Datasets:

dcarpintero
/

arxiv.cs.CL.10k.embeddings.jina

Dataset card Data Studio Files Files and versions Community

Split (1)

train · 10k rows

id stringlengths 33 33	doc_url stringlengths 33 33	title stringlengths 13 211	publication_date timestamp[s]	update_date timestamp[s]	authors stringlengths 6 16.6k	category_primary stringclasses 60 values	category_all stringlengths 5 132	abstract stringlengths 123 1.99k	embeddings sequencelengths 768 768
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17396v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17396v1	Fine-tuning Transformer-based Encoder for Turkish Language Understanding Tasks	2024-01-30T19:27:04	2024-01-30T19:27:04	Savas Yildirim	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Deep learning-based and lately Transformer-based language models have been dominating the studies of natural language processing in the last years. Thanks to their accurate and fast fine-tuning characteristics, they have outperformed traditional machine learning-based approaches and achieved state-of-the-art results for many challenging natural language understanding (NLU) problems. Recent studies showed that the Transformer-based models such as BERT, which is Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers, have reached impressive achievements on many tasks. Moreover, thanks to their transfer learning capacity, these architectures allow us to transfer pre-built models and fine-tune them to specific NLU tasks such as question answering. In this study, we provide a Transformer-based model and a baseline benchmark for the Turkish Language. We successfully fine-tuned a Turkish BERT model, namely BERTurk that is trained with base settings, to many downstream tasks and evaluated with a the Turkish Benchmark dataset. We showed that our studies significantly outperformed other existing baseline approaches for Named-Entity Recognition, Sentiment Analysis, Question Answering and Text Classification in Turkish Language. We publicly released these four fine-tuned models and resources in reproducibility and with the view of supporting other Turkish researchers and applications.	[ -0.7382655143737793, -0.8918630480766296, 0.24591772258281708, 0.17174385488033295, -0.4909738302230835, -0.24449066817760468, -0.4725832939147949, -0.4973287582397461, -0.3260289132595062, 0.5910539031028748, -0.5761755704879761, -0.3345593512058258, -0.7292634844779968, 0.4241829514503479, -0.2717157006263733, 1.120175838470459, -0.2356405407190323, 0.031234262511134148, -0.13990822434425354, -0.24554063379764557, -0.6310704350471497, -0.13697849214076996, -0.6647734642028809, -0.4524596333503723, 0.36705487966537476, 0.4318483769893646, 0.5474950671195984, 0.40450239181518555, 0.5265694260597229, 0.22494491934776306, -0.29407018423080444, 0.10103681683540344, -0.2014082819223404, 0.3225594162940979, -0.21153169870376587, -0.3211107850074768, -0.12200386822223663, -0.33160433173179626, 0.7249243855476379, 0.7280862331390381, 0.004623735789209604, 0.49451354146003723, 0.42395535111427307, 0.7576065063476562, -0.5764867067337036, 0.32474756240844727, -0.6055012941360474, -0.15246549248695374, 0.06848850846290588, 0.15151849389076233, -0.3503614664077759, -0.326047420501709, 0.28003156185150146, -0.4081631600856781, 0.5801663398742676, -0.332094669342041, 0.9985014200210571, 0.4618859589099884, -0.32950809597969055, -0.2772385776042938, -0.8433942198753357, 0.6703518033027649, -0.8399757742881775, 0.7109230756759644, 0.47226956486701965, 0.5147823691368103, -0.09220538288354874, -0.8034961223602295, -0.6931241154670715, -0.19584564864635468, -0.34714990854263306, 0.043954528868198395, -0.2695275545120239, 0.17607946693897247, -0.035491492599248886, 0.501742422580719, -0.5707954168319702, 0.037534698843955994, -0.3414405584335327, 0.01927044242620468, 0.26830756664276123, 0.0747576653957367, -0.12121686339378357, -0.16506503522396088, 0.05673827975988388, -0.048095569014549255, -0.37270885705947876, 0.36454522609710693, 0.2737402021884918, 0.4923100769519806, 0.12455488741397858, 0.5937350988388062, -0.5859413743019104, 0.8367816209793091, 0.29025590419769287, 0.3127234876155853, -0.058549799025058746, -0.2901066541671753, -0.43063265085220337, -0.03140939772129059, 0.38516852259635925, -0.09358897805213928, 0.21568992733955383, -0.4159339666366577, -0.16418227553367615, -0.11305331438779831, 0.4456615149974823, -0.8092542886734009, -0.19823068380355835, 0.2679794728755951, -0.5671591758728027, -0.256430059671402, -0.02283262461423874, -0.5193237662315369, -0.29388895630836487, -0.36245161294937134, 0.5070040822029114, -0.41297027468681335, -0.1463705152273178, 0.4292006194591522, 0.28665032982826233, 0.589880645275116, 0.42571982741355896, -0.95272296667099, 0.4283655285835266, 0.9093067049980164, 0.5158583521842957, 0.03163789212703705, -0.1204884722828865, -0.47443270683288574, -0.07261283695697784, -0.08203566074371338, 0.6845153570175171, -0.5669322609901428, 0.0738702118396759, 0.18809936940670013, 0.25053808093070984, -0.15225103497505188, -0.4166010618209839, 1.013481616973877, -0.5754971504211426, 0.43801718950271606, -0.22448574006557465, -0.5802737474441528, -0.4841780364513397, 0.4840100109577179, -0.7287584543228149, 0.9904047250747681, -0.14549733698368073, -0.8479923605918884, 0.21183963119983673, -0.5125989317893982, -0.5837416052818298, 0.1121542751789093, 0.13162995874881744, -0.4801087975502014, 0.37532252073287964, 0.4386601150035858, 0.5462530255317688, -0.26225659251213074, 0.1607804149389267, 0.03572699800133705, -0.48919013142585754, -0.01915372721850872, -0.5329655408859253, 0.5910338759422302, 0.3834877014160156, -0.34694230556488037, 0.08494558185338974, -0.5919472575187683, -0.2711228132247925, 0.022593766450881958, -0.564421534538269, -0.21591465175151825, -0.006543855648487806, 0.3044866621494293, 0.14692528545856476, 0.37632936239242554, -0.7431321144104004, -0.07357581704854965, -0.4785297214984894, 0.2263132482767105, 0.38910427689552307, -0.05709563195705414, 0.44347327947616577, -0.19507654011249542, 0.3875434398651123, 0.0010659928666427732, 0.08512592315673828, -0.05498436465859413, -0.3763241767883301, -1.262007236480713, -0.022195041179656982, 0.46455639600753784, 0.5408799052238464, -0.4931344985961914, 0.5985561609268188, -0.31404197216033936, -0.48215970396995544, -1.068881630897522, 0.03496686741709709, -0.0012805210426449776, 0.7595756649971008, 0.426284521818161, -0.12123492360115051, -0.4333130717277527, -1.042617678642273, -0.3773457109928131, -0.00439869798719883, -0.20381219685077667, 0.46600237488746643, 0.2739688456058502, -0.3697540760040283, 0.8552921414375305, -0.1110486090183258, -0.44002780318260193, -0.6518495082855225, 0.387372761964798, 0.5854591131210327, 0.48774442076683044, 0.16577012836933136, -0.7114155292510986, -0.4882456362247467, 0.2294810563325882, -0.282421350479126, 0.10574975609779358, -0.17837592959403992, 0.025733545422554016, 0.41098737716674805, 0.3695114552974701, -0.6023865342140198, 0.08872857689857483, 0.4427298903465271, -0.3408682942390442, 0.5202078819274902, -0.37902310490608215, 0.07636173069477081, -1.1130852699279785, 0.27826759219169617, -0.053161244839429855, -0.30447831749916077, -0.9583406448364258, 0.10434982925653458, 0.050208739936351776, 0.03048667125403881, -0.320211797952652, 0.2704188823699951, -0.09888023883104324, 0.32339391112327576, -0.26797839999198914, -0.19236601889133453, 0.03771393001079559, 0.4880765676498413, 0.22192513942718506, 0.6951594352722168, 0.39829033613204956, -0.4568232297897339, 0.1435203105211258, 0.3475223779678345, -0.5025526285171509, 0.23415938019752502, -0.8225255608558655, 0.2345399111509323, -0.39775726199150085, -0.045531146228313446, -0.9682458639144897, 0.1861128956079483, 0.2956484854221344, -0.37990254163742065, 0.2877284586429596, -0.4162568747997284, -0.5351437926292419, -0.20028381049633026, 0.06884297728538513, 0.1570153534412384, 0.5484462380409241, -0.458635538816452, 0.8635388612747192, -0.057714078575372696, -0.36725732684135437, -0.6653836965560913, -0.6456905007362366, -0.10331548750400543, -0.08567987382411957, -0.5209373235702515, 0.26708200573921204, 0.28730788826942444, 0.07827048003673553, 0.01670471392571926, -0.21996597945690155, -0.2372463196516037, 0.03332452476024628, 0.006999055854976177, 0.040376927703619, -0.4415409564971924, 0.1867998093366623, 0.23280608654022217, -0.1351359784603119, 0.003252048511058092, -0.34332120418548584, 0.5829116702079773, -0.5717048048973083, -0.24191999435424805, -0.5081738233566284, 0.20186884701251984, 0.5314008593559265, -0.620914876461029, 0.9677879810333252, 0.9982650279998779, -0.4814779460430145, 0.12350383400917053, -0.8204530477523804, -0.3365311920642853, -0.464988112449646, 0.5188137888908386, -0.4445849657058716, -1.1056610345840454, 0.5993533730506897, -0.13480691611766815, 0.30067893862724304, 0.5279942750930786, 0.5665922164916992, -0.47582608461380005, 0.8740071654319763, 0.8174909949302673, -0.2578062415122986, 0.3876616358757019, -0.10508846491575241, 0.2624453604221344, -0.6079374551773071, -0.09731081128120422, -0.7094338536262512, -0.3164054751396179, -0.6849013566970825, -0.17689092457294464, 0.009522234089672565, 0.06644193828105927, -0.2002367526292801, 0.4281230866909027, -0.3084200918674469, 0.40375205874443054, 0.6139293313026428, 0.06434109061956406, 0.2634583115577698, 0.02112872339785099, 0.01631210371851921, 0.05083982273936272, -0.6131298542022705, -0.7260875701904297, 0.7031919956207275, 0.4714313745498657, 0.6583980917930603, -0.05116695910692215, 0.5910953879356384, 0.22881658375263214, -0.1781519204378128, -0.62835693359375, 0.26134228706359863, -0.3992854952812195, -0.4910268783569336, -0.4884270131587982, -0.2286539524793625, -1.0630288124084473, 0.2068076729774475, -0.2239280492067337, -0.5767364501953125, 0.2818780541419983, 0.1362539827823639, -0.29107606410980225, 0.24715487658977509, -0.4871065020561218, 1.1226006746292114, 0.12192562967538834, -0.0938810482621193, -0.5061721801757812, -0.5815577507019043, -0.009550553746521473, 0.14515849947929382, -0.17884398996829987, -0.09807780385017395, 0.38007238507270813, 0.6567232608795166, 0.061616163700819016, 0.6410241723060608, -0.2843624949455261, -0.0628931075334549, 0.07061844319105148, 0.09458690136671066, 0.6146451830863953, 0.17113874852657318, -0.024940546602010727, 0.11156436055898666, 0.16513007879257202, -0.43429505825042725, -0.5917386412620544, 0.4233548939228058, -0.7660990953445435, -0.49790510535240173, -0.11325516551733017, -0.5312702655792236, -0.22543203830718994, 0.19760824739933014, 0.11495207250118256, 0.3262232840061188, -0.37592706084251404, 0.42676621675491333, 0.796225368976593, -0.22037507593631744, 0.3713594675064087, 0.4770219326019287, 0.32097309827804565, -0.1346912533044815, 0.761610209941864, -0.24821344017982483, -0.15010665357112885, 0.5272742509841919, -0.03621629253029823, -0.29107874631881714, -0.7162681818008423, -0.3717556297779083, 0.22896656394004822, -0.3933550715446472, -0.1644725352525711, -0.6233354210853577, -0.36923402547836304, -0.3261372148990631, -0.008472059853374958, -0.6525811553001404, -0.2852482199668884, -0.33440062403678894, -0.008372653275728226, 0.2279433161020279, 0.6470509767532349, 0.21507872641086578, 0.25204232335090637, -0.820239245891571, 0.41437870264053345, 0.49300965666770935, 0.6350695490837097, -0.07741980254650116, -0.75923091173172, -0.5627717971801758, 0.137114480137825, -0.060117535293102264, -0.5956794619560242, 0.2470826357603073, 0.20345208048820496, 0.5320603847503662, 0.3698321580886841, 0.15429925918579102, 0.47750920057296753, -0.4787079989910126, 0.3750631511211395, -0.43528443574905396, -0.859811544418335, 0.5855470895767212, -0.17649982869625092, 0.5615991353988647, 0.8946424126625061, 0.04499570652842522, -0.8979577422142029, -0.5007665753364563, -0.2789914906024933, -0.6207073330879211, 0.81697678565979, 0.6181846857070923, 0.3066883981227875, 0.3871932029724121, 0.4143264591693878, 0.4944530725479126, 0.04227012023329735, -0.40761810541152954, -0.1990266740322113, -0.3128741383552551, -0.46651583909988403, -0.13635613024234772, -0.3544462025165558, 0.17922183871269226, -0.44792604446411133, 0.6569263339042664, -0.08230620622634888, 0.38312095403671265, 0.15843668580055237, -0.6443859934806824, 0.008800031617283821, 0.6466321349143982, 0.5609676241874695, 0.4409675598144531, -0.6050717234611511, 0.1853727400302887, 0.49058467149734497, -0.7034731507301331, -0.07209910452365875, 0.7100266814231873, -0.02322530187666416, 0.0992908701300621, 0.195282444357872, 0.8648472428321838, -0.17183706164360046, -0.5450929403305054, 0.17317593097686768, -0.46350061893463135, -0.0948604866862297, -0.1416977494955063, -0.07785344123840332, 0.06908132135868073, 0.4227151572704315, 0.4614364504814148, 0.040633734315633774, 0.32458898425102234, 0.014893308281898499, 0.18865041434764862, 0.3703164756298065, -0.5598916411399841, -0.3294402062892914, 0.4427681863307953, 0.20856353640556335, -0.13108526170253754, 0.8868725895881653, 0.10905785113573074, -0.46104249358177185, 0.48189979791641235, 0.41703498363494873, 1.0354936122894287, -0.07261454313993454, 0.1761394888162613, 0.24709655344486237, 0.5732800960540771, 0.20577363669872284, 0.31949394941329956, -0.4023004174232483, -0.9111817479133606, -0.4761282503604889, -0.855527400970459, -0.5081667304039001, 0.3828648328781128, -0.9457188844680786, 0.16681966185569763, -0.03964115306735039, 0.08645971119403839, -0.2203942984342575, 0.3309679925441742, -1.0163800716400146, 0.29154011607170105, 0.3728196620941162, 1.0365527868270874, -0.8701561093330383, 1.0616741180419922, 0.9774724841117859, -0.08279047161340714, -0.34971562027931213, 0.0181803610175848, -0.7011666297912598, -0.4514737129211426, 0.3587373197078705, 0.3559376299381256, -0.0033546551130712032, 0.13740135729312897, -0.19063587486743927, -0.6244245767593384, 0.8028455376625061, 0.4778488874435425, -0.5188939571380615, 0.1702658087015152, 0.5319963097572327, 0.700072169303894, -0.08845331519842148, 0.13047701120376587, 0.8679748177528381, 0.5315130352973938, -0.15792334079742432, -0.8243643641471863, -0.05245358496904373, -0.3281973600387573, -0.1285417228937149, 0.13394035398960114, -0.2795965373516083, 0.4194979667663574, 0.04025178402662277, -0.008385051973164082, -0.02073528803884983, 0.964874804019928, 0.0006429082714021206, -0.11055340617895126, 0.5234960317611694, 0.581486165523529, 0.4811042249202728, -0.09834597259759903, 0.7073874473571777, -0.3339100480079651, 0.3954622447490692, 1.0105088949203491, 0.3189658522605896, 0.9828962683677673, 0.49105823040008545, 0.004021609667688608, 0.4414336085319519, 0.6200734376907349, -0.011139783076941967, 0.7620741724967957, -0.3184950649738312, -0.2902694642543793, -0.3631414771080017, -0.03319671005010605, -0.25890642404556274, 0.5437861680984497, 0.2822311818599701, -0.3013840913772583, -0.34833845496177673, 0.03564668819308281, -0.2602190673351288, -0.26543012261390686, -0.1770220398902893, 0.9682087898254395, -0.1700497716665268, -0.4582480490207672, 0.5234005451202393, 0.1864658147096634, 0.6104732751846313, -0.3815617263317108, 0.005305118393152952, -0.41758599877357483, 0.3282238245010376, 0.13687390089035034, -0.8350231647491455, 0.4888075888156891, 0.019547639414668083, -0.13031898438930511, -0.30574461817741394, 0.9895775318145752, -0.6172001361846924, -0.6009852886199951, -0.06972167640924454, 0.4914935827255249, -0.05270960554480553, -0.26612937450408936, -0.6338379979133606, -0.30434679985046387, -0.10155729949474335, -0.2501640319824219, 0.1083228811621666, 0.40427127480506897, 0.23837827146053314, 0.5093803405761719, 0.406723290681839, -0.15940500795841217, 0.025388846173882484, 0.2781181335449219, 0.6803940534591675, -0.579181969165802, -0.3549002707004547, -0.7695401310920715, 0.4789206087589264, 0.2006581574678421, -0.22567683458328247, 0.5518279671669006, 0.51188063621521, 0.8156843781471252, -0.2853119969367981, 0.5827733874320984, 0.13269397616386414, 0.3564789593219757, -0.18189960718154907, 1.095133662223816, -0.407016783952713, -0.21407468616962433, -0.12489597499370575, -0.9222206473350525, -0.3866548240184784, 0.662571907043457, -0.16740331053733826, -0.2445632666349411, 0.22381249070167542, 0.588715672492981, -0.28719907999038696, 0.156289204955101, 0.17691469192504883, 0.20158176124095917, 0.2045563906431198, 0.4038965106010437, 0.6866756677627563, -0.5047804117202759, 0.6092161536216736, -0.5513592958450317, 0.023035427555441856, -0.2954915165901184, -0.5547241568565369, -1.0660802125930786, -0.7591434121131897, -0.1507527083158493, 0.05076580494642258, 0.2540229260921478, 0.788719654083252, 0.5036232471466064, -1.3627821207046509, -0.10993514955043793, -0.36584773659706116, 0.07617682963609695, -0.39060479402542114, -0.17644672095775604, 0.5612861514091492, -0.6195083856582642, -0.7445790767669678, 0.09674052894115448, 0.11056216806173325, -0.017946064472198486, -0.042861420661211014, -0.05945742502808571, -0.1005418449640274, 0.04497046023607254, 0.5764606595039368, 0.20208203792572021, -0.8003599047660828, -0.3153238594532013, 0.18634508550167084, -0.06275700777769089, 0.04747621715068817, 0.505140483379364, -1.0872033834457397, 0.5529301166534424, 0.7136398553848267, 1.0563969612121582, 0.5965701937675476, -0.04934677109122276, 0.7628067135810852, -0.6353912353515625, 0.026527252048254013, 0.2513901889324188, 0.40895605087280273, 0.30260780453681946, -0.2855568528175354, 0.2498549073934555, -0.36962586641311646, -0.4734582006931305, -0.6145803332328796, -0.08334267884492874, -0.8117659687995911, -0.12460514158010483, 0.7458736300468445, 0.07189079374074936, -0.02248539589345455, -0.2779640257358551, -0.31103265285491943, 0.6754096150398254, -0.24988700449466705, 1.0266984701156616, 0.6537652611732483, -0.0765334814786911, -0.49304836988449097, -0.369344025850296, 0.47107353806495667, 0.8414580821990967, -0.665436327457428, 0.23979955911636353, 0.06410004943609238, 0.1356167048215866, -0.15712223947048187, -0.07859084010124207, 0.2672608196735382, 0.2925989031791687, -0.4793880879878998, 0.04872088134288788, -0.17028570175170898, -0.20900346338748932, -0.6934719085693359, 0.03776594623923302, 0.17992030084133148, -0.5401529669761658 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17390v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17390v2	Customizing Language Model Responses with Contrastive In-Context Learning	2024-01-30T19:13:12	2024-04-08T05:22:51	Xiang Gao, Kamalika Das	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Large language models (LLMs) are becoming increasingly important for machine learning applications. However, it can be challenging to align LLMs with our intent, particularly when we want to generate content that is preferable over others or when we want the LLM to respond in a certain style or tone that is hard to describe. To address this challenge, we propose an approach that uses contrastive examples to better describe our intent. This involves providing positive examples that illustrate the true intent, along with negative examples that show what characteristics we want LLMs to avoid. The negative examples can be retrieved from labeled data, written by a human, or generated by the LLM itself. Before generating an answer, we ask the model to analyze the examples to teach itself what to avoid. This reasoning step provides the model with the appropriate articulation of the user's need and guides it towards generting a better answer. We tested our approach on both synthesized and real-world datasets, including StackExchange and Reddit, and found that it significantly improves performance compared to standard few-shot prompting	[ -0.4475155174732208, -0.8185681700706482, 0.5271456837654114, 0.02905748039484024, -0.5519545674324036, -0.26664891839027405, -0.45656126737594604, -0.3094383776187897, 0.07700970023870468, 0.5897431969642639, -0.5970828533172607, -0.6256436109542847, -0.33060553669929504, 0.22605808079242706, -0.31109121441841125, 1.1616767644882202, -0.08767194300889969, 0.003695773659273982, -0.3748393952846527, -0.2042764127254486, -0.5586107969284058, -0.5319821834564209, -0.9522120952606201, -0.5358219146728516, 0.6752379536628723, 0.7079653739929199, 0.46739131212234497, 0.4103919565677643, 0.3331993818283081, 0.27587890625, -0.08223748207092285, 0.04524221271276474, -0.6613723039627075, 0.3207460641860962, -0.2637757658958435, -0.3197036683559418, -0.18450872600078583, 0.01239612977951765, 0.30461326241493225, 0.9046388864517212, 0.05967128649353981, 0.1644582599401474, 0.2611304819583893, 0.4078710079193115, -0.48282429575920105, 0.13118109107017517, -0.7185882925987244, -0.015966640785336494, 0.05164536088705063, -0.40123891830444336, -0.5781757831573486, -0.18896347284317017, 0.2351190447807312, -0.594498336315155, 0.20579223334789276, -0.0910727009177208, 0.6849297881126404, 0.13344347476959229, -0.5234466195106506, -0.6022086143493652, -0.6526927947998047, 0.9363455772399902, -1.034075140953064, 0.17862114310264587, 0.410806268453598, 0.28997138142585754, -0.12221165746450424, -0.4633484184741974, -0.6152782440185547, -0.21226397156715393, -0.4143317639827728, 0.18927738070487976, -0.06076684594154358, -0.13305118680000305, 0.23300747573375702, 0.14923423528671265, -0.49695977568626404, 0.28694427013397217, -0.17761334776878357, -0.021418394520878792, 0.47381022572517395, 0.40147915482521057, 0.01957099139690399, 0.047452136874198914, -0.14035850763320923, -0.18811143934726715, -0.8802094459533691, 0.09616827219724655, 0.38242992758750916, 0.6144458651542664, -0.32550060749053955, 0.5882479548454285, -0.24816763401031494, 0.877558171749115, 0.3310411274433136, 0.020630856975913048, 0.22832350432872772, -0.14767096936702728, -0.24858972430229187, -0.09682322293519974, 0.5026779174804688, 0.6510210037231445, 0.20222383737564087, -0.12615112960338593, -0.341997891664505, -0.04335954412817955, 0.201717346906662, -1.22846257686615, -0.09285560250282288, 0.29574114084243774, -0.47334474325180054, -0.32092854380607605, -0.34057414531707764, -0.7554379105567932, -0.48527902364730835, -0.6005240082740784, 0.3334225118160248, -0.1921691745519638, -0.029332801699638367, 0.16342096030712128, -0.028005007654428482, 0.49606430530548096, 0.37586623430252075, -0.9804114699363708, 0.44119954109191895, 0.5851175785064697, 0.5014710426330566, -0.15833477675914764, 0.024141760542988777, -0.8833715319633484, 0.12455195188522339, -0.3495291471481323, 0.8028569221496582, -0.7858437895774841, -0.3914650082588196, 0.12644337117671967, -0.21569398045539856, 0.22412344813346863, -0.7105177640914917, 0.4480115473270416, -0.6150822639465332, 0.5587608814239502, -0.30889779329299927, -0.7206846475601196, -0.1477520763874054, 0.4703349471092224, -0.3404909074306488, 0.5826768279075623, 0.06288457661867142, -0.6868604421615601, 0.2773659825325012, -0.6523621678352356, -0.5836797952651978, -0.032080817967653275, -0.3654802739620209, -0.5409181118011475, 0.17023636400699615, 0.2586303949356079, 0.7280714511871338, -0.11589530110359192, 0.09249312430620193, -0.4549165666103363, -0.339471697807312, 0.4905800223350525, -0.2869630753993988, 0.5008358359336853, 0.3312872648239136, -0.20302969217300415, 0.4138232171535492, -0.5608041882514954, -0.11292193830013275, 0.26232898235321045, -0.4028085768222809, -0.4845247268676758, 0.051634177565574646, 0.005788066424429417, 0.3912130296230316, 0.0483657568693161, -0.2616014778614044, 0.034530431032180786, -0.5718345046043396, 0.3502085506916046, 0.782639741897583, -0.014215640723705292, 0.4196144640445709, -0.39410290122032166, 0.6036993861198425, 0.05617669224739075, -0.08653970807790756, -0.3389124870300293, -0.21921275556087494, -0.8360001444816589, -0.16868601739406586, -0.05145920813083649, 0.2714294493198395, -0.6267075538635254, 0.30765917897224426, -0.117093525826931, -0.1942519098520279, -0.4385681450366974, 0.3924407958984375, 0.4291205108165741, 1.1364425420761108, 0.4727747440338135, -0.07751719653606415, -0.6697832942008972, -0.951282262802124, -0.22308215498924255, -0.01978234387934208, -0.28393492102622986, 0.8247543573379517, 0.3658621311187744, -0.19877758622169495, 0.9156586527824402, -0.5931383371353149, 0.11588257551193237, -0.5384894013404846, 0.00945794302970171, 0.33147233724594116, 0.24762316048145294, 0.449640691280365, -0.9801515340805054, -0.6090651750564575, -0.12008706480264664, -0.5411658883094788, -0.4035062789916992, -0.04243561252951622, -0.1680382490158081, 0.029050864279270172, 0.688309907913208, -0.21946518123149872, 0.018575219437479973, 0.5430644750595093, -0.29674848914146423, 0.42424020171165466, -0.028945423662662506, -0.02484758198261261, -1.5428311824798584, 0.09784085303544998, 0.18726526200771332, -0.27133482694625854, -0.7852210402488708, 0.18698453903198242, -0.17050467431545258, -0.10399090498685837, -0.733185887336731, 0.8853115439414978, -0.12300264835357666, 0.14786465466022491, -0.2989344894886017, 0.26060858368873596, 0.07113594561815262, 0.3140842318534851, 0.3079218864440918, 0.6350693106651306, 0.28010427951812744, -0.8037323951721191, 0.17569223046302795, 0.26335659623146057, -0.21167504787445068, 0.6194733381271362, -0.755610466003418, 0.2590622007846832, -0.2898036241531372, 0.4672871530056, -1.1457555294036865, -0.43274223804473877, 0.25841203331947327, -0.19247376918792725, 0.2403465211391449, -0.28160005807876587, -0.27875635027885437, -0.0975503996014595, -0.42621350288391113, 0.4518175423145294, 0.5750162601470947, -0.7714570164680481, 0.4320046901702881, 0.2253940999507904, -0.3363005220890045, -0.27954721450805664, -0.7716813683509827, 0.10165373235940933, -0.7857879996299744, -0.24529115855693817, 0.4773979187011719, -0.5095460414886475, -0.34687039256095886, -0.1719171553850174, 0.17627215385437012, -0.07762429863214493, 0.3811749815940857, 0.079802967607975, 0.24879133701324463, -0.2656322717666626, 0.23951879143714905, -0.06086326390504837, -0.012889075092971325, -0.04786457493901253, -0.062427978962659836, 0.7053796648979187, -0.13246425986289978, -0.33875250816345215, -0.4649178683757782, 0.447307288646698, 0.14038591086864471, -0.04968486726284027, 0.5629860162734985, 0.5369375348091125, -0.2540549337863922, -0.33527103066444397, -0.3031417727470398, -0.5639997124671936, -0.5047875046730042, 0.18814097344875336, -0.3318248391151428, -1.0000311136245728, 0.4701775014400482, 0.04967605695128441, 0.147064670920372, -0.03761797770857811, 0.7686919569969177, -0.34126582741737366, 1.0573700666427612, 0.41268283128738403, -0.018921643495559692, 0.5929092764854431, -0.08658641576766968, 0.20658494532108307, -0.7665467858314514, -0.05086187273263931, -0.4637162685394287, -0.3929242491722107, -0.5629855990409851, -0.20301008224487305, 0.06779611855745316, -0.013953020796179771, -0.14278565347194672, 0.25621792674064636, -0.24051998555660248, 0.6837226748466492, 0.28757187724113464, 0.07512170076370239, 0.05645277723670006, 0.018746392801404, 0.053094979375600815, -0.09407642483711243, -0.590300440788269, -0.7461323142051697, 0.9299803376197815, 0.20459675788879395, 0.9976450800895691, 0.23676952719688416, 0.9406149387359619, -0.11458349972963333, 0.7842631936073303, -0.8975879549980164, 0.4856528341770172, -0.3005669116973877, -0.40862739086151123, -0.15472917258739471, -0.5012366771697998, -1.036435842514038, 0.3617982268333435, -0.2024419605731964, -0.61829674243927, -0.11704505980014801, 0.6570123434066772, -0.3132251501083374, -0.11724751442670822, -0.9683427214622498, 0.9207270741462708, -0.1026175394654274, -0.35100188851356506, 0.015910830348730087, -0.41187402606010437, 0.3721693456172943, 0.07227327674627304, 0.25641801953315735, 0.14710058271884918, -0.1048303171992302, 0.34330251812934875, -0.10971499234437943, 1.3400828838348389, 0.05898682028055191, -0.21461890637874603, 0.19346129894256592, 0.17132410407066345, 0.6536471247673035, -0.0635809451341629, -0.34524035453796387, -0.41315069794654846, -0.5414475202560425, -0.3357577621936798, -0.6916821599006653, 0.7622506022453308, -0.3884493410587311, -0.6853418350219727, 0.15189990401268005, -0.558799147605896, -0.3929069936275482, -0.023712577298283577, 0.13129308819770813, 0.5106406807899475, -0.27752310037612915, 0.30135950446128845, 0.6146122813224792, -0.32267093658447266, 0.4187179505825043, 0.7211384773254395, -0.17437425255775452, -0.07610320299863815, 0.9619282484054565, -0.21933504939079285, 0.2899865508079529, 0.6228730082511902, 0.6542835831642151, -0.5139302015304565, -0.6429389119148254, -0.18283192813396454, 0.0828901156783104, -0.9104570746421814, -0.10318759828805923, -0.46906763315200806, 0.12574921548366547, -0.4589364528656006, -0.4192444682121277, 0.05885414034128189, -0.15510503947734833, -0.5844958424568176, -0.016992582008242607, 0.12385652959346771, 0.5858991742134094, 0.3839341104030609, 0.23444581031799316, -0.5649614334106445, 0.2739957571029663, 0.48522594571113586, 0.15854014456272125, -0.006682703737169504, -0.7974948883056641, -0.09906803071498871, -0.10426033288240433, -0.39256179332733154, -0.7472705245018005, 0.3442046642303467, 0.25003498792648315, 0.6250852942466736, 0.5037996768951416, 0.2286301702260971, 0.5783684253692627, -0.5673227310180664, 0.688620388507843, -0.015016785822808743, -0.8101919889450073, 0.647861897945404, -0.33035042881965637, 0.4558739960193634, 0.5828681588172913, 0.5557461380958557, -0.699297308921814, -0.5150057673454285, -0.4023163616657257, -0.8687909841537476, 0.4594896137714386, 0.0475304052233696, 0.5529248714447021, -0.1374841183423996, 0.42999744415283203, 0.2590866684913635, 0.17833638191223145, -0.9913959503173828, -0.05598108842968941, -0.19369785487651825, -0.5185084939002991, -0.2538142800331116, -0.12193115800619125, -0.22334425151348114, 0.052732422947883606, 0.6034446358680725, -0.4153338074684143, -0.16954290866851807, -0.1371600180864334, -0.2549569010734558, 0.18134291470050812, 0.573472261428833, 0.907842218875885, 0.5154631733894348, -0.09791596233844757, 0.45469966530799866, 0.34410205483436584, 0.1927644908428192, -0.06822460144758224, -0.02449307031929493, -0.2809670567512512, -0.25132986903190613, 0.4907936155796051, 0.6140908598899841, 0.1309310346841812, -0.7845416069030762, 0.5177094340324402, -0.1158495545387268, -0.05983581021428108, -0.035973817110061646, 0.1926097422838211, 0.39968109130859375, 0.16456978023052216, -0.11783775687217712, -0.45506879687309265, 0.23228003084659576, -0.4796755611896515, -0.07805667817592621, 0.532672107219696, -0.41214820742607117, -0.3032527267932892, 0.26473891735076904, 0.47841721773147583, -0.41887733340263367, 0.4313141405582428, -0.23848971724510193, -0.4883354604244232, 0.5837805867195129, 0.8999679684638977, 0.8392158150672913, -0.15545104444026947, 0.1962769329547882, 0.37587636709213257, -0.11228975653648376, 0.31537607312202454, 0.08560258150100708, -0.2676678001880646, -0.8435350656509399, -0.31099140644073486, -0.42513278126716614, -0.581799328327179, 0.5457245111465454, -0.6210111379623413, 0.3667784035205841, -0.2467687427997589, 0.11448147147893906, 0.08902254700660706, -0.24910590052604675, -0.6176130771636963, 0.2740613520145416, 0.15480919182300568, 0.6767391562461853, -0.9833230376243591, 0.651486873626709, 0.725024938583374, -0.41155576705932617, -0.4723435938358307, 0.23677556216716766, -0.009275577031075954, -0.6709617376327515, 0.7094462513923645, 0.3188822567462921, -0.21875643730163574, -0.3005415201187134, -0.6337206363677979, -0.33865392208099365, 0.8191851377487183, 0.5140234231948853, -0.5458688735961914, 0.2658994197845459, 0.015953456982970238, 0.6870483756065369, -0.77276211977005, 0.06129470467567444, 0.2643735408782959, 0.19756615161895752, 0.05997340753674507, -0.29377442598342896, 0.22672508656978607, -0.22334080934524536, 0.03430493548512459, -0.06626686453819275, -0.4292811155319214, 0.6620315909385681, -0.38477832078933716, -0.1929626613855362, -0.0995858907699585, 0.5286576747894287, 0.30658483505249023, 0.3351430594921112, 0.7286787033081055, 0.3870311975479126, 0.6154719591140747, 0.3256210684776306, 1.157772183418274, -0.12312987446784973, 0.12516380846500397, 1.7072181701660156, -0.3530992865562439, 1.0412636995315552, 0.8026383519172668, 0.19329361617565155, 0.4853627681732178, 0.8650715351104736, 0.10015575587749481, 0.5783770680427551, 0.4981544613838196, -0.3710345923900604, -0.4092820882797241, -0.27889585494995117, -0.1474338173866272, 0.29179519414901733, 0.36537954211235046, -0.41024699807167053, -0.336496502161026, -0.08822400122880936, -0.07946614176034927, 0.40429002046585083, -0.14099039137363434, 0.9604690670967102, 0.020888112485408783, -0.637118399143219, 0.49183791875839233, -0.054010190069675446, 0.7188873887062073, -0.44096267223358154, -0.2531108558177948, -0.4074079096317291, 0.11304812878370285, -0.1918245255947113, -0.8397347927093506, 0.27324262261390686, 0.2363084852695465, -0.32580772042274475, -0.30963027477264404, 0.4229619801044464, -0.686839759349823, -0.3608351945877075, 0.22976666688919067, 0.10131210088729858, 0.2088911086320877, 0.2228839099407196, -0.6750050783157349, -0.0014908815501257777, -0.11875744163990021, -0.25586917996406555, 0.3849486708641052, 0.2124803513288498, 0.023259535431861877, 0.7450003623962402, 0.5334616303443909, -0.14552715420722961, -0.29129958152770996, 0.38483357429504395, 0.9062222242355347, -0.4963356554508209, -0.4760589599609375, -0.8951970934867859, 0.3968847692012787, -0.17039577662944794, -0.39686691761016846, 0.6300150156021118, 0.556247889995575, 1.1371307373046875, -0.09283732622861862, 0.7563602924346924, 0.3572157919406891, 0.4636426568031311, -0.6567249298095703, 0.3001978397369385, -0.7323427796363831, 0.5591955184936523, -0.12733636796474457, -0.7383068799972534, -0.36305928230285645, 0.646492063999176, -0.4122122824192047, 0.2637488543987274, 0.5351703763008118, 0.9771580100059509, -0.2533702552318573, -0.28770503401756287, 0.5286772847175598, 0.20969359576702118, 0.6361599564552307, 0.6024273633956909, 0.8997512459754944, -0.023800905793905258, 0.758144199848175, -0.30802369117736816, -0.01399958971887827, -0.45865634083747864, -1.150286316871643, -1.1162285804748535, -0.46560001373291016, -0.3677145540714264, -0.37060409784317017, -0.15444228053092957, 1.2468618154525757, 0.8711406588554382, -0.98388671875, -0.3558216989040375, -0.10421864688396454, 0.22400246560573578, 0.15594427287578583, -0.20948396623134613, 0.1959991753101349, -0.6708603501319885, -0.8108076453208923, 0.45834165811538696, -0.0052941301837563515, 0.31177565455436707, -0.06192319467663765, -0.31511104106903076, 0.11735732108354568, 0.26320651173591614, 0.7425870895385742, 0.22994746267795563, -0.7193410396575928, -0.41879114508628845, -0.13106754422187805, -0.33350539207458496, 0.07032567262649536, 0.9720820188522339, -0.5466340780258179, 0.36700308322906494, 0.4379574656486511, 0.7552171349525452, 0.5044606924057007, -0.02654179371893406, 0.5706126093864441, -0.8971588015556335, 0.01896197721362114, 0.40854915976524353, 0.3147779405117035, 0.6530514359474182, -0.3095724582672119, 0.20393037796020508, -0.18658357858657837, -0.25241777300834656, -0.6305828094482422, 0.5385363698005676, -0.9116738438606262, -0.607651948928833, 1.2710075378417969, -0.20023807883262634, -0.004266434349119663, -0.06159767508506775, -0.3218555748462677, -0.004628449212759733, -0.3743402659893036, 0.927147626876831, 0.6649768352508545, -0.32392197847366333, -0.03411436453461647, -0.2870800197124481, 0.49282848834991455, 0.377321720123291, -1.021934151649475, 0.24003346264362335, 0.48148807883262634, 0.46833866834640503, -0.13830047845840454, 0.5148211717605591, 0.07908059656620026, 0.17571064829826355, -0.3210776448249817, -0.1854185312986374, 0.07787556946277618, -0.09520771354436874, -0.6576211452484131, 0.07192931324243546, 0.23846988379955292, 0.0011003934778273106 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17377v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17377v3	Infini-gram: Scaling Unbounded n-gram Language Models to a Trillion Tokens	2024-01-30T19:03:49	2024-04-04T17:28:38	Jiacheng Liu, Sewon Min, Luke Zettlemoyer, Yejin Choi, Hannaneh Hajishirzi	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR	Are $n$-gram language models still relevant in this era of neural large language models (LLMs)? Our answer is yes, and we showcase their values in both text analysis and improving neural LLMs. This was done by modernizing $n$-gram LMs in two aspects. First, we train them at the same data scale as neural LLMs -- 5 trillion tokens. This is the largest $n$-gram LM ever built. Second, existing $n$-gram LMs use small $n$ which hinders their performance; we instead allow $n$ to be arbitrarily large, by introducing a new $\infty$-gram LM with backoff. Instead of pre-computing $n$-gram count tables (which would be very expensive), we develop an engine named infini-gram -- powered by suffix arrays -- that can compute $\infty$-gram (as well as $n$-gram with arbitrary $n$) probabilities with millisecond-level latency. The $\infty$-gram framework and infini-gram engine enable us to conduct many novel and interesting analyses of human-written and machine-generated text: we find that the $\infty$-gram LM has fairly high accuracy for next-token prediction (47%), and can complement neural LLMs to greatly reduce their perplexity. When analyzing machine-generated text, we also observe irregularities in the machine--$\infty$-gram agreement level with respect to the suffix length, which indicates deficiencies in neural LLM pretraining and the positional embeddings of Transformers.	[ -0.33529290556907654, -0.5438780188560486, 0.6973629593849182, 0.15520234405994415, -0.1508304923772812, 0.20685088634490967, -0.4479552209377289, -0.36671268939971924, 0.14763613045215607, 0.5271725654602051, -0.036249931901693344, -0.2339046150445938, -0.5424849390983582, 0.23621991276741028, -0.45603659749031067, 0.8042174577713013, 0.3793909549713135, 0.2767888307571411, -0.40306001901626587, -0.046647824347019196, -0.2329973429441452, -0.6735855937004089, -0.7046110033988953, -0.30573344230651855, 0.5444498658180237, 0.6344931125640869, 0.7131520509719849, 0.6783044338226318, 0.5582615733146667, 0.3448216915130615, -0.33888769149780273, -0.13655252754688263, -0.4143647849559784, -0.12769825756549835, 0.27529478073120117, -0.5129028558731079, -0.7167258858680725, 0.056677401065826416, 1.1541436910629272, 1.055242657661438, 0.1678108274936676, 0.003583261277526617, -0.0007781832246109843, 0.7649359703063965, -0.43442052602767944, -0.15747979283332825, -0.5923905372619629, -0.11191833019256592, -0.45392319560050964, -0.2061241716146469, -0.670908510684967, -0.37621989846229553, -0.1715296357870102, -0.3559899926185608, -0.09517601877450943, 0.17955873906612396, 0.663703441619873, 0.09013795107603073, -0.5046948790550232, -0.33098292350769043, -0.5663688778877258, 0.7403631806373596, -1.2015804052352905, 0.36913612484931946, 0.2462185025215149, 0.16447007656097412, -0.7907684445381165, -0.9011067748069763, -0.7252838015556335, -0.5523665547370911, 0.17521648108959198, 0.049704134464263916, -0.2938750982284546, 0.289112389087677, 0.3589661419391632, 0.6929699182510376, -0.41005098819732666, 0.7188717722892761, -0.19950999319553375, 0.05096355453133583, 0.502149760723114, 0.1433696150779724, 0.38292354345321655, 0.03665102645754814, -0.3227313458919525, 0.1449911743402481, -0.8877517580986023, -0.2698623836040497, 0.5363540053367615, 0.3637351393699646, 0.4147174656391144, 0.4629262685775757, -0.009226836264133453, 0.7206710577011108, 0.07249325513839722, -0.2710932493209839, 0.06750727444887161, -0.24848437309265137, -0.33588704466819763, 0.12132024765014648, 0.8264034390449524, 0.36308926343917847, 0.48858702182769775, -0.515857994556427, -0.2408648282289505, -0.11169768869876862, 0.22223994135856628, -0.9111125469207764, 0.2427157461643219, 0.024312777444720268, -0.537773072719574, -0.07962749153375626, 0.035583171993494034, -0.9231090545654297, -0.4821375906467438, -0.049587056040763855, 0.38864290714263916, -0.327741414308548, -0.2060396671295166, 0.31024253368377686, -0.09818590432405472, 0.1793603003025055, -0.05252086743712425, -1.1418399810791016, 0.5289280414581299, 0.8954842686653137, 0.937870442867279, 0.13214878737926483, -0.21169263124465942, -0.5586158037185669, -0.13617216050624847, -0.4654594659805298, 0.6606061458587646, -0.5503131747245789, -0.3587164282798767, 0.14590664207935333, -0.21935679018497467, -0.11069168895483017, -0.6366901397705078, 0.5528108477592468, -0.6588873267173767, 0.11076538264751434, -0.07827596366405487, -1.05574631690979, -0.022289473563432693, 0.16357019543647766, -0.5694057941436768, 0.8521751165390015, -0.06452427059412003, -0.4869406521320343, 0.27263695001602173, -0.6416146159172058, -0.3685480058193207, 0.07649005204439163, 0.16702167689800262, -0.2528323233127594, 0.518631100654602, -0.06490960717201233, 0.46617594361305237, -0.658888041973114, 0.3361908495426178, -0.4292375147342682, -0.6439754366874695, 0.40002328157424927, -0.7301481366157532, 0.6784679889678955, 0.1242361068725586, -0.08085542917251587, 0.1909000277519226, -1.0001087188720703, 0.11486876755952835, -0.0356815867125988, -0.45752230286598206, -0.050420016050338745, -0.31044092774391174, 0.05472470447421074, 0.1568625122308731, 0.3140294551849365, -0.843948483467102, 0.08221705257892609, -0.49800097942352295, 0.7319668531417847, 0.5730143785476685, -0.19266289472579956, 0.6634728908538818, -0.20748132467269897, 0.5258018374443054, -0.37747642397880554, 0.13714227080345154, -0.2808000147342682, -0.6312830448150635, -0.9634501934051514, -0.19126258790493011, 0.5078045129776001, 0.17458577454090118, -0.19619855284690857, 0.46314695477485657, -0.49141719937324524, -0.6134080290794373, -0.17423805594444275, -0.20427516102790833, 0.32909244298934937, 0.3460892140865326, 0.05248499661684036, -0.25289255380630493, -0.2899986803531647, -0.8797709941864014, -0.41619545221328735, -0.27955296635627747, -0.18362382054328918, -0.09053505957126617, 0.32441258430480957, -0.10615120828151703, 0.8852580785751343, -0.08534753322601318, -0.11796493828296661, -0.2056066393852234, 0.07958320528268814, 0.35833147168159485, 0.4035443961620331, 0.4331629276275635, -0.4444410800933838, -0.45455795526504517, 0.07217774540185928, -0.5142686367034912, -0.22233669459819794, -0.1077963262796402, 0.15198613703250885, 0.35910212993621826, 0.9962174892425537, -0.5271164774894714, 0.16393856704235077, 0.5784826278686523, -0.45122891664505005, 0.3093830347061157, -0.6173511743545532, -0.3076838552951813, -1.1616277694702148, 0.12512236833572388, -0.1179003044962883, -0.25181758403778076, -0.8576436042785645, 0.17420564591884613, 0.3000640571117401, 0.05163878947496414, -0.180875763297081, 0.6155229806900024, -0.5480502843856812, -0.1847112476825714, -0.5374220013618469, 0.16519393026828766, -0.320835679769516, 0.4518870711326599, -0.5456278920173645, 0.8479622006416321, 0.41665613651275635, -0.4231336712837219, 0.055912889540195465, -0.20643672347068787, -0.24041135609149933, 0.334747314453125, -0.42532962560653687, 0.29060184955596924, -0.08872426301240921, 0.31455159187316895, -1.03740394115448, -0.031850285828113556, -0.04218008369207382, -0.46359485387802124, 0.4621572494506836, -0.10268017649650574, -0.8387908339500427, -0.1445092260837555, -0.22465230524539948, 0.31328150629997253, 0.5686433911323547, -0.7205051183700562, 0.7417953610420227, 0.41341426968574524, 0.037372369319200516, -0.24489784240722656, -0.6643431782722473, 0.7164902687072754, -0.2804839313030243, -0.4701273739337921, 0.234749898314476, -0.19128958880901337, -0.40803787112236023, -0.03947848081588745, 0.04375578463077545, 0.016769548878073692, 0.1224539577960968, 0.3069368600845337, 0.19152763485908508, -0.24777622520923615, 0.39731013774871826, -0.3076883852481842, -0.32733431458473206, 0.11269290745258331, -0.7007365226745605, 0.6792056560516357, -0.4952763020992279, -0.24001061916351318, -0.1860424280166626, 0.2855238616466522, 0.8472508788108826, -0.003404126735404134, 0.5823673009872437, 0.3363395035266876, -0.46858763694763184, 0.16522462666034698, -0.5506033897399902, 0.05827082693576813, -0.48864057660102844, 0.4382660686969757, -0.22197723388671875, -1.1993578672409058, 0.4372089207172394, -0.23012199997901917, 0.006513579748570919, 0.7047668099403381, 0.39673957228660583, 0.1814437210559845, 0.9198824763298035, 0.8242802023887634, -0.31594693660736084, 0.47049495577812195, 0.031222276389598846, 0.3637823462486267, -0.904148519039154, 0.020934132859110832, -0.453640341758728, -0.3283255100250244, -0.8765088319778442, -0.12107711285352707, 0.2117847502231598, 0.02889787033200264, -0.3256089687347412, 0.0431591235101223, -0.0589376725256443, 0.678727924823761, 0.5336858630180359, -0.47091594338417053, 0.3236221671104431, -0.13737909495830536, 0.018837496638298035, 0.06267029792070389, -0.9375384449958801, -0.7530716061592102, 1.3875010013580322, 0.5273531079292297, 0.31744709610939026, 0.12801414728164673, 0.4822639226913452, 0.01077025942504406, 0.5482943654060364, -0.8553441166877747, 0.8226367831230164, -0.6028954982757568, -0.29824429750442505, -0.1627669632434845, -0.42923298478126526, -0.8302390575408936, 0.13864946365356445, -0.19306300580501556, -0.6807289719581604, 0.00851035863161087, -0.11920766532421112, -0.5290406942367554, 0.6922312378883362, -0.7913805246353149, 0.6873564720153809, -0.28019458055496216, -0.17945878207683563, -0.19866158068180084, -0.5449927449226379, 0.30761244893074036, -0.27918270230293274, 0.17604905366897583, -0.041670337319374084, -0.27102556824684143, 0.7160800099372864, -0.6933607459068298, 0.8208900690078735, 0.15528690814971924, -0.2753719091415405, 0.07359779626131058, -0.08212351053953171, 0.3680662214756012, 0.06722821295261383, -0.18909111618995667, 0.3175320625305176, -0.3913397490978241, -0.4281579852104187, -0.6876648664474487, 1.036257266998291, -0.37533095479011536, -0.6568440198898315, -0.5430477261543274, -0.6027200222015381, -0.26428481936454773, 0.44442328810691833, 0.21361371874809265, 0.7565107345581055, -0.09304474294185638, 0.18636690080165863, 0.5499545931816101, 0.037059321999549866, 0.8053351640701294, 0.20620708167552948, -0.2333160936832428, -0.4999485909938812, 1.036736249923706, 0.2185649871826172, 0.464371919631958, 0.3745359182357788, 0.39537301659584045, -0.1470026820898056, -0.7625478506088257, -0.4605047404766083, 0.25126442313194275, -0.588694155216217, -0.062012407928705215, -0.5834395289421082, -0.18461468815803528, -0.06662896275520325, -0.13605475425720215, -0.22524291276931763, -0.45524248480796814, -0.48406973481178284, 0.0785592570900917, 0.41056346893310547, 0.9978204965591431, -0.0253337100148201, 0.38662630319595337, -0.8181535005569458, -0.25786319375038147, 0.21722105145454407, 0.5905246138572693, 0.2208094298839569, -0.7486348152160645, -0.26389235258102417, -0.13853558897972107, 0.1222720742225647, -0.5765586495399475, 0.30295151472091675, 0.30245649814605713, 0.10339964926242828, 0.513916015625, -0.38053590059280396, 0.6488938331604004, -0.6758373379707336, 0.671755313873291, 0.1316375732421875, -0.9294214844703674, -0.32958984375, -0.34341105818748474, 0.5689873099327087, 0.4095624089241028, 0.07334798574447632, -0.9790770411491394, -0.5096138119697571, -0.7516346573829651, -0.8968930244445801, 0.40630847215652466, 0.005690136458724737, 0.3976709246635437, -0.15875346958637238, 0.6875870823860168, 0.1209067776799202, 0.017099658027291298, -0.3098246157169342, -0.08044986426830292, 0.15944263339042664, -0.2248360514640808, -0.24237434566020966, -0.6125850081443787, 0.47583529353141785, -0.06700631231069565, 0.5991278886795044, -0.2909853756427765, 0.12280885130167007, -0.22040928900241852, 0.16825993359088898, 0.03254464268684387, 0.3263623118400574, 0.7243940830230713, 0.5266369581222534, -0.18922995030879974, 0.3320503234863281, 0.43652239441871643, -0.6757012605667114, -0.01433823723345995, -0.044534724205732346, -0.08895896375179291, -0.1559959053993225, 0.48875266313552856, 0.8155481815338135, 0.5205476880073547, -0.8695157170295715, 0.40113434195518494, -0.13103501498699188, -0.17529064416885376, -0.6070694923400879, -0.20557637512683868, 0.21871303021907806, 0.2618005573749542, 0.2607411742210388, 0.16171598434448242, -0.10772313922643661, -0.6469095349311829, 0.1293308287858963, 0.492672324180603, -0.35292378067970276, -0.308987557888031, 0.5557577610015869, -0.02748456783592701, -0.3990987241268158, 0.7327058911323547, -0.35969066619873047, -0.5086022615432739, 0.4045732915401459, 0.782260537147522, 1.0257089138031006, 0.24297553300857544, -0.05387110635638237, 0.37369391322135925, 0.2603365182876587, -0.33559659123420715, 0.017787260934710503, 0.28908926248550415, -0.6124475002288818, -0.3176078796386719, -0.5527793765068054, -0.2968277335166931, 0.13569943606853485, -0.30842193961143494, -0.0822286531329155, -0.7458840012550354, -0.266982764005661, -0.03479824587702751, 0.09617602825164795, -0.1949595808982849, 0.09491532295942307, 0.19264402985572815, 0.9666075110435486, -0.5348808169364929, 0.6464329361915588, 0.4575735926628113, -0.44932183623313904, -0.4653674364089966, 0.25131529569625854, -0.22493226826190948, -0.6232488751411438, 0.6326818466186523, 0.17992866039276123, -0.11397138237953186, 0.34330958127975464, -0.4287789463996887, -1.0778577327728271, 0.8543809056282043, 0.4774341285228729, -0.6312925219535828, 0.20950816571712494, 0.29749783873558044, 0.8105126023292542, -0.3013257086277008, 0.4260083734989166, 0.6179684400558472, 0.539277195930481, 0.011173316277563572, -0.8510774374008179, -0.07500270754098892, -0.398366779088974, 0.149602010846138, 0.591806173324585, -0.7890897393226624, 1.0525954961776733, -0.1988719403743744, -0.4652155637741089, 0.35554665327072144, 0.8416139483451843, -0.07306760549545288, 0.014767074026167393, 0.46274444460868835, 0.8108546733856201, 0.897631049156189, -0.03813304007053375, 1.1604814529418945, -0.2843160927295685, -0.00480212876573205, 0.9096683859825134, -0.2372078150510788, 1.0072087049484253, 0.5485108494758606, -0.04388215392827988, 0.25066688656806946, 0.5046775341033936, 0.09207413345575333, -0.0967959314584732, 0.5779003500938416, -0.3823302984237671, -0.3431849777698517, -0.28532686829566956, -0.03025798872113228, 0.4342992305755615, 0.19313594698905945, -0.17346955835819244, -0.25001439452171326, -0.14525899291038513, 0.4581397473812103, 0.20076869428157806, -0.42096567153930664, 0.5386282801628113, 0.15282580256462097, -0.40048810839653015, 0.4271189272403717, 0.1953609734773636, 0.8961566090583801, -0.5613638162612915, 0.12293485552072525, -0.38356974720954895, 0.3732708990573883, -0.06445043534040451, -0.5569728016853333, 0.02418304793536663, 0.28821858763694763, -0.04646454378962517, -0.2516533136367798, 0.7153381109237671, -0.47533902525901794, -0.6837971210479736, 0.14849859476089478, 0.26359808444976807, 0.236486554145813, -0.15321888029575348, 0.03905821591615677, -0.030773252248764038, -0.31432580947875977, -0.12819521129131317, 0.6078042387962341, 0.4147697389125824, -0.2049192488193512, 0.5924981236457825, 0.7528970241546631, 0.13658475875854492, 0.2982868254184723, 0.23710395395755768, 0.6977124214172363, -0.792533814907074, -0.31056898832321167, -0.9412537217140198, 0.08517377823591232, -0.12523847818374634, -0.607075572013855, 0.9561944007873535, 0.6410741806030273, 0.9127722978591919, 0.20308539271354675, 0.5552109479904175, 0.25110095739364624, -0.02012135460972786, -0.6103364825248718, 0.743213415145874, -0.6833328008651733, 0.009466025047004223, -0.07079386711120605, -0.9014977216720581, -0.7797096967697144, 0.11046996712684631, -0.20390364527702332, 0.22320148348808289, 0.6543012857437134, 0.6823379397392273, 0.3062240779399872, 0.1811160147190094, 0.3839157819747925, 0.17376640439033508, 0.364150732755661, 0.488956093788147, 0.7827558517456055, -0.47847601771354675, 0.4288206696510315, 0.13649745285511017, -0.2385759949684143, -0.22894605994224548, -1.0832184553146362, -0.7005373239517212, -0.48447972536087036, -0.06459630280733109, 0.0055011361837387085, -0.12218553572893143, 0.916251540184021, 0.2875744700431824, -0.5147402882575989, -0.4811054468154907, -0.3679509162902832, -0.1362466961145401, -0.1001172736287117, -0.1148780956864357, 0.32314956188201904, -0.47722747921943665, -0.8598257303237915, 0.5462679862976074, 0.5457656383514404, 0.08422164618968964, -0.4178653359413147, -0.0015554205747321248, -0.21059343218803406, 0.1868361383676529, 0.6763303875923157, 0.3073122501373291, -0.5407161116600037, -0.34142833948135376, 0.19295136630535126, -0.07555029541254044, 0.08380290865898132, 0.9842490553855896, -0.5381008982658386, 0.473762184381485, 0.5771238207817078, 0.720317542552948, 0.11594190448522568, -0.37521353363990784, 0.6303380131721497, -0.5064914226531982, -0.029634352773427963, 0.13594236969947815, 0.4717651903629303, 0.42731162905693054, -0.1783502697944641, 0.26264357566833496, 0.13522280752658844, -0.6437305808067322, -0.7840290069580078, 0.13290879130363464, -0.6533755660057068, -0.15279419720172882, 1.2582708597183228, 0.1437540054321289, -0.45288076996803284, 0.06360616534948349, -0.032549478113651276, 0.14447052776813507, -0.263017475605011, 0.5727118253707886, 0.7809433937072754, 0.11864664405584335, 0.08146938681602478, -0.559871256351471, 0.3757067024707794, 0.6526076197624207, -0.6652249693870544, 0.16815629601478577, 0.3572249114513397, -0.0033956081606447697, 0.16090793907642365, 0.5288060903549194, -0.19844242930412292, -0.04353725165128708, 0.16094408929347992, 0.05904056876897812, -0.2604305148124695, -0.3506052792072296, -0.7593087553977966, 0.19324465095996857, 0.31393492221832275, -0.22151412069797516 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17373v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17373v1	Arabic Tweet Act: A Weighted Ensemble Pre-Trained Transformer Model for Classifying Arabic Speech Acts on Twitter	2024-01-30T19:01:24	2024-01-30T19:01:24	Khadejaa Alshehri, Areej Alhothali, Nahed Alowidi	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Speech acts are a speakers actions when performing an utterance within a conversation, such as asking, recommending, greeting, or thanking someone, expressing a thought, or making a suggestion. Understanding speech acts helps interpret the intended meaning and actions behind a speakers or writers words. This paper proposes a Twitter dialectal Arabic speech act classification approach based on a transformer deep learning neural network. Twitter and social media, are becoming more and more integrated into daily life. As a result, they have evolved into a vital source of information that represents the views and attitudes of their users. We proposed a BERT based weighted ensemble learning approach to integrate the advantages of various BERT models in dialectal Arabic speech acts classification. We compared the proposed model against several variants of Arabic BERT models and sequence-based models. We developed a dialectal Arabic tweet act dataset by annotating a subset of a large existing Arabic sentiment analysis dataset (ASAD) based on six speech act categories. We also evaluated the models on a previously developed Arabic Tweet Act dataset (ArSAS). To overcome the class imbalance issue commonly observed in speech act problems, a transformer-based data augmentation model was implemented to generate an equal proportion of speech act categories. The results show that the best BERT model is araBERTv2-Twitter models with a macro-averaged F1 score and an accuracy of 0.73 and 0.84, respectively. The performance improved using a BERT-based ensemble method with a 0.74 and 0.85 averaged F1 score and accuracy on our dataset, respectively.	[ -0.1356220841407776, -0.7696245908737183, -0.029416974633932114, 0.2956830859184265, -0.24030239880084991, 0.2900821566581726, -0.18748052418231964, -0.29325512051582336, 0.3416772484779358, 0.3151968717575073, -0.49574920535087585, -0.5220250487327576, -0.9987510442733765, -0.4425952136516571, -0.7420950531959534, 0.6633445620536804, 0.14447778463363647, 0.31492698192596436, 0.49182820320129395, -0.37926822900772095, -0.330718457698822, -0.257810115814209, -1.0210522413253784, -0.3632620871067047, 0.3049326241016388, 0.23654404282569885, 0.5413413643836975, -0.24976959824562073, 0.42912155389785767, 0.4029877185821533, 0.05322481319308281, -0.020436469465494156, -0.2758168578147888, -0.05690666288137436, -0.028220899403095245, 0.12249381095170975, -0.38384565711021423, -0.16478347778320312, 0.5019230246543884, 0.4209258556365967, -0.41513872146606445, 0.19853712618350983, -0.05865165963768959, 0.3315976858139038, -0.3536387085914612, 0.14248329401016235, -0.4832521080970764, -0.1863139569759369, -0.07655772566795349, 0.25879254937171936, -0.17093133926391602, -0.7177406549453735, 0.30790817737579346, 0.21608752012252808, -0.03773904964327812, -0.23078900575637817, 0.5451021194458008, 0.06606538593769073, -0.32694682478904724, -0.11129553616046906, -0.566501796245575, 0.8440354466438293, -0.9510753154754639, 0.2098717838525772, 0.037882737815380096, 0.4990593492984772, 0.2790951728820801, -0.8385158181190491, -0.8045435547828674, -0.060778286308050156, 0.030034100636839867, -0.17765137553215027, -0.4895690679550171, -0.007397984620183706, -0.14277945458889008, -0.010785571299493313, -0.5262160301208496, -0.04332847520709038, -0.20114228129386902, -0.14391326904296875, 0.656913161277771, -0.27809715270996094, 0.47276756167411804, -0.21349124610424042, -0.22292350232601166, -0.28348514437675476, -0.24433504045009613, 0.13778217136859894, -0.017621833831071854, 0.6352975964546204, -0.2437315434217453, 0.2569892406463623, 0.004765298217535019, 0.2667447030544281, -0.03897562250494957, 0.1895296573638916, 0.2639475464820862, 0.42631447315216064, -0.3974510133266449, 0.4927466809749603, 0.7458871603012085, 0.03023761697113514, 0.7817728519439697, 0.005766882561147213, -0.4167904853820801, -0.2344522923231125, 0.516707718372345, -0.9100088477134705, 0.0066075557842850685, 0.3148595094680786, -0.402557373046875, -0.3206518888473511, 0.07615669071674347, -0.46382638812065125, -0.5039216876029968, -0.4477793872356415, 0.8702232837677002, -0.7124566435813904, -0.4156135618686676, -0.2512187659740448, 0.11584414541721344, 0.45403558015823364, 0.48342883586883545, -0.763676106929779, 0.4691992998123169, 0.7542991042137146, 0.6566877365112305, 0.04217299446463585, 0.06773582845926285, -0.35050681233406067, -0.13615991175174713, -0.3108031451702118, 0.5246710777282715, -0.6652823090553284, -0.22348593175411224, 0.5619995594024658, -0.2606140077114105, -0.2595606744289398, -0.28912803530693054, 0.7612690329551697, -0.905141294002533, 0.1294173300266266, -0.03771645575761795, -0.6833810210227966, -0.615423858165741, 0.08842148631811142, -0.5662788152694702, 0.7317561507225037, 0.3508714437484741, -0.4434930384159088, 0.31554678082466125, -0.9036811590194702, -0.7816535234451294, 0.22713603079319, -0.09999628365039825, -0.26057279109954834, 0.009531219489872456, 0.5243208408355713, 0.6926010251045227, 0.08074069768190384, 0.260385662317276, -0.14643573760986328, -0.44600531458854675, 0.4615638256072998, -0.33197078108787537, 1.0173910856246948, 0.19806380569934845, -0.4865821301937103, 0.09333721548318863, -0.21435335278511047, 0.2669356167316437, -0.1645050048828125, 0.13273951411247253, -0.006453546695411205, 0.14757336676120758, 0.5711836814880371, 0.15290680527687073, -0.028692953288555145, -0.5700243711471558, -0.01235605776309967, -0.5596414804458618, 0.4010198414325714, 0.6986123919487, 0.13510747253894806, 0.18049369752407074, -0.4066270589828491, 0.14472024142742157, -0.002833928680047393, 0.03684139624238014, 0.46711841225624084, -0.42675235867500305, -0.5785627961158752, -0.2601241171360016, 0.4203267991542816, 0.6001700758934021, -0.8089805841445923, 0.7063831686973572, -0.7397936582565308, -0.6392319202423096, -0.7381452322006226, -0.16780275106430054, -0.04338293522596359, 0.32982105016708374, 0.3472829759120941, -0.01561698503792286, -0.5362533926963806, -0.7025145888328552, -0.3327140808105469, -0.4032105803489685, 0.10208980739116669, 0.08378084748983383, 0.37902894616127014, -0.10243736952543259, 1.0314942598342896, -0.05661002919077873, -0.4367040693759918, -0.7373013496398926, 0.6646422743797302, 0.21653315424919128, 0.24451902508735657, 0.7706567645072937, -0.9674310684204102, -0.6741247773170471, -0.09498295187950134, -0.24051515758037567, -0.40766623616218567, 0.23802530765533447, 0.2917453348636627, 0.33216947317123413, 0.16114680469036102, -0.5582596659660339, 0.34378713369369507, 0.3886096477508545, -0.23569318652153015, -0.1712181717157364, 0.5667814016342163, 0.4611838757991791, -1.3597279787063599, -0.26647377014160156, -0.010422913357615471, -0.3270590603351593, -1.0534579753875732, -0.2324572503566742, -0.1433345228433609, -0.019338207319378853, -0.6651318669319153, 0.5524100065231323, 0.5020360946655273, 0.0995180532336235, -0.4617745280265808, -0.383799284696579, -0.47471317648887634, 0.4825153648853302, 0.03596081957221031, 0.6451917886734009, 0.5658109188079834, -0.43359506130218506, 0.24722272157669067, 0.1316961795091629, -0.6488683819770813, 0.2582208514213562, -0.5613573789596558, 0.156901016831398, -0.0434342697262764, 0.14524893462657928, -1.274065613746643, -0.22124280035495758, 0.22477413713932037, -0.8351362943649292, 0.45547613501548767, 0.06236208230257034, -0.30662617087364197, -0.16148324310779572, -0.2807457745075226, 0.22875843942165375, 0.7382360100746155, -0.4029877185821533, 1.2062194347381592, 0.2739195227622986, -0.3911310136318207, -0.7032071352005005, -0.663209080696106, 0.0075663113966584206, -0.2926553189754486, -0.7588311433792114, 0.26094526052474976, 0.5089436769485474, -0.43839871883392334, -0.011421158909797668, -0.046094879508018494, -0.2768661677837372, -0.03760775178670883, 0.2651819586753845, -0.01951267197728157, -0.07137935608625412, 0.18495096266269684, 0.18804946541786194, 0.5420019626617432, 0.03252704069018364, -0.2888580858707428, 0.7675600647926331, 0.039854925125837326, -0.12192264199256897, -0.792820394039154, 0.3591679334640503, 0.6543781757354736, -0.10085305571556091, 0.8300283551216125, 1.3383561372756958, -0.4186854362487793, -0.37623071670532227, -0.7567983865737915, -0.28507211804389954, -0.43932464718818665, 0.2783685326576233, 0.020000938326120377, -0.7554218173027039, 0.24502921104431152, -0.037193216383457184, 0.1592676192522049, 0.5209004878997803, 0.6927690505981445, -0.4691612422466278, 0.6956970691680908, 0.5244731307029724, -0.6896882653236389, 0.9291021227836609, -0.2865874469280243, 0.4430418014526367, -0.2289859503507614, 0.04074631258845329, -0.4825930595397949, -0.7326257228851318, -0.6184574365615845, -0.3866487741470337, 0.4369807541370392, -0.5112916827201843, -0.49028676748275757, 0.3103094696998596, -0.14263932406902313, -0.0864332765340805, 0.5303733944892883, 0.2336047887802124, -0.37563225626945496, 0.5855668187141418, 0.4509497880935669, 0.13430161774158478, -0.2879660427570343, -0.5673365592956543, 0.9484302401542664, 0.2666172981262207, 0.6232503652572632, 0.5746154189109802, 0.8087334632873535, 1.257306456565857, 0.6515403389930725, -0.9345785975456238, 0.5751627683639526, -0.2650938332080841, -0.34843090176582336, -0.5136010050773621, -0.3394339978694916, -0.6631197333335876, -0.007020076736807823, 0.054972533136606216, -0.871026873588562, 0.07858604937791824, -0.3510538339614868, -0.326813668012619, 0.18485376238822937, -0.8014187812805176, 0.5037680864334106, -0.11331617832183838, -0.08236807584762573, -0.4991808831691742, -0.5764530897140503, 0.06943202763795853, -0.08307831734418869, 0.3739800751209259, -0.11631526052951813, 0.12565231323242188, 1.1165440082550049, -0.41756734251976013, 0.9365141987800598, -0.6180219650268555, 0.0782507061958313, 0.5561875700950623, -0.062186989933252335, 0.4901915192604065, -0.42367881536483765, -0.32407131791114807, 0.4024397134780884, -0.2459573745727539, -0.39177682995796204, -0.659858763217926, 0.36461660265922546, -1.0499086380004883, -0.365479439496994, -0.20431697368621826, -0.24317972362041473, -0.4900604486465454, -0.12230087071657181, -0.047386158257722855, 0.5028672218322754, -0.3318036198616028, 0.2605949938297272, 0.2715965807437897, 0.15277555584907532, 0.8828327655792236, 0.6943368911743164, 0.07273916900157928, -0.5369945764541626, 0.8040481209754944, 0.17912186682224274, -0.0695897564291954, 0.6083102822303772, 0.05470672622323036, -0.48962584137916565, -0.5400274395942688, -0.18867769837379456, -0.10176846385002136, -0.5084758400917053, -0.13457156717777252, -0.5329925417900085, -0.43525758385658264, -0.8893054127693176, 0.01350891962647438, 0.12444208562374115, -0.5078147053718567, 0.07120546698570251, -0.07756180316209793, 0.40360528230667114, 0.5498448014259338, 0.05673200637102127, 0.8675833344459534, -0.6799903512001038, 0.17040115594863892, 0.42601555585861206, -0.00614613201469183, 0.11109080910682678, -0.9906832575798035, -0.11900166422128677, 0.12840242683887482, -0.5245997309684753, -0.7690110206604004, 0.5108956694602966, 0.48718658089637756, 0.20778752863407135, 0.6135692000389099, 0.1358594000339508, 0.47285032272338867, -0.5585653781890869, 0.887323260307312, 0.11776653677225113, -1.0599404573440552, 0.4072308838367462, -0.14068791270256042, -0.09092476218938828, 0.29067152738571167, 0.35551491379737854, -0.6259427666664124, -0.22728411853313446, -0.6511708498001099, -0.7226998805999756, 0.9524153470993042, 0.6019155979156494, 0.636082112789154, 0.18232764303684235, -0.03740210458636284, -0.09387332946062088, 0.32606929540634155, -0.6915083527565002, -0.15750132501125336, -0.30600666999816895, -0.6090531945228577, 0.0018229236593469977, -0.1789463311433792, -0.056174539029598236, -0.41886618733406067, 0.6910045742988586, 0.09640936553478241, 0.3681369125843048, -0.031292062252759933, -0.17273564636707306, -0.18254664540290833, 0.5759029984474182, 0.41556474566459656, 0.39829233288764954, -0.3583141565322876, -0.24411995708942413, 0.2965054214000702, -0.49462708830833435, 0.21138423681259155, 0.31724119186401367, 0.11612140387296677, 0.06052711233496666, 0.6883273124694824, 0.8009413480758667, -0.07284437119960785, -0.6025751233100891, 0.7482020854949951, 0.19917206466197968, -0.16408267617225647, -0.4629885256290436, 0.029120681807398796, -0.08533622324466705, 0.3632142245769501, 0.6368508338928223, 0.15652769804000854, 0.1864902675151825, -0.5912339687347412, 0.33446186780929565, 0.3175000846385956, -0.5692383050918579, -0.1770544946193695, 0.13356418907642365, 0.25813210010528564, -0.5464081168174744, 0.5864894986152649, -0.1623246669769287, -0.8229634761810303, 0.5300309062004089, 0.10245261341333389, 1.308540940284729, -0.7667986750602722, 0.37841859459877014, -0.010894102975726128, 0.3281363248825073, 0.30526724457740784, 0.61268150806427, -0.16810214519500732, -0.9658471345901489, -0.3975135385990143, -0.7459860444068909, -0.41920772194862366, 0.2761414349079132, -0.3315955698490143, 0.14462444186210632, -0.30656152963638306, -0.24539199471473694, 0.1328735500574112, 0.017526837065815926, -0.4666479825973511, 0.505097508430481, 0.48573800921440125, 0.6962130069732666, -0.9948998689651489, 1.0125707387924194, 0.7774769067764282, -0.1532292664051056, -0.965819776058197, 0.4368814527988434, -0.10101791471242905, -0.9472200870513916, 0.7141597867012024, 0.1811375766992569, -0.1789902299642563, 0.10244879871606827, -0.5974652767181396, -0.7262887954711914, 0.7909453511238098, 0.1809244602918625, -0.17110028862953186, 0.27078917622566223, 0.5229014754295349, 0.667893648147583, -0.38545796275138855, 0.5134513974189758, 0.37541529536247253, 0.36919015645980835, 0.46258509159088135, -0.6696022748947144, -0.09858441352844238, -0.003772170515730977, -0.1944536417722702, 0.1762373149394989, -0.566950798034668, 0.7493464946746826, 0.19230742752552032, -0.07381371408700943, -0.1136690229177475, 0.800391674041748, -0.2870042026042938, 0.42260658740997314, 0.7041174173355103, 0.4432962238788605, 0.5206485986709595, -0.2816171646118164, 0.8003790378570557, -0.08119156956672668, 0.2566804885864258, 0.6690627336502075, -0.4705349802970886, 1.1043893098831177, 0.1227700412273407, -0.36232900619506836, 0.7780075669288635, 0.4605269730091095, 0.08457818627357483, 0.6128112077713013, 0.1168433427810669, -0.57314532995224, -0.1956622451543808, -0.3034874498844147, -0.00361243705265224, 0.6360844969749451, 0.6370200514793396, -0.30260106921195984, -0.3899807035923004, 0.15932045876979828, -0.1827540099620819, -0.11159118264913559, -0.5183262228965759, 0.8522576093673706, 0.11424976587295532, -0.509465754032135, 0.31212761998176575, 0.12789998948574066, 0.3279573321342468, -0.5739810466766357, 0.07442281395196915, 0.06444323062896729, 0.09847671538591385, -0.2689676582813263, -0.7267721891403198, 0.3160165250301361, 0.12125975638628006, 0.13599702715873718, -0.27009785175323486, 0.7167549133300781, -0.3631853759288788, -0.6806443333625793, 0.23795583844184875, 0.393570214509964, 0.056283947080373764, -0.29592186212539673, -0.7661500573158264, -0.08260006457567215, -0.0238563884049654, -0.2671598196029663, -0.0345953144133091, 0.33984512090682983, -0.09201917797327042, 0.46954160928726196, 0.19121317565441132, 0.0026271487586200237, -0.1339203119277954, 0.6236317157745361, 0.6554096341133118, -0.4033498466014862, -0.3077883720397949, -0.8524162769317627, 0.47901180386543274, -0.2599709630012512, 0.15483541786670685, 0.29959219694137573, 0.17660324275493622, 0.4045499265193939, -0.005463277455419302, 0.8301652669906616, -0.4545237421989441, 0.8546785712242126, -0.26380857825279236, 0.8886555433273315, -0.511061429977417, 0.11462540924549103, -0.33637768030166626, -0.5981384515762329, 0.05275704339146614, 0.36861321330070496, -0.5544964671134949, 0.5657942295074463, 0.3408205509185791, 0.7582615613937378, -0.11377592384815216, 0.44827860593795776, 0.2412073165178299, 0.3307945728302002, 0.3719159662723541, 0.19947774708271027, 0.6732109785079956, -0.522428035736084, 0.30243629217147827, -0.10673485696315765, -0.025646628811955452, -0.32796019315719604, -0.3264912962913513, -0.9227745532989502, -0.5146436095237732, -0.16612136363983154, -0.2425829917192459, -0.00872099306434393, 1.4858680963516235, 0.7107398509979248, -1.244286298751831, -0.4278380572795868, 0.10518891364336014, 0.03498965501785278, -0.40721821784973145, -0.338370144367218, 0.7160672545433044, -0.5119056701660156, -0.9222944974899292, 0.19821278750896454, -0.17250825464725494, -0.0003937792789656669, 0.33488163352012634, 0.15956728160381317, -0.281417578458786, 0.5273599624633789, 0.7388546466827393, -0.13511474430561066, -0.7561816573143005, -0.3983311355113983, -0.3185974657535553, -0.04355189576745033, -0.176393061876297, 0.653760552406311, -0.7388471364974976, 0.0513150654733181, 0.17959129810333252, 0.7583596110343933, 0.13409942388534546, 0.17513416707515717, 0.3503458499908447, -1.0571620464324951, -0.2498701959848404, 0.6373469829559326, 0.3590409457683563, 0.3019344210624695, 0.008051121607422829, 0.2536187767982483, -0.036650318652391434, -0.33820176124572754, -0.36852216720581055, -0.1027141883969307, -1.3153502941131592, -0.24730756878852844, 1.0402109622955322, 0.13475826382637024, -0.052402060478925705, 0.01817658357322216, -0.29343467950820923, 0.5419467091560364, -0.9034815430641174, 1.0728155374526978, 0.7319507002830505, 0.01416949462145567, -0.15011005103588104, -0.2557048797607422, 0.531059205532074, 0.6078944206237793, -0.5652166604995728, -0.20142139494419098, 0.04557134211063385, 0.061685897409915924, 0.027101930230855942, 0.26983121037483215, 0.26690372824668884, 0.28527015447616577, -0.545326828956604, 0.05129466950893402, 0.36083734035491943, -0.007359212730079889, -0.39401867985725403, 0.6577785015106201, -0.24256445467472076, -0.35206976532936096 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17268v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17268v1	Weaver: Foundation Models for Creative Writing	2024-01-30T18:58:43	2024-01-30T18:58:43	Tiannan Wang, Jiamin Chen, Qingrui Jia, Shuai Wang, Ruoyu Fang, Huilin Wang, Zhaowei Gao, Chunzhao Xie, Chuou Xu, Jihong Dai, Yibin Liu, Jialong Wu, Shengwei Ding, Long Li, Zhiwei Huang, Xinle Deng, Teng Yu, Gangan Ma, Han Xiao, Zixin Chen, Danjun Xiang, Yunxia Wang, Yuanyuan Zhu, Yi Xiao, Jing Wang, Yiru Wang, Siran Ding, Jiayang Huang, Jiayi Xu, Yilihamu Tayier, Zhenyu Hu, Yuan Gao, Chengfeng Zheng, Yueshu Ye, Yihang Li, Lei Wan, Xinyue Jiang, Yujie Wang, Siyu Cheng, Zhule Song, Xiangru Tang, Xiaohua Xu, Ningyu Zhang, Huajun Chen, Yuchen Eleanor Jiang, Wangchunshu Zhou	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG	This work introduces Weaver, our first family of large language models (LLMs) dedicated to content creation. Weaver is pre-trained on a carefully selected corpus that focuses on improving the writing capabilities of large language models. We then fine-tune Weaver for creative and professional writing purposes and align it to the preference of professional writers using a suit of novel methods for instruction data synthesis and LLM alignment, making it able to produce more human-like texts and follow more diverse instructions for content creation. The Weaver family consists of models of Weaver Mini (1.8B), Weaver Base (6B), Weaver Pro (14B), and Weaver Ultra (34B) sizes, suitable for different applications and can be dynamically dispatched by a routing agent according to query complexity to balance response quality and computation cost. Evaluation on a carefully curated benchmark for assessing the writing capabilities of LLMs shows Weaver models of all sizes outperform generalist LLMs several times larger than them. Notably, our most-capable Weaver Ultra model surpasses GPT-4, a state-of-the-art generalist LLM, on various writing scenarios, demonstrating the advantage of training specialized LLMs for writing purposes. Moreover, Weaver natively supports retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) and function calling (tool usage). We present various use cases of these abilities for improving AI-assisted writing systems, including integration of external knowledge bases, tools, or APIs, and providing personalized writing assistance. Furthermore, we discuss and summarize a guideline and best practices for pre-training and fine-tuning domain-specific LLMs.	[ -0.25510284304618835, -0.763970136642456, 0.6240939497947693, 0.07375840842723846, 0.07091882824897766, 0.40741080045700073, -0.2814091145992279, -0.4618692696094513, 0.09013756364583969, 0.8072531223297119, -0.572221040725708, -0.5407450795173645, -0.65628582239151, 0.14729087054729462, -0.5932548642158508, 1.0064465999603271, -0.12512549757957458, 0.03461231663823128, -0.3112615644931793, 0.07004915177822113, -0.43963950872421265, -0.33966541290283203, -0.789444088935852, 0.024063926190137863, 0.8361283540725708, 0.35342758893966675, 0.5490918159484863, 0.5415616035461426, 0.7207627296447754, 0.35523712635040283, -0.10394977033138275, 0.47411882877349854, -0.7017785310745239, 0.023323841392993927, -0.32468780875205994, -0.43489640951156616, -0.7516223192214966, 0.07603903114795685, 0.7238725423812866, 1.023362636566162, 0.025123871862888336, 0.23049890995025635, 0.016306420788168907, 0.714364767074585, -0.5978127717971802, -0.3129739761352539, -0.5314304828643799, 0.029959987848997116, -0.47768038511276245, -0.07319361716508865, -0.4679917097091675, -0.47778353095054626, 0.1912834346294403, -0.5489325523376465, 0.4115760326385498, 0.16229355335235596, 0.6575866341590881, 0.13189375400543213, -0.5168131589889526, -0.7007668018341064, -0.8539208173751831, 0.7427272796630859, -0.7247847318649292, 0.24437308311462402, 0.12713153660297394, 0.15255974233150482, -0.3716035783290863, -0.8775390982627869, -0.694830060005188, -0.22609391808509827, 0.24881847202777863, 0.2634612023830414, -0.02256636694073677, 0.0072250873781740665, -0.04203422740101814, 0.8062423467636108, -0.543420135974884, 0.1336543709039688, -0.1126081719994545, 0.20585261285305023, 0.558504581451416, 0.5689475536346436, 0.0323592834174633, 0.3461265563964844, -0.02495347149670124, 0.16008904576301575, -0.8215298056602478, -0.04525475949048996, 0.6437130570411682, -0.06018820405006409, 0.0039051922503858805, 0.7828684449195862, -0.09278944879770279, 0.9983699917793274, 0.267014741897583, -0.23334349691867828, -0.3030529022216797, -0.24451057612895966, -0.07020597159862518, -0.4242021143436432, 0.5236691832542419, 0.490516722202301, 0.3851325511932373, -0.3956502377986908, -0.21509131789207458, -0.023881344124674797, 0.41128310561180115, -0.3931640684604645, 0.034711647778749466, -0.08632173389196396, -0.5848146080970764, -0.5103889107704163, 0.06912931799888611, -0.6268768906593323, -0.7826924920082092, -0.5344467759132385, 0.13679702579975128, -0.30254435539245605, -0.2926672697067261, 0.35973960161209106, -0.23134881258010864, 0.23047766089439392, 0.27590125799179077, -1.1161274909973145, 0.3480511009693146, 0.5591449737548828, 0.5381492376327515, -0.34670010209083557, -0.3849186301231384, -0.18497280776500702, 0.6024883985519409, -0.6540435552597046, 0.9812414050102234, -0.3347189128398895, -0.4994024336338043, 0.04671858623623848, -0.34902670979499817, -0.0259476937353611, -0.31312474608421326, 0.6007655262947083, -0.3935798406600952, 0.3809598386287689, 0.2165771722793579, -0.7638667821884155, -0.04748262092471123, 0.2267093062400818, -0.6627835631370544, 0.621326744556427, 0.590750515460968, -0.6469246745109558, 0.03944895789027214, -0.35600703954696655, -0.46113356947898865, -0.0196970347315073, 0.18712587654590607, -0.2690686583518982, 0.45500123500823975, -0.284257709980011, 0.3548087477684021, -0.6317241191864014, 0.09400375187397003, 0.11281658709049225, -0.3152811825275421, 0.30951493978500366, -0.2618718445301056, 0.509008526802063, 0.36158648133277893, -0.1752549409866333, 0.18683625757694244, -1.0911275148391724, 0.18662935495376587, 0.0881451964378357, -0.7938950657844543, 0.34235045313835144, -0.00932345725595951, 0.00282976683229208, -0.43583112955093384, 0.24717214703559875, -0.44097068905830383, 0.21328586339950562, -0.42598316073417664, 0.2998983860015869, 0.6651288866996765, -0.19067184627056122, 0.6241579055786133, -0.6423007845878601, 0.8574219942092896, -0.43262654542922974, -0.07802238315343857, -0.23753084242343903, -0.2862156331539154, -1.0905014276504517, -0.24622899293899536, 0.38770225644111633, 0.511481523513794, -0.34434303641319275, 0.5175375938415527, -0.07016211748123169, -0.9088051319122314, -0.40967875719070435, 0.368644118309021, 0.5995310544967651, 0.7004410028457642, 0.1308809071779251, -0.3306162357330322, -0.6656502485275269, -0.5318447947502136, -0.3555004596710205, 0.06992516666650772, 0.21208526194095612, 0.0010485658422112465, -0.11940653622150421, -0.5107979774475098, 0.9356848001480103, -0.604056179523468, -0.31640663743019104, -0.7376731634140015, 0.08732017129659653, 0.30934229493141174, 0.44061243534088135, 0.5954187512397766, -0.6724443435668945, -0.8141551613807678, -0.17395614087581635, -0.6648293733596802, -0.30843761563301086, -0.3752270042896271, -0.3913603127002716, 0.518944263458252, 0.30671700835227966, -0.8451012372970581, 0.42621201276779175, 0.6897086501121521, -0.5413267612457275, 0.8495769500732422, 0.058714836835861206, -0.07856058329343796, -0.9989454746246338, 0.04467901587486267, -0.2063296139240265, -0.11614405363798141, -0.5693902969360352, 0.3137267529964447, -0.2791445255279541, -0.09350825101137161, -0.07060517370700836, 0.7162905335426331, -0.6568154096603394, 0.22999759018421173, -0.4514271020889282, -0.17206543684005737, 0.31427717208862305, 0.2645004987716675, 0.018648279830813408, 0.5263209939002991, 0.3834261894226074, -0.3300073444843292, 0.520885169506073, 0.3604823648929596, -0.20130646228790283, 0.48022451996803284, -0.5181934237480164, 0.17439450323581696, -0.04799109324812889, 0.2209920585155487, -0.7579208612442017, -0.19854949414730072, 0.06269463896751404, -0.3529532551765442, 0.33516788482666016, 0.006838815286755562, -0.45139795541763306, -0.37172022461891174, -0.06074407324194908, -0.13230744004249573, 0.5174242854118347, -0.11441199481487274, 0.9419193863868713, 0.16078510880470276, -0.40405774116516113, -0.1246272549033165, -0.7211499810218811, 0.3130115568637848, -0.19352726638317108, -0.8654257655143738, 0.37733620405197144, -0.4728030860424042, -0.16102808713912964, 0.040826216340065, 0.2823120951652527, -0.04994061589241028, 0.17224900424480438, 0.13294383883476257, 0.15828905999660492, -0.36331605911254883, -0.12272099405527115, -0.09749168902635574, -0.2680966854095459, -0.22345101833343506, -0.2377704679965973, 0.6406002640724182, -0.1739971935749054, -0.29581737518310547, -0.148668572306633, 0.6787027716636658, 0.19244332611560822, -0.4120030999183655, 0.6150893568992615, 0.591488778591156, -0.06039513275027275, -0.3221934735774994, -0.8099415898323059, 0.40674251317977905, -0.4953484535217285, 0.07175281643867493, -0.34912124276161194, -0.8225665092468262, 0.23313061892986298, -0.04433230310678482, 0.08041950315237045, 0.39951181411743164, 0.6376311182975769, -0.17850930988788605, 0.7706512212753296, 1.0123651027679443, 0.32154661417007446, 0.5764651894569397, -0.48432081937789917, 0.41412997245788574, -0.904517412185669, -0.015464152209460735, -0.30208757519721985, -0.26102814078330994, -0.19222144782543182, -0.2644006311893463, 0.07360738515853882, 0.39116406440734863, -0.22847901284694672, 0.18144023418426514, -0.6134799718856812, 0.6007001996040344, 1.0680363178253174, -0.34636396169662476, 0.3318691551685333, -0.11881181597709656, -0.10674270242452621, 0.15392005443572998, -0.6412160396575928, -0.8908911943435669, 1.343758225440979, 0.11941692978143692, 0.8603941202163696, 0.22040072083473206, 0.6077448725700378, 0.11355248838663101, 0.18144641816616058, -0.5417996048927307, 0.6596493721008301, -0.40965577960014343, -0.504471480846405, -0.23971831798553467, -0.06246553361415863, -0.6723433136940002, -0.15744751691818237, -0.47275131940841675, -0.1855454295873642, -0.0795639380812645, 0.18803216516971588, -0.49388378858566284, 0.2904202938079834, -0.8435454964637756, 0.6884564161300659, -0.3676963150501251, -0.5634641051292419, -0.14041846990585327, -0.48835650086402893, 0.1467147022485733, -0.1667250394821167, -0.08138587325811386, 0.01077527366578579, 0.0014132187934592366, 0.34130823612213135, -0.1485493779182434, 0.9275174140930176, 0.17058876156806946, -0.0930115133523941, 0.6550955772399902, 0.37518709897994995, 0.26024219393730164, -0.20569631457328796, -0.40998566150665283, -0.05545207858085632, -0.13086682558059692, -0.03584788739681244, -0.26887962222099304, 0.4374088644981384, -0.6156222224235535, -0.8070138692855835, -0.26818329095840454, -0.7223885655403137, -0.3269747495651245, 0.5750452280044556, 0.4032495617866516, 0.572749137878418, -0.31593057513237, 0.2956506907939911, 0.5861762166023254, -0.07899226248264313, 0.4647793769836426, 0.579876720905304, -0.14740359783172607, -0.4586690366268158, 0.7508593201637268, 0.04147578030824661, 0.20607894659042358, 0.2976742386817932, 0.2021380364894867, 0.05817524343729019, -1.0543490648269653, -0.5144859552383423, 0.047016873955726624, -0.6864608526229858, -0.20539802312850952, -0.6373586654663086, -0.4247812032699585, -0.680074155330658, -0.8265600800514221, -0.15352678298950195, -0.6807637810707092, -0.47763562202453613, -0.014746519736945629, 0.1731671541929245, 1.0147600173950195, -0.10754908621311188, 0.6971749663352966, -0.8923502564430237, 0.31221896409988403, -0.07416984438896179, 0.44874081015586853, 0.11374346166849136, -0.22360609471797943, -0.39386606216430664, -0.1152869239449501, -0.8020820617675781, -0.3962118625640869, 0.25590643286705017, 0.2855348289012909, 0.7075846791267395, 0.4002056419849396, -0.346017986536026, 0.5043650269508362, -0.7603001594543457, 0.9279457330703735, 0.33527177572250366, -0.9030116200447083, 0.40129590034484863, -0.748127281665802, 0.2343795746564865, 0.44635009765625, 0.2898331880569458, -0.6419298648834229, -0.4336647689342499, -0.41553419828414917, -0.7631596326828003, 0.22928626835346222, -0.12434172630310059, 0.2750180661678314, -0.11648350208997726, 0.5014438629150391, 0.28220921754837036, 0.3297511637210846, -0.6768273711204529, 0.39284035563468933, -0.1323181539773941, -0.7916700839996338, -0.16898703575134277, -0.48535794019699097, -0.280077189207077, 0.01267946045845747, 0.5467636585235596, -0.13991881906986237, 0.15470997989177704, 0.07532922923564911, -0.020501477643847466, -0.17691490054130554, -0.05990036204457283, 0.5262680053710938, 1.0093024969100952, 0.14661124348640442, -0.08859386295080185, 0.020845433697104454, -0.33907774090766907, -0.005188922863453627, 0.0060273343697190285, -0.1793302297592163, -0.2736549973487854, 0.9554672241210938, 0.5548115968704224, 0.1887575387954712, -0.8940645456314087, 0.4543485939502716, 0.126070037484169, -0.13665767014026642, -0.6782932877540588, 0.5414727330207825, 0.4458529055118561, 0.21175415813922882, 0.08536992222070694, 0.07509355247020721, 0.14437316358089447, -0.4311894476413727, -0.2885568141937256, 0.47072678804397583, -0.007205847650766373, -0.19728687405586243, 0.688418447971344, 0.5023189187049866, -0.5506529211997986, 0.47438710927963257, -0.08328936994075775, -0.30301204323768616, 0.4681915044784546, 0.6931790709495544, 0.880672037601471, 0.08861241489648819, 0.20724324882030487, -0.06468287110328674, -0.08133327215909958, 0.06897904723882675, 0.3024578094482422, 0.1672852635383606, -0.6269949674606323, -0.041022878140211105, -0.8944956064224243, -0.4645159840583801, -0.47320982813835144, -0.3353746235370636, 0.3882794678211212, -0.7509588003158569, -0.1404455006122589, -0.21820291876792908, 0.1999778151512146, -0.6254231333732605, 0.2638949453830719, 0.14165404438972473, 1.0522977113723755, -0.20537911355495453, 0.45106080174446106, 0.7259590029716492, -0.5349453091621399, -0.7027260065078735, -0.27769750356674194, 0.12733130156993866, -0.45838502049446106, 0.29243335127830505, 0.06433555483818054, -0.4617955982685089, 0.43113407492637634, -0.5170932412147522, -0.9716301560401917, 1.274857997894287, 0.16232122480869293, -0.5338311791419983, -0.42950719594955444, 0.3911098539829254, 0.7786793112754822, -0.8015131950378418, -0.021002784371376038, 0.3068189024925232, 0.2064555138349533, 0.12425926327705383, -0.5571103692054749, -0.3282024562358856, -0.16773004829883575, 0.16613885760307312, -0.16922257840633392, -0.9434433579444885, 1.0180221796035767, -0.1915380209684372, -0.03862408921122551, 0.8820971846580505, 0.38406696915626526, 0.30884432792663574, 0.16984844207763672, 0.251090943813324, 0.8054893016815186, 0.7299699187278748, 0.003117548767477274, 1.1310831308364868, -0.36142662167549133, -0.3108203709125519, 1.0748094320297241, -0.4444889724254608, 0.6793916821479797, 0.2841395139694214, 0.1762256920337677, 0.8688660860061646, 0.42523831129074097, -0.26817968487739563, 0.3939823806285858, 0.392123281955719, -0.29392513632774353, -0.0560779869556427, -0.09245620667934418, -0.22406867146492004, 0.3987070322036743, -0.05829472839832306, -0.364560604095459, 0.10662462562322617, -0.09378159791231155, 0.012823810800909996, 0.5956382155418396, -0.31504806876182556, 0.9709955453872681, 0.0622861422598362, -0.6586279273033142, 0.1416059136390686, 0.19400906562805176, 0.5251033306121826, -0.8132167458534241, 0.09938333928585052, -0.27815699577331543, 0.4938547909259796, -0.2966965436935425, -0.9598615765571594, 0.4310051202774048, 0.21212954819202423, -0.5910588502883911, -0.4627276062965393, 0.6051609516143799, -0.2628955543041229, -0.861640214920044, 0.13783882558345795, 0.2942841053009033, -0.23665079474449158, 0.1681550145149231, -0.27899864315986633, 0.2734614312648773, -0.22055348753929138, -0.5118710994720459, -0.07641024142503738, 0.6540862917900085, 0.09161046892404556, 0.6945176720619202, 0.768919825553894, 0.5071988105773926, 0.37987881898880005, 0.12955215573310852, 0.8010857105255127, -0.6972204446792603, -0.5103935599327087, -0.39157798886299133, 0.871722400188446, -0.1847098171710968, -0.6677208542823792, 0.6975619792938232, 0.6084054708480835, 0.7889497876167297, -0.2490188032388687, 0.8861380815505981, -0.1918264776468277, 1.1053866147994995, -0.6173280477523804, 0.8824430704116821, -0.32444193959236145, -0.05286109447479248, -0.12732911109924316, -1.103340983390808, -0.36757224798202515, 0.3504196107387543, -0.14582043886184692, -0.057823337614536285, 0.7027496695518494, 0.670594334602356, 0.14489206671714783, -0.010518167167901993, 0.13731327652931213, -0.09402146190404892, 0.4690806567668915, 0.5475571751594543, 1.0278940200805664, -0.08434122055768967, 0.5246948599815369, -0.07322478294372559, -0.3681407570838928, 0.012625771574676037, -1.0528597831726074, -1.091042160987854, -0.44783592224121094, -0.038096100091934204, -0.052205342799425125, -0.053836967796087265, 0.4529879093170166, 0.7093001008033752, -0.48040518164634705, -0.29502618312835693, -0.23426945507526398, -0.12885089218616486, 0.04134710878133774, -0.16266845166683197, 0.027814948931336403, -0.35788238048553467, -0.7281134724617004, 0.3859551250934601, 0.05492989718914032, 0.1892428994178772, -0.38250645995140076, -0.19117186963558197, -0.13643063604831696, 0.4525326192378998, 0.5692073702812195, 0.01467497181147337, -0.5496284365653992, -0.056025050580501556, -0.07782774418592453, -0.21132206916809082, -0.28917258977890015, 0.7940804362297058, -0.38404765725135803, 0.20122244954109192, 0.4274956285953522, 0.8274000287055969, 0.19333992898464203, -0.11109998822212219, 0.7931073904037476, -0.3801419734954834, 0.060863178223371506, 0.407918781042099, 0.2986922264099121, 0.49581554532051086, -0.5392298102378845, 0.7261090278625488, 0.19416923820972443, -0.6691265106201172, -0.6176775693893433, 0.4177405536174774, -0.8476832509040833, -0.2989695966243744, 0.9835330843925476, -0.1577373743057251, 0.028904583305120468, 0.2908816635608673, -0.4692084491252899, 0.18148520588874817, 0.36868181824684143, 0.7251796722412109, 0.9575197100639343, -0.20819135010242462, -0.17128555476665497, -0.17940886318683624, 0.34539735317230225, 0.1648232638835907, -0.6485745310783386, -0.03332378715276718, 0.6454373598098755, 0.3293963074684143, 0.04375327378511429, 0.8485046029090881, -0.028286734595894814, 0.17852716147899628, 0.12392167001962662, 0.2468278855085373, -0.33814287185668945, -0.45284366607666016, 0.06021959334611893, 0.18517214059829712, 0.3555677831172943, 0.4255477786064148 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17263v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17263v3	Robust Prompt Optimization for Defending Language Models Against Jailbreaking Attacks	2024-01-30T18:56:08	2024-06-05T23:39:54	Andy Zhou, Bo Li, Haohan Wang	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV	Despite advances in AI alignment, large language models (LLMs) remain vulnerable to adversarial attacks or jailbreaking, in which adversaries can modify prompts to induce unwanted behavior. While some defenses have been proposed, they have not been adapted to newly proposed attacks and more challenging threat models. To address this, we propose an optimization-based objective for defending LLMs against jailbreaking attacks and an algorithm, Robust Prompt Optimization (RPO) to create robust system-level defenses. Our approach directly incorporates the adversary into the defensive objective and optimizes a lightweight and transferable suffix, enabling RPO to adapt to worst-case adaptive attacks. Our theoretical and experimental results show improved robustness to both jailbreaks seen during optimization and unknown jailbreaks, reducing the attack success rate (ASR) on GPT-4 to 6% and Llama-2 to 0% on JailbreakBench, setting the state-of-the-art. Code can be found at https://github.com/lapisrocks/rpo	[ -0.12530995905399323, -0.9297398924827576, 0.4561196267604828, 0.3637494742870331, -0.20701964199543, 0.32572078704833984, -0.3459039628505707, -0.21084292232990265, 0.054585691541433334, 0.37876787781715393, -0.6527961492538452, -0.34458011388778687, -0.5506226420402527, 0.2078353762626648, 0.00421812804415822, 0.9981445074081421, 0.1402476578950882, -0.2011527717113495, -0.140320286154747, -0.13324421644210815, -0.9389801025390625, -0.397337943315506, -0.6134755611419678, 0.13341742753982544, 0.13736720383167267, 0.5042698383331299, 0.6813019514083862, 0.8157204985618591, 0.32135194540023804, 0.26899656653404236, -0.1521528959274292, 0.18593142926692963, -0.25844597816467285, 0.8817057609558105, 0.0005470823962241411, -0.32903456687927246, -0.32001814246177673, -0.3755331337451935, 0.26148438453674316, 0.22548654675483704, -0.15933984518051147, -0.1107475534081459, -0.16274574398994446, 0.7111116647720337, -0.9203768372535706, -0.3088606894016266, -0.9046911001205444, 0.013835319317877293, -0.09025023132562637, -0.03114740177989006, -0.5619516968727112, -0.325724333524704, -0.15580007433891296, -0.6011406183242798, -0.15095734596252441, 0.19857434928417206, 0.7140186429023743, 0.4371967315673828, 0.08268936723470688, -0.16178956627845764, -0.21685847640037537, 0.767292857170105, -0.72310870885849, 0.1946534365415573, 0.2700600028038025, 0.0877721980214119, -0.7041460871696472, -0.23297351598739624, -0.055080682039260864, -0.6697807312011719, 0.29291388392448425, -0.13877709209918976, -0.6259004473686218, 0.11689011752605438, 0.32639724016189575, -0.0811401829123497, -0.6892657279968262, 0.44124457240104675, -0.052484724670648575, -0.5398498773574829, 0.42645809054374695, 0.21194420754909515, 0.6721556186676025, -0.09229438006877899, -0.49440985918045044, 0.044369619339704514, -0.8347992300987244, 0.34010574221611023, 0.5987037420272827, 0.7094565629959106, -0.05250585079193115, 0.4261535704135895, -0.033038824796676636, 0.7388858199119568, -0.0005023296689614654, -0.3911427855491638, -0.04490400850772858, -0.1827148050069809, 0.2462022602558136, 0.05378458648920059, 0.962835967540741, 0.48061835765838623, 0.3589172065258026, -0.20346082746982574, -0.5017763376235962, -0.07374225556850433, 0.3517131805419922, -0.8837829828262329, -0.10676959156990051, 0.25917497277259827, -0.2899245321750641, -0.7417284846305847, -0.11597216129302979, -0.9146636128425598, -0.6248900890350342, 0.43303602933883667, 0.17622815072536469, -0.543552041053772, 0.057293448597192764, -0.0482591837644577, -0.06729444116353989, -0.01681024208664894, 0.06917846947908401, -1.0939751863479614, 0.2855660319328308, 0.7488861083984375, 1.024977445602417, -0.14089958369731903, -0.25176557898521423, -1.0910732746124268, 0.08496887981891632, -0.29145514965057373, 0.7149754166603088, -0.4102160930633545, -0.6516397595405579, -0.1618824154138565, -0.28387129306793213, -0.2608906030654907, -0.4640885293483734, 0.9542639255523682, -0.4907832741737366, -0.1928974688053131, 0.10500219464302063, -0.42967021465301514, 0.29273471236228943, 0.3904436528682709, -0.5979102849960327, 0.8361208438873291, -0.19814997911453247, -0.8163926601409912, 0.010449567809700966, -0.3654913902282715, -0.7109518647193909, -0.10252394527196884, 0.11528801172971725, -0.7490572929382324, 0.30474451184272766, 0.6599112749099731, 0.19264990091323853, -0.24624739587306976, 0.3400735855102539, -0.46031269431114197, -0.14086174964904785, 0.25284695625305176, -0.2236483246088028, 0.7203308343887329, 0.44986099004745483, -0.25073516368865967, 0.42967092990875244, -0.669906735420227, -0.10724946856498718, 0.427774041891098, -0.3835649788379669, -0.5267060995101929, 0.37744125723838806, -0.4366200864315033, -0.3362782895565033, 0.3832818269729614, -0.5898681879043579, 0.5796080231666565, -0.4106651544570923, 0.7858171463012695, 0.9496907591819763, -0.03141764551401138, 0.31813451647758484, -0.016832049936056137, 0.8674049377441406, -0.3606824576854706, 0.4208991527557373, -0.3209276795387268, -0.34729698300361633, -0.2710167169570923, -0.48839133977890015, 0.03885467350482941, 1.0720157623291016, -0.4627794325351715, 0.4764891564846039, -0.07268952578306198, -0.3280462622642517, -0.2643476128578186, 0.3334296941757202, 0.4599977731704712, 0.7359070181846619, 0.31753841042518616, -0.03206425532698631, -0.548703670501709, -0.9114373326301575, -0.6234443783760071, -0.5377500653266907, 0.2573457360267639, 0.0957007110118866, 0.11110514402389526, -0.1297294795513153, 0.8408679366111755, -0.5127857327461243, 0.07501980662345886, -0.5492851138114929, -0.35036730766296387, 0.2974003553390503, 0.5795992016792297, 0.763529896736145, -0.3230745792388916, -0.2961817681789398, -0.21219933032989502, -0.5126138925552368, -0.8014265298843384, -0.25432440638542175, 0.07332843542098999, -0.0015068723587319255, 0.7240650653839111, -0.7006154656410217, 0.14624756574630737, 0.28801530599594116, -0.33770209550857544, 0.7982364892959595, -0.007523087318986654, -0.19507010281085968, -0.9907646179199219, -0.17847014963626862, -0.05314108729362488, -0.40168771147727966, -0.7251080870628357, 0.30880269408226013, 0.03007720410823822, -0.4662072956562042, -0.23531952500343323, 0.604179859161377, -0.33101946115493774, 0.18354976177215576, -0.3300483822822571, 0.1492154896259308, -0.010050499811768532, 0.11883677542209625, -0.3272467851638794, 1.1626664400100708, 0.7972419857978821, -0.2603992819786072, 0.34493398666381836, 0.11454598605632782, -0.211932972073555, 0.3965640068054199, -0.9266908168792725, 0.1972782164812088, 0.11991162598133087, 0.006512376945465803, -0.7336457967758179, -0.05073711648583412, 0.4796123206615448, -0.5443487167358398, 0.3924165666103363, -0.4797971248626709, -0.24234531819820404, -0.17489024996757507, -0.6749055981636047, 0.25098466873168945, 0.314735472202301, -0.539978563785553, 0.4948025345802307, 0.21729512512683868, -0.47183629870414734, -0.8315550684928894, -0.3725222647190094, 0.38304275274276733, -0.6203937530517578, -0.6679758429527283, 0.2165997475385666, -0.017344355583190918, -0.3562050461769104, -0.31913045048713684, -0.14881515502929688, 0.23262353241443634, 0.6748065948486328, 0.07125341892242432, 0.47382891178131104, -0.19153650104999542, -0.26514357328414917, 0.08844782412052155, -0.2163088470697403, 0.24350287020206451, -0.28039854764938354, 0.5387402176856995, -0.12498500198125839, -0.20111440122127533, -0.5252149105072021, 0.3723832368850708, 0.6911078691482544, -0.17274628579616547, 0.6827322244644165, 0.3686889708042145, -0.05727003514766693, -0.3151848316192627, -0.35739704966545105, -0.14346711337566376, -0.4966913163661957, 0.4437805414199829, -0.5558688640594482, -0.9876466989517212, 0.5745577812194824, -0.027084901928901672, 0.03099248744547367, 0.029630638659000397, 0.33378565311431885, 0.28887027502059937, 1.0789824724197388, 0.5532903075218201, -0.6238052248954773, 0.7498985528945923, 0.42152807116508484, 0.2591748535633087, -0.8283831477165222, -0.0535094328224659, -0.7529564499855042, 0.17408427596092224, -0.5407335758209229, 0.1873428076505661, 0.05917475000023842, 0.4631597697734833, -0.3464352488517761, 0.6135481595993042, -0.5004235506057739, 0.43209150433540344, 0.43231216073036194, 0.012342335656285286, 0.026595452800393105, -0.16377489268779755, -0.16294971108436584, 0.031029613688588142, -0.6799432635307312, -0.5830323696136475, 0.8926960229873657, 0.6041685342788696, 1.0855069160461426, 0.29655054211616516, 0.7974764704704285, 0.43264415860176086, -0.04329567402601242, -0.759840190410614, 0.6967399716377258, 0.06656243652105331, -0.20052972435951233, 0.06585066765546799, -0.6058794856071472, -0.7765806317329407, 0.14629501104354858, -0.14345534145832062, -1.1652822494506836, -0.028966065496206284, 0.21293780207633972, -0.3959794044494629, 0.31066593527793884, -0.6955579519271851, 0.937969446182251, -0.462370902299881, -0.23797692358493805, 0.06655586510896683, -0.7772551774978638, 0.38517940044403076, -0.0091378353536129, 0.3356529176235199, -0.2966110110282898, -0.22899605333805084, 0.4898848235607147, -0.7775655388832092, 0.7674658298492432, -0.41558295488357544, -0.08424419909715652, 0.2544593811035156, 0.2721285820007324, 0.8825942277908325, 0.27910035848617554, -0.05733410269021988, -0.41649359464645386, -0.20954185724258423, -0.44955649971961975, -0.510718822479248, 0.6088734865188599, -0.6860219836235046, -1.095360279083252, -0.23874737322330475, -0.6195720434188843, -0.17443174123764038, 0.22368809580802917, 0.21062497794628143, 0.20959970355033875, -0.22587978839874268, -0.12413496524095535, 0.6662865281105042, -0.42598435282707214, 0.6171411275863647, 0.1997751146554947, -0.10555315762758255, -0.7896451950073242, 0.8450396656990051, -0.495370477437973, 0.46885353326797485, 0.24093881249427795, 0.5168448686599731, -0.07067693024873734, -0.9311721920967102, -0.6727867722511292, -0.06876883655786514, -0.6195284128189087, -0.5824126601219177, -0.4033189117908478, 0.11983393877744675, -0.6086277365684509, -0.2156502902507782, -0.34395214915275574, -0.5005999803543091, -0.2951798737049103, -0.0408322736620903, 0.6093239784240723, 0.2343396544456482, -0.12165405601263046, 0.3382846713066101, -0.8255289793014526, 0.15879622101783752, 0.12366128712892532, -0.0315893180668354, -0.20294485986232758, -0.7428640127182007, 0.08042626827955246, -0.3621389865875244, -0.3185831606388092, -0.9993939399719238, 0.2983017563819885, 0.3696003258228302, 0.7215304970741272, 0.4603918492794037, 0.5006492733955383, 0.4983045160770416, -0.5370091795921326, 0.5158402323722839, 0.1511937826871872, -1.0137124061584473, 1.0042845010757446, -0.417183518409729, 0.11875670403242111, 0.8914997577667236, -0.16098330914974213, -0.16996778547763824, -0.38023021817207336, -0.188919797539711, -0.9767061471939087, 0.37741148471832275, 0.09098279476165771, 0.37973496317863464, -0.09230069071054459, 0.585754930973053, -0.10743770748376846, 0.10287614911794662, -0.8871974349021912, -0.13215477764606476, -0.19218789041042328, -0.10277234017848969, 0.4108748435974121, -0.2817198634147644, -0.10828586667776108, 0.08160175383090973, 0.729022204875946, -0.12087804824113846, 0.009787392802536488, 0.070682592689991, -0.22154541313648224, 0.12465963512659073, 0.5177444815635681, 0.9139428734779358, 0.08749578148126602, -0.16038300096988678, 0.054395612329244614, 0.14791619777679443, -0.7622087597846985, 0.3801739513874054, 0.31098777055740356, -0.4282485246658325, -0.3754490315914154, 0.5782317519187927, 0.9694661498069763, -0.17807067930698395, -0.9553284049034119, 0.5148503184318542, -0.19930191338062286, 0.2628883421421051, 0.13526222109794617, 0.2937939167022705, -0.3200319707393646, 0.2985847294330597, 0.2815017104148865, 0.07848554104566574, -0.08933405578136444, -0.37357988953590393, 0.0333528034389019, 0.6582546830177307, -0.24144506454467773, -0.16076195240020752, 0.7996019124984741, 0.1230570375919342, -0.5633861422538757, 0.5586584806442261, -0.0365651473402977, -0.9244459271430969, 0.6424228549003601, 0.88763427734375, 1.1322704553604126, -0.28554365038871765, -0.2505088746547699, 0.2524101436138153, 0.6704449653625488, -0.026520930230617523, 0.11957339942455292, -0.1159529834985733, -0.6826543211936951, -0.1803523451089859, -0.48220041394233704, -0.43371009826660156, -0.12384892255067825, -0.582131564617157, 0.3075755536556244, -0.8512933254241943, -0.2377246618270874, -0.35919272899627686, -0.28027671575546265, 0.13539579510688782, -0.10958412289619446, 0.007003282196819782, 1.126883864402771, -0.7383943796157837, 0.6403737664222717, 0.5437291264533997, -0.12543436884880066, -0.5772915482521057, 0.035796940326690674, 0.09814926981925964, -0.8292943239212036, 0.25770848989486694, 0.4454927146434784, -0.25232982635498047, -0.17357878386974335, -0.5697121620178223, -0.7117065787315369, 0.6688397526741028, 0.6610899567604065, -0.6462928652763367, 0.33609509468078613, -0.23523855209350586, 0.10183870047330856, -0.4322097599506378, -0.23913070559501648, 0.527158796787262, 0.34143948554992676, -0.206556037068367, -0.6427386999130249, 0.24651795625686646, -0.27536076307296753, 0.03372351825237274, 0.42486292123794556, -0.5042778253555298, 0.4392857253551483, -0.6420540809631348, -0.13383077085018158, 0.6276644468307495, 0.6545485258102417, 0.7179784774780273, 0.08010677248239517, 0.6268524527549744, 0.9243419766426086, 0.4812456965446472, -0.137567400932312, 1.1160180568695068, -0.3966580629348755, 0.027650339528918266, 0.931831955909729, -0.15883567929267883, 0.6515673995018005, 0.633675754070282, -0.062070660293102264, 0.3847186863422394, 0.7517651915550232, -0.13696633279323578, 0.7763514518737793, 0.397000789642334, -0.4232073426246643, -0.19380711019039154, -0.20573389530181885, -0.29542282223701477, 0.1823253184556961, 0.2765218913555145, -0.17277087271213531, -0.012712478637695312, 0.21576432883739471, 0.5475377440452576, 0.26681625843048096, -0.37770527601242065, 0.7487941384315491, -0.00024471283541060984, -0.7348933219909668, 0.5633035898208618, 0.23261377215385437, 0.6933403611183167, -0.5959449410438538, 0.4788421094417572, -0.38568928837776184, 0.05562321096658707, -0.09391573816537857, -0.5001548528671265, 0.1940254122018814, 0.4108704626560211, -0.16351096332073212, 0.06725652515888214, 0.9413778781890869, 0.1192832961678505, -0.25554758310317993, 0.2895415723323822, 0.17978958785533905, -0.16489331424236298, 0.19953307509422302, -0.8827052116394043, 0.5317614674568176, 0.018115336075425148, -0.3910427689552307, 0.45543405413627625, 0.13474613428115845, -0.171323761343956, 1.0011652708053589, 0.6769444346427917, 0.17650914192199707, -0.005493475589901209, 0.13976217806339264, 1.08627450466156, -0.5363209247589111, -0.5186926126480103, -1.3523868322372437, 0.2354702204465866, 0.020639358088374138, -0.24708041548728943, 0.5610366463661194, 0.46360665559768677, 0.26757797598838806, 0.20852982997894287, 0.6896895170211792, -0.10583997517824173, 0.15602189302444458, -0.663674533367157, 0.45717284083366394, -0.2077305018901825, 0.651583194732666, -0.5299057364463806, -0.9287000298500061, -0.4694402515888214, 0.6445396542549133, -0.25700706243515015, -0.1852283626794815, 0.27916932106018066, 0.8542917370796204, 0.24207866191864014, -0.22663316130638123, 0.07083510607481003, -0.013467730022966862, 0.5101501941680908, 0.6060370206832886, 0.9768838286399841, -0.16065029799938202, 0.5785221457481384, -0.1156710535287857, -0.3251129686832428, 0.009485128335654736, -1.2955046892166138, -0.9841233491897583, 0.02794497460126877, -0.24305231869220734, -0.4899209439754486, 0.45662784576416016, 1.0277225971221924, 0.5394863486289978, -0.7532222867012024, -0.08407621830701828, -0.23724161088466644, 0.2744036912918091, 0.005114634521305561, -0.22510142624378204, 0.17914555966854095, -0.6725361943244934, -0.2568536698818207, 1.033005952835083, 0.4085034132003784, 0.034337397664785385, -0.05907590314745903, -0.051587674766778946, -0.007051446475088596, 0.19532617926597595, 0.33049440383911133, 0.74417644739151, -0.7210061550140381, -0.4339451193809509, 0.0670844167470932, -0.11147688329219818, -0.006173277739435434, 0.7092469334602356, -0.5660337805747986, 0.2664397954940796, 0.37006765604019165, 1.0690618753433228, -0.2355697900056839, 0.280724436044693, 0.7207772135734558, -0.8009923696517944, 0.3755528926849365, 0.14782649278640747, 0.5607067942619324, 0.4984699785709381, -0.3854946196079254, 0.20500598847866058, 0.352343887090683, -0.5656322836875916, -1.219882845878601, 0.5692722201347351, -0.8742555379867554, -0.403910756111145, 0.9236411452293396, -0.32413995265960693, -0.2723999619483948, 0.06545595824718475, -0.12017323821783066, -0.17812052369117737, -0.7694634795188904, 0.7386329770088196, 0.5653872489929199, -0.08611323684453964, -0.3758494257926941, -0.47560378909111023, 0.3914920687675476, 0.5473161339759827, -0.8421556949615479, 0.2782902717590332, 0.4367411434650421, 0.30545827746391296, 0.025216558948159218, 0.132717102766037, -0.00471273111179471, 0.2401704043149948, -0.1372915804386139, -0.2033892422914505, -0.2610393166542053, -0.30371057987213135, -0.5266079306602478, 0.18361930549144745, 0.47327515482902527, -0.27813443541526794 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17256v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17256v2	Weak-to-Strong Jailbreaking on Large Language Models	2024-01-30T18:48:37	2024-02-05T18:19:46	Xuandong Zhao, Xianjun Yang, Tianyu Pang, Chao Du, Lei Li, Yu-Xiang Wang, William Yang Wang	cs.CL	cs.CL	Large language models (LLMs) are vulnerable to jailbreak attacks - resulting in harmful, unethical, or biased text generations. However, existing jailbreaking methods are computationally costly. In this paper, we propose the weak-to-strong jailbreaking attack, an efficient method to attack aligned LLMs to produce harmful text. Our key intuition is based on the observation that jailbroken and aligned models only differ in their initial decoding distributions. The weak-to-strong attack's key technical insight is using two smaller models (a safe and an unsafe one) to adversarially modify a significantly larger safe model's decoding probabilities. We evaluate the weak-to-strong attack on 5 diverse LLMs from 3 organizations. The results show our method can increase the misalignment rate to over 99% on two datasets with just one forward pass per example. Our study exposes an urgent safety issue that needs to be addressed when aligning LLMs. As an initial attempt, we propose a defense strategy to protect against such attacks, but creating more advanced defenses remains challenging. The code for replicating the method is available at https://github.com/XuandongZhao/weak-to-strong	[ -0.04756666719913483, -0.8548333644866943, 0.5306571125984192, 0.2215295284986496, -0.3878166973590851, 0.06684437394142151, -0.30616307258605957, -0.6997816562652588, 0.060225293040275574, 0.7341256737709045, -0.27634918689727783, -0.43804240226745605, -0.6969211101531982, -0.11305578798055649, -0.4105464816093445, 1.143826961517334, 0.02905350551009178, 0.03303547576069832, 0.2682848274707794, -0.18306051194667816, -0.7138122320175171, -0.42673352360725403, -0.20449714362621307, -0.038401756435632706, 0.34555211663246155, 0.36008206009864807, 0.97178053855896, 0.7438490390777588, 0.62144935131073, 0.2681223750114441, -0.3306506276130676, -0.15668699145317078, -0.723433256149292, 0.42462289333343506, -0.26837098598480225, -0.41881564259529114, -0.42530909180641174, -0.20176851749420166, 0.3779744803905487, 0.37954649329185486, -0.1129176914691925, -0.08431988954544067, -0.01367224846035242, 0.8513156175613403, -0.8303331732749939, -0.38861286640167236, -1.0852149724960327, -0.1412028819322586, -0.5274746417999268, 0.34574824571609497, -0.6539738178253174, -0.15971073508262634, -0.28612226247787476, -0.13032549619674683, -0.22997824847698212, 0.10315614193677902, 0.7235917448997498, 0.08859086781740189, -0.28622549772262573, -0.1516415923833847, -0.47432610392570496, 0.716382622718811, -0.8687252998352051, 0.17771947383880615, 0.3160147964954376, 0.12906983494758606, -0.31663551926612854, -0.3264652192592621, -0.211983323097229, -0.24084673821926117, 0.22973324358463287, -0.18492677807807922, -0.4337756037712097, 0.008861243724822998, 0.24265314638614655, 0.15318214893341064, -0.4910605251789093, 0.5192974209785461, -0.3767184317111969, -0.0886211022734642, 0.7406980395317078, 0.08948981016874313, 0.47323065996170044, -0.17098790407180786, -0.5224344730377197, -0.15610116720199585, -1.0040866136550903, -0.33039557933807373, 0.6067293882369995, 0.5575125217437744, -0.22479751706123352, 0.8753039240837097, 0.22245100140571594, 0.4826461672782898, 0.18308328092098236, -0.09282759577035904, 0.08056766539812088, -0.17588336765766144, -0.286981999874115, 0.4235575497150421, 0.9298105239868164, 0.313961923122406, 0.2447420358657837, -0.4419640302658081, -0.42181965708732605, -0.1480654925107956, 0.4282028377056122, -0.7994666695594788, -0.10903080552816391, 0.21960711479187012, -0.4277243912220001, -0.6664497256278992, 0.0824255719780922, -0.6235228776931763, -0.8700929284095764, 0.3845272362232208, 0.33642855286598206, -0.5206696391105652, -0.002471630461513996, 0.012564069591462612, 0.07614774256944656, 0.320665568113327, -0.02188027836382389, -0.9845504760742188, 0.23140038549900055, 0.7695275545120239, 0.8704953789710999, 0.11890991032123566, -0.23724094033241272, -0.5157181620597839, 0.3995475471019745, -0.2648303806781769, 0.5455760359764099, -0.03924320265650749, -0.4330398142337799, -0.2509920597076416, -0.24224792420864105, 0.06606659293174744, -0.6338970065116882, 0.6203942894935608, -0.6785654425621033, -0.4172265827655792, 0.10821489244699478, -0.4787994921207428, 0.23978880047798157, 0.2520875334739685, -0.9791483283042908, 0.33417341113090515, -0.18253593146800995, -0.9693164229393005, 0.01833563670516014, -0.088585764169693, -0.7666193842887878, -0.2772901952266693, 0.11922935396432877, -0.9236879944801331, 0.23719516396522522, 0.33079051971435547, 0.393282026052475, -0.10409054160118103, 0.38547953963279724, -0.79841548204422, -0.26987171173095703, 0.4036675989627838, -0.5113452672958374, 0.9529037475585938, 0.43541833758354187, -0.24392668902873993, 0.055871471762657166, -0.6196221709251404, -0.07179287821054459, 0.5471111536026001, -0.3519100248813629, -0.5848264098167419, 0.2360944151878357, -0.14726950228214264, -0.013611843809485435, 0.35071995854377747, -0.46329832077026367, 0.5503547787666321, -0.7112078070640564, 0.4878339469432831, 0.8804759383201599, 0.0466388501226902, 0.6227762699127197, -0.15526728332042694, 0.19610384106636047, -0.07684209942817688, 0.1905098557472229, 0.12868690490722656, -0.32092997431755066, -0.13336817920207977, -0.25562584400177, 0.20475545525550842, 0.678222119808197, -0.4001561105251312, 0.30542343854904175, -0.0818280503153801, -0.4844169616699219, -0.6612786650657654, 0.6920467615127563, 0.529050886631012, 0.13941459357738495, 0.3845401406288147, -0.1032164990901947, -0.6134247779846191, -0.8005480766296387, -0.7369810938835144, -0.30523136258125305, 0.10634644329547882, -0.1887563169002533, 0.4301024079322815, -0.28339412808418274, 0.512482762336731, -0.455355703830719, -0.23782731592655182, -0.42236873507499695, -0.30892032384872437, 0.27297765016555786, 0.660977840423584, 0.578859806060791, -0.503515362739563, -0.22300882637500763, -0.275908887386322, -0.7233702540397644, -0.03554735332727432, -0.16965864598751068, -0.09736615419387817, 0.01773475483059883, 0.6252495646476746, -0.8215709924697876, 0.22160689532756805, 0.6143002510070801, -0.5596519708633423, 0.558984637260437, 0.03557400032877922, -0.3299502432346344, -1.2293825149536133, -0.195652574300766, -0.020263805985450745, -0.1613403856754303, -0.7653941512107849, 0.39662259817123413, 0.16936630010604858, -0.17458601295948029, -0.4950370490550995, 0.265847772359848, -0.45373526215553284, 0.17610697448253632, -0.20343387126922607, -0.011956709437072277, -0.1604345589876175, -0.0063183545134961605, -0.5072519779205322, 0.5669232606887817, 0.3251914381980896, -0.0507645457983017, 0.24784144759178162, 0.36702778935432434, -0.5703004598617554, 0.18138965964317322, -0.6137651205062866, 0.3499302566051483, 0.009313343092799187, 0.21137887239456177, -0.7748309969902039, -0.1442069560289383, 0.23959238827228546, -0.34853026270866394, 0.4615072011947632, -0.3886556029319763, -0.49261316657066345, -0.07608691602945328, -0.5835179090499878, 0.4176660478115082, 0.24368388950824738, -0.6081123352050781, 0.23784807324409485, 0.41441938281059265, -0.1312875747680664, -0.757668137550354, -0.9492976665496826, 0.5013169050216675, -0.5086613297462463, -0.9113606214523315, 0.38258495926856995, 0.1729522943496704, -0.6741304397583008, -0.1942310333251953, -0.1791948825120926, -0.021221663802862167, 0.49744653701782227, 0.22042341530323029, 0.44713258743286133, -0.08412112295627594, -0.2835127115249634, -0.12923426926136017, -0.03273493051528931, 0.17108681797981262, -0.24583537876605988, 0.33752867579460144, -0.1267871856689453, -0.389590322971344, -0.3746039569377899, 0.3796631395816803, 0.8275840878486633, -0.15523280203342438, 1.0633901357650757, 0.18830162286758423, -0.3479977250099182, -0.20356805622577667, -0.3496931195259094, -0.11571210622787476, -0.4969494640827179, 0.45279794931411743, -0.1865624338388443, -0.7739344239234924, 0.48068487644195557, 0.03516622260212898, 0.14050649106502533, 0.17476674914360046, 0.5316870808601379, 0.028602013364434242, 1.2741519212722778, 0.6555933952331543, -0.7210051417350769, 0.42327913641929626, 0.10083416104316711, 0.5119667053222656, -0.5902117490768433, -0.13548633456230164, -0.651249885559082, -0.23330090939998627, -0.48160991072654724, -0.11999205499887466, -0.10168004781007767, 0.5775632858276367, -0.34922775626182556, 0.48938116431236267, -0.22997702658176422, 0.547735333442688, 0.04395918920636177, 0.18273094296455383, 0.2508225440979004, -0.1732196807861328, 0.024779941886663437, 0.08829298615455627, -0.39648503065109253, -0.33791303634643555, 1.1474504470825195, 0.5655849575996399, 1.3058449029922485, 0.6012679934501648, 0.8675273060798645, 0.1517292857170105, 0.33453768491744995, -0.7308049201965332, 0.45406854152679443, -0.3171750605106354, -0.6081077456474304, -0.04679751768708229, -0.5482493042945862, -0.7276857495307922, 0.20407477021217346, -0.37000322341918945, -1.024469256401062, -0.04277364909648895, 0.19254030287265778, -0.15142537653446198, 0.6504586338996887, -0.9091073870658875, 0.9234273433685303, -0.6071019172668457, -0.4710049331188202, -0.04722975939512253, -0.7452791333198547, 0.784968376159668, -0.2468210905790329, 0.40072160959243774, -0.04160842299461365, 0.3161410093307495, 0.6228190064430237, -0.718591570854187, 0.9190733432769775, -0.1862676739692688, -0.21779486536979675, 0.10496223717927933, 0.2672518789768219, 1.0080821514129639, 0.2292696088552475, -0.18206344544887543, -0.06517130881547928, -0.4329797029495239, -0.44027307629585266, -0.3459557592868805, 0.6886868476867676, -0.7595125436782837, -0.7292454838752747, -0.21573983132839203, -0.5227880477905273, -0.17893223464488983, 0.22593370079994202, 0.23836855590343475, 0.06138550862669945, -0.252362459897995, 0.015277577564120293, 0.6619930863380432, -0.14933925867080688, 0.27913641929626465, 0.2603539526462555, -0.017747942358255386, -0.5015950202941895, 0.7933003902435303, -0.16037887334823608, 0.5174421668052673, 0.15729466080665588, 0.17783111333847046, -0.11465522646903992, -1.0014877319335938, -0.262130469083786, 0.19567835330963135, -0.5928372144699097, -0.5884674787521362, -0.1671113222837448, -0.18960830569267273, -0.5158793330192566, -0.4161309003829956, -0.6032178997993469, -0.29495856165885925, -0.03484588488936424, -0.1394091695547104, 0.31277015805244446, 0.5370360612869263, 0.02368694730103016, 0.37254083156585693, -0.8489059209823608, 0.27933087944984436, 0.19149549305438995, 0.2268628031015396, -0.05075395107269287, -0.4894866943359375, -0.25186407566070557, -0.146869495511055, -0.3562881350517273, -1.195077657699585, 0.2931201756000519, 0.005849280394613743, 0.25960710644721985, 0.6308669447898865, 0.3367067575454712, 0.6198411583900452, -0.5911200046539307, 0.34531453251838684, 0.4424867331981659, -1.0445494651794434, 0.5242193937301636, -0.27338337898254395, 0.27141425013542175, 0.7890684604644775, -0.17128929495811462, -0.22668781876564026, -0.7383662462234497, -0.48555228114128113, -1.1272228956222534, 0.5425353050231934, 0.21312399208545685, 0.17137672007083893, 0.10693966597318649, 0.2741072177886963, -0.19813139736652374, -0.026173695921897888, -1.007900595664978, -0.13751350343227386, -0.025420846417546272, -0.3557385802268982, 0.09865383058786392, -0.3013295531272888, -0.21717053651809692, -0.050014130771160126, 0.7153586149215698, 0.19705934822559357, -0.01705930568277836, -0.14509239792823792, -0.4518246352672577, -0.14474870264530182, 0.6295746564865112, 0.4124847948551178, 0.2579698860645294, -0.26560521125793457, 0.27488958835601807, 0.18794141709804535, -0.7222557663917542, 0.2611922025680542, 0.17987488210201263, -0.17989495396614075, -0.3684048652648926, 0.43983036279678345, 0.7992904186248779, 0.086310975253582, -0.754554808139801, 0.6794963479042053, -0.036484505981206894, -0.075590580701828, -0.002523173810914159, -0.04259525611996651, 0.11600608378648758, 0.37335458397865295, 0.14174884557724, 0.09525782614946365, -0.31590381264686584, -0.5836008191108704, 0.12421903759241104, 0.5872117280960083, -0.30045846104621887, -0.16519252955913544, 0.7388839721679688, 0.00823246967047453, -0.1789291352033615, 0.7486370801925659, -0.052812233567237854, -0.5551643371582031, 0.5837613344192505, 0.9984923601150513, 0.8930565118789673, -0.32111307978630066, -0.19078700244426727, -0.01897606998682022, 0.7630435228347778, -0.2968998849391937, -0.06314220279455185, 0.323839008808136, -0.8339147567749023, -0.3798609673976898, -0.42916372418403625, -0.1926405280828476, 0.2755865454673767, -0.5566259622573853, 0.35187196731567383, -0.7480932474136353, -0.1394488364458084, -0.08796022087335587, -0.21037280559539795, 0.05060778558254242, -0.12530358135700226, 0.33848729729652405, 0.8496353030204773, -0.7188693284988403, 0.8336619734764099, 0.5769336819648743, 0.002454349072650075, -0.8446577191352844, 0.2344636172056198, 0.32290247082710266, -0.6820328235626221, 0.2953415811061859, 0.25424399971961975, -0.014607686549425125, -0.2750120759010315, -0.8312488794326782, -0.7380825877189636, 0.8067411780357361, 0.5704237222671509, -0.853381872177124, -0.040069907903671265, -0.10734548419713974, 0.15304681658744812, -0.09926177561283112, -0.3863104581832886, 0.6624993681907654, 0.3782280385494232, -0.2670469284057617, -0.5756025910377502, 0.36825305223464966, -0.0908757895231247, -0.14630837738513947, 0.7075687646865845, -0.4816061854362488, 0.7024136781692505, -0.6332921385765076, -0.20164990425109863, 0.28852665424346924, 0.5959441065788269, 0.5442309379577637, 0.24374736845493317, 0.520359456539154, 0.967129647731781, 0.607417106628418, 0.06594838201999664, 0.7862967848777771, -0.27228376269340515, 0.3498900234699249, 1.0419180393218994, -0.4334535002708435, 0.926493763923645, 0.7434481382369995, 0.12535704672336578, 0.11953626573085785, 0.1686626821756363, -0.35347411036491394, 0.7335075736045837, 0.44294828176498413, -0.23869480192661285, -0.08006471395492554, 0.3874102532863617, -0.22903303802013397, 0.4032262861728668, 0.395500123500824, -0.36216825246810913, -0.2690940797328949, 0.20994976162910461, 0.5983564853668213, 0.11425913870334625, -0.4273494780063629, 0.7119312882423401, 0.33273714780807495, -0.31230783462524414, 0.6430106163024902, 0.5221860408782959, 0.6237666010856628, -0.6142066121101379, 0.34833088517189026, 0.07107261568307877, 0.4027003049850464, -0.34038245677948, -0.7713437676429749, 0.336611807346344, 0.5340615510940552, -0.07064443826675415, -0.0870986059308052, 0.9334062337875366, -0.16356827318668365, -0.1915171593427658, 0.5202166438102722, 0.21659091114997864, -0.23740383982658386, 0.06317511200904846, -0.694881021976471, 0.35407641530036926, 0.044208429753780365, -0.39169496297836304, 0.659162163734436, -0.007001836784183979, -0.14365306496620178, 0.4850767254829407, 0.6012425422668457, 0.1762281358242035, -0.0004997113719582558, 0.02559792436659336, 1.0274057388305664, -0.6994458436965942, -0.4454156160354614, -1.295169711112976, 0.3352241516113281, -0.03218792378902435, -0.04281720891594887, 0.7486875057220459, 0.44420525431632996, 0.680855929851532, 0.3527128994464874, 0.7199537754058838, -0.0836678221821785, -0.04356304556131363, -0.8210338950157166, 1.0438042879104614, -0.2330513298511505, 0.7489253878593445, -0.4902949631214142, -0.8210833072662354, -0.38029178977012634, 0.45272666215896606, -0.48779961466789246, -0.31200680136680603, 0.45248380303382874, 0.6569976210594177, 0.07213209569454193, -0.10504980385303497, -0.028617780655622482, 0.6905941367149353, 0.42372456192970276, 0.6676315069198608, 0.9132310152053833, -0.3332485556602478, 0.765095055103302, -0.18382202088832855, -0.07294952869415283, -0.15996120870113373, -0.8383738398551941, -0.891303300857544, 0.05383399873971939, 0.02831214852631092, -0.852594792842865, 0.4638991057872772, 0.736569344997406, 0.3562477231025696, -0.6320323348045349, -0.20183047652244568, -0.09989606589078903, 0.32873478531837463, -0.09309449791908264, -0.17212620377540588, 0.19746002554893494, -0.1729302704334259, -0.21689079701900482, 0.7046483159065247, 0.13808223605155945, 0.09742644429206848, 0.0021029373165220022, -0.050616554915905, -0.18022432923316956, 0.01524016261100769, 0.2784225642681122, 0.4747468829154968, -0.37126538157463074, -0.20092162489891052, -0.35762205719947815, -0.38200467824935913, 0.04418278485536575, 0.6848028898239136, -0.330587238073349, 0.20511604845523834, 0.32928285002708435, 0.8851611018180847, 0.26308369636535645, 0.21810539066791534, 0.5595861077308655, -0.8727216720581055, 0.34530559182167053, 0.326449453830719, 0.4366734027862549, 0.3096062242984772, -0.4845392107963562, 0.005254371091723442, 0.19252026081085205, -0.5357397794723511, -1.0959415435791016, 0.37893441319465637, -0.9195659160614014, -0.727240264415741, 1.021988034248352, -0.05285098776221275, -0.4373258352279663, 0.026502270251512527, -0.01402193121612072, 0.08612740784883499, -0.41075941920280457, 0.8319103717803955, 0.525730311870575, 0.23870278894901276, 0.2160550057888031, -0.4689514935016632, 0.2627429664134979, 0.44376134872436523, -0.6932157278060913, 0.29037243127822876, 0.2741619944572449, 0.389995813369751, -0.04587332904338837, 0.1713164895772934, -0.3432421088218689, 0.13283349573612213, -0.06415926665067673, -0.21748533844947815, -0.04138443246483803, -0.24515944719314575, -0.6351706981658936, 0.24440203607082367, 0.3611878752708435, 0.06136883795261383 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17244v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17244v2	LLaMP: Large Language Model Made Powerful for High-fidelity Materials Knowledge Retrieval and Distillation	2024-01-30T18:37:45	2024-06-02T07:50:21	Yuan Chiang, Elvis Hsieh, Chia-Hong Chou, Janosh Riebesell	cs.CL	cs.CL, cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.AI	Reducing hallucination of Large Language Models (LLMs) is imperative for use in the sciences, where reliability and reproducibility are crucial. However, LLMs inherently lack long-term memory, making it a nontrivial, ad hoc, and inevitably biased task to fine-tune them on domain-specific literature and data. Here we introduce LLaMP, a multimodal retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) framework of hierarchical reasoning-and-acting (ReAct) agents that can dynamically and recursively interact with computational and experimental data on Materials Project (MP) and run atomistic simulations via high-throughput workflow interface. Without fine-tuning, LLaMP demonstrates strong tool usage ability to comprehend and integrate various modalities of materials science concepts, fetch relevant data stores on the fly, process higher-order data (such as crystal structure and elastic tensor), and streamline complex tasks in computational materials and chemistry. We propose a simple metric combining uncertainty and confidence estimates to evaluate the self-consistency of responses by LLaMP and vanilla LLMs. Our benchmark shows that LLaMP effectively mitigates the intrinsic bias in LLMs, counteracting the errors on bulk moduli, electronic bandgaps, and formation energies that seem to derive from mixed data sources. We also demonstrate LLaMP's capability to edit crystal structures and run annealing molecular dynamics simulations using pre-trained machine-learning force fields. The framework offers an intuitive and nearly hallucination-free approach to exploring and scaling materials informatics, and establishes a pathway for knowledge distillation and fine-tuning other language models. Code and live demo are available at https://github.com/chiang-yuan/llamp	[ -0.18524235486984253, -0.9197127223014832, 0.7321966886520386, 0.12468418478965759, 0.09280586987733841, 0.3605659306049347, -0.4053935706615448, -0.18403466045856476, 0.11779875308275223, 0.24925705790519714, -0.2806566655635834, -0.27137458324432373, -0.3878142833709717, 0.0907023623585701, -0.23486092686653137, 0.6149706244468689, -0.3253651261329651, 0.0020075496286153793, -0.4554516673088074, 0.148947611451149, -0.12509167194366455, -0.3621115982532501, -0.1166352927684784, -0.8272972702980042, 0.5729897618293762, 0.22966940701007843, 0.5867469310760498, 0.5072925686836243, 0.6654808521270752, 0.3436107337474823, -0.08032771944999695, 0.5282291769981384, -0.5064681768417358, 0.4143584668636322, -0.5028226375579834, -0.44195646047592163, -0.6461741328239441, -0.08213520795106888, 0.3764320909976959, 0.6389419436454773, -0.19507619738578796, 0.22630539536476135, 0.09359047561883926, 0.4819979965686798, -0.49199506640434265, 0.22173157334327698, -0.9131729006767273, 0.05926254019141197, -0.1674419492483139, -0.6477545499801636, -0.5276823043823242, 0.050719182938337326, -0.08393488824367523, -0.547742486000061, 0.14309394359588623, 0.20962189137935638, 0.6508275866508484, 0.45106759667396545, -0.34147241711616516, -0.2776782810688019, -0.7437395453453064, 0.9521927237510681, -0.4483192265033722, 0.5148894786834717, 0.4393565058708191, 0.32684534788131714, -0.5321926474571228, -0.98658287525177, -0.6274352073669434, -0.19378843903541565, 0.17279846966266632, -0.07208086550235748, 0.22420743107795715, 0.13390260934829712, 0.023886309936642647, 0.5961059331893921, -0.48357048630714417, -0.18515998125076294, -0.20797455310821533, -0.3474573493003845, 0.2673940360546112, 0.022642815485596657, -0.011062934063374996, -0.16728882491588593, -0.37437930703163147, -0.14361807703971863, -0.5747523307800293, -0.7036922574043274, 0.04752245917916298, 0.28278714418411255, 0.21140410006046295, 0.7563968896865845, -0.057961199432611465, 0.37655043601989746, 0.05318346992135048, -0.3814079463481903, 0.3091619312763214, -0.2498038113117218, -0.30762967467308044, -0.09559943526983261, 0.6345571279525757, 0.078705333173275, 0.2732056677341461, -0.25719866156578064, -0.31996822357177734, 0.1532304733991623, 0.11449520289897919, -0.9098536968231201, -0.2979125678539276, 0.41168034076690674, -0.2064749002456665, -0.19299288094043732, -0.42703863978385925, -0.7897698283195496, -0.7595676183700562, -0.46388038992881775, 0.520943284034729, -0.21287688612937927, -0.2793174982070923, 0.043335605412721634, -0.042698733508586884, -0.1859777569770813, 0.40686124563217163, -0.9846513867378235, 0.1437605768442154, 0.5834276676177979, 0.7195807695388794, -0.42844200134277344, -0.45967379212379456, -0.3224697411060333, 0.23799848556518555, -0.38921812176704407, 0.6525326371192932, -0.4331496059894562, -0.37803465127944946, -0.3954217731952667, -0.07001110911369324, 0.39915716648101807, -0.8081888556480408, 0.25088098645210266, -0.45893752574920654, -0.07427681237459183, -0.10986033827066422, -0.331254780292511, 0.11713952571153641, 0.36134272813796997, -0.6085988879203796, 1.0365676879882812, 0.1877831518650055, -0.6125431060791016, 0.3124886155128479, -0.055676866322755814, -0.13944600522518158, -0.16911709308624268, -0.4509044289588928, -0.2217140942811966, 0.23683105409145355, -0.015467697754502296, 0.32283470034599304, -0.6610826253890991, 0.47648075222969055, -0.5087065100669861, -0.20406726002693176, 0.17292428016662598, -0.6953272223472595, 0.1430767923593521, 0.2581755518913269, -0.1761476993560791, 0.13435590267181396, -0.7976846694946289, -0.03170871362090111, 0.02244696207344532, -0.5275064706802368, -0.03449394553899765, 0.034711334854364395, 0.051938287913799286, 0.2877195477485657, 0.34551694989204407, -0.4131104052066803, 0.3845435678958893, -0.12210322171449661, 0.5039014220237732, 0.9430789351463318, -0.010483048856258392, 0.4738088846206665, -0.2340754121541977, 0.20634444057941437, -0.06303432583808899, -0.11972910910844803, -0.2548050284385681, 0.00025759433628991246, -0.5653117299079895, -0.2609795033931732, 0.364609956741333, 0.24178774654865265, -0.9099432229995728, -0.1597658395767212, -0.3345292806625366, -0.5115771293640137, -0.2932550311088562, 0.4247662425041199, 0.07846293598413467, 0.4500653147697449, 0.45082104206085205, -0.012864219956099987, -0.44704946875572205, -0.6491985321044922, -0.027797650545835495, -0.10405083000659943, -0.13044749200344086, 0.3308055102825165, 0.5445672869682312, -0.4294899106025696, 0.8128073215484619, -0.45506441593170166, -0.3128850758075714, -0.07399747520685196, 0.3513132929801941, 0.39627569913864136, 0.2940223515033722, 0.05445598438382149, -0.8953973054885864, -0.25554749369621277, 0.12398908287286758, -0.9070619344711304, -0.10736963152885437, -0.18779020011425018, -0.24931561946868896, 0.2781849801540375, 0.5540862083435059, -0.7369161248207092, -0.008135383948683739, 0.5575079917907715, -0.0188151765614748, 0.5607604384422302, -0.21947000920772552, 0.1272534281015396, -1.0966004133224487, 0.24473802745342255, -0.08884637802839279, -0.18427403271198273, -0.3849875032901764, 0.04792015627026558, 0.06805340200662613, 0.01327469665557146, -0.5747671127319336, 0.7477511763572693, -0.7169792652130127, -0.2199920117855072, -0.47890686988830566, 0.14973090589046478, 0.2483644038438797, 0.6065608263015747, 0.08994321525096893, 0.9334637522697449, 0.31786012649536133, -0.6348576545715332, 0.3958882987499237, -0.01342019997537136, -0.30973511934280396, 0.6748281121253967, -0.5518593192100525, -0.027395233511924744, 0.023772869259119034, 0.10674985498189926, -0.6274780035018921, -0.4778079092502594, -0.022232605144381523, -0.3867776095867157, 0.535415768623352, -0.10844261944293976, -0.8298858404159546, -0.22019757330417633, -0.21439121663570404, 0.4102994203567505, 0.2386341691017151, -0.6083495020866394, 1.0268086194992065, 0.39297235012054443, -0.20164057612419128, -0.6813139915466309, -0.595953643321991, -0.10942555218935013, -0.12149903178215027, -0.3642941117286682, 0.46519023180007935, -0.40630781650543213, -0.4048548638820648, -0.23115870356559753, -0.6473709344863892, -0.19957734644412994, -0.003047812730073929, 0.0996793881058693, 0.2983059585094452, 0.10209019482135773, 0.5275497436523438, 0.026962054893374443, 0.013507847674190998, 0.011551355943083763, -0.0948026031255722, 0.9868561625480652, -0.04632129520177841, -0.4387134909629822, -0.09044993668794632, -0.11710461974143982, 0.9418249726295471, -0.10565205663442612, 0.3105163276195526, 0.23849543929100037, -0.37778255343437195, -0.5661442279815674, -0.360502153635025, -0.4121585488319397, -0.5954055190086365, 0.4004005789756775, -0.42588773369789124, -0.4746246039867401, 0.3521798849105835, -0.46328482031822205, 0.10281652212142944, 0.23825407028198242, 0.7118104696273804, 0.007550186011940241, 0.7070469856262207, 0.31629008054733276, -0.06023237109184265, 0.2337338924407959, -0.047761380672454834, 0.06216518580913544, -0.8073476552963257, -0.2407343089580536, -0.1563573032617569, -0.24011389911174774, -0.29482075572013855, -0.8267186284065247, 0.4658942222595215, 0.12947161495685577, -0.2712753713130951, -0.054698146879673004, -0.5396079421043396, 0.5245034694671631, 0.23354800045490265, -0.07151521742343903, 0.4060284495353699, 0.2902873456478119, -0.11311908811330795, 0.0825376883149147, -0.381891667842865, -0.320854127407074, 0.9748201370239258, 0.35564857721328735, 1.452483892440796, -0.15095537900924683, 0.47772273421287537, 0.3921896517276764, 0.047949809581041336, -0.7192260026931763, 0.545261025428772, 0.3176605701446533, -0.6218261122703552, -0.16591374576091766, -0.527233362197876, -0.7142819762229919, 0.4241577982902527, -0.20430970191955566, -0.4366103410720825, 0.18167614936828613, 0.21568916738033295, -0.051362402737140656, 0.38180434703826904, -0.3752509653568268, 0.39528968930244446, -0.5058082342147827, -0.8862749934196472, -0.20612400770187378, -0.3140910565853119, 0.10265043377876282, -0.3282826542854309, 0.28098800778388977, -0.24234385788440704, 0.09800254553556442, 0.22715912759304047, -0.1745794117450714, 0.6438602209091187, 0.06660068035125732, -0.43620896339416504, 0.35639557242393494, 0.556846559047699, 0.5355615615844727, 0.0801888108253479, -0.31189751625061035, 0.14537623524665833, -0.0812903419137001, -0.13032373785972595, -0.6062515377998352, 0.8285605907440186, -0.42066091299057007, -0.6165735721588135, -0.4827127456665039, -0.8593106865882874, -0.07730058580636978, 0.41075801849365234, 0.02585238218307495, 0.1649000197649002, 0.10137181729078293, 0.30793946981430054, 0.8321679830551147, -0.19502869248390198, 0.1866311877965927, 0.3154635429382324, -0.44986024498939514, -0.3550017476081848, 1.2070984840393066, 0.16973264515399933, 0.21822646260261536, 0.3857841491699219, 0.014147013425827026, -0.2207474708557129, -0.3396669924259186, -0.4458182752132416, 0.3154129385948181, -0.659100353717804, -0.463276743888855, -0.474783718585968, -0.20024892687797546, -0.22324348986148834, -0.19840691983699799, -0.539036750793457, -0.412859171628952, -0.1626771241426468, -0.1441037505865097, 0.3449133634567261, 0.4965258240699768, -0.11989296972751617, 0.01711367629468441, -0.45278432965278625, 0.6175516843795776, 0.10378619283437729, 0.5272470712661743, -0.051244836300611496, -0.34546181559562683, -0.14235055446624756, -0.041535552591085434, -0.31352412700653076, -0.6684041619300842, 0.38006919622421265, 0.2261527180671692, 0.562690019607544, -0.026910673826932907, 0.06305002421140671, 0.5576768517494202, -0.5152384042739868, 0.5248348712921143, -0.1436942219734192, -0.8168942332267761, 0.36203354597091675, -0.42506152391433716, 0.13570328056812286, 0.489937424659729, 0.41561341285705566, -0.18345065414905548, -0.07981876283884048, -0.2042774260044098, -1.106340765953064, 0.4330747127532959, 0.0021359026432037354, -0.15670374035835266, 0.06579193472862244, 0.15743540227413177, 0.013497559353709221, 0.541109561920166, -0.7842755913734436, -0.23421835899353027, -0.06877155601978302, -0.2452128529548645, 0.10241317003965378, -0.24808983504772186, -0.2681194543838501, -0.024160917848348618, 0.7757210731506348, -0.3230264484882355, 0.11422455310821533, 0.17057104408740997, -0.38622015714645386, -0.04888555034995079, 0.31250688433647156, 0.33846521377563477, 0.6966983675956726, -0.4211648404598236, 0.4039131999015808, 0.18700045347213745, -0.5133161544799805, 0.17508095502853394, -0.08371265977621078, 0.07754147052764893, -0.10148397833108902, 0.08432268351316452, 0.3691917955875397, 0.012824076227843761, -0.8466665148735046, 0.12935273349285126, 0.1522643268108368, -0.1546979546546936, -0.24397575855255127, -0.1855792999267578, 0.033770784735679626, 0.3664121627807617, 0.35577812790870667, -0.14427708089351654, 0.19819898903369904, -0.6708232164382935, 0.41991180181503296, 0.2536419630050659, -0.07240350544452667, -0.04566671699285507, 0.6733396053314209, 0.06933904439210892, 0.030882541090250015, 0.5286400318145752, -0.05082877352833748, -0.2215840369462967, 0.34683504700660706, 0.5712423920631409, 0.3835827112197876, -0.19619910418987274, 0.11789754778146744, 0.18394403159618378, 0.18018268048763275, -0.1781070977449417, 0.2927111089229584, -0.15554390847682953, -0.4158068597316742, -0.27448979020118713, -0.9344399571418762, -0.5109887719154358, 0.1150670275092125, -0.3271453380584717, 0.19190022349357605, -0.5596725940704346, -0.11913255602121353, -0.0999971553683281, 0.14555829763412476, -0.20259082317352295, 0.11893249303102493, 0.10689570009708405, 0.9653432965278625, -0.5479093194007874, 0.9375487565994263, 0.3138678967952728, -0.29923203587532043, -0.5524200201034546, -0.20822010934352875, 0.0968899354338646, -0.5686587691307068, 0.7070404291152954, 0.007284778170287609, -0.31540995836257935, -0.1735299825668335, -0.43418875336647034, -1.1422423124313354, 1.2352805137634277, 0.48081445693969727, -0.5312210321426392, -0.007862452417612076, 0.12126077711582184, 0.6252807974815369, 0.020583858713507652, 0.32974088191986084, 0.49255433678627014, 0.5035300850868225, 0.35417309403419495, -0.8797056078910828, 0.011975751258432865, -0.32370254397392273, -0.3298815190792084, 0.24486106634140015, -0.6132239103317261, 1.125019907951355, 0.005304379388689995, -0.21685895323753357, -0.03297390788793564, 0.7132777571678162, 0.6625933051109314, 0.2706649899482727, 0.14379656314849854, 0.45740869641304016, 0.9108680486679077, -0.14781637489795685, 0.745064914226532, -0.5798541307449341, 0.29695960879325867, 1.2896672487258911, -0.6019002199172974, 0.7395632266998291, 0.7850613594055176, 0.02145957015454769, 0.44876745343208313, 0.4056737720966339, -0.13592912256717682, 0.4669454097747803, 0.40117278695106506, -0.23845142126083374, -0.3109629154205322, -0.20543664693832397, -0.28328269720077515, 0.21509627997875214, 0.5162584781646729, -0.20075520873069763, -0.1533682644367218, -0.059990789741277695, 0.007853981107473373, 0.06673406064510345, -0.26339542865753174, 0.42700114846229553, 0.1829736977815628, -0.5245130658149719, 0.6833990812301636, -0.11482466757297516, 0.7486749887466431, -0.5563267469406128, -0.32759547233581543, -0.3224659264087677, 0.29838138818740845, -0.1903565376996994, -0.7467060685157776, 0.07586271315813065, -0.1608627289533615, -0.3194597363471985, -0.18040376901626587, 0.7257274985313416, -0.4842812716960907, -0.2553755044937134, 0.23187002539634705, 0.38140547275543213, 0.11965563893318176, 0.04609442874789238, -0.3662742078304291, 0.25481924414634705, -0.17973551154136658, -0.4312857389450073, 0.36698949337005615, 0.534542441368103, -0.15472674369812012, 1.0133789777755737, 0.6454637050628662, 0.25831636786460876, -0.09056439995765686, -0.09164758026599884, 1.0695892572402954, -0.41474971175193787, 0.11647520214319229, -0.795978307723999, 0.2649252712726593, -0.0059033711440861225, 0.03405110165476799, 0.7727584838867188, 0.6473437547683716, 0.8177068829536438, -0.030378030613064766, 0.6155696511268616, 0.05885063484311104, 0.37295764684677124, -0.43465784192085266, 0.7307299375534058, -0.7533165216445923, 0.39775341749191284, -0.1831752508878708, -0.9883255958557129, -0.2000238001346588, 0.6019954085350037, 0.04149843007326126, 0.09815492480993271, 0.5706701278686523, 0.8640053272247314, -0.19964681565761566, -0.5351735353469849, 0.19568012654781342, 0.4865818917751312, 0.4830265939235687, 0.20380449295043945, 0.6664486527442932, -0.19222167134284973, 0.4945457875728607, -0.06290900707244873, -0.023974569514393806, -0.16125275194644928, -0.7135767340660095, -0.7706887722015381, -0.3840998709201813, 0.10184068977832794, -0.3694247007369995, -0.05449938774108887, 1.095008134841919, 0.6399255394935608, -0.40086981654167175, -0.30596923828125, -0.10974548757076263, 0.19300761818885803, 0.16627855598926544, -0.1934862583875656, 0.2589585483074188, -0.41916489601135254, -0.8804672956466675, 0.5336458086967468, 0.34120166301727295, 0.11894739419221878, -0.4104407727718353, -0.10616552084684372, -0.0181122999638319, 0.38133227825164795, 0.737561821937561, 0.31508705019950867, -0.5032938718795776, 0.09044783562421799, 0.20946253836154938, -0.26456329226493835, 0.12078601866960526, 0.43034854531288147, -0.8559614419937134, 0.5129002332687378, 0.6941016316413879, 0.6214993000030518, 0.5692935585975647, -0.12194835394620895, 0.5927870869636536, -0.6405895948410034, 0.044509947299957275, 0.28099194169044495, 0.40473583340644836, 0.2678922712802887, -0.31680718064308167, 0.6563969850540161, 0.12057787925004959, -0.8554285168647766, -1.1604033708572388, 0.3816622495651245, -1.0213980674743652, -0.6446152329444885, 1.169061303138733, 0.24483788013458252, -0.46620631217956543, 0.22719907760620117, -0.3167794644832611, 0.2529277503490448, -0.35978972911834717, 0.9640049934387207, 0.5870741009712219, -0.10477839410305023, -0.0638793483376503, -0.4614686667919159, 0.5604545474052429, 0.3830861747264862, -0.8534948229789734, 0.42324674129486084, 0.6574205756187439, 0.18482930958271027, 0.3893762230873108, 0.5381924510002136, -0.19787637889385223, 0.09953825920820236, 0.15503166615962982, 0.27445706725120544, -0.24973274767398834, -0.9869993329048157, 0.008031574077904224, 0.13917526602745056, 0.1868007332086563, 0.40638697147369385 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17228v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17228v1	Morality is Non-Binary: Building a Pluralist Moral Sentence Embedding Space using Contrastive Learning	2024-01-30T18:15:25	2024-01-30T18:15:25	Jeongwoo Park, Enrico Liscio, Pradeep K. Murukannaiah	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Recent advances in NLP show that language models retain a discernible level of knowledge in deontological ethics and moral norms. However, existing works often treat morality as binary, ranging from right to wrong. This simplistic view does not capture the nuances of moral judgment. Pluralist moral philosophers argue that human morality can be deconstructed into a finite number of elements, respecting individual differences in moral judgment. In line with this view, we build a pluralist moral sentence embedding space via a state-of-the-art contrastive learning approach. We systematically investigate the embedding space by studying the emergence of relationships among moral elements, both quantitatively and qualitatively. Our results show that a pluralist approach to morality can be captured in an embedding space. However, moral pluralism is challenging to deduce via self-supervision alone and requires a supervised approach with human labels.	