130470276,
-0.1645977795124054,
-0.4305410385131836,
-0.32822170853614807,
0.010432957671582699,
0.5310822129249573,
0.48549678921699524,
-0.13968554139137268,
0.5363941192626953,
-0.5658729076385498,
-0.2419746369123459,
-0.10515383630990982,
-0.44793233275413513,
0.5669753551483154,
0.29475975036621094,
-0.43472030758857727,
0.24734990298748016,
-0.6923977732658386,
0.17767612636089325,
-0.008373023942112923,
-0.4735887348651886,
-0.4093405604362488,
0.09274802356958389,
-0.1475769281387329,
0.21947069466114044,
0.4516991078853607,
-0.5698876976966858,
0.5638144612312317,
-0.6299698948860168,
0.22064630687236786,
1.1481058597564697,
-0.4022388160228729,
0.7272566556930542,
-0.2123916894197464,
0.2992495596408844,
-0.42211270332336426,
0.1678299605846405,
0.032833460718393326,
0.08225502073764801,
-0.776542603969574,
-0.08832522481679916,
0.6087948679924011,
0.29341545701026917,
-0.3859763443470001,
0.6404930949211121,
-0.30323803424835205,
-0.27264347672462463,
-0.8478788137435913,
0.18157340586185455,
0.7244065403938293,
0.3937840163707733,
0.48931577801704407,
-0.3772590756416321,
-0.24146968126296997,
-0.9318574666976929,
-0.5348137021064758,
-0.14997299015522003,
0.22371742129325867,
0.19919757544994354,
0.09673784673213959,
0.08998572826385498,
1.1173168420791626,
-0.49105507135391235,
-0.15025797486305237,
0.015915915369987488,
-0.0050698514096438885,
0.03167310357093811,
0.8044571280479431,
0.5208578109741211,
-0.6535446643829346,
-0.5179247260093689,
0.30898863077163696,
-0.42216071486473083,
-0.10511565208435059,
-0.11354193836450577,
-0.1669708788394928,
0.20923615992069244,
0.371852308511734,
-0.16173943877220154,
0.15175822377204895,
0.5846145153045654,
-0.4961545765399933,
0.3241913616657257,
-0.36947762966156006,
0.37141600251197815,
-0.8046107292175293,
-0.13268356025218964,
0.0949295237660408,
-0.535226047039032,
-0.3817952573299408,
0.22759340703487396,
0.2028689682483673,
0.4086843430995941,
-0.17384913563728333,
0.7426083087921143,
-0.18544067442417145,
-0.08643129467964172,
-0.5935545563697815,
0.013768555596470833,
0.1383618265390396,
0.7946199178695679,
0.1066175326704979,
0.7677534818649292,
0.24785159528255463,
-0.5065182447433472,
0.2200162410736084,
0.37022507190704346,
-0.4049251973628998,
0.7818153500556946,
-0.42855286598205566,
0.12296794354915619,
-0.0801556184887886,
0.1133350133895874,
-0.8710272312164307,
-0.303897887468338,
0.04735583811998367,
-0.1833450347185135,
0.45945510268211365,
-0.38975176215171814,
-0.333329975605011,
-0.2849147617816925,
-0.10924442857503891,
0.1775372326374054,
0.18241168558597565,
-1.1248669624328613,
0.5378414988517761,
0.34577205777168274,
0.02694043144583702,
-0.7557995915412903,
-0.6525514721870422,
-0.371506929397583,
-0.1470567137002945,
-0.1518176645040512,
0.4675843119621277,
0.049772802740335464,
-0.046895407140254974,
-0.010471897199749947,
-0.26247233152389526,
0.16257613897323608,
0.25334790349006653,
0.07009360194206238,
0.23774906992912292,
0.028842849656939507,
0.314814031124115,
0.313924640417099,
-0.17316366732120514,
-0.15970343351364136,
-0.315805584192276,
0.5113288164138794,
-0.31476113200187683,
-0.49116870760917664,
-0.4244310259819031,
0.12618035078048706,
0.25166192650794983,
-0.4397745132446289,
0.4689721465110779,
0.19288788735866547,
0.058523211628198624,
-0.09120815247297287,
-0.6299915909767151,
-0.2133425921201706,
-0.5530498027801514,
0.17575187981128693,
-0.5203406810760498,
-0.9402908682823181,
-0.018543878570199013,
-0.03420012444257736,
0.1605398803949356,
0.4335978329181671,
0.5658738017082214,
-0.03221472352743149,
1.2845969200134277,
0.4726291596889496,
-0.43577367067337036,
0.7239058017730713,
0.058263037353754044,
0.24887917935848236,
-0.5388268828392029,
0.05994998663663864,
-0.5063784718513489,
-0.3213004469871521,
-0.7726612687110901,
0.12101343274116516,
0.18754887580871582,
-0.04281320795416832,
-0.7853401303291321,
0.3951570689678192,
-0.6303780674934387,
0.6639994978904724,
0.8337846994400024,
0.15068814158439636,
0.133836567401886,
-0.2409389168024063,
-0.23222999274730682,
0.16364192962646484,
-0.5331222414970398,
-0.3480890989303589,
1.1062555313110352,
0.16858938336372375,
0.8675944209098816,
0.05245823785662651,
0.8025087118148804,
0.2480362355709076,
0.043323490768671036,
-0.5442441701889038,
0.3629029393196106,
-0.3413945734500885,
-0.5386397838592529,
-0.4795841574668884,
-0.41167929768562317,
-0.8288217186927795,
0.5121002793312073,
-0.37070611119270325,
-0.8268693089485168,
0.10701369494199753,
0.6311401128768921,
-0.684786856174469,
0.18444769084453583,
-0.8468232750892639,
1.2748439311981201,
-0.6629687547683716,
-0.5404521226882935,
-0.3833716809749603,
-0.75957190990448,
0.1511448621749878,
0.16609615087509155,
0.18324288725852966,
-0.18467915058135986,
0.361183226108551,
0.5239595174789429,
-0.35032448172569275,
0.6818037629127502,
-0.4118999242782593,
0.0210479274392128,
-0.0803028866648674,
0.06715963780879974,
0.5312454700469971,
-0.14682111144065857,
-0.13390956819057465,
-0.2713869512081146,
0.17124725878238678,
-0.3916458487510681,
-0.7661652565002441,
1.0368205308914185,
-0.787357747554779,
-0.7792233824729919,
-0.3805385231971741,
-0.4999041259288788,
-0.5360724329948425,
0.2207210659980774,
-0.21745525300502777,
0.2991141080856323,
-0.15378746390342712,
-0.052581895142793655,
0.3651500344276428,
-0.08025328814983368,
0.23559604585170746,
0.6410357356071472,
-0.6523556113243103,
-0.35488373041152954,
1.124061942100525,
-0.09317992627620697,
0.544152557849884,
0.45698848366737366,
0.6357677578926086,
-0.4244407117366791,
0.012857622466981411,
-0.7073049545288086,
-0.029672609642148018,
-0.45028069615364075,
-0.20289210975170135,
-0.4445045590400696,
0.17548266053199768,
-0.5883938670158386,
-0.3400946855545044,
-0.6650872230529785,
-0.4923431873321533,
-0.09115176647901535,
-0.06800655275583267,
0.3389173150062561,
0.4699481427669525,
-0.10775457322597504,
0.6590584516525269,
-0.4004040062427521,
0.09245055913925171,
0.6185309886932373,
0.6211987733840942,
-0.07492025196552277,
-0.6076993346214294,
-0.14974185824394226,
0.021342827007174492,
-0.37680649757385254,
-0.31868618726730347,
0.1456870287656784,
-0.027274038642644882,
0.48650750517845154,
0.6908305883407593,
0.11024512350559235,
0.9415290355682373,
-0.4658131003379822,
0.51261305809021,
0.21218369901180267,
-0.9029952883720398,
0.6236391663551331,
-0.24096164107322693,
0.24641606211662292,
0.9916178584098816,
0.18274712562561035,
-0.48481789231300354,
-0.22860205173492432,
-0.4799538850784302,
-0.556688129901886,
0.9169038534164429,
-0.32712480425834656,
0.13218022882938385,
0.002777076791971922,
0.2435913383960724,
0.14354534447193146,
0.2681247293949127,
-0.5795431733131409,
-0.09387847781181335,
-0.2310764491558075,
-0.3907422721385956,
-0.11354053765535355,
0.22848014533519745,
-0.08632460236549377,
-0.43588531017303467,
0.8431529998779297,
-0.5701032876968384,
-0.05465726926922798,
-0.14398197829723358,
0.019893649965524673,
-0.08422492444515228,
0.4445227384567261,
0.07373068481683731,
0.20275160670280457,
-0.15730798244476318,
0.12737390398979187,
0.05352681130170822,
0.3748265206813812,
0.20183344185352325,
0.200841024518013,
-0.14232969284057617,
-0.7331598997116089,
-0.08430199325084686,
1.0623679161071777,
0.5622367262840271,
-0.5734469890594482,
0.824069082736969,
0.09237459301948547,
-0.14395715296268463,
0.1505759060382843,
0.32122424244880676,
-0.16283626854419708,
0.41988420486450195,
-0.24031738936901093,
0.13568289577960968,
0.19091291725635529,
-0.47964537143707275,
0.1631622016429901,
0.7248436808586121,
-0.5425837635993958,
-0.025802839547395706,
0.7551369071006775,
0.038384512066841125,
-0.05230111628770828,
0.29727962613105774,
-0.40484586358070374,
-0.6030323505401611,
0.3002344071865082,
0.624553382396698,
0.5613083839416504,
-0.2756405472755432,
0.25718992948532104,
0.2691976726055145,
-0.014612340368330479,
-0.4406490921974182,
0.13536863029003143,
-0.32315778732299805,
-0.9783857464790344,
-0.4134673774242401,
-0.784696102142334,
-0.42175865173339844,
-0.17080077528953552,
-0.8196324706077576,
0.14224697649478912,
-0.5000684261322021,
-0.04261808469891548,
0.1598759889602661,
0.006823318544775248,
-0.6922450065612793,
0.2862357497215271,
-0.013564841821789742,
0.549532413482666,
-0.9056137800216675,
0.9558586478233337,
0.5829409956932068,
-0.31648725271224976,
-0.9990742206573486,
0.00481044314801693,
0.12540200352668762,
-0.9026652574539185,
0.3336969316005707,
0.2350989729166031,
-0.1168440654873848,
0.07875819504261017,
-0.41435614228248596,
-0.9769232273101807,
0.636538565158844,
0.3789629340171814,
-0.7600529789924622,
-0.05193557217717171,
-0.3489130139350891,
0.44171154499053955,
-0.1579476296901703,
0.3174149692058563,
0.8928275108337402,
0.6019042730331421,
-0.0966334119439125,
-1.0281838178634644,
-0.08687906712293625,
0.12370547652244568,
-0.03599890321493149,
0.5692081451416016,
-0.9494194388389587,
0.4973140060901642,
-0.03978538140654564,
0.13233841955661774,
-0.0376727357506752,
0.7501918077468872,
-0.08541053533554077,
0.028834355995059013,
0.8745499849319458,
0.8179887533187866,
0.5614234209060669,
0.06157867982983589,
0.9668529629707336,
-0.22845114767551422,
0.5056987404823303,
1.5757571458816528,
-0.3559425473213196,
0.8719731569290161,
0.5442114472389221,
-0.26644665002822876,
0.5302987694740295,
0.4170672595500946,
0.011599437333643436,
0.8289716243743896,
-0.028916459530591965,
-0.001350439852103591,
-0.6393433213233948,
-0.0919574424624443,
0.01376437023282051,
0.7833070158958435,
-0.007738485001027584,
-0.18327265977859497,
-0.23685231804847717,
0.10342191904783249,
-0.08166402578353882,
0.5532184839248657,
-0.5454702973365784,
0.8504320979118347,
-0.34304192662239075,
-1.3824851512908936,
0.23915648460388184,
0.19029615819454193,
0.6488814949989319,
-0.4529150128364563,
0.14684025943279266,
0.05322076752781868,
0.3555772006511688,
-0.18232156336307526,
-0.8421295285224915,
0.0909419134259224,
-0.16778087615966797,
-0.1586972028017044,
-0.45982643961906433,
0.4496239125728607,
-0.6940836310386658,
-0.2394438087940216,
0.35456863045692444,
0.21627573668956757,
-0.12257017940282822,
0.059980761259794235,
-0.701995313167572,
-0.1871921718120575,
0.016970288008451462,
-0.35299184918403625,
0.5356348752975464,
0.05830077454447746,
-0.2421496957540512,
0.3463524281978607,
0.4493696987628937,
-0.09912657737731934,
-0.12700073421001434,
0.2089148461818695,
0.7460441589355469,
-0.5568250417709351,
-0.8016221523284912,
-0.7683865427970886,
0.22570717334747314,
-0.11199121177196503,
-0.3625381886959076,
0.4430462419986725,
0.5118998885154724,
1.2140438556671143,
0.23002560436725616,
0.7451319694519043,
-0.08597800135612488,
0.6784942746162415,
-0.5798373222351074,
0.5981177091598511,
-0.7850534319877625,
0.016299225389957428,
-0.131003275513649,
-0.520072340965271,
-0.08706418424844742,
0.7977260947227478,
-0.5739406943321228,
0.048522308468818665,
0.28013715147972107,
0.8566297292709351,
-0.234188050031662,
0.07455620169639587,
0.26191288232803345,
-0.09500090777873993,
0.25464990735054016,
0.3686066269874573,
0.48494765162467957,
-0.09067722409963608,
0.13326190412044525,
-0.34184229373931885,
-0.22080165147781372,
-0.26349958777427673,
-0.6338743567466736,
-0.8341907262802124,
-0.4567621648311615,
-0.04428809881210327,
-0.2639496624469757,
0.06296010315418243,
1.673021674156189,
0.755134105682373,
-0.8848975896835327,
-0.12373752146959305,
-0.07347982376813889,
-0.006104601547122002,
-0.5074931979179382,
-0.1648934781551361,
0.4577397406101227,
-0.722682774066925,
-0.8698728084564209,
0.620141863822937,
0.22579698264598846,
-0.1985427439212799,
-0.24769015610218048,
-0.38201630115509033,
-0.28641098737716675,
-0.0018110144883394241,
0.3362021744251251,
0.3908977210521698,
-0.9155186414718628,
-0.6546325087547302,
-0.45777034759521484,
-0.2638970613479614,
0.1936473399400711,
0.6970027685165405,
-0.9018229842185974,
0.7961537837982178,
0.15419216454029083,
1.0003421306610107,
0.6688682436943054,
0.19162330031394958,
0.5963134169578552,
-0.6331930756568909,
0.011976211331784725,
-0.06687215715646744,
0.38704389333724976,
0.1346551775932312,
-0.3376297950744629,
0.3683413565158844,
-0.16089974343776703,
-0.8610079884529114,
-0.679906964302063,
0.33894556760787964,
-0.9450492262840271,
-0.20579694211483002,
0.940528929233551,
-0.05943945422768593,
-0.14274679124355316,
0.2750135064125061,
-0.2580283582210541,
0.16994425654411316,
-0.5162283182144165,
0.7600297331809998,
0.5106126070022583,
0.020482128486037254,
0.04191270470619202,
-0.25265878438949585,
0.43499505519866943,
0.8806918859481812,
-0.6652172803878784,
0.08951517194509506,
0.43468740582466125,
0.28232353925704956,
-0.06850343197584152,
0.690915584564209,
0.22072365880012512,
0.3141821324825287,
-0.3663676679134369,
0.19927743077278137,
0.04723439738154411,
-0.5256480574607849,
-0.6354178786277771,
-0.10605914890766144,
0.31812453269958496,
-0.33272936940193176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11251v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11251v1 | LLM can Achieve Self-Regulation via Hyperparameter Aware Generation | 2024-02-17T11:18:22 | 2024-02-17T11:18:22 | Siyin Wang, Shimin Li, Tianxiang Sun, Jinlan Fu, Qinyuan Cheng, Jiasheng Ye, Junjie Ye, Xipeng Qiu, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the realm of Large Language Models (LLMs), users commonly employ diverse
decoding strategies and adjust hyperparameters to control the generated text.
However, a critical question emerges: Are LLMs conscious of the existence of
these decoding strategies and capable of regulating themselves? The current
decoding generation process often relies on empirical and heuristic manual
adjustments to hyperparameters based on types of tasks and demands. However,
this process is typically cumbersome, and the decoding hyperparameters may not
always be optimal for each sample. To address the aforementioned challenges, we
propose a novel text generation paradigm termed Hyperparameter Aware Generation
(HAG). By leveraging hyperparameter-aware instruction tuning, the LLM
autonomously determines the optimal decoding strategy and configs based on the
input samples, enabling self-regulation. Our approach eliminates the need for
extensive manual tuning, offering a more autonomous, self-regulate model
behavior. Experimental results spanning six datasets across reasoning,
creativity, translation, and mathematics tasks demonstrate that
hyperparameter-aware instruction tuning empowers the LLMs to self-regulate the
decoding strategy and hyperparameter. HAG extends the current paradigm in the
text generation process, highlighting the feasibility of endowing the LLMs with
self-regulate decoding strategies. | [
-0.23607562482357025,
-0.7147517204284668,
0.4647568464279175,
0.4138893783092499,
-0.20370933413505554,
-0.2024381160736084,
-0.2829637825489044,
-0.22843900322914124,
-0.10336553305387497,
1.021855115890503,
-0.4720696210861206,
-0.2949431836605072,
-0.40552911162376404,
0.45958808064460754,
-0.23986348509788513,
1.0447837114334106,
0.006908670999109745,
-0.40031909942626953,
-0.14651528000831604,
0.204453244805336,
-0.5274792313575745,
-0.5818156599998474,
-0.5658528804779053,
-0.3067173957824707,
0.4551089107990265,
0.22336329519748688,
0.7564539313316345,
1.6178447008132935,
0.36344942450523376,
0.37906962633132935,
0.16586612164974213,
0.4369966983795166,
-0.5066381692886353,
0.34128767251968384,
-0.24917185306549072,
-0.4596825838088989,
-0.49507564306259155,
-0.06121840327978134,
0.5572718381881714,
0.031091395765542984,
-0.31119611859321594,
0.3116806149482727,
0.48250582814216614,
0.6720643043518066,
-0.854006826877594,
0.05039335414767265,
-0.8745235204696655,
0.0651402473449707,
-0.13037487864494324,
-0.809080958366394,
-0.6270462274551392,
-0.09418494254350662,
-0.40501049160957336,
-0.5357896685600281,
0.25293034315109253,
0.19609469175338745,
0.7206640243530273,
0.6180374026298523,
-0.31968384981155396,
-0.33410653471946716,
-0.7569804787635803,
0.569090723991394,
-0.7815117835998535,
0.19288499653339386,
0.7150321006774902,
0.03606736287474632,
-0.24273671209812164,
-0.4584216773509979,
-0.3003738522529602,
0.3125072121620178,
-0.13663797080516815,
0.13042514026165009,
-0.2096252143383026,
0.16223256289958954,
0.1893254667520523,
0.29024288058280945,
-0.11016158014535904,
0.08479590713977814,
-0.031449418514966965,
-0.4281006157398224,
0.33551618456840515,
0.3782894015312195,
0.0861508920788765,
-0.6872576475143433,
-0.27790266275405884,
0.18608549237251282,
-0.6835685968399048,
-0.1986905038356781,
0.3549681603908539,
0.22579294443130493,
0.07892531901597977,
0.44513463973999023,
-0.1518990695476532,
0.8574976325035095,
0.35763388872146606,
-0.0815637856721878,
-0.2626136839389801,
-0.33147865533828735,
-0.42939794063568115,
0.2216717004776001,
0.9242114424705505,
0.18622516095638275,
0.25447598099708557,
0.12815488874912262,
-0.41520386934280396,
-0.2613067030906677,
0.6650927662849426,
-0.6627131700515747,
-0.1849941611289978,
-0.13149306178092957,
-0.3290359079837799,
-0.3309454917907715,
-0.3637385368347168,
-0.7171610593795776,
-0.1488923877477646,
-0.3221485912799835,
0.6224021315574646,
-0.1425817608833313,
0.16673673689365387,
0.3092840313911438,
0.21710370481014252,
0.13874654471874237,
0.004171868320554495,
-1.489853858947754,
0.18847282230854034,
0.4531712532043457,
0.7218865752220154,
-0.11897945404052734,
-0.5805169939994812,
-0.39684852957725525,
0.7591928839683533,
-0.5168631672859192,
0.5161567330360413,
-0.22052951157093048,
-0.5326371788978577,
0.1505795419216156,
-0.302122563123703,
-0.018966879695653915,
-0.4549788534641266,
0.3482190668582916,
-0.669766902923584,
0.03676243871450424,
-0.3113202154636383,
-0.6917964816093445,
0.2632506787776947,
0.1797146499156952,
-0.46648934483528137,
0.9382832646369934,
-0.008271527476608753,
-0.7323724627494812,
0.21353116631507874,
-0.20790116488933563,
-0.4691726565361023,
0.22105269134044647,
-0.4590144157409668,
-0.47454142570495605,
0.2217344492673874,
0.31148818135261536,
0.5891871452331543,
-0.4250153601169586,
0.0036644015926867723,
-0.021821070462465286,
-0.14471520483493805,
0.07198185473680496,
-0.698775589466095,
0.40884673595428467,
0.2842566967010498,
-0.4308496415615082,
0.0727597251534462,
-0.8126403093338013,
0.44023993611335754,
-0.06887102872133255,
-0.9568281173706055,
-0.12613460421562195,
0.13871479034423828,
-0.3807077705860138,
0.1711033135652542,
0.45654210448265076,
-0.2706126272678375,
0.08646153658628464,
-0.2654651999473572,
0.5561783909797668,
0.9864204525947571,
0.3581733703613281,
0.184974804520607,
-0.4132672846317291,
0.4913043677806854,
-0.28092101216316223,
0.18449588119983673,
-0.4371228814125061,
0.023220069706439972,
-1.0138353109359741,
-0.2970128357410431,
0.07357751578092575,
0.517827033996582,
-0.4418102204799652,
0.8743270039558411,
0.1973489224910736,
-0.29350546002388,
-0.6721027493476868,
0.6451776623725891,
0.5587565302848816,
0.6509583592414856,
0.37914082407951355,
0.21493110060691833,
-0.39594265818595886,
-0.6639038324356079,
-0.2577473819255829,
-0.033384960144758224,
0.238080233335495,
0.38751938939094543,
0.15689702332019806,
-0.032707348465919495,
0.7009732127189636,
-0.47467973828315735,
-0.42073914408683777,
-0.2858845889568329,
0.14226675033569336,
0.11854388564825058,
0.6747737526893616,
0.06993995606899261,
-0.36104997992515564,
-0.4820168912410736,
-0.0052637034095823765,
-0.819892942905426,
-0.20248432457447052,
-0.433475136756897,
-0.49809014797210693,
0.14759236574172974,
1.025243878364563,
-0.385514497756958,
0.1759355217218399,
0.42721259593963623,
-0.3177262246608734,
0.7429312467575073,
-0.9579458236694336,
0.04201978072524071,
-1.1444659233093262,
-0.336704820394516,
-0.13168194890022278,
-0.2942083179950714,
-0.2100425660610199,
0.2009393721818924,
0.440547913312912,
0.10909430682659149,
-0.3387453854084015,
0.1838538497686386,
-0.6637853980064392,
0.13499586284160614,
-0.7913069725036621,
-0.42454516887664795,
0.014256343245506287,
0.4394547939300537,
-0.1799970120191574,
0.9719895720481873,
0.8379142880439758,
-0.9496917128562927,
0.2613625228404999,
0.3491159677505493,
-0.4233473539352417,
0.16222217679023743,
-0.9017507433891296,
0.02262715995311737,
-0.046362560242414474,
0.27713891863822937,
-0.5916045308113098,
-0.4692838490009308,
0.08222486823797226,
-0.03914642333984375,
0.14818254113197327,
-0.09931814670562744,
-0.63334721326828,
-0.26570022106170654,
0.30406811833381653,
0.2957843244075775,
0.7606768012046814,
-0.6438892483711243,
0.4735657274723053,
0.07595498114824295,
-0.020114995539188385,
-0.34205350279808044,
-0.7088627815246582,
0.15608352422714233,
-0.20270007848739624,
-0.047649405896663666,
0.1364724189043045,
-0.18086722493171692,
0.24063843488693237,
-0.30757951736450195,
-0.00937411468476057,
0.2535637617111206,
-0.14079700410366058,
0.20390406250953674,
0.207904651761055,
-0.10795321315526962,
0.06117142736911774,
0.37079766392707825,
-0.14678272604942322,
0.18266823887825012,
-0.5383272767066956,
0.4740639626979828,
0.20461951196193695,
-0.2156405746936798,
-0.5670210719108582,
0.3319748044013977,
0.5535175204277039,
-0.709089994430542,
0.2952207624912262,
0.45544111728668213,
-0.08283363282680511,
-0.6627373695373535,
-0.37920859456062317,
-0.1014067754149437,
-0.6764790415763855,
0.16570168733596802,
-0.4838305413722992,
-0.971018373966217,
0.24745793640613556,
-0.12314953655004501,
0.02956196665763855,
0.16952912509441376,
1.1177945137023926,
-0.08666049689054489,
1.1362982988357544,
0.8021336793899536,
0.17900536954402924,
0.3921165466308594,
0.004703249782323837,
-0.1377631425857544,
-0.7786756157875061,
0.15022151172161102,
-0.48092928528785706,
-0.15852026641368866,
-0.8642662763595581,
-0.2304038554430008,
0.5297780632972717,
-0.05750006437301636,
-0.20005165040493011,
0.2004571408033371,
-0.6059752106666565,
1.0025279521942139,
0.631075918674469,
0.13258974254131317,
0.18238765001296997,
-0.208560049533844,
-0.1246650293469429,
-0.03788314387202263,
-0.9110555052757263,
-0.5288781523704529,
0.9852038025856018,
0.2287731170654297,
1.1685456037521362,
-0.16248679161071777,
1.087931513786316,
0.46923115849494934,
-0.2632807791233063,
-0.5977517366409302,
0.6078386902809143,
-0.1554054319858551,
-0.585199236869812,
-0.4288553297519684,
-0.44767433404922485,
-0.9844427704811096,
0.10367067903280258,
-0.21189598739147186,
-0.5061277747154236,
0.06263522803783417,
0.6438318490982056,
-0.6276715993881226,
0.11130724102258682,
-0.5214529037475586,
0.5989240407943726,
-0.2620757818222046,
-0.673978865146637,
-0.2758738100528717,
-0.35261619091033936,
0.06746150553226471,
-0.18653634190559387,
0.12460421025753021,
-0.1419305056333542,
-0.16823628544807434,
0.5400550961494446,
-0.11755380779504776,
1.0078333616256714,
0.12800657749176025,
-0.4828265309333801,
0.4219246208667755,
0.5338341593742371,
0.7004216313362122,
0.15756294131278992,
-0.09743081778287888,
-0.305602103471756,
-0.07504910975694656,
-0.6174654364585876,
-0.656648576259613,
0.9785045981407166,
-0.8662444353103638,
-1.149499535560608,
-0.07964712381362915,
-0.7249940037727356,
-0.28209394216537476,
0.5953056216239929,
0.6866142153739929,
0.4363003969192505,
0.01591259241104126,
0.009283754974603653,
0.7669338583946228,
0.08447889238595963,
0.6568700671195984,
0.5338720679283142,
-0.1552255004644394,
-0.5325551629066467,
1.0908780097961426,
-0.043634265661239624,
0.3858857750892639,
0.41961830854415894,
0.5579015016555786,
-0.27141597867012024,
-0.5521134734153748,
-0.6728808283805847,
0.17752936482429504,
-0.5930044651031494,
-0.34631213545799255,
-0.5139247179031372,
-0.16178251802921295,
-0.41099223494529724,
-0.37929585576057434,
-0.37329646944999695,
0.09679145365953445,
-0.5551503300666809,
0.016725363209843636,
0.07477221637964249,
0.9739949703216553,
-0.12070859968662262,
0.5572680234909058,
-0.8518860936164856,
0.3713458776473999,
0.6001613736152649,
0.46693870425224304,
-0.11992919445037842,
-0.5298378467559814,
-0.6172724962234497,
-0.17501574754714966,
-0.35085001587867737,
-0.7921555638313293,
0.42523908615112305,
0.32615113258361816,
0.3196125626564026,
0.33641117811203003,
0.10462135821580887,
0.4321568012237549,
-0.8315861225128174,
0.5085116624832153,
0.012840809300541878,
-1.2312111854553223,
0.5419244170188904,
-0.5569701194763184,
0.6156743764877319,
0.3563067615032196,
0.24299530684947968,
-0.33386164903640747,
-0.6301667094230652,
-0.11719366908073425,
-0.4924294948577881,
0.675908625125885,
-0.004568513482809067,
0.6619372963905334,
-0.2931048572063446,
0.6212633848190308,
0.14534418284893036,
0.022169334813952446,
-0.6340257525444031,
0.08834178745746613,
-0.4547278583049774,
-0.19206252694129944,
-0.12114561349153519,
-0.20780615508556366,
-0.24491916596889496,
-0.1329178363084793,
0.498309850692749,
-0.3246692419052124,
0.09768246114253998,
0.36827558279037476,
0.20895420014858246,
-0.4018787145614624,
0.3630773425102234,
0.1686730831861496,
0.5086104869842529,
0.11877796053886414,
0.4691030979156494,
-0.08906317502260208,
-0.07931338995695114,
0.409932941198349,
-0.3870227336883545,
-0.3242512345314026,
-0.4188932180404663,
0.248079314827919,
0.9353559613227844,
0.16807891428470612,
-0.29372438788414,
0.1295793056488037,
-0.04678836092352867,
-0.42913517355918884,
0.15316787362098694,
0.7719959020614624,
-0.03131289407610893,
0.1623491793870926,
0.08665404468774796,
-0.16099680960178375,
-0.15695635974407196,
-0.08030643314123154,
0.23300093412399292,
0.22878974676132202,
-0.2861140966415405,
-0.10125517845153809,
0.8076274394989014,
0.3106987178325653,
-0.36812862753868103,
0.364011287689209,
-0.05092456191778183,
-0.08220137655735016,
0.40143540501594543,
1.2515920400619507,
0.8147860169410706,
-0.10834065824747086,
0.2548690140247345,
0.2801540195941925,
0.31450334191322327,
-0.11121921241283417,
0.198395773768425,
-0.2961159944534302,
-0.790678083896637,
-0.48794111609458923,
-0.8554128408432007,
-0.1720636785030365,
0.10416141152381897,
-0.764411985874176,
0.06021864339709282,
-0.6774853467941284,
-0.16889351606369019,
0.030410325154662132,
-0.413837730884552,
-0.3150739073753357,
0.35269659757614136,
-0.11323796212673187,
0.8129444718360901,
-0.4261282980442047,
0.892128050327301,
0.6368062496185303,
0.0005118880071677268,
-0.6134656667709351,
0.3008236289024353,
-0.26315200328826904,
-0.9723135828971863,
0.2633439898490906,
-0.06944715231657028,
-0.3673735558986664,
0.6644760966300964,
-0.43309444189071655,
-0.8089407682418823,
0.854473352432251,
0.421335905790329,
-0.6064006686210632,
-0.2715575397014618,
0.19361113011837006,
0.6769434809684753,
-0.2861458361148834,
-0.38993561267852783,
0.5119991898536682,
0.37054020166397095,
-0.17197179794311523,
-0.6155781745910645,
0.16241677105426788,
0.035757772624492645,
0.10637935250997543,
0.4493437111377716,
-0.9975872039794922,
0.5790966153144836,
-0.2904394268989563,
-0.20644424855709076,
-0.062386952340602875,
0.9898099303245544,
-0.12499362975358963,
-0.26890814304351807,
0.21811628341674805,
0.36201122403144836,
0.3518156409263611,
0.5282022953033447,
0.8565428853034973,
-0.849933922290802,
0.2216484695672989,
1.2010246515274048,
-0.025625860318541527,
0.7549607753753662,
0.34818214178085327,
0.08835085481405258,
0.16536137461662292,
0.33465224504470825,
-0.13196223974227905,
0.3288246989250183,
0.17756107449531555,
-0.3253752291202545,
-0.8065738081932068,
-0.021845977753400803,
-0.0816650539636612,
0.8804970979690552,
0.2381117194890976,
-0.5356231927871704,
-0.28961944580078125,
-0.06458229571580887,
0.07943850755691528,
0.4084433913230896,
-0.3976052403450012,
0.9047801494598389,
-0.262828528881073,
-0.9218848347663879,
1.055307388305664,
0.21493825316429138,
0.48527392745018005,
-0.8276765942573547,
0.22650973498821259,
-0.02533698081970215,
0.12108740210533142,
-0.06115031987428665,
-0.6374460458755493,
0.18676535785198212,
0.11814063787460327,
-0.35547783970832825,
-0.577876627445221,
0.6763712763786316,
-0.5047346949577332,
-0.37682047486305237,
-0.00316417682915926,
0.8216696977615356,
-0.26347532868385315,
0.21143409609794617,
-0.6432644128799438,
0.08161988854408264,
0.09467821568250656,
-0.3092045783996582,
0.46156054735183716,
0.5686445236206055,
0.26250308752059937,
0.6526830196380615,
0.513795793056488,
0.34523630142211914,
0.2876097857952118,
-0.2327526956796646,
0.536781370639801,
-0.8728891611099243,
-0.7696985006332397,
-0.9950639605522156,
-0.2089260369539261,
0.5715495347976685,
-0.6082820892333984,
0.9574918150901794,
0.36531952023506165,
0.8176935315132141,
-0.08003741502761841,
1.059328556060791,
0.1570969521999359,
0.256132572889328,
-0.6636053919792175,
0.8474799990653992,
-0.47074103355407715,
0.04173349216580391,
0.13089443743228912,
-0.5242296457290649,
-0.0038029502611607313,
0.10577527433633804,
0.010091627947986126,
-0.059678684920072556,
0.34113597869873047,
0.8024150133132935,
0.02355354093015194,
-0.11136617511510849,
0.6587029099464417,
0.18250004947185516,
0.25740864872932434,
0.2394782155752182,
0.5132383704185486,
0.07903239876031876,
0.6005024313926697,
-0.1376909464597702,
-0.32620587944984436,
0.07380890101194382,
-0.8383541703224182,
-0.8969625234603882,
-0.4204961359500885,
-0.03864410147070885,
-0.16886761784553528,
0.1522543579339981,
0.9435587525367737,
0.725226879119873,
-0.4582447111606598,
-0.6150392293930054,
-0.525325357913971,
-0.051541268825531006,
-0.24059908092021942,
-0.16304780542850494,
0.21694040298461914,
-0.9192635416984558,
-0.7203340530395508,
0.45967385172843933,
0.5192188024520874,
0.2526939809322357,
-0.5657041072845459,
-0.18179453909397125,
-0.005336552392691374,
0.7048245668411255,
0.5550633668899536,
0.3574390411376953,
-0.42332223057746887,
-0.078405000269413,
-0.0034407665953040123,
-0.5681931376457214,
0.1558680236339569,
1.151373028755188,
-0.535707414150238,
0.6788318157196045,
0.3285984396934509,
0.8727335333824158,
0.1594013124704361,
0.01858895644545555,
0.6664284467697144,
-0.7116355299949646,
-0.47361648082733154,
0.008143099956214428,
0.10864892601966858,
-0.006556217093020678,
-0.7022322416305542,
-0.14234969019889832,
0.023337220773100853,
-0.9859350323677063,
-0.4525528848171234,
0.5150024890899658,
-0.462386816740036,
-0.2484670877456665,
1.227800965309143,
-0.12545469403266907,
-0.5196199417114258,
0.2166813760995865,
-0.3921378552913666,
0.445239394903183,
-0.280021071434021,
1.1142258644104004,
0.7421170473098755,
-0.5626034140586853,
-0.2264557182788849,
-0.23984254896640778,
0.7977189421653748,
0.7285407185554504,
-1.0133100748062134,
0.7314397692680359,
0.5776554346084595,
-0.05286746099591255,
-0.2720131278038025,
0.579544186592102,
0.030289970338344574,
0.2747519910335541,
-0.13347145915031433,
-0.04724537208676338,
-0.2689838409423828,
-0.5146780014038086,
-0.1752653419971466,
0.2192806452512741,
0.09865621477365494,
-0.09629065543413162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11243v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11243v1 | Can Large Language Models perform Relation-based Argument Mining? | 2024-02-17T10:37:51 | 2024-02-17T10:37:51 | Deniz Gorur, Antonio Rago, Francesca Toni | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Argument mining (AM) is the process of automatically extracting arguments,
their components and/or relations amongst arguments and components from text.
As the number of platforms supporting online debate increases, the need for AM
becomes ever more urgent, especially in support of downstream tasks.
Relation-based AM (RbAM) is a form of AM focusing on identifying agreement
(support) and disagreement (attack) relations amongst arguments. RbAM is a
challenging classification task, with existing methods failing to perform
satisfactorily. In this paper, we show that general-purpose Large Language
Models (LLMs), appropriately primed and prompted, can significantly outperform
the best performing (RoBERTa-based) baseline. Specifically, we experiment with
two open-source LLMs (Llama-2 and Mistral) with ten datasets. | [
-0.2604760527610779,
-0.8767427206039429,
0.7405731081962585,
0.08489196747541428,
-0.37936317920684814,
-0.3319609761238098,
-0.3176374137401581,
-0.5436831116676331,
-0.069358691573143,
0.7179304957389832,
-0.5412079691886902,
-0.4069056510925293,
-0.7102946043014526,
0.12272262573242188,
-0.3240227997303009,
1.045421838760376,
-0.021907944232225418,
0.10344667732715607,
-0.34587562084198,
-0.502923846244812,
-0.5329523086547852,
-0.8167827725410461,
-0.7758532166481018,
-0.6409770250320435,
0.5559525489807129,
0.4872123897075653,
0.8399264216423035,
0.6134671568870544,
0.4539264142513275,
0.3378508388996124,
-0.09797292947769165,
0.24883876740932465,
-0.2315308004617691,
0.5579355359077454,
-0.5410459041595459,
-0.5927731990814209,
-0.47880828380584717,
-0.07610959559679031,
0.4175892174243927,
0.354775071144104,
-0.27446448802948,
-0.027894427999854088,
-0.2511664628982544,
0.479360431432724,
-0.5277594327926636,
0.05862562730908394,
-1.0997533798217773,
-0.2377195656299591,
-0.2669757902622223,
-0.2725559175014496,
-0.7048452496528625,
-0.10004448145627975,
0.01510164886713028,
-0.11741609871387482,
-0.11649218201637268,
0.24266281723976135,
1.1929931640625,
-0.03244674950838089,
-0.2584877908229828,
-0.7203394174575806,
-0.6496730446815491,
0.828853189945221,
-1.038243055343628,
0.031442999839782715,
0.39587849378585815,
0.2134389579296112,
-0.2737792432308197,
-0.5267910361289978,
-0.46702858805656433,
-0.24194492399692535,
-0.18303664028644562,
-0.29962578415870667,
-0.4470407962799072,
0.002624735701829195,
0.45074841380119324,
0.4923076033592224,
-0.37148433923721313,
0.38528972864151,
-0.1573760062456131,
0.141083225607872,
0.3738231062889099,
0.2282438576221466,
0.24186669290065765,
-0.571045994758606,
-0.43383049964904785,
0.03939396142959595,
-0.8885166645050049,
-0.25711870193481445,
0.20884200930595398,
0.3118366599082947,
-0.19257554411888123,
0.6904507279396057,
0.09061253070831299,
0.8340141177177429,
-0.11051569133996964,
0.057686056941747665,
-0.30335986614227295,
0.11564550548791885,
-0.3789783716201782,
-0.14998759329319,
1.101902723312378,
0.1919509470462799,
0.6057540774345398,
0.005423564929515123,
-0.13442273437976837,
0.22869959473609924,
-0.10452359169721603,
-0.8899657726287842,
-0.3585014045238495,
0.23309054970741272,
-0.46084165573120117,
-0.16245631873607635,
-0.11897975206375122,
-0.900873064994812,
-0.6162866353988647,
-0.32522347569465637,
0.2568543553352356,
-0.24883215129375458,
-0.3543888032436371,
0.0291561521589756,
-0.03780039772391319,
0.3467920124530792,
0.27576151490211487,
-0.820149302482605,
0.37838366627693176,
0.9300748705863953,
0.9470556974411011,
0.08179458230733871,
0.04953750967979431,
-0.8604478240013123,
0.2556533217430115,
-0.2349766045808792,
1.2870155572891235,
-0.9042944312095642,
-0.25755438208580017,
0.05023639276623726,
-0.3956091105937958,
0.04689296707510948,
-1.0504757165908813,
0.8294228315353394,
-0.8146146535873413,
0.2065889537334442,
-0.08797978609800339,
-0.7208927869796753,
-0.048416025936603546,
0.41272735595703125,
-0.7269859313964844,
0.7269047498703003,
-0.07689740508794785,
-0.6235617995262146,
0.08898793905973434,
-0.4748644232749939,
-0.446698397397995,
0.025481395423412323,
-0.3641093969345093,
-0.5390734076499939,
0.14358778297901154,
0.291249543428421,
0.6433186531066895,
-0.9316229224205017,
0.3782561421394348,
-0.5700024962425232,
-0.021806837990880013,
0.4800003170967102,
-0.22030706703662872,
0.739467203617096,
0.19715525209903717,
-0.17723967134952545,
0.24876387417316437,
-0.6135204434394836,
-0.028903765603899956,
0.21085134148597717,
-0.22799953818321228,
-0.5965713858604431,
0.34920167922973633,
-0.2468915730714798,
0.34247395396232605,
0.0761105865240097,
-0.3503701686859131,
0.2967274785041809,
-0.3711218535900116,
0.7557439804077148,
0.6933252215385437,
0.2645600736141205,
-0.030641961842775345,
-0.27635884284973145,
0.5104464888572693,
0.10440768301486969,
-0.37179088592529297,
-0.4014158248901367,
-0.6255242824554443,
-1.0048047304153442,
-0.2776537239551544,
0.45570534467697144,
0.5643442273139954,
-0.13329996168613434,
0.36386269330978394,
-0.49980446696281433,
-0.17679749429225922,
-0.3817138671875,
0.3178451359272003,
0.2946301996707916,
0.3052197992801666,
0.35206514596939087,
-0.077118419110775,
-0.7625375986099243,
-0.8763459920883179,
-0.23948045074939728,
-0.519030749797821,
0.09123209118843079,
0.47733303904533386,
0.18802551925182343,
-0.44886985421180725,
0.9806559085845947,
-0.47416383028030396,
-0.2619490325450897,
-0.3254985809326172,
0.4692608714103699,
0.3372790515422821,
-0.09603508561849594,
0.3568260967731476,
-0.4623846411705017,
-0.5234902501106262,
0.295510858297348,
-0.9675095081329346,
-0.31761011481285095,
-0.021228251978754997,
-0.05146268010139465,
0.3429425358772278,
0.5375863909721375,
-0.8808857798576355,
0.06299643963575363,
0.48758402466773987,
-0.2191462367773056,
0.5111954212188721,
-0.014855640009045601,
-0.08324544876813889,
-1.2791452407836914,
0.026164228096604347,
0.1879485547542572,
-0.35741060972213745,
-0.49087175726890564,
0.1381675899028778,
-0.10122164338827133,
-0.23540861904621124,
-0.13293898105621338,
0.5698084235191345,
-0.3055810332298279,
0.15875151753425598,
-0.6295439004898071,
0.037907883524894714,
-0.1910528689622879,
0.24551182985305786,
0.2540533244609833,
0.4791931211948395,
0.3193518817424774,
-0.4964739978313446,
0.372721791267395,
0.23251895606517792,
-0.2500431537628174,
0.5946393609046936,
-0.6590397357940674,
0.19420424103736877,
0.03798127919435501,
0.1785113364458084,
-1.077459454536438,
-0.35960736870765686,
0.07303785532712936,
-0.34439221024513245,
0.22452519834041595,
-0.5581856966018677,
-0.32579925656318665,
-0.018511604517698288,
-0.10893547534942627,
0.27339181303977966,
0.32758110761642456,
-0.610134482383728,
0.7233474254608154,
0.4476662278175354,
-0.4942651093006134,
-0.6981783509254456,
-0.4778294861316681,
0.3929004967212677,
-0.5447280406951904,
-0.5566767454147339,
0.14586374163627625,
0.22502274811267853,
-0.7204759120941162,
0.32495054602622986,
0.3320399820804596,
-0.06169578433036804,
-0.2254062294960022,
0.49667561054229736,
0.29857337474823,
-0.26771166920661926,
0.20354920625686646,
-0.4904204308986664,
-0.20514552295207977,
0.33705946803092957,
0.17992573976516724,
0.6098366975784302,
0.028894463554024696,
-0.2493785172700882,
-0.21446050703525543,
0.575096607208252,
0.8152517080307007,
-0.13550950586795807,
0.6986477375030518,
0.010331634432077408,
-0.43173786997795105,
-0.49938732385635376,
-0.7226360440254211,
-0.08338022232055664,
-0.47111818194389343,
0.19260960817337036,
-0.31462258100509644,
-1.005732536315918,
0.5132125616073608,
-0.3053862154483795,
0.3522002398967743,
0.4903566837310791,
0.7946791648864746,
0.16603818535804749,
0.8149034976959229,
0.2493591159582138,
-0.6233863830566406,
0.245143324136734,
-0.01999661698937416,
0.31822046637535095,
-0.6754930019378662,
0.11463778465986252,
-0.6882189512252808,
-0.08141940832138062,
-0.4088931977748871,
-0.43427395820617676,
0.06710949540138245,
0.13488735258579254,
-0.23096980154514313,
0.21612903475761414,
-0.09745442867279053,
0.30363041162490845,
0.1626782864332199,
-0.1558356136083603,
0.48938798904418945,
0.20335425436496735,
0.05721154436469078,
-0.1324169933795929,
-0.5226855874061584,
-0.7217163443565369,
1.1018046140670776,
0.5160283446311951,
0.7612102627754211,
0.2177654653787613,
0.503909707069397,
0.45568153262138367,
0.9534229040145874,
-1.048214316368103,
0.7666390538215637,
-0.11842601001262665,
-0.8006856441497803,
0.01828547939658165,
-0.6691731214523315,
-1.0303910970687866,
0.32379743456840515,
-0.4024697542190552,
-0.5856338143348694,
-0.11732297390699387,
0.15495221316814423,
-0.19566655158996582,
0.5608474016189575,
-0.6144683361053467,
0.6509798765182495,
-0.333886057138443,
-0.46978995203971863,
-0.47654205560684204,
-0.09257504343986511,
0.6303849220275879,
0.05095594748854637,
0.3880871534347534,
-0.15446697175502777,
0.3021354675292969,
0.8330820202827454,
-0.5060644745826721,
0.531415581703186,
-0.10286729782819748,
-0.1487756222486496,
0.5992982387542725,
0.07111384719610214,
0.607262134552002,
-0.05386127904057503,
-0.3082686960697174,
-0.050475627183914185,
-0.41708794236183167,
-0.08800297230482101,
-0.7453967332839966,
0.9357441663742065,
-0.6369563937187195,
-0.9635775089263916,
-0.506712794303894,
-0.39458218216896057,
-0.3382360637187958,
-0.04723498225212097,
-0.17016929388046265,
0.3162071406841278,
-0.05906179919838905,
0.34971803426742554,
0.5488876104354858,
-0.012236368842422962,
0.36799776554107666,
0.5372499823570251,
-0.2380732297897339,
-0.6720851063728333,
0.781430721282959,
-0.12416461110115051,
0.01005577016621828,
0.37636491656303406,
0.49797797203063965,
-0.3317919671535492,
-0.5757706165313721,
-0.4108470380306244,
0.46117085218429565,
-0.7641196846961975,
-0.5147514343261719,
-0.715308427810669,
-0.2002565860748291,
0.02285369299352169,
0.16789081692695618,
-0.1258564293384552,
-0.22472946345806122,
0.09452499449253082,
-0.03589845076203346,
0.49852776527404785,
0.8495511412620544,
0.19307933747768402,
0.1672014743089676,
-0.8123091459274292,
0.28832486271858215,
0.5938425064086914,
0.2752607464790344,
0.23378650844097137,
-0.39220166206359863,
-0.007508893497288227,
-0.2176547795534134,
-0.4272991120815277,
-1.0537673234939575,
0.25730690360069275,
0.21561361849308014,
0.31902876496315,
0.6701935529708862,
0.05262574553489685,
0.8024119138717651,
-0.5440477132797241,
0.6412808895111084,
0.16817860305309296,
-0.7893725037574768,
0.46863609552383423,
-0.5626648664474487,
-0.14119304716587067,
0.28692731261253357,
0.36468976736068726,
-0.25851020216941833,
-0.018502218648791313,
-0.6038196682929993,
-0.8484472036361694,
0.5994340777397156,
-0.05929330363869667,
0.04166319593787193,
-0.13577322661876678,
0.48485344648361206,
-0.1844213753938675,
0.041271623224020004,
-1.1861308813095093,
-0.03901300206780434,
0.39961081743240356,
-0.16183574497699738,
0.05293772742152214,
-0.5203960537910461,
-0.19317977130413055,
0.045948635786771774,
0.5604945421218872,
0.11461552232503891,
0.20038580894470215,
-0.08747367560863495,
-0.01477637980133295,
-0.5026290416717529,
0.6779418587684631,
0.4147980809211731,
0.6184538006782532,
-0.12366731464862823,
0.28523150086402893,
0.25905731320381165,
0.07015492767095566,
0.33903175592422485,
0.05821749195456505,
0.013712545856833458,
-0.006804809905588627,
0.454206258058548,
0.8049395680427551,
0.2399081438779831,
-0.908897340297699,
0.41919058561325073,
0.039442550390958786,
-0.19162242114543915,
-0.19330668449401855,
-0.020465819165110588,
0.4223834276199341,
0.12801678478717804,
0.2725449502468109,
-0.26675423979759216,
-0.12659083306789398,
-0.9123770594596863,
0.13832388818264008,
0.922792911529541,
-0.10928063094615936,
-0.10644020885229111,
0.4510689377784729,
0.08682669699192047,
-0.42847615480422974,
0.5995779633522034,
0.14773964881896973,
-0.6542190909385681,
0.17174340784549713,
0.6237504482269287,
0.5973576903343201,
-0.08495856076478958,
-0.05538409203290939,
0.24889688193798065,
-0.025533566251397133,
-0.05043955147266388,
-0.028715457767248154,
0.02171914651989937,
-0.7055619359016418,
-0.6567254066467285,
-0.6075593829154968,
-0.8051601052284241,
0.6956758499145508,
-0.5666120052337646,
0.36095643043518066,
-0.6386869549751282,
-0.2647128701210022,
0.15653805434703827,
0.07232683151960373,
-0.25344839692115784,
0.11501197516918182,
0.11581259965896606,
0.5746002793312073,
-0.8325679302215576,
0.7552840709686279,
0.991266667842865,
0.012156748212873936,
-0.5968371033668518,
-0.028307203203439713,
-0.21260471642017365,
-0.30735287070274353,
0.6839451789855957,
0.15651027858257294,
-0.23500405251979828,
-0.4146672785282135,
-0.44923633337020874,
-0.43210527300834656,
0.6079455018043518,
0.6395246982574463,
-0.36388877034187317,
0.18453578650951385,
0.22813603281974792,
0.6061803698539734,
-0.40271589159965515,
0.3272034227848053,
0.16406415402889252,
0.42744240164756775,
0.04946691170334816,
-0.6197196841239929,
0.00019109973800368607,
-0.26862633228302,
-0.3380845785140991,
0.39694589376449585,
-0.6214035153388977,
0.9474434852600098,
-0.016589945182204247,
-0.214423269033432,
-0.004715622402727604,
1.016573190689087,
0.6005473136901855,
0.2533859610557556,
0.6100407242774963,
0.9360485672950745,
0.5890661478042603,
0.04400221258401871,
0.8985211849212646,
-0.2867666184902191,
0.15472343564033508,
1.1494452953338623,
-0.5543267130851746,
1.422877550125122,
0.27987024188041687,
-0.15930187702178955,
1.1280031204223633,
0.4122529923915863,
0.1056230217218399,
0.11620166152715683,
0.24021926522254944,
-0.3349379599094391,
-0.71996009349823,
-0.04744526743888855,
-0.17825593054294586,
0.2465934306383133,
0.7734747529029846,
-0.46417316794395447,
-0.33872124552726746,
-0.4493657350540161,
0.329476535320282,
0.3823925852775574,
-0.2833932042121887,
0.7675730586051941,
0.3684483766555786,
-1.126841425895691,
0.6449139714241028,
0.25966161489486694,
0.6022293567657471,
-0.7298431992530823,
-0.17614415287971497,
0.12357670813798904,
0.4546695649623871,
-0.23168544471263885,
-0.7120208740234375,
0.057218119502067566,
0.3197370171546936,
-0.3130916953086853,
0.1390831619501114,
0.9030604362487793,
-0.22907672822475433,
-0.2712084650993347,
0.451198548078537,
0.5951704382896423,
-0.15165750682353973,
0.1123243197798729,
-0.5932620763778687,
0.1114639863371849,
-0.16359855234622955,
-0.3190470039844513,
0.5222322940826416,
0.40732821822166443,
-0.2471243441104889,
0.7884706258773804,
0.5748170614242554,
0.20935146510601044,
-0.11876719444990158,
-0.2452245056629181,
1.0381958484649658,
-0.6189023852348328,
-0.16128484904766083,
-1.265998125076294,
0.2035508155822754,
-0.3008512854576111,
-0.09825414419174194,
0.7683789134025574,
0.4920610785484314,
0.41773611307144165,
0.014139738865196705,
0.8485652804374695,
0.04393266886472702,
0.6335260272026062,
-0.6043932437896729,
0.2608562409877777,
-0.19208572804927826,
0.2297126203775406,
-0.16118042171001434,
-0.868986964225769,
-0.3787526488304138,
0.8347705006599426,
-0.4841950237751007,
-0.029809722676873207,
0.540681004524231,
0.7897031903266907,
-0.2280777394771576,
0.11083322763442993,
0.07303235679864883,
0.16260944306850433,
0.593664288520813,
0.8537355661392212,
0.9610300660133362,
-0.22935904562473297,
0.547669529914856,
0.28515976667404175,
-0.21367689967155457,
-0.19414855539798737,
-1.0535303354263306,
-1.3443636894226074,
-0.28062671422958374,
-0.3552466928958893,
-0.43560731410980225,
0.13093994557857513,
1.1886699199676514,
0.7296409606933594,
-0.9687559008598328,
-0.5809037685394287,
-0.14599013328552246,
0.050178755074739456,
0.16861052811145782,
-0.17570297420024872,
0.2835245430469513,
-0.3908784091472626,
-0.5922209024429321,
0.449405699968338,
0.14226628839969635,
-0.2957353889942169,
-0.3054678440093994,
-0.13080787658691406,
-0.3893141448497772,
0.36561229825019836,
0.5827732086181641,
0.4625367522239685,
-0.7231018543243408,
-0.13528873026371002,
-0.38888293504714966,
0.1366548091173172,
0.16636213660240173,
1.0151894092559814,
-0.6891160011291504,
0.21940231323242188,
0.48938214778900146,
0.6496794819831848,
0.2833261787891388,
0.38806459307670593,
0.6975206732749939,
-0.6382421255111694,
0.007053838111460209,
-0.05315900221467018,
0.6480996012687683,
0.48331451416015625,
-0.03957997262477875,
0.3760395050048828,
0.0687822550535202,
-0.7994565963745117,
-0.9701244831085205,
0.42036905884742737,
-0.9200103282928467,
-0.26359641551971436,
1.5689258575439453,
-0.4015843868255615,
-0.04543247073888779,
-0.13381628692150116,
-0.30613988637924194,
-0.0686783418059349,
-0.326382040977478,
0.7317409515380859,
1.060711145401001,
-0.15413929522037506,
-0.323272168636322,
-0.48716479539871216,
0.4743346869945526,
0.5562441945075989,
-0.8810552954673767,
0.6628243327140808,
0.5731936097145081,
0.17830276489257812,
0.3061681091785431,
0.41996467113494873,
-0.1764799952507019,
0.0034277543891221285,
-0.40663665533065796,
-0.44022756814956665,
-0.009325179271399975,
-0.1794583797454834,
-0.32446473836898804,
0.7882317900657654,
0.5910735726356506,
0.3092425465583801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05561v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05561v1 | Detecting a Proxy for Potential Comorbid ADHD in People Reporting Anxiety Symptoms from Social Media Data | 2024-02-17T10:32:43 | 2024-02-17T10:32:43 | Claire S. Lee, Noelle Lim, Michael Guerzhoy | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | We present a novel task that can elucidate the connection between anxiety and
ADHD; use Transformers to make progress toward solving a task that is not
solvable by keyword-based classifiers; and discuss a method for visualization
of our classifier illuminating the connection between anxiety and ADHD
presentations.
Up to approximately 50% of adults with ADHD may also have an anxiety disorder
and approximately 30\% of adults with anxiety may also have ADHD. Patients
presenting with anxiety may be treated for anxiety without ADHD ever being
considered, possibly affecting treatment. We show how data that bears on ADHD
that is comorbid with anxiety can be obtained from social media data, and show
that Transformers can be used to detect a proxy for possible comorbid ADHD in
people with anxiety symptoms.
We collected data from anxiety and ADHD online forums (subreddits). We
identified posters who first started posting in the Anxiety subreddit and later
started posting in the ADHD subreddit as well. We use this subset of the
posters as a proxy for people who presented with anxiety symptoms and then
became aware that they might have ADHD. We fine-tune a Transformer
architecture-based classifier to classify people who started posting in the
Anxiety subreddit and then started posting in the ADHD subreddit vs. people who
posted in the Anxiety subreddit without later posting in the ADHD subreddit. We
show that a Transformer architecture is capable of achieving reasonable results
(76% correct for RoBERTa vs. under 60% correct for the best keyword-based
model, both with 50% base rate). | [
-0.7044854760169983,
-0.9674288630485535,
0.9092614054679871,
0.04185519367456436,
-0.0025733867660164833,
0.26417842507362366,
0.18095943331718445,
-0.5100548267364502,
0.8302764296531677,
0.08568263798952103,
-0.7963240742683411,
-0.5383120775222778,
-0.891932487487793,
-0.46919336915016174,
-0.6083309650421143,
0.7829689979553223,
-0.20049335062503815,
0.25349825620651245,
-0.10714074969291687,
0.1682400405406952,
-0.46222105622291565,
-0.4604761600494385,
-1.266010046005249,
-0.3495360016822815,
0.38431715965270996,
0.3704218566417694,
0.7608631253242493,
0.6245538592338562,
0.6623556017875671,
0.13903918862342834,
0.016727959737181664,
0.08978872001171112,
-0.035102393478155136,
0.038679517805576324,
-0.24328255653381348,
-0.24741755425930023,
-0.6875102519989014,
-0.11912184953689575,
0.16857558488845825,
0.3783876299858093,
-0.16110432147979736,
0.4015547037124634,
0.022061016410589218,
0.4071827828884125,
-0.4101828932762146,
-0.09149879217147827,
-0.4079331159591675,
0.25117066502571106,
-0.14704589545726776,
-0.3579816520214081,
0.002292223507538438,
-0.08078277856111526,
-0.4503103196620941,
-0.4624587297439575,
0.8271991014480591,
0.16257184743881226,
0.7166303992271423,
0.6124730706214905,
-0.7095651626586914,
-0.35467904806137085,
-1.0405519008636475,
0.33902597427368164,
0.2149011194705963,
0.4955021142959595,
0.4421582520008087,
0.37551772594451904,
-0.07915758341550827,
-0.8666519522666931,
-0.7142836451530457,
0.1125284805893898,
-0.1969149112701416,
0.15836548805236816,
-0.5126294493675232,
-0.07758910953998566,
0.2636113464832306,
0.36117812991142273,
-0.8231661319732666,
-0.09588529169559479,
-0.590657114982605,
-0.2992050051689148,
0.5715965628623962,
0.2450837790966034,
0.46488651633262634,
0.1085892766714096,
-0.3974187672138214,
-0.18101955950260162,
-0.10642237216234207,
0.29296088218688965,
0.2602081298828125,
0.06048779934644699,
-0.11640548706054688,
0.3819836974143982,
0.5045714378356934,
0.1606971174478531,
0.6097350716590881,
0.02011210285127163,
-0.029852138832211494,
0.275112509727478,
0.25099658966064453,
0.44510266184806824,
0.43466290831565857,
0.512456476688385,
0.1002899780869484,
0.0021980199962854385,
-0.0007715817773714662,
0.8057502508163452,
0.6514140963554382,
-0.475170761346817,
-0.33347487449645996,
0.4244926869869232,
-0.6613860130310059,
-0.034721408039331436,
0.07082614302635193,
-0.9424186944961548,
-0.7657285928726196,
-0.23254644870758057,
0.5448395609855652,
-0.2883412837982178,
-0.22826743125915527,
-0.13670343160629272,
-0.25919702649116516,
-0.020302293822169304,
0.27557653188705444,
-0.7219705581665039,
0.7735134363174438,
0.8276430368423462,
0.967671811580658,
-0.6170274019241333,
-0.09695036709308624,
-0.354454904794693,
-0.14922714233398438,
-0.3461325168609619,
1.1260801553726196,
-0.25863224267959595,
-0.45542070269584656,
0.07852012664079666,
0.12593859434127808,
-0.4567522406578064,
-0.662787914276123,
0.9931228756904602,
-0.6663419008255005,
-0.19443029165267944,
0.11868415772914886,
-0.436794638633728,
0.06505614519119263,
0.10214675962924957,
-1.0056310892105103,
0.9241564273834229,
0.22880510985851288,
-0.6778464317321777,
0.1990414261817932,
-0.5302203297615051,
-0.633455216884613,
0.10934513062238693,
-0.00045147858327254653,
-0.3291643559932709,
0.04274149611592293,
0.09228686988353729,
0.17937114834785461,
-0.14376775920391083,
0.36880412697792053,
-0.44085758924484253,
-0.5662810206413269,
0.46597734093666077,
-0.2955991327762604,
0.5029851198196411,
0.30714771151542664,
-0.11087113618850708,
0.005863143131136894,
-0.6330488324165344,
-0.14056192338466644,
-0.06093132868409157,
-0.11813497543334961,
-0.40331506729125977,
-0.023567894473671913,
0.05927806720137596,
0.4079938232898712,
0.27428197860717773,
-0.5573319792747498,
0.01442499179393053,
0.3048396706581116,
-0.03751077875494957,
0.8143065571784973,
0.4478318393230438,
-0.15189242362976074,
-0.6782305240631104,
0.7248185873031616,
0.3584994375705719,
0.3874913454055786,
0.2786799371242523,
-0.6326531171798706,
-0.6847641468048096,
-0.5763252973556519,
-0.3078950047492981,
0.43285873532295227,
-0.5957562923431396,
0.4940422475337982,
-0.25911471247673035,
-0.4629453122615814,
-0.6696253418922424,
-0.08003479242324829,
0.0935099720954895,
0.4579971730709076,
0.7774532437324524,
-0.2621374726295471,
-0.6002922058105469,
-0.7297171950340271,
-0.35080456733703613,
-0.10387847572565079,
-0.1707460582256317,
0.11544822156429291,
0.33014118671417236,
-0.6570177674293518,
0.4129868745803833,
-0.8671579360961914,
-0.7167666554450989,
0.2792312800884247,
0.5414886474609375,
0.05070232227444649,
0.3745264708995819,
0.35238116979599,
-1.0475614070892334,
-0.6843541860580444,
0.04236658290028572,
-0.12137448787689209,
0.13916821777820587,
0.1973949372768402,
-0.19494888186454773,
-0.15006741881370544,
0.9209165573120117,
-0.9034599661827087,
0.4399423599243164,
0.4303433299064636,
-0.3340288996696472,
0.15209150314331055,
0.040790192782878876,
0.04350042715668678,
-1.2198578119277954,
0.2076958864927292,
0.16919752955436707,
-0.05384546518325806,
-0.6977124214172363,
-0.21702247858047485,
-0.22155186533927917,
-0.10064879059791565,
-0.05915818363428116,
0.36126822233200073,
0.27785730361938477,
0.3277989327907562,
-0.32436510920524597,
-0.14977090060710907,
-0.24575646221637726,
0.5714291930198669,
-0.042228635400533676,
0.3864702880382538,
0.7133684158325195,
-0.49473607540130615,
0.4001573324203491,
-0.08970743417739868,
-0.05565965548157692,
0.6723182201385498,
-0.34324049949645996,
0.1785614937543869,
-0.4802403748035431,
0.21200232207775116,
-1.5653208494186401,
-0.5140555500984192,
0.3634924590587616,
-0.6363515257835388,
0.34019917249679565,
0.20139244198799133,
-0.19178442656993866,
-0.7700962424278259,
-0.3940678834915161,
0.30070021748542786,
0.40412187576293945,
-0.6064766049385071,
0.8635449409484863,
0.5467569231987,
0.03274665027856827,
-0.32135263085365295,
-0.4343375861644745,
-0.43014776706695557,
-0.5525777339935303,
-0.25401848554611206,
0.7680470943450928,
0.009650818072259426,
-0.16933758556842804,
0.4205683469772339,
-0.6012513637542725,
-0.4675667881965637,
0.10779517889022827,
0.49520355463027954,
0.09061279147863388,
0.008328836411237717,
0.4542737603187561,
0.043014951050281525,
-0.12521839141845703,
0.3553195893764496,
-0.1371961534023285,
0.7693613171577454,
-0.11474332213401794,
-0.4502847194671631,
-0.5752419233322144,
0.34993258118629456,
0.7513900995254517,
0.1039508804678917,
0.5966582894325256,
1.0319069623947144,
-0.6128355264663696,
-0.35327088832855225,
-0.3776247799396515,
-0.31108179688453674,
-0.47569677233695984,
0.11255406588315964,
-0.31447869539260864,
-0.6238030195236206,
0.7461565732955933,
-0.08767683058977127,
-0.539395272731781,
0.5002680420875549,
0.2548791766166687,
-0.21725179255008698,
1.4806925058364868,
0.7931581735610962,
0.1258605420589447,
0.36673668026924133,
0.037877414375543594,
0.5333791375160217,
-0.5670050382614136,
-0.12699982523918152,
-0.3571801781654358,
-0.6466959118843079,
-0.995690643787384,
-0.3270880877971649,
0.5222302675247192,
-0.3976757526397705,
-0.22080594301223755,
0.10390482097864151,
-0.38795799016952515,
-0.007458261214196682,
0.6179563403129578,
0.43695124983787537,
0.11931636929512024,
0.22232775390148163,
0.042246852070093155,
-0.09154259413480759,
-0.44259876012802124,
-0.28203141689300537,
0.9103211760520935,
0.27798667550086975,
0.7827135324478149,
0.15451239049434662,
0.40167149901390076,
0.9922671318054199,
0.8382697105407715,
-1.1174542903900146,
0.43493765592575073,
-0.4291744828224182,
-0.7238460183143616,
0.052699390798807144,
-0.236657977104187,
-1.0055036544799805,
-0.24897047877311707,
-0.09078699350357056,
-0.9750977158546448,
0.4382668137550354,
0.3289448916912079,
-0.5086618661880493,
0.05292344093322754,
-0.6035598516464233,
0.9353477358818054,
-0.18875104188919067,
-0.2664000689983368,
-0.3080856502056122,
-0.8199356198310852,
0.44563981890678406,
-0.6208587288856506,
0.22612270712852478,
0.03617085516452789,
0.2657202482223511,
0.8800062537193298,
-0.31569451093673706,
0.5166440010070801,
-0.023992380127310753,
0.05369880422949791,
0.48636019229888916,
-0.014227514155209064,
-0.07064563035964966,
-0.23672471940517426,
0.3641686737537384,
-0.11808646470308304,
0.009562939405441284,
0.034327249974012375,
-0.8678524494171143,
0.8424791097640991,
-1.0085569620132446,
-0.6923538446426392,
-0.488668292760849,
-0.41827693581581116,
-0.5030710697174072,
0.07175827026367188,
0.18439866602420807,
0.17595405876636505,
0.08416622877120972,
0.17355531454086304,
0.6232151389122009,
0.36887621879577637,
0.15615910291671753,
0.4932728111743927,
0.062411703169345856,
-0.3001856505870819,
0.8600425720214844,
0.051196448504924774,
-0.32441410422325134,
0.5439507961273193,
0.2497769445180893,
-0.39976048469543457,
0.12296188622713089,
0.22862103581428528,
0.3185003399848938,
-0.734230101108551,
-0.10773367434740067,
-0.4694284498691559,
-0.4193534553050995,
-0.5310219526290894,
0.0007579730590805411,
-0.3715094327926636,
-0.4149196743965149,
-0.18869401514530182,
-0.3148576021194458,
0.1954907923936844,
0.5207309126853943,
-0.16522884368896484,
0.49173709750175476,
-0.5236281752586365,
0.5166305303573608,
0.6367238163948059,
0.2650757133960724,
0.3289821147918701,
-0.3061267137527466,
-0.1356724500656128,
0.000477944384329021,
-0.819179356098175,
-0.7961627244949341,
0.4093441665172577,
0.05953102186322212,
0.45110884308815,
0.8188144564628601,
0.33179888129234314,
0.8998096585273743,
-0.15139922499656677,
0.48746374249458313,
0.0510193407535553,
-0.7831035256385803,
0.37923479080200195,
-0.003334788838401437,
-0.2357206642627716,
0.3482808768749237,
1.2802988290786743,
-0.7392076253890991,
-0.22007443010807037,
-0.7811791300773621,
-0.8539639711380005,
0.7306368350982666,
0.07870981842279434,
-0.11172815412282944,
-0.09576491266489029,
0.14673654735088348,
-0.44831782579421997,
0.05536791682243347,
-0.46431946754455566,
-0.6259101033210754,
-0.19982591271400452,
-0.4416971206665039,
-0.08026251196861267,
-0.1328456848859787,
-0.3508055806159973,
-0.22250492870807648,
0.5630386471748352,
-0.02509421296417713,
0.49958038330078125,
0.35381513833999634,
0.34495440125465393,
-0.5692532658576965,
-0.019548609852790833,
0.24936406314373016,
0.37315231561660767,
-0.537125825881958,
0.7839887142181396,
-0.2502157688140869,
-0.8470233082771301,
0.2965950667858124,
0.4396360516548157,
0.23284873366355896,
0.15633244812488556,
0.4396270513534546,
0.5895965695381165,
-0.26844316720962524,
-0.5601377487182617,
0.5934178233146667,
-0.3620433807373047,
-0.06151294335722923,
-0.5570167303085327,
0.15906153619289398,
-0.08699026703834534,
0.2724177837371826,
0.5933356881141663,
0.44400981068611145,
0.22299697995185852,
-0.6636503338813782,
0.4507387578487396,
0.4262239336967468,
-0.6636322140693665,
-0.5999755263328552,
0.881361722946167,
-0.21464377641677856,
-0.8814058303833008,
0.4060957431793213,
-0.11489696800708771,
-0.5135249495506287,
0.8484770059585571,
0.4699300229549408,
0.9761362671852112,
-0.7363920211791992,
0.24400830268859863,
0.23564259707927704,
0.14864911139011383,
0.10770952701568604,
0.2044447511434555,
-0.07152416557073593,
-0.8503384590148926,
0.33324894309043884,
-0.5299469828605652,
-0.1925993710756302,
0.591575026512146,
-1.050352931022644,
0.4232800602912903,
-0.2899632453918457,
-0.7837719321250916,
0.39351096749305725,
0.0006800586706958711,
-0.6071736216545105,
0.33962470293045044,
0.2115534096956253,
0.6343544721603394,
-1.2949036359786987,
0.5778406262397766,
1.2859524488449097,
0.025899887084960938,
-0.6253552436828613,
0.7593389749526978,
0.07076040655374527,
-0.606035053730011,
0.3350050449371338,
0.2835928201675415,
-0.45244377851486206,
-0.06507229059934616,
-0.42799636721611023,
-0.9530326128005981,
1.0038602352142334,
-0.10513677448034286,
0.03590989112854004,
0.27700987458229065,
0.19377575814723969,
1.1470723152160645,
-0.3712442219257355,
-0.04739467054605484,
0.40881064534187317,
0.40259695053100586,
0.30877387523651123,
-0.5604711771011353,
0.10809207707643509,
-0.5365355014801025,
0.007525856141000986,
-0.005140603519976139,
-0.6507939696311951,
1.1421639919281006,
0.04848278686404228,
-0.4688218832015991,
-0.2152145951986313,
0.2878732681274414,
0.1324261575937271,
0.7134038805961609,
0.5881183743476868,
0.49789467453956604,
0.9238213300704956,
0.08081289380788803,
0.9541284441947937,
-0.9026626944541931,
0.2765082120895386,
0.9237703680992126,
-0.3169912099838257,
0.6962026953697205,
0.6209542155265808,
-0.08522357046604156,
0.46648526191711426,
0.5656670331954956,
0.1630842089653015,
0.5126486420631409,
-0.19559453427791595,
-0.4983876049518585,
-0.2689613401889801,
-0.6621360778808594,
-0.2244906723499298,
0.37859970331192017,
0.8205180168151855,
-0.22876136004924774,
-0.22696377336978912,
0.02074451744556427,
0.18222524225711823,
0.028570562601089478,
-0.28618285059928894,
0.40709105134010315,
0.04618363454937935,
-1.035338282585144,
0.4447190761566162,
0.23725800216197968,
0.14277051389217377,
-0.445637583732605,
-0.0025845193304121494,
-0.3032078742980957,
0.7670027017593384,
-0.17759177088737488,
-0.652589738368988,
0.6369327902793884,
-0.24065230786800385,
-0.15173408389091492,
-0.2633951008319855,
0.9108238220214844,
-0.41125717759132385,
-0.39775627851486206,
0.429482102394104,
0.6460926532745361,
-0.02045464888215065,
-0.06846148520708084,
-0.29394373297691345,
-0.2906588912010193,
-0.4341992735862732,
0.0016536281909793615,
0.08388237655162811,
0.1494772732257843,
-0.46269628405570984,
0.6052913069725037,
0.4475240707397461,
-0.12998975813388824,
-0.1077093780040741,
-0.1864200085401535,
0.905491054058075,
-0.18231157958507538,
-0.32848799228668213,
-0.8170881271362305,
0.19493669271469116,
-0.00849835854023695,
-0.23878511786460876,
0.8123024702072144,
0.4733094573020935,
0.5868141651153564,
-0.2557351291179657,
0.5608856081962585,
-0.2287866622209549,
0.5800665616989136,
0.05498502403497696,
0.4829750657081604,
-0.866546094417572,
0.015686163678765297,
0.016975615173578262,
-0.48723089694976807,
-0.41731181740760803,
0.5613069534301758,
-0.3128123879432678,
-0.08613435178995132,
1.0926250219345093,
0.9198654890060425,
-0.28533515334129333,
-0.0188000425696373,
-0.13785424828529358,
0.19520612061023712,
0.32720431685447693,
0.43573880195617676,
0.720733106136322,
-0.31576377153396606,
0.41932806372642517,
-0.34543779492378235,
-0.19126713275909424,
-0.3495883643627167,
-0.31473883986473083,
-0.8913506269454956,
-0.590061604976654,
-0.6051298379898071,
-0.5002865195274353,
0.1275257021188736,
0.8481690287590027,
0.4747474789619446,
-0.7983441352844238,
-0.135631263256073,
-0.23536160588264465,
0.674146294593811,
-0.7764597535133362,
-0.34894490242004395,
0.590497612953186,
0.0580243319272995,
-0.6326438188552856,
0.014741451479494572,
-0.27761998772621155,
0.15348073840141296,
-0.023366263136267662,
0.3816279470920563,
-0.19235330820083618,
0.11326282471418381,
0.3035973608493805,
0.12289256602525711,
-0.18454499542713165,
-0.2462286651134491,
0.10001993179321289,
-0.18443728983402252,
0.07531874626874924,
0.7624424695968628,
-0.40801864862442017,
0.27808430790901184,
0.3149755299091339,
0.29053640365600586,
0.4236295521259308,
0.5078375339508057,
0.06872956454753876,
-0.7885586023330688,
-0.23171363770961761,
0.09860409796237946,
0.23794245719909668,
0.09409338980913162,
-0.6457477807998657,
0.27352315187454224,
0.6001716256141663,
-0.30646708607673645,
-0.5646739602088928,
0.012816272675991058,
-0.9041263461112976,
-0.1761009693145752,
0.9243603944778442,
-0.047580599784851074,
-0.3000752925872803,
-0.29049763083457947,
-0.1717076450586319,
0.3126794397830963,
-0.3456172049045563,
1.3379358053207397,
0.6161056160926819,
-0.5207741260528564,
0.18156231939792633,
-0.39765986800193787,
0.612006425857544,
0.09911703318357468,
-0.6462904214859009,
-0.5469658374786377,
0.17478542029857635,
0.07639402896165848,
0.5880340933799744,
0.49380916357040405,
0.20852352678775787,
0.40029001235961914,
0.11448150873184204,
-0.07783673703670502,
0.19680878520011902,
-0.46059921383857727,
-0.29756903648376465,
0.3977757692337036,
-0.3118862509727478,
-0.4659133851528168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11218v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11218v2 | Controlled Text Generation for Large Language Model with Dynamic Attribute Graphs | 2024-02-17T08:14:37 | 2024-05-24T04:56:41 | Xun Liang, Hanyu Wang, Shichao Song, Mengting Hu, Xunzhi Wang, Zhiyu Li, Feiyu Xiong, Bo Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Controlled Text Generation (CTG) aims to produce texts that exhibit specific
desired attributes. In this study, we introduce a pluggable CTG framework for
Large Language Models (LLMs) named Dynamic Attribute Graphs-based controlled
text generation (DATG). This framework utilizes an attribute scorer to evaluate
the attributes of sentences generated by LLMs and constructs dynamic attribute
graphs. DATG modulates the occurrence of key attribute words and key
anti-attribute words, achieving effective attribute control without
compromising the original capabilities of the model. We conduct experiments
across four datasets in two tasks: toxicity mitigation and sentiment
transformation, employing five LLMs as foundational models. Our findings
highlight a remarkable enhancement in control accuracy, achieving a peak
improvement of 19.29% over baseline methods in the most favorable task across
four datasets. Additionally, we observe a significant decrease in perplexity,
markedly improving text fluency. | [
-0.026948340237140656,
-1.1495392322540283,
0.49982598423957825,
0.3236466944217682,
-0.18755394220352173,
0.3526839315891266,
-0.34905433654785156,
-0.2554379105567932,
-0.005811591167002916,
0.6785727739334106,
-0.6188482046127319,
-1.002465009689331,
-0.4949907958507538,
0.2998499572277069,
-0.3506872057914734,
1.0621143579483032,
-0.06658196449279785,
-0.3114163875579834,
-0.14287711679935455,
0.07412486523389816,
-0.6253184676170349,
-0.3463612496852875,
-0.8476278185844421,
-0.49727776646614075,
0.7839494347572327,
0.30274349451065063,
0.9314472675323486,
0.7497368454933167,
0.49272987246513367,
0.2778422236442566,
-0.18614433705806732,
0.5083453059196472,
-0.6347520351409912,
0.4262082576751709,
-0.10901553183794022,
-0.41007038950920105,
-0.8133289813995361,
0.10515846312046051,
0.6023220419883728,
0.24839872121810913,
0.010344431735575199,
-0.3129040598869324,
0.05193547159433365,
0.39606478810310364,
-0.44134464859962463,
0.23989208042621613,
-0.7409210205078125,
0.05890028551220894,
-0.12072692066431046,
-0.30695033073425293,
-0.7295017838478088,
-0.3752790689468384,
-0.09781984984874725,
-0.4850567877292633,
-0.16632938385009766,
-0.06753554195165634,
0.8499899506568909,
0.26519346237182617,
-0.8789361715316772,
-0.327648401260376,
-0.6562920212745667,
0.9408307075500488,
-0.8665323853492737,
0.09594208002090454,
0.2646150290966034,
-0.012177042663097382,
-0.5168202519416809,
-0.9392550587654114,
-0.6226790547370911,
-0.6049120426177979,
-0.19840601086616516,
0.26654288172721863,
-0.16687501966953278,
0.39310330152511597,
0.17078304290771484,
0.2856265604496002,
-0.4281860291957855,
0.45049262046813965,
0.35764676332473755,
-0.19761650264263153,
0.8259925246238708,
0.4831945300102234,
0.3823118507862091,
-0.4209592938423157,
-0.2593690752983093,
-0.12872736155986786,
-0.8960011005401611,
-0.18414223194122314,
0.4099920988082886,
0.29090020060539246,
0.13392652571201324,
0.5352253913879395,
-0.01705366000533104,
0.6332083344459534,
0.15267044305801392,
-0.28343576192855835,
0.13997063040733337,
-0.25596752762794495,
-0.16335703432559967,
-0.04843372479081154,
0.9691472053527832,
0.2733709216117859,
0.10634326189756393,
-0.09389461576938629,
-0.27534961700439453,
-0.08123428374528885,
0.32698941230773926,
-0.8402655124664307,
-0.3298289477825165,
0.30481499433517456,
-0.3070800304412842,
-0.965757429599762,
-0.31390249729156494,
-0.5149518847465515,
-0.5390944480895996,
-0.10807248950004578,
0.13924145698547363,
-0.6084641814231873,
-0.15788254141807556,
-0.05714137852191925,
0.213588148355484,
-0.0601261705160141,
0.34638485312461853,
-0.5067064166069031,
0.013906695879995823,
0.3055678606033325,
0.8169271349906921,
-0.6602592468261719,
0.10755515843629837,
-0.5064436197280884,
0.4639297127723694,
-0.3747138977050781,
0.6338667273521423,
-0.7663236260414124,
-0.42432689666748047,
0.14353907108306885,
-0.25335028767585754,
0.053294386714696884,
-0.34007102251052856,
0.4888049066066742,
-0.5507038235664368,
0.265613853931427,
0.04020066559314728,
-0.5818247199058533,
-0.0766487866640091,
0.45548778772354126,
-0.7904801964759827,
1.1970173120498657,
0.09405945986509323,
-0.767490565776825,
0.33393341302871704,
-0.591835081577301,
-0.6592636108398438,
0.24741895496845245,
-0.20036573708057404,
-0.6393574476242065,
-0.07431700825691223,
0.0184640996158123,
0.5327256917953491,
-0.2564973533153534,
0.3909651041030884,
-0.13097409904003143,
-0.030823267996311188,
0.5253307223320007,
-0.3670899569988251,
0.48483195900917053,
0.2649848461151123,
-0.29064932465553284,
0.365208238363266,
-1.004015326499939,
0.3004884421825409,
-0.061780959367752075,
-0.6860166192054749,
-0.28227919340133667,
0.32151156663894653,
0.20220111310482025,
0.09930277615785599,
0.2000940889120102,
-0.2834928631782532,
0.24315105378627777,
-0.11499827355146408,
0.392311692237854,
0.6024078130722046,
0.17138098180294037,
0.354918509721756,
-0.20426902174949646,
0.5933437943458557,
0.04611975699663162,
-0.23336046934127808,
-0.05605349689722061,
-0.1517924815416336,
-0.6782495379447937,
-0.4629706144332886,
0.18319553136825562,
0.5959604978561401,
-0.962321937084198,
0.9556447863578796,
-0.17804349958896637,
-0.5008098483085632,
0.2582891285419464,
0.009902913123369217,
0.3324481248855591,
0.331491619348526,
0.07790801674127579,
-0.15997639298439026,
-0.14913123846054077,
-0.6843624114990234,
-0.1871444582939148,
-0.28086432814598083,
-0.18080627918243408,
0.5116813778877258,
0.2794036269187927,
-0.16860637068748474,
0.8550158143043518,
-0.8568714261054993,
-0.2937639355659485,
-0.6141154170036316,
0.5623412132263184,
-0.07606633752584457,
0.5017785429954529,
0.810326099395752,
-0.661723256111145,
-0.5636574625968933,
-0.01765505038201809,
-0.3963797390460968,
-0.598161518573761,
-0.4184119701385498,
-0.3915051221847534,
0.2089429348707199,
0.5527175068855286,
-0.5552535057067871,
0.2646852433681488,
0.6391127109527588,
-0.2962256968021393,
0.7611998915672302,
-0.17970618605613708,
0.24465759098529816,
-1.1418795585632324,
0.11392886191606522,
0.06415396928787231,
-0.4719747304916382,
-0.8839269876480103,
0.11597888171672821,
0.07387247681617737,
-0.01492778304964304,
-0.40143996477127075,
0.3623947501182556,
-0.1379101574420929,
0.7312783002853394,
-0.4898521900177002,
0.07962750643491745,
-0.005247350782155991,
0.3819141387939453,
-0.01368285808712244,
0.6914269328117371,
0.34409773349761963,
-0.6652960181236267,
0.4962354004383087,
0.32685139775276184,
-0.2064821869134903,
0.6350041031837463,
-0.6225067973136902,
0.11478188633918762,
-0.002043426036834717,
0.41629502177238464,
-1.0009177923202515,
-0.3875729441642761,
-0.10148807615041733,
-0.19759708642959595,
0.5212538242340088,
0.36476996541023254,
-0.7884085178375244,
-0.36142823100090027,
-0.1751890629529953,
0.04577000066637993,
0.42475882172584534,
-0.12343501299619675,
0.5903279781341553,
0.17651204764842987,
-0.17396831512451172,
-0.15646497905254364,
-0.7292744517326355,
0.22776465117931366,
-0.32104453444480896,
-0.5143553614616394,
0.49561378359794617,
-0.048443928360939026,
-0.08018472045660019,
-0.18349908292293549,
0.21275034546852112,
-0.06681851297616959,
0.0872962474822998,
-0.03255101665854454,
0.023405196145176888,
0.017714446410536766,
0.6454580426216125,
0.3671492040157318,
0.05268377438187599,
-0.016497580334544182,
-0.06081383302807808,
0.7655168771743774,
0.34972208738327026,
0.09450751543045044,
-0.30225393176078796,
0.20765838027000427,
0.5559334754943848,
-0.4416336715221405,
0.8187830448150635,
0.4951404631137848,
-0.14075849950313568,
-0.5912371277809143,
-0.1295877993106842,
-0.08022282272577286,
-0.5569292306900024,
0.7390101552009583,
-0.28206032514572144,
-0.9692031741142273,
0.6830075979232788,
-0.19598199427127838,
0.07164882868528366,
0.23322691023349762,
0.7316866517066956,
-0.027215134352445602,
1.2736974954605103,
0.6528618335723877,
0.09944339841604233,
0.6883141994476318,
0.06703747063875198,
0.2620975971221924,
-0.36515048146247864,
-0.09720653295516968,
-0.28678831458091736,
-0.4999818503856659,
-0.9847174882888794,
-0.23184356093406677,
0.5765514373779297,
-0.050951991230249405,
-0.4021630883216858,
0.08608798682689667,
-0.41251906752586365,
0.3493534326553345,
0.2967919111251831,
0.5192071795463562,
0.3481917083263397,
-0.14617638289928436,
-0.10476099699735641,
-0.13556267321109772,
-0.6315909028053284,
-0.5556952357292175,
0.7958425283432007,
0.2914266288280487,
1.044416904449463,
0.0372810997068882,
0.32067492604255676,
0.4591715633869171,
0.3878827393054962,
-0.7574924230575562,
0.7668634057044983,
-0.5880248546600342,
-0.4286617934703827,
-0.27325063943862915,
-0.543868899345398,
-0.6340689063072205,
-0.07859282940626144,
-0.4971197545528412,
-0.582548201084137,
-0.32192057371139526,
0.32420116662979126,
-0.07758496701717377,
0.3491387963294983,
-0.40859395265579224,
0.4989641606807709,
-0.36555054783821106,
-0.5114627480506897,
-0.2850905656814575,
-0.26646727323532104,
0.4725210964679718,
-0.3447335958480835,
-0.23356389999389648,
-0.05513164401054382,
0.006229538936167955,
0.6607801914215088,
-0.4457932710647583,
0.8484343886375427,
0.1260826736688614,
-0.403000146150589,
0.38464200496673584,
0.38567620515823364,
0.8874910473823547,
-0.24427010118961334,
-0.27068454027175903,
-0.15078631043434143,
-0.3382752537727356,
-0.15911762416362762,
-0.43581458926200867,
0.9100977182388306,
-0.5310742855072021,
-0.5962482690811157,
-0.2692622244358063,
-1.1510945558547974,
-0.21275293827056885,
0.5605642795562744,
0.08239278197288513,
0.20857471227645874,
-0.18773460388183594,
0.4044210910797119,
0.7809671759605408,
-0.8293440341949463,
0.22254855930805206,
0.31433022022247314,
-0.20119722187519073,
-0.5036525726318359,
0.5810520052909851,
0.08638500422239304,
0.6316859126091003,
0.35897475481033325,
0.3206460177898407,
-0.12939725816249847,
-0.5859384536743164,
-0.14878010749816895,
0.24983155727386475,
-0.4887865483760834,
-0.4779190421104431,
-0.6764631867408752,
-0.3088363707065582,
-0.4456544518470764,
-0.21244946122169495,
-0.1348380297422409,
-0.27211859822273254,
-0.49521324038505554,
-0.32079318165779114,
0.801991879940033,
0.8569875955581665,
0.23494088649749756,
0.8849315047264099,
-0.6944860219955444,
-0.03791113942861557,
0.04311583563685417,
0.5073493123054504,
-0.07393746078014374,
-0.26991650462150574,
-0.19215254485607147,
0.015862345695495605,
-0.642201840877533,
-1.070874810218811,
0.5621840953826904,
0.2605445086956024,
0.24745048582553864,
0.43614494800567627,
0.1862066090106964,
0.45511868596076965,
-0.5170896053314209,
0.9581350088119507,
0.19988231360912323,
-1.0275743007659912,
0.5004169344902039,
-0.7433487772941589,
0.3875928223133087,
0.1960095465183258,
0.2096826434135437,
-0.46159252524375916,
-1.027981162071228,
-0.31267672777175903,
-0.9099670648574829,
0.6339806914329529,
0.41904377937316895,
0.39046868681907654,
-0.0693666934967041,
0.49646419286727905,
0.014726665802299976,
0.2995327115058899,
-0.807465672492981,
-0.17773908376693726,
-0.10595009475946426,
-0.5643162727355957,
0.24833367764949799,
-0.33242958784103394,
0.012968497350811958,
0.048374079167842865,
0.5646378993988037,
-0.0747368261218071,
-0.09209968894720078,
-0.2262856662273407,
0.01799919456243515,
-0.04951432719826698,
0.3142629861831665,
0.35982048511505127,
0.3186659514904022,
-0.12409782409667969,
0.32475700974464417,
0.14249831438064575,
-0.6219735741615295,
0.09269342571496964,
-0.18319661915302277,
-0.4378415644168854,
-0.20772163569927216,
0.2649611532688141,
0.7190974950790405,
-0.049413036555051804,
-0.5083575248718262,
0.2977217435836792,
0.2056674361228943,
-0.1200343519449234,
0.022864680737257004,
0.3607754409313202,
-0.09380627423524857,
-0.07736623287200928,
0.23746778070926666,
-0.5082538723945618,
-0.2239895612001419,
-0.28714171051979065,
0.35365158319473267,
0.4918166697025299,
-0.2971307039260864,
-0.13512535393238068,
0.861011266708374,
0.3718031048774719,
-0.029814695939421654,
0.5378280878067017,
-0.05854223296046257,
-0.602783203125,
0.49824392795562744,
0.8196495771408081,
0.7583005428314209,
-0.2184700071811676,
0.42017486691474915,
0.3271327316761017,
0.24122688174247742,
0.23729592561721802,
0.19835197925567627,
0.1939557045698166,
-0.7407605648040771,
-0.48131048679351807,
-0.48146069049835205,
-0.2264675498008728,
0.5121414661407471,
-0.2695282995700836,
0.5039970874786377,
-0.41876110434532166,
-0.3478015661239624,
-0.19707559049129486,
0.1865006983280182,
-0.33916470408439636,
0.4606345295906067,
-0.13841089606285095,
0.9041751027107239,
-1.0197292566299438,
0.7936829328536987,
0.6022197604179382,
-0.4864846467971802,
-0.8416299223899841,
0.06396445631980896,
-0.1921675056219101,
-0.3890729248523712,
0.6782171726226807,
-0.06008245423436165,
-0.05561516433954239,
0.28143736720085144,
-0.9037982225418091,
-0.7019571661949158,
1.2041010856628418,
0.10605999082326889,
-0.29948684573173523,
-0.017547879368066788,
0.4633609354496002,
0.8002891540527344,
-0.29597100615501404,
0.24540181457996368,
0.6263320446014404,
0.6481693387031555,
0.2779194414615631,
-0.7418563961982727,
0.234074205160141,
0.04550124332308769,
0.17009980976581573,
0.1689818948507309,
-0.6822658777236938,
0.7265067100524902,
0.170726016163826,
-0.2872854471206665,
0.13163161277770996,
0.8277227282524109,
0.23682329058647156,
-0.10327935218811035,
0.483938992023468,
0.378131628036499,
0.7867899537086487,
-0.23098060488700867,
0.8803529143333435,
-0.35561496019363403,
0.15043219923973083,
0.9277598857879639,
-0.458281546831131,
0.44310668110847473,
0.17487287521362305,
0.043890222907066345,
0.7099867463111877,
0.3837108612060547,
0.05351767688989639,
0.4317140281200409,
0.3430606424808502,
-0.4080774188041687,
-0.35223010182380676,
-0.3087116777896881,
0.15798638761043549,
0.47898608446121216,
0.31699010729789734,
-0.6356704831123352,
-0.21372869610786438,
0.09288221597671509,
0.46232497692108154,
0.24906131625175476,
-0.2984541654586792,
0.7611198425292969,
-0.17794904112815857,
-0.4444563388824463,
0.4105856418609619,
0.1352701038122177,
0.6126174926757812,
-0.8851245045661926,
-0.025818750262260437,
-0.28648898005485535,
0.2518237233161926,
-0.2531638741493225,
-1.002820611000061,
0.048618949949741364,
0.2326008379459381,
-0.03068823553621769,
-0.4920694828033447,
0.9256696105003357,
-0.7950046062469482,
-0.5583713054656982,
-0.15997081995010376,
0.24611085653305054,
-0.1258280724287033,
0.21824300289154053,
-0.38104552030563354,
-0.03041989728808403,
0.05905187502503395,
-0.5120185613632202,
0.052838779985904694,
0.6717387437820435,
-0.35715004801750183,
0.5971578359603882,
0.43935245275497437,
0.4819742441177368,
-0.0801938995718956,
-0.12818536162376404,
0.9318323731422424,
-0.583166241645813,
-0.547228217124939,
-0.7063462734222412,
0.588924765586853,
-0.1995161771774292,
-0.033024683594703674,
0.699909508228302,
0.39604994654655457,
0.50089430809021,
0.03961137309670448,
0.9889182448387146,
-0.36394256353378296,
0.3037985563278198,
-0.556425929069519,
1.118373155593872,
-0.4318482577800751,
0.09998437762260437,
-0.2671146094799042,
-0.6743191480636597,
-0.8410881757736206,
0.4321223199367523,
-0.31241852045059204,
0.07478294521570206,
0.7663718461990356,
0.9330278635025024,
0.12290197610855103,
-0.35388118028640747,
0.3164993226528168,
0.573489785194397,
1.0551191568374634,
0.4027007222175598,
0.515080451965332,
-0.05476763844490051,
0.4304564297199249,
0.02693716064095497,
-0.3917194604873657,
0.0808556005358696,
-1.337160587310791,
-0.9759856462478638,
-0.33137694001197815,
-0.4317062497138977,
-0.5579357147216797,
-0.21561245620250702,
0.7916693091392517,
0.28535783290863037,
-0.801068127155304,
-0.013183862902224064,
-0.3303350806236267,
0.1436692178249359,
-0.058021772652864456,
-0.3183697462081909,
0.5693533420562744,
-0.31465113162994385,
-0.8268005847930908,
-0.026806160807609558,
0.2069099396467209,
0.06438801437616348,
-0.3242691457271576,
-0.029591001570224762,
-0.0958053320646286,
0.4032381474971771,
0.7471626996994019,
-0.22298729419708252,
-0.371320903301239,
-0.6794665455818176,
-0.05211440101265907,
-0.4908733069896698,
-0.02836187370121479,
0.9390278458595276,
-0.6201246976852417,
0.3417551815509796,
0.7616444230079651,
0.2923666536808014,
0.1387491226196289,
0.09848769009113312,
0.7549504637718201,
-0.9363040924072266,
0.002937454031780362,
0.22999462485313416,
-0.07388193905353546,
0.2173788994550705,
-0.4232802093029022,
0.13633659482002258,
0.08316531032323837,
-0.6408590078353882,
-0.7769867181777954,
0.6183025240898132,
-0.9681227803230286,
-0.2594938278198242,
1.4393744468688965,
-0.14338193833827972,
-0.15536321699619293,
0.3008882403373718,
-0.3827773332595825,
0.5852063894271851,
-0.27374497056007385,
0.9172044396400452,
0.6285984516143799,
-0.26790040731430054,
-0.07509048283100128,
-0.02124628983438015,
0.6288444399833679,
0.12316569685935974,
-1.1270300149917603,
0.23232406377792358,
0.9332864284515381,
0.10272687673568726,
-0.08737689256668091,
0.3642493486404419,
-0.2056989222764969,
-0.0954110398888588,
-0.3707355856895447,
0.19646643102169037,
-0.11255180090665817,
-0.12199398130178452,
0.035800471901893616,
0.03737442195415497,
-0.06475253403186798,
0.16893890500068665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11217v1 | Asclepius: A Spectrum Evaluation Benchmark for Medical Multi-Modal Large Language Models | 2024-02-17T08:04:23 | 2024-02-17T08:04:23 | Wenxuan Wang, Yihang Su, Jingyuan Huan, Jie Liu, Wenting Chen, Yudi Zhang, Cheng-Yi Li, Kao-Jung Chang, Xiaohan Xin, Linlin Shen, Michael R. Lyu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | The significant breakthroughs of Medical Multi-Modal Large Language Models
(Med-MLLMs) renovate modern healthcare with robust information synthesis and
medical decision support. However, these models are often evaluated on
benchmarks that are unsuitable for the Med-MLLMs due to the intricate nature of
the real-world diagnostic frameworks, which encompass diverse medical
specialties and involve complex clinical decisions. Moreover, these benchmarks
are susceptible to data leakage, since Med-MLLMs are trained on large
assemblies of publicly available data. Thus, an isolated and clinically
representative benchmark is highly desirable for credible Med-MLLMs evaluation.
To this end, we introduce Asclepius, a novel Med-MLLM benchmark that rigorously
and comprehensively assesses model capability in terms of: distinct medical
specialties (cardiovascular, gastroenterology, etc.) and different diagnostic
capacities (perception, disease analysis, etc.). Grounded in 3 proposed core
principles, Asclepius ensures a comprehensive evaluation by encompassing 15
medical specialties, stratifying into 3 main categories and 8 sub-categories of
clinical tasks, and exempting from train-validate contamination. We further
provide an in-depth analysis of 6 Med-MLLMs and compare them with 5 human
specialists, providing insights into their competencies and limitations in
various medical contexts. Our work not only advances the understanding of
Med-MLLMs' capabilities but also sets a precedent for future evaluations and
the safe deployment of these models in clinical environments. We launch and
maintain a leaderboard for community assessment of Med-MLLM capabilities
(https://asclepius-med.github.io/). | [
-0.518561065196991,
-0.3172432780265808,
0.3790484368801117,
0.2794059216976166,
-0.08324074000120163,
0.2992968261241913,
-0.736184298992157,
-0.6479345560073853,
-0.026345038786530495,
0.6116642355918884,
-0.4242652356624603,
-0.5615754127502441,
-0.6049544811248779,
0.12882040441036224,
-0.2519545257091522,
0.8862777352333069,
0.22244204580783844,
0.5256600379943848,
-0.24594371020793915,
-0.4398561418056488,
-0.23992566764354706,
-0.5080872774124146,
-0.5071660876274109,
-0.245675191283226,
0.5099004507064819,
-0.011366753838956356,
0.5681010484695435,
0.2787502408027649,
0.7067338824272156,
0.25560933351516724,
-0.08318972587585449,
0.18401917815208435,
-0.06348739564418793,
0.1860560178756714,
-0.32437676191329956,
0.06454923003911972,
-0.5621606707572937,
0.020759442821145058,
0.7900611758232117,
1.1001646518707275,
-0.225942924618721,
0.39740797877311707,
0.031100748106837273,
0.8142104744911194,
-0.82159024477005,
-0.040046293288469315,
-0.4192560315132141,
-0.14112213253974915,
-0.23059332370758057,
0.04543694108724594,
-0.38379088044166565,
-0.42674851417541504,
0.04630410298705101,
-0.5898422002792358,
0.012664222158491611,
-0.12655453383922577,
0.6653715968132019,
0.3877454400062561,
-0.7303396463394165,
-0.2246204912662506,
-0.6117899417877197,
0.45533454418182373,
-0.4241984784603119,
0.560812771320343,
0.2047838717699051,
0.8537478446960449,
-0.008235540241003036,
-0.7766961455345154,
-0.13085883855819702,
-0.4982936382293701,
0.3249518871307373,
0.20597262680530548,
-0.16653724014759064,
-0.11373045295476913,
0.013255663216114044,
0.23066838085651398,
-0.5521916747093201,
0.171182781457901,
-0.7266301512718201,
-0.1421251893043518,
0.7064592838287354,
0.33470436930656433,
0.09990194439888,
-0.06049145758152008,
-0.5308411717414856,
-0.014350613579154015,
-0.7646839022636414,
0.06925319880247116,
0.07795614749193192,
0.07383545488119125,
-0.09216546267271042,
0.43437525629997253,
-0.06718206405639648,
0.5178573727607727,
-0.3417506814002991,
0.20532561838626862,
0.4966078996658325,
-0.34669846296310425,
-0.21474912762641907,
-0.21584205329418182,
0.9243879914283752,
0.30128926038742065,
-0.11841551214456558,
-0.10618352890014648,
0.04735380783677101,
0.4822351336479187,
0.6214653253555298,
-0.7656391263008118,
-0.35293105244636536,
0.2573741674423218,
-0.6136935949325562,
-0.39219391345977783,
-0.10488491505384445,
-0.7497085332870483,
-0.6078532934188843,
-0.10705449432134628,
0.218438521027565,
-0.59148108959198,
-0.43654316663742065,
0.23093119263648987,
0.06247290223836899,
-0.4449368417263031,
0.3175397217273712,
-0.44304877519607544,
0.6981997489929199,
0.7995957136154175,
0.2793198227882385,
-0.45559585094451904,
-0.22076751291751862,
-0.15701813995838165,
0.016680115833878517,
-0.416530042886734,
0.8371567130088806,
-0.9422464966773987,
-0.37585747241973877,
-0.11888082325458527,
-0.035033222287893295,
-0.20427919924259186,
-0.8843000531196594,
0.7943481802940369,
-0.18454588949680328,
-0.09746305644512177,
-0.21262666583061218,
-0.5542424917221069,
-0.29491549730300903,
0.22345994412899017,
-0.5734611749649048,
0.7794597744941711,
-0.1568278819322586,
-0.3776046633720398,
0.5445815324783325,
-0.815050482749939,
-0.2830124795436859,
0.09493003040552139,
-0.4766239523887634,
-0.5164295434951782,
0.20162181556224823,
0.03931117057800293,
0.2905586361885071,
-0.7792949676513672,
0.33025991916656494,
-0.6242491006851196,
0.008455973118543625,
0.7058771252632141,
-0.4390501379966736,
0.8265382647514343,
0.4797877073287964,
-0.031355518847703934,
0.4788972735404968,
-0.8573983311653137,
0.2734302282333374,
-0.14733697474002838,
-0.3722086250782013,
-0.20814958214759827,
0.06671140342950821,
0.42206403613090515,
0.27560660243034363,
0.10462921857833862,
-0.5688881278038025,
0.12154769897460938,
-0.10957127064466476,
0.5624991059303284,
0.42940375208854675,
0.02486148662865162,
0.05477983132004738,
-0.3512902855873108,
0.5262498259544373,
-0.2195347100496292,
0.4745452404022217,
0.036306414753198624,
-0.5610978603363037,
-0.10444885492324829,
-0.9391468167304993,
0.465753436088562,
0.20707295835018158,
-0.4285634458065033,
0.5437126755714417,
-0.22068703174591064,
-0.877663791179657,
-0.6668304204940796,
-0.1517704427242279,
0.5142324566841125,
0.24818755686283112,
0.2858559489250183,
-0.38647112250328064,
-0.1946180760860443,
-0.9583892822265625,
-0.3918561041355133,
0.19714657962322235,
-0.17004331946372986,
0.36229652166366577,
0.470234215259552,
-0.5518321990966797,
0.29703813791275024,
-0.291743665933609,
-0.2892712652683258,
-0.04305668920278549,
-0.12710857391357422,
0.23236651718616486,
0.5616719722747803,
0.34564119577407837,
-0.5930589437484741,
-0.261472225189209,
0.0559944286942482,
-0.6339390873908997,
-0.10451425611972809,
0.27876994013786316,
0.23268306255340576,
-0.019679170101881027,
0.343189001083374,
-0.43175414204597473,
0.17231710255146027,
0.9139072299003601,
-0.7724775075912476,
0.7272027134895325,
-0.6242012977600098,
0.36228764057159424,
-0.735801637172699,
0.6746988892555237,
-0.17514674365520477,
-0.22336827218532562,
-0.49139222502708435,
0.4798923134803772,
0.3662804365158081,
-0.4025631844997406,
-0.025162655860185623,
0.4411497116088867,
-0.45665445923805237,
-0.2293877750635147,
-0.06411350518465042,
-0.04832887649536133,
-0.06157732009887695,
0.1313842087984085,
-0.07773718982934952,
0.17992161214351654,
0.7073253989219666,
-0.4965563118457794,
0.15752024948596954,
0.03644673153758049,
-0.41879576444625854,
0.5795319080352783,
-0.42641448974609375,
-0.17183366417884827,
0.32202327251434326,
0.35880404710769653,
-0.7219923138618469,
0.15240848064422607,
0.018953202292323112,
-0.5953385829925537,
0.2235809862613678,
-0.07897176593542099,
-0.7360519766807556,
-0.5992000699043274,
-0.22984959185123444,
0.6535743474960327,
0.49383991956710815,
-0.09980156272649765,
0.47459033131599426,
0.5637514591217041,
0.09146714955568314,
-0.4203437268733978,
-0.18397071957588196,
-0.02820013090968132,
-0.11062110215425491,
-0.56746506690979,
0.0630149245262146,
-0.32960236072540283,
-0.18298892676830292,
0.010846336372196674,
-0.28001531958580017,
-0.2472226917743683,
0.3476364016532898,
0.5858649611473083,
0.49515753984451294,
-0.3249737620353699,
0.2500648498535156,
0.05152402073144913,
-0.385149210691452,
0.13905982673168182,
0.01578856259584427,
0.40897610783576965,
-0.2755865752696991,
-0.9017429947853088,
-0.2527671754360199,
0.22658929228782654,
1.0089342594146729,
-0.5527551174163818,
0.2726101577281952,
0.5311765670776367,
-0.5838900208473206,
0.10429324209690094,
-0.7233884334564209,
-0.23754748702049255,
-0.39360764622688293,
0.5349950194358826,
-0.3088114857673645,
-0.6376755833625793,
0.47878751158714294,
-0.18425041437149048,
0.10926546156406403,
0.49487513303756714,
0.7511471509933472,
-0.15004891157150269,
0.7771799564361572,
0.12112613022327423,
0.21761545538902283,
-0.10248902440071106,
0.0038107167929410934,
-0.20633459091186523,
-0.9361996650695801,
-0.2378312051296234,
-0.42810672521591187,
-0.2672154903411865,
-0.48941770195961,
-0.8604487776756287,
0.8512393832206726,
-0.14666061103343964,
-0.3135099709033966,
-0.13377828896045685,
-0.6850640177726746,
0.07995544373989105,
0.11448578536510468,
0.2518259882926941,
0.46984946727752686,
-0.1304713934659958,
-0.1898486316204071,
-0.16625837981700897,
-0.4476243853569031,
-0.36525315046310425,
1.6798160076141357,
0.6263962388038635,
0.5106033086776733,
0.11630749702453613,
0.33514246344566345,
0.19191768765449524,
0.5520708560943604,
-0.4532622992992401,
0.3865453600883484,
-0.5363050699234009,
-1.0987061262130737,
-0.1504061371088028,
-0.30003926157951355,
-1.1970860958099365,
0.602364182472229,
-0.7106062173843384,
-0.5761615633964539,
0.04047786071896553,
0.02998032234609127,
-0.671394407749176,
0.19837425649166107,
-0.3022622764110565,
1.0578848123550415,
-0.09335703402757645,
-0.1834011971950531,
-0.7348054051399231,
-0.6171148419380188,
0.2453562319278717,
-0.20688512921333313,
0.39779970049858093,
-0.5659826397895813,
-0.589394748210907,
0.5112388730049133,
-0.32201337814331055,
0.5984370112419128,
-0.14065015316009521,
0.31695130467414856,
-0.1262606382369995,
0.16764917969703674,
-0.04892384633421898,
0.09394614398479462,
0.005208865273743868,
0.4280388057231903,
0.38515543937683105,
-0.3478400707244873,
-0.3286850154399872,
0.5809219479560852,
-0.7328287363052368,
-0.03991840034723282,
-0.38664594292640686,
-0.4531833529472351,
-0.5932242274284363,
0.2347390204668045,
0.2658625543117523,
0.7713816165924072,
-0.2436465620994568,
0.35863441228866577,
0.6550881862640381,
-0.3600391745567322,
0.11183301359415054,
0.9022901654243469,
-0.40729501843452454,
-0.5603221654891968,
0.8982823491096497,
-0.13451676070690155,
0.2180592566728592,
-0.0075334543362259865,
0.2503410279750824,
-0.2504345774650574,
-0.7877621650695801,
-0.596226692199707,
0.25914570689201355,
-0.497273325920105,
-0.12227948009967804,
-0.6942163705825806,
-0.1261475682258606,
-0.035461995750665665,
-0.21376962959766388,
-0.9019074440002441,
-0.2681944966316223,
0.1957789659500122,
0.40887007117271423,
0.09105449169874191,
0.7320757508277893,
0.09066907316446304,
-0.31825435161590576,
-0.7974339127540588,
0.22831682860851288,
-0.05580541491508484,
0.40580788254737854,
-0.1498272716999054,
-0.22020362317562103,
0.05814203992486,
-0.3223291039466858,
-0.28473740816116333,
-0.8107873797416687,
0.19684109091758728,
0.028542231768369675,
0.871808648109436,
0.5795449018478394,
-0.0195765383541584,
0.39719158411026,
-0.5869449377059937,
0.47419899702072144,
0.5083547234535217,
-0.8987846374511719,
0.2609114348888397,
-0.44805917143821716,
0.1611948162317276,
0.8461982011795044,
0.17212752997875214,
-0.4942503869533539,
-0.6429885625839233,
-0.7710685133934021,
-0.8720255494117737,
0.24275736510753632,
0.2659434378147125,
-0.3773159384727478,
0.17920738458633423,
-0.009761256165802479,
0.2215331345796585,
0.4677220284938812,
-0.4982331693172455,
-0.348698228597641,
0.10703005641698837,
-0.2739933133125305,
-0.15121637284755707,
-0.03739279881119728,
-0.5080834031105042,
-0.448338121175766,
0.36106929183006287,
-0.06691088527441025,
0.2254657745361328,
0.09732130169868469,
-0.01872880756855011,
0.15083491802215576,
0.38064393401145935,
0.7730352878570557,
0.7999634146690369,
0.038194019347429276,
0.2677132189273834,
0.264570027589798,
-0.6249469518661499,
-0.040312401950359344,
0.24178418517112732,
0.4625300467014313,
-0.14115576446056366,
0.4223949909210205,
0.09672839939594269,
0.5480436086654663,
-1.078668475151062,
0.7513362765312195,
0.007257948629558086,
0.04058612883090973,
-0.42452529072761536,
-0.15186123549938202,
0.24200035631656647,
0.42111194133758545,
0.40102460980415344,
0.7543492317199707,
0.32914605736732483,
-0.501711905002594,
0.3287620544433594,
0.42279696464538574,
-0.59418785572052,
-0.3482070863246918,
0.7832401394844055,
0.30377325415611267,
0.10848898440599442,
0.3603930175304413,
-0.10591306537389755,
-0.2203085571527481,
0.6705809831619263,
0.3986230790615082,
0.650368332862854,
-0.4674525856971741,
-0.21307802200317383,
0.37510356307029724,
0.35507839918136597,
0.10601212829351425,
0.23057137429714203,
0.002155651105567813,
-0.45029789209365845,
-0.2575591802597046,
-0.4917328357696533,
-0.2355170100927353,
-0.1485988348722458,
-0.9617805480957031,
0.2870258688926697,
-0.6893740892410278,
-0.4098411202430725,
0.3378269076347351,
0.0024989014491438866,
-0.5772016644477844,
0.14097128808498383,
0.3897750675678253,
1.048728585243225,
-0.7392001748085022,
1.08599054813385,
0.8356207013130188,
-0.057497359812259674,
-0.42297226190567017,
-0.25853919982910156,
0.08762011677026749,
-0.9242863655090332,
0.5844658613204956,
0.0752527266740799,
0.05963704735040665,
-0.4750296175479889,
0.030426934361457825,
-0.7135547399520874,
0.9582619071006775,
0.4978547990322113,
-0.4373847246170044,
0.10551950335502625,
-0.21571481227874756,
0.7788218855857849,
-0.5366351008415222,
0.25847792625427246,
0.3458598554134369,
0.5048715472221375,
0.022037673741579056,
-1.4175108671188354,
0.3430938422679901,
-0.46963730454444885,
-0.15082603693008423,
0.039432767778635025,
-0.46550706028938293,
0.83141028881073,
-0.25344231724739075,
-0.07820738852024078,
0.18448854982852936,
0.08129990100860596,
0.4792954921722412,
0.42898252606391907,
0.4308985769748688,
0.43618035316467285,
0.8252413272857666,
-0.0895695611834526,
1.2112059593200684,
-0.6088963150978088,
0.36873680353164673,
0.9043439626693726,
-0.2761734127998352,
1.052437663078308,
0.17280088365077972,
-0.28670594096183777,
0.34873953461647034,
0.48325636982917786,
-0.18698595464229584,
0.37802332639694214,
0.22047610580921173,
-0.31616678833961487,
-0.4874687194824219,
0.17014263570308685,
-0.7692850232124329,
0.3167744576931,
0.565584123134613,
-0.4587782919406891,
-0.05587898567318916,
0.16471002995967865,
-0.011397745460271835,
0.12157141417264938,
-0.4402051568031311,
0.5852242112159729,
-0.04139295592904091,
-0.39942559599876404,
0.7105736136436462,
-0.19584010541439056,
0.32672804594039917,
-0.684593915939331,
0.2872737944126129,
0.37583285570144653,
0.4646591544151306,
-0.32353097200393677,
-0.532306969165802,
0.4329126477241516,
-0.28099963068962097,
-0.03156202659010887,
0.09339589625597,
0.5424226522445679,
-0.22733663022518158,
-0.6804417967796326,
0.39173591136932373,
0.24284125864505768,
0.0768686980009079,
-0.23694536089897156,
-0.7862356305122375,
0.3928719460964203,
-0.2840808928012848,
0.12505468726158142,
0.19224897027015686,
0.1663200408220291,
0.05001422017812729,
0.9635586738586426,
0.5856373906135559,
0.35608038306236267,
-0.1017007827758789,
-0.12999221682548523,
0.9515901803970337,
-0.4895767569541931,
-0.46981126070022583,
-0.7955220937728882,
0.5482729077339172,
-0.17845690250396729,
-0.40975040197372437,
0.6749666333198547,
0.9300714731216431,
0.29447653889656067,
0.032635148614645004,
0.5903520584106445,
0.20042434334754944,
0.6043890118598938,
-0.19018077850341797,
1.1647841930389404,
-0.6895396113395691,
0.2772623896598816,
-0.21676120162010193,
-0.5716866850852966,
-0.3228049576282501,
0.41874030232429504,
-0.3778359293937683,
-0.1531103551387787,
0.988307774066925,
0.2905041575431824,
-0.016488557681441307,
0.13018301129341125,
0.5532359480857849,
0.21618977189064026,
0.16223439574241638,
0.7001599073410034,
0.9083644151687622,
-0.15128932893276215,
0.4046088457107544,
0.15628385543823242,
-0.40031495690345764,
-0.29440441727638245,
-0.4084407687187195,
-0.9482677578926086,
-0.6384562849998474,
-0.42127248644828796,
-0.34087520837783813,
0.1003403589129448,
1.1088535785675049,
0.8757909536361694,
-0.7328215837478638,
-0.2853127419948578,
0.3335302174091339,
-0.12536101043224335,
-0.5582388043403625,
-0.08337542414665222,
0.3156697750091553,
-0.1016099750995636,
-0.284381628036499,
0.5460518002510071,
0.5305359959602356,
-0.3798941671848297,
-0.4281793236732483,
0.18877474963665009,
0.3753134310245514,
-0.06296124309301376,
0.5509901642799377,
0.1522769033908844,
-0.8403157591819763,
-0.02318563684821129,
-0.3745945692062378,
-0.31417039036750793,
0.09852442890405655,
1.080922245979309,
-0.6251468062400818,
0.6271864175796509,
-0.024945683777332306,
0.6474739909172058,
0.4282519221305847,
-0.48876115679740906,
0.43967190384864807,
-0.11109654605388641,
0.04346388578414917,
0.65633225440979,
0.4263855814933777,
0.09677640348672867,
0.12044369429349899,
0.4261700510978699,
0.2098848968744278,
-0.4065701961517334,
-1.0485931634902954,
0.10298850387334824,
-1.130584478378296,
-0.5994406342506409,
1.1393972635269165,
-0.23785369098186493,
0.006809467915445566,
-0.3782193064689636,
-0.019546909257769585,
-0.11689013987779617,
-0.29605767130851746,
0.6749057173728943,
0.19003312289714813,
-0.1751670241355896,
0.26881876587867737,
-0.8736270666122437,
0.5814371705055237,
0.3691766858100891,
-0.8740781545639038,
0.10954748839139938,
0.5025967955589294,
0.7365899085998535,
0.16447672247886658,
0.7146754264831543,
-0.5059691667556763,
0.5410986542701721,
0.05613322928547859,
0.2947583496570587,
-0.2468339502811432,
-0.20001749694347382,
-0.39690738916397095,
0.5459803938865662,
0.03734787553548813,
-0.17950305342674255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11208v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11208v1 | Watch Out for Your Agents! Investigating Backdoor Threats to LLM-Based Agents | 2024-02-17T06:48:45 | 2024-02-17T06:48:45 | Wenkai Yang, Xiaohan Bi, Yankai Lin, Sishuo Chen, Jie Zhou, Xu Sun | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Leveraging the rapid development of Large Language Models LLMs, LLM-based
agents have been developed to handle various real-world applications, including
finance, healthcare, and shopping, etc. It is crucial to ensure the reliability
and security of LLM-based agents during applications. However, the safety
issues of LLM-based agents are currently under-explored. In this work, we take
the first step to investigate one of the typical safety threats, backdoor
attack, to LLM-based agents. We first formulate a general framework of agent
backdoor attacks, then we present a thorough analysis on the different forms of
agent backdoor attacks. Specifically, from the perspective of the final
attacking outcomes, the attacker can either choose to manipulate the final
output distribution, or only introduce malicious behavior in the intermediate
reasoning process, while keeping the final output correct. Furthermore, the
former category can be divided into two subcategories based on trigger
locations: the backdoor trigger can be hidden either in the user query or in an
intermediate observation returned by the external environment. We propose the
corresponding data poisoning mechanisms to implement the above variations of
agent backdoor attacks on two typical agent tasks, web shopping and tool
utilization. Extensive experiments show that LLM-based agents suffer severely
from backdoor attacks, indicating an urgent need for further research on the
development of defenses against backdoor attacks on LLM-based agents. Warning:
This paper may contain biased content. | [
-0.16978669166564941,
-0.8348695635795593,
0.5889531373977661,
-0.17624011635780334,
0.17350491881370544,
0.12002125382423401,
0.26272594928741455,
-0.7330175042152405,
-0.035522595047950745,
0.9988013505935669,
-0.674200177192688,
-0.7279170751571655,
-0.3022598624229431,
-0.0656624287366867,
-0.4597298800945282,
0.8403522372245789,
0.19184690713882446,
-0.038653045892715454,
-0.1474132090806961,
0.3044604957103729,
-0.46760061383247375,
-0.8563860654830933,
-0.6597518920898438,
-0.2285580039024353,
0.882929265499115,
0.3650137782096863,
0.8330612778663635,
0.26635417342185974,
0.5051696300506592,
0.3770180642604828,
0.29880329966545105,
-0.27096906304359436,
-0.4875141382217407,
0.4579825699329376,
-0.3740319311618805,
-0.5495398640632629,
-0.6525119543075562,
0.05251958221197128,
0.034655649214982986,
0.08961053192615509,
-0.011575124226510525,
0.13640300929546356,
-0.1571057289838791,
0.573651909828186,
-0.7064871788024902,
-0.1402014195919037,
-0.7371699810028076,
0.07278089970350266,
-0.17216326296329498,
-0.4598623812198639,
-0.6732235550880432,
-0.383327841758728,
-0.27405884861946106,
-0.14860481023788452,
0.11496936529874802,
0.03719532862305641,
0.5415924191474915,
0.37673163414001465,
-0.489762544631958,
-0.31687185168266296,
-0.41398900747299194,
0.38142290711402893,
-0.45479002594947815,
0.2052692472934723,
0.40165793895721436,
0.5136864185333252,
-0.5489199757575989,
-0.5195381045341492,
-0.37310776114463806,
-0.37710005044937134,
-0.10999027639627457,
0.11252281069755554,
-0.4127776622772217,
0.04967175051569939,
0.09093505889177322,
0.09593315422534943,
-0.7135018110275269,
0.3617790937423706,
0.053963396698236465,
-0.3472551107406616,
0.8497729897499084,
0.425763875246048,
0.4172433316707611,
0.2430519312620163,
-0.40857335925102234,
-0.1904689222574234,
-1.1071306467056274,
-0.1597747802734375,
0.7599768042564392,
0.2256852686405182,
-0.07976236939430237,
0.709520161151886,
-0.033243052661418915,
0.2450106292963028,
-0.06462816894054413,
0.12517790496349335,
-0.1243031769990921,
-0.28599780797958374,
-0.10224206745624542,
-0.044409915804862976,
0.4765726923942566,
0.4607105851173401,
0.17081335186958313,
-0.464805543422699,
-0.4286448359489441,
-0.19620633125305176,
0.5427529811859131,
-0.49106839299201965,
0.2707260847091675,
0.5481310486793518,
-0.28491175174713135,
-0.8269335627555847,
-0.057904232293367386,
-0.7701050043106079,
-0.5110700726509094,
0.5300647020339966,
0.4429001212120056,
-0.06772737205028534,
-0.06509895622730255,
-0.2965763807296753,
0.011398610658943653,
0.5861109495162964,
0.22085221111774445,
-0.596811830997467,
0.46427810192108154,
0.9321145415306091,
0.573274552822113,
-0.13619381189346313,
-0.45344051718711853,
-0.6149680018424988,
0.5292080044746399,
-0.28279703855514526,
0.7006645202636719,
-0.2791641354560852,
-0.6266880035400391,
0.26784583926200867,
0.1103048250079155,
0.06434803456068039,
-0.5504227876663208,
0.09620800614356995,
-0.9080901145935059,
0.014357779175043106,
-0.06077132001519203,
-0.18796256184577942,
-0.17677392065525055,
0.6416512131690979,
-0.6037656664848328,
0.5996188521385193,
-0.08340737223625183,
-0.7733590006828308,
-0.03913411125540733,
-0.42342421412467957,
-0.4578935205936432,
-0.05464598163962364,
-0.110401451587677,
-0.2625117599964142,
-0.02432982623577118,
-0.08068756759166718,
0.38878965377807617,
-0.11764821410179138,
-0.31648969650268555,
-0.38342413306236267,
-0.3061721920967102,
0.7612046599388123,
-0.47169971466064453,
0.6583232283592224,
0.09042156487703323,
-0.2291494607925415,
0.17929108440876007,
-0.4731954336166382,
-0.045771386474370956,
0.1553228795528412,
-0.10370675474405289,
-0.10333771258592606,
-0.14498744904994965,
-0.20258723199367523,
0.2352394312620163,
0.5474021434783936,
-0.5254495143890381,
0.1228490024805069,
-0.4411216378211975,
-0.0064026969484984875,
0.9769608974456787,
0.3730708360671997,
0.3400863707065582,
-0.4375547468662262,
0.7676838636398315,
0.06246974691748619,
0.5486101508140564,
-0.0633741244673729,
-0.41468968987464905,
-0.20665711164474487,
-0.079926997423172,
-0.13235650956630707,
0.8039464950561523,
-0.7407276034355164,
0.3049044609069824,
0.378353476524353,
-0.5986489057540894,
-0.05621836334466934,
-0.12555691599845886,
0.4629182815551758,
0.3688775897026062,
-0.022976672276854515,
-0.09843643009662628,
-0.008121845312416553,
-0.5746862888336182,
-0.4522646367549896,
-0.20947706699371338,
0.06847678869962692,
0.31498780846595764,
0.664269208908081,
-0.7410262823104858,
0.844737708568573,
-0.6111735105514526,
-0.1976173222064972,
-0.14392155408859253,
-0.48532846570014954,
0.06976235657930374,
0.5526520609855652,
0.6389626860618591,
-0.5494264960289001,
-0.20925529301166534,
-0.041302941739559174,
-0.743846595287323,
-0.13500221073627472,
-0.0005506623419933021,
-0.2375393807888031,
0.4354586601257324,
0.5153270959854126,
-0.9013743996620178,
0.7006219029426575,
0.39230579137802124,
-0.32371267676353455,
0.5431298017501831,
-0.018530365079641342,
-0.35740426182746887,
-0.9491556286811829,
-0.11562124639749527,
-0.21345973014831543,
-0.2413518875837326,
-0.6921874284744263,
0.3050680458545685,
-0.18263322114944458,
-0.3909432590007782,
-0.6429247260093689,
0.619061291217804,
-0.17920349538326263,
-0.39392587542533875,
-0.25195854902267456,
-0.11498260498046875,
0.016788672655820847,
0.40631747245788574,
-0.261472225189209,
0.8310528993606567,
0.604620099067688,
-0.3528284728527069,
0.6833680272102356,
-0.04822701960802078,
0.23981286585330963,
0.17136694490909576,
-0.44942134618759155,
0.5422810316085815,
0.22665953636169434,
0.3735128939151764,
-0.8007704615592957,
-0.16673122346401215,
1.0094784498214722,
-0.6856454014778137,
0.5139210820198059,
-0.10907813906669617,
-0.5626739859580994,
0.0020536945667117834,
-0.6980444192886353,
0.05778069049119949,
0.16741520166397095,
-0.490407794713974,
0.6430838704109192,
0.31205102801322937,
-0.10036477446556091,
-0.7889940142631531,
-0.7287237644195557,
0.1703399270772934,
-0.3710954785346985,
-0.8144742846488953,
-0.20348304510116577,
-0.08045351505279541,
-0.6295315623283386,
-0.060745496302843094,
-0.27274852991104126,
-0.05056053400039673,
0.47356438636779785,
0.48850157856941223,
0.13662956655025482,
-0.0938025638461113,
-0.1569489687681198,
-0.16162383556365967,
-0.4167320132255554,
0.4672747254371643,
-0.1472494900226593,
0.43425461649894714,
-0.0025283382274210453,
-0.723284125328064,
-0.3657245337963104,
0.7108938097953796,
0.4844881594181061,
0.018706096336245537,
0.7925585508346558,
0.20976218581199646,
-0.2987997233867645,
-0.19136230647563934,
-0.4736930727958679,
-0.5660753846168518,
-0.5758243799209595,
0.3338244557380676,
-0.33572372794151306,
-0.33519354462623596,
0.576252281665802,
0.10786785185337067,
0.004052625969052315,
0.09558402001857758,
0.6130882501602173,
-0.07541237771511078,
0.8672872185707092,
0.7596691250801086,
-0.11609309911727905,
0.2739062011241913,
-0.2147219330072403,
0.0072998846881091595,
-0.41438165307044983,
-0.4141418933868408,
-0.4191359877586365,
0.1273568868637085,
-0.8190546631813049,
-0.11779668182134628,
0.1516389399766922,
-0.43468406796455383,
-0.07798568904399872,
0.1407758891582489,
0.056166887283325195,
0.43405982851982117,
0.3863961398601532,
0.1473892480134964,
0.3131648004055023,
-0.1737867146730423,
-0.007370998151600361,
0.3509446084499359,
-0.5044234395027161,
-0.5707753300666809,
1.1823415756225586,
0.5851216912269592,
1.306613802909851,
0.29703691601753235,
1.004241704940796,
0.608880341053009,
0.287192702293396,
-0.6415245532989502,
0.6840947270393372,
0.28623679280281067,
-0.7033327221870422,
-0.301076740026474,
-0.23494307696819305,
-1.0719290971755981,
0.31942018866539,
0.2589702010154724,
-0.7872498631477356,
0.14637809991836548,
-0.006325070280581713,
-0.07346838712692261,
0.1871575564146042,
-0.7195805907249451,
0.8487566709518433,
-0.5937128663063049,
-0.537555992603302,
-0.13213668763637543,
-0.7499644160270691,
0.21158742904663086,
-0.2684311270713806,
0.16398285329341888,
-0.07578862458467484,
-0.05642038211226463,
0.23961617052555084,
-0.6527009606361389,
1.0844236612319946,
-0.044675108045339584,
-0.4774860441684723,
0.19660642743110657,
0.2430385947227478,
0.6836066246032715,
0.34647446870803833,
0.041950251907110214,
0.3460463881492615,
-0.037298042327165604,
-0.4768786132335663,
-0.4581799805164337,
0.6082466244697571,
-0.612417995929718,
-1.057307243347168,
-0.7638014554977417,
-0.4048808515071869,
-0.20968101918697357,
0.1811182200908661,
0.38236314058303833,
0.16382364928722382,
-0.009979123249650002,
-0.2322821021080017,
0.3013708293437958,
-0.31301605701446533,
0.45849111676216125,
0.8137988448143005,
-0.1046057641506195,
-0.11355579644441605,
0.889228105545044,
-0.058172836899757385,
0.38775214552879333,
0.42605507373809814,
0.19999447464942932,
-0.2720385491847992,
-0.6953308582305908,
-0.21959160268306732,
0.2784712016582489,
-0.8023524284362793,
-0.3079671263694763,
-0.2824475169181824,
-0.19599390029907227,
-0.7439073920249939,
-0.018370797857642174,
-0.3406440317630768,
0.06755875051021576,
-0.2925024628639221,
-0.05828071013092995,
0.38012897968292236,
0.7845467329025269,
-0.19416086375713348,
0.4144786298274994,
-0.812684953212738,
0.08924029767513275,
0.3457491099834442,
0.09111511707305908,
-0.04705067723989487,
-0.011231793090701103,
-0.4283493459224701,
-0.15840692818164825,
-0.43096575140953064,
-1.197928786277771,
0.5641531944274902,
-0.4337838590145111,
0.72966468334198,
0.48758313059806824,
0.28089722990989685,
-0.045609936118125916,
-0.24420464038848877,
0.5942099094390869,
-0.11898822337388992,
-0.6029425859451294,
0.4474926292896271,
-0.29859182238578796,
-0.26610684394836426,
0.28219062089920044,
0.2009260058403015,
-0.37437427043914795,
-0.5765859484672546,
-0.5143571496009827,
-0.8993701338768005,
0.48082152009010315,
0.2491265833377838,
0.016840416938066483,
0.11087547987699509,
0.2033412754535675,
0.1898135095834732,
0.47351473569869995,
-0.5731292963027954,
-0.13845191895961761,
-0.04954329505562782,
0.218096524477005,
0.01833074726164341,
-0.21983861923217773,
-0.3153534531593323,
0.4650728404521942,
0.5973506569862366,
0.011866231448948383,
0.0024022057186812162,
0.11426209658384323,
-0.27198541164398193,
-0.2555427551269531,
0.2844402492046356,
0.45968908071517944,
0.40136393904685974,
-0.19234001636505127,
0.2116824984550476,
0.10546675324440002,
-0.7106202244758606,
0.09164287149906158,
0.09887009859085083,
-0.1264367699623108,
-0.33406445384025574,
0.40842974185943604,
-0.013107524253427982,
-0.09321065247058868,
-0.6993638277053833,
0.5497415065765381,
-0.2601391077041626,
0.3904891610145569,
-0.7426866888999939,
0.03682345896959305,
-0.2399977147579193,
0.6669520139694214,
0.31243252754211426,
-0.18741123378276825,
0.13796083629131317,
-0.8298174738883972,
0.19104638695716858,
0.6012628078460693,
-0.26646387577056885,
-0.35052257776260376,
0.21780100464820862,
0.3003627359867096,
-0.4587516188621521,
0.4067176580429077,
0.08893139660358429,
-0.6404388546943665,
0.823829710483551,
0.5999047756195068,
1.213087558746338,
-0.31468066573143005,
-0.14823153614997864,
-0.6408941745758057,
0.7044724225997925,
0.4033780097961426,
0.31007951498031616,
-0.0024515644181519747,
-0.8815436363220215,
0.07763342559337616,
-0.17899742722511292,
-0.8443835973739624,
0.16663628816604614,
-0.4059601128101349,
-0.017417415976524353,
-0.4909214675426483,
-0.14890645444393158,
-0.4577057957649231,
0.11403650045394897,
-0.18555502593517303,
0.04289914295077324,
0.27599748969078064,
0.7788985967636108,
-0.6380447149276733,
0.7631472945213318,
0.48884809017181396,
-0.3618098795413971,
-0.3772895932197571,
0.45895665884017944,
0.2217429131269455,
-0.846934974193573,
0.6247943639755249,
0.1811070591211319,
-0.5776850581169128,
-0.24979129433631897,
-0.6641244888305664,
-0.5974816679954529,
0.9995055198669434,
0.30339425802230835,
-0.26516270637512207,
-0.01824568584561348,
0.2592918276786804,
0.323080450296402,
-0.2985324561595917,
-0.07512513548135757,
0.5508771538734436,
0.4623441994190216,
-0.034387681633234024,
-0.360578328371048,
0.1939319521188736,
-0.18145567178726196,
-0.3646121323108673,
0.023186886683106422,
-0.6849488019943237,
0.8817111849784851,
-0.1789141148328781,
-0.1276485174894333,
0.11794649064540863,
0.2665434777736664,
0.3909950852394104,
1.020363450050354,
0.16119995713233948,
0.36710959672927856,
0.42068368196487427,
0.1885461062192917,
1.0398012399673462,
-0.2259000986814499,
0.10256285220384598,
0.9533289670944214,
-0.6672214865684509,
0.5194668173789978,
0.45650964975357056,
0.0864700898528099,
0.13490106165409088,
0.6581217050552368,
-0.2521345019340515,
0.3065313994884491,
0.31159070134162903,
-0.2459813952445984,
0.0743088647723198,
0.05942597612738609,
-0.5843497514724731,
0.38528192043304443,
0.43000277876853943,
-0.11317665129899979,
-0.15991994738578796,
0.036803264170885086,
0.23532085120677948,
-0.07034354656934738,
-0.34042054414749146,
0.6897658109664917,
0.16708378493785858,
-0.1229894831776619,
0.0655556470155716,
-0.007133585400879383,
0.4042699635028839,
-0.5948880910873413,
0.1168091893196106,
-0.3545517027378082,
0.25256112217903137,
-0.32890498638153076,
-0.7761018872261047,
0.2824314832687378,
0.02565334364771843,
0.08863567560911179,
-0.11799994111061096,
0.9657028913497925,
-0.012727553024888039,
-0.034053537994623184,
0.6696018576622009,
0.448652982711792,
0.3612857460975647,
-0.39360108971595764,
-0.5197163224220276,
0.03787386044859886,
-0.38360053300857544,
-0.4673630893230438,
0.522117018699646,
0.2714344263076782,
-0.09796183556318283,
0.9041324853897095,
0.7868552207946777,
0.15702907741069794,
0.14264680445194244,
0.033551350235939026,
0.9620038270950317,
-0.9119001626968384,
-0.6752264499664307,
-1.0989203453063965,
0.10208375006914139,
-0.027904877439141273,
0.2475472241640091,
0.992609441280365,
0.5876258015632629,
0.6362391114234924,
-0.03530789166688919,
0.6473444700241089,
0.5229185223579407,
0.3457961082458496,
-0.628716230392456,
1.0408563613891602,
-0.4077887535095215,
0.6222386956214905,
-0.27918165922164917,
-0.5391435027122498,
-0.014520649798214436,
-0.17824816703796387,
-0.327906996011734,
0.13491451740264893,
0.6087372899055481,
0.9996110200881958,
0.46492138504981995,
-0.15440577268600464,
0.40771040320396423,
0.2759780287742615,
0.5289163589477539,
0.41422292590141296,
1.2633947134017944,
-0.08486904948949814,
0.7409213781356812,
-0.2362988144159317,
-0.02593463473021984,
-0.4840780794620514,
-0.6030916571617126,
-1.0290648937225342,
0.021274225786328316,
-0.1419541984796524,
-0.6154899597167969,
0.371982216835022,
0.45577406883239746,
0.35356152057647705,
-0.6245167851448059,
-0.3411813974380493,
0.11101635545492172,
0.6754847168922424,
-0.0011689170496538281,
-0.19065438210964203,
0.02925202064216137,
-0.10514257848262787,
-0.2981747090816498,
0.4563431739807129,
0.27454113960266113,
0.15432195365428925,
-0.4298730194568634,
0.019639331847429276,
-0.029280444607138634,
0.19226466119289398,
0.25571802258491516,
0.4928411543369293,
-0.5462790131568909,
-0.39398708939552307,
-0.1804783195257187,
-0.3735767602920532,
-0.20393410325050354,
0.6587503552436829,
-0.553580105304718,
0.013369652442634106,
0.4323790371417999,
0.47457054257392883,
0.21346759796142578,
-0.012668320909142494,
0.6635498404502869,
-0.8131377696990967,
0.32811036705970764,
0.36691319942474365,
0.1821807622909546,
0.11727917939424515,
-0.9725678563117981,
0.49248597025871277,
0.23171618580818176,
-0.4436275362968445,
-0.9970730543136597,
0.7641470432281494,
-0.7542217373847961,
-0.4511018693447113,
1.0253381729125977,
-0.09754537791013718,
-0.6184231042861938,
-0.30838727951049805,
-0.1449381411075592,
0.1652836948633194,
-0.5771660804748535,
0.6821317672729492,
0.23491135239601135,
-0.26303836703300476,
0.05965489521622658,
-0.4918915927410126,
0.338308185338974,
-0.19156070053577423,
-0.9488772749900818,
0.014046530239284039,
0.25858595967292786,
0.2895529568195343,
0.09937240183353424,
0.2866019606590271,
-0.1356775462627411,
0.41664448380470276,
0.269533634185791,
-0.13060921430587769,
-0.1963859498500824,
-0.3375314772129059,
-0.5309765934944153,
0.2635694444179535,
0.028950201347470284,
-0.6152721643447876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12399v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12399v2 | Turn Waste into Worth: Rectifying Top-$k$ Router of MoE | 2024-02-17T06:23:27 | 2024-02-21T13:33:12 | Zhiyuan Zeng, Qipeng Guo, Zhaoye Fei, Zhangyue Yin, Yunhua Zhou, Linyang Li, Tianxiang Sun, Hang Yan, Dahua Lin, Xipeng Qiu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Sparse Mixture of Experts (MoE) models are popular for training large
language models due to their computational efficiency. However, the commonly
used top-$k$ routing mechanism suffers from redundancy computation and memory
costs due to the unbalanced routing. Some experts are overflow, where the
exceeding tokens are dropped. While some experts are vacant, which are padded
with zeros, negatively impacting model performance. To address the dropped
tokens and padding, we propose the Rectify-Router, comprising the Intra-GPU
Rectification and the Fill-in Rectification. The Intra-GPU Rectification
handles dropped tokens, efficiently routing them to experts within the GPU
where they are located to avoid inter-GPU communication. The Fill-in
Rectification addresses padding by replacing padding tokens with the tokens
that have high routing scores. Our experimental results demonstrate that the
Intra-GPU Rectification and the Fill-in Rectification effectively handle
dropped tokens and padding, respectively. Furthermore, the combination of them
achieves superior performance, surpassing the accuracy of the vanilla top-1
router by 4.7%. | [
-0.64625483751297,
-0.737953245639801,
0.2284982055425644,
-0.18960002064704895,
-0.48097994923591614,
0.1918523609638214,
-0.21855613589286804,
-0.08099784702062607,
0.17566369473934174,
0.4007139801979065,
-0.3992413878440857,
0.09780609607696533,
-0.6956436038017273,
-0.31017905473709106,
-0.44371429085731506,
0.9997929334640503,
0.3050110340118408,
-0.10225924104452133,
-0.2651841938495636,
-0.12144724279642105,
-0.8627673387527466,
-0.26647961139678955,
-0.8291809558868408,
-0.5460053086280823,
0.5192345976829529,
0.49759578704833984,
0.6699631810188293,
0.6395362019538879,
0.23124626278877258,
0.4505467414855957,
-0.1495448499917984,
0.25926247239112854,
-1.0739206075668335,
-0.07977336645126343,
-0.24687737226486206,
-0.34960755705833435,
-0.50908362865448,
-0.33722254633903503,
0.45786190032958984,
0.6674045920372009,
-0.5640137195587158,
-0.170399472117424,
-0.051144395023584366,
0.8495210409164429,
-0.8947371244430542,
-0.050452448427677155,
-0.8638269901275635,
-0.07521174103021622,
-0.48250362277030945,
-0.433898001909256,
-0.43130069971084595,
-0.2065039426088333,
-0.1327938586473465,
-0.7082921862602234,
0.4350798428058624,
0.17602896690368652,
0.847102165222168,
0.5711386799812317,
-0.11335346102714539,
0.1910059005022049,
-0.7286641597747803,
0.8687517046928406,
-0.710960865020752,
0.6388915181159973,
0.3826172351837158,
0.31628575921058655,
-0.05359305441379547,
-0.28440314531326294,
-0.40219321846961975,
0.33575767278671265,
-0.14278797805309296,
-0.009237272664904594,
-0.4405638873577118,
0.05114690586924553,
0.009403065778315067,
0.8020836710929871,
-0.14018210768699646,
-0.06229023635387421,
-0.6903589367866516,
0.027327487245202065,
0.6820940971374512,
0.14720895886421204,
0.2969419062137604,
0.41271159052848816,
-0.2564222514629364,
0.0857999324798584,
-0.9282549023628235,
-0.16114550828933716,
0.27365320920944214,
0.1748528778553009,
0.32662439346313477,
0.29750779271125793,
-0.290365070104599,
0.5566967129707336,
0.5893248915672302,
-0.2113747000694275,
0.26075848937034607,
0.0777546688914299,
-0.30507364869117737,
0.06790222972631454,
0.24473540484905243,
0.29305946826934814,
0.3175753653049469,
-0.5983753800392151,
-0.25885674357414246,
-0.5686989426612854,
0.75201416015625,
-0.8515511155128479,
-0.6783192157745361,
0.05317216366529465,
-0.2628224194049835,
-0.12843957543373108,
-0.3845643401145935,
-0.6610362529754639,
-0.22697259485721588,
-0.3402087390422821,
0.5478792786598206,
-0.3807066082954407,
-0.9135227203369141,
0.19293171167373657,
-0.02102844975888729,
0.027058271691203117,
0.4612806439399719,
-1.1588002443313599,
0.3261307179927826,
0.9595993161201477,
0.9004526734352112,
0.000584215740673244,
0.11831681430339813,
-0.4668966829776764,
0.05032383278012276,
-0.45212921500205994,
0.7017410397529602,
-0.3550114333629608,
-0.6696276664733887,
-0.17493173480033875,
-0.35650089383125305,
-0.24601280689239502,
-0.7595484256744385,
0.48473531007766724,
-0.697796642780304,
0.08381103724241257,
-0.5282086730003357,
-0.5437176823616028,
-0.44447192549705505,
0.28518185019493103,
-0.5982828140258789,
1.0453108549118042,
0.1878400593996048,
-0.9182024598121643,
0.2660699188709259,
-0.4868878424167633,
-0.31992819905281067,
0.3923075497150421,
0.04438158497214317,
-0.3504183292388916,
0.2319120615720749,
0.2513856291770935,
0.28703585267066956,
-0.10977958142757416,
0.22705979645252228,
-0.1362520009279251,
-0.4571426212787628,
-0.05145023390650749,
-0.46858522295951843,
0.6805664896965027,
0.32117927074432373,
-0.15865708887577057,
0.11448007076978683,
-0.9805065393447876,
-0.005699046887457371,
-0.09557130187749863,
-0.35696423053741455,
-0.5996370911598206,
-0.01923578605055809,
0.05627405643463135,
0.046254705637693405,
-0.007634685840457678,
-0.8445910811424255,
0.17762774229049683,
-0.5389921069145203,
0.7184588313102722,
1.098448395729065,
-0.163919597864151,
0.43792733550071716,
-0.3408665359020233,
0.21687538921833038,
-0.04955758526921272,
-0.03329555317759514,
-0.0011529931798577309,
-0.7484737634658813,
-1.1145051717758179,
-0.5737515091896057,
0.12608575820922852,
0.460962176322937,
-0.7097163200378418,
0.06954068690538406,
-0.4884478747844696,
-0.5533664226531982,
-0.8489395380020142,
0.06953881680965424,
0.5500296354293823,
0.8407090902328491,
0.4435725510120392,
-0.2551210820674896,
-0.08016672730445862,
-0.7684922814369202,
-0.0952535942196846,
-0.10369895398616791,
-0.03491054102778435,
0.37370121479034424,
0.09936363995075226,
0.03295290842652321,
1.016466498374939,
-0.5651469826698303,
-0.19190028309822083,
-0.018617060035467148,
0.046380095183849335,
0.10669384896755219,
0.8539848327636719,
0.4502004086971283,
-0.6381590962409973,
-0.3057458698749542,
0.12463245540857315,
-0.2734387218952179,
0.0329151451587677,
0.22110220789909363,
-0.3864234983921051,
0.13567772507667542,
0.3889886140823364,
-0.8530824184417725,
0.3666425347328186,
0.20622952282428741,
-0.037349555641412735,
0.0837242379784584,
-0.2166205197572708,
0.30039119720458984,
-0.9127864241600037,
0.18068170547485352,
-0.2621811628341675,
-0.17879265546798706,
-0.4796493649482727,
0.3140919804573059,
-0.23822027444839478,
-0.28409814834594727,
-0.12941990792751312,
0.7526558041572571,
-0.16493366658687592,
0.07763118296861649,
-0.2706436216831207,
-0.2890295684337616,
-0.03750212863087654,
0.6085003018379211,
-0.1574963629245758,
0.9018231630325317,
0.277176171541214,
-0.5074684619903564,
0.24765516817569733,
-0.043220072984695435,
-0.13132719695568085,
0.6091654300689697,
-0.5760161876678467,
0.29057303071022034,
-0.25130948424339294,
-0.17220951616764069,
-1.5036793947219849,
-0.207167387008667,
0.3609357178211212,
-0.4998807907104492,
0.6075456738471985,
-0.45300477743148804,
-0.28213533759117126,
-0.20420826971530914,
-0.02649734728038311,
0.8314216136932373,
0.7535524964332581,
-0.5778732895851135,
0.6455515623092651,
0.5488302111625671,
-0.5760464072227478,
-0.726145327091217,
-0.8298046588897705,
-0.0567648820579052,
-0.027159206569194794,
-0.58348548412323,
0.3247251510620117,
-0.12620340287685394,
0.1524183601140976,
0.1172250509262085,
0.019161060452461243,
-0.33204418420791626,
0.08882395178079605,
0.17695832252502441,
-0.05143597349524498,
-0.27922582626342773,
0.13656118512153625,
0.1607719510793686,
-0.528143584728241,
-0.03861713036894798,
-0.2009260505437851,
0.638617753982544,
0.003513815812766552,
-0.6574346423149109,
-0.4808109402656555,
0.4553775489330292,
0.7549800872802734,
-0.20576688647270203,
0.7316891551017761,
0.5670000314712524,
-0.6003828048706055,
0.23543398082256317,
-1.038805365562439,
-0.12528683245182037,
-0.518272876739502,
0.421332985162735,
-0.43930020928382874,
-0.7389676570892334,
0.4860687255859375,
-0.03874758258461952,
0.5216885209083557,
0.41058602929115295,
0.49832311272621155,
0.060106586664915085,
0.7809005379676819,
0.6924758553504944,
-0.343738317489624,
0.26422134041786194,
-0.279414564371109,
0.6992319226264954,
-0.6667711138725281,
-0.4364630877971649,
-0.4158359467983246,
-0.39183974266052246,
-0.3174757957458496,
-0.3434489369392395,
0.2773955464363098,
0.31000375747680664,
-0.33783602714538574,
-0.08969748020172119,
-0.5614733695983887,
0.4899047017097473,
0.7710150480270386,
0.21673382818698883,
0.20284472405910492,
0.18334054946899414,
-0.12017639726400375,
-0.056310899555683136,
-1.1005792617797852,
-0.13996362686157227,
0.8800223469734192,
0.36605995893478394,
0.8074207305908203,
-0.019350826740264893,
0.5363816618919373,
0.23781344294548035,
0.6313174366950989,
-0.5425876379013062,
0.5097031593322754,
-0.12529349327087402,
-0.47634145617485046,
-0.374231219291687,
-0.4404728412628174,
-0.6866466999053955,
0.45473772287368774,
-0.1818356215953827,
-0.5039434432983398,
0.25272712111473083,
0.6381837129592896,
-0.4725012183189392,
1.1268786191940308,
-0.4542202949523926,
0.5843728184700012,
0.08574411273002625,
-0.29360634088516235,
-0.5160461068153381,
-0.08065761625766754,
0.42950573563575745,
0.1143740564584732,
0.24013198912143707,
0.14182792603969574,
0.03599128499627113,
0.36866050958633423,
-0.8081974983215332,
0.6382554173469543,
-0.25458812713623047,
-0.28543686866760254,
0.06263159215450287,
0.16310162842273712,
0.39621108770370483,
-0.23421268165111542,
-0.005509547423571348,
0.3547382652759552,
-0.6812257766723633,
-0.626467764377594,
-0.4855784773826599,
0.8737261295318604,
-0.940784215927124,
-0.5692426562309265,
0.025679059326648712,
-0.4791242182254791,
-0.022433528676629066,
0.13791975378990173,
0.4406947195529938,
0.6711965203285217,
0.24449479579925537,
0.16160181164741516,
0.8922399878501892,
-0.1501733958721161,
0.3712159991264343,
0.23803666234016418,
0.07040051370859146,
-0.8763910531997681,
1.106286644935608,
0.27578017115592957,
0.1983308047056198,
0.34800586104393005,
-0.03412345051765442,
-0.10852157324552536,
-0.7254627346992493,
-1.0500082969665527,
-0.057014767080545425,
-0.4276442527770996,
-0.3944445252418518,
-0.7022538185119629,
-0.3702445924282074,
-0.078620046377182,
-0.4531268775463104,
-0.9324666261672974,
-0.43577080965042114,
-0.20940092206001282,
-0.2555103003978729,
0.46705886721611023,
0.5125145316123962,
-0.08815055340528488,
0.5853464007377625,
-0.7371099591255188,
0.0401303693652153,
0.3484422266483307,
0.5875070691108704,
0.6911905407905579,
-0.6107145547866821,
-0.3666349947452545,
0.0057527790777385235,
-0.32660582661628723,
-0.3666065037250519,
0.3354452848434448,
-0.015176109038293362,
0.5785788297653198,
0.8351292610168457,
-0.05618630722165108,
1.08138906955719,
-0.7013148665428162,
0.5915957689285278,
0.23704499006271362,
-0.6894724369049072,
0.11742768436670303,
-0.3059914708137512,
0.06530750542879105,
0.4932861328125,
0.3438322842121124,
-0.4408101439476013,
-0.3469412922859192,
-0.4224340617656708,
-1.1491855382919312,
0.651969850063324,
0.3069915175437927,
0.16686998307704926,
-0.1714925915002823,
0.45026642084121704,
0.24095655977725983,
0.2564096450805664,
-0.3656251132488251,
-0.3565453290939331,
-0.29225635528564453,
-0.1262119859457016,
0.18175403773784637,
-0.454232782125473,
-0.057379040867090225,
-0.2000739574432373,
0.9772157073020935,
0.38765203952789307,
0.28670355677604675,
-0.11683442443609238,
-0.02373572811484337,
-0.5322085022926331,
0.3309520483016968,
0.6892662048339844,
0.9198313355445862,
-0.29890766739845276,
-0.21993966400623322,
0.24016369879245758,
-0.24994556605815887,
0.09466402232646942,
-0.07284783571958542,
-0.5348634719848633,
0.13922978937625885,
0.23509645462036133,
0.8120715618133545,
0.5006344318389893,
-0.31727370619773865,
0.41013213992118835,
0.17761686444282532,
-0.06524944305419922,
-0.004688856191933155,
0.09486570954322815,
0.023858973756432533,
-0.03003150410950184,
0.6245964765548706,
0.5329420566558838,
0.228465273976326,
-0.09802039712667465,
0.15646587312221527,
0.4315963685512543,
-0.13904008269309998,
-0.0994984433054924,
0.6353517770767212,
0.7715080380439758,
-0.500575065612793,
1.0400278568267822,
-0.001649657846428454,
-0.6483458876609802,
0.2597557306289673,
0.3522445261478424,
0.8586750030517578,
-0.18556587398052216,
-0.2488192319869995,
0.6582481861114502,
0.1788802295923233,
0.06125703081488609,
0.0074463593773543835,
-0.0890084058046341,
-0.5109348297119141,
-0.6613385677337646,
-0.3492581844329834,
-0.17212055623531342,
0.10285770148038864,
-0.8815488815307617,
-0.10678772628307343,
-0.36954718828201294,
-0.15185865759849548,
-0.44934773445129395,
-0.339439332485199,
-0.5195704698562622,
0.137328639626503,
0.1118268221616745,
0.8192649483680725,
-0.8135779500007629,
0.4874025285243988,
0.5541857481002808,
-0.2975759208202362,
-0.45473194122314453,
-0.3064403831958771,
-0.20612746477127075,
-0.8349497318267822,
0.7046673893928528,
0.02983909472823143,
-0.2538379430770874,
0.10427242517471313,
-0.13323649764060974,
-0.9144587516784668,
0.9542772173881531,
0.29848790168762207,
-0.8191661238670349,
-0.004581494722515345,
0.07329857349395752,
0.15969380736351013,
0.11885403841733932,
0.570604681968689,
-0.07413265854120255,
0.08471465110778809,
0.15936732292175293,
-1.1691008806228638,
0.00045158708235248923,
-0.4253356158733368,
0.03929558023810387,
0.6049083471298218,
-1.1184388399124146,
1.287305235862732,
-0.2019065022468567,
-0.29620009660720825,
0.20353543758392334,
0.7290369868278503,
0.33150550723075867,
0.31705886125564575,
0.6414547562599182,
1.2787986993789673,
0.8938623666763306,
-0.04796022176742554,
0.8302778601646423,
-0.3991042971611023,
0.45870935916900635,
0.8100626468658447,
0.17896687984466553,
0.9942177534103394,
0.3907272219657898,
-0.16560305655002594,
0.4569881558418274,
0.539329469203949,
0.4378969967365265,
0.9412226676940918,
0.36403876543045044,
-0.35074207186698914,
-0.49685046076774597,
0.36430123448371887,
-0.7244706749916077,
-0.04187740385532379,
0.24611374735832214,
0.02366345189511776,
-0.6311735510826111,
0.1698729395866394,
0.3187074363231659,
-0.21645981073379517,
-0.8217378854751587,
0.7394372224807739,
-0.17954853177070618,
-0.712948739528656,
0.6697362661361694,
0.2082217037677765,
0.7709218263626099,
-0.35524988174438477,
-0.18732428550720215,
-0.5979195237159729,
0.4626105725765228,
-0.13416776061058044,
-0.641186535358429,
0.16357292234897614,
-0.05374336242675781,
-0.4014267325401306,
-0.34637251496315,
0.8181898593902588,
-0.6429942846298218,
-0.549010694026947,
-0.04593411833047867,
0.2025749683380127,
0.3811362683773041,
-0.15685784816741943,
-0.3838817775249481,
-0.09381099045276642,
-0.1735493689775467,
-0.017819669097661972,
0.43783333897590637,
0.5878276824951172,
0.14193211495876312,
1.0868937969207764,
0.6346959471702576,
0.06526489555835724,
0.3809671700000763,
-0.0037579480558633804,
1.240155577659607,
-0.40288516879081726,
-0.5353363156318665,
-0.8770546913146973,
0.6408230066299438,
0.00014482965343631804,
-0.3823634088039398,
0.3133665919303894,
0.8365687727928162,
1.1598317623138428,
-0.2079746425151825,
0.5264773368835449,
0.17669224739074707,
0.4568985104560852,
-0.6081506609916687,
0.9904367327690125,
-0.6295145750045776,
0.15405386686325073,
-0.11663994938135147,
-0.6036673784255981,
0.0503188893198967,
0.7772091031074524,
0.03321845829486847,
0.10750453174114227,
0.013216855935752392,
0.710551917552948,
-0.3980933129787445,
-0.10074450820684433,
0.33199813961982727,
0.12132391333580017,
0.24652232229709625,
0.6725104451179504,
0.48085010051727295,
-0.3875954747200012,
0.5727049708366394,
-0.264955997467041,
-0.2897532284259796,
-0.5396745800971985,
-0.7341504096984863,
-0.8264312148094177,
-0.32177233695983887,
-0.5460913181304932,
-0.08512454479932785,
0.20237189531326294,
0.7619038224220276,
1.1651278734207153,
-0.796775758266449,
0.10289490967988968,
-0.16366173326969147,
0.09720706939697266,
-0.12374590337276459,
-0.2854093909263611,
0.43294739723205566,
-0.4401984214782715,
-0.632907509803772,
-0.007982950657606125,
0.34285783767700195,
-0.39246582984924316,
-0.38478147983551025,
-0.13032174110412598,
-0.06444861739873886,
0.06668789684772491,
0.6637998819351196,
0.2558619976043701,
-0.9856758713722229,
-0.31936824321746826,
-0.28464826941490173,
0.08205607533454895,
0.1815013885498047,
0.9188032150268555,
-0.7964773178100586,
0.4941760003566742,
0.6314327120780945,
1.3177286386489868,
0.3372615575790405,
0.15705786645412445,
0.5276912450790405,
-0.720962643623352,
-0.16976511478424072,
0.045556921511888504,
0.4415295422077179,
0.3210902214050293,
-0.5611070394515991,
0.5316073298454285,
0.45136359333992004,
-0.5939611196517944,
-0.8575783371925354,
-0.15452809631824493,
-0.9210745692253113,
-0.059412602335214615,
0.7772254347801208,
-0.34354734420776367,
-0.04508785903453827,
-0.17231200635433197,
-0.4339936375617981,
0.020860707387328148,
-0.5564473867416382,
0.9218419790267944,
1.0080552101135254,
-0.013347586616873741,
-0.5161323547363281,
-0.49775877594947815,
0.15835565328598022,
0.5754501223564148,
-0.4457957148551941,
0.1229439377784729,
0.46512800455093384,
0.6759066581726074,
0.26072660088539124,
1.040748119354248,
0.004839187953621149,
0.1501699686050415,
0.048796750605106354,
0.053726084530353546,
-0.5969865918159485,
-0.26833900809288025,
0.18235941231250763,
0.17883165180683136,
-0.011007815599441528,
-0.6603193283081055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11203v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11203v1 | Exploring ChatGPT for Next-generation Information Retrieval: Opportunities and Challenges | 2024-02-17T05:44:40 | 2024-02-17T05:44:40 | Yizheng Huang, Jimmy Huang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence (AI) has highlighted ChatGPT
as a pivotal technology in the field of information retrieval (IR).