[ -0.35313090682029724, -0.4299010932445526, 0.6797908544540405, 0.14462214708328247, -0.5708639025688171, -0.050644975155591965, 0.2610207796096802, -0.388435035943985, 0.20992858707904816, 0.3148622214794159, -0.05689311772584915, -0.3547961413860321, -0.602138340473175, 0.11878147721290588, -0.07079283893108368, 1.0479907989501953, 0.5309224128723145, 0.12356199324131012, -0.4216439723968506, -0.48193833231925964, -0.30310332775115967, -0.6519949436187744, -0.478302001953125, -0.03526512160897255, 0.4002224802970886, 0.17223630845546722, 0.8298097848892212, 0.6396535038948059, 0.14864718914031982, 0.40922755002975464, -0.18409383296966553, -0.20885685086250305, -0.5305428504943848, -0.20088911056518555, -0.5238379240036011, -0.3717135787010193, 0.04923663288354874, 0.24281065165996552, 0.4854583740234375, 0.7716843485832214, -0.06269475817680359, -0.16720210015773773, -0.12148464471101761, 0.5998526215553284, -0.5707459449768066, -0.030961597338318825, -0.5642454624176025, 0.30507558584213257, 0.39665424823760986, 0.25535377860069275, -0.2130734622478485, -0.8256971836090088, 0.22480963170528412, -0.5072876214981079, 0.21698136627674103, 0.08292196691036224, 0.39024895429611206, 0.19164514541625977, -1.004348874092102, -0.4714236855506897, -0.22691433131694794, 1.3638827800750732, -0.6235302090644836, 0.47125327587127686, 0.37227663397789, -0.20292580127716064, 0.1529809832572937, -0.5807006359100342, -0.457122266292572, -0.1451028436422348, -0.2995016276836395, 0.09489750117063522, -0.016088204458355904, -0.07653441280126572, 0.012824973091483116, 0.2634851038455963, -0.021162550896406174, 0.008889483287930489, -0.6139696836471558, 0.09019020199775696, 0.8296974301338196, -0.12987609207630157, 0.28545787930488586, -0.51694256067276, -0.6928333640098572, 0.05327052250504494, -0.29043009877204895, 0.2822430729866028, 0.7608848810195923, 0.1856512427330017, -0.08396542817354202, 0.31227007508277893, 0.7378418445587158, 0.11515149474143982, 0.341510146856308, 0.1424618661403656, 0.2228933721780777, -0.32419177889823914, 0.06343667209148407, 0.07936794310808182, 0.640369713306427, 0.6188623309135437, 0.2741295397281647, -0.058118414133787155, -0.14016491174697876, 0.284771591424942, 0.7839434742927551, -0.6682882905006409, -0.11698070168495178, 0.20433416962623596, -0.620937705039978, -0.6627479791641235, 0.23235540091991425, -0.3387845754623413, -0.34179532527923584, -0.2254590392112732, 0.012478794902563095, -0.5763082504272461, -0.07742521911859512, 0.412027508020401, -0.26885831356048584, 0.42976808547973633, 0.24561819434165955, -0.9704515337944031, 0.4037332534790039, 0.7636116147041321, 0.5188219547271729, 0.10866725444793701, 0.004091884940862656, -0.3573278486728668, 0.08074308186769485, -0.4929599463939667, 0.542536199092865, -0.7446171641349792, -0.653192400932312, -0.08511186391115189, -0.06122154742479324, 0.36315473914146423, -0.36373651027679443, 0.7051177024841309, -0.2081565260887146, 0.3879449963569641, -0.274734765291214, -0.7349144220352173, -0.4948408901691437, 0.2280392050743103, -0.6020879745483398, 0.4718230068683624, -0.07420235127210617, -0.7967165112495422, 0.2926682233810425, -0.4812791049480438, -0.2324599325656891, 0.2729647159576416, -0.5453366041183472, -0.461062490940094, 0.3409532308578491, -0.14378118515014648, 0.31020045280456543, 0.1975995898246765, 0.533069908618927, -0.5004395246505737, -0.4222429692745209, 0.2016480416059494, -0.142716184258461, 1.0119112730026245, -0.029676882550120354, -0.1267896592617035, -0.22964249551296234, -0.5731245875358582, -0.032081615179777145, 0.03212922066450119, -0.36399129033088684, -0.7039963603019714, 0.2880604863166809, 0.12072195112705231, 0.29548370838165283, 0.25350838899612427, -0.7860876321792603, -0.04543715715408325, -0.6210744976997375, 0.41039949655532837, 1.121686577796936, -0.1070684939622879, 0.6758844256401062, -0.4227266311645508, 0.054682377725839615, 0.14784061908721924, 0.12401285767555237, 0.36585038900375366, -0.45594334602355957, -0.5426395535469055, 0.07117772847414017, -0.12106812000274658, 0.4509080648422241, -0.23689128458499908, 0.9757955074310303, 0.32640039920806885, 0.007975463755428791, -0.3390272855758667, 0.046043604612350464, 0.5804954767227173, 0.07881574332714081, 0.5395411849021912, -0.48785150051116943, -0.49753665924072266, -1.0949597358703613, -0.3005412220954895, -0.3068042993545532, 0.19792167842388153, 0.5026136040687561, 0.9006181955337524, -0.15489639341831207, 0.7409244179725647, -0.30210378766059875, -0.1781296730041504, 0.039754144847393036, -0.0666007474064827, 0.1456463783979416, 0.733293354511261, 0.6135562658309937, -1.113686203956604, -0.028998764231801033, -0.11743400990962982, -1.0598400831222534, 0.3008277714252472, 0.12787264585494995, -0.06380283832550049, -0.3474968671798706, 0.671230673789978, 0.10625303536653519, 0.336017906665802, 0.49196857213974, -0.8432922959327698, 0.3937074542045593, -0.2409745305776596, -0.1814664751291275, -1.2293308973312378, -0.2070988118648529, -0.20717982947826385, -0.30397048592567444, -0.2605443000793457, -0.14809361100196838, -0.072360560297966, 0.0834965631365776, -0.5478670597076416, 0.4383780360221863, -0.10815070569515228, -0.2057977318763733, -0.0459289513528347, 0.24891944229602814, 0.10372862964868546, 0.3865634500980377, -0.12277843058109283, 0.30797460675239563, 0.24606604874134064, -0.4099508225917816, 0.30159974098205566, 0.5986344218254089, 0.05491916090250015, 0.7673454880714417, -0.6868281364440918, 0.1901247799396515, -0.36004599928855896, 0.23555758595466614, -0.7831587791442871, 0.29183194041252136, 0.260223925113678, -0.2494651973247528, -0.38189005851745605, -0.3956240117549896, -0.30023393034935, 0.12796930968761444, -0.6001783013343811, 0.7785454392433167, 0.48663094639778137, -0.4194370210170746, 0.42702415585517883, 0.48917242884635925, -0.22299616038799286, -0.8814866542816162, -0.6310492753982544, -0.20450709760189056, -0.14677922427654266, -0.6020368933677673, 0.4403286874294281, 0.03999016433954239, -0.6464763283729553, 0.33826738595962524, -0.16728579998016357, -0.10320475697517395, 0.14928880333900452, 0.31263527274131775, 0.11111185699701309, -0.09228197485208511, 0.6342170238494873, 0.21319697797298431, -0.31089410185813904, 0.1738773137331009, -0.3764077126979828, 0.14282143115997314, -0.8159202337265015, -0.30748090147972107, -0.1168348491191864, 0.8036298155784607, 0.23377656936645508, -0.08498574793338776, 0.545193076133728, 0.2521193027496338, -0.28253015875816345, -0.23981337249279022, -0.3764936625957489, -0.08265024423599243, -0.48713287711143494, 0.09154991060495377, 0.038998089730739594, -1.1378073692321777, 0.21722185611724854, -0.08427122980356216, 0.34760215878486633, 0.44197848439216614, 0.14360304176807404, -0.38722744584083557, 0.35162103176116943, 0.8852006793022156, 0.5419341921806335, 0.4341127276420593, -0.29949307441711426, 0.3586637079715729, -0.6840529441833496, -0.1976323127746582, -0.23349972069263458, -0.48914551734924316, -0.8414818644523621, -0.6090424060821533, 0.1272488385438919, 0.38094061613082886, -0.4525162875652313, -0.05096283555030823, -0.3939797580242157, 0.7909895181655884, 0.3784761130809784, 0.04745161533355713, 0.3403976559638977, -0.2571132481098175, -0.2762424051761627, -0.14030137658119202, -0.27689099311828613, -0.9726827144622803, 0.8042016625404358, -0.03496544435620308, 0.6159456968307495, 0.4832945466041565, 1.0908563137054443, 0.4254699945449829, -0.2259606420993805, -0.6722733378410339, 0.5295161604881287, -0.870006263256073, -0.41297000646591187, -0.06625878065824509, -0.19623270630836487, -1.2779942750930786, 0.6157152652740479, -0.3298462927341461, -0.42312100529670715, 0.6849443316459656, -0.10346993058919907, -0.2685699164867401, 0.6006069779396057, -0.7018673419952393, 0.6307830810546875, -0.27100247144699097, -0.38217687606811523, -0.4725174009799957, -0.8253706693649292, 0.12949565052986145, 0.10873719304800034, 0.22698558866977692, -0.17445464432239532, -0.32015126943588257, 0.7318116426467896, -0.27809834480285645, 1.2261358499526978, -0.06739341467618942, -0.21768803894519806, 0.0008790006977505982, 0.24566732347011566, 0.18178679049015045, 0.4678458273410797, 0.1037212684750557, 0.0436202734708786, 0.13521160185337067, -0.7078169584274292, -0.5660894513130188, 0.5885565280914307, -0.9129180312156677, -0.33825331926345825, -0.627432644367218, -0.40051543712615967, -0.1369280070066452, 0.016221653670072556, -0.0864497572183609, 0.3140472173690796, -0.6292589902877808, 0.5529040694236755, 0.6746565103530884, -0.6283473968505859, 0.5017507672309875, 0.25108253955841064, -0.15984469652175903, -0.3557893931865692, 0.5244975686073303, -0.13664406538009644, -0.0031028389930725098, 0.2537071108818054, 0.46646684408187866, -0.535155177116394, -0.16315174102783203, 0.06279698014259338, 0.36742350459098816, -0.8870145678520203, 0.2510104179382324, -0.7470081448554993, -0.12632203102111816, -0.2787218987941742, -1.0604346990585327, -0.5183814764022827, -0.3092287480831146, -0.2506905794143677, -0.29842665791511536, 0.1931232362985611, 1.0699247121810913, -0.3920932710170746, -0.20450569689273834, -0.9278846383094788, 0.5022475123405457, 0.8047466278076172, 0.3609127700328827, -0.22214536368846893, -0.25720804929733276, 0.2812125086784363, -0.18759477138519287, -0.2509324550628662, -0.6084076762199402, 0.07245510071516037, 0.05582943558692932, 0.6406334638595581, 0.4453534185886383, 0.19853080809116364, 0.30544015765190125, -0.31476351618766785, 0.6804240345954895, 0.44134074449539185, -1.1483114957809448, 0.5795023441314697, -0.139785036444664, -0.13495083153247833, 0.4605010449886322, 0.46488532423973083, -0.6254189014434814, -0.29171282052993774, -1.0853935480117798, -0.8442904353141785, 0.3094787895679474, 0.23538456857204437, 0.5932033061981201, -0.20922590792179108, 0.351673424243927, 0.4576994478702545, 0.2536463141441345, -1.075486183166504, -0.04486183449625969, -0.49676597118377686, -0.1635132133960724, -0.19129708409309387, -0.26005157828330994, -0.33025699853897095, -0.14767944812774658, 0.23192089796066284, -0.11366873234510422, 0.28033867478370667, 0.13380612432956696, -0.15874718129634857, 0.3255692720413208, 0.5972709655761719, 0.0457804910838604, 0.664768397808075, -0.06161507964134216, 0.3259012997150421, 0.11795680224895477, -0.2341986745595932, 0.4120405614376068, -0.26870882511138916, -0.04247941076755524, -0.22508198022842407, 0.3655971586704254, 0.4222124516963959, 0.4481199085712433, -0.31567367911338806, 0.9028350710868835, -0.15301181375980377, -0.4013393521308899, -0.510795533657074, -0.13292577862739563, 0.1403861939907074, 0.5800614953041077, -0.13593050837516785, 0.18679700791835785, 0.11860593408346176, -0.7337671518325806, 0.47319918870925903, 0.3108293414115906, -0.5574380159378052, -0.3094978928565979, 0.36532989144325256, 0.4140545725822449, -0.19805584847927094, 0.7891942858695984, -0.23967216908931732, -0.338052362203598, 0.6810271143913269, 0.6268286108970642, 0.7667900919914246, -0.1185004934668541, 0.5479140877723694, 0.5520442128181458, 0.2586394250392914, 0.07604324072599411, 0.40974414348602295, -0.08932290226221085, -1.2125355005264282, -0.28326961398124695, -0.6551226377487183, -0.4128738343715668, -0.4688887894153595, -0.6827685236930847, -0.14756275713443756, -0.8654693365097046, 0.14151357114315033, -0.12880322337150574, -0.012822494842112064, -0.17273397743701935, 0.24671326577663422, 0.14688554406166077, 0.14211182296276093, -0.7937168478965759, 0.5205716490745544, 0.4693108797073364, -0.39628276228904724, -0.3362603187561035, -0.20485447347164154, -0.10521520674228668, -0.7705104947090149, 0.6189043521881104, 0.3285364806652069, -0.6711660623550415, -0.12883053719997406, -0.791079044342041, -0.40875330567359924, 0.8235400319099426, 0.2989073693752289, -0.2933445870876312, -0.011517955921590328, -0.41007253527641296, 0.5807650089263916, -0.3787063956260681, -0.4223770797252655, -0.034163884818553925, 0.33807095885276794, -0.10229429602622986, -0.10750377923250198, 0.2249484360218048, -0.3910406529903412, 0.026784537360072136, 0.3021344840526581, -0.674008309841156, 1.058519721031189, -0.5794591307640076, -0.3937382996082306, -0.2562097907066345, 0.3253410756587982, 0.17610982060432434, 0.2228323221206665, 0.7529146671295166, 0.6263308525085449, 0.8093824982643127, 0.19710397720336914, 0.7718448042869568, 0.047182224690914154, 0.35529154539108276, 0.9716924428939819, -0.00025261606788262725, 0.7228332757949829, 0.6765453219413757, -0.01636797934770584, 1.0680909156799316, 0.07552450895309448, -0.3903248906135559, 0.4483259320259094, 0.2473209649324417, -0.2959694564342499, -0.4674951136112213, -0.1722143590450287, -0.2814446687698364, 0.6295928359031677, 0.3575730621814728, -0.5299782156944275, -0.16081969439983368, -0.2818349003791809, -0.2967713177204132, 0.26351025700569153, -0.17627504467964172, 0.8854381442070007, 0.46997201442718506, -0.1342514157295227, 0.02870841696858406, 0.03472550958395004, 0.8177422285079956, -0.4417875409126282, -0.1638326644897461, -0.012426609173417091, 0.11843957751989365, -0.34383508563041687, -0.9820750951766968, 0.532323956489563, -0.14886468648910522, -0.05043775960803032, -0.4841015040874481, 0.5224155783653259, -0.10950638353824615, -0.4171389937400818, 0.6232750415802002, 0.6707605123519897, 0.20680898427963257, 0.5299508571624756, -0.662168025970459, -0.7441461086273193, 0.005672128405421972, 0.3297557234764099, 0.24292604625225067, 0.49160200357437134, -0.044930122792720795, 0.5322151780128479, 0.8800248503684998, -0.3091641068458557, -0.06953950226306915, -0.017817314714193344, 0.6739581227302551, -1.3306052684783936, -0.824816107749939, -0.8195215463638306, 0.5059725642204285, -0.1025848239660263, -0.5029944777488708, 0.33630576729774475, 0.4651366174221039, 0.9222390651702881, 0.09578430652618408, 0.7093481421470642, -0.15216320753097534, 0.05846155434846878, -0.4293994903564453, 0.4132539629936218, -0.6239628791809082, 0.06389623880386353, -0.026524491608142853, -0.6641919612884521, -0.3770519495010376, 1.0571165084838867, -0.36096224188804626, 0.18315833806991577, 0.7843821048736572, 0.4678436815738678, -0.17868134379386902, 0.26934269070625305, 0.669134259223938, 0.198740154504776, 0.09883705526590347, 0.5369388461112976, 1.2027099132537842, -0.361741840839386, 0.5528507232666016, -0.09013175964355469, 0.06385396420955658, 0.07107119262218475, -0.8309166431427002, -0.6175404191017151, -0.5569269061088562, -0.04075699672102928, -0.16046416759490967, -0.13079378008842468, 0.8844236135482788, 0.4543915092945099, -0.6556010842323303, -0.33901530504226685, -0.29046905040740967, 0.38683855533599854, -0.1691221445798874, -0.1982448250055313, 0.2938472628593445, -0.2822278141975403, -0.6335297226905823, 0.16590248048305511, 0.5240964293479919, 0.08774527907371521, -0.08289863169193268, -0.0006094826385378838, -0.5045821666717529, 0.24600887298583984, 0.7517719268798828, -0.19420896470546722, -0.8258581161499023, -0.5495323538780212, -0.6384276151657104, -0.16179315745830536, 0.2108144760131836, 0.8886078000068665, -0.5345536470413208, 0.4178884029388428, 0.4832721948623657, 0.5031024217605591, 0.13640457391738892, 0.14590172469615936, 0.5650302171707153, -0.8037671446800232, 0.0873047411441803, 0.7452600598335266, 0.4517019987106323, 0.24140430986881256, -0.2557068169116974, 0.5054839849472046, 0.4680855870246887, -0.5273710489273071, -0.17823980748653412, 0.8111019730567932, -1.0711652040481567, -0.6546317934989929, 0.7490347027778625, -0.2272006869316101, 0.04055719077587128, -0.7629712224006653, -0.2479301542043686, 0.014860142953693867, -0.411075621843338, 0.7575388550758362, 0.4338860511779785, -0.16602294147014618, 0.08747612684965134, -0.11264441162347794, 0.2203061431646347, 0.33576756715774536, -0.7240791320800781, -0.2472890317440033, 0.6151772737503052, 0.3903067409992218, 0.25357457995414734, 0.4215768277645111, -0.42801812291145325, 0.2426888644695282, 0.4538287818431854, -0.03479921817779541, 0.0942295491695404, 0.10649807006120682, -0.35286766290664673, 0.46826913952827454, -0.4874299168586731, -0.11018859595060349 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17221v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17221v1	MouSi: Poly-Visual-Expert Vision-Language Models	2024-01-30T18:09:11	2024-01-30T18:09:11	Xiaoran Fan, Tao Ji, Changhao Jiang, Shuo Li, Senjie Jin, Sirui Song, Junke Wang, Boyang Hong, Lu Chen, Guodong Zheng, Ming Zhang, Caishuang Huang, Rui Zheng, Zhiheng Xi, Yuhao Zhou, Shihan Dou, Junjie Ye, Hang Yan, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xipeng Qiu, Xuanjing Huang, Zuxuan Wu, Yu-Gang Jiang	cs.CV	cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG	Current large vision-language models (VLMs) often encounter challenges such as insufficient capabilities of a single visual component and excessively long visual tokens. These issues can limit the model's effectiveness in accurately interpreting complex visual information and over-lengthy contextual information. Addressing these challenges is crucial for enhancing the performance and applicability of VLMs. This paper proposes the use of ensemble experts technique to synergizes the capabilities of individual visual encoders, including those skilled in image-text matching, OCR, image segmentation, etc. This technique introduces a fusion network to unify the processing of outputs from different visual experts, while bridging the gap between image encoders and pre-trained LLMs. In addition, we explore different positional encoding schemes to alleviate the waste of positional encoding caused by lengthy image feature sequences, effectively addressing the issue of position overflow and length limitations. For instance, in our implementation, this technique significantly reduces the positional occupancy in models like SAM, from a substantial 4096 to a more efficient and manageable 64 or even down to 1. Experimental results demonstrate that VLMs with multiple experts exhibit consistently superior performance over isolated visual encoders and mark a significant performance boost as more experts are integrated. We have open-sourced the training code used in this report. All of these resources can be found on our project website.	[ -0.5050820112228394, -0.2565215826034546, 0.4755452573299408, -0.25627124309539795, -0.5069771409034729, 0.3153683841228485, -0.2784489393234253, -0.7245123386383057, 0.1552886664867401, 0.4579181373119354, -0.09225407242774963, -0.4077913463115692, -0.6551566123962402, 0.14511828124523163, -0.33564630150794983, 0.3727991282939911, -0.0323539562523365, 0.26988327503204346, -0.6134946942329407, -0.23833104968070984, -0.2013872265815735, -0.40690475702285767, -0.44201305508613586, 0.014471824280917645, 0.2829492390155792, 0.15432509779930115, 0.6443725824356079, 0.5859485864639282, 0.9153681993484497, 0.4646056294441223, 0.028715137392282486, 0.45036816596984863, -0.40514838695526123, -0.02484997734427452, -0.3101779520511627, -0.4726155698299408, -0.47529712319374084, -0.4765470027923584, 0.6491170525550842, 0.31251442432403564, -0.1782476007938385, 0.04121583327651024, -0.09974581003189087, 0.5634549856185913, -0.890306293964386, 0.07856975495815277, -0.7279133796691895, 0.06939799338579178, -0.29964637756347656, -0.255695104598999, -0.40618935227394104, 0.08713851869106293, 0.2732057273387909, -0.5791634321212769, 0.0380440317094326, 0.1771080642938614, 0.6076194047927856, 0.6149599552154541, -0.21714703738689423, 0.3571464419364929, -0.5777497291564941, 0.77579665184021, -0.7386904954910278, 0.4175105690956116, -0.0027303711976855993, 0.36859557032585144, -0.04962193965911865, -0.38309571146965027, -0.7705774307250977, 0.20032885670661926, -0.04551662132143974, 0.4389136731624603, -0.028847921639680862, 0.2541389763355255, 0.04189378395676613, 0.17303036153316498, -0.4152877628803253, 0.3790557086467743, -0.6918566226959229, 0.01449345238506794, 1.1040053367614746, 0.28149306774139404, 0.10080350190401077, 0.23118844628334045, -0.4927363097667694, -0.16732066869735718, -0.19583092629909515, -0.0958593562245369, 0.1271924376487732, -0.15311336517333984, -0.0025586995761841536, 0.5709121823310852, -0.3173051178455353, 1.0008498430252075, -0.14273379743099213, -0.5092671513557434, 0.3129647970199585, -0.10745173692703247, -0.3151383697986603, -0.025311466306447983, 0.7966680526733398, 0.40734100341796875, 0.31814560294151306, -0.04640955850481987, -0.4093273878097534, 0.0454382561147213, 0.1271974891424179, -0.2908412516117096, -0.32467591762542725, 0.022782621905207634, -0.39163705706596375, -0.22575095295906067, 0.19538910686969757, -0.9235057830810547, -0.48433902859687805, -0.48368561267852783, 0.4838173985481262, -0.4567025899887085, -0.23692215979099274, 0.07336252182722092, -0.4295797646045685, 0.21918295323848724, 0.5241618156433105, -0.8393884301185608, 0.2470720112323761, 0.4550260305404663, 0.5085938572883606, -0.47647443413734436, -0.426448792219162, -0.3784346878528595, 0.2974783778190613, -0.14767181873321533, 0.7234193682670593, -0.826915442943573, -0.3892088234424591, -0.10445227473974228, -0.4183879792690277, -0.3450761139392853, -0.4071004390716553, 0.07099305838346481, -0.3489726781845093, 0.03260500729084015, -0.0071044787764549255, -0.45815590023994446, -0.08029619604349136, -0.03463561832904816, -0.45186033844947815, 0.6778416037559509, -0.16498835384845734, -0.5452626347541809, 0.35389742255210876, -0.4072825312614441, -0.29930296540260315, 0.55654376745224, -0.7193568348884583, -0.1507505625486374, 0.35742834210395813, 0.5348716974258423, 0.49689236283302307, -0.1646183878183365, -0.028369612991809845, -0.1930209845304489, -0.21483789384365082, 0.07804454118013382, -0.2105930745601654, 0.3028847575187683, 0.09142620861530304, -0.11119731515645981, 0.3789013922214508, -0.8385867476463318, 0.07015533000230789, 0.15623535215854645, -0.30755722522735596, -0.5057662129402161, 0.08728587627410889, -0.05246451869606972, 0.05263718590140343, 0.4303360879421234, -0.29707852005958557, 0.22038625180721283, -0.19040998816490173, 0.25000035762786865, 0.8527197241783142, -0.261394739151001, 0.5391459465026855, 0.1526034027338028, 0.31040483713150024, 0.07710792869329453, 0.242813840508461, -0.299354612827301, -0.6828003525733948, -0.9303174614906311, -0.3109334111213684, 0.16300298273563385, 0.7127609252929688, -1.3871735334396362, 0.4152398407459259, -0.43251824378967285, -0.41831469535827637, -0.732539176940918, 0.4199143350124359, 0.6416262984275818, 0.38715338706970215, 0.3227871358394623, -0.7231037020683289, -0.43322381377220154, -1.0207886695861816, 0.06528875231742859, -0.15082620084285736, 0.04122747480869293, 0.16450828313827515, 0.5552513003349304, 0.05541260913014412, 1.0187125205993652, -0.40372976660728455, -0.12147682160139084, -0.17877519130706787, -0.024561846628785133, -0.09533116966485977, 0.4860934317111969, 0.47071200609207153, -1.0075129270553589, -0.2548210620880127, 0.1698114573955536, -1.0130778551101685, 0.29997730255126953, 0.13001228868961334, -0.0411623977124691, 0.4940691888332367, 0.4037845730781555, -0.5616990923881531, 0.5643852949142456, 0.6109694838523865, -0.16760654747486115, 0.44924789667129517, -0.49191561341285706, 0.11122125387191772, -0.9696785807609558, -0.1898890882730484, 0.3454054296016693, -0.09939005225896835, -0.5280832648277283, 0.5244737863540649, -0.1089446097612381, -0.1890907734632492, -0.4781903028488159, 0.36793580651283264, -0.6048339009284973, -0.2210223525762558, -0.0391315296292305, 0.037116456776857376, -0.24656735360622406, 0.602517306804657, 0.4635724723339081, 0.616299033164978, 0.8529090285301208, -0.5022384524345398, 0.5726001858711243, 0.1357312798500061, -0.45630499720573425, 0.6884545087814331, -0.4157122075557709, 0.13075101375579834, -0.17262984812259674, 0.020584266632795334, -0.8228933811187744, -0.4649292826652527, 0.14702719449996948, -0.23578646779060364, 0.3326105773448944, 0.007519696839153767, -0.4565582871437073, -0.6592779755592346, 0.017533646896481514, 0.49459874629974365, 0.8143841028213501, -0.4967670440673828, 0.8725289702415466, 0.4944090247154236, 0.03347200155258179, -0.5317088961601257, -0.5903316736221313, 0.22704936563968658, -0.0946793332695961, -1.0037827491760254, 0.3979954421520233, 0.16945503652095795, -0.4164334833621979, 0.04234696552157402, 0.03234861418604851, 0.0542619451880455, -0.06335152685642242, 0.08404889702796936, 0.2940754294395447, -0.2968643009662628, 0.3251497745513916, -0.2483823448419571, -0.22317010164260864, -0.30754584074020386, -0.41105717420578003, 0.3854900598526001, -0.3803870975971222, -0.5956239104270935, -0.4735179543495178, 0.4032333195209503, 0.6745636463165283, -0.8342505097389221, 0.8730737566947937, 0.7775216102600098, -0.2506016194820404, -0.039612554013729095, -0.8880099058151245, -0.14869612455368042, -0.4872884750366211, 0.502469003200531, -0.3574985861778259, -0.711978554725647, 0.45423945784568787, -0.006033960729837418, -0.0886583924293518, 0.3213430941104889, 0.38635608553886414, -0.31791070103645325, 1.0607662200927734, 0.8338892459869385, -0.14332666993141174, 0.4534261226654053, -0.2828490734100342, 0.26520881056785583, -0.582432210445404, -0.5867899656295776, 0.035153377801179886, -0.45586636662483215, -0.16322293877601624, -0.6610103249549866, 0.5938828587532043, -0.0005321463104337454, 0.17623324692249298, 0.12096460908651352, -0.5982010960578918, 0.6598605513572693, 0.7543286085128784, 0.36515408754348755, 0.10544946789741516, 0.2572462260723114, 0.12833568453788757, 0.12320787459611893, -0.9766319990158081, -0.14203274250030518, 0.722164511680603, 0.27061229944229126, 0.9209569692611694, -0.02861597388982773, 0.6943452954292297, 0.0012744656996801496, -0.40117347240448, -0.5183559656143188, 0.9922793507575989, -0.3732597231864929, 0.05838099867105484, -0.4969504773616791, -0.127218097448349, -0.5070613622665405, 0.27310818433761597, -0.5765064358711243, -0.801338255405426, 0.5585587024688721, 0.2896921932697296, -0.4963855743408203, 0.5970264077186584, -0.7349793910980225, 0.6345223784446716, -0.5105457305908203, -0.45541179180145264, -0.348442941904068, -0.6921551823616028, 0.28804150223731995, -0.03430701792240143, -0.02301625907421112, 0.1859590709209442, -0.27151966094970703, 0.6328819394111633, -0.5112743377685547, 0.8223848342895508, 0.048147521913051605, -0.010665600188076496, 0.33541762828826904, -0.27888956665992737, 0.4910447597503662, -0.34278786182403564, 0.007364481687545776, 0.37410256266593933, -0.4829775094985962, -0.4377540946006775, -0.5099377632141113, 0.4438929855823517, -0.7788200378417969, -0.8482450842857361, -0.10778169333934784, -0.43017420172691345, -0.13720200955867767, 0.0319356769323349, 0.3717763125896454, 0.618104100227356, 0.32683953642845154, 0.2356564849615097, 0.7534902095794678, 0.03648906201124191, 0.6269684433937073, 0.23586854338645935, -0.03426780924201012, -0.47402751445770264, 1.1135761737823486, 0.06895630061626434, 0.3056279122829437, 0.4534182548522949, -0.13184520602226257, 0.056732725352048874, -0.9243857264518738, -0.535803496837616, -0.15190288424491882, -0.8195672631263733, -0.0642695426940918, -0.5466628670692444, -0.2071554809808731, -0.4388960897922516, -0.3285132348537445, -0.25449877977371216, -0.30134814977645874, -0.15688104927539825, 0.09849409759044647, 0.4069380462169647, 0.48287418484687805, 0.2061968296766281, 0.2853686213493347, -0.8372012376785278, 0.06231137365102768, 0.5930416584014893, 0.16299326717853546, -0.008456479758024216, -0.1994239240884781, -0.4257235527038574, -0.27738091349601746, 0.20120090246200562, -0.7052898406982422, 0.5157029628753662, 0.1193532645702362, 1.0327842235565186, 0.40522587299346924, -0.08434447646141052, 0.8863829374313354, -0.25664329528808594, 0.8213956356048584, 0.45410120487213135, -0.7032960057258606, 0.5512563586235046, -0.26616567373275757, 0.44674333930015564, 0.43051162362098694, 0.10083375126123428, 0.09097199141979218, -0.3900802433490753, -0.3705691993236542, -0.9961616396903992, 0.5700024962425232, 0.29600781202316284, -0.30401611328125, 0.24962826073169708, 0.05184390768408775, -0.0490114688873291, 0.21907803416252136, -0.22897295653820038, 0.11429386585950851, -0.08773770928382874, -0.47691577672958374, -0.07001137733459473, -0.16949757933616638, -0.21808554232120514, -0.409511536359787, 0.5047685503959656, -0.2529671788215637, 0.21368233859539032, 0.3461553454399109, -0.25249648094177246, -0.1285010576248169, 0.020145222544670105, 0.699530303478241, 0.830642819404602, 0.12815655767917633, 0.027950558811426163, 0.6217119693756104, -0.25267139077186584, -0.1723160445690155, 0.001352098654024303, 0.008784685283899307, -0.1286306083202362, 0.5967381596565247, 1.0392273664474487, 0.23965707421302795, -0.7559962868690491, 0.39680835604667664, 0.16998907923698425, -0.03721902146935463, -0.4778517782688141, 0.3570534288883209, -0.19744333624839783, 0.4655162990093231, 0.5350388884544373, 0.628104567527771, 0.01952093280851841, -0.4602840542793274, 0.145457461476326, 0.26970693469047546, -0.32881221175193787, -0.10124894231557846, 0.4317528009414673, 0.7051175236701965, -0.4235239624977112, 0.51764315366745, 0.03375338390469551, -0.6360010504722595, 0.8428983092308044, 0.22448337078094482, 0.6705082654953003, -0.30775314569473267, -0.02898724004626274, 0.11714094132184982, 0.16287854313850403, -0.146145299077034, 0.21177496016025543, 0.06826140731573105, -0.8121340274810791, -0.39035314321517944, -0.4579009413719177, -0.23816494643688202, -0.24938859045505524, -0.5322856903076172, 0.3929539918899536, -0.2704026997089386, -0.014316669665277004, -0.17680874466896057, -0.5405553579330444, -0.9019052982330322, 0.1582203358411789, 0.7588900327682495, 0.9421849250793457, -0.6187989711761475, 0.9212329387664795, 0.9701642394065857, -0.2379373461008072, -0.5368862748146057, -0.26227930188179016, 0.05231030657887459, -0.9259238243103027, 0.5724589824676514, 0.028684938326478004, -0.20944873988628387, 0.054772377014160156, -0.6678587198257446, -0.6990891098976135, 1.3181495666503906, 0.15950416028499603, -1.0226496458053589, -0.04258450120687485, -0.09202150255441666, 0.6670129895210266, -0.6148341298103333, 0.28299766778945923, 0.3657371997833252, 0.2557676434516907, 0.18866637349128723, -1.1271624565124512, -0.24844704568386078, -0.44212907552719116, 0.09875717014074326, 0.17009414732456207, -0.7867681384086609, 0.7895728349685669, -0.46846792101860046, 0.0030000817496329546, 0.1112826019525528, 0.7918455004692078, 0.28140103816986084, 0.24044516682624817, 0.6862601041793823, 0.6948250532150269, 0.742448091506958, 0.06168070062994957, 1.1230474710464478, -0.37712952494621277, -0.000719443429261446, 0.8902075290679932, -0.12239977717399597, 1.0999181270599365, 0.5298373699188232, 0.04859113320708275, 0.3729188144207001, 0.38841983675956726, -0.37362706661224365, 0.6773772835731506, -0.16750667989253998, -0.3260418474674225, -0.7562366724014282, -0.12541350722312927, -0.43186768889427185, 0.4570440948009491, 0.4374583661556244, -0.5125067830085754, 0.062161508947610855, 0.24865970015525818, -0.579332172870636, 0.170591801404953, -0.713581383228302, 0.8154298663139343, 0.18631704151630402, -0.5587447881698608, 0.18732689321041107, -0.26682397723197937, 0.8676887154579163, -0.4253850281238556, -0.017662083730101585, 0.155939519405365, 0.33438557386398315, -0.27414268255233765, -1.0184541940689087, -0.2081301212310791, -0.3514752984046936, 0.09383641928434372, -0.062488000839948654, 1.1036667823791504, -0.6160449385643005, -0.6871339678764343, 0.19389596581459045, 0.4484540522098541, 0.18730522692203522, 0.1394893378019333, -0.4772537052631378, 0.043123919516801834, -0.0316341333091259, 0.1212739497423172, 0.24106191098690033, 0.2693652808666229, -0.10682213306427002, 0.8022667169570923, 0.3772313594818115, -0.07302713394165039, 0.11085408926010132, 0.0926688089966774, 0.8580995202064514, -0.4451327919960022, -0.4295836091041565, -0.8953790664672852, 0.8366809487342834, -0.43709462881088257, -0.30306026339530945, 0.6290874481201172, 0.30438268184661865, 0.971284806728363, -0.38270410895347595, 0.8218749165534973, 0.1865164339542389, -0.18488509953022003, -0.765953540802002, 0.5729421377182007, -0.6065351963043213, 0.16057045757770538, -0.24022462964057922, -0.8264899849891663, -0.24692150950431824, 0.45844218134880066, -0.46812352538108826, -0.07693564146757126, 0.33261582255363464, 0.48890793323516846, -0.0158732607960701, -0.01282880362123251, 0.5779101848602295, 0.043075717985630035, 0.10588502138853073, 0.6878302097320557, 0.781207263469696, -0.1635829508304596, 0.5754320025444031, -0.38487571477890015, -0.13181689381599426, -0.477971613407135, -0.5900816321372986, -1.0522884130477905, -0.6376959681510925, -0.4411770701408386, 0.2290426641702652, 0.24458029866218567, 0.8555421233177185, 0.8274438381195068, -0.5958239436149597, -0.015268411487340927, 0.01246675755828619, -0.04406500980257988, -0.23806548118591309, -0.09513533860445023, 0.20313912630081177, -0.0017270678654313087, -0.6819645762443542, 0.4046933948993683, 0.5165889859199524, 0.21822164952754974, -0.5504330992698669, -0.31770551204681396, 0.15295198559761047, -0.16849255561828613, 0.6204646825790405, 0.12799294292926788, -0.8938581347465515, -0.3197827935218811, -0.10275515168905258, 0.006914238445460796, -0.059699613600969315, 0.4316794276237488, -0.9690648913383484, 0.7568195462226868, 0.8722006678581238, 0.4504315257072449, 0.18680956959724426, 0.05374133959412575, 0.7902782559394836, -0.5547422170639038, 0.29801395535469055, 0.18939416110515594, 0.7220532298088074, 0.29648682475090027, -0.34069278836250305, 0.6793692111968994, 0.44108015298843384, -0.2529926896095276, -0.7050535678863525, -0.011726194992661476, -1.154204249382019, -0.17887920141220093, 0.9965468645095825, -0.09771502763032913, -0.4637792110443115, 0.039100438356399536, -0.24585571885108948, -0.08972477912902832, -0.5041078925132751, 0.6226720809936523, 0.49107223749160767, -0.012558896094560623, -0.6334847211837769, -0.245980903506279, 0.1239711195230484, 0.34896746277809143, -0.6907023787498474, -0.6173663139343262, 0.13706208765506744, -0.11095859110355377, 0.5511038303375244, 0.3781666159629822, 0.11876798421144485, 0.34431836009025574, 0.21438194811344147, 0.3422507047653198, -0.3428916037082672, -0.48881232738494873, -0.3071692883968353, 0.15772618353366852, -0.2299443483352661, -0.30326852202415466 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17206v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17206v1	Gazetteer-Enhanced Bangla Named Entity Recognition with BanglaBERT Semantic Embeddings K-Means-Infused CRF Model	2024-01-30T17:47:07	2024-01-30T17:47:07	Niloy Farhan, Saman Sarker Joy, Tafseer Binte Mannan, Farig Sadeque	cs.CL	cs.CL	Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a sub-task of Natural Language Processing (NLP) that distinguishes entities from unorganized text into predefined categorization. In recent years, a lot of Bangla NLP subtasks have received quite a lot of attention; but Named Entity Recognition in Bangla still lags behind. In this research, we explored the existing state of research in Bangla Named Entity Recognition. We tried to figure out the limitations that current techniques and datasets face, and we would like to address these limitations in our research. Additionally, We developed a Gazetteer that has the ability to significantly boost the performance of NER. We also proposed a new NER solution by taking advantage of state-of-the-art NLP tools that outperform conventional techniques.	[ -0.6512596607208252, -0.8860041499137878, 0.14262957870960236, 0.2534744441509247, -0.5182568430900574, 0.1501508206129074, -0.3417532444000244, -0.9290932416915894, 0.608452558517456, 0.5459368228912354, -0.20710493624210358, -0.21590544283390045, -0.9447587132453918, 0.4973123371601105, -0.4682593047618866, 1.0319653749465942, 0.08721614629030228, -0.06327616423368454, -0.16616952419281006, 0.2158975899219513, -0.7454085946083069, -0.2290145307779312, -0.6152604818344116, -0.34682366251945496, 0.46636533737182617, 0.17082419991493225, 0.44671735167503357, 0.2835090458393097, 0.8002530336380005, 0.26080647110939026, -0.15610972046852112, 0.3316759169101715, -0.31349191069602966, 0.25535088777542114, -0.31345894932746887, 0.06849480420351028, -0.10226602852344513, -0.5363927483558655, 0.8067781925201416, 0.4669514298439026, 0.06338823586702347, 0.06877382099628448, -0.0748705118894577, 0.6381202340126038, -0.9264963865280151, 0.21996662020683289, -0.6180559992790222, -0.04819980636239052, -0.41492360830307007, -0.368842750787735, -0.41602885723114014, -0.6615085601806641, 0.24368421733379364, -0.5076556205749512, 0.11397445946931839, 0.03853842243552208, 1.149256706237793, 0.2632329761981964, -0.577835738658905, -0.6014333367347717, -0.8392611145973206, 0.694186806678772, -0.6270512938499451, 0.8046076893806458, 0.3809410333633423, 0.44471678137779236, -0.4474191665649414, -0.502625584602356, -0.540461003780365, 0.19587008655071259, -0.1261267215013504, -0.012507333420217037, -0.056196779012680054, -0.27242228388786316, -0.028524771332740784, 0.23481586575508118, -0.41517555713653564, -0.05353325605392456, -0.3696395754814148, -0.3415977358818054, 0.637214720249176, 0.06768491864204407, 0.26618486642837524, -0.4585687518119812, -0.5240521430969238, 0.22063207626342773, -0.5966624617576599, -0.02281525358557701, 0.15428607165813446, 0.38114628195762634, 0.21735212206840515, 0.596325159072876, -0.4902002215385437, 0.789786159992218, 0.18130315840244293, -0.38842809200286865, 0.24785174429416656, -0.11576323211193085, -0.26733681559562683, 0.4913201332092285, 0.5083868503570557, 0.3291531205177307, 0.14540617167949677, -0.43539100885391235, -0.22519803047180176, -0.04716010019183159, 0.26256057620048523, -1.0207388401031494, -0.45500633120536804, -0.05265156179666519, -0.3174864649772644, -0.06418608129024506, 0.1631186455488205, -0.9816957116127014, -0.6860451698303223, -0.1767018884420395, 0.3368244767189026, -0.46854621171951294, -0.33260735869407654, -0.12241894006729126, -0.164479061961174, 0.6462073922157288, 0.6323897242546082, -0.9334218502044678, 0.45257070660591125, 0.48976001143455505, 0.5270406603813171, -0.09394372999668121, 0.23512157797813416, -0.15537410974502563, 0.07913900166749954, -0.28572848439216614, 1.4331271648406982, -0.8409551978111267, -0.4620894491672516, -0.11968797445297241, 0.0075756278820335865, -0.1142161414027214, -0.620945155620575, 0.533362865447998, -1.084863305091858, -0.2256103754043579, -0.39621493220329285, -0.7857794165611267, -0.5415279269218445, 0.4400584399700165, -0.6355323195457458, 1.1384875774383545, 0.09883645921945572, -1.0827676057815552, 0.7252560257911682, -0.2849208116531372, -0.2463218867778778, 0.5285881757736206, -0.24116523563861847, -0.3861546516418457, 0.1335601955652237, 0.5475001931190491, 0.47698453068733215, -0.323874294757843, 0.23893943428993225, 0.20412953197956085, -0.3191227614879608, 0.3872810900211334, -0.08511242270469666, 0.5014324188232422, 0.07387728244066238, 0.011811355128884315, -0.16000954806804657, -0.9272844195365906, 0.11463703960180283, 0.12306254357099533, -0.5174757242202759, -0.6295244693756104, -0.006607882212847471, 0.5546038150787354, 0.09338398277759552, 0.4061599671840668, -0.7188295125961304, 0.32690176367759705, -0.5076200366020203, 0.005374714732170105, 0.32102298736572266, 0.33951783180236816, 0.48350948095321655, -0.023979615420103073, 0.2774926722049713, -0.045481134206056595, -0.27672716975212097, 0.023207612335681915, -0.6774640083312988, -0.7156214118003845, -0.3457922041416168, 1.006666898727417, 0.5820227861404419, -0.5631806254386902, 0.38759714365005493, -0.3479313254356384, -0.5899588465690613, -0.44610607624053955, -0.07475705444812775, 0.2570512294769287, 0.3848206698894501, 0.48398303985595703, -0.4085615575313568, -0.9035248756408691, -0.9511351585388184, -0.20611552894115448, 0.17447848618030548, 0.25619617104530334, 0.35819241404533386, 0.45712393522262573, -0.5559829473495483, 1.291132926940918, -0.4473470449447632, -0.3804391026496887, -0.38128936290740967, 0.07234864681959152, 0.03419623151421547, 0.2795850932598114, 0.3330394923686981, -1.3348344564437866, -0.4695291519165039, -0.013672292232513428, -0.5421291589736938, -0.22985976934432983, 0.015734737738966942, 0.06426814943552017, 0.11378810554742813, 0.35922741889953613, -0.36949679255485535, 0.7603431940078735, 0.168988898396492, -0.3852544128894806, 0.5327547788619995, -0.023330003023147583, 0.20504140853881836, -0.9956353306770325, -0.4049638509750366, -0.04139936342835426, -0.44592636823654175, -0.5100312232971191, 0.10148449242115021, 0.2838352918624878, 0.018877888098359108, -0.34506285190582275, 0.760707676410675, -0.7333148121833801, 0.014357405714690685, -0.7438924908638, 0.20318378508090973, -0.27612873911857605, 0.09996023029088974, 0.3276872932910919, 0.4701663553714752, 0.6053701639175415, -0.8465439081192017, 0.2648911774158478, 0.44546759128570557, -0.2376704066991806, 0.5576239228248596, -0.5114051103591919, 0.1638566106557846, -0.07331861555576324, 0.16350461542606354, -0.6641583442687988, -0.5130214691162109, 0.44220975041389465, -0.4450579881668091, 0.615283727645874, -0.18754148483276367, -0.5945035219192505, -0.20079423487186432, 0.11771230399608612, 0.5386880040168762, 0.4477337896823883, -0.5509496331214905, 0.733782947063446, 0.7186897993087769, -0.1629391759634018, -0.44111600518226624, -0.6971908211708069, 0.3785887360572815, -0.07219284027814865, -0.15546688437461853, 0.5059178471565247, 0.3128688633441925, -0.012068505398929119, 0.2127741277217865, -0.08789326250553131, -0.46307075023651123, -0.18353721499443054, 0.39732882380485535, 0.15047574043273926, 0.04587837681174278, 0.05299317464232445, 0.19150587916374207, -0.31370148062705994, -0.19442805647850037, 0.009593411348760128, 0.5459111332893372, -0.07982008904218674, -0.11700686812400818, -0.4390620291233063, 0.2640475332736969, -0.1381564736366272, -0.4133833348751068, 1.0230073928833008, 0.6604354977607727, -0.8419965505599976, -0.001391156460158527, -0.8038597702980042, 0.16462570428848267, -0.4053860902786255, 0.16473588347434998, -0.22739562392234802, -0.9262964725494385, 0.42743560671806335, -0.3818124234676361, -0.3198715150356293, 0.45255741477012634, 0.6588600277900696, 0.48966991901397705, 0.32492324709892273, 0.8753036856651306, 0.11264534294605255, 0.2879106104373932, 0.12373176217079163, 0.7526554465293884, -1.046327829360962, -0.6702966690063477, -0.45506590604782104, -0.2901655435562134, -0.8519240021705627, -0.4346957206726074, -0.022699683904647827, 0.1448429971933365, 0.252719521522522, 0.7792527675628662, -0.8367011547088623, 0.5278173089027405, 0.3132907450199127, 0.03511389344930649, 0.2698083817958832, -0.5086643099784851, 0.09504727274179459, -0.16842997074127197, -0.2612093687057495, -0.6278585195541382, 0.7231727242469788, 0.010107029229402542, 0.7598376870155334, -0.001378653571009636, 1.111506462097168, 0.41317522525787354, 0.08300383388996124, -0.7685394883155823, 0.7470738291740417, 0.2820132076740265, -0.665221095085144, -0.06947427242994308, -0.24587805569171906, -1.0672506093978882, 0.09563139826059341, -0.5183796286582947, -1.028419017791748, 0.7103127241134644, -0.20107731223106384, -0.13648854196071625, 0.23708242177963257, -0.47499337792396545, 0.4670756757259369, 0.18471570312976837, 0.10767136514186859, 0.10523279756307602, -0.4957314431667328, 0.20119988918304443, -0.2764829993247986, 0.1944102942943573, -0.09099239110946655, -0.09850624948740005, 0.8465183973312378, -0.04746691882610321, 0.3515406548976898, -0.2030600905418396, 0.07210033386945724, 0.3949948847293854, -0.1013307049870491, 0.4851629137992859, 0.2402847558259964, 0.045187417417764664, 0.28316161036491394, -0.07777854800224304, -0.2739601731300354, -0.4735826551914215, 0.7877774834632874, -0.40865013003349304, -0.11585976183414459, -0.6605247259140015, -0.5794010758399963, 0.1423088014125824, 0.573524534702301, 0.19902347028255463, 0.5400347113609314, -0.19831393659114838, 0.25007718801498413, 0.5220230221748352, -0.20580698549747467, 0.5012272596359253, 0.42659062147140503, -0.5191049575805664, -0.44653794169425964, 0.9056164026260376, 0.36987265944480896, -0.4160770773887634, 0.739855945110321, -0.12805330753326416, -0.3022104501724243, -0.8646420240402222, -0.4608810544013977, -0.06874796748161316, -0.6507176160812378, -0.6078091263771057, -0.9883492588996887, -0.4676688313484192, -0.5804771184921265, -0.2892226576805115, -0.3898605406284332, -0.515082597732544, -0.22797051072120667, 0.17386339604854584, 0.44252610206604004, 1.008966326713562, 0.2859070897102356, 0.13414432108402252, -0.8294684886932373, 0.4801778495311737, 0.07764295488595963, 0.1655767410993576, -0.09501170367002487, -0.516866147518158, -0.47793546319007874, -0.25841277837753296, -0.20037692785263062, -1.2516385316848755, 0.6321414113044739, 0.2004057914018631, 0.41280725598335266, 0.502869725227356, 0.24239036440849304, 0.7459083795547485, -0.7343517541885376, 0.5743220448493958, -0.2286623865365982, -0.6547279357910156, 0.5952032208442688, -0.24666516482830048, 0.11383914202451706, 0.5736575126647949, 0.37077847123146057, -0.16249173879623413, -0.18229323625564575, -0.5329985022544861, -1.0329999923706055, 0.2020440697669983, 0.35830414295196533, 0.008361594751477242, -0.40804123878479004, 0.4072289764881134, 0.13107211887836456, 0.2066660225391388, -0.7681683897972107, -0.1312355101108551, 0.02152463234961033, 0.18016207218170166, 0.4369684159755707, -0.4593857228755951, 0.5759495496749878, -0.16700614988803864, 0.9077496528625488, 0.3438868522644043, 0.5659782290458679, 0.4897924065589905, -0.3862728774547577, 0.055470842868089676, 0.6727042198181152, 0.1456766426563263, 0.5288835763931274, -0.30321747064590454, 0.039376307278871536, 0.4269278645515442, -0.5799840092658997, -0.015997588634490967, 0.3563110828399658, -0.3519357144832611, 0.13063012063503265, 0.1694604903459549, 0.44712355732917786, 0.5138576626777649, -0.5582248568534851, 0.3885173201560974, -0.015588952228426933, 0.228690043091774, -0.525990903377533, 0.049098096787929535, 0.033739905804395676, 0.49301162362098694, 0.5380101203918457, 0.20924922823905945, 0.546258807182312, -0.25075778365135193, 0.14514446258544922, 0.4612589180469513, -0.47238993644714355, -0.010153607465326786, 0.3998859226703644, -0.16056250035762787, -0.5868091583251953, 0.5895155072212219, -0.8532551527023315, -0.6324526071548462, 0.4105028212070465, 0.9087201952934265, 0.8353472352027893, -0.20762544870376587, -0.04604361206293106, 0.5195406675338745, 0.26569995284080505, 0.05344373360276222, 0.13266952335834503, -0.11764861643314362, -0.774947464466095, -0.28202736377716064, -0.9123457074165344, -0.4301443099975586, -0.2085193544626236, -0.8211567997932434, 0.5457763075828552, -0.4110914170742035, -0.3024420440196991, 0.03780263289809227, 0.19454418122768402, -0.6993336081504822, 0.451658695936203, 0.27709144353866577, 0.8123525977134705, -0.6172714829444885, 0.6281720399856567, 1.0242273807525635, -0.17823673784732819, -0.7573890089988708, -0.05634292587637901, -0.10100382566452026, -0.22364549338817596, 0.7501713633537292, 0.466277539730072, -0.03728603944182396, 0.0849166214466095, -0.1192857101559639, -1.0178996324539185, 1.008642315864563, -0.11510593444108963, -0.6352530717849731, 0.015809588134288788, -0.22242698073387146, 0.44655856490135193, -0.3193167448043823, 0.4308346211910248, 0.3693481981754303, 0.622069239616394, -0.03712721914052963, -0.9014930725097656, 0.09410929679870605, -0.4561346173286438, 0.0946224182844162, 0.7187290787696838, -0.4772627353668213, 0.5602157711982727, -0.09342630207538605, -0.3192068934440613, -0.019969331100583076, 1.0553377866744995, 0.1244073212146759, 0.6037526726722717, 0.32752978801727295, 0.8968997001647949, 0.7434002757072449, -0.1346418410539627, 0.9213177561759949, 0.05156732723116875, 0.4936903715133667, 1.024790644645691, -0.32726460695266724, 0.9313594102859497, 0.3410680890083313, -0.2554419934749603, 0.8196708559989929, 0.6632282137870789, -0.2828444540500641, 0.7936512231826782, 0.10368438810110092, -0.3232063949108124, -0.09365066140890121, -0.5212960243225098, -0.4870672821998596, 0.6949543356895447, 0.4088580012321472, -0.12810063362121582, -0.48332956433296204, 0.18616066873073578, -0.1193700060248375, 0.09142793715000153, -0.4307303726673126, 0.9463825821876526, -0.05396140739321709, -0.15911240875720978, 0.13367414474487305, 0.12748588621616364, 0.7666465044021606, -0.4457172155380249, -0.23959051072597504, 0.4778726398944855, 0.005149891600012779, -0.35914936661720276, -0.42289838194847107, 0.5572041273117065, -0.015539414249360561, -0.2828134000301361, 0.13503879308700562, 1.4309041500091553, -0.2944107949733734, -0.7460466623306274, 0.45000123977661133, 0.3875391185283661, 0.370187371969223, -0.0608251616358757, -0.4344165623188019, -0.05654262751340866, -0.43087467551231384, -0.1895228922367096, 0.3964834213256836, 0.5261111855506897, 0.031764917075634, 0.4979369044303894, 0.46201398968696594, 0.24950037896633148, 0.2555272579193115, -0.014623571187257767, 0.9936050176620483, -0.8105510473251343, -0.5974143147468567, -0.8418303728103638, 0.14394420385360718, -0.030553514137864113, -0.20557749271392822, 1.0475527048110962, 0.7765408754348755, 0.8659728169441223, -0.10450106114149094, 0.5440219044685364, -0.4269155263900757, 0.6867977976799011, -0.41173428297042847, 0.623583197593689, -0.30859461426734924, 0.07725311070680618, -0.616301417350769, -1.267397165298462, -0.41845592856407166, 0.7537949085235596, -0.48724403977394104, 0.01301194541156292, 0.5746910572052002, 0.7161359190940857, -0.015278936363756657, 0.1973484754562378, 0.14235810935497284, -0.13754338026046753, 0.05223594978451729, 0.4494975209236145, 0.8482556343078613, -0.7250124216079712, 0.19587713479995728, -0.3471287786960602, 0.08896240592002869, -0.37547773122787476, -1.024749994277954, -1.081255316734314, -0.6310802102088928, -0.41171711683273315, -0.056392326951026917, 0.20696456730365753, 1.2123457193374634, 0.5846638679504395, -1.1161607503890991, 0.37956684827804565, -0.10106681287288666, 0.0926155224442482, -0.021176528185606003, -0.2966761589050293, 0.5267965197563171, -0.08688332885503769, -0.7283457517623901, 0.4395727217197418, 0.37605607509613037, -0.15620845556259155, 0.16017597913742065, 0.19580166041851044, -0.5409364104270935, 0.21582598984241486, 0.3315640687942505, 0.204774409532547, -0.5904711484909058, -0.122008316218853, -0.20583347976207733, 0.0743185356259346, 0.07514964044094086, 0.740164041519165, -1.0053846836090088, 0.47476571798324585, 0.5564382076263428, 1.15591299533844, 0.2068527489900589, 0.06875878572463989, -0.09770586341619492, -0.5581890940666199, -0.007473412435501814, 0.2818385660648346, 0.45304054021835327, 0.6238036751747131, -0.6530717611312866, 0.32240384817123413, 0.17054790258407593, -0.9603636264801025, -0.701116681098938, 0.023527326062321663, -1.203155755996704, 0.1527043879032135, 0.9826802015304565, 0.1217666044831276, -0.21509325504302979, -0.5473455786705017, -0.36065512895584106, 0.44648727774620056, -0.6138285994529724, 0.6835569143295288, 0.6449373960494995, -0.25591161847114563, -0.23685462772846222, -0.5586254596710205, 0.09539234638214111, -0.08822562545537949, -0.6809560656547546, -0.43551722168922424, 0.3210914731025696, 0.17785382270812988, 0.3898511528968811, 0.7221936583518982, -0.23088936507701874, 0.23160196840763092, -0.0010327842319384217, 0.026684096083045006, -0.19398054480552673, -0.5622313022613525, -0.07807618379592896, 0.026188980787992477, -0.07077354192733765, 0.008988822810351849 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01761v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01761v1	Rethinking Interpretability in the Era of Large Language Models	2024-01-30T17:38:54	2024-01-30T17:38:54	Chandan Singh, Jeevana Priya Inala, Michel Galley, Rich Caruana, Jianfeng Gao	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG	Interpretable machine learning has exploded as an area of interest over the last decade, sparked by the rise of increasingly large datasets and deep neural networks. Simultaneously, large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across a wide array of tasks, offering a chance to rethink opportunities in interpretable machine learning. Notably, the capability to explain in natural language allows LLMs to expand the scale and complexity of patterns that can be given to a human. However, these new capabilities raise new challenges, such as hallucinated explanations and immense computational costs. In this position paper, we start by reviewing existing methods to evaluate the emerging field of LLM interpretation (both interpreting LLMs and using LLMs for explanation). We contend that, despite their limitations, LLMs hold the opportunity to redefine interpretability with a more ambitious scope across many applications, including in auditing LLMs themselves. We highlight two emerging research priorities for LLM interpretation: using LLMs to directly analyze new datasets and to generate interactive explanations.	[ 0.008695580996572971, -0.5914173722267151, 0.9061858654022217, 0.19146117568016052, -0.3720141649246216, 0.0329192616045475, -0.5641470551490784, -0.7902944087982178, -0.05488964915275574, 0.7363477945327759, -0.5512323379516602, -0.182139590382576, -0.979759931564331, 0.08600274473428726, -0.5639093518257141, 0.9332915544509888, -0.23683913052082062, 0.022673143073916435, -0.38265088200569153, -0.16968338191509247, -0.5965489149093628, -0.46933886408805847, -0.6691985130310059, -0.5959250330924988, 0.6090945601463318, 0.20753861963748932, 0.8844848871231079, 0.823429524898529, 0.382846474647522, 0.31908050179481506, -0.15632325410842896, 0.205099418759346, -0.46600866317749023, 0.20812632143497467, 0.12374521791934967, -0.6202836632728577, -0.5006054639816284, -0.023494165390729904, 0.8068936467170715, 1.1522037982940674, 0.02389378473162651, -0.04220718517899513, 0.3043559491634369, 0.6152349710464478, -0.35914066433906555, 0.5361997485160828, -0.7626358866691589, -0.03943901136517525, -0.011020426638424397, -0.23624156415462494, -0.5607456564903259, 0.05292237922549248, 0.44350242614746094, -0.4897986948490143, 0.00556220905855298, -0.02504791133105755, 0.5263933539390564, 0.3674485981464386, -0.4182673692703247, -0.5663591623306274, -0.8339514136314392, 0.9143998026847839, -0.6030097603797913, 0.6465604901313782, 0.23174013197422028, 0.4797748029232025, -0.24427670240402222, -0.9725697040557861, -0.4275660514831543, -0.24932663142681122, -0.12233524769544601, -0.18035945296287537, -0.35927313566207886, -0.23496882617473602, 0.17967994511127472, 0.4130582809448242, -0.3506624400615692, 0.600910484790802, -0.02694808691740036, -0.0074916682206094265, 0.7202269434928894, 0.3717387318611145, 0.19783902168273926, -0.005698148626834154, -0.10788777470588684, 0.27511224150657654, -0.7550088167190552, -0.06267275661230087, 0.17882929742336273, 0.4266577959060669, -0.01862284727394581, 0.4000225067138672, -0.12318820506334305, 0.7458088397979736, -0.2651642858982086, 0.22680269181728363, 0.033869460225105286, -0.08948295563459396, -0.4479563534259796, -0.01320409681648016, 0.34187957644462585, 0.19912894070148468, 0.2806982398033142, -0.31007635593414307, -0.19101306796073914, -0.2757585048675537, 0.4643193185329437, -0.7912687063217163, -0.07003515213727951, 0.5077546834945679, -0.8195121884346008, -0.391938716173172, 0.02831704169511795, -0.8660379648208618, -0.8541774749755859, -0.7241555452346802, 0.2507476210594177, -0.08029273897409439, -0.34136879444122314, 0.3958175778388977, 0.08339612185955048, 0.2779594361782074, 0.5895718336105347, -0.900928795337677, 0.04446185752749443, 1.0462672710418701, 0.7058179378509521, -0.1627323031425476, -0.36743223667144775, -0.4348766505718231, -0.049517132341861725, -0.30877360701560974, 0.49428248405456543, -0.6085942983627319, -0.27684900164604187, 0.16506482660770416, 0.1922430545091629, 0.060957059264183044, -0.5827536582946777, 0.3862181305885315, -0.560023307800293, 0.1322215497493744, -0.030202917754650116, -0.5357599258422852, -0.46781954169273376, 0.07682918757200241, -0.6730895042419434, 0.4135882556438446, -0.05462944507598877, -0.4465921223163605, 0.4743303656578064, -0.7076559066772461, -0.45798006653785706, 0.14950479567050934, -0.046621810644865036, -0.43623122572898865, 0.3233039975166321, 0.2417094111442566, 0.6267512440681458, -0.2925889194011688, 0.5975199341773987, -0.43692854046821594, -0.36790308356285095, 0.6205981373786926, -0.8335009217262268, 0.7909079790115356, 0.40250542759895325, -0.36959928274154663, 0.15385626256465912, -0.7922748327255249, 0.08110355585813522, 0.10602059215307236, -0.27129021286964417, 0.017723647877573967, 0.37308627367019653, -0.15917372703552246, -0.13471198081970215, 0.3184279501438141, 0.05535990372300148, -0.10080806910991669, -0.4721108376979828, 0.8315427899360657, 0.945766270160675, -0.3829856216907501, 0.2902730107307434, -0.045111339539289474, 0.7192427515983582, -0.2966257333755493, 0.03838425502181053, -0.3005349338054657, -0.3947294354438782, -0.5677847862243652, -0.4489290118217468, 0.15791112184524536, 0.2586348056793213, -0.48384344577789307, 0.25519251823425293, -0.4240638017654419, -0.42891767621040344, -0.6355860233306885, 0.13472190499305725, 0.05628618970513344, 0.19336766004562378, 0.2887035012245178, -0.047998346388339996, -0.685548722743988, -0.9229966402053833, -0.7646863460540771, -0.2420436143875122, -0.18749503791332245, 0.3929519057273865, 0.4426845610141754, -0.4831233620643616, 0.6669409871101379, -0.2029086947441101, 0.18394385278224945, -0.48747867345809937, 0.07202650606632233, 0.4073658883571625, 0.24111488461494446, 0.11262906342744827, -0.8050898313522339, -0.009796160273253918, 0.12557834386825562, -0.9424454569816589, -0.12653318047523499, -0.3635658323764801, 0.27169230580329895, 0.11854260414838791, 0.5961889624595642, -0.48993980884552, 0.39839524030685425, 0.5057371258735657, -0.2585999667644501, 0.5702969431877136, -0.21282102167606354, -0.16779926419258118, -0.5996305346488953, 0.05370590090751648, -0.2806740403175354, -0.23088404536247253, -0.7475930452346802, 0.1985926628112793, -0.004056356847286224, -0.07906170934438705, -0.41949957609176636, 0.6139980554580688, -0.6115130186080933, -0.36055517196655273, -0.4690946340560913, 0.12595266103744507, 0.0804852694272995, -0.061403337866067886, -0.11856234818696976, 0.3592812716960907, 0.6140445470809937, -0.48684167861938477, 0.4116494357585907, 0.14761464297771454, -0.6544975638389587, 0.2894560396671295, -0.5738969445228577, -0.008518960326910019, -0.31174197793006897, 0.6013854742050171, -0.807316780090332, -0.3985753059387207, 0.15900227427482605, -0.41540658473968506, 0.3958013951778412, -0.11567474901676178, -0.32665231823921204, -0.17439009249210358, -0.1732850968837738, 0.3823099136352539, 0.37629109621047974, -0.9127231240272522, 0.8368098735809326, 0.00008327298564836383, 0.0653640553355217, -0.6206962466239929, -0.6832945346832275, 0.43579259514808655, -0.6277908086776733, -0.5537450909614563, -0.020701592788100243, 0.14764775335788727, -0.6844108700752258, -0.043841272592544556, -0.24105772376060486, -0.035251423716545105, 0.7779894471168518, 0.4113498330116272, 0.3075014352798462, -0.26716479659080505, 0.210170179605484, -0.3033715784549713, -0.24171662330627441, 0.3142273724079132, -0.35521775484085083, 0.3098481595516205, -0.19129465520381927, -0.3623087704181671, -0.5035566091537476, 0.16575267910957336, 0.614454984664917, -0.10789180546998978, 0.9217036366462708, 0.5235498547554016, -0.4408152997493744, -0.17746855318546295, -0.22513006627559662, -0.05868755280971527, -0.43278101086616516, 0.485978901386261, -0.4759722948074341, -1.0407365560531616, 0.4560648202896118, -0.1960260570049286, 0.2078855037689209, 0.5428803563117981, 0.7147790789604187, -0.16354702413082123, 1.1505703926086426, 0.6116697192192078, 0.18056532740592957, 0.4017070531845093, 0.04166582599282265, 0.5225877165794373, -0.7083573937416077, -0.36595556139945984, -0.49099376797676086, -0.20105350017547607, -0.6962860226631165, -0.3824637830257416, 0.020664287731051445, 0.03821755200624466, 0.014300346374511719, -0.07904840260744095, -0.1881834715604782, 0.4714311361312866, -0.003477860474959016, -0.12072136998176575, 0.38717925548553467, -0.1597742736339569, 0.4903716742992401, 0.05856766179203987, -0.47117310762405396, -1.0716795921325684, 1.1643410921096802, 0.8092144727706909, 0.705430269241333, 0.010598805733025074, 0.288333922624588, 0.21653734147548676, 0.5666543841362, -0.9663926362991333, 0.321276992559433, -0.22390156984329224, -0.5923600792884827, -0.4683101773262024, -0.375797301530838, -1.2471134662628174, 0.5919609665870667, -0.21645943820476532, -0.9106307029724121, -0.013686228543519974, 0.20504087209701538, -0.020855920389294624, 0.48237890005111694, -0.7448049187660217, 0.9276152849197388, -0.5015398263931274, -0.1557134985923767, -0.21827664971351624, -0.3971021771430969, 0.5411443710327148, -0.3396275043487549, 0.513821542263031, 0.07664284855127335, -0.13758452236652374, 0.5720422267913818, -0.169671431183815, 0.9885656833648682, -0.06280460208654404, -0.5408483743667603, -0.07982348650693893, 0.06399030983448029, 0.6406229734420776, 0.07445192337036133, -0.3846379816532135, 0.44520053267478943, 0.09557058662176132, -0.3964920938014984, -0.831138014793396, 0.5886961817741394, -0.4232960045337677, -0.825471818447113, -0.1943390965461731, -0.6941492557525635, -0.14779752492904663, -0.027070341631770134, -0.07168915867805481, 0.4565331041812897, -0.16058683395385742, 0.22138287127017975, 0.5519527196884155, -0.41164490580558777, 0.08580351620912552, 0.4252671003341675, -0.4464019536972046, -0.04468737170100212, 1.0698610544204712, -0.03171933442354202, 0.25970786809921265, 0.299227237701416, 0.27434995770454407, -0.4074590504169464, -1.049857497215271, -0.3786756098270416, 0.17858818173408508, -0.8660498857498169, 0.46922799944877625, -0.5045875310897827, 0.04178399220108986, -0.17295415699481964, -0.0820692926645279, -0.06515417248010635, -0.3194367587566376, -0.7345771789550781, -0.06544632464647293, 0.037270259112119675, 0.8706457614898682, -0.03765708953142166, 0.20739595592021942, -0.5958162546157837, 0.20800839364528656, 0.30056360363960266, 0.47514763474464417, 0.25196167826652527, -0.719024658203125, -0.2993602156639099, -0.037654194980859756, 0.07056281715631485, -0.6070827841758728, 0.28543099761009216, -0.11820188909769058, 0.5875920057296753, 0.6764662265777588, -0.29560354351997375, 0.6542855501174927, -0.5335368514060974, 0.7103598117828369, -0.036089248955249786, -0.9363594055175781, 0.3724958598613739, -0.07480176538228989, 0.0059377155266702175, 0.13383737206459045, 0.375897079706192, -0.7334397435188293, -0.36782005429267883, -0.5747069716453552, -0.824505090713501, 0.5057504177093506, -0.032259244471788406, 0.19238649308681488, 0.3280263841152191, 0.47266268730163574, 0.6556143760681152, 0.12483954429626465, -0.5895993113517761, 0.05870288610458374, -0.05184819921851158, -0.17600874602794647, -0.5211998224258423, -0.3223573565483093, 0.04743117094039917, -0.04409037157893181, 0.39634785056114197, -0.20135259628295898, 0.18840427696704865, -0.18285556137561798, -0.3198208510875702, -0.0672677680850029, 0.40452322363853455, 0.4164266884326935, 1.2018272876739502, -0.0889652669429779, 0.4752448797225952, 0.251871794462204, -0.08713538944721222, -0.18121542036533356, 0.06523845344781876, 0.05844961106777191, -0.1847390979528427, 1.0386143922805786, 0.9502914547920227, 0.12611281871795654, -0.9600705504417419, 0.08057606220245361, 0.018581517040729523, -0.33033424615859985, -0.3590044379234314, 0.00634040916338563, 0.20529088377952576, 0.3819406032562256, 0.16008014976978302, -0.3868492841720581, 0.02152976207435131, -0.8572198748588562, -0.07062704116106033, 0.5489303469657898, -0.4991348385810852, -0.22059303522109985, 0.6755082011222839, -0.016055043786764145, -0.440232515335083, 0.5652621388435364, 0.21831455826759338, -0.5244588255882263, 0.5524656772613525, 0.2566094696521759, 0.9117794632911682, 0.04600943252444267, -0.08139989525079727, -0.10799972712993622, 0.4605058431625366, 0.003185071051120758, 0.003394261235371232, 0.05478883907198906, -0.696732223033905, -0.6640130877494812, -0.5117238759994507, -0.6897494196891785, 0.49968844652175903, -0.8389426469802856, 0.05828671529889107, -0.14160200953483582, 0.402068167924881, 0.521095871925354, -0.07241160422563553, -0.5060333609580994, 0.13823628425598145, 0.11150792241096497, 0.7543830275535583, -0.8268360495567322, 0.5869958996772766, 0.5135492086410522, -0.005154594779014587, -0.3662853538990021, 0.07323605567216873, 0.07960875332355499, -1.2098486423492432, 0.6505862474441528, 0.371555358171463, 0.06839161366224289, -0.3392012417316437, -0.7232731580734253, -0.48048922419548035, 0.9069993495941162, 0.3526158034801483, -0.5411094427108765, 0.14524433016777039, 0.0867728441953659, 0.662720263004303, -0.42015475034713745, 0.09468346834182739, 1.0637367963790894, 0.7520040273666382, -0.17788755893707275, -0.6515321135520935, 0.12904149293899536, 0.1355259269475937, -0.10066694766283035, 0.10246416181325912, -0.2310238480567932, 0.5128756165504456, -0.2398384064435959, -0.21952779591083527, 0.09796962141990662, 0.7049057483673096, 0.027286386117339134, 0.6278409957885742, 0.615788996219635, 0.26149266958236694, 1.0109859704971313, 0.002727723214775324, 1.19691801071167, 0.20972786843776703, 0.10316626727581024, 1.1994208097457886, -0.39725276827812195, 0.8120588660240173, 0.6024907231330872, -0.270643025636673, 0.34102603793144226, 0.9252753257751465, -0.17211005091667175, 0.1405290812253952, 0.5659728050231934, -0.17516405880451202, -0.6140491366386414, 0.01871422864496708, -0.03519752621650696, 0.5528075695037842, 0.405897319316864, -0.5165002346038818, -0.15117287635803223, 0.03307250887155533, -0.14568714797496796, 0.059575922787189484, -0.1987980455160141, 0.5311954021453857, 0.19152680039405823, -0.43314552307128906, 0.3965337574481964, -0.09672457724809647, 0.39685744047164917, -0.20143485069274902, -0.1426878720521927, 0.0538354367017746, 0.20663268864154816, -0.3396291732788086, -0.9125362634658813, 0.4999884366989136, 0.22027817368507385, -0.12184222787618637, -0.5907453894615173, 0.5910426378250122, -0.12855957448482513, -0.38003072142601013, 0.3279595375061035, 0.7334004044532776, 0.6670103669166565, -0.13154257833957672, -0.6887723207473755, 0.26018422842025757, 0.09794188290834427, -0.2178574800491333, 0.42513278126716614, 0.6678225994110107, -0.008204665035009384, 1.0714616775512695, 0.6113989353179932, 0.03866035118699074, -0.1583729237318039, 0.06465014815330505, 0.6091535687446594, -0.6832050681114197, -0.2724411189556122, -1.1024175882339478, 0.3083115518093109, 0.3542976975440979, 0.0825667679309845, 0.6506836414337158, 0.3748602867126465, 0.5558315515518188, 0.21069806814193726, 0.8220818638801575, 0.0978173017501831, 0.3388260304927826, -0.6957184076309204, 0.5307935476303101, -0.6678373217582703, 0.6517762541770935, 0.035890188068151474, -0.7249599099159241, -0.34912365674972534, 0.4374687671661377, -0.4103037118911743, 0.09894278645515442, 0.5675936937332153, 0.45999711751937866, 0.0300611462444067, 0.442435622215271, 0.3454713821411133, 0.5218068957328796, 0.4916565716266632, 0.30926448106765747, 1.391985297203064, -0.021702781319618225, 0.640640914440155, 0.20978496968746185, -0.11522803455591202, -0.46123653650283813, -1.1063021421432495, -0.8361344337463379, -0.39210182428359985, -0.31220704317092896, -0.3333728313446045, -0.2090223878622055, 0.5873807072639465, 0.3986920118331909, -0.7291381359100342, -0.17119351029396057, -0.06830411404371262, 0.588655948638916, -0.2821929454803467, -0.212654247879982, 0.37265637516975403, -0.27187782526016235, -0.7902346849441528, 0.546753466129303, 0.22935833036899567, -0.013974810019135475, -0.5075927972793579, -0.21379077434539795, 0.3679807186126709, -0.02940426766872406, 0.8943344354629517, 0.20226842164993286, -1.1657928228378296, -0.45350372791290283, -0.23634293675422668, 0.37582671642303467, -0.020939694717526436, 0.8162859678268433, -0.5496655702590942, 0.547353982925415, 0.24095134437084198, 1.0208020210266113, 0.4152451455593109, -0.35827040672302246, 0.7244239449501038, -0.038167376071214676, -0.2793843448162079, 0.16015943884849548, 0.45557311177253723, 0.24619387090206146, -0.2171461433172226, 0.594268262386322, -0.14689308404922485, -0.457440048456192, -1.264664888381958, 0.234916552901268, -0.9129979014396667, -0.5891742706298828, 0.9330832958221436, -0.2790433466434479, -0.11248348653316498, -0.2965795695781708, 0.03052693046629429, 0.1713407188653946, 0.14490824937820435, 0.7245042324066162, 0.8601956963539124, -0.23285621404647827, -0.2437453269958496, -0.9992715716362, 0.20745046436786652, 0.45695650577545166, -0.9078760147094727, 0.6664106845855713, 0.4081759452819824, 0.1937357485294342, -0.17755647003650665, 0.1363561600446701, -0.11834035813808441, 0.12134159356355667, -0.274996280670166, -0.23333196341991425, -0.02405371516942978, -0.25773099064826965, -1.0690641403198242, -0.013047718442976475, 0.3825748562812805, 0.05923285335302353 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17196v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17196v1	Single Word Change is All You Need: Designing Attacks and Defenses for Text Classifiers	2024-01-30T17:30:44	2024-01-30T17:30:44	Lei Xu, Sarah Alnegheimish, Laure Berti-Equille, Alfredo Cuesta-Infante, Kalyan Veeramachaneni	cs.CL	cs.CL	In text classification, creating an adversarial example means subtly perturbing a few words in a sentence without changing its meaning, causing it to be misclassified by a classifier. A concerning observation is that a significant portion of adversarial examples generated by existing methods change only one word. This single-word perturbation vulnerability represents a significant weakness in classifiers, which malicious users can exploit to efficiently create a multitude of adversarial examples. This paper studies this problem and makes the following key contributions: (1) We introduce a novel metric \r{ho} to quantitatively assess a classifier's robustness against single-word perturbation. (2) We present the SP-Attack, designed to exploit the single-word perturbation vulnerability, achieving a higher attack success rate, better preserving sentence meaning, while reducing computation costs compared to state-of-the-art adversarial methods. (3) We propose SP-Defense, which aims to improve \r{ho} by applying data augmentation in learning. Experimental results on 4 datasets and BERT and distilBERT classifiers show that SP-Defense improves \r{ho} by 14.6% and 13.9% and decreases the attack success rate of SP-Attack by 30.4% and 21.2% on two classifiers respectively, and decreases the attack success rate of existing attack methods that involve multiple-word perturbations.	[ -0.4577919840812683, -1.22696852684021, 0.11679051071405411, -0.14245232939720154, -0.2445024996995926, -0.1411222219467163, -0.1222836971282959, -0.2040034979581833, 0.15264831483364105, 0.5065075159072876, -0.3157353401184082, -0.37918663024902344, -0.7887234687805176, 0.006712316069751978, -0.4531002640724182, 1.5623784065246582, 0.16423583030700684, -0.15134307742118835, -0.011314650066196918, -0.28933945298194885, -0.19071416556835175, -0.8856908679008484, -0.5023006200790405, 0.07149045169353485, 0.7404671907424927, 0.29201018810272217, 0.8866767883300781, 0.4550231099128723, 0.9083518981933594, 0.29452580213546753, -0.007624147925525904, -0.2635839879512787, -0.3647298216819763, 0.36339688301086426, 0.018531227484345436, -0.6005184054374695, -0.510595977306366, 0.05141203850507736, 0.7086231708526611, 0.6754332780838013, 0.25474634766578674, 0.060788918286561966, 0.06538323312997818, 0.7831124067306519, -0.8795289993286133, -0.364760160446167, -1.0761128664016724, 0.1999100148677826, -0.5699397325515747, -0.3126237392425537, -0.5699819326400757, -0.10395798832178116, 0.26850205659866333, -0.5205107927322388, 0.40632086992263794, -0.3547215163707733, 0.939854621887207, 0.48359981179237366, -0.3452915549278259, -0.13267022371292114, -0.4105900824069977, 0.5603062510490417, -0.48940879106521606, 0.09616699814796448, 0.09668539464473724, 0.28564125299453735, -0.41340094804763794, -0.7077483534812927, -0.4637511670589447, -0.3130565583705902, 0.07591819763183594, 0.1396990716457367, -0.3431301414966583, 0.2727624773979187, 0.21588119864463806, 0.3256816864013672, -0.24123434722423553, -0.22900688648223877, -0.27970340847969055, -0.20689840614795685, 0.7919896841049194, 0.04376750811934471, 0.3461397588253021, 0.13145709037780762, -0.779779314994812, -0.42984241247177124, -0.702739417552948, 0.039770789444446564, 0.7947178483009338, 0.4512103199958801, 0.3776095509529114, 0.46401333808898926, 0.3346019685268402, 0.47847050428390503, 0.011444668285548687, -0.158216193318367, 0.10310404002666473, -0.21514892578125, -0.2957897186279297, 0.303819477558136, 0.8465070724487305, 0.02358107827603817, 0.06470966339111328, -0.2624296247959137, -0.17439426481723785, 0.6917758584022522, 0.7589937448501587, -0.6806832551956177, -0.48651838302612305, -0.026024525985121727, -0.1709146499633789, -0.8387406468391418, 0.3441029489040375, -1.077104091644287, -0.7315571904182434, 0.32763952016830444, 0.750710129737854, -0.5881513357162476, 0.01617276296019554, 0.4450027048587799, -0.5279674530029297, -0.18455001711845398, 0.08040814101696014, -0.5269378423690796, 0.3280646800994873, 0.5544611215591431, 0.45506253838539124, -0.1220775842666626, -0.6983257532119751, -0.37972426414489746, -0.17610034346580505, -0.35323014855384827, 0.9055293798446655, -0.340093731880188, -0.6265028119087219, -0.22568364441394806, -0.3857170641422272, -0.015435327775776386, -0.09707207977771759, 0.759783148765564, -0.32547086477279663, 0.3829781413078308, 0.04995902255177498, -0.5686990022659302, -0.09123419225215912, 0.4151991307735443, -0.6755932569503784, 0.9082908630371094, -0.18251581490039825, -1.3969634771347046, 0.4976460039615631, -0.7902522683143616, -0.7872158288955688, 0.1693703681230545, 0.03964931517839432, -0.9094732403755188, 0.2724776864051819, -0.10163335502147675, 0.16611027717590332, 0.06747495383024216, -0.28651756048202515, -0.4084594249725342, -0.3318747282028198, 0.4880562722682953, -0.7735157012939453, 0.7179187536239624, 0.0966358408331871, -0.2855529189109802, 0.042345158755779266, -0.7846485376358032, -0.0035947770811617374, 0.32865792512893677, -0.5018724203109741, -0.5909782648086548, 0.2577722370624542, -0.14827057719230652, -0.21281516551971436, 0.2822696566581726, -0.6358869671821594, 0.4441303312778473, -0.6840265989303589, 0.09619943797588348, 0.8511460423469543, 0.23389074206352234, 0.393558144569397, -0.47971034049987793, 0.5660260319709778, -0.09860052168369293, 0.26012951135635376, -0.30732807517051697, -0.46360474824905396, -0.6860995888710022, -0.4198112487792969, 0.38147833943367004, 0.5770698189735413, -0.778591513633728, 0.324502170085907, -0.29162293672561646, -0.6608986258506775, -0.581052303314209, -0.049539487808942795, 0.3142830431461334, 0.12497560679912567, 0.480996310710907, -0.07214480638504028, -0.5587549209594727, -0.555700421333313, -1.039968490600586, -0.3135449290275574, 0.052116233855485916, -0.2040005624294281, 0.4058840274810791, -0.19494658708572388, 0.7819907069206238, -0.5890727043151855, -0.2100159227848053, -0.2097056359052658, 0.019726481288671494, -0.19357407093048096, 0.2103399783372879, 0.7019718289375305, -0.9081283807754517, -0.44980335235595703, -0.15502969920635223, -0.5375728607177734, -0.02863602712750435, -0.38109290599823, 0.04192661494016647, 0.14262273907661438, 0.22791405022144318, -0.2787166237831116, 0.9027191400527954, 0.19886508584022522, -0.7045999765396118, 0.5492895245552063, -0.22180363535881042, 0.06457965075969696, -1.0040366649627686, -0.4156218469142914, 0.18069100379943848, 0.1665850728750229, -1.076377034187317, 0.7588177919387817, -0.03428439050912857, -0.09320946037769318, -0.49562329053878784, 0.38400986790657043, -0.08582083880901337, 0.5131657123565674, -0.284152090549469, 0.08060534298419952, -0.07685419917106628, 0.3096630871295929, -0.5844300389289856, 0.5881432294845581, 0.7241795659065247, -0.9524815678596497, 0.37430286407470703, 0.06753797829151154, -0.03237725421786308, 0.6905745267868042, -0.6196545362472534, 0.27995842695236206, -0.3457348942756653, 0.2695849537849426, -1.0649000406265259, 0.07117785513401031, 0.33645179867744446, -0.7812125086784363, 0.4429262578487396, 0.11287380754947662, -0.4002288281917572, -0.4044933319091797, -0.7314146757125854, -0.004907551221549511, 0.01536492072045803, -0.7289606928825378, 0.5592701435089111, 0.3816404342651367, 0.13299313187599182, -0.6376208066940308, -0.9193711280822754, 0.5136505365371704, -0.6178314089775085, -0.5928797721862793, 0.46861958503723145, -0.267935574054718, -0.25101181864738464, -0.08081549406051636, -0.32281726598739624, 0.04111971706151962, 0.6527334451675415, 0.17048141360282898, 0.4036031663417816, -0.012259301729500294, 0.3513646125793457, -0.2085253745317459, -0.1593196839094162, 0.18959419429302216, -0.3849636912345886, 0.34868550300598145, 0.00453687971457839, -0.41462913155555725, -0.5195698738098145, 0.32708224654197693, 0.718953013420105, -0.0758545994758606, 0.6050503849983215, 0.4859696924686432, -0.3308737874031067, -0.2443666160106659, -0.308308869600296, -0.14817306399345398, -0.5097189545631409, 0.6178922653198242, -0.863315224647522, -0.6843737363815308, 0.026494383811950684, 0.19606271386146545, 0.34742602705955505, 0.5172752141952515, 0.14807529747486115, 0.1347241997718811, 1.0466763973236084, 0.4903242588043213, -0.27908405661582947, 0.5367891192436218, 0.04048781841993332, 0.38410264253616333, -0.37142008543014526, 0.06529591977596283, -0.7327748537063599, -0.24145479500293732, -0.8536726236343384, 0.08996887505054474, 0.5015160441398621, -0.02659265324473381, -0.4065310060977936, 0.6316685676574707, -0.8853758573532104, 0.3070332407951355, 0.2825157046318054, 0.36704689264297485, -0.21062298119068146, 0.24620409309864044, 0.054544996470212936, -0.16465584933757782, -0.7630516886711121, -0.5517138242721558, 1.2392950057983398, 0.4740106463432312, 0.9598393440246582, 0.3733569085597992, 0.7494224309921265, 0.4459981918334961, 0.223509281873703, -0.8402458429336548, 0.7523419857025146, -0.5339579582214355, -0.4329937994480133, -0.29864516854286194, -0.4981539845466614, -1.007952332496643, 0.4829127788543701, -0.4452613294124603, -0.5882107019424438, -0.12335320562124252, 0.18194812536239624, -0.10910797119140625, 0.7087880373001099, -0.7090018391609192, 0.802727222442627, -0.4244799017906189, -0.2465871274471283, -0.02114759013056755, -0.2843082547187805, -0.024589385837316513, -0.19215117394924164, 0.10086043924093246, 0.34458374977111816, -0.13245388865470886, 0.5932909846305847, -0.25810831785202026, 0.8072263598442078, -0.29980528354644775, -0.09535828977823257, 0.15082187950611115, 0.14324437081813812, 0.53366619348526, -0.13907234370708466, -0.17456264793872833, -0.17895948886871338, -0.03151785582304001, -0.6066511273384094, -0.579640805721283, 0.36800771951675415, -0.49507206678390503, -0.8540856242179871, -0.5785285830497742, -0.20726723968982697, -0.14321991801261902, 0.015754971653223038, 0.5804187655448914, 0.317035049200058, -0.4757457673549652, 0.3516291081905365, 0.9448775053024292, -0.3242127299308777, 0.38224393129348755, 0.3354252874851227, 0.17817728221416473, -0.47881442308425903, 0.9982396960258484, 0.04993511363863945, 0.39419370889663696, 0.5465454459190369, 0.5677019357681274, -0.1045374870300293, -0.3769518733024597, -0.3107023239135742, -0.3768109083175659, -0.5939522981643677, -0.3486155867576599, -0.7179971933364868, -0.13639692962169647, -0.6633472442626953, -0.24150335788726807, -0.10871920734643936, -0.3779281973838806, -0.11607027053833008, -0.05682928115129471, 0.4737009108066559, 0.6177476644515991, 0.21162095665931702, 0.2691217362880707, -0.553712785243988, 0.1425919234752655, 0.46467065811157227, 0.07397472858428955, -0.25046128034591675, -0.6625304222106934, 0.025554349645972252, 0.06608583778142929, -0.3653731942176819, -1.1809840202331543, 0.18768808245658875, 0.2962718605995178, 0.6149715185165405, 0.46123990416526794, 0.2856428623199463, 0.49554118514060974, -0.46185392141342163, 1.012933373451233, 0.3567690849304199, -0.941453754901886, 0.6742929220199585, 0.09095833450555801, 0.3309635818004608, 0.6543571949005127, 0.14205703139305115, -0.40233540534973145, -0.5174673795700073, -0.8116990923881531, -0.7238026857376099, 0.38216501474380493, 0.1170114055275917, 0.326322078704834, 0.0037053911946713924, 0.3574843406677246, 0.035110365599393845, 0.07003972679376602, -0.6243274807929993, -0.6165791749954224, -0.5264493227005005, -0.11291104555130005, 0.11750563234090805, -0.1965634822845459, -0.10760180652141571, -0.15019044280052185, 0.8759998083114624, -0.06988483667373657, 0.18439710140228271, 0.16804461181163788, 0.07449980825185776, 0.35966378450393677, 0.56146240234375, 0.373999685049057, -0.08360208570957184, 0.10037223994731903, 0.47252005338668823, 0.5482524633407593, -0.8763247728347778, 0.18511930108070374, 0.21664853394031525, -0.24557848274707794, 0.04066087305545807, 0.3569851517677307, 0.726141631603241, 0.16471630334854126, -0.29494595527648926, 0.688184916973114, -0.2278747856616974, -0.22490234673023224, -0.05801049992442131, 0.17154675722122192, -0.6791868805885315, -0.2747665345668793, 0.3678087592124939, 0.3219367563724518, -0.0007472641882486641, -0.6104094386100769, 0.3131635785102844, 0.5642911195755005, -0.43851080536842346, -0.27592986822128296, 0.6060524582862854, -0.1646801233291626, -0.5579717755317688, -0.209743469953537, -0.3255063593387604, -1.0381929874420166, 0.5967229008674622, 0.6516107320785522, 0.8690065145492554, -0.456337034702301, 0.15874114632606506, 0.06977449357509613, 0.5199690461158752, 0.03558121621608734, -0.004043474793434143, 0.004699026234447956, -0.8107085227966309, 0.2906586825847626, -0.36507999897003174, -0.30466392636299133, 0.05435063689947128, -0.6585190892219543, 0.23534627258777618, -0.6982356905937195, -0.299699068069458, 0.48161762952804565, 0.17214959859848022, -0.4050915241241455, 0.3494316637516022, -0.15659375488758087, 0.8118234872817993, -0.5101311802864075, 0.6343682408332825, 1.230879545211792, -0.46475258469581604, -0.3008232116699219, 0.25831711292266846, 0.12246912717819214, -0.26107701659202576, 0.20550230145454407, 0.02169044315814972, -0.23816776275634766, -0.4929819703102112, -0.6428052186965942, -0.4579540193080902, 0.5172384977340698, 0.21859702467918396, -0.23883271217346191, 0.1058163270354271, 0.20263096690177917, 0.6780202984809875, -0.07207833975553513, -0.2915170192718506, 0.5223149657249451, 0.5171090960502625, -0.3432105481624603, -0.33416253328323364, -0.09139268845319748, -0.30266332626342773, -0.008949056267738342, 0.5492829084396362, -0.46752920746803284, 0.8810896873474121, -0.07867676019668579, -0.6238723993301392, -0.04523371905088425, 0.5223535299301147, -0.005567657761275768, 0.4488813877105713, 0.7166455984115601, 0.8524020910263062, 0.7266592383384705, -0.17750850319862366, 1.157699704170227, -0.39661937952041626, 0.2565878629684448, 1.0863535404205322, -0.06299463659524918, 0.684238076210022, 0.2799971401691437, -0.4008862376213074, 0.2644987106323242, 0.2154254913330078, -0.098751962184906, 0.3498142957687378, 0.4989587664604187, -0.6749576330184937, 0.05042280629277229, 0.35310426354408264, -0.3384718894958496, 0.5007522702217102, 0.3566541373729706, -0.06873272359371185, -0.13550446927547455, 0.3427982032299042, 0.49939221143722534, 0.468372642993927, -0.1376446783542633, 0.8344055414199829, -0.2556561827659607, -0.4359624981880188, 0.3489609956741333, 0.15284916758537292, 1.0734283924102783, -0.7690906524658203, 0.3272557854652405, -0.05711617320775986, 0.4249577522277832, -0.2957153916358948, -0.6012140512466431, 0.1838332861661911, 0.12373781204223633, -0.17409446835517883, -0.13276472687721252, 0.9247831106185913, -0.24076171219348907, -0.5253475904464722, 0.1337479054927826, -0.06214141845703125, -0.0511525496840477, -0.12991568446159363, -0.6827290654182434, -0.056689344346523285, 0.08227058500051498, -0.09087167680263519, 0.4693843722343445, 0.5782550573348999, 0.4527743458747864, 0.4815281331539154, 0.5350013375282288, 0.41598230600357056, 0.0916581004858017, -0.0050979675725102425, 0.9206395149230957, -0.4651316702365875, -0.5497716069221497, -0.9947496652603149, 0.09821288287639618, -0.1459628939628601, -0.4006955027580261, 1.0255178213119507, 0.40472331643104553, 0.8429768681526184, 0.2683654725551605, 1.0407034158706665, 0.10756748914718628, 0.39925795793533325, -0.14896614849567413, 0.7737283706665039, -0.46310049295425415, 0.4074939787387848, -0.5003625154495239, -0.4833196997642517, -0.5134269595146179, 0.5202120542526245, -0.09212692826986313, -0.4049120843410492, 0.7313714027404785, 0.7428101301193237, 0.3189427852630615, 0.19466009736061096, 0.3713141679763794, 0.10823243856430054, 0.5560563802719116, 0.34944653511047363, 0.6661502122879028, -0.8881052136421204, 0.7715509533882141, -0.20552977919578552, -0.34692901372909546, 0.12978634238243103, -0.7037508487701416, -0.9548676609992981, -0.5495426058769226, -0.5334946513175964, -0.7437968254089355, 0.5245579481124878, 0.6191740036010742, 0.3707208037376404, -0.7507753372192383, 0.2529013752937317, -0.21268315613269806, 0.06944432854652405, -0.32585859298706055, -0.34039631485939026, 0.4145658612251282, -0.6395600438117981, -0.3153128921985626, 0.5889376401901245, 0.26415249705314636, 0.10630162060260773, -0.3789319396018982, 0.33209672570228577, -0.1510169953107834, 0.4816039204597473, 0.4915825426578522, 0.25947433710098267, -0.3371671736240387, -0.5576320886611938, -0.21719476580619812, -0.22616443037986755, -0.10805465281009674, 0.9065461158752441, -0.6571386456489563, 0.6307336688041687, 0.48641443252563477, 1.1259877681732178, -0.10369960218667984, -0.1214829683303833, 0.11340194940567017, -0.7873030304908752, 0.1922338902950287, 0.19495753943920135, 0.26629960536956787, 0.2888876497745514, -0.6528905034065247, 0.3853355944156647, 0.47471681237220764, -0.3911064565181732, -0.9424861669540405, 0.47030797600746155, -0.5361701846122742, -0.6222928166389465, 0.9420883059501648, -0.24965748190879822, -0.2016083300113678, 0.05639321729540825, -0.24268785119056702, 0.12206880003213882, -0.1887318342924118, 1.083457350730896, 0.7018998265266418, 0.3687623143196106, 0.3525143563747406, -0.14980825781822205, 0.5311428308486938, 0.4761551022529602, -0.8673040270805359, -0.04267687350511551, 0.19419652223587036, 0.17145437002182007, 0.4223155975341797, 0.14476440846920013, -0.19990399479866028, 0.28614717721939087, 0.46410050988197327, -0.04234407842159271, 0.059131644666194916, -0.46501651406288147, -0.45410633087158203, 0.5808243155479431, -0.33472970128059387, -0.6305597424507141 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17181v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17181v1	Transfer Learning for Text Diffusion Models	2024-01-30T17:11:56	2024-01-30T17:11:56	Kehang Han, Kathleen Kenealy, Aditya Barua, Noah Fiedel, Noah Constant	cs.CL	cs.CL	In this report, we explore the potential for text diffusion to replace autoregressive (AR) decoding for the training and deployment of large language models (LLMs). We are particularly interested to see whether pretrained AR models can be transformed into text diffusion models through a lightweight adaptation procedure we call ``AR2Diff''. We begin by establishing a strong baseline setup for training text diffusion models. Comparing across multiple architectures and pretraining objectives, we find that training a decoder-only model with a prefix LM objective is best or near-best across several tasks. Building on this finding, we test various transfer learning setups for text diffusion models. On machine translation, we find that text diffusion underperforms the standard AR approach. However, on code synthesis and extractive QA, we find diffusion models trained from scratch outperform AR models in many cases. We also observe quality gains from AR2Diff -- adapting AR models to use diffusion decoding. These results are promising given that text diffusion is relatively underexplored and can be significantly faster than AR decoding for long text generation.	[ 0.009034700691699982, -0.7276452779769897, 0.6434260010719299, 0.16557225584983826, -0.2615785300731659, 0.03183154761791229, -0.02013818733394146, -0.4501560926437378, -0.3427876830101013, 0.5865604877471924, -0.07338342070579529, -0.38842490315437317, -1.1301831007003784, 0.0732947438955307, -0.9133996963500977, 0.9647701382637024, -0.3617039918899536, -0.03566710278391838, -0.1448967605829239, -0.06341854482889175, -0.2101200371980667, -0.40186071395874023, -0.9748847484588623, -0.6417728066444397, 0.3295575678348541, 0.13561466336250305, 0.2919688820838928, 0.522811233997345, 0.38433441519737244, 0.1242220550775528, -0.1909862905740738, 0.004340561106801033, -0.5111401677131653, 0.13190527260303497, -0.3081279695034027, -0.3576905429363251, -0.17467695474624634, -0.0497860386967659, 0.7347688674926758, 0.568717896938324, -0.2808676064014435, -0.0765584334731102, 0.20301005244255066, 0.9043172597885132, -0.6313170194625854, -0.17708101868629456, -0.47829607129096985, 0.09060531109571457, 0.17897415161132812, -0.049233321100473404, -0.7073498964309692, -0.23492567241191864, 0.22591693699359894, -0.2923288643360138, 0.10161630809307098, 0.098651222884655, 0.3725043535232544, 0.2321479320526123, -1.0667914152145386, -0.5397350788116455, -0.9842778444290161, 0.6352959275245667, -0.4677378833293915, 0.47761663794517517, 0.48286646604537964, -0.10123167186975479, -0.01118185929954052, -0.7168940901756287, -0.4014267027378082, -0.12954607605934143, 0.06090492010116577, 0.027480317279696465, -0.46184372901916504, -0.08558548241853714, -0.13667349517345428, 0.2538655400276184, -0.5891432762145996, 0.13401244580745697, -0.2645719349384308, -0.001101217931136489, 0.4498341381549835, 0.008193067274987698, 0.20983146131038666, 0.24790441989898682, -0.4796375334262848, -0.15664571523666382, -0.4636434018611908, -0.1694909632205963, 0.2142648845911026, -0.16013379395008087, -0.27114081382751465, 0.21694712340831757, 0.10820826888084412, 0.6061561107635498, 0.062421806156635284, -0.005235868040472269, 0.21404021978378296, -0.46576911211013794, -0.16971103847026825, -0.040347870439291, 0.7098422646522522, 0.004419523291289806, 0.047734618186950684, -0.25049763917922974, -0.40196728706359863, -0.4357627332210541, 0.2426138073205948, -0.8838122487068176, -0.5065019726753235, -0.22238394618034363, -0.7789661288261414, -0.29607275128364563, -0.3610054850578308, -0.7183250784873962, -0.40631192922592163, -0.05737922340631485, 0.665503740310669, -0.2663261890411377, -0.5945764183998108, 0.35056832432746887, -0.23025791347026825, 0.19682390987873077, 0.4193965494632721, -1.0041221380233765, 0.49084198474884033, 0.25014063715934753, 1.0834914445877075, -0.808369517326355, -0.16481442749500275, -0.4852182865142822, 0.194926455616951, -0.43254974484443665, 1.069669246673584, -0.3497023284435272, -0.69141685962677, 0.1496140956878662, -0.0014673512196168303, -0.15392087399959564, -0.5706801414489746, 0.5020674467086792, -0.6077724099159241, 0.1419459879398346, 0.05328226462006569, -0.5507789850234985, -0.17947392165660858, 0.07014533132314682, -0.617359459400177, 1.0421911478042603, 0.4524436593055725, -0.5773864984512329, -0.012681378051638603, -0.5660027265548706, -0.7591273784637451, -0.45387470722198486, 0.49091076850891113, -0.3297146260738373, -0.004530962556600571, -0.172926127910614, 0.48924997448921204, -0.10735241323709488, -0.23368121683597565, -0.034460145980119705, -0.18563435971736908, 0.08430961519479752, -0.5232879519462585, 0.6041412353515625, 0.5252916812896729, -0.1612621545791626, -0.21313613653182983, -0.6712942719459534, -0.4407608211040497, -0.01701102964580059, -0.43798089027404785, -0.5430121421813965, -0.02250812202692032, 0.14444230496883392, -0.14553412795066833, 0.048115164041519165, 0.015217134729027748, 0.27607297897338867, -0.26928699016571045, 0.4123302400112152, 0.5345041155815125, 0.14240112900733948, 1.2324546575546265, -0.10539738088846207, 0.6223689913749695, 0.25306716561317444, -0.19516050815582275, -0.13976527750492096, -0.3053877055644989, -0.7024893164634705, 0.05721687525510788, 0.4833085834980011, 0.597025454044342, -0.7759114503860474, 0.24224834144115448, 0.10685835778713226, -0.4208364486694336, -0.1892808973789215, 0.3477327823638916, 0.09558034688234329, 0.6698618531227112, 0.3965650498867035, -0.16793036460876465, -0.3125244379043579, -0.46372389793395996, -0.15502089262008667, -0.24752764403820038, 0.33467233180999756, -0.13878744840621948, 0.579984724521637, -0.6549854874610901, 0.45807090401649475, -0.40348848700523376, -0.1417333483695984, -0.43743565678596497, 0.4779268801212311, -0.2824164032936096, 0.5583497285842896, 0.5736202597618103, -0.7851595878601074, -0.6240418553352356, -0.022814916446805, -0.35578522086143494, -0.15173621475696564, -0.1293102502822876, -0.23586685955524445, 0.32348525524139404, 0.8338400721549988, -0.3282417356967926, 0.40656399726867676, 0.9069525599479675, -0.4835442304611206, 0.47544336318969727, -0.46339404582977295, 0.2560572326183319, -1.4011201858520508, 0.022512124851346016, 0.0752834677696228, -0.6086305379867554, -0.5763772130012512, -0.3251938223838806, 0.050128109753131866, 0.11005525290966034, -0.5045113563537598, 1.0789684057235718, -0.6269923448562622, -0.08253245800733566, -0.6646888256072998, 0.01509509701281786, 0.11619998514652252, 0.008997836150228977, 0.26619452238082886, 1.141370415687561, 0.48730480670928955, -1.0301668643951416, 0.09840377420186996, 0.26505494117736816, -0.4089367985725403, 0.20665650069713593, -0.45236581563949585, 0.03310948982834816, -0.17967139184474945, 0.4390372633934021, -1.2682355642318726, 0.172000914812088, 0.40832921862602234, -0.2038155049085617, 0.21596914529800415, -0.4026672840118408, -0.44985416531562805, 0.01552928052842617, 0.0993005558848381, 0.6893958449363708, 1.0338813066482544, -0.5098702907562256, 0.7016823887825012, 0.2603415250778198, -0.13930536806583405, -0.4197879433631897, -0.8632404804229736, -0.06265086680650711, -0.2602686882019043, -0.13272497057914734, 0.47110024094581604, -0.2296467423439026, -0.10543036460876465, 0.1233539953827858, 0.10386457294225693, -0.4720016121864319, 0.2894441783428192, -0.18707945942878723, -0.1432255506515503, -0.06129863113164902, 0.2286989986896515, 0.3277226686477661, -0.08154968917369843, 0.04321231693029404, -0.29710516333580017, 0.3140547275543213, 0.43254202604293823, 0.00036858784733340144, -0.36109620332717896, 0.26075685024261475, 0.27651694416999817, -0.14294908940792084, 0.9306797981262207, 0.8279306292533875, -0.09501916915178299, -0.49348607659339905, -0.296730637550354, -0.011120536364614964, -0.4181618094444275, 0.41452115774154663, -0.20937472581863403, -0.7770951986312866, 0.5924023985862732, -0.5320895910263062, -0.02046002633869648, 0.5303795337677002, 0.5223507285118103, -0.13499444723129272, 0.9207534790039062, 1.2746585607528687, 0.16966462135314941, 0.9578183889389038, -0.3378627896308899, -0.0042512728832662106, -0.794859766960144, -0.1337423026561737, -0.6837469935417175, -0.09727921336889267, -0.06911381334066391, -0.4742089509963989, -0.0487712137401104, 0.3474251329898834, -0.058715760707855225, 0.22891882061958313, -0.22244402766227722, 0.5861051082611084, 0.08276712149381638, -0.06802019476890564, 0.3564903736114502, 0.2676798105239868, 0.3475334644317627, 0.36945903301239014, -0.6138321161270142, -0.31926229596138, 1.1688350439071655, 0.49521201848983765, 0.9909699559211731, 0.19709862768650055, 0.6708233952522278, 0.8624507784843445, 0.31691139936447144, -0.744276762008667, 0.21434803307056427, -0.45115429162979126, -0.1034436747431755, -0.10836198925971985, -0.6422349810600281, -1.0192795991897583, 0.1281510293483734, -0.1263299584388733, -0.3208228051662445, 0.16612780094146729, 0.0640869066119194, -0.08562003821134567, 0.3304175138473511, -0.8208863735198975, 0.7575452923774719, 0.03962979093194008, 0.006486434955149889, -0.22791065275669098, -0.30024248361587524, 0.48526909947395325, -0.2794215977191925, 0.3051218092441559, 0.04710354283452034, -0.32695305347442627, 0.9708325266838074, 0.0882800742983818, 0.5837929248809814, -0.016962429508566856, -0.5947490334510803, 0.21893836557865143, 0.4476764500141144, 0.6441885828971863, -0.12344492971897125, -0.22477033734321594, -0.016566753387451172, 0.12020069360733032, -0.3888836205005646, -0.46120762825012207, 0.4513481855392456, -0.9035744071006775, -0.2681105434894562, -0.44110366702079773, -0.3402796983718872, -0.04736756905913353, 0.3038102090358734, 0.4317095875740051, 0.3199056386947632, -0.2849697768688202, 0.027048956602811813, 1.353196144104004, 0.013103011064231396, 0.6142469048500061, 0.5712531208992004, -0.22124306857585907, -0.21206329762935638, 0.6394481062889099, -0.11867675930261612, 0.5236340165138245, 0.4644269347190857, 0.21661174297332764, -0.5303332805633545, -1.013536810874939, -0.48875924944877625, 0.10538408160209656, -0.8834553360939026, -0.13365718722343445, -0.8405500054359436, -0.33975204825401306, -0.4668607711791992, -0.10650801658630371, -0.42379310727119446, -0.1949356347322464, -0.9875249266624451, 0.09765755385160446, 0.4299607574939728, 1.0546021461486816, -0.05527786910533905, 0.6787108182907104, -0.926537811756134, 0.3205214738845825, 0.09339305758476257, 0.18124502897262573, 0.04890893027186394, -1.3048813343048096, -0.5403959155082703, -0.12773317098617554, -0.03415891155600548, -0.8150522112846375, 0.4314599335193634, 0.22003073990345, 0.4076267182826996, 0.13832013309001923, 0.11134248226881027, 0.2701191306114197, -0.6390195488929749, 0.9310813546180725, 0.25672096014022827, -0.8271048069000244, 0.38454294204711914, -0.1825989931821823, 0.19412419199943542, 0.5146776437759399, 0.5742464661598206, -0.31994304060935974, -0.05274186655879021, -0.3815230429172516, -0.5368366241455078, 0.4878286123275757, -0.07109270989894867, 0.43276727199554443, 0.053003206849098206, 0.7537773251533508, 0.3726192116737366, -0.13122080266475677, -0.7777458429336548, -0.27718234062194824, 0.13710352778434753, -0.48120200634002686, -0.2857508361339569, -0.5065383315086365, 0.02315903827548027, -0.11112753301858902, 0.62761390209198, 0.09203681349754333, 0.35851818323135376, 0.19042880833148956, -0.5211329460144043, -0.038743022829294205, 0.12063822895288467, 0.7196661829948425, 0.5212103128433228, 0.11470673978328705, 0.3214474320411682, 0.06378918886184692, -0.5847139954566956, 0.6908450722694397, -0.11081496626138687, -0.06293872743844986, -0.06518685072660446, 0.3105497360229492, 0.6869688630104065, -0.022430015727877617, -0.5152987241744995, 0.6869864463806152, -0.24590866267681122, -0.600470781326294, -0.1338643729686737, 0.1667993813753128, 0.0031611875165253878, 0.36018380522727966, 0.4115492105484009, 0.17014262080192566, 0.4132806062698364, -0.47703319787979126, 0.23559999465942383, 0.3431243300437927, -0.21266533434391022, -0.2987813651561737, 0.689980149269104, 0.4720883369445801, -0.38062503933906555, 0.38182711601257324, -0.3361363708972931, -0.3332057595252991, 0.5242512822151184, 0.696499764919281, 0.957303524017334, -0.1395891308784485, 0.31886929273605347, 0.07360760867595673, 0.212049663066864, -0.7443474531173706, -0.2132004201412201, -0.21605291962623596, -0.5989965200424194, -0.558113157749176, -0.5427396297454834, -0.3074490427970886, -0.05962369963526726, -0.4614894390106201, 0.17646969854831696, -0.26885101199150085, -0.04249405115842819, -0.47416743636131287, -0.064744733273983, -0.42185771465301514, 0.06366977095603943, 0.2199421226978302, 1.0438443422317505, -1.1592758893966675, 1.0688539743423462, 0.6659720540046692, -0.10227841883897781, -0.34204065799713135, 0.30072474479675293, -0.49613168835639954, -0.669337809085846, 0.743046224117279, -0.19783882796764374, -0.3297191858291626, 0.4686570167541504, -0.4529668688774109, -0.8739632964134216, 0.9703848361968994, 0.32961368560791016, -0.33499979972839355, -0.150503009557724, -0.32376429438591003, 0.44304782152175903, -0.37972187995910645, 0.31707480549812317, 0.4464305639266968, 0.07982978969812393, 0.17888547480106354, -0.6668987274169922, -0.2340075522661209, 0.10731123387813568, 0.12496405094861984, 0.15217232704162598, -0.6413649320602417, 0.7004515528678894, -0.06408999860286713, -0.12044887989759445, 0.2408483922481537, 0.8558455109596252, -0.20611301064491272, 0.2772791385650635, 0.4626079201698303, 0.5366148948669434, 0.4575953781604767, 0.23738113045692444, 0.8086390495300293, -0.060775645077228546, 0.21651452779769897, 0.8737648129463196, -0.30244702100753784, 1.0406848192214966, 0.35864880681037903, -0.09187884628772736, 0.8566654920578003, 0.688544750213623, 0.33100128173828125, 0.8408387303352356, -0.08829919993877411, -0.41964462399482727, -0.12575823068618774, 0.1912161260843277, -0.3957197368144989, 0.06549396365880966, 0.2268998920917511, -0.5400416254997253, -0.2999170422554016, 0.5376207828521729, -0.1719525009393692, 0.07879062741994858, -0.3436194062232971, 1.0823460817337036, 0.09232906997203827, -0.5158878564834595, 0.4956302344799042, 0.23199373483657837, 0.7566013336181641, -0.6325103640556335, -0.13533984124660492, -0.44165706634521484, 0.198308065533638, -0.0324065200984478, -0.8592106103897095, 0.34713679552078247, -0.10084856301546097, -0.5151143074035645, -0.6381740570068359, 0.8660727143287659, -0.7443272471427917, -0.3346809446811676, 0.28389543294906616, 0.5702383518218994, 0.29996830224990845, 0.1470929980278015, -0.7464288473129272, 0.14911885559558868, 0.10636326670646667, -0.3657222390174866, 0.7033025026321411, 0.5833487510681152, 0.25468549132347107, 0.7296726703643799, 0.46159234642982483, 0.17803823947906494, 0.14482161402702332, -0.1024683341383934, 0.5345858335494995, -0.5562280416488647, -0.5626922249794006, -0.8778531551361084, 0.3596876859664917, 0.4171464145183563, -0.040293242782354355, 0.5604569911956787, 0.35961073637008667, 0.5296750664710999, -0.03336336836218834, 0.8291928172111511, 0.21295346319675446, 0.39135831594467163, -0.8650131821632385, 0.7341657280921936, -0.5757132768630981, 0.18834979832172394, 0.07453537732362747, -0.9991816878318787, 0.05139750614762306, 0.6017292737960815, -0.12820938229560852, 0.09718459099531174, 0.7808196544647217, 0.3880743980407715, -0.15719088912010193, -0.45018327236175537, 0.21602171659469604, -0.005944614298641682, 0.39831677079200745, 0.5475816130638123, 0.8212716579437256, -0.7691069841384888, 0.7130587697029114, 0.0018456346588209271, -0.20489999651908875, -0.2527666389942169, -1.1032532453536987, -0.9319222569465637, -0.7145874500274658, -0.6330058574676514, -0.461590051651001, 0.15872779488563538, 0.43538254499435425, 0.7307589650154114, -0.42866256833076477, -0.24038685858249664, -0.3726722002029419, 0.23326323926448822, -0.029927261173725128, -0.1849239021539688, 0.3299323320388794, -0.38516587018966675, -0.7240005135536194, 0.3677501082420349, -0.06159795820713043, 0.7083804607391357, -0.35409802198410034, -0.2608571946620941, -0.22537973523139954, 0.0828402116894722, 0.6962360739707947, 0.31259194016456604, -0.22147178649902344, -0.0051299287006258965, -0.19015517830848694, -0.24593839049339294, -0.08753939718008041, 0.7834635972976685, -0.8348399996757507, 0.09671149402856827, 0.6104176044464111, 0.9500993490219116, 0.5574988126754761, 0.03447239100933075, 0.5157915353775024, -0.5102384686470032, 0.3241341710090637, 0.14342176914215088, 0.02811734564602375, 0.11387894302606583, -0.33412930369377136, 0.3243429660797119, 0.2220253348350525, -0.7169188857078552, -0.9992368221282959, 0.10053759068250656, -0.8256049156188965, -0.5209673643112183, 1.6474049091339111, 0.03557142987847328, -0.3218724727630615, -0.16437025368213654, -0.15869224071502686, 0.22225622832775116, -0.37166905403137207, 0.4974782466888428, 0.7498645186424255, -0.1551143079996109, -0.7081038355827332, -0.4220406711101532, 0.7581375241279602, 0.2983640730381012, -0.909727156162262, 0.28725913166999817, 0.3102189004421234, 0.6258296370506287, -0.26646071672439575, 0.9752805233001709, 0.015448284335434437, 0.20794428884983063, -0.06888936460018158, 0.000158420589286834, 0.10873249173164368, -0.3391413390636444, -0.7633908987045288, -0.17816327512264252, 0.34667906165122986, 0.10901129990816116 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17169v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17169v1	Conditional and Modal Reasoning in Large Language Models	2024-01-30T16:56:54	2024-01-30T16:56:54	Wesley H. Holliday, Matthew Mandelkern	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LO, 68T50, 03B65, I.2.7	The reasoning abilities of large language models (LLMs) are the topic of a growing body of research in artificial intelligence and cognitive science. In this paper, we probe the extent to which a dozen LLMs are able to distinguish logically correct inferences from logically fallacious ones. We focus on inference patterns involving conditionals (e.g., 'If Ann has a queen, then Bob has a jack') and epistemic modals (e.g., 'Ann might have an ace', 'Bob must have a king'). These inference patterns have been of special interest to logicians, philosophers, and linguists, since they plausibly play a central role in human reasoning. Assessing LLMs on these inference patterns is thus highly relevant to the question of how much the reasoning abilities of LLMs match those of humans. Among the LLMs we tested, all but GPT-4 often make basic mistakes with conditionals. Moreover, even GPT-4 displays logically inconsistent judgments across inference patterns involving epistemic modals.	[ -0.13664638996124268, -0.9950843453407288, 1.1747850179672241, 0.21580246090888977, -0.07194266468286514, -0.16715221107006073, -0.4336860179901123, -0.4859335422515869, 0.01207941398024559, 0.5032908320426941, -0.28969305753707886, -0.4809221029281616, -0.5593756437301636, 0.584847092628479, -0.34186315536499023, 0.6102970838546753, 0.04634470120072365, 0.07648594677448273, -0.3410433828830719, 0.05856052041053772, -0.5539548397064209, -0.6253749132156372, -0.5307405591011047, -0.23131556808948517, 0.408895879983902, 0.05011449381709099, 0.8510012626647949, 0.49588900804519653, 0.2860463559627533, 0.37233009934425354, -0.10871189832687378, 0.20994873344898224, -0.16565802693367004, 0.2733573019504547, -0.31277841329574585, -0.9826715588569641, -0.4149596095085144, 0.07200048863887787, 0.5285649299621582, 0.6659107804298401, 0.06280370056629181, -0.22420023381710052, -0.33558031916618347, 0.5030420422554016, -0.36779797077178955, 0.4270559251308441, -0.9034610390663147, -0.14183248579502106, -0.2632858157157898, -0.0468730591237545, -0.6619585752487183, -0.11098480969667435, 0.009302516467869282, -0.5521013736724854, 0.05155010521411896, 0.37180599570274353, 0.7785804867744446, 0.33841097354888916, -0.6669946908950806, -0.2283848077058792, -0.3921862840652466, 0.9182628393173218, -0.8900630474090576, 0.6101226806640625, 0.7346876263618469, 0.1291453242301941, -0.390521764755249, -0.5798189640045166, -0.8517918586730957, -0.535905659198761, -0.3932470381259918, 0.028036879375576973, -0.1328197717666626, 0.3684973120689392, 0.6745664477348328, 0.24421966075897217, -0.5118597745895386, 0.12638351321220398, -0.09247809648513794, -0.2304569035768509, 0.49951931834220886, 0.10873882472515106, 0.20902495086193085, -0.44394004344940186, -0.2606053054332733, 0.27401793003082275, -0.6881923079490662, 0.09640399366617203, 0.21296964585781097, 0.1330481618642807, -0.2773544490337372, 0.5315107107162476, -0.032824866473674774, 1.0693589448928833, 0.1394805759191513, -0.41843703389167786, 0.07277659326791763, -0.4413544237613678, -0.35005712509155273, -0.15386591851711273, 0.5142282247543335, 0.17973564565181732, 0.3425964415073395, -0.12006358057260513, -0.5188241004943848, 0.2960933744907379, -0.028513949364423752, -0.42701274156570435, -0.3972363770008087, 0.1734597384929657, -0.4221670627593994, -0.018343649804592133, -0.012339363805949688, -0.1574937254190445, -0.263752281665802, -0.6549687385559082, 0.758917510509491, -0.43051669001579285, -0.17518283426761627, 0.3887178301811218, -0.2612520158290863, 0.4226668179035187, 0.6722467541694641, -0.659435510635376, 0.1284847855567932, 0.8473312854766846, 0.4859732687473297, -0.25443604588508606, -0.30044791102409363, -0.47070014476776123, 0.2711733877658844, -0.5236542820930481, 0.8305991291999817, -0.960968554019928, -0.06111220270395279, -0.12442248314619064, 0.04208679124712944, -0.2299262136220932, -0.37397703528404236, 0.6949030756950378, -0.7853628993034363, 0.192396342754364, -0.8137959837913513, -0.7507376670837402, -0.7066280841827393, 0.39040595293045044, -0.6690884828567505, 0.3602329194545746, 0.10065256804227829, -0.6045027375221252, 0.43916240334510803, -0.2514494061470032, -0.6069295406341553, -0.043199457228183746, -0.7676259875297546, -0.19622191786766052, 0.1631501466035843, 0.015438061207532883, 0.44084200263023376, -0.7120792269706726, 0.2650730311870575, -0.38553330302238464, -0.20667125284671783, 0.5559258460998535, -0.5715016722679138, 0.6813053488731384, 0.06084345653653145, -0.3539721965789795, -0.0820760726928711, -0.5961298942565918, -0.01907583512365818, 0.019313450902700424, -0.513070285320282, -0.3773376941680908, 0.3429222106933594, -0.296467661857605, 0.18643805384635925, 0.052100248634815216, -0.20550468564033508, 0.5029298663139343, 0.06378951668739319, 0.7114488482475281, 0.8686143755912781, -0.06649883091449738, 0.15754130482673645, -0.5621827244758606, 0.4109574258327484, 0.16781973838806152, -0.13082776963710785, -0.13033424317836761, -0.6402068138122559, -0.8820302486419678, -0.7868112325668335, 0.5379210114479065, 0.5589686036109924, -0.8062874674797058, 0.4820718467235565, -0.05390867590904236, 0.06519383192062378, -0.003979250323027372, 0.07930280268192291, 0.3812089264392853, 0.2498280107975006, 0.13274620473384857, -0.013895601965487003, -0.4376976191997528, -1.109625220298767, -0.32139724493026733, -0.3700917959213257, 0.025856710970401764, 0.16862860321998596, 0.5331330299377441, -0.11932967603206635, 0.9346886873245239, -0.07484828680753708, 0.05914006009697914, -0.4516344368457794, -0.1239367127418518, 0.5413575172424316, 0.2549136281013489, 0.7184193134307861, -0.925677478313446, -0.11682060360908508, -0.20927530527114868, -0.6576967239379883, -0.26963096857070923, -0.3272062838077545, -0.04503500089049339, 0.34896785020828247, 0.408685564994812, -0.8531425595283508, 0.41539129614830017, 0.5551943182945251, -0.604444682598114, 0.48823660612106323, -0.14224101603031158, 0.4184562563896179, -0.5956746339797974, -0.3352987766265869, -0.0473891906440258, -0.4624522924423218, -0.5715099573135376, -0.16684046387672424, 0.02545926906168461, 0.46997690200805664, 0.015691444277763367, 0.3622029721736908, -0.5693913698196411, -0.30677226185798645, -0.014961079694330692, -0.028418127447366714, 0.12968476116657257, 0.36105236411094666, 0.08024334162473679, 0.610367476940155, 0.5139415860176086, -0.6593719720840454, 0.08130986988544464, 0.06190507486462593, -0.34060707688331604, 0.6037595868110657, -0.5850099325180054, -0.03280814737081528, -0.0387897863984108, 0.44377419352531433, -0.9407011866569519, -0.3787868618965149, 0.029991241171956062, -0.22366605699062347, 0.2040233165025711, -0.1480111926794052, -0.72652667760849, -0.17054927349090576, -0.1628701388835907, 0.3824087381362915, 0.5058705806732178, -0.378513902425766, 0.950793445110321, 0.23065350949764252, 0.06703406572341919, -0.2870510518550873, -0.7610539793968201, 0.003867724910378456, -0.0808301791548729, -0.7375819087028503, 0.15084579586982727, -0.191897451877594, -0.7238380312919617, -0.1000506803393364, -0.26505181193351746, -0.038322318345308304, 0.13740162551403046, 0.16592459380626678, 0.338316947221756, -0.30893465876579285, 0.045197226107120514, 0.002276839455589652, 0.12463387846946716, 0.1110636442899704, -0.11588019132614136, 0.3979121148586273, -0.3289223909378052, -0.7556598782539368, -0.4092506468296051, 0.08627082407474518, 0.834039032459259, -0.05667071044445038, 0.5532810688018799, 0.00026522131520323455, -0.43929722905158997, -0.22473277151584625, -0.867740273475647, -0.0910215899348259, -0.4484582841396332, 0.13103222846984863, -0.7534555196762085, -0.8038772940635681, 0.697555661201477, 0.3356844484806061, -0.06226750835776329, 0.4809330105781555, 0.6594399809837341, 0.10293684154748917, 1.2005155086517334, 0.36999136209487915, 0.1339247226715088, 0.16472791135311127, -0.11539385467767715, 0.3375852704048157, -0.5137523412704468, -0.21211940050125122, -0.3423652946949005, -0.21476419270038605, -0.7670760154724121, -0.5829720497131348, 0.30087345838546753, 0.24717167019844055, -0.4202883541584015, 0.1411580592393875, 0.049878183752298355, 0.6637091636657715, 0.5227476358413696, 0.07801920175552368, 0.5913369059562683, -0.2915165424346924, -0.051279403269290924, 0.21568453311920166, -0.6098434329032898, -0.6129863858222961, 0.8270485401153564, 0.28491854667663574, 0.5625023245811462, 0.4816209077835083, 0.23555006086826324, 0.4679966866970062, 0.33000677824020386, -0.7251144051551819, 0.7648727297782898, -0.01831403560936451, -0.8907033205032349, -0.1115519180893898, -0.4910823106765747, -0.6975162625312805, 0.42128026485443115, -0.2138921469449997, -0.6085395812988281, 0.3442973792552948, 0.2799232602119446, -0.2793370187282562, 0.408890962600708, -0.6786401867866516, 0.9141013622283936, -0.34099334478378296, -0.03923700004816055, -0.32960227131843567, -0.6369328498840332, 0.6724871397018433, -0.3006134033203125, 0.2789236903190613, -0.25769081711769104, -0.29432982206344604, 0.4457819163799286, -0.30363762378692627, 0.8104003071784973, 0.12474501878023148, -0.08977896720170975, 0.1667754352092743, 0.40463289618492126, 0.5381247401237488, 0.07253516465425491, -0.22614698112010956, 0.37237638235092163, 0.2647758722305298, -0.37624597549438477, -0.49567514657974243, 0.5456681847572327, -0.7567780017852783, -0.8960204720497131, -0.5675386786460876, -0.6510559916496277, -0.3014085292816162, 0.027521727606654167, 0.1025402843952179, 0.42742466926574707, 0.1791628897190094, 0.04046185314655304, 0.5319154858589172, -0.1910337507724762, 0.3519907593727112, 0.7888957858085632, -0.2927774488925934, -0.17062164843082428, 0.655390202999115, 0.11830084770917892, 0.4969809353351593, 0.465304970741272, 0.18368428945541382, -0.19743245840072632, -0.7801851034164429, -0.3693157434463501, 0.5119507908821106, -0.9079384803771973, -0.09104340523481369, -0.3380431532859802, 0.031719375401735306, -0.050307370722293854, -0.14980924129486084, 0.05217745155096054, -0.37711259722709656, -0.02906327322125435, -0.06267988681793213, 0.5156524181365967, 0.8636810183525085, -0.14125956594944, -0.13803869485855103, -0.5247636437416077, 0.3007943630218506, 0.6308618783950806, -0.07570190727710724, -0.14410072565078735, -0.7028831839561462, 0.38614174723625183, -0.1110718697309494, 0.08447501063346863, -0.9016960263252258, 0.037086766213178635, 0.10637803375720978, 0.659105658531189, 0.6070716381072998, -0.015078561380505562, 0.46895742416381836, -0.5440309047698975, 0.7800591588020325, 0.1873817890882492, -1.0971503257751465, 0.15335045754909515, -0.7370566725730896, -0.21422214806079865, 0.3739764094352722, 0.2865879237651825, -0.5279466509819031, -0.46119043231010437, -0.5576546788215637, -0.4260798990726471, 0.5472211241722107, 0.2673042416572571, -0.10452862828969955, -0.32464441657066345, 0.3170963525772095, 0.2511582672595978, 0.3335142731666565, -0.7984127402305603, -0.19109271466732025, 0.06594570726156235, -0.06235365569591522, -0.00748658599331975, -0.16052386164665222, -0.11381730437278748, -0.4083276093006134, 0.408107191324234, 0.04276205226778984, 0.12686565518379211, -0.02443419024348259, -0.320587694644928, -0.00470231007784605, 0.21958009898662567, 0.8253771066665649, 1.1264792680740356, -0.02492372691631317, 0.5115015506744385, 0.2393636405467987, -0.08712516725063324, 0.14734676480293274, -0.09793847054243088, -0.2405320405960083, -0.12247280776500702, 0.7044181823730469, 0.7749338150024414, 0.07819510996341705, -0.7165902853012085, 0.7738217711448669, -0.0806022509932518, -0.1768576204776764, -0.4947361648082733, 0.18060842156410217, 0.10699854046106339, 0.48344185948371887, 0.2282455712556839, 0.020755229517817497, -0.08434900641441345, -0.8909733891487122, 0.017293039709329605, 0.5443870425224304, 0.15665549039840698, -0.5434685349464417, 0.4803541302680969, 0.16807442903518677, -0.37747982144355774, 0.5045989751815796, -0.4917910099029541, -0.8474687933921814, 0.5577336549758911, 0.5226244926452637, 0.5733327865600586, 0.050650980323553085, -0.1864132434129715, 0.015313602052628994, 0.458219438791275, -0.16114775836467743, 0.3287195563316345, -0.048625797033309937, -0.9661262631416321, -0.7896771430969238, -0.6215923428535461, -0.4757317304611206, 0.23268865048885345, -0.40124595165252686, 0.27658867835998535, -0.4763902723789215, -0.044003888964653015, 0.056665223091840744, -0.4324280023574829, -0.7100141644477844, -0.011063513346016407, 0.31542760133743286, 0.7633138298988342, -1.035976767539978, 0.6682061553001404, 0.5994435548782349, -0.4829781651496887, -0.9561260342597961, 0.1912214159965515, 0.09570692479610443, -0.9483506083488464, 1.040066123008728, 0.08406078070402145, 0.021583380177617073, -0.21532942354679108, -0.5433241724967957, -0.9195703864097595, 0.7301238179206848, 0.5246238708496094, -0.5630792379379272, -0.07626745104789734, -0.14880627393722534, 0.2285415530204773, -0.11432063579559326, 0.4584505259990692, 0.9102019667625427, 0.8713491559028625, -0.1989709734916687, -1.1669377088546753, 0.19059783220291138, 0.14238262176513672, -0.02504320815205574, 0.23374739289283752, -0.6002519726753235, 1.1497613191604614, -0.23789723217487335, -0.04146432876586914, 0.04170288145542145, 0.6659900546073914, 0.42744484543800354, 0.04375068098306656, 0.8566068410873413, 0.8005297183990479, 0.7736695408821106, -0.22609925270080566, 1.1401546001434326, -0.33164480328559875, 0.1473546177148819, 0.6212170720100403, -0.3110107481479645, 0.6770660877227783, 0.24434319138526917, -0.4287008047103882, 0.6046030521392822, 0.7831791639328003, 0.14959721267223358, 0.3481699228286743, 0.2417604774236679, -0.28803643584251404, -1.0631885528564453, 0.34978529810905457, -0.24423286318778992, 0.6181855201721191, 0.5090882778167725, -0.22992484271526337, 0.06355548650026321, -0.16344910860061646, 0.2224995195865631, -0.12910552322864532, -0.38871678709983826, 0.42370960116386414, 0.16234375536441803, -0.753109335899353, 0.6262313723564148, 0.09602738916873932, 0.558504045009613, -0.5189276337623596, -0.1548858880996704, -0.13320542871952057, 0.11790886521339417, -0.2755511999130249, -0.6796393990516663, -0.11213444173336029, -0.1084633618593216, -0.3875485360622406, 0.06017880141735077, 0.30469098687171936, -0.1775544285774231, -0.3569987118244171, 0.11657591164112091, 0.5356727242469788, 0.3927430510520935, 0.1487104743719101, -0.5593437552452087, 0.20782333612442017, 0.09688995033502579, -0.4071780741214752, 0.11521672457456589, 0.6402402520179749, -0.3166951537132263, 0.6225622892379761, 0.7024456262588501, 0.20353728532791138, 0.07893911004066467, 0.2755601704120636, 0.6386593580245972, -0.6991764307022095, -0.32770511507987976, -0.9814012050628662, 0.25891757011413574, 0.09833963960409164, -0.15285351872444153, 0.8345555067062378, 0.41366443037986755, 0.6438772678375244, 0.047996968030929565, 0.8977925777435303, -0.08718133717775345, 0.4854493737220764, -0.948714554309845, 0.2726978063583374, -0.4168984889984131, 0.5279665589332581, -0.19444727897644043, -0.7815173864364624, -0.25997069478034973, 0.9466952681541443, -0.7764294147491455, 0.31204843521118164, 0.9569703936576843, 0.6819179654121399, -0.17362339794635773, 0.19814206659793854, 0.6064130067825317, 0.6606249213218689, 0.3071223497390747, 0.5708218812942505, 1.156633734703064, 0.006971590220928192, 0.15848757326602936, 0.18357859551906586, -0.15276655554771423, -0.17011119425296783, -1.0998035669326782, -1.009500503540039, -0.47803887724876404, -0.10870831459760666, -0.2958632707595825, -0.07271494716405869, 1.1347144842147827, 0.4733576774597168, -0.8321647047996521, -0.06781921535730362, -0.10677036643028259, 0.4104400873184204, -0.02978954277932644, -0.14821375906467438, 0.3199279308319092, -0.20430845022201538, -0.5765529870986938, 0.5301552414894104, 0.28956013917922974, -0.1300688087940216, -0.17373931407928467, -0.033112309873104095, -0.022589482367038727, 0.3376769721508026, 0.6558846831321716, 0.10305587202310562, -1.2614606618881226, -0.7257868051528931, -0.19920237362384796, -0.04986705258488655, 0.04074498638510704, 0.795423686504364, -0.6830301880836487, 0.13291680812835693, 0.7859174013137817, 0.5631721615791321, 0.23766964673995972, -0.11634812504053116, 0.5802799463272095, -0.19227206707000732, 0.14900250732898712, 0.3042847514152527, 0.8122483491897583, 0.21653129160404205, 0.07340341061353683, 0.30734363198280334, 0.5530625581741333, -0.7760049700737, -0.8853723406791687, 0.5335789322853088, -1.1838370561599731, -0.3826919496059418, 1.3948067426681519, 0.009949294850230217, -0.049638230353593826, -0.24791572988033295, -0.027153581380844116, -0.13228830695152283, -0.24998977780342102, 0.45486101508140564, 0.6364039778709412, -0.4083710014820099, -0.00793223176151514, -0.997083842754364, 0.3835427761077881, 0.45668938755989075, -0.6935054659843445, -0.03398905321955681, 0.741828978061676, 0.5280374884605408, -0.008756592869758606, 0.47351983189582825, 0.25919657945632935, 0.42918798327445984, -0.18607740104198456, -0.2125735580921173, 0.02919171191751957, -0.1436220407485962, -0.22531481087207794, -0.11381310224533081, 0.3634801208972931, 0.13399578630924225 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00891v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00891v1	Large Language Models in Cybersecurity: State-of-the-Art	2024-01-30T16:55:25	2024-01-30T16:55:25	Farzad Nourmohammadzadeh Motlagh, Mehrdad Hajizadeh, Mehryar Majd, Pejman Najafi, Feng Cheng, Christoph Meinel	cs.CR	cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG	The rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) has revolutionized our comprehension of intelligence bringing us closer to Artificial Intelligence. Since their introduction, researchers have actively explored the applications of LLMs across diverse fields, significantly elevating capabilities. Cybersecurity, traditionally resistant to data-driven solutions and slow to embrace machine learning, stands out as a domain. This study examines the existing literature, providing a thorough characterization of both defensive and adversarial applications of LLMs within the realm of cybersecurity. Our review not only surveys and categorizes the current landscape but also identifies critical research gaps. By evaluating both offensive and defensive applications, we aim to provide a holistic understanding of the potential risks and opportunities associated with LLM-driven cybersecurity.	[ -0.21522879600524902, -1.2629313468933105, 0.4206952154636383, -0.17676569521427155, 0.05770787224173546, 0.618721604347229, -0.04690677300095558, -0.8084051609039307, 0.018219666555523872, 0.6009495854377747, -0.28140750527381897, -0.3301088511943817, -0.8854969143867493, 0.009109600447118282, -0.8609117269515991, 0.9205542206764221, 0.18311524391174316, 0.010189040564000607, -0.3168952167034149, 0.29755574464797974, -0.33750230073928833, -1.2037707567214966, -0.6888536214828491, -0.4353209435939789, 0.28117772936820984, -0.21020744740962982, 0.7094833850860596, 0.329793781042099, 0.8926632404327393, 0.43591463565826416, -0.23444920778274536, -0.18760338425636292, -0.5333698391914368, 0.17390640079975128, -0.3722025752067566, -0.747597336769104, -0.4362785220146179, -0.06487894058227539, 0.4883959889411926, 0.6073612570762634, -0.1418502926826477, -0.05519716814160347, -0.24140869081020355, 0.6379361748695374, -0.5896350741386414, -0.16379648447036743, -1.019103765487671, -0.03370407596230507, -0.5284101963043213, -0.27682816982269287, -0.5949904918670654, 0.001441076397895813, 0.3167954683303833, -0.3936949074268341, -0.2951085865497589, 0.21330051124095917, 0.3396238088607788, 0.0010465356754139066, -0.46007248759269714, -0.34447529911994934, -0.9952090978622437, 0.843502938747406, -0.49880683422088623, 0.2945687770843506, 0.19440478086471558, 0.44461679458618164, -0.4266718029975891, -0.838147759437561, -0.3462800085544586, -0.3878394365310669, 0.31328070163726807, -0.07162383198738098, -0.825248658657074, -0.013388530351221561, 0.19033761322498322, 0.2646820545196533, -0.6997604966163635, 0.726688802242279, -0.5351288914680481, -0.07611075043678284, 0.8740492463111877, 0.4940761625766754, 0.5101900100708008, 0.41578254103660583, -0.3977447748184204, 0.1532895714044571, -0.9542074799537659, -0.08381190150976181, 0.48636388778686523, 0.2327180802822113, -0.17911429703235626, 0.4266834259033203, 0.11004023253917694, 0.6430015563964844, -0.2274187058210373, -0.4448714554309845, -0.1512099653482437, -0.14950686693191528, -0.39612457156181335, 0.06256178021430969, 0.7648561596870422, 0.10956405848264694, 0.39925357699394226, -0.2662908732891083, -0.21159125864505768, 0.10146765410900116, 0.8263564705848694, -0.5796970129013062, -0.06604386121034622, 0.29159969091415405, -0.4888402819633484, -0.6534609794616699, 0.155019149184227, -0.7396007776260376, -0.940285325050354, -0.34339210391044617, 0.07566484063863754, -0.14909625053405762, -0.3425685167312622, 0.2348284125328064, -0.039566684514284134, 0.24148797988891602, 0.224307581782341, -0.4666460156440735, 0.5602759718894958, 0.88089519739151, 0.7334239482879639, -0.2828037142753601, -0.10859618335962296, 0.047564756125211716, -0.04267410561442375, -0.6255630850791931, 0.3129233419895172, -0.4128767251968384, -0.41353437304496765, 0.303297221660614, -0.15268848836421967, 0.12178607285022736, -0.4291941821575165, 0.08181720227003098, -0.9477502703666687, -0.22866645455360413, 0.24590125679969788, -0.32139328122138977, -0.12995852530002594, 0.5422934889793396, -0.5587955117225647, 0.5378482341766357, -0.11009632796049118, -0.8593450784683228, -0.09935691207647324, -0.45123594999313354, -0.7050347924232483, 0.2413349747657776, 0.08559864014387131, -0.366160124540329, 0.12265055626630783, -0.14875954389572144, 0.6373096108436584, -0.6244467496871948, 0.17235232889652252, -0.6390928626060486, -0.23387941718101501, 0.6960486769676208, -0.36150887608528137, 0.95414137840271, 0.34985318779945374, -0.3169177174568176, 0.091237373650074, -0.442476749420166, -0.27994319796562195, 0.5809454321861267, 0.04273761063814163, -0.3406347632408142, 0.2364712804555893, -0.10037817806005478, 0.15243518352508545, 0.48924246430397034, -0.5560964941978455, -0.0511043407022953, -0.4549483358860016, 0.7894273996353149, 0.8258588910102844, -0.1233711913228035, 0.33428093791007996, -0.2332594245672226, 0.665245771408081, -0.003674897365272045, 0.34389498829841614, -0.0015454095555469394, -0.16339628398418427, -0.3739132583141327, -0.3977615237236023, 0.12424352765083313, 0.986294150352478, -0.6477257609367371, 0.2902885377407074, -0.1157950684428215, -0.921766459941864, -0.20912332832813263, 0.051966097205877304, 0.13902364671230316, -0.11220457404851913, 0.014244601130485535, 0.14434519410133362, -0.5605127811431885, -0.9875698685646057, -0.2212575376033783, -0.2551324665546417, 0.3019430339336395, 0.2113369107246399, 0.5374535918235779, -0.548662543296814, 0.5133682489395142, -0.46030303835868835, 0.05027979612350464, -0.5720872282981873, -0.2657789885997772, 0.04277604818344116, 0.14032302796840668, 0.5743584036827087, -0.8109699487686157, -0.2001720517873764, 0.0877385139465332, -0.8513351082801819, 0.20552776753902435, -0.03033369779586792, 0.19101403653621674, 0.10164154320955276, 0.8419638276100159, -0.5465108752250671, 0.3880998492240906, 0.5197054743766785, -0.0810948833823204, 0.600797712802887, 0.02476968616247177, 0.021005423739552498, -1.1529978513717651, 0.06513821333646774, 0.09339139610528946, -0.3672628402709961, -1.2027864456176758, 0.49615421891212463, -0.23261642456054688, -0.3836653530597687, -0.6359004378318787, 0.5000764727592468, -0.3094198405742645, 0.003295304486528039, -0.4547426998615265, 0.2924950122833252, -0.2936202585697174, -0.16798454523086548, -0.19691452383995056, 0.5346916913986206, 1.044697642326355, -0.6699720621109009, 0.7956342101097107, -0.16062897443771362, -0.3701048195362091, 0.5748264789581299, -0.7962207794189453, 0.08305304497480392, 0.12338902801275253, 0.3209932744503021, -0.5732501745223999, -0.20574945211410522, -0.026768945157527924, -0.25240153074264526, 0.611592710018158, 0.120047427713871, -0.7489248514175415, -0.6430255770683289, -0.3591006100177765, 0.41173189878463745, 0.4892543852329254, -0.3873648941516876, 0.4738731384277344, 0.9617391228675842, -0.3251822292804718, -0.5476378798484802, -0.8167166113853455, 0.5048828125, -0.4433620572090149, -0.5318995714187622, 0.25715628266334534, -0.023052386939525604, -0.9020326733589172, -0.5455288290977478, 0.1460263878107071, -0.0336349718272686, 0.8074793219566345, 0.2579844892024994, 0.46889790892601013, -0.07390713691711426, -0.12036304175853729, -0.6921471953392029, 0.15995879471302032, 0.47068625688552856, -0.3719416856765747, 0.5430873036384583, -0.155269056558609, -0.374105840921402, -0.33605992794036865, 0.3113943040370941, 0.7714347243309021, -0.21722325682640076, 0.836659848690033, 0.23767267167568207, -0.46892470121383667, -0.22445335984230042, -0.36638572812080383, -0.1288091093301773, -0.4810689687728882, 0.7161147594451904, -0.15040837228298187, -1.144693374633789, 0.36908963322639465, -0.14899858832359314, 0.13407450914382935, 0.3377302289009094, 0.70308917760849, 0.004389421548694372, 0.7716923356056213, 0.771736741065979, -0.6370114088058472, 0.4005398750305176, 0.0007285143947228789, 0.7584353089332581, -0.4431697130203247, -0.1954822987318039, -0.4502231478691101, -0.05044964328408241, -0.899355947971344, 0.19868427515029907, 0.27800247073173523, -0.076706163585186, -0.23940454423427582, 0.35962098836898804, -0.22053775191307068, 0.1489872932434082, 0.18500009179115295, 0.05986926704645157, -0.026052910834550858, -0.006447080988436937, 0.3326106369495392, 0.3923279047012329, -0.6196731925010681, -0.49947986006736755, 1.239643931388855, 0.8000959753990173, 0.9086610674858093, 0.4442024230957031, 0.32826465368270874, 0.5804381370544434, -0.10571039468050003, -0.6517592668533325, 0.7614412903785706, -0.29027295112609863, -0.6856140494346619, -0.23318058252334595, -0.35407403111457825, -1.1522448062896729, -0.10435757040977478, -0.35529014468193054, -1.0648444890975952, -0.3631606101989746, 0.03300438076257706, -0.19091467559337616, 0.6425567269325256, -0.12886734306812286, 0.4148840606212616, -0.3881644308567047, -0.29402339458465576, -0.369896799325943, -0.508582353591919, 0.5405562520027161, -0.4784283936023712, 0.23520179092884064, 0.005493725184351206, -0.0008518854738213122, 0.7282319664955139, 0.084837906062603, 1.0150970220565796, 0.16583584249019623, -0.30262520909309387, 0.40875232219696045, 0.19307070970535278, 0.6563850045204163, -0.08333796262741089, 0.07669153809547424, 0.5062627792358398, -0.11747173964977264, -0.2960648834705353, -0.19065269827842712, 0.8333640694618225, -0.6067332625389099, -0.9795064926147461, -0.7435338497161865, -0.441079705953598, -0.23119956254959106, 0.1822863221168518, 0.025503885000944138, 0.3685643970966339, -0.5166886448860168, 0.41894567012786865, 1.094885230064392, -0.45317238569259644, 0.481608122587204, 0.5606752634048462, -0.21935038268566132, -0.3155834674835205, 0.7958442568778992, -0.04755047336220741, 0.42946329712867737, 0.5683688521385193, 0.03139679506421089, -0.13509929180145264, -0.8946632742881775, -0.20407377183437347, 0.05695609748363495, -0.55027836561203, -0.31641295552253723, -0.5375180840492249, -0.6412360072135925, -0.4976057708263397, -0.42529165744781494, -0.1857396513223648, -0.1705714762210846, -0.1597670018672943, -0.07810500264167786, 0.49708473682403564, 1.0224963426589966, 0.5152884125709534, 0.3488313853740692, -0.4556306004524231, 0.1599617749452591, 0.09992549568414688, 0.11457753926515579, -0.12004473060369492, -0.621760904788971, -0.23408962786197662, -0.16654883325099945, -0.1537795215845108, -0.7792922854423523, 0.34395459294319153, -0.20301814377307892, 0.6344963908195496, 0.25925275683403015, -0.09557395428419113, 0.18522201478481293, -0.4716663658618927, 0.9765695333480835, 0.3390406370162964, -0.7071669697761536, 0.3398689031600952, -0.4472843110561371, 0.31353962421417236, 0.0894167348742485, 0.5539778470993042, -0.40485680103302, -0.29957735538482666, -0.5914999842643738, -0.7426313757896423, 0.356105774641037, -0.051225706934928894, 0.3858981430530548, 0.13401538133621216, 0.07447608560323715, -0.18101538717746735, 0.17140239477157593, -0.7307687401771545, -0.31546422839164734, 0.118167944252491, 0.019827216863632202, -0.1425786167383194, -0.2247506082057953, -0.1952323019504547, 0.3116922676563263, 0.7185160517692566, 0.01962798833847046, 0.30970290303230286, -0.3004703223705292, -0.037514425814151764, 0.128107488155365, 0.433148592710495, 0.6983335018157959, 0.6543673872947693, 0.36333373188972473, 0.09497256577014923, 0.3907650113105774, -0.5840603709220886, 0.22519665956497192, -0.027029646560549736, -0.27813804149627686, -0.33511731028556824, 0.5561683177947998, 0.5147976279258728, -0.04061593487858772, -0.8453439474105835, 0.6604911684989929, 0.2974960505962372, -0.29754364490509033, -0.6769651770591736, -0.003209996037185192, 0.009637344628572464, 0.3357822597026825, 0.2889920473098755, -0.14437438547611237, -0.01046555582433939, -0.8236739635467529, -0.014435377903282642, 0.899129331111908, -0.22527065873146057, -0.1302063912153244, 0.3649437725543976, -0.04613424465060234, -0.3085751533508301, 0.40072956681251526, 0.27255430817604065, -0.7047268152236938, 0.4992339313030243, 0.7528245449066162, 0.9435340762138367, -0.18483196198940277, -0.20959867537021637, -0.09717323631048203, 0.6737233400344849, 0.006821450777351856, 0.11986667662858963, 0.4862595796585083, -0.564926028251648, -0.006225415039807558, -0.5616962313652039, -0.3500347435474396, 0.5604655742645264, -0.30908873677253723, 0.1357378363609314, -1.0242515802383423, -0.37833768129348755, 0.012044143863022327, -0.08952079713344574, -0.5632975697517395, 0.09291160106658936, 0.5232122540473938, 1.1308002471923828, -0.6146220564842224, 0.5792747139930725, 0.538918137550354, 0.12780296802520752, -0.17193160951137543, -0.1690664440393448, 0.3657415211200714, -0.6463711857795715, 0.6077783107757568, -0.021600214764475822, -0.13852092623710632, -0.4198095202445984, -0.4868614971637726, -0.8820527791976929, 0.9996941089630127, 0.18614616990089417, -0.7139230370521545, 0.100690096616745, 0.4665107727050781, 0.5471832752227783, -0.4408508241176605, -0.10187103599309921, 0.6568964719772339, 0.2564321458339691, -0.5709781646728516, -0.8116443753242493, -0.05478627607226372, -0.20876069366931915, 0.10480637848377228, 0.4832383990287781, -0.7340171337127686, 0.605054497718811, 0.09285236150026321, -0.00028121861396357417, -0.05622226372361183, 0.5364585518836975, 0.17491239309310913, 0.2998952269554138, 0.16853095591068268, 0.5065524578094482, 0.5398654341697693, -0.06312736868858337, 1.1094151735305786, -0.21393026411533356, -0.2581787407398224, 0.674731969833374, -0.46548575162887573, 0.7944696545600891, 0.16845671832561493, -0.3921301066875458, 0.39464738965034485, 0.5946651101112366, -0.2615353763103485, 0.08261172473430634, 0.6650662422180176, -0.3398588001728058, -0.07443168014287949, 0.008189567364752293, 0.003509147558361292, 0.5498307943344116, 0.6065340638160706, -0.501934826374054, 0.09720873832702637, 0.09471505135297775, 0.19026778638362885, 0.13526779413223267, -0.802211344242096, 0.8985569477081299, 0.3693167567253113, -0.2549646198749542, 0.42234018445014954, 0.3253149390220642, 0.5903041362762451, -0.8487911224365234, 0.3495287597179413, 0.3220565617084503, 0.2183634340763092, -0.07104811072349548, -0.7062081694602966, 0.24943414330482483, 0.28441449999809265, -0.05713378265500069, -0.10623475909233093, 0.9216784834861755, 0.04582695662975311, -0.3184736967086792, 0.4860723316669464, 0.13825467228889465, 0.08470138162374496, 0.022094180807471275, -0.9110346436500549, 0.14661239087581635, -0.3358366787433624, -0.19205988943576813, 0.6426500082015991, 0.13863639533519745, -0.22844795882701874, 1.071244716644287, 0.6549955010414124, 0.27102699875831604, 0.06875308603048325, -0.18887723982334137, 0.8186472058296204, -0.3898201286792755, -0.3621251881122589, -1.3205918073654175, 0.14857171475887299, -0.25748589634895325, -0.27832940220832825, 0.8844514489173889, 0.3660181760787964, 0.7986690998077393, 0.037213023751974106, 1.0157616138458252, 0.13991281390190125, 0.4056882858276367, -0.6434025168418884, 0.6972150206565857, -0.2640114724636078, 0.3734826147556305, -0.19993281364440918, -0.6780781149864197, -0.2711262106895447, -0.022096887230873108, -0.3768545091152191, -0.1106264591217041, 0.5291588306427002, 0.7839887142181396, 0.14754098653793335, -0.08858857303857803, 0.5619334578514099, 0.22135676443576813, 0.32134655117988586, 0.3834606111049652, 0.7958332300186157, -0.23722878098487854, 0.28001025319099426, 0.09537060558795929, -0.21807245910167694, -0.43291789293289185, -0.8288090229034424, -1.250903844833374, -0.2225954383611679, -0.16933169960975647, -0.3403227627277374, 0.39713647961616516, 0.7520904541015625, 0.6701057553291321, -0.820761501789093, -0.22960905730724335, 0.11126244068145752, -0.0710456594824791, 0.022333741188049316, -0.14682932198047638, -0.1444535106420517, -0.14301152527332306, -0.24738654494285583, 0.6490323543548584, 0.447015643119812, 0.3037281930446625, -0.7366064190864563, 0.17989017069339752, -0.08405385166406631, 0.5827979445457458, 0.8350867629051208, 0.3513050973415375, -0.9038154482841492, 0.05762957036495209, 0.025543944910168648, -0.39836061000823975, -0.4689263105392456, 0.7801145315170288, -0.3702942132949829, 0.13148707151412964, 0.5400369763374329, 1.1797634363174438, -0.10420320183038712, -0.31986644864082336, 0.7578409314155579, -0.36018750071525574, 0.00021140920580364764, 0.2115611881017685, 0.6113678216934204, 0.3171967566013336, -0.5365402102470398, 0.3875805139541626, 0.22816996276378632, -0.59444659948349, -0.9052251577377319, 0.5630698204040527, -0.6694566011428833, -0.7116062641143799, 1.0782281160354614, -0.07706349343061447, -0.23158101737499237, -0.1558338701725006, 0.18447966873645782, -0.1208958551287651, 0.05814854055643082, 0.7197086811065674, 0.7383043169975281, 0.38627541065216064, 0.01569616235792637, -0.7556516528129578, 0.40282803773880005, -0.031576968729496, -0.9748526215553284, 0.35357096791267395, 0.08083218336105347, -0.026556938886642456, 0.18691325187683105, 0.17626331746578217, -0.2219247668981552, 0.2080373913049698, -0.06625939905643463, -0.20231561362743378, 0.001832730369642377, -0.6873393654823303, -0.4441785514354706, 0.18681907653808594, 0.18684092164039612, 0.330858439207077 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17167v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17167v3	Planning, Creation, Usage: Benchmarking LLMs for Comprehensive Tool Utilization in Real-World Complex Scenarios	2024-01-30T16:52:56	2024-06-03T11:28:29	Shijue Huang, Wanjun Zhong, Jianqiao Lu, Qi Zhu, Jiahui Gao, Weiwen Liu, Yutai Hou, Xingshan Zeng, Yasheng Wang, Lifeng Shang, Xin Jiang, Ruifeng Xu, Qun Liu	cs.CL	cs.CL	The recent trend of using Large Language Models (LLMs) as tool agents in real-world applications underscores the necessity for comprehensive evaluations of their capabilities, particularly in complex scenarios involving planning, creating, and using tools. However, existing benchmarks typically focus on simple synthesized queries that do not reflect real-world complexity, thereby offering limited perspectives in evaluating tool utilization. To address this issue, we present UltraTool, a novel benchmark designed to improve and evaluate LLMs' ability in tool utilization within real-world scenarios. UltraTool focuses on the entire process of using tools - from planning and creating to applying them in complex tasks. It emphasizes real-world complexities, demanding accurate, multi-step planning for effective problem-solving. A key feature of UltraTool is its independent evaluation of planning with natural language, which happens before tool usage and simplifies the task solving by mapping out the intermediate steps. Thus, unlike previous work, it eliminates the restriction of pre-defined toolset. Through extensive experiments on various LLMs, we offer novel insights into the evaluation of capabilities of LLMs in tool utilization, thereby contributing a fresh perspective to this rapidly evolving field. The benchmark is publicly available at https://github.com/JoeYing1019/UltraTool.	