Distinguished from its predecessors, ChatGPT offers significant benefits that
have attracted the attention of both the industry and academic communities.
While some view ChatGPT as a groundbreaking innovation, others attribute its
success to the effective integration of product development and market
strategies. The emergence of ChatGPT, alongside GPT-4, marks a new phase in
Generative AI, generating content that is distinct from training examples and
exceeding the capabilities of the prior GPT-3 model by OpenAI. Unlike the
traditional supervised learning approach in IR tasks, ChatGPT challenges
existing paradigms, bringing forth new challenges and opportunities regarding
text quality assurance, model bias, and efficiency. This paper seeks to examine
the impact of ChatGPT on IR tasks and offer insights into its potential future
developments. | [
-0.3342728018760681,
-0.6863833665847778,
0.5155055522918701,
-0.12120985984802246,
0.021454043686389923,
0.3629089891910553,
0.12142586708068848,
-0.5598650574684143,
-0.15115396678447723,
0.17874494194984436,
-0.3690466284751892,
-0.22094593942165375,
-0.6508328318595886,
0.036921046674251556,
-0.6909224987030029,
1.229399561882019,
0.08909536898136139,
-0.2589477002620697,
-0.10306001454591751,
0.21030104160308838,
-0.6152703166007996,
-0.9544817805290222,
-0.7550104856491089,
-0.33946478366851807,
0.2666090130805969,
0.4258187711238861,
0.8128005266189575,
0.039633579552173615,
1.0574575662612915,
0.24572418630123138,
0.0715351328253746,
-0.0940282791852951,
-0.38857609033584595,
0.225462406873703,
0.21046318113803864,
-0.45898914337158203,
-0.1947699338197708,
0.21569892764091492,
0.6308000087738037,
0.30546650290489197,
-0.24130716919898987,
-0.13135842978954315,
0.16446717083454132,
0.870135486125946,
-0.4360949397087097,
0.5336909890174866,
-0.8949252963066101,
0.24673379957675934,
-0.5191743969917297,
-0.3932778835296631,
-0.3742324113845825,
-0.5648505687713623,
0.6402128338813782,
-0.6637493968009949,
0.3891843557357788,
0.15285293757915497,
1.0621802806854248,
0.2495328038930893,
-0.3908785283565521,
-0.37493011355400085,
-0.6523308157920837,
0.46374234557151794,
-0.38973262906074524,
0.5715131759643555,
0.28294211626052856,
0.5791527628898621,
-0.29449719190597534,
-1.0462965965270996,
-0.6392024159431458,
-0.18528860807418823,
0.160844624042511,
0.29679498076438904,
-0.11647675186395645,
-0.028470655903220177,
-0.08451692759990692,
0.49336498975753784,
-0.708307147026062,
-0.16931231319904327,
-0.2361440807580948,
0.0627242922782898,
0.293327659368515,
-0.06637642532587051,
0.2978866696357727,
-0.16105113923549652,
-0.4003418982028961,
-0.09364349395036697,
-0.7166659235954285,
-0.2977362275123596,
0.39091387391090393,
0.19676491618156433,
0.5086491703987122,
0.7595447897911072,
-0.3320428431034088,
0.2317303866147995,
-0.2944895923137665,
0.3282347619533539,
0.31727996468544006,
-0.2993820607662201,
0.12991933524608612,
-0.017557283863425255,
0.678887665271759,
0.15835466980934143,
0.005897957365959883,
-0.14455601572990417,
-0.14632992446422577,
-0.21791933476924896,
0.2056570202112198,
-0.7420822381973267,
-0.43332770466804504,
-0.1235027015209198,
-0.583995521068573,
-0.16546188294887543,
0.1658797711133957,
-0.9527429342269897,
-0.5372535586357117,
-0.0719166249036789,
0.5610515475273132,
-0.7066894173622131,
-0.3243333399295807,
-0.14185874164104462,
-0.4239416718482971,
0.644076406955719,
0.5675908923149109,
-1.0116848945617676,
0.12493833899497986,
0.9716164469718933,
0.9496994614601135,
-0.23626407980918884,
-0.010254821740090847,
-0.2806410789489746,
-0.052989136427640915,
-0.09408698976039886,
1.11997652053833,
-0.7408469319343567,
-0.4535766541957855,
-0.10916716605424881,
-0.5430455803871155,
-0.2699008882045746,
-0.6031218767166138,
0.5014047026634216,
-0.7940400838851929,
0.32529908418655396,
-0.05766972526907921,
-0.4726437032222748,
-0.2847703993320465,
0.5295606851577759,
-0.5685204267501831,
1.1365911960601807,
0.13581804931163788,
-0.7694432735443115,
0.3793933093547821,
-0.672038197517395,
-0.34132400155067444,
0.5208510756492615,
-0.37299737334251404,
-0.5096637010574341,
-0.07203178107738495,
-0.006031688302755356,
0.00867023691534996,
-0.3671770989894867,
0.07479638606309891,
0.08971310406923294,
-0.3651970624923706,
0.2525421380996704,
-0.8445315957069397,
0.29513803124427795,
0.3163340091705322,
-0.33828455209732056,
-0.3333713710308075,
-0.42017775774002075,
0.14725317060947418,
0.033424798399209976,
-0.4265052080154419,
-0.05101586878299713,
0.34834250807762146,
0.0789337232708931,
0.037973932921886444,
0.36214572191238403,
-0.3882168233394623,
0.3448250889778137,
0.08030969649553299,
0.7154773473739624,
0.6488521695137024,
0.18485106527805328,
0.0978301465511322,
-0.3276940882205963,
0.5910214185714722,
-0.29595375061035156,
0.4167029559612274,
-0.3964160084724426,
-0.9364691376686096,
-0.5299491286277771,
0.1742231696844101,
0.48950812220573425,
0.7711607813835144,
-0.8319346904754639,
-0.05018632113933563,
-0.30488067865371704,
-0.5251697301864624,
-0.5088532567024231,
-0.2419985681772232,
0.10917459428310394,
0.3319956362247467,
0.348065048456192,
-0.34868142008781433,
-0.39756977558135986,
-0.6505923867225647,
-0.21733061969280243,
-0.5537306666374207,
-0.002152141649276018,
0.5215351581573486,
0.26605260372161865,
-0.20365488529205322,
1.042848825454712,
-0.32049158215522766,
-0.639263391494751,
-0.29883453249931335,
0.3975142240524292,
0.2587515413761139,
0.4847593903541565,
0.05765062943100929,
-1.5852328538894653,
-0.5338649749755859,
0.3205961585044861,
-0.7131010293960571,
0.17983441054821014,
-0.05999601632356644,
-0.16193397343158722,
0.026210013777017593,
0.5089345574378967,
-0.7454221248626709,
0.3487256169319153,
0.19425635039806366,
-0.030964650213718414,
0.45124638080596924,
0.021158965304493904,
0.4878461956977844,
-0.7540938258171082,
0.1973893940448761,
-0.1534816175699234,
0.04990161582827568,
-0.5847892165184021,
-0.17230430245399475,
-0.07010599970817566,
-0.47698262333869934,
-0.14331082999706268,
0.24864493310451508,
-0.3344728946685791,
-0.173943892121315,
-0.07779188454151154,
0.25058862566947937,
-0.08481963723897934,
0.09519758820533752,
-0.16808775067329407,
1.0927053689956665,
0.08274392038583755,
-0.40540412068367004,
0.09442427009344101,
0.6052422523498535,
-0.1966044306755066,
0.3195885419845581,
-0.5717055201530457,
0.25257670879364014,
-0.18625468015670776,
0.18879224359989166,
-0.6834813952445984,
-0.27319854497909546,
0.17643515765666962,
-0.8247367143630981,
0.2568128705024719,
-0.20757757127285004,
-0.6095340847969055,
-0.3543614447116852,
-0.17776088416576385,
0.4223558306694031,
0.7342357635498047,
-0.4685516655445099,
0.6251299381256104,
0.4548218548297882,
-0.42795249819755554,
-0.6503317952156067,
-0.4069384038448334,
0.34566909074783325,
-0.10686704516410828,
-0.48194336891174316,
0.48179009556770325,
-0.11346281319856644,
-0.09907405078411102,
0.04753176122903824,
-0.1783403903245926,
-0.13334685564041138,
0.04707150533795357,
0.0032543789129704237,
0.392132431268692,
-0.16030584275722504,
0.1620246320962906,
-0.304399311542511,
-0.3111228048801422,
-0.24538350105285645,
-0.5559186935424805,
0.7168571352958679,
-0.29555755853652954,
-0.613552451133728,
-0.4800647497177124,
0.33662155270576477,
0.13125494122505188,
-0.44922974705696106,
0.395620197057724,
0.6515294909477234,
-0.03172328695654869,
0.3391011655330658,
-0.7015630006790161,
-0.044825807213783264,
-0.503376841545105,
0.5228988528251648,
-0.13172613084316254,
-0.8108660578727722,
0.27708619832992554,
-0.15081369876861572,
0.034804731607437134,
0.3926517069339752,
0.1739734411239624,
-0.13925205171108246,
1.0087190866470337,
0.7110621929168701,
-0.08249757438898087,
0.9068862795829773,
-0.12876130640506744,
0.6044313311576843,
-0.6745527386665344,
-0.601048469543457,
-0.6885409951210022,
0.041093144565820694,
-0.8369836807250977,
-0.17402607202529907,
0.647543728351593,
0.007089278195053339,
-0.257449209690094,
-0.12614305317401886,
-0.5715653300285339,
0.47249776124954224,
1.0941036939620972,
0.14782974123954773,
0.5668283104896545,
-0.17770527303218842,
0.5180104374885559,
0.188644677400589,
-0.610713541507721,
-0.4574044346809387,
0.9180324673652649,
0.07432886958122253,
0.778191864490509,
0.13391737639904022,
0.5427190065383911,
0.6315648555755615,
0.23554682731628418,
-0.706515908241272,
0.50520920753479,
-0.18877756595611572,
-0.5539982318878174,
-0.1928025782108307,
-0.40911775827407837,
-1.0571577548980713,
0.23111358284950256,
-0.03589935228228569,
-0.641079306602478,
-0.044734518975019455,
0.19264674186706543,
0.0157796498388052,
0.19529029726982117,
-1.003953218460083,
0.7118903398513794,
-0.2641453444957733,
-0.1841040700674057,
0.04006877914071083,
-0.7418130040168762,
-0.05909169837832451,
-0.0006536305299960077,
-0.0695834755897522,
-0.1970808506011963,
-0.03944963216781616,
0.5895400047302246,
-0.014827392995357513,
0.4321133494377136,
0.004290762823075056,
0.23245759308338165,
0.38384610414505005,
-0.10439347475767136,
0.47284841537475586,
-0.036378923803567886,
-0.2989673614501953,
0.1253979206085205,
-0.10582699626684189,
-0.3473544418811798,
-0.5999813079833984,
0.35324257612228394,
-0.6933531165122986,
-0.8788434267044067,
-0.6302390098571777,
-0.45789164304733276,
-0.11595429480075836,
0.5198501348495483,
0.3299958109855652,
0.2789646089076996,
-0.1758524477481842,
0.20093481242656708,
0.7238596081733704,
-0.3833855390548706,
0.34222933650016785,
0.22014236450195312,
-0.02557695098221302,
-0.06605686247348785,
1.2918108701705933,
0.015013537369668484,
0.2919113039970398,
0.6080952882766724,
-0.10373765975236893,
-0.15134453773498535,
-0.8606116771697998,
-0.12821251153945923,
-0.2752537131309509,
-0.5971825122833252,
-0.3716104030609131,
-0.8083027601242065,
-0.506455659866333,
-0.4240068197250366,
0.2628888189792633,
-0.3184349834918976,
-0.22650963068008423,
-0.11378409713506699,
0.18082314729690552,
0.29254794120788574,
0.8716825842857361,
0.18798303604125977,
0.20151734352111816,
-0.8293994665145874,
0.024162843823432922,
0.24296356737613678,
0.5257577300071716,
-0.18541264533996582,
-0.02294754795730114,
-0.191674143075943,
-0.09670685976743698,
-0.6099870204925537,
-0.5407655835151672,
0.3735758364200592,
0.3706136643886566,
0.585407018661499,
-0.00008016914216568694,
0.05508417263627052,
0.30558013916015625,
-0.6586716175079346,
0.9778096079826355,
-0.23324590921401978,
-0.5133710503578186,
0.6024200320243835,
-0.4891425371170044,
0.12487086653709412,
0.5792083740234375,
0.5128307938575745,
-0.940886914730072,
-0.16141177713871002,
-0.6820247769355774,
-1.175628662109375,
0.5029153227806091,
0.552647590637207,
0.21230970323085785,
-0.056392066180706024,
0.3511284589767456,
0.3426405191421509,
0.27121323347091675,
-0.5966066718101501,
0.11017269641160965,
-0.2862629294395447,
-0.18079474568367004,
0.33740490674972534,
-0.16729702055454254,
0.473734974861145,
0.21452437341213226,
1.0394831895828247,
-0.13816650211811066,
0.8227270841598511,
0.2011021226644516,
0.024358415976166725,
0.4768869876861572,
0.3137451112270355,
-0.04389001801609993,
0.25337377190589905,
-0.205553337931633,
-0.18660134077072144,
-0.2373868227005005,
-0.7296372652053833,
-0.2004118263721466,
0.5870962738990784,
-0.2878933548927307,
-0.09232718497514725,
0.17445619404315948,
0.575309693813324,
-0.2035745531320572,
-0.6795737743377686,
0.5751628279685974,
-0.28227296471595764,
-0.04926806688308716,
-0.603519082069397,
0.14180225133895874,
-0.5011542439460754,
0.5487604737281799,
0.9556213617324829,
0.039435431361198425,
0.4448828399181366,
-0.5552459955215454,
0.23210205137729645,
0.6330847144126892,
-0.34969210624694824,
0.017901673913002014,
0.8058211803436279,
0.02224089205265045,
-0.31758853793144226,
1.1478272676467896,
-0.016771426424384117,
-0.7268005609512329,
0.4791681468486786,
0.3251689672470093,
0.6361535787582397,
-0.103251613676548,
0.17601455748081207,
-0.03882444649934769,
0.24689802527427673,
-0.1158943921327591,
0.07730722427368164,
-0.1562795341014862,
-0.5971376299858093,
-0.051776617765426636,
-0.3451038599014282,
-0.8417119979858398,
-0.09599126875400543,
-0.36489683389663696,
0.22277162969112396,
0.016531383618712425,
-0.17536242306232452,
-0.1867959052324295,
-0.07767018675804138,
-0.5249773859977722,
-0.11144360154867172,
-0.03731805086135864,
0.666310727596283,
-0.21301087737083435,
0.621445894241333,
0.34491613507270813,
-0.6881895661354065,
-0.41679316759109497,
0.38144776225090027,
0.06928054243326187,
-0.9058086276054382,
0.6055258512496948,
0.3994772732257843,
0.22413784265518188,
0.3289649188518524,
-0.2284873127937317,
-1.0126068592071533,
1.167621374130249,
0.1100521981716156,
-0.14272540807724,
-0.462555468082428,
0.24876375496387482,
0.4184701144695282,
0.20671971142292023,
0.5900980234146118,
0.5381753444671631,
0.450576514005661,
0.16778592765331268,
-0.8132683634757996,
-0.483221173286438,
-0.5452661514282227,
0.1638905256986618,
0.43424731492996216,
-0.7091876268386841,
1.0020052194595337,
-0.09139624238014221,
-0.44980424642562866,
0.32780390977859497,
0.6626084446907043,
-0.014670109376311302,
0.2308029681444168,
0.1595645695924759,
0.08939525485038757,
0.7681068181991577,
-0.3585115373134613,
1.2354823350906372,
-0.03495250642299652,
0.3077986538410187,
0.8660008907318115,
-0.19800128042697906,
0.8142377138137817,
0.362565279006958,
-0.1539890319108963,
0.40535861253738403,
0.7590314149856567,
-0.22636453807353973,
0.44685813784599304,
-0.1194537952542305,
-0.6753904819488525,
0.1458042711019516,
-0.33790123462677,
-0.5431666374206543,
0.4086510241031647,
0.5375810861587524,
-0.14187631011009216,
-0.13667160272598267,
0.23331989347934723,
-0.20556184649467468,
-0.1482786387205124,
-0.0939229428768158,
0.9606137871742249,
-0.25049465894699097,
-0.7587181925773621,
-0.07528893649578094,
-0.39240074157714844,
0.5815053582191467,
-0.5545048713684082,
-0.45306944847106934,
-0.25125518441200256,
0.29093924164772034,
-0.05368904769420624,
-0.9541283249855042,
0.018582677468657494,
-0.18307235836982727,
0.2217739224433899,
-0.2625424265861511,
0.762913167476654,
-0.10267522931098938,
-0.11191585659980774,
-0.023618366569280624,
0.47411802411079407,
0.23613359034061432,
-0.3254166543483734,
-0.5704458951950073,
-0.08331798017024994,
0.047407422214746475,
-0.36035600304603577,
0.40973472595214844,
0.7394982576370239,
0.04797477275133133,
0.8158448338508606,
0.49760252237319946,
-0.24879761040210724,
0.2633207440376282,
-0.06789545714855194,
0.8296686410903931,
-0.58022540807724,
-0.3288310170173645,
-0.634272038936615,
0.0999739021062851,
-0.045896273106336594,
-0.13384559750556946,
0.6221316456794739,
0.6375793218612671,
0.9995119571685791,
0.42903751134872437,
1.1154824495315552,
-0.563202977180481,
0.32838302850723267,
-0.49772465229034424,
0.5892669558525085,
-0.3159065544605255,
0.35513836145401,
-0.22213034331798553,
-0.7724491953849792,
-0.33190029859542847,
0.33842071890830994,
-0.2135564088821411,
0.23200350999832153,
0.6460070610046387,
0.6579201221466064,
0.21261228621006012,
0.5031649470329285,
0.07961729913949966,
0.000495921412948519,
0.8028349876403809,
0.47977137565612793,
1.075398564338684,
-0.5422048568725586,
1.112378716468811,
0.06082575395703316,
-0.2678864598274231,
-0.17982837557792664,
-0.64451003074646,
-0.4287637770175934,
-0.9204557538032532,
0.018716217949986458,
-0.14831724762916565,
0.3685300350189209,
0.7485803961753845,
0.500438928604126,
-0.6133028268814087,
0.20952443778514862,
-0.3232249319553375,
0.03151336684823036,
-0.10647151619195938,
-0.29613861441612244,
0.33430248498916626,
-0.7337520122528076,
-0.7339118123054504,
0.07103574275970459,
0.2637287378311157,
0.2377077043056488,
0.21605026721954346,
0.17875312268733978,
-0.40392279624938965,
-0.5007359981536865,
0.6833509206771851,
0.4105151891708374,
-0.15583813190460205,
-0.27971866726875305,
-0.0213040541857481,
-0.031140519306063652,
0.4187781810760498,
0.8857318162918091,
-1.0038158893585205,
0.17902615666389465,
0.34707385301589966,
1.1659727096557617,
0.7686824798583984,
0.039785925298929214,
0.7834151387214661,
-0.4363889694213867,
-0.11399717628955841,
0.44682320952415466,
-0.024270933121442795,
0.40181878209114075,
-0.5853763818740845,
0.902590811252594,
0.21641136705875397,
-0.9772979021072388,
-0.5561485886573792,
0.07305145263671875,
-0.7831142544746399,
0.004412961192429066,
0.9371439218521118,
0.0847964659333229,
0.09876933693885803,
-0.2752179503440857,
-0.5396440625190735,
0.31436070799827576,
-0.5897034406661987,
0.9316346645355225,
0.43246397376060486,
-0.6487932801246643,
-0.416187047958374,
-1.1561144590377808,
0.5124317407608032,
0.48447227478027344,
-1.0214195251464844,
0.02986573986709118,
0.3316677212715149,
-0.2943309545516968,
-0.000015152159903664142,
0.6299169063568115,
-0.429916113615036,
0.24628356099128723,
0.08298934996128082,
-0.008830261416733265,
0.17142902314662933,
-0.18913587927818298,
0.16378971934318542,
0.1822492927312851,
0.2733520567417145,
-0.18632660806179047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11199v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11199v2 | Direct Evaluation of Chain-of-Thought in Multi-hop Reasoning with Knowledge Graphs | 2024-02-17T05:22:56 | 2024-06-19T05:14:05 | Minh-Vuong Nguyen, Linhao Luo, Fatemeh Shiri, Dinh Phung, Yuan-Fang Li, Thuy-Trang Vu, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate strong reasoning abilities when
prompted to generate chain-of-thought (CoT) explanations alongside answers.
However, previous research on evaluating LLMs has solely focused on answer
accuracy, neglecting the correctness of the generated CoT. In this paper, we
delve deeper into the CoT reasoning capabilities of LLMs in multi-hop question
answering by utilizing knowledge graphs (KGs). We propose a novel
discriminative and generative CoT evaluation paradigm to assess LLMs' knowledge
of reasoning and the accuracy of the generated CoT. Through experiments
conducted on 5 different families of LLMs across 2 multi-hop question-answering
datasets, we find that LLMs possess sufficient knowledge to perform reasoning.
However, there exists a significant disparity between answer accuracy and
faithfulness of the CoT reasoning generated by LLMs, indicating that they often
arrive at correct answers through incorrect reasoning. | [
-0.37299418449401855,
-1.03834867477417,
1.0292538404464722,
0.1359330415725708,
-0.22373932600021362,
0.6621970534324646,
-0.1539791077375412,
-0.26318609714508057,
-0.013357414864003658,
0.34521764516830444,
-0.47872477769851685,
-0.6274638175964355,
-0.7461180090904236,
0.3921830952167511,
-0.27216801047325134,
0.640948474407196,
-0.341818243265152,
-0.12729215621948242,
-0.4108459949493408,
-0.11062879860401154,
-0.5712466239929199,
-0.4096338748931885,
-0.5314092040061951,
-0.26354002952575684,
0.7349233627319336,
0.13843241333961487,
0.7813915610313416,
0.27597734332084656,
0.3300885856151581,
0.26333144307136536,
-0.23887577652931213,
0.8358816504478455,
-0.45553064346313477,
0.1385568529367447,
-0.20402371883392334,
-0.43444955348968506,
-0.498767614364624,
-0.10861054062843323,
0.5546806454658508,
0.7954615354537964,
0.20324447751045227,
0.2048313170671463,
-0.06640951335430145,
0.8485539555549622,
-0.8121641278266907,
-0.05162399634718895,
-0.9334398508071899,
0.043741125613451004,
0.10408248752355576,
-0.31105145812034607,
-0.7978804707527161,
-0.7146691679954529,
0.042681653052568436,
-0.42563802003860474,
-0.07479154318571091,
0.15248341858386993,
0.495812326669693,
-0.021971875801682472,
-0.7487284541130066,
-0.6087736487388611,
-0.6994799375534058,
0.4258648455142975,
-0.46386533975601196,
0.5498574376106262,
0.23922555148601532,
0.3834554851055145,
-0.45056065917015076,
-0.6394984126091003,
-0.7172713875770569,
-0.05605298653244972,
-0.1195683553814888,
0.09755297750234604,
-0.09321559220552444,
0.1311449557542801,
0.2922421395778656,
0.2617764472961426,
-0.5152996778488159,
-0.2411932498216629,
-0.16487236320972443,
-0.08040223270654678,
0.5480085015296936,
0.1829478144645691,
0.0798383504152298,
0.008338497020304203,
-0.5041327476501465,
-0.11226135492324829,
-0.49436113238334656,
-0.06451024115085602,
0.23428422212600708,
0.2515562176704407,
0.08672454208135605,
0.6088330745697021,
-0.0848468765616417,
1.1255238056182861,
0.08379597961902618,
-0.2767099142074585,
0.264023095369339,
-0.27526482939720154,
-0.24645055830478668,
-0.1595320999622345,
0.8799784183502197,
0.19561250507831573,
0.5521919131278992,
-0.3967583179473877,
0.007275380659848452,
0.03346854820847511,
0.29893600940704346,
-0.3270708918571472,
-0.03446552902460098,
0.37255316972732544,
-0.2154076248407364,
-0.36487042903900146,
0.009022130630910397,
-0.731553852558136,
-0.48356080055236816,
0.017704926431179047,
0.3532128632068634,
-0.4106656014919281,
-0.28756794333457947,
0.23795749247074127,
-0.44733142852783203,
0.1934228241443634,
0.3094407320022583,
-0.25824713706970215,
0.17171791195869446,
0.5963431000709534,
0.7023921012878418,
0.008489172905683517,
-0.39031997323036194,
-0.5193082690238953,
0.282189279794693,
-0.7847795486450195,
0.7808656096458435,
-0.5740221738815308,
-0.11882346868515015,
-0.1438901126384735,
-0.2575088441371918,
-0.4140755534172058,
-0.38433635234832764,
0.39855530858039856,
-1.0485502481460571,
-0.3674970269203186,
-0.5435983538627625,
-0.7160042524337769,
-0.1038944348692894,
0.5738555788993835,
-0.5071347951889038,
0.8012869954109192,
0.1362736076116562,
-1.087045669555664,
0.416129469871521,
-0.4064538776874542,
-0.4298281669616699,
0.062135349959135056,
-0.28836849331855774,
-0.09590093791484833,
-0.2144910842180252,
0.44609183073043823,
0.32450246810913086,
-0.25765541195869446,
0.3761351704597473,
-0.523243248462677,
-0.2883235514163971,
0.5748884081840515,
-0.4714178740978241,
0.8511768579483032,
0.254021018743515,
-0.174006849527359,
-0.08110174536705017,
-0.6109857559204102,
0.378419429063797,
0.31640973687171936,
-0.27928462624549866,
-0.29406142234802246,
-0.022618364542722702,
-0.9608374238014221,
0.32789796590805054,
0.09828639030456543,
-0.46209844946861267,
0.28427568078041077,
-0.10841406136751175,
0.20604649186134338,
0.8570459485054016,
0.11536422371864319,
0.10440666228532791,
-0.2610745429992676,
0.6171975135803223,
0.03288565203547478,
0.20714415609836578,
0.23681992292404175,
-0.6490182280540466,
-0.5713089108467102,
-0.11286943405866623,
0.10606974363327026,
0.22082528471946716,
-0.9771299362182617,
0.37930458784103394,
-0.38722118735313416,
-0.5560160875320435,
-0.29853329062461853,
0.2019329071044922,
0.5015608668327332,
0.4751532971858978,
0.2733950614929199,
0.014478078112006187,
-0.41185858845710754,
-0.5473961234092712,
-0.29390037059783936,
-0.33790335059165955,
0.20596255362033844,
0.40439659357070923,
0.47992125153541565,
-0.2021227478981018,
0.9271565079689026,
-0.653509259223938,
0.39544540643692017,
-0.4483836591243744,
0.030068743973970413,
0.11988107115030289,
-0.12120886892080307,
0.25259485840797424,
-0.5794342756271362,
-0.1422756463289261,
-0.010065876878798008,
-0.8764855265617371,
0.13000664114952087,
-0.034722041338682175,
-0.489406019449234,
-0.16389650106430054,
0.19817328453063965,
-0.7074280381202698,
0.2778416872024536,
0.47576606273651123,
-0.41908812522888184,
0.8862056136131287,
-0.0783771350979805,
0.2714027166366577,
-0.7225831151008606,
-0.1589619517326355,
-0.3312779664993286,
-0.21978279948234558,
-0.39672163128852844,
0.19661512970924377,
0.03904144465923309,
0.17359459400177002,
-0.19779489934444427,
0.4076002240180969,
-0.4620615839958191,
-0.39358213543891907,
-0.026210879907011986,
0.6257704496383667,
0.40758344531059265,
0.3820793628692627,
-0.09041467308998108,
0.7897443175315857,
0.40967047214508057,
-0.7822497487068176,
0.5889062285423279,
0.4157629609107971,
-0.39344289898872375,
0.28121018409729004,
-0.3550589084625244,
0.5626271367073059,
-0.20352452993392944,
0.5045788288116455,
-1.1723625659942627,
0.05834123492240906,
0.03935258835554123,
-0.41320592164993286,
-0.07967140525579453,
-0.15407595038414001,
-0.6143765449523926,
-1.0445252656936646,
-0.2378675490617752,
0.4987945854663849,
0.2020052969455719,
-0.7933177351951599,
0.5043209791183472,
0.13666965067386627,
0.2335207164287567,
-0.7820380330085754,
-0.37784022092819214,
-0.14735881984233856,
-0.03972376510500908,
-0.6721864342689514,
-0.052884526550769806,
0.023423653095960617,
-0.2510799169540405,
-0.10749826580286026,
-0.2684169411659241,
-0.05952351167798042,
-0.022264452651143074,
-0.239328533411026,
0.17219196259975433,
-0.04905777797102928,
0.5227464437484741,
0.019366372376680374,
0.1593637764453888,
0.1616433560848236,
-0.3303014039993286,
0.7897285223007202,
-0.30007001757621765,
-0.5153123736381531,
0.0684884637594223,
-0.1477055847644806,
0.7543361186981201,
-0.33611273765563965,
0.7047551274299622,
0.33987510204315186,
-0.051440827548503876,
-0.326138436794281,
-0.4742063879966736,
0.1267509162425995,
-0.42995044589042664,
0.18043668568134308,
-0.8214786648750305,
-0.7094689607620239,
0.43467435240745544,
-0.36880743503570557,
-0.20326881110668182,
0.47569039463996887,
0.45835039019584656,
-0.1387174129486084,
0.9108842015266418,
0.07226371765136719,
0.341675341129303,
-0.261141300201416,
-0.42688676714897156,
0.571580171585083,
-1.1551549434661865,
-0.4663642942905426,
-0.34989112615585327,
-0.09403421729803085,
-0.5715092420578003,
-0.6159704327583313,
0.4095139801502228,
0.41545671224594116,
-0.599414050579071,
0.23152638971805573,
-0.4147968590259552,
0.49747753143310547,
0.30307823419570923,
0.33928245306015015,
0.4628444015979767,
-0.33113738894462585,
-0.6330377459526062,
0.618747889995575,
-0.9530588388442993,
-0.6813269257545471,
1.1531360149383545,
0.23309819400310516,
0.8047118782997131,
-0.040061838924884796,
0.4279848337173462,
0.29036158323287964,
0.15026211738586426,
-0.6769609451293945,
0.6160224676132202,
-0.0612148717045784,
-0.5278733968734741,
-0.3147750496864319,
-0.6992965340614319,
-0.8207091689109802,
0.26822829246520996,
-0.06909943372011185,
-0.7671952843666077,
-0.06429353356361389,
0.07891585677862167,
-0.2310372143983841,
0.7222543954849243,
-0.4614658057689667,
0.7403286695480347,
-0.5892115831375122,
-0.07527907192707062,
-0.07007036358118057,
-0.6006801128387451,
0.6140747666358948,
0.028734836727380753,
0.30720967054367065,
-0.056087881326675415,
0.33016732335090637,
0.8160284161567688,
-0.46817925572395325,
0.5016219019889832,
-0.1384476125240326,
-0.339479923248291,
0.8978483080863953,
0.37304219603538513,
0.5001136660575867,
-0.2405039668083191,
-0.09590992331504822,
0.16555893421173096,
0.004894646815955639,
-0.26981881260871887,
-0.9216352701187134,
0.5046635270118713,
-0.7805131673812866,
-0.642861545085907,
-0.18799319863319397,
-0.6059738397598267,
-0.6295187473297119,
0.03305564448237419,
-0.020184684544801712,
0.43623918294906616,
0.1152038499712944,
-0.22958117723464966,
0.34880530834198,
-0.3829410970211029,
-0.034760672599077225,
0.10288790613412857,
-0.5857016444206238,
-0.5860470533370972,
0.5946299433708191,
-0.03604406490921974,
0.6668111085891724,
0.34245410561561584,
0.40381890535354614,
-0.633479118347168,
-0.304633229970932,
-0.6765159964561462,
0.2391897290945053,
-1.1169143915176392,
-0.23805683851242065,
-0.7703021764755249,
-0.36588147282600403,
-0.1911281794309616,
-0.18268629908561707,
-0.29506000876426697,
-0.2625119686126709,
0.42657721042633057,
-0.4419654607772827,
0.3830643594264984,
0.9257226586341858,
0.22222758829593658,
0.09506309032440186,
-0.649461030960083,
0.5026901364326477,
0.7331758737564087,
0.42503923177719116,
0.4066534638404846,
-0.1292138248682022,
0.11024373024702072,
0.2507270872592926,
-0.5164967775344849,
-1.0599801540374756,
-0.24671173095703125,
-0.24268300831317902,
0.512406587600708,
0.39223620295524597,
0.13423089683055878,
0.9056296944618225,
-0.3728885054588318,
0.689409077167511,
0.3021771013736725,
-0.9702969789505005,
0.6476292610168457,
-0.0452214740216732,
0.12761373817920685,
0.3603227138519287,
0.410522997379303,
-0.22344347834587097,
-0.5979702472686768,
-0.532630443572998,
-0.6054295301437378,
0.32087668776512146,
0.2936813533306122,
-0.12676583230495453,
-0.5461282134056091,
0.36294734477996826,
0.1313897967338562,
0.18538913130760193,
-0.6352712512016296,
-0.26905226707458496,
0.11528174579143524,
0.004851129371672869,
0.27516868710517883,
-0.26902857422828674,
-0.07260897755622864,
-0.29184797406196594,
0.5601767897605896,
-0.17262962460517883,
0.39401674270629883,
0.30699244141578674,
0.006818279158324003,
-0.1838344782590866,
0.3956068754196167,
0.23436489701271057,
1.0707042217254639,
-0.18067803978919983,
0.6108877062797546,
0.3819013833999634,
-0.10776181519031525,
0.40680867433547974,
-0.5211750864982605,
0.03579575940966606,
-0.09594566375017166,
0.6764927506446838,
0.7266578078269958,
-0.28403642773628235,
-0.5910230875015259,
0.7053682208061218,
-0.02641945518553257,
-0.14437387883663177,
-0.06633582711219788,
0.037217237055301666,
0.2816193401813507,
0.1474558562040329,
0.1654285043478012,
0.14917270839214325,
-0.082073874771595,
-0.5731974840164185,
0.04847315698862076,
0.5292306542396545,
-0.1638331413269043,
0.001911808387376368,
0.44744741916656494,
0.20050308108329773,
-0.2241593897342682,
0.8319617509841919,
-0.372289776802063,
-0.7615769505500793,
0.6792294383049011,
0.7886267900466919,
0.7772017121315002,
0.024065200239419937,
0.3418758809566498,
0.40331366658210754,
0.33504176139831543,
0.31316474080085754,
0.20006050169467926,
-0.23645104467868805,
-1.2318708896636963,
-0.5919563174247742,
-0.6785619854927063,
-0.33641761541366577,
0.10619912296533585,
-0.6105116605758667,
0.1664532572031021,
-0.38168585300445557,
-0.30789270997047424,
-0.13365161418914795,
-0.2574582099914551,
-0.8042378425598145,
0.3252834379673004,
0.1507057100534439,
0.9376402497291565,
-0.659511148929596,
0.5342199802398682,
0.48452028632164,
-0.3487568497657776,
-0.9977779388427734,
0.3117152154445648,
-0.48884937167167664,
-0.9725186824798584,
0.8785443305969238,
0.1657094806432724,
-0.7270541191101074,
-0.15022006630897522,
-0.4021144211292267,
-0.6932486295700073,
1.1981983184814453,
0.418783962726593,
-0.6055954098701477,
0.08466555178165436,
0.2816169857978821,
0.4602475166320801,
-0.3125309348106384,
0.5488004088401794,
0.7179573774337769,
0.39123520255088806,
0.43665611743927,
-0.9350544214248657,
0.09058398753404617,
0.09596400707960129,
-0.028663652017712593,
0.14957375824451447,
-0.5870983004570007,
0.57890784740448,
-0.6130867600440979,
-0.15755648910999298,
-0.3171652853488922,
0.29444289207458496,
0.6967753171920776,
0.31588608026504517,
0.6535892486572266,
0.6651071310043335,
1.10504949092865,
0.00021081867453176528,
1.29640531539917,
-0.2531253397464752,
0.34337908029556274,
1.091778039932251,
-0.3636685311794281,
0.6052728295326233,
0.2575528025627136,
-0.6057201027870178,
0.8962517380714417,
0.5071766972541809,
0.3867281973361969,
0.41103774309158325,
0.5479860901832581,
-0.14565721154212952,
-0.5140399932861328,
0.17534324526786804,
-0.15803073346614838,
0.47767117619514465,
0.18292485177516937,
-0.34608322381973267,
-0.0554792620241642,
-0.208593487739563,
0.014630414545536041,
-0.00043213958269916475,
-0.38854867219924927,
0.7814620137214661,
0.043120644986629486,
-0.6425297260284424,
0.8995944261550903,
-0.1642826944589615,
0.17173561453819275,
-0.42543524503707886,
-0.050566162914037704,
-0.005130680277943611,
0.018864935263991356,
-0.14409169554710388,
-1.1794610023498535,
0.2329760640859604,
0.31274721026420593,
-0.0050852238200604916,
0.11687195301055908,
0.6917622685432434,
-0.04967580363154411,
-0.652788519859314,
0.7573956847190857,
0.8104764223098755,
0.16012316942214966,
0.15036362409591675,
-0.4890287518501282,
-0.010209420695900917,
-0.22378259897232056,
-0.11115910857915878,
-0.17210927605628967,
0.6576299667358398,
-0.04860030487179756,
0.984675943851471,
0.4640604257583618,
0.09361835569143295,
0.21726712584495544,
0.4211094081401825,
0.9524864554405212,
-0.4215446710586548,
-0.3632957637310028,
-1.0500177145004272,
0.2402191162109375,
-0.045033011585474014,
-0.11969220638275146,
0.6700941324234009,
0.5650867223739624,
0.8421199321746826,
-0.10285875201225281,
0.9827442169189453,
-0.13778336346149445,
0.25792425870895386,
-0.5357098579406738,
0.2430102676153183,
-0.2248704731464386,
0.16059395670890808,
-0.6015341281890869,
-0.7469897270202637,
-0.04924299195408821,
0.6579824090003967,
-0.7594547271728516,
0.20399020612239838,
1.054468035697937,
0.42027708888053894,
0.08025263994932175,
0.1329662948846817,
0.3684488832950592,
0.3880823254585266,
0.24819143116474152,
0.7394253611564636,
1.2251381874084473,
-0.4317929148674011,
0.5450606346130371,
-0.20765593647956848,
-0.21212054789066315,
0.39470332860946655,
-0.7713102698326111,
-1.0029184818267822,
-0.39310580492019653,
-0.2680118680000305,
-0.4178551733493805,
0.1350976973772049,
0.7726303935050964,
0.38677099347114563,
-0.6268836855888367,
-0.14341230690479279,
-0.4406624734401703,
0.5372732281684875,
-0.42046499252319336,
-0.2555593252182007,
0.6265419125556946,
-0.5589651465415955,
-0.1934501975774765,
0.3602789342403412,
0.31997594237327576,
-0.29731541872024536,
-0.16196979582309723,
-0.3169161379337311,
-0.3328305184841156,
0.1332530528306961,
0.8800778388977051,
-0.48444852232933044,
-0.7590153217315674,
-0.5239174962043762,
-0.07524138689041138,
0.20760194957256317,
0.12364140152931213,
0.7606667876243591,
-0.8099344372749329,
0.6938749551773071,
0.34108269214630127,
0.6043636202812195,
0.403908371925354,
0.29116174578666687,
0.43353092670440674,
-0.6340421438217163,
-0.2963522970676422,
0.23183079063892365,
0.3553653359413147,
0.25419583916664124,
-0.3157940208911896,
0.4445638358592987,
0.20809920132160187,
-0.46847599744796753,
-0.4469815492630005,
0.4631589651107788,
-0.7983519434928894,
-0.3172050714492798,
1.3833388090133667,
-0.35353636741638184,
-0.10334368795156479,
-0.16095879673957825,
-0.19795678555965424,
0.39279186725616455,
0.1439983993768692,
0.571700930595398,
0.7596624493598938,
-0.34680280089378357,
0.026727836579084396,
-0.2153967171907425,
0.20832307636737823,
-0.07939327508211136,
-0.7937763929367065,
0.2922760546207428,
0.31600767374038696,
0.3754550814628601,
0.19779525697231293,
0.8989108800888062,
-0.15992550551891327,
0.08604548126459122,
0.15266327559947968,
-0.13815359771251678,
-0.016048476099967957,
-0.5207963585853577,
0.23569044470787048,
0.18846125900745392,
0.4894750118255615,
-0.22382035851478577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11197v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11197v2 | Centroid-Based Efficient Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding | 2024-02-17T05:15:12 | 2024-06-11T07:14:46 | Hiroyuki Deguchi, Yusuke Sakai, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe, Hideki Tanaka, Masao Utiyama | cs.CL | cs.CL | Minimum Bayes risk (MBR) decoding achieved state-of-the-art translation
performance by using COMET, a neural metric that has a high correlation with
human evaluation. However, MBR decoding requires quadratic time since it
computes the expected score between a translation hypothesis and all reference
translations. We propose centroid-based MBR (CBMBR) decoding to improve the
speed of MBR decoding. Our method clusters the reference translations in the
feature space, and then calculates the score using the centroids of each
cluster. The experimental results show that our CBMBR not only improved the
decoding speed of the expected score calculation 5.7 times, but also
outperformed vanilla MBR decoding in translation quality by up to 0.5 COMET in
the WMT'22 En$\leftrightarrow$Ja, En$\leftrightarrow$De, En$\leftrightarrow$Zh,
and WMT'23 En$\leftrightarrow$Ja translation tasks. | [
-0.27881523966789246,
-0.5025599598884583,
0.5101451277732849,
0.2869994044303894,
-0.5589854717254639,
0.07772062718868256,
-0.047662001103162766,
-0.3821456730365753,
0.11891655623912811,
0.4290952980518341,
-0.4557061791419983,
-0.7543824911117554,
-0.5853617787361145,
0.056016601622104645,
0.08765225857496262,
0.962935745716095,
0.4924814999103546,
0.31380778551101685,
0.20279531180858612,
0.01843058131635189,
-0.0862584188580513,
-0.5289300084114075,
-0.6434200406074524,
0.20626206696033478,
0.8324754238128662,
0.6558417677879333,
0.9712657332420349,
0.7246175408363342,
0.9313775300979614,
0.23949244618415833,
-0.43832141160964966,
-0.19694676995277405,
-0.2712481617927551,
-0.72444087266922,
-0.2860375940799713,
-0.40225523710250854,
-0.48387956619262695,
-0.30710089206695557,
0.6972393989562988,
1.1886091232299805,
-0.27561312913894653,
0.3386682868003845,
0.130681112408638,
1.1680002212524414,
-0.9288482069969177,
0.16951143741607666,
-0.5132390856742859,
-0.23341600596904755,
-0.20230206847190857,
-0.25272226333618164,
-0.6308810710906982,
-0.6289929151535034,
-0.19201426208019257,
-0.24556753039360046,
0.2559444010257721,
0.18911954760551453,
0.31678470969200134,
0.049754269421100616,
-0.7788854241371155,
0.09704042226076126,
-0.5722208023071289,
0.6971246600151062,
-0.3805451989173889,
0.39543527364730835,
0.19567377865314484,
0.7141798734664917,
-0.4763149619102478,
-0.053834401071071625,
-0.590996265411377,
0.42657339572906494,
0.026448171585798264,
0.013573670759797096,
-0.4408862888813019,
0.13080018758773804,
0.20265719294548035,
-0.06926042586565018,
-0.4296540319919586,
-0.14775551855564117,
-0.24982650578022003,
-0.4308740794658661,
0.6848675608634949,
0.30907416343688965,
-0.09794629365205765,
-0.4710081219673157,
-0.16467595100402832,
-0.6562530398368835,
-0.7515670657157898,
0.5845156908035278,
0.271622896194458,
0.2495366632938385,
-0.04516157880425453,
0.4627073109149933,
-0.35582563281059265,
0.4671880304813385,
0.1738356202840805,
-0.44130370020866394,
0.3867061138153076,
-0.21498475968837738,
-0.05974198505282402,
0.18050070106983185,
0.7151679396629333,
0.8853280544281006,
-0.33129847049713135,
-0.31533095240592957,
-0.032719943672418594,
-0.04066086933016777,
0.29661431908607483,
-0.9221647381782532,
-0.06386886537075043,
0.07013032585382462,
-0.7638716697692871,
-0.20001102983951569,
-0.2370608150959015,
-0.9369868636131287,
-0.1830931305885315,
0.07510527968406677,
0.7009989023208618,
-0.8565266728401184,
0.01192997582256794,
0.19714635610580444,
-0.28343942761421204,
0.39949774742126465,
0.029175668954849243,
-0.7366026639938354,
0.421631783246994,
0.4911609888076782,
0.6994873285293579,
-0.033701129257678986,
0.03014274872839451,
-0.6782110333442688,
0.042049385607242584,
-0.5075960755348206,
0.8598082065582275,
-0.03873983398079872,
-0.5760036706924438,
-0.050887905061244965,
-0.01047325599938631,
-0.1381932944059372,
-0.3629813492298126,
0.6357091069221497,
-0.4640980660915375,
-0.6363393068313599,
-0.6813334226608276,
-0.1283654272556305,
-0.5195990204811096,
-0.12729030847549438,
-0.47962304949760437,
0.5305976271629333,
0.23399214446544647,
-1.0364152193069458,
0.38606151938438416,
-0.32219016551971436,
-0.7590325474739075,
-0.04555510729551315,
-0.025007756426930428,
-0.33263254165649414,
0.3893037736415863,
0.5097289681434631,
0.5409803986549377,
-0.26319244503974915,
0.24316854774951935,
-0.3933009207248688,
-0.4241742491722107,
0.5302784442901611,
-0.3715144395828247,
0.7220024466514587,
0.17979216575622559,
-0.2632174789905548,
-0.18901358544826508,
-0.9544752836227417,
0.14566202461719513,
-0.09382608532905579,
-0.26670876145362854,
-0.23568809032440186,
0.46655476093292236,
0.18380823731422424,
-0.008382204920053482,
0.1561487913131714,
-0.8163108229637146,
-0.19854123890399933,
-0.24179375171661377,
0.1300412118434906,
0.48581787943840027,
0.2066923826932907,
0.6143757700920105,
-0.6001539826393127,
0.05277729779481888,
0.3956541419029236,
0.27274617552757263,
0.3896504044532776,
-0.6229338645935059,
-0.3345104455947876,
-0.26434653997421265,
0.054014015942811966,
0.6650732159614563,
-1.0874255895614624,
0.7533197402954102,
-0.7610229849815369,
-0.9268255829811096,
-0.595919132232666,
-0.19545120000839233,
0.6260596513748169,
0.43291428685188293,
0.6989889740943909,
-0.3517352044582367,
-0.07684051990509033,
-1.2990531921386719,
-0.263996958732605,
-0.3022519052028656,
0.09747281670570374,
0.04600003361701965,
0.13226275146007538,
-0.4445663094520569,
0.7766315340995789,
-0.4218543767929077,
-0.14205273985862732,
-0.5140238404273987,
0.05364770069718361,
0.7435632944107056,
0.8353032469749451,
0.6349279284477234,
-0.5152187347412109,
-0.5140777230262756,
0.08690407127141953,
-0.03144494444131851,
0.1924840360879898,
-0.24406582117080688,
-0.5029081106185913,
0.15292856097221375,
0.026887275278568268,
-0.5487490892410278,
0.7337039113044739,
0.6580623388290405,
-0.23625615239143372,
0.40294602513313293,
-0.43953171372413635,
0.4621974229812622,
-0.9491527676582336,
0.3552453815937042,
-0.17752379179000854,
-0.14452187716960907,
-0.655904233455658,
-0.24841514229774475,
0.564558207988739,
0.16289447247982025,
-0.4880184829235077,
0.06109778583049774,
-0.5240524411201477,
-0.13640478253364563,
-0.38950982689857483,
0.14080816507339478,
-0.31424760818481445,
0.44251346588134766,
0.04580215737223625,
0.6684802174568176,
0.5307620763778687,
-1.0791316032409668,
-0.3794722557067871,
0.5491350293159485,
-0.5283004641532898,
0.5833409428596497,
-0.22113682329654694,
0.012195363640785217,
-0.3146072328090668,
0.02135823853313923,
-0.9722911715507507,
0.1904943734407425,
0.2509689927101135,
-0.614490807056427,
0.5234402418136597,
-0.4259033799171448,
-0.5798513293266296,
-0.4232678711414337,
-0.30840805172920227,
0.4753090441226959,
0.7570057511329651,
-0.6629476547241211,
0.4293402135372162,
0.5354991555213928,
-0.2134241759777069,
-0.7592390179634094,
-0.7317623496055603,
0.1171426847577095,
0.14334209263324738,
-0.659935474395752,
0.4530230760574341,
-0.42982053756713867,
0.29591479897499084,
-0.062307387590408325,
-0.19228605926036835,
-0.038147859275341034,
0.037882737815380096,
0.3290366232395172,
0.2027338147163391,
0.018426308408379555,
-0.3785768449306488,
0.7455392479896545,
-0.4857275187969208,
0.1509549617767334,
-0.05339110270142555,
0.06467597186565399,
-0.07973727583885193,
-0.24900275468826294,
-0.29569342732429504,
0.6455072164535522,
0.3912382125854492,
0.22113686800003052,
0.951961100101471,
0.7837385535240173,
-0.479981392621994,
0.12301207333803177,
-0.762583315372467,
-0.10287081450223923,
-0.4909960627555847,
0.2296830713748932,
-0.70707106590271,
-0.8169846534729004,
0.603546142578125,
0.09213865548372269,
-0.3296182453632355,
0.43858659267425537,
0.40129783749580383,
-0.15942837297916412,
1.2737253904342651,
0.8710551857948303,
-0.46374717354774475,
0.1584143042564392,
-0.2202681601047516,
0.33989354968070984,
-1.1719391345977783,
-0.27822181582450867,
-0.6442656517028809,
-0.5151181817054749,
-0.55184006690979,
-0.42955222725868225,
0.6855455040931702,
0.22538842260837555,
0.05274917930364609,
0.5724940299987793,
-0.41297703981399536,
0.4790711998939514,
0.5997635126113892,
0.48318934440612793,
0.012496446259319782,
0.05963842570781708,
-0.6120428442955017,
-0.22672921419143677,
-1.0585823059082031,
-0.20388764142990112,
1.1392896175384521,
0.09589084982872009,
0.6435658931732178,
0.5364598631858826,
0.7055159211158752,
0.09226280450820923,
0.45435431599617004,
-0.59980708360672,
0.6780194044113159,
-0.19256436824798584,
-0.6826608777046204,
0.004354656208306551,
-0.9209815263748169,
-1.052948236465454,
0.3741031885147095,
-0.445521742105484,
-0.8460360765457153,
0.6808456778526306,
0.04530578851699829,
-0.5912262201309204,
0.37849029898643494,
-0.2690778970718384,
0.9688730835914612,
-0.20456643402576447,
-0.1686374694108963,
-0.5164477825164795,
-0.9399564862251282,
0.35816919803619385,
0.08101145178079605,
0.6770104765892029,
-0.14306165277957916,
0.023955771699547768,
0.6697484254837036,
-0.36149364709854126,
0.7365492582321167,
-0.37882259488105774,
0.5416843891143799,
0.28460729122161865,
0.5296061635017395,
0.34041348099708557,
0.18834295868873596,
0.03642217814922333,
0.3015526533126831,
0.5871543288230896,
-0.6490813493728638,
-0.1832341104745865,
0.3470543324947357,
-0.7919720411300659,
-0.4129810929298401,
-0.6857730150222778,
-0.44510921835899353,
-0.09517206996679306,
0.23969370126724243,
0.4606770873069763,
0.2868969440460205,
-0.4385019838809967,
0.19968169927597046,
0.5289249420166016,
-0.2208091765642166,
0.6567561030387878,
0.8018894791603088,
0.021283499896526337,
-1.0069677829742432,
0.6860231161117554,
-0.20973509550094604,
0.03346308693289757,
0.7140801548957825,
0.12351437658071518,
-0.39700281620025635,
-0.9431816935539246,
-0.6168979406356812,
0.4681295156478882,
-0.7211792469024658,
-0.7677963972091675,
-0.7914491891860962,
-0.1061529889702797,
-0.4271481931209564,
-0.33395886421203613,
-0.4166554808616638,
-0.2288622409105301,
0.09448695927858353,
0.05451183766126633,
0.1313609927892685,
0.22361578047275543,
-0.636692225933075,
0.7839359641075134,
-1.7049334049224854,
0.20549656450748444,
-0.23510833084583282,
0.16240765154361725,
-0.31641122698783875,
-0.6232401728630066,
-0.7294225096702576,
0.08983805030584335,
0.03468937799334526,
-1.2118719816207886,
0.5745595693588257,
-0.06829816848039627,
0.7805543541908264,
0.48719289898872375,
0.2894183099269867,
0.7539485096931458,
-0.7188591361045837,
0.21905583143234253,
0.3615127503871918,
-1.1192461252212524,
0.27497902512550354,
-0.019482646137475967,
0.287961483001709,
0.9781422019004822,
0.5615171790122986,
-0.6805381178855896,
0.09141011536121368,
-0.4723955988883972,
-0.47596317529678345,
0.583645224571228,
0.27849647402763367,
-0.2419249564409256,
-0.43207013607025146,
0.5197263360023499,
-0.02924628183245659,
-0.02845684438943863,
-0.24786531925201416,
0.014222822152078152,
0.28469955921173096,
-0.3055923581123352,
-0.5268605947494507,
-0.44595810770988464,
0.11794320493936539,
-0.2791158854961395,
0.6130733489990234,
-0.31806209683418274,
0.5035348534584045,
0.4983120858669281,
-0.5150492787361145,
-0.4203414022922516,
0.29803895950317383,
0.15333136916160583,
0.09328612685203552,
-0.6134927272796631,
0.10918111354112625,
0.3216928243637085,
-0.5417448282241821,
0.1540798544883728,
0.10662870854139328,
-0.1888110339641571,
-0.014367909170687199,
0.029584186151623726,
0.17575566470623016,
0.5568503737449646,
-0.4705965518951416,
1.0443450212478638,
-0.27606889605522156,
-0.026613807305693626,
-0.13684090971946716,
0.027612317353487015,
-0.07049811631441116,
0.32380324602127075,
0.2707519233226776,
0.4814877212047577,
0.5171118378639221,
-0.49626991152763367,
0.23767255246639252,
0.3532556891441345,
-0.3809196352958679,
-0.363552063703537,
0.44767946004867554,
-0.03169391304254532,
0.24968820810317993,
0.479636549949646,
-0.5498107671737671,
-0.5026254653930664,
0.3780510127544403,
0.6523656845092773,
0.8796030282974243,
-0.31235289573669434,
0.12933672964572906,
0.8871986865997314,
0.781279981136322,
-0.03354698792099953,
0.6663097739219666,
0.09476760774850845,
-0.8009434938430786,
-0.45821917057037354,
-0.7383333444595337,
-0.5393996834754944,
-0.7097630500793457,
-0.954011857509613,
-0.0696309432387352,
-0.6351350545883179,
-0.5435900688171387,
-0.33124473690986633,
-0.21065863966941833,
-0.74370938539505,
0.1785028725862503,
0.07648826390504837,
1.1508803367614746,
-0.5419900417327881,
0.990023136138916,
0.4987877309322357,
-0.16894745826721191,
-0.4610424339771271,
-0.4823321998119354,
0.08937186747789383,
-0.28166210651397705,
0.21893584728240967,
0.3153688609600067,
-0.25613388419151306,
0.12599118053913116,
-0.21286539733409882,
-1.2099655866622925,
1.3382835388183594,
0.02111084945499897,
-0.772990882396698,
0.2538081407546997,
0.22969947755336761,
0.2993362545967102,
-0.4455234706401825,
0.15362361073493958,
0.826273500919342,
0.24236424267292023,
-0.11705201864242554,
-0.501762866973877,
0.26366057991981506,
-0.13051477074623108,
0.26699361205101013,
0.2995895743370056,
-0.43868643045425415,
0.49064043164253235,
-0.5776479840278625,
-0.449133962392807,
0.19530069828033447,
0.5789255499839783,
-0.03569132462143898,
0.3665594458580017,
0.3756108582019806,
0.5214838981628418,
0.5477949380874634,
0.0434773713350296,
1.2037489414215088,
-0.6545624136924744,
-0.0072942147962749004,
0.7130351662635803,
0.10619226098060608,
1.4166849851608276,
0.24235868453979492,
-0.260558545589447,
0.36393502354621887,
0.5221254825592041,
0.3232540488243103,
0.8343434929847717,
-0.006442714482545853,
-0.11347267031669617,
-0.2936365008354187,
0.46281230449676514,
-0.08139750361442566,
0.016989577561616898,
0.6426945924758911,
0.03203708678483963,
-0.07062213867902756,
-0.030515015125274658,
0.0005034857313148677,
0.009659277275204659,
-0.44608235359191895,
0.7502940893173218,
0.16913539171218872,
-0.3793641924858093,
0.48139238357543945,
0.4011565148830414,
0.535376787185669,
-0.4199230968952179,
0.41197890043258667,
-0.27967220544815063,
0.4566560685634613,
-0.024181663990020752,
-0.6400712728500366,
0.5744831562042236,
-0.2545524835586548,
-0.1476289927959442,
0.3315976560115814,
0.6333506107330322,
-0.33506980538368225,
-0.6758459806442261,
0.5446719527244568,
0.35131585597991943,
0.2904604375362396,
-0.5385993123054504,
-0.5299372673034668,
-0.08600492030382156,
-0.16616198420524597,
0.2797609567642212,
0.34797418117523193,
0.47528567910194397,
0.29617202281951904,
0.6748641729354858,
0.9624873399734497,
-0.0635184496641159,
0.27260202169418335,
-0.29342034459114075,
0.8772496581077576,
-1.16107976436615,
-0.4059014916419983,
-0.5866809487342834,
0.578604519367218,
0.25354376435279846,
0.027556169778108597,
0.4625091850757599,
0.7586042881011963,
0.4845351576805115,
-0.3200136721134186,
0.42494890093803406,
-0.019786519929766655,
0.5517439842224121,
-0.633568286895752,
0.9881986379623413,
-0.17422939836978912,
-0.1164485365152359,
-0.19098596274852753,
-1.184921383857727,
-0.5651723742485046,
0.6475857496261597,
-0.152765154838562,
-0.4731597900390625,
1.124894618988037,
0.88352370262146,
0.124635711312294,
-0.22378598153591156,
0.5480200052261353,
0.001226872089318931,
0.1803029477596283,
1.055765151977539,
0.3664809763431549,
-0.6501638293266296,
0.9007547497749329,
-0.6805914640426636,
-0.6493121981620789,
-0.5287765860557556,
-0.8194210529327393,
-0.9854705929756165,
-0.21832959353923798,
-0.4332554042339325,
-0.3419111371040344,
-0.05802091956138611,
0.7770077586174011,
0.3963247537612915,
-0.7397491335868835,
-0.259316086769104,
0.18707619607448578,
0.10490213334560394,
-0.5323923230171204,
-0.06164746731519699,
0.34395137429237366,
-0.4530285894870758,
-0.2767040431499481,
0.472001314163208,
0.4945300817489624,
0.01932397484779358,
0.4514707922935486,
-0.11748678982257843,
-0.05132781341671944,
0.20615869760513306,
0.6856018900871277,
-0.0093705914914608,
-0.24975323677062988,
-0.5867303609848022,
-0.13001395761966705,
-0.4992682635784149,
0.19594967365264893,
0.7250379920005798,
-0.4332050085067749,
0.11198298633098602,
0.6228266954421997,
0.9752213358879089,
0.6270226836204529,
-0.14609397947788239,
0.19165357947349548,
-0.18791601061820984,
0.02568628452718258,
0.061197828501462936,
0.5546746850013733,
0.17946068942546844,
-0.3456260859966278,
0.32498693466186523,
0.47900915145874023,
-0.5362546443939209,
-0.11270395666360855,
0.03301414102315903,
-1.6041268110275269,
-0.028412463143467903,
0.6905282139778137,
-0.06092187762260437,
-0.9046734571456909,
0.09276249259710312,
-0.09954662621021271,
0.14756660163402557,
-0.364228218793869,
0.6133741140365601,
0.39059096574783325,
0.19149243831634521,
-0.1001550629734993,
-0.3471982181072235,
0.3466586768627167,
0.38123974204063416,
-0.4009339213371277,
-0.177108034491539,
0.613457202911377,
0.4465174674987793,
0.20682133734226227,
0.6228238940238953,
-0.4771016240119934,
0.7239378094673157,
0.49043402075767517,
0.45395606756210327,
0.24320009350776672,
-0.44224321842193604,
-0.3158474862575531,
-0.1165187656879425,
0.13880997896194458,
-0.1996249258518219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11194v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11194v2 | Evaluating LLMs' Mathematical Reasoning in Financial Document Question Answering | 2024-02-17T05:10:18 | 2024-02-29T09:13:58 | Pragya Srivastava, Manuj Malik, Vivek Gupta, Tanuja Ganu, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs), excel in natural language understanding, but
their capability for complex mathematical reasoning with an amalgamation of
structured tables and unstructured text is uncertain. This study explores LLMs'
mathematical reasoning on four financial tabular question-answering datasets:
TATQA, FinQA, ConvFinQA, and Multihiertt. Through extensive experiments with
various models and prompting techniques, we assess how LLMs adapt to complex
tables and mathematical tasks. We focus on sensitivity to table complexity and
performance variations with an increasing number of arithmetic reasoning steps.
The results provide insights into LLMs' capabilities and limitations in
handling complex mathematical scenarios for semi-structured tables. Ultimately,
we introduce a novel prompting technique tailored to semi-structured documents,
matching or outperforming other baselines in performance while providing a
nuanced understanding of LLMs abilities for such a task. | [
-0.1520860642194748,
-1.290493130683899,
0.922419011592865,
0.4106176197528839,
-0.07119963318109512,
0.3343084752559662,
0.00039043265860527754,
-0.26094090938568115,
-0.4316238760948181,
0.5067105293273926,
-0.6567456126213074,
-0.7155997157096863,
-0.2859802544116974,
0.4685317873954773,
-0.433694064617157,
0.9023820161819458,
-0.37350261211395264,
0.14150039851665497,
-0.5830302834510803,
0.1795128583908081,
-0.43333956599235535,
-0.4909706711769104,
-0.6983269453048706,
-0.4558423161506653,
0.2965162992477417,
0.6829240918159485,
0.8297702670097351,
0.28422603011131287,
0.6881893277168274,
0.3653859794139862,
0.09489379823207855,
0.14937029778957367,
-0.11355019360780716,
0.13440769910812378,
-0.15188781917095184,
-0.9356771111488342,
-0.5764599442481995,
-0.22964422404766083,
0.49856171011924744,
0.7614210247993469,
-0.39429500699043274,
0.27042362093925476,
-0.05283282697200775,
0.9510598182678223,
-0.11230143904685974,
0.5994143486022949,
-0.7087193727493286,
0.026857711374759674,
-0.2957542836666107,
-0.1314762681722641,
-0.5781050324440002,
-0.4515858292579651,
0.3782418668270111,
-0.856490433216095,
-0.006144050508737564,
0.19627676904201508,
0.5502374172210693,
0.27940696477890015,
-0.41451629996299744,
-0.7435632348060608,
-0.6637100577354431,
0.47823911905288696,
-0.5936059355735779,
0.26752182841300964,
0.3659627139568329,
0.43303194642066956,
-0.1915472149848938,
-0.7626645565032959,
-0.5122852325439453,
-0.2073545902967453,
-0.040639281272888184,
0.08706827461719513,
-0.2699294686317444,
0.047651778906583786,
0.5719426870346069,
0.1939820647239685,
-0.6046304702758789,
0.062466852366924286,
-0.28913968801498413,
-0.11297240108251572,
0.44605666399002075,
0.26487624645233154,
0.0482042133808136,
-0.06584971398115158,
-0.24531207978725433,
0.004649234935641289,
-0.5573420524597168,
0.3832356631755829,
0.3670293390750885,
0.21408724784851074,
-0.1964966207742691,
0.7871506214141846,
0.16974486410617828,
0.9467526078224182,
-0.2356431931257248,
-0.27292680740356445,
-0.3256394863128662,
-0.1998506635427475,
-0.40842968225479126,
0.15353405475616455,
0.21683797240257263,
0.21467579901218414,
0.7155987024307251,
0.05468513444066048,
-0.4461968243122101,
-0.11205936223268509,
-0.012402592226862907,
-0.2624158263206482,
-0.11640007793903351,
0.2694104015827179,
-0.07462722063064575,
-0.09348626434803009,
-0.04328268766403198,
-0.6619852781295776,
-0.24512313306331635,
-0.49819549918174744,
0.6208307147026062,
-0.37836211919784546,
0.38304275274276733,
0.45410096645355225,
-0.27051565051078796,
0.2494809627532959,
0.5633760094642639,
-0.8950774669647217,
0.4432077407836914,
0.816708505153656,
0.5402607321739197,
0.21113301813602448,
-0.004003141541033983,
-0.7952001690864563,
0.3342750370502472,
-0.23306109011173248,
1.1911388635635376,
-0.5778204798698425,
-0.2925153076648712,
0.028923790901899338,
-0.40636491775512695,
-0.41075047850608826,
-0.6545829772949219,
0.6866984963417053,
-0.6326996088027954,
0.23714053630828857,
-0.5218641757965088,
-0.5541555285453796,
-0.16674911975860596,
0.33836695551872253,
-0.6557785868644714,
0.8629680871963501,
0.3497380018234253,
-0.5531986951828003,
0.37227773666381836,
-0.9811092019081116,
-0.5669224858283997,
0.046826016157865524,
-0.08596395701169968,
-0.37184521555900574,
0.0017610089853405952,
0.3628990948200226,
0.26777175068855286,
-0.6056646108627319,
0.32590797543525696,
-0.43601515889167786,
-0.1909356415271759,
0.9000723361968994,
-0.47645774483680725,
0.21906790137290955,
0.14041513204574585,
-0.005836569704115391,
0.019985701888799667,
-0.7302872538566589,
-0.09220471978187561,
0.11265626549720764,
-0.47049593925476074,
-0.24680952727794647,
0.014566542580723763,
-0.28665393590927124,
0.032452818006277084,
0.23840057849884033,
-0.22832338511943817,
0.31965911388397217,
-0.41784775257110596,
0.8178544640541077,
0.8068995475769043,
0.06929899752140045,
0.3954586386680603,
-0.5981598496437073,
0.6286893486976624,
-0.04430141672492027,
-0.1420147866010666,
0.031248508021235466,
-0.25183165073394775,
-0.4805842936038971,
-0.06965044885873795,
0.3011850416660309,
0.7410030364990234,
-0.8139391541481018,
-0.2303481549024582,
-0.012298348359763622,
-0.2039555013179779,
-0.13216347992420197,
0.3630160093307495,
0.20704884827136993,
0.7873693108558655,
0.20268411934375763,
0.5238173604011536,
-0.19756655395030975,
-1.0930054187774658,
-0.4712109863758087,
-0.012088765390217304,
-0.09090384095907211,
0.37185680866241455,
0.607438862323761,
0.4018441140651703,
0.7080526947975159,
-0.5672604441642761,
0.05762196704745293,
-0.31941524147987366,
0.23345232009887695,
0.6238805055618286,
-0.12129480391740799,
0.5603768825531006,
-0.8338811993598938,
-0.47970905900001526,
-0.23410005867481232,
-0.5685930848121643,
-0.20900703966617584,
-0.6551780104637146,
-0.06645224988460541,
0.22790458798408508,
0.41815194487571716,
-0.606592059135437,
0.4402654767036438,
0.2101598083972931,
-0.4590764343738556,
0.43717485666275024,
-0.4191199243068695,
-0.06100013852119446,
-0.7765669226646423,
-0.09525682777166367,
0.28857630491256714,
-0.023378713056445122,
-0.6476475596427917,
-0.4144074022769928,
0.09611557424068451,
-0.006374008487910032,
-0.14398524165153503,
0.487689346075058,
-0.5092363357543945,
-0.5537219047546387,
0.2032768726348877,
0.458820641040802,
0.16715878248214722,
0.3267805278301239,
-0.1536083072423935,
1.177119255065918,
0.428548663854599,
-0.6039542555809021,
0.49907392263412476,
0.45713692903518677,
-0.5003294944763184,
0.7209973931312561,
-0.8465733528137207,
-0.15678054094314575,
-0.04157024994492531,
0.11167377233505249,
-1.3994555473327637,
-0.15731589496135712,
-0.04199977219104767,
-0.168940931558609,
0.3430899977684021,
0.12579038739204407,
-0.5310484170913696,
-0.5787830352783203,
-0.13939635455608368,
0.12260791659355164,
-0.12676973640918732,
-0.29471564292907715,
0.9404081702232361,
-0.05494774505496025,
-0.6149906516075134,
-0.5453347563743591,
-0.538806676864624,
0.29151466488838196,
-0.2824886441230774,
-0.9563717246055603,
0.12250558286905289,
-0.010533418506383896,
-0.8856576085090637,
-0.19736731052398682,
-0.4503648281097412,
0.13178206980228424,
0.24513256549835205,
-0.005458025261759758,
0.7424900531768799,
-0.33174750208854675,
0.1274276077747345,
0.3030191659927368,
-0.1615622192621231,
0.4590875804424286,
-0.3273831903934479,
0.3262841999530792,
-0.38760408759117126,
-0.44768717885017395,
-0.07396897673606873,
0.06941656768321991,
0.6106597185134888,
-0.2137802392244339,
0.7194939851760864,
-0.043244775384664536,
-0.43669119477272034,
-0.2291557639837265,
-0.5569384694099426,
0.15604054927825928,
-0.5152589082717896,
0.13826698064804077,
-0.5837481617927551,
-0.8444807529449463,
0.9786548018455505,
0.08250847458839417,
0.2947843670845032,
0.72669917345047,
0.9302994608879089,
-0.30312013626098633,
0.6173659563064575,
-0.08741985261440277,
0.38574427366256714,
-0.01359571423381567,
-0.15355440974235535,
0.15879963338375092,
-0.4040672481060028,
-0.6227942705154419,
-0.8619620203971863,
-0.399481862783432,
-0.14036677777767181,
-0.2640010416507721,
0.5832942128181458,
-0.15503418445587158,
-0.1623992770910263,
0.03419872000813484,
-0.10715174674987793,
0.5459339022636414,
0.28833073377609253,
-0.006283583585172892,
0.38754552602767944,
-0.1463671177625656,
-0.3406074047088623,
0.08453339338302612,
-0.46595320105552673,
-0.5577163100242615,
0.71318119764328,
0.4211896061897278,
1.0986058712005615,
0.25549429655075073,
0.193161740899086,
0.3095034062862396,
0.29856669902801514,
-0.638628363609314,
0.3662305474281311,
-0.1268521398305893,
-0.6140435934066772,
-0.6662003397941589,
-0.7198591232299805,
-0.7101506590843201,
-0.18171902000904083,
-0.2371036410331726,
-0.5860491991043091,
-0.0787520557641983,
-0.009358406066894531,
-0.6566896438598633,
0.18012060225009918,
-0.718669593334198,
0.7869357466697693,
-0.5591939687728882,
-0.18945668637752533,
0.08971614390611649,
-0.3910350501537323,
0.42870402336120605,
-0.44815006852149963,
0.544974148273468,
-0.09910993278026581,
-0.24853432178497314,
0.6036879420280457,
-0.43673503398895264,
0.625268816947937,
0.05631314590573311,
-0.5293741822242737,
0.46574556827545166,
0.461221843957901,
0.4942883849143982,
0.28695133328437805,
-0.4075964391231537,
-0.16082161664962769,
0.4095209538936615,
-0.2923920452594757,
-0.8379851579666138,
0.48051249980926514,
-0.42883193492889404,
-0.7528160810470581,
-0.4116269052028656,
-1.053989291191101,
-0.6390766501426697,
0.020593807101249695,
-0.0957297682762146,
0.4509631395339966,
0.27630171179771423,
0.2933255732059479,
0.566886842250824,
-0.1572556048631668,
0.3755093514919281,
0.47230398654937744,
-0.12037961184978485,
-0.32377150654792786,
0.4704063832759857,
0.3798871338367462,
0.23055271804332733,
0.6718725562095642,
0.3802092969417572,
-0.9775230288505554,
-0.484004408121109,
-0.5378493666648865,
0.25549426674842834,
-0.8596378564834595,
-0.38133201003074646,
-0.2794511914253235,
-0.1199895367026329,
-0.1911652535200119,
-0.3437465727329254,
0.3167240619659424,
-0.777915358543396,
-0.3020406663417816,
-0.42136478424072266,
0.576846718788147,
0.7445536255836487,
0.2281435877084732,
0.058450136333703995,
-1.0936273336410522,
0.3748839497566223,
0.5866076350212097,
0.4486466646194458,
-0.017205653712153435,
-0.7735092043876648,
0.09227876365184784,
-0.14887511730194092,
0.12724681198596954,
-1.0070582628250122,
0.08131607621908188,
0.1455697864294052,
0.6664818525314331,
0.22066566348075867,
0.03291637450456619,
0.5376603007316589,
-0.10544107109308243,
0.34054768085479736,
-0.05867037922143936,
-0.973876953125,
0.18700894713401794,
-0.5745318531990051,
0.2574102282524109,
0.5810112953186035,
0.3549278974533081,
-0.2519609332084656,
-0.19987820088863373,
-0.3443804681301117,
-0.43423664569854736,
0.5800787210464478,
0.17086176574230194,
-0.03848174959421158,
0.29588326811790466,
0.9496811032295227,
0.0704272985458374,
0.3315260708332062,
-0.47588980197906494,
-0.053307369351387024,
0.1471184492111206,
-0.2650541365146637,
0.1697334498167038,
-0.22701241075992584,
-0.04624579846858978,
-0.23922383785247803,
0.25950902700424194,
-0.10047782212495804,
-0.157556414604187,
0.021655825898051262,
0.1254969984292984,
-0.26898643374443054,
0.46484801173210144,
0.8739485740661621,
1.1169722080230713,
-0.1350657343864441,
0.05492227524518967,
0.531524658203125,
-0.26811739802360535,
-0.08188406378030777,
0.3096429407596588,
-0.02032875455915928,
-0.14600443840026855,
0.4866078495979309,
0.48593127727508545,
0.46234238147735596,
-0.77977055311203,
0.18967348337173462,
-0.30176934599876404,
-0.7825843095779419,
-0.365849107503891,
0.10761027783155441,
0.41633591055870056,
0.263781875371933,
0.6335407495498657,
-0.27048978209495544,
-0.06392104178667068,
-0.7497342228889465,
0.23583222925662994,
0.3554980158805847,
0.09283943474292755,
0.01603696681559086,
0.6999378204345703,
-0.12634825706481934,
-0.47158482670783997,
0.7342442870140076,
0.15602749586105347,
-0.5724261403083801,
0.8235751986503601,
0.6903431415557861,
0.32862386107444763,
0.07537739723920822,
0.24576124548912048,
0.06496284902095795,
0.30456018447875977,
0.14535100758075714,
0.7462254762649536,
0.0014809054555371404,
-0.5226912498474121,
-0.5112115740776062,
-0.6668740510940552,
-0.7485111951828003,
-0.12773862481117249,
-0.6375490427017212,
0.20087772607803345,
-0.6613759398460388,
-0.10609161108732224,
0.5648400783538818,
-0.08603250980377197,
-0.5877628326416016,
0.09795567393302917,
0.02732047438621521,
1.318760633468628,
-0.669008731842041,
0.1924794316291809,
0.7206932306289673,
-0.30281293392181396,
-1.14817476272583,
-0.4707605540752411,
0.1771499514579773,
-1.1555383205413818,
0.38741305470466614,
-0.23477570712566376,
0.11782845854759216,
-0.0940416157245636,
-0.437325656414032,
-0.5000999569892883,
0.9069612622261047,
0.5508049130439758,
-0.6536573171615601,
-0.3445574939250946,
0.654995858669281,
0.5323808789253235,
-0.08735974133014679,
0.16582609713077545,
0.8090337514877319,
0.9540624022483826,
0.5966761112213135,
-0.7210439443588257,
-0.21205180883407593,
-0.028334103524684906,
-0.39038801193237305,
0.378506600856781,
-0.5058651566505432,
0.8082878589630127,
-0.37372347712516785,
0.18561406433582306,
-0.13324397802352905,
0.5633888244628906,
0.37152567505836487,
0.8839655518531799,
0.5132691860198975,
0.39565563201904297,
1.020425796508789,
-0.45013633370399475,
0.8915429711341858,
-0.14654222130775452,
0.05581912770867348,
0.823954701423645,
-0.5142537355422974,
0.6612734198570251,
0.19563297927379608,
-0.5074977874755859,
0.5747224688529968,
0.7390945553779602,
-0.19390922784805298,
-0.27220380306243896,
0.5094296932220459,
-0.2444072812795639,
-0.5854858160018921,
0.03410337120294571,
-0.13713857531547546,
0.42181506752967834,
0.6175440549850464,
0.017511725425720215,
-0.46023279428482056,
-0.19380144774913788,
-0.11150553077459335,
0.3028726279735565,
-0.3184092938899994,
0.7351500988006592,
0.4798150360584259,
-0.6485950946807861,
0.021407483145594597,
0.17336905002593994,
-0.19798792898654938,
-0.6698705554008484,
-0.08728177845478058,
-0.2831876873970032,
-0.05102869123220444,
-0.27753710746765137,
-1.3042508363723755,
0.3222910761833191,
0.25387459993362427,
-0.0703241154551506,
-0.16759444773197174,
0.597226083278656,
-0.17234644293785095,
-0.6919022798538208,
-0.17775845527648926,
0.6552026271820068,
-0.11914794147014618,
-0.10365915298461914,
-0.802202045917511,
-0.28788402676582336,
-0.050053395330905914,
-0.1993306428194046,
0.30154186487197876,
1.046807050704956,
-0.19804704189300537,
0.8651936054229736,
1.0103942155838013,
-0.21666015684604645,
-0.27362510561943054,
0.3937218189239502,
0.7947750687599182,
-0.6304295063018799,
-0.42067763209342957,
-1.07418954372406,
0.09594373404979706,
0.2555128037929535,
-0.25036945939064026,
0.7208159565925598,
0.7688080072402954,
0.4067401885986328,
-0.028310349211096764,
0.3452017307281494,
0.6564226150512695,
0.373740553855896,
-0.9225698709487915,
0.32026952505111694,
-0.49767065048217773,
0.5332798361778259,
-0.3858967423439026,
-0.881902813911438,
-0.45113998651504517,
0.4961285889148712,
-0.7243768572807312,
-0.017228778451681137,
0.5585829615592957,
0.3843134343624115,
0.1661437451839447,
0.4120747148990631,
0.2712978720664978,
0.29839763045310974,
0.30163881182670593,
0.6082162261009216,
0.9364612698554993,
0.1777094155550003,
0.8722171783447266,
0.09249739348888397,
0.023409519344568253,
-0.034963224083185196,
-0.9172901511192322,
-0.8151903748512268,
-0.27911216020584106,
-0.11729899793863297,
-0.43641743063926697,
-0.3316870927810669,
0.7028168439865112,
-0.2546294331550598,
-0.6474459171295166,
-0.2276756465435028,
0.2005694955587387,
0.2996298372745514,
0.27144819498062134,
-0.2062240093946457,
0.479095458984375,
-0.06915395706892014,
-0.2974853217601776,
0.07676748931407928,
0.7670940160751343,
0.28996989130973816,
-0.15515808761119843,
0.13329023122787476,
-0.08306688815355301,
0.40673360228538513,
0.42257580161094666,
0.17493924498558044,
-0.33106881380081177,
-0.017011214047670364,
0.5129141211509705,
-0.05376357585191727,
0.01724507473409176,
0.9018850922584534,
-0.04832432419061661,
0.14827732741832733,
0.5137238502502441,
0.6734586954116821,
0.49015310406684875,
0.45291799306869507,
0.35765331983566284,
-0.2616497576236725,
-0.2650546431541443,
0.29674825072288513,
0.5175025463104248,
-0.058596473187208176,
-0.4786793291568756,
0.36034080386161804,
0.09259241819381714,
-0.47980132699012756,
-0.6173242330551147,
-0.1753438264131546,
-1.0240191221237183,
-0.24070508778095245,
0.8922926187515259,
0.12243089824914932,
-0.4095744788646698,
-0.3072357773780823,
-0.23983657360076904,
-0.19347620010375977,
-0.43298202753067017,
0.6751832962036133,
1.176297903060913,
-0.2363053560256958,
-0.14437146484851837,
-0.7313327193260193,
0.17636768519878387,
0.39321956038475037,
-1.0451412200927734,
0.21250447630882263,
0.5432393550872803,
0.08541246503591537,
-0.02549091912806034,
0.47307443618774414,
-0.1063544824719429,
0.4938453733921051,
-0.05630645528435707,
-0.6314423084259033,
-0.277702659368515,
-0.3116668462753296,
-0.19640132784843445,
0.19369420409202576,
0.217902272939682,
0.4966041147708893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11192v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11192v2 | I Learn Better If You Speak My Language: Understanding the Superior Performance of Fine-Tuning Large Language Models with LLM-Generated Responses | 2024-02-17T05:05:31 | 2024-06-01T03:36:23 | Xuan Ren, Biao Wu, Lingqiao Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper explores an intriguing observation: fine-tuning a large language
model (LLM) with responses generated by a LLM often yields better results than
using responses generated by humans. We conduct an in-depth investigation to
understand why this occurs. Contrary to the common belief that these instances
is simply due to the more detailed nature of LLM-generated content, our study
identifies another contributing factor: an LLM is inherently more "familiar"
with LLM generated responses. This familiarity is evidenced by lower perplexity
before fine-tuning. We design a series of experiments to understand the impact
of the "familiarity" and our conclusion reveals that this "familiarity"
significantly impacts learning performance. Training with LLM-generated
responses not only enhances performance but also helps maintain the model's
capabilities in other tasks after fine-tuning on a specific task. | [
-0.5434415936470032,
-0.618644118309021,
0.44994741678237915,
-0.32062360644340515,
-0.1402130275964737,
0.22633545100688934,
-0.6677341461181641,
-0.6217613220214844,
-0.06353089213371277,
0.2828245759010315,
-0.3761623501777649,
-0.1991458535194397,
-0.7466893196105957,
0.2803393304347992,
-0.29989153146743774,
0.7409241795539856,
0.6484701037406921,
0.3330150544643402,
-0.3760918080806732,
0.07808508723974228,
-0.5815123915672302,
-0.635552167892456,
-1.057968258857727,
-0.7850022912025452,
0.6930651664733887,
0.6503451466560364,
0.34765714406967163,
0.6099131107330322,
0.6105309128761292,
0.4613504707813263,
-0.07473129034042358,
0.14379805326461792,
-0.7365394234657288,
-0.013209761120378971,
-0.11153823882341385,
-0.8408803343772888,
-0.07915209978818893,
-0.07046764343976974,
0.5989863276481628,
0.724865198135376,
-0.04453802481293678,
0.1984286606311798,
0.4118434190750122,
0.7975393533706665,
-0.321734756231308,
0.053495559841394424,
-0.9509660601615906,
-0.10283225029706955,
-0.06162905693054199,
-0.3279193639755249,
-0.32486265897750854,
-0.32707303762435913,
0.14520226418972015,
-0.4377443790435791,
0.35263800621032715,
-0.09308306872844696,
0.7609332799911499,
0.13260097801685333,
-0.3788760006427765,
-0.17819081246852875,
-0.7562839984893799,
0.6048595309257507,
-0.9790504574775696,
0.4718163311481476,
0.4258062541484833,
0.35690838098526,
-0.18495264649391174,
-0.6124085187911987,
-0.7215573191642761,
-0.4856477677822113,
-0.19317327439785004,
0.10404720157384872,
0.07522092759609222,
0.023062696680426598,
0.6197085976600647,
0.4837867021560669,
-0.5871514081954956,
0.37732815742492676,
-0.5769352912902832,
-0.14532732963562012,
0.6406804323196411,
0.31010890007019043,
0.22165687382221222,
0.17516909539699554,
0.043548330664634705,
-0.29580461978912354,
-0.8708648681640625,
0.45496413111686707,
0.8324747681617737,
0.4496508538722992,
-0.06025891751050949,
0.569334864616394,
-0.4025486707687378,
0.7353222966194153,
0.15603727102279663,
-0.3770642578601837,
0.12681467831134796,
-0.09444800019264221,
-0.09583543986082077,
-0.12742656469345093,
0.6190422773361206,
0.3623203933238983,
0.7812392711639404,
-0.2271132916212082,
-0.22170071303844452,
-0.11179844290018082,
0.33421942591667175,
-0.7956125736236572,
-0.2934042513370514,
-0.09422492235898972,
-0.46444037556648254,
-0.25082117319107056,
-0.028244029730558395,
-0.15466958284378052,
-0.4840623736381531,
-0.7037177085876465,
0.34178224205970764,
-0.5401610732078552,
-0.27194783091545105,
0.35902243852615356,
0.033129703253507614,
0.3349043130874634,
0.3001106381416321,
-1.2041919231414795,
0.3985486924648285,
0.8129663467407227,
0.526043713092804,
-0.28897735476493835,
-0.420958548784256,
-0.8157941102981567,
-0.16458483040332794,
-0.3574456572532654,
0.8596674203872681,
-0.34126508235931396,
-0.7063286304473877,
0.15211264789104462,
-0.23177091777324677,
-0.05510561168193817,
-1.241891622543335,
0.18724216520786285,
-0.504734992980957,
0.04774082452058792,
-0.578045129776001,
-0.5618221163749695,
0.07250560820102692,
0.11820176243782043,
-0.476788729429245,
0.7703059911727905,
-0.17345644533634186,
-0.5951563715934753,
0.5814545750617981,
-0.26119497418403625,
-0.5375073552131653,
0.09470117092132568,
-0.3079189360141754,
-0.18227475881576538,
0.2506893575191498,
-0.23119309544563293,
0.3753775954246521,
-0.02005099132657051,
0.10444959253072739,
-0.45749932527542114,
-0.18778470158576965,
0.5525500178337097,
-0.3065270185470581,
0.3075088858604431,
0.3249528706073761,
-0.1765603870153427,
0.09094084054231644,
-0.6446343064308167,
0.053083114326000214,
0.17802174389362335,
-0.8633189797401428,
-0.2953190207481384,
0.11479178071022034,
-0.26283079385757446,
-0.020467517897486687,
0.24051503837108612,
-0.6653420925140381,
0.1478498876094818,
-0.6772314310073853,
0.1263994425535202,
0.8398228883743286,
0.029100123792886734,
0.45509228110313416,
-0.41329237818717957,
0.20656725764274597,
0.0707612857222557,
-0.3482228219509125,
-0.0969836562871933,
-0.13754983246326447,
-0.7018457651138306,
0.2113492786884308,
0.18837864696979523,
0.23638226091861725,
-0.47252780199050903,
-0.08833905309438705,
-0.15974169969558716,
-0.12432116270065308,
-0.5409252047538757,
0.6091537475585938,
0.6495000720024109,
0.7750088572502136,
0.22544945776462555,
-0.3706258535385132,
-0.558232843875885,
-1.1734323501586914,
-0.6392812728881836,
-0.3280319273471832,
-0.020719090476632118,
0.5163600444793701,
0.22689290344715118,
0.04664294049143791,
0.7142153978347778,
-0.7046730518341064,
0.04473055526614189,
-0.49270763993263245,
0.017941031605005264,
-0.014869843609631062,
0.4451700747013092,
0.4347079396247864,
-0.5235142707824707,
-0.7177731990814209,
0.29392218589782715,
-0.4942340850830078,
-0.18366087973117828,
-0.11923274397850037,
0.1107352152466774,
0.07990941405296326,
0.702139139175415,
-0.20814178884029388,
0.04824710637331009,
0.4332524538040161,
-0.18820759654045105,
0.48944953083992004,
-0.43558987975120544,
0.021505797281861305,
-1.2056690454483032,
-0.09335073828697205,
-0.019030937924981117,
-0.32718831300735474,
-0.40779364109039307,
0.004522888921201229,
-0.016196396201848984,
0.006508014164865017,
-0.34157052636146545,
0.5438113808631897,
-0.2956526577472687,
-0.1638423353433609,
-0.35564157366752625,
0.05513182282447815,
-0.2553546130657196,
0.3028562366962433,
0.015747783705592155,
1.198530673980713,
0.42177385091781616,
-0.8495382070541382,
-0.06935400515794754,
0.1738530695438385,
-0.6115585565567017,
0.4882943630218506,
-0.7492498159408569,
0.21152833104133606,
-0.09106317907571793,
-0.39575889706611633,
-1.0431158542633057,
-0.5237581133842468,
-0.17996370792388916,
-0.4892352223396301,
0.6962133049964905,
0.2121172994375229,
-0.3509935438632965,
-0.39814329147338867,
0.0836348831653595,
0.03757365792989731,
0.5113667249679565,
-0.935699462890625,
0.33665207028388977,
0.2628704607486725,
-0.2414523810148239,
-0.45717310905456543,
-0.5535526275634766,
-0.1056240126490593,
-0.2909786105155945,
-0.379185289144516,
-0.010431448929011822,
-0.505352795124054,
-0.5303968191146851,
-0.3712538778781891,
-0.2928040623664856,
0.0428786464035511,
0.484899640083313,
0.37748098373413086,
-0.3061407208442688,
-0.38267117738723755,
0.23575720191001892,
-0.06131195276975632,
-0.10309085249900818,
0.17263883352279663,
0.08655949681997299,
0.720122218132019,
-0.3048689067363739,
-0.40782415866851807,
-0.5983405113220215,
0.23724184930324554,
0.393734872341156,
-0.1837569922208786,
0.619918942451477,
0.39840686321258545,
0.05222417041659355,
-0.18960659205913544,
-0.47825396060943604,
-0.6615544557571411,
-0.5936191082000732,
0.4068354070186615,
-0.644953727722168,
-0.8810694217681885,
0.3777739703655243,
-0.18227890133857727,
0.0569373182952404,
0.06341590732336044,
0.5807837247848511,
-0.6781996488571167,
1.153634786605835,
0.8761146068572998,
-0.276699036359787,
0.7287188768386841,
-0.3195238411426544,
0.10169119387865067,
-0.6950608491897583,
-0.3126588761806488,
-0.5868873000144958,
-0.4795059561729431,
-0.5843052268028259,
-0.01838310807943344,
0.2673909664154053,
0.03097054921090603,
-0.1633642017841339,
0.14541864395141602,
0.00708169536665082,
0.6060229539871216,
0.6675572395324707,
0.24477332830429077,
0.45112210512161255,
0.007159654051065445,
-0.09674451500177383,
-0.048164963722229004,
-0.5343016386032104,
-0.6631158590316772,
0.9727758169174194,
0.31201377511024475,
0.9166961312294006,
0.36078378558158875,
1.0649149417877197,
0.07262934744358063,
0.31980255246162415,
-0.8159347772598267,
0.5532499551773071,
-0.10579727590084076,
-0.3579954504966736,
-0.09360725432634354,
-0.4836988151073456,
-1.1042509078979492,
0.12487234175205231,
-0.42855823040008545,
-0.6140680313110352,
-0.27736198902130127,
0.39726313948631287,
-0.2599712014198303,
0.23940913379192352,
-0.852314293384552,
0.5167152881622314,
-0.3538905084133148,
-0.11919086426496506,
-0.3530735373497009,
-0.48603978753089905,
0.14549420773983002,
-0.07843495160341263,
0.016180673614144325,
-0.011748610995709896,
0.0059421369805932045,
0.5336706042289734,
-0.10239031910896301,
1.0162633657455444,
0.1572439819574356,
-0.08071371167898178,
0.15566480159759521,
0.0819062814116478,
0.28361061215400696,
0.24259434640407562,
-0.11788859963417053,
-0.12921388447284698,
-0.3678271174430847,
-0.30473592877388,
-0.5911954045295715,
0.7875339388847351,
-1.0283715724945068,
-0.9857186079025269,
0.06356813758611679,
-0.5011517405509949,
-0.37055057287216187,
0.23735563457012177,
0.4176172614097595,
0.4306403398513794,
-0.24186640977859497,
0.28308361768722534,
0.8446390628814697,
-0.17340975999832153,
0.47054654359817505,
0.7478201985359192,
-0.020383255556225777,
-0.1815194934606552,
0.8861989378929138,
0.12086601555347443,
0.5535656213760376,
0.4324567914009094,
0.45760399103164673,
-0.2883279025554657,
-0.7157370448112488,
-0.28401005268096924,
0.3031403124332428,
-0.7093031406402588,
-0.1989583522081375,
-0.6103371381759644,
-0.013590449467301369,
-0.36310911178588867,
0.08717545866966248,
-0.189684197306633,
-0.20804443955421448,
-0.2730894982814789,
-0.4394952952861786,
0.3077297806739807,
0.868924617767334,
-0.18700066208839417,
0.5665671825408936,
-0.534528374671936,
0.14981523156166077,
0.7735801339149475,
0.3493095934391022,
0.030029011890292168,
-0.7443017363548279,
-0.41766995191574097,
0.15398108959197998,
-0.4306425154209137,
-0.563169002532959,
0.3417556881904602,
0.536195695400238,
0.6340407729148865,
0.43740856647491455,
-0.24631772935390472,
0.8129408359527588,
-0.5141276717185974,
0.5508083701133728,
0.028390254825353622,
-0.6224285960197449,
0.2786824703216553,
-0.34550580382347107,
0.4507492780685425,
0.692330002784729,
0.29881295561790466,
-0.307523250579834,
-0.7449067831039429,
-0.6124047040939331,
-0.8056893944740295,
0.3807322084903717,
-0.17178919911384583,
0.6748651266098022,
-0.17503364384174347,
0.74697345495224,
0.2023020088672638,
0.3128570020198822,
-0.7196229696273804,
-0.46584436297416687,
0.2584651708602905,
0.1881992369890213,
-0.49993446469306946,
-0.28261810541152954,
-0.031314998865127563,
-0.14501282572746277,
0.6473026871681213,
-0.37912431359291077,
0.11490586400032043,
0.008887753821909428,
-0.21808911859989166,
-0.33503028750419617,
-0.08371678739786148,
0.7174341678619385,
0.34468337893486023,
0.021735191345214844,
0.26599961519241333,
0.47839272022247314,
-0.36797183752059937,
-0.2966462969779968,
-0.5258732438087463,
0.10911810398101807,
-0.24590972065925598,
0.675757884979248,
0.7492677569389343,
0.11004369705915451,
-0.6833410263061523,
0.3165493607521057,
-0.29596346616744995,
-0.2595658302307129,
-0.02666400745511055,
0.6604669690132141,
0.4132274091243744,
0.5013686418533325,
0.18818917870521545,
0.08377797156572342,
0.1233745589852333,
-0.6300884485244751,
0.22196915745735168,
0.656086802482605,
-0.08450795710086823,
-0.24884064495563507,
0.632942795753479,
0.08669422566890717,
-0.5962668061256409,
0.5139009356498718,
0.168191596865654,
-0.5684958696365356,
0.7258549332618713,
0.7912989258766174,
0.625576913356781,
-0.10595542192459106,
-0.033451348543167114,
0.6624083518981934,
0.08064088225364685,
0.205099955201149,
0.2528116703033447,
-0.21884344518184662,
-0.6397536993026733,
-0.32201823592185974,
-0.7322452068328857,
-0.4708369970321655,
0.3629125952720642,
-0.7824610471725464,
0.0531017929315567,
-0.3889513611793518,
-0.19542156159877777,
-0.03341258689761162,
0.16178008913993835,
-0.7484461069107056,
0.43903225660324097,
0.25201186537742615,
0.8086798787117004,
-0.8568751811981201,
0.9559022784233093,
0.6372027397155762,
-0.412634015083313,
-1.2952224016189575,
0.1979956179857254,
-0.3137848675251007,
-0.9579755067825317,
0.8444340229034424,
0.011878633871674538,
-0.2939226031303406,
0.18248160183429718,
-0.4529294967651367,
-0.7540179491043091,
0.784553587436676,
0.544289231300354,
-0.6739106178283691,
0.39764681458473206,
0.23375140130519867,
0.6590314507484436,
-0.36949682235717773,
0.10289102047681808,
0.635479211807251,
0.056936684995889664,
-0.033783167600631714,
-0.998614490032196,
-0.4136115312576294,
-0.046359315514564514,
0.05946771800518036,
-0.0047857738099992275,
-0.6179872155189514,
0.7877750396728516,
-0.6264956593513489,
-0.16104494035243988,
0.16540689766407013,
0.735835075378418,
-0.20879589021205902,
0.20068404078483582,
0.18682056665420532,
0.46902376413345337,
0.9127823114395142,
-0.020160650834441185,
1.1337902545928955,
-0.3371184766292572,
0.15500357747077942,
1.3328337669372559,
-0.030775759369134903,
1.1516926288604736,
0.40312209725379944,
0.07305851578712463,
0.48324382305145264,
0.7498180270195007,
0.41474243998527527,
0.5497159957885742,
0.21229401230812073,
-0.5268186926841736,
-0.333166241645813,
0.20162254571914673,
-0.4248650074005127,
0.3684835731983185,
0.10364201664924622,
-0.31135833263397217,
-0.07622800022363663,
0.0580538846552372,
-0.24292762577533722,
0.5752863883972168,
-0.265392005443573,
1.37537682056427,
0.2714301347732544,
-0.6212389469146729,
0.7815937995910645,
-0.2059432566165924,
0.5219707489013672,
-0.5003911852836609,
0.20196881890296936,
-0.4562169015407562,
0.22179481387138367,
-0.32286524772644043,
-0.8436486124992371,
0.3043445944786072,
0.05216648429632187,
-0.47033074498176575,
-0.1806986778974533,
0.5508395433425903,
-0.5915306210517883,
0.00464378297328949,
0.2570476531982422,
0.6987060308456421,
0.14953690767288208,
0.17247316241264343,
-0.49083030223846436,
0.06168300658464432,
0.02435261756181717,
-0.26196110248565674,
0.887631893157959,
0.31814560294151306,
0.2252480834722519,
0.9364461302757263,
0.871189296245575,
0.1196509301662445,
0.283100426197052,
0.14098098874092102,
0.8513261079788208,
-0.3469967842102051,
-0.016486966982483864,
-0.8884280323982239,
0.422552227973938,
-0.09446089714765549,
-0.3297993242740631,
0.6647408604621887,
0.7680557370185852,
1.1827789545059204,
-0.4230457544326782,
0.8533644676208496,
0.2897825241088867,
0.6377179622650146,
-0.5664013624191284,
0.7000164985656738,
-0.7052647471427917,
0.46217119693756104,
0.002088899025693536,
-0.5997145175933838,
-0.12654133141040802,
0.7979727387428284,
-0.7218563556671143,
-0.10030891001224518,
0.4583500325679779,
0.942636251449585,
-0.05729575455188751,
-0.28299480676651,
0.8278712630271912,
0.23486360907554626,
0.3124029338359833,
0.253073513507843,
0.830891489982605,
-0.036884840577840805,
0.3939846158027649,
-0.3867756724357605,
0.1543961763381958,
-0.0942743569612503,
-0.7585258483886719,
-1.00834321975708,
-0.6269460916519165,
-0.28555193543434143,
-0.46457862854003906,
-0.06764751672744751,
0.9911611676216125,
0.4885175824165344,
-0.7523627877235413,
-0.7567566633224487,
-0.0582837238907814,
0.1660451889038086,
0.11007814109325409,
-0.13547863066196442,
-0.12631580233573914,
-0.8049123883247375,
-0.8056736588478088,
0.36755961179733276,
-0.047088995575904846,
0.14894253015518188,
0.14176635444164276,
-0.49031227827072144,
0.201798677444458,
0.0543091706931591,
0.6740707159042358,
0.48541370034217834,
-0.5356146693229675,
-0.3339330852031708,
0.025191541761159897,
-0.40931904315948486,
0.28705379366874695,
0.7218729853630066,
-0.7770236134529114,
0.7490689158439636,
0.32665082812309265,
0.7296578288078308,
0.4938701391220093,
-0.047704242169857025,
0.7820078730583191,
-0.6126714944839478,
-0.024930639192461967,
0.0015019357670098543,
0.3305782079696655,
0.44165268540382385,
-0.4531473219394684,
0.25467196106910706,
0.007863270118832588,
-0.4886007010936737,
-0.7865807414054871,
0.5279965996742249,
-0.8219208717346191,
-0.028938204050064087,
1.3183015584945679,
-0.10683123022317886,
-0.022802630439400673,
0.07119761407375336,
-0.5068520903587341,
0.20268474519252777,
-0.3774597644805908,
0.9114497303962708,
0.41738224029541016,
-0.24308988451957703,
0.016574610024690628,
-0.6742077469825745,
0.7190795540809631,
0.389554888010025,
-0.6080825328826904,
-0.07612290978431702,
0.1786809116601944,
0.8571975827217102,
-0.09247425943613052,
0.501760721206665,
0.3079717755317688,
0.38008397817611694,
-0.25496211647987366,
-0.21780778467655182,
-0.10167618095874786,
-0.23842889070510864,
-0.5031219720840454,
0.01849823258817196,
0.9650284647941589,
-0.11465810984373093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11191v1 | Knowledge Graph Assisted Automatic Sports News Writing | 2024-02-17T04:54:58 | 2024-02-17T04:54:58 | Yang Cao, Xinyi Chen, Xin Zhang, Siying Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present a novel method for automatically generating sports
news, which employs a unique algorithm that extracts pivotal moments from live
text broadcasts and uses them to create an initial draft of the news. This
draft is further refined by incorporating key details and background
information from a specially designed sports knowledge graph. This graph
contains 5,893 entities, which are classified into three distinct conceptual
categories, interconnected through four relationship types, and characterized
by 27 unique attributes. In addition, we create a multi-stage learning model by
combining convolutional neural networks and a transformer encoder. This model
expresses entity-task interactions using convolutional neural networks and
enriches entity representations in the query set with the transformer encoder.
It also includes a processor to compute matching scores for incomplete triples,
addressing few-shot knowledge graph completion problem. The efficiency of this
approach has been confirmed through both subjective and objective evaluations
of 50 selected test cases, demonstrating its capability in revolutionizing the
creation of sports news. | [
-0.19475355744361877,
-0.6861430406570435,
0.5224267840385437,
0.29693153500556946,
-0.3903520405292511,
0.3348999619483948,
0.11980590969324112,
-0.7010700106620789,
0.4591144323348999,
0.08752871304750443,
-0.7004396915435791,
-0.5894650816917419,
-0.6976791024208069,
0.07552285492420197,
-0.2803005874156952,
1.1895103454589844,
-0.2188040018081665,
-0.0025919179897755384,
-0.2661409378051758,
-0.1270424872636795,
-0.4687652289867401,
-0.009569146670401096,
-0.9781073927879333,
-0.36970534920692444,
0.2387842983007431,
0.3856358230113983,
0.47359171509742737,
0.596122682094574,
0.7222251892089844,
0.3332505226135254,
0.16656415164470673,
0.5556813478469849,
-0.5556248426437378,
0.3889823257923126,
0.2613646388053894,
-0.12700672447681427,
-0.5673754811286926,
0.006895088125020266,
0.49363473057746887,
0.669991672039032,
0.17992545664310455,
0.3422284722328186,
0.14045053720474243,
0.7305756211280823,
-0.1657634824514389,
0.4843023717403412,
-0.5949019193649292,
0.28567323088645935,
-0.004617071710526943,
-0.3671039342880249,
-0.05411228537559509,
-0.519010066986084,
-0.12168741971254349,
-0.9746507406234741,
0.23486700654029846,
0.003098738845437765,
0.9122598767280579,
0.17439597845077515,
-0.48952609300613403,
-0.4526064693927765,
-0.7847126722335815,
0.07165560126304626,
-0.5405599474906921,
0.5079862475395203,
-0.031595468521118164,
0.5600847005844116,
0.056634172797203064,
-0.5035605430603027,
-0.6056405901908875,
-0.045514993369579315,
-0.16120308637619019,
0.32471999526023865,
-0.050725094974040985,
-0.07829803973436356,
0.15837445855140686,
-0.044137146323919296,
-0.482143372297287,
-0.3444596529006958,
-0.6733418107032776,
0.044628217816352844,
0.8279894590377808,
0.2664927542209625,
0.17829452455043793,
-0.25825241208076477,
0.048718713223934174,
0.4359217882156372,
-0.49720948934555054,
0.21087773144245148,
0.610196053981781,
0.14520077407360077,
0.1726910024881363,
0.8230713605880737,
-0.6830147504806519,
0.7534998655319214,
0.21190249919891357,
-0.5365425944328308,
0.30618372559547424,
-0.08187285810709,
-0.17153050005435944,
0.316937655210495,
0.8825081586837769,
0.8397605419158936,
0.19713373482227325,
-0.6026424765586853,
-0.05289357155561447,
-0.18722257018089294,
0.20495736598968506,
-0.5145258903503418,
-0.13244780898094177,
0.10830914229154587,
-0.44590994715690613,
-0.5584014058113098,
-0.0010820436291396618,
-0.5155179500579834,
-0.48138925433158875,
-0.4463184177875519,
0.40200090408325195,
-0.7345786690711975,
0.05828269571065903,
-0.07833386212587357,
-0.6297044157981873,
-0.10893069952726364,
0.33818891644477844,
-0.5595332980155945,
0.09164291620254517,
0.15925733745098114,
0.5098266005516052,
0.16062162816524506,
-0.22596226632595062,
-0.5159361362457275,
0.6452130079269409,
-0.09802696108818054,
0.9050308465957642,
-0.23968124389648438,
-0.0072753033600747585,
0.09049063175916672,
-0.4161074459552765,
0.13684169948101044,
0.07926157861948013,
0.2651507258415222,
-0.8872808218002319,
-0.14702598750591278,
0.05993461608886719,
-1.0366564989089966,
-0.279521644115448,
0.3493015468120575,
-0.7520365118980408,
1.0202243328094482,
0.15579789876937866,
-0.8778353333473206,
0.8431702256202698,
-0.6786003708839417,
-0.9149944186210632,
0.14365673065185547,
-0.015012137591838837,
-0.7333376407623291,
-0.1922002136707306,
0.3450106680393219,
0.462062269449234,
0.18061693012714386,
0.17107084393501282,
-0.4038960337638855,
-0.08721157908439636,
-0.06593834608793259,
0.05043831467628479,
0.4048164188861847,
0.10129702091217041,
-0.279130220413208,
-0.1640452891588211,
-0.9552316069602966,
0.012872721999883652,
0.20056460797786713,
-0.458334356546402,
-0.11306743323802948,
0.09508660435676575,
-0.452099084854126,
0.31522655487060547,
0.10081972926855087,
-0.6667100191116333,
0.2656708061695099,
-0.30774810910224915,
0.26989707350730896,
0.19508080184459686,
0.4058161973953247,
0.5208742022514343,
-0.12043837457895279,
0.3338078558444977,
0.15691204369068146,
0.3068625330924988,
-0.10334106534719467,
-0.354474812746048,
-0.589406430721283,
0.3298807442188263,
0.1819918006658554,
0.6001961827278137,
-0.9007729887962341,
0.5538994669914246,
-0.4665766954421997,
-0.6117616295814514,
-0.41987594962120056,
0.2744276821613312,
0.09529459476470947,
0.7465535402297974,
0.26900485157966614,
0.06711610406637192,
-0.7348645329475403,
-0.5936302542686462,
-0.5469290018081665,
0.11883071810007095,
0.47809678316116333,
0.3809715509414673,
0.24395905435085297,
0.49412453174591064,
0.9923679828643799,
-0.8354529738426208,
-0.5783672332763672,
-0.46935009956359863,
0.06497006863355637,
0.061996642500162125,
0.29511454701423645,
0.8875066041946411,
-0.7257722020149231,
-0.6558838486671448,
-0.11516045033931732,
-1.1671062707901,
0.24963097274303436,
-0.12108170241117477,
-0.11643973737955093,
-0.07387234270572662,
0.5299381017684937,
-0.5982190370559692,
0.6050703525543213,
0.35202476382255554,
-0.5035129189491272,
0.3398861885070801,
-0.20429228246212006,
0.31297022104263306,
-0.9051756262779236,
-0.13955917954444885,
0.3464399576187134,
-0.48402655124664307,
-0.43930312991142273,
-0.39460837841033936,
-0.3595908284187317,
-0.1565486192703247,
-0.34003275632858276,
0.4218902587890625,
-0.48946085572242737,
-0.05704624578356743,
-0.3628077507019043,
0.29656606912612915,
0.2749581038951874,
0.3470652103424072,
0.09049834311008453,
0.15663424134254456,
0.3874874413013458,
-0.7063667178153992,
0.7258772253990173,
0.3592216670513153,
-0.20893007516860962,
0.2870107591152191,
-0.41897666454315186,
-0.06820283085107803,
-0.599560022354126,
0.4840918481349945,
-0.8427293300628662,
-0.3037305772304535,
0.5288049578666687,
-0.5576508641242981,
0.2316880077123642,
-0.12092993408441544,
-0.3702033460140228,
-0.8152274489402771,
-0.060216497629880905,
0.2878158390522003,
0.13763947784900665,
0.09556718170642853,
0.5454416275024414,
0.7245304584503174,
-0.1311245858669281,
-0.13742974400520325,
-0.4019859731197357,
0.0036881319247186184,
0.047068871557712555,
-0.5722127556800842,
0.2318205088376999,
-0.0035119187086820602,
0.07453911751508713,
0.40241095423698425,
-0.004112801048904657,
-0.27793875336647034,
-0.0002469406754244119,
0.1247081384062767,
0.12906283140182495,
-0.25668370723724365,
0.17696422338485718,
0.18847709894180298,
0.12219350039958954,
-0.16478979587554932,
-0.630495548248291,
0.25365909934043884,
0.18440166115760803,
-0.03909257426857948,
-0.51026850938797,
0.5489864349365234,
0.28863826394081116,
-0.11327466368675232,
0.7129417657852173,
0.4249042570590973,
-0.4170766770839691,
-0.2281506508588791,
-0.37302395701408386,
0.04650947451591492,
-0.35376861691474915,
0.3509519398212433,
-0.4031619131565094,
-0.7422400116920471,
0.33058273792266846,
0.020296432077884674,
0.13454580307006836,
0.7958388924598694,
0.26717716455459595,
-0.4352225661277771,
1.178971290588379,
0.5133668184280396,
-0.05833692103624344,
0.3416458070278168,
-0.4376322031021118,
0.27676141262054443,
-0.41737455129623413,
-0.5428411364555359,
-0.33369776606559753,
-0.5790426731109619,
-0.12651562690734863,
0.2620687484741211,
0.5116720199584961,
0.22927403450012207,
-0.3310260474681854,
0.37368088960647583,
-0.6820605397224426,
0.7896531224250793,
0.7213950753211975,
0.46425509452819824,
0.5202704071998596,
-0.19325484335422516,
0.05685010552406311,
-0.11676406115293503,
-0.9079816341400146,
-0.08770245313644409,
1.0432453155517578,
0.004017957951873541,
0.44944384694099426,
-0.05543528497219086,
0.8141513466835022,
0.4869607090950012,
0.5617404580116272,
-0.7868980765342712,
0.2259705811738968,
-0.20250707864761353,
-0.6389177441596985,
-0.6403622031211853,
-0.33877888321876526,
-0.5436355471611023,
-0.2764313817024231,
-0.6404549479484558,
-0.42834892868995667,
-0.1868533194065094,
0.16109876334667206,
-0.7344083786010742,
0.4099588692188263,
-0.5785955786705017,
0.48332422971725464,
-0.16906678676605225,
-0.02222243696451187,
0.20847782492637634,
-0.43334755301475525,
0.6394751071929932,
0.0014218924334272742,
0.38429152965545654,
-0.14022216200828552,
0.30441537499427795,
1.0310235023498535,
-0.4774465262889862,
0.6712603569030762,
-0.37345513701438904,
0.283401757478714,
0.5817548632621765,
0.12788203358650208,
0.44997382164001465,
0.3053610324859619,
0.07415546476840973,
-0.25838395953178406,
-0.3500399589538574,
-0.11759297549724579,
-0.5604353547096252,
0.3467049300670624,
-0.7823874950408936,
-0.48565351963043213,
-0.19527022540569305,
-0.58949214220047,
-0.5268996953964233,
0.6955355405807495,
0.3211379945278168,
0.5970558524131775,
-0.2114427089691162,
0.05658803880214691,
0.2368782013654709,
0.15078027546405792,
0.5805075168609619,
0.44326192140579224,
-0.19818170368671417,
-0.6021527051925659,
0.8495476245880127,
0.33583617210388184,
-0.4555913805961609,
0.35534054040908813,
0.007184569723904133,
-0.22328178584575653,
-0.8625361323356628,
-0.4356912076473236,
0.06027737632393837,
-0.7325778603553772,
-0.9063233137130737,
-0.6497620940208435,
-0.48699256777763367,
-0.8392173647880554,
-0.03339556232094765,
-0.09958860278129578,
-0.4959510564804077,
-0.02867237664759159,
-0.3746306896209717,
0.3042793571949005,
1.1508903503417969,
0.09962542355060577,
0.37463846802711487,
-1.177355170249939,
0.6410943269729614,
0.20692268013954163,
0.5206623077392578,
-0.1415879875421524,
-0.19724169373512268,
-0.49215614795684814,
0.07878407835960388,
-0.5918538570404053,
-1.0436596870422363,
0.3892715275287628,
0.2650550901889801,
0.6461790800094604,
0.41075465083122253,
0.03573213145136833,
0.4740064740180969,
-0.7545183897018433,
0.7442996501922607,
0.4669096767902374,
-0.7897045612335205,
0.7728692293167114,
-0.6209359765052795,
0.03146366775035858,
0.5920224785804749,
0.4425131380558014,
-0.24548771977424622,
-0.8372047543525696,
-0.8488067388534546,
-0.40968021750450134,
0.8005593419075012,
0.22697211802005768,
-0.12113884836435318,
-0.13441386818885803,
0.6027345657348633,
0.1643129289150238,
0.3458704948425293,
-0.5974606275558472,
-0.3488856852054596,
-0.5571803450584412,
-0.4429607093334198,
0.11544141173362732,
-0.021058516576886177,
-0.10593857616186142,
-0.670077383518219,
0.830756664276123,
-0.19364620745182037,
0.09345900267362595,
0.29904475808143616,
-0.28838250041007996,
-0.08416640013456345,
-0.3510846793651581,
0.45577576756477356,
0.7296126484870911,
-0.0417574979364872,
-0.1839158535003662,
0.1586408019065857,
-0.267604798078537,
0.06416179239749908,
0.41759592294692993,
-0.4850790500640869,
0.2681474983692169,
0.3910353183746338,
0.9275254607200623,
0.45072755217552185,
-0.10222309082746506,
0.5118889212608337,
0.0010216768132522702,
-0.7520249485969543,
-0.10970596969127655,
0.012430633418262005,
0.29090192914009094,
0.38024166226387024,
0.5292102694511414,
0.30057084560394287,
0.23019817471504211,
-0.44868165254592896,
0.4465261399745941,
0.2991968095302582,
-0.43107110261917114,
-0.18365509808063507,
1.1993277072906494,
0.3465937674045563,
-0.12533427774906158,
0.43201184272766113,
-0.3859434127807617,
-0.5807089805603027,
0.6107104420661926,
0.4175359308719635,
0.4647066295146942,
0.24884536862373352,
0.6938809156417847,
0.4018554091453552,
-0.08117391914129257,
0.11754024773836136,
0.15959209203720093,
0.111104816198349,
-0.8438776731491089,
-0.3076237738132477,
-0.7514416575431824,
-0.019994176924228668,
-0.11360956728458405,
-0.16051636636257172,
0.17516513168811798,
-0.1878974586725235,
-0.3281516134738922,
0.5165392756462097,
0.44979599118232727,
-0.9984176754951477,
0.5272175073623657,
0.3126586377620697,
1.044995903968811,
-0.7231079936027527,
0.6298009157180786,
0.9427679181098938,
-0.9246736764907837,
-1.1966533660888672,
-0.2548568844795227,
-0.1405828297138214,
-0.7188024520874023,
0.8716675639152527,
-0.22277608513832092,
0.28585579991340637,
0.42209479212760925,
-0.3747226893901825,
-0.5815102458000183,
1.3816477060317993,
0.39686015248298645,
-0.22821664810180664,
-0.6081500053405762,
0.368901789188385,
0.21307937800884247,
-0.6002724170684814,
0.21923653781414032,
0.46549686789512634,
0.5984991788864136,
0.3328741192817688,
-0.6673312187194824,
-0.05284684896469116,
-0.07884322851896286,
-0.548575222492218,
0.18033701181411743,
-0.9268080592155457,
0.5122000575065613,
-0.13567982614040375,
0.14443694055080414,
-0.4344950318336487,
0.9806447625160217,
-0.04268046095967293,
0.37380340695381165,
0.3829822540283203,
0.6036532521247864,
0.8726345896720886,
0.032408054918050766,
0.8928452730178833,
-0.5910366773605347,
0.3668641448020935,
0.8775337338447571,
-0.06095929071307182,
0.1820243000984192,
-0.04239991307258606,
-0.04014186933636665,
0.3040148615837097,
0.26891034841537476,
-0.14991723001003265,
0.37242627143859863,
0.07302625477313995,
-0.22184276580810547,
-0.4565105438232422,
0.051196422427892685,
-0.1896076798439026,
0.6687132716178894,
-0.07224904745817184,
-0.5189926624298096,
-0.8219588994979858,
0.11649207025766373,
0.12151490896940231,
-0.0017472581239417195,
-0.4901023507118225,
1.1664726734161377,
0.0036866290029138327,
-0.7998755574226379,
-0.25674504041671753,
-0.07881560176610947,
0.24590402841567993,
-0.5265837907791138,
-0.08148885518312454,
-0.16139189898967743,
-0.018358761444687843,
-0.2571435272693634,
-1.1371160745620728,
0.44129127264022827,
-0.02634979411959648,
-0.36558252573013306,
-0.20831429958343506,
1.1395995616912842,
-0.562677264213562,
-0.7634157538414001,
-0.14246897399425507,
0.7961288094520569,
-0.18479345738887787,
-0.232495978474617,
-0.584980845451355,
-0.06591964513063431,
-0.201356440782547,
-0.412112295627594,
-0.01718657836318016,
0.8368093967437744,
0.17072750627994537,
0.38487476110458374,
0.43438345193862915,
0.430113285779953,
0.26177462935447693,
0.10625861585140228,
0.9259544014930725,
-0.6183413863182068,
-0.6918224692344666,
-0.6203217506408691,
0.44703879952430725,
-0.5323075652122498,
-0.31521132588386536,
0.6414761543273926,
1.0345559120178223,
0.3613640069961548,
-0.18598859012126923,
1.1668411493301392,
-0.08534641563892365,
0.40608006715774536,
-0.4362698495388031,
1.0975703001022339,
-0.23411458730697632,
-0.24684341251850128,
-0.06386076658964157,
-0.6046621799468994,
-0.586542010307312,
-0.0743807852268219,
-0.03798902779817581,
-0.33935558795928955,
0.6995751857757568,
-0.059299174696207047,
0.07291170954704285,
0.21823495626449585,
0.015412664972245693,
-0.1168527901172638,
0.4474203586578369,
0.5484362840652466,
0.23511424660682678,
-0.6894277930259705,
1.065889596939087,
-0.28941044211387634,
-0.14363233745098114,
-0.20656074583530426,
-0.9063437581062317,
-1.0594983100891113,
-0.5776700973510742,
-0.36499151587486267,
-0.4299536347389221,
0.2668105661869049,
0.5568246841430664,
0.6236156225204468,
-0.5702912211418152,
0.27399471402168274,
-0.06990983337163925,
0.21962213516235352,
-0.33645349740982056,
-0.2647411525249481,
0.4298369586467743,
-0.6901443004608154,
-0.5277315974235535,
0.05112353712320328,
0.019629141315817833,
-0.09392553567886353,
0.1443014293909073,
0.015165221877396107,
-0.17922481894493103,
-0.13902564346790314,
0.7401241064071655,
0.3830099105834961,
0.047488655894994736,
-0.5978147387504578,
0.008908582851290703,
-0.07900486141443253,
0.13425126671791077,
0.8562321662902832,
-1.080224633216858,
0.08798719942569733,
0.5837267637252808,
0.6142354011535645,
0.5862557291984558,
-0.03942234814167023,
0.6327208280563354,
-0.7626374959945679,
0.09285236150026321,
0.23726309835910797,
0.22466576099395752,
0.1725430190563202,
-0.5380786657333374,
0.15264245867729187,
0.7610843777656555,
-0.18417832255363464,
-0.3465682566165924,
-0.13044174015522003,
-0.7898238897323608,
-0.14588254690170288,
0.996966540813446,
0.2581627666950226,
-0.37453529238700867,
-0.12275189906358719,
-0.12343480437994003,
0.8449431657791138,
-0.34414324164390564,
0.8317592144012451,
0.7741093635559082,
-0.35007375478744507,
0.0995529294013977,
-0.4761653542518616,
0.8367787003517151,
-0.6520028710365295,
-0.6997624039649963,
-0.32141631841659546,
0.4809313416481018,
0.4432544708251953,
-0.18104244768619537,
0.9210028648376465,
0.1239909678697586,
0.2127595841884613,
0.31969109177589417,
-0.07904912531375885,
-0.7083774209022522,
-0.3790739178657532,
0.6683650016784668,
0.5172422528266907,
-0.4187699556350708,
-0.08219897747039795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11190v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11190v1 | Disclosure and Mitigation of Gender Bias in LLMs | 2024-02-17T04:48:55 | 2024-02-17T04:48:55 | Xiangjue Dong, Yibo Wang, Philip S. Yu, James Caverlee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) can generate biased responses. Yet previous
direct probing techniques contain either gender mentions or predefined gender
stereotypes, which are challenging to comprehensively collect. Hence, we
propose an indirect probing framework based on conditional generation. This
approach aims to induce LLMs to disclose their gender bias even without
explicit gender or stereotype mentions. We explore three distinct strategies to
disclose explicit and implicit gender bias in LLMs. Our experiments demonstrate
that all tested LLMs exhibit explicit and/or implicit gender bias, even when
gender stereotypes are not present in the inputs. In addition, an increased
model size or model alignment amplifies bias in most cases. Furthermore, we
investigate three methods to mitigate bias in LLMs via Hyperparameter Tuning,
Instruction Guiding, and Debias Tuning. Remarkably, these methods prove
effective even in the absence of explicit genders or stereotypes. | [
-0.3505702316761017,
-0.8346812725067139,
0.6073459982872009,
0.2973540127277374,
0.27680572867393494,
-0.009021766483783722,
-0.2895224988460541,
-0.21678578853607178,
-0.13391831517219543,
0.681835949420929,
-1.0206631422042847,
-0.4940083920955658,
-0.5067915916442871,
0.20954768359661102,
-0.42420780658721924,
0.6964578032493591,
0.013653944246470928,
0.4031126797199249,
-0.21405206620693207,
0.16383473575115204,
-0.533534586429596,
-0.47192075848579407,
-0.7953178882598877,
-0.4187403917312622,
0.5108452439308167,
0.4746634066104889,
0.4474989175796509,
0.7188493609428406,
0.29780733585357666,
0.39293619990348816,
-0.3158213794231415,
0.07671532779932022,
-0.6352583169937134,
0.3366513252258301,
-0.2273985594511032,
-0.8329529166221619,
-0.5058325529098511,
0.26362767815589905,
0.6320947408676147,
0.786198079586029,
0.09806328266859055,
0.4071533679962158,
0.3037843704223633,
0.7472895979881287,
-0.8175035119056702,
0.10819689184427261,
-0.670356810092926,
0.12605513632297516,
-0.1687404066324234,
-0.26562920212745667,
-0.5888541340827942,
-0.37240496277809143,
0.08811712265014648,
-0.25576576590538025,
0.57807856798172,
0.1817834973335266,
0.5539617538452148,
0.1123008131980896,
-0.8385396003723145,
-0.1464928835630417,
-0.7820488810539246,
0.8504059910774231,
-0.5491209030151367,
0.3269142210483551,
0.40497151017189026,
0.3334452211856842,
-0.10169019550085068,
-0.21842683851718903,
-0.43042099475860596,
-0.44420671463012695,
-0.4113575220108032,
-0.17291627824306488,
-0.12881718575954437,
0.17852850258350372,
0.5808144211769104,
0.14443396031856537,
-0.4146726131439209,
0.15454164147377014,
-0.012157012708485126,
-0.3587632477283478,
0.42972591519355774,
0.15602193772792816,
0.16863715648651123,
-0.16112495958805084,
-0.34511008858680725,
-0.03221200779080391,
-1.3181270360946655,
-0.3503730297088623,
1.0157755613327026,
0.33224353194236755,
-0.2913278639316559,
0.7975785732269287,
-0.03894416242837906,
0.46778324246406555,
0.45240435004234314,
0.013585790991783142,
0.11346838623285294,
-0.48273754119873047,
-0.045004893094301224,
0.2722651958465576,
0.5023322701454163,
0.23597490787506104,
0.3182259500026703,
0.1249355897307396,
-0.21113739907741547,
-0.00989861786365509,
-0.13361792266368866,
-0.6846251487731934,
0.29980000853538513,
0.08116837590932846,
-0.2730451822280884,
-0.41593214869499207,
-0.27943703532218933,
-0.8816609978675842,
-0.6128445267677307,
-0.379072904586792,
0.48193061351776123,
0.09271728247404099,
-0.25037404894828796,
-0.04926452040672302,
-0.30602094531059265,
0.3855927884578705,
0.16458247601985931,
-1.0831056833267212,
0.2090793251991272,
0.6605967283248901,
0.3591875731945038,
0.2701350450515747,
0.0005702897906303406,
-0.6512199640274048,
0.5652620792388916,
-0.405254989862442,
0.3154827952384949,
-0.5237798690795898,
-0.3646511137485504,
0.23273694515228271,
-0.09260530024766922,
0.18543905019760132,
-0.5809032917022705,
0.37244677543640137,
-0.1843164712190628,
0.33360132575035095,
-0.6875081658363342,
-0.326101154088974,
0.17131634056568146,
0.22804361581802368,
-0.4142613708972931,
0.8582648634910583,
-0.011942226439714432,
-1.1694116592407227,
0.3037777543067932,
-0.4274979829788208,
-0.2454276829957962,
-0.38187047839164734,
-0.5540760159492493,
-0.17597778141498566,
-0.04361158609390259,
0.5468616485595703,
0.2979557514190674,
-0.4293636083602905,
0.4499712884426117,
-0.23583483695983887,
-0.5459588766098022,
0.08503343909978867,
-0.5700921416282654,
0.6873905062675476,
-0.13389213383197784,
-0.7459643483161926,
0.12223904579877853,
-0.4508885443210602,
-0.390501469373703,
0.10980410128831863,
0.0016854014247655869,
-0.35788533091545105,
0.07068981230258942,
-0.4201519787311554,
0.015244502574205399,
0.09139884263277054,
-0.5736365914344788,
0.12931054830551147,
-0.41399022936820984,
0.15068663656711578,
1.1100828647613525,
-0.2952325642108917,
0.7696300148963928,
-0.21572798490524292,
0.604053795337677,
0.12034199386835098,
0.1536376029253006,
-0.03222257271409035,
0.0246705561876297,
-1.196460247039795,
-0.3385390341281891,
0.35000383853912354,
0.38823452591896057,
-0.8421905636787415,
0.3099539577960968,
-0.1855103224515915,
-0.03516170382499695,
-0.5985158681869507,
0.22465425729751587,
0.7937672734260559,
0.8112429976463318,
-0.08195900171995163,
0.3422743082046509,
-0.7390317320823669,
-1.4413623809814453,
-0.47195515036582947,
-0.2809641659259796,
-0.1739027351140976,
0.5158605575561523,
0.35970842838287354,
-0.013669248670339584,
0.7984883189201355,
-0.5379230380058289,
-0.17286120355129242,
-0.488743394613266,
0.2953983247280121,
0.22916682064533234,
0.36374756693840027,
0.5243288278579712,
-0.649681806564331,
-0.024075647816061974,
-0.49932822585105896,
-0.6295265555381775,
-0.44989049434661865,
0.19173471629619598,
-0.3853398859500885,
0.13702164590358734,
0.6305155754089355,
-0.5685601234436035,
0.23609530925750732,
0.7508774399757385,
-0.41056323051452637,
0.4124670922756195,
0.1071021556854248,
-0.023303886875510216,
-0.7079868316650391,
-0.2217894047498703,
0.15608766674995422,
-0.30449292063713074,
-0.4140143394470215,
0.0061949766241014,
0.23348474502563477,
0.039568912237882614,
-0.5866255760192871,
0.7833433747291565,
-0.8662075996398926,
-0.20652078092098236,
-0.1969471573829651,
-0.05400010570883751,
0.019163107499480247,
0.1523946225643158,
0.02843557298183441,
0.8219814896583557,
0.5761319994926453,
-0.8314644694328308,
-0.03376876190304756,
0.14316914975643158,
-0.03295465186238289,
0.40778622031211853,
-0.5843538641929626,
0.32765212655067444,
-0.5094751119613647,
0.6051487326622009,
-0.9174401760101318,
0.08847850561141968,
0.45192718505859375,
-0.43815934658050537,
0.44956550002098083,
-0.4917328655719757,
-0.5246601104736328,
-0.3355799913406372,
-0.6504538655281067,
0.3793514668941498,
0.4888421595096588,
-0.6907466053962708,
0.54929518699646,
0.0443260557949543,
-0.16012226045131683,
-0.8177950382232666,
-0.6473004221916199,
-0.1855173259973526,
-0.21143753826618195,
-0.6124808192253113,
0.16081979870796204,
-0.31114661693573,
-0.3930160701274872,
-0.3819293975830078,
-0.1530325561761856,
0.3624230921268463,
0.0011096171801909804,
0.2118113487958908,
0.3826831579208374,
-0.2999502122402191,
0.09721723943948746,
0.24321192502975464,
0.09904392808675766,
0.24618090689182281,
0.1275920420885086,
0.8846047520637512,
0.10817858576774597,
-0.5169717073440552,
-0.18440978229045868,
0.43681082129478455,
0.17755357921123505,
-0.022828152403235435,
0.6480031609535217,
0.6172260046005249,
-0.1463075876235962,
-0.2932721972465515,
-0.8185246586799622,
-0.6380268335342407,
-0.6283606886863708,
0.18333382904529572,
-0.3470759391784668,
-0.9844675064086914,
0.33247268199920654,
-0.08397608995437622,
-0.19199596345424652,
0.2231711745262146,
0.6227515339851379,
-0.014694374985992908,
1.4967657327651978,
0.969511091709137,
-0.102469801902771,
0.1176234781742096,
0.014737003482878208,
0.25461509823799133,
-0.9150559306144714,
-0.11798311024904251,
-0.834719717502594,
-0.3301863670349121,
-0.9087057709693909,
-0.3067949712276459,
0.32452380657196045,
-0.24291102588176727,
-0.4933995008468628,
-0.15040706098079681,
-0.137311652302742,
0.4716339409351349,
0.6748790740966797,
0.10248878598213196,
0.2563728094100952,
-0.10358356684446335,
-0.15325257182121277,
-0.1493004709482193,
-0.48389947414398193,
-0.5512546896934509,
1.076408863067627,
0.5000187754631042,
0.8908450603485107,
0.2142217755317688,
0.612887442111969,
0.12279075384140015,
0.33728399872779846,
-0.4284946918487549,
0.7700589299201965,
0.1118001639842987,
-1.090233325958252,
-0.19549240171909332,
-0.6794179081916809,
-0.641800582408905,
0.23988328874111176,
0.06060272082686424,
-0.6328073143959045,
0.4409045875072479,
0.3996470868587494,
0.10069352388381958,
0.11578929424285889,
-0.600313127040863,
0.12657594680786133,
-0.18764327466487885,
-0.5399850010871887,
0.21914701163768768,
-0.47846493124961853,
0.8861260414123535,
-0.03373583033680916,
0.2409418821334839,
-0.2826724946498871,
-0.10983666032552719,
0.5474178791046143,
-0.21601183712482452,
1.205524206161499,
-0.2140960842370987,
-0.39411914348602295,
-0.18089984357357025,
0.2779603898525238,
0.6007894277572632,
0.36064982414245605,
-0.1292339414358139,
-0.0064924550242722034,
-0.428954154253006,
-0.34420254826545715,
-0.4219171106815338,
0.8148697018623352,
-0.6489662528038025,
-1.1618818044662476,
-0.41765275597572327,
-0.6095203161239624,
-0.6908571720123291,
0.04061288759112358,
0.2999943494796753,
0.11935094743967056,
-0.0966978669166565,
-0.19148604571819305,
1.0054868459701538,
-0.5449126362800598,
0.21980130672454834,
0.8739876747131348,
-0.307657390832901,
0.316976934671402,
0.34349676966667175,
-0.35348036885261536,
0.31913456320762634,
0.372384637594223,
0.391315221786499,
-0.27843502163887024,
-0.25408288836479187,
-0.3104453384876251,
0.5790507197380066,
-0.6398898959159851,
-0.2141432911157608,
-0.5840813517570496,
-0.13721445202827454,
-0.8203563690185547,
0.14639581739902496,
-0.44506898522377014,
-0.17781181633472443,
-0.06663726270198822,
-0.4418536424636841,
0.3538988530635834,
0.5604762434959412,
-0.1495063453912735,
0.3431224822998047,
-0.37758100032806396,
0.594553530216217,
0.4284888803958893,
0.02039411850273609,
-0.22428590059280396,
-0.45213213562965393,
0.49637019634246826,
0.2349773496389389,
-0.019525956362485886,
-0.7769907116889954,
0.45115599036216736,
-0.009604700841009617,
0.5733022093772888,
0.4751756191253662,
0.01922750473022461,
0.379133939743042,
-0.5680162310600281,
0.6919870972633362,
0.13772298395633698,
-1.2411404848098755,
0.8307508826255798,
-0.6190670728683472,
0.044480908662080765,
0.4420294463634491,
0.5257659554481506,
-0.19013194739818573,
-0.5638498663902283,
-0.32454124093055725,
-0.9558184742927551,
0.8019123673439026,
0.16165845096111298,
0.6062630414962769,
-0.0694885328412056,
0.46105262637138367,
0.24464429914951324,
0.49312958121299744,
-0.7749835848808289,
-0.6667595505714417,
0.3176702558994293,
-0.05429460480809212,
-0.1685047596693039,
-0.6663005948066711,
-0.7089216113090515,
-0.3686210811138153,
0.5893729329109192,
-0.05048440769314766,
0.45499861240386963,
0.11801917105913162,
-0.1957896500825882,
0.04386824369430542,
0.29974374175071716,
0.6861422657966614,
0.6926636695861816,
-0.47030314803123474,
0.3947225511074066,
-0.029017185792326927,
-0.28896835446357727,
0.4501769542694092,
-0.21559496223926544,
-0.6203628182411194,
0.16948001086711884,
0.3504306972026825,
0.7724111080169678,
0.008412313647568226,
-0.4734494984149933,
0.627495527267456,
-0.13457055389881134,
-0.4065566956996918,
-0.08989894390106201,
0.03229836747050285,
0.3436109125614166,
0.2051425576210022,
0.23050786554813385,
-0.5307456254959106,
0.1486407071352005,
-0.7069166302680969,
-0.12338990718126297,
0.4961247742176056,
-0.45707789063453674,
-0.08950979262590408,
0.5531129240989685,
0.24977998435497284,
0.16188456118106842,
0.5304219722747803,
-0.0028811227530241013,
-0.4757292568683624,
0.7206733226776123,
0.7330967783927917,
0.6675017476081848,
-0.37071493268013,
0.4247402846813202,
0.15984250605106354,
0.604856550693512,
0.08462061733007431,
0.3121761679649353,
0.08978273719549179,
-0.7632198333740234,
-0.22938759624958038,
-0.37082335352897644,
-0.366941899061203,
0.1377563178539276,
-0.6609203815460205,
0.35623693466186523,
-0.43292704224586487,
-0.13642039895057678,
-0.26853230595588684,
-0.18065650761127472,
-0.7500520348548889,
0.11566421389579773,
0.33844342827796936,
0.8556997179985046,
-0.9310709834098816,
0.5022608637809753,
0.2961227297782898,
-0.21528713405132294,
-0.7373723983764648,
0.12922674417495728,
0.30098769068717957,
-1.020669937133789,
1.2085870504379272,
0.09352792054414749,
-0.37461110949516296,
-0.07876991480588913,
-0.6633151769638062,
-0.8784096837043762,
0.976715624332428,
0.853795051574707,
-0.801658570766449,
-0.08988519757986069,
0.29345694184303284,
0.12030302733182907,
-0.2093346118927002,
0.5688371062278748,
0.5587811470031738,
0.8229292035102844,
-0.09111938625574112,
-0.8232345581054688,
0.2663086950778961,
0.07327596843242645,
0.03868873044848442,
-0.005482502747327089,
-0.5469300150871277,
0.8820183873176575,
-0.08929711580276489,
-0.03235728666186333,
-0.09048092365264893,
0.6290407180786133,
0.39309224486351013,
0.2614077627658844,
0.5418179035186768,
0.10381311923265457,
0.6495180130004883,
-0.1924082636833191,
1.008505940437317,
0.089668869972229,
-0.07647877186536789,
1.1053999662399292,
-0.7182362675666809,
0.3230465054512024,
0.7325378060340881,
0.07711190730333328,
0.09281811118125916,
0.47267746925354004,
0.16961954534053802,
0.3607061207294464,
0.8555545210838318,
-0.2980350852012634,
-0.06774382293224335,
-0.41050899028778076,
-0.6112024188041687,
0.46197590231895447,
0.2568460702896118,
-0.5832903981208801,
-0.18266315758228302,
0.12431810051202774,
0.5283339619636536,
0.014855613000690937,
-0.36690810322761536,
0.5057006478309631,
0.04928898438811302,
-0.6003076434135437,
0.38602814078330994,
0.21157975494861603,
1.0348002910614014,
-0.7288341522216797,
-0.041357625275850296,
-0.8342617154121399,
0.11844237893819809,
-0.0088479770347476,
-0.2780131995677948,
-0.1545938402414322,
-0.02179371565580368,
-0.3666055202484131,
-0.3834317624568939,
0.7871384620666504,
-0.4738076627254486,
-0.6680932641029358,
0.46295592188835144,
0.6792604923248291,
-0.21869909763336182,
-0.07234512269496918,
-0.3997208774089813,
0.1605200320482254,
0.04755957052111626,
-0.35419681668281555,
0.5658721923828125,
0.17974203824996948,
-0.14642763137817383,
0.8710220456123352,
0.4835822582244873,
0.28503313660621643,
0.2052006721496582,
0.41461455821990967,
0.7908199429512024,
-0.6120954155921936,
0.009634614922106266,
-0.8938806653022766,
0.08003583550453186,
-0.07371970266103745,
0.03225765749812126,
0.9953497052192688,
0.38424912095069885,
0.5698568820953369,
0.00627931347116828,
0.7261542677879333,
0.4814981520175934,
0.644113302230835,
-0.7774166464805603,
0.6471790671348572,
-0.35456541180610657,
0.6522113084793091,
-0.2837632894515991,
-0.9709542393684387,
0.03845946863293648,
0.20609645545482635,
-0.28554680943489075,
0.273274689912796,
0.595115065574646,
1.0207570791244507,
-0.030378764495253563,
-0.10985919088125229,
0.1729663461446762,
0.419981986284256,
0.2480219453573227,
0.23584412038326263,
1.119388222694397,
-0.19439107179641724,
0.4422127902507782,
-0.2944789230823517,
-0.20560497045516968,
-0.031578194350004196,
-1.1781941652297974,
-0.9982419610023499,
-0.07341830432415009,
-0.38443782925605774,
-0.1548876166343689,
0.49198102951049805,
0.4317293167114258,
0.6998737454414368,
-0.2949393093585968,
-0.24357502162456512,
0.0862528383731842,
0.32583296298980713,
0.24407173693180084,
-0.2520507574081421,
0.22559355199337006,
-0.14814193546772003,
-1.0103598833084106,
0.5140671133995056,
-0.03555683791637421,
-0.08679083734750748,
-0.5022411942481995,
0.1811646968126297,
-0.08059515804052353,
0.3034604489803314,
0.3704139292240143,
-0.12609000504016876,
-0.47916460037231445,
-0.3265778124332428,
-0.05008333548903465,
-0.17173004150390625,
-0.13887643814086914,
0.985508382320404,
-0.6277555227279663,
-0.06736382842063904,
0.5660952925682068,
0.2667830288410187,
0.45283734798431396,
-0.14735718071460724,
1.146401286125183,
-1.1366556882858276,
0.37414705753326416,
0.2566598653793335,
0.32104429602622986,
0.3472343385219574,
-0.7375069260597229,
0.31866297125816345,
-0.11807101964950562,
-0.23837946355342865,
-0.8893198370933533,
0.4495384693145752,
-0.7684731483459473,
-0.40965673327445984,
1.5348678827285767,
0.16795235872268677,
-0.09000279754400253,
0.11945227533578873,
-0.2677350342273712,
0.314655601978302,
-0.24758398532867432,
0.3483370840549469,
0.598355770111084,
0.06671427935361862,
-0.04005349054932594,
-0.9332109093666077,
0.47200000286102295,
0.7698429226875305,
-0.5314794182777405,
0.09455668926239014,
0.4173074960708618,
0.38068726658821106,
-0.33531519770622253,
0.6714807152748108,
-0.23172134160995483,
-0.08998415619134903,
-0.1844273805618286,
0.09951549023389816,
-0.023032745346426964,
-0.16493283212184906,
-0.2311766892671585,
-0.20409627258777618,
0.0336434468626976,
-0.15455161035060883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11187v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11187v1 | LaCo: Large Language Model Pruning via Layer Collapse | 2024-02-17T04:16:30 | 2024-02-17T04:16:30 | Yifei Yang, Zouying Cao, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) based on transformer are witnessing a notable
trend of size expansion, which brings considerable costs to both model training
and inference. However, existing methods such as model quantization, knowledge
distillation, and model pruning are constrained by various issues, including
hardware support limitations, the need for extensive training, and alterations
to the internal structure of the model. In this paper, we propose a concise
layer-wise pruning method called \textit{Layer Collapse (LaCo)}, in which rear
model layers collapse into a prior layer, enabling a rapid reduction in model
size while preserving the model structure. Comprehensive experiments show that
our method maintains an average task performance of over 80\% at pruning ratios
of 25-30\%, significantly outperforming existing state-of-the-art structured
pruning methods. We also conduct post-training experiments to confirm that the
proposed pruning method effectively inherits the parameters of the original
model. Finally, we discuss our motivation from the perspective of layer-wise
similarity and evaluate the performance of the pruned LLMs across various
pruning ratios. | [
-0.3044254779815674,
-0.7166913747787476,
0.4271255135536194,
0.0774146020412445,
-0.3440529406070709,
0.04325096309185028,
-0.3650567829608917,
-0.2232341170310974,
-0.0661953017115593,
0.8028458952903748,
-0.7456249594688416,
-0.3751350939273834,
-0.2961895763874054,
-0.18799568712711334,
-0.5921752452850342,
0.7688159346580505,
0.17854799330234528,
-0.3410257399082184,
-0.16516627371311188,
0.1852986365556717,
-0.3218117356300354,
-0.508450448513031,
-0.9212680459022522,
-0.42415475845336914,
0.43731871247291565,
0.358895480632782,
0.4557713270187378,
0.6344688534736633,
0.36574047803878784,
0.43051019310951233,
-0.5223901867866516,
0.37318339943885803,
-0.6124960780143738,
0.1455715447664261,
0.21666909754276276,
-0.6197465062141418,
-0.37365269660949707,
-0.060590535402297974,
0.9974747896194458,
0.7952312231063843,
-0.3042049705982208,
0.18551068007946014,
0.19934584200382233,
0.8264514207839966,
-0.636400043964386,
0.12339729070663452,
-0.8465322256088257,
0.19028589129447937,
-0.03072342649102211,
0.05620024725794792,
-0.7060351967811584,
-0.12683254480361938,
-0.1916174292564392,
-0.3225333094596863,
0.38970062136650085,
0.05457163229584694,
0.8569339513778687,
0.26156559586524963,
-0.38129010796546936,
0.3260871469974518,
-1.0977720022201538,
1.0102983713150024,
-0.9726985096931458,
0.41130539774894714,
0.1980600357055664,
0.2812768816947937,
0.15276890993118286,
-0.624302089214325,
-0.5671908855438232,
-0.42788952589035034,
-0.15193581581115723,
0.09685361385345459,
0.14342376589775085,
0.06623254716396332,
0.22138193249702454,
0.5371759533882141,
-0.2668535113334656,
0.26695939898490906,
-0.5063923597335815,
-0.298818975687027,
0.39427223801612854,
-0.08669126778841019,
0.26115718483924866,
0.05698179081082344,
-0.4017620086669922,
-0.13880601525306702,
-1.1449530124664307,
-0.06798612326383591,
0.4935506582260132,
0.1394975185394287,
0.34729301929473877,
0.4615044593811035,
0.030651364475488663,
0.6331928968429565,
-0.16090244054794312,
-0.4641322195529938,
0.18139652907848358,
-0.12091916799545288,
-0.5061873197555542,
-0.07598181813955307,
0.8348934650421143,
0.3276245594024658,
0.1846417337656021,
-0.30646273493766785,
-0.25247225165367126,
-0.268815815448761,
0.2058868706226349,
-0.8571814298629761,
-0.16260573267936707,
0.28531548380851746,
-0.44855019450187683,
-0.21685318648815155,
-0.03602367267012596,
-0.2623785436153412,
-0.04252074286341667,
-0.18609771132469177,
0.0711413323879242,
-0.5775472521781921,
-0.3181942105293274,
-0.007593986112624407,
0.22743546962738037,
0.18297819793224335,
0.35795608162879944,
-0.6259881258010864,
0.5284538269042969,
0.8945134282112122,
0.9669689536094666,
0.0069326371885836124,
-0.25070682168006897,
-0.675166666507721,
0.21008306741714478,
-0.2989295423030853,
0.2683470547199249,
-0.18164940178394318,
-0.32556790113449097,
-0.09159806370735168,
0.0251326821744442,
-0.1491190791130066,
-0.7811999917030334,
0.9009709358215332,
-0.6525994539260864,
0.05391337350010872,
0.01050780713558197,
-0.45331379771232605,
-0.4041610360145569,
0.39904096722602844,
-0.8736682534217834,
0.7257354259490967,
-0.11423038691282272,
-0.6791063547134399,
-0.18622930347919464,
-0.16687355935573578,
-0.6550476551055908,
-0.1414073407649994,
0.26368284225463867,
-0.8056596517562866,
0.2619323134422302,
0.3471672236919403,
0.6003044247627258,
-0.5804346203804016,
0.3281496465206146,
-0.10053688287734985,
-0.20648488402366638,
-0.01200393121689558,
-0.19184286892414093,
0.9489374160766602,
0.2454141229391098,
0.0598103366792202,
0.09373112767934799,
-0.7114812731742859,
-0.11893640458583832,
0.2004484385251999,
-0.2164393961429596,
-0.3891715109348297,
0.07618377357721329,
-0.20274636149406433,
0.17044173181056976,
0.13144610822200775,
-0.6393309235572815,
0.18040212988853455,
-0.7835015654563904,
1.0685017108917236,
0.5224497318267822,
-0.029045116156339645,
0.5994547605514526,
-0.2963027060031891,
0.3712077736854553,
0.10620206594467163,
0.31626635789871216,
-0.2874264717102051,
-0.13252589106559753,
-1.0519956350326538,
-0.2147505283355713,
0.2819274067878723,
0.39890849590301514,
-0.574352502822876,
0.6064894199371338,
-0.35178428888320923,
-0.4821673631668091,
-0.5363418459892273,
0.3749435842037201,
0.5285412073135376,
0.7528314590454102,
0.29464370012283325,
-0.22429536283016205,
-0.3354048728942871,
-1.3167394399642944,
0.11369738727807999,
-0.23956149816513062,
-0.32871514558792114,
0.011567742563784122,
0.33673545718193054,
0.17118456959724426,
0.8598014116287231,
-0.5378906726837158,
-0.39521315693855286,
-0.37413299083709717,
-0.03521503135561943,
0.23519694805145264,
0.673369824886322,
0.274713397026062,
-0.7848942279815674,
-0.08701261132955551,
0.20350973308086395,
-0.3336479067802429,
0.026093166321516037,
-0.10944998264312744,
0.1109960600733757,
-0.06227773055434227,
0.6052245497703552,
-0.691068172454834,
-0.027597548440098763,
0.5473794341087341,
0.3445599377155304,
0.7047321200370789,
-0.124717116355896,
-0.176547572016716,
-1.0152888298034668,
-0.04287303239107132,
0.06047139689326286,
-0.23391889035701752,
-0.7460722923278809,
0.23893791437149048,
0.21379008889198303,
-0.14661283791065216,
-0.624826967716217,
0.3238280415534973,
-0.7698519229888916,
0.08862272650003433,
-0.1883644312620163,
-0.019700651988387108,
0.21194607019424438,
0.5699795484542847,
0.028608884662389755,
0.4269213080406189,
0.37766098976135254,
-0.5626896619796753,
0.33077389001846313,
0.021281523630023003,
-0.5477117300033569,
-0.19073159992694855,
-0.8542171716690063,
0.26293355226516724,
-0.1318957805633545,
0.3385234475135803,
-0.8068189024925232,
0.2051849067211151,
0.0104666817933321,
0.021778736263513565,
0.35365283489227295,
-0.4452347755432129,
-0.531317949295044,
-0.46221768856048584,
-0.47860461473464966,
0.39547088742256165,
0.6080496907234192,
-0.4443574547767639,
0.5883135795593262,
0.402974933385849,
-0.11251132935285568,
-0.5599154829978943,
-0.8870221376419067,
0.058171167969703674,
-0.5351639986038208,
-0.8118951916694641,
0.5633982419967651,
-0.12023305147886276,
-0.21255230903625488,
-0.21353627741336823,
-0.2243722528219223,
-0.08749160915613174,
0.11132130771875381,
0.29150861501693726,
0.30295926332473755,
-0.3170977830886841,
-0.05721093341708183,
0.23014885187149048,
0.15223371982574463,
0.15047717094421387,
-0.22563768923282623,
0.7554076313972473,
-0.08471427112817764,
-0.4252122640609741,
-0.5360510349273682,
0.12338200211524963,
0.6208107471466064,
-0.5900523662567139,
1.015270709991455,
0.3304003179073334,
-0.17877523601055145,
-0.6747128367424011,
-0.7598138451576233,
-0.17134089767932892,
-0.5216891765594482,
0.3399878442287445,
-0.37979963421821594,
-1.0889204740524292,
0.7763091921806335,
-0.35519254207611084,
0.08712980151176453,
0.2853299379348755,
0.3567592203617096,
0.018160004168748856,
0.6438786387443542,
0.6076260209083557,
-0.2649659812450409,
0.5311127305030823,
-0.5713114738464355,
0.25371503829956055,
-1.0466820001602173,
-0.173300102353096,
-0.5449427962303162,
-0.29875871539115906,
-0.05787154659628868,
-0.5222952961921692,
0.09295672923326492,
0.3062869608402252,
-0.21640637516975403,
0.4086135923862457,
-0.5550198554992676,
0.592734158039093,
0.48650771379470825,
0.24046427011489868,
0.32472360134124756,
0.06541278213262558,
0.10683629661798477,
0.2519022226333618,
-0.7934923768043518,
-0.24480237066745758,
0.5959084630012512,
0.6437546610832214,
0.5084023475646973,
0.04589718207716942,
0.7179256677627563,
-0.1287459433078766,
0.2851267158985138,
-0.9521803855895996,
0.7093837261199951,
-0.19572971761226654,
-0.3008876442909241,
-0.5488638281822205,
-0.7218617796897888,
-0.6263638734817505,
0.32335853576660156,
0.07894694805145264,
-0.7055785059928894,
0.10787606984376907,
0.24067199230194092,
-0.270230770111084,
0.4939011335372925,
-0.8593496084213257,
0.49456074833869934,
-0.09114894270896912,
-0.25664740800857544,
-0.0678616315126419,
-0.5976095199584961,
0.8040187954902649,
-0.15786050260066986,
0.31279635429382324,
-0.02367282845079899,
0.025038285180926323,
0.8219802379608154,
-0.8961061835289001,
0.9839262366294861,
-0.08568217605352402,
-0.352857381105423,
0.41441965103149414,
0.3139927387237549,
0.6395860910415649,
-0.22740212082862854,
-0.13276401162147522,
0.16027839481830597,
-0.3088681697845459,
-0.136537104845047,
-0.8228824138641357,
0.8031367659568787,
-0.6929056644439697,
-0.6995489597320557,
0.30307358503341675,
-0.6470361351966858,
-0.271973580121994,
0.08432312309741974,
-0.05365941673517227,
0.47231626510620117,
-0.04966636002063751,
0.37016427516937256,
0.5456410050392151,
-0.25147637724876404,
0.5136408805847168,
0.3727153241634369,
-0.16877123713493347,
-0.30976971983909607,
0.9056426882743835,
0.15973177552223206,
0.387969434261322,
0.7321299910545349,
0.40507835149765015,
-0.07920961081981659,
-0.9027594923973083,
0.008182339370250702,
0.3913425803184509,
-0.39324846863746643,
-0.27140289545059204,
-0.2927352786064148,
-0.6905694007873535,
-0.32971182465553284,
0.06818622350692749,
-0.5148991942405701,
-0.6175009608268738,
0.17324978113174438,
-0.1469060778617859,
-0.016109108924865723,
0.49024754762649536,
0.43197375535964966,
0.7307878136634827,
-0.9873727560043335,
0.03611341863870621,
0.23708604276180267,
0.14379197359085083,
0.37584036588668823,
-0.608138918876648,
-0.25580745935440063,
-0.1359606236219406,
-0.12600450217723846,
-0.532265841960907,
0.5975499749183655,
0.4189608097076416,
0.40089306235313416,
0.6395304203033447,
0.19985848665237427,
0.6292116045951843,
-0.7271458506584167,
0.5180049538612366,
0.4390224814414978,
-0.9814934134483337,
0.6628369688987732,
-0.1952204555273056,
0.3373540937900543,
0.31868547201156616,
0.20139051973819733,
-0.3739755153656006,
-0.5385663509368896,
-0.5256940126419067,
-1.110605001449585,
0.6119531393051147,
0.36973729729652405,
0.020992295816540718,
0.25710585713386536,
0.40580517053604126,
0.0038875441532582045,
0.10770397633314133,
-0.8741387128829956,
-0.21287982165813446,
0.013330151326954365,
0.07354676723480225,
-0.1432999223470688,
-0.44107940793037415,
-0.3117218017578125,
-0.19502590596675873,
0.702614426612854,
0.12136457115411758,
-0.13967262208461761,
-0.019594503566622734,
-0.3900282382965088,
0.16694790124893188,
0.21569141745567322,
0.4037972688674927,
0.5766242742538452,
-0.19956128299236298,
0.34613317251205444,
0.11090495437383652,
-0.46300941705703735,
0.09193416684865952,
-0.19284285604953766,
-0.539402961730957,
-0.2763592600822449,
0.6301286816596985,
0.8311696648597717,
0.20013053715229034,
-0.5166362524032593,
0.24682311713695526,
0.07358963787555695,
-0.32817432284355164,
-0.0690920501947403,
0.2308841049671173,
0.24028848111629486,
0.07320103049278259,
0.37932711839675903,
-0.07858111709356308,
-0.014624395407736301,
-0.6247986555099487,
0.07214534282684326,
0.3629908263683319,
-0.12014991790056229,
-0.23126773536205292,
0.45076683163642883,
0.3044438362121582,
-0.4226806163787842,
0.7062097787857056,
0.18275894224643707,
-0.6111694574356079,
0.7233255505561829,
0.6686832904815674,
0.7091012001037598,
-0.3415481746196747,
0.23337914049625397,
0.4869367182254791,
0.7340037822723389,
-0.4454863667488098,
-0.469585120677948,
-0.2700783610343933,
-0.924157977104187,
-0.8965839147567749,
-0.7003406882286072,
-0.20310071110725403,
0.4339202046394348,
-0.5512403845787048,
-0.055004507303237915,
-0.6554164290428162,
0.011003791354596615,
-0.208438441157341,
0.023083705455064774,
-0.20986470580101013,
0.31875914335250854,
0.09688252955675125,
1.0640003681182861,
-0.9252116680145264,
1.2451276779174805,
0.4872446358203888,
-0.4012591242790222,
-0.8352915644645691,
0.01849251613020897,
-0.1613054871559143,
-0.7781516313552856,
0.6845566630363464,
0.14700947701931,
-0.2582338750362396,
-0.018005356192588806,
-0.4555474519729614,
-0.6933113932609558,
1.1190516948699951,
0.7675744891166687,
-1.050922155380249,
-0.1711972951889038,
0.17282697558403015,
0.2822422683238983,
-0.29709747433662415,
0.1138070598244667,
0.47769683599472046,
0.370630145072937,
0.3210544288158417,
-0.8806058764457703,
0.1595737338066101,
-0.3428719639778137,
0.2159986048936844,
0.3584829270839691,
-0.8794995546340942,
0.8261368870735168,
-0.002645696047693491,
-0.3687037527561188,
-0.01712646149098873,
0.7444531321525574,
0.0612318180501461,
0.004055126570165157,
1.034053921699524,
0.5991472601890564,
0.6787959337234497,
0.013085204176604748,
0.7807268500328064,
-0.2918013334274292,
0.5137065649032593,
1.2651535272598267,
-0.3185316324234009,
0.8573936820030212,
0.5012965798377991,
-0.2272697538137436,
0.27289247512817383,
0.3570212423801422,
0.10043059289455414,
0.4288877248764038,
0.2893519997596741,
-0.11713232845067978,
-0.35416489839553833,
-0.00864221341907978,
-0.21818797290325165,
0.2258467972278595,
0.21875259280204773,
-0.224253848195076,
-0.07762712240219116,
-0.010035856626927853,
0.11742974817752838,
0.058564793318510056,
-0.4009387195110321,
0.5636093020439148,
0.31381842494010925,
-0.636987566947937,
0.6097759008407593,
0.03430983051657677,
0.4344503581523895,
-0.7043052911758423,
0.24024330079555511,
-0.27769735455513,
0.2426493912935257,
-0.19371700286865234,
-0.4684910476207733,
0.4653167426586151,
-0.3113476634025574,
-0.09196293354034424,
-0.466248482465744,
0.8507687449455261,
-0.4590640664100647,
-0.7522146105766296,
0.41998156905174255,
0.4587346613407135,
0.019877610728144646,
-0.27873343229293823,
-0.4573994278907776,
0.4281024634838104,
0.12873806059360504,
-0.38252636790275574,
0.3586893677711487,
0.30727559328079224,
0.04374818503856659,
0.9293763637542725,
0.5528078675270081,
0.27161118388175964,
-0.04839928448200226,
0.24981604516506195,
1.0762141942977905,
-0.5166589617729187,
-0.15133842825889587,
-0.8492137789726257,
0.4847213327884674,
-0.2134748101234436,
0.0370720699429512,
0.7491785883903503,
0.6658725142478943,
0.8404949307441711,
0.07626718282699585,
0.42996713519096375,
0.16455061733722687,
0.35372596979141235,
-0.7671568989753723,
0.7491665482521057,
-0.6182178854942322,
0.64846271276474,
-0.09447525441646576,
-1.091483235359192,
-0.27918967604637146,
0.5319147109985352,
-0.3220520615577698,
-0.06929853558540344,
0.6957966089248657,
0.7507493495941162,
-0.18770243227481842,
-0.25087958574295044,
0.40748003125190735,
0.6113532185554504,
0.2550024092197418,
0.46946245431900024,
0.7352936267852783,
-0.1921928972005844,
0.6979760527610779,
-0.7008143663406372,
-0.16499944031238556,
0.0032900769729167223,
-0.8995460867881775,
-0.9086494445800781,
-0.7412696480751038,
-0.3880515396595001,
-0.1297168880701065,
-0.09952305257320404,
0.32050585746765137,
0.9581535458564758,
-0.7154873013496399,
-0.3569486439228058,
-0.030059456825256348,
0.2239314764738083,
-0.2998523414134979,
-0.18708160519599915,
0.5069811940193176,
-0.059168823063373566,
-0.7445339560508728,
0.6243156790733337,
0.23029689490795135,
-0.3579223155975342,
-0.36867615580558777,
0.035129278898239136,
-0.10715968906879425,
-0.20589333772659302,
0.8355756998062134,
0.24507786333560944,
-0.7588545680046082,
0.0064218780025839806,
-0.33397284150123596,
0.2985873520374298,
-0.10639078915119171,
0.9962773323059082,
-0.7988540530204773,
-0.011088764294981956,
0.3751571774482727,
0.5672799348831177,
0.75319504737854,
0.11619681119918823,
0.7140790224075317,
-1.082604169845581,
0.3675537407398224,
0.2139097899198532,
0.5491164326667786,
0.2826845347881317,
-0.07393141090869904,
0.3487761318683624,
-0.02483218163251877,
-0.3784596621990204,
-0.9890168905258179,
0.372572124004364,
-1.1959128379821777,
-0.4317565858364105,
1.0214409828186035,
-0.2625088691711426,
-0.651748776435852,
0.35878682136535645,
-0.21002936363220215,
0.2657160460948944,
-0.27202385663986206,
0.6723588109016418,
0.5249611139297485,
0.20723627507686615,
-0.6301245093345642,
-0.3629119098186493,
0.16533246636390686,
0.2985953688621521,
-0.6251495480537415,
0.33049920201301575,
0.3929816782474518,
0.12936511635780334,
0.35745543241500854,
0.38016727566719055,
0.0028355864342302084,
-0.3266502320766449,
-0.23989161849021912,
0.060065798461437225,
-0.43044763803482056,
-0.44228342175483704,
-0.09559939056634903,
0.6863164901733398,
-0.03128765523433685,
-0.1223093643784523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11178v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11178v1 | RENOVI: A Benchmark Towards Remediating Norm Violations in Socio-Cultural Conversations | 2024-02-17T03:13:42 | 2024-02-17T03:13:42 | Haolan Zhan, Zhuang Li, Xiaoxi Kang, Tao Feng, Yuncheng Hua, Lizhen Qu, Yi Ying, Mei Rianto Chandra, Kelly Rosalin, Jureynolds Jureynolds, Suraj Sharma, Shilin Qu, Linhao Luo, Lay-Ki Soon, Zhaleh Semnani Azad, Ingrid Zukerman, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Norm violations occur when individuals fail to conform to culturally accepted
behaviors, which may lead to potential conflicts. Remediating norm violations
requires social awareness and cultural sensitivity of the nuances at play. To
equip interactive AI systems with a remediation ability, we offer ReNoVi - a
large-scale corpus of 9,258 multi-turn dialogues annotated with social norms,
as well as define a sequence of tasks to help understand and remediate norm
violations step by step. ReNoVi consists of two parts: 512 human-authored
dialogues (real data), and 8,746 synthetic conversations generated by ChatGPT
through prompt learning. While collecting sufficient human-authored data is
costly, synthetic conversations provide suitable amounts of data to help
mitigate the scarcity of training data, as well as the chance to assess the
alignment between LLMs and humans in the awareness of social norms. We thus
harness the power of ChatGPT to generate synthetic training data for our task.
To ensure the quality of both human-authored and synthetic data, we follow a
quality control protocol during data collection. Our experimental results
demonstrate the importance of remediating norm violations in socio-cultural
conversations, as well as the improvement in performance obtained from
synthetic data. | [
-0.3457440137863159,
-1.1154670715332031,
0.003567351261153817,
0.10668270289897919,
-0.16004545986652374,
0.22273869812488556,
-0.2930470108985901,
-0.4802412688732147,
0.39742472767829895,
0.2896888852119446,
-0.46058544516563416,
-0.12900853157043457,
-0.5041550397872925,
0.16145972907543182,
-0.361583948135376,
0.9776992201805115,
0.14575590193271637,
0.008052974008023739,
-0.4182850122451782,
-0.1419147104024887,
-0.4614691734313965,
-0.340622216463089,
-0.7612091898918152,
-0.2530979514122009,
0.5152711868286133,
0.692744791507721,
0.5175765156745911,
0.35477641224861145,
0.40117520093917847,
0.32868751883506775,
0.04100754112005234,
0.6604411005973816,
-1.0897096395492554,
0.4655332863330841,
0.008938092738389969,
-0.24801978468894958,
-0.5727238655090332,
0.0714290514588356,
0.9383265972137451,
0.13322795927524567,
-0.12903697788715363,
0.49182888865470886,
0.024093223735690117,
0.4609543979167938,
-0.45200687646865845,
0.15985608100891113,
-0.5527795553207397,
0.06415567547082901,
0.07524341344833374,
-0.15980754792690277,
-0.29218825697898865,
-0.5230600237846375,
-0.25642213225364685,
-0.7078002691268921,
0.035447850823402405,
-0.16081500053405762,
1.2100297212600708,
0.5646457076072693,
-0.4833267629146576,
0.1290917992591858,
-0.8885082006454468,
0.6555333137512207,
-0.3923003375530243,
0.4853299558162689,
0.505736768245697,
0.30294069647789,
-0.32424014806747437,
-1.030357003211975,
-0.7173010110855103,
0.19931438565254211,
-0.02039247751235962,
0.1443309187889099,
-0.26045534014701843,
-0.31353965401649475,
0.4612160623073578,
0.23136644065380096,
-0.1482909619808197,
-0.28136706352233887,
-0.8256893157958984,
-0.46442079544067383,
0.9084331393241882,
0.4388892650604248,
0.2891223430633545,
-0.31705284118652344,
-0.11842160671949387,
-0.21973109245300293,
-0.6940892338752747,
0.2286103069782257,
0.33913111686706543,
0.016695160418748856,
0.15174902975559235,
0.05929763987660408,
-0.4098396301269531,
0.45455485582351685,
-0.05921101197600365,
-0.22749051451683044,
0.43620285391807556,
-0.6603022813796997,
-0.15092141926288605,
-0.319975882768631,
0.8451879620552063,
0.6874502897262573,
0.7507929801940918,
0.14893604815006256,
-0.11552703380584717,
-0.21169574558734894,
0.7042126059532166,
-0.8699871301651001,
-0.06916255503892899,
-0.1220676377415657,
-0.28691866993904114,
-0.57855224609375,
-0.17266537249088287,
-0.6942773461341858,
-0.3059494197368622,
-0.6038737297058105,
0.2623583972454071,
-0.33994951844215393,
-0.22931168973445892,
-0.20676028728485107,
-0.2022138386964798,
0.7622224688529968,
0.5385259389877319,
-0.7442683577537537,
0.24461697041988373,
0.6230196952819824,
0.8060092926025391,
0.1343490332365036,
0.0774870365858078,
-0.6949061751365662,
-0.0902044028043747,
-0.31790629029273987,
0.6195792555809021,
-0.540501594543457,
-0.7814051508903503,
-0.031312499195337296,
-0.015213927254080772,
0.10789484530687332,
-0.43144750595092773,
0.8421279788017273,
-0.30419349670410156,
-0.07436443865299225,
-0.316003680229187,
-0.21178007125854492,
-0.11012189090251923,
0.7905430197715759,
-0.3131370544433594,
0.930561363697052,
-0.06335795670747757,
-0.6564048528671265,
0.4836684763431549,
-0.22220246493816376,
-0.5170354247093201,
0.19142112135887146,
-0.41492894291877747,
-0.5556163787841797,
-0.24833862483501434,
0.2180248200893402,
0.06483526527881622,
-0.2867031395435333,
0.1668720245361328,
0.13893602788448334,
-0.6231088042259216,
0.09062066674232483,
-0.6270056962966919,
0.7210376858711243,
0.3743717670440674,
0.004410135094076395,
0.33486708998680115,
-0.5731003880500793,
0.025515956804156303,
0.09900804609060287,
-0.31741052865982056,
-0.2917014956474304,
0.011300182901322842,
-0.0013086021644994617,
0.1224270910024643,
0.07257921248674393,
-0.6229694485664368,
0.22652317583560944,
-0.06410258263349533,
0.5663409233093262,
0.9629799127578735,
0.2731744349002838,
0.11238297820091248,
-0.7345267534255981,
0.49411752820014954,
-0.1954210102558136,
0.6533520817756653,
0.07186238467693329,
-0.5245844125747681,
-0.8431747555732727,
-0.3496975302696228,
-0.012651113793253899,
0.6015879511833191,
-0.6630817651748657,
-0.19020339846611023,
-0.6347028017044067,
-0.617999792098999,
-0.7417439818382263,
0.20926012098789215,
0.2741847634315491,
0.5830621123313904,
0.15048637986183167,
-0.3501272201538086,
-0.7115584015846252,
-0.8871211409568787,
-0.2486286759376526,
-0.360794335603714,
0.11243826895952225,
0.6576720476150513,
0.36223626136779785,
-0.5674896240234375,
1.1724110841751099,
-0.16792301833629608,
-0.26004743576049805,
0.21808014810085297,
0.19153591990470886,
-0.3027622401714325,
0.4227488040924072,
0.019363459199666977,
-1.034270167350769,
-0.54944908618927,
-0.3012904226779938,
-0.789821445941925,
0.10046614706516266,
-0.09846528619527817,
0.022638441994786263,
0.06885938346385956,
1.0502663850784302,
-0.02013334073126316,
0.5288316607475281,
0.22550331056118011,
0.011881114915013313,
0.628386378288269,
-0.3147414028644562,
0.528689980506897,
-1.0952672958374023,
-0.05982130765914917,
-0.12641768157482147,
-0.4353877604007721,
-0.6941986083984375,
-0.2475622594356537,
-0.14145240187644958,
0.06601694226264954,
-0.6233768463134766,
0.418849915266037,
-0.11608146876096725,
0.2688610851764679,
0.11781832575798035,
0.21039776504039764,
-0.12323206663131714,
0.3455178141593933,
0.03499819338321686,
0.8452036380767822,
0.047008611261844635,
-0.36014682054519653,
0.5082448124885559,
0.5554187297821045,
-0.2773197889328003,
0.776513934135437,
-0.960690438747406,
0.36908403038978577,
-0.2339095175266266,
0.40398624539375305,
-1.0715152025222778,
-0.22478243708610535,
0.37336626648902893,
-0.6567453742027283,
-0.05366494134068489,
-0.2692698836326599,
-0.5928464531898499,
0.20940124988555908,
-0.41532665491104126,
0.4922284781932831,
0.850259006023407,
-0.13215719163417816,
0.5183195471763611,
0.5827080011367798,
-0.11954715102910995,
-0.6409381031990051,
-0.27559083700180054,
0.34728890657424927,
-0.19425387680530548,
-0.9323934316635132,
-0.2408943921327591,
0.10499770194292068,
-0.5507310032844543,
-0.40324026346206665,
0.1427551656961441,
0.22148962318897247,
0.12728574872016907,
0.6681615710258484,
0.11493102461099625,
0.15189588069915771,
0.2965694069862366,
-0.025280460715293884,
-0.10406943410634995,
0.27687686681747437,
0.24589133262634277,
0.41705432534217834,
-0.435833215713501,
-0.271702378988266,
-0.41430047154426575,
0.041216664016246796,
0.7707386016845703,
-0.2167188823223114,
0.516329288482666,
1.0558345317840576,
-0.22761914134025574,
0.2441839575767517,
-0.6340097188949585,
-0.4058721959590912,
-0.465273916721344,
0.0747491866350174,
-0.3213091492652893,
-0.8688058853149414,
0.44859641790390015,
-0.14549347758293152,
0.3288782835006714,
0.14644667506217957,
0.5126860737800598,
-0.16346675157546997,
0.7625014185905457,
0.34783023595809937,
-0.009955733083188534,
0.6675431132316589,
-0.24790330231189728,
0.46634945273399353,
-0.8455926179885864,
-0.35320213437080383,
-0.28968173265457153,
-0.4339810311794281,
-0.7690040469169617,
-0.6586570143699646,
0.5398625135421753,
-0.42114314436912537,
-0.34238600730895996,
0.1081324890255928,
-0.43608614802360535,
0.3879275321960449,
0.450982928276062,
0.041760947555303574,
0.5597667098045349,
-0.09197781980037689,
0.30303657054901123,
-0.21226760745048523,
-0.5414114594459534,
-0.6232113838195801,
0.988517165184021,
0.37367844581604004,
0.7743620276451111,
0.048119064420461655,
0.6905089616775513,
0.659790575504303,
0.5617513060569763,
-0.7569540739059448,
0.5223903656005859,
0.34026211500167847,
-0.5941158533096313,
-0.522577166557312,
-0.31687137484550476,
-0.8444396257400513,
0.2740384340286255,
-0.47691255807876587,
-0.5842922925949097,
0.47959038615226746,
0.022881461307406425,
-0.2674153745174408,
0.1780061423778534,
-0.53475022315979,
0.7694546580314636,
0.2555605471134186,
-0.5906473398208618,
-0.519926130771637,
-0.6848210692405701,
0.3475756347179413,
-0.09074244648218155,
0.5519529581069946,
-0.0668702945113182,
0.4096505641937256,
0.636653482913971,
-0.2493627667427063,
1.2579402923583984,
0.05820704251527786,
-0.07785831391811371,
0.2999146282672882,
0.1459837555885315,
0.5430437326431274,
0.4369267523288727,
0.2091035693883896,
0.23708710074424744,
0.14391295611858368,
-0.30305761098861694,
-0.2876754701137543,
0.5181254148483276,
-0.983142614364624,
-0.6890407204627991,
-0.3851834535598755,
-0.5967015027999878,
-0.03990890458226204,
0.041138000786304474,
0.152984157204628,
0.26770877838134766,
-0.7443178296089172,
0.40718430280685425,
0.7850174307823181,
-0.18260009586811066,
-0.02828182652592659,
0.37181320786476135,
-0.07328911870718002,
-0.22439727187156677,
1.009925127029419,
0.007056493312120438,
0.3101384937763214,
-0.1983993798494339,
-0.016733255237340927,
0.05454752594232559,
-0.06151323392987251,
-0.2186589539051056,
0.13169416785240173,
-0.7581793665885925,
-0.07988819479942322,
-0.6645282506942749,
-0.2780298888683319,
-0.7331903576850891,
-0.13162600994110107,
-0.32541438937187195,
-0.21355083584785461,
-0.030342640355229378,
-0.006297683343291283,
0.5096883773803711,
0.46508294343948364,
-0.5663854479789734,
-0.0026979579124599695,
-0.779621422290802,
0.26111117005348206,
0.6942679286003113,
-0.05780370905995369,
-0.25242140889167786,
-0.8951670527458191,
-0.11825133860111237,
0.4375156760215759,
-0.28241515159606934,
-0.3188999593257904,
0.5228052735328674,
0.3429805338382721,
0.333139032125473,
0.45675453543663025,
0.15467426180839539,
0.87617427110672,
-0.4722975194454193,
0.5642006993293762,
-0.2644919455051422,
-0.6941890716552734,
0.604302704334259,
-0.3880578577518463,
-0.1837848424911499,
0.4991755783557892,
0.2851675748825073,
-1.2765814065933228,
-0.49599605798721313,
-0.8086386919021606,
-0.9071066975593567,
0.36236104369163513,
0.1048445999622345,
0.41231676936149597,
-0.3562912046909332,
0.5407546758651733,
-0.2733510136604309,
0.03830883651971817,
-0.2716147005558014,
-0.06043289229273796,
-0.23146730661392212,
0.2962011396884918,
-0.11262288689613342,
-0.3730265200138092,
-0.6076923608779907,
-0.4930664300918579,
0.5571203827857971,
0.10815370082855225,
-0.12593410909175873,
0.42181405425071716,
-0.31677737832069397,
-0.16447006165981293,
0.14581896364688873,
0.6978463530540466,
0.5300849080085754,
-0.17422738671302795,
-0.11455337703227997,
0.4555276930332184,
-0.6917052268981934,
0.09654233604669571,
-0.4841303527355194,
-0.20596633851528168,
-0.28083670139312744,
0.16312167048454285,
0.4204968214035034,
0.06392639130353928,
-0.7493290901184082,
0.37638646364212036,
-0.4208216965198517,
-0.12252379953861237,
-0.7907142043113708,
0.20801684260368347,
-0.07319292426109314,
0.13814786076545715,
-0.05018707737326622,
-0.1003696396946907,
0.0918886587023735,
-0.6586514115333557,
0.5136428475379944,
0.31504783034324646,
-0.6566669940948486,
-0.0031512361019849777,
0.39401373267173767,
0.3746398091316223,
-0.540658175945282,
1.2837440967559814,
-0.1518884003162384,
-0.24076426029205322,
0.3533911406993866,
0.23945896327495575,
0.4083870053291321,
-0.11003676056861877,
0.4452575147151947,
0.5693271160125732,
0.30850929021835327,
0.06848461180925369,
0.13975182175636292,
-0.08302763849496841,
-1.1808034181594849,
-0.6014646887779236,
-0.42937955260276794,
-0.5169820189476013,
-0.16739828884601593,
-0.933061957359314,
0.1115729957818985,
-0.5401325821876526,
-0.28203293681144714,
-0.13894891738891602,
-0.15824373066425323,
-0.5304234623908997,
-0.15199114382266998,
0.011585731990635395,
0.7401055693626404,
-1.3213104009628296,
0.7445763945579529,
0.5721885561943054,
-0.6522862911224365,
-0.4522290527820587,
-0.3078862726688385,
0.20591089129447937,
-0.9465347528457642,
1.0032511949539185,
-0.33657118678092957,
-0.3877027928829193,
-0.002291932702064514,
-0.7725728750228882,
-0.4010397791862488,
0.8502492308616638,
0.044543586671352386,
-0.2878114879131317,
0.3129577338695526,
-0.03298717364668846,
0.7797365784645081,
-0.051957279443740845,
0.09261875599622726,
0.9139894247055054,
0.6841844916343689,
0.09894043207168579,
-0.9986348152160645,
-0.009011403657495975,
-0.6316149234771729,
-0.1713859587907791,
0.06429775059223175,
-0.8853806257247925,
0.5023687481880188,
-0.14981703460216522,
-0.11953292042016983,
-0.32251325249671936,
0.4856744110584259,
0.12441934645175934,
0.07414689660072327,
0.6067670583724976,
0.3903121054172516,
0.8006331324577332,
-0.34261488914489746,
0.8514078259468079,
-0.01656770147383213,
0.14861802756786346,
0.8097462058067322,
-0.09986823052167892,
0.6096204519271851,
0.5950990319252014,
0.2072930634021759,
0.48060184717178345,
0.6493079662322998,
-0.003876693081110716,
0.035734809935092926,
0.41213294863700867,
-0.28298482298851013,
-0.6042420864105225,
-0.443351686000824,
-0.06436102837324142,
0.677466869354248,
0.7045674324035645,
0.14913423359394073,
-0.022381635382771492,
0.06987448781728745,
0.0540333017706871,
0.17281371355056763,
0.06623762845993042,
0.9922899603843689,
-0.05610337480902672,
-0.5716056227684021,
0.7519034743309021,
-0.25283360481262207,
0.4330607056617737,
-0.20655471086502075,
-0.30524587631225586,
-0.48989298939704895,
0.14520548284053802,
-0.295025110244751,
-0.5832833051681519,
0.3764488995075226,
-0.1814187616109848,
-0.11002261936664581,
-0.598332941532135,
0.6413142681121826,
-0.3264768719673157,
-0.21273189783096313,
-0.20298980176448822,
0.5350447297096252,
0.5466690063476562,
0.07666736096143723,
-0.4695625901222229,
0.3059194087982178,
0.08169474452733994,
0.010506706312298775,
0.29463106393814087,
0.428272545337677,
-0.48365518450737,
0.8043926358222961,
0.7235230803489685,
-0.014056100510060787,
-0.236289381980896,
0.1681298166513443,
0.8653478026390076,
-0.3716469705104828,
-0.24024543166160583,
-0.5990852117538452,
0.48642486333847046,
-0.3806208074092865,
-0.22565887868404388,
0.743955135345459,
0.3068329691886902,
0.7955966591835022,
0.2708647549152374,
0.6357112526893616,
0.02747185528278351,
0.21510149538516998,
-0.017737234011292458,
0.6182432174682617,
-0.3896574378013611,
0.11936429888010025,
-0.08252518624067307,
-0.5883607864379883,
-0.13651791214942932,
0.8572084903717041,
-0.44711846113204956,
-0.08560146391391754,
0.08588980883359909,
0.8951791524887085,
0.07587455213069916,
-0.08190726488828659,
0.3397330641746521,
0.16123393177986145,
0.8419216871261597,
0.22242391109466553,
0.9714645743370056,
-0.4725828170776367,
0.6081114411354065,
0.1657826006412506,
-0.2792680859565735,
-0.4506405293941498,
-0.6832305192947388,
-0.6381974220275879,
-0.6737358570098877,
-0.32720327377319336,
-0.47324153780937195,
0.28156545758247375,
0.887662947177887,
0.5897589325904846,
-0.5098618865013123,
-0.10447706282138824,
0.37985891103744507,
0.2560097873210907,
-0.2815731167793274,
-0.21196185052394867,
0.18486207723617554,
-0.6400061845779419,
-0.8798620104789734,
0.3127867579460144,
0.1863473355770111,
-0.0889408141374588,
-0.21134570240974426,
-0.16934415698051453,
-0.13952083885669708,
0.23136954009532928,
0.5651996731758118,
0.6154806613922119,
-0.425080806016922,
-0.6808167099952698,
0.10324220359325409,
-0.15525370836257935,
0.1598312109708786,
0.9858683347702026,
-0.7331711053848267,
0.7184795141220093,
0.7317929267883301,
0.41385790705680847,
0.5399224162101746,
0.25564858317375183,
0.8478984236717224,
-0.9632681012153625,
0.25291937589645386,
0.22564399242401123,
0.3104788661003113,
0.294575572013855,
-0.28990358114242554,
0.4681757986545563,
0.25414028763771057,
-0.7665430903434753,
-0.8778305053710938,
0.2559807598590851,
-0.5885010957717896,
0.023837614804506302,
1.2851747274398804,
-0.02921355701982975,
-0.06381961703300476,
-0.41452306509017944,
-0.3436231017112732,
0.4272702634334564,
-0.3495129346847534,
1.2320307493209839,
0.7446890473365784,
0.01721501536667347,
-0.040794771164655685,
-0.6480597853660583,
0.7554243206977844,
0.32268962264060974,
-0.5388111472129822,
0.264144629240036,
0.7176246047019958,
0.40143153071403503,
0.20969310402870178,
0.763606071472168,
-0.3757311999797821,
0.3958035111427307,
0.02270638756453991,
0.21537639200687408,
-0.1946593075990677,
-0.2030927836894989,
-0.16676145792007446,
-0.2947719693183899,
-0.05361712723970413,
-0.15494242310523987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11177v1 | A Question Answering Based Pipeline for Comprehensive Chinese EHR Information Extraction | 2024-02-17T02:55:35 | 2024-02-17T02:55:35 | Huaiyuan Ying, Sheng Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Electronic health records (EHRs) hold significant value for research and
applications. As a new way of information extraction, question answering (QA)
can extract more flexible information than conventional methods and is more
accessible to clinical researchers, but its progress is impeded by the scarcity
of annotated data. In this paper, we propose a novel approach that
automatically generates training data for transfer learning of QA models. Our
pipeline incorporates a preprocessing module to handle challenges posed by
extraction types that are not readily compatible with extractive QA frameworks,
including cases with discontinuous answers and many-to-one relationships. The
obtained QA model exhibits excellent performance on subtasks of information
extraction in EHRs, and it can effectively handle few-shot or zero-shot
settings involving yes-no questions. Case studies and ablation studies
demonstrate the necessity of each component in our design, and the resulting
model is deemed suitable for practical use. | [
-0.06087922677397728,
-0.703163206577301,
0.7588146924972534,
-0.5674723386764526,
-0.36742448806762695,
-0.222707599401474,
0.42539897561073303,
-0.507189154624939,
0.04049846902489662,
0.6867613196372986,
-0.5935507416725159,
-0.39725860953330994,
-0.3859114646911621,
-0.06896175444126129,
-0.32220590114593506,
1.1934250593185425,
-0.08573918789625168,
0.05159059539437294,
0.040553268045186996,
-0.09634304791688919,
-0.38838231563568115,
-0.548384428024292,
-0.5833542346954346,
-0.1858501434326172,
0.4123179614543915,
0.4465329051017761,
0.3162972033023834,
0.8768303990364075,
0.6147500276565552,
0.1400018036365509,
0.16582399606704712,
-0.0010157078504562378,
-0.1255759447813034,
0.12077416479587555,
0.05098339170217514,
-0.4978981018066406,
-0.5903531312942505,
-0.5357832908630371,
0.34137076139450073,
0.3285035490989685,
-0.3893516957759857,
0.7479441165924072,
-0.2459060400724411,
0.495836466550827,
-0.5951570868492126,
0.06059077009558678,
-0.8702868819236755,
0.17852436006069183,
-0.12804120779037476,
-0.3736690282821655,
-0.3897213637828827,
-0.4562794864177704,
0.5781255960464478,
-0.6133086085319519,
0.1384260356426239,
-0.2518642246723175,
1.1152801513671875,
0.20105434954166412,
-0.3550579845905304,
-0.16711293160915375,
-0.7362619638442993,
0.4681535065174103,
-0.6870993375778198,
0.232987180352211,
0.15202981233596802,
0.6452553272247314,
0.41341736912727356,
-0.976507842540741,
-0.46246179938316345,
0.5112656354904175,
-0.03801983967423439,
0.18520298600196838,
0.062581367790699,
0.04343745484948158,
0.18260744214057922,
0.23457486927509308,
-0.6319776177406311,
-0.18803660571575165,
-0.745072603225708,
0.07185658812522888,
0.5354239344596863,
0.329131543636322,
0.4921461343765259,
-0.45410552620887756,
-0.36173754930496216,
-0.0667477697134018,
-0.461581826210022,
0.3558095693588257,
-0.508194088935852,
0.16898702085018158,
-0.09448722004890442,
0.3848813474178314,
-0.21353834867477417,
0.40232759714126587,
0.2263561189174652,
-0.07844763249158859,
0.3826553523540497,
-0.13206039369106293,
-0.34200096130371094,
0.07892333716154099,
0.5539349317550659,
-0.021358950063586235,
-0.061078257858753204,
-0.29079991579055786,
-0.1568792462348938,
-0.4731297791004181,
0.27818363904953003,
-0.9102391600608826,
-0.5470232367515564,
0.85624760389328,
-0.5402442812919617,
-0.17168204486370087,
0.37730664014816284,
-0.8648779988288879,
-0.15203538537025452,
-0.21005454659461975,
0.5407128930091858,
-0.29786747694015503,
-0.23312252759933472,
0.121546670794487,
-0.12268301099538803,
0.6897431015968323,
0.18439269065856934,
-0.8036937713623047,
0.16085709631443024,
0.5172547101974487,
0.6292317509651184,
-0.2572442591190338,
0.14716413617134094,
-1.056564211845398,
0.05597146600484848,
-0.102251335978508,
0.6594343781471252,
-0.2710798978805542,
-0.07335753738880157,
0.16240936517715454,
0.242060124874115,
-0.17422524094581604,
-0.6493138670921326,
0.21823912858963013,
-0.8814615607261658,
0.3454325795173645,
-0.04018707945942879,
-0.5394697785377502,
-0.15072213113307953,
0.3673555552959442,
-0.7201983332633972,
0.635849118232727,
0.2350953221321106,
-0.8498696684837341,
0.12610077857971191,
-0.6211693286895752,
-0.2412155717611313,
0.44549301266670227,
-0.12103331089019775,
-0.6458314657211304,
-0.3522486686706543,
0.4713894724845886,
0.3952951729297638,
-0.2711274325847626,
0.26569482684135437,
-0.08599477261304855,
-0.08817828446626663,
0.1671939492225647,
0.08110694587230682,
0.9102398157119751,
0.4708186686038971,
-0.03651649132370949,
0.14476890861988068,
-0.7602867484092712,
0.3949104845523834,
0.13011875748634338,
-0.31036561727523804,
-0.11339902877807617,
-0.3564094305038452,
-0.12830723822116852,
0.6041218638420105,
0.3176819980144501,
-0.5953342914581299,
0.02766198292374611,
-0.2713243365287781,
0.3702639937400818,
0.3662845194339752,
0.5447940826416016,
0.054233670234680176,
-0.6368734836578369,
0.8252761363983154,
0.1619822084903717,
0.32914814352989197,
-0.4248421788215637,
-0.2264646589756012,
-0.7376270294189453,
-0.15272156894207,
0.35814517736434937,
0.8827403783798218,
-0.9965547919273376,
0.4546903967857361,
-0.4424484372138977,
-0.5091316103935242,
-0.956452488899231,
0.07827656716108322,
0.05958959832787514,
0.9417092800140381,
0.7066674828529358,
-0.31884151697158813,
-0.4254060387611389,
-0.5735455751419067,
0.17165504395961761,
-0.4519219398498535,
-0.44337087869644165,
0.01843271590769291,
0.1534879058599472,
0.18819475173950195,
0.8311190009117126,
-0.5194005966186523,
-0.22576363384723663,
-0.5451682806015015,
0.12087900936603546,
0.2113562375307083,
0.251219242811203,
0.045130591839551926,
-0.9026642441749573,
-0.3056076765060425,
0.34466442465782166,
-1.0919346809387207,
0.0341394804418087,
-0.4149920642375946,
-0.22451584041118622,
-0.5341910123825073,
0.13846148550510406,
-0.5084881782531738,
0.26107627153396606,
0.17048314213752747,
0.14002612233161926,
0.44377368688583374,
0.03929122909903526,
0.09397586435079575,
-1.1881577968597412,
0.5304733514785767,
0.0016522682271897793,
-0.20894929766654968,
-0.9069089889526367,
0.17850875854492188,
0.2544651925563812,
-0.1637878715991974,
-0.981306791305542,
0.4606344997882843,
-0.247823104262352,
0.2150893360376358,
-0.036854151636362076,
0.00022137623454909772,
0.42908284068107605,
0.4712912142276764,
0.22553065419197083,
0.23205266892910004,
0.49856022000312805,
-0.674320638179779,
0.4244121313095093,
0.8464593887329102,
0.17791223526000977,
0.36354345083236694,
-0.7273427248001099,
0.49965551495552063,
-0.41928669810295105,
-0.011885290034115314,
-0.5032111406326294,
-0.1880640685558319,
0.47620508074760437,
-0.2834469974040985,
0.19392672181129456,
-0.564574122428894,
0.004493770655244589,
-0.3107464909553528,
-0.2104462832212448,
0.22436659038066864,
0.7941893339157104,
-0.41132089495658875,
0.6482681035995483,
0.47433364391326904,
-0.5787070989608765,
-0.35479605197906494,
-0.5028136372566223,
-0.41606423258781433,
-0.3852165639400482,
-0.43595436215400696,
0.24045871198177338,
0.07052341103553772,
0.000004630249350157101,
0.11351028829813004,
0.05152704939246178,
-0.7775932550430298,
-0.007119222544133663,
-0.08621074259281158,
0.7545590996742249,
-0.4738558232784271,
0.3783361613750458,
0.08400285989046097,
0.14990021288394928,
0.26439177989959717,
-0.1939808428287506,
0.08705286681652069,
0.27394264936447144,
-0.39790281653404236,
-0.771949052810669,
0.3253060579299927,
0.41623827815055847,
-0.7100831270217896,
0.47584211826324463,
0.3204153776168823,
-0.6361818909645081,
-0.10411552339792252,
-0.3642336428165436,
-0.3019416928291321,
-0.39805105328559875,
0.5580569505691528,
-0.20507940649986267,
-0.490238219499588,
0.4492322504520416,
0.0007059270283207297,
0.5590270161628723,
0.3901475667953491,
0.30523908138275146,
0.09741275757551193,
0.7979710698127747,
0.5329274535179138,
0.024697959423065186,
0.3472735583782196,
-0.134422168135643,
-0.12663286924362183,
-0.7514508962631226,
-0.3169212341308594,
-0.462860107421875,
0.2714483141899109,
-0.31201082468032837,
-0.08884194493293762,
0.5833211541175842,
-0.12532728910446167,
-0.28212326765060425,
0.11415281891822815,
-0.44426125288009644,
0.17887140810489655,
0.08843033015727997,
0.44108009338378906,
0.2998009920120239,
-0.2674231231212616,
0.42034095525741577,
0.16976973414421082,
-0.7263988256454468,
-0.5266072750091553,
1.1516783237457275,
0.5340059399604797,
0.2785654067993164,
-0.05552046000957489,
0.6468708515167236,
-0.0022009359672665596,
0.3681810200214386,
-0.5281940698623657,
0.038429953157901764,
-0.13816912472248077,
-0.5576552748680115,
-0.5875918865203857,
-0.4286254644393921,
-0.8734890818595886,
0.209550678730011,
-0.390593558549881,
-0.615719199180603,
0.0887448638677597,
0.06682492792606354,
-0.8369427919387817,
0.5152280926704407,
-0.4229500889778137,
0.9644656777381897,
-0.28387635946273804,
-0.1888902187347412,
0.5384489297866821,
-1.0407003164291382,
0.2663487493991852,
-0.32871299982070923,
0.2024441659450531,
-0.03227970376610756,
0.4276891350746155,
0.7319221496582031,
-0.3185287117958069,
0.3578100800514221,
-0.19067725539207458,
0.17671766877174377,
0.6504594087600708,
-0.026038385927677155,
0.4681724011898041,
-0.14251713454723358,
-0.26228067278862,
-0.09096831828355789,
0.5688257217407227,
-0.4430456757545471,
-0.5730531811714172,
-0.053620658814907074,
-0.4975000023841858,
-0.37172481417655945,
-0.09761479496955872,
-0.2523963153362274,
-0.2656727731227875,
0.3308143615722656,
0.21172039210796356,
0.32047393918037415,
0.015157030895352364,
-0.07067353278398514,
0.7974337935447693,
-0.2711567282676697,
-0.1229286715388298,
0.3794955611228943,
-0.014812345616519451,
-0.09856729209423065,
0.8424306511878967,
0.10067420452833176,
0.2521531879901886,
0.4921526312828064,
0.1859843134880066,
-0.3736744523048401,
-0.6644469499588013,
-0.7840926647186279,
0.29466626048088074,
-0.682630181312561,
-0.06948059052228928,
-0.727034866809845,
-0.8051052093505859,
-0.3959886133670807,
0.3574613034725189,
-0.14450858533382416,
0.025953613221645355,
-0.626910924911499,
-0.3247033357620239,
0.11412037163972855,
0.5326489806175232,
0.42677509784698486,
0.10291235148906708,
-1.553949236869812,
0.49003222584724426,
0.5594492554664612,
-0.09156633913516998,
-0.018395641818642616,
-0.7872437238693237,
-0.3138390779495239,
-0.1283581405878067,
-0.4797072112560272,
-0.9760042428970337,
0.5848115682601929,
0.205801323056221,
0.43601351976394653,
0.48793476819992065,
0.4906737506389618,
0.6863807439804077,
-0.4295005202293396,
0.8166700005531311,
0.09590360522270203,
-0.6215305924415588,
0.5345277786254883,
-0.15633511543273926,
0.09034542739391327,
0.7864418625831604,
0.4808064103126526,
-0.5426874756813049,
-0.03453031927347183,
-0.6431177854537964,
-0.7873831987380981,
0.5036720037460327,
-0.2409203052520752,
0.02480921894311905,
0.14697182178497314,
0.6785250306129456,
0.4096994400024414,
0.10866089165210724,
-0.6185735464096069,
-0.2195420116186142,
-0.07736443728208542,
-0.37022435665130615,
0.5641945004463196,
0.040937043726444244,
0.09680676460266113,
0.07164177298545837,
0.6276092529296875,
-0.15438590943813324,
-0.06613114476203918,
0.5818037390708923,
-0.15260513126850128,
-0.3473290205001831,
0.6052860021591187,
-0.302310585975647,
0.75948166847229,
-0.2943193018436432,
0.1210784986615181,
0.25799667835235596,
-0.24246850609779358,
0.05709515139460564,
0.152886301279068,
-0.3044586181640625,
-0.058099959045648575,
0.12301679700613022,
0.6339687705039978,
-0.5410165190696716,
-0.8078229427337646,
0.6270068883895874,
-0.11242517083883286,
-0.20118501782417297,
-0.36342138051986694,
-0.024609996005892754,
-0.12019181996583939,
0.1004067212343216,
0.4450191259384155,
-0.46675607562065125,
0.4181879758834839,
-0.33200934529304504,
0.7607547044754028,
0.1480862945318222,
-0.699144721031189,
-0.4352264702320099,
0.8482453227043152,
0.01044166088104248,
-0.1334056705236435,
0.8334565758705139,
0.23091553151607513,
-0.3753218948841095,
0.5551450252532959,
0.26257121562957764,
0.7568868398666382,
-0.2580922544002533,
0.3576541244983673,
0.5307304859161377,
-0.06006564199924469,
0.10355138778686523,
0.22641651332378387,
0.17679737508296967,
-0.4799594283103943,
-0.376686692237854,
-0.2780066430568695,
-0.616493284702301,
0.33919042348861694,
-1.1015042066574097,
0.5149421095848083,
-0.33288484811782837,
0.20412006974220276,
-0.06257923692464828,
-0.2727869153022766,
-0.8619683980941772,
0.4679865539073944,
0.24662178754806519,
0.5771249532699585,
-0.9176097512245178,
0.8568624258041382,
0.5523218512535095,
-0.5901729464530945,
-1.08233642578125,
-0.10322053730487823,
-0.2541693449020386,
-0.6459460854530334,
0.32029008865356445,
0.08539678156375885,
0.45911794900894165,
-0.01862582378089428,
-0.28733304142951965,
-0.5841268301010132,
1.1882164478302002,
0.4842478632926941,
-0.3715716600418091,
-0.34010806679725647,
0.23497556149959564,
0.6236197352409363,
-0.26422029733657837,
0.3783807158470154,
0.5371555089950562,
0.050614651292562485,
0.24771109223365784,
-0.8435801267623901,
0.21322697401046753,
-0.38385245203971863,
-0.5786178112030029,
-0.06512146443128586,
-0.509571373462677,
0.8293556571006775,
-0.200662761926651,
-0.5329121351242065,
0.012510538101196289,
0.5043426752090454,
0.2750108540058136,
0.412706196308136,
0.3115260899066925,
0.17154279351234436,
0.8608503937721252,
0.3774738311767578,
0.8992800116539001,
-0.19735290110111237,
0.15803752839565277,
1.0116655826568604,
-0.45428258180618286,
0.9554222822189331,
0.49017927050590515,
-0.13018782436847687,
0.5471603274345398,
0.6699562668800354,
0.19864413142204285,
0.42111748456954956,
0.11593704670667648,
-0.08230052888393402,
-0.33153235912323,
-0.2474985271692276,
-0.4223594665527344,
0.19008506834506989,
0.08991202712059021,
-0.39750969409942627,
-0.1659046858549118,
-0.3160387873649597,
-0.19580142199993134,
-0.3310777246952057,
-0.09953095018863678,
1.1531685590744019,
0.15989534556865692,
-0.6530939340591431,
0.3750656843185425,
-0.24000731110572815,
0.15638010203838348,
-0.7722896933555603,
-0.4860565960407257,
0.016160231083631516,
-0.4277914762496948,
-0.40822675824165344,
-0.48445552587509155,
0.24112747609615326,
0.02618519216775894,
0.1086929515004158,
0.049321249127388,
0.5886428356170654,
-0.5442960858345032,
-0.24599090218544006,
-0.151370108127594,
0.953039288520813,
0.40829959511756897,
0.07623626291751862,
-0.6598829030990601,
-0.5979085564613342,
0.10040182620286942,
-0.10052716732025146,
0.2965056300163269,
0.7189232110977173,
0.16550901532173157,
0.5537887215614319,
0.747682511806488,
0.630280077457428,
0.22605784237384796,
-0.18812547624111176,
0.7401642203330994,
-0.565193235874176,
-0.7276498079299927,
-0.5836194157600403,
0.754108726978302,
0.08356571942567825,
-0.31568750739097595,
0.2020329087972641,
0.31416451930999756,
0.5057798027992249,
0.004200408700853586,
1.1650872230529785,
0.19680921733379364,
0.8862569332122803,
-0.5602397322654724,
0.6213724613189697,
-0.36858975887298584,
0.3120535612106323,
-0.06977502256631851,
-0.5045233964920044,
-0.20508410036563873,
0.26033449172973633,
-0.22806231677532196,
-0.42882946133613586,
0.4997591972351074,
0.2513512670993805,
0.08463111519813538,
-0.012282511219382286,
0.379832923412323,
-0.12591587007045746,
0.6299119591712952,
0.9030144214630127,
0.5941115021705627,
-0.706725001335144,
0.6520620584487915,
-0.35451188683509827,
-0.0763857513666153,
0.08347751200199127,
-0.6270396113395691,
-0.5300748348236084,
-0.4775744080543518,
-0.5140114426612854,
-0.2157064527273178,
-0.015031963586807251,
0.9546407461166382,
0.8843689560890198,
-0.9833875298500061,
0.16062131524085999,
0.2364174723625183,
-0.07702811062335968,
-0.18528297543525696,
-0.21240942180156708,
0.7806555032730103,
-0.1551542431116104,
-0.3390974998474121,
-0.04503845423460007,
-0.06335268914699554,
-0.027505118399858475,
0.06881830096244812,
0.16546867787837982,
-0.004650129470974207,
-0.0992092415690422,
0.1559985727071762,
0.7176252603530884,
-0.2126680165529251,
-0.34937286376953125,
0.30552399158477783,
0.09045517444610596,
0.5859092473983765,
0.5010461211204529,
-0.6201048493385315,
0.5998315811157227,
0.4375109374523163,
1.2100249528884888,
0.42118486762046814,
0.5259128212928772,
0.27329111099243164,
-0.5792306661605835,
-0.257290780544281,
0.36399441957473755,
0.10740523785352707,
0.4095102548599243,
-0.6225225925445557,
0.15609103441238403,
-0.07741785794496536,
-0.4850558638572693,
-0.5438824892044067,
0.03228466957807541,
-0.7736477255821228,
-0.08319981396198273,
0.9593473672866821,
-0.44081562757492065,
-0.3129133880138397,
-0.6089178919792175,
-0.17243149876594543,
0.5480673313140869,
-0.1512996107339859,
0.8540688753128052,
0.23565834760665894,
-0.37784239649772644,
-0.40541139245033264,
-0.5846970677375793,
0.2574588358402252,
0.2686662971973419,
-1.3242579698562622,
0.09923727810382843,
0.2886974811553955,
0.5093640685081482,
-0.07209550589323044,
0.7837460041046143,
-0.4841494858264923,
0.5547579526901245,
-0.507193922996521,
0.25440388917922974,
0.07066024094820023,
-0.24144496023654938,
-0.5790077447891235,
0.5313752889633179,
0.2940030097961426,
-0.5729990005493164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11176v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11176v2 | KnowTuning: Knowledge-aware Fine-tuning for Large Language Models | 2024-02-17T02:54:32 | 2024-04-17T11:45:00 | Yougang Lyu, Lingyong Yan, Shuaiqiang Wang, Haibo Shi, Dawei Yin, Pengjie Ren, Zhumin Chen, Maarten de Rijke, Zhaochun Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite their success at many natural language processing (NLP) tasks, large
language models still struggle to effectively leverage knowledge for
knowledge-intensive tasks, manifesting limitations such as generating
incomplete, non-factual, or illogical answers. These limitations stem from
inadequate knowledge awareness of LLMs during vanilla fine-tuning. To address
these problems, we propose a knowledge-aware fine-tuning (KnowTuning) method to
improve fine-grained and coarse-grained knowledge awareness of LLMs. We devise
a fine-grained knowledge augmentation stage to train LLMs to identify difficult
fine-grained knowledge in answers. We also propose a coarse-grained knowledge
comparison stage to train LLMs to distinguish between reliable and unreliable
knowledge, in three aspects: completeness, factuality, and logicality.
Extensive experiments on both generic and medical question answering (QA)
datasets confirm the effectiveness of KnowTuning, through automatic and human
evaluations, across various sizes of LLMs. We further verify that KnowTuning
generates more facts with less factual error rate under fine-grained facts
evaluation. | [
-0.3540433347225189,
-0.9930705428123474,
0.7463394403457642,
-0.1162789985537529,
-0.03420534357428551,
-0.019780565053224564,
-0.45381057262420654,
-0.5818190574645996,
-0.14519600570201874,
0.3459794223308563,
-0.47002410888671875,
-0.4318905770778656,
-0.42165255546569824,
-0.028775963932275772,
-0.16647741198539734,
1.0266083478927612,
0.11655400693416595,
0.19814306497573853,
-0.5592567324638367,
-0.05691474676132202,
-0.5113910436630249,
-0.07789791375398636,
-0.9457739591598511,
-0.5021748542785645,
0.5085009932518005,
0.6176105737686157,
0.6659441590309143,
0.7975193858146667,
0.5054560899734497,
0.24178454279899597,
-0.31773608922958374,
0.6113355755805969,
-0.5738653540611267,
0.14990408718585968,
-0.4253638684749603,
-0.7218670845031738,
-0.4563333988189697,
-0.3299684226512909,
0.19206303358078003,
0.6453661322593689,
0.0016193547053262591,
0.24763090908527374,
0.14584535360336304,
0.7121138572692871,
-0.5258709192276001,
0.15617337822914124,
-0.9431285858154297,
-0.04910070821642876,
-0.06009857729077339,
-0.2686269283294678,
0.1416897177696228,
-0.48664507269859314,
0.20248796045780182,
-0.6661130785942078,
0.36321723461151123,
0.11072175204753876,
0.7331879138946533,
0.6503418684005737,
-0.13054220378398895,
-0.24439911544322968,
-0.6490147709846497,
0.6185410618782043,
-0.9287095665931702,
0.35403451323509216,
0.6397914886474609,
0.2629832923412323,
-0.13414360582828522,
-0.5977416038513184,
-0.575589120388031,
0.0273404773324728,
-0.07851517200469971,
-0.10257471352815628,
0.002340903040021658,
0.27904683351516724,
0.3788626790046692,
0.5716042518615723,
-0.3755273222923279,
0.24664509296417236,
-0.19247543811798096,
-0.38604292273521423,
0.31733986735343933,
0.0065056257881224155,
0.16410121321678162,
-0.06971763074398041,
-0.23337450623512268,
0.25337716937065125,
-0.5751361846923828,
0.07184697687625885,
-0.1775604486465454,
0.12952525913715363,
0.09583156555891037,
0.6061168313026428,
-0.7237765789031982,
0.9406211972236633,
0.2017465978860855,
-0.34364452958106995,
0.047991350293159485,
-0.3828200697898865,
-0.3471870720386505,
0.02407495677471161,
0.43819352984428406,
0.5511462688446045,
0.4118328392505646,
-0.309781938791275,
-0.3068515658378601,
-0.17222477495670319,
0.1596502810716629,
-0.6746522188186646,
-0.1568991243839264,
0.3244720697402954,
0.004309255164116621,
-0.40739017724990845,
-0.3797166049480438,
-0.435234934091568,
-0.7337820529937744,
-0.5733352303504944,
0.786668062210083,
-0.7225468158721924,
-0.07396627217531204,
0.32397371530532837,
-0.10944311320781708,
0.3332836329936981,
0.3942137062549591,
-0.8782086968421936,
0.14752039313316345,
0.7170596122741699,
0.5533767938613892,
0.18225590884685516,
-0.1337445229291916,
-0.675206184387207,
0.1878463476896286,
-0.22190995514392853,
0.8679635524749756,
-0.3396669328212738,
0.19661203026771545,
-0.20518584549427032,
-0.2190614938735962,
0.09729371964931488,
-0.7425658702850342,
0.6151626110076904,
-0.5997329354286194,
-0.11169510334730148,
-0.511574387550354,
-0.9294448494911194,
-0.16462595760822296,
0.7248335480690002,
-0.3066759705543518,
0.9549922347068787,
0.18985335528850555,
-0.8148655295372009,
0.5083280801773071,
-0.4581652283668518,
-0.48883119225502014,
0.03386913985013962,
-0.15150222182273865,
-0.36562126874923706,
0.1687212735414505,
0.4443713128566742,
0.7304641008377075,
-0.26390495896339417,
0.41767799854278564,
-0.39700281620025635,
-0.05175112932920456,
0.04305429756641388,
-0.3496266007423401,
0.242158904671669,
0.20276248455047607,
-0.1166360080242157,
0.16426515579223633,
-0.9800735116004944,
0.3372245728969574,
-0.06793186813592911,
-0.42630186676979065,
-0.4479910731315613,
-0.10492335259914398,
-0.5107940435409546,
0.12899820506572723,
0.4606294631958008,
-0.5693719983100891,
0.05049385502934456,
-0.7457285523414612,
0.3476389944553375,
0.5926111340522766,
0.11352097988128662,
0.39926081895828247,
-0.8305550813674927,
0.1784130036830902,
0.18603329360485077,
0.15534530580043793,
0.07737318426370621,
-0.24471266567707062,
-1.0900225639343262,
0.223287433385849,
0.2236560881137848,
0.6316365003585815,
-0.8769468069076538,
0.36585280299186707,
-0.16378113627433777,
-0.5798353552818298,
-0.5821940898895264,
0.4576839208602905,
0.48052889108657837,
0.8958815336227417,
0.5664787888526917,
0.09370332956314087,
-0.5780530571937561,
-0.8792888522148132,
-0.5305834412574768,
0.059822410345077515,
-0.05736861005425453,
0.26602229475975037,
0.213159441947937,
-0.16282881796360016,
0.9126471281051636,
-0.5448789000511169,
-0.5222671627998352,
-0.005285445600748062,
-0.021433888003230095,
0.013289025984704494,
0.4603565037250519,
0.13171084225177765,
-0.567084789276123,
-0.1616697758436203,
0.31731390953063965,
-0.6325937509536743,
0.021359259262681007,
0.025216445326805115,
0.0939222201704979,
-0.014393366873264313,
0.7758362293243408,
-0.5079289674758911,
0.013708270154893398,
0.3886420428752899,
-0.1855359673500061,
0.5729120373725891,
-0.45789751410484314,
0.028555328026413918,
-1.0823721885681152,
-0.1081925481557846,
-0.1563737839460373,
-0.5533422827720642,
-0.5358033776283264,
-0.06944075226783752,
0.15662653744220734,
0.23334649205207825,
-0.29869240522384644,
0.6247483491897583,
-0.3517216742038727,
0.20124635100364685,
-0.12358680367469788,
0.24373918771743774,
0.06870846450328827,
0.3743230998516083,
-0.04911242797970772,
0.7852880358695984,
0.5736457109451294,
-0.9103872776031494,
0.4070253074169159,
0.13737046718597412,
-0.5788979530334473,
0.6844874620437622,
-0.5150412917137146,
0.04796324670314789,
-0.11881823092699051,
-0.4368779957294464,
-0.6607628464698792,
-0.45020487904548645,
-0.11319354921579361,
-0.3511015474796295,
0.3168416917324066,
-0.22152182459831238,
-0.38416436314582825,
-0.2662036120891571,
0.01640344224870205,
0.31424248218536377,
0.356054425239563,
-0.36889195442199707,
0.6368139982223511,
0.3104785680770874,
-0.19669465720653534,
-0.4498911201953888,
-0.45042431354522705,
-0.2179456204175949,
-0.11265001446008682,
-0.5995924472808838,
-0.03306884318590164,
-0.009907214902341366,
-0.17588649690151215,
-0.1054995134472847,
-0.41932234168052673,
-0.2281797081232071,
0.2139323502779007,
-0.10207561403512955,
-0.28336596488952637,
-0.15222695469856262,
0.6098988056182861,
0.20584224164485931,
-0.03940068557858467,
0.037489064037799835,
-0.4942344129085541,
0.5067471861839294,
-0.23741039633750916,
-0.35291606187820435,
-0.18472829461097717,
-0.23178264498710632,
0.5081508159637451,
-0.3620262145996094,
0.5673096776008606,
0.8197766542434692,
-0.5228156447410583,
-0.2357034534215927,
-0.9672728180885315,
-0.38562026619911194,
-0.44956907629966736,
0.4760853350162506,
-0.2933500409126282,
-1.1739436388015747,
0.5666353106498718,
-0.29497385025024414,
0.011344715021550655,
0.39804285764694214,
0.3873398005962372,
-0.22028948366641998,
0.7706087827682495,
0.6023303866386414,
0.06989365816116333,
0.19517113268375397,
-0.002639399142935872,
-0.12466250360012054,
-0.7173786759376526,
-0.16854454576969147,
-0.43739306926727295,
-0.3359484076499939,
-0.3475438058376312,
-0.6131601333618164,
0.5112813711166382,
0.23664836585521698,
-0.32388925552368164,
-0.09963285177946091,
-0.25115084648132324,
0.7147391438484192,
0.5398917198181152,
0.43204331398010254,
0.6059299111366272,
-0.20131632685661316,
-0.11829306930303574,
0.15137532353401184,
-0.9061374664306641,
-0.2594093680381775,
0.9915216565132141,
0.24668003618717194,
0.8429312705993652,
-0.15482987463474274,
0.3533515930175781,
-0.07740399241447449,
-0.006423342972993851,
-0.9081161022186279,
0.37626543641090393,
-0.1262574940919876,
-0.6004765033721924,
-0.4925863742828369,
-0.5686427354812622,
-0.5747683048248291,
-0.30364590883255005,
-0.5444039702415466,
-0.3718002438545227,
-0.08682505041360855,
0.473042756319046,
-0.7971222400665283,
0.45942145586013794,
-0.8473048806190491,
0.7811484932899475,
-0.23059192299842834,
-0.16026447713375092,
-0.1969372183084488,
-0.6398357152938843,
0.3499036133289337,
-0.17607277631759644,
0.2418745756149292,
-0.1342240869998932,
0.11679767817258835,
0.6682292222976685,
-0.2908681631088257,
0.9364392757415771,
-0.1084727793931961,
-0.3012661933898926,
0.009712053462862968,
0.09690837562084198,
0.6168633103370667,
0.3294585049152374,
-0.023167552426457405,
-0.18739038705825806,
0.27820703387260437,
-0.2459142655134201,
-0.681170642375946,
0.7364437580108643,
-0.5780178308486938,
-0.6557422280311584,
0.05364516004920006,
-0.7244946956634521,
-0.7885873913764954,
0.46360933780670166,
0.22285495698451996,
0.42590993642807007,
-0.1513759195804596,
0.19060298800468445,
1.322147250175476,
-0.14044152200222015,
-0.007570368703454733,
0.6499962210655212,
-0.27042531967163086,
-0.2472708523273468,
0.8166274428367615,
0.11572715640068054,
0.40360355377197266,
0.6127525568008423,
0.35431087017059326,
-0.15581215918064117,
-0.7800787091255188,
-0.2496097832918167,
0.20821158587932587,
-0.5722949504852295,
-0.5560363531112671,
-0.5694441199302673,
-0.44887489080429077,
-0.38742297887802124,
0.10810285806655884,
-0.4596515893936157,
-0.4319932460784912,
-0.29061615467071533,
-0.1441442370414734,
0.682072103023529,
0.6665311455726624,
0.04190610349178314,
0.3200220763683319,
-0.8896652460098267,
0.5896866321563721,
0.8383088111877441,
0.9035785794258118,
-0.10883859544992447,
-0.6061695218086243,
-0.4940083920955658,
0.3000854253768921,
-0.10480516403913498,
-0.3153298795223236,
-0.06670471280813217,
0.4630337655544281,
0.2851026654243469,
0.5417389273643494,
0.18847541511058807,
0.7855697870254517,
-0.4581763446331024,
0.34202471375465393,
-0.14636388421058655,
-0.6871344447135925,
0.6397774815559387,
-0.49934303760528564,
0.5627559423446655,
0.7717695236206055,
0.06651864945888519,
-0.6082863807678223,
-0.676101803779602,
-0.49553385376930237,
-0.5713548064231873,
0.5149275660514832,
-0.06463213264942169,
0.013451171107590199,
0.05248367786407471,
0.5666354298591614,
0.10908529907464981,
0.23187531530857086,
-0.4767540991306305,
-0.10062344372272491,
0.21327261626720428,
-0.2639622688293457,
-0.04130566120147705,
-0.41011133790016174,
-0.24544468522071838,
-0.35155659914016724,
0.7699334025382996,
-0.295769602060318,
-0.11948902904987335,
0.4477057158946991,
-0.255158394575119,
-0.19648441672325134,
0.5252755880355835,
0.5632208585739136,
0.7620112299919128,
-0.19062596559524536,
0.34372058510780334,
0.5658502578735352,
-0.4377414286136627,
-0.17653776705265045,
0.1125713437795639,
-0.3031294643878937,
-0.37829872965812683,
0.31999969482421875,
0.7859625816345215,
0.33022093772888184,
-0.6119346022605896,
0.3673851490020752,
-0.08024311810731888,
-0.1524345427751541,
-0.2716362178325653,
0.4992895722389221,
0.30958446860313416,
0.34227117896080017,
0.03408712148666382,
0.4548400938510895,
0.016736751422286034,
-0.26330459117889404,
0.22311347723007202,
0.5499612092971802,
-0.6566829681396484,
-0.0342043973505497,
0.5590048432350159,
0.10428039729595184,
-0.06074807047843933,
0.2810044288635254,
-0.1898779571056366,
-0.3273371756076813,
0.3768240809440613,
0.3682096600532532,
0.426566481590271,
-0.09763199836015701,
-0.05434510484337807,
0.2810521423816681,
0.3610914945602417,
-0.2927659749984741,
0.3902483582496643,
0.09328851848840714,
-0.9736508727073669,
-0.7022090554237366,
-0.7982938289642334,
-0.15373830497264862,
0.3532240390777588,
-0.58747398853302,
0.30354374647140503,
-0.5156346559524536,
-0.17137254774570465,
0.015809858217835426,
-0.026437193155288696,
-0.8406732082366943,
0.4952054023742676,
-0.11153919994831085,
1.048126459121704,
-0.6056137681007385,
0.7121782302856445,
0.7921391725540161,
-0.15680751204490662,
-1.115110993385315,
-0.0921730101108551,
-0.22241127490997314,
-0.9638553261756897,
0.3061144948005676,
0.014380032196640968,
-0.012891648337244987,
0.4226139783859253,
-0.5715559720993042,
-0.7473182082176208,
1.046966552734375,
0.41081702709198,
-0.7902454137802124,
-0.12717598676681519,
0.14903749525547028,
0.5331280827522278,
0.03914152830839157,
0.04127808287739754,
0.8250135779380798,
0.5151882767677307,
0.021004877984523773,
-1.1880966424942017,
-0.09559492021799088,
0.058078598231077194,
-0.29293084144592285,
0.15777838230133057,
-0.47195976972579956,
0.36292269825935364,
-0.40602707862854004,
-0.036794353276491165,
0.0034594035241752863,
0.5639865398406982,
0.00214463216252625,
0.42522796988487244,
0.5267255306243896,
0.9610479474067688,
1.2072447538375854,
-0.2254837304353714,
0.7950934767723083,
-0.3157888352870941,
0.2064393013715744,
1.355581283569336,
0.13466279208660126,
0.6295921206474304,
0.40669411420822144,
-0.057128287851810455,
0.09806743264198303,
0.3473203778266907,
0.2930103540420532,
0.1503191590309143,
0.14444373548030853,
-0.3153868615627289,
-0.6582247018814087,
-0.04774201661348343,
-0.32110998034477234,
0.48877641558647156,
0.3219045400619507,
-0.1314130574464798,
-0.3410905599594116,
0.18838123977184296,
0.19070349633693695,
0.13943152129650116,
-0.6795271635055542,
1.2569020986557007,
0.12241866439580917,
-0.6820759773254395,
0.7882645726203918,
-0.11873462051153183,
0.5919300317764282,
-0.6844372153282166,
0.09603507816791534,
-0.22076654434204102,
0.18717937171459198,
-0.32034504413604736,
-0.9434756636619568,
0.24781803786754608,
-0.041672416031360626,
-0.5195344686508179,
0.043707143515348434,
0.9611758589744568,
-0.6781089901924133,
-0.399566113948822,
-0.04346609488129616,
0.702471137046814,
-0.058412548154592514,
-0.3407330811023712,
-0.4335932731628418,
-0.4157356321811676,
0.06044791266322136,
0.00002306157875864301,
0.2656953036785126,
0.8659311532974243,
0.04028655216097832,
1.0679959058761597,
0.5727432370185852,
0.3601428270339966,
0.009421870112419128,
0.19061224162578583,
0.920589029788971,
-0.5676229000091553,
-0.21173207461833954,
-0.8063206076622009,
0.21233560144901276,
-0.05293438211083412,
-0.16883526742458344,
0.6187581419944763,
0.5405226349830627,
0.9127383828163147,
-0.19825753569602966,
0.7765291333198547,
0.06250672787427902,
0.8500297665596008,
-0.8198449015617371,
0.96047443151474,
-0.40357130765914917,
0.3667428493499756,
0.002229120582342148,
-0.6436312794685364,
-0.4160918891429901,
0.3360326290130615,
-0.4696643650531769,
0.04447869583964348,
0.538437008857727,
0.8125378489494324,
-0.13572892546653748,
-0.03630145639181137,
0.5435655117034912,
0.6471280455589294,
0.09608912467956543,
0.5282974243164062,
0.5978959202766418,
-0.23717737197875977,
0.598247230052948,
-0.3990369141101837,
-0.11720822751522064,
0.006369176786392927,
-0.8722729086875916,
-0.8663769960403442,
-0.4517439305782318,
-0.1446305513381958,
-0.20861250162124634,
-0.02121482603251934,
0.8004197478294373,
0.6407186388969421,
-0.7809683084487915,
0.23926810920238495,
-0.24353960156440735,
0.3703050911426544,
-0.2059975117444992,
-0.20366977155208588,
0.23048144578933716,
-0.915478527545929,
-0.3155266344547272,
0.20277759432792664,
0.15999069809913635,
0.06486930698156357,
-0.04596102610230446,
0.158850759267807,
-0.06766422837972641,
-0.06463085860013962,
0.6016815304756165,
0.22872789204120636,
-0.4121379554271698,
-0.513765811920166,
-0.007338681723922491,
-0.0067553166300058365,
0.04433884844183922,
0.6491839289665222,
-0.8767044544219971,
0.5473730564117432,
0.27254047989845276,
0.7362066507339478,
0.13970082998275757,
0.13980406522750854,
0.5078508257865906,
-0.9919679164886475,
-0.11694519221782684,
0.27870064973831177,
0.2154432237148285,
0.3831239938735962,
-0.43757763504981995,
0.25219592452049255,
0.03384982794523239,
-0.7798261046409607,
-0.4755823612213135,
0.34677639603614807,
-0.9074352383613586,
-0.15983887016773224,
1.2051527500152588,
0.0729188397526741,
-0.15295527875423431,
-0.4377208948135376,
-0.4357677102088928,
0.4012044072151184,
-0.16568773984909058,
0.9125514626502991,
0.6417899131774902,
0.10601259768009186,
-0.13162867724895477,
-0.5842899680137634,
1.0167734622955322,
0.46145331859588623,
-0.9365950226783752,
0.336459219455719,
0.42691755294799805,
0.6025509238243103,
-0.003287544008344412,
0.42276880145072937,
0.059381626546382904,
0.2069147229194641,
-0.5195040702819824,
-0.03546713665127754,
-0.3364754319190979,
-0.15498565137386322,
-0.0939435064792633,
0.017532257363200188,
0.5464538335800171,
0.2904765009880066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11175v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11175v2 | M4GT-Bench: Evaluation Benchmark for Black-Box Machine-Generated Text Detection | 2024-02-17T02:50:33 | 2024-06-27T05:42:12 | Yuxia Wang, Jonibek Mansurov, Petar Ivanov, Jinyan Su, Artem Shelmanov, Akim Tsvigun, Osama Mohanned Afzal, Tarek Mahmoud, Giovanni Puccetti, Thomas Arnold, Alham Fikri Aji, Nizar Habash, Iryna Gurevych, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has brought an unprecedented surge
in machine-generated text (MGT) across diverse channels. This raises legitimate
concerns about its potential misuse and societal implications. The need to
identify and differentiate such content from genuine human-generated text is
critical in combating disinformation, preserving the integrity of education and
scientific fields, and maintaining trust in communication. In this work, we
address this problem by introducing a new benchmark based on a multilingual,
multi-domain, and multi-generator corpus of MGTs -- M4GT-Bench. The benchmark
is compiled of three tasks: (1) mono-lingual and multi-lingual binary MGT
detection; (2) multi-way detection where one need to identify, which particular
model generated the text; and (3) mixed human-machine text detection, where a
word boundary delimiting MGT from human-written content should be determined.
On the developed benchmark, we have tested several MGT detection baselines and
also conducted an evaluation of human performance. We see that obtaining good
performance in MGT detection usually requires an access to the training data
from the same domain and generators. The benchmark is available at
https://github.com/mbzuai-nlp/M4GT-Bench. | [
-0.5262347459793091,
-0.8493613004684448,
0.48705872893333435,
0.007987343706190586,
-0.34599730372428894,
0.34832265973091125,
-0.345419317483902,
-0.468533992767334,
-0.1394391655921936,
0.23895052075386047,
-0.5248033404350281,
-0.6622177362442017,
-0.6617112755775452,
0.5614228844642639,
-0.38165655732154846,
0.9481208324432373,
-0.1892727166414261,
-0.0677366629242897,
-0.053886447101831436,
-0.13835716247558594,
-0.4602939784526825,
-0.7788688540458679,
-0.4060882031917572,
-0.45712679624557495,
0.492704838514328,
0.11421149224042892,
0.3886238634586334,
0.49642840027809143,
0.29407715797424316,
0.3145468533039093,
0.16993555426597595,
0.29362571239471436,
-0.4954410791397095,
0.04944104328751564,
0.007843677885830402,
-0.14229793846607208,
-0.16842657327651978,
0.18768611550331116,
0.8933244347572327,
-0.0007040476193651557,
-0.013367452658712864,
0.26294848322868347,
0.2143343836069107,
0.2767874598503113,
-0.706255316734314,
0.06952723115682602,
-0.8079859018325806,
0.11732608079910278,
-0.5015259981155396,
-0.3735068738460541,
-0.4407862722873688,
-0.16567853093147278,
-0.27540358901023865,
-0.3005366623401642,
0.5009641051292419,
-0.03697879612445831,
0.906308650970459,
-0.010220136493444443,
-0.39938944578170776,
-0.24627651274204254,
-0.3242321312427521,
0.7393202185630798,
-0.5429961681365967,
0.6114028096199036,
0.16999760270118713,
0.49777817726135254,
-0.08571531623601913,
-0.6853691339492798,
-0.7040961980819702,
-0.15371592342853546,
0.06287992745637894,
0.19941794872283936,
-0.2702043950557709,
-0.31388047337532043,
0.3229127526283264,
0.1779826581478119,
-0.7171105146408081,
-0.08492127060890198,
-0.21833643317222595,
-0.5924167633056641,
0.3359581530094147,
-0.031330764293670654,
0.13837851583957672,
-0.3683772087097168,
-0.5109230279922485,
-0.11062434315681458,
-0.6423447728157043,
-0.43463289737701416,
0.6025245785713196,
0.09286633878946304,
-0.07487846910953522,
0.502980649471283,
-0.17335763573646545,
0.48282212018966675,
-0.2699635624885559,
-0.31680354475975037,
0.6390653252601624,
-0.5226238965988159,
0.022700877860188484,
-0.0025705478619784117,
1.0453451871871948,
0.30763328075408936,
0.2860146462917328,
-0.26109832525253296,
-0.38393479585647583,
0.4119715988636017,
0.3599099814891815,
-1.0432560443878174,
-0.09612676501274109,
-0.21272356808185577,
-0.407047837972641,
-0.3572389781475067,
-0.08358993381261826,
-0.9911020994186401,
-0.3598845303058624,
-0.15504975616931915,
0.5004059672355652,
-0.37084317207336426,
-0.43321558833122253,
0.070737324655056,
-0.1205044537782669,
0.06192571297287941,
-0.15339073538780212,
-0.7624982595443726,
0.15059509873390198,
0.7253836393356323,
0.8836907744407654,
-0.43628767132759094,
-0.4673062562942505,
-0.600855827331543,
0.15229466557502747,
0.00342274596914649,
0.8404132127761841,
-0.3393341600894928,
-0.3591749370098114,
0.027544017881155014,
0.015107313171029091,
0.0007186227012425661,
-0.5020390152931213,
0.9639448523521423,
-0.22109398245811462,
0.08136666566133499,
-0.12737524509429932,
-0.36561688780784607,
0.05948710814118385,
0.6667584776878357,
-0.6047651767730713,
1.315068006515503,
0.24350495636463165,
-0.8252737522125244,
0.5142205953598022,
-0.5705556869506836,
-0.36031603813171387,
0.21939469873905182,
-0.41743969917297363,
-0.8352925181388855,
-0.09911113232374191,
0.187344491481781,
0.4728868007659912,
-0.34484556317329407,
0.473715215921402,
-0.4172030985355377,
-0.41052061319351196,
0.4281383752822876,
-0.8121568560600281,
0.2786470651626587,
0.16842518746852875,
-0.5566040873527527,
0.02143201045691967,
-0.8390495181083679,
0.2061317414045334,
0.19505497813224792,
-0.41037866473197937,
-0.11769820749759674,
-0.09698077291250229,
0.2958392798900604,
0.4490409195423126,
0.23282824456691742,
-0.7041728496551514,
-0.021059630438685417,
0.06811495125293732,
0.3121427595615387,
0.8606221079826355,
-0.09770358353853226,
-0.2232787013053894,
-0.2197517454624176,
0.5780696272850037,
0.01733156479895115,
-0.01537760067731142,
-0.03290150314569473,
-0.591443657875061,
-0.38276153802871704,
-0.3467283546924591,
0.5220722556114197,
0.3913393020629883,
-1.0076655149459839,
0.4000587463378906,
-0.32321617007255554,
-0.34364548325538635,
-0.5822939872741699,
0.18159011006355286,
0.641452968120575,
0.3072200417518616,
0.3479340672492981,
-0.30545756220817566,
-0.5214605331420898,
-0.9764668941497803,
-0.40936583280563354,
0.0795477107167244,
-0.047377608716487885,
0.1897609829902649,
0.7228146195411682,
-0.6323904395103455,
0.5931415557861328,
-0.5711528658866882,
-0.09930931031703949,
-0.028822941705584526,
0.5104092955589294,
-0.15325339138507843,
0.2694237232208252,
0.560638427734375,
-0.6569634079933167,
-0.3047253489494324,
-0.017659856006503105,
-0.9560701251029968,
-0.47262775897979736,
0.13459038734436035,
-0.3818935453891754,
-0.012232283130288124,
0.32991355657577515,
-0.4627009630203247,
0.2589547336101532,
0.8830154538154602,
-0.21965110301971436,
1.0046372413635254,
-0.16077446937561035,
0.30923429131507874,
-1.0962958335876465,
0.14985668659210205,
0.17031949758529663,
-0.2954382300376892,
-0.5095860958099365,
0.09446604549884796,
0.36829835176467896,
-0.1433880478143692,
-0.23140329122543335,
0.5392921566963196,
-0.4764978587627411,
-0.3105941116809845,
-0.4304485023021698,
0.3641987144947052,
0.11166313290596008,
0.4412655532360077,
-0.2614652216434479,
1.1496741771697998,
0.10719446837902069,
-0.41549092531204224,
0.14194069802761078,
0.19279858469963074,
-0.37936538457870483,
0.7859155535697937,
-0.4305058419704437,
0.2603468596935272,
0.26259633898735046,
0.03644166886806488,
-0.9074178338050842,
0.07630676031112671,
0.2873287796974182,
-0.5639505386352539,
0.17020483314990997,
-0.2118404060602188,
-0.9589968919754028,
-0.3345346450805664,
-0.3579454720020294,
0.39440858364105225,
0.1431988775730133,
-0.5912523865699768,
0.35603663325309753,
0.4858514368534088,
-0.007648610044270754,
-0.7378472685813904,
-0.6079068779945374,
0.39726242423057556,
-0.14641495048999786,
-0.4710872769355774,
0.33051201701164246,
-0.25281432271003723,
0.14492438733577728,
-0.10628893226385117,
-0.16816715896129608,
-0.045654039829969406,
0.1923501044511795,
0.030331339687108994,
0.0964709222316742,
-0.2986922562122345,
0.03039870783686638,
0.08719702064990997,
-0.2791869640350342,
0.1820959746837616,
-0.2687341272830963,
0.6227973103523254,
-0.10723478347063065,
-0.34854644536972046,
-0.06434452533721924,
0.276508629322052,
0.3937007486820221,
-0.3865472674369812,
0.4874931275844574,
1.1858729124069214,
-0.40603452920913696,
-0.15690666437149048,
-0.5780267715454102,
-0.10682052373886108,
-0.47197768092155457,
0.21519191563129425,
-0.647677481174469,
-0.8253390789031982,
0.17290368676185608,
-0.03166031837463379,
-0.16109170019626617,
0.41030898690223694,
0.795918881893158,
0.5040462017059326,
0.8812596201896667,
0.31616485118865967,
-0.1771908402442932,
0.29820340871810913,
0.012801163829863071,
0.11129693686962128,
-0.7722781300544739,
0.09477619081735611,
-0.6383236050605774,
-0.07175403088331223,
-0.7813172936439514,
-0.34294989705085754,
0.3004821836948395,
-0.26846304535865784,
-0.011721989139914513,
0.32799530029296875,
-0.6368216276168823,
0.45945966243743896,
0.49278539419174194,
0.15233753621578217,
0.43527650833129883,
-0.12922576069831848,
-0.5000733733177185,
-0.06689316779375076,
-0.3268662393093109,
-0.7935066223144531,
1.3499783277511597,
0.15428774058818817,
0.4634684920310974,
0.22515447437763214,
0.8351293206214905,
0.5032396912574768,
0.7682214975357056,
-0.4840526580810547,
0.4993423819541931,
0.0034708636812865734,
-0.729735791683197,
0.12242184579372406,
-0.7661498785018921,
-1.195542335510254,
0.8283823728561401,
-0.47815629839897156,
-0.5813981294631958,
-0.42368051409721375,
-0.07649006694555283,
0.12258278578519821,
0.3092935383319855,
-0.8786114454269409,
1.2388153076171875,
-0.33051466941833496,
-0.5019779801368713,
0.008753441274166107,
-0.3186261057853699,
0.540168285369873,
-0.39465880393981934,
0.20056912302970886,
-0.3457004725933075,
0.023611966520547867,
0.7312870621681213,
0.10010842233896255,
0.5101849436759949,
-0.2291681319475174,
-0.10630512237548828,
0.15337735414505005,
-0.06154128909111023,
0.38584133982658386,
0.041902028024196625,
-0.040584318339824677,
0.36562108993530273,
-0.12933823466300964,
-0.3303379714488983,
-0.08173006027936935,
0.781909704208374,
-0.7219506502151489,
-0.2148033082485199,
-0.4850480556488037,
-0.3783424198627472,
-0.16569703817367554,
0.5883610844612122,
0.2787541151046753,
0.5718427300453186,
-0.43376123905181885,
0.1640288084745407,
0.31230178475379944,
-0.1937275230884552,
0.24023869633674622,
0.5464698672294617,
-0.20443372428417206,
-0.49381202459335327,
0.883877694606781,
-0.15660785138607025,
0.03762175142765045,
0.26694172620773315,
0.24131114780902863,
-0.5608392357826233,
-0.824302077293396,
-0.7546130418777466,
0.21069926023483276,
-0.6958043575286865,
-0.3478589653968811,
-0.6782188415527344,
-0.18427954614162445,
-0.22067829966545105,
0.2189386636018753,
-0.08635538071393967,
0.15327605605125427,
-0.14852792024612427,
-0.11301124840974808,
0.009974301792681217,
0.5720269680023193,
0.1686074435710907,
0.40781599283218384,
-0.8465320467948914,
0.6592694520950317,
0.015342580154538155,
0.5397496223449707,
-0.3291577398777008,
-0.31787705421447754,
-0.3697682321071625,
-0.017570048570632935,
-0.7171722650527954,
-0.736605703830719,
0.3848690688610077,
-0.17882196605205536,
0.7726296782493591,
0.2509113848209381,
-0.23567171394824982,
0.37787944078445435,
-0.750896692276001,
0.4596156179904938,
0.12807060778141022,
-1.0295377969741821,
0.01443609781563282,
-0.48136404156684875,
0.3550461232662201,
0.5780786275863647,
0.09005218744277954,
-0.4704645276069641,
-0.4280223250389099,
-0.5781979560852051,
-0.49638471007347107,
0.3652013838291168,
0.47986170649528503,
-0.10605715215206146,
0.038112152367830276,
0.13494449853897095,
0.22038201987743378,
0.48356208205223083,
-1.0244905948638916,
-0.09497761726379395,
-0.22435352206230164,
-0.3246614933013916,
-0.3794488310813904,
-0.1721317619085312,
-0.069913350045681,
0.2216852456331253,
0.5246099233627319,
-0.28240764141082764,
0.42719078063964844,
-0.13544826209545135,
-0.3446665108203888,
0.040174029767513275,
0.429455041885376,
0.7109436988830566,
0.5730810165405273,
-0.23208221793174744,
0.30212560296058655,
-0.00044535216875374317,
-0.6723969578742981,
0.2566293478012085,
0.4501167833805084,
-0.09684767574071884,
0.2541745901107788,
0.10184258967638016,
0.41264525055885315,
0.36704155802726746,
-0.5238018035888672,
0.5522893071174622,
-0.16674476861953735,
-0.45970553159713745,
-0.13020136952400208,
-0.10625077784061432,
-0.007315260823816061,
0.0807105079293251,
0.3640311658382416,
0.026311267167329788,
0.3103845417499542,
-0.2971358299255371,
0.6079891324043274,
0.4888410270214081,
-0.08676126599311829,
-0.3432883024215698,
0.7066941857337952,
0.29919493198394775,
-0.12182111293077469,
0.21027760207653046,
-0.5367879867553711,
-0.7319768667221069,
0.27523303031921387,
0.6010071635246277,
1.0165883302688599,
-0.03979111835360527,
0.1513739377260208,
0.3146114945411682,
0.5376476645469666,
-0.008939187042415142,
0.16736280918121338,
0.05955873802304268,
-0.9266291260719299,
-0.4397980868816376,
-0.538893461227417,
-0.40698733925819397,
0.3875201940536499,
-0.4266228675842285,
0.2923663854598999,
-0.129582479596138,
-0.3313446342945099,
0.37765175104141235,
0.100909523665905,
-0.5222440361976624,
0.052173271775245667,
0.3403073847293854,
0.5881257653236389,
-0.8012602925300598,
0.8224436044692993,
0.2463470995426178,
-0.13698109984397888,
-0.29004600644111633,
0.05786481872200966,
0.31237128376960754,
-0.763852596282959,
0.21034656465053558,
0.6896613240242004,
-0.440168172121048,
-0.10167676955461502,
-0.33051973581314087,
-0.4066731631755829,
0.9421984553337097,
0.2933463454246521,
-0.2890458405017853,
0.3685855269432068,
0.11795397102832794,
0.4991149306297302,
-0.21456032991409302,
0.2413623332977295,
0.6274468898773193,
0.6838303208351135,
-0.3898010849952698,
-0.6903772354125977,
0.1662011444568634,
-0.32871875166893005,
-0.23902158439159393,
0.6492766737937927,
-0.36963531374931335,
0.8535007238388062,
0.35618856549263,
-0.2993723154067993,
0.04043440893292427,
0.3759174048900604,
0.5442313551902771,
0.47909069061279297,
0.45082589983940125,
0.5539035797119141,
0.6831881999969482,
-0.3317137360572815,
0.9245412945747375,
-0.28370001912117004,
0.443853497505188,
0.7712432146072388,
-0.41379737854003906,
0.6864829659461975,
0.13432782888412476,
-0.12966816127300262,
0.3374975919723511,
0.5209180116653442,
-0.33199721574783325,
0.35021108388900757,
0.3995722830295563,
-0.51084303855896,
0.08185101300477982,
0.14432577788829803,
-0.4728657901287079,
0.40643730759620667,
0.31809499859809875,
-0.20001648366451263,
-0.32512807846069336,
-0.22623777389526367,
0.1193995475769043,
-0.011712206527590752,
-0.09870009124279022,
0.5811837911605835,
-0.1536128669977188,
-0.6848479509353638,
0.8071872591972351,
0.32496407628059387,
0.9524109959602356,
-0.6358287930488586,
0.09513264894485474,
0.2016272395849228,
0.4129592776298523,
0.018838847056031227,
-0.7431196570396423,
-0.015014156699180603,
0.33190739154815674,
0.029708968475461006,
-0.08010612428188324,
0.8921123147010803,
-0.4985366463661194,
-0.37370797991752625,
0.40976738929748535,
0.7774089574813843,
0.21729792654514313,
-0.2561700940132141,
-0.9442073702812195,
0.0919419527053833,
-0.05869904160499573,
-0.0638052448630333,
0.44848814606666565,
0.6255238652229309,
0.01992172934114933,
0.4858970642089844,
0.873584508895874,
-0.1134127750992775,
0.15228745341300964,
0.309335857629776,
0.715503990650177,
-0.7071632742881775,
-0.3524669408798218,
-1.037634015083313,
0.13691076636314392,
-0.31440550088882446,
-0.37876054644584656,
0.8620827794075012,
0.9376236200332642,
0.8071497678756714,
-0.15950405597686768,
1.0740238428115845,
0.23223240673542023,
0.4598429501056671,
-0.6045745611190796,
0.6448239684104919,
-0.4015287756919861,
-0.06559620797634125,
-0.5485482811927795,
-0.8668844103813171,
-0.19447655975818634,
0.38900110125541687,
-0.02265576459467411,
0.19453415274620056,
0.8942679762840271,
0.7638477683067322,
-0.3053281009197235,
-0.05173077806830406,
0.4522152543067932,
-0.20860861241817474,
0.38808348774909973,
0.5348036885261536,
0.9882155656814575,
-0.45464059710502625,
0.9554383158683777,
0.016620496287941933,
-0.1430966556072235,
-0.2639525234699249,
-1.0470356941223145,
-0.9896835088729858,
-0.3792991042137146,
-0.17164283990859985,
-0.4157981872558594,
-0.09230665117502213,
0.5580973029136658,
0.6390412449836731,
-0.644910991191864,
-0.29180461168289185,
0.29579484462738037,
0.04466390982270241,
-0.2683698832988739,
-0.1925070434808731,
0.20742446184158325,
-0.13273783028125763,
-0.675654411315918,
0.3313632607460022,
0.24494417011737823,
0.1315975934267044,
-0.30350035429000854,
-0.06558845937252045,
-0.28768855333328247,
-0.14696533977985382,
0.7589715719223022,
0.01891636662185192,
-0.5282880067825317,
-0.33745408058166504,
-0.2538887560367584,
-0.2761428952217102,
0.29711100459098816,
0.8904886245727539,
-0.4328819811344147,
0.4701903760433197,
0.22397971153259277,
0.9007565379142761,
0.7226686477661133,
0.14729180932044983,
0.531775712966919,
-1.093734860420227,
0.023213768377900124,
0.012286627665162086,
0.6287323832511902,
0.5645121932029724,
-0.11333716660737991,
0.6692114472389221,
0.441963791847229,
-0.6180008053779602,
-0.8389785289764404,
0.1292283535003662,
-0.9040285348892212,
-0.13457871973514557,
1.1925723552703857,
-0.0952056497335434,
-0.1014673039317131,
-0.25371861457824707,
-0.271078497171402,
0.28275999426841736,
-0.4894734025001526,
0.6907796859741211,
0.889763593673706,
0.3091476261615753,
-0.19784463942050934,
-0.9514736533164978,
0.2832259237766266,
0.05590042471885681,
-1.1974196434020996,
0.03341606259346008,
0.5574814677238464,
0.2947736978530884,
0.13273383677005768,
0.5997880101203918,
-0.14536720514297485,
0.14770619571208954,
0.05531911179423332,
0.35108089447021484,
-0.08731252700090408,
-0.18930591642856598,
-0.1523730754852295,
0.20025283098220825,
-0.10252445191144943,
-0.41780349612236023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11167v1 | Token-Ensemble Text Generation: On Attacking the Automatic AI-Generated Text Detection | 2024-02-17T02:25:57 | 2024-02-17T02:25:57 | Fan Huang, Haewoon Kwak, Jisun An | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The robustness of AI-content detection models against cultivated attacks
(e.g., paraphrasing or word switching) remains a significant concern. This
study proposes a novel token-ensemble generation strategy to challenge the
robustness of current AI-content detection approaches. We explore the ensemble
attack strategy by completing the prompt with the next token generated from
random candidate LLMs. We find the token-ensemble approach significantly drops
the performance of AI-content detection models (The code and test sets will be
released). Our findings reveal that token-ensemble generation poses a vital
challenge to current detection models and underlines the need for advancing
detection technologies to counter sophisticated adversarial strategies. | [
-0.4796581268310547,
-0.8087570667266846,
0.19391515851020813,
-0.3038020730018616,
-0.37331897020339966,
0.4486410319805145,
0.09932960569858551,
-0.38213440775871277,
-0.03864680603146553,
0.7204526662826538,
-0.6568777561187744,
-0.4327441453933716,
-0.615117609500885,
0.3799745738506317,
-0.8679474592208862,
1.1489615440368652,
0.11877767741680145,
-0.22656431794166565,
-0.26258546113967896,
-0.009355858899652958,
-0.44798171520233154,
-0.3891892433166504,
-1.1410874128341675,
0.015416773036122322,
0.5312196612358093,
0.278972327709198,
0.35318246483802795,
0.4522687792778015,
0.5561726689338684,
0.34832996129989624,
-0.05994652956724167,
0.3098093271255493,
-0.3461266756057739,
0.4583909511566162,
0.12137290835380554,
-0.7045365571975708,
-0.03993569687008858,
-0.03529927507042885,
0.6631776094436646,
0.07940971851348877,
0.3099847137928009,
0.01350332424044609,
-0.07446640729904175,
0.2558276653289795,
-0.5418404936790466,
-0.30101487040519714,
-1.2758435010910034,
0.09529571235179901,
-0.6433025598526001,
-0.37381720542907715,
-0.7123107314109802,
0.37128689885139465,
-0.2900160253047943,
-0.3959539234638214,
0.3273845911026001,
0.4324164092540741,
0.5867421627044678,
0.21469593048095703,
-0.27075931429862976,
-0.38083481788635254,
-0.31673404574394226,
0.6465955376625061,
-0.5198990106582642,
-0.2909042537212372,
0.16343288123607635,
0.14056038856506348,
-0.2804872691631317,
-0.9666021466255188,
-0.8735364079475403,
-0.11270350962877274,
0.22288282215595245,
0.1134302094578743,
-0.5259000062942505,
-0.01518474705517292,
-0.15665178000926971,
0.2338569462299347,
-0.5423679947853088,
0.2518540024757385,
-0.20491434633731842,
-0.49705708026885986,
0.6117458939552307,
0.21353894472122192,
0.6621807217597961,
-0.38067346811294556,
-0.5289924144744873,
-0.1949557214975357,
-0.7689922451972961,
-0.03023042343556881,
0.7810587882995605,
0.28408539295196533,
0.13129693269729614,
0.5652485489845276,
0.21441689133644104,
0.37578102946281433,
0.25653842091560364,
0.010797538794577122,
-0.17639108002185822,
-0.3667357563972473,
-0.085917167365551,
0.3234158754348755,
0.916011393070221,
0.3464668393135071,
-0.23482577502727509,
-0.2836807072162628,
-0.5442387461662292,
0.10391682386398315,
0.3331734836101532,
-0.48582419753074646,
-0.17601872980594635,
0.3054778277873993,
-0.46593987941741943,
-1.1024885177612305,
0.02955264039337635,
-0.6994740962982178,
-0.2942136824131012,
0.3192834258079529,
0.41339731216430664,
-0.5192703008651733,
-0.12317080050706863,
-0.3917638063430786,
-0.5604850053787231,
0.30522871017456055,
0.10769609361886978,
-0.8268375396728516,
0.24226561188697815,
0.7882348895072937,
0.8536627888679504,
-0.7606555819511414,
-0.3800254762172699,
-0.9076679944992065,
0.21301567554473877,
-0.44662338495254517,
1.0100756883621216,
-0.3907793462276459,
-0.8211589455604553,
-0.0234091617166996,
-0.24599865078926086,
-0.07633419334888458,
-0.5011985301971436,
0.6076858043670654,
-0.5068654417991638,
0.3387961685657501,
-0.03944805637001991,
-0.7017006874084473,
0.24680805206298828,
0.4435112178325653,
-0.7613546252250671,
0.9347008466720581,
-0.14875738322734833,
-1.0907957553863525,
0.4929165840148926,
-0.5878651142120361,
-0.5735305547714233,
0.3005794286727905,
-0.2446853369474411,
-0.42742231488227844,
0.05743969976902008,
0.39416906237602234,
0.3797520399093628,
0.04562406614422798,
-0.06680815666913986,
-0.014698883518576622,
-0.5678537487983704,
0.3764607906341553,
-0.8076789379119873,
0.5921501517295837,
0.3718927502632141,
-0.4248887598514557,
0.15809756517410278,
-0.7345602512359619,
-0.1786697506904602,
0.34588855504989624,
-0.33030736446380615,
-0.21712921559810638,
0.08691351860761642,
0.15011316537857056,
-0.1986178308725357,
0.2974567413330078,
-0.3440871238708496,
0.10413840413093567,
-0.44417497515678406,
0.5609281659126282,
1.1207115650177002,
0.17437803745269775,
0.6244425177574158,
-0.6018399000167847,
0.6874989867210388,
0.22048337757587433,
0.04703936725854874,
-0.6368709802627563,
-0.6933741569519043,
-0.2826616168022156,
-0.3941085934638977,
0.246394544839859,
0.4608440697193146,
-1.0675959587097168,
0.33515453338623047,
0.005697136744856834,
-0.39843547344207764,
-0.29715728759765625,
0.06274157762527466,
0.2015882283449173,
0.5138886570930481,
0.23418010771274567,
-0.026792366057634354,
-0.38195371627807617,
-0.38645821809768677,
-0.6635614037513733,
-0.5071654915809631,
-0.039582666009664536,
0.16180817782878876,
0.5856543183326721,
-0.1716877520084381,
0.8413705229759216,
-0.09476599842309952,
0.10934971272945404,
-0.4540831446647644,
0.22697430849075317,
-0.24258551001548767,
0.5974639654159546,
0.6358726024627686,
-0.8939535617828369,
-0.30015459656715393,
-0.328538179397583,
-0.35887667536735535,
-0.09565343707799911,
-0.3459298014640808,
0.05035127326846123,
0.33475783467292786,
0.661575198173523,
-0.7196071743965149,
0.2657230496406555,
0.303369402885437,
-0.27280330657958984,
0.5560504794120789,
0.11883299052715302,
0.15146265923976898,
-1.3877339363098145,
-0.16472186148166656,
-0.22932706773281097,
-0.09751217812299728,
-0.6031181812286377,
0.44940343499183655,
-0.26322078704833984,
-0.3106445372104645,
-0.6182950139045715,
0.6824594736099243,
-0.10767390578985214,
0.09679120779037476,
-0.26397740840911865,
-0.02187398448586464,
0.04702470079064369,
0.16922233998775482,
-0.3142053186893463,
0.9313856363296509,
0.4880717992782593,
-0.5329750180244446,
0.25648218393325806,
0.20250150561332703,
-0.1521349996328354,
0.6088595986366272,
-0.4984818994998932,
0.3213609457015991,
-0.12374640256166458,
0.4985644817352295,
-1.4055709838867188,
-0.31729957461357117,
0.4807131886482239,
-0.734663188457489,
0.5179413557052612,
0.05796318128705025,
-0.7052884697914124,
-0.309233695268631,
-0.6385405659675598,
0.5127308964729309,
0.4698372185230255,
-0.6720216870307922,
0.5713512301445007,
0.11503525823354721,
-0.01690390519797802,
-0.4496889114379883,
-0.9029350280761719,
0.6841109991073608,
-0.6789690852165222,
-0.8512301445007324,
0.5537937879562378,
0.10134321451187134,
-0.4485165476799011,
-0.19992077350616455,
0.03817055746912956,
0.11397123336791992,
0.4332875907421112,
-0.1506517082452774,
0.12273552268743515,
-0.15544888377189636,
0.03760955110192299,
0.06925086677074432,
0.038743965327739716,
0.1795799732208252,
-0.5119335055351257,
0.7528070211410522,
0.2555240988731384,
-0.54460209608078,
-0.5911532044410706,
0.37574440240859985,
0.6214677691459656,
-0.3426586091518402,
0.5880478024482727,
0.9197970628738403,
-0.21757729351520538,
-0.2945859432220459,
-0.2758229374885559,
-0.2748570740222931,
-0.5764198303222656,
0.34447094798088074,
-0.13464206457138062,
-0.6755243539810181,
0.4492209553718567,
-0.03199963644146919,
0.2683751881122589,
0.714576005935669,
0.3572794497013092,
-0.20436468720436096,
1.2012213468551636,
0.09803597629070282,
-0.18574099242687225,
0.4158251881599426,
-0.1942649632692337,
0.04864179715514183,
-0.5163730382919312,
-0.05859440192580223,
-0.5873350501060486,
-0.28834301233291626,
-0.6125967502593994,
-0.1857956498861313,
0.18055178225040436,
-0.19121648371219635,
-0.07296957820653915,
0.15524601936340332,
-0.8227114081382751,
0.2856033742427826,
0.7241650819778442,
0.19613969326019287,
0.1819959431886673,
0.07026463001966476,
-0.00328539265319705,
0.3247393071651459,
-0.6650174856185913,
-0.5513585805892944,
1.4697364568710327,
0.10748817771673203,
0.45955386757850647,
0.028108621016144753,
1.1623492240905762,
0.8143510222434998,
-0.10208586603403091,
-0.47277921438217163,
0.6705582141876221,
-0.0488528273999691,
-0.46132034063339233,
-0.2895618677139282,
-0.19980306923389435,
-1.0007048845291138,
-0.029509883373975754,
-0.2073623687028885,
-0.7595142722129822,
-0.2969776391983032,
0.010974259115755558,
-0.2960594892501831,
0.7485048174858093,
-0.43042126297950745,
0.6134257912635803,
-0.1376461386680603,
-0.04213111102581024,
-0.01974971406161785,
-0.5309790372848511,
0.5278401970863342,
-0.24270415306091309,
0.26402992010116577,
0.23443225026130676,
-0.23175804316997528,
0.7382125854492188,
-0.43576085567474365,
0.8776284456253052,
-0.051939915865659714,
-0.11941570043563843,
0.7925323247909546,
0.14130602777004242,
0.845063328742981,
0.09689675271511078,
0.06070781871676445,
-0.10177672654390335,
-0.24779963493347168,
-0.5423883199691772,
-0.2425423413515091,
0.4232881963253021,
-0.5353536009788513,
-0.8281534314155579,
-0.3263339102268219,
-0.5281895399093628,
0.07716047763824463,
0.10887373983860016,
0.8509535193443298,
0.3849267065525055,
-0.32010793685913086,
-0.02747528627514839,
0.6309569478034973,
-0.32470983266830444,
0.7231839299201965,
-0.23656947910785675,
0.051264047622680664,
-0.5021724700927734,
1.2371675968170166,
-0.17484046518802643,
0.33627596497535706,
0.3061541020870209,
0.11808429658412933,
-0.3104313015937805,
-1.0156117677688599,
-0.539073646068573,
-0.4561176300048828,
-0.6260334849357605,
-0.1677788347005844,
-0.531988263130188,
-0.0795373022556305,
-0.5262789726257324,
-0.28725358843803406,
0.16557195782661438,
-0.35880231857299805,
-0.5488457083702087,
0.01776982471346855,
0.34593018889427185,
0.5741655826568604,
0.1467563658952713,
0.6357923746109009,
-0.81851726770401,
0.08860699832439423,
0.3781009316444397,
-0.3751804530620575,
-0.11369820684194565,
-0.41359612345695496,
0.1185711994767189,
-0.08847633749246597,
-0.5650252103805542,
-0.8782118558883667,
0.1838097870349884,
0.0704931914806366,
0.4739840626716614,
0.5319259762763977,
0.1668468862771988,
0.11837422847747803,
-0.42305028438568115,
1.2845689058303833,
0.21681568026542664,
-0.8797707557678223,
0.5833002328872681,
-0.6115396022796631,
0.2962034046649933,
0.48686888813972473,
-0.2430252879858017,
-0.2749235928058624,
-0.7355591058731079,
-0.9730896949768066,
-0.77422034740448,
0.4545821249485016,
0.5192868709564209,
0.4265715479850769,
-0.5324428081512451,
0.3391086459159851,
-0.03458138555288315,
0.36013659834861755,
-0.5962820649147034,
-0.09649807959794998,
-0.24487528204917908,
-0.386976957321167,
0.19688333570957184,
0.0267802644520998,
-0.04508645460009575,
0.2508881986141205,
0.44096556305885315,
-0.1904343068599701,
0.42730146646499634,
0.1411377489566803,
-0.012687040492892265,
0.0488278791308403,
-0.016494784504175186,
0.48870787024497986,
-0.052726227790117264,
0.4866761863231659,
0.0333833247423172,
0.3259706199169159,
-0.5316332578659058,
0.11235012859106064,
-0.029967430979013443,
-0.4421965479850769,
0.14068667590618134,
0.7077875733375549,
0.6937291622161865,
-0.034229304641485214,
-0.8648344874382019,
0.6282897591590881,
0.01301493775099516,
-0.34681248664855957,
-0.19568271934986115,
0.3731481730937958,
-0.19956494867801666,
0.09364109486341476,
0.7799155116081238,
0.4668866693973541,
0.05679729953408241,
-0.5758471488952637,
0.5291382670402527,
0.6400995850563049,
-0.2783927321434021,
-0.07589948922395706,
0.7851783037185669,
0.18273678421974182,
-0.6286143064498901,
0.3445441722869873,
-0.28129342198371887,
-0.6313022971153259,
1.1826541423797607,
0.6579825282096863,
0.9106873273849487,
-0.043154578655958176,
0.27765437960624695,
-0.15324051678180695,
0.3468839228153229,
-0.12211918085813522,
-0.09085489064455032,
-0.2460150122642517,
-0.7501832246780396,
0.0026209161151200533,
-0.3868599236011505,
-0.3841482400894165,
0.1174163967370987,
-0.431841105222702,
0.3184441924095154,
-0.619255542755127,
-0.1303011178970337,
-0.15673482418060303,
-0.1657867133617401,
-0.32604193687438965,
0.17006006836891174,
0.28934118151664734,
0.838260293006897,
-0.3066888749599457,
0.42550137639045715,
0.40727075934410095,
-0.18937240540981293,
-0.521851658821106,
0.5140725374221802,
0.10392773896455765,
-1.012539029121399,
0.39644894003868103,
0.3357193171977997,
0.15767346322536469,
0.2079460173845291,
-0.7390379309654236,
-0.4803781807422638,
1.1452672481536865,
0.12373119592666626,
-0.23489119112491608,
-0.19965210556983948,
0.04155910760164261,
0.21680666506290436,
-0.28259962797164917,
-0.017263038083910942,
0.4381568729877472,
0.46978759765625,
0.1698550283908844,
-0.27952951192855835,
-0.08966291695833206,
-0.1539713591337204,
-0.19449982047080994,
0.1510794311761856,
-0.8159885406494141,
1.1380153894424438,
0.04799883812665939,
-0.18694332242012024,
0.50654137134552,
0.7563614249229431,
0.40472450852394104,
0.5727236866950989,
0.7137011885643005,
0.5955376625061035,
0.9106108546257019,
0.07735411822795868,
1.0089476108551025,
-0.4486965537071228,
-0.10363610833883286,
0.6005767583847046,
-0.2655240297317505,
0.6503997445106506,
0.602774441242218,
-0.006792397703975439,
0.24603763222694397,
0.7944886684417725,
-0.43298137187957764,
0.48327720165252686,
0.39526692032814026,
-0.7079647183418274,
-0.24640025198459625,
0.03145512938499451,
-0.21184252202510834,
0.6965632438659668,
0.240504652261734,
-0.31132417917251587,
-0.058462776243686676,
0.17487633228302002,
0.0317821204662323,
0.12139346450567245,
-0.5790191888809204,
0.8229846358299255,
-0.21577374637126923,
-0.8113540410995483,
0.3028929829597473,
0.09470261633396149,
0.9355997443199158,
-0.37058597803115845,
0.21797055006027222,
0.0016919135814532638,
-0.10000882297754288,
-0.1353216916322708,
-0.39316651225090027,
0.11553152650594711,
0.1695619821548462,
0.23724916577339172,
0.013001817278563976,
1.0144881010055542,
-0.08635897189378738,
-0.594291627407074,
-0.16567227244377136,
0.35802167654037476,
0.04305664077401161,
-0.008029391057789326,
-0.5724647045135498,
-0.18199637532234192,
-0.022187912836670876,
-0.24017727375030518,
0.4963209629058838,
0.5068712830543518,
0.032264869660139084,
0.47425636649131775,
0.8976293802261353,
-0.17256109416484833,
0.12003109604120255,
-0.23905080556869507,
0.8353069424629211,
-0.23549401760101318,
-0.632796049118042,
-1.163536548614502,
0.16701218485832214,
-0.2760647237300873,
-0.31922292709350586,
0.7227475643157959,
0.4140009582042694,
0.7765645980834961,
0.31739693880081177,
1.146390438079834,
0.0585038885474205,
0.04221191257238388,
-0.6629873514175415,
0.8256558775901794,
-0.5512494444847107,
0.4590457081794739,
-0.40689074993133545,
-0.5157932639122009,
-0.09920082241296768,
0.11926388740539551,
0.17923560738563538,
0.03614905849099159,
0.6190491914749146,
0.5446939468383789,
0.19078001379966736,
0.20838871598243713,
0.23052068054676056,
-0.02440265566110611,
0.5954409837722778,
0.29755234718322754,
0.9271395802497864,
-0.568572461605072,
0.9470207095146179,
0.24655377864837646,
0.09330622851848602,
0.06977915018796921,
-0.7893872857093811,
-1.2327758073806763,
-0.3346661627292633,
-0.15554770827293396,
-0.3214239180088043,
0.25550806522369385,
0.6425184011459351,
0.1827625036239624,
-0.7012283205986023,
0.20218341052532196,
-0.6415607333183289,
0.11294683814048767,
-0.08343536406755447,
-0.23613286018371582,
0.2624143362045288,
-0.709932267665863,
-0.8629282116889954,
0.505348265171051,
0.10191445797681808,
0.3206614851951599,
-0.5203253626823425,
0.11713617295026779,
0.04559990391135216,
0.3979480266571045,
0.1527918130159378,
0.08885245025157928,
-0.658276379108429,
-0.31736040115356445,
0.1364210993051529,
-0.18686389923095703,
-0.08582552522420883,
0.7604023814201355,
-0.7074347734451294,
-0.05117076262831688,
0.40681758522987366,
1.0640650987625122,
0.2652019262313843,
-0.023472951725125313,
0.6019532680511475,
-0.9210615754127502,
0.2924801707267761,
0.3690909445285797,
0.37294653058052063,
0.19273053109645844,
-0.6878151893615723,
0.07995583117008209,
0.6433641910552979,
-0.3151461184024811,
-1.0756722688674927,
0.3001006245613098,
-0.6680673956871033,
-0.6479544043540955,
1.0671782493591309,
-0.036634884774684906,
-0.46255773305892944,
-0.08546843379735947,
-0.4033549129962921,
0.14954479038715363,
-0.48938894271850586,
0.8882374167442322,
0.6975057125091553,
0.2613691985607147,
0.04547211527824402,
-0.046762943267822266,
0.48621565103530884,
0.48320332169532776,
-0.6284166574478149,
-0.2688797414302826,
0.11636333167552948,
-0.0037319741677492857,
0.23474188148975372,
0.4770362079143524,
0.0923856571316719,
0.40925610065460205,
0.30501896142959595,
-0.3093998432159424,
-0.06889761984348297,
-0.20394665002822876,
-0.09112986922264099,
0.45543617010116577,
-0.20826253294944763,
-0.4759528338909149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11166v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11166v1 | GenDec: A robust generative Question-decomposition method for Multi-hop reasoning | 2024-02-17T02:21:44 | 2024-02-17T02:21:44 | Jian Wu, Linyi Yang, Yuliang Ji, Wenhao Huang, Börje F. Karlsson, Manabu Okumura | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-hop QA (MHQA) involves step-by-step reasoning to answer complex
questions and find multiple relevant supporting facts. However, Existing large
language models'(LLMs) reasoning ability in multi-hop question answering
remains exploration, which is inadequate in answering multi-hop questions.
Moreover, it is unclear whether LLMs follow a desired reasoning chain to reach
the right final answer. In this paper, we propose a \textbf{gen}erative
question \textbf{dec}omposition method (GenDec) from the perspective of
explainable QA by generating independent and complete sub-questions based on
incorporating additional extracted evidence for enhancing LLMs' reasoning
ability in RAG. To demonstrate the impact, generalization, and robustness of
Gendec, we conduct two experiments, the first is combining GenDec with small QA
systems on paragraph retrieval and QA tasks. We secondly examine the reasoning
capabilities of various state-of-the-art LLMs including GPT-4 and GPT-3.5
combined with GenDec. We experiment on the HotpotQA, 2WikihopMultiHopQA,
MuSiQue, and PokeMQA datasets. | [
-0.8037706017494202,
-1.1496573686599731,
0.9148902297019958,
-0.1774274855852127,
-0.18709184229373932,
0.17510531842708588,
-0.05991761386394501,
-0.16320331394672394,
0.13521379232406616,
0.3926376700401306,
-0.5158502459526062,
-0.6130518913269043,
-0.250891774892807,
0.3891233205795288,
-0.1774863600730896,
0.5585551261901855,
-0.1640872061252594,
-0.20086544752120972,
-0.29254570603370667,
-0.2374117076396942,
-0.2933909595012665,
-0.5028133988380432,
-0.6016102433204651,
-0.001237358315847814,
0.3235509693622589,
0.43520259857177734,
0.48103487491607666,
0.30853116512298584,
0.29125869274139404,
0.266707181930542,
-0.4307478070259094,
0.4159042239189148,
-0.2298838347196579,
0.4573296010494232,
-0.28910988569259644,
-0.33699697256088257,
-0.41619178652763367,
0.060747262090444565,
0.5404291749000549,
0.6655958294868469,
-0.1189751923084259,
0.023516949266195297,
0.05705151706933975,
0.4001792073249817,
-0.6755111217498779,
-0.1319430023431778,
-0.5090844035148621,
-0.21938231587409973,
0.07052289694547653,
-0.3770919144153595,
-0.4507748782634735,
-0.4574296474456787,
-0.09381931275129318,
-0.3730042278766632,
0.2750345468521118,
-0.03674651309847832,
0.6489682793617249,
0.2560645639896393,
-0.5144004821777344,
-0.09553330391645432,
-0.7895445823669434,
0.5602279305458069,
-0.6449153423309326,
0.5509271621704102,
0.3867303729057312,
0.3280676007270813,
-0.16268250346183777,
-0.5514524579048157,
-0.49592670798301697,
0.061020880937576294,
0.3771669566631317,
0.3303575813770294,
0.1727561056613922,
-0.06679746508598328,
0.4057950973510742,
0.5316978693008423,
-0.6262919902801514,
-0.028594544157385826,
-0.13617195188999176,
-0.06929932534694672,
0.09892476350069046,
0.21742649376392365,
0.4063464403152466,
-0.17967650294303894,
-0.41657376289367676,
-0.140620157122612,
-0.7437570095062256,
0.19297966361045837,
0.14905110001564026,
0.004789974074810743,
0.04991660639643669,
0.6608350872993469,
-0.2129564881324768,
0.6455376148223877,
0.12822631001472473,
-0.203240767121315,
0.10943776369094849,
-0.6967989206314087,
-0.12540408968925476,
-0.38217711448669434,
0.648965060710907,
0.16616153717041016,
0.04887605458498001,
-0.09317636489868164,
0.17170926928520203,
-0.1616489142179489,
0.08569910377264023,
-0.77140873670578,
-0.1443275362253189,
0.4299578368663788,
-0.5257300138473511,
-0.03574223443865776,
-0.0061488766223192215,
-1.146889090538025,
-0.19602277874946594,
-0.18579243123531342,
0.31812411546707153,
-0.6595808863639832,
-0.22153538465499878,
0.1402265429496765,
-0.1247977465391159,
0.6735278367996216,
0.25779998302459717,
-0.6972766518592834,
-0.08383999764919281,
0.6118573546409607,
0.5328651666641235,
0.2275570183992386,
-0.3154088854789734,
-0.4782197177410126,
0.048287857323884964,
-0.46397295594215393,
0.937817394733429,
-0.44133052229881287,
-0.1591959297657013,
-0.20183293521404266,
0.044109929352998734,
-0.4504886567592621,
-0.33585798740386963,
0.6624557971954346,
-0.8335850834846497,
0.37227293848991394,
-0.21478642523288727,
-0.6405404210090637,
-0.2633533477783203,
0.3711225986480713,
-0.6172645688056946,
0.6265379786491394,
-0.02058015577495098,
-1.108122706413269,
0.2626863121986389,
-0.348999559879303,
-0.2877994477748871,
-0.05166089907288551,
-0.19458523392677307,
-0.31108471751213074,
-0.2106735110282898,
0.8310568332672119,
0.3099513649940491,
-0.3754948377609253,
0.01925378292798996,
-0.3697570562362671,
-0.03033357299864292,
0.28326454758644104,
-0.5734724402427673,
1.0780863761901855,
0.40269190073013306,
-0.24261251091957092,
0.07910379022359848,
-0.6254830956459045,
0.2783045470714569,
0.2858438491821289,
-0.5564499497413635,
-0.5053459405899048,
0.032890915870666504,
-0.7014158964157104,
0.16738641262054443,
0.024841733276844025,
-0.5316734313964844,
0.26190346479415894,
-0.2594977915287018,
0.45058056712150574,
0.5559017062187195,
0.3512398302555084,
0.5212593078613281,
-0.21365925669670105,
0.8814228177070618,
-0.3393305540084839,
0.27484017610549927,
-0.34717848896980286,
-0.8090714812278748,
-0.4834096133708954,
-0.30876389145851135,
0.5276884436607361,
0.5472003221511841,
-1.0732777118682861,
0.4780033230781555,
-0.08483782410621643,
-0.15814805030822754,
-0.5585092902183533,
-0.1286352127790451,
0.06968161463737488,
0.46046119928359985,
0.529413640499115,
0.2055455595254898,
-0.36699768900871277,
-0.47187739610671997,
0.09159933030605316,
-0.09207520633935928,
-0.22379684448242188,
0.08119404315948486,
0.2813168466091156,
-0.19536817073822021,
0.7753716707229614,
-0.42189016938209534,
0.11075591295957565,
-0.39255115389823914,
0.2302091270685196,
0.019947195425629616,
0.20363347232341766,
0.46855834126472473,
-0.6177448630332947,
-0.0018239552155137062,
-0.4054292142391205,
-0.7695680856704712,
-0.14474381506443024,
-0.21440869569778442,
-0.2805514931678772,
-0.06369344145059586,
0.7584984302520752,
-0.5797039866447449,
0.4553282558917999,
0.4739597737789154,
-0.379457950592041,
0.7873788475990295,
-0.4130555987358093,
0.5603487491607666,
-1.034622073173523,
-0.2562576234340668,
-0.4199729859828949,
-0.00962037593126297,
-0.47540992498397827,
0.500224769115448,
0.10553359985351562,
-0.021495461463928223,
-0.13170930743217468,
0.08415001630783081,
-0.3805736303329468,
0.05922748148441315,
-0.2315392643213272,
-0.01223781332373619,
0.17467734217643738,
0.33942195773124695,
-0.22159728407859802,
0.784558892250061,
0.5512299537658691,
-0.6777797341346741,
0.22155910730361938,
0.49206891655921936,
-0.23561589419841766,
0.539350688457489,
-0.5825296640396118,
0.3032148480415344,
-0.33401650190353394,
0.3589426577091217,
-1.056220531463623,
-0.025237955152988434,
0.19052276015281677,
-0.5424004793167114,
-0.015231646597385406,
-0.3263190984725952,
-0.46292930841445923,
-0.42444297671318054,
-0.40973183512687683,
0.7922834753990173,
0.47194957733154297,
-0.8892020583152771,
1.0618607997894287,
0.11599486321210861,
-0.18326495587825775,
-0.14192883670330048,
-0.3294259011745453,
0.10281307250261307,
-0.3541732728481293,
-0.9220139384269714,
0.1114850863814354,
-0.32287925481796265,
-0.35721445083618164,
-0.07207560539245605,
0.014427060261368752,
0.22805118560791016,
0.05903543159365654,
0.13788814842700958,
0.1427871137857437,
-0.24619072675704956,
-0.08911504596471786,
0.12628543376922607,
-0.24239206314086914,
0.11563791334629059,
-0.08569544553756714,
0.5915489196777344,
-0.059492211788892746,
-0.5142596364021301,
-0.062076274305582047,
0.6630244851112366,
0.6431617736816406,
-0.6038068532943726,
0.6396197080612183,
0.2811397910118103,
-0.038279738277196884,
-0.4186582565307617,
-0.44887810945510864,
-0.12162467837333679,
-0.37564611434936523,
-0.23826701939105988,
-0.7835400700569153,
-0.9587257504463196,
0.7125221490859985,
-0.259010374546051,
0.01588565856218338,
0.6321772336959839,
0.6173645853996277,
-0.06903426349163055,
1.1962329149246216,
0.13704665005207062,
0.23242804408073425,
0.03276611492037773,
-0.36267319321632385,
0.1524537056684494,
-0.9842652082443237,
-0.28490930795669556,
-0.8945479393005371,
0.16682015359401703,
-0.45500627160072327,
-0.7605689764022827,
0.47256460785865784,
0.20133869349956512,
-0.385921835899353,
0.16805845499038696,
-0.23056408762931824,
0.37215834856033325,
0.7637976408004761,
0.008094496093690395,
0.5223575830459595,
-0.12367409467697144,
-0.5602185130119324,
0.3440099060535431,
-0.7730907797813416,
-0.2540513575077057,
1.0927863121032715,
0.3789612054824829,
1.1055951118469238,
0.06492279469966888,
0.706925630569458,
-0.22409598529338837,
-0.2539910674095154,
-0.590317964553833,
0.4605046808719635,
-0.07862699776887894,
-0.587490975856781,
-0.427824467420578,
-0.7812095284461975,
-0.8592664003372192,
0.4980567395687103,
0.01556809339672327,
-0.47509539127349854,
0.34088727831840515,
-0.40721702575683594,
-0.5957202315330505,
0.5794541239738464,
-0.5472038388252258,
0.6274575591087341,
-0.24238009750843048,
0.10395482182502747,
-0.041982319205999374,
-0.7154840230941772,
0.4181874096393585,
0.16885478794574738,
0.38502615690231323,
-0.030760109424591064,
0.3124229609966278,
0.7237730026245117,
-0.4780562222003937,
0.2936403453350067,
0.01240796223282814,
-0.41774222254753113,
0.6482510566711426,
0.2935599982738495,
0.3311719596385956,
0.07365894317626953,
0.20265990495681763,
0.0050750006921589375,
-0.019278503954410553,
-0.15569651126861572,
-0.5286384224891663,
0.632060706615448,
-0.5360998511314392,
-0.6271173357963562,
-0.2659926116466522,
-0.38924500346183777,
-0.40646064281463623,
-0.015779519453644753,
0.2709532082080841,
0.5014731287956238,
-0.10499731451272964,
0.06825757771730423,
0.9686846137046814,
-0.4251924157142639,
0.2687748670578003,
0.34006333351135254,
-0.3589114844799042,
-0.723775327205658,
0.4940755069255829,
-0.1495034247636795,
0.46687015891075134,
0.31947049498558044,
0.3322161138057709,
-0.39440780878067017,
-0.5435143113136292,
-0.5977185964584351,
0.2548567056655884,
-0.7970333099365234,
-0.21037021279335022,
-0.8166433572769165,
-0.2645978331565857,
-0.5095525979995728,
-0.052284497767686844,
-0.1752922087907791,
-0.269090473651886,
-0.055002015084028244,
-0.2616380453109741,
0.09409205615520477,
0.25732049345970154,
-0.2709696888923645,
-0.16048811376094818,
-0.6798799633979797,
1.079826831817627,
0.9980764985084534,
0.2698402404785156,
-0.04218770191073418,
-0.4766105115413666,
0.1519891619682312,
0.1460060179233551,
-0.06870018690824509,
-0.9749369025230408,
-0.03718432039022446,
-0.003790266579017043,
0.6739400029182434,
0.5466692447662354,
0.11223478615283966,
0.3727632462978363,
-0.39570537209510803,
0.5636858344078064,
-0.050939615815877914,
-0.6940780878067017,
0.5410737991333008,
-0.36196577548980713,
0.4259226620197296,
0.5499050617218018,
0.26042136549949646,
-0.16553716361522675,
-0.494360089302063,
-0.7062970995903015,
-0.7697101831436157,
0.36893829703330994,
0.26901108026504517,
-0.33990517258644104,
-0.10444744676351547,
0.13073764741420746,
0.19407838582992554,
-0.39878156781196594,
-0.25618845224380493,
-0.2409951388835907,
-0.15639178454875946,
0.20233656466007233,
0.24307577311992645,
-0.6161718964576721,
-0.15299583971500397,
-0.2907100319862366,
0.5189525485038757,
-0.17348161339759827,
0.39319756627082825,
0.19647099077701569,
0.0716545432806015,
-0.06154695525765419,
0.67629075050354,
0.29479876160621643,
0.7476570010185242,
-0.4346907138824463,
0.590691089630127,
-0.03898791968822479,
-0.13142114877700806,
0.4088296592235565,
0.1167927160859108,
-0.5007426738739014,
-0.21300087869167328,
0.3529491722583771,
0.2616596221923828,
-0.328294575214386,
-0.3418829143047333,
0.40781280398368835,
-0.23397205770015717,
-0.4877176582813263,
0.08470983058214188,
-0.14057277143001556,
0.30886220932006836,
0.2951612174510956,
0.34711840748786926,
-0.06909583508968353,
0.08166132867336273,
-0.45401638746261597,
0.2547762393951416,
0.2682168781757355,
0.07057462632656097,
-0.06410311907529831,
0.9863088726997375,
0.10141341388225555,
0.32933419942855835,
0.771808385848999,
-0.38903331756591797,
-0.6937809586524963,
0.7471087574958801,
0.34009143710136414,
0.9214798808097839,
-0.4332049489021301,
0.5266492366790771,
0.5073294043540955,
0.552480936050415,
-0.06651896238327026,
0.569192111492157,
0.114099882543087,
-0.8391343951225281,
-0.961670458316803,
-0.36754122376441956,
-0.13995446264743805,
0.14124087989330292,
-0.3739219605922699,
-0.13690397143363953,
-0.30822861194610596,
-0.06923897564411163,
0.05409491807222366,
-0.5530499815940857,
-0.6378428339958191,
-0.07608842849731445,
0.158370241522789,
0.7248015999794006,
-0.721644401550293,
0.4282107651233673,
0.5267561078071594,
-0.6944243311882019,
-1.022716999053955,
0.22289088368415833,
-0.13137389719486237,
-0.482814759016037,
0.26793476939201355,
-0.1291383057832718,
-0.2705915570259094,
-0.14115196466445923,
-0.7004479765892029,
-0.7103158831596375,
0.8615150451660156,
0.19766420125961304,
-0.11756964027881622,
0.07600948959589005,
0.14029911160469055,
0.40100327134132385,
-0.19776906073093414,
0.3097544014453888,
0.6274346709251404,
0.5538049340248108,
0.37531226873397827,
-0.8072937726974487,
0.08194971084594727,
0.08283223956823349,
-0.10268444567918777,
0.14803116023540497,
-0.35533222556114197,
0.9559652805328369,
-0.5144996643066406,
-0.28948062658309937,
0.20757532119750977,
0.5001503825187683,
0.4301675856113434,
0.30768632888793945,
0.59913170337677,
1.0091404914855957,
0.4699632525444031,
-0.0703413262963295,
0.9335556626319885,
0.08357023447751999,
0.4436150789260864,
1.017773151397705,
-0.05451620742678642,
0.4370271861553192,
0.240694060921669,
-0.34970900416374207,
0.6286354064941406,
0.5590305328369141,
0.28950759768486023,
0.5647163391113281,
0.31920066475868225,
-0.13905620574951172,
-0.6884104609489441,
-0.017012547701597214,
-0.5364316701889038,
0.5186895132064819,
0.21896617114543915,
-0.16225582361221313,
-0.4448387324810028,
0.30630016326904297,
-0.05146067962050438,
-0.11439576745033264,
-0.2706567645072937,
0.9189887642860413,
-0.000686262093950063,
-0.5920770168304443,
0.7100498080253601,
0.16455677151679993,
0.3447026312351227,
-0.39732474088668823,
-0.2065434604883194,
-0.611939549446106,
-0.009400430135428905,
-0.05326716974377632,
-0.7960212230682373,
-0.043858740478754044,
-0.12427129596471786,
-0.06976749747991562,
-0.13744498789310455,
0.722318708896637,
-0.4608144462108612,
-0.33227792382240295,
0.2649019956588745,
0.9912439584732056,
0.04718153551220894,
-0.33840668201446533,
-0.4635836184024811,
-0.2702960968017578,
0.04376106336712837,
-0.051181476563215256,
0.13440710306167603,
0.8607054352760315,
0.0432579442858696,
0.7530230283737183,
0.5318790674209595,
-0.22757507860660553,
0.18427792191505432,
0.47144147753715515,
0.8296557664871216,
-0.5818971395492554,
-0.588837742805481,
-0.441011518239975,
0.20728562772274017,
0.25270313024520874,
0.08707351982593536,
0.8696461319923401,
0.44369664788246155,
0.5626859664916992,
-0.07574194669723511,
0.7307098507881165,
-0.34245923161506653,
0.7620957493782043,
-0.672907829284668,
0.14812658727169037,
-0.33158960938453674,
0.3067903518676758,
-0.30274662375450134,
-0.9532535672187805,
-0.09236622601747513,
0.35898762941360474,
-0.130057230591774,
0.2027350664138794,
1.0074262619018555,
0.5777121782302856,
0.06338796764612198,
0.19723977148532867,
0.17964057624340057,
-0.009807776659727097,
0.5184574127197266,
0.675285816192627,
1.2832531929016113,
-0.20467109978199005,
0.6672033667564392,
-0.3245161771774292,
-0.3906305134296417,
0.07344558835029602,
-0.5258013010025024,
-0.8395974040031433,
-0.6103278994560242,
-0.4151109755039215,
-0.39209774136543274,
-0.2665310800075531,
0.5607231259346008,
0.16199354827404022,
-0.7974064946174622,
0.2893920838832855,
0.01361385639756918,
0.33516690135002136,
-0.6704294085502625,
-0.24287675321102142,
0.7127747535705566,
-0.2965222895145416,
-0.44587695598602295,
0.7913429141044617,
0.2549958825111389,
0.022953150793910027,
-0.352497935295105,
0.13247522711753845,
-0.43502184748649597,
-0.04507429897785187,
0.6028725504875183,
0.19892537593841553,
-0.4314205050468445,
-0.45425108075141907,
0.176707923412323,
0.1637958288192749,
0.04167976975440979,
1.0938247442245483,
-0.6798902153968811,
0.581904947757721,
0.95677649974823,
0.7071503400802612,
0.207405686378479,
0.4621161222457886,
0.322918564081192,
-0.3613833785057068,
-0.36778542399406433,
0.24560332298278809,
0.4376784563064575,
-0.006131914909929037,
-0.0679471343755722,
0.6030436158180237,
0.12728802859783173,
-0.8217039108276367,
-0.11361797899007797,
0.24056415259838104,
-0.9604814052581787,
-0.7322424650192261,
1.5235257148742676,
0.02451534941792488,
-0.009414834901690483,
-0.5371398329734802,
-0.22372737526893616,
0.08250220119953156,
-0.11954988539218903,
0.6749944686889648,
0.5118210911750793,
-0.16440914571285248,
-0.2138666808605194,
-0.5218773484230042,
0.19889594614505768,
0.24802228808403015,
-0.9915701746940613,
0.1336381882429123,
0.787202000617981,
0.29460370540618896,
0.17006973922252655,
0.6691129803657532,
-0.39945295453071594,
0.1187438890337944,
0.09866829216480255,
-0.010416323319077492,
-0.16077670454978943,
-0.4871797561645508,
-0.26210564374923706,
0.6483953595161438,
0.025122283026576042,
-0.45081356167793274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11163v1 | KG-Agent: An Efficient Autonomous Agent Framework for Complex Reasoning over Knowledge Graph | 2024-02-17T02:07:49 | 2024-02-17T02:07:49 | Jinhao Jiang, Kun Zhou, Wayne Xin Zhao, Yang Song, Chen Zhu, Hengshu Zhu, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we aim to improve the reasoning ability of large language
models (LLMs) over knowledge graphs (KGs) to answer complex questions. Inspired
by existing methods that design the interaction strategy between LLMs and KG,
we propose an autonomous LLM-based agent framework, called KG-Agent, which
enables a small LLM to actively make decisions until finishing the reasoning
process over KGs. In KG-Agent, we integrate the LLM, multifunctional toolbox,
KG-based executor, and knowledge memory, and develop an iteration mechanism
that autonomously selects the tool then updates the memory for reasoning over
KG. To guarantee the effectiveness, we leverage program language to formulate
the multi-hop reasoning process over the KG, and synthesize a code-based
instruction dataset to fine-tune the base LLM. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that only using 10K samples for tuning LLaMA-7B can outperform
state-of-the-art methods using larger LLMs or more data, on both in-domain and
out-domain datasets. Our code and data will be publicly released. | [
-0.47392919659614563,
-0.9133590459823608,
0.8252344131469727,
-0.09275061637163162,
-0.04382259398698807,
0.40149468183517456,
-0.23243288695812225,
-0.47883740067481995,
0.07281434535980225,
0.6474412083625793,
-0.39112192392349243,
-0.5368931889533997,
-0.5209705233573914,
-0.07059171795845032,
0.05915725231170654,
0.4773726761341095,
-0.14828823506832123,
-0.10689327865839005,
-0.26486891508102417,
-0.1645175665616989,
-0.21420885622501373,
-0.23241271078586578,
-0.8556546568870544,
-0.7378259897232056,
0.6621698141098022,
0.49000436067581177,
0.9962049722671509,
0.8759258389472961,
0.22780193388462067,
0.42192864418029785,
0.08128094673156738,
0.6214951276779175,
-0.468727707862854,
0.329476535320282,
-0.40580663084983826,
-0.46397730708122253,
-0.6412658095359802,
-0.293851763010025,
0.27127113938331604,
0.4967694580554962,
-0.023306502029299736,
-0.06796589493751526,
-0.491466760635376,
0.5997070074081421,
-0.6118290424346924,
0.6514412760734558,
-0.5516711473464966,
-0.16663560271263123,
0.0182710699737072,
-0.25192248821258545,
-0.5889959931373596,
-0.3587176203727722,
-0.13516032695770264,
-0.7626063823699951,
-0.33315685391426086,
0.14291998744010925,
0.41147470474243164,
0.4545345604419708,
-0.7257046699523926,
-0.4925297200679779,
-0.6117039322853088,
0.5254834294319153,
-0.6169465184211731,
0.2833210825920105,
0.311298131942749,
0.7023316621780396,
-0.6055452227592468,
-0.7566325664520264,
-0.7062209844589233,
-0.3768930435180664,
-0.0003587082901503891,
-0.02891702577471733,
-0.10919807106256485,
0.28530576825141907,
0.16473552584648132,
-0.12132591754198074,
-0.3200805187225342,
0.03374970704317093,
0.09964984655380249,
-0.23718862235546112,
0.7952131032943726,
0.20752234756946564,
0.11076625436544418,
0.06149987876415253,
-0.030640002340078354,
-0.21910178661346436,
-0.6028386354446411,
-0.039289504289627075,
0.5222052931785583,
0.18709801137447357,
0.29777011275291443,
0.6446220278739929,
-0.6647865176200867,
0.9061172604560852,
-0.08557455241680145,
-0.4060444235801697,
0.2095574140548706,
0.13994291424751282,
-0.1946740448474884,
-0.043740347027778625,
0.6534702777862549,
0.328561007976532,
0.43695497512817383,
-0.45459622144699097,
-0.18643295764923096,
-0.08478636294603348,
0.1942002773284912,
-0.663000762462616,
-0.3264791667461395,
0.32083797454833984,
-0.08480748534202576,
-0.17285294830799103,
-0.15374399721622467,
-0.46445634961128235,
-0.5132998824119568,
-0.46485480666160583,
0.6384660601615906,
-0.4651142954826355,
-0.30506882071495056,
0.16713771224021912,
-0.17409302294254303,
0.14903141558170319,
0.6186028122901917,
-0.3790311813354492,
0.10569997131824493,
0.4888686239719391,
0.22822338342666626,
0.053868237882852554,
-0.3587079644203186,
-0.5125528573989868,
0.6103928089141846,
-0.47451069951057434,
0.9609317183494568,
-0.6766314506530762,
-0.18747855722904205,
-0.296414315700531,
0.0015369926113635302,
-0.1323973387479782,
-0.5799278020858765,
0.2530534565448761,
-0.9967058300971985,
-0.2520338296890259,
-0.315591961145401,
-0.6547181010246277,
-0.6586351990699768,
0.5739834904670715,
-0.6166794896125793,
0.7467936277389526,
0.16755534708499908,
-0.23486697673797607,
0.09250614047050476,
-0.901972234249115,
-0.4704861640930176,
0.039371706545352936,
-0.1916879564523697,
-0.17957696318626404,
-0.5048931241035461,
0.29355382919311523,
0.5339074730873108,
-0.3990249037742615,
0.2642034590244293,
-0.5449534058570862,
-0.1954936385154724,
0.1006348729133606,
-0.11710572242736816,
0.6162921786308289,
0.25728192925453186,
-0.14387443661689758,
0.20909905433654785,
-0.799094557762146,
0.5074480772018433,
0.209934264421463,
-0.4229680895805359,
-0.019586341455578804,
0.11409503221511841,
-0.6412749886512756,
0.15209662914276123,
0.310201495885849,
-0.3326793909072876,
0.5768929719924927,
-0.22580486536026,
0.2551146149635315,
0.7625713348388672,
-0.010080402716994286,
0.49492189288139343,
-0.4676661491394043,
0.6333835124969482,
-0.14107313752174377,
0.11045390367507935,
0.05104862153530121,
-0.39391028881073,
-0.732938826084137,
-0.3180570602416992,
0.019189199432730675,
0.5219826102256775,
-1.0578972101211548,
0.23680472373962402,
-0.2551462948322296,
-0.7404395341873169,
-0.24402081966400146,
0.12184713780879974,
0.43037837743759155,
0.44423213601112366,
0.33985087275505066,
0.1379886269569397,
-0.17291826009750366,
-0.7535170912742615,
-0.11578332632780075,
-0.21398122608661652,
0.24496228992938995,
0.631035566329956,
0.43996524810791016,
-0.39245375990867615,
1.17978036403656,
-0.5843797326087952,
-0.000139348951051943,
-0.36142563819885254,
-0.003561087418347597,
0.15349321067333221,
0.22577951848506927,
0.40855661034584045,
-0.7082948684692383,
-0.5407775044441223,
0.4297759532928467,
-0.9319685697555542,
-0.18467779457569122,
0.08316251635551453,
-0.4216669499874115,
0.12681293487548828,
0.5277534127235413,
-0.9356769323348999,
0.11927025765180588,
0.14848592877388,
-0.45234233140945435,
0.5199477076530457,
-0.2858637571334839,
0.15153363347053528,
-0.8499060273170471,
-0.12203647941350937,
-0.5700175166130066,
-0.35396280884742737,
-0.47128239274024963,
0.35898566246032715,
-0.020726319402456284,
0.22210519015789032,
-0.24594426155090332,
0.7271706461906433,
-0.48301467299461365,
-0.039419062435626984,
-0.4853978455066681,
0.12254858762025833,
0.04272398725152016,
0.6841055750846863,
-0.15147067606449127,
0.5761566162109375,
0.5193706154823303,
-0.6908320784568787,
0.9978620409965515,
0.10988233983516693,
-0.23847076296806335,
0.33373016119003296,
-0.377114862203598,
0.41218286752700806,
-0.36458322405815125,
0.34790724515914917,
-0.6530539393424988,
-0.397203654050827,
0.40607598423957825,
-0.3369990885257721,
0.30155935883522034,
-0.1720585823059082,
-0.6613597869873047,
-0.3982030749320984,
-0.005003334488719702,
0.08908988535404205,
0.1990881711244583,
-0.5929150581359863,
1.251815676689148,
0.30717411637306213,
0.10408391803503036,
-0.7526900768280029,
-0.1715550273656845,
0.08188717812299728,
0.022781651467084885,
-0.892422616481781,
0.03803078085184097,
-0.21495281159877777,
-0.3748059868812561,
0.3128051459789276,
-0.008117436431348324,
-0.07399720698595047,
0.13129913806915283,
0.061713796108961105,
-0.17113636434078217,
-0.04628191515803337,
0.3484146296977997,
0.2993572950363159,
-0.32992666959762573,
0.04113532975316048,
-0.3751049041748047,
0.6483303308486938,
-0.06570016592741013,
-0.6681388020515442,
-0.001881215488538146,
0.14594770967960358,
0.7780799865722656,
-0.08672868460416794,
0.5888701677322388,
0.272394597530365,
-0.060487911105155945,
-0.586556077003479,
-0.5689170360565186,
0.07612834870815277,
-0.4985024333000183,
0.4353896677494049,
-0.754852831363678,
-0.8394224047660828,
0.6369479894638062,
-0.5400374531745911,
-0.14919358491897583,
0.27550387382507324,
0.8002380728721619,
0.06214926391839981,
1.0382050275802612,
0.2144360989332199,
-0.10803111642599106,
-0.06839372217655182,
-0.3773494064807892,
0.23676973581314087,
-0.4692915678024292,
-0.42567896842956543,
-0.22659292817115784,
-0.29349273443222046,
-0.16142530739307404,
-0.565790057182312,
0.5041720271110535,
0.2779516279697418,
-0.5572830438613892,
0.2155967503786087,
-0.44895437359809875,
0.7361001968383789,
0.6275571584701538,
-0.0491425096988678,
0.4928220212459564,
-0.49115675687789917,
-0.26571711897850037,
0.6975257992744446,
-0.8795112371444702,
-0.4849403202533722,
0.9500272274017334,
0.0819757953286171,
0.8635980486869812,
0.3067067563533783,
0.2878609299659729,
0.2747490406036377,
0.3261362910270691,
-0.8021208047866821,
0.793198823928833,
0.3806091845035553,
-0.6046417951583862,
-0.5376608967781067,
-0.5854432582855225,
-0.8131189942359924,
0.4111165404319763,
0.05189138278365135,
-0.6485391855239868,
-0.1419258862733841,
0.06396627426147461,
-0.15555407106876373,
0.33996447920799255,
-0.8585249185562134,
0.7457771897315979,
-0.21271932125091553,
-0.10630806535482407,
-0.20868615806102753,
-0.7159522771835327,
0.30321359634399414,
-0.11660974472761154,
0.12718576192855835,
-0.21880541741847992,
0.06825396418571472,
0.328480988740921,
-0.7336593866348267,
0.6481011509895325,
-0.36078283190727234,
-0.09526901692152023,
0.6695724725723267,
0.1172284409403801,
0.9340950846672058,
-0.09708966314792633,
-0.18017427623271942,
-0.2418864518404007,
-0.05708031728863716,
-0.28540265560150146,
-1.0278674364089966,
0.5041107535362244,
-1.0689387321472168,
-0.7581507563591003,
-0.005883190780878067,
-0.9120834469795227,
-0.4289017617702484,
0.28517505526542664,
-0.16146628558635712,
0.2924569845199585,
0.2978322505950928,
0.22984664142131805,
0.4504350423812866,
-0.1059332937002182,
0.31944605708122253,
0.8091093897819519,
-0.25700172781944275,
-0.4594694674015045,
0.864520788192749,
0.3945208787918091,
0.3930220305919647,
0.5523464679718018,
0.29206156730651855,
-0.31375542283058167,
-0.4662230610847473,
-0.7068326473236084,
0.05696622282266617,
-1.0932294130325317,
-0.37565353512763977,
-0.78669273853302,
-0.1767653524875641,
-0.3370717763900757,
-0.20954397320747375,
-0.4181617796421051,
-0.28939560055732727,
0.201134592294693,
-0.17409934103488922,
0.6313286423683167,
0.6570424437522888,
0.07013867795467377,
0.46510952711105347,
-0.6480575203895569,
0.3238985240459442,
0.5804010033607483,
0.24019891023635864,
0.2402319312095642,
-0.17482873797416687,
-0.2109980434179306,
-0.10278516262769699,
-0.19431672990322113,
-0.6938395500183105,
0.17850437760353088,
-0.11062723398208618,
0.8909274339675903,
0.5154029726982117,
0.3805803954601288,
0.643151044845581,
-0.20001673698425293,
0.30845320224761963,
-0.24825118482112885,
-0.8635163903236389,
0.294811874628067,
-0.5576551556587219,
0.25874966382980347,
0.29098525643348694,
0.16112607717514038,
-0.27767500281333923,
-0.5494681000709534,
-0.43698784708976746,
-0.694147527217865,
0.7851999998092651,
0.19207873940467834,
-0.20512664318084717,
0.06578785181045532,
0.485226571559906,
-0.04094942659139633,
0.3085188567638397,
-0.5495449900627136,
-0.2950979769229889,
0.03462117910385132,
-0.25296977162361145,
0.1928154081106186,
-0.10048756003379822,
-0.2632215619087219,
-0.2668899595737457,
0.8930509686470032,
-0.5892812609672546,
0.23097924888134003,
0.03304886072874069,
-0.11305048316717148,
-0.15524370968341827,
0.12927362322807312,
0.32456648349761963,
0.7145153880119324,
-0.02312738075852394,
0.3154255449771881,
0.3391949534416199,
-0.23085829615592957,
0.2931375503540039,
0.16692054271697998,
-0.11346327513456345,
-0.48074063658714294,
0.47917741537094116,
0.6199379563331604,
-0.15717361867427826,
-0.9836778044700623,
0.30683445930480957,
0.20064005255699158,
-0.22960056364536285,
-0.24778588116168976,
0.5175102353096008,
0.5262729525566101,
0.8335615992546082,
0.229146808385849,
-0.02686700038611889,
-0.20281730592250824,
-0.3701855540275574,
0.010312355123460293,
0.4207698404788971,
0.0007499920902773738,
0.11881469935178757,
0.5336120128631592,
0.07884363830089569,
-0.2580958604812622,
0.44874292612075806,
-0.7046118974685669,
-0.5702202916145325,
0.9544895887374878,
0.4507119655609131,
0.452379047870636,
-0.057098690420389175,
0.16944153606891632,
0.05191507935523987,
0.30909788608551025,
0.02034919336438179,
0.32689571380615234,
-0.14882563054561615,
-1.24321711063385,
-0.7778776288032532,
-0.3534986972808838,
-0.5909595489501953,
-0.14350749552249908,
-0.12378256022930145,
0.08313285559415817,
-0.41824471950531006,
0.1280633956193924,
-0.24187126755714417,
0.1846047341823578,
-0.30547285079956055,
0.24258790910243988,
-0.0607382133603096,
0.9308309555053711,
-0.3799130618572235,
1.0570062398910522,
0.727766752243042,
-0.31546175479888916,
-1.2207289934158325,
-0.46990716457366943,
-0.11011648178100586,
-0.9024505019187927,
0.6488685011863708,
0.03816535323858261,
-0.5664100050926208,
0.15367834270000458,
-0.6739027500152588,
-1.0817551612854004,
1.5187009572982788,
0.6095929741859436,
-0.3928545415401459,
0.25624945759773254,
0.15790875256061554,
0.34549185633659363,
-0.4046422839164734,
0.3120587468147278,
0.49385419487953186,
0.8008183836936951,
0.5772575736045837,
-0.7330412268638611,
-0.08499611914157867,
-0.29407960176467896,
-0.4631659984588623,
0.2926602065563202,
-0.9903407096862793,
0.7470139265060425,
-0.3144203722476959,
0.1462942361831665,
-0.04987984523177147,
0.5111851692199707,
0.37584251165390015,
0.45819732546806335,
0.6456040740013123,
0.8209073543548584,
0.9930044412612915,
0.11494451761245728,
1.0886507034301758,
-0.40927720069885254,
0.2660403251647949,
1.090035080909729,
-0.4101993441581726,
0.29471996426582336,
-0.006036472972482443,
-0.04135003313422203,
0.4692697823047638,
0.3621787428855896,
0.10440617799758911,
0.37608298659324646,
0.260576456785202,
-0.42873868346214294,
-0.6756035089492798,
0.023299606516957283,
-0.13851624727249146,
0.5689101815223694,
0.25389614701271057,
-0.05907448008656502,
-0.33242496848106384,
0.10391689091920853,
0.28405889868736267,
-0.08963709324598312,
-0.35774195194244385,
0.7348604202270508,
-0.13331584632396698,
-0.6973804235458374,
0.22879153490066528,
0.19818860292434692,
0.01935899630188942,
-0.7399706244468689,
-0.01702454313635826,
0.09345457702875137,
0.35308563709259033,
-0.1286909431219101,
-0.7251133918762207,
0.1374998539686203,
-0.3144338130950928,
-0.17177893221378326,
0.004777000285685062,
1.0007203817367554,
-0.27373647689819336,
-0.30071091651916504,
0.6438690423965454,
0.7602241635322571,
0.10927743464708328,
-0.172384113073349,
-0.5374099016189575,
-0.1592067927122116,
-0.1354740411043167,
-0.6100260019302368,
0.20606128871440887,
0.8860166668891907,
-0.18458418548107147,
1.251031756401062,
0.657339870929718,
-0.10070163756608963,
0.05337047576904297,
0.16470253467559814,
1.1437739133834839,
-0.6221539974212646,
-0.3433389961719513,
-0.7767909169197083,
0.27285000681877136,
-0.13045820593833923,
0.046500854194164276,
0.6660571694374084,
0.44887229800224304,
0.8183989524841309,
0.021407384425401688,
0.860298216342926,
-0.23423637449741364,
0.3868221044540405,
-0.5276187062263489,
0.7373352646827698,
-0.3329634666442871,
0.16423724591732025,
-0.05560523644089699,
-0.6709055304527283,
-0.23452123999595642,
0.6267983317375183,
-0.4121902585029602,
0.19756031036376953,
0.5036206245422363,
1.0240312814712524,
0.11372162401676178,
-0.033110711723566055,
0.4544205367565155,
0.4122059643268585,
0.546050488948822,
0.6212407350540161,
0.8859903216362,
-0.020936351269483566,
0.715557336807251,
-0.14509087800979614,
-0.14257600903511047,
-0.027878412976861,
-0.8307055830955505,
-0.8757469058036804,
-0.1349523514509201,
-0.17568932473659515,
-0.2899377644062042,
-0.03557289019227028,
1.1542314291000366,
0.6414692401885986,
-0.42540186643600464,
-0.0819942057132721,
-0.1628107875585556,
0.6658108830451965,
-0.3312160074710846,
-0.17895053327083588,
0.39333707094192505,
-0.363779217004776,
-0.6975387930870056,
0.5615383982658386,
0.37950122356414795,
-0.3698209822177887,
-0.25398099422454834,
-0.45040664076805115,
-0.07679377496242523,
0.10066459327936172,
0.8062735199928284,
0.0887296050786972,
-0.4872036278247833,
-0.5138481855392456,
-0.10623638331890106,
0.017032645642757416,
-0.0676317885518074,
0.6171902418136597,
-0.7578374743461609,
0.7159218788146973,
0.42630892992019653,
0.7995004057884216,
0.5156069993972778,
-0.11295818537473679,
0.5142291188240051,
-0.342043399810791,
-0.10011499375104904,
0.20499630272388458,
0.2820724844932556,
-0.04515666887164116,
-0.41336458921432495,
0.5898405909538269,
0.3038095235824585,
-0.6831362843513489,
-0.3509014844894409,
0.4106677174568176,
-1.0740419626235962,
-0.5452266335487366,
1.2906827926635742,
-0.08606447279453278,
-0.32357949018478394,
-0.38219788670539856,
-0.33503302931785583,
0.26521918177604675,
-0.46372613310813904,
0.5498658418655396,
0.7571446299552917,
-0.5313984751701355,
-0.21892434358596802,
-0.3628509044647217,
0.21586352586746216,
-0.051262903958559036,
-0.960992157459259,
-0.036821551620960236,
0.530194103717804,
0.21569372713565826,
0.2014698088169098,
0.849120557308197,
0.07513222843408585,
0.154057115316391,
0.16852967441082,
0.16829444468021393,
-0.6705606579780579,
-0.4947627782821655,
0.3679331839084625,
0.5744958519935608,
0.14786046743392944,
0.10170195996761322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11161v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11161v1 | PANDA (Pedantic ANswer-correctness Determination and Adjudication):Improving Automatic Evaluation for Question Answering and Text Generation | 2024-02-17T01:56:19 | 2024-02-17T01:56:19 | Zongxia Li, Ishani Mondal, Yijun Liang, Huy Nghiem, Jordan Lee Boyd-Graber | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Question answering (QA) can only make progress if we know if an answer is
correct, but for many of the most challenging and interesting QA examples,
current answer correctness (AC) metrics do not align with human judgments,
particularly verbose, free form answers from large language models (LLM). There
are two challenges: a lack of data and that models are too big. LLM based
scorers correlate better with humans, but this expensive task has only been
tested on limited QA datasets. We rectify these issues by providing clear
guidelines for evaluating machine QA adopted from human QA contests. We also
introduce Precise ANswer correctness Determination and Adjudication (PANDA), a
small, efficient, deterministic AC classifier (812 KB) that more accurately
evaluates answer correctness. | [
-0.24945291876792908,
-1.2409281730651855,
0.4373253583908081,
0.3574628233909607,
-0.20508958399295807,
0.06353309750556946,
0.008949034847319126,
-0.16784390807151794,
0.08916371315717697,
0.2690123915672302,
-0.23520246148109436,
-0.24999482929706573,
-0.32522332668304443,
0.4161991477012634,
-0.2961222231388092,
1.1093109846115112,
-0.18754617869853973,
-0.12153878062963486,
-0.5991310477256775,
-0.1761748045682907,
-0.4844507873058319,
-0.5262711048126221,
-0.6752080917358398,
-0.03486932814121246,
0.25506851077079773,
0.4352066218852997,
0.8836972713470459,
0.6189648509025574,
0.7386587858200073,
0.2988163232803345,
-0.29030168056488037,
0.10104365646839142,
-0.09744907915592194,
0.05662396550178528,
-0.13225191831588745,
-0.8421088457107544,
-0.5377033352851868,
0.17628376185894012,
0.5167144536972046,
0.6274265050888062,
-0.4895421862602234,
0.42894577980041504,
-0.27554750442504883,
0.8605599403381348,
-0.6552121639251709,
0.22142861783504486,
-0.6103759407997131,
0.051501862704753876,
-0.05712900310754776,
-0.03222275897860527,
-0.13960212469100952,
-0.8381121754646301,
0.14196035265922546,
-0.9690754413604736,
0.480655312538147,
-0.03239087015390396,
0.8360257148742676,
0.7931635975837708,
-0.4924590289592743,
-0.5279919505119324,
-0.3821187913417816,
0.6705659031867981,
-0.4672674834728241,
-0.03015170432627201,
0.41183456778526306,
0.6222988963127136,
-0.07146590203046799,
-0.5012015104293823,
-0.8362423181533813,
-0.06959167122840881,
0.03850080817937851,
-0.0531051903963089,
-0.2395714670419693,
-0.025902289897203445,
0.3854229152202606,
0.26990559697151184,
-0.6143962144851685,
-0.12488953769207001,
-0.43870481848716736,
-0.09790340811014175,
0.8941150307655334,
0.4770350456237793,
0.23339343070983887,
-0.24515219032764435,
0.08493009209632874,
-0.13484708964824677,
-0.6483162641525269,
0.5364800095558167,
0.5596864223480225,
-0.15861453115940094,
0.27922388911247253,
0.7253172397613525,
-0.3219398260116577,
0.7715449333190918,
0.5737860202789307,
-0.024424726143479347,
0.09184765815734863,
-0.3325851559638977,
-0.07375393807888031,
0.056474097073078156,
0.7611971497535706,
0.31541091203689575,
0.2306632101535797,
-0.05622896924614906,
-0.05807911232113838,
0.40577030181884766,
0.44485539197921753,
-0.7113631963729858,
-0.6204130053520203,
0.4390900731086731,
-0.2936519980430603,
-0.42759087681770325,
0.05454382300376892,
-0.6652668118476868,
-0.3896133303642273,
-0.25600749254226685,
0.34860891103744507,
-0.21224644780158997,
-0.161021888256073,
0.0891847312450409,
-0.2218039482831955,
0.34406107664108276,
0.6012269854545593,
-0.6777474284172058,
0.1699056774377823,
0.7623081207275391,
0.39683833718299866,
0.010945698246359825,
-0.08724988251924515,
-0.8602046966552734,
-0.2602801024913788,
-0.8830893635749817,
0.9759098887443542,
-0.4292457699775696,
-0.23865634202957153,
-0.24810652434825897,
-0.01534265000373125,
-0.14228078722953796,
-0.8333310484886169,
0.684174120426178,
-0.582088828086853,
0.4134156107902527,
-0.3259342908859253,
-0.449533611536026,
-0.3429816961288452,
0.28978440165519714,
-0.7285704016685486,
0.8927309513092041,
0.19224078953266144,
-0.7814163565635681,
0.48752498626708984,
-0.6238750219345093,
-0.41413888335227966,
0.06207275390625,
0.08655525743961334,
-0.5508764386177063,
-0.08287648111581802,
0.29057568311691284,
0.33728843927383423,
-0.2192850410938263,
0.2798408567905426,
-0.2907717525959015,
-0.5319327116012573,
0.45371460914611816,
-0.4942876696586609,
0.9591993093490601,
0.3066421449184418,
-0.10466598719358444,
0.04704580828547478,
-0.7875326871871948,
0.015608380548655987,
0.13405615091323853,
-0.7014145255088806,
-0.1454593390226364,
-0.007441992871463299,
-0.2834315001964569,
0.14609460532665253,
0.46614065766334534,
-0.6447643637657166,
0.15318310260772705,
-0.3334667980670929,
0.5144940614700317,
0.7738720178604126,
-0.12603406608104706,
0.25547367334365845,
-0.6039056777954102,
0.8394348621368408,
-0.04266832396388054,
0.003695255843922496,
0.0963713601231575,
-0.7618066072463989,
-0.5725919008255005,
-0.07635427266359329,
0.44700583815574646,
1.0345678329467773,
-0.7353841066360474,
0.5540511608123779,
-0.16146227717399597,
-0.7273587584495544,
-0.8931381702423096,
0.3502739369869232,
0.45666447281837463,
0.5668330788612366,
0.21582135558128357,
-0.2549726366996765,
-0.2533125877380371,
-0.7350527048110962,
-0.3370860815048218,
-0.8207877278327942,
0.04381862282752991,
0.2838713824748993,
0.37208133935928345,
0.14189931750297546,
0.8835473656654358,
-0.6667002439498901,
0.005105138290673494,
0.06487038731575012,
0.1829672008752823,
0.08408358693122864,
0.32409948110580444,
0.5018503069877625,
-0.9978504180908203,
-0.5591776967048645,
-0.22589519619941711,
-0.6571510434150696,
-0.17840193212032318,
0.13645467162132263,
0.05405251681804657,
0.3857104480266571,
0.1409408301115036,
-0.6462205648422241,
0.36224165558815,
0.18621015548706055,
-0.43407660722732544,
0.8828156590461731,
-0.13209421932697296,
0.38392844796180725,
-0.6471535563468933,
0.20180977880954742,
0.04103101044893265,
-0.29377323389053345,
-0.344818115234375,
0.01959964632987976,
0.20045512914657593,
-0.02018585056066513,
-0.33914893865585327,
0.47338026762008667,
0.00983328279107809,
0.14590738713741302,
0.007484389003366232,
0.3515419363975525,
0.2923528552055359,
0.44270944595336914,
-0.023047083988785744,
1.0437675714492798,
0.10584716498851776,
-0.7693068385124207,
0.9665282368659973,
0.45658451318740845,
-0.4564110338687897,
1.0472068786621094,
-0.7965854406356812,
0.17460638284683228,
-0.2797531485557556,
0.2887342870235443,
-1.2049946784973145,
-0.18884599208831787,
0.24313269555568695,
-0.7420926094055176,
0.32023102045059204,
0.22193671762943268,
-0.5977173447608948,
-0.5707219243049622,
-0.3591651916503906,
0.4905424118041992,
0.5071040987968445,
-0.5566787719726562,
0.15508079528808594,
0.41595712304115295,
-0.3838723599910736,
-0.8030595779418945,
-0.40481695532798767,
0.09672421962022781,
-0.3273298442363739,
-0.7123926281929016,
-0.08648241311311722,
-0.44161146879196167,
-0.5655194520950317,
-0.06650100648403168,
-0.051817476749420166,
-0.2907892167568207,
0.383563756942749,
-0.1572795808315277,
0.02269081585109234,
-0.2317049652338028,
0.32144439220428467,
-0.03368774428963661,
-0.00505225220695138,
0.2297564297914505,
0.3808214068412781,
0.2187964916229248,
-0.3280642330646515,
-0.07130947709083557,
-0.7192348837852478,
0.1734466552734375,
0.36059924960136414,
-0.2859702408313751,
0.357255220413208,
0.37608209252357483,
-0.31938639283180237,
0.10253952443599701,
-0.5550268292427063,
0.18430855870246887,
-0.3997122347354889,
0.27542826533317566,
-0.45465904474258423,
-0.46925589442253113,
0.43831348419189453,
0.40048375725746155,
0.16929368674755096,
0.7012885212898254,
0.37151268124580383,
-0.25859546661376953,
1.3642436265945435,
0.3734537661075592,
0.24482925236225128,
0.22379019856452942,
-0.05322915315628052,
0.008789373561739922,
-0.7882890105247498,
-0.18882597982883453,
-0.9187554121017456,
0.0058973138220608234,
-0.4093407392501831,
-0.13308092951774597,
0.16053546965122223,
0.32204562425613403,
-0.3563344180583954,
0.39734581112861633,
-0.7563962340354919,
0.1614910066127777,
0.48341694474220276,
-0.002738282550126314,
0.27189409732818604,
-0.4891134202480316,
0.1889307051897049,
0.05330055579543114,
-0.5895702242851257,
-0.7834623456001282,
1.2365894317626953,
0.16501149535179138,
0.6624636650085449,
0.20045128464698792,
0.36289018392562866,
0.38464751839637756,
0.49448591470718384,
-0.7475863099098206,
0.4720376133918762,
-0.15893301367759705,
-0.843849241733551,
-0.40347275137901306,
-0.5617663264274597,
-0.7497989535331726,
0.04898460954427719,
-0.006536792032420635,
-0.359357625246048,
0.033271126449108124,
0.07964621484279633,
-0.5922155380249023,
-0.02638322487473488,
-0.8743162155151367,
1.0317966938018799,
-0.10095866024494171,
-0.01822630688548088,
0.004403186496347189,
-0.7166001200675964,
0.41076287627220154,
-0.29088321328163147,
0.05295737087726593,
-0.1487209051847458,
-0.1663975566625595,
1.0252183675765991,
-0.41271141171455383,
0.5547595024108887,
-0.13466614484786987,
-0.4194248914718628,
0.6605883240699768,
0.08583138138055801,
0.33319640159606934,
0.04439834505319595,
-0.24109509587287903,
-0.2441130429506302,
0.6115711331367493,
-0.5293367505073547,
-0.7933397889137268,
0.3629382252693176,
-0.8004649877548218,
-0.8863118290901184,
-0.4206034243106842,
-0.2615807056427002,
-0.05639377608895302,
-0.2142372876405716,
0.1772407591342926,
0.10306934267282486,
-0.31760796904563904,
0.16594958305358887,
0.859586238861084,
-0.3746509253978729,
-0.08324547111988068,
0.5927858352661133,
-0.10560969263315201,
-0.5725574493408203,
0.871495246887207,
0.2077273428440094,
0.0011642702156677842,
0.6043652296066284,
0.040242649614810944,
-0.5575401186943054,
-0.16702480614185333,
-0.8562306761741638,
0.2666224539279938,
-0.8522846102714539,
-0.237404927611351,
-0.5231135487556458,
-0.012190527282655239,
-0.6217647790908813,
-0.1260281801223755,
0.040030304342508316,
-0.8580828309059143,
-0.4825332462787628,
-0.10648053139448166,
0.2105584740638733,
0.7077240347862244,
0.012153453193604946,
0.22338207066059113,
-0.6511496305465698,
0.6093598008155823,
0.6670097708702087,
0.16003096103668213,
-0.28392109274864197,
-0.39371225237846375,
0.1471167355775833,
0.28278571367263794,
-0.671176552772522,
-0.8400104641914368,
0.049363747239112854,
0.2779981195926666,
0.5145999193191528,
0.4696517288684845,
0.2259608507156372,
0.5698267817497253,
-0.1920156329870224,
1.109884262084961,
0.10575584322214127,
-0.9337807893753052,
0.859469473361969,
0.007682850118726492,
-0.05663440376520157,
0.36308515071868896,
0.005413569509983063,
-0.5229718089103699,
-0.27019864320755005,
-0.7050666213035583,
-0.38404884934425354,
0.6940925717353821,
0.018454307690262794,
-0.015699878334999084,
-0.17389865219593048,
0.5410724878311157,
0.0933506190776825,
0.34426671266555786,
-0.29365596175193787,
-0.17390422523021698,
-0.3991096317768097,
-0.4022035598754883,
-0.29539453983306885,
-0.11171777546405792,
-0.14776664972305298,
-0.11102912575006485,
0.8698216676712036,
-0.2544132471084595,
0.04121727868914604,
0.24645839631557465,
-0.06503480672836304,
-0.39974069595336914,
0.2591279447078705,
0.29047346115112305,
0.8189234733581543,
-0.20283621549606323,
-0.19812138378620148,
0.17159001529216766,
-0.36779269576072693,
0.3660232722759247,
0.2464476376771927,
-0.34381577372550964,
-0.07027758657932281,
0.13859820365905762,
0.4041166305541992,
-0.4010976552963257,
-0.8867471814155579,
0.8321822285652161,
-0.5323494076728821,
-0.09514851123094559,
-0.2981380820274353,
0.4025301933288574,
-0.18482565879821777,
-0.01573897711932659,
0.2773842513561249,
-0.06757491081953049,
0.07335665076971054,
-0.39586135745048523,
0.06617037951946259,
0.44837427139282227,
-0.36678197979927063,
-0.1795704960823059,
0.9400942325592041,
0.15861578285694122,
-0.5644780397415161,
0.6945840120315552,
-0.18862205743789673,
-0.6098699569702148,
1.0586320161819458,
0.15799057483673096,
0.760231614112854,
-0.2643046975135803,
0.4947846829891205,
0.3568660020828247,
0.24194426834583282,
0.05522512272000313,
0.43767762184143066,
-0.3013232350349426,
-0.4843173921108246,
-0.3264416754245758,
-0.6772889494895935,
-0.5514941215515137,
-0.23869119584560394,
-0.5603346228599548,
0.30120864510536194,
-0.4646108150482178,
-0.16694672405719757,
0.12871763110160828,
0.6278020739555359,
-0.5702456831932068,
0.5070341229438782,
-0.3311556279659271,
0.8993670344352722,
-0.5902222990989685,
0.4925678074359894,
1.131752610206604,
-0.707621693611145,
-0.6816537380218506,
-0.09956987202167511,
-0.2644837200641632,
-0.5015130639076233,
0.5684257745742798,
0.17237786948680878,
0.19187615811824799,
-0.17190085351467133,
-0.7531201243400574,
-0.37869206070899963,
1.0526155233383179,
0.3308476209640503,
-0.14603856205940247,
-0.06539931148290634,
-0.00803658738732338,
0.767336368560791,
0.07769071310758591,
0.14892061054706573,
0.5696559548377991,
0.37186315655708313,
-0.031204257160425186,
-1.0927798748016357,
-0.07167600840330124,
-0.46821102499961853,
-0.08328588306903839,
0.02504921890795231,
-0.7854841351509094,
0.7197823524475098,
-0.5158056616783142,
-0.2722994089126587,
0.5028999447822571,
0.6695759296417236,
0.34347963333129883,
0.4236335754394531,
0.4990401864051819,
0.8743010759353638,
0.9554972052574158,
-0.2369246631860733,
0.9678794145584106,
-0.04450593888759613,
0.14937031269073486,
0.551541805267334,
-0.1418745219707489,
0.7883623838424683,
0.23809881508350372,
-0.6329705119132996,
0.41391727328300476,
1.0031980276107788,
0.26445189118385315,
0.22142428159713745,
0.3144921660423279,
-0.08171048760414124,
-0.465442031621933,
0.08560329675674438,
-0.2756939232349396,
0.5269913673400879,
0.42790669202804565,
-0.030652722343802452,
-0.0385381318628788,
-0.26070281863212585,
-0.009020635858178139,
0.4606550335884094,
-0.3027629256248474,
0.9970003962516785,
-0.1055152416229248,
-1.1085541248321533,
0.7534199953079224,
0.10132299363613129,
0.46871301531791687,
-0.2395276129245758,
-0.2162642627954483,
-0.3042707145214081,
0.23703330755233765,
-0.12744693458080292,
-1.0780428647994995,
0.3536255657672882,
0.2837532162666321,
-0.26409614086151123,
0.23929578065872192,
0.333530992269516,
-0.2932887077331543,
-0.4516972005367279,
-0.30288198590278625,
0.2790682911872864,
0.4494578540325165,
-0.15132761001586914,
-0.7700415849685669,
-0.467793345451355,
-0.22129078209400177,
-0.10349281132221222,
-0.04045232757925987,
0.7538949847221375,
-0.041777703911066055,
0.8768991827964783,
0.6061944961547852,
0.012141600251197815,
0.17677690088748932,
-0.5337231755256653,
0.5280627012252808,
-0.3992687165737152,
-0.6076962351799011,
-0.40410280227661133,
0.1493706852197647,
0.03651968017220497,
-0.41267067193984985,
0.5337801575660706,
0.6618646383285522,
0.6515724658966064,
0.10342706739902496,
0.8474451899528503,
-0.10012985020875931,
0.8360835313796997,
-0.2728978991508484,
0.6470707058906555,
-0.6387415528297424,
0.22876688838005066,
-0.3098938763141632,
-0.8204396367073059,
-0.3957786560058594,
0.7252131700515747,
-0.35348090529441833,
-0.1464756578207016,
0.37801095843315125,
0.5687591433525085,
0.35994952917099,
0.13923168182373047,
0.08588138967752457,
0.06315691769123077,
0.5050248503684998,
0.7717634439468384,
0.9210097193717957,
-0.6242825388908386,
0.9180079102516174,
-0.3513323962688446,
-0.3228842616081238,
-0.2665621340274811,
-0.6324797868728638,
-0.6092682480812073,
-0.7028982639312744,
-0.5939604640007019,
-0.4973837435245514,
0.07569877803325653,
0.6375588178634644,
0.20580191910266876,
-0.8973075151443481,
0.04946284741163254,
0.06615851819515228,
0.46992793679237366,
-0.4804013669490814,
-0.32871928811073303,
0.6410723924636841,
-0.5165374875068665,
-0.8270400166511536,
-0.1552933305501938,
-0.03399623930454254,
-0.05643906071782112,
-0.2916256785392761,
-0.14710074663162231,
-0.052121732383966446,
0.2089547961950302,
0.3696913421154022,
0.3749680817127228,
-0.6308882832527161,
-0.35082218050956726,
0.09262975305318832,
-0.2238541841506958,
0.15143373608589172,
0.4250567555427551,
-0.9210045337677002,
0.5237924456596375,
0.6546188592910767,
0.6895915865898132,
-0.15765807032585144,
0.45304253697395325,
0.5342850089073181,
-0.27194932103157043,
-0.33998361229896545,
0.35097700357437134,
0.251706063747406,
0.6518805027008057,
-0.3862076997756958,
0.5370027422904968,
0.35058778524398804,
-0.8490120768547058,
-0.8023653030395508,
0.09580670297145844,
-0.6885374188423157,
-0.27848517894744873,
1.1330857276916504,
-0.39134740829467773,
-0.44880467653274536,
-0.3917829692363739,
-0.6016365885734558,
0.3984372019767761,
-0.3551318645477295,
1.1233857870101929,
0.9563570618629456,
-0.16395027935504913,
0.19052237272262573,
-0.1748470664024353,
0.7020043134689331,
0.32788950204849243,
-0.8255494832992554,
0.20793724060058594,
0.5428923964500427,
0.3537086844444275,
0.38136106729507446,
0.7132514119148254,
-0.12458417564630508,
0.8399084806442261,
-0.06006729230284691,
-0.2461012899875641,
0.16087451577186584,
-0.31280988454818726,
-0.3373887836933136,
0.27188488841056824,
0.13094598054885864,
-0.2774815857410431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11159v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11159v3 | Assessing News Thumbnail Representativeness: Counterfactual text can enhance the cross-modal matching ability | 2024-02-17T01:27:29 | 2024-06-07T00:56:09 | Yejun Yoon, Seunghyun Yoon, Kunwoo Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | This paper addresses the critical challenge of assessing the
representativeness of news thumbnail images, which often serve as the first
visual engagement for readers when an article is disseminated on social media.