[ -0.5062178373336792, -0.8154183626174927, 0.4870203733444214, 0.4756871163845062, -0.3831539750099182, 0.3594505488872528, -0.2516423463821411, -0.5883282423019409, -0.024909328669309616, 0.5880680680274963, -0.5543681383132935, -0.5739051699638367, -0.060684505850076675, 0.070505291223526, -0.5059161186218262, 0.5177764296531677, -0.1068892776966095, -0.10168767720460892, -0.3127792179584503, -0.24767500162124634, -0.4894779622554779, -0.477783203125, -0.3169841468334198, -0.45029762387275696, 0.22487914562225342, 0.4173486530780792, 0.796076238155365, 0.5023699402809143, 0.5954422354698181, 0.3501060903072357, 0.10123980045318604, 0.3081985414028168, -0.36856406927108765, 0.30188116431236267, -0.10688477009534836, -0.1863146275281906, -0.5005866289138794, -0.14255869388580322, 0.546139121055603, 0.8470296263694763, -0.30379071831703186, 0.3263753056526184, 0.04476074501872063, 0.26846742630004883, -0.8091856837272644, -0.13432978093624115, -0.6793166399002075, 0.32406628131866455, -0.011448832228779793, -0.15931512415409088, -0.09168773889541626, -0.3455412983894348, 0.24529752135276794, -0.701934814453125, 0.14629749953746796, -0.1297626942396164, 0.39108675718307495, 0.17773717641830444, -0.30185237526893616, -0.12787114083766937, -1.1244970560073853, 0.6073697805404663, -0.7007547616958618, 0.462395042181015, -0.028340309858322144, 0.6051768064498901, -0.47487035393714905, -0.8752959370613098, -0.5700833797454834, -0.21588076651096344, 0.21536937355995178, 0.131137877702713, -0.13182328641414642, -0.019489062950015068, 0.3899162709712982, -0.04766995087265968, -0.4597373902797699, 0.14831791818141937, -0.10438058525323868, -0.3647666275501251, 0.6618872880935669, 0.5288895964622498, 0.1523105502128601, -0.036354660987854004, -0.4806295335292816, -0.1544121950864792, -0.7806011438369751, -0.051051221787929535, 0.05621863156557083, 0.24186363816261292, -0.001118237036280334, 0.7361406087875366, -0.23302099108695984, 0.4629979729652405, -0.7617794871330261, -0.30135229229927063, 0.1812313050031662, -0.40595242381095886, -0.6162755489349365, -0.23609969019889832, 0.6729670166969299, 0.5771194100379944, 0.37530913949012756, -0.22462362051010132, -0.4618995487689972, -0.23343154788017273, 0.3637888729572296, -0.7650193572044373, -0.022443238645792007, 0.07742873579263687, -0.1753511279821396, -0.23331895470619202, -0.19563624262809753, -0.7094440460205078, -0.743457555770874, -0.1464020311832428, 0.17135761678218842, -0.08680348098278046, -0.25486427545547485, -0.0003636961046140641, 0.1157408133149147, 0.2680199444293976, 0.2825644314289093, -0.125138521194458, 0.37890130281448364, 0.5907800197601318, 0.8176451921463013, -0.17663373053073883, -0.4335150122642517, -0.6040251851081848, 0.309433251619339, -0.6340869665145874, 1.1513975858688354, -0.4176076650619507, -0.8814823627471924, 0.1807161420583725, -0.15190692245960236, 0.35198020935058594, -0.9590362310409546, 0.7538802027702332, -0.2722187340259552, -0.3291258215904236, -0.1641986072063446, -0.4394954442977905, 0.07922658324241638, 0.28542646765708923, -0.5720834732055664, 1.4991251230239868, 0.05558277666568756, -0.19814527034759521, 0.6433818340301514, -0.6048620939254761, -0.4673685133457184, 0.3419646620750427, -0.21865572035312653, -0.289253294467926, 0.2549459934234619, -0.08418039977550507, 0.4942760169506073, -0.7012497186660767, 0.43216121196746826, -0.39996740221977234, -0.3965834379196167, 0.44018810987472534, -0.27421635389328003, 0.4606438875198364, 0.24749745428562164, -0.2789229154586792, 0.29789045453071594, -0.7128567695617676, 0.1665453463792801, 0.23147746920585632, -0.28848132491111755, -0.23852545022964478, -0.021685920655727386, 0.17123396694660187, 0.2540210783481598, 0.1414719521999359, -0.7111157178878784, 0.3518946170806885, -0.3631214201450348, 0.021804844960570335, 0.726731538772583, -0.04513132944703102, 0.18808260560035706, 0.0018755221972241998, 0.5540128946304321, -0.36489418148994446, 0.281000554561615, 0.1488218754529953, -0.12548202276229858, -0.6751351356506348, -0.08442509174346924, 0.13501481711864471, 0.5512425899505615, -0.5573062896728516, 0.30008941888809204, -0.20698894560337067, -0.8474075198173523, -0.002773601794615388, 0.18255271017551422, 0.469583123922348, 0.2931862771511078, 0.12597166001796722, -0.2622367739677429, -0.6394931077957153, -0.9558244347572327, -0.36148184537887573, -0.014537022449076176, -0.1812879741191864, 0.43914127349853516, 0.3607717752456665, -0.23289664089679718, 0.820148229598999, -0.5494341850280762, -0.07300601154565811, -0.5606048703193665, 0.19570738077163696, -0.05507379025220871, 0.25885650515556335, 0.30572137236595154, -0.5165421962738037, -0.5150083899497986, -0.045287199318408966, -0.9008802771568298, -0.36255717277526855, -0.23294652998447418, -0.3298928141593933, 0.0035497588105499744, 0.5562300682067871, -0.5137530565261841, 0.4637893736362457, 0.3683246374130249, -0.20369036495685577, 0.8907222747802734, -0.38250431418418884, -0.3752664029598236, -0.794710099697113, 0.2543080449104309, -0.1846393346786499, -0.16364316642284393, -0.5083006024360657, 0.1355009824037552, 0.10427561402320862, -0.22547340393066406, -0.6539619565010071, 0.7795211672782898, -0.6542813181877136, -0.5078722238540649, -0.21467944979667664, 0.2591106593608856, -0.15463823080062866, 0.1287236213684082, -0.2886255979537964, 1.1189690828323364, 0.4522072374820709, -0.5247719883918762, 0.5136839747428894, 0.07056038081645966, -0.44319164752960205, 0.402680367231369, -0.7237025499343872, 0.1845771223306656, 0.4910484254360199, 0.21198700368404388, -0.7132040858268738, -0.07471127808094025, -0.25745275616645813, -0.014096474274992943, -0.02328234165906906, -0.2826976776123047, -1.0882035493850708, -0.40548551082611084, -0.3629751205444336, 0.11722671985626221, 0.5079843997955322, -0.3216947317123413, 0.7988837361335754, 0.48975586891174316, 0.0020240508019924164, -0.3795921504497528, -0.4375295639038086, 0.3581677973270416, -0.08017071336507797, -0.38623976707458496, 0.2552656829357147, -0.17574435472488403, -0.3689591884613037, -0.06065302714705467, -0.6733286380767822, -0.11467442661523819, 0.22826464474201202, 0.28558382391929626, 0.29016250371932983, 0.058426111936569214, -0.029744798317551613, -0.08751149475574493, -0.2643588185310364, 0.15525706112384796, 0.06269513815641403, 0.7401660084724426, 0.08986713737249374, -0.43371888995170593, -0.18706011772155762, 0.24052636325359344, 0.6747931838035583, -0.3658253252506256, 0.2695384621620178, 0.36861342191696167, -0.3220132291316986, -0.4974357485771179, -0.77108234167099, 0.005070451647043228, -0.5217885375022888, 0.39738741517066956, -0.5055398941040039, -0.3268749415874481, 0.4724985957145691, -0.6578200459480286, 0.4229845404624939, 0.11718329042196274, 0.33486583828926086, -0.01823117397725582, 0.9980141520500183, 0.6736493110656738, 0.18758133053779602, 0.25397565960884094, -0.4196263253688812, 0.04452480748295784, -1.0944141149520874, -0.3539632260799408, -0.4478764533996582, -0.24802817404270172, -0.5173482894897461, -0.5947332382202148, 0.49408748745918274, 0.11805775761604309, 0.05957677215337753, 0.31528887152671814, -0.41871973872184753, 0.6363652348518372, 0.4167045056819916, -0.4917323589324951, 0.3750685751438141, -0.054235320538282394, -0.5745531320571899, 0.15527647733688354, -0.4404881000518799, -0.8287757635116577, 1.44505774974823, -0.11286475509405136, 0.5743932723999023, -0.2019912451505661, 0.777464747428894, 0.2279304563999176, 0.3041084408760071, -0.7600327134132385, 1.0876481533050537, 0.08680488914251328, -0.4979887008666992, -0.3002798855304718, -0.25107887387275696, -1.0879980325698853, 0.4797040820121765, -0.4536716043949127, -0.7241644859313965, -0.10519479960203171, -0.13608121871948242, -0.3134700059890747, 0.42233186960220337, -0.5815147757530212, 0.7940160632133484, -0.49702930450439453, -0.5829610228538513, -0.27744820713996887, -0.41549918055534363, -0.18282398581504822, -0.0924680083990097, 0.15222395956516266, -0.6008803248405457, -0.2907838225364685, 0.6270739436149597, -0.20918312668800354, 0.5310438871383667, -0.33078882098197937, 0.005166302900761366, 0.34040114283561707, 0.4869807958602905, 0.7049486041069031, 0.12184061855077744, -0.2624048888683319, -0.06424190104007721, 0.014905044808983803, -0.23141220211982727, -0.5411841869354248, 0.8490094542503357, -0.560401976108551, -0.36663520336151123, -0.36956992745399475, -0.7391654253005981, -0.5825493931770325, 0.5996398329734802, -0.16621649265289307, 0.7054816484451294, -0.7564054727554321, 0.22457902133464813, 0.32245564460754395, -0.2712348401546478, 0.6175042390823364, 0.7066681385040283, -0.3643353581428528, -0.044221557676792145, 0.6110992431640625, 0.29223790764808655, 0.09975852817296982, 0.02481052093207836, 0.23971690237522125, -0.2678428888320923, -0.941860020160675, -0.4662974774837494, 0.1209661141037941, -0.5587979555130005, -0.14867672324180603, -0.5956460237503052, 0.03089177794754505, -0.035086847841739655, -0.3473786413669586, -0.5226384997367859, -0.2974613308906555, 0.2933230400085449, -0.0775374174118042, -0.11805988848209381, 0.7684815526008606, 0.11125807464122772, 0.13040371239185333, -0.7802038788795471, 0.35352957248687744, 0.26011988520622253, 0.5616801381111145, -0.16610269248485565, 0.17361943423748016, -0.26680901646614075, -0.09787996858358383, -0.43288516998291016, -0.5671645402908325, 0.2563551366329193, 0.054378293454647064, 0.9618900418281555, 0.09512943029403687, 0.26746565103530884, 0.7050701379776001, -0.2666347324848175, 0.5593633055686951, -0.2047276347875595, -0.6025792956352234, 0.4229786694049835, -0.2757910490036011, 0.4660007059574127, 0.5981131792068481, 0.1279921531677246, -0.3018592298030853, -0.4556289613246918, -0.6628267168998718, -1.0913078784942627, 0.4994279146194458, 0.33229488134384155, 0.1427828073501587, 0.32353439927101135, 0.20453400909900665, 0.09526315331459045, 0.17908324301242828, -0.48843690752983093, -0.1556345522403717, 0.18365605175495148, 0.25455233454704285, 0.022213051095604897, -0.4159526824951172, -0.34061384201049805, -0.16488979756832123, 0.35273876786231995, -0.09750983864068985, 0.16397413611412048, 0.04204210266470909, -0.3412237763404846, -0.04440155252814293, 0.39610689878463745, 0.3837607502937317, 0.9823241829872131, -0.3090053200721741, 0.2090449333190918, 0.5288598537445068, -0.42455431818962097, -0.07706227153539658, 0.30248621106147766, 0.024332987144589424, -0.19157949090003967, 0.5106329917907715, 0.31482261419296265, 0.22974294424057007, -1.234075903892517, 0.15149343013763428, -0.015094221569597721, -0.04949703440070152, -0.29797616600990295, 0.12660817801952362, 0.21445885300636292, 0.2574409246444702, 0.31702542304992676, -0.17047233879566193, 0.37589845061302185, -0.5478780269622803, -0.08618678897619247, 0.45067915320396423, -0.32558104395866394, -0.2139919251203537, 0.2227262705564499, 0.48620855808258057, -0.34774553775787354, 0.5475959181785583, -0.3381768465042114, -0.21830303966999054, 0.5525763034820557, 0.6876040101051331, 1.084218978881836, 0.00480628851801157, 0.13769717514514923, 0.11179051548242569, 0.3008451461791992, 0.34602198004722595, 0.4817781448364258, -0.12187261134386063, -0.6694301962852478, -0.30332863330841064, -0.6495890617370605, -0.4985261559486389, 0.062024783343076706, -0.3362220227718353, 0.14555999636650085, -0.6342566609382629, -0.10147422552108765, -0.019145606085658073, 0.2166728675365448, -0.7591112852096558, 0.19013023376464844, -0.18630430102348328, 0.9610039591789246, -0.5568751692771912, 0.8242607712745667, 1.18113374710083, -0.09370721876621246, -0.7443927526473999, 0.10062037408351898, 0.3050331175327301, -0.8271756768226624, 0.22399139404296875, 0.18433819711208344, -0.4594496190547943, -0.2812192142009735, -0.21317343413829803, -0.6061526536941528, 1.1333653926849365, 0.25261804461479187, -0.44683074951171875, 0.23014529049396515, 0.43800532817840576, 0.669418454170227, -0.27511075139045715, 0.16797670722007751, 0.726180911064148, 0.4066484868526459, 0.17435859143733978, -1.1088345050811768, 0.19226223230361938, -0.2904147505760193, 0.021348265931010246, 0.6179295778274536, -0.2692825496196747, 0.5098652839660645, -0.18768498301506042, -0.32224521040916443, -0.02991127036511898, 0.1933944821357727, 0.29363200068473816, 0.47305062413215637, 0.6980089545249939, 0.4467052221298218, 0.41779428720474243, 0.023772871121764183, 1.001281499862671, -0.19537369906902313, 0.10058031231164932, 1.1300865411758423, -0.6756864190101624, 0.7950646281242371, 0.27563726902008057, -0.2658502459526062, 0.2711207866668701, 0.30159860849380493, 0.04514841362833977, 0.14012369513511658, 0.15407979488372803, -0.3393575847148895, -0.2931060194969177, -0.41206517815589905, -0.15914341807365417, 0.6080006957054138, 0.10145021229982376, 0.15379518270492554, -0.4037519097328186, -0.05941682308912277, 0.0828559398651123, 0.023160379379987717, 0.10234463214874268, 0.9942708611488342, -0.08405329287052155, -0.5219191908836365, 0.48006778955459595, -0.24333420395851135, 0.29761531949043274, -0.7146042585372925, 0.008767062798142433, -0.3510487675666809, 0.22444340586662292, -0.08097700774669647, -1.1166162490844727, 0.3637096583843231, 0.20836199820041656, 0.4526439905166626, -0.04733218997716904, 0.6269859671592712, 0.2664504051208496, -0.554278552532196, 0.5026739239692688, 0.7602185010910034, 0.03742007166147232, -0.20688116550445557, -0.6393578052520752, 0.10419360548257828, -0.14464840292930603, -0.3075540363788605, 0.2844420075416565, 0.6002873182296753, -0.250328928232193, 0.8989648818969727, 0.9039162397384644, 0.20674699544906616, -0.025838319212198257, 0.3584974408149719, 1.0320149660110474, -0.8351921439170837, -0.06862732768058777, -0.7184051275253296, 0.46205639839172363, -0.3511873185634613, -0.5247362852096558, 0.7771973013877869, 1.1047751903533936, 0.8242011666297913, 0.2587275505065918, 0.7410697340965271, -0.06490308791399002, 0.2916225492954254, -0.3052842915058136, 0.42813220620155334, -0.7682319283485413, 0.49194660782814026, -0.47947442531585693, -1.2344191074371338, -0.45103955268859863, 0.2593895494937897, -0.058443062007427216, -0.19280923902988434, 0.5566017627716064, 0.7120280265808105, -0.14838096499443054, -0.1307738572359085, 0.4945544898509979, 0.028419936075806618, 0.5791699886322021, 0.11718326807022095, 0.9876177310943604, 0.18251855671405792, 0.8426463007926941, -0.6075619459152222, -0.2802373170852661, -0.23105770349502563, -0.9634889364242554, -0.6674325466156006, -0.32808762788772583, 0.08361184597015381, 0.19633780419826508, -0.042491719126701355, 1.0583983659744263, 0.7123405933380127, -0.39322876930236816, -0.8345121145248413, -0.11190591752529144, -0.06774817407131195, -0.2854217290878296, -0.15094506740570068, 0.061913054436445236, -0.2235921025276184, -0.40305665135383606, 0.5698185563087463, 0.4989134967327118, 0.0681956559419632, -0.405291348695755, 0.14091899991035461, -0.07483161240816116, 0.2373753935098648, 0.7908816337585449, 0.2971542179584503, -0.6259695887565613, -0.010921891778707504, 0.10716947913169861, 0.13367784023284912, -0.03798438608646393, 1.1394147872924805, -0.7705824375152588, 0.8031229376792908, 0.4455680251121521, 0.3538114130496979, 0.7545150518417358, -0.20970508456230164, 0.614740788936615, -0.6192278265953064, 0.19130487740039825, 0.30418652296066284, 0.34495842456817627, 0.32981839776039124, -0.014741410501301289, 0.9476713538169861, -0.09921164810657501, -0.4903046488761902, -1.1517558097839355, 0.20803424715995789, -0.9699876308441162, -0.1832403540611267, 1.0129729509353638, 0.1113947406411171, 0.2810865044593811, -0.24997322261333466, -0.4330331087112427, 0.2874875068664551, -0.3847614526748657, 0.6325834393501282, 0.23261365294456482, -0.547958254814148, 0.18057061731815338, -0.8436326384544373, 0.23252978920936584, 0.28497257828712463, -0.9924112558364868, 0.44910505414009094, 0.5763416290283203, 0.1943185031414032, 0.0066352118737995625, 0.47668153047561646, -0.0005813832976855338, 0.10771039128303528, -0.08788610249757767, 0.22078999876976013, -0.3089664578437805, -0.44999271631240845, 0.28248295187950134, 0.12276148796081543, 0.41733255982398987, 0.17842639982700348 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01759v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01759v1	Systematic Literature Review: Computational Approaches for Humour Style Classification	2024-01-30T16:21:47	2024-01-30T16:21:47	Mary Ogbuka Kenneth, Foaad Khosmood, Abbas Edalat	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG	Understanding various humour styles is essential for comprehending the multifaceted nature of humour and its impact on fields such as psychology and artificial intelligence. This understanding has revealed that humour, depending on the style employed, can either have therapeutic or detrimental effects on an individual's health and relationships. Although studies dedicated exclusively to computational-based humour style analysis remain somewhat rare, an expansive body of research thrives within related task, particularly binary humour and sarcasm recognition. In this systematic literature review (SLR), we survey the landscape of computational techniques applied to these related tasks and also uncover their fundamental relevance to humour style analysis. Through this study, we unveil common approaches, illuminate various datasets and evaluation metrics, and effectively navigate the complex terrain of humour research. Our efforts determine potential research gaps and outlined promising directions. Furthermore, the SLR identifies a range of features and computational models that can seamlessly transition from related tasks like binary humour and sarcasm detection to invigorate humour style classification. These features encompass incongruity, sentiment and polarity analysis, ambiguity detection, acoustic nuances, visual cues, contextual insights, and more. The computational models that emerge contain traditional machine learning paradigms, neural network architectures, transformer-based models, and specialised models attuned to the nuances of humour. Finally, the SLR provides access to existing datasets related to humour and sarcasm, facilitating the work of future researchers.	[ -0.25599032640457153, -0.5138658881187439, 0.3327849209308624, 0.6262111663818359, -0.20066393911838531, 0.10550878196954727, -0.08450451493263245, -0.4093197286128998, 0.4811893701553345, 0.5029953718185425, -0.5377132892608643, -0.23803502321243286, -0.4588901400566101, 0.3028613328933716, -0.3340969979763031, 1.0630470514297485, 0.42291438579559326, 0.48904210329055786, -0.236106276512146, -0.19896665215492249, -0.2725517451763153, -0.6977595686912537, -0.5997925996780396, -0.25006088614463806, 0.765272855758667, 0.33827972412109375, 0.5740617513656616, -0.1423490047454834, 0.9118397831916809, 0.2925562858581543, -0.22772595286369324, -0.11680831015110016, -0.3301980793476105, 0.1307498812675476, -0.21105176210403442, -0.5300801396369934, -0.06682609021663666, -0.18818862736225128, 0.16233432292938232, 0.7351806163787842, -0.28218981623649597, 0.17963865399360657, -0.4032690227031708, 0.7388068437576294, -0.625206470489502, -0.08755305409431458, -0.3526986241340637, 0.3534589409828186, -0.39595893025398254, -0.24079187214374542, -0.4263504445552826, -0.5022180080413818, -0.1122056320309639, -0.14061197638511658, 0.08638831973075867, 0.13365623354911804, 0.18261365592479706, 0.24677474796772003, -0.3384702205657959, -0.40513288974761963, -0.8957920670509338, 0.5598007440567017, -0.7698432803153992, -0.022406769916415215, -0.21971096098423004, 0.6958389282226562, 0.17624861001968384, -0.8031305074691772, -0.5057747960090637, 0.07506325840950012, -0.29002851247787476, 0.003974970430135727, -0.09372977167367935, -0.08622319251298904, 0.5023787617683411, 0.25167614221572876, -0.6391237378120422, -0.344938725233078, -0.64030921459198, -0.17879511415958405, 0.9138170480728149, 0.28823718428611755, 0.46721184253692627, -0.5140842795372009, -0.022671986371278763, 0.02149735763669014, -0.3815576434135437, 0.33710867166519165, 0.4094713032245636, 0.08849814534187317, 0.10442612320184708, 0.2996867299079895, -0.18796123564243317, 0.29857099056243896, -0.03805534914135933, -0.49372974038124084, 0.3056519031524658, -0.24381275475025177, -0.03400922566652298, 0.11940722912549973, 0.9041188359260559, 0.019264061003923416, 0.322334349155426, -0.07243270426988602, -0.28182855248451233, 0.03405534103512764, 0.6422154307365417, -0.4125216007232666, -0.3281534016132355, -0.08105570077896118, -0.519221842288971, -0.6779932975769043, -0.01805950701236725, -0.6245218515396118, -0.6866323351860046, -0.3835550844669342, 0.022980641573667526, -0.3818412125110626, -0.4629868268966675, 0.001993592595681548, -0.6098778247833252, 0.28390541672706604, 0.4445169270038605, -0.3747839629650116, 0.40557751059532166, 0.8113440275192261, 0.7122793793678284, 0.03228341042995453, 0.12839889526367188, -0.11137811094522476, -0.2816659212112427, -0.3402286469936371, 0.6820505261421204, -0.6385434865951538, -0.007004871033132076, -0.03551843389868736, -0.1371958702802658, -0.18232733011245728, -0.4173557162284851, 0.9530772566795349, -0.5104484558105469, 0.03545861318707466, -0.16956868767738342, 0.08457966893911362, -0.42016473412513733, 0.14656227827072144, -0.8329008221626282, 0.8964149951934814, 0.2105356752872467, -1.4116175174713135, -0.06143686920404434, -0.679689884185791, -0.7643788456916809, -0.03427017480134964, -0.012038630433380604, -0.2079787254333496, 0.43952643871307373, 0.03572706878185272, 0.17107579112052917, -0.2998599410057068, 0.5766445994377136, -0.5805701017379761, -0.6392345428466797, 0.5978351831436157, -0.1236598789691925, 1.1612476110458374, 0.46920767426490784, -0.45641836524009705, 0.13789670169353485, -0.4311193525791168, -0.0091553945094347, 0.2183236926794052, 0.5288900136947632, -0.495242178440094, -0.05270871892571449, 0.27663472294807434, 0.5204324126243591, -0.1297130435705185, -0.3576323390007019, -0.1269749104976654, -0.5519850850105286, 0.8177158832550049, 0.33892592787742615, -0.04817032068967819, 0.12386907637119293, -0.3483574688434601, 0.6724936962127686, 0.01640288531780243, 0.5172762274742126, 0.07003188133239746, -0.3841574788093567, -0.5403652191162109, -0.07917248457670212, 0.4050642251968384, 0.8726983070373535, -0.8893733024597168, 0.36850449442863464, -0.27833324670791626, -0.6304835081100464, -0.5384160280227661, -0.36100485920906067, 0.2904260754585266, 0.44712793827056885, 0.13945883512496948, -0.6453972458839417, -0.42666560411453247, -0.9005028605461121, -0.3972662389278412, -0.16430766880512238, 0.20146791636943817, 0.44419559836387634, 0.3184322118759155, -0.12369932234287262, 0.9090794324874878, -0.28104549646377563, 0.23730610311031342, -0.358614057302475, 0.3488385081291199, 0.14379246532917023, 0.2278638780117035, 0.705421507358551, -0.9498022794723511, -0.2936941981315613, -0.003433967474848032, -0.8161917328834534, -0.33148157596588135, 0.02708437852561474, -0.0017390932189300656, 0.038030873984098434, 0.39461255073547363, -0.16618625819683075, 0.6376636028289795, -0.048162635415792465, 0.18527178466320038, 0.8954691886901855, 0.7139313220977783, 0.37099403142929077, -0.3620726764202118, 0.25470638275146484, -0.10181284695863724, -0.04859289526939392, -0.8115678429603577, 0.1035403460264206, -0.07385947555303574, -0.1555190235376358, -0.4436907172203064, 0.6214832663536072, -0.08699504286050797, -0.16775427758693695, 0.06574634462594986, -0.17184162139892578, -0.022606143727898598, 0.35911470651626587, -0.08539328724145889, 0.2853708863258362, 0.5495068430900574, -0.13259662687778473, 0.44281455874443054, -0.25789913535118103, 0.007413303479552269, 0.5623456239700317, -0.5912268757820129, 0.4238937199115753, -0.1183144599199295, 0.3358114957809448, -1.380309820175171, -0.3092711269855499, 0.5162206888198853, -0.5102702379226685, 0.5045082569122314, -0.18195556104183197, -0.7034267783164978, -0.5688473582267761, -0.6038579344749451, 0.7610654830932617, 0.46669986844062805, -0.19050069153308868, 0.722064197063446, 0.18507349491119385, -0.7584705948829651, -0.8015537261962891, -0.6166952252388, 0.07754386216402054, -0.5911014080047607, -0.8403308391571045, 0.16735737025737762, -0.14471043646335602, -0.6567050814628601, -0.3354605436325073, 0.04941853508353233, -0.1473771184682846, -0.105989471077919, 0.10026871412992477, 0.03843850642442703, -0.05131949111819267, -0.08531279116868973, 0.13644574582576752, 0.22099517285823822, 0.3332875967025757, 0.2775534689426422, 0.49058979749679565, 0.010339262895286083, -0.2940046489238739, -0.3431243300437927, 0.27607157826423645, 0.514115571975708, 0.004551806952804327, 0.1771419644355774, 0.9794090390205383, -0.08583778887987137, -0.12973932921886444, -0.8223384618759155, -0.06756351888179779, -0.4416796565055847, 0.011370380409061909, -0.08230096846818924, -0.7440999746322632, 0.49311402440071106, -0.11239710450172424, -0.260075181722641, 0.3407337963581085, 0.06700175255537033, -0.1796884536743164, 0.8713998198509216, 0.7214704751968384, -0.26682302355766296, 0.5306124091148376, 0.14594124257564545, 0.531476616859436, -0.6968514323234558, -0.0990888699889183, -0.6086763739585876, -0.5093681812286377, -0.45396384596824646, -0.22974465787410736, 0.5504962205886841, -0.10162020474672318, -0.1903313547372818, -0.14477218687534332, -0.622364342212677, 0.3445955216884613, 0.2480890303850174, 0.041604191064834595, 0.07394077628850937, 0.11686132103204727, -0.2741612493991852, -0.10441762953996658, -0.6296313405036926, -0.11050869524478912, 0.8368338942527771, 0.3531798720359802, 0.8814641833305359, 0.2073274552822113, 0.7122529745101929, 0.3587230443954468, 0.49776503443717957, -0.9369946718215942, 0.5546894073486328, -0.26904740929603577, -0.48143333196640015, -0.12090062350034714, -0.6069942116737366, -0.3610738515853882, -0.1457018107175827, 0.11668574064970016, -0.5718549489974976, 0.12850096821784973, -0.024926424026489258, -0.13058945536613464, 0.057527899742126465, -0.6314162611961365, 0.43129488825798035, -0.3690757751464844, -0.34985947608947754, -0.06239965185523033, -1.3680630922317505, 0.8190421462059021, 0.14058388769626617, 0.6185822486877441, 0.17518040537834167, 0.2860472500324249, 0.6823557615280151, -0.02439410425722599, 0.9534592032432556, -0.05816486105322838, 0.2704121470451355, 0.3062537908554077, 0.32881009578704834, -0.11067210882902145, 0.11407898366451263, -0.23473471403121948, 0.4029471278190613, 0.13499073684215546, -0.17757782340049744, -0.9169151782989502, 0.5099312663078308, -0.5169774293899536, -0.29663383960723877, -0.6779632568359375, -0.3972974121570587, -0.24447163939476013, -0.07864998281002045, 0.1778266280889511, 0.5115888714790344, -0.2027086466550827, -0.21557718515396118, 0.5046809911727905, -0.1318969428539276, 0.3819866478443146, 0.059484079480171204, -0.1539151668548584, -0.6942037343978882, 0.6858393549919128, -0.07043803483247757, 0.09388080984354019, 0.20768238604068756, 0.2047225683927536, -0.387741357088089, -0.4163070321083069, -0.1618846356868744, 0.6234861016273499, -0.8792531490325928, -0.08314506709575653, -0.5929188132286072, -0.5896486639976501, -0.9556240439414978, -0.24113820493221283, 0.11830365657806396, -0.7615493535995483, -0.0770283192396164, 0.38838016986846924, 0.4548773765563965, 1.122489094734192, -0.010995395481586456, 0.1960013210773468, -0.34471938014030457, -0.07487640529870987, 0.035951167345047, 0.31177350878715515, 0.1989085078239441, -0.41328805685043335, 0.31802505254745483, -0.46642452478408813, -0.33814215660095215, -1.0751374959945679, 0.5654832720756531, 0.06583449989557266, 0.2952755391597748, 0.5192374587059021, 0.11394698917865753, 0.6271114349365234, -0.540306568145752, 0.7390616536140442, 0.37696367502212524, -0.5828002691268921, 0.5387004613876343, -0.06754713505506516, -0.0072104898281395435, 0.6920560598373413, 0.8409222960472107, -0.8931319713592529, 0.035765934735536575, -0.7884560823440552, -0.6984621286392212, 0.7281246185302734, 0.22167722880840302, 0.010457856580615044, 0.02905517816543579, 0.5502810478210449, 0.06651022285223007, 0.5061809420585632, -0.5869287252426147, -0.23025617003440857, -0.26384997367858887, -0.2582140266895294, 0.08783551305532455, 0.013578253798186779, -0.4209098219871521, -0.4754372537136078, 0.3301546573638916, -0.3085348308086395, 0.3360353410243988, 0.1036650687456131, -0.15471988916397095, -0.03911897912621498, 0.44780686497688293, 0.3862862288951874, 0.5276743173599243, -0.16733549535274506, 0.1407165229320526, -0.060595035552978516, -0.4487435519695282, -0.22899530827999115, 0.0819234699010849, -0.13761849701404572, 0.25512436032295227, 0.32828035950660706, 0.41283565759658813, 0.3362346589565277, -0.7322511076927185, 0.5226559638977051, -0.22669923305511475, 0.11221250146627426, -0.5461705923080444, 0.20816200971603394, -0.1232394203543663, -0.0008207079372368753, 0.15411265194416046, 0.5304991006851196, 0.9448825716972351, -0.8229007720947266, 0.028405260294675827, 0.42588910460472107, -0.3661196231842041, -0.3974870443344116, -0.16449031233787537, -0.009115999564528465, -0.3729894161224365, 0.4574318826198578, -0.39805686473846436, -0.8491920232772827, 0.6714015007019043, 0.4109235107898712, 0.9736684560775757, -0.2478761374950409, 0.20451219379901886, 0.3667210638523102, 0.17446745932102203, 0.005973957013338804, 0.30090153217315674, 0.06306107342243195, -0.30338776111602783, -0.0037446338683366776, -0.7964422702789307, -0.4034270644187927, -0.16695483028888702, -0.4325648248195648, 0.5746141076087952, -0.636960506439209, -0.1130271777510643, 0.35002145171165466, -0.2040434628725052, -0.5392557382583618, 0.09610097855329514, 0.30944859981536865, 0.83315110206604, -0.8359864354133606, 0.15278509259223938, 0.8626726865768433, -0.30148831009864807, -0.5771083831787109, 0.047182150185108185, 0.6493096351623535, -0.42925944924354553, 0.5170797109603882, 0.20888680219650269, -0.43629932403564453, -0.3518066108226776, -0.9147404432296753, -0.6584388017654419, 0.8479716181755066, -0.07680647820234299, -0.3465922176837921, -0.11787115037441254, -0.0984654575586319, 0.8872567415237427, -0.5300714373588562, 0.9168599843978882, 0.5724759697914124, 0.27826350927352905, 0.8402430415153503, -1.0156540870666504, -0.10290699452161789, -0.6852632761001587, 0.0006989554385654628, 0.0947725847363472, -0.6281249523162842, 0.7690653800964355, -0.12200070917606354, -0.1852036565542221, -0.0008532172651030123, 0.20402400195598602, 0.2898959517478943, 0.8766590356826782, 0.555870532989502, 0.469652384519577, 0.5301738381385803, 0.0071890586987137794, 0.7767009735107422, -0.15772460401058197, 0.19961045682430267, 0.7857236862182617, -0.5160823464393616, 0.6925011873245239, 0.05786873400211334, -0.19524112343788147, 0.9020792245864868, 0.646067202091217, 0.24925021827220917, 0.290373295545578, 0.4734286963939667, 0.021165940910577774, 0.050937239080667496, -0.15312840044498444, -0.3841943144798279, 0.21406520903110504, 0.6421976089477539, -0.31733623147010803, 0.006938517093658447, -0.07927951216697693, 0.13636979460716248, -0.2743920087814331, -0.41427648067474365, 0.878964900970459, 0.17631880939006805, -0.46295246481895447, 0.3766029477119446, -0.0940857082605362, 1.0314809083938599, -0.4928959310054779, -0.023332927376031876, -0.07628680765628815, -0.17199920117855072, -0.531204342842102, -0.7003456950187683, 0.5156118273735046, -0.13260214030742645, 0.05458615720272064, 0.18997636437416077, 1.2330256700515747, 0.07729843258857727, -0.6461625099182129, 0.20795755088329315, 0.285071462392807, 0.2282087653875351, -0.05484249070286751, -0.917444109916687, 0.00690497225150466, -0.32102879881858826, 0.07736963778734207, 0.21831676363945007, 1.0503145456314087, -0.33812206983566284, 0.6192970871925354, 0.4150178134441376, 0.06673450022935867, -0.08645089715719223, 0.5261613726615906, 1.0874825716018677, -0.9984580874443054, -0.5639159083366394, -0.5514644384384155, 0.41216450929641724, -0.3401733934879303, -0.36253076791763306, 0.3624701201915741, 0.16761687397956848, 0.47722455859184265, -0.13620616495609283, 0.7449530363082886, -0.23118337988853455, 0.42304694652557373, -0.2082507461309433, 0.5590674877166748, -0.6757030487060547, 0.1286737322807312, -0.74560546875, -0.4891946017742157, -0.5679059028625488, 0.4453750252723694, -0.5785623788833618, 0.3646152913570404, 0.8937464356422424, 0.7772476077079773, -0.14790605008602142, 0.5531328916549683, -0.13950097560882568, 0.07135213166475296, -0.08565104007720947, 0.18401449918746948, 0.9966163039207458, 0.06621704995632172, 0.22338201105594635, -0.7440738677978516, -0.4497799575328827, -0.5758192539215088, -0.7325860261917114, -0.8763869404792786, -0.39616620540618896, -0.2586497664451599, -0.3075926899909973, -0.08755740523338318, 0.7848034501075745, 0.6136932373046875, -0.6367822289466858, -0.24143406748771667, 0.3752838969230652, 0.24842509627342224, -0.3634909391403198, -0.3787311017513275, -0.07569722086191177, -0.46817728877067566, 0.0002822697861120105, -0.0886722281575203, 0.516930341720581, -0.5877556800842285, -0.32915955781936646, 0.2418317198753357, -0.05665936321020126, 0.23921659588813782, 0.7296561002731323, 0.2482175976037979, -0.8565245866775513, 0.15906201303005219, 0.12881888449192047, -0.1340791881084442, -0.00527900829911232, 1.2794301509857178, -0.5051859021186829, 0.33579808473587036, 0.8031390309333801, 0.45706799626350403, 0.09333234280347824, 0.033994052559137344, -0.019020307809114456, -0.8418119549751282, -0.13025182485580444, 0.841300368309021, 0.3110957443714142, 0.510787844657898, -0.686306357383728, 0.8733158111572266, 0.5998404622077942, -0.4951837658882141, -0.9313496351242065, 0.14241760969161987, -1.3446013927459717, -0.3320353925228119, 1.0118218660354614, 0.18533553183078766, -0.5714117288589478, -0.2995178699493408, -0.3584708869457245, -0.05836303532123566, -0.2478855699300766, 0.8419703841209412, 0.6845014095306396, -0.6770519614219666, -0.191847026348114, -0.5644896030426025, 0.5015950202941895, 0.2138746678829193, -0.6820508241653442, -0.1735258847475052, 0.42426836490631104, 0.38207244873046875, 0.6539535522460938, 0.6788927316665649, -0.4560515284538269, 0.45677706599235535, -0.3280198872089386, 0.13016106188297272, 0.46087750792503357, -0.6764941811561584, -0.5871555209159851, 0.33418479561805725, -0.12740173935890198, 0.8727878928184509 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17139v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17139v1	Large Language Model Evaluation via Matrix Entropy	2024-01-30T16:19:55	2024-01-30T16:19:55	Lai Wei, Zhiquan Tan, Chenghai Li, Jindong Wang, Weiran Huang	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT	Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized the field of natural language processing, extending their strong capabilities into multi-modal domains. Thus, it is vital to define proper and diversified metrics for the evaluation of LLMs. In this paper, we introduce matrix entropy, a novel metric rooted in information theory and geometry principles to quantify the data compression proficiency in LLMs. It reflects the model's ability to extract relevant information and eliminate unnecessary elements, thereby providing insight into the language model's intrinsic capability. Specifically, we demonstrate its applicability in both single-modal (language) and multi-modal settings. For language models, our findings reveal that the matrix entropy of representations follows a scaling law type reduction when the model scales up, serving as a complement to the traditional loss scaling law. For the multi-modal setting, we also propose an evaluation method based on matrix entropy for assessing alignment quality and we find that modern large multi-modal models exhibit great alignment performance.	[ -0.25541970133781433, -0.5859647393226624, 0.6007938385009766, 0.16158385574817657, -0.303599089384079, 0.12006811052560806, -0.4970725476741791, -0.1925022304058075, 0.1765923649072647, 0.05803070589900017, -0.335894912481308, -0.5554221868515015, -0.7141379117965698, -0.0049849688075482845, -0.5229993462562561, 0.7247957587242126, -0.2670604884624481, 0.3047231137752533, -0.5610175132751465, -0.010352909564971924, -0.4306482672691345, -0.4484789967536926, -0.2778242230415344, -0.17958155274391174, 0.500106155872345, 0.018543895334005356, 0.636404275894165, 0.8879806399345398, 0.9802831411361694, 0.36651456356048584, 0.008500254712998867, -0.026203280314803123, -0.5266603827476501, 0.2950119972229004, 0.04940885305404663, -0.5137576460838318, -0.5408372282981873, -0.04372980818152428, 1.3068712949752808, 0.8238702416419983, -0.3504126965999603, 0.4365120232105255, 0.3089684545993805, 0.6564509272575378, -0.73623126745224, 0.19673457741737366, -0.5355634689331055, -0.030560586601495743, -0.30396324396133423, -0.36769136786460876, -0.3336835205554962, -0.4569489061832428, -0.1692550778388977, -0.5496103167533875, -0.247383713722229, 0.088060662150383, 0.6000782251358032, 0.5301074385643005, -0.5116310119628906, -0.13927742838859558, -0.8819409608840942, 0.7954453229904175, -0.5831902623176575, 0.7538133859634399, 0.2811765968799591, 0.376116007566452, -0.0031043398194015026, -0.3497700095176697, -0.6252846717834473, -0.22517773509025574, 0.2911333739757538, -0.09975706785917282, -0.39214593172073364, 0.008220088668167591, -0.05792425572872162, 0.5500724911689758, -0.6862557530403137, 0.26159965991973877, -0.3471421003341675, -0.34305113554000854, 0.46725642681121826, 0.5080169439315796, 0.42030543088912964, 0.06250422447919846, -0.3950408399105072, -0.13565582036972046, -0.45428064465522766, 0.05257727950811386, 0.5116428732872009, 0.18816855549812317, -0.2135431468486786, 0.6439738273620605, 0.030108733102679253, 0.8615893721580505, -0.25852662324905396, -0.6337652802467346, 0.14291751384735107, -0.40081101655960083, -0.2415742129087448, -0.1532672792673111, 0.7719626426696777, 0.15760040283203125, -0.034931279718875885, -0.3266933560371399, -0.18133758008480072, 0.0769745260477066, 0.17814503610134125, -0.6349125504493713, 0.09928200393915176, 0.01386567484587431, -0.6071228384971619, -0.11972770094871521, 0.12098591774702072, -0.5188175439834595, -0.6497891545295715, -0.5070082545280457, 0.41419386863708496, -0.34943240880966187, -0.2734605669975281, 0.31821009516716003, -0.08470554649829865, 0.16962939500808716, 0.3906008005142212, -0.6087340116500854, 0.14438559114933014, 1.0781891345977783, 0.9890598058700562, -0.21549376845359802, -0.3376437723636627, -0.28205806016921997, 0.0726681798696518, -0.35662132501602173, 0.6818587183952332, -0.8920405507087708, 0.12824958562850952, -0.2847038805484772, -0.3618966341018677, -0.2084498554468155, -0.32465100288391113, 0.3957386314868927, -0.589642345905304, -0.06272652000188828, 0.04303691163659096, -0.5769438147544861, -0.2747201919555664, 0.4078877866268158, -0.7572283148765564, 0.7399909496307373, 0.08888742327690125, -0.6657483577728271, 0.5044530630111694, -0.39020419120788574, -0.2451293170452118, -0.06789030879735947, -0.03795225918292999, -0.24193264544010162, 0.42160260677337646, -0.2436719834804535, 0.4483592212200165, -0.815384566783905, 0.298220694065094, -0.7492277026176453, -0.19734908640384674, 0.4670964777469635, -0.6756286025047302, 0.46449655294418335, 0.30917036533355713, 0.23935063183307648, -0.003097116481512785, -0.9147622585296631, 0.09742249548435211, -0.12989665567874908, -0.854290246963501, -0.40757519006729126, -0.09908588975667953, -0.0588410347700119, 0.17445647716522217, 0.4826749265193939, -0.4576207995414734, 0.42400211095809937, -0.1472838670015335, 0.23039238154888153, 0.7698793411254883, -0.27526146173477173, 0.552498996257782, -0.19628764688968658, 0.6496044993400574, -0.12463688850402832, 0.02293986640870571, 0.16426938772201538, -0.19181540608406067, -0.5853866934776306, -0.7593420743942261, 0.5240232348442078, 0.5908266305923462, -0.4773228168487549, 0.5583913922309875, -0.7260158061981201, -0.6871103644371033, -0.5457158088684082, 0.5129935145378113, 0.17899979650974274, 0.08186982572078705, -0.055531349033117294, -0.47305312752723694, -0.6101595163345337, -0.8963781595230103, -0.23759333789348602, -0.24964380264282227, -0.17501311004161835, 0.024935077875852585, 0.33701708912849426, -0.12482721358537674, 0.772266685962677, -0.18752118945121765, 0.06707215309143066, -0.14627127349376678, 0.18968459963798523, 0.2566453814506531, 0.5289432406425476, 0.15536805987358093, -0.33142685890197754, -0.1662428379058838, 0.037565115839242935, -0.7650682330131531, -0.0737772136926651, 0.07979709655046463, 0.04751023277640343, 0.043586451560258865, 0.3085421323776245, -0.5982916951179504, 0.3296913504600525, 0.681882381439209, -0.36367174983024597, 0.43601226806640625, -0.1264549344778061, 0.15840333700180054, -1.1366329193115234, 0.3516605496406555, 0.10118421912193298, -0.25385189056396484, -0.671161413192749, 0.12827502191066742, 0.1321668177843094, -0.014415566809475422, -0.18190713226795197, 0.3167002499103546, -0.4951673448085785, -0.3416077196598053, -0.1774265468120575, -0.08499079942703247, 0.014079384505748749, 0.25860926508903503, -0.15326537191867828, 0.6017204523086548, 0.6371362805366516, -0.6187984347343445, 0.4872397482395172, -0.2194453477859497, -0.7836400270462036, 0.7979073524475098, -0.36680325865745544, 0.08767642825841904, -0.35516607761383057, 0.16229218244552612, -1.0410264730453491, -0.017410513013601303, -0.1267240047454834, -0.34753841161727905, 0.5765928030014038, -0.05034014210104942, -0.7194151282310486, -0.2589513957500458, -0.34259915351867676, 0.693714439868927, 0.09966938197612762, -0.18144036829471588, 0.4580564498901367, 0.5034402012825012, 0.00553899398073554, -0.6435598731040955, -0.5378659963607788, 0.30077511072158813, -0.5477114319801331, -0.7081618905067444, 0.00608243839815259, -0.32732734084129333, -0.4988875985145569, -0.29639407992362976, -0.04066256433725357, -0.1565171778202057, 0.3172975182533264, 0.07323729991912842, 0.1731889545917511, -0.4717952311038971, 0.2817395031452179, -0.25231635570526123, 0.023440031334757805, -0.02266697585582733, -0.25938284397125244, 0.8079378604888916, -0.3963022828102112, -0.4016769826412201, -0.6153891086578369, 0.1604798138141632, 0.8494160771369934, -0.10034063458442688, 0.8208394646644592, 0.7625828981399536, -0.4141239523887634, 0.22647970914840698, -0.5783491730690002, 0.0020463080145418644, -0.4073360860347748, 0.5169687271118164, -0.25171568989753723, -0.8903940916061401, 0.6598155498504639, -0.01750447228550911, -0.19487319886684418, 0.44780638813972473, 0.7202430963516235, 0.20195640623569489, 1.151174783706665, 0.8078064322471619, -0.30323636531829834, 0.3607943058013916, -0.06222477927803993, 0.3677619993686676, -1.0362788438796997, -0.2819283902645111, -0.6645260453224182, -0.5315420031547546, -0.4029557704925537, -0.5887609720230103, 0.5810185670852661, 0.3855218291282654, -0.46618565917015076, 0.27114200592041016, -0.21738657355308533, 0.37481021881103516, 0.3503727912902832, -0.06596683710813522, 0.3524825870990753, 0.07078362256288528, -0.001140204374678433, 0.04645109921693802, -0.563737690448761, -0.592186450958252, 0.9953016638755798, 0.7339178323745728, 1.080372929573059, 0.4832959473133087, 0.43683090806007385, 0.24484258890151978, 0.26514339447021484, -1.0354582071304321, 0.4205295145511627, 0.11449256539344788, -0.40111055970191956, -0.40338242053985596, -0.7772971987724304, -0.9430882334709167, 0.12136982381343842, -0.14512032270431519, -1.0221689939498901, 0.10752792656421661, -0.10789600759744644, -0.33399704098701477, 0.5155240893363953, -0.5673142671585083, 0.642953097820282, -0.15392322838306427, -0.17265500128269196, -0.31120145320892334, -0.354630708694458, 0.4941128194332123, -0.24439984560012817, 0.19296513497829437, -0.15806050598621368, -0.40087994933128357, 0.8879198431968689, -0.30835336446762085, 0.6401100754737854, 0.11520903557538986, -0.35802215337753296, 0.0628664642572403, 0.538956880569458, 0.22316193580627441, -0.000022388960132957436, -0.16637669503688812, 0.3905552327632904, 0.173038512468338, -0.14737239480018616, -0.7330531477928162, 0.6238648891448975, -0.7214588522911072, -0.3806796669960022, -0.12125344574451447, -0.9611595869064331, -0.18670788407325745, 0.11462004482746124, 0.032511547207832336, 0.42877262830734253, -0.16132541000843048, 0.51640385389328, 0.37803414463996887, -0.24152372777462006, 0.41442570090293884, 0.5656227469444275, -0.10891325771808624, -0.3683028519153595, 0.9869837760925293, 0.13024742901325226, 0.1591050624847412, 0.5382561087608337, 0.2902074456214905, -0.1911274492740631, -0.566493809223175, -0.351130872964859, 0.05625063180923462, -0.8490708470344543, -0.5878757238388062, -0.37965476512908936, -0.11136224120855331, -0.4732798635959625, 0.12825147807598114, -0.4026011526584625, -0.5284448862075806, -0.1513916701078415, 0.14178237318992615, 0.10424677282571793, 0.8857988715171814, -0.26587536931037903, 0.12681837379932404, -0.6923810243606567, -0.11135540157556534, 0.22475376725196838, 0.6532466411590576, 0.05773679167032242, -0.6859170198440552, -0.3925991952419281, -0.10637427866458893, -0.35116493701934814, -0.7210942506790161, 0.3670540153980255, 0.29458168148994446, 0.6387823224067688, 0.6474814414978027, -0.24148212373256683, 0.547591507434845, -0.3712014853954315, 0.7004117965698242, 0.39638620615005493, -1.1209430694580078, 0.09071222692728043, -0.2584531307220459, 0.40074509382247925, 0.40569964051246643, 0.19874350726604462, -0.554928183555603, -0.4125067889690399, -0.2046670913696289, -0.6206244230270386, 0.33721041679382324, -0.004650040529668331, 0.0973091647028923, 0.2151510864496231, 0.23879607021808624, 0.12474944442510605, 0.24275000393390656, -0.8445178866386414, -0.06806401908397675, 0.12202169001102448, -0.38086485862731934, -0.07977508753538132, -0.1556122601032257, -0.01392565667629242, -0.39896830916404724, 0.4166284501552582, -0.037045709788799286, 0.4572829008102417, -0.15550142526626587, -0.3267473876476288, -0.15661002695560455, 0.4646374583244324, 0.9969016909599304, 0.8919286727905273, -0.1731596440076828, 0.4900147020816803, 0.24148429930210114, -0.417066752910614, 0.1911335587501526, -0.10160407423973083, 0.40479081869125366, -0.4002152681350708, 0.5529770255088806, 0.7145514488220215, 0.05830110237002373, -0.41681692004203796, 0.4308158755302429, -0.16081450879573822, 0.16753007471561432, 0.10051612555980682, -0.10775631666183472, -0.137904554605484, 0.3303000330924988, 0.28316429257392883, 0.03018667921423912, 0.17831552028656006, -0.5286985635757446, 0.03859998658299446, 0.6614351272583008, -0.42168325185775757, -0.4620671570301056, 0.2552471160888672, -0.23846718668937683, -0.1408986747264862, 0.42391112446784973, 0.0033432049676775932, -0.4281637668609619, 0.4330419898033142, 0.5789148807525635, 0.7802347540855408, -0.3772008717060089, -0.06941721588373184, 0.3976481258869171, 0.6486366391181946, 0.0028460959438234568, 0.06871446222066879, -0.11447995156049728, -0.7402190566062927, -0.5001623034477234, -0.863745391368866, -0.032670389860868454, 0.20453403890132904, -0.6464779376983643, 0.07526549696922302, -0.36694493889808655, -0.18366815149784088, -0.008759367279708385, -0.07845566421747208, -0.8785268664360046, -0.1785653680562973, 0.47065064311027527, 0.7952383756637573, -0.7665064930915833, 0.736305832862854, 0.4909142553806305, -0.25124186277389526, -0.6065653562545776, -0.16253241896629333, 0.24288339912891388, -1.0824311971664429, 0.746139407157898, 0.11854918301105499, -0.26810911297798157, -0.3352956771850586, -0.53862464427948, -1.2929514646530151, 0.9736081957817078, 0.9357017278671265, -0.3951062262058258, 0.11622685194015503, 0.2525925934314728, 0.5987538695335388, -0.39934274554252625, 0.24119898676872253, 0.5952842831611633, 0.6137454509735107, -0.15419572591781616, -1.2337931394577026, 0.041406743228435516, -0.3826664984226227, 0.06676267087459564, 0.33918172121047974, -0.3141990602016449, 0.8604726791381836, 0.06521209329366684, -0.36242353916168213, -0.008639683946967125, 0.6446427702903748, -0.03786669671535492, 0.1129075288772583, 0.5139656066894531, 0.8060024976730347, 0.936820387840271, 0.08329538255929947, 1.1411138772964478, -0.6579248905181885, 0.4317387640476227, 0.8013736009597778, -0.1882013976573944, 0.9362037181854248, 0.42514902353286743, -0.14184100925922394, 0.5706282258033752, 0.4678637385368347, 0.23123034834861755, 0.21009279787540436, 0.5508226156234741, -0.21973009407520294, -0.4255170226097107, -0.24191072583198547, -0.2741210162639618, 0.8056822419166565, 0.3940957188606262, -0.3682158291339874, -0.29441314935684204, -0.009054728783667088, 0.1010269746184349, -0.14618104696273804, -0.41885873675346375, 0.9114760756492615, -0.008104413747787476, -0.5389525294303894, 0.7761550545692444, 0.15151873230934143, 0.45865049958229065, -0.4431803226470947, 0.24630339443683624, -0.012630466371774673, 0.11830909550189972, -0.08267367631196976, -0.8340660929679871, 0.30717965960502625, 0.02294519729912281, -0.3437410891056061, -0.13004232943058014, 0.45907455682754517, -0.4497278034687042, -0.6724896430969238, -0.00016471870185341686, 0.32147079706192017, 0.30797135829925537, 0.06453622132539749, -0.5547782778739929, 0.34391966462135315, -0.4569109082221985, -0.17584584653377533, 0.351096510887146, 0.3786226809024811, 0.2552279829978943, 0.7703503966331482, 0.37801873683929443, 0.18834234774112701, -0.04493466764688492, -0.07810233533382416, 0.6969585418701172, -0.49215975403785706, -0.29928866028785706, -1.1361596584320068, 0.25606006383895874, 0.057435426861047745, -0.22099633514881134, 0.8890195488929749, 0.8307222723960876, 0.43300384283065796, 0.28340840339660645, 0.58528733253479, 0.18980860710144043, 0.14748604595661163, -0.6897589564323425, 0.7061242461204529, -0.5879518389701843, 0.3662826418876648, -0.32652390003204346, -1.094181776046753, -0.4909392297267914, 0.545728325843811, -0.2893962860107422, 0.014911796897649765, 0.7063826322555542, 0.8548219203948975, -0.2533091604709625, -0.30457204580307007, 0.48115184903144836, 0.09158644825220108, 0.12227585166692734, 0.6555607914924622, 1.00046968460083, -0.251881867647171, 0.446715384721756, 0.09122435748577118, -0.282808393239975, -0.04094427824020386, -0.9766536355018616, -0.661159336566925, -0.9632741808891296, -0.20424118638038635, -0.5145407915115356, -0.49921566247940063, 0.9607869982719421, 0.8114230632781982, -0.42877674102783203, -0.47764119505882263, 0.3324577808380127, 0.2724047303199768, -0.06753912568092346, -0.20112991333007812, 0.3650483787059784, -0.23168358206748962, -0.46480968594551086, 0.5620280504226685, 0.6360985636711121, -0.12137875705957413, -0.704239547252655, -0.1149805560708046, -0.0854586586356163, 0.32281753420829773, 0.6418216228485107, 0.06918514519929886, -0.6258229613304138, -0.26542261242866516, -0.1772170066833496, -0.3029586672782898, 0.1807950735092163, 1.0123430490493774, -0.36217981576919556, 0.5520453453063965, 0.8690328598022461, 0.6425269246101379, -0.016883518546819687, -0.29337456822395325, 0.7643142938613892, -0.6890387535095215, -0.03936976194381714, 0.0523003488779068, 0.5648075938224792, 0.4558670222759247, -0.30012747645378113, 0.2851579785346985, 0.06382735073566437, -0.48616477847099304, -1.108988881111145, 0.20594246685504913, -1.0239412784576416, -0.09924519807100296, 1.3079010248184204, 0.01827775500714779, -0.4149458706378937, 0.046608973294496536, 0.1340193748474121, 0.28428083658218384, -0.19469976425170898, 0.9087000489234924, 0.8613927364349365, 0.25838983058929443, -0.21417315304279327, -0.4149790406227112, 0.2251916229724884, 0.3362548053264618, -0.7692651152610779, 0.11365096271038055, 0.44120800495147705, 0.20282118022441864, 0.32753807306289673, 0.30646926164627075, -0.04978896304965019, 0.004764729179441929, -0.21589195728302002, 0.2709381878376007, 0.09429115802049637, -0.3507882058620453, -0.8450297117233276, 0.20010671019554138, 0.20852182805538177, 0.20021173357963562 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17099v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17099v1	MT-Ranker: Reference-free machine translation evaluation by inter-system ranking	2024-01-30T15:30:03	2024-01-30T15:30:03	Ibraheem Muhammad Moosa, Rui Zhang, Wenpeng Yin	cs.CL	cs.CL, I.2.7	Traditionally, Machine Translation (MT) Evaluation has been treated as a regression problem -- producing an absolute translation-quality score. This approach has two limitations: i) the scores lack interpretability, and human annotators struggle with giving consistent scores; ii) most scoring methods are based on (reference, translation) pairs, limiting their applicability in real-world scenarios where references are absent. In practice, we often care about whether a new MT system is better or worse than some competitors. In addition, reference-free MT evaluation is increasingly practical and necessary. Unfortunately, these two practical considerations have yet to be jointly explored. In this work, we formulate the reference-free MT evaluation into a pairwise ranking problem. Given the source sentence and a pair of translations, our system predicts which translation is better. In addition to proposing this new formulation, we further show that this new paradigm can demonstrate superior correlation with human judgments by merely using indirect supervision from natural language inference and weak supervision from our synthetic data. In the context of reference-free evaluation, MT-Ranker, trained without any human annotations, achieves state-of-the-art results on the WMT Shared Metrics Task benchmarks DARR20, MQM20, and MQM21. On a more challenging benchmark, ACES, which contains fine-grained evaluation criteria such as addition, omission, and mistranslation errors, MT-Ranker marks state-of-the-art against reference-free as well as reference-based baselines.	[ -0.3257206678390503, -0.3307588994503021, 0.5517233610153198, 0.3047141432762146, -0.565359890460968, 0.08481363952159882, -0.2685701549053192, -0.37977755069732666, 0.27568161487579346, 0.37337249517440796, -0.1062353253364563, -0.3928946852684021, -0.9841938614845276, 0.3211071491241455, -0.360638827085495, 1.2012741565704346, -0.1910528987646103, 0.1632336676120758, -0.6927647590637207, -0.492509663105011, -0.5433890223503113, -0.672799289226532, -0.2918541729450226, -0.42112967371940613, 0.6468674540519714, 0.3421388566493988, 0.8818299770355225, 0.7909756898880005, 1.0423660278320312, 0.2715582549571991, 0.08233101665973663, 0.2710016071796417, -0.3232421576976776, 0.28827324509620667, 0.017539968714118004, -0.3770234286785126, -0.6163191199302673, 0.39123034477233887, 0.6886141896247864, 0.7195640206336975, 0.19025781750679016, 0.5241656303405762, 0.05731715261936188, 0.8220551609992981, -0.3426731526851654, 0.07568433880805969, -0.6939737796783447, -0.09171278774738312, -0.18145659565925598, -0.4599933624267578, -0.5521363019943237, -0.4513985812664032, -0.17715133726596832, -0.42745375633239746, 0.0715838298201561, 0.3343207836151123, 0.8942888379096985, 0.5845208764076233, -0.6191850304603577, 0.09944301843643188, -0.6090860962867737, 0.7939354777336121, -0.35969218611717224, 0.3084146976470947, 0.552696704864502, 0.5738413333892822, 0.11894793808460236, -0.28123992681503296, -0.20823416113853455, -0.4137547016143799, -0.17653922736644745, 0.35504448413848877, -0.12135163694620132, -0.16966842114925385, -0.028701985254883766, 0.4815254509449005, -0.426063597202301, -0.11937685310840607, -0.5225618481636047, 0.09701569378376007, 0.474834144115448, 0.04663096368312836, 0.04765258729457855, -0.2810840606689453, -0.5491014122962952, -0.2122928947210312, -0.6394513845443726, -0.24695754051208496, 0.2612026333808899, 0.4037351906299591, -0.01637735776603222, 0.5704618692398071, -0.12094924598932266, 0.42468929290771484, -0.004627772141247988, 0.21026045083999634, 0.275785356760025, -0.1671438217163086, -0.15543122589588165, -0.1940702199935913, 1.1746655702590942, 0.7373068332672119, 0.08794775605201721, -0.7733970284461975, -0.37992462515830994, -0.00432608462870121, 0.41964903473854065, -0.6773641109466553, -0.17433969676494598, 0.0470113568007946, -0.47993147373199463, -0.5585204362869263, 0.24384082853794098, -0.4614635109901428, -0.10123858600854874, -0.35668930411338806, 0.877201497554779, -0.1977161169052124, -0.0067421249113976955, -0.5077224969863892, -0.14527258276939392, -0.07699599862098694, 0.12551426887512207, -0.4537377953529358, 0.25576651096343994, 0.46378573775291443, 0.8488398194313049, -0.5739424228668213, -0.23508353531360626, -0.8491412997245789, 0.167805477976799, -0.560203492641449, 0.7680752277374268, -0.3635340929031372, -0.43793055415153503, -0.29699042439460754, -0.10913997888565063, -0.07072612643241882, -0.8260006904602051, 0.8607791662216187, -0.4503526985645294, 0.40955209732055664, -0.24811509251594543, -0.3105939030647278, 0.01736823469400406, 0.16506540775299072, -0.4649812579154968, 1.2516083717346191, 0.1821325123310089, -0.5132858753204346, 0.37056681513786316, -0.6114180684089661, -0.3683161437511444, 0.19154895842075348, 0.26336899399757385, -0.3685133755207062, 0.19517302513122559, 0.10215189307928085, 0.2505198121070862, -0.5739646553993225, 0.5560996532440186, -0.33389946818351746, -0.59248286485672, 0.17854470014572144, -0.3760055899620056, 0.43825778365135193, 0.20163455605506897, -0.1336098313331604, 0.3465273976325989, -0.46889179944992065, 0.1558961421251297, 0.1305834800004959, -0.2615118622779846, -0.6087552309036255, -0.1537693291902542, -0.20302227139472961, 0.3856565058231354, 0.15949556231498718, -0.3731469511985779, 0.24367105960845947, -0.12321892380714417, 0.171822190284729, 0.7209295034408569, -0.053698476403951645, 0.4125784635543823, -0.38238972425460815, 0.32442334294319153, -0.16279999911785126, 0.32231804728507996, 0.2082739770412445, -0.565430760383606, -1.0419763326644897, 0.006951162591576576, 0.6150986552238464, 0.6494998335838318, -0.984856128692627, 0.5376444458961487, -0.7186257839202881, -0.3837546706199646, -0.9706027507781982, 0.1864849328994751, 0.8374205827713013, 0.2844258248806, 0.8249415755271912, -0.23623239994049072, -0.369788259267807, -0.9611133933067322, -0.47041475772857666, -0.1273791790008545, -0.15236422419548035, -0.052863262593746185, 0.3371785283088684, 0.012795453891158104, 0.5694132447242737, -0.25632554292678833, -0.4883718192577362, -0.17131415009498596, 0.07592212408781052, 0.20721027255058289, 0.7262496948242188, 0.26958274841308594, -0.651849627494812, -0.4926876425743103, -0.21504636108875275, -0.9943028092384338, -0.32731178402900696, 0.20065677165985107, -0.440932959318161, -0.12689858675003052, 0.4435380697250366, -0.24888306856155396, 0.06099393963813782, 0.7441011071205139, -0.11463728547096252, 0.35972392559051514, -0.5511640906333923, 0.42914149165153503, -1.122244119644165, 0.26682206988334656, 0.01922561414539814, -0.22923080623149872, -0.4524115025997162, 0.3855504095554352, 0.10186932235956192, 0.03418374061584473, -0.08729320019483566, 0.5166723132133484, -0.19149890542030334, 0.05626744404435158, -0.13432946801185608, 0.40054020285606384, 0.0952361524105072, 0.4846372902393341, -0.3959970474243164, 0.7530531287193298, -0.09069176763296127, -0.35266220569610596, 0.11191850155591965, 0.2615927457809448, -0.06659585982561111, 0.7174400091171265, -0.59678053855896, 0.39600348472595215, 0.05792020633816719, 0.04261293634772301, -0.8458993434906006, 0.15967245399951935, 0.34291738271713257, -0.6081292629241943, 0.26765182614326477, -0.417198121547699, -0.7370837330818176, -0.21807333827018738, -0.27916833758354187, 0.3754991292953491, 0.3296389579772949, -0.41666993498802185, -0.17658135294914246, 0.27153876423835754, 0.01240657176822424, -0.39370429515838623, -0.604250967502594, 0.3646058738231659, -0.17186345160007477, -0.22786042094230652, 0.3796229660511017, -0.21084968745708466, -0.27862751483917236, 0.11716395616531372, -0.38067248463630676, -0.07965673506259918, 0.08704914152622223, 0.4188624322414398, 0.5495668649673462, -0.06847339123487473, 0.0225530918687582, 0.23680828511714935, -0.6955189108848572, -0.037682995200157166, -0.21095184981822968, 0.10240522027015686, -0.1781768500804901, -0.39729416370391846, -0.3856733441352844, 0.3846580982208252, 0.7176914215087891, -0.32882341742515564, 0.7505596876144409, 0.5248011946678162, -0.0875382274389267, 0.3545530140399933, -0.520370602607727, 0.19105218350887299, -0.3958112597465515, -0.03699138015508652, -0.5713239908218384, -0.47995632886886597, -0.029148424044251442, 0.040945593267679214, -0.002984272548928857, 0.6362069249153137, 0.11434679478406906, -0.13825492560863495, 1.195375680923462, 0.3503679037094116, 0.046472638845443726, 0.3347710967063904, -0.16015078127384186, 0.1762842833995819, -1.0559064149856567, -0.26123538613319397, -0.5611506700515747, -0.4482397437095642, -0.669225811958313, -0.488189160823822, 0.6417492628097534, 0.33236488699913025, -0.03808164224028587, 0.5664106011390686, -0.5048430562019348, 0.5124082565307617, 0.8232833743095398, -0.004591666627675295, 0.5850502252578735, -0.1623612344264984, -0.6419016718864441, -0.18208743631839752, -0.3269892632961273, -0.7479997277259827, 1.1791056394577026, -0.11811015754938126, -0.024424569681286812, 0.17404763400554657, 0.7373502850532532, 0.6025387048721313, 0.7867518067359924, -0.7487603425979614, 0.4719557762145996, -0.2488202154636383, -0.4956858158111572, 0.03350410982966423, -0.8046262860298157, -0.879227876663208, 0.739214301109314, -0.43714791536331177, -0.4101410508155823, -0.3137766122817993, 0.01035644207149744, 0.06787559390068054, 0.15650400519371033, -0.8684410452842712, 0.967162549495697, -0.21356643736362457, -0.41424939036369324, -0.12654070556163788, -0.8464257717132568, 0.323959618806839, -0.05769364535808563, 0.3584405481815338, -0.30372628569602966, 0.08229998499155045, 0.8181136250495911, -0.3237057328224182, 0.07890880852937698, -0.25611406564712524, 0.3138052225112915, -0.12766295671463013, 0.32767775654792786, 0.1972907930612564, -0.18090742826461792, -0.3594983220100403, 0.23137429356575012, 0.28180959820747375, -0.4838321805000305, -0.5016339421272278, 0.7537805438041687, -0.7930566668510437, -0.503530740737915, -0.29328086972236633, -0.5264400839805603, -0.3873559534549713, 0.417301744222641, 0.20620276033878326, 0.27995535731315613, -0.10104537010192871, 0.2983168661594391, 0.07856573909521103, -0.05783059448003769, 0.09030640870332718, 0.43388065695762634, -0.4001631736755371, -0.8472525477409363, 1.0921220779418945, 0.0917917937040329, 0.32114356756210327, 0.817169189453125, 0.2525336742401123, -0.23185141384601593, -0.5789759755134583, -0.6732234954833984, 0.26110661029815674, -0.5614113211631775, -0.41668543219566345, -0.4092460572719574, 0.055222343653440475, 0.03921813517808914, 0.030270610004663467, -0.31023159623146057, -0.6870253682136536, 0.4510980546474457, -0.036337438970804214, 0.03164457529783249, 0.7380076050758362, 0.13303911685943604, 0.2782074511051178, -0.8277456164360046, 0.44645166397094727, 0.019295718520879745, 0.46395143866539, -0.2683066725730896, -0.40866175293922424, -0.44434767961502075, 0.005639543291181326, -0.45631155371665955, -0.5181363821029663, 0.3238988518714905, -0.1707410365343094, 0.6189978122711182, 0.16744667291641235, 0.32683899998664856, 0.8330430388450623, -0.5118939280509949, 0.5205339193344116, 0.044736675918102264, -0.9528478384017944, 0.3698306679725647, -0.1960262805223465, 0.15477699041366577, 0.7822378277778625, 0.16152167320251465, -0.5807812213897705, -0.655404806137085, -0.45130568742752075, -0.8710908889770508, 0.7282583713531494, 0.5403960347175598, -0.2227533757686615, 0.06131020560860634, 0.2812201678752899, 0.24534618854522705, 0.2925281524658203, -0.6182994842529297, -0.5714555382728577, -0.16255776584148407, -0.2377910017967224, -0.4350545406341553, -0.03388199582695961, -0.12177473306655884, -0.38434121012687683, 0.7731871008872986, 0.13569708168506622, 0.4154864549636841, -0.007997087202966213, -0.5019741654396057, -0.3355879783630371, 0.23915502429008484, 0.3247881233692169, 0.32949233055114746, -0.6066967248916626, 0.4010043144226074, 0.08242310583591461, -0.12634751200675964, 0.15548358857631683, 0.07975021004676819, -0.3157244026660919, 0.1524195671081543, 0.1922726333141327, 0.670648992061615, 0.23763582110404968, -0.19022198021411896, 0.6458420753479004, 0.0731077566742897, -0.16680334508419037, 0.04901374131441116, -0.3720982074737549, -0.0345296710729599, -0.06611118465662003, 0.47400057315826416, 0.6082103848457336, 0.015529758296906948, -0.14735066890716553, 0.08356130123138428, 0.3577982485294342, -0.8808107376098633, -0.4390682280063629, 0.9141123294830322, 0.3207603096961975, -0.37842175364494324, 0.3579977750778198, -0.446847140789032, -0.44120562076568604, 0.20794060826301575, 0.4350350797176361, 0.8814795613288879, -0.24871818721294403, -0.020742041990160942, 0.26805174350738525, 0.5403821468353271, -0.020421363413333893, -0.21810303628444672, -0.16988761723041534, -0.34580403566360474, -0.30485835671424866, -0.6327437162399292, -0.7157682776451111, -0.07407466322183609, -0.977747917175293, 0.1851608157157898, -0.08115123957395554, -0.14714230597019196, -0.1555047631263733, 0.0749824047088623, -0.47234493494033813, 0.15988607704639435, -0.10770236700773239, 0.5612419843673706, -0.5821141600608826, 0.9983131289482117, 0.7230942249298096, -0.5895459055900574, -0.28569942712783813, 0.1429838091135025, -0.04112216457724571, -0.7063149213790894, 0.49902644753456116, 0.4027113914489746, -0.27934372425079346, 0.0007040260825306177, 0.08033023774623871, -0.7213713526725769, 0.9643071889877319, 0.572708010673523, 0.09721381217241287, 0.02926620841026306, 0.0925511047244072, 0.5479318499565125, -0.0010574894258752465, 0.48650941252708435, 0.17987960577011108, 0.4895947575569153, -0.19445957243442535, -1.069972276687622, 0.20032085478305817, -0.6112980842590332, -0.032881177961826324, 0.5959870219230652, -0.7347315549850464, 0.32595294713974, -0.012880797497928143, -0.11362732946872711, 0.2806246280670166, 0.18869058787822723, -0.19115464389324188, 0.32429900765419006, 0.4502025842666626, 0.4747462868690491, 0.4017065763473511, -0.24715366959571838, 1.092696189880371, -0.4085538387298584, 0.3316866457462311, 0.9198409914970398, 0.04173366352915764, 1.1712843179702759, 0.55826336145401, -0.3475547134876251, 0.44986242055892944, 0.2370051145553589, 0.09806286543607712, 0.45767831802368164, 0.018336327746510506, 0.022328007966279984, -0.45253533124923706, -0.09209580719470978, -0.4416355490684509, 0.2983838617801666, -0.006447433494031429, -0.4150681495666504, -0.041674453765153885, -0.2912054657936096, -0.017192471772432327, 0.1662767380475998, 0.09599028527736664, 0.7432789206504822, 0.20767462253570557, -0.8515230417251587, 0.8269786238670349, 0.20854850113391876, 0.4814780354499817, -0.3969949185848236, 0.10518705099821091, -0.2683781087398529, 0.2279137372970581, -0.057679057121276855, -0.4855213463306427, 0.43224257230758667, 0.12639982998371124, -0.23894409835338593, -0.6580071449279785, 0.1619778871536255, -0.37952324748039246, -0.41425737738609314, 0.3718647360801697, 0.8807316422462463, 0.41756078600883484, -0.24419881403446198, -0.4002482295036316, -0.1329500824213028, -0.2966422438621521, 0.12281951308250427, 0.6250429749488831, 0.29139572381973267, -0.22106806933879852, 0.615676760673523, 0.8225102424621582, -0.08480376750230789, -0.15973004698753357, 0.0324128232896328, 0.5218968987464905, -0.6748785376548767, -0.10205818712711334, -0.7547552585601807, 0.17217206954956055, -0.12427597492933273, -0.1884760856628418, 0.6843571662902832, 0.7960271239280701, 0.6565262675285339, 0.1322871595621109, 0.570391058921814, 0.15045617520809174, 0.6092394590377808, -0.2604135274887085, 0.702861487865448, -0.671157956123352, 0.23683075606822968, -0.4716295897960663, -1.05516517162323, -0.6562997102737427, 0.2963467240333557, -0.4600512385368347, -0.1745675504207611, 0.9345982074737549, 0.3446047306060791, -0.06541392207145691, -0.2966378927230835, 0.4396415948867798, -0.1036534383893013, 0.14645648002624512, 0.44538021087646484, 0.7953268885612488, -0.8085495829582214, 1.1263790130615234, -0.34049251675605774, -0.18575972318649292, -0.32924529910087585, -0.7959722280502319, -0.7010186314582825, -0.5188560485839844, -0.15719543397426605, -0.2627600431442261, 0.12975889444351196, 1.1771446466445923, 0.6200741529464722, -0.7749876379966736, -0.3364776074886322, 0.23520037531852722, 0.3167334496974945, -0.5841763615608215, -0.19964414834976196, 0.258120596408844, -0.34937337040901184, -0.8901767134666443, 0.5794959664344788, 0.41133344173431396, -0.12814830243587494, 0.14949676394462585, -0.24794143438339233, 0.049114685505628586, -0.21339978277683258, 0.6819524168968201, -0.25123903155326843, -0.7697431445121765, -0.26623061299324036, -0.07650420814752579, -0.24567940831184387, 0.3854050040245056, 0.5549700260162354, -0.7717825174331665, 0.6072337031364441, 0.17657500505447388, 0.40259259939193726, 0.4170624315738678, 0.2801777124404907, 0.6247586607933044, -0.7006794810295105, -0.07120818644762039, -0.05326065048575401, 0.35995426774024963, 0.5163365602493286, 0.13446466624736786, 0.5335066914558411, 0.47159433364868164, -0.5354262590408325, -0.9464969038963318, -0.015210987068712711, -1.089300513267517, 0.14563694596290588, 1.008634090423584, -0.14041879773139954, 0.21607309579849243, 0.0899210199713707, -0.1578478366136551, 0.4804774522781372, -0.4433840215206146, 0.8139632940292358, 0.4211385250091553, 0.04293086379766464, 0.17004750669002533, -0.7320157289505005, 0.11427532881498337, 0.5230104327201843, -0.741546094417572, -0.2189149409532547, 0.13638892769813538, 0.1523558646440506, 0.17131811380386353, 0.23763617873191833, -0.3029577434062958, -0.10639933496713638, -0.043853405863046646, -0.015935732051730156, -0.38115832209587097, -0.11068171262741089, -0.11638843268156052, 0.2660033404827118, 0.3428344130516052, -0.5070544481277466 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17093v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17093v1	StrokeNUWA: Tokenizing Strokes for Vector Graphic Synthesis	2024-01-30T15:20:26	2024-01-30T15:20:26	Zecheng Tang, Chenfei Wu, Zekai Zhang, Mingheng Ni, Shengming Yin, Yu Liu, Zhengyuan Yang, Lijuan Wang, Zicheng Liu, Juntao Li, Nan Duan	cs.CV	cs.CV, cs.CL	To leverage LLMs for visual synthesis, traditional methods convert raster image information into discrete grid tokens through specialized visual modules, while disrupting the model's ability to capture the true semantic representation of visual scenes. This paper posits that an alternative representation of images, vector graphics, can effectively surmount this limitation by enabling a more natural and semantically coherent segmentation of the image information. Thus, we introduce StrokeNUWA, a pioneering work exploring a better visual representation ''stroke tokens'' on vector graphics, which is inherently visual semantics rich, naturally compatible with LLMs, and highly compressed. Equipped with stroke tokens, StrokeNUWA can significantly surpass traditional LLM-based and optimization-based methods across various metrics in the vector graphic generation task. Besides, StrokeNUWA achieves up to a 94x speedup in inference over the speed of prior methods with an exceptional SVG code compression ratio of 6.9%.	[ -0.7498931884765625, -0.5529147386550903, 0.5875464677810669, -0.059362590312957764, -0.67476487159729, 0.19177354872226715, 0.037117525935173035, -0.6350815296173096, 0.6166303157806396, 0.541894257068634, -0.7051003575325012, -0.4570351243019104, -0.5989115238189697, 0.07786015421152115, -0.4415990114212036, 0.4615704417228699, -0.05593344196677208, 0.13462060689926147, -0.1759682446718216, -0.16070368885993958, -0.4921719431877136, -0.1646747589111328, -0.4841606914997101, -0.3594900965690613, 0.7882327437400818, 0.13533741235733032, 0.5978407263755798, 0.6124638915061951, 0.4711723029613495, 0.38390833139419556, 0.21921633183956146, 0.2232869267463684, -0.6415894627571106, 0.23427006602287292, 0.1917176991701126, -0.3404920995235443, -0.13758248090744019, -0.12952998280525208, 0.339126318693161, 0.5139238834381104, 0.5763283967971802, -0.023252667859196663, -0.21985426545143127, 0.805005669593811, -0.7286288142204285, -0.009599159471690655, -0.5578902959823608, 0.28246837854385376, -0.19549092650413513, -0.3951863646507263, -0.19018301367759705, -0.5812841057777405, -0.024828854948282242, -1.0028952360153198, 0.08673527836799622, 0.08815598487854004, 0.8569908142089844, 0.28451621532440186, -0.2386876791715622, 0.21821492910385132, -0.47730904817581177, 0.7187480926513672, -0.48298391699790955, 0.20100687444210052, -0.08859247714281082, 0.6695641279220581, -0.4421353340148926, -1.2680416107177734, -0.5594624280929565, 0.1416957974433899, 0.441403865814209, 0.25648704171180725, -0.14838658273220062, 0.2906765341758728, 0.3492600619792938, 0.12270371615886688, -0.12113068997859955, 0.14869222044944763, -0.35736390948295593, -0.45722696185112, 0.6066265106201172, 0.304800808429718, 0.625158429145813, -0.3752802312374115, -0.746024489402771, -0.24873894453048706, -0.8845471739768982, -0.26163017749786377, 0.3981521725654602, 0.038267865777015686, 0.004382144194096327, 0.671780526638031, -0.0967990830540657, 0.8267079591751099, -0.5407024621963501, -0.04384789988398552, 0.028317052870988846, -0.15798212587833405, -0.28909796476364136, 0.005438848864287138, 0.624822199344635, 0.8749483823776245, 0.19269920885562897, 0.029730111360549927, -0.07670314610004425, 0.34668371081352234, 0.19224315881729126, -0.8936768770217896, -0.27930834889411926, 0.10850194096565247, -0.6851071119308472, -0.2478596270084381, 0.20577570796012878, -0.8174472451210022, -0.3935377299785614, -0.3614773750305176, 0.43337342143058777, -0.5409072637557983, -0.17991429567337036, 0.10233639180660248, -0.8891631364822388, 0.6109638810157776, 0.6963146924972534, -0.4038258194923401, 0.00036355681368149817, 0.7199466228485107, 1.0357110500335693, -0.4547346830368042, -0.12472571432590485, -0.37642306089401245, 0.23318195343017578, -0.6676037311553955, 1.055748462677002, -0.26231446862220764, -0.681950032711029, -0.19293911755084991, -0.25298261642456055, 0.5885949730873108, -0.216953307390213, 0.2855791449546814, -0.3701411485671997, -0.22321075201034546, -0.6733522415161133, -0.49611136317253113, -0.33861249685287476, -0.22845464944839478, -0.6627152562141418, 0.8886241912841797, 0.10454730689525604, -0.8695785999298096, 0.6986802816390991, -0.3279706537723541, -0.40976905822753906, 0.27235710620880127, -0.48107147216796875, -0.21986225247383118, 0.3071950078010559, 0.2043953686952591, 0.37446683645248413, -0.29989293217658997, -0.12196321040391922, -0.46467554569244385, -0.5152599215507507, 0.33485427498817444, -0.2778393030166626, 0.3906802535057068, 0.20164212584495544, -0.14743831753730774, 0.45220696926116943, -0.8302746415138245, 0.20358039438724518, 0.13866910338401794, 0.06705106794834137, -0.471102774143219, -0.29414448142051697, 0.25983569025993347, 0.29452642798423767, 0.07492093741893768, -0.707735002040863, 0.11722996830940247, -0.5252458453178406, 0.4888262152671814, 0.9781075119972229, 0.21221648156642914, 0.2750966250896454, -0.3251773715019226, 0.29295113682746887, -0.23500797152519226, 0.16815845668315887, -0.1923828423023224, -0.9250416159629822, -1.0945608615875244, -0.6119639277458191, 0.2527357041835785, -0.14514650404453278, -1.18667733669281, 0.35159096121788025, -0.41777360439300537, -0.23798726499080658, -0.44751808047294617, -0.32884854078292847, -0.09199726581573486, 0.5831747651100159, 0.22236725687980652, -0.5666212439537048, -0.7913777828216553, -0.9167407155036926, -0.042836375534534454, 0.12017544358968735, -0.2421533316373825, -0.1297990381717682, 0.4271406829357147, -0.1403898000717163, 0.7982946038246155, -0.6746006011962891, -0.22082962095737457, -0.38763168454170227, 0.27756762504577637, 0.07782556116580963, 0.2500309348106384, 0.4012487828731537, -0.3335675001144409, -0.4762328267097473, -0.03735674172639847, -0.5579233169555664, -0.13156892359256744, -0.052706096321344376, -0.5435184836387634, 0.054798003286123276, 0.642514169216156, -0.2882046103477478, 1.0611501932144165, 0.26301243901252747, -0.11325244605541229, 0.28824716806411743, -0.19043606519699097, 0.12137094885110855, -0.7341461181640625, 0.05392098054289818, -0.299313485622406, -0.464985191822052, -0.45243439078330994, -0.05707067996263504, -0.3363001048564911, -0.08754368871450424, -0.39510828256607056, 0.45712268352508545, -0.5744121074676514, -0.47140562534332275, -0.6558957695960999, -0.03517160192131996, -0.0951787531375885, 0.48413488268852234, 0.10051453858613968, 0.6859009265899658, 0.6659684777259827, -0.4745003879070282, 0.24850958585739136, 0.23431441187858582, -0.3599866032600403, 0.6859669089317322, -0.843051016330719, 0.16397322714328766, -0.2866770923137665, 0.3079614043235779, -1.2146855592727661, -0.35022974014282227, 0.16278913617134094, -0.15201470255851746, 0.05148579552769661, -0.012385925278067589, -0.12906557321548462, -0.2327030748128891, -0.7949286699295044, 0.25498682260513306, 0.7816959023475647, -0.8077468276023865, 0.8430042862892151, 0.5220767855644226, 0.32942622900009155, -0.2361316829919815, -0.9808585047721863, 0.23780573904514313, -0.020702192559838295, -0.6211926937103271, 0.44971606135368347, 0.28566253185272217, -0.007371654734015465, 0.008402450941503048, 0.03237398713827133, 0.2933453917503357, -0.3156168758869171, 0.4428294897079468, 0.4062105417251587, 0.008686678484082222, -0.311453640460968, 0.05860528722405434, -0.47544968128204346, -0.15690673887729645, -0.2541292607784271, 0.3901931941509247, 0.4531312584877014, -0.6267910003662109, -0.3146495521068573, 0.26534008979797363, 0.3852345049381256, 0.15855981409549713, 0.17265398800373077, 0.7516205906867981, -0.15906071662902832, -0.5330976247787476, -0.26305636763572693, -0.14879998564720154, -0.515914261341095, 0.10061509162187576, -0.34605634212493896, -0.7821092009544373, 0.4616372883319855, -0.3547469675540924, 0.10043139010667801, 0.5088393092155457, 0.4423816502094269, 0.04810718446969986, 0.8356901407241821, 0.4624039828777313, 0.42092373967170715, 0.5211196541786194, -0.6771655678749084, 0.03206690773367882, -0.9740971922874451, -0.38367682695388794, -0.1562042385339737, -0.7534119486808777, -0.6069104075431824, -0.935122549533844, 0.7648311853408813, -0.40411508083343506, 0.05839373171329498, 0.037788424640893936, -0.7417047023773193, 0.4642489552497864, 0.6508495807647705, 0.28865891695022583, 0.048380713909864426, 0.23372438549995422, -0.2607406675815582, -0.2145884782075882, -0.8106959462165833, -0.27582764625549316, 0.9910314083099365, 0.0818062573671341, 0.8793209791183472, -0.2044152170419693, 0.7275983095169067, 0.12648674845695496, 0.20918139815330505, -0.994114875793457, 0.8035992383956909, -0.07321304827928543, -0.09467604756355286, -0.22031372785568237, -0.25987786054611206, -1.171697974205017, 0.3659921884536743, -0.48895347118377686, -0.5436843037605286, 0.12472356110811234, -0.24420574307441711, -0.07296836376190186, 0.46111562848091125, -0.5624849796295166, 0.5571685433387756, 0.02243584394454956, -0.3801997900009155, -0.1831275373697281, -0.6615298390388489, 0.4015345871448517, 0.20719867944717407, -0.001455947756767273, -0.39819276332855225, -0.5294679999351501, 0.7185033559799194, -0.9416409730911255, 0.8351617455482483, 0.026831693947315216, 0.1913190484046936, 0.5252382159233093, 0.14814534783363342, 0.1550704836845398, -0.27917906641960144, 0.4274289309978485, 0.25442349910736084, -0.13638795912265778, -0.2971654534339905, -0.7036813497543335, 0.9149426221847534, -0.68599933385849, -0.2770337164402008, -0.3859594166278839, -0.3226321339607239, -0.155528724193573, 0.27715709805488586, 0.44453078508377075, 0.6010581254959106, -0.27396804094314575, -0.21022488176822662, 0.21434925496578217, -0.31549501419067383, 0.5456767678260803, -0.30080100893974304, -0.5116948485374451, -0.7454416751861572, 1.0088508129119873, 0.17675940692424774, 0.06626330316066742, 0.2188701033592224, 0.2201768457889557, -0.41566145420074463, -0.7887378334999084, -0.37666818499565125, 0.20223528146743774, -1.0448334217071533, -0.47021833062171936, -0.3765552341938019, -0.028515782207250595, 0.04161106050014496, -0.4202597737312317, -0.19171562790870667, -0.9569591283798218, -0.26131415367126465, 0.007841240614652634, 0.6647278070449829, 1.1641699075698853, -0.16302022337913513, 0.2700933814048767, -0.4343649744987488, 0.6655121445655823, 0.3476366698741913, 0.4996311366558075, 0.24852386116981506, -0.12320030480623245, 0.16485100984573364, -0.5251877903938293, -0.13528527319431305, -0.7849317193031311, 0.3606676459312439, -0.005181914195418358, 0.32241183519363403, 0.1778859794139862, -0.259243369102478, 1.052808165550232, -0.46171635389328003, 0.9425932168960571, 0.8132513761520386, -0.7040938138961792, 0.3202460706233978, -0.09483198821544647, 0.508643627166748, 0.3916424512863159, 0.08109616488218307, -0.38009119033813477, -0.3472491502761841, -0.5376938581466675, -1.0386582612991333, 0.20062020421028137, 0.1868676394224167, 0.0752805769443512, -0.0006258542416617274, 0.2164754867553711, 0.3743400573730469, -0.07529865205287933, -0.126252681016922, -0.1970915049314499, -0.44461870193481445, -0.18747884035110474, 0.23493868112564087, -0.2824755907058716, -0.05510258674621582, -0.4054470360279083, 0.46615949273109436, -0.26908349990844727, 0.4805222749710083, 0.3355327844619751, 0.1795652061700821, 0.053525667637586594, -0.47909578680992126, 0.35888737440109253, 0.6176421046257019, 0.37793105840682983, 0.3523186147212982, -0.03503040224313736, -0.40923601388931274, 0.15790928900241852, -0.27963048219680786, -0.34746918082237244, 0.34405404329299927, 0.5951017141342163, 0.9949068427085876, 0.35055699944496155, -0.3604092597961426, 0.4445180296897888, -0.2402515411376953, -0.24921219050884247, -0.054706159979104996, 0.2424841970205307, 0.03941810131072998, -0.16436339914798737, 0.20179463922977448, 0.12427087873220444, 0.34299615025520325, -0.04979550093412399, 0.2953900098800659, 0.6170839667320251, -0.2108888477087021, -0.2572196125984192, 0.824192464351654, 0.40416425466537476, 0.08107927441596985, 0.2954699695110321, 0.18025055527687073, -0.19008177518844604, 0.43606802821159363, 0.16618850827217102, 1.1095690727233887, 0.17887187004089355, 0.14454896748065948, 0.44057050347328186, -0.025402367115020752, 0.07928641140460968, 0.6064330339431763, 0.09648153185844421, -0.4233945310115814, -0.6075469255447388, -0.5175186395645142, -0.39551231265068054, -0.2859457731246948, -0.17969147861003876, 0.6842440962791443, -0.8392421007156372, -0.4938947856426239, 0.08337941765785217, -0.4964072108268738, -0.4983326196670532, -0.033613171428442, 0.15856489539146423, 0.894022524356842, -0.48295819759368896, 0.5424090623855591, 0.3949865996837616, -0.495302677154541, -0.5172440409660339, -0.27869901061058044, -0.2444532811641693, -0.8460403680801392, 0.5486953258514404, 0.1518549919128418, -0.44745033979415894, -0.009541451930999756, -0.6572465300559998, -0.6284337639808655, 0.8881562948226929, 0.49748918414115906, -0.24538446962833405, 0.31684044003486633, 0.3294426500797272, 0.31213855743408203, -0.2539345324039459, 0.11084078997373581, 0.310526967048645, 0.5359872579574585, 0.828242838382721, -0.2921876907348633, 0.2125084400177002, 0.14588376879692078, 0.7894172072410583, 0.12152183055877686, -0.44569775462150574, 0.5784109830856323, -0.09557219594717026, -0.36400163173675537, 0.24001134932041168, 1.0752549171447754, 0.008626307360827923, -0.030361350625753403, 0.26326483488082886, 0.5156976580619812, 0.6124417781829834, -0.29932618141174316, 1.1336923837661743, -0.11233553290367126, -0.09384909272193909, 0.663063108921051, 0.08541788160800934, 0.42274710536003113, 0.8148584961891174, -0.07903938740491867, 0.4799109101295471, 0.5575697422027588, 0.24539142847061157, 0.5974759459495544, 0.3310489058494568, -0.31352677941322327, -0.239684596657753, -0.14203311502933502, -0.24368882179260254, 0.44454625248908997, 0.1433456540107727, -0.10797372460365295, -0.2421833872795105, 0.0435912162065506, -0.20845533907413483, 0.0678432285785675, -0.5223082304000854, 0.7845751047134399, 0.3285706341266632, -0.2850647568702698, 0.7670785188674927, -0.029027732089161873, 0.8095220327377319, -0.7185796499252319, -0.4105431139469147, 0.013959357514977455, -0.26621899008750916, -0.17995601892471313, -0.8748013377189636, 0.39031982421875, -0.3205009698867798, 0.5875772833824158, -0.11368095129728317, 1.2637628316879272, -0.08644463121891022, -0.5868731141090393, 0.03151900693774223, 0.3407013714313507, 0.16071905195713043, 0.2612934112548828, -0.5893429517745972, 0.8239095211029053, -0.24404612183570862, -0.03273862972855568, 0.08688703179359436, 0.521938681602478, 0.00341568305157125, 0.5877639055252075, 0.6887367963790894, 0.2139708697795868, 0.14661072194576263, 0.1415809690952301, 0.9948471784591675, -0.6230658292770386, -0.6363255381584167, -0.7131048440933228, 0.2272244244813919, -0.3269692063331604, -0.19494949281215668, 0.9165836572647095, 0.38743966817855835, 0.5238980054855347, -0.26181113719940186, 1.0879579782485962, 0.16184371709823608, -0.17196005582809448, -0.8675618767738342, 0.43563419580459595, -0.3948743939399719, -0.3740105926990509, -0.34956619143486023, -0.7856234908103943, -0.5420147180557251, 0.8112879395484924, -0.19837762415409088, -0.013215826824307442, 0.49326738715171814, 0.5475108623504639, -0.08412469178438187, 0.11017326265573502, 0.5743794441223145, -0.20333172380924225, 0.29085448384284973, 0.3905574679374695, 1.0584317445755005, -0.25586727261543274, 0.08531060814857483, -0.030964192003011703, -0.060635045170784, -0.14515875279903412, -1.12952721118927, -1.0502134561538696, -0.507585883140564, -0.3515941798686981, -0.38662052154541016, -0.27165931463241577, 0.7976166009902954, 0.6220887303352356, -0.5006223917007446, -0.23345640301704407, -0.3189835548400879, 0.3363962471485138, -0.02843165025115013, -0.14466288685798645, 0.227749764919281, -0.14642229676246643, -0.6322752237319946, 0.11859072744846344, 0.6846484541893005, 0.4011439085006714, -0.722375750541687, -0.05223683640360832, 0.2933428883552551, 0.29161062836647034, 0.6222822666168213, 0.24089016020298004, -0.5379190444946289, -0.48820215463638306, -0.29489004611968994, 0.06974244862794876, 0.27166277170181274, 1.130334734916687, -0.8231910467147827, 0.6357587575912476, 0.9430096745491028, 0.5034302473068237, 0.9005380272865295, -0.2341981828212738, 0.6897183656692505, -0.4934511184692383, 0.5952235460281372, -0.04706506058573723, 0.4319906234741211, 0.6336867809295654, -0.007574389688670635, 0.4016813635826111, 0.38414114713668823, 0.023358475416898727, -0.5031805634498596, 0.4698784053325653, -1.198826551437378, -0.4280935525894165, 1.064622402191162, 0.31171873211860657, -0.9453912377357483, -0.07807227969169617, -0.6174519062042236, 0.2278812974691391, -0.1656361222267151, 0.316864013671875, 0.2669205963611603, -0.26375770568847656, 0.187788188457489, -0.3273963928222656, 0.7219735383987427, -0.2192467600107193, -0.6508084535598755, -0.2250465601682663, 0.7733864188194275, 0.11878853291273117, -0.16193567216396332, 1.0051223039627075, -0.22081127762794495, 0.18543179333209991, 0.24242965877056122, 0.13755150139331818, -0.34244629740715027, -0.16154935956001282, -0.15475574135780334, 0.1655469834804535, 0.1547384262084961, -0.30170387029647827 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17092v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17092v1	NNOSE: Nearest Neighbor Occupational Skill Extraction	2024-01-30T15:18:29	2024-01-30T15:18:29	Mike Zhang, Rob van der Goot, Min-Yen Kan, Barbara Plank	cs.CL	cs.CL	The labor market is changing rapidly, prompting increased interest in the automatic extraction of occupational skills from text. With the advent of English benchmark job description datasets, there is a need for systems that handle their diversity well. We tackle the complexity in occupational skill datasets tasks -- combining and leveraging multiple datasets for skill extraction, to identify rarely observed skills within a dataset, and overcoming the scarcity of skills across datasets. In particular, we investigate the retrieval-augmentation of language models, employing an external datastore for retrieving similar skills in a dataset-unifying manner. Our proposed method, \textbf{N}earest \textbf{N}eighbor \textbf{O}ccupational \textbf{S}kill \textbf{E}xtraction (NNOSE) effectively leverages multiple datasets by retrieving neighboring skills from other datasets in the datastore. This improves skill extraction \emph{without} additional fine-tuning. Crucially, we observe a performance gain in predicting infrequent patterns, with substantial gains of up to 30\% span-F1 in cross-dataset settings.	[ -0.3352484703063965, -0.22502020001411438, 0.3099593222141266, -0.09816767275333405, -0.1328410655260086, -0.00022428388183470815, -0.2149002104997635, -1.0353041887283325, 0.6594290137290955, 0.5204014182090759, -0.6404892206192017, -0.5620002746582031, -0.6312143802642822, 0.35786986351013184, -0.5364720225334167, 0.7434791326522827, 0.4729134440422058, -0.30461370944976807, -0.3131409287452698, -0.06770716607570648, -0.3489425480365753, -0.14755947887897491, -0.7480356097221375, 0.008996760472655296, 0.34476780891418457, 0.7728840708732605, 0.4544205963611603, 0.9044090509414673, 0.46035036444664, 0.3887430429458618, 0.0015845343004912138, 0.3879886567592621, -0.4617379307746887, 0.25110340118408203, -0.21168893575668335, -0.6624677181243896, -0.3985927999019623, -0.05414777249097824, 0.6417913436889648, 1.0194634199142456, 0.14310023188591003, 0.13349339365959167, -0.014601820148527622, 0.50057053565979, -0.3802042603492737, 0.27233973145484924, -0.9683953523635864, -0.14154869318008423, -0.5915815234184265, 0.1540737748146057, 0.029739679768681526, -0.44273099303245544, 0.32646462321281433, -0.550554633140564, 0.44769883155822754, -0.00739991245791316, 0.7688519954681396, 0.1248934343457222, -0.07054299116134644, -0.03628339618444443, -0.24802100658416748, 1.0356310606002808, -0.576210081577301, 0.37639474868774414, 0.6353445053100586, 0.3614371120929718, 0.2277659773826599, -0.7394182682037354, -0.38641777634620667, 0.08115493506193161, -0.16072885692119598, 0.007976219989359379, 0.038407761603593826, -0.36125439405441284, 0.14941813051700592, 0.6803801655769348, -0.16656525433063507, 0.4473230838775635, -0.6973084807395935, 0.1326848566532135, 0.7503979206085205, 0.48972418904304504, 0.04650247097015381, -0.09978965669870377, 0.09203196316957474, -0.10973381251096725, -0.592657208442688, -0.10850122570991516, 0.5451611280441284, 0.7071765065193176, 0.15816842019557953, 0.4820173978805542, -0.6949933767318726, 0.7976114749908447, -0.3394201397895813, -0.29962730407714844, 0.6533429026603699, -0.4290270209312439, 0.016675151884555817, -0.19447258114814758, 0.5459522604942322, 0.34557077288627625, 0.004771563224494457, -0.5991200804710388, -0.31243768334388733, -0.23100639879703522, 0.353496789932251, -0.29854413866996765, -0.23582057654857635, -0.1236017569899559, -0.5207099914550781, -0.673426628112793, 0.056257959455251694, -1.00448477268219, -0.4226587116718292, -0.28968486189842224, -0.00046060228487476707, -0.3351040184497833, -0.2673656940460205, -0.13841673731803894, -0.5072098970413208, 0.005717871244996786, -0.023869862779974937, -0.8030973076820374, 0.523155927658081, 0.8569970726966858, 1.0992507934570312, -0.434699147939682, -0.3137136995792389, -0.4812450110912323, -0.18795232474803925, -0.12120387703180313, 0.5604532361030579, -0.9236900210380554, -0.06917181611061096, -0.2462172508239746, 0.26068082451820374, -0.036899372935295105, -0.8689246773719788, 0.2881195545196533, -0.5438463687896729, 0.24137847125530243, -0.18083509802818298, -0.40319693088531494, -0.23418502509593964, 0.03821977600455284, -1.0779870748519897, 1.4798306226730347, 0.3761460781097412, -0.6892976760864258, 0.6062465310096741, -0.7319529056549072, -0.32626816630363464, 0.0754571408033371, -0.17548948526382446, -0.3410593867301941, 0.24610736966133118, 0.11778536438941956, 0.47692379355430603, -0.3680998980998993, -0.30541369318962097, -0.49854496121406555, -0.4590565264225006, -0.19525273144245148, -0.29364514350891113, 0.760386049747467, -0.14824733138084412, -0.10440216958522797, -0.4681675136089325, -0.8277788162231445, -0.01724504493176937, 0.12614549696445465, 0.012719372287392616, -0.6080381870269775, -0.2416323572397232, -0.11430104076862335, 0.4527634382247925, 0.21927037835121155, -0.9392136335372925, 0.04527122154831886, -0.7135920524597168, 0.12989725172519684, 0.5942604541778564, -0.10925277322530746, 0.39411893486976624, -0.5273587703704834, 0.5573744177818298, -0.3256482481956482, -0.028152579441666603, 0.20645730197429657, -0.5965686440467834, 0.010036986321210861, -0.30271971225738525, 0.03554047271609306, 0.550299882888794, -1.1425613164901733, 0.36135268211364746, -0.4517996311187744, -0.7182956337928772, -0.7641439437866211, 0.30024853348731995, 0.5389996767044067, 0.6596168875694275, 0.6310431957244873, -0.5217007398605347, -0.6388871073722839, -0.7966488003730774, -0.29893743991851807, 0.4393866956233978, -0.09372477233409882, 0.18636153638362885, 0.12963125109672546, 0.0945686548948288, 1.0716710090637207, -0.6906157732009888, -0.42495235800743103, -0.10842551290988922, -0.026608997955918312, 0.6860212087631226, 0.24235442280769348, 0.47091978788375854, -0.760603129863739, -0.7134196758270264, 0.34495100378990173, -0.7707745432853699, -0.26141685247421265, 0.34384748339653015, -0.026841409504413605, -0.07395223528146744, 0.6598328948020935, -0.15880988538265228, 0.4272002577781677, 0.43190908432006836, 0.18863418698310852, 0.7986221313476562, 0.32352742552757263, -0.06958580762147903, -0.9424102306365967, 0.27420687675476074, 0.09916329383850098, -0.13101445138454437, -0.7193901538848877, 0.004649762995541096, -0.3040147125720978, 0.16103096306324005, -0.4064178168773651, 0.6614814400672913, -0.5570335388183594, -0.6195201277732849, -0.4296301007270813, 0.3273791968822479, 0.012065538205206394, 0.2990685999393463, 0.33754390478134155, 0.8928784728050232, 0.710196316242218, -0.5846150517463684, 0.46567007899284363, 0.4686010181903839, -0.38954025506973267, 0.697719395160675, -0.41593918204307556, 0.23395542800426483, -0.15823088586330414, -0.390247106552124, -0.370987206697464, -0.10180871933698654, -0.10267647355794907, -0.14913564920425415, 0.056499846279621124, -0.5141456723213196, -0.34475526213645935, -0.39729058742523193, -0.35454827547073364, 0.11905896663665771, 0.24027881026268005, -0.5870002508163452, 0.28011995553970337, 0.5220913887023926, -0.6000049114227295, -0.7915692925453186, -0.6981332898139954, -0.13522185385227203, -0.36356109380722046, -0.48169565200805664, 0.5105556845664978, 0.3518870770931244, -0.20883746445178986, 0.04718654230237007, -0.26342082023620605, -0.6476898789405823, -0.006369871087372303, 0.06808655709028244, 0.431613028049469, -0.23410528898239136, 0.33518654108047485, 0.0547526478767395, -0.3203611671924591, -0.19674795866012573, -0.2819077670574188, 0.28713327646255493, 0.22287780046463013, -0.29709333181381226, -0.09740471094846725, 0.22029612958431244, 0.3653618395328522, -0.17167364060878754, 0.8163981437683105, 0.6838266253471375, -0.42931756377220154, 0.04298028722405434, -0.6294863820075989, -0.45571911334991455, -0.5435156226158142, 0.668230414390564, -0.3948870897293091, -0.717696487903595, 0.44865238666534424, -0.015584533102810383, 0.2654680609703064, 0.31897905468940735, -0.10765811800956726, -0.05342388153076172, 0.4580158591270447, 0.45567652583122253, -0.22744090855121613, 0.7163194417953491, -0.27199214696884155, 0.04624581336975098, -1.057239294052124, -0.3120003640651703, -0.5161319971084595, -0.28767597675323486, -0.4696372449398041, -0.4416370391845703, 0.4170205891132355, -0.28970813751220703, 0.3332921862602234, 0.6699313521385193, -0.5217570066452026, 0.8828095197677612, 0.6753467917442322, 0.37301909923553467, 0.33336547017097473, 0.39154383540153503, 0.09920083731412888, -0.32413098216056824, -0.621242344379425, -0.2906920909881592, 1.2681459188461304, 0.12320174276828766, 0.25071781873703003, -0.006041434593498707, 0.9877210259437561, -0.006567477248609066, 0.17287588119506836, -0.4169509708881378, 0.44079774618148804, -1.0110834836959839, -0.3036162257194519, -0.73859703540802, -0.6779382228851318, -1.0994150638580322, 0.33601027727127075, -0.4177319407463074, -0.9154685735702515, 0.3738057017326355, -0.1133008822798729, -0.33306315541267395, 0.5194557905197144, -0.5347211956977844, 0.6730791926383972, 0.06046175956726074, -0.5754150748252869, -0.0700625628232956, -0.5726124048233032, 0.24179986119270325, -0.2578050196170807, 0.18819035589694977, -0.23795759677886963, 0.04843950271606445, 0.5446230173110962, -0.36104676127433777, 0.8443585634231567, -0.18049660325050354, 0.10587988048791885, -0.03189239278435707, 0.045456837862730026, 0.5661338567733765, -0.20149795711040497, -0.808506190776825, 0.2977142035961151, -0.09252085536718369, -0.35794317722320557, -0.46357640624046326, 0.7150673270225525, -0.4602542519569397, -0.06340551376342773, 0.08961164206266403, -0.4526389539241791, -0.26006102561950684, 0.46785667538642883, 0.2824169099330902, 0.7413221597671509, -0.15380077064037323, 0.2312888503074646, 0.4612879157066345, 0.0435333326458931, 0.36480122804641724, 0.22445210814476013, 0.24811120331287384, -0.3905221223831177, 1.3762513399124146, 0.23573347926139832, 0.36306002736091614, 0.2867739498615265, -0.04930362105369568, -0.5315056443214417, -0.2960786819458008, 0.15945354104042053, 0.1434805989265442, -0.6320236921310425, -0.3525848090648651, -0.5987939238548279, -0.06842099130153656, -0.35596296191215515, -0.10236643999814987, -0.34870654344558716, -0.4313233494758606, -0.17040900886058807, -0.23495493829250336, 0.6545611023902893, 0.9287489056587219, -0.23203040659427643, 0.29085618257522583, -0.9834185242652893, 0.3862611651420593, 0.33256426453590393, 0.6721053123474121, -0.05563216656446457, -0.17798325419425964, -0.428553968667984, 0.045915957540273666, 0.14178940653800964, -0.9856212735176086, 0.5804710984230042, 0.23850460350513458, 0.8022971153259277, 0.19181334972381592, -0.15088523924350739, 0.7057672739028931, -0.06627736985683441, 0.3958965837955475, 0.05009128153324127, -0.7823178768157959, 0.1470964550971985, -0.12782736122608185, 0.0841887965798378, 1.004930853843689, 0.49225983023643494, -0.7763810157775879, -0.3666585683822632, -0.7943291664123535, -1.0606529712677002, 0.9851844906806946, 0.2980496883392334, -0.08120017498731613, -0.2680598795413971, 0.3437180817127228, 0.5741989016532898, 0.4161281883716583, -0.43650057911872864, -0.13955213129520416, 0.09502194821834564, -0.31899943947792053, 0.19507001340389252, 0.13901445269584656, 0.18120524287223816, -0.17341308295726776, 0.5707318186759949, -0.24706116318702698, 0.37878456711769104, -0.029193397611379623, -0.11740496754646301, 0.24388553202152252, -0.14264459908008575, -0.0114326486364007, 0.39052435755729675, -0.08599354326725006, 0.026894960552453995, 0.5587979555130005, -0.4677451252937317, -0.2958790361881256, 0.07195686548948288, 0.16526912152767181, 0.14760111272335052, 0.4419326186180115, 0.3839380145072937, 0.22478577494621277, -0.37513452768325806, 0.5401934385299683, 0.336460143327713, -0.09860621392726898, -0.2656485140323639, 0.2291182428598404, -0.2942902445793152, 0.13304847478866577, 0.31143635511398315, 0.054917097091674805, 0.3656255304813385, -0.15247954428195953, 0.5494115948677063, 0.35644763708114624, -0.3886275589466095, -0.11560537666082382, 0.20940154790878296, 0.08386528491973877, -0.06943786889314651, 0.9549590945243835, -0.5523287653923035, -0.21108978986740112, 0.8782389163970947, 0.3682314455509186, 0.6619404554367065, -0.11744555085897446, 0.024258093908429146, 0.4344956874847412, 0.35102927684783936, -0.1789485365152359, 0.3114266097545624, 0.1525137573480606, -0.6937646269798279, -0.5326701998710632, -0.21432237327098846, -0.228346586227417, -0.08890165388584137, -0.8195694088935852, 0.31139883399009705, -0.1721096783876419, -0.06524128466844559, -0.1613297164440155, -0.08532918244600296, -0.9576663374900818, 0.28242790699005127, -0.09937570989131927, 0.7210375070571899, -1.198473334312439, 0.6650702357292175, 0.6779093146324158, -0.3970586657524109, -0.44068965315818787, -0.08551766723394394, -0.09284991770982742, -0.9729588031768799, 0.4965979754924774, 0.20457260310649872, -0.06884162127971649, 0.026869280263781548, -0.2841850221157074, -1.0440285205841064, 1.1760669946670532, 0.3055553436279297, -0.47185763716697693, -0.13759008049964905, 0.09126380831003189, 0.48847606778144836, -0.5333579778671265, 0.6117552518844604, 0.910922646522522, 0.30600011348724365, -0.15699535608291626, -1.2690902948379517, 0.0036974078975617886, -0.33898812532424927, -0.08138053119182587, 0.2577280104160309, -0.4540627598762512, 0.7254161834716797, 0.018780745565891266, -0.1690504103899002, -0.13640078902244568, 0.3758089542388916, -0.027890577912330627, 0.33462247252464294, 0.6178737878799438, 0.4109831154346466, 1.0910130739212036, 0.08314565569162369, 0.6985483765602112, -0.11995133757591248, 0.051480282098054886, 1.5211807489395142, -0.1718980222940445, 0.7765831351280212, 0.3152328431606293, -0.20848408341407776, 0.7509555220603943, 0.08172878623008728, 0.05928772687911987, 0.44680553674697876, -0.13070248067378998, -0.0426153689622879, -0.14742016792297363, -0.16889649629592896, -0.27476584911346436, 0.6673316359519958, 0.3223128020763397, -0.3710750639438629, -0.3299269378185272, -0.09712674468755722, -0.26512181758880615, 0.11450930684804916, -0.10095816850662231, 0.8848803639411926, 0.04388152062892914, -0.2857619822025299, 0.19154012203216553, -0.20297536253929138, 0.696484386920929, -0.4001385569572449, -0.47882798314094543, -0.16069698333740234, -0.2847587764263153, -0.45897072553634644, -1.0019400119781494, 0.8684840798377991, -0.29965299367904663, -0.27007973194122314, -0.11695991456508636, 0.7201927900314331, -0.5036435723304749, -0.2380675971508026, 0.3009679317474365, 0.5086920857429504, 0.3477250635623932, -0.246128648519516, -0.5423970222473145, -0.24125903844833374, 0.05361919850111008, 0.4752557575702667, 0.2737741768360138, 0.5067386627197266, -0.12561918795108795, 0.6441766023635864, 0.7314492464065552, 0.24945320188999176, 0.41415509581565857, -0.25669991970062256, 0.8586178421974182, -0.570469856262207, -0.6743805408477783, -0.37170740962028503, 0.4064671993255615, -0.7749894857406616, -0.45182937383651733, 0.6041778922080994, 0.5646142959594727, 0.8747835159301758, -0.04812178388237953, 0.7315939664840698, -0.208055779337883, 0.88676917552948, -0.3627697825431824, 0.13584856688976288, -0.5149492621421814, 0.3171001374721527, -0.4257780611515045, -0.8743048310279846, -0.027445588260889053, 0.5256577730178833, -0.5819079279899597, 0.15718555450439453, 0.7018109560012817, 1.0294644832611084, -0.41942429542541504, 0.18441730737686157, 0.3670915365219116, -0.16953890025615692, -0.21066953241825104, 0.38208523392677307, 0.4700210988521576, -0.36286044120788574, 0.48006218671798706, -0.7266111373901367, -0.16371573507785797, -0.1702924221754074, -0.7952331900596619, -0.5485328435897827, -0.4270150363445282, -0.40733739733695984, 0.02804553136229515, -0.09830716997385025, 0.8626984357833862, 0.8721972107887268, -0.6597733497619629, -0.31905004382133484, 0.000158573457156308, 0.1870158463716507, -0.8183327913284302, -0.3391360640525818, 0.1703995317220688, -0.27789106965065, -0.7782663106918335, 0.8981226086616516, 0.14824938774108887, -0.26256564259529114, 0.14237414300441742, 0.20110110938549042, -0.015284053981304169, -0.45051056146621704, 0.38264623284339905, 0.32290396094322205, -0.26354101300239563, -0.09201063215732574, 0.01906757801771164, 0.12452806532382965, -0.007836573757231236, 0.6339457631111145, -0.5869786739349365, 0.510867714881897, 0.48558467626571655, 0.651303768157959, 0.3138774633407593, -0.07144289463758469, 0.5714171528816223, -1.461025357246399, 0.20227743685245514, 0.30398833751678467, 0.2715352773666382, 0.3349900245666504, -0.6145287156105042, 0.7453831434249878, 0.3436101973056793, -0.13574402034282684, -0.7247254252433777, 0.1928669810295105, -0.2570313513278961, -0.04708309471607208, 0.7008548378944397, -0.10776839405298233, -0.04025806486606598, -0.8239465951919556, 0.10400714725255966, 0.025204192847013474, -0.3037495017051697, 0.8095711469650269, 0.3355436325073242, -0.11020389944314957, -0.25915056467056274, -0.6176482439041138, 0.39189720153808594, 0.3338213860988617, -0.8982740044593811, -0.006400004494935274, 0.34534934163093567, 0.33723312616348267, 0.15463191270828247, 0.6272958517074585, -0.1819758117198944, 0.4473443329334259, 0.12772388756275177, 0.26206207275390625, -0.21754007041454315, -0.46086201071739197, -0.33119404315948486, 0.2359941452741623, 0.15762747824192047, -0.2904590666294098 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17072v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17072v2	SemScore: Automated Evaluation of Instruction-Tuned LLMs based on Semantic Textual Similarity	2024-01-30T14:52:50	2024-02-05T10:53:21	Ansar Aynetdinov, Alan Akbik	cs.CL	cs.CL	Instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently showcased remarkable advancements in their ability to generate fitting responses to natural language instructions. However, many current works rely on manual evaluation to judge the quality of generated responses. Since such manual evaluation is time-consuming, it does not easily scale to the evaluation of multiple models and model variants. In this short paper, we propose a straightforward but remarkably effective evaluation metric called SemScore, in which we directly compare model outputs to gold target responses using semantic textual similarity (STS). We conduct a comparative evaluation of the model outputs of 12 prominent instruction-tuned LLMs using 8 widely-used evaluation metrics for text generation. We find that our proposed SemScore metric outperforms all other, in many cases more complex, evaluation metrics in terms of correlation to human evaluation. These findings indicate the utility of our proposed metric for the evaluation of instruction-tuned LLMs.	[ 0.024378588423132896, -0.7761181592941284, 0.5942108035087585, 0.02832714095711708, -0.36542272567749023, 0.07474039494991302, -0.5448721647262573, -0.07910285145044327, 0.03756662458181381, 0.5920761227607727, -0.7204824090003967, -0.9719403982162476, -0.6478565335273743, 0.3529197573661804, -0.6281868815422058, 0.9700456261634827, -0.009396503679454327, 0.0901569053530693, -0.566891610622406, 0.22011618316173553, -0.18515710532665253, -0.2301904261112213, -0.26975104212760925, -0.4002760350704193, 0.19777856767177582, 0.3363119065761566, 0.581545889377594, 0.7739043235778809, 0.773087203502655, 0.4566517472267151, -0.0547671802341938, 0.5818360447883606, -0.37725257873535156, 0.03756814822554588, -0.12461008131504059, -0.16877567768096924, -0.6628302335739136, 0.02992353029549122, 0.6811178922653198, 0.46311357617378235, 0.1729326844215393, 0.7790589928627014, 0.40626060962677, 0.7485304474830627, -0.582500159740448, -0.1266603022813797, -0.732577919960022, 0.033890027552843094, 0.07433248311281204, -0.5962082147598267, -0.47838738560676575, -0.6172195672988892, 0.003329199505969882, -0.3271346390247345, 0.27839621901512146, -0.04999786242842674, 0.5559581518173218, 0.3749741315841675, -0.40957221388816833, -0.6300407648086548, -0.4463193714618683, 0.8857644200325012, -0.9220883846282959, 0.222800612449646, 0.1565946489572525, 0.3264204263687134, -0.05625087022781372, -0.5960068106651306, -0.2250646948814392, -0.569462239742279, 0.07652625441551208, 0.3408612906932831, 0.062419768422842026, -0.011872162111103535, 0.15773476660251617, 0.45797014236450195, -0.6946917772293091, 0.09170808643102646, -0.09386760741472244, -0.19555367529392242, 0.6030147671699524, 0.48364725708961487, 0.39010900259017944, -0.3890557289123535, -0.49702879786491394, -0.019710421562194824, -0.4537023901939392, -0.20836488902568817, 0.5371299982070923, 0.4033573567867279, 0.04838617891073227, 0.7456536293029785, -0.24204562604427338, 0.7780094742774963, 0.05374949425458908, -0.3165280520915985, 0.26043644547462463, -0.3324296772480011, -0.20318961143493652, 0.0635596290230751, 0.7227075099945068, 0.6134247183799744, 0.24237138032913208, -0.45359936356544495, -0.38685354590415955, 0.43812400102615356, 0.461569607257843, -0.8256673216819763, 0.07428495585918427, -0.1400483399629593, -0.5042737722396851, -0.3167257010936737, 0.14723718166351318, -0.47355636954307556, -0.10746105760335922, -0.5047769546508789, 0.5914525985717773, -0.3798644244670868, 0.13967163860797882, 0.14364758133888245, -0.02166459709405899, 0.3154100775718689, 0.1569381207227707, -0.7080722451210022, 0.6311294436454773, 1.1372181177139282, 0.783841609954834, -0.6062150597572327, -0.3124009966850281, -0.7194814682006836, 0.0862843245267868, -0.3035507798194885, 1.0910402536392212, -0.7703002095222473, -0.37660151720046997, -0.14446903765201569, -0.09927069395780563, -0.14812198281288147, -0.6983976364135742, 0.7733991146087646, -0.41237300634384155, 0.04059727489948273, -0.024055782705545425, -0.9688599705696106, 0.08312308043241501, 0.44009432196617126, -0.47814440727233887, 1.264638066291809, 0.1320212185382843, -0.6627238988876343, 0.2554008960723877, -0.37428075075149536, -0.5528227090835571, 0.08726584166288376, -0.039762552827596664, -0.33429184556007385, 0.32015711069107056, 0.012060066685080528, 0.3817155957221985, -0.6119566559791565, 0.04630417376756668, -0.31642264127731323, -0.6135119795799255, 0.2094143182039261, -0.5290719866752625, 0.2786088287830353, 0.12155216932296753, -0.5166864991188049, 0.3129160404205322, -0.7600796222686768, 0.573745608329773, -0.10435858368873596, -0.43629398941993713, -0.3527519106864929, -0.09712620079517365, -0.28774070739746094, -0.06391966342926025, 0.5618655681610107, -0.36192449927330017, -0.30101603269577026, -0.5309160947799683, 0.3315911293029785, 0.77103590965271, -0.07421562820672989, 0.4812670350074768, -0.36038410663604736, 0.4156382977962494, -0.33189988136291504, 0.125185027718544, -0.16360151767730713, -0.03651580587029457, -0.8353275060653687, -0.19791872799396515, 0.29600146412849426, 0.4966922998428345, -0.14613226056098938, 0.8462801575660706, -0.4734404683113098, -0.8194611668586731, -0.6631133556365967, 0.5341945290565491, 0.7636638879776001, 0.48386457562446594, 0.2000657171010971, -0.47667574882507324, -0.3229565918445587, -0.9503298401832581, -0.8965595364570618, -0.007001378107815981, -0.19823119044303894, 0.4993899464607239, 0.31731116771698, -0.16512241959571838, 0.5573813915252686, -0.27378779649734497, -0.019598493352532387, -0.09183789789676666, 0.10223668813705444, 0.03134247288107872, 0.12127909809350967, 0.14831720292568207, -0.12790393829345703, -0.47987475991249084, -0.07297343760728836, -0.573148250579834, -0.3320944607257843, 0.17063412070274353, -0.25363248586654663, 0.10112140327692032, 0.41940072178840637, -0.3169892430305481, 0.08806852996349335, 0.525733470916748, -0.4400029480457306, 0.5513611435890198, -0.3256446123123169, 0.4771302044391632, -1.129152536392212, -0.07092607766389847, -0.13386495411396027, -0.22952617704868317, -0.17503923177719116, 0.025593288242816925, 0.3475772738456726, -0.0862329974770546, -0.4038587808609009, 0.42789196968078613, -0.44769972562789917, -0.6545448303222656, -0.1893070936203003, 0.5498835444450378, 0.007584306877106428, 0.2736049294471741, -0.27717122435569763, 0.8452582359313965, 0.03943770006299019, -0.6659155488014221, 0.3752014935016632, 0.10966514050960541, -0.757168173789978, 0.6013036370277405, -0.8421788811683655, 0.3610580265522003, 0.1354464441537857, 0.025217367336153984, -0.9325935244560242, -0.011706002987921238, -0.2695693373680115, -0.3793397545814514, 0.0033320074435323477, 0.03549140319228172, -0.5768537521362305, -0.3005819618701935, -0.45423293113708496, -0.015810636803507805, 0.6409612894058228, -0.4695917069911957, 0.4408131539821625, 0.15454714000225067, -0.18195651471614838, -0.15907977521419525, -0.43433377146720886, -0.016421040520071983, -0.20812977850437164, -0.6006900668144226, 0.39538124203681946, -0.3095683157444, -0.13130280375480652, 0.047424040734767914, -0.3447890281677246, 0.35859379172325134, 0.26753097772598267, 0.31755247712135315, 0.27220427989959717, -0.41945743560791016, 0.10648484528064728, 0.2839895784854889, -0.22878149151802063, 0.1643257439136505, -0.2298908531665802, 0.46441787481307983, -0.35837021470069885, -0.6975997686386108, -0.316371351480484, 0.15839369595050812, 0.4318036735057831, -0.24796609580516815, 0.3032723665237427, 0.46447816491127014, -0.19969801604747772, -0.36666175723075867, -0.38979601860046387, -0.2575678527355194, -0.49544820189476013, 0.4795265793800354, -0.24074786901474, -0.7985210418701172, -0.016772981733083725, -0.4105790853500366, 0.24394108355045319, 0.5805462002754211, 0.7630263566970825, 0.032137274742126465, 1.3040062189102173, 0.2610287368297577, 0.23581664264202118, 0.22450122237205505, 0.03593602403998375, -0.0810312032699585, -0.8380867838859558, -0.07484326511621475, -0.6960563659667969, -0.40837857127189636, -0.3755018413066864, -0.4731849730014801, 0.2680428624153137, -0.03765670955181122, -0.4436382055282593, 0.39967647194862366, -0.4237199127674103, 0.6353917717933655, 0.3578706383705139, 0.05521595478057861, 0.38757506012916565, 0.17157424986362457, -0.2403658628463745, -0.1642993986606598, -0.5591866970062256, -1.2130664587020874, 0.9936134815216064, 0.18494290113449097, 0.8559653162956238, 0.005545482505112886, 0.9099031090736389, 0.5887966752052307, 0.37618812918663025, -0.796135425567627, 0.7837803959846497, -0.6365370154380798, -0.1689876765012741, -0.13503021001815796, -0.5769218802452087, -0.6111963391304016, 0.01675223931670189, -0.3894406855106354, -0.38856473565101624, -0.8762215971946716, 0.03346852585673332, -0.2639506459236145, -0.05767349526286125, -0.915789783000946, 0.8368602395057678, -0.6803042888641357, -0.26333510875701904, -0.30762580037117004, -0.2841208577156067, 0.09808646142482758, 0.08698365837335587, 0.09276685863733292, -0.38432392477989197, -0.28861141204833984, 0.891481339931488, -0.4076305031776428, 0.8065693974494934, 0.25986042618751526, -0.1581733077764511, 0.26191505789756775, 0.18927617371082306, 0.28769218921661377, -0.13439412415027618, -0.23155003786087036, -0.12500108778476715, -0.04916241019964218, -0.15236124396324158, -0.7945750951766968, 1.1432945728302002, -0.8932693600654602, -0.44147396087646484, 0.0629548653960228, -0.35584747791290283, -0.21066558361053467, 0.2537565529346466, 0.19732142984867096, 0.7156634330749512, -0.47243255376815796, -0.006008530501276255, 0.48763027787208557, -0.23246172070503235, 0.20468568801879883, 0.7277432680130005, -0.0156532172113657, -0.3789573013782501, 0.9417135119438171, -0.05164249613881111, 0.2822214365005493, 0.4299708306789398, 0.1654871702194214, -0.40523841977119446, -0.15410180389881134, -0.640269935131073, 0.18462441861629486, -0.7028143405914307, -0.46229198575019836, -0.5200286507606506, -0.3380213677883148, -0.2866469621658325, -0.23278756439685822, -0.568422257900238, -0.3671869933605194, -0.3571579158306122, -0.02294248156249523, 0.25835514068603516, 0.7890409827232361, 0.46638762950897217, 0.1615705043077469, -1.0498675107955933, 0.21686774492263794, 0.4667610824108124, 0.48434099555015564, -0.1086377426981926, -0.9337870478630066, -0.09774349629878998, 0.0031375340186059475, -0.3380197286605835, -0.7817021608352661, 0.23684358596801758, 0.5437183380126953, 0.47916916012763977, 0.21207551658153534, 0.13804523646831512, 0.7113460898399353, -0.7645503878593445, 0.720790684223175, -0.009980724193155766, -1.1367883682250977, 0.6607162356376648, 0.18910472095012665, 0.4970555007457733, 0.6550403833389282, -0.04992085322737694, -0.04735623300075531, -0.463326632976532, -0.6177167892456055, -0.7526814937591553, 0.36248698830604553, 0.03183316811919212, 0.46462300419807434, -0.28554022312164307, 0.20101764798164368, 0.396256685256958, 0.0388144850730896, -0.09528793394565582, -0.07066436856985092, 0.18449342250823975, -0.5109636783599854, -0.25118833780288696, -0.22251470386981964, -0.035212211310863495, 0.14823900163173676, 0.6117668747901917, -0.1416764259338379, 0.14154106378555298, -0.045798055827617645, -0.535406231880188, -0.1896287053823471, 0.5747231245040894, 0.505667507648468, 0.4337625503540039, -0.047967370599508286, 0.3850291073322296, 0.4893476665019989, -0.3753783702850342, -0.04332500323653221, -0.1388811618089676, -0.19394779205322266, 0.10056380182504654, 0.5848482847213745, 0.849065363407135, 0.6566441655158997, -0.8743056058883667, 0.5264159440994263, -0.2145952582359314, -0.20445626974105835, -0.18373943865299225, 0.4441932141780853, 0.10807453840970993, 0.35092511773109436, -0.08956750482320786, -0.006800495088100433, 0.2707499861717224, -0.2709665894508362, 0.2465321123600006, 0.46784961223602295, -0.5686314702033997, -0.2676132619380951, 0.3658478558063507, 0.43470799922943115, -0.7534836530685425, 0.47880539298057556, -0.0928046926856041, -0.6270678043365479, 0.6134482026100159, 0.849310040473938, 0.9789186120033264, -0.013970522210001945, 0.2936803102493286, 0.49617889523506165, 0.35815784335136414, 0.11838655173778534, 0.1775152087211609, -0.17985060811042786, -0.3956494927406311, -0.3997061550617218, -0.96479332447052, -0.35108375549316406, -0.12678256630897522, -0.8171840906143188, 0.41650113463401794, -0.4392901659011841, -0.3277808427810669, -0.22244052588939667, 0.275370717048645, -0.7280091643333435, 0.2026696801185608, 0.15677639842033386, 1.024807095527649, -0.9165695905685425, 0.4446747303009033, 0.8854342103004456, 0.1491451859474182, -0.7922831177711487, -0.062038764357566833, -0.16150732338428497, -0.7435779571533203, 0.3974955081939697, 0.37554848194122314, -0.5929528474807739, 0.07006784528493881, -0.2092997282743454, -0.5526203513145447, 1.178629994392395, 0.5409424901008606, -0.5738017559051514, 0.261008620262146, 0.02574780583381653, 0.6416902542114258, -0.5316840410232544, 0.6056568026542664, 0.9342239499092102, 0.28464940190315247, -0.10262496769428253, -0.7093786597251892, -0.07895387709140778, -0.4980211555957794, 0.08428490906953812, 0.18452951312065125, -0.5465367436408997, 0.45294350385665894, -0.20195724070072174, -0.35301879048347473, 0.2171063870191574, 0.7676278352737427, 0.3305976092815399, 0.24079203605651855, 0.5780859589576721, 0.5555030107498169, 0.7282360196113586, 0.14329759776592255, 0.9321064352989197, -0.5415496230125427, 0.40953513979911804, 1.3097813129425049, -0.4041697680950165, 0.9924846887588501, 0.15549686551094055, -0.12694692611694336, 0.40775397419929504, 0.5431138277053833, 0.11539138853549957, 0.3742811679840088, 0.27389195561408997, -0.08955562859773636, -0.5481687784194946, -0.011455776169896126, -0.3427908420562744, 0.5173642635345459, 0.2080327421426773, -0.5376850366592407, -0.33635830879211426, -0.5836696028709412, -0.2157571017742157, 0.539298415184021, -0.3455240726470947, 1.0779532194137573, 0.007264771964401007, -0.7228758931159973, 0.5514602661132812, 0.1723891943693161, 0.6093758344650269, -0.6108930110931396, 0.04397374391555786, -0.2594149112701416, 0.23519368469715118, -0.19448748230934143, -0.5832117199897766, 0.206373929977417, 0.6032189130783081, -0.24343903362751007, -0.05958012491464615, 0.8638712763786316, -0.40461596846580505, -0.6124802827835083, 0.28867170214653015, 0.41804182529449463, 0.22455088794231415, 0.27490806579589844, -0.8074693083763123, 0.23190727829933167, -0.19772784411907196, -0.25506025552749634, 0.27170443534851074, 0.3726334571838379, 0.15270957350730896, 0.5066092610359192, 0.44468072056770325, 0.051162078976631165, 0.191841721534729, 0.16664685308933258, 0.6335228681564331, -0.5729081034660339, -0.37518155574798584, -0.9358489513397217, 0.14661172032356262, -0.21895380318164825, -0.45128774642944336, 0.9066725969314575, 0.7227984666824341, 0.7091735005378723, -0.13471278548240662, 0.7748901844024658, 0.31967800855636597, 0.7807888984680176, -0.6591182947158813, 0.49049797654151917, -0.5257312655448914, 0.4592251479625702, -0.49553418159484863, -1.2712441682815552, 0.0047050826251506805, 0.5659523606300354, -0.38274434208869934, 0.15997424721717834, 0.6629163026809692, 0.8877527117729187, -0.22239740192890167, 0.09282664954662323, 0.32267871499061584, -0.011408571153879166, -0.19686025381088257, 0.5385526418685913, 0.8866987228393555, -0.4230786859989166, 0.513953447341919, 0.08393794298171997, -0.3438545763492584, -0.22647088766098022, -0.9918292760848999, -1.0167126655578613, -0.2981720566749573, -0.22560466825962067, -0.18377186357975006, 0.17668695747852325, 1.0822945833206177, 0.4061606228351593, -0.6539615988731384, -0.27648577094078064, 0.2072753608226776, 0.02470899187028408, -0.20046421885490417, -0.11394303292036057, 0.497093141078949, -0.563042402267456, -0.7474571466445923, 0.3861196041107178, 0.5335381031036377, -0.2363649606704712, -0.22451266646385193, -0.3482747972011566, 0.30159905552864075, 0.4335991442203522, 0.7641449570655823, -0.29551395773887634, -0.6502007842063904, -0.33837178349494934, 0.2608441114425659, -0.6515492796897888, -0.42921775579452515, 0.815578818321228, -0.622709333896637, 0.33258387446403503, 0.5108759999275208, 0.8946828246116638, 0.19308149814605713, 0.09819512814283371, 0.4407654106616974, -0.6375380754470825, -0.3109849691390991, 0.0903940349817276, 0.011954428628087044, 0.46461886167526245, -0.071338951587677, 0.409348726272583, -0.16485819220542908, -0.569182276725769, -0.6336163282394409, 0.2269626408815384, -0.8046361804008484, 0.016102096065878868, 1.3802014589309692, -0.14987605810165405, -0.4903036952018738, 0.469224750995636, -0.20037341117858887, 0.3749951720237732, -0.16196896135807037, 0.8585261702537537, 0.3749731183052063, 0.19931071996688843, 0.2032737135887146, -0.45963147282600403, 0.25047752261161804, 0.6491251587867737, -0.9699195623397827, -0.007979119196534157, 0.3660004138946533, 0.30527904629707336, -0.15613950788974762, 0.30044281482696533, -0.23068374395370483, 0.23929940164089203, -0.17486590147018433, -0.08985487371683121, -0.06868766248226166, -0.22791244089603424, -0.11340432614088058, 0.029756924137473106, 0.18799570202827454, 0.0045118676498532295 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17043v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17043v2	CRUD-RAG: A Comprehensive Chinese Benchmark for Retrieval-Augmented Generation of Large Language Models	2024-01-30T14:25:32	2024-02-19T03:14:30	Yuanjie Lyu, Zhiyu Li, Simin Niu, Feiyu Xiong, Bo Tang, Wenjin Wang, Hao Wu, Huanyong Liu, Tong Xu, Enhong Chen, Yi Luo, Peng Cheng, Haiying Deng, Zhonghao Wang, Zijia Lu	cs.CL	cs.CL	Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) is a technique that enhances the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) by incorporating external knowledge sources. This method addresses common LLM limitations, including outdated information and the tendency to produce inaccurate "hallucinated" content. However, the evaluation of RAG systems is challenging, as existing benchmarks are limited in scope and diversity. Most of the current benchmarks predominantly assess question-answering applications, overlooking the broader spectrum of situations where RAG could prove advantageous. Moreover, they only evaluate the performance of the LLM component of the RAG pipeline in the experiments, and neglect the influence of the retrieval component and the external knowledge database. To address these issues, this paper constructs a large-scale and more comprehensive benchmark, and evaluates all the components of RAG systems in various RAG application scenarios. Specifically, we have categorized the range of RAG applications into four distinct types-Create, Read, Update, and Delete (CRUD), each representing a unique use case. "Create" refers to scenarios requiring the generation of original, varied content. "Read" involves responding to intricate questions in knowledge-intensive situations. "Update" focuses on revising and rectifying inaccuracies or inconsistencies in pre-existing texts. "Delete" pertains to the task of summarizing extensive texts into more concise forms. For each of these CRUD categories, we have developed comprehensive datasets to evaluate the performance of RAG systems. We also analyze the effects of various components of the RAG system, such as the retriever, the context length, the knowledge base construction, and the LLM. Finally, we provide useful insights for optimizing the RAG technology for different scenarios.	[ -0.4601666033267975, -0.7154784798622131, 0.08393801748752594, 0.13064666092395782, -0.21160854399204254, 0.16575001180171967, -0.4612623453140259, -0.3925831615924835, 0.027831444516777992, 0.5592307448387146, -0.1010056585073471, -0.35309508442878723, -0.37292492389678955, 0.008625750429928303, -0.4898917078971863, 1.0193724632263184, 0.025197098031640053, -0.05399114638566971, -0.24046021699905396, -0.10266180336475372, -0.6340797543525696, -0.3967522084712982, -0.7186651825904846, -0.24145632982254028, 0.5161807537078857, 0.33926334977149963, 0.5177050828933716, 0.7415023446083069, 0.7189295291900635, 0.2585715353488922, -0.19192516803741455, 0.6615814566612244, -0.6973349452018738, 0.5260159373283386, -0.34249183535575867, -0.43518489599227905, -0.4951270520687103, -0.35861736536026, 0.7494755387306213, 0.4266151189804077, -0.2836189568042755, 0.5243549942970276, 0.15201233327388763, 0.7242074608802795, -1.046221137046814, -0.1357787549495697, -0.8021319508552551, -0.07362747192382812, -0.6493454575538635, -0.2913525402545929, -0.3928356468677521, -0.5617967844009399, -0.11941377073526382, -0.4601844549179077, 0.3422186076641083, 0.23934903740882874, 0.9148421883583069, 0.10961516201496124, -0.5220090746879578, -0.3823876976966858, -0.8023403882980347, 0.8620813488960266, -0.7003357410430908, 0.5247095227241516, 0.2564944326877594, 0.6500750780105591, -0.2328951209783554, -0.8841608166694641, -0.5450852513313293, -0.25784626603126526, -0.16478893160820007, 0.33066296577453613, 0.36825844645500183, -0.17974287271499634, 0.3291550576686859, 0.49849992990493774, -0.7491784691810608, -0.07415514439344406, -0.3158048987388611, 0.04389486834406853, 0.601349949836731, 0.563248872756958, 0.24238912761211395, -0.3283647894859314, -0.4355488717556, -0.24661220610141754, -0.7920867204666138, -0.027441639453172684, 0.17777808010578156, 0.32717251777648926, -0.017639029771089554, 0.6596335768699646, -0.21473246812820435, 0.697293221950531, -0.059028610587120056, -0.499566912651062, 0.22903206944465637, -0.16619426012039185, -0.27986887097358704, -0.2820429801940918, 0.6845271587371826, 0.35649189352989197, -0.013805722817778587, -0.18895360827445984, -0.4781200587749481, -0.02934952825307846, 0.42855069041252136, -0.6630170941352844, -0.01073745172470808, 0.1278553009033203, -0.5019133687019348, -0.17315617203712463, 0.06222457438707352, -0.9993346333503723, -0.8123800158500671, -0.2666565477848053, 0.1307096630334854, -0.48336419463157654, -0.36163124442100525, -0.2152177095413208, -0.1393144577741623, 0.5647868514060974, 0.2488284856081009, -0.5453182458877563, 0.46004506945610046, 1.0306787490844727, 0.6525080800056458, -0.546130895614624, -0.2237018495798111, -0.5866339802742004, 0.44828203320503235, -0.5711974501609802, 1.0792316198349, -0.34833237528800964, -0.5842552185058594, 0.035604480654001236, -0.04570334032177925, 0.027695804834365845, -0.9584965705871582, 0.9925248026847839, -0.7551766037940979, 0.0534878633916378, -0.4367653727531433, -0.6509509682655334, -0.15131975710391998, 0.42806747555732727, -0.5618054270744324, 1.1092076301574707, 0.2207592874765396, -0.8456346392631531, 0.2630876302719116, -0.2608199417591095, -0.519176185131073, 0.3121248483657837, -0.20203213393688202, -0.3111516535282135, 0.04743652045726776, -0.20265455543994904, 0.12778055667877197, -0.9358232617378235, 0.27759885787963867, -0.11388742923736572, -0.346966028213501, 0.22250697016716003, -0.3512979745864868, 0.5223814845085144, 0.45174017548561096, -0.15337291359901428, -0.16238954663276672, -0.6342387795448303, 0.25448644161224365, 0.18744240701198578, -0.33879944682121277, -0.5275958180427551, -0.06889624148607254, 0.01971634104847908, -0.079400934278965, 0.4210149049758911, -0.4220833480358124, 0.13124583661556244, -0.34040743112564087, -0.21086153388023376, 0.6412013173103333, 0.11797621101140976, 0.29628440737724304, -0.6791821122169495, 0.6384578347206116, -0.013695379719138145, 0.16902385652065277, -0.30938249826431274, -0.0775812417268753, -0.8607005476951599, -0.1978774517774582, 0.5161806344985962, 0.6563668847084045, -0.8860931396484375, -0.012951076962053776, -0.28377699851989746, -0.8221190571784973, -0.3002738058567047, 0.07868532836437225, 0.700847864151001, 0.6668393611907959, 0.28032395243644714, -0.253934770822525, -0.37680914998054504, -0.8652317523956299, -0.5719491839408875, 0.029127052053809166, -0.051546234637498856, 0.5042468309402466, 0.12119074165821075, -0.1304416060447693, 0.6452741622924805, -0.5235635638237, -0.2315249741077423, -0.16555827856063843, -0.05932129546999931, 0.2309931069612503, 0.2595425546169281, 0.3398161828517914, -0.9482733607292175, -0.6596267223358154, 0.35672488808631897, -0.6717995405197144, -0.3841898441314697, 0.03541852906346321, -0.23184092342853546, 0.5041893720626831, 0.17499753832817078, -0.5366197824478149, 0.37330642342567444, 0.5586679577827454, -0.0891382172703743, 0.9639356732368469, -0.23839899897575378, 0.45661720633506775, -0.9547107815742493, 0.48287180066108704, -0.18578960001468658, -0.04688610881567001, -0.6288883090019226, 0.3752070367336273, 0.36694568395614624, -0.0010607698932290077, -0.21548403799533844, 0.8462896347045898, -0.642128050327301, -0.3935331404209137, -0.3038339912891388, 0.5799448490142822, 0.18216240406036377, 0.3057006001472473, -0.31961387395858765, 0.8494884371757507, 0.11878272145986557, -0.800050675868988, 0.3288963735103607, 0.11132266372442245, -0.27648279070854187, 0.6680168509483337, -0.5864689350128174, 0.12340638041496277, -0.08747407048940659, 0.0025222802069038153, -0.8948649764060974, -0.1649261713027954, 0.09267927706241608, -0.514484703540802, 0.39533382654190063, -0.04295499250292778, -0.5290079712867737, -0.23864416778087616, -0.2563159763813019, 0.3442445397377014, 0.4931561350822449, -0.4152865409851074, 0.8425142168998718, 0.58331298828125, -0.16878655552864075, -0.7776047587394714, -0.38140618801116943, 0.09078819304704666, -0.2603093385696411, -0.4665370583534241, 0.32593590021133423, 0.014450610615313053, -0.318737268447876, 0.0377916619181633, -0.17367643117904663, -0.11243842542171478, -0.09344310313463211, 0.08789028972387314, 0.3616023063659668, -0.17605842649936676, 0.07213135808706284, 0.03467792645096779, -0.06756874173879623, -0.13404440879821777, 0.2445497363805771, 0.7892253398895264, 0.25040626525878906, -0.4259903132915497, -0.048501867800951004, 0.05649721994996071, 0.3143177628517151, -0.5571578741073608, 0.4740786850452423, 0.45506879687309265, -0.20077356696128845, -0.6292263269424438, -0.6601040363311768, 0.1940726488828659, -0.5171991586685181, 0.24616846442222595, -0.486358642578125, -0.4550457298755646, 0.6069916486740112, -0.17146658897399902, 0.3943246006965637, 0.44393807649612427, 0.5109123587608337, 0.24214470386505127, 0.5687210559844971, 0.1177908405661583, -0.025719454512000084, 0.16486065089702606, -0.1497168093919754, -0.02664336934685707, -1.0863415002822876, -0.146696075797081, -0.8272786140441895, -0.11840059608221054, -0.636712908744812, -0.6440213322639465, 0.42913010716438293, 0.18864929676055908, -0.47099295258522034, 0.2626020610332489, -0.5169227123260498, 0.2196878045797348, 0.454621821641922, -0.18918681144714355, 0.454569011926651, -0.23096488416194916, -0.0885268971323967, 0.007332970388233662, -0.5687547326087952, -0.4589582681655884, 1.0545793771743774, -0.027558686211705208, 0.9103572368621826, 0.20083889365196228, 0.6056366562843323, 0.37900030612945557, 0.514247715473175, -0.6464968919754028, 0.6984938979148865, -0.4862217903137207, -0.49783068895339966, -0.08500413596630096, -0.6953063607215881, -1.0869325399398804, 0.407988041639328, -0.20296867191791534, -0.35905903577804565, -0.08131430298089981, 0.04453127831220627, 0.01243883278220892, 0.41810342669487, -0.579006016254425, 0.5779428482055664, -0.29519960284233093, -0.4153561592102051, -0.15395934879779816, -0.29256999492645264, 0.6291557550430298, -0.23534178733825684, 0.2845923900604248, 0.1867012232542038, -0.32091671228408813, 0.47006022930145264, -0.13997648656368256, 0.3732154071331024, -0.28940826654434204, -0.16676488518714905, 0.42953431606292725, 0.44977644085884094, 0.5785133242607117, -0.13626708090305328, -0.23813703656196594, 0.01512701716274023, 0.14950017631053925, 0.01634674146771431, -0.6115325093269348, 0.6672700047492981, -0.5878350138664246, -0.5507541298866272, -0.3804406225681305, -0.497417688369751, -0.3350161612033844, 0.42715558409690857, -0.02747671864926815, 0.7194507718086243, -0.19551946222782135, 0.25436651706695557, 0.5579888224601746, -0.7444484829902649, 0.11214186996221542, 0.6445485949516296, -0.5491886734962463, -0.5369221568107605, 0.9115905165672302, 0.24869723618030548, 0.24958373606204987, 0.4084233343601227, 0.12832392752170563, -0.21030379831790924, -0.47444239258766174, -0.41813746094703674, 0.3754349648952484, -0.5376056432723999, -0.4940006136894226, -0.6349108815193176, -0.46177414059638977, -0.5038829445838928, 0.08995699137449265, -0.37760400772094727, -0.1659732460975647, 0.07341624051332474, 0.4711321294307709, 0.14453727006912231, 0.7183324694633484, 0.1105879545211792, 0.13010497391223907, -0.9878930449485779, 0.7344119548797607, -0.056944891810417175, 0.6269810199737549, 0.341817170381546, -0.6518186330795288, -0.37335237860679626, -0.020265724509954453, -0.469546914100647, -0.5638740062713623, 0.42156434059143066, -0.006784216500818729, 0.781764566898346, 0.3052841126918793, 0.32211002707481384, 0.8196595311164856, -0.6039564609527588, 0.8164746761322021, -0.17709366977214813, -0.679375171661377, 0.1790924072265625, -0.5081701278686523, 0.22535884380340576, 0.3942994475364685, 0.11297155171632767, -0.8967525362968445, -0.3723829984664917, -0.45091232657432556, -0.9637119174003601, 0.5060188174247742, -0.1682579070329666, -0.18144989013671875, -0.10769053548574448, 0.47021418809890747, 0.08606701344251633, 0.14048685133457184, -0.14695708453655243, -0.5101849436759949, 0.2585274577140808, -0.02909550443291664, 0.11835119873285294, -0.32789888978004456, 0.037093210965394974, 0.2837616801261902, 0.8023790121078491, 0.17547710239887238, -0.007886526174843311, 0.08421985805034637, -0.020462218672037125, -0.07877097278833389, 0.1571856141090393, 0.45120927691459656, 0.8108036518096924, 0.06430567055940628, -0.180369034409523, 0.3451490104198456, -0.6370609402656555, -0.20092225074768066, -0.023832939565181732, -0.3194984197616577, 0.060459163039922714, 0.24892665445804596, 0.4125858545303345, -0.07274218648672104, -0.8981838822364807, 0.28781747817993164, -0.09698791056871414, 0.09046253561973572, -0.5529087781906128, 0.15868666768074036, 0.01646653562784195, 0.2281065583229065, 0.5496797561645508, -0.16046585142612457, 0.22465993463993073, -0.2717362344264984, 0.18243609368801117, 0.4309651851654053, 0.04957346245646477, -0.06593040376901627, 0.4806825816631317, -0.021967051550745964, -0.46732139587402344, 0.2563762664794922, -0.20427007973194122, -0.39986568689346313, 0.5706204175949097, 0.4437333047389984, 0.8195461630821228, -0.3704555630683899, 0.12013204395771027, 0.5608127117156982, 0.2405627816915512, -0.06879938393831253, 0.2122977077960968, 0.11683563143014908, -0.6478391885757446, -0.4019032418727875, -0.680284857749939, -0.6264761090278625, 0.1423247754573822, -0.8300581574440002, 0.40641361474990845, -0.30772143602371216, -0.20488594472408295, -0.22837375104427338, 0.28003841638565063, -0.5715998411178589, 0.25097113847732544, -0.16085900366306305, 0.9531927108764648, -0.23774354159832, 0.6296325922012329, 0.6615024209022522, -0.10365123301744461, -0.8654329776763916, 0.06242147460579872, 0.021564433351159096, -0.6233009099960327, 0.6810048818588257, -0.2266225963830948, -0.1654551923274994, -0.36188721656799316, -0.08179697394371033, -0.8592289686203003, 1.0674704313278198, 0.11182328313589096, -0.5251621603965759, 0.10081350058317184, 0.17609675228595734, 0.6973584890365601, -0.13481765985488892, 0.3116930425167084, 0.46129006147384644, 0.45420706272125244, 0.013229009695351124, -1.1099917888641357, -0.010959579609334469, -0.166394904255867, 0.24113790690898895, 0.465786337852478, -0.8226693272590637, 1.1408898830413818, 0.07133799046278, -0.6024416089057922, 0.3060014843940735, 0.4636121690273285, 0.5677374601364136, 0.35062456130981445, 0.5177287459373474, 0.5793907642364502, 0.691885769367218, 0.02694525569677353, 1.0737942457199097, -0.5361791849136353, 0.22390398383140564, 1.400639295578003, -0.6271116137504578, 0.8696385025978088, 0.13002650439739227, -0.1863066852092743, 0.3825186491012573, 0.18390777707099915, 0.06253022700548172, 0.25528115034103394, 0.3411767780780792, -0.27068471908569336, 0.1607041209936142, -0.21864929795265198, -0.5129480361938477, 0.4178546667098999, 0.38475891947746277, -0.1563110202550888, -0.3020857274532318, -0.22109980881214142, -0.03975584730505943, 0.2753532826900482, -0.26713114976882935, 0.9104017019271851, -0.01665911078453064, -0.8261182904243469, 0.6924393177032471, 0.027661385014653206, 0.5590439438819885, -0.7269304394721985, -0.10602153837680817, -0.4984276592731476, 0.31303462386131287, -0.1378091424703598, -0.7737531661987305, 0.2737888991832733, 0.13985691964626312, -0.018941788002848625, 0.10670265555381775, 1.0245347023010254, -0.3485822081565857, -0.22539594769477844, 0.3168209195137024, 0.6506655812263489, 0.12723228335380554, 0.33009952306747437, -0.5540401935577393, 0.23322933912277222, -0.11117344349622726, -0.5260019302368164, 0.3828831911087036, 0.8772398233413696, -0.1501547396183014, 0.8544281721115112, 0.5863142609596252, 0.5855388045310974, -0.05116305500268936, 0.1510908603668213, 0.9740641117095947, -0.8419021368026733, -0.2984623908996582, -0.47553175687789917, 0.2715449631214142, -0.21212594211101532, -0.2339305877685547, 1.037761926651001, 0.813175618648529, 0.7296952605247498, 0.13739725947380066, 0.8368073105812073, -0.34983423352241516, 1.3367804288864136, -0.12323533743619919, 0.8003661036491394, -0.6894930005073547, 0.26682794094085693, -0.4365518391132355, -1.006277084350586, -0.06923873722553253, 0.11642955243587494, -0.17592285573482513, 0.16862766444683075, 0.5956413149833679, 0.9226118922233582, 0.09127189964056015, -0.01849723421037197, 0.40251436829566956, 0.17296387255191803, 0.30280396342277527, 0.25737306475639343, 0.7790172100067139, -0.4674339294433594, 0.6173564791679382, -0.14174309372901917, -0.13978995382785797, 0.03501840680837631, -0.6937877535820007, -0.6843680739402771, -0.6070646643638611, 0.1867554783821106, -0.4162955582141876, 0.16051341593265533, 0.6130553483963013, 0.2402268648147583, -0.7066885828971863, -0.559632420539856, 0.4805949628353119, 0.005027481820434332, -0.2290136069059372, -0.27994686365127563, 0.49697181582450867, -0.5971431136131287, -0.6746984720230103, 0.09246734529733658, 0.14475952088832855, -0.35027945041656494, -0.28419944643974304, 0.11123235523700714, -0.07344052940607071, -0.04285474121570587, 0.7095906734466553, 0.29418253898620605, -0.3953396677970886, -0.13299712538719177, 0.16798631846904755, -0.24574749171733856, -0.16181282699108124, 0.813446044921875, -0.660478413105011, 0.2945360243320465, 0.6671208143234253, 1.0322282314300537, 0.4439314603805542, 0.29673120379447937, 0.438231498003006, -0.4630192220211029, -0.10291837900876999, 0.27402955293655396, 0.18468572199344635, 0.3250274956226349, -0.19083786010742188, 0.6232844591140747, 0.0124030327424407, -0.9417712688446045, -1.0582363605499268, 0.033702123910188675, -0.8632538914680481, -0.2663516104221344, 1.3082534074783325, -0.11216014623641968, -0.306281179189682, -0.17613735795021057, -0.32942602038383484, 0.3019774556159973, -0.2326842099428177, 0.7890269756317139, 0.31274428963661194, 0.0946604460477829, -0.07913895696401596, -0.8458354473114014, 0.5011031031608582, 0.18930038809776306, -0.8619938492774963, 0.45870906114578247, 0.6616007089614868, 0.2861683666706085, 0.13635146617889404, 0.6158275008201599, -0.2778836190700531, 0.1839592456817627, -0.023628801107406616, 0.2056741565465927, 0.03410957381129265, -0.19964654743671417, 0.052289120852947235, 0.2724963128566742, 0.03435046970844269, 0.17532365024089813 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17039v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.17039v1	Taking Action Towards Graceful Interaction: The Effects of Performing Actions on Modelling Policies for Instruction Clarification Requests	2024-01-30T14:18:31	2024-01-30T14:18:31	Brielen Madureira, David Schlangen	cs.CL	cs.CL	Clarification requests are a mechanism to help solve communication problems, e.g. due to ambiguity or underspecification, in instruction-following interactions. Despite their importance, even skilful models struggle with producing or interpreting such repair acts. In this work, we test three hypotheses concerning the effects of action taking as an auxiliary task in modelling iCR policies. Contrary to initial expectations, we conclude that its contribution to learning an iCR policy is limited, but some information can still be extracted from prediction uncertainty. We present further evidence that even well-motivated, Transformer-based models fail to learn good policies for when to ask Instruction CRs (iCRs), while the task of determining what to ask about can be more successfully modelled. Considering the implications of these findings, we further discuss the shortcomings of the data-driven paradigm for learning meta-communication acts.	