We focus on whether a news image represents the actors discussed in the news
text. To serve the challenge, we introduce NewsTT, a manually annotated dataset
of 1000 news thumbnail images and text pairs. We found that the pretrained
vision and language models, such as BLIP-2, struggle with this task. Since news
subjects frequently involve named entities or proper nouns, the pretrained
models could have a limited capability to match news actors' visual and textual
appearances. We hypothesize that learning to contrast news text with its
counterfactual, of which named entities are replaced, can enhance the
cross-modal matching ability of vision and language models. We propose
CFT-CLIP, a contrastive learning framework that updates vision and language
bi-encoders according to the hypothesis. We found that our simple method can
boost the performance for assessing news thumbnail representativeness,
supporting our assumption. Code and data can be accessed at
https://github.com/ssu-humane/news-images-acl24. | [
-0.41114526987075806,
-0.6986476182937622,
0.5269776582717896,
0.23025406897068024,
-0.8077110052108765,
0.3756283223628998,
0.0035982795525342226,
-0.6056623458862305,
0.40206098556518555,
0.2029569298028946,
-0.37150806188583374,
-0.28105005621910095,
-0.6263386607170105,
0.14105741679668427,
-0.6895724534988403,
0.8234343528747559,
0.004426566418260336,
0.03338966891169548,
-0.18207836151123047,
-0.3180031180381775,
-0.08908899128437042,
-0.06822271645069122,
-0.48588159680366516,
0.1611424684524536,
0.30007028579711914,
0.13618075847625732,
1.1559072732925415,
0.5885427594184875,
0.5332753658294678,
0.32869014143943787,
0.19943857192993164,
-0.16263838112354279,
-0.41318169236183167,
-0.47693687677383423,
-0.5283187627792358,
-0.19291232526302338,
0.1574665755033493,
0.47162508964538574,
0.49326080083847046,
0.3217284083366394,
0.3704679310321808,
0.22704599797725677,
-0.025551093742251396,
0.5995299816131592,
-0.42279547452926636,
-0.016568729653954506,
-0.872525691986084,
0.062048256397247314,
-0.22157436609268188,
-0.2951594889163971,
-0.1731223165988922,
-0.35804232954978943,
0.22941119968891144,
-0.49945974349975586,
0.6198611259460449,
0.10164518654346466,
1.1403248310089111,
0.11511889845132828,
-0.5376598238945007,
-0.13912713527679443,
-0.21893130242824554,
0.5473684072494507,
-0.3340911865234375,
0.8221806287765503,
0.16758790612220764,
0.27053117752075195,
0.3782978057861328,
-0.37334248423576355,
-0.7716442346572876,
-0.20031674206256866,
-0.24482040107250214,
0.18922825157642365,
-0.6948454976081848,
-0.3859264850616455,
0.16576217114925385,
0.40436607599258423,
-0.7463070750236511,
-0.12315649539232254,
-0.3752453029155731,
-0.30023810267448425,
0.24539969861507416,
-0.13329021632671356,
0.48999595642089844,
-0.3009214699268341,
-0.6204936504364014,
-0.25929081439971924,
-0.44241076707839966,
-0.02143058367073536,
0.26576635241508484,
0.03905526548624039,
-0.3211289942264557,
0.5062611103057861,
-0.09766599535942078,
0.4370504319667816,
0.31396767497062683,
0.032320957630872726,
0.33304038643836975,
-0.5578002333641052,
-0.25017449259757996,
0.14663363993167877,
0.6878294348716736,
1.011252760887146,
0.09427962452173233,
-0.22302961349487305,
0.03338420391082764,
0.26605287194252014,
0.2631331980228424,
-0.8057299852371216,
-0.09598799049854279,
0.05929042771458626,
-0.4592546820640564,
-0.3994044065475464,
0.20815995335578918,
-0.8783766031265259,
-0.23437556624412537,
-0.1342705637216568,
0.7172612547874451,
-0.27579131722450256,
-0.3900679349899292,
-0.12271782755851746,
-0.49374738335609436,
0.26811468601226807,
0.40695440769195557,
-0.5397565364837646,
0.03063107840716839,
0.5196232795715332,
1.0265001058578491,
-0.17639406025409698,
-0.33552685379981995,
-0.5160848498344421,
-0.07413144409656525,
-0.6927512288093567,
0.8953466415405273,
-0.7204865217208862,
-0.09582730382680893,
-0.030430547893047333,
0.02621067687869072,
0.07312946766614914,
-0.6321833729743958,
0.2165101021528244,
-0.40657833218574524,
0.20398138463497162,
-0.6613231897354126,
-0.22753407061100006,
-0.11628325283527374,
0.42927688360214233,
-0.9666349291801453,
0.9061806797981262,
0.4245918393135071,
-1.104926347732544,
0.6585509777069092,
-0.10017097741365433,
-0.5057075619697571,
-0.2302108258008957,
-0.3430492579936981,
-0.4845540225505829,
0.201258584856987,
0.5538343787193298,
0.41569784283638,
0.0035485532134771347,
0.046524833887815475,
-0.37776145339012146,
-0.36109891533851624,
0.2631835341453552,
-0.29256415367126465,
0.5532650947570801,
-0.1622813493013382,
-0.2852383852005005,
0.08628085255622864,
-0.5188625454902649,
-0.41117656230926514,
0.0440150685608387,
-0.09449335187673569,
-0.5460427403450012,
-0.3118635416030884,
0.43649405241012573,
0.28709936141967773,
0.01583956927061081,
-0.7234976887702942,
-0.07807013392448425,
0.03815276920795441,
0.3673284947872162,
0.44781723618507385,
0.10143276304006577,
0.29449978470802307,
-0.44227248430252075,
0.2971703112125397,
0.48390671610832214,
0.35522934794425964,
-0.29469189047813416,
-0.027780797332525253,
-0.5548571944236755,
-0.12490468472242355,
0.4766785204410553,
0.44600263237953186,
-1.3539049625396729,
0.15529893338680267,
-0.19264617562294006,
-0.5625817775726318,
-0.5853463411331177,
0.09376551955938339,
0.4095710813999176,
0.4818795919418335,
0.5330471992492676,
-0.49655887484550476,
-0.6635118126869202,
-1.1377722024917603,
-0.47924450039863586,
-0.20819133520126343,
0.1284206360578537,
0.1794998049736023,
0.3697541356086731,
-0.05035217106342316,
0.7794179916381836,
0.0747688040137291,
-0.34972742199897766,
-0.3119899034500122,
0.3803897500038147,
0.06580483913421631,
0.35107114911079407,
0.9628022313117981,
-1.1162362098693848,
-0.48397597670555115,
-0.16164855659008026,
-0.33681780099868774,
-0.07625158131122589,
-0.3980807662010193,
0.010084741748869419,
0.1797058880329132,
0.5948901176452637,
-0.48852723836898804,
0.5577901601791382,
0.6212447881698608,
-0.3359798789024353,
0.5756840109825134,
0.34749919176101685,
0.5660945773124695,
-0.8809128403663635,
0.1267646998167038,
0.4743262827396393,
-0.4665184020996094,
-0.3131239712238312,
-0.17362216114997864,
-0.04422847926616669,
-0.25622183084487915,
-0.6872864365577698,
0.7313231229782104,
-0.31532859802246094,
-0.4129263460636139,
-0.19116520881652832,
0.3666173219680786,
-0.05901242047548294,
0.3002713918685913,
0.5698227882385254,
1.0603768825531006,
0.49480879306793213,
-0.06910066306591034,
0.11319148540496826,
0.1391107738018036,
-0.5747600197792053,
0.6751847267150879,
-0.6309934854507446,
-0.09785701334476471,
-0.08239460736513138,
0.22070585191249847,
-1.1418590545654297,
-0.11160790175199509,
0.07663077116012573,
-0.3780842125415802,
-0.13833747804164886,
-0.051010072231292725,
-0.6284793019294739,
-0.32227128744125366,
-0.6108907461166382,
0.3817237913608551,
0.2858240306377411,
-0.5873847007751465,
0.5295640230178833,
0.0548076406121254,
-0.09467709064483643,
-0.4146305322647095,
-0.5823810696601868,
0.1521950364112854,
0.11684244871139526,
-0.19701527059078217,
0.41746270656585693,
0.21064496040344238,
0.07326307892799377,
0.31726738810539246,
-0.3668783903121948,
-0.017085544764995575,
-0.18848413228988647,
-0.04338119551539421,
0.2270330935716629,
-0.18350036442279816,
0.15579766035079956,
0.10036181658506393,
0.04466988518834114,
-0.22853295505046844,
0.4178408086299896,
0.2559809386730194,
-0.06597553938627243,
-0.18367834389209747,
-0.33455267548561096,
0.4188282787799835,
0.533860445022583,
-0.27163684368133545,
0.21900171041488647,
1.0310053825378418,
-0.21349483728408813,
0.23227323591709137,
-0.7608930468559265,
-0.07636167854070663,
-0.3797946870326996,
0.5761539340019226,
0.04479866847395897,
-0.5860428214073181,
0.3942406475543976,
0.11137598007917404,
-0.11489900946617126,
0.25448963046073914,
0.30929744243621826,
0.11479237675666809,
0.750210165977478,
0.6971948742866516,
-0.25061318278312683,
0.8234320282936096,
-0.06105886027216911,
-0.17611682415008545,
-0.5893315076828003,
-0.04839332401752472,
-0.1711377054452896,
-0.4581904709339142,
-0.40879860520362854,
-0.49044129252433777,
0.29716452956199646,
0.026661930605769157,
-0.02165759541094303,
0.4897051155567169,
-0.32831305265426636,
0.7115528583526611,
0.690044105052948,
0.45431533455848694,
0.3569938540458679,
-0.10109984129667282,
-0.018614670261740685,
-0.10199812054634094,
-0.4887946546077728,
-0.2967131733894348,
0.5265316963195801,
0.3959012031555176,
0.6529361009597778,
0.040128566324710846,
0.42920196056365967,
0.2343813180923462,
0.5513426661491394,
-0.7837499976158142,
0.6199870705604553,
-0.4449956715106964,
-0.38051629066467285,
0.0699789896607399,
-0.26520299911499023,
-0.557853639125824,
0.24638567864894867,
-0.6270102262496948,
-0.5420981645584106,
0.47610560059547424,
0.143795445561409,
-0.262953519821167,
0.21357104182243347,
-0.6054052114486694,
0.9377073049545288,
-0.3359891176223755,
-0.3594622015953064,
-0.12748657166957855,
-0.5713548064231873,
0.14815466105937958,
-0.08107226341962814,
-0.00831528939306736,
0.10284555703401566,
-0.26269420981407166,
0.8687461018562317,
-0.11972711980342865,
1.0018266439437866,
0.017545396462082863,
0.3661535978317261,
0.06108754128217697,
0.0700913816690445,
0.13989996910095215,
0.0274594034999609,
0.19825497269630432,
0.18466544151306152,
0.14530231058597565,
-0.5054928660392761,
-0.5402037501335144,
0.3623223304748535,
-0.5247831344604492,
-0.7827275991439819,
-0.39079269766807556,
-0.27378061413764954,
-0.2773098945617676,
0.4411630928516388,
0.34425508975982666,
0.48857635259628296,
-0.4690329432487488,
0.46532565355300903,
0.2580486536026001,
-0.002071953611448407,
0.7237852215766907,
0.5517187714576721,
-0.3601709008216858,
-0.5800366997718811,
0.8646816611289978,
0.0542944073677063,
-0.0721772164106369,
0.47630271315574646,
0.21818898618221283,
-0.43541833758354187,
-0.4709104299545288,
-0.5746964812278748,
0.10765081644058228,
-0.5279713273048401,
-0.29524415731430054,
-0.4235681891441345,
-0.023108894005417824,
-0.13083940744400024,
-0.35615572333335876,
-0.3826266825199127,
-0.15547068417072296,
-0.38888049125671387,
-0.0646466389298439,
0.1269536018371582,
0.5537495017051697,
0.013338807970285416,
0.13950270414352417,
-0.810120701789856,
0.3708004653453827,
0.537424623966217,
0.327100932598114,
-0.06218167021870613,
-0.239590123295784,
-0.13087259232997894,
-0.2651607096195221,
-0.3990122377872467,
-0.9883643984794617,
0.015927791595458984,
0.1155708059668541,
0.6746087074279785,
0.528080940246582,
0.23171770572662354,
0.6554410457611084,
-0.3540205657482147,
0.8066568374633789,
0.5185335874557495,
-1.1637508869171143,
0.5703564286231995,
-0.2491089105606079,
0.3546695411205292,
0.7684359550476074,
0.6875708699226379,
-0.4114348590373993,
-0.6539945006370544,
-0.6442168354988098,
-0.38472169637680054,
0.13001883029937744,
0.13768111169338226,
0.22829408943653107,
-0.3056056797504425,
-0.08550789952278137,
0.2212500423192978,
0.24128755927085876,
-0.8325121998786926,
0.2868841290473938,
-0.9455177187919617,
-0.27238529920578003,
0.02743547596037388,
-0.16983136534690857,
-0.06694211810827255,
-0.08035804331302643,
0.18291091918945312,
-0.23679324984550476,
0.16798701882362366,
0.4823470115661621,
-0.15326045453548431,
-0.2619474232196808,
0.2896561026573181,
0.5810169577598572,
0.6886281967163086,
-0.20853541791439056,
0.4136618971824646,
-0.23256468772888184,
-0.6115579009056091,
-0.1505139172077179,
0.25872716307640076,
-0.10119111090898514,
0.36963263154029846,
0.7861878275871277,
0.6867355704307556,
0.5963975787162781,
-0.6396112442016602,
0.9417269229888916,
0.0504634864628315,
-0.28471988439559937,
0.3344918191432953,
-0.0805099681019783,
-0.23803411424160004,
0.6242874264717102,
0.766463577747345,
0.13769830763339996,
0.26361560821533203,
-1.005933165550232,
0.47787055373191833,
0.5461809039115906,
-0.5370716452598572,
-0.42548736929893494,
0.3581778407096863,
0.4116886556148529,
-0.11019499599933624,
0.31927990913391113,
-0.187358096241951,
-0.9888954162597656,
0.5147678852081299,
0.47742751240730286,
0.5705930590629578,
0.02321195974946022,
0.48430752754211426,
0.2088739573955536,
0.40601521730422974,
-0.0521724633872509,
0.12992256879806519,
0.046365804970264435,
-0.5984063744544983,
0.002302182838320732,
-0.14722520112991333,
-0.4635109603404999,
0.15734244883060455,
-0.5511332154273987,
0.23775702714920044,
-0.5088905096054077,
-0.23368431627750397,
0.2692265808582306,
0.17481373250484467,
-0.6795098185539246,
0.27582746744155884,
-0.07924800366163254,
1.1887480020523071,
-1.3866750001907349,
0.6314483284950256,
0.804077684879303,
-0.635341465473175,
-0.5397838354110718,
0.5239701867103577,
-0.041887130588293076,
-0.6487100720405579,
0.5405065417289734,
0.38428810238838196,
0.18282215297222137,
-0.1365114003419876,
-0.485861212015152,
-0.3515309989452362,
0.9145021438598633,
0.5490729808807373,
-0.5692641139030457,
0.11001794785261154,
-0.02316993661224842,
0.5374196767807007,
-0.35732826590538025,
0.18103930354118347,
0.08433769643306732,
0.3641611933708191,
0.25819021463394165,
-1.0852653980255127,
0.2778172492980957,
-0.17164435982704163,
0.008784322068095207,
0.013819183222949505,
-0.928617000579834,
0.7477437853813171,
-0.4014417231082916,
-0.4385005533695221,
-0.10380162298679352,
0.6234639286994934,
-0.017452366650104523,
0.5104777812957764,
0.7502871155738831,
0.3523877263069153,
0.17426523566246033,
0.04807097092270851,
0.7644983530044556,
-0.006942708045244217,
0.5177825689315796,
0.9076322317123413,
-0.04665717855095863,
1.0724924802780151,
0.7487390041351318,
-0.13464868068695068,
0.2505054771900177,
0.6399829387664795,
-0.4129541218280792,
0.8786512613296509,
-0.3391217589378357,
0.13134297728538513,
-0.5010366439819336,
-0.29679879546165466,
-0.24035890400409698,
0.5698301792144775,
-0.13436509668827057,
-0.5792509317398071,
-0.7523260712623596,
0.1520731896162033,
-0.2656952142715454,
0.2833003103733063,
-0.4116061329841614,
0.5596680641174316,
-0.1772659868001938,
-0.32959437370300293,
0.13092342019081116,
-0.3822319507598877,
0.5125720500946045,
-0.004913740791380405,
-0.30457696318626404,
-0.15647907555103302,
-0.29851651191711426,
-0.0882449597120285,
-1.06630539894104,
0.38708820939064026,
-0.21809610724449158,
-0.13087230920791626,
0.19911302626132965,
0.6183742880821228,
-0.5342952609062195,
-0.7355127334594727,
0.15048302710056305,
0.44537314772605896,
-0.16842782497406006,
-0.0418701171875,
-0.9547122120857239,
0.40114283561706543,
-0.18622472882270813,
-0.10558879375457764,
0.21501469612121582,
0.3183266520500183,
-0.09468719363212585,
0.26821988821029663,
0.5307083129882812,
-0.11894349008798599,
-0.3083992600440979,
-0.044577229768037796,
0.9918608665466309,
-0.5626795887947083,
-0.6310906410217285,
-0.717718243598938,
0.09236883372068405,
-0.24265806376934052,
-0.36207860708236694,
0.5535761117935181,
0.8353517055511475,
0.8530168533325195,
-0.1729692667722702,
0.5392316579818726,
0.00038699762080796063,
0.5273543000221252,
-0.7924089431762695,
0.5753755569458008,
-0.5339128375053406,
-0.13176152110099792,
-0.3386225998401642,
-0.6058297753334045,
-0.11361508816480637,
0.4399021863937378,
-0.4157390594482422,
0.1318819522857666,
0.7602710723876953,
0.687578022480011,
-0.5193763375282288,
0.01941177435219288,
0.40068867802619934,
0.029761960729956627,
-0.15478827059268951,
0.45562076568603516,
0.7326061129570007,
-0.537877082824707,
0.5288483500480652,
-0.3560132384300232,
-0.2418355941772461,
-0.4563409984111786,
-1.1358360052108765,
-1.2995840311050415,
-0.7636078596115112,
-0.5332615375518799,
-0.15851536393165588,
0.2557462155818939,
0.8263368606567383,
0.7238343954086304,
-0.47008028626441956,
0.38989171385765076,
0.19493162631988525,
0.19665728509426117,
-0.367123544216156,
-0.18804959952831268,
0.6367012858390808,
0.11862648278474808,
-0.5373808145523071,
-0.11208949238061905,
0.2501411437988281,
0.19717857241630554,
-0.17658038437366486,
0.3480880558490753,
-0.17217184603214264,
0.15572912991046906,
0.6338503360748291,
0.15696683526039124,
-0.8321745991706848,
-0.7999690175056458,
-0.03636831417679787,
-0.17299655079841614,
0.14570580422878265,
0.9928206205368042,
-0.8331227898597717,
0.23887266218662262,
0.33854690194129944,
0.7652482986450195,
0.33443525433540344,
0.32404404878616333,
0.0366201288998127,
-0.8446551561355591,
0.2332613468170166,
-0.12769706547260284,
0.32752129435539246,
0.47917094826698303,
-0.3349281847476959,
0.396906316280365,
0.5147245526313782,
0.05259538069367409,
-0.7151939272880554,
0.06457565724849701,
-1.5542068481445312,
-0.33258041739463806,
1.0518072843551636,
-0.008884971030056477,
-0.2857891023159027,
-0.19408218562602997,
-0.40421393513679504,
0.1323413848876953,
-0.47211915254592896,
0.7597987651824951,
0.596031129360199,
0.15370410680770874,
-1.0334725379943848,
-0.3114219009876251,
0.41803768277168274,
0.014596427790820599,
-0.6334814429283142,
-0.06610306352376938,
0.26206716895103455,
0.4628056585788727,
0.29716235399246216,
0.5734013319015503,
-0.12101084738969803,
0.7396649122238159,
0.2385191172361374,
-0.3899604380130768,
-0.3131605386734009,
-0.13381327688694,
0.05466311797499657,
-0.04528657719492912,
-0.3206005096435547,
-0.26951098442077637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11142v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11142v1 | Grasping the Essentials: Tailoring Large Language Models for Zero-Shot Relation Extraction | 2024-02-17T00:20:06 | 2024-02-17T00:20:06 | Sizhe Zhou, Yu Meng, Bowen Jin, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relation extraction (RE), a crucial task in NLP, aims to identify semantic
relationships between entities mentioned in texts. Despite significant
advancements in this field, existing models typically rely on extensive
annotated data for training, which can be both costly and time-consuming to
acquire. Moreover, these models often struggle to adapt to new or unseen
relationships. In contrast, few-shot learning settings, which aim to reduce
annotation requirements, may offer incomplete and biased supervision for
understanding target relation semantics, leading to degraded and unstable
performance. To provide the model with accurate and explicit descriptions of
the relations types and meanwhile minimize the annotation requirements, we
study the definition only zero-shot RE setting where only relation definitions
expressed in natural language are used to train a RE model. Motivated by the
strong synthetic data generation power of LLMs, we propose a framework REPaL
which consists of three stages: (1) We utilize LLMs to generate initial seed
instances based on relation definitions and an unlabeled corpora. (2) We
fine-tune a bidirectional Small Language Model (SLM) using these initial seeds
to learn the relations for the target domain. (3) We enhance pattern coverage
and mitigate bias resulting from the limited number of initial seeds by
incorporating feedback acquired from SLM's predictions on unlabeled corpora. To
accomplish this, we leverage the multi-turn conversation ability of LLMs to
generate new instances in follow-up dialogues. Experiments on two datasets show
REPaL achieves better zero-shot performance with large margins over baseline
methods. | [
-0.2299024760723114,
-0.5986250042915344,
0.674045205116272,
0.013835454359650612,
-0.3682483434677124,
-0.1878710389137268,
-0.22393262386322021,
-0.5772750377655029,
0.1434778869152069,
0.7639545798301697,
-0.7084272503852844,
-0.44226303696632385,
-0.4189666509628296,
0.3138790428638458,
-0.2930339276790619,
1.1053853034973145,
0.10243278741836548,
-0.1769285649061203,
-0.07086554914712906,
-0.321139931678772,
-0.2619932293891907,
-0.36808815598487854,
-0.4121716320514679,
-0.5247393250465393,
0.6211541295051575,
0.5208532810211182,
0.5931301712989807,
0.704060971736908,
0.21116694808006287,
0.11279377341270447,
-0.0070298523642122746,
0.04407743364572525,
-0.6708934903144836,
0.4721148610115051,
-0.23526941239833832,
-0.5169413089752197,
-0.29159173369407654,
0.07015284895896912,
0.5751264691352844,
0.8086732029914856,
0.16744861006736755,
0.4372185468673706,
-0.22835403680801392,
0.41173431277275085,
-0.819380521774292,
0.2275589257478714,
-1.008103847503662,
0.04893697798252106,
-0.0747351199388504,
-0.3621928095817566,
-0.5195963382720947,
0.11523783206939697,
0.22566817700862885,
-0.540453314781189,
0.19920198619365692,
-0.06980802863836288,
1.1371872425079346,
0.04468011483550072,
-0.2682439684867859,
0.004733364097774029,
-0.8375215530395508,
0.8262178897857666,
-0.7510111927986145,
0.3181753158569336,
0.21766431629657745,
0.21924790740013123,
-0.29791152477264404,
-0.5378269553184509,
-0.3960666060447693,
-0.19665370881557465,
-0.154623344540596,
-0.07180465012788773,
-0.11749981343746185,
0.026039274409413338,
0.43824446201324463,
0.3062220811843872,
-0.2591893672943115,
0.09682931005954742,
-0.17465642094612122,
0.10392196476459503,
0.6043300032615662,
0.11045616865158081,
0.10794461518526077,
-0.2971525490283966,
-0.23192095756530762,
0.1603984236717224,
-1.0773531198501587,
-0.32174941897392273,
0.008747427724301815,
0.6117098331451416,
-0.023810960352420807,
0.802850067615509,
-0.1903959959745407,
0.823431670665741,
0.04706171900033951,
-0.22281020879745483,
0.059540193527936935,
-0.3597736954689026,
-0.4690500795841217,
-0.15307919681072235,
1.000601053237915,
0.04482552409172058,
0.661000669002533,
-0.29140231013298035,
-0.11602412164211273,
-0.055659398436546326,
0.11367955803871155,
-0.9619906544685364,
-0.04619920253753662,
0.1344163566827774,
-0.12671668827533722,
-0.5183382630348206,
-0.2687303423881531,
-0.6763161420822144,
0.007084188051521778,
-0.4463818669319153,
0.09880036860704422,
-0.5372917056083679,
-0.32475966215133667,
-0.11075305938720703,
-0.00452565448358655,
0.6337549686431885,
0.21630676090717316,
-0.8764348030090332,
0.08074940741062164,
0.7697106003761292,
0.8933916091918945,
0.09093453735113144,
-0.11321162432432175,
-0.6081513166427612,
0.402910977602005,
-0.46438127756118774,
0.6085672974586487,
-0.594473659992218,
-0.20297066867351532,
0.17628313601016998,
0.010207287035882473,
-0.00124234682880342,
-0.19393379986286163,
0.3285844624042511,
-0.6695398688316345,
0.22384849190711975,
0.13384653627872467,
-0.6272070407867432,
-0.040799397975206375,
0.3449142277240753,
-0.47339144349098206,
0.7486388087272644,
0.2353820502758026,
-0.7121647596359253,
0.3453737497329712,
-0.29114633798599243,
-0.514447033405304,
0.06334523856639862,
-0.36621958017349243,
-0.35431697964668274,
0.18923018872737885,
0.23050908744335175,
0.6020617485046387,
-0.4295590817928314,
0.07835618406534195,
-0.5097338557243347,
-0.1485467255115509,
0.021239588037133217,
-0.06260692328214645,
0.7329403162002563,
0.13661213219165802,
-0.0800165981054306,
0.005704018287360668,
-1.0751290321350098,
0.024769993498921394,
0.211091548204422,
-0.04645629972219467,
-0.4831833243370056,
-0.22661595046520233,
-0.13591279089450836,
0.40277475118637085,
-0.07479488104581833,
-0.585658073425293,
0.29976072907447815,
-0.7901068925857544,
0.31036829948425293,
0.4062654376029968,
0.4460013508796692,
0.8402572274208069,
0.028297195211052895,
0.6794641017913818,
-0.10553207993507385,
-0.17278583347797394,
-0.6059266924858093,
-0.19558975100517273,
-0.7912576198577881,
-0.1922106295824051,
0.37988245487213135,
0.46874698996543884,
-0.8639927506446838,
0.35729262232780457,
-0.46836087107658386,
-0.38331326842308044,
-0.5378397107124329,
0.38287782669067383,
0.5318713784217834,
0.5620076656341553,
0.1732291430234909,
-0.10060065984725952,
-0.7425391674041748,
-0.8955301642417908,
-0.04253452643752098,
-0.08466687053442001,
-0.1854747086763382,
0.2776300013065338,
0.32543978095054626,
-0.05055661499500275,
1.2631621360778809,
-0.5775034427642822,
-0.3474763035774231,
-0.5134204030036926,
0.02682369202375412,
0.36714163422584534,
0.12025311589241028,
0.5227130055427551,
-0.43956518173217773,
-0.5963816046714783,
0.053360845893621445,
-1.0353730916976929,
-0.1113898754119873,
-0.3687751889228821,
-0.26415830850601196,
0.15014220774173737,
0.32550671696662903,
-0.7688230872154236,
0.26618102192878723,
0.2906877100467682,
0.0189050305634737,
0.3968111276626587,
0.18539263308048248,
-0.4605395495891571,
-1.097557544708252,
0.052336398512125015,
0.23417448997497559,
-0.45138904452323914,
-0.7894196510314941,
0.2090563327074051,
0.010953858494758606,
-0.19629955291748047,
-0.5396689176559448,
0.4745986759662628,
-0.6837590336799622,
-0.17602837085723877,
-0.31956952810287476,
0.4785262644290924,
0.12819403409957886,
0.4845274090766907,
0.3226371705532074,
0.5680754780769348,
0.31640297174453735,
-0.5504612922668457,
0.0955183207988739,
0.2793574035167694,
-0.02548292465507984,
0.41188403964042664,
-0.6198256015777588,
0.20516419410705566,
-0.0497804693877697,
0.1185840517282486,
-0.7022971510887146,
-0.12154452502727509,
0.3828234076499939,
-0.5689671039581299,
0.6511179208755493,
-0.5246560573577881,
-0.2849348783493042,
0.06579244881868362,
-0.2881709933280945,
0.053374819457530975,
0.3044861853122711,
-0.3555222153663635,
0.542069137096405,
0.3357532322406769,
-0.017267867922782898,
-0.6956225037574768,
-0.46566301584243774,
0.25598955154418945,
-0.016410281881690025,
-0.459628164768219,
0.21595130860805511,
0.4481263756752014,
-0.28025928139686584,
-0.00762786203995347,
-0.016475170850753784,
-0.12882167100906372,
-0.028480462729930878,
0.3741222321987152,
0.37102118134498596,
-0.240701824426651,
0.2142105996608734,
-0.22713418304920197,
-0.315883994102478,
-0.08058629930019379,
-0.0782572403550148,
0.47273698449134827,
0.19437871873378754,
0.04778684675693512,
-0.34974029660224915,
0.20973952114582062,
0.5917252898216248,
-0.08759498596191406,
0.8094711303710938,
0.354841411113739,
-0.287746787071228,
-0.20106728374958038,
-0.3806077241897583,
-0.25400370359420776,
-0.322323739528656,
0.33705565333366394,
-0.6258227825164795,
-0.8422315716743469,
0.2577674984931946,
-0.0458514429628849,
0.37917858362197876,
0.4002595543861389,
0.42535847425460815,
0.10356713086366653,
0.4879397451877594,
0.9053021669387817,
-0.31098148226737976,
0.4025364816188812,
-0.34308263659477234,
0.20887626707553864,
-1.0399681329727173,
0.007074205204844475,
-0.39402711391448975,
0.052982352674007416,
-0.5060699582099915,
-0.2723468840122223,
-0.13792820274829865,
0.35492873191833496,
-0.2085203230381012,
0.8099341988563538,
-0.3277813494205475,
0.3271391689777374,
0.3384154736995697,
-0.21568767726421356,
0.3783204257488251,
0.09538020938634872,
0.15591716766357422,
-0.27631980180740356,
-0.7195963263511658,
-0.6045652031898499,
1.1663974523544312,
0.3096674680709839,
0.6429932713508606,
-0.06839964538812637,
0.8834569454193115,
-0.20014403760433197,
0.5973758697509766,
-1.1123913526535034,
0.41130581498146057,
0.15826845169067383,
-0.6311322450637817,
-0.28832605481147766,
-0.49878445267677307,
-1.0293102264404297,
0.4308631122112274,
-0.28658610582351685,
-0.6354328989982605,
0.20682038366794586,
0.0017197055276483297,
-0.4856676161289215,
0.13879260420799255,
-0.5270681977272034,
0.6633054614067078,
-0.12492930144071579,
-0.5942085981369019,
0.13569755852222443,
-0.6998787522315979,
0.6591939926147461,
-0.05497519671916962,
0.08107999712228775,
-0.2998727560043335,
0.009127412922680378,
0.4180299639701843,
-0.24070610105991364,
0.8176651000976562,
-0.07434237748384476,
-0.06609895825386047,
0.2962815761566162,
0.4042290449142456,
0.3091764450073242,
0.025990091264247894,
-0.06633269786834717,
0.21355485916137695,
0.14120478928089142,
-0.1365058869123459,
-0.6543903350830078,
0.5919503569602966,
-0.5899237394332886,
-0.4563469886779785,
-0.48022031784057617,
-0.4219982326030731,
-0.3366919159889221,
0.23940907418727875,
0.03280473127961159,
0.1480724811553955,
-0.24022437632083893,
0.2420962005853653,
0.3543412983417511,
-0.27143746614456177,
0.4646846652030945,
0.6856834292411804,
-0.5241798758506775,
-0.4112437963485718,
0.7051934599876404,
0.0575820617377758,
0.37719395756721497,
0.5031213760375977,
-0.07649995386600494,
-0.2075808346271515,
-0.24509687721729279,
-0.4267147183418274,
0.5337606072425842,
-0.324302613735199,
-0.5322054624557495,
-0.6260776519775391,
-0.3143711984157562,
-0.4911637604236603,
0.049332164227962494,
-0.4896187484264374,
-0.48251813650131226,
-0.48133549094200134,
-0.10627222806215286,
0.3682214319705963,
0.4814038872718811,
-0.013904971070587635,
0.32824087142944336,
-0.9009335041046143,
0.4065277874469757,
0.01616453006863594,
0.006749262101948261,
-0.02721269056200981,
-0.7390506863594055,
-0.0983973890542984,
-0.07246522605419159,
-0.21479256451129913,
-0.9717329144477844,
0.6340324878692627,
0.4158289432525635,
0.22112515568733215,
0.5359356999397278,
0.05800068750977516,
0.73197340965271,
-0.6593860983848572,
0.5668405890464783,
0.2928001582622528,
-0.5094637274742126,
0.7007297873497009,
-0.411201149225235,
0.19868026673793793,
0.6231533885002136,
0.4173663556575775,
-0.5641286969184875,
-0.11358972638845444,
-0.7119524478912354,
-0.8640450835227966,
0.8317914009094238,
0.2877969741821289,
0.2730533182621002,
-0.1109856516122818,
0.7899205088615417,
-0.15594089031219482,
0.28959035873413086,
-0.8959909081459045,
-0.19703416526317596,
0.17172911763191223,
-0.02063118666410446,
-0.003155216109007597,
-0.6247564554214478,
-0.17489492893218994,
-0.06011238694190979,
0.6867947578430176,
-0.026940427720546722,
0.01126844808459282,
0.0951945036649704,
-0.22055427730083466,
-0.2562808394432068,
0.3146417737007141,
0.3053661584854126,
0.7249003648757935,
-0.4261772036552429,
0.02630031295120716,
-0.03049440123140812,
-0.04706702008843422,
0.15940161049365997,
-0.07768674194812775,
-0.5402430295944214,
0.26405075192451477,
0.6185005903244019,
0.6716514229774475,
0.5380465388298035,
-0.473297119140625,
0.5415591597557068,
0.13688790798187256,
-0.15163247287273407,
-0.4404793083667755,
-0.027479037642478943,
0.08612656593322754,
-0.003765215165913105,
0.2231428027153015,
-0.34402623772621155,
-0.24073192477226257,
-0.7341219186782837,
0.5232731103897095,
0.5134174823760986,
-0.46518319845199585,
-0.35500743985176086,
0.3618317246437073,
0.13353095948696136,
-0.45601651072502136,
0.6643484234809875,
-0.16997884213924408,
-0.24784323573112488,
0.2375439554452896,
0.6251183152198792,
0.8224160671234131,
-0.03650571405887604,
0.2635499835014343,
0.5760911703109741,
0.2249486744403839,
0.10164747387170792,
-0.31545525789260864,
-0.1279996633529663,
-1.0295605659484863,
-0.8755293488502502,
-0.8815577626228333,
-0.32885000109672546,
0.3718182444572449,
-0.8387904167175293,
0.4128151834011078,
-0.5227448344230652,
0.09292525053024292,
0.08070074021816254,
0.01073913648724556,
-0.5516337156295776,
-0.034320518374443054,
-0.060962822288274765,
0.7879296541213989,
-0.7451098561286926,
1.0494555234909058,
0.3655115067958832,
-0.8135820627212524,
-0.7889525890350342,
-0.26194989681243896,
-0.07512320578098297,
-0.8442676067352295,
0.7827304005622864,
0.1167224645614624,
0.010926313698291779,
-0.0337412990629673,
-0.5286914706230164,
-0.740180253982544,
0.9795945882797241,
0.5879840850830078,
-0.8916904926300049,
-0.11196509748697281,
0.07958433777093887,
0.5684404373168945,
-0.7414239645004272,
0.2152584195137024,
0.7658355832099915,
0.03170819953083992,
0.4715011417865753,
-0.5543166995048523,
0.0012740333331748843,
0.10851247608661652,
0.055460479110479355,
0.27930113673210144,
-0.3269829750061035,
0.5146952271461487,
-0.1412428468465805,
-0.36918845772743225,
0.07180777937173843,
0.5958378314971924,
0.34517180919647217,
0.1657923012971878,
0.2520720958709717,
0.6585550308227539,
0.1087738648056984,
0.0539587065577507,
1.0554429292678833,
-0.4240942895412445,
0.32395651936531067,
1.7634552717208862,
-0.49746519327163696,
1.081268072128296,
0.6272655725479126,
-0.1622864156961441,
0.3227424621582031,
0.5712354779243469,
0.047171689569950104,
0.31369173526763916,
0.04438423365354538,
-0.2905581593513489,
-0.3084660470485687,
-0.20737431943416595,
-0.15413200855255127,
0.560858428478241,
0.3781573474407196,
-0.5525890588760376,
-0.5242557525634766,
-0.28235146403312683,
0.16852648556232452,
0.03936226665973663,
-0.058091383427381516,
0.9259538650512695,
0.4403224289417267,
-0.48546817898750305,
0.41487136483192444,
-0.09357059746980667,
0.5049902200698853,
-0.6048755645751953,
-0.2077816128730774,
-0.22349901497364044,
0.046371713280677795,
-0.14882540702819824,
-0.5247405767440796,
0.3018750846385956,
0.11899161338806152,
-0.20856738090515137,
-0.0859406590461731,
0.8194776773452759,
-0.5643243193626404,
-0.49427908658981323,
0.4602479338645935,
0.6418785452842712,
0.21382908523082733,
-0.1745644360780716,
-0.616261899471283,
-0.049609579145908356,
0.0568048320710659,
-0.3274608850479126,
0.39845335483551025,
0.630852222442627,
0.2368648648262024,
0.4769339859485626,
0.7257989048957825,
0.40808409452438354,
-0.21471922099590302,
0.222369983792305,
0.7819145917892456,
-0.6838535666465759,
0.20806317031383514,
-1.0713480710983276,
0.2990694046020508,
-0.29001641273498535,
-0.08486374467611313,
0.8280988931655884,
0.44033727049827576,
0.7175644636154175,
0.055446937680244446,
0.6378587484359741,
-0.016840366646647453,
0.5495857000350952,
-0.2542567849159241,
0.33719155192375183,
-0.30239567160606384,
0.2726512849330902,
-0.25508368015289307,
-1.1834392547607422,
-0.5793721675872803,
0.7777706980705261,
-0.3562454283237457,
-0.24224857985973358,
0.4902626574039459,
0.6959807276725769,
0.05229279771447182,
-0.2905431389808655,
0.5894930958747864,
0.18189309537410736,
0.4764993190765381,
0.5366871356964111,
0.6240366101264954,
-0.5510258674621582,
0.6693743467330933,
-0.22815167903900146,
-0.11757458746433258,
-0.002994928974658251,
-0.9437370300292969,
-0.8337762355804443,
-0.16121457517147064,
-0.20253482460975647,
-0.26084598898887634,
-0.08760035037994385,
0.9709791541099548,
0.7774897217750549,
-0.6919305324554443,
-0.20683304965496063,
-0.20563149452209473,
0.0607675239443779,
0.22537624835968018,
-0.2658400237560272,
0.12155450880527496,
-0.62452232837677,
-0.6415268182754517,
0.37038370966911316,
0.6108258962631226,
-0.05580839514732361,
-0.34408628940582275,
0.013726385310292244,
-0.564075231552124,
-0.1649014800786972,
0.826965868473053,
0.6024965643882751,
-0.6236557960510254,
-0.3099227249622345,
-0.1416165977716446,
0.06626224517822266,
0.04962532967329025,
0.8117068409919739,
-0.7382301688194275,
0.46001672744750977,
0.17982697486877441,
0.6653579473495483,
0.6534718871116638,
-0.051265861839056015,
0.9072306752204895,
-1.0030261278152466,
0.414954274892807,
0.2378634661436081,
0.3278799057006836,
0.37246400117874146,
-0.2916201949119568,
0.8389061093330383,
0.1789497584104538,
-0.3641051650047302,
-0.8750680088996887,
0.4448196589946747,
-0.8310917615890503,
-0.2268424779176712,
1.4089555740356445,
-0.25772765278816223,
-0.28142157196998596,
-0.12331826984882355,
-0.01992662250995636,
0.3384915888309479,
-0.2883228659629822,
0.5444020628929138,
0.5223888754844666,
-0.28495311737060547,
-0.4447338283061981,
-0.5333593487739563,
0.41460126638412476,
0.20588617026805878,
-0.47544753551483154,
0.2528385519981384,
0.5767461657524109,
0.37457117438316345,
0.3060246407985687,
0.6771658062934875,
-0.1777159571647644,
-0.06930923461914062,
-0.13094618916511536,
0.20347662270069122,
-0.16035492718219757,
-0.318599134683609,
-0.38799211382865906,
0.2751331627368927,
0.28543663024902344,
-0.19166244566440582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11140v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11140v1 | Boosting of Thoughts: Trial-and-Error Problem Solving with Large Language Models | 2024-02-17T00:13:36 | 2024-02-17T00:13:36 | Sijia Chen, Baochun Li, Di Niu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The reasoning performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) on a wide range of
problems critically relies on chain-of-thought prompting, which involves
providing a few chain of thought demonstrations as exemplars in prompts. Recent
work, e.g., Tree of Thoughts, has pointed out the importance of exploration and
self-evaluation in reasoning step selection for complex problem solving. In
this paper, we present Boosting of Thoughts (BoT), an automated prompting
framework for problem solving with LLMs by iteratively exploring and
self-evaluating many trees of thoughts in order to acquire an ensemble of
trial-and-error reasoning experiences, which will serve as a new form of
prompting to solve the complex problem. Starting from a simple prompt without
requiring examples, BoT iteratively explores and evaluates a large collection
of reasoning steps, and more importantly, uses error analysis obtained from the
LLM on them to explicitly revise prompting, which in turn enhances reasoning
step generation, until a final answer is attained. Our experiments with GPT-4
and Llama2 across extensive complex mathematical problems demonstrate that BoT
consistently achieves higher or comparable problem-solving rates than other
advanced prompting approaches. | [
-0.37836363911628723,
-1.175426959991455,
0.8308407664299011,
0.6898780465126038,
-0.023353643715381622,
0.34045395255088806,
-0.18917042016983032,
-0.06530794501304626,
0.016877219080924988,
0.15044856071472168,
-0.9772968888282776,
0.03709074482321739,
-0.42054715752601624,
0.34810665249824524,
-0.21557548642158508,
0.7651404738426208,
-0.3066754937171936,
0.20555196702480316,
-0.08793558180332184,
0.3750303089618683,
-0.7363662719726562,
-0.2784658670425415,
-0.9340078830718994,
-0.3398849666118622,
0.4771212935447693,
0.4882996082305908,
0.3783246576786041,
0.05087819695472717,
0.5259604454040527,
0.308215469121933,
-0.049490395933389664,
0.39892858266830444,
-0.5000454187393188,
0.3958438038825989,
-0.2999843657016754,
-0.6258970499038696,
-0.279281347990036,
-0.14530892670154572,
0.39146333932876587,
0.4478379487991333,
-0.08251827210187912,
0.10864081233739853,
0.018853643909096718,
0.7891353964805603,
-0.36353230476379395,
0.27859118580818176,
-0.7570555806159973,
0.01127543207257986,
0.1478268802165985,
-0.6072272062301636,
-0.2892780303955078,
-0.39500892162323,
0.14302925765514374,
-0.5672731399536133,
0.10382428020238876,
0.1928136795759201,
0.22873766720294952,
0.5240314602851868,
0.1388959288597107,
-0.5501049160957336,
-0.5617225170135498,
0.7611194252967834,
-0.5505994558334351,
-0.08424528688192368,
0.08787847310304642,
0.27254852652549744,
-0.568766176700592,
-0.2408224195241928,
-0.6954122185707092,
-0.1194942444562912,
0.2145761251449585,
0.19146709144115448,
-0.27518561482429504,
-0.03136424347758293,
0.6052906513214111,
0.28712373971939087,
-0.24523943662643433,
-0.3061675429344177,
-0.17154893279075623,
0.000948778644669801,
0.4859071373939514,
0.15736271440982819,
0.1492174118757248,
-0.20927152037620544,
-0.17953753471374512,
-0.4630938470363617,
-0.656560480594635,
0.17486044764518738,
0.183399498462677,
0.31103992462158203,
0.37872135639190674,
0.44276848435401917,
-0.35298725962638855,
0.6289631724357605,
0.10404407978057861,
0.02056959643959999,
0.19430789351463318,
-0.3425164520740509,
-0.24191586673259735,
-0.05764230713248253,
0.684674859046936,
0.3078750967979431,
0.41158151626586914,
0.21548008918762207,
-0.4209911823272705,
0.09165891259908676,
0.23233288526535034,
-0.6571743488311768,
-0.45090651512145996,
0.4063597321510315,
-0.03859464451670647,
-0.30681461095809937,
-0.2684961259365082,
-0.7947890758514404,
-0.4471462666988373,
-0.17150135338306427,
0.7344735264778137,
-0.3810637593269348,
-0.20082156360149384,
0.45473313331604004,
-0.20281589031219482,
-0.15485946834087372,
0.645271360874176,
-0.5307249426841736,
0.10510363429784775,
0.5740947127342224,
0.5900415182113647,
-0.1619279980659485,
-0.2164650857448578,
-0.6896740794181824,
-0.286773681640625,
-0.5446402430534363,
0.8890409469604492,
-0.4885379672050476,
-0.5336921215057373,
0.0665852427482605,
-0.2619902789592743,
0.10262315720319748,
-0.5547508597373962,
0.6758667230606079,
-0.39249947667121887,
0.14747999608516693,
-0.4636973440647125,
-0.5787873268127441,
-0.18545596301555634,
0.5244611501693726,
-0.47876670956611633,
1.2615174055099487,
0.0004659086116589606,
-0.6379602551460266,
0.16713033616542816,
-1.0835837125778198,
-0.29118654131889343,
0.19445590674877167,
-0.27709531784057617,
-0.18755213916301727,
0.22728505730628967,
0.572392463684082,
0.3289857506752014,
-0.32629844546318054,
0.12876105308532715,
0.008937625214457512,
-0.15773515403270721,
0.08484070748090744,
-0.3389565646648407,
0.8171718120574951,
0.10589338839054108,
-0.5774990916252136,
0.350585401058197,
-0.5211445689201355,
0.3177288770675659,
0.5411229133605957,
-0.15494683384895325,
-0.06336013972759247,
-0.023935245350003242,
-0.45065823197364807,
0.21991868317127228,
0.11720512062311172,
-0.38979804515838623,
0.6093956232070923,
-0.33884501457214355,
0.5054610967636108,
0.7564772367477417,
0.25255274772644043,
-0.08536522835493088,
-0.31455060839653015,
0.7379328012466431,
0.1368662267923355,
0.013992274180054665,
-0.7541835308074951,
-0.7628855109214783,
-1.0999040603637695,
0.20825354754924774,
0.1090739369392395,
0.57301926612854,
-0.9113402962684631,
0.35927820205688477,
0.009385406970977783,
-0.3243551254272461,
-0.6381344199180603,
0.15898527204990387,
0.29675978422164917,
0.4959649443626404,
0.45042282342910767,
-0.04780013486742973,
-0.5025822520256042,
-0.7572880387306213,
-0.2918608486652374,
-0.19560901820659637,
0.02708330750465393,
0.32338762283325195,
0.6222579479217529,
-0.16743658483028412,
1.0169601440429688,
-0.5376056432723999,
-0.04109611734747887,
-0.21904142200946808,
0.47045430541038513,
0.21826907992362976,
0.5305315256118774,
-0.10489744693040848,
-0.42753860354423523,
-0.32109206914901733,
-0.24253761768341064,
-0.34314805269241333,
-0.11806005239486694,
-0.350187212228775,
-0.23203353583812714,
-0.12135621905326843,
0.3183876872062683,
-0.4534308910369873,
0.2353547066450119,
0.20370106399059296,
-0.058451488614082336,
0.734686017036438,
-0.3683204650878906,
0.1735396385192871,
-0.7532950639724731,
-0.08540123701095581,
-0.03693648800253868,
-0.30087172985076904,
-0.27098649740219116,
-0.0734366923570633,
0.005084563512355089,
0.06924311071634293,
-0.15141011774539948,
0.37182876467704773,
-0.4670248329639435,
0.07666084915399551,
-0.3664510250091553,
0.33108407258987427,
-0.04029429703950882,
0.5961800813674927,
-0.060066916048526764,
0.9560595750808716,
0.7242779731750488,
-0.4568427503108978,
0.5777841806411743,
0.10350655764341354,
-0.45949697494506836,
0.3724285662174225,
-0.522779643535614,
0.6904667019844055,
-0.19691242277622223,
0.32905006408691406,
-1.2630103826522827,
-0.1540675014257431,
0.19125543534755707,
-0.2828921973705292,
0.16601066291332245,
0.12896668910980225,
-0.7514806389808655,
-0.9498813152313232,
-0.4585261046886444,
0.49034813046455383,
0.3618089258670807,
-0.5877184867858887,
0.38701924681663513,
0.13667820394039154,
-0.2932162284851074,
-0.6332076787948608,
-0.27784621715545654,
0.14892324805259705,
0.09597590565681458,
-0.399384468793869,
0.03838397189974785,
-0.37760886549949646,
-0.3162379860877991,
-0.06879264116287231,
0.00925309769809246,
0.3385900557041168,
0.227285698056221,
0.037854310125112534,
0.3132562041282654,
0.11837806552648544,
0.17545080184936523,
0.04684314504265785,
-0.06451567262411118,
0.3339635729789734,
-0.5048510432243347,
0.6518639922142029,
-0.29369696974754333,
-0.5810015797615051,
-0.3546264171600342,
0.26337313652038574,
0.22262631356716156,
-0.15888266265392303,
-0.034316156059503555,
0.02391357533633709,
-0.39702197909355164,
-0.5457616448402405,
-0.6778178811073303,
-0.35099631547927856,
-0.48450905084609985,
0.4180190861225128,
-0.46677854657173157,
-0.7665644884109497,
0.18873843550682068,
-0.31092220544815063,
0.22909334301948547,
0.20888309180736542,
0.752536416053772,
-0.33714327216148376,
1.1665252447128296,
0.5728282332420349,
-0.17966285347938538,
0.3055347502231598,
-0.25119104981422424,
0.328547865152359,
-0.6961873173713684,
-0.026541566476225853,
-0.33444130420684814,
-0.30828189849853516,
-0.12533576786518097,
-0.8103341460227966,
0.4612305164337158,
0.20248766243457794,
0.06969880312681198,
0.028488367795944214,
-0.7817739844322205,
0.8728255033493042,
0.35322242975234985,
-0.14594750106334686,
0.3541187345981598,
0.00023380661150440574,
-0.3173478841781616,
0.15111702680587769,
-0.8520301580429077,
-0.3149070143699646,
0.9650097489356995,
0.12423253804445267,
0.6669974327087402,
-0.29865312576293945,
0.525388777256012,
0.18345677852630615,
0.5046659111976624,
-1.1093919277191162,
0.567609429359436,
0.4901154935359955,
-0.7266891598701477,
-0.3649475872516632,
-0.40342867374420166,
-0.8874498605728149,
0.05107639357447624,
-0.04164264723658562,
-0.7080719470977783,
-0.1248934268951416,
0.37074849009513855,
-0.6532711386680603,
0.2724713683128357,
-0.3776511251926422,
0.43759435415267944,
-0.3275776505470276,
-0.2238968014717102,
-0.5715702772140503,
-0.45361098647117615,
0.3433474600315094,
-0.09296490997076035,
0.1441948562860489,
0.22252170741558075,
0.11956682801246643,
0.6922123432159424,
-0.04324382543563843,
0.6529945731163025,
-0.05451854318380356,
-0.33981600403785706,
0.49393540620803833,
0.47067874670028687,
0.9106642603874207,
-0.25312113761901855,
0.05658125877380371,
-0.4602402448654175,
-0.2603243291378021,
-0.1634039729833603,
-0.9364725947380066,
0.5925596356391907,
-0.34868094325065613,
-1.029483437538147,
-0.24553772807121277,
-0.7393677234649658,
-0.5440396070480347,
0.16980667412281036,
0.035378966480493546,
0.4241909682750702,
0.09533490985631943,
-0.13204529881477356,
0.7049912810325623,
0.03104647994041443,
0.381277471780777,
0.008181856945157051,
-0.5918540954589844,
-0.3997248411178589,
0.7765915989875793,
0.005554395727813244,
0.2771027684211731,
0.07907997816801071,
0.3143112361431122,
-0.47731730341911316,
-0.511894702911377,
-0.6495757102966309,
0.19497931003570557,
-0.8603731393814087,
-0.21838636696338654,
-0.6177520155906677,
0.011641085147857666,
-0.029191868379712105,
0.044618576765060425,
-0.2451907843351364,
-0.4596174657344818,
0.22944040596485138,
-0.14574529230594635,
0.369699090719223,
0.9054537415504456,
0.2156473994255066,
0.025509150698781013,
-0.6100202798843384,
-0.011933560483157635,
0.518896758556366,
0.12637662887573242,
0.4114293158054352,
-0.1742607206106186,
-0.10413414984941483,
-0.08252621442079544,
-0.5408674478530884,
-0.8717021346092224,
0.19882403314113617,
-0.25608906149864197,
0.3808768689632416,
0.3296542763710022,
-0.05318918079137802,
0.8067386746406555,
-0.5640998482704163,
0.73374342918396,
0.247879296541214,
-0.9726170897483826,
0.8197933435440063,
-0.39072972536087036,
0.25561392307281494,
0.5280508399009705,
0.2579810321331024,
-0.5499802231788635,
-0.40734559297561646,
-0.7275535464286804,
-0.556721568107605,
0.6082226634025574,
0.27603378891944885,
-0.12687593698501587,
0.011622464284300804,
0.44709452986717224,
0.003005906706675887,
0.3064352571964264,
-0.5407242774963379,
-0.1752016395330429,
-0.0480501614511013,
-0.06994201987981796,
0.11419273167848587,
-0.1446583867073059,
-0.3859732747077942,
-0.3278440237045288,
0.7763383984565735,
-0.4361071288585663,
0.24883835017681122,
0.5596515536308289,
-0.03280884772539139,
-0.5654906630516052,
0.30676889419555664,
0.49752387404441833,
0.686424970626831,
0.10884604603052139,
0.18812470138072968,
0.3793266713619232,
-0.03152185678482056,
0.15663157403469086,
-0.2262236475944519,
-0.12012124806642532,
-0.2197251170873642,
-0.01714477874338627,
0.6780691146850586,
0.0414847731590271,
-0.8540313839912415,
0.3252960741519928,
0.05984270200133324,
-0.2114582061767578,
0.020298149436712265,
0.35378122329711914,
0.2488512396812439,
0.16198797523975372,
0.5129431486129761,
0.13763777911663055,
0.18485426902770996,
-0.6176408529281616,
-0.04291575774550438,
0.6067459583282471,
-0.28826749324798584,
-0.18771857023239136,
0.32631105184555054,
0.24995248019695282,
-0.5888189673423767,
0.47315019369125366,
-0.46438100934028625,
-1.0858901739120483,
0.5212002396583557,
0.7064172625541687,
1.0154104232788086,
0.05504876375198364,
0.12180454283952713,
0.536600649356842,
0.0991981029510498,
-0.29933515191078186,
0.4968133270740509,
-0.34746211767196655,
-0.6937406659126282,
-0.8176843523979187,
-0.2789364755153656,
-0.5929269790649414,
0.19862030446529388,
-0.225367933511734,
0.1521158665418625,
-0.6404834985733032,
-0.0868312418460846,
-0.1466863453388214,
0.11611483991146088,
-0.4833771884441376,
0.11344058066606522,
0.2656128406524658,
1.0512505769729614,
-0.4868221580982208,
0.6252145767211914,
0.6206519603729248,
-0.07125299423933029,
-0.9913902282714844,
0.16388925909996033,
0.04786764830350876,
-0.7739579081535339,
0.7620850801467896,
0.2732051908969879,
-0.5568602085113525,
0.2651172876358032,
-0.7076025605201721,
-0.6793140769004822,
0.806638240814209,
0.033744510263204575,
-0.7292808294296265,
0.032825589179992676,
-0.104764424264431,
0.36184775829315186,
-0.41875895857810974,
0.35836610198020935,
0.5622962713241577,
0.5329458117485046,
0.1945488154888153,
-0.8707624077796936,
0.08268357068300247,
-0.34760531783103943,
-0.26724180579185486,
0.1069541946053505,
-0.6828398108482361,
0.8481329083442688,
-0.47428226470947266,
-0.2658577859401703,
0.03984953090548515,
0.47327569127082825,
0.5283052921295166,
-0.00012381721171550453,
0.8496228456497192,
0.44779568910598755,
1.1557265520095825,
-0.07325425744056702,
0.9957457780838013,
-0.3426940441131592,
0.3341580033302307,
0.9698083996772766,
-0.23269888758659363,
0.7964925169944763,
0.4812569320201874,
-0.3943222165107727,
0.5643231272697449,
0.5813595652580261,
0.012671173550188541,
0.15534496307373047,
0.5032445788383484,
-0.10064861178398132,
-0.5358957052230835,
0.21186865866184235,
-0.178340345621109,
-0.11261486262083054,
0.3705693483352661,
0.06506627798080444,
-0.24310632050037384,
-0.15514586865901947,
-0.11422660946846008,
-0.10602615773677826,
-0.4360324740409851,
0.5273984670639038,
0.08334933966398239,
-1.189648985862732,
0.5361306071281433,
-0.4559907615184784,
0.604118287563324,
-0.428513765335083,
-0.17244286835193634,
0.059142667800188065,
0.19696387648582458,
-0.04945787042379379,
-0.9800001382827759,
-0.1257501095533371,
0.17904768884181976,
-0.06069991737604141,
-0.34684035181999207,
0.7104937434196472,
-0.12403542548418045,
-0.663657009601593,
0.20927388966083527,
0.8425579071044922,
0.15998923778533936,
-0.16679641604423523,
-0.9543735384941101,
-0.1871608942747116,
0.12295127660036087,
-0.3179858922958374,
-0.034012097865343094,
0.5546810626983643,
-0.05147123709321022,
1.034010410308838,
0.7967040538787842,
0.06138872727751732,
-0.026547100394964218,
0.19259339570999146,
0.9733780026435852,
-0.7390925288200378,
-0.44111698865890503,
-1.0040793418884277,
0.4123675525188446,
-0.1577538102865219,
-0.2709730565547943,
0.8271345496177673,
0.39397355914115906,
0.6651679277420044,
-0.04791712388396263,
0.8491905331611633,
0.17246834933757782,
0.49384140968322754,
-0.4379057288169861,
0.33275696635246277,
-0.5087666511535645,
0.2161511927843094,
-0.39263445138931274,
-0.9687542915344238,
-0.14725863933563232,
0.7088691592216492,
-0.3381240665912628,
-0.1423364281654358,
0.8132296800613403,
0.80281001329422,
0.3795199394226074,
0.4305582344532013,
0.08795548230409622,
0.29582715034484863,
0.5287426710128784,
0.6548628211021423,
1.2747405767440796,
0.001306378049775958,
0.37916386127471924,
-0.06743158400058746,
-0.4177003800868988,
-0.2090342789888382,
-0.9315090775489807,
-0.8396692276000977,
-0.44923141598701477,
-0.1512472927570343,
-0.36086344718933105,
-0.07560478895902634,
1.456878900527954,
0.45041632652282715,
-0.8555677533149719,
-0.20345383882522583,
-0.5642711520195007,
0.1439591348171234,
-0.2991158664226532,
-0.15902045369148254,
0.22676698863506317,
-0.9846053123474121,
-0.7874311804771423,
0.6445304751396179,
0.31039193272590637,
-0.051411114633083344,
-0.684780478477478,
0.15348270535469055,
0.035232216119766235,
0.2633364200592041,
0.3675437271595001,
0.12300650775432587,
-0.7111576795578003,
-0.14618782699108124,
0.1545911282300949,
0.12395079433917999,
0.39561039209365845,
1.0832457542419434,
-1.044499397277832,
0.8141841888427734,
0.5107786655426025,
0.730563759803772,
0.4358874559402466,
0.030632013455033302,
0.6799784898757935,
-0.3034053146839142,
-0.16625243425369263,
0.4439348876476288,
0.4613400399684906,
0.3183465003967285,
-0.2502148449420929,
0.4707794487476349,
0.21319009363651276,
-0.5637311935424805,
-0.8468899726867676,
0.20739085972309113,
-0.8264398574829102,
-0.27925917506217957,
1.0845216512680054,
0.027628235518932343,
-0.431442528963089,
-0.05288263410329819,
-0.7520939707756042,
0.019198480993509293,
-0.48369166254997253,
1.056517481803894,
1.0257911682128906,
-0.45627039670944214,
0.10757414996623993,
-0.3801718056201935,
0.8098474144935608,
0.9744464159011841,
-0.8400905132293701,
0.4479126036167145,
0.30514150857925415,
-0.03392216935753822,
0.5587881207466125,
0.5341087579727173,
0.11467812210321426,
0.3101292848587036,
-0.14450325071811676,
-0.2602365016937256,
0.05441218987107277,
-0.460935115814209,
-0.374257892370224,
0.04783386364579201,
0.028551345691084862,
0.14505550265312195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11138v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11138v2 | Contrastive Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-17T00:09:32 | 2024-06-06T06:03:34 | Tianyi Lorena Yan, Fei Wang, James Y. Huang, Wenxuan Zhou, Fan Yin, Aram Galstyan, Wenpeng Yin, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Instruction tuning has been used as a promising approach to improve the
performance of large language models (LLMs) on unseen tasks. However, current
LLMs exhibit limited robustness to unseen instructions, generating inconsistent
outputs when the same instruction is phrased with slightly varied forms or
language styles. This behavior indicates LLMs' lack of robustness to textual
variations and generalizability to unseen instructions, potentially leading to
trustworthiness issues. Accordingly, we propose Contrastive Instruction Tuning,
which maximizes the similarity between the hidden representations of
semantically equivalent instruction-instance pairs while minimizing the
similarity between semantically different ones. To facilitate this approach, we
augment the existing FLAN collection by paraphrasing task instructions.
Experiments on the PromptBench benchmark show that CoIN consistently improves
LLMs' robustness to unseen instructions with variations across character, word,
sentence, and semantic levels by an average of +2.5% in accuracy. Code is
available at https://github.com/luka-group/CoIN. | [
-0.1799411177635193,
-0.8259246349334717,
0.5164106488227844,
-0.15452860295772552,
-0.33743834495544434,
0.13285726308822632,
-0.6140556335449219,
-0.3057330548763275,
0.24263785779476166,
0.7062113285064697,
-0.6890355348587036,
-0.6552178263664246,
-0.6761281490325928,
-0.022290488705039024,
-0.2587831914424896,
1.0968834161758423,
0.015008286572992802,
-0.12653464078903198,
-0.2020845264196396,
-0.2094237208366394,
-0.2850031852722168,
0.02377740852534771,
-0.5637764930725098,
-0.4766559302806854,
0.47562795877456665,
0.8651142716407776,
0.8238318562507629,
0.8072863221168518,
0.4852970540523529,
0.4404434263706207,
0.13849589228630066,
0.417044997215271,
-0.5131180286407471,
0.08905025571584702,
-0.30891987681388855,
-0.6478263735771179,
-0.33989933133125305,
-0.0220754723995924,
0.3347654342651367,
0.5135529637336731,
0.011280151084065437,
-0.06478475034236908,
0.25879713892936707,
0.8020521402359009,
-0.7887738347053528,
0.2904715836048126,
-0.7442924976348877,
-0.38682615756988525,
-0.16777144372463226,
-0.28987857699394226,
-0.13237573206424713,
-0.22663399577140808,
0.006916709244251251,
-0.987872838973999,
0.4257296323776245,
0.11047711223363876,
0.9643707275390625,
0.015147767961025238,
0.16673582792282104,
-0.5671896934509277,
-0.452071875333786,
0.9389939308166504,
-0.8554342985153198,
-0.02043476328253746,
0.5480775833129883,
0.08734215050935745,
0.061867982149124146,
-0.6455302238464355,
-0.3938613533973694,
-0.366451233625412,
0.021581292152404785,
0.09704280644655228,
0.04908827319741249,
0.17649149894714355,
0.31978628039360046,
0.577082097530365,
-0.28823256492614746,
0.07827039808034897,
-0.052557606250047684,
-0.24312040209770203,
0.21211108565330505,
0.16311979293823242,
0.21448704600334167,
0.12513256072998047,
-0.3003890812397003,
-0.536113440990448,
-0.5580599904060364,
-0.007131719961762428,
0.7298169136047363,
0.4162326157093048,
-0.2704430818557739,
0.43640828132629395,
-0.3963876962661743,
0.701322078704834,
0.31903135776519775,
-0.03538823500275612,
0.3029428720474243,
-0.16739685833454132,
-0.07522004097700119,
0.08164160698652267,
0.5865375995635986,
0.5223314166069031,
0.10051257163286209,
-0.167057603597641,
-0.5528716444969177,
0.16644060611724854,
0.254279226064682,
-0.8061902523040771,
-0.4124748408794403,
-0.13486425578594208,
-0.34902870655059814,
-0.43448325991630554,
0.36230868101119995,
-0.666357159614563,
-0.37642666697502136,
-0.3494666814804077,
0.645627498626709,
-0.6607189178466797,
-0.11817334592342377,
0.037281639873981476,
-0.1725236177444458,
0.2513890862464905,
0.16139021515846252,
-1.1767066717147827,
0.46082833409309387,
1.18634831905365,
0.8134334683418274,
-0.0388578437268734,
-0.19636353850364685,
-1.050247311592102,
0.18589431047439575,
-0.5236877799034119,
0.5687293410301208,
-0.9888482093811035,
-0.4443112909793854,
0.1687755286693573,
0.11760081350803375,
-0.06119020655751228,
-0.7456803321838379,
0.46954500675201416,
-0.5553786754608154,
0.027671897783875465,
-0.5460408926010132,
-0.7974637150764465,
0.03346387669444084,
0.17580357193946838,
-0.7984117269515991,
0.6849889755249023,
0.27917400002479553,
-0.9619947671890259,
0.17917098104953766,
-0.5265593528747559,
-0.5687130689620972,
-0.01688464917242527,
-0.2022581696510315,
-0.35942572355270386,
0.45186588168144226,
0.3821967840194702,
0.2033383995294571,
-0.11003289371728897,
-0.33579936623573303,
-0.3006323575973511,
-1.0382391214370728,
0.2749156653881073,
-0.3565947711467743,
0.389756977558136,
0.21541368961334229,
-0.5871307849884033,
0.22811713814735413,
-0.7445611357688904,
-0.057157110422849655,
-0.11406899243593216,
-0.09991740435361862,
-0.698115348815918,
-0.16199815273284912,
-0.11961232125759125,
-0.2521197199821472,
0.5192633271217346,
-0.4110536277294159,
-0.0781695544719696,
-0.8620755672454834,
0.49854716658592224,
0.9348779320716858,
-0.20350119471549988,
0.529394805431366,
-0.6391327381134033,
0.5038248300552368,
0.21999016404151917,
-0.04808180406689644,
-0.26227614283561707,
-0.1941162347793579,
-1.081622838973999,
-0.09366422146558762,
0.2696145474910736,
0.7076685428619385,
-0.9643240571022034,
0.3604593873023987,
-0.2915213704109192,
-0.045175325125455856,
-0.7323687076568604,
0.5113033056259155,
0.6194018721580505,
0.6321535706520081,
0.3664504289627075,
-0.13864438235759735,
-0.24671222269535065,
-0.9928674697875977,
-0.4656756818294525,
0.0907750129699707,
-0.10910577327013016,
0.22350731492042542,
0.3141877055168152,
-0.015307847410440445,
0.22644999623298645,
-0.3214172422885895,
0.041000764816999435,
0.06336090713739395,
0.34676504135131836,
0.23491866886615753,
0.6148920059204102,
0.1316702663898468,
-0.4902198910713196,
-0.4126448333263397,
0.21091249585151672,
-0.38415786623954773,
0.0183111522346735,
-0.07530666142702103,
-0.25225603580474854,
0.24060681462287903,
0.8122027516365051,
-0.3211789131164551,
0.2329254299402237,
0.5394257307052612,
-0.1289050579071045,
0.3046445846557617,
-0.5316590070724487,
0.4753301739692688,
-1.1220709085464478,
-0.10680689662694931,
-0.31443968415260315,
-0.27573201060295105,
-0.14538510143756866,
0.2023819237947464,
0.3041370213031769,
-0.07358229905366898,
-0.06713350862264633,
0.2705042362213135,
-0.6262074112892151,
0.06508786231279373,
-0.5932680368423462,
0.4901563823223114,
0.11246490478515625,
0.165603905916214,
-0.11115897446870804,
1.0266119241714478,
0.7295708060264587,
-0.5534455180168152,
0.3103272616863251,
-0.0682850256562233,
-0.6687461733818054,
0.7462648153305054,
-0.7315120697021484,
0.2814921736717224,
0.1622234433889389,
-0.31777694821357727,
-0.7544674277305603,
-0.13347600400447845,
0.25868746638298035,
-0.219304621219635,
0.788554310798645,
0.28161871433258057,
-0.32294559478759766,
-0.024487502872943878,
-0.5573546290397644,
0.02733134850859642,
0.5994783043861389,
-0.5661449432373047,
0.3312409222126007,
-0.18708114326000214,
-0.004568327218294144,
-0.790024995803833,
-0.7426872849464417,
-0.11638801544904709,
-0.3119446337223053,
-0.3889022469520569,
0.5354505181312561,
-0.22736485302448273,
-0.3837217092514038,
0.06758669763803482,
-0.5100457668304443,
0.2496725171804428,
0.06799786537885666,
0.2532429099082947,
0.1324121654033661,
-0.4990636706352234,
0.12758946418762207,
0.20218734443187714,
-0.1986526995897293,
0.02536315657198429,
-0.3243902325630188,
0.2631535232067108,
-0.2917693853378296,
-0.24495916068553925,
-0.47475066781044006,
0.3847257196903229,
0.25341305136680603,
-0.13047626614570618,
0.8129441738128662,
0.7654996514320374,
-0.05965742468833923,
-0.3604907989501953,
-0.6012150049209595,
-0.3544462025165558,
-0.6477013230323792,
0.30206799507141113,
-0.5520206689834595,
-1.0277438163757324,
0.531183123588562,
-0.1845061331987381,
0.11217191070318222,
0.25218501687049866,
0.230782613158226,
-0.11226723343133926,
0.698752224445343,
0.7211936712265015,
-0.1156206801533699,
0.7252725958824158,
-0.056995656341314316,
-0.043189775198698044,
-0.7586142420768738,
0.126876562833786,
-0.5359631180763245,
-0.3900723159313202,
-0.9002352952957153,
-0.5398267507553101,
0.0733238011598587,
0.2789533734321594,
-0.22435890138149261,
0.28381451964378357,
-0.3745042681694031,
0.7222188115119934,
0.8272431492805481,
0.49457088112831116,
0.04452738165855408,
0.18343383073806763,
-0.1649233102798462,
-0.0018047346966341138,
-0.47062745690345764,
-0.5391345024108887,
1.0361948013305664,
-0.2597765028476715,
0.8374521732330322,
-0.3147631287574768,
1.1878046989440918,
0.17589527368545532,
0.007273413240909576,
-0.34497034549713135,
0.4587419331073761,
-0.5148850679397583,
-0.19955183565616608,
-0.13754704594612122,
-0.5476114153862,
-0.8948626518249512,
-0.11590117961168289,
-0.09532223641872406,
-0.616466760635376,
-0.20215362310409546,
0.18300460278987885,
-0.25762662291526794,
0.29279786348342896,
-0.7203511595726013,
0.881938099861145,
-0.12570959329605103,
-0.5344846248626709,
-0.5645350813865662,
-0.5868724584579468,
0.27823352813720703,
0.042177293449640274,
0.25409695506095886,
0.0003643849049694836,
-0.44392067193984985,
0.5530000925064087,
-0.621605634689331,
0.8383966088294983,
0.13025979697704315,
-0.18728969991207123,
0.09632493555545807,
0.18665136396884918,
0.7467178702354431,
0.15057595074176788,
-0.26166412234306335,
0.00018348562298342586,
-0.0653487890958786,
-0.6579293608665466,
-0.8413837552070618,
1.456613302230835,
-0.8208945989608765,
-0.9220149517059326,
-0.10032764822244644,
-0.8282166123390198,
-0.2484775334596634,
0.16938836872577667,
0.27854567766189575,
0.47366511821746826,
-0.15147849917411804,
0.1536334902048111,
1.0228712558746338,
-0.2648589611053467,
0.5144925117492676,
0.4112194776535034,
0.36479875445365906,
-0.4700952470302582,
1.170114278793335,
-0.34535568952560425,
0.35224804282188416,
1.0496307611465454,
0.3782602548599243,
-0.0833207443356514,
-0.3332603871822357,
-0.24879337847232819,
0.22265852987766266,
-0.7301715612411499,
-0.18438905477523804,
-0.12202993035316467,
0.17320232093334198,
-0.3242543339729309,
-0.38200607895851135,
-0.33841630816459656,
-0.4055655002593994,
-0.585015594959259,
-0.12035585939884186,
0.6061713099479675,
0.593553364276886,
-0.06498722732067108,
0.40716731548309326,
-0.6894391775131226,
0.3957909345626831,
0.44013872742652893,
0.46466392278671265,
-0.25778594613075256,
-0.7093709111213684,
-0.2687201499938965,
0.1563463658094406,
-0.06245564669370651,
-0.6577982306480408,
-0.042312558740377426,
0.32971617579460144,
0.47995227575302124,
0.7446419596672058,
0.3088104724884033,
0.891220211982727,
-0.3896431624889374,
0.5776512026786804,
0.22147676348686218,
-1.223679542541504,
0.6351085901260376,
-0.25631487369537354,
0.48823779821395874,
0.802887499332428,
0.13309255242347717,
-0.1358380764722824,
-0.5833359360694885,
-0.6524929404258728,
-0.7580784559249878,
0.8449844121932983,
0.1652531921863556,
0.42940792441368103,
-0.10702408105134964,
0.4856266379356384,
0.39005833864212036,
0.21443620324134827,
-0.3719732463359833,
-0.3106648325920105,
-0.2961806058883667,
-0.494975745677948,
-0.3282119333744049,
-0.23913724720478058,
-0.33993810415267944,
0.05330662801861763,
0.6324318051338196,
-0.02039855718612671,
0.022980788722634315,
-0.07710085809230804,
-0.06158719211816788,
-0.23370985686779022,
0.30316412448883057,
0.7551863193511963,
0.754753828048706,
-0.08620745688676834,
0.41884174942970276,
0.17865152657032013,
-0.41087472438812256,
-0.3285326659679413,
0.0852593332529068,
-0.28962743282318115,
-0.13316045701503754,
0.622230589389801,
1.016944169998169,
0.6727812886238098,
-0.7039154171943665,
0.4166790246963501,
0.043017249554395676,
-0.20082688331604004,
-0.008890853263437748,
0.5230997204780579,
0.33952975273132324,
0.39658984541893005,
-0.22960308194160461,
0.012978529557585716,
-0.05743469297885895,
-0.4723280668258667,
0.22761742770671844,
0.4467642307281494,
-0.5041080713272095,
-0.2004781812429428,
0.606690526008606,
0.20705734193325043,
-0.5123777389526367,
0.7232612371444702,
-0.05404195189476013,
-0.17051813006401062,
0.46911412477493286,
0.5636996030807495,
0.8417205214500427,
-0.17946666479110718,
0.2669964134693146,
0.21069824695587158,
0.5396983623504639,
0.035626012831926346,
0.33763790130615234,
-0.3376694321632385,
-0.5365067720413208,
-0.11336229741573334,
-0.5740264058113098,
-0.43546953797340393,
0.23130866885185242,
-0.9068616628646851,
0.12034101784229279,
-0.5995319485664368,
0.21426507830619812,
-0.2906506657600403,
0.23412762582302094,
-0.6205165982246399,
0.010479120537638664,
-0.030512016266584396,
0.6310503482818604,
-0.6844270825386047,
0.8874968886375427,
0.731846809387207,
-0.41873854398727417,
-0.7114145159721375,
0.12487778067588806,
-0.30888763070106506,
-0.9978384375572205,
0.20890319347381592,
0.35511520504951477,
-0.3218809962272644,
-0.3096264898777008,
-0.5022620558738708,
-0.4759645164012909,
1.0910056829452515,
0.5336371660232544,
-0.9731457829475403,
0.1764911711215973,
0.08949864655733109,
0.37945127487182617,
-0.35430678725242615,
0.26502758264541626,
0.5315671563148499,
0.38809850811958313,
-0.0583466961979866,
-0.5692086219787598,
0.20226521790027618,
-0.1283554583787918,
0.07749523967504501,
0.16309013962745667,
-0.7131083011627197,
0.8756505250930786,
-0.15962526202201843,
0.027291905134916306,
0.2498137503862381,
0.8033361434936523,
0.2028030902147293,
0.298949271440506,
0.6503158807754517,
0.52750164270401,
0.7950839400291443,
0.0704851970076561,
0.9796092510223389,
-0.647355318069458,
-0.09217953681945801,
1.18959379196167,
-0.20600998401641846,
0.7565380334854126,
0.523269772529602,
0.07411932200193405,
0.8564358949661255,
0.32481876015663147,
0.2155802994966507,
0.5155208706855774,
0.18010003864765167,
-0.2474454641342163,
-0.5955421924591064,
0.1775665283203125,
-0.31117507815361023,
0.2560115456581116,
0.4659273624420166,
-0.5002776980400085,
-0.0615934319794178,
-0.12559689581394196,
-0.02870927006006241,
0.5820658802986145,
-0.4668482840061188,
0.6236739158630371,
0.2103075236082077,
-0.5747020840644836,
0.6216928362846375,
0.10301358997821808,
0.8323974609375,
-0.7913087010383606,
-0.24820922315120697,
-0.463001012802124,
0.36871102452278137,
-0.05902453884482384,
-0.2530450224876404,
0.012237003073096275,
-0.19059737026691437,
-0.23415914177894592,
-0.17415671050548553,
0.6372597813606262,
-0.4924706220626831,
-0.5773979425430298,
0.19896581768989563,
0.16650228202342987,
0.009188945405185223,
0.038518261164426804,
-0.8463699817657471,
0.2584773600101471,
-0.06620202213525772,
-0.1670827865600586,
0.5241522789001465,
0.77708500623703,
0.04583512619137764,
0.5059975385665894,
0.34222906827926636,
0.11373201757669449,
-0.11271681636571884,
0.2604079842567444,
0.8339042663574219,
-0.6828795671463013,
-0.6293562650680542,
-0.7255403995513916,
-0.004481395706534386,
-0.2580106854438782,
-0.3246711492538452,
0.8641607761383057,
0.5190266370773315,
1.082445502281189,
-0.18341682851314545,
0.37353023886680603,
0.2936599552631378,
0.46799755096435547,
-0.7263669371604919,
0.5398444533348083,
-0.6424494385719299,
0.5049240589141846,
-0.3923867344856262,
-0.7687864303588867,
0.11252222210168839,
0.7716283202171326,
-0.11744096875190735,
0.06758157908916473,
0.8916718363761902,
1.1911641359329224,
-0.2514551877975464,
0.07368785887956619,
0.4824856221675873,
-0.05310418829321861,
-0.20612472295761108,
0.687288224697113,
0.6594221591949463,
-0.4589446187019348,
0.7802828550338745,
-0.5036938190460205,
-0.21307885646820068,
-0.029507242143154144,
-0.8591033220291138,
-1.0970344543457031,
-0.3738095462322235,
-0.543767511844635,
-0.2539738118648529,
0.3683069348335266,
0.6145009398460388,
0.5856646299362183,
-1.1187599897384644,
-0.30435407161712646,
-0.3820180594921112,
0.3036910593509674,
-0.7634556293487549,
-0.23346863687038422,
0.5229492783546448,
-0.6623698472976685,
-0.8166324496269226,
0.6269460916519165,
0.1601068377494812,
-0.2866843044757843,
0.03618072345852852,
-0.20462964475154877,
0.06989488750696182,
0.25401782989501953,
0.15317067503929138,
0.022677583619952202,
-0.8267786502838135,
-0.5182586312294006,
-0.023509597405791283,
-0.09038200974464417,
-0.1008036658167839,
1.1102147102355957,
-0.450080007314682,
0.6632659435272217,
0.5134803056716919,
0.5648975968360901,
0.5166756510734558,
0.11413588374853134,
0.4645088315010071,
-0.7535076141357422,
0.1686868518590927,
0.08352591097354889,
0.10901692509651184,
0.4586281478404999,
-0.30594971776008606,
0.05213336646556854,
0.13442035019397736,
-0.4818349778652191,
-0.5161340832710266,
0.22160445153713226,
-0.8943673372268677,
-0.44833773374557495,
0.9710439443588257,
-0.4602632224559784,
-0.34220874309539795,
0.23389051854610443,
0.005601100157946348,
0.4767661392688751,
-0.500602126121521,
0.822116494178772,
0.747239887714386,
0.06423923373222351,
-0.19490736722946167,
-0.48012784123420715,
0.5182814002037048,
0.7060555219650269,
-0.6013236045837402,
0.12142712622880936,
0.37171560525894165,
0.48579829931259155,
-0.06104414910078049,
0.26618707180023193,
-0.03685786947607994,
0.21227265894412994,
0.3441391587257385,
-0.27598726749420166,
-0.318465918302536,
-0.07648073136806488,
-0.3455559015274048,
0.13982418179512024,
0.19827662408351898,
-0.5007447004318237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14830v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14830v1 | Orca-Math: Unlocking the potential of SLMs in Grade School Math | 2024-02-16T23:44:38 | 2024-02-16T23:44:38 | Arindam Mitra, Hamed Khanpour, Corby Rosset, Ahmed Awadallah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Mathematical word problem-solving has long been recognized as a complex task
for small language models (SLMs). A recent study hypothesized that the smallest
model size, needed to achieve over 80% accuracy on the GSM8K benchmark, is 34
billion parameters. To reach this level of performance with smaller models,
researcher often train SLMs to generate Python code or use tools to help avoid
calculation errors. Additionally, they employ ensembling, where outputs of up
to 100 model runs are combined to arrive at a more accurate result. Result
selection is done using consensus, majority vote or a separate a verifier model
used in conjunction with the SLM. Ensembling provides a substantial boost in
accuracy but at a significant cost increase with multiple calls to the model
(e.g., Phi-GSM uses top-48 to boost the performance from 68.2 to 81.5).
In this work, we present Orca-Math, a 7-billion-parameter SLM based on the
Mistral-7B, which achieves 86.81% on GSM8k without the need for multiple model
calls or the use of verifiers, code execution or any other external tools. Our
approach has the following key elements: (1) A high quality synthetic dataset
of 200K math problems created using a multi-agent setup where agents
collaborate to create the data, (2) An iterative learning techniques that
enables the SLM to practice solving problems, receive feedback on its solutions
and learn from preference pairs incorporating the SLM solutions and the
feedback. When trained with Supervised Fine-Tuning alone, Orca-Math achieves
81.50% on GSM8k pass@1 metric. With iterative preference learning, Orca-Math
achieves 86.81% pass@1. Orca-Math surpasses the performance of significantly
larger models such as LLAMA-2-70B, WizardMath-70B, Gemini-Pro, ChatGPT-3.5. It
also significantly outperforms other smaller models while using much smaller
data (hundreds of thousands vs. millions of problems). | [
-0.3981291949748993,
-0.7302561402320862,
0.34678032994270325,
0.12618333101272583,
-0.16225199401378632,
0.18933629989624023,
-0.08392083644866943,
-0.49570009112358093,
0.09316855669021606,
0.4319060444831848,
-0.41794589161872864,
-0.495569109916687,
-0.581735372543335,
-0.20304809510707855,
-0.07061619311571121,
0.7943505048751831,
-0.029005058109760284,
0.40999874472618103,
-0.1603332757949829,
-0.21924106776714325,
-0.3331453204154968,
-0.6220160126686096,
-1.1287809610366821,
-0.5291910767555237,
0.4004567861557007,
0.6209755539894104,
0.7386505007743835,
0.8274799585342407,
0.5280801057815552,
0.22760343551635742,
-0.20643110573291779,
0.4933006167411804,
-0.5284374356269836,
-0.0011048680171370506,
-0.028619466349482536,
-0.7447383999824524,
-0.721997082233429,
0.0701022669672966,
0.4954797327518463,
0.8322519659996033,
-0.44932401180267334,
0.4831591546535492,
-0.08814570307731628,
0.9174435138702393,
-0.5493977665901184,
0.4842711091041565,
-0.7126325964927673,
0.0035321437753736973,
-0.4486099183559418,
-0.09608804434537888,
-0.34802818298339844,
-0.5376706123352051,
-0.08890564739704132,
-0.7053113579750061,
0.04132341593503952,
0.016751088201999664,
0.6554563045501709,
0.2414618283510208,
-0.21849969029426575,
-0.6739703416824341,
-0.4880138337612152,
0.9818384051322937,
-0.6087440848350525,
0.33179953694343567,
0.501370370388031,
0.415921151638031,
-0.3587157726287842,
-0.4996153712272644,
-0.2140730321407318,
-0.08269599080085754,
0.4042257070541382,
0.2599368989467621,
0.20186537504196167,
-0.06810387223958969,
0.5562658905982971,
0.2019132375717163,
-0.48074421286582947,
-0.029515443369746208,
-0.7188393473625183,
-0.046921256929636,
0.6846221089363098,
0.600467324256897,
0.13070781528949738,
0.09457683563232422,
-0.004676388576626778,
-0.1796645224094391,
-0.9354692697525024,
0.5027415752410889,
0.3458516299724579,
0.3855253756046295,
0.16698148846626282,
0.7608572244644165,
0.11516926437616348,
0.8811483979225159,
-0.10397575795650482,
-0.6454066038131714,
-0.15202629566192627,
-0.24816542863845825,
-0.2938835024833679,
0.16741688549518585,
0.3605961501598358,
-0.20497798919677734,
0.059682734310626984,
0.22135314345359802,
-0.31064942479133606,
0.572209358215332,
0.20481576025485992,
-0.9337868094444275,
-0.1548008769750595,
-0.21077626943588257,
-0.3523136377334595,
-0.13191834092140198,
-0.062358707189559937,
-0.48928284645080566,
-0.1918075680732727,
-0.6395336985588074,
0.496881365776062,
-0.4780159294605255,
0.13626322150230408,
0.6628785133361816,
0.2002033293247223,
0.07198520004749298,
0.6147928237915039,
-0.8097240328788757,
0.6276929378509521,
0.8257947564125061,
0.8642509579658508,
0.02564210817217827,
-0.28795138001441956,
-0.4823245406150818,
-0.25959205627441406,
-0.6849705576896667,
0.6261256337165833,
-0.6189956068992615,
-0.4566623866558075,
-0.36798804998397827,
-0.4818941056728363,
-0.29300764203071594,
-0.6755838990211487,
0.6318089365959167,
-0.5696577429771423,
0.03487415611743927,
-0.24226167798042297,
-0.42981043457984924,
-0.23790563642978668,
0.0956825464963913,
-0.4790697991847992,
1.2421395778656006,
0.11913686990737915,
-0.3083345293998718,
0.24970829486846924,
-0.6362319588661194,
-0.07655023783445358,
0.0640181303024292,
-0.04036708176136017,
-0.5842916965484619,
0.3411366939544678,
0.14234495162963867,
-0.03101741336286068,
-0.4588257670402527,
0.014754898846149445,
-0.5130107402801514,
-0.4516284465789795,
0.1385735422372818,
-0.2404729574918747,
0.7364072203636169,
0.39517730474472046,
-0.051718950271606445,
-0.2071843296289444,
-0.7246750593185425,
0.18287570774555206,
0.24849456548690796,
-0.28470441699028015,
-0.43231526017189026,
-0.263580858707428,
-0.33059385418891907,
0.2803926169872284,
0.2831856906414032,
-0.5367434620857239,
0.2032402902841568,
-0.5562307834625244,
0.6688233613967896,
0.5673797130584717,
-0.4066867530345917,
0.6326894164085388,
-0.5520119071006775,
0.6695744395256042,
-0.2411566823720932,
0.15078391134738922,
-0.22155457735061646,
-0.7432060837745667,
-0.8076533675193787,
-0.22717487812042236,
0.5124551057815552,
0.08305453509092331,
-0.6503479480743408,
0.00807959958910942,
-0.13278041779994965,
-0.8207157254219055,
-0.7511862516403198,
0.18383203446865082,
0.2578184902667999,
0.5391687154769897,
0.19448503851890564,
-0.40889525413513184,
-0.3591107130050659,
-0.4430720806121826,
-0.29513636231422424,
-0.09843946993350983,
0.1890801638364792,
0.36788374185562134,
0.41454312205314636,
0.07572720944881439,
1.1516985893249512,
-0.6641783118247986,
-0.5239497423171997,
-0.03742928430438042,
0.076020747423172,
0.3525810241699219,
0.3839900493621826,
0.45084458589553833,
-0.7501158118247986,
-0.5594304203987122,
-0.10587547719478607,
-0.6507946252822876,
-0.13787733018398285,
0.322928786277771,
-0.07268800586462021,
0.05313585698604584,
0.09152576327323914,
-0.5611847043037415,
0.7497162222862244,
0.3859437108039856,
-0.23927262425422668,
0.5338323712348938,
-0.41911518573760986,
-0.2760962247848511,
-0.723790168762207,
-0.145529106259346,
0.16930893063545227,
-0.29506224393844604,
-0.533530592918396,
0.2264385223388672,
0.2097918838262558,
-0.6582968831062317,
-0.44566813111305237,
0.3445661664009094,
-0.4801948368549347,
-0.24309185147285461,
-0.2684765160083771,
0.056334931403398514,
-0.0987139418721199,
0.35534489154815674,
-0.07251939177513123,
0.8886699080467224,
0.5483521819114685,
-0.516758918762207,
0.2454560250043869,
-0.14916303753852844,
-0.2292463183403015,
0.3766568601131439,
-0.7024138569831848,
0.3130941092967987,
-0.148238405585289,
0.27130794525146484,
-0.7509040832519531,
-0.04086916521191597,
0.04234888777136803,
-0.5904101133346558,
-0.1368645876646042,
-0.16141487658023834,
-0.6792436242103577,
-0.29182806611061096,
-0.3651040494441986,
0.5667970776557922,
0.3649370074272156,
-0.6805667281150818,
0.8528216481208801,
0.6728639006614685,
-0.15968233346939087,
-0.3682185113430023,
-0.3168764114379883,
0.043802373111248016,
-0.27639055252075195,
-0.8035503029823303,
0.3158429265022278,
-0.176493838429451,
-0.1255604326725006,
-0.12697754800319672,
-0.4987986385822296,
0.037669457495212555,
0.07980737090110779,
0.40711215138435364,
0.5347931385040283,
-0.11986040323972702,
0.07710803300142288,
0.17602001130580902,
-0.4032367467880249,
0.12732306122779846,
-0.408086359500885,
0.8122754693031311,
-0.4847007989883423,
-0.4361725449562073,
0.16287025809288025,
0.02195088192820549,
0.6157276034355164,
-0.2977555990219116,
0.6354843378067017,
0.20111863315105438,
-0.6924672722816467,
-0.48951712250709534,
-0.24318556487560272,
-0.1466522216796875,
-0.5141968727111816,
0.053359951823949814,
-0.6672437787055969,
-0.8152922987937927,
0.6312602162361145,
-0.048618774861097336,
0.3602709174156189,
0.13587646186351776,
0.31138548254966736,
0.17642101645469666,
1.4294774532318115,
0.5645437240600586,
-0.16181334853172302,
0.3383221924304962,
-0.2839850187301636,
0.2402581125497818,
-0.48883455991744995,
-0.4074157774448395,
-0.745634913444519,
-0.2373773455619812,
-0.3765711486339569,
-0.37209558486938477,
0.7845233082771301,
0.24433742463588715,
-0.3130151629447937,
0.5174852609634399,
-0.6005416512489319,
0.5397935509681702,
0.44808241724967957,
0.19121092557907104,
0.4320366084575653,
0.26433026790618896,
-0.0835365429520607,
-0.3033426105976105,
-0.8209875226020813,
-0.5713531374931335,
1.246191382408142,
0.4215508997440338,
1.126567006111145,
0.244781956076622,
0.5735070705413818,
-0.051466744393110275,
0.4450462758541107,
-0.9869008660316467,
0.61406409740448,
-0.12703083455562592,
-0.4089442491531372,
-0.34137222170829773,
-0.6573082804679871,
-1.0529989004135132,
0.502592146396637,
0.07574012130498886,
-0.591656506061554,
-0.05586811527609825,
-0.03790292516350746,
-0.46883583068847656,
0.06807884573936462,
-0.661616325378418,
0.46589431166648865,
0.017634626477956772,
-0.12718254327774048,
-0.21721863746643066,
-0.24170900881290436,
0.25908660888671875,
-0.2177814096212387,
0.2939291298389435,
-0.03150554746389389,
-0.259229451417923,
0.7739005088806152,
-0.7158041000366211,
0.6326304078102112,
0.1461278200149536,
-0.39676880836486816,
0.3817019760608673,
0.25339457392692566,
0.33836400508880615,
0.37867581844329834,
-0.1396012008190155,
0.13290885090827942,
-0.06847194582223892,
-0.4070078730583191,
-0.6114400625228882,
0.892520546913147,
-0.8108806610107422,
-0.43125057220458984,
-0.5284519195556641,
-0.5797953009605408,
-0.0838443860411644,
0.08612393587827682,
0.14417512714862823,
0.6968981623649597,
0.43649822473526,
0.015471757389605045,
0.6975746750831604,
0.2059740424156189,
0.5183521509170532,
0.6849390268325806,
-0.532120406627655,
-0.6098240613937378,
1.3488024473190308,
0.6179065108299255,
0.11796040087938309,
-0.119123175740242,
0.29652661085128784,
-0.4929503798484802,
-0.2590484619140625,
-0.5495198965072632,
0.4299810826778412,
-0.6132856607437134,
-0.3609299957752228,
-0.46382084488868713,
-0.4553733468055725,
-0.2822205424308777,
-0.2098562866449356,
-0.5739568471908569,
-0.4176103174686432,
-0.2962644398212433,
0.20161829888820648,
0.08974968641996384,
0.5817853808403015,
0.10892898589372635,
0.20034681260585785,
-0.5624239444732666,
0.00007542701496277004,
0.3232667148113251,
0.12503288686275482,
0.055538974702358246,
-0.8083000183105469,
-0.23733003437519073,
0.21912990510463715,
-0.5366729497909546,
-0.6298505067825317,
0.643489420413971,
0.07083981484174728,
0.1447402387857437,
0.3308110535144806,
-0.09878560900688171,
1.1240952014923096,
-0.21210946142673492,
0.5626521706581116,
0.14494642615318298,
-1.1701489686965942,
0.40835824608802795,
-0.13714109361171722,
0.18660086393356323,
0.3052505552768707,
0.17180489003658295,
-0.2884635925292969,
-0.2720467150211334,
-0.8605135083198547,
-0.4773576259613037,
0.9692714214324951,
0.323339581489563,
-0.17133736610412598,
0.5415766835212708,
0.5051899552345276,
0.13219454884529114,
0.2954810857772827,
-0.3816567361354828,
-0.2744976282119751,
-0.1528162807226181,
-0.18848437070846558,
-0.19732923805713654,
0.06394308805465698,
0.06680923700332642,
-0.3915289640426636,
0.5744391083717346,
-0.20050595700740814,
0.0417548343539238,
-0.10844156891107559,
-0.12470168620347977,
-0.15550477802753448,
-0.01617494411766529,
0.8217076659202576,
0.9520407319068909,
-0.039266616106033325,
0.3183176815509796,
0.3605755567550659,
-0.9448326230049133,
0.12995992600917816,
0.1550627052783966,
-0.2578924596309662,
0.11720110476016998,
-0.06493768841028214,
0.4272896349430084,
-0.05203676596283913,
-0.6925948262214661,
0.10934971272945404,
-0.07998909801244736,
-0.21083307266235352,
-0.4377569854259491,
0.23179744184017181,
-0.035606369376182556,
-0.06340118497610092,
0.5427701473236084,
0.29636460542678833,
0.09930361807346344,
-0.4740109443664551,
-0.21513493359088898,
0.288587749004364,
-0.24245381355285645,
-0.4398970603942871,
0.5287570953369141,
-0.2527565658092499,
-0.6230469942092896,
0.18764907121658325,
-0.13142460584640503,
-0.6119426488876343,
1.1158065795898438,
0.799715518951416,
0.2481604367494583,
-0.27268683910369873,
0.2369820922613144,
0.3053153455257416,
0.31520602107048035,
-0.4910629093647003,
0.46487775444984436,
0.056528426706790924,
-0.7663469910621643,
-0.23287658393383026,
-0.3982440233230591,
-0.646533191204071,
0.14698699116706848,
-0.9087598919868469,
0.37804126739501953,
-0.6788126826286316,
-0.3287903964519501,
0.0893329307436943,
0.473421573638916,
-0.5035030245780945,
0.24259792268276215,
-0.02815643884241581,
0.9777179956436157,
-0.6014716029167175,
0.8857653141021729,
1.1222269535064697,
-0.08403705060482025,
-1.1750588417053223,
-0.5998942255973816,
0.08005190640687943,
-0.9158481359481812,
0.7172661423683167,
0.17907479405403137,
-0.2955703139305115,
0.17328836023807526,
-0.626541018486023,
-0.8615142107009888,
0.9376636743545532,
0.5923447012901306,
-0.4396096169948578,
0.13377995789051056,
0.3382601737976074,
0.5151935815811157,
-0.5563047528266907,
0.5327514410018921,
0.582595705986023,
0.16520041227340698,
0.2346755862236023,
-0.8545315265655518,
-0.1943848729133606,
-0.21605771780014038,
0.2214249223470688,
0.4512801766395569,
-0.8450508117675781,
1.1128711700439453,
-0.14814165234565735,
-0.1564764827489853,
-0.07555660605430603,
0.6692646741867065,
0.7961275577545166,
0.6698629856109619,
0.5279158353805542,
0.7027464509010315,
0.7917516231536865,
-0.1353394240140915,
0.5095920562744141,
-0.22274178266525269,
0.5755264163017273,
0.8462170958518982,
-0.248309925198555,
0.6514338850975037,
0.2519320547580719,
-0.17765170335769653,
0.047802310436964035,
0.8145597577095032,
0.36874741315841675,
0.37952759861946106,
0.3640082776546478,
-0.3892779052257538,
-0.4353134334087372,
-0.19278647005558014,
-0.5679746270179749,
0.4668934941291809,
0.7516077756881714,
-0.002659785095602274,
-0.5197156667709351,
-0.04810306802392006,
0.02250274457037449,
0.10454034060239792,
-0.7736297249794006,
0.40676987171173096,
0.6032531261444092,
-0.5835466384887695,
0.5950092673301697,
0.3247245252132416,
0.5105591416358948,
-0.6004478931427002,
-0.10361994802951813,
-0.3690079152584076,
0.3161243498325348,
-0.1286921203136444,
-0.4816800653934479,
0.1606484204530716,
-0.048645805567502975,
-0.01310484204441309,
-0.2579033374786377,
0.9756805896759033,
-0.5728471279144287,
-0.5076611042022705,
-0.04881540685892105,
0.33605703711509705,
0.09762220829725266,
0.031974732875823975,
-0.6799196004867554,
0.08872418850660324,
-0.37889933586120605,
0.17821547389030457,
0.5595143437385559,
0.47057756781578064,
-0.08081568032503128,
1.0268796682357788,
0.87867671251297,
0.42577075958251953,
0.06305589526891708,
-0.09788065403699875,
1.1606982946395874,
-0.47254693508148193,
-0.6379822492599487,
-0.8703733086585999,
-0.025615205988287926,
0.07708926498889923,
-0.5414494872093201,
0.970763087272644,
0.775871217250824,
0.9858629703521729,
0.0814838781952858,
0.3565436899662018,
0.385658323764801,
0.31799355149269104,
-0.39763131737709045,
0.5569366216659546,
-0.4553698003292084,
0.4265124797821045,
-0.09368448704481125,
-1.0713177919387817,
-0.06705991178750992,
0.8290172815322876,
-0.4010009169578552,
-0.14019902050495148,
0.5288382768630981,
0.7251838445663452,
-0.02799299731850624,
0.4459571838378906,
0.4357239305973053,
-0.46188676357269287,
0.38148242235183716,
0.832593560218811,
0.9032216668128967,
-0.5699204206466675,
0.5773823261260986,
-0.21283461153507233,
-0.30952250957489014,
-0.08290143311023712,
-0.5124155282974243,
-1.1101486682891846,
-0.1139136403799057,
-0.09622859209775925,
-0.5845682621002197,
-0.06355942040681839,
1.0080159902572632,
0.5881620049476624,
-0.4612239897251129,
-0.5343151092529297,
-0.03482643514871597,
0.20025455951690674,
-0.2907829284667969,
-0.16906902194023132,
0.30404049158096313,
-0.4019928276538849,
-0.8148972392082214,
0.3423798084259033,
0.38213062286376953,
0.028535889461636543,
-0.2516515851020813,
-0.11448103934526443,
0.6939338445663452,
0.3468209505081177,
0.5607265830039978,
0.27271023392677307,
-0.4311719536781311,
0.08882730454206467,
0.24582205712795258,
-0.37744131684303284,
-0.05069249868392944,
0.9333773255348206,
-0.6829298138618469,
0.45422741770744324,
0.2812574803829193,
0.7471055388450623,
0.6762803196907043,
0.09150301665067673,
0.2743821144104004,
-0.1958034783601761,
0.1046876311302185,
0.24117493629455566,
0.29997339844703674,
-0.13599376380443573,
-0.16704441606998444,
0.5749263167381287,
0.3452061414718628,
-0.4188889265060425,
-0.9618198871612549,
0.06218097731471062,
-0.8013972640037537,
0.0719153955578804,
0.896914541721344,
-0.15372878313064575,
-0.38871172070503235,
-0.14248934388160706,
-0.34294798970222473,
-0.1938723623752594,
-0.7872508764266968,
0.9833598136901855,
0.6425307393074036,
0.16003072261810303,
-0.012192449532449245,
-0.45014166831970215,
0.41458433866500854,
0.7205410003662109,
-0.8108055591583252,
-0.4645034670829773,
0.06424412131309509,
0.07329115271568298,
0.2521616220474243,
0.5220199227333069,
-0.25521257519721985,
0.276945024728775,
0.02084178477525711,
-0.2275187224149704,
-0.46449995040893555,
-0.4788760542869568,
-0.27562692761421204,
0.4394877552986145,
-0.12104558199644089,
-0.1870657056570053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11131v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11131v1 | Speculative Streaming: Fast LLM Inference without Auxiliary Models | 2024-02-16T23:36:43 | 2024-02-16T23:36:43 | Nikhil Bhendawade, Irina Belousova, Qichen Fu, Henry Mason, Mohammad Rastegari, Mahyar Najibi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Speculative decoding is a prominent technique to speed up the inference of a
large target language model based on predictions of an auxiliary draft model.