[ -0.13664956390857697, -0.9088170528411865, 0.3997732102870941, 0.12307079881429672, 0.16497862339019775, -0.3672713041305542, 0.04816874861717224, -0.4055171012878418, 0.15363597869873047, 0.4848657548427582, -0.8817604184150696, 0.09322581440210342, -0.6500177383422852, 0.041767511516809464, -0.4495529532432556, 1.1145062446594238, -0.13945958018302917, 0.06783801317214966, -0.07187223434448242, 0.11091981828212738, -0.899922788143158, -0.00900538731366396, -0.7394325137138367, -0.5006479024887085, 0.7041029930114746, 0.8950167894363403, 0.7825267314910889, 0.41937780380249023, 0.6600995063781738, 0.41321635246276855, -0.1071884036064148, -0.11227211356163025, -0.4429648220539093, 0.1261088103055954, -0.30680519342422485, -0.7302924394607544, -0.16257095336914062, 0.08105392009019852, 0.7544183135032654, 0.8056106567382812, -0.3181321322917938, 0.12870405614376068, 0.5309255719184875, 0.7438757419586182, -0.5950812697410583, 0.3679729402065277, -0.19976526498794556, 0.11691761016845703, 0.24358616769313812, 0.031475652009248734, -0.30288195610046387, -0.2977059781551361, 0.49183106422424316, -0.2179688960313797, -0.0516621358692646, -0.14942990243434906, 0.7110623121261597, 0.332372784614563, -0.5550790429115295, -0.6578758358955383, -1.1802818775177002, 0.7045727372169495, -0.43698593974113464, 0.3294838070869446, 0.5279694199562073, 0.128749281167984, -0.33749592304229736, -0.8855347037315369, -0.5660684108734131, -0.16781707108020782, -0.4438991844654083, 0.0044736675918102264, -0.25093215703964233, 0.4636552035808563, 0.6820013523101807, 0.08673140406608582, 0.008436329662799835, -0.1030225157737732, -0.7827281355857849, 0.019174620509147644, 0.33585333824157715, 0.3906811475753784, -0.07433129101991653, -0.2697415351867676, -0.30722835659980774, -0.13842982053756714, -0.4472348392009735, 0.7645401358604431, 0.3179417550563812, 0.17268745601177216, -0.40942737460136414, 0.63420170545578, -0.11812455207109451, 0.5741479992866516, 0.3165442645549774, 0.11139319092035294, -0.4036211371421814, 0.0027324382681399584, -0.2813567817211151, -0.21615558862686157, 0.5230838656425476, 0.1531083583831787, 0.05535830557346344, 0.1469668596982956, -0.17403391003608704, -0.09153663367033005, 0.379308819770813, -0.699817955493927, -0.11790022253990173, 0.20020924508571625, -0.3266691267490387, -0.05647849664092064, 0.3596370816230774, -0.8038896918296814, 0.04346945881843567, -0.835455060005188, 0.4469481110572815, -0.29164278507232666, -0.06622950732707977, 0.08817020803689957, -0.038004275411367416, 0.47294512391090393, 0.357719749212265, -0.6852763891220093, 0.4326763153076172, 0.7249829769134521, 0.43794527649879456, 0.1536487489938736, -0.36923861503601074, -0.4956236183643341, 0.0873456671833992, -0.4237104058265686, 0.5584636926651001, -0.7322845458984375, -0.7295584082603455, -0.030592167750000954, 0.3314054012298584, -0.7229626774787903, -0.279909610748291, 0.4653008282184601, -0.4395938515663147, -0.004723604768514633, -0.5243750810623169, -0.4506694972515106, -0.4086412787437439, 0.36114180088043213, -0.7445215582847595, 0.49387258291244507, -0.053557638078927994, -0.7708505392074585, 0.26736608147621155, -0.7874020338058472, -0.6578924059867859, -0.18255293369293213, -0.14075057208538055, -0.25776243209838867, 0.14387823641300201, -0.357820987701416, 0.3331942856311798, -0.10903952270746231, 0.25082165002822876, -0.293057918548584, -0.46722379326820374, 0.5872198343276978, -0.7134789824485779, 0.5706136226654053, 0.045423708856105804, -0.5552747845649719, 0.030203700065612793, -0.34319791197776794, 0.07981091737747192, -0.23244087398052216, -0.35813403129577637, -0.10078121721744537, 0.17678505182266235, -0.5966697335243225, 0.4201207756996155, -0.02713548019528389, -0.1534711867570877, 0.2503366768360138, -0.1744152009487152, 0.368672639131546, 0.8094652891159058, 0.2434404194355011, 0.5226446986198425, -0.5531901121139526, 0.6380530595779419, -0.14380846917629242, 0.5508796572685242, -0.2024248093366623, -0.2739361524581909, -0.8412153720855713, 0.15093211829662323, 0.1842450648546219, 0.559305727481842, -0.9073880314826965, -0.4226338267326355, -0.18350642919540405, -0.3122619092464447, -0.5020238161087036, -0.08037593960762024, 0.8224762082099915, 0.6061847805976868, 0.0836847722530365, -0.24328720569610596, -0.26540297269821167, -0.6748460531234741, -0.36775192618370056, -0.43628478050231934, 0.41118162870407104, 0.25849324464797974, 0.5952211022377014, 0.05649958923459053, 0.7271401882171631, -0.21624250710010529, -0.16980330646038055, -0.373995840549469, 0.4641123116016388, -0.12608447670936584, 0.5154069066047668, 0.32049044966697693, -1.1133551597595215, -0.5702260136604309, -0.2928563356399536, -0.5337236523628235, 0.28438183665275574, -0.11885961890220642, 0.17721512913703918, 0.19630922377109528, 0.46254125237464905, -0.8725438117980957, 0.902724027633667, 0.2136826068162918, 0.11743219196796417, 0.5028746724128723, -0.23970434069633484, 0.5749382972717285, -0.46631813049316406, -0.056605901569128036, -0.1734286993741989, 0.17778314650058746, -1.0564171075820923, 0.025943055748939514, -0.10081588476896286, -0.0038549317978322506, -0.6017170548439026, 0.35782960057258606, -0.289515882730484, -0.02443353645503521, -0.30812352895736694, -0.4017500877380371, -0.1978631317615509, 0.5955124497413635, 0.16425050795078278, 0.5756868720054626, 0.6402795314788818, -1.2438656091690063, -0.3148205578327179, 0.27760156989097595, 0.18320631980895996, 0.5563926100730896, -0.8898555040359497, 0.04777131974697113, -0.3588504493236542, 0.2765396535396576, -0.8620603680610657, -0.61738520860672, 0.670836329460144, -0.23260703682899475, 0.43340545892715454, -0.48064830899238586, -0.11766737699508667, -0.5994983911514282, -0.12242980301380157, 0.01265840046107769, 0.2565388083457947, -0.28281170129776, 0.9075592756271362, 0.14853116869926453, 0.09899137169122696, -0.7514514327049255, -0.7315227389335632, -0.37091323733329773, -0.2559521496295929, -0.2848377227783203, 0.13924537599086761, -0.13057278096675873, -0.4094088077545166, -0.14818371832370758, -0.26187071204185486, -0.105117067694664, 0.18713299930095673, 0.5367369651794434, 0.15754592418670654, 0.15353818237781525, -0.0999615266919136, -0.06610770523548126, 0.03828129172325134, 0.40445059537887573, 0.2240607738494873, 0.3047189712524414, -0.07408364862203598, -0.7950355410575867, -0.9018173217773438, 0.3125593066215515, 0.8509196639060974, -0.21724189817905426, 0.549456775188446, 0.23071816563606262, -0.04571101814508438, 0.000048081081331474707, -0.2593434751033783, -0.534781277179718, -0.5160300135612488, -0.08764798194169998, -0.2126036137342453, -0.5467095971107483, 0.24944525957107544, -0.0443413108587265, 0.4122679829597473, 0.09174692630767822, -0.18715138733386993, -0.4230973422527313, 1.1917781829833984, 0.760409951210022, 0.13987037539482117, 0.7438806295394897, -0.3484638035297394, 0.21743221580982208, -0.6235955357551575, -0.41280102729797363, -0.6323291063308716, -0.46039873361587524, -0.6926736831665039, -0.0797950029373169, 0.31692400574684143, -0.11239312589168549, -0.16932864487171173, 0.36591166257858276, -0.1729055494070053, -0.0037481943145394325, 0.48969537019729614, 0.19509205222129822, -0.01150968112051487, -0.12812432646751404, 0.24695266783237457, -0.06025952845811844, -0.9020271897315979, -0.3407127857208252, 0.4970819056034088, 0.17925064265727997, 1.0683956146240234, 0.03785855323076248, 0.4869585931301117, 0.05717441067099571, 0.4407670199871063, -0.8386591672897339, 0.71693354845047, 0.11921446025371552, -0.32706552743911743, -0.1673070639371872, -0.4018976092338562, -1.0219097137451172, 0.03549027815461159, -0.11242913454771042, -0.5157836675643921, 0.3975186347961426, 0.5941974520683289, -0.2690940499305725, 0.17107895016670227, -0.7109202146530151, 0.6034500002861023, -0.09098698198795319, -0.611621618270874, -0.4922120273113251, -0.983483612537384, 0.4364871084690094, 0.38260504603385925, 0.4577542245388031, 0.32638928294181824, 0.3464113175868988, 0.5256584882736206, -0.38357779383659363, 1.3928077220916748, -0.4743005633354187, -0.016996053978800774, 0.8701438307762146, 0.25699007511138916, 0.8428356051445007, -0.3530861735343933, 0.12405954301357269, -0.28146252036094666, -0.007389634847640991, -0.1415799856185913, -0.7581275701522827, 0.3301239311695099, -0.3341723084449768, -0.9929109215736389, -0.3201953172683716, -0.43627113103866577, 0.04506922885775566, 0.048791684210300446, 0.10230657458305359, 0.6508235335350037, -0.008196174167096615, 0.19749632477760315, 0.883847177028656, 0.2215145081281662, 0.7164825201034546, 1.0568535327911377, 0.08550506830215454, -0.0004985986743122339, 0.6065039038658142, 0.4593241512775421, 0.5285326838493347, 0.1373642385005951, 0.08075221627950668, -0.12174642831087112, -0.1486617624759674, 0.04000354930758476, 0.21419452130794525, -0.5872159600257874, -0.13102596998214722, -0.6587480306625366, -0.1722298413515091, -0.25969427824020386, -0.023219730705022812, -0.02870067022740841, -0.1537119299173355, -0.4842889904975891, -0.1905146837234497, 0.30068498849868774, 1.0501569509506226, -0.28117477893829346, 0.4788144826889038, -0.7895923852920532, -0.09430336207151413, 0.2414221167564392, -0.04254109784960747, 0.2540057599544525, -0.49995583295822144, -0.08331231772899628, 0.39514848589897156, -0.6109709143638611, -0.7408361434936523, -0.013036967255175114, 0.22719402611255646, 0.422402024269104, 0.5900694727897644, 0.13947151601314545, 1.1039782762527466, -0.6724448800086975, 0.7601439356803894, -0.08429735153913498, -0.6833709478378296, 0.5916503667831421, 0.015681952238082886, 0.13557817041873932, 0.40348461270332336, 0.6237809658050537, -0.36302876472473145, -0.4178798198699951, -0.8997424244880676, -0.5496960282325745, 0.7777894735336304, -0.1421726644039154, 0.5913282632827759, -0.20696508884429932, 0.5374380946159363, -0.17333278059959412, 0.20521682500839233, -0.4236554205417633, -0.2390761822462082, 0.13071854412555695, 0.17138294875621796, 0.43672534823417664, -0.22068722546100616, -0.1069440171122551, 0.003632891923189163, 0.7006574273109436, 0.03759515658020973, 0.23366320133209229, 0.3867458701133728, 0.07698959112167358, -0.4262637197971344, 0.5632394552230835, 0.8488875031471252, 0.2826799154281616, 0.42176491022109985, -0.10072225332260132, 0.16456355154514313, -0.4524257481098175, -0.05395913124084473, 0.012350819073617458, -0.2611229717731476, -0.19113712012767792, 0.34683656692504883, 0.7442482709884644, 0.6695665121078491, -0.5612034201622009, 0.49582555890083313, -0.04428386688232422, -0.21570485830307007, -0.19429552555084229, 0.4448578655719757, -0.3761178255081177, 0.32128334045410156, 0.09342670440673828, 0.3738868534564972, 0.2537423074245453, -0.7031365036964417, 0.41292804479599, 0.6303840279579163, -0.9515670537948608, -0.7132790684700012, 0.5820621252059937, -0.2881368398666382, -0.49148330092430115, 0.6668344140052795, 0.08250261098146439, -0.5781493186950684, 0.6657758355140686, 0.3143642246723175, 0.3894539773464203, -0.5523951649665833, 0.49378228187561035, 0.24706824123859406, 0.2093399614095688, -0.33606502413749695, 0.48203587532043457, -0.20232859253883362, -0.29205000400543213, -0.41844382882118225, 0.019582901149988174, -0.6303886771202087, -0.18531489372253418, -1.0505828857421875, 0.4081228971481323, -0.30743202567100525, -0.26941338181495667, -0.2841298580169678, -0.368438720703125, -0.7786720991134644, 0.16482926905155182, -0.5305907130241394, 0.8941938877105713, -0.9035811424255371, 0.35425612330436707, 0.51569664478302, -0.5670919418334961, -1.3638107776641846, 0.1891537457704544, -0.06307016313076019, -0.48157885670661926, 0.7163400053977966, 0.08337918668985367, -0.26131942868232727, -0.16271854937076569, -0.8274466395378113, -0.8400465846061707, 0.9322084784507751, 0.27865031361579895, -0.494655579328537, -0.27411317825317383, 0.24439123272895813, 0.43353742361068726, 0.04886756092309952, 0.24971140921115875, 0.3567398190498352, 0.5713594555854797, 0.4793819487094879, -0.8353145718574524, -0.15247666835784912, 0.18737512826919556, -0.4563567638397217, 0.2977554202079773, -0.9131526350975037, 0.8739150762557983, -0.5757272243499756, -0.3903661370277405, 0.1649327129125595, 0.7631562948226929, -0.017194146290421486, 0.43401530385017395, 0.5180776715278625, 0.2502695918083191, 0.49757489562034607, -0.10780738294124603, 1.2785528898239136, -0.14927789568901062, 0.15239547193050385, 1.0917479991912842, -0.3192998170852661, 0.7323639988899231, 0.5977960228919983, 0.06592404097318649, 0.6176498532295227, 0.4686736762523651, 0.3164733350276947, 0.6057089567184448, -0.12563556432724, -0.15936370193958282, 0.18278911709785461, -0.13644438982009888, 0.08997225016355515, 0.3803088665008545, 0.6982318162918091, -0.20776182413101196, -0.31629952788352966, 0.19198454916477203, 0.08075898885726929, -0.14277015626430511, -0.6085436344146729, 0.8621687889099121, 0.1644260585308075, -1.332409381866455, 0.13693980872631073, -0.2151426076889038, 0.10495376586914062, -0.6048957705497742, -0.5328084826469421, 0.08900895714759827, 0.06929882615804672, -0.230657696723938, -0.8774102330207825, 0.5345748662948608, -0.2665475010871887, -0.10271408408880234, -0.22432971000671387, 0.7920683026313782, -0.5291796922683716, -0.052715741097927094, 0.07800295203924179, 0.22042827308177948, 0.1523488163948059, 0.584801435470581, -0.9671117663383484, -0.09588126838207245, 0.07708287984132767, -0.2744881212711334, 0.19032970070838928, 0.5670648217201233, -0.3002200722694397, 0.8232468366622925, 0.34830620884895325, -0.2326950579881668, -0.023556426167488098, -0.20554623007774353, 0.7457104325294495, -0.15778015553951263, -0.2275329828262329, -0.7207480072975159, 0.9421724677085876, 0.19475792348384857, 0.04413120821118355, 0.5418794751167297, 0.11287871748209, 0.7551846504211426, -0.04256617650389671, 0.565060555934906, -0.32761284708976746, 0.4018869996070862, -0.5847712755203247, 0.1832049936056137, -0.1439182013273239, 0.3754667043685913, -0.08929437398910522, -0.34172940254211426, 0.11389058083295822, 0.4276859760284424, -0.6798120141029358, 0.13086223602294922, 0.47267860174179077, 0.7912728786468506, -0.16696195304393768, 0.3422410488128662, -0.004073998425155878, -0.017773140221834183, 0.1615431010723114, 0.1454819291830063, 0.945264458656311, -0.34460172057151794, 0.4867805540561676, -0.24628780782222748, 0.012036136351525784, -0.06927459686994553, -0.5647391080856323, -0.8553253412246704, -0.609087347984314, -0.250381201505661, -0.3748842775821686, 0.13268190622329712, 1.1145298480987549, 0.46418511867523193, -0.6203627586364746, -0.12932775914669037, -0.4004586935043335, 0.44614407420158386, -0.5328398942947388, -0.2592734098434448, 0.2987906038761139, -0.4769328236579895, -0.6951068639755249, 0.21699489653110504, -0.22496406733989716, 0.45880967378616333, 0.018944215029478073, -0.06472243368625641, 0.0398029200732708, 0.21301080286502838, 0.3557273745536804, 0.8271957635879517, -0.6103882789611816, -0.4079665243625641, 0.11189853399991989, 0.03259970247745514, -0.03659559413790703, 1.1192092895507812, -0.5517791509628296, 0.06979486346244812, 0.13837702572345734, 0.29427093267440796, 0.23946835100650787, -0.06622359901666641, 0.5812929272651672, -0.45405590534210205, -0.2188897430896759, 0.04679931327700615, 0.27266666293144226, 0.18831123411655426, -0.4971250891685486, 0.3057864308357239, -0.14469394087791443, -0.6186418533325195, -0.6615505814552307, 0.5242847204208374, -0.2760251462459564, -0.04298114776611328, 1.0398297309875488, -0.2475748062133789, -0.44448333978652954, -0.06855227798223495, -0.2741025984287262, 0.057033341377973557, -0.22782962024211884, 0.700039267539978, 0.5422802567481995, -0.38163450360298157, -0.3058958351612091, -0.6895806789398193, 0.6931663751602173, 0.32829177379608154, -0.4960273802280426, 0.26077693700790405, 0.491341233253479, 0.3687649667263031, -0.01732092909514904, 0.5983384251594543, 0.044968318194150925, 0.33045005798339844, -0.5392328500747681, -0.40998807549476624, 0.2847540080547333, -0.7818981409072876, -0.37116560339927673, 0.0005975628737360239, -0.09431139379739761, -0.1052689477801323 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07913v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07913v2	QACP: An Annotated Question Answering Dataset for Assisting Chinese Python Programming Learners	2024-01-30T13:11:23	2024-02-23T02:35:41	Rui Xiao, Lu Han, Xiaoying Zhou, Jiong Wang, Na Zong, Pengyu Zhang	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC	In online learning platforms, particularly in rapidly growing computer programming courses, addressing the thousands of students' learning queries requires considerable human cost. The creation of intelligent assistant large language models (LLMs) tailored for programming education necessitates distinct data support. However, in real application scenarios, the data resources for training such LLMs are relatively scarce. Therefore, to address the data scarcity in intelligent educational systems for programming, this paper proposes a new Chinese question-and-answer dataset for Python learners. To ensure the authenticity and reliability of the sources of the questions, we collected questions from actual student questions and categorized them according to various dimensions such as the type of questions and the type of learners. This annotation principle is designed to enhance the effectiveness and quality of online programming education, providing a solid data foundation for developing the programming teaching assists (TA). Furthermore, we conducted comprehensive evaluations of various LLMs proficient in processing and generating Chinese content, highlighting the potential limitations of general LLMs as intelligent teaching assistants in computer programming courses.	[ -0.4061076045036316, -0.7583742737770081, 0.3178917467594147, 0.17665044963359833, 0.1837211698293686, 0.1752692013978958, -0.1264442652463913, -0.38662028312683105, 0.22042667865753174, 0.46433115005493164, -0.47596466541290283, -0.4122947156429291, -0.22166241705417633, 0.16945527493953705, -0.3308321535587311, 0.9742066860198975, 0.15708528459072113, 0.18272536993026733, -0.5089933276176453, -0.07408585399389267, -0.345603883266449, -0.40567973256111145, -0.8684786558151245, 0.17760513722896576, 0.3956435024738312, 0.5832518339157104, 0.8070274591445923, 0.6957527995109558, 0.5006701350212097, 0.18350327014923096, 0.29747647047042847, 0.29309356212615967, 0.22723983228206635, -0.049079474061727524, 0.0327206589281559, -0.6185439229011536, -0.361624151468277, -0.14251017570495605, 0.4650026559829712, 0.685692548751831, 0.007959038950502872, 0.37869641184806824, 0.054899200797080994, 0.20602963864803314, -0.41851434111595154, 0.20484057068824768, -0.42201006412506104, 0.08060526847839355, -0.01926710270345211, -0.1531982123851776, -0.12106812745332718, -0.7957643270492554, 0.06103070080280304, -0.9138602018356323, -0.0882316306233406, -0.0942130908370018, 0.4819132685661316, 0.5194820761680603, -0.1493082046508789, -0.2958061993122101, -0.1435960978269577, 0.5488740801811218, -0.8909624218940735, -0.21821151673793793, 0.7357417345046997, 0.5090072751045227, -0.12666666507720947, -0.631170928478241, -0.9190183877944946, -0.011802253313362598, 0.11054292321205139, 0.012718159705400467, 0.6002137064933777, 0.2756945490837097, 0.2994011640548706, 0.46087610721588135, -0.8193656802177429, 0.05896182730793953, -0.263091504573822, -0.26329556107521057, 0.7921550273895264, 0.22433824837207794, 0.6761219501495361, 0.016239631921052933, -0.110731340944767, -0.08847444504499435, -0.4192976951599121, 0.2968136668205261, 0.4126056432723999, 0.26342669129371643, -0.1902991235256195, 0.31832224130630493, -0.3556595742702484, 0.895208477973938, -0.40784168243408203, -0.24492959678173065, 0.1304699033498764, -0.16777274012565613, 0.036766134202480316, -0.25119689106941223, 0.6246671676635742, 0.24987411499023438, 0.4676906168460846, 0.021891970187425613, 0.16450823843479156, -0.36562883853912354, -0.16621558368206024, -0.5213516354560852, -0.7233313322067261, 0.7264962196350098, -0.12119132280349731, 0.028755364939570427, 0.19034212827682495, -0.4446035325527191, -0.48032569885253906, -0.2248798906803131, 0.3469257652759552, -0.18640093505382538, -0.15316349267959595, -0.09200146794319153, -0.22570306062698364, 0.35518139600753784, 0.41766607761383057, -0.9078782796859741, 0.18915270268917084, 0.500830888748169, 0.602062463760376, 0.11811186373233795, -0.3773917257785797, -0.5133530497550964, -0.17998488247394562, -0.2644578516483307, 0.6085690855979919, -0.6285878419876099, 0.02677263505756855, 0.15484528243541718, 0.049474913626909256, 0.14221182465553284, -0.3298395872116089, 0.19867518544197083, -0.4808090627193451, 0.2615955173969269, -0.36967378854751587, -0.5784121155738831, -0.12529918551445007, 0.41485923528671265, -0.5460765957832336, 1.0115686655044556, 0.25958579778671265, -0.6956096291542053, 0.055184293538331985, -0.6015620827674866, -0.06389311701059341, 0.4239663779735565, -0.43272343277931213, -0.24896469712257385, -0.611927330493927, 0.5024437308311462, 0.3545686602592468, -0.1515069454908371, 0.2358408272266388, -0.2420680820941925, -0.4319537878036499, 0.49182161688804626, -0.09996149688959122, 1.1696070432662964, 0.1536778062582016, -0.10828093439340591, -0.04967337101697922, -0.8075674772262573, 0.44551628828048706, 0.08144121617078781, -0.6082658171653748, -0.18210449814796448, 0.07563047856092453, 0.02350548282265663, 0.32449066638946533, 0.3435085117816925, -0.6504709720611572, 0.7637754082679749, -0.12182504683732986, 0.316287636756897, 0.6142703890800476, 0.25587019324302673, -0.01590069942176342, -0.12811779975891113, 0.6219050288200378, -0.3126828074455261, 0.2306273728609085, -0.21736322343349457, -0.5907613635063171, -0.8811946511268616, 0.1275288611650467, 0.07047197967767715, 0.66108638048172, -1.1016685962677002, 0.20039798319339752, 0.0962444543838501, -0.2869625687599182, -0.7331321835517883, 0.38822445273399353, 0.27213770151138306, 0.3763138949871063, 0.5868398547172546, 0.05534468963742256, -0.5022432804107666, -0.58189857006073, 0.1807185858488083, -0.29808905720710754, -0.3735741674900055, 0.2797795534133911, 0.20117221772670746, 0.13200238347053528, 0.9745486974716187, -0.5366124510765076, -0.08617640286684036, -0.4494028389453888, -0.1515684723854065, -0.055398013442754745, 0.5901209712028503, 0.4237833023071289, -0.7371129393577576, -0.4308883845806122, -0.45016124844551086, -0.6426903605461121, -0.25285351276397705, -0.48569804430007935, -0.09174711257219315, 0.01992257684469223, 0.08632057160139084, -0.3074479401111603, 0.29268866777420044, 0.4407104551792145, -0.03165494278073311, 0.4432143270969391, -0.11695538461208344, 0.08256582170724869, -0.896083414554596, -0.025021281093358994, 0.012915601953864098, 0.15609462559223175, -0.363176554441452, 0.2833544909954071, 0.24590443074703217, -0.33072471618652344, -0.5323804616928101, 0.4025844931602478, -0.21081888675689697, -0.07047087699174881, -0.2966618835926056, 0.5580941438674927, -0.022385474294424057, 0.6820060610771179, 0.3066020607948303, 0.7977885603904724, 0.6185950040817261, -0.49000924825668335, 0.8005964159965515, 0.5993434190750122, -0.07227633148431778, 0.23834651708602905, -0.6407080888748169, 0.187442347407341, 0.05826844274997711, 0.21935436129570007, -0.9596738219261169, -0.2651120722293854, 0.40469425916671753, -0.6733258962631226, -0.031555820256471634, -0.08080138266086578, -0.4293084442615509, -0.36491116881370544, -0.3192465305328369, 0.385446161031723, 0.16766083240509033, -0.691135823726654, -0.08655650168657303, 0.2138998955488205, -0.2868382930755615, -0.6545829176902771, -0.6222651600837708, 0.13052982091903687, 0.06307695806026459, -0.3121456503868103, -0.2345304638147354, -0.2435312122106552, -0.1503971666097641, -0.1577022224664688, 0.24634505808353424, -0.31066763401031494, 0.35344836115837097, 0.10947270691394806, 0.3355422019958496, -0.17051438987255096, 0.35832372307777405, -0.045843034982681274, -0.047894030809402466, 0.24585331976413727, -0.3378377854824066, 0.4525226950645447, 0.16991466283798218, -0.3961923122406006, -0.6171135902404785, 0.20218214392662048, -0.07757444679737091, -0.5014691352844238, 0.612551212310791, 0.3886122703552246, -0.3643803894519806, -0.2982466518878937, -0.14667105674743652, 0.05049708113074303, -0.44367077946662903, 0.42184582352638245, 0.025079919025301933, -0.5543971061706543, 0.37476781010627747, 0.4325852394104004, 0.5260864496231079, 0.2257576286792755, 0.2171228975057602, -0.046813976019620895, 1.0704689025878906, 0.6144965887069702, -0.4968917667865753, 0.27794864773750305, -0.4331991970539093, 0.05479968711733818, -0.6293272972106934, -0.45061251521110535, -0.6119264960289001, -0.04407229647040367, -0.3893759846687317, -0.16066411137580872, 0.09473104029893875, -0.06117282435297966, -0.44428327679634094, 0.2055772840976715, -0.8185839056968689, 0.5354589819908142, 0.7485984563827515, 0.11778080463409424, -0.014966236427426338, -0.3013131320476532, 0.5792565941810608, 0.23483695089817047, -0.5458167791366577, -0.4655439555644989, 1.2050457000732422, 0.2637602686882019, 0.5462466478347778, -0.0008319574990309775, 0.3651389181613922, 0.3979478180408478, -0.03838066756725311, -0.5165780186653137, 0.5652333498001099, 0.25371065735816956, -0.6893153786659241, -0.5102944374084473, -0.29078441858291626, -0.47291210293769836, -0.12994873523712158, -0.2910844087600708, -0.7923319935798645, -0.06858506053686142, 0.15290498733520508, -0.6369084715843201, 0.4015805125236511, -0.4070839583873749, 0.9520777463912964, -0.6868715286254883, -0.2985464930534363, 0.2254619002342224, -0.8624141216278076, 0.19665299355983734, 0.11821902543306351, -0.14548033475875854, -0.05908849462866783, -0.10126332193613052, 0.9089699983596802, -0.7074084877967834, 0.6262263059616089, -0.38545721769332886, 0.20652924478054047, 0.8042173981666565, -0.1651693433523178, 0.1846817135810852, 0.2866140305995941, -0.1189495101571083, -0.031072044745087624, 0.2742878198623657, -0.7412248253822327, -0.4961257576942444, 0.48570868372917175, -0.9252020716667175, -0.7014820575714111, -0.443916916847229, -0.9466511607170105, -0.128024160861969, -0.08904007077217102, -0.22952817380428314, 0.3689538836479187, 0.4974132478237152, 0.07790957391262054, 0.45417410135269165, -0.5970019698143005, 0.5056621432304382, 0.19048883020877838, -0.1689320057630539, -0.20730789005756378, 1.213852882385254, 0.08861830830574036, 0.33983591198921204, 0.3981976807117462, -0.11126898229122162, -0.16425415873527527, -0.5869697332382202, -0.5445614457130432, 0.03459116443991661, -0.8049049973487854, -0.06850044429302216, -0.5601137280464172, -0.38185179233551025, -0.6156249642372131, -0.10550884902477264, 0.24365663528442383, -0.7132318019866943, -0.22029292583465576, -0.15191414952278137, 0.49483075737953186, 0.3946390151977539, 0.19149675965309143, 0.36606261134147644, -0.5929616689682007, 0.2884265184402466, 0.4064892530441284, 0.20881368219852448, -0.05459301173686981, -0.29793038964271545, -0.44349420070648193, 0.27201923727989197, -0.501461386680603, -0.7300227880477905, 0.37305620312690735, 0.5605805516242981, 0.6347630023956299, 0.5342574119567871, 0.4472168982028961, 0.5055506229400635, 0.33104825019836426, 1.1046781539916992, -0.27375662326812744, -0.63057941198349, 0.7996415495872498, -0.06480631232261658, 0.11678284406661987, 0.39807650446891785, 0.6277571320533752, -0.6356009244918823, -0.5914904475212097, -0.4411300718784332, -0.8187085390090942, 0.9117137789726257, -0.13085071742534637, 0.06139795854687691, 0.007204106543213129, 0.5940923690795898, 0.12983539700508118, 0.2794634997844696, -0.9467053413391113, -0.3842940330505371, -0.5112000107765198, -0.4369022250175476, 0.11094757914543152, -0.009004097431898117, 0.25590890645980835, -0.13079918920993805, 0.6503728032112122, -0.3814389407634735, -0.09644807875156403, -0.03929661586880684, -0.06506945192813873, 0.15634110569953918, 0.0630171075463295, 0.08772561699151993, 0.6526916027069092, -0.2836707830429077, -0.010324079543352127, 0.15253934264183044, -0.5376474857330322, -0.11013352870941162, -0.15400616824626923, -0.23762188851833344, -0.38575100898742676, 0.41293519735336304, 0.1280682235956192, -0.5010149478912354, -1.1949503421783447, 0.5883663296699524, -0.07311800867319107, 0.22735841572284698, -0.745073139667511, 0.5908783078193665, -0.062026891857385635, 0.15044228732585907, 0.6502330899238586, -0.46288183331489563, 0.14882071316242218, -0.4599490761756897, 0.10832710564136505, 0.20777955651283264, -0.005503172054886818, -0.11872207373380661, 0.7443608641624451, 0.22108137607574463, -0.3601113557815552, 1.0456359386444092, -0.10317940264940262, -0.5324341058731079, 1.0307085514068604, 0.390315443277359, 0.35318708419799805, -0.10616413503885269, 0.34903404116630554, 0.5687282085418701, 0.023947155103087425, 0.22890545427799225, 0.5543568730354309, -0.5355037450790405, -0.3312353193759918, -0.1401275247335434, -0.23534253239631653, -0.8061253428459167, 0.07864325493574142, -0.6832457780838013, 0.219161257147789, -0.9105588793754578, 0.3063945472240448, -0.2609597146511078, 0.37305521965026855, -0.36014699935913086, 0.5954741835594177, 0.32884112000465393, 0.8712829351425171, -0.9050358533859253, 1.090736985206604, 0.732267439365387, -1.0440760850906372, -0.9070715308189392, -0.08524731546640396, -0.23553070425987244, -0.8429597020149231, 0.6398767828941345, 0.09165068715810776, 0.7152498960494995, -0.02470353990793228, -0.9480775594711304, -0.7837218046188354, 1.0102754831314087, 0.05736687034368515, -0.16879399120807648, -0.12116217613220215, 0.6877653002738953, 0.5265612602233887, -0.26997384428977966, 0.6845705509185791, 0.41183656454086304, 0.24525204300880432, -0.12008404731750488, -0.5354198813438416, -0.13572315871715546, -0.4586557149887085, -0.25962698459625244, -0.1683904528617859, -0.7130256295204163, 1.0789573192596436, -0.35777613520622253, -0.028076456859707832, 0.3135179579257965, 0.7074623107910156, 0.23014181852340698, 0.4581935405731201, 0.04436778277158737, 0.09155504405498505, 0.6690532565116882, -0.23108471930027008, 0.7718616724014282, -0.5467014312744141, 0.1249903216958046, 0.9102824926376343, 0.13456808030605316, 0.8733744621276855, 0.4301457405090332, -0.49566611647605896, 0.3014702796936035, 0.9857214689254761, -0.10595174878835678, 0.0712435320019722, 0.33735156059265137, 0.019874127581715584, -0.5471460819244385, -0.16148652136325836, -0.4777999818325043, 0.08066042512655258, 0.4101995527744293, 0.10267812013626099, 0.07578150182962418, -0.030162295326590538, -0.1337229609489441, 0.13761590421199799, -0.2817653715610504, 0.5463411211967468, -0.11573425680398941, -0.5397824645042419, 0.4452539086341858, -0.15725713968276978, 0.4278908669948578, -0.5708194971084595, -0.3889792263507843, -0.574601948261261, -0.13151925802230835, -0.715247392654419, -1.040787696838379, -0.1304827779531479, -0.009995514526963234, 0.1967192143201828, 0.36527276039123535, 0.18660475313663483, -0.5590676069259644, -0.4531869888305664, -0.18206404149532318, 0.13287043571472168, 0.501947283744812, 0.22909677028656006, -0.634972095489502, -0.2614041268825531, 0.0828842744231224, -0.037004899233579636, 0.3843398690223694, 0.2984057366847992, -0.12481909245252609, 1.151803731918335, 0.5574989914894104, 0.3186911642551422, 0.21309292316436768, -0.20382994413375854, 0.7929987907409668, -0.4426575303077698, -0.5330082774162292, -0.27185162901878357, 0.5733534693717957, -0.10860491544008255, -0.507374107837677, 0.8664112687110901, 0.45411503314971924, 1.0831764936447144, 0.24178671836853027, 1.0419126749038696, -0.16166867315769196, 0.5331150889396667, -0.29206395149230957, 0.7102893590927124, -0.5380195379257202, 0.6449044346809387, -0.22991980612277985, -0.8251171112060547, -0.26174983382225037, 0.5564743876457214, -0.3482149541378021, -0.07089825719594955, 0.15691174566745758, 0.6554182767868042, 0.2585909366607666, -0.04171246290206909, 0.162367045879364, -0.18614256381988525, 0.4901510775089264, 0.9778090119361877, 0.7669140696525574, -0.6050474643707275, 0.7389885783195496, -0.7166252136230469, -0.10091359168291092, -0.1715899258852005, -0.38125696778297424, -0.8966591358184814, -0.5424641370773315, -0.5346696376800537, -0.056564390659332275, 0.09190087765455246, 1.313939094543457, 0.17452983558177948, -1.0466222763061523, -0.11901405453681946, 0.13298776745796204, 0.12792222201824188, -0.2510683834552765, -0.23232844471931458, 0.8558365702629089, -0.29809850454330444, -0.6872957944869995, -0.09331131726503372, -0.1061658039689064, -0.010370145551860332, -0.4702271819114685, -0.21471381187438965, -0.25523245334625244, -0.17959970235824585, 0.10365300625562668, 0.8078275918960571, -0.5319600701332092, -0.5343882441520691, 0.14873768389225006, -0.06461658328771591, -0.00009374804358230904, 0.5362175107002258, -0.7775072455406189, 0.6082578301429749, 0.44987571239471436, 1.0558816194534302, -0.33485761284828186, 0.25464314222335815, 0.10090044885873795, -0.6696794033050537, 0.27105435729026794, 0.302802175283432, 0.30401375889778137, 0.26782795786857605, -0.36663103103637695, 0.18486709892749786, 0.05609780550003052, -0.6833657026290894, -0.6525281071662903, -0.25580570101737976, -0.8705679774284363, -0.24046233296394348, 0.9912611246109009, -0.6128576397895813, 0.017785269767045975, -0.42086103558540344, -0.4702560305595398, 0.33037254214286804, -0.09137512743473053, 1.0225257873535156, 0.3008653521537781, -0.3421981930732727, -0.42184320092201233, -0.5667948126792908, 0.33596283197402954, 0.15128403902053833, -1.019457221031189, 0.06032548099756241, 0.5485527515411377, 0.010298887267708778, -0.028124995529651642, 0.5014133453369141, 0.302314817905426, 0.703173041343689, 0.21723581850528717, 0.3868340849876404, -0.4698360860347748, -0.3458341360092163, 0.08303368091583252, 0.20499540865421295, 0.43469393253326416, -0.5533201098442078 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16968v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16968v1	Distinguishing Fictional Voices: a Study of Authorship Verification Models for Quotation Attribution	2024-01-30T12:49:40	2024-01-30T12:49:40	Gaspard Michel, Elena V. Epure, Romain Hennequin, Christophe Cerisara	cs.CL	cs.CL	Recent approaches to automatically detect the speaker of an utterance of direct speech often disregard general information about characters in favor of local information found in the context, such as surrounding mentions of entities. In this work, we explore stylistic representations of characters built by encoding their quotes with off-the-shelf pretrained Authorship Verification models in a large corpus of English novels (the Project Dialogism Novel Corpus). Results suggest that the combination of stylistic and topical information captured in some of these models accurately distinguish characters among each other, but does not necessarily improve over semantic-only models when attributing quotes. However, these results vary across novels and more investigation of stylometric models particularly tailored for literary texts and the study of characters should be conducted.	[ -0.01270617637783289, -0.6267805099487305, 0.8835775256156921, -0.1520313173532486, 0.13574406504631042, 0.07465966045856476, -0.17352870106697083, -0.6288944482803345, 0.5042546391487122, 0.8646185994148254, -0.5498363971710205, -0.15429161489009857, -0.4820321500301361, 0.4490194022655487, -0.26422637701034546, 0.6828545331954956, 0.06959541887044907, 0.024876555427908897, -0.5148802399635315, 0.17793044447898865, -0.20436815917491913, -0.673980712890625, -0.4743140935897827, -0.04395261034369469, 0.9092979431152344, -0.042650006711483, 0.7153252363204956, 0.38142868876457214, 0.3039710521697998, 0.41594845056533813, -0.03264384716749191, 0.253486305475235, -0.2399711310863495, 0.38839054107666016, -0.15531674027442932, -0.7789307832717896, 0.06606431305408478, 0.2952817976474762, 0.7961907982826233, 0.40107664465904236, 0.32622140645980835, -0.04862184822559357, -0.004515157546848059, 0.11946593225002289, -0.49225756525993347, 0.26601216197013855, -0.5910405516624451, -0.1283150613307953, -0.45961621403694153, -0.4763040840625763, -0.8289751410484314, -0.788268506526947, 0.08749829977750778, -0.542439877986908, 0.37354394793510437, 0.27393439412117004, 1.0063824653625488, -0.06335821747779846, -0.5174500346183777, -0.7342230677604675, -0.7111432552337646, 0.9883958101272583, -0.5992507934570312, -0.16699104011058807, 0.5850985646247864, 0.2839341163635254, 0.11642882972955704, -0.5807510614395142, -0.4109068214893341, -0.7194186449050903, -0.6021336913108826, -0.07271700352430344, -0.0272603090852499, 0.044332798570394516, 0.2942003905773163, 0.3464851975440979, -0.3175114095211029, -0.08179797232151031, -0.2750116288661957, -0.27690672874450684, 0.7028446197509766, -0.18428607285022736, 0.5072844624519348, -0.6445670127868652, -0.3097021281719208, -0.17791104316711426, -0.8173231482505798, 0.0908195897936821, 0.6848009824752808, 0.3777986466884613, 0.06629253923892975, 0.44376707077026367, 0.45460957288742065, 0.16410677134990692, -0.055451806634664536, 0.20422598719596863, 0.07682381570339203, -0.22344808280467987, -0.044113609939813614, 0.30717384815216064, 0.6706326007843018, -0.1612509936094284, 0.5697516798973083, -0.09643363952636719, -0.13124561309814453, -0.2884584367275238, 0.4243852198123932, -0.37577158212661743, -0.26999539136886597, -0.03783541917800903, -0.3296082317829132, -0.3743495047092438, 0.1719154268503189, -0.23319903016090393, -0.8482788801193237, -0.33189657330513, 0.4149511754512787, -0.3061791956424713, -0.2909180521965027, -0.4005056619644165, -0.4682031273841858, 0.07312239706516266, 0.49515867233276367, -0.9058949947357178, -0.06954245269298553, 0.3945944607257843, 0.5997543334960938, 0.12589173018932343, -0.18365252017974854, -0.34055715799331665, 0.2503710091114044, -0.5938851833343506, 0.7698171138763428, -0.6525225639343262, -0.2380748987197876, 0.2111130654811859, 0.17342139780521393, -0.44757044315338135, -0.31303223967552185, 0.6064532399177551, -0.3783796727657318, 0.25234320759773254, -0.7226470112800598, -0.8180000185966492, 0.012190128676593304, -0.1751318871974945, -0.9118106961250305, 0.609092116355896, 0.09213446080684662, -0.7645652890205383, 0.23965896666049957, -0.33517441153526306, -0.23599733412265778, 0.2016686648130417, -0.6016541123390198, -0.21656252443790436, 0.293590247631073, -0.040009092539548874, 0.6294745802879333, -0.4673919677734375, 0.19938191771507263, -0.16150619089603424, -0.3215959072113037, 0.7301943898200989, -0.14165626466274261, 1.0407925844192505, 0.40670064091682434, -0.0819496363401413, 0.021298399195075035, -0.5453376770019531, -0.033589765429496765, 0.23496749997138977, 0.18312805891036987, -0.5484854578971863, 0.10179325193166733, 0.41284629702568054, -0.5489915013313293, 0.20949725806713104, -0.6393336653709412, 0.12800738215446472, -0.15862248837947845, 0.441368043422699, 0.6217727661132812, 0.1505928337574005, 0.13376742601394653, -0.7320254445075989, 0.6754021048545837, -0.46223872900009155, -0.5314669013023376, -0.36757180094718933, -0.40902411937713623, -0.45223867893218994, -0.8092354536056519, 0.5183601379394531, 0.5916712284088135, -0.7592962384223938, 0.6595437526702881, 0.03692743927240372, -0.5123647451400757, -0.2186487466096878, -0.2855345606803894, 0.5308605432510376, 0.18844196200370789, 0.1269284039735794, 0.08759605139493942, -0.5250391960144043, -0.9213200807571411, -0.6497102975845337, -0.6864861845970154, -0.47130444645881653, 0.28841108083724976, 0.5364859104156494, 0.20852059125900269, 1.133953332901001, -0.5786980390548706, -0.19859354197978973, -0.39929622411727905, 0.6002457141876221, -0.11171354353427887, 0.5808756351470947, 1.056870698928833, -0.7234662175178528, -0.6013643741607666, -0.007897470146417618, -0.9275364875793457, -0.27115118503570557, -0.26355335116386414, 0.04497348889708519, -0.376508891582489, 0.8047698140144348, -0.5737435817718506, 0.4200059473514557, -0.05439404398202896, -0.34963759779930115, 0.7810717821121216, -0.0508505254983902, 0.6110755205154419, -0.9260867834091187, 0.15268826484680176, -0.07691947370767593, -0.4312378168106079, -0.6498343348503113, -0.0002836362982634455, -0.012644987553358078, -0.12139182537794113, -0.1394779086112976, 0.6107572317123413, -0.6278265118598938, 0.25777173042297363, 0.06621729582548141, 0.020505055785179138, 0.2833973467350006, 0.3771878480911255, 0.33241528272628784, 0.798873245716095, 0.14858829975128174, -0.26510071754455566, 0.38379108905792236, 0.20800600945949554, -0.676920473575592, 0.7080607414245605, -0.6328409314155579, 0.2085440754890442, -0.25647982954978943, 0.26638132333755493, -1.4765706062316895, -0.568630039691925, -0.09277929365634918, -0.3788868486881256, 0.3990419805049896, -0.35150349140167236, -0.6185585856437683, -0.0014556067762896419, -0.18489639461040497, 0.3955681324005127, 0.5092453360557556, -0.27064427733421326, 0.7558971643447876, 0.1990552395582199, -0.6698395609855652, -0.14982815086841583, -0.644221305847168, -0.11791722476482391, -0.48403239250183105, -0.5406774282455444, 0.43542802333831787, 0.06678687036037445, -0.5206174850463867, -0.2567008137702942, 0.3591349720954895, -0.5274736881256104, -0.013627003878355026, 0.02550126612186432, 0.31182965636253357, -0.2631484270095825, 0.10886672884225845, 0.1830410212278366, 0.3119896352291107, 0.0872514545917511, 0.2985781729221344, 0.01629655621945858, 0.3495734930038452, -0.19130171835422516, -0.6189114451408386, 0.6063302755355835, 0.6084430813789368, -0.005213855765759945, 0.6522474884986877, 0.2854973077774048, -0.36211979389190674, -0.20351764559745789, -0.6697472333908081, -0.24746902287006378, -0.47046029567718506, 0.15677347779273987, -0.39027929306030273, -0.6209946870803833, 0.8521755337715149, 0.31556662917137146, -0.27547386288642883, 0.542150616645813, 0.1704273670911789, -0.34584328532218933, 0.44560706615448, 0.4577041268348694, 0.3233012557029724, 0.6434377431869507, 0.212039977312088, 0.07573169469833374, -0.495571106672287, 0.02605995535850525, -1.0580270290374756, 0.02076822891831398, -0.507909893989563, -0.24162103235721588, 0.23162145912647247, -0.20120207965373993, -0.03807787224650383, 0.6476771235466003, -0.39142441749572754, 0.9025334715843201, 0.6116141676902771, -0.00933376420289278, 0.057944782078266144, 0.03164537250995636, -0.09201180189847946, -0.35774990916252136, -0.02765519730746746, -0.7804067730903625, 0.9124044179916382, 0.42996469140052795, 0.530563473701477, 0.2554701268672943, 0.5925325751304626, 0.8850646615028381, -0.17059393227100372, -0.4872888922691345, 0.433280885219574, -0.0366646982729435, -1.1010751724243164, -0.30849650502204895, -0.4933757483959198, -0.7487027049064636, 0.14414052665233612, -0.1158115342259407, -0.9753578901290894, 0.576496958732605, 0.04541381448507309, -0.6547501683235168, 0.2018200159072876, -0.6880539059638977, 0.6749151349067688, 0.1021319180727005, -0.25916406512260437, -0.026637258008122444, -0.4344138503074646, 0.12438590079545975, -0.04084865748882294, -0.005414998158812523, -0.04538732022047043, 0.46687912940979004, 0.8827846050262451, -0.36951950192451477, 0.8939692974090576, -0.24764768779277802, -0.32814091444015503, 0.5342592597007751, 0.18410424888134003, 0.6621506810188293, -0.2730902433395386, -0.23063603043556213, 0.177992045879364, 0.47854143381118774, -0.3012637794017792, -0.45397913455963135, 0.4038603603839874, -0.755201518535614, -0.39991724491119385, -0.5413119792938232, -0.27393367886543274, -0.40081286430358887, 0.045509371906518936, 0.7377614378929138, 0.6253068447113037, -0.5989699363708496, 0.38425368070602417, 0.5051776766777039, -0.2533898949623108, 0.17756113409996033, 0.13933269679546356, -0.009961696341633797, -0.40613776445388794, 0.573570191860199, 0.22269627451896667, 0.31424587965011597, 0.5714462399482727, -0.10483334213495255, -0.33576399087905884, -0.29931411147117615, -0.4079538881778717, 0.5148393511772156, -0.8872073292732239, 0.2018023580312729, -0.4281320571899414, -0.2690393030643463, -0.584500253200531, -0.41531580686569214, -0.3337777554988861, -0.46607542037963867, -0.45130765438079834, 0.0849839523434639, 0.3020137846469879, 1.0989882946014404, 0.4561847448348999, 0.4339618980884552, -0.4355151951313019, 0.054897233843803406, 0.25827306509017944, -0.27060991525650024, 0.03688519448041916, -0.6748068332672119, -0.29764240980148315, -0.1996312290430069, -0.19191299378871918, -1.0181338787078857, 0.3582420349121094, 0.06471781432628632, 0.4648589491844177, 0.3759450912475586, 0.19210147857666016, 0.3613457679748535, -0.653243362903595, 1.0476577281951904, 0.12903104722499847, -1.0247200727462769, 0.3286748230457306, -0.7142267823219299, -0.1648084670305252, 0.7481999397277832, 0.3641066551208496, -0.42194145917892456, -0.5726967453956604, -0.5550171136856079, -0.37715375423431396, 0.7470964193344116, 0.5778131484985352, 0.2142496556043625, 0.0778651237487793, 0.32533854246139526, 0.1919759213924408, 0.3365824222564697, -0.7134634852409363, -0.03657116740942001, 0.06852889060974121, -0.4306272268295288, -0.22918204963207245, -0.586148202419281, -0.35008588433265686, -0.07397785037755966, 0.33815798163414, 0.009821995161473751, 0.6625627875328064, 0.44167381525039673, -0.25636258721351624, 0.1528276950120926, 0.14688140153884888, 0.6595751643180847, 0.6241926550865173, -0.305569589138031, 0.03685197979211807, -0.3491702675819397, -0.28713998198509216, 0.07279469072818756, -0.07837288081645966, -0.0494513139128685, 0.34401074051856995, 1.029754400253296, 0.7769582867622375, 0.2613193988800049, -0.24444791674613953, 0.684461772441864, 0.09917090088129044, -0.047978948801755905, -0.8055197596549988, 0.09830902516841888, -0.09984156489372253, 0.32835662364959717, 0.5371271371841431, 0.19335350394248962, 0.23619745671749115, -0.692116379737854, -0.02464263141155243, 0.3909492790699005, -0.22205331921577454, -0.5067296028137207, 0.5620241761207581, 0.28047558665275574, -0.08847363293170929, 0.22428174316883087, 0.0041104089468717575, -0.4092208445072174, 0.819258987903595, 0.2720465660095215, 1.3468722105026245, -0.30417898297309875, 0.24613237380981445, 0.20513902604579926, 0.2346644252538681, 0.12426415085792542, -0.12084965407848358, -0.17442958056926727, -0.6963892579078674, -0.11475515365600586, -0.43742403388023376, -0.6866727471351624, -0.10658816248178482, -0.6431393623352051, 0.29798951745033264, -0.5809458494186401, -0.17324958741664886, 0.2995241582393646, -0.16357144713401794, -0.30502378940582275, 0.03532429784536362, 0.482781320810318, 0.23765496909618378, -1.0491888523101807, 0.772185206413269, 0.32928499579429626, -0.5708509683609009, -0.6826699376106262, 0.15433652698993683, 0.2325429469347, -0.4580555856227875, 0.7873873114585876, 0.21127445995807648, -0.21685416996479034, 0.0230838805437088, -0.5702458620071411, -0.6709269881248474, 0.7574825882911682, 0.7243478298187256, -0.2554420232772827, -0.44523048400878906, -0.007632382679730654, 0.3794030547142029, -0.6381220817565918, 0.7084126472473145, 0.00993383675813675, 0.4407925605773926, 0.286338210105896, -1.1437616348266602, -0.16143451631069183, -0.35272517800331116, 0.0015139798633754253, -0.2887542247772217, -0.298986554145813, 1.1081699132919312, 0.2737533152103424, -0.30567097663879395, 0.5624286532402039, 0.8020520806312561, 0.031273357570171356, 0.11782840639352798, 0.3707379400730133, -0.25632160902023315, 1.2491366863250732, -0.10928910225629807, 1.1194908618927002, 0.08338721096515656, 0.20324404537677765, 1.0844773054122925, -0.35555580258369446, 0.6182276010513306, 0.20992660522460938, -0.35441240668296814, 0.837035059928894, 0.42568740248680115, -0.07403334975242615, 0.5331112742424011, 0.15349316596984863, -0.35295921564102173, -0.23086482286453247, -0.15838764607906342, -0.4948037564754486, 0.29255199432373047, -0.09931409358978271, -0.8307895064353943, 0.4325144290924072, 0.16871377825737, 0.2578469216823578, 0.37506431341171265, -0.12845221161842346, 0.6058352589607239, 0.14233820140361786, -0.684120774269104, 0.5476335883140564, -0.015069326385855675, 0.4247554838657379, -0.9545242190361023, 0.05680326372385025, 0.14402063190937042, 0.24063293635845184, -0.18997547030448914, -0.29292187094688416, 0.050106748938560486, 0.021961862221360207, -0.44039633870124817, -0.4911225438117981, 0.6093552112579346, -0.48754340410232544, -0.6536425352096558, 0.017945798113942146, 0.032732415944337845, 0.32983270287513733, -0.138835147023201, -0.10661491751670837, 0.003298965049907565, 0.19876787066459656, -0.253803014755249, -0.1485849916934967, 0.5334674715995789, 0.06249381601810455, 0.19784849882125854, 0.39817407727241516, 0.2866189777851105, -0.1135169118642807, -0.08621130883693695, 0.35077109932899475, -0.8309868574142456, -0.6665425300598145, -0.7597264647483826, 0.49091461300849915, -0.3430636525154114, -0.40933558344841003, 1.0435471534729004, 0.17442908883094788, 0.43865683674812317, -0.5418386459350586, 0.8582170605659485, -0.011100786738097668, 0.8132169842720032, -0.7426867485046387, 1.0666199922561646, -0.524360716342926, 0.19730280339717865, -0.6028054356575012, -0.851129949092865, -0.08429186791181564, 0.9195940494537354, -0.41510745882987976, 0.27158087491989136, 0.91490238904953, 0.7287858724594116, 0.09229470789432526, 0.4909467399120331, 0.39858412742614746, 0.09128223359584808, 0.22882138192653656, 0.07958120107650757, 0.9411566853523254, -0.3001577854156494, -0.24712160229682922, 0.37475350499153137, -0.09237127006053925, -0.2648412585258484, -0.8416767120361328, -1.0764474868774414, -0.7802191972732544, -0.5634480118751526, -0.18412093818187714, -0.08421126753091812, 0.9422895312309265, 0.7238139510154724, -0.8651437163352966, -0.3867528736591339, 0.140068918466568, -0.0952441394329071, -0.1294361650943756, -0.1733786165714264, 0.22928377985954285, -0.2571069300174713, -0.8885281085968018, 0.5155082941055298, -0.14505062997341156, -0.041459422558546066, -0.34460189938545227, 0.21246807277202606, -0.17911341786384583, 0.8422980904579163, 0.17407287657260895, 0.2348184734582901, -0.9007208347320557, -0.3755750060081482, -0.2966119647026062, -0.29251113533973694, 0.09277012944221497, 1.0974719524383545, -0.2895619869232178, 0.3857208490371704, 0.4899935722351074, 0.2584034204483032, 0.21723850071430206, 0.0464969128370285, 0.7474149465560913, -0.921930730342865, 0.17941783368587494, 0.33453941345214844, 0.4787384271621704, 0.41984498500823975, -0.6731982827186584, 0.22207342088222504, 0.49124181270599365, -0.661319375038147, -0.9389264583587646, 0.3771669864654541, -0.8393657803535461, -0.20726728439331055, 1.046515703201294, -0.5058661699295044, -0.28626689314842224, -0.13615550100803375, -0.3494492769241333, -0.03348302096128464, -0.1810188740491867, 0.2557861804962158, 1.3498597145080566, 0.15745039284229279, 0.095737025141716, -0.32173338532447815, 0.7804653644561768, 0.4304225444793701, -0.46043428778648376, 0.5065305829048157, 0.695231556892395, -0.07572894543409348, 0.5762422680854797, 0.6251773238182068, -0.07268556952476501, -0.05710623785853386, 0.18598432838916779, 0.06910713762044907, 0.07161684334278107, -0.5713534355163574, 0.028115909546613693, 0.35183045268058777, 0.19450676441192627, 0.12780004739761353 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16960v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16960v1	Two Heads Are Better Than One: Integrating Knowledge from Knowledge Graphs and Large Language Models for Entity Alignment	2024-01-30T12:41:04	2024-01-30T12:41:04	Linyao Yang, Hongyang Chen, Xiao Wang, Jing Yang, Fei-Yue Wang, Han Liu	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Entity alignment, which is a prerequisite for creating a more comprehensive Knowledge Graph (KG), involves pinpointing equivalent entities across disparate KGs. Contemporary methods for entity alignment have predominantly utilized knowledge embedding models to procure entity embeddings that encapsulate various similarities-structural, relational, and attributive. These embeddings are then integrated through attention-based information fusion mechanisms. Despite this progress, effectively harnessing multifaceted information remains challenging due to inherent heterogeneity. Moreover, while Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited exceptional performance across diverse downstream tasks by implicitly capturing entity semantics, this implicit knowledge has yet to be exploited for entity alignment. In this study, we propose a Large Language Model-enhanced Entity Alignment framework (LLMEA), integrating structural knowledge from KGs with semantic knowledge from LLMs to enhance entity alignment. Specifically, LLMEA identifies candidate alignments for a given entity by considering both embedding similarities between entities across KGs and edit distances to a virtual equivalent entity. It then engages an LLM iteratively, posing multiple multi-choice questions to draw upon the LLM's inference capability. The final prediction of the equivalent entity is derived from the LLM's output. Experiments conducted on three public datasets reveal that LLMEA surpasses leading baseline models. Additional ablation studies underscore the efficacy of our proposed framework.	[ -0.286784291267395, -0.6619309782981873, 0.9732235670089722, -0.07120580226182938, -0.11918800324201584, 0.22473567724227905, -0.18998251855373383, -0.6215951442718506, 0.2809921205043793, 0.44763073325157166, -0.20367711782455444, -0.5915088653564453, -0.6168470978736877, -0.12507857382297516, -0.40600940585136414, 0.7724446058273315, -0.14973241090774536, 0.0377253033220768, -0.2815709710121155, -0.17163576185703278, -0.4599916338920593, 0.06764686107635498, -0.4690159559249878, -0.38479161262512207, 0.6833785772323608, 0.08392670005559921, 0.6978186964988708, 0.8819583654403687, 0.4567568898200989, 0.2295648157596588, 0.13778872787952423, 0.41466543078422546, -0.31855490803718567, 0.001835030852816999, -0.5363001823425293, -0.19698643684387207, -0.5782856941223145, -0.3940649628639221, 0.8387016654014587, 0.9145702123641968, -0.1757681965827942, 0.19630269706249237, 0.1373450756072998, 0.4036817252635956, -0.6478109359741211, 0.23543766140937805, -0.8014581799507141, -0.3818720281124115, -0.26387280225753784, 0.14993351697921753, -0.22523078322410583, -0.3958936929702759, 0.2420196235179901, -0.7354646921157837, -0.451752245426178, 0.28865334391593933, 1.1122208833694458, 0.5634329319000244, -0.770206868648529, -0.24891260266304016, -0.528845489025116, 0.5294156670570374, -0.5423880815505981, 0.8516314625740051, -0.2788200080394745, 0.12255194783210754, -0.07781901210546494, -0.4935804605484009, -0.8131500482559204, 0.2237074375152588, -0.08133427053689957, 0.04918670654296875, -0.14037154614925385, 0.1095067709684372, 0.011863932944834232, 0.06269148737192154, -0.4514314532279968, 0.317298948764801, -0.021136460825800896, -0.1696140617132187, 0.2723948359489441, -0.14324648678302765, 0.4407022297382355, -0.0029595997184515, -0.5422571897506714, 0.13562649488449097, -0.9232062697410583, -0.2795206606388092, 0.30596527457237244, 0.44916853308677673, 0.07103459537029266, 0.9331356883049011, 0.036500830203294754, 0.6796331405639648, 0.26945382356643677, -0.33240410685539246, 0.14904358983039856, -0.24982880055904388, -0.2761392593383789, 0.4202483892440796, 0.6737197637557983, 0.5030193328857422, 0.2561761736869812, -0.4997900724411011, -0.04974288493394852, 0.1708824187517166, 0.2130287140607834, -0.7349517941474915, -0.014885292388498783, 0.3422476649284363, -0.07739046216011047, -0.005183075089007616, -0.08516916632652283, -0.722484290599823, -0.4922865033149719, -0.6502053737640381, 0.2885596454143524, -0.5435724258422852, -0.35545435547828674, 0.0002526990429032594, -0.04046549275517464, 0.33172130584716797, 0.3270561099052429, -0.8637162446975708, -0.025689031928777695, 0.9168171882629395, 0.694523811340332, -0.15406347811222076, -0.2876758277416229, -0.2912610173225403, 0.9467288255691528, -0.22723603248596191, 0.8236465454101562, -0.5769736170768738, 0.23351924121379852, 0.09257379174232483, 0.009771750308573246, -0.13222482800483704, -0.2942521274089813, 0.18658028542995453, -0.8526408672332764, -0.1790388524532318, -0.3426801264286041, -0.8918112516403198, -0.25385236740112305, 0.2714797258377075, -0.6646033525466919, 0.7766274809837341, 0.17183329164981842, -0.8111728429794312, 0.460533082485199, -0.38475501537323, -0.24528802931308746, -0.13084305822849274, -0.4059731364250183, -0.397413969039917, -0.1123436838388443, 0.3391186594963074, 0.40760350227355957, -0.3756639361381531, 0.4788013696670532, -0.6292505264282227, 0.046378228813409805, 0.024368256330490112, 0.07375703752040863, 0.5954402089118958, -0.03553719446063042, -0.19580231606960297, -0.10361283272504807, -0.6291388273239136, -0.08015942573547363, 0.1173054426908493, -0.36240485310554504, -0.5457573533058167, -0.23800401389598846, -0.3634090721607208, 0.21016258001327515, 0.456259161233902, -0.4824647307395935, 0.3535315990447998, -0.4335628151893616, 0.2190859615802765, 0.7009486556053162, 0.038406457751989365, 0.7723820805549622, -0.0852673128247261, 0.21969425678253174, 0.1351822018623352, -0.42762866616249084, 0.19605652987957, -0.2718797028064728, -0.4439075291156769, -0.36897942423820496, 0.5585192441940308, 0.645045816898346, -0.7301755547523499, 0.497639000415802, -0.8654918074607849, -0.3275918960571289, -0.7396039366722107, 0.3827061057090759, 0.3255173861980438, 0.8479791283607483, 0.3669012784957886, -0.27853086590766907, -0.5242705345153809, -0.9215214848518372, -0.23094773292541504, -0.17530134320259094, 0.016995662823319435, 0.2678648829460144, 0.32379665970802307, -0.16707001626491547, 0.8313663005828857, -0.3791579306125641, -0.3451464772224426, 0.00450187036767602, -0.2886698246002197, -0.10175831615924835, 0.49606946110725403, 0.5068016648292542, -0.5353277921676636, -0.30813509225845337, 0.44332459568977356, -0.9485023021697998, 0.0710941031575203, 0.041448693722486496, -0.6796413660049438, -0.1568129062652588, 0.15844035148620605, -0.8546955585479736, -0.18990293145179749, 0.5178585052490234, -0.1920190304517746, 0.10701847076416016, 0.2341294288635254, 0.2309020757675171, -1.2102625370025635, 0.13315309584140778, 0.07398507744073868, -0.25097763538360596, -0.5861780047416687, 0.14836980402469635, 0.39368122816085815, 0.03910410776734352, -0.20815803110599518, 0.5877811908721924, -0.567270815372467, -0.4159727096557617, 0.014524624682962894, 0.6439098119735718, 0.15783683955669403, 0.4082077741622925, 0.06911219656467438, 0.5567122101783752, 0.4387325644493103, -0.5335068702697754, 0.3773728013038635, 0.5382241606712341, -0.37666550278663635, 0.9788199663162231, -0.3348076343536377, 0.2379935085773468, -0.30615368485450745, 0.2699749171733856, -0.6969330310821533, -0.3809141516685486, 0.19952617585659027, -0.1802092343568802, 0.8015506267547607, -0.23583371937274933, -0.32282647490501404, -0.21183183789253235, -0.12152747809886932, 0.33072003722190857, 0.13568958640098572, -0.5892931222915649, 1.1884881258010864, 0.5935336947441101, -0.2750225365161896, -1.122256875038147, -0.5798081755638123, 0.04665132611989975, -0.2595866918563843, -0.8889451026916504, 0.6529628038406372, 0.3193472623825073, -0.23070064187049866, 0.4287738502025604, -0.13139547407627106, 0.12001530081033707, 0.029373278841376305, -0.010657122358679771, 0.44931870698928833, -0.4999273419380188, 0.41759181022644043, 0.24543626606464386, -0.03832710161805153, -0.1639738827943802, -0.8479213118553162, 0.4485434293746948, 0.22032295167446136, -0.542598307132721, -0.3261198103427887, 0.3367897868156433, 0.4740588665008545, -0.4514558017253876, 0.9474194645881653, 0.3677477240562439, -0.6962316632270813, 0.24874356389045715, -0.8791919350624084, 0.024090763181447983, -0.34184354543685913, 0.555199146270752, -0.4526910185813904, -0.8206872940063477, 0.3474216163158417, -0.40842095017433167, 0.3609161972999573, 0.36008045077323914, 0.42954912781715393, -0.14805684983730316, 1.0381940603256226, 0.699750542640686, -0.19695152342319489, 0.2463976889848709, 0.08237279951572418, 0.5312140583992004, -1.0727487802505493, -0.2595914304256439, -0.5154721736907959, -0.16762812435626984, -0.3901572525501251, -0.3474882245063782, 0.024567846208810806, 0.3459187150001526, -0.3793463110923767, 0.44775184988975525, -0.3304254412651062, 0.345104455947876, 0.19783742725849152, 0.039499424397945404, 0.35961687564849854, -0.010719586163759232, -0.0803961530327797, 0.07369103282690048, -0.5160109400749207, -0.7024195194244385, 1.1538050174713135, 0.38050708174705505, 0.5968292951583862, 0.36452239751815796, 0.7078863978385925, -0.3664216101169586, 0.5506700277328491, -0.7259135246276855, 0.2054295837879181, -0.05718119814991951, -0.44109323620796204, -0.4410547614097595, -0.31498783826828003, -0.6521326899528503, 0.3054451644420624, -0.22697317600250244, -0.9611836671829224, 0.19143414497375488, 0.30029067397117615, -0.46265891194343567, 0.3621504604816437, -0.6831946969032288, 0.8937955498695374, -0.23404532670974731, -0.35340118408203125, 0.1030636727809906, -0.39356979727745056, 0.4629242420196533, -0.2754826843738556, 0.3223258852958679, -0.14348164200782776, -0.2588132321834564, 0.4490082859992981, 0.011994432657957077, 0.5611447691917419, -0.16333699226379395, -0.5988870859146118, 0.08728758990764618, -0.11819284409284592, 0.9379863739013672, -0.14584092795848846, -0.09713936597108841, 0.005489610135555267, -0.240534245967865, -0.28328070044517517, -0.859892725944519, 0.8819673657417297, -0.6189109086990356, -0.6858558058738708, 0.23002022504806519, -0.5232803225517273, -0.4405919313430786, 0.3122542202472687, -0.15468575060367584, 0.1622166931629181, -0.0453481450676918, 0.057986315339803696, 0.7716898322105408, 0.0628846064209938, -0.027353430166840553, 0.3882371187210083, -0.22599010169506073, -0.3846421539783478, 0.9408719539642334, 0.25284069776535034, 0.30958279967308044, 0.6362215280532837, -0.23360320925712585, -0.5854286551475525, -0.4828726649284363, -0.7431939840316772, 0.49173787236213684, -0.9001684784889221, -0.38086998462677, -1.1757583618164062, 0.1491249054670334, -0.8300692439079285, -0.12391704320907593, -0.40051332116127014, -0.22311334311962128, -0.007403767667710781, -0.23935893177986145, 0.06965681910514832, 0.5378443598747253, 0.1665319949388504, 0.023063814267516136, -0.6758013963699341, 0.17448920011520386, 0.4317032992839813, 0.26313772797584534, 0.07453031092882156, -0.2042953372001648, -0.04870736971497536, -0.04008834436535835, -0.18176352977752686, -1.1743061542510986, 0.07788769155740738, 0.08100523799657822, 0.6552854180335999, 0.3308168053627014, -0.25766417384147644, 0.8783329129219055, -0.5503360629081726, 0.399558961391449, 0.2683089077472687, -0.9801192879676819, 0.3277222514152527, -0.03559585288167, 0.026064690202474594, 0.43534204363822937, 0.5260778069496155, -0.43199196457862854, -0.5365044474601746, -0.30886635184288025, -0.8373697996139526, 0.3330562710762024, -0.08959034085273743, -0.15494707226753235, 0.06759452819824219, 0.3538760840892792, -0.12728415429592133, 0.305664598941803, -0.7405588626861572, -0.13290050625801086, 0.11476680636405945, -0.8791693449020386, 0.15440817177295685, -0.09789295494556427, -0.24830885231494904, 0.12256286293268204, 0.958789587020874, -0.4308320879936218, 0.12159176170825958, -0.12527905404567719, -0.5156106352806091, -0.19881512224674225, 0.24020026624202728, 0.18242406845092773, 0.7125027179718018, 0.154539093375206, 0.38597074151039124, 0.4324090778827667, -0.11835496127605438, 0.09887682646512985, 0.33271273970603943, -0.18118175864219666, -0.32383108139038086, 0.3343167304992676, 0.6574903130531311, 0.47574469447135925, -0.42993661761283875, 0.472051739692688, 0.36149856448173523, 0.1296042799949646, -0.025992073118686676, -0.21046431362628937, 0.7889938354492188, 0.578937828540802, 0.056939009577035904, -0.3603355288505554, -0.025867551565170288, -0.42830750346183777, 0.15055590867996216, 0.7043611407279968, -0.329384982585907, -0.008408716879785061, 0.6236423254013062, 0.054053518921136856, 0.10545767843723297, 0.496055006980896, 0.07242432236671448, -0.5652686953544617, 0.43818411231040955, 0.4835421144962311, 0.42766162753105164, -0.4109996557235718, -0.16067495942115784, 0.36550959944725037, 0.27212071418762207, 0.054575368762016296, 0.028806613758206367, 0.06218191981315613, -0.9724693894386292, -0.5680528283119202, -0.7682197690010071, -0.0668184757232666, -0.14853335916996002, -0.42311105132102966, 0.3519722819328308, -0.13667169213294983, -0.0024489699862897396, 0.34279105067253113, -0.11333447694778442, -0.905619740486145, 0.04369426146149635, 0.18470357358455658, 0.6062176823616028, -0.7894972562789917, 0.7812604308128357, 0.8509984612464905, -0.5445882081985474, -1.1251379251480103, -0.0998518094420433, 0.13426710665225983, -0.9288185834884644, 0.5332883596420288, 0.21945537626743317, -0.06798557937145233, 0.2718583643436432, -0.25700831413269043, -1.2701387405395508, 1.5091663599014282, 0.7576769590377808, -0.915908932685852, -0.4246312379837036, 0.13138988614082336, 0.14630703628063202, -0.6397493481636047, 0.09300265461206436, 0.7028606534004211, 0.6132339239120483, 0.07541120797395706, -0.7647689580917358, 0.24796386063098907, 0.18855677545070648, -0.01552534382790327, 0.5165217518806458, -0.5252317190170288, 0.4913572072982788, -0.22672699391841888, -0.5799794793128967, -0.26057198643684387, 0.890155017375946, 0.19345349073410034, 0.07215404510498047, 0.5450494289398193, 0.9012203216552734, 1.108585238456726, -0.057736586779356, 0.8228297829627991, -0.5452063679695129, 0.22106918692588806, 1.3335745334625244, -0.6311245560646057, 0.6514620184898376, 0.6372175812721252, -0.10012132674455643, 0.5668467879295349, 0.44789204001426697, 0.1146913468837738, 0.3921896815299988, -0.008917013183236122, -0.09888371080160141, -0.3884868025779724, -0.3195980489253998, -0.24743147194385529, 0.2950597405433655, 0.2957709729671478, -0.4171971082687378, -0.2554931640625, -0.14026424288749695, -0.01854659989476204, -0.05540956184267998, -0.12220770120620728, 1.024208426475525, 0.06918396800756454, -0.7312523722648621, 0.0019215786596760154, -0.10962844640016556, 0.3707524240016937, -0.2741684317588806, -0.09122344851493835, 0.10367053002119064, -0.04024764150381088, -0.23804830014705658, -0.8050183057785034, 0.13508766889572144, -0.10932580381631851, -0.1975797861814499, 0.00015750349848531187, 0.7903501987457275, -0.8279433250427246, -0.15220700204372406, 0.47785988450050354, 0.5004506707191467, -0.07209835201501846, 0.015560389496386051, -0.5285986065864563, -0.09252005070447922, -0.0869387835264206, -0.15369540452957153, 0.33987095952033997, 0.6013633012771606, 0.08170139044523239, 0.545462965965271, 0.5227050185203552, -0.03863050043582916, 0.002846657996997237, 0.16589151322841644, 0.835422933101654, -0.4326522946357727, -0.32051289081573486, -0.8193961381912231, 0.5652477145195007, -0.35470375418663025, 0.031848110258579254, 0.43857571482658386, 0.5686569809913635, 0.8504213690757751, 0.3653661012649536, 0.6271581649780273, 0.07442506402730942, 0.33689090609550476, -0.7576974630355835, 0.3787168860435486, -0.5728530287742615, 0.15708906948566437, -0.31360647082328796, -1.3122408390045166, -0.07909683883190155, 0.3125276267528534, -0.17496086657047272, -0.1350266933441162, 0.6736825704574585, 0.805061936378479, -0.14054889976978302, -0.1276031881570816, 0.21590277552604675, 0.15140578150749207, 0.3689587116241455, 0.735111653804779, 0.6858604550361633, -0.21894299983978271, 0.5055897831916809, -0.10431016981601715, -0.1410180926322937, 0.08153854310512543, -0.9228735566139221, -0.6954797506332397, -0.4924179017543793, -0.45916929841041565, -0.30984166264533997, 0.09684188663959503, 1.0262395143508911, 0.43465831875801086, -0.6308907270431519, 0.4057486653327942, 0.10160773992538452, 0.2506100833415985, -0.017597798258066177, -0.1597287505865097, 0.4907761216163635, -0.1516771763563156, -0.9071295857429504, 0.20093606412410736, 0.4842665195465088, 0.2550193667411804, -0.30513623356819153, 0.1232210099697113, -0.2650452256202698, 0.015032842755317688, 0.349895179271698, 0.04746640846133232, -0.9142158627510071, -0.627402126789093, -0.06194736063480377, -0.3848802149295807, -0.027908101677894592, 0.4983873665332794, -0.41465094685554504, 0.21814095973968506, 0.2782844305038452, 1.2604821920394897, 0.2745608389377594, 0.02560664899647236, 0.6566500067710876, -0.663725733757019, -0.19434261322021484, 0.03310282528400421, 0.6105402112007141, 0.598689615726471, -0.5890964269638062, 0.45774605870246887, -0.05714431405067444, -0.3436231315135956, -0.6917606592178345, 0.3169163167476654, -0.8329477310180664, -0.0530259944498539, 1.087565541267395, -0.3167780637741089, -0.38658270239830017, -0.05367276072502136, 0.0916784405708313, 0.6881164908409119, -0.3382405638694763, 0.5346051454544067, 0.7591747641563416, 0.1574638932943344, -0.09582778811454773, -0.31889644265174866, 0.20858100056648254, 0.37383008003234863, -1.0000051259994507, 0.049332525581121445, 0.4759526252746582, 0.3211284875869751, 0.4736414849758148, 0.34976693987846375, -0.1366671472787857, 0.08921854943037033, -0.1936424970626831, 0.19603045284748077, 0.03236951306462288, -0.3330993056297302, -0.13097846508026123, 0.29163917899131775, 0.06749007105827332, 0.1591646820306778 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01758v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01758v1	Aalap: AI Assistant for Legal & Paralegal Functions in India	2024-01-30T12:39:58	2024-01-30T12:39:58	Aman Tiwari, Prathamesh Kalamkar, Atreyo Banerjee, Saurabh Karn, Varun Hemachandran, Smita Gupta	cs.CY	cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL	Using proprietary Large Language Models on legal tasks poses challenges due to data privacy issues, domain data heterogeneity, domain knowledge sophistication, and domain objectives uniqueness. We created Aalalp, a fine-tuned Mistral 7B model on instructions data related to specific Indian legal tasks. The performance of Aalap is better than gpt-3.5-turbo in 31\% of our test data and obtains an equivalent score in 34\% of the test data as evaluated by GPT4. Training Aalap mainly focuses on teaching legal reasoning rather than legal recall. Aalap is definitely helpful for the day-to-day activities of lawyers, judges, or anyone working in legal systems.	[ -0.12202445417642593, -0.6069217324256897, 0.17864948511123657, 0.256931334733963, -0.1638624519109726, -0.17563308775424957, 0.22727347910404205, -0.647499680519104, 0.07297083735466003, 0.04738835245370865, 0.04749422147870064, -0.19275052845478058, -0.5686407089233398, 0.03149710223078728, -0.6036340594291687, 0.7351319789886475, 0.237226203083992, 0.382525235414505, 0.04332232475280762, -0.3733956217765808, -0.749521017074585, -0.6091691255569458, -1.1548742055892944, -0.09365745633840561, 0.01825694926083088, 0.05043691024184227, 0.9142195582389832, 0.518050491809845, 0.7381747961044312, 0.2836850583553314, 0.060918934643268585, -0.21512770652770996, 0.1506493091583252, 0.2409362494945526, -0.060124367475509644, -0.6140304207801819, -0.6969590783119202, -0.09722879528999329, 0.35293737053871155, 0.2650856375694275, -0.6498405337333679, 0.2052338868379593, -0.09921671450138092, 1.0438116788864136, -0.7854348421096802, 0.4601028263568878, -0.43857112526893616, 0.09824060648679733, -0.13852714002132416, -0.039315152913331985, -0.1886654496192932, -0.5523470640182495, -0.23528335988521576, -0.41261085867881775, 0.2245936095714569, 0.26204580068588257, 0.729492723941803, 0.5491666197776794, -0.24412454664707184, -0.6887695789337158, -0.7064737677574158, 0.18022431433200836, -0.7616555690765381, 0.33269086480140686, 0.620415449142456, 0.5884985327720642, 0.24646243453025818, -0.5711277723312378, -0.6701319813728333, -0.4547262191772461, 0.21257759630680084, -0.03414125367999077, -0.12782040238380432, 0.2942690849304199, 0.2502123713493347, 0.36298438906669617, -0.7134813666343689, -0.02564929611980915, -0.7160726189613342, -0.11432124674320221, 0.9866694808006287, 0.14015226066112518, 0.5521464943885803, 0.17791427671909332, 0.12154124677181244, 0.013885068707168102, -0.7472516894340515, 0.2800610363483429, 0.3603040874004364, 0.15769927203655243, -0.15548932552337646, 0.466975599527359, -0.02585594914853573, 0.9530481696128845, 0.18718217313289642, -0.09342948347330093, 0.09394989162683487, -0.1613214761018753, -0.3507767915725708, 0.3006329834461212, 0.633680522441864, 0.09069164842367172, 0.48157697916030884, 0.1408088654279709, -0.2290681153535843, -0.1746603548526764, 0.19585148990154266, -0.34907159209251404, -0.09302230924367905, 0.14529740810394287, -0.7574434280395508, 0.2814832031726837, -0.05866612121462822, -0.29183489084243774, -0.5302487015724182, -0.6040359735488892, 0.21497949957847595, -0.43122196197509766, 0.003526177955791354, 0.01645149290561676, 0.12189804762601852, 0.5944399833679199, 0.5281149744987488, -1.0096274614334106, 0.2890326976776123, 0.45429617166519165, 0.9299400448799133, -0.3142722547054291, -0.279256671667099, -0.7354426383972168, 0.1477729082107544, -0.4283919334411621, 0.7512611150741577, -0.7539827227592468, -0.3594321310520172, 0.2042854279279709, -0.4020952582359314, -0.2370113879442215, -0.6506937146186829, 0.48361170291900635, -0.5778220891952515, -0.28396254777908325, -0.19208277761936188, -0.4414486587047577, -0.24053706228733063, 0.20546521246433258, -0.5633276104927063, 0.624740719795227, 0.09813747555017471, -0.36169037222862244, 0.7649111747741699, -1.0095664262771606, -0.2773488759994507, 0.24352844059467316, -0.46675994992256165, -0.07277512550354004, -0.1702640950679779, 0.3548186421394348, 0.18929289281368256, -0.23206304013729095, 0.24078425765037537, -0.24001479148864746, -0.4177722930908203, -0.31658366322517395, -0.3938879072666168, 1.1603398323059082, 0.5514920949935913, -0.11561417579650879, 0.1968095451593399, -0.7577095031738281, -0.08914651721715927, -0.2425127476453781, -0.5148853659629822, -0.1550009548664093, -0.3004012107849121, -0.11773521453142166, 0.39954128861427307, 0.18248963356018066, -0.2753274440765381, 0.4494398534297943, -0.42374366521835327, 0.12272220104932785, 0.6125751733779907, 0.038528356701135635, 0.3287886083126068, -0.3182181119918823, 1.190816879272461, -0.3130491077899933, 0.2471655160188675, 0.15140263736248016, -0.9975118041038513, -0.6659707427024841, -0.029197022318840027, 0.5764421224594116, 0.9196568131446838, -0.4545529782772064, 0.3246215879917145, 0.23301811516284943, -0.26032331585884094, -1.1600769758224487, 0.435871422290802, 0.3295064866542816, 0.36780622601509094, 0.2862415313720703, -0.053269803524017334, -0.26315587759017944, -1.157984972000122, -0.24342003464698792, -0.4742351174354553, 0.327829509973526, -0.12565240263938904, 0.37130576372146606, 0.022725990042090416, 0.6347286105155945, -0.14043423533439636, -0.7852751016616821, -0.2535015046596527, 0.06878605484962463, 0.21768131852149963, 0.2973650097846985, 0.5990787148475647, -0.8917289972305298, -1.187686562538147, -0.01829625852406025, -0.866767406463623, -0.3251570165157318, -0.13888031244277954, 0.3399592936038971, 0.36889663338661194, 0.5664141774177551, -0.9599528312683105, 0.9169614911079407, -0.01494553592056036, -0.46518972516059875, 0.633905291557312, -0.5484873652458191, 0.37058085203170776, -0.8682091236114502, 0.13355356454849243, -0.256069153547287, -0.29250726103782654, -0.4979017376899719, 0.5321153998374939, 0.06572304666042328, -0.5102351903915405, -0.6824031472206116, 0.6705603003501892, -0.6955157518386841, -0.09511260688304901, -0.5391207933425903, -0.4638914465904236, -0.46341925859451294, 0.32399803400039673, -0.05891113355755806, 1.2667123079299927, 0.8296268582344055, -0.5254356265068054, 0.4917946457862854, 0.46510595083236694, 0.11343883723020554, 0.538894772529602, -0.603273332118988, 0.021993085741996765, -0.05388801917433739, 0.001775608048774302, -0.4447512924671173, -0.21209891140460968, 0.08608172088861465, -0.3719107508659363, 0.4011198878288269, -0.05488572642207146, -0.5094300508499146, -0.2711702287197113, -0.20738939940929413, 0.4078088700771332, 0.5669638514518738, -0.16231299936771393, 0.6806589961051941, 0.6299339532852173, -0.36203378438949585, -0.8320921063423157, -0.3275534212589264, 0.11068166047334671, -0.36791861057281494, -0.23287886381149292, -0.15314197540283203, 0.06379500776529312, -0.42717957496643066, -0.15938261151313782, 0.03327978029847145, -0.29707643389701843, -0.35162872076034546, 0.7423384189605713, -0.11425520479679108, -0.11061139404773712, -0.12127799540758133, 0.01310370210558176, -0.010278682224452496, 0.24784453213214874, 0.7090610861778259, 0.6763181686401367, -0.47803738713264465, -0.7990859746932983, -0.7887840270996094, 0.5144145488739014, 0.45300909876823425, 0.031108887866139412, 0.45127981901168823, 0.33351609110832214, -0.2796669602394104, 0.12312739342451096, -0.5659319162368774, 0.3825625479221344, -0.5319143533706665, 0.07957819104194641, -0.43992871046066284, -0.39448514580726624, 0.493813157081604, 0.5073844790458679, 0.09367693215608597, 0.6488398313522339, 0.8314812183380127, 0.22165346145629883, 0.9423701763153076, 0.680098295211792, -0.5227001309394836, 0.14947226643562317, -0.030589651316404343, 0.3852429986000061, -0.4565531015396118, -0.23654581606388092, -0.44831931591033936, 0.04152951389551163, -0.3033234477043152, -0.06455972790718079, 0.392920583486557, 0.15394005179405212, -0.3281375467777252, 0.26087820529937744, -0.659051239490509, 0.41345325112342834, 0.9099295735359192, -0.07236778736114502, 0.2564559876918793, -0.24603982269763947, 0.3295917510986328, 0.24823307991027832, -0.6060684323310852, -0.3468945324420929, 1.3382335901260376, 0.43781912326812744, 0.7139508724212646, 0.2590389549732208, 0.6795753836631775, 0.8572931289672852, 0.06677912175655365, -0.7097362875938416, 0.7331075668334961, 0.057471007108688354, -0.6388894319534302, -0.16342121362686157, 0.3448107838630676, -0.9388585686683655, -0.12949135899543762, -0.2760096788406372, -0.6269442439079285, 0.35900789499282837, 0.5035923719406128, -0.6651729941368103, -0.06886279582977295, -1.0580512285232544, 0.5833725929260254, 0.05071825161576271, -0.2766580581665039, -0.29263603687286377, -0.7875564694404602, 0.33983081579208374, -0.05360734090209007, 0.1886128932237625, -0.06843607127666473, 0.12405376881361008, 0.6702386736869812, -0.5602679252624512, 0.4360135793685913, -0.48099640011787415, 0.2931927740573883, 0.5822898745536804, 0.1754433810710907, 0.22253623604774475, 0.3093881905078888, -0.15027570724487305, -0.13981977105140686, 0.27473655343055725, -0.25681760907173157, -0.44527673721313477, 0.6932995915412903, -0.6097802519798279, -0.9330158233642578, -0.8244366645812988, -1.1037566661834717, -0.2871643006801605, 0.20202018320560455, -0.11842307448387146, -0.03554655238986015, 0.25743550062179565, 0.06062779575586319, 0.09786273539066315, -0.16046752035617828, 0.760195255279541, 0.50565505027771, -0.00042683599167503417, 0.05320434272289276, 0.7879186272621155, -0.10097730904817581, -0.08099579066038132, 0.09788458049297333, -0.13111156225204468, -0.7694076299667358, -0.6552736759185791, -0.421514630317688, 0.10374671965837479, -1.1035348176956177, -0.2836229205131531, -0.5878990888595581, -0.6738423109054565, -0.7279518246650696, -0.16219253838062286, -0.04765445739030838, -0.6366007924079895, 0.06189767271280289, 0.12811288237571716, 0.180047869682312, 0.8239898681640625, -0.30265748500823975, 0.1506725400686264, -0.7012224197387695, 0.5594767332077026, 0.4488975405693054, -0.011206677183508873, -0.15223735570907593, -0.6429299116134644, 0.09896481782197952, -0.24452565610408783, -0.5531706213951111, -0.8361648917198181, 0.38962775468826294, 0.49068063497543335, 0.6281582713127136, 0.6634353995323181, -0.29050734639167786, 0.738339364528656, -0.795749843120575, 0.920239269733429, 0.07040958851575851, -0.7426189184188843, 0.6705112457275391, -0.2385425865650177, 0.27108079195022583, 0.6905074715614319, 0.6192375421524048, 0.13609746098518372, -0.5260676741600037, -0.625777542591095, -0.8062862157821655, 0.4971248507499695, 0.24227480590343475, 0.0959162563085556, 0.2475643903017044, 0.752296507358551, -0.017564930021762848, 0.2503986358642578, -0.9087169170379639, -0.19998657703399658, 0.13869360089302063, -0.05362771078944206, 0.20820552110671997, -0.13066725432872772, -0.14301873743534088, -0.6892327666282654, 0.6346274018287659, 0.2863619327545166, 0.33956462144851685, -0.09040642529726028, -0.08799660205841064, 0.2714553773403168, 0.2524043917655945, 0.8762145042419434, 1.1167227029800415, -0.25170978903770447, -0.14852379262447357, 0.13259093463420868, -0.8573614954948425, 0.4798281192779541, 0.2618752121925354, 0.06473907828330994, -0.10831714421510696, 0.7088271379470825, 0.5567185282707214, -0.913390576839447, -0.7558085322380066, 0.4706028997898102, 0.0321233868598938, -0.16835053265094757, -0.6192340850830078, 0.6521373391151428, -0.11345551908016205, 0.20300467312335968, 0.6871252059936523, 0.05596083775162697, 0.6866950392723083, -0.7851190567016602, 0.3121562600135803, 0.441908061504364, -0.025538744404911995, -0.019195254892110825, 1.1575961112976074, 0.11782217770814896, -0.846613347530365, 0.4028703570365906, -0.12458252906799316, -0.029019178822636604, 0.7234371304512024, 0.5878202319145203, 0.5545383095741272, -0.5760006308555603, -0.013900241814553738, 0.31533282995224, 0.2085370570421219, -0.28000718355178833, 0.3272573947906494, -0.12164285033941269, -0.17536072432994843, -0.2867085039615631, -0.6184382438659668, -0.38706421852111816, 0.40044349431991577, -0.8150355219841003, 0.40499576926231384, -0.5887507200241089, 0.021453890949487686, 0.0907331258058548, -0.32945021986961365, -0.609873354434967, 0.423039048910141, -0.0048689404502511024, 1.058781385421753, -1.0680609941482544, 1.015754222869873, 0.8136967420578003, -0.8148781657218933, -0.7486262917518616, 0.02695966139435768, -0.05360987037420273, -1.1681066751480103, 0.9976798295974731, 0.021704554557800293, 0.16771245002746582, -0.22586849331855774, -0.25433942675590515, -0.577906608581543, 0.9425649046897888, 0.4255997836589813, -0.687023401260376, -0.47985413670539856, 0.4009988307952881, 0.795918345451355, -0.32927921414375305, 0.22044022381305695, 0.6401843428611755, 0.1496359407901764, -0.2504289448261261, -1.2345845699310303, -0.03619857132434845, -0.6453996896743774, -0.007130465004593134, -0.06384379416704178, -0.3751177191734314, 0.7148919105529785, -0.03409520536661148, 0.38571691513061523, -0.30389147996902466, 0.7088257074356079, 0.6140390634536743, 0.34876763820648193, 0.5075926184654236, 0.4083293080329895, 0.35130155086517334, 0.3350420892238617, 1.2069175243377686, -0.6052423119544983, -0.07338889688253403, 1.2006248235702515, -0.3585495948791504, 0.7693749070167542, 0.7170645594596863, -0.34555116295814514, -0.0405360609292984, 0.6135602593421936, 0.12984095513820648, 0.46249398589134216, 0.0056628938764333725, -0.21317337453365326, -0.04357429966330528, 0.11646682769060135, -0.5811868906021118, 0.5655211210250854, 0.35134750604629517, -0.13779449462890625, -0.2718755900859833, 0.08729898184537888, -0.4267730116844177, 0.23992404341697693, -0.5080592632293701, 0.5517773032188416, 0.13692565262317657, -0.676131546497345, 0.7073410749435425, -0.0857405886054039, 0.2090335488319397, -0.4739513397216797, -0.6203117370605469, -0.2638125717639923, 0.1012980043888092, -0.12523074448108673, -0.8210229873657227, 0.7053038477897644, -0.12059061229228973, 0.05501431226730347, -0.00581796420738101, 0.6783418655395508, -0.18877936899662018, -0.27511128783226013, -0.03653973340988159, 0.22552576661109924, 0.3537740409374237, -0.04015735536813736, -1.3049236536026, -0.16215389966964722, -0.16817474365234375, -0.09543890506029129, 0.376512348651886, 0.05422241985797882, -0.28699642419815063, 1.1088776588439941, 0.2485814392566681, 0.4896794855594635, 0.3373085558414459, -0.07296725362539291, 0.5534136891365051, -0.45403605699539185, -0.6445145010948181, -0.7098277807235718, 0.362306147813797, -0.1510467380285263, -0.48420989513397217, 0.5897312760353088, 0.7773632407188416, 0.28802621364593506, -0.189523845911026, 0.6863901019096375, -0.39310988783836365, 0.45326149463653564, -0.7776135802268982, 0.8180025815963745, -0.43346577882766724, 0.3938829004764557, 0.12508442997932434, -1.0371935367584229, -0.28628191351890564, 0.7636749148368835, -0.1330982893705368, 0.17116901278495789, 0.5608963370323181, 0.6604591608047485, -0.3847317695617676, -0.3493131399154663, 0.44681885838508606, -0.16916663944721222, 0.46459507942199707, 0.3860720694065094, 0.4784133732318878, -0.46366769075393677, 0.36340343952178955, -0.09802505373954773, -0.13845133781433105, -0.051821161061525345, -0.4522008001804352, -1.0730650424957275, -0.6831745505332947, -0.06526696681976318, -0.2785724699497223, 0.23814482986927032, 0.8983266949653625, 0.6032827496528625, -0.9973878264427185, -0.41933611035346985, -0.24333752691745758, -0.5741876363754272, 0.06565804034471512, -0.2870979607105255, 0.965510368347168, -0.5889111161231995, -0.6725850105285645, 0.4060080051422119, 0.17841175198554993, -0.10714253038167953, -0.12617234885692596, -0.18836762011051178, -0.6953828930854797, -0.027283886447548866, 0.36435702443122864, 0.6571902632713318, -0.6970101594924927, -0.13798251748085022, -0.541822075843811, 0.08193477243185043, 0.0774712786078453, 0.600825309753418, -0.08486904203891754, 0.570119321346283, 0.28562575578689575, 0.8231720328330994, 0.2580586075782776, 0.27485761046409607, 0.7306194305419922, -0.49550139904022217, 0.7641326189041138, 0.46753111481666565, 0.5308203101158142, -0.004975978285074234, -0.6548230051994324, 0.6518871188163757, -0.09900866448879242, -0.7881872653961182, -0.917186975479126, -0.07701955735683441, -0.9087622165679932, -0.1552283763885498, 1.2980331182479858, -0.251991331577301, -0.03239614516496658, -0.4187650978565216, -0.4158700704574585, 0.13324929773807526, -0.5254744291305542, 1.0139713287353516, 0.6894447803497314, -0.6501922011375427, -0.3972732126712799, -1.2069305181503296, 1.092650294303894, 0.46080026030540466, -0.9502589106559753, -0.43325352668762207, 0.434676855802536, 0.20115309953689575, 0.16832877695560455, 1.317883849143982, -0.07432693988084793, 0.7462436556816101, 0.09305468946695328, 0.12211864441633224, -0.25177139043807983, -0.42496225237846375, -0.41257959604263306, 0.43369239568710327, 0.49764758348464966, -0.3740103244781494 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16895v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16895v2	Cross-Lingual Transfer from Related Languages: Treating Low-Resource Maltese as Multilingual Code-Switching	2024-01-30T11:04:36	2024-02-03T07:26:47	Kurt Micallef, Nizar Habash, Claudia Borg, Fadhl Eryani, Houda Bouamor	cs.CL	cs.CL	Although multilingual language models exhibit impressive cross-lingual transfer capabilities on unseen languages, the performance on downstream tasks is impacted when there is a script disparity with the languages used in the multilingual model's pre-training data. Using transliteration offers a straightforward yet effective means to align the script of a resource-rich language with a target language, thereby enhancing cross-lingual transfer capabilities. However, for mixed languages, this approach is suboptimal, since only a subset of the language benefits from the cross-lingual transfer while the remainder is impeded. In this work, we focus on Maltese, a Semitic language, with substantial influences from Arabic, Italian, and English, and notably written in Latin script. We present a novel dataset annotated with word-level etymology. We use this dataset to train a classifier that enables us to make informed decisions regarding the appropriate processing of each token in the Maltese language. We contrast indiscriminate transliteration or translation to mixing processing pipelines that only transliterate words of Arabic origin, thereby resulting in text with a mixture of scripts. We fine-tune the processed data on four downstream tasks and show that conditional transliteration based on word etymology yields the best results, surpassing fine-tuning with raw Maltese or Maltese processed with non-selective pipelines.	[ -0.3639538884162903, -0.24711591005325317, 0.2882508337497711, 0.11715816706418991, -0.30306312441825867, 0.4602883756160736, -0.49312302470207214, -0.6546125411987305, 0.4988486170768738, 0.5047788619995117, -0.6475838422775269, -0.35960322618484497, -0.8439313173294067, 0.17534737288951874, -0.2541435956954956, 0.9359866976737976, -0.3254191279411316, 0.5266567468643188, 0.41497260332107544, -0.40248656272888184, -0.12427713721990585, -0.4010380208492279, -0.666880190372467, -0.22536224126815796, 0.858433723449707, 0.4753018021583557, 0.8074444532394409, 0.5913973450660706, 0.5222729444503784, 0.27074649930000305, 0.36854544281959534, 0.19443202018737793, -0.46099480986595154, -0.04526585340499878, -0.5896024703979492, -0.672500729560852, 0.21576707065105438, -0.18921032547950745, 0.537294864654541, 0.8355714678764343, 0.08479081094264984, 0.27569419145584106, -0.1561916619539261, 0.6816650629043579, -0.7246686816215515, 0.08835917711257935, -0.7703043222427368, 0.053100232034921646, -0.7423025369644165, -0.39011743664741516, -0.3132663071155548, -0.08061521500349045, -0.22029879689216614, -0.4543880820274353, 0.2963464856147766, 0.05430084839463234, 0.5627667307853699, 0.2994609475135803, 0.020510978996753693, -0.3637813329696655, -0.7710405588150024, 0.7786569595336914, -0.4619731307029724, 0.6723949909210205, 0.49304452538490295, 0.2398335486650467, 0.3462010622024536, -0.6440075039863586, -0.3276060223579407, 0.15269751846790314, -0.21602195501327515, 0.02566804364323616, 0.04758164659142494, -0.2315385341644287, 0.14019350707530975, 0.07531372457742691, -0.38449710607528687, 0.19134153425693512, -0.5421399474143982, -0.4115791320800781, 0.34133443236351013, -0.07013343274593353, 0.7246282696723938, 0.05144502967596054, -0.3557603359222412, -0.17910286784172058, -0.9883750677108765, 0.11791425198316574, 0.7716236114501953, 0.8281739950180054, -0.14662344753742218, 0.5569186806678772, 0.04415246471762657, 0.528098464012146, 0.25493261218070984, -0.2596917152404785, 0.22326543927192688, -0.6310543417930603, 0.19064638018608093, 0.6527836918830872, 0.6159184575080872, 0.006175716407597065, 0.30005326867103577, -0.3613673448562622, -0.07736443728208542, -0.006442313548177481, 0.220180943608284, -0.7570282220840454, 0.1834862232208252, -0.19817642867565155, -0.4083402752876282, 0.08467395603656769, -0.03575853258371353, -0.5724411606788635, -0.1254727840423584, -0.24825745820999146, 0.2741050124168396, -0.5785892009735107, -0.1149095818400383, 0.03253721818327904, -0.13181927800178528, 0.1779242306947708, 0.16774438321590424, -1.2826876640319824, 0.16825149953365326, 0.4665689170360565, 0.7787889242172241, -0.1726129949092865, -0.38891997933387756, -0.775444746017456, 0.33738386631011963, -0.2943829596042633, 0.6490267515182495, -0.9011367559432983, -0.3745884895324707, 0.15419770777225494, 0.1659991592168808, -0.4757991433143616, -0.4496493935585022, 0.512671709060669, -0.5463371276855469, 0.23634180426597595, -0.32414865493774414, -0.13383620977401733, -0.18321266770362854, -0.13875527679920197, -0.8766962289810181, 0.9919562339782715, 0.4832499623298645, -1.0162572860717773, 0.4439558982849121, -0.2624906897544861, -0.8925234079360962, 0.16279953718185425, -0.26986613869667053, 0.00844686571508646, 0.13980519771575928, 0.14737585186958313, -0.07408067584037781, -0.20058394968509674, 0.08500856161117554, -0.1561971753835678, -0.5451716184616089, -0.017717204988002777, -0.3659229576587677, 0.8076800107955933, 0.3615846335887909, -0.5893705487251282, -0.20459893345832825, -0.6771053075790405, 0.007217012345790863, -0.34501826763153076, -0.2583787441253662, -0.6562910079956055, -0.08335240185260773, 0.37616783380508423, 0.5422037839889526, 0.3977026343345642, -0.7665609121322632, 0.043485261499881744, -0.2805160880088806, 0.24762354791164398, 0.37788352370262146, -0.4252329170703888, 0.51663738489151, -0.27075037360191345, 0.7532739043235779, 0.25587770342826843, 0.006930469069629908, 0.21747921407222748, -0.3412095010280609, -0.9213445782661438, -0.2985748052597046, 0.6955011487007141, 0.6602068543434143, -1.3404619693756104, -0.10158757120370865, -0.5033905506134033, -0.22589926421642303, -1.071662425994873, 0.32708021998405457, 0.3855724036693573, 0.23387788236141205, 0.4163185954093933, -0.5280806422233582, -0.6101783514022827, -1.068197250366211, -0.3050282597541809, -0.18966558575630188, 0.4882422387599945, 0.07388518005609512, 0.05321168154478073, -0.15464437007904053, 0.5815519094467163, 0.10939546674489975, -0.14839176833629608, -0.660871684551239, 0.34754547476768494, 0.1815468668937683, 0.5569193363189697, 0.5401338934898376, -0.792877733707428, -0.9533817172050476, 0.5642372369766235, -0.2502921223640442, -0.2504502236843109, -0.31299516558647156, -0.435762494802475, 0.20768515765666962, 0.6234758496284485, -0.4538688659667969, 0.30341634154319763, 0.5964136123657227, -0.0944766104221344, 0.27598506212234497, -0.04686090722680092, 0.39636966586112976, -1.0985156297683716, 0.33305689692497253, -0.32280105352401733, -0.23722083866596222, -0.5943391919136047, 0.013720422051846981, 0.17766885459423065, 0.09850788861513138, -0.8537288904190063, 0.7525938153266907, -0.4083373546600342, -0.1923687607049942, -0.03139438480138779, -0.33674487471580505, -0.26709988713264465, 0.4865984618663788, 0.4355821907520294, 1.0692421197891235, 0.32616478204727173, -0.1300305277109146, 0.09564578533172607, 0.18723130226135254, -0.3479915261268616, 0.6321508288383484, -0.03621349111199379, -0.1324169784784317, -0.0037156601902097464, -0.016986314207315445, -0.798704981803894, 0.08223850280046463, 0.5281041860580444, -0.39814576506614685, 0.7016527056694031, -0.6326143145561218, -0.4825855493545532, 0.10356097668409348, -0.017035696655511856, 0.8228525519371033, 0.2707440257072449, -0.48718881607055664, 0.4535168707370758, -0.01246262900531292, -0.5219407081604004, -0.8460027575492859, -0.9306480884552002, 0.21258358657360077, -0.3338361084461212, -0.4325336813926697, 0.4650060832500458, -0.021884212270379066, -0.15730562806129456, 0.1033574789762497, -0.08639585971832275, -0.2724139988422394, -0.17659398913383484, 0.06960304081439972, 0.3456924557685852, -0.44946375489234924, -0.1603260636329651, 0.24067451059818268, -0.12844052910804749, -0.2129937708377838, -0.4509276747703552, 0.6143835783004761, 0.4299219250679016, -0.5007585883140564, -0.21510645747184753, 0.5530940294265747, 0.5330642461776733, -0.34656453132629395, 0.8382993340492249, 1.019684910774231, -0.002316684229299426, -0.14119558036327362, -0.38078421354293823, 0.2028106302022934, -0.421040803194046, 0.18216736614704132, -0.6498121023178101, -0.7593112587928772, 0.6318739652633667, -0.0099626574665308, 0.060240913182497025, 0.6539689898490906, 0.5953370332717896, 0.12771283090114594, 0.8732272982597351, 0.7700659036636353, -0.29493531584739685, 0.6704599857330322, 0.05196034535765648, 0.43107640743255615, -0.5350839495658875, 0.11066663265228271, -0.8077558279037476, -0.4243784546852112, -1.0598448514938354, -0.6577972769737244, 0.06332390010356903, -0.12740826606750488, 0.12360779196023941, 0.5764541029930115, 0.24713093042373657, 0.46918514370918274, 0.47891750931739807, -0.14817838370800018, 0.2401842623949051, 0.48401400446891785, -0.4891175925731659, -0.03348156437277794, -0.9346709251403809, -0.22898787260055542, 1.0302802324295044, -0.07039143890142441, 0.8938462734222412, 0.2056671679019928, 1.041293740272522, 0.28973665833473206, 0.4557715356349945, -0.6410768032073975, 0.1481970250606537, -0.544172465801239, -0.6877971291542053, -0.08941962569952011, -0.6365383267402649, -0.8960703015327454, 0.37346771359443665, -0.00412954343482852, -0.580177903175354, 0.3385356664657593, -0.3455217778682709, -0.22752179205417633, 0.5013964772224426, -0.5332129597663879, 0.6520968675613403, -0.3734160363674164, -0.777790904045105, -0.3137657046318054, -0.9028860330581665, 0.18778635561466217, -0.39477258920669556, 0.5468322038650513, 0.17185933887958527, 0.08377962559461594, 0.5561423301696777, -0.340074360370636, 0.7967351675033569, 0.09606121480464935, -0.1997968554496765, 0.13423171639442444, 0.2389640361070633, 0.16710567474365234, -0.25778815150260925, -0.1458311527967453, 0.43496331572532654, 0.21560081839561462, -0.5220834016799927, -0.4449399411678314, 0.6298857927322388, -0.8247823715209961, -0.3342215120792389, -0.31873226165771484, -0.635619044303894, -0.48114213347435, 0.3353251516819, 0.41067221760749817, 0.5214468836784363, -0.10563313215970993, -0.21685458719730377, 0.4584442377090454, -0.3862431049346924, 0.3979441225528717, 0.63092440366745, -0.02024262025952339, -0.3819744884967804, 1.1090373992919922, 0.05000649765133858, 0.3441431224346161, 0.6689412593841553, -0.240884467959404, -0.46755415201187134, -0.5471700429916382, -1.1855391263961792, 0.38501131534576416, -0.7302988171577454, 0.08351769298315048, -0.16805404424667358, -0.25984328985214233, -0.31294479966163635, -0.2389124482870102, -0.408460408449173, -0.6312538385391235, -0.11142418533563614, 0.09167137742042542, -0.14945977926254272, 0.5885255336761475, -0.2351527363061905, 0.22024038434028625, -1.0839611291885376, 0.16505439579486847, -0.1586349457502365, 0.2614705562591553, -0.30727821588516235, -0.47950753569602966, -0.6694597005844116, 0.20882143080234528, 0.09238697588443756, -0.6720468401908875, 0.38699448108673096, 0.16824184358119965, 0.694135844707489, 0.30085745453834534, -0.12010841071605682, 0.7753051519393921, -0.5952938199043274, 0.4648522436618805, 0.49142274260520935, -0.8071223497390747, -0.01581377536058426, -0.24045632779598236, 0.15133662521839142, 1.0179715156555176, 0.6705790758132935, -0.8376840949058533, -0.379219651222229, -0.5655238032341003, -0.8412215113639832, 0.9008951187133789, 0.23024404048919678, 0.004017539322376251, 0.05710426717996597, 0.02611265704035759, 0.5964245796203613, 0.23852327466011047, -0.49137502908706665, -0.0928199365735054, -0.025546537712216377, -0.5146142840385437, -0.45795807242393494, 0.1735200732946396, -0.04363272711634636, -0.1885589063167572, 0.581220269203186, -0.18718871474266052, -0.03490452840924263, 0.006808445323258638, -0.7576332092285156, -0.42504388093948364, 0.45843371748924255, 0.40916597843170166, 0.6732810139656067, 0.06700076907873154, 0.44840213656425476, -0.09020642936229706, -0.5771999955177307, 0.23771530389785767, 0.24987828731536865, -0.26978713274002075, 0.1782178282737732, 0.5190528631210327, 0.7071035504341125, 0.4194734990596771, -0.5708444118499756, 0.18095794320106506, 0.00830900389701128, -0.052410904318094254, 0.3205837309360504, -0.03005879372358322, 0.1132219135761261, 0.13631248474121094, 0.032273706048727036, 0.16685748100280762, 0.19000789523124695, -0.7769086956977844, 0.07072039693593979, 0.347043514251709, -0.2743114233016968, -0.31317201256752014, 0.27646318078041077, 0.22826650738716125, -0.06536880880594254, 0.5241276621818542, 0.012919032946228981, -0.6782411336898804, 0.43561527132987976, 0.5466998219490051, 0.8025441765785217, -0.2320435792207718, 0.43871957063674927, 0.43824315071105957, 0.3436066806316376, 0.10750304162502289, 0.23412051796913147, -0.5167612433433533, -0.7102435231208801, -0.43077725172042847, -0.9073820114135742, -0.24472498893737793, -0.23734647035598755, -0.8507326245307922, 0.07705933600664139, -0.2048325091600418, -0.0788566842675209, 0.0186450257897377, -0.12921348214149475, -0.9674075245857239, -0.05024227499961853, 0.49587929248809814, 0.8287027478218079, -0.955745279788971, 1.1009713411331177, 0.7193815112113953, -0.4416700303554535, -0.5844162106513977, 0.014631342142820358, -0.35674893856048584, -1.2062289714813232, 1.0385644435882568, 0.09127235412597656, -0.5025572776794434, 0.009669151157140732, 0.047015320509672165, -0.9053546786308289, 0.551103949546814, 0.4286273121833801, -0.6984713673591614, 0.11409658938646317, 0.6755322217941284, 0.5741481184959412, -0.3125895857810974, 0.3102099597454071, 0.5915071368217468, 0.6605250835418701, 0.17952437698841095, -1.0697592496871948, -0.11740273237228394, -0.3399701416492462, -0.1256767064332962, 0.526675820350647, -0.5564762949943542, 0.5956962704658508, -0.0966227650642395, -0.36173000931739807, 0.15151503682136536, 0.275621235370636, -0.36658215522766113, 0.1276097297668457, 0.347379595041275, 0.6535613536834717, 0.29815492033958435, 0.004603302106261253, 0.8534132838249207, -0.6970313191413879, 0.03162005916237831, 1.0655971765518188, -0.40566563606262207, 0.8825719952583313, 0.8506761789321899, -0.2663584351539612, 0.7030746340751648, 0.7121467590332031, 0.407880574464798, 0.7513879537582397, 0.01614127866923809, -0.296858012676239, -0.2816251814365387, -0.3160780966281891, -0.2881206274032593, 0.5957145094871521, 0.2947283983230591, -0.5231240391731262, -0.5568033456802368, -0.21746514737606049, -0.06057845428586006, -0.2684360146522522, -0.36639660596847534, 0.6488608717918396, -0.10487288981676102, -0.9632467031478882, 0.5434951186180115, 0.24662639200687408, 0.5012127757072449, -0.9581905007362366, 0.08512159436941147, -0.4574378728866577, 0.05256134644150734, -0.19127924740314484, -0.4922589063644409, 0.32997503876686096, 0.11588610708713531, -0.09687317907810211, -0.5734769701957703, 0.49219611287117004, -0.9075194597244263, -0.7307502031326294, 0.42348021268844604, 0.807761549949646, 0.12475883960723877, 0.4081946313381195, -0.6975900530815125, 0.052425894886255264, 0.15798735618591309, 0.3234938979148865, 0.5902616381645203, 0.35685059428215027, -0.24141749739646912, 0.14055517315864563, 0.8034802079200745, 0.47125449776649475, 0.28975123167037964, 0.4055374562740326, 0.6661884784698486, -0.590261697769165, -0.6654649972915649, -0.6955433487892151, 0.1624578833580017, 0.3470543324947357, -0.23291203379631042, 0.6608153581619263, 0.6591023802757263, 1.0859792232513428, 0.01848331093788147, 0.827364981174469, -0.08320590853691101, 0.2175019532442093, -0.7654989957809448, 0.5296298265457153, -0.6190140843391418, -0.05536323040723801, -0.06549421697854996, -0.8655062317848206, 0.013057469390332699, 0.5931215882301331, -0.28713473677635193, 0.00404083589091897, 0.839198112487793, 0.6392520070075989, -0.46037983894348145, -0.15841037034988403, 0.24496665596961975, -0.15847517549991608, -0.16678574681282043, 0.6120654344558716, 0.9271861910820007, -0.08792631328105927, 0.27353739738464355, -0.25608810782432556, 0.04147164896130562, -0.06946852058172226, -0.5486459136009216, -0.5907453298568726, -0.44976282119750977, -0.0800400972366333, -0.20516632497310638, 0.21489585936069489, 0.8770826458930969, 0.6732984781265259, -0.8190638422966003, -0.4947999119758606, 0.15040647983551025, 0.02786312624812126, -0.15968355536460876, -0.15605264902114868, 0.08458735793828964, -0.5644816160202026, -0.7280290722846985, 0.44874051213264465, 0.3896769881248474, -0.1104489266872406, -0.3419526517391205, -0.07261531800031662, -0.2843186557292938, 0.06310401111841202, 0.33989468216896057, 0.2390197515487671, -0.572036862373352, -0.06959353387355804, -0.15988954901695251, -0.36959755420684814, 0.19837650656700134, 1.1938177347183228, -0.43171146512031555, 0.4946940243244171, 0.4511137306690216, 0.8717601895332336, 0.6128408312797546, -0.15077203512191772, 0.5033174157142639, -0.579869270324707, 0.20493188500404358, -0.04060811176896095, 0.493755042552948, 0.625999391078949, -0.36943843960762024, 0.3669990301132202, 0.33516255021095276, 0.19295059144496918, -0.35466986894607544, 0.23539680242538452, -0.7978833317756653, -0.32754766941070557, 1.14956796169281, -0.21104319393634796, -0.2980964183807373, -0.11599187552928925, -0.20943975448608398, 0.3839171230792999, -0.10878457129001617, 0.5548712015151978, 1.012342929840088, 0.12793001532554626, -0.011201244778931141, -0.4058931767940521, 0.4209113121032715, 0.5032517313957214, -0.6354754567146301, -0.1487046182155609, 0.39814576506614685, 0.5673404335975647, 0.17551051080226898, 0.5284239053726196, -0.17922207713127136, 0.24772414565086365, 0.03287022188305855, 0.04376060888171196, 0.23970367014408112, -0.4346843957901001, -0.23406706750392914, -0.08123280107975006, 0.0719732716679573, -0.05748508498072624 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16862v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16862v1	State Value Generation with Prompt Learning and Self-Training for Low-Resource Dialogue State Tracking	2024-01-30T10:05:03	2024-01-30T10:05:03	Ming Gu, Yan Yang, Chengcai Chen, Zhou Yu	cs.CL	cs.CL	Recently, low-resource dialogue state tracking (DST) has received increasing attention. First obtaining state values then based on values to generate slot types has made great progress in this task. However, obtaining state values is still an under-studied problem. Existing extraction-based approaches cannot capture values that require the understanding of context and are not generalizable either. To address these issues, we propose a novel State VAlue Generation based framework (SVAG), decomposing DST into state value generation and domain slot generation. Specifically, we propose to generate state values and use self-training to further improve state value generation. Moreover, we design an estimator aiming at detecting incomplete generation and incorrect generation for pseudo-labeled data selection during self-training. Experimental results on the MultiWOZ 2.1 dataset show that our method which has only less than 1 billion parameters achieves state-of-the-art performance under the data ratio settings of 5%, 10%, and 25% when limited to models under 100 billion parameters. Compared to models with more than 100 billion parameters, SVAG still reaches competitive results.	[ -0.47471487522125244, -0.43163827061653137, 0.6031389832496643, -0.28748267889022827, -0.5804936289787292, -0.0059991865418851376, 0.13641461730003357, -0.18025216460227966, 0.21606816351413727, 0.2403985559940338, -1.0289980173110962, -0.07271021604537964, -0.3140299320220947, -0.09452316164970398, 0.1904807984828949, 1.1265703439712524, 0.3461337089538574, -0.03471912071108818, -0.10440205782651901, -0.18065862357616425, -0.5693378448486328, -0.695574164390564, -0.24014152586460114, -0.022011946886777878, 0.16538292169570923, 0.2384563386440277, -0.06683726608753204, 0.35479870438575745, -0.1713957041501999, 0.25730499625205994, -0.04778280109167099, 0.36179277300834656, -0.4752374291419983, 0.19439397752285004, -0.047996897250413895, -0.1691652238368988, -0.4274579584598541, 0.17762167751789093, 0.5458532571792603, 0.22673046588897705, -0.36009469628334045, 0.461383193731308, -0.06859266012907028, 0.40351858735084534, -0.6199650764465332, 0.44878512620925903, -0.8360239267349243, -0.028694624081254005, -0.15183024108409882, -0.4132941961288452, -0.24695037305355072, -0.38567018508911133, 0.21942900121212006, -0.3334346115589142, 0.40764859318733215, -0.10731585323810577, 0.8584793210029602, 0.5373128652572632, -0.5988110303878784, -0.22644995152950287, -0.566122829914093, 0.9329972863197327, -0.6074156761169434, 0.17991307377815247, 0.17809349298477173, 0.30298084020614624, -0.2730419635772705, -0.5168730020523071, -0.6839497685432434, -0.004393499344587326, 0.10097705572843552, 0.18745112419128418, -0.13472403585910797, 0.04173310101032257, 0.34662312269210815, 0.3140645921230316, -0.1791130155324936, -0.01610981486737728, -0.4282812476158142, -0.2901030480861664, 0.5770179033279419, 0.41925087571144104, -0.18869373202323914, -0.7104504108428955, -0.6618571281433105, -0.06706967949867249, -0.6733070611953735, 0.4674934148788452, 0.3219892084598541, 0.6220306158065796, 0.17250482738018036, 0.21472516655921936, -0.27443161606788635, 0.7661396861076355, 0.2896971106529236, -0.5628579258918762, 0.2140360027551651, -0.6325218677520752, -0.1309337019920349, 0.0807875320315361, 0.6795511245727539, 0.13724081218242645, -0.3971085250377655, 0.22153964638710022, -0.2024303376674652, -0.08005344867706299, 0.38535603880882263, -0.8382653594017029, -0.12027931213378906, 0.02017909288406372, -0.48452943563461304, -0.4255341589450836, -0.4612569510936737, -0.5870286226272583, -0.06268661469221115, -0.26261523365974426, 0.408698707818985, -0.3002486824989319, -0.5677896738052368, -0.15568701922893524, 0.013235903345048428, 0.31271833181381226, 0.5819721817970276, -1.0935842990875244, -0.11954580247402191, 0.15876202285289764, 0.7995027899742126, -0.33509209752082825, 0.12953351438045502, -0.5151099562644958, -0.05757243558764458, -0.22604171931743622, 0.9177433848381042, -0.18840648233890533, -0.5821675062179565, -0.27031198143959045, -0.24527639150619507, 0.017422141507267952, -0.29530081152915955, 0.007468529976904392, -0.4315992295742035, 0.1924392729997635, -0.4524993300437927, -0.4949484169483185, 0.31518933176994324, 0.18330197036266327, -0.5017805695533752, 1.1722686290740967, 0.2859697639942169, -0.42719918489456177, 0.6385034322738647, -0.5344475507736206, -0.20210060477256775, 0.37796515226364136, -0.6190921664237976, -0.5329469442367554, 0.15318302810192108, -0.00009303826664108783, 0.30161166191101074, -0.22347822785377502, 0.30794572830200195, -0.31672558188438416, -0.09001429378986359, -0.009356201626360416, -0.7768124938011169, 0.4941295385360718, 0.39480069279670715, -0.26580336689949036, -0.2024836540222168, -0.9409153461456299, 0.4443720579147339, 0.09793655574321747, -0.48430538177490234, -0.16974720358848572, -0.011349012143909931, -0.42698487639427185, 0.7110538482666016, 0.20766977965831757, -0.6308370232582092, 0.31133511662483215, -0.21493856608867645, 0.30737441778182983, 0.9739223122596741, 0.38696572184562683, 0.22960875928401947, 0.0342889204621315, 0.709290087223053, 0.24844075739383698, -0.11160104721784592, -0.32856395840644836, -0.13627095520496368, -0.5867159962654114, -0.5044663548469543, 0.1903226524591446, 0.21261966228485107, -0.9450609683990479, 0.4960760474205017, -0.03306320682168007, -0.373835027217865, -0.6945066452026367, -0.04229021444916725, 0.3384118974208832, 0.8873424530029297, 0.4277653396129608, -0.01698228530585766, -0.22001294791698456, -0.7072551250457764, 0.0332975797355175, -0.18873479962348938, 0.01806856133043766, 0.4958040118217468, 0.36625540256500244, 0.3004623055458069, 1.3415788412094116, -0.8062112331390381, -0.33171749114990234, -0.33831921219825745, 0.27607253193855286, 0.05411722511053085, 0.4836367666721344, 0.4078231155872345, -0.566845715045929, -0.2301689088344574, -0.4015990197658539, -0.4669756293296814, 0.07285462319850922, -0.12793280184268951, -0.015216507017612457, 0.3526638448238373, 0.12973181903362274, -0.3439033627510071, 0.541759729385376, 0.3652099072933197, -0.13950777053833008, 0.40206533670425415, -0.07007155567407608, 0.16135507822036743, -1.1950647830963135, 0.06524263322353363, 0.22857265174388885, -0.37906697392463684, -0.5474498867988586, -0.7146987318992615, -0.147843599319458, -0.38302403688430786, -0.656417191028595, 0.4568568468093872, -0.27494531869888306, -0.19431890547275543, -0.5280037522315979, -0.08916854113340378, -0.12878994643688202, 0.9021536707878113, 0.1695089191198349, 1.0147426128387451, 0.06139550358057022, -0.8146547079086304, 0.39218083024024963, 0.44202083349227905, -0.43442749977111816, 0.7799568772315979, -0.3268026113510132, 0.1389426589012146, -0.16017979383468628, 0.5069209933280945, -0.9390010833740234, 0.07045815885066986, 0.17235271632671356, -0.3946463465690613, 0.08725063502788544, -0.7207546234130859, -0.043856363743543625, -0.08842357993125916, 0.11374153196811676, 0.18617556989192963, 0.6500108242034912, -0.6420612335205078, 0.3197011649608612, 0.7109255790710449, -0.37110066413879395, -0.635151207447052, 0.014690592885017395, -0.3283103406429291, -0.20440897345542908, -0.2917712926864624, -0.031477171927690506, -0.02293248474597931, 0.38902541995048523, -0.17576049268245697, -0.6082883477210999, -0.13345235586166382, 0.0843849629163742, 0.054736752063035965, 0.43530723452568054, 0.042058952152729034, 0.42003798484802246, 0.3407265245914459, -0.4016077518463135, 0.10747959464788437, -0.4167603552341461, 0.4314400553703308, -0.19732476770877838, -0.29907485842704773, -0.39830246567726135, 0.45381128787994385, 0.13579703867435455, -0.390665203332901, 0.3870510458946228, 0.4720543324947357, -0.14430350065231323, -0.6700149178504944, -0.13357870280742645, -0.29918819665908813, -0.527407705783844, 0.27902501821517944, -0.6634595394134521, -0.8087637424468994, 0.06887885183095932, -0.5064449310302734, 0.12286622077226639, 0.47500747442245483, 0.5050250887870789, -0.41773033142089844, 1.204777479171753, 0.574509859085083, 0.20807060599327087, 0.6226886510848999, -0.33213138580322266, 0.11863558739423752, -0.6022362112998962, -0.2132958322763443, -0.4569096565246582, 0.05703841149806976, -0.5398013591766357, -0.20834340155124664, 0.6969815492630005, 0.013607087545096874, 0.15806928277015686, 0.15167033672332764, -0.4853229522705078, 0.1280083805322647, 0.6220880746841431, -0.001535606337711215, 0.032957274466753006, -0.04787614569067955, 0.08871807157993317, -0.3110435903072357, -0.920562744140625, -0.34954115748405457, 0.7274088263511658, 0.10217711329460144, 1.0285512208938599, -0.014489355497062206, 0.9038873314857483, 0.5478042364120483, -0.09158962965011597, -0.8277407288551331, 0.505656898021698, 0.1498596966266632, -0.5550224184989929, -0.6160221099853516, -0.653742790222168, -0.6906203031539917, 0.5645866394042969, -0.26098260283470154, -0.5579162836074829, 0.25378453731536865, 0.6181625127792358, -0.6249244809150696, 0.05176045000553131, -0.48043009638786316, 0.8603190779685974, -0.15710435807704926, -0.04665594920516014, -0.19540289044380188, -0.6218539476394653, 0.2279060184955597, 0.001418389263562858, -0.34334325790405273, -0.4966683089733124, 0.38391366600990295, 0.5081998705863953, -0.4624727964401245, 0.8881272673606873, -0.6710596680641174, -0.3314492404460907, 0.5957799553871155, -0.1612454652786255, 0.568936824798584, 0.1362491101026535, 0.19076992571353912, -0.06480787694454193, 0.13870711624622345, -0.3999975025653839, -0.5590593814849854, 0.47136637568473816, -0.5786688923835754, -0.5113701820373535, -0.5298994183540344, -0.17672522366046906, -0.26404905319213867, 0.260693222284317, 0.39402684569358826, 0.7023298144340515, -0.18050286173820496, -0.0871519073843956, 0.8772146105766296, -0.05740412697196007, 0.5312246680259705, 0.5952338576316833, 0.5161066055297852, -0.47112876176834106, 1.2224855422973633, 0.18437790870666504, 0.4686601758003235, -0.13453197479248047, 0.0367421954870224, -0.765328049659729, -0.12962843477725983, -0.8220999240875244, -0.023369623348116875, -0.6928410530090332, -0.4418887197971344, -0.4750095009803772, -0.29297515749931335, -0.4132426083087921, 0.06388634443283081, -0.6603600978851318, -0.38222071528434753, -0.32602664828300476, -0.13922761380672455, 0.21249932050704956, 0.4738442897796631, -0.09717987477779388, 0.17552947998046875, -0.7946414351463318, 0.3474227488040924, 0.5160199999809265, 0.3301636874675751, -0.22762681543827057, -0.3260516822338104, -0.37928441166877747, 0.07016610354185104, -0.3132863938808441, -0.6975986361503601, 0.34513792395591736, 0.1501445323228836, 0.6987374424934387, 0.12748409807682037, 0.4633828103542328, 0.8867353796958923, -0.5559080243110657, 0.899645984172821, 0.3035026788711548, -1.0200557708740234, 0.9069927930831909, -0.14874283969402313, 0.34118837118148804, 0.5037216544151306, 0.07864275574684143, -0.42728400230407715, -0.20741917192935944, -0.8331130146980286, -0.5922809839248657, 1.2847950458526611, -0.015161585062742233, 0.15044982731342316, -0.0540061891078949, 0.23109889030456543, 0.11423032730817795, 0.34758856892585754, -0.5231919884681702, -0.28544607758522034, -0.6280198693275452, -0.1825314164161682, 0.10985152423381805, -0.20982635021209717, -0.22031056880950928, 0.018253063783049583, 0.7103680372238159, -0.7199663519859314, 0.37035614252090454, 0.18229490518569946, -0.08737742900848389, -0.12385216355323792, 0.40413549542427063, 0.688779354095459, 0.5357415080070496, -0.06154947727918625, -0.16318859159946442, 0.40721315145492554, -0.04316914826631546, 0.6448097825050354, 0.06089545786380768, -0.29010045528411865, 0.09226441383361816, -0.24867680668830872, 1.118718147277832, -0.05433562770485878, -0.4834158718585968, 0.7718328237533569, -0.08731915056705475, -0.06792457401752472, -0.5881470441818237, 0.35554447770118713, -0.3570293188095093, 0.23303750157356262, 0.3977908194065094, 0.056193795055150986, 0.19278883934020996, -0.03437083959579468, 0.28254830837249756, 0.5219647884368896, -0.4609702229499817, -0.3461041748523712, 0.5600877404212952, 0.5969604849815369, 0.056376148015260696, 0.43930783867836, -0.47204113006591797, -0.23532922565937042, 0.35171589255332947, 0.6706773638725281, 0.7104796767234802, -0.1545969545841217, 0.3325284719467163, 0.47342994809150696, -0.13799038529396057, 0.00565204257145524, 0.3624230623245239, -0.6277521252632141, -0.6864574551582336, -0.462251752614975, -0.6147553324699402, -0.35697227716445923, 0.3799404203891754, -1.0158973932266235, 0.23046179115772247, -0.26048600673675537, -0.37647947669029236, -0.08182991296052933, 0.20308737456798553, -0.5880760550498962, 0.36397966742515564, 0.2333267331123352, 0.5179338455200195, -0.9501909017562866, 1.0284518003463745, 0.3027549088001251, -0.3142698109149933, -0.6156640648841858, -0.06785362958908081, 0.18095506727695465, -0.6476854085922241, 0.5943911671638489, 0.1089666560292244, -0.5842654705047607, 0.22307519614696503, -0.512771487236023, -0.9767872095108032, 1.158932089805603, 0.25012117624282837, -0.27620863914489746, -0.14157100021839142, -0.24920246005058289, 0.30784615874290466, -0.19817259907722473, -0.0611083097755909, 0.6459639072418213, 0.05295517295598984, 0.2609218657016754, -0.6711513996124268, -0.019878925755620003, -0.09419867396354675, 0.1911260187625885, 0.42150911688804626, -0.9047670960426331, 0.629366934299469, -0.16285039484500885, -0.5782992839813232, -0.18456017971038818, 0.880044162273407, 0.39553388953208923, 0.06130845844745636, 0.7257187962532043, 0.3410293459892273, 0.5591877102851868, -0.006053669843822718, 0.48486366868019104, -0.19449695944786072, 0.4905192255973816, 1.093654990196228, -0.24132965505123138, 0.3750850260257721, 0.3003661036491394, 0.042026959359645844, 0.2778448760509491, 0.5692889094352722, -0.13472065329551697, 0.904720664024353, -0.03911713510751724, -0.5074695944786072, -0.6101793646812439, -0.06537853181362152, -0.2898053824901581, 0.6372829079627991, 0.3000604510307312, -0.08218422532081604, -0.3471401333808899, 0.04815976694226265, 0.06386765092611313, -0.3123409152030945, -0.08607354760169983, 1.1699105501174927, -0.052786096930503845, -0.7591351866722107, 0.6388591527938843, -0.1875186413526535, 0.37565886974334717, -0.8171859383583069, -0.3457576632499695, -0.22602155804634094, 0.0333893820643425, 0.22083526849746704, -0.42921605706214905, -0.06145600229501724, 0.15838557481765747, -0.1850084811449051, -0.5601410269737244, 0.6102240681648254, -0.5697885155677795, -0.05192042514681816, -0.16379380226135254, 0.5265809893608093, 0.017577774822711945, 0.36719101667404175, -0.5386081337928772, -0.3100604712963104, 0.21530675888061523, -0.24011176824569702, 0.37988004088401794, 0.28166064620018005, 0.1382060945034027, 0.5589106678962708, 0.656950831413269, 0.13124080002307892, 0.06718000769615173, -0.22926804423332214, 0.8444046378135681, -0.9100515842437744, -0.9573665261268616, -0.5218988656997681, 0.6319560408592224, -0.1863000988960266, -0.6404852271080017, 0.5410909652709961, 0.22693942487239838, 0.8063128590583801, 0.03795132413506508, 1.1650302410125732, -0.2656143009662628, 0.6671146750450134, -0.540103554725647, 0.43957921862602234, -0.3796396255493164, -0.022913504391908646, -0.11869551241397858, -0.4600899815559387, 0.6069364547729492, 0.4984511733055115, 0.052040889859199524, -0.08174943923950195, 0.2664918303489685, 0.45893535017967224, 0.12141913175582886, -0.17394711077213287, 0.4526069760322571, -0.2728681266307831, 0.714971661567688, 0.4725516736507416, 1.004223108291626, -0.1340729147195816, 0.735733687877655, -0.028682773932814598, -0.3430575430393219, -0.13914267718791962, -0.7305296659469604, -0.7671869993209839, -0.8653438091278076, -0.061027657240629196, -0.4370778799057007, -0.276966392993927, 1.1947494745254517, 0.9876121878623962, -0.48539772629737854, 0.071914441883564, 0.24789784848690033, -0.12437809258699417, -0.17948321998119354, -0.17676885426044464, 0.15784770250320435, -0.7867167592048645, -0.6983481049537659, 0.8422595858573914, 0.18533974885940552, 0.2695673406124115, -0.43940478563308716, -0.11227747052907944, 0.1417129635810852, 0.24041767418384552, 0.5125432014465332, 0.48590415716171265, -0.6708850264549255, -0.3606042265892029, -0.3194350004196167, -0.2723155915737152, 0.24296611547470093, 0.7968794703483582, -0.9450969696044922, 0.6724839210510254, 0.20801906287670135, 0.4926975667476654, 0.8332954049110413, 0.34743091464042664, 0.6070274114608765, -1.0999109745025635, 0.08921682834625244, 0.278585284948349, 0.11677712202072144, 0.05981624498963356, -0.41348886489868164, 0.10981184989213943, 0.3763326406478882, -0.4217338263988495, -0.8378589153289795, 0.7116094827651978, -0.6870667338371277, -0.11180870234966278, 0.7946818470954895, -0.1856652945280075, -0.03738684579730034, 0.021755974739789963, -0.05303647741675377, 0.30606991052627563, -0.6104793548583984, 0.8800423741340637, 0.33144497871398926, -0.47455018758773804, -0.10743726789951324, -0.32142987847328186, 1.0600484609603882, 0.16982020437717438, -0.9756619930267334, 0.014604286290705204, 0.8345475196838379, 0.4731987714767456, -0.0670202448964119, 1.1012769937515259, 0.07213113456964493, 0.2992526888847351, 0.0648251324892044, 0.19930537045001984, -0.13474832475185394, -0.3215407431125641, -0.6277768015861511, 0.03649527207016945, -0.18699118494987488, -0.6131255030632019 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03362v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03362v1	NanoNER: Named Entity Recognition for nanobiology using experts' knowledge and distant supervision	2024-01-30T09:10:53	2024-01-30T09:10:53	Martin Lentschat, Cyril Labbé, Ran Cheng	cs.IR	cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL	Here we present the training and evaluation of NanoNER, a Named Entity Recognition (NER) model for Nanobiology. NER consists in the identification of specific entities in spans of unstructured texts and is often a primary task in Natural Language Processing (NLP) and Information Extraction. The aim of our model is to recognise entities previously identified by domain experts as constituting the essential knowledge of the domain. Relying on ontologies, which provide us with a domain vocabulary and taxonomy, we implemented an iterative process enabling experts to determine the entities relevant to the domain at hand. We then delve into the potential of distant supervision learning in NER, supporting how this method can increase the quantity of annotated data with minimal additional manpower. On our full corpus of 728 full-text nanobiology articles, containing more than 120k entity occurrences, NanoNER obtained a F1-score of 0.98 on the recognition of previously known entities. Our model also demonstrated its ability to discover new entities in the text, with precision scores ranging from 0.77 to 0.81. Ablation experiments further confirmed this and allowed us to assess the dependency of our approach on the external resources. It highlighted the dependency of the approach to the resource, while also confirming its ability to rediscover up to 30% of the ablated terms. This paper details the methodology employed, experimental design, and key findings, providing valuable insights and directions for future related researches on NER in specialized domain. Furthermore, since our approach require minimal manpower , we believe that it can be generalized to other specialized fields.	[ -0.5655257701873779, -0.7899081707000732, 0.6236572265625, -0.49852362275123596, -0.05748307704925537, -0.046261001378297806, -0.3434435725212097, -0.6644706130027771, 0.4040532410144806, 0.43235892057418823, -0.23275011777877808, -0.31006941199302673, -0.7688995599746704, 0.7910559773445129, -0.5388773083686829, 1.036412239074707, 0.4395730495452881, -0.09414232522249222, -0.3922317326068878, 0.08228473365306854, -0.13284747302532196, -0.1269097626209259, -1.122246503829956, -0.2786225974559784, 0.7367163896560669, 0.6681922674179077, 0.15279462933540344, 0.7640260457992554, 0.7409098744392395, 0.43561631441116333, -0.6495676040649414, 0.2963423728942871, -0.25177305936813354, -0.1528540849685669, -0.7796828746795654, -0.02110966295003891, -0.32418838143348694, -0.16037505865097046, 0.35649242997169495, 0.7280919551849365, 0.06312841922044754, 0.2452678382396698, -0.0753883570432663, 0.5318790674209595, -0.5171117186546326, -0.22806651890277863, -0.7956116199493408, 0.2767471373081207, -0.18555621802806854, -0.041506577283144, -0.29715874791145325, 0.05325206369161606, 0.5326952338218689, -0.7130617499351501, 0.6127123832702637, 0.03618370369076729, 0.823074460029602, 0.15709947049617767, -0.5188590288162231, -0.30059775710105896, -0.9848973155021667, 0.665383517742157, -0.5747113227844238, 0.6169397234916687, 0.1360245943069458, 0.29222092032432556, 0.03197675198316574, -0.9568362832069397, -0.5894280076026917, -0.47132501006126404, -0.026785559952259064, -0.04373415932059288, -0.3330746591091156, -0.0369744636118412, 0.22048065066337585, 0.2868422865867615, -0.17882110178470612, 0.13329540193080902, -0.6580449342727661, -0.03605354204773903, 0.3314954936504364, 0.11929508298635483, 0.19646893441677094, -0.2922687828540802, -0.32329389452934265, 0.19508978724479675, -0.23289696872234344, -0.20063842833042145, 0.14078891277313232, 0.4375488758087158, 0.30791905522346497, 0.23817943036556244, -0.5568981766700745, 0.5088226199150085, 0.49705231189727783, -0.12166068702936172, 0.09076034277677536, -0.3352276682853699, -0.05294536054134369, 0.34329020977020264, 0.6705985069274902, 0.149441197514534, 0.09147775173187256, -0.5118453502655029, -0.08412092924118042, -0.43137115240097046, 0.512008011341095, -0.9533003568649292, -0.43423759937286377, -0.03854179382324219, -0.3005663752555847, -0.17966146767139435, 0.11456343531608582, -1.0371448993682861, -0.5692154169082642, -0.2026231437921524, 0.31047967076301575, -0.3092665374279022, -0.45148155093193054, -0.46301770210266113, -0.37893226742744446, -0.3137195408344269, 0.336971640586853, -1.0031882524490356, 0.7725164890289307, 0.5705909132957458, 0.84904944896698, -0.32380881905555725, -0.21331697702407837, -0.2950325906276703, 0.19886060059070587, -0.026901135221123695, 0.8858258128166199, -0.4927866756916046, -0.5004009008407593, -0.6402708888053894, -0.021148988977074623, 0.06267602741718292, -0.8295493125915527, 0.12336397916078568, -0.6224908828735352, -0.47958433628082275, -0.06621277332305908, -0.681810736656189, -0.22942395508289337, 0.3366086483001709, -0.9019244313240051, 0.47781533002853394, 0.1945199817419052, -0.8507954478263855, 0.5049660205841064, -0.66563880443573, -0.09595410525798798, 0.34407758712768555, 0.014738991856575012, -0.35056638717651367, -0.031132852658629417, 0.02056700922548771, 0.3193664252758026, -0.3141452372074127, 0.20624135434627533, -0.3264886438846588, 0.04542630538344383, 0.6221684813499451, -0.04938020929694176, 0.17727068066596985, -0.02269643358886242, -0.12416137754917145, 0.04457855597138405, -0.9635475277900696, -0.21337667107582092, -0.026327060535550117, 0.0016024935757741332, -0.5915514230728149, -0.2981444299221039, 0.02080158330500126, -0.009217203594744205, 0.1312926560640335, -0.9666028022766113, 0.08345797657966614, -0.48435214161872864, 0.7231267690658569, 0.45357537269592285, 0.625751256942749, 0.7889765501022339, 0.054980602115392685, 0.3455147445201874, 0.05060471594333649, 0.26129457354545593, 0.21679234504699707, -0.3011903166770935, -0.8388959169387817, -0.13495196402072906, 0.7997010946273804, 0.5789659023284912, -0.322748601436615, 0.08262008428573608, -0.12066066265106201, -0.578366219997406, -0.2818097174167633, 0.34873661398887634, 0.468735009431839, 0.8788930177688599, 0.7322894334793091, -0.2771140933036804, -0.8594344258308411, -0.9030314087867737, -0.07136870175600052, 0.29817867279052734, 0.2748729884624481, 0.30012497305870056, 1.0442203283309937, -0.7042319774627686, 1.0961450338363647, -0.511213481426239, -0.5822789072990417, -0.19460543990135193, 0.020749934017658234, 0.2435002475976944, 0.6153077483177185, 0.10046038031578064, -1.1789538860321045, -0.2917644679546356, 0.5812573432922363, -0.5868632793426514, 0.1073349341750145, 0.12337339669466019, 0.09077684581279755, -0.18665127456188202, 0.8120690584182739, -0.6010157465934753, 0.35253819823265076, 0.08215358108282089, -0.07231123745441437, 0.533932626247406, -0.11779589205980301, -0.0009887281339615583, -1.0903347730636597, 0.2852948009967804, 0.33619630336761475, -0.2428591549396515, -0.8072187304496765, 0.03584994375705719, -0.029107676818966866, 0.11442281305789948, -0.5158734321594238, 0.9067594408988953, -0.6029031276702881, 0.044609662145376205, -0.6071149706840515, 0.13370338082313538, 0.03427761793136597, 0.0749695897102356, 0.14403371512889862, 0.493690550327301, 0.18592597544193268, -0.8322713375091553, 0.3552147448062897, 0.421029657125473, 0.028012804687023163, 0.596116840839386, -0.7611950039863586, 0.15379759669303894, 0.17482875287532806, 0.011384948156774044, -0.27996179461479187, -0.2955140769481659, 0.3212970197200775, -0.6765064597129822, 0.4088805317878723, -0.35777661204338074, -0.46462705731391907, -0.3895086348056793, 0.35850223898887634, 0.3222212493419647, 0.3133980929851532, -0.34514787793159485, 0.784255862236023, 0.37279003858566284, -0.3097127676010132, -0.2773345112800598, -0.5406147837638855, 0.09078598022460938, -0.33320069313049316, 0.08386742323637009, 0.5392491817474365, 0.36856451630592346, -0.3475586175918579, 0.4803074300289154, -0.6151114702224731, -0.5081761479377747, 0.15441082417964935, 0.4977168142795563, -0.013657134026288986, -0.036858927458524704, 0.16152803599834442, 0.028472742065787315, -0.5465956330299377, -0.12056875973939896, -0.3007025420665741, -0.003019403200596571, -0.13111212849617004, 0.012980894185602665, -0.5410506129264832, 0.25752153992652893, 0.1582050770521164, -0.3399679362773895, 0.5725005865097046, 0.603098452091217, -0.6740067005157471, -0.3232043981552124, -0.4774491786956787, -0.33468836545944214, -0.5132907629013062, 0.33882835507392883, -0.23037344217300415, -0.9703817367553711, 0.4245337247848511, -0.4388117492198944, -0.5303809642791748, 0.7096560597419739, 0.10180719196796417, 0.17127418518066406, 0.6490361094474792, 1.1299866437911987, 0.2145252525806427, 0.3121199607849121, -0.4859226644039154, 0.23946842551231384, -1.187013864517212, -0.6223970651626587, -0.4806993007659912, -0.027513448148965836, -0.19987668097019196, -0.2930149435997009, 0.3429509997367859, 0.4693749248981476, -0.18768969178199768, 0.6339617967605591, -0.8601663112640381, 0.6074495315551758, 0.7004611492156982, 0.12851423025131226, 0.3146333396434784, -0.42728859186172485, -0.20463275909423828, 0.11138830333948135, -0.4187222421169281, -0.520244300365448, 0.8194264769554138, 0.1740296334028244, 0.2368708699941635, -0.21809040009975433, 0.9691255688667297, 0.31295672059059143, 0.276925653219223, -0.6680041551589966, 0.6282624006271362, -0.14846813678741455, -0.559194803237915, -0.3326546549797058, -0.5498313307762146, -1.0011317729949951, -0.04120615869760513, -0.32851165533065796, -1.035915732383728, 0.36432960629463196, 0.1319589465856552, -0.5474496483802795, 0.3923055827617645, -0.4338596761226654, 0.8561934232711792, -0.05464707314968109, -0.012804059311747551, -0.14044688642024994, -0.6462167501449585, 0.14338847994804382, -0.4727267324924469, 0.25809529423713684, 0.07796359807252884, -0.00810136180371046, 1.0963908433914185, -0.45231714844703674, 0.8970093727111816, 0.017831427976489067, 0.2564600706100464, 0.2382296621799469, 0.10222350060939789, 0.07806544750928879, 0.5205501914024353, -0.09303384274244308, 0.21547341346740723, -0.09317320585250854, 0.07579410821199417, -0.5175772905349731, 0.7756621241569519, -0.599946141242981, -0.5386967062950134, -0.57222980260849, -0.2739747166633606, 0.17096133530139923, 0.9082580208778381, 0.29576990008354187, 0.24814240634441376, -0.14524954557418823, 0.0369977131485939, 0.8875455856323242, -0.013492083176970482, 0.29706871509552, 0.696230411529541, -0.09952448308467865, -0.8666351437568665, 1.1013870239257812, 0.24361340701580048, -0.016378939151763916, 0.6759100556373596, 0.22292262315750122, -0.04854773357510567, -0.9458621740341187, -0.3493538796901703, -0.007407627068459988, -0.7129576802253723, -0.5770017504692078, -1.1639564037322998, -0.36106809973716736, -0.5228246450424194, -0.14066442847251892, -0.34352755546569824, -0.2894684374332428, -0.7505095601081848, -0.3296574652194977, 0.8865030407905579, 0.8577933311462402, -0.30039024353027344, 0.3285250663757324, -1.0682867765426636, 0.5140107870101929, 0.2880406677722931, 0.1461387574672699, 0.07863245904445648, -0.5065398812294006, -0.4352620542049408, -0.09087888151407242, -0.1652914583683014, -0.9671130180358887, 0.49977943301200867, 0.40024590492248535, 0.6263108849525452, 0.6061692833900452, -0.032118864357471466, 0.6214330196380615, -0.5789515972137451, 0.44129160046577454, 0.02695968560874462, -1.0611246824264526, 0.649383008480072, -0.09114021807909012, -0.010102049447596073, 0.8557827472686768, 0.524038553237915, -0.5151535272598267, -0.2588975429534912, -0.8898118138313293, -1.160212755203247, 0.45151230692863464, -0.05624553933739662, -0.10728582739830017, -0.2708873450756073, 0.5088034868240356, 0.3585379123687744, 0.22974947094917297, -0.38540905714035034, -0.035581037402153015, 0.10915529727935791, 0.09465327113866806, 0.059683654457330704, -0.020528573542833328, 0.08512593805789948, -0.2943527400493622, 0.7609399557113647, 0.08455029875040054, 0.2184503823518753, 0.5381599068641663, -0.2642846405506134, 0.026144258677959442, 0.1469932198524475, 0.15074050426483154, 0.40007442235946655, -0.1746913492679596, 0.1611669957637787, 0.5070605278015137, -0.4343179762363434, -0.045185986906290054, 0.32463034987449646, -0.18933254480361938, 0.006352525670081377, 0.4036264419555664, 0.47084036469459534, 0.26677441596984863, -0.5821205377578735, 0.31576618552207947, 0.27923688292503357, -0.1766674518585205, -0.4172893464565277, 0.11241613328456879, 0.04400496557354927, 0.6444318294525146, 0.4616282284259796, 0.4499356746673584, 0.6091610789299011, -0.0600799135863781, 0.5807676315307617, 0.12405450642108917, -0.5322193503379822, -0.4053337574005127, 0.6913013458251953, 0.07303912192583084, -0.30371057987213135, 0.8259700536727905, -0.6425551772117615, -0.5571691393852234, 1.0184284448623657, 0.6991720199584961, 0.8444254994392395, -0.06554818153381348, 0.19013768434524536, 0.4090796709060669, -0.022010719403624535, -0.03826819732785225, -0.13376592099666595, -0.18447324633598328, -0.608665943145752, -0.11925230920314789, -0.7977386713027954, -0.6452648639678955, -0.1376761794090271, -0.738750159740448, 0.06133008003234863, -0.6888566017150879, -0.3869289457798004, 0.6955907940864563, -0.0017410949803888798, -0.627088189125061, 0.41638344526290894, 0.1770719736814499, 1.0800358057022095, -0.7835181951522827, 0.5159045457839966, 0.9246894717216492, -0.6328039169311523, -0.5999252200126648, -0.291266530752182, 0.09801064431667328, -0.20124852657318115, 1.1544322967529297, 0.4481959640979767, -0.1209455281496048, 0.41378703713417053, -0.1781153678894043, -1.1481895446777344, 1.0816692113876343, -0.29131340980529785, -0.541877031326294, -0.07753072679042816, -0.23580694198608398, 0.6424786448478699, -0.22745540738105774, 0.3064993917942047, 0.4765078127384186, 0.4082169830799103, -0.08996773511171341, -0.8847926259040833, 0.1618560552597046, -0.5815187692642212, 0.15333858132362366, 0.5481424331665039, -0.37466853857040405, 0.76119065284729, -0.47942614555358887, -0.15177497267723083, 0.3142542541027069, 0.9087128043174744, 0.05224975198507309, 0.703646183013916, 0.3045659363269806, 0.7645475268363953, 0.8255059719085693, 0.14113223552703857, 0.6177464723587036, 0.004851735197007656, 0.3381475508213043, 1.14631986618042, -0.3551914393901825, 0.7466020584106445, 0.5937910676002502, 0.03484103083610535, 0.44423118233680725, 0.5796745419502258, -0.6552556753158569, 0.6751194000244141, 0.3416745662689209, -0.2305796593427658, 0.09773838520050049, -0.5315827131271362, -0.19810432195663452, 0.1518040895462036, 0.47640690207481384, -0.3504079580307007, -0.1012677475810051, 0.5774359703063965, -0.07118550688028336, 0.10028883814811707, -0.6586493849754333, 1.0548430681228638, 0.36743319034576416, -0.16225093603134155, -0.09764155745506287, 0.14811155200004578, 0.6651018261909485, -0.275265097618103, -0.23921380937099457, 0.1766297072172165, 0.34227854013442993, -0.4100939631462097, -0.4236651062965393, 0.41786086559295654, -0.006013150792568922, -0.5275158882141113, 0.06255403906106949, 0.9231375455856323, -0.1707160472869873, -0.44550973176956177, 0.30735912919044495, 0.41833311319351196, 0.17754723131656647, -0.0038393998984247446, -0.4691944420337677, -0.42545685172080994, -0.3606031835079193, -0.06906744092702866, 0.27182114124298096, 0.596479594707489, -0.10023811459541321, 0.6370589733123779, 0.6887381672859192, 0.10346539318561554, -0.14002269506454468, -0.13793279230594635, 0.7514750361442566, -0.9365156292915344, -0.3503086268901825, -0.8870115280151367, 0.17730361223220825, -0.24425476789474487, -0.6367524266242981, 0.8916929960250854, 0.5512415170669556, 1.2951394319534302, -0.17937017977237701, 0.5739570260047913, -0.1528390645980835, 0.6524637341499329, -0.28061383962631226, 0.47751808166503906, -0.3289338946342468, -0.06286916136741638, -0.4521948993206024, -0.621573269367218, -0.41377657651901245, 0.43078941106796265, -0.43461963534355164, -0.035213571041822433, 0.7300403118133545, 0.5783315300941467, -0.21307805180549622, -0.04054596275091171, -0.13111460208892822, 0.13739018142223358, -0.006165182217955589, 0.34107616543769836, 0.8434296250343323, -0.04049214720726013, 0.4132704436779022, -0.776566743850708, 0.10316507518291473, -0.3785625994205475, -0.856969952583313, -0.894360363483429, -0.3631245791912079, -0.5701134204864502, -0.16230911016464233, 0.15906605124473572, 1.0235812664031982, 0.7476187348365784, -0.8503223657608032, 0.3132847845554352, -0.5607641339302063, -0.029426254332065582, -0.4938802719116211, -0.2066337764263153, 0.20181353390216827, 0.04235643520951271, -0.5632050633430481, 0.4697088599205017, 0.06088560074567795, 0.19107510149478912, 0.15004727244377136, 0.1679977923631668, -0.09200746566057205, -0.2402523308992386, 0.26056548953056335, 0.6504225730895996, -0.5752789974212646, 0.05702951177954674, 0.021930711343884468, 0.08259912580251694, -0.13112059235572815, 0.6237004995346069, -0.8474879860877991, 0.23711492121219635, 0.3945949375629425, 0.7783893346786499, 0.20792542397975922, 0.09968447685241699, 0.17690452933311462, -0.5639152526855469, -0.26893702149391174, 0.42274272441864014, 0.1553674191236496, 0.4141289293766022, -0.7681216597557068, 0.4512336254119873, 0.2863919138908386, -0.6488335132598877, -0.8738505244255066, 0.172879159450531, -0.9497824907302856, -0.36660605669021606, 0.9906995296478271, -0.030888205394148827, -0.32870203256607056, -0.09376806765794754, 0.017829248681664467, 0.627572238445282, -0.5929959416389465, 0.49357572197914124, 0.12740278244018555, -0.20584027469158173, -0.27984118461608887, -0.5629326701164246, 0.3001433312892914, -0.046801045536994934, -0.7875464558601379, -0.3310827910900116, 0.18023046851158142, 0.5590060949325562, 0.6181025505065918, 0.5313918590545654, 0.05954133719205856, 0.267389178276062, 0.15434905886650085, 0.16232958436012268, -0.3869004249572754, -0.7488988041877747, -0.4043537378311157, 0.02062600664794445, 0.02229747734963894, -0.006122861988842487 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16818v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16818v2	H2O-Danube-1.8B Technical Report	2024-01-30T08:45:08	2024-04-15T17:58:01	Philipp Singer, Pascal Pfeiffer, Yauhen Babakhin, Maximilian Jeblick, Nischay Dhankhar, Gabor Fodor, Sri Satish Ambati	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.LG	We present H2O-Danube, a series of small 1.8B language models consisting of H2O-Danube-1.8B, trained on 1T tokens, and the incremental improved H2O-Danube2-1.8B trained on an additional 2T tokens. Our models exhibit highly competitive metrics across a multitude of benchmarks and, as of the time of this writing, H2O-Danube2-1.8B achieves the top ranking on Open LLM Leaderboard for all models below the 2B parameter range. The models follow core principles of LLama 2 and Mistral, and we leverage and refine various techniques for pre-training large language models. We additionally release chat models trained with supervised fine-tuning followed by direct preference optimization. We make all models openly available under Apache 2.0 license further democratizing LLMs to a wider audience economically.	