While effective, in application-specific settings, it often involves
fine-tuning both draft and target models to achieve high acceptance rates. As
the number of downstream tasks grows, these draft models add significant
complexity to inference systems. We propose Speculative Streaming, a
single-model speculative decoding method that fuses drafting into the target
model by changing the fine-tuning objective from next token prediction to
future n-gram prediction. Speculative Streaming speeds up decoding by 1.8 -
3.1X in a diverse set of tasks, such as Summarization, Structured Queries, and
Meaning Representation, without sacrificing generation quality. Additionally,
Speculative Streaming is parameter-efficient. It achieves on-par/higher
speed-ups than Medusa-style architectures while using ~10000X fewer extra
parameters, making it well-suited for resource-constrained devices. | [
-0.3241843283176422,
-0.6710733771324158,
0.579135000705719,
0.25709137320518494,
-0.6184144616127014,
0.3713627755641937,
0.003479019971564412,
-0.5206284523010254,
0.6975607872009277,
0.8490820527076721,
-0.8968837857246399,
-0.19811277091503143,
-0.6140450835227966,
-0.08578095585107803,
-0.7605400085449219,
0.42058345675468445,
0.05899898707866669,
-0.20916670560836792,
0.05337662249803543,
0.40098780393600464,
0.11607455462217331,
-0.40170902013778687,
-0.9333926439285278,
0.13155019283294678,
0.678657591342926,
0.40790462493896484,
0.49103134870529175,
1.0065613985061646,
0.34326446056365967,
0.26284298300743103,
0.05911019444465637,
0.44804009795188904,
-0.8956398963928223,
0.29018786549568176,
0.19993849098682404,
-0.6873562932014465,
-0.5639135241508484,
-0.04856298491358757,
0.7759511470794678,
0.5107443332672119,
0.08087863773107529,
0.2617247402667999,
-0.23223498463630676,
0.7546190619468689,
-1.0515527725219727,
-0.059793055057525635,
-0.8573508262634277,
-0.08469761908054352,
-0.6180211305618286,
-0.7688936591148376,
-0.7606207132339478,
-0.16991396248340607,
-0.21166600286960602,
-0.6892075538635254,
0.5705600380897522,
0.44793909788131714,
0.5741018652915955,
0.5206971764564514,
-0.4071071743965149,
0.26380661129951477,
-0.8764734864234924,
0.5801284909248352,
-0.8429776430130005,
0.48731881380081177,
0.545902669429779,
0.2727939784526825,
-0.07393931597471237,
-0.9313156604766846,
-0.5338016152381897,
0.006034640595316887,
0.22286918759346008,
0.29095473885536194,
0.08044026046991348,
0.24229952692985535,
0.28927081823349,
0.24747060239315033,
-0.37907302379608154,
0.19693531095981598,
-0.4191248118877411,
-0.25781020522117615,
0.8523266911506653,
0.45106247067451477,
-0.27369824051856995,
0.15003110468387604,
-0.23381786048412323,
0.2942376434803009,
-0.6427898406982422,
-0.1444137692451477,
0.7226898670196533,
0.28781139850616455,
-0.2784879505634308,
0.4107969403266907,
-0.5766080021858215,
0.6268846988677979,
0.20564039051532745,
-0.03896817937493324,
-0.07782857120037079,
-0.17522265017032623,
-0.1589818149805069,
0.084321990609169,
0.47659769654273987,
0.23638562858104706,
-0.254011332988739,
-0.18960964679718018,
-0.06282882392406464,
0.3745823800563812,
0.20902808010578156,
-0.7743858695030212,
-0.1539800763130188,
0.47612982988357544,
-0.6125841736793518,
-0.31878310441970825,
-0.29188695549964905,
-0.7060022950172424,
-0.29055631160736084,
-0.1277470737695694,
-0.1745910793542862,
-0.5222834944725037,
-0.313789963722229,
0.3440802991390228,
-0.3919578492641449,
0.16725578904151917,
0.33372917771339417,
-1.211240291595459,
0.2901317775249481,
0.7125710844993591,
0.8087783455848694,
-0.35731083154678345,
-0.2815788984298706,
-0.8486012816429138,
0.30591103434562683,
-0.45670658349990845,
1.341853141784668,
-0.5280835628509521,
-0.4136257469654083,
-0.13181257247924805,
-0.3494609296321869,
-0.05069729685783386,
0.0031332182697951794,
1.063706398010254,
-0.8966039419174194,
-0.4622332453727722,
-0.21162769198417664,
-1.087113380432129,
-0.1622297763824463,
-0.047583721578121185,
-0.6851140856742859,
0.6787752509117126,
-0.13055752217769623,
-0.796856164932251,
0.5786082148551941,
-0.20028744637966156,
-0.2700488865375519,
0.2818000912666321,
0.17108429968357086,
0.3411162197589874,
0.3128872215747833,
0.17167887091636658,
0.5399187803268433,
-0.2918296754360199,
0.04247422143816948,
-0.7819182872772217,
-0.7942620515823364,
0.02279757149517536,
-0.9985952973365784,
0.18342527747154236,
0.5843890309333801,
0.29987215995788574,
0.06218880042433739,
-0.6188868284225464,
0.14223939180374146,
-0.1295810490846634,
-0.3971555829048157,
-0.11093780398368835,
0.4702048599720001,
0.20693884789943695,
-0.03270778805017471,
-0.09851184487342834,
-0.5111444592475891,
0.36382707953453064,
-0.4464667737483978,
0.33877190947532654,
0.6927151083946228,
-0.05206506326794624,
0.4258650243282318,
-0.2473306655883789,
0.591854453086853,
-0.2757258415222168,
0.0461471863090992,
-0.3875062167644501,
-0.3962417244911194,
-0.7079899907112122,
-0.5428624749183655,
0.3704890310764313,
0.3105071187019348,
-1.0354818105697632,
0.004324048291891813,
-0.2633803188800812,
-0.5373678803443909,
-0.6260151863098145,
0.044335782527923584,
0.09299574047327042,
0.3662252426147461,
0.22937047481536865,
0.33702442049980164,
-0.701922595500946,
-0.7373377084732056,
-0.4374760091304779,
-0.12815028429031372,
0.1768413782119751,
-0.035776786506175995,
-0.20332850515842438,
-0.16046011447906494,
0.3925613462924957,
-0.5072253346443176,
0.33370286226272583,
-0.4348400831222534,
0.22405897080898285,
0.3121024966239929,
0.38013389706611633,
0.5068473815917969,
-0.5956106781959534,
-0.3844958245754242,
-0.22831080853939056,
-0.5774469375610352,
-0.010009996592998505,
-0.24051862955093384,
-0.2661134600639343,
0.1992977410554886,
0.7819667458534241,
-0.6789463758468628,
0.25796613097190857,
0.7693001627922058,
-0.5077956318855286,
0.6787996292114258,
-0.21897125244140625,
0.16478608548641205,
-0.890845775604248,
-0.33119744062423706,
-0.1259189397096634,
-0.09493942558765411,
-0.6786448359489441,
0.344714879989624,
0.17360854148864746,
0.05761396139860153,
-0.5942005515098572,
0.7228562235832214,
-0.37135425209999084,
0.33909568190574646,
-0.6214046478271484,
-0.27276942133903503,
-0.13058869540691376,
0.12768171727657318,
0.2653002440929413,
0.6599668264389038,
0.7642726898193359,
-0.6302970051765442,
0.0884314626455307,
-0.29284921288490295,
-0.07966803759336472,
-0.2680140733718872,
-0.3467540740966797,
0.17682060599327087,
-0.08131109178066254,
0.3927435576915741,
-0.869417667388916,
-0.3427174389362335,
0.08496882766485214,
-0.20776736736297607,
0.309340238571167,
-0.25822561979293823,
-0.4078512489795685,
-0.5210698843002319,
-0.21334533393383026,
0.5177265405654907,
0.392204612493515,
-0.4066292643547058,
0.8231558799743652,
0.1491939127445221,
0.04408885911107063,
-0.662585973739624,
-0.6605978608131409,
-0.022728897631168365,
-0.07664058357477188,
-0.7340000867843628,
0.5062414407730103,
0.052126627415418625,
-0.014185996726155281,
0.0402226485311985,
-0.2965647280216217,
-0.13309748470783234,
-0.03925381228327751,
0.09590446203947067,
0.4538533687591553,
-0.3902771472930908,
-0.2677597999572754,
0.5218413472175598,
-0.46591413021087646,
-0.054120659828186035,
-0.5385626554489136,
0.40270501375198364,
0.21476566791534424,
-0.3490302562713623,
-0.4497832953929901,
0.7289228439331055,
0.5404382348060608,
0.16590823233127594,
0.45467957854270935,
0.6874973177909851,
-0.22260063886642456,
-0.4302149713039398,
-0.8781392574310303,
-0.26120078563690186,
-0.542935848236084,
0.04453631490468979,
-0.6232470273971558,
-0.9799225330352783,
0.5955348610877991,
-0.03144516795873642,
0.11288971453905106,
0.3595845699310303,
0.341117262840271,
-0.1899687647819519,
0.8845524787902832,
0.6357921361923218,
0.00028391825617291033,
0.3139956593513489,
-0.3044233024120331,
0.10103766620159149,
-0.4555601179599762,
0.06636784970760345,
-0.297650009393692,
-0.4007757008075714,
-0.3662744164466858,
-0.7458482384681702,
-0.08318676054477692,
0.12172751128673553,
0.3346084952354431,
0.05993753299117088,
0.042585283517837524,
0.5483192801475525,
0.6200914978981018,
0.1661972999572754,
0.4338122308254242,
-0.043684542179107666,
-0.1366647481918335,
0.05108121410012245,
-0.8497274518013,
-0.34640833735466003,
1.3068220615386963,
0.15640003979206085,
0.9241830706596375,
-0.09684210270643234,
0.6707596778869629,
0.5168830156326294,
0.290372371673584,
-0.7939910888671875,
0.6000968813896179,
-0.3860187828540802,
-0.5954529643058777,
-0.07236689329147339,
-0.28316590189933777,
-0.5169092416763306,
0.3843575417995453,
-0.5142974853515625,
-0.7195268273353577,
0.2129228115081787,
0.5472656488418579,
-0.5952397584915161,
0.6461487412452698,
-0.9721227884292603,
0.37325000762939453,
0.16209954023361206,
-0.609819769859314,
-0.6138134002685547,
-0.14201056957244873,
0.9658023118972778,
-0.09855200350284576,
-0.11151600629091263,
-0.3781011998653412,
-0.2481597512960434,
0.48518291115760803,
-0.48702532052993774,
0.5983344912528992,
-0.10246666520833969,
0.12520615756511688,
0.4199829697608948,
0.31862789392471313,
0.7026827931404114,
0.2611473798751831,
-0.3999442160129547,
0.1628797948360443,
0.26772916316986084,
-0.6663796901702881,
-0.6959512829780579,
0.5749333500862122,
-0.4957274794578552,
-0.7612249851226807,
-0.3330089747905731,
-0.6573525071144104,
-0.42906248569488525,
0.05300357565283775,
0.5523194074630737,
0.3886203169822693,
-0.03610868752002716,
-0.23132117092609406,
0.546639621257782,
0.31030842661857605,
0.6179400682449341,
0.46938005089759827,
-0.14643409848213196,
0.11817193776369095,
0.8851597309112549,
-0.16343232989311218,
0.32836952805519104,
0.5389867424964905,
-0.12741735577583313,
-0.4751427471637726,
-1.2484002113342285,
-0.33033809065818787,
0.1510266810655594,
-0.4699994921684265,
-0.07298792153596878,
-0.893326461315155,
-0.19125740230083466,
-0.3462061285972595,
-0.34602952003479004,
-0.5181641578674316,
-0.4301679730415344,
-0.28504398465156555,
-0.24344800412654877,
0.4443618655204773,
0.2811512053012848,
-0.08326274901628494,
0.4454686939716339,
-1.0543522834777832,
0.5205111503601074,
-0.06873620301485062,
0.32388684153556824,
0.04526872932910919,
-0.7641167640686035,
-0.19742117822170258,
-0.16758552193641663,
0.046034619212150574,
-0.6989907622337341,
0.6000312566757202,
-0.00410076417028904,
0.5563295483589172,
0.9914012551307678,
0.13566896319389343,
0.9145217537879944,
-0.5664160251617432,
0.4965555965900421,
-0.04876890406012535,
-0.7933008074760437,
0.22883924841880798,
-0.5444754958152771,
0.2986876666545868,
0.5378278493881226,
0.3957986831665039,
-0.3986871838569641,
-0.42386242747306824,
-0.3998972475528717,
-0.8404795527458191,
0.7724770307540894,
-0.10428476333618164,
0.19119931757450104,
-0.056459009647369385,
0.42508387565612793,
0.40300923585891724,
-0.14099830389022827,
0.037138476967811584,
-0.2900337874889374,
0.025564422830939293,
0.2574896216392517,
-0.33045703172683716,
-0.6572946310043335,
0.36739382147789,
-0.393614798784256,
0.6744198203086853,
-0.3458642363548279,
0.4258461892604828,
-0.09510043263435364,
0.24434813857078552,
-0.13498425483703613,
0.033380452543497086,
0.4703696072101593,
0.31130680441856384,
-0.5952052474021912,
0.1620771735906601,
0.0707121267914772,
-0.6060175895690918,
0.10354412347078323,
0.16043944656848907,
-0.299841970205307,
0.047082651406526566,
0.492249459028244,
0.9248728156089783,
0.31817588210105896,
-0.6879726052284241,
-0.09759647399187088,
-0.314233660697937,
-0.47590675950050354,
-0.06458096951246262,
0.2941509783267975,
0.25965073704719543,
0.21566557884216309,
0.5722654461860657,
0.6622331738471985,
0.42624303698539734,
-0.2956954538822174,
0.17842866480350494,
0.2617170214653015,
-0.0077963583171367645,
-0.27450668811798096,
0.7944685220718384,
0.27499404549598694,
0.03665164113044739,
0.5014669299125671,
-0.466793030500412,
0.12854531407356262,
0.39512065052986145,
0.644240140914917,
1.0573318004608154,
0.10836442559957504,
0.06997640430927277,
0.28913456201553345,
0.13128383457660675,
-0.1279708445072174,
0.5542019605636597,
-0.07325422018766403,
-0.8456264734268188,
-0.9681344032287598,
-0.8003576397895813,
-0.33403873443603516,
-0.12009620666503906,
-0.5725263357162476,
0.12153730541467667,
-0.4529758095741272,
-0.21025048196315765,
0.10734167695045471,
-0.22609341144561768,
-0.5682368278503418,
-0.1460295468568802,
0.4716668725013733,
1.5532854795455933,
-0.5805534720420837,
1.2565120458602905,
0.25978827476501465,
0.13649393618106842,
-0.9385181069374084,
0.18279406428337097,
0.27876079082489014,
-0.6111375093460083,
0.5485631823539734,
-0.07240164279937744,
-0.31734853982925415,
0.2238427847623825,
-0.24322457611560822,
-1.2898626327514648,
0.9078890085220337,
0.6167464256286621,
-0.6733879446983337,
-0.32635384798049927,
-0.3025062084197998,
0.24940542876720428,
-0.41366952657699585,
0.4997800588607788,
0.5283857583999634,
0.3253653645515442,
0.5469582676887512,
-0.30864301323890686,
0.12489654123783112,
-0.2836872637271881,
0.04141661152243614,
0.13811525702476501,
-0.6309010982513428,
0.7848435044288635,
-0.37571755051612854,
-0.37180274724960327,
0.1910070925951004,
1.0078716278076172,
0.20008349418640137,
0.2441994845867157,
0.2828649878501892,
0.3555527329444885,
0.9226049184799194,
-0.05711303651332855,
1.3790819644927979,
-0.41488075256347656,
-0.05725850537419319,
1.0996859073638916,
-0.37977221608161926,
1.1633293628692627,
0.6496350169181824,
-0.05823489651083946,
0.2588197886943817,
0.8714520335197449,
0.40675389766693115,
0.6435513496398926,
-0.13008315861225128,
-0.5600984692573547,
-0.6725452542304993,
0.014367254450917244,
-0.32132256031036377,
0.46812811493873596,
0.6941009759902954,
-0.07548650354146957,
-0.24128106236457825,
-0.28316599130630493,
-0.4308810830116272,
-0.0877801775932312,
-0.6308097243309021,
0.31866365671157837,
0.1223781555891037,
-0.6554598808288574,
0.7362739443778992,
0.16270054876804352,
0.9469757676124573,
-0.8140823841094971,
0.23831073939800262,
-0.23388245701789856,
0.13452884554862976,
-0.1328907310962677,
-0.416757196187973,
0.5123535394668579,
-0.12625932693481445,
-0.3056255280971527,
-0.17379547655582428,
0.81246018409729,
-0.04606401175260544,
-0.7525308132171631,
0.3898870050907135,
0.6266941428184509,
0.10431064665317535,
-0.2152196168899536,
-0.4705050587654114,
0.35578688979148865,
-0.1753939390182495,
-0.2716251015663147,
0.13999269902706146,
0.3323959410190582,
0.1472206860780716,
0.9211026430130005,
1.1000031232833862,
0.33199894428253174,
0.35631126165390015,
0.11392393708229065,
0.9110732674598694,
-0.7788781523704529,
-0.747005820274353,
-0.8881985545158386,
0.34992262721061707,
0.14489740133285522,
-0.25580283999443054,
0.7584378123283386,
0.4136301577091217,
0.5231314897537231,
-0.2833373546600342,
0.7318934202194214,
0.1602656990289688,
0.27625903487205505,
-0.9490740895271301,
0.48942428827285767,
-0.32499590516090393,
0.24582664668560028,
0.02147047221660614,
-0.574505090713501,
-0.05172291398048401,
-0.17012520134449005,
-0.2765100598335266,
-0.35217761993408203,
0.8313069343566895,
0.7422670722007751,
-0.22097833454608917,
0.5442955493927002,
0.5016810297966003,
0.10036588460206985,
-0.14265960454940796,
0.5097154378890991,
0.9426019191741943,
-0.2227541208267212,
0.31477174162864685,
-0.28202173113822937,
-0.10053843259811401,
-0.31953078508377075,
-0.9604330658912659,
-0.8372392058372498,
-0.2851344645023346,
-0.16588474810123444,
-0.22048166394233704,
0.14425522089004517,
0.7952442765235901,
1.025244951248169,
-0.6792364716529846,
-0.253000944852829,
-0.13475841283798218,
0.010604015551507473,
-0.5902068614959717,
-0.22402824461460114,
0.10077446699142456,
-0.45621737837791443,
-0.6702674627304077,
0.8210455775260925,
0.4109828472137451,
-0.1783139854669571,
-0.1282409429550171,
-0.07320871204137802,
-0.24118733406066895,
0.38548359274864197,
0.6302146315574646,
0.38375282287597656,
-0.870259702205658,
0.13687822222709656,
-0.014731611125171185,
0.22357586026191711,
-0.32718154788017273,
1.1574862003326416,
-0.8233448266983032,
0.22232985496520996,
0.5794658660888672,
0.7978324890136719,
1.1323738098144531,
-0.00783955305814743,
0.6250256299972534,
-0.3334469199180603,
0.6225681304931641,
0.3130713105201721,
0.48966237902641296,
-0.282745361328125,
-0.6914557218551636,
0.1426435112953186,
0.4141625761985779,
-0.10930493474006653,
-0.6501978635787964,
0.18008877336978912,
-1.1769037246704102,
-0.3476412892341614,
0.921922504901886,
-0.005775391589850187,
-0.28488659858703613,
-0.1612454503774643,
-0.014331272803246975,
0.038822803646326065,
-0.7213854193687439,
0.5485572814941406,
0.4085337817668915,
-0.22320912778377533,
-0.283175528049469,
-0.6784977912902832,
0.4782170057296753,
0.2817957103252411,
-0.5568497180938721,
0.21639634668827057,
0.4606093168258667,
-0.03303907439112663,
-0.19091127812862396,
0.9479950666427612,
0.2883456349372864,
0.2993440628051758,
0.6522087454795837,
-0.4141171872615814,
-0.17932479083538055,
-0.2817041873931885,
0.02746257372200489,
0.343545138835907,
0.006514299660921097,
0.12092816829681396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11129v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11129v1 | BlendFilter: Advancing Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models via Query Generation Blending and Knowledge Filtering | 2024-02-16T23:28:02 | 2024-02-16T23:28:02 | Haoyu Wang, Tuo Zhao, Jing Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented Large Language Models (LLMs) offer substantial benefits
in enhancing performance across knowledge-intensive scenarios. However, these
methods often face challenges with complex inputs and encounter difficulties
due to noisy knowledge retrieval, notably hindering model effectiveness. To
address this issue, we introduce BlendFilter, a novel approach that elevates
retrieval-augmented LLMs by integrating query generation blending with
knowledge filtering. BlendFilter proposes the blending process through its
query generation method, which integrates both external and internal knowledge
augmentation with the original query, ensuring comprehensive information
gathering. Additionally, our distinctive knowledge filtering module capitalizes
on the intrinsic capabilities of the LLM, effectively eliminating extraneous
data. We conduct extensive experiments on three open-domain question answering
benchmarks, and the findings clearly indicate that our innovative BlendFilter
surpasses state-of-the-art baselines significantly. | [
-0.6541908383369446,
-0.9535317420959473,
0.677971601486206,
-0.04115796834230423,
-0.24950799345970154,
0.5429508090019226,
-0.16469615697860718,
-0.5395956635475159,
0.1950509399175644,
0.961516261100769,
-0.6391215324401855,
-0.31010791659355164,
-0.48147520422935486,
-0.2733340561389923,
-0.6178660988807678,
0.5585967302322388,
0.06133152171969414,
0.09473177045583725,
-0.5835757255554199,
-0.12585976719856262,
-0.47485312819480896,
-0.4217040240764618,
-0.7258912920951843,
-0.7062775492668152,
0.30379194021224976,
0.04306449368596077,
0.6589140295982361,
-0.07195446640253067,
0.14971622824668884,
0.2945542633533478,
-0.29792580008506775,
0.7220738530158997,
-0.7696489095687866,
0.6446983814239502,
-0.24121513962745667,
-0.6282761096954346,
-0.13298383355140686,
-0.30863407254219055,
0.6492623090744019,
0.824381411075592,
-0.3604254424571991,
-0.17059023678302765,
0.0805467814207077,
0.6051624417304993,
-0.9427483081817627,
-0.1518247276544571,
-1.0583611726760864,
-0.017851218581199646,
-0.08772971481084824,
-0.28563955426216125,
-0.23864927887916565,
-0.31634238362312317,
-0.0765388086438179,
-0.5297017097473145,
0.14420083165168762,
0.49473583698272705,
0.5080667734146118,
0.13244280219078064,
-0.3762555420398712,
0.12833762168884277,
-0.7014015316963196,
0.7137764692306519,
-0.6413663625717163,
0.5537201166152954,
0.511108934879303,
0.637643575668335,
-0.5366227030754089,
-0.9298346042633057,
-0.7748478651046753,
0.12552522122859955,
-0.0340425968170166,
0.1858208179473877,
-0.10515105724334717,
0.05876646190881729,
0.02096579596400261,
0.5688199996948242,
-0.4693187475204468,
-0.15050184726715088,
-0.20722894370555878,
-0.2255590558052063,
0.4900224506855011,
0.08085201680660248,
0.15945570170879364,
0.2119584083557129,
-0.15441715717315674,
0.16612638533115387,
-0.7605490684509277,
-0.22121460735797882,
0.17717011272907257,
0.2567553222179413,
0.5403604507446289,
0.5946701765060425,
-0.6220574378967285,
0.9789028167724609,
0.014525758102536201,
-0.07645196467638016,
-0.23199379444122314,
-0.43896403908729553,
-0.33422577381134033,
-0.2458152174949646,
0.5108439922332764,
0.13936981558799744,
0.006663052830845118,
-0.22557884454727173,
-0.43567463755607605,
-0.6387278437614441,
0.11200316995382309,
-0.9806177020072937,
-0.26175153255462646,
0.02334790676832199,
-0.13323314487934113,
-0.17195798456668854,
0.10392376780509949,
-0.8545417189598083,
-0.6825045347213745,
-0.19603998959064484,
0.6214667558670044,
-0.09247832000255585,
-0.3840538561344147,
0.3031028211116791,
-0.18896162509918213,
0.31067681312561035,
0.39250245690345764,
-0.44127580523490906,
0.4212453365325928,
0.7838992476463318,
0.569518506526947,
-0.351101279258728,
0.2627546191215515,
-0.8228652477264404,
0.23403117060661316,
-0.18325898051261902,
0.914539635181427,
-0.8351126909255981,
-0.5715445876121521,
0.1726335883140564,
-0.3873614966869354,
-0.03256404399871826,
-1.040199637413025,
0.35678091645240784,
-1.4168274402618408,
0.3447900712490082,
-0.04648713022470474,
-0.7501391768455505,
-0.2584299147129059,
0.360319584608078,
-0.5869516134262085,
1.4319368600845337,
0.16781871020793915,
-0.42980584502220154,
0.19129179418087006,
-0.2704639136791229,
-0.5541525483131409,
0.5136498212814331,
-0.13188685476779938,
0.1384097933769226,
-0.044778287410736084,
0.36690187454223633,
0.04830920696258545,
-0.8300087451934814,
0.3592648506164551,
-0.4014001190662384,
-0.236243337392807,
0.22875240445137024,
-0.2810860872268677,
0.5830725431442261,
0.26096001267433167,
0.19218622148036957,
0.02209698036313057,
-0.5312027335166931,
0.3365134000778198,
0.07387743145227432,
-0.34091249108314514,
-0.43149426579475403,
-0.01359974592924118,
-0.004315638914704323,
0.08801376819610596,
0.2675464153289795,
-0.6146994233131409,
-0.1090785339474678,
-0.3620591163635254,
0.3477587401866913,
0.47689002752304077,
0.4219492971897125,
0.337248831987381,
-0.4543168842792511,
0.719941258430481,
0.05427907034754753,
0.03626302257180214,
-0.15567462146282196,
-0.6926180124282837,
-0.7531190514564514,
-0.2798026204109192,
0.1606016457080841,
0.35621652007102966,
-1.1397556066513062,
0.33653247356414795,
-0.10880545526742935,
-0.3763473331928253,
-0.6109694838523865,
0.48206305503845215,
0.03377167508006096,
0.6966171860694885,
0.4915079176425934,
-0.24807673692703247,
-0.3926449716091156,
-0.6091055274009705,
-0.5912531614303589,
-0.05234237760305405,
-0.13515721261501312,
0.5141605138778687,
0.19193236529827118,
-0.08386588096618652,
1.0820785760879517,
-0.9741904735565186,
-0.06620942056179047,
-0.23902569711208344,
-0.22094354033470154,
0.35038071870803833,
0.20921988785266876,
0.289418488740921,
-1.1222764253616333,
-0.43663033843040466,
0.15122967958450317,
-0.33749333024024963,
-0.20866769552230835,
0.4416176676750183,
-0.5773762464523315,
-0.161681666970253,
0.6907238960266113,
-0.5648141503334045,
0.12037375569343567,
0.2937386631965637,
-0.30378660559654236,
0.3807811141014099,
-0.11899661272764206,
0.36425554752349854,
-0.8983138799667358,
0.10124574601650238,
-0.24596582353115082,
-0.5817071795463562,
-0.4643303155899048,
0.2988622784614563,
-0.041589610278606415,
-0.1246754452586174,
-0.2979485094547272,
0.8963645100593567,
-0.21899326145648956,
0.1964758336544037,
-0.35035789012908936,
0.2923164963722229,
0.5977466106414795,
0.16697265207767487,
-0.27551618218421936,
0.7728145718574524,
0.24164427816867828,
-0.5787375569343567,
0.4563134014606476,
0.09834843128919601,
-0.5075408220291138,
0.7079875469207764,
-0.47866329550743103,
0.0675109326839447,
-0.1938377171754837,
0.29647937417030334,
-1.2264289855957031,
-0.24812236428260803,
-0.07143814861774445,
-0.21250194311141968,
0.2981134057044983,
-0.319232702255249,
-0.6496089100837708,
-0.3832768499851227,
-0.21996819972991943,
0.49204596877098083,
0.6594451665878296,
-0.7136951088905334,
0.9762914776802063,
0.4247901737689972,
-0.1682659089565277,
-0.3501184582710266,
-0.5199763178825378,
-0.025900190696120262,
-0.11110131442546844,
-0.8020603656768799,
0.3835158348083496,
-0.38226577639579773,
-0.052218761295080185,
-0.05925234034657478,
-0.30445995926856995,
-0.5244135856628418,
0.0409202054142952,
-0.2060985118150711,
0.23865684866905212,
-0.3205808997154236,
0.03241043537855148,
0.24108609557151794,
0.5437295436859131,
0.025325309485197067,
-0.42737194895744324,
0.7104116082191467,
0.495738685131073,
-0.4687598645687103,
0.10942494869232178,
0.4412032961845398,
0.6121752262115479,
-0.4913688004016876,
0.8598597645759583,
0.5072889924049377,
-0.42395731806755066,
-0.5455543398857117,
-0.9471898674964905,
-0.31979307532310486,
-0.5374706983566284,
0.3516014516353607,
-0.4650629162788391,
-1.3226560354232788,
0.3977920711040497,
-0.060079872608184814,
-0.05607745796442032,
0.2744072675704956,
0.34907349944114685,
-0.12628711760044098,
0.9942505955696106,
0.25223204493522644,
0.08077981323003769,
0.5838754773139954,
0.11386359483003616,
0.3275807797908783,
-0.9009081125259399,
-0.43152526021003723,
-0.542600154876709,
-0.15577657520771027,
-0.2487296313047409,
-0.7236590385437012,
0.5344843864440918,
0.20016418397426605,
-0.1394127756357193,
-0.24422985315322876,
-0.1601373255252838,
0.7414781451225281,
0.5706185102462769,
0.4059680104255676,
0.6640788912773132,
0.15067078173160553,
-0.2718650698661804,
0.1261945515871048,
-0.7693648934364319,
0.1526961326599121,
1.0811721086502075,
-0.15249823033809662,
0.8642300963401794,
0.013981997035443783,
0.4899575710296631,
0.187140092253685,
0.057642899453639984,
-0.6278042197227478,
0.629515528678894,
-0.15462525188922882,
-0.6822929978370667,
0.00719549972563982,
-0.5742156505584717,
-0.7143262624740601,
0.769253134727478,
-0.4001332223415375,
-0.38671398162841797,
-0.04127342626452446,
0.10303878784179688,
-0.19340692460536957,
0.43609148263931274,
-0.6102365851402283,
0.5043091773986816,
-0.20248854160308838,
-0.4096115827560425,
-0.34313756227493286,
-0.22832365334033966,
0.583946168422699,
-0.28158217668533325,
0.1994357407093048,
-0.1151452586054802,
0.0017928583547472954,
0.46921196579933167,
-0.27527981996536255,
0.5805540680885315,
-0.15496021509170532,
-0.022503744810819626,
0.4511806070804596,
0.21429166197776794,
0.3956961929798126,
-0.04882100597023964,
-0.3047707974910736,
-0.20460830628871918,
-0.08039410412311554,
-0.288434237241745,
-0.7817462086677551,
0.8078123927116394,
-0.2490740269422531,
-0.8616998791694641,
-0.08717691153287888,
-0.7019668221473694,
-0.5313058495521545,
0.4577282667160034,
-0.07590661197900772,
0.2613722085952759,
-0.1810780018568039,
0.290520042181015,
0.9249648451805115,
-0.22912000119686127,
0.03363645821809769,
0.6836804747581482,
-0.6224973797798157,
-0.5164624452590942,
0.8618485927581787,
0.042647071182727814,
0.4789198935031891,
0.4544919431209564,
0.12728367745876312,
-0.40952616930007935,
-0.6599671840667725,
-0.16503570973873138,
0.3267067074775696,
-0.5996893644332886,
-0.3286587595939636,
-0.6551720499992371,
-0.4007090628147125,
-0.49477067589759827,
0.22903060913085938,
-0.09652085602283478,
-0.40454602241516113,
-0.01398051343858242,
0.26808637380599976,
0.3641522228717804,
0.4976080060005188,
0.43107080459594727,
0.23714052140712738,
-0.7491711974143982,
0.5950183868408203,
0.4580811858177185,
0.5207921266555786,
-0.034979771822690964,
-0.6861655712127686,
-0.14057210087776184,
0.015692250803112984,
-0.35747212171554565,
-0.5031388998031616,
0.22827857732772827,
0.5310105085372925,
0.7010722160339355,
0.1317441761493683,
0.30775272846221924,
0.8464949727058411,
-0.4131889343261719,
0.7684735655784607,
-0.003022541990503669,
-0.5024234652519226,
0.5261063575744629,
-0.10153356939554214,
0.5995043516159058,
0.6905495524406433,
0.23654760420322418,
-0.3340260982513428,
-0.47159552574157715,
-0.27439695596694946,
-1.0339024066925049,
0.5398735404014587,
0.06596418470144272,
0.04488900303840637,
0.15905800461769104,
0.4549037516117096,
0.009436838328838348,
0.5197693705558777,
-0.234543114900589,
-0.2167282998561859,
0.14344942569732666,
-0.2307640165090561,
0.24497103691101074,
-0.1958455890417099,
-0.31932616233825684,
-0.3354703485965729,
0.8682427406311035,
-0.07126233726739883,
-0.02574227750301361,
-0.03913053125143051,
-0.30805736780166626,
-0.26918020844459534,
0.06485426425933838,
0.1468711495399475,
0.4379647672176361,
-0.04779154434800148,
-0.022804586216807365,
0.03903988376259804,
-0.3955056965351105,
-0.24840977787971497,
0.31523051857948303,
-0.44167134165763855,
-0.20117981731891632,
0.05666440352797508,
0.6555659174919128,
0.19078747928142548,
-0.935545027256012,
0.2968539297580719,
-0.06748268008232117,
0.010731944814324379,
0.016607195138931274,
0.5486041307449341,
0.18361902236938477,
0.24050641059875488,
0.5558009147644043,
-0.1295345574617386,
0.4931260943412781,
-0.45737236738204956,
0.16691024601459503,
0.7557673454284668,
-0.11991049349308014,
-0.005761086940765381,
0.7955087423324585,
0.1629597693681717,
0.06746313720941544,
0.5134087204933167,
0.1483210176229477,
-0.6201725006103516,
0.243234783411026,
0.5596879124641418,
0.6973005533218384,
-0.21819914877414703,
0.05400652438402176,
0.275957852602005,
0.15516455471515656,
-0.08349644392728806,
0.40328389406204224,
-0.4372336268424988,
-0.7788243889808655,
-0.5407742857933044,
-1.0581247806549072,
-0.5665825009346008,
0.03236842527985573,
-0.5859543681144714,
0.12191181629896164,
-0.10686373710632324,
0.08390919864177704,
-0.020212650299072266,
-0.03071300871670246,
-0.629375696182251,
0.3349246382713318,
0.04987887665629387,
1.0468887090682983,
-0.435240775346756,
0.7424676418304443,
0.8701164126396179,
-0.08883999288082123,
-0.502138078212738,
-0.05354076623916626,
-0.32742998003959656,
-1.0245063304901123,
0.3908533453941345,
-0.0742654800415039,
-0.27626273036003113,
0.12796634435653687,
-0.391275554895401,
-0.7911632061004639,
0.9733452200889587,
0.5501028299331665,
-0.18728803098201752,
0.02174067683517933,
0.20819275081157684,
0.41454291343688965,
-0.3674716055393219,
0.37731701135635376,
0.9004632234573364,
0.5927233695983887,
0.6901166439056396,
-0.6802771687507629,
-0.06953446567058563,
-0.26921308040618896,
0.06329663842916489,
0.3524743914604187,
-0.5683009624481201,
0.4332646429538727,
0.2393275797367096,
-0.04490649700164795,
0.07739905267953873,
0.5910833477973938,
0.29391416907310486,
0.2844472825527191,
0.4262382686138153,
0.471933513879776,
0.8565318584442139,
-0.21565383672714233,
0.9765722751617432,
-0.22931821644306183,
0.0319296270608902,
1.3433805704116821,
-0.5472086668014526,
0.9442736506462097,
0.3951132297515869,
-0.2494654655456543,
0.37551790475845337,
0.33748504519462585,
0.3183826804161072,
0.5213653445243835,
-0.04992767795920372,
-0.7399905920028687,
-0.48729196190834045,
-0.3123325705528259,
-0.21924977004528046,
0.26069772243499756,
0.43630996346473694,
-0.0642673596739769,
-0.2640627920627594,
-0.0998990386724472,
-0.1726146787405014,
0.10307064652442932,
-0.34907931089401245,
0.9217402935028076,
0.1287984848022461,
-1.043699860572815,
0.5215116739273071,
-0.17288687825202942,
0.5366093516349792,
-0.7933691740036011,
-0.003050489816814661,
-0.33935630321502686,
0.05471926927566528,
-0.20894019305706024,
-1.099764108657837,
0.1342102438211441,
-0.307849645614624,
-0.21193131804466248,
-0.09442776441574097,
0.9170101284980774,
-0.9377894401550293,
-0.2442704141139984,
0.3779345750808716,
0.6207274198532104,
-0.14287906885147095,
-0.4222294092178345,
-0.5490456819534302,
-0.06334923952817917,
0.006936841644346714,
-0.2867465615272522,
0.3950877785682678,
0.40960192680358887,
0.13367438316345215,
0.701698362827301,
0.778718888759613,
0.2228233963251114,
0.43118882179260254,
0.2009844183921814,
1.0911924839019775,
-0.4460900127887726,
-0.4353315532207489,
-0.4698171019554138,
0.36804264783859253,
-0.283931165933609,
0.1261170506477356,
0.49561142921447754,
0.615793764591217,
0.7219796776771545,
0.08974263072013855,
0.7124029397964478,
0.07035333663225174,
0.46541836857795715,
-0.5358402132987976,
0.8263807892799377,
-0.8013319373130798,
0.3684833347797394,
0.2437715232372284,
-1.2342004776000977,
-0.36725345253944397,
0.10598025470972061,
-0.05583928897976875,
0.31652671098709106,
0.3194196820259094,
0.9574010968208313,
-0.22850985825061798,
0.053061265498399734,
0.5749880075454712,
0.47141918540000916,
0.45061931014060974,
0.28217756748199463,
0.6227307319641113,
-0.35708922147750854,
0.6173170208930969,
-0.005205498076975346,
0.03511841967701912,
-0.27539119124412537,
-0.6513941884040833,
-0.7839121222496033,
-0.3732605278491974,
-0.20233365893363953,
-0.21529662609100342,
-0.012063478119671345,
0.6100682616233826,
0.8493039011955261,
-0.8601230382919312,
-0.2659473121166229,
0.016397060826420784,
0.2537595331668854,
0.08885446935892105,
-0.2507811188697815,
-0.1072247326374054,
-0.41599929332733154,
-0.845890998840332,
0.7456310391426086,
0.26423054933547974,
-0.22071422636508942,
-0.31362655758857727,
0.07374318689107895,
-0.32879558205604553,
0.4297041594982147,
0.8103969097137451,
0.1817248910665512,
-0.5320289731025696,
0.0024323523975908756,
-0.05112246796488762,
0.14042866230010986,
0.03315701708197594,
0.7494199275970459,
-1.0854085683822632,
0.8794850707054138,
0.6025881767272949,
1.1010059118270874,
0.750917911529541,
0.020354535430669785,
0.5672865509986877,
-0.8046591281890869,
-0.1381789892911911,
0.3252163827419281,
0.46524760127067566,
0.41996607184410095,
-0.3377380073070526,
0.4697825014591217,
0.13053520023822784,
-0.3806605339050293,
-0.9093816876411438,
0.35413292050361633,
-0.8470597863197327,
-0.2278958261013031,
1.0053222179412842,
0.18026064336299896,
0.07189058512449265,
-0.13623426854610443,
-0.20643265545368195,
-0.04317628964781761,
-0.32917192578315735,
0.2728903293609619,
0.8005212545394897,
-0.05188482627272606,
-0.08067082613706589,
-0.6783915758132935,
0.1703270971775055,
0.4806467592716217,
-0.7285277247428894,
-0.17251424491405487,
0.7009741067886353,
0.40563514828681946,
-0.2836945652961731,
0.4881051480770111,
-0.25107669830322266,
0.05632224678993225,
-0.4688705801963806,
-0.2829909324645996,
0.002705354243516922,
-0.03571164608001709,
-0.02538311667740345,
0.5832883715629578,
0.21320952475070953,
0.22062274813652039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14633v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14633v3 | Born With a Silver Spoon? Investigating Socioeconomic Bias in Large Language Models | 2024-02-16T23:18:19 | 2024-04-16T17:14:16 | Smriti Singh, Shuvam Keshari, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | Socioeconomic bias in society exacerbates disparities, influencing access to
opportunities and resources based on individuals' economic and social
backgrounds. This pervasive issue perpetuates systemic inequalities, hindering
the pursuit of inclusive progress as a society. In this paper, we investigate
the presence of socioeconomic bias, if any, in large language models. To this
end, we introduce a novel dataset SilverSpoon, consisting of 3000 samples that
illustrate hypothetical scenarios that involve underprivileged people
performing ethically ambiguous actions due to their circumstances, and ask
whether the action is ethically justified. Further, this dataset has a
dual-labeling scheme and has been annotated by people belonging to both ends of
the socioeconomic spectrum. Using SilverSpoon, we evaluate the degree of
socioeconomic bias expressed in large language models and the variation of this
degree as a function of model size. We also perform qualitative analysis to
analyze the nature of this bias. Our analysis reveals that while humans
disagree on which situations require empathy toward the underprivileged, most
large language models are unable to empathize with the socioeconomically
underprivileged regardless of the situation. To foster further research in this
domain, we make SilverSpoon and our evaluation harness publicly available. | [
-0.07648319005966187,
-0.5490915775299072,
0.5212238430976868,
0.1758810579776764,
0.06333096325397491,
0.37892311811447144,
-0.18704290688037872,
-0.31856569647789,
0.1100139394402504,
0.336540162563324,
-0.2769003212451935,
0.04569664224982262,
-0.8665293455123901,
-0.3034171760082245,
0.026425618678331375,
1.19598388671875,
0.6316598057746887,
0.26462602615356445,
-0.1696760654449463,
-0.08821612596511841,
-0.03511324152350426,
-0.3457907736301422,
-0.4744983911514282,
-0.38446250557899475,
0.27038511633872986,
0.5891897678375244,
0.9637970328330994,
0.39288708567619324,
-0.04332095384597778,
0.2525274157524109,
-0.3655000925064087,
-0.1316078007221222,
-0.46352845430374146,
-0.279158353805542,
-0.35033878684043884,
0.005201694089919329,
-0.447234570980072,
0.23393040895462036,
0.3600171208381653,
0.977510929107666,
0.02037595957517624,
0.7237557768821716,
0.4186133146286011,
0.4405953586101532,
-0.8792927265167236,
-0.019814273342490196,
-0.4504072070121765,
0.04863202944397926,
-0.326555460691452,
0.33209994435310364,
-0.029946327209472656,
-0.4149112403392792,
0.04781424626708031,
-0.36021721363067627,
0.041704706847667694,
-0.3139953911304474,
0.5704707503318787,
-0.04031065106391907,
-0.6684942841529846,
-0.32942837476730347,
-0.390444278717041,
1.063975214958191,
-0.7286626696586609,
0.14453144371509552,
0.4818613529205322,
0.012413442134857178,
0.039097242057323456,
-0.6069038510322571,
-0.5328432321548462,
-0.15885694324970245,
-0.038836754858493805,
0.07769068330526352,
0.13028402626514435,
-0.1991858184337616,
0.2859427034854889,
0.055003710091114044,
-0.20383723080158234,
0.09678301215171814,
-0.6300261616706848,
0.18006464838981628,
0.6520038843154907,
-0.09323026984930038,
0.3476739823818207,
-0.2813757359981537,
-0.14130090177059174,
0.07237604260444641,
-0.3685735762119293,
0.27498334646224976,
0.8601031303405762,
0.3789774775505066,
-0.32821041345596313,
0.5730165243148804,
0.32936573028564453,
0.41151872277259827,
0.09566772729158401,
0.0853896513581276,
0.3038971722126007,
-0.021864918991923332,
0.25309523940086365,
0.40573930740356445,
0.366647332906723,
0.6481518745422363,
0.7082313299179077,
0.18183942139148712,
-0.20088215172290802,
0.32807040214538574,
0.10492829233407974,
-0.5013139247894287,
0.20799647271633148,
0.2632502615451813,
-0.3282676339149475,
-0.39919546246528625,
-0.09094514697790146,
-0.9240843653678894,
-1.0443817377090454,
-0.0015865352470427752,
0.03567218407988548,
0.21734921634197235,
-0.49278831481933594,
0.022079914808273315,
-0.4064478278160095,
0.13256242871284485,
-0.00575270876288414,
-1.0108261108398438,
0.37652766704559326,
0.9038439393043518,
0.8079776763916016,
0.35932493209838867,
-0.31684789061546326,
-0.49601879715919495,
0.22059917449951172,
-0.2735591232776642,
0.5324897766113281,
-0.7339925765991211,
-0.580856442451477,
-0.32874834537506104,
-0.10001260042190552,
0.2512381672859192,
-0.3368067443370819,
0.20138423144817352,
0.09294885396957397,
-0.11728253960609436,
-0.40333542227745056,
-0.13771256804466248,
0.3919510841369629,
0.2303788959980011,
-0.3210936188697815,
0.5475225448608398,
0.3173237442970276,
-1.1496590375900269,
0.6041343212127686,
-0.8639370799064636,
-0.5691136717796326,
0.13672369718551636,
-0.2955869436264038,
-0.11958125978708267,
0.17625395953655243,
0.010892690159380436,
0.11767706274986267,
-0.3403611481189728,
0.6478191614151001,
-0.7093513607978821,
-0.3763982951641083,
0.45920518040657043,
-0.629798173904419,
1.2704850435256958,
-0.03761940449476242,
-0.5679932832717896,
-0.24496527016162872,
-0.7558255195617676,
-0.37141257524490356,
0.23244015872478485,
0.1495743989944458,
-0.9235901236534119,
-0.035300303250551224,
0.13300000131130219,
0.3239339292049408,
0.578236997127533,
-0.7715610861778259,
0.0009391417843289673,
-0.43643200397491455,
0.7262768745422363,
1.2212270498275757,
-0.11922717094421387,
0.6558734178543091,
-0.1533748358488083,
0.486719012260437,
0.0777057632803917,
0.6578947305679321,
0.5215485095977783,
-0.14603984355926514,
-0.40906980633735657,
-0.07804343849420547,
0.4906579554080963,
0.44452425837516785,
-0.15077859163284302,
-0.03620322048664093,
-0.027422361075878143,
-0.1966349482536316,
-1.0141760110855103,
-0.030505413189530373,
0.22263401746749878,
0.4596802294254303,
0.021519377827644348,
-0.2222767323255539,
-0.42131227254867554,
-1.1638875007629395,
-0.4451717138290405,
0.0434127151966095,
0.017574695870280266,
0.5219314694404602,
0.6823647022247314,
-0.19819596409797668,
0.8775020241737366,
-0.34369733929634094,
-0.17967037856578827,
-0.0028083494398742914,
0.007907931692898273,
0.12069050222635269,
0.6042295694351196,
0.2751360535621643,
-0.8027040362358093,
-0.2865617573261261,
0.16620683670043945,
-0.4937313497066498,
-0.3613748252391815,
0.07170892506837845,
0.04073578864336014,
0.17024484276771545,
0.1842893362045288,
-0.3992365896701813,
0.500641942024231,
0.7174790501594543,
-0.7034735679626465,
0.3832366466522217,
-0.08727196604013443,
-0.0704960823059082,
-0.8936434388160706,
0.14479486644268036,
0.21297809481620789,
0.13076914846897125,
-0.2748487591743469,
-0.3990451693534851,
0.03080763667821884,
-0.007057371083647013,
-0.3568827509880066,
0.831804633140564,
-0.46905383467674255,
-0.3472149074077606,
0.023744311183691025,
0.23723256587982178,
-0.019144603982567787,
-0.1500377058982849,
-0.11101391166448593,
0.820289134979248,
0.4225345849990845,
-0.10606089979410172,
-0.19650934636592865,
-0.09100600332021713,
-0.1792738288640976,
0.658876895904541,
-0.9294741153717041,
-0.13339057564735413,
-0.2677787244319916,
0.12708760797977448,
-0.8144568204879761,
-0.0958128422498703,
0.08187442272901535,
-0.5176435112953186,
-0.22676284611225128,
-0.23125284910202026,
-0.2781944274902344,
-0.35475775599479675,
-0.2865162789821625,
0.3604952096939087,
0.5334091782569885,
-0.11229357123374939,
0.2920534610748291,
0.9188113212585449,
-0.594546914100647,
-0.6845042705535889,
-0.7217726111412048,
0.0560721680521965,
-0.38242751359939575,
-0.502139151096344,
-0.2354532927274704,
0.10572097450494766,
-0.8959988951683044,
-0.1694776862859726,
0.03210816904902458,
0.06568622589111328,
0.270738810300827,
0.30966708064079285,
0.19444292783737183,
0.17749501764774323,
-0.11813604831695557,
0.456269234418869,
-0.17696380615234375,
0.08419712632894516,
-0.07469851523637772,
0.5379543900489807,
-0.18091042339801788,
-0.15639033913612366,
0.23752689361572266,
0.4318440854549408,
0.7079376578330994,
-0.268192857503891,
0.5663025379180908,
0.25924205780029297,
-0.22485759854316711,
-0.016713324934244156,
-0.3513749837875366,
-0.1190682128071785,
-0.507614254951477,
0.2270646095275879,
0.008236847817897797,
-0.7980347275733948,
0.638530969619751,
0.28648585081100464,
0.17887777090072632,
0.03850936144590378,
0.27596691250801086,
0.2628915011882782,
1.393757700920105,
0.36738455295562744,
-0.04375596344470978,
0.14952950179576874,
-0.17317867279052734,
0.31520476937294006,
-0.9879211187362671,
0.11789320409297943,
-0.47980690002441406,
-0.32521432638168335,
-0.5740365982055664,
-0.06848064810037613,
0.42545244097709656,
-0.24193838238716125,
-0.49266794323921204,
-0.43434417247772217,
-0.4576195180416107,
0.6174776554107666,
0.3462119698524475,
0.0028601065278053284,
0.21711605787277222,
-0.383149117231369,
0.02739064209163189,
-0.12314864248037338,
-0.6082162261009216,
-0.8272190690040588,
0.9700778126716614,
0.3054538071155548,
0.6030968427658081,
0.009782898239791393,
0.5178927183151245,
0.6862805485725403,
0.4708768129348755,
-0.47914111614227295,
0.35819682478904724,
-0.3201051354408264,
-0.5902605652809143,
-0.3510796129703522,
-0.3377574384212494,
-1.136286973953247,
0.17345720529556274,
0.002914487849920988,
-0.8438389301300049,
0.3852478861808777,
0.2682815492153168,
-0.2989203631877899,
0.00543681625276804,
-0.917294979095459,
0.914722740650177,
-0.3893742561340332,
-0.6880890727043152,
0.014353766106069088,
-0.9604398012161255,
0.4519263207912445,
-0.02316819503903389,
0.9748860001564026,
-0.11945752799510956,
0.10705318301916122,
0.5256983637809753,
-0.2965274453163147,
1.0876487493515015,
-0.5024941563606262,
-0.22760145366191864,
-0.11060747504234314,
-0.005787195172160864,
0.2622557580471039,
0.26692676544189453,
-0.2876328229904175,
0.10039438307285309,
0.09841065853834152,
-0.7651341557502747,
-0.259860098361969,
0.9329608678817749,
-0.9114861488342285,
-0.4477841854095459,
-0.7653460502624512,
-0.6188516020774841,
-0.18549296259880066,
0.3265281021595001,
-0.04818977043032646,
0.342176228761673,
-0.06855730712413788,
-0.1328054666519165,
0.30798617005348206,
-0.2836505174636841,
0.12940995395183563,
0.37648698687553406,
-0.08644133061170578,
-0.24885986745357513,
0.6502537131309509,
0.715659499168396,
0.2725757956504822,
-0.6944613456726074,
0.5647848844528198,
-0.211470827460289,
0.02111542411148548,
-0.45661628246307373,
0.5403000712394714,
-0.34810134768486023,
0.13945917785167694,
-0.5351478457450867,
0.01355035975575447,
-1.0284335613250732,
-0.6384567022323608,
-0.3165288269519806,
-0.21993272006511688,
-0.2823818027973175,
-0.11200027912855148,
0.11394848674535751,
0.7701664566993713,
-0.2449321299791336,
0.09519694000482559,
-0.46823516488075256,
0.13512399792671204,
0.32726606726646423,
0.2920071482658386,
0.4979424476623535,
-0.5497860908508301,
-0.12093618512153625,
0.449318528175354,
-0.23602448403835297,
-0.558133065700531,
0.10681571811437607,
-0.06295206397771835,
0.27684301137924194,
0.35075071454048157,
0.4120645523071289,
0.8482751846313477,
-0.5359045267105103,
0.9427821636199951,
0.003933851607143879,
-1.1051359176635742,
0.3609095811843872,
-0.46028125286102295,
0.5053162574768066,
0.3335510194301605,
0.21602126955986023,
-0.6248134970664978,
-0.6275034546852112,
-1.121665120124817,
-1.2674540281295776,
0.6456338763237,
-0.24974076449871063,
0.25625133514404297,
-0.17523621022701263,
-0.01621977798640728,
0.28844305872917175,
0.2789561450481415,
-0.6637101769447327,
0.10410312563180923,
-0.22335681319236755,
-0.24859993159770966,
-0.29102879762649536,
-0.20292465388774872,
-0.11592558026313782,
-0.21943365037441254,
0.43906643986701965,
0.010844079777598381,
-0.3666931390762329,
-0.0553225502371788,
-0.2418266385793686,
-0.06974757462739944,
0.3809804618358612,
0.40898701548576355,
1.0051655769348145,
0.20783631503582,
0.20647765696048737,
0.15800032019615173,
-0.5793527364730835,
0.19933997094631195,
0.14636430144309998,
-0.17475107312202454,
-0.4112088680267334,
-0.016064705327153206,
0.5853782296180725,
0.22091792523860931,
-0.9802654981613159,
0.6453712582588196,
-0.03912230581045151,
0.06148192286491394,
-0.724801242351532,
-0.04929598793387413,
0.21801285445690155,
0.6121259927749634,
0.3692655861377716,
-0.2544970214366913,
0.3716977834701538,
-0.614494264125824,
-0.16311289370059967,
0.493617445230484,
-0.29314035177230835,
-0.2596713900566101,
0.4337581694126129,
0.07596662640571594,
-0.463998943567276,
0.46944427490234375,
-0.04926075041294098,
-0.33193233609199524,
0.4752371609210968,
0.6139023303985596,
0.5371776819229126,
-0.06882697343826294,
0.5609254240989685,
-0.1862582266330719,
0.3445572555065155,
-0.08988963812589645,
0.10391120612621307,
-0.22837580740451813,
-0.7352781295776367,
-0.09221593290567398,
-0.8617409467697144,
-0.24604488909244537,
-0.08252715319395065,
-0.7625863552093506,
0.0682082250714302,
-0.4165489673614502,
-0.3795166313648224,
0.1018010601401329,
-0.10535039752721786,
-0.2715901732444763,
0.1085863709449768,
-0.07116753607988358,
0.5807780027389526,
-1.3251255750656128,
0.4097261130809784,
0.8358618021011353,
-0.2281695157289505,
-0.3501668870449066,
0.060260821133852005,
0.02206539735198021,
-0.8185962438583374,
0.6155071258544922,
0.07647961378097534,
-0.2643868029117584,
0.12418795377016068,
-0.38945457339286804,
-0.628270149230957,
0.6796118021011353,
0.4231923818588257,
-0.20947574079036713,
-0.06909521669149399,
0.19640234112739563,
0.4307301938533783,
-0.1949443370103836,
0.08917856961488724,
0.9102157950401306,
0.6847246289253235,
-0.21913926303386688,
-0.9316540360450745,
-0.2634064853191376,
-0.40501081943511963,
0.23514944314956665,
0.17987386882305145,
-0.8868416547775269,
0.8960050344467163,
-0.33118629455566406,
0.14748339354991913,
-0.2765924036502838,
0.24134580790996552,
0.4403461515903473,
0.6386387348175049,
0.5421125292778015,
0.3036341369152069,
0.5837604403495789,
0.26140081882476807,
0.7523724436759949,
-0.21107448637485504,
0.38370591402053833,
0.8951765298843384,
-0.7491210103034973,
0.31753382086753845,
0.7830326557159424,
-0.04847114160656929,
0.26924943923950195,
0.46356919407844543,
0.21581168472766876,
0.2669844925403595,
0.3558409810066223,
-0.2548227310180664,
0.027087150141596794,
-0.47062405943870544,
-0.14335793256759644,
0.5018322467803955,
0.46340638399124146,
-0.32009357213974,
-0.09375347942113876,
0.22459720075130463,
0.370382696390152,
0.25257551670074463,
-0.7199808955192566,
0.6018086671829224,
0.07647889852523804,
-0.435078889131546,
0.12434381991624832,
-0.3088899254798889,
0.7989879250526428,
-0.5485286712646484,
0.09193259477615356,
-0.24558469653129578,
0.29303836822509766,
-0.3094898760318756,
-0.8576052784919739,
0.19130101799964905,
0.24764622747898102,
-0.0898250937461853,
-0.041140373796224594,
0.7732715606689453,
-0.31450653076171875,
-0.6202698945999146,
0.27460289001464844,
0.28498122096061707,
0.15849445760250092,
0.34109005331993103,
-0.7366876602172852,
0.22505035996437073,
-0.1079200878739357,
-0.22883887588977814,
0.6018511056900024,
0.6225870847702026,
-0.26304230093955994,
0.5116538405418396,
0.3363478481769562,
0.4951784312725067,
0.013140284456312656,
0.10934284329414368,
0.49082276225090027,
-0.5095590949058533,
-0.8205052614212036,
-0.8896681070327759,
0.8331429958343506,
-0.5257422924041748,
-0.5216596722602844,
0.9458335638046265,
0.48907098174095154,
0.6732032895088196,
0.05438733100891113,
1.0626928806304932,
-0.07526926696300507,
0.45047900080680847,
-0.06129175052046776,
0.941383957862854,
-0.7177090048789978,
0.03777959942817688,
-0.6492180824279785,
-0.43981286883354187,
-0.01934232749044895,
0.9134013652801514,
-0.664795458316803,
0.3623008131980896,
0.03178797662258148,
0.6986656188964844,
-0.22327490150928497,
-0.08722858875989914,
0.19764454662799835,
0.30028197169303894,
0.026443995535373688,
0.1016881912946701,
0.7554354071617126,
0.09358161687850952,
-0.09671475738286972,
0.06347036361694336,
-0.44818779826164246,
-0.061844974756240845,
-0.7277761697769165,
-0.4920964241027832,
-0.3310963809490204,
-0.11064121127128601,
-0.6362187266349792,
0.25716644525527954,
0.9745205044746399,
0.21847094595432281,
-0.36956509947776794,
-0.6525676250457764,
0.21596607565879822,
0.28999394178390503,
-0.01769055239856243,
-0.3228030204772949,
0.18172286450862885,
-0.02760680764913559,
-0.7845678925514221,
-0.447678804397583,
0.2885406017303467,
-0.012634295970201492,
-0.5042287111282349,
0.09243880957365036,
-0.22986085712909698,
0.24579617381095886,
0.6471861600875854,
0.18162475526332855,
-0.3862234652042389,
-0.38508445024490356,
-0.22287558019161224,
0.015134043991565704,
-0.30833449959754944,
0.6728528738021851,
-0.4330246150493622,
0.16652430593967438,
0.05742494389414787,
0.4057745933532715,
0.06466749310493469,
-0.02730555459856987,
0.40027859807014465,
-0.6561688184738159,
0.29419252276420593,
0.4184837341308594,
0.09624123573303223,
0.4711807370185852,
-0.48311686515808105,
0.0960257351398468,
0.1948946714401245,
-0.82770836353302,
-1.256224513053894,
0.3856656849384308,
-0.5067341327667236,
-0.5037743449211121,
1.2063980102539062,
0.18242475390434265,
-0.37001362442970276,
-0.24023589491844177,
-0.2351282835006714,
0.35741788148880005,
-0.684693455696106,
1.0505473613739014,
0.5954651236534119,
0.1342136114835739,
-0.25265711545944214,
-0.3537781536579132,
0.08504021167755127,
0.20396721363067627,
-0.298104465007782,
0.4233252704143524,
0.6804301738739014,
0.36830535531044006,
-0.0570904016494751,
0.5787703990936279,
-0.24358902871608734,
0.21484720706939697,
0.11052776873111725,
0.1425425410270691,
0.11446703970432281,
-0.060375064611434937,
-0.3238452672958374,
0.20416143536567688,
0.28006529808044434,
0.20644156634807587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11122v1 | Navigating the Dual Facets: A Comprehensive Evaluation of Sequential Memory Editing in Large Language Models | 2024-02-16T23:08:55 | 2024-02-16T23:08:55 | Zihao Lin, Mohammad Beigi, Hongxuan Li, Yufan Zhou, Yuxiang Zhang, Qifan Wang, Wenpeng Yin, Lifu Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Memory Editing (ME) has emerged as an efficient method to modify erroneous
facts or inject new facts into Large Language Models (LLMs). Two mainstream ME
methods exist: parameter-modifying ME and parameter-preserving ME (integrating
extra modules while preserving original parameters). Regrettably, previous
studies on ME evaluation have two critical limitations: (i) evaluating LLMs
with single edit only, neglecting the need for continuous editing, and (ii)
evaluations focusing solely on basic factual triples, overlooking broader LLM
capabilities like logical reasoning and reading understanding. This study
addresses these limitations with contributions threefold: (i) We explore how ME
affects a wide range of fundamental capabilities of LLMs under sequential
editing. Experimental results reveal an intriguing phenomenon: Most
parameter-modifying ME consistently degrade performance across all tasks after
a few sequential edits. In contrast, parameter-preserving ME effectively
maintains LLMs' fundamental capabilities but struggles to accurately recall
edited knowledge presented in a different format. (ii) We extend our evaluation
to different editing settings, such as layers to edit, model size, instruction
tuning, etc. Experimental findings indicate several strategies that can
potentially mitigate the adverse effects of ME. (iii) We further explain why
parameter-modifying ME damages LLMs from three dimensions: parameter changes
after editing, language modeling capability, and the in-context learning
capability. Our in-depth study advocates more careful use of ME in real-world
scenarios. | [
-0.2148648202419281,
-1.1132808923721313,
0.7408283352851868,
0.2498849481344223,
-0.21984340250492096,
0.19811688363552094,
-0.41701993346214294,
-0.2820497155189514,
-0.11858801543712616,
0.578140377998352,
-0.3523973822593689,
-0.3717603385448456,
-0.4889576733112335,
0.006058336701244116,
-0.09720145910978317,
0.9940887689590454,
-0.26295822858810425,
0.14653275907039642,
-0.2475067377090454,
-0.3038364350795746,
-0.7635632753372192,
-0.678941011428833,
-0.8401676416397095,
-0.07258115708827972,
0.6990777254104614,
0.39999499917030334,
0.8576998114585876,
0.545690655708313,
0.2763497829437256,
0.31850168108940125,
-0.37539738416671753,
0.03571270406246185,
-0.41664811968803406,
0.11078815907239914,
-0.39279499650001526,
-0.35439181327819824,
-0.7109092473983765,
0.14038333296775818,
1.023056149482727,
0.8024401068687439,
0.15591415762901306,
0.22685857117176056,
0.1955597698688507,
0.8961167335510254,
-0.6736767292022705,
-0.18786579370498657,
-0.6240001320838928,
-0.08334830403327942,
-0.4055671989917755,
-0.19329532980918884,
-0.3865358531475067,
-0.04920579865574837,
0.2053578644990921,
-0.24235743284225464,
-0.07249945402145386,
-0.18891604244709015,
0.43358245491981506,
0.3118872046470642,
-0.32410702109336853,
-0.2795981168746948,
-1.0508451461791992,
0.6509341597557068,
-0.6432076096534729,
0.3452971875667572,
0.05391823872923851,
0.22511747479438782,
-0.15076175332069397,
-0.5766487717628479,
-0.5762888193130493,
-0.1950160264968872,
0.07468846440315247,
0.07952433079481125,
-0.08511455357074738,
0.27495914697647095,
0.5662426948547363,
0.26455533504486084,
-0.4023838937282562,
0.2257993221282959,
-0.624006986618042,
-0.32068049907684326,
0.4140965938568115,
0.3651237487792969,
0.32055139541625977,
-0.13783375918865204,
-0.13856635987758636,
-0.021294444799423218,
-0.7679966688156128,
0.129659503698349,
0.579709529876709,
0.011386719532310963,
0.3564227819442749,
0.6529953479766846,
0.05120128393173218,
0.8054459691047668,
0.010777625255286694,
-0.32072725892066956,
-0.19041109085083008,
-0.39828047156333923,
-0.2619791328907013,
-0.22075799107551575,
0.5774775147438049,
0.34405696392059326,
0.046938370913267136,
-0.15625105798244476,
-0.06504019349813461,
-0.26580509543418884,
0.2028547078371048,
-0.7763792276382446,
-0.10466956347227097,
0.23677639663219452,
-0.35417306423187256,
-0.025893568992614746,
-0.15337219834327698,
-0.6222452521324158,
-0.3044126033782959,
-0.37470611929893494,
0.6107778549194336,
-0.5529324412345886,
0.08581655472517014,
0.42908015847206116,
-0.08723658323287964,
-0.16279694437980652,
0.7231445908546448,
-0.7902393937110901,
0.23695822060108185,
0.7538660168647766,
0.8574284911155701,
0.09567462652921677,
-0.6312006711959839,
-0.4027152359485626,
0.2279379963874817,
-0.14641590416431427,
0.6656967997550964,
-0.7178421020507812,
-0.38720858097076416,
-0.2625791132450104,
-0.29905617237091064,
-0.22225452959537506,
-0.6637558937072754,
0.43924251198768616,
-0.8291531205177307,
0.1305348426103592,
-0.5208545327186584,
-0.41122567653656006,
-0.19196411967277527,
0.012325603514909744,
-0.7010828852653503,
0.6641923189163208,
-0.023496143519878387,
-0.6071423888206482,
0.31878861784935,
-0.30835720896720886,
-0.39160120487213135,
-0.5085275173187256,
-0.0859142392873764,
-0.26538634300231934,
0.3293939530849457,
-0.030090898275375366,
0.4200110137462616,
-0.0621490478515625,
0.3439212441444397,
-0.14446289837360382,
-0.274227112531662,
0.3013424575328827,
-0.4404889643192291,
0.5311740040779114,
-0.07263878732919693,
-0.007193917874246836,
0.23320050537586212,
-0.7232565879821777,
-0.26631394028663635,
-0.24956373870372772,
-0.602288544178009,
-0.4568236470222473,
0.02710329368710518,
-0.3110225200653076,
0.42203205823898315,
0.3727368116378784,
-0.4532971680164337,
0.41810908913612366,
-0.12999719381332397,
0.2964337170124054,
1.0484347343444824,
0.27886244654655457,
0.5166334509849548,
-0.30246132612228394,
0.4335091710090637,
0.13799282908439636,
0.1352628916501999,
-0.1937391459941864,
-0.3579194247722626,
-0.7047196626663208,
-0.20690499246120453,
0.3520171642303467,
0.6436637043952942,
-0.6648535132408142,
0.1658967286348343,
-0.2444159835577011,
-0.18727360665798187,
-0.48438289761543274,
0.3643065392971039,
0.5220124125480652,
0.5399580001831055,
0.4794416129589081,
-0.14360107481479645,
-0.37157249450683594,
-1.2336026430130005,
-0.7115089297294617,
-0.1517513245344162,
0.07589714229106903,
0.16598211228847504,
0.4652670621871948,
-0.23634114861488342,
0.7413820028305054,
-0.3178388476371765,
-0.1089940145611763,
-0.07413598895072937,
0.22625023126602173,
0.09033143520355225,
0.6113492250442505,
0.28931689262390137,
-0.18491186201572418,
-0.3884296715259552,
-0.27996179461479187,
-0.5295103192329407,
-0.2846720814704895,
-0.6546329855918884,
-0.13317105174064636,
0.2679153382778168,
0.4547116160392761,
-0.5946972966194153,
0.5193800926208496,
0.3593950569629669,
-0.3383398950099945,
0.8873871564865112,
-0.5219696760177612,
0.32630643248558044,
-0.5307439565658569,
-0.16580189764499664,
-0.18549253046512604,
0.023743154481053352,
-0.7359108924865723,
0.06468295305967331,
0.367225706577301,
0.2253885716199875,
-0.19120655953884125,
0.6494902968406677,
-0.6014124751091003,
-0.12129712849855423,
-0.26519882678985596,
0.07682236284017563,
0.08399251103401184,
0.4049373269081116,
-0.3576200306415558,
0.9330174326896667,
0.25381243228912354,
-0.6245806217193604,
-0.01664157211780548,
0.06282082945108414,
-0.37838560342788696,
0.45723479986190796,
-0.4184653162956238,
0.4978974461555481,
-0.18265345692634583,
0.19207873940467834,
-0.8787050247192383,
0.19126778841018677,
0.18674759566783905,
0.0503651387989521,
0.607537031173706,
-0.0006809295155107975,
-0.7862362861633301,
-0.12549395859241486,
-0.48337170481681824,
0.5065792202949524,
0.23015332221984863,
-0.5788053274154663,
0.5093918442726135,
0.0926593691110611,
-0.3084449768066406,
-0.48163843154907227,
-0.6024052500724792,
0.4632619619369507,
-0.2210288941860199,
-0.9272818565368652,
0.35537323355674744,
-0.2765848934650421,
-0.6219351887702942,
-0.025285474956035614,
-0.385700523853302,
0.09110953658819199,
0.07735031098127365,
-0.021635733544826508,
0.1962098926305771,
-0.12463725358247757,
-0.0002489877224434167,
0.5680856108665466,
-0.30941152572631836,
-0.030740952119231224,
-0.03249687701463699,
0.1965222805738449,
-0.12486019730567932,
-0.3428824543952942,
-0.5001609325408936,
0.29929518699645996,
0.5560994744300842,
-0.3697509169578552,
0.7489827871322632,
0.3238784670829773,
-0.15104199945926666,
-0.11099483072757721,
-0.871856689453125,
-0.018288949504494667,
-0.4607332646846771,
0.5504260659217834,
-0.7411108016967773,
-1.1274935007095337,
0.6195691823959351,
-0.18122118711471558,
0.18724970519542694,
0.33040937781333923,
0.3508148789405823,
-0.05973341688513756,
0.8792227506637573,
0.38725027441978455,
0.13594761490821838,
0.27482157945632935,
-0.06745278835296631,
0.2930968105792999,
-1.2916494607925415,
-0.08806468546390533,
-0.2835956811904907,
-0.6362756490707397,
-0.34714218974113464,
-0.798672616481781,
0.536464512348175,
0.4046059250831604,
0.03547103703022003,
-0.044203754514455795,
-0.018377576023340225,
0.44808658957481384,
0.15837562084197998,
0.2690633237361908,
0.4860178232192993,
-0.3419475555419922,
-0.06485749781131744,
-0.46484166383743286,
-0.4816216230392456,
-0.8169950246810913,
1.10657799243927,
0.40849798917770386,
0.6245807409286499,
0.30029046535491943,
0.3908534348011017,
0.0627463161945343,
0.2555558979511261,
-0.6608303785324097,
0.690217137336731,
-0.2831727862358093,
-0.535944938659668,
-0.26445576548576355,
-0.22659239172935486,
-0.47092798352241516,
0.4932394325733185,
-0.13439549505710602,
-0.6939913034439087,
0.03952806442975998,
0.26554811000823975,
-0.4694536626338959,
0.5830792784690857,
-0.6698067784309387,
0.7848979830741882,
-0.42685914039611816,
-0.7309550046920776,
-0.664946436882019,
-0.5348528623580933,
0.6199796199798584,
-0.2698589563369751,
0.22769157588481903,
0.0554899238049984,
-0.4405011236667633,
0.6838298439979553,
-0.44933879375457764,
0.6987760066986084,
-0.30186572670936584,
0.10137312114238739,
0.11929982155561447,
0.3435073494911194,
0.3572899103164673,
0.2079612910747528,
-0.20740215480327606,
0.0923285111784935,
0.12142795324325562,
-0.3417668044567108,
-0.9943040609359741,
0.8410113453865051,
-0.5946956276893616,
-0.9930254220962524,
-0.31331294775009155,
-0.688434898853302,
-0.4173929989337921,
0.06465228646993637,
-0.27505162358283997,
0.47007253766059875,
-0.30044275522232056,
0.04140244051814079,
0.6790015697479248,
-0.5998978614807129,
0.2993515133857727,
0.5729389786720276,
-0.29491668939590454,
-0.3185451328754425,
0.6923454403877258,
0.4941645562648773,
0.4772654175758362,
0.24854139983654022,
0.41196075081825256,
0.10648591816425323,
-0.893639862537384,
-0.5499032735824585,
0.32061877846717834,
-0.6740053296089172,
0.268464058637619,
-0.7845271825790405,
0.025904519483447075,
-0.062358032912015915,
-0.11739829182624817,
-0.37949198484420776,
-0.6576559543609619,
-0.18226109445095062,
-0.074858158826828,
0.1726483851671219,
0.9079379439353943,
-0.3000278174877167,
0.4589158892631531,
-0.693173348903656,
0.2157861888408661,
0.39295095205307007,
0.4353857636451721,
0.016255229711532593,
-0.6094920039176941,
-0.3790552318096161,
-0.12340762466192245,
-0.10734245926141739,
-0.9122995734214783,
-0.07904493808746338,
0.09584366530179977,
0.48910242319107056,
0.2744339406490326,
-0.44936180114746094,
1.1715468168258667,
-0.886381208896637,
0.6783896684646606,
-0.3026774227619171,
-1.043588638305664,
0.3702159523963928,
-0.20696313679218292,
0.4631350636482239,
0.7641162872314453,
0.062308140099048615,
-0.48858875036239624,
-0.3715119957923889,
-0.4838119149208069,
-0.7257941365242004,
0.7414350509643555,
-0.18114009499549866,
0.20358039438724518,
0.23395998775959015,
0.9387195110321045,
0.3036327064037323,
0.21134181320667267,
-0.25789889693260193,
-0.3540361225605011,
0.20030207931995392,
0.2982804775238037,
-0.07082729041576385,
-0.8792814016342163,
0.21816030144691467,
-0.5970830917358398,
0.6925354599952698,
0.31257346272468567,
-0.10738474875688553,
0.1240687295794487,
-0.3355563282966614,
-0.06862196326255798,
0.2751736342906952,
0.8564049005508423,
0.9026707410812378,
-0.36365553736686707,
0.1500515341758728,
0.2745164632797241,
-0.3976811468601227,
-0.09704840183258057,
-0.2709778845310211,
-0.2548183500766754,
-0.06056078523397446,
0.2978478670120239,
0.7722539305686951,
0.7455620765686035,
-0.5218127965927124,
0.17869921028614044,
-0.1056455597281456,
-0.024167636409401894,
-0.06632357090711594,
0.0921342670917511,
-0.004515651147812605,
0.24625074863433838,
0.031021829694509506,
0.4797932505607605,
0.10661116242408752,
-0.6128019094467163,
0.2036665380001068,
0.46828827261924744,
0.08979358524084091,
-0.6444765329360962,
0.5259672403335571,
-0.15977337956428528,
-0.2386411428451538,
0.5067285895347595,
0.007500975392758846,
-0.44224417209625244,
0.18938937783241272,
0.36724311113357544,
0.9462966918945312,
-0.5018684267997742,
-0.029499102383852005,
0.5683650374412537,
0.5783719420433044,
0.08820540457963943,
0.012070936150848866,
-0.019789323210716248,
-0.6505554914474487,
-0.4563503563404083,
-0.40961411595344543,
-0.43788257241249084,
0.34247440099716187,
-0.6210245490074158,
0.24023573100566864,
-0.9059969186782837,
0.018052395433187485,
-0.005994969513267279,
-0.08253735303878784,
-0.5034371614456177,
0.06611455976963043,
-0.0382101871073246,
0.8953623175621033,
-0.5529641509056091,
0.9224534630775452,
0.7228379845619202,
-0.2648344337940216,
-0.4330989718437195,
0.13643638789653778,
0.2871799170970917,
-0.6823471784591675,
0.3293883800506592,
-0.02793210931122303,
-0.10716758668422699,
-0.14279663562774658,
-0.4074341654777527,
-0.8274142742156982,
1.0376129150390625,
0.33073997497558594,
-0.4436357915401459,
-0.0043700020760297775,
0.01717217080295086,
0.5644097328186035,
0.00027550061349757016,
0.1467052698135376,
0.9802322387695312,
0.6494864225387573,
0.12373138964176178,
-0.8328853249549866,
0.016400545835494995,
-0.05717650055885315,
-0.0006978171295486391,
0.1395968794822693,
-0.6936662197113037,
1.021182894706726,
-0.3229518234729767,
-0.24591246247291565,
0.1923585683107376,
0.5647636651992798,
0.08319270610809326,
-0.00868703331798315,
0.43282467126846313,
0.6502491235733032,
0.7217483520507812,
0.25270941853523254,
1.011130452156067,
-0.2109510451555252,
-0.06246582046151161,
1.3819929361343384,
-0.24551108479499817,
0.9579329490661621,
0.6803584694862366,
-0.16165852546691895,
0.36150723695755005,
0.40537625551223755,
0.3290728032588959,
0.31898537278175354,
0.18417665362358093,
-0.41314858198165894,
-0.047588050365448,
0.3735918402671814,
-0.18590189516544342,
0.4180971682071686,
0.4303431808948517,
-0.1294384002685547,
-0.20632995665073395,
-0.04281627759337425,
0.5433377027511597,
0.0624421089887619,
-0.11336059868335724,
0.6395323872566223,
0.006992488633841276,
-0.6157519817352295,
0.23254549503326416,
0.4157394766807556,
0.3829710781574249,
-0.4900546073913574,
-0.01420772634446621,
-0.08478900045156479,
0.15115886926651,
-0.12723588943481445,
-0.8020250797271729,
0.6895278096199036,
0.2295553982257843,
-0.35586538910865784,
-0.533603847026825,
0.6122376918792725,
-0.4128280282020569,
-0.33327412605285645,
0.37019574642181396,
0.5987725853919983,
0.009446021169424057,
-0.342440664768219,
-0.7760432362556458,
0.448799192905426,
0.017935829237103462,
-0.40339305996894836,
0.562056839466095,
0.4312964975833893,
-0.09524405002593994,
0.4022320508956909,
0.5506245493888855,
0.20763717591762543,
0.15587516129016876,
0.13305340707302094,
0.8289387226104736,
-0.8798027038574219,
-0.1634347140789032,
-1.1049325466156006,
0.8404449224472046,
0.1539773792028427,
-0.2453928142786026,
0.8634507060050964,
0.769176185131073,
0.7532023787498474,
-0.041277337819337845,
0.688127875328064,
0.09690649062395096,
0.3540101647377014,
-0.8144235014915466,
0.531157374382019,
-0.427053302526474,
0.6485142111778259,
-0.30442360043525696,
-0.89132159948349,
-0.3850330710411072,
0.28243711590766907,
-0.643999457359314,
0.002374278148636222,
0.9871512055397034,
0.758211076259613,
0.10247324407100677,
-0.03264997899532318,
0.5646079182624817,
0.8236216902732849,
0.2915348708629608,
0.45238861441612244,
1.0783878564834595,
-0.3625950515270233,
-0.022708725184202194,
-0.6201500296592712,
-0.43037235736846924,
0.06352131068706512,
-0.7936842441558838,
-1.0695021152496338,
-0.5519176721572876,
-0.4227767586708069,
-0.15157833695411682,
0.09005492925643921,
0.5901020169258118,
0.21285967528820038,
-0.6202012300491333,
-0.3268437385559082,
0.3924427926540375,
0.25996142625808716,
0.01943228207528591,
-0.13018518686294556,
0.3955345153808594,
-0.13132736086845398,
-0.6243644952774048,
0.6065610647201538,
0.7895855903625488,
-0.2979888617992401,
-0.38129064440727234,
0.07417304068803787,
-0.34402015805244446,
0.07285478711128235,
0.7581042051315308,
0.18784542381763458,
-0.8820040225982666,
-0.5458683967590332,
-0.27738580107688904,
0.033587824553251266,
0.013780303299427032,
0.9016382694244385,
-0.7332423329353333,
0.8507183790206909,
0.4884125292301178,
0.679232656955719,
0.3040562570095062,
0.05475691705942154,
0.5649051666259766,
-0.43209829926490784,
0.13271312415599823,
0.001773867174051702,
0.425454705953598,
0.3512478768825531,
-0.4201417565345764,
0.1410948485136032,
0.15465645492076874,
-0.6568233370780945,
-0.6450013518333435,
-0.04130459204316139,
-0.9357329607009888,
-0.24084404110908508,
1.051419734954834,
0.10112395137548447,
-0.09858045727014542,
-0.03515616059303284,
-0.3747670352458954,
0.07853270322084427,
-0.010150406509637833,
0.5776466727256775,
0.939983069896698,
-0.3808079659938812,
-0.0754268690943718,
-1.1030399799346924,
0.3274431824684143,
0.5460830330848694,
-0.4847760796546936,
0.03304808586835861,
0.8975948095321655,
0.2551482021808624,
-0.11280287802219391,
0.5625151991844177,
-0.24557405710220337,
0.26452890038490295,
-0.21398574113845825,
-0.1760959029197693,
-0.20425419509410858,
-0.5933002829551697,
-0.819640040397644,
-0.10179276019334793,
0.29043468832969666,
0.15053348243236542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11114v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11114v2 | Whose Emotions and Moral Sentiments Do Language Models Reflect? | 2024-02-16T22:34:53 | 2024-06-17T23:41:37 | Zihao He, Siyi Guo, Ashwin Rao, Kristina Lerman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI | Language models (LMs) are known to represent the perspectives of some social
groups better than others, which may impact their performance, especially on
subjective tasks such as content moderation and hate speech detection. To
explore how LMs represent different perspectives, existing research focused on
positional alignment, i.e., how closely the models mimic the opinions and
stances of different groups, e.g., liberals or conservatives. However, human
communication also encompasses emotional and moral dimensions. We define the
problem of affective alignment, which measures how LMs' emotional and moral
tone represents those of different groups. By comparing the affect of responses
generated by 36 LMs to the affect of Twitter messages, we observe significant
misalignment of LMs with both ideological groups. This misalignment is larger
than the partisan divide in the U.S. Even after steering the LMs towards
specific ideological perspectives, the misalignment and liberal tendencies of
the model persist, suggesting a systemic bias within LMs. | [
-0.2620398700237274,
-0.6210845708847046,
0.5871151089668274,
0.07577873766422272,
-0.11911158263683319,
0.3422420620918274,
-0.045425742864608765,
-0.32565006613731384,
0.36665165424346924,
0.5518195033073425,
-0.412341445684433,
-0.36332306265830994,
-0.7353365421295166,
-0.10087165236473083,
-0.27249231934547424,
1.0677173137664795,
0.2776135504245758,
0.3285638093948364,
0.2138936072587967,
-0.5941649079322815,
-0.056110937148332596,
-0.6624584197998047,
-0.5130658149719238,
-0.5281782150268555,
0.7500585913658142,
0.13418971002101898,
1.2706360816955566,
0.41822895407676697,
0.6565011143684387,
0.28506776690483093,
-0.1787838637828827,
-0.49390387535095215,
-0.6236993074417114,
0.05502493306994438,
-0.5475149750709534,
-0.3323483169078827,
-0.2500922977924347,
0.32594457268714905,
0.46993887424468994,
0.4826906621456146,
-0.16812652349472046,
0.06970376521348953,
-0.028327984735369682,
0.7372369170188904,
-0.45491254329681396,
-0.43167051672935486,
-0.6587913632392883,
-0.1060115322470665,
-0.019787311553955078,
-0.11815597116947174,
-0.3879050612449646,
-0.7959446310997009,
0.2172524482011795,
-0.08883825689554214,
-0.13430911302566528,
0.18113650381565094,
1.0354087352752686,
0.26391327381134033,
-0.8412501811981201,
-0.47598040103912354,
-0.5654698014259338,
1.127188801765442,
-0.8926323056221008,
0.4230310618877411,
0.22140353918075562,
-0.18768854439258575,
0.14204256236553192,
0.18195213377475739,
-0.6891048550605774,
0.13904431462287903,
-0.09547677636146545,
0.1922181099653244,
-0.2338179498910904,
0.09163843840360641,
0.23444509506225586,
0.09338808059692383,
-0.4859534502029419,
0.04535193741321564,
-0.4193848967552185,
0.22998440265655518,
0.7098565101623535,
0.2701147794723511,
0.4860541820526123,
-0.42100775241851807,
-0.3426700234413147,
-0.09648121893405914,
-0.5910462737083435,
0.3945148289203644,
0.7856055498123169,
0.40508607029914856,
-0.13894730806350708,
0.6379708051681519,
0.371339350938797,
0.5993887782096863,
0.15736189484596252,
0.11789528280496597,
0.05204463005065918,
-0.039123449474573135,
-0.29177621006965637,
0.177551731467247,
0.9127557277679443,
0.7943931818008423,
0.5955992341041565,
0.5363469123840332,
-0.19306901097297668,
0.27064090967178345,
0.5175397396087646,
-0.5552549958229065,
0.1318834275007248,
0.22623106837272644,
-0.7381820678710938,
-0.48696133494377136,
0.050110287964344025,
-0.6366438269615173,
-1.0310009717941284,
-0.44970718026161194,
0.011691360734403133,
-0.3871939480304718,
-0.4520336389541626,
0.03472735732793808,
0.2467184215784073,
0.5001713633537292,
0.1628221571445465,
-0.8190624117851257,
0.14254380762577057,
0.9377322793006897,
0.7056859135627747,
-0.08766110986471176,
0.1894068419933319,
-0.34495285153388977,
-0.07196088880300522,
-0.4518983066082001,
0.5760262608528137,
-1.0796700716018677,
-0.4343700110912323,
0.15992748737335205,
0.038753412663936615,
0.05339115113019943,
-0.12479966878890991,
0.7058014273643494,
-0.3563661277294159,
0.3748079538345337,
-0.8698689341545105,
-0.6039929389953613,
-0.2463088035583496,
0.13032110035419464,
-0.5322147607803345,
0.6021655797958374,
-0.11611604690551758,
-1.0566816329956055,
0.0993860736489296,
-0.33061718940734863,
-0.04872720316052437,
-0.20264260470867157,
-0.43353980779647827,
-0.22096402943134308,
0.4653663635253906,
-0.38202857971191406,
0.33369025588035583,
-0.3647790849208832,
0.29146692156791687,
-0.6574717164039612,
-0.29061222076416016,
0.474347859621048,
-0.0481773279607296,
0.9623389840126038,
0.11319565027952194,
-0.356197714805603,
0.34891757369041443,
-0.28890228271484375,
-0.16810807585716248,
0.18718817830085754,
-0.0612793043255806,
-0.7900820970535278,
0.4952915608882904,
0.11777190119028091,
0.6027486324310303,
0.14593954384326935,
-0.6490203738212585,
0.13638979196548462,
-0.4070228040218353,
0.24799709022045135,
1.1940720081329346,
-0.2979688346385956,
0.6556583046913147,
-0.376129150390625,
0.43685615062713623,
0.23857347667217255,
0.25910133123397827,
0.4212793707847595,
-0.32270339131355286,
-0.8055988550186157,
0.4469441771507263,
-0.4180406332015991,
0.6017760038375854,
-0.026463840156793594,
0.25295159220695496,
0.02013075165450573,
-0.4852629005908966,
-0.7057766914367676,
-0.04747102037072182,
0.3904937505722046,
0.20190542936325073,
0.0704251229763031,
-0.08404426276683807,
-0.3599376678466797,
-1.3258744478225708,
-0.7362983822822571,
-0.6850636601448059,
0.4839555025100708,
0.3008616268634796,
0.29662805795669556,
-0.04301655292510986,
0.7760944962501526,
-0.2842612564563751,
0.2202264666557312,
0.06753945350646973,
0.19124390184879303,
0.19928990304470062,
0.2289842665195465,
0.6289792656898499,
-0.7663065791130066,
-0.5943034887313843,
0.04532465711236,
-0.5747310519218445,
-0.3433819115161896,
0.1687326729297638,
-0.33545878529548645,
0.40566062927246094,
0.06702552735805511,
-0.173916757106781,
0.326163649559021,
0.9106154441833496,
-0.8546837568283081,
0.25038543343544006,
0.3713134229183197,
0.4899948239326477,
-1.187416672706604,
-0.15458440780639648,
0.26944634318351746,
-0.05693253502249718,
-0.6263477206230164,
-0.5875855684280396,
0.0982498973608017,
0.161490336060524,
-0.5949885249137878,
0.3667621910572052,
-0.1095067635178566,
-0.03590543940663338,
-0.06103155016899109,
0.2528619170188904,
0.18755781650543213,
0.014706438407301903,
0.08606573194265366,
0.4205125570297241,
0.4203197658061981,
-0.07055863738059998,
0.20988930761814117,
0.045997194945812225,
0.05768200755119324,
1.0558720827102661,
-0.5817167162895203,
0.22375895082950592,
-0.42542997002601624,
-0.05414798855781555,
-0.94002366065979,
-0.05269581452012062,
0.4509750306606293,
-0.16490714251995087,
0.020240111276507378,
-0.11356032639741898,
-0.1350060999393463,
-0.16077277064323425,
-0.3243740200996399,
0.29333895444869995,
0.5131082534790039,
-0.18522073328495026,
0.6974842548370361,
0.5565869808197021,
-0.20192763209342957,
-0.8257375359535217,
-0.5611552000045776,
-0.26893171668052673,
-0.5813561081886292,
-0.4714633822441101,
0.013366712257266045,
0.09167440980672836,
-1.0617166757583618,
0.16617801785469055,
0.06904184073209763,
0.19533249735832214,
-0.23463916778564453,
0.4863039255142212,
0.17734669148921967,
-0.14513257145881653,
0.40962982177734375,
-0.07464586943387985,
0.30936387181282043,
0.19121091067790985,
0.022541237995028496,
0.38122597336769104,
-0.6316965818405151,
-0.4336763918399811,
-0.230103999376297,
0.5412078499794006,
0.65885329246521,
-0.26081857085227966,
1.092812418937683,
0.14548611640930176,
-0.29714199900627136,
0.10798148810863495,
-0.6999661922454834,
-0.057433120906353,
-0.4671822190284729,
0.18722699582576752,
0.1895320564508438,
-0.9156487584114075,
0.6291266083717346,
0.3765369653701782,
0.1531578153371811,
0.3838808238506317,
0.4685323238372803,
-0.4104844927787781,
1.2875618934631348,
0.61287522315979,
-0.26101356744766235,
0.6531359553337097,
0.05999919772148132,
0.44735628366470337,
-0.7392383217811584,
-0.058613236993551254,
-0.6234773993492126,
-0.4861123859882355,
-0.7168998718261719,
-0.1823020577430725,
-0.23776639997959137,
0.1253363937139511,
-0.576788604259491,
0.11886623501777649,
-0.8014968037605286,
0.4465969502925873,
0.04445787891745567,
-0.23043788969516754,
-0.046574655920267105,
-0.1818026751279831,
0.11616893857717514,
-0.3878480792045593,
-0.2718959450721741,
-1.015065312385559,
0.7916468381881714,
0.4927384853363037,
0.8775040507316589,
0.394975483417511,
0.5203979015350342,
0.23454275727272034,
0.7065855860710144,
-0.7082594633102417,
0.4247381389141083,
-0.10974080115556717,
-0.6248674988746643,
-0.11870668828487396,
-0.25694331526756287,
-0.5391485095024109,
0.05628964304924011,
-0.022402239963412285,
-1.0388153791427612,
0.3823883831501007,
0.14363515377044678,
-0.09845875203609467,
0.5264544486999512,
-0.3677828013896942,
0.8857699036598206,
-0.6919803619384766,
-0.4738507568836212,
-0.24849288165569305,
-0.7310761213302612,
0.32255440950393677,
-0.027954276651144028,
0.4458635449409485,
-0.6475768089294434,
0.0002453835040796548,
0.7350611686706543,
-0.26382091641426086,
0.8660380244255066,
-0.26185891032218933,
-0.474102258682251,
0.12334369122982025,
0.14750362932682037,
0.385485976934433,
-0.27649757266044617,
-0.3602023422718048,
0.1815088987350464,
0.10175604373216629,
-0.3286997973918915,
-0.32151055335998535,
0.8892783522605896,
-0.8440951108932495,
-0.7537689208984375,
-0.49584564566612244,
-0.5079891085624695,
-0.029545489698648453,
0.014066402800381184,
0.13428086042404175,
0.1523127406835556,
-0.46227145195007324,
0.029250118881464005,
0.49012625217437744,
-0.36549925804138184,
0.4600662589073181,
0.4877610504627228,
-0.5067768692970276,
-0.160913348197937,
0.8468432426452637,
-0.016920696943998337,
0.53120356798172,
-0.016341371461749077,
0.14769601821899414,
-0.2618676424026489,
0.07138650864362717,
-0.12589837610721588,
0.5585669875144958,
-0.8494285345077515,
-0.13932450115680695,
-0.5417788624763489,
0.04410970211029053,
-0.2222277820110321,
-0.52101731300354,
-0.64054274559021,
-0.056322693824768066,
-0.33681100606918335,
0.07434463500976562,
0.3987341523170471,
1.0752809047698975,
0.2132161259651184,
0.4635274112224579,
-0.6743994951248169,
-0.09502705931663513,
0.0578111931681633,
0.5610541105270386,
-0.3994852304458618,
-0.5173934102058411,
-0.030705079436302185,
0.21966613829135895,
-0.37677961587905884,
-1.3616600036621094,
0.1719810664653778,
-0.038531217724084854,
0.16305071115493774,
0.7091461420059204,
0.09116306900978088,
0.3916696608066559,
-0.35197949409484863,
0.7667682766914368,
0.23843812942504883,
-1.1191816329956055,
0.43836554884910583,
-0.5420914888381958,
0.12776660919189453,
0.4661147892475128,
0.5512513518333435,
-0.9389868378639221,
-0.7985374331474304,
-0.5749146938323975,
-0.24037450551986694,
0.7455767393112183,
0.1176222637295723,
0.3476749658584595,
-0.3597061038017273,
0.13935096561908722,
-0.15264984965324402,
-0.001340129878371954,
-0.7814165949821472,
-0.27740392088890076,
-0.4654010832309723,
-0.666680097579956,
0.03654658794403076,
-0.3691767454147339,
-0.25748780369758606,
0.09727081656455994,
0.5871934294700623,
0.0656922236084938,
0.03439825028181076,
0.03172723203897476,
0.26160234212875366,
-0.45451682806015015,
0.49191272258758545,
0.6391481757164001,
0.701326847076416,
-0.1532619148492813,
0.2594210207462311,
-0.22068721055984497,
-0.12782780826091766,
0.4392852783203125,
-0.22918513417243958,
-0.01256702933460474,
-0.05042828619480133,
0.052214935421943665,
0.8344482183456421,
0.033001333475112915,
-0.4054481089115143,
0.6360634565353394,
-0.009104941971600056,
0.2361813187599182,
-0.21403175592422485,
-0.10687784105539322,
0.4909251928329468,
0.5325160622596741,
0.07824452966451645,
-0.037113819271326065,
-0.02285151369869709,
-0.6878417134284973,
-0.14090684056282043,
0.7629124522209167,
-0.8593369126319885,
-0.5137342810630798,
0.5013030767440796,
0.14789511263370514,
-0.6839202642440796,
0.4314954876899719,
0.05703461915254593,
-0.8236717581748962,
0.5102864503860474,
0.36649227142333984,
0.8029670119285583,
-0.7238854765892029,
0.38498207926750183,
0.26787737011909485,
0.35373690724372864,
0.07484803348779678,
0.4974563419818878,
0.5235154628753662,
-1.0983351469039917,
-0.1463555246591568,
-0.7456404566764832,
-0.3079673647880554,
-0.2187032848596573,
-0.8156580328941345,
0.2759879529476166,
-0.39038366079330444,
-0.4892996549606323,
-0.09173516929149628,
-0.24661032855510712,
-0.36818063259124756,
0.3020853102207184,
0.5374220609664917,
0.3289676308631897,
-0.9940020442008972,
0.7167185544967651,
0.801901638507843,
-0.2797708213329315,
-0.8458714485168457,
0.10336543619632721,
0.3220336139202118,
-0.5898497104644775,
0.5706648230552673,
0.1864234358072281,
-0.5281189680099487,
-0.12305597215890884,
-0.5906586050987244,
-0.7789879441261292,
0.4968268871307373,
0.29566818475723267,
-0.6586484313011169,
0.026690125465393066,
0.34884390234947205,
0.6436547636985779,
-0.61152583360672,
0.033994439989328384,
0.32140132784843445,
0.3394324779510498,
-0.28434765338897705,
-0.7508928775787354,
0.03776250034570694,
-0.36395183205604553,
0.03272302448749542,
0.5427801609039307,
-0.8763381242752075,
0.8093788623809814,
0.04717569053173065,
-0.14151357114315033,
-0.5945677161216736,
0.37559542059898376,
0.31415000557899475,
0.07267564535140991,
0.5869025588035583,
0.32219254970550537,
0.636442244052887,
-0.10396160930395126,
1.078361988067627,
-0.5566501617431641,
0.486814945936203,
0.8113642930984497,
-0.36510157585144043,
0.6638093590736389,
0.6611712574958801,
0.03989947587251663,
0.575229287147522,
0.5178224444389343,
0.2165687531232834,
0.3849535584449768,
0.18440942466259003,
-0.14382420480251312,
-0.2309192270040512,
-0.5653877854347229,
-0.30100658535957336,
0.4123894274234772,
0.4658281207084656,
-0.6357972025871277,
0.1998089700937271,
-0.2544456422328949,
0.01778288185596466,
0.29608699679374695,
-0.3259332478046417,
0.5960829854011536,
0.250728964805603,
-0.48180240392684937,
0.3270476162433624,
-0.054164521396160126,
0.5270575881004333,
-0.35401248931884766,
0.13275831937789917,
-0.16906169056892395,
-0.016834840178489685,
-0.45141202211380005,
-1.1481261253356934,
0.5588223338127136,
0.10298995673656464,
-0.0909489095211029,
-0.29584240913391113,
0.5730869174003601,
-0.46386340260505676,
-0.3988664746284485,
0.7062087059020996,
0.28057968616485596,
0.019012821838259697,
0.22140508890151978,
-0.8422211408615112,
0.4517538249492645,
0.09880779683589935,
-0.5194219946861267,
-0.005779911298304796,
0.3234957158565521,
-0.08387821167707443,
0.4874887764453888,
0.2828727960586548,
-0.024141857400536537,
-0.0496860034763813,
0.19850322604179382,
0.6753623485565186,
-0.9333300590515137,
-0.03954930230975151,
-1.1540048122406006,
0.6469908356666565,
-0.22842007875442505,
-0.24280864000320435,
0.4761551022529602,
0.3634302616119385,
0.6391556262969971,
0.32681015133857727,
0.5987365245819092,
-0.0025548681151121855,
0.38723596930503845,
-0.34121736884117126,
0.8613384962081909,
-0.6259845495223999,
0.16706623136997223,
-0.58327716588974,
-1.0665830373764038,
0.006671038921922445,
0.9285224676132202,
-0.6766796708106995,
0.07637276500463486,
0.5824799537658691,
0.6388411521911621,
0.026043470948934555,
0.3023236095905304,
0.2211519181728363,
0.3524013161659241,
0.25120851397514343,
0.40448421239852905,
1.3138635158538818,
-0.04520060494542122,
0.10597608983516693,
-0.25930628180503845,
0.021744124591350555,
-0.04770929366350174,
-0.822479784488678,
-0.7339748740196228,
-0.5570431351661682,
-0.3320655822753906,
-0.4912794828414917,
-0.12415749579668045,
1.0664280652999878,
0.2984216809272766,
-0.8029547333717346,
-0.37552013993263245,
0.0056153712794184685,
0.3084583580493927,
0.3144959807395935,
-0.2659889757633209,
0.30847522616386414,
0.08527283370494843,
-0.7807247042655945,
-0.1724013239145279,
0.540810763835907,
-0.04501860961318016,
-0.2862105369567871,
-0.13189513981342316,
-0.3401273488998413,
0.5420214533805847,
0.3900226950645447,
-0.030420076102018356,
-1.2203023433685303,
-0.8290621638298035,
0.2011803388595581,
-0.7018015384674072,
0.19843213260173798,
0.74049311876297,
-0.19324703514575958,
0.35322630405426025,
0.2914837896823883,
0.16243213415145874,
-0.27307865023612976,
0.32288891077041626,
0.670741617679596,
-0.28407493233680725,
0.045017797499895096,
0.455582857131958,
0.5230309367179871,
0.4815185070037842,
-0.40042394399642944,
0.28126004338264465,
-0.026976995170116425,
-0.8204667568206787,
-0.7199898958206177,
0.5218867063522339,
-1.0014299154281616,
-0.0458793118596077,
1.1995443105697632,
0.05072983726859093,
-0.050065889954566956,
0.24892379343509674,
-0.2708498537540436,
0.38717198371887207,
-0.4848976135253906,
0.6431487202644348,
0.9007545113563538,
-0.13330791890621185,
-0.2754267156124115,
-0.512768030166626,
0.4594274163246155,
0.7308800220489502,
-0.6390145421028137,
0.25474628806114197,
0.71100914478302,
0.19698204100131989,
0.14398713409900665,
0.5296204686164856,
-0.07178708165884018,
-0.14453543722629547,
-0.4485492408275604,
0.30760225653648376,
0.6723677515983582,
0.08937377482652664,
-0.45566612482070923,
-0.06891394406557083,
-0.02161414548754692,
0.41271379590034485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11111v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11111v1 | Language Models as Science Tutors | 2024-02-16T22:24:13 | 2024-02-16T22:24:13 | Alexis Chevalier, Jiayi Geng, Alexander Wettig, Howard Chen, Sebastian Mizera, Toni Annala, Max Jameson Aragon, Arturo Rodríguez Fanlo, Simon Frieder, Simon Machado, Akshara Prabhakar, Ellie Thieu, Jiachen T. Wang, Zirui Wang, Xindi Wu, Mengzhou Xia, Wenhan Jia, Jiatong Yu, Jun-Jie Zhu, Zhiyong Jason Ren, Sanjeev Arora, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | NLP has recently made exciting progress toward training language models (LMs)
with strong scientific problem-solving skills. However, model development has
not focused on real-life use-cases of LMs for science, including applications
in education that require processing long scientific documents. To address
this, we introduce TutorEval and TutorChat. TutorEval is a diverse
question-answering benchmark consisting of questions about long chapters from
STEM textbooks, written by experts. TutorEval helps measure real-life usability
of LMs as scientific assistants, and it is the first benchmark combining long
contexts, free-form generation, and multi-disciplinary scientific knowledge.
Moreover, we show that fine-tuning base models with existing dialogue datasets
leads to poor performance on TutorEval. Therefore, we create TutorChat, a
dataset of 80,000 long synthetic dialogues about textbooks. We use TutorChat to
fine-tune Llemma models with 7B and 34B parameters. These LM tutors specialized
in math have a 32K-token context window, and they excel at TutorEval while
performing strongly on GSM8K and MATH. Our datasets build on open-source
materials, and we release our models, data, and evaluations. | [
-0.12197837233543396,
-0.5715158581733704,
0.38978835940361023,
0.24702762067317963,
-0.08503931760787964,
0.2828500270843506,
-0.3556719422340393,
-0.41153258085250854,
-0.04806332662701607,
0.4305786192417145,
-0.5123935341835022,
-0.5418992638587952,
-0.24594931304454803,
0.3627318739891052,
-0.37414559721946716,
1.0263645648956299,
0.1730058193206787,
0.428047239780426,
-0.6754114627838135,
0.01866891048848629,
-0.21045704185962677,
-0.34083592891693115,
-0.6420707106590271,
-0.15845073759555817,
0.4365619421005249,
0.27202391624450684,
0.5393338203430176,
0.582412838935852,
0.4851644039154053,
0.1944231539964676,
-0.34269437193870544,
0.20764268934726715,
-0.3548569679260254,
0.45302823185920715,
-0.4082345962524414,
-0.606867253780365,
-0.31667184829711914,
-0.152271568775177,
0.5592867732048035,
1.0401513576507568,
-0.03376401588320732,
0.05926883593201637,
-0.05419024080038071,
0.5641432404518127,
-0.1983623504638672,
0.4646783173084259,
-0.5001988410949707,
-0.16050028800964355,
-0.03637467324733734,
0.07733411341905594,
-0.5440496802330017,
-0.3794483542442322,
0.4355784058570862,
-0.648453414440155,
0.3812137842178345,
0.22956576943397522,
0.4704398810863495,
0.24913936853408813,
-0.28263697028160095,
-0.42604172229766846,
-0.5385616421699524,
0.937473714351654,
-0.9611281752586365,
0.3639872372150421,
0.4490284323692322,
0.520645022392273,
-0.4237668514251709,
-0.6806609034538269,
-0.3603963255882263,
-0.32848504185676575,
-0.017687072977423668,
0.02384948544204235,
-0.02710813656449318,
-0.009080632589757442,
0.2432735562324524,
0.02751355618238449,
-0.557614803314209,
0.15692710876464844,
-0.810948371887207,
-0.1120411679148674,
0.5259492993354797,
0.18222421407699585,
0.12885820865631104,
-0.38836437463760376,
-0.08179357647895813,
-0.12169206887483597,
-0.7328058481216431,
0.06065724417567253,
0.07936396449804306,
0.7852926850318909,
0.042433105409145355,
0.7071426510810852,
0.0714532807469368,
0.6854193210601807,
-0.4083921015262604,
-0.11721295118331909,
-0.11425366252660751,
-0.5250622630119324,
0.11340523511171341,
0.06628245860338211,
0.6162043809890747,
0.3575502634048462,
0.4105572998523712,
-0.09212087839841843,
0.059934623539447784,
-0.15388186275959015,
0.04607453569769859,
-1.0964610576629639,
-0.27643436193466187,
0.19751136004924774,
-0.018607158213853836,
-0.11207140982151031,
-0.3825565576553345,
-0.8228325247764587,
-0.48764604330062866,
-0.39970043301582336,
-0.03705276548862457,
-0.3728070557117462,
-0.127492755651474,
0.27602291107177734,
0.25654318928718567,
-0.24936307966709137,
0.27426785230636597,
-0.9559152126312256,
0.4781136214733124,
0.8501935601234436,
1.006438136100769,
-0.21382762491703033,
-0.23167328536510468,
-0.19376590847969055,
-0.18430183827877045,
-0.29945287108421326,
0.6796162724494934,
-0.36291924118995667,
-0.582804799079895,
-0.01580965705215931,
0.08466923236846924,
-0.028586940839886665,
-0.42899441719055176,
0.41432660818099976,
-0.41031238436698914,
0.44214797019958496,
-0.03163308650255203,
-0.791032075881958,
0.01095191016793251,
0.01186305657029152,
-0.4279995262622833,
1.0265265703201294,
0.04380239546298981,
-0.5932722091674805,
0.007262083236128092,
-0.8823415637016296,
-0.030328264459967613,
0.13978101313114166,
0.038862962275743484,
-0.20078620314598083,
-0.10140321403741837,
0.17410163581371307,
0.5772337317466736,
-0.4313512444496155,
0.6022356152534485,
-0.1114998310804367,
-0.11279086023569107,
0.12097647786140442,
-0.3919452726840973,
0.5533455014228821,
0.19765987992286682,
0.07176705449819565,
0.13755734264850616,
-0.8608472943305969,
0.012071873061358929,
-0.0035013456363230944,
-0.024381518363952637,
-0.49123069643974304,
0.31305447220802307,
0.048488717526197433,
-0.012314959429204464,
0.18146337568759918,
-0.7803386449813843,
0.3369040787220001,
-0.7093948721885681,
0.7161899209022522,
0.4984203577041626,
-0.28003543615341187,
0.18485569953918457,
-0.10352841019630432,
0.42582622170448303,
-0.25745606422424316,
-0.2160850316286087,
-0.48622429370880127,
-0.5016561150550842,
-0.6194853186607361,
-0.19928209483623505,
0.24030055105686188,
0.27002617716789246,
-0.4537118077278137,
0.18598203361034393,
-0.2446092814207077,
-0.7803767919540405,
-0.6967896819114685,
0.10319481790065765,
0.3216973841190338,
0.9317740797996521,
0.6481704115867615,
0.09114377200603485,
-0.5175163745880127,
-0.8611568808555603,
-0.35734209418296814,
-0.10089036822319031,
-0.23946832120418549,
0.3936246335506439,
0.5786940455436707,
0.06100268289446831,
1.1919077634811401,
-0.5183953642845154,
0.005301966331899166,
-0.0008067316957749426,
-0.1028105691075325,
0.3514151871204376,
0.37067103385925293,
0.582394003868103,
-0.5012560486793518,
-0.5012511014938354,
-0.1162019670009613,
-0.6869220733642578,
-0.09855566173791885,
0.2952793836593628,
0.1277816742658615,
0.20386800169944763,
0.5808869004249573,
-0.6734357476234436,
0.23780560493469238,
0.55640709400177,
-0.33466988801956177,
0.7728539705276489,
-0.1296900510787964,
-0.11033125966787338,
-1.3165520429611206,
0.07170698046684265,
0.11190766841173172,
-0.21497222781181335,
-0.6370711326599121,
-0.026527922600507736,
0.027920572087168694,
-0.5448868870735168,
-0.6647495031356812,
0.8370838165283203,
-0.22536629438400269,
-0.1310296207666397,
-0.3602728247642517,
0.23590710759162903,
-0.05533929914236069,
0.15936359763145447,
0.1907859593629837,
0.9550117254257202,
0.5658668875694275,
-0.32871437072753906,
0.4178088307380676,
0.19713521003723145,
-0.5658340454101562,
0.2547147274017334,
-1.041191816329956,
-0.014077696949243546,
-0.03288941830396652,
0.3824820816516876,
-0.7071928977966309,
-0.23392342031002045,
-0.16090552508831024,
-0.13226503133773804,
0.019775759428739548,
-0.1503940224647522,
-0.47580206394195557,
-0.30301710963249207,
-0.010339025408029556,
0.3302991986274719,
0.3292323052883148,
-0.6250827312469482,
0.3093021512031555,
0.03272460401058197,
-0.7432100176811218,
-0.6062662601470947,
-0.24169625341892242,
0.020195772871375084,
0.08825189620256424,
-0.5732949376106262,
0.27436935901641846,
-0.2782074809074402,
-0.1920366883277893,
0.10137154906988144,
-0.14183583855628967,
-0.051387377083301544,
0.010837104171514511,
0.25413501262664795,
0.3715159296989441,
-0.47358959913253784,
0.3536539673805237,
0.1573449820280075,
-0.09921590983867645,
0.1907862424850464,
-0.08313758671283722,
0.5145047307014465,
-0.476591020822525,
-0.3959605395793915,
-0.2660634219646454,
0.27758824825286865,
0.5874896049499512,
-0.03234914690256119,
0.7052438259124756,
0.023563681170344353,
-0.22848980128765106,
-0.1824343353509903,
-0.3105398416519165,
-0.5190206170082092,
-0.4658876359462738,
0.5920538902282715,
-0.1615474969148636,
-1.045722246170044,
0.4992496371269226,
-0.0004346553760115057,
0.4775048792362213,
0.2862222194671631,
0.4203268587589264,
-0.06472670286893845,
1.0038352012634277,
0.49648550152778625,
0.0759265199303627,
0.17429323494434357,
-0.12284126877784729,
0.3144865930080414,
-0.5931567549705505,
-0.25234508514404297,
-0.6461915373802185,
0.1601526290178299,
-0.3462885916233063,
-0.42098140716552734,
0.21396221220493317,
0.14280115067958832,
-0.21752163767814636,
0.48951342701911926,
-0.6440325975418091,
0.8415635824203491,
0.3334449827671051,
-0.3120332360267639,
0.3029620051383972,
-0.03693430870771408,
-0.2041400969028473,
-0.3429230749607086,
-0.6423110961914062,
-0.7192195057868958,
1.1089308261871338,
0.36305537819862366,
0.7051109075546265,
-0.16976067423820496,
0.2725013196468353,
-0.14753197133541107,
0.3147529661655426,
-0.7538706660270691,
0.6633113622665405,
-0.10260272026062012,
-0.6335357427597046,
-0.374045193195343,
-0.34431952238082886,
-0.843238353729248,
0.32912734150886536,
0.024615779519081116,
-0.5070302486419678,
-0.22194062173366547,
0.12860828638076782,
-0.2608722448348999,
0.21982935070991516,
-0.583771288394928,
0.7861367464065552,
-0.2673664391040802,
-0.4056732952594757,
-0.2054286003112793,
-0.7057482600212097,
0.22982358932495117,
-0.05779415741562843,
0.3329733610153198,
-0.3020135462284088,
0.19223326444625854,
0.7814810872077942,
-0.36071786284446716,
1.0065325498580933,
-0.07696706801652908,
0.012874305248260498,
0.16943952441215515,
0.20428630709648132,
0.04741505905985832,
0.10746163874864578,
-0.24468719959259033,
0.008871193043887615,
0.4814824163913727,
-0.5175471305847168,
-0.6652718782424927,
0.9134071469306946,
-0.8102937340736389,
-0.8113332390785217,
-0.4949161410331726,
-0.7936827540397644,
-0.2787097692489624,
0.11135010421276093,
-0.247488871216774,
0.29146069288253784,
-0.0616321787238121,
0.48045188188552856,
0.3742985129356384,
-0.0685543492436409,
0.33753129839897156,
0.6950935125350952,
-0.4535601735115051,
-0.11674186587333679,
0.8611068725585938,
-0.01859414018690586,
0.4101295471191406,
0.04354874789714813,
0.3718361556529999,
-0.3387855291366577,
-0.3965097665786743,
-0.2829413414001465,
0.42191222310066223,
-0.6537634134292603,
-0.17970126867294312,
-0.5322714447975159,
-0.4907287061214447,
-0.5798835754394531,
-0.04621683433651924,
-0.5098176598548889,
-0.7140869498252869,
-0.5039052963256836,
-0.18373611569404602,
0.5836520195007324,
0.5548654198646545,
0.10467740148305893,
0.181976318359375,
-0.6993768215179443,
-0.0359104759991169,
0.19435568153858185,
0.13060754537582397,
-0.04603084921836853,
-0.4808708429336548,
-0.2775099277496338,
0.21287313103675842,
-0.17499402165412903,
-0.5725043416023254,
0.6003337502479553,
0.337454617023468,
0.2732708752155304,
0.17996634542942047,
-0.08838804811239243,
0.5111779570579529,
-0.6859353184700012,
0.8877152800559998,
0.022964201867580414,
-0.6997650265693665,
0.4727824032306671,
-0.31138020753860474,
0.06989282369613647,
0.39827725291252136,
0.7388454675674438,
-0.6398530006408691,
-0.3548576533794403,
-0.2623097002506256,
-0.7071173191070557,
0.5078712105751038,
-0.1388590782880783,
0.20748436450958252,
0.10226082801818848,
0.43795067071914673,
0.32073983550071716,
0.23310044407844543,
-0.4977000951766968,
0.05328309163451195,
-0.6721989512443542,
-0.3666565716266632,
-0.2574246823787689,
-0.06276559829711914,
-0.19151410460472107,
-0.4555623531341553,
0.4948332607746124,
-0.32082799077033997,
-0.21991664171218872,
0.005569099448621273,
0.031349778175354004,
0.13692592084407806,
0.3149789273738861,
0.8948197960853577,
0.8978828191757202,
-0.380143940448761,
0.09195153415203094,
-0.08584234863519669,
-0.43752962350845337,
-0.08965785056352615,
0.30162864923477173,
-0.03548189252614975,
0.02079932764172554,
0.3181203305721283,
0.669851541519165,
0.4164702594280243,
-0.9197640419006348,
0.2811349332332611,
0.04111331328749657,
-0.22373737394809723,
-0.18590901792049408,
0.15730653703212738,
0.5211769938468933,
-0.04198149964213371,
0.539090633392334,
-0.07269492745399475,
-0.23512399196624756,
-0.2819535732269287,
0.04643046483397484,
0.33794841170310974,
-0.225691020488739,
-0.5650655627250671,
0.654192328453064,
0.30445194244384766,
-0.521587610244751,
0.5609397292137146,
0.26224127411842346,
-0.38142165541648865,
0.7286661267280579,
0.864922285079956,
0.35364463925361633,
-0.2750656306743622,
0.25641337037086487,
0.3793332278728485,
-0.035748422145843506,
-0.07741137593984604,
0.05228576064109802,
0.08295004814863205,
-0.500506579875946,
-0.5707850456237793,
-0.6562862992286682,
-0.8999233841896057,
0.15242712199687958,
-0.5853517651557922,
0.32692939043045044,
-0.3718128800392151,
0.07988883554935455,
0.3335476219654083,
0.08849973231554031,
-0.3825075030326843,
-0.031363990157842636,
-0.5064164996147156,
0.961163341999054,
-0.8565964698791504,
0.658443808555603,
0.482305645942688,
-0.16402186453342438,
-0.49383974075317383,
-0.7700294256210327,
-0.031011424958705902,
-0.6613035202026367,
0.9366047978401184,
0.11138613522052765,
0.09064681082963943,
0.1074937954545021,
-0.7206193804740906,
-0.77876216173172,
0.9305230975151062,
0.3551359474658966,
-0.7441105842590332,
-0.2778712809085846,
0.21589232981204987,
0.9131681323051453,
-0.4580121636390686,
0.3832510709762573,
0.31289801001548767,
0.13146452605724335,
0.03707830607891083,
-0.9422674179077148,
-0.20567619800567627,
-0.22050657868385315,
-0.2919546365737915,
-0.11794572323560715,
-0.47644010186195374,
0.8594549894332886,
-0.20226401090621948,
-0.03429674729704857,
0.27651405334472656,
0.6986422538757324,
0.5737006068229675,
0.3727357089519501,
0.18571825325489044,
0.20976592600345612,
0.7064260244369507,
-0.054248783737421036,
0.8615708947181702,
-0.4846767485141754,
0.3286019265651703,
0.993212878704071,
-0.39322489500045776,
0.8769746422767639,
0.61122065782547,
-0.275491863489151,
0.4705583155155182,
0.6797012686729431,
-0.13069133460521698,
0.3780638575553894,
0.44386255741119385,
-0.302749365568161,
-0.19049634039402008,
-0.3414953351020813,
-0.41299936175346375,
0.03219199553132057,
0.619261622428894,
-0.0306441280990839,
-0.4317667782306671,
0.22959952056407928,
-0.01902078092098236,
0.37552183866500854,
-0.05321792513132095,
0.32004591822624207,
0.3556000292301178,
-0.5708755254745483,
0.4811058044433594,
-0.09694735705852509,
0.48178356885910034,
-0.5282902717590332,
-0.04961859807372093,
-0.32044005393981934,
-0.00034937061718665063,
-0.11401411145925522,
-0.7164669632911682,
0.11102539300918579,
0.19226188957691193,
-0.27219218015670776,
-0.1458824723958969,
0.4706956148147583,
-0.6650298237800598,
-0.559992790222168,
0.0042707063257694244,
0.47867661714553833,
0.5134580731391907,
0.3261510729789734,
-0.5866960287094116,
-0.2591831684112549,
-0.28563645482063293,
-0.2993447184562683,
0.36601972579956055,
-0.0197202879935503,
-0.20612283051013947,
1.1719871759414673,
0.9387821555137634,
0.33690860867500305,
0.06381913274526596,
0.1278836578130722,
0.8830372095108032,
-0.5107920169830322,
-0.14327172935009003,
-0.6562824845314026,
0.22565068304538727,
-0.005250600166618824,
-0.3514827787876129,
0.7855733036994934,
0.7176241874694824,
0.6654559373855591,
-0.14847706258296967,
0.5672690272331238,
0.4250746965408325,
1.0318324565887451,
-0.3819971978664398,
0.7579712271690369,
-0.34912121295928955,
0.2778071165084839,
-0.05957702919840813,
-0.908311128616333,
-0.501316249370575,
0.5676848292350769,
-0.24281924962997437,
-0.17651693522930145,
0.6906367540359497,
0.8620045781135559,
-0.04692453891038895,
0.3653331995010376,
0.20886556804180145,
0.08224895596504211,
0.6961085200309753,
0.28784409165382385,
0.9243730902671814,
-0.18634270131587982,
0.4149901568889618,
-0.2159540206193924,
0.09139609336853027,
-0.28948384523391724,
-0.9333842396736145,
-1.2556878328323364,
-0.47905096411705017,
-0.21751141548156738,
-0.13969722390174866,
0.16723714768886566,
1.0258560180664062,
0.7014221549034119,
-0.8350614309310913,
-0.30727720260620117,
-0.21381650865077972,
0.0438261404633522,
0.1613585650920868,
-0.26945045590400696,
0.6768112182617188,
-0.3774842917919159,
-0.8696911334991455,
0.9224228858947754,
0.01597503386437893,
0.21470826864242554,
-0.6198955178260803,
0.14960695803165436,
0.11758415400981903,
0.21605205535888672,
0.5067411065101624,
0.5697462558746338,
-0.7488336563110352,
-0.2769659161567688,
0.5019316077232361,
-0.09951868653297424,
-0.10438580811023712,
0.7876250743865967,
-0.7598103284835815,
0.5441233515739441,
0.2959728538990021,
0.7011269927024841,
0.5503168702125549,
-0.052827704697847366,
0.5297325849533081,
-0.6645523905754089,
0.1924440562725067,
0.6187971234321594,
0.16956086456775665,
0.5591775178909302,
0.11580213904380798,
0.5029482841491699,
0.07066452503204346,
-0.8411896824836731,
-1.291031837463379,
0.0036626395303756,
-0.7801493406295776,
-0.32560044527053833,
0.7662867307662964,
-0.23372186720371246,
-0.2370285540819168,
-0.033964481204748154,
-0.17763952910900116,
-0.0683261826634407,
-0.3957377076148987,
0.7701841592788696,
0.9954211115837097,
-0.14923718571662903,
-0.18518801033496857,
-0.7137508392333984,
0.6259814500808716,
0.7951316833496094,
-0.753589928150177,
0.19430449604988098,
0.31410348415374756,
0.31349077820777893,
0.38913100957870483,
0.12480425089597702,
0.11514794081449509,
0.14254118502140045,
-0.23371364176273346,
0.0026746555231511593,
-0.42938119173049927,
-0.4209080934524536,
0.002864169655367732,
0.06511786580085754,
-0.04427793249487877,
0.3349721431732178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11100v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11100v2 | When LLMs Meet Cunning Texts: A Fallacy Understanding Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-02-16T22:12:53 | 2024-06-09T17:55:05 | Yinghui Li, Qingyu Zhou, Yuanzhen Luo, Shirong Ma, Yangning Li, Hai-Tao Zheng, Xuming Hu, Philip S. Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) make remarkable evolutions in language
understanding and generation. Following this, various benchmarks for measuring
all kinds of capabilities of LLMs have sprung up. In this paper, we challenge
the reasoning and understanding abilities of LLMs by proposing a FaLlacy
Understanding Benchmark (FLUB) containing cunning texts that are easy for
humans to understand but difficult for models to grasp. Specifically, the
cunning texts that FLUB focuses on mainly consist of the tricky, humorous, and
misleading texts collected from the real internet environment. And we design
three tasks with increasing difficulty in the FLUB benchmark to evaluate the
fallacy understanding ability of LLMs. Based on FLUB, we investigate the
performance of multiple representative and advanced LLMs, reflecting our FLUB
is challenging and worthy of more future study. Interesting discoveries and
valuable insights are achieved in our extensive experiments and detailed
analyses. We hope that our benchmark can encourage the community to improve
LLMs' ability to understand fallacies. Our data and codes are available at
https://github.com/THUKElab/FLUB. | [
-0.1978009194135666,
-0.679716169834137,
0.6733086109161377,
0.32835108041763306,
-0.25750741362571716,
0.22245344519615173,
-0.23435623943805695,
-0.35305967926979065,
-0.2908473014831543,
0.6211652159690857,
-0.7425682544708252,
-0.42680755257606506,
-0.8446557521820068,
0.3386136293411255,
-0.4813249111175537,
0.8106364011764526,
-0.156560480594635,
0.08660518378019333,
-0.3240810036659241,
0.005900121759623289,
-0.3313853442668915,
-0.43767765164375305,
-0.3979358971118927,
-0.48367005586624146,
0.49414241313934326,
0.37803778052330017,
0.730545163154602,
0.39064091444015503,
0.669731855392456,
0.4010382890701294,
-0.11235872656106949,
0.456382155418396,
-0.8154175281524658,
-0.08904555439949036,
-0.23559662699699402,
-0.8690199255943298,
-0.2373160421848297,
-0.09734299778938293,
0.4718857705593109,
0.6403909921646118,
-0.18280962109565735,
-0.018800871446728706,
-0.04590624198317528,
0.7953610420227051,
-0.6376388072967529,
0.03902418538928032,
-1.067850947380066,
-0.14104551076889038,
-0.4251982867717743,
0.07812637835741043,
-0.5756574273109436,
-0.2852940857410431,
-0.17265170812606812,
-0.4556207060813904,
0.19321194291114807,
0.16605374217033386,
0.8982721567153931,
0.40091538429260254,
-0.4911797046661377,
-0.4590357542037964,
-0.34317120909690857,
0.9082043766975403,
-0.7360072135925293,
0.3043961524963379,
0.06650420278310776,
0.3909130394458771,
-0.6272754073143005,
-0.6483137011528015,
-0.5277280211448669,
-0.17679022252559662,
-0.0235595703125,
-0.1102643683552742,
-0.24160964787006378,
-0.21418191492557526,
0.25220730900764465,
0.24889731407165527,
-0.5476849675178528,
0.004393978510051966,
0.045079007744789124,
-0.16788078844547272,
0.5965757369995117,
0.24806687235832214,
0.13202013075351715,
-0.2836540937423706,
-0.5185611844062805,
0.13305318355560303,
-0.577519416809082,
-0.1427406221628189,
0.5237084627151489,
0.02743401937186718,
-0.0315147265791893,
0.2946442663669586,
0.11044792085886002,
0.5054727792739868,
-0.17525659501552582,
-0.3385586440563202,
0.3647423982620239,
-0.23326589167118073,
-0.18651556968688965,
-0.22737018764019012,
0.607949435710907,
0.2354448437690735,
0.7436709403991699,
-0.19066502153873444,
-0.3338547945022583,
0.004781610332429409,
0.2570590376853943,
-0.43794912099838257,
-0.13435375690460205,
0.0773594081401825,
-0.31328025460243225,
-0.3954378366470337,
-0.1662197858095169,
-0.5538151264190674,
-0.7084643840789795,
0.1181102842092514,
0.5457800626754761,
-0.7501788139343262,
-0.34036245942115784,
0.4162161648273468,
-0.28533536195755005,
0.22909513115882874,
0.49882981181144714,
-0.6632082462310791,
0.5311635136604309,
0.9966301321983337,
0.6616678833961487,
-0.33677446842193604,
-0.5728153586387634,
-0.2652401924133301,
0.2411169558763504,
-0.17678284645080566,
1.0037225484848022,
-0.33191901445388794,
-0.239047572016716,
-0.2847108542919159,
-0.21182984113693237,
-0.3539191782474518,
-0.7559062242507935,
0.8557162284851074,
-0.3453522026538849,
-0.019192522391676903,
-0.1811463087797165,
-0.5200983285903931,
-0.31497693061828613,
0.43033963441848755,
-0.6895790696144104,
0.8496134281158447,
-0.06561855226755142,
-0.9170997738838196,
0.21080516278743744,
-0.3711089491844177,
-0.5131323337554932,
0.056492604315280914,
-0.1276867687702179,
-0.22106552124023438,
0.22008682787418365,
0.15640631318092346,
0.46288543939590454,
-0.5051423907279968,
0.400306761264801,
-0.3739291727542877,
-0.47321146726608276,
0.7268343567848206,
-0.8741748929023743,
0.6910346150398254,
0.13082773983478546,
-0.37095317244529724,
-0.4702959656715393,
-0.5862637162208557,
-0.04712940379977226,
0.44166305661201477,
-0.4963495135307312,
-0.3984377980232239,
0.2879481911659241,
-0.07162334769964218,
-0.009476336650550365,
0.4796169698238373,
-0.16607588529586792,
0.09052391350269318,
-0.4135749638080597,
0.47372183203697205,
0.9157511591911316,
-0.3111204206943512,
-0.19328227639198303,
-0.5256341695785522,
0.24373190104961395,
0.056003719568252563,
-0.04793723672628403,
-0.012697595171630383,
-0.31097403168678284,
-0.6701720952987671,
-0.29970496892929077,
0.3047204613685608,
0.4945111870765686,
-0.6573431491851807,
0.2240421324968338,
-0.672467052936554,
-0.4905766248703003,
-0.5797234773635864,
0.5272709727287292,
0.6086580753326416,
0.31894415616989136,
0.19210626184940338,
-0.014446103014051914,
-0.08545546233654022,
-1.0418076515197754,
-0.9448347091674805,
-0.30085164308547974,
-0.14861290156841278,
0.38395771384239197,
0.7081650495529175,
-0.052786607295274734,
0.6867112517356873,
-0.3764873743057251,
-0.10751757025718689,
-0.4016561210155487,
0.3537648320198059,
0.31305262446403503,
0.14971566200256348,
0.40036413073539734,
-1.0285968780517578,
-0.2706698179244995,
-0.22400160133838654,
-0.5964406132698059,
-0.30367738008499146,
-0.04426281154155731,
0.14075607061386108,
0.2630614638328552,
0.3599605858325958,
-0.5608099699020386,
0.12645620107650757,
0.42950448393821716,
-0.3295082747936249,
0.7113760709762573,
0.11739320307970047,
0.38696298003196716,
-0.8684081435203552,
-0.06830835342407227,
-0.04810073599219322,
-0.422339528799057,
-0.46274060010910034,
0.15603254735469818,
0.18112246692180634,
0.5750661492347717,
-0.6627714037895203,
0.4527471959590912,
-0.4680089056491852,
0.03483167290687561,
0.05644799768924713,
0.33899152278900146,
0.020654084160923958,
0.2680876553058624,
-0.1626541018486023,
0.6494885683059692,
0.1613793969154358,
-0.3279074728488922,
0.4703609347343445,
-0.034824151545763016,
-0.45462700724601746,
0.7476280331611633,
-0.343405544757843,
0.03015553578734398,
-0.007591395638883114,
0.14880335330963135,
-1.140555739402771,
-0.3331651985645294,
0.03955605998635292,
-0.5120189189910889,
0.1556817889213562,
-0.11450399458408356,
-0.8422631621360779,
-0.2872769832611084,
-0.3258766531944275,
0.2471163421869278,
0.43498870730400085,
-0.6009848713874817,
0.5364073514938354,
0.1902303546667099,
0.30529314279556274,
-0.9494556784629822,
-1.0023735761642456,
0.2880781292915344,
-0.48762279748916626,
-0.8732048273086548,
0.2735256254673004,
-0.25614067912101746,
-0.4558676481246948,
-0.24282795190811157,
-0.2154773324728012,
-0.010018858127295971,
0.22226935625076294,
-0.049681369215250015,
-0.2419966608285904,
-0.3044816553592682,
0.009660323150455952,
-0.3131447732448578,
-0.0000033373714813933475,
0.29351192712783813,
0.12627620995044708,
0.3903619050979614,
-0.2696166932582855,
-0.5028853416442871,
-0.07370993494987488,
-0.03937514126300812,
0.524080216884613,
0.4179241359233856,
0.5198864340782166,
0.21710728108882904,
-0.46542540192604065,
-0.4982399642467499,
-0.8365464806556702,
-0.01344561018049717,
-0.567054033279419,
0.39396029710769653,
-0.73656165599823,
-0.37952885031700134,
0.4739621579647064,
-0.3389005959033966,
0.22530172765254974,
0.23587775230407715,
0.4664324223995209,
-0.04541276395320892,
0.8751183748245239,
0.2653263211250305,
0.06993918865919113,
-0.07510584592819214,
0.17142237722873688,
0.001528759952634573,
-0.3916662633419037,
-0.21604648232460022,
-0.5525472164154053,
-0.39861229062080383,
-0.364944726228714,
-0.4768911898136139,
0.1970447599887848,
0.2521103024482727,
0.05064801126718521,
0.2858273983001709,
-0.12466563284397125,
0.6393271088600159,
0.17801369726657867,
0.09014956653118134,
0.6039098501205444,
0.028664613142609596,
-0.3989487886428833,
-0.3090953826904297,
-0.49541953206062317,
-0.6563867330551147,
1.0149998664855957,
0.5039255619049072,
0.8719813823699951,
0.5744149088859558,
0.5379127860069275,
0.3690912127494812,
0.22062355279922485,
-0.6872916221618652,
0.8813926577568054,
-0.3322724997997284,
-0.7167420983314514,
0.04924512654542923,
-0.6145737171173096,
-0.8572250604629517,
0.3468806743621826,
0.003909101244062185,
-0.8033062219619751,
-0.3051098883152008,
-0.03087146021425724,
0.24582597613334656,
0.40388524532318115,
-0.7902235388755798,
0.9343045949935913,
-0.4047262370586395,
-0.27881699800491333,
-0.3697742521762848,
-0.5120241641998291,
0.6037642955780029,
-0.1275099217891693,
0.6237745881080627,
-0.2751377820968628,
-0.5327956676483154,
0.6608841419219971,
-0.37876805663108826,
0.8201698064804077,
0.19251205027103424,
-0.23792889714241028,
-0.008639179170131683,
0.2352597415447235,
0.42189711332321167,
-0.004821922164410353,
-0.4578057825565338,
0.20598961412906647,
-0.06567034870386124,
-0.6235948801040649,
-0.5727102160453796,
0.671638548374176,
-0.5581339001655579,
-0.7149327397346497,
-0.49948444962501526,
-0.37808212637901306,
-0.36941415071487427,
0.23465369641780853,
0.15086129307746887,
0.33439359068870544,
-0.28658443689346313,
0.09877369552850723,
0.6599384546279907,
0.06310346722602844,
0.41962796449661255,
0.7192796468734741,
-0.003632537554949522,
-0.22963759303092957,
0.8760061860084534,
0.02905154973268509,
0.3637763261795044,
0.427671879529953,
0.06668812781572342,
-0.32627665996551514,
-0.9480260610580444,
-0.38736769556999207,
0.46915480494499207,
-1.1620453596115112,
-0.1074991524219513,
-0.42364436388015747,
-0.22675904631614685,
-0.232184037566185,
-0.09838195890188217,
-0.21940384805202484,
-0.17266389727592468,
-0.1968613862991333,
0.20261698961257935,
0.28640156984329224,
0.858454704284668,
-0.025458186864852905,
0.3331562280654907,
-0.7407463788986206,
0.3314911127090454,
0.10286153852939606,
0.18403279781341553,
-0.10780113935470581,
-0.7401836514472961,
0.08287759125232697,
-0.1605556458234787,
-0.42458316683769226,
-1.0878864526748657,
0.07754094153642654,
0.01183901634067297,
0.7513012886047363,
0.5636656284332275,
0.07820875197649002,
0.5608066320419312,
-0.4641735255718231,
0.6578671336174011,
0.1462273895740509,
-1.0395745038986206,
0.30292657017707825,
-0.3127933442592621,
0.2972099184989929,
0.603890061378479,
0.46283280849456787,
-0.3821621239185333,
-0.5054718255996704,
-0.6250482797622681,
-0.6516339778900146,
0.6300216913223267,
0.3983568549156189,
0.21251028776168823,
0.023406250402331352,
0.41887524724006653,
0.41284292936325073,
0.3815898597240448,
-1.1062594652175903,
-0.2995244860649109,
0.35975345969200134,
-0.37609243392944336,
-0.004515922628343105,
-0.1354314088821411,
-0.09293965995311737,
0.16557243466377258,
0.5872118473052979,
-0.17887677252292633,
-0.18335369229316711,
-0.14897313714027405,
-0.41866663098335266,
-0.04775369539856911,
0.25354570150375366,
0.37543541193008423,
0.8301231861114502,
-0.027372781187295914,
0.35602644085884094,
0.5068122148513794,
-0.6475754976272583,
0.0243149995803833,
0.10857491940259933,
0.13297170400619507,
-0.09526932239532471,
0.829733669757843,
0.3516872525215149,
0.5578941702842712,
-0.9858260154724121,
0.662114679813385,
-0.16459089517593384,
-0.36375612020492554,
-0.18665966391563416,
0.3453878164291382,
0.43798503279685974,
0.1386346071958542,
0.5716201066970825,
0.10165102034807205,
0.04808775335550308,
-0.41239288449287415,
0.1266116052865982,
0.5254051089286804,
0.045088786631822586,
-0.06206225976347923,
0.36739078164100647,
0.2905401885509491,
-0.5484035015106201,
0.23996470868587494,
-0.30083903670310974,
-0.6102182269096375,
0.6138868927955627,
0.497461199760437,
0.5667856931686401,
0.02842297963798046,
0.19919109344482422,
-0.10845985263586044,
0.6706113219261169,
-0.16100145876407623,
0.33312076330184937,
0.18828053772449493,
-0.7231041789054871,
-0.3097749650478363,
-0.568613588809967,
-0.5445016622543335,
0.4353022575378418,
-0.14836570620536804,
0.6685131788253784,
-0.3047434985637665,
0.18017803132534027,
0.2009582370519638,
0.24916201829910278,
-0.42380771040916443,
0.06365975737571716,
0.11358358711004257,
1.0632308721542358,
-0.5917021036148071,
0.5941171646118164,
0.5584592819213867,
-0.005171752534806728,
-0.3894692063331604,
0.38826462626457214,
0.3397623598575592,
-1.0147653818130493,
0.39081794023513794,
0.47591227293014526,
-0.4249207377433777,
-0.023199280723929405,
-0.7385212182998657,
-0.43920353055000305,
0.7203640937805176,
0.6826978325843811,
-0.6183093786239624,
-0.06747164577245712,
0.35231614112854004,
0.33775800466537476,
-0.19781938195228577,
0.41380301117897034,
0.7947421073913574,
0.7936597466468811,
0.14940090477466583,
-0.8351878523826599,
0.2992202639579773,
-0.1131877601146698,
-0.4825156331062317,
0.18287359178066254,
-0.9031910300254822,
0.8590757846832275,
-0.26778772473335266,
-0.22604741156101227,
0.07903145253658295,
0.463581383228302,
0.39960038661956787,
0.559198260307312,
0.8437566757202148,
0.49910590052604675,
0.6096032857894897,
-0.18745514750480652,
0.5504863858222961,
0.13822805881500244,
0.19298440217971802,
0.795970618724823,
-0.1442350298166275,
0.8683628439903259,
0.5045556426048279,
-0.34926363825798035,
0.4768768548965454,
0.6804187297821045,
-0.028634021058678627,
0.2148660272359848,
0.5634012222290039,
-0.15877339243888855,
-0.6104894876480103,
0.25617945194244385,
-0.20274333655834198,
0.3937896490097046,
0.5903630256652832,
-0.06454909592866898,
-0.3924413323402405,
-0.2505071461200714,
0.3196326494216919,
0.5333619713783264,
-0.08476763963699341,
0.6046125292778015,
0.29026514291763306,
-0.6337438225746155,
0.8629518747329712,
0.16256871819496155,
0.9091107845306396,
-0.5297524333000183,
0.11234404146671295,
-0.09980903565883636,
0.2666005790233612,
-0.1980525404214859,
-0.9198139309883118,
0.12191454321146011,
0.04617302492260933,
0.16533233225345612,
0.04804680868983269,
0.5588378310203552,
-0.02876679226756096,
-0.5232293605804443,
0.5237748622894287,
0.4815397560596466,
0.5717938542366028,
0.11711753159761429,
-1.1345330476760864,
0.18412429094314575,
-0.004038953687995672,
-0.4866299033164978,
0.14750030636787415,
0.7197272777557373,
0.14886873960494995,
0.9079458713531494,
0.35367777943611145,
-0.034080881625413895,
-0.12899138033390045,
-0.05617363750934601,
0.735535204410553,
-0.7723971605300903,
-0.38889560103416443,
-1.072155475616455,
0.2638871669769287,
-0.2636232078075409,
-0.38930732011795044,
0.5808396935462952,
0.45720914006233215,
0.674267053604126,
0.19210949540138245,
0.7229241728782654,
0.05466305464506149,
0.5530502200126648,
-0.6832641959190369,
0.7421726584434509,
-0.9552826285362244,
0.5501542091369629,
-0.23137596249580383,
-0.6394299864768982,
-0.08455251902341843,
0.29839199781417847,
-0.4604535400867462,
0.1699170023202896,
0.8097972273826599,
0.7622005939483643,
-0.3488035798072815,
0.13853996992111206,
0.4469001293182373,
0.5064620971679688,
0.19131691753864288,
1.1273798942565918,
0.9671528339385986,
-0.3831805884838104,
1.056257963180542,
0.02066183276474476,
-0.1560438871383667,
-0.4422834515571594,
-1.1787829399108887,
-1.2884445190429688,
-0.3186253011226654,
-0.22563113272190094,
-0.40017443895339966,
0.2772381901741028,
0.6006461977958679,
0.3191964030265808,
-0.5386083722114563,
-0.1757948398590088,
-0.26803115010261536,
0.6933028697967529,
-0.14492906630039215,
-0.25385090708732605,
0.045412156730890274,
-0.2405942678451538,
-0.9669886231422424,
0.4015941619873047,
0.049469757825136185,
0.04167965054512024,
-0.43613091111183167,
-0.1250351071357727,
-0.3047043979167938,
0.5097322463989258,
0.04843634366989136,
-0.07448802143335342,
-0.957275390625,
-0.16962818801403046,
-0.19727163016796112,
-0.21917980909347534,
-0.011248826049268246,
0.6664847731590271,
-0.5961822867393494,
0.10646269470453262,
0.5788734555244446,
0.533622145652771,
0.2619839608669281,
-0.09012453258037567,
0.49286583065986633,
-0.48826199769973755,
-0.22237423062324524,
0.0627313107252121,
0.23601563274860382,
0.5260751843452454,
-0.40433719754219055,
0.5108613967895508,
0.3842238485813141,
-0.34552475810050964,
-1.1397751569747925,
0.297309935092926,
-0.6937305927276611,
-0.6980937719345093,
1.1552751064300537,
-0.3150327801704407,
-0.3160126507282257,
-0.33892756700515747,
-0.04419342428445816,
-0.1590518206357956,
-0.23868215084075928,
0.8230947256088257,
1.0468635559082031,
0.09026812016963959,
-0.03369514271616936,
-0.7528709769248962,
0.4946296215057373,
0.7086845636367798,
-0.7884856462478638,
0.2825113534927368,
0.367366760969162,
0.5464566946029663,
0.057009391486644745,
0.4311676621437073,
-0.01063351146876812,
0.351598858833313,
0.03184961900115013,
-0.4589322507381439,
0.041698649525642395,
-0.17625373601913452,
-0.09999209642410278,
0.31812185049057007,
0.07642348855733871,
0.13914412260055542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15397v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15397v1 | Regulating Large Language Models: A Roundtable Report | 2024-02-16T21:49:17 | 2024-02-16T21:49:17 | Gabriel Nicholas, Paul Friedl | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | On July 20, 2023, a group of 27 scholars and digital rights advocates with
expertise in law, computer science, political science, and other disciplines
gathered for the Large Language Models, Law and Policy Roundtable, co-hosted by
the NYU School of Law's Information Law Institute and the Center for Democracy
& Technology. The roundtable convened to discuss how law and policy can help
address some of the larger societal problems posed by large language models
(LLMs). The discussion focused on three policy topic areas in particular:
1. Truthfulness: What risks do LLMs pose in terms of generating mis- and
disinformation? How can these risks be mitigated from a technical and/or
regulatory perspective?
2. Privacy: What are the biggest privacy risks involved in the creation,
deployment, and use of LLMs? How can these risks be mitigated from a technical
and/or regulatory perspective?
3. Market concentration: What threats do LLMs pose concerning market/power
concentration? How can these risks be mitigated from a technical and/or
regulatory perspective?
In this paper, we provide a detailed summary of the day's proceedings. We
first recap what we deem to be the most important contributions made during the
issue framing discussions. We then provide a list of potential legal and
regulatory interventions generated during the brainstorming discussions. | [
-0.5016308426856995,
-0.7780787348747253,
0.7054675221443176,
0.00865164678543806,
0.13672445714473724,
0.14196659624576569,
-0.398762971162796,
-0.7907335162162781,
0.03211389109492302,
0.9547531604766846,
-0.03856232762336731,
-0.21632443368434906,
-0.7445917129516602,
-0.1502055525779724,
-0.7086839079856873,
0.9277058839797974,
0.056071072816848755,
0.03717411309480667,
-0.06039325147867203,
0.06727350503206253,
-0.3975132405757904,
-0.7776798009872437,
-0.43559134006500244,
-0.06430628150701523,
0.5526280999183655,
0.1215650737285614,
0.7203203439712524,
0.47909241914749146,
0.5005210041999817,
0.4148705303668976,
-0.46589845418930054,
-0.23053425550460815,
-0.5294809341430664,
-0.03319511190056801,
-0.13886576890945435,
-0.5075560808181763,
-0.44108790159225464,
0.2367754429578781,
0.7576184272766113,
0.8106834888458252,
-0.3558104634284973,
0.12879040837287903,
0.05269399657845497,
0.8187236189842224,
-0.4567856192588806,
0.02665444277226925,
-0.3707532584667206,
0.13905352354049683,
-0.1981831192970276,
-0.013553060591220856,
-0.47074320912361145,
-0.5566686987876892,
0.07411732524633408,
-0.406520277261734,
0.01579173281788826,
0.3767126202583313,
0.6221889853477478,
0.1061449721455574,
-0.5838194489479065,
-0.3467862904071808,
-0.8342728018760681,
0.8509302735328674,
-0.858717143535614,
0.4372485876083374,
0.5480781197547913,
0.19207917153835297,
-0.3399507403373718,
-0.803645670413971,
-0.6847043633460999,
-0.2507963180541992,
0.2225542813539505,
-0.2076398730278015,
-0.4340597689151764,
0.02417961321771145,
0.4723489582538605,
0.33571022748947144,
-0.329247385263443,
0.25608599185943604,
-0.858106791973114,
-0.39121168851852417,
0.8030574321746826,
0.1311500072479248,
0.1544264256954193,
0.22650869190692902,
0.1985480785369873,
0.2967172861099243,
-0.798829197883606,
-0.4364508092403412,
0.7546558976173401,
0.25597432255744934,
-0.2217239886522293,
0.5184077620506287,
-0.09016820043325424,
0.7274808883666992,
-0.03646983951330185,
0.10868007689714432,
0.23726795613765717,
-0.4612464904785156,
0.03161901980638504,
0.24425892531871796,
0.682253897190094,
0.3128404915332794,
0.2617289125919342,
0.11736870557069778,
-0.26120129227638245,
-0.508686363697052,
0.4578356444835663,
-0.6301494836807251,
0.24501755833625793,
0.2882530987262726,
-0.6541808843612671,
-0.2639910876750946,
0.17948350310325623,
-0.9175831079483032,
-0.8324609398841858,
-0.7107608318328857,
0.11665034294128418,
0.31853654980659485,
-0.42715099453926086,
0.2845318019390106,
-0.05850076302886009,
0.21995192766189575,
0.12017577886581421,
-0.924872875213623,
0.2903274595737457,
0.928821325302124,
0.6776556372642517,
0.05287880823016167,
0.1784784346818924,
-0.2373790144920349,
0.27716657519340515,
-0.3165515661239624,
0.13261309266090393,
-0.3547952175140381,
-0.5329818725585938,
0.4125334620475769,
-0.11439135670661926,
0.35724908113479614,
-0.48005491495132446,
0.1737368404865265,
-0.5343647003173828,
0.38416787981987,
-0.509698748588562,
-0.534929096698761,
-0.12168323248624802,
0.3708585798740387,
-0.782833456993103,
0.3439556360244751,
-0.4549730122089386,
-0.8300790786743164,
0.048740752041339874,
-0.934343159198761,
-0.31927844882011414,
0.10202536731958389,
-0.48195093870162964,
0.07403732091188431,
0.02626352198421955,
-0.317708820104599,
0.5044879913330078,
-0.35905376076698303,
0.6657255291938782,
-0.3808908462524414,
-0.06992846727371216,
0.5300633907318115,
-0.6134783029556274,
0.8226075768470764,
0.21022112667560577,
-0.43701043725013733,
0.4238935112953186,
-0.7348836660385132,
-0.12237821519374847,
0.18881216645240784,
-0.1578492969274521,
-0.10958541184663773,
-0.027063941583037376,
0.03549440577626228,
0.21254056692123413,
0.31232333183288574,
-0.4796777367591858,
-0.0536574125289917,
-0.17231281101703644,
1.143565058708191,
0.8723228573799133,
0.04390955716371536,
0.44487154483795166,
-0.30171850323677063,
0.3409058451652527,
-0.10125114023685455,
0.4752432703971863,
0.062063783407211304,
-0.34068432450294495,
-0.511645495891571,
0.002310289302840829,
0.4030402898788452,
0.17932836711406708,
-0.39861416816711426,
0.24437394738197327,
-0.3231920301914215,
-0.4594055712223053,
-0.37181106209754944,
-0.1598014533519745,
0.032973285764455795,
0.038564570248126984,
-0.01306005660444498,
-0.11426695436239243,
-0.29473012685775757,
-0.9396823644638062,
-0.10778699070215225,
-0.19950976967811584,
0.3024357259273529,
0.16773267090320587,
0.5049285292625427,
-0.04234222322702408,
0.9220656752586365,
-0.4034426808357239,
-0.19190296530723572,
-0.1236179918050766,
0.05255122855305672,
0.027713771909475327,
0.32916489243507385,
0.3013891279697418,
-0.9710557460784912,
-0.27910712361335754,
-0.1742793470621109,
-0.4402429163455963,
0.01968519017100334,
0.21315082907676697,
0.48406651616096497,
0.4080626368522644,
0.7888553738594055,
-0.5446005463600159,
0.30121004581451416,
0.5436928272247314,
-0.15021811425685883,
0.6106910705566406,
-0.36079737544059753,
0.054214198142290115,
-0.9933508634567261,
0.003218561178073287,
-0.03538939356803894,
-0.08221465349197388,
-0.7012747526168823,
0.017859721556305885,
-0.27770450711250305,
-0.18076778948307037,
-0.600376307964325,
0.5587084889411926,
-0.3478914797306061,
-0.2863558232784271,
-0.47404026985168457,
0.354973703622818,
-0.24305935204029083,
-0.07545410096645355,
-0.32683926820755005,
0.9237132668495178,
0.3361363112926483,
-0.6920039653778076,
0.46020352840423584,
0.11368589848279953,
-0.45606786012649536,
0.4912776052951813,
-0.5549205541610718,
0.25886210799217224,
-0.01670464314520359,
0.3346916735172272,
-0.3583953380584717,
-0.26879382133483887,
0.14490963518619537,
-0.2199152559041977,
0.275247722864151,
0.23744148015975952,
-0.6580555438995361,
-0.44424039125442505,
-0.2746163010597229,
0.39134326577186584,
0.21602608263492584,
-0.07463013380765915,
0.32863715291023254,
1.2191274166107178,
-0.2974777817726135,
-0.5311659574508667,
-0.7537389993667603,
0.5323622226715088,
-0.26113009452819824,
-0.4430718421936035,
0.13898222148418427,
-0.18311342597007751,
-0.6895900964736938,
-0.049944233149290085,
0.12844350934028625,
-0.19449590146541595,
0.035408783704042435,
0.40697604417800903,
-0.0705878809094429,
0.04347853735089302,
0.10863867402076721,
-0.37083515524864197,
-0.25570395588874817,
0.3758942782878876,
-0.2756132483482361,
0.7422056198120117,
-0.40525609254837036,
-0.19856677949428558,
-0.3137238621711731,
0.48008590936660767,
0.6667391657829285,
-0.21921950578689575,
0.5375073552131653,
0.29076018929481506,
-0.2719470262527466,
0.06625344604253769,
-0.7999656796455383,
-0.09828847646713257,
-0.49697422981262207,
0.34760499000549316,
0.1453985720872879,
-1.4734573364257812,
0.4303782284259796,
0.07776521891355515,
0.343927264213562,
0.30209770798683167,
0.8755968809127808,
0.07564672082662582,
0.6573910117149353,
1.174257755279541,
-0.23587097227573395,
0.5758510828018188,
0.01868176832795143,
0.6185359358787537,
-0.3869803845882416,
-0.25089994072914124,
-0.7632063031196594,
-0.13677485287189484,
-0.8772838711738586,
-0.22867491841316223,
0.2903670072555542,
-0.5431615710258484,
-0.30119046568870544,
0.1938825398683548,
-0.21695230901241302,
0.4700070023536682,
0.5622225999832153,
-0.2476038932800293,
0.43353697657585144,
-0.17962439358234406,
0.2167176604270935,
0.1940053552389145,
-0.46808499097824097,
-0.7938559651374817,
1.037825584411621,
0.7510784864425659,
0.5756954550743103,
0.00911168847233057,
0.5227760672569275,
0.45212769508361816,
0.07427053898572922,
-0.6332040429115295,
0.9061790704727173,
0.013189227320253849,
-1.0183768272399902,
-0.4855623245239258,
-0.5216115713119507,
-0.543372392654419,
0.019759155809879303,
-0.09049635380506516,
-0.739858090877533,
0.20461982488632202,
0.07063739746809006,
-0.24851186573505402,
0.48414304852485657,
-0.23839956521987915,
0.54913330078125,
-0.2799924910068512,
-0.31425967812538147,
-0.6322317123413086,
-0.636803388595581,
0.38589584827423096,
-0.38746869564056396,
0.6904506683349609,
-0.2145664542913437,
-0.01924913376569748,
0.9522577524185181,
-0.1908184140920639,
0.8309887051582336,
0.02752533368766308,
-0.38071712851524353,
0.30743494629859924,
-0.31693005561828613,
0.243948832154274,
-0.3716881573200226,
0.10927560925483704,
0.484518826007843,
0.27577540278434753,
-0.19134530425071716,
-0.040911965072155,
0.6311776041984558,
-0.7556709051132202,
-0.8634093999862671,
-0.46223652362823486,
-0.5249908566474915,
-0.1506248265504837,
0.3825652599334717,
0.1072445809841156,
0.17795386910438538,
-0.4201882481575012,
0.4528164267539978,
0.908624529838562,
-0.2565164864063263,
0.6236997246742249,
0.5544400811195374,
-0.4967455267906189,
-0.4594601094722748,
0.9340658783912659,
0.5068976879119873,
0.31682297587394714,
-0.03747870773077011,
0.141027569770813,
-0.17561639845371246,
-0.5936954617500305,
0.007666350342333317,
0.25439998507499695,
-0.7088178396224976,
0.08640561997890472,
-0.6105512380599976,
-0.4638241231441498,
-0.34321674704551697,
0.13495899736881256,
-0.3990698754787445,
-0.4227462410926819,
-0.36113491654396057,
-0.07361660897731781,
0.1913634091615677,
0.8593306541442871,
-0.1052258312702179,
0.13677793741226196,
-0.7836117744445801,
0.05292072892189026,
0.14182239770889282,
0.3262617886066437,
-0.09999355673789978,
-0.40851256251335144,
-0.12045959383249283,
-0.023526081815361977,
-0.33167222142219543,
-0.34410005807876587,
-0.022672099992632866,
-0.3076862394809723,
0.42582350969314575,
0.023772405460476875,
0.2341923713684082,
0.36987316608428955,
-0.6465124487876892,
0.8287035822868347,
0.5103437900543213,
-0.9209692478179932,
0.05151094123721123,
-0.26599210500717163,
-0.1561773717403412,
0.23221085965633392,
0.3210376501083374,
-0.863835871219635,
-0.5797055959701538,
-0.4820863902568817,
-0.8951537013053894,
0.43801572918891907,
-0.10697377473115921,
0.7447460889816284,
0.28330135345458984,
0.264767050743103,
0.04278823733329773,
0.5534703135490417,
-0.7378349304199219,
-0.0444270558655262,
0.1490952968597412,
-0.21993909776210785,
0.24010656774044037,
-0.4932134449481964,
-0.36010444164276123,
0.006140043493360281,
0.6227213740348816,
0.23469926416873932,
-0.04678044840693474,
-0.0888632982969284,
0.19073832035064697,
-0.2743987441062927,
0.6206700801849365,
0.8969935774803162,
1.1493146419525146,
0.3885408937931061,
0.12622806429862976,
-0.10533428192138672,
-0.7406041026115417,
0.32922378182411194,
-0.10086366534233093,
-0.4791669249534607,
-0.302249550819397,
0.15637582540512085,
0.5415588021278381,
-0.10214672237634659,
-0.6558216214179993,
0.5612366199493408,
0.041121501475572586,
-0.5320884585380554,
-0.4223942756652832,
0.035085808485746384,
0.007850836031138897,
0.4488671123981476,
0.3097878396511078,
-0.3918236792087555,
0.03312801569700241,
-0.628919243812561,
0.10278439521789551,
0.3549250066280365,
-0.5311482548713684,
-0.1517173796892166,
0.5067877769470215,
0.25729647278785706,
-0.22889001667499542,
0.22668009996414185,
0.2866670787334442,
-0.43944329023361206,
0.4061580002307892,
0.24139875173568726,
0.788266658782959,
-0.0872131809592247,
0.20826545357704163,
-0.14464858174324036,
0.7225792407989502,
-0.3690035939216614,
0.015211417339742184,
0.3762396275997162,
-0.5442904829978943,
-0.309014230966568,
-0.24208632111549377,
-0.6108648777008057,
0.2945909798145294,
-0.35378172993659973,
0.017271624878048897,
-0.7717424631118774,
-0.5830400586128235,
0.09378982335329056,
0.4033851623535156,
-0.250308096408844,
-0.1959630846977234,
0.34450432658195496,
0.7813272476196289,
-0.7062180638313293,
0.5701834559440613,
0.3738131523132324,
-0.4109974801540375,
-0.41578152775764465,
0.14577047526836395,
0.35719427466392517,
-0.35949376225471497,
0.31907445192337036,
0.04333832859992981,
0.07523263245820999,
-0.07014312595129013,
-0.9207698702812195,
-0.6394152641296387,
0.9153881669044495,
0.5082295536994934,
-0.906098484992981,
0.1363772302865982,
0.5215494632720947,
0.44039595127105713,
-0.10083193331956863,
-0.09905469417572021,
0.617218017578125,
0.6758204102516174,
0.17566034197807312,
-1.2905118465423584,
-0.010330026969313622,
0.12456437945365906,
0.14528776705265045,
0.2792081832885742,
-0.8727125525474548,
0.6746414303779602,
-0.0031359062995761633,
0.02821528911590576,
-0.18420036137104034,
0.7350157499313354,
-0.01857123337686062,
0.3302356004714966,
0.13390791416168213,
0.24628333747386932,
0.7786715030670166,
-0.028012365102767944,
0.809492290019989,
-0.3765404522418976,
0.10974804311990738,
0.7101409435272217,
-0.5979627370834351,
0.6344448328018188,
0.49942463636398315,
-0.24679110944271088,
-0.2278311401605606,
0.5211651921272278,
-0.05199910327792168,
0.3497673273086548,
0.5258947610855103,
-0.21308846771717072,
0.18440388143062592,
-0.44680657982826233,
-0.5996519327163696,
0.16381694376468658,
0.28620627522468567,
-0.15118615329265594,
-0.022076640278100967,
0.2718038260936737,
0.16760115325450897,
0.2609972357749939,
-0.39300262928009033,
0.7509374022483826,
0.30400577187538147,
-0.2232779562473297,
-0.09282508492469788,
0.23669305443763733,
0.411171019077301,
-0.4771175980567932,
0.14637738466262817,
-0.07757112383842468,
0.007729618344455957,
-0.15064850449562073,
-0.9993710517883301,
0.4596666097640991,
0.14049184322357178,
-0.39871710538864136,
-0.23139259219169617,
0.3553514778614044,
-0.3779083490371704,
-0.2702150046825409,
0.004193686880171299,
0.11193212121725082,
0.04645519703626633,
0.016377286985516548,
-0.68909752368927,
0.8159487843513489,
-0.23101922869682312,
-0.22472833096981049,
0.5622272491455078,
0.5110756754875183,
-0.2739746868610382,
0.8335347175598145,
0.5269214510917664,
0.22816802561283112,
0.2642766535282135,
0.05239257961511612,
0.909924328327179,
-0.629374623298645,
-0.46997156739234924,
-0.5712495446205139,
0.22107629477977753,
-0.21112270653247833,
-0.12757742404937744,
0.43206092715263367,
0.34276723861694336,
0.7430130243301392,
0.26297837495803833,
0.7321950793266296,
-0.2609521448612213,
0.2419101595878601,
-0.550995409488678,
1.0410224199295044,
-0.3021979331970215,
0.37245407700538635,
0.20377150177955627,
-1.0320611000061035,
-0.37762919068336487,
0.3411010205745697,
-0.6581669449806213,
0.16965362429618835,
0.36158236861228943,
0.7017650008201599,
0.23510803282260895,
0.21558602154254913,
0.40353330969810486,
0.4959062933921814,
0.6776567101478577,
-0.08026404678821564,
0.6913206577301025,
-0.09918179363012314,
0.4189339578151703,
0.0722062811255455,
0.08568980544805527,
-0.2909480035305023,
-0.9521005749702454,
-0.5466909408569336,
-0.653904914855957,
-0.5213015675544739,
-0.3062748908996582,
0.03792378678917885,
0.9940853118896484,
0.4122876524925232,
-0.7580777406692505,
-0.48727554082870483,
0.06178944185376167,
0.19173888862133026,
0.38515377044677734,
-0.1821574717760086,
0.05439026653766632,
-0.05478557571768761,
-0.5250298976898193,
0.012246552854776382,
0.5334746837615967,
0.02004167065024376,
-0.5441281795501709,
0.08986512571573257,
-0.05521080270409584,
0.09121475368738174,
0.5744647979736328,
0.45189595222473145,
-0.820916473865509,
-0.4801287353038788,
-0.4099330008029938,
-0.4311352074146271,
-0.1457781344652176,
0.8204604983329773,
0.0006232244777493179,
0.42836758494377136,
0.26221922039985657,
0.6302178502082825,
0.22886060178279877,
-0.3754560053348541,
0.6595150232315063,
-0.3136577904224396,
0.193932443857193,
0.44360998272895813,
0.15777724981307983,
0.24241459369659424,
-0.034834813326597214,
0.3518766164779663,
0.018761996179819107,
-0.6374406218528748,
-0.9632629752159119,
0.2499825805425644,
-0.8068366646766663,
-0.24312801659107208,
1.039089560508728,
0.12733575701713562,
-0.17156070470809937,
-0.2746829390525818,
-0.1725495159626007,
0.06298763304948807,
-0.1118517518043518,
0.8159723877906799,
0.9446591734886169,
0.4689829647541046,
-0.2220434844493866,
-1.1448134183883667,
0.309611439704895,
-0.204743430018425,
-0.8702693581581116,
0.3937588334083557,
0.7655910849571228,
0.16563446819782257,
0.1457778811454773,
0.6374109387397766,
-0.4364411532878876,
-0.06640616804361343,
-0.38274773955345154,
0.03037203848361969,
-0.15554264187812805,
-0.46342846751213074,
-0.4422815442085266,
0.10065235942602158,
0.06339989602565765,
0.14932335913181305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11094v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11094v2 | Word Embeddings Revisited: Do LLMs Offer Something New? | 2024-02-16T21:47:30 | 2024-03-02T14:01:04 | Matthew Freestone, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker Santu | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Learning meaningful word embeddings is key to training a robust language
model. The recent rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) has provided us with
many new word/sentence/document embedding models. Although LLMs have shown
remarkable advancement in various NLP tasks, it is still unclear whether the
performance improvement is merely because of scale or whether underlying
embeddings they produce significantly differ from classical encoding models
like Sentence-BERT (SBERT) or Universal Sentence Encoder (USE). This paper
systematically investigates this issue by comparing classical word embedding
techniques against LLM-based word embeddings in terms of their latent vector
semantics. Our results show that LLMs tend to cluster semantically related
words more tightly than classical models. LLMs also yield higher average
accuracy on the Bigger Analogy Test Set (BATS) over classical methods. Finally,
some LLMs tend to produce word embeddings similar to SBERT, a relatively
lighter classical model. | [
-0.053319212049245834,
-0.7531307339668274,
0.7385567426681519,
-0.24360981583595276,
-0.35434579849243164,
0.19624339044094086,
-0.40390557050704956,
-0.33248648047447205,
0.18309803307056427,
0.3165852427482605,
-0.08655884116888046,
-0.45149460434913635,
-0.8025531768798828,
-0.009352813474833965,
-0.49632859230041504,
0.5726144909858704,
-0.0884145051240921,
0.42902660369873047,
-0.6180109977722168,
-0.22296658158302307,
-0.32447996735572815,
-0.5971959233283997,
-0.2510313093662262,
-0.5562469363212585,
0.5157890915870667,
-0.17257045209407806,
0.8461984395980835,
0.683678925037384,
0.5894951224327087,
0.2854766547679901,
-0.39189964532852173,
0.05594763532280922,
-0.4356887936592102,
0.14303451776504517,
0.05914841592311859,
-0.6621449589729309,
-0.08065396547317505,
0.0956590548157692,
0.5301859974861145,
0.9149813652038574,
-0.222757488489151,
-0.03882134333252907,
0.1364668905735016,
0.41321247816085815,
-0.627101719379425,
0.03287089243531227,
-0.9058078527450562,
0.17115706205368042,
-0.017861001193523407,
-0.21139509975910187,
-0.3947371244430542,
-0.3913012146949768,
0.2600242495536804,
-0.3215569853782654,
-0.0067083220928907394,
0.13166816532611847,
0.7753862738609314,
0.2504676282405853,
-0.23302403092384338,
-0.5736404657363892,
-0.5425145626068115,
0.8376198410987854,
-0.818567156791687,
0.6594513654708862,
0.03843071684241295,
0.050571125000715256,
-0.13931593298912048,
-0.766822874546051,
-0.4733612537384033,
-0.3422689139842987,
0.16423921287059784,
-0.07972836494445801,
-0.2550460398197174,
0.034541938453912735,
0.1616838425397873,
0.4719836711883545,
-0.2542317807674408,
0.43288612365722656,
-0.10314511507749557,
-0.04159664735198021,
0.29944634437561035,
0.060622379183769226,
0.22915548086166382,
-0.12466248869895935,
-0.4602953791618347,
-0.2059786170721054,
-1.0664764642715454,
0.030742526054382324,
0.08486615866422653,
0.2492896020412445,
-0.013901174068450928,
0.8444315791130066,
0.3566550612449646,
0.7270761728286743,
-0.2357233613729477,
-0.35110023617744446,
0.10711396485567093,
0.04487970471382141,
-0.10340598225593567,
0.049546971917152405,
0.4905701279640198,
0.310977965593338,
0.4256734848022461,
-0.5719438791275024,
-0.3045104146003723,
0.30482369661331177,
0.20154155790805817,
-0.49588167667388916,
-0.025060150772333145,
-0.11136958748102188,
-0.5239109396934509,
-0.2914789915084839,
0.25550004839897156,
-0.17072167992591858,
-0.30218377709388733,
-0.316697895526886,
0.5840429663658142,
-0.4301489591598511,
0.06408684700727463,
0.13058669865131378,
-0.3539031744003296,
0.6294928193092346,
0.38572123646736145,
-0.7693626284599304,
0.20790424942970276,
0.9621802568435669,
0.8314021825790405,
-0.2905685007572174,
-0.05637480691075325,
-0.40816444158554077,
-0.022520139813423157,
-0.7106209397315979,
0.813156247138977,
-0.8675065636634827,
-0.3653005063533783,
0.36976978182792664,
-0.21635344624519348,
0.09570653736591339,
-0.6879625916481018,
0.20248723030090332,
-0.6215034127235413,
0.14104539155960083,
-0.5029201507568359,
-1.031496524810791,
-0.11454585194587708,
0.23931311070919037,
-0.40019315481185913,
0.9430843591690063,
0.004728465806692839,
-0.8857370018959045,
0.5623478293418884,
-0.13400210440158844,
-0.20247800648212433,
-0.07394742220640182,
-0.36714285612106323,
-0.2238122820854187,
0.632504403591156,
0.053693607449531555,
0.8191066980361938,
-0.24170368909835815,
-0.11163916438817978,
-0.7378248572349548,
-0.5463001132011414,
0.7248180508613586,
-0.3147795796394348,
0.25684407353401184,
0.09675063192844391,
0.015681413933634758,
-0.15867412090301514,
-0.4648113548755646,
0.016203714534640312,
0.10561008751392365,
-0.4384315013885498,
-0.6087150573730469,
0.09806466847658157,
-0.2924557328224182,
0.025690127164125443,
0.3151065707206726,
-0.6478977203369141,
0.017948588356375694,
-0.3905000686645508,
0.6481644511222839,
0.7059555649757385,
-0.20278021693229675,
0.39777782559394836,
-0.4614192247390747,
0.4271900951862335,
-0.11627984791994095,
-0.4358528256416321,
-0.12664178013801575,
-0.35908061265945435,
-0.6538379788398743,
-0.3573307693004608,
0.5414851903915405,
0.37164533138275146,
-0.5524274706840515,
0.49887531995773315,
-0.43055886030197144,
-0.31208816170692444,
-0.43374165892601013,
0.0826304480433464,
0.11582908034324646,
0.11448200792074203,
0.08990661054849625,
-0.30516108870506287,
-0.24678878486156464,
-0.7053635716438293,
-0.279997855424881,
-0.021274108439683914,
-0.0893905907869339,
0.24322810769081116,
0.45137912034988403,
-0.12530826032161713,
0.7931626439094543,
-0.47851622104644775,
-0.04119120165705681,
-0.4205840229988098,
-0.16605272889137268,
-0.13727335631847382,
-0.01384003646671772,
0.6903988122940063,
-0.2943595349788666,
-0.28369683027267456,
-0.27347248792648315,
-0.7801191210746765,
0.1270783245563507,
0.0807209387421608,
0.31760039925575256,
0.13344739377498627,
0.7408851385116577,
-0.32080137729644775,
0.1826993227005005,
0.8164349794387817,
-0.11016028374433517,
0.2598838210105896,
-0.4563695788383484,
-0.19119839370250702,
-1.1505722999572754,
-0.3521936535835266,
-0.21378283202648163,
-0.3095429837703705,
-0.38952624797821045,
0.23343388736248016,
0.12215906381607056,
-0.09102362394332886,
-0.5658276677131653,
0.2123957723379135,
-0.5788293480873108,
-0.4444824159145355,
-0.4483109712600708,
0.47299596667289734,
-0.12434306740760803,
0.23922155797481537,
-0.06892598420381546,
0.8500335216522217,
0.5188072919845581,
-0.5236205458641052,
0.33709731698036194,
0.18970683217048645,
-0.51362544298172,
0.24592356383800507,
-0.8353637456893921,
0.028327055275440216,
-0.15250900387763977,
0.1611054390668869,
-0.9932947158813477,
0.18194802105426788,
-0.33474355936050415,
-0.260255366563797,
0.5843043327331543,
0.25313788652420044,
-0.6465371251106262,
-0.36245080828666687,
-0.6877678632736206,
0.09220923483371735,
0.7461442947387695,
-0.6203975081443787,
0.15246222913265228,
0.4960712194442749,
-0.018199563026428223,
-0.31161928176879883,
-0.97286456823349,
0.047100141644477844,
-0.37252530455589294,
-0.4048706889152527,
0.3153650462627411,
0.22733759880065918,
-0.2918902039527893,
0.21628059446811676,
-0.08446747809648514,
0.050934575498104095,
0.2329481542110443,
0.13778355717658997,
0.03298679739236832,
-0.2580167055130005,
0.5040414333343506,
-0.04330919682979584,
0.013944526202976704,
-0.05336768180131912,
-0.20836377143859863,
0.5879133939743042,
-0.26664918661117554,
-0.4702886641025543,
-0.14559799432754517,
0.30668529868125916,
0.33430027961730957,
-0.2802117168903351,
0.9306206107139587,
0.6393831372261047,
-0.39720532298088074,
-0.12104504555463791,
-0.5190160870552063,
-0.3389119803905487,
-0.4307015836238861,
0.26506051421165466,
-0.2288445085287094,
-1.5384870767593384,
0.23588238656520844,
-0.3260938823223114,
0.11426626890897751,
0.37074247002601624,
0.5516287088394165,
-0.29740428924560547,
0.6765762567520142,
0.8828521966934204,
-0.045707013458013535,
0.4412286579608917,
-0.17725929617881775,
0.34150323271751404,
-1.0358057022094727,
0.04493557661771774,
-0.44746196269989014,
-0.30113232135772705,
-0.7988199591636658,
-0.7133933901786804,
0.24595890939235687,
0.23179209232330322,
0.05538277328014374,
0.34555497765541077,
-0.20836424827575684,
0.12029431015253067,
0.327047199010849,
-0.03659631311893463,
0.13044951856136322,
0.34482723474502563,
-0.35238373279571533,
-0.40808042883872986,
-0.9213725328445435,
-0.7479873895645142,
1.2655808925628662,
0.4806373715400696,
1.1117591857910156,
0.10081524401903152,
0.7617257833480835,
0.1806209236383438,
0.23753738403320312,
-0.9661070108413696,
0.5230532884597778,
-0.4419187307357788,
-0.10402418673038483,
-0.09357775002717972,
-0.23841573297977448,
-1.1774260997772217,
0.42414408922195435,
-0.6837432384490967,
-0.6194795370101929,
-0.03206877037882805,
-0.07530023157596588,
-0.19860446453094482,
0.5700145363807678,
-0.41678375005722046,
0.576570451259613,
-0.22621557116508484,
-0.10784255713224411,
-0.36621740460395813,
-0.1844325214624405,
0.08069080859422684,
-0.04878077656030655,
0.17274542152881622,
-0.11654082685709,
-0.4273926615715027,
0.7114668488502502,
-0.48617082834243774,
0.6640055775642395,
0.22426027059555054,
-0.2933254539966583,
0.24865151941776276,
-0.1435670703649521,
0.42753028869628906,
-0.17511820793151855,
-0.011505601927638054,
0.0988122969865799,
0.051953237503767014,
-0.27246567606925964,
-0.6546061038970947,
0.8485540151596069,
-0.6672365665435791,
-0.5456502437591553,
-0.37000811100006104,
-0.41524985432624817,
-0.19735541939735413,
-0.13448753952980042,
0.17557798326015472,
0.7070807218551636,
-0.42199867963790894,
0.6771886944770813,
0.8968623876571655,
-0.4898563027381897,
0.4880281388759613,
0.1843302696943283,
-0.14764711260795593,
-0.2618449926376343,
0.60538250207901,
0.15027667582035065,
0.27278244495391846,
0.733450174331665,
0.3051653206348419,
-0.37807393074035645,
-0.6033250093460083,
0.007492137141525745,
0.4546058177947998,
-0.605452835559845,
-0.06283584237098694,
-0.6291793584823608,
-0.021280357614159584,
-0.35502755641937256,
-0.33463847637176514,
-0.3863367438316345,
-0.4539141058921814,
-0.1551392525434494,
-0.08591758459806442,
0.45224499702453613,
0.8959528803825378,
-0.04861307516694069,
0.20573468506336212,
-0.7536731958389282,
0.025779593735933304,
0.48267340660095215,
0.18483063578605652,
-0.11610343307256699,
-0.6200348138809204,
-0.20866310596466064,
-0.17755061388015747,
-0.23201270401477814,
-0.9226354360580444,
0.037734922021627426,
0.33606386184692383,
0.5976550579071045,
0.5356850624084473,
-0.16524121165275574,
0.46728795766830444,
-0.7941374778747559,
0.9490557312965393,
0.18222658336162567,
-0.6736032366752625,
0.30468612909317017,
-0.2060118019580841,
0.28581616282463074,
0.1836593747138977,
0.40233930945396423,
-0.46933743357658386,
-0.4111204743385315,
-0.7155096530914307,
-0.7066554427146912,
0.05692606046795845,
-0.13545958697795868,
0.5258543491363525,
-0.18126238882541656,
0.4948268234729767,
0.1318921595811844,
0.5352776646614075,
-0.6282457709312439,
-0.10790219157934189,
0.187839075922966,
-0.09146489202976227,
-0.3226296305656433,
-0.6226115822792053,
0.1516674906015396,
-0.030008241534233093,
0.26747241616249084,
0.10621620714664459,
0.614586353302002,
0.04200632870197296,
-0.3505808413028717,
0.18679243326187134,
0.41357749700546265,
0.3232814371585846,
0.49688857793807983,
0.00021650180860888213,
0.27385997772216797,
0.49232497811317444,
-0.19551129639148712,
0.004183787852525711,
-0.1931057572364807,
-0.042377881705760956,
0.1816912591457367,
0.7981173396110535,
0.9029399752616882,
0.5507059693336487,
-0.737225353717804,
0.7379956841468811,
0.1079677939414978,
-0.29568660259246826,
-0.2779842019081116,
0.10800522565841675,
0.40066856145858765,
0.220840722322464,
-0.05040498822927475,
-0.24793773889541626,
-0.15855731070041656,
-0.7549082040786743,
0.11964957416057587,
0.7313326597213745,
-0.42512327432632446,
-0.09957868605852127,
0.507123589515686,
-0.08919444680213928,
-0.15912269055843353,
0.3320089280605316,
0.01057911105453968,
-0.5910323858261108,
0.059238582849502563,
0.5391380786895752,
0.6680666208267212,
-0.044370077550411224,
-0.01588124968111515,
0.04334137216210365,
0.3597250282764435,
-0.18682710826396942,
0.19426734745502472,
-0.0990605354309082,
-0.7998149991035461,
-0.47031325101852417,
-0.7895381450653076,
-0.4861246645450592,
0.05105730518698692,
-0.6579270362854004,
0.009960771538317204,
-0.5162252187728882,
-0.10481014102697372,
-0.39096325635910034,
-0.01726277731359005,
-0.6639554500579834,
-0.01769619807600975,
0.13735677301883698,
0.8167915344238281,
-0.8164142966270447,
0.8700600266456604,
0.9970822930335999,
-0.1035332903265953,
-0.8227617740631104,
-0.010623631067574024,
-0.22188995778560638,
-0.7558340430259705,
0.4203701317310333,
0.2655804753303528,
0.03823484107851982,
-0.1128753125667572,
-0.42022842168807983,
-0.8965240716934204,
1.1924748420715332,
0.33455154299736023,
-0.5955695509910583,
-0.05892164260149002,
0.13159531354904175,
0.6777337789535522,
-0.4214646518230438,
0.02573380060493946,
0.34791067242622375,
0.0006443234160542488,
-0.057607948780059814,
-0.4919773042201996,
-0.029002506285905838,
0.22215458750724792,
0.4990610182285309,
0.1548788696527481,
-0.34876319766044617,
0.7471445202827454,
-0.1487794816493988,
-0.1410750299692154,
0.1535109430551529,
0.9299226999282837,
0.15650199353694916,
-0.11088453978300095,
0.3740278482437134,
0.926409125328064,
0.67142653465271,
-0.25427863001823425,
1.1821424961090088,
-0.31153643131256104,
0.31297990679740906,
0.8958661556243896,
-0.18392451107501984,
1.3561521768569946,
0.4802727699279785,
-0.41797301173210144,
0.48356056213378906,
0.6021746397018433,
-0.03394850715994835,
0.5449163317680359,
0.4333217442035675,
-0.11167341470718384,
-0.3900180160999298,
0.030500320717692375,
-0.45243537425994873,
0.5080125331878662,
0.5080588459968567,
-0.33973899483680725,
-0.34883373975753784,
0.19735948741436005,
0.09050200879573822,
0.37593209743499756,
-0.16040758788585663,
0.7306808829307556,
0.501003086566925,
-0.2120898962020874,
0.3443724513053894,
0.19506196677684784,
1.0959820747375488,
-0.5935921669006348,
0.261348694562912,
-0.04940928891301155,
0.34390828013420105,
0.1846369206905365,
-0.4803464710712433,
0.22833648324012756,
0.011912485584616661,
0.21724596619606018,
-0.1452271193265915,
0.7672213315963745,
-0.4734392464160919,
-0.43643078207969666,
0.29911836981773376,
0.7062375545501709,
0.29419514536857605,
0.12877681851387024,
-0.6686376333236694,
0.22011391818523407,
-0.3823651969432831,
-0.18137942254543304,
0.38319069147109985,
0.5060995221138,
0.19675005972385406,
0.6464586853981018,
0.5413548350334167,
0.3501608073711395,
0.23744481801986694,
0.013708946295082569,
0.7093760371208191,
-0.5837558507919312,
-0.3307144045829773,
-0.673647940158844,
0.00891895778477192,
0.17144514620304108,
-0.09024500846862793,
0.8610095381736755,
0.3757738769054413,
0.9473277926445007,
-0.07674552500247955,
0.6147100329399109,
0.19031834602355957,
0.5173491835594177,
-0.7236969470977783,
0.40556856989860535,
-0.8959096670150757,
0.24612724781036377,
-0.3394176959991455,
-1.0354996919631958,
-0.35232093930244446,
0.8978781700134277,
-0.36348822712898254,
0.06506416201591492,
0.8514269590377808,
0.7194123268127441,
-0.03829206898808479,
-0.10205136984586716,
0.5686852335929871,
0.1305343210697174,
0.19660034775733948,
0.299987256526947,
0.925295352935791,
-0.3686767518520355,
0.23410971462726593,
0.06021576002240181,
-0.0610785186290741,
-0.2457045018672943,
-0.9091545343399048,
-0.993837833404541,
-0.3906196653842926,
-0.2891234755516052,
-0.04756465181708336,
0.14304493367671967,
0.8955739140510559,
0.20157203078269958,
-0.5602959990501404,
-0.11137545108795166,
-0.07539930194616318,
-0.005986145697534084,
-0.16241252422332764,
-0.14883224666118622,
0.3619433343410492,
-0.5524688959121704,
-0.5926360487937927,
0.36723750829696655,
0.3889501392841339,
0.24408511817455292,
-0.38705503940582275,
-0.043847162276506424,
-0.07929340749979019,
0.19186408817768097,
0.8510016202926636,
-0.18399225175380707,
-0.8035939335823059,
-0.5783059597015381,
-0.013378284871578217,
-0.311110258102417,
-0.08712400496006012,
0.8508407473564148,
-0.6378023624420166,
0.21141740679740906,
0.622245728969574,
0.9638135433197021,
0.30929651856422424,
-0.4409908652305603,
0.6054800152778625,
-0.4652230441570282,
0.17318657040596008,
0.017861533910036087,
0.608894407749176,
0.562166154384613,
0.15136441588401794,
0.29032182693481445,
0.19896133244037628,
-0.34506484866142273,
-0.7545819878578186,
0.2724064290523529,
-0.8072004318237305,
-0.4507129192352295,
1.2656958103179932,
-0.21285617351531982,
-0.2069869041442871,
0.2396756261587143,
0.12852850556373596,
0.23560605943202972,
-0.06803364306688309,
0.5406917929649353,
0.8056591153144836,
0.09069528430700302,
-0.10281050205230713,
-0.3449709415435791,
0.3155238628387451,
0.487921804189682,
-0.3583841323852539,
-0.3258395195007324,
0.3320217728614807,
0.3541724979877472,
0.06941145658493042,
0.20276705920696259,
-0.2891789674758911,
0.020620500668883324,
0.009260994382202625,
-0.13210918009281158,
-0.0680137649178505,
-0.14015263319015503,
-0.5174733996391296,
0.16469812393188477,
0.48117995262145996,
-0.20272761583328247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11078v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11078v3 | Model Editing by Standard Fine-Tuning | 2024-02-16T21:10:33 | 2024-06-03T05:39:10 | Govind Gangadhar, Karl Stratos | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Standard fine-tuning is considered not as effective as specialized methods
for model editing due to its comparatively poor performance. However, it is
simple, agnostic to the architectural details of the model being edited, and
able to leverage advances in standard training techniques with no additional
work (e.g., black-box PEFT for computational efficiency), making it an
appealing choice for a model editor. In this work, we show that standard
fine-tuning alone can yield competitive model editing performance with two
minor modifications. First, we optimize the conditional likelihood rather than
the full likelihood. Second, in addition to the typical practice of training on
randomly paraphrased edit prompts to encourage generalization, we also train on
random or similar unedited facts to encourage locality. Our experiments on the
ZsRE and CounterFact datasets demonstrate that these simple modifications allow
standard fine-tuning to match or outperform highly specialized editors in terms
of edit score. | [
-0.38257211446762085,
-0.8283252120018005,
0.7008523344993591,
-0.36367204785346985,
-0.3956272006034851,
-0.4413264989852905,
-0.4295152723789215,
-0.5533141493797302,
-0.08397912979125977,
0.4858000576496124,
-0.4934866428375244,
-0.5877724885940552,
-0.4145900309085846,
0.18963652849197388,
-0.2789106070995331,
1.0944948196411133,
0.11390819400548935,
0.04576912894845009,
-0.24900543689727783,
-0.3775225281715393,
-0.3778994381427765,
-0.5955665707588196,
-0.6913724541664124,
-0.06689102947711945,
0.7052457332611084,
0.4017195403575897,
1.1241729259490967,
0.7672930955886841,
0.5609537363052368,
0.3155362904071808,
-0.5365108847618103,
0.41285672783851624,
-0.5476163029670715,
-0.25593873858451843,
-0.6748684048652649,
-0.5510423183441162,
-0.8813103437423706,
0.13345003128051758,
0.49472537636756897,
0.5984136462211609,
0.1384183168411255,
0.2369607537984848,
0.01892959140241146,
0.7883343696594238,
-0.8499798774719238,
-0.18479515612125397,
-0.8139697313308716,
-0.10329501330852509,
-0.34919455647468567,
-0.05929793417453766,
-0.21539361774921417,
-0.18847176432609558,
-0.00555749237537384,
-0.7606981992721558,
0.767413318157196,
-0.1346365362405777,
0.896207332611084,
0.472198486328125,
-0.3660827875137329,
0.022911155596375465,
-0.7626764178276062,
0.41770267486572266,
-0.9261995553970337,
0.2996535003185272,
0.030489744618535042,
0.11488033086061478,
-0.06962673366069794,
-0.7543804049491882,
-0.34740397334098816,
0.05266923829913139,
-0.00015356598305515945,
-0.06606011837720871,
-0.3085390329360962,
0.5099143981933594,
0.5804395079612732,
0.4310030937194824,
-0.22590488195419312,
0.3912668228149414,
-0.4074626564979553,
-0.025417227298021317,
0.782595157623291,
0.30930086970329285,
0.13410086929798126,
-0.061276573687791824,
0.16430723667144775,
0.05044887214899063,
-0.6466200947761536,
0.30093157291412354,
0.47467929124832153,
0.4450286030769348,
0.2086920589208603,
0.6633853316307068,
-0.5926762819290161,
1.0007721185684204,
0.3351103663444519,
0.3786202073097229,
-0.05553055554628372,
-0.318103551864624,
-0.5286281108856201,
-0.23783457279205322,
0.5735319256782532,
0.8238095045089722,
0.24479183554649353,
-0.19372309744358063,
-0.4325391948223114,
0.076455257833004,
0.29408377408981323,
-0.7089146971702576,
-0.44941049814224243,
-0.10586348921060562,
-0.5922064185142517,
-0.5154165029525757,
-0.05208621919155121,
-0.5477592945098877,
-0.22578634321689606,
-0.6201268434524536,
0.7040830850601196,
-0.13202811777591705,
0.3255184590816498,
0.4678348898887634,
-0.6070696711540222,
-0.2709271311759949,
0.7271355390548706,
-0.89070725440979,
0.16493664681911469,
0.6804020404815674,
0.8042006492614746,
0.00719046825543046,
-0.31090301275253296,
-0.5558254718780518,
-0.21529275178909302,
-0.6153263449668884,
0.8917976021766663,
-0.8025986552238464,
-0.35341838002204895,
-0.45424097776412964,
-0.15985572338104248,
-0.10691813379526138,
-0.5438979268074036,
0.5569538474082947,
-0.5113940238952637,
-0.18968747556209564,
-0.609117329120636,
-0.6804506778717041,
-0.09678501635789871,
-0.1545080840587616,
-0.5418878793716431,
0.8275520205497742,
-0.054344162344932556,
-0.6212446093559265,
0.6669520139694214,
-0.5363177061080933,
-0.3268779516220093,
-0.4960584342479706,
0.07528027147054672,
-0.5907565951347351,
0.5872469544410706,
0.39599597454071045,
0.37812501192092896,
0.012211577035486698,
0.12517531216144562,
-0.6386087536811829,
-0.6587371230125427,
0.06529711186885834,
-0.11540646106004715,
0.36831051111221313,
0.23735374212265015,
-0.03839652240276337,
0.2353157252073288,
-0.9354093074798584,
-0.09582412242889404,
-0.28359082341194153,
-0.255755752325058,
-0.4426363408565521,
0.020898278802633286,
-0.1683657020330429,
0.10535550117492676,
0.14478497207164764,
-0.4967927634716034,
0.547590970993042,
-0.4098517894744873,
0.400003582239151,
0.6864032745361328,
0.38102903962135315,
0.6954842209815979,
-0.580236554145813,
0.24876095354557037,
-0.09782947599887848,
0.18489034473896027,
0.3223380446434021,
-0.4593631327152252,
-0.7995979189872742,
-0.33085232973098755,
0.9316417574882507,
0.38189563155174255,
-0.37070754170417786,
0.0030403812415897846,
0.039585452526807785,
-0.6352050304412842,
-0.745437502861023,
0.4073849618434906,
0.25680941343307495,
0.5774956941604614,
0.5328741669654846,
-0.14048981666564941,
-0.6149035692214966,
-1.3218629360198975,
-0.8128924369812012,
0.5375375747680664,
-0.19371353089809418,
0.23257049918174744,
0.33821648359298706,
-0.013611779548227787,
0.882131814956665,
-0.4843209385871887,
-0.0045119901187717915,
-0.19263418018817902,
0.27728530764579773,
0.19020485877990723,
0.7014188170433044,
0.9021627306938171,
-0.596182107925415,
-0.556681752204895,
-0.10296539962291718,
-0.4687806963920593,
-0.21152229607105255,
-0.34377044439315796,
-0.2136094868183136,
-0.08985769003629684,
0.5988785028457642,
-0.6757405400276184,
0.6033457517623901,
0.1510576456785202,
-0.12087070941925049,
0.40438517928123474,
-0.43713197112083435,
0.47685566544532776,
-0.5815405249595642,
-0.038587138056755066,
-0.033966999500989914,
-0.2282666265964508,
-0.6922870874404907,
0.2117498815059662,
0.2656460702419281,
-0.14392994344234467,
-0.4417576491832733,
0.3643314242362976,
-0.21398243308067322,
0.04299059137701988,
-0.2923915684223175,
0.008956789039075375,
-0.00910367164760828,
0.5139912962913513,
0.19755321741104126,
0.627472460269928,
0.32010653614997864,
-0.7140036225318909,
-0.07304645329713821,
0.27336323261260986,
-0.5125378966331482,
0.4323314130306244,
-1.0032758712768555,
0.4976159930229187,
-0.23460310697555542,
-0.05816425383090973,
-0.4934520721435547,
-0.18699808418750763,
-0.09088455885648727,
-0.08159229159355164,
0.1359090656042099,
-0.3176153898239136,
-0.45849597454071045,
0.13326893746852875,
-0.30348917841911316,
0.060375384986400604,
0.4481304883956909,
-0.4542746841907501,
0.1995924562215805,
-0.094151072204113,
-0.12435595691204071,
-0.15567441284656525,
-0.6726806163787842,
-0.039913929998874664,
-0.10739867389202118,
-0.66472989320755,
0.47924327850341797,
-0.29273751378059387,
-0.1453387588262558,
-0.03836755454540253,
-0.24537786841392517,
-0.15257351100444794,
0.3305899500846863,
-0.043021589517593384,
0.2860136032104492,
-0.15672458708286285,
0.09393692016601562,
0.5805346965789795,
-0.08462177962064743,
-0.45732253789901733,
0.2616031765937805,
-0.26269444823265076,
0.11046597361564636,
-0.1693611890077591,
-0.6203457117080688,
0.20176826417446136,
0.5458782911300659,
-0.4185168147087097,
0.5099994540214539,
0.1707001030445099,
-0.3139515817165375,
-0.28581950068473816,
-0.41108623147010803,
-0.16925570368766785,
-0.4683619439601898,
0.4866528809070587,
-0.677882194519043,
-0.78957599401474,
0.43377310037612915,
-0.10143236070871353,
0.31213802099227905,
0.6381105184555054,
0.27944979071617126,
-0.18040406703948975,
1.3388912677764893,
0.7265602946281433,
0.3725403845310211,
0.4126366078853607,
0.048684682697057724,
-0.017516382038593292,
-0.7035031914710999,
0.317972332239151,
-0.7438289523124695,
-0.8094903826713562,
-0.6616138815879822,
-0.18533596396446228,
0.28696727752685547,
0.5766749978065491,
-0.22665786743164062,
0.3050397038459778,
-0.459349125623703,
0.8265662789344788,
0.6826695799827576,
0.44497573375701904,
0.40059226751327515,
-0.36380794644355774,
-0.005255931988358498,
-0.26227062940597534,
-0.952076256275177,
-0.6054219603538513,
1.2011773586273193,
0.13444741070270538,
0.5959509015083313,
-0.07328633219003677,
0.7816803455352783,
0.18988719582557678,
-0.03676220402121544,
-0.38565558195114136,
0.32925060391426086,
-0.7373964786529541,
-0.6116077899932861,
-0.3377077281475067,
-0.17858560383319855,
-0.2954750061035156,
0.12534314393997192,
-0.5966664552688599,
-0.5322373509407043,
0.8178372979164124,
0.5919060111045837,
-0.8484285473823547,
0.41242215037345886,
-0.6917121410369873,
1.0724385976791382,
0.35124263167381287,
-0.1148180216550827,
-0.4314148426055908,
-0.2892896831035614,
0.13321234285831451,
-0.22062243521213531,
0.1347985714673996,
0.0753534659743309,
0.0691932663321495,
0.5884003639221191,
-0.4451407492160797,
0.7456980347633362,
-0.16168025135993958,
0.5680192708969116,
0.06058590114116669,
0.2686309218406677,
0.6874819993972778,
0.33928051590919495,
-0.317752867937088,
0.09812530875205994,
0.1221022754907608,
-0.37398824095726013,
-0.9349956512451172,
0.4855523109436035,
-0.6613274812698364,
-0.6594735383987427,
0.018716013059020042,
-0.5419973731040955,
-0.34102970361709595,
0.08902782201766968,
0.6140056252479553,
0.4280606806278229,
-0.21043528616428375,
0.4546724259853363,
0.7709341645240784,
0.060444045811891556,
0.03160746768116951,
0.5878291726112366,
0.2670346796512604,
-0.14601203799247742,
0.5284770727157593,
0.2912300229072571,
0.3015253245830536,
0.2387653887271881,
0.290113240480423,
0.2845015227794647,
-0.8575313687324524,
-0.4052242040634155,
-0.15018442273139954,
-0.6407572627067566,
-0.17465074360370636,
-0.6310931444168091,
-0.16186828911304474,
-0.24951793253421783,
-0.6842438578605652,
-0.602641761302948,
-0.7917823791503906,
-0.5120968818664551,
-0.03714854270219803,
0.3472786843776703,
0.6895255446434021,
-0.5288971066474915,
0.3155645728111267,
-0.7718218564987183,
0.46237027645111084,
0.5918563604354858,
0.34341585636138916,
-0.25942039489746094,
-0.81003737449646,
-0.45234841108322144,
0.2810293734073639,
-0.22236207127571106,
-0.6244308948516846,
-0.08236590772867203,
0.5176911354064941,
0.4704532027244568,
0.11671893298625946,
0.15518084168434143,
0.9254513382911682,
-0.5071772336959839,
0.7281363010406494,
-0.2834996283054352,
-1.1156119108200073,
0.7050862908363342,
-0.3944716155529022,
0.421895295381546,
0.8370471000671387,
0.08432383090257645,
-0.40420424938201904,
-0.5258733034133911,
-0.5889612436294556,
-0.306109756231308,
0.7530784010887146,
0.030788112431764603,
0.09641940146684647,
0.1183876022696495,
0.8140149116516113,
0.1270601451396942,
0.3394332826137543,
-0.41076579689979553,
-0.14451885223388672,
-0.14805500209331512,
-0.0059493063017725945,
-0.21900631487369537,
-0.39366841316223145,
-0.04908369109034538,
-0.5949069261550903,
0.7109465599060059,
0.13047710061073303,
-0.11023945361375809,
0.37008368968963623,
-0.21141308546066284,
-0.3903280794620514,
0.3945227265357971,
0.7752429246902466,
0.6496058106422424,
-0.5797991156578064,
-0.1763342320919037,
0.4879779815673828,
-0.01165563054382801,
-0.18561787903308868,
-0.08300238102674484,
-0.6171591281890869,
0.13811402022838593,
0.3588477075099945,
1.14862859249115,
0.6952119469642639,
-0.16363081336021423,
0.1518842577934265,
0.06417118012905121,
-0.6018182635307312,
0.6856541037559509,
0.7195387482643127,
0.07198970019817352,
0.4884094297885895,
-0.16832628846168518,
0.8185119032859802,
0.4113995432853699,
-0.23623983561992645,
0.07450229674577713,
0.2560040056705475,
-0.06235682964324951,
-0.2988438904285431,
0.9137315154075623,
0.05330606922507286,
-0.38993221521377563,
0.413310170173645,
-0.1950279027223587,
-0.14021950960159302,
0.5233240127563477,
0.06493694335222244,
0.7464407682418823,
0.05800651013851166,
-0.08641631156206131,
0.4891608953475952,
0.2620526850223541,
-0.30830806493759155,
0.08024203777313232,
-0.022203821688890457,
-0.5660198926925659,
-0.2101510465145111,
-0.4465004503726959,
-0.44099998474121094,
0.1308038830757141,
-0.815115749835968,
0.7399905323982239,
-0.7164578437805176,
-0.17510314285755157,
0.4972236752510071,
-0.25152379274368286,
-0.8835514783859253,
0.41435685753822327,
-0.18800309300422668,
1.131164789199829,
-0.7674959301948547,
0.7855496406555176,
0.8663651347160339,
-0.30436041951179504,
-0.48454588651657104,
-0.35712841153144836,
0.03412668779492378,
-0.1447010636329651,
0.3216223120689392,
-0.17032787203788757,
0.25450780987739563,
-0.03610004484653473,
-0.5320953726768494,
-0.6843623518943787,
0.7318133115768433,
0.5271233320236206,
-1.1016169786453247,
-0.3202133774757385,
-0.1653006225824356,
0.6998248100280762,
-0.22348308563232422,
-0.1176549643278122,
0.6316339373588562,
0.29433009028434753,
-0.18923313915729523,
-0.9794902801513672,
-0.2837833762168884,
-0.08869310468435287,
0.16668829321861267,
0.09809747338294983,
-0.6161870360374451,
0.9950154423713684,
-0.138764888048172,
0.07856663316488266,
0.17169399559497833,
0.5330178737640381,
-0.20067723095417023,
0.2572370767593384,
0.4221607744693756,
0.7583410739898682,
0.6775794625282288,
0.13598968088626862,
0.6988680958747864,
-0.33419498801231384,
0.43492990732192993,
1.5415946245193481,
0.02709238976240158,
0.8418937921524048,
0.0836896076798439,
-0.0348367765545845,
0.21706430613994598,
0.7513011693954468,
-0.2325551062822342,
0.7283499240875244,
-0.3390341103076935,
-0.09853068739175797,
-0.7884649038314819,
0.5089055299758911,
-0.23820899426937103,
0.5354216694831848,
0.0013996250927448273,
-0.4301113486289978,
-0.40852442383766174,
-0.02645045891404152,
-0.10185886174440384,
0.3563051223754883,
-0.5618373155593872,
0.690105676651001,
0.08739244192838669,
-0.4290851354598999,
0.3243127465248108,
0.3555164337158203,
0.49167773127555847,
-0.39615434408187866,
-0.06625908613204956,
-0.11854436993598938,
0.05374694615602493,
-0.20292231440544128,
-0.4749692976474762,
0.47779834270477295,
0.23782788217067719,
-0.5316849946975708,
-0.09149245917797089,
0.6295183300971985,
-0.17039918899536133,
-0.5092164278030396,
-0.18356525897979736,
0.21520699560642242,
-0.24223056435585022,
-0.28373533487319946,
-0.7384586930274963,
-0.12448711693286896,
0.037106022238731384,
-0.3917342722415924,
0.453250914812088,
0.4642180800437927,
-0.014849320985376835,
0.2928193211555481,
0.7089464068412781,
0.16544947028160095,
-0.28351178765296936,
-0.047494739294052124,
0.7274807691574097,
-0.6384116411209106,
-0.6848766207695007,
-0.8232247233390808,
0.6378518342971802,
-0.13236580789089203,
-0.568030595779419,
0.6458741426467896,
0.4516938328742981,
0.8430863618850708,
-0.22823956608772278,
0.7242638468742371,
0.2768400013446808,
0.5912368893623352,
-0.7774930596351624,
0.6873202323913574,
-0.5854853987693787,
0.07408152520656586,
-0.30120331048965454,
-0.8253233432769775,
-0.30195125937461853,
0.4766457974910736,
-0.6041069626808167,
-0.16589297354221344,
0.4459344744682312,
0.9629759192466736,
-0.3458162248134613,
0.09139419347047806,
0.48993295431137085,
0.1963203400373459,
-0.016582002863287926,
0.3103537857532501,
0.272085040807724,
-0.4158199727535248,
0.09376799315214157,
-0.6469786167144775,
-0.1258411854505539,
-0.18356026709079742,
-0.881401777267456,
-1.1808781623840332,
-0.26446616649627686,
-0.43219229578971863,
0.07183901965618134,
0.49122095108032227,
0.895909309387207,
0.6368620991706848,
-0.7937254309654236,
0.25744378566741943,
-0.03170387074351311,
0.08029065281152725,
-0.391040563583374,
-0.06846779584884644,
0.3082629442214966,
-0.43442630767822266,
-0.8444991111755371,
0.5496528148651123,
0.18895263969898224,
0.03695886954665184,
0.4344483017921448,
0.1034640520811081,
-0.10064809769392014,
0.4925173819065094,
0.3088381290435791,
0.20899628102779388,
-0.44638946652412415,
-0.40273135900497437,
-0.19361744821071625,
-0.10409914702177048,
0.14900314807891846,
0.746547281742096,
-0.4873555898666382,
0.6986736059188843,
0.4617019593715668,
0.4410930275917053,
0.5145552754402161,
0.1389601081609726,
0.6914379000663757,
-0.5741215944290161,
0.2677365243434906,
-0.014455165714025497,
0.2816466987133026,
0.0458776131272316,
-0.49100297689437866,
0.28275278210639954,
0.3250952363014221,
-0.7086635231971741,
-0.8324730396270752,
0.0182719137519598,
-0.6523999571800232,
-0.4926961064338684,
0.7672656774520874,
0.017553316429257393,
-0.09022840112447739,
0.14228864014148712,
-0.38463935256004333,
0.3750841021537781,
-0.2040630578994751,
0.9042421579360962,
0.7592772841453552,
-0.3539108335971832,
-0.02177031897008419,
-0.6731644868850708,
0.8813591003417969,
0.45797672867774963,
-0.33023127913475037,
-0.06074408069252968,
0.5746979117393494,
0.5959951281547546,
-0.3860918879508972,
0.37097734212875366,
0.24194099009037018,
0.9743068218231201,
0.09325207024812698,
-0.10304147750139236,
-0.48927998542785645,
-0.23086225986480713,
-0.5927175283432007,
-0.08354759961366653,
0.3137736916542053,
0.0921260192990303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11073v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11073v3 | AFaCTA: Assisting the Annotation of Factual Claim Detection with Reliable LLM Annotators | 2024-02-16T20:59:57 | 2024-06-02T18:35:25 | Jingwei Ni, Minjing Shi, Dominik Stammbach, Mrinmaya Sachan, Elliott Ash, Markus Leippold | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the rise of generative AI, automated fact-checking methods to combat
misinformation are becoming more and more important. However, factual claim
detection, the first step in a fact-checking pipeline, suffers from two key
issues that limit its scalability and generalizability: (1) inconsistency in
definitions of the task and what a claim is, and (2) the high cost of manual
annotation. To address (1), we review the definitions in related work and
propose a unifying definition of factual claims that focuses on verifiability.
To address (2), we introduce AFaCTA (Automatic Factual Claim deTection
Annotator), a novel framework that assists in the annotation of factual claims
with the help of large language models (LLMs). AFaCTA calibrates its annotation
confidence with consistency along three predefined reasoning paths. Extensive
evaluation and experiments in the domain of political speech reveal that AFaCTA
can efficiently assist experts in annotating factual claims and training
high-quality classifiers, and can work with or without expert supervision. Our
analyses also result in PoliClaim, a comprehensive claim detection dataset
spanning diverse political topics. | [
-0.2213635891675949,
-0.8332593441009521,
0.7332548499107361,
0.22439050674438477,
-0.20429731905460358,
0.16966596245765686,
-0.1446269303560257,
-0.5014742612838745,
0.3385874629020691,
0.5310534834861755,
-0.09504018723964691,
-0.32639697194099426,
-0.9081330895423889,
0.1828775554895401,
-0.34656041860580444,
0.8100813031196594,
-0.0645187497138977,
-0.21457049250602722,
-0.47117581963539124,
-0.48277193307876587,
-0.3356497287750244,
-0.5181994438171387,
-0.5725564360618591,
-0.18108130991458893,
0.2961994707584381,
0.4161766767501831,
0.770205020904541,
0.7349781394004822,
0.3374782204627991,
0.4130490720272064,
0.05846073105931282,
0.4841848909854889,
0.050579946488142014,
0.21023094654083252,
-0.09136851876974106,
-0.7189728021621704,
-0.2716723680496216,
0.2530975937843323,
0.6134028434753418,
0.36544936895370483,
-0.15515859425067902,
0.26821768283843994,
-0.5969953536987305,
0.4281917214393616,
-0.760593593120575,
0.4701312482357025,
-0.8768961429595947,
-0.08456117659807205,
-0.425504207611084,
0.02374003455042839,
-0.38255080580711365,
-0.511335551738739,
-0.05062360689043999,
-0.4432610273361206,
0.35078203678131104,
0.10676763951778412,
0.9081358909606934,
0.6323336362838745,
-0.4968082308769226,
-0.5121250748634338,
-0.6213589310646057,
0.17671515047550201,
-0.6284633278846741,
0.25280526280403137,
0.3361567556858063,
0.27925464510917664,
0.04614318162202835,
-0.7572858929634094,
-0.987252414226532,
-0.34262287616729736,
-0.26284587383270264,
-0.16264455020427704,
-0.17149269580841064,
0.15986616909503937,
0.49720025062561035,
0.5189692378044128,
-0.1701008826494217,
-0.08904677629470825,
-0.2965696156024933,
-0.7413554787635803,
0.7039008736610413,
-0.329370379447937,
0.3749864101409912,
-0.21491362154483795,
-0.4122775197029114,
0.1651618629693985,
-0.8251785635948181,
-0.07032452523708344,
0.4037146270275116,
0.28319934010505676,
-0.09386172145605087,
0.5821030735969543,
-0.3266795575618744,
0.5469202399253845,
0.03432348370552063,
-0.1286485344171524,
0.12184276431798935,
-0.2592220902442932,
-0.39634767174720764,
0.2138429582118988,
0.685492992401123,
-0.15774910151958466,
0.0397430956363678,
-0.10544953495264053,
-0.15411312878131866,
0.375389039516449,
0.08580759167671204,
-0.6622393727302551,
-0.3353225588798523,
0.2756519019603729,
-0.22179333865642548,
-0.2680465579032898,
0.25254178047180176,
-0.5199999809265137,
-0.6651008725166321,
-0.5126200914382935,
0.43061867356300354,
-0.12713831663131714,
-0.31102436780929565,
-0.14343595504760742,
0.112175352871418,
-0.08205843716859818,
0.5096637010574341,
-0.4598902463912964,
0.08283689618110657,
0.7246465682983398,
0.7931531667709351,
0.11524578928947449,
0.01666445843875408,
-0.8840628266334534,
-0.11894415318965912,
-0.502454400062561,
1.168452262878418,
-0.4632534980773926,
0.1148938536643982,
0.2780539095401764,
0.07172098010778427,
0.09853143990039825,
-0.5043978095054626,
0.7766720056533813,
-0.5018228888511658,
0.08052758872509003,
-0.4504472315311432,
-0.6308228969573975,
-0.45769527554512024,
0.39384931325912476,
-0.8406696319580078,
0.742612898349762,
-0.19307713210582733,
-0.5126446485519409,
0.8196150064468384,
-0.49535661935806274,
-0.48502376675605774,
0.12031382322311401,
-0.42254191637039185,
-0.4264906942844391,
0.15857136249542236,
0.018556073307991028,
0.3410830497741699,
-0.21424971520900726,
0.4959639310836792,
-0.05172812193632126,
0.06444588303565979,
0.40160825848579407,
-0.47977447509765625,
0.902134895324707,
-0.025609618052840233,
-0.5278328657150269,
0.13753899931907654,
-0.8629912734031677,
-0.4408518373966217,
-0.0935339704155922,
-0.4342065453529358,
-0.16514691710472107,
0.1538666933774948,
-0.18284636735916138,
0.12256012111902237,
0.23305530846118927,
-0.7738944292068481,
0.2630721628665924,
-0.11226090788841248,
0.07921456545591354,
0.7836739420890808,
-0.12933260202407837,
-0.04287349060177803,
-0.3679784834384918,
0.16073061525821686,
-0.044039931148290634,
-0.10071741789579391,
-0.28722405433654785,
-0.4951886534690857,
-0.9541229009628296,
-0.6689574122428894,
0.7619576454162598,
0.8178279399871826,
-0.6242015361785889,
0.26826968789100647,
-0.06731763482093811,
-0.22176387906074524,
-0.4798121750354767,
0.20368415117263794,
0.14340424537658691,
0.5745548605918884,
0.3689354956150055,
-0.05320461466908455,
-0.6366006135940552,
-0.822424054145813,
-0.4149135947227478,
-0.6592521071434021,
-0.03729880601167679,
-0.0035722756292670965,
0.49108174443244934,
-0.09491095691919327,
1.0714523792266846,
-0.19051551818847656,
-0.4918895661830902,
0.1592491865158081,
0.4689346253871918,
-0.016577625647187233,
0.10504848510026932,
0.47606155276298523,
-1.009325385093689,
-0.3938336968421936,
-0.14155802130699158,
-0.682158350944519,
-0.30396705865859985,
-0.41810423135757446,
0.26936694979667664,
0.5695753693580627,
0.4148499071598053,
-0.9068421125411987,
0.49418431520462036,
0.24889850616455078,
-0.500558078289032,
0.30876728892326355,
-0.08740703016519547,
0.31505802273750305,
-0.6706780195236206,
-0.03130365163087845,
-0.0009291601600125432,
-0.5256893634796143,
-0.472906231880188,
-0.21080751717090607,
-0.04985935986042023,
0.2970176935195923,
-0.2451256513595581,
0.3781895041465759,
-0.254645437002182,
0.17039762437343597,
-0.4444209337234497,
0.16337049007415771,
-0.10397402197122574,
0.18736056983470917,
-0.06822417676448822,
0.6579650044441223,
0.50423264503479,
-0.49860310554504395,
0.3408186435699463,
0.39299505949020386,
-0.04641244187951088,
0.7165396213531494,
-0.415968656539917,
0.06631326675415039,
0.02163587138056755,
0.36646655201911926,
-1.2055761814117432,
-0.38699108362197876,
0.45344239473342896,
-0.4385607838630676,
0.29427164793014526,
-0.31943824887275696,
-0.7825207114219666,
-0.025225333869457245,
-0.09411412477493286,
-0.02827012911438942,
0.08331102132797241,
-0.7674077749252319,
1.0287984609603882,
0.6546313166618347,
-0.19473975896835327,
-0.6445837020874023,
-0.5843357443809509,
0.2811587154865265,
-0.03772512450814247,
-0.3975389003753662,
0.16733431816101074,
0.3453475832939148,
-0.633383572101593,
0.062462616711854935,
-0.2764613926410675,
-0.12170187383890152,
0.0617637075483799,
0.449808269739151,
0.30815380811691284,
-0.20557290315628052,
0.24265232682228088,
-0.05993179604411125,
-0.16456714272499084,
0.352979838848114,
0.07159382849931717,
-0.03772784024477005,
-0.10386170446872711,
-0.5160025954246521,
-0.5940024256706238,
0.19415970146656036,
0.668205201625824,
-0.2677055299282074,
0.6987385153770447,
0.42919808626174927,
-0.5676522254943848,
-0.04269629716873169,
-1.0196170806884766,
0.17136795818805695,
-0.41313865780830383,
-0.13793963193893433,
-0.007802451495081186,
-0.704584002494812,
0.5728791356086731,
-0.291592001914978,
0.4305999279022217,
0.7648600935935974,
0.4625365734100342,
0.1376660019159317,
0.5376935601234436,
0.5864869356155396,
-0.08556593954563141,
0.08604677021503448,
0.022934135049581528,
0.21910147368907928,
-0.22840259969234467,
-0.1352587193250656,
-0.5711891055107117,
-0.05664822831749916,
-0.5658989548683167,
-0.5609958171844482,
-0.033264968544244766,
-0.34971997141838074,
-0.21723537147045135,
-0.10338475555181503,
-0.33281776309013367,
0.40618860721588135,
0.3483715057373047,
-0.1579863429069519,
0.541320264339447,
-0.003917496185749769,
0.3439200520515442,
0.1690479964017868,
-0.4166123867034912,
-0.5829513669013977,
1.0329735279083252,
0.4425680935382843,
0.22947560250759125,
0.30336326360702515,
0.37937960028648376,
0.7489111423492432,
1.001711130142212,
-0.7548166513442993,
0.43350130319595337,
-0.2149602770805359,
-0.8633251786231995,
-0.10461793094873428,
-0.2339220643043518,
-0.1646135002374649,
0.3757637143135071,
-0.6008851528167725,
-0.5103839635848999,
0.39583322405815125,
0.4022475481033325,
-0.403953492641449,
0.5815645456314087,
-0.3542724549770355,
0.5569698214530945,
-0.1695321798324585,
-0.21083594858646393,
-0.20178738236427307,
-0.5121443271636963,
0.5115850567817688,
0.05060616135597229,
0.1399252861738205,
-0.3235168755054474,
-0.019720731303095818,
0.6880964636802673,
-0.42278891801834106,
1.0699659585952759,
-0.5391786098480225,
0.01645529642701149,
0.6098163723945618,
-0.05282488465309143,
0.5112787485122681,
0.25166502594947815,
0.12103379517793655,
0.2592487633228302,
-0.05095392465591431,
-0.2005813866853714,
-0.3874991834163666,
0.14390771090984344,
-0.3603011965751648,
-0.755355715751648,
-0.8648615479469299,
-0.3867577314376831,
-0.11236129701137543,
0.018052950501441956,
-0.0034764697775244713,
0.368801474571228,
-0.36527371406555176,
0.29119154810905457,
0.9124670624732971,
0.07218092679977417,
0.07893914729356766,
0.5179890990257263,
-0.07902014255523682,
-0.5326305031776428,
0.8358855843544006,
0.23278029263019562,
-0.05922887474298477,
0.24830801784992218,
0.05795902758836746,
-0.4829806089401245,
-0.5333291292190552,
-0.40470996499061584,
0.19990341365337372,
-0.7678229808807373,
-0.6033205986022949,
-0.7348141074180603,
-0.03690045326948166,
-0.21214477717876434,
0.04479510709643364,
-0.4401116967201233,
-0.6751384735107422,
-0.08784079551696777,
-0.38175898790359497,
0.598171591758728,
0.5680947303771973,
-0.4244457483291626,
0.3095768392086029,
-0.25981512665748596,
0.7360595464706421,
0.4667440354824066,
0.11118531227111816,
-0.6276780366897583,
-0.3508446216583252,
0.11566707491874695,
0.031479738652706146,
-0.18934866786003113,
-0.6799865365028381,
-0.13047800958156586,
0.30349066853523254,
0.4982379376888275,
0.49371299147605896,
0.1226816177368164,
0.2155134081840515,
-0.4848332703113556,
0.7552924156188965,
-0.0432596281170845,
-0.9379414916038513,
0.44835424423217773,
0.03313154727220535,
-0.4393751323223114,
0.7959038615226746,
0.34009790420532227,
-0.19770662486553192,
-0.403677374124527,
-0.7467436194419861,
-0.7246818542480469,
0.23945152759552002,
0.02994040958583355,
0.0541536808013916,
-0.1568199098110199,
0.464860200881958,
0.1432679444551468,
0.18583576381206512,
-0.5442025661468506,
-0.3650782108306885,
-0.2646488845348358,
-0.2618526518344879,
0.22762428224086761,
-0.45844388008117676,
-0.7132828831672668,
0.192937970161438,
0.7628099918365479,
-0.4696395695209503,
0.09732122719287872,
0.4643019437789917,
-0.30050915479660034,
-0.04829596355557442,
0.1733306348323822,
0.5414746999740601,
0.7444748878479004,
0.0123616773635149,
0.17086969316005707,
0.21319669485092163,
-0.40353086590766907,
0.2976246178150177,
0.5118200778961182,
-0.41838955879211426,
0.3751986622810364,
0.536793053150177,
0.6928538680076599,
-0.11164049059152603,
-0.39934366941452026,
0.6468597054481506,
0.01790723018348217,
-0.05241983011364937,
-0.5526513457298279,
0.01877325214445591,
-0.12474881857633591,
0.28811824321746826,
0.6386032104492188,
0.27957451343536377,
0.0932437852025032,
-0.6596754193305969,
0.49379387497901917,
0.5638143420219421,
-0.037552375346422195,
-0.20643232762813568,
0.6687220931053162,
0.27770352363586426,
-0.2143411487340927,
0.2865367829799652,
-0.15092264115810394,
-0.7289842963218689,
0.7388449311256409,
0.22909371554851532,
0.806829571723938,
-0.284198522567749,
0.48111656308174133,
0.17015187442302704,
0.5745020508766174,
-0.24043099582195282,
0.016993148252367973,
-0.003868031082674861,
-0.7129026651382446,
-0.5862342119216919,
-0.3101966381072998,
-0.7556812167167664,
-0.021458284929394722,
-0.25105056166648865,
0.05792349576950073,
-0.7171039581298828,
-0.16359323263168335,
0.13417135179042816,
0.2958941161632538,
-0.4818110764026642,
0.27193719148635864,
0.4157078266143799,
1.0969947576522827,
-1.105677604675293,
0.412289559841156,
0.5949496626853943,
-0.5225563645362854,
-0.5430921912193298,
0.1771765798330307,
0.4545745253562927,
-0.5594614744186401,
0.5728093981742859,
0.21990960836410522,
-0.19862240552902222,
-0.4523574709892273,
-0.7743368744850159,
-0.4971792697906494,
1.0760537385940552,
0.6957980394363403,
-0.2433994561433792,
0.2529306411743164,
0.18971844017505646,
0.3307304084300995,
-0.4588407874107361,
-0.0830366462469101,
0.4170614778995514,
0.698860228061676,
0.17541351914405823,
-0.6274689435958862,
0.34767886996269226,
0.25910863280296326,
-0.4691488444805145,
-0.09046574681997299,
-0.8797286152839661,
0.6617224812507629,
-0.15674756467342377,
-0.3569893538951874,
-0.06512589752674103,
1.2416703701019287,
0.3456782102584839,
0.591032862663269,
0.8708568811416626,
0.5289686918258667,
1.2281588315963745,
-0.3034657835960388,
0.8978452682495117,
-0.20173682272434235,
0.17634299397468567,
1.0118943452835083,
-0.18624357879161835,
0.5797688961029053,
0.22949156165122986,
-0.1324278563261032,
0.45294666290283203,
0.4979398846626282,
-0.06576535850763321,
0.03942336142063141,
0.024034207686781883,
-0.4946006238460541,
-0.4115581512451172,
-0.17872174084186554,
-0.07637649774551392,
0.5389434099197388,
0.6014814376831055,
-0.05885658413171768,
-0.07224172353744507,
-0.27431005239486694,
0.3297511041164398,
0.17890679836273193,
-0.1962709128856659,
0.4944474697113037,
-0.16210472583770752,
-0.611344575881958,
0.22791361808776855,
-0.24067258834838867,
0.4364857077598572,
-0.47024574875831604,
-0.3716025650501251,
-0.3165853023529053,
-0.031257614493370056,
-0.3990497589111328,
-0.5468074679374695,
0.46432140469551086,
0.03910909593105316,
-0.1760440617799759,
0.09237605333328247,
0.8493200540542603,
-0.47747161984443665,
-0.39248302578926086,
-0.09352882951498032,
0.3992319405078888,
-0.15544724464416504,
-0.1796570122241974,
-0.6134862899780273,
0.23993994295597076,
-0.12960323691368103,
-0.18209922313690186,
-0.10583692789077759,
0.6327075362205505,
0.04614446684718132,
0.6837046146392822,
0.8138782382011414,
0.1275343894958496,
-0.14674587547779083,
-0.3151937425136566,
0.7271712422370911,
-0.2792726457118988,
-0.2277435064315796,
-0.7235454320907593,
0.5489654541015625,
-0.23782309889793396,
-0.06997667253017426,
0.519756555557251,
0.47865137457847595,
0.4289442300796509,
0.2405063956975937,
0.8961108922958374,
-0.39752811193466187,
0.5302647948265076,
-0.6949713230133057,
0.676557719707489,
-0.2809421420097351,
0.07396984100341797,
0.14819934964179993,
-0.6524130702018738,
-0.5744344592094421,
0.7583942413330078,
-0.07936178892850876,
-0.3138183057308197,
0.5146040916442871,
0.5845763087272644,
-0.16109314560890198,
0.006469549145549536,
0.027552664279937744,
0.4908594787120819,
0.49901604652404785,
-0.09627346694469452,
0.5885633826255798,
-0.2970212996006012,
0.3162468671798706,
-0.2049262374639511,
-0.20942211151123047,
-0.2266000509262085,
-1.0981696844100952,
-0.7237949371337891,
-0.5707924962043762,
-0.8380036354064941,
-0.5073533654212952,
-0.11745771020650864,
0.7918059825897217,
0.6347844004631042,
-1.1092443466186523,
0.18317583203315735,
0.08358097821474075,
0.3498234152793884,
-0.017357131466269493,
-0.21595124900341034,
0.4657178223133087,
-0.4328083395957947,
-0.5913590788841248,
0.3205154836177826,
0.2505566477775574,
-0.18417584896087646,
-0.35129019618034363,
0.3166765570640564,
-0.6212474703788757,
0.5780168771743774,
0.44500672817230225,
0.8579038381576538,
-0.7501839399337769,
-0.6862003803253174,
-0.6004932522773743,
0.12839210033416748,
0.11067723482847214,
0.8197158575057983,
-0.8004733920097351,
0.36594024300575256,
0.3102584183216095,
1.0955257415771484,
0.20993749797344208,
0.20248547196388245,
0.365134060382843,
-0.6630311608314514,
0.25630003213882446,
0.048761676996946335,
0.5128101110458374,
0.6302989721298218,
-0.49124979972839355,
0.7385618090629578,
0.48218822479248047,
-0.5047991871833801,
-1.023283839225769,
0.15560367703437805,
-0.9519131779670715,
0.11931543052196503,
0.9073429107666016,
-0.4181647002696991,
-0.2737154960632324,
-0.19499196112155914,
-0.10114935785531998,
0.24799935519695282,
-0.15198194980621338,
0.8580799698829651,
0.8749374151229858,
-0.10820270329713821,
0.0341554693877697,
-0.6804916262626648,
0.729414165019989,
0.17265255749225616,
-0.7424360513687134,
0.2906370162963867,
0.8097752928733826,
0.38715946674346924,
0.6849813461303711,
0.7316677570343018,
0.10884910821914673,
0.3007878065109253,
0.043694838881492615,
-0.08602575212717056,
-0.11855498701334,
-0.4594539999961853,
-0.13167795538902283,
0.29783380031585693,
-0.08501381427049637,
-0.36330434679985046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11068v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11068v1 | Bridging Causal Discovery and Large Language Models: A Comprehensive Survey of Integrative Approaches and Future Directions | 2024-02-16T20:48:53 | 2024-02-16T20:48:53 | Guangya Wan, Yuqi Wu, Mengxuan Hu, Zhixuan Chu, Sheng Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Causal discovery (CD) and Large Language Models (LLMs) represent two emerging
fields of study with significant implications for artificial intelligence.
Despite their distinct origins, CD focuses on uncovering cause-effect
relationships from data, and LLMs on processing and generating humanlike text,
the convergence of these domains offers novel insights and methodologies for
understanding complex systems. This paper presents a comprehensive survey of
the integration of LLMs, such as GPT4, into CD tasks. We systematically review
and compare existing approaches that leverage LLMs for various CD tasks and
highlight their innovative use of metadata and natural language to infer causal
structures. Our analysis reveals the strengths and potential of LLMs in both
enhancing traditional CD methods and as an imperfect expert, alongside the
challenges and limitations inherent in current practices. Furthermore, we
identify gaps in the literature and propose future research directions aimed at
harnessing the full potential of LLMs in causality research. To our knowledge,
this is the first survey to offer a unified and detailed examination of the
synergy between LLMs and CD, setting the stage for future advancements in the
field. | [
-0.3836973011493683,
-1.0458381175994873,
1.0645402669906616,
0.24423706531524658,
0.19205600023269653,
0.18837128579616547,
-0.5013953447341919,
-0.7774534225463867,
0.01317621860653162,
0.40064170956611633,
-0.5842240452766418,
-0.4763535261154175,
-0.8824201226234436,
0.15758848190307617,
-0.49271970987319946,
0.7314971685409546,
-0.07490091025829315,
0.10402444750070572,
-0.4829021096229553,
0.04497469589114189,
-0.7020747065544128,
-0.6039661169052124,
-0.6383437514305115,
-0.578681468963623,
0.7511169910430908,
0.19563981890678406,
0.6057384610176086,
0.37525475025177,
0.6361182928085327,
0.36604925990104675,
0.0005697775632143021,
0.3240426182746887,
-0.30382102727890015,
0.07525776326656342,
-0.44680508971214294,
-0.3571191430091858,
-0.32463884353637695,
0.0162956640124321,
0.6548691987991333,
0.9607599377632141,
0.08194874972105026,
-0.047014135867357254,
0.08984142541885376,
0.38609981536865234,
-0.5348257422447205,
0.32901161909103394,
-0.4251045882701874,
-0.10008266568183899,
-0.39458486437797546,
-0.4030115306377411,
-0.2710809111595154,
-0.34675776958465576,
0.20267482101917267,
-0.4499988257884979,
0.21631519496440887,
-0.0636005848646164,
0.3723577857017517,
0.5081338286399841,
-0.9632883667945862,
-0.6427571773529053,
-1.1690574884414673,
0.9563295245170593,
-0.876266360282898,
0.2634190022945404,
0.16864638030529022,
0.18728496134281158,
-0.6201443076133728,
-0.8410676717758179,
-0.7409544587135315,
-0.2635326385498047,
-0.14147917926311493,
0.041194286197423935,
-0.24009251594543457,
0.10809426009654999,
0.17038483917713165,
0.19127324223518372,
-0.4654788374900818,
0.6602076888084412,
-0.04724269360303879,
-0.30798274278640747,
0.7271488308906555,
0.40689826011657715,
0.5954200625419617,
0.20089899003505707,
-0.3013492226600647,
0.3221471607685089,
-1.0524204969406128,
-0.3025768995285034,
0.31531664729118347,
0.3094885051250458,
-0.15541240572929382,
0.5092792510986328,
0.016673710197210312,
0.791282057762146,
-0.3067726194858551,
-0.14775538444519043,
-0.19227057695388794,
-0.7970014810562134,
-0.16545113921165466,
0.09425132721662521,
0.8935049176216125,
-0.11289113014936447,
-0.08446169644594193,
-0.4314911365509033,
-0.024637019261717796,
0.03351409360766411,
-0.00564577616751194,
-0.4176734685897827,
-0.064576156437397,
0.1857333481311798,
-0.24868981540203094,
0.002265464747324586,
0.018369236961007118,
-0.5215408802032471,
-0.6128105521202087,
-0.9395276308059692,
0.26489800214767456,
-0.22233468294143677,
-0.30008286237716675,
0.2076118439435959,
0.05555744469165802,
0.3061676025390625,
0.4552442133426666,
-0.6452622413635254,
0.2525479793548584,
0.8976390957832336,
0.6304140090942383,
-0.0798301249742508,
-0.3632410764694214,
-0.4854187071323395,
0.3932971656322479,
-0.27426430583000183,
0.8873658180236816,
-0.4030437469482422,
-0.12655574083328247,
0.33948877453804016,
0.056041181087493896,
0.0010552644962444901,
-0.4005100727081299,
0.9405458569526672,
-0.6843138337135315,
0.17012065649032593,
-0.5119143724441528,
-0.6484339237213135,
-0.4067557156085968,
0.15990757942199707,
-0.7472137212753296,
0.8308539390563965,
-0.2718755304813385,
-0.8105247616767883,
0.3845086097717285,
-0.5130733251571655,
-0.614981472492218,
0.035386327654123306,
-0.30298444628715515,
-0.31898146867752075,
-0.056021548807621,
-0.12715445458889008,
0.6661521792411804,
-1.0054296255111694,
1.0108522176742554,
-0.49348872900009155,
-0.19294238090515137,
0.12858419120311737,
-0.4661620855331421,
0.6845061779022217,
-0.054163750261068344,
-0.667669415473938,
0.21961025893688202,
-0.6489856839179993,
-0.4179340898990631,
0.09876390546560287,
-0.29327479004859924,
-0.3938528597354889,
0.538022518157959,
-0.049834951758384705,
0.39684221148490906,
0.3956693708896637,
-0.32135793566703796,
0.25396060943603516,
-0.11128116399049759,
0.41871702671051025,
0.7215005159378052,
-0.1243337020277977,
0.5204760432243347,
-0.039209455251693726,
0.19819018244743347,
0.1431310474872589,
0.10834577679634094,
-0.07039503008127213,
-0.34559300541877747,
-0.5234211683273315,
-0.027149133384227753,
-0.051488883793354034,
0.45367443561553955,
-0.7525372505187988,
0.5602682828903198,
-0.23338966071605682,
-0.45902618765830994,
-0.12192002683877945,
0.1399553418159485,
0.3004078269004822,
0.41565072536468506,
0.3544013202190399,
-0.07525218278169632,
-0.5074582695960999,
-0.8594881296157837,
-0.36404183506965637,
-0.1564452201128006,
0.03736518323421478,
0.3100503087043762,
0.3995048701763153,
-0.48430681228637695,
0.9928644299507141,
-0.4094277322292328,
-0.3208996653556824,
-0.21388736367225647,
0.1194075271487236,
0.3768874704837799,
0.3359571397304535,
0.42272424697875977,
-0.8927746415138245,
-0.1423407644033432,
0.152908056974411,
-1.0482349395751953,
-0.1392601728439331,
-0.048980463296175,
0.12059703469276428,
-0.051496561616659164,
0.7235948443412781,
-0.6410961151123047,
0.15818649530410767,
0.32283511757850647,
-0.5216003060340881,
0.5591530799865723,
-0.23898707330226898,
0.08066659420728683,
-0.7762824296951294,
0.10785449296236038,
0.13386116921901703,
0.2286721020936966,
-0.842307984828949,
-0.17175081372261047,
0.05575645714998245,
0.3723986744880676,
-0.08783816546201706,
0.6344265341758728,
-0.7792361378669739,
-0.19874371588230133,
-0.15793530642986298,
0.14751866459846497,
-0.46140894293785095,
0.18437790870666504,
-0.240830197930336,
0.4101794362068176,
0.49058130383491516,
-0.6535114049911499,
0.3878774046897888,
0.11673527210950851,
-0.17425093054771423,
0.3476592004299164,
-0.6047264337539673,
-0.1143103763461113,
-0.2185305804014206,
0.47595080733299255,
-0.9126991629600525,
-0.3861216604709625,
0.12127409875392914,
-0.1214977353811264,
0.42574676871299744,
0.05070887878537178,
-1.1267427206039429,
-0.3729637563228607,
-0.09202603250741959,
0.6637392044067383,
0.17223365604877472,
-0.5872009992599487,
0.5687782168388367,
0.6085245609283447,
-0.33444082736968994,
-0.45127689838409424,
-0.37063366174697876,
0.549605131149292,
-0.44933703541755676,
-0.628186047077179,
0.3691388666629791,
-0.21093866229057312,
-0.5040510296821594,
-0.2826713025569916,
0.20525847375392914,
-0.01910608820617199,
0.242844820022583,
0.11352675408124924,
0.2210841029882431,
-0.114064522087574,
0.27392834424972534,
-0.026112714782357216,
-0.007954024709761143,
0.4057576060295105,
-0.43380752205848694,
0.4578154683113098,
0.1390582174062729,
-0.3382609784603119,
-0.12286495417356491,
0.3906817138195038,
0.6080641150474548,
-0.3172386884689331,
0.5856828093528748,
0.635577917098999,
-0.32820838689804077,
-0.05134487524628639,
-0.709970235824585,
-0.15489639341831207,
-0.38721394538879395,
0.12216352671384811,
0.06611594557762146,
-1.078041434288025,
0.4590621590614319,
-0.5107976198196411,
-0.04673616588115692,
0.4359482228755951,
0.7284640073776245,
0.2489887923002243,
0.8807089328765869,
0.7976829409599304,
-0.44491860270500183,
0.3292226791381836,
-0.0946001410484314,
0.6840210556983948,
-0.6871159672737122,
-0.4469567835330963,
-0.638485848903656,
-0.18042314052581787,
-0.7115324139595032,
-0.391753226518631,
0.5556558966636658,
-0.08390969783067703,
-0.4901881217956543,
-0.08441625535488129,
-0.14131219685077667,
0.10292240977287292,
0.6238492131233215,
-0.04870851710438728,
0.5922896862030029,
-0.5193381309509277,
0.14145691692829132,
0.18057870864868164,
-0.6398966908454895,
-0.4620111286640167,
0.9748858213424683,
0.19859951734542847,
0.6259913444519043,
0.26036518812179565,
0.40677571296691895,
0.1644899994134903,
0.2767915725708008,
-0.5654951333999634,
0.5449723601341248,
0.21311338245868683,
-0.6201679110527039,
-0.3645264804363251,
-0.27091318368911743,
-0.9748175144195557,
-0.10118608921766281,
-0.15746119618415833,
-0.5303916931152344,
0.15448854863643646,
-0.12072300165891647,
0.13790005445480347,
0.3102220892906189,
-0.48221248388290405,
0.677410900592804,
-0.33239540457725525,
-0.6512730717658997,
-0.2655208706855774,
-0.9336023926734924,
0.8560905456542969,
-0.25479891896247864,
0.5217899084091187,
-0.06869500130414963,
-0.03110261633992195,
0.5674931406974792,
-0.11352872848510742,
1.138436198234558,
-0.07814543694257736,
-0.6758847832679749,
0.11419273912906647,
-0.06475964188575745,
0.7355703115463257,
-0.028161391615867615,
0.14379183948040009,
0.30791258811950684,
-0.3588848412036896,
-0.2912936508655548,
-0.4440499544143677,
1.0996860265731812,
-0.6718789935112,
-0.5351051688194275,
-0.3623769283294678,
-0.6628608703613281,
-0.31235015392303467,
0.4276658296585083,
-0.0865401178598404,
0.44476109743118286,
-0.31547969579696655,
-0.22847330570220947,
0.7882252931594849,
-0.41146743297576904,
0.6339088082313538,
0.7736827731132507,
0.26015692949295044,
-0.07235374301671982,
0.6965980529785156,
-0.036960989236831665,
-0.011270958930253983,
0.5237775444984436,
0.07210998982191086,
-0.24537351727485657,
-0.6739922165870667,
0.08809573948383331,
0.5714929103851318,
-0.6457152962684631,
-0.2828625738620758,
-0.6232729554176331,
0.05224829539656639,
-0.37138256430625916,
-0.14672042429447174,
-0.17100892961025238,
-0.0668025091290474,
-0.39933082461357117,
-0.15259197354316711,
0.31457456946372986,
1.1659566164016724,
-0.13240255415439606,
0.05056034028530121,
-0.6467770338058472,
0.18785160779953003,
0.008199174888432026,
0.2905144691467285,
0.2364409863948822,
0.05305696278810501,
-0.4177771508693695,
-0.13229882717132568,
-0.3496301472187042,
-0.6935173869132996,
0.3570937514305115,
-0.052120745182037354,
0.6260437965393066,
0.472677618265152,
-0.010643801651895046,
0.5966808199882507,
-0.7867314219474792,
0.8489363193511963,
0.20273301005363464,
-0.7119943499565125,
0.4058211147785187,
-0.6047968864440918,
-0.0077246190048754215,
0.02260488085448742,
0.6232088208198547,
-0.4255613088607788,
-0.45676442980766296,
-0.5339784026145935,
-1.006309151649475,
0.3970722258090973,
0.014807223342359066,
-0.3319603502750397,
0.005892546381801367,
0.1865517795085907,
0.1536744236946106,
-0.0034511862322688103,
-0.46207621693611145,
-0.23898129165172577,
0.5545517206192017,
-0.1592407077550888,
-0.43773263692855835,
-0.18275567889213562,
-0.28285425901412964,
-0.1368289440870285,
0.4621485471725464,
-0.19366879761219025,
0.1634669154882431,
0.19645258784294128,
-0.09768063575029373,
-0.02607486955821514,
0.22503574192523956,
0.4839610755443573,
0.6012334227561951,
0.13576330244541168,
0.2850126624107361,
-0.06929797679185867,
-0.19205738604068756,
0.06140254810452461,
0.206906259059906,
-0.04460383951663971,
-0.1479400098323822,
0.9601482152938843,
0.5133062601089478,
0.630424439907074,
-0.7598854899406433,
0.383425235748291,
0.060886867344379425,
-0.04511338844895363,
-0.5861533284187317,
-0.1770225167274475,
0.23580090701580048,
0.5281701683998108,
0.36957070231437683,
-0.29258063435554504,
0.3657378852367401,
-0.6906031966209412,
-0.07613649219274521,
0.7083877325057983,
-0.1355447918176651,
-0.6011819243431091,
0.8229328989982605,
0.015298154205083847,
0.11069943755865097,
0.3074875473976135,
0.13704361021518707,
-0.3905104994773865,
0.6479157209396362,
0.384560227394104,
0.9019020795822144,
-0.126246839761734,
-0.02925206907093525,
0.24417303502559662,
0.2835270166397095,
-0.042563024908304214,
0.058880191296339035,
-0.1588847041130066,
-0.7221254706382751,
-0.524878978729248,
-0.40887147188186646,
-0.3351844549179077,
-0.11726467311382294,
-0.33701133728027344,
0.35282137989997864,
-0.018354836851358414,
0.17082525789737701,
0.054224465042352676,
0.18802513182163239,
-0.860621452331543,
0.038150180131196976,
0.062306150794029236,
0.5881139636039734,
-0.9149638414382935,
0.7104954123497009,
0.5306050777435303,
-0.4580807685852051,
-0.7325727939605713,
-0.013678868301212788,
0.24969521164894104,
-0.5300347208976746,
0.9115001559257507,
-0.20947569608688354,
0.06461400538682938,
0.06706776469945908,
-0.6257110238075256,
-0.9810135960578918,
1.4228427410125732,
0.2743128538131714,
-0.36370790004730225,
-0.1801542341709137,
0.2282920926809311,
0.4911320209503174,
-0.10910452157258987,
0.34489986300468445,
0.9524087309837341,
0.7517923712730408,
-0.10589081048965454,
-0.9179495573043823,
0.27789056301116943,
0.11987021565437317,
-0.13190636038780212,
0.441710501909256,
-0.5025373697280884,
0.7068681716918945,
-0.20117568969726562,
-0.28599196672439575,
-0.020761718973517418,
0.6028720736503601,
0.13876529037952423,
0.6458684206008911,
0.14132679998874664,
0.40328100323677063,
0.6958595514297485,
-0.05817032232880592,
1.1808007955551147,
-0.18711553514003754,
0.26960301399230957,
0.9441289305686951,
-0.4585530459880829,
0.3534786105155945,
0.5741153359413147,
-0.4134209454059601,
0.5117828249931335,
0.6600662469863892,
0.36116448044776917,
0.3036401867866516,
0.2644307613372803,
-0.5294246673583984,
-0.0800776258111,
-0.2527127265930176,
-0.1094079464673996,
0.16692501306533813,
0.5924302339553833,
-0.17612147331237793,
-0.38455021381378174,
-0.038533471524715424,
0.20829211175441742,
-0.040694691240787506,
-0.19328831136226654,
0.8948889374732971,
0.12942302227020264,
-0.6940083503723145,
0.2390785962343216,
-0.10168857127428055,
0.6206077337265015,
-0.6614477038383484,
-0.16740655899047852,
-0.3090382218360901,
0.1590907722711563,
-0.2211601734161377,
-0.7195701599121094,
0.10695251822471619,
-0.26567766070365906,
-0.2686591148376465,
-0.06787944585084915,
0.7856693863868713,
-0.5218369364738464,
-0.24137887358665466,
0.6638050675392151,
0.6161019206047058,
-0.14015787839889526,
0.12504638731479645,
-0.16882330179214478,
0.13088715076446533,
-0.28255707025527954,
0.0362602174282074,
0.4412015974521637,
0.9117889404296875,
-0.28178462386131287,
0.7156040668487549,
0.8051378130912781,
0.17465326189994812,
0.07302097231149673,
0.05901959910988808,
1.0269333124160767,
-0.9985280632972717,
-0.11227093636989594,
-1.0426890850067139,
0.35086843371391296,
-0.005480286665260792,
-0.05027061328291893,
0.8544784784317017,
0.4193996787071228,
0.6241341829299927,
-0.03631286695599556,
0.899804413318634,
0.0013793021207675338,
0.43103930354118347,
-0.6545832753181458,
0.416602224111557,
-0.46765509247779846,
0.48966184258461,
-0.5686513185501099,
-0.6570267677307129,
-0.567303478717804,
-0.21129029989242554,
-0.3755657374858856,
-0.19766660034656525,
0.6914567947387695,
0.640293538570404,
0.006831879261881113,
-0.06138031557202339,
0.18134088814258575,
0.48794862627983093,
0.8993733525276184,
0.646243155002594,
0.982490599155426,
-0.15333291888237,
0.13932812213897705,
0.2200791984796524,
-0.4256429672241211,
-0.2157423347234726,
-0.9374901056289673,
-0.7468736171722412,
-0.8121036291122437,
-0.045062996447086334,
0.21175521612167358,
-0.14915741980075836,
0.5427035689353943,
0.16961055994033813,
-0.4851358234882355,
-0.27106979489326477,
-0.3802410960197449,
0.43860337138175964,
0.06324893236160278,
-0.25825101137161255,
0.4956073462963104,
-0.45996204018592834,
-0.7508713603019714,
0.5485924482345581,
0.5109831690788269,
-0.16330985724925995,
-0.4474242627620697,
-0.07859113067388535,
-0.2694660425186157,
0.05883786082267761,
0.9818847179412842,
0.39342859387397766,
-0.8587563633918762,
-0.20322667062282562,
-0.14501677453517914,
0.10763487219810486,
-0.4337874948978424,
1.2407786846160889,
-0.72898268699646,
0.16936416923999786,
0.4724794626235962,
0.8218420147895813,
0.17179131507873535,
-0.48688599467277527,
0.9094390869140625,
-0.344536691904068,
0.01698276773095131,
0.29296377301216125,
0.5336665511131287,
0.3228166103363037,
-0.4574601650238037,
0.6672311425209045,
0.28202036023139954,
-0.8578444719314575,
-0.7931334376335144,
0.3986595571041107,
-1.0417693853378296,
-0.3480006754398346,
1.1321580410003662,
0.15687258541584015,
0.26465702056884766,
-0.36827173829078674,
-0.1178453117609024,
0.24201764166355133,
0.09582162648439407,
0.7000345587730408,
0.6567560434341431,
-0.2993509769439697,
0.20667560398578644,
-0.6707497239112854,
0.42285624146461487,
0.0700325295329094,
-0.9451344013214111,
0.17061308026313782,
0.7595484852790833,
-0.01376013271510601,
-0.0057590315118432045,
0.49492526054382324,
-0.24161280691623688,
-0.0345938615500927,
-0.5506484508514404,
0.0569494292140007,
0.3035072684288025,
-0.27019137144088745,
-0.29351136088371277,
-0.028982216492295265,
0.005657825153321028,
0.4964679777622223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11060v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11060v1 | Persona-DB: Efficient Large Language Model Personalization for Response Prediction with Collaborative Data Refinement | 2024-02-16T20:20:43 | 2024-02-16T20:20:43 | Chenkai Sun, Ke Yang, Revanth Gangi Reddy, Yi R. Fung, Hou Pong Chan, ChengXiang Zhai, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | The increasing demand for personalized interactions with large language
models (LLMs) calls for the development of methodologies capable of accurately
and efficiently identifying user opinions and preferences. Retrieval
augmentation emerges as an effective strategy, as it can accommodate a vast
number of users without the costs from fine-tuning. Existing research, however,
has largely focused on enhancing the retrieval stage and devoted limited
exploration toward optimizing the representation of the database, a crucial
aspect for tasks such as personalization. In this work, we examine the problem
from a novel angle, focusing on how data can be better represented for more
efficient retrieval in the context of LLM customization. To tackle this
challenge, we introduce Persona-DB, a simple yet effective framework consisting
of a hierarchical construction process to improve generalization across task
contexts and collaborative refinement to effectively bridge knowledge gaps
among users. In the task of response forecasting, Persona-DB demonstrates
superior efficiency in maintaining accuracy with a significantly reduced
retrieval size, a critical advantage in scenarios with extensive histories or
limited context windows. Our experiments also indicate a marked improvement of
over 15% under cold-start scenarios, when users have extremely sparse data.
Furthermore, our analysis reveals the increasing importance of collaborative
knowledge as the retrieval capacity expands. | [
-0.6685946583747864,
-0.6093767285346985,
0.7030383944511414,
0.21475745737552643,
0.06320542097091675,
0.2560673952102661,
-0.2930004894733429,
-0.29625043272972107,
0.4350060522556305,
0.6374982595443726,
-0.7805569171905518,
-0.5149228572845459,
-0.13422958552837372,
-0.06699458509683609,
-0.13517440855503082,
0.8377199172973633,
0.5515699982643127,
0.06439164280891418,
-0.50752854347229,
-0.008791116066277027,
-0.5690152645111084,
-0.7186328768730164,
-0.4953429400920868,
-0.5244044661521912,
0.7856805324554443,
0.6182116866111755,
0.6972842812538147,
0.550571084022522,
0.4478999674320221,
0.3280111253261566,
0.17998521029949188,
0.04132996127009392,
-0.7414332628250122,
0.5465916991233826,
-0.24082203209400177,
-0.40693235397338867,
-0.5645657777786255,
-0.33486929535865784,
0.3956778645515442,
1.2376697063446045,
-0.34636422991752625,
0.008393500931560993,
0.10064519941806793,
0.8274854421615601,
-0.5763651728630066,
0.3288649618625641,
-0.5329273343086243,
-0.07183203846216202,
-0.2704334259033203,
-0.21308401226997375,
-0.5893912315368652,
-0.16660575568675995,
0.569610059261322,
-0.5933139324188232,
0.31418561935424805,
0.32087135314941406,
0.282949298620224,
0.10351008176803589,
-0.37882837653160095,
0.15981899201869965,
-0.8979202508926392,
0.8075990676879883,
-0.47283560037612915,
0.526650607585907,
0.3415241539478302,
0.5452353954315186,
-0.32138878107070923,
-0.691892683506012,
-0.33990538120269775,
-0.1188274547457695,
-0.19583866000175476,
0.09346932172775269,
-0.07938345521688461,
0.0662749856710434,
0.20652861893177032,
0.2936699688434601,
-0.6018012762069702,
0.16525258123874664,
0.017086833715438843,
-0.13707609474658966,
0.5554795861244202,
0.4005107283592224,
0.0032823060173541307,
-0.30699673295021057,
-0.15698528289794922,
0.09169422090053558,
-0.6156134009361267,
-0.13977515697479248,
0.3223079442977905,
0.46554893255233765,
0.1010255515575409,
0.5347936153411865,
-0.47211843729019165,
0.634830117225647,
0.44895124435424805,
-0.0027925691101700068,
0.4348602294921875,
-0.27305868268013,
-0.23483018577098846,
-0.36082857847213745,
0.7456135153770447,
0.35082802176475525,
0.030235793441534042,
-0.4699256420135498,
-0.11472376435995102,
-0.3154437839984894,
0.40094953775405884,
-0.8259066343307495,
-0.3852534890174866,
0.3933550715446472,
-0.39263418316841125,
-0.07506591826677322,
-0.05195760726928711,
-0.9578312039375305,
-0.815618097782135,
-0.61263507604599,
-0.09300275146961212,
-0.5172861218452454,
-0.1329537183046341,
0.06653342396020889,
0.28752601146698,
0.007092669606208801,
0.6208594441413879,
-1.0163917541503906,
0.43715140223503113,
0.7841205596923828,
0.4617977738380432,
-0.11021697521209717,
0.044933632016181946,
-0.7032052874565125,
0.3752574026584625,
-0.1549605131149292,
0.9901180267333984,
-0.7010437846183777,
-0.5819122791290283,
-0.11210077255964279,
-0.2081107348203659,
0.13676919043064117,
-0.6285861134529114,
0.386700838804245,
-0.7167863249778748,
0.5453181266784668,
-0.6611751317977905,
-0.6460104584693909,
0.07997376471757889,
0.16187311708927155,
-0.5931776165962219,
0.7419620156288147,
0.20408473908901215,
-0.7663178443908691,
0.3645946979522705,
-0.4422350525856018,
-0.2469194084405899,
0.34627893567085266,
-0.28369754552841187,
-0.32072100043296814,
0.12571516633033752,
0.30063116550445557,
0.7084294557571411,
-0.47820335626602173,
0.2403835505247116,
-0.6327725052833557,
-0.39106252789497375,
0.17486713826656342,
0.34499961137771606,
0.37235596776008606,
0.19622834026813507,
-0.04645054042339325,
0.20273487269878387,
-0.7172773480415344,
0.039850980043411255,
-0.0041867587715387344,
-0.40796056389808655,
-0.5799659490585327,
0.036907367408275604,
0.11824321746826172,
-0.04000724107027054,
0.5386536717414856,
-0.4136296510696411,
0.2037069946527481,
-0.7482732534408569,
-0.15620705485343933,
0.7642399668693542,
0.07609183341264725,
0.8063092231750488,
-0.352220743894577,
0.5095455050468445,
-0.03109411522746086,
-0.09043663740158081,
-0.42325496673583984,
-0.35543039441108704,
-0.5027353763580322,
-0.1655322164297104,
0.23115913569927216,
0.46107563376426697,
-0.5786011815071106,
0.5517963171005249,
-0.5398292541503906,
-0.38148897886276245,
-0.36830952763557434,
0.22440800070762634,
0.29030418395996094,
0.759161114692688,
0.26081520318984985,
-0.5598174333572388,
-0.9036272764205933,
-1.2437515258789062,
-0.18966542184352875,
-0.20342913269996643,
-0.4772453010082245,
0.7661494016647339,
0.16915707290172577,
-0.31226611137390137,
1.1421161890029907,
-0.8913502097129822,
-0.19461077451705933,
-0.36917275190353394,
-0.041996609419584274,
0.29541900753974915,
0.37675559520721436,
0.6867237091064453,
-0.8459780216217041,
-0.6996949911117554,
0.06736546009778976,
-0.5801409482955933,
-0.16146212816238403,
-0.004198047332465649,
-0.14662177860736847,
-0.028554972261190414,
0.05077625438570976,
-0.41328394412994385,
-0.03175465762615204,
0.19951537251472473,
-0.20093348622322083,
0.45886722207069397,
-0.20639081299304962,
0.18887285888195038,
-1.2657204866409302,
0.2617259919643402,
0.19652725756168365,
-0.40245112776756287,
-0.7334494590759277,
0.16848422586917877,
0.0693378895521164,
-0.043538812547922134,
0.014726240187883377,
0.4555131494998932,
-0.3546614348888397,
-0.2797093689441681,
-0.15215103328227997,
0.159033864736557,
-0.18245351314544678,
0.6005735993385315,
0.03389986231923103,
0.6816432476043701,
0.32956013083457947,
-0.5004002451896667,
0.5599590539932251,
0.43782681226730347,
-0.4300662875175476,
1.0199154615402222,
-0.5819255113601685,
0.5178083777427673,
-0.5287299156188965,
0.22993233799934387,
-0.9617542028427124,
-0.6639001965522766,
0.16995428502559662,
-0.4286949336528778,
0.14609678089618683,
-0.17473077774047852,
-0.6897906064987183,
-0.257986843585968,
-0.30398836731910706,
-0.08681154996156693,
0.41692015528678894,
-0.50484699010849,
0.7125669121742249,
0.6284692287445068,
-0.25185248255729675,
-0.42745018005371094,
-0.4005906283855438,
0.16715341806411743,
-0.36612290143966675,
-0.7210732698440552,
0.5307227373123169,
-0.5003237128257751,
-0.3616274297237396,
-0.34085607528686523,
0.039647553116083145,
-0.22818322479724884,
0.018595578148961067,
0.1818227767944336,
0.22569964826107025,
0.058909475803375244,
0.20695017278194427,
-0.05554508417844772,
0.033971574157476425,
0.04149336740374565,
-0.0994916632771492,
0.7802146077156067,
0.06235199421644211,
-0.06078420951962471,
-0.22355486452579498,
0.363573282957077,
0.3647107779979706,
-0.10164987295866013,
0.9082109332084656,
0.4864422678947449,
-0.42422324419021606,
-0.049043986946344376,
-0.8060450553894043,
-0.25512880086898804,
-0.5088672637939453,
0.34578266739845276,
-0.5835601687431335,
-0.7904103398323059,
0.7601852416992188,
-0.12376990914344788,
0.0033710417337715626,
-0.03629973530769348,
0.5260555744171143,
-0.20911505818367004,
1.1475623846054077,
0.7168515920639038,
-0.2743743658065796,
0.5361270308494568,
-0.1338297426700592,
-0.037478815764188766,
-1.0532249212265015,
-0.8060345649719238,
-0.5805240869522095,
-0.31923556327819824,
-0.2861422896385193,
-0.2571850121021271,
0.4195772707462311,
-0.33305180072784424,
-0.3063929080963135,
0.448468416929245,
-0.1995597779750824,
0.28907138109207153,
0.4052351713180542,
0.3655109405517578,
0.45246249437332153,
0.169425368309021,
-0.020743293687701225,
-0.6611034274101257,
-0.3827225863933563,
-0.24729494750499725,
1.237778663635254,
0.18939846754074097,
0.704373836517334,
0.36239877343177795,
0.7919403910636902,
0.07916674017906189,
0.34586453437805176,
-0.8471555709838867,
0.632828950881958,
-0.07828663289546967,
-0.5476042628288269,
-0.11080212146043777,
-0.5603038668632507,
-1.0380796194076538,
0.4165322184562683,
-0.3410828411579132,
-0.860019326210022,
0.26798784732818604,
0.17630115151405334,
-0.5024769902229309,
-0.1490737646818161,
-0.7390650510787964,
0.5993824601173401,
0.05908481776714325,
-0.6823890209197998,
-0.3636823892593384,
-0.6222623586654663,
0.33101901412010193,
-0.3480493128299713,
0.16607818007469177,
0.05299302935600281,
-0.368694543838501,
0.5505127310752869,
-0.395871102809906,
0.7748996019363403,
-0.24320144951343536,
0.025982536375522614,
-0.24061034619808197,
0.13135145604610443,
0.61588054895401,
0.015699518844485283,
-0.3517571985721588,
-0.602784276008606,
-0.23985376954078674,
-0.3660701513290405,
-0.9476141929626465,
1.0263521671295166,
-0.5321055054664612,
-0.7956487536430359,
-0.10619315505027771,
-0.4470602571964264,
-0.8355552554130554,
0.2600008249282837,
0.050707485526800156,
0.29991018772125244,
-0.47693586349487305,
0.6276121735572815,
1.0231376886367798,
-0.34540531039237976,
-0.029246017336845398,
0.7441774606704712,
-0.3967498540878296,
-0.4122854471206665,
0.5616713762283325,
-0.027038168162107468,
-0.27036282420158386,
0.6462994813919067,
0.15747718513011932,
-0.4380393624305725,
-0.5508354306221008,
-0.14866596460342407,
0.20991432666778564,
-0.48331376910209656,
-0.13287660479545593,
-0.8203708529472351,
0.3141234517097473,
-0.5802584290504456,
0.123539499938488,
-0.19736339151859283,
-0.2399194985628128,
-0.36728617548942566,
0.016856197267770767,
0.007871899753808975,
0.48156705498695374,
0.29886412620544434,
0.48934444785118103,
-0.5319921374320984,
0.23845717310905457,
0.2274734079837799,
0.4969181716442108,
0.1373705118894577,
-0.381603479385376,
-0.3994784653186798,
-0.08497930318117142,
-0.29208827018737793,
-0.9308367967605591,
0.5777261257171631,
0.042558975517749786,
0.5888810753822327,
0.2724692225456238,
0.10098111629486084,
0.8308409452438354,
-0.4087478220462799,
0.4611811935901642,
0.10435536503791809,
-0.6045415997505188,
0.6484578847885132,
-0.7145519852638245,
0.3708189129829407,
0.5983872413635254,
0.43252041935920715,
-0.6501986980438232,
0.05922834575176239,
-0.6254513263702393,
-0.8997534513473511,
0.6128116846084595,
0.016372671350836754,
0.19392120838165283,
0.2516299784183502,
0.5357732772827148,
0.2414379119873047,
0.586990475654602,
-0.3424954116344452,
-0.3306056559085846,
0.08946642279624939,
-0.07394279539585114,
-0.15123601257801056,
-0.1825949251651764,
0.031283143907785416,
-0.29542022943496704,
0.3694726824760437,
-0.2874142825603485,
0.14844074845314026,
-0.1395941823720932,
0.15712836384773254,
-0.20968680083751678,
0.26881980895996094,
-0.09973074495792389,
0.7144551873207092,
-0.3171943426132202,
-0.3229962885379791,
0.08330514281988144,
-0.143784761428833,
-0.15448080003261566,
0.21322263777256012,
-0.1401200294494629,
-0.2187771052122116,
0.17424766719341278,
0.6972714066505432,
0.5469051599502563,
-0.7115638256072998,
0.42369237542152405,
-0.12779861688613892,
0.19328123331069946,
-0.45753785967826843,
0.08700738847255707,
0.22346147894859314,
0.21215873956680298,
0.4549404978752136,
0.11958027631044388,
0.5679745674133301,
-0.6072015762329102,
0.11917983740568161,
0.5510818362236023,
0.09323889017105103,
-0.48964056372642517,
0.7377334237098694,
0.24402931332588196,
-0.08227398991584778,
0.6563548445701599,
0.27343660593032837,
-0.0486203134059906,
0.28221672773361206,
0.33738723397254944,
0.7292913198471069,
-0.5542552471160889,
0.32428860664367676,
0.31814220547676086,
-0.28376543521881104,
-0.07665865868330002,
0.13828298449516296,
-0.050392139703035355,
-0.6753101944923401,
-0.3741821050643921,
-0.6282307505607605,
-0.5661829113960266,
0.2966361939907074,
-0.7341834306716919,
0.12880541384220123,
-0.7821177840232849,
-0.2875705063343048,
0.10955691337585449,
0.3813765048980713,
-0.7876358032226562,
0.22600381076335907,
-0.08588317036628723,
0.737754762172699,
-0.38828688859939575,
0.8596233129501343,
0.8242499828338623,
-0.26651230454444885,
-0.56855309009552,
-0.05386433005332947,
0.11360327899456024,
-0.5131112337112427,
0.49501752853393555,
-0.0069257477298378944,
0.08468276262283325,
-0.049303509294986725,
-0.42182686924934387,
-0.8877469301223755,
1.0685608386993408,
0.7471383213996887,
-0.7544263601303101,
-0.13648085296154022,
-0.0029827055986970663,
0.9529163837432861,
-0.6407043933868408,
0.021558549255132675,
0.7286804914474487,
0.4492097496986389,
0.370592325925827,
-0.7833660244941711,
-0.01821598783135414,
-0.16737891733646393,
0.25849655270576477,
0.041011564433574677,
-0.5601370930671692,
0.45871514081954956,
-0.20189723372459412,
-0.09985705465078354,
0.35288894176483154,
0.8322305679321289,
0.20669284462928772,
0.2823352813720703,
0.36300215125083923,
0.42924588918685913,
0.9722582697868347,
-0.044428568333387375,
1.323004126548767,
-0.14793634414672852,
0.09639476239681244,
1.3409507274627686,
-0.40487197041511536,
0.8732296228408813,
0.3102399706840515,
-0.2749307453632355,
0.7351516485214233,
0.6893455982208252,
0.11386629939079285,
0.6656206250190735,
-0.06893108785152435,
-0.3554890751838684,
-0.46054401993751526,
-0.18167732656002045,
-0.24223461747169495,
0.13246005773544312,
0.3466137647628784,
-0.3268524706363678,
0.112071193754673,
0.0003411927027627826,
0.0007285949541255832,
0.5133501291275024,
-0.21055829524993896,
0.8571639657020569,
-0.09271448105573654,
-0.7668700814247131,
0.20324140787124634,
0.024257421493530273,
0.6723634004592896,
-0.42074134945869446,
0.36666128039360046,
-0.4883005917072296,
0.2818889915943146,
-0.3427901268005371,
-0.6775912046432495,
0.26937413215637207,
-0.20031115412712097,
-0.42799580097198486,
-0.30373328924179077,
0.677483081817627,
-0.44161084294319153,
-0.17340223491191864,
0.31516382098197937,
0.7521795034408569,
-0.12085837125778198,
-0.24281448125839233,
-0.7055280804634094,
0.023524686694145203,
-0.05771065875887871,
-0.40917736291885376,
0.6571229100227356,
0.09895452111959457,
0.20243030786514282,
1.0401029586791992,
0.5309920907020569,
0.049508124589920044,
-0.3434296250343323,
0.18237368762493134,
1.0788171291351318,
-0.4846775531768799,
-0.5512082576751709,
-0.6079816818237305,
0.37559109926223755,
-0.2667073905467987,
0.17095498740673065,
0.9263352155685425,
0.8847863078117371,
0.7193455100059509,
-0.2848822772502899,
0.8635030388832092,
0.11464894562959671,
0.9545105695724487,
-0.16886566579341888,
0.4418129324913025,
-0.38331809639930725,
0.7933815717697144,
-0.5448989868164062,
-1.1517773866653442,
-0.30253270268440247,
0.4137206971645355,
-0.5558649301528931,
0.3010573983192444,
0.3986625671386719,
0.7704353928565979,
-0.09974092990159988,
-0.12295806407928467,
0.28937920928001404,
0.23841997981071472,
0.36129534244537354,
0.5090340375900269,
0.35509178042411804,
-0.07703938335180283,
0.45937803387641907,
-0.44394344091415405,
-0.27004197239875793,
-0.16836801171302795,
-0.49232667684555054,
-0.9661611318588257,
-0.8412678837776184,
-0.2383955717086792,
-0.2786453664302826,
0.06851000338792801,
1.0745389461517334,
0.8586023449897766,
-0.781291127204895,
-0.4367170035839081,
0.1354280412197113,
-0.13028749823570251,
0.17854660749435425,
-0.24297237396240234,
0.14751073718070984,
-0.14262156188488007,
-0.990708589553833,
0.5829309225082397,
0.15191052854061127,
0.021480301395058632,
-0.5337217450141907,
-0.2509385943412781,
0.19253401458263397,
-0.017114631831645966,
0.6287039518356323,
0.2646845579147339,
-0.4563940763473511,
-0.19935303926467896,
0.2648630142211914,
-0.024048201739788055,
0.09877865761518478,
0.8497549295425415,
-1.3752163648605347,
0.5439264178276062,
0.595278263092041,
0.6008965373039246,
0.6780611276626587,
0.26407986879348755,
0.9893406629562378,
-0.960158109664917,
-0.08377755433320999,
0.2375289797782898,
0.4475748836994171,
0.7315239906311035,
-0.6370803713798523,
0.4905436933040619,
0.2545127868652344,
-0.44428059458732605,
-0.6698555946350098,
0.33351531624794006,
-0.979045033454895,
-0.24780072271823883,
0.8698931932449341,
-0.10153868049383163,
-0.09827838838100433,
-0.20910631120204926,
-0.37886735796928406,
-0.26798588037490845,
-0.8059312105178833,
0.9557551145553589,
0.5557796359062195,
-0.38792964816093445,
-0.3972773849964142,
-0.2853405177593231,
0.47557610273361206,
0.2740548849105835,
-0.8897385001182556,
0.14816780388355255,
0.9392285346984863,
0.4148121178150177,
0.13902951776981354,
0.8218150734901428,
0.1295793354511261,
0.10014954954385757,
-0.46089932322502136,
-0.44701164960861206,
0.016365477815270424,
-0.29718437790870667,
-0.14415211975574493,
0.5136771202087402,
0.08379713445901871,
0.32933181524276733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11058v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11058v3 | II-MMR: Identifying and Improving Multi-modal Multi-hop Reasoning in Visual Question Answering | 2024-02-16T20:14:47 | 2024-06-03T01:09:38 | Jihyung Kil, Farideh Tavazoee, Dongyeop Kang, Joo-Kyung Kim | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Visual Question Answering (VQA) often involves diverse reasoning scenarios
across Vision and Language (V&L). Most prior VQA studies, however, have merely
focused on assessing the model's overall accuracy without evaluating it on
different reasoning cases. Furthermore, some recent works observe that
conventional Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting fails to generate effective
reasoning for VQA, especially for complex scenarios requiring multi-hop
reasoning. In this paper, we propose II-MMR, a novel idea to identify and
improve multi-modal multi-hop reasoning in VQA. In specific, II-MMR takes a VQA
question with an image and finds a reasoning path to reach its answer using two
novel language promptings: (i) answer prediction-guided CoT prompt, or (ii)
knowledge triplet-guided prompt. II-MMR then analyzes this path to identify
different reasoning cases in current VQA benchmarks by estimating how many hops
and what types (i.e., visual or beyond-visual) of reasoning are required to
answer the question. On popular benchmarks including GQA and A-OKVQA, II-MMR
observes that most of their VQA questions are easy to answer, simply demanding
"single-hop" reasoning, whereas only a few questions require "multi-hop"
reasoning. Moreover, while the recent V&L model struggles with such complex
multi-hop reasoning questions even using the traditional CoT method, II-MMR
shows its effectiveness across all reasoning cases in both zero-shot and
fine-tuning settings. | [
-0.5643881559371948,
-1.0758053064346313,
0.710349977016449,
-0.005032228771597147,
-0.16617199778556824,
0.247300922870636,
0.17582456767559052,
-0.5087572932243347,
-0.28182944655418396,
0.21757782995700836,
-0.7433903217315674,
0.06917797029018402,
-0.5276212096214294,
0.15885618329048157,
0.1329476684331894,
0.3874610662460327,
-0.22507429122924805,
0.3398060202598572,
-0.2682673931121826,
-0.300306111574173,
-0.9502959251403809,
-0.41398292779922485,
-0.5455618500709534,
0.15246202051639557,
0.8552232384681702,
0.6856719851493835,
0.3537124991416931,
0.43335065245628357,
0.852342963218689,
0.2819266617298126,
-0.18877272307872772,
0.6875298023223877,
-0.23693004250526428,
-0.02385198511183262,
0.05667544901371002,
-0.4700520634651184,
-0.3153899013996124,
-0.23604682087898254,
0.5961207151412964,
0.2458156943321228,
0.28644585609436035,
0.25909188389778137,
-0.17206546664237976,
0.7863631844520569,
-0.880456805229187,
0.017465567216277122,
-0.6012828946113586,
-0.119203582406044,
-0.14186115562915802,
-0.7073633670806885,
-0.46633926033973694,
-0.08457474410533905,
0.08898168802261353,
-0.5379323363304138,
-0.019183313474059105,
-0.0843772292137146,
0.6156740784645081,
0.3981374204158783,
-0.9029926657676697,
-0.2124033123254776,
-0.818323016166687,
0.5758206248283386,
-0.2098943591117859,
0.49352142214775085,
0.12138441950082779,
0.8973554968833923,
0.04016878828406334,
-0.5269830226898193,
-0.8939408659934998,
0.03172726929187775,
0.14301860332489014,
0.3670154809951782,
-0.2015914022922516,
-0.03660162165760994,
0.46803879737854004,
-0.004385089501738548,
-0.5526976585388184,
-0.4386826753616333,
-0.6877920627593994,
-0.39673861861228943,
0.09288318455219269,
0.3112937808036804,
0.16010159254074097,
-0.07675948739051819,
-0.6653681397438049,
-0.08330574631690979,
-0.3779660761356354,
0.8516373038291931,
0.008215036243200302,
0.06875024735927582,
0.23756377398967743,
0.9248325824737549,
-0.48205453157424927,
0.823835551738739,
-0.009620415046811104,
-0.2898677885532379,
0.2691866159439087,
-0.7002131938934326,
0.13127577304840088,
-0.5071876049041748,
0.37850266695022583,
0.7547585964202881,
0.3328453302383423,
0.40055304765701294,
-0.028194069862365723,
0.06032663956284523,
0.08961943536996841,
-0.7669122219085693,
-0.15385660529136658,
0.12309665977954865,
-0.5456334948539734,
0.15218932926654816,
0.15781132876873016,
-0.6942920684814453,
-0.15543702244758606,
-0.3026394248008728,
0.8731668591499329,
-0.5686579942703247,
-0.2561675012111664,
-0.05076815187931061,
-0.553551197052002,
0.8040162324905396,
0.7821195125579834,
-0.28664618730545044,
-0.011587747372686863,
0.6774136424064636,
0.8253549933433533,
0.20734883844852448,
-0.3891308903694153,
-1.1277658939361572,
0.004368841648101807,
-0.25227028131484985,
1.083120346069336,
-0.560643196105957,
0.025502342730760574,
-0.19232392311096191,
0.04070207476615906,
-0.27769556641578674,
-0.41520723700523376,
0.38407132029533386,
-0.7369771599769592,
0.14041957259178162,
-0.7861935496330261,
-0.19287274777889252,
-0.37377676367759705,
0.719526469707489,
-0.485059529542923,
0.7449979186058044,
-0.13911035656929016,
-0.87168288230896,
0.5109244585037231,
-0.5810554027557373,
-0.10271447896957397,
-0.11137930303812027,
-0.4113945960998535,
-0.17069408297538757,
-0.12373421341180801,
0.6402568817138672,
-0.03643820062279701,
-0.2362878918647766,
-0.1862330436706543,
-0.2360626608133316,
-0.4662528336048126,
0.3566402792930603,
-0.6632833480834961,
0.5852472186088562,
0.2199346125125885,
-0.27728718519210815,
0.2879825532436371,
-0.5868972539901733,
0.29172179102897644,
0.05698313191533089,
-0.2976225018501282,
-0.2957107424736023,
-0.024340296164155006,
-0.23851926624774933,
0.4989170730113983,
-0.023048998787999153,
-0.3734797537326813,
0.2748928666114807,
-0.014681450091302395,
0.20082810521125793,
0.6847818493843079,
0.2196127474308014,
0.2192724645137787,
-0.3991270661354065,
0.5609081387519836,
0.34927403926849365,
0.3663879632949829,
-0.3854095935821533,
-0.9765673279762268,
-0.8653534054756165,
-0.554062008857727,
-0.08855611830949783,
0.8326019644737244,
-1.2231714725494385,
-0.3244291841983795,
-0.015772884711623192,
-0.2143673300743103,
-0.6213456988334656,
-0.11250653117895126,
0.6005977392196655,
0.6898398995399475,
0.6100109219551086,
-0.14934483170509338,
-0.43201470375061035,
-0.6232458353042603,
-0.20824730396270752,
-0.2632328271865845,
0.15201599895954132,
0.3883696496486664,
0.48281431198120117,
-0.26344358921051025,
0.7815654873847961,
-0.2836480140686035,
-0.12539978325366974,
-0.012060163542628288,
0.3173971176147461,
-0.14287590980529785,
0.112489715218544,
0.2445986568927765,
-0.9884335398674011,
-0.3326556384563446,
-0.18241842091083527,
-0.5314103364944458,
-0.02834111638367176,
-0.29335817694664,
-0.2029295414686203,
-0.05406058207154274,
0.5849825739860535,
-0.5387294292449951,
0.5036411285400391,
0.14767391979694366,
-0.5236074924468994,
0.725519061088562,
-0.22307710349559784,
0.5996891260147095,
-0.7739889621734619,
-0.07929369807243347,
-0.06229330599308014,
-0.048590920865535736,
-0.4080425798892975,
0.10819023102521896,
0.24118991196155548,
0.2739136219024658,
-0.3545823097229004,
0.6149572730064392,
-0.6529595255851746,
0.08914892375469208,
-0.1705973744392395,
-0.22853659093379974,
0.04601733013987541,
0.4751091003417969,
0.05393235385417938,
1.089937448501587,
0.4809783399105072,
-0.573615312576294,
0.39403441548347473,
0.2529957592487335,
-0.10675323009490967,
0.8995206356048584,
-0.6789650321006775,
0.17642107605934143,
-0.498530775308609,
0.19097355008125305,
-1.547110676765442,
-0.09581068903207779,
0.3881171941757202,
-0.7874682545661926,
-0.0030194397550076246,
-0.3251861333847046,
-0.258093923330307,
-0.6350008249282837,
-0.2648318409919739,
0.7588766813278198,
0.21248210966587067,
-0.6222890615463257,
0.749465823173523,
-0.022172387689352036,
0.08068247884511948,
-0.7566360235214233,
-0.38528844714164734,
0.05296677350997925,
-0.1687331199645996,
-0.6961790323257446,
-0.2639854848384857,
-0.4706250727176666,
-0.27742648124694824,
-0.18568603694438934,
-0.14119449257850647,
-0.41191521286964417,
-0.2345629781484604,
0.09399038553237915,
0.32439395785331726,
-0.4203852713108063,
0.08626344799995422,
-0.08311804383993149,
-0.44638222455978394,
-0.02558189071714878,
0.05778228119015694,
0.19995076954364777,
-0.5018333792686462,
-0.584405779838562,
-0.4090632200241089,
0.6611447930335999,
0.8360406160354614,
-0.7988253235816956,
0.2971731126308441,
1.0784002542495728,
-0.07852106541395187,
0.21329356729984283,
-0.7136247754096985,
-0.13075220584869385,
-0.42151179909706116,
0.20504286885261536,
-1.0562382936477661,
-1.0011789798736572,
0.2137453705072403,
-0.23582802712917328,
-0.1704079806804657,
0.2859782576560974,
0.7051268815994263,
-0.3736346364021301,
1.244778037071228,
0.5624713897705078,
0.5215903520584106,
0.2100924551486969,
-0.27090322971343994,
0.24345044791698456,
-1.0045262575149536,
-0.5504949688911438,
-0.22750680148601532,
-0.27104732394218445,
-0.28778958320617676,
-1.0002517700195312,
0.9407130479812622,
0.3339694142341614,
-0.19037096202373505,
-0.06508523225784302,
-0.37864062190055847,
0.5054340958595276,
0.9062932133674622,
0.1595485508441925,
0.3798467516899109,
-0.20758022367954254,
-0.23398332297801971,
0.06739044189453125,
-0.599153459072113,
-0.1991644650697708,
0.8386276364326477,
0.24252453446388245,
0.5005879998207092,
0.46338507533073425,
0.16418850421905518,
-0.03095315583050251,
-0.2519623339176178,
-1.032518744468689,
0.4471370577812195,
0.33712735772132874,
-0.6079249382019043,
-0.198810413479805,
-0.4621325135231018,
-0.618314266204834,
0.41955724358558655,
-0.26980671286582947,
-0.5958940982818604,
0.3423313796520233,
0.333402156829834,
-0.4471416175365448,
0.18747417628765106,
-0.5921748280525208,
0.8028790950775146,
-0.26702380180358887,
-0.2748444974422455,
-0.06278563290834427,
-1.122593879699707,
0.5523668527603149,
0.3023465871810913,
0.316139817237854,
0.1273583024740219,
-0.07456133514642715,
0.3701965808868408,
-0.5711055397987366,
0.5027011036872864,
-0.18916352093219757,
0.2671705186367035,
0.6722959876060486,
0.07238155603408813,
0.392619252204895,
-0.0911792516708374,
0.3203914761543274,
-0.03226073831319809,
0.21857064962387085,
-0.34117206931114197,
-0.6058262586593628,
0.21888013184070587,
-0.5434863567352295,
-0.34444859623908997,
-0.5214110612869263,
-0.5280594825744629,
-0.37990236282348633,
0.058456167578697205,
0.30903375148773193,
0.6582360863685608,
0.1911650449037552,
0.20781302452087402,
0.6535288095474243,
0.04566185548901558,
0.3742167353630066,
0.4103659391403198,
0.01946759968996048,
-0.7620956301689148,
0.6449918150901794,
-0.007732128258794546,
0.327204167842865,
0.586665689945221,
0.26055678725242615,
-0.4201763868331909,
-0.1659451574087143,
-0.9504469037055969,
0.04762312397360802,
-0.7337196469306946,
-0.27306580543518066,
-0.8542820811271667,
-0.18545137345790863,
-0.011755282990634441,
-0.08919432014226913,
-0.1769828051328659,
-0.3203490674495697,
0.044391218572854996,
0.07882644236087799,
0.48078444600105286,
0.2569397985935211,
-0.34408870339393616,
0.1809454709291458,
-0.692664384841919,
0.8463659286499023,
0.9599200487136841,
0.2297159731388092,
-0.02470177784562111,
-0.46848446130752563,
0.1321229636669159,
0.04852895811200142,
-0.13832694292068481,
-0.9322587847709656,
-0.14667922258377075,
0.142821803689003,
0.39011460542678833,
0.34448543190956116,
-0.14033721387386322,
1.1254727840423584,
-0.7780770063400269,
0.5869978070259094,
0.45782241225242615,
-0.6971434354782104,
0.5811448097229004,
-0.23364195227622986,
0.3768214285373688,
0.5631757974624634,
0.15162529051303864,
-0.4064224660396576,
-0.040981780737638474,
-0.018315425142645836,
-0.7009397149085999,
0.2889074981212616,
0.0826549381017685,
-0.12462253868579865,
-0.01991034857928753,
0.11781523376703262,
-0.031873296946287155,
-0.013485935516655445,
-0.515218198299408,
-0.21734952926635742,
-0.0906517505645752,
0.15858297049999237,
0.22705568373203278,
-0.566776692867279,
-0.06805858761072159,
-0.5446434020996094,
0.3538172245025635,
-0.33581042289733887,
0.3578673303127289,
0.4335392415523529,
-0.08589194715023041,
-0.31160688400268555,
0.3251746594905853,
0.428525447845459,
0.7472694516181946,
-0.25003620982170105,
0.45511364936828613,
-0.039718497544527054,
-0.2858591675758362,
0.20318655669689178,
-0.10483729094266891,
-0.16409148275852203,
-0.056760746985673904,
0.39937129616737366,
0.6005311012268066,
-0.4221896231174469,
-0.8316757678985596,
1.0589406490325928,
-0.3151562809944153,
-0.21848367154598236,
-0.14203327894210815,
-0.03984730690717697,
-0.06313784420490265,
0.8023265600204468,
0.3130527436733246,
0.41990119218826294,
0.4664749503135681,
-0.6159915924072266,
0.4266902506351471,
0.5698344707489014,
-0.6463404893875122,
-0.044952139258384705,
0.7317208051681519,
0.0014975483063608408,
-0.19723327457904816,
0.6762219071388245,
-0.21822701394557953,
-0.5972489714622498,
0.5124654173851013,
0.42043337225914,
0.6444727182388306,
-0.10175526142120361,
0.3531978130340576,
0.6494885683059692,
0.5890737175941467,
0.157963365316391,
0.8764457702636719,
-0.14295688271522522,
-0.552136242389679,
-0.5836715698242188,
-0.15913400053977966,
-0.36150068044662476,
-0.1630040407180786,
-0.6211559176445007,
0.23803621530532837,
-0.2721310555934906,
-0.10435349494218826,
0.043441709131002426,
-0.3470878601074219,
-0.772803008556366,
0.27749499678611755,
0.28378787636756897,
0.8344295024871826,
-0.627013623714447,
0.49250778555870056,
0.5766834616661072,
-0.6428812146186829,
-0.8671155571937561,
0.08453990519046783,
0.49458399415016174,
-0.871015727519989,
0.49346983432769775,
0.3357590138912201,
-0.5505918264389038,
-0.08498884737491608,
-0.569267988204956,
-0.6803426742553711,
1.1584728956222534,
-0.14195488393306732,
-0.3324476182460785,
0.20724523067474365,
-0.07935447990894318,
0.2578396499156952,
-0.1471341848373413,
0.6802510619163513,
0.19215066730976105,
0.4974576532840729,
0.8206332325935364,
-1.0465854406356812,
-0.09855092316865921,
-0.6082919239997864,
0.020720576867461205,
0.10611269623041153,
-0.7233019471168518,
0.9201333522796631,
-0.8660202026367188,
0.0622914619743824,
0.18409651517868042,
0.4210520088672638,
0.5879380702972412,
0.7518219351768494,
0.6289405226707458,
0.3312285840511322,
0.6768026947975159,
-0.022313054651021957,
0.6523967981338501,
0.13700959086418152,
0.008796822279691696,
1.22771155834198,
0.027234496548771858,
1.0666908025741577,
0.7901033163070679,
0.08872278034687042,
0.3867928087711334,
0.48537304997444153,
0.24469535052776337,
0.6714397668838501,
-0.0036229738034307957,
-0.18355746567249298,
-0.6225275993347168,
0.011455290019512177,
-0.4856564700603485,
0.6713656187057495,
0.0945497676730156,
0.1830420345067978,
-0.04506763815879822,
0.06700976938009262,
-0.20005731284618378,
-0.18446727097034454,
-0.24338839948177338,
0.9108852744102478,
-0.10446787625551224,
-0.47880253195762634,
0.6264273524284363,
-0.1470392644405365,
0.3966328501701355,
-0.3875117599964142,
-0.46459880471229553,
-0.06586933135986328,
0.1080971211194992,
0.19355712831020355,
-0.8203811645507812,
0.12466896325349808,
0.13836835324764252,
-0.34133535623550415,
0.10423765331506729,
0.5976113677024841,
-0.36601829528808594,
-0.627435028553009,
0.16483193635940552,
1.1461210250854492,
0.06298752129077911,
-0.32599103450775146,
-0.6191327571868896,
-0.11570621281862259,
-0.20926839113235474,
-0.10602205991744995,
-0.20918872952461243,
0.9648224711418152,
-0.20219998061656952,
0.8117766976356506,
0.7170011401176453,
-0.3113859295845032,
0.3385462462902069,
0.1350443959236145,
0.8421904444694519,
-0.7009127736091614,
-0.4244930148124695,
-0.634972095489502,
1.0123662948608398,
-0.04096176475286484,
-0.37370389699935913,
0.5742009282112122,
0.5693333148956299,
0.6220665574073792,
-0.09016363322734833,
0.6168477535247803,
-0.04344945773482323,
0.6220061182975769,
-0.6143384575843811,
0.13075029850006104,
-0.8630355596542358,
0.13693661987781525,
-0.2930485010147095,
-0.6671395301818848,
-0.3005279004573822,
0.5995710492134094,
-0.25822922587394714,
-0.16054150462150574,
0.7291796207427979,
0.9118664860725403,
-0.23056244850158691,
-0.33234143257141113,
0.24583140015602112,
0.14936354756355286,
0.29013222455978394,
0.7139993906021118,
1.36980140209198,
-0.46718674898147583,
0.8101844191551208,
-0.10399504750967026,
-0.6054171323776245,
-0.3104213774204254,
-0.654954731464386,
-0.7420955896377563,
-0.7029351592063904,
-0.19233430922031403,
-0.3393765091896057,
0.008012630045413971,
0.6986958980560303,
0.5132850408554077,
-0.5790774822235107,
0.029706384986639023,
0.06540965288877487,
0.03293120115995407,
-0.6727240681648254,
-0.22492855787277222,
0.17140232026576996,
-0.1935705542564392,
-0.22435395419597626,
0.3875468373298645,
0.5170869827270508,
-0.22445012629032135,
0.16013602912425995,
-0.14188559353351593,
-0.3601282238960266,
0.18678341805934906,
0.8912756443023682,
0.23219585418701172,
-0.947051465511322,
-0.622656524181366,
0.446182519197464,
0.07731367647647858,
0.37824752926826477,
0.7355148792266846,
-0.7229762673377991,
1.0726251602172852,
0.5624353885650635,
0.5089297294616699,
0.3378836214542389,
0.15360254049301147,
0.2943283021450043,
-0.32272273302078247,
-0.0839705616235733,
0.22221830487251282,
0.24999666213989258,
0.043391332030296326,
-0.08035393804311752,
0.3937895596027374,
0.3861541152000427,
-0.432869017124176,
-0.4208057224750519,
0.3926877975463867,
-1.447999119758606,
-0.21988174319267273,
1.238410472869873,
0.29100239276885986,
-0.03811265155673027,
-0.17053551971912384,
-0.8169719576835632,
0.12345977127552032,
-0.11535733938217163,
0.4839368462562561,
0.4689612090587616,
-0.36698827147483826,
-0.6015013456344604,
-0.7593779563903809,
0.24785417318344116,
0.07593011856079102,
-0.7845461964607239,
-0.18778830766677856,
0.9406825304031372,
0.2622634470462799,
-0.03565240651369095,
1.0680032968521118,
-0.0378548689186573,
0.7506850957870483,
0.12183205783367157,
-0.2919490933418274,
-0.15297284722328186,
-0.8569844365119934,
-0.10871558636426926,
0.09999791532754898,
0.02670801244676113,
-0.590233564376831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11051v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11051v1 | Large Language Models Fall Short: Understanding Complex Relationships in Detective Narratives | 2024-02-16T19:59:45 | 2024-02-16T19:59:45 | Runcong Zhao, Qinglin Zhu, Hainiu Xu, Jiazheng Li, Yuxiang Zhou, Yulan He, Lin Gui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing datasets for narrative understanding often fail to represent the
complexity and uncertainty of relationships in real-life social scenarios. To
address this gap, we introduce a new benchmark, Conan, designed for extracting
and analysing intricate character relation graphs from detective narratives.
Specifically, we designed hierarchical relationship categories and manually
extracted and annotated role-oriented relationships from the perspectives of
various characters, incorporating both public relationships known to most
characters and secret ones known to only a few. Our experiments with advanced
Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Llama2 reveal their
limitations in inferencing complex relationships and handling longer
narratives. The combination of the Conan dataset and our pipeline strategy is
geared towards understanding the ability of LLMs to comprehend nuanced
relational dynamics in narrative contexts. | [
-0.13123229146003723,
-0.5765184760093689,
0.876216471195221,
0.15838313102722168,
-0.23081162571907043,
0.40426573157310486,
-0.0015367214800789952,
-0.8505687117576599,
0.08608394116163254,
0.6163759231567383,
-0.7681323885917664,
-0.3464657664299011,
-0.7463909387588501,
0.27944067120552063,
-0.03301320597529411,
1.197922945022583,
-0.004983608145266771,
-0.1327323168516159,
-0.052405063062906265,
-0.28866907954216003,
-0.21882767975330353,
-0.5014512538909912,
-0.789190411567688,
-0.3687741756439209,
0.9552080035209656,
-0.16944698989391327,
0.9551366567611694,
0.7242975831031799,
0.6108587980270386,
0.08198655396699905,
-0.14732873439788818,
0.5984707474708557,
-1.0305804014205933,
0.21495094895362854,
-0.050967831164598465,
-0.5061255097389221,
-0.5781412720680237,
0.10352502763271332,
0.3144356310367584,
1.0167495012283325,
0.23115742206573486,
0.04478243365883827,
-0.1901722103357315,
0.5819572806358337,
-0.6817048192024231,
0.83172607421875,
-0.27795663475990295,
0.10996638238430023,
-0.3604036569595337,
-0.10496851801872253,
-0.31237053871154785,
-0.23645035922527313,
0.5157933235168457,
-0.749427080154419,
0.258266806602478,
0.23663641512393951,
1.0026865005493164,
-0.11625580489635468,
-0.6954637765884399,
-0.5867041945457458,
-0.7172146439552307,
0.5209774374961853,
-0.39353322982788086,
-0.06262552738189697,
0.7071574330329895,
0.45845794677734375,
-0.30553656816482544,
-0.6817507147789001,
-0.3201596736907959,
-0.41315385699272156,
-0.12814876437187195,
0.024378977715969086,
-0.3242945373058319,
0.0976390540599823,
0.2934727966785431,
0.328648179769516,
-0.38776397705078125,
-0.01565679907798767,
-0.523415207862854,
0.023041807115077972,
0.7888187766075134,
0.7364293932914734,
0.2532837390899658,
-0.2322668880224228,
0.08427804708480835,
-0.257495641708374,
-0.926509439945221,
0.12335889786481857,
0.6695414185523987,
0.26859891414642334,
-0.05615440011024475,
0.5157593488693237,
0.18028222024440765,
0.38520970940589905,
-0.1136241927742958,
-0.3003302216529846,
0.031652942299842834,
-0.01057466585189104,
-0.01032995618879795,
0.07068715244531631,
1.054268717765808,
0.5616347193717957,
0.8141204714775085,
-0.20439539849758148,
0.2525119185447693,
-0.0914015918970108,
0.18287622928619385,
-0.8002336025238037,
-0.41067415475845337,
0.03508428856730461,
-0.3341059386730194,
-0.5087156295776367,
-0.1660485714673996,
-0.6965662240982056,
-0.8230919241905212,
0.11798128485679626,
0.03451899066567421,
-0.2919127941131592,
-0.2737273573875427,
0.014087351970374584,
-0.21703028678894043,
0.16934697329998016,
0.4739997684955597,
-0.7385526895523071,
0.3554912805557251,
0.7178665399551392,
0.9302103519439697,
-0.20819197595119476,
-0.29689982533454895,
-0.6577602624893188,
0.5564247369766235,
-0.6175645589828491,
0.3876560926437378,
-0.6431024670600891,
-0.14848361909389496,
0.01144140213727951,
0.22988776862621307,
0.10485801845788956,
-0.3528112769126892,
0.6064328551292419,
-0.5310832858085632,
-0.09562816470861435,
-0.218854621052742,
-0.405550479888916,
-0.1422618329524994,
0.34383001923561096,
-0.8501572012901306,
0.5687814950942993,
0.06862230598926544,
-0.8150344491004944,
0.12376908212900162,
-0.1234346404671669,
-0.658789873123169,
-0.16756680607795715,
-0.08234608918428421,
-0.33570972084999084,
0.09471020102500916,
0.42080578207969666,
0.8838993310928345,
-0.6833217144012451,
0.5756515264511108,
-0.758368730545044,
-0.34231823682785034,
0.009970839135348797,
-0.18130037188529968,
0.8534892201423645,
0.1823352873325348,
0.14393045008182526,
-0.29594695568084717,
-0.915912926197052,
-0.605236828327179,
0.39538130164146423,
-0.05664924532175064,
-0.5807750225067139,
0.3733074367046356,
-0.08520959317684174,
-0.18535107374191284,
0.07916253805160522,
-0.4371182918548584,
0.35923510789871216,
0.05302959308028221,
0.7999436855316162,
0.43691182136535645,
-0.010644099675118923,
-0.0018187445821240544,
-0.08401986211538315,
0.8526511788368225,
-0.20904852449893951,
-0.3308121860027313,
-0.22033847868442535,
-0.3630337715148926,
-0.4560515880584717,
-0.2731066644191742,
0.06483776867389679,
0.5398381948471069,
-0.41173651814460754,
0.4116672873497009,
-0.4972737431526184,
-0.572394073009491,
-0.405486524105072,
-0.1953931301832199,
0.43895912170410156,
0.1664661169052124,
0.10068957507610321,
-0.3501739799976349,
-0.2774895131587982,
-0.7034153938293457,
-0.36676549911499023,
-0.4693548381328583,
-0.17373354732990265,
0.2240563929080963,
0.2979394793510437,
-0.29796770215034485,
0.9789628982543945,
-0.9101663827896118,
-0.4115016758441925,
-0.5085945129394531,
0.2634429335594177,
0.1215975284576416,
0.16698932647705078,
0.4347940683364868,
-0.37885782122612,
-0.3257785737514496,
0.08373810350894928,
-0.9283736944198608,
0.11315224319696426,
0.007758305408060551,
0.24024222791194916,
-0.5348910093307495,
0.6616528630256653,
-0.6445233225822449,
0.4329353868961334,
0.5336140990257263,
-0.03791147470474243,
0.8063463568687439,
-0.09639250487089157,
-0.05064018815755844,
-0.8984867334365845,
-0.055927541106939316,
0.13433986902236938,
-0.5379829406738281,
-0.4930213987827301,
-0.10178454965353012,
-0.02998739667236805,
-0.4030606746673584,
0.11109402775764465,
0.3963598310947418,
-0.6059309840202332,
-0.31682026386260986,
0.2965069115161896,
0.40036115050315857,
0.1508844494819641,
0.6173121333122253,
0.12153082340955734,
0.5229012370109558,
0.3322104811668396,
-0.2152186632156372,
0.545333206653595,
0.20222240686416626,
-0.49851149320602417,
0.4820415675640106,
-0.8592943549156189,
0.09092371165752411,
-0.20000800490379333,
0.5967037081718445,
-1.1120398044586182,
-0.5280134677886963,
-0.05272694677114487,
-0.26043596863746643,
0.5184337496757507,
-0.7538523077964783,
-0.8157048225402832,
-0.16122034192085266,
-0.24470330774784088,
0.4779270887374878,
0.16540735960006714,
-0.38524678349494934,
0.3825177252292633,
0.5254496932029724,
-0.2624587118625641,
-0.5406284332275391,
-0.6290183663368225,
0.26799631118774414,
-0.3712225556373596,
-0.7866875529289246,
-0.07513447105884552,
0.14894181489944458,
-0.36341598629951477,
-0.03428904712200165,
-0.02293485961854458,
-0.4812929034233093,
-0.03664596006274223,
0.08553178608417511,
0.02163504995405674,
-0.3215002119541168,
0.09332965314388275,
0.20813427865505219,
-0.08305186033248901,
0.2234705686569214,
0.5940700173377991,
0.43250155448913574,
-0.1905388981103897,
0.004749776795506477,
-0.26639142632484436,
0.17026185989379883,
1.0714436769485474,
-0.3302345275878906,
0.7452687621116638,
0.5741381645202637,
-0.18443477153778076,
-0.003403474809601903,
-0.25631171464920044,
0.20155449211597443,
-0.3774951100349426,
0.6928991079330444,
-0.6565881371498108,
-0.9840444326400757,
0.8405340909957886,
-0.1040213480591774,
-0.34004783630371094,
0.2350270003080368,
0.006538461893796921,
-0.05955495685338974,
1.1436631679534912,
0.38278403878211975,
-0.29877328872680664,
0.09926839172840118,
-0.18728074431419373,
0.737552285194397,
-1.1206609010696411,
-0.025143656879663467,
-0.19764544069766998,
0.0991230234503746,
-0.6926113367080688,
0.049951907247304916,
0.37082886695861816,
0.46985936164855957,
-0.09946467727422714,
0.6342450380325317,
-0.024278057739138603,
0.5400406718254089,
-0.05852701514959335,
-0.05811302736401558,
0.5741893649101257,
-0.23310595750808716,
0.40567746758461,
-0.1673375368118286,
-0.4324871897697449,
-0.582219123840332,
1.0085242986679077,
0.6010473966598511,
0.9947729110717773,
0.30007004737854004,
0.22871755063533783,
0.14960765838623047,
-0.12786567211151123,
-0.7145070433616638,
0.317293256521225,
-0.2667814791202545,
-0.673629105091095,
-0.32387304306030273,
-0.5374143719673157,
-1.4226582050323486,
0.20623576641082764,
0.01499962154775858,
-0.8704901337623596,
0.26690611243247986,
-0.28652429580688477,
-0.37601858377456665,
0.21452198922634125,
-0.5361247062683105,
0.7534050941467285,
0.07757005840539932,
-0.42500442266464233,
-0.12002509087324142,
-0.9358182549476624,
0.6126111149787903,
0.13397927582263947,
0.14151351153850555,
-0.589238703250885,
0.24026645720005035,
0.6494930982589722,
-0.5302736163139343,
0.8875750303268433,
0.26816678047180176,
-0.12856443226337433,
0.14822843670845032,
0.6242409944534302,
0.7440535426139832,
0.15355205535888672,
-0.24291476607322693,
-0.03851469233632088,
0.19931170344352722,
-0.34801098704338074,
-0.45245659351348877,
0.5573119521141052,
-0.8026997447013855,
-0.2701966464519501,
-0.6259134411811829,
-0.7867900133132935,
-0.4713597595691681,
0.05769156292080879,
0.1685197800397873,
0.8222746253013611,
-0.363079696893692,
0.23756402730941772,
0.42353007197380066,
-0.11039003729820251,
0.19876506924629211,
0.2193906009197235,
-0.0832330659031868,
-0.21700038015842438,
0.6787977814674377,
0.1238698810338974,
0.42308309674263,
0.2643192708492279,
0.18638184666633606,
-0.13379068672657013,
-0.5314100384712219,
-0.3327043354511261,
0.423780620098114,
-0.5862182974815369,
-0.049969207495450974,
-0.786882221698761,
-0.112834632396698,
-0.2563709020614624,
-0.15564952790737152,
-0.3607650399208069,
-0.1222916916012764,
-0.33866891264915466,
-0.2640502452850342,
0.4442194700241089,
1.123054027557373,
0.2724209725856781,
0.2666929364204407,
-0.7804321050643921,
0.2635602653026581,
0.42288070917129517,
0.11955032497644424,
0.22766806185245514,
-0.12731918692588806,
-0.062416788190603256,
-0.29335519671440125,
-0.1602497398853302,
-0.772013247013092,
0.5362042188644409,
0.1682766079902649,
0.15055063366889954,
0.6094658374786377,
0.2814214527606964,
0.9839478135108948,
-0.40140414237976074,
0.7444067597389221,
0.08538062870502472,
-0.7570840120315552,
0.41919881105422974,
-1.028277039527893,
0.014023270457983017,
0.6786746382713318,
0.4358852803707123,
-0.42559462785720825,
-0.48977726697921753,
-0.457794725894928,
-0.7514658570289612,
0.8845685124397278,
0.37032321095466614,
0.07426516711711884,
-0.12429969012737274,
0.3600641191005707,
0.09759937971830368,
0.40736162662506104,
-0.8650933504104614,
-0.18071138858795166,
0.4119080901145935,
-0.21766190230846405,
-0.2895765006542206,
-0.31574133038520813,
-0.08036419749259949,
-0.13690926134586334,
0.22178401052951813,
-0.12243784219026566,
0.037872109562158585,
0.2403879314661026,
-0.1926179826259613,
-0.22288691997528076,
-0.20421934127807617,
0.24435316026210785,
1.1307830810546875,
-0.651344358921051,
0.20393307507038116,
-0.13259932398796082,
-0.507818341255188,
-0.1861398071050644,
0.04166677966713905,
0.34660422801971436,
-0.2624611258506775,
1.2285141944885254,
0.8836824297904968,
0.11924956738948822,
-0.8355104327201843,
0.7519704699516296,
-0.14508236944675446,
0.1616438776254654,
-0.24918189644813538,
-0.0007680474082008004,
0.17572659254074097,
0.3198677599430084,
0.27883395552635193,
-0.20540845394134521,
0.02605484612286091,
-1.3284403085708618,
-0.12227719277143478,
0.09624390304088593,
-0.7310926914215088,
-0.372324138879776,
0.49244424700737,
0.06692216545343399,
-0.21061360836029053,
0.7488282918930054,
-0.4546082019805908,
-0.4199208915233612,
0.7953038215637207,
0.4256027340888977,
0.8020322918891907,
0.20836375653743744,
0.2826913297176361,
0.31136998534202576,
0.3884701728820801,
-0.1378500610589981,
-0.485053151845932,
0.14979895949363708,
-0.6410720348358154,
-0.5111186504364014,
-0.35334035754203796,
-0.4203639328479767,
0.47628331184387207,
-0.9480623602867126,
0.1340107023715973,
-0.5111510753631592,
0.2638811767101288,
-0.08445049822330475,
0.35971498489379883,
-0.466168075799942,
0.001824512961320579,
-0.36519667506217957,
0.3824350833892822,
-0.9059839248657227,
0.9066929221153259,
0.13549275696277618,
-0.5560478568077087,
-0.7791507244110107,
0.2745341956615448,
-0.09734328836202621,
-0.8512098789215088,
0.6064305305480957,
0.3368801474571228,
-0.24528583884239197,
-0.25131991505622864,
-0.5241357684135437,
-0.5680496096611023,
1.191379189491272,
0.48955902457237244,
-0.7088315486907959,
-0.1543942391872406,
0.05249164626002312,
0.9766703248023987,
-0.8170146942138672,
0.2033037394285202,
0.727716863155365,
0.22027599811553955,
0.036767877638339996,
-0.874750018119812,
0.13761509954929352,
-0.19539882242679596,
-0.2543390989303589,
0.2326008826494217,
-0.7662805318832397,
0.8014317750930786,
-0.22359433770179749,
-0.09805075079202652,
0.22651676833629608,
0.3929852843284607,
0.3212563693523407,
0.5944969654083252,
0.4899018704891205,
0.39573973417282104,
0.810309886932373,
-0.009875595569610596,
1.2998346090316772,
0.10930735617876053,
0.33132532238960266,
1.419492483139038,
-0.5118318200111389,
0.5686750411987305,
-0.01131585892289877,
-0.34648770093917847,
0.49891236424446106,
0.9187645316123962,
-0.1810940057039261,
0.5262852311134338,
0.25372886657714844,
0.06625727564096451,
-0.33277052640914917,
-0.0013011726550757885,
-0.37116438150405884,
0.2982712686061859,
0.3923075795173645,
-0.28136470913887024,
-0.019437666982412338,
-0.3456548750400543,
0.4680093824863434,
-0.09309878945350647,
-0.2854368984699249,
0.5756838917732239,
0.18262480199337006,
-0.5400070548057556,
0.2154858559370041,
-0.2596811354160309,
0.21639247238636017,
-0.8194273114204407,
-0.004267050419002771,
-0.13424816727638245,
0.1497943252325058,
-0.017049547284841537,
-0.8701767921447754,
0.02954588644206524,
-0.037719860672950745,
-0.14836923778057098,
0.298382967710495,
0.437602162361145,
-0.5266963839530945,
-0.5299742221832275,
0.7192363739013672,
0.26086363196372986,
0.3200858235359192,
-0.13655981421470642,
-0.34620344638824463,
0.27431222796440125,
-0.13613270223140717,
-0.03789934888482094,
0.3190034329891205,
0.8723016977310181,
-0.12933416664600372,
0.6734204292297363,
0.5558978319168091,
0.0870138630270958,
-0.11563505977392197,
0.07412297278642654,
0.6369516849517822,
-0.45258814096450806,
-0.47105398774147034,
-0.6684213876724243,
0.1812487691640854,
-0.238871231675148,
-0.6246122717857361,
0.6130954623222351,
0.427408903837204,
0.42778733372688293,
0.13161908090114594,
0.6366217732429504,
0.12439767271280289,
0.36465540528297424,
-0.3447767496109009,
0.5914647579193115,
-0.49982085824012756,
0.4903205335140228,
-0.5572634339332581,
-1.021619439125061,
-0.35878753662109375,
0.5522531270980835,
-0.32951346039772034,
-0.28526565432548523,
0.8277600407600403,
0.5596322417259216,
-0.23995545506477356,
0.011069703847169876,
0.2735593020915985,
0.3237203061580658,
0.5851793885231018,
0.7248292565345764,
0.938499391078949,
-0.440142422914505,
0.8264315128326416,
0.1676841527223587,
-0.10133510082960129,
-0.19338345527648926,
-0.9190119504928589,
-1.5012564659118652,
-0.5138925909996033,
-0.17585276067256927,
-0.222878098487854,
0.27295809984207153,
0.5901899933815002,
0.8389114737510681,
-0.3400275409221649,
-0.41899409890174866,
-0.23881860077381134,
0.054921433329582214,
-0.11391574889421463,
-0.24874910712242126,
0.6379709839820862,
-0.07824279367923737,
-0.6137235760688782,
0.4373103678226471,
0.3123318552970886,
-0.27022334933280945,
-0.37109899520874023,
-0.12613023817539215,
-0.003913407679647207,
0.022303977981209755,
0.7686783075332642,
0.12916281819343567,
-0.5918019413948059,
-0.4015616476535797,
-0.3610033094882965,
0.10209684818983078,
0.11746588349342346,
1.0499550104141235,
-0.28486812114715576,
0.5929827094078064,
0.49811509251594543,
0.4486203193664551,
1.0854182243347168,
-0.20579813420772552,
1.0112935304641724,
-0.6232671737670898,
-0.10855745524168015,
0.2071887105703354,
0.24978207051753998,
0.2781173586845398,
-0.522719144821167,
0.8708685040473938,
0.14679241180419922,
-0.5509344339370728,
-0.9380612969398499,
0.47749415040016174,
-1.2162803411483765,
-0.3960658609867096,
0.986328125,
-0.6316124796867371,
-0.17178602516651154,
-0.4957362115383148,
-0.13179920613765717,
0.039095401763916016,
-0.4855916500091553,
0.6258046627044678,
0.9920063614845276,
-0.2794533669948578,
-0.12435763329267502,
-0.7138299942016602,
0.5082986950874329,
-0.11141586303710938,
-0.6519235968589783,
0.6398154497146606,
0.42067205905914307,
0.05866210535168648,
0.3383598327636719,
0.43668001890182495,
-0.16668283939361572,
-0.1344965547323227,
-0.031017519533634186,
-0.5861057043075562,
-0.1831279844045639,
-0.3601614534854889,
0.054603252559900284,
0.44988200068473816,
-0.28336867690086365,
0.20846913754940033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11035v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11035v2 | Retrieval-Augmented Generation: Is Dense Passage Retrieval Retrieving? | 2024-02-16T19:28:52 | 2024-04-16T20:22:21 | Benjamin Reichman, Larry Heck | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Dense passage retrieval (DPR) is the first step in the retrieval augmented
generation (RAG) paradigm for improving the performance of large language
models (LLM). DPR fine-tunes pre-trained networks to enhance the alignment of
the embeddings between queries and relevant textual data. A deeper
understanding of DPR fine-tuning will be required to fundamentally unlock the
full potential of this approach. In this work, we explore DPR-trained models
mechanistically by using a combination of probing, layer activation analysis,
and model editing. Our experiments show that DPR training decentralizes how
knowledge is stored in the network, creating multiple access pathways to the
same information. We also uncover a limitation in this training style: the
internal knowledge of the pre-trained model bounds what the retrieval model can
retrieve. These findings suggest a few possible directions for dense retrieval:
(1) expose the DPR training process to more knowledge so more can be
decentralized, (2) inject facts as decentralized representations, (3) model and
incorporate knowledge uncertainty in the retrieval process, and (4) directly
map internal model knowledge to a knowledge base. | [
-0.253736674785614,
-0.742236852645874,
0.658804178237915,
-0.1356574296951294,
-0.18172411620616913,
0.2197287380695343,
-0.23386801779270172,
-0.3660441040992737,
-0.007783934939652681,
0.7689624428749084,
-0.2613152861595154,
-0.03780744969844818,
-0.5312718152999878,
0.08905190974473953,
-0.29545828700065613,
0.8960023522377014,
0.04181215912103653,
0.1765224039554596,
-0.050098683685064316,
0.04653842747211456,
-0.35432738065719604,
-0.6199729442596436,
-0.6847941875457764,
-0.5107104182243347,
0.6201308965682983,
0.4252561032772064,
0.6517800688743591,
0.7584164142608643,
0.7186025977134705,
0.32730910181999207,
-0.2966340482234955,
0.3512488007545471,
-0.706478476524353,
0.32242223620414734,
-0.31033796072006226,
-0.6077821850776672,
-0.206363707780838,
-0.1214742362499237,
1.0211321115493774,
0.9129899740219116,
-0.10976838320493698,
-0.06316529214382172,
0.08868618309497833,
0.8886925578117371,
-0.6994959712028503,
-0.2874830663204193,
-0.8751651048660278,
0.03991330415010452,
-0.21793556213378906,
-0.43808797001838684,
-0.45886504650115967,
0.0042569758370518684,
0.21193602681159973,
-0.401630163192749,
0.4840894341468811,
0.22525323927402496,
0.6966651678085327,
0.34712061285972595,
-0.4175584614276886,
-0.24219423532485962,
-0.7232858538627625,
0.6972166895866394,
-0.3498672544956207,
0.428233802318573,
0.4031260013580322,
0.3511640727519989,
-0.16271281242370605,
-0.9924576878547668,
-0.5865978002548218,
-0.3474518060684204,
-0.19653207063674927,
-0.19600486755371094,
0.31561020016670227,
0.2549026906490326,
0.17427493631839752,
0.6958959698677063,
-0.3187373876571655,
0.04748481139540672,
-0.3745594620704651,
-0.002353576710447669,
0.7360341548919678,
0.14931976795196533,
0.2552658021450043,
-0.21720077097415924,
-0.48287704586982727,
-0.21103964745998383,
-0.6355029344558716,
-0.22065065801143646,
0.27714264392852783,
0.5448475480079651,
0.21451769769191742,
0.7554882764816284,
-0.30940037965774536,
0.958072304725647,
0.21435147523880005,
0.020315658301115036,
0.06875020265579224,
-0.5686457753181458,
-0.11584418267011642,
0.1957508772611618,
0.6136457920074463,
-0.1587081253528595,
0.030878687277436256,
-0.21423549950122833,
-0.6309162974357605,
-0.6606529951095581,
0.5102518796920776,
-0.7155589461326599,
-0.2701782286167145,
0.07642075419425964,
-0.37717923521995544,
-0.23265552520751953,
-0.01810704730451107,
-0.34944918751716614,
-0.39872443675994873,
-0.6862635612487793,
0.600719690322876,
-0.4754122197628021,
-0.5319643616676331,
0.33927813172340393,
-0.4158642292022705,
0.04427624121308327,
0.1998712569475174,
-1.0139105319976807,
0.47827279567718506,
0.8415184617042542,
0.7668192386627197,
0.0421392060816288,
-0.34266677498817444,
-0.4172813594341278,
0.2069815695285797,
-0.3316093385219574,
0.6499459743499756,
-0.6351543664932251,
-0.07948915660381317,
-0.15847183763980865,
-0.3611556887626648,
-0.051778893917798996,
-0.5648265480995178,
0.26209449768066406,
-1.0695877075195312,
-0.09766516834497452,
-0.6617574095726013,
-0.6706312894821167,
-0.0738481804728508,
0.37709566950798035,
-0.7337576746940613,
0.9373469352722168,
0.1486411690711975,
-0.9386805891990662,
0.4650331139564514,
-0.2797386050224304,
-0.17578987777233124,
0.08059787005186081,
-0.2960265576839447,
-0.2119496613740921,
0.22999471426010132,
0.15029393136501312,
0.40544265508651733,
-0.11526963859796524,
0.18765141069889069,
-0.22726912796497345,
-0.4099319577217102,
0.24053165316581726,
-0.32447201013565063,
0.7544732689857483,
0.3508951663970947,
-0.05416633188724518,
-0.26334986090660095,
-0.6179419755935669,
-0.05805234983563423,
0.06305695325136185,
-0.4175761938095093,
-0.5983768701553345,
-0.16219402849674225,
-0.39230212569236755,
-0.06709899008274078,
0.3594381511211395,
-0.5348863005638123,
0.5757750868797302,
-0.35965898633003235,
0.3190585970878601,
0.5452058911323547,
0.4131428599357605,
0.8755110502243042,
-0.2826962172985077,
0.24931468069553375,
0.13853229582309723,
0.09926058351993561,
0.030499298125505447,
-0.04182637482881546,
-0.5190142393112183,
-0.13680274784564972,
0.4199860990047455,
0.16482634842395782,
-0.7127229571342468,
0.010749836452305317,
-0.2597382068634033,
-0.42061132192611694,
-0.44342929124832153,
0.18386352062225342,
0.3893479108810425,
0.6589128971099854,
0.40540456771850586,
-0.08336308598518372,
-0.48386117815971375,
-0.6453728675842285,
-0.13819250464439392,
0.03749200329184532,
0.29322847723960876,
0.34421297907829285,
0.48471376299858093,
-0.13384179770946503,
0.7351597547531128,
-0.5188128352165222,
-0.3562367558479309,
-0.39750778675079346,
0.05666042119264603,
0.21838264167308807,
0.5470690131187439,
0.3647194504737854,
-1.0661741495132446,
-0.46893197298049927,
0.0497349388897419,
-0.5560749769210815,
0.08123047649860382,
-0.11836062371730804,
-0.29145172238349915,
-0.3908346891403198,
0.7170171737670898,
-0.3926369249820709,
0.01132175698876381,
0.22950558364391327,
0.01697186566889286,
0.508263349533081,
-0.41056960821151733,
0.1778232306241989,
-0.9435559511184692,
-0.07363495975732803,
-0.37821584939956665,
-0.05135499686002731,
-0.5501984357833862,
0.22660449147224426,
0.0960230752825737,
-0.11782796680927277,
-0.15925611555576324,
0.5477677583694458,
-0.8466482162475586,
-0.3468194603919983,
-0.3430800139904022,
0.2925613224506378,
0.3156903386116028,
0.21965771913528442,
0.11110913008451462,
0.9755962491035461,
0.4154718816280365,
-0.8244411945343018,
0.1322452425956726,
0.363361656665802,
-0.36226892471313477,
0.12198758870363235,
-0.7161716818809509,
0.2340860813856125,
-0.34594297409057617,
0.10861855745315552,
-0.8696378469467163,
-0.20837512612342834,
-0.1437569558620453,
-0.2477390021085739,
0.7098366618156433,
-0.3384522795677185,
-0.4832291901111603,
0.03008914366364479,
0.07635316252708435,
0.6955095529556274,
0.15525849163532257,
-0.5413695573806763,
0.4734838008880615,
0.4684808850288391,
-0.03726824373006821,
-0.9152669906616211,
-0.5850852131843567,
-0.03278028592467308,
0.09429560601711273,
-0.5235748291015625,
0.567776083946228,
0.3140758275985718,
-0.46164029836654663,
-0.07516362518072128,
0.0562712587416172,
-0.3486873209476471,
0.039415791630744934,
-0.17650748789310455,
-0.1797787845134735,
-0.1468832939863205,
0.36593061685562134,
0.18947705626487732,
0.1592375934123993,
-0.13348804414272308,
-0.11179444193840027,
0.6273148655891418,
0.06473120301961899,
-0.47172829508781433,
-0.2001749873161316,
0.2305758148431778,
0.1779814064502716,
-0.6478644609451294,
0.7502577304840088,
0.40298011898994446,
-0.2001693993806839,
-0.4374350905418396,
-0.526301383972168,
-0.4658660590648651,
-0.4957762360572815,
0.3166477382183075,
-0.6115970015525818,
-0.8893304467201233,
0.4562133252620697,
-0.07433807849884033,
-0.21367721259593964,
0.23112240433692932,
0.3103102445602417,
-0.042277395725250244,
0.8832939863204956,
0.7175047993659973,
0.12810349464416504,
0.6902059316635132,
-0.545724630355835,
-0.09938692301511765,
-1.154727816581726,
-0.22439414262771606,
-0.5127893090248108,
-0.46445155143737793,
-0.3608514070510864,
-0.3689859211444855,
0.43351778388023376,
0.5318974256515503,
-0.3991832733154297,
0.14624252915382385,
-0.6351717710494995,
0.5692213177680969,
0.48696956038475037,
0.5355560779571533,
0.4372093379497528,
0.1382857710123062,
-0.1870816946029663,
-0.09684186428785324,
-0.9654400944709778,
-0.24198855459690094,
1.114151120185852,
0.22148756682872772,
0.6973404288291931,
0.06191994249820709,
0.981025755405426,
0.13740850985050201,
0.04524228721857071,
-0.4846135675907135,
0.42650923132896423,
-0.10736829787492752,
-0.74567049741745,
-0.35365137457847595,
-0.5469348430633545,
-0.9213757514953613,
0.1589731127023697,
-0.21207420527935028,
-0.20156778395175934,
0.44987109303474426,
0.11039295792579651,
-0.39338943362236023,
0.3530585765838623,
-0.5582084655761719,
0.5155240297317505,
-0.4216547906398773,
-0.4571249186992645,
-0.3707064092159271,
-0.5570353865623474,
0.30107876658439636,
0.03775390237569809,
-0.2736799418926239,
0.2160724401473999,
-0.07277970761060715,
0.3292178213596344,
-0.34743326902389526,
0.6991906762123108,
-0.2800193428993225,
0.00973337423056364,
0.4167904853820801,
0.21926970779895782,
0.45370760560035706,
0.1725502610206604,
-0.2932600677013397,
-0.1120205968618393,
-0.2120734006166458,
-0.38802406191825867,
-0.7125250101089478,
0.4905827045440674,
-0.866115152835846,
-0.4733337461948395,
-0.35440993309020996,
-0.4663887619972229,
-0.11217494308948517,
0.38502201437950134,
0.16438789665699005,
0.6816704869270325,
-0.024287236854434013,
0.3093602657318115,
1.0586425065994263,
-0.08840247243642807,
0.061369117349386215,
0.5037398338317871,
-0.10759495943784714,
-0.2901369333267212,
0.7723295092582703,
0.29763102531433105,
0.36052465438842773,
0.9223966598510742,
0.18420661985874176,
-0.49946001172065735,
-0.9790502190589905,
-0.22565977275371552,
0.388947069644928,
-0.5784162282943726,
-0.19399450719356537,
-0.6985218524932861,
-0.358188658952713,
-0.35860675573349,
0.05703572556376457,
-0.45996615290641785,
-0.3177230954170227,
-0.41296449303627014,
-0.08788783848285675,
0.40277642011642456,
0.8368247151374817,
-0.28821855783462524,
0.3703859746456146,
-0.8138631582260132,
0.371482253074646,
0.3192451000213623,
0.4394609332084656,
0.06742718815803528,
-0.6816039681434631,
-0.36923494935035706,
0.24659761786460876,
-0.1304847002029419,
-0.7019065618515015,
0.16415612399578094,
0.34388914704322815,
0.49813607335090637,
0.19145765900611877,
0.16212446987628937,
0.7455095648765564,
-0.5435038805007935,
0.5080462694168091,
-0.23967918753623962,
-0.4463237524032593,
0.6005500555038452,
-0.424970418214798,
-0.11312518268823624,
0.8582605123519897,
0.4632207155227661,
-0.11988607794046402,
-0.025998109951615334,
-0.4685395359992981,
-0.6216855645179749,
0.4200023412704468,
-0.18835648894309998,
0.1548680067062378,
-0.10050049424171448,
0.9644150733947754,
-0.005276241339743137,
0.3279547691345215,
-0.421529084444046,
0.11189956963062286,
-0.027379045262932777,
0.012000557035207748,
0.008415495976805687,
-0.44151878356933594,
-0.1451026052236557,
-0.26860710978507996,
0.3968479633331299,
0.07328659296035767,
0.09558913856744766,
0.6402990221977234,
-0.25963112711906433,
-0.08949486166238785,
0.04507669061422348,
0.3565342128276825,
0.7783350348472595,
-0.26505759358406067,
0.17253558337688446,
-0.12439820915460587,
-0.5584281086921692,
0.15132176876068115,
-0.04011760279536247,
-0.29288822412490845,
-0.12800851464271545,
0.3994980454444885,
0.8358866572380066,
0.1531674861907959,
-0.4047161638736725,
0.4692581295967102,
0.00223755557090044,
-0.10944224148988724,
-0.41233259439468384,
0.16078664362430573,
-0.41168496012687683,
0.4718216061592102,
0.5223015546798706,
-0.017639880999922752,
0.3102514445781708,
-0.410128653049469,
0.4572049081325531,
0.47394639253616333,
-0.26718056201934814,
-0.19090838730335236,
0.5736595392227173,
0.01118306815624237,
-0.10467147827148438,
0.858512818813324,
-0.22072048485279083,
-0.5379438996315002,
0.24769441783428192,
0.40989744663238525,
0.6384667754173279,
-0.006294444669038057,
0.1560632437467575,
0.5383009910583496,
0.3701156675815582,
-0.37782174348831177,
0.3033565282821655,
-0.34969112277030945,
-0.9203002452850342,
-0.8159263134002686,
-0.7363526225090027,
-0.35068705677986145,
0.01554508414119482,
-0.7536675333976746,
0.07499466091394424,
-0.4125647246837616,
-0.07348547130823135,
-0.2777000963687897,
0.38153454661369324,
-0.510769248008728,
0.2521476745605469,
-0.07321663945913315,
0.9899107217788696,
-0.6014983654022217,
0.7014576196670532,
0.5272749066352844,
-0.6532886028289795,
-1.0733336210250854,
-0.03869280591607094,
-0.480421781539917,
-0.7842950820922852,
0.9527468085289001,
-0.18105176091194153,
0.052204955369234085,
0.2577815353870392,
-0.5634943842887878,
-0.9704928398132324,
0.9614976644515991,
0.3801651895046234,
-0.6253481507301331,
-0.1539858877658844,
0.1559980809688568,
0.6114347577095032,
-0.26391637325286865,
0.18214631080627441,
0.3428668677806854,
0.23449935019016266,
-0.14267335832118988,
-0.6961212158203125,
-0.0394272617995739,
-0.03857980668544769,
0.034863706678152084,
0.21498052775859833,
-0.5867770910263062,
1.085001826286316,
-0.3173515796661377,
-0.15673811733722687,
-0.07412492483854294,
0.6606853604316711,
0.2936312258243561,
0.07761545479297638,
0.39718303084373474,
0.839288592338562,
0.6793621182441711,
0.05682918801903725,
1.2490224838256836,
-0.2746584415435791,
0.06307549774646759,
1.2087863683700562,
-0.1969030797481537,
0.9554921984672546,
0.45784735679626465,
0.024616798385977745,
0.4016563594341278,
0.5570437908172607,
0.27776166796684265,
0.6630237698554993,
0.06089991703629494,
-0.34911003708839417,
-0.2704900801181793,
-0.19108469784259796,
-0.42707979679107666,
0.4724140167236328,
0.39503011107444763,
-0.47068721055984497,
-0.007720617111772299,
-0.0618712417781353,
-0.3096502125263214,
0.23027831315994263,
-0.48852965235710144,
1.0245678424835205,
0.09200423210859299,
-0.6986662149429321,
0.6769517660140991,
-0.3162115812301636,
0.19069059193134308,
-0.5068017244338989,
-0.17942595481872559,
-0.2771594524383545,
0.30405697226524353,
-0.17350196838378906,
-0.9332352876663208,
0.22969363629817963,
-0.41761547327041626,
-0.3555602431297302,
-0.34923866391181946,
0.9275116920471191,
-0.5020058751106262,
-0.19044247269630432,
0.27541929483413696,
0.6447644233703613,
0.010925518348813057,
-0.3465220332145691,
-0.7477620244026184,
0.08829697221517563,
-0.07466128468513489,
-0.34534144401550293,
0.4721567630767822,
1.0013033151626587,
0.14337201416492462,
0.6487377882003784,
0.595202624797821,
0.32984453439712524,
0.19811730086803436,
0.353908509016037,
1.0064295530319214,
-0.44731301069259644,
-0.15786856412887573,
-0.5814374089241028,
0.5048555135726929,
-0.18887992203235626,
-0.14706286787986755,
0.6944507956504822,
0.390547513961792,
0.874008059501648,
0.11621672660112381,
0.5475214123725891,
0.047607067972421646,
0.6385334730148315,
-0.537656307220459,
0.6612136960029602,
-0.6922717690467834,
0.24045710265636444,
-0.11690467596054077,
-0.946223795413971,
0.04830287769436836,
0.4739857614040375,
-0.30562007427215576,
0.0718066617846489,
0.42028293013572693,
0.8472480177879333,
-0.24914732575416565,
-0.2591862380504608,
0.0637504905462265,
0.2265171855688095,
0.08085184544324875,
0.13048629462718964,
0.8595775961875916,
-0.523856520652771,
0.4740236699581146,
-0.6112373471260071,
-0.18149663507938385,
-0.12751613557338715,
-0.6368777751922607,
-0.6552652716636658,
-0.7088589668273926,
0.024403773248195648,
-0.14180056750774384,
0.03724135458469391,
0.47834184765815735,
0.5202533602714539,
-0.37005168199539185,
-0.14302438497543335,
-0.3802565932273865,
0.054396625608205795,
-0.15173320472240448,
-0.20943230390548706,
0.15387041866779327,
-0.7319377064704895,
-0.4930497407913208,
0.5926238894462585,
0.05412362143397331,
0.10877012461423874,
-0.34080079197883606,
0.03427569568157196,
-0.3818344175815582,
-0.308352530002594,
0.4142549932003021,
0.180204838514328,
-0.16020573675632477,
-0.16967317461967468,
0.19743111729621887,
-0.20333653688430786,
-0.19011501967906952,
0.9726744294166565,
-0.6284754276275635,
0.5840961933135986,
0.75669926404953,
0.9323562979698181,
0.5942140817642212,
0.18328934907913208,
0.7405649423599243,
-1.094996690750122,
0.24187664687633514,
0.5356305837631226,
0.31400591135025024,
0.38454777002334595,
-0.48998698592185974,
0.44732901453971863,
-0.061750032007694244,
-0.9909430146217346,
-1.002334475517273,
0.4356246590614319,
-0.8100326657295227,
-0.23638394474983215,
1.0777126550674438,
0.2289704978466034,
-0.13991641998291016,
-0.17916113138198853,
-0.27176839113235474,
0.3359318971633911,
-0.09988921880722046,
0.7486559152603149,
0.3164783716201782,
-0.05773436278104782,
-0.20792576670646667,
-0.4574524760246277,
0.7105785608291626,
0.3036644756793976,
-0.25186920166015625,
0.06370942294597626,
0.4845931828022003,
0.1567881852388382,
0.2476533055305481,
0.9235860705375671,
-0.08360034227371216,
0.03311901539564133,
0.11911051720380783,
-0.134046733379364,
-0.2016928493976593,
-0.5099952220916748,
-0.2356230914592743,
0.22149209678173065,
0.2094394415616989,
0.13701803982257843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11034v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11034v2 | PAT-Questions: A Self-Updating Benchmark for Present-Anchored Temporal Question-Answering | 2024-02-16T19:26:09 | 2024-06-03T18:36:59 | Jannat Ara Meem, Muhammad Shihab Rashid, Yue Dong, Vagelis Hristidis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing work on Temporal Question Answering (TQA) has predominantly focused
on questions anchored to specific timestamps or events (e.g. "Who was the US
president in 1970?"). Little work has studied questions whose temporal context
is relative to the present time (e.g. "Who was the previous US president?"). We
refer to this problem as Present-Anchored Temporal QA (PATQA). PATQA poses
unique challenges: (1) large language models (LLMs) may have outdated
knowledge, (2) complex temporal relationships (e.g. 'before', 'previous') are
hard to reason, (3) multi-hop reasoning may be required, and (4) the gold
answers of benchmarks must be continuously updated. To address these
challenges, we introduce the PAT-Questions benchmark, which includes single and
multi-hop temporal questions. The answers in PAT-Questions can be automatically
refreshed by re-running SPARQL queries on a knowledge graph, if available. We
evaluate several state-of-the-art LLMs and a SOTA temporal reasoning model
(TEMPREASON-T5) on PAT-Questions through direct prompting and
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). The results highlight the limitations of
existing solutions in PATQA and motivate the need for new methods to improve
PATQA reasoning capabilities. | [
-0.43109411001205444,
-0.9292120337486267,
0.7756661772727966,
0.3931846618652344,
-0.2951448857784271,
0.3306780159473419,
0.11877404898405075,
-0.4292316436767578,
-0.04114692658185959,
0.596056342124939,
-0.86292564868927,
-0.09619006514549255,
-0.07633741945028305,
0.2592138648033142,
0.1348186433315277,
0.5709019303321838,
-0.2343073934316635,
-0.1955186277627945,
-0.0843081846833229,
-0.36021366715431213,
-0.6014477014541626,
-0.5213978290557861,
-0.5709386467933655,
-0.31384462118148804,
0.2624483108520508,
0.35292989015579224,
0.3049910366535187,
0.45486539602279663,
0.3258153200149536,
0.24264398217201233,
-0.0626644566655159,
0.3534679114818573,
0.05230125039815903,
0.48677319288253784,
-0.24128808081150055,
-0.310031533241272,
-0.45008575916290283,
0.12672209739685059,
0.6814104318618774,
1.0429120063781738,
0.024430256336927414,
0.5945098996162415,
-0.3028096556663513,
0.5208794474601746,
-0.682237982749939,
-0.0798134058713913,
-0.6995664238929749,
-0.005476051941514015,
-0.07516415417194366,
-0.5422232747077942,
-0.1523911952972412,
-0.5919356942176819,
0.24430179595947266,
-0.44457632303237915,
0.10667692124843597,
-0.17199788987636566,
0.9413142800331116,
0.4311973750591278,
-0.8130571246147156,
-0.1303039789199829,
-0.5798749327659607,
0.5490664839744568,
-0.29719725251197815,
0.49060529470443726,
0.2994561195373535,
0.4266350269317627,
-0.16110414266586304,
-0.7136867046356201,
-0.5730181336402893,
-0.38799044489860535,
0.34229710698127747,
0.2601710855960846,
-0.07840834558010101,
-0.4771159291267395,
0.231552854180336,
0.1885586827993393,
-0.4215701222419739,
-0.19249635934829712,
-0.06485309451818466,
0.09465093165636063,
0.09013786166906357,
0.17571306228637695,
0.006524714641273022,
-0.360951691865921,
-0.8983996510505676,
-0.12678754329681396,
-0.6811584234237671,
0.26755717396736145,
0.24021410942077637,
-0.08931781351566315,
0.3833545744419098,
0.36767008900642395,
-0.5255616903305054,
0.5866645574569702,
0.3736001253128052,
0.32196536660194397,
0.07350213825702667,
-0.4223145544528961,
0.00764297042042017,
-0.3200022578239441,
0.3404800593852997,
0.2572040855884552,
0.32357507944107056,
-0.06920415908098221,
0.27780213952064514,
-0.29172950983047485,
0.14052505791187286,
-0.4546392261981964,
0.06511896848678589,
0.5094560384750366,
0.06092448532581329,
0.1089615598320961,
-0.016174642369151115,
-0.8464231491088867,
-0.20426861941814423,
-0.1005394384264946,
0.5965344905853271,
-0.24838681519031525,
-0.23974549770355225,
-0.008813567459583282,
-0.25401613116264343,
0.3985341191291809,
0.4977285861968994,
-0.25347861647605896,
0.258954793214798,
0.7282522320747375,
0.3184623420238495,
0.32168057560920715,
-0.49142691493034363,
-0.7136504650115967,
0.3243428170681,
-0.6851804852485657,
1.0644160509109497,
-0.43356847763061523,
-0.1445850282907486,
-0.0676523894071579,
0.19459420442581177,
0.02270243875682354,
-0.7104272246360779,
0.2355678677558899,
-0.7712526917457581,
0.44907140731811523,
-0.841743528842926,
-0.3367430567741394,
0.26468625664711,
0.6001509428024292,
-0.40497350692749023,
1.40621018409729,
0.19812457263469696,
-0.6859073042869568,
0.45227140188217163,
-0.37575334310531616,
-0.14140842854976654,
0.04673445224761963,
-0.1106509119272232,
-0.19169244170188904,
-0.26789405941963196,
0.25315287709236145,
0.3431590795516968,
-0.4992719888687134,
0.5259073376655579,
-0.09675943106412888,
-0.11628052592277527,
0.43072184920310974,
-0.13237552344799042,
0.9653027057647705,
0.2276768684387207,
-0.45334237813949585,
-0.3133701682090759,
-0.580401599407196,
0.2658237814903259,
0.030037714168429375,
-0.27405229210853577,
-0.14046715199947357,
-0.07739131152629852,
-0.7841808199882507,
0.19423609972000122,
0.44419175386428833,
-0.6510661840438843,
0.1882682740688324,
0.18785837292671204,
0.30369725823402405,
0.9728056192398071,
0.5245726704597473,
0.04549142345786095,
-0.6113936901092529,
0.5947055816650391,
0.059981174767017365,
0.33007070422172546,
-0.4455774426460266,
-0.6105652451515198,
-0.6378506422042847,
0.25696834921836853,
0.2199171781539917,
0.6859169006347656,
-0.49338260293006897,
0.003456419100984931,
-0.41052690148353577,
-0.429269403219223,
-0.3138929307460785,
-0.18237993121147156,
0.274368554353714,
0.8060172200202942,
0.5228339433670044,
-0.23246502876281738,
-0.48004481196403503,
-0.4598081409931183,
-0.4321165084838867,
-0.6915649175643921,
-0.028785787522792816,
0.5847015380859375,
0.49171751737594604,
0.3571951985359192,
0.8505518436431885,
-0.5213640332221985,
0.2520422339439392,
0.136599600315094,
0.34761539101600647,
0.006117808632552624,
0.3371294438838959,
0.26112326979637146,
-0.6007162928581238,
-0.3022703230381012,
-0.25144141912460327,
-0.6913277506828308,
-0.5008899569511414,
-0.32084885239601135,
-0.03359125927090645,
0.028521841391921043,
0.44447141885757446,
-0.7422366738319397,
0.12182877212762833,
0.35671117901802063,
-0.4840168058872223,
0.8001813888549805,
-0.16423743963241577,
0.5900033116340637,
-1.010359525680542,
0.08848153054714203,
-0.33019405603408813,
-0.20450033247470856,
-0.4069617986679077,
0.1200566291809082,
0.08507364243268967,
-0.2853854298591614,
-0.36319103837013245,
0.9062017798423767,
-0.49628502130508423,
-0.14442755281925201,
0.16159497201442719,
0.23221638798713684,
0.23516963422298431,
0.28100019693374634,
-0.17760027945041656,
0.8866186738014221,
0.1619676649570465,
-0.7058895230293274,
0.23275192081928253,
0.18756814301013947,
-0.03156150132417679,
0.6178751587867737,
-0.6191792488098145,
0.48318612575531006,
-0.08610665053129196,
0.4376908242702484,
-0.8615914583206177,
-0.014129629358649254,
0.06384777277708054,
-0.49745193123817444,
0.1940009891986847,
-0.21585701406002045,
-0.34058693051338196,
-0.3722452223300934,
-0.3215501606464386,
0.40976983308792114,
0.3884095847606659,
-0.8071610331535339,
0.5750556588172913,
0.20721757411956787,
-0.11223261803388596,
-0.9975751042366028,
-0.3544638752937317,
0.25980710983276367,
-0.0751599445939064,
-0.6040751934051514,
0.3862897753715515,
-0.23668667674064636,
-0.5326133370399475,
0.28551816940307617,
-0.4569034278392792,
-0.22562117874622345,
0.048306163400411606,
-0.16370749473571777,
0.006904772482812405,
-0.22875747084617615,
0.22915184497833252,
-0.2623821198940277,
-0.21737627685070038,
0.02525508776307106,
-0.3212491273880005,
0.6197212338447571,
-0.15654043853282928,
-0.1938902735710144,
-0.4188970923423767,
0.5811625719070435,
0.47467830777168274,
-0.5046045780181885,
0.3881712257862091,
0.2959887981414795,
-0.2545129358768463,
-0.46271297335624695,
-0.9411664009094238,
-0.20676355063915253,
-0.48647430539131165,
0.06589152663946152,
-0.6732670068740845,
-0.9939084649085999,
0.697758674621582,
-0.355215847492218,
-0.2138349711894989,
0.2965119779109955,
0.4804326891899109,
-0.3828204572200775,
0.4275662302970886,
0.12191326916217804,
0.22587300837039948,
0.37325379252433777,
-0.052346814423799515,
-0.1823424994945526,
-0.808032751083374,
-0.24463315308094025,
-0.6234667897224426,
0.11905016005039215,
-0.4579329788684845,
-0.7396233081817627,
0.27167320251464844,
0.1781841665506363,
-0.7422406077384949,
0.18755298852920532,
-0.24664637446403503,
0.2970944344997406,
0.7255048751831055,
-0.003792537609115243,
0.28276708722114563,
-0.6861844062805176,
-0.07853750139474869,
0.2507610619068146,
-0.5131286382675171,
-0.36355262994766235,
1.007551908493042,
0.13293538987636566,
0.6063674688339233,
0.11748740077018738,
0.4915527403354645,
0.31250080466270447,
0.0926799550652504,
-0.008443688973784447,
0.8020157814025879,
0.017957625910639763,
-0.9759473204612732,
-0.1849002242088318,
-0.5341587662696838,
-0.854590117931366,
-0.0005016420618630946,
0.08217041939496994,
-0.6665233373641968,
0.35684943199157715,
0.2619083523750305,
-0.32469645142555237,
0.35879114270210266,
-0.6642248034477234,
0.9313288331031799,
-0.2455052137374878,
-0.33679285645484924,
0.28989917039871216,
-0.7112134099006653,
0.11792917549610138,
0.04314849153161049,
-0.21688714623451233,
-0.5170148611068726,
-0.23790132999420166,
0.45624253153800964,
-0.390578031539917,
0.735813558101654,
-0.338783860206604,
0.3295055627822876,
0.5803073644638062,
0.16424940526485443,
0.5376694202423096,
0.24287573993206024,
0.1121121421456337,
-0.22528323531150818,
0.4047313630580902,
-0.5195812582969666,
-0.7185882925987244,
0.5864431262016296,
-0.6710273027420044,
-0.9661365747451782,
-0.7271969318389893,
-0.2831960916519165,
-0.515620768070221,
0.004093869123607874,
-0.10696224868297577,
0.5646830201148987,
-0.0594409741461277,
0.08374928683042526,
0.643602192401886,
-0.3860689401626587,
0.24574412405490875,
0.8316189050674438,
0.07451742142438889,
-0.3671073913574219,
0.25321152806282043,
0.3005915582180023,
0.2942255139350891,
0.5876632928848267,
0.2946225106716156,
-0.3386218547821045,
-0.23465342819690704,
-0.3546024560928345,
0.38516363501548767,
-0.6271191239356995,
-0.24783387780189514,
-0.7944854497909546,
0.08754538744688034,
-0.38318300247192383,
0.14722929894924164,
-0.39889198541641235,
-0.7565109729766846,
-0.14531540870666504,
0.08241552859544754,
0.17842437326908112,
0.38092806935310364,
-0.05453755706548691,
-0.14938704669475555,
-0.4879821836948395,
0.5517328977584839,
0.7985262274742126,
0.4581299424171448,
-0.2791741192340851,
-0.22644585371017456,
0.29717421531677246,
-0.39132511615753174,
-0.22832754254341125,
-1.2613465785980225,
-0.20457682013511658,
0.24831847846508026,
0.5806447863578796,
-0.20041151344776154,
0.3786028325557709,
0.8343045115470886,
-0.7044632434844971,
1.0520402193069458,
-0.42975619435310364,
-0.8584616780281067,
0.826259434223175,
-0.441424161195755,
0.5936691761016846,
0.5880393385887146,
0.3839193880558014,
-0.6088618636131287,
-0.31371501088142395,
-0.7169614434242249,
-0.4199618399143219,
0.3178669810295105,
-0.2090383619070053,
0.06686195731163025,
-0.3779986798763275,
0.7533099055290222,
0.010906168259680271,
0.19338561594486237,
-0.4274204969406128,
-0.25595998764038086,
-0.21549032628536224,
0.2201496809720993,
0.2542347311973572,
-0.29333654046058655,
0.021906156092882156,
0.021537337452173233,
0.6411566734313965,
-0.24364081025123596,
0.3103673756122589,
0.5050950646400452,
0.20067699253559113,
-0.2909429967403412,
0.633884608745575,
0.25292158126831055,
1.0147548913955688,
-0.5921374559402466,
0.31031230092048645,
0.4393905997276306,
-0.18432094156742096,
0.29800230264663696,
0.23773017525672913,
-0.14934737980365753,
-0.15143635869026184,
0.2823511064052582,
0.21173928678035736,
0.05214694142341614,
-0.636076033115387,
0.5569289922714233,
-0.046436067670583725,
-0.0909084603190422,
-0.4641329050064087,
-0.22757020592689514,
-0.07442542165517807,
0.4715963304042816,
0.8454622030258179,
-0.12462079524993896,
-0.3728799819946289,
-0.969032347202301,
0.43864181637763977,
0.3292224705219269,
-0.30858364701271057,
-0.41559654474258423,
0.790621817111969,
-0.16430406272411346,
-0.3065931499004364,
0.3521060049533844,
-0.29330191016197205,
-0.8603519797325134,
0.5120216012001038,
0.6993955373764038,
0.6853192448616028,
-0.5110387802124023,
0.5111746788024902,
0.34359654784202576,
0.4394416809082031,
0.18491801619529724,
0.9620009064674377,
-0.15488983690738678,
-0.6756823658943176,
-0.5421321988105774,
-0.23882856965065002,
-0.8022083640098572,
0.15383398532867432,
-0.570990800857544,
-0.2239353358745575,
-0.6159998774528503,
-0.5201073884963989,
-0.18434792757034302,
0.4663231074810028,
-0.7230013012886047,
0.4359953701496124,
-0.37266090512275696,
1.0258126258850098,
-0.5905600786209106,
0.537200927734375,
0.7738032341003418,
-0.3551277220249176,
-0.6352669596672058,
0.1385369896888733,
-0.1364774852991104,
-0.6080228686332703,
0.6417033672332764,
-0.25818106532096863,
-0.09789927303791046,
-0.07427961379289627,
-0.40145817399024963,
-0.8485910892486572,
1.1432106494903564,
0.4277340769767761,
0.1911778450012207,
0.04992096498608589,
0.07461325079202652,
0.5514286160469055,
-0.09863671660423279,
-0.0943608209490776,
0.38927218317985535,
0.3939901888370514,
-0.09580196440219879,
-0.8516303300857544,
0.12144901603460312,
-0.39561590552330017,
-0.5267496109008789,
0.4420933425426483,
-0.9877303242683411,
1.133581519126892,
-0.1382121592760086,
-0.16664119064807892,
0.09021987020969391,
0.4909290373325348,
0.37718120217323303,
0.46208101511001587,
0.5705097317695618,
0.6595838665962219,
0.8414011597633362,
-0.3599788248538971,
0.9218865036964417,
-0.17557530105113983,
0.12170271575450897,
1.4365150928497314,
-0.3307158052921295,
0.8538592457771301,
0.470130056142807,
-0.2735316753387451,
0.6604289412498474,
0.553083598613739,
0.048611417412757874,
0.27447912096977234,
-0.01267834659665823,
-0.2806624174118042,
-0.5009147524833679,
-0.2997959554195404,
-0.6011515259742737,
0.43128252029418945,
-0.06439825892448425,
0.1398509442806244,
-0.2724105715751648,
-0.30976957082748413,
0.09845957159996033,
0.01800468936562538,
0.0648413896560669,
0.5609762072563171,
-0.19558140635490417,
-1.0149344205856323,
0.21806597709655762,
-0.3517115116119385,
-0.20563073456287384,
-0.6499943137168884,
-0.07052642107009888,
-0.5412804484367371,
0.03892248868942261,
0.45421063899993896,
-0.7940356731414795,
0.050946321338415146,
0.15982569754123688,
-0.05355481803417206,
-0.12483160197734833,
0.45723381638526917,
-0.052128665149211884,
-0.2034357786178589,
0.1296701282262802,
1.0601398944854736,
-0.08801382035017014,
0.07330232858657837,
-0.7378028035163879,
-0.09028806537389755,
-0.39813002943992615,
-0.24743887782096863,
0.07348960638046265,
0.8251158595085144,
-0.12426171451807022,
1.121288776397705,
0.3728799819946289,
0.15459474921226501,
0.5456407070159912,
0.16006053984165192,
0.8531980514526367,
-0.870148777961731,
-0.5941261053085327,
-0.24679605662822723,
0.27735111117362976,
-0.020170509815216064,
-0.5716965198516846,
0.6976291537284851,
0.2807838022708893,
0.6043235659599304,
0.2897626459598541,
0.42041900753974915,
-0.0244759451597929,
0.9317071437835693,
-0.46632054448127747,
0.09672902524471283,
-0.6447665095329285,
0.3492306172847748,
-0.2886880934238434,
-0.722690999507904,
-0.08747578412294388,
0.0916391983628273,
-0.24785463511943817,
0.23056335747241974,
0.8711403608322144,
0.45218905806541443,
0.27721816301345825,
0.11666862666606903,
0.016219941899180412,
0.131108820438385,
0.3580525517463684,
0.5558121800422668,
1.2712100744247437,
-0.44630882143974304,
0.5523087978363037,
-0.5325756072998047,
-0.1516551375389099,
0.2189582884311676,
-1.1576405763626099,
-0.6986156702041626,
-0.9810805916786194,
-0.5131276249885559,
-0.23976993560791016,
0.477151095867157,
0.8585147857666016,
0.6382726430892944,
-0.6080862879753113,
0.03007896989583969,
0.3703766465187073,
-0.03886748105287552,
-0.44357651472091675,
-0.16726890206336975,
0.6868097186088562,
-0.3735562562942505,
-0.39632856845855713,
0.5269526243209839,
0.2474897801876068,
-0.05166204273700714,
-0.06117874011397362,
0.47270676493644714,
-0.6432403326034546,
0.21265088021755219,
0.27668705582618713,
0.5203089714050293,
-0.6611323356628418,
-0.8123362064361572,
0.3283383548259735,
0.2993590831756592,
0.2816488444805145,
0.7792854905128479,
-0.9962336421012878,
0.5749015808105469,
0.38449007272720337,
0.7618327736854553,
0.6456341743469238,
0.6426727771759033,
0.3944769501686096,
-0.8842487335205078,
-0.36576125025749207,
0.36000439524650574,
0.12325968593358994,
0.30991822481155396,
-0.14268578588962555,
0.5198269486427307,
0.2311762571334839,
-0.8902571797370911,
-0.8781698346138,
0.2650699317455292,
-1.1658366918563843,
-0.3592640161514282,
0.7682555913925171,
-0.14582735300064087,
-0.259345680475235,
-0.4932798743247986,
0.17077754437923431,
0.18163864314556122,
-0.057454176247119904,
0.657163679599762,
0.4948287606239319,
-0.32293152809143066,
-0.2680334746837616,
-0.6290109157562256,
0.4672229588031769,
0.424861878156662,
-0.8530478477478027,
0.289195716381073,
0.3330213725566864,
0.46311211585998535,
0.1016671359539032,
1.1617445945739746,
-0.1324586421251297,
0.521826446056366,
0.16722096502780914,
-0.4728837311267853,
-0.20309899747371674,
-0.48940470814704895,
0.07159702479839325,
0.47399672865867615,
-0.03151652589440346,
-0.23009058833122253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10893v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10893v1 | RLVF: Learning from Verbal Feedback without Overgeneralization | 2024-02-16T18:50:24 | 2024-02-16T18:50:24 | Moritz Stephan, Alexander Khazatsky, Eric Mitchell, Annie S Chen, Sheryl Hsu, Archit Sharma, Chelsea Finn | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The diversity of contexts in which large language models (LLMs) are deployed
requires the ability to modify or customize default model behaviors to
incorporate nuanced requirements and preferences. A convenient interface to
specify such model adjustments is high-level verbal feedback, such as "Don't
use emojis when drafting emails to my boss." However, while writing high-level
feedback is far simpler than collecting annotations for reinforcement learning
from human feedback (RLHF), we find that simply prompting a model with such
feedback leads to overgeneralization of the feedback to contexts where it is
not relevant. We study the problem of incorporating verbal feedback without
such overgeneralization, inspiring a new method Contextualized Critiques with
Constrained Preference Optimization (C3PO). C3PO uses a piece of high-level
feedback to generate a small synthetic preference dataset specifying how the
feedback should (and should not) be applied. It then fine-tunes the model in
accordance with the synthetic preference data while minimizing the divergence
from the original model for prompts where the feedback does not apply. Our
experimental results indicate that our approach effectively applies verbal
feedback to relevant scenarios while preserving existing behaviors for other
contexts. For both human- and GPT-4-generated high-level feedback, C3PO
effectively adheres to the given feedback comparably to in-context baselines
while reducing overgeneralization by 30%. | [
-0.3821914494037628,
-0.9980422258377075,
0.5112099051475525,
0.3197815716266632,
-0.17836356163024902,
0.019427889958024025,
-0.7317374348640442,
-0.3929656744003296,
0.04068981856107712,
0.5005282163619995,
-0.8498938083648682,
-0.474137544631958,
-0.14449694752693176,
0.03685302287340164,
0.16799189150333405,
1.0402694940567017,
-0.02972041629254818,
0.03662380576133728,
-0.3938467800617218,
0.12391415238380432,
-0.39251255989074707,
-0.6805187463760376,
-0.602029025554657,
-0.8250616192817688,
0.6377705335617065,
0.6955909729003906,
0.36128100752830505,
0.391238808631897,
-0.08486279100179672,
0.1969212293624878,
-0.04985074698925018,
0.394961416721344,
-0.7264984250068665,
0.18275785446166992,
-0.16526219248771667,
-0.2912019193172455,
-0.08134981989860535,
0.03791828081011772,
0.6424443125724792,
0.5449220538139343,
-0.4403376281261444,
0.03571774438023567,
0.22989438474178314,
0.8272290825843811,
-0.8391761779785156,
0.5039573907852173,
-0.49429139494895935,
0.48348289728164673,
0.31023457646369934,
-0.4698413908481598,
-0.651411771774292,
-0.5053618550300598,
0.17491917312145233,
-0.8009606003761292,
-0.04780188947916031,
-0.016101794317364693,
0.6624675393104553,
0.278260737657547,
-0.20992468297481537,
-0.16001418232917786,
-1.0498762130737305,
0.9796096086502075,
-0.3876195251941681,
0.3278209865093231,
0.6627472639083862,
0.17763487994670868,
-0.10664843022823334,
-0.34218689799308777,
-0.3761114180088043,
-0.6584092974662781,
-0.0151682673022151,
0.23033595085144043,
0.010542120784521103,
0.1699095517396927,
0.34179890155792236,
-0.1544855833053589,
-0.10049602389335632,
0.15929700434207916,
-0.3571256995201111,
-0.10731710493564606,
0.4190840721130371,
-0.08042116463184357,
-0.04442308470606804,
-0.13426795601844788,
-0.43300849199295044,
-0.11551979184150696,
-0.794221818447113,
0.41154858469963074,
-0.014254426583647728,
0.4596189856529236,
0.1019393801689148,
0.464304119348526,
-0.20448563992977142,
0.5187447667121887,
0.281633198261261,
-0.1334877461194992,
0.37525463104248047,
-0.1258433759212494,
-0.11688219755887985,
0.02302488498389721,
0.6477023959159851,
0.4948628544807434,
0.4961473047733307,
-0.2563773989677429,
-0.24436403810977936,
-0.16027019917964935,
0.24086584150791168,
-0.8604183197021484,
0.32681068778038025,
0.09507375210523605,
-0.46395963430404663,
-0.29334187507629395,
-0.007958436384797096,
-0.6553128361701965,
-0.31714653968811035,
-0.5245487093925476,
0.042408429086208344,
-0.3574061691761017,
-0.009625323116779327,
-0.1555803120136261,
-0.0002526683092582971,
0.2889057695865631,
0.33475810289382935,
-1.1625940799713135,
0.3606081008911133,
0.7825524806976318,
0.6440272331237793,
-0.08537375926971436,
-0.50273197889328,
-0.7626714706420898,
0.2514612376689911,
-0.3948330879211426,
0.6295450925827026,
-0.6071416139602661,
-0.6022984385490417,
0.15102270245552063,
-0.09010452777147293,
-0.08688236027956009,
-0.6643166542053223,
0.5212764143943787,
-0.3108099400997162,
0.1915699988603592,
-0.42579394578933716,
-0.5514113903045654,
-0.02777273766696453,
0.4147517681121826,
-0.2555239200592041,
1.0047515630722046,
0.09906625002622604,
-0.5338966250419617,
0.6698216795921326,
-0.5567927956581116,
-0.45471733808517456,
0.06322412937879562,
-0.3210582733154297,
-0.29420551657676697,
-0.03419914469122887,
0.3303225040435791,
0.3479934334754944,
0.011886360123753548,
0.18770186603069305,
-0.5505743622779846,
-0.35354602336883545,
0.2575225830078125,
-0.13111387193202972,
0.23317541182041168,
0.1252746880054474,
-0.4080597758293152,
0.39433255791664124,
-0.6500133275985718,
0.13057349622249603,
-0.06460107117891312,
-0.6331508755683899,
-0.32160067558288574,
0.09886559844017029,
-0.1297455132007599,
0.4070291221141815,
0.0742282122373581,
-0.7490037679672241,
0.23985986411571503,
-0.6942211389541626,
0.5290374159812927,
0.7659297585487366,
0.12837015092372894,
0.5405399203300476,
-0.39574259519577026,
0.7164621949195862,
-0.3458740711212158,
0.3346627652645111,
0.25656142830848694,
-0.13708651065826416,
-0.577437162399292,
-0.1514815241098404,
-0.012076630257070065,
0.5525540113449097,
-0.766370415687561,
0.37072986364364624,
-0.1438642144203186,
-0.10910379886627197,
-0.14629876613616943,
0.46391522884368896,
0.5337567925453186,
0.45290979743003845,
0.28971928358078003,
-0.14441253244876862,
-0.6561370491981506,
-0.722874104976654,
-0.010564055293798447,
-0.30011871457099915,
0.060218971222639084,
0.5900661945343018,
0.2615925371646881,
-0.05140485614538193,
0.9788558483123779,
-0.36784300208091736,
-0.2853468656539917,
-0.5192537903785706,
0.10038795322179794,
-0.12860506772994995,
0.4567612111568451,
0.38882091641426086,
-0.40607041120529175,
-0.2210668921470642,
-0.06401607394218445,
-0.5279526114463806,
-0.04952344298362732,
-0.11248182505369186,
-0.011457827873528004,
0.2961481809616089,
0.8611347675323486,
-0.5377722382545471,
-0.013351283967494965,
0.35019510984420776,
-0.15594297647476196,
0.12713582813739777,
-0.3570499122142792,
-0.18114303052425385,
-0.7462191581726074,
0.003215279197320342,
0.03406145051121712,
-0.31803855299949646,
-0.4040447473526001,
-0.01831263303756714,
-0.004966897889971733,
-0.1349029392004013,
-0.4805535078048706,
0.6158031821250916,
-0.21330000460147858,
0.1115831658244133,
-0.23395247757434845,
0.04915454611182213,
-0.09734734147787094,
0.9051708579063416,
0.2867867946624756,
0.3740360736846924,
0.15540756285190582,
-0.5849517583847046,
0.24049581587314606,
0.16466087102890015,
-0.0192802045494318,
0.54523766040802,
-0.757074236869812,
0.15713173151016235,
-0.38935208320617676,
0.7421684265136719,
-0.5436572432518005,
-0.16944026947021484,
0.41963663697242737,
-0.4610050320625305,
0.20271342992782593,
-0.13315002620220184,
-0.27818185091018677,
-0.26175346970558167,
-0.6485915780067444,
0.162478506565094,
0.4867408573627472,
-0.5572366714477539,
0.6421606540679932,
0.24745722115039825,
-0.09375452995300293,
-0.702401340007782,
-0.5643574595451355,
-0.20788921415805817,
-0.03367888554930687,
-0.3531349301338196,
0.20180413126945496,
-0.18343830108642578,
0.03525004908442497,
-0.2563333213329315,
0.07251649349927902,
0.16023214161396027,
0.05860498547554016,
0.4355243742465973,
0.2318812757730484,
0.18598724901676178,
0.2004915177822113,
-0.06799601018428802,
0.052065979689359665,
0.20932301878929138,
-0.2939305603504181,
0.45656251907348633,
-0.11416669189929962,
-0.07843144237995148,
-0.36693888902664185,
0.18104349076747894,
0.4245785176753998,
-0.20858213305473328,
0.47989988327026367,
0.699283242225647,
-0.19888032972812653,
-0.6433322429656982,
-0.306374728679657,
-0.3787945508956909,
-0.4493139386177063,
0.31195610761642456,
-0.21673545241355896,
-1.241190791130066,
0.15601715445518494,
0.06186674162745476,
0.11450590193271637,
-0.06548182666301727,
0.7092817425727844,
0.0296787042170763,
1.2203269004821777,
0.4510626494884491,
0.1178792268037796,
0.8063246607780457,
-0.2881345748901367,
-0.0524546355009079,
-0.8547795414924622,
-0.432564914226532,
-0.3081720769405365,
-0.14793802797794342,
-0.597818911075592,
-0.21228529512882233,
0.19261419773101807,
-0.10634282231330872,
-0.3144862651824951,
-0.10282116383314133,
-0.26825252175331116,
0.6133424043655396,
0.5946300029754639,
0.36326372623443604,
0.013690818101167679,
-0.050456125289201736,
-0.22206908464431763,
-0.03731359541416168,
-0.7979743480682373,
-0.033447470515966415,
0.9608285427093506,
0.53866046667099,
0.7361340522766113,
0.024289196357131004,
0.9500012993812561,
0.0806397870182991,
0.5059632062911987,
-1.098739743232727,
0.4637630879878998,
-0.06141335144639015,
-0.33729133009910583,
-0.41407066583633423,
-0.6311642527580261,
-1.0113810300827026,
0.385811448097229,
-0.36959120631217957,
-0.7786188125610352,
0.3699064552783966,
0.48176053166389465,
-0.6200549602508545,
-0.13466334342956543,
-0.700157105922699,
0.5867394804954529,
0.15274806320667267,
-0.5228106379508972,
-0.2558969557285309,
-0.5677111148834229,
0.3064602315425873,
0.17319530248641968,
0.46680495142936707,
-0.0718952864408493,
0.09859583526849747,
0.4863644540309906,
-0.5752281546592712,
1.251092553138733,
-0.44030317664146423,
-0.20347918570041656,
0.21381570398807526,
0.04611380770802498,
0.6702196598052979,
0.2326260209083557,
0.14650388062000275,
-0.567481517791748,
-0.07060569524765015,
-0.251168429851532,
-0.9081289768218994,
0.8767924904823303,
-0.9592556953430176,
-0.5902414917945862,
-0.30341967940330505,
-0.36953121423721313,
-0.5422026515007019,
0.08403375744819641,
0.30649954080581665,
0.43210360407829285,
-0.3244098126888275,
0.28788310289382935,
0.6122153997421265,
-0.1387077122926712,
0.40267446637153625,
0.4292278289794922,
-0.33980095386505127,
-0.5696723461151123,
0.9407193064689636,
-0.04303687438368797,
0.3456321358680725,
0.34719404578208923,
0.5973894596099854,
-0.5085486769676208,
-0.22885380685329437,
-0.3361395597457886,
0.23272301256656647,
-0.9935364723205566,
0.1623310148715973,
-0.4470027685165405,
-0.013524327427148819,
-0.2726031541824341,
-0.17170582711696625,
-0.3546479642391205,
-0.4577599763870239,
-0.31621432304382324,
-0.14337410032749176,
0.029814885929226875,
0.7707405090332031,
-0.12728305160999298,
-0.14957644045352936,
-0.6731129884719849,
0.14677824079990387,
0.549968421459198,
0.2918112277984619,
0.26606377959251404,
-0.41275086998939514,
-0.18986466526985168,
-0.03429242596030235,
-0.30675145983695984,
-0.5067561864852905,
0.2841838002204895,
0.4015342891216278,
0.5395539999008179,
0.10804826021194458,
0.0831277072429657,
0.3307974636554718,
-0.3789827525615692,
0.747546374797821,
0.030323509126901627,
-0.9667275547981262,
0.6030897498130798,
-0.44182297587394714,
0.5088198781013489,
0.6341851353645325,
0.3050864040851593,
-0.5364541411399841,
-0.3042423725128174,
-0.4705063998699188,
-1.0250890254974365,
0.6656509637832642,
-0.0662589743733406,
0.379518061876297,
-0.1126507893204689,
0.6164292097091675,
-0.1439770758152008,
0.2641291916370392,
-1.1046459674835205,
0.027510100975632668,
-0.4620334208011627,
0.08270376920700073,
0.049852870404720306,
-0.2300880402326584,
-0.37286055088043213,
-0.43509364128112793,
0.7742610573768616,
-0.2761520445346832,
-0.06108219549059868,
0.4013103246688843,
-0.11923306435346603,
-0.40779757499694824,
0.4221420884132385,
0.8319627046585083,
0.6777991652488708,
-0.3463597595691681,
0.003002340905368328,
0.2615126669406891,
-0.18951794505119324,
0.11454200744628906,
-0.20285072922706604,
-0.299018919467926,
-0.25966376066207886,
0.39697742462158203,
0.9981610774993896,
0.2933434247970581,
-0.525974452495575,
0.5679140090942383,
-0.12139520049095154,
-0.4411911368370056,
-0.366519033908844,
0.1712912768125534,
-0.20574501156806946,
0.06414509564638138,
0.07731078565120697,
-0.1251787543296814,
-0.05662345886230469,
-0.7434273362159729,
0.14088597893714905,
0.3891361951828003,
-0.7146219611167908,
-0.1342107653617859,
0.37444478273391724,
0.4415034055709839,
-0.10042952001094818,
0.3286610543727875,
-0.28897640109062195,
-0.49539926648139954,
0.41619962453842163,
0.6101585030555725,
0.8972238898277283,
-0.03558044880628586,
0.49968206882476807,
0.5190766453742981,
0.06272253394126892,
-0.21386496722698212,
0.11842893809080124,
-0.45390909910202026,
-0.7917335033416748,
-0.6617297530174255,
-0.5001772046089172,
-0.5695654153823853,
0.054392579942941666,
-0.749201238155365,
0.1918984055519104,
-1.0345072746276855,
-0.21604983508586884,
0.039674438536167145,
-0.2951430678367615,
-0.2704194188117981,
0.1320534199476242,
0.23909592628479004,
0.4570564031600952,
-0.6546311974525452,
0.8709976673126221,
0.5629467964172363,
-0.5329766273498535,
-0.7956416010856628,
0.14375285804271698,
-0.020955583080649376,
-0.9556223154067993,
0.7819655537605286,
0.12040092796087265,
-0.34388867020606995,
-0.03424029052257538,
-0.5956408381462097,
-0.7443484663963318,
0.8217856287956238,
0.2748141884803772,
-0.46252328157424927,
0.009567199274897575,
-0.14225636422634125,
0.6737558841705322,
-0.40103164315223694,
0.172817200422287,
0.5208291411399841,
0.5035828351974487,
0.2792224884033203,
-0.7860314249992371,
0.2518746554851532,
-0.1692337840795517,
0.40386107563972473,
0.07903444021940231,
-0.8203408718109131,
0.5119678378105164,
-0.23467274010181427,
-0.11061286926269531,
-0.15141412615776062,
0.5109743475914001,
0.34472420811653137,
-0.09044288098812103,
0.7413387894630432,
0.3042500913143158,
0.5321389436721802,
0.07624159753322601,
1.2045701742172241,
-0.13496175408363342,
0.49088001251220703,
1.2950971126556396,
-0.359666645526886,
0.8306580781936646,
0.660792887210846,
0.12381419539451599,
0.6319265365600586,
0.5800307989120483,
-0.0065856254659593105,
0.6646260023117065,
0.6207725405693054,
-0.16455258429050446,
-0.2754923701286316,
-0.3627474009990692,
-0.17332957684993744,
0.39086708426475525,
0.2549268305301666,
-0.18648716807365417,
-0.17199279367923737,
0.10963860899209976,
0.1273943930864334,
0.32220903038978577,
-0.26330670714378357,
0.9569619297981262,
0.10872731357812881,
-1.1783984899520874,
1.1341663599014282,
-0.08516187965869904,
0.7372955083847046,
-0.5244650840759277,
-0.06887595355510712,
-0.1366005837917328,
0.21547476947307587,
-0.3697086572647095,
-0.41413024067878723,
0.24201975762844086,
-0.1964869350194931,
-0.306061714887619,
-0.3958459794521332,
0.2864976227283478,
-0.6375055313110352,
-0.3050731420516968,
0.4122888147830963,
0.27444979548454285,
-0.37601858377456665,
0.2509942650794983,
-0.6921971440315247,
-0.011004998348653316,
0.03515789657831192,
-0.39482003450393677,
0.30262017250061035,
0.24468787014484406,
-0.100983165204525,
0.7907355427742004,
0.6116609573364258,
0.20297573506832123,
-0.42200514674186707,
0.5177977681159973,
0.7279902696609497,
-0.6253414750099182,
-0.620921790599823,
-0.81458580493927,
0.09266254305839539,
0.0443229116499424,
-0.4149740934371948,
0.6095184683799744,
0.14923885464668274,
0.9513856768608093,
-0.04063381254673004,
0.9217724204063416,
0.18121729791164398,
0.5207574367523193,
-0.7898820638656616,
0.22405602037906647,
-0.4628628194332123,
0.448760986328125,
-0.2960283160209656,
-0.9164619445800781,
-0.27858468890190125,
0.5197165012359619,
-0.4407288730144501,
0.2989896833896637,
0.8033066987991333,
0.6719210147857666,
0.17051568627357483,
0.012005990371108055,
0.21891112625598907,
0.08151183277368546,
0.3150426149368286,
0.6668446063995361,
1.0883182287216187,
0.2952997386455536,
0.5210134983062744,
-0.3619135916233063,
-0.26125723123550415,
-0.20722734928131104,
-0.8955144882202148,
-0.9900870323181152,
-0.2923341691493988,
-0.22832055389881134,
-0.5320753455162048,
0.19577352702617645,
1.5581029653549194,
0.8552148342132568,
-0.7607977986335754,
-0.34612837433815,
-0.2692662477493286,
0.0970752015709877,
-0.05448160320520401,
-0.23572921752929688,
0.10088223218917847,
-0.5983899831771851,
-0.5408710837364197,
0.631865918636322,
0.08884294331073761,
0.008602116256952286,
-0.43569350242614746,
-0.3373955190181732,
0.0018488038331270218,
0.1091359555721283,
0.7289648056030273,
0.5524066090583801,
-0.8448505997657776,
-0.6157350540161133,
-0.08927303552627563,
0.02217523753643036,
0.10406117886304855,
0.9636686444282532,
-0.6749719381332397,
0.42062073945999146,
0.47754591703414917,
0.5102306604385376,
0.7048246264457703,
0.10206454247236252,
0.9125743508338928,
-1.214693546295166,
0.3455705940723419,
0.20534515380859375,
0.21506480872631073,
0.4722144305706024,
-0.49366942048072815,
0.23884543776512146,
0.15792149305343628,
-0.4809757471084595,
-0.5873125791549683,
0.36993587017059326,
-0.7533209919929504,
-0.511827290058136,
1.5207173824310303,
-0.10620597004890442,
-0.274501770734787,
0.07047443091869354,
-0.3521544635295868,
0.04328039661049843,
-0.7577909827232361,
0.7769961357116699,
0.7287271022796631,
-0.35698238015174866,
-0.21863393485546112,
-0.40669283270835876,
0.9489954710006714,
0.675591230392456,
-0.7410566806793213,
0.19564594328403473,
0.6666467785835266,
0.2685278356075287,
-0.13976113498210907,
0.7025946378707886,
0.06611239910125732,
0.44251328706741333,
-0.49617066979408264,
0.057895727455616,
-0.1585099995136261,
-0.30202746391296387,
-0.5763363242149353,
0.2216295599937439,
0.5295712947845459,
0.07434450089931488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10892v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10892v2 | Proving membership in LLM pretraining data via data watermarks | 2024-02-16T18:49:27 | 2024-06-10T19:39:34 | Johnny Tian-Zheng Wei, Ryan Yixiang Wang, Robin Jia | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Detecting whether copyright holders' works were used in LLM pretraining is
poised to be an important problem. This work proposes using data watermarks to
enable principled detection with only black-box model access, provided that the
rightholder contributed multiple training documents and watermarked them before
public release. By applying a randomly sampled data watermark, detection can be
framed as hypothesis testing, which provides guarantees on the false detection
rate. We study two watermarks: one that inserts random sequences, and another
that randomly substitutes characters with Unicode lookalikes. We first show how
three aspects of watermark design -- watermark length, number of duplications,
and interference -- affect the power of the hypothesis test. Next, we study how
a watermark's detection strength changes under model and dataset scaling: while
increasing the dataset size decreases the strength of the watermark, watermarks
remain strong if the model size also increases. Finally, we view SHA hashes as
natural watermarks and show that we can robustly detect hashes from
BLOOM-176B's training data, as long as they occurred at least 90 times.