[ -0.32632532715797424, -0.6869356036186218, 0.3617631793022156, 0.5169813632965088, -0.3495129346847534, 0.08741538226604462, -0.3115723133087158, -0.6133062243461609, 0.16592320799827576, 0.9623908996582031, -0.4272463917732239, -0.6611208319664001, -0.6856634616851807, -0.15476305782794952, -0.28119945526123047, 0.7259202599525452, -0.04057522863149643, 0.20374570786952972, 0.04440847039222717, -0.19232067465782166, -0.33196574449539185, -0.6697906255722046, -0.7515425682067871, -0.5141370892524719, 0.7932177782058716, 0.8427684307098389, 0.5200214982032776, 0.7261598110198975, 0.7252658009529114, 0.25739941000938416, -0.22218351066112518, -0.32067224383354187, -0.82359379529953, 0.2511269748210907, 0.20198720693588257, -0.6285474896430969, -0.8620979189872742, 0.09274615347385406, 0.5771448016166687, 0.44627639651298523, -0.46885791420936584, 0.5666364431381226, -0.051113955676555634, 0.8261703252792358, -0.3531225323677063, 0.34733453392982483, -0.7728704214096069, -0.2167816162109375, -0.3385215103626251, -0.19925439357757568, -0.5862973928451538, -0.1868189573287964, 0.370827317237854, -0.7107409238815308, -0.25000640749931335, 0.49923864006996155, 0.9752404093742371, 0.3762219548225403, -0.19300734996795654, -0.23482677340507507, -0.6271247267723083, 0.7283587455749512, -0.8930716514587402, 0.3964640498161316, 0.426025390625, 0.4555256962776184, -0.17768140137195587, -0.6355974078178406, -0.10760573297739029, -0.30857953429222107, 0.2709697484970093, 0.022972485050559044, -0.45011240243911743, 0.04258069396018982, -0.24546287953853607, 0.2067471593618393, -0.4394002854824066, 0.7149664163589478, -0.6318174004554749, 0.14001712203025818, 0.5015006065368652, 0.37531912326812744, -0.1705273985862732, 0.12202371656894684, -0.40132975578308105, 0.20977574586868286, -0.9227901697158813, -0.0004078751662746072, 0.5175350308418274, 0.37386950850486755, -0.4829067885875702, 0.5920498371124268, -0.4437532424926758, 0.3096562623977661, -0.10111723095178604, -0.07940015941858292, 0.03699792921543121, -0.021421166136860847, -0.2175147831439972, 0.09927663952112198, 0.5722006559371948, 0.14996042847633362, 0.07385233044624329, -0.12499228864908218, -0.06343267112970352, -0.17249809205532074, 0.10411370545625687, -1.20680832862854, -0.3549395799636841, 0.22905653715133667, -0.6725857257843018, -0.6593002676963806, -0.23849911987781525, -0.445064902305603, -0.20840120315551758, -0.38256409764289856, 0.3492516577243805, -0.11249840259552002, -0.4749065935611725, 0.17417532205581665, -0.11981912702322006, 0.287174254655838, 0.3683566451072693, -0.8710255026817322, 0.6334891319274902, 0.7951951622962952, 0.7134667634963989, -0.41094815731048584, -0.11417782306671143, -0.22631970047950745, -0.22996091842651367, -0.40819087624549866, 0.868369996547699, -0.5830740928649902, -0.3128635287284851, -0.07892798632383347, -0.20268835127353668, 0.511156439781189, -0.8489345908164978, 0.4433788061141968, -0.6943902969360352, 0.07650667428970337, 0.04559570550918579, -0.6585841178894043, -0.10174132138490677, 0.28644391894340515, -0.5867530703544617, 1.330889344215393, 0.280599981546402, -0.6818101406097412, 0.1405630111694336, -0.649719774723053, 0.26247638463974, 0.09946023672819138, 0.24172654747962952, -0.42935827374458313, 0.0014937464147806168, -0.23225156962871552, 0.0903177410364151, -0.4798130691051483, 0.055838100612163544, -0.6869240999221802, -0.37040725350379944, 0.1499454826116562, -0.23108269274234772, 0.7301391363143921, 0.3566213548183441, -0.04341825470328331, 0.4877603352069855, -0.7106796503067017, -0.05036496743559837, 0.08155253529548645, -0.6967882513999939, -0.2065601795911789, -0.06304974108934402, 0.15011486411094666, 0.06483123451471329, 0.4465399384498596, -0.5061428546905518, 0.21316944062709808, -0.4395534098148346, 0.42433351278305054, 0.9091506600379944, -0.107126884162426, 0.5372772812843323, -0.06306459754705429, 0.6865519881248474, 0.2801070809364319, 0.2950105369091034, -0.04603985697031021, -0.5761522650718689, -1.1651625633239746, -0.6984460353851318, 0.535902202129364, 0.763611912727356, -0.44944512844085693, 0.5410473346710205, -0.3023710250854492, -1.040961742401123, -0.766593873500824, 0.2773074209690094, 0.308100163936615, 0.3204787075519562, 0.09481728076934814, -0.012940979562699795, -0.6999559998512268, -1.1439539194107056, 0.21758399903774261, -0.2581283748149872, 0.14512360095977783, 0.37068626284599304, 0.524540901184082, -0.2842216193675995, 0.9849556684494019, -0.4479610323905945, 0.09524870663881302, -0.27252644300460815, 0.07118148356676102, 0.20697152614593506, 0.4212256669998169, 0.7162612676620483, -0.36388468742370605, -0.7142834067344666, 0.011488106101751328, -0.5414324998855591, -0.13372761011123657, 0.7456992864608765, -0.40045952796936035, 0.5769870281219482, 0.3096742033958435, -0.22274717688560486, 0.2763090133666992, 0.9750152826309204, -0.3433060050010681, 0.43725064396858215, -0.219879150390625, -0.1318710893392563, -1.217352032661438, -0.15277203917503357, -0.02329498901963234, -0.2619900703430176, -0.5401145219802856, 0.032538339495658875, -0.13948765397071838, -0.1662951111793518, -0.6746629476547241, 0.8784128427505493, -0.33451640605926514, 0.04636366292834282, -0.4387883245944977, 0.002490210346877575, -0.3548771142959595, 0.5387634634971619, -0.08434461057186127, 0.6771599650382996, 0.7955259084701538, -0.6190406680107117, 0.6471825242042542, 0.23773209750652313, -0.38772082328796387, 0.00570043595507741, -0.8952164649963379, 0.18579533696174622, 0.20657891035079956, 0.2046663761138916, -0.9613675475120544, 0.06662809103727341, 0.11158652603626251, -0.5455917119979858, 0.16003713011741638, -0.4126092791557312, -0.524377167224884, -0.31281670928001404, -0.23163871467113495, 0.32673779129981995, 0.7432276606559753, -0.5303071141242981, 0.17687730491161346, 0.6508792638778687, -0.4373466968536377, -0.25504493713378906, -0.40286263823509216, 0.12630392611026764, -0.5139544010162354, -0.7562522888183594, -0.018674420192837715, -0.07428885251283646, -0.4671170711517334, -0.06740481406450272, -0.013217000290751457, -0.33558639883995056, 0.41734185814857483, 0.4157939553260803, 0.5637628436088562, -0.45065000653266907, -0.2275998890399933, -0.22389060258865356, -0.3589438498020172, -0.09231064468622208, -0.45663151144981384, 0.6247638463973999, -0.23632986843585968, 0.15185660123825073, -0.5089834928512573, 0.07215388119220734, 0.2408202588558197, -0.20014077425003052, 0.7251212000846863, 0.2842586636543274, -0.40648338198661804, -0.02684462070465088, -0.44255197048187256, -0.0804223120212555, -0.5301469564437866, 0.3133144676685333, -0.46232831478118896, -1.280163049697876, 0.6341784000396729, 0.06917955726385117, 0.015783781185746193, 0.13536213338375092, 0.7979980111122131, -0.21455812454223633, 0.7632440328598022, 0.9358776807785034, -0.2853168547153473, 0.7937294840812683, -0.2775971591472626, 0.08841504156589508, -0.61357581615448, -0.0817454606294632, -0.84149569272995, -0.0961880311369896, -1.0481411218643188, -0.32120954990386963, 0.3601994216442108, 0.2753012478351593, -0.32636862993240356, 0.6506803035736084, -0.1605554074048996, 0.44533851742744446, 0.7765084505081177, 0.054885104298591614, 0.20723257958889008, 0.09312032163143158, 0.012250158004462719, -0.08019454777240753, -0.7191752195358276, -0.922928512096405, 1.2636141777038574, 0.7594504356384277, 0.9803021550178528, 0.19349656999111176, 0.7671645879745483, 0.33556845784187317, 0.6175684928894043, -0.8344979286193848, 0.4062434732913971, 0.055558476597070694, -1.0068464279174805, -0.6106128692626953, -0.36942192912101746, -0.9635249376296997, 0.2977465093135834, -0.1899886131286621, -0.6159623861312866, -0.427518755197525, 0.15319134294986725, -0.1287493109703064, 0.12458496540784836, -0.6074845194816589, 1.0675386190414429, -0.1614627242088318, -0.2592543661594391, -0.5022203922271729, -0.46339887380599976, 0.34073612093925476, 0.1674089878797531, 0.12176410108804703, -0.5936059951782227, -0.19179843366146088, 0.5893127918243408, -0.21705535054206848, 0.5173179507255554, -0.1696787327528, -0.31995171308517456, 0.3388066291809082, 0.2583683133125305, 0.3415162265300751, -0.04376097023487091, -0.2709188759326935, 0.570463240146637, -0.10368329286575317, -0.617173433303833, -0.30883458256721497, 0.6190376281738281, -0.8079746961593628, -0.5468907356262207, -0.150440976023674, -0.30442506074905396, 0.017417630180716515, 0.12193717062473297, 0.04937538504600525, 0.32803139090538025, -0.43412578105926514, 0.3935948610305786, 0.6401761174201965, -0.20910975337028503, 0.33594369888305664, 0.8482443690299988, -0.4898732304573059, -0.6899816393852234, 0.8308532238006592, 0.04861494526267052, 0.4413009285926819, 0.30430248379707336, 0.08437139540910721, -0.10897611081600189, -0.7309191226959229, -0.44717440009117126, 0.2274787724018097, -0.4522474706172943, -0.06396651268005371, -0.38694173097610474, -0.18788529932498932, -0.5530655384063721, 0.19773973524570465, -0.5866725444793701, -0.6587858200073242, -0.26241636276245117, -0.2626245617866516, 0.24537818133831024, 0.9268902540206909, 0.1948760598897934, 0.5531032681465149, -0.8320237994194031, 0.10073745250701904, -0.034772612154483795, 0.6231628060340881, -0.3284033536911011, -0.9277510643005371, -0.6758835315704346, -0.05555718392133713, -0.441830575466156, -0.575328528881073, 0.4116498529911041, -0.13774485886096954, 0.5649378895759583, 0.3050628900527954, -0.22533565759658813, 0.5596224069595337, -0.6876313090324402, 0.7032986879348755, 0.08236805349588394, -0.8073471188545227, 0.7229165434837341, -0.5807024836540222, -0.05430802330374718, 0.36563387513160706, 0.29631882905960083, -0.37458041310310364, -0.5971253514289856, -0.6183354258537292, -0.7817518711090088, 0.8229758143424988, 0.2977291941642761, 0.08995499461889267, 0.21759268641471863, 0.1855846643447876, 0.26983681321144104, 0.23847241699695587, -0.6312338709831238, -0.40390002727508545, -0.008284625597298145, -0.19085949659347534, 0.0006312566692940891, -0.4847792387008667, 0.10260289162397385, -0.33424732089042664, 1.0649354457855225, 0.08337797224521637, 0.11867184937000275, -0.30096909403800964, 0.10505804419517517, -0.09709475934505463, 0.3057933449745178, 0.701941967010498, 0.6873894333839417, -0.4771104156970978, -0.15852631628513336, 0.1466723531484604, -0.25497809052467346, 0.14492620527744293, 0.005381609778851271, -0.12285973876714706, -0.03813701868057251, 0.23573622107505798, 1.1484469175338745, 0.3544504642486572, -0.5345574617385864, 0.14246387779712677, -0.00720274168998003, -0.20924001932144165, -0.42604511976242065, 0.18949724733829498, 0.4235236346721649, 0.40405434370040894, 0.1399499624967575, -0.3566470444202423, 0.12146297097206116, -0.55698162317276, 0.036367159336805344, 0.2879907190799713, -0.4167405962944031, -0.3510791063308716, 0.3863796293735504, 0.617073655128479, -0.4895622730255127, 0.5750949382781982, -0.12663069367408752, -0.5150848031044006, 0.632318377494812, 0.40320339798927307, 0.7864732146263123, -0.05653390288352966, 0.049980249255895615, 0.5277137160301208, 0.3471235930919647, -0.01663556508719921, 0.25961410999298096, 0.01478722132742405, -0.6124281287193298, 0.08307486772537231, -0.6515467762947083, -0.878994345664978, -0.028377994894981384, -0.6752169132232666, 0.641300618648529, -0.23014141619205475, -0.30126437544822693, -0.052552275359630585, 0.3272208869457245, -0.36043795943260193, -0.12181974202394485, 0.42512938380241394, 1.2835522890090942, -0.5222335457801819, 1.2233978509902954, 0.5429747104644775, -0.36567386984825134, -0.4968169629573822, -0.5160799622535706, -0.22427166998386383, -0.7340800762176514, 0.7518719434738159, 0.06980311125516891, -0.05310288816690445, 0.20247018337249756, -0.8085058927536011, -1.1091645956039429, 1.298622727394104, 0.45337650179862976, -0.5639522671699524, -0.16863861680030823, 0.10335854440927505, 0.5673951506614685, -0.6104874014854431, 0.01611369289457798, 0.6597782373428345, 0.492114394903183, -0.11783948540687561, -1.3585588932037354, -0.38456565141677856, -0.1840219497680664, 0.1516648679971695, 0.08730503916740417, -0.8593437075614929, 0.6038295030593872, -0.2565781772136688, -0.03904557228088379, 0.44151532649993896, 0.8643218278884888, 0.4804425537586212, 0.17775936424732208, 0.3187534213066101, 0.733802318572998, 0.4709988236427307, -0.22896146774291992, 0.7375555634498596, -0.5081570148468018, 0.3923757076263428, 1.3686310052871704, -0.41379889845848083, 1.3363837003707886, 0.43572095036506653, -0.16417784988880157, 0.571323812007904, 0.9521135687828064, 0.07231803238391876, 0.5524167418479919, 0.4419088363647461, -0.07689307630062103, -0.2572595477104187, -0.048326585441827774, -0.225651815533638, 0.4602448344230652, 0.23047158122062683, 0.07100975513458252, -0.07601702958345413, -0.17863653600215912, 0.09840964525938034, -0.21474134922027588, -0.23978188633918762, 0.9275208115577698, 0.26408272981643677, -0.5920999050140381, 0.5987037420272827, 0.27008485794067383, 0.9122809171676636, -0.6025137305259705, 0.03440353646874428, -0.3060782849788666, 0.3345847427845001, 0.11879967153072357, -0.5820547938346863, 0.006714442744851112, 0.26975497603416443, -0.12682650983333588, -0.2633386254310608, 0.5576107501983643, -0.5259745717048645, -0.4922027587890625, 0.5024595856666565, 0.30334344506263733, 0.2426312267780304, -0.056177619844675064, -0.5471780896186829, 0.1605316698551178, -0.39673230051994324, -0.5372947454452515, 0.08058369159698486, 0.49609461426734924, 0.07206401228904724, 0.9735355377197266, 0.410271555185318, 0.08780032396316528, 0.39472073316574097, 0.020580822601914406, 0.5555328726768494, -0.6464726328849792, -0.501587986946106, -0.6330482959747314, 0.39581575989723206, 0.0759386271238327, -0.371863454580307, 0.7795120477676392, 1.0442098379135132, 0.828762948513031, 0.04289884492754936, 0.7174112200737, 0.34599021077156067, 0.49563369154930115, -0.4294872581958771, 0.6169686317443848, -0.4888065457344055, 0.11344075202941895, 0.2628367245197296, -0.8048591017723083, 0.2627543807029724, 0.13975577056407928, 0.015812436118721962, -0.18869085609912872, 0.5300227403640747, 0.7882682681083679, 0.1562216430902481, -0.01201346144080162, 0.37008339166641235, 0.38492295145988464, 0.40026673674583435, 0.30044490098953247, 0.7734625935554504, -0.4985595941543579, 0.6223273277282715, -0.12522944808006287, -0.2526085674762726, -0.41692277789115906, -0.7360761165618896, -0.9451531767845154, -0.3511863648891449, -0.18872547149658203, -0.3451511859893799, -0.10291597247123718, 1.175016164779663, 0.9548377990722656, -0.736900269985199, -0.7604988217353821, 0.2591491937637329, 0.06659593433141708, 0.2886325418949127, -0.20317521691322327, -0.2945370078086853, -0.3878645598888397, -0.7071921825408936, 0.3115289807319641, 0.5575645565986633, 0.26811692118644714, -0.634392261505127, -0.5371959805488586, 0.04891705513000488, 0.4400661587715149, 0.6657708883285522, -0.10436397045850754, -0.8067706823348999, -0.03120041824877262, 0.19116057455539703, -0.5473799705505371, 0.3537328839302063, 0.5377560257911682, -0.4097956418991089, -0.11380206793546677, 0.4705043435096741, 0.35764172673225403, 0.8394542932510376, -0.22441785037517548, 0.3216225504875183, -0.45053306221961975, 0.3513752520084381, -0.049599114805459976, 0.41506463289260864, 0.30279675126075745, 0.08773072063922882, 0.6905497908592224, 0.10676057636737823, -0.4388106167316437, -0.9256577491760254, 0.1270771026611328, -1.186445713043213, -0.1674100160598755, 1.3469226360321045, -0.1630169302225113, -0.32027921080589294, 0.15090760588645935, -0.2640986740589142, 0.14207084476947784, -0.45259442925453186, 0.6912717819213867, 1.1684354543685913, 0.06552159786224365, -0.025349155068397522, -0.6567872166633606, 0.23811979591846466, 0.010246201418340206, -1.146645426750183, 0.12009135633707047, 0.4758742153644562, 0.6964932680130005, -0.23552055656909943, 0.9464788436889648, -0.12804816663265228, 0.05961737036705017, 0.05918192118406296, 0.20740559697151184, -0.08104131370782852, -0.6096116900444031, -0.3221060335636139, -0.2198963761329651, 0.39500921964645386, -0.10621042549610138 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01752v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01752v1	Identifying False Content and Hate Speech in Sinhala YouTube Videos by Analyzing the Audio	2024-01-30T08:08:34	2024-01-30T08:08:34	W. A. K. M. Wickramaarachchi, Sameeri Sathsara Subasinghe, K. K. Rashani Tharushika Wijerathna, A. Sahashra Udani Athukorala, Lakmini Abeywardhana, A. Karunasena	eess.AS	eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD	YouTube faces a global crisis with the dissemination of false information and hate speech. To counter these issues, YouTube has implemented strict rules against uploading content that includes false information or promotes hate speech. While numerous studies have been conducted to reduce offensive English-language content, there's a significant lack of research on Sinhala content. This study aims to address the aforementioned gap by proposing a solution to minimize the spread of violence and misinformation in Sinhala YouTube videos. The approach involves developing a rating system that assesses whether a video contains false information by comparing the title and description with the audio content and evaluating whether the video includes hate speech. The methodology encompasses several steps, including audio extraction using the Pytube library, audio transcription via the fine-tuned Whisper model, hate speech detection employing the distilroberta-base model and a text classification LSTM model, and text summarization through the fine-tuned BART-Large- XSUM model. Notably, the Whisper model achieved a 48.99\% word error rate, while the distilroberta-base model demonstrated an F1 score of 0.856 and a recall value of 0.861 in comparison to the LSTM model, which exhibited signs of overfitting.	[ -0.41303783655166626, -1.0296686887741089, 0.025242343544960022, 0.2374262809753418, -0.38475915789604187, 0.06772308051586151, -0.30834370851516724, -0.47083356976509094, 0.33828434348106384, 0.45026931166648865, -0.34942036867141724, -0.1985066533088684, -0.7674445509910583, 0.023797551169991493, -0.6518389582633972, 1.225359559059143, 0.07790817320346832, 0.19797389209270477, 0.3800544738769531, -0.035927318036556244, -0.529841423034668, -0.35817378759384155, -0.5745193958282471, 0.05515173077583313, 0.5525302290916443, 0.1895872801542282, 0.6928669214248657, 0.2758384943008423, 0.3570886552333832, 0.2520678639411926, -0.42585745453834534, -0.018300248309969902, -0.6886239051818848, 0.052105147391557693, -0.24400024116039276, -0.5064198970794678, -0.24077358841896057, -0.17783010005950928, 0.702276349067688, 0.03662814199924469, -0.18042831122875214, 0.5109013915061951, 0.08450445532798767, 0.20958523452281952, -0.5938017964363098, -0.1417626291513443, -0.720672607421875, 0.1452273428440094, -0.3707941174507141, -0.3728862702846527, -0.32814839482307434, -0.5454299449920654, 0.20562759041786194, -0.2879190444946289, 0.4524408280849457, 0.07520154118537903, 0.5755941271781921, 0.3756501078605652, -0.18922623991966248, -0.4897099733352661, -0.9256973266601562, 0.6855581998825073, -0.8262544274330139, 0.578211784362793, 0.39241087436676025, 0.12846191227436066, 0.0517641119658947, -0.05467317998409271, -0.7955231666564941, -0.07644253224134445, 0.26390859484672546, -0.014094612561166286, -0.5827283263206482, 0.030296266078948975, 0.23955760896205902, 0.5909016728401184, -0.702978253364563, 0.1396588832139969, -0.656295895576477, -0.38102567195892334, 0.805648148059845, 0.04345459118485451, 0.6328433752059937, -0.5617517828941345, -0.39372310042381287, -0.04623439535498619, -0.35285085439682007, 0.037423405796289444, 0.7628262042999268, 0.16527462005615234, 0.05492524430155754, 0.7410599589347839, -0.0683121308684349, 0.41555139422416687, -0.014033681713044643, -0.5625008344650269, 0.2504851520061493, -0.33867236971855164, -0.37302151322364807, 0.7582799792289734, 0.7495932579040527, 0.5671390295028687, 0.30359309911727905, 0.15575844049453735, 0.019000159576535225, 0.2611428201198578, 0.5613046288490295, -0.8079967498779297, -0.013427271507680416, 0.035181924700737, -0.47499194741249084, -0.4209384620189667, -0.3541678190231323, -1.012520432472229, -0.5493665933609009, -0.12822116911411285, 0.733776867389679, -0.4441516697406769, -0.7088202834129333, -0.0514286644756794, -0.4245597720146179, 0.08699416369199753, 0.3324590027332306, -0.45150089263916016, 0.38504093885421753, 0.3551083207130432, 0.8377314209938049, -0.45366910099983215, -0.13421614468097687, -0.3375520408153534, 0.033409442752599716, -0.21396404504776, 0.6289954781532288, -0.3246408998966217, -0.21538563072681427, -0.03622214496135712, 0.07944250106811523, 0.20820188522338867, -0.6190077662467957, 0.8576275110244751, -0.5405322909355164, 0.14366264641284943, -0.10368465632200241, -0.5679643154144287, -0.589214563369751, 0.11676337569952011, -0.6615232229232788, 0.8670266270637512, -0.022997669875621796, -0.7769750952720642, 0.21781378984451294, -0.5591180920600891, -0.22473181784152985, 0.13825121521949768, 0.07938938587903976, -0.6621037721633911, 0.1168002039194107, -0.06989023089408875, 0.058925870805978775, -0.18446019291877747, 0.5240872502326965, -0.1269574910402298, -0.28858277201652527, 0.3804434835910797, -0.9468669891357422, 0.867483913898468, 0.2729618549346924, -0.7106138467788696, 0.1384434551000595, -0.41366371512413025, -0.052626222372055054, 0.23545213043689728, -0.1056271493434906, -0.3223624527454376, -0.07614868134260178, 0.33227670192718506, 0.0884086936712265, -0.1387956142425537, -0.7453736662864685, -0.2806350290775299, -0.41834086179733276, -0.0166618749499321, 0.7074704170227051, 0.23935860395431519, -0.08504831790924072, -0.42301490902900696, 0.6732509732246399, -0.0687093660235405, 0.3012160062789917, 0.3971695303916931, -0.6107458472251892, -0.5604428648948669, -0.012546814046800137, 0.02683964930474758, 0.6135410666465759, -0.24361078441143036, 0.17257770895957947, -0.0805867612361908, -0.6728729605674744, -0.3963644504547119, 0.37596002221107483, 0.5327677130699158, 0.5728274583816528, 0.6121705174446106, -0.32790493965148926, -0.851875901222229, -0.8458510041236877, -0.27972471714019775, -0.288651704788208, 0.26522380113601685, 0.10159710049629211, 0.3503819704055786, 0.0047791507095098495, 0.7409455180168152, -0.5069130659103394, -0.46505656838417053, -0.3459831178188324, 0.1971072107553482, -0.16285482048988342, 0.18439486622810364, 0.540631890296936, -1.2117116451263428, -0.5509336590766907, -0.34211480617523193, -0.4895966649055481, -0.20566275715827942, 0.3038065433502197, 0.06896618753671646, -0.12171343713998795, 0.16309817135334015, -0.04805383086204529, 0.8744221925735474, 0.43748584389686584, -0.1461169719696045, 0.6713644862174988, 0.2843977212905884, 0.49289360642433167, -0.8268293142318726, -0.23805461823940277, 0.07773210108280182, -0.1296282261610031, -0.6494507789611816, -0.28915318846702576, -0.3905981779098511, -0.29533207416534424, -0.6646849513053894, 0.26986798644065857, 0.16827864944934845, 0.14366939663887024, -0.5018648505210876, -0.09055415540933609, -0.2633606493473053, 0.4457331895828247, 0.19805122911930084, 0.7780587673187256, 0.3235512375831604, -0.6735436916351318, 0.6416404843330383, 0.22475962340831757, -0.3333282172679901, 0.6764772534370422, -0.5502074956893921, -0.3363237977027893, -0.09567867964506149, 0.032343585044145584, -0.9417640566825867, -0.23438774049282074, 0.39890000224113464, -0.6607389450073242, -0.06080859899520874, -0.1620267778635025, -0.32550933957099915, -0.11956143379211426, -0.2809446454048157, 0.5868392586708069, 0.43549853563308716, -0.20310083031654358, 0.3438303470611572, 0.9870032668113708, -0.39759960770606995, -0.4319375157356262, -0.39013299345970154, -0.006374218501150608, -0.6246117353439331, -0.2907809615135193, 0.4165872633457184, -0.2105802297592163, -0.28250357508659363, 0.1923271119594574, -0.1743340641260147, -0.3813974857330322, -0.12253477424383163, 0.38936272263526917, -0.007235816679894924, -0.30477312207221985, -0.05773233622312546, -0.005787342321127653, 0.3084198832511902, 0.275728315114975, 0.1806964874267578, 0.7449080944061279, 0.04394710436463356, 0.04874330013990402, -0.7890477180480957, 0.31221136450767517, 0.4242511987686157, -0.11466814577579498, 0.3555469512939453, 0.8656459450721741, -0.47135958075523376, -0.1907854974269867, -0.6587042212486267, 0.17655445635318756, -0.39265280961990356, 0.4530944526195526, 0.04311424121260643, -0.5225042700767517, 0.262871652841568, 0.302257776260376, -0.4232045114040375, 0.6240859031677246, 0.6604490280151367, 0.05790383741259575, 0.8927504420280457, 0.47322049736976624, -0.10136047750711441, 0.6220758557319641, -0.20250742137432098, 0.13128627836704254, -0.7016692757606506, -0.34518691897392273, -0.5121428370475769, -0.12880423665046692, -0.6042283773422241, -0.2694369852542877, 0.5462328195571899, -0.021891819313168526, -0.15775859355926514, 0.4581003189086914, -0.5390695333480835, 0.4947378933429718, 0.42637574672698975, 0.07533510029315948, 0.3020123243331909, 0.25868088006973267, 0.07063914090394974, -0.2689305543899536, -0.46202218532562256, -0.222992941737175, 0.986668050289154, 0.4084218740463257, 0.6571582555770874, 0.5353460907936096, 0.3406783640384674, 0.7229540944099426, 0.16467006504535675, -0.8115640878677368, 0.47875750064849854, -0.18513983488082886, -0.8086708188056946, -0.39195793867111206, -0.36152228713035583, -0.7617286443710327, -0.14147597551345825, -0.06658920645713806, -0.6773123145103455, -0.11737045645713806, -0.10441607236862183, -0.24154990911483765, 0.5682491064071655, -0.4881855249404907, 0.6123381853103638, -0.3720172047615051, -0.3518909215927124, -0.44388794898986816, -0.23431496322155, 0.5126463174819946, -0.06136317178606987, 0.43265849351882935, 0.0604911670088768, 0.35891634225845337, 1.1531230211257935, -0.21322718262672424, 0.7254406213760376, -0.21077750623226166, -0.3831429183483124, 0.5892264246940613, 0.14953356981277466, -0.1405075043439865, 0.09103377163410187, 0.1597577929496765, 0.28530463576316833, -0.05833566188812256, 0.00021854530496057123, -0.5072646141052246, 0.6022787094116211, -0.8519032597541809, -0.2849307954311371, -0.44074591994285583, -0.21344546973705292, -0.017442557960748672, 0.2430429607629776, 0.4132138192653656, 0.3906790018081665, -0.26745209097862244, 0.2096114456653595, 0.8982290029525757, -0.39787524938583374, 0.34236639738082886, 0.5117790102958679, -0.45478737354278564, -0.7579115629196167, 1.1135591268539429, 0.2781296372413635, 0.1408591866493225, 0.1478017419576645, 0.39333266019821167, -0.5512747764587402, -0.5245064496994019, -0.539618968963623, 0.08315572142601013, -0.5283591151237488, -0.1985453963279724, -0.46827980875968933, -0.5558049082756042, -0.41703203320503235, 0.29492607712745667, -0.35163959860801697, 0.08865655213594437, 0.02338954620063305, -0.05242721363902092, 0.36663225293159485, 0.837156355381012, 0.0347202830016613, 0.47657886147499084, -0.4376958906650543, 0.7678317427635193, 0.4160126745700836, 0.41956067085266113, 0.010848745703697205, -0.8953524231910706, -0.01907588541507721, 0.1548546701669693, -0.5356098413467407, -1.2416409254074097, 0.3611149489879608, -0.08416082710027695, 0.4362623393535614, 0.2615419924259186, 0.024124685674905777, 0.9127663373947144, -0.3519895374774933, 0.9051597118377686, 0.18108204007148743, -0.9074061512947083, 0.836103618144989, -0.09445465356111526, -0.24877041578292847, 0.26797449588775635, 0.6312220096588135, -0.534368097782135, -0.6043341755867004, -0.8214389085769653, -0.5728310346603394, 0.47370627522468567, 0.4679969847202301, 0.10851365327835083, 0.19312380254268646, -0.09604908525943756, 0.10534076392650604, 0.2859121561050415, -0.7617682218551636, -0.47009167075157166, -0.405363529920578, -0.04928851127624512, 0.01159337256103754, -0.4065711796283722, -0.024056261405348778, -0.37549686431884766, 0.7462692260742188, 0.2992943823337555, 0.007637434173375368, 0.26904961466789246, -0.3817017376422882, -0.26774993538856506, 0.28797054290771484, 0.6895784735679626, 0.5007565021514893, -0.47383689880371094, 0.15224596858024597, 0.04665578156709671, -0.8713771104812622, 0.32287296652793884, -0.3388788402080536, -0.40882569551467896, 0.5239502191543579, 0.17968051135540009, 0.8161125779151917, 0.07816392183303833, -0.775387704372406, 0.7227514386177063, -0.05500033497810364, 0.019916344434022903, -0.5933793783187866, 0.29046258330345154, -0.4004996418952942, -0.015727028250694275, 0.48642972111701965, 0.04998214170336723, 0.34839728474617004, -0.4834299683570862, 0.2861148416996002, 0.34451162815093994, -0.37813785672187805, -0.25390827655792236, 0.6514445543289185, 0.030473625287413597, -0.5695062279701233, 0.2399509996175766, -0.23155178129673004, -0.7715883255004883, 0.45161476731300354, 0.6515185832977295, 0.7308279275894165, -0.579028308391571, 0.45899081230163574, 0.615929365158081, 0.33447709679603577, 0.039852727204561234, 0.13681213557720184, -0.07524136453866959, -0.6361516118049622, -0.29916098713874817, -0.8592395186424255, -0.3982197940349579, 0.5759630799293518, -0.8558846712112427, 0.4911077320575714, -0.36276906728744507, -0.04793531075119972, 0.1262378841638565, 0.1659449338912964, -0.40335598587989807, 0.5598989129066467, 0.3422120213508606, 0.440331369638443, -1.0197865962982178, 0.597650945186615, 0.10230685770511627, -0.6727732419967651, -0.9060745239257812, -0.03479316085577011, 0.10905377566814423, -0.6103823184967041, 0.6320009231567383, 0.11417242139577866, -0.3738437294960022, -0.04361262917518616, -0.3956354260444641, -0.6522784233093262, 0.38997021317481995, 0.29654303193092346, -0.22998027503490448, 0.00449706707149744, 0.23026618361473083, 0.5398407578468323, -0.23204389214515686, 0.3108958303928375, 0.3055538833141327, 0.22052982449531555, -0.06125909835100174, -1.299390435218811, -0.17727796733379364, -0.20811912417411804, -0.19378337264060974, 0.052018385380506516, -0.4908476769924164, 0.7315035462379456, 0.2561981976032257, -0.23423612117767334, -0.38648566603660583, 0.4252645969390869, 0.07191977649927139, 0.5250498056411743, 0.6992897987365723, 0.5576972961425781, 0.6020148992538452, 0.39780619740486145, 0.6007774472236633, 0.1601950079202652, 0.35994753241539, 1.1386553049087524, 0.10099329054355621, 0.8504320979118347, 0.2749226987361908, -0.2139555662870407, 0.5884491205215454, 0.26757311820983887, -0.07998581230640411, 0.32089963555336, 0.25357887148857117, -0.1841243952512741, -0.0030917548574507236, -0.6901776790618896, -0.39318326115608215, 0.8700037002563477, 0.4623250961303711, -0.33595582842826843, -0.3435494005680084, 0.3573485016822815, -0.001308870268985629, 0.09763851761817932, -0.5940378308296204, 0.8985702395439148, -0.306789368391037, -0.3881990909576416, 0.7585448622703552, -0.014488386921584606, 0.821265459060669, -0.4310649633407593, -0.10057137161493301, 0.18675534427165985, -0.1003352552652359, -0.34245413541793823, -0.7084363698959351, 0.6176308393478394, 0.5226381421089172, -0.19617806375026703, -0.16378869116306305, 0.5098791718482971, -0.540758490562439, -0.40521398186683655, 0.2149076759815216, 0.09414579719305038, 0.37814879417419434, -0.23157915472984314, -0.5725694894790649, 0.42633408308029175, 0.12719866633415222, 0.18315421044826508, 0.20205217599868774, 0.0923720970749855, -0.09229767322540283, 0.43777233362197876, 0.6096932888031006, 0.6005258560180664, 0.24939975142478943, -0.0076940590515732765, 0.4578070342540741, -0.724549412727356, -0.5156258940696716, -0.9594154953956604, 0.12435760349035263, -0.2091529369354248, -0.5156965851783752, 0.8852933049201965, 0.9708731174468994, 1.0016028881072998, 0.052372753620147705, 0.8400483727455139, -0.20540384948253632, 0.6786861419677734, -0.4478069543838501, 0.6888172030448914, -0.6100366115570068, -0.010410189628601074, -0.6170957684516907, -0.7530860900878906, -0.08316226303577423, 0.6561949849128723, -0.18864892423152924, -0.40359678864479065, 0.6467165350914001, 0.8073276877403259, -0.17211584746837616, 0.22544553875923157, 0.12832163274288177, 0.3817956745624542, 0.2912088632583618, 0.2848060727119446, 0.9072132706642151, -0.6428073644638062, 0.7454074621200562, -0.4494677186012268, -0.10459677875041962, -0.32704004645347595, -0.6046702265739441, -0.5762625932693481, -0.5698206424713135, -0.47507497668266296, -0.5733715891838074, -0.3024177551269531, 0.6914802193641663, 0.4801112413406372, -0.7873647809028625, -0.42667755484580994, 0.1470479667186737, 0.3612838685512543, -0.19323815405368805, -0.33043891191482544, 0.17721828818321228, 0.1634839028120041, -0.8609666228294373, 0.34430041909217834, 0.3554019033908844, -0.0654529556632042, -0.45803096890449524, -0.003698068205267191, -0.16877630352973938, 0.06499277800321579, 0.3003552258014679, 0.2169368714094162, -0.9454317688941956, -0.3538943827152252, -0.06836745887994766, 0.07268077880144119, 0.051246702671051025, 0.7366272211074829, -0.4795820116996765, 0.45825836062431335, 0.4388371407985687, 0.45539233088493347, 0.44170475006103516, 0.09003961831331253, 0.09540249407291412, -0.47492438554763794, 0.11060100793838501, 0.4203241467475891, 0.00262916530482471, 0.21061138808727264, -0.3488433361053467, 0.06536306440830231, 0.4292765259742737, -0.41800767183303833, -1.193943738937378, 0.18382912874221802, -1.1266241073608398, 0.021158672869205475, 1.130723237991333, 0.25076794624328613, -0.3538361191749573, -0.22304800152778625, -0.5884867310523987, 0.6148041486740112, -0.2605942487716675, 0.8192349672317505, 0.7475085854530334, -0.10931053012609482, -0.11607343703508377, -0.7139741778373718, 0.6675029993057251, 0.3762163519859314, -0.45561477541923523, -0.023380031809210777, 0.40191277861595154, 0.65318363904953, 0.4158041477203369, 0.4879002273082733, 0.005019483156502247, 0.42051753401756287, -0.0905054435133934, -0.24519631266593933, 0.13359937071800232, -0.4447627365589142, -0.3830605745315552, 0.5290395021438599, -0.1910691261291504, -0.1834888607263565 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01751v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01751v1	Performance Assessment of ChatGPT vs Bard in Detecting Alzheimer's Dementia	2024-01-30T07:55:43	2024-01-30T07:55:43	Balamurali B T, Jer-Ming Chen	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Large language models (LLMs) find increasing applications in many fields. Here, three LLM chatbots (ChatGPT-3.5, ChatGPT-4 and Bard) are assessed - in their current form, as publicly available - for their ability to recognize Alzheimer's Dementia (AD) and Cognitively Normal (CN) individuals using textual input derived from spontaneous speech recordings. Zero-shot learning approach is used at two levels of independent queries, with the second query (chain-of-thought prompting) eliciting more detailed than the first. Each LLM chatbot's performance is evaluated on the prediction generated in terms of accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, precision and F1 score. LLM chatbots generated three-class outcome ("AD", "CN", or "Unsure"). When positively identifying AD, Bard produced highest true-positives (89% recall) and highest F1 score (71%), but tended to misidentify CN as AD, with high confidence (low "Unsure" rates); for positively identifying CN, GPT-4 resulted in the highest true-negatives at 56% and highest F1 score (62%), adopting a diplomatic stance (moderate "Unsure" rates). Overall, three LLM chatbots identify AD vs CN surpassing chance-levels but do not currently satisfy clinical application.	[ -0.2711452841758728, -1.1480451822280884, 0.808992326259613, 0.11506331712007523, -0.05683793127536774, 0.03017600253224373, -0.3578029274940491, -0.6553972363471985, 0.12864670157432556, 0.21898630261421204, -0.3957274258136749, -0.7642725110054016, -0.8322563767433167, -0.15095822513103485, -0.18686921894550323, 1.143646001815796, 0.06887742877006531, 0.21390880644321442, 0.06739133596420288, -0.020893113687634468, -0.5186230540275574, -0.40451404452323914, -1.402849555015564, -0.2521209120750427, 0.4743408262729645, 0.31673938035964966, 0.5614146590232849, 0.13130062818527222, 0.542715847492218, 0.31802642345428467, -0.283421128988266, -0.08872885257005692, -0.5440054535865784, 0.07969696074724197, 0.19000953435897827, -0.37466344237327576, -1.0878374576568604, 0.3206438720226288, 0.48469117283821106, 0.22023318707942963, -0.11782600730657578, 0.11645108461380005, 0.0954359769821167, 0.7838830351829529, -0.4704574942588806, 0.5033084154129028, -0.7218029499053955, -0.02066580206155777, -0.3726062774658203, -0.13986994326114655, -0.3542441129684448, -0.6031216382980347, 0.2957468628883362, -0.35970914363861084, 0.030839111655950546, 0.012617578729987144, 0.7926836013793945, 0.018283812329173088, -0.300590842962265, -0.5256800651550293, -0.6173723340034485, 0.5942042469978333, -0.8333485126495361, 0.004615651909261942, 0.6446828246116638, 0.5626379251480103, -0.3369547128677368, -0.4347159266471863, -0.5291383266448975, -0.7263258695602417, 0.2894813120365143, 0.43375855684280396, -0.4247765839099884, 0.41703903675079346, 0.14511486887931824, 0.592369794845581, -0.9198058843612671, 0.38366755843162537, -0.5757294297218323, -0.6148455739021301, 0.5617160201072693, 0.17859676480293274, 0.310686320066452, -0.03257627412676811, -0.27957865595817566, 0.052236899733543396, -0.4597150385379791, -0.008924903348088264, 0.22977833449840546, 0.2781562805175781, 0.10478030890226364, 0.6175619959831238, -0.16058796644210815, 0.6360804438591003, 0.019796768203377724, -0.23382535576820374, 0.4088752567768097, -0.11879289895296097, -0.279268741607666, 0.2946053445339203, 0.9426664113998413, 0.33738943934440613, 0.4923582375049591, -0.01941007748246193, -0.04250171408057213, 0.4952997863292694, -0.09866679459810257, -0.6179367303848267, -0.31409353017807007, 0.4036853313446045, -0.35177406668663025, -0.010805158875882626, -0.2881239652633667, -0.5726358890533447, -0.35443007946014404, 0.16484251618385315, 0.7191322445869446, -0.6126247048377991, -0.1117914468050003, 0.24137519299983978, -0.10359860956668854, 0.46904006600379944, 0.585848867893219, -0.6119512915611267, 0.2858099043369293, 0.6722946763038635, 0.8602861166000366, -0.7399968504905701, -0.14318150281906128, -0.7331775426864624, 0.025995178148150444, -0.27754637598991394, 1.1590232849121094, -0.3341878652572632, -0.2861068546772003, -0.3512580692768097, -0.10993970185518265, -0.2910155653953552, -0.508852481842041, 0.914267361164093, -0.498844712972641, 0.44242894649505615, 0.06867790967226028, -0.8117852807044983, -0.3356350064277649, 0.4118492007255554, -0.7561594247817993, 1.1685618162155151, 0.16560377180576324, -0.6069313287734985, 0.5425913333892822, -0.6887164115905762, -0.22303776443004608, 0.19536462426185608, -0.08940909057855606, -0.30235254764556885, -0.11513258516788483, 0.11903761327266693, 0.698603630065918, -0.10221366584300995, 0.03586975112557411, -0.3587222993373871, -0.46695876121520996, 0.21321195363998413, -0.9703526496887207, 0.5682205557823181, 0.023389821872115135, -0.24174758791923523, 0.09712649136781693, -0.6217761039733887, 0.21143285930156708, -0.1993025839328766, -0.6251807808876038, -0.03481736406683922, -0.0785289853811264, -0.23557771742343903, 0.183172807097435, 0.33811232447624207, -0.6879404187202454, -0.1422601342201233, -0.32941433787345886, 0.18889524042606354, 0.7338522672653198, 0.01800309680402279, 0.022974809631705284, -0.4878104329109192, 0.544762372970581, -0.15882691740989685, 0.26848724484443665, 0.09310459345579147, -1.0156196355819702, -0.35509148240089417, -0.5229717493057251, 0.38542425632476807, 0.9563079476356506, -0.394030898809433, 0.46875837445259094, -0.1575353890657425, -0.48366522789001465, -0.521027684211731, -0.06500598788261414, 0.5137450098991394, 0.43861082196235657, 0.3066392242908478, -0.608816385269165, 0.12445052713155746, -0.6574522852897644, -0.1997251957654953, -0.5046548247337341, -0.1599758267402649, 0.6527580618858337, 0.20889224112033844, -0.11299736797809601, 0.40637636184692383, -0.34526363015174866, -0.5758665204048157, -0.25177350640296936, 0.1351747065782547, 0.11437644064426422, 0.18225689232349396, 0.2616322338581085, -0.42831382155418396, -0.5616666674613953, 0.12614236772060394, -0.641071617603302, 0.07437912374734879, 0.3353014588356018, 0.016571803018450737, 0.5059705376625061, 0.26503172516822815, -0.6699207425117493, 0.8225061297416687, 0.7028211355209351, -0.20189160108566284, 0.5909450054168701, -0.29106828570365906, 0.33990079164505005, -0.711439847946167, -0.17792783677577972, -0.17850078642368317, -0.13893970847129822, -0.5493416786193848, -0.6152370572090149, -0.2759997844696045, 0.1200745478272438, -0.3014601767063141, 0.5977988243103027, -0.4458785057067871, -0.4274461567401886, -0.17189107835292816, 0.6337710022926331, -0.2635522484779358, 0.46122047305107117, -0.11562708020210266, 0.7784310579299927, 0.6958258748054504, -0.48089367151260376, 0.41547510027885437, -0.16540057957172394, -0.5664669871330261, 0.44553789496421814, -0.6639431118965149, 0.14693692326545715, 0.08200833946466446, 0.3594999611377716, -1.5681719779968262, -0.12374269217252731, 0.1773749738931656, -0.7636743783950806, 0.2766379714012146, 0.03089388832449913, -0.2537359297275543, -0.3845943212509155, -0.41360315680503845, 0.3465137481689453, 0.47204431891441345, -0.04019435495138168, 0.7642716765403748, 0.4359824061393738, -0.28627777099609375, -0.5447655916213989, -0.6337710618972778, -0.057400237768888474, -0.32830366492271423, -0.7519810199737549, 0.2182680368423462, -0.13456712663173676, 0.04535509645938873, 0.07496952265501022, -0.2543308436870575, -0.07616830617189407, -0.07204359024763107, 0.08891130238771439, 0.3412153422832489, -0.3960014283657074, 0.10521858185529709, -0.3074370324611664, -0.25472086668014526, -0.1896415650844574, 0.14789646863937378, 0.6942712664604187, -0.45535433292388916, -0.5405203104019165, -0.7109828591346741, -0.07733175903558731, 0.6826497316360474, -0.11381108313798904, 0.3683115243911743, 0.9437968134880066, -0.16092704236507416, 0.08051817119121552, -0.7315128445625305, 0.0350581519305706, -0.4744739532470703, 0.3539409041404724, -0.26780396699905396, -1.0417766571044922, 0.6737474203109741, -0.054564375430345535, -0.2374029904603958, 0.5081524848937988, 0.8713090419769287, 0.0272316075861454, 0.9511278867721558, 0.3181626796722412, -0.2519718110561371, 0.5273471474647522, 0.06417808681726456, 0.13003842532634735, -0.9688246250152588, -0.08544456213712692, -0.26846349239349365, -0.11782915145158768, -0.9347464442253113, -0.4269995093345642, 0.6990787982940674, -0.11821063607931137, -0.23570385575294495, 0.09121932834386826, -0.42528384923934937, 0.3336893320083618, 0.4334719777107239, 0.2424074411392212, 0.3363224267959595, -0.12173474580049515, 0.007582495920360088, 0.21127650141716003, -0.4830448031425476, -0.744445264339447, 1.3940898180007935, 0.22264954447746277, 0.4682774543762207, 0.22754469513893127, 0.47791817784309387, 0.536250650882721, 0.3702346980571747, -1.1962616443634033, 0.8061639666557312, -0.4072299599647522, -0.7317908406257629, -0.5881185531616211, -0.4159645140171051, -1.2528481483459473, 0.0671527087688446, -0.016560638323426247, -0.9424508213996887, -0.24452435970306396, -0.011712033301591873, -0.5731923580169678, 0.12900860607624054, -0.7390453219413757, 0.8981088995933533, -0.3973518908023834, -0.03004712425172329, -0.26167115569114685, -0.4973350465297699, 0.5017359852790833, -0.15405313670635223, -0.0036862867418676615, -0.5691824555397034, -0.02466641552746296, 0.8116680979728699, 0.17301800847053528, 0.6554345488548279, -0.12405304610729218, 0.018164698034524918, 0.48130548000335693, 0.22899861633777618, 0.29379409551620483, -0.1665799617767334, -0.35375797748565674, 0.13991615176200867, 0.08365195244550705, -0.38476914167404175, -0.5004737973213196, 0.639092206954956, -0.7670427560806274, -0.6855900287628174, -0.49239176511764526, -0.35095298290252686, -0.370044082403183, 0.03410457447171211, 0.03404809162020683, 0.36983832716941833, -0.5960825085639954, -0.06266988813877106, 0.6276413798332214, -0.44502249360084534, 0.27804896235466003, 0.7624614834785461, -0.16049936413764954, -0.35190215706825256, 0.8334811925888062, 0.030403682962059975, 0.6183246374130249, 0.105097696185112, 0.3176015615463257, -0.08727573603391647, -0.6697993278503418, -0.4192087948322296, 0.24504029750823975, -0.5497323274612427, -0.028684182092547417, -0.3849814236164093, -0.4188861846923828, -0.20010027289390564, 0.3005754351615906, -0.23113222420215607, -0.520889937877655, -0.04793287068605423, -0.2182275801897049, 0.5325732231140137, 0.7636281251907349, -0.08459790050983429, 0.34927189350128174, -0.6047964096069336, 0.24476005136966705, 0.38860657811164856, 0.2324192076921463, -0.1600903868675232, -0.5290480852127075, 0.10734161734580994, -0.12056219577789307, -0.4846245348453522, -0.9143581986427307, 0.2196776568889618, 0.3098452389240265, 0.8340722322463989, 0.49797073006629944, -0.34841984510421753, 0.5979351997375488, -0.4515659809112549, 1.0546132326126099, -0.041979867964982986, -0.6714280247688293, 0.4813273549079895, -0.2688819468021393, -0.09355688840150833, 0.5781798958778381, 0.45322585105895996, -0.31843575835227966, -0.3452279269695282, -0.6143199801445007, -0.7124157547950745, 0.7231573462486267, 0.19266080856323242, -0.02723650448024273, -0.12842023372650146, 0.39435645937919617, -0.09976409375667572, -0.09716257452964783, -0.49034246802330017, -0.1248820498585701, 0.32519203424453735, -0.11136799305677414, -0.2965850830078125, -0.26149094104766846, -0.027108337730169296, -0.12372656911611557, 0.48913824558258057, 0.10301443934440613, 0.7288509011268616, 0.10248073935508728, 0.3651081919670105, 0.03740657493472099, 0.12858439981937408, 0.6169878840446472, 0.458999902009964, -0.4467315077781677, -0.12314902245998383, 0.2876061201095581, -0.7415512204170227, -0.10337387025356293, -0.048663441091775894, 0.31033778190612793, -0.16798090934753418, 0.54490727186203, 0.7169767022132874, -0.2382553517818451, -0.7478118538856506, 0.8663275837898254, -0.246387779712677, -0.00684103649109602, -0.44612419605255127, 0.2881125807762146, 0.08424045145511627, 0.27838632464408875, 0.17546328902244568, 0.026870042085647583, 0.24513308703899384, -0.6820590496063232, 0.2036706954240799, 0.6779545545578003, -0.5633000731468201, -0.3144977390766144, 0.40055355429649353, -0.15952059626579285, -0.3834407329559326, 0.6854717135429382, -0.3099135458469391, -0.545357346534729, 0.7101852893829346, 0.3696459233760834, 0.9697142243385315, -0.49564018845558167, 0.19402842223644257, 0.21074093878269196, 0.17801012098789215, -0.1837616264820099, 0.4084581434726715, 0.02434874139726162, -0.9095468521118164, -0.48905619978904724, -0.451293021440506, -0.4605764150619507, 0.14245334267616272, -0.7955755591392517, 0.21856823563575745, -0.1905037760734558, -0.5440305471420288, 0.150799959897995, 0.24491101503372192, -0.4784442186355591, 0.14029720425605774, 0.19504263997077942, 0.79533451795578, -0.7914857268333435, 0.9151460528373718, 0.4683901071548462, -0.2958531081676483, -0.6918235421180725, 0.28090620040893555, 0.06129167228937149, -1.2337591648101807, 0.6624827980995178, 0.15500836074352264, -0.2698385715484619, -0.17673924565315247, -0.3333575427532196, -0.8296017050743103, 1.3567430973052979, 0.24859726428985596, -0.11336270719766617, 0.06106926500797272, -0.23923759162425995, 0.7764487862586975, -0.25673341751098633, 0.6226213574409485, 0.689476728439331, 0.43422672152519226, 0.33604541420936584, -1.4458733797073364, -0.1845422089099884, 0.020011089742183685, -0.21970687806606293, 0.0064826044254004955, -0.7445401549339294, 0.8701027035713196, -0.0830036923289299, -0.38356199860572815, 0.07419393956661224, 0.47652140259742737, 0.6197082996368408, 0.6400446891784668, 0.24465729296207428, 0.5182605981826782, 1.0883668661117554, 0.03756958618760109, 1.003161907196045, -0.37372279167175293, 0.009595787152647972, 0.8614057898521423, -0.34018486738204956, 1.1617403030395508, 0.06568637490272522, -0.2908688485622406, 0.5311275720596313, 0.6884720921516418, 0.3633817434310913, 0.37664079666137695, 0.2772059440612793, -0.4291425049304962, -0.11969258636236191, 0.21092283725738525, -0.180373877286911, 0.6591590046882629, 0.9524586200714111, -0.046291202306747437, -0.18368734419345856, -0.04754021763801575, 0.2983021140098572, -0.272976279258728, -0.3740949034690857, 0.8367549777030945, 0.06034918501973152, -0.625071108341217, 0.6094648241996765, -0.05081222578883171, 0.6766552925109863, -0.5798989534378052, -0.0017409682041034102, -0.22167089581489563, 0.2608366310596466, -0.013142835348844528, -1.018078327178955, 0.1632707267999649, 0.01765531301498413, 0.08030635118484497, 0.3853403627872467, 0.6883271932601929, -0.12968449294567108, -0.344077467918396, 0.553178608417511, 0.6844753623008728, 0.9200047850608826, -0.0006391014903783798, -0.8985665440559387, 0.060271479189395905, -0.19608335196971893, -0.4779565930366516, 0.3876500129699707, 0.6562147736549377, -0.2952446937561035, 0.8304903507232666, 0.39979517459869385, 0.3492860496044159, 0.13459400832653046, -0.04374053329229355, 0.7047444581985474, -0.40456557273864746, -0.0575588122010231, -0.9192228317260742, -0.09097260981798172, 0.03906797245144844, -0.44474855065345764, 0.8026787042617798, 0.5400879383087158, 0.5786108374595642, 0.3248603045940399, 0.5589944124221802, 0.07987475395202637, 0.5091302990913391, -0.5539196133613586, 0.3719131350517273, -0.3251814842224121, 0.32869264483451843, -0.33437544107437134, -0.7644277215003967, -0.3753169775009155, 0.7300851941108704, -0.7365854978561401, 0.476349800825119, 0.7461503744125366, 1.0379612445831299, 0.07948259264230728, 0.013887939974665642, 0.5250205993652344, 0.3911561071872711, 0.19933946430683136, 1.0028659105300903, 0.9136914610862732, -0.37781932950019836, 0.5758174061775208, 0.3108316659927368, -0.6829630732536316, -0.052422910928726196, -0.9104120135307312, -0.9999216794967651, -0.25374484062194824, -0.25305819511413574, -0.3732052445411682, 0.18450209498405457, 0.5848624110221863, 0.3526672422885895, -0.8055093884468079, -0.2066754698753357, 0.2222122997045517, -0.1649271845817566, -0.3498682975769043, -0.24194839596748352, 0.8732728362083435, -0.16931979358196259, -0.5625885725021362, 0.5465212464332581, 0.41315561532974243, -0.11462894082069397, -0.33975866436958313, -0.06726662814617157, 0.07027164846658707, 0.17359361052513123, 0.7374650835990906, 0.20955736935138702, -0.8178926110267639, -0.3131580352783203, -0.185658797621727, -0.276463121175766, 0.1674574762582779, 0.3143988847732544, -0.818232536315918, 0.28782424330711365, 0.5501421689987183, 0.39273571968078613, 0.7182987928390503, 0.2633882462978363, 0.2784174382686615, -0.10048171877861023, -0.14971505105495453, 0.42048805952072144, 0.046823352575302124, 0.2137303203344345, -0.5113601088523865, 0.4287859797477722, 0.06657345592975616, -1.068040370941162, -0.539291262626648, 0.13417746126651764, -1.429029107093811, -0.10793162882328033, 1.2855042219161987, -0.30231383442878723, -0.25936293601989746, -0.31991544365882874, -0.31339186429977417, 0.07181756943464279, -0.6208018064498901, 0.7011409997940063, 0.7146180272102356, -0.7187792062759399, 0.23545870184898376, -1.1641287803649902, 0.6458672285079956, 0.3025889992713928, -0.4405819773674011, -0.12390436977148056, 0.5609682202339172, 0.3649146854877472, -0.02814064361155033, 1.1674940586090088, -0.4986298382282257, 0.3515486419200897, -0.34558409452438354, -0.01651182398200035, 0.1675315648317337, -0.17433637380599976, -0.44998013973236084, 0.07038453966379166, 0.15950249135494232, -0.3253491520881653 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16788v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16788v1	Can Large Language Models be Trusted for Evaluation? Scalable Meta-Evaluation of LLMs as Evaluators via Agent Debate	2024-01-30T07:03:32	2024-01-30T07:03:32	Steffi Chern, Ethan Chern, Graham Neubig, Pengfei Liu	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Despite the utility of Large Language Models (LLMs) across a wide range of tasks and scenarios, developing a method for reliably evaluating LLMs across varied contexts continues to be challenging. Modern evaluation approaches often use LLMs to assess responses generated by LLMs. However, the meta-evaluation conducted to assess the effectiveness of these LLMs as evaluators is typically constrained by the coverage of existing benchmarks or requires extensive human annotation. This underscores the urgency of methods for scalable meta-evaluation that can effectively, reliably, and efficiently evaluate the performance of LLMs as evaluators across diverse tasks and scenarios, particularly in potentially new, user-defined scenarios. To fill this gap, we propose ScaleEval, an agent-debate-assisted meta-evaluation framework that leverages the capabilities of multiple communicative LLM agents. This framework supports multi-round discussions to assist human annotators in discerning the most capable LLMs as evaluators, which significantly eases their workload in cases that used to require large-scale annotations during meta-evaluation. We release the code for our framework, which is publicly available at: \url{https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/scaleeval}.	[ -0.46941256523132324, -0.6745860576629639, 0.5384137034416199, 0.43534430861473083, 0.07949776947498322, 0.28089141845703125, -0.5909979343414307, -0.47081196308135986, 0.16371075809001923, 0.4507797360420227, -0.27178531885147095, -0.2537490129470825, -0.7259314060211182, 0.21144753694534302, -0.319903701543808, 0.9740801453590393, -0.012683922424912453, 0.21541795134544373, -0.4350869953632355, -0.5093263983726501, -0.18293768167495728, -0.5080223083496094, -0.8039109110832214, -0.5790666937828064, 0.5155001878738403, 0.3298264741897583, 0.8628729581832886, 0.31873056292533875, 0.7377458810806274, 0.42183253169059753, -0.09465255588293076, 0.20427361130714417, -0.2638453543186188, 0.3915707468986511, -0.2613946199417114, -0.21224336326122284, -0.8293891549110413, 0.154839888215065, 0.8730618357658386, 0.6232179999351501, -0.31286653876304626, 0.5832197666168213, 0.09587150812149048, 0.4692167639732361, -0.801813006401062, 0.2526856064796448, -0.6889623999595642, -0.09454423934221268, 0.06643743813037872, 0.06195082142949104, -0.608716607093811, -0.34179073572158813, 0.149478018283844, -0.31583482027053833, -0.29074424505233765, -0.049827054142951965, 0.5196853280067444, 0.39100947976112366, -0.4614674746990204, -0.28464895486831665, -0.6741893887519836, 0.5676561594009399, -0.6827605962753296, 0.22645224630832672, 0.3150654733181, 0.6000584363937378, -0.017878232523798943, -1.0094650983810425, -0.4863838255405426, -0.5714457035064697, -0.01705903559923172, -0.11115086078643799, -0.2729470133781433, -0.04346654936671257, 0.20642341673374176, 0.20743952691555023, -0.34090474247932434, 0.262912392616272, 0.21388652920722961, -0.34800201654434204, 0.6496078968048096, 0.3013615906238556, 0.18093536794185638, -0.25048181414604187, -0.263313353061676, -0.0004402782942634076, -0.5176211595535278, -0.24052324891090393, 0.07305355370044708, 0.43511560559272766, 0.028332415968179703, 0.46747955679893494, -0.11767961084842682, 0.40408754348754883, 0.11372070014476776, 0.005996739491820335, 0.5652152299880981, -0.3441353440284729, -0.3134766221046448, -0.385006844997406, 1.1693623065948486, 0.37655574083328247, 0.2641617953777313, -0.07989028841257095, -0.3525955080986023, -0.08162874728441238, 0.38045671582221985, -1.0624843835830688, 0.2807563245296478, 0.3187735080718994, -0.4164027273654938, -0.5638647079467773, -0.16401199996471405, -0.8842240571975708, -0.5520025491714478, 0.058403294533491135, 0.512071430683136, 0.07858273386955261, -0.2787250876426697, -0.015859920531511307, 0.1915140151977539, 0.10474137216806412, 0.453035444021225, -0.8261359333992004, 0.3480013608932495, 0.7866689562797546, 0.7623924016952515, 0.026264656335115433, -0.4776179790496826, -0.8716466426849365, -0.1519770622253418, -0.39548298716545105, 0.6252619624137878, -0.8659787178039551, -0.2951783537864685, 0.22416430711746216, -0.04842827469110489, -0.07246547937393188, -0.48849308490753174, 0.781385064125061, -0.5863370895385742, -0.05643162503838539, -0.3812945783138275, -0.3961300849914551, 0.2244715541601181, 0.654159426689148, -1.0403616428375244, 0.9681990146636963, -0.05119441822171211, -0.7831763625144958, 0.47038185596466064, -0.8129520416259766, -0.2923857569694519, 0.28888019919395447, -0.30305537581443787, -0.4497140944004059, 0.022195369005203247, 0.3839332163333893, 0.40907853841781616, -0.6127304434776306, 0.24197138845920563, -0.48086029291152954, -0.16224627196788788, 0.4688762426376343, -0.6151613593101501, 0.4669090211391449, 0.2818654477596283, -0.5131881237030029, 0.39427492022514343, -0.641796350479126, 0.15309908986091614, -0.16219516098499298, -0.31651461124420166, -0.17316611111164093, 0.03640454262495041, 0.20937387645244598, 0.11131435632705688, 0.3373464345932007, -0.4522567093372345, 0.1254688799381256, -0.14451831579208374, 0.5198233723640442, 0.6629427671432495, -0.08224627375602722, 0.4781467616558075, -0.28484779596328735, 0.7719082236289978, -0.5623162984848022, 0.2508507966995239, -0.0694877877831459, -0.08011205494403839, -0.5224350094795227, -0.3500343859195709, 0.34930863976478577, 0.2702798843383789, -0.7385711669921875, 0.20190498232841492, -0.514014720916748, -0.7220583558082581, -0.5743694305419922, 0.03745351359248161, 0.4574907422065735, 0.11467529833316803, 0.10439340770244598, 0.07433899492025375, -0.3778012990951538, -0.7670756578445435, -0.41536465287208557, -0.3120551109313965, -0.26005372405052185, 0.4642985761165619, 0.6259203553199768, -0.5338266491889954, 0.9353110790252686, -0.18046313524246216, -0.1286112517118454, -0.45633384585380554, 0.42065346240997314, -0.22610484063625336, 0.19714365899562836, 0.4119865298271179, -0.5866552591323853, -0.5993921160697937, 0.061826400458812714, -0.5666466951370239, -0.407060444355011, -0.14318513870239258, 0.16255119442939758, 0.1666523963212967, 0.5684986114501953, -0.6818843483924866, -0.006866959854960442, 0.7570369839668274, -0.3437325060367584, 0.5568374991416931, -0.21791566908359528, 0.14660736918449402, -1.1504656076431274, 0.2732776403427124, -0.29677459597587585, -0.6131684184074402, -0.4323369860649109, 0.36336082220077515, 0.08303264528512955, 0.1316239833831787, -0.1743081510066986, 0.7512954473495483, -0.37181249260902405, -0.05052519589662552, -0.2723393440246582, 0.40303200483322144, -0.08273657411336899, -0.026613639667630196, 0.07334215193986893, 0.8336478471755981, 0.4915662407875061, -0.1916881948709488, 0.26310792565345764, 0.03161986172199249, -0.30764201283454895, 0.7232823371887207, -0.7322854399681091, 0.21244032680988312, 0.2278864085674286, 0.6969767808914185, -0.8383881449699402, -0.15357258915901184, 0.09548790007829666, -0.3735622763633728, 0.1505441516637802, -0.07749606668949127, -0.5933973789215088, -0.22188520431518555, -0.42097190022468567, 0.47715142369270325, 0.09703415632247925, -0.6115139126777649, 0.8289995193481445, 0.5236623287200928, -0.1296217441558838, -0.780917763710022, -0.577264130115509, 0.47087761759757996, -0.21320755779743195, -0.5563707947731018, -0.23301798105239868, -0.18363678455352783, -0.5270711779594421, -0.17721852660179138, -0.02875933237373829, -0.07763523608446121, 0.23956510424613953, 0.35582607984542847, 0.11240940541028976, -0.0627865344285965, 0.36810335516929626, -0.2855040729045868, -0.19031716883182526, 0.3103119432926178, -0.19995245337486267, 0.39476829767227173, -0.6745654344558716, -0.5792920589447021, 0.01175579335540533, 0.046817198395729065, 0.9931433796882629, -0.4783228635787964, 0.6257357001304626, 0.8899990916252136, -0.2918286919593811, -0.39225172996520996, -0.8951666951179504, -0.0476766861975193, -0.4697391986846924, 0.46394750475883484, -0.34894251823425293, -1.2605186700820923, 0.5824686288833618, -0.4001973569393158, 0.14219968020915985, 0.5969159603118896, 0.9061408638954163, 0.14784929156303406, 0.6426308155059814, 0.5174782872200012, -0.13050507009029388, 0.2489282339811325, -0.07878771424293518, -0.12225017696619034, -0.9753053188323975, -0.09387379884719849, -0.5692982077598572, -0.39900001883506775, -0.658794641494751, -0.8161516189575195, 0.3910837173461914, -0.5332841277122498, -0.09342361241579056, 0.07294516265392303, -0.12206524610519409, 0.5781946778297424, -0.08099203556776047, -0.2505563497543335, 0.33962804079055786, -0.3142012357711792, -0.1463233232498169, 0.14692279696464539, -0.34113362431526184, -0.8281939029693604, 1.328492283821106, 0.6527732014656067, 0.9043185114860535, 0.029039481654763222, 0.5717352032661438, 0.44437041878700256, 0.8395070433616638, -0.790459930896759, 0.5731625556945801, 0.23566120862960815, -0.7969150543212891, -0.7822001576423645, -0.5859081149101257, -0.8400787115097046, 0.7355636954307556, -0.2647458612918854, -0.771614134311676, -0.03315986320376396, -0.15973210334777832, -0.29874029755592346, 0.32618963718414307, -0.38128170371055603, 0.961682140827179, -0.08028370141983032, -0.24203862249851227, -0.3399023115634918, -0.6683858633041382, 0.22262777388095856, -0.343394935131073, 0.4594818651676178, 0.04916824400424957, -0.265750914812088, 0.7091661095619202, -0.7036336660385132, 0.7757672071456909, -0.00030679244082421064, -0.2583296597003937, 0.42261916399002075, 0.0917591005563736, 0.523024320602417, 0.35194131731987, -0.16680584847927094, 0.19195301830768585, 0.08639297634363174, -0.17641443014144897, -0.7467674016952515, 0.5992885828018188, -0.6412058472633362, -0.4838152825832367, -0.4117202162742615, -0.39064452052116394, -0.4253542423248291, 0.0799102634191513, -0.06775243580341339, 0.28172990679740906, -0.4848199188709259, 0.4689960181713104, 0.36215901374816895, 0.20699955523014069, 0.6725056171417236, 0.6563844084739685, -0.46084344387054443, -0.6650921702384949, 0.6596572399139404, -0.12023716419935226, 0.46905088424682617, 0.37238892912864685, 0.4768558144569397, -0.06413569301366806, -0.3974032402038574, -0.3331744968891144, -0.03971438482403755, -0.5946491956710815, -0.3046165704727173, -0.5083353519439697, -0.25475865602493286, -0.0019964224193245173, -0.012787352316081524, -0.7264413237571716, -0.375221312046051, 0.17807930707931519, -0.2998179495334625, 0.013454248197376728, 0.829068660736084, -0.21191011369228363, 0.13572342693805695, -0.6891700029373169, 0.03443647921085358, 0.5604504346847534, 0.2693268656730652, 0.09407676756381989, -0.5476935505867004, -0.3846326768398285, -0.009238580241799355, -0.03028334677219391, -0.5008275508880615, 0.15523499250411987, 0.11402057111263275, 0.5535382032394409, 0.30338698625564575, 0.1256812959909439, 0.4700254201889038, -0.6733874678611755, 0.6599705219268799, -0.07620426267385483, -1.1554781198501587, 0.08141404390335083, -0.13558198511600494, 0.18599933385849, 0.8668770790100098, 0.1458207070827484, -0.5689501166343689, -0.559013843536377, -0.5042991638183594, -0.7072476148605347, 0.38545116782188416, 0.1681831032037735, 0.15574833750724792, 0.009840319864451885, 0.18399383127689362, 0.020665321499109268, 0.36476901173591614, -0.8559856414794922, 0.02204493060708046, 0.0878804549574852, 0.11745667457580566, -0.28149786591529846, -0.49565407633781433, -0.3106142580509186, 0.03552839905023575, 0.18661221861839294, -0.2857044041156769, -0.16088815033435822, 0.17722798883914948, -0.3070915639400482, -0.24819856882095337, 0.5475370287895203, 0.6179543733596802, 0.8594204187393188, -0.19166120886802673, 0.3454747796058655, 0.5081348419189453, -0.6110174655914307, 0.195200115442276, -0.0049743326380848885, -0.010214132256805897, -0.03948773816227913, 0.8543247580528259, 0.5502148270606995, 0.4277983605861664, -0.7248045802116394, 0.7605531215667725, -0.3252812623977661, -0.25951290130615234, -0.23487626016139984, -0.441113144159317, 0.27877020835876465, 0.586884617805481, 0.2960495054721832, -0.2015617936849594, 0.0339624397456646, -0.44212639331817627, 0.4121636152267456, 0.7240059971809387, -0.23011627793312073, -0.2430959790945053, 0.514254629611969, 0.46234962344169617, -0.3018943965435028, 0.2972666025161743, -0.2800730764865875, -0.5457378625869751, 0.43949368596076965, 0.2675248384475708, 1.312049388885498, -0.4190271198749542, 0.46097785234451294, 0.08769030123949051, 0.6987147927284241, -0.011524911038577557, 0.04176464304327965, -0.00995407160371542, -0.587939977645874, -0.5478363037109375, -0.7645053863525391, -0.7893974781036377, 0.0896216332912445, -0.5592299699783325, -0.05916488170623779, -0.45069557428359985, -0.38395240902900696, -0.2281351238489151, 0.26452285051345825, -0.5042344331741333, 0.04722587764263153, 0.3009864091873169, 1.0198097229003906, -0.9414696097373962, 0.6694034337997437, 0.668088972568512, -0.2689909338951111, -0.749758780002594, 0.2873632609844208, -0.1713634878396988, -0.6856298446655273, 0.7692697644233704, 0.016126887872815132, -0.3300657272338867, -0.509972333908081, -0.3176480829715729, -0.7608487010002136, 1.2400096654891968, 0.5131141543388367, -0.5253598690032959, 0.14574496448040009, 0.26457998156547546, 0.8643410205841064, -0.6805985569953918, 0.8953143358230591, 0.4290331304073334, 0.7236758470535278, 0.46181654930114746, -1.3593794107437134, 0.28913015127182007, -0.0667986124753952, -0.11660761386156082, -0.12643364071846008, -0.9314399361610413, 0.7659062147140503, -0.2198350429534912, 0.08284808695316315, -0.07450640946626663, 0.5534170866012573, 0.04175687953829765, 0.33423253893852234, 0.620182454586029, 0.4550073742866516, 0.8649877309799194, 0.2518818974494934, 0.9323264360427856, -0.264250785112381, 0.5782320499420166, 1.3038119077682495, -0.5009822249412537, 1.249194622039795, 0.2263214886188507, -0.2096567451953888, 0.4206392467021942, 0.4392007291316986, 0.1287553459405899, -0.09040282666683197, 0.34650641679763794, -0.2182946652173996, -0.5500548481941223, -0.032039765268564224, -0.12060718238353729, 0.6270589232444763, 0.16055279970169067, -0.22874027490615845, -0.3331308662891388, -0.21600580215454102, 0.2810375988483429, 0.08910120278596878, -0.20759135484695435, 0.6103761196136475, 0.07393500208854675, -0.4036318361759186, 0.4980998635292053, -0.005034915171563625, 0.34620362520217896, -0.6102832555770874, 0.1429249793291092, -0.2135421484708786, 0.06258873641490936, -0.23657260835170746, -0.5219167470932007, 0.23185408115386963, 0.1215686947107315, 0.14710642397403717, -0.3184109926223755, 0.6267392039299011, -0.3840820789337158, -0.5394831895828247, 0.32161572575569153, 0.7329000234603882, 0.001852884073741734, -0.25259751081466675, -0.5698522329330444, 0.3407937288284302, -0.43356943130493164, -0.5389012098312378, 0.42589277029037476, 0.5192906260490417, -0.18844708800315857, 1.033224105834961, 0.353375107049942, 0.07744327932596207, -0.2858331501483917, 0.3780868351459503, 0.9086718559265137, -0.2930704355239868, -0.21279434859752655, -1.2221671342849731, 0.3510272800922394, -0.09976068139076233, -0.010278691537678242, 0.8705695867538452, 0.5342047810554504, 0.46636325120925903, 0.131516233086586, 0.7060551643371582, 0.12411385029554367, 0.21275217831134796, -0.20636197924613953, 1.0953131914138794, -0.4255688190460205, 0.23348547518253326, -0.4969829022884369, -0.9113583564758301, -0.2070612758398056, 0.5502628684043884, -0.26067933440208435, 0.26291173696517944, 0.9390171766281128, 0.443373441696167, 0.2856657803058624, -0.22143661975860596, 0.3780803084373474, 0.3007644712924957, 0.6182690858840942, 0.46358609199523926, 0.9385882616043091, -0.03112049214541912, 0.7110512852668762, 0.2927784323692322, -0.4603840112686157, -0.28531649708747864, -1.1870591640472412, -1.1580325365066528, -0.4061410129070282, -0.2448902428150177, -0.16643019020557404, -0.1706276834011078, 1.0653153657913208, 0.4603234529495239, -0.5267831087112427, -0.5767523646354675, 0.21712547540664673, 0.336681991815567, -0.07195901870727539, -0.17769767343997955, 0.2892020344734192, -0.49893298745155334, -0.7784580588340759, 0.25400516390800476, 0.3567189872264862, -0.49322497844696045, -0.7112450003623962, -0.09934242814779282, 0.06059306859970093, 0.4074411690235138, 0.6575711369514465, 0.06357797235250473, -0.7309613227844238, -0.5400175452232361, -0.30531901121139526, -0.3243195116519928, -0.186382457613945, 0.7043851017951965, -0.7032187581062317, 0.4620323181152344, 0.31023693084716797, 0.985751211643219, 0.22302637994289398, -0.035171329975128174, 0.5136505365371704, -0.4760408401489258, -0.2024104744195938, 0.2109052538871765, 0.26644930243492126, 0.2541023790836334, -0.015112063847482204, 0.6509177684783936, -0.03841376677155495, -0.8338086605072021, -1.051363229751587, 0.06069108843803406, -0.9217145442962646, 0.09294459223747253, 1.4080088138580322, -0.325191468000412, -0.041754353791475296, 0.47375133633613586, -0.06872955709695816, -0.20095089077949524, -0.2633401155471802, 0.6629252433776855, 1.0280876159667969, 0.17964904010295868, -0.0563015341758728, -0.5059435367584229, 0.4724673926830292, 0.22873376309871674, -0.9825878143310547, 0.4973328411579132, 0.3795223534107208, 0.35438650846481323, 0.2878371775150299, 0.6611672639846802, 0.011813963763415813, 0.02818261831998825, 0.08434624969959259, -0.028527531772851944, -0.05384288355708122, -0.3558943569660187, -0.38487762212753296, 0.3002481460571289, 0.4146418571472168, -0.08450504392385483 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01750v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01750v1	PACE: A Pragmatic Agent for Enhancing Communication Efficiency Using Large Language Models	2024-01-30T06:55:17	2024-01-30T06:55:17	Jiaxuan Li, Minxi Yang, Dahua Gao, Wenlong Xu, Guangming Shi	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Current communication technologies face limitations in terms of theoretical capacity, spectrum availability, and power resources. Pragmatic communication, leveraging terminal intelligence for selective data transmission, offers resource conservation. Existing research lacks universal intention resolution tools, limiting applicability to specific tasks. This paper proposes an image pragmatic communication framework based on a Pragmatic Agent for Communication Efficiency (PACE) using Large Language Models (LLM). In this framework, PACE sequentially performs semantic perception, intention resolution, and intention-oriented coding. To ensure the effective utilization of LLM in communication, a knowledge base is designed to supplement the necessary knowledge, dedicated prompts are introduced to facilitate understanding of pragmatic communication scenarios and task requirements, and a chain of thought is designed to assist in making reasonable trade-offs between transmission efficiency and cost. For experimental validation, this paper constructs an image pragmatic communication dataset along with corresponding evaluation standards. Simulation results indicate that the proposed method outperforms traditional and non-LLM-based pragmatic communication in terms of transmission efficiency.	[ -0.24138228595256805, -0.8750814199447632, 0.7568516731262207, 0.5400063991546631, -0.7717081308364868, -0.3216305077075958, -0.7323487997055054, -0.546776533126831, 0.33105772733688354, 0.20313559472560883, -0.2724928557872772, -0.6888429522514343, -0.5570008754730225, 0.02620011195540428, -0.19360873103141785, 0.26064014434814453, -0.11154630035161972, -0.3134058117866516, 0.18427130579948425, -0.09078991413116455, -0.6627658009529114, 0.004489376675337553, -1.0604186058044434, -0.41253718733787537, 0.47388091683387756, 0.6191307306289673, 0.9680071473121643, 0.7028172612190247, 0.8456259369850159, 0.38071170449256897, 0.16160424053668976, 0.16384799778461456, -0.49064427614212036, 0.17689743638038635, -0.37246471643447876, -0.32222262024879456, -0.45929035544395447, -0.1884704828262329, 0.8303236961364746, 0.23332299292087555, -0.2692016661167145, 0.024821840226650238, -0.48464810848236084, 0.6460992097854614, -0.311979204416275, 0.4136826694011688, -0.6832075715065002, -0.14885567128658295, -0.014572466723620892, -0.4095168113708496, -0.5234681367874146, -0.22310931980609894, -0.16962003707885742, -0.8379933834075928, -0.5879033803939819, 0.19177021086215973, 0.6942294239997864, 0.14002303779125214, -0.24257035553455353, -0.30016401410102844, -0.7648181915283203, 0.4958178699016571, -0.32139208912849426, 0.2974110245704651, 0.23078308999538422, 0.415232390165329, -0.08115263283252716, -0.5689571499824524, -0.7294838428497314, -0.3861168324947357, 0.1070941761136055, 0.014902590773999691, -0.3753262162208557, 0.25298091769218445, 0.11040286719799042, -0.0453009232878685, -0.2205951064825058, 0.04541606083512306, -0.044455330818891525, -0.2550185024738312, 0.6739609241485596, 0.0917884111404419, 0.17910133302211761, 0.1565920114517212, -0.38698965311050415, 0.06666888296604156, -0.335387647151947, -0.26340925693511963, 0.2843489944934845, 0.15118609368801117, -0.10527694970369339, 0.412537157535553, -0.2453308403491974, 1.1154241561889648, -0.023091748356819153, -0.4264264404773712, 0.17925560474395752, -0.35758277773857117, -0.07601221650838852, 0.03132418170571327, 0.7071177959442139, 0.7193925976753235, 0.3497236669063568, -0.19930486381053925, -0.1962088942527771, 0.1759176403284073, 0.3456333577632904, -0.9474747776985168, 0.014076214283704758, 0.022602105513215065, -0.6737240552902222, 0.07234068214893341, -0.23005741834640503, -0.3365696370601654, -0.17055468261241913, -0.3614208996295929, 0.30279430747032166, -0.7912091016769409, -0.512953519821167, 0.41265571117401123, -0.16471929848194122, 0.529222309589386, 0.7170824408531189, -0.29009243845939636, -0.23423263430595398, 0.4655984938144684, 1.1349915266036987, 0.07438068836927414, -0.29746317863464355, -0.2563033998012543, 0.13427819311618805, -0.4170835316181183, 0.9542492628097534, -0.7715264558792114, -0.5573213696479797, -0.30624017119407654, 0.0966537669301033, 0.0362628810107708, -0.14630398154258728, 0.6902391314506531, -0.5529726147651672, -0.6238569617271423, 0.015231135301291943, -0.3407432734966278, -0.11259239912033081, -0.016092700883746147, -0.6654995083808899, 0.3126644492149353, -0.030583763495087624, -0.5839750170707703, 0.24832001328468323, -0.6534358859062195, -0.6043630838394165, 0.5393070578575134, 0.040206603705883026, -0.1252409666776657, 0.038797903805971146, -0.3281605541706085, 0.4341126084327698, -0.20274272561073303, 0.4491480588912964, 0.06431220471858978, -0.6592534184455872, -0.012563759461045265, -0.36966270208358765, 0.277559757232666, 0.5793887972831726, -0.11207028478384018, 0.17345348000526428, -0.6570284962654114, 0.07586444914340973, 0.21357889473438263, -0.43846216797828674, -0.40836021304130554, -0.2818298041820526, -0.24067461490631104, 0.281009703874588, 0.3347703516483307, -0.6444389820098877, 0.1478152722120285, 0.16234490275382996, 0.1739746779203415, 0.6101114153862, -0.057816144078969955, 0.616502046585083, -0.5742117166519165, 0.46778908371925354, -0.13371145725250244, 0.2178225964307785, -0.32108405232429504, -0.5555614233016968, -0.5580306649208069, -0.5283170342445374, -0.10220923274755478, 0.47056636214256287, -1.010764479637146, 0.5261235237121582, -0.6438626646995544, -0.7062022089958191, -0.5614791512489319, -0.06458214670419693, 0.36884045600891113, 0.5169798135757446, 0.08298574388027191, -0.42882129549980164, -0.10532239079475403, -0.8992869257926941, -0.5250437259674072, -0.2749819755554199, 0.29157620668411255, 0.4523928761482239, 0.13180072605609894, 0.10229398310184479, 0.6788281798362732, -0.11312119662761688, 0.03261562064290047, -0.42111071944236755, 0.12323655933141708, 0.3480721712112427, 0.5518137812614441, 0.17262743413448334, -0.861510694026947, -0.4586855471134186, 0.021518085151910782, -0.4549088478088379, -0.053898900747299194, -0.47058960795402527, -0.6182268261909485, -0.03808069974184036, 0.10479247570037842, -0.8594969511032104, 0.4633044898509979, 0.581915557384491, -0.49767932295799255, 0.41998398303985596, -0.4698144495487213, 0.44618475437164307, -0.6930028796195984, 0.15750201046466827, 0.41264650225639343, -0.43267276883125305, -0.873762309551239, -0.20415307581424713, 0.14295990765094757, -0.16207042336463928, -0.6762236952781677, 0.6665656566619873, -0.560019314289093, -0.19053399562835693, -0.5295059084892273, 0.07817862182855606, -0.03525865450501442, 0.2914199233055115, 0.5733293890953064, 1.0267131328582764, 0.640687882900238, -0.7417371869087219, 0.5562152862548828, 0.2778955101966858, -0.3704877495765686, 0.9230033755302429, -0.6349545121192932, 0.15296266973018646, -0.4862760603427887, 0.27279579639434814, -0.6651279330253601, -0.010682844556868076, 0.37670037150382996, -0.2008189857006073, 0.34179630875587463, -0.0640290156006813, -0.452374666929245, -0.2576632797718048, -0.09697574377059937, 0.13889442384243011, 0.862515926361084, -0.5042650103569031, 0.6033540368080139, 0.22588907182216644, 0.13957643508911133, -0.18374967575073242, -0.6237156391143799, 0.3334673047065735, -0.4143662750720978, -1.064604640007019, 0.40629664063453674, 0.10448449105024338, -0.23814992606639862, -0.155143603682518, 0.020886395126581192, 0.077483169734478, 0.031088897958397865, 0.17512717843055725, 0.2399633228778839, 0.24994690716266632, 0.46995288133621216, -0.4216086268424988, 0.006939162965863943, -0.035809628665447235, -0.48821645975112915, 0.509273111820221, -0.05338155850768089, -0.31802138686180115, -0.8775966763496399, 0.43764132261276245, 0.32926350831985474, -0.13757048547267914, 0.9086629152297974, 0.5869233012199402, 0.2588382363319397, -0.18266268074512482, -0.45526397228240967, -0.13462752103805542, -0.4685387909412384, 0.27249032258987427, -0.5037803649902344, -0.6422757506370544, 0.2848803699016571, -0.5090577602386475, 0.0806155726313591, -0.04124040901660919, 0.34500542283058167, 0.2703997492790222, 0.6286715865135193, 0.7386393547058105, 0.3942027986049652, 1.023967981338501, -0.1982383280992508, 0.4260614216327667, -0.7231937646865845, -0.1646573543548584, -0.31222259998321533, -0.33339792490005493, -0.24591007828712463, -0.8622832298278809, 0.1617615818977356, 0.028243420645594597, -0.3463277816772461, 0.4780566394329071, -0.6085870265960693, 0.23617731034755707, 0.39351195096969604, 0.32018592953681946, 0.5113539099693298, 0.13998058438301086, 0.33987563848495483, 0.20940348505973816, -0.6896886825561523, -0.7992037534713745, 0.6910176873207092, 0.4428486227989197, 1.2259165048599243, -0.11227695643901825, 0.38106635212898254, 0.3486582040786743, 0.3694346249103546, -1.02812659740448, 0.9443983435630798, 0.14425747096538544, -0.11640550196170807, -0.18071940541267395, -0.5994436144828796, -0.7157040238380432, 0.20959094166755676, 0.04694482684135437, -0.6140799522399902, 0.26103827357292175, 0.09023313224315643, 0.11858480423688889, 0.07700396329164505, -0.6794619560241699, 0.7344074249267578, -0.15369881689548492, -0.5991417765617371, -0.48618990182876587, -0.589779794216156, 0.4426809549331665, -0.13212496042251587, 0.05609860271215439, -0.49879270792007446, -0.341172993183136, 0.7077663540840149, -0.304810106754303, 0.5327367186546326, -0.31584104895591736, -0.14953844249248505, 0.6147332191467285, -0.09946954250335693, 0.9402864575386047, -0.22332508862018585, -0.3940400779247284, 0.1614447385072708, -0.7273389101028442, -0.2631213665008545, -0.4269329607486725, 0.5178666114807129, -0.3281826078891754, -0.503419041633606, 0.06870372593402863, -0.6115337610244751, 0.02285791002213955, 0.2090805172920227, -0.05180957168340683, 0.33665844798088074, -0.07723774015903473, -0.03205560892820358, 0.3551708459854126, -0.21446549892425537, 0.44928595423698425, 0.7963316440582275, 0.07798980921506882, 0.18165194988250732, 0.9732146263122559, -0.13486401736736298, 0.401250958442688, 0.03638921678066254, -0.13052497804164886, -0.4460844397544861, -0.6100358366966248, -0.16876666247844696, 0.479154497385025, -0.939325749874115, -0.33501356840133667, -0.6111623048782349, 0.08658614754676819, -0.032855890691280365, -0.32410040497779846, -0.18361009657382965, -0.14114320278167725, -0.10072226077318192, 0.15914751589298248, 0.6159870624542236, 0.2666551172733307, 0.01598316803574562, 0.8120813369750977, -0.5538825988769531, 0.3305046260356903, 0.06259772181510925, 0.40583473443984985, -0.04809662699699402, -0.571273922920227, -0.2675377130508423, -0.008018000982701778, -0.20253616571426392, -0.8292009830474854, 0.5035648345947266, 0.4730190634727478, 0.6166097521781921, 0.16160686314105988, 0.013307899236679077, 0.7843663096427917, -0.4203299283981323, 0.4030275046825409, 0.5002235770225525, -0.9277998208999634, 0.6765632629394531, -0.26336440443992615, 0.19299288094043732, 0.33825787901878357, 0.2807048559188843, -0.4559767544269562, -0.46121931076049805, -0.7221392393112183, -0.6205689907073975, 0.5141139626502991, 0.038167692720890045, 0.0353180468082428, -0.18767930567264557, 0.39209380745887756, -0.33604896068573, 0.295113205909729, -0.15721899271011353, 0.06693591922521591, -0.1929687261581421, -0.11832572519779205, 0.14845941960811615, 0.08619315177202225, -0.20490626990795135, -0.05603000149130821, 0.5384123921394348, -0.3434806764125824, 0.5936300754547119, 0.45542097091674805, -0.20762673020362854, 0.10782591998577118, 0.4537273049354553, 0.27643972635269165, 0.9234546422958374, 0.1736713945865631, 0.04830938205122948, -0.2599357068538666, -0.5716408491134644, 0.4792204201221466, -0.13325218856334686, 0.012197083793580532, 0.2516435980796814, 0.2728588879108429, 1.1316606998443604, -0.1096673235297203, -0.7003882527351379, 0.5862371325492859, -0.20522484183311462, 0.03154870495200157, -0.051438383758068085, 0.10565775632858276, 0.2888237237930298, 0.20489631593227386, 0.1390259861946106, 0.0038244074676185846, -0.04677549749612808, -0.4243234097957611, 0.13980436325073242, 0.6150206923484802, 0.04316333681344986, -0.18121975660324097, 0.27333229780197144, 0.620076596736908, -0.4855552911758423, 0.5175125598907471, -0.5194087624549866, -0.16570352017879486, 0.8297798037528992, 0.7337690591812134, 0.5759491920471191, -0.08526487648487091, 0.6045610904693604, 0.2456824630498886, 0.15108579397201538, -0.4638756811618805, 0.6079069972038269, -0.22839125990867615, -0.8207810521125793, -0.7511359453201294, -0.5606001019477844, -0.18498240411281586, -0.35560542345046997, -0.19812382757663727, 0.248712420463562, -0.39392194151878357, -0.5174899697303772, -0.14931784570217133, 0.013823178596794605, -0.8178834319114685, -0.07996121048927307, 0.04912351816892624, 1.4579699039459229, -0.5847458243370056, 1.0409523248672485, 0.9109809994697571, 0.044765230268239975, -1.1821744441986084, -0.19925710558891296, -0.38730067014694214, -1.0877286195755005, 0.8517767190933228, 0.25805726647377014, -0.3510141670703888, 0.3283156752586365, -0.47086960077285767, -0.47393709421157837, 1.4020695686340332, 0.44546201825141907, -0.9326932430267334, 0.310883104801178, -0.6208797097206116, 0.33808591961860657, -0.7995307445526123, 0.39796480536460876, 0.6419969201087952, 0.879273533821106, 0.6022583246231079, -0.9015801548957825, 0.2932174801826477, -0.12748026847839355, 0.4159814715385437, 0.29213008284568787, -0.8045560121536255, 0.38108810782432556, -0.4034092426300049, -0.6292928457260132, 0.1204521432518959, 0.6320743560791016, 0.17986246943473816, 0.13261330127716064, 0.5498857498168945, 0.4419865608215332, 0.62602698802948, 0.05428924411535263, 1.1013059616088867, -0.6908412575721741, 0.0741749033331871, 0.6068814396858215, -0.43003278970718384, 0.3671737611293793, 0.4721889793872833, -0.027043383568525314, 0.2509453296661377, 0.2365444153547287, 0.18595771491527557, 0.4250197112560272, 0.19877752661705017, -0.6292605996131897, -0.37734583020210266, -0.6879897117614746, 0.10890234261751175, 0.5287667512893677, 0.42043328285217285, -0.2704434096813202, -0.24801293015480042, 0.010427449829876423, 0.19740532338619232, 0.13141272962093353, -0.6257020831108093, 0.616673469543457, -0.24211087822914124, -0.6456635594367981, 0.5975518822669983, 0.09218981117010117, 0.8494097590446472, -0.7729106545448303, -0.08964697271585464, 0.060715850442647934, -0.0520477220416069, -0.11728767305612564, -1.038649082183838, 0.3325207829475403, -0.11763332784175873, 0.3044188320636749, -0.30866047739982605, 1.2741849422454834, -0.6055238246917725, -0.0841604545712471, 0.11951316148042679, 0.3828834593296051, 0.480181485414505, -0.001619397778995335, -0.6777065992355347, 0.6169465184211731, -0.19774241745471954, -0.13014893233776093, 0.05874446779489517, 0.43968671560287476, 0.031109491363167763, 0.8645326495170593, 0.5651828050613403, 0.6963390111923218, -0.16126026213169098, 0.10868807882070541, 0.9811586737632751, -0.6048511862754822, -0.595535397529602, -0.5236559510231018, 0.3238780200481415, -0.44188356399536133, -0.08357274532318115, 0.7116168737411499, 0.03876678645610809, 0.20737296342849731, 0.122390978038311, 0.6312808990478516, -0.21020802855491638, -0.13655860722064972, -0.4405188262462616, 0.18473736941814423, -0.11464855819940567, 0.17825758457183838, 0.1268480271100998, -0.8592954277992249, 0.11148910969495773, 0.9544971585273743, -0.5340911746025085, 0.08645603060722351, 0.6149556040763855, 0.8222631812095642, 0.07756322622299194, 0.08125826716423035, 0.48058316111564636, -0.07654184103012085, 0.2132202386856079, 0.9158340096473694, 0.8817583322525024, 0.0026556248776614666, 0.30858147144317627, -0.2252991944551468, -0.5958462953567505, -0.14286509156227112, -1.1843751668930054, -0.6258864998817444, -0.326183021068573, -0.2984018623828888, -0.1515633910894394, 0.4889959692955017, 0.6737363338470459, 0.879501461982727, 0.28920355439186096, 0.018931930884718895, -0.34146735072135925, 0.05724500119686127, -0.10982050001621246, -0.22587907314300537, 0.11285139620304108, -0.43098291754722595, -0.5063968896865845, 0.19508673250675201, 0.4553808569908142, 0.13218741118907928, -0.18364664912223816, -0.2054549604654312, -0.12336266040802002, 0.11491154134273529, 0.42203161120414734, 0.3166379928588867, -0.2532532811164856, -0.2270304411649704, -0.38715797662734985, -0.17419694364070892, 0.08139925450086594, 1.1296000480651855, -0.7846605181694031, 0.23297657072544098, 0.40820568799972534, 0.5166993737220764, 0.09422680735588074, 0.5878649353981018, 0.43156111240386963, -0.52592933177948, 0.8350026607513428, 0.3919307589530945, 0.08780030906200409, 0.48244595527648926, -0.6814720034599304, 0.24856573343276978, 0.11427812278270721, -0.6837686896324158, -0.18239560723304749, 0.417830228805542, -0.9589526653289795, -0.24142293632030487, 1.5090101957321167, -0.46939826011657715, -0.5475329756736755, -0.07718352228403091, -0.3276549279689789, 0.0450887493789196, -0.969906210899353, 0.09373164921998978, 0.42587265372276306, -0.2447105497121811, -0.3570045828819275, -0.4967404901981354, 0.37844860553741455, 0.1739717274904251, -0.9239706993103027, 0.07468530535697937, 0.6942535042762756, 0.07011464983224869, 0.09034278988838196, 1.276307225227356, 0.04199659451842308, 0.3019174635410309, 0.04084569588303566, 0.09185834974050522, -0.20745119452476501, -0.5316686034202576, -0.3589743971824646, -0.22238945960998535, 0.32157403230667114, -0.3006577491760254 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16748v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16748v1	Detecting Racist Text in Bengali: An Ensemble Deep Learning Framework	2024-01-30T04:56:55	2024-01-30T04:56:55	S. S. Saruar, Nusrat, Sadia	cs.CL	cs.CL	Racism is an alarming phenomenon in our country as well as all over the world. Every day we have come across some racist comments in our daily life and virtual life. Though we can eradicate this racism from virtual life (such as Social Media). In this paper, we have tried to detect those racist comments with NLP and deep learning techniques. We have built a novel dataset in the Bengali Language. Further, we annotated the dataset and conducted data label validation. After extensive utilization of deep learning methodologies, we have successfully achieved text detection with an impressive accuracy rate of 87.94\% using the Ensemble approach. We have applied RNN and LSTM models using BERT Embeddings. However, the MCNN-LSTM model performed highest among all those models. Lastly, the Ensemble approach has been followed to combine all the model results to increase overall performance.	[ -0.40233856439590454, -0.7235003113746643, 0.039218105375766754, 0.15112824738025665, -0.516273558139801, 0.47950950264930725, -0.21624942123889923, -0.9080535173416138, 0.3685533106327057, 0.406606525182724, -0.10956895351409912, -0.6299309134483337, -0.6708822250366211, 0.17918041348457336, -0.45091769099235535, 1.182988166809082, 0.14649412035942078, 0.2093626707792282, 0.14584389328956604, -0.36529427766799927, -0.14096699655056, -0.5880202054977417, -0.6256406307220459, -0.07273658365011215, 0.48335394263267517, -0.00033456762321293354, 0.311135470867157, 0.4643077850341797, 0.4170420467853546, 0.37019288539886475, -0.34728798270225525, 0.2864745855331421, -0.2619871199131012, 0.5255542993545532, -0.2900693714618683, -0.3906252384185791, -0.054135486483573914, -0.3677551746368408, 0.5468575358390808, 0.3464323580265045, 0.24804961681365967, 0.07701914012432098, -0.03827337920665741, 0.5946695804595947, -0.7959845662117004, -0.028823504224419594, -0.5847160816192627, 0.31743472814559937, -0.3245166540145874, 0.33034059405326843, -0.34590208530426025, -0.5346835255622864, -0.3010304868221283, -0.22842338681221008, 0.3682417869567871, -0.06994766741991043, 0.323711097240448, 0.08364754915237427, -0.4325496256351471, -0.48564279079437256, -0.8319369554519653, 0.8134772777557373, -0.8934842944145203, 0.1912691742181778, 0.3967823386192322, 0.1863032430410385, 0.1331268846988678, -0.4352548122406006, -0.8541319966316223, -0.10563256591558456, 0.04780837893486023, 0.19989359378814697, 0.17048503458499908, -0.03203166648745537, -0.016766004264354706, 0.32664504647254944, -0.5453780293464661, 0.31801533699035645, -0.43092676997184753, -0.3482721745967865, 0.7860855460166931, 0.08848829567432404, 0.42754653096199036, -0.1874672770500183, -0.3094012439250946, 0.021932996809482574, 0.01168535090982914, -0.3194520175457001, 0.5925819277763367, 0.5774443745613098, -0.27591589093208313, 0.3527083098888397, -0.2420465052127838, 0.7178978323936462, -0.3963163197040558, -0.06525202840566635, 0.3147943317890167, -0.06663791835308075, -0.14890803396701813, 0.24319282174110413, 0.6894103288650513, 0.30914902687072754, 0.8070571422576904, 0.011893181130290031, -0.2272036224603653, 0.65433269739151, 0.19750437140464783, -0.7355074882507324, -0.2705969512462616, 0.14936889708042145, -0.5521636605262756, -0.5322856903076172, -0.2720000147819519, -1.2402913570404053, -0.9740266799926758, 0.012059647589921951, -0.30260324478149414, -0.3357463479042053, -0.6641762256622314, -0.32237857580184937, -0.07197189331054688, 0.27391448616981506, 0.3175389766693115, -0.9004614949226379, 0.025777067989110947, 0.6556833982467651, 0.9145235419273376, -0.3062207102775574, 0.048044342547655106, 0.06159200519323349, -0.12673047184944153, -0.3131316304206848, 0.7706539630889893, -0.5564287304878235, -0.08071186393499374, 0.46535515785217285, -0.5542137622833252, 0.1492452770471573, -0.5614668726921082, 0.8541016578674316, -0.8157351016998291, -0.1358625590801239, 0.15213042497634888, -0.7583104968070984, -0.171134352684021, 0.5457242131233215, -0.5658301711082458, 0.985028862953186, -0.030549686402082443, -1.0786255598068237, 0.3027777075767517, -0.3218321204185486, -0.7772257924079895, 0.3233828544616699, 0.057268623262643814, -0.5451281666755676, 0.1779191941022873, 0.32259073853492737, 0.3624192178249359, 0.21347756683826447, 0.21731695532798767, -0.7128220200538635, -0.4371352195739746, 0.26021793484687805, -0.5657621622085571, 1.1736375093460083, 0.5408762097358704, -0.45752546191215515, -0.11355947703123093, -0.854884684085846, 0.08477704226970673, -0.001201965962536633, -0.2818428874015808, -0.4760691225528717, -0.12193787097930908, 0.4074765741825104, 0.07331182807683945, -0.1469133198261261, -0.7839233875274658, 0.1307084858417511, -0.42212486267089844, 0.16994570195674896, 0.8730160593986511, -0.1086222231388092, 0.37057825922966003, -0.030339153483510017, 0.4257698953151703, 0.15848639607429504, -0.2255079746246338, 0.00260031595826149, -0.687985897064209, -0.6793411374092102, -0.07724028825759888, 0.5272021889686584, 0.697028398513794, -0.6449199914932251, 0.47077739238739014, 0.08666811883449554, -0.2522351145744324, -0.47239747643470764, -0.019609183073043823, 0.20312879979610443, 0.17386625707149506, 0.2827654480934143, -0.17092902958393097, -0.8612537980079651, -0.6122022867202759, -0.3539716899394989, -0.2671940326690674, 0.19659282267093658, 0.04699743911623955, 0.7331268191337585, -0.5763686299324036, 0.8238985538482666, -0.19736479222774506, -0.27081620693206787, -0.2944040298461914, 0.14293412864208221, -0.034327104687690735, 0.6640446186065674, 0.47304874658584595, -1.145652174949646, -0.7536766529083252, 0.1342611461877823, -0.8455710411071777, -0.10699933022260666, 0.05045992508530617, 0.17464542388916016, 0.7095858454704285, 0.6120105981826782, -0.25196248292922974, 0.573671281337738, 0.40252503752708435, -0.008696384727954865, 0.45953357219696045, 0.12720774114131927, 0.1267661601305008, -1.1484953165054321, -0.2500493824481964, 0.2759215533733368, -0.29234960675239563, -0.5535044074058533, 0.21048960089683533, -0.17033252120018005, -0.034403346478939056, -0.16527429223060608, 0.8076716065406799, -0.20050249993801117, 0.07765442132949829, -0.3880843222141266, 0.10609520971775055, -0.25810834765434265, 0.45424574613571167, 0.08611124753952026, 0.12803564965724945, 0.26007044315338135, -0.4457233250141144, 0.568695604801178, 0.014362938702106476, -0.6469134092330933, 0.5147900581359863, -0.15102456510066986, 0.0741376057267189, -0.1528627872467041, 0.333954781293869, -1.2374838590621948, -0.3010611832141876, 0.5593010187149048, -0.602696418762207, 0.14811977744102478, -0.10020436346530914, -0.5248761773109436, -0.42321404814720154, -0.21087193489074707, 0.5963813662528992, 0.2359783798456192, -0.5611281394958496, 0.5976033210754395, 0.5384031534194946, -0.2383427768945694, -0.6075729727745056, -0.9719299077987671, 0.23040524125099182, -0.10119839757680893, -0.44490447640419006, 0.12805259227752686, -0.008599614724516869, -0.444072961807251, -0.14984500408172607, 0.023997513577342033, -0.4389455318450928, 0.06960146874189377, 0.17348498106002808, -0.10740260779857635, -0.05983387678861618, 0.25756508111953735, 0.002496128436177969, 0.1920255422592163, -0.039143387228250504, -0.06636349111795425, 0.7035486698150635, 0.024023057892918587, -0.08355610817670822, -0.46800464391708374, 0.5783525705337524, 0.4373936653137207, -0.19409510493278503, 0.7450370788574219, 0.9930786490440369, -0.5748313665390015, -0.3625429570674896, -0.5981177687644958, -0.19188576936721802, -0.38564160466194153, 0.5948105454444885, 0.2573681175708771, -0.8170926570892334, 0.7567169070243835, -0.08209408819675446, -0.38941308856010437, 0.25989043712615967, 0.660223126411438, -0.399499773979187, 0.8895381093025208, 0.6415156722068787, -0.4519752860069275, 0.5313547253608704, -0.203663632273674, 0.5330924987792969, -0.5318351984024048, -0.28991612792015076, -0.5986486673355103, -0.4691855311393738, -1.0547901391983032, -0.11652961373329163, 0.06353544443845749, -0.0607537142932415, -0.3871150612831116, -0.0996311828494072, -0.7553898692131042, 0.47221529483795166, 0.580374538898468, 0.22446608543395996, 0.009803450666368008, 0.12669847905635834, -0.19641634821891785, -0.1261051893234253, -0.4772012233734131, -0.4172724187374115, 0.8804656863212585, 0.1525055170059204, 0.5258212685585022, 0.047328103333711624, 0.7659099102020264, 0.8389230966567993, 0.5510610938072205, -0.5782651901245117, 0.6670798659324646, -0.18176721036434174, -0.9673441648483276, -0.20204836130142212, -0.3166443407535553, -0.7300772666931152, 0.2742827534675598, -0.3302842080593109, -0.6300539374351501, 0.17661693692207336, -0.02255154959857464, -0.11006943881511688, 0.6529691219329834, -0.6037724018096924, 0.5703423023223877, -0.2572530210018158, -0.2650584876537323, -0.05033637210726738, -0.7672462463378906, 0.5463070273399353, -0.03198138624429703, 0.44084036350250244, 0.04110493138432503, 0.1655663102865219, 0.7839697003364563, -0.09345999360084534, 1.2895196676254272, -0.20633715391159058, -0.07613812386989594, 0.34284213185310364, -0.09240712970495224, 0.4435781240463257, -0.15833540260791779, -0.273140549659729, 0.29772430658340454, -0.615226686000824, -0.4443519115447998, -0.35963085293769836, 0.597874641418457, -0.5940909385681152, 0.06055467948317528, -0.7294562458992004, -0.6101083755493164, 0.053450584411621094, 0.22385546565055847, 0.18049992620944977, 0.21876874566078186, -0.12072785943746567, 0.10125935077667236, 0.40818697214126587, -0.2654421627521515, 0.727075457572937, 0.0918164849281311, -0.23273736238479614, -0.5841207504272461, 0.8067827224731445, 0.0732596293091774, -0.1469789445400238, 0.20583750307559967, 0.06542342901229858, -0.39287373423576355, -0.8687720894813538, -0.5222029089927673, -0.02444443479180336, -0.783772349357605, -0.27278047800064087, -0.7209615707397461, -0.19339095056056976, -0.6879069209098816, -0.27237945795059204, 0.0006656385376118124, -0.1286991983652115, -0.25858965516090393, -0.05433228611946106, 0.18891876935958862, 0.8510383367538452, -0.11933887004852295, 0.4557947814464569, -0.7269282341003418, 0.2676815986633301, 0.0916462317109108, 0.4217747151851654, 0.16159279644489288, -0.4374716877937317, -0.48996978998184204, 0.24173639714717865, -0.26721900701522827, -0.8961267471313477, 0.6629759073257446, -0.10096868872642517, 0.3403579890727997, 0.34325534105300903, 0.3790242671966553, 0.24445819854736328, -0.13477642834186554, 0.7342069149017334, -0.07645372301340103, -0.6830474734306335, 0.4371977746486664, -0.2916238605976105, 0.028307732194662094, 0.48569613695144653, 0.568818211555481, -0.46397387981414795, -0.5984694957733154, -0.4378719627857208, -0.8514476418495178, 0.32881009578704834, 0.1411857157945633, 0.2277887463569641, -0.008998195640742779, 0.33308908343315125, -0.17741137742996216, 0.19630204141139984, -1.0808016061782837, -0.35172128677368164, -0.10709085315465927, -0.3524283468723297, 0.06353610754013062, -0.4069277346134186, 0.1647355556488037, -0.4165579676628113, 0.6004517078399658, 0.00014788612315896899, 0.04997283220291138, 0.11994650214910507, -0.2679046392440796, 0.17931683361530304, 0.15942342579364777, 0.7735597491264343, 0.3965641260147095, -0.16791850328445435, -0.012305974029004574, 0.14765967428684235, -0.5692384243011475, 0.17477373778820038, -0.021245524287223816, -0.26500818133354187, 0.11656789481639862, 0.7272236347198486, 0.43636882305145264, -0.23679472506046295, -0.46121838688850403, 0.30064675211906433, 0.09214527904987335, 0.06579980254173279, -0.5001814961433411, 0.025030506774783134, 0.04905390366911888, 0.3578796684741974, 0.49759936332702637, 0.46751999855041504, 0.1876497119665146, -0.5254822373390198, 0.26819461584091187, 0.30802953243255615, -0.4226413667201996, 0.02908484824001789, 0.32782983779907227, 0.4734196960926056, -0.7468563914299011, 0.6749292612075806, -0.4999561309814453, -1.093304991722107, 0.8550425171852112, 0.5905553698539734, 0.7981356382369995, -0.4105653464794159, 0.45021161437034607, 0.34865158796310425, 0.39601558446884155, 0.19524960219860077, 0.10103471577167511, -0.2852368652820587, -1.164017677307129, -0.5143532156944275, -0.8349229693412781, -0.3889414072036743, 0.2239256650209427, -0.5984728932380676, 0.009190576151013374, -0.5518725514411926, 0.10625026375055313, 0.05835879594087601, 0.2105870395898819, -0.20157399773597717, 0.5072268843650818, 0.4150537848472595, 0.6696609258651733, -1.1071863174438477, 0.7105865478515625, 0.5288143157958984, -0.03996463865041733, -0.22994442284107208, 0.14875683188438416, 0.07054339349269867, -0.6175293326377869, 0.9007298350334167, 0.5620997548103333, 0.06708990782499313, -0.1264411062002182, -0.6662501096725464, -0.25476139783859253, 0.17169460654258728, 0.24416470527648926, -0.6856627464294434, 0.37606972455978394, 0.1835617870092392, 0.9154295921325684, -0.28641027212142944, 0.28054919838905334, 0.43146082758903503, 0.611183762550354, -0.0823124572634697, -0.24282175302505493, -0.3586583137512207, -0.45487844944000244, -0.04690596088767052, 0.2574689984321594, -0.5155184268951416, 0.8267115354537964, -0.13533790409564972, -0.10488148778676987, 0.052693162113428116, 0.7812651991844177, 0.20470485091209412, 0.7091988325119019, 0.39982932806015015, 0.701183557510376, 0.7388816475868225, -0.019803199917078018, 1.0085936784744263, 0.019971709698438644, 0.4639817178249359, 1.0714671611785889, -0.536963939666748, 0.5695604085922241, 0.12136774510145187, -0.1457327902317047, 0.6372525095939636, 0.7503061890602112, -0.12093813717365265, 0.4209271967411041, 0.6524754166603088, -0.6403740048408508, -0.1118781641125679, -0.21341431140899658, -0.35820692777633667, 0.6533218026161194, 0.26770731806755066, -0.34493955969810486, -0.19554409384727478, 0.25319617986679077, -0.1371234804391861, 0.5363312363624573, -0.5477953553199768, 0.7305748462677002, -0.05289115384221077, -0.31251394748687744, 0.21864378452301025, -0.05412362515926361, 1.1321028470993042, -0.19386519491672516, -0.16235683858394623, -0.358069509267807, 0.5471224188804626, -0.20580844581127167, -0.5944457650184631, 0.5248609185218811, -0.0373920314013958, -0.37000080943107605, -0.03423905372619629, 1.065616250038147, -0.5538471937179565, -0.8381189703941345, 0.613877534866333, 0.086088627576828, 0.14241990447044373, -0.18221065402030945, -0.6635243892669678, 0.2853204607963562, 0.17354661226272583, 0.0772404670715332, 0.29643458127975464, 0.3610052466392517, -0.0776476114988327, 0.5679441690444946, 0.5714012980461121, 0.33146530389785767, 0.13005360960960388, -0.04811752960085869, 0.5856598615646362, -0.5888247489929199, -0.6625705361366272, -1.116141438484192, 0.30668455362319946, -0.5899113416671753, -0.3380186855792999, 0.7838162779808044, 0.6385403275489807, 1.2603379487991333, 0.015250666998326778, 0.9695783257484436, 0.05350174754858017, 0.6473692655563354, -0.1656576246023178, 0.8966249227523804, -0.24244531989097595, 0.03855297341942787, -0.4459530711174011, -0.9794901013374329, -0.6110391616821289, 0.9257838129997253, -0.08899983763694763, 0.3576584756374359, 0.2486019730567932, 0.6841987371444702, 0.06173798069357872, 0.4989277720451355, 0.2895021438598633, 0.35449114441871643, 0.38133057951927185, 0.1592566967010498, 0.8008010983467102, -0.45794838666915894, 0.423805832862854, -0.28722506761550903, -0.11574496328830719, -0.4073037803173065, -0.953205406665802, -0.888610303401947, -0.5266561508178711, -0.3402951657772064, -0.5618495345115662, 0.14467282593250275, 0.6068916320800781, 0.6180916428565979, -1.2320634126663208, -0.08182137459516525, -0.09346558153629303, 0.4667094945907593, -0.047707751393318176, -0.28229278326034546, 0.29778170585632324, -0.15412572026252747, -0.8832160830497742, 0.036646224558353424, 0.12491744011640549, 0.043804340064525604, -0.25565895438194275, 0.16572625935077667, -0.5813257098197937, -0.24528616666793823, 0.6423133611679077, 0.2841303050518036, -0.35130229592323303, -0.285600870847702, -0.6044268608093262, -0.21646526455879211, -0.15953637659549713, 0.7897832989692688, -0.7587653398513794, 0.5770145654678345, 0.5332754850387573, 1.0221413373947144, 0.5696523189544678, -0.1786293238401413, 0.12904733419418335, -0.7618771195411682, 0.37672898173332214, 0.7832410931587219, 0.25159159302711487, 0.4752095341682434, -0.2698020040988922, 0.5065401196479797, 0.4737734794616699, -0.733415961265564, -1.140735387802124, 0.2498244196176529, -0.9244425892829895, -0.30247169733047485, 1.0067702531814575, -0.05153707414865494, -0.17110523581504822, -0.5626864433288574, -0.10235078632831573, 0.4932951331138611, -0.38359612226486206, 1.002962589263916, 0.48146313428878784, 0.17352701723575592, -0.0551789328455925, -0.22318898141384125, 0.14890722930431366, 0.39486342668533325, -0.6032348871231079, -0.11956513673067093, 0.25343260169029236, -0.007637434639036655, 0.49307215213775635, 0.4841241240501404, 0.32386812567710876, 0.05173128843307495, -0.06217888742685318, 0.2862660884857178, 0.06077682599425316, -0.2954401969909668, -0.37250572443008423, 0.4855439364910126, -0.771106481552124, -0.39625534415245056 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16745v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16745v1	MT-Eval: A Multi-Turn Capabilities Evaluation Benchmark for Large Language Models	2024-01-30T04:50:28	2024-01-30T04:50:28	Wai-Chung Kwan, Xingshan Zeng, Yuxin Jiang, Yufei Wang, Liangyou Li, Lifeng Shang, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu, Kam-Fai Wong	cs.CL	cs.CL	Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly relied upon for complex multi-turn conversations across diverse real-world applications. However, existing benchmarks predominantly focus on single-turn evaluations, overlooking the models' capabilities in multi-turn interactions. To address this gap, we introduce MT-Eval, a comprehensive benchmark designed to evaluate multi-turn conversational abilities. By analyzing human-LLM conversations, we categorize interaction patterns into four types: recollection, expansion, refinement, and follow-up. We construct multi-turn queries for each category either by augmenting existing datasets or by creating new examples with GPT-4 to avoid data leakage. To study the factors impacting multi-turn abilities, we create single-turn versions of the 1170 multi-turn queries and compare performance. Our evaluation of 11 well-known LLMs shows that while closed-source models generally surpass open-source ones, certain open-source models exceed GPT-3.5-Turbo in specific tasks. We observe significant performance degradation in multi-turn settings compared to single-turn settings in most models, which is not correlated with the models' fundamental capabilities. Moreover, we identify the distance to relevant content and susceptibility to error propagation as the key factors influencing multi-turn performance. MT-Eval is released publicly to encourage future research towards more robust conversational models.	[ -0.494459867477417, -1.0455577373504639, 0.7884515523910522, 0.31344565749168396, -0.10328079760074615, 0.4648928642272949, -0.4930002987384796, -0.3063749670982361, -0.0662204846739769, 0.7910766005516052, -0.5161387324333191, -0.5364984273910522, -0.5303151607513428, 0.055926330387592316, -0.5485777854919434, 0.8592069149017334, 0.05392858386039734, 0.16324059665203094, -0.42237794399261475, -0.41557204723358154, -0.34296730160713196, -0.8003807067871094, -0.6318632364273071, -0.17243149876594543, 0.5600799918174744, 0.3075607717037201, 0.4914551377296448, 0.12668384611606598, 0.4973697066307068, 0.3875389099121094, 0.04657180234789848, 0.39285367727279663, -0.4420674741268158, 0.23257838189601898, 0.11422280222177505, -0.4081610441207886, -0.7706105709075928, 0.08778931200504303, 0.8377963304519653, 0.625247061252594, -0.3971134126186371, 0.2327069342136383, 0.07433848083019257, 0.7345596551895142, -0.49211031198501587, 0.06072661280632019, -0.7280616164207458, -0.2923206090927124, -0.3116495907306671, -0.13748186826705933, -0.754773736000061, -0.4772123396396637, 0.06065187230706215, -0.2884284257888794, 0.11646626144647598, 0.19028329849243164, 0.4242895245552063, 0.03490143641829491, -0.3670817017555237, 0.0021806787699460983, -0.8157854080200195, 0.8409683108329773, -0.8219731450080872, 0.6717228293418884, 0.26627543568611145, 0.4480518102645874, -0.13601668179035187, -0.6979206204414368, -0.6848457455635071, -0.46249938011169434, 0.017201608046889305, 0.01020482461899519, -0.23537157475948334, 0.09559880197048187, 0.2654748558998108, 0.2409745454788208, -0.5598932504653931, -0.08275481313467026, -0.3432459831237793, 0.07039399445056915, 0.6010183095932007, 0.4620186686515808, 0.06539968401193619, 0.09429347515106201, -0.24380990862846375, -0.328517347574234, -0.7506930828094482, 0.015230255201458931, 0.4174649715423584, 0.37843164801597595, -0.026811685413122177, 0.6841133236885071, -0.16821882128715515, 0.5884361863136292, -0.18821518123149872, -0.024434292688965797, 0.3496856987476349, -0.4160693883895874, -0.00903946440666914, -0.4186347424983978, 1.112688660621643, 0.3804619610309601, 0.092951700091362, -0.15333080291748047, -0.09261070191860199, -0.31020474433898926, 0.4534098207950592, -0.7373751997947693, 0.010466274805366993, 0.24400776624679565, -0.3464992940425873, -0.12005038559436798, 0.029817627742886543, -1.035796880722046, -0.32024654746055603, -0.3365248739719391, 0.42086920142173767, -0.5457848310470581, -0.38843539357185364, -0.06457805633544922, 0.026117753237485886, 0.13061977922916412, 0.06407348811626434, -0.5390376448631287, 0.4905620813369751, 0.986242949962616, 0.9450761079788208, -0.45412251353263855, -0.6753324866294861, -0.8975282311439514, -0.34105101227760315, -0.2127547711133957, 0.7663469910621643, -0.7859344482421875, -0.3563171625137329, 0.002782279159873724, -0.15815934538841248, -0.2357180416584015, -0.5335805416107178, 0.614564061164856, -0.41984823346138, 0.0730292797088623, -0.0024174784775823355, -0.2686624825000763, -0.16970974206924438, 0.2966897487640381, -0.580568253993988, 1.1239867210388184, 0.033502478152513504, -0.49951785802841187, 0.14801950752735138, -0.8475214242935181, -0.5657777190208435, -0.0471639409661293, -0.00887018907815218, -0.5843585729598999, 0.3626229763031006, 0.10216420888900757, 0.2870734632015228, -0.4103022813796997, 0.25071725249290466, -0.5201277732849121, -0.11716631799936295, 0.6480945348739624, -0.869601845741272, 0.356925904750824, -0.10657324641942978, -0.06124749779701233, 0.4382295310497284, -0.8714061975479126, 0.4246748089790344, -0.0531955361366272, -0.40033331513404846, -0.2644592225551605, 0.14587214589118958, 0.044836025685071945, 0.26795804500579834, -0.011890404857695103, -0.44378572702407837, 0.2675589621067047, -0.14276674389839172, 0.3182459771633148, 0.5401474237442017, -0.13746316730976105, -0.08168981969356537, -0.14573366940021515, 0.551297128200531, -0.13336196541786194, 0.2873770594596863, -0.32324400544166565, -0.5495309829711914, -0.891406774520874, -0.2837091088294983, 0.2588999569416046, 0.34428244829177856, -0.7844425439834595, 0.15674400329589844, -0.427301824092865, -0.6411364078521729, -0.9048138856887817, 0.07086803764104843, 0.759914755821228, 0.06850811094045639, 0.6325474977493286, -0.16265836358070374, -0.2908998429775238, -1.1500413417816162, -0.4739725887775421, -0.06920468807220459, -0.1832709014415741, 0.43269869685173035, 0.26582399010658264, -0.06604677438735962, 0.7110413908958435, -0.40775251388549805, 0.04346394166350365, -0.4958600699901581, 0.5607478618621826, -0.0678931474685669, 0.05524500831961632, 0.15863394737243652, -0.5429090857505798, -0.6039786338806152, -0.000901064311619848, -0.33533331751823425, -0.2705869972705841, 0.11749333888292313, -0.11171392351388931, 0.40810132026672363, 0.0048710862174630165, -0.5765934586524963, 0.3859204947948456, 0.9311336278915405, -0.2937644422054291, 0.5436297059059143, -0.3937692642211914, 0.41815024614334106, -0.7584860920906067, 0.026062140241265297, 0.015632297843694687, -0.10632931441068649, -0.887911319732666, -0.10318417847156525, 0.3307081162929535, 0.04352983832359314, -0.48846152424812317, 0.28516802191734314, -0.3392268121242523, -0.30803021788597107, -0.1522846221923828, 0.2312791645526886, 0.13178320229053497, 0.49334517121315, 0.09878257662057877, 1.0002827644348145, 0.28616535663604736, -0.5537030696868896, 0.12515363097190857, 0.054012034088373184, -0.2860080301761627, 0.806718647480011, -0.5105851292610168, 0.580445408821106, 0.303632915019989, 0.08643963932991028, -0.9974599480628967, 0.011015386320650578, -0.3206096589565277, -0.2506939768791199, 0.28709664940834045, -0.23641721904277802, -0.5755258202552795, -0.425883948802948, -0.39688849449157715, 0.2990209460258484, 0.32972878217697144, -0.5768633484840393, 0.9837403893470764, 0.3350716531276703, -0.25036340951919556, -0.30741381645202637, -0.32566145062446594, 0.32294440269470215, -0.2798677682876587, -0.6884545683860779, 0.2339918166399002, -0.3135308623313904, -0.23052078485488892, -0.46413546800613403, 0.18713189661502838, -0.05323921516537666, -0.14112572371959686, 0.17041143774986267, 0.3156639337539673, -0.1698521375656128, -0.16567911207675934, -0.08830885589122772, -0.11727024614810944, 0.0878109335899353, 0.2501869797706604, 0.9224692583084106, -0.44559162855148315, -0.721381425857544, -0.26346614956855774, 0.38315337896347046, 1.063537836074829, -0.5280925631523132, 0.657575786113739, 0.4115059971809387, 0.06250128149986267, 0.022248318418860435, -0.991338312625885, -0.06546375155448914, -0.4665203392505646, 0.51200270652771, -0.5710011124610901, -0.4724934995174408, 0.4549512565135956, 0.031926944851875305, 0.1820126324892044, 0.29943937063217163, 0.5950364470481873, 0.18886400759220123, 1.230892539024353, 0.3701961040496826, 0.08393444120883942, 0.2070363461971283, -0.11197017133235931, 0.20729054510593414, -1.3332353830337524, -0.3716515302658081, -0.4871353805065155, -0.04198417067527771, -0.47568926215171814, -0.5404255390167236, 0.4344896376132965, -0.12362528592348099, -0.04458761215209961, 0.38441193103790283, -0.2819165885448456, 0.32116663455963135, 0.49973034858703613, -0.08124728500843048, 0.6322978138923645, -0.3625015616416931, -0.02980654127895832, -0.08455635607242584, -0.4112720787525177, -0.6095636487007141, 1.2853214740753174, 0.3656337559223175, 0.6459853053092957, 0.20336954295635223, 0.35871532559394836, 0.03248715028166771, 0.8200732469558716, -0.6242280602455139, 0.6773606538772583, -0.03520825877785683, -0.4795498847961426, -0.3227442502975464, -0.5916250944137573, -0.8253255486488342, 0.6549131870269775, -0.21214993298053741, -0.646743655204773, -0.45897597074508667, 0.003823414444923401, -0.07846441864967346, 0.4640260636806488, -0.8251673579216003, 0.8431951999664307, -0.8419519066810608, -0.4975002706050873, -0.3605416715145111, -0.1948951631784439, 0.40500256419181824, -0.1991381049156189, 0.29513922333717346, -0.18305155634880066, 0.14693965017795563, 0.49431705474853516, -0.19082902371883392, 0.6303178071975708, -0.14376404881477356, 0.08822481334209442, 0.17662565410137177, 0.14301630854606628, 0.5142931342124939, -0.184956893324852, -0.08423179388046265, 0.5105074644088745, 0.0782022774219513, 0.1295294612646103, -0.4640464782714844, 0.6461194157600403, -0.5207209587097168, -0.46381038427352905, -0.1800834983587265, -0.28732988238334656, -0.5295810103416443, 0.09489177167415619, -0.08781614899635315, 0.48323774337768555, -0.44539979100227356, 0.4382078945636749, 0.25823119282722473, -0.24418699741363525, 0.3776308298110962, 0.9380200505256653, -0.5214905142784119, -0.4840812683105469, 0.9398114085197449, 0.07013416290283203, 0.5353683233261108, 0.23106840252876282, 0.30034977197647095, -0.4648413360118866, -0.6812116503715515, -0.5547359585762024, 0.07341105490922928, -0.37084320187568665, -0.12081491947174072, -0.7909330129623413, -0.0904446393251419, -0.01595492660999298, 0.3089814782142639, -0.7989416718482971, -0.17524142563343048, 0.2261916995048523, 0.04011646285653114, 0.2364576756954193, 0.8536787033081055, 0.2813684046268463, 0.1236422136425972, -0.8063052296638489, 0.22536326944828033, 0.19199691712856293, 0.7790170311927795, 0.14084844291210175, -0.44412824511528015, -0.05493391677737236, -0.07938356697559357, -0.6982364654541016, -0.6096899509429932, 0.4590655267238617, 0.0987754687666893, 0.6558519601821899, 0.29216474294662476, -0.015796367079019547, 0.6449090838432312, -0.8034319877624512, 0.755451500415802, 0.16923785209655762, -0.9029302597045898, 0.18554836511611938, -0.1952042281627655, 0.18844671547412872, 0.5868076682090759, 0.12474174052476883, -0.6255683302879333, -0.5605711936950684, -0.6652519106864929, -0.8296956419944763, 0.6239611506462097, 0.2856355309486389, 0.017572950571775436, -0.1073174923658371, -0.09641343355178833, 0.2570124566555023, 0.3538261651992798, -0.4858672320842743, -0.2254602313041687, -0.11325065791606903, 0.016749273985624313, -0.09760947525501251, -0.24328961968421936, -0.08905433863401413, -0.14581315219402313, 0.399975061416626, -0.11528755724430084, 0.13435670733451843, -0.2807295322418213, 0.11352188140153885, -0.0006678924546577036, 0.5937585830688477, 0.834833562374115, 0.7941966652870178, -0.2647858262062073, 0.21463903784751892, 0.540617823600769, -0.33722105622291565, -0.1723853349685669, 0.20381182432174683, 0.299654096364975, -0.2001800239086151, 0.31209778785705566, 0.6910662651062012, 0.2515186071395874, -0.7163864970207214, 0.4189687669277191, -0.21463187038898468, -0.03877496346831322, -0.18074944615364075, 0.03879472613334656, 0.11780259758234024, 0.15014393627643585, 0.4189535677433014, -0.1330539733171463, 0.12219558656215668, -0.5838735699653625, -0.04248557612299919, 0.7008599638938904, -0.1798478662967682, -0.5239254832267761, 0.42809078097343445, 0.29403775930404663, -0.7581669092178345, 0.6574535965919495, -0.08221440762281418, -0.6342260837554932, 0.28295910358428955, 0.3739742338657379, 1.0873056650161743, -0.26341211795806885, 0.049984388053417206, 0.30693140625953674, 0.21789804100990295, -0.06102323532104492, 0.08177302032709122, 0.12522561848163605, -0.5280235409736633, -0.5615238547325134, -0.4670281708240509, -0.8141601085662842, 0.5190331339836121, -0.7092650532722473, 0.08889955282211304, -0.051761478185653687, -0.30562153458595276, 0.08041960000991821, -0.13939109444618225, -0.841439962387085, -0.2981598973274231, -0.080691859126091, 0.6665855050086975, -0.5141458511352539, 0.7369996905326843, 0.42156267166137695, -0.1612839549779892, -0.3428420424461365, -0.1405639350414276, 0.10461533814668655, -0.6896404027938843, 0.42138534784317017, 0.2589106857776642, -0.4483758509159088, -0.33795979619026184, -0.33421075344085693, -0.5673149228096008, 0.9419620633125305, 0.10331042855978012, -0.5908014178276062, 0.3839333653450012, 0.43415147066116333, 0.733378529548645, -0.5290728807449341, 0.6341449618339539, 0.877336323261261, 0.6070510149002075, -0.051503896713256836, -1.2192161083221436, -0.21790769696235657, -0.0658673495054245, -0.0447525754570961, 0.36518099904060364, -0.8742763996124268, 0.7351354360580444, -0.15907789766788483, -0.10042542219161987, 0.048239827156066895, 0.25789108872413635, 0.41240522265434265, 0.5006959438323975, 0.4496667981147766, 0.5301076173782349, 0.616954505443573, -0.30528923869132996, 1.212602138519287, -0.4695805013179779, 0.2592735290527344, 1.1465213298797607, -0.5387451648712158, 1.367546558380127, 0.42030903697013855, -0.4633199870586395, 0.21982528269290924, -0.002721477532759309, 0.2008362114429474, 0.3879328668117523, 0.1678883284330368, -0.2884335219860077, -0.23507945239543915, 0.26503506302833557, -0.12510919570922852, 0.507430374622345, 0.47740790247917175, -0.08749183267354965, 0.04711880162358284, -0.008769526146352291, -0.04515485838055611, -0.05601426586508751, 0.06264681369066238, 0.8270233273506165, -0.10951130837202072, -0.9239702820777893, 0.3533608317375183, 0.03362741693854332, 0.6010391712188721, -0.5708609223365784, -0.13468097150325775, -0.26776033639907837, 0.294475793838501, 0.02388276532292366, -1.0698816776275635, 0.28200024366378784, 0.10825256258249283, -0.011671998538076878, -0.0785786360502243, 0.41409385204315186, -0.4627784192562103, -0.49301043152809143, 0.3368191123008728, 0.618367612361908, 0.15616434812545776, -0.3071514964103699, -0.6116812825202942, 0.4278861880302429, -0.05196520313620567, -0.47445183992385864, 0.41066503524780273, 0.3566465675830841, 0.06178414821624756, 0.9621421098709106, 0.8167952299118042, 0.05074049532413483, 0.027633333578705788, 0.3212629556655884, 0.8285367488861084, -0.6187236905097961, 0.05570124089717865, -0.9538338780403137, 0.6553841233253479, -0.2024185061454773, -0.400348424911499, 0.7595688104629517, 0.79119873046875, 0.4999469518661499, 0.12986502051353455, 0.7623527646064758, 0.2360156625509262, 0.669891893863678, -0.5707539916038513, 0.553966224193573, -0.31796908378601074, 0.46571704745292664, -0.1468394249677658, -1.052298903465271, -0.011676211841404438, 0.43107736110687256, -0.4980461895465851, 0.2702999413013458, 0.6808046102523804, 0.6699439883232117, -0.12262033671140671, 0.08944465219974518, 0.4852582514286041, 0.15602385997772217, 0.6966217160224915, 0.35709407925605774, 1.0959128141403198, -0.08255726099014282, 0.7729836702346802, -0.14544618129730225, -0.30615121126174927, -0.25770917534828186, -0.9793571829795837, -1.074136734008789, -0.6038200855255127, -0.17784136533737183, -0.326799213886261, -0.11730444431304932, 0.8741259574890137, 0.8009344935417175, -0.6447622179985046, -0.30761849880218506, 0.2180868536233902, 0.017255285754799843, -0.28978776931762695, -0.25852736830711365, 0.303043007850647, -0.2475700080394745, -0.7580937743186951, 0.7301089763641357, 0.5357950329780579, -0.20183239877223969, -0.650996208190918, -0.11474809050559998, 0.048829689621925354, 0.19695286452770233, 0.9256711602210999, 0.2251717895269394, -0.7725020051002502, -0.2700614929199219, 0.046285998076200485, 0.10549401491880417, 0.35025012493133545, 0.939491868019104, -0.4787106513977051, 0.5649551749229431, 0.14809799194335938, 0.5152186751365662, 0.758407711982727, 0.13321098685264587, 0.5089039206504822, -0.7450075745582581, -0.30466046929359436, 0.10590720921754837, 0.2971072793006897, 0.5255022048950195, 0.11158521473407745, 0.41935572028160095, -0.23700323700904846, -0.6619179248809814, -0.9020175933837891, 0.02174285240471363, -0.9456877112388611, 0.10620462894439697, 1.2431282997131348, 0.037726785987615585, 0.13982820510864258, -0.14256678521633148, -0.27269113063812256, -0.19426213204860687, -0.49408096075057983, 0.73196941614151, 0.926884114742279, -0.5198184251785278, -0.35989660024642944, -0.9292355179786682, 0.1884767860174179, 0.13366781175136566, -1.0004732608795166, 0.5570188164710999, 0.44010084867477417, 0.2490542232990265, 0.3575590252876282, 0.48422664403915405, -0.21756847202777863, -0.25011539459228516, -0.19130870699882507, 0.07012014836072922, -0.22520633041858673, -0.4348028600215912, -0.18487612903118134, 0.1631590723991394, 0.22891956567764282, 0.0060603744350373745 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16736v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16736v3	Engineering A Large Language Model From Scratch	2024-01-30T04:29:48	2024-02-03T16:34:46	Abiodun Finbarrs Oketunji	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, cs.SE, I.2.7, I.2.7	The proliferation of deep learning in natural language processing (NLP) has led to the development and release of innovative technologies capable of understanding and generating human language with remarkable proficiency. Atinuke, a Transformer-based neural network, optimises performance across various language tasks by utilising a unique configuration. The architecture interweaves layers for processing sequential data with attention mechanisms to draw meaningful affinities between inputs and outputs. Due to the configuration of its topology and hyperparameter tuning, it can emulate human-like language by extracting features and learning complex mappings. Atinuke is modular, extensible, and integrates seamlessly with existing machine learning pipelines. Advanced matrix operations like softmax, embeddings, and multi-head attention enable nuanced handling of textual, acoustic, and visual signals. By unifying modern deep learning techniques with software design principles and mathematical theory, the system achieves state-of-the-art results on natural language tasks whilst remaining interpretable and robust.	[ -0.3023894429206848, -0.6333010196685791, 0.32649117708206177, 0.22875341773033142, -0.1636095941066742, 0.3634912073612213, -0.47764894366264343, -0.5208578705787659, 0.19526273012161255, 0.6610693335533142, -0.36114946007728577, -0.2769942879676819, -0.39928391575813293, 0.025428511202335358, -0.5423638820648193, 0.6802898645401001, 0.1935308426618576, -0.15801844000816345, 0.22542449831962585, -0.13868220150470734, -0.27842915058135986, -0.36381053924560547, -1.0929447412490845, -0.8784785866737366, 0.6286789178848267, 0.5561237931251526, 0.8609395027160645, 0.6918907761573792, 0.3465717136859894, 0.3800545930862427, 0.04164490848779678, 0.12676137685775757, -0.13634169101715088, 0.10315019637346268, -0.023302555084228516, -0.5582676529884338, -0.5786802172660828, -0.3583604395389557, 0.6975793242454529, 0.9291724562644958, -0.06528870761394501, -0.09396830201148987, 0.14377361536026, 0.6586122512817383, -0.564769983291626, 0.3031497299671173, -0.6769099831581116, 0.23279407620429993, -0.33106255531311035, 0.05633492395281792, -0.406000018119812, -0.37772709131240845, 0.08535144478082657, -0.7468920946121216, -0.16301293671131134, -0.18617862462997437, 0.8278059363365173, 0.3280767500400543, -0.11459141224622726, -0.24184928834438324, -0.559760332107544, 0.9524990320205688, -0.7229073643684387, 0.5944089293479919, 0.5063114762306213, 0.6202694177627563, -0.11892092972993851, -0.8854894638061523, -0.4699699580669403, 0.08893425762653351, -0.2665553390979767, -0.01711535081267357, 0.1956840455532074, 0.007008584216237068, -0.032165657728910446, 0.4528957009315491, -0.5551166534423828, 0.48663434386253357, -0.25630316138267517, -0.11935660988092422, 0.6875557899475098, 0.09854824841022491, 0.33776628971099854, -0.6085805892944336, -0.04411160945892334, -0.06418833136558533, -0.6219836473464966, -0.12392328679561615, 0.35057532787323, 0.5298763513565063, 0.22988107800483704, 0.541114866733551, -0.3978668749332428, 0.5829777121543884, -0.1852836310863495, 0.12101399153470993, 0.19610416889190674, -0.19116875529289246, -0.3944777846336365, 0.37216269969940186, 1.1648883819580078, -0.2041279375553131, 0.6696138978004456, -0.27769970893859863, -0.27546507120132446, 0.053231071680784225, 0.6839112639427185, -0.45391610264778137, -0.2799033522605896, 0.2620856463909149, -0.3364863991737366, -0.9066929817199707, -0.4252212643623352, -0.8000848293304443, -0.4618373215198517, -0.5060179233551025, 0.19384677708148956, -0.5847717523574829, -0.2435566484928131, 0.28021445870399475, 0.3578164279460907, 0.1934555619955063, 0.13109399378299713, -1.092150330543518, 0.299421489238739, 0.8262585997581482, 0.6935356855392456, -0.13006748259067535, -0.40539053082466125, -0.2718583941459656, 0.15850046277046204, -0.4734514653682709, 0.9422606229782104, -0.5145643353462219, -0.0072570787742733955, 0.08315581828355789, -0.24636498093605042, 0.15931794047355652, -0.5280438661575317, 0.6558317542076111, -0.5316531658172607, 0.270717054605484, 0.20339392125606537, -0.4612099826335907, -0.35592806339263916, 0.13713675737380981, -0.8025979995727539, 0.8784598708152771, -0.01193983107805252, -0.6370266079902649, 0.3389575183391571, -1.1272284984588623, -0.8533047437667847, 0.3093099296092987, -0.07850528508424759, -0.4473594129085541, 0.24309508502483368, 0.2559775114059448, 0.4669908583164215, -0.5365443825721741, 0.4564327895641327, -0.04752285033464432, -0.24960735440254211, 0.09831073135137558, -0.31110817193984985, 0.9579923152923584, 0.2848370671272278, -0.2086275964975357, 0.3536107540130615, -1.1743783950805664, 0.3578031063079834, 0.12846973538398743, -0.43557149171829224, -0.27601900696754456, 0.032284703105688095, 0.24787266552448273, 0.13746380805969238, -0.05565185099840164, -0.4425109028816223, 0.1823214888572693, -0.996227502822876, 0.9251576662063599, 0.4706507921218872, -0.21737341582775116, 0.7254786491394043, 0.1554056853055954, 0.27358773350715637, -0.1384180635213852, 0.11890579015016556, -0.2769632041454315, -0.5735417008399963, -0.8694025278091431, -0.12133901566267014, 0.2218635380268097, 0.5878902077674866, -0.7249964475631714, 0.6221696138381958, -0.42563772201538086, -0.38785576820373535, -0.8937501907348633, 0.3389071822166443, 0.17352990806102753, 0.403928279876709, 0.23194947838783264, -0.3032273054122925, -0.7989545464515686, -1.3122544288635254, -0.22952815890312195, -0.08264186978340149, -0.25294917821884155, -0.11006703227758408, 0.18085667490959167, -0.3593836724758148, 1.0041643381118774, -0.573175311088562, -0.4771765172481537, -0.5352288484573364, 0.20919862389564514, 0.47193750739097595, 0.49299535155296326, 0.14029289782047272, -0.7928144931793213, -0.6920291781425476, 0.5134455561637878, -1.1018821001052856, 0.0028959151823073626, -0.09726151823997498, -0.2515365779399872, 0.1108635663986206, 0.6130307912826538, -0.7887493371963501, 0.2394113689661026, 0.09423880279064178, 0.10298831015825272, 0.35489898920059204, 0.0034108897671103477, -0.007012161426246166, -1.400711178779602, 0.2667856514453888, -0.20554141700267792, -0.21140196919441223, -0.9202457666397095, 0.20261023938655853, 0.07261858880519867, -0.500341534614563, -0.48459601402282715, 0.46970808506011963, -0.22231332957744598, -0.09031464904546738, -0.4767693281173706, 0.10891877114772797, 0.1425427794456482, 0.6206048130989075, -0.007192567922174931, 0.5466978549957275, 0.54826819896698, -0.38032737374305725, 0.6878558397293091, 0.3543456494808197, -0.5190151929855347, 0.4952136278152466, -0.8721019625663757, 0.2164507359266281, 0.1174500584602356, -0.07015439867973328, -0.6471513509750366, -0.4953354001045227, 0.13090260326862335, -0.5465490818023682, 0.47420355677604675, -0.028444288298487663, -0.8982691764831543, -0.4704521894454956, -0.2505868375301361, 0.26498180627822876, 0.511794924736023, -0.35829752683639526, 0.8351844549179077, 0.42606401443481445, -0.04620487615466118, -0.4115879237651825, -0.7880975604057312, 0.41384029388427734, -0.16155323386192322, -0.6149408221244812, 0.07390502095222473, 0.47406262159347534, -0.3409014046192169, -0.22937549650669098, 0.4485776126384735, -0.5070176124572754, 0.21536454558372498, -0.013494203798472881, 0.013185963034629822, -0.4517286419868469, 0.25206997990608215, 0.10050415247678757, -0.6321976780891418, 0.04129190742969513, -0.5223636031150818, 0.687163770198822, 0.05225086957216263, -0.21803130209445953, -0.7076749801635742, 0.5252625346183777, 0.8500142693519592, -0.32383179664611816, 0.5594618916511536, 0.6010710597038269, -0.596103310585022, -0.2734602093696594, -0.21351665258407593, -0.4043545126914978, -0.56071937084198, 0.709978461265564, -0.5447723865509033, -0.3808429539203644, 0.4903584122657776, 0.05004622042179108, 0.24937804043293, 0.45016899704933167, 0.5090869665145874, -0.13251887261867523, 0.9579002261161804, 0.7508411407470703, -0.3154694437980652, 0.3090091645717621, -0.1285039186477661, 0.44140738248825073, -0.83988356590271, 0.028389843180775642, -0.39860454201698303, -0.4813021421432495, -0.31883499026298523, -0.07556472718715668, 0.002259942004457116, -0.13988041877746582, -0.31452420353889465, 0.5927839279174805, -0.5509313941001892, 0.6199373006820679, 0.4814162254333496, -0.015348679386079311, 0.3521744906902313, -0.029632238671183586, 0.16363346576690674, -0.24931101500988007, -0.8077582120895386, -0.4030628502368927, 1.1925603151321411, 0.32488223910331726, 0.817939043045044, -0.11736926436424255, 0.3319666385650635, 0.19422097504138947, 0.11259998381137848, -1.019612193107605, 0.5322304368019104, -0.3185098171234131, -0.5061607360839844, -0.3767274022102356, -0.13906505703926086, -1.0062538385391235, 0.15454231202602386, -0.18235470354557037, -0.7419145703315735, -0.14529402554035187, 0.02612956427037716, -0.2936553359031677, 0.32832038402557373, -0.6885223984718323, 0.7251901030540466, -0.1429455429315567, -0.2531754672527313, -0.4385205805301666, -0.6634560823440552, 0.44011563062667847, -0.5195358991622925, 0.054771196097135544, 0.2502771317958832, 0.07194743305444717, 0.5721899271011353, -0.09431632608175278, 0.9077715277671814, 0.20971065759658813, -0.2048320174217224, 0.03642948344349861, 0.09309451282024384, 0.2684657871723175, 0.11268740147352219, -0.248785138130188, -0.016571523621678352, -0.8439503908157349, -0.34358298778533936, -0.7839138507843018, 0.9243015050888062, -0.7844114899635315, -0.27995890378952026, 0.0037493198178708553, -0.6490511894226074, -0.1961020678281784, 0.45828548073768616, 0.21658724546432495, 0.6918386220932007, 0.008822529576718807, 0.37995365262031555, 0.7496309876441956, -0.37722018361091614, 0.4574213922023773, 0.11991924047470093, -0.49649715423583984, -0.3901103436946869, 1.0721865892410278, 0.05191466212272644, 0.2870706021785736, 0.474994421005249, 0.2674793601036072, -0.17828278243541718, -0.2915053367614746, -0.642813503742218, 0.15094004571437836, -0.9507364630699158, -0.1579086035490036, -0.8430769443511963, -0.4064481258392334, -0.25852343440055847, -0.43295443058013916, -0.9616313576698303, -0.4371185898780823, -0.007236060686409473, 0.023937229067087173, 0.10223706066608429, 0.9830112457275391, 0.3000619113445282, 0.26406198740005493, -0.6320840120315552, 0.4045853912830353, 0.3884909749031067, 0.502692461013794, 0.19891461730003357, -0.3680650591850281, -0.5247756242752075, -0.08400895446538925, -0.26256898045539856, -0.4462113082408905, 0.2101733386516571, 0.5336461067199707, 0.48627838492393494, 0.2580876350402832, -0.17353077232837677, 0.27528345584869385, -0.6713245511054993, 0.5672160387039185, 0.011102055199444294, -0.8387520909309387, 0.7656905651092529, -0.36548689007759094, 0.723946750164032, 0.5100961327552795, 0.3172226548194885, -0.47910022735595703, -0.4679979383945465, -0.5831330418586731, -0.892464816570282, 0.6386560797691345, 0.39256876707077026, -0.04520779103040695, 0.4153350293636322, 0.4172144830226898, 0.14977867901325226, 0.27258455753326416, -0.46873265504837036, -0.10350923240184784, -0.34166669845581055, -0.4831811785697937, -0.15053300559520721, 0.0895642563700676, -0.034008122980594635, -0.46601852774620056, 0.5829225182533264, -0.35549071431159973, 0.2928759753704071, -0.3135128617286682, -0.3832176625728607, 0.002784863580018282, -0.022208692505955696, 0.6148166656494141, 0.6437563300132751, 0.2452986091375351, 0.043978817760944366, 0.2608141005039215, -0.6226264238357544, 0.09952571988105774, -0.24978886544704437, -0.09177789837121964, -0.04366170987486839, 0.5946822762489319, 0.875540018081665, 0.5365638136863708, -0.42389169335365295, 0.12169043719768524, 0.023281274363398552, -0.11836453527212143, -0.269643634557724, 0.046166494488716125, 0.2169712334871292, 0.0678500086069107, 0.379209965467453, 0.13410614430904388, 0.2184101641178131, -0.5277823209762573, 0.49970540404319763, -0.04074134677648544, -0.6418651342391968, -0.5381718873977661, 0.6601060032844543, 0.19448354840278625, -0.6357080936431885, 0.9303053617477417, 0.41084185242652893, -0.7625507116317749, 0.4012686014175415, 0.4224688708782196, 1.1347243785858154, -0.16255536675453186, 0.10822366178035736, 0.3072325885295868, 0.3182690441608429, 0.27289336919784546, 0.030617596581578255, 0.08710312098264694, -0.7220393419265747, -0.7215604782104492, -0.8251569271087646, -0.18113061785697937, 0.08474157750606537, -0.4966171383857727, 0.5194675326347351, -0.5609608292579651, 0.07011007517576218, 0.3027171194553375, -0.07844959944486618, -0.44333595037460327, 0.4344288408756256, 0.22110043466091156, 0.7391266226768494, -0.8063278794288635, 1.304189682006836, 0.8268067240715027, -0.3058823049068451, -0.6938953399658203, -0.24288521707057953, -0.07772562652826309, -0.8805851340293884, 0.7383164167404175, 0.2513682246208191, 0.004141682758927345, 0.19808268547058105, -0.30547720193862915, -0.6340792775154114, 0.6687084436416626, 0.3469454348087311, -0.2892421782016754, 0.033827610313892365, 0.4475667476654053, 0.6749262809753418, -0.29871195554733276, 0.14290973544120789, 0.6935177445411682, 0.510473370552063, -0.1270476132631302, -0.830415666103363, -0.24569353461265564, -0.37495169043540955, 0.034328244626522064, 0.46734941005706787, -0.36720895767211914, 0.6645697355270386, 0.1350356787443161, 0.04674440622329712, -0.28068819642066956, 0.6887154579162598, -0.16972123086452484, -0.34834131598472595, 0.49380427598953247, 0.603962242603302, 0.5474701523780823, -0.14493753015995026, 1.2085195779800415, -0.150588259100914, 0.12368863821029663, 1.0852497816085815, -0.10268162935972214, 0.828389585018158, 0.4214046597480774, -0.00729023152962327, 0.38706862926483154, 0.2713634669780731, 0.26839497685432434, 0.4784294366836548, 0.13383136689662933, -0.09848246723413467, -0.1827692985534668, -0.1054888591170311, -0.0395452119410038, 0.7549556493759155, 0.3127245306968689, -0.21505840122699738, -0.15187548100948334, 0.4401024281978607, -0.052393000572919846, 0.2394820600748062, -0.10636571049690247, 0.9253544807434082, 0.21870578825473785, -0.3863269090652466, 0.5942676663398743, -0.19936658442020416, 0.720081627368927, -0.8850703239440918, 0.15448759496212006, -0.1477525383234024, 0.5539841055870056, -0.2669755220413208, -1.063912034034729, 0.7286713123321533, -0.28855860233306885, -0.24302369356155396, -0.24890568852424622, 0.9206845760345459, -0.2658139169216156, -0.6117695569992065, 0.34234946966171265, 0.06733504682779312, -0.010240036062896252, -0.16514189541339874, -0.6993198394775391, 0.24504312872886658, 0.01605846732854843, -0.5182688236236572, 0.31226444244384766, 0.47306543588638306, -0.07629343867301941, 1.0424797534942627, 0.4882661700248718, 0.06917832046747208, -0.012457286939024925, 0.357822984457016, 0.9104882478713989, -0.5929958820343018, -0.4727315604686737, -0.7695854306221008, 0.7535648941993713, -0.3275766670703888, -0.3966139256954193, 0.5354249477386475, 0.470782995223999, 0.4651903212070465, 0.07320334017276764, 0.6424328684806824, 0.12862178683280945, 0.33070671558380127, -0.3472691476345062, 1.230264663696289, -0.7900279760360718, -0.06549736112356186, -0.22207409143447876, -1.162951946258545, -0.7461574673652649, 0.7294420599937439, 0.04742783308029175, -0.38873291015625, 0.7357994318008423, 0.4949798285961151, -0.21541793644428253, 0.20669636130332947, 0.4446268081665039, 0.23844580352306366, 0.6707602739334106, 0.55282062292099, 0.4300147593021393, -0.7718766331672668, 0.39759546518325806, -0.12816278636455536, -0.09242408722639084, -0.052407968789339066, -0.6073262691497803, -0.8017938137054443, -0.6090091466903687, -0.13589398562908173, 0.09951675683259964, -0.11300003528594971, 0.7847248315811157, 0.6696062088012695, -0.9483698010444641, -0.457281231880188, -0.1194831132888794, -0.13396722078323364, -0.020992618054151535, -0.2156873196363449, 0.31026965379714966, -0.7328733205795288, -0.8712009787559509, 0.6216486692428589, 0.5373022556304932, -0.28356844186782837, -0.6803929805755615, -0.06406141817569733, -0.3789600729942322, -0.09997159987688065, 0.7677556872367859, 0.13475565612316132, -0.5456612706184387, -0.23936429619789124, -0.0477934405207634, -0.2669176459312439, 0.20738479495048523, 0.7353036999702454, -0.8179812431335449, 0.5286676287651062, 0.5025851130485535, 0.9963352084159851, 0.17046886682510376, -0.5026910901069641, 1.1981850862503052, -0.5939072966575623, 0.5120134353637695, 0.4185192286968231, 0.14905309677124023, 0.5477599501609802, -0.32290610671043396, 0.4610937237739563, 0.06950630247592926, -0.5010970830917358, -0.8726457953453064, 0.3797444701194763, -0.6856800317764282, -0.19151298701763153, 0.677914023399353, 0.17969681322574615, -0.382091760635376, -0.3499477207660675, -0.11357437074184418, 0.1977403312921524, -0.24605238437652588, 0.6434033513069153, 0.6632490754127502, 0.2565763294696808, -0.1482718288898468, -0.6829809546470642, 0.5307329297065735, 0.4652838110923767, -0.8008160591125488, 0.08974021673202515, -0.17975156009197235, -0.16654418408870697, 0.4416186809539795, 0.24473106861114502, -0.06527876108884811, 0.11376558244228363, -0.04027711972594261, 0.18458178639411926, 0.05055220052599907, -0.5219524502754211, -0.18147829174995422, 0.31849804520606995, 0.00823576096445322, -0.016089726239442825 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16731v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16731v1	Towards Generating Informative Textual Description for Neurons in Language Models	2024-01-30T04:06:25	2024-01-30T04:06:25	Shrayani Mondal, Rishabh Garodia, Arbaaz Qureshi, Taesung Lee, Youngja Park	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Recent developments in transformer-based language models have allowed them to capture a wide variety of world knowledge that can be adapted to downstream tasks with limited resources. However, what pieces of information are understood in these models is unclear, and neuron-level contributions in identifying them are largely unknown. Conventional approaches in neuron explainability either depend on a finite set of pre-defined descriptors or require manual annotations for training a secondary model that can then explain the neurons of the primary model. In this paper, we take BERT as an example and we try to remove these constraints and propose a novel and scalable framework that ties textual descriptions to neurons. We leverage the potential of generative language models to discover human-interpretable descriptors present in a dataset and use an unsupervised approach to explain neurons with these descriptors. Through various qualitative and quantitative analyses, we demonstrate the effectiveness of this framework in generating useful data-specific descriptors with little human involvement in identifying the neurons that encode these descriptors. In particular, our experiment shows that the proposed approach achieves 75% precision@2, and 50% recall@2	[ -0.36475643515586853, -0.4560956060886383, 0.5596644878387451, 0.18787725269794464, -0.164229154586792, -0.32122504711151123, -0.5480125546455383, -0.24475830793380737, 0.201473668217659, 0.19363442063331604, -0.4519224762916565, -0.31103962659835815, -0.40987396240234375, -0.10577457398176193, -0.7954088449478149, 1.1489664316177368, 0.24367089569568634, -0.0681731328368187, -0.4269491136074066, 0.038860417902469635, -0.15826193988323212, -0.2917967438697815, -0.5265145301818848, -0.736638069152832, 0.8159446120262146, 0.0972299799323082, 0.6046656370162964, 0.48091739416122437, 0.2288195639848709, 0.23913782835006714, -0.41880089044570923, -0.03813808038830757, -0.1091320812702179, -0.035925328731536865, -0.29233238101005554, -0.5303084254264832, -0.304964154958725, -0.4022994637489319, 0.4584982991218567, 0.9610618352890015, -0.02405686490237713, -0.020084962248802185, 0.21709667146205902, 0.5597826242446899, -0.2649244964122772, 0.2855807840824127, -1.057802677154541, 0.06469296663999557, 0.010726184584200382, -0.15566228330135345, -0.7808083891868591, -0.022506795823574066, 0.4136497378349304, -0.6275158524513245, 0.7712105512619019, -0.3166092038154602, 0.9987538456916809, -0.0929018035531044, -0.1675383299589157, -0.18676544725894928, -0.6562008261680603, 0.42683643102645874, -0.7148234844207764, -0.08871051669120789, 0.4952104687690735, 0.25520527362823486, -0.051179058849811554, -0.7334380149841309, -0.6224833726882935, -0.04205773025751114, -0.6246598958969116, -0.07598035782575607, -0.19800898432731628, 0.0016548747662454844, 0.12768948078155518, 0.16002362966537476, -0.35334280133247375, 0.20056292414665222, -0.32121387124061584, -0.3551466464996338, 0.560386061668396, 0.054901834577322006, 0.3979867696762085, -0.23698566854000092, -0.42732498049736023, 0.07432025671005249, -0.5894084572792053, -0.003170972689986229, 0.2977823317050934, 0.3963516652584076, -0.137346088886261, 0.42520129680633545, 0.2771221399307251, 0.6803563237190247, 0.002052404684945941, 0.5179349184036255, 0.07900156080722809, -0.08790524303913116, -0.023722747340798378, -0.015130985528230667, 0.827350914478302, 0.34716930985450745, 0.4614902138710022, -0.48932039737701416, -0.250443696975708, -0.12369970977306366, 0.6120677590370178, -0.8590149283409119, -0.5515627861022949, -0.04849523305892944, -0.8989056348800659, -0.518433153629303, -0.26922330260276794, -0.9410246014595032, -0.6227620244026184, -0.16827619075775146, 0.4288150370121002, -0.5789539813995361, -0.43068844079971313, -0.14045807719230652, -0.32066085934638977, 0.2980008125305176, 0.1962030678987503, -1.7111921310424805, 0.32093358039855957, 0.3635334074497223, 0.8615320324897766, 0.010223660618066788, -0.24628597497940063, 0.17819134891033173, 0.18914178013801575, -0.36124661564826965, 0.7348743677139282, -0.3121589422225952, 0.03713224455714226, -0.1168721541762352, 0.03658384084701538, 0.05016792193055153, -0.2152012586593628, 0.20171698927879333, -0.3501685559749603, 0.057137198746204376, -0.2227247953414917, -0.3291893005371094, -0.36399906873703003, -0.16092681884765625, -0.8553840517997742, 0.7844880223274231, 0.011011673137545586, -0.9948800206184387, 0.4159892201423645, -0.7783378958702087, -0.7547057271003723, 0.17724891006946564, -0.24312831461429596, -0.24164403975009918, 0.6377279162406921, 0.33583709597587585, 0.6929572820663452, -0.4207042157649994, 0.5326374769210815, 0.008310731500387192, -0.19255106151103973, 0.5722686052322388, -0.637773871421814, 0.6681188344955444, -0.06028563156723976, -0.25843146443367004, 0.2558874189853668, -0.6967447400093079, 0.08519352972507477, 0.17446832358837128, -0.09633476287126541, -0.20321716368198395, 0.38870441913604736, 0.26285070180892944, -0.10135848075151443, 0.26978906989097595, -0.40913626551628113, 0.024353105574846268, -0.4819542169570923, 1.0452513694763184, 0.7808589339256287, -0.3590756058692932, 0.60358065366745, -0.056632865220308304, 0.06812427937984467, -0.15116523206233978, -0.042391903698444366, -0.3666394054889679, -0.45122674107551575, -0.7436516880989075, -0.13419997692108154, 0.45074474811553955, 0.0827096626162529, -0.7259610891342163, 0.6431868076324463, -0.3685891628265381, -0.4285019040107727, -0.37345731258392334, -0.25024911761283875, 0.1798643171787262, 0.5087243318557739, 0.3599519431591034, -0.14052997529506683, -0.32373371720314026, -1.3208682537078857, 0.017392415553331375, -0.35981255769729614, -0.47025981545448303, 0.14199721813201904, 0.5630868673324585, -0.040436748415231705, 1.0336148738861084, -0.3144169747829437, 0.005312991328537464, -0.3797517716884613, 0.46518853306770325, 0.25217753648757935, 0.25812825560569763, 0.463805615901947, -0.7714523077011108, 0.05111747980117798, 0.4159526526927948, -0.860018789768219, 0.04732402786612511, -0.5407518148422241, 0.06375104933977127, -0.15662126243114471, 0.2202620804309845, -0.6360633969306946, 0.5823681354522705, 0.2716337740421295, -0.137180358171463, 0.3271149694919586, -0.7415361404418945, -0.362932950258255, -0.9206647276878357, 0.15334270894527435, -0.12588998675346375, 0.14222146570682526, -0.6673590540885925, -0.34760963916778564, 0.11936106532812119, -0.040584973990917206, 0.053600411862134933, 0.44246408343315125, -0.3898982107639313, -0.24576659500598907, -0.2209642231464386, 0.1694517284631729, 0.05553075671195984, 0.7027098536491394, 0.21772433817386627, 0.445754736661911, 0.7567077875137329, -0.5014477372169495, 0.17234492301940918, 0.41623884439468384, -0.3899690806865692, 0.2080286741256714, -1.0563899278640747, -0.1822044998407364, -0.463558554649353, 0.19058829545974731, -1.078114628791809, -0.3987099826335907, -0.19004635512828827, -0.6716451644897461, 0.25143131613731384, -0.246833935379982, -0.448997437953949, -0.2629971504211426, 0.07087825238704681, 0.4237110912799835, 0.6001263856887817, -0.8756958842277527, 0.8571911454200745, 0.31527477502822876, -0.10580942779779434, -0.2504991888999939, -0.9504826664924622, 0.16087013483047485, -0.1545470803976059, -0.5738829970359802, 0.7339069843292236, 0.12718330323696136, 0.0955096185207367, 0.0021211912389844656, 0.01630355231463909, -0.42480871081352234, 0.25652116537094116, 0.5070578455924988, 0.1351163685321808, -0.0944330021739006, 0.9028398394584656, 0.11819429695606232, -0.19821059703826904, 0.22310812771320343, -0.1642059087753296, 0.44642719626426697, -0.06793081760406494, -0.1286492943763733, -0.4208044409751892, 0.3680540919303894, 0.6327718496322632, -0.14188691973686218, 0.6132388710975647, 0.6681012511253357, -0.5853767991065979, -0.5464767813682556, 0.12951357662677765, -0.4496616721153259, -0.42522692680358887, 0.5453821420669556, -0.4245988130569458, -0.2945617437362671, 0.48293301463127136, -0.01755603775382042, -0.16403301060199738, 0.5606260299682617, 0.6151652932167053, -0.21512141823768616, 0.9875699281692505, 0.745442271232605, 0.20464129745960236, 0.31611528992652893, -0.08194241672754288, 0.36260414123535156, -0.703308641910553, -0.4318161606788635, -0.24412231147289276, -0.36301857233047485, -0.4064563810825348, -0.0991116538643837, 0.05772816762328148, 0.16094882786273956, 0.0777362659573555, 0.4960898756980896, -0.8900080323219299, 0.5132659077644348, 0.46392810344696045, 0.09471539407968521, -0.08545824885368347, 0.1340455412864685, -0.35181379318237305, -0.06258581578731537, -0.7635223269462585, -0.7728761434555054, 0.9824292063713074, 0.4727405607700348, 0.9136734008789062, -0.15011660754680634, 0.29728299379348755, 0.2651277184486389, 0.3288653492927551, -0.782863974571228, 0.5422185659408569, -0.29991742968559265, -0.7851890325546265, -0.2609517276287079, -0.2744465172290802, -0.9035690426826477, 0.33120521903038025, -0.37195831537246704, -0.958534300327301, 0.19329458475112915, 0.24001942574977875, -0.397855281829834, 0.3199493885040283, -0.8035802841186523, 0.8673631548881531, -0.5981829762458801, -0.09961594641208649, -0.14787353575229645, -0.7027140855789185, 0.03358521685004234, 0.010010636411607265, -0.015450659207999706, -0.07712460309267044, 0.13854552805423737, 0.8021414279937744, -0.3787965178489685, 1.1478404998779297, -0.14580626785755157, -0.22271476686000824, 0.14506840705871582, -0.12023075670003891, 0.22295443713665009, -0.0011487002484500408, -0.07103633135557175, 0.22245968878269196, -0.13275082409381866, -0.2367248833179474, -0.7636777758598328, 0.5882728099822998, -0.5442180037498474, 0.0022338302806019783, -0.04049384221434593, -0.7523620128631592, -0.005274537950754166, 0.027533546090126038, 0.4972046911716461, 0.70632004737854, -0.36734738945961, 0.016072183847427368, 0.6635880470275879, -0.5034111142158508, 0.7034145593643188, 0.19210034608840942, -0.1629543900489807, -0.2158692628145218, 0.9703448414802551, -0.19129635393619537, -0.03060864470899105, 0.5803934335708618, 0.11017864942550659, -0.2755196988582611, -0.6599675416946411, -0.42380189895629883, 0.03630908951163292, -0.731073260307312, -0.07906801998615265, -0.49099770188331604, -0.23225317895412445, 0.07915165275335312, -0.2085341215133667, -0.18544353544712067, -0.6617758274078369, -0.3575098216533661, -0.21194787323474884, 0.4527243673801422, 1.1441065073013306, -0.06406091898679733, 0.6524890661239624, -0.46666473150253296, 0.45716679096221924, 0.48937344551086426, 0.5101487040519714, 0.27093005180358887, -0.3813650608062744, -0.32219216227531433, 0.33575931191444397, -0.09533339738845825, -0.9250510931015015, 0.4686378538608551, 0.3659698963165283, 0.606575071811676, 0.3817581534385681, -0.12110184133052826, 0.2753159701824188, -0.6279687285423279, 0.6744590997695923, 0.46113306283950806, -1.125178337097168, 0.7611762285232544, -0.18571338057518005, 0.10173136740922928, 0.1813611537218094, 0.22687432169914246, -0.17501667141914368, -0.01407476607710123, -0.5648616552352905, -1.1003787517547607, 0.7344233989715576, 0.47712278366088867, 0.4869815409183502, -0.19900654256343842, 0.3103421628475189, 0.3374606966972351, 0.030331997200846672, -0.8806381225585938, -0.1380820870399475, -0.25577419996261597, -0.43933701515197754, -0.014203025959432125, -0.34933921694755554, -0.2159247249364853, -0.19885389506816864, 0.45212769508361816, -0.34009766578674316, 0.719156801700592, -0.032453883439302444, -0.28093910217285156, 0.2321081906557083, 0.29689541459083557, 0.4265621304512024, 0.6747705340385437, -0.15856321156024933, 0.5592760443687439, 0.0265034306794405, -0.1942906528711319, -0.13423782587051392, 0.13792787492275238, -0.20367830991744995, 0.4381173253059387, 0.724692165851593, 0.7597832679748535, -0.0009460080182179809, -0.47708120942115784, 0.6896967887878418, -0.23760336637496948, -0.13117502629756927, -0.2678484618663788, -0.24774926900863647, 0.3807013928890228, 0.1018846333026886, 0.41647765040397644, 0.21165630221366882, -0.08932290226221085, -0.2832927703857422, 0.2272031009197235, 0.42906907200813293, -0.708791971206665, -0.7311578989028931, 0.5258732438087463, 0.28546398878097534, -0.18398620188236237, 0.5868180990219116, 0.009781695902347565, -0.48162510991096497, 0.8407058715820312, 0.6613215208053589, 0.9703099727630615, 0.12600965797901154, 0.5643203258514404, 0.30291447043418884, 0.3302825391292572, -0.03175366297364235, 0.03354978561401367, -0.3047352433204651, -0.9557992219924927, -0.2988324761390686, -0.6206277012825012, 0.11134622246026993, 0.08477035909891129, -0.9636081457138062, -0.08615713566541672, -0.41159501671791077, -0.34104016423225403, 0.7975621223449707, -0.8564155101776123, -0.4840107560157776, 0.20320959389209747, 0.19629530608654022, 0.7194318175315857, -1.0192971229553223, 0.8990853428840637, 0.4492592513561249, -0.5926197171211243, -0.4466805160045624, 0.09265758097171783, -0.5098729729652405, -0.884736180305481, 0.972205638885498, 0.2537972033023834, 0.03689628094434738, -0.25297611951828003, -0.6832879185676575, -0.3186459541320801, 0.9769681692123413, 0.44367146492004395, -0.4027383029460907, -0.23624981939792633, -0.06277675181627274, 0.8587464690208435, -0.4654935896396637, 0.5618869066238403, 0.3742522597312927, 0.43197840452194214, 0.0733865275979042, -0.5623735189437866, 0.20084290206432343, -0.49102237820625305, 0.28974616527557373, 0.22885403037071228, 0.14414429664611816, 0.8555808663368225, -0.6416378617286682, -0.4181019961833954, 0.1363859325647354, 0.497586727142334, -0.5418163537979126, -0.06812261790037155, 0.39798247814178467, 0.2754005193710327, 0.7167274355888367, -0.2562221586704254, 1.0030852556228638, -0.01824466697871685, 0.4224371612071991, 1.2872973680496216, 0.1621074229478836, 0.6994696855545044, 0.6718104481697083, -0.09470478445291519, 0.5487536191940308, 0.3816211521625519, -0.1461574137210846, 0.6861050128936768, 0.5656364560127258, -0.2596929967403412, -0.3781568109989166, -0.2580738067626953, -0.1343548744916916, 0.39949312806129456, 0.47487887740135193, -1.0552682876586914, -0.4040376842021942, -0.023990590125322342, -0.35615938901901245, 0.15011657774448395, -0.14704452455043793, 0.9396985769271851, -0.0549941286444664, -0.378206342458725, 0.6420642733573914, -0.17851179838180542, 0.5149071216583252, -0.5265791416168213, -0.2907189726829529, 0.030578529462218285, 0.2062760889530182, -0.31646862626075745, -0.9340565800666809, 0.40745165944099426, -0.036502059549093246, -0.6456949710845947, -0.5593529939651489, 0.6705082654953003, -0.5725408792495728, -0.433069109916687, 0.3755752444267273, 0.16292326152324677, 0.16877539455890656, 0.02195304073393345, -0.3452068567276001, -0.2803274691104889, 0.01386181265115738, 0.1049787700176239, 0.10946235060691833, 0.7049205899238586, 0.018722791224718094, 0.6988555788993835, 0.26384276151657104, -0.0020100551191717386, -0.1465708315372467, 0.09943805634975433, 0.8277707099914551, -0.7132835388183594, -0.11525711417198181, -0.8414637446403503, 0.6765214204788208, -0.19164618849754333, -0.18904337286949158, 0.33949658274650574, 0.23571330308914185, 0.45561474561691284, -0.33613327145576477, 1.0620582103729248, -0.4393267035484314, 0.17306967079639435, -0.3998602032661438, 0.9887529015541077, -0.31674709916114807, 0.3677254021167755, 0.22476328909397125, -0.560829758644104, -0.22041556239128113, 0.9360178112983704, -0.1572590172290802, -0.14363999664783478, 0.7506674528121948, 0.7980210781097412, -0.07188410311937332, 0.17399530112743378, 0.3586796820163727, 0.32397428154945374, 0.08786754310131073, 0.7009594440460205, 1.075150966644287, -0.2505095303058624, 0.6399328708648682, -0.07154951244592667, -0.163153737783432, 0.14050491154193878, -0.9239852428436279, -1.1911489963531494, -0.882716953754425, -0.14452172815799713, -0.03118758834898472, -0.17875023186206818, 0.2550555467605591, 0.7945711016654968, -0.8431469202041626, 0.00036876494414173067, -0.45331019163131714, 0.18145763874053955, -0.22080227732658386, -0.22037328779697418, 0.42392614483833313, -0.5448938012123108, -0.25115713477134705, 0.2224092036485672, 0.22776207327842712, 0.13247781991958618, -0.22633014619350433, 0.11407674103975296, -0.01990148238837719, 0.03261541202664375, 0.5564444065093994, 0.008927809074521065, -0.9092321395874023, -0.22885745763778687, -0.29157114028930664, 0.04696038365364075, -0.07966232299804688, 1.0554224252700806, -0.7694100141525269, 0.6134817004203796, 0.46014147996902466, 0.7165156006813049, 0.5987139940261841, -0.38089826703071594, 0.8394215703010559, -0.861360490322113, -0.04437513276934624, 0.1758439838886261, 0.3796258270740509, 0.5591686367988586, -0.2187807857990265, 0.31733256578445435, -0.2248796671628952, -0.20182925462722778, -0.4499317407608032, 0.439067006111145, -1.0805127620697021, -0.4216856062412262, 0.9838796257972717, -0.4284157156944275, -0.2252785563468933, -0.09904759377241135, -0.1307523399591446, 0.0003837252443190664, -0.15584738552570343, 0.7379122972488403, 0.6380226016044617, 0.10195394605398178, 0.07026814669370651, -0.3289925754070282, 0.499616414308548, 0.21417507529258728, -0.8602142333984375, 0.5491328239440918, 0.42138975858688354, 0.17754234373569489, 0.2812875509262085, 0.2644873261451721, -0.13212262094020844, -0.034400030970573425, 0.01464512012898922, 0.42499038577079773, 0.21041522920131683, -0.4221462905406952, -0.2447393834590912, 0.11252403259277344, -0.010697565041482449, -0.23569080233573914 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00888v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00888v1	Security and Privacy Challenges of Large Language Models: A Survey	2024-01-30T04:00:54	2024-01-30T04:00:54	Badhan Chandra Das, M. Hadi Amini, Yanzhao Wu	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR	Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated extraordinary capabilities and contributed to multiple fields, such as generating and summarizing text, language translation, and question-answering. Nowadays, LLM is becoming a very popular tool in computerized language processing tasks, with the capability to analyze complicated linguistic patterns and provide relevant and appropriate responses depending on the context. While offering significant advantages, these models are also vulnerable to security and privacy attacks, such as jailbreaking attacks, data poisoning attacks, and Personally Identifiable Information (PII) leakage attacks. This survey provides a thorough review of the security and privacy challenges of LLMs for both training data and users, along with the application-based risks in various domains, such as transportation, education, and healthcare. We assess the extent of LLM vulnerabilities, investigate emerging security and privacy attacks for LLMs, and review the potential defense mechanisms. Additionally, the survey outlines existing research gaps in this domain and highlights future research directions.	