Together, our results point towards a promising future for data watermarks in
real world use. | [
-0.3392484486103058,
-0.40602409839630127,
0.6942267417907715,
-0.05927272140979767,
-0.7037340402603149,
0.10138675570487976,
0.16227972507476807,
-0.566200852394104,
0.10463754832744598,
0.7629254460334778,
-0.5300706624984741,
-0.5243450999259949,
-0.6457966566085815,
-0.0062410589307546616,
-0.7609140872955322,
0.6847641468048096,
-0.314303994178772,
-0.032368652522563934,
-0.3265128433704376,
-0.34176307916641235,
-0.23105938732624054,
-0.9043463468551636,
-0.2604026198387146,
-0.3085910975933075,
0.42732712626457214,
0.16244013607501984,
0.4163002073764801,
1.016533613204956,
0.5055923461914062,
0.16137272119522095,
0.0498395636677742,
0.044314004480838776,
-0.5558934807777405,
0.15953294932842255,
0.0904635339975357,
-0.9523903727531433,
-0.13614322245121002,
0.41687628626823425,
0.6599607467651367,
0.03393898159265518,
0.18709632754325867,
0.3117695450782776,
-0.018526215106248856,
0.6450195908546448,
-0.8736628890037537,
-0.04568905755877495,
-0.6961188912391663,
0.28311488032341003,
-0.8181422352790833,
-0.3627837896347046,
-0.4370710849761963,
-0.2444489747285843,
-0.32829025387763977,
-0.6777011156082153,
0.4807099997997284,
0.4923926591873169,
1.2814432382583618,
0.3129505217075348,
-0.08149030804634094,
-0.15160056948661804,
-0.6191394925117493,
0.8241568803787231,
-0.859439492225647,
0.3871251940727234,
0.7574432492256165,
0.41702860593795776,
-0.055549751967191696,
-0.7371672987937927,
-0.5851414799690247,
-0.06623006612062454,
0.29009172320365906,
0.08394955843687057,
-0.053022198379039764,
-0.25633516907691956,
0.6676853895187378,
0.6577860116958618,
-0.37080374360084534,
-0.0762791633605957,
-0.11614710837602615,
-0.2825208604335785,
0.909084141254425,
-0.06477812677621841,
0.2466069608926773,
0.35536348819732666,
-0.3656429946422577,
-0.3177335560321808,
-1.1588993072509766,
-0.08716537803411484,
0.8837208151817322,
0.12589234113693237,
-0.2618166208267212,
0.6226581931114197,
0.07887840270996094,
0.5017550587654114,
-0.08676987886428833,
0.049505364149808884,
0.11948662996292114,
-0.21897129714488983,
-0.32723185420036316,
0.06339410692453384,
0.6435624361038208,
-0.11295817792415619,
0.5941748023033142,
-0.08579031378030777,
-0.35447725653648376,
-0.21701163053512573,
0.09746395796537399,
-0.9319839477539062,
-0.34850141406059265,
0.14624972641468048,
-0.5813364386558533,
-0.3706987798213959,
0.3738662004470825,
-0.3025398254394531,
-0.7597821950912476,
-0.5253415703773499,
0.8362313508987427,
-0.22468401491641998,
-0.34851422905921936,
0.2731979191303253,
-0.33967694640159607,
0.24322614073753357,
0.03752893954515457,
-0.5140195488929749,
0.06785640865564346,
0.6392154097557068,
0.7200695276260376,
-0.36345821619033813,
-0.22363607585430145,
-0.36080804467201233,
0.25255465507507324,
-0.37594175338745117,
0.8111540675163269,
-0.48598361015319824,
-0.2273426353931427,
-0.13911888003349304,
0.10111089795827866,
0.22035014629364014,
-0.9233251810073853,
0.11648914217948914,
-0.8743555545806885,
-0.008411290124058723,
-0.6089488863945007,
-1.056087851524353,
0.13441090285778046,
0.10191896557807922,
-0.8902631998062134,
0.8311529755592346,
0.18959486484527588,
-1.1189788579940796,
0.7747965455055237,
-0.4947271943092346,
-0.2636142373085022,
0.10888803750276566,
-0.16869331896305084,
-1.0156992673873901,
0.012174696661531925,
0.005628539249300957,
0.2680450677871704,
0.1380062848329544,
0.041070252656936646,
-0.7117931246757507,
-0.6270484924316406,
0.6991561651229858,
-0.32846972346305847,
0.690028965473175,
0.0022175582125782967,
-0.3864412009716034,
-0.1444508135318756,
-0.7269430160522461,
0.11699718236923218,
0.4147338271141052,
-0.38624927401542664,
-0.38048890233039856,
0.001312915817834437,
-0.10467489063739777,
-0.1427152454853058,
0.11713441461324692,
-0.48156678676605225,
0.10014721006155014,
0.4528023302555084,
0.03461902588605881,
0.8648349642753601,
0.26297667622566223,
-0.039670996367931366,
-0.5461105108261108,
0.6132888197898865,
0.36079949140548706,
0.1932533234357834,
-0.060167256742715836,
-0.337834894657135,
-0.6636701226234436,
-0.4821610152721405,
0.7454475164413452,
0.1181352436542511,
-0.5939701795578003,
0.4245770275592804,
-0.28149116039276123,
-0.20312589406967163,
-0.4762771725654602,
0.3660190999507904,
0.13018912076950073,
0.15925979614257812,
0.47658658027648926,
-0.4117826223373413,
-0.5157819390296936,
-0.9449344277381897,
-0.46751320362091064,
-0.09495345503091812,
-0.20768015086650848,
0.35842299461364746,
0.7112504839897156,
0.032980021089315414,
1.1054456233978271,
-0.5128781795501709,
-0.20546434819698334,
-0.05208924040198326,
0.29989922046661377,
0.06684660911560059,
0.5202005505561829,
0.3794749677181244,
-0.9457462430000305,
-0.2910160720348358,
-0.4244759976863861,
-0.8505778312683105,
-0.2772926986217499,
0.08677959442138672,
-0.052012283354997635,
-0.328988254070282,
0.4708799123764038,
0.002089685294777155,
0.8141535520553589,
0.5265315175056458,
-0.22268544137477875,
0.6241810321807861,
-0.10525147616863251,
0.2532186508178711,
-0.7455621957778931,
0.029240835458040237,
-0.2695883810520172,
-0.2372157722711563,
-0.3167608380317688,
0.01952972449362278,
0.34699803590774536,
-0.20684091746807098,
-0.5220581889152527,
0.37096959352493286,
-0.3019840121269226,
-0.2317303568124771,
-0.5259003639221191,
-0.5580507516860962,
0.03340716287493706,
0.07514345645904541,
0.11962281912565231,
0.9838422536849976,
0.5712607502937317,
-0.6602515578269958,
0.11325185000896454,
0.018275268375873566,
-0.646745502948761,
0.6640032529830933,
-0.749794065952301,
0.34612998366355896,
-0.12367410957813263,
0.13255959749221802,
-0.8185483813285828,
-0.028423957526683807,
0.06200192868709564,
-0.17205609381198883,
0.2046504020690918,
-0.6546031832695007,
-0.7246143221855164,
-0.18334577977657318,
-0.2846194803714752,
0.41137516498565674,
0.30060699582099915,
-0.5893199443817139,
0.30823415517807007,
0.2536441385746002,
0.3497091829776764,
-0.43438705801963806,
-0.9604473114013672,
-0.11811830848455429,
-0.5090353488922119,
-0.5837149024009705,
0.588444709777832,
-0.29425379633903503,
0.014191042631864548,
-0.03495096415281296,
-0.41152089834213257,
-0.5297113656997681,
0.38961514830589294,
0.6012102365493774,
0.20490537583827972,
-0.1812652349472046,
-0.24001148343086243,
-0.2815333306789398,
-0.1468651443719864,
0.012287700548768044,
-0.35302242636680603,
0.3395971357822418,
0.23267072439193726,
-0.9093494415283203,
-0.41590172052383423,
0.010899033397436142,
0.35349011421203613,
-0.3284403383731842,
0.4495091438293457,
0.5199993252754211,
-0.5470759868621826,
-0.3958125710487366,
-0.6584046483039856,
-0.27444347739219666,
-0.5024028420448303,
-0.10810540616512299,
-0.038207679986953735,
-0.6373786926269531,
0.605836808681488,
0.004178480710834265,
0.14292511343955994,
-0.051967862993478775,
0.15375393629074097,
-0.29340660572052,
0.3618232309818268,
0.5099384188652039,
-0.21539181470870972,
0.8009821772575378,
-0.5036296844482422,
0.2607870399951935,
-0.7190171480178833,
0.02023889683187008,
-0.4183175563812256,
-0.5450453162193298,
-0.2614750266075134,
-0.45778632164001465,
0.10254368185997009,
0.29557478427886963,
-0.18696320056915283,
0.4805300831794739,
-0.13167162239551544,
0.85206139087677,
0.6455920934677124,
0.47910138964653015,
0.2863869369029999,
0.08449377864599228,
-0.01425278838723898,
-0.2506275773048401,
-0.19153867661952972,
-0.507839560508728,
1.5644981861114502,
0.2001344859600067,
0.6350405812263489,
-0.1491532027721405,
1.2413955926895142,
0.7114797830581665,
0.6372824907302856,
-0.4939241111278534,
0.3880215883255005,
0.16076652705669403,
-1.101594090461731,
-0.26536720991134644,
-0.40154334902763367,
-1.008657693862915,
-0.012333564460277557,
-0.24984395503997803,
-0.254198282957077,
0.2503618001937866,
0.007272764109075069,
-0.02623826451599598,
0.452519953250885,
-0.37904050946235657,
0.6671357750892639,
-0.48097777366638184,
-0.7155212163925171,
-0.010256925597786903,
-0.1140080988407135,
0.21977975964546204,
-0.451911598443985,
0.33885884284973145,
-0.3389335870742798,
0.18968218564987183,
1.0897053480148315,
-0.4792349636554718,
0.4974671006202698,
-0.5787651538848877,
-0.11027415096759796,
0.5102162957191467,
0.12786409258842468,
0.3966471552848816,
0.007727041840553284,
-0.007049181032925844,
0.09143862128257751,
-0.10381536185741425,
-0.5160893797874451,
-0.3046901822090149,
0.1324804127216339,
-0.5757412314414978,
-0.4527791440486908,
-0.37043049931526184,
-0.39491015672683716,
-0.17377088963985443,
0.4243334233760834,
0.27348846197128296,
0.15699532628059387,
0.17404425144195557,
0.5207827091217041,
0.7921890616416931,
0.07674595713615417,
0.2913403809070587,
0.7227402329444885,
-0.021095991134643555,
-0.18657784163951874,
1.0548653602600098,
0.3606639802455902,
0.08315244317054749,
0.0114506296813488,
0.30749747157096863,
-0.43231821060180664,
-1.2838276624679565,
-0.1856180876493454,
0.16461578011512756,
-0.5973464846611023,
-0.16162733733654022,
-0.09922613948583603,
-0.22724732756614685,
0.07530239224433899,
0.06665186583995819,
-0.3587420582771301,
0.060442496091127396,
-0.15274423360824585,
-0.10325804352760315,
0.27158457040786743,
0.6679751873016357,
-0.09177318960428238,
0.4572232663631439,
-0.4601513147354126,
0.6209068894386292,
0.5623257160186768,
0.5599271059036255,
-0.2038397341966629,
-0.7397556304931641,
-0.24492967128753662,
0.2251368761062622,
-0.4419662356376648,
-0.6293817162513733,
0.10305432230234146,
-0.000353647192241624,
0.6501777768135071,
0.6439486145973206,
0.10312990844249725,
0.6238805055618286,
-0.30768245458602905,
0.6652570366859436,
-0.035879041999578476,
-0.935590386390686,
0.4851979911327362,
-0.2935939431190491,
-0.35086944699287415,
0.8955130577087402,
0.5247518420219421,
-0.04555707424879074,
-0.34917789697647095,
-0.8928229212760925,
-0.5785572528839111,
0.32882991433143616,
0.2985340356826782,
-0.060345608741045,
0.42221298813819885,
0.42754852771759033,
0.034048158675432205,
0.19887767732143402,
-1.0008951425552368,
-0.29439133405685425,
-0.13770350813865662,
-0.07559742033481598,
0.1970597505569458,
-0.20421543717384338,
-0.19725321233272552,
-0.010006860829889774,
0.655123233795166,
0.027269680052995682,
0.12446268647909164,
0.12330760061740875,
-0.2996334731578827,
0.03323131799697876,
0.06680724769830704,
0.0739947035908699,
0.8035592436790466,
-0.42031368613243103,
0.1614273637533188,
-0.04872358217835426,
-0.5521001219749451,
0.433817058801651,
-0.0068862237967550755,
-0.3028853237628937,
-0.02734878845512867,
0.6216427683830261,
0.36388877034187317,
0.2112046182155609,
-0.3548141419887543,
0.7842331528663635,
-0.06596437096595764,
-0.3240753710269928,
-0.1633075326681137,
0.29969003796577454,
0.19800442457199097,
0.0557430125772953,
0.5575773119926453,
-0.27877339720726013,
-0.11415279656648636,
-0.3696024715900421,
0.6011495590209961,
0.4238227307796478,
-0.1538105010986328,
-0.2690891623497009,
0.757822573184967,
-0.16745275259017944,
-0.049272067844867706,
0.3562478721141815,
-0.01250365935266018,
-0.5379953980445862,
0.7362275123596191,
0.3750215172767639,
0.5809179544448853,
-0.061587173491716385,
-0.11658141762018204,
0.1608550250530243,
0.2136249542236328,
-0.33071884512901306,
0.3067237436771393,
-0.2524334788322449,
-0.8783538341522217,
0.048190489411354065,
-0.5464040637016296,
-0.6633185744285583,
0.4922386407852173,
-0.8495528101921082,
0.28335967659950256,
-0.7595704793930054,
-0.40092605352401733,
0.21249015629291534,
0.22735734283924103,
-0.732964277267456,
0.34131908416748047,
0.4698105454444885,
0.7528347969055176,
-1.1023212671279907,
0.8539882302284241,
0.2632758319377899,
-0.2973152995109558,
-0.6357809901237488,
-0.012150686234235764,
0.09864499419927597,
-0.9499627351760864,
0.38400375843048096,
0.3337689936161041,
0.272614449262619,
-0.05772542580962181,
-1.112675428390503,
-0.6853979825973511,
1.1872602701187134,
0.5796133279800415,
-0.5587711334228516,
0.3745933473110199,
0.4882175624370575,
0.12920290231704712,
-0.2171664834022522,
-0.23573118448257446,
0.4133284091949463,
0.5980838537216187,
-0.032101526856422424,
-0.23974819481372833,
0.0704181045293808,
-0.05649711936712265,
-0.39399728178977966,
-0.1337820589542389,
-0.3281334638595581,
0.8284443020820618,
0.006236664019525051,
-0.42915114760398865,
-0.1570661962032318,
0.5909568667411804,
0.8558104038238525,
0.4371618330478668,
0.6962397694587708,
0.6146558523178101,
1.0027391910552979,
-0.23111507296562195,
1.0837032794952393,
-0.27154791355133057,
0.30694589018821716,
0.8813036680221558,
-0.47931644320487976,
0.712972104549408,
0.4917251169681549,
-0.472761869430542,
0.38869497179985046,
0.6921876668930054,
-0.4678795635700226,
0.5509158968925476,
0.7095023393630981,
-0.2665436267852783,
-0.45394429564476013,
-0.196525439620018,
-0.6528374552726746,
-0.06945888698101044,
0.07752694189548492,
-0.3470570147037506,
0.1272837221622467,
-0.32192695140838623,
-0.10669679194688797,
-0.1658550500869751,
-0.09027818590402603,
0.45451468229293823,
0.2984592318534851,
-0.07786022871732712,
0.4392957389354706,
-0.030796820297837257,
0.8471929430961609,
-0.8143898248672485,
0.1910061240196228,
-0.2785530090332031,
0.13216696679592133,
-0.40608590841293335,
-0.8087142109870911,
0.004409925080835819,
0.08493970334529877,
0.03451436758041382,
-0.13754987716674805,
0.7986840009689331,
-0.32643193006515503,
-0.3104628026485443,
0.19330692291259766,
0.42952919006347656,
0.26681777834892273,
-0.3716636896133423,
-0.6150705814361572,
0.20071041584014893,
-0.03755117580294609,
-0.164164736866951,
0.4952802062034607,
0.34116330742836,
-0.02959396317601204,
0.7639532089233398,
1.1775628328323364,
0.3871335983276367,
0.25199177861213684,
0.12285260111093521,
0.6926233172416687,
-0.5696110725402832,
-0.5529667139053345,
-0.831139087677002,
0.14841152727603912,
-0.16917933523654938,
-0.052009664475917816,
0.7653241157531738,
0.803404688835144,
0.8098084330558777,
-0.056827183812856674,
0.8767622709274292,
0.2486562430858612,
-0.07217565923929214,
-0.5367797017097473,
0.8651692867279053,
-0.4943741261959076,
0.053415823727846146,
-0.17831522226333618,
-0.8010696172714233,
-0.15871234238147736,
0.500461757183075,
-0.239967480301857,
-0.07853657752275467,
0.5639724731445312,
0.6938267350196838,
-0.463136225938797,
0.20456507802009583,
0.24174737930297852,
-0.42236417531967163,
0.6720954775810242,
0.39423680305480957,
0.9650691747665405,
-0.6407471299171448,
0.299179345369339,
-0.46749207377433777,
-0.01005861908197403,
-0.0689888745546341,
-1.2740848064422607,
-0.9679624438285828,
-0.41546496748924255,
-0.6301999092102051,
-0.45599064230918884,
-0.14020097255706787,
0.5282629728317261,
1.1551679372787476,
-1.1092182397842407,
-0.035183731466531754,
0.10698919743299484,
0.2589360475540161,
-0.1122167706489563,
-0.22243839502334595,
0.4277436435222626,
0.20005469024181366,
-0.2313508540391922,
0.33699896931648254,
-0.03536758944392204,
0.9345264434814453,
-0.016590910032391548,
-0.09626351296901703,
0.06068447604775429,
0.12606117129325867,
-0.09994189441204071,
0.2238301783800125,
-0.016685547307133675,
-0.1628400981426239,
-0.38466861844062805,
0.10302253067493439,
0.05552656576037407,
1.199570894241333,
-0.3671112060546875,
0.2827545404434204,
0.28262874484062195,
0.7608458399772644,
0.8510992527008057,
0.23996277153491974,
0.2431012988090515,
-0.7358778119087219,
0.25467148423194885,
0.08800145238637924,
0.5686044096946716,
0.42848655581474304,
-0.20583462715148926,
0.49052953720092773,
0.588692307472229,
-0.2881520390510559,
-1.0300638675689697,
-0.15060542523860931,
-0.660110592842102,
0.033483296632766724,
0.8863927125930786,
-0.6726992726325989,
-0.29307204484939575,
-0.3088096082210541,
0.1575065553188324,
0.11602012813091278,
0.0008766763494350016,
0.7653868198394775,
0.9791887402534485,
0.273302286863327,
0.21981678903102875,
-0.5501219034194946,
0.5034939646720886,
0.25937870144844055,
-0.9552293419837952,
0.4580497443675995,
0.18352578580379486,
0.741977334022522,
0.02357632666826248,
0.598832905292511,
-0.37936124205589294,
0.20804263651371002,
-0.031103141605854034,
-0.026253992691636086,
-0.6769707202911377,
-0.21480122208595276,
-0.18898442387580872,
0.0362476222217083,
0.02108491212129593,
-0.330299973487854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10891v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10891v1 | Instruction Diversity Drives Generalization To Unseen Tasks | 2024-02-16T18:47:21 | 2024-02-16T18:47:21 | Dylan Zhang, Justin Wang, Francois Charton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Instruction tuning -- fine-tuning a large language model (LLM) on pairs of
instructions and desired outcomes -- is an approach that enables pre-trained
language models to perform real-world tasks and follow human instructions. Its
practical success depends on the model learning a broader set of instructions
than those it was trained on. Yet the factors that determine model
generalization to such \emph{unseen tasks} are not well understood. %To
understand the driving factors of generalization, In this paper, we experiment
with string rewrites, a symbolic task that serves as a building block for
Turing complete Markov algorithms while allowing experimental control of
"inputs" and "instructions". We investigate the trade-off between the number of
instructions the model is trained on and the number of training samples
provided for each instruction and observe that the diversity of the instruction
set determines generalization. Generalization emerges once a diverse enough set
of tasks is provided, even though very few examples are provided for each task.
Instruction diversity also ensures robustness with respect to non-uniform
distributions of instructions in the training set. | [
-0.23834161460399628,
-0.9276549816131592,
0.4321032166481018,
0.07144144177436829,
-0.35065197944641113,
0.24105650186538696,
-0.25189369916915894,
-0.2548995614051819,
-0.20113682746887207,
0.5589063763618469,
-0.9465183019638062,
-0.6657614707946777,
-0.8493077754974365,
-0.021600978448987007,
-0.3994768261909485,
1.3462663888931274,
-0.07197526842355728,
-0.08738632500171661,
0.10304907709360123,
-0.061523474752902985,
-0.4453667402267456,
-0.30334070324897766,
-0.401621013879776,
-0.30122047662734985,
0.6779918074607849,
0.5415349006652832,
0.6896209716796875,
0.9969755411148071,
0.4081414043903351,
0.3965643346309662,
0.07311677932739258,
0.121230348944664,
-0.718417763710022,
0.3204774260520935,
-0.11405506730079651,
-0.9647181630134583,
-0.14649656414985657,
0.04476082697510719,
0.9845808148384094,
0.9375476837158203,
-0.15925104916095734,
0.32867124676704407,
0.2857057750225067,
0.6651890277862549,
-0.41073811054229736,
-0.0752808153629303,
-0.85857093334198,
-0.07823783159255981,
-0.17083309590816498,
-0.12134968489408493,
-0.22561046481132507,
-0.4421543478965759,
0.056061867624521255,
-0.6374703645706177,
0.7800183892250061,
-0.03050672449171543,
0.7107331156730652,
0.086025670170784,
-0.5626851320266724,
-0.14550237357616425,
-0.969822883605957,
1.2104054689407349,
-0.3791819214820862,
0.25764521956443787,
0.23455049097537994,
0.07252607494592667,
-0.43140193819999695,
-0.3364184498786926,
-0.11572562158107758,
0.011456883512437344,
0.162746399641037,
-0.25117719173431396,
-0.155264213681221,
0.3822424113750458,
0.4630128741264343,
0.46029937267303467,
-0.25499427318573,
0.20895349979400635,
-0.5625510811805725,
0.06961243599653244,
0.5229291319847107,
0.3415393531322479,
0.5724891424179077,
0.3290345370769501,
0.2069420963525772,
-0.11411663889884949,
-0.696671187877655,
0.19224706292152405,
0.6034281849861145,
0.1950433999300003,
-0.13161815702915192,
0.6564394235610962,
-0.4136953055858612,
0.8917463421821594,
0.06284945458173752,
0.09833884239196777,
0.01923324540257454,
-0.5108699798583984,
-0.35696616768836975,
-0.1695140302181244,
0.35814085602760315,
0.15189483761787415,
0.5554381608963013,
-0.051978301256895065,
-0.18662840127944946,
0.08180024474859238,
0.559851884841919,
-0.6534837484359741,
-0.1682807058095932,
-0.2712654173374176,
-0.45862460136413574,
-0.1447066366672516,
0.006948441732674837,
-0.25290462374687195,
0.09669534116983414,
-0.5670823454856873,
0.11950068920850754,
-0.4893864095211029,
0.1552133709192276,
0.07324158400297165,
-0.42002737522125244,
0.36848634481430054,
0.37098053097724915,
-1.4489017724990845,
0.5186971426010132,
1.0543969869613647,
0.5579249858856201,
-0.13582704961299896,
-0.41713443398475647,
-0.45711129903793335,
0.17554952204227448,
-0.5180037617683411,
0.4181433320045471,
-1.0364048480987549,
-0.38076505064964294,
-0.3058357834815979,
0.11721301078796387,
-0.22827480733394623,
-0.5346183776855469,
0.17497201263904572,
-0.4732459783554077,
0.09775160998106003,
-0.2331024408340454,
-0.4802696406841278,
-0.41668522357940674,
-0.21016620099544525,
-0.4765987992286682,
0.6301576495170593,
0.1926536113023758,
-0.46557459235191345,
0.6983711123466492,
-0.4757865369319916,
-0.593913733959198,
-0.08826383948326111,
-0.33282336592674255,
-0.45397794246673584,
0.8407977223396301,
-0.03921443596482277,
0.18495945632457733,
-0.18824391067028046,
0.023341042920947075,
-0.2491060048341751,
-0.9012982249259949,
0.09958799183368683,
-0.47392570972442627,
0.522309422492981,
-0.022172797471284866,
-0.6071057319641113,
0.3156980276107788,
-0.5329626798629761,
0.07371730357408524,
0.047564778476953506,
-0.6669146418571472,
-0.45725810527801514,
0.02402382716536522,
-0.5205952525138855,
-0.17933639883995056,
-0.045859429985284805,
-0.49561434984207153,
0.418681263923645,
-0.6128215789794922,
0.21416117250919342,
0.9348602294921875,
-0.06073641777038574,
0.48423805832862854,
-0.4187048375606537,
0.6849604845046997,
-0.12517423927783966,
0.08306329697370529,
-0.20628869533538818,
-0.9005476236343384,
-0.8474608659744263,
0.10743258893489838,
0.19289301335811615,
0.565567672252655,
-0.28984686732292175,
0.09453989565372467,
-0.09971150755882263,
-0.3754628300666809,
-0.8900995850563049,
0.4302685558795929,
0.6249183416366577,
-0.04828430339694023,
0.05474745109677315,
-0.3093506991863251,
-0.6011718511581421,
-1.1909717321395874,
-0.6601276993751526,
0.35616642236709595,
-0.23426386713981628,
0.24936586618423462,
0.4082348346710205,
-0.3680785298347473,
0.4539918005466461,
-0.36899805068969727,
0.10687214881181717,
-0.16183096170425415,
0.2768181562423706,
0.41381874680519104,
0.750612199306488,
0.1923678070306778,
-0.5695533156394958,
-0.2790786921977997,
0.0015765082789584994,
-0.5614824891090393,
0.052480246871709824,
-0.2363557666540146,
-0.1021452397108078,
0.23830367624759674,
0.34034252166748047,
-0.2342509627342224,
0.4554727375507355,
0.6066160202026367,
-0.11152727901935577,
0.3669266402721405,
-0.5706804990768433,
0.3313949406147003,
-0.6917125582695007,
-0.2925448715686798,
-0.11666368693113327,
0.08356822282075882,
-0.6165619492530823,
0.35340818762779236,
-0.14351724088191986,
-0.11301732063293457,
-0.2240694761276245,
0.01841418817639351,
-0.844894289970398,
-0.26500964164733887,
-0.31762173771858215,
-0.22532185912132263,
-0.21055713295936584,
0.6184022426605225,
-0.32207638025283813,
0.6220137476921082,
0.8066121935844421,
-0.7173183560371399,
0.1360454112291336,
-0.16752487421035767,
-0.25937727093696594,
0.06786609441041946,
-0.787993848323822,
0.2013075351715088,
-0.1492827832698822,
-0.13186782598495483,
-0.927647054195404,
-0.018755193799734116,
0.12321989238262177,
-0.22783981263637543,
0.2909444570541382,
-0.10921797156333923,
-0.5286005735397339,
-0.14892800152301788,
-0.08433572202920914,
0.5839273929595947,
0.7753921151161194,
-0.20950330793857574,
0.6518029570579529,
0.10626187920570374,
0.10722538828849792,
-0.5554527044296265,
-0.6811997294425964,
-0.2975674271583557,
-0.014300910755991936,
-0.45259952545166016,
0.07462181895971298,
-0.1570269614458084,
-0.2693454325199127,
-0.19142885506153107,
-0.4822475016117096,
-0.02809607982635498,
0.4760381281375885,
0.6066814064979553,
0.18650515377521515,
-0.3345780670642853,
0.10501988232135773,
0.6776300072669983,
0.17471188306808472,
0.22153273224830627,
-0.5598583817481995,
0.5106701850891113,
-0.00962338037788868,
-0.6665375828742981,
-0.48474016785621643,
0.5546870827674866,
0.23156706988811493,
-0.15165366232395172,
0.7349547743797302,
0.3218300938606262,
-0.013736950233578682,
-0.5521258115768433,
-0.2892405390739441,
-0.2802014648914337,
-0.579382061958313,
0.6013395190238953,
-0.5381882786750793,
-1.254754900932312,
0.2915302515029907,
-0.04169998690485954,
0.43071502447128296,
0.2880531847476959,
0.47615426778793335,
-0.18315809965133667,
1.105543851852417,
0.714657723903656,
0.2547415494918823,
0.5487242341041565,
-0.08038656413555145,
-0.07906041294336319,
-0.5676811337471008,
-0.049737539142370224,
-0.44740864634513855,
-0.7946190237998962,
-1.0923858880996704,
-0.5553663969039917,
0.07392952591180801,
0.0035211113281548023,
-0.20054395496845245,
0.10203702747821808,
-0.6980397701263428,
0.889582097530365,
1.0199358463287354,
0.15234322845935822,
0.07027165591716766,
0.29459431767463684,
-0.2366369515657425,
0.05110566318035126,
-0.6299772262573242,
-0.39283978939056396,
1.3767714500427246,
0.18044139444828033,
0.8526816368103027,
-0.02182445302605629,
1.1962215900421143,
0.09938716143369675,
-0.06481856107711792,
-0.48155125975608826,
0.7186631560325623,
-0.6824737191200256,
-0.42820584774017334,
-0.34946614503860474,
-0.44233939051628113,
-1.4604161977767944,
0.28118616342544556,
-0.12166435271501541,
-0.644824743270874,
-0.08807075768709183,
0.3586023449897766,
-0.13677586615085602,
0.37994202971458435,
-0.7652257680892944,
0.6923314332962036,
-0.09576132148504257,
-0.06825827807188034,
-0.6665268540382385,
-0.5032906532287598,
0.5657678842544556,
-0.05129464343190193,
0.024262597784399986,
0.04889044165611267,
-0.08333425223827362,
0.6671721935272217,
0.08514173328876495,
1.1577786207199097,
0.09199982136487961,
-0.3144511878490448,
0.017938952893018723,
0.23315060138702393,
0.5230990052223206,
-0.18782839179039001,
0.23188486695289612,
0.02182186394929886,
-0.40480098128318787,
-0.52598637342453,
-0.7555252909660339,
0.8121944665908813,
-0.9445827603340149,
-1.129723072052002,
-0.027774939313530922,
-0.8520880937576294,
0.02972046658396721,
0.0593671053647995,
0.18056826293468475,
0.4833912253379822,
-0.24163486063480377,
0.3530808389186859,
1.0596239566802979,
-0.2578704357147217,
0.14360634982585907,
0.42678266763687134,
-0.21196116507053375,
0.10487538576126099,
0.9214990735054016,
0.123203344643116,
0.6904964447021484,
0.5707812309265137,
-0.03720659762620926,
0.2955348789691925,
-0.6256974935531616,
-0.2225165218114853,
0.1647469848394394,
-0.7166565656661987,
0.4360896646976471,
-0.6416974067687988,
-0.03729797527194023,
-0.29358208179473877,
-0.11635956913232803,
0.005416959524154663,
-0.42770659923553467,
-0.5099121332168579,
-0.13160063326358795,
0.06004755571484566,
0.9969124794006348,
0.12122458964586258,
0.31410279870033264,
-0.7296432852745056,
0.6024677753448486,
0.7054374814033508,
0.4512479603290558,
-0.040733806788921356,
-0.6524534821510315,
-0.20988203585147858,
0.1934114545583725,
-0.20224465429782867,
-0.8573899269104004,
-0.0011255701538175344,
0.22865675389766693,
0.774728536605835,
0.3096276521682739,
-0.4621864855289459,
0.48006147146224976,
-0.7033835649490356,
0.3866459131240845,
-0.19316548109054565,
-0.9715598821640015,
0.6551164984703064,
-0.49728670716285706,
0.6832630634307861,
0.28946563601493835,
0.1710362285375595,
-0.4752154052257538,
-0.9730284214019775,
-0.6870442032814026,
-0.6229054927825928,
0.8556726574897766,
0.21304187178611755,
0.38899871706962585,
0.1385382115840912,
0.3250161409378052,
0.3536161482334137,
0.27603280544281006,
-0.31771597266197205,
-0.3538382053375244,
-0.10420522093772888,
-0.0542365200817585,
-0.19820676743984222,
-0.3045220375061035,
-0.3044307827949524,
-0.28190547227859497,
0.2663024067878723,
0.09649152308702469,
0.22593778371810913,
-0.3583845794200897,
-0.03070957586169243,
-0.19814161956310272,
0.5994893312454224,
1.0769914388656616,
0.5712186694145203,
-0.06694896519184113,
0.18618616461753845,
0.14565984904766083,
-0.41797518730163574,
0.23808187246322632,
-0.18160688877105713,
-0.3737897574901581,
-0.05184372141957283,
0.3793126344680786,
1.2256393432617188,
0.5010785460472107,
-0.4185802638530731,
-0.198760986328125,
-0.0021443176083266735,
-0.3597743809223175,
0.14559732377529144,
0.9903530478477478,
0.10956815630197525,
0.2080305516719818,
0.27262505888938904,
0.12117155641317368,
0.11418090760707855,
-0.5977196097373962,
0.28510966897010803,
0.6490765810012817,
-0.14826799929141998,
-0.4359704256057739,
0.49350497126579285,
0.09097585082054138,
-0.6677185297012329,
0.7094751000404358,
-0.17049571871757507,
-0.27175411581993103,
0.8825230002403259,
0.6807523965835571,
0.9328029751777649,
-0.2647647261619568,
0.24745693802833557,
0.1873202919960022,
0.682330846786499,
0.04645218700170517,
0.5017768144607544,
-0.17415423691272736,
-0.5407214760780334,
-0.1954944133758545,
-0.5660678744316101,
-0.3211502730846405,
-0.22369597852230072,
-0.6037521958351135,
-0.1338425874710083,
-0.5851663947105408,
0.15180358290672302,
-0.23011019825935364,
-0.2656925618648529,
-0.7018348574638367,
0.3099963963031769,
0.038861650973558426,
0.4940579831600189,
-0.8203501105308533,
0.8157309889793396,
0.5747559070587158,
-0.04361988231539726,
-0.9244022965431213,
-0.034630365669727325,
-0.017527218908071518,
-1.1084702014923096,
0.9121540188789368,
0.16684915125370026,
-0.028225883841514587,
-0.002456930698826909,
-0.6273088455200195,
-0.9170833826065063,
0.8539433479309082,
0.49360567331314087,
-0.9071168899536133,
-0.10559725016355515,
0.25922396779060364,
0.5817228555679321,
-0.4136526584625244,
-0.05988362804055214,
0.6041747331619263,
0.38044261932373047,
-0.05746830999851227,
-0.864710807800293,
0.05661921203136444,
-0.2713928818702698,
0.2558169364929199,
0.4827919900417328,
-0.2583313286304474,
1.093026876449585,
-0.4445888102054596,
-0.41955867409706116,
-0.17204387485980988,
0.6193765997886658,
0.5843508243560791,
-0.0035719063598662615,
0.40467387437820435,
0.3609566390514374,
0.6763975620269775,
-0.0449489951133728,
1.2615126371383667,
0.036163412034511566,
-0.079981230199337,
1.1998727321624756,
0.18538124859333038,
0.4662579596042633,
0.5439906716346741,
-0.1271110475063324,
0.7757583260536194,
0.4864978492259979,
-0.5041659474372864,
0.19631512463092804,
0.7670798301696777,
-0.19952355325222015,
-0.33508655428886414,
0.11772013455629349,
-0.1715191900730133,
0.32899728417396545,
0.14923901855945587,
-0.6200376749038696,
-0.24230748414993286,
-0.030371779575943947,
-0.2364293485879898,
0.03237166255712509,
-0.4853658080101013,
0.7997863292694092,
-0.014612934552133083,
-0.8214206695556641,
0.7914858460426331,
0.06949380040168762,
0.7477381229400635,
-0.773869514465332,
-0.2787313759326935,
-0.023498091846704483,
0.18071205914020538,
-0.0842479020357132,
-0.7998277544975281,
0.24646209180355072,
-0.25375503301620483,
-0.573256254196167,
-0.20806941390037537,
0.5936279892921448,
-0.4932730495929718,
-0.6411247849464417,
0.20723748207092285,
0.2503228783607483,
0.2367994636297226,
-0.05564373731613159,
-0.5768303275108337,
-0.016983477398753166,
0.30584102869033813,
-0.16422876715660095,
0.6724175810813904,
0.6758052706718445,
-0.24823908507823944,
0.777633011341095,
0.6206894516944885,
0.03538710996508598,
0.48750749230384827,
-0.009637040086090565,
0.8537417054176331,
-0.7385095953941345,
-0.334303081035614,
-0.9936468601226807,
0.36714211106300354,
0.23742710053920746,
-0.3334173858165741,
0.8823551535606384,
0.438131183385849,
0.9642699956893921,
-0.4115070402622223,
0.6640759110450745,
0.4662523567676544,
0.12481770664453506,
-0.4194464087486267,
0.5881443619728088,
-0.46295034885406494,
0.16107916831970215,
-0.06897646188735962,
-0.8904988765716553,
-0.061973847448825836,
0.18886379897594452,
-0.2285700887441635,
0.34348592162132263,
0.5428746938705444,
0.8569063544273376,
-0.14243057370185852,
-0.0199375469237566,
0.42972657084465027,
-0.10489197820425034,
0.05720505863428116,
0.7087149620056152,
0.6650809049606323,
-0.17803075909614563,
0.5141554474830627,
-0.017106350511312485,
-0.23498931527137756,
0.1000332161784172,
-0.5219046473503113,
-0.985381007194519,
-0.3820267915725708,
-0.2214806079864502,
0.12089363485574722,
0.2281494438648224,
0.6399109959602356,
0.5599575042724609,
-0.9137500524520874,
-0.5202405452728271,
-0.35053810477256775,
0.4791478216648102,
-0.514732837677002,
-0.16650889813899994,
-0.07010815292596817,
-0.6124260425567627,
-0.7862532138824463,
0.3809927999973297,
0.22795741260051727,
0.1725492626428604,
0.012667454779148102,
0.02400180511176586,
-0.14344678819179535,
0.16276437044143677,
0.18737398087978363,
0.25598302483558655,
-0.9942891001701355,
-0.12518183887004852,
0.1454233080148697,
-0.015351173467934132,
0.04137728735804558,
1.016659140586853,
-0.44941410422325134,
0.3648054897785187,
0.435794472694397,
0.6267157196998596,
0.21729198098182678,
-0.028339093551039696,
1.016831636428833,
-0.907305121421814,
-0.20708560943603516,
-0.17064853012561798,
0.090537890791893,
-0.009486467577517033,
-0.33848837018013,
0.16008152067661285,
0.23988215625286102,
-0.6735657453536987,
-0.6231858730316162,
0.5136735439300537,
-0.5984428524971008,
-0.46835288405418396,
1.021347999572754,
-0.10902583599090576,
-0.31390276551246643,
-0.03476874902844429,
-0.22769863903522491,
0.4823541045188904,
-0.398872435092926,
0.8007174134254456,
0.5935532450675964,
-0.10319142043590546,
-0.37968286871910095,
-0.3109265863895416,
0.5499876141548157,
0.7358524799346924,
-0.6535803079605103,
0.1627143919467926,
0.3708471655845642,
0.4201192259788513,
-0.09073743969202042,
0.3008418083190918,
0.4365091025829315,
0.52752286195755,
-0.0880088359117508,
-0.007975636050105095,
-0.05910422280430794,
-0.34772321581840515,
-0.5690619349479675,
0.3132341504096985,
0.05780008062720299,
-0.4554634392261505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10890v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10890v2 | When is Tree Search Useful for LLM Planning? It Depends on the Discriminator | 2024-02-16T18:45:58 | 2024-06-06T14:55:40 | Ziru Chen, Michael White, Raymond Mooney, Ali Payani, Yu Su, Huan Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we examine how large language models (LLMs) solve multi-step
problems under a language agent framework with three components: a generator, a
discriminator, and a planning method. We investigate the practical utility of
two advanced planning methods, iterative correction and tree search. We present
a comprehensive analysis of how discrimination accuracy affects the overall
performance of agents when using these two methods or a simpler method,
re-ranking. Experiments on two tasks, text-to-SQL parsing and mathematical
reasoning, show that: (1) advanced planning methods demand discriminators with
at least 90% accuracy to achieve significant improvements over re-ranking; (2)
current LLMs' discrimination abilities have not met the needs of advanced
planning methods to achieve such improvements; (3) with LLM-based
discriminators, advanced planning methods may not adequately balance accuracy
and efficiency. For example, compared to the other two methods, tree search is
at least 10--20 times slower but leads to negligible performance gains, which
hinders its real-world applications. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/OSU-NLP-Group/llm-planning-eval. | [
-0.1571163535118103,
-0.6436184048652649,
0.7946402430534363,
0.20583084225654602,
-0.07304246723651886,
0.3662562370300293,
-0.09965213388204575,
-0.6477872729301453,
0.06240556761622429,
0.4109199643135071,
-0.33624497056007385,
-0.5291706323623657,
-0.5820934772491455,
0.24260927736759186,
-0.46458154916763306,
0.29159823060035706,
-0.1798078566789627,
-0.05350315198302269,
0.174020454287529,
-0.12657442688941956,
-0.588056743144989,
-0.5437675714492798,
-0.9228179454803467,
-0.48255085945129395,
0.6214934587478638,
0.5073835253715515,
0.9733151197433472,
0.9504243731498718,
0.20718331634998322,
0.434892863035202,
-0.46428075432777405,
0.17864231765270233,
-0.15554171800613403,
0.5905881524085999,
-0.023821169510483742,
-0.6536948084831238,
-0.40822166204452515,
-0.07495023310184479,
0.6753586530685425,
0.5003073215484619,
-0.4129921495914459,
-0.23563091456890106,
-0.20675529539585114,
0.8710899949073792,
-0.688198983669281,
0.36346226930618286,
-1.0042777061462402,
0.13174191117286682,
-0.3783767521381378,
-0.44632071256637573,
-0.6105309128761292,
-0.27303004264831543,
-0.08310726284980774,
-0.3430197536945343,
0.48083484172821045,
0.029502131044864655,
0.5189488530158997,
0.24289868772029877,
-0.41578298807144165,
-0.4765331745147705,
-0.9522275924682617,
0.8458102345466614,
-0.5323027968406677,
0.357512503862381,
0.5518127679824829,
0.4233870804309845,
-0.37783920764923096,
-0.4037843346595764,
-0.29261261224746704,
-0.15654252469539642,
-0.11755361407995224,
-0.25288766622543335,
-0.255499005317688,
0.45792055130004883,
0.5967411994934082,
0.14114166796207428,
-0.48237845301628113,
0.5790309906005859,
-0.10126225650310516,
-0.10001233965158463,
0.6514002680778503,
0.14820703864097595,
0.11495471000671387,
0.1341346800327301,
0.2704337239265442,
-0.35725846886634827,
-0.7415390610694885,
0.13580727577209473,
0.23231405019760132,
0.5410924553871155,
0.603251039981842,
0.5946948528289795,
-0.2853531539440155,
0.8427473306655884,
-0.20962998270988464,
-0.4037575125694275,
-0.01284059602767229,
-0.22579072415828705,
-0.09436438977718353,
0.1350804567337036,
0.37666743993759155,
0.25173720717430115,
0.4684120714664459,
-0.10277722030878067,
-0.8019716739654541,
0.20032213628292084,
0.11138471961021423,
-0.7037977576255798,
-0.2292669713497162,
0.36141321063041687,
-0.19786714017391205,
0.0729069635272026,
-0.49175411462783813,
-0.5871381163597107,
-0.2740679979324341,
-0.17832927405834198,
-0.051819052547216415,
-0.2253326177597046,
-0.13332106173038483,
0.13364121317863464,
0.04375503957271576,
0.28911152482032776,
0.5001912117004395,
-0.7545362114906311,
0.2219199389219284,
0.6916224360466003,
0.746184229850769,
0.09537995606660843,
-0.43248340487480164,
-0.7979559302330017,
0.1439390629529953,
-0.769787073135376,
0.9830664396286011,
-0.6097924113273621,
-0.4391075372695923,
0.25656014680862427,
-0.24993009865283966,
-0.22126705944538116,
-0.8356591463088989,
0.5871025919914246,
-0.6102055907249451,
-0.10498237609863281,
-0.17666611075401306,
-0.21335990726947784,
-0.25946885347366333,
0.008660261519253254,
-1.0611175298690796,
0.9663878679275513,
-0.18282483518123627,
-0.4751327931880951,
0.7596510052680969,
-0.557588517665863,
-0.5529499053955078,
0.018012387678027153,
-0.27719423174858093,
-0.604998767375946,
0.08945146948099136,
0.30300745368003845,
0.44410446286201477,
-0.025088487192988396,
0.3895682990550995,
-0.0021401247940957546,
-0.5768869519233704,
0.0056805904023349285,
-0.2794072926044464,
0.6709743738174438,
0.2012287676334381,
-0.3413916826248169,
0.3376321494579315,
-0.6043134927749634,
0.17238357663154602,
0.20344778895378113,
-0.8106721043586731,
-0.061302151530981064,
0.6731173992156982,
-0.35872143507003784,
0.14689667522907257,
-0.011524384841322899,
-0.48826661705970764,
0.2199055403470993,
-0.3675742745399475,
0.14473138749599457,
0.9918289184570312,
-0.541578471660614,
0.41528427600860596,
-0.3907141387462616,
0.7196833491325378,
-0.3664158582687378,
-0.0838494598865509,
-0.009180156514048576,
-0.42097964882850647,
-0.7496986985206604,
-0.01220155693590641,
0.16153421998023987,
0.4188331961631775,
-0.7193590998649597,
0.11410658061504364,
-0.10145377367734909,
-0.36529532074928284,
-0.34864532947540283,
-0.12052583694458008,
0.4807441830635071,
-0.4017581045627594,
0.31154200434684753,
-0.02939468063414097,
-0.7333453893661499,
-0.5142672061920166,
-0.4304738938808441,
-0.4910074472427368,
0.3258455693721771,
-0.020509371533989906,
0.2554838955402374,
0.11495447903871536,
0.9411359429359436,
-0.3541052043437958,
-0.35185086727142334,
-0.5262886881828308,
-0.060295842587947845,
0.11649657040834427,
0.08202509582042694,
0.5235822796821594,
-0.7810763120651245,
-0.44608044624328613,
0.06315603852272034,
-0.4528823792934418,
-0.24433304369449615,
0.044727593660354614,
0.3214825689792633,
0.5278860926628113,
0.45741406083106995,
-0.6987318396568298,
0.4300050139427185,
0.565285861492157,
-0.3051764667034149,
0.52569580078125,
-0.2528776228427887,
-0.1796308010816574,
-0.5455062985420227,
-0.15236014127731323,
-0.08013754338026047,
-0.19834986329078674,
-0.8025320768356323,
0.400571346282959,
-0.06697562336921692,
0.2710745930671692,
-0.2854194641113281,
0.3312179446220398,
-0.6421117186546326,
-0.4580850601196289,
-0.3909040689468384,
0.151323601603508,
-0.306483656167984,
0.2636706233024597,
-0.07368038594722748,
1.0445483922958374,
0.34233957529067993,
-0.8739513158798218,
0.09761872887611389,
0.05792215093970299,
-0.23288342356681824,
0.3162286579608917,
-0.14358624815940857,
0.30349841713905334,
-0.26150766015052795,
0.39384838938713074,
-0.8349031805992126,
0.13716550171375275,
0.022653279826045036,
-0.34450024366378784,
0.4201159179210663,
0.0029154778458178043,
-0.6478540897369385,
-0.4861232340335846,
-0.4897089898586273,
0.31365856528282166,
0.021834135055541992,
-0.7006021738052368,
0.7224848866462708,
0.31658366322517395,
0.039499420672655106,
-0.8403518795967102,
-0.5629391074180603,
0.12660951912403107,
-0.21124853193759918,
-0.41813725233078003,
0.5155960321426392,
0.0528644397854805,
-0.3262386918067932,
-0.14524182677268982,
-0.2900616526603699,
0.02068881317973137,
0.2613220810890198,
0.01744898222386837,
-0.24402669072151184,
-0.07231911271810532,
-0.06956467777490616,
-0.29140108823776245,
-0.3547511398792267,
0.06327995657920837,
0.11734634637832642,
0.8147358894348145,
0.28919950127601624,
-0.49488261342048645,
-0.22020657360553741,
0.34005337953567505,
0.3324521780014038,
-0.3340825140476227,
0.33736124634742737,
-0.01834246516227722,
-0.25478336215019226,
-0.2569214701652527,
-0.6360911130905151,
0.14517952501773834,
-0.46343374252319336,
0.6092597842216492,
-0.6748028993606567,
-0.7610693573951721,
0.41558048129081726,
-0.060022346675395966,
0.48149508237838745,
0.4068591892719269,
0.32994964718818665,
0.10517924278974533,
1.5589786767959595,
0.6906131505966187,
-0.0533151738345623,
0.5633720755577087,
-0.0844721719622612,
0.24876463413238525,
-0.6580744385719299,
-0.21502846479415894,
-1.1717065572738647,
-0.3845602571964264,
-0.7654229402542114,
-0.4022453725337982,
-0.08371326327323914,
0.082986019551754,
-0.08624662458896637,
0.37241706252098083,
-0.5756820440292358,
0.6740015745162964,
0.5851873755455017,
-0.2976662218570709,
0.6885430812835693,
0.09625440090894699,
-0.023883309215307236,
0.020271072164177895,
-0.6824151277542114,
-0.5679535269737244,
0.8994782567024231,
0.29260876774787903,
0.6449134945869446,
0.14283734560012817,
0.646933376789093,
-0.09671569615602493,
0.14170397818088531,
-0.9829662442207336,
0.8871913552284241,
-0.3492017984390259,
-0.5145685076713562,
-0.5473390817642212,
-0.34013909101486206,
-1.392706036567688,
0.6721668243408203,
0.20327164232730865,
-0.7370817065238953,
0.4039056897163391,
-0.000004707887001131894,
-0.07308819890022278,
0.5969254374504089,
-0.501056969165802,
0.3528384268283844,
-0.43355846405029297,
0.22642283141613007,
-0.49364492297172546,
-0.11723755300045013,
-0.005069546867161989,
-0.3213295340538025,
0.11413221806287766,
-0.34403201937675476,
0.06329811364412308,
0.8900666832923889,
-0.3032221496105194,
0.5120625495910645,
-0.42991864681243896,
-0.1532571017742157,
0.07384461909532547,
0.2682200074195862,
0.922967255115509,
-0.6970358490943909,
-0.4494771659374237,
-0.18333682417869568,
-0.03655068203806877,
-0.27800312638282776,
-0.33461228013038635,
0.43331819772720337,
-0.4942772090435028,
-1.0305639505386353,
-0.6190090775489807,
-0.5033671259880066,
0.00263682147487998,
0.15971499681472778,
-0.16378185153007507,
0.031681619584560394,
0.012853073887526989,
0.18895156681537628,
0.1654406487941742,
-0.28765544295310974,
0.790240466594696,
0.709382176399231,
-0.7579671740531921,
0.025284457951784134,
0.6571745276451111,
0.46759918332099915,
0.32076916098594666,
0.4135732054710388,
0.22751890122890472,
-0.1952802985906601,
-1.0669230222702026,
-0.19701434671878815,
0.19423767924308777,
-0.8268094658851624,
-0.3328024744987488,
-0.49305281043052673,
-0.3218168318271637,
-0.017300447449088097,
-0.08457699418067932,
-0.21124790608882904,
-0.24282057583332062,
0.1774250864982605,
-0.22284111380577087,
0.2665921449661255,
0.9847044944763184,
-0.016560813412070274,
0.49512219429016113,
-0.13696730136871338,
0.13133712112903595,
0.16048723459243774,
0.19736361503601074,
-0.09427351504564285,
-0.014381328597664833,
-0.1333649456501007,
-0.10638707876205444,
-0.37135177850723267,
-0.7676476836204529,
0.4053867757320404,
0.1161363273859024,
0.7298858165740967,
-0.01943855732679367,
-0.10910256206989288,
0.7593111991882324,
-0.2714907228946686,
0.3298601806163788,
-0.26478031277656555,
-0.4761621057987213,
0.5460783243179321,
0.12758687138557434,
0.40973198413848877,
0.4848679006099701,
0.09079144150018692,
-0.341896653175354,
-0.5452036261558533,
-0.2571253180503845,
-0.8659072518348694,
1.1725085973739624,
0.2262088507413864,
-0.2881743609905243,
0.19059142470359802,
0.2234148532152176,
-0.2928272485733032,
0.03548318147659302,
-0.7089532613754272,
-0.29777106642723083,
0.3941296935081482,
0.4103633165359497,
-0.1382046490907669,
-0.5326433181762695,
0.1484190821647644,
-0.1582476645708084,
0.5580825805664062,
-0.22409717738628387,
0.18198493123054504,
-0.07907252013683319,
-0.0036352709867060184,
-0.5394420623779297,
0.33355751633644104,
0.29570823907852173,
0.8395721316337585,
-0.2382851392030716,
0.21165841817855835,
0.27047979831695557,
-0.359968364238739,
0.2219812572002411,
0.3163609802722931,
-0.31423190236091614,
0.20916111767292023,
0.4485218822956085,
0.5211886763572693,
-0.058189939707517624,
-0.5021042823791504,
0.19761157035827637,
-0.003043876029551029,
-0.27096617221832275,
-0.18015402555465698,
0.01073240116238594,
-0.09626239538192749,
0.34059855341911316,
0.3672148287296295,
-0.07298973202705383,
0.07026579231023788,
-0.554885983467102,
0.03780262917280197,
0.6028267741203308,
0.07626624405384064,
-0.013635542243719101,
0.37265515327453613,
-0.059983354061841965,
-0.806301474571228,
0.5569076538085938,
-0.23626525700092316,
-0.7892805933952332,
0.647028923034668,
0.6845372319221497,
0.8501002788543701,
-0.7972863912582397,
0.3774397671222687,
0.17213508486747742,
0.39067572355270386,
-0.1994934380054474,
0.2936243414878845,
0.0010987119749188423,
-0.8593972325325012,
-0.9199042320251465,
-0.5742436051368713,
-0.29900026321411133,
-0.10050754249095917,
-0.090083047747612,
0.32198774814605713,
-0.45964208245277405,
-0.12264281511306763,
-0.07062797248363495,
0.23941485583782196,
-0.6072220206260681,
0.08230078220367432,
-0.22853849828243256,
0.7625110149383545,
-0.514603316783905,
0.8336582779884338,
0.6683086156845093,
-0.1395634412765503,
-0.9259209632873535,
0.09027247130870819,
0.020932717248797417,
-1.0475677251815796,
0.6454331874847412,
0.3199608623981476,
-0.4010724127292633,
-0.07414647191762924,
-0.1390226185321808,
-1.0185071229934692,
1.2307143211364746,
0.42861342430114746,
-0.8547065854072571,
-0.4639396667480469,
0.3732544183731079,
0.5327070355415344,
-0.1059158518910408,
0.46736133098602295,
0.8620609641075134,
0.5075138807296753,
0.3520713746547699,
-1.1738609075546265,
-0.009020645171403885,
0.26105785369873047,
0.18276116251945496,
0.6003046631813049,
-0.40833160281181335,
0.8649758696556091,
-0.16624020040035248,
-0.6431243419647217,
0.028342733159661293,
0.13478869199752808,
0.6872285008430481,
0.3874320983886719,
0.741068422794342,
0.4774894714355469,
0.8128453493118286,
-0.17444001138210297,
0.9662923812866211,
-0.16273233294487,
0.20964697003364563,
0.9196007251739502,
-0.35243913531303406,
0.9223231077194214,
0.2095773071050644,
-0.557698130607605,
0.29895296692848206,
0.703431248664856,
0.38006725907325745,
0.36249491572380066,
0.3634028136730194,
-0.19721375405788422,
-0.14298942685127258,
-0.1315266191959381,
-0.15753351151943207,
0.4681505262851715,
0.2794159948825836,
-0.29270410537719727,
-0.5057831406593323,
-0.38009122014045715,
0.16810056567192078,
0.2340119183063507,
-0.18949376046657562,
0.6798054575920105,
0.0049331760965287685,
-0.7567927837371826,
0.5147740244865417,
0.1587071418762207,
0.5108656883239746,
-0.39131325483322144,
-0.18502263724803925,
-0.24386340379714966,
0.3446883261203766,
-0.47032734751701355,
-1.0522691011428833,
0.37157830595970154,
-0.14784836769104004,
0.1547202318906784,
-0.48162561655044556,
0.6960511207580566,
-0.09029222279787064,
-0.1604255884885788,
0.7902972102165222,
0.5487584471702576,
0.15633949637413025,
-0.38417404890060425,
-0.6969261765480042,
0.20294606685638428,
0.12841607630252838,
-0.2596927285194397,
0.08949202299118042,
0.5028080344200134,
-0.33767545223236084,
0.9067347645759583,
0.5525917410850525,
0.2513298988342285,
0.06543304771184921,
0.20433221757411957,
0.8214065432548523,
-0.81686931848526,
-0.25549113750457764,
-0.9310402870178223,
0.1473880261182785,
0.17494677007198334,
0.07399395108222961,
0.4928308427333832,
0.7973955273628235,
0.9972032904624939,
0.42934468388557434,
0.3207417130470276,
0.10599923133850098,
0.46432191133499146,
-0.8264144062995911,
-0.024441730231046677,
-0.41937264800071716,
0.6721135973930359,
-0.13178011775016785,
-1.527762532234192,
-0.4453335404396057,
0.7256968021392822,
-0.31993749737739563,
0.3053063750267029,
0.8678924441337585,
0.9200120568275452,
0.4426906406879425,
-0.16900376975536346,
0.5080376267433167,
0.2737519145011902,
0.7901580929756165,
0.6548795104026794,
1.0274274349212646,
-0.009214283898472786,
0.6587414741516113,
-0.17392030358314514,
0.003327935701236129,
-0.2099476307630539,
-0.4322681427001953,
-0.5389205813407898,
-0.5295728445053101,
-0.11258842796087265,
-0.24220320582389832,
0.30257683992385864,
0.809771716594696,
0.5467109680175781,
-0.6356770396232605,
-0.6339064836502075,
-0.26814109086990356,
0.44721609354019165,
-0.1413826048374176,
-0.17807374894618988,
0.26036909222602844,
-0.34038522839546204,
-0.7570973038673401,
0.6313241720199585,
0.18132707476615906,
-0.14002394676208496,
-0.3823888599872589,
-0.23157864809036255,
-0.45236116647720337,
-0.3074180483818054,
0.7018209099769592,
0.2615581750869751,
-1.0310945510864258,
-0.3433048129081726,
-0.16889263689517975,
0.055660609155893326,
0.27291280031204224,
0.9305800199508667,
-0.9039670825004578,
0.5758199095726013,
0.28602680563926697,
0.34035050868988037,
0.6861850619316101,
-0.09521797299385071,
0.5686396360397339,
-0.5558405518531799,
-0.16439653933048248,
0.28762587904930115,
0.41002917289733887,
0.2317986935377121,
-0.2087162733078003,
0.8128966093063354,
-0.1006956622004509,
-0.8159909248352051,
-0.7335172295570374,
0.41304659843444824,
-0.5317209959030151,
-0.2610815763473511,
1.225761890411377,
0.34646937251091003,
-0.03174176067113876,
-0.3242914378643036,
-0.6232216954231262,
0.042701005935668945,
-0.5644373893737793,
0.43827754259109497,
0.6361127495765686,
-0.4415697157382965,
-0.29141488671302795,
-0.5541672706604004,
0.6482583284378052,
0.4115678071975708,
-0.5886316895484924,
0.24823662638664246,
0.5635392665863037,
-0.10410900413990021,
0.34360626339912415,
1.0781399011611938,
0.1585865169763565,
0.059602878987789154,
-0.15351401269435883,
-0.03696794435381889,
0.278186559677124,
-0.5556730628013611,
-0.3818388879299164,
0.10019705444574356,
0.8847047090530396,
-0.08059296756982803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10886v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10886v1 | Reviewer2: Optimizing Review Generation Through Prompt Generation | 2024-02-16T18:43:10 | 2024-02-16T18:43:10 | Zhaolin Gao, Kianté Brantley, Thorsten Joachims | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent developments in LLMs offer new opportunities for assisting authors in
improving their work. In this paper, we envision a use case where authors can
receive LLM-generated reviews that uncover weak points in the current draft.
While initial methods for automated review generation already exist, these
methods tend to produce reviews that lack detail, and they do not cover the
range of opinions that human reviewers produce. To address this shortcoming, we
propose an efficient two-stage review generation framework called Reviewer2.
Unlike prior work, this approach explicitly models the distribution of possible
aspects that the review may address. We show that this leads to more detailed
reviews that better cover the range of aspects that human reviewers identify in
the draft. As part of the research, we generate a large-scale review dataset of
27k papers and 99k reviews that we annotate with aspect prompts, which we make
available as a resource for future research. | [
-0.6050713062286377,
-0.3154759109020233,
0.8772042989730835,
0.44478967785835266,
-0.48729175329208374,
-0.30398911237716675,
0.14690402150154114,
-0.4947695732116699,
0.06880255043506622,
0.5805500149726868,
-0.8166977167129517,
-0.3884910047054291,
-0.2109432965517044,
0.5798599123954773,
-0.22590601444244385,
1.1696524620056152,
-0.12546290457248688,
-0.01020282693207264,
-0.10010489076375961,
0.10756649076938629,
-0.42915695905685425,
-0.10870035737752914,
-0.7364224195480347,
-0.4368414580821991,
0.8430331945419312,
0.519406795501709,
0.48934873938560486,
0.20542775094509125,
0.5422517657279968,
0.19499534368515015,
-0.29157915711402893,
0.546533465385437,
-0.39656639099121094,
0.6059542894363403,
-0.06617185473442078,
-0.5326167345046997,
-0.6221291422843933,
0.14181455969810486,
0.4450920522212982,
0.4205596446990967,
0.31713441014289856,
0.19551435112953186,
0.3818748891353607,
0.7766680717468262,
-0.30807551741600037,
-0.09539536386728287,
-0.464016854763031,
0.23152954876422882,
-0.048826731741428375,
-0.4579686224460602,
-0.3086187541484833,
-0.6796280741691589,
-0.08895290642976761,
-0.4423503875732422,
0.49242886900901794,
0.03932871297001839,
0.5776162147521973,
0.13735859096050262,
-0.4421069622039795,
-0.41986972093582153,
-0.5840006470680237,
0.5748891234397888,
-0.4700867831707001,
-0.1409865915775299,
0.3091394007205963,
0.3158837854862213,
-0.19323842227458954,
-0.4352923333644867,
-0.6150963306427002,
-0.11754323542118073,
-0.09071538597345352,
0.30076107382774353,
-0.015802744776010513,
0.12058167904615402,
0.3524264097213745,
0.36012670397758484,
-0.3921661376953125,
0.17569014430046082,
-0.2973998486995697,
-0.3326408863067627,
0.9123768210411072,
0.4005635976791382,
-0.23716171085834503,
-0.5735031366348267,
-0.24580185115337372,
-0.19906656444072723,
-1.1165733337402344,
0.3413604199886322,
0.8198409080505371,
0.08110431581735611,
0.18634475767612457,
0.6652384400367737,
-0.36180004477500916,
0.44979381561279297,
0.19529910385608673,
0.044247645884752274,
-0.00859297439455986,
-0.7105709314346313,
0.12451305985450745,
-0.4930453896522522,
0.6131145358085632,
0.9113060832023621,
-0.32338598370552063,
0.47356659173965454,
-0.8953750133514404,
-0.30623748898506165,
0.26231297850608826,
-1.0160820484161377,
-0.11499550938606262,
0.5124170184135437,
-0.6539821624755859,
-0.7314097285270691,
0.4018475413322449,
-0.9222984313964844,
-0.9215099215507507,
-0.33037275075912476,
0.060603491961956024,
0.004926771391183138,
-0.1297881305217743,
-0.4022802710533142,
-0.2528367042541504,
0.027100924402475357,
0.739512026309967,
-0.5297241806983948,
-0.021151699125766754,
0.7494310736656189,
0.6154817938804626,
-0.11098282784223557,
0.019232086837291718,
-0.6953475475311279,
-0.3657156825065613,
-0.5254260897636414,
1.3019452095031738,
-0.10375895351171494,
-0.5842962265014648,
0.25452113151550293,
-0.3529011607170105,
0.7451808452606201,
-0.7619107365608215,
0.5412771105766296,
-0.2801319360733032,
0.3304159641265869,
-0.4509008526802063,
0.01580618880689144,
0.04645852372050285,
0.45637601613998413,
-0.5973255038261414,
1.1230686902999878,
0.41676896810531616,
-0.743967592716217,
0.455672949552536,
-0.4409828782081604,
-0.3463670015335083,
0.031924959272146225,
-0.186620831489563,
-0.6739218831062317,
0.4770489037036896,
0.46899181604385376,
0.34655746817588806,
-0.5963053703308105,
0.07209315150976181,
-0.14194165170192719,
-0.17232093214988708,
0.2707020044326782,
-0.05388367548584938,
0.4329923391342163,
0.5395005941390991,
-0.3493128716945648,
0.45565497875213623,
-0.5434677600860596,
0.20363357663154602,
-0.16603025794029236,
-0.4985141158103943,
0.23617808520793915,
0.021465962752699852,
0.12657776474952698,
0.2228870838880539,
-0.02009865827858448,
-0.24679075181484222,
0.1828855723142624,
-0.4719257950782776,
0.35109132528305054,
0.8152326941490173,
0.6930263638496399,
0.4103245139122009,
-0.5940929651260376,
0.7367041707038879,
0.25587666034698486,
0.3223273456096649,
-0.6044807434082031,
-0.32457494735717773,
-0.8020259737968445,
0.26016053557395935,
0.19043776392936707,
0.3057192265987396,
-0.8811197876930237,
0.614368200302124,
0.34846052527427673,
-0.49698060750961304,
-0.6586670279502869,
0.5509272217750549,
0.6428333520889282,
0.20833304524421692,
0.028221342712640762,
-0.23513327538967133,
-0.4677257835865021,
-0.926608681678772,
-0.15022693574428558,
-0.7923932671546936,
-0.23032768070697784,
0.33443331718444824,
0.20737528800964355,
-0.18867002427577972,
0.7898200154304504,
-0.3569125831127167,
-0.04395191743969917,
-0.6168878674507141,
0.0712461918592453,
0.18683703243732452,
0.22097231447696686,
0.03762520104646683,
-0.5838637351989746,
-0.18825113773345947,
-0.2653861939907074,
-0.7202394008636475,
-0.5927573442459106,
-0.4507058262825012,
-0.3315717875957489,
0.1086580753326416,
0.40774229168891907,
-0.5574797987937927,
0.1460224688053131,
0.14630599319934845,
-0.43720316886901855,
0.5009964108467102,
0.012291831895709038,
0.08211109042167664,
-1.0155421495437622,
-0.028722168877720833,
0.0518203005194664,
-0.10732444375753403,
-0.29568880796432495,
0.02060345746576786,
-0.004849710501730442,
-0.3720037639141083,
-0.20870007574558258,
0.5576053261756897,
-0.705646812915802,
0.056476373225450516,
-0.4246664345264435,
0.192300945520401,
0.39630410075187683,
0.2037413865327835,
-0.16430196166038513,
0.5488281846046448,
0.04957431182265282,
-0.4795149862766266,
0.12356583029031754,
0.2466486096382141,
-0.43953895568847656,
0.6902813911437988,
-0.7899392247200012,
0.33652952313423157,
-0.33367326855659485,
0.4773556888103485,
-1.0884215831756592,
-0.5374518632888794,
0.26839202642440796,
-0.32629233598709106,
0.26871541142463684,
0.07097272574901581,
-0.5851856470108032,
-0.6011161804199219,
-0.984964907169342,
-0.11064738035202026,
0.499408096075058,
-0.4876024127006531,
0.35586103796958923,
0.24780051410198212,
-0.723888099193573,
-0.12652455270290375,
-0.27175503969192505,
0.11150521785020828,
0.0342504046857357,
-0.7024416327476501,
0.010856184177100658,
0.02423759177327156,
-0.5791780352592468,
-0.2900013029575348,
-0.033937420696020126,
0.3278311789035797,
-0.056217022240161896,
0.31607145071029663,
0.06351828575134277,
0.06585513055324554,
-0.02646801248192787,
0.44395115971565247,
-0.17403076589107513,
0.1998850256204605,
-0.05949017405509949,
0.14839927852153778,
0.2751375436782837,
-0.25193163752555847,
-0.4702145457267761,
0.6953591704368591,
0.27972978353500366,
0.04542974755167961,
-0.3509521186351776,
0.3102208971977234,
-0.04733274504542351,
-0.7170650362968445,
-0.7322690486907959,
-0.5411670804023743,
-0.4265320301055908,
0.44704368710517883,
-0.37404805421829224,
-0.6697598695755005,
0.3578433394432068,
-0.09192491322755814,
0.4463662803173065,
0.4441406726837158,
0.781247079372406,
-0.20100049674510956,
1.0498173236846924,
0.6355107426643372,
0.30301034450531006,
0.5359483361244202,
-0.14191362261772156,
0.08332169055938721,
-1.0042675733566284,
-0.3709121644496918,
-0.5960183143615723,
-0.40811946988105774,
-0.2813451290130615,
-0.5040984153747559,
0.6435396671295166,
0.5558626055717468,
0.09066037088632584,
0.06502088159322739,
-0.6647564768791199,
0.41561612486839294,
0.7419881224632263,
0.3133751451969147,
0.010347914882004261,
0.015422094613313675,
-0.23934349417686462,
0.03576109930872917,
-0.46558865904808044,
-0.9392775297164917,
1.0753475427627563,
0.4968359172344208,
0.5633547902107239,
-0.055988747626543045,
0.9008546471595764,
0.32160869240760803,
0.5182143449783325,
-0.5662079453468323,
0.7303854823112488,
0.3347192108631134,
-0.4429682493209839,
-0.16761068999767303,
-0.31363150477409363,
-0.6778326034545898,
0.2569977045059204,
-0.35018596053123474,
-0.13627882301807404,
0.2692553699016571,
0.4109709560871124,
-0.5535018444061279,
0.010627140291035175,
-0.5995616316795349,
0.2709425389766693,
-0.10363338887691498,
-0.5974204540252686,
-0.003812564769759774,
-0.6644669771194458,
0.5303553938865662,
-0.2057647705078125,
-0.16918599605560303,
-0.09414330869913101,
-0.06734895706176758,
0.5964275598526001,
-0.8520971536636353,
0.7895205616950989,
-0.5560297966003418,
-0.20710183680057526,
0.8295588493347168,
0.2910936772823334,
0.8033288717269897,
0.5884761214256287,
-0.30960920453071594,
-0.334196001291275,
-0.46463873982429504,
-0.0831681564450264,
-0.5722463726997375,
0.5208448767662048,
-0.6623374223709106,
-0.6232744455337524,
-0.21680468320846558,
-0.2749328911304474,
-0.21652930974960327,
0.005948017816990614,
0.676303505897522,
0.40779921412467957,
0.07604800909757614,
-0.3268151581287384,
0.2802232801914215,
-0.2362566590309143,
0.28749725222587585,
0.23088915646076202,
-0.1599722057580948,
-0.8671994805335999,
0.47564050555229187,
-0.08693652600049973,
-0.13089199364185333,
0.06499386578798294,
0.10675530135631561,
-0.4937497675418854,
-0.9389576315879822,
-0.6512611508369446,
0.11001944541931152,
-0.7031541466712952,
-0.5169700980186462,
-0.6012270450592041,
0.13204677402973175,
-0.24621105194091797,
-0.1012485921382904,
0.08368930965662003,
-0.5241056680679321,
-0.306026816368103,
-0.23419898748397827,
0.1353580802679062,
1.3428376913070679,
-0.12390980869531631,
0.30556127429008484,
-0.5873226523399353,
0.26075029373168945,
0.3272012770175934,
0.08364907652139664,
0.01120084710419178,
-0.29567086696624756,
0.00693536177277565,
-0.5211813449859619,
-0.9173630475997925,
-0.8648505210876465,
0.06266925483942032,
-0.14616073668003082,
0.39863771200180054,
0.6359592080116272,
0.1487826257944107,
0.35297277569770813,
-0.3297308385372162,
1.2003549337387085,
0.35238057374954224,
-0.589158296585083,
1.0122859477996826,
-0.36322033405303955,
0.42334622144699097,
0.8876669406890869,
-0.09140285104513168,
-0.19723710417747498,
-0.7157277464866638,
-0.40678882598876953,
-0.9691621661186218,
0.684368908405304,
0.3205792307853699,
0.185282900929451,
0.04904874786734581,
0.5587229132652283,
0.42356961965560913,
0.31228920817375183,
-0.4683380424976349,
0.2208171784877777,
-0.12173471599817276,
0.08498043566942215,
0.02419467270374298,
-0.8818535804748535,
-0.25021660327911377,
0.24696551263332367,
0.6259512305259705,
-0.2605109214782715,
0.33273613452911377,
0.5223591327667236,
0.12404214590787888,
-0.4597417414188385,
0.32522809505462646,
0.6120163798332214,
0.6261870861053467,
0.04691264033317566,
0.37342673540115356,
-0.004659145139157772,
-0.31416818499565125,
0.287222295999527,
0.09034956991672516,
-0.7447540163993835,
0.16527292132377625,
0.7387365698814392,
0.7305152416229248,
-0.08150499314069748,
-0.3704966604709625,
0.358608216047287,
0.08979018032550812,
-0.46680113673210144,
-0.08903607726097107,
0.16327814757823944,
-0.13501481711864471,
0.40742745995521545,
0.36151644587516785,
0.16320620477199554,
0.27125412225723267,
-0.42972445487976074,
0.1838197112083435,
0.2172074019908905,
-0.40681082010269165,
-0.5411311984062195,
0.7011534571647644,
0.8518702983856201,
-0.48898783326148987,
0.5131816864013672,
-0.4714988172054291,
-0.496339350938797,
0.42306214570999146,
0.20957379043102264,
1.1464296579360962,
0.189529687166214,
0.17210610210895538,
0.6336840391159058,
0.22644008696079254,
-0.08058149367570877,
0.6378505825996399,
-0.1605949103832245,
-0.12605442106723785,
-0.154888316988945,
-0.5665454864501953,
-0.7302348613739014,
-0.08774612843990326,
-0.47407206892967224,
0.5082047581672668,
-0.6642019748687744,
-0.4480644762516022,
-0.13533420860767365,
0.24070295691490173,
-0.5097343921661377,
-0.058706607669591904,
0.06468567997217178,
0.7685753107070923,
-0.5860572457313538,
0.34077155590057373,
0.6841163039207458,
-0.486541748046875,
-0.7453325986862183,
0.18356359004974365,
0.2888678014278412,
-0.4033512771129608,
0.4676109552383423,
0.47544631361961365,
0.013893099501729012,
-0.3736339807510376,
-0.4413560926914215,
-0.08845898509025574,
1.1598392724990845,
0.10017003118991852,
-0.82431560754776,
0.2064169943332672,
-0.17602024972438812,
0.5710389018058777,
-0.39437079429626465,
0.6224132776260376,
0.2054595947265625,
0.5962100625038147,
-0.022350864484906197,
-0.3946515619754791,
0.20911045372486115,
-0.6204335689544678,
0.2732044756412506,
0.07833655923604965,
-0.6400250792503357,
0.8050150871276855,
-0.5751484036445618,
-0.1921766996383667,
0.27667200565338135,
0.7453668713569641,
0.6140046715736389,
0.5897539854049683,
0.788990318775177,
0.10039961338043213,
0.779107391834259,
-0.055686235427856445,
1.231046438217163,
-0.24922345578670502,
-0.04084636643528938,
0.9208646416664124,
-0.45198217034339905,
0.7638699412345886,
0.6517122983932495,
-0.13471922278404236,
0.36160731315612793,
0.91336590051651,
-0.1676461547613144,
0.35856467485427856,
0.5215701460838318,
-0.43657755851745605,
-0.18424925208091736,
-0.17452740669250488,
-0.17285381257534027,
-0.29518306255340576,
-0.2185475081205368,
-0.5305610299110413,
-0.22080935537815094,
-0.3208295702934265,
-0.018543880432844162,
0.21486221253871918,
-0.3432990610599518,
1.194201111793518,
0.20841728150844574,
-1.2886043787002563,
0.19311946630477905,
0.11939386278390884,
0.6580859422683716,
-0.4811686873435974,
-0.21573852002620697,
-0.69145667552948,
-0.04217589646577835,
-0.3353307843208313,
-1.1024749279022217,
0.09431879967451096,
0.43412724137306213,
-0.3978525996208191,
-0.6354162096977234,
0.6385263204574585,
-0.2475215345621109,
-0.6200926303863525,
0.125162273645401,
0.743651807308197,
0.2933223247528076,
-0.1017862856388092,
-0.5149886012077332,
0.11581961810588837,
0.07320217043161392,
-0.6902406215667725,
-0.00035804719664156437,
0.6128238439559937,
-0.42390498518943787,
0.2474820762872696,
0.6638855338096619,
0.25375768542289734,
-0.2013774812221527,
0.2238500416278839,
0.9410474896430969,
-0.7825130820274353,
-0.5437750220298767,
-0.7439501881599426,
0.6145440340042114,
-0.2978527545928955,
-0.7795690298080444,
0.5209452509880066,
0.6073315739631653,
0.446344792842865,
-0.05543415993452072,
1.04140305519104,
0.03390313684940338,
0.5839340686798096,
-0.6216917037963867,
0.5224476456642151,
-0.28115880489349365,
0.5092740058898926,
-0.04631974548101425,
-1.2840628623962402,
-0.3768834173679352,
0.3166954815387726,
0.03041801229119301,
0.11812970042228699,
0.731360137462616,
1.171451449394226,
0.48537367582321167,
-0.1308346688747406,
0.0013283591251820326,
-0.009664753451943398,
0.5201895833015442,
0.6195868253707886,
1.189164400100708,
-0.2668241560459137,
0.5285016298294067,
-0.2217266708612442,
-0.030136393383145332,
-0.3952190577983856,
-0.8948476314544678,
-1.1500438451766968,
-0.3241038918495178,
-0.20522460341453552,
-0.7777000069618225,
-0.147452712059021,
0.9320071339607239,
0.7087417840957642,
-0.743309497833252,
-0.0005882942350581288,
-0.2927967309951782,
0.22299708425998688,
0.07074729353189468,
-0.174207866191864,
0.25761890411376953,
-0.5456697344779968,
-0.6088338494300842,
0.25440463423728943,
0.289285808801651,
0.11065085232257843,
-0.7099635601043701,
-0.36090192198753357,
0.6810498833656311,
0.02751797065138817,
0.5737747550010681,
-0.2075740247964859,
-0.7286095023155212,
-0.11334627866744995,
-0.10633765161037445,
-0.2623353600502014,
-0.13834165036678314,
1.2132309675216675,
-0.4343177080154419,
0.4344179034233093,
0.9005483984947205,
0.14089210331439972,
0.2681407332420349,
0.25189071893692017,
0.6768143177032471,
-0.5710828900337219,
-0.05185925215482712,
0.5254442691802979,
0.23762252926826477,
0.40531280636787415,
-0.5311228036880493,
0.6579749584197998,
-0.006413673050701618,
-0.4378228187561035,
-0.9266473054885864,
0.2571321129798889,
-1.0089879035949707,
0.09195412695407867,
1.4285354614257812,
-0.017359958961606026,
0.14720453321933746,
0.011987166479229927,
-0.58716881275177,
-0.1882154941558838,
-0.5624327063560486,
0.774273157119751,
0.5775843262672424,
-0.3881959915161133,
-0.13123437762260437,
-0.4459671676158905,
0.6547801494598389,
0.35740968585014343,
-1.1085096597671509,
-0.039045970886945724,
0.5738211870193481,
0.05684986710548401,
-0.07310511916875839,
0.877898097038269,
-0.267255038022995,
0.5023292303085327,
0.08459673076868057,
0.04645279422402382,
-0.34504419565200806,
-0.445665568113327,
-0.6679372191429138,
0.45360058546066284,
0.5463356375694275,
0.3858341872692108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10884v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10884v1 | Multi-modal preference alignment remedies regression of visual instruction tuning on language model | 2024-02-16T18:42:08 | 2024-02-16T18:42:08 | Shengzhi Li, Rongyu Lin, Shichao Pei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | In production, multi-modal large language models (MLLMs) are expected to
support multi-turn queries of interchanging image and text modalities. However,
the current MLLMs trained with visual-question-answering (VQA) datasets could
suffer from degradation, as VQA datasets lack the diversity and complexity of
the original text instruction datasets which the underlying language model had
been trained with. To address this challenging degradation, we first collect a
lightweight (6k entries) VQA preference dataset where answers were annotated by
Gemini for 5 quality metrics in a granular fashion, and investigate standard
Supervised Fine-tuning, rejection sampling, Direct Preference Optimization
(DPO), and SteerLM. Our findings indicate that the with DPO we are able to
surpass instruction-following capabilities of the language model, achieving a
6.73 score on MT-Bench, compared to Vicuna's 6.57 and LLaVA's 5.99 despite
small data scale. This enhancement in textual instruction proficiency
correlates with boosted visual instruction performance (+4.9\% on MM-Vet, +6\%
on LLaVA-Bench), with minimal alignment tax on visual knowledge benchmarks
compared to previous RLHF approach. In conclusion, we propose a
distillation-based multi-modal alignment model with fine-grained annotations on
a small dataset that reconciles the textual and visual performance of MLLMs,
restoring and boosting language capability after visual instruction tuning. | [
-0.298957496881485,
-0.972999095916748,
0.4265322685241699,
-0.08641471713781357,
-0.30803775787353516,
-0.10779824107885361,
-0.3647995591163635,
-0.23588211834430695,
0.04224318638443947,
0.5981396436691284,
-0.5720983743667603,
-0.43358883261680603,
-0.5898370742797852,
-0.05087500438094139,
-0.1148427277803421,
0.9198895692825317,
0.027839407324790955,
0.3680475056171417,
-0.4698410630226135,
-0.25964921712875366,
-0.7853104472160339,
-0.29837384819984436,
-0.23321466147899628,
-0.06276247650384903,
0.5723764300346375,
0.6147751212120056,
0.7739014029502869,
0.94246906042099,
0.6104161143302917,
0.34914740920066833,
0.03934618830680847,
0.42110493779182434,
-0.4669954180717468,
0.2163572609424591,
0.17205213010311127,
-0.41227373480796814,
-0.5238851308822632,
0.009490391239523888,
0.5859520435333252,
0.46495601534843445,
-0.11102525144815445,
0.29237937927246094,
0.18968579173088074,
0.9379721879959106,
-0.7343515753746033,
0.0635497197508812,
-0.6605715155601501,
-0.2033662348985672,
-0.10344427078962326,
-0.3353688716888428,
-0.5110548734664917,
-0.35029178857803345,
0.24080456793308258,
-0.7119483351707458,
0.02011188492178917,
0.08301699161529541,
0.8349956274032593,
0.7685530781745911,
-0.5225570201873779,
0.03182036429643631,
-0.45635971426963806,
1.020772933959961,
-0.56733638048172,
0.42612868547439575,
0.5051425099372864,
0.3618968427181244,
0.04312988743185997,
-0.47894561290740967,
-0.4210943579673767,
-0.22266817092895508,
-0.10608261078596115,
0.17296698689460754,
0.11045387387275696,
0.17998549342155457,
0.19926978647708893,
0.3729478418827057,
-0.5366091132164001,
0.1288827508687973,
-0.30035340785980225,
-0.21832002699375153,
0.34886133670806885,
0.3762734830379486,
0.16178204119205475,
-0.21972782909870148,
-0.5242046117782593,
-0.2731589376926422,
-0.45253807306289673,
0.2950875461101532,
0.1870775669813156,
0.3551383912563324,
0.07378946989774704,
0.7049224376678467,
-0.3045729100704193,
1.1388216018676758,
0.058188941329717636,
-0.3787001073360443,
0.34865090250968933,
-0.5976488590240479,
-0.39213666319847107,
-0.10909641534090042,
0.6760553121566772,
0.7350103855133057,
0.25464800000190735,
0.2957029938697815,
-0.12384318560361862,
-0.19637198746204376,
0.25555118918418884,
-0.8004087805747986,
-0.1353919804096222,
0.014205960556864738,
-0.47409987449645996,
-0.16635994613170624,
-0.11817706376314163,
-0.6872216463088989,
-0.40848061442375183,
-0.8222612738609314,
0.531493604183197,
-0.4389197826385498,
0.04919441044330597,
0.17147867381572723,
-0.11362158507108688,
0.22364482283592224,
0.5599201917648315,
-1.0387349128723145,
-0.0775023102760315,
0.5194971561431885,
0.5848568081855774,
-0.1255211979150772,
-0.4159508943557739,
-0.6679227948188782,
-0.0984921008348465,
-0.187249556183815,
0.4944402575492859,
-0.7181927561759949,
-0.22068019211292267,
-0.02698751538991928,
0.028018226847052574,
-0.26182493567466736,
-0.5152985453605652,
0.3640107810497284,
-0.3990805447101593,
0.4502524733543396,
-0.5917235612869263,
-0.4308992326259613,
-0.13411112129688263,
0.3776344656944275,
-0.6333163380622864,
0.9927724003791809,
-0.005493561737239361,
-0.7849144339561462,
0.5650429725646973,
-0.24185338616371155,
-0.15366682410240173,
-0.2793673872947693,
-0.2566063106060028,
-0.4366225600242615,
0.11066022515296936,
0.42978012561798096,
0.3505256175994873,
-0.2831290364265442,
0.25668662786483765,
-0.3372700810432434,
-0.4198760986328125,
0.17337504029273987,
-0.8323405981063843,
0.5159140825271606,
-0.000148722407175228,
-0.25895553827285767,
0.4450274705886841,
-0.7971783876419067,
0.1367444545030594,
-0.12703648209571838,
-0.396275132894516,
-0.5654205679893494,
-0.06719803810119629,
0.018267620354890823,
0.2524564862251282,
0.4132639467716217,
-0.31668978929519653,
0.4963822364807129,
-0.05938411504030228,
0.15430600941181183,
0.8015508055686951,
-0.19923914968967438,
0.43545955419540405,
-0.03398434817790985,
0.4613114893436432,
0.07300674170255661,
0.625370979309082,
-0.07462480664253235,
-0.4778362512588501,
-0.9839070439338684,
-0.49162688851356506,
0.27202993631362915,
0.5296688079833984,
-1.0000872611999512,
0.1028643250465393,
-0.26606300473213196,
-0.19808991253376007,
-0.815855860710144,
0.2528146505355835,
0.5624938011169434,
0.8772156834602356,
0.6227373480796814,
-0.12387685477733612,
-0.3444657623767853,
-1.1756830215454102,
0.07462087273597717,
-0.08006925880908966,
0.19332687556743622,
0.3164464831352234,
0.11342864483594894,
-0.11709974706172943,
0.7376213073730469,
-0.5746276378631592,
-0.2571444809436798,
0.11712129414081573,
0.11330359429121017,
0.012102039530873299,
0.22861593961715698,
0.6157954335212708,
-0.8628212213516235,
-0.5350626707077026,
-0.018720773980021477,
-0.4365856945514679,
-0.11175453662872314,
0.12805543839931488,
-0.2510380148887634,
0.3417688012123108,
0.36282938718795776,
-0.0935305505990982,
0.34237295389175415,
0.6418671607971191,
-0.31778162717819214,
0.5837868452072144,
-0.15393662452697754,
0.5534678101539612,
-1.1269067525863647,
-0.20078207552433014,
0.07660572230815887,
-0.2237410694360733,
-0.3502237796783447,
-0.23913118243217468,
0.21734508872032166,
0.27967140078544617,
-0.4311069846153259,
0.38431766629219055,
-0.38752493262290955,
0.15029685199260712,
-0.3770536780357361,
0.0628245398402214,
0.18284830451011658,
0.5229310393333435,
0.2113763988018036,
0.9656012654304504,
0.5917725563049316,
-0.3072802424430847,
0.2345908284187317,
0.19907686114311218,
-0.09409225732088089,
0.6177892684936523,
-0.581283450126648,
-0.18911112844944,
-0.1586725413799286,
-0.20381417870521545,
-1.0443869829177856,
-0.06861651688814163,
0.25893434882164,
-0.20120595395565033,
0.526731014251709,
-0.21571901440620422,
-0.08856718242168427,
-0.10095441341400146,
-0.5338066220283508,
0.2765304148197174,
0.2391699105501175,
-0.44719475507736206,
0.4897785186767578,
0.08171335607767105,
-0.07271453738212585,
-1.1860171556472778,
-0.4379432201385498,
-0.09102462977170944,
-0.18357743322849274,
-0.46923303604125977,
0.149606853723526,
-0.16708137094974518,
-0.11356466263532639,
-0.06939994543790817,
-0.15242049098014832,
-0.07948728650808334,
-0.03883592411875725,
0.12107152491807938,
0.6997278332710266,
-0.42018967866897583,
0.19315417110919952,
0.09396921098232269,
-0.09059254080057144,
-0.24725443124771118,
-0.06854847818613052,
0.3276604115962982,
-0.2897304594516754,
-0.36363157629966736,
-0.38120725750923157,
0.23496390879154205,
0.8306247591972351,
-0.41556599736213684,
0.7727760672569275,
0.739956796169281,
0.007247315254062414,
0.15116265416145325,
-0.5954935550689697,
-0.2019132375717163,
-0.4353936016559601,
0.39190489053726196,
-0.23401804268360138,
-0.842110276222229,
0.19011704623699188,
0.21714909374713898,
0.0919705256819725,
0.32192447781562805,
0.5401966571807861,
-0.12994664907455444,
0.9470593333244324,
0.697848379611969,
-0.0785185769200325,
0.9069580435752869,
-0.02902863547205925,
-0.1322452425956726,
-0.7768194675445557,
-0.17573735117912292,
-0.3196452558040619,
-0.47736164927482605,
-0.655876636505127,
-0.431993305683136,
0.37502995133399963,
0.15805670619010925,
-0.18663553893566132,
0.07239247858524323,
-0.6409671306610107,
0.43321534991264343,
0.8666661977767944,
0.2193070650100708,
0.3770601749420166,
0.06824471801519394,
-0.035862263292074203,
-0.2793969511985779,
-0.5997530221939087,
-0.5235998630523682,
1.1529182195663452,
0.13168729841709137,
0.9472463130950928,
-0.003573935478925705,
0.6458231210708618,
-0.02991827018558979,
0.27365243434906006,
-0.9186880588531494,
0.3560487627983093,
-0.3292044699192047,
-0.4608592689037323,
-0.4668719172477722,
-0.43201667070388794,
-0.6384187936782837,
0.3089987337589264,
-0.44074949622154236,
-0.687635064125061,
0.2796853482723236,
0.4178958833217621,
-0.24847981333732605,
-0.09964123368263245,
-0.9969806671142578,
1.1285948753356934,
-0.5749720931053162,
-0.766636073589325,
-0.018503017723560333,
-0.7447609305381775,
0.42385467886924744,
0.2029981166124344,
-0.048664748668670654,
0.09081283956766129,
-0.09949775785207748,
0.4259719252586365,
-0.3390101492404938,
0.8413970470428467,
-0.11158441752195358,
-0.0610988549888134,
0.0636724978685379,
-0.2318650186061859,
0.22560708224773407,
-0.01886189915239811,
0.12610921263694763,
-0.10170217603445053,
0.1459231674671173,
-0.3619164526462555,
-0.691615104675293,
0.7747981548309326,
-0.8027543425559998,
-0.7052559852600098,
-0.29229071736335754,
-0.540571928024292,
-0.26686957478523254,
0.0763004943728447,
0.21459516882896423,
0.508594274520874,
0.025056056678295135,
0.4341486692428589,
0.8153077363967896,
-0.057437580078840256,
0.4533731937408447,
0.48720964789390564,
-0.27601003646850586,
-0.6491678953170776,
1.0190397500991821,
0.054815471172332764,
0.4715934693813324,
0.4526328444480896,
0.2598419189453125,
-0.42687609791755676,
-0.4312015175819397,
-0.8076897859573364,
-0.0158386267721653,
-0.6711435914039612,
-0.3258437216281891,
-0.3714968264102936,
0.06575500965118408,
-0.1512407511472702,
0.030590293928980827,
-0.44910886883735657,
-0.3699510097503662,
-0.36204078793525696,
0.10903472453355789,
0.42976757884025574,
0.4897599220275879,
0.29607143998146057,
0.1274503767490387,
-0.7794013619422913,
0.40829020738601685,
0.470306396484375,
0.3914095163345337,
-0.20779336988925934,
-0.5969114303588867,
-0.3084578812122345,
0.21625778079032898,
-0.3380366265773773,
-0.7419496178627014,
0.12374283373355865,
0.24457505345344543,
0.5174559354782104,
0.33901891112327576,
-0.08775327354669571,
0.9314504861831665,
-0.38500598073005676,
0.7278982400894165,
0.22060443460941315,
-0.7172514200210571,
0.5911837816238403,
-0.2737080156803131,
0.2739548981189728,
0.7918206453323364,
0.3041718602180481,
-0.33295148611068726,
-0.13673119246959686,
-0.11698626726865768,
-0.8641778826713562,
0.5616557598114014,
-0.08142372220754623,
-0.04570094868540764,
0.1670360118150711,
0.31500735878944397,
0.20378157496452332,
0.3759843707084656,
-0.6731559038162231,
-0.43959274888038635,
-0.49469223618507385,
-0.3856959640979767,
-0.1277349293231964,
-0.284094899892807,
-0.23249699175357819,
-0.3998424708843231,
0.6476190686225891,
-0.4036741852760315,
-0.2177956998348236,
0.04219731315970421,
-0.1216617301106453,
-0.0002380856458330527,
0.3493289053440094,
0.8188420534133911,
0.6950495839118958,
-0.25396332144737244,
0.0070027937181293964,
-0.1748741865158081,
-0.5717452168464661,
0.12914280593395233,
0.15840192139148712,
-0.23308448493480682,
-0.26998305320739746,
0.2595037817955017,
0.8604034781455994,
0.07210210710763931,
-0.5572877526283264,
0.5337144732475281,
-0.35683169960975647,
-0.025378068909049034,
0.19516123831272125,
0.18350164592266083,
-0.00972635205835104,
0.2487691193819046,
0.2333536595106125,
0.11674109846353531,
0.19997909665107727,
-0.40069517493247986,
0.04897744953632355,
0.5740784406661987,
-0.5896618962287903,
0.016212599352002144,
0.580796480178833,
0.20087116956710815,
0.023792723193764687,
0.5451774001121521,
0.24485467374324799,
-0.22876019775867462,
0.3537810742855072,
0.2969505786895752,
0.5588656067848206,
-0.03411071375012398,
0.24795767664909363,
0.28848373889923096,
0.3753684163093567,
-0.14539532363414764,
0.37252914905548096,
0.001271296525374055,
-0.5516529679298401,
-0.5055676102638245,
-0.6473935842514038,
-0.3074580430984497,
0.05567709729075432,
-0.8898324370384216,
0.35518547892570496,
-0.22781918942928314,
-0.2529546916484833,
-0.08928774297237396,
-0.11661915481090546,
-0.6263240575790405,
0.25604453682899475,
0.19769936800003052,
0.6098781824111938,
-0.9088082313537598,
0.9659066200256348,
0.8449682593345642,
-0.71876460313797,
-0.6374297738075256,
0.01662267930805683,
0.15588009357452393,
-0.7802824378013611,
0.5534046292304993,
0.054476696997880936,
-0.2239125519990921,
-0.14125527441501617,
-0.43975022435188293,
-0.7505853772163391,
1.171021580696106,
0.5214324593544006,
-0.7916674017906189,
0.26944783329963684,
0.056437768042087555,
0.5905604362487793,
-0.21175222098827362,
0.19745758175849915,
0.5264856815338135,
0.46954724192619324,
-0.013411477208137512,
-1.00870943069458,
-0.2185932993888855,
-0.21386095881462097,
-0.09793055802583694,
0.25470951199531555,
-0.7229187488555908,
0.5826850533485413,
-0.11752792447805405,
0.23082123696804047,
0.0016075619496405125,
0.49722209572792053,
0.103250652551651,
0.34527021646499634,
0.3718697428703308,
0.5786179304122925,
0.6458610892295837,
-0.22157691419124603,
0.9060767292976379,
-0.24673426151275635,
0.20192697644233704,
1.2382694482803345,
0.05937616527080536,
0.9578360915184021,
0.9400689601898193,
0.0643819123506546,
0.2907775640487671,
0.6009589433670044,
0.2909904420375824,
0.6143031120300293,
-0.16195780038833618,
0.05696077644824982,
-0.4622817039489746,
-0.253817617893219,
-0.4332036077976227,
0.6414669752120972,
0.16097061336040497,
-0.4822099804878235,
0.10195846110582352,
0.01844755932688713,
-0.31598785519599915,
0.2539243698120117,
-0.22162070870399475,
0.8347129225730896,
-0.19421114027500153,
-0.70213383436203,
0.8633842468261719,
-0.31669750809669495,
0.6666399836540222,
-0.5531522035598755,
-0.1474170833826065,
-0.2781533896923065,
0.09122489392757416,
-0.04041557013988495,
-0.7635003924369812,
-0.017494142055511475,
-0.18663389980793,
-0.5222676992416382,
-0.2039797157049179,
0.5385756492614746,
-0.7013261914253235,
-0.5029488205909729,
0.06968703866004944,
0.7224058508872986,
-0.31110337376594543,
0.13974235951900482,
-0.7338263988494873,
0.17510749399662018,
0.0801621526479721,
-0.359253466129303,
0.43342018127441406,
0.41067826747894287,
-0.06761287897825241,
0.5537628531455994,
0.3399752676486969,
-0.19384554028511047,
0.1593133956193924,
0.35302361845970154,
0.958526611328125,
-0.5071722865104675,
0.0020997337996959686,
-0.8543597459793091,
0.730006992816925,
-0.1241675466299057,
-0.5430732369422913,
0.695530891418457,
0.5186383128166199,
0.7305864095687866,
-0.16665053367614746,
0.5336638689041138,
0.1446899026632309,
0.10971321910619736,
-0.8930701017379761,
0.37575486302375793,
-0.9259450435638428,
0.1878776252269745,
-0.32826173305511475,
-0.968124270439148,
-0.18660761415958405,
0.36959975957870483,
-0.43590018153190613,
-0.04538450762629509,
0.6368247270584106,
0.8554530143737793,
-0.08688023686408997,
-0.19671271741390228,
0.41557446122169495,
-0.11665831506252289,
0.03269527852535248,
0.30753517150878906,
0.8786286115646362,
-0.3385881185531616,
0.5217846035957336,
-0.3332677185535431,
-0.3418242335319519,
-0.415086954832077,
-0.7532805800437927,
-0.83453369140625,
-0.6504794955253601,
-0.2521044611930847,
-0.12995173037052155,
-0.055018629878759384,
0.957938551902771,
0.6200369000434875,
-0.5837842226028442,
-0.029901273548603058,
0.3174308240413666,
0.11274329572916031,
-0.42323434352874756,
-0.2296811193227768,
0.3874969482421875,
-0.39845776557922363,
-0.8476437926292419,
0.2597149908542633,
0.3735186457633972,
0.20883074402809143,
-0.21239209175109863,
-0.06567777693271637,
-0.1875895857810974,
-0.13505195081233978,
0.6890493631362915,
0.009744074195623398,
-0.9257177114486694,
-0.413006067276001,
0.4683637320995331,
-0.2880750894546509,
0.18431039154529572,
0.6862257719039917,
-0.5444324016571045,
0.7797232270240784,
0.5577383041381836,
0.6179564595222473,
0.1678890883922577,
0.20947207510471344,
0.531826376914978,
-0.783368706703186,
0.153318852186203,
0.029469992965459824,
0.49416446685791016,
0.3892726004123688,
-0.35018032789230347,
0.202854186296463,
0.037101127207279205,
-0.5469158291816711,
-0.5022897124290466,
0.18691007792949677,
-1.1323603391647339,
-0.23974141478538513,
1.0286073684692383,
0.10407686233520508,
-0.2711797058582306,
0.03896106779575348,
-0.7023575901985168,
0.17527152597904205,
-0.42463743686676025,
0.8142715692520142,
0.7000926733016968,
-0.11046556383371353,
-0.29931050539016724,
-0.591955304145813,
0.5322324633598328,
0.5298367142677307,
-0.5883780717849731,
0.2918568551540375,
0.9894898533821106,
0.17789363861083984,
0.07114572823047638,
0.40394484996795654,
-0.0442252978682518,
0.4133898615837097,
-0.18929423391819,
0.05939890444278717,
-0.3376578688621521,
-0.5093086361885071,
-0.30746567249298096,
-0.02401973307132721,
0.2781071066856384,
-0.5188089609146118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10882v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10882v3 | Universal Prompt Optimizer for Safe Text-to-Image Generation | 2024-02-16T18:36:36 | 2024-06-25T05:56:40 | Zongyu Wu, Hongcheng Gao, Yueze Wang, Xiang Zhang, Suhang Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Text-to-Image (T2I) models have shown great performance in generating images
based on textual prompts. However, these models are vulnerable to unsafe input
to generate unsafe content like sexual, harassment and illegal-activity images.