[ -0.22711628675460815, -0.9103179574012756, 0.5643332004547119, -0.04059027135372162, 0.14334014058113098, 0.12771375477313995, -0.1515142321586609, -0.8100428581237793, -0.17876483500003815, 0.835930347442627, -0.4329637587070465, -0.4187231659889221, -0.7990372776985168, -0.12915803492069244, -0.6201090812683105, 0.7526578307151794, 0.12002897262573242, 0.1330639123916626, -0.1744268834590912, 0.034573715180158615, -0.389244943857193, -1.245350956916809, -0.546207070350647, 0.05353274941444397, 0.5894946455955505, 0.13414496183395386, 0.38058653473854065, 0.21953879296779633, 0.8032360076904297, 0.37555694580078125, -0.2055576741695404, -0.25831133127212524, -0.41978922486305237, 0.3660806119441986, -0.21695902943611145, -0.45311400294303894, -0.5864444971084595, -0.18479789793491364, 0.7020374536514282, 0.8654977679252625, -0.03322931006550789, 0.24102894961833954, -0.17005759477615356, 0.6911389231681824, -0.7468620538711548, -0.07769932597875595, -0.6870744824409485, -0.03428998962044716, -0.5688609480857849, -0.0071117752231657505, -0.4297010600566864, -0.40034914016723633, 0.10511737316846848, 0.029818596318364143, -0.02449432574212551, 0.1491709202528, 0.38748928904533386, 0.034777794033288956, -0.6929799318313599, -0.3103131949901581, -0.7783201932907104, 0.7923797369003296, -0.6311017870903015, 0.5175870656967163, 0.4577344059944153, 0.26152417063713074, -0.19228458404541016, -0.503701388835907, -0.2531936466693878, -0.29262349009513855, 0.1589309126138687, -0.2723410129547119, -0.30204713344573975, -0.03187764436006546, 0.3584509789943695, 0.49877873063087463, -0.7757707238197327, 0.7250440716743469, -0.3609391748905182, -0.18715064227581024, 0.917338490486145, 0.5258042812347412, 0.4816194474697113, 0.08240370452404022, -0.21931302547454834, -0.09757713228464127, -1.101459264755249, -0.07465527206659317, 0.7111061215400696, 0.014636131934821606, -0.17263875901699066, 0.627677857875824, -0.10080264508724213, 0.7687262892723083, -0.5897548198699951, -0.07179094851016998, -0.008937714621424675, -0.18885619938373566, -0.20296619832515717, -0.09563768655061722, 0.9311903715133667, 0.28982171416282654, 0.15667632222175598, -0.20952028036117554, -0.11921805143356323, -0.48147204518318176, 0.05471237376332283, -0.6519269347190857, 0.09277766197919846, 0.43077561259269714, -0.32046592235565186, -0.355292409658432, 0.16810280084609985, -0.9706143736839294, -0.7206050753593445, 0.11408473551273346, -0.08566206693649292, -0.04885275289416313, -0.3337409198284149, 0.04805312678217888, 0.2529674470424652, 0.43640896677970886, 0.16181546449661255, -1.0632981061935425, 0.35591256618499756, 0.798032283782959, 0.7432542443275452, -0.2915799915790558, -0.17045170068740845, -0.17101895809173584, 0.25830894708633423, -0.14749227464199066, 0.35934093594551086, -0.26748126745224, -0.7517195343971252, 0.3458569347858429, 0.03650033101439476, -0.1274653673171997, -0.5213512182235718, 0.13816769421100616, -0.6984356045722961, 0.11309900879859924, -0.09207864105701447, -0.6238647699356079, 0.10239146649837494, 0.5101723670959473, -0.6903363466262817, 0.5979491472244263, -0.20470453798770905, -0.9239799380302429, -0.31867772340774536, -0.5798709988594055, -0.3595305383205414, 0.10344570130109787, -0.1660645455121994, -0.5011049509048462, 0.21310041844844818, -0.03074086271226406, 0.704522430896759, -0.31931304931640625, 0.28144216537475586, -0.40392693877220154, -0.11412183195352554, 0.844774067401886, -0.5214673280715942, 0.9721548557281494, 0.32704007625579834, -0.03914640098810196, 0.16218382120132446, -0.729519784450531, -0.09296473115682602, 0.4261508882045746, -0.2647112309932709, -0.35775822401046753, -0.05548107624053955, 0.06625418365001678, -0.028851866722106934, 0.5494756102561951, -0.5665584206581116, 0.25919216871261597, -0.3486848771572113, 0.5960917472839355, 0.7379692196846008, 0.26010337471961975, 0.41856294870376587, -0.05718240141868591, 0.6933275461196899, -0.020600998774170876, 0.48900893330574036, -0.17233417928218842, -0.517035722732544, -0.1644544005393982, -0.0807061418890953, 0.3000783920288086, 0.7474899888038635, -0.1989651918411255, 0.3754426836967468, -0.13290391862392426, -0.5588467717170715, -0.04377351701259613, 0.10510256886482239, 0.2277291864156723, 0.14453566074371338, -0.13948193192481995, 0.044279228895902634, -0.25499677658081055, -0.9098827242851257, -0.331859290599823, -0.17270764708518982, 0.09248229116201401, 0.3889169692993164, 0.5367669463157654, -0.3712472915649414, 0.5910173654556274, -0.7280134558677673, -0.19432301819324493, -0.33318954706192017, -0.34871912002563477, -0.06421703100204468, 0.6254974007606506, 0.48673027753829956, -0.745136559009552, -0.2634715139865875, -0.05377218499779701, -0.7182028293609619, 0.014312255196273327, 0.14510837197303772, 0.21489135921001434, 0.1570902168750763, 0.6164489388465881, -0.661768913269043, 0.22355006635189056, 0.8538649082183838, -0.19993479549884796, 0.5503250956535339, -0.07891993224620819, -0.10637016594409943, -1.1520692110061646, 0.21728835999965668, -0.24370652437210083, -0.24441714584827423, -0.8549126386642456, 0.3305770456790924, 0.018155867233872414, -0.46270444989204407, -0.5762298107147217, 0.610029399394989, -0.5100128054618835, -0.13870473206043243, -0.2938094437122345, -0.09213416278362274, -0.3684324622154236, -0.04110191762447357, -0.13649210333824158, 0.757421612739563, 0.8565868139266968, -0.517503023147583, 0.4880969822406769, 0.10786231607198715, -0.4561821520328522, 0.13049910962581635, -0.6060305237770081, 0.41755411028862, 0.11260300874710083, 0.13262836635112762, -0.687799334526062, -0.5767675638198853, 0.3330066502094269, -0.4374350905418396, 0.5091935992240906, 0.0799756869673729, -0.6723657250404358, -0.17184220254421234, -0.4577198922634125, 0.4455624222755432, 0.4256007969379425, -0.17104557156562805, 0.35174933075904846, 0.7807493805885315, -0.3291078805923462, -0.7179333567619324, -0.765404999256134, 0.3755086660385132, -0.29588356614112854, -0.5162473320960999, -0.016584599390625954, -0.15484236180782318, -0.519599974155426, -0.15507103502750397, 0.11078538000583649, -0.23048606514930725, 0.6553666591644287, 0.43186691403388977, 0.2917179763317108, 0.057043809443712234, -0.2731173038482666, -0.29787391424179077, -0.046734049916267395, 0.5268508791923523, 0.007815921679139137, 0.6629102826118469, -0.06201016530394554, -0.6146407723426819, -0.36315953731536865, 0.7215090990066528, 0.5440855622291565, -0.36516013741493225, 1.0369255542755127, 0.23999567329883575, -0.44155049324035645, -0.0023914978373795748, -0.5650627017021179, -0.11965522170066833, -0.4751809239387512, 0.5371105074882507, -0.04296707361936569, -1.403111457824707, 0.573782742023468, -0.18632200360298157, 0.1399611383676529, 0.0424668975174427, 0.7897694706916809, 0.005605107173323631, 0.9299678206443787, 0.7967731952667236, -0.3816744089126587, 0.5369681715965271, -0.06523776054382324, 0.4420011341571808, -0.6656369566917419, -0.4872954189777374, -0.5937861800193787, 0.016172200441360474, -0.7864655256271362, 0.0038305812049657106, 0.3199252486228943, -0.1881151646375656, -0.09377965331077576, 0.020830903202295303, -0.17578500509262085, 0.43082937598228455, 0.41572505235671997, -0.1601148098707199, 0.43145477771759033, -0.2342887669801712, 0.27721771597862244, 0.15827761590480804, -0.2561752200126648, -0.5970717072486877, 1.1685916185379028, 0.6709306240081787, 0.9900007247924805, 0.563853919506073, 0.7797984480857849, 0.10826636105775833, 0.10062925517559052, -0.5753292441368103, 0.6688899993896484, -0.08314887434244156, -0.9681614637374878, -0.3461887538433075, -0.5307521224021912, -0.9476902484893799, 0.1113571971654892, -0.048205841332674026, -1.1806503534317017, 0.044664014130830765, 0.04734998941421509, -0.17695429921150208, 0.4398125410079956, -0.5576462149620056, 0.7623146176338196, -0.44588202238082886, -0.3994395434856415, 0.09184173494577408, -0.8560768365859985, 0.6994897127151489, -0.4734051525592804, 0.33268335461616516, -0.14427870512008667, 0.05520230904221535, 0.6814975142478943, -0.2912229895591736, 0.9094205498695374, -0.06004348397254944, -0.29293859004974365, 0.08847545832395554, -0.048047587275505066, 0.4577942192554474, 0.13883890211582184, 0.09656970947980881, 0.43034207820892334, 0.15638868510723114, -0.2099512219429016, -0.3093763291835785, 1.0005719661712646, -0.7644568085670471, -0.9312118887901306, -0.6106624007225037, -0.536784827709198, -0.4494130611419678, 0.08760880678892136, 0.21085402369499207, 0.1464909017086029, -0.2801530957221985, 0.19845400750637054, 0.9727634191513062, -0.5038642287254333, 0.5018017888069153, 0.5995585918426514, -0.4514572024345398, -0.2984652519226074, 0.8012206554412842, 0.03432285413146019, 0.29037943482398987, 0.355598509311676, 0.12117423117160797, -0.3075524866580963, -0.8520912528038025, -0.28478115797042847, 0.3449440598487854, -0.5084890127182007, -0.09430631250143051, -0.5515102744102478, -0.581184983253479, -0.4874996542930603, 0.10907044261693954, -0.41359779238700867, -0.27513718605041504, -0.2255447506904602, -0.15647786855697632, 0.30649247765541077, 0.967117190361023, 0.24655026197433472, 0.512180507183075, -0.936813473701477, -0.032456111162900925, 0.24230611324310303, 0.27830612659454346, -0.09922219812870026, -0.2706325948238373, -0.2247658669948578, -0.358055055141449, -0.2520518898963928, -0.9688470959663391, 0.24007517099380493, -0.26272907853126526, 0.44206252694129944, 0.3415153920650482, -0.05470021069049835, 0.21015508472919464, -0.6914846897125244, 1.145039439201355, 0.22267548739910126, -0.6569991111755371, 0.3274231255054474, -0.32652124762535095, -0.01711110956966877, 0.48391100764274597, 0.3983161747455597, -0.530707836151123, -0.3973722755908966, -0.42802858352661133, -0.9050101041793823, 0.38454413414001465, 0.17396192252635956, 0.45821741223335266, 0.25994765758514404, 0.23159262537956238, -0.12142324447631836, 0.28497549891471863, -0.85577392578125, -0.3400407135486603, 0.2114618718624115, -0.09659631550312042, 0.12750107049942017, -0.41007083654403687, -0.15103788673877716, 0.01726933941245079, 0.523593008518219, 0.31302598118782043, -0.01427962351590395, -0.2294693887233734, 0.03429790586233139, 0.1698499619960785, 0.6034591794013977, 0.6765785217285156, 0.6165950894355774, 0.008362121880054474, 0.21968325972557068, 0.23767733573913574, -0.6634459495544434, 0.28790807723999023, 0.03490601107478142, -0.1508154720067978, -0.20218192040920258, 0.3790983259677887, 0.5599958300590515, 0.10199937969446182, -0.894818127155304, 0.6876504421234131, -0.19318518042564392, -0.19418130815029144, -0.6840111613273621, 0.0907319113612175, 0.18546411395072937, 0.1825937181711197, 0.15344329178333282, -0.35098353028297424, -0.01270846277475357, -0.4558711051940918, -0.18264171481132507, 0.7063334584236145, -0.20657256245613098, -0.2955363988876343, 0.7323750853538513, -0.02669406868517399, -0.36406365036964417, 0.47777050733566284, 0.3520207703113556, -0.3908674120903015, 0.3794832229614258, 0.5503795742988586, 0.8160822987556458, -0.5967960357666016, -0.24096998572349548, -0.1311083287000656, 0.5226790904998779, -0.0925632193684578, 0.18777287006378174, 0.1769150346517563, -0.6013233065605164, -0.1038697212934494, -0.42298606038093567, -0.7911887764930725, 0.5268422961235046, -0.7330952882766724, -0.03740300238132477, -0.6419029235839844, -0.3352504074573517, -0.26210710406303406, -0.15593762695789337, -0.40092384815216064, -0.03978719934821129, 0.4738141894340515, 0.8206838965415955, -0.6850142478942871, 0.9252743721008301, 0.7764411568641663, -0.1178116723895073, -0.4502517282962799, -0.09645742923021317, 0.09661666303873062, -0.5417977571487427, 0.5418643951416016, 0.048508789390325546, -0.060436081141233444, -0.18631064891815186, -0.6365628242492676, -0.6158987283706665, 0.8889849781990051, 0.5576223134994507, -0.9462382197380066, -0.07828490436077118, 0.7194095253944397, 0.3309195041656494, -0.014762659557163715, -0.20864316821098328, 0.6269954442977905, 0.35028505325317383, -0.3411400020122528, -0.8142284154891968, -0.17860820889472961, -0.03853404521942139, 0.05971776321530342, 0.017515476793050766, -0.7749012112617493, 0.821552574634552, 0.051721081137657166, -0.03486247360706329, 0.06089560315012932, 0.42640793323516846, 0.3706110417842865, 0.36673757433891296, 0.27634575963020325, 0.4090423882007599, 0.7233128547668457, 0.12091978639364243, 1.088054895401001, -0.3871970474720001, 0.2675512731075287, 0.9700520038604736, -0.6072300672531128, 0.8117446303367615, 0.4812788665294647, -0.21709957718849182, 0.054476525634527206, 0.5613914132118225, -0.00864530261605978, 0.31354019045829773, 0.38684725761413574, -0.5254911184310913, -0.04014212638139725, 0.05356054753065109, -0.43410181999206543, 0.4234628677368164, 0.39498987793922424, -0.4213275909423828, -0.08946571499109268, 0.12946826219558716, 0.2762424051761627, -0.001856024842709303, -0.35118499398231506, 0.8824131488800049, 0.418689101934433, -0.11950642615556717, 0.024902528151869774, 0.3274987041950226, 0.46095529198646545, -0.8774328231811523, 0.20069758594036102, -0.09689389914274216, 0.1690177321434021, -0.2112748920917511, -0.8368201851844788, 0.36260268092155457, 0.3373314142227173, -0.03226500004529953, -0.26508641242980957, 0.6083759665489197, -0.1521115005016327, -0.31577998399734497, 0.21290530264377594, 0.4705343246459961, 0.17403952777385712, -0.14948779344558716, -0.6247695088386536, 0.5775160789489746, -0.30530717968940735, -0.5001565217971802, 0.8320028185844421, 0.07447351515293121, -0.08747585117816925, 0.8627954125404358, 0.5354615449905396, 0.2986302971839905, 0.47094398736953735, 0.14619874954223633, 0.830116868019104, -0.7193027138710022, -0.31002822518348694, -1.2303123474121094, 0.16558632254600525, -0.17399442195892334, -0.2068348228931427, 0.9919391870498657, 0.6922582387924194, 0.7155658602714539, -0.13812054693698883, 0.9169605374336243, 0.18378345668315887, 0.48626959323883057, -0.6832685470581055, 1.114683985710144, -0.22800284624099731, 0.5953097939491272, -0.13751709461212158, -0.8039946556091309, -0.4377501308917999, 0.22431443631649017, -0.4696982800960541, -0.09529215097427368, 0.5519778728485107, 0.7113735675811768, 0.21629463136196136, -0.04215877130627632, 0.46337562799453735, 0.08751840144395828, 0.6765347719192505, 0.49332383275032043, 1.0794981718063354, -0.2219039797782898, 0.19869586825370789, -0.13748548924922943, 0.06415442377328873, -0.1073748841881752, -0.7706119418144226, -1.0398869514465332, -0.45696574449539185, -0.37232330441474915, -0.06951082497835159, 0.042054153978824615, 0.5712055563926697, 0.5173929333686829, -0.987787127494812, -0.4039659798145294, 0.185855433344841, 0.2043471336364746, 0.25103914737701416, -0.18641549348831177, 0.3460642993450165, 0.10520333796739578, -0.747633159160614, 0.5279209613800049, 0.2162461131811142, 0.14846192300319672, -0.6392346620559692, 0.27791547775268555, 0.06575979292392731, -0.021849771961569786, 0.5120214223861694, 0.45722806453704834, -0.5716314315795898, -0.24767804145812988, -0.050373926758766174, -0.2400093376636505, -0.35512253642082214, 0.9077407121658325, -0.09758546948432922, 0.17427794635295868, 0.33518609404563904, 1.0320520401000977, 0.2322937697172165, -0.09552454203367233, 0.31168872117996216, -0.643614649772644, 0.1781928688287735, 0.21529686450958252, 0.4089209735393524, 0.3970964252948761, -0.5500359535217285, 0.19935034215450287, 0.10371436178684235, -0.7335598468780518, -1.160926103591919, 0.45122653245925903, -1.057154655456543, -0.28779810667037964, 1.0423345565795898, -0.20768389105796814, -0.3833070397377014, -0.20411622524261475, 0.07957915961742401, -0.13664494454860687, -0.03154740110039711, 0.5273736715316772, 0.6162508726119995, -0.07402458786964417, -0.20372474193572998, -0.9965762495994568, 0.30186396837234497, -0.09268274903297424, -0.971116840839386, 0.42071783542633057, 0.46184977889060974, 0.5207688212394714, -0.20726363360881805, 0.5116626024246216, -0.43427416682243347, -0.11102098226547241, -0.3684070110321045, -0.15511924028396606, -0.212476909160614, -0.31423813104629517, -0.560603141784668, 0.42671799659729004, 0.3608878254890442, -0.15730513632297516 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16727v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16727v2	Recent Advances in Hate Speech Moderation: Multimodality and the Role of Large Models	2024-01-30T03:51:44	2024-02-02T04:07:25	Ming Shan Hee, Shivam Sharma, Rui Cao, Palash Nandi, Tanmoy Chakraborty, Roy Ka-Wei Lee	cs.CL	cs.CL	In the evolving landscape of online communication, moderating hate speech (HS) presents an intricate challenge, compounded by the multimodal nature of digital content. This comprehensive survey delves into the recent strides in HS moderation, spotlighting the burgeoning role of large language models (LLMs) and large multimodal models (LMMs). Our exploration begins with a thorough analysis of current literature, revealing the nuanced interplay between textual, visual, and auditory elements in propagating HS. We uncover a notable trend towards integrating these modalities, primarily due to the complexity and subtlety with which HS is disseminated. A significant emphasis is placed on the advances facilitated by LLMs and LMMs, which have begun to redefine the boundaries of detection and moderation capabilities. We identify existing gaps in research, particularly in the context of underrepresented languages and cultures, and the need for solutions to handle low-resource settings. The survey concludes with a forward-looking perspective, outlining potential avenues for future research, including the exploration of novel AI methodologies, the ethical governance of AI in moderation, and the development of more nuanced, context-aware systems. This comprehensive overview aims to catalyze further research and foster a collaborative effort towards more sophisticated, responsible, and human-centric approaches to HS moderation in the digital era. WARNING: This paper contains offensive examples.	[ -0.678246259689331, -1.0759363174438477, 0.5064305067062378, -0.07870448380708694, 0.02661152370274067, 0.22603276371955872, -0.23388226330280304, -0.6968711018562317, 0.3788415789604187, 0.46387746930122375, -0.5518897175788879, -0.044461898505687714, -1.0196070671081543, 0.019384758546948433, -0.42916110157966614, 1.1885221004486084, 0.34248772263526917, 0.20999525487422943, -0.10996134579181671, -0.31508201360702515, -0.25487035512924194, -0.6280258297920227, -0.5575375556945801, -0.2396678328514099, 1.0874149799346924, -0.03272932767868042, 0.6438877582550049, 0.543228268623352, 0.5420265793800354, 0.3534218370914459, -0.36133697628974915, 0.13329161703586578, -0.6965534090995789, 0.53315269947052, 0.018717151135206223, -0.041519202291965485, -0.5203037858009338, 0.21216373145580292, 0.6328158378601074, 0.4485054314136505, -0.019321147352457047, 0.0484938845038414, -0.041923291981220245, 0.23424024879932404, -0.7397488355636597, -0.15709219872951508, -0.5280882716178894, 0.013747778721153736, -0.5003185272216797, -0.13810575008392334, -0.2629433870315552, -0.1898224651813507, -0.13257211446762085, -0.42446771264076233, -0.17649714648723602, 0.006971035618335009, 0.23596616089344025, 0.1792304962873459, -0.8596944808959961, -0.5156171321868896, -1.0484862327575684, 1.1638474464416504, -0.6021401882171631, 0.51215660572052, 0.5356788039207458, 0.1819818764925003, 0.10624202340841293, -0.7483505010604858, -0.5598492622375488, -0.30013617873191833, 0.23591969907283783, 0.027563191950321198, -0.4646933674812317, 0.11743875592947006, 0.2467460036277771, 0.43019118905067444, -0.12025884538888931, 0.458981990814209, -0.5492585897445679, -0.3818691372871399, 0.6571016311645508, 0.2894904315471649, 0.28046703338623047, -0.10382211953401566, -0.18380996584892273, 0.2364780753850937, -0.2999875843524933, -0.15768003463745117, 0.5820780396461487, 0.20957554876804352, -0.19405746459960938, 0.4425593316555023, 0.08132177591323853, 0.6351369023323059, -0.2008148580789566, -0.4631290137767792, 0.014224783517420292, -0.45090627670288086, -0.04883101209998131, -0.10253841429948807, 0.70081627368927, 0.5086562037467957, 0.010846691206097603, 0.16457515954971313, -0.2502930462360382, 0.2836081087589264, 0.45474472641944885, -0.799456000328064, -0.031716346740722656, -0.020821072161197662, -0.6266563534736633, -0.34518393874168396, -0.27655282616615295, -1.0271095037460327, -1.1481181383132935, -0.419894278049469, 0.31892848014831543, 0.009548403322696686, -0.33184054493904114, -0.2932523190975189, -0.3062254786491394, 0.008149546571075916, 0.4161621332168579, -0.5254876613616943, 0.11717996746301651, 0.5813929438591003, 0.7548214793205261, -0.23406977951526642, -0.04339463636279106, -0.416839599609375, 0.16551212966442108, -0.14310793578624725, 0.34779927134513855, -0.705582320690155, -0.3686162233352661, 0.16341225802898407, -0.31620675325393677, 0.32393696904182434, -0.42198893427848816, 0.8491643667221069, -0.7550309300422668, 0.35025259852409363, -0.19036774337291718, -0.30900540947914124, -0.30552276968955994, 0.4594022035598755, -0.6013827323913574, 0.6918587684631348, -0.04804833605885506, -0.7077649235725403, 0.24114947021007538, -0.7940990924835205, -0.3516439199447632, 0.0993238240480423, -0.2740195393562317, -0.3581236004829407, 0.050841737538576126, -0.04089898616075516, 0.34767264127731323, -0.3036280572414398, 0.29284968972206116, -0.5309299826622009, -0.18469920754432678, 0.2683126628398895, -0.6747040748596191, 0.9818502068519592, 0.48992007970809937, -0.5422091484069824, 0.6408132314682007, -0.2896038591861725, -0.4022473096847534, 0.1367812156677246, -0.15671294927597046, -0.4189443290233612, 0.188104048371315, 0.32326415181159973, 0.34062308073043823, 0.04207604005932808, -0.5296130776405334, -0.29982495307922363, 0.16194015741348267, 0.7987999320030212, 0.9969691038131714, -0.08195406943559647, 0.2704639732837677, -0.7039124369621277, 0.6042082905769348, 0.014557740651071072, 0.5499114394187927, -0.036979950964450836, -0.592680037021637, -0.6176009774208069, -0.2305348813533783, -0.2664545774459839, 0.2718318700790405, -0.5580536723136902, 0.14274577796459198, 0.01590132713317871, -0.6364448666572571, -0.4365607798099518, 0.17724309861660004, 0.18560518324375153, 0.1777219921350479, 0.3648201525211334, -0.2496534287929535, -0.6726439595222473, -0.9301727414131165, -0.0717119500041008, -0.134144589304924, 0.29144203662872314, 0.3671194314956665, 0.36355364322662354, -0.4739770293235779, 0.5908512473106384, -0.11093034595251083, -0.3275095224380493, -0.34041643142700195, 0.19894352555274963, -0.33016330003738403, 0.19257083535194397, 0.5404200553894043, -1.0917342901229858, -0.3984251618385315, -0.42008134722709656, -0.4443522095680237, 0.03994184732437134, 0.10235666483640671, 0.09820504486560822, -0.12918247282505035, 0.6234456300735474, -0.06809873133897781, 0.11699450016021729, 0.9535534977912903, -0.32386887073516846, 0.3371363580226898, 0.27061644196510315, 0.5694466829299927, -0.9946166276931763, -0.13257555663585663, 0.08035299181938171, -0.18146376311779022, -0.8725525736808777, 0.17746871709823608, -0.4371504485607147, 0.02503903955221176, -0.4901873767375946, 0.2805488407611847, -0.3737151026725769, 0.2467924803495407, -0.2502511739730835, 0.22817476093769073, -0.34494829177856445, 0.0899728536605835, -0.31360092759132385, 0.5282979011535645, 0.30870234966278076, -0.5235797762870789, 0.6413154006004333, -0.007659409195184708, -0.46737074851989746, 0.7618884444236755, -0.2730746567249298, 0.04959056153893471, -0.4004627764225006, 0.42976388335227966, -0.7692098617553711, -0.2574426829814911, 0.3425825834274292, -0.20257942378520966, -0.05980134382843971, -0.21771927177906036, -0.39150601625442505, -0.45275717973709106, -0.4918321967124939, 0.8284094929695129, 0.34599220752716064, 0.11292281746864319, 0.6052117347717285, 1.094091773033142, -0.30444803833961487, -0.4157651364803314, -0.6774875521659851, 0.36089596152305603, -0.5268142819404602, -0.48866960406303406, 0.28668540716171265, -0.456783652305603, -0.8109107613563538, -0.42222610116004944, 0.2264932245016098, -0.22644935548305511, 0.22730740904808044, 0.3411538004875183, -0.04159717261791229, -0.038074225187301636, -0.1441500037908554, -0.15702158212661743, 0.4708166718482971, 0.20321330428123474, 0.24866941571235657, 0.7105520963668823, 0.0683281272649765, -0.24692010879516602, -0.5086477398872375, 0.6233948469161987, 0.9326529502868652, -0.1850559264421463, 0.7071529626846313, 0.9327535629272461, -0.3753719627857208, -0.018464477732777596, -0.6661568284034729, -0.39134371280670166, -0.4126124382019043, 0.15273626148700714, 0.257024884223938, -1.3407846689224243, 0.36155688762664795, 0.25898653268814087, 0.23008203506469727, 0.321342408657074, 0.7433275580406189, 0.03032594732940197, 1.0715346336364746, 0.8305792808532715, -0.0018736516358330846, 0.8668080568313599, 0.1718384474515915, 0.348599910736084, -0.5509714484214783, -0.23613294959068298, -0.5443832278251648, -0.31621772050857544, -0.658273458480835, -0.548397421836853, 0.628162682056427, -0.33514395356178284, -0.13331443071365356, -0.18325179815292358, -0.24696886539459229, 0.17743539810180664, 0.44867128133773804, 0.018881892785429955, 0.3736506998538971, -0.09062811732292175, 0.3098866641521454, -0.3167174160480499, -0.3618922531604767, -0.219219371676445, 0.9120321273803711, 0.5864076018333435, 0.5327251553535461, 0.4254912734031677, 0.18304233253002167, 0.913371205329895, 0.4343513250350952, -0.8455163240432739, 0.3955450654029846, 0.06406234204769135, -0.971197247505188, -0.184687077999115, -0.3684711456298828, -0.5043668746948242, 0.07807312905788422, -0.27476614713668823, -0.2888646125793457, -0.07394357025623322, 0.20031137764453888, -0.47748202085494995, 0.6349870562553406, -0.24151611328125, 0.6153447031974792, -0.11163100600242615, -0.48100343346595764, -0.6291086077690125, -0.5799338817596436, 0.5408575534820557, -0.2053845226764679, 0.7831411361694336, -0.2118757665157318, -0.0694885328412056, 0.989311158657074, 0.12030348926782608, 0.9903703927993774, -0.1425032764673233, -0.5484690070152283, 0.3231392204761505, 0.07248365879058838, 0.3031668961048126, -0.3640593886375427, -0.08362871408462524, 0.26343289017677307, -0.1380496323108673, -0.1904706060886383, 0.009534931741654873, 0.7634187936782837, -0.5779489874839783, -0.47519221901893616, -0.281099796295166, -0.5589749217033386, -0.23734720051288605, 0.3067266643047333, 0.02245428040623665, 0.44040539860725403, -0.23359952867031097, 0.5202764272689819, 0.8516382575035095, -0.19484847784042358, 0.47534969449043274, 0.16942551732063293, -0.36145949363708496, -0.47104769945144653, 0.8207612037658691, 0.11977963149547577, 0.2679624557495117, 0.06040602922439575, 0.35807645320892334, -0.25206318497657776, -0.6263378262519836, -0.4074436128139496, 0.1192336156964302, -0.6084594130516052, -0.14691077172756195, -0.8506870269775391, -0.22285710275173187, -0.7151972651481628, -0.3398849368095398, -0.27633875608444214, 0.008433418348431587, -0.0398172065615654, 0.17664538323879242, 0.2972310483455658, 1.053015112876892, -0.22789211571216583, 0.4259870648384094, -0.41688838601112366, 0.40665003657341003, 0.4972671568393707, 0.3226699233055115, -0.013196470215916634, -0.792234480381012, -0.08281028270721436, 0.19578340649604797, -0.28987905383110046, -0.9133917093276978, 0.16261623799800873, -0.12779058516025543, 0.43642085790634155, 0.641737163066864, 0.154202401638031, 0.697654128074646, -0.32405343651771545, 1.0339583158493042, 0.17062079906463623, -0.6383925676345825, 0.3442745506763458, -0.6780555248260498, -0.13504299521446228, 0.2757757008075714, 0.7221449613571167, -0.9763304591178894, -0.5376032590866089, -0.30879175662994385, -0.6288744211196899, 0.5270707011222839, -0.10897386074066162, 0.4937487840652466, 0.10891855508089066, -0.26217973232269287, 0.039741355925798416, 0.4767531156539917, -1.1545894145965576, -0.5596381425857544, -0.09000900387763977, 0.13811010122299194, -0.0810379683971405, -0.713983416557312, -0.5483667254447937, -0.39596420526504517, 0.5493154525756836, 0.18199388682842255, 0.07820067554712296, -0.3195456564426422, 0.04613685607910156, -0.28627943992614746, 0.46921804547309875, 0.8659752011299133, 0.7324351072311401, -0.0099447350949049, 0.32114705443382263, -0.15739154815673828, -0.4230565130710602, -0.09599713236093521, -0.23942911624908447, -0.4939190149307251, -0.16880781948566437, 0.20650772750377655, 0.665637731552124, 0.12486159801483154, -0.7335242033004761, 0.6254586577415466, 0.1194327250123024, -0.16558074951171875, -0.4411212205886841, -0.21548216044902802, -0.21163560450077057, 0.2770785689353943, 0.13429738581180573, 0.0030612857080996037, 0.18184010684490204, -0.7185009717941284, 0.062479712069034576, 0.5409993529319763, -0.5386666059494019, -0.08440256118774414, 0.7077466249465942, 0.25458139181137085, -0.16375456750392914, 0.38708919286727905, -0.11001140624284744, -0.42173537611961365, 0.222609743475914, 0.5078448057174683, 0.6149264574050903, -0.3009333312511444, 0.3113252818584442, 0.1275935173034668, 0.4404161870479584, 0.2783219814300537, 0.022999407723546028, -0.1820283830165863, -0.7423300743103027, -0.21576333045959473, -0.7384968996047974, -0.2786218822002411, 0.47670236229896545, -0.46423041820526123, 0.07607243210077286, -0.7305818796157837, -0.384491503238678, 0.128169447183609, -0.12040971219539642, -0.1603316068649292, -0.14243289828300476, 0.6562381982803345, 0.49203377962112427, -0.8684288859367371, 0.4669950008392334, 0.44623586535453796, -0.28023871779441833, -0.1321534365415573, -0.024798668920993805, 0.6781607866287231, -0.49565139412879944, 0.2965441942214966, 0.06326813250780106, -0.3309057056903839, 0.020086560398340225, -0.557469367980957, -0.5726980566978455, 0.6996303200721741, -0.053625382483005524, -0.2694914937019348, -0.06546812504529953, -0.036587465554475784, 0.5491232872009277, -0.10414490103721619, 0.21974021196365356, 0.30267152190208435, 0.7195698618888855, -0.07101249694824219, -0.952408492565155, -0.18533354997634888, 0.002156391739845276, -0.061266761273145676, 0.21298347413539886, -0.7610654234886169, 1.0043137073516846, 0.1256965696811676, -0.25329989194869995, -0.14333133399486542, 0.5256935358047485, -0.08141102641820908, 0.3583727478981018, 0.5588864684104919, 0.4004729986190796, 0.34654897451400757, 0.06167318671941757, 0.647598147392273, 0.08151635527610779, -0.1723140925168991, 0.8445781469345093, -0.029867997393012047, 0.5550079941749573, 0.529880940914154, -0.08911138772964478, 0.46601516008377075, 0.36594054102897644, -0.02748538739979267, 0.11711299419403076, 0.2979418635368347, -0.7286646962165833, -0.46689826250076294, -0.9683178663253784, -0.33119574189186096, 0.7532394528388977, 0.49320653080940247, -0.3618703782558441, -0.34658434987068176, 0.3745103180408478, 0.3440004289150238, 0.4595152735710144, -0.6274053454399109, 0.6783183217048645, -0.12246420979499817, -0.4784519672393799, -0.011000467464327812, 0.4057411849498749, 1.300443172454834, -0.7365241646766663, 0.12045958638191223, 0.004255101550370455, -0.09225236624479294, -0.1082095205783844, -0.6712715029716492, 0.4008629322052002, 0.0673242062330246, -0.31833982467651367, -0.8667788505554199, 0.5716474652290344, -0.29805660247802734, -0.02200355753302574, 0.44038113951683044, 0.4893876314163208, 0.005029689054936171, -0.19992613792419434, -0.7209641337394714, 0.8246821761131287, -0.04862720146775246, 0.13117341697216034, 0.35292261838912964, 0.07195523381233215, -0.2840419113636017, 0.5988600254058838, 0.5808857083320618, 0.1165768951177597, 0.39242857694625854, 0.15877291560173035, 0.7967844009399414, -0.5972435474395752, -0.32716822624206543, -0.7908421754837036, 0.2551339268684387, -0.10349127650260925, -0.46898508071899414, 0.8821355700492859, 0.46951955556869507, 1.110182285308838, 0.2637847661972046, 0.6342978477478027, -0.3670309782028198, 0.5619690418243408, -0.1893765926361084, 0.9420552849769592, -0.5673978328704834, -0.11908842623233795, -0.3422479033470154, -0.6427213549613953, -0.32527604699134827, 0.35485997796058655, -0.1429845541715622, 0.15092062950134277, 0.16003835201263428, 0.8639098405838013, 0.061447251588106155, 0.06181264668703079, 0.5630781054496765, 0.43078145384788513, 0.6377363801002502, -0.05464669689536095, 1.0619959831237793, -0.11977890878915787, 0.36628180742263794, -0.38016462326049805, -0.30932918190956116, -0.3305707573890686, -0.8056363463401794, -0.6632949709892273, -0.8446943759918213, -0.2245814949274063, -0.29354673624038696, -0.09437992423772812, 1.0077941417694092, 0.6297866702079773, -0.7104522585868835, -0.3076801300048828, 0.418575644493103, 0.2758042812347412, 0.008386054076254368, -0.23770014941692352, -0.38668951392173767, 0.15847286581993103, -0.9699260592460632, 0.5283101201057434, 0.3175278902053833, -0.06117067113518715, -0.6072449088096619, 0.008049671538174152, -0.3065929114818573, 0.0507013238966465, 1.2230757474899292, 0.28070947527885437, -1.0187128782272339, -0.08026988059282303, -0.20733684301376343, -0.26583510637283325, -0.23480930924415588, 1.0786973237991333, -0.37146657705307007, 0.4903227984905243, 0.3941001892089844, 0.6340911984443665, -0.03714936971664429, -0.23038826882839203, 0.33201169967651367, -0.3552701771259308, 0.07678864896297455, 0.7035195827484131, 0.21286098659038544, 0.22154326736927032, 0.11790550500154495, -0.03338373824954033, 0.500571608543396, -0.5557481050491333, -1.094547986984253, 0.5667349100112915, -1.013310432434082, -0.370072603225708, 1.137399435043335, 0.4229210913181305, 0.30365344882011414, -0.41799911856651306, -0.15674762427806854, 0.1662740260362625, -0.29632461071014404, 0.8354697227478027, 0.6984179615974426, -0.1660424768924713, -0.314283162355423, -0.7135269641876221, 0.648999810218811, 0.1683354377746582, -0.7861620783805847, 0.1783374845981598, 1.2359038591384888, -0.09203282743692398, 0.20700491964817047, 0.6407372951507568, -0.2335018366575241, -0.030372561886906624, -0.12630359828472137, -0.21366848051548004, -0.017659518867731094, -0.6009514927864075, -0.40654560923576355, 0.38707900047302246, 0.06546319276094437, 0.41823697090148926 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16713v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16713v1	Prospects for inconsistency detection using large language models and sheaves	2024-01-30T03:17:45	2024-01-30T03:17:45	Steve Huntsman, Michael Robinson, Ludmilla Huntsman	cs.CY	cs.CY, cs.CL, math.AT	We demonstrate that large language models can produce reasonable numerical ratings of the logical consistency of claims. We also outline a mathematical approach based on sheaf theory for lifting such ratings to hypertexts such as laws, jurisprudence, and social media and evaluating their consistency globally. This approach is a promising avenue to increasing consistency in and of government, as well as to combating mis- and disinformation and related ills.	[ -0.1783631145954132, -1.014266014099121, 0.7604895830154419, 0.3756431043148041, 0.13446007668972015, -0.0551227442920208, -0.36551669239997864, -0.7626481652259827, 0.08114561438560486, 0.6592426300048828, 0.06760548800230026, -0.48559263348579407, -0.967373251914978, 0.024931635707616806, -0.7478612661361694, 1.1163914203643799, -0.14913330972194672, -0.05078057944774628, -0.14880631864070892, -0.4388960003852844, -0.34402212500572205, -0.40122920274734497, -0.4561786353588104, -0.36065155267715454, 0.36170804500579834, 0.3258724808692932, 1.0566662549972534, 0.6284692883491516, 0.6782917976379395, 0.35260000824928284, 0.12640078365802765, 0.15838505327701569, 0.03499437868595123, 0.09285721927881241, -0.5586217045783997, -0.3978469669818878, -0.28299546241760254, -0.13552197813987732, 0.9086517691612244, 0.6291464567184448, -0.2786564528942108, -0.025364600121974945, 0.018141871318221092, 0.6246438026428223, -0.7271037101745605, 0.2397332489490509, -0.873164176940918, -0.022855697199702263, -0.2739751935005188, -0.13532595336437225, -0.3896446228027344, -0.698053777217865, 0.2972961962223053, -0.592504620552063, 0.1854926198720932, 0.21835774183273315, 1.082077980041504, -0.05825750529766083, -0.6688034534454346, -0.5510600805282593, -0.8994103074073792, 0.8664281368255615, -0.8344461917877197, 0.5184326171875, 0.770879864692688, 0.3269098103046417, -0.33030909299850464, -0.4137841463088989, -0.7776992321014404, -0.6123419404029846, -0.13367541134357452, -0.07126566767692566, -0.23194128274917603, 0.04279199615120888, 0.7177441120147705, 0.3165518343448639, -0.5839319229125977, -0.0010111503070220351, -0.005397699773311615, -0.5221105217933655, 0.6984262466430664, -0.14590398967266083, 0.5404561758041382, -0.3219658434391022, -0.2153453230857849, 0.03438933193683624, -0.9363515377044678, -0.08730293810367584, 0.8032978177070618, -0.05489058420062065, -0.32466813921928406, 0.7351751327514648, -0.25793975591659546, 0.557003378868103, -0.0019906857050955296, -0.4625011384487152, -0.08720114827156067, -0.11557610332965851, -0.2831193208694458, 0.1367442011833191, 0.49810197949409485, 0.1895712912082672, 0.33461421728134155, 0.15514494478702545, -0.31971031427383423, 0.24583923816680908, 0.1618475764989853, -0.4287204444408417, -0.34184518456459045, 0.22207283973693848, -0.42910417914390564, -0.206282377243042, 0.4031452238559723, -0.5519327521324158, -0.7550336718559265, -0.5679528117179871, 0.4096776247024536, -0.39511457085609436, -0.6826674342155457, 0.3340458869934082, -0.022590523585677147, -0.05342978239059448, 0.5316414833068848, -0.8835948705673218, 0.32704171538352966, 0.8212328553199768, 0.4694058895111084, 0.3945485055446625, -0.14308767020702362, -0.40557295083999634, 0.12125838547945023, -0.5599389672279358, 0.8352271318435669, -0.5017949342727661, 0.08945974707603455, 0.41561028361320496, 0.1382005661725998, 0.11565127968788147, -0.6940239071846008, 0.8061422109603882, -0.307831734418869, -0.10890675336122513, -0.15508180856704712, -0.7436950206756592, -0.1814539134502411, 0.6067674160003662, -0.8789545297622681, 0.8310032486915588, 0.30138111114501953, -0.8611624836921692, 0.5749813914299011, -0.5502965450286865, -0.4046030342578888, -0.05649841949343681, -0.18909990787506104, -0.5428981781005859, 0.21297675371170044, -0.2681034207344055, 0.1517246663570404, -0.3555446267127991, 0.718762993812561, -0.3558201193809509, 0.036776501685380936, 0.5104246735572815, -0.4734300374984741, 0.7331604361534119, 0.33200934529304504, -0.5167513489723206, 0.04589758813381195, -0.790353000164032, -0.01184985414147377, -0.08612186461687088, -0.503038763999939, -0.6223275661468506, 0.27254951000213623, 0.19180265069007874, -0.0006567286909557879, 0.10235939174890518, -0.6724344491958618, 0.30042365193367004, -0.2583215832710266, 0.36022016406059265, 0.5748577117919922, -0.2698328495025635, 0.16778698563575745, -0.4855574071407318, 0.03208411857485771, 0.2828383445739746, -0.07167533040046692, -0.09963735938072205, -0.3580431044101715, -0.9369641542434692, 0.16209100186824799, 0.5647819638252258, 0.4435541033744812, -0.7117716073989868, 0.6053928732872009, -0.393635094165802, -0.15500880777835846, -0.13505782186985016, 0.02417055517435074, 0.397372305393219, 0.3058684468269348, 0.16636721789836884, 0.22160440683364868, -0.8458463549613953, -0.9212427139282227, -0.6417059302330017, -0.5784880518913269, 0.09953664988279343, -0.1679561734199524, 0.7838560938835144, -0.1325400471687317, 0.9370089173316956, -0.06764286756515503, 0.039116282016038895, 0.012679827399551868, 0.3536338806152344, 0.006700723897665739, 0.7720495462417603, 0.4954798221588135, -1.1836433410644531, -0.38994163274765015, 0.40786033868789673, -0.9639910459518433, 0.06338062882423401, 0.27399319410324097, 0.1981947273015976, 0.4849734902381897, 0.34899380803108215, -0.5647538900375366, 0.5422629714012146, 0.5052712559700012, -0.33870184421539307, 0.6915493011474609, -0.2778082489967346, 0.5428244471549988, -0.8999019861221313, -0.027193721383810043, 0.5929698348045349, -0.5264042615890503, -0.6357973217964172, -0.11632978171110153, 0.3609163165092468, 0.32701757550239563, -0.24747078120708466, 0.5680431127548218, -0.3511383533477783, 0.028941413387656212, -0.2739347219467163, -0.04459987208247185, -0.009037002921104431, -0.23757143318653107, -0.19843199849128723, 0.42867153882980347, 0.5336049795150757, -0.6240095496177673, 0.2989383637905121, -0.027107911184430122, -0.6842794418334961, 1.1311380863189697, -0.48159295320510864, -0.33528730273246765, -0.20094452798366547, 0.34474197030067444, -0.9964967966079712, -0.7438213229179382, 0.125525563955307, -0.28164181113243103, 0.21866381168365479, -0.3993315100669861, -0.5788697600364685, -0.5561932325363159, -0.18913796544075012, 0.3362191915512085, 0.37753814458847046, -0.6696630120277405, 0.5781036019325256, 0.6806725263595581, 0.08839418739080429, -0.6521796584129333, -0.5770609974861145, 0.09477367997169495, -0.3493098020553589, -0.7516366243362427, 0.03981872648000717, 0.12929420173168182, -0.7345987558364868, 0.12656578421592712, -0.2781483232975006, -0.2144092321395874, 0.004038060083985329, 0.09020446240901947, 0.01953013613820076, -0.38048791885375977, 0.24161754548549652, -0.30097702145576477, 0.21438810229301453, 0.22804562747478485, -0.8780189752578735, 0.27898508310317993, -0.16308705508708954, -0.4927530586719513, -0.33584243059158325, 0.3432353436946869, 0.6383169889450073, 0.11350639909505844, 0.46270647644996643, 0.29572877287864685, -0.9914872050285339, -0.11217086017131805, -1.0514750480651855, 0.13756904006004333, -0.3977373242378235, 0.06060502678155899, -0.32252445816993713, -0.9284459948539734, 0.6238811612129211, -0.17572157084941864, -0.18317122757434845, 0.8288692235946655, 0.30321940779685974, 0.2037009745836258, 1.1264783143997192, 0.8865785002708435, 0.1379358321428299, 0.356847882270813, -0.08716729283332825, 0.3697608709335327, -0.5833219289779663, -0.2602981626987457, -0.9476600289344788, 0.07663456350564957, -0.7914742827415466, 0.07110495120286942, 0.1931220293045044, 0.4498634338378906, -0.3059450685977936, 0.572873055934906, -0.20780892670154572, 0.8101702332496643, 0.2213120460510254, -0.14667731523513794, 0.46584802865982056, 0.194033682346344, -0.1080206036567688, 0.04087607562541962, -0.4649236798286438, -0.7489511966705322, 0.9180710315704346, 0.42098599672317505, 0.9465773105621338, 0.27684739232063293, 0.35254615545272827, 0.6432944536209106, 0.6352182030677795, -0.59224534034729, 0.18182815611362457, -0.13121852278709412, -0.6751047372817993, -0.3547042906284332, -0.6528984904289246, -0.8950430154800415, 0.041488297283649445, -0.4884141683578491, -1.1596680879592896, 0.066044382750988, 0.18289627134799957, -0.04927050322294235, 0.5417406558990479, -0.450656920671463, 0.6892588138580322, -0.0543128065764904, -0.2363732010126114, -0.3248763084411621, -0.3234001398086548, 0.6946492791175842, -0.09707262367010117, 0.23139184713363647, -0.3450106978416443, 0.44604507088661194, 0.6918200254440308, -0.5009385943412781, 0.5145127773284912, -0.0939396396279335, -0.604478120803833, 0.5859025120735168, 0.12647584080696106, 0.6919357180595398, 0.2330171912908554, -0.07392658293247223, 0.13510280847549438, 0.08747389167547226, -0.482084721326828, -0.6573334336280823, 0.7636038064956665, -0.6091213822364807, -0.5920930504798889, -0.5378254652023315, -0.6422504186630249, -0.08018367737531662, 0.0898999497294426, 0.2896323502063751, 0.5689967274665833, -0.25777214765548706, 0.2265690565109253, 0.9719504117965698, 0.018284637480974197, 0.2679958641529083, 0.716962993144989, -0.3166619539260864, -0.4129842221736908, 0.8079987168312073, 0.519469141960144, 0.0997532308101654, 0.22231604158878326, 0.23744893074035645, -0.5675098299980164, -0.5170778632164001, -0.5241443514823914, 0.13389793038368225, -0.7372372150421143, -0.4307102560997009, -0.7280225157737732, -0.31924301385879517, -0.4100177586078644, 0.1604509800672531, -0.18579785525798798, -0.38051679730415344, 0.4382069408893585, 0.07409115135669708, 0.510444164276123, 1.3229775428771973, -0.07706893235445023, 0.23855534195899963, -0.7820203304290771, 0.17021022737026215, -0.1022256538271904, 0.5109379291534424, -0.13615426421165466, -0.5245223641395569, -0.25452908873558044, 0.34798121452331543, -0.20750856399536133, -0.495482861995697, -0.1491829752922058, -0.12080472707748413, 0.45696812868118286, 0.5501160621643066, -0.05026032775640488, 0.6030490398406982, -0.4231290817260742, 0.4928857088088989, 0.5505823493003845, -1.3923015594482422, 0.5905381441116333, -0.6143677830696106, -0.15937204658985138, 0.1987377554178238, 0.5354753136634827, -0.7258142232894897, -0.5492929220199585, -0.9638603925704956, -0.43300941586494446, 0.42057809233665466, 0.09904088079929352, 0.05008146911859512, -0.16573752462863922, 0.30600860714912415, 0.017518257722258568, 0.07659927755594254, -0.5705279111862183, 0.13591979444026947, 0.016571693122386932, -0.32751351594924927, 0.41185107827186584, -0.3419296443462372, -0.48483601212501526, -0.08958473056554794, 0.5215465426445007, -0.25588348507881165, -0.13085563480854034, 0.3864613175392151, -0.08694329857826233, -0.4021245837211609, 0.37693095207214355, 0.9488268494606018, 1.2820416688919067, 0.2268998771905899, 0.5498226881027222, 0.12922291457653046, -0.5828784704208374, 0.5051719546318054, -0.09004776179790497, -0.16122160851955414, 0.04341895505785942, 0.34942376613616943, 0.36251673102378845, 0.2545761168003082, -0.4695235788822174, 0.5060808062553406, 0.1974327713251114, -0.36001309752464294, -0.4972727596759796, -0.15665782988071442, -0.01681935042142868, 0.10040005296468735, 0.3697631061077118, 0.36871257424354553, 0.0612177699804306, -0.8333198428153992, 0.5134172439575195, 0.5190242528915405, -0.17539533972740173, -0.26440170407295227, 0.4711650311946869, -0.09200287610292435, -0.28463026881217957, 0.21881546080112457, -0.02690410055220127, -0.6033744812011719, 0.9436683058738708, 0.7648724317550659, 0.5340797901153564, -0.3067125082015991, 0.36884039640426636, 0.17881189286708832, 0.40989068150520325, -0.9816147685050964, 0.018287820741534233, 0.36386775970458984, -0.8053303360939026, -0.43822863698005676, -0.5476589798927307, -0.4747597575187683, 0.24551159143447876, -0.40375760197639465, 0.257272869348526, -0.6152540445327759, -0.18345148861408234, 0.4010583460330963, 0.004344697576016188, -0.31975048780441284, 0.302542507648468, 0.01576959528028965, 0.7860127091407776, -0.8653872609138489, 1.0437018871307373, 0.6736566424369812, -0.5139071941375732, -0.9548782706260681, 0.24108228087425232, 0.26720741391181946, -0.5192981958389282, 0.6394037008285522, 0.20801973342895508, -0.1923767477273941, -0.4324338436126709, -0.8739992380142212, -1.0195300579071045, 0.5320490598678589, 0.6700431108474731, -0.5777462124824524, 0.39764684438705444, 0.2550216317176819, 0.40069976449012756, -0.42701640725135803, 0.12080605328083038, 0.6951322555541992, 0.8395501971244812, -0.15987204015254974, -1.2127374410629272, 0.054126471281051636, -0.10035645216703415, 0.09145453572273254, 0.5988093614578247, -0.38725176453590393, 1.1082957983016968, 0.02491498738527298, -0.35683295130729675, 0.2288636565208435, 0.7551543712615967, 0.07895643264055252, 0.4993393123149872, 0.6045956015586853, 0.6520124673843384, 1.1289739608764648, -0.5009037256240845, 1.0857185125350952, -0.25944826006889343, 0.7681390047073364, 0.661643385887146, -0.5658977031707764, 0.5887520909309387, 0.09373895078897476, -0.17516712844371796, 0.5985780954360962, 0.306237131357193, 0.06980699300765991, -0.03892907127737999, 0.4523698389530182, -0.36368775367736816, -0.2069469541311264, -0.3340110778808594, -0.42520761489868164, 0.3497028648853302, 0.4765496551990509, -0.09142214804887772, -0.5073447823524475, 0.13220959901809692, 0.05382595956325531, 0.3787633180618286, -0.3922623097896576, 0.521876335144043, -0.0864754319190979, -0.9047887921333313, 0.6245492100715637, 0.2083044946193695, 0.5387575030326843, -0.6280376315116882, -0.49143072962760925, 0.12256384640932083, 0.4305075705051422, -0.6152582764625549, -1.123225450515747, 0.5284972786903381, 0.04800606891512871, -0.20651447772979736, 0.1253535896539688, 1.0712594985961914, -0.5604522228240967, -0.3939877450466156, 0.3017633855342865, 0.30535170435905457, 0.12307111918926239, 0.11713562160730362, -0.6248946189880371, 0.3208801746368408, -0.23376604914665222, 0.16540485620498657, 0.1943250596523285, 0.7533018589019775, -0.49144840240478516, 0.6248524785041809, 0.7559285163879395, -0.04849465563893318, -0.10560393333435059, 0.08123564720153809, 0.5277513265609741, -0.5969592332839966, -0.2218376249074936, -0.8821352124214172, 0.3727160394191742, -0.4142356216907501, -0.28014707565307617, 1.0255036354064941, 0.561088502407074, 0.9817484021186829, 0.08970381319522858, 0.9221354722976685, -0.2156449854373932, 0.2798220217227936, -0.8785900473594666, 0.6422200202941895, -0.2130943387746811, 0.16330085694789886, -0.35211941599845886, -1.182081699371338, -0.466064989566803, 0.7637020349502563, -0.35912856459617615, -0.10038846731185913, 0.8785392045974731, 0.6132095456123352, -0.28136569261550903, 0.28641968965530396, 0.42362409830093384, 0.24472124874591827, 0.27794644236564636, 0.14029332995414734, 1.0931795835494995, -0.4710007905960083, 0.29791179299354553, 0.241038516163826, -0.05696446821093559, -0.17401546239852905, -0.9535527229309082, -0.6321820616722107, -0.4232383072376251, -0.4505196511745453, -1.0877271890640259, 0.10248983651399612, 0.8767024278640747, 0.7644458413124084, -1.158812403678894, -0.3664276599884033, -0.3960294723510742, 0.48150861263275146, 0.01402183435857296, -0.2465045303106308, 0.18696855008602142, -0.2805491089820862, -0.6158525347709656, -0.028861697763204575, 0.4690517485141754, 0.11842130124568939, -0.42996442317962646, 0.0889272689819336, -0.3305470049381256, 0.3887748420238495, 0.6113744974136353, 0.5118452310562134, -0.9500681161880493, -0.8599362373352051, -0.5087820291519165, -0.36646541953086853, 0.12645092606544495, 1.0255919694900513, -0.3518822491168976, 0.018432119861245155, 0.5062201619148254, 0.7074254155158997, 0.0714489221572876, 0.09881605952978134, 0.4355660676956177, -0.3137006461620331, 0.08445224910974503, -0.03719925507903099, 0.5625560879707336, 0.47801676392555237, -0.3430633544921875, 0.5739012360572815, 0.2169923633337021, -0.5954418182373047, -0.6452433466911316, 0.5473628640174866, -0.8150978684425354, 0.00827755406498909, 0.9242677092552185, -0.36969271302223206, -0.35714879631996155, -0.46909308433532715, 0.022347716614603996, -0.19936951994895935, -0.24530383944511414, 0.8621238470077515, 1.2787864208221436, 0.22522446513175964, 0.27546679973602295, -0.7596435546875, 0.5714742541313171, 0.36385679244995117, -1.0007059574127197, 0.11651527136564255, 0.5713273286819458, 0.5788297653198242, 0.6640473008155823, 0.5459471344947815, -0.2184741199016571, 0.22052063047885895, 0.1293487399816513, -0.47685086727142334, 0.606959342956543, -0.5783733129501343, -0.24577786028385162, -0.00748533196747303, 0.012136446312069893, 0.5298797488212585 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16678v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16678v1	The Detection and Understanding of Fictional Discourse	2024-01-30T01:57:17	2024-01-30T01:57:17	Andrew Piper, Haiqi Zhou	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.LG	In this paper, we present a variety of classification experiments related to the task of fictional discourse detection. We utilize a diverse array of datasets, including contemporary professionally published fiction, historical fiction from the Hathi Trust, fanfiction, stories from Reddit, folk tales, GPT-generated stories, and anglophone world literature. Additionally, we introduce a new feature set of word "supersenses" that facilitate the goal of semantic generalization. The detection of fictional discourse can help enrich our knowledge of large cultural heritage archives and assist with the process of understanding the distinctive qualities of fictional storytelling more broadly.	[ -0.6142845749855042, -0.8605135083198547, 0.6095411777496338, -0.30749157071113586, -0.13205400109291077, 0.32085680961608887, -0.23826974630355835, -0.5546160936355591, 0.526093602180481, 0.5472407341003418, -0.4601189196109772, -0.16622543334960938, -0.4557020664215088, 0.13139434158802032, -0.5211365818977356, 0.9753185510635376, 0.03049718402326107, -0.08926539123058319, -0.5157838463783264, -0.07594116032123566, -0.12052450329065323, -0.42199772596359253, -0.006029513198882341, -0.04158880561590195, 0.6468442678451538, 0.16900734603405, 0.8530424237251282, 0.3376476764678955, 0.24723033607006073, 0.33790889382362366, -0.11034763604402542, 0.6639233827590942, -0.45385876297950745, 0.2697124481201172, -0.5702195763587952, -0.7987737655639648, 0.2097475230693817, 0.17220747470855713, 0.6374994516372681, 0.17544832825660706, 0.2164783626794815, 0.4200716018676758, -0.16088952124118805, 0.0244252048432827, -0.5783419013023376, 0.1963110864162445, -0.46301236748695374, 0.15839719772338867, -0.6593489050865173, -0.35062095522880554, -0.3925699293613434, -0.6023351550102234, -0.03992585465312004, -0.739100456237793, 0.6979050040245056, 0.5696318745613098, 1.0600090026855469, -0.28650376200675964, -0.4265037477016449, -0.18299372494220734, -0.8519166111946106, 0.7239006757736206, -0.0935525894165039, 0.29341059923171997, 0.41187459230422974, 0.5060976147651672, 0.11132729053497314, -0.5714526176452637, -0.947325587272644, -0.37220028042793274, -0.45165303349494934, 0.205642431974411, -0.4880351126194, -0.2330721616744995, 0.11551506072282791, 0.7358200550079346, -0.8500919342041016, -0.2043229043483734, -0.24859635531902313, -0.7091178297996521, 0.27835091948509216, 0.2830534875392914, 0.6851609349250793, -0.5392396450042725, 0.048776861280202866, 0.12384352087974548, -0.5377258062362671, -0.4588089883327484, 0.4647698998451233, -0.11191219091415405, 0.225751131772995, 0.18086637556552887, -0.06462009251117706, 0.32498517632484436, -0.28937026858329773, -0.22794273495674133, 0.08083855360746384, -0.4688739776611328, 0.06572975963354111, -0.0760587751865387, 0.6028071641921997, 0.27629488706588745, 0.7450228333473206, -0.24069960415363312, 0.201272115111351, 0.48505133390426636, 0.08314505964517593, -0.40373706817626953, -0.02760165184736252, -0.37972187995910645, -0.5530656576156616, -0.4117441773414612, -0.15096567571163177, -0.3080103397369385, -0.7021623849868774, -0.3978661894798279, 0.029545024037361145, -0.606232762336731, -0.6680816411972046, 0.16463986039161682, -0.6488522291183472, 0.3274666666984558, 0.3934420347213745, -0.853155255317688, 0.37421566247940063, 0.8321892023086548, 0.7164729833602905, -0.08826550841331482, -0.22458642721176147, 0.015252404846251011, 0.4831489026546478, -0.4884270131587982, 1.3580740690231323, -0.7100018858909607, -0.352739542722702, -0.03099798411130905, 0.05894238129258156, 0.0019017804879695177, -0.5063955783843994, 0.7946949005126953, -0.5641235113143921, 0.5548208355903625, -0.3315180838108063, -0.7110359072685242, -0.40092068910598755, 0.43264275789260864, -0.39141035079956055, 0.4908747375011444, 0.0677635669708252, -1.0090922117233276, 0.1987609565258026, -0.25844061374664307, -0.239236980676651, 0.22220014035701752, -0.2872602641582489, 0.11574025452136993, 0.2820720374584198, 0.1817973554134369, 0.3130444884300232, -0.7151164412498474, 0.5811308026313782, -0.02450309880077839, -0.4526977837085724, 0.2648483216762543, -0.5502329468727112, 0.5283713936805725, 0.3368825912475586, -0.08247147500514984, -0.2307511419057846, -0.37275055050849915, -0.39754122495651245, 0.204473614692688, 0.41153791546821594, -0.5713270902633667, -0.1727675199508667, 0.2758549153804779, -0.46829745173454285, 0.05536537989974022, -0.8327210545539856, 0.15735718607902527, -0.301914244890213, -0.033189646899700165, 0.28775790333747864, 0.40852460265159607, -0.06324347108602524, -0.5265568494796753, 0.7663483619689941, -0.22596848011016846, -0.06607570499181747, -0.3488272726535797, -0.5948090553283691, -0.7098955512046814, 0.003734361845999956, 0.5367926359176636, 0.8394447565078735, -0.873893678188324, 0.4591747522354126, -0.2905125319957733, -0.594237744808197, -0.30649682879447937, -0.5653948187828064, 0.47349417209625244, 0.4720061123371124, 0.30038076639175415, 0.36560046672821045, -0.561045229434967, -1.260003924369812, -0.47816506028175354, -0.5240374803543091, -0.3727600872516632, 0.20700745284557343, 0.32718226313591003, -0.12619581818580627, 0.9147995114326477, -0.9289340972900391, -0.2883126437664032, -0.13899849355220795, 0.5186450481414795, -0.082908034324646, 0.13925789296627045, 0.7933127284049988, -0.9419959783554077, -0.3836226165294647, 0.4169623851776123, -0.9571776986122131, -0.05278840661048889, -0.13566532731056213, -0.045815225690603256, -0.2881307303905487, 0.5835543274879456, -0.40665799379348755, 0.28984493017196655, -0.09096004068851471, -0.2657849192619324, 0.7862720489501953, 0.16845647990703583, 0.7227922081947327, -0.8717755079269409, -0.21526551246643066, -0.07484825700521469, -0.4784868657588959, -0.45073384046554565, -0.02593677118420601, -0.028694018721580505, 0.1782945841550827, -0.3434934914112091, 0.31240832805633545, -0.23013758659362793, 0.24721848964691162, -0.2297610193490982, 0.10199359059333801, 0.1749948412179947, 0.09756890684366226, 0.3159111738204956, 0.6355851292610168, 0.389358252286911, -0.19211098551750183, 0.3348708152770996, 0.24678680300712585, -0.35129836201667786, 0.8060746788978577, -0.1401716023683548, 0.07606486976146698, -0.2623971998691559, 0.41418591141700745, -1.1588083505630493, -0.5938891172409058, 0.2356913983821869, -0.5058401823043823, 0.2583273947238922, -0.03343651816248894, -0.8765051960945129, -0.35233086347579956, -0.3026909828186035, 0.11622485518455505, 0.2515936493873596, -0.3172564208507538, 0.5282793641090393, 0.6407188177108765, -0.08607770502567291, -0.1915627270936966, -0.7685122489929199, 0.2027682512998581, -0.4542856514453888, -0.4921601116657257, 0.12101785093545914, 0.10122071951627731, -0.20176033675670624, 0.06949852406978607, 0.24886834621429443, -0.27929678559303284, -0.1596686691045761, -0.05558685585856438, 0.2230350226163864, -0.5144963264465332, 0.17943772673606873, 0.5875157117843628, -0.002036650199443102, -0.007052331697195768, -0.09197816252708435, 0.4073508381843567, -0.30783811211586, -0.08540887385606766, -0.6260969638824463, 0.37262746691703796, 0.560327410697937, 0.21288278698921204, 0.6540865302085876, 0.6953729391098022, -0.4404941499233246, 0.07086601853370667, -0.7422982454299927, 0.048890307545661926, -0.4602682292461395, -0.07793205231428146, -0.47755423188209534, -1.1383140087127686, 0.473248153924942, -0.15606005489826202, -0.21195119619369507, 0.7915191650390625, 0.3568033277988434, -0.06132848933339119, 0.4626455307006836, 0.08975520730018616, -0.016686776652932167, -0.023286178708076477, -0.0691099688410759, 0.16596612334251404, -0.5450343489646912, 0.08837857097387314, -0.5606350302696228, -0.18948307633399963, -0.40153616666793823, -0.4730677604675293, 0.24586762487888336, -0.3184707760810852, 0.01869095303118229, 0.6046426296234131, -0.485352486371994, 1.1817198991775513, 0.13367047905921936, -0.21955165266990662, 0.7646205425262451, 0.005006409715861082, -0.16970352828502655, -0.3614135980606079, -0.2966013550758362, -0.7745477557182312, 0.7904594540596008, 0.4254477024078369, 0.48880091309547424, 0.06745187193155289, 0.41250815987586975, 0.7943584322929382, 0.45136168599128723, -0.5564031004905701, 0.5397112369537354, -0.24101917445659637, -0.7785879373550415, -0.017701227217912674, -0.28391724824905396, -0.9239119291305542, 0.4353252649307251, -0.006359335966408253, -0.8439542651176453, 0.5373310446739197, 0.006866308860480785, -0.4365161657333374, 0.43095862865448, -0.570117175579071, 0.5611393451690674, 0.20628948509693146, 0.08989299833774567, -0.506492018699646, -0.46762537956237793, 0.7587347030639648, -0.045443564653396606, 0.3414926826953888, -0.12725362181663513, 0.010515619069337845, 0.6325327754020691, 0.3699627220630646, 0.6655503511428833, 0.09103022515773773, -0.0902334526181221, 0.5398604273796082, 0.5544782280921936, -0.16273732483386993, 0.13909851014614105, 0.22080430388450623, 0.29861682653427124, 0.22480610013008118, -0.04201161861419678, -0.5196549296379089, 0.5589599609375, -0.5599337220191956, -0.6593037843704224, -0.5250850915908813, -0.523510754108429, -0.44077324867248535, 0.0019290820928290486, 0.5159143805503845, 0.4187304377555847, -0.7805207371711731, 0.14196981489658356, 0.7554349303245544, -0.1709667146205902, 0.07114187628030777, 0.5023200511932373, -0.5548461675643921, -0.21523694694042206, 1.14418363571167, 0.28085699677467346, -0.07081581652164459, 0.5565661191940308, 0.5382779240608215, -0.3866080343723297, -0.5972322225570679, -0.3177972733974457, 0.3687874376773834, -0.5469533801078796, -0.2936387062072754, -0.7925699353218079, -0.3831198215484619, -0.5276641845703125, -0.10053593665361404, -0.057365577667951584, -0.5758458375930786, -0.37514448165893555, -0.3854221701622009, 0.29250332713127136, 0.7890598773956299, -0.07528489828109741, 0.3690258264541626, -0.6862486004829407, 0.6693116426467896, 0.1454000324010849, -0.12124715000391006, -0.07529991120100021, -0.6299508213996887, -0.004753168672323227, -0.29225096106529236, -0.28709715604782104, -0.6346372365951538, 0.13599209487438202, 0.13187752664089203, 0.5126285552978516, 0.6472797393798828, 0.09569103270769119, 0.3433682322502136, -0.6886149644851685, 0.8681885004043579, 0.06662233173847198, -0.8227604627609253, 0.6585187315940857, -1.005074143409729, 0.15352460741996765, 0.5422385334968567, 0.9120559096336365, -0.8347529768943787, -0.7724849581718445, -0.8615220189094543, -0.21607422828674316, 0.5214563012123108, 0.28727829456329346, 0.3831450045108795, -0.393870085477829, 0.22068648040294647, 0.45500338077545166, 0.1816364973783493, -0.5111624002456665, -0.09385388344526291, 0.008812587708234787, 0.09624599665403366, 0.1147778257727623, -0.31145527958869934, -0.2661876380443573, -0.315402090549469, 0.43573373556137085, -0.019213315099477768, 0.24982856214046478, 0.13421688973903656, -0.39828601479530334, 0.09834092855453491, 0.12781637907028198, 0.44529804587364197, 0.7827749848365784, -0.06101952865719795, 0.17870482802391052, 0.060763001441955566, -0.6119250655174255, 0.029574554413557053, -0.2335604429244995, -0.1976327747106552, 0.1745845228433609, 0.7835254669189453, 0.70325767993927, 0.2092474400997162, -0.31115031242370605, 0.3952883183956146, -0.37480396032333374, -0.2771056592464447, -0.3366485834121704, 0.4964115619659424, 0.2088293433189392, 0.23063018918037415, 0.3238111436367035, 0.2059311866760254, 0.6847466826438904, -0.74472975730896, 0.47913116216659546, 0.17361731827259064, 0.034713178873062134, -0.3067795932292938, 0.38297221064567566, 0.030774874612689018, -0.20822025835514069, 0.12506145238876343, -0.48868855834007263, -0.5655457377433777, 0.38885995745658875, 0.5615212321281433, 0.849014937877655, -0.2979758679866791, 0.8564252257347107, 0.13126005232334137, 0.29007792472839355, 0.16133153438568115, -0.04452598839998245, -0.006688341032713652, -1.1004509925842285, -0.1632416844367981, -0.6835941672325134, -0.619798481464386, 0.2579018771648407, -0.6164161562919617, 0.1347319483757019, -0.31234365701675415, 0.16839812695980072, 0.45293745398521423, -0.3665788471698761, -0.2585867643356323, -0.10922142118215561, 0.6070990562438965, 0.7813518643379211, -1.0486162900924683, 0.6473711729049683, 0.21738247573375702, -0.1504572182893753, -0.1478801667690277, 0.48134851455688477, 0.37432241439819336, -0.2877661883831024, 0.48746076226234436, 0.039206501096487045, -0.35242602229118347, -0.043714579194784164, -0.3161880671977997, -0.8337411284446716, 0.6038404703140259, 0.6646262407302856, -0.3994588851928711, 0.10755321383476257, 0.1543956995010376, 0.8400346636772156, -0.3788003921508789, 0.42635688185691833, 0.9368778467178345, 0.619147777557373, -0.08033951371908188, -0.9499377012252808, -0.20607388019561768, -0.040564633905887604, -0.057092588394880295, 0.05528800189495087, -0.740105152130127, 0.38509583473205566, 0.5465960502624512, -0.36052486300468445, 0.04897226393222809, 1.0788918733596802, 0.16699331998825073, 0.3332972228527069, 0.5422099828720093, 0.23843778669834137, 1.028516411781311, -0.19696973264217377, 1.1659685373306274, 0.27412837743759155, 0.3555884063243866, 0.9257936477661133, -0.1152130588889122, 0.337037593126297, -0.22327256202697754, -0.42886441946029663, 0.7968885898590088, 0.8151099681854248, -0.012464156374335289, 0.2339686006307602, 0.265287309885025, -0.5004600882530212, -0.2786465883255005, -0.5794880986213684, -0.5893354415893555, 0.6368743777275085, 0.609497606754303, 0.045221228152513504, -0.4011698067188263, 0.5592790246009827, 0.15132957696914673, 0.3600107729434967, -0.3633737564086914, 0.5818244218826294, 0.02425660751760006, -0.533007800579071, 0.4522677958011627, -0.3847965896129608, 0.6568877100944519, -0.57533198595047, 0.08429881930351257, -0.10638754814863205, -0.13952717185020447, 0.02885226346552372, -0.825619637966156, 0.6082559823989868, -0.18995369970798492, -0.360725462436676, -0.18387196958065033, 1.169840931892395, -0.16530141234397888, -0.5400259494781494, 0.2537926435470581, 0.5345398187637329, 0.3034219741821289, -0.12089809030294418, -0.3527137041091919, -0.15372750163078308, -0.07645883411169052, -0.186914324760437, 0.2940433621406555, 0.6845880746841431, -0.2493722289800644, 0.1547829955816269, 0.441331684589386, -0.15495210886001587, -0.3487972319126129, 0.1176208034157753, 0.8105220794677734, -0.6704580783843994, -0.7788506746292114, -0.693886399269104, -0.08425933122634888, -0.38676509261131287, -0.49171602725982666, 0.8921717405319214, 0.7090057730674744, 0.616395115852356, -0.3315686881542206, 0.7838007211685181, 0.1268855780363083, 0.9229758977890015, -0.3190762400627136, 0.8395999073982239, -0.24278578162193298, -0.08458830416202545, -0.33708009123802185, -0.6946367621421814, -0.3532337546348572, 0.43289342522621155, -0.3506462275981903, -0.6006126403808594, 0.9421518445014954, 0.47413384914398193, -0.24177460372447968, 0.8287554979324341, 0.47766539454460144, 0.027299225330352783, -0.02846149168908596, -0.0583256259560585, 1.3697363138198853, -0.10875695943832397, 0.22076396644115448, 0.09673106670379639, -0.298467218875885, 0.17588847875595093, -0.6868115067481995, -0.805679440498352, -0.5580139756202698, -0.4349845349788666, -0.07961548119783401, -0.09415540844202042, 0.25818026065826416, 0.48148465156555176, -1.0352753400802612, -0.16340371966362, 0.06408631801605225, 0.20710481703281403, 0.09787303954362869, -0.3268238604068756, 0.17259550094604492, -0.32004737854003906, -0.7249312400817871, 0.6152447462081909, 0.39370882511138916, -0.16696391999721527, -0.35610875487327576, 0.5103656053543091, -0.4388403594493866, 0.4490496516227722, 0.4513012766838074, 0.19639870524406433, -0.7098321914672852, -0.6320368647575378, -0.16735310852527618, 0.35603901743888855, -0.014255405403673649, 1.3664469718933105, -0.7240395545959473, 0.16842158138751984, 0.5475085377693176, 0.6467817425727844, 0.5278365015983582, -0.07344244420528412, 0.4763900637626648, -0.7161830067634583, 0.11428548395633698, 0.42485833168029785, 0.4272155165672302, 0.06182541698217392, -0.872524082660675, 0.6412999033927917, 0.8103082776069641, -0.5789955854415894, -0.754132866859436, 0.18337301909923553, -0.7357251644134521, -0.6109321117401123, 0.9111250638961792, -0.11861325800418854, -0.2261553406715393, -0.6612180471420288, -0.4094550609588623, 0.06673064082860947, 0.0072244638577103615, 0.33587661385536194, 1.1251883506774902, -0.36841294169425964, -0.011577343568205833, -0.6422960758209229, 0.44810929894447327, -0.012516157701611519, -0.8243151903152466, 0.24941809475421906, 0.6951459050178528, 0.08507852256298065, 0.7961470484733582, 0.5835188627243042, -0.07941368967294693, 0.27453896403312683, -0.03658144548535347, -0.4224851727485657, 0.20173808932304382, -0.45921504497528076, 0.17590273916721344, 0.5804967284202576, -0.5843640565872192, -0.07192990183830261 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16659v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16659v3	History-Aware Conversational Dense Retrieval	2024-01-30T01:24:18	2024-05-28T13:18:29	Fengran Mo, Chen Qu, Kelong Mao, Tianyu Zhu, Zhan Su, Kaiyu Huang, Jian-Yun Nie	cs.IR	cs.IR, cs.CL	Conversational search facilitates complex information retrieval by enabling multi-turn interactions between users and the system. Supporting such interactions requires a comprehensive understanding of the conversational inputs to formulate a good search query based on historical information. In particular, the search query should include the relevant information from the previous conversation turns. However, current approaches for conversational dense retrieval primarily rely on fine-tuning a pre-trained ad-hoc retriever using the whole conversational search session, which can be lengthy and noisy. Moreover, existing approaches are limited by the amount of manual supervision signals in the existing datasets. To address the aforementioned issues, we propose a History-Aware Conversational Dense Retrieval (HAConvDR) system, which incorporates two ideas: context-denoised query reformulation and automatic mining of supervision signals based on the actual impact of historical turns. Experiments on two public conversational search datasets demonstrate the improved history modeling capability of HAConvDR, in particular for long conversations with topic shifts.	[ -0.49225544929504395, -1.13711678981781, 0.49616241455078125, -0.04028996452689171, -0.1528785079717636, -0.139495387673378, -0.31525176763534546, -0.09407242387533188, 0.5496890544891357, 0.7714160680770874, -0.45435506105422974, -0.3849409520626068, -0.02019369974732399, -0.5566973686218262, -0.7210068702697754, 0.6635921597480774, 0.20317819714546204, -0.24231812357902527, 0.09866657853126526, -0.22944429516792297, -0.8479620218276978, -0.7652588486671448, -0.9334354996681213, -0.2992400527000427, 0.35003194212913513, 0.3300075829029083, 1.0985709428787231, 0.5675526857376099, 0.24886289238929749, 0.17732645571231842, -0.39937180280685425, 0.4513496458530426, -0.8833472728729248, 0.48409146070480347, -0.10464264452457428, -0.12127082794904709, -0.45055997371673584, -0.4715462028980255, 0.32327207922935486, 0.5225507020950317, -0.6926708817481995, -0.4048439562320709, -0.06824570149183273, 0.4875522255897522, -0.8108457326889038, 0.13712584972381592, -0.7569164037704468, 0.003852874506264925, -0.04755738377571106, -0.6700571179389954, -0.4052791893482208, -0.33470696210861206, 0.3670669496059418, -0.6732358336448669, 0.4403837025165558, -0.02493894472718239, 0.569398820400238, -0.12414874136447906, -0.6790198683738708, -0.21953481435775757, -0.9236932396888733, 0.763850212097168, -0.5016379356384277, 0.6902552843093872, 0.4636317491531372, 0.5451160073280334, -0.35142436623573303, -0.8702843189239502, -0.2974250018596649, 0.13681626319885254, -0.5024166703224182, -0.03370065614581108, -0.2223162055015564, 0.07369125634431839, 0.1447788029909134, 0.3588176965713501, -0.23657546937465668, -0.0743529349565506, -0.500916063785553, -0.29041600227355957, 0.6561682224273682, 0.49641162157058716, -0.030270075425505638, -0.4551403820514679, -0.345014363527298, -0.11435870081186295, -0.4014167785644531, -0.03710329160094261, -0.025646844878792763, 0.32184404134750366, 0.15146635472774506, 0.2764235734939575, -0.6593101620674133, 0.8592919111251831, 0.08057412505149841, 0.10192224383354187, -0.10468078404664993, -0.5743970274925232, -0.018176520243287086, 0.3166569173336029, 0.7421988844871521, 0.4494834542274475, 0.33896154165267944, 0.005890549160540104, -0.06732103228569031, -0.35108426213264465, 0.4825096130371094, -0.7840517163276672, -0.3208659589290619, -0.1808633804321289, -0.4503328800201416, 0.06225612014532089, 0.13786056637763977, -0.8524283766746521, -0.48696690797805786, -0.47151511907577515, 0.27966582775115967, -0.4319347143173218, -0.14041735231876373, 0.2994312644004822, -0.2079714983701706, 0.4387294352054596, 0.6083328127861023, -0.8811526894569397, 0.42187240719795227, 0.5705336332321167, 0.6826660633087158, -0.22922205924987793, 0.12956376373767853, -0.5597419142723083, 0.1591676026582718, -0.08995183557271957, 0.48243680596351624, -0.653091549873352, -0.9206135869026184, 0.09381356090307236, -0.0038067158311605453, 0.14459013938903809, -0.34022465348243713, 0.5580759048461914, -1.0718196630477905, 0.24360954761505127, -0.22301429510116577, -0.33423590660095215, -0.10531967878341675, 0.2699123024940491, -0.6555137038230896, 0.9689348340034485, -0.1251676380634308, -0.7295515537261963, 0.287700891494751, -0.2545626759529114, -0.7107120156288147, 0.09967504441738129, -0.4695335328578949, -0.4952274560928345, -0.36334100365638733, 0.549121618270874, 0.3734748065471649, 0.026904508471488953, 0.5449132323265076, -0.09422234445810318, -0.7982414364814758, -0.11017695814371109, -0.5939866304397583, 0.665174663066864, 0.18826033174991608, -0.24959003925323486, -0.13688886165618896, -0.3923913538455963, -0.07958502322435379, -0.1388409435749054, -0.45357346534729004, -0.5408387184143066, 0.17039711773395538, -0.1725846379995346, -0.21621057391166687, 0.36601659655570984, -0.2560131549835205, 0.25811833143234253, -0.3997029960155487, 0.33717021346092224, 0.38585489988327026, 0.452949583530426, 0.5235930681228638, -0.3384060263633728, 0.22142711281776428, 0.037949975579977036, 0.24510729312896729, -0.5063726305961609, -0.1911841481924057, -0.9420660734176636, 0.06030130013823509, -0.18548408150672913, 0.4781050384044647, -0.40287908911705017, 0.35526764392852783, -0.41111233830451965, -0.33442753553390503, -0.09278791397809982, 0.14782306551933289, 0.11527172476053238, 0.38694700598716736, 0.603073000907898, -0.4066455662250519, -1.031188726425171, -0.7032522559165955, -0.10106289386749268, -0.2548300325870514, 0.11997862905263901, 0.9416937828063965, 0.059187158942222595, -0.3769942820072174, 1.155135989189148, -0.8613864183425903, -0.4720887839794159, 0.052437182515859604, 0.17615975439548492, 0.23102526366710663, 0.3716670572757721, 0.013337639160454273, -0.9732887744903564, -0.203264519572258, 0.1687435507774353, -0.6716374754905701, 0.4737101197242737, -0.07638806849718094, -0.3414669632911682, -0.020994940772652626, 1.1353375911712646, -0.5932117104530334, 0.6613636612892151, -0.1214492991566658, -0.1225409209728241, 0.1876027137041092, -0.36325785517692566, 0.530917763710022, -0.9397287368774414, -0.027647830545902252, -0.45618268847465515, -0.1750640571117401, -0.497077614068985, -0.5512055158615112, 0.13429994881153107, -0.21113671362400055, -0.42718473076820374, 0.5219129920005798, -0.48272809386253357, 0.20865406095981598, 0.005294130649417639, 0.19725610315799713, 0.03236513212323189, 0.34851816296577454, 0.277121365070343, 0.4337506592273712, 0.3874301612377167, -0.9468156099319458, 0.526175856590271, 0.5057168006896973, -0.17475908994674683, 0.5468441247940063, -0.5208654403686523, 0.14667363464832306, -0.18693362176418304, 0.267643004655838, -0.8195169568061829, -0.10900021344423294, -0.3304188549518585, -0.28323817253112793, 0.22794826328754425, -0.40487295389175415, -0.16174575686454773, -0.2821376323699951, -0.0627727210521698, 0.44520771503448486, 0.4687853455543518, -0.7257056832313538, 0.6225332617759705, 0.3853977620601654, -0.054346609860658646, -0.6597365736961365, -0.13404914736747742, 0.16495399177074432, -0.17457135021686554, -0.5103493928909302, 0.3824983537197113, 0.07785278558731079, -0.17819678783416748, -0.397634893655777, -0.17596487700939178, -0.2941116988658905, -0.03510149195790291, 0.18423670530319214, 0.1770511418581009, -0.14742200076580048, 0.2552865147590637, -0.10987013578414917, 0.19926345348358154, -0.11447334289550781, 0.04398766905069351, 0.859104573726654, 0.03713023290038109, -0.27150169014930725, -0.3610215187072754, 0.22209236025810242, 0.4798583388328552, -0.3693295121192932, 0.3742419481277466, 0.6423329710960388, -0.27956515550613403, -0.03461318463087082, -0.989633321762085, -0.6394813656806946, -0.4564937651157379, 0.13295678794384003, -0.10560194402933121, -1.1391332149505615, 0.3268381953239441, 0.24326802790164948, -0.11173103749752045, 0.06995057314634323, 0.48820093274116516, -0.11151088774204254, 1.0693016052246094, 0.2723321318626404, -0.12702395021915436, 0.8651439547538757, -0.12237042933702469, 0.1705801784992218, -0.5870320796966553, -0.43994560837745667, -0.26035600900650024, -0.13668309152126312, -0.44628438353538513, 0.00905483216047287, 0.3990563154220581, -0.03770936280488968, -0.2275427132844925, 0.29177477955818176, -0.335103303194046, 0.2914730906486511, 0.5974642634391785, 0.49715057015419006, 0.5753905177116394, 0.000025329161871923134, 0.3607373535633087, -0.021325889974832535, -0.4692021906375885, -0.06239011138677597, 0.8824119567871094, -0.11060553789138794, 1.4037247896194458, 0.07360401004552841, 0.6361060738563538, 0.3973153233528137, -0.25756964087486267, -0.8512498140335083, 0.5757741332054138, 0.1516578495502472, -0.7672633528709412, -0.5747175216674805, -0.4301851987838745, -1.5319055318832397, 0.17309701442718506, -0.11520788818597794, -0.5158071517944336, 0.4583173096179962, 0.21292434632778168, -0.5094064474105835, 0.003792624454945326, -0.5040205717086792, 0.6549744606018066, -0.14880990982055664, -0.20020781457424164, -0.32395434379577637, -0.6952521204948425, 0.14189939200878143, 0.1797805279493332, 0.0909612774848938, 0.25867512822151184, 0.4589504599571228, 0.7529679536819458, -0.19388075172901154, 0.7755287885665894, -0.17950420081615448, 0.26438477635383606, 0.3624284267425537, 0.49456265568733215, 0.6092516779899597, 0.3711169958114624, 0.15511375665664673, -0.3257536292076111, 0.14410613477230072, -0.15826170146465302, -0.6680006980895996, 0.9433771371841431, -0.5398275256156921, -0.9561448097229004, -0.0941946804523468, -0.45621058344841003, 0.03947782889008522, 0.4576877951622009, 0.09430593997240067, 0.5924993753433228, -0.6692979335784912, 0.6501117944717407, 0.9462925791740417, 0.2020193636417389, 0.2973146438598633, 0.682788074016571, -0.1940358728170395, 0.09885580092668533, 0.40047526359558105, 0.06784229725599289, -0.1735253930091858, 0.4863346517086029, -0.006742911878973246, -0.14514417946338654, -0.28187108039855957, -0.029938405379652977, 0.059020597487688065, -0.6170591711997986, -0.21559445559978485, -1.038834571838379, -0.11127790063619614, -0.46056926250457764, -0.3123358190059662, -0.3713720440864563, -0.18886159360408783, -0.7122359275817871, -0.017549477517604828, 0.4971681237220764, 0.34958764910697937, 0.1329183727502823, 0.4666597843170166, -0.4955562353134155, 0.4597395658493042, 0.6030900478363037, 0.3611717224121094, -0.07116100937128067, -0.4805435240268707, -0.27217912673950195, 0.10204681009054184, -0.27274027466773987, -0.5781052708625793, 0.49396100640296936, 0.21315529942512512, 0.6345928311347961, 0.29528090357780457, 0.2886178493499756, 0.6841102242469788, -0.30035412311553955, 0.49684232473373413, -0.006504656746983528, -0.40809422731399536, 0.9855549931526184, -0.31190723180770874, 0.3163716197013855, 0.6089475154876709, 0.2994841933250427, -0.6889108419418335, 0.11063793301582336, -0.53235924243927, -0.9566150903701782, 0.6410107016563416, -0.0038416048046201468, 0.18483804166316986, -0.2112368941307068, 0.27350080013275146, -0.11740884184837341, -0.07570110261440277, -0.024486007168889046, -0.0978422462940216, -0.3643713593482971, 0.1306791752576828, -0.07087049633264542, -0.26601311564445496, -0.13308921456336975, -0.12759409844875336, 0.5190007090568542, 0.11046531051397324, -0.0924166887998581, 0.4233173429965973, -0.3425985872745514, 0.06203976273536682, 0.5384775996208191, -0.10898914188146591, 0.7298528552055359, -0.625149130821228, 0.13958844542503357, 0.3243829607963562, -0.3901256322860718, 0.02392941154539585, 0.2091379165649414, -0.09320685267448425, 0.153220072388649, -0.11513715982437134, 0.7676095962524414, 0.5148687362670898, -0.6243645548820496, 0.7324761152267456, -0.4366139769554138, 0.12823203206062317, -0.6825747489929199, 0.2548424303531647, -0.11308436095714569, 0.1777300089597702, 0.4781261086463928, -0.22345006465911865, 0.5425902605056763, -0.3770885467529297, 0.4918491542339325, 0.5875663161277771, -0.9067992568016052, 0.08778410404920578, 0.5186074376106262, 0.1618502140045166, -0.2589356005191803, 1.0930110216140747, 0.22004906833171844, -0.11510488390922546, 0.14794476330280304, 0.2710692584514618, 0.19508984684944153, -0.3146281838417053, -0.052393343299627304, 0.40735605359077454, -0.061374664306640625, -0.4011380970478058, 0.04206172749400139, -0.43554702401161194, -0.6196017265319824, -0.17125959694385529, -0.3658130466938019, -0.32116296887397766, 0.042208436876535416, -1.0383836030960083, 0.6175429224967957, -0.14164400100708008, -0.320075124502182, -0.20098255574703217, -0.15188616514205933, -0.7928040027618408, 0.30028674006462097, -0.06611723452806473, 0.6734841465950012, -0.3301575779914856, 0.6129565834999084, 0.28485211730003357, -0.16384530067443848, -0.18639269471168518, -0.5443803668022156, -0.09287823736667633, -0.7651335000991821, 0.633091926574707, -0.15788522362709045, -0.36099034547805786, 0.18874457478523254, -0.395114541053772, -0.7041313648223877, 1.3458133935928345, 0.12855689227581024, -0.6199476718902588, -0.2637687027454376, -0.3737150728702545, 0.4802198112010956, -0.02826813980937004, 0.2702711820602417, 1.004648208618164, 0.08708563446998596, 0.2678965926170349, -0.8948103189468384, 0.06029392033815384, 0.020365770906209946, -0.04212901368737221, 0.47351357340812683, -0.4479961693286896, 0.7872645258903503, -0.07214866578578949, -0.5528296232223511, -0.00467477785423398, 0.8482248783111572, -0.0242367684841156, 0.2990853786468506, 0.4295794367790222, 0.4370715320110321, 0.6350303292274475, -0.15213221311569214, 0.9910100698471069, -0.0014795042807236314, 0.2889632284641266, 1.170925498008728, -0.07401484251022339, 0.7207493185997009, 0.38993823528289795, 0.12677593529224396, 0.2275492250919342, 0.1476677805185318, 0.2907564043998718, 0.4006118178367615, -0.12806560099124908, -0.34329357743263245, -0.4940161108970642, -0.1285836547613144, -0.46675217151641846, 0.5173990726470947, 0.5559714436531067, -0.3528912663459778, -0.20250634849071503, -0.29180559515953064, 0.3829076290130615, 0.029098844155669212, -0.23822911083698273, 1.1017593145370483, -0.007900389842689037, -0.719334602355957, 0.7978087663650513, -0.32512885332107544, 0.8471308946609497, -0.5596672296524048, -0.03209220618009567, -0.588783860206604, 0.16491444408893585, -0.29821592569351196, -0.6263232231140137, 0.03899155929684639, -0.5778425931930542, -0.08155036717653275, 0.054222848266363144, 0.8286877274513245, -0.5043633580207825, -0.030806051567196846, 0.2961941063404083, 0.6461097002029419, -0.053322773426771164, -0.12350191175937653, -0.27862536907196045, 0.16968461871147156, -0.01669212244451046, -0.22785989940166473, 0.04116446524858475, 0.3328312933444977, -0.27637600898742676, 0.5834323167800903, 0.42435207962989807, -0.23287628591060638, -0.02126316726207733, 0.24026428163051605, 0.8501853942871094, -1.1194719076156616, -0.621086597442627, -0.6481139659881592, -0.013755138963460922, -0.15560811758041382, -0.04973222687840462, 0.6091290712356567, 0.688403844833374, 0.7391781210899353, 0.4139076769351959, 0.7404202222824097, 0.2087366282939911, 0.6620868444442749, -0.5499704480171204, 0.5951674580574036, -0.261055588722229, 0.3698352873325348, 0.0143642108887434, -0.7651504874229431, -0.19209158420562744, 0.4389345645904541, -0.2627806067466736, 0.0669114887714386, 0.2819122076034546, 1.1454416513442993, -0.4230090081691742, 0.3561137318611145, 0.22642332315444946, 0.19955912232398987, 0.6052162051200867, 0.18837659060955048, 0.9550700783729553, -0.3772648870944977, 0.957771897315979, -0.031060222536325455, -0.05650586634874344, -0.7340573668479919, -0.5153168439865112, -0.7259411215782166, -0.5830351710319519, 0.004564548376947641, -0.3430328369140625, 0.3533983826637268, 0.5471159815788269, 0.805115818977356, -0.6883995532989502, -0.538244903087616, 0.2070084512233734, -0.05450522527098656, -0.06029466912150383, -0.27202558517456055, 0.4248693287372589, -0.32159772515296936, -0.3528764843940735, 0.7355374097824097, 0.13539449870586395, -0.04369628056883812, -0.12377826124429703, -0.12136991322040558, -0.39853721857070923, -0.11091800779104233, 0.7780827879905701, 0.3908350467681885, -0.359770804643631, -0.3797628879547119, -0.01090199500322342, -0.17300927639007568, 0.3723996579647064, 1.2501659393310547, -1.0712287425994873, 0.8883163928985596, 0.48822492361068726, 0.4103914797306061, 1.3240995407104492, 0.22172130644321442, 0.5856823325157166, -0.812708854675293, -0.0495888777077198, 0.3445934057235718, 0.28205379843711853, 0.5620509386062622, -0.5251504182815552, 0.22384895384311676, -0.09431149065494537, -0.5069728493690491, -0.45019692182540894, 0.14711594581604004, -1.076622486114502, -0.25929132103919983, 1.1307870149612427, 0.3551948070526123, 0.11457665264606476, -0.6593717336654663, -0.6227096915245056, 0.3310927152633667, -0.8327515125274658, 0.6640708446502686, 0.38770896196365356, -0.32559844851493835, -0.10955365002155304, -0.3903791606426239, 0.3896480202674866, 0.25585249066352844, -0.25510913133621216, 0.2178080976009369, 0.7163734436035156, -0.12129215151071548, 0.022486720234155655, 0.8349989652633667, -0.35783088207244873, 0.26341602206230164, -0.3854638636112213, -0.14071884751319885, 0.06918574124574661, -0.12858712673187256, -0.01458357647061348, 0.2354506403207779, -0.031010085716843605, 0.2877279818058014 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16657v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16657v1	Recovering Mental Representations from Large Language Models with Markov Chain Monte Carlo	2024-01-30T01:22:18	2024-01-30T01:22:18	Jian-Qiao Zhu, Haijiang Yan, Thomas L. Griffiths	cs.AI	cs.AI, cs.CL	Simulating sampling algorithms with people has proven a useful method for efficiently probing and understanding their mental representations. We propose that the same methods can be used to study the representations of Large Language Models (LLMs). While one can always directly prompt either humans or LLMs to disclose their mental representations introspectively, we show that increased efficiency can be achieved by using LLMs as elements of a sampling algorithm. We explore the extent to which we recover human-like representations when LLMs are interrogated with Direct Sampling and Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC). We found a significant increase in efficiency and performance using adaptive sampling algorithms based on MCMC. We also highlight the potential of our method to yield a more general method of conducting Bayesian inference \textit{with} LLMs.	[ -0.434458464384079, -0.7157507538795471, 0.8520607352256775, 0.08564937114715576, -0.14483430981636047, 0.1530694216489792, -0.6539720892906189, -0.2852705121040344, 0.3589426279067993, 0.7132938504219055, -0.5623626112937927, -0.3117808699607849, -0.45289555191993713, -0.01602724939584732, -0.16448408365249634, 0.6021626591682434, 0.14674092829227448, 0.23182521760463715, 0.03793436288833618, 0.25035375356674194, -0.0531596913933754, -0.774209201335907, -0.8231112957000732, -0.506178617477417, 0.6657054424285889, 0.22908109426498413, 0.2981833517551422, 0.3640955090522766, 0.30937618017196655, 0.23964057862758636, 0.1726987361907959, 0.19747191667556763, -0.4794057607650757, 0.18611621856689453, -0.47553956508636475, -0.7159276604652405, -0.27577996253967285, 0.0812671035528183, 0.9106503129005432, 0.9737825393676758, -0.6163052916526794, 0.06370975822210312, -0.024786239489912987, 0.6678203344345093, -0.8122928142547607, 0.21555843949317932, -0.9619876742362976, 0.01757677085697651, -0.12182486057281494, -0.4509503245353699, -0.7928480505943298, -0.12114784866571426, 0.022113580256700516, -0.3343766927719116, 0.20015592873096466, 0.10892088711261749, 0.04853891208767891, -0.38113105297088623, -0.40133002400398254, -0.2510656714439392, -1.019673466682434, 0.9253196120262146, -0.543102502822876, 0.07877235859632492, 0.43372079730033875, 0.55918288230896, -0.6049390435218811, -0.4553993344306946, -0.794550895690918, -0.5247862339019775, 0.3871217668056488, 0.1950497180223465, -0.1303248107433319, 0.16782619059085846, 0.6676220297813416, 0.21365739405155182, -0.1520041823387146, 0.15847283601760864, -0.3266470730304718, -0.11864358931779861, 0.775522768497467, 0.19040638208389282, 0.32952454686164856, 0.07236141711473465, -0.1765679270029068, -0.5169082880020142, -0.8317020535469055, -0.2647351026535034, 0.38969793915748596, 0.22199732065200806, 0.14748579263687134, 0.6859726905822754, -0.1644512414932251, 0.5847159028053284, -0.20531989634037018, -0.08184557408094406, 0.09535107761621475, 0.12408644706010818, -0.2836775481700897, 0.014417853206396103, 0.7429358959197998, 0.2859480082988739, 0.9298932552337646, 0.12416102737188339, -0.1919640600681305, 0.027027618139982224, 0.25711390376091003, -0.4604510962963104, -0.5161605477333069, -0.03866613656282425, -0.3484954833984375, 0.16997702419757843, 0.13105203211307526, -0.8726646304130554, -0.5922911763191223, -0.24483376741409302, 0.33170831203460693, -0.204149529337883, -0.47252121567726135, 0.17594219744205475, -0.2064047008752823, 0.19982214272022247, 0.5130746960639954, -1.045875072479248, 0.5959748029708862, 0.46948492527008057, 0.5796949863433838, -0.04080133140087128, -0.03666909784078598, -0.488523930311203, 0.3623727858066559, -0.6326400637626648, 0.8287374973297119, -0.4702763259410858, -0.47276946902275085, 0.0010890588164329529, -0.09094081073999405, 0.034790005534887314, -0.8194961547851562, 0.10770177841186523, -0.6010568141937256, -0.12744487822055817, -0.6070609092712402, -0.48942801356315613, -0.19930578768253326, 0.21385078132152557, -0.8598334789276123, 0.6487462520599365, -0.019215378910303116, -0.7838510870933533, -0.058090850710868835, -0.3621659576892853, 0.08975166082382202, -0.12537036836147308, -0.33021026849746704, -0.06999022513628006, 0.5229582190513611, 0.5011918544769287, 0.7595658898353577, -0.22180752456188202, 0.011245743371546268, -0.6903117895126343, -0.6448245644569397, 0.5600616335868835, -0.5264228582382202, 0.7576658129692078, 0.24065713584423065, 0.09118766337633133, -0.14553815126419067, -0.553318440914154, -0.17752452194690704, 0.2750230133533478, -0.37299564480781555, -0.41136178374290466, 0.4357117712497711, -0.1765863299369812, 0.10499794036149979, -0.09745359420776367, -0.5898250341415405, 0.4669123589992523, -0.3656059205532074, 0.20136557519435883, 0.6924862265586853, 0.34350183606147766, 0.3383157551288605, -0.4194573163986206, 0.6850059628486633, 0.2222754806280136, -0.7036880850791931, -0.12298575043678284, -0.3208237886428833, -0.6049007177352905, -0.4065569043159485, 0.21447062492370605, 0.4466581642627716, -0.8735424280166626, 0.10599489510059357, -0.3409341275691986, -0.23773247003555298, -0.5491735935211182, 0.00694524310529232, -0.032968517392873764, 0.11485248059034348, 0.1054755449295044, -0.4952012300491333, -0.7006134986877441, -0.9373571872711182, -0.4466685354709625, -0.34175392985343933, -0.5093905925750732, 0.26167017221450806, 0.39649465680122375, -0.286560595035553, 0.7654567956924438, -0.34007635712623596, 0.2454838901758194, -0.47060683369636536, 0.14971943199634552, 0.33694517612457275, 0.38659903407096863, 0.34580308198928833, -0.30384114384651184, -0.2061048001050949, -0.20674844086170197, -0.4941864013671875, -0.04279972240328789, -0.23310312628746033, -0.20664872229099274, 0.0604979433119297, 0.47084733843803406, -0.40816688537597656, 0.26338136196136475, 0.577809751033783, 0.04283362999558449, 0.6831790208816528, -0.49157458543777466, 0.16945475339889526, -0.9998471736907959, -0.018900876864790916, 0.13966961205005646, -0.49851158261299133, -0.544373095035553, 0.009584200568497181, 0.13106125593185425, 0.010301429778337479, -0.2068767547607422, 0.5038772225379944, -0.8437040448188782, -0.3604065179824829, -0.39499953389167786, 0.31832098960876465, -0.43215152621269226, 0.348894327878952, 0.24058006703853607, 0.6788580417633057, 0.5071210861206055, -0.7286102771759033, 0.30711376667022705, -0.4819251000881195, -0.6380950212478638, 0.4894132614135742, -0.35388660430908203, 0.2781565487384796, -0.6510331630706787, 0.5908893346786499, -1.1699371337890625, -0.30451318621635437, 0.38100698590278625, -0.22527441382408142, 0.327271968126297, -0.022821100428700447, -0.8284322619438171, -0.36763325333595276, -0.34914156794548035, 0.19696244597434998, 0.7549712657928467, -0.5551699995994568, 0.5269344449043274, 0.6353958249092102, -0.11866242438554764, -0.3008630573749542, -0.797344982624054, 0.02074970118701458, -0.26346832513809204, -0.07798672467470169, 0.053687866777181625, -0.06597871333360672, -0.49464157223701477, -0.3788686692714691, 0.036880556493997574, 0.09929735213518143, 0.1490030288696289, 0.017530925571918488, 0.14831070601940155, 0.08222674578428268, 0.34547004103660583, 0.02896963804960251, 0.17586007714271545, 0.4583420753479004, -0.23678277432918549, 0.7784342169761658, 0.2660071551799774, -0.5750370621681213, -0.3611035645008087, 0.4173407554626465, 0.27295616269111633, 0.003032576059922576, 0.708401620388031, 0.443996787071228, -0.6213221549987793, -0.289511501789093, -0.7763118743896484, -0.3722553253173828, -0.41880476474761963, 0.5365243554115295, -0.3966127336025238, -0.8401731252670288, 0.5817700028419495, -0.32559478282928467, -0.17290110886096954, 0.4226078689098358, 1.0030744075775146, -0.3679739832878113, 1.2271168231964111, 0.5949605703353882, -0.273423433303833, 0.5320417284965515, -0.1989096701145172, -0.0551774725317955, -1.166949987411499, -0.17672346532344818, -0.41075095534324646, -0.3966097831726074, -0.6122036576271057, -0.824828565120697, 0.26982536911964417, 0.18815097212791443, -0.09634291380643845, -0.05080149322748184, -0.10874149948358536, 0.47715625166893005, 0.5318273901939392, 0.3479574918746948, 0.40842482447624207, 0.5056047439575195, -0.3546108901500702, -0.09739325195550919, -0.6174550652503967, -0.6687127947807312, 1.1677359342575073, 0.41007378697395325, 0.9487442374229431, 0.04372187331318855, 0.7570620179176331, 0.11634564399719238, 0.6607042551040649, -0.7606727480888367, 0.7111428380012512, 0.1747729778289795, -0.7186775207519531, 0.06286897510290146, -0.7236080765724182, -1.0590213537216187, 0.3332824409008026, -0.18501147627830505, -1.4187499284744263, 0.0754772201180458, 0.25890791416168213, -0.09394125640392303, 0.5836867690086365, -0.48936566710472107, 0.15423423051834106, 0.19072598218917847, 0.07247983664274216, -0.651343584060669, -0.3734392821788788, 0.6801614761352539, -0.19084186851978302, 0.21855635941028595, -0.23468822240829468, -0.04824193939566612, 1.0199795961380005, -0.15888120234012604, 0.7850824594497681, -0.25257980823516846, -0.3433160185813904, 0.571158230304718, 0.13584725558757782, 0.37334945797920227, 0.10473751276731491, -0.2692582309246063, -0.1841978132724762, 0.03996995463967323, -0.5153286457061768, -0.8901723623275757, 0.7662624716758728, -0.6289086937904358, -0.7058227062225342, -0.45907166600227356, -0.7879016995429993, -0.39197322726249695, -0.17933416366577148, -0.1239764466881752, 0.011134310625493526, -0.18679934740066528, 0.04052071273326874, 0.7057482004165649, -0.3094364404678345, 0.3860015869140625, 0.38049545884132385, -0.49906957149505615, -0.30009257793426514, 0.5693492293357849, 0.14428776502609253, 0.4121038615703583, 0.5123751163482666, -0.02217176742851734, -0.2037106156349182, -0.39596307277679443, -0.09415755420923233, 0.6098933815956116, -0.557007908821106, 0.1620572805404663, -0.5469844937324524, -0.024329770356416702, -0.2006688266992569, 0.23917879164218903, -0.17937976121902466, -0.39457646012306213, -0.21928955614566803, -0.009631349705159664, 0.310897558927536, 0.6739041805267334, -0.2625432014465332, 0.47782233357429504, -0.6771895885467529, 0.282414972782135, 0.39763781428337097, 0.11116648465394974, 0.34516045451164246, -0.33366307616233826, -0.220683291554451, 0.5035779476165771, -0.11531654000282288, -1.2255858182907104, 0.43579113483428955, -0.0047157881781458855, 0.6994923949241638, 0.4343719482421875, -0.14731204509735107, 0.7863287329673767, -0.5611133575439453, 0.5486652851104736, 0.12217270582914352, -0.7566179633140564, 0.431991308927536, -0.32569989562034607, 0.3611716330051422, 0.3623690605163574, 0.6828559041023254, -0.7228302359580994, -0.13735279440879822, -0.4726454019546509, -0.47407376766204834, 0.5230328440666199, 0.010965677909553051, 0.23141838610172272, -0.37860631942749023, 0.5767084360122681, -0.34534093737602234, 0.18240141868591309, -0.389997273683548, -0.012858446687459946, 0.5032163262367249, -0.36530035734176636, -0.45906856656074524, -0.44910290837287903, -0.12706433236598969, -0.19576825201511383, 0.39714449644088745, -0.1962411254644394, 0.8322866559028625, 0.2540627717971802, -0.15188191831111908, 0.0230090394616127, 0.14900082349777222, 0.3220694661140442, 0.7141849398612976, -0.38042372465133667, 0.47716501355171204, 0.37684905529022217, -0.5040056109428406, 0.22655747830867767, -0.16620051860809326, 0.33493363857269287, -0.19263435900211334, 0.3122418224811554, 0.4366477131843567, 0.025641823187470436, -1.1428745985031128, 0.1509859412908554, -0.1334947943687439, 0.024037538096308708, -0.3084888756275177, 0.2844815254211426, 0.4499684274196625, 0.4115220308303833, 0.43928787112236023, -0.22033905982971191, 0.016911940649151802, -1.0711196660995483, 0.05425232648849487, 0.558992326259613, -0.16291256248950958, -0.28192368149757385, 0.28679221868515015, -0.4811762869358063, -0.33231887221336365, 0.869675874710083, -0.10704705864191055, -0.4197089374065399, 0.4154502749443054, 0.8242607116699219, 0.5473783016204834, -0.3215884566307068, 0.004697391297668219, 0.33146655559539795, 0.1709476113319397, -0.494663804769516, 0.5559526681900024, -0.24847334623336792, -0.9587917327880859, -0.5973678827285767, -0.42173177003860474, -0.5443567633628845, -0.1410585641860962, -0.8485154509544373, -0.01722892001271248, -0.5850176215171814, -0.21077610552310944, -0.4538092613220215, 0.26370617747306824, -0.5907420516014099, 0.11830499023199081, 0.5656543970108032, 1.0611618757247925, -0.6894795894622803, 1.172552227973938, 0.7163341045379639, -0.03255167603492737, -0.7798568606376648, 0.05980813130736351, -0.11476168781518936, -0.8801817297935486, 0.49770596623420715, -0.062012139707803726, -0.19151629507541656, 0.16264225542545319, -0.7708700299263, -0.8747632503509521, 1.1202088594436646, 0.473164826631546, -0.9143295884132385, 0.054830119013786316, -0.14225314557552338, 0.5072054862976074, -0.5952461957931519, 0.3954958915710449, 0.6361914277076721, 0.10731637477874756, 0.08551465719938278, -0.5687710642814636, 0.1201968714594841, -0.07084008306264877, 0.5071872472763062, -0.010794561356306076, -0.1489281803369522, 0.7378743886947632, -0.2948433756828308, -0.3966924846172333, 0.06742043048143387, 0.985934853553772, 1.0449570417404175, -0.03373929485678673, 0.5039141178131104, 0.4160921275615692, 1.1515116691589355, 0.16856323182582855, 1.2869290113449097, 0.021198099479079247, 0.3939726650714874, 1.0954355001449585, -0.18498191237449646, 1.1664471626281738, 0.5876368880271912, -0.3882526159286499, 0.5778677463531494, 0.5877804160118103, 0.10906465351581573, 0.38254356384277344, 0.8992908000946045, -0.37502288818359375, -0.29941070079803467, 0.21815070509910583, -0.20249678194522858, 0.15348748862743378, 0.7627588510513306, -0.454804927110672, -0.1772926151752472, 0.008889867924153805, -0.0661771297454834, -0.035925596952438354, -0.5703786015510559, 0.5169587731361389, 0.3913494944572449, -0.6279404759407043, 0.42541149258613586, 0.21327215433120728, 0.6297917366027832, -0.38154324889183044, -0.1004706397652626, 0.010164771229028702, 0.07488489896059036, 0.1841684728860855, -0.629034698009491, 0.10063040256500244, -0.1165538802742958, -0.09198171645402908, -0.04085227847099304, 0.8355535864830017, -0.6983773708343506, -0.662817120552063, 0.17654432356357574, 0.502821147441864, 0.5173062086105347, -0.3224113881587982, -0.24523819983005524, 0.07711651921272278, -0.1134350523352623, -0.3489956557750702, 0.4544967710971832, 0.33591699600219727, -0.12898416817188263, 0.8801801800727844, 0.5572433471679688, 0.44421759247779846, 0.2333613932132721, 0.1705883890390396, 0.7243009209632874, -0.9323850274085999, -0.17270421981811523, -1.069028615951538, 0.27282097935676575, -0.026642747223377228, 0.2932819128036499, 0.6666422486305237, 0.13927245140075684, 0.871395468711853, -0.28037020564079285, 0.7312886714935303, 0.3850857615470886, 0.539811372756958, -0.7809066772460938, 0.6858704090118408, -0.275819331407547, 0.31321462988853455, -0.3193051517009735, -1.1119049787521362, -0.19928808510303497, 0.9376550912857056, -0.3160533607006073, 0.23493145406246185, 0.6012095808982849, 0.7345510125160217, -0.10746602714061737, -0.04689306393265724, 0.30506792664527893, 0.3168705999851227, 0.36230161786079407, 0.8300653696060181, 0.9947668313980103, -0.08055523037910461, -0.03445201739668846, -0.1910378485918045, -0.31445011496543884, -0.137569397687912, -0.8328791260719299, -0.953991711139679, -0.3484635353088379, -0.24365435540676117, -0.27584031224250793, -0.06364739686250687, 1.2953969240188599, 0.5205461382865906, -0.5861411690711975, -0.6041811108589172, 0.13194875419139862, 0.04368994012475014, -0.18766841292381287, -0.1543569713830948, 0.11357385665178299, -0.04994114488363266, -0.9565484523773193, 0.34091126918792725, 0.2043030858039856, 0.06580567359924316, -0.7782877087593079, 0.10721012949943542, -0.23311251401901245, 0.25631019473075867, 0.6387847661972046, 0.10833628475666046, -0.5937654972076416, -0.1522926390171051, -0.25316980481147766, -0.06386974453926086, 0.01385751087218523, 1.0705726146697998, -1.1056714057922363, 0.5936632752418518, 0.6130101680755615, 0.6865052580833435, 0.7720527648925781, -0.029743557795882225, 0.8650959134101868, -0.5492761135101318, 0.0835823118686676, 0.25411662459373474, 0.5748347640037537, 0.2487395703792572, 0.01759411208331585, 0.1382090449333191, 0.15107204020023346, -0.33998435735702515, -0.629274308681488, 0.474117636680603, -1.2130398750305176, -0.3056662380695343, 1.130672574043274, -0.1943587362766266, -0.40815219283103943, 0.1468995213508606, -0.24960431456565857, 0.3319089710712433, -0.29591429233551025, 0.7912324666976929, 0.8296495676040649, -0.04541192203760147, -0.43116673827171326, -0.7334415912628174, 0.045053377747535706, 0.21195721626281738, -0.6069175004959106, -0.08008580654859543, 0.27175161242485046, 0.41814228892326355, -0.048813749104738235, 0.9833018779754639, -0.1445823758840561, -0.052717648446559906, -0.16603201627731323, 0.030087100341916084, 0.43695390224456787, -0.17388099431991577, -0.4714435636997223, 0.12814690172672272, 0.1645742505788803, 0.13471107184886932 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16658v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16658v2	OWSM v3.1: Better and Faster Open Whisper-Style Speech Models based on E-Branchformer	2024-01-30T01:22:18	2024-06-16T20:33:38	Yifan Peng, Jinchuan Tian, William Chen, Siddhant Arora, Brian Yan, Yui Sudo, Muhammad Shakeel, Kwanghee Choi, Jiatong Shi, Xuankai Chang, Jee-weon Jung, Shinji Watanabe	cs.CL	cs.CL, eess.AS	Recent studies have highlighted the importance of fully open foundation models. The Open Whisper-style Speech Model (OWSM) is an initial step towards reproducing OpenAI Whisper using public data and open-source toolkits. However, previous versions of OWSM (v1 to v3) are still based on standard Transformer, which might lead to inferior performance compared to state-of-the-art speech encoder architectures. This work aims to improve the performance and efficiency of OWSM without additional data. We present a series of E-Branchformer-based models named OWSM v3.1, ranging from 100M to 1B parameters. OWSM v3.1 outperforms its predecessor, OWSM v3, in most evaluation benchmarks, while showing an improved inference speed of up to 25%. We further reveal the emergent ability of OWSM v3.1 in zero-shot contextual biasing speech recognition. We also provide a model trained on a subset of data with low license restrictions. We will publicly release the code, pre-trained models, and training logs.	[ -0.24674606323242188, -0.4877927601337433, 0.3557349145412445, 0.06431660056114197, -0.23738433420658112, -0.47090762853622437, -0.05080059543251991, -0.8660556077957153, 0.03528953716158867, 0.609395444393158, -0.5940916538238525, -0.4214474558830261, -0.5799582600593567, -0.06236238032579422, -0.46790173649787903, 0.6035043001174927, -0.08467618376016617, 0.35908418893814087, 0.04941940680146217, -0.25161367654800415, -0.0062658474780619144, -0.3149445652961731, -0.512774646282196, -0.2895498275756836, 0.2474973350763321, 0.2543174624443054, 0.3823920786380768, 0.6984239816665649, 0.2725270390510559, 0.2311326116323471, -0.3710850477218628, -0.43522870540618896, -0.5341556668281555, 0.19878140091896057, 0.3240041434764862, -0.5211384296417236, -0.5979762673377991, -0.12588028609752655, 0.414978951215744, 0.5911334156990051, -0.4296821653842926, 0.2071022242307663, -0.07713016122579575, 0.5252870917320251, -0.5246854424476624, 0.20040370523929596, -0.8583647608757019, 0.05583609268069267, -0.39178982377052307, 0.16073495149612427, -0.41929325461387634, -0.2558189034461975, 0.6520081162452698, -0.5121309161186218, 0.38200631737709045, -0.00021666265092790127, 0.6742119193077087, 0.11410073935985565, -0.052735090255737305, 0.0394243560731411, -0.9071187973022461, 0.7609223127365112, -0.8748161792755127, 0.874914824962616, 0.15899433195590973, 0.622483491897583, 0.1304311752319336, -0.8940662145614624, -0.33404940366744995, 0.050640128552913666, 0.37071704864501953, -0.051732465624809265, -0.7088254690170288, 0.21425992250442505, 0.22034873068332672, 0.48749861121177673, -0.3259861171245575, 0.3131679892539978, -0.4650295078754425, -0.22430340945720673, 0.25835472345352173, -0.07248891144990921, -0.13086338341236115, 0.2097722440958023, -0.257906973361969, -0.22172923386096954, -0.7827207446098328, 0.03793226554989815, 0.3687654137611389, 0.38329240679740906, -0.2675357162952423, 0.41172727942466736, -0.5555956363677979, 0.7509238719940186, -0.019631115719676018, -0.4914351999759674, 0.3408185541629791, 0.06601756066083908, -0.3229385316371918, 0.22405029833316803, 0.5178836584091187, 0.2840852737426758, -0.08860833942890167, -0.0898420587182045, -0.12339098006486893, -0.12868192791938782, 0.10762475430965424, -1.0877478122711182, 0.052209656685590744, 0.38664907217025757, -0.7703953981399536, -0.2673557698726654, 0.20310552418231964, -0.41040605306625366, -0.20564743876457214, -0.3879222571849823, 0.6273621320724487, -0.31254974007606506, -0.37190160155296326, 0.13047672808170319, -0.5067083239555359, 0.29681989550590515, 0.5979187488555908, -0.6418386101722717, 0.5334643721580505, 0.6024277806282043, 1.032659649848938, 0.020480968058109283, 0.011109628714621067, -0.5827820301055908, 0.09898930042982101, -0.24365250766277313, 0.499240905046463, -0.18038411438465118, -0.3433331549167633, -0.18178246915340424, -0.1066315621137619, 0.27782440185546875, -0.5719301104545593, 0.5556502342224121, -0.32780763506889343, 0.28705722093582153, 0.12861059606075287, -0.4737980365753174, -0.106198750436306, -0.23093079030513763, -0.8498768210411072, 0.7365438342094421, 0.053940605372190475, -0.5548600554466248, 0.3524397909641266, -0.9590575695037842, -0.22101181745529175, 0.01005701906979084, 0.06451380252838135, -0.46743327379226685, 0.25311994552612305, 0.42740964889526367, 0.25624436140060425, -0.14683817327022552, -0.027321534231305122, -0.3563043475151062, -0.4425728917121887, -0.21290740370750427, -0.6767393350601196, 0.8786967396736145, 0.2108241766691208, -0.5948851704597473, 0.2090218961238861, -0.6330275535583496, -0.0739574208855629, 0.10194645822048187, 0.1357150822877884, -0.2187705785036087, 0.19308896362781525, 0.02099752612411976, -0.022051053121685982, -0.10944386571645737, -0.9817609786987305, -0.22862128913402557, -0.5321165919303894, 0.525455892086029, 0.7022517323493958, -0.2117755264043808, 0.27289366722106934, -0.4371393322944641, 0.24016791582107544, 0.15898555517196655, 0.3852846324443817, -0.41000664234161377, -0.6799803972244263, -0.7324814796447754, -0.6796034574508667, 0.1878446489572525, 0.2773268520832062, -0.3110578656196594, 0.27070125937461853, -0.291439950466156, -0.7722358703613281, -0.9482828974723816, -0.2371404767036438, 0.22503066062927246, 0.5450475215911865, 0.5098520517349243, 0.033473849296569824, -0.8733694553375244, -0.8735764026641846, -0.2297114133834839, -0.2716095447540283, -0.5020219087600708, 0.32556402683258057, 0.17099590599536896, -0.027420956641435623, 1.2522319555282593, -0.595556914806366, -0.2458856999874115, -0.2974351942539215, 0.1834883838891983, 0.09356581419706345, 0.14237770438194275, 0.4447803199291229, -0.7466869354248047, -0.09296776354312897, -0.23743748664855957, -0.30481868982315063, -0.20375561714172363, 0.6063738465309143, 0.024959255009889603, 0.25533148646354675, 0.43053606152534485, -0.4186165928840637, 0.48790156841278076, 0.7091027498245239, 0.022475650534033775, 0.4322032630443573, 0.3467872440814972, -0.2577337622642517, -0.9838305711746216, -0.026513151824474335, 0.04537412151694298, -0.31515634059906006, -0.8807966709136963, -0.14387524127960205, 0.07406779378652573, -0.3417486846446991, -0.9570122957229614, 0.4818611741065979, -0.4809974431991577, 0.10623876005411148, -0.17328330874443054, 0.05839915573596954, -0.06250076740980148, 0.29226693511009216, 0.3574959933757782, 0.5630927681922913, 0.8182554244995117, -0.6818649768829346, -0.050035975873470306, 0.17240488529205322, -0.2537441551685333, 0.38976535201072693, -0.8667385578155518, 0.16909456253051758, -0.2308507263660431, 0.5165678262710571, -0.44401785731315613, -0.12824898958206177, 0.0005859687807969749, -0.35378921031951904, 0.310896098613739, -0.1083105057477951, 0.02794674225151539, -0.5390375852584839, -0.548407793045044, -0.15992118418216705, 0.79082190990448, -0.8862093687057495, 0.5667493939399719, 0.5556368231773376, -0.10302327573299408, -0.2702292501926422, -0.5969256162643433, -0.33786025643348694, -0.13765987753868103, -0.556121826171875, 0.6547880172729492, 0.10899407416582108, -0.1818726509809494, -0.10229320824146271, -0.47776782512664795, -0.07641080021858215, -0.07664448767900467, 0.3246745765209198, 0.21214713156223297, -0.5158427357673645, -0.09868109971284866, -0.06091868504881859, 0.09015663713216782, -0.014718163758516312, -0.42484161257743835, 0.22325767576694489, -0.25435060262680054, -0.3458183705806732, -0.4591895639896393, 0.25260627269744873, 0.6395646333694458, -0.17588697373867035, 0.7536365985870361, 0.3163602650165558, -0.7492056488990784, -0.1272227168083191, -0.5901278257369995, -0.11319909244775772, -0.4491589367389679, 0.2070154845714569, -0.22279594838619232, -1.1747092008590698, 0.01818700321018696, 0.06442160904407501, 0.2710636556148529, 0.4239465892314911, 0.2768345773220062, 0.04075350984930992, 1.2358344793319702, 0.7042362093925476, -0.20838028192520142, 0.5535129904747009, -0.067767433822155, 0.1716235876083374, -0.9348962903022766, -0.2519891858100891, -0.8433119058609009, 0.06919538229703903, -0.2791152596473694, -0.4749152660369873, 0.6058117747306824, 0.2513580024242401, -0.15093006193637848, 0.4295186698436737, -0.25710541009902954, 0.12769415974617004, 0.3299562633037567, 0.0990707278251648, 0.25757646560668945, 0.008511427789926529, 0.11504267156124115, 0.13310810923576355, -0.6558390259742737, -0.6242268681526184, 1.1784406900405884, 0.7892477512359619, 0.8767820000648499, 0.2392922043800354, 0.5887628793716431, -0.07708902657032013, 0.4909679591655731, -0.8486090302467346, 0.3147258460521698, -0.010366843082010746, -0.7153152823448181, -0.6246384978294373, -0.3936339020729065, -0.6516063809394836, 0.5593453645706177, 0.15155547857284546, -0.9012451171875, 0.03770320117473602, 0.2351742833852768, -0.2881528437137604, 0.4869593381881714, -0.4850125014781952, 0.5987188816070557, 0.16341887414455414, -0.060168929398059845, 0.1541481763124466, -0.5533298254013062, 0.33924606442451477, 0.07501501590013504, 0.07953817397356033, -0.23480837047100067, -0.028208540752530098, 0.8621621131896973, -0.8683857917785645, 0.7948436737060547, -0.5145772099494934, -0.20828600227832794, 0.3725978434085846, -0.39753982424736023, 0.4024267792701721, -0.260224312543869, -0.2480301409959793, 0.6354533433914185, -0.01589619740843773, 0.015230064280331135, -0.38495007157325745, 0.5424070358276367, -0.6459424495697021, -0.5350591540336609, -0.016736093908548355, 0.04530631750822067, -0.44902127981185913, 0.24825112521648407, 0.4347386956214905, 0.8881382346153259, -0.5649614334106445, 0.6338056921958923, 0.6830287575721741, 0.2980015277862549, 0.5993601679801941, 0.815077543258667, -0.3250006139278412, -0.3809482157230377, 0.6036465167999268, 0.1593175232410431, 0.33985087275505066, 0.47095969319343567, 0.36574602127075195, -0.4561913013458252, -0.4688943922519684, -0.5626009702682495, -0.05443315953016281, -0.42428842186927795, -0.43817418813705444, -0.9013885855674744, -0.2928676903247833, -0.5023636221885681, -0.02210710011422634, -0.5678747892379761, -0.49823781847953796, -0.290319561958313, -0.0637633353471756, 0.48856300115585327, 0.7408972978591919, 0.008346276357769966, 0.3995269536972046, -0.7414844036102295, 0.5195028781890869, 0.3278874456882477, 0.6041281223297119, -0.04039378836750984, -0.381614625453949, -0.028766419738531113, 0.2485416680574417, -0.4829294979572296, -0.9465562701225281, 0.08523818105459213, 0.3438866436481476, 0.6750918626785278, 0.624757707118988, 0.08437906950712204, 0.64045649766922, -0.6361240744590759, 0.8462413549423218, 0.24574123322963715, -1.2699220180511475, 0.6820046901702881, -0.3413677513599396, 0.5001897215843201, 0.3426818251609802, 0.3218661844730377, -0.3606405258178711, -0.5487638711929321, -0.5077912211418152, -0.5132437348365784, 1.060931921005249, 0.35213300585746765, -0.043714284896850586, 0.13632963597774506, -0.27991899847984314, 0.39304599165916443, 0.2608136236667633, -0.40245136618614197, -0.2771753668785095, -0.6429901123046875, -0.1908719390630722, -0.12158350646495819, 0.0788419097661972, -0.010440526530146599, -0.3614819049835205, 0.7608112692832947, -0.29204118251800537, 0.35595524311065674, 0.47773417830467224, -0.09234710037708282, -0.38267162442207336, 0.38766148686408997, 0.47168999910354614, 0.44082877039909363, -0.33125293254852295, -0.035692621022462845, 0.34073030948638916, -0.5894365310668945, 0.04097561165690422, 0.24110616743564606, -0.2656145691871643, 0.38341450691223145, 0.3127705454826355, 1.430497169494629, 0.5081390142440796, -0.6488385796546936, 0.7592806220054626, -0.11866814643144608, -0.34537357091903687, -0.12600325047969818, -0.0022581627126783133, 0.03229144960641861, 0.004583833739161491, 0.4708940386772156, 0.21661712229251862, 0.4017719626426697, -0.5244100093841553, -0.0050969370640814304, 0.3108813464641571, -0.6431980729103088, -0.21193723380565643, 0.6788952946662903, 0.3573106527328491, -0.37361764907836914, 0.2183704823255539, 0.20390354096889496, -0.5426114797592163, 0.3126695454120636, 0.8226656317710876, 1.128021240234375, -0.545291006565094, 0.06862369924783707, 0.240512415766716, 0.28956788778305054, -0.15264888107776642, 0.3202227056026459, -0.22737367451190948, -0.3519655466079712, -0.05689797177910805, -0.7419903874397278, -0.7442397475242615, 0.30614328384399414, -0.873068630695343, 0.44505906105041504, -0.03243253380060196, -0.0973743200302124, -0.24877634644508362, -0.5016621351242065, -0.5409447550773621, 0.20359085500240326, 0.2997148334980011, 1.4169062376022339, -0.41309499740600586, 0.6170622706413269, 0.4355384409427643, 0.2311948537826538, -0.7451887130737305, 0.2469521164894104, 0.10951188206672668, -0.3845491409301758, -0.019616078585386276, 0.6660457253456116, -0.5231329202651978, 0.14585524797439575, -0.5474031567573547, -0.9820525050163269, 1.322427749633789, 0.25122711062431335, -0.8577966094017029, -0.04649069905281067, -0.10247465968132019, 0.411097913980484, -0.46135443449020386, 0.3420596420764923, 0.3389626443386078, 0.21932867169380188, 0.0477239266037941, -1.157052755355835, -0.23845548927783966, -0.046596918255090714, 0.23738664388656616, 0.38509106636047363, -0.3650985360145569, 0.7774889469146729, -0.24170175194740295, -0.29432275891304016, 0.23559008538722992, 0.820594847202301, 0.1459295153617859, 0.08940783143043518, 0.6383146047592163, 0.4563848376274109, 0.6697947382926941, -0.20722530782222748, 0.8255329132080078, -0.07628870755434036, -0.025149909779429436, 1.0240229368209839, -0.5630125999450684, 1.3650575876235962, 0.33538129925727844, -0.16103307902812958, 0.6195150017738342, 0.03520284220576286, 0.42542582750320435, 0.7052218317985535, 0.027677910402417183, -0.26521730422973633, 0.19494134187698364, -0.0032026381231844425, -0.6329106092453003, 0.6420257687568665, 0.04575115814805031, -0.28319498896598816, -0.19619831442832947, 0.12963047623634338, 0.056918784976005554, -0.39193210005760193, -0.46952176094055176, 0.8760513067245483, 0.09187477082014084, -0.4129367768764496, 0.30839934945106506, 0.31441718339920044, 0.772631824016571, -0.9175746440887451, -0.05421852320432663, 0.22028309106826782, 0.06725962460041046, 0.010379794985055923, -0.31910717487335205, 0.2759506404399872, 0.2985821068286896, -0.07516777515411377, -0.2582937479019165, 0.8676615953445435, -0.3146180212497711, -0.2100612372159958, 0.3433530032634735, 0.337089478969574, 0.012269251048564911, -0.3296407163143158, -0.2701832950115204, 0.33871906995773315, -0.384948194026947, -0.2784530222415924, -0.03479551896452904, 0.04024882614612579, 0.10377644747495651, 0.34713977575302124, 0.7440488338470459, -0.07086534798145294, 0.15089020133018494, 0.37072789669036865, 0.74457186460495, -0.3760271668434143, -0.6985572576522827, -0.5548222064971924, 0.41063788533210754, -0.20153117179870605, -0.40392062067985535, 0.6455202698707581, 0.5539136528968811, 0.904812753200531, -0.1670530140399933, 0.8453850150108337, 0.09479214996099472, 0.992912769317627, -0.5862060189247131, 0.7619073987007141, -0.4223945736885071, -0.09283170104026794, -0.4360658824443817, -0.7687252163887024, 0.08713724464178085, 0.39843153953552246, -0.005247585475444794, 0.06783676147460938, 0.5302482843399048, 0.8400821089744568, -0.05107541009783745, 0.7874377369880676, 0.38426673412323, 0.2105320394039154, 0.1997472196817398, 0.24050205945968628, 0.6901101469993591, -0.7028848528862, 0.5342931151390076, -0.5633329749107361, -0.5375048518180847, -0.3392588794231415, -0.883040189743042, -0.7405725717544556, -0.49321895837783813, -0.2711525559425354, 0.1418563425540924, 0.03425229340791702, 0.8503336310386658, 1.28036367893219, -0.6983711123466492, -0.1851135939359665, -0.12910769879817963, -0.15229429304599762, -0.36564937233924866, -0.21017977595329285, -0.28447195887565613, 0.19666436314582825, -0.5215182304382324, 0.8597970008850098, 0.37626901268959045, 0.15568077564239502, -0.32642507553100586, -0.4075471758842468, 0.36522382497787476, 0.30032050609588623, 0.6200349926948547, 0.20432239770889282, -0.9503944516181946, -0.16347192227840424, 0.05246661230921745, 0.07725976407527924, 0.12933450937271118, 0.7767578959465027, -0.7702268362045288, 0.44349586963653564, 0.24564455449581146, 0.03242268040776253, 0.6275461912155151, -0.15652012825012207, 0.5883825421333313, -0.4377054274082184, 0.023703329265117645, 0.260639488697052, 0.4642833471298218, 0.3751158118247986, -0.0057520195841789246, 0.14591482281684875, 0.018870467320084572, -0.08823195844888687, -0.9711052179336548, 0.11822079867124557, -0.6736520528793335, -0.13372914493083954, 0.7958030104637146, -0.02767033316195011, -0.36515843868255615, -0.09623893350362778, -0.4534827172756195, 0.34584128856658936, -0.3369833528995514, 0.06425411999225616, 0.3956940174102783, -0.1844853013753891, -0.03803539276123047, -0.283135324716568, 0.4312785565853119, -0.08739931136369705, -0.9550994634628296, -0.026630261912941933, 0.3986891210079193, 0.2819630801677704, -0.03683725744485855, 0.8223564028739929, -0.39820703864097595, 0.29058972001075745, 0.2482081949710846, 0.053795091807842255, -0.23666079342365265, -0.6963462829589844, -0.6261230111122131, 0.3969590663909912, 0.031530145555734634, -0.2822350561618805 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16656v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16656v1	Gradient-Based Language Model Red Teaming	2024-01-30T01:19:25	2024-01-30T01:19:25	Nevan Wichers, Carson Denison, Ahmad Beirami	cs.CL	cs.CL	Red teaming is a common strategy for identifying weaknesses in generative language models (LMs), where adversarial prompts are produced that trigger an LM to generate unsafe responses. Red teaming is instrumental for both model alignment and evaluation, but is labor-intensive and difficult to scale when done by humans. In this paper, we present Gradient-Based Red Teaming (GBRT), a red teaming method for automatically generating diverse prompts that are likely to cause an LM to output unsafe responses. GBRT is a form of prompt learning, trained by scoring an LM response with a safety classifier and then backpropagating through the frozen safety classifier and LM to update the prompt. To improve the coherence of input prompts, we introduce two variants that add a realism loss and fine-tune a pretrained model to generate the prompts instead of learning the prompts directly. Our experiments show that GBRT is more effective at finding prompts that trigger an LM to generate unsafe responses than a strong reinforcement learning-based red teaming approach, and succeeds even when the LM has been fine-tuned to produce safer outputs.	[ -0.4144611656665802, -0.9127310514450073, 0.0744514912366867, 0.305763840675354, 0.10580054670572281, 0.381378710269928, -0.2965664565563202, -0.35091084241867065, -0.05186280235648155, 0.09704329073429108, -0.7771908044815063, -0.36865657567977905, -0.39154279232025146, 0.007848032750189304, -0.01869293488562107, 1.3449589014053345, 0.05969374254345894, 0.14590026438236237, 0.0555521585047245, -0.10519169270992279, -0.7063698172569275, -0.6096290946006775, -1.0888489484786987, -0.3794156312942505, 0.6226592063903809, 0.33651161193847656, 0.6804695129394531, 0.3041676878929138, 0.6959922313690186, 0.2764134705066681, 0.03008406236767769, -0.10625716298818588, -0.7207071185112, 0.38793087005615234, -0.08285168558359146, -0.376786470413208, -0.35383281111717224, 0.08282124996185303, 0.2202220857143402, 0.3308499753475189, -0.38464078307151794, -0.12117179483175278, 0.2387625277042389, 0.42169344425201416, -0.54445880651474, 0.06523995101451874, -0.5507892966270447, 0.25387486815452576, 0.19009248912334442, -0.2930414080619812, -0.4480435848236084, -0.4496426284313202, 0.029327262192964554, -0.31858134269714355, 0.4677318036556244, 0.14200946688652039, 0.7708112597465515, 0.3436744809150696, 0.05819327384233475, -0.21589967608451843, -0.6129727363586426, 0.7274197936058044, -0.35115236043930054, 0.1492282897233963, 0.27876797318458557, 0.6649215817451477, -0.03468618541955948, -0.3549821376800537, -0.47078174352645874, -0.38723504543304443, -0.11333466321229935, 0.31624269485473633, -0.16787762939929962, 0.244036003947258, 0.059717293828725815, -0.04479091241955757, -0.9814039468765259, 0.3151431083679199, -0.2137836515903473, -0.30868616700172424, 0.604809045791626, 0.4167916178703308, 0.5899091362953186, 0.10196883231401443, -0.5870139598846436, -0.3210397958755493, -0.603725016117096, 0.022451117634773254, 0.3611582815647125, 0.5812686085700989, -0.27691370248794556, 0.31025931239128113, -0.010171842761337757, 0.6626993417739868, 0.23571382462978363, 0.018874168395996094, -0.05281832441687584, -0.35191771388053894, -0.12536945939064026, -0.1004023477435112, 0.9567487239837646, 0.47546830773353577, 0.23606304824352264, -0.1889994740486145, -0.5208632946014404, 0.3529997766017914, 0.23830996453762054, -0.6007493138313293, -0.5046270489692688, 0.12039848417043686, -0.232634037733078, -0.5269731283187866, -0.14226926863193512, -0.842069685459137, -0.5505259037017822, 0.02549601159989834, 0.3791710436344147, -0.5888497829437256, -0.16323144733905792, -0.04778361693024635, -0.18736858665943146, 0.15996861457824707, 0.461514413356781, -1.0255218744277954, 0.16347697377204895, 0.5727261900901794, 0.8349704742431641, -0.11828599870204926, -0.5030560493469238, -1.0663949251174927, -0.18039879202842712, -0.11486971378326416, 0.5792887806892395, -0.31878599524497986, -0.49621906876564026, -0.1146269217133522, -0.3195017874240875, -0.03942355513572693, -0.41100776195526123, 0.2664352357387543, -0.6095523834228516, 0.5205715894699097, -0.1713019460439682, -0.23611676692962646, 0.09901654720306396, 0.46615785360336304, -0.4994693100452423, 0.7732413411140442, 0.11942113190889359, -0.8384224772453308, 0.39046844840049744, -0.8083707094192505, -0.39379265904426575, 0.46013718843460083, -0.29298338294029236, -0.4551165997982025, -0.474481463432312, 0.1250038892030716, 0.629477322101593, -0.25333669781684875, 0.33352991938591003, -0.2594883143901825, -0.24286453425884247, 0.14005008339881897, -0.282340407371521, 0.9974493980407715, -0.027075497433543205, -0.4249136447906494, 0.6635040640830994, -0.5544337630271912, 0.11353901773691177, 0.11233261227607727, -0.49075841903686523, -0.14740824699401855, -0.19579967856407166, -0.02808508276939392, 0.24898667633533478, 0.03043786808848381, -0.2830725908279419, -0.16325269639492035, -0.03905943036079407, 0.2607244849205017, 0.884675920009613, -0.07911547273397446, 0.4828343093395233, -0.48440903425216675, 0.9414602518081665, -0.19973592460155487, 0.10220973938703537, 0.07787201553583145, -0.5258035659790039, -0.6155214309692383, -0.51767498254776, 0.1412954181432724, 0.9228058457374573, -1.0231555700302124, 0.5326439738273621, 0.03074989840388298, -0.46039026975631714, -0.4781300723552704, -0.09322962909936905, 0.6711100339889526, 0.9067986607551575, 0.4678635597229004, -0.09343618899583817, -0.4706997871398926, -0.7186123728752136, -0.174075186252594, -0.4570484459400177, 0.00901277270168066, 0.3587656319141388, 0.5061212182044983, -0.34316015243530273, 0.8899672627449036, -0.33185645937919617, -0.09659668058156967, -0.5921589732170105, 0.5727779269218445, -0.17227110266685486, 0.5514775514602661, 0.5278844833374023, -0.722931444644928, -0.7422168850898743, 0.021470682695508003, -0.712309718132019, -0.16128265857696533, -0.15535642206668854, 0.1411757916212082, 0.3683670163154602, 0.5544547438621521, -0.2459159940481186, 0.05793672800064087, 0.7708835601806641, -0.45292356610298157, 0.7017496824264526, -0.07144160568714142, 0.120628222823143, -0.8144292831420898, 0.04842449724674225, 0.19496282935142517, -0.30448850989341736, -0.6520589590072632, 0.3162698447704315, 0.03223990276455879, -0.30750030279159546, -0.46835872530937195, 0.5266752243041992, -0.3892281949520111, 0.29307445883750916, 0.1284913867712021, 0.1207980141043663, -0.21994146704673767, 0.6793648600578308, -0.00007793684198986739, 1.0531376600265503, 0.4616164267063141, -0.651325523853302, 0.670015811920166, 0.04530121758580208, -0.14885586500167847, 0.47555795311927795, -0.7780303359031677, 0.14245398342609406, -0.26057693362236023, 0.23270626366138458, -0.8586975932121277, -0.21055257320404053, 0.4280422031879425, -0.48275333642959595, 0.467599093914032, -0.2944793701171875, -0.13279908895492554, -0.2630839943885803, -0.31027951836586, 0.3852747082710266, 0.7062886953353882, -0.6291688680648804, 0.1863652765750885, 0.28684577345848083, -0.4528955817222595, -0.7223507165908813, -0.6805657744407654, 0.011146558448672295, -0.4331936836242676, -0.717701256275177, 0.15838487446308136, -0.12997335195541382, -0.2601160407066345, -0.09096736460924149, 0.37818190455436707, -0.2353031486272812, 0.5224300026893616, 0.08874420821666718, 0.35776081681251526, -0.17156778275966644, 0.006300056353211403, -0.3369814157485962, -0.10907343775033951, 0.011267040856182575, 0.04989524930715561, 0.7033916115760803, -0.4331870377063751, -0.07326804846525192, -0.4341103136539459, 0.4978189468383789, 0.3451025187969208, -0.24166326224803925, 0.9150373935699463, 0.537822425365448, -0.1397363841533661, -0.6133460998535156, -0.035977739840745926, -0.5579638481140137, -0.5039930939674377, 0.49090084433555603, -0.015269099734723568, -1.163742184638977, 0.558426022529602, 0.2753184735774994, -0.11584746837615967, 0.0563884973526001, 0.5261420607566833, -0.2936631143093109, 0.8014963865280151, 0.6282174587249756, -0.11670958250761032, 0.5390331149101257, -0.03076000139117241, -0.012148869223892689, -0.4336865246295929, -0.1563999503850937, -0.515103816986084, -0.16097047924995422, -0.34410735964775085, -0.4317281246185303, 0.4568818509578705, 0.1243370771408081, -0.44534245133399963, 0.2806093096733093, -0.4141445755958557, 0.5827969312667847, 0.708360493183136, 0.07760582864284515, -0.11355813592672348, -0.21488945186138153, -0.3907487690448761, -0.09673991799354553, -1.0988264083862305, -0.30889394879341125, 0.5681806802749634, 0.4362185597419739, 0.9108566641807556, 0.36662134528160095, 0.8025785088539124, 0.21971860527992249, 0.42269930243492126, -0.7308511137962341, 0.7018719911575317, 0.2162684053182602, -0.3876272439956665, -0.5604843497276306, -0.7728697061538696, -0.7905942797660828, 0.08523790538311005, -0.40581318736076355, -0.41561052203178406, -0.2820211946964264, 0.4450329840183258, -0.6011834144592285, 0.07105937600135803, -0.7556224465370178, 0.77800053358078, -0.2875043451786041, -0.35886305570602417, 0.10481138527393341, -0.7923388481140137, 0.4033351540565491, 0.06919658929109573, -0.051486920565366745, 0.2638084292411804, 0.28619271516799927, 0.6631459593772888, -0.4042350649833679, 1.1776540279388428, -0.26368898153305054, -0.23734857141971588, 0.23842310905456543, 0.28930673003196716, 0.8100463151931763, 0.04237129166722298, 0.1488017588853836, -0.07619545608758926, -0.7923316359519958, -0.25315403938293457, -0.6803902983665466, 0.4502796232700348, -0.600791871547699, -0.6690317392349243, -0.3681531548500061, -0.5140376091003418, -0.30001771450042725, 0.05927583575248718, 0.4348614513874054, 0.2738860845565796, -0.41048988699913025, -0.1460614800453186, 0.6811366081237793, -0.45280131697654724, 0.7075017690658569, 0.4656745493412018, 0.019483070820569992, -0.505062460899353, 1.0340397357940674, -0.20407319068908691, 0.36220553517341614, 0.3589576184749603, 0.1499951332807541, -0.3261908292770386, -0.6577243208885193, -0.5369204878807068, -0.006521915551275015, -0.5501687526702881, -0.30396199226379395, -0.3765689730644226, -0.2529294788837433, -0.13315238058567047, -0.4217861294746399, -0.13336744904518127, -0.2524130642414093, -0.3169352114200592, -0.17723755538463593, 0.3126164376735687, 0.4344427287578583, -0.22662310302257538, 0.17831498384475708, -0.9009777307510376, 0.0029459178913384676, 0.6620922684669495, 0.2915641963481903, -0.14512665569782257, -0.2048356980085373, -0.14553654193878174, 0.004972151480615139, -0.15953712165355682, -0.7159937024116516, 0.4741455912590027, -0.1667061746120453, 0.4124208092689514, 0.06598358601331711, 0.2358667105436325, 0.38722971081733704, -0.5752547979354858, 0.8048332333564758, 0.6799414157867432, -0.7949047684669495, 0.4997570514678955, -0.771404504776001, 0.0056927138939499855, 0.5531299710273743, 0.3587813973426819, -0.5559298992156982, -0.38332271575927734, -0.44840702414512634, -0.6436766386032104, 0.6317728757858276, 0.1212075799703598, -0.1570432186126709, -0.1456480473279953, -0.10036688297986984, -0.01393184345215559, 0.004030704498291016, -0.8213103413581848, -0.27658694982528687, -0.1658133566379547, -0.3297264277935028, -0.10908912122249603, -0.06489045172929764, -0.42600947618484497, 0.20143136382102966, 0.5919024348258972, -0.19838367402553558, 0.28223153948783875, 0.11271099001169205, -0.06253272294998169, -0.24627704918384552, 0.35421350598335266, 0.8492380380630493, 0.12846070528030396, -0.12586665153503418, 0.0670701339840889, 0.10688943415880203, -0.2409842163324356, 0.3269065320491791, 0.028355689719319344, -0.2168053239583969, -0.21684131026268005, 0.5372447967529297, 0.8286537528038025, -0.13138002157211304, -0.6858185529708862, 0.6489375233650208, -0.41623178124427795, -0.32339799404144287, 0.22071708738803864, 0.4803251028060913, -0.04771142080426216, 0.22812694311141968, 0.06050875410437584, 0.3975392282009125, -0.21508485078811646, -0.4411959648132324, 0.3007621169090271, 0.64778733253479, -0.6090985536575317, -0.31427323818206787, 0.6488159894943237, 0.7348856925964355, -0.5625830888748169, 0.5044093728065491, -0.49189868569374084, -0.9309307336807251, 0.64111328125, 0.5368120670318604, 0.9355428218841553, -0.403041809797287, 0.486028254032135, 0.2562030255794525, 0.31034499406814575, -0.12508128583431244, 0.31021538376808167, 0.18513505160808563, -0.892027735710144, -0.43502071499824524, -0.2303408831357956, -0.5300412178039551, 0.16824547946453094, -0.6540420055389404, 0.10675514489412308, -0.5927116274833679, 0.008813188411295414, -0.5071583986282349, -0.26713576912879944, -0.31821271777153015, 0.2731894254684448, -0.026049301028251648, 0.5840258002281189, -0.8834019899368286, 0.5053533315658569, 0.849067211151123, -0.4574730098247528, -0.7034873962402344, 0.18117396533489227, 0.04291429743170738, -0.7668111324310303, 0.9109544157981873, -0.04732838273048401, -0.26100417971611023, -0.08181339502334595, -0.47960907220840454, -0.46279919147491455, 0.9048976302146912, 0.5525770783424377, -0.6751745343208313, -0.008893575519323349, -0.15039882063865662, 0.5335929989814758, -0.05363880842924118, -0.023257236927747726, 0.053636617958545685, 0.24862344563007355, -0.09084616601467133, -1.0199062824249268, 0.2328505516052246, -0.11886043101549149, -0.25475582480430603, 0.2971816062927246, -0.8098829388618469, 1.0296504497528076, -0.5611321330070496, -0.5841193795204163, -0.135311096906662, 0.5815647840499878, 0.4958147406578064, 0.06620629876852036, 0.46978840231895447, 0.5091961622238159, 1.0539097785949707, 0.014643851667642593, 0.9566429853439331, -0.11388728767633438, 0.44504863023757935, 1.3360192775726318, -0.23738206923007965, 0.6029669046401978, 0.24404942989349365, 0.051169831305742264, 0.3321019113063812, 0.393045037984848, 0.0541125163435936, 0.6750613451004028, 0.3977099359035492, -0.49797120690345764, -0.3149814307689667, 0.12813301384449005, -0.37150734663009644, 0.07913640141487122, 0.13986016809940338, -0.14977140724658966, -0.19052466750144958, -0.18131311237812042, 0.09006168693304062, 0.19857238233089447, -0.2689169645309448, 0.6503878831863403, -0.09287091344594955, -0.7816500663757324, 0.8074924349784851, -0.05295430123806, 0.9414792060852051, -0.3766137957572937, 0.020142829045653343, -0.2759849727153778, 0.07579050958156586, 0.0078389598056674, -0.5881642699241638, 0.2028503268957138, 0.25013968348503113, -0.23345601558685303, -0.22284191846847534, 0.6138638257980347, -0.6193684339523315, -0.16201423108577728, 0.40239638090133667, 0.47988852858543396, -0.30646419525146484, 0.27991652488708496, -0.8923615217208862, -0.19505451619625092, 0.040788404643535614, -0.035736747086048126, 0.4314967393875122, 0.3654600977897644, -0.004899672232568264, 0.9070290923118591, 0.5322506427764893, 0.07268019020557404, 0.10893077403306961, -0.042718105018138885, 0.7571558356285095, -0.7023374438285828, -0.6046841740608215, -0.8694003224372864, 0.5068397521972656, 0.03649595379829407, -0.2732728123664856, 0.632120668888092, 0.1865917295217514, 0.6806671023368835, -0.17924436926841736, 1.1931794881820679, 0.14583879709243774, 0.41342461109161377, -0.6312281489372253, 1.0117666721343994, -0.20295193791389465, 0.20896314084529877, -0.22459650039672852, -0.47659245133399963, -0.5950595140457153, 0.866058886051178, -0.026869678869843483, 0.2452087700366974, 0.6879597902297974, 0.9876804351806641, 0.139438197016716, 0.015944385901093483, 0.38505977392196655, 0.14935021102428436, 0.441449910402298, 0.7205643653869629, 1.0426666736602783, -0.08061394095420837, 0.5864608287811279, -0.024015510454773903, -0.30542799830436707, -0.25702375173568726, -1.0192534923553467, -1.173724889755249, -0.4337724447250366, -0.4463535249233246, -0.5462121963500977, 0.4214884638786316, 0.9592433571815491, 0.6138483285903931, -0.7309992909431458, -0.038269080221652985, -0.526466965675354, 0.03246720880270004, -0.12820614874362946, -0.2891456186771393, 0.05832160264253616, -0.6055045127868652, -0.4243924915790558, 0.6085672974586487, 0.07388924062252045, 0.46554237604141235, -0.19034314155578613, -0.4722728729248047, 0.11308323591947556, -0.28787174820899963, 0.37261295318603516, 0.4393727481365204, -0.39203161001205444, -0.49677640199661255, -0.14250795543193817, -0.3120891749858856, -0.10129240155220032, 0.6261972188949585, -0.7256776094436646, 0.1682543009519577, 0.4982311725616455, 0.807313859462738, -0.12287580966949463, -0.027036502957344055, 1.0674504041671753, -0.9575446248054504, -0.12400022894144058, 0.5800925493240356, 0.3137395977973938, 0.4892897605895996, -0.36594271659851074, 0.5253629684448242, 0.19033214449882507, -0.5561514496803284, -0.8685150742530823, 0.3952442407608032, -0.7693976163864136, -0.2549743950366974, 1.367678165435791, -0.32032182812690735, -0.005520480219274759, -0.2971132695674896, -0.27518415451049805, 0.14143052697181702, -0.6341315507888794, 0.8661937713623047, 0.47554251551628113, -0.15488719940185547, -0.11045785248279572, 0.05495292693376541, 0.8078439235687256, 0.5419771075248718, -0.7550085783004761, 0.21700115501880646, 0.5193449854850769, 0.24378643929958344, 0.16409604251384735, 0.5195249319076538, 0.38325023651123047, 0.5534839630126953, -0.034128788858652115, 0.07098164409399033, -0.13535837829113007, -0.547416090965271, -0.6863945722579956, 0.4482627511024475, -0.11357268691062927, -0.111737459897995 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16646v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16646v1	Incoherent Probability Judgments in Large Language Models	2024-01-30T00:40:49	2024-01-30T00:40:49	Jian-Qiao Zhu, Thomas L. Griffiths	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Autoregressive Large Language Models (LLMs) trained for next-word prediction have demonstrated remarkable proficiency at producing coherent text. But are they equally adept at forming coherent probability judgments? We use probabilistic identities and repeated judgments to assess the coherence of probability judgments made by LLMs. Our results show that the judgments produced by these models are often incoherent, displaying human-like systematic deviations from the rules of probability theory. Moreover, when prompted to judge the same event, the mean-variance relationship of probability judgments produced by LLMs shows an inverted-U-shaped like that seen in humans. We propose that these deviations from rationality can be explained by linking autoregressive LLMs to implicit Bayesian inference and drawing parallels with the Bayesian Sampler model of human probability judgments.	