Existing studies based on image checker, model fine-tuning and embedding
blocking are impractical in real-world applications. Hence, we propose the
first universal prompt optimizer for safe T2I (POSI) generation in black-box
scenario. We first construct a dataset consisting of toxic-clean prompt pairs
by GPT-3.5 Turbo. To guide the optimizer to have the ability of converting
toxic prompt to clean prompt while preserving semantic information, we design a
novel reward function measuring toxicity and text alignment of generated images
and train the optimizer through Proximal Policy Optimization. Experiments show
that our approach can effectively reduce the likelihood of various T2I models
in generating inappropriate images, with no significant impact on text
alignment. It is also flexible to be combined with methods to achieve better
performance. Our code is available at https://github.com/wzongyu/POSI. | [
0.010026037693023682,
-0.5432004332542419,
0.6648051738739014,
0.20329952239990234,
-0.6867461204528809,
-0.4267725348472595,
0.1289055347442627,
-0.19704174995422363,
-0.4103987514972687,
0.3470202386379242,
-0.680846631526947,
-0.5925396084785461,
-0.40387946367263794,
0.15954823791980743,
0.30397242307662964,
0.9752728939056396,
0.2436649352312088,
-0.17320853471755981,
0.08695288747549057,
0.21973063051700592,
-0.9261462092399597,
-0.0318891778588295,
-1.245235562324524,
0.16788093745708466,
0.5013578534126282,
0.4627245366573334,
0.6701832413673401,
0.5586225986480713,
0.34078481793403625,
0.21337810158729553,
0.00647309236228466,
0.3038148880004883,
-0.5163037180900574,
0.40289735794067383,
-0.5070939064025879,
-0.06834112852811813,
-0.2751603424549103,
-0.26227259635925293,
0.29393500089645386,
-0.228698268532753,
0.19626706838607788,
-0.16137610375881195,
0.06138615310192108,
0.13761888444423676,
-0.8968296051025391,
-0.2406444251537323,
-0.46306872367858887,
0.15098869800567627,
0.055465493351221085,
-0.5154902935028076,
-0.6515421867370605,
-0.6432883739471436,
-0.16571302711963654,
-0.8008949160575867,
-0.22069676220417023,
0.0735023096203804,
1.0238783359527588,
0.4814431071281433,
-0.5416278839111328,
-0.0522669181227684,
-0.5630605816841125,
0.7904452085494995,
-0.6430251002311707,
-0.20735731720924377,
0.09924666583538055,
0.3234870135784149,
-0.31490856409072876,
-0.4988499581813812,
-0.2987856864929199,
-0.033849675208330154,
-0.01519810687750578,
0.21211716532707214,
-0.3122609853744507,
0.14583232998847961,
0.04200686886906624,
-0.15259262919425964,
-0.5646752119064331,
0.2191881537437439,
0.005368540994822979,
-0.4214727580547333,
0.6730273962020874,
0.3516959547996521,
0.6061071157455444,
-0.20890749990940094,
-0.4637092053890228,
-0.18435804545879364,
-0.7356656789779663,
0.23824059963226318,
0.4245613217353821,
-0.0383702889084816,
0.06826106458902359,
0.3570724427700043,
0.2402307689189911,
0.28322833776474,
0.03382677584886551,
-0.1310620754957199,
0.017590995877981186,
-0.5276872515678406,
0.24858886003494263,
-0.026087801903486252,
1.1927375793457031,
0.8890539407730103,
0.35782355070114136,
-0.1749696135520935,
-0.2928512394428253,
0.28068700432777405,
0.4044685661792755,
-1.400506615638733,
0.014254539273679256,
0.22949384152889252,
-0.25162196159362793,
-1.035882830619812,
0.018028996884822845,
-0.9807058572769165,
-0.4866490364074707,
0.2078441083431244,
0.4702877998352051,
-0.4806372821331024,
-0.27850568294525146,
-0.129823237657547,
-0.19563671946525574,
0.0760035291314125,
0.10855187475681305,
-0.5440106391906738,
-0.2083175778388977,
0.5373308062553406,
0.6394329071044922,
-0.026257790625095367,
0.05771433562040329,
-0.888985812664032,
0.33166956901550293,
-0.47746542096138,
0.7322232127189636,
-0.3825512230396271,
-0.5744191408157349,
0.21029962599277496,
0.060510676354169846,
0.25871697068214417,
-0.19741767644882202,
0.8537600040435791,
-0.29468172788619995,
0.22864492237567902,
-0.16788487136363983,
-0.1795724332332611,
0.2998158931732178,
0.05741233378648758,
-0.4085426926612854,
0.6483742594718933,
-0.09587807953357697,
-0.9770616888999939,
0.3456414043903351,
-0.7401066422462463,
-0.38398751616477966,
0.20118705928325653,
-0.13833339512348175,
-0.7928319573402405,
-0.050038039684295654,
0.10519470274448395,
0.2332269698381424,
-0.22663992643356323,
0.5846520066261292,
-0.2478688359260559,
-0.48277074098587036,
0.13946254551410675,
-0.37983444333076477,
0.8285523653030396,
0.40379947423934937,
-0.46674951910972595,
0.44496142864227295,
-0.5051243901252747,
0.024818483740091324,
0.5274402499198914,
-0.0027536724228411913,
-0.4147573411464691,
0.08945706486701965,
0.28624966740608215,
0.2843455970287323,
0.04433169215917587,
-0.9550833106040955,
-0.08149280399084091,
-0.07912714034318924,
0.48823168873786926,
0.8266319632530212,
0.41529470682144165,
0.3501635789871216,
-0.2212124615907669,
0.3345794379711151,
0.14107684791088104,
0.3517596125602722,
-0.45497873425483704,
-0.6264538168907166,
-0.1467369794845581,
-0.1564425826072693,
0.17082293331623077,
1.0160486698150635,
-0.7631636261940002,
0.692126989364624,
0.06101488322019577,
-0.31765422224998474,
-0.30732762813568115,
-0.3196195662021637,
0.7738162875175476,
0.7315378785133362,
0.10857632011175156,
-0.11656724661588669,
-0.06376025080680847,
-0.8642802238464355,
-0.1734088659286499,
0.02056463249027729,
-0.4236006736755371,
0.19915328919887543,
0.366330087184906,
-0.1969388872385025,
0.7266038656234741,
-0.4686901867389679,
-0.2675158381462097,
0.1798265129327774,
0.07850886136293411,
-0.148000568151474,
0.8512890338897705,
0.6991287469863892,
-0.6356422901153564,
-0.17615839838981628,
-0.18972377479076385,
-0.6881332993507385,
-0.23666627705097198,
-0.17757107317447662,
-0.5264316201210022,
0.2798554301261902,
0.3767071068286896,
-0.4155898690223694,
0.5593938231468201,
0.05318686366081238,
-0.8463357090950012,
0.5079845786094666,
-0.42541995644569397,
0.25755825638771057,
-1.2993628978729248,
0.3674141764640808,
0.23316487669944763,
-0.1649218201637268,
-0.6239885687828064,
0.10299094021320343,
0.37148162722587585,
-0.5865627527236938,
-0.5896753668785095,
0.6858135461807251,
-0.1256929188966751,
0.5312872529029846,
-0.01943477801978588,
-0.1404157131910324,
0.006459953263401985,
0.3872164785861969,
0.03455529734492302,
1.0026006698608398,
0.6356209516525269,
-0.49795299768447876,
-0.10022301226854324,
0.3904281556606293,
-0.07650578022003174,
0.8993351459503174,
-0.8568967580795288,
0.3608682155609131,
-0.33334171772003174,
-0.02977648191154003,
-1.1431678533554077,
-0.41457486152648926,
0.6269447207450867,
-0.3558522164821625,
0.5101017951965332,
0.059128716588020325,
-0.33086860179901123,
-0.31368380784988403,
-0.5542171597480774,
0.39519330859184265,
0.8044760227203369,
-0.4964568316936493,
0.09791526943445206,
0.16559962928295135,
-0.14458639919757843,
-0.6461316347122192,
-0.5738220810890198,
0.1292085349559784,
-0.26395612955093384,
-0.7637942433357239,
0.3693983852863312,
-0.13505035638809204,
0.08630052208900452,
0.07336506992578506,
-0.07878412306308746,
-0.06143626943230629,
0.10392697900533676,
0.1999136507511139,
0.44043922424316406,
-0.03508570045232773,
-0.09103313833475113,
0.501599907875061,
-0.5485524535179138,
0.07466626167297363,
-0.23528161644935608,
0.10317736864089966,
0.07956644147634506,
-0.056288182735443115,
-0.8788052201271057,
0.6754653453826904,
0.3090704083442688,
-0.3007715344429016,
0.5503804683685303,
0.569478452205658,
-0.43246957659721375,
-0.10801801085472107,
-0.1889985054731369,
-0.02689271792769432,
-0.544640064239502,
0.40279608964920044,
-0.2676026523113251,
-0.6673406362533569,
0.16069288551807404,
-0.005205444525927305,
0.294266015291214,
0.23232072591781616,
0.22792282700538635,
0.050372764468193054,
1.320338249206543,
0.4077516794204712,
0.20604990422725677,
0.4315366744995117,
0.03651493042707443,
0.26099228858947754,
-0.3932269215583801,
-0.3492911159992218,
-0.5238635540008545,
-0.17202520370483398,
-0.4063093960285187,
-0.0731535404920578,
0.5314664840698242,
-0.01756884716451168,
-0.8153839111328125,
0.04981176555156708,
-0.9512833952903748,
0.7528131008148193,
0.49914073944091797,
0.3618602454662323,
0.024910518899559975,
0.15891112387180328,
-0.10141701251268387,
-0.19556376338005066,
-0.3821631371974945,
-0.7402905225753784,
0.7706899046897888,
0.21007613837718964,
0.7043331265449524,
-0.14525069296360016,
0.6887964606285095,
0.29061001539230347,
0.10050924122333527,
-0.3628561198711395,
0.6582472920417786,
-0.3335663676261902,
-0.3283669054508209,
-0.30098897218704224,
-0.3600706458091736,
-1.0015991926193237,
0.059756871312856674,
-0.3164350688457489,
-0.7075368762016296,
0.13543467223644257,
0.2605660855770111,
-0.3671351969242096,
0.44884228706359863,
-0.8258179426193237,
1.1163214445114136,
-0.27750563621520996,
-0.6752468347549438,
0.17563067376613617,
-0.656849205493927,
0.30930230021476746,
0.03315066918730736,
0.05439048632979393,
0.044882286339998245,
-0.37872961163520813,
0.38597238063812256,
-0.39764392375946045,
0.5695595145225525,
-0.5710923075675964,
-0.171116441488266,
0.3171977698802948,
0.3262255787849426,
0.5692548751831055,
0.16856485605239868,
-0.14382678270339966,
0.042454466223716736,
-0.13509337604045868,
-0.51270991563797,
-0.1644536554813385,
0.6177309155464172,
-0.6034110188484192,
-0.47502562403678894,
-0.12209925800561905,
-0.42647671699523926,
-0.02406548149883747,
0.3179264962673187,
0.9200445413589478,
0.48341163992881775,
-0.10894059389829636,
-0.24871540069580078,
0.732578456401825,
-0.6104770302772522,
0.6204348802566528,
0.16049708425998688,
0.30190327763557434,
-0.6190395355224609,
1.1778788566589355,
-0.3809480667114258,
0.0794944018125534,
0.2325110137462616,
0.2660538852214813,
-0.3565560579299927,
-0.5281475782394409,
-0.7168883681297302,
0.18772447109222412,
-0.41087549924850464,
-0.5706427693367004,
-0.3676014542579651,
-0.09173095226287842,
-0.26930949091911316,
-0.4079881012439728,
-0.011759057641029358,
-0.11240217834711075,
-0.621681809425354,
0.10949002951383591,
0.16234534978866577,
0.5166753530502319,
0.07499665021896362,
0.2837207019329071,
-0.7686827182769775,
0.18662889301776886,
0.2608017921447754,
0.5788565874099731,
-0.20463784039020538,
-0.11911917477846146,
0.4156845808029175,
-0.08299683779478073,
-0.6865611672401428,
-1.0757157802581787,
0.3197144865989685,
0.12069770693778992,
0.18446794152259827,
0.6245948672294617,
0.46627986431121826,
0.2863451838493347,
-0.5963059067726135,
0.7613307237625122,
0.5603031516075134,
-0.6780527830123901,
0.8231492042541504,
-0.6521801352500916,
0.10578227043151855,
0.5011603832244873,
0.19685904681682587,
-0.34011155366897583,
-0.6365179419517517,
-0.37518733739852905,
-0.7435038089752197,
0.7778895497322083,
0.4236008822917938,
0.07995046675205231,
-0.04023392125964165,
0.4147125482559204,
0.19102256000041962,
0.010025149211287498,
-0.4021741449832916,
-0.11716511845588684,
-0.42176496982574463,
-0.5246385931968689,
0.20443786680698395,
-0.5251227617263794,
0.015201318077743053,
0.28336143493652344,
0.6313723921775818,
-0.059480346739292145,
0.33785903453826904,
0.2746342122554779,
0.07739785313606262,
-0.519348680973053,
0.5792855024337769,
0.4216551184654236,
0.10309431701898575,
-0.15361909568309784,
-0.1468578428030014,
-0.17275434732437134,
-0.44826680421829224,
0.5351499319076538,
0.0203431136906147,
-0.7780920267105103,
-0.16802608966827393,
-0.16898535192012787,
0.9842589497566223,
0.003035474568605423,
-0.6148693561553955,
0.7976735830307007,
-0.24486970901489258,
-0.4041363298892975,
-0.0351082906126976,
0.4125570058822632,
-0.24707335233688354,
0.14724773168563843,
0.2406173199415207,
0.27871036529541016,
0.22368820011615753,
-0.0618802085518837,
0.12064750492572784,
0.4210508167743683,
-0.36004889011383057,
-0.21698080003261566,
1.2447878122329712,
0.5902777910232544,
-0.5953062176704407,
0.4605017900466919,
-0.6936858892440796,
-0.2449309229850769,
0.6311187148094177,
0.8729525208473206,
1.033270239830017,
-0.42185091972351074,
0.4175196886062622,
0.7576058506965637,
0.30840185284614563,
0.06849770992994308,
0.39347782731056213,
0.17124293744564056,
-0.3718070685863495,
-0.14994706213474274,
-0.1961805522441864,
-0.32477375864982605,
0.2310773879289627,
-0.30065757036209106,
0.47211888432502747,
-0.4953185021877289,
-0.19880907237529755,
-0.11538083851337433,
-0.17457450926303864,
-0.401946097612381,
0.21977201104164124,
0.19657348096370697,
0.6597937345504761,
-0.7982727289199829,
0.35538408160209656,
0.8255334496498108,
-0.3181014358997345,
-0.7020996809005737,
-0.11147645115852356,
0.08245058357715607,
-0.4332706928253174,
-0.017737919464707375,
0.48955583572387695,
0.17669335007667542,
0.0665736272931099,
-0.6414545774459839,
-0.31192484498023987,
1.040392518043518,
0.5267935395240784,
-0.5884523391723633,
-0.1597876250743866,
0.0688212588429451,
0.29193705320358276,
-0.2657982110977173,
0.3421727120876312,
0.41330474615097046,
0.45508313179016113,
0.22703154385089874,
-0.43098193407058716,
0.5726235508918762,
-0.6284449696540833,
0.3786871135234833,
0.4002112150192261,
-0.43596190214157104,
0.34885677695274353,
-0.5156132578849792,
-0.5209640264511108,
0.4863587021827698,
0.28551051020622253,
0.4865868091583252,
0.5525416731834412,
0.6306777000427246,
0.4797585606575012,
0.6536924839019775,
-0.2590811550617218,
1.0467438697814941,
-0.013053609058260918,
-0.04782538861036301,
0.5462983846664429,
-0.12040950357913971,
0.38827502727508545,
0.22212617099285126,
0.3953743577003479,
0.27965736389160156,
0.6689093112945557,
-0.2945200800895691,
0.7522797584533691,
0.06916345655918121,
-0.27331826090812683,
-0.23821274936199188,
-0.4187054932117462,
-0.26809367537498474,
-0.24178913235664368,
0.1715731918811798,
-0.1310010552406311,
-0.3343794643878937,
0.0834571048617363,
0.23576587438583374,
0.10675168037414551,
-0.30394917726516724,
0.7368726134300232,
-0.32990846037864685,
-0.8410696983337402,
0.4777136743068695,
-0.053264737129211426,
0.9300503134727478,
-0.4659951627254486,
0.04452770575881004,
-0.10865365713834763,
0.12331348657608032,
-0.11511167883872986,
-0.9591095447540283,
0.17354533076286316,
0.20803722739219666,
0.11903566122055054,
-0.06487628817558289,
1.1214861869812012,
-0.44169068336486816,
-0.21602578461170197,
0.009307478554546833,
-0.09664485603570938,
0.016757672652602196,
0.05095431208610535,
-0.5618748068809509,
-0.19034737348556519,
0.11653554439544678,
-0.18626418709754944,
0.2789992094039917,
0.5933951735496521,
-0.2531275749206543,
0.27778366208076477,
0.5349629521369934,
-0.1119479238986969,
-0.266635537147522,
-0.07540100812911987,
0.5966222882270813,
-0.6744120717048645,
-0.8281599283218384,
-0.6214227676391602,
0.8711280822753906,
-0.2233564853668213,
-0.5196022391319275,
0.051273737102746964,
0.28001388907432556,
0.373767614364624,
-0.18020790815353394,
0.7674176692962646,
-0.015991508960723877,
0.015094384551048279,
-0.30244219303131104,
0.9232050180435181,
-0.6727418303489685,
-0.27609917521476746,
-0.4544166326522827,
-0.698581874370575,
-0.2987073063850403,
0.2739073634147644,
-0.045354459434747696,
-0.28864362835884094,
0.6257582902908325,
1.046281099319458,
0.18556039035320282,
0.21804556250572205,
0.14922647178173065,
-0.23823541402816772,
0.40199464559555054,
0.8866094946861267,
0.7372329831123352,
-0.4016090929508209,
0.9331372380256653,
-0.31916430592536926,
-0.42775559425354004,
0.13845455646514893,
-1.2097783088684082,
-0.8659753799438477,
-0.37581875920295715,
-0.42259979248046875,
-0.47511613368988037,
0.20803257822990417,
0.6016921401023865,
0.536736249923706,
-0.8176316618919373,
0.2458924651145935,
-0.24044401943683624,
-0.07398465275764465,
0.12975193560123444,
-0.19674433767795563,
0.3657139241695404,
-0.5361472964286804,
-0.5952554941177368,
0.012967381626367569,
0.2542569041252136,
0.23815752565860748,
0.2688831388950348,
-0.32151028513908386,
0.37499576807022095,
0.1403420865535736,
0.29750293493270874,
0.19297800958156586,
-0.396821528673172,
-0.24207770824432373,
-0.06712877005338669,
-0.2804487347602844,
0.03409885615110397,
0.706754207611084,
-0.29540058970451355,
0.3131067752838135,
0.3198103904724121,
0.7095106244087219,
0.045845672488212585,
0.02587858773767948,
0.4317902624607086,
-0.6891970038414001,
0.29649004340171814,
0.24154604971408844,
0.22221632301807404,
0.3097859025001526,
-0.7333955764770508,
0.46660107374191284,
0.07648663222789764,
-0.6475399136543274,
-0.8518377542495728,
0.20531274378299713,
-0.8452314734458923,
-0.2886120080947876,
1.1766681671142578,
-0.0370580218732357,
-0.4745982587337494,
0.05415162444114685,
-0.7483735680580139,
0.44952332973480225,
-0.8660685420036316,
0.6061886548995972,
0.15592586994171143,
0.28677377104759216,
-0.15272080898284912,
-0.11076553910970688,
0.5493663549423218,
0.3691163659095764,
-0.9957359433174133,
-0.2794021964073181,
0.6463693976402283,
0.2919889986515045,
0.03908024728298187,
0.48393702507019043,
-0.3118748962879181,
0.6753062605857849,
-0.00507798045873642,
-0.0011213164543733,
-0.4559294283390045,
-0.2148946076631546,
-0.30207347869873047,
0.19714882969856262,
-0.24862168729305267,
-0.5875130891799927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11005v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11005v2 | Exploring Value Biases: How LLMs Deviate Towards the Ideal | 2024-02-16T18:28:43 | 2024-02-21T22:02:18 | Sarath Sivaprasad, Pramod Kaushik, Sahar Abdelnabi, Mario Fritz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large-Language-Models (LLMs) are deployed in a wide range of applications,
and their response has an increasing social impact. Understanding the
non-deliberate(ive) mechanism of LLMs in giving responses is essential in
explaining their performance and discerning their biases in real-world
applications. This is analogous to human studies, where such inadvertent
responses are referred to as sampling. We study this sampling of LLMs in light
of value bias and show that the sampling of LLMs tends to favour high-value
options. Value bias corresponds to this shift of response from the most likely
towards an ideal value represented in the LLM. In fact, this effect can be
reproduced even with new entities learnt via in-context prompting. We show that
this bias manifests in unexpected places and has implications on relevant
application scenarios, like choosing exemplars. The results show that value
bias is strong in LLMs across different categories, similar to the results
found in human studies. | [
-0.4227168560028076,
-0.6445767879486084,
0.565851092338562,
-0.2290608286857605,
-0.1380840688943863,
-0.04170442000031471,
-0.1316942572593689,
-0.7065868973731995,
0.4812931418418884,
0.6983432769775391,
-0.3824658691883087,
-0.23740890622138977,
-0.5375709533691406,
-0.08822698891162872,
-0.4020543694496155,
0.9891481995582581,
0.014672582969069481,
0.21997076272964478,
-0.23502489924430847,
-0.3013233542442322,
-0.29115939140319824,
-0.8109301924705505,
-0.5933129191398621,
-0.5078974366188049,
0.5413342714309692,
0.26440349221229553,
0.6231673955917358,
0.4923655092716217,
0.18260672688484192,
0.06744786351919174,
-0.07890685647726059,
-0.12074247002601624,
-0.9375903010368347,
0.199782595038414,
-0.22067944705486298,
-0.9094390869140625,
-0.2905827760696411,
0.558533251285553,
0.5373370051383972,
0.7905598878860474,
0.273959219455719,
0.4937831461429596,
0.1008036732673645,
0.7068620324134827,
-0.9176369309425354,
0.11768479645252228,
-0.7380423545837402,
-0.029330050572752953,
-0.2800230085849762,
-0.22899940609931946,
-0.5041976571083069,
-0.5015235543251038,
0.14433567225933075,
-0.3737671673297882,
0.12131930142641068,
0.11409540474414825,
0.8538806438446045,
0.010420183651149273,
-0.45528513193130493,
-0.3367617130279541,
-0.6236492395401001,
1.0512372255325317,
-0.5529406070709229,
0.1556396335363388,
0.3473750650882721,
0.1959458589553833,
-0.22025005519390106,
-0.18128813803195953,
-0.45508530735969543,
-0.2470570206642151,
0.212262824177742,
-0.02872617356479168,
0.1804017275571823,
0.07148437201976776,
0.33914485573768616,
0.45383697748184204,
0.050467804074287415,
0.35792040824890137,
-0.32044604420661926,
0.10879293084144592,
0.7737547755241394,
-0.013830532319843769,
-0.05937628075480461,
-0.2161882519721985,
-0.26847174763679504,
-0.29429519176483154,
-1.2233184576034546,
0.37761521339416504,
0.7370353937149048,
0.2955194413661957,
0.12479611486196518,
0.8893874883651733,
-0.09497518837451935,
0.7614254355430603,
0.07635941356420517,
-0.08468335121870041,
0.15175074338912964,
-0.13331840932369232,
-0.37491360306739807,
0.12304965406656265,
0.4761960208415985,
0.49099573493003845,
0.7791716456413269,
0.29552769660949707,
-0.4569595158100128,
-0.043518856167793274,
0.28189924359321594,
-0.6270626187324524,
0.2455282062292099,
0.15361708402633667,
-0.6547641754150391,
-0.5832748413085938,
-0.059920039027929306,
-0.7123804688453674,
-0.25558048486709595,
-0.4386575222015381,
0.23876990377902985,
-0.08139920979738235,
-0.22820407152175903,
0.17451657354831696,
-0.15343448519706726,
0.3328383266925812,
0.27920767664909363,
-1.043033480644226,
0.22412163019180298,
0.4476011097431183,
0.43795013427734375,
-0.3921995460987091,
0.005949815269559622,
-0.5089341998100281,
-0.009124155156314373,
-0.574776291847229,
0.9205428957939148,
-0.6938347220420837,
-0.8295922875404358,
0.17958644032478333,
-0.2561120092868805,
0.36460965871810913,
-0.8285834193229675,
0.629136323928833,
-0.7750651240348816,
0.02384304255247116,
-0.6240944862365723,
-0.5588365793228149,
-0.07867434620857239,
0.2665632963180542,
-0.7263035774230957,
1.2059053182601929,
0.14602543413639069,
-0.5697075724601746,
0.8864395022392273,
-0.6501889228820801,
-0.1794232726097107,
-0.23430757224559784,
-0.5862443447113037,
-0.19350935518741608,
0.46984732151031494,
-0.07306323200464249,
0.3464726209640503,
-0.3782632648944855,
-0.045497920364141464,
-0.7015241980552673,
-0.46227556467056274,
0.7496854066848755,
-0.7349943518638611,
0.6861197352409363,
0.2153240144252777,
-0.24876604974269867,
0.07030252367258072,
-0.6461560726165771,
0.10636251419782639,
0.245713010430336,
-0.2666439414024353,
-0.903605580329895,
0.021041253581643105,
0.08268605917692184,
0.39778292179107666,
-0.006592556368559599,
-0.3396526873111725,
0.25184813141822815,
-0.3343922793865204,
0.2475321739912033,
1.1121069192886353,
0.011454666033387184,
0.5579691529273987,
-0.4315715432167053,
0.46364158391952515,
-0.09307389706373215,
0.06853192299604416,
0.16817007958889008,
-0.13595986366271973,
-0.5181134343147278,
-0.1258794665336609,
0.2295842468738556,
0.023384111002087593,
-0.24733887612819672,
0.0060827466659247875,
-0.1705801635980606,
0.0513584166765213,
-0.7025112509727478,
0.022564290091395378,
0.058150533586740494,
0.23091718554496765,
0.04471474513411522,
-0.19075238704681396,
-0.3388839066028595,
-1.163354754447937,
-0.4569278359413147,
-0.30029216408729553,
-0.09666404128074646,
0.49808862805366516,
0.35270121693611145,
-0.029936186969280243,
1.247435212135315,
-0.507766604423523,
0.11247167736291885,
-0.3181006908416748,
0.002764275297522545,
0.16899573802947998,
-0.042097385972738266,
0.5394320487976074,
-0.9207744598388672,
-0.08744427561759949,
-0.5421271324157715,
-0.49335426092147827,
-0.3958427309989929,
-0.10537038743495941,
-0.3175129294395447,
0.29954230785369873,
0.3773048222064972,
-0.37897589802742004,
0.28439033031463623,
0.4103257358074188,
-0.10731398314237595,
0.6634441018104553,
0.0711950734257698,
0.08315697312355042,
-1.079767107963562,
-0.014918657019734383,
0.25570228695869446,
-0.017717452719807625,
-0.2589254379272461,
-0.04881343990564346,
0.009038863703608513,
0.4657205045223236,
-0.5999530553817749,
0.8315646648406982,
-0.5265063047409058,
-0.44888871908187866,
-0.4669629633426666,
0.20214393734931946,
0.016630111262202263,
-0.10976309329271317,
0.2207891345024109,
0.7718006372451782,
0.03571264073252678,
-0.770806610584259,
0.0780845358967781,
-0.017080608755350113,
-0.29840126633644104,
0.862702488899231,
-0.4108715057373047,
-0.03572962060570717,
-0.2710140645503998,
0.2836798429489136,
-0.9149605631828308,
-0.2263592630624771,
-0.03653274476528168,
-0.3289438784122467,
0.1386040598154068,
-0.18783271312713623,
-0.3979323208332062,
-0.3255445659160614,
-0.5252465009689331,
0.46114134788513184,
0.4931212067604065,
-0.5081216096878052,
0.078488789498806,
0.6943165063858032,
-0.04942182078957558,
-0.7145782709121704,
-0.48981326818466187,
-0.0073959254659712315,
-0.3420364260673523,
-0.2601546049118042,
0.09280136227607727,
-0.1545782834291458,
-0.8560153841972351,
-0.1235252246260643,
-0.1179351806640625,
0.17300641536712646,
-0.03437846153974533,
0.35355144739151,
0.5249035954475403,
0.01814962364733219,
0.16264455020427704,
-0.020062366500496864,
0.014555915258824825,
0.31647202372550964,
-0.3968163728713989,
0.5883389115333557,
0.20214702188968658,
-0.7617420554161072,
0.016330957412719727,
0.2158006876707077,
0.7541075944900513,
0.014383343979716301,
0.5439190864562988,
0.03524331375956535,
-0.2947734296321869,
-0.32054880261421204,
-0.6876992583274841,
-0.44607600569725037,
-0.4438144564628601,
0.3323986232280731,
-0.4506927728652954,
-0.8057491183280945,
0.2320696860551834,
0.15061156451702118,
0.27212026715278625,
0.18662340939044952,
0.765691339969635,
-0.22332178056240082,
0.9125247001647949,
0.5030691623687744,
-0.23185394704341888,
0.6126605868339539,
-0.28184571862220764,
0.27290958166122437,
-0.9932723045349121,
0.04796373471617699,
-0.40076717734336853,
-0.39871692657470703,
-0.5954245328903198,
-0.37654510140419006,
0.42489999532699585,
-0.056707486510276794,
0.04803672060370445,
-0.3705786168575287,
-0.2857140004634857,
0.6223548650741577,
0.6620143055915833,
-0.10085762292146683,
0.23633219301700592,
0.007402775343507528,
-0.032596368342638016,
-0.1068829596042633,
-0.481548935174942,
-0.8561936616897583,
1.4051401615142822,
0.2735549211502075,
1.1095794439315796,
-0.24108079075813293,
0.6128755211830139,
0.1318719983100891,
0.5338282585144043,
-1.0497915744781494,
0.5019675493240356,
0.4223925769329071,
-0.7767045497894287,
-0.42608028650283813,
-0.12617366015911102,
-0.9863491058349609,
0.348537415266037,
-0.17381702363491058,
-0.5708028674125671,
0.20345771312713623,
0.23788520693778992,
-0.39606884121894836,
0.380935400724411,
-0.4541366994380951,
0.3267329931259155,
-0.35373103618621826,
-0.6475660800933838,
-0.19932958483695984,
-0.4975833594799042,
0.3957165479660034,
-0.06566209346055984,
0.35628873109817505,
-0.33340057730674744,
0.21038711071014404,
0.46502119302749634,
0.1582375466823578,
0.8653857707977295,
-0.02231425791978836,
-0.3321044445037842,
0.28200748562812805,
0.17052766680717468,
0.48279356956481934,
0.24576081335544586,
-0.4091120958328247,
-0.0959925651550293,
-0.13161711394786835,
-0.6277487277984619,
-0.3592155873775482,
0.5145424604415894,
-0.7817177176475525,
-0.6530807614326477,
-0.4970974028110504,
-0.649385392665863,
-0.2904055416584015,
0.015392034314572811,
0.29191482067108154,
0.17050762474536896,
-0.4515777826309204,
0.03271394222974777,
1.0673362016677856,
-0.2947128415107727,
0.28600725531578064,
0.4132509231567383,
-0.3027549684047699,
0.12252229452133179,
0.24024447798728943,
0.44746267795562744,
0.888205349445343,
0.3575178384780884,
0.13922008872032166,
-0.6271599531173706,
-0.49309805035591125,
-0.5362043976783752,
0.11778420209884644,
-0.6691235899925232,
0.2117699235677719,
-0.5361533164978027,
-0.05306772515177727,
-0.41733720898628235,
-0.433769166469574,
-0.39158645272254944,
-0.2637172043323517,
-0.26900821924209595,
-0.5506592392921448,
0.2241169661283493,
0.7453543543815613,
0.023846784606575966,
-0.21126782894134521,
-0.41821804642677307,
0.279251366853714,
0.41287797689437866,
0.2224465310573578,
-0.012459304183721542,
-0.47784215211868286,
-0.10375872999429703,
0.30902373790740967,
-0.13198387622833252,
-0.8365334272384644,
0.3579077124595642,
-0.30797040462493896,
0.8766322731971741,
0.5492100119590759,
0.16120712459087372,
0.3303380608558655,
-0.30396753549575806,
0.8663767576217651,
-0.21073110401630402,
-0.7018547058105469,
0.3852618634700775,
-0.35823461413383484,
0.1463603526353836,
0.6720792055130005,
0.2843809723854065,
-0.8094642758369446,
-0.29540154337882996,
-0.561623215675354,
-0.9517410397529602,
0.5360054969787598,
-0.1509401649236679,
0.3904050290584564,
-0.11132926493883133,
0.5744551420211792,
0.23181745409965515,
0.43174615502357483,
-1.1356585025787354,
-0.2907472848892212,
-0.008482052013278008,
0.021583931520581245,
-0.0967966616153717,
-0.5236092805862427,
-0.3128955066204071,
0.20812250673770905,
0.5782487392425537,
-0.21837876737117767,
0.30455586314201355,
0.0444914847612381,
-0.18554772436618805,
-0.23853833973407745,
0.5970715880393982,
0.6633927822113037,
0.6661226749420166,
-0.2486364096403122,
0.314291387796402,
0.23714180290699005,
-0.1702398955821991,
0.34251806139945984,
-0.30814799666404724,
-0.2621748149394989,
-0.1580805629491806,
-0.02955504320561886,
0.6458339095115662,
0.1499129980802536,
-0.7425052523612976,
0.4781726598739624,
0.20560091733932495,
0.011478728614747524,
-0.32631561160087585,
0.11435332149267197,
0.0036214562132954597,
-0.07126051187515259,
0.40127456188201904,
-0.22883588075637817,
0.2680053412914276,
-0.8301364779472351,
-0.14717444777488708,
0.7643866539001465,
-0.42736580967903137,
-0.25186118483543396,
0.5338809490203857,
0.07709772139787674,
-0.19936805963516235,
0.3557899296283722,
-0.28100818395614624,
-0.18930396437644958,
0.620922327041626,
0.594933807849884,
0.7276871204376221,
0.06287944316864014,
0.13644646108150482,
-0.021513398736715317,
0.24410896003246307,
-0.13678857684135437,
0.2741909325122833,
0.16885864734649658,
-0.9626457095146179,
-0.38985735177993774,
-0.6298484802246094,
-0.5206195712089539,
0.30925995111465454,
-0.8334106802940369,
0.24857664108276367,
-0.03484548628330231,
-0.13111339509487152,
-0.2681211829185486,
-0.3592052161693573,
-0.5474443435668945,
0.1863124668598175,
0.27421697974205017,
0.9420109391212463,
-0.9188761115074158,
0.8275856375694275,
0.6931240558624268,
-0.2939431965351105,
-0.7511422634124756,
0.19390395283699036,
0.2161780595779419,
-1.167153239250183,
0.9366927742958069,
0.08382700383663177,
-0.23290422558784485,
-0.26062965393066406,
-0.5807430148124695,
-0.9421563744544983,
0.7380742430686951,
0.36684393882751465,
-0.26083245873451233,
-0.1687532216310501,
0.4911816120147705,
0.38532140851020813,
-0.39244237542152405,
0.47381630539894104,
0.6795666813850403,
0.4416768252849579,
0.017842138186097145,
-0.7818154096603394,
-0.13718412816524506,
-0.09388694912195206,
0.2854510545730591,
0.33505991101264954,
-0.7731376886367798,
0.7290422916412354,
-0.20842145383358002,
0.14505206048488617,
-0.39623984694480896,
0.36429569125175476,
0.5873969197273254,
0.18762338161468506,
0.387740820646286,
0.3052709102630615,
0.6818290948867798,
0.05938030779361725,
1.1393115520477295,
-0.34741783142089844,
0.11979452520608902,
0.8580478429794312,
-0.6657717823982239,
0.8174617886543274,
0.920290470123291,
-0.19069679081439972,
0.1753404289484024,
0.9957771897315979,
0.30969053506851196,
0.3865589201450348,
0.6647129654884338,
-0.5009829998016357,
0.05145274102687836,
-0.20056773722171783,
-0.2560155987739563,
0.2803557515144348,
0.5227311253547668,
-0.567672610282898,
0.01670919358730316,
-0.07515321671962738,
0.12311255186796188,
-0.0869174599647522,
-0.464726060628891,
0.6302947402000427,
0.3089715540409088,
-0.7933089733123779,
0.44653335213661194,
-0.1561843603849411,
0.808709442615509,
-0.4898817837238312,
0.07672234624624252,
-0.04634203761816025,
0.07102809846401215,
-0.09808994829654694,
-0.8738166093826294,
0.10914963483810425,
-0.2625112235546112,
-0.3565486967563629,
-0.5352963805198669,
0.5748372077941895,
-0.20325212180614471,
-0.2762523591518402,
0.28047114610671997,
0.7316363453865051,
0.037392426282167435,
0.02724282257258892,
-0.37468892335891724,
-0.06400355696678162,
0.07030559331178665,
-0.4944811463356018,
0.6001831889152527,
0.4063199460506439,
-0.31033918261528015,
0.5769866704940796,
0.6779773831367493,
0.3565462529659271,
0.11291272193193436,
0.014627029187977314,
0.5054442882537842,
-0.5721388459205627,
-0.42258432507514954,
-1.0739926099777222,
0.23332186043262482,
-0.22194497287273407,
-0.30711302161216736,
0.7349684238433838,
0.6779161095619202,
1.174060344696045,
0.02513374201953411,
1.0982109308242798,
0.40958917140960693,
0.4206177890300751,
-0.6407340168952942,
0.5322032570838928,
-0.3035719692707062,
0.43206965923309326,
-0.29057279229164124,
-0.9040646553039551,
0.04085664451122284,
0.6873583197593689,
-0.750779390335083,
0.09024837613105774,
0.4351382851600647,
0.6021638512611389,
0.05127912387251854,
-0.013658899813890457,
0.3044140338897705,
-0.028315044939517975,
0.5323665142059326,
0.2934136688709259,
0.9611949324607849,
0.1525968313217163,
0.17375509440898895,
0.234819695353508,
-0.36310985684394836,
-0.5030779838562012,
-0.9455079436302185,
-0.7105258107185364,
-0.21399082243442535,
0.11371336132287979,
-0.4400973618030548,
0.14439848065376282,
1.5209747552871704,
0.8062667846679688,
-0.569044828414917,
-0.6407032608985901,
0.1398373544216156,
0.07533716410398483,
0.049069005995988846,
-0.24218791723251343,
0.021882755681872368,
-0.3428156077861786,
-0.968097984790802,
0.007243825122714043,
0.38065850734710693,
0.3434264361858368,
-0.4761969745159149,
0.13851340115070343,
0.10052599757909775,
0.5348560810089111,
0.7549514770507812,
0.18467086553573608,
-0.5505380034446716,
-0.327084481716156,
0.1267411857843399,
-0.3280477821826935,
0.33218997716903687,
0.8863952159881592,
-0.7903182506561279,
0.28580668568611145,
0.2969232499599457,
0.592953085899353,
0.5136059522628784,
-0.28618550300598145,
0.763424277305603,
-0.5142946839332581,
0.08930898457765579,
0.4060971438884735,
0.37294748425483704,
0.08468275517225266,
-0.39691296219825745,
0.32218489050865173,
0.22562849521636963,
-0.551020622253418,
-0.9157781004905701,
0.6342769265174866,
-0.6659345030784607,
-0.3194984495639801,
1.583638310432434,
0.37858137488365173,
-0.043020520359277725,
-0.00847425777465105,
-0.38303983211517334,
0.009456949308514595,
-0.4468858242034912,
1.1572859287261963,
1.0260542631149292,
-0.48413392901420593,
0.03113633580505848,
-0.9896883368492126,
0.4530109465122223,
0.43875694274902344,
-0.949899435043335,
0.01912018097937107,
0.6434943079948425,
0.3938477337360382,
-0.08070401847362518,
0.8246681690216064,
-0.26166531443595886,
0.005957452114671469,
-0.38023650646209717,
0.22228799760341644,
0.33794498443603516,
0.12918627262115479,
-0.3343653380870819,
0.23758268356323242,
0.641785740852356,
0.0058102961629629135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10866v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10866v2 | EcoRank: Budget-Constrained Text Re-ranking Using Large Language Models | 2024-02-16T18:03:42 | 2024-05-28T02:34:57 | Muhammad Shihab Rashid, Jannat Ara Meem, Yue Dong, Vagelis Hristidis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved state-of-the-art performance in
text re-ranking. This process includes queries and candidate passages in the
prompts, utilizing pointwise, listwise, and pairwise prompting strategies. A
limitation of these ranking strategies with LLMs is their cost: the process can
become expensive due to API charges, which are based on the number of input and
output tokens. We study how to maximize the re-ranking performance given a
budget, by navigating the vast search spaces of prompt choices, LLM APIs, and
budget splits. We propose a suite of budget-constrained methods to perform text
re-ranking using a set of LLM APIs. Our most efficient method, called EcoRank,
is a two-layered pipeline that jointly optimizes decisions regarding budget
allocation across prompt strategies and LLM APIs. Our experimental results on
four popular QA and passage reranking datasets show that EcoRank outperforms
other budget-aware supervised and unsupervised baselines. | [
-0.24757009744644165,
-0.6214017271995544,
0.8068352341651917,
0.31905895471572876,
-0.24509207904338837,
0.32781359553337097,
-0.17729441821575165,
-0.21460150182247162,
0.28626638650894165,
0.646173894405365,
-0.6582867503166199,
-0.49425044655799866,
-0.3706567585468292,
0.4079119563102722,
-0.18953154981136322,
0.7162932753562927,
0.10202455520629883,
-0.0768233984708786,
-0.45312219858169556,
-0.11682921648025513,
-0.26492437720298767,
-0.6472634077072144,
-0.8303778767585754,
-0.2870346009731293,
1.0840299129486084,
0.5386824607849121,
0.42709705233573914,
0.8256589770317078,
0.4784631133079529,
0.28513672947883606,
-0.34216558933258057,
0.2200804054737091,
-0.6540522575378418,
0.4889205992221832,
-0.24671022593975067,
-0.49145448207855225,
-0.2466014325618744,
0.019048506394028664,
0.47501447796821594,
0.5922825932502747,
-0.04523341730237007,
0.2667885720729828,
0.14670535922050476,
0.7009373903274536,
-0.6393117904663086,
0.18636618554592133,
-0.6973127722740173,
-0.3427570164203644,
-0.33615192770957947,
-0.38360434770584106,
-0.6832764744758606,
-0.5500071048736572,
0.23590418696403503,
-0.7192362546920776,
-0.1255432814359665,
0.46448424458503723,
0.629749059677124,
0.4561019241809845,
-0.4098457992076874,
-0.3206702470779419,
-0.20807230472564697,
0.9808369278907776,
-0.2581354081630707,
0.5283932089805603,
0.30659183859825134,
-0.05630965158343315,
0.0431678332388401,
-0.8217717409133911,
-0.03884414955973625,
-0.007239673752337694,
0.23701556026935577,
0.1543276309967041,
-0.3088756799697876,
0.09122002124786377,
-0.11753096431493759,
0.16953349113464355,
-0.4938284158706665,
0.3801004886627197,
-0.07152058184146881,
-0.18872390687465668,
0.5234232544898987,
0.041074324399232864,
0.3408219516277313,
-0.07472466677427292,
-0.33119162917137146,
-0.412937194108963,
-0.7629317045211792,
0.009899451397359371,
0.5548293590545654,
0.45713838934898376,
0.5171980261802673,
0.6469753384590149,
-0.28963354229927063,
0.5381684899330139,
-0.09056738018989563,
-0.17645427584648132,
0.07751546055078506,
-0.34476691484451294,
-0.03748030215501785,
0.04420410096645355,
0.28669700026512146,
0.584254801273346,
0.19897645711898804,
-0.19942502677440643,
-0.4879806935787201,
-0.3023739457130432,
0.10343268513679504,
-0.6882796287536621,
-0.20542187988758087,
0.2468978613615036,
-0.43834495544433594,
-0.28391027450561523,
-0.41780826449394226,
-0.9273108243942261,
-0.245272696018219,
-0.30830442905426025,
0.6582132577896118,
-0.027935804799199104,
0.11110994219779968,
-0.20086033642292023,
-0.23937557637691498,
0.10110978037118912,
0.27466779947280884,
-0.7838443517684937,
0.11352518200874329,
0.8579952120780945,
1.0133721828460693,
0.06156475841999054,
-0.2704809606075287,
-0.6025915145874023,
-0.06836340576410294,
-0.42122793197631836,
1.1341708898544312,
-0.6647971868515015,
-0.4485645592212677,
0.3843560814857483,
-0.17808303236961365,
0.14450405538082123,
-0.737941324710846,
0.7872828245162964,
-0.7590254545211792,
-0.042405370622873306,
-0.49644583463668823,
-0.7650191187858582,
0.15500777959823608,
-0.04565693065524101,
-0.7132366299629211,
0.9515151381492615,
0.05709763988852501,
-0.47803881764411926,
0.3812887668609619,
-0.31418576836586,
-0.378280371427536,
0.16883480548858643,
0.46868374943733215,
-0.29084935784339905,
-0.021396147087216377,
0.4039193391799927,
0.1443779170513153,
-0.3145950734615326,
0.1959621012210846,
-0.19629064202308655,
-0.29058071970939636,
-0.15702636539936066,
-0.3083820939064026,
0.5834885835647583,
0.3375009000301361,
0.06718695163726807,
0.1825811117887497,
-0.3980565667152405,
0.0350487120449543,
-0.08027171343564987,
-0.732323408126831,
-0.6607627272605896,
0.19822543859481812,
0.2653931975364685,
-0.2703830301761627,
0.4637620747089386,
-0.5259879231452942,
0.4222503900527954,
-0.5578019022941589,
0.6837077736854553,
0.8887901902198792,
-0.0033114091493189335,
0.6402428150177002,
-0.23895017802715302,
0.4253040850162506,
-0.7363055348396301,
0.15125347673892975,
-0.2615024447441101,
-0.48457252979278564,
-0.6505731344223022,
-0.3886744976043701,
0.469997376203537,
0.5847851037979126,
-0.4733757972717285,
0.2808966636657715,
-0.047560159116983414,
-0.47722768783569336,
-0.6184110045433044,
0.08336539566516876,
0.22752651572227478,
0.15869562327861786,
0.29207634925842285,
0.37691760063171387,
-0.4393240213394165,
-0.935571551322937,
-0.6123685240745544,
-0.2688721716403961,
-0.10951927304267883,
0.42301812767982483,
0.19461409747600555,
-0.05208330601453781,
0.7910030484199524,
-0.7784947156906128,
-0.33631432056427,
-0.23119790852069855,
0.23647341132164001,
0.20721273124217987,
0.1919642686843872,
0.20583482086658478,
-0.6818346381187439,
-0.2945610284805298,
-0.4642026722431183,
0.0653051882982254,
-0.7582553625106812,
-0.02833470143377781,
-0.19934849441051483,
0.25936421751976013,
0.7906087040901184,
-0.29201266169548035,
0.19991928339004517,
0.5077708959579468,
-0.1954050213098526,
0.2677275538444519,
-0.23062193393707275,
-0.032188527286052704,
-0.8820986151695251,
-0.034190185368061066,
-0.007156744599342346,
-0.3684116303920746,
-0.01178302988409996,
0.39004674553871155,
-0.01389593817293644,
-0.2692103981971741,
0.025868074968457222,
0.7368210554122925,
-0.3532150089740753,
-0.008066272363066673,
-0.25284823775291443,
0.3992159962654114,
0.03558552265167236,
0.499587744474411,
-0.029715748503804207,
0.9076989889144897,
0.11720941215753555,
-0.4643799662590027,
0.21670851111412048,
0.20598119497299194,
-0.3215118944644928,
0.49305880069732666,
-0.7263215184211731,
-0.046711280941963196,
0.06758516281843185,
0.535423219203949,
-1.2152689695358276,
0.18561610579490662,
-0.2365616261959076,
-0.1526125818490982,
0.04646632447838783,
-0.3181353509426117,
-0.5998362302780151,
0.02789539471268654,
-0.42585569620132446,
0.4994543492794037,
0.4524749219417572,
-0.879999577999115,
0.26665860414505005,
0.5758330821990967,
-0.8146428465843201,
-0.3579673171043396,
-0.3605450987815857,
0.24719902873039246,
-0.06546122580766678,
-0.2960067093372345,
0.635143518447876,
-0.11303053796291351,
-0.2262193262577057,
-0.024089114740490913,
-0.11181960999965668,
0.1380278319120407,
0.05451097711920738,
-0.006857596337795258,
0.24352648854255676,
0.018400873988866806,
0.25178244709968567,
0.16506753861904144,
-0.2235790640115738,
0.05955616384744644,
-0.5771894454956055,
0.6100363731384277,
0.1423611342906952,
-0.25125637650489807,
-0.046668969094753265,
0.42654168605804443,
0.7188723087310791,
-0.43356961011886597,
0.4977080523967743,
-0.00786046776920557,
-0.4513891637325287,
-0.2736264169216156,
-0.5786610841751099,
0.09630278497934341,
-0.48047876358032227,
0.43511390686035156,
-0.15439943969249725,
-0.8620165586471558,
0.33828338980674744,
-0.42155835032463074,
0.5899519324302673,
0.40271666646003723,
0.5233780741691589,
0.02223999798297882,
1.1804932355880737,
0.5537658333778381,
-0.2605450451374054,
0.49560999870300293,
0.04201998934149742,
0.3705781102180481,
-0.7882185578346252,
-0.3226117491722107,
-0.8720274567604065,
-0.5397313833236694,
-0.7275382280349731,
-0.3959082067012787,
0.34414172172546387,
-0.009702637791633606,
-0.3398609459400177,
-0.0047958483919501305,
-0.42583131790161133,
0.6906148791313171,
0.852700412273407,
0.04757649078965187,
0.3563152253627777,
0.025902092456817627,
-0.3710674047470093,
0.0127965547144413,
-0.5819332003593445,
-0.3793536424636841,
1.1829755306243896,
0.24107104539871216,
0.6343188881874084,
0.44431352615356445,
0.8960954546928406,
0.32691389322280884,
0.27949976921081543,
-0.8316261768341064,
0.5066813826560974,
-0.2236946076154709,
-0.31522655487060547,
-0.6909427642822266,
-0.5723567008972168,
-1.0657880306243896,
0.3764238953590393,
-0.042733579874038696,
-0.72404545545578,
0.1983250379562378,
-0.16441747546195984,
-0.25397294759750366,
0.2537747919559479,
-0.42163142561912537,
0.4963298439979553,
-0.16269944608211517,
-0.4241803288459778,
-0.4500855505466461,
-0.14213991165161133,
0.012896405532956123,
-0.16208553314208984,
0.1746140569448471,
0.14731766283512115,
-0.4388369023799896,
0.7389198541641235,
-0.5216791033744812,
0.40409737825393677,
0.09622140228748322,
-0.13977575302124023,
-0.1024266853928566,
0.011142922565340996,
0.6063270568847656,
0.24017827212810516,
-0.10235226154327393,
-0.1835566908121109,
-0.09604714810848236,
-0.3927435576915741,
-0.23711508512496948,
1.1016883850097656,
-0.566645622253418,
-0.6791414022445679,
-0.42869433760643005,
-0.47630074620246887,
-0.25635451078414917,
0.410934716463089,
0.4583642780780792,
0.6617142558097839,
-0.14388997852802277,
0.28526973724365234,
0.9058137536048889,
-0.5669591426849365,
0.5018970370292664,
0.31105977296829224,
-0.5055472254753113,
-0.6829636096954346,
1.0031002759933472,
0.2699384391307831,
0.04369843751192093,
0.7605125308036804,
0.2545519173145294,
-0.8554701209068298,
-0.48607826232910156,
-0.22506916522979736,
0.09978416562080383,
-0.6112506985664368,
-0.36254796385765076,
-0.6466670036315918,
0.051397182047367096,
-0.4613072872161865,
-0.502601146697998,
-0.355254203081131,
-0.3721902370452881,
-0.2173403650522232,
-0.23537158966064453,
0.329330176115036,
0.5909342169761658,
-0.08333493024110794,
-0.029127880930900574,
-0.36627453565597534,
0.014581428840756416,
0.48310354351997375,
0.5299422740936279,
0.15905404090881348,
-0.34176141023635864,
-0.08391880989074707,
-0.43241116404533386,
-0.14553841948509216,
-0.7469667196273804,
0.5269888639450073,
0.036222271621227264,
0.6079866290092468,
0.2972005605697632,
0.37544482946395874,
0.611565351486206,
-0.6706399917602539,
0.5393346548080444,
-0.14308981597423553,
-0.8418635725975037,
0.3351019620895386,
-0.3446286916732788,
0.27814409136772156,
0.6922475695610046,
0.014763683080673218,
-0.3548703193664551,
-0.5044803619384766,
-0.4212457537651062,
-1.4235146045684814,
0.532280683517456,
0.04369106516242027,
0.07581949234008789,
-0.02927308715879917,
0.32083818316459656,
-0.22743907570838928,
0.14558330178260803,
-0.4165722131729126,
-0.2656720280647278,
0.11935669183731079,
-0.20277881622314453,
-0.1860252469778061,
-0.48410820960998535,
-0.08110854774713516,
-0.1280660778284073,
0.6322245001792908,
0.03625693544745445,
-0.03387653827667236,
0.4155160188674927,
-0.09096871316432953,
-0.044732820242643356,
0.3044044077396393,
0.4209631681442261,
0.4344123601913452,
-0.3664538562297821,
0.018374277278780937,
0.07398505508899689,
-0.17981398105621338,
0.17816609144210815,
0.06260790675878525,
-0.3025069534778595,
0.1418750137090683,
0.22942966222763062,
0.33522406220436096,
0.7119799256324768,
-0.8240471482276917,
0.2655223309993744,
-0.001286452985368669,
-0.27176329493522644,
-0.07944466173648834,
-0.46097350120544434,
0.4035440683364868,
0.3797994554042816,
0.4158256947994232,
-0.3065575063228607,
0.33574533462524414,
-0.44146260619163513,
0.20332320034503937,
0.388191282749176,
-0.038177646696567535,
0.22353872656822205,
0.6668152809143066,
0.7588765025138855,
-0.645610511302948,
0.7411596179008484,
0.01730160228908062,
-0.6916070580482483,
0.42282968759536743,
0.4716854393482208,
0.8700597882270813,
0.012549437582492828,
0.366451233625412,
0.302327960729599,
0.48940134048461914,
-0.37538227438926697,
0.1545242816209793,
0.10274575650691986,
-0.3299671709537506,
-0.2997308075428009,
-0.6915116906166077,
-0.8199070692062378,
0.0024056918919086456,
-0.6708811521530151,
0.1728173941373825,
-0.588442862033844,
-0.25146088004112244,
-0.15150892734527588,
0.34186527132987976,
-0.5031909942626953,
-0.07790648937225342,
0.11793608218431473,
1.1825826168060303,
-0.42815494537353516,
0.2662014365196228,
0.710336446762085,
-0.27483317255973816,
-0.7182337045669556,
0.11462629586458206,
0.04921731352806091,
-0.6371350288391113,
0.5677657723426819,
0.06969048827886581,
-0.2328069508075714,
0.5070430636405945,
-0.32853594422340393,
-1.1443653106689453,
0.9684012532234192,
0.3329160213470459,
-0.8459028005599976,
0.06137921288609505,
-0.2785889804363251,
0.18919344246387482,
-0.1274878978729248,
0.28960663080215454,
0.24473266303539276,
0.5782182216644287,
-0.11665283888578415,
-0.7112351059913635,
-0.1836099922657013,
0.06148911640048027,
-0.14742207527160645,
0.5137923359870911,
-0.9744828343391418,
0.767128050327301,
-0.2207820564508438,
-0.2389068901538849,
0.36790043115615845,
0.4387435019016266,
0.4664708971977234,
0.6365063190460205,
0.6041615009307861,
0.7184556126594543,
1.033522129058838,
-0.13601574301719666,
0.8938457369804382,
-0.24389052391052246,
0.4283389151096344,
0.6066705584526062,
-0.6048775315284729,
1.2462788820266724,
0.5137781500816345,
-0.1635970026254654,
0.49095603823661804,
1.0008797645568848,
0.04180153086781502,
0.8037718534469604,
0.4379699230194092,
-0.03133362531661987,
-0.46069467067718506,
-0.4364631175994873,
-0.07455834746360779,
0.08156176656484604,
-0.0325850211083889,
-0.2254457026720047,
-0.22047030925750732,
-0.15457794070243835,
0.1382765769958496,
0.061668623238801956,
-0.4237019121646881,
0.780389130115509,
0.06649119406938553,
-0.78281569480896,
0.14755843579769135,
0.1478440761566162,
0.6082683801651001,
-0.41007035970687866,
0.016333801671862602,
-0.532080888748169,
0.016924889758229256,
0.16368576884269714,
-0.6192958354949951,
-0.17869402468204498,
0.18483789265155792,
-0.321301132440567,
-0.6912687420845032,
0.47680890560150146,
-0.37415811419487,
-0.5710053443908691,
0.22795511782169342,
0.4307757019996643,
-0.053652189671993256,
-0.2672966718673706,
-0.5167891383171082,
0.033244092017412186,
-0.031506773084402084,
-0.43029090762138367,
0.622315526008606,
0.3418181240558624,
0.008312889374792576,
0.9709043502807617,
0.8774601817131042,
0.0647975355386734,
-0.23493342101573944,
0.20648939907550812,
0.7225859761238098,
-0.5164089798927307,
-0.7535985112190247,
-0.8122760057449341,
-0.05160856992006302,
-0.11272408068180084,
-0.44042298197746277,
0.4432361423969269,
0.7083123922348022,
0.7715269923210144,
0.3129136264324188,
0.6535059213638306,
0.6640813946723938,
0.5162795186042786,
-0.7055530548095703,
0.6838642954826355,
-0.8193459510803223,
0.5361487865447998,
-0.31735384464263916,
-1.0730420351028442,
-0.14055411517620087,
0.3824976086616516,
-0.13726530969142914,
-0.3090132474899292,
0.5545957088470459,
0.6745985150337219,
0.5035472512245178,
-0.16462060809135437,
0.1347077488899231,
-0.14739802479743958,
0.23697973787784576,
0.5011250972747803,
0.7947030067443848,
0.10841710865497589,
0.8326464891433716,
0.10414478927850723,
-0.3086249530315399,
-0.46682658791542053,
-0.7067558169364929,
-0.5038354992866516,
-0.4898897707462311,
-0.31310930848121643,
-0.019803224131464958,
0.1877119094133377,
0.8766394853591919,
0.5559666752815247,
-0.36080753803253174,
-0.1915045529603958,
0.10661967843770981,
0.5631087422370911,
-0.28519895672798157,
-0.2166842818260193,
0.4538840651512146,
-0.4000706672668457,
-1.1349527835845947,
0.37758228182792664,
0.5010892152786255,
-0.5405732989311218,
-0.2772805094718933,
0.1448349952697754,
-0.272000253200531,
0.5246958136558533,
0.5543070435523987,
0.137403205037117,
-0.9514588117599487,
-0.07270894199609756,
0.43241986632347107,
-0.16284088790416718,
-0.4553816020488739,
0.9730241298675537,
-0.7717658877372742,
0.08908777683973312,
0.7648329734802246,
0.8366752862930298,
-0.14726313948631287,
0.19839540123939514,
0.6930351257324219,
-0.5538644790649414,
-0.44891825318336487,
0.17491063475608826,
0.38073718547821045,
0.10240479558706284,
-0.4118952453136444,
0.4718930423259735,
0.05868038907647133,
-1.0076277256011963,
-1.0570893287658691,
0.05666045844554901,
-0.8392599821090698,
-0.5902469754219055,
1.2587281465530396,
0.024000758305191994,
0.08615206927061081,
-0.12795686721801758,
-0.30685779452323914,
-0.04917953535914421,
-0.6175161004066467,
0.5801903605461121,
0.7503291964530945,
-0.025821756571531296,
-0.2607683539390564,
-0.28998640179634094,
0.3287923336029053,
0.5481554865837097,
-0.49529948830604553,
0.2919999063014984,
0.4886487126350403,
0.2206428349018097,
0.03264424577355385,
0.37001416087150574,
0.09615545719861984,
-0.23413479328155518,
-0.09951234608888626,
-0.2211143672466278,
0.07577154785394669,
-0.27858632802963257,
-0.15254560112953186,
0.26204919815063477,
0.21181702613830566,
-0.19606439769268036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10835v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10835v2 | Time Series Forecasting with LLMs: Understanding and Enhancing Model Capabilities | 2024-02-16T17:15:28 | 2024-02-19T02:30:15 | Mingyu Jin, Hua Tang, Chong Zhang, Qinkai Yu, Chengzhi Liu, Suiyuan Zhu, Yongfeng Zhang, Mengnan Du | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have been applied in many fields with rapid
development in recent years. As a classic machine learning task, time series
forecasting has recently received a boost from LLMs. However, there is a
research gap in the LLMs' preferences in this field. In this paper, by
comparing LLMs with traditional models, many properties of LLMs in time series
prediction are found. For example, our study shows that LLMs excel in
predicting time series with clear patterns and trends but face challenges with
datasets lacking periodicity. We explain our findings through designing prompts
to require LLMs to tell the period of the datasets. In addition, the input
strategy is investigated, and it is found that incorporating external knowledge
and adopting natural language paraphrases positively affects the predictive
performance of LLMs for time series. Overall, this study contributes to insight
into the advantages and limitations of LLMs in time series forecasting under
different conditions. | [
-0.20820841193199158,
-0.5094101428985596,
0.8162491917610168,
0.3019193410873413,
-0.4876266121864319,
0.2785272002220154,
-0.12353029102087021,
-0.5498654842376709,
-0.03204640373587608,
0.618730902671814,
-0.7309467196464539,
-0.34721454977989197,
-0.45060455799102783,
0.47346967458724976,
-0.2755156457424164,
0.5987911224365234,
-0.24217861890792847,
0.3178273141384125,
-0.33546000719070435,
0.18601250648498535,
-0.6109137535095215,
-0.5801507234573364,
-0.3801271617412567,
-0.5734802484512329,
0.3050333857536316,
0.11295156180858612,
0.6043258309364319,
0.7211907505989075,
0.38010451197624207,
0.325633704662323,
-0.04405301436781883,
0.4418981969356537,
-0.02552531473338604,
0.5316705703735352,
0.33956795930862427,
-0.5216428637504578,
-0.266740620136261,
-0.17245177924633026,
0.6457415223121643,
0.8401978611946106,
-0.11393999308347702,
0.13690339028835297,
0.157777339220047,
0.6220358610153198,
0.03778267651796341,
0.64247065782547,
-0.5647146701812744,
0.12637408077716827,
-0.17317479848861694,
-0.4203638434410095,
-0.17433856427669525,
-0.20439697802066803,
0.2012207806110382,
-0.4318283200263977,
0.08276300877332687,
0.3328840434551239,
0.5709447860717773,
0.4383828341960907,
-0.3076450228691101,
-0.0991431400179863,
-0.9772380590438843,
1.059640645980835,
-1.0014289617538452,
0.28208494186401367,
0.17092880606651306,
0.6025753021240234,
-0.03775437921285629,
-0.5080683827400208,
-0.15014877915382385,
-0.3776019811630249,
0.05908152833580971,
-0.12413844466209412,
0.1483766883611679,
-0.34688735008239746,
0.32692277431488037,
0.31177958846092224,
-0.3954642117023468,
0.29874104261398315,
-0.13792437314987183,
0.1726684421300888,
0.47396576404571533,
0.6803167462348938,
-0.18399854004383087,
-0.32450973987579346,
-0.43160316348075867,
0.2973234951496124,
-0.5858386158943176,
0.034285809844732285,
0.19770991802215576,
0.618277907371521,
-0.2219252586364746,
0.559489369392395,
-0.002004279987886548,
0.5565004944801331,
-0.2989043593406677,
-0.18026027083396912,
-0.009816930629312992,
-0.06551315635442734,
-0.35292288661003113,
-0.2810412347316742,
0.47856229543685913,
0.35320091247558594,
0.42134997248649597,
-0.3624025285243988,
-0.06839478015899658,
-0.23891615867614746,
-0.2084246128797531,
-0.6792922019958496,
0.21220870316028595,
0.09546341747045517,
-0.522834837436676,
-0.28064271807670593,
0.08069060742855072,
-0.8954569101333618,
-0.6072625517845154,
-0.8771170377731323,
-0.0029324812348932028,
-0.2551485002040863,
0.12763121724128723,
-0.01943572424352169,
-0.18288107216358185,
0.11116417497396469,
0.6647847890853882,
-0.7563570141792297,
0.30706551671028137,
0.7163786888122559,
0.9114565253257751,
-0.3576033115386963,
0.04998345673084259,
-0.40581512451171875,
0.05176317319273949,
-0.28015193343162537,
0.6212713718414307,
-0.5552059412002563,
-0.6766456365585327,
-0.07358209043741226,
-0.04761712998151779,
0.08691434562206268,
-0.5401486158370972,
0.0112928980961442,
-0.6125512719154358,
0.031496018171310425,
-0.30672016739845276,
-0.6157812476158142,
-0.17442990839481354,
0.053843263536691666,
-0.516299843788147,
0.7945642471313477,
-0.12810464203357697,
-0.44235891103744507,
0.16750973463058472,
-0.4724675416946411,
-0.2597663700580597,
-0.002522034104913473,
-0.12197596579790115,
-0.22495102882385254,
-0.09411953389644623,
0.5088483691215515,
0.7479586005210876,
-0.5440484881401062,
0.43658849596977234,
-0.5713738799095154,
-0.009590508416295052,
0.6903546452522278,
-0.7426255941390991,
0.29581135511398315,
0.6424906849861145,
-0.14539694786071777,
0.0673077404499054,
-0.5851307511329651,
-0.24402202665805817,
0.08364825695753098,
-0.02655944414436817,
-0.07064462453126907,
0.2587275207042694,
-0.017243774607777596,
0.01968471333384514,
0.22903628647327423,
-0.07558382302522659,
0.294556587934494,
-0.3745795786380768,
0.7937694191932678,
0.9637598991394043,
0.10849589109420776,
0.4067077040672302,
-0.7596598863601685,
0.9074631929397583,
-0.04398566111922264,
0.10899914056062698,
-0.5137524604797363,
-0.26948603987693787,
-0.45268023014068604,
-0.17537780106067657,
0.18971699476242065,
0.6889805793762207,
-0.6814470291137695,
0.27279454469680786,
-0.264090895652771,
-0.49446696043014526,
0.19293956458568573,
0.46663448214530945,
-0.18687966465950012,
0.32056307792663574,
0.1708264797925949,
0.06298701465129852,
-0.7029083967208862,
-0.3466513156890869,
-0.027788031846284866,
0.11636900156736374,
-0.16555552184581757,
0.35190460085868835,
0.2054213583469391,
0.012760501354932785,
0.7963966727256775,
-0.5906225442886353,
0.09086760878562927,
-0.5235438346862793,
-0.026742074638605118,
0.5118786096572876,
-0.10001353174448013,
0.3772604763507843,
-0.6210543513298035,
-0.39819732308387756,
-0.2943495512008667,
-0.8789449334144592,
-0.1520199179649353,
-0.0815330222249031,
0.3736536204814911,
0.3755451440811157,
0.7046601176261902,
-0.4295084476470947,
0.1924624890089035,
0.5172633528709412,
-0.14785805344581604,
0.5169588327407837,
0.03689054399728775,
-0.1372831165790558,
-1.2473068237304688,
-0.09765073657035828,
0.33917954564094543,
-0.3426015377044678,
-0.3846278190612793,
-0.4868090748786926,
-0.2650753855705261,
-0.3427067995071411,
-0.4012546241283417,
0.7980855703353882,
-0.5019997954368591,
-0.1377192586660385,
-0.21436826884746552,
-0.04026024416089058,
0.009234600700438023,
0.04843298718333244,
0.06224943697452545,
0.8831173181533813,
0.3460337221622467,
-0.7794127464294434,
0.6025062203407288,
0.05425665155053139,
-0.5996537208557129,
-0.0996040478348732,
-0.6315819621086121,
-0.13071775436401367,
-0.10075188428163528,
0.05437236651778221,
-0.777665913105011,
-0.052609678357839584,
-0.009542365558445454,
-0.132328599691391,
0.6114590167999268,
0.04031232371926308,
-0.44542521238327026,
-0.40933412313461304,
-0.3037586808204651,
-0.008292343467473984,
0.6061823964118958,
-0.5245553851127625,
0.39604565501213074,
-0.025850560516119003,
-0.40342003107070923,
-0.4382694959640503,
-0.5768628716468811,
0.16307371854782104,
-0.6656854152679443,
-0.4446914792060852,
0.2635904550552368,
-0.3091975450515747,
-0.6146337389945984,
-0.28229016065597534,
-0.1936306655406952,
0.26620179414749146,
0.4171525537967682,
0.31588077545166016,
0.6099035739898682,
-0.3055340051651001,
0.26606762409210205,
-0.4637551009654999,
-0.2109004259109497,
-0.09015817195177078,
-0.2652157247066498,
0.6926242709159851,
-0.06724637746810913,
-0.354680597782135,
-0.3764927089214325,
0.0891200602054596,
0.5656945109367371,
0.007612846326082945,
0.5999668836593628,
0.16957229375839233,
-0.24006253480911255,
-0.15790267288684845,
-0.533208966255188,
-0.21542038023471832,
-0.522295355796814,
0.1309972107410431,
0.031030884012579918,
-0.7884634733200073,
0.3329920172691345,
-0.09743888676166534,
-0.04118550941348076,
0.26133692264556885,
0.3810475766658783,
-0.18207693099975586,
0.8760588765144348,
0.46821948885917664,
-0.36783331632614136,
0.7287224531173706,
-0.2071186751127243,
0.04709016904234886,
-0.7747219204902649,
-0.3358144760131836,
-0.5022687315940857,
-0.12461645156145096,
-0.470762699842453,
-0.2031572014093399,
0.36483561992645264,
0.02757933735847473,
-0.3579825758934021,
0.013617490418255329,
-0.13017922639846802,
0.18199867010116577,
0.3932263255119324,
0.09932693094015121,
0.40132936835289,
0.35359570384025574,
0.301157683134079,
-0.38123947381973267,
-0.47632667422294617,
-0.8223487138748169,
1.0859220027923584,
0.6081271171569824,
1.249409556388855,
-0.08727682381868362,
0.2784789204597473,
0.4652462601661682,
0.12555499374866486,
-0.7430470585823059,
0.48199212551116943,
-0.2899516522884369,
-0.11317861825227737,
-0.42150357365608215,
-0.36163511872291565,
-0.9556697607040405,
-0.1449703425168991,
-0.10918738692998886,
-0.5262338519096375,
0.03078617714345455,
-0.11624450981616974,
-0.35322922468185425,
0.4497232437133789,
-0.2177310287952423,
0.5109421014785767,
-0.5715565085411072,
-0.17191040515899658,
-0.0005302536301314831,
-0.39138534665107727,
-0.06520514190196991,
0.11480708420276642,
0.3512117564678192,
-0.4953517019748688,
-0.3283647298812866,
0.5767244696617126,
-0.45872482657432556,
1.0150372982025146,
0.08107982575893402,
0.010291196405887604,
0.10776754468679428,
-0.059751905500888824,
0.364542692899704,
0.21813616156578064,
-0.3927381932735443,
0.08871641755104065,
0.053552865982055664,
-0.2302398681640625,
-0.5200347304344177,
0.6905258893966675,
-0.7031165361404419,
-0.8998996615409851,
-0.6285115480422974,
-0.7599470019340515,
-0.4959791898727417,
-0.05539471656084061,
0.03826848417520523,
0.7018414735794067,
-0.17449919879436493,
0.10992689430713654,
0.5295670032501221,
0.047247469425201416,
0.9018660187721252,
0.4023667573928833,
-0.6448935270309448,
-0.3170211613178253,
0.6412674784660339,
0.2762347459793091,
0.25836247205734253,
0.6220541000366211,
0.3542369604110718,
-0.3936083912849426,
-0.7464773654937744,
-0.2552991211414337,
0.36521536111831665,
-0.6730061173439026,
-0.2233724147081375,
-0.25608986616134644,
-0.20359930396080017,
-0.6156307458877563,
-0.0038361377082765102,
0.20423081517219543,
-0.4589713513851166,
-0.6842408180236816,
-0.06950671970844269,
0.7093467712402344,
0.9024875164031982,
0.3626174330711365,
0.18100368976593018,
-0.9549173712730408,
0.2292661964893341,
0.27231448888778687,
0.19913655519485474,
0.017555098980665207,
-0.5589967966079712,
-0.11672976613044739,
-0.15792137384414673,
-0.6168498396873474,
-0.8529660701751709,
0.902184009552002,
-0.12138789892196655,
0.519931972026825,
0.4938329756259918,
-0.10791757702827454,
0.6084306836128235,
-0.43795958161354065,
1.0166606903076172,
-0.03294120728969574,
-0.8020082712173462,
0.35653939843177795,
-0.5165552496910095,
0.3076063394546509,
-0.13760395348072052,
0.44244062900543213,
-0.620500385761261,
-0.12058784812688828,
-0.4303247928619385,
-0.6553351283073425,
0.5414650440216064,
-0.15463022887706757,
0.1881507784128189,
0.11032141000032425,
0.37556207180023193,
0.3151372969150543,
0.6530399918556213,
-0.5338554382324219,
-0.41418588161468506,
-0.21506084501743317,
-0.17629824578762054,
-0.6254499554634094,
-0.29159700870513916,
0.11767259240150452,
-0.17049004137516022,
0.5338398814201355,
0.0909874364733696,
0.22066792845726013,
0.06454163044691086,
0.2620508670806885,
-0.1378021389245987,
0.36474141478538513,
0.4632088541984558,
0.8458498120307922,
-0.1804634928703308,
-0.149713397026062,
0.47295716404914856,
0.06749845296144485,
-0.024894818663597107,
0.17567119002342224,
-0.014521376229822636,
0.29991093277931213,
0.39377421140670776,
0.9203588366508484,
0.089741550385952,
-0.6019328236579895,
-0.11997270584106445,
0.2828279435634613,
0.04179177060723305,
-0.6264800429344177,
-0.06427961587905884,
0.26117151975631714,
0.5327266454696655,
0.6081032156944275,
-0.060755982995033264,
-0.1682869791984558,
-0.5952273011207581,
-0.34850001335144043,
0.5364803075790405,
-0.07681099325418472,
-0.0960930660367012,
0.5984657406806946,
0.08287916332483292,
-0.20940417051315308,
0.2921142280101776,
0.23306572437286377,
-0.3931078016757965,
0.9585252404212952,
0.5234894156455994,
0.6586995124816895,
-0.29901084303855896,
-0.05418935790657997,
-0.13943062722682953,
0.10329030454158783,
-0.2989853322505951,
0.2094084769487381,
0.16326625645160675,
-0.45203620195388794,
-0.45608946681022644,
-0.7427883148193359,
-0.6972818374633789,
0.48307016491889954,
-0.44264915585517883,
0.6258589029312134,
-0.5874756574630737,
-0.19955959916114807,
-0.10764331370592117,
0.17193028330802917,
-0.5687533617019653,
-0.029817530885338783,
0.23941659927368164,
1.075390100479126,
-0.6067415475845337,
0.7423455119132996,
0.42385563254356384,
-0.11717307567596436,
-0.612912118434906,
-0.19030000269412994,
-0.05504501983523369,
-0.7202847599983215,
0.6703110933303833,
0.27902352809906006,
0.23265981674194336,
-0.13802441954612732,
-0.32828080654144287,
-0.8949248194694519,
1.2766644954681396,
0.29932719469070435,
-0.6204877495765686,
-0.29158854484558105,
0.20418387651443481,
0.39974716305732727,
-0.6425286531448364,
-0.1661926805973053,
0.28828978538513184,
0.548305869102478,
0.11691713333129883,
-0.7204267978668213,
-0.10779102146625519,
0.04715525731444359,
0.20430229604244232,
0.44105973839759827,
-0.338985413312912,
0.8295393586158752,
-0.126703143119812,
-0.07189162820577621,
0.5991638898849487,
0.8458958268165588,
-0.08888434618711472,
0.8708644509315491,
0.19467264413833618,
0.04574037715792656,
0.6056746244430542,
-0.1102474108338356,
1.1548327207565308,
-0.11494053155183792,
0.15127761662006378,
0.9244369864463806,
-0.4836116135120392,
0.7436363697052002,
0.416597455739975,
-0.5809877514839172,
0.5161375999450684,
0.8518523573875427,
-0.5146083235740662,
0.35769838094711304,
0.04420534893870354,
-0.2312197983264923,
-0.5563995242118835,
-0.07555463910102844,
-0.5136541724205017,
-0.057475581765174866,
0.5643104314804077,
-0.30237722396850586,
-0.20643609762191772,
0.121308334171772,
0.08278767764568329,
0.2994130551815033,
-0.47961243987083435,
0.5741052627563477,
0.5432840585708618,
-0.42489030957221985,
0.23214368522167206,
-0.03496340289711952,
0.6701874136924744,
-0.7284295558929443,
0.1232290118932724,
-0.06599760055541992,
-0.08762940019369125,
-0.1454617977142334,
-0.5516681671142578,
0.4555012881755829,
-0.08329718559980392,
-0.2691210210323334,
-0.2742387354373932,
0.5511178374290466,
-0.17083802819252014,
-0.6876217722892761,
0.06769408285617828,
0.682209312915802,
-0.06172472611069679,
0.0554199256002903,
-0.5407720804214478,
-0.13596022129058838,
-0.2087215632200241,
-0.12028184533119202,
0.18769727647304535,
0.29177650809288025,
-0.11397271603345871,
1.0445877313613892,
0.6279561519622803,
0.2678185999393463,
-0.09515514969825745,
0.030686480924487114,
0.4426197111606598,
-0.8180913925170898,
-0.2120257318019867,
-1.1203066110610962,
0.002496767323464155,
0.13449017703533173,
0.26548147201538086,
0.9329022765159607,
0.3463576138019562,
0.21969512104988098,
-0.25033140182495117,
0.9811519980430603,
0.5807945728302002,
0.8072981238365173,
-0.9295709133148193,
0.11010866612195969,
-0.3614254295825958,
0.8546041250228882,
0.09796634316444397,
-0.8072111010551453,
-0.1790398508310318,
-0.04853728041052818,
-0.6573349833488464,
0.22269447147846222,
0.5918034315109253,
0.42017316818237305,
0.14455032348632812,
0.31345871090888977,
0.32100099325180054,
0.12218058854341507,
0.19797083735466003,
0.17059658467769623,
0.9932286143302917,
0.16666395962238312,
0.5568459033966064,
-0.2491944134235382,
0.03648558259010315,
-0.2750331163406372,
-1.2176724672317505,
-1.161618947982788,
-0.35850369930267334,
-0.09120657294988632,
-0.14976412057876587,
0.009634522721171379,
1.207444429397583,
0.31900158524513245,
-0.7565020322799683,
-0.5604994893074036,
0.007264996413141489,
0.23322921991348267,
-0.1478077471256256,
-0.26887819170951843,
0.1481909304857254,
-0.48140648007392883,
-0.7890200018882751,
0.564761221408844,
0.05192301794886589,
0.5196786522865295,
-0.36276957392692566,
0.07093322277069092,
0.4432988166809082,
0.05419270694255829,
0.5053234696388245,
0.2195960283279419,
-0.6670156717300415,
0.05997101217508316,
0.3191453814506531,
0.22326509654521942,
0.04201241210103035,
0.8749980330467224,
-0.7014560699462891,
-0.07129625976085663,
0.44259387254714966,
0.4250524342060089,
0.5302765965461731,
-0.06426862627267838,
0.7153010964393616,
-0.44562119245529175,
-0.02401748113334179,
0.133331298828125,
0.7334613800048828,
0.5594364404678345,
-0.3313579559326172,
0.29047074913978577,
0.2956257164478302,
-0.6419768333435059,
-0.6519893407821655,
0.20856019854545593,
-0.9204620718955994,
-0.4830043911933899,
1.2573131322860718,
0.18773253262043,
0.014626514166593552,
-0.3053209185600281,
-0.13353149592876434,
0.2724963426589966,
-0.418826162815094,
0.6694951057434082,
0.7140476703643799,
-0.20526021718978882,
0.012144599109888077,
-0.9469835758209229,
0.29492560029029846,
0.20107191801071167,
-0.6173269748687744,
0.12869009375572205,
0.11893536895513535,
0.3763068914413452,
-0.1948411464691162,
-0.03457096591591835,
0.030994519591331482,
-0.11035749316215515,
-0.6196141242980957,
-0.43842411041259766,
-0.6462305188179016,
-0.2596420347690582,
-0.5379751920700073,
-0.038089483976364136,
0.5037907361984253,
0.053683795034885406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11000v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11000v2 | ASGEA: Exploiting Logic Rules from Align-Subgraphs for Entity Alignment | 2024-02-16T17:03:05 | 2024-03-05T13:57:28 | Yangyifei Luo, Zhuo Chen, Lingbing Guo, Qian Li, Wenxuan Zeng, Zhixin Cai, Jianxin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Entity alignment (EA) aims to identify entities across different knowledge
graphs that represent the same real-world objects. Recent embedding-based EA
methods have achieved state-of-the-art performance in EA yet faced
interpretability challenges as they purely rely on the embedding distance and
neglect the logic rules behind a pair of aligned entities. In this paper, we
propose the Align-Subgraph Entity Alignment (ASGEA) framework to exploit logic
rules from Align-Subgraphs. ASGEA uses anchor links as bridges to construct
Align-Subgraphs and spreads along the paths across KGs, which distinguishes it
from the embedding-based methods. Furthermore, we design an interpretable
Path-based Graph Neural Network, ASGNN, to effectively identify and integrate
the logic rules across KGs. We also introduce a node-level multi-modal
attention mechanism coupled with multi-modal enriched anchors to augment the
Align-Subgraph. Our experimental results demonstrate the superior performance
of ASGEA over the existing embedding-based methods in both EA and Multi-Modal
EA (MMEA) tasks. | [
-0.1612674593925476,
-0.7351765036582947,
0.6259363889694214,
0.026340600103139877,
-0.28300461173057556,
-0.07815001159906387,
0.08427109569311142,
-0.5696472525596619,
0.5767666101455688,
0.1800190955400467,
-0.8861082196235657,
-0.6017907857894897,
-0.5703290700912476,
-0.11109740287065506,
-0.13092239201068878,
0.6900036931037903,
-0.13407720625400543,
-0.033143140375614166,
-0.3868277370929718,
-0.3910151422023773,
-0.6508383750915527,
0.1441430300474167,
-0.612365186214447,
-0.362959623336792,
0.3032754957675934,
0.06684670597314835,
0.7196823358535767,
0.7341648936271667,
0.2065465897321701,
0.24734267592430115,
0.27110153436660767,
0.40415194630622864,
-0.12623454630374908,
-0.3371666669845581,
-0.6323990821838379,
-0.22017210721969604,
-0.7868835926055908,
-0.1556674689054489,
0.4135447144508362,
0.4775101840496063,
-0.10399806499481201,
0.25599050521850586,
-0.23125410079956055,
0.4294291138648987,
-0.5991114377975464,
0.8224320411682129,
-0.5857521295547485,
-0.07149823009967804,
-0.24793197214603424,
0.06214077025651932,
-0.3558228015899658,
-0.05861435458064079,
0.06922288984060287,
-1.2576860189437866,
-0.394549697637558,
0.34418946504592896,
1.1919713020324707,
0.4889271557331085,
-0.5142583250999451,
-0.33773255348205566,
-0.0417487807571888,
0.42915380001068115,
-0.5492648482322693,
0.7693187594413757,
-0.2127130627632141,
0.21697989106178284,
-0.07414400577545166,
-0.5726659893989563,
-0.6113067269325256,
0.4218657910823822,
-0.5153344869613647,
0.17394641041755676,
-0.4149802327156067,
0.17678706347942352,
0.3814481794834137,
-0.10560944676399231,
-0.30010512471199036,
-0.10981831699609756,
-0.12349367886781693,
-0.2182188481092453,
0.4563377797603607,
-0.12702231109142303,
0.6957547664642334,
-0.21434518694877625,
-0.6614023447036743,
0.3383243680000305,
-0.7933681607246399,
-0.028180278837680817,
0.3112146556377411,
0.43699294328689575,
0.2591172158718109,
0.5768586993217468,
-0.22908778488636017,
0.47076380252838135,
0.18393677473068237,
-0.05491640418767929,
0.34738561511039734,
-0.3822256326675415,
-0.4508371353149414,
0.305842787027359,
0.7155729532241821,
0.4141910970211029,
0.25137022137641907,
-0.4105188548564911,
-0.16300271451473236,
0.2183859795331955,
0.2376740425825119,
-0.5183188319206238,
-0.20328781008720398,
-0.18132245540618896,
-0.5271150469779968,
0.06582392752170563,
-0.052701640874147415,
-0.6221392750740051,
-0.17623713612556458,
-0.425080269575119,
0.6588435173034668,
-0.6608384251594543,
-0.1543012261390686,
0.12582536041736603,
-0.0435507632791996,
0.392679363489151,
0.38304403424263,
-0.6751239895820618,
0.5532055497169495,
0.7445698380470276,
0.5470850467681885,
0.19546249508857727,
-0.3917858302593231,
-0.5066244602203369,
0.5804215669631958,
-0.007753073703497648,
0.6494308114051819,
-0.7315183877944946,
0.25801172852516174,
-0.14022469520568848,
0.15043945610523224,
-0.4474474787712097,
-0.2574843168258667,
0.5264774560928345,
-1.0433601140975952,
-0.28094783425331116,
-0.25849342346191406,
-0.680082380771637,
-0.6676323413848877,
0.20630048215389252,
-0.759051501750946,
0.5396551489830017,
0.04013703018426895,
-0.48891738057136536,
0.49070027470588684,
-0.7160793542861938,
-0.7820807695388794,
-0.15328268706798553,
-0.5261132121086121,
-0.3430067002773285,
-0.19515284895896912,
0.5697048902511597,
-0.0052465288899838924,
-0.32850712537765503,
0.18317478895187378,
-0.08833089470863342,
-0.1310645490884781,
-0.124326191842556,
-0.1511959433555603,
0.8543878197669983,
-0.055350854992866516,
-0.5790144801139832,
0.12109889090061188,
-0.5270053744316101,
0.11722889542579651,
-0.03128150850534439,
-0.0748116597533226,
-0.3972623944282532,
0.09936653077602386,
-0.38091057538986206,
0.36067846417427063,
0.2726196050643921,
-0.4674896001815796,
0.1443088948726654,
-0.3116033971309662,
0.2564931809902191,
0.7236925959587097,
0.012189893051981926,
0.575786292552948,
0.008458251133561134,
0.4927009344100952,
0.33911603689193726,
-0.05716123431921005,
0.14570721983909607,
-0.4820174276828766,
-0.4112469553947449,
-0.29603224992752075,
0.5587219595909119,
0.6690855622291565,
-0.8371330499649048,
0.6150168776512146,
-0.640893816947937,
-0.2986620366573334,
-0.8119114637374878,
0.28508737683296204,
0.3963121771812439,
0.9085619449615479,
0.6523295640945435,
-0.3376903235912323,
-0.3512578010559082,
-1.0059207677841187,
-0.48074576258659363,
-0.06309589743614197,
0.1897614449262619,
0.5157846212387085,
0.34157466888427734,
-0.36075350642204285,
0.7821785807609558,
-0.48873409628868103,
-0.7140401601791382,
0.056236252188682556,
-0.21750913560390472,
-0.04431726783514023,
0.5536097884178162,
0.4489583969116211,
-0.5570924878120422,
-0.32750430703163147,
-0.03544068709015846,
-0.8217496871948242,
-0.22155945003032684,
-0.1358713060617447,
-0.512881875038147,
0.02208225429058075,
0.6112044453620911,
-0.9820485711097717,
0.3536255657672882,
0.09416689723730087,
-0.5227383375167847,
-0.025283968076109886,
0.3127123713493347,
0.0682789608836174,
-0.8033376932144165,
-0.08656826615333557,
0.15536916255950928,
-0.3549194633960724,
-0.14831751585006714,
0.03144529089331627,
0.11360036581754684,
-0.0010764463804662228,
-0.17890150845050812,
0.20765924453735352,
-0.6780537366867065,
-0.42966586351394653,
0.1288681924343109,
0.6124399304389954,
0.4016055762767792,
0.5145543217658997,
-0.03212761506438255,
0.23805074393749237,
0.6150424480438232,
-0.26291537284851074,
0.42781543731689453,
0.5165084004402161,
-0.1026218831539154,
0.8569060564041138,
-0.40993568301200867,
-0.006697900127619505,
-0.2644466161727905,
0.4196665287017822,
-0.5453529357910156,
0.2172805517911911,
0.5346777439117432,
-0.19392874836921692,
0.5676676034927368,
-0.4152457118034363,
-0.2657613456249237,
0.0772552639245987,
-0.02851320430636406,
0.4617893397808075,
0.2531173825263977,
-0.5152341723442078,
1.522233009338379,
0.34276822209358215,
0.32418012619018555,
-0.9215393662452698,
-0.34017783403396606,
-0.287504106760025,
-0.01336108148097992,
-0.9466809630393982,
0.3937181234359741,
0.4477517604827881,
-0.1108369380235672,
0.8173959255218506,
-0.4334767460823059,
0.49795740842819214,
0.1338423639535904,
0.4082565903663635,
0.29226887226104736,
-0.5961434245109558,
0.07181865721940994,
0.37944933772087097,
-0.3840596079826355,
0.25328877568244934,
-0.7495893836021423,
0.15424613654613495,
-0.03967016190290451,
-0.6849802732467651,
-0.5772892236709595,
0.33284851908683777,
0.4595366418361664,
-0.5050036311149597,
0.8190906047821045,
0.3418761193752289,
-0.8738035559654236,
-0.1674489676952362,
-0.21677978336811066,
-0.11312446743249893,
-0.42687487602233887,
0.21159318089485168,
-0.6930963397026062,
-0.3137551248073578,
0.3995193839073181,
-0.47105446457862854,
-0.0011383290402591228,
0.7523687481880188,
-0.06467293202877045,
-0.01734796166419983,
0.9534497261047363,
0.367067813873291,
-0.11396371573209763,
0.29106977581977844,
-0.01647341065108776,
0.5797995924949646,
-0.9082297682762146,
-0.5687373280525208,
-0.12070624530315399,
-0.6874788999557495,
-0.2729355990886688,
-0.4122841954231262,
0.1440369188785553,
0.32276415824890137,
-0.3406916856765747,
0.4729955792427063,
-0.26092496514320374,
0.553434431552887,
0.41223910450935364,
0.1683892160654068,
0.31687960028648376,
-0.12799681723117828,
-0.11738672852516174,
-0.003125227987766266,
-0.6209920644760132,
-0.34202849864959717,
0.5367012023925781,
0.3476220667362213,
0.9635365009307861,
0.4014362394809723,
0.46145308017730713,
0.004211526829749346,
0.40854695439338684,
-0.9546197056770325,
0.48583364486694336,
-0.11996274441480637,
-0.4611780643463135,
-0.49085089564323425,
-0.34857994318008423,
-0.5653842687606812,
0.13161027431488037,
-0.2588776648044586,
-0.815881073474884,
0.17721377313137054,
0.15050078928470612,
-0.4308513402938843,
0.33676645159721375,
-0.9172895550727844,
1.3178045749664307,
-0.1490054726600647,
0.015166879631578922,
0.10703111439943314,
-0.7761474847793579,
-0.03698228672146797,
0.30663251876831055,
0.089841328561306,
-0.19115333259105682,
-0.11458948999643326,
0.4845048189163208,
-0.3393961787223816,
0.6597338318824768,
-0.3044346570968628,
0.011820757761597633,
0.391236811876297,
-0.011981494724750519,
0.7341439723968506,
0.20289044082164764,
0.16121633350849152,
0.12307130545377731,
-0.12357388436794281,
-0.35326090455055237,
-1.0158950090408325,
0.7502752542495728,
-0.6905341744422913,
-0.6640093326568604,
-0.14838305115699768,
-0.5330129861831665,
-0.33915263414382935,
0.5297189950942993,
-0.04177204519510269,
0.6339958310127258,
0.21639643609523773,
-0.049926791340112686,
0.6104676127433777,
0.20810949802398682,
0.09815265983343124,
0.36150649189949036,
0.012439998798072338,
-0.21044375002384186,
1.0279996395111084,
0.3841772675514221,
0.16030237078666687,
0.612437903881073,
-0.13003681600093842,
-0.6304274797439575,
-0.25478681921958923,
-1.060153841972351,
0.24574726819992065,
-0.8961771726608276,
-0.470632404088974,
-0.8412550091743469,
-0.12409279495477676,
-0.7102475166320801,
-0.3359442353248596,
-0.2735809087753296,
-0.2667387127876282,
-0.30124256014823914,
-0.3316526412963867,
0.33669528365135193,
0.47887465357780457,
0.08290551602840424,
-0.16758784651756287,
-0.6984776854515076,
0.11299974471330643,
0.2812141478061676,
0.37609609961509705,
0.1457539200782776,
-0.09458643943071365,
0.17205199599266052,
-0.1914076805114746,
0.04186593368649483,
-1.1238133907318115,
-0.13153621554374695,
0.05821206420660019,
0.7091735005378723,
0.4662506878376007,
0.010793124325573444,
0.8236317038536072,
-0.6322274804115295,
0.14284765720367432,
0.03658667579293251,
-1.2495524883270264,
0.4892464876174927,
-0.11010441929101944,
-0.20531418919563293,
0.5622867345809937,
0.46879565715789795,
-0.2538995146751404,
0.13319580256938934,
-0.7677901983261108,
-0.9069728255271912,
0.7569335699081421,
0.035557083785533905,
-0.23980261385440826,
0.1592680811882019,
0.33705341815948486,
-0.3494601845741272,
0.28697800636291504,
-0.6331697106361389,
-0.4467117488384247,
-0.23233912885189056,
-0.873512327671051,
0.3844074010848999,
0.23436066508293152,
-0.36965131759643555,
0.12766969203948975,
0.8898630738258362,
-0.6118856072425842,
0.08096478134393692,
0.05980297178030014,
-0.4215462803840637,
-0.09561636298894882,
0.07807940244674683,
0.10269761830568314,
0.7257432341575623,
0.2213890552520752,
0.35609784722328186,
0.408695787191391,
-0.19028106331825256,
0.06471993774175644,
0.46813565492630005,
-0.386601984500885,
-0.32945725321769714,
0.298973023891449,
0.6877891421318054,
0.29354366660118103,
-0.47078439593315125,
0.6701510548591614,
0.14956003427505493,
0.3312355577945709,
-0.08614781498908997,
-0.06981713324785233,
0.49706730246543884,
0.5088571906089783,
-0.07408666610717773,
0.18195217847824097,
0.20823438465595245,
-0.6344954967498779,
0.3682544529438019,
0.5031223893165588,
-0.8145202994346619,
-0.24401524662971497,
0.6660926938056946,
0.18450801074504852,
-0.20163851976394653,
0.7142865061759949,
-0.43306463956832886,
-0.6434005498886108,
0.6750699877738953,
0.7696188688278198,
0.5665475726127625,
0.12547191977500916,
0.0422743484377861,
0.10430379211902618,
0.6269525289535522,
0.43419164419174194,
0.28052252531051636,
0.22266601026058197,
-0.905953049659729,
-0.3962193727493286,
-0.5403462052345276,
0.10317470878362656,
-0.31503069400787354,
-0.626152753829956,
0.2548375725746155,
-0.292695552110672,
0.2913009524345398,
0.2063041776418686,
-0.13940449059009552,
-0.6828481554985046,
0.4196789264678955,
-0.09467267990112305,
1.0025246143341064,
-1.1085103750228882,
0.4748965799808502,
1.1238195896148682,
-0.7022016048431396,
-1.251388430595398,
-0.05679470673203468,
0.27101606130599976,
-0.8942498564720154,
0.4244370758533478,
0.15205225348472595,
-0.3071032464504242,
0.1239323765039444,
-0.1802440881729126,
-0.909456193447113,
1.6305023431777954,
0.5189158320426941,
-0.31293749809265137,
-0.2583920657634735,
-0.2775333523750305,
0.34757453203201294,
-0.6220453381538391,
0.04656195268034935,
0.7201138734817505,
0.46413454413414,
0.004289816599339247,
-0.5291935801506042,
0.7450933456420898,
-0.24840717017650604,
-0.29196953773498535,
0.5422418117523193,
-0.9915323853492737,
0.36938005685806274,
-0.07722974568605423,
-0.39461836218833923,
-0.5157715678215027,
0.863756537437439,
0.20903350412845612,
0.42945706844329834,
0.8360928893089294,
1.0315942764282227,
0.7769774794578552,
-0.14523299038410187,
0.7407160401344299,
-0.2021356225013733,
0.1985308974981308,
1.1841058731079102,
-0.34655430912971497,
0.5044904947280884,
0.40758270025253296,
0.1659446656703949,
0.8019284605979919,
0.27458125352859497,
0.2038416713476181,
0.5027486085891724,
0.06836266815662384,
-0.05588599666953087,
-0.39285674691200256,
-0.3898601233959198,
0.05465763062238693,
0.2839289605617523,
0.4321795403957367,
-0.38928601145744324,
-0.1475536972284317,
-0.3474726974964142,
0.07661312818527222,
-0.06346534937620163,
-0.4798858165740967,
0.7829602956771851,
0.10566165298223495,
-0.5775639414787292,
-0.46571993827819824,
-0.0740031823515892,
0.18601490557193756,
-0.29978057742118835,
-0.2784125506877899,
0.31195035576820374,
0.02388625591993332,
-0.5514222383499146,
-0.6392967104911804,
0.22651663422584534,
-0.49018189311027527,
-0.3218037188053131,
0.0067460075952112675,
1.079952359199524,
-0.4358370900154114,
-0.13217411935329437,
0.5961151719093323,
0.43782222270965576,
-0.22136875987052917,
0.1495642215013504,
-0.6596343517303467,
-0.25047725439071655,
-0.19822552800178528,
-0.09920991212129593,
0.19371071457862854,
0.8513080477714539,
-0.20519322156906128,
0.4071941375732422,
0.4668883681297302,
-0.272993266582489,
0.0029478478245437145,
0.20875129103660583,
0.9410308003425598,
-0.4385010004043579,
-0.4554179012775421,
-0.7332198619842529,
0.4040452539920807,
-0.15788647532463074,
-0.03811519593000412,
0.510057270526886,
0.5431392192840576,
0.8835425972938538,
0.31285467743873596,
0.42422062158584595,
-0.2611330449581146,
-0.015919946134090424,
-0.8211292624473572,
0.653058648109436,
-0.5190625786781311,
0.2054237574338913,
-0.3262048065662384,
-0.7280862927436829,
0.0023478916846215725,
0.5557753443717957,
-0.26975563168525696,
0.039227474480867386,
0.7705690264701843,
0.7216447591781616,
-0.3716298043727875,
0.0815669596195221,
-0.017267249524593353,
0.11391419172286987,
0.2855045795440674,
0.6109635233879089,
0.5184484124183655,
-0.6040334701538086,
0.5178142786026001,
0.057194434106349945,
-0.13305488228797913,
0.08171148598194122,
-0.8538516163825989,
-0.5544180274009705,
-0.3017268478870392,
-0.5295932292938232,
-0.45031702518463135,
-0.11351153999567032,
0.9645780324935913,
0.45788681507110596,
-0.8163479566574097,
0.5457677245140076,
0.07284808903932571,
0.5323699712753296,
-0.5583178997039795,
-0.24492086470127106,
0.6181478500366211,
-0.08499035984277725,
-0.6465779542922974,
0.38230231404304504,
0.544428288936615,
-0.09465279430150986,
-0.0012232623994350433,
0.08508739620447159,
-0.542156994342804,
0.1582973301410675,
0.3530738949775696,
0.1386260688304901,
-0.614757239818573,
-0.7577906847000122,
0.10168645530939102,
-0.09281840920448303,
-0.028844909742474556,
0.6262375712394714,
-0.5720992684364319,
0.36636489629745483,
0.561144232749939,
1.1129173040390015,
0.12148098647594452,
0.39410319924354553,
0.5280303359031677,
-0.8264689445495605,
-0.34934425354003906,
0.12598997354507446,
0.692901611328125,
0.10221629589796066,
-0.4674379527568817,
0.6750086545944214,
0.4269941449165344,
-0.14765982329845428,
-0.352964848279953,
0.3173482120037079,
-0.9580195546150208,
0.1778707504272461,
0.9608599543571472,
-0.49042829871177673,
-0.5234938859939575,
-0.20429372787475586,
-0.02624097466468811,
0.40746811032295227,
-0.4696432650089264,
0.18984651565551758,
0.43664565682411194,
-0.39915409684181213,
0.1523250788450241,
-0.2410212755203247,
0.5150798559188843,
0.38624560832977295,
-1.0003718137741089,
-0.3595958948135376,
0.5156781077384949,
0.41833871603012085,
0.5197622179985046,
0.6658592820167542,
-0.22496214509010315,
0.3604275584220886,
0.12130317091941833,
-0.18587779998779297,
-0.09326814115047455,
-0.5261793732643127,
-0.05143728852272034,
0.21296326816082,
-0.23349325358867645,
-0.24340350925922394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04769v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04769v2 | Using Hallucinations to Bypass GPT4's Filter | 2024-02-16T17:02:53 | 2024-03-11T01:21:32 | Benjamin Lemkin | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are initially trained on vast amounts of data,
then fine-tuned using reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF); this
also serves to teach the LLM to provide appropriate and safe responses. In this
paper, we present a novel method to manipulate the fine-tuned version into
reverting to its pre-RLHF behavior, effectively erasing the model's filters;
the exploit currently works for GPT4, Claude Sonnet, and (to some extent) for
Inflection-2.5. Unlike other jailbreaks (for example, the popular "Do Anything
Now" (DAN) ), our method does not rely on instructing the LLM to override its
RLHF policy; hence, simply modifying the RLHF process is unlikely to address
it. Instead, we induce a hallucination involving reversed text during which the
model reverts to a word bucket, effectively pausing the model's filter. We
believe that our exploit presents a fundamental vulnerability in LLMs currently
unaddressed, as well as an opportunity to better understand the inner workings
of LLMs during hallucinations. | [
-0.46634209156036377,
-0.9860399961471558,
0.7247792482376099,
-0.0857468992471695,
-0.4470314085483551,
-0.04651348292827606,
-0.3602347671985626,
-0.5030364394187927,
0.34315022826194763,
1.275736689567566,
-0.704215407371521,
-0.41329455375671387,
-0.5966870784759521,
0.13174352049827576,
-0.5837441682815552,
1.1712294816970825,
0.08020532876253128,
-0.12017901241779327,
0.2374717891216278,
0.2047869712114334,
-0.5342388153076172,
-0.6402124166488647,
-0.6497628092765808,
-0.730305016040802,
0.6322694420814514,
0.14410634338855743,
0.7816576361656189,
0.22873170673847198,
0.2199893593788147,
0.29851922392845154,
0.08275353908538818,
0.09249676018953323,
-0.8242478370666504,
0.1366327852010727,
-0.18306085467338562,
-0.446638286113739,
-0.11555532366037369,
0.030566656962037086,
0.5934451222419739,
0.45322927832603455,
-0.2929074764251709,
-0.41939777135849,
0.22119180858135223,
0.6570513844490051,
-0.4082861542701721,
-0.010633622296154499,
-1.0183947086334229,
0.2256401777267456,
-0.01764857769012451,
-0.5541286468505859,
-0.5693637132644653,
-0.25581368803977966,
-0.1938650906085968,
-0.32387575507164,
0.2526076138019562,
-0.044603560119867325,
0.7808326482772827,
0.5422021746635437,
0.06136542186141014,
-0.23939915001392365,
-0.8646944761276245,
0.5434421300888062,
-0.7311402559280396,
0.39402657747268677,
0.6299739480018616,
0.16075415909290314,
-0.6325639486312866,
-0.5869817733764648,
-0.819916844367981,
-0.4274822175502777,
-0.0789988711476326,
-0.18576310575008392,
0.07608077675104141,
0.11517437547445297,
0.2847072184085846,
0.2123328149318695,
-0.5423562526702881,
0.2104288935661316,
-0.5166687369346619,
-0.37357163429260254,
0.3303571045398712,
0.03766267001628876,
0.22133059799671173,
-0.18518143892288208,
-0.1585162729024887,
-0.042597655206918716,
-0.8574543595314026,
-0.40640076994895935,
0.46972161531448364,
0.34976187348365784,
0.3929632306098938,
0.4812759459018707,
0.0670289397239685,
0.5004842877388,
0.035519346594810486,
-0.034861452877521515,
0.05410796403884888,
0.260577917098999,
-0.47335657477378845,
0.24665915966033936,
0.6051088571548462,
0.14011909067630768,
0.4076436460018158,
-0.4265957176685333,
-0.5064269304275513,
0.12560254335403442,
0.5657575130462646,
-0.7597381472587585,
-0.4139944314956665,
0.1853257715702057,
-0.2370651513338089,
-0.4076908528804779,
0.04858201742172241,
-0.7353180050849915,
-0.8452345728874207,
-0.04098419472575188,
0.7266960740089417,
-0.38548654317855835,
-0.0038197918329387903,
0.29668745398521423,
0.15930390357971191,
0.17422924935817719,
0.15429797768592834,
-0.8788655996322632,
0.43884533643722534,
0.6959319710731506,
0.8809573650360107,
-0.06115390732884407,
-0.6534402370452881,
-0.9188458919525146,
0.002560974098742008,
-0.25275975465774536,
0.6276973485946655,
-0.5969332456588745,
-0.5352324843406677,
0.09003681689500809,
0.27205607295036316,
0.14428716897964478,
-0.8801552057266235,
0.28101563453674316,
-0.7922859191894531,
0.07655800879001617,
-0.07642795890569687,
-0.3496532738208771,
-0.3189639747142792,
0.1913583129644394,
-0.7899322509765625,
0.6515651345252991,
-0.021194791421294212,
-0.6051395535469055,
0.09471558779478073,
-0.2985961139202118,
-0.37589454650878906,
-0.19886206090450287,
-0.060404855757951736,
-0.6167362332344055,
0.0809997096657753,
0.3891063630580902,
0.32692062854766846,
0.16683800518512726,
0.29605355858802795,
-0.46531742811203003,
-0.9153827428817749,
0.2423270344734192,
-0.5127537846565247,
0.7260041832923889,
-0.024630993604660034,
-0.518325924873352,
0.3146815896034241,
-0.4840084910392761,
-0.26596593856811523,
0.12209397554397583,
-0.1512001007795334,
-0.23191243410110474,
-0.048914387822151184,
-0.11109735816717148,
0.23151929676532745,
-0.1960417628288269,
-0.3834139108657837,
0.24269306659698486,
-0.563660740852356,
0.5554684996604919,
0.9735477566719055,
0.26884520053863525,
0.25246208906173706,
-0.30454277992248535,
0.6061658263206482,
-0.17924772202968597,
0.09523666650056839,
-0.035354577004909515,
-0.32517895102500916,
-0.5680260062217712,
-0.21417362987995148,
0.005538121331483126,
0.46029189229011536,
-0.884865403175354,
0.2881792485713959,
-0.05176560953259468,
-0.2360227257013321,
-0.5131930112838745,
0.327498197555542,
0.24673974514007568,
0.3176434636116028,
0.4891631603240967,
-0.254535436630249,
-0.42779311537742615,
-0.7548450827598572,
-0.5140228867530823,
-0.12166164815425873,
0.026002921164035797,
0.0748177021741867,
0.5339202284812927,
-0.5367379188537598,
0.45682668685913086,
-0.48871666193008423,
-0.516991913318634,
-0.2919154763221741,
0.17639829218387604,
0.2192676067352295,
0.3878442347049713,
0.13109980523586273,
-0.4555531442165375,
0.21153301000595093,
-0.39829710125923157,
-0.5358868837356567,
-0.3247602581977844,
-0.4422614574432373,
-0.0456681028008461,
0.37439030408859253,
0.8731015920639038,
-0.6634687185287476,
0.630419135093689,
0.4482206702232361,
-0.5272789001464844,
0.7593469023704529,
-0.4132632613182068,
0.1342262625694275,
-0.5825127959251404,
-0.22572478652000427,
-0.21727725863456726,
-0.35028576850891113,
-0.44882556796073914,
0.18518614768981934,
0.02206600457429886,
-0.03859177604317665,
-0.34610292315483093,
0.5126430988311768,
-0.47197791934013367,
-0.11774115264415741,
-0.5947913527488708,
0.2567543685436249,
-0.10647178441286087,
0.6047832369804382,
-0.1384250670671463,
0.5871731638908386,
0.26341378688812256,
-0.6136577725410461,
0.23461401462554932,
0.1273769736289978,
-0.2757478654384613,
0.16730022430419922,
-0.4028799831867218,
0.5291531085968018,
-0.24632558226585388,
0.3302178978919983,
-0.8010666370391846,
-0.11457028985023499,
0.5769108533859253,
-0.19715678691864014,
0.36388400197029114,
-0.08952099084854126,
-0.6493083834648132,
-0.32224273681640625,
-0.571807324886322,
0.018878458067774773,
0.37917935848236084,
-0.785940408706665,
0.4916049540042877,
0.29609739780426025,
0.06817925721406937,
-0.3260311186313629,
-0.7797719836235046,
0.5030759572982788,
-0.40426105260849,
-0.10884775966405869,
0.27614626288414,
-0.06303806602954865,
-0.1970263123512268,
-0.09646344184875488,
-0.005128609016537666,
0.15473857522010803,
0.09416399896144867,
0.3259052634239197,
0.3215676248073578,
0.22913074493408203,
-0.09573978185653687,
0.1023237332701683,
-0.021550698205828667,
0.2661886513233185,
-0.2727850079536438,
0.8337022066116333,
-0.010746806859970093,
-0.4531177282333374,
-0.4621794819831848,
0.08711230754852295,
0.6536509990692139,
-0.055179085582494736,
0.5713534951210022,
0.40447261929512024,
-0.5486934781074524,
-0.47923213243484497,
-0.46737462282180786,
-0.9604161381721497,
-0.5147569179534912,
0.6021707057952881,
-0.34959858655929565,
-1.069053292274475,
0.4816873073577881,
0.13499610126018524,
-0.15577617287635803,
-0.07508498430252075,
0.4771631956100464,
0.11356741935014725,
0.8271268606185913,
0.48396074771881104,
-0.22275696694850922,
0.4544529616832733,
-0.14390073716640472,
0.5078759789466858,
-0.9010426998138428,
-0.11010324954986572,
-0.31076863408088684,
-0.42838427424430847,
-0.5864642262458801,
-0.34858834743499756,
0.3176664412021637,
0.17727617919445038,
-0.15651853382587433,
0.18488797545433044,
-0.42550185322761536,
0.6571017503738403,
0.3373166620731354,
0.5017393231391907,
0.40091824531555176,
-0.004700545687228441,
-0.025580231100320816,
-0.16851107776165009,
-0.3172435760498047,
-0.42279016971588135,
0.9661464095115662,
0.33370262384414673,
0.9044240713119507,
-0.015273657627403736,
0.8532102108001709,
0.2876111567020416,
0.34788474440574646,
-0.6689015030860901,
0.8362265229225159,
-0.05187153443694115,
-0.2973056435585022,
-0.5427787899971008,
-0.26937738060951233,
-0.8422716856002808,
0.5783733129501343,
-0.07265102118253708,
-0.9727111458778381,
-0.0014353807782754302,
0.272138386964798,
-0.33582860231399536,
0.6634916663169861,
-0.6350873112678528,
0.640221893787384,
-0.04018109664320946,
-0.4609762728214264,
-0.5862561464309692,
-0.4241692125797272,
0.7575446367263794,
-0.2559775412082672,
0.30602365732192993,
0.15687619149684906,
0.23145551979541779,
0.5193929076194763,
-0.40451815724372864,
1.1027991771697998,
-0.2798601984977722,
-0.2809526026248932,
-0.015557474456727505,
0.5046184659004211,
0.767622709274292,
0.23322808742523193,
0.15110905468463898,
0.039780955761671066,
-0.23237748444080353,
-0.16317659616470337,
-0.8362704515457153,
1.124293565750122,
-0.622441828250885,
-0.9644279479980469,
-0.4829053282737732,
-0.30916744470596313,
-0.19822831451892853,
0.08170418441295624,
0.1018901839852333,
0.21108806133270264,
0.03745494782924652,
-0.2595057785511017,
0.6787766218185425,
-0.46648961305618286,
0.41364961862564087,
0.37480273842811584,
-0.8285858631134033,
-0.36547785997390747,
0.8018079996109009,
0.05663590505719185,
0.21442291140556335,
0.016417020931839943,
0.3159344792366028,
-0.26135432720184326,
-0.6079063415527344,
-0.30724671483039856,
0.4979011118412018,
-0.6532105803489685,
0.02029743604362011,
-0.6546732187271118,
-0.33792880177497864,
-0.24817074835300446,
-0.02886074036359787,
-0.2282315045595169,
-0.09602555632591248,
-0.3007369637489319,
-0.18598343431949615,
0.3060988187789917,
0.8082430958747864,
-0.03443482518196106,
0.11190864443778992,
-0.5357126593589783,
0.5374019742012024,
0.4681684672832489,
0.44973063468933105,
0.03739161044359207,
-0.945219874382019,
-0.040332138538360596,
-0.16980743408203125,
-0.23884308338165283,
-1.0532374382019043,
0.4628598690032959,
0.03527999669313431,
0.24737194180488586,
0.38180387020111084,
0.06272188574075699,
0.7484737634658813,
-0.6146345734596252,
0.7005952596664429,
-0.14401760697364807,
-0.9928973913192749,
0.3512929081916809,
-0.17160865664482117,
0.32625657320022583,
0.4186354875564575,
-0.0016062670620158315,
-0.6933261752128601,
-0.7836154699325562,
-0.3266323208808899,
-0.755547046661377,
0.614708423614502,
0.014475272968411446,
0.3766610026359558,
0.023527905344963074,
0.6611663103103638,
0.20003168284893036,
0.20967109501361847,
-0.8015468120574951,
0.0034733174834400415,
-0.3671204745769501,
0.30370914936065674,
-0.17497475445270538,
-0.31403684616088867,
-0.0009528431110084057,
-0.5346592664718628,
0.8365174531936646,
0.08088777959346771,
0.09722103923559189,
0.30804112553596497,
-0.23836594820022583,
-0.09076741337776184,
0.20384027063846588,
0.7419499158859253,
0.4863816797733307,
-0.23548340797424316,
0.46499893069267273,
0.10958672314882278,
-0.6879030466079712,
-0.05046916753053665,
-0.11405529826879501,
-0.33249467611312866,
-0.1618136614561081,
0.3123517632484436,
0.9805463552474976,
0.38945484161376953,
-0.7683680057525635,
0.0731680765748024,
0.05247122421860695,
-0.26145175099372864,
-0.390117883682251,
0.1115887463092804,
-0.14504049718379974,
0.41235822439193726,
0.11028771102428436,
-0.03345419093966484,
0.0012318127555772662,
-0.758979082107544,
0.5140846967697144,
0.33113083243370056,
-0.5381200313568115,
-0.37758585810661316,
0.764831006526947,
-0.3307601511478424,
-0.5117635130882263,
0.6914986371994019,
-0.16371653974056244,
-0.828473687171936,
0.15900787711143494,
0.8096825480461121,
1.1618504524230957,
-0.21268309652805328,
0.3575034439563751,
0.22420167922973633,
0.614190399646759,
-0.19008998572826385,
0.14179106056690216,
0.22779437899589539,
-0.9334901571273804,
-0.4305512309074402,
-0.4535142183303833,
-0.1532483845949173,
0.6325888633728027,
-0.3516564667224884,
0.23294153809547424,
-0.5986723303794861,
0.023859549313783646,
-0.27265802025794983,
-0.3244937062263489,
-0.29786595702171326,
-0.06108444929122925,
0.13835687935352325,
0.5230721235275269,
-0.6512850522994995,
1.179757833480835,
0.4091340899467468,
-0.16895551979541779,
-0.6592056751251221,
0.553631603717804,
0.06376317143440247,
-0.7584158182144165,
0.37743130326271057,
0.1744012087583542,
-0.5469666123390198,
0.14253057539463043,
-0.8118208050727844,
-0.39919281005859375,
0.647864043712616,
0.36404678225517273,
-0.5921894311904907,
0.1915898621082306,
-0.040076956152915955,
0.4604134261608124,
-0.09129799157381058,
-0.10130082815885544,
1.0531800985336304,
0.6206797957420349,
-0.07300188392400742,
-0.7232221364974976,
0.22747252881526947,
-0.09623908251523972,
-0.017144184559583664,
0.2058107554912567,
-0.29285499453544617,
0.7128331065177917,
-0.4852783977985382,
0.005312570836395025,
-0.11678166687488556,
0.32666346430778503,
0.40938180685043335,
-0.06733929365873337,
0.744421660900116,
0.605126142501831,
0.7828586101531982,
0.13574616611003876,
0.8981911540031433,
-0.036047063767910004,
0.31888675689697266,
1.3177410364151,
-0.48828306794166565,
0.9405749440193176,
0.9439230561256409,
0.11040783673524857,
0.3527233600616455,
0.4291639029979706,
-0.04883787781000137,
0.8578268885612488,
0.5607662796974182,
-0.17772817611694336,
-0.24897027015686035,
0.3370608687400818,
-0.06138962134718895,
0.3546130657196045,
0.3160882890224457,
-0.034262169152498245,
-0.19627365469932556,
0.4466990530490875,
0.34163978695869446,
0.3029203712940216,
-0.29406479001045227,
0.6524254083633423,
0.22947292029857635,
-0.7243946194648743,
0.922931969165802,
0.06985761970281601,
0.5976425409317017,
-0.31196919083595276,
-0.20278945565223694,
-0.2005046159029007,
0.25504007935523987,
-0.09348352253437042,
-0.5673447847366333,
0.45250773429870605,
-0.0828048512339592,
0.12458179891109467,
-0.0931331142783165,
0.6150290966033936,
-0.5054611563682556,
-0.2576819956302643,
0.7055443525314331,
0.021883441135287285,
0.26063263416290283,
-0.4252776503562927,
-0.4829558730125427,
0.3503425121307373,
0.14945049583911896,
-0.3714374899864197,
0.24755525588989258,
0.27809903025627136,
-0.0934562236070633,
0.760891318321228,
0.5738629698753357,
0.43249988555908203,
0.06395257264375687,
0.4357573688030243,
1.0229523181915283,
-0.9591036438941956,
-0.47234204411506653,
-1.1104419231414795,
0.0179780013859272,
0.11372806876897812,
-0.06257292628288269,
0.49373602867126465,
0.2853379547595978,
0.9679524898529053,
-0.11377880722284317,
0.7858994603157043,
0.36824825406074524,
0.36313265562057495,
-0.8689987063407898,
1.0660984516143799,
-0.42333051562309265,
0.8312238454818726,
-0.3768772482872009,
-0.9437694549560547,
-0.4851090908050537,
0.6351101398468018,
-0.4891526699066162,
-0.017379989847540855,
0.9661211967468262,
1.1877501010894775,
0.13128827512264252,
0.06917273253202438,
0.5330378413200378,
0.7394891381263733,
0.4789990186691284,
0.4884149730205536,
0.808724582195282,
-0.22383958101272583,
0.4772643744945526,
-0.2701305150985718,
-0.1377640813589096,
-0.20516908168792725,
-0.6044309139251709,
-1.2373038530349731,
-0.4232995808124542,
-0.10837411880493164,
-0.6692609190940857,
0.28925395011901855,
0.8222529888153076,
0.3616388440132141,
-0.9134239554405212,
-0.11134666204452515,
-0.19697634875774384,
0.2736991345882416,
-0.18501217663288116,
-0.18478931486606598,
0.2935909032821655,
-0.29772040247917175,
-0.5584350228309631,
0.5085946917533875,
0.3955637216567993,
0.04721332713961601,
-0.7188815474510193,
-0.2795802056789398,
-0.022809455171227455,
0.048410844057798386,
0.4067510664463043,
0.15106740593910217,
-1.0004733800888062,
-0.6663041710853577,
-0.19004850089550018,
0.06432103365659714,
0.015492304228246212,
0.9614084959030151,
-1.017712950706482,
0.3467857539653778,
0.21150809526443481,
0.565329372882843,
0.6079867482185364,
-0.26634541153907776,
0.43845152854919434,
-0.3522833585739136,
0.2753894627094269,
0.3227697014808655,
0.2759826183319092,
0.30945128202438354,
-0.45661497116088867,
0.09226640313863754,
0.2968427240848541,
-0.5049130320549011,
-0.9450719356536865,
0.36841249465942383,
-0.595782995223999,
-0.6120109558105469,
1.0505958795547485,
0.3437820076942444,
-0.18728718161582947,
-0.27095937728881836,
-0.3981846570968628,
0.11175192147493362,
-0.21982572972774506,
1.4625509977340698,
0.8066636919975281,
0.10180271416902542,
-0.37983375787734985,
-0.8175386190414429,
0.6259332895278931,
0.3432977795600891,
-0.6476675271987915,
0.20789963006973267,
0.386391818523407,
0.22090698778629303,
-0.289365291595459,
0.6277233362197876,
-0.34587913751602173,
-0.09402348846197128,
-0.3724627196788788,
0.03344060108065605,
-0.07709095627069473,
-0.5140077471733093,
-0.6003623008728027,
0.09249510616064072,
-0.028411556035280228,
-0.07963152229785919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10812v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10812v1 | Exploring Hybrid Question Answering via Program-based Prompting | 2024-02-16T16:35:41 | 2024-02-16T16:35:41 | Qi Shi, Han Cui, Haofeng Wang, Qingfu Zhu, Wanxiang Che, Ting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Question answering over heterogeneous data requires reasoning over diverse
sources of data, which is challenging due to the large scale of information and
organic coupling of heterogeneous data. Various approaches have been proposed
to address these challenges. One approach involves training specialized
retrievers to select relevant information, thereby reducing the input length.
Another approach is to transform diverse modalities of data into a single
modality, simplifying the task difficulty and enabling more straightforward
processing. In this paper, we propose HProPro, a novel program-based prompting
framework for the hybrid question answering task. HProPro follows the code
generation and execution paradigm. In addition, HProPro integrates various
functions to tackle the hybrid reasoning scenario. Specifically, HProPro
contains function declaration and function implementation to perform hybrid
information-seeking over data from various sources and modalities, which
enables reasoning over such data without training specialized retrievers or
performing modal transformations. Experimental results on two typical hybrid
question answering benchmarks HybridQA and MultiModalQA demonstrate the
effectiveness of HProPro: it surpasses all baseline systems and achieves the
best performances in the few-shot settings on both datasets. | [
-0.4354030191898346,
-1.0108722448349,
0.6061966419219971,
0.18295025825500488,
-0.26427891850471497,
0.552512526512146,
-0.2589512765407562,
-0.3692818284034729,
0.109891876578331,
0.13527657091617584,
-0.6560852527618408,
-0.19362367689609528,
0.03291649743914604,
0.2753850221633911,
0.06546877324581146,
1.019461989402771,
-0.044083815068006516,
0.0773487389087677,
-0.35540300607681274,
-0.2544093728065491,
-0.5684970617294312,
-0.11957442760467529,
-0.11716678738594055,
-0.26850196719169617,
0.46330249309539795,
0.5753311514854431,
0.6617065668106079,
0.297387957572937,
0.036301352083683014,
0.23794019222259521,
0.18119730055332184,
0.39454466104507446,
-0.5134426951408386,
0.07799593359231949,
-0.13587011396884918,
-0.45572158694267273,
0.11233582347631454,
-0.15764330327510834,
0.5294779539108276,
0.5935816168785095,
-0.20528213679790497,
0.32860472798347473,
-0.06505385041236877,
0.021526610478758812,
-0.7552009224891663,
-0.28313928842544556,
-0.6689379811286926,
0.2003219574689865,
-0.05650140345096588,
-0.7771685719490051,
-0.29084646701812744,
-0.6127589344978333,
-0.0554727278649807,
-0.8189737200737,
0.09397953748703003,
0.33245187997817993,
0.5278506875038147,
0.27303481101989746,
-0.31375107169151306,
-0.0116663109511137,
-0.8549172878265381,
0.7816532850265503,
-0.3631097674369812,
-0.025929423049092293,
0.36850863695144653,
0.5185622572898865,
0.060239583253860474,
-0.3528701364994049,
-0.8531942963600159,
-0.24555639922618866,
-0.02178986743092537,
0.2481185346841812,
0.0752784013748169,
0.06739316135644913,
0.27765923738479614,
0.6720917820930481,
-0.7970519661903381,
-0.13028165698051453,
-0.5308457612991333,
-0.4780240058898926,
0.2101077288389206,
0.24179331958293915,
0.2345002293586731,
-0.3931514322757721,
-0.3856922686100006,
-0.19543835520744324,
-0.4261527359485626,
0.15891295671463013,
0.3291091322898865,
0.17481182515621185,
-0.13697683811187744,
0.6912229061126709,
-0.03609945997595787,
0.8264452815055847,
0.07293190807104111,
-0.1784786432981491,
0.16802510619163513,
-0.3477761149406433,
-0.2787119150161743,
-0.20125839114189148,
0.7451104521751404,
0.07158797979354858,
-0.08420799672603607,
0.020697928965091705,
0.16123634576797485,
0.05900919809937477,
0.012197298929095268,
-0.23716026544570923,
-0.13822606205940247,
0.5380591750144958,
-0.4973391890525818,
-0.25431346893310547,
0.1946321576833725,
-1.2185500860214233,
-0.29627373814582825,
-0.06205236166715622,
0.5739881992340088,
-0.5118817090988159,
-0.17399956285953522,
0.0480804517865181,
-0.26263752579689026,
0.4967030882835388,
0.48019641637802124,
-0.483069509267807,
0.24048581719398499,
0.6802838444709778,
0.4526248872280121,
-0.2101266086101532,
-0.4119807183742523,
-1.0755246877670288,
0.20988404750823975,
0.02926291525363922,
0.7886388897895813,
-0.852955162525177,
-0.46992364525794983,
-0.138398215174675,
-0.16928477585315704,
-0.4584788978099823,
-0.669142484664917,
0.3972679376602173,
-0.3964979648590088,
0.673068642616272,
-0.386146605014801,
-0.28487205505371094,
0.03541292995214462,
0.3102177381515503,
-0.3619121313095093,
1.6103942394256592,
0.3935871124267578,
-0.903515100479126,
0.21078702807426453,
-0.4973876178264618,
-0.6063494086265564,
0.43507492542266846,
-0.5769965648651123,
-0.03521919623017311,
-0.13986364006996155,
0.2544514238834381,
-0.15779614448547363,
-0.486049622297287,
0.16406039893627167,
-0.18855515122413635,
-0.5149136781692505,
0.0057007791474461555,
-0.13739441335201263,
0.5997036099433899,
0.1324203461408615,
-0.38527458906173706,
0.20377133786678314,
-0.4441319704055786,
0.3230159878730774,
0.02059469185769558,
-0.4613741636276245,
-0.38868045806884766,
-0.363079309463501,
-0.13047416508197784,
0.2725400924682617,
0.22902916371822357,
-0.7750572562217712,
0.23397167026996613,
0.07481271028518677,
0.2289968580007553,
0.4643113315105438,
0.07874520868062973,
0.2807183563709259,
-0.4753601551055908,
1.1132036447525024,
-0.3803809583187103,
0.1800766885280609,
-0.25316062569618225,
-0.7040213942527771,
-0.09650534391403198,
-0.22231647372245789,
-0.05383805185556412,
1.0845929384231567,
-1.1265114545822144,
0.09156211465597153,
0.23728878796100616,
-0.14279645681381226,
-0.629571795463562,
0.07946903258562088,
0.23963825404644012,
1.037853717803955,
0.4700463116168976,
0.34227776527404785,
-0.4845426678657532,
-0.5564104318618774,
0.051349200308322906,
-0.26764437556266785,
0.02291501685976982,
0.6454980969429016,
0.3233550786972046,
-0.022933518514037132,
0.8310893774032593,
-0.5531686544418335,
0.4357871115207672,
-0.6832000613212585,
0.392915278673172,
0.08608338236808777,
0.3707932233810425,
0.3374600410461426,
-1.0234214067459106,
-0.371509850025177,
0.20739242434501648,
-0.5496499538421631,
-0.10638776421546936,
-0.21050994098186493,
-0.1793445497751236,
-0.39598438143730164,
0.35290002822875977,
-0.5395897626876831,
0.20724955201148987,
0.546937882900238,
0.15827615559101105,
1.0079149007797241,
-0.443099707365036,
0.47193506360054016,
-0.9204719066619873,
0.4738636016845703,
-0.319051057100296,
-0.06635314226150513,
-0.3575320243835449,
-0.07747619599103928,
-0.023138422518968582,
-0.5578615069389343,
-0.37802669405937195,
0.3276459276676178,
-0.25968825817108154,
-0.041432492434978485,
-0.11213672906160355,
-0.2832881808280945,
0.09523579478263855,
0.28162598609924316,
0.07085581123828888,
1.0610980987548828,
0.5668784976005554,
-0.5205413699150085,
0.43010345101356506,
0.38106122612953186,
0.1398119330406189,
0.4753243625164032,
-0.870368242263794,
0.3133912980556488,
-0.27971816062927246,
0.4484386146068573,
-0.9885950088500977,
-0.4423025846481323,
0.255210816860199,
-0.20661740005016327,
-0.17930425703525543,
-0.11756965517997742,
-0.40303313732147217,
-0.9114116430282593,
-0.5499869585037231,
0.7007679343223572,
0.425733357667923,
-0.5268259644508362,
0.6345685720443726,
0.06683619320392609,
-0.17556996643543243,
-0.4969234764575958,
-0.42845436930656433,
-0.1654530018568039,
-0.24247227609157562,
-0.4567129909992218,
0.44258448481559753,
-0.3078259229660034,
-0.10713676363229752,
-0.07075474411249161,
0.026359854266047478,
-0.20137614011764526,
-0.44433850049972534,
-0.02827560156583786,
0.7170568108558655,
-0.2369113564491272,
-0.03536022827029228,
0.2688257694244385,
0.057301394641399384,
-0.17491617798805237,
-0.08399458974599838,
0.6470139622688293,
-0.13234907388687134,
-0.30516940355300903,
-0.4000130891799927,
0.6917505264282227,
0.6019223928451538,
-0.550016462802887,
0.46869271993637085,
0.5311713814735413,
-0.03622153401374817,
-0.36637651920318604,
-0.3437039852142334,
-0.22164200246334076,
-0.4899328351020813,
-0.08662845939397812,
-0.286942720413208,
-0.9120547771453857,
0.35587820410728455,
-0.11379879713058472,
-0.08877027034759521,
-0.0815228745341301,
0.5974183678627014,
-0.23458020389080048,
1.002261996269226,
0.46611014008522034,
0.050739508122205734,
0.34985145926475525,
-0.036567557603120804,
0.14282624423503876,
-0.4920926094055176,
-0.4293854832649231,
-0.45395663380622864,
-0.08091381937265396,
-0.36322253942489624,
-0.7642002701759338,
0.8128508925437927,
-0.16488862037658691,
0.071272112429142,
0.38741663098335266,
-0.6051228642463684,
0.5110486149787903,
0.6374664306640625,
0.22260966897010803,
0.30690401792526245,
-0.09005793184041977,
-0.2980497479438782,
0.10356065630912781,
-1.017119288444519,
-0.05858774855732918,
0.5863428711891174,
-0.07444781810045242,
0.7982186675071716,
-0.43717923760414124,
0.6154484748840332,
0.27643460035324097,
0.0283803828060627,
-0.687960684299469,
0.5611258149147034,
0.25806695222854614,
-0.44567999243736267,
-0.22419202327728271,
-0.7330151200294495,
-0.7048999667167664,
0.188288152217865,
-0.30424952507019043,
-0.6242508888244629,
0.23771290481090546,
0.5534298419952393,
-0.7347167730331421,
0.1937107890844345,
-0.4576338827610016,
0.8063355088233948,
-0.35531485080718994,
-0.3805491626262665,
-0.2184859812259674,
-0.7642869353294373,
0.3735488951206207,
0.4107418954372406,
0.07013729959726334,
0.06927397102117538,
0.015847910195589066,
0.29434671998023987,
-0.3286702036857605,
0.3886987864971161,
-0.10118526965379715,
0.1291418969631195,
0.4598078727722168,
0.2932173013687134,
0.40221041440963745,
0.1974910944700241,
-0.18425393104553223,
-0.5991261601448059,
0.2512362003326416,
-0.3835464119911194,
-0.578711986541748,
0.5148718953132629,
-0.20690937340259552,
-0.32388097047805786,
-0.22515085339546204,
-0.9544163942337036,
-0.6149205565452576,
0.04334532842040062,
0.593522310256958,
0.3893224596977234,
0.07752524316310883,
-0.04658767580986023,
0.7291274070739746,
-0.6076039671897888,
0.1289357990026474,
0.17047534883022308,
0.009845981374382973,
-0.46919921040534973,
0.9280980229377747,
-0.5552118420600891,
0.3255670964717865,
0.5252360701560974,
0.5728536248207092,
-0.3458014726638794,
-0.15000878274440765,
-0.7336350679397583,
0.37597668170928955,
-0.25914040207862854,
-0.07415413856506348,
-0.5122275352478027,
0.1681772768497467,
-0.22843745350837708,
-0.20883026719093323,
-0.02768321894109249,
-0.24711686372756958,
0.07200775295495987,
0.09276872128248215,
0.3438236713409424,
0.2071485072374344,
-0.03646085411310196,
-0.15337136387825012,
-0.7216158509254456,
0.6543557047843933,
0.6102608442306519,
0.04284759610891342,
-0.1279304474592209,
-0.11770755797624588,
0.20082513988018036,
-0.18532633781433105,
0.08273455500602722,
-1.0088086128234863,
-0.022412585094571114,
0.14878436923027039,
0.6571135520935059,
0.034597426652908325,
0.22747555375099182,
0.6350669264793396,
-0.1656518578529358,
0.5597650408744812,
0.08347971737384796,
-0.6268107891082764,
0.7989541292190552,
-0.6882062554359436,
0.4772149324417114,
1.0795446634292603,
0.44737404584884644,
-0.6000772714614868,
-0.1666300743818283,
-0.4141785204410553,
-0.3980863094329834,
0.5604719519615173,
-0.14882054924964905,
0.08521551638841629,
0.14683860540390015,
0.10814139246940613,
0.5183014869689941,
0.4799816906452179,
-0.402319073677063,
-0.0120680071413517,
-0.22007478773593903,
-0.09330300986766815,
0.44569242000579834,
0.4036998450756073,
-0.26138752698898315,
-0.5036140084266663,
0.3286915421485901,
-0.4623820185661316,
0.34128156304359436,
0.1930931657552719,
-0.0431070514023304,
-0.1582280844449997,
0.4577452540397644,
0.3654777705669403,
0.5112032890319824,
-0.0732506513595581,
-0.022759396582841873,
0.09000828117132187,
-0.35814225673675537,
-0.012660777196288109,
0.3044290244579315,
-0.2713152766227722,
-0.20624959468841553,
0.11068549752235413,
0.45755478739738464,
0.09219631552696228,
-1.1062482595443726,
0.39413610100746155,
0.18474744260311127,
-0.014939457178115845,
0.27692386507987976,
0.1269948035478592,
-0.16174204647541046,
-0.27480068802833557,
0.6093866229057312,
-0.142969012260437,
0.21175354719161987,
-0.8457332253456116,
0.10132117569446564,
0.253141850233078,
-0.08381932228803635,
-0.2839895486831665,
0.5233783721923828,
0.14253757894039154,
-0.03114468976855278,
0.5963934063911438,
-0.19749414920806885,
-0.758621335029602,
0.5309880971908569,
0.665006697177887,
0.31837448477745056,
-0.12850265204906464,
0.8359988927841187,
0.28780651092529297,
0.06812504678964615,
0.11823097616434097,
0.6957557201385498,
-0.5503957271575928,
-0.5123178362846375,
-0.45803070068359375,
-0.369653582572937,
-0.8499553203582764,
0.2980155646800995,
-0.5237712264060974,
-0.04491883143782616,
-0.5959010124206543,
0.3362608850002289,
-0.10213391482830048,
-0.3976691663265228,
-0.2547489106655121,
0.1013900637626648,
0.22811004519462585,
0.9187384247779846,
-0.8542571067810059,
0.45502153038978577,
0.8538085222244263,
-0.28108885884284973,
-0.9307450652122498,
0.14386387169361115,
0.029268937185406685,
-0.6617192625999451,
-0.040811687707901,
-0.03892417252063751,
-0.2303534299135208,
-0.16659384965896606,
-0.5327799320220947,
-0.21194957196712494,
0.7897747755050659,
0.4208272695541382,
-0.031485047191381454,
-0.14555759727954865,
0.3389328420162201,
0.4313853979110718,
-0.2814904451370239,
0.10086274147033691,
0.4588777720928192,
0.6381980776786804,
0.3855363130569458,
-1.0546305179595947,
-0.049279943108558655,
-0.35340097546577454,
-0.3078531324863434,
0.24528302252292633,
-0.4003640115261078,
0.8309094905853271,
-0.2981031835079193,
0.00017151034262496978,
0.05167388170957565,
0.3213093876838684,
0.6440907716751099,
0.5808424949645996,
0.5381096005439758,
0.21650028228759766,
1.003339171409607,
0.21388503909111023,
1.1234327554702759,
-0.09014414995908737,
0.10284777730703354,
1.1430069208145142,
-0.53687584400177,
0.6360341310501099,
0.6381009817123413,
-0.15592126548290253,
0.7900999188423157,
0.357544481754303,
0.10338668525218964,
0.3088797926902771,
-0.16149555146694183,
-0.5649367570877075,
-0.38924553990364075,
-0.22756099700927734,
-0.3224618434906006,
0.4182991683483124,
0.11082004755735397,
0.10968952625989914,
-0.4981467127799988,
0.3522847890853882,
-0.14986814558506012,
0.3393824100494385,
-0.21815790235996246,
0.3120248019695282,
-0.17271198332309723,
-1.0841246843338013,
0.4904649257659912,
-0.2109483927488327,
0.7037283778190613,
-0.848388135433197,
-0.20536382496356964,
-0.0819782018661499,
-0.2344321608543396,
-0.2981264591217041,
-0.8136034607887268,
0.2874012887477875,
-0.08371581882238388,
-0.016944533213973045,
-0.16422460973262787,
0.7362688779830933,
-0.4055159091949463,
-0.2979598641395569,
0.05541260913014412,
0.8479960560798645,
-0.30709967017173767,
-0.019481826573610306,
-0.9025923609733582,
0.0548250637948513,
-0.05661456659436226,
0.25180912017822266,
-0.013528509065508842,
0.23735061287879944,
-0.21843263506889343,
0.4470506012439728,
0.7904852628707886,
-0.07418904453516006,
0.150313138961792,
0.1361110359430313,
0.7956873178482056,
-0.4272172152996063,
-0.8260769248008728,
-0.13061220943927765,
0.2607153058052063,
-0.2037227302789688,
-0.5847796201705933,
0.846997857093811,
0.7084325551986694,
0.4018600285053253,
-0.11221010982990265,
0.8375357389450073,
-0.6099222898483276,
0.6219163537025452,
-0.18161232769489288,
-0.05834130197763443,
-0.3548908233642578,
0.015643909573554993,
-0.26727861166000366,
-0.7293087244033813,
0.0622837170958519,
0.39868223667144775,
-0.708314061164856,
0.012609662488102913,
0.5861395597457886,
0.9157976508140564,
-0.37889528274536133,
0.28258922696113586,
0.009547727182507515,
-0.2644134759902954,
-0.20759528875350952,
0.6356024146080017,
1.1914311647415161,
0.05080946534872055,
0.8242287635803223,
-0.37520933151245117,
-0.37670615315437317,
-0.12640480697155,
-0.6365208029747009,
-0.5446416735649109,
-0.3647562861442566,
-0.14332063496112823,
-0.35132890939712524,
-0.0329897366464138,
0.93738853931427,
0.8411663770675659,
-0.7356142997741699,
-0.09523291140794754,
-0.19060811400413513,
-0.025307996198534966,
-0.37626978754997253,
-0.3438013195991516,
0.08843863755464554,
0.19106848537921906,
-0.4131377339363098,
0.7824253439903259,
0.4708077609539032,
-0.17038504779338837,
-0.07899720221757889,
-0.0869252011179924,
-0.20118825137615204,
0.01887790486216545,
0.28404852747917175,
1.091209053993225,
-0.22218868136405945,
-0.13613496720790863,
0.2987711429595947,
0.014706249348819256,
0.3882805109024048,
1.2578092813491821,
-1.071667194366455,
0.297441691160202,
0.8233401775360107,
0.7318122386932373,
0.6515563726425171,
0.4496306777000427,
0.6130061149597168,
-0.4621778428554535,
0.13686344027519226,
0.6683540344238281,
-0.10937941819429398,
0.4057375192642212,
-0.6634870767593384,
0.030733168125152588,
0.2655162513256073,
-0.2820015847682953,
-0.7488618493080139,
0.1888892501592636,
-1.1832005977630615,
-0.2470751255750656,
0.9630236029624939,
0.30474022030830383,
-0.3210308253765106,
-0.30251383781433105,
-0.5457648634910583,
-0.0882020890712738,
-0.35445988178253174,
0.459664911031723,
0.0159342959523201,
-0.6801849603652954,
-0.33653172850608826,
-0.4838712811470032,
0.3892420530319214,
0.6235260367393494,
-1.2283518314361572,
-0.0500204972922802,
0.6684718728065491,
0.35398152470588684,
-0.039107710123062134,
0.7406214475631714,
-0.25367602705955505,
0.8950745463371277,
-0.03494315594434738,
-0.4788278341293335,
-0.11898685991764069,
-0.3380666673183441,
-0.23022249341011047,
0.3909183740615845,
-0.36035922169685364,
-0.043827421963214874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10811v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10811v2 | Quantifying the Persona Effect in LLM Simulations | 2024-02-16T16:35:35 | 2024-06-17T11:06:57 | Tiancheng Hu, Nigel Collier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable promise in simulating
human language and behavior. This study investigates how integrating persona
variables-demographic, social, and behavioral factors-impacts LLMs' ability to
simulate diverse perspectives. We find that persona variables account for <10%
variance in annotations in existing subjective NLP datasets. Nonetheless,
incorporating persona variables via prompting in LLMs provides modest but
statistically significant improvements. Persona prompting is most effective in
samples where many annotators disagree, but their disagreements are relatively
minor. Notably, we find a linear relationship in our setting: the stronger the
correlation between persona variables and human annotations, the more accurate
the LLM predictions are using persona prompting. In a zero-shot setting, a
powerful 70b model with persona prompting captures 81% of the annotation
variance achievable by linear regression trained on ground truth annotations.
However, for most subjective NLP datasets, where persona variables have limited
explanatory power, the benefits of persona prompting are limited. | [
-0.5246466994285583,
-0.5919528007507324,
0.9671619534492493,
0.7826481461524963,
0.02443702705204487,
0.03403538465499878,
-0.171059250831604,
-0.45101475715637207,
0.26833030581474304,
0.45834654569625854,
-0.5951370596885681,
-0.30354490876197815,
-0.3827512264251709,
0.10006318986415863,
0.054887834936380386,
0.789125382900238,
0.38417521119117737,
0.26422592997550964,
-0.4886714220046997,
0.1832350343465805,
-0.480891615152359,
-0.900343120098114,
-0.552962064743042,
-0.7720422148704529,
0.9644534587860107,
0.10198000073432922,
0.4646036922931671,
0.10070633143186569,
0.3200688362121582,
0.25762560963630676,
0.02959892340004444,
-0.060457635670900345,
-0.43574291467666626,
0.2628597021102905,
-0.2456769198179245,
-0.6901828050613403,
-0.3269258141517639,
0.35155147314071655,
0.7403197288513184,
1.003859043121338,
0.09852501004934311,
0.16363288462162018,
0.07668650150299072,
0.43395304679870605,
-0.5075605511665344,
0.21738754212856293,
-0.19790267944335938,
0.11755126714706421,
-0.27853694558143616,
-0.284494549036026,
-0.6187019944190979,
-0.28951483964920044,
0.3870386779308319,
-0.22990161180496216,
-0.20764286816120148,
0.15310817956924438,
0.4408656656742096,
0.23075661063194275,
-0.45075955986976624,
0.03945578634738922,
-1.0836882591247559,
0.7925111651420593,
-0.6853266358375549,
0.061601631343364716,
0.3608141243457794,
0.07041602581739426,
-0.20942360162734985,
-0.2522817552089691,
-0.5522011518478394,
-0.2447470873594284,
-0.2064548283815384,
0.1021818295121193,
-0.15561307966709137,
0.17019763588905334,
0.6087280511856079,
-0.03383341059088707,
-0.06403429806232452,
0.2702837288379669,
-0.2166716754436493,
-0.03637205809354782,
0.5285090804100037,
0.3589029610157013,
0.14293107390403748,
-0.608302652835846,
-0.1343543529510498,
0.0017361989011988044,
-0.5978536605834961,
0.2554849684238434,
0.6567750573158264,
0.34727296233177185,
-0.10310464352369308,
0.6785778999328613,
0.025883356109261513,
0.5246262550354004,
0.3377453088760376,
-0.5055259466171265,
0.24040819704532623,
0.04594412446022034,
-0.15146765112876892,
-0.3165009319782257,
0.7908812165260315,
0.46074771881103516,
0.5332656502723694,
-0.11994724720716476,
0.03750842437148094,
0.018069177865982056,
0.2290429174900055,
-0.6350160837173462,
-0.26193514466285706,
0.3273663818836212,
-0.2801852822303772,
-0.17655856907367706,
0.018428144976496696,
-0.9821339845657349,
-0.9632279872894287,
-0.537704348564148,
0.2051299512386322,
-0.46018728613853455,
-0.08623097836971283,
0.10186046361923218,
-0.07203789055347443,
0.6458210349082947,
0.6874380707740784,
-0.8516074419021606,
0.19115817546844482,
0.8200526833534241,
0.726356565952301,
-0.16148966550827026,
-0.28692367672920227,
-0.5493272542953491,
-0.023466622456908226,
-0.12349833548069,
0.908863365650177,
-0.727738618850708,
-0.5969144701957703,
0.03247397392988205,
-0.45207732915878296,
-0.1922539621591568,
-0.5375352501869202,
0.23324711620807648,
-0.03184373304247856,
0.23394310474395752,
-0.8483048677444458,
-0.5878443121910095,
0.18499653041362762,
0.13619141280651093,
-0.4561450183391571,
0.8011341691017151,
0.10486595332622528,
-0.7555334568023682,
0.39551299810409546,
-0.42718973755836487,
-0.1825093924999237,
0.3122854232788086,
-0.45134779810905457,
0.021630391478538513,
0.3727622926235199,
0.2173711210489273,
0.758952260017395,
-0.12303514033555984,
0.46986958384513855,
-0.2809981107711792,
-0.3088960349559784,
0.818024218082428,
-0.17836695909500122,
0.7615723013877869,
-0.22117069363594055,
-0.23438715934753418,
-0.08857637643814087,
-0.4296770691871643,
-0.3450213074684143,
-0.10613217949867249,
-0.28055182099342346,
-0.3908812999725342,
-0.09201003611087799,
0.07059391587972641,
0.3725311756134033,
-0.03006564825773239,
-0.4774579703807831,
0.27450668811798096,
-0.21098127961158752,
-0.08576793223619461,
0.9078357815742493,
0.4352261424064636,
0.5362026691436768,
-0.4769541025161743,
0.8912248611450195,
-0.06793031841516495,
-0.053589656949043274,
-0.21622121334075928,
-0.8425999283790588,
-0.6387695670127869,
-0.5971410870552063,
0.2409987598657608,
0.5577540397644043,
-0.5829364061355591,
0.14974752068519592,
-0.17261585593223572,
-0.37091684341430664,
-0.3910994529724121,
-0.09799791127443314,
0.49045273661613464,
0.4179025888442993,
-0.1210913211107254,
-0.2384311854839325,
-0.5139760971069336,
-0.9743468165397644,
-0.40646177530288696,
-0.7596956491470337,
-0.46281957626342773,
0.700634241104126,
0.5081049203872681,
-0.002511544618755579,
0.9541088938713074,
-0.3338383436203003,
-0.1138928085565567,
-0.2983218729496002,
0.39885130524635315,
-0.04695116728544235,
0.3349846303462982,
0.8832424283027649,
-0.3905025124549866,
-0.5390275716781616,
-0.5770538449287415,
-0.6789358854293823,
-0.5557277798652649,
-0.43766266107559204,
-0.04626348242163658,
-0.18176105618476868,
0.2511099874973297,
-0.5823876857757568,
0.3205142319202423,
0.38763633370399475,
-0.3031429648399353,
0.7097606658935547,
-0.013926745392382145,
0.25821563601493835,
-0.7436254024505615,
0.05649184063076973,
0.6360172629356384,
-0.16766563057899475,
-0.7520899176597595,
0.051539503037929535,
-0.18280094861984253,
0.06357187777757645,
-0.5899007320404053,
0.6358259916305542,
-0.16849249601364136,
-0.23023688793182373,
-0.11714810878038406,
0.1589227169752121,
0.06639854609966278,
0.43454039096832275,
0.1563289314508438,
0.89658123254776,
0.3274109661579132,
-0.5716776251792908,
0.14316554367542267,
0.26364004611968994,
-0.24476614594459534,
1.0953625440597534,
-0.6770240068435669,
0.24022801220417023,
-0.5337480306625366,
0.4688064157962799,
-1.0824024677276611,
-0.5898157358169556,
0.3626922369003296,
-0.3321535587310791,
0.08006657660007477,
-0.03362578526139259,
-0.6743860840797424,
-0.26820430159568787,
-0.4433850347995758,
-0.002363350009545684,
0.5613033771514893,
-0.34184199571609497,
0.974270761013031,
0.35825788974761963,
-0.11742985993623734,
-0.18916554749011993,
-0.7252811789512634,
0.33089974522590637,
-0.508515477180481,
-0.3749695420265198,
0.24424153566360474,
-0.24098718166351318,
-0.7333655953407288,
-0.5909374356269836,
0.30647966265678406,
0.20189467072486877,
-0.07099933177232742,
0.5193972587585449,
0.38392579555511475,
0.14122821390628815,
-0.021841177716851234,
-0.19374263286590576,
0.04876051843166351,
0.5151344537734985,
-0.12454357743263245,
0.6701740026473999,
-0.20801158249378204,
-0.27093958854675293,
-0.6716411113739014,
0.20155984163284302,
0.37004518508911133,
0.029434282332658768,
0.9769687056541443,
0.3362310230731964,
-0.2528647780418396,
0.14369451999664307,
-0.7025671601295471,
-0.08670305460691452,
-0.4952099025249481,
0.04478314146399498,
-0.3324572741985321,
-0.7689152956008911,
0.7778398394584656,
-0.15622912347316742,
0.14650990068912506,
-0.07363210618495941,
0.44921600818634033,
-0.45682546496391296,
0.8046739101409912,
0.45175525546073914,
0.03982393816113472,
0.49401620030403137,
0.10578148812055588,
0.12726861238479614,
-1.1263096332550049,
-0.7379329800605774,
-0.521584689617157,
-0.5524774193763733,
-0.6678714752197266,
-0.6476587057113647,
0.1756407767534256,
-0.47104623913764954,
-0.09616262465715408,
-0.013707172125577927,
0.010236091911792755,
0.35437119007110596,
0.5266935229301453,
0.263938307762146,
0.05453868210315704,
-0.044353846460580826,
-0.005471722222864628,
-0.8382943868637085,
-0.21208840608596802,
-0.5800415277481079,
1.034496545791626,
0.45061689615249634,
0.9439439177513123,
0.1863715648651123,
0.6914498805999756,
0.1360643059015274,
0.49276259541511536,
-0.8196595311164856,
0.847521960735321,
0.01239471510052681,
-0.6036591529846191,
0.01231070514768362,
-0.3554188311100006,
-0.5136085152626038,
0.11668116599321365,
-0.34945058822631836,
-1.2078619003295898,
0.5790829062461853,
0.20351217687129974,
-0.6205631494522095,
0.0422210618853569,
-0.544053316116333,
0.25239333510398865,
-0.15164493024349213,
-0.5116147994995117,
0.2319018840789795,
-0.6563600301742554,
0.5158941149711609,
-0.2762441337108612,
0.04576549679040909,
-0.28612059354782104,
-0.1959603875875473,
0.6046593189239502,
0.0765109583735466,
1.2413004636764526,
-0.3356287479400635,
-0.19651836156845093,
-0.0688946545124054,
0.1638651192188263,
0.28906017541885376,
0.13005630671977997,
-0.348550409078598,
0.005530175287276506,
-0.3516743779182434,
-0.30018895864486694,
-0.7271820902824402,
0.679108738899231,
-0.8564286231994629,
-0.8147896528244019,
-0.43504318594932556,
-0.6887084245681763,
-0.6665716171264648,
-0.3562021553516388,
0.17179855704307556,
0.10079815238714218,
-0.13587166368961334,
0.2759854197502136,
0.8725872039794922,
-0.6581302881240845,
0.09520424157381058,
0.5140015482902527,
-0.7143048048019409,
-0.2774469256401062,
0.45902565121650696,
0.017191583290696144,
0.3250040113925934,
0.27993664145469666,
0.2783721089363098,
-0.2000851035118103,
0.047285471111536026,
-0.09563764929771423,
0.5040896534919739,
-0.7404714226722717,
0.1388034075498581,
-0.826735258102417,
0.07966354489326477,
-0.33855336904525757,
-0.19620956480503082,
-0.08646189421415329,
-0.19311119616031647,
-0.2825465798377991,
-0.21609929203987122,
0.2090853899717331,
0.6283343434333801,
0.1062212735414505,
0.8030345439910889,
-0.2612464129924774,
0.11294896900653839,
0.4296998679637909,
0.10965501517057419,
0.002743852324783802,
-0.6692711710929871,
0.12904851138591766,
-0.14911240339279175,
0.09367115050554276,
-1.0426013469696045,
0.3288259208202362,
0.10073496401309967,
0.443086177110672,
0.5457042455673218,
-0.16851182281970978,
0.9124011397361755,
-0.4833186864852905,
1.032816767692566,
0.0542597733438015,
-0.9287962913513184,
0.5667493939399719,
-0.7134992480278015,
0.6168532967567444,
0.7451487183570862,
0.3468879163265228,
-0.6840336322784424,
-0.5007210969924927,
-0.3629884719848633,
-0.6159056425094604,
0.6591588258743286,
0.21713872253894806,
0.5204705595970154,
0.010827271267771721,
0.9480909705162048,
0.058440059423446655,
0.32030120491981506,
-0.8933736085891724,
-0.5771706700325012,
0.0704549252986908,
0.04517096281051636,
0.06044204160571098,
-0.41859859228134155,
0.16363170742988586,
-0.4200609624385834,
0.32701030373573303,
0.0842856839299202,
0.396380215883255,
-0.08549823611974716,
0.36332961916923523,
-0.13434846699237823,
-0.04427630454301834,
0.4414706528186798,
0.5632649064064026,
-0.22176504135131836,
0.14307597279548645,
0.11139503121376038,
-0.2787262797355652,
0.13886506855487823,
-0.1687532514333725,
-0.43997982144355774,
0.07003908604383469,
0.36513060331344604,
0.811298668384552,
0.5088054537773132,
-0.5554431676864624,
0.41579851508140564,
-0.32197001576423645,
-0.2162490338087082,
-0.33098405599594116,
0.2564748525619507,
0.34284472465515137,
0.2910861670970917,
0.39290568232536316,
-0.004537796601653099,
0.05638132244348526,
-0.5376792550086975,
-0.011330435052514076,
0.40123575925827026,
-0.14214959740638733,
-0.45390045642852783,
0.7727686166763306,
0.18741625547409058,
-0.650612473487854,
0.5559577345848083,
0.1768539547920227,
-0.3100162148475647,
0.5045931935310364,
0.4615184962749481,
0.6533518433570862,
-0.49969935417175293,
0.648918628692627,
0.27614501118659973,
0.2566784918308258,
-0.013771048747003078,
0.08722108602523804,
0.2461775541305542,
-0.501984715461731,
-0.5926098227500916,
-0.6778584718704224,
-0.8495048880577087,
0.3357155919075012,
-0.6411400437355042,
0.2980157732963562,
-0.6267044544219971,
-0.32913199067115784,
0.20970535278320312,
0.094735287129879,
-0.9140698313713074,
0.09372876584529877,
0.43678227066993713,
0.624488115310669,
-1.0673954486846924,
0.5936492681503296,
0.8765057325363159,
-0.36309513449668884,
-0.7565843462944031,
0.4942212998867035,
0.3060806691646576,
-0.5884097218513489,
0.6524739265441895,
0.2910342812538147,
0.0707876980304718,
-0.09688177704811096,
-0.6757910251617432,
-0.6847435832023621,
0.7371847629547119,
0.819541335105896,
-0.42554453015327454,
-0.016942495480179787,
0.5131193995475769,
0.8172184228897095,
-0.5921820402145386,
0.09299780428409576,
0.5677235126495361,
0.5799850821495056,
0.2073536068201065,
-0.6675313711166382,
-0.16630461812019348,
-0.13449938595294952,
0.22307711839675903,
-0.23545846343040466,
-0.6044431924819946,
0.7835119366645813,
-0.1226399689912796,
0.07601368427276611,
-0.16333824396133423,
0.7596160173416138,
0.6861758232116699,
0.24400784075260162,
0.47748830914497375,
-0.04991934821009636,
0.8102105855941772,
0.11789602041244507,
1.231197476387024,
-0.15235401690006256,
-0.0017217856366187334,
1.167581558227539,
-0.614669680595398,
0.6601572632789612,
0.7312536239624023,
-0.2888558506965637,
0.7250128388404846,
0.6439497470855713,
0.05016682669520378,
0.24621184170246124,
0.12691690027713776,
-0.4471980333328247,
-0.38545605540275574,
-0.35844185948371887,
0.01835368201136589,
0.4626650810241699,
0.40349280834198,
-0.3825591206550598,
0.18684899806976318,
0.20167256891727448,
0.25276684761047363,
0.14660505950450897,
-0.025209655985236168,
0.44574370980262756,
0.31850671768188477,
-0.8028435111045837,
-0.24994637072086334,
-0.013955662958323956,
0.7094509601593018,
-0.5081841349601746,
0.2199326455593109,
-0.4232047200202942,
-0.16684167087078094,
-0.10607580095529556,
-0.7460301518440247,
0.08217953145503998,
0.07500320672988892,
-0.1464846432209015,
-0.5731658935546875,
0.7557944655418396,
-0.33430373668670654,
-0.5554667115211487,
0.2663322985172272,
0.8389577865600586,
0.272338330745697,
-0.11293251067399979,
-0.4128517210483551,
-0.018593639135360718,
-0.09865392744541168,
-0.5347594618797302,
0.6436619162559509,
0.45133525133132935,
0.2468060702085495,
0.7511857151985168,
0.5209531784057617,
0.11353597044944763,
-0.12128431349992752,
0.29914870858192444,
0.8104353547096252,
-0.554721474647522,
-0.2797670364379883,
-1.0624210834503174,
0.6155272722244263,
-0.050833869725465775,
-0.17736493051052094,
1.0130598545074463,
0.2424498051404953,
0.3848447799682617,
-0.22823303937911987,
0.6531973481178284,
0.04550536349415779,
0.21811167895793915,
-0.14622825384140015,
0.4360463619232178,
-0.15735158324241638,
0.5520243644714355,
-0.544227659702301,
-0.9455031752586365,
-0.29635146260261536,
0.7621967196464539,
-0.672577440738678,
0.3478061854839325,
0.3776458203792572,
0.42691680788993835,
0.3351786434650421,
-0.06903987377882004,
0.4408700466156006,
0.00640110531821847,
0.4318738877773285,
0.2356986701488495,
0.7979462146759033,
0.12975876033306122,
-0.08420940488576889,
-0.3709948658943176,
-0.22959040105342865,
-0.14799676835536957,
-0.9838241338729858,
-1.3781429529190063,
-0.4166247546672821,
-0.3958635926246643,
-0.3307962119579315,
-0.18302622437477112,
0.9928040504455566,
0.5536912083625793,
-0.4806530773639679,
-0.2067505121231079,
0.3033605217933655,
-0.2140505015850067,
0.15121306478977203,
-0.2841717302799225,
-0.15206781029701233,
-0.07070856541395187,
-1.0004823207855225,
0.022488534450531006,
0.4396257996559143,
0.008864196017384529,
-0.9354877471923828,
-0.02807665430009365,
-0.19328142702579498,
0.5162989497184753,
0.714817464351654,
-0.04740495607256889,
-0.7860279083251953,
-0.4994886815547943,
0.35147058963775635,
-0.11136917769908905,
0.07306195050477982,
0.8813122510910034,
-1.0483089685440063,
0.26706230640411377,
0.22987739741802216,
0.2658551037311554,
0.23683524131774902,
0.3043164610862732,
0.750296413898468,
-1.119918942451477,
0.13558445870876312,
0.26868531107902527,
0.31320297718048096,
0.5572100281715393,
-0.6783850193023682,
0.40578022599220276,
0.18232880532741547,
-0.49702560901641846,
-0.6828087568283081,
0.24638128280639648,
-0.8242760300636292,
-0.07614362984895706,
1.4793260097503662,
-0.23711250722408295,
-0.23246310651302338,
-0.15348441898822784,
-0.2192414253950119,
-0.32577088475227356,
-0.565837025642395,
0.8493357300758362,
0.947584867477417,
-0.5591379404067993,
-0.4984356760978699,
-0.783316969871521,
0.2578921318054199,
0.3282068371772766,
-1.0389745235443115,
0.06827914714813232,
0.798662006855011,
0.16334493458271027,
0.10757357627153397,
0.8634483814239502,
0.18767334520816803,
-0.09878825396299362,
-0.17019402980804443,
-0.13907335698604584,
0.25990957021713257,
-0.19710573554039001,
-0.4711107909679413,
0.05520366504788399,
0.12581539154052734,
0.4511716365814209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10805v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10805v1 | Generative Cross-Modal Retrieval: Memorizing Images in Multimodal Language Models for Retrieval and Beyond | 2024-02-16T16:31:46 | 2024-02-16T16:31:46 | Yongqi Li, Wenjie Wang, Leigang Qu, Liqiang Nie, Wenjie Li, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.MM | cs.MM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.IR | The recent advancements in generative language models have demonstrated their
ability to memorize knowledge from documents and recall knowledge to respond to
user queries effectively. Building upon this capability, we propose to enable
multimodal large language models (MLLMs) to memorize and recall images within
their parameters. Given a user query for visual content, the MLLM is
anticipated to "recall" the relevant image from its parameters as the response.
Achieving this target presents notable challenges, including inbuilt visual
memory and visual recall schemes within MLLMs. To address these challenges, we
introduce a generative cross-modal retrieval framework, which assigns unique
identifier strings to represent images and involves two training steps:
learning to memorize and learning to retrieve. The first step focuses on
training the MLLM to memorize the association between images and their
respective identifiers. The latter step teaches the MLLM to generate the
corresponding identifier of the target image, given the textual query input. By
memorizing images in MLLMs, we introduce a new paradigm to cross-modal
retrieval, distinct from previous discriminative approaches. The experiments
demonstrate that the generative paradigm performs effectively and efficiently
even with large-scale image candidate sets. | [
-0.26005813479423523,
-0.7914801239967346,
0.43759989738464355,
0.03665769845247269,
-0.3287148177623749,
0.0032495807390660048,
-0.12153969705104828,
-0.2603265047073364,
-0.02154327929019928,
0.47727465629577637,
-0.25389036536216736,
-0.34596893191337585,
-0.4292967915534973,
-0.13319364190101624,
-0.5047259330749512,
0.7321307063102722,
0.01837453804910183,
0.2814369797706604,
-0.426827996969223,
-0.34620821475982666,
-0.4690510928630829,
-0.5220968723297119,
-0.7562564611434937,
-0.10239250212907791,
0.8221359252929688,
-0.10083356499671936,
0.5456041097640991,
0.49682798981666565,
0.3799600601196289,
0.3194562792778015,
0.09612316638231277,
0.11477120965719223,
-0.5360051393508911,
0.3833775520324707,
-0.3548886477947235,
-0.6837765574455261,
0.1583510786294937,
-0.31293463706970215,
0.753858745098114,
0.4900408685207367,
-0.013871879316866398,
-0.17107073962688446,
-0.3287450969219208,
0.6356176137924194,
-0.9488620162010193,
0.22995352745056152,
-1.0058242082595825,
0.3280302882194519,
-0.12396509945392609,
-0.7598782777786255,
-0.6131982803344727,
0.07028502970933914,
-0.020515644922852516,
-0.6907771229743958,
0.31598949432373047,
0.1496594101190567,
0.5629169940948486,
-0.109223872423172,
-0.5924817323684692,
-0.43973734974861145,
-0.7231900095939636,
0.6945420503616333,
-0.14358128607273102,
0.8716913461685181,
0.7334498763084412,
0.4427608251571655,
0.30021122097969055,
-0.9237427115440369,
-0.4634207785129547,
-0.26616743206977844,
0.01295260526239872,
0.14004379510879517,
-0.013691306114196777,
-0.203577920794487,
0.35766276717185974,
0.46510276198387146,
-0.6421861052513123,
-0.24992254376411438,
-0.3715672194957733,
-0.38572371006011963,
0.33306899666786194,
0.28036290407180786,
0.42912912368774414,
0.01544551644474268,
-0.5843952298164368,
-0.22457894682884216,
-0.8331409096717834,
-0.2548176646232605,
-0.14331349730491638,
0.17155073583126068,
0.16779373586177826,
0.5916942358016968,
0.06982151418924332,
0.5258261561393738,
0.02417277731001377,
-0.3562191426753998,
0.26428693532943726,
-0.46299540996551514,
-0.20269809663295746,
-0.28650030493736267,
0.5573466420173645,
0.30172112584114075,
0.008687109686434269,
-0.24407482147216797,
-0.5547731518745422,
-0.17880374193191528,
0.28316226601600647,
-0.6639609336853027,
-0.2584158182144165,
-0.4378880262374878,
-0.8233500719070435,
0.1916835457086563,
-0.14331848919391632,
-0.7113471627235413,
-0.2935653030872345,
-0.3103904128074646,
0.8074732422828674,
-0.6429212093353271,
-0.12992830574512482,
-0.2737284004688263,
-0.22256794571876526,
0.1844399869441986,
0.4982917904853821,
-1.0852692127227783,
-0.016449106857180595,
0.24854347109794617,
0.5461388826370239,
0.14796002209186554,
-0.5612995028495789,
-0.6202260851860046,
0.5476744771003723,
-0.24592453241348267,
0.5147576332092285,
-0.914257824420929,
-0.5691782832145691,
0.1697995513677597,
0.1080465093255043,
-0.22947417199611664,
-0.5929256081581116,
0.048467960208654404,
-0.9002881646156311,
0.3068324625492096,
-0.5074918866157532,
-0.40972423553466797,
-0.45746710896492004,
0.4695720374584198,
-1.0036410093307495,
0.8975892066955566,
0.04857727885246277,
-0.6966267228126526,
0.21818123757839203,
-0.11817039549350739,
-0.6197654604911804,
-0.07330702990293503,
-0.3397669792175293,
-0.4236355423927307,
0.16695638000965118,
0.19342055916786194,
0.45600107312202454,
-0.5069594383239746,
-0.0761270746588707,
-0.2853040099143982,
-0.14351890981197357,
0.12939149141311646,
-0.6092367768287659,
0.46860766410827637,
0.2130695879459381,
-0.003406188916414976,
0.12796837091445923,
-0.5343457460403442,
-0.05549415200948715,
0.35110923647880554,
-0.6163384318351746,
-0.6081666350364685,
-0.1069527119398117,
0.44369935989379883,
0.37505120038986206,
0.1124996542930603,
-0.3487468957901001,
-0.0595782995223999,
0.29457607865333557,
0.28383851051330566,
0.4494290053844452,
-0.03696136549115181,
0.4859394431114197,
-0.3608948588371277,
0.4351227879524231,
0.17524372041225433,
0.1416534185409546,
-0.7685718536376953,
-0.16310402750968933,
-0.6707186102867126,
-0.3872305452823639,
0.09387237578630447,
0.40715715289115906,
-1.3114255666732788,
-0.032729536294937134,
-0.1364288479089737,
-0.2758561372756958,
-0.26191794872283936,
0.37038660049438477,
0.7063482403755188,
0.2374662309885025,
0.4648609459400177,
-0.5158276557922363,
-0.5011323094367981,
-0.821839451789856,
0.09920341521501541,
-0.05074290931224823,
0.052976276725530624,
0.5621832609176636,
0.6261627078056335,
-0.16044208407402039,
0.5328429341316223,
-0.24892866611480713,
-0.5197323560714722,
-0.052446551620960236,
0.34392261505126953,
-0.5843669176101685,
0.32802900671958923,
0.6426509618759155,
-1.3641555309295654,
-0.47433945536613464,
0.15055625140666962,
-0.7895212769508362,
0.4614730179309845,
-0.24796341359615326,
-0.027671560645103455,
0.3860584497451782,
0.8229584693908691,
-0.852544367313385,
0.28308162093162537,
0.25747525691986084,
-0.212156742811203,
0.29662197828292847,
-0.38374069333076477,
0.276345431804657,
-0.959973931312561,
0.3036889135837555,
-0.168289914727211,
-0.3228645324707031,
-0.30268964171409607,
0.08107329159975052,
0.23256056010723114,
-0.13872437179088593,
-0.3465307652950287,
0.5184757709503174,
-0.9284482598304749,
-0.1673314869403839,
-0.09076343476772308,
-0.21236644685268402,
0.09082242846488953,
0.5528008341789246,
0.17958588898181915,
0.7965826988220215,
0.6856881976127625,
-0.32297298312187195,
0.4026307165622711,
0.1684238761663437,
-0.33376365900039673,
0.823419451713562,
-0.27886003255844116,
0.19173559546470642,
-0.5669333934783936,
0.32336559891700745,
-0.8254542350769043,
0.07694573700428009,
-0.05787472799420357,
-0.04986109212040901,
0.5543343424797058,
-0.13263975083827972,
-0.6165798902511597,
-0.12894870340824127,
-0.024910494685173035,
0.7468312382698059,
0.3533655107021332,
-0.5251772403717041,
1.0800014734268188,
0.3429851531982422,
-0.08454257249832153,
-0.6080377697944641,
-0.40156927704811096,
0.06791182607412338,
-0.041027262806892395,
-0.16175857186317444,
0.2867162823677063,
-0.01304665021598339,
0.2099059820175171,
0.1391858607530594,
0.08420354872941971,
-0.08989470452070236,
-0.16216418147087097,
0.12882040441036224,
0.16872595250606537,
-0.13948461413383484,
0.4762163460254669,
-0.36331164836883545,
0.05241382122039795,
-0.17613892257213593,
-0.25306129455566406,
0.6773542761802673,
0.012547780759632587,
-0.6475905179977417,
-0.0014333681901916862,
0.8727922439575195,
0.834565281867981,
-0.753016471862793,
0.3911203145980835,
0.9344770908355713,
-0.3605981469154358,
-0.04547945410013199,
-0.6750249266624451,
-0.11788301169872284,
-0.3885912299156189,
0.6970422267913818,
-0.7177977561950684,
-0.7529772520065308,
0.5056287050247192,
0.09090343117713928,
-0.2525672912597656,
0.06778467446565628,
0.8550861477851868,
-0.20321373641490936,
1.0198827981948853,
0.7279835939407349,
-0.0015896933618932962,
0.7156323790550232,
-0.2643681764602661,
-0.08425736427307129,
-0.8474240899085999,
-0.723388135433197,
-0.1408742219209671,
-0.1986236870288849,
-0.020391404628753662,
-0.8177599310874939,
0.3666873574256897,
0.093754343688488,
0.03592304885387421,
0.12704099714756012,
0.012123369611799717,
0.565423309803009,
0.8035759925842285,
0.29416629672050476,
0.4215974509716034,
0.18395619094371796,
-0.44188159704208374,
0.10843395441770554,
-0.5889232158660889,
0.007010628469288349,
1.0058941841125488,
0.08306898176670074,
1.215800404548645,
-0.005348585080355406,
0.4559358060359955,
-0.01314141508191824,
0.18359676003456116,
-0.7592934966087341,
0.6470146775245667,
-0.20319482684135437,
-0.7337803244590759,
-0.08872367441654205,
-0.3480861485004425,
-0.9634793996810913,
0.5073712468147278,
-0.33737826347351074,
-0.34452584385871887,
0.2317150980234146,
0.2860819697380066,
-0.13459058105945587,
0.44783684611320496,
-0.3962896466255188,
0.8742149472236633,
-0.5180718898773193,
-0.3657061755657196,
-0.5013154149055481,
-0.8676941394805908,
0.2114025056362152,
-0.06298407167196274,
-0.17397670447826385,
0.09096350520849228,
-0.15832242369651794,
0.22352570295333862,
0.21033690869808197,
0.9252274036407471,
-0.05402979254722595,
-0.03863418847322464,
-0.018163859844207764,
0.17338933050632477,
0.16002680361270905,
-0.2644973397254944,
0.1512725055217743,
-0.24478085339069366,
-0.014794938266277313,
-0.23220257461071014,
-0.7301456332206726,
0.6383131146430969,
-0.35578757524490356,
-0.4843377470970154,
-0.10523046553134918,
-0.9372562766075134,
-0.05121711641550064,
0.2655607759952545,
0.17150044441223145,
0.48874589800834656,
-0.5003413558006287,
0.4621674716472626,
0.9625558257102966,
-0.2182905673980713,
0.5680950880050659,
0.4105443060398102,
-0.5014364719390869,
-0.5483337044715881,
1.1187059879302979,
0.10977597534656525,
0.41230258345603943,
0.8828656077384949,
-0.28168895840644836,
-0.4129882752895355,
-0.3776523172855377,
-0.356319785118103,
0.1449393332004547,
-1.0720641613006592,
-0.2172757089138031,
-0.6189877390861511,
-0.013305931352078915,
-0.1435340940952301,
0.023066768422722816,
-0.23040872812271118,
-0.2959200441837311,
-0.26050588488578796,
0.31961244344711304,
0.0638076663017273,
0.45748451352119446,
0.08548275381326675,
-0.2518666684627533,
-0.9087733626365662,
0.6024672985076904,
0.6527813673019409,
0.33752837777137756,
0.24711459875106812,
-0.1518726497888565,
-0.2255476415157318,
-0.1598276048898697,
-0.37180542945861816,
-0.6854968070983887,
0.40909966826438904,
0.43591412901878357,
0.8209278583526611,
0.40473684668540955,
-0.2694379389286041,
0.6082093715667725,
-0.5740550756454468,
0.38407787680625916,
0.4830007255077362,
-0.7242767214775085,
0.5014407634735107,
-0.16151772439479828,
0.42416349053382874,
0.2675514221191406,
0.6614295244216919,
-0.729552149772644,
-0.016429342329502106,
-0.1706756353378296,
-0.7468218803405762,
0.33104944229125977,
-0.11481452733278275,
0.34481289982795715,
-0.1554233431816101,
-0.08057963848114014,
0.2723235487937927,
0.23675745725631714,
-0.7603828310966492,
0.047522906213998795,
-0.3734831213951111,
-0.21588128805160522,
-0.11669301986694336,
-0.331015408039093,
-0.5537359714508057,
-0.27958446741104126,
0.4220191240310669,
-0.3133127987384796,
0.3515247702598572,
0.1333606094121933,
-0.60478276014328,
-0.03668509051203728,
0.22606998682022095,
0.5777040123939514,
0.6578306555747986,
0.044607482850551605,
0.4143088757991791,
-0.026779361069202423,
-0.26006507873535156,
0.11057548969984055,
0.11614345759153366,
-0.25800129771232605,
0.00041169035830534995,
0.2357928305864334,
1.0719135999679565,
0.26449769735336304,
-0.8828206658363342,
0.5731672048568726,
0.028187088668346405,
-0.052205439656972885,
-0.26605868339538574,
-0.320602685213089,
0.20836840569972992,
0.4091045558452606,
0.47318920493125916,
0.03322543948888779,
0.11358319222927094,
-0.9363864064216614,
0.28659945726394653,
0.8261625170707703,
-0.30754223465919495,
-0.3187544643878937,
0.6764956116676331,
0.057349707931280136,
-0.2452947348356247,
0.6765853762626648,
0.10088881850242615,
-0.4784826338291168,
0.41982322931289673,
0.937889814376831,
0.7405821084976196,
-0.19674304127693176,
0.18385331332683563,
0.1849936991930008,
0.11177457123994827,
-0.15241095423698425,
0.4340318739414215,
-0.38098812103271484,
-0.581996738910675,
0.05594911426305771,
-0.4588441252708435,
0.02917015738785267,
-0.07253774255514145,
-0.5754085779190063,
-0.022496629506349564,
-0.5681072473526001,
-0.14304319024085999,
-0.045324865728616714,
-0.5387935638427734,
-0.6836449503898621,
0.30577677488327026,
0.451385498046875,
0.8294296860694885,
-0.7246493697166443,
1.0197923183441162,
0.7242382168769836,
-0.828648030757904,
-0.4730227291584015,
-0.15757088363170624,
0.03937279060482979,
-0.9799924492835999,
1.0040953159332275,
0.13965369760990143,
0.005626369267702103,
-0.058557964861392975,
-0.32517552375793457,
-0.7675579786300659,
1.319128155708313,
0.2523174583911896,
-0.37830278277397156,
-0.20108403265476227,
-0.058337777853012085,
0.4523518681526184,
-0.44748562574386597,
0.23925580084323883,
0.13364338874816895,
0.2538996934890747,
0.39690130949020386,
-1.016100525856018,
0.20014645159244537,
-0.4284224808216095,
0.5985245704650879,
0.3001954257488251,
-0.5553534030914307,
1.0692603588104248,
-0.5229292511940002,
-0.39887043833732605,
0.249419167637825,
0.4326227903366089,
0.04795113578438759,
0.38769659399986267,
0.5728750824928284,
0.8456307053565979,
0.4456818103790283,
0.03959639370441437,
1.1719462871551514,
0.018273621797561646,
0.2703855335712433,
0.8883097767829895,
-0.18858730792999268,
1.008701205253601,
0.7369048595428467,
0.17118403315544128,
0.2029801905155182,
0.26921001076698303,
-0.18687912821769714,
0.8341256976127625,
-0.22620999813079834,
-0.5465652942657471,
-0.5275769233703613,
-0.27494874596595764,
-0.39712807536125183,
0.47367098927497864,
0.4290003478527069,
-0.8343733549118042,
-0.41415929794311523,
0.49611252546310425,
-0.3988558053970337,
0.04586135223507881,
-0.3574172556400299,
0.9229322671890259,
0.1352594643831253,
-0.569878101348877,
0.6665531992912292,
-0.30764034390449524,
0.3959297239780426,
-0.6679536700248718,
-0.28579291701316833,
-0.08189336210489273,
0.19815772771835327,
0.05488443374633789,
-0.6038735508918762,
0.10833320021629333,
-0.6130984425544739,
-0.4587870240211487,
-0.26367610692977905,
0.6298512816429138,
-1.0868865251541138,
-0.44894713163375854,
0.4051348567008972,
0.34983059763908386,
-0.18937891721725464,
0.07590886950492859,
-0.7209494113922119,
0.1812957376241684,
-0.14732889831066132,
-0.11934280395507812,
0.37971198558807373,
0.31623244285583496,
-0.2622918486595154,
0.926825761795044,
0.5867375731468201,
-0.27756303548812866,
0.3328072428703308,
0.28838691115379333,
0.9566679000854492,
-0.7027617692947388,
-0.2162782996892929,
-0.4906170070171356,
0.3152606785297394,
0.15153707563877106,
-0.03365824371576309,
0.5343389511108398,
0.6681249141693115,
1.0024700164794922,
-0.48345285654067993,
0.7233437895774841,
-0.20539405941963196,
0.07473639398813248,
-0.8365776538848877,
0.5490118265151978,
-0.892266035079956,
-0.01295737735927105,
0.060648199170827866,
-0.7437098622322083,
-0.3474283218383789,
0.45167258381843567,
-0.0408257320523262,
0.2087300717830658,
0.7306565642356873,
1.1270536184310913,
-0.2989689111709595,
-0.17663125693798065,
0.5175828337669373,
-0.0055681392550468445,
0.17650192975997925,
0.8075140118598938,
1.0756622552871704,
-0.4082470238208771,
0.8138203024864197,
-0.18197396397590637,
0.22187837958335876,
-0.28629904985427856,
-0.5245745778083801,
-0.9587798714637756,
-0.9734289050102234,
0.05729304999113083,
-0.09295571595430374,
0.20154041051864624,
0.7509829998016357,
0.7971491813659668,
-0.5958581566810608,
-0.09870246797800064,
0.3052944839000702,
0.025700625032186508,
-0.26221030950546265,
-0.1720753163099289,
0.16721850633621216,
-0.40495073795318604,
-0.8145955204963684,
0.2356298863887787,
0.6151707768440247,
0.3275413513183594,
-0.42099031805992126,
-0.13107581436634064,
-0.5896679162979126,
-0.297374963760376,
0.8930609226226807,
0.5412887334823608,
-0.9452490210533142,
-0.11115433275699615,
0.011578184552490711,
-0.49113333225250244,
0.15064284205436707,
1.198201298713684,
-0.7989668250083923,
0.6398670077323914,
0.6580997705459595,
0.7952592372894287,
0.8097316026687622,
-0.2514974772930145,
0.5384978652000427,
-0.5503893494606018,
0.18216779828071594,
0.26926836371421814,
0.4411858022212982,
0.5573528409004211,
-0.03810012340545654,
0.15793217718601227,
0.3054647147655487,
-0.17693519592285156,
-0.4794960021972656,
0.4426102638244629,
-0.9841333031654358,
-0.4901847541332245,
0.8856407403945923,
-0.18784819543361664,
0.014700083993375301,
-0.06887489557266235,
-0.36929962038993835,
0.02609417587518692,
-0.011532333679497242,
0.7800060510635376,
0.44630154967308044,
0.27950167655944824,
-0.7976207733154297,
-0.2841586768627167,
0.2689628005027771,
0.6694173812866211,
-0.6078215837478638,
-0.09273973852396011,
0.7739052772521973,
0.3493771255016327,
0.2776625454425812,
0.7541180849075317,
-0.3388662040233612,
0.4791753888130188,
0.21122972667217255,
0.03184596076607704,
-0.07494030147790909,
-0.5683689713478088,
-0.09597791731357574,
0.44408828020095825,
-0.1756231039762497,
-0.15094523131847382
] |
Subsets and Splits