[ -0.04249133542180061, -0.6972923874855042, 0.7670134902000427, 0.04303393140435219, -0.09657622128725052, -0.1126406192779541, -0.05352375656366348, -0.669596791267395, 0.027170797809958458, 0.5046188831329346, -0.3100075125694275, -0.26947537064552307, -0.6102569699287415, -0.052419066429138184, -0.5684207677841187, 0.8227730393409729, 0.10336336493492126, 0.08668962121009827, -0.0884920284152031, -0.05676883086562157, -0.2812210023403168, -0.5887660384178162, -0.7788527011871338, -0.5862212777137756, 0.2840617597103119, 0.1397799551486969, 1.0556397438049316, 0.39665699005126953, 0.45262035727500916, 0.28020545840263367, 0.3988170325756073, -0.40613865852355957, -0.19326283037662506, 0.29295629262924194, -0.19464723765850067, -0.6367937922477722, -0.31383538246154785, 0.1676688939332962, 0.6751980781555176, 1.0203008651733398, -0.15162041783332825, -0.12301710993051529, 0.23149248957633972, 0.5558087825775146, -0.4612506031990051, 0.3207457363605499, -0.8337967395782471, 0.042529791593551636, -0.04780537635087967, -0.05261712148785591, -0.5473647713661194, -0.35341760516166687, 0.33287885785102844, -0.33524057269096375, 0.39012137055397034, 0.16931861639022827, 0.42844387888908386, -0.06410812586545944, -0.4232833683490753, -0.3993692398071289, -0.7450792193412781, 0.8510288596153259, -0.6484250426292419, 0.4820663630962372, 0.41391193866729736, 0.207595556974411, -0.5634269714355469, -0.41765096783638, -0.8634837865829468, -0.585184633731842, 0.1507357358932495, 0.1965479850769043, -0.17796334624290466, 0.09840274602174759, 0.1773560494184494, 0.18392615020275116, -0.6643000841140747, 0.14680249989032745, 0.1596531867980957, -0.08345897495746613, 1.0637270212173462, 0.1563326120376587, 0.08106786012649536, -0.03622705489397049, -0.3744695484638214, -0.21845483779907227, -0.7343694567680359, -0.06316853314638138, 0.5617305636405945, -0.14140819013118744, -0.01194837037473917, 0.717070460319519, -0.1915128529071808, 0.6186348795890808, 0.1910001039505005, -0.3605920076370239, 0.06125180795788765, 0.04523841664195061, -0.35025402903556824, -0.05899864807724953, 0.9056951403617859, 0.19719991087913513, 0.6124221682548523, -0.08816573023796082, -0.16563449800014496, 0.19430334866046906, -0.022148849442601204, -0.2618824541568756, -0.6069291234016418, 0.3450522720813751, -0.40473198890686035, -0.1446669101715088, 0.25019240379333496, -0.299387127161026, -0.2805953919887543, -0.31894153356552124, 0.484001487493515, -0.5739143490791321, -0.14510610699653625, 0.23578016459941864, -0.04059818759560585, 0.13587063550949097, 0.6801396012306213, -0.787619948387146, 0.2841099202632904, 0.5604903697967529, 0.41506141424179077, -0.3489701747894287, -0.6052874326705933, -0.40734875202178955, 0.173481285572052, -0.6689477562904358, 0.9593231678009033, -0.41513094305992126, -0.15963463485240936, -0.010163113474845886, -0.05817365646362305, 0.09440615028142929, -0.49424153566360474, 0.26684415340423584, -0.5620830655097961, 0.008932583965361118, 0.08928090333938599, -0.722453773021698, -0.2555619478225708, -0.05876319110393524, -0.4501878023147583, 0.5755810737609863, -0.15670588612556458, -0.6670934557914734, 0.7140809893608093, 0.1088123768568039, -0.3078514039516449, 0.2592551112174988, -0.4013916552066803, -0.239024356007576, 0.3280220329761505, -0.2575181722640991, 0.5165442228317261, -0.0529826395213604, 0.45201706886291504, -0.7222023606300354, -0.06719017028808594, 0.6574751734733582, -0.8513915538787842, 0.5798720717430115, 0.05284983292222023, -0.3329610228538513, -0.00552488025277853, -0.6206555366516113, -0.03355421498417854, -0.0820537656545639, -0.29978397488594055, -0.3456128239631653, 0.47177475690841675, -0.07001195847988129, 0.25937092304229736, 0.07784860581159592, -0.250227153301239, 0.15618711709976196, -0.4648907780647278, 0.13823147118091583, 0.7397549748420715, -0.06400178372859955, 0.576366662979126, -0.5608360767364502, 0.1400451958179474, 0.11285438388586044, 0.10978611558675766, -0.018520718440413475, -0.7085193991661072, -0.7595849633216858, -0.21743479371070862, -0.051319420337677, 0.5049979090690613, -0.39966896176338196, 0.5390815138816833, -0.17331847548484802, -0.42934945225715637, -0.10148414969444275, 0.06323300302028656, 0.0732492059469223, 0.2528197169303894, 0.09469520300626755, -0.5173949599266052, -0.3989975154399872, -0.8584803342819214, -0.6319409608840942, -0.6493563055992126, -0.0694999098777771, -0.03302542865276337, 0.6190484762191772, -0.23835346102714539, 0.840717613697052, -0.06994346529245377, -0.057417046278715134, -0.13452234864234924, 0.33743345737457275, 0.2727484703063965, 0.5278496146202087, 0.1432233601808548, -0.5435340404510498, -0.32195213437080383, -0.20427305996418, -0.6253969669342041, -0.03677569702267647, -0.1948373168706894, -0.015288345515727997, 0.6530255079269409, 0.47517144680023193, -0.5183082818984985, 0.5492392182350159, 0.5247342586517334, -0.5142570734024048, 0.6237910389900208, -0.3010583221912384, 0.054438114166259766, -0.8088759779930115, -0.39542728662490845, 0.017415717244148254, -0.4425053298473358, -0.27998030185699463, -0.23178021609783173, -0.2606062889099121, 0.5556740164756775, -0.05854329466819763, 0.6499578356742859, -0.49819472432136536, -0.36155790090560913, -0.20186224579811096, 0.11253306269645691, -0.0808129608631134, 0.03279457613825798, 0.19636304676532745, 0.32526472210884094, 0.28725340962409973, -0.6501607894897461, 0.3573549687862396, -0.014044191688299179, -0.6692033410072327, 0.4974237382411957, -0.47294625639915466, -0.2815406322479248, -0.21994546055793762, 0.4546671509742737, -1.2848050594329834, -0.6166509985923767, -0.004585913848131895, -0.34753555059432983, 0.3793582320213318, 0.07711413502693176, -0.6767048835754395, -0.2155631184577942, -0.08745550364255905, 0.35496044158935547, 0.686008632183075, -0.5215005874633789, 0.36619600653648376, 0.501903772354126, -0.3173583149909973, -0.4599650502204895, -1.0570372343063354, -0.042040493339300156, 0.07750437408685684, -0.45986637473106384, 0.15815071761608124, -0.11241907626390457, -0.7737900614738464, -0.1996627002954483, -0.0009339739917777479, -0.19752858579158783, 0.14461977779865265, 0.31154340505599976, 0.27985718846321106, 0.08135759085416794, 0.27457424998283386, 0.06679313629865646, 0.1705053299665451, 0.2644835114479065, -0.29884180426597595, 0.4262131452560425, 0.033246900886297226, -0.8363728523254395, -0.6460683941841125, 0.431871235370636, 0.4343568682670593, 0.44532978534698486, 0.5383608937263489, 0.017574617639183998, -0.3281879723072052, -0.00762394443154335, -0.8447224497795105, -0.2552941143512726, -0.30747509002685547, 0.3867950141429901, -0.5751808285713196, -0.8983886241912842, 0.5749905705451965, 0.44253262877464294, 0.001589211169630289, 0.748021125793457, 0.6724159717559814, -0.41325467824935913, 1.1753413677215576, 0.32988134026527405, 0.21490776538848877, 0.34266161918640137, 0.06735222041606903, -0.08005259931087494, -0.4331521689891815, -0.14226512610912323, -0.22537468373775482, 0.10552875697612762, -0.7645577788352966, -0.3494572341442108, 0.18522340059280396, 0.3813945949077606, -0.43700501322746277, -0.05244448781013489, -0.01442776806652546, 0.39521947503089905, 0.46428433060646057, -0.05693194642663002, 0.4723767340183258, 0.041289687156677246, -0.12788435816764832, -0.09361594915390015, -0.8321182727813721, -0.6700120568275452, 0.8534418344497681, 0.3775936961174011, 1.0111887454986572, 0.18861034512519836, 0.7118101716041565, 0.33289313316345215, 0.6148688197135925, -0.6548616886138916, 0.3700788617134094, -0.036379050463438034, -0.43182575702667236, -0.3214130699634552, -0.4417857527732849, -1.047723650932312, 0.2938217520713806, -0.3862665891647339, -0.8574117422103882, 0.28421705961227417, 0.20767273008823395, -0.15412458777427673, 0.19468224048614502, -0.4229845404624939, 0.5861066579818726, -0.14468318223953247, -0.29490020871162415, -0.2857277989387512, -0.4493715763092041, 0.6466630101203918, -0.2048245370388031, 0.3628602921962738, -0.38336384296417236, -0.13405805826187134, 0.4135400056838989, -0.35437217354774475, 0.9813182353973389, 0.1857299953699112, -0.3638036549091339, 0.3585067689418793, 0.4870133101940155, 0.5729395151138306, 0.32926616072654724, -0.10068849474191666, 0.37736499309539795, -0.12838810682296753, -0.2797880470752716, -0.38917315006256104, 0.5285989046096802, -0.7016234397888184, -0.583145797252655, -0.6926408410072327, -0.6982678174972534, -0.12248039990663528, -0.08726838231086731, 0.5162860155105591, 0.3051392436027527, -0.45194050669670105, -0.1497122049331665, 0.5126147270202637, -0.16744720935821533, 0.4570170044898987, 0.612322986125946, -0.27724677324295044, -0.4630122780799866, 0.4673328697681427, 0.31368061900138855, 0.47470980882644653, 0.2352263480424881, -0.10052546113729477, -0.43770599365234375, -0.47762009501457214, -0.08458803594112396, 0.21763348579406738, -0.6460273861885071, 0.01952580362558365, -0.6768113970756531, -0.05765919014811516, -0.513226330280304, -0.22568321228027344, -0.1560412049293518, -0.5030282735824585, -0.22869162261486053, 0.16376693546772003, 0.09058550000190735, 1.0140786170959473, -0.10774149000644684, 0.2134225219488144, -0.6989079117774963, 0.06927131116390228, 0.5235524773597717, 0.17522743344306946, -0.10577184706926346, -0.8956451416015625, 0.035561706870794296, -0.04772820696234703, -0.13657598197460175, -0.8269563317298889, 0.5399598479270935, 0.27724480628967285, 0.6281500458717346, 0.4707585871219635, -0.11278294026851654, 0.4718324542045593, -0.59839928150177, 0.5879973769187927, 0.439486026763916, -0.8747486472129822, 0.37095022201538086, -0.3933984637260437, 0.46935373544692993, 0.3237411081790924, 0.39708390831947327, -0.2534492015838623, -0.9604271650314331, -0.8493312001228333, -0.5774275064468384, 0.5194547176361084, 0.01280037872493267, 0.26111721992492676, -0.39220067858695984, 0.23710429668426514, 0.5679871439933777, 0.11177560687065125, -0.8577288389205933, -0.0515717975795269, 0.19351531565189362, -0.27111396193504333, -0.3367454409599304, -0.6276895999908447, 0.19935227930545807, -0.07751116156578064, 0.659082293510437, -0.23040840029716492, 0.12662099301815033, 0.43373334407806396, -0.1791895180940628, -0.19427016377449036, 0.19040381908416748, 0.47359952330589294, 0.7132781147956848, -0.11530691385269165, 0.20939363539218903, 0.2664088010787964, -0.32990381121635437, 0.24285940825939178, -0.029663866385817528, -0.07467015832662582, 0.07332820445299149, 0.7434054613113403, 0.5513465404510498, 0.44830581545829773, -0.5765030980110168, 0.6236253976821899, -0.17330153286457062, -0.19158612191677094, -0.739712655544281, 0.1132250651717186, 0.07331980019807816, 0.5038275122642517, 0.5092606544494629, 0.24420221149921417, 0.19575569033622742, -0.8462512493133545, 0.16871361434459686, 0.6543378233909607, -0.17215120792388916, -0.4125998318195343, 0.5671842694282532, -0.30278506875038147, -0.09590785950422287, 0.3561791181564331, -0.24314379692077637, -0.34185245633125305, 0.42140576243400574, 0.5021470189094543, 0.9264352917671204, -0.33700379729270935, 0.01178348995745182, 0.28412777185440063, 0.35223904252052307, -0.541443407535553, 0.43819281458854675, -0.072031170129776, -0.902790367603302, -0.5541505217552185, -0.807387113571167, -0.5212685465812683, -0.030587755143642426, -0.5012247562408447, 0.16482673585414886, -0.2863217294216156, -0.2536081075668335, 0.014698844403028488, -0.3350270092487335, -0.43953168392181396, 0.27462971210479736, 0.2742743194103241, 0.6858144998550415, -0.8123565316200256, 0.9723179340362549, 0.48621422052383423, -0.32846367359161377, -0.634829580783844, 0.3085572123527527, -0.24845339357852936, -0.5805559158325195, 0.9344791173934937, 0.024883929640054703, 0.04206212982535362, -0.11821109801530838, -0.6463671922683716, -1.0543822050094604, 0.7203777432441711, 0.5711301565170288, -0.7861687541007996, 0.15374086797237396, -0.0018760955426841974, 0.47155311703681946, -0.5941290855407715, 0.27814754843711853, 0.3870176076889038, 0.17096394300460815, 0.03424297645688057, -0.8927191495895386, -0.2120204120874405, 0.2987363338470459, 0.17844901978969574, 0.027146082371473312, -0.5312585234642029, 1.1085338592529297, -0.40025874972343445, -0.33544203639030457, 0.11844456940889359, 0.8846355080604553, 0.4824228882789612, 0.26271694898605347, 0.4624181091785431, 0.621295690536499, 0.6581730842590332, -0.03931374102830887, 1.2506581544876099, -0.21700116991996765, 0.3317100703716278, 1.4217522144317627, -0.3088637888431549, 1.1946483850479126, 0.4159654378890991, -0.4658242166042328, 0.7586593627929688, 0.5129768252372742, 0.19764524698257446, 0.2112099975347519, 0.21346087753772736, -0.4100162088871002, -0.5447770953178406, 0.3055714964866638, -0.1102999895811081, 0.5099664926528931, 0.4102626144886017, -0.44754213094711304, -0.08171550184488297, -0.1343115121126175, -0.21696379780769348, -0.11464163661003113, -0.2981414496898651, 0.8796260952949524, 0.41085392236709595, -0.8906357288360596, 0.30415263772010803, -0.1707758903503418, 0.6203019618988037, -0.3205100893974304, -0.031868673861026764, -0.03578260913491249, 0.23613253235816956, -0.18030954897403717, -1.077534556388855, 0.4759879410266876, -0.2708412706851959, -0.4353542923927307, 0.07707323133945465, 0.6733511686325073, -0.5033068060874939, -0.4840751886367798, 0.4047923982143402, 0.5625666975975037, 0.5030378699302673, 0.01610013097524643, -0.6456329226493835, -0.1765357255935669, -0.16825833916664124, -0.3130587935447693, 0.3368394672870636, 0.46198147535324097, -0.296568363904953, 0.6475635766983032, 0.5951117873191833, 0.14209116995334625, 0.2638864517211914, -0.00789248663932085, 0.154386967420578, -0.5876805782318115, -0.28230005502700806, -1.0456982851028442, 0.07481414824724197, 0.20781144499778748, -0.1473356932401657, 0.7932518720626831, 0.2793462574481964, 0.9364637732505798, -0.09923278540372849, 0.9047806859016418, 0.32682469487190247, 0.30230581760406494, -0.5131674408912659, 0.6960616111755371, -0.4315578043460846, 0.1761603057384491, -0.047576647251844406, -0.9898046255111694, -0.24630612134933472, 0.8355964422225952, -0.43821603059768677, 0.07569795101881027, 0.5841214656829834, 0.3640998899936676, 0.25268685817718506, -0.00385633809491992, 0.6383933424949646, 0.536507248878479, -0.1137731596827507, 0.567543625831604, 0.9275972843170166, -0.3659816384315491, 0.2077110856771469, 0.11252464354038239, -0.26724645495414734, -0.30261820554733276, -0.7853832840919495, -0.7165958285331726, -0.4916452169418335, -0.45051267743110657, -0.45052143931388855, -0.023254163563251495, 0.8731528520584106, 0.40606558322906494, -0.9781492352485657, -0.45800918340682983, -0.6599900126457214, 0.02309279888868332, 0.12448728829622269, -0.32660651206970215, 0.14203406870365143, -0.552182137966156, -0.7140147686004639, 0.12330581247806549, 0.4960353672504425, 0.39904022216796875, -0.4000566601753235, 0.0976211354136467, -0.12584593892097473, 0.33659112453460693, 0.6435368061065674, 0.10905379056930542, -0.9587051868438721, -0.3716390132904053, -0.5403964519500732, -0.4789807200431824, -0.08060947805643082, 0.2746518552303314, -0.7739037871360779, 0.4171036183834076, 0.6397806406021118, 0.04815065860748291, 0.20661033689975739, -0.29195767641067505, 0.8503962755203247, -0.14824610948562622, 0.19084729254245758, 0.25895100831985474, 0.6489671468734741, 0.2883507311344147, -0.07765425741672516, 0.2752922475337982, 0.38497060537338257, -0.7054354548454285, -0.655254602432251, 0.5381994843482971, -0.8199923038482666, -0.17875713109970093, 1.1370645761489868, -0.2657042145729065, -0.3147384226322174, -0.3786199688911438, 0.17334602773189545, 0.15863193571567535, -0.32708799839019775, 0.7776080369949341, 0.864281177520752, -0.48607224225997925, 0.004093043971806765, -0.6437034606933594, 0.47725924849510193, 0.5557448267936707, -0.5930865406990051, -0.1146145686507225, 0.7041990756988525, 0.4033408463001251, 0.054718729108572006, 0.606214165687561, -0.07686654478311539, 0.3842112720012665, 0.23641620576381683, 0.11883106827735901, 0.7434344291687012, -0.08843360841274261, -0.47771182656288147, 0.1696448028087616, 0.26583024859428406, 0.39192625880241394 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16640v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16640v3	TeenyTinyLlama: open-source tiny language models trained in Brazilian Portuguese	2024-01-30T00:25:54	2024-05-17T12:36:21	Nicholas Kluge Corrêa, Sophia Falk, Shiza Fatimah, Aniket Sen, Nythamar de Oliveira	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.LG	Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced natural language processing, but their progress has yet to be equal across languages. While most LLMs are trained in high-resource languages like English, multilingual models generally underperform monolingual ones. Additionally, aspects of their multilingual foundation sometimes restrict the byproducts they produce, like computational demands and licensing regimes. In this study, we document the development of open-foundation models tailored for use in low-resource settings, their limitations, and their benefits. This is the TeenyTinyLlama pair: two compact models for Brazilian Portuguese text generation. We release them under the permissive Apache 2.0 license on GitHub and Hugging Face for community use and further development. See https://github.com/Nkluge-correa/TeenyTinyLlama	[ -0.11688955128192902, -0.8381324410438538, 0.47672268748283386, 0.5891062021255493, -0.24191515147686005, -0.13158725202083588, -0.695688009262085, -0.6014718413352966, 0.21318696439266205, 0.7611115574836731, -0.4682200253009796, -0.4534212648868561, -0.5164461731910706, 0.15301848948001862, -0.25918835401535034, 1.028523325920105, 0.0018026242032647133, 0.2477545589208603, -0.03129008039832115, -0.23312270641326904, -0.13596074283123016, -0.06201157346367836, -0.776379406452179, -0.26439711451530457, 0.6035819053649902, 0.7059769034385681, 0.7041580080986023, 0.6040007472038269, 0.38290926814079285, 0.3137119710445404, -0.30075404047966003, -0.1971486210823059, -0.6639772653579712, 0.150085911154747, -0.30987459421157837, -0.26344120502471924, -0.23044009506702423, -0.1356436312198639, 0.8005553483963013, 0.6668688654899597, -0.07113360613584518, 0.16811075806617737, 0.04512735828757286, 0.4953213334083557, -0.3881763517856598, 0.19791680574417114, -0.6104393601417542, -0.3134100139141083, -0.36026862263679504, 0.07442105561494827, -0.2915077805519104, -0.7648707628250122, 0.231062114238739, -0.36748266220092773, 0.273275762796402, -0.29647818207740784, 0.5542290210723877, 0.07533919811248779, -0.5627927780151367, -0.673030436038971, -0.6106691956520081, 0.6705416440963745, -0.48711034655570984, 0.16861680150032043, 0.06390181928873062, 0.3708840012550354, -0.1663963943719864, -0.5195592641830444, -0.49767714738845825, -0.4980832636356354, -0.09021224826574326, -0.20441515743732452, -0.18666788935661316, 0.044602055102586746, -0.21768943965435028, 0.49080392718315125, -0.7619495391845703, 0.25968465209007263, -0.8764248490333557, 0.12083250284194946, 0.6109076142311096, -0.06639743596315384, 0.3465439975261688, -0.4086514115333557, -0.2816201150417328, 0.11620020121335983, -1.1054390668869019, -0.29015982151031494, 0.384488970041275, 0.9400149583816528, -0.4270465672016144, 0.6450811624526978, -0.06776108592748642, 0.6445691585540771, -0.5136184692382812, -0.31947875022888184, -0.05040957033634186, -0.38253480195999146, -0.20467965304851532, 0.06010714918375015, 0.8701023459434509, -0.14830844104290009, 0.39407023787498474, -0.35753893852233887, -0.14925599098205566, 0.3273274898529053, 0.08701298385858536, -0.9671761393547058, -0.08872495591640472, 0.16702306270599365, -0.46155208349227905, -0.22198271751403809, -0.5168600082397461, -0.6615044474601746, -0.39555537700653076, -0.2710903286933899, 0.39044076204299927, -0.30710557103157043, -0.4456591010093689, 0.08630876988172531, 0.23229610919952393, -0.3642055094242096, 0.3000369966030121, -0.8357167840003967, 0.315263032913208, 0.4725918471813202, 1.082823634147644, -0.05928724631667137, -0.15823696553707123, -0.1781993806362152, 0.06494851410388947, -0.2106490135192871, 0.7240710854530334, -0.305017352104187, -0.6314103007316589, 0.11700743436813354, 0.04385530576109886, -0.009848355315625668, -0.5621437430381775, 0.7437918782234192, -0.20798812806606293, 0.03653840348124504, 0.10287109762430191, -0.038740113377571106, 0.10050389170646667, 0.10967040061950684, -0.6489807963371277, 1.0138969421386719, 0.22265204787254333, -0.43282952904701233, 0.03514509275555611, -0.6497371196746826, -0.1337888538837433, 0.16824151575565338, -0.17889249324798584, -0.07820533215999603, 0.37741410732269287, -0.2047581821680069, 0.4666234850883484, -0.5372123718261719, 0.1545940339565277, -0.3089023232460022, -0.13411018252372742, 0.1657240241765976, -0.32996445894241333, 0.8365621566772461, 0.3984394073486328, 0.0775354653596878, 0.36026787757873535, -0.9805333018302917, 0.026974154636263847, 0.35489538311958313, -0.5558863878250122, -0.4860312342643738, -0.4680866599082947, 0.5726652145385742, 0.2861875593662262, 0.3963051736354828, -0.6454795598983765, 0.43012574315071106, -0.39672452211380005, 0.6583656668663025, 0.4689211845397949, -0.23902495205402374, 0.5648061633110046, -0.13023820519447327, 0.6129074692726135, -0.10640405863523483, -0.18085967004299164, -0.13066959381103516, -0.4219580292701721, -0.8312224745750427, -0.25343185663223267, 0.4234783947467804, 0.15627290308475494, -0.996512770652771, -0.4156236946582794, -0.4482932984828949, -0.8257520794868469, -0.5635331273078918, 0.38510361313819885, 0.6105578541755676, 0.058920543640851974, 0.16443128883838654, 0.015120304189622402, -0.4577632546424866, -0.9194549322128296, -0.059090275317430496, -0.09506335854530334, 0.13759583234786987, 0.18195225298404694, 0.49578848481178284, -0.26076409220695496, 0.6283515095710754, -0.2776486277580261, -0.4246324896812439, -0.365665465593338, -0.012755491770803928, 0.22248360514640808, 0.6553821563720703, 0.898398220539093, -0.7886039018630981, -0.5409405827522278, -0.07249285280704498, -0.33832085132598877, -0.22144336998462677, 0.18374982476234436, 0.138785719871521, 0.2539574205875397, 0.3096212148666382, -0.5782970190048218, 0.26705339550971985, 0.9062239527702332, -0.3434618413448334, 0.42733749747276306, -0.4786580502986908, -0.21495455503463745, -1.2583696842193604, -0.039791058748960495, 0.5674692988395691, -0.3561449348926544, -0.511221170425415, 0.5782886147499084, 0.023552831262350082, -0.17663943767547607, -0.5129467844963074, 0.7305087447166443, -0.6192002296447754, -0.07171163707971573, -0.539679765701294, 0.5388463139533997, -0.3683200180530548, 0.0669463500380516, 0.3887080252170563, 0.859427809715271, 0.2539520561695099, -0.49152934551239014, 0.3327495753765106, 0.034200720489025116, -0.13974732160568237, 0.624586284160614, -0.8613134026527405, -0.029354743659496307, 0.05065077170729637, -0.009023522026836872, -0.7727925777435303, -0.45232105255126953, 0.23039288818836212, -0.368268758058548, 0.3178808391094208, -0.5926473140716553, -0.5061495900154114, -0.3446550667285919, -0.17900224030017853, 0.20858535170555115, 0.11763981729745865, -0.784747838973999, 0.16703453660011292, 0.6410282254219055, -0.3934234082698822, -0.11282674968242645, -0.8987892270088196, 0.015697967261075974, -0.23900285363197327, -0.8046935796737671, 0.3477768301963806, -0.19418330490589142, -0.38298535346984863, 0.10283821076154709, 0.25913000106811523, -0.424520879983902, 0.0015273522585630417, 0.41816458106040955, 0.07283832132816315, -0.5645999312400818, 0.3959856331348419, 0.0892183929681778, -0.19602639973163605, -0.2814594507217407, -0.2824589014053345, 0.5732438564300537, -0.6567707061767578, 0.30520206689834595, 0.06944183260202408, 0.22038720548152924, 0.1719883233308792, 0.11772502958774567, 0.8257237076759338, 0.4820699095726013, -0.6059324145317078, -0.3771207630634308, -0.28539136052131653, 0.00840113963931799, -0.48995599150657654, -0.002321316860616207, -0.352089524269104, -1.1210514307022095, 0.1463100016117096, -0.08345823734998703, -0.09001049399375916, 0.4475533366203308, 0.9574202299118042, 0.19725564122200012, 0.2543272376060486, 0.8506529927253723, 0.4698556065559387, 0.32639673352241516, -0.3029324412345886, -0.13983789086341858, -0.5923057198524475, -0.16518603265285492, -0.9934284687042236, -0.1770447939634323, -0.975643515586853, -0.5513047575950623, 0.30008262395858765, 0.19894364476203918, 0.07039108127355576, 0.753510057926178, -0.5907785892486572, 0.7423926591873169, 0.707400381565094, -0.1052364930510521, 0.4861951768398285, -0.05616335570812225, -0.08508510887622833, -0.1691965013742447, -0.8187360763549805, -0.9814995527267456, 1.2362518310546875, 0.08671300858259201, 0.7692623138427734, 0.47620683908462524, 0.8574578166007996, 0.05865782871842384, 0.36294615268707275, -0.6266288161277771, 0.5461652874946594, -0.4239669740200043, -0.6427117586135864, -0.21887367963790894, -0.5120368003845215, -1.2384014129638672, 0.3888547122478485, -0.39423373341560364, -1.0331571102142334, 0.06726014614105225, 0.11369417607784271, -0.39216554164886475, -0.02081138826906681, -0.8261959552764893, 1.0718975067138672, -0.02616596221923828, -0.628991961479187, -0.43757954239845276, -0.3844599425792694, 0.47441041469573975, -0.10439013689756393, 0.2345668077468872, -0.17262113094329834, -0.18105222284793854, 0.5289446115493774, -0.4139905869960785, 0.7552021741867065, 0.09611064940690994, -0.26664701104164124, 0.5337098836898804, 0.3216259777545929, 0.06748297065496445, 0.4749351739883423, 0.07065355032682419, 0.23852001130580902, 0.34127992391586304, -0.4498831033706665, 0.12486463040113449, 1.4739665985107422, -0.9171810746192932, -0.2290930151939392, -0.6743758916854858, -0.437232106924057, -0.12456527352333069, 0.46193209290504456, 0.14567895233631134, 0.1514182984828949, -0.4491633474826813, 0.5389732718467712, 0.6557632088661194, -0.11352088302373886, 0.6973124742507935, 0.7614659070968628, -0.4795704483985901, -0.3302186131477356, 1.020009160041809, 0.36984357237815857, -0.07677728682756424, 0.14187370240688324, 0.3777199387550354, -0.12925200164318085, -0.6848810315132141, -0.6979384422302246, 0.32531705498695374, -0.46087875962257385, 0.06960771232843399, -0.49572890996932983, -0.1035238578915596, -0.5405552983283997, -0.00027162631158716977, -0.46764615178108215, -0.9718707203865051, -0.2767353951931, 0.1351129561662674, 0.18964724242687225, 0.906341016292572, -0.3359992802143097, 0.827228307723999, -0.7370208501815796, 0.4212323725223541, 0.13134630024433136, 0.18330638110637665, -0.26876217126846313, -0.1434127241373062, -0.3960246443748474, 0.07976249605417252, -0.429379940032959, -0.8170593976974487, 0.4531443417072296, 0.16555017232894897, 0.11309485882520676, 0.15428902208805084, -0.17400503158569336, 0.2685704827308655, -0.2828868329524994, 0.5563853979110718, 0.14175817370414734, -0.7658908367156982, 0.7139344215393066, -0.6839112043380737, 0.28793826699256897, 0.48365822434425354, 0.28788354992866516, -0.5332075357437134, -0.03137783706188202, -0.5991926789283752, -0.5017529726028442, 0.8193612694740295, 0.36591652035713196, 0.19689726829528809, 0.02582346647977829, 0.440887451171875, 0.22875112295150757, 0.33844783902168274, -1.0234520435333252, 0.12442085891962051, 0.008672775700688362, -0.36522966623306274, -0.24791474640369415, -0.34845566749572754, -0.010943271219730377, 0.19726982712745667, 0.8611935377120972, -0.3623279333114624, -0.0710669755935669, -0.21409182250499725, -0.28354740142822266, -0.327235609292984, 0.4007764756679535, 0.7121109962463379, 0.571078360080719, -0.05716070905327797, 0.11901836842298508, -0.1718042939901352, -0.5435799956321716, 0.11809661239385605, 0.1100391298532486, -0.4509502649307251, 0.20014482736587524, 0.19618305563926697, 0.6016794443130493, 0.4637104272842407, -0.7728394865989685, 0.35213372111320496, -0.19449064135551453, 0.3091959059238434, -0.34032055735588074, 0.15570686757564545, 0.44613537192344666, 0.3740828335285187, -0.002700026845559478, -0.15651459991931915, -0.013271554373204708, -0.6624783277511597, -0.491211473941803, 0.23021677136421204, -0.25365620851516724, -0.40293455123901367, 0.5428568720817566, 0.3463388979434967, -0.38198035955429077, 0.2908063530921936, -0.08152544498443604, -0.0910395011305809, 0.5360130667686462, 0.6211729049682617, 0.7475029826164246, -0.1830814778804779, 0.4272472560405731, 0.35385048389434814, 0.694572389125824, -0.01220408920198679, 0.45996740460395813, 0.0394088439643383, -0.5472280383110046, -0.031223028898239136, -0.7452295422554016, -0.41331806778907776, 0.14084981381893158, -0.45088911056518555, 0.3917704224586487, -0.5125693082809448, -0.21525099873542786, 0.023757783696055412, 0.2611630856990814, -0.6459387540817261, 0.26162752509117126, 0.050418708473443985, 0.9671181440353394, -0.6101152300834656, 1.114262580871582, 0.7630967497825623, -0.5599940419197083, -0.35711660981178284, -0.26837798953056335, 0.0405142642557621, -0.7315027713775635, 0.48323655128479004, 0.1473134160041809, 0.05735445395112038, -0.1101175919175148, -0.424045592546463, -0.8222911953926086, 0.7735543847084045, 0.6622918248176575, -0.6557020545005798, -0.32793566584587097, 0.370792418718338, 0.8664278984069824, -0.42891088128089905, 0.194527730345726, 0.5299171805381775, 0.19737543165683746, 0.10430491715669632, -0.8920302391052246, -0.2991238236427307, -0.14774037897586823, 0.35535040497779846, 0.08977480232715607, -1.051094651222229, 1.0333689451217651, -0.33187761902809143, -0.08400072902441025, 0.5631701350212097, 0.6195056438446045, 0.35460352897644043, 0.29778048396110535, 0.08098825067281723, 0.4874878227710724, 0.525773286819458, -0.5208191871643066, 0.8952070474624634, -0.5870680809020996, 0.3419528603553772, 1.5440902709960938, 0.15112121403217316, 1.0216351747512817, 0.5074933767318726, 0.04285503923892975, 0.3905888795852661, 0.7840043306350708, 0.412935733795166, 0.26776123046875, 0.18685071170330048, -0.23062792420387268, -0.11159331351518631, -0.36622509360313416, -0.5146222710609436, 0.39241015911102295, 0.6191999912261963, -0.37175530195236206, -0.2825514078140259, 0.017359262332320213, 0.32170096039772034, 0.28380510210990906, -0.442935973405838, 0.5883552432060242, 0.4369923770427704, -0.4059297740459442, 0.39784106612205505, 0.5114790797233582, 0.6167024374008179, -0.602907121181488, 0.3113189935684204, -0.41754916310310364, 0.34250608086586, -0.08056125044822693, -0.640914261341095, 0.3686501979827881, 0.3617168068885803, -0.07927250862121582, -0.3748272657394409, 0.8798515796661377, -0.6731739044189453, -0.6573712229728699, 0.31777331233024597, 0.5211318135261536, 0.08067957311868668, 0.05156433582305908, -0.5930201411247253, 0.36328354477882385, -0.5447390675544739, -0.275533527135849, 0.24425733089447021, 0.594467282295227, -0.13814790546894073, 0.6912962198257446, 0.5820904970169067, 0.5373848080635071, 0.24940526485443115, -0.15398037433624268, 0.6519399881362915, -0.4192512035369873, -0.6979916095733643, -0.6629741787910461, -0.013533632270991802, 0.07628452777862549, -0.6416839361190796, 0.8206095099449158, 0.6372461318969727, 1.0418131351470947, -0.18108606338500977, 0.6263063549995422, 0.03210071474313736, 0.34574973583221436, -0.5449475646018982, 0.7813218235969543, -0.62843257188797, 0.0739545226097107, -0.1274614930152893, -1.1786185503005981, -0.1292589008808136, 0.5143919587135315, -0.20942407846450806, 0.018612878397107124, 0.4359409809112549, 0.7090686559677124, 0.020967693999409676, 0.19028392434120178, 0.21752965450286865, 0.5769578814506531, 0.08220384269952774, 0.854405403137207, 0.6330037713050842, -0.2955417037010193, 0.5893345475196838, -0.4990929961204529, -0.13044586777687073, -0.45271480083465576, -0.8310977220535278, -1.0056908130645752, -0.4345129132270813, -0.38878342509269714, -0.5281983017921448, 0.10831507295370102, 1.1669760942459106, 0.748950183391571, -0.7284582853317261, -0.547684907913208, -0.1898198127746582, 0.198775053024292, 0.2830358147621155, -0.15338779985904694, 0.08569668233394623, 0.016439862549304962, -0.9770085215568542, 0.7391049861907959, 0.3633517920970917, 0.4220426380634308, -0.83427494764328, -0.20750218629837036, -0.038267832249403, 0.2239866405725479, 0.35948142409324646, 0.4332640469074249, -0.6355912089347839, 0.058050937950611115, -0.4476531147956848, -0.4627760648727417, -0.03711864352226257, 0.8300008773803711, -0.8672783970832825, 0.5185675024986267, 0.44195055961608887, 0.18283842504024506, 0.493140310049057, -0.6428788304328918, 0.33856239914894104, -0.7347031831741333, 0.6951823830604553, 0.13932211697101593, 0.5359784364700317, 0.47346633672714233, 0.013934827409684658, 0.881678581237793, 0.38393688201904297, -0.24697746336460114, -1.0086023807525635, 0.07866238802671432, -0.9016018509864807, -0.23986083269119263, 1.1839410066604614, -0.11496622860431671, -0.3144476115703583, 0.3701227009296417, -0.35548684000968933, 0.13411201536655426, -0.2967208921909332, 0.716361403465271, 0.5408183932304382, 0.5479041337966919, -0.15302206575870514, -0.4515550136566162, 0.2489272803068161, -0.15400822460651398, -0.8722333908081055, -0.19233597815036774, 0.4727063775062561, 0.19979341328144073, 0.24118004739284515, 0.7181435823440552, 0.05421372130513191, 0.31288281083106995, 0.1684640794992447, -0.11551103740930557, 0.022219792008399963, -0.6619526147842407, -0.48564013838768005, 0.41246235370635986, 0.09925966709852219, 0.2756483554840088 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16638v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16638v1	Breaking Free Transformer Models: Task-specific Context Attribution Promises Improved Generalizability Without Fine-tuning Pre-trained LLMs	2024-01-30T00:23:29	2024-01-30T00:23:29	Stepan Tytarenko, Mohammad Ruhul Amin	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.2.4	Fine-tuning large pre-trained language models (LLMs) on particular datasets is a commonly employed strategy in Natural Language Processing (NLP) classification tasks. However, this approach usually results in a loss of models generalizability. In this paper, we present a framework that allows for maintaining generalizability, and enhances the performance on the downstream task by utilizing task-specific context attribution. We show that a linear transformation of the text representation from any transformer model using the task-specific concept operator results in a projection onto the latent concept space, referred to as context attribution in this paper. The specific concept operator is optimized during the supervised learning stage via novel loss functions. The proposed framework demonstrates that context attribution of the text representation for each task objective can improve the capacity of the discriminator function and thus achieve better performance for the classification task. Experimental results on three datasets, namely HateXplain, IMDB reviews, and Social Media Attributions, illustrate that the proposed model attains superior accuracy and generalizability. Specifically, for the non-fine-tuned BERT on the HateXplain dataset, we observe 8% improvement in accuracy and 10% improvement in F1-score. Whereas for the IMDB dataset, fine-tuned state-of-the-art XLNet is outperformed by 1% for both accuracy and F1-score. Furthermore, in an out-of-domain cross-dataset test, DistilBERT fine-tuned on the IMDB dataset in conjunction with the proposed model improves the F1-score on the HateXplain dataset by 7%. For the Social Media Attributions dataset of YouTube comments, we observe 5.2% increase in F1-metric. The proposed framework is implemented with PyTorch and provided open-source on GitHub.	[ -0.2906004786491394, -0.5575827360153198, 0.39780107140541077, 0.07921909540891647, -0.33378538489341736, -0.14521804451942444, -0.4293946325778961, -0.2358817607164383, 0.09817803651094437, 0.5830749869346619, -0.603443443775177, -0.41167497634887695, -0.8529387712478638, -0.08256734907627106, -0.8903602957725525, 1.150542140007019, -0.1501520723104477, -0.4499729871749878, -0.2532981038093567, -0.16688989102840424, -0.4191986620426178, -0.5184000730514526, -0.45648378133773804, -0.347360223531723, 0.7275252342224121, 0.2573937773704529, 0.6169578433036804, 0.6256412863731384, 0.6671505570411682, 0.2414458990097046, -0.007066434249281883, 0.055156584829092026, -0.5778473615646362, -0.0032290183007717133, -0.5327014923095703, -0.5676981806755066, -0.10478030890226364, 0.011404951103031635, 0.3594895601272583, 0.39144453406333923, -0.07961484044790268, 0.2516081929206848, 0.26346588134765625, 0.3025961220264435, -0.7129614353179932, 0.11944981664419174, -0.895647406578064, -0.012821093201637268, 0.017781905829906464, -0.4679032862186432, -0.4726000130176544, -0.17570115625858307, 0.06440811604261398, -0.5261178016662598, 0.6408501863479614, -0.18053191900253296, 0.9843903183937073, 0.6875337958335876, -0.4360834062099457, -0.2245546579360962, -0.8544747233390808, 0.9962818026542664, -0.46583953499794006, 0.34737706184387207, 0.17764602601528168, 0.3528946042060852, 0.14959873259067535, -0.5965891480445862, -0.41800743341445923, 0.06296266615390778, -0.22611075639724731, -0.25412940979003906, -0.4684308171272278, -0.008044513873755932, 0.03526319935917854, 0.4079930782318115, -0.26412031054496765, 0.1538316309452057, -0.21650345623493195, -0.07058967649936676, 0.48238444328308105, -0.0891898050904274, -0.019355105236172676, -0.30416855216026306, -0.28414300084114075, -0.1378670334815979, -0.579005777835846, 0.11818540841341019, 0.16709259152412415, 0.5166751742362976, 0.07570202648639679, 0.451821893453598, -0.05101684108376503, 0.38887733221054077, 0.1063021719455719, 0.11100996285676956, 0.26518458127975464, -0.15970687568187714, -0.22327814996242523, -0.13815268874168396, 0.6313664317131042, 0.4978792071342468, 0.40703529119491577, -0.40059879422187805, -0.2453383058309555, 0.33131083846092224, 0.6502910852432251, -0.7572447657585144, -0.11565522849559784, 0.08397755026817322, -0.3896689713001251, -0.5394275784492493, -0.08748127520084381, -0.3173544704914093, -0.18651390075683594, -0.49973875284194946, 0.42618104815483093, -0.4120192527770996, -0.1693895310163498, -0.1920160949230194, 0.14557760953903198, 0.12142311036586761, 0.3671393096446991, -0.7651658654212952, 0.24563950300216675, 0.5560470819473267, 0.9466006755828857, -0.5625513195991516, 0.16939577460289001, -0.49515002965927124, 0.2377331554889679, -0.29000696539878845, 0.6274849772453308, -0.444543719291687, -0.07226124405860901, 0.0007115639746189117, 0.132837176322937, -0.09215997904539108, -0.5850390791893005, 0.6582729816436768, -0.5502938628196716, 0.06806567311286926, 0.018454836681485176, -0.5510817766189575, -0.1621001958847046, 0.2920893728733063, -0.681184709072113, 0.6877914667129517, 0.181658074259758, -0.7260262966156006, 0.4261869490146637, -0.9435890316963196, -0.2687726318836212, -0.21076202392578125, -0.07211051881313324, -0.2250121831893921, 0.20879854261875153, 0.3803245425224304, 0.7869718670845032, -0.2706414759159088, 0.6094099879264832, -0.021612154319882393, -0.49324366450309753, -0.0021052758675068617, -0.4519907832145691, 0.5652672052383423, 0.13946209847927094, -0.48533931374549866, 0.37943407893180847, -0.5984282493591309, -0.0682528018951416, 0.04614194855093956, -0.34744179248809814, -0.37351036071777344, 0.2765350043773651, 0.27224716544151306, 0.31403636932373047, -0.23937258124351501, -0.533015787601471, 0.04818464443087578, -0.3324522078037262, 0.40786147117614746, 0.7843502759933472, -0.17975683510303497, 0.5502236485481262, -0.07224982231855392, 0.48151376843452454, 0.13628707826137543, -0.18048319220542908, -0.06488926708698273, -0.18443866074085236, -0.797214686870575, -0.33490049839019775, 0.2174345999956131, 0.622678279876709, -0.7969264984130859, 0.48713067173957825, -0.5791601538658142, -0.3740963041782379, -0.39631590247154236, 0.22436320781707764, 0.3448694050312042, 0.5618515014648438, 0.6518958806991577, -0.2004055678844452, -0.5584195256233215, -0.9490536451339722, -0.4242085814476013, 0.16514265537261963, -0.4683762192726135, 0.20795078575611115, 0.3784906566143036, -0.5316229462623596, 1.147265911102295, -0.487295925617218, -0.6388697028160095, -0.4069056808948517, 0.13137692213058472, 0.32082605361938477, 0.5941479802131653, 0.33384454250335693, -0.9086475372314453, -0.3468455970287323, -0.22582553327083588, -0.6543093919754028, -0.13076430559158325, 0.017247917130589485, 0.09934420138597488, 0.10097600519657135, 0.5175594091415405, -0.3338008224964142, 0.4380565285682678, 0.5913810729980469, -0.4991230368614197, 0.3408803343772888, 0.10886465758085251, 0.03910291567444801, -0.9614264965057373, 0.01417582482099533, 0.28219354152679443, -0.3534693121910095, -0.6854227781295776, 0.011624215170741081, -0.003810691414400935, -0.0048623052425682545, -0.5841122269630432, 0.3844364285469055, 0.05500050261616707, 0.2807925343513489, -0.21104902029037476, 0.07731391489505768, -0.18788737058639526, 0.6648681163787842, 0.013328060507774353, 0.5493897795677185, 0.29334667325019836, -0.7074772715568542, 0.3112953305244446, 0.27575942873954773, -0.42547667026519775, 0.489263653755188, -0.6950145363807678, 0.10507295280694962, -0.22737284004688263, 0.2745586335659027, -0.8337234258651733, -0.0785469114780426, 0.0347825363278389, -0.3122854232788086, 0.2846132218837738, 0.0652661845088005, -0.42188894748687744, -0.13332314789295197, -0.1127307340502739, 0.1663302481174469, 0.2838036119937897, -0.6343298554420471, 0.7551692128181458, 0.06470001488924026, 0.1553104668855667, -0.5584093928337097, -0.8705577850341797, -0.038383983075618744, -0.43961983919143677, -0.570121705532074, 0.8860638737678528, 0.06434593349695206, -0.11055165529251099, 0.12591028213500977, -0.2579081058502197, -0.18861348927021027, -0.05586491525173187, 0.22433839738368988, 0.1032269224524498, -0.018874026834964752, 0.16731537878513336, 0.12916088104248047, -0.1974416971206665, -0.04000173881649971, -0.0889536440372467, 0.3933885991573334, 0.08084125816822052, 0.013184836134314537, -0.3990592956542969, 0.25640934705734253, 0.22939516603946686, -0.05250542610883713, 0.8076703548431396, 0.7381259202957153, -0.3023718297481537, -0.4005505442619324, -0.45156532526016235, -0.32022523880004883, -0.49101534485816956, 0.4815552830696106, -0.3238200545310974, -1.2222533226013184, 0.4092600345611572, 0.056107424199581146, 0.10982897877693176, 0.5347697734832764, 0.4980352818965912, 0.07571609318256378, 0.8030781745910645, 1.014566421508789, -0.26362690329551697, 0.640454113483429, -0.34496837854385376, 0.3207457661628723, -0.6905665993690491, 0.04649607464671135, -0.38403743505477905, -0.44849321246147156, -0.5490224361419678, -0.5699490308761597, 0.12302403897047043, 0.08069097995758057, -0.12504889070987701, 0.5485790967941284, -0.7401024103164673, 0.5363484621047974, 0.5039961338043213, 0.0740930438041687, 0.3378073275089264, 0.1777675896883011, 0.04337901622056961, -0.12264832854270935, -0.5110941529273987, -0.508589506149292, 1.258606195449829, 0.4219295382499695, 0.6252152323722839, 0.1365467607975006, 0.5442830324172974, 0.6627781987190247, 0.5285604596138, -0.6595780849456787, 0.429034948348999, -0.42928043007850647, -0.6485376358032227, -0.36007311940193176, -0.5099735856056213, -0.6274576187133789, 0.2795226573944092, -0.06038669869303703, -1.0951831340789795, 0.10523908585309982, 0.23987676203250885, -0.07779525220394135, 0.3669564425945282, -0.6078754663467407, 0.8632668256759644, 0.10646749287843704, -0.37668654322624207, -0.24288251996040344, -0.44935375452041626, 0.34950315952301025, -0.23592185974121094, 0.15369437634944916, -0.16691873967647552, 0.027034485712647438, 0.8664926886558533, -0.2262556105852127, 0.7655445337295532, -0.4425981938838959, -0.2908935248851776, 0.3061138391494751, -0.07610168308019638, 0.570327639579773, -0.14246486127376556, -0.016535749658942223, 0.1849001795053482, -0.16345976293087006, -0.04604649171233177, -0.7004213929176331, 0.6800564527511597, -0.7159003615379333, -0.4518345892429352, 0.03718404099345207, -0.6718235015869141, -0.2711389362812042, 0.09267135709524155, 0.4129737317562103, 0.2861582934856415, -0.031669069081544876, 0.6543769836425781, 0.6379953622817993, -0.17931891977787018, 0.32209569215774536, 0.27999916672706604, -0.04447927325963974, -0.17571882903575897, 0.9318471550941467, -0.05603106692433357, 0.11874204874038696, 0.5983635187149048, -0.0062372153624892235, -0.3831399381160736, -0.3349827826023102, -0.026751117780804634, -0.03146019205451012, -0.8361377716064453, -0.3108430802822113, -0.6236532926559448, -0.10845078527927399, -0.3162708580493927, -0.32383403182029724, -0.3483515977859497, -0.341010183095932, -0.35210612416267395, -0.1624133139848709, 0.19408272206783295, 0.3352261781692505, 0.21330556273460388, 0.6504161953926086, -0.4232524335384369, 0.3872130811214447, 0.07151629775762558, 0.5285127758979797, -0.19029873609542847, -0.6899656653404236, -0.3291955292224884, -0.1673090010881424, -0.48248565196990967, -0.656130850315094, 0.34108540415763855, 0.35947513580322266, 0.32871702313423157, 0.321830153465271, 0.03090914897620678, 0.5332569479942322, -0.44099152088165283, 0.5165876746177673, 0.25001171231269836, -1.1347899436950684, 0.5592589378356934, -0.3934643864631653, 0.2473871409893036, 0.44199201464653015, 0.3619335889816284, -0.5615407228469849, -0.5303980708122253, -0.435427725315094, -1.0219852924346924, 0.8581467270851135, 0.4127785861492157, 0.32611528038978577, 0.13489650189876556, 0.29544776678085327, -0.03151041269302368, 0.20113445818424225, -0.7648913264274597, -0.22357644140720367, -0.32671886682510376, -0.34830328822135925, -0.5026940703392029, -0.13395439088344574, 0.04317217692732811, -0.49760907888412476, 0.6297874450683594, -0.2875116765499115, 0.4709610939025879, 0.05227150395512581, -0.34238094091415405, -0.018599731847643852, 0.3855646550655365, 0.28884223103523254, 0.5099233984947205, -0.3693869411945343, 0.057383935898542404, 0.022977296262979507, -0.2346554547548294, 0.29242315888404846, 0.23004423081874847, -0.2125241607427597, 0.15760673582553864, 0.3373178243637085, 0.7876590490341187, 0.3238943815231323, -0.5825628042221069, 0.5244123339653015, -0.013296867720782757, -0.36446261405944824, -0.1546822190284729, 0.3756250739097595, 0.04922374710440636, 0.24693535268306732, 0.5394097566604614, 0.12984555959701538, 0.0944400355219841, -0.29921263456344604, 0.47001463174819946, 0.2814026176929474, -0.5175018906593323, -0.19375839829444885, 0.9175810813903809, 0.06842298060655594, -0.06400831788778305, 0.4469766914844513, 0.021121395751833916, -0.43847060203552246, 0.38182926177978516, 0.5636540651321411, 0.9530028104782104, -0.3009617030620575, 0.21931909024715424, 0.24072077870368958, 0.1786094605922699, -0.004028261173516512, -0.2563927471637726, -0.2487918585538864, -1.0878288745880127, -0.6241013407707214, -0.7707858681678772, -0.32072684168815613, 0.21908481419086456, -0.5286825895309448, 0.2695438265800476, -0.34501418471336365, -0.1890282779932022, 0.00799747183918953, -0.2102363258600235, -0.7773518562316895, 0.5042973160743713, 0.07640492916107178, 0.7076497077941895, -0.6716811656951904, 0.9529836773872375, 0.4471745193004608, -0.27234524488449097, -0.7898263931274414, -0.11627475172281265, -0.12258310616016388, -0.35330039262771606, 0.7364662885665894, 0.4526127874851227, -0.020495038479566574, 0.0744820237159729, -0.4653879702091217, -1.0129954814910889, 1.0439237356185913, 0.5825622081756592, -0.641272783279419, -0.4298402965068817, 0.3321681022644043, 0.4649043381214142, -0.6107680797576904, 0.15969178080558777, 0.677638828754425, 0.14934852719306946, 0.08331557363271713, -0.8462064862251282, 0.23353372514247894, -0.24408754706382751, 0.1696215569972992, 0.2122877538204193, -0.1240198165178299, 0.6346523761749268, 0.03535874933004379, -0.13191059231758118, -0.4586506187915802, 0.620050847530365, -0.030076520517468452, 0.0782003253698349, 0.7669138312339783, 0.4375978112220764, 0.4899137318134308, -0.2622024714946747, 0.9602121710777283, -0.11182095110416412, 0.5763030052185059, 1.0884336233139038, 0.18602804839611053, 0.7375170588493347, 0.6475116014480591, -0.11599408835172653, 0.6357220411300659, 0.20409227907657623, -0.14563482999801636, 0.6811748743057251, 0.334125816822052, -0.032810285687446594, -0.06975604593753815, -0.15104378759860992, 0.12267318367958069, 0.5152006149291992, 0.20410487055778503, -0.7821779847145081, -0.3384256660938263, 0.20725151896476746, 0.07426831126213074, 0.016102870926260948, -0.33085373044013977, 0.5384286046028137, -0.019831089302897453, -0.47770315408706665, 0.8125558495521545, 0.2378012239933014, 1.2054200172424316, -0.6654469966888428, 0.292682409286499, 0.007917768321931362, 0.6395796537399292, -0.40219876170158386, -0.35159537196159363, 0.8233515620231628, 0.2693987488746643, -0.46447625756263733, -0.47053247690200806, 0.857194185256958, -0.4270341396331787, -0.45185476541519165, 0.3890470862388611, 0.1801849603652954, -0.03922583535313606, -0.5380463600158691, -0.5719928741455078, 0.1094302386045456, 0.2054595798254013, -0.48157191276550293, 0.1570306420326233, 0.1326448917388916, -0.13537251949310303, 0.6916064023971558, 0.5669755935668945, -0.12156961858272552, -0.11756911873817444, -0.03235761076211929, 0.9062745571136475, -0.6618399620056152, -0.43162715435028076, -0.7137171626091003, 0.6954098343849182, 0.07363170385360718, -0.18319527804851532, 0.6274572610855103, 0.2944975793361664, 0.9719076752662659, -0.15186446905136108, 0.6631860136985779, -0.22975406050682068, 0.615208089351654, -0.2640138566493988, 0.6039644479751587, -0.6864153742790222, 0.20437975227832794, -0.5934678316116333, -1.1221760511398315, -0.5150123834609985, 0.48255351185798645, -0.42169830203056335, -0.032766636461019516, 0.5891045331954956, 0.6574099659919739, -0.18610291182994843, -0.16912294924259186, 0.3022669553756714, -0.13894261419773102, 0.7263422608375549, 0.4990193843841553, 0.3610296845436096, -0.42641082406044006, 0.710256040096283, -0.3009801208972931, -0.21902036666870117, -0.11610190570354462, -0.8550336360931396, -0.832263171672821, -0.5395479202270508, -0.3424062132835388, -0.09827413409948349, -0.013142815791070461, 0.7635504007339478, 0.6896740198135376, -0.8951971530914307, -0.01953294314444065, -0.262432336807251, 0.006526895798742771, -0.28346583247184753, -0.35838159918785095, 0.43059587478637695, -0.5059263706207275, -0.734683096408844, 0.30967220664024353, 0.024907778948545456, -0.31333282589912415, -0.09873072057962418, -0.01507216040045023, -0.06896356493234634, 0.08842217177152634, 0.7999022603034973, -0.13811686635017395, -0.7355614900588989, -0.44695916771888733, -0.11269066482782364, 0.13021929562091827, 0.071714386343956, 0.9186052680015564, -0.8468261361122131, 0.1454925388097763, 0.118629090487957, 0.7441228628158569, 0.47935381531715393, 0.17144766449928284, 0.5930527448654175, -0.9870408773422241, 0.0632161945104599, 0.2223632037639618, 0.22106558084487915, 0.47646671533584595, -0.386758953332901, 0.6193789839744568, 0.17935678362846375, -0.4272889792919159, -0.7210565805435181, 0.15902729332447052, -0.7511416077613831, -0.24307240545749664, 1.0230401754379272, -0.11990930885076523, -0.029722021892666817, 0.10800737142562866, 0.12076076865196228, 0.4152911901473999, -0.47572702169418335, 0.63154137134552, 0.6769071221351624, 0.03371012583374977, -0.3043699562549591, -0.38202035427093506, 0.5684942603111267, 0.46882301568984985, -0.6404011249542236, 0.15380235016345978, 0.32713574171066284, 0.3628523051738739, 0.3634565770626068, 0.4687792658805847, 0.036303211003541946, -0.25700584053993225, -0.46122807264328003, 0.07105907052755356, -0.11621192842721939, -0.389975905418396, -0.23217135667800903, 0.36454376578330994, -0.3742024898529053, -0.15763403475284576 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01748v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01748v2	Large Multi-Modal Models (LMMs) as Universal Foundation Models for AI-Native Wireless Systems	2024-01-30T00:21:41	2024-02-07T17:55:11	Shengzhe Xu, Christo Kurisummoottil Thomas, Omar Hashash, Nikhil Muralidhar, Walid Saad, Naren Ramakrishnan	cs.NI	cs.NI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG	Large language models (LLMs) and foundation models have been recently touted as a game-changer for 6G systems. However, recent efforts on LLMs for wireless networks are limited to a direct application of existing language models that were designed for natural language processing (NLP) applications. To address this challenge and create wireless-centric foundation models, this paper presents a comprehensive vision on how to design universal foundation models that are tailored towards the deployment of artificial intelligence (AI)-native networks. Diverging from NLP-based foundation models, the proposed framework promotes the design of large multi-modal models (LMMs) fostered by three key capabilities: 1) processing of multi-modal sensing data, 2) grounding of physical symbol representations in real-world wireless systems using causal reasoning and retrieval-augmented generation (RAG), and 3) enabling instructibility from the wireless environment feedback to facilitate dynamic network adaptation thanks to logical and mathematical reasoning facilitated by neuro-symbolic AI. In essence, these properties enable the proposed LMM framework to build universal capabilities that cater to various cross-layer networking tasks and alignment of intents across different domains. Preliminary results from experimental evaluation demonstrate the efficacy of grounding using RAG in LMMs, and showcase the alignment of LMMs with wireless system designs. Furthermore, the enhanced rationale exhibited in the responses to mathematical questions by LMMs, compared to vanilla LLMs, demonstrates the logical and mathematical reasoning capabilities inherent in LMMs. Building on those results, we present a sequel of open questions and challenges for LMMs. We then conclude with a set of recommendations that ignite the path towards LMM-empowered AI-native systems.	[ -0.4952693283557892, -0.4476229250431061, 0.43561869859695435, 0.21957753598690033, 0.01002098061144352, -0.2644100487232208, -0.14794008433818817, -0.8945327401161194, 0.08306726813316345, 0.6590792536735535, -0.47265052795410156, -0.1902029812335968, -0.3338218331336975, 0.10200952738523483, -0.31910356879234314, 0.779679536819458, 0.10800345987081528, -0.2585097551345825, 0.01742096245288849, -0.4346274137496948, -0.662850022315979, -0.32576802372932434, -0.20878556370735168, -0.6624274849891663, 0.5170376896858215, 0.15909987688064575, 0.8463721871376038, 0.2165389209985733, 0.44298064708709717, 0.3329787850379944, 0.02071523852646351, 0.23633155226707458, 0.013311592862010002, 0.07354042679071426, -0.15489228069782257, -0.2725900411605835, -0.3319756090641022, 0.04983343183994293, 0.4358922839164734, 0.977461576461792, 0.06253550201654434, -0.060182515531778336, -0.2892182469367981, 0.7416090369224548, -0.6622409224510193, 0.024100538343191147, -0.754346489906311, 0.006920200306922197, 0.1924809068441391, -0.14051875472068787, -0.5430145263671875, 0.09523124247789383, 0.14445388317108154, -0.5885000824928284, -0.22633598744869232, -0.0049756187945604324, 0.45234817266464233, 0.22047585248947144, -0.8604516983032227, -0.24026921391487122, -0.8417677283287048, 0.8957207202911377, -0.7183497548103333, 0.5081779956817627, 0.22638289630413055, 0.32662370800971985, -0.3880936801433563, -0.4634895324707031, -0.3925491273403168, -0.5584334135055542, -0.014149635098874569, -0.02535385638475418, 0.0849570631980896, 0.3077462911605835, 0.18763728439807892, 0.2100926786661148, -0.29448801279067993, -0.013852812349796295, -0.11430275440216064, -0.060595396906137466, 0.6475422382354736, 0.03791607543826103, 0.16727274656295776, -0.038562845438718796, -0.3226805031299591, 0.6756544709205627, -0.6267561316490173, 0.07703539729118347, -0.05054396763443947, 0.4882725775241852, -0.3096850514411926, 0.6651184558868408, -0.6578024625778198, 1.1391239166259766, -0.11235562711954117, -0.4363413155078888, 0.09337765723466873, -0.20892609655857086, -0.40945175290107727, 0.017403898760676384, 0.5672433376312256, 0.00914852786809206, 0.16990609467029572, -0.38111037015914917, -0.33807694911956787, 0.37936532497406006, 0.3651132881641388, -0.6086703538894653, 0.17047426104545593, 0.21296313405036926, -0.6721257567405701, -0.38612475991249084, -0.17472758889198303, -0.13688166439533234, -0.29220226407051086, -0.5811011791229248, 0.6185104250907898, -0.23977282643318176, -0.3504572808742523, 0.7044364213943481, 0.055118925869464874, 0.17462775111198425, 0.22511941194534302, -0.8579713702201843, 0.1344156414270401, 0.5526119470596313, 0.6032149791717529, 0.23485273122787476, -0.18493305146694183, 0.028407922014594078, 0.44260138273239136, -0.15068840980529785, 0.37956538796424866, -0.3483544588088989, -0.24885617196559906, -0.12278381735086441, -0.09367576986551285, -0.1239963248372078, 0.0968613550066948, 0.6691509485244751, -0.8558535575866699, 0.19766244292259216, -0.21175909042358398, -0.14157845079898834, -0.5339561700820923, 0.39936915040016174, -0.5463880896568298, 0.5770500898361206, -0.06321065127849579, -0.847606897354126, -0.07187683880329132, -1.0398645401000977, -0.5221205353736877, -0.20074164867401123, -0.2914922833442688, -0.0965607538819313, 0.31655701994895935, 0.06807832419872284, 0.5405331254005432, -0.7323080897331238, 0.4714902341365814, -0.2365090698003769, -0.262274831533432, 0.1260434240102768, -0.5128247737884521, 0.9419159889221191, 0.25034594535827637, -0.7512483596801758, 0.15898486971855164, -0.9101146459579468, 0.2463623434305191, 0.009813318960368633, -0.4161573052406311, -0.32830604910850525, 0.41069722175598145, -0.036717139184474945, 0.39942941069602966, -0.0252840556204319, -0.6121363043785095, 0.044073134660720825, -0.3432218134403229, 0.6199795007705688, 0.5596610307693481, -0.3294682800769806, 0.5857215523719788, -0.6084818243980408, -0.00874545332044363, -0.28375688195228577, 0.12829485535621643, -0.4665917754173279, -0.5075361728668213, -0.6429021954536438, -0.3128460645675659, -0.04444773122668266, 0.4224270284175873, -0.4114712178707123, 0.6522661447525024, -0.28442975878715515, -0.40413898229599, -0.07523549348115921, -0.08786580711603165, 0.14666050672531128, 0.7054870128631592, 0.39112889766693115, 0.19675174355506897, -0.31378576159477234, -0.9562808275222778, 0.05986270308494568, 0.058952558785676956, 0.06857210397720337, 0.20727604627609253, 0.5489708185195923, -0.5565690994262695, 1.094274640083313, -0.036930978298187256, -0.21429750323295593, -0.014711721800267696, -0.10482517629861832, 0.27347978949546814, 0.5309638977050781, 0.5813687443733215, -1.1636152267456055, 0.06701096892356873, 0.22122304141521454, -1.0966299772262573, -0.19702202081680298, -0.1672651320695877, 0.01452646218240261, -0.08261746168136597, 0.14912280440330505, -1.06296968460083, 0.48153841495513916, 0.6865268349647522, -0.4187700152397156, 0.6235060095787048, 0.12418140470981598, 0.1567099392414093, -1.0876792669296265, 0.21407166123390198, 0.06064784526824951, 0.06211569905281067, -0.5227396488189697, 0.5775335431098938, -0.09249719232320786, -0.3449259102344513, -0.08250075578689575, 0.5233981609344482, -0.6109090447425842, -0.28326186537742615, -0.32449424266815186, -0.2996228039264679, 0.3643815219402313, 0.3455161452293396, -0.17106026411056519, 0.5221080780029297, 0.5079349875450134, -0.6442195773124695, 0.42872706055641174, -0.019455721601843834, -0.14753782749176025, 0.5000342726707458, -0.8505858778953552, -0.2739170491695404, -0.029237018898129463, 0.7373553514480591, -0.8958710432052612, -0.1471622735261917, -0.0909101590514183, -0.2546670436859131, -0.15230219066143036, -0.08589614182710648, -0.11153767257928848, -0.34984809160232544, -0.15844644606113434, 0.5724021196365356, 0.12156212329864502, -0.6120986342430115, 1.2831130027770996, 0.20365017652511597, 0.360943078994751, -0.5820417404174805, -0.5720391273498535, 0.2193966656923294, -0.10194090753793716, -1.1339937448501587, 0.5592923760414124, -0.24023008346557617, -0.22231222689151764, -0.07318218052387238, -0.21256203949451447, 0.029467584565281868, 0.3790550231933594, 0.5176419019699097, -0.058534760028123856, -0.4098854064941406, 0.09638676047325134, -0.018476752564311028, -0.26845404505729675, 0.2110423743724823, -0.6984270215034485, 0.3542630970478058, -0.19310228526592255, -0.6919806003570557, -0.40177008509635925, 0.6436652541160583, 1.0471171140670776, -0.5408921837806702, 0.4780639410018921, 0.5549609065055847, -0.5642912983894348, -0.24778129160404205, -0.7415251731872559, -0.04438233748078346, -0.5318297147750854, 0.020076869055628777, -0.6362745761871338, -0.9186702370643616, 0.4600293040275574, -0.36009347438812256, 0.40982410311698914, 0.3686259686946869, 0.5485798120498657, -0.1175563707947731, 1.1432368755340576, 0.8081247210502625, -0.30926865339279175, 0.25275808572769165, -0.34069743752479553, 0.25183048844337463, -0.8794246912002563, -0.4660530984401703, -0.5790278315544128, -0.4382995069026947, -0.1388988196849823, -0.2316732257604599, 0.4781605303287506, 0.2199154496192932, -0.5620881915092468, -0.01710529252886772, -0.6291874647140503, 0.21420727670192719, 0.3176391124725342, 0.08157725632190704, 0.32644328474998474, 0.28329983353614807, -0.24984686076641083, 0.23343046009540558, -0.5504424571990967, -0.3244803249835968, 0.9413878321647644, 0.35587188601493835, 0.7921773791313171, 0.2357058823108673, 0.15166252851486206, 0.16732454299926758, 0.31640905141830444, -0.6330891251564026, 0.4922010600566864, 0.09689925611019135, -0.647416353225708, -0.21467168629169464, -0.36419805884361267, -0.6897569298744202, 0.5246998071670532, -0.42970943450927734, -0.6749243140220642, 0.08323882520198822, -0.25165894627571106, -0.23552964627742767, 0.44514819979667664, -0.4176257848739624, 0.42887285351753235, -0.41063088178634644, -0.051114700734615326, -0.3057991564273834, -0.5844318270683289, 0.6610907912254333, 0.09083865582942963, 0.4915081858634949, -0.35121554136276245, -0.04640880972146988, 0.3487732410430908, -0.2579750120639801, 0.8052818179130554, -0.1055508628487587, -0.2737918198108673, 0.42100733518600464, 0.013283364474773407, 0.3173801004886627, 0.21999500691890717, -0.35711103677749634, 0.15799899399280548, -0.4099541902542114, -0.21504193544387817, -0.30840927362442017, 0.901780366897583, -0.9403859972953796, -0.3125167787075043, -0.057360388338565826, -0.7945780158042908, -0.4039967954158783, 0.46723058819770813, 0.10942807793617249, 0.7971124053001404, -0.08396650850772858, 0.5171765685081482, 0.7204512357711792, 0.0414506196975708, 0.5625394582748413, 0.48732370138168335, -0.23625589907169342, -0.2867686152458191, 0.5864716172218323, -0.13525350391864777, 0.15502363443374634, 0.42388761043548584, 0.2437300980091095, -0.1567583680152893, -0.5219010710716248, -0.739215612411499, -0.01848367415368557, -0.5937491655349731, -0.33909520506858826, -0.9131965637207031, -0.347928524017334, -0.18597951531410217, -0.670214056968689, -0.2006371170282364, -0.31270885467529297, -0.17110201716423035, 0.0857032909989357, 0.38443267345428467, 0.5112369656562805, -0.13550186157226562, 0.5349465608596802, -0.5864147543907166, 0.8365495204925537, 0.4185383915901184, 0.4109206795692444, 0.054767537862062454, -0.36307933926582336, -0.21503280103206635, 0.36158478260040283, -0.11298314481973648, -0.7758557796478271, -0.019585464149713516, 0.20965711772441864, 0.5791044235229492, 0.24771951138973236, -0.10600192099809647, 0.3029589354991913, -0.3996017277240753, 0.5870245099067688, 0.5058194994926453, -0.7323676943778992, 0.3600555956363678, -0.8651389479637146, 0.15252567827701569, 0.3206661343574524, 0.16635505855083466, -0.5028769373893738, 0.2025158852338791, -0.2535620331764221, -0.6615065336227417, 0.23462845385074615, -0.11211903393268585, 0.42046913504600525, 0.07764318585395813, 0.3709407448768616, -0.1609685868024826, 0.18476374447345734, -0.8600494861602783, -0.10244522988796234, -0.22805635631084442, -0.1876743584871292, 0.23755663633346558, -0.1118554174900055, -0.5012118816375732, -0.25238651037216187, 0.4045734107494354, -0.4068974554538727, 0.21063421666622162, 0.029760869219899178, -0.09340792894363403, -0.11581209301948547, 0.19257903099060059, 0.5302792191505432, 0.7893673181533813, -0.04791934788227081, 0.03428336977958679, -0.004099840763956308, -0.05295180156826973, 0.4434489607810974, 0.10569044202566147, -0.4994542896747589, -0.02109508588910103, 0.3328070342540741, 0.6291805505752563, 0.47821617126464844, -0.4144246280193329, 0.45877712965011597, 0.11820226162672043, -0.24136142432689667, -0.3149946928024292, -0.013048455119132996, 0.3290865421295166, 0.1110236868262291, 0.7690317630767822, 0.30617260932922363, -0.011663153767585754, -0.4947441518306732, 0.13803954422473907, 0.7674198746681213, 0.05068002641201019, -0.3676254451274872, 0.7537662386894226, 0.4634319245815277, -0.16590125858783722, 0.30024755001068115, 0.10813556611537933, -0.3482189476490021, 0.6847336888313293, 0.8536077737808228, 0.5611802339553833, -0.15582232177257538, 0.19636285305023193, 0.06333423405885696, 0.4619594216346741, -0.2560618221759796, 0.30341291427612305, -0.04924275353550911, -0.9481233954429626, -0.5586591958999634, -0.5269462466239929, 0.022616352885961533, 0.0582091398537159, -0.39326101541519165, 0.16210682690143585, -0.6660374999046326, -0.07796037942171097, 0.0029407781548798084, 0.011586341075599194, -0.6323930621147156, 0.6845316290855408, 0.20825043320655823, 1.0301932096481323, -0.678299605846405, 0.5572096705436707, 0.6475962400436401, -0.08897251635789871, -0.9167489409446716, -0.4476051330566406, -0.07074780762195587, -0.5660779476165771, 0.5362755060195923, 0.301532119512558, -0.3119213283061981, 0.01339437160640955, -0.5211631059646606, -0.9537827968597412, 1.2081722021102905, 0.25505146384239197, -0.268521249294281, -0.36085349321365356, -0.04429009556770325, 0.07660169154405594, -0.4521942138671875, 0.39867329597473145, 0.16624267399311066, 0.5438045859336853, -0.13500089943408966, -0.9175181984901428, -0.03342954441905022, -0.16670049726963043, -0.017711598426103592, 0.16346925497055054, -0.7095888257026672, 1.0274420976638794, -0.29109081625938416, 0.06838241219520569, 0.11128086596727371, 0.5659294128417969, 0.35868585109710693, 0.2662798762321472, 0.5362871885299683, 0.6869885921478271, 0.44869086146354675, 0.05245545506477356, 0.8930394053459167, -0.3603423833847046, 0.12635710835456848, 0.5836739540100098, -0.2872716784477234, 0.4499463737010956, 0.2582894265651703, 0.20913663506507874, 0.543383002281189, 0.13193777203559875, 0.3798469603061676, 0.41675129532814026, 0.16943050920963287, -0.582353949546814, -0.17958258092403412, -0.3338042199611664, -0.7929292917251587, 0.6244730353355408, 0.5119317173957825, -0.061589304357767105, -0.5131158828735352, 0.23274090886116028, -0.1250779628753662, 0.055872365832328796, -0.5438958406448364, 0.2958570718765259, 0.18898160755634308, -0.2126314789056778, 0.5474703311920166, 0.6816336512565613, 1.1143062114715576, -0.9377142190933228, -0.031224792823195457, -0.1409910023212433, -0.08938450366258621, -0.46474289894104004, -0.1803077608346939, 0.2351100593805313, -0.22924962639808655, -0.5497980117797852, -0.08621583878993988, 0.9528468251228333, -0.01777184195816517, -0.5001356601715088, 0.5256442427635193, 0.46986180543899536, -0.33251529932022095, -0.10224480926990509, -0.7296363115310669, 0.4438355565071106, -0.20518432557582855, -0.39747530221939087, 0.43358540534973145, 0.4948507249355316, -0.3068719506263733, 0.9824253916740417, 1.0834659337997437, -0.07880817353725433, 0.06283582746982574, -0.07881437242031097, 0.9359626770019531, -0.7086392045021057, -0.5669686198234558, -0.5425264239311218, 0.6223255395889282, 0.21527732908725739, -0.2761693298816681, 0.5042635202407837, 0.17566324770450592, 0.5051616430282593, 0.10212099552154541, 0.9461577534675598, -0.36038291454315186, 0.05760941281914711, -0.4130744934082031, 0.6111013293266296, -0.5412960648536682, 0.10705463588237762, -0.1404011994600296, -0.9686766862869263, -0.2931668758392334, 0.7841797471046448, 0.00488431379199028, 0.08995321393013, 0.23797607421875, 0.6139665246009827, -0.3031494617462158, 0.2412283569574356, 0.38576093316078186, -0.0734994038939476, 0.508736789226532, 0.7303394675254822, 0.7421218752861023, -0.43937963247299194, 0.2623227536678314, -0.16746261715888977, -0.2768552899360657, -0.32093483209609985, -1.1048873662948608, -0.7219778895378113, -0.3412962257862091, 0.15232758224010468, -0.30466291308403015, -0.13471336662769318, 0.9670964479446411, 0.9325591325759888, -0.5816578269004822, -0.1909240484237671, -0.19556385278701782, 0.2811414301395416, 0.040329355746507645, -0.15073071420192719, 0.15183976292610168, -0.13748642802238464, -0.04401674121618271, 0.8423666954040527, 0.3829139173030853, -0.15133273601531982, -0.42313963174819946, -0.12771107256412506, -0.14818988740444183, 0.09855356067419052, 0.9702326655387878, 0.5110698938369751, -0.8554339408874512, -0.5297328233718872, 0.015611977316439152, -0.29409992694854736, -0.36837875843048096, 1.0132776498794556, -0.9596883654594421, 0.09522054344415665, 0.18043838441371918, 1.0148502588272095, -0.1295822709798813, 0.0033200790639966726, 0.44780978560447693, -0.4578995108604431, 0.5694869756698608, 0.27434390783309937, 0.3701406717300415, 0.1700850874185562, -0.2155846506357193, 0.4206284284591675, 0.3095495104789734, -0.446294367313385, -0.8259145617485046, 0.6131633520126343, -1.0133988857269287, -0.30452394485473633, 1.0664554834365845, 0.11290247738361359, 0.2702941596508026, -0.2115304172039032, -0.16328811645507812, -0.14836029708385468, 0.062459684908390045, 0.6479865312576294, 0.2528592050075531, 0.05090466886758804, -0.006766424048691988, -0.660435140132904, 0.14085356891155243, 0.4309028685092926, -0.7187744975090027, -0.06298500299453735, 0.6903409361839294, 0.2830982208251953, 0.25706782937049866, 0.9410340189933777, -0.05356381833553314, 0.2179570198059082, -0.23540787398815155, 0.06329507380723953, -0.4524558484554291, -0.7160711884498596, -0.26114100217819214, 0.40877044200897217, -0.07966355979442596, -0.02343381941318512 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16635v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16635v2	Improving Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback with Efficient Reward Model Ensemble	2024-01-30T00:17:37	2024-05-21T22:21:16	Shun Zhang, Zhenfang Chen, Sunli Chen, Yikang Shen, Zhiqing Sun, Chuang Gan	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL	Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is a widely adopted approach for aligning large language models with human values. However, RLHF relies on a reward model that is trained with a limited amount of human preference data, which could lead to inaccurate predictions. As a result, RLHF may produce outputs that are misaligned with human values. To mitigate this issue, we contribute a reward ensemble method that allows the reward model to make more accurate predictions. As using an ensemble of large language model-based reward models can be computationally and resource-expensive, we explore efficient ensemble methods including linear-layer ensemble and LoRA-based ensemble. Empirically, we run Best-of-$n$ and Proximal Policy Optimization with our ensembled reward models, and verify that our ensemble methods help improve the alignment performance of RLHF outputs.	[ -0.30805474519729614, -0.3553466498851776, 0.24557048082351685, 0.06936366111040115, 0.15836381912231445, 0.17591293156147003, -0.35856884717941284, -0.4793446660041809, 0.34324026107788086, 0.4810594916343689, -0.756424605846405, -0.07029655575752258, -0.3182872235774994, -0.2835835814476013, 0.09523748606443405, 1.0048179626464844, 0.05427262559533119, 0.08471029996871948, -0.21015340089797974, -0.29856470227241516, -0.3741416931152344, -0.49677130579948425, -0.6746978759765625, -0.7907572984695435, 0.7653337717056274, 0.635840654373169, 0.4933711290359497, 0.5815365314483643, 0.3884877562522888, 0.26451513171195984, 0.0620797798037529, 0.43066906929016113, -0.5996007919311523, 0.10001031309366226, -0.1804623156785965, -0.0774901881814003, -0.26929348707199097, -0.0672241821885109, 0.5644776821136475, 0.36744949221611023, -0.6348540782928467, -0.05339139327406883, 0.07066766917705536, 0.7375567555427551, -0.9596041440963745, 0.09809348732233047, -0.23096022009849548, 0.22370554506778717, 0.06287571787834167, -0.2505655884742737, -0.5283776521682739, -0.6369489431381226, 0.19957610964775085, -0.7829127907752991, -0.2979304790496826, 0.20829293131828308, 0.6457494497299194, 0.28435608744621277, -0.11835860460996628, 0.026424206793308258, -0.762630820274353, 1.0813440084457397, -0.6572561264038086, 0.1278715282678604, 0.4807775914669037, 0.5022833347320557, -0.2798148989677429, -0.29063454270362854, -0.37229982018470764, -0.36410027742385864, 0.054848719388246536, 0.2945145070552826, 0.11626732349395752, 0.07330892235040665, 0.08015214651823044, 0.058564912527799606, -0.36131927371025085, 0.5271615982055664, -0.04035700112581253, -0.3259158134460449, 1.0461828708648682, 0.20528386533260345, -0.06380645185709, 0.073692187666893, -0.49794262647628784, -0.9198905825614929, -0.6284970045089722, 0.4646153151988983, 0.6952751278877258, 0.325292706489563, 0.24237367510795593, 0.2596016228199005, -0.1758488565683365, 0.6766215562820435, 0.24280624091625214, -0.18533577024936676, 0.12234383821487427, 0.013708068057894707, 0.13712066411972046, 0.34468376636505127, 0.6895058751106262, 0.46811357140541077, 0.04636182636022568, -0.23886236548423767, -0.6409305930137634, 0.10028304904699326, 0.39168915152549744, -0.6353532671928406, -0.1795652061700821, 0.2728840708732605, -0.4276611804962158, -0.6767950057983398, 0.0326201505959034, -0.7677029371261597, -0.5695610046386719, -0.2067866176366806, 0.4608897864818573, -0.23184670507907867, -0.3094412386417389, -0.07688890397548676, -0.22310152649879456, 0.20975537598133087, 0.40279853343963623, -1.2758088111877441, 0.44377660751342773, 0.6767215728759766, 0.37363556027412415, -0.4092805087566376, -0.492087185382843, -1.111400842666626, -0.04118374362587929, -0.3175477385520935, 0.9756687879562378, -0.4003908932209015, -0.37342867255210876, 0.11780064553022385, -0.21677212417125702, -0.039950061589479446, -0.8180027604103088, 0.6404439210891724, -0.5725220441818237, 0.2725166082382202, -0.39060258865356445, -0.7015134692192078, -0.016244152560830116, 0.3422798812389374, -0.7028345465660095, 0.9499118328094482, 0.15613433718681335, -0.6247708201408386, 0.271729975938797, -0.8667184710502625, -0.29792124032974243, -0.0649692714214325, 0.000023622334992978722, -0.460316926240921, -0.1616744101047516, 0.3888222277164459, 0.19742383062839508, -0.10459005832672119, 0.2578061819076538, -0.3726075291633606, -0.5712518095970154, 0.3871566653251648, -0.280724436044693, 0.3134472966194153, 0.38041844964027405, -0.25940054655075073, 0.6070237755775452, -0.4957980811595917, 0.2634018659591675, 0.15117724239826202, -0.6080978512763977, -0.23573070764541626, 0.2682996690273285, 0.3514592945575714, -0.07171986252069473, 0.11138049513101578, -0.38218551874160767, 0.4077088534832001, -0.3376197814941406, 0.5038542151451111, 1.1756681203842163, -0.08459090441465378, 0.6575575470924377, -0.5242560505867004, 0.6966739892959595, -0.14792296290397644, 0.06138193979859352, 0.21531958878040314, -0.09360433369874954, -0.21570661664009094, -0.05508165434002876, 0.6121720671653748, 0.4106099605560303, -0.49109214544296265, 0.5062190294265747, -0.032622791826725006, -0.24026846885681152, -0.5118569731712341, 0.030612528324127197, 0.4397105276584625, 0.4575633704662323, 0.2911677062511444, -0.32253026962280273, -0.4075862169265747, -0.7822725176811218, -0.2905348837375641, -0.35475119948387146, 0.16806036233901978, 0.2939377725124359, 0.4033546447753906, -0.17836005985736847, 0.7938806414604187, -0.4718432128429413, -0.07594779878854752, -0.24712342023849487, 0.20242062211036682, 0.05301429703831673, 0.5801650285720825, 0.2280629575252533, -0.45021405816078186, -0.11682095378637314, 0.015422954224050045, -0.2710355818271637, 0.17675146460533142, 0.014232190325856209, -0.20299571752548218, 0.3260800540447235, 0.12853765487670898, -0.22706685960292816, 0.07186529040336609, 0.5844801068305969, -0.24770821630954742, 0.5870107412338257, -0.44026505947113037, 0.1277085393667221, -0.5928492546081543, 0.01252533495426178, -0.07346939295530319, -0.46685540676116943, -0.37078917026519775, -0.13785353302955627, 0.15483704209327698, 0.16610291600227356, -0.28831765055656433, 0.6187139749526978, -0.009062673896551132, -0.21247240900993347, -0.38744696974754333, -0.042474567890167236, -0.16109979152679443, 0.8958888053894043, 0.37079620361328125, 0.6433760523796082, 0.1272105574607849, -0.49128320813179016, 0.5636903643608093, 0.10582514852285385, -0.47744452953338623, 0.6167451739311218, -0.5205399394035339, 0.16604411602020264, -0.04560443386435509, 0.5380264520645142, -0.6088908910751343, -0.6795290112495422, 0.24181737005710602, -0.22495490312576294, 0.14940299093723297, 0.15826627612113953, -0.16437043249607086, -0.17053478956222534, -0.4785795211791992, 0.4535900354385376, 0.4430369734764099, -0.8654194474220276, 0.3364061713218689, 0.5101160407066345, 0.05830448120832443, -0.9659970998764038, -0.37127891182899475, -0.3288704454898834, -0.40695920586586, -0.36799660325050354, 0.5286781191825867, 0.08000688254833221, -0.1283026486635208, -0.06268305331468582, -0.08896056562662125, 0.10413657873868942, 0.21026098728179932, 0.10698676109313965, 0.31337860226631165, 0.10330882668495178, 0.4019899368286133, -0.192620187997818, -0.17466755211353302, 0.010102376341819763, -0.3780461847782135, 0.6125455498695374, -0.2979661226272583, -0.4400649666786194, -0.42105787992477417, 0.2017969787120819, 0.31968772411346436, -0.3607385754585266, 0.5493720769882202, 0.6367775201797485, -0.22701922059059143, -0.2635171711444855, -0.4181238114833832, -0.5474829077720642, -0.38527530431747437, 0.42816606163978577, 0.1012718677520752, -0.8062676787376404, 0.40293043851852417, -0.02608424797654152, 0.18155492842197418, 0.32238975167274475, 0.28889933228492737, -0.2498919665813446, 1.2455257177352905, 0.33155572414398193, -0.4867848753929138, 0.7121521234512329, -0.25101855397224426, -0.1135396882891655, -0.5958703756332397, -0.2711719572544098, -0.39396461844444275, -0.6132001876831055, -0.6429513096809387, -0.1391202211380005, 0.3893389105796814, 0.08390327543020248, -0.5210886001586914, 0.12158868461847305, -0.5054596066474915, 0.5038391351699829, 0.8436126112937927, 0.3477705419063568, 0.07427825778722763, 0.0024545881897211075, 0.08670826256275177, 0.1677541434764862, -0.9772147536277771, -0.24727822840213776, 0.9762611985206604, 0.45112279057502747, 1.033197045326233, 0.13911612331867218, 1.013656735420227, 0.4787956774234772, 0.1654992699623108, -0.7244062423706055, 0.17161540687084198, 0.10720861703157425, -0.13474419713020325, -0.7206713557243347, -0.6015224456787109, -1.0774354934692383, 0.1734817773103714, -0.409088671207428, -0.773647129535675, 0.18330390751361847, 0.6552174687385559, -0.7994749546051025, 0.24245919287204742, -0.6480116844177246, 0.9357848763465881, -0.5478930473327637, -0.5013428330421448, -0.41980406641960144, -0.6218952536582947, 0.4142514765262604, 0.320602685213089, 0.14912091195583344, 0.11359190195798874, 0.19120599329471588, 1.0242836475372314, -0.7236581444740295, 0.5885280966758728, -0.4619075059890747, -0.216794952750206, 0.23294195532798767, -0.11998263001441956, 1.0458769798278809, -0.05775759741663933, -0.00884254276752472, -0.3156765401363373, 0.0019045076332986355, -0.551689088344574, -0.6691648960113525, 0.7436981797218323, -1.0968430042266846, -0.24369336664676666, -0.4844881296157837, -0.6766254901885986, -0.46276387572288513, -0.1588655710220337, 0.12781451642513275, 0.41738757491111755, -0.2055303007364273, -0.03428523987531662, 0.7998865842819214, -0.16790440678596497, 0.5113499164581299, -0.05800962820649147, -0.3509441614151001, -0.5889295339584351, 1.0263808965682983, -0.18638482689857483, 0.34361693263053894, 0.45278656482696533, 0.4016190469264984, -0.6608678102493286, -0.10632941871881485, -0.5399344563484192, -0.045432887971401215, -0.4799904525279999, -0.11784295737743378, -0.14805607497692108, 0.016369735822081566, -0.46707531809806824, -0.020693030208349228, -0.41363415122032166, -0.5164975523948669, 0.09604927152395248, 0.0382407046854496, 0.3506661355495453, 0.8706256747245789, -0.26149505376815796, 0.310541033744812, -0.7049808502197266, -0.12374080717563629, 0.5831794142723083, 0.4098750352859497, 0.15427808463573456, -0.3405493199825287, -0.28447574377059937, 0.09288628399372101, -0.28143391013145447, -0.7783351540565491, 0.2750759720802307, -0.05240543186664581, 0.7131726741790771, 0.4695543944835663, 0.2711081802845001, 0.5373945832252502, -0.11587376147508621, 0.49445855617523193, 0.4014749526977539, -0.6887435913085938, 0.40682119131088257, -0.2791249454021454, 0.24354252219200134, 0.41397303342819214, -0.10872301459312439, -0.6332154273986816, 0.24266019463539124, -0.6868796348571777, -0.7070465087890625, 0.9416614770889282, -0.15245777368545532, -0.3721076250076294, 0.28968346118927, 0.05493030324578285, -0.08632493764162064, 0.03546299785375595, -0.6347456574440002, 0.08621237426996231, -0.31903377175331116, -0.24092476069927216, -0.19022147357463837, 0.008054693229496479, -0.38185620307922363, 0.05950135737657547, 0.9029161334037781, -0.3355664610862732, 0.2562566101551056, 0.053561851382255554, -0.0637834295630455, -0.47663408517837524, 0.39444777369499207, 0.9340499639511108, 0.3940437138080597, -0.4096313416957855, 0.022230641916394234, 0.25629186630249023, 0.00030610364046879113, 0.43982839584350586, -0.09846573323011398, 0.06595839560031891, -0.5066213011741638, 0.27803146839141846, 0.9846062660217285, 0.1632867455482483, -1.0500229597091675, 0.48947960138320923, -0.05089397355914116, -0.35720619559288025, -0.2840866446495056, 0.32185134291648865, 0.1780681610107422, 0.4132474958896637, 0.07888893038034439, 0.2838689982891083, -0.16309228539466858, -0.46791958808898926, 0.07741747796535492, 0.4421188235282898, -0.5906425714492798, 0.11014378070831299, 0.3828190267086029, 0.21280214190483093, -0.4479987919330597, 0.7263948917388916, -0.17027369141578674, -0.6748190522193909, 0.5619724988937378, 0.36701053380966187, 0.7451944947242737, -0.283119261264801, 0.35878318548202515, 0.45933854579925537, -0.03360914811491966, -0.5214342474937439, -0.0014216878917068243, -0.3858625292778015, -0.8576470613479614, -0.6693297624588013, -0.3961760401725769, -0.6640516519546509, -0.012914293445646763, -0.8722413182258606, -0.04985682666301727, -0.4206239879131317, -0.04798617213964462, -0.2692382335662842, 0.012422854080796242, -0.3119475543498993, -0.10767170786857605, 0.08586461842060089, 0.6665884852409363, -0.7359328866004944, 0.7850642800331116, 0.7447777390480042, -0.2548254728317261, -1.046980857849121, -0.11595652997493744, -0.16588154435157776, -0.8709638714790344, 0.7601963877677917, -0.011681864969432354, -0.28964507579803467, -0.13885115087032318, -0.5410475134849548, -0.6571200489997864, 0.9825297594070435, 0.14616893231868744, -0.7540602684020996, 0.040931761264801025, -0.15969093143939972, 0.3554235100746155, -0.4414915144443512, 0.3195432424545288, 0.5792383551597595, 0.6666186451911926, 0.024107210338115692, -0.6955512762069702, -0.21225330233573914, -0.07533277571201324, 0.08319990336894989, 0.32966455817222595, -0.6337441205978394, 0.4993622303009033, -0.2794964909553528, 0.147056445479393, -0.0013135031331330538, 0.796674907207489, 0.6406660676002502, 0.18497350811958313, 0.999779999256134, 0.811365008354187, 1.0661087036132812, 0.018760183826088905, 1.152159333229065, 0.01651749573647976, 0.3672995865345001, 1.1186779737472534, -0.4619499146938324, 1.0337257385253906, 0.5162364840507507, -0.2317810207605362, 0.6193810105323792, 0.980106770992279, 0.24828998744487762, 0.8065749406814575, 0.5129522681236267, -0.24255728721618652, -0.6226856112480164, -0.07939202338457108, -0.20859000086784363, 0.2814955711364746, 0.004342257976531982, 0.03531447798013687, -0.11397820711135864, -0.048281241208314896, -0.20276401937007904, 0.24710170924663544, -0.44791096448898315, 0.9392673969268799, -0.3719725012779236, -1.2790539264678955, 0.5597038865089417, -0.0005998215056024492, 0.7504070997238159, -0.34540677070617676, -0.15829436480998993, -0.16116680204868317, 0.4470313489437103, -0.19775423407554626, -0.5323672294616699, -0.11399457603693008, -0.1822812259197235, -0.09439799934625626, -0.26561155915260315, 0.6919439435005188, -0.6211091876029968, -0.1444278061389923, 0.15925243496894836, 0.18885356187820435, -0.07019854336977005, 0.017159782350063324, -0.5510092377662659, -0.23410433530807495, -0.01577894203364849, -0.24404671788215637, 0.6045952439308167, -0.19383294880390167, -0.24337497353553772, 0.572608470916748, 0.6548248529434204, 0.12474669516086578, -0.19133052229881287, -0.055125728249549866, 0.4511829912662506, -0.7023175358772278, -0.7424888014793396, -0.625530481338501, 0.29281625151634216, -0.2176186740398407, -0.2696547210216522, 0.12862929701805115, 0.24810890853405, 0.8689640760421753, -0.014568885788321495, 0.8014870882034302, 0.20634165406227112, 0.556768536567688, -0.5535246729850769, 0.47935569286346436, -0.4370138347148895, 0.2954714000225067, -0.03582027181982994, -0.8365712761878967, -0.03176882490515709, 0.8204343318939209, -0.18741343915462494, 0.023906800895929337, 0.3818146586418152, 0.8918895125389099, 0.11587342619895935, 0.19256719946861267, 0.18957458436489105, -0.18581728637218475, 0.17444083094596863, 0.7222962379455566, 1.2575796842575073, -0.11916719377040863, 0.3584904670715332, -0.4157932996749878, -0.13603556156158447, -0.435730516910553, -0.9897246360778809, -0.34592705965042114, -0.3356064558029175, -0.19937963783740997, -0.5587579607963562, 0.24549059569835663, 1.5054857730865479, 0.893021285533905, -1.021172046661377, -0.563999354839325, -0.10432884097099304, 0.3133031725883484, -0.8251023292541504, -0.2066677361726761, 0.45093023777008057, -0.415982186794281, -0.5901647210121155, 0.41218969225883484, 0.03291693702340126, -0.14726829528808594, -0.44833508133888245, -0.9144046306610107, -0.07828297466039658, -0.14203524589538574, 0.3055337071418762, 0.5526397228240967, -0.6412146091461182, -0.46039140224456787, -0.04750417545437813, -0.0349530354142189, -0.07078729569911957, 0.8502691388130188, -0.7301306128501892, 0.12675799429416656, 0.49629953503608704, 0.9496504664421082, 0.4205719828605652, 0.21213378012180328, 0.673485279083252, -0.6090335845947266, -0.20242218673229218, 0.25859448313713074, 0.3938238322734833, 0.19139687716960907, -0.24052336812019348, 0.546211838722229, 0.07833494246006012, -0.8921488523483276, -0.8814266920089722, 0.24352668225765228, -1.0017518997192383, -0.2625200152397156, 0.9015067219734192, -0.18938656151294708, -0.4044272005558014, 0.31543174386024475, -0.2089795172214508, 0.016540849581360817, -0.7515986561775208, 0.9132221937179565, 0.5430759787559509, -0.3843972086906433, -0.2348753958940506, -0.08180879056453705, 0.5762079954147339, 0.7778030037879944, -0.955007016658783, 0.029649967327713966, 0.4751235842704773, -0.01653219200670719, 0.03451421484351158, 0.5016053915023804, 0.1734207570552826, 0.6035981774330139, -0.33130818605422974, 0.33396896719932556, 0.07994339615106583, -0.20313392579555511, -0.5502920746803284, 0.07224772125482559, 0.4566691815853119, -0.2656380832195282 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16589v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16589v2	ToPro: Token-Level Prompt Decomposition for Cross-Lingual Sequence Labeling Tasks	2024-01-29T21:44:27	2024-03-13T09:45:02	Bolei Ma, Ercong Nie, Shuzhou Yuan, Helmut Schmid, Michael Färber, Frauke Kreuter, Hinrich Schütze	cs.CL	cs.CL	Prompt-based methods have been successfully applied to multilingual pretrained language models for zero-shot cross-lingual understanding. However, most previous studies primarily focused on sentence-level classification tasks, and only a few considered token-level labeling tasks such as Named Entity Recognition (NER) and Part-of-Speech (POS) tagging. In this paper, we propose Token-Level Prompt Decomposition (ToPro), which facilitates the prompt-based method for token-level sequence labeling tasks. The ToPro method decomposes an input sentence into single tokens and applies one prompt template to each token. Our experiments on multilingual NER and POS tagging datasets demonstrate that ToPro-based fine-tuning outperforms Vanilla fine-tuning and Prompt-Tuning in zero-shot cross-lingual transfer, especially for languages that are typologically different from the source language English. Our method also attains state-of-the-art performance when employed with the mT5 model. Besides, our exploratory study in multilingual large language models shows that ToPro performs much better than the current in-context learning method. Overall, the performance improvements show that ToPro could potentially serve as a novel and simple benchmarking method for sequence labeling tasks.	[ -0.4762192964553833, -0.6233340501785278, 0.09935380518436432, 0.1560673713684082, -0.507591187953949, 0.2448836714029312, -0.17820614576339722, -0.22260913252830505, 0.09227006882429123, 0.2134014517068863, -0.49667757749557495, -0.7946531176567078, -0.49604737758636475, 0.5141171813011169, -0.07628853619098663, 0.9746077656745911, 0.17130379378795624, -0.005676541477441788, -0.07657018303871155, -0.11947076767683029, -0.7584337592124939, -0.47615915536880493, -0.9984086155891418, 0.07919531315565109, 0.8156667351722717, 0.6479332447052002, 0.06696392595767975, 0.6259413361549377, 0.03271743282675743, 0.24470119178295135, -0.5405285358428955, 0.11991923302412033, -0.40436312556266785, 0.3604259490966797, -0.49644017219543457, -0.5528128147125244, -0.370909720659256, -0.13653768599033356, 0.6530510187149048, 0.6333172917366028, -0.05378444120287895, 0.23482388257980347, -0.2868170738220215, 0.2096703052520752, -0.5602822303771973, -0.007980269379913807, -0.566418468952179, 0.23393815755844116, -0.10692440718412399, -0.2198534607887268, -0.6308760046958923, 0.07291828840970993, -0.12355870008468628, -0.9616755843162537, 0.21945777535438538, 0.6082656979560852, 0.7741541266441345, 0.1472107470035553, -0.27571916580200195, -0.026515016332268715, -0.44206640124320984, 0.839654266834259, -0.4701571762561798, 0.609519362449646, 0.4344075620174408, 0.32493889331817627, 0.2146553248167038, -0.37277117371559143, -0.4817110002040863, -0.08347472548484802, -0.11957523226737976, -0.1354529857635498, -0.33326563239097595, -0.12459567189216614, 0.4609260857105255, 0.1788615584373474, -0.7128341794013977, 0.4141630232334137, -0.30259767174720764, -0.5183106064796448, 0.0020992893259972334, 0.043954964727163315, 0.5684186816215515, -0.2802075445652008, -0.5891085863113403, -0.07662283629179001, -0.7965960502624512, 0.12736444175243378, -0.02301499806344509, 0.6831052303314209, 0.10294356942176819, 0.45753195881843567, -0.17781047523021698, 0.670177698135376, 0.24492058157920837, -0.2634957730770111, 0.24722445011138916, -0.7227171063423157, -0.2708972692489624, 0.27279719710350037, 0.6036788821220398, 0.30714505910873413, 0.12928256392478943, -0.32918691635131836, -0.18840312957763672, -0.10476301610469818, -0.3202255666255951, -0.789158284664154, 0.29069674015045166, 0.09146751463413239, -0.3112027943134308, -0.1463502049446106, -0.37253811955451965, -0.639634907245636, -0.2660287618637085, -0.19075335562229156, 0.3936196565628052, -0.4031623303890228, -0.13012301921844482, -0.07602473348379135, -0.21185967326164246, 0.36221712827682495, 0.27846139669418335, -0.7347540259361267, 0.19598165154457092, 0.7392640113830566, 0.925498366355896, -0.1218961551785469, -0.4666098654270172, -1.3508641719818115, 0.2001437097787857, -0.42150020599365234, 0.6853304505348206, -0.5477904081344604, -0.36348745226860046, -0.2969743013381958, 0.05899600684642792, -0.2038673609495163, -0.6326042413711548, 0.2564268112182617, -0.2880086898803711, 0.5110109448432922, -0.41850507259368896, -0.3547596335411072, 0.16244958341121674, 0.5837817192077637, -0.4830867052078247, 1.1942386627197266, 0.1495351940393448, -0.795802652835846, 0.4850395619869232, -0.6297236680984497, -0.6245286464691162, 0.1981370896100998, 0.1935000866651535, 0.044661007821559906, -0.0028172272723168135, 0.5966777801513672, 0.3436392843723297, -0.5692326426506042, 0.4179822504520416, 0.16040974855422974, -0.25696834921836853, -0.06392136961221695, -0.007545171305537224, 0.8137209415435791, 0.2757534980773926, -0.2700534760951996, 0.5576964616775513, -0.9213176965713501, -0.2909274697303772, -0.1497778445482254, 0.10096926242113113, -0.6692317128181458, -0.4138578772544861, -0.2354731559753418, 0.3817417025566101, 0.1425430178642273, -0.8950584530830383, 0.2940884232521057, -0.37371957302093506, 0.30539897084236145, 0.4107023775577545, 0.10328590869903564, 0.48166629672050476, -0.010035012848675251, 0.7664176821708679, 0.3237312138080597, 0.07048633694648743, -0.7760114073753357, -0.32917627692222595, -0.5404654741287231, -0.5271912813186646, 0.5758562684059143, 0.9463943839073181, -1.1666433811187744, 0.30587729811668396, -0.07231231033802032, -0.25375476479530334, -0.5496892929077148, -0.25284624099731445, 0.6784297823905945, 1.1783665418624878, 0.633848249912262, -0.22679424285888672, -0.3653212785720825, -0.6728084683418274, -0.18790066242218018, -0.178835928440094, -0.052598174661397934, -0.006314291153103113, 0.13640308380126953, 0.03377629444003105, 0.7440917491912842, -0.24987678229808807, -0.3711199164390564, -0.4809361696243286, 0.48017600178718567, 0.08581552654504776, 0.5022642612457275, 0.6273086667060852, -0.40620285272598267, -0.36580219864845276, 0.15476739406585693, -0.16123561561107635, -0.33569222688674927, -0.12364616990089417, -0.20206990838050842, 0.2143118679523468, 0.4916623532772064, -0.48835355043411255, 0.19769005477428436, 0.011262081563472748, -0.4608592391014099, 0.27578791975975037, -0.18782387673854828, 0.2882118821144104, -1.060034990310669, 0.3300321400165558, 0.03994549438357353, -0.24692153930664062, -0.7362512350082397, -0.01797790825366974, -0.014353308826684952, -0.34298819303512573, -0.6978358030319214, 0.8829224109649658, -0.45940884947776794, -0.26136380434036255, 0.012170027010142803, -0.0696139708161354, 0.04344197362661362, 0.5574155449867249, 0.023699425160884857, 0.8078035712242126, 0.97794508934021, -0.6455398797988892, -0.038296911865472794, 0.3187330961227417, -0.20318183302879333, 0.7709805369377136, -0.7202573418617249, 0.15675023198127747, -0.39015838503837585, 0.10937681794166565, -1.2871276140213013, -0.02091561071574688, 0.6382569670677185, -0.5379586219787598, 0.3723349869251251, -0.3238374590873718, -0.5387017130851746, 0.10205534845590591, -0.2907089591026306, 0.7558996081352234, 0.450920432806015, -0.36296334862709045, 0.5202604532241821, 0.1324542909860611, -0.44839417934417725, -0.8129103779792786, -0.5601967573165894, 0.07118107378482819, -0.2302139699459076, -0.24707572162151337, 0.48049142956733704, 0.016728030517697334, 0.07971777766942978, -0.16762004792690277, -0.07242481410503387, 0.10559888184070587, -0.050858158618211746, -0.17309530079364777, 0.1640251725912094, -0.22059667110443115, -0.17427095770835876, 0.3375335931777954, -0.4976680874824524, -0.34856417775154114, -0.35101231932640076, 0.5925737619400024, 0.17396052181720734, 0.07076903432607651, -0.42707765102386475, 0.5692847967147827, 0.6246105432510376, -0.7312469482421875, 0.6612030267715454, 0.651129961013794, -0.4265294075012207, -0.22155889868736267, -0.038871243596076965, 0.260189950466156, -0.39950665831565857, -0.03213018923997879, -0.5514192581176758, -0.9612191915512085, 0.7842349410057068, -0.01928357407450676, 0.06064548343420029, 0.40609216690063477, 0.3360786736011505, 0.17724032700061798, 0.860732913017273, 0.5573732256889343, 0.012202100828289986, 0.6218236684799194, -0.03919205814599991, 0.0721525102853775, -0.7080838680267334, -0.3648841679096222, -0.7672592997550964, -0.12803710997104645, -0.2416359931230545, -0.4155256748199463, 0.2972604036331177, 0.06648403406143188, -0.326328307390213, 0.5004292130470276, -0.39142394065856934, 0.513893187046051, 0.6343542337417603, -0.174952432513237, 0.1714002788066864, 0.024540193378925323, -0.42775624990463257, 0.12237638235092163, -0.6940843462944031, -0.0008884476847015321, 0.3892992436885834, 0.044030435383319855, 0.41525694727897644, -0.28129643201828003, 0.7680463790893555, 0.26381340622901917, -0.009246906265616417, -0.871467649936676, 0.7176419496536255, -0.16053879261016846, -0.28274551033973694, -0.5217632055282593, -0.5549959540367126, -1.075373888015747, 0.3358975350856781, 0.12772753834724426, -0.8446264266967773, 0.25605273246765137, 0.2316797971725464, -0.2620120942592621, 0.16680262982845306, -0.41550561785697937, 1.055160403251648, -0.18350538611412048, -0.018980802968144417, 0.06499401479959488, -0.8296992182731628, -0.14098013937473297, 0.1747961938381195, 0.39815330505371094, -0.14947350323200226, -0.22680221498012543, 0.8018636703491211, -0.4012151062488556, 0.7078460454940796, -0.571756899356842, -0.36250245571136475, 0.24768826365470886, 0.27942779660224915, 0.2944318652153015, -0.16714338958263397, -0.016647377982735634, 0.23156417906284332, 0.05364632606506348, -0.2743263840675354, -0.5924213528633118, 0.42601126432418823, -0.42037054896354675, -0.33556097745895386, -0.27949684858322144, -0.3292316794395447, -0.20712152123451233, 0.3792167603969574, 0.44407758116722107, 0.7321985363960266, 0.03981217369437218, -0.28233325481414795, 0.5887492299079895, -0.668190598487854, 0.5293372273445129, 0.3141818642616272, -0.3040112853050232, -0.8478818535804749, 1.04718017578125, 0.17283470928668976, 0.0718424916267395, 0.8678703904151917, 0.2635100185871124, -0.25247108936309814, -0.6329250335693359, -0.8003479838371277, 0.21745213866233826, -0.693051278591156, -0.3627937436103821, -0.39448457956314087, 0.4045875668525696, -0.5070381164550781, -0.05232967808842659, -0.1875966340303421, -0.6380677819252014, -0.31842052936553955, -0.17111223936080933, 0.10486413538455963, 0.38485705852508545, -0.12040102481842041, 0.4794597625732422, -0.7909312844276428, 0.5940653085708618, -0.19940344989299774, 0.3529251217842102, -0.037675365805625916, -0.47512876987457275, -0.1144467443227768, -0.26506873965263367, 0.39466923475265503, -0.866033136844635, 0.48626676201820374, 0.21986158192157745, 0.6000280976295471, -0.012468356639146805, 0.08503779768943787, 0.7618008255958557, -0.6293534636497498, 0.8662611842155457, 0.2522546648979187, -1.3405442237854004, 0.7217951416969299, -0.33315110206604004, 0.5163851380348206, 0.5475060939788818, 0.6382027268409729, -0.9757552742958069, -0.17831352353096008, -0.15911467373371124, -1.1377058029174805, 0.9904564023017883, -0.27539750933647156, -0.23322643339633942, -0.2738535702228546, 0.094076007604599, 0.5789659023284912, 0.14615637063980103, -0.39929869771003723, -0.22845986485481262, -0.03737776726484299, -0.1739923059940338, -0.015522275120019913, -0.05972748249769211, 0.09358973056077957, -0.4300170838832855, 0.4623335301876068, -0.2152625173330307, 0.4114363491535187, 0.2954596281051636, -0.5108566880226135, -0.15582431852817535, 0.5063859820365906, 0.6752237677574158, 0.5643739104270935, 0.1777215600013733, 0.09815206378698349, 0.134395033121109, 0.017238883301615715, 0.2474914789199829, -0.06534325331449509, -0.36155855655670166, 0.031142255291342735, 0.3990415036678314, 1.1395466327667236, 0.45750272274017334, -0.48438236117362976, 0.38950425386428833, -0.07603055238723755, 0.03488386422395706, 0.2649884521961212, 0.021402647718787193, -0.37466001510620117, -0.04090756177902222, 0.6357139945030212, -0.043659891933202744, 0.03940622881054878, -0.6122042536735535, 0.3162946105003357, 0.08267966657876968, -0.06734643876552582, -0.515022873878479, 0.5901873111724854, 0.104923777282238, -0.4694904386997223, 0.3996039032936096, -0.37417301535606384, -0.6833472847938538, 0.6210562586784363, 0.6939331293106079, 0.7320452332496643, -0.28855159878730774, 0.4714807868003845, 0.6052504181861877, 0.18393181264400482, 0.15306541323661804, 0.6199620366096497, -0.43807607889175415, -0.3713662028312683, -0.7209950089454651, -0.5102663636207581, -0.5667485594749451, -0.13658630847930908, -0.7073407769203186, 0.17097815871238708, -0.4178968369960785, 0.13285477459430695, 0.13212579488754272, -0.3804795444011688, -0.6727483868598938, 0.2038927525281906, 0.38415464758872986, 0.9353246092796326, -0.6575538516044617, 0.5530351996421814, 0.8456616997718811, -0.28163447976112366, -0.6152148246765137, -0.1313706487417221, -0.2045135796070099, -0.5674981474876404, 0.8281927704811096, 0.3549925684928894, -0.1857994943857193, 0.23444443941116333, -0.4513297379016876, -0.9623594284057617, 0.7503060698509216, 0.37872445583343506, -0.5182152390480042, -0.15726813673973083, 0.21406401693820953, 0.5274676084518433, -0.4189618229866028, 0.4023396968841553, 0.1623978465795517, 0.5002331137657166, 0.26430362462997437, -1.283308506011963, 0.31229880452156067, -0.07308363169431686, -0.12989017367362976, 0.40872517228126526, -0.5746480226516724, 0.8600338697433472, -0.20969435572624207, -0.4181644022464752, 0.01533596683293581, 0.6381494998931885, 0.03776618838310242, 0.5494850873947144, 0.5749233365058899, 0.4196944236755371, 0.9676985144615173, -0.006084791384637356, 0.6903232336044312, -0.2751748263835907, 0.21584002673625946, 0.7980510592460632, -0.41275754570961, 0.8267458081245422, 0.41474273800849915, 0.24658504128456116, 0.506140947341919, 0.6889671683311462, 0.17447763681411743, 0.6876152157783508, 0.0786723718047142, 0.0789143517613411, -0.14617633819580078, -0.36745068430900574, -0.1553892344236374, 0.3786085844039917, 0.4406348466873169, -0.041546035557985306, -0.41374412178993225, 0.4781337380409241, 0.032961655408144, -0.49330422282218933, -0.7521135807037354, 0.8368034362792969, -0.2312762439250946, -0.9822607636451721, 0.739186704158783, 0.0625021904706955, 0.7397533059120178, -0.482970654964447, 0.039481744170188904, -0.42134159803390503, -0.14396686851978302, -0.03138318285346031, -0.6079205870628357, 0.06937595456838608, 0.26853033900260925, 0.09141403436660767, -0.5312431454658508, 0.7066785097122192, -0.6327221989631653, -0.15489627420902252, 0.24205759167671204, 0.7136362791061401, 0.1243649497628212, 0.2177252620458603, -0.4317505955696106, 0.03975015506148338, -0.09556231647729874, -0.17560051381587982, 0.3260682225227356, 0.59039705991745, -0.3251629173755646, 0.4479803442955017, 0.5685572624206543, -0.1540321260690689, 0.1290525645017624, 0.30607593059539795, 0.6697245240211487, -1.089660406112671, -0.6363033652305603, -0.6964002251625061, 0.6457216143608093, 0.07971309870481491, -0.6964171528816223, 0.4559612274169922, 0.569222092628479, 1.1750373840332031, -0.02952233888208866, 0.5141956210136414, -0.14968359470367432, 0.5274896621704102, -0.4259125888347626, 0.2697793245315552, -0.539414644241333, 0.013260041363537312, -0.28620636463165283, -0.8200380206108093, -0.5818017721176147, 0.32004207372665405, -0.042952198535203934, -0.243976891040802, 0.6217613816261292, 0.5060495734214783, -0.019607650116086006, -0.28339478373527527, 0.4226638972759247, -0.08140764385461807, 0.014064228162169456, 0.44660788774490356, 0.828353226184845, -0.13274024426937103, 0.5018701553344727, -0.22856807708740234, -0.16195914149284363, 0.03879000246524811, -0.9263851046562195, -0.9702820777893066, -0.5082516670227051, -0.4519404172897339, 0.2082478553056717, 0.08834312111139297, 1.0957286357879639, 0.4595378637313843, -0.8584362268447876, 0.016863355413079262, 0.25123143196105957, 0.07706043869256973, -0.3573664426803589, -0.17226442694664001, 0.20709562301635742, -0.5663989186286926, -0.6205714344978333, 0.7659721374511719, 0.2939195930957794, -0.16744503378868103, 0.03749282285571098, 0.13182340562343597, -0.06872192770242691, -0.06306921690702438, 0.8397865295410156, 0.3135060966014862, -0.6274179220199585, -0.27315786480903625, 0.610079824924469, 0.04930073767900467, 0.334090918302536, 1.0803143978118896, -0.9776721000671387, 0.30103930830955505, 0.8531555533409119, 0.694672703742981, 0.48194190859794617, 0.14466655254364014, 0.5144702792167664, -1.0644476413726807, -0.06605757772922516, 0.06279323995113373, 0.42625293135643005, 0.40078604221343994, -0.3338390290737152, 0.42557206749916077, 0.20193621516227722, -0.14996026456356049, -0.9940343499183655, 0.1445123553276062, -1.1143052577972412, -0.34839722514152527, 1.0414373874664307, -0.29048386216163635, -0.3737696409225464, 0.0021402069833129644, -0.4816150665283203, 0.6434650421142578, -0.36297038197517395, 0.1544971913099289, 0.6139004230499268, -0.19435392320156097, -0.3787776231765747, 0.04291355982422829, 0.1481918841600418, 0.5376622080802917, -0.7439959049224854, 0.16753409802913666, 0.6226693391799927, 0.29811519384384155, 0.22933946549892426, 0.48819389939308167, 0.04194428399205208, 0.3138574957847595, -0.11859296262264252, -0.04134112969040871, -0.518501341342926, -0.8026991486549377, -0.5448218584060669, 0.3941113352775574, -0.17088164389133453, -0.38462957739830017 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16587v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16587v3	A Linguistic Comparison between Human and ChatGPT-Generated Conversations	2024-01-29T21:43:27	2024-04-26T01:16:35	Morgan Sandler, Hyesun Choung, Arun Ross, Prabu David	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY	This study explores linguistic differences between human and LLM-generated dialogues, using 19.5K dialogues generated by ChatGPT-3.5 as a companion to the EmpathicDialogues dataset. The research employs Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count (LIWC) analysis, comparing ChatGPT-generated conversations with human conversations across 118 linguistic categories. Results show greater variability and authenticity in human dialogues, but ChatGPT excels in categories such as social processes, analytical style, cognition, attentional focus, and positive emotional tone, reinforcing recent findings of LLMs being "more human than human." However, no significant difference was found in positive or negative affect between ChatGPT and human dialogues. Classifier analysis of dialogue embeddings indicates implicit coding of the valence of affect despite no explicit mention of affect in the conversations. The research also contributes a novel, companion ChatGPT-generated dataset of conversations between two independent chatbots, which were designed to replicate a corpus of human conversations available for open access and used widely in AI research on language modeling. Our findings enhance understanding of ChatGPT's linguistic capabilities and inform ongoing efforts to distinguish between human and LLM-generated text, which is critical in detecting AI-generated fakes, misinformation, and disinformation.	[ -0.35057154297828674, -1.109739899635315, 0.2805366516113281, 0.09200377017259598, -0.10346328467130661, 0.43234845995903015, -0.37084266543388367, -0.5784289836883545, 0.3015146553516388, 0.46975213289260864, -0.564678430557251, -0.3896591067314148, -0.40744462609291077, 0.451325923204422, -0.1481822282075882, 0.8614479899406433, 0.24420060217380524, 0.2632089853286743, -0.06462762504816055, -0.0156418364495039, -0.2697731852531433, -0.7972627878189087, -0.8857543468475342, -0.5836805105209351, 0.6113274097442627, 0.06463836133480072, 0.6935816407203674, -0.08198782056570053, 0.5836459398269653, 0.3259427547454834, -0.10636354237794876, 0.14217859506607056, -0.43352097272872925, 0.13320505619049072, 0.06455779820680618, -0.3165837824344635, -0.37049517035484314, 0.14662611484527588, 0.16819962859153748, 0.09978081285953522, -0.12555670738220215, -0.008746371604502201, 0.11884254962205887, 0.5475630164146423, -0.14706017076969147, 0.19483385980129242, -0.5644195079803467, 0.165297269821167, -0.1230643168091774, -0.36584004759788513, -0.34053561091423035, -0.4316531717777252, 0.21117591857910156, -0.1374557465314865, 0.24107667803764343, 0.060778506100177765, 0.7300756573677063, 0.25512415170669556, -0.2827896773815155, -0.583346426486969, -0.38790324330329895, 0.49179351329803467, -0.8613247871398926, 0.2660429775714874, 0.3186779022216797, -0.03454769030213356, -0.27899110317230225, -0.3210563659667969, -0.8158010244369507, -0.5585086345672607, -0.21630731225013733, 0.33041444420814514, -0.36630573868751526, 0.23128698766231537, 0.22582168877124786, 0.48944318294525146, -0.7840518951416016, 0.056508082896471024, -0.2539910674095154, -0.22976787388324738, 0.6258168816566467, 0.2801738977432251, 0.546002984046936, -0.6490999460220337, -0.018698737025260925, -0.11799927800893784, -0.7221033573150635, -0.10340416431427002, 0.6393508315086365, 0.09200942516326904, -0.2657383978366852, 0.6758970618247986, -0.15051428973674774, 0.5408719778060913, -0.13836424052715302, -0.2870517373085022, 0.20601168274879456, -0.18261930346488953, -0.1462593525648117, 0.09798582643270493, 1.0324311256408691, 0.6814966201782227, 0.6390657424926758, -0.16870512068271637, 0.07353784143924713, 0.3299960494041443, 0.10247120261192322, -0.7436116337776184, -0.2728446125984192, 0.07818593829870224, -0.49939483404159546, -0.39126431941986084, -0.05666245520114899, -0.6067124605178833, -0.6787548065185547, -0.18645794689655304, -0.0673976019024849, -0.33667126297950745, -0.23155611753463745, 0.012241511605679989, -0.10626810789108276, 0.5863721370697021, 0.2122807651758194, -0.7259415984153748, 0.2948850095272064, 0.8113051652908325, 0.7213075160980225, -0.29602062702178955, -0.15237094461917877, -0.18123528361320496, -0.5156013369560242, -0.07274539023637772, 0.8333772420883179, -0.5491759777069092, -0.572411835193634, -0.012890975922346115, -0.19076882302761078, 0.05267203971743584, -0.6118737459182739, 0.5886923670768738, -0.15824851393699646, 0.466871440410614, -0.1763697862625122, -0.4148225486278534, -0.12396898120641708, 0.45822256803512573, -0.24269966781139374, 1.0155192613601685, 0.06955119967460632, -0.9597095847129822, 0.2406052201986313, -0.7042539119720459, -0.28094860911369324, 0.15331479907035828, -0.3913458287715912, -0.1722859889268875, -0.0827912986278534, -0.08642701804637909, 0.36474311351776123, -0.6388925909996033, 0.25869879126548767, -0.1548863798379898, -0.1940053403377533, 0.8170127272605896, -0.6340211629867554, 0.5204168558120728, 0.2396218329668045, -0.4556116461753845, -0.0731934979557991, -0.47316858172416687, -0.009198617190122604, 0.22350768744945526, -0.21299290657043457, 0.06078615039587021, 0.1398482322692871, -0.04603391885757446, 0.17148077487945557, 0.008183799684047699, -0.8802787065505981, 0.16419284045696259, -0.4514216184616089, 0.5700437426567078, 0.553792417049408, 0.1501368135213852, 0.20077620446681976, -0.3931977450847626, 0.5610173344612122, 0.01804765872657299, 0.026574360206723213, -0.266927033662796, -0.7948963046073914, -0.8772905468940735, -0.04486145079135895, 0.01870824210345745, 0.9188835024833679, -0.24525794386863708, 0.44503194093704224, -0.15637992322444916, -0.44693949818611145, -0.7585129141807556, -0.07409588247537613, 0.5023141503334045, 0.451464980840683, 0.21831214427947998, -0.48505812883377075, -0.43923377990722656, -0.860321581363678, -0.40145018696784973, -0.4652903079986572, -0.21287469565868378, 0.7426630854606628, 0.28031182289123535, -0.3672516345977783, 1.005033254623413, -0.28414952754974365, -0.036531537771224976, -0.3387761116027832, 0.16834509372711182, 0.0018402223940938711, 0.20791812241077423, 0.36496201157569885, -0.5170959234237671, -0.6939560174942017, -0.019782327115535736, -0.7171882390975952, -0.2455490380525589, -0.15706868469715118, -0.06453359127044678, 0.284008264541626, 0.23233744502067566, -0.8307473659515381, 0.6033661365509033, 0.4910898804664612, -0.4783133268356323, 0.25674518942832947, 0.13747991621494293, 0.41175034642219543, -1.2006915807724, -0.2842390537261963, -0.16469192504882812, 0.01848985068500042, -0.6367320418357849, -0.3500222861766815, -0.2887765169143677, -0.16258828341960907, -0.4633881747722626, 0.7115722894668579, -0.3776794970035553, 0.05358455330133438, 0.04580458626151085, 0.4684816598892212, -0.1951841413974762, 0.4748457074165344, 0.08388642966747284, 0.8088321685791016, 0.3929898142814636, -0.16312895715236664, 0.7050226330757141, 0.5454030632972717, -0.18010388314723969, 0.4319968521595001, -0.740439772605896, 0.4550324082374573, 0.19891376793384552, 0.4348500669002533, -0.9340307116508484, -0.30454954504966736, 0.6477503776550293, -0.8252307176589966, 0.03693899139761925, -0.091263547539711, -0.6573630571365356, -0.14232395589351654, -0.3447786569595337, 0.07642921060323715, 0.8490037322044373, -0.19557330012321472, 0.3384056091308594, 0.29671648144721985, -0.5560033917427063, -0.16724009811878204, -0.695626974105835, 0.4096550941467285, -0.3392828404903412, -0.8383326530456543, -0.05716541409492493, -0.08375086635351181, -0.7130220532417297, -0.21697211265563965, 0.33065277338027954, 0.13045673072338104, -0.016712283715605736, 0.43215346336364746, 0.20382632315158844, -0.2796820402145386, 0.1499284952878952, -0.24721260368824005, 0.00633848924189806, 0.17832636833190918, 0.12066724896430969, 0.810064435005188, -0.33977827429771423, -0.5709744095802307, -0.3880366086959839, 0.3360711932182312, 0.1966257244348526, 0.06963426619768143, 0.6454567313194275, 0.782055675983429, 0.19755558669567108, 0.3515600264072418, -0.7943199276924133, -0.36412209272384644, -0.4223043918609619, 0.058487627655267715, -0.1675753891468048, -1.089121699333191, 0.49956050515174866, 0.2576523721218109, -0.09605301171541214, 0.31647393107414246, 0.8584930896759033, -0.07219477742910385, 0.8639749884605408, 0.1001594290137291, -0.19240690767765045, 0.497604101896286, 0.17462705075740814, 0.46801379323005676, -0.8263484239578247, -0.16513393819332123, -0.41402238607406616, -0.1364070475101471, -1.0112112760543823, -0.3398178815841675, 0.07297925651073456, -0.2830958366394043, -0.20564696192741394, 0.04317062348127365, -0.560980498790741, 0.3428365886211395, 0.38587990403175354, 0.1366271823644638, 0.3111703395843506, -0.0688115805387497, 0.3408184051513672, -0.18160100281238556, -0.5802503228187561, -0.729541003704071, 0.9300552010536194, 0.18700122833251953, 0.6716204285621643, 0.34791475534439087, 0.7791592478752136, 0.5401917695999146, 0.40127643942832947, -0.8120717406272888, 0.6462848782539368, 0.18596996366977692, -0.4019264280796051, -0.07210719585418701, -0.5144293308258057, -1.0379643440246582, 0.16371628642082214, -0.2304835468530655, -1.0273467302322388, -0.45139071345329285, -0.014685047790408134, -0.02933686226606369, 0.25039801001548767, -0.7683343887329102, 0.6791441440582275, -0.3161309063434601, -0.31121471524238586, -0.18918488919734955, -0.7308527231216431, 0.14610326290130615, 0.11365342140197754, -0.06414281576871872, -0.38924986124038696, 0.34651482105255127, 0.5779993534088135, -0.3496433198451996, 1.052596926689148, 0.1454320102930069, -0.2544107437133789, 0.6599411964416504, 0.146932914853096, 0.32766100764274597, 0.1880873292684555, 0.13074760138988495, 0.22066526114940643, -0.2600737512111664, -0.2683459222316742, -0.3427506983280182, 0.4084377884864807, -0.7831006646156311, -0.6401054263114929, -0.43255919218063354, -0.37266725301742554, -0.03845294937491417, -0.059441760182380676, 0.23726651072502136, 0.4939533770084381, -0.6122309565544128, 0.09311209619045258, 0.32007354497909546, -0.7357338070869446, 0.2571025490760803, 0.6058997511863708, -0.08958671987056732, -0.22151553630828857, 0.8143816590309143, -0.40038058161735535, 0.4118958115577698, 0.5088645219802856, 0.31028833985328674, -0.2902807295322418, -0.041925638914108276, -0.31230390071868896, 0.3325076699256897, -0.545220136642456, -0.100944384932518, -0.6975015997886658, -0.2795760929584503, -0.5433750152587891, -0.12323537468910217, -0.18317675590515137, -0.2175426334142685, -0.013424819335341454, 0.00922473706305027, 0.852343738079071, 0.9025378227233887, -0.012392351403832436, 0.33675116300582886, -0.8545941114425659, 0.1487007439136505, 0.22751115262508392, -0.03294475004076958, -0.17575564980506897, -0.595308780670166, 0.20640812814235687, 0.30556535720825195, -0.5015837550163269, -0.9283297657966614, 0.552184522151947, 0.2049815058708191, 0.35300472378730774, 0.35810843110084534, -0.11342902481555939, 0.5058909058570862, -0.3717859387397766, 1.2152323722839355, 0.16067975759506226, -0.7384383082389832, 0.35324525833129883, -0.6092780232429504, 0.2696019411087036, 0.2418343424797058, 0.11336871981620789, -0.9563921093940735, -0.527346670627594, -0.9889102578163147, -0.6057326197624207, 0.4621322751045227, 0.5340520739555359, 0.2837633192539215, -0.32234689593315125, 0.16646885871887207, -0.046596042811870575, 0.08720129728317261, -0.6122178435325623, -0.204908549785614, 0.07494203001260757, -0.045666567981243134, -0.24009934067726135, -0.32484930753707886, -0.050730932503938675, -0.0009112299303524196, 0.20982177555561066, 0.020389849320054054, 0.688088595867157, 0.14688625931739807, -0.10816322267055511, 0.20395229756832123, 0.4637245237827301, 0.6521931290626526, 0.15067335963249207, -0.11562773585319519, 0.14767542481422424, 0.4098897874355316, -0.46437105536460876, -0.12041113525629044, -0.24232159554958344, 0.21256856620311737, -0.026804419234395027, 0.5442323088645935, 0.7949637174606323, 0.11587312817573547, -0.8765887022018433, 0.46892616152763367, -0.27836087346076965, -0.038807377219200134, -0.30138471722602844, -0.035907451063394547, 0.31214678287506104, 0.3621653616428375, -0.11214669048786163, 0.041031841188669205, 0.18275387585163116, -0.5718722343444824, 0.0469808429479599, 0.2748691141605377, -0.3391726016998291, -0.44458848237991333, 0.3499254882335663, 0.5246448516845703, -0.8008604645729065, 1.0413482189178467, -0.23305657505989075, -0.6672177910804749, 0.4127190113067627, 0.34311211109161377, 1.1371989250183105, -0.008568479679524899, 0.36176735162734985, 0.25369080901145935, 0.04914971813559532, 0.15615756809711456, 0.1517368108034134, -0.21263708174228668, -1.004359245300293, -0.2309907227754593, -0.40608274936676025, -0.7562629580497742, 0.02750033140182495, -0.5339086651802063, 0.0023722394835203886, -0.05255499482154846, -0.19657889008522034, -0.11247590184211731, -0.06537093967199326, -0.6295291781425476, -0.14874571561813354, 0.176184743642807, 0.412548303604126, -0.6331161856651306, 0.6368960738182068, 0.33994439244270325, -0.3453947901725769, -0.7562479376792908, 0.09033557027578354, 0.22294113039970398, -0.8435315489768982, 0.6883675456047058, 0.20846378803253174, -0.3278186023235321, -0.08132440596818924, -0.4747750759124756, -0.31422191858291626, 0.9082392454147339, 0.1472935527563095, -0.11454769968986511, 0.34273263812065125, 0.5142887830734253, 0.8642140030860901, -0.24339064955711365, 0.6370797753334045, 0.689956784248352, 0.28081831336021423, -0.0052711027674376965, -1.1248862743377686, -0.20949004590511322, -0.4603402614593506, -0.26572537422180176, 0.14974252879619598, -0.8021093606948853, 0.6700329780578613, -0.11162979900836945, -0.2623177766799927, 0.15289294719696045, 0.23606982827186584, 0.26517531275749207, 0.1043756753206253, 0.1745358407497406, 0.23987935483455658, 0.5080340504646301, -0.1448986828327179, 1.1525291204452515, -0.40581369400024414, 0.30614057183265686, 0.8956583142280579, -0.37560737133026123, 0.68879234790802, 0.35593003034591675, -0.34274420142173767, 0.29347988963127136, 0.903473436832428, 0.07815288007259369, 0.0029821256175637245, 0.3879121243953705, -0.5299976468086243, -0.0423806868493557, -0.22029660642147064, -0.3761202096939087, 0.5066750645637512, 0.32845747470855713, -0.2067469358444214, 0.05359931290149689, -0.2423771321773529, 0.33289235830307007, -0.22510933876037598, 0.14155761897563934, 1.0439099073410034, 0.2494463175535202, -0.7497214674949646, 0.42928388714790344, -0.17514324188232422, 0.7307219505310059, -0.31377801299095154, -0.10665681213140488, -0.47794678807258606, 0.07495325058698654, -0.2162439227104187, -0.9471871256828308, 0.052382633090019226, 0.3897419571876526, 0.1903698593378067, -0.4137560725212097, 0.8958947062492371, -0.34186646342277527, -0.17316557466983795, 0.2431364506483078, 0.7877611517906189, 0.7338823080062866, -0.09807930141687393, -0.7409177422523499, 0.03231942281126976, 0.2012631595134735, -0.4052301049232483, 0.3132614493370056, 0.4900018274784088, 0.03931255266070366, 0.7733168601989746, 0.5725748538970947, 0.09794270992279053, 0.15071985125541687, 0.3024120628833771, 0.8031908869743347, -0.8304225206375122, -0.14307546615600586, -1.0613152980804443, 0.3062761127948761, -0.14150911569595337, -0.4198039770126343, 0.7065285444259644, 0.4977562427520752, 0.5664398670196533, -0.18344439566135406, 0.8701569437980652, -0.28625157475471497, 0.6622172594070435, -0.488707035779953, 0.5350379347801208, -0.08559181541204453, 0.2162037491798401, -0.5281373262405396, -0.7769614458084106, -0.06266258656978607, 0.9127034544944763, -0.36964571475982666, 0.03642912954092026, 0.5281681418418884, 1.156842589378357, 0.15932312607765198, 0.11248500645160675, 0.3326042592525482, 0.13408266007900238, 0.3179185092449188, 0.39019182324409485, 1.480488896369934, -0.18567004799842834, 0.28609341382980347, 0.1897362768650055, -0.02340567670762539, -0.14175058901309967, -0.7499488592147827, -1.08467698097229, -0.43181708455085754, -0.22336113452911377, -0.32495078444480896, -0.06072802469134331, 1.030428409576416, 0.13787318766117096, -0.5542858242988586, -0.2631784975528717, -0.10849283635616302, -0.0855666995048523, 0.3991919159889221, -0.28460508584976196, 0.09819922596216202, -0.1258489191532135, -0.7462959885597229, 0.1978609561920166, 0.3161918520927429, 0.04919696971774101, -0.2966171205043793, -0.41482555866241455, 0.16804979741573334, 0.20389783382415771, 0.6381937265396118, 0.17436523735523224, -0.9846471548080444, -0.4901464879512787, 0.17545194923877716, -0.1760706901550293, 0.26767146587371826, 0.9365842342376709, -0.5993700623512268, 0.23373755812644958, 0.5286644697189331, 0.3544027507305145, 0.33132636547088623, 0.09347587078809738, 0.5275707244873047, -0.4890086054801941, 0.3070729374885559, 0.24791057407855988, 0.16484813392162323, 0.46551579236984253, -0.31149956583976746, 0.6987835168838501, 0.17975538969039917, -0.7457761764526367, -0.571438193321228, 0.4984012842178345, -1.2236323356628418, 0.31389012932777405, 1.3934900760650635, -0.17423322796821594, 0.21509163081645966, -0.09515488892793655, -0.7076384425163269, 0.24573850631713867, -0.7059721350669861, 0.7880755066871643, 0.7325111627578735, -0.6322505474090576, -0.2612280547618866, -0.5440365672111511, 0.5752122402191162, 0.3236583173274994, -0.9076648354530334, 0.00571926636621356, 0.3532809615135193, 0.04851589724421501, 0.046012457460165024, 0.7277060747146606, -0.13955305516719818, -0.010534645058214664, 0.10003602504730225, 0.3035065233707428, 0.35048428177833557, 0.35802435874938965, -0.07748028635978699, -0.27367621660232544, 0.06325267255306244, 0.12134581804275513 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16582v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16582v1	Massively Multilingual Text Translation For Low-Resource Languages	2024-01-29T21:33:08	2024-01-29T21:33:08	Zhong Zhou	cs.CL	cs.CL	Translation into severely low-resource languages has both the cultural goal of saving and reviving those languages and the humanitarian goal of assisting the everyday needs of local communities that are accelerated by the recent COVID-19 pandemic. In many humanitarian efforts, translation into severely low-resource languages often does not require a universal translation engine, but a dedicated text-specific translation engine. For example, healthcare records, hygienic procedures, government communication, emergency procedures and religious texts are all limited texts. While generic translation engines for all languages do not exist, translation of multilingually known limited texts into new, low-resource languages may be possible and reduce human translation effort. We attempt to leverage translation resources from rich-resource languages to efficiently produce best possible translation quality for well known texts, which are available in multiple languages, in a new, low-resource language. To reach this goal, we argue that in translating a closed text into low-resource languages, generalization to out-of-domain texts is not necessary, but generalization to new languages is. Performance gain comes from massive source parallelism by careful choice of close-by language families, style-consistent corpus-level paraphrases within the same language and strategic adaptation of existing large pretrained multilingual models to the domain first and then to the language. Such performance gain makes it possible for machine translation systems to collaborate with human translators to expedite the translation process into new, low-resource languages.	[ -0.22455474734306335, -0.4089636206626892, 0.4491535723209381, 0.3112349212169647, -0.32378479838371277, 0.2857862412929535, -0.7003662586212158, -0.4914979338645935, 0.13641545176506042, 0.6704983711242676, -0.31166839599609375, -0.28461527824401855, -0.5353119373321533, 0.4468231201171875, -0.3256019353866577, 1.3214706182479858, -0.1642700582742691, -0.28142568469047546, 0.004298517480492592, -0.4860491454601288, -0.1688242405653, -0.6454308032989502, -0.4396255314350128, -0.13463197648525238, 0.540778636932373, 0.6430454850196838, 0.9879937767982483, 0.6550267338752747, 0.7758123278617859, 0.2697594165802002, 0.1283312439918518, 0.14403791725635529, -0.6973761320114136, 0.06751187145709991, -0.38648679852485657, -0.2550734579563141, -0.2805270552635193, -0.2679547369480133, 0.6398227214813232, 0.6255542635917664, 0.0432913638651371, 0.477655291557312, 0.19140909612178802, 0.549813449382782, -0.5968159437179565, 0.11377871781587601, -0.37210944294929504, 0.010443725623190403, -0.43576857447624207, -0.35326293110847473, -0.2590700089931488, -0.25270456075668335, -0.008775677531957626, -0.5631294250488281, 0.3221494257450104, 0.052887752652168274, 0.34522074460983276, 0.30996617674827576, -0.44363078474998474, -0.21275903284549713, -0.914851188659668, 1.0245953798294067, -0.4077087342739105, 0.2601979374885559, 0.3912340998649597, 0.2804497480392456, 0.18021847307682037, -0.6198102831840515, -0.4156559705734253, 0.02027781680226326, 0.03475074842572212, 0.022499941289424896, -0.0847548097372055, -0.12111321091651917, 0.15575115382671356, 0.5149356722831726, -0.5056858658790588, -0.06575335562229156, -0.46381524205207825, -0.1627863198518753, 0.4696388840675354, 0.09669229388237, 0.4844081401824951, -0.2917604148387909, -0.36459264159202576, -0.20530889928340912, -0.5291714072227478, -0.0559430867433548, -0.10462022572755814, 0.4536387324333191, -0.3363613486289978, 0.3620610535144806, -0.24473625421524048, 0.37647977471351624, -0.4537539780139923, -0.4470314085483551, 0.1604917198419571, -0.8837562799453735, -0.1285632848739624, -0.023205114528536797, 0.636817216873169, 0.2039862722158432, 0.112371064722538, -0.19688117504119873, -0.15627212822437286, -0.050936032086610794, 0.05079030245542526, -0.8004246950149536, 0.04399466514587402, -0.24050281941890717, -0.7750626802444458, -0.2291373908519745, -0.4743337333202362, -0.9703106880187988, -0.35486340522766113, -0.0859874039888382, -0.01490083895623684, -0.29345712065696716, -0.21398113667964935, 0.10014753043651581, -0.11234133690595627, -0.03719622641801834, 0.36138173937797546, -0.8911013007164001, 0.341000497341156, 0.2598639726638794, 1.0483589172363281, 0.017169419676065445, -0.34585702419281006, -0.7225451469421387, 0.44712936878204346, -0.20517411828041077, 0.5268611311912537, -0.6183335781097412, -0.4386969804763794, -0.05770961567759514, -0.13536231219768524, 0.11665026843547821, -0.4754568338394165, 0.8201683759689331, -0.3858870565891266, -0.00696700531989336, -0.49237775802612305, 0.16218475997447968, -0.2326604723930359, 0.028575126081705093, -0.597489058971405, 0.7400858402252197, 0.10019303113222122, -0.38506701588630676, 0.06057516857981682, -0.5652585029602051, -0.6860093474388123, 0.13144883513450623, 0.032045915722846985, -0.15468724071979523, 0.2246716320514679, 0.23685766756534576, 0.26176849007606506, -0.8923212289810181, -0.0011707772500813007, -0.13569001853466034, -0.18563920259475708, -0.20044855773448944, -0.5493025779724121, 0.5276114344596863, 0.4950963854789734, -0.19718541204929352, -0.04776645451784134, -0.3797289729118347, -0.03541550785303116, 0.15408572554588318, -0.6779757142066956, -0.5300660133361816, -0.10338124632835388, 0.596000611782074, 0.441321462392807, 0.6053255796432495, -0.32649344205856323, 0.29090192914009094, -0.23345358669757843, 0.5216670632362366, 0.4139882028102875, -0.1637977808713913, 0.7432286143302917, -0.2958042621612549, 0.6784040927886963, -0.2229871302843094, 0.26455923914909363, -0.2077266424894333, -0.5681231021881104, -0.5357853770256042, -0.32092565298080444, -0.0049959821626544, 0.7368186712265015, -0.9236475229263306, -0.11884413659572601, -0.2561384439468384, -0.25015416741371155, -0.5275517702102661, 0.5035557746887207, 0.5191885828971863, 0.3837404251098633, 0.6318920850753784, -0.29568788409233093, -0.489013135433197, -0.8177946209907532, -0.3343978226184845, 0.023730700835585594, 0.17971089482307434, 0.29334765672683716, 0.21274347603321075, -0.2636503577232361, 0.28220880031585693, -0.37358903884887695, -0.5235564708709717, -0.5195819139480591, 0.11242756247520447, 0.2364785224199295, 0.46179401874542236, 0.6168764233589172, -0.954442024230957, -0.7141168713569641, 0.6179987788200378, -0.8381275534629822, 0.05112267658114433, -0.11595138907432556, -0.25635799765586853, 0.11329218745231628, 0.4974227249622345, -0.3478392958641052, 0.11734286695718765, 0.7660903930664062, 0.027017641812562943, 0.2532596290111542, -0.5773765444755554, 0.26985129714012146, -1.2704355716705322, 0.32335591316223145, -0.18449093401432037, -0.24318987131118774, -0.557746171951294, 0.3461414575576782, -0.02123344875872135, -0.4396909475326538, -0.4226357042789459, 0.5405922532081604, -0.5007320046424866, 0.0685967355966568, -0.4056145250797272, 0.08203651010990143, -0.02546336129307747, 0.3348696231842041, -0.1906839907169342, 0.88414067029953, 0.2724379897117615, -0.3716144859790802, 0.6102672815322876, 0.4271615445613861, -0.12602750957012177, 0.5691815614700317, -0.3246244788169861, -0.06531322002410889, -0.12778900563716888, 0.26786500215530396, -0.3532537817955017, -0.3777783215045929, 0.16729141771793365, -0.07597389817237854, 0.09467007964849472, -0.01885124295949936, -0.5910818576812744, -0.27668696641921997, -0.010089291259646416, 0.8474696278572083, 0.6264750361442566, -0.34223616123199463, 0.1671305149793625, 0.3551225960254669, -0.5207120776176453, -0.5471711158752441, -0.7493370771408081, 0.3952137231826782, -0.04823215678334236, -0.49955978989601135, 0.2370184361934662, -0.11203733086585999, -0.12165264040231705, 0.0881703644990921, 0.034940123558044434, -0.49583861231803894, -0.02945808507502079, -0.22916154563426971, 0.112779900431633, -0.2599293291568756, 0.18843123316764832, 0.18792696297168732, -0.013400164432823658, -0.34030306339263916, -0.5963653922080994, 0.3313130736351013, -0.22846683859825134, -0.13858379423618317, -0.35903802514076233, 1.0517849922180176, 0.9025272727012634, -0.45297104120254517, 0.7960660457611084, 0.5768609642982483, -0.4068901836872101, 0.1541118174791336, -0.5152794718742371, 0.028672434389591217, -0.4160565435886383, 0.40905436873435974, -0.48596706986427307, -0.912003219127655, 0.5197340250015259, -0.2911982834339142, -0.07802369445562363, 0.5296087861061096, 0.7208250164985657, 0.23997578024864197, 0.6766670346260071, 0.8513275980949402, -0.29515179991722107, 0.2666510045528412, -0.004081007558852434, 0.23827765882015228, -0.47537368535995483, -0.019085189327597618, -0.6976527571678162, -0.3210403025150299, -0.7368844747543335, -0.6489818692207336, 0.5542835593223572, 0.11368932574987411, 0.2398304045200348, 0.5532283186912537, -0.5031812191009521, 0.4854402542114258, 0.6571658849716187, -0.07031245529651642, 0.5610947608947754, 0.18767517805099487, -0.08324016630649567, -0.044775258749723434, -0.854887068271637, -0.5294596552848816, 0.8497046232223511, 0.02432030811905861, 0.5923728942871094, 0.25937944650650024, 0.8322713375091553, 0.3118903338909149, 0.39801040291786194, -0.5800741314888, 0.23376408219337463, -0.6066561937332153, -0.475188285112381, -0.4047490954399109, -0.46950283646583557, -0.7935421466827393, 0.32094255089759827, -0.19950808584690094, -0.21580541133880615, 0.22327928245067596, -0.011599806137382984, -0.3206843137741089, 0.36062735319137573, -0.7056273818016052, 0.9434794783592224, -0.15073460340499878, -0.3629428744316101, -0.7746302485466003, -0.5200289487838745, 0.172669917345047, -0.6191109418869019, 0.4963875114917755, -0.10956239700317383, -0.2561177611351013, 0.3501701056957245, -0.18403556942939758, 0.6302433013916016, 0.15733182430267334, -0.0036513577215373516, 0.20448754727840424, -0.07006119936704636, 0.5460430979728699, -0.015772540122270584, -0.11012008041143417, 0.29402363300323486, -0.07336294651031494, -0.7866158485412598, -0.36437857151031494, 0.725776731967926, -0.7972802519798279, -0.5839464068412781, -0.22980132699012756, -0.7383061051368713, 0.06645528972148895, 0.5135015249252319, 0.3052983283996582, 0.2805478274822235, -0.3536992073059082, 0.23421381413936615, 0.5050797462463379, -0.47092336416244507, 0.4140157401561737, 0.3480888307094574, 0.16729162633419037, -0.4206768870353699, 1.1759711503982544, 0.007888254709541798, 0.18610119819641113, 0.7071484327316284, 0.2551678717136383, -0.13323180377483368, -0.4713902175426483, -0.6814108490943909, 0.28363412618637085, -0.5248645544052124, -0.21337243914604187, -0.4920312166213989, 0.02318095788359642, -0.33644822239875793, -0.54356449842453, -0.3317316770553589, -0.37195631861686707, -0.27088814973831177, 0.33891239762306213, 0.1743466854095459, 0.753663957118988, -0.17849209904670715, 0.0909176617860794, -1.243073582649231, 0.5182296633720398, 0.17001575231552124, 0.07611497491598129, -0.14979736506938934, -0.3866803050041199, -0.6970819234848022, -0.08917777240276337, -0.3647769093513489, -0.6822763681411743, 0.5181223154067993, 0.3909226953983307, 0.4581214189529419, 0.17629104852676392, 0.3186814486980438, 0.5578129291534424, -0.8089577555656433, 0.3701934814453125, 0.5229519009590149, -0.9888020753860474, 0.4312986731529236, -0.550388753414154, 0.42389431595802307, 0.5450479984283447, 0.3778158128261566, -1.1173104047775269, -0.46375322341918945, -0.32507091760635376, -0.8077081441879272, 0.6097832918167114, 0.23894700407981873, 0.26923441886901855, 0.12057968974113464, 0.14233604073524475, 0.12591452896595, 0.39846792817115784, -0.32700610160827637, -0.0016572020249441266, -0.23643916845321655, -0.08454078435897827, -0.36973485350608826, -0.19248072803020477, -0.2815142571926117, -0.00388527219183743, 0.29981958866119385, -0.28224068880081177, -0.005464304704219103, 0.16095185279846191, -0.1471855491399765, -0.3242263197898865, 0.577581524848938, 0.6778560280799866, 0.48903802037239075, 0.06803169846534729, 0.08944444358348846, 0.2774651050567627, -0.494880348443985, 0.3810872733592987, 0.14543752372264862, -0.007950886152684689, -0.11230339854955673, 0.31581997871398926, 0.5873861908912659, 0.3879956901073456, -0.5468915700912476, 0.44701090455055237, 0.08444561064243317, 0.14939294755458832, -0.01289463322609663, -0.27944281697273254, 0.0002417822543065995, 0.38775280117988586, 0.4060044586658478, 0.6052048802375793, 0.16160212457180023, -0.527358889579773, 0.08517422527074814, 0.28455907106399536, 0.11682421714067459, -0.4778967797756195, 0.8249855637550354, 0.6881487369537354, -0.14040982723236084, 0.40532514452934265, -0.1703982651233673, -0.28928205370903015, 0.21117162704467773, 0.44200363755226135, 0.8937906622886658, -0.3511629104614258, 0.21993133425712585, 0.2804504930973053, 0.46206510066986084, -0.38540324568748474, 0.12508349120616913, -0.19616781175136566, -0.39261186122894287, -0.8122860789299011, -0.7107816338539124, -0.459280788898468, 0.07360456883907318, -0.670732855796814, 0.0729471892118454, -0.3419016897678375, -0.02455037087202072, -0.25720182061195374, -0.28172335028648376, -0.7181202173233032, -0.08715753257274628, 0.17227493226528168, 0.7995098829269409, -0.7452641725540161, 0.8427169919013977, 0.7234286069869995, -0.5393580794334412, -0.2317000925540924, 0.10145638138055801, -0.22888688743114471, -0.7231190204620361, 0.64622563123703, -0.12396571040153503, -0.10091803967952728, 0.01666085049510002, -0.12855181097984314, -1.0060597658157349, 0.6751840114593506, 0.8250863552093506, -0.5796099901199341, -0.31752505898475647, 0.27633991837501526, 0.6118356585502625, -0.04226004332304001, -0.2968798577785492, 0.18386808037757874, 0.5170750021934509, -0.2188090980052948, -1.294813632965088, 0.1819058656692505, -0.15435613691806793, 0.12928295135498047, 0.38055530190467834, -0.9746652841567993, 0.6857506036758423, -0.2848743796348572, -0.16314011812210083, 0.09933868050575256, 0.6294065713882446, -0.21934586763381958, 0.25896966457366943, 0.1108250692486763, 0.41792359948158264, 0.7763032913208008, 0.1497441828250885, 1.3200232982635498, -0.4230120778083801, 0.32880526781082153, 0.7881293296813965, -0.040273021906614304, 0.7805690169334412, 0.4998268187046051, -0.045482732355594635, 0.12043773382902145, 0.2282562255859375, 0.3090619146823883, 0.6367395520210266, -0.10883129388093948, -0.7681869268417358, -0.48056116700172424, -0.5995782017707825, -0.5101174712181091, 0.4383065700531006, 0.20401690900325775, -0.3852883279323578, -0.40550538897514343, 0.3165416717529297, 0.04678450897336006, 0.3143247365951538, -0.2622973322868347, 0.4166460335254669, 0.23621514439582825, -0.5911146998405457, 0.8569977283477783, 0.18612508475780487, 0.547247052192688, -0.4287860691547394, 0.08026745915412903, -0.13445860147476196, 0.23130859434604645, -0.08547723293304443, -0.33889853954315186, 0.6141350269317627, 0.16584986448287964, -0.6449292898178101, -0.5775189399719238, 0.5596157312393188, -0.5137807130813599, -0.46157369017601013, 0.3762997090816498, 0.7985758185386658, 0.1887218952178955, -0.1868673413991928, -0.5171806812286377, 0.021720904856920242, -0.06208987161517143, 0.15565991401672363, 0.5373217463493347, 0.5871350765228271, -0.18667368590831757, 0.442289263010025, 0.7638169527053833, 0.326941579580307, -0.042333316057920456, -0.15665149688720703, 0.8122063875198364, -0.5784478187561035, -0.5723434090614319, -0.698451042175293, -0.007877360098063946, 0.12115177512168884, -0.2563440501689911, 0.7864707112312317, 0.5422806739807129, 0.9050502777099609, -0.15705621242523193, 1.1452038288116455, 0.02364368736743927, 0.10726510733366013, -0.2391355037689209, 0.8376992344856262, -0.6659737229347229, -0.3003910183906555, -0.1620819866657257, -0.812069833278656, -0.16547326743602753, 0.36077001690864563, -0.10225841403007507, -0.4410991668701172, 0.8465681076049805, 0.38184425234794617, 0.07203778624534607, -0.19250160455703735, 0.5803217887878418, -0.0433974526822567, 0.22860056161880493, 0.8101996779441833, 0.4167844355106354, -0.36591827869415283, 1.1483136415481567, -0.1707233190536499, -0.5227027535438538, -0.2549646496772766, -0.6917447447776794, -0.5868099927902222, -0.5165417194366455, -0.056259069591760635, -0.2392231673002243, 0.09123191237449646, 0.8418883085250854, 0.6213616728782654, -0.8618391752243042, -0.44618940353393555, 0.04618782177567482, 0.13996170461177826, -0.4006325900554657, -0.1390998810529709, 0.021418394520878792, -0.440913587808609, -0.9861910939216614, 0.6269495487213135, 0.5703111886978149, -0.056226760149002075, -0.29930979013442993, -0.10304223746061325, -0.13792508840560913, 0.010494614951312542, 0.707261860370636, 0.5945190787315369, -0.5122799873352051, -0.013690955005586147, -0.033463556319475174, -0.37352684140205383, -0.03749287500977516, 1.1338858604431152, -0.4656659662723541, 0.3708897531032562, 0.5735803842544556, 1.0605826377868652, 0.3654375672340393, -0.359004408121109, 0.6016321778297424, -0.766981840133667, 0.4618256688117981, 0.18776604533195496, 0.263893187046051, 0.4775400459766388, -0.394073486328125, 0.3589489758014679, 0.5727114081382751, -0.6026396155357361, -0.6630980968475342, 0.43021470308303833, -0.645207941532135, -0.0615592822432518, 1.08511483669281, -0.12439092248678207, -0.16015750169754028, -0.24407468736171722, -0.24645937979221344, 0.48850250244140625, -0.634170651435852, 0.7024372220039368, 0.6757522225379944, 0.06937290728092194, 0.023380868136882782, -0.6366360187530518, 0.5455637574195862, 0.4013212025165558, -0.8294466733932495, 0.05954546108841896, 0.3841244578361511, -0.14241084456443787, 0.36955004930496216, 0.7359511256217957, -0.00495234876871109, 0.2853643298149109, -0.15148580074310303, -0.002787230769172311, 0.21151737868785858, -0.23891915380954742, -0.17476889491081238, 0.3671035170555115, -0.018014853820204735, -0.05666181072592735 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16578v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16578v3	Leveraging Professional Radiologists' Expertise to Enhance LLMs' Evaluation for Radiology Reports	2024-01-29T21:24:43	2024-02-17T03:07:00	Qingqing Zhu, Xiuying Chen, Qiao Jin, Benjamin Hou, Tejas Sudharshan Mathai, Pritam Mukherjee, Xin Gao, Ronald M Summers, Zhiyong Lu	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	In radiology, Artificial Intelligence (AI) has significantly advanced report generation, but automatic evaluation of these AI-produced reports remains challenging. Current metrics, such as Conventional Natural Language Generation (NLG) and Clinical Efficacy (CE), often fall short in capturing the semantic intricacies of clinical contexts or overemphasize clinical details, undermining report clarity. To overcome these issues, our proposed method synergizes the expertise of professional radiologists with Large Language Models (LLMs), like GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 1. Utilizing In-Context Instruction Learning (ICIL) and Chain of Thought (CoT) reasoning, our approach aligns LLM evaluations with radiologist standards, enabling detailed comparisons between human and AI generated reports. This is further enhanced by a Regression model that aggregates sentence evaluation scores. Experimental results show that our "Detailed GPT-4 (5-shot)" model achieves a 0.48 score, outperforming the METEOR metric by 0.19, while our "Regressed GPT-4" model shows even greater alignment with expert evaluations, exceeding the best existing metric by a 0.35 margin. Moreover, the robustness of our explanations has been validated through a thorough iterative strategy. We plan to publicly release annotations from radiology experts, setting a new standard for accuracy in future assessments. This underscores the potential of our approach in enhancing the quality assessment of AI-driven medical reports.	[ -0.23687462508678436, -0.3019026219844818, 1.000221610069275, -0.030650179833173752, -0.4119708836078644, 0.11893939226865768, -0.37506991624832153, -0.742923378944397, -0.07578353583812714, 0.2616238296031952, -0.1576506644487381, -0.6458001732826233, -0.9443992376327515, 0.3599843382835388, -0.13282863795757294, 1.0030715465545654, -0.06161763146519661, 0.43995437026023865, -0.5187707543373108, 0.04409622400999069, -0.6714531779289246, -0.042108193039894104, -0.4643281102180481, -0.5221885442733765, 0.3377296030521393, 0.2994846701622009, 1.077484369277954, 0.7277780771255493, 0.9992274641990662, 0.26270124316215515, 0.28606322407722473, 0.40137460827827454, -0.10468615591526031, -0.17534679174423218, -0.09535138309001923, 0.07451711595058441, -0.6682717800140381, 0.0657297670841217, 0.2661271393299103, 0.6230040192604065, -0.0031949570402503014, -0.017369922250509262, -0.17321935296058655, 0.4911821782588959, -0.541396975517273, 0.27745938301086426, -0.4355009198188782, -0.042407456785440445, 0.025689564645290375, -0.7306629419326782, -0.3402385413646698, -0.4687213599681854, 0.34270817041397095, -0.5670336484909058, -0.10558327287435532, -0.19189348816871643, 0.8471788167953491, 0.35262778401374817, -0.30805739760398865, -0.5639564394950867, -0.6871516108512878, 0.5122910141944885, -0.7347922325134277, 0.027316123247146606, 0.47426360845565796, 0.4861595332622528, 0.13020870089530945, -0.9113860726356506, -0.16766084730625153, -0.6314446926116943, -0.18340185284614563, 0.4715091288089752, -0.1539192497730255, 0.09152743965387344, 0.0412641279399395, 0.23056678473949432, -0.5793046355247498, 0.2460934966802597, -0.3019895851612091, -0.15790438652038574, 0.978537917137146, 0.29714298248291016, 0.3576749861240387, -0.12624916434288025, -0.49402764439582825, 0.030560584738850594, -0.5732459425926208, -0.5853042602539062, -0.16340337693691254, 0.11882390081882477, 0.1144636869430542, 0.4194943606853485, -0.1913677155971527, 0.5881449580192566, -0.04118180274963379, -0.329603374004364, 0.29542040824890137, -0.36232298612594604, -0.17079731822013855, 0.10988990217447281, 0.8197804689407349, 0.535121500492096, 0.09794948250055313, -0.39256906509399414, -0.2876206040382385, 0.060855038464069366, 0.48086991906166077, -0.6643668413162231, -0.24007128179073334, 0.12650205194950104, -0.48001620173454285, -0.48362088203430176, 0.14062991738319397, -0.4357928931713104, -0.4994930922985077, -0.34070929884910583, 0.8330559730529785, -0.7030178904533386, -0.10052160918712616, 0.24783745408058167, 0.10508769005537033, 0.062489937990903854, 0.4944971203804016, -0.5197261571884155, 0.2881733775138855, 0.5916654467582703, 0.6222508549690247, 0.14397470653057098, -0.18839877843856812, -0.5304784774780273, 0.13645073771476746, -0.2942322790622711, 1.0661388635635376, -0.5537344217300415, -0.31774917244911194, -0.21000798046588898, -0.6457396745681763, -0.06365109980106354, -0.5276073217391968, 0.2830165922641754, -0.41657754778862, 0.4832593500614166, 0.06293623894453049, -0.6269217133522034, -0.055300213396549225, 0.3299941122531891, -0.18813593685626984, 0.6715269088745117, 0.42904192209243774, -0.6002647280693054, 0.6018508672714233, -0.6909400224685669, -0.31967616081237793, 0.5547024011611938, -0.6183121204376221, -0.3562900125980377, 0.03273655101656914, 0.6724289655685425, 0.47125548124313354, -0.6588680148124695, 0.46106261014938354, 0.2702622711658478, -0.35361143946647644, 0.3320792019367218, -0.19822239875793457, 0.3192283809185028, 0.16478896141052246, -0.283368855714798, 0.30338767170906067, -0.3296123743057251, 0.08355225622653961, 0.023374252021312714, -0.2575116753578186, 0.050739895552396774, -0.1477307230234146, -0.34309348464012146, 0.10841978341341019, 0.06127902865409851, -0.3370721936225891, 0.07092651724815369, -0.31538623571395874, 0.07445849478244781, 0.5617685914039612, 0.20842012763023376, 0.17050935328006744, -0.7563426494598389, 0.6616884469985962, -0.24792972207069397, 0.23289185762405396, -0.12289036810398102, -0.4469739496707916, -0.4162614047527313, -0.47709155082702637, 0.3765563368797302, 0.33294206857681274, -0.66901034116745, 0.3364948332309723, -0.6679030656814575, -0.6250905990600586, -0.7624606490135193, 0.02035881206393242, 0.5903280973434448, 0.7431644201278687, 0.37834057211875916, -0.5128981471061707, -0.2569628953933716, -0.8825254440307617, -0.16008198261260986, -0.08726035058498383, -0.23414306342601776, 0.30203455686569214, 0.3247356116771698, -0.29895687103271484, 0.7803695797920227, -0.4830256402492523, -0.533177375793457, -0.3853743076324463, 0.4454286992549896, 0.10976210236549377, 0.055451489984989166, 0.3435293734073639, -0.4094596207141876, -0.46883898973464966, 0.08415064960718155, -1.0807888507843018, -0.19299674034118652, -0.26419246196746826, 0.1366562843322754, 0.22859609127044678, 0.3992842435836792, -0.4169519245624542, 0.41451284289360046, 0.14885665476322174, -0.3075597584247589, 0.44806650280952454, -0.5784317255020142, 0.3322504162788391, -0.6479803919792175, 0.07799188047647476, 0.0796055719256401, -0.36961933970451355, -0.3495848476886749, 0.04569580778479576, -0.03070027567446232, 0.05025792494416237, -0.2321564257144928, 0.31574547290802, -0.641250491142273, -0.2719455361366272, -0.3032420575618744, 0.36733606457710266, -0.11297586560249329, 0.0054818992502987385, 0.09013562649488449, 0.565867006778717, 0.5322272777557373, -0.3402494788169861, 0.17836296558380127, 0.19691112637519836, -0.4121108651161194, 0.2335788607597351, -0.4263857305049896, 0.44413378834724426, -0.07384715974330902, 0.25561025738716125, -0.6150294542312622, -0.3808882534503937, 0.0035870985593646765, -0.5576558113098145, 0.4727284908294678, -0.08474452793598175, -0.4711277484893799, -0.34646347165107727, -0.36511003971099854, 0.10601776093244553, 0.5414018034934998, -0.22246810793876648, 0.7202902436256409, 0.36887258291244507, -0.2532826066017151, -0.5317651033401489, -0.4163999855518341, 0.5197376012802124, -0.07868807762861252, -0.7109495401382446, 0.41093412041664124, -0.01877998188138008, -0.36153319478034973, 0.08316535502672195, 0.05411934852600098, 0.01827850565314293, 0.07105626910924911, 0.004340492654591799, 0.444284051656723, -0.3176051080226898, 0.14322897791862488, -0.28872278332710266, -0.2889026701450348, 0.2623535990715027, -0.0066851177252829075, 0.4317789375782013, -0.5320295691490173, -0.37841781973838806, -0.5586581230163574, 0.019625581800937653, 0.5027401447296143, -0.20245006680488586, 0.38472995162010193, 0.6773331761360168, -0.303982675075531, 0.2510490119457245, -0.6346297860145569, -0.33696624636650085, -0.356220543384552, 0.46929553151130676, -0.1941656768321991, -0.6000669002532959, 0.17732129991054535, -0.06340482085943222, -0.09454774856567383, 0.5375576019287109, 0.6637165546417236, -0.15037694573402405, 0.9994307160377502, 0.2963172495365143, 0.07324019819498062, -0.006840125657618046, -0.18461838364601135, 0.10863133519887924, -0.8694819211959839, -0.4390769302845001, -0.10948795080184937, 0.018804099410772324, -0.30660489201545715, -0.47173553705215454, 0.8044986128807068, -0.2637953758239746, 0.02300274930894375, -0.23487308621406555, -0.7551253437995911, 0.5328224301338196, 0.16896873712539673, 0.4879950284957886, 0.43246981501579285, -0.21332058310508728, 0.246844083070755, 0.056502267718315125, -0.7885486483573914, -0.6080582141876221, 1.3462469577789307, 0.5720129013061523, 0.5466371774673462, 0.06187024712562561, 0.6861142516136169, 0.42484188079833984, 0.70090651512146, -0.8251807689666748, 0.454373836517334, -0.25093233585357666, -0.1990460306406021, -0.2428406924009323, -0.2031134068965912, -0.7065528631210327, 0.1392289251089096, -0.4117641746997833, -0.4390071630477905, -0.47888994216918945, -0.011828680522739887, -0.6329370141029358, -0.13195373117923737, -0.49500393867492676, 0.5283300280570984, -0.5691846609115601, -0.25111123919487, -0.4873187839984894, -0.6883599758148193, 0.2146972268819809, -0.11303777247667313, 0.3472701609134674, -0.3071914315223694, -0.22863472998142242, 0.5319836139678955, -0.42504769563674927, 0.7494083642959595, -0.10990282893180847, 0.13315951824188232, 0.20167681574821472, 0.1505211740732193, 0.27809494733810425, 0.24251572787761688, -0.03641336038708687, 0.09684443473815918, -0.24735698103904724, -0.10473071783781052, -0.5780469179153442, 0.6509836912155151, -0.9647619128227234, -0.6681739091873169, -0.4187130331993103, -0.8532238602638245, -0.36852365732192993, 0.14200517535209656, 0.2988172471523285, 0.6273322105407715, -0.15405884385108948, -0.18281131982803345, 0.3060244619846344, -0.2695860266685486, 0.07350178807973862, 0.48403140902519226, -0.015312944538891315, -0.5085186958312988, 0.7649221420288086, -0.003974446561187506, 0.1527973711490631, 0.3226974308490753, 0.6154658198356628, -0.18044094741344452, -0.9658340215682983, -0.3964689373970032, 0.26964378356933594, -0.9425058364868164, -0.5526809096336365, -0.5052783489227295, -0.3555288016796112, -0.36285400390625, -0.3683007061481476, -0.17646868526935577, -0.15214139223098755, -0.09585245698690414, 0.10005280375480652, 0.4228211045265198, 0.960135281085968, -0.012630573473870754, 0.2834008038043976, -0.6658105850219727, -0.01606994867324829, 0.06764674186706543, 0.1653510332107544, -0.17886005342006683, -0.6912887692451477, -0.42945680022239685, -0.3171720802783966, -0.3126406967639923, -0.5673623085021973, 0.5529201030731201, 0.0682399794459343, 0.6683019995689392, 0.172421395778656, -0.09115266054868698, 0.6533255577087402, -0.1434582769870758, 0.49567508697509766, 0.22957725822925568, -0.9072082042694092, 0.673812747001648, -0.6024438738822937, 0.4960486590862274, 0.6247379183769226, 0.23177704215049744, -0.03434043377637863, -0.7260434031486511, -0.6931900978088379, -0.982467770576477, 0.5719017386436462, 0.08588049560785294, -0.0897308811545372, -0.16019514203071594, 0.3524470329284668, 0.14626526832580566, -0.1877889335155487, -0.4848278760910034, 0.3426956236362457, -0.0570712648332119, -0.38259968161582947, 0.09309282153844833, -0.16268830001354218, -0.3450218141078949, -0.2288483828306198, 0.5044712424278259, -0.3713752031326294, 0.451346218585968, 0.4835392236709595, -0.32936638593673706, -0.0926796942949295, 0.10292001068592072, 0.8030539155006409, 1.3621243238449097, -0.3253415524959564, 0.23633036017417908, 0.46372154355049133, -0.40745222568511963, -0.34090346097946167, -0.05693257227540016, 0.3109041154384613, -0.053321629762649536, 0.918031632900238, 0.4500422477722168, 0.18500196933746338, -0.5441867709159851, 0.7574933171272278, -0.1632487028837204, -0.3499809503555298, -0.5702354311943054, -0.04912794753909111, 0.07288077473640442, 0.12498140335083008, 0.49481400847435, 0.2282957285642624, 0.14419004321098328, -0.2273588925600052, 0.41765934228897095, 0.31018784642219543, -0.5234811902046204, -0.04787234961986542, 0.5078004598617554, 0.21056251227855682, -0.013264583423733711, 0.7695251107215881, 0.07829612493515015, -0.18881593644618988, 0.7664932012557983, 0.49978524446487427, 0.71715247631073, -0.07068794220685959, 0.13819719851016998, 0.4150802195072174, 0.21433120965957642, -0.10605268180370331, 0.037417929619550705, 0.2842685580253601, -0.5761176943778992, -0.5969432592391968, -0.09075840562582016, -0.47661206126213074, 0.07988573610782623, -0.7266662120819092, 0.5012477040290833, -0.7245533466339111, -0.17204713821411133, 0.07731132209300995, -0.0050526512786746025, -0.6578484773635864, 0.41074138879776, 0.46523767709732056, 0.8718782663345337, -0.5627477765083313, 0.7402763366699219, 0.6911088228225708, -0.6538832783699036, -0.8884239792823792, 0.15152034163475037, 0.024293549358844757, -1.0509684085845947, 0.6634469032287598, 0.36635667085647583, -0.23616424202919006, -0.1814097762107849, -0.26080191135406494, -0.7201767563819885, 1.5560532808303833, 0.3083411753177643, -0.29676496982574463, 0.2094458043575287, -0.08021555095911026, 0.8097146153450012, -0.8063241839408875, 0.9197388887405396, 0.5005724430084229, 0.38125866651535034, 0.09675268828868866, -1.0961027145385742, 0.2732268273830414, -0.05140618234872818, -0.16915874183177948, -0.023930566385388374, -0.4271116256713867, 0.26543688774108887, -0.5290608406066895, -0.09450724720954895, -0.21305455267429352, 0.7004753947257996, 0.19095122814178467, 0.43852919340133667, 0.4033619463443756, 0.2716823220252991, 0.8513769507408142, 0.16810214519500732, 1.4092252254486084, -0.38596805930137634, 0.131550595164299, 1.003204107284546, -0.24108998477458954, 0.5875105857849121, 0.24956804513931274, 0.06266000866889954, 0.5321303009986877, 0.43692848086357117, -0.2666292190551758, 0.5680030584335327, 0.026505939662456512, -0.26974138617515564, -0.41296443343162537, -0.27189531922340393, -0.21655982732772827, 0.6964606642723083, 0.2987613379955292, -0.5242224931716919, -0.17616339027881622, -0.04142334684729576, 0.20711976289749146, 0.16548427939414978, -0.2722129821777344, 0.985133171081543, 0.04269874468445778, -0.7776342034339905, 0.6648516058921814, -0.11958282440900803, 0.4490724503993988, -0.4701853394508362, 0.14100396633148193, -0.08491364121437073, 0.22278742492198944, -0.4141678512096405, -0.8543711304664612, 0.5852477550506592, 0.1208803728222847, 0.13234274089336395, -0.21174494922161102, 0.5545511245727539, -0.14603066444396973, -0.3869016766548157, 0.1642218828201294, 0.37014293670654297, 0.19184856116771698, 0.13221706449985504, -0.47614359855651855, -0.012440879829227924, -0.03208405151963234, -0.05253787711262703, 0.40307602286338806, 0.07165075838565826, -0.16633445024490356, 0.7022837400436401, 0.22780555486679077, 0.22177168726921082, -0.5524665117263794, 0.3530440330505371, 1.056067705154419, -0.36764001846313477, -0.10887710750102997, -0.8840234875679016, 0.5017797350883484, -0.08922867476940155, -0.4022520184516907, 0.31534260511398315, 0.538791835308075, 0.5291868448257446, 0.0932316705584526, 0.8204938173294067, 0.0993628054857254, 0.35263705253601074, -0.6684340834617615, 0.7328271865844727, -0.3266685903072357, 0.6621662974357605, -0.15987534821033478, -0.4032464325428009, -0.5880458354949951, 0.5027464032173157, -0.6851012706756592, 0.12661780416965485, 0.9055638909339905, 0.5742507576942444, 0.08172950148582458, -0.11292167752981186, 0.42361918091773987, 0.13957829773426056, 0.44320133328437805, 0.5976818799972534, 0.9274148344993591, -0.22037820518016815, 0.5891174077987671, -0.2477588653564453, -0.5333364009857178, -0.2075394093990326, -0.9516310095787048, -0.8457318544387817, -0.23794354498386383, -0.6857319474220276, -0.24656325578689575, 0.2222919464111328, 0.9246846437454224, 0.6516662240028381, -0.2446729838848114, -0.10737764090299606, 0.2211153656244278, -0.3643249273300171, -0.0014741297345608473, -0.16270054876804352, 0.7013717889785767, -0.4645611047744751, -0.21630319952964783, 0.50495845079422, 0.5156341195106506, -0.21407267451286316, -0.21326133608818054, -0.15390077233314514, 0.2509150505065918, -0.07462847232818604, 0.44718313217163086, -0.33294540643692017, -0.6758564710617065, -0.3607983887195587, -0.13367851078510284, -0.37621596455574036, 0.29323863983154297, 0.5755107998847961, -1.023620843887329, 0.45964735746383667, 0.2458687573671341, 0.5211442112922668, 0.34380945563316345, 0.08522496372461319, 0.7102208733558655, -0.5101076364517212, -0.1814940869808197, 0.7101927399635315, 0.22551612555980682, 0.5385092496871948, -0.7578207850456238, 0.4998501241207123, -0.0008369277929887176, -0.690552830696106, -0.5385777354240417, -0.13741621375083923, -0.8866997361183167, -0.40523862838745117, 1.0142488479614258, -0.1432567536830902, 0.09614161401987076, -0.11523996293544769, -0.0246584415435791, 0.25250107049942017, -0.2518261969089508, 1.0757452249526978, 0.2928754389286041, -0.7109915018081665, -0.2911972999572754, -0.5875243544578552, 0.5266293287277222, 0.38881716132164, -0.9045383334159851, -0.32297393679618835, 0.4162003695964813, 0.42524752020835876, 0.09081584215164185, 0.9393168687820435, -0.45376840233802795, 0.6514971256256104, -0.21230873465538025, 0.14977285265922546, -0.5317192673683167, -0.22534529864788055, -0.34815844893455505, -0.030671294778585434, 0.45100584626197815, 0.10588710755109787 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16577v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16577v1	LLMs as On-demand Customizable Service	2024-01-29T21:24:10	2024-01-29T21:24:10	Souvika Sarkar, Mohammad Fakhruddin Babar, Monowar Hasan, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable language understanding and generation capabilities. However, training, deploying, and accessing these models pose notable challenges, including resource-intensive demands, extended training durations, and scalability issues. To address these issues, we introduce a concept of hierarchical, distributed LLM architecture that aims at enhancing the accessibility and deployability of LLMs across heterogeneous computing platforms, including general-purpose computers (e.g., laptops) and IoT-style devices (e.g., embedded systems). By introducing a "layered" approach, the proposed architecture enables on-demand accessibility to LLMs as a customizable service. This approach also ensures optimal trade-offs between the available computational resources and the user's application needs. We envision that the concept of hierarchical LLM will empower extensive, crowd-sourced user bases to harness the capabilities of LLMs, thereby fostering advancements in AI technology in general.	[ -0.2411944568157196, -0.847395122051239, 0.5898522138595581, 0.5893645286560059, 0.23498722910881042, 0.6923314332962036, -0.11769565939903259, -0.4754193127155304, 0.22673822939395905, 0.45472511649131775, -0.3116527497768402, -0.5536156892776489, -0.49839770793914795, -0.08622099459171295, -0.27896612882614136, 0.5669878125190735, 0.04339310899376869, -0.18857789039611816, -0.49545222520828247, 0.06901402771472931, -0.17202191054821014, -0.4350843131542206, -0.6272121667861938, -0.40976792573928833, 0.5077285170555115, 0.462633341550827, 1.0881688594818115, 1.1381930112838745, 0.5016288757324219, 0.4275852143764496, -0.10166630893945694, 0.13278687000274658, -0.029095731675624847, 0.10051071643829346, -0.14602671563625336, -0.5738077163696289, -0.9416526556015015, -0.15215082466602325, 0.9822495579719543, 0.8846357464790344, -0.34199559688568115, -0.09103626012802124, 0.0169155802577734, 0.37929776310920715, -0.4720446765422821, 0.04768343269824982, -0.802655816078186, 0.06996326148509979, -0.14329907298088074, -0.25698909163475037, -0.15235535800457, -0.17077212035655975, 0.2918360233306885, -0.6545804142951965, -0.10628630965948105, 0.1281680315732956, 0.500272274017334, 0.24674808979034424, -0.0214613638818264, -0.13594938814640045, -0.7156316637992859, 0.7353175282478333, -0.3691078722476959, 0.33746686577796936, 0.4605485200881958, 0.42115679383277893, 0.023728474974632263, -0.7176584005355835, -0.1332113891839981, -0.3753777742385864, 0.07851503789424896, -0.08920349925756454, -0.09498994052410126, -0.05553194507956505, -0.12706880271434784, 0.48812660574913025, -0.4846700429916382, 0.645496129989624, 0.16982200741767883, 0.03676305711269379, 0.19459524750709534, 0.3997024893760681, 0.7820144891738892, 0.0401301309466362, -0.30786770582199097, 0.7704441547393799, -0.7708008885383606, -0.24852478504180908, 0.23392754793167114, 0.774228572845459, -0.546880304813385, 0.35267236828804016, -0.17074714601039886, 0.3645191490650177, 0.14131677150726318, -0.2570995092391968, 0.32695385813713074, -0.07643822580575943, -0.43234169483184814, 0.051737867295742035, 0.5592420697212219, -0.3492448329925537, -0.2329505980014801, -0.3405749201774597, -0.1780388504266739, -0.5357704758644104, 0.2720372676849365, -0.586782693862915, 0.11362642794847488, 0.40781456232070923, -0.362600177526474, -0.32173019647598267, -0.553238570690155, -0.4262988269329071, -0.5863997936248779, -0.2683878242969513, 0.14243099093437195, -0.18817763030529022, -0.25866514444351196, -0.05997230485081673, 0.1709551066160202, -0.03023936226963997, 0.38076475262641907, -1.2466545104980469, 0.47675666213035583, 0.7111445069313049, 1.1848012208938599, -0.38753652572631836, -0.2213306725025177, -0.31661608815193176, 0.5194478631019592, -0.12222094088792801, 0.6114128828048706, -0.7124864459037781, -0.4154505431652069, 0.23899558186531067, -0.17148172855377197, -0.10464818775653839, -0.7019991278648376, 0.04806741699576378, -0.5968501567840576, 0.10190184414386749, 0.21190795302391052, -0.3317572772502899, 0.297285795211792, 0.6604971885681152, -0.34375831484794617, 0.8370528817176819, 0.057366885244846344, -0.713482141494751, -0.07195591181516647, -0.6634641885757446, -0.582724928855896, 0.6126269698143005, -0.4325726330280304, -0.45065686106681824, -0.10097619146108627, 0.27750465273857117, 0.6569163799285889, -0.6045152544975281, 0.09454558044672012, -0.22062693536281586, -0.21830829977989197, -0.26485589146614075, -0.08779631555080414, 0.736870288848877, 0.3107997477054596, -0.46312394738197327, 0.24876824021339417, -0.9349427819252014, 0.044554293155670166, 0.11799590289592743, -1.016129970550537, -0.3342125415802002, 0.31806477904319763, 0.16477461159229279, -0.14279280602931976, 0.705685555934906, -0.45802950859069824, 0.37404558062553406, -0.34948086738586426, 0.5472150444984436, 0.7585278153419495, -0.4193805158138275, 0.7325195670127869, -0.1712794452905655, 0.5393330454826355, -0.03293539956212044, 0.23960840702056885, -0.037022266536951065, -0.2123100906610489, -0.5504047274589539, -0.8077858090400696, -0.236092671751976, 0.7314034104347229, -0.6903896331787109, 0.5727957487106323, -0.37092405557632446, -0.3912073075771332, -0.51729416847229, 0.2808578610420227, 0.2524855136871338, 0.1864403933286667, 0.1783134788274765, 0.08531305938959122, -0.4330059587955475, -1.0494935512542725, 0.17688824236392975, -0.10334604978561401, -0.13189856708049774, 0.49973157048225403, 0.12111970037221909, -0.9461521506309509, 0.8458797335624695, -0.09610632061958313, -0.2710167169570923, -0.45544692873954773, -0.21705088019371033, 0.02032691054046154, 0.4273008108139038, 0.24632957577705383, -0.6225679516792297, -0.4313480854034424, 0.6706873178482056, -0.845951497554779, -0.279458612203598, 0.034067049622535706, 0.1266312599182129, 0.060014866292476654, 0.5796014666557312, -0.3405356705188751, -0.2298736870288849, 0.6759030222892761, 0.1585962027311325, 0.3124193251132965, -0.49820101261138916, -0.06990449130535126, -1.29334557056427, -0.18733249604701996, -0.32677844166755676, -0.40138381719589233, -0.5054969787597656, 0.19041776657104492, -0.17713762819766998, -0.2567792236804962, -0.36023038625717163, 0.39232897758483887, -0.5325031280517578, -0.5344526767730713, -0.37772712111473083, 0.24996903538703918, -0.33132240176200867, 0.20616284012794495, -0.013838172890245914, 0.7599920034408569, 0.9279499053955078, -0.4453257918357849, 0.2621019780635834, 0.01773555763065815, -0.2694454789161682, 0.572550892829895, -0.6969593167304993, 0.027133172377943993, 0.07679694890975952, 0.1492917239665985, -0.7139459848403931, -0.3775680661201477, -0.10246396064758301, -0.01642816700041294, -0.0690433531999588, 0.09185291081666946, -0.530532956123352, 0.08373410254716873, -0.1748167872428894, 0.3145003914833069, 0.42412033677101135, -0.8161522746086121, 1.049454927444458, 0.6022297739982605, -0.2678842842578888, -0.47098708152770996, -0.7732598185539246, 0.2516416907310486, -0.12430420517921448, -0.5894839763641357, 0.4568575322628021, 0.0051553379744291306, -0.3457949757575989, -0.0011078984243795276, 0.35826677083969116, -0.1124303936958313, 0.37050607800483704, 0.6436504125595093, 0.06677783280611038, -0.45920881628990173, 0.023037565872073174, 0.10193775594234467, -0.00995668862015009, -0.2504788041114807, -0.47100985050201416, 0.6351078152656555, -0.2937103807926178, -0.4938911497592926, -0.4979819655418396, 0.454384982585907, 0.7768266201019287, -0.22862623631954193, 0.715559720993042, 0.5259139537811279, -0.43428272008895874, -0.4872920513153076, -0.4101892113685608, 0.43371787667274475, -0.5853205919265747, 0.5449061393737793, -0.33195871114730835, -1.3356198072433472, 0.6495684385299683, -0.2756107449531555, 0.29609233140945435, 0.0702935978770256, 1.1534408330917358, -0.2311369627714157, 1.0666933059692383, 0.8576240539550781, -0.5443650484085083, 0.768893301486969, -0.0071105039678514, 0.20070680975914001, -0.6942235827445984, -0.3431893289089203, -0.6086089015007019, -0.15824510157108307, -0.7432560324668884, -0.528536319732666, 0.2860995829105377, -0.15637722611427307, -0.6649109125137329, 0.027779866009950638, -0.33303412795066833, 0.5371206402778625, 0.4626351594924927, -0.00930758472532034, 0.3489745259284973, 0.2630728781223297, -0.26784494519233704, 0.334837943315506, -0.7901259064674377, -0.6305121183395386, 0.4345635771751404, 0.7544394731521606, 0.8191853761672974, 0.39241141080856323, 0.6444993615150452, 0.3513605296611786, 0.25989651679992676, -0.7196252942085266, 0.6211643218994141, -0.19573138654232025, -0.5379036664962769, -0.33207014203071594, -0.4495186507701874, -0.8122824430465698, 0.23236802220344543, 0.10956638306379318, -0.8659220337867737, 0.027654282748699188, 0.044496841728687286, -0.26567739248275757, 0.5384773015975952, -0.5035285353660583, 0.2980039119720459, -0.35357460379600525, -0.25171220302581787, -0.38020533323287964, -0.3683791160583496, 0.1504145860671997, 0.005340316332876682, 0.4071064293384552, -0.15047283470630646, -0.4109976291656494, 0.3265658915042877, -0.33356425166130066, 1.015260100364685, -0.01625136099755764, -0.14395855367183685, 0.04244089499115944, 0.04933011904358864, 0.4018530547618866, -0.0005097873508930206, -0.15925981104373932, 0.016017640009522438, -0.46029579639434814, -0.5986981391906738, -0.48854148387908936, 1.0904995203018188, -1.2449499368667603, -0.6501566767692566, -0.12210021167993546, -0.8467925190925598, -0.4609791934490204, 0.062056880444288254, -0.17055059969425201, 0.35706406831741333, -0.28688329458236694, 0.3058966100215912, 0.6162839531898499, -0.5945596694946289, 0.39125415682792664, 0.5313547849655151, -0.31182122230529785, -0.2216397374868393, 0.9469693899154663, -0.00438989233225584, 0.5500478744506836, 0.6819311380386353, 0.2755308151245117, -0.03276007995009422, -0.8263961672782898, -0.3303931951522827, -0.1263236701488495, -0.5497469902038574, 0.21772520244121552, -0.6408215165138245, -0.29837632179260254, -0.23870688676834106, -0.5765167474746704, -0.4752318263053894, -0.21125240623950958, -0.45404350757598877, -0.13627202808856964, 0.2134609967470169, 0.805681049823761, 0.03092965856194496, 0.6336230635643005, -0.5411605834960938, 0.28820812702178955, 0.34420496225357056, 0.5919642448425293, 0.11608367413282394, -0.5384655594825745, -0.6354954242706299, -0.36229372024536133, -0.08343792706727982, -0.021288171410560608, 0.14109773933887482, 0.09760197252035141, 0.5856837630271912, 0.27913886308670044, -0.5060279369354248, 0.5193391442298889, -0.7424318790435791, 0.8691363334655762, 0.17271026968955994, -0.7644267082214355, 0.38342511653900146, -0.7177609205245972, 0.40861931443214417, 0.22620394825935364, 0.569233775138855, -0.36281514167785645, -0.5675379037857056, -0.3112294375896454, -0.9403055906295776, 0.5491580963134766, -0.13309481739997864, 0.4929836392402649, 0.004653820302337408, 0.29278117418289185, -0.08343713730573654, 0.12989357113838196, -0.578326404094696, -0.2578568160533905, 0.05279312655329704, -0.1315458118915558, 0.12110301107168198, -0.004717601463198662, -0.03637821599841118, -0.13053660094738007, 0.5321446061134338, -0.023346170783042908, 0.2415902465581894, -0.22785629332065582, 0.013860839419066906, -0.0658990815281868, 0.411420077085495, 0.21865595877170563, 0.6246395111083984, -0.21847951412200928, 0.3980635106563568, -0.0028444849886000156, -0.5191397070884705, 0.13913245499134064, -0.05694667994976044, -0.35327771306037903, -0.3848629891872406, 0.4901388883590698, 0.8644387125968933, 0.34597495198249817, -0.6707638502120972, 0.026534292846918106, 0.2377488613128662, -0.06519165635108948, -0.05960695818066597, 0.16019821166992188, 0.48543092608451843, 0.5929214954376221, 0.28334900736808777, -0.16261355578899384, -0.25427040457725525, -0.794081449508667, 0.09938007593154907, 0.4354804456233978, -0.25077947974205017, -0.24141450226306915, 0.6815440654754639, 0.3870196044445038, -0.7098946571350098, 0.3909600079059601, 0.2964196801185608, -0.3274759352207184, 0.39209315180778503, 0.6732091903686523, 0.9414354562759399, -0.3407854735851288, 0.30613741278648376, -0.20846699178218842, 0.4099481701850891, 0.13637937605381012, 0.13500022888183594, 0.013457482680678368, -0.8255306482315063, 0.01490823831409216, -0.6557521224021912, -0.5455129742622375, 0.13004687428474426, -0.18017931282520294, -0.09600929170846939, -1.0610321760177612, 0.006354847922921181, -0.1746760755777359, -0.10369081795215607, -0.4415023922920227, 0.2321658581495285, 0.2495339959859848, 0.7740821838378906, -0.49457600712776184, 0.9710351228713989, 0.6344396471977234, -0.21614643931388855, -0.7177296876907349, -0.08677903562784195, -0.05553020164370537, -1.0796886682510376, 0.628785252571106, -0.40824979543685913, -0.28221115469932556, -0.011019566096365452, -0.25943827629089355, -0.7752366662025452, 1.1551365852355957, 0.4781871736049652, -0.4861905574798584, -0.03009621985256672, 0.5493188500404358, 0.6130136251449585, -0.7136561870574951, 0.19552864134311676, 0.37633663415908813, 0.24913068115711212, -0.04928562417626381, -0.9379780292510986, -0.16613495349884033, -0.08591842651367188, 0.28411176800727844, -0.24723517894744873, -0.5330624580383301, 0.8802680969238281, -0.07403833419084549, -0.04785463958978653, -0.056797586381435394, 0.49527162313461304, 0.22035229206085205, -0.04418650269508362, 0.3765268325805664, 0.28240323066711426, 0.8065156936645508, 0.28752797842025757, 1.259297251701355, -0.18199850618839264, -0.01443706639111042, 1.081052541732788, -0.3880060315132141, 1.0503129959106445, 0.40237709879875183, -0.15685881674289703, 0.35973426699638367, 0.6367855072021484, 0.3667604327201843, 0.6171547770500183, 0.30318278074264526, -0.5217558741569519, -0.2103629857301712, -0.47166192531585693, -0.19705866277217865, 0.12463055551052094, 0.3550613522529602, -0.36659857630729675, -0.355460524559021, 0.17480957508087158, -0.23027807474136353, 0.18606813251972198, -0.6319917440414429, 0.723300039768219, 0.13536851108074188, 0.07849953323602676, 0.5233707427978516, 0.2954220473766327, 0.7615260481834412, -0.5818122625350952, 0.3019598722457886, -0.18410617113113403, 0.14943324029445648, -0.5266252756118774, -0.5616735219955444, 0.21990083158016205, 0.21546611189842224, -0.3019874691963196, -0.5462347865104675, 0.6553225517272949, -0.29239213466644287, -0.42256852984428406, 0.5243328213691711, 0.9068188667297363, 0.041435159742832184, 0.2949802279472351, -0.7172518968582153, 0.25418519973754883, -0.34107062220573425, -0.33058181405067444, 0.6828943490982056, 0.3793622851371765, -0.17467382550239563, 1.0559885501861572, 0.44036343693733215, 0.13490575551986694, 0.34359800815582275, 0.36331626772880554, 0.894479513168335, -0.060278456658124924, -0.6177613139152527, -0.7683468461036682, 0.3661752939224243, 0.24025866389274597, -0.013907430693507195, 0.7111830115318298, 0.5611351728439331, 0.557039737701416, 0.1317477822303772, 1.0567556619644165, -0.14983078837394714, 0.3301711082458496, -0.16785965859889984, 0.7471121549606323, -0.7209914922714233, 0.6357733011245728, -0.12117772549390793, -0.6956473588943481, -0.4374064803123474, 0.3665279746055603, -0.36555910110473633, 0.03904195874929428, 0.2524876892566681, 0.7321491241455078, -0.37957191467285156, -0.24689817428588867, 0.47221148014068604, 0.20835398137569427, 0.47021251916885376, 0.2442665994167328, 0.7510592937469482, 0.13290534913539886, 0.05980512499809265, 0.1085178330540657, -0.32815369963645935, -0.2368992567062378, -0.712637722492218, -0.8994076251983643, -0.494737833738327, -0.31215131282806396, 0.09971881657838821, 0.14209526777267456, 1.157053828239441, 0.7777153253555298, -0.6152791976928711, -0.622251033782959, -0.01672356389462948, 0.3044782876968384, 0.03979593887925148, -0.07340235263109207, 0.31188738346099854, -0.44228842854499817, -0.7284438610076904, 0.632226288318634, 0.6469840407371521, -0.1098913699388504, -0.5798764228820801, -0.10680770874023438, -0.15424691140651703, 0.18594567477703094, 0.6719608902931213, 0.18996044993400574, -0.628726601600647, -0.38803544640541077, -0.0644422322511673, -0.5878153443336487, 0.20142190158367157, 0.7058142423629761, -0.47042399644851685, 0.05872196704149246, 0.43983352184295654, 1.3894520998001099, 0.1450708657503128, -0.12112540751695633, 0.4636002779006958, -0.8331067562103271, 0.23351585865020752, 0.19875067472457886, 0.22097966074943542, 0.337103933095932, -0.42410728335380554, 0.05019007623195648, 0.11970187723636627, -0.3485770523548126, -0.7274846434593201, 0.389453262090683, -1.0084408521652222, -0.22151167690753937, 0.9380337595939636, -0.2571229934692383, -0.20604516565799713, -0.37275230884552, 0.09718295186758041, -0.12006241083145142, -0.24130254983901978, 0.7462184429168701, 0.28202661871910095, -0.087424136698246, -0.31398528814315796, -0.47080641984939575, 0.21457619965076447, 0.25962933897972107, -1.3205609321594238, 0.2106436789035797, 0.15411196649074554, 0.2548210918903351, 0.22280195355415344, 0.7912561893463135, -0.027458555996418, -0.1040940061211586, -0.18339264392852783, 0.024105163291096687, -0.10006098449230194, -0.36624813079833984, -0.17249885201454163, 0.4065033197402954, 0.18457020819187164, -0.26262179017066956 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16575v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16575v1	Beyond Image-Text Matching: Verb Understanding in Multimodal Transformers Using Guided Masking	2024-01-29T21:22:23	2024-01-29T21:22:23	Ivana Beňová, Jana Košecká, Michal Gregor, Martin Tamajka, Marcel Veselý, Marián Šimko	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.CV	The dominant probing approaches rely on the zero-shot performance of image-text matching tasks to gain a finer-grained understanding of the representations learned by recent multimodal image-language transformer models. The evaluation is carried out on carefully curated datasets focusing on counting, relations, attributes, and others. This work introduces an alternative probing strategy called guided masking. The proposed approach ablates different modalities using masking and assesses the model's ability to predict the masked word with high accuracy. We focus on studying multimodal models that consider regions of interest (ROI) features obtained by object detectors as input tokens. We probe the understanding of verbs using guided masking on ViLBERT, LXMERT, UNITER, and VisualBERT and show that these models can predict the correct verb with high accuracy. This contrasts with previous conclusions drawn from image-text matching probing techniques that frequently fail in situations requiring verb understanding. The code for all experiments will be publicly available https://github.com/ivana-13/guided_masking.	[ -0.5988262891769409, -0.9468659162521362, 0.7058049440383911, 0.011300625279545784, -0.3163086473941803, -0.12372567504644394, -0.07185795158147812, -0.25683704018592834, -0.0012370168697088957, 0.69166100025177, -0.7103684544563293, -0.438477486371994, -0.8927670121192932, -0.12136770039796829, -0.4670940935611725, 0.5205334424972534, -0.07704080641269684, 0.37047576904296875, -0.2929588556289673, -0.2097274214029312, -0.9400206804275513, -0.28287413716316223, -0.3296271562576294, -0.23963484168052673, 0.4302936792373657, 0.1295126974582672, 0.6050542593002319, 0.6310142874717712, 0.6419589519500732, 0.30965277552604675, -0.05308149382472038, 0.20437365770339966, -0.32743561267852783, 0.19593766331672668, -0.12426760792732239, -0.5170122981071472, -0.19910548627376556, -0.08595293015241623, 0.4349990487098694, 0.38885006308555603, 0.2973378300666809, 0.10811521112918854, -0.3279520273208618, 0.4241209626197815, -0.7914741635322571, 0.3644980788230896, -0.6627559661865234, 0.18937698006629944, -0.23700015246868134, -0.09229342639446259, -0.7133457660675049, 0.409723162651062, -0.1474020630121231, -0.31561896204948425, 0.6910112500190735, 0.10495499521493912, 1.0112311840057373, 0.2973870038986206, -0.7917601466178894, -0.1817421019077301, -0.6524444222450256, 0.5020471215248108, -0.1203458309173584, 0.8545633554458618, 0.5541925430297852, 0.49354562163352966, -0.0415215902030468, -0.8645963668823242, -0.7847814559936523, -0.021543553099036217, -0.4945737421512604, 0.21291020512580872, -0.3351890742778778, 0.24943961203098297, 0.07938475906848907, 0.376761257648468, -0.6287673711776733, -0.22036497294902802, -0.31880173087120056, -0.29826289415359497, 0.1710210144519806, -0.03779502585530281, 0.3219812512397766, -0.48285236954689026, -0.6755045652389526, -0.402006059885025, -0.2575501799583435, 0.09826362878084183, -0.09224743396043777, 0.11510923504829407, 0.36644142866134644, 0.7170411348342896, 0.1226024180650711, 0.8643309473991394, 0.029120871797204018, -0.013696794398128986, -0.011967317201197147, -0.5277014374732971, -0.4906087815761566, -0.2337484508752823, 0.3764036297798157, 0.4173034727573395, 0.29985231161117554, -0.14038625359535217, -0.4919525980949402, 0.3694459795951843, 0.3759607970714569, -0.622534453868866, -0.25952714681625366, -0.05249157175421715, -0.39099618792533875, 0.03703039512038231, 0.30631542205810547, -0.8381145000457764, -0.38149207830429077, -0.43478235602378845, 0.9369860887527466, -0.36524978280067444, -0.27116891741752625, 0.5711787343025208, -0.2200755774974823, 0.6367597579956055, 0.19284524023532867, -0.6163262128829956, 0.29557278752326965, 0.7773662805557251, 0.8522116541862488, 0.10204407572746277, -0.23883549869060516, -0.8518456220626831, 0.05879516899585724, -0.3108081817626953, 0.8263099193572998, -0.5545641779899597, -0.34799689054489136, -0.024758268147706985, 0.22056113183498383, -0.39160194993019104, -0.3488435447216034, 0.4952160716056824, -0.7478244304656982, 0.32191529870033264, 0.13793514668941498, -0.40379202365875244, -0.7298367023468018, 0.3672649562358856, -0.7578526735305786, 0.8690809011459351, -0.22353501617908478, -0.07998471707105637, 0.3920615315437317, -0.7075694799423218, -0.28436169028282166, -0.09876609593629837, -0.18161159753799438, -0.25926363468170166, 0.3710460066795349, 0.6867927312850952, 0.7419579029083252, 0.0923634022474289, 0.38376566767692566, 0.13475550711154938, -0.33197057247161865, 0.3809722661972046, -0.37998417019844055, 0.3260631263256073, -0.02369852550327778, -0.28780776262283325, 0.44850605726242065, -0.46379730105400085, -0.27197906374931335, -0.010288347490131855, 0.29499638080596924, -0.21250778436660767, -0.08336330205202103, 0.17762567102909088, 0.15877434611320496, -0.2965301275253296, -0.5298560857772827, -0.07505763322114944, 0.08742175251245499, 0.025591127574443817, 0.8173007369041443, -0.15473836660385132, 0.4927869439125061, -0.21524949371814728, 0.736998438835144, 0.1058218777179718, 0.21928949654102325, -0.842496931552887, -0.5656836032867432, -0.8921379446983337, -0.6675927639007568, 0.21433399617671967, 0.39571449160575867, -0.809230387210846, 0.060716498643159866, -0.41823986172676086, -0.5385995507240295, -0.6015523076057434, -0.0959407389163971, 0.5223898887634277, 0.44801509380340576, 0.5512368083000183, -0.5021387934684753, -0.24935699999332428, -0.7900291085243225, -0.23650500178337097, 0.09206468611955643, -0.15254858136177063, 0.6071416735649109, 0.46135255694389343, -0.36093050241470337, 0.6999203562736511, -0.7809438705444336, -0.8099241852760315, -0.1331220418214798, 0.26203879714012146, 0.014418973587453365, 0.1286967694759369, 0.6087391972541809, -1.1176199913024902, -0.22877757251262665, -0.05698339268565178, -0.23070141673088074, 0.1855461597442627, -0.20729580521583557, -0.2764909565448761, -0.018226558342576027, 0.664656400680542, -0.554384171962738, 0.3414846956729889, 0.6861994862556458, -0.8116931915283203, 0.04425649717450142, 0.04580698534846306, 0.30480721592903137, -0.8272141218185425, -0.19361409544944763, 0.24966886639595032, -0.5956830382347107, -0.8696384429931641, 0.3116399347782135, 0.33469149470329285, -0.1429416984319687, -0.6016107201576233, 0.5357080101966858, -0.8075487613677979, -0.1008680984377861, -0.27847668528556824, 0.2729472219944, 0.3306431174278259, 0.5604062676429749, -0.0009336968068964779, 0.7288033366203308, 0.8702105283737183, -0.4691716134548187, 0.4015417993068695, 0.2528998553752899, -0.5061367750167847, 0.33947518467903137, -0.49967238306999207, 0.34495267271995544, -0.5950615406036377, 0.0606149360537529, -1.446907877922058, -0.15845926105976105, 0.24544529616832733, -0.540970504283905, 0.455221951007843, -0.4342948794364929, -0.344056636095047, 0.10191342234611511, -0.25991976261138916, 0.6154958605766296, 0.6266165971755981, -0.5862138271331787, 1.1187069416046143, 0.10488402098417282, 0.2835081219673157, -0.5245134830474854, -0.6155440211296082, 0.1950998455286026, -0.14015726745128632, -0.7719455361366272, 0.4274735748767853, 0.2910362482070923, -0.1429293155670166, -0.04742696136236191, -0.2296709418296814, -0.23713961243629456, 0.03297872468829155, 0.2146836817264557, 0.25186625123023987, -0.3510671555995941, 0.32560354471206665, -0.2424132227897644, -0.10797110199928284, 0.030932044610381126, 0.038982611149549484, 0.7194309234619141, -0.09495048224925995, -0.5800328850746155, -0.22033418715000153, 0.2619352638721466, 0.7373677492141724, -0.6504896283149719, 0.6200958490371704, 1.0026943683624268, -0.3981415331363678, 0.23389451205730438, -0.7268584370613098, -0.4062582552433014, -0.44912800192832947, 0.30601033568382263, -0.714085578918457, -0.7684645056724548, 0.5377306342124939, 0.22043518722057343, -0.34154802560806274, 0.30859243869781494, 0.24655495584011078, 0.07397512346506119, 0.9361895322799683, 0.8777899146080017, 0.4207296669483185, 0.5277661085128784, -0.05302397161722183, 0.37788084149360657, -0.6675705313682556, -0.5105480551719666, -0.3242899775505066, -0.41114261746406555, -0.5187955498695374, -0.7782173156738281, 0.34300103783607483, -0.22750641405582428, 0.49905169010162354, 0.3772640526294708, -0.3004750907421112, 0.6426276564598083, 0.4160437285900116, 0.2716712951660156, 0.3216750919818878, -0.0991293266415596, 0.3374301791191101, -0.048126220703125, -0.2085547298192978, -0.33546969294548035, 0.699693500995636, 0.28557273745536804, 0.7764924168586731, 0.3060248792171478, 0.08984358608722687, 0.02277578040957451, 0.04708629474043846, -1.3000596761703491, 0.6241943836212158, -0.12735337018966675, -0.6888231635093689, -0.05424030125141144, 0.06985257565975189, -0.931053102016449, 0.6849803924560547, -0.1793689876794815, -0.4948563873767853, 0.30725616216659546, 0.05882212147116661, 0.04786901921033859, 0.3607681393623352, -0.9073744416236877, 0.949797511100769, -0.13428302109241486, -0.13262946903705597, -0.1285422444343567, -0.6162092089653015, 0.43252429366111755, 0.0063423835672438145, 0.10548356920480728, -0.05864882841706276, -0.15944840013980865, 0.5082299709320068, 0.32341745495796204, 0.7942814230918884, -0.13898786902427673, -0.03565409034490585, -0.11723793298006058, 0.3349868357181549, 0.022728560492396355, -0.1010662168264389, 0.2062685340642929, 0.09113730490207672, 0.02189841866493225, -0.41831812262535095, -0.8807432651519775, 0.4078402817249298, -0.17930319905281067, -0.7202033400535583, -0.45117461681365967, -0.4163622558116913, 0.08785484731197357, 0.28595760464668274, 0.0028026902582496405, 0.7129517793655396, 0.03715164586901665, 0.15658089518547058, 0.8606763482093811, 0.04573207348585129, 0.36761417984962463, 0.40873005986213684, -0.5502128601074219, -0.1128828227519989, 0.6524607539176941, -0.2621527314186096, 0.19439572095870972, 0.6662227511405945, 0.017304357141256332, -0.47932788729667664, -0.309196412563324, -0.47662025690078735, 0.3007035255432129, -0.8324466943740845, -0.27431410551071167, -0.6587785482406616, 0.12266702950000763, -0.41030237078666687, 0.013665608130395412, -0.19486989080905914, -0.03955652192234993, -0.2840830087661743, -0.14090071618556976, 0.5242058634757996, 0.6669324636459351, 0.2802726626396179, 0.2603858411312103, -0.8344337344169617, 0.537070095539093, 0.3143768608570099, 0.39140260219573975, -0.3096100389957428, -0.5654140710830688, 0.09447494894266129, -0.053481750190258026, -0.21163082122802734, -1.0902106761932373, 0.3365243971347809, 0.354324072599411, 0.3259112536907196, 0.3330470025539398, -0.13965432345867157, 0.8617703318595886, -0.43131744861602783, 0.8670720458030701, -0.04346495494246483, -1.2740603685379028, 0.6006084680557251, -0.03243723511695862, 0.1683029979467392, 0.17703962326049805, 0.2573172450065613, -0.8154106736183167, -0.09747600555419922, -0.2157767415046692, -0.6449456810951233, 0.5706300735473633, 0.1268627792596817, 0.5131839513778687, 0.056717801839113235, 0.3613358438014984, 0.13900108635425568, -0.020917346701025963, -0.8025456666946411, -0.22980131208896637, -0.3251625597476959, -0.13451901078224182, -0.4458840787410736, -0.36391162872314453, -0.018979907035827637, -0.14883804321289062, 0.3655538260936737, -0.21606795489788055, 0.6003562211990356, 0.28165924549102783, -0.6066092848777771, 0.2612270712852478, 0.19112059473991394, 0.937832772731781, 0.5001522898674011, -0.10355392843484879, 0.617224931716919, -0.2433091551065445, -0.6619798541069031, 0.1490686982870102, 0.03352201730012894, 0.23920242488384247, 0.44323626160621643, 0.33477914333343506, 0.9316788911819458, -0.09991367161273956, -0.6448023319244385, 0.7949430346488953, -0.2971614599227905, -0.11212778836488724, -0.15615807473659515, -0.06340261548757553, -0.28911495208740234, 0.2014460563659668, 0.17558111250400543, 0.128494530916214, 0.15042442083358765, -0.5187920928001404, 0.18922832608222961, 0.5651171207427979, -0.7338164448738098, -0.3552301228046417, 0.38983801007270813, -0.16154471039772034, -0.3455556333065033, 0.5658065676689148, -0.10988181084394455, -0.5731441974639893, 0.6941066384315491, 0.4420422911643982, 0.914969265460968, -0.10944874584674835, 0.1314314305782318, 0.05340490862727165, 0.4179095923900604, 0.06862524151802063, 0.2336438149213791, -0.09810375422239304, -0.7787593007087708, -0.6402944326400757, -0.07778222113847733, -0.16406267881393433, 0.024498414248228073, -0.6850178241729736, 0.4982641637325287, 0.0031954545993357897, -0.03548431396484375, 0.10232316702604294, -0.6371744275093079, -0.6420852541923523, 0.13536329567432404, 0.017068063840270042, 0.7631130814552307, -0.9304782748222351, 0.5273711681365967, 0.9687089323997498, -0.28501278162002563, -0.43152573704719543, 0.21314512193202972, -0.14897236227989197, -1.0113794803619385, 0.664711058139801, 0.5236977338790894, -0.47756174206733704, 0.01303927693516016, -0.2758881449699402, -0.6932528018951416, 1.0197705030441284, 0.20946195721626282, 0.01599283143877983, 0.25712132453918457, -0.07286711782217026, 0.30605918169021606, 0.08038125187158585, 0.4702759385108948, 0.2760990262031555, 0.49748459458351135, 0.12038735300302505, -0.7952784895896912, -0.016718532890081406, -0.114458367228508, -0.06652123481035233, 0.6705590486526489, -0.35113611817359924, 0.7529438138008118, 0.08706303685903549, -0.4944973587989807, -0.13647012412548065, 0.6551477313041687, -0.4364595115184784, 0.4410918653011322, 0.5453650951385498, 0.287444531917572, 0.3561074137687683, -0.325734406709671, 0.8401747345924377, 0.056184493005275726, 0.3470471203327179, 0.6911770105361938, 0.004339786246418953, 0.5733470916748047, 0.7282742857933044, 0.1828559786081314, 0.32429203391075134, 0.4225458800792694, -0.12467648833990097, 0.5907601118087769, 0.1087542250752449, -0.3512580692768097, -0.3105427324771881, -0.29180672764778137, 0.0186307430267334, 0.9563606381416321, 0.254294216632843, -0.3521510660648346, -0.17060455679893494, 0.38726574182510376, -0.10122302919626236, 0.25177204608917236, -0.2327277660369873, 0.9373530745506287, -0.17634543776512146, -0.6374510526657104, 0.32921355962753296, 0.18621215224266052, 0.7129384875297546, -0.40880709886550903, -0.11913274973630905, -0.31341397762298584, 0.17203237116336823, 0.05876482278108597, -0.92519211769104, 0.27346181869506836, -0.14032968878746033, -0.14794044196605682, -0.5926114916801453, 0.8427626490592957, -0.3945135772228241, -0.42915111780166626, 0.2538798749446869, 0.6419803500175476, 0.11701148003339767, -0.19155114889144897, -0.11150021851062775, -0.03379393741488457, -0.14318270981311798, -0.10974901169538498, 0.06802800297737122, 0.3609220087528229, 0.07756507396697998, 0.5504003763198853, 0.4131130278110504, -0.4761809706687927, 0.2508156895637512, -0.0051941415295004845, 0.5981594920158386, -0.5908605456352234, -0.05599056929349899, -1.0399038791656494, 0.5122185349464417, 0.2842938303947449, -0.11941112577915192, 0.6155462861061096, 0.33841121196746826, 0.9818714261054993, -0.46824005246162415, 0.05109049379825592, 0.24513103067874908, -0.0009214361780323088, -0.9006097316741943, 0.43788573145866394, -0.642667829990387, -0.20316027104854584, -0.2458759844303131, -0.785587728023529, -0.699022650718689, 0.7025529146194458, -0.035437121987342834, -0.057587698101997375, 0.6677553057670593, 1.1878341436386108, -0.6088399291038513, -0.2069838047027588, 0.621152937412262, -0.08447331935167313, 0.6250320076942444, 0.23777736723423004, 0.7938379049301147, -0.669913113117218, 0.5245503187179565, -0.32606905698776245, -0.16210421919822693, 0.05557376518845558, -0.9296805262565613, -1.0590951442718506, -0.9480575323104858, -0.20560148358345032, -0.04308915138244629, -0.23894326388835907, 0.4654563069343567, 0.6708595156669617, -0.35908886790275574, -0.03484495356678963, -0.0575965978205204, 0.1351696103811264, -0.27316734194755554, -0.24963156878948212, 0.3999071419239044, -0.14959076046943665, -0.8762975931167603, 0.3598076403141022, 0.16336968541145325, 0.2512451112270355, -0.30417129397392273, 0.3741518557071686, -0.2816649377346039, 0.09890357404947281, 0.8075211644172668, -0.2757830321788788, -0.9447279572486877, -0.30349108576774597, 0.5962350964546204, 0.08149119466543198, 0.11641228944063187, 0.9688085913658142, -0.7775179147720337, 0.7592207193374634, 0.5249930024147034, 0.7767441868782043, 0.7741381525993347, -0.10282540321350098, 0.4321047365665436, -0.8569833636283875, 0.19181837141513824, 0.018927311524748802, 0.4328838288784027, 0.38113832473754883, -0.3434813916683197, 0.33946675062179565, 0.12233591824769974, -0.25125065445899963, -0.6716558933258057, 0.6607491970062256, -1.0493084192276, -0.3258441984653473, 1.0485115051269531, -0.0060789440758526325, -0.28595826029777527, -0.05116153880953789, -0.6182185411453247, 0.2938254773616791, -0.08168573677539825, 0.5918712019920349, 0.8133643865585327, -0.11758653074502945, -0.7012248635292053, -0.4392324388027191, 0.20358718931674957, 0.7554321885108948, -0.375985324382782, -0.16709314286708832, 0.5707714557647705, -0.12238001823425293, 0.24130888283252716, 0.21331757307052612, -0.025541704148054123, 0.203496053814888, -0.308813214302063, -0.08336015045642853, -0.15046019852161407, -0.4042634069919586, -0.5947649478912354, -0.06824052333831787, -0.1271810531616211, -0.8911558985710144 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16569v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16569v1	Autoencoder-Based Domain Learning for Semantic Communication with Conceptual Spaces	2024-01-29T21:08:33	2024-01-29T21:08:33	Dylan Wheeler, Balasubramaniam Natarajan	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.IV	Communication with the goal of accurately conveying meaning, rather than accurately transmitting symbols, has become an area of growing interest. This paradigm, termed semantic communication, typically leverages modern developments in artificial intelligence and machine learning to improve the efficiency and robustness of communication systems. However, a standard model for capturing and quantifying the details of "meaning" is lacking, with many leading approaches to semantic communication adopting a black-box framework with little understanding of what exactly the model is learning. One solution is to utilize the conceptual spaces framework, which models meaning explicitly in a geometric manner. Though prior work studying semantic communication with conceptual spaces has shown promising results, these previous attempts involve hand-crafting a conceptual space model, severely limiting the scalability and practicality of the approach. In this work, we develop a framework for learning a domain of a conceptual space model using only the raw data with high-level property labels. In experiments using the MNIST and CelebA datasets, we show that the domains learned using the framework maintain semantic similarity relations and possess interpretable dimensions.	[ -0.5636770725250244, -0.9251288175582886, 0.3857431411743164, 0.05171463266015053, -0.24098601937294006, -0.1406652182340622, -0.20435793697834015, -0.6031382083892822, 0.3316018581390381, 0.24756014347076416, -0.5480201244354248, -0.6990310549736023, -0.8640888333320618, -0.07867124676704407, -0.31665465235710144, 0.633272111415863, -0.12858998775482178, -0.4959798753261566, -0.3351946771144867, -0.30275994539260864, -0.4961619973182678, -0.5580073595046997, -0.2295144945383072, -0.20607517659664154, 0.37871086597442627, 0.17966878414154053, 0.8407996892929077, 0.8964177370071411, 0.3663167953491211, 0.2518652081489563, 0.042171966284513474, 0.23006093502044678, -0.36720845103263855, 0.060299236327409744, -0.13980360329151154, -0.0814347192645073, -0.39784544706344604, 0.12469875812530518, 0.5953283309936523, 1.2688459157943726, -0.26153257489204407, 0.09179645031690598, 0.08276067674160004, 0.5239626169204712, -0.7085885405540466, 0.6703898310661316, -0.785591185092926, 0.23493091762065887, 0.1581602692604065, -0.25167953968048096, -0.17222191393375397, 0.08832738548517227, 0.14774249494075775, -1.1477776765823364, 0.04674704000353813, 0.16881901025772095, 1.1412619352340698, 0.35582593083381653, -0.5345825552940369, -0.5585505366325378, -0.7124204635620117, 0.5250499844551086, -0.3290365934371948, 0.7036356925964355, 0.5597626566886902, 0.27826178073883057, -0.16644775867462158, -0.47919484972953796, -0.819791316986084, -0.12018090486526489, -0.09234356880187988, 0.030962752178311348, -0.2200920432806015, -0.20684301853179932, 0.11583717912435532, 0.139753520488739, -0.584427535533905, 0.04531972110271454, -0.37106606364250183, -0.0859934464097023, 0.5370820760726929, 0.18519842624664307, 0.05596452206373215, -0.3943939805030823, -0.6189695000648499, -0.33826127648353577, -0.3911815583705902, -0.43377378582954407, -0.13297590613365173, 0.2171306014060974, -0.07404708862304688, 0.46681976318359375, -0.19472697377204895, 0.6341894865036011, 0.12526196241378784, 0.5296242237091064, 0.1838112324476242, -0.08008210361003876, -0.3627525269985199, -0.24963605403900146, 0.6892248392105103, 0.21713732182979584, 0.32588499784469604, -0.4223419725894928, -0.007575214374810457, 0.33244532346725464, 0.5105263590812683, -0.6769893765449524, -0.4837071895599365, -0.03406529128551483, -0.4848429560661316, 0.02403826266527176, 0.0938524603843689, -0.34253522753715515, -0.10289411246776581, -0.5244556665420532, 0.4164024293422699, -0.43634217977523804, -0.4948210120201111, 0.3551512360572815, 0.12156397849321365, 0.38531023263931274, 0.2815902531147003, -0.9027891159057617, 0.5380048751831055, 0.3965035378932953, 0.6169212460517883, -0.2898368239402771, -0.3571191430091858, -0.08273600041866302, 0.33492904901504517, -0.49091437458992004, 0.7381681799888611, -0.4584044814109802, -0.6255726218223572, -0.2421780675649643, -0.1954277902841568, -0.21578466892242432, -0.5480623245239258, -0.05218769982457161, -0.8182955384254456, -0.04600417986512184, 0.04888637363910675, -0.8675912618637085, 0.03073667548596859, 0.05155995115637779, -0.6128278374671936, 0.7885744571685791, 0.2696150243282318, -0.3931913375854492, 0.5938643217086792, -0.7651097178459167, -0.46272796392440796, 0.27711910009384155, -0.3402828574180603, -0.41964641213417053, 0.18392521142959595, 0.007933530025184155, 0.735133945941925, 0.0371675118803978, 0.13449518382549286, -0.5471785068511963, 0.04635632410645485, 0.3426985740661621, -0.14875149726867676, 0.19622473418712616, 0.5113989114761353, -0.23473389446735382, -0.2580870985984802, -0.8659878373146057, 0.08452680706977844, 0.30261823534965515, 0.016349485144019127, -0.6595214009284973, -0.25375232100486755, -0.08704661577939987, 0.5515415072441101, 0.0338481143116951, -0.6002939343452454, -0.08797870576381683, -0.41507232189178467, 0.2004135698080063, 0.5621874928474426, -0.057160165160894394, 0.889914870262146, 0.030652301385998726, 0.1316896229982376, 0.3974002003669739, 0.021513458341360092, 0.20124664902687073, -0.27481940388679504, -0.7718522548675537, -0.18900182843208313, 0.10724801570177078, 0.22119824588298798, -0.7325659394264221, 0.9012810587882996, -0.4546477794647217, -0.2576577067375183, -0.3306601941585541, 0.1780577301979065, 0.18324273824691772, 0.4046567380428314, 0.4590216279029846, -0.5069579482078552, -0.1045055016875267, -0.7844976186752319, -0.09000476449728012, 0.0064895376563072205, 0.1513638198375702, 0.6099798679351807, 0.7097702622413635, -0.09192157536745071, 1.0018326044082642, -0.856334388256073, -0.6364781856536865, 0.17580938339233398, 0.07676788419485092, -0.164084792137146, 0.5110189914703369, 0.362419068813324, -0.9720393419265747, -0.40373241901397705, -0.0064257425256073475, -0.9428590536117554, 0.15152493119239807, -0.12492702901363373, -0.3751397728919983, -0.15750126540660858, 0.4929608702659607, -0.9123605489730835, 0.7178310751914978, 0.3331237733364105, -0.5678431391716003, 0.17834064364433289, -0.1918545514345169, -0.05510585755109787, -1.07014000415802, -0.13437874615192413, 0.10317949950695038, -0.12163973599672318, -0.48247647285461426, -0.21081504225730896, -0.012905100360512733, -0.23983614146709442, -0.344331294298172, 0.938051164150238, -0.47309818863868713, -0.15439605712890625, -0.553440272808075, 0.26186466217041016, 0.23059505224227905, 0.7097418904304504, 0.613232433795929, 0.4377814531326294, 0.29481130838394165, -0.875899076461792, 0.3799508512020111, 0.7465097308158875, -0.21360331773757935, 0.9827820062637329, -0.6478842496871948, 0.13915647566318512, -0.07830417901277542, 0.2778896987438202, -0.6691197156906128, -0.14822818338871002, 0.2893897593021393, -0.7479987740516663, 0.008618082851171494, -0.05877934396266937, -0.5958142876625061, -0.23042890429496765, 0.42780405282974243, 0.4622396230697632, 0.3455178737640381, -0.47601425647735596, 0.6355578899383545, 0.6660107374191284, 0.20577991008758545, -0.15630312263965607, -0.6518555283546448, 0.015720298513770103, -0.18398256599903107, -0.45929059386253357, 0.24329283833503723, 0.21723361313343048, 0.15862663090229034, 0.26238277554512024, -0.3177972435951233, -0.43296775221824646, 0.2473791092634201, 0.40900182723999023, 0.11179029196500778, -0.01753813959658146, 0.36196714639663696, 0.11001457273960114, -0.28450751304626465, 0.42126840353012085, -0.9645246267318726, 0.23520462214946747, -0.050200045108795166, -0.49462783336639404, -0.4324592053890228, 0.48624834418296814, 0.31057319045066833, -0.15541478991508484, 0.9897372722625732, 0.39581596851348877, -0.7455239295959473, -0.6546342372894287, -0.026043834164738655, -0.3026987612247467, -0.4925402104854584, 0.29764285683631897, -0.8308345675468445, -0.8941961526870728, 0.38747772574424744, -0.3255802094936371, -0.276325523853302, 0.504861056804657, 0.29462867975234985, -0.3061515688896179, 0.66629558801651, 0.8618084788322449, 0.2518349885940552, 0.2748548984527588, -0.4932580292224884, 0.3529755175113678, -0.7238515019416809, -0.4526980221271515, -0.33036360144615173, -0.07010001689195633, -0.18157240748405457, -0.5484040975570679, 0.2889849543571472, 0.01234399527311325, -0.23853768408298492, 0.7932679057121277, -0.4093925952911377, 0.275115430355072, 0.3233247399330139, -0.08557931333780289, 0.19673937559127808, 0.31171169877052307, -0.19601711630821228, -0.036383431404829025, -0.9233376383781433, -0.4326859414577484, 0.7650604248046875, 0.4082982838153839, 0.814021646976471, -0.02321450784802437, 0.461520791053772, 0.42935261130332947, 0.21106559038162231, -0.7410941123962402, 0.37678784132003784, 0.033853646367788315, -0.28340625762939453, -0.35207614302635193, -0.6479900479316711, -1.1199601888656616, 0.4066295325756073, -0.20270788669586182, -0.5559819936752319, 0.5649017095565796, 0.056765116751194, -0.0848703682422638, 0.2130107581615448, -0.3266843557357788, 0.9373695850372314, 0.12202541530132294, 0.04227077215909958, -0.27267733216285706, -0.5632007122039795, -0.10058066993951797, -0.19542087614536285, 0.1767861247062683, -0.2022310048341751, 0.13801899552345276, 0.5633705258369446, -0.35184231400489807, 0.9901767373085022, -0.2560977339744568, -0.5042927861213684, 0.04042709618806839, 0.31005677580833435, 0.32198166847229004, -0.004016892518848181, 0.3171817660331726, 0.2994186282157898, 0.0705733373761177, -0.5146839618682861, -0.9178827404975891, 0.5501055717468262, -0.9152016043663025, -0.0466986820101738, -0.15408484637737274, -0.5044342279434204, -0.47127509117126465, 0.008460704237222672, 0.11215142905712128, 0.5283930897712708, -0.4608381986618042, -0.029780644923448563, 0.8064650297164917, -0.19555026292800903, 0.07619006186723709, 0.40903645753860474, 0.1409417986869812, -0.21865858137607574, 0.8515534400939941, -0.17434318363666534, 0.3419594168663025, 0.3578864634037018, -0.353731244802475, -0.5169777274131775, -0.057027220726013184, -0.40341320633888245, 0.12911421060562134, -0.9894965291023254, -0.21212288737297058, -0.8432945609092712, -0.4007573127746582, -0.1795709729194641, -0.14319072663784027, -0.5221784710884094, -0.4943872392177582, -0.3296630382537842, -0.044034190475940704, 0.08220534026622772, 0.6836270093917847, -0.012329015880823135, 0.33154186606407166, -0.7821878790855408, 0.4410609304904938, 0.13548770546913147, 0.5452871918678284, 0.15933635830879211, -0.485111266374588, -0.5709999203681946, 0.2993728220462799, -0.14564839005470276, -0.3947746455669403, 0.451128751039505, 0.3999965190887451, 0.4427338242530823, -0.035489000380039215, 0.07555147260427475, 0.5768246054649353, -0.4624558985233307, 0.4260590970516205, 0.19354547560214996, -0.9928580522537231, 0.6807084679603577, -0.09006726741790771, 0.24582305550575256, 0.10170028358697891, 0.3626280426979065, -0.7078680992126465, -0.29949426651000977, -0.9715544581413269, -0.6508690714836121, 0.39622581005096436, 0.41462844610214233, 0.4826287627220154, -0.3590560257434845, 0.5256528258323669, 0.0844685286283493, 0.2052008956670761, -0.4557802975177765, -0.22911517322063446, -0.5478053689002991, -0.49970585107803345, 0.11849939823150635, 0.20653705298900604, -0.23185265064239502, -0.03350745514035225, 0.2879122793674469, -0.38820311427116394, 0.7085226774215698, 0.10085773468017578, -0.695452094078064, 0.07204989343881607, 0.12474972009658813, 0.23522621393203735, 0.6185482144355774, 0.2812436521053314, 0.2066604346036911, 0.2222490906715393, -0.3629593253135681, 0.23938779532909393, 0.2382863163948059, 0.2214721441268921, -0.06469424813985825, 0.2544587552547455, 1.1478215456008911, 0.011509210802614689, -0.11842267215251923, 0.7043663263320923, -0.004352210555225611, -0.5277289748191833, -0.2958439886569977, 0.013761037029325962, -0.0180314090102911, 0.2136833518743515, 0.19846758246421814, 0.03704266622662544, 0.11884178221225739, -0.16130194067955017, 0.5210938453674316, 0.3960956037044525, -0.5015645623207092, -0.34827908873558044, 0.7530414462089539, 0.20708562433719635, 0.17176368832588196, 0.6835676431655884, -0.09588222205638885, -0.2887573540210724, 0.6596555113792419, 0.42065393924713135, 0.7260199785232544, 0.07861506938934326, 0.2980687916278839, -0.06581684201955795, 0.05288388207554817, 0.3554381728172302, -0.012042997404932976, -0.6863020658493042, -1.108999490737915, -0.31787240505218506, -0.8036972284317017, -0.19794562458992004, -0.16823546588420868, -0.7944760918617249, -0.2147299349308014, -0.4052563011646271, -0.22338663041591644, 0.113675057888031, -0.011791304685175419, -0.8709133863449097, 0.49477043747901917, 0.35889533162117004, 1.0444910526275635, -0.8691336512565613, 0.9708225131034851, 0.707710325717926, -0.2367859184741974, -0.7358902096748352, -0.1631622314453125, -0.25281623005867004, -0.49555593729019165, 1.1826810836791992, -0.027684399858117104, -0.3948124647140503, 0.17287448048591614, -0.361418217420578, -0.9484696984291077, 0.9329189658164978, -0.05670192837715149, -0.3393460512161255, 0.08599498122930527, 0.5161535143852234, 0.6434134840965271, -0.6810564398765564, -0.20793865621089935, 0.09149682521820068, 0.15929974615573883, 0.23460836708545685, -0.8971611857414246, 0.021048834547400475, -0.3858937919139862, 0.49081772565841675, 0.11430756002664566, -0.4377787113189697, 0.16438402235507965, 0.11724117398262024, -0.47154054045677185, -0.014770349487662315, 1.2775849103927612, 0.024936778470873833, 0.055618517100811005, 0.48420682549476624, 0.5517746210098267, 0.7742056846618652, -0.12923048436641693, 0.8217316269874573, -0.28734442591667175, 0.5777413249015808, 0.8935956358909607, -0.352970689535141, 0.7353829145431519, 0.27989500761032104, 0.14415694773197174, 0.5523316860198975, 0.43260878324508667, 0.08230916410684586, 0.6334392428398132, 0.34436511993408203, -0.10687994211912155, -0.401365727186203, 0.08600614964962006, 0.025167139247059822, 0.5454556941986084, 0.952105700969696, -0.1568007469177246, -0.15953674912452698, 0.4160017967224121, -0.21240995824337006, 0.2374732792377472, 0.02912585437297821, 1.0109201669692993, 0.41282936930656433, -0.16641265153884888, 0.7217239141464233, -0.062014974653720856, 0.28146734833717346, -0.3780457377433777, -0.2019146829843521, -0.02864065393805504, 0.35585683584213257, 0.09588304162025452, -0.7791978120803833, 0.5287893414497375, -0.4907865822315216, -0.1747237592935562, -0.23127049207687378, 0.7108413577079773, -0.662889838218689, -0.024355923756957054, 0.43393245339393616, 0.5464234948158264, -0.0049185059033334255, 0.10213454812765121, -0.8913936614990234, 0.06742556393146515, -0.8231367468833923, -0.06612001359462738, 0.18748565018177032, 0.7493156790733337, -0.1569773554801941, 0.8727812170982361, 0.543273389339447, 0.13860800862312317, 0.02363215573132038, -0.07194773852825165, 0.9094658493995667, -0.6717731356620789, -0.5046119093894958, -0.47744184732437134, 0.17043738067150116, -0.2901931405067444, -0.2150062769651413, 0.5227773785591125, 0.315818727016449, 1.1356792449951172, -0.0676717609167099, 0.7818163633346558, -0.05131163075566292, 0.16282659769058228, -0.6170965433120728, 0.5761430263519287, -0.3249742090702057, 0.272299587726593, -0.025799836963415146, -0.9074299931526184, -0.4267655313014984, 1.0919032096862793, -0.23145851492881775, 0.13840512931346893, 0.738911509513855, 0.6143539547920227, -0.491290807723999, 0.07345843315124512, 0.46050456166267395, 0.12381576001644135, 0.09479597210884094, 0.7748634815216064, 1.0729248523712158, -0.46535488963127136, 0.22118648886680603, -0.14423403143882751, -0.3305283188819885, 0.07282588630914688, -0.5911370515823364, -0.9478514194488525, -0.9723765850067139, -0.3843138515949249, -0.511519193649292, 0.28809985518455505, 0.922095775604248, 1.1129095554351807, -0.5795762538909912, -0.19310972094535828, 0.030064741149544716, -0.21893033385276794, -0.12527672946453094, -0.18636876344680786, 0.6312264800071716, -0.3730108141899109, -0.43938615918159485, 0.04575473815202713, 0.3887476325035095, 0.16285422444343567, -0.20830152928829193, -0.07839321345090866, 0.13225077092647552, 0.17755693197250366, 0.6924228668212891, 0.30036601424217224, -0.5408446788787842, -0.33889293670654297, 0.007157227955758572, -0.45304420590400696, 0.12630154192447662, 0.7044510245323181, -0.8443882465362549, 0.04279367998242378, 0.054618168622255325, 0.8883423209190369, 0.5907934308052063, -0.10904621332883835, 0.7163994908332825, -0.8794347643852234, 0.000709658779669553, -0.08360351622104645, 0.10661708563566208, 0.484561949968338, -0.578767716884613, 0.19504234194755554, 0.37943360209465027, -0.2778223156929016, -0.05283240228891373, 0.411857932806015, -0.6979125738143921, -0.5169270038604736, 1.1865885257720947, -0.24189424514770508, -0.49073556065559387, -0.23000562191009521, 0.15429137647151947, 0.15189136564731598, -0.17076627910137177, 0.715021014213562, 0.6512852907180786, 0.10130881518125534, -0.07682876288890839, -0.34015366435050964, 0.7129793763160706, 0.26006755232810974, -0.9412557482719421, 0.1894957572221756, 0.6711562871932983, 0.37987834215164185, -0.02588578127324581, 0.5329154133796692, -0.19221197068691254, 0.3055805265903473, -0.1250760853290558, -0.10655166953802109, -0.0302751287817955, -0.5362470746040344, -0.20814819633960724, -0.007953347638249397, -0.1559756100177765, -0.352691113948822 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16561v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16561v1	Multi-class Regret Detection in Hindi Devanagari Script	2024-01-29T20:58:43	2024-01-29T20:58:43	Renuka Sharma, Sushama Nagpal, Sangeeta Sabharwal, Sabur Butt	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	The number of Hindi speakers on social media has increased dramatically in recent years. Regret is a common emotional experience in our everyday life. Many speakers on social media, share their regretful experiences and opinions regularly. It might cause a re-evaluation of one's choices and a desire to make a different option if given the chance. As a result, knowing the source of regret is critical for investigating its impact on behavior and decision-making. This study focuses on regret and how it is expressed, specifically in Hindi, on various social media platforms. In our study, we present a novel dataset from three different sources, where each sentence has been manually classified into one of three classes "Regret by action", "Regret by inaction", and "No regret". Next, we use this dataset to investigate the linguistic expressions of regret in Hindi text and also identify the textual domains that are most frequently associated with regret. Our findings indicate that individuals on social media platforms frequently express regret for both past inactions and actions, particularly within the domain of interpersonal relationships. We use a pre-trained BERT model to generate word embeddings for the Hindi dataset and also compare deep learning models with conventional machine learning models in order to demonstrate accuracy. Our results show that BERT embedding with CNN consistently surpassed other models. This described the effectiveness of BERT for conveying the context and meaning of words in the regret domain.	[ -0.21824923157691956, -0.871485710144043, 0.22861410677433014, 0.5335147976875305, -0.2684714198112488, 0.35473448038101196, -0.46622800827026367, -0.2681838274002075, 0.30989450216293335, -0.005164995323866606, -0.6720171570777893, -0.5880426168441772, -0.5972017049789429, 0.014652429148554802, -0.24082453548908234, 0.7116724252700806, -0.09620410203933716, 0.30929625034332275, -0.04717720299959183, -0.11298203468322754, -0.6830556392669678, -0.40166234970092773, -0.7623956203460693, -0.03265706077218056, 0.5847988128662109, 0.6055793762207031, 0.4006595015525818, -0.231766939163208, 0.576040506362915, 0.3181425929069519, 0.2596838176250458, 0.15355809032917023, -0.5585449934005737, 0.09363031387329102, 0.009032749570906162, -0.207117959856987, 0.001795208198018372, -0.19045791029930115, 0.4189836084842682, 0.22297847270965576, -0.16876904666423798, 0.07659591734409332, 0.024081643670797348, 0.865742564201355, -0.7293902039527893, 0.1968638002872467, -0.6246628165245056, 0.09305281937122345, -0.15586493909358978, -0.006261299829930067, -0.1930617392063141, -1.0824382305145264, 0.15853404998779297, -0.13012942671775818, 0.08674425631761551, -0.4517748951911926, 0.7351706027984619, 0.2383098155260086, -0.29840144515037537, -0.4830719530582428, -0.7851300239562988, 0.8722814321517944, -0.5875474810600281, 0.5826871991157532, 0.34808290004730225, 0.5095317363739014, 0.24187828600406647, -0.28130167722702026, -0.7760704755783081, -0.07898899912834167, -0.010701301507651806, -0.004103957209736109, 0.1928982436656952, -0.14212578535079956, -0.3915614187717438, 0.3864896297454834, -0.4540211856365204, -0.18635952472686768, -0.4757687449455261, -0.06569434702396393, 0.4582744836807251, -0.1713424026966095, 0.29470524191856384, -0.37851613759994507, -0.36864933371543884, -0.36237531900405884, -0.3504897356033325, -0.19733771681785583, 0.637651801109314, 0.3529964089393616, -0.04040602594614029, 0.6165148019790649, -0.20185017585754395, 0.661698043346405, -0.32255613803863525, 0.06861146539449692, 0.2656826078891754, -0.1492626965045929, -0.10188183188438416, 0.38133394718170166, 0.667213499546051, 0.5033242702484131, 0.6839160323143005, 0.19195210933685303, 0.2315027415752411, 0.4717577397823334, 0.3379659950733185, -0.349762886762619, -0.10017098486423492, -0.0013067576801404357, -0.34126016497612, -0.3232709765434265, -0.21412989497184753, -1.1426125764846802, -0.5783337950706482, 0.035202756524086, 0.3028516173362732, -0.774875819683075, -0.2723925709724426, 0.0584675632417202, 0.040795426815748215, 0.6945244073867798, 0.2706077992916107, -0.7017187476158142, 0.001310677151195705, 0.3424925208091736, 0.8391025066375732, 0.126694455742836, -0.3740241229534149, 0.028342097997665405, -0.03394513577222824, -0.5028500556945801, 0.9100834131240845, -0.554865300655365, -0.6416944265365601, 0.3505103588104248, -0.3510666787624359, -0.03451182693243027, -0.13662903010845184, 0.953772246837616, -0.4879525303840637, -0.19587379693984985, -0.2851283550262451, -0.41567739844322205, -0.5732042193412781, 0.4332163333892822, -0.3761095404624939, 0.6886366009712219, -0.15576250851154327, -0.5386973023414612, 0.6370755434036255, -0.5305160284042358, -0.723618745803833, 0.10111585259437561, -0.17648552358150482, -0.5537646412849426, -0.016644995659589767, 0.1461249738931656, 0.7508552670478821, -0.08711791038513184, 0.3412785232067108, -0.6280516386032104, -0.2601969242095947, 0.18054388463497162, -0.37689778208732605, 0.264302134513855, 0.2187284529209137, -0.11109795421361923, 0.053709711879491806, -0.5980386137962341, 0.08958182483911514, 0.20027026534080505, -0.3103446662425995, -0.4226457178592682, -0.006132757291197777, 0.11296610534191132, 0.23080797493457794, 0.1819194257259369, -0.8190323114395142, 0.08106595277786255, -0.07982783019542694, 0.27730944752693176, 0.9679280519485474, 0.12120917439460754, 0.08031358569860458, -0.07950357347726822, 0.16838841140270233, -0.1018977239727974, 0.33154621720314026, 0.25118011236190796, -0.4841037392616272, -0.6660364866256714, 0.3364150822162628, 0.10285152494907379, 0.20561999082565308, -0.5524239540100098, 0.20904870331287384, -0.23837673664093018, -0.7288139462471008, -0.5868311524391174, -0.010477268137037754, 0.3151410222053528, 0.23830631375312805, 0.3223249316215515, -0.039954617619514465, -0.6249391436576843, -1.0015666484832764, -0.5289203524589539, -0.2423134595155716, 0.6020932197570801, 0.4270578920841217, -0.03275042027235031, -0.40744075179100037, 0.7928150296211243, -0.9694427251815796, -0.780411958694458, -0.6268086433410645, 0.27144187688827515, -0.22776900231838226, 0.34856176376342773, 0.3167475759983063, -1.2439037561416626, -0.6924818158149719, -0.08629529178142548, -0.7621480226516724, 0.3585177958011627, -0.2566521167755127, -0.17226925492286682, 0.4647310674190521, 0.1736554652452469, -0.37001800537109375, 0.5104470252990723, 0.5521663427352905, -0.12492717057466507, 0.24524350464344025, 0.0037594095338135958, 0.3658253848552704, -1.0683717727661133, -0.26619860529899597, 0.20457640290260315, 0.3342224657535553, -0.5123823881149292, -0.416081964969635, 0.06160693243145943, 0.004420334007591009, -0.4912621080875397, 0.5582531094551086, -0.26045042276382446, 0.07462690025568008, -0.031195003539323807, -0.03460153937339783, -0.3839684724807739, 0.6579482555389404, 0.14039486646652222, 0.5548943281173706, 0.5541794896125793, -0.5331631898880005, 0.04145756736397743, 0.5550024509429932, -0.3501371741294861, 0.2591865360736847, -0.3163018226623535, 0.11207295209169388, -0.2812214493751526, -0.008584320545196533, -1.282371163368225, -0.4274826943874359, 0.3016347885131836, -0.7732449173927307, 0.3500317335128784, 0.011600042693316936, -0.392811119556427, -0.4655449390411377, -0.43258166313171387, 0.23219440877437592, 0.25965616106987, -0.3857308030128479, 0.6133143901824951, 0.46439963579177856, -0.03421024605631828, -0.6593523621559143, -1.05107581615448, 0.07453861832618713, -0.1405055820941925, -0.3219674229621887, 0.10572315007448196, -0.16652095317840576, -0.06854940205812454, -0.03312511369585991, 0.05140935629606247, -0.31989896297454834, -0.2650645077228546, 0.42741894721984863, 0.1993076205253601, 0.26863351464271545, 0.2996714413166046, 0.05933358520269394, 0.0758962333202362, -0.16123762726783752, 0.08158520609140396, 0.9343084692955017, -0.40704774856567383, -0.4085075855255127, -0.17489098012447357, 0.4218098223209381, 0.5100188851356506, -0.0060666268691420555, 0.7107170820236206, 0.9622023701667786, -0.5929652452468872, 0.19155697524547577, -0.8335432410240173, 0.10072287172079086, -0.44085171818733215, 0.29025569558143616, -0.17027972638607025, -0.6560181975364685, 0.3847784698009491, -0.061548978090286255, -0.3384830951690674, 0.5385034680366516, 0.5277761816978455, 0.2423626184463501, 0.6910298466682434, 0.7415592074394226, -0.17209120094776154, 0.37166592478752136, -0.3303019404411316, 0.6278542280197144, -0.5586283802986145, -0.39599379897117615, -0.13919207453727722, -0.3908791244029999, -0.7852287888526917, -0.16035522520542145, 0.20691826939582825, -0.21485799551010132, -0.12905490398406982, 0.25331392884254456, -0.6932255029678345, 0.40808358788490295, 0.41825446486473083, 0.3372765779495239, 0.033551525324583054, -0.1721089482307434, 0.2508111596107483, -0.2362981140613556, -0.26242494583129883, -0.3642895817756653, 0.7983986139297485, -0.04548589885234833, 0.8849313259124756, 0.4533974230289459, 0.9384220242500305, 0.536154568195343, 0.33703961968421936, -0.9013053178787231, 0.6822801828384399, -0.28724542260169983, -0.5876867771148682, -0.3471633791923523, -0.2453928291797638, -0.832429051399231, -0.2576581835746765, -0.07363428920507431, -0.557708740234375, 0.5026756525039673, -0.16201619803905487, -0.4984523057937622, 0.37738677859306335, -1.1492960453033447, 0.7999245524406433, -0.3904200792312622, -0.35781702399253845, -0.2508404552936554, -0.6338579058647156, 0.7668082118034363, -0.3479197919368744, 0.03744393214583397, -0.2869737446308136, 0.2340618371963501, 0.7220261096954346, -0.09118690341711044, 0.9570271968841553, -0.15622875094413757, 0.3200448155403137, 0.5302523970603943, 0.025143947452306747, 0.30149757862091064, 0.09206193685531616, -0.08780767023563385, 0.2533198595046997, -0.5551948547363281, -0.17350555956363678, -0.1818273365497589, 1.141229510307312, -0.740263044834137, -0.21085357666015625, -0.4445621371269226, 0.014853673055768013, -0.4124532639980316, 0.28616318106651306, 0.14244458079338074, 0.08451701700687408, -0.42348024249076843, -0.06060175225138664, 0.33405572175979614, -0.553684413433075, 0.7036880850791931, 0.18677230179309845, -0.23115941882133484, -0.26069432497024536, 1.0116223096847534, 0.23695343732833862, -0.10480720549821854, 0.18409660458564758, 0.24675460159778595, -0.7143988013267517, -0.20432226359844208, -0.2118445336818695, 0.1400790959596634, -0.9821377396583557, -0.32387208938598633, -0.936057984828949, -0.21034207940101624, -0.591865599155426, -0.38399964570999146, -0.4620110094547272, -0.15254445374011993, -0.15959952771663666, -0.17954912781715393, 0.7485596537590027, 0.9695058465003967, -0.16572250425815582, 0.2083711177110672, -0.884239137172699, 0.10299559682607651, 0.5823979377746582, 0.8124824166297913, 0.23095190525054932, -0.01179330050945282, -0.03832513466477394, -0.15919643640518188, -0.34356966614723206, -0.9118825197219849, 0.8156827092170715, 0.26476070284843445, 0.28802672028541565, 0.28242620825767517, 0.08300185948610306, 0.6303200721740723, -0.3082168996334076, 0.7981483936309814, 0.14583490788936615, -0.8275189995765686, 0.8234301209449768, -0.306714802980423, 0.10740151256322861, 0.7904797196388245, 0.7047216892242432, -0.6168698072433472, 0.005819529294967651, -0.4317775368690491, -1.000290870666504, 0.5583782196044922, 0.03288280591368675, 0.4153920114040375, -0.26224061846733093, 0.2778039574623108, 0.172852024435997, 0.22906115651130676, -0.726913332939148, -0.3655029833316803, -0.2607945501804352, 0.041663847863674164, -0.1140366867184639, -0.36209091544151306, 0.36575233936309814, -0.23842337727546692, 0.5426509976387024, 0.14639998972415924, 0.49185675382614136, 0.2826465368270874, -0.0766245573759079, -0.011279403232038021, 0.2314527928829193, 0.6791864037513733, 0.39631959795951843, -0.4556073248386383, -0.1724483221769333, 0.12791505455970764, -0.4168742597103119, 0.11892125755548477, -0.04242151603102684, 0.39433470368385315, 0.10169416666030884, -0.03436288610100746, 0.5631384253501892, 0.29805150628089905, -0.4849222004413605, 0.4035460352897644, -0.3601750135421753, 0.08230779320001602, -0.7328078150749207, -0.4073999226093292, 0.14874917268753052, 0.00843258760869503, 0.417134165763855, 0.5942233204841614, 0.29496124386787415, -0.6036841869354248, 0.2983178496360779, 0.09680820256471634, -0.6084086298942566, -0.1534641683101654, 0.445835143327713, 0.020971225574612617, -0.37793490290641785, 0.4832534193992615, -0.39764922857284546, -0.796040415763855, 0.14396928250789642, 0.1627025157213211, 1.2757521867752075, -0.45720237493515015, 0.585641086101532, 0.5092751383781433, -0.05745673552155495, -0.11213493347167969, 0.47006964683532715, 0.08865951746702194, -0.767101526260376, -0.525704562664032, -0.9433190822601318, -0.39370664954185486, 0.0781278908252716, -0.47096359729766846, 0.5006271004676819, -0.5068216919898987, -0.09952114522457123, -0.2137666940689087, -0.3138408362865448, -0.7376015186309814, 0.3584023416042328, 0.10805104672908783, 0.5584254860877991, -0.9047183394432068, 0.6642813086509705, 0.601654589176178, -0.573164165019989, -0.8465120196342468, 0.4989568591117859, 0.11369659751653671, -0.9633914232254028, 0.8607324361801147, 0.3450990617275238, -0.24008646607398987, 0.11783798038959503, -0.13490916788578033, -0.8380778431892395, 0.5194183588027954, -0.19264072179794312, -0.29010218381881714, 0.2328290045261383, 0.056502606719732285, 0.7424220442771912, 0.032492902129888535, 0.016298536211252213, 0.2434302121400833, 0.592748761177063, 0.21055731177330017, -0.391597718000412, -0.22205638885498047, -0.07406336814165115, -0.07293529808521271, 0.3665994703769684, -0.9857826232910156, 0.9479301571846008, -0.30396413803100586, -0.2959281802177429, -0.3970029354095459, 0.4597818851470947, -0.12435711920261383, 0.25107449293136597, 0.36445435881614685, 0.516978919506073, 0.2747766971588135, -0.24401825666427612, 1.0747959613800049, 0.0508817657828331, 0.3438555598258972, 0.7328693270683289, -0.3137573003768921, 0.9807198643684387, 0.1744222640991211, -0.20358052849769592, 0.5975857377052307, 0.8383655548095703, 0.10440116375684738, 0.8012707233428955, 0.28336507081985474, -0.2415500432252884, -0.23696056008338928, -0.31795284152030945, -0.26635605096817017, 0.7840698957443237, 0.4394295811653137, -0.1576061099767685, -0.48419588804244995, 0.26423659920692444, -0.2032758891582489, 0.15715163946151733, -0.1876857429742813, 0.9002500772476196, -0.11048338562250137, -0.5797154307365417, 0.5159371495246887, -0.3985007703304291, 0.8222584128379822, -0.6299170255661011, -0.07640335708856583, -0.16055570542812347, 0.4596748650074005, -0.10481785237789154, -1.0281221866607666, 0.7275555729866028, -0.022269202396273613, 0.08556186407804489, -0.05457580089569092, 1.0258605480194092, -0.5308738350868225, -0.5633025765419006, 0.5376812815666199, 0.5089197754859924, 0.16092371940612793, -0.2344285547733307, -0.7443299889564514, 0.2488841861486435, 0.13765853643417358, -0.10210134834051132, 0.25059306621551514, 0.429419606924057, 0.07765686511993408, 0.7632127404212952, 0.5209872126579285, -0.048163075000047684, 0.12003085017204285, 0.23368269205093384, 0.8011274933815002, -0.727496862411499, -0.2769688367843628, -0.9179380536079407, 0.2701188623905182, -0.21061019599437714, -0.3046957850456238, 0.788983941078186, 0.4515976011753082, 0.9845354557037354, -0.32108911871910095, 1.0004233121871948, -0.11320526897907257, 0.5689869523048401, -0.3000713884830475, 0.7523576617240906, -0.5978932976722717, 0.13470333814620972, -0.4356858730316162, -0.6686494946479797, -0.41782769560813904, 0.5094354152679443, -0.49150651693344116, 0.34191223978996277, 0.46789440512657166, 0.501739501953125, 0.3173210322856903, 0.14157678186893463, 0.3324190080165863, -0.06702730804681778, 0.13009785115718842, 0.45563414692878723, 0.8449690341949463, -0.4599449634552002, 0.737562894821167, -0.33156344294548035, 0.02674766629934311, -0.40248048305511475, -0.5996967554092407, -0.6471385359764099, -0.8351757526397705, -0.1843290477991104, -0.17000485956668854, -0.004431427922099829, 0.7987337708473206, 0.24318209290504456, -0.7941256165504456, -0.021300997585058212, -0.28563907742500305, 0.3455623686313629, 0.08357396721839905, -0.3053419888019562, 0.7024644613265991, -0.5434203743934631, -0.7990229725837708, 0.14293420314788818, 0.29594212770462036, 0.20659710466861725, -0.28759652376174927, 0.05382561683654785, -0.8394057750701904, 0.08066818863153458, 0.5361873507499695, 0.17168983817100525, -0.6358720064163208, -0.3180388808250427, 0.040754273533821106, -0.0003103262570220977, 0.08965148776769638, 0.70013427734375, -0.5253583192825317, 0.6208909153938293, 0.4026525616645813, 0.6550295948982239, 0.43452781438827515, -0.2183237373828888, 0.3378094434738159, -0.8828287720680237, -0.2944772243499756, 0.2589987814426422, 0.3491915166378021, 0.7448739409446716, -0.574570894241333, 0.5068706274032593, 0.13042739033699036, -0.5257394313812256, -0.6703605651855469, 0.021489625796675682, -0.8661820292472839, -0.37327954173088074, 1.193953275680542, 0.12302827090024948, -0.02709575928747654, -0.07771360874176025, -0.3871375620365143, 0.6233960390090942, -0.6063447594642639, 1.1227561235427856, 0.8982151746749878, -0.11448849737644196, -0.10616102814674377, -0.3130161166191101, 0.728063702583313, 0.4121191203594208, -0.5373465418815613, 0.25212129950523376, 0.21197615563869476, -0.23238074779510498, 0.5123922824859619, 0.6055962443351746, -0.00406657624989748, -0.06495431065559387, -0.13896635174751282, 0.3325292468070984, 0.32210811972618103, -0.1888144165277481, -0.3182480037212372, 0.13062839210033417, -0.18156205117702484, -0.5029551386833191 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16558v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16558v1	Diverse, but Divisive: LLMs Can Exaggerate Gender Differences in Opinion Related to Harms of Misinformation	2024-01-29T20:50:28	2024-01-29T20:50:28	Terrence Neumann, Sooyong Lee, Maria De-Arteaga, Sina Fazelpour, Matthew Lease	cs.CY	cs.CY, cs.CL	The pervasive spread of misinformation and disinformation poses a significant threat to society. Professional fact-checkers play a key role in addressing this threat, but the vast scale of the problem forces them to prioritize their limited resources. This prioritization may consider a range of factors, such as varying risks of harm posed to specific groups of people. In this work, we investigate potential implications of using a large language model (LLM) to facilitate such prioritization. Because fact-checking impacts a wide range of diverse segments of society, it is important that diverse views are represented in the claim prioritization process. This paper examines whether a LLM can reflect the views of various groups when assessing the harms of misinformation, focusing on gender as a primary variable. We pose two central questions: (1) To what extent do prompts with explicit gender references reflect gender differences in opinion in the United States on topics of social relevance? and (2) To what extent do gender-neutral prompts align with gendered viewpoints on those topics? To analyze these questions, we present the TopicMisinfo dataset, containing 160 fact-checked claims from diverse topics, supplemented by nearly 1600 human annotations with subjective perceptions and annotator demographics. Analyzing responses to gender-specific and neutral prompts, we find that GPT 3.5-Turbo reflects empirically observed gender differences in opinion but amplifies the extent of these differences. These findings illuminate AI's complex role in moderating online communication, with implications for fact-checkers, algorithm designers, and the use of crowd-workers as annotators. We also release the TopicMisinfo dataset to support continuing research in the community.	[ -0.42028841376304626, -0.7018810510635376, 0.4096580147743225, 0.319744348526001, -0.06220628321170807, 0.17099685966968536, 0.0348668172955513, -0.6549519300460815, -0.029333651065826416, 0.20014643669128418, -0.34738653898239136, -0.07083700597286224, -1.03131103515625, 0.26651322841644287, -0.3336445093154907, 1.0883822441101074, 0.20769111812114716, -0.04448579251766205, -0.08131930977106094, 0.03136230260133743, -0.6780465245246887, -0.7069498896598816, -0.3061041831970215, -0.09337273985147476, 0.8741428256034851, 0.4440042972564697, 0.7857593894004822, 0.33546289801597595, 0.5005439519882202, 0.36719584465026855, -0.3841269612312317, 0.06527405977249146, -0.5313859581947327, 0.0828671008348465, -0.351922869682312, -0.7004407048225403, -0.1785992830991745, 0.4634905457496643, 0.5010175704956055, 0.8700365424156189, -0.13369041681289673, 0.3291679322719574, 0.10834050178527832, 0.5765116810798645, -0.5584949254989624, -0.22639457881450653, -0.6705523133277893, -0.11048740148544312, -0.10866256058216095, -0.007736392319202423, -0.19171342253684998, -0.5190818905830383, 0.4649113714694977, -0.10429571568965912, 0.3492669463157654, 0.23310586810112, 0.8812441825866699, 0.29288017749786377, -0.7759482860565186, -0.3232533633708954, -0.775830090045929, 0.7296027541160583, -0.42090436816215515, 0.15941180288791656, 0.38057851791381836, 0.18350541591644287, 0.05424521490931511, -0.08748481422662735, -0.5033223628997803, -0.07149636000394821, -0.18465803563594818, -0.08034909516572952, -0.43083253502845764, -0.22655119001865387, 0.6035753488540649, 0.37257546186447144, -0.27819228172302246, 0.34163299202919006, -0.5563047528266907, -0.3221897482872009, 0.6475943326950073, 0.08469926565885544, 0.508811891078949, -0.1416175812482834, -0.26633983850479126, 0.1932302862405777, -0.9530788660049438, -0.0128578320145607, 0.784312903881073, 0.35152268409729004, -0.06389550119638443, 0.49255236983299255, -0.10730762779712677, 0.46232056617736816, 0.22346633672714233, -0.2304755002260208, 0.2607996165752411, -0.24987129867076874, -0.2083483636379242, 0.31542113423347473, 0.6930813193321228, 0.5665281414985657, -0.0175030380487442, 0.1599181890487671, 0.09383025765419006, -0.01970587857067585, 0.21328195929527283, -0.8062853217124939, 0.3576326072216034, 0.04609678313136101, -0.41387417912483215, -0.1302480399608612, 0.2956462502479553, -0.7947173714637756, -0.9565138816833496, -0.2592453062534332, 0.09644454717636108, 0.08875764906406403, -0.2985798120498657, 0.013757911510765553, -0.25207218527793884, -0.058477092534303665, 0.6860729455947876, -0.6498424410820007, 0.014671925455331802, 0.6837537288665771, 0.7049660682678223, 0.018526963889598846, -0.026937933638691902, -0.4035607576370239, 0.05099504813551903, -0.35947760939598083, 0.642918586730957, -0.553733229637146, -0.3510327935218811, -0.02830466628074646, 0.0015185498632490635, 0.13077007234096527, -0.501030683517456, 0.6052446365356445, -0.27884337306022644, 0.2994363307952881, -0.8608524203300476, -0.38835638761520386, -0.2920163571834564, 0.3368034362792969, -0.6146238446235657, 0.5847572088241577, -0.19933360815048218, -1.0955650806427002, 0.509432852268219, -0.37028270959854126, -0.4219649136066437, -0.04003814607858658, -0.4279645085334778, -0.22096240520477295, 0.026575962081551552, 0.011564484797418118, 0.3046247363090515, -0.6707887053489685, 0.5623927712440491, -0.23411405086517334, -0.15752676129341125, 0.4943677484989166, -0.5801272988319397, 0.5701888203620911, 0.06830090284347534, -0.5635802149772644, 0.11928746849298477, -0.16631637513637543, -0.5701107382774353, -0.09946180880069733, -0.4537009000778198, -0.39953336119651794, -0.008001156151294708, -0.2535451054573059, 0.3487067222595215, 0.04656248912215233, -0.5075189471244812, 0.026444770395755768, -0.07276000082492828, 0.2825784385204315, 0.8392534255981445, -0.07949036359786987, 0.31476348638534546, -0.5300907492637634, 0.3061836361885071, 0.17290472984313965, 0.3263380825519562, -0.005766930058598518, -0.684830367565155, -0.6218498349189758, -0.23317252099514008, 0.3928006589412689, 0.6891694664955139, -0.34341931343078613, 0.3722359240055084, -0.13391263782978058, -0.5064236521720886, -0.4341568648815155, -0.08223972469568253, 0.3106969892978668, 0.4626571834087372, 0.10761131346225739, 0.1258777678012848, -0.33629101514816284, -1.304701566696167, -0.42074820399284363, -0.34845030307769775, 0.13097698986530304, 0.2583487927913666, 0.3440372049808502, -0.20218467712402344, 0.8305346965789795, -0.5689019560813904, -0.1802162081003189, -0.25126180052757263, 0.49113428592681885, 0.2557033598423004, 0.24288734793663025, 0.4936584532260895, -0.9750347137451172, -0.3153895139694214, -0.31988582015037537, -0.5463249087333679, -0.3555099070072174, -0.07021284103393555, -0.14017803966999054, 0.0032997934613376856, 0.22306066751480103, -0.5551500916481018, 0.3400682508945465, 0.3948415219783783, -0.5051810145378113, 0.3368978500366211, 0.00048452048213221133, 0.38942229747772217, -0.8083163499832153, -0.06613028049468994, 0.22817784547805786, -0.10619961470365524, -0.6749758720397949, -0.1786491572856903, -0.1672036498785019, 0.22811219096183777, -0.42185065150260925, 0.26488593220710754, -0.3673771917819977, 0.028126277029514313, -0.37233099341392517, -0.1349351704120636, -0.23003773391246796, -0.11694927513599396, -0.18531955778598785, 0.6314687132835388, 0.4127396047115326, -0.6120645999908447, -0.03525172173976898, 0.1524219661951065, -0.23166854679584503, 0.4424121677875519, -0.5962889194488525, 0.07627897709608078, -0.44584545493125916, 0.27290743589401245, -0.9242814183235168, -0.13985562324523926, 0.39950278401374817, -0.3543601632118225, 0.24212610721588135, -0.16618360579013824, -0.5907108187675476, -0.38771986961364746, -0.33639228343963623, 0.18091192841529846, 0.17693060636520386, -0.2207130491733551, 0.5149099230766296, 0.7819868922233582, -0.46119773387908936, -0.7971372604370117, -0.6939655542373657, 0.2269652634859085, -0.28342175483703613, -0.4379882514476776, 0.020210115239024162, -0.22452503442764282, -0.712184727191925, -0.2269250601530075, -0.08907845616340637, 0.06500604003667831, 0.21562029421329498, 0.5507484078407288, 0.28713253140449524, 0.12899565696716309, 0.4359043836593628, -0.0008135810494422913, -0.010006073862314224, -0.0375080443918705, 0.3475548028945923, 0.5157976150512695, -0.15188492834568024, -0.45017099380493164, -0.11940113455057144, 0.6940315365791321, 0.452987939119339, -0.16846342384815216, 0.7729061245918274, 0.2563728988170624, -0.41478684544563293, 0.1463722437620163, -0.8614141345024109, -0.21383404731750488, -0.43453776836395264, 0.34630316495895386, 0.10673771798610687, -1.1859256029129028, 0.3418720066547394, 0.04215484485030174, 0.2805382013320923, 0.6230950355529785, 0.47883862257003784, -0.10249752551317215, 0.8980608582496643, 0.6083298921585083, -0.4107438921928406, 0.36536523699760437, 0.05589118227362633, 0.18287749588489532, -0.3728400766849518, -0.02370782382786274, -0.697668731212616, -0.4628916084766388, -0.6518462300300598, -0.3636367917060852, 0.166987344622612, -0.025008641183376312, -0.370296835899353, -0.2697596549987793, -0.3734331727027893, 0.3927573561668396, 0.37316444516181946, -0.050677090883255005, 0.3109574615955353, -0.0337003730237484, 0.29390469193458557, -0.1692744940519333, -0.5860409140586853, -0.7322254180908203, 0.8817405700683594, 0.6524375677108765, 0.6228424906730652, 0.4093135893344879, 0.14632733166217804, 0.5945374965667725, 0.760077178478241, -0.5049902200698853, 0.5088813900947571, -0.18703831732273102, -1.180302619934082, -0.25718021392822266, -0.49442633986473083, -0.7580510973930359, 0.33290210366249084, -0.3401883542537689, -0.6624587774276733, 0.3701561689376831, 0.03540440648794174, -0.27358701825141907, 0.41355663537979126, -0.41744792461395264, 0.31828439235687256, -0.270447313785553, -0.239024817943573, -0.26462674140930176, -0.6439335942268372, 0.5717487335205078, -0.23859326541423798, 0.36634793877601624, -0.4452383518218994, 0.04445153847336769, 0.6713948845863342, -0.3047696650028229, 1.239741563796997, -0.13672645390033722, -0.31193485856056213, 0.26043418049812317, -0.10968709737062454, 0.21267469227313995, 0.12523984909057617, -0.12042303383350372, 0.4582667946815491, -0.3943515121936798, 0.0334937758743763, -0.16315409541130066, 0.5323500037193298, -0.9807642102241516, -1.1268724203109741, -0.7372987270355225, -0.4868703782558441, -0.0061329808086156845, 0.0632176622748375, 0.16577748954296112, 0.3384428322315216, 0.00762460520491004, 0.15778326988220215, 0.7040690183639526, -0.4525417983531952, 0.29061296582221985, 0.7884557843208313, -0.1003306582570076, -0.070362389087677, 0.6765102744102478, 0.41540586948394775, 0.1743742972612381, 0.43454933166503906, 0.3708348870277405, -0.24559491872787476, -0.34602800011634827, -0.2361745983362198, 0.36588749289512634, -0.85081547498703, -0.20400293171405792, -0.8604230284690857, -0.06111026927828789, -0.0710814967751503, 0.218523308634758, -0.19760316610336304, -0.031559523195028305, -0.18565386533737183, -0.2934094965457916, 0.20344911515712738, 0.7460935711860657, 0.12182094156742096, 0.16627094149589539, -0.5736420750617981, 0.3385699391365051, 0.6757862567901611, 0.12243248522281647, -0.24730408191680908, -0.31681597232818604, 0.16631491482257843, 0.10394959151744843, -0.18425603210926056, -1.0833868980407715, -0.012443233281373978, -0.2077452391386032, 0.8736546635627747, 0.32202333211898804, 0.1388799250125885, 0.3668285012245178, -0.38369813561439514, 0.8089289665222168, 0.2483915537595749, -0.7432569265365601, 0.4455856680870056, -0.4177025556564331, -0.013741535134613514, 0.5892792344093323, 0.7077250480651855, -0.7198635339736938, -0.5309175848960876, -0.37682414054870605, -0.7519283890724182, 0.6281254291534424, 0.09091608226299286, 0.14307339489459991, -0.10951976478099823, 0.22003906965255737, 0.3487919569015503, 0.4746849238872528, -0.591153085231781, -0.5869699716567993, -0.071263886988163, 0.10247216373682022, 0.049350306391716, -0.6692638993263245, -0.4708155393600464, -0.09698871523141861, 0.37937453389167786, -0.06129869818687439, 0.32687002420425415, 0.17987065017223358, -0.0514705665409565, -0.1544414758682251, 0.6288976669311523, 0.7582720518112183, 0.7444531917572021, -0.0676531195640564, 0.359573632478714, 0.16463108360767365, -0.5461485981941223, 0.30751433968544006, 0.17639712989330292, -0.41792482137680054, 0.018681135028600693, 0.29987630248069763, 0.7464869618415833, -0.06223398074507713, -0.37664860486984253, 0.5092592835426331, -0.22139565646648407, -0.20288333296775818, 0.08849393576383591, -0.094632089138031, 0.12554846704006195, 0.275633305311203, 0.6351779699325562, 0.09639284759759903, 0.16919447481632233, -0.7663023471832275, -0.17487004399299622, 0.4294601380825043, -0.19744724035263062, -0.22031117975711823, 0.5255308747291565, 0.4499704837799072, 0.002480502473190427, 0.2858745753765106, -0.03259080648422241, -0.6109125018119812, 0.6905494928359985, 0.25890204310417175, 0.7748653292655945, -0.3180956244468689, 0.25144222378730774, 0.3244926929473877, 0.6303339004516602, -0.17770570516586304, 0.2026127725839615, 0.4709034860134125, -0.7110813856124878, -0.22241301834583282, -0.3434526324272156, -0.2819279730319977, 0.24133051931858063, -0.14329847693443298, 0.21150138974189758, -0.5647611021995544, -0.4989990293979645, 0.18507620692253113, -0.13982558250427246, -0.6166573762893677, 0.2685371935367584, 0.5340064167976379, 0.6036871075630188, -0.8506656289100647, 0.22396081686019897, 0.6065484881401062, -0.43051207065582275, -0.6401985287666321, 0.47649461030960083, 0.4143301844596863, -0.31818631291389465, 0.9362474679946899, 0.330689013004303, -0.21003231406211853, -0.5022634267807007, -0.5633919835090637, -0.9854205250740051, 0.9424969553947449, 0.6077799797058105, -0.9707284569740295, 0.3371875584125519, 0.36924225091934204, 0.33827248215675354, -0.28949809074401855, 0.48943519592285156, 0.1403566598892212, 0.6031282544136047, 0.018815530464053154, -1.161831021308899, 0.2606007754802704, -0.07982706278562546, -0.14502494037151337, 0.06671880185604095, -0.7968750596046448, 1.1150856018066406, -0.14423276484012604, -0.27865487337112427, -0.5448935031890869, 0.4477725028991699, 0.23411931097507477, 0.16328158974647522, 0.8879727721214294, -0.007401837967336178, 0.9650757908821106, -0.11817166209220886, 1.072135090827942, -0.07520835846662521, 0.031446605920791626, 0.940883457660675, -0.30438777804374695, 0.44876158237457275, 0.28707176446914673, -0.24564021825790405, 0.2379949390888214, 0.6756621599197388, 0.06837087124586105, 0.1845741719007492, 0.2368520051240921, -0.15649089217185974, -0.22426392138004303, -0.41415169835090637, -0.6363942623138428, 0.350102961063385, 0.41224634647369385, -0.49470633268356323, -0.1326598972082138, -0.2527327239513397, 0.27058401703834534, -0.12350328266620636, -0.36376944184303284, 0.477274090051651, 0.043767012655735016, -0.6592665910720825, 0.11304895579814911, 0.20245744287967682, 0.8933449983596802, -0.5192720293998718, 0.018753228709101677, -0.1621825248003006, -0.1442662626504898, -0.3161085247993469, -0.9415732026100159, 0.21931315958499908, 0.18615597486495972, -0.5940067768096924, -0.10847119987010956, 0.9738523960113525, -0.41157907247543335, -0.5823596715927124, 0.1530745029449463, 0.6758068799972534, -0.0791618824005127, -0.3449462950229645, -0.6714587211608887, 0.09627281874418259, 0.02553367055952549, -0.049533553421497345, 0.30249741673469543, 0.22029897570610046, -0.4418327808380127, 0.6993312239646912, 0.5918483138084412, -0.05603601038455963, -0.07950904220342636, 0.36791443824768066, 0.9606879949569702, -0.5006827712059021, -0.5446053743362427, -1.0275150537490845, 0.4444901645183563, -0.26563823223114014, -0.3412187695503235, 0.8499018549919128, 0.4432990550994873, 0.34983912110328674, 0.1269606202840805, 0.9672319889068604, -0.08291327208280563, 0.7448455095291138, -0.1596861034631729, 0.821578860282898, -0.32038503885269165, 0.40747764706611633, -0.4858061373233795, -0.8006765246391296, -0.19209545850753784, 0.24764586985111237, -0.6472545862197876, 0.17506043612957, 0.34203973412513733, 0.6324708461761475, 0.2628103792667389, 0.299856036901474, 0.031240781769156456, 0.319383829832077, 0.4548223614692688, 0.1756143420934677, 1.3137648105621338, -0.057141270488500595, 0.3932930827140808, 0.11827906966209412, -0.21473786234855652, -0.32269448041915894, -0.9647238850593567, -1.0380288362503052, -0.3202603757381439, -0.6468755602836609, -0.03867277503013611, -0.02449818141758442, 0.9329026937484741, 0.4762590825557709, -0.4724573493003845, 0.015177168883383274, 0.32567018270492554, 0.3737165629863739, 0.17351290583610535, -0.18866455554962158, 0.07208964228630066, 0.21840700507164001, -0.5229794383049011, -0.08448641747236252, 0.15539689362049103, -0.049485042691230774, -0.3518182039260864, 0.14664018154144287, -0.33070385456085205, 0.04117294028401375, 0.536327064037323, -0.02961345575749874, -0.7808802723884583, -0.3676280379295349, -0.1607539802789688, -0.26669642329216003, -0.025591067969799042, 0.8169955611228943, -0.37972772121429443, 0.18437792360782623, 0.47990092635154724, 0.4431999623775482, -0.018035320565104485, 0.07618963718414307, 0.5748047828674316, -0.6839731931686401, -0.05106896162033081, 0.08150369673967361, 0.3758727014064789, 0.5609570145606995, -0.7254653573036194, 0.2717558741569519, 0.2764356732368469, -0.4413299560546875, -0.6578317880630493, 0.198067769408226, -0.6712650656700134, -0.40587130188941956, 1.4628885984420776, 0.12091527134180069, 0.07017848640680313, -0.30926835536956787, -0.5623739957809448, 0.07901481539011002, -0.7223505973815918, 0.8376172184944153, 0.8832069635391235, 0.09929435700178146, -0.2589111626148224, -0.7740370035171509, 0.4720647633075714, 0.10890138894319534, -0.8873524069786072, 0.2062664031982422, 0.587307870388031, 0.4455465078353882, 0.33854514360427856, 0.5853522419929504, 0.04505275562405586, 0.039780668914318085, -0.28078731894493103, -0.15689337253570557, 0.08695897459983826, -0.17533382773399353, -0.21666036546230316, 0.2845720648765564, -0.07264501601457596, 0.033298999071121216 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16553v5	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16553v5	SelectLLM: Can LLMs Select Important Instructions to Annotate?	2024-01-29T20:44:10	2024-04-18T01:35:12	Ritik Sachin Parkar, Jaehyung Kim, Jong Inn Park, Dongyeop Kang	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Instruction tuning benefits from large and diverse datasets, however creating such datasets involves a high cost of human labeling. While synthetic datasets generated by large language models (LLMs) have partly solved this issue, they often contain low-quality data. One effective solution is selectively annotating unlabelled instructions, especially given the relative ease of acquiring unlabeled instructions or texts from various sources. However, how to select unlabelled instructions is not well-explored, especially in the context of LLMs. Further, traditional data selection methods, relying on input embedding space density, tend to underestimate instruction sample complexity, whereas those based on model prediction uncertainty often struggle with synthetic label quality. Therefore, we introduce SelectLLM, an alternative framework that leverages the capabilities of LLMs to more effectively select unlabeled instructions. SelectLLM consists of two key steps: Coreset-based clustering of unlabelled instructions for diversity and then prompting a LLM to identify the most beneficial instructions within each cluster. Our experiments demonstrate that SelectLLM matches or outperforms other state-of-the-art methods in instruction tuning benchmarks. It exhibits remarkable consistency across human and synthetic datasets, along with better cross-dataset generalization, as evidenced by a 10% performance improvement on the Cleaned Alpaca test set when trained on Dolly data. All code and data are publicly available (https://github.com/minnesotanlp/select-llm).	[ -0.37237870693206787, -0.6172865033149719, 0.374723881483078, 0.1170230284333229, -0.44455286860466003, 0.2478613704442978, -0.5636831521987915, -0.3789215683937073, -0.012269723229110241, 0.8484557271003723, -0.652115523815155, -0.7807067632675171, -0.5291852951049805, 0.009304331615567207, -0.40951696038246155, 0.8705902695655823, 0.06130966544151306, 0.16085685789585114, -0.3931140601634979, -0.1452731192111969, -0.37333351373672485, -0.19464291632175446, -0.5196669697761536, -0.43583932518959045, 0.2959534525871277, 0.6637510657310486, 0.6259986758232117, 1.1369119882583618, 0.48166295886039734, 0.20178884267807007, -0.2774271070957184, 0.7495700120925903, -0.4304221272468567, 0.08328930288553238, -0.015131146647036076, -0.5771713256835938, -0.2677935063838959, 0.1842438131570816, 0.656349241733551, 0.78814697265625, 0.052201952785253525, 0.29421573877334595, 0.07245044410228729, 0.8866623044013977, -0.555668294429779, 0.11861205101013184, -0.6933050751686096, 0.010396375320851803, -0.2322847992181778, -0.09227969497442245, -0.5502613186836243, -0.6027886867523193, -0.04544582590460777, -0.45088887214660645, 0.24067358672618866, 0.3031788766384125, 0.4650973975658417, 0.4236505627632141, -0.07847825437784195, -0.27078312635421753, -0.6891381740570068, 1.1141477823257446, -0.42298635840415955, 0.2042764127254486, 0.6578203439712524, 0.26765039563179016, -0.2657710313796997, -0.3595722019672394, 0.06699617207050323, -0.1840609610080719, -0.157610684633255, 0.08755756169557571, 0.07264898717403412, 0.12271630018949509, 0.27888065576553345, 0.44115644693374634, -0.2230575829744339, 0.576649010181427, -0.49242186546325684, -0.2151174396276474, 0.6764089465141296, -0.07103946059942245, 0.23105107247829437, 0.3227425515651703, -0.32335034012794495, -0.09323202818632126, -1.0117181539535522, -0.05255237594246864, 0.44517338275909424, 0.35808101296424866, -0.005119051318615675, 0.5854577422142029, -0.18420426547527313, 0.9577785134315491, -0.002268065232783556, -0.06825327128171921, 0.18311479687690735, -0.11190260946750641, -0.1549915373325348, 0.21264289319515228, 0.526161789894104, 0.2311411052942276, 0.07601423561573029, -0.37373173236846924, -0.22444157302379608, -0.20496688783168793, 0.2356160581111908, -0.6987938284873962, -0.3650486171245575, 0.13605952262878418, -0.4255847632884979, -0.04010971635580063, 0.17722868919372559, -0.9029204249382019, -0.4252169132232666, -0.498905748128891, -0.0007349083316512406, -0.11767889559268951, 0.22640953958034515, -0.3236537277698517, -0.024515893310308456, 0.2606237828731537, 0.27626192569732666, -1.1019731760025024, 0.14110925793647766, 0.6576477885246277, 0.49780747294425964, -0.6694130301475525, -0.029027149081230164, -0.5782225728034973, 0.1133451908826828, -0.4444602131843567, 0.7426254749298096, -1.0629366636276245, -0.6072308421134949, -0.1832638829946518, 0.025080012157559395, -0.08530513942241669, -0.9080906510353088, 0.4621867835521698, -0.48420029878616333, 0.033020440489053726, -0.314487487077713, -0.6932713389396667, -0.0649031549692154, -0.12074539065361023, -0.7690058946609497, 1.0844534635543823, 0.22381721436977386, -0.370016872882843, 0.2797676920890808, -0.4562252461910248, -0.5086345672607422, -0.15668760240077972, -0.3356007933616638, -0.5139303803443909, 0.17762906849384308, 0.4608039855957031, 0.3595213294029236, -0.390169620513916, -0.12257079035043716, -0.22267702221870422, -0.6268117427825928, 0.4082717299461365, -0.31670424342155457, 0.5838817358016968, 0.1230834349989891, -0.28223881125450134, 0.2406640350818634, -0.8287899494171143, 0.19603464007377625, -0.17411500215530396, -0.6374172568321228, -0.11585627496242523, 0.0014967789174988866, -0.42634546756744385, -0.20366783440113068, 0.11791151016950607, -0.41286733746528625, 0.2509227991104126, -0.2707197666168213, 0.21929074823856354, 0.7602997422218323, -0.21791957318782806, 0.7383147478103638, -0.32099607586860657, 0.5393872261047363, -0.1670888066291809, 0.24040718376636505, -0.07779503613710403, -0.5919468998908997, -0.901229739189148, -0.4067199230194092, 0.29000675678253174, 0.7063784599304199, -0.5121790766716003, 0.4821293354034424, 0.15967059135437012, -0.26961639523506165, -0.9971224069595337, 0.50760817527771, 0.6268472075462341, 0.33167123794555664, 0.6960355043411255, 0.07542771100997925, -0.6187653541564941, -0.9543858170509338, -0.06660198420286179, 0.15046148002147675, -0.10755060613155365, 0.24382655322551727, -0.04104047268629074, -0.24319955706596375, 0.7987744808197021, -0.5184166431427002, -0.1930873841047287, -0.22397920489311218, -0.0587792694568634, 0.20720979571342468, 0.49465200304985046, 0.2749011814594269, -0.5057723522186279, -0.36923748254776, 0.12478382885456085, -0.4920378625392914, -0.3775716722011566, -0.050067488104104996, -0.39199987053871155, 0.10153822600841522, 0.4514012038707733, -0.439809113740921, 0.29519209265708923, 0.39510577917099, 0.2828013598918915, 0.25790926814079285, -0.26836907863616943, 0.09911055862903595, -0.8263077735900879, -0.20150570571422577, -0.2967221736907959, -0.09297049045562744, -0.17506043612957, -0.05766526237130165, 0.1915932595729828, 0.1356254518032074, -0.44533637166023254, 0.462943971157074, -0.8484939336776733, -0.19645383954048157, -0.3492492139339447, -0.09432416409254074, -0.171407088637352, 0.3426888585090637, 0.08817360550165176, 0.8321882486343384, 0.489621639251709, -0.5473774671554565, 0.2992842197418213, 0.18338294327259064, -0.3047115206718445, 0.22015300393104553, -0.36623823642730713, 0.3865301012992859, -0.11296530067920685, -0.09990005195140839, -0.6764196753501892, -0.17543601989746094, 0.17597109079360962, -0.06903182715177536, 0.6251319646835327, -0.24627116322517395, -0.3326978087425232, -0.20767535269260406, -0.3005850911140442, -0.04890107735991478, 0.8535053133964539, -0.8586970567703247, 0.35896557569503784, 0.5484506487846375, 0.19462858140468597, -0.6534174680709839, -0.5222110152244568, -0.3507665991783142, -0.25777390599250793, 0.029693936929106712, 0.2452774941921234, -0.10950198024511337, -0.17525511980056763, -0.1610732227563858, -0.31883224844932556, -0.06540432572364807, 0.22423624992370605, 0.4742387533187866, 0.2660437226295471, 0.004726155195385218, 0.09958143532276154, 0.5028107762336731, -0.2698570191860199, 0.014795300550758839, -0.3417569398880005, 0.06832200288772583, 0.1660827398300171, -0.4570187032222748, -0.10299190878868103, 0.24297574162483215, 0.039406727999448776, -0.2753789722919464, 0.43225714564323425, 0.8421748876571655, -0.14926020801067352, -0.8763406276702881, -0.5113806128501892, -0.36872997879981995, -0.46759092807769775, 0.36346903443336487, 0.23407180607318878, -1.0600286722183228, 0.16815145313739777, -0.2039085179567337, 0.38634201884269714, -0.0899406373500824, 0.37572312355041504, -0.2536514401435852, 0.8163896799087524, 0.36212408542633057, -0.01910906285047531, 0.4216824769973755, -0.11810426414012909, -0.07560310512781143, -0.8668959736824036, -0.20881181955337524, -0.5370411276817322, -0.5653160810470581, -0.448820561170578, -0.7297505140304565, 0.2160736322402954, 0.1769052892923355, 0.11745841056108475, 0.1813487559556961, -0.8430156707763672, 1.0049930810928345, 0.8214828372001648, 0.23044273257255554, 0.16867366433143616, 0.32239028811454773, -0.1119365394115448, -0.007340975571423769, -0.5364229679107666, -0.7312911748886108, 1.136536955833435, 0.041310276836156845, 0.9489061236381531, -0.1378258913755417, 0.7657783031463623, 0.26938146352767944, 0.4340954124927521, -0.5145586729049683, 0.7278479933738708, -0.6094599366188049, -0.4661790430545807, -0.19092251360416412, -0.47310349345207214, -1.0739014148712158, 0.23534363508224487, -0.2889876663684845, -0.8401742577552795, -0.18483644723892212, 0.37844741344451904, -0.45377567410469055, 0.38829949498176575, -0.8234341144561768, 0.5677754878997803, -0.35771608352661133, -0.20864631235599518, 0.04307496175169945, -0.6378574967384338, 0.22015929222106934, -0.14501255750656128, 0.07470051199197769, -0.40800315141677856, -0.10410859435796738, 0.7303487658500671, -0.1580321043729782, 1.1073850393295288, 0.07700735330581665, 0.04044945538043976, 0.455952912569046, -0.05803360790014267, 0.26887843012809753, 0.07543610781431198, -0.07883373647928238, 0.11797980219125748, -0.22103005647659302, -0.24459220468997955, -0.584717869758606, 0.9488418698310852, -0.8640278577804565, -0.6898442506790161, 0.15938450396060944, -0.668631374835968, -0.2523523271083832, 0.03207434341311455, 0.24109163880348206, 0.29190146923065186, 0.020315170288085938, 0.2855513095855713, 1.0444692373275757, -0.259915828704834, 0.5407513380050659, 0.4350726008415222, -0.13140246272087097, -0.532059371471405, 1.0666489601135254, 0.22230015695095062, 0.24299664795398712, 0.7576208114624023, 0.21273651719093323, -0.35572031140327454, -0.7429153919219971, -0.5726170539855957, 0.030836820602416992, -0.8630955815315247, -0.20743973553180695, -0.5036759376525879, -0.16250735521316528, 0.06233536824584007, -0.13703064620494843, -0.34239843487739563, -0.5843718647956848, -0.7715402245521545, -0.44760435819625854, 0.4067831039428711, 0.5919780731201172, 0.16379636526107788, 0.37587693333625793, -0.8924031257629395, 0.1302170604467392, 0.41146886348724365, 0.21893024444580078, -0.18550261855125427, -0.3265823423862457, -0.23152513802051544, 0.21390093863010406, -0.1989230066537857, -0.8237643837928772, 0.07160347700119019, 0.23196683824062347, 0.9442493915557861, 0.2937557101249695, 0.2059325873851776, 0.43014073371887207, -0.24299690127372742, 0.4705275297164917, -0.14657482504844666, -0.5384441018104553, 0.7418533563613892, 0.05986917391419411, 0.3834324777126312, 0.551777184009552, 0.2836885154247284, 0.06688089668750763, -0.4448853135108948, -0.32925161719322205, -0.909329354763031, 0.8083409667015076, 0.05425124242901802, 0.014805124141275883, -0.1244683712720871, 0.4013022780418396, 0.4682537913322449, 0.22638137638568878, -0.3709254562854767, -0.3357318341732025, 0.2033773958683014, -0.3682287931442261, 0.12652279436588287, -0.27887672185897827, -0.3096165359020233, -0.12092402577400208, 0.6285240650177002, -0.10982614755630493, 0.05642502009868622, -0.15058279037475586, -0.20943479239940643, -0.17498522996902466, 0.3867191672325134, 0.4991868734359741, 0.7853251695632935, -0.14978480339050293, 0.21175001561641693, 0.31889858841896057, -0.4814507067203522, 0.08957729488611221, 0.11706472933292389, -0.5649304986000061, -0.08789161592721939, 0.5057705044746399, 0.9140468239784241, 0.35737043619155884, -0.686861515045166, 0.024911310523748398, 0.1202436238527298, 0.10520992428064346, -0.0932064950466156, 0.6807314157485962, 0.1449541449546814, 0.2103622704744339, 0.27794477343559265, -0.012816408649086952, -0.13457779586315155, -0.12697733938694, 0.2225370556116104, 0.388665109872818, -0.5319864153862, -0.21367418766021729, 0.6315145492553711, 0.4315800368785858, -0.2970200181007385, 0.7220494747161865, -0.2518673837184906, -0.0812455266714096, 0.7591793537139893, 0.35961857438087463, 0.6646776795387268, -0.13339459896087646, 0.3717302978038788, 0.18297086656093597, 0.4371977746486664, -0.23995263874530792, 0.23818793892860413, -0.00817440077662468, -0.5806572437286377, -0.35697925090789795, -0.7323110699653625, -0.4130058288574219, 0.08398602902889252, -0.693179190158844, 0.017622262239456177, -0.6812715530395508, -0.14725573360919952, -0.3306730389595032, -0.15330199897289276, -0.4415849447250366, 0.08202798664569855, 0.17791211605072021, 0.6014472246170044, -0.7039908766746521, 0.8131943345069885, 0.8785858750343323, -0.1080310195684433, -0.6580555438995361, -0.3993881046772003, 0.10740497708320618, -0.9589290618896484, 0.3442060351371765, 0.3099704384803772, 0.1392519325017929, -0.05594097822904587, -0.47718143463134766, -0.6796507239341736, 1.0874985456466675, 0.4774912893772125, -0.7410894632339478, 0.20506522059440613, 0.17532332241535187, 0.313643217086792, -0.5101972222328186, 0.4138029217720032, 0.8479911088943481, 0.33338192105293274, 0.36547374725341797, -0.5530858635902405, 0.012106060050427914, 0.10536830127239227, 0.05072006583213806, 0.2856719493865967, -0.6503687500953674, 0.572736918926239, -0.5050851702690125, -0.13655158877372742, -0.01637737639248371, 0.6844707131385803, 0.39051708579063416, 0.09562351554632187, 0.29608872532844543, 0.4711410105228424, 0.9757343530654907, -0.18574945628643036, 0.7910705804824829, -0.03807087987661362, 0.018456144258379936, 1.199623465538025, -0.2136521190404892, 0.6812848448753357, 0.4310750961303711, -0.2815004885196686, -0.0034598943311721087, 0.9502283334732056, -0.1329701840877533, 0.48479390144348145, 0.2353672832250595, -0.2038758397102356, -0.5227658152580261, -0.15464965999126434, -0.39700040221214294, 0.2917921543121338, 0.39190077781677246, -0.6358181834220886, -0.22202423214912415, -0.2501855790615082, 0.009567489847540855, 0.12737047672271729, -0.4144766628742218, 0.8129306435585022, 0.15372532606124878, -0.6270891427993774, 0.5819430351257324, -0.19759580492973328, 0.46875447034835815, -0.4904865026473999, -0.3873695433139801, -0.33042579889297485, 0.10981672257184982, -0.29293155670166016, -0.6934440732002258, 0.07604463398456573, -0.13269086182117462, -0.3159548342227936, -0.28034326434135437, 0.637667715549469, -0.7897250652313232, -0.6189364194869995, 0.2611235976219177, 0.386299192905426, 0.2038283348083496, 0.3078871965408325, -0.5971026420593262, 0.2592070400714874, 0.2747626304626465, -0.04497572034597397, 0.5126429200172424, 0.10890045762062073, -0.31613901257514954, 0.6842473149299622, 0.7278585433959961, 0.19945740699768066, 0.14815054833889008, 0.070583775639534, 0.9276089072227478, -0.43751418590545654, -0.16157986223697662, -0.8411556482315063, 0.37076565623283386, -0.2617951035499573, -0.23214413225650787, 0.6927061676979065, 0.4927644729614258, 1.0953582525253296, -0.1883542239665985, 0.7301831841468811, 0.3190873861312866, 0.5584600567817688, -0.9256706237792969, 0.5945796370506287, -0.09842293709516525, 0.672719419002533, 0.24783223867416382, -1.15604829788208, -0.20956699550151825, 0.5303894281387329, -0.3166882395744324, 0.15798404812812805, 0.5453342199325562, 1.023321270942688, -0.07687363773584366, 0.27129775285720825, 0.24442324042320251, -0.0788041278719902, 0.0584978312253952, 0.37100881338119507, 0.9255804419517517, 0.19057081639766693, 0.5517114400863647, -0.42720040678977966, -0.29480013251304626, -0.16414698958396912, -0.8558651804924011, -1.3410826921463013, -0.09653766453266144, -0.4689512252807617, 0.062244657427072525, 0.14798960089683533, 1.1716769933700562, 0.8875511884689331, -0.8703952431678772, -0.25770869851112366, 0.3650238513946533, 0.4949960708618164, -0.5330984592437744, -0.10629959404468536, 0.38435959815979004, -0.4384111166000366, -0.6596761345863342, 0.6693583726882935, 0.25581058859825134, 0.17218735814094543, -0.033016759902238846, -0.005466241389513016, 0.1572171151638031, -0.17740103602409363, 0.4134348928928375, 0.22647930681705475, -0.792112410068512, -0.093897245824337, -0.09711368381977081, 0.07462974637746811, 0.05752817541360855, 0.8287606239318848, -0.36755430698394775, 0.5727478265762329, 0.36896783113479614, 0.9726349711418152, 0.36355751752853394, 0.1503952294588089, 0.39467281103134155, -1.1353009939193726, 0.06958377361297607, 0.24385517835617065, 0.24932044744491577, 0.41532376408576965, -0.4593069851398468, 0.5333003401756287, -0.05540326237678528, -0.5490497946739197, -0.6016537547111511, 0.09407602995634079, -0.8351539969444275, -0.34723690152168274, 1.3767116069793701, -0.2900943458080292, -0.5291454792022705, 0.025691518560051918, -0.36460041999816895, 0.05157008394598961, -0.4872499108314514, 0.752585232257843, 0.47210583090782166, -0.1794169843196869, -0.45576485991477966, -0.5189326405525208, 0.6582404375076294, 0.2833901345729828, -0.8938691020011902, 0.09554648399353027, 0.6338423490524292, 0.10943803936243057, -0.11626611649990082, 0.3065710961818695, -0.033018339425325394, 0.17556172609329224, -0.42341697216033936, -0.06414846330881119, -0.4677979052066803, -0.3817870616912842, -0.00820919405668974, 0.13487647473812103, 0.1701340675354004, -0.49635812640190125 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16541v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16541v1	GuReT: Distinguishing Guilt and Regret related Text	2024-01-29T20:20:44	2024-01-29T20:20:44	Sabur Butt, Fazlourrahman Balouchzahi, Abdul Gafar Manuel Meque, Maaz Amjad, Hector G. Ceballos Cancino, Grigori Sidorov, Alexander Gelbukh	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	The intricate relationship between human decision-making and emotions, particularly guilt and regret, has significant implications on behavior and well-being. Yet, these emotions subtle distinctions and interplay are often overlooked in computational models. This paper introduces a dataset tailored to dissect the relationship between guilt and regret and their unique textual markers, filling a notable gap in affective computing research. Our approach treats guilt and regret recognition as a binary classification task and employs three machine learning and six transformer-based deep learning techniques to benchmark the newly created dataset. The study further implements innovative reasoning methods like chain-of-thought and tree-of-thought to assess the models interpretive logic. The results indicate a clear performance edge for transformer-based models, achieving a 90.4% macro F1 score compared to the 85.3% scored by the best machine learning classifier, demonstrating their superior capability in distinguishing complex emotional states.	[ -0.47485536336898804, -0.5067229270935059, 0.6602581143379211, 0.2205105572938919, -0.02555408701300621, 0.05118853598833084, -0.17651937901973724, -0.5574700832366943, -0.09578780829906464, 0.04943118616938591, -0.7838032841682434, -0.30168744921684265, -0.7077646851539612, 0.031147893518209457, -0.040149278938770294, 1.0774797201156616, -0.02674875780940056, 0.08428122848272324, -0.5056319832801819, 0.11618417501449585, -0.669107973575592, -0.30974382162094116, -0.7203238606452942, -0.6959074139595032, 0.5400103330612183, 0.3650083839893341, 0.573552131652832, -0.05614420026540756, 0.7174423933029175, 0.27674975991249084, 0.21264652907848358, 0.2027970552444458, -0.713798999786377, 0.14761312305927277, -0.25805479288101196, -0.22860650718212128, -0.20162411034107208, 0.012338106520473957, -0.30784082412719727, -0.03959936648607254, 0.2722955048084259, 0.09151840209960938, -0.10693152993917465, 0.7374785542488098, -1.0576064586639404, 0.43627697229385376, -0.4345817267894745, 0.2742803394794464, 0.05480276048183441, 0.2478104829788208, -0.6544499397277832, -0.7233915328979492, -0.15035554766654968, -0.21965399384498596, 0.3906426727771759, -0.42418617010116577, 0.7165399193763733, 0.6219976544380188, -0.6029385924339294, -0.5298725962638855, -0.9035793542861938, 0.7324187755584717, -0.48700833320617676, 0.2924001216888428, 0.37959185242652893, 0.21747340261936188, 0.175848588347435, -0.7277479767799377, -0.41511088609695435, 0.13899241387844086, -0.44738712906837463, 0.08188065886497498, -0.4602980613708496, 0.009601583704352379, 0.17513246834278107, 0.3950105905532837, -0.4897100031375885, -0.22154608368873596, -0.23072092235088348, -0.1553652286529541, 0.9243976473808289, 0.40869444608688354, 0.0032888788264244795, -0.2566867470741272, -0.2034091204404831, -0.21481092274188995, -0.3371170163154602, 0.37670981884002686, 0.38041752576828003, 0.2061852216720581, -0.03053942322731018, 0.32320085167884827, -0.11024323105812073, 0.3768385052680969, -0.04611903801560402, 0.10592323541641235, 0.2531542181968689, 0.35371509194374084, -0.5134514570236206, -0.012623298913240433, 1.0249155759811401, 0.46170929074287415, 0.48606595396995544, 0.08125295490026474, -0.08243332803249359, 0.6977975964546204, 0.816155195236206, -0.6262629628181458, -0.3954928517341614, 0.31633254885673523, -0.4659859538078308, -0.31912291049957275, 0.11377633363008499, -0.7736517190933228, -0.7620673179626465, -0.32958322763442993, 0.2955409288406372, -0.5639121532440186, 0.2359897941350937, 0.4028865396976471, 0.018534796312451363, -0.052006304264068604, 0.4522477686405182, -0.4904661774635315, 0.20849333703517914, 0.7885547876358032, 0.5487681031227112, -0.16917118430137634, -0.08855582028627396, -0.33849817514419556, -0.4146043062210083, -0.28546565771102905, 0.555255651473999, -0.5958197116851807, -0.3403512239456177, -0.049875665456056595, -0.04562091454863548, 0.017919549718499184, -0.16079233586788177, 1.3903934955596924, -0.3781324028968811, -0.009335500188171864, -0.3703055679798126, -0.45208513736724854, -1.007003664970398, 0.21648971736431122, -0.917322039604187, 0.868000328540802, 0.2964671850204468, -0.6209976077079773, 0.39333316683769226, -0.15754760801792145, -0.5059224367141724, 0.11037030071020126, -0.16534224152565002, -0.5050942897796631, 0.5506182909011841, -0.1978779435157776, 0.6653059124946594, -0.66835618019104, 0.6326930522918701, -0.4363196790218353, -0.43801620602607727, 0.26538801193237305, -0.24037112295627594, 0.37637239694595337, 0.21285121142864227, -0.5427080988883972, -0.10691159218549728, -0.5720458626747131, -0.03571242839097977, -0.09462196379899979, -0.13593943417072296, -0.3028557002544403, 0.2059556394815445, 0.17598827183246613, 0.4938647747039795, 0.14964409172534943, -0.43920183181762695, 0.2184663861989975, 0.39245912432670593, 0.39542844891548157, 0.6882789731025696, -0.2226082980632782, 0.04342259466648102, -0.023446790874004364, 0.3650120198726654, 0.09066107124090195, 0.34360310435295105, 0.2963336110115051, -0.47033438086509705, -0.9049645066261292, 0.07941965758800507, 0.0732751339673996, 0.36554405093193054, -0.10366196185350418, 0.44837790727615356, 0.04105302691459656, -0.6957478523254395, -0.4071498513221741, -0.3417747914791107, 0.5010509490966797, 0.577783465385437, 0.5549429059028625, -0.19728566706180573, -0.6040611267089844, -0.8494576215744019, -0.35483765602111816, -0.26410236954689026, 0.3808322846889496, 0.7453283667564392, 0.5776208639144897, -0.6112609505653381, 1.001043677330017, -0.8060551881790161, -0.4441700577735901, 0.26039624214172363, 0.4454781115055084, 0.2635676860809326, 0.5070224404335022, 0.2876937687397003, -1.1423419713974, -0.423960417509079, 0.20481348037719727, -1.0285488367080688, 0.19507718086242676, -0.36070045828819275, -0.0178761538118124, 0.10981375724077225, 0.010431692935526371, -0.5918569564819336, 0.8779928088188171, 0.05004432797431946, -0.6999803185462952, 0.780278205871582, -0.050893690437078476, 0.5433058738708496, -0.031476881355047226, 0.027995070442557335, 0.06788154691457748, 0.23116235435009003, -0.6572906970977783, -0.336917519569397, 0.3863530457019806, 0.3154841661453247, -0.2676900625228882, 0.32900470495224, -0.15487250685691833, 0.10100489109754562, 0.08370485156774521, -0.6104297041893005, 0.012259932234883308, 0.5814549326896667, 0.0908733680844307, 0.2255854308605194, 0.44196516275405884, -0.42738932371139526, 0.3645031750202179, 0.5372342467308044, -0.2711103856563568, 0.45017844438552856, -0.47225362062454224, 0.26225408911705017, -0.09048823267221451, 0.07927224785089493, -0.9492787718772888, -0.24934665858745575, 0.32751283049583435, -0.5906928181648254, 0.0616905651986599, -0.2523652911186218, 0.08555903285741806, -0.5561190247535706, -0.14375454187393188, 0.5900558829307556, 0.49994081258773804, -0.41921308636665344, 0.9565559029579163, -0.06146235764026642, -0.05281199887394905, -0.7846890687942505, -0.8226159811019897, -0.09548936039209366, -0.3076229393482208, -0.2784465253353119, 0.3796921670436859, -0.002604990266263485, -0.35455599427223206, 0.03602778539061546, 0.006657872349023819, -0.061907682567834854, -0.22102074325084686, 0.9288556575775146, 0.27769994735717773, 0.19164705276489258, 0.393146812915802, 0.0735674500465393, -0.3356466591358185, 0.32408785820007324, -0.1745663434267044, 0.49459943175315857, -0.5169897079467773, -0.22182117402553558, -0.08400633186101913, 0.40274757146835327, 0.6871746182441711, -0.245340958237648, 0.40002357959747314, 0.7226778864860535, -0.4508174955844879, -0.07728291302919388, -0.6778698563575745, 0.24861323833465576, -0.39487364888191223, -0.07672186195850372, -0.3879638910293579, -0.8476414680480957, 0.533014178276062, -0.015072480775415897, -0.45434069633483887, 0.5848824381828308, 0.5777137279510498, -0.03663668408989906, 0.6822935342788696, 0.5874431729316711, -0.5675992965698242, -0.10978740453720093, -0.28791800141334534, 0.4146491289138794, -0.4893920123577118, -0.4151388108730316, -0.5596970915794373, -0.6330912113189697, -0.6554950475692749, -0.4262283146381378, 0.11673492193222046, 0.10510154813528061, -0.8801003694534302, -0.08327848464250565, -0.6413450837135315, 0.29370859265327454, 0.38040462136268616, 0.25351306796073914, 0.09781459718942642, -0.28616195917129517, 0.2157278209924698, -0.22333601117134094, 0.08861716836690903, -0.4267834424972534, 0.7296319603919983, -0.15001513063907623, 0.8048501014709473, -0.0738305002450943, 0.6743045449256897, 0.8908780217170715, -0.1169799268245697, -0.9621434807777405, 0.2994941473007202, -0.3194270133972168, -0.2995181381702423, 0.02652885764837265, -0.515988826751709, -0.6713956594467163, -0.13905437290668488, -0.12498674541711807, -0.8977742195129395, 0.6614150404930115, -0.14016203582286835, -0.24344225227832794, 0.2707882225513458, -0.5974225401878357, 0.9770154356956482, -0.282101035118103, -0.5799265503883362, -0.1904163956642151, -0.7659285664558411, 0.4612377882003784, -0.05007082223892212, 0.10154004395008087, 0.13478389382362366, 0.4594220519065857, 0.5392207503318787, -0.0947798639535904, 0.7954456806182861, -0.09062019735574722, 0.13631869852542877, 0.27516016364097595, 0.5637741684913635, 0.7074108123779297, 0.10276691615581512, -0.3477993607521057, 0.004961335100233555, -0.6380786895751953, 0.027924463152885437, -0.5096468925476074, 0.7811934351921082, -0.7619960308074951, 0.006308730226010084, -0.33037635684013367, -0.5572348833084106, -0.1406967043876648, 0.22994056344032288, 0.31770220398902893, 0.04053045064210892, -0.41552263498306274, -0.008997493423521519, 0.7564566135406494, -0.14989104866981506, 0.6057485938072205, 0.08446216583251953, -0.11126719415187836, -0.27269914746284485, 0.8021459579467773, -0.27857664227485657, -0.38991984724998474, 0.31830140948295593, 0.24953623116016388, -0.2733219563961029, -0.007695329841226339, -0.0390101820230484, 0.2222047597169876, -0.8626245856285095, -0.5949556231498718, -0.7873924970626831, 0.14913952350616455, -0.3324066996574402, -0.5345290303230286, -0.4916030466556549, -0.12541058659553528, -0.44257789850234985, -0.2587817907333374, 0.6078976392745972, 1.0401092767715454, -0.06930387020111084, 0.08808452636003494, -0.6472076773643494, 0.24450573325157166, 0.3524843454360962, 0.3335525691509247, 0.12123557180166245, -0.028789304196834564, -0.046551309525966644, -0.1772139072418213, -0.2515506446361542, -0.8679859042167664, 0.7075860500335693, 0.0804143100976944, 0.04144127294421196, 0.704539954662323, 0.260685533285141, 0.47612252831459045, -0.09641459584236145, 0.6709368228912354, 0.17018850147724152, -1.21163010597229, 0.5294722318649292, -0.16679783165454865, -0.1127108484506607, 0.6359472870826721, 0.8939329385757446, -0.6564449667930603, 0.22664758563041687, -0.6804202795028687, -0.6140973567962646, 0.7921128869056702, 0.07108240574598312, -0.18732206523418427, 0.15306749939918518, 0.25504156947135925, 0.4513273537158966, 0.08337961137294769, -0.8244581818580627, -0.35493138432502747, 0.009419947862625122, -0.11656027287244797, -0.460633248090744, -0.3302358388900757, 0.11271266639232635, -0.25175341963768005, 0.5447595119476318, -0.11448672413825989, 0.49677252769470215, 0.11074221879243851, -0.17621064186096191, -0.14922979474067688, 0.1516624540090561, 0.25508683919906616, 0.10490058362483978, -0.24022738635540009, 0.28524500131607056, 0.03555517643690109, -0.5006468892097473, 0.42847877740859985, -0.12628047168254852, 0.034935519099235535, -0.09507112950086594, 0.37999504804611206, 0.9056701064109802, -0.005696667358279228, -0.35717567801475525, 0.434752494096756, -0.2873949110507965, -0.25769859552383423, -0.20579789578914642, 0.052618224173784256, 0.15149201452732086, 0.5711566805839539, 0.16380877792835236, 0.48492416739463806, 0.6287622451782227, -0.26296499371528625, 0.17993372678756714, -0.029874684289097786, -0.9858232736587524, -0.18599437177181244, 0.2788955867290497, -0.2859523296356201, -0.40434256196022034, 1.0214186906814575, -0.4154421389102936, -0.788451075553894, 0.570363461971283, 0.18752190470695496, 1.0583596229553223, -0.2536207139492035, 0.6174420714378357, 0.48982465267181396, 0.11365398019552231, -0.14568458497524261, 0.4456676244735718, -0.05722562223672867, -0.5847391486167908, -0.2075992375612259, -0.5210053324699402, -0.35727033019065857, -0.11988847702741623, -1.051414132118225, 0.2841030955314636, -0.09063256531953812, -0.21876005828380585, -0.24349677562713623, 0.07196015119552612, -0.9627994298934937, 0.8892136216163635, 0.2160319685935974, 0.5110411047935486, -1.08153235912323, 0.35488536953926086, 0.3899782598018646, -0.29652726650238037, -0.7838174104690552, -0.3915384113788605, 0.17201188206672668, -0.3660754859447479, 0.7263809442520142, 0.42343372106552124, -0.268006831407547, -0.4000442922115326, -0.3201468586921692, -0.36402222514152527, 0.8003280162811279, 0.21046887338161469, -0.5099661350250244, 0.16237333416938782, 0.28264763951301575, 0.5808583498001099, -0.21063297986984253, 0.7700242400169373, 0.7217695713043213, 0.7200644016265869, 0.0014591150684282184, -0.233228400349617, 0.03958506137132645, -0.3590047359466553, -0.3132064640522003, 0.49712756276130676, -0.6087561249732971, 1.309744119644165, -0.17493149638175964, -0.02725033275783062, -0.6870980262756348, 0.5247961282730103, -0.06988726556301117, 0.5887427926063538, 0.375278502702713, 0.8551874160766602, 0.9075168371200562, -0.3876782953739166, 0.8905594944953918, 0.33090680837631226, 0.7317259311676025, 1.092391014099121, -0.3498050272464752, 0.4697178304195404, 0.28921324014663696, -0.38465556502342224, 0.7952359914779663, 0.6743513345718384, -0.11228999495506287, 0.4719984233379364, 0.16162505745887756, -0.32136353850364685, -0.513447642326355, 0.06413920968770981, -0.19692426919937134, 0.6312413215637207, 0.5036659240722656, -0.4117659628391266, -0.09433713555335999, 0.042684588581323624, -0.15172947943210602, -0.2291191965341568, -0.2520516812801361, 0.6560177206993103, 0.0009767948649823666, -0.6282593607902527, 0.24291443824768066, -0.3188011646270752, 0.7210314273834229, -0.4496030807495117, 0.028454996645450592, -0.29776763916015625, 0.4837450087070465, -0.6434594988822937, -0.8320715427398682, 0.25022149085998535, 0.21286535263061523, -0.4959193766117096, 0.010531964711844921, 1.2007015943527222, -0.048289649188518524, -0.5389124751091003, 0.6414699554443359, 0.42540231347084045, 0.05273588374257088, -0.43270668387413025, -0.5741352438926697, 0.29820379614830017, 0.2715950906276703, -0.39302757382392883, 0.027010351419448853, 0.5911369919776917, -0.0851307362318039, 0.7640425562858582, 0.33027395606040955, -0.36621832847595215, -0.25519877672195435, 0.10704336315393448, 0.7049635052680969, -0.974111020565033, -0.476237952709198, -1.0629372596740723, 0.7303823828697205, 0.06560364365577698, -0.4298103153705597, 0.3321572542190552, 0.5050821304321289, 0.715444028377533, -0.4599713385105133, 0.970281720161438, -0.49788469076156616, 0.015290256589651108, -0.16292613744735718, 0.5550380349159241, -0.3532888889312744, -0.15842172503471375, -0.608231782913208, -0.3519045114517212, -0.33702823519706726, 0.7848013639450073, -0.57084059715271, 0.18529538810253143, 0.6354628205299377, 0.520144522190094, -0.030337003991007805, 0.6994261145591736, 0.18463902175426483, -0.0808943435549736, 0.29366180300712585, 1.1848963499069214, 1.1332054138183594, -0.5587436556816101, 0.13972975313663483, -0.4524606168270111, -0.09482414275407791, -0.4090508222579956, -1.1578290462493896, -0.4542340338230133, -0.8052084445953369, -0.2447885274887085, -0.09514380246400833, -0.24916785955429077, 0.5155107378959656, 0.45468848943710327, -0.808447003364563, -0.2703119218349457, -0.3767489790916443, 0.3184910714626312, -0.4434746205806732, -0.24469006061553955, 0.33400842547416687, -0.3807966411113739, -0.32275262475013733, 0.05324447527527809, 0.11619193106889725, -0.34085091948509216, 0.14567320048809052, -0.2944011390209198, -0.11146990209817886, -0.16538693010807037, 0.4605114758014679, -0.09683330357074738, -0.538107693195343, -0.3214527368545532, -0.2237897515296936, -0.130896657705307, 0.12586936354637146, 1.2611163854599, -1.0392471551895142, 0.40431317687034607, 0.5847140550613403, 0.5498428344726562, 0.8451493382453918, -0.24534918367862701, 0.328064888715744, -0.30245447158813477, -0.5080037117004395, 0.41422635316848755, 0.4832277297973633, 0.20217344164848328, -0.9472267627716064, 0.869788646697998, 0.003752542892470956, -0.916472852230072, -0.4921485483646393, 0.14220833778381348, -1.1365036964416504, -0.3266220986843109, 0.5639012455940247, -0.3976143002510071, 0.10001856088638306, 0.06797582656145096, -0.36404895782470703, 0.5408385992050171, -0.4554734230041504, 0.8353484869003296, 0.7487700581550598, -0.5060586929321289, -0.0072019388899207115, -0.013594360090792179, 0.5768753290176392, 0.35787269473075867, -0.852174699306488, 0.4810509979724884, 0.8494585752487183, -0.3419460356235504, 0.2964976727962494, 0.16209867596626282, 0.020101582631468773, 0.3343273401260376, 0.1191815733909607, 0.4122943580150604, -0.06960708647966385, -0.5962575674057007, -0.4868963360786438, 0.39290642738342285, -0.6272855997085571, 0.2200978398323059 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16475v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16475v2	InfoLossQA: Characterizing and Recovering Information Loss in Text Simplification	2024-01-29T19:00:01	2024-06-04T13:36:07	Jan Trienes, Sebastian Joseph, Jörg Schlötterer, Christin Seifert, Kyle Lo, Wei Xu, Byron C. Wallace, Junyi Jessy Li	cs.CL	cs.CL	Text simplification aims to make technical texts more accessible to laypeople but often results in deletion of information and vagueness. This work proposes InfoLossQA, a framework to characterize and recover simplification-induced information loss in form of question-and-answer (QA) pairs. Building on the theory of Question Under Discussion, the QA pairs are designed to help readers deepen their knowledge of a text. We conduct a range of experiments with this framework. First, we collect a dataset of 1,000 linguist-curated QA pairs derived from 104 LLM simplifications of scientific abstracts of medical studies. Our analyses of this data reveal that information loss occurs frequently, and that the QA pairs give a high-level overview of what information was lost. Second, we devise two methods for this task: end-to-end prompting of open-source and commercial language models, and a natural language inference pipeline. With a novel evaluation framework considering the correctness of QA pairs and their linguistic suitability, our expert evaluation reveals that models struggle to reliably identify information loss and applying similar standards as humans at what constitutes information loss.	[ -0.1424473524093628, -0.7033176422119141, 0.6390553116798401, 0.18193823099136353, -0.23450018465518951, -0.05394333600997925, 0.12024683505296707, -0.2143671214580536, 0.1048995703458786, 0.35179242491722107, -0.5713430643081665, -0.10459116101264954, -0.5655111074447632, 0.0810256376862526, -0.6313118934631348, 1.2429505586624146, -0.1907634288072586, 0.17169006168842316, -0.41756394505500793, 0.0026569294277578592, -0.3757018446922302, -0.5293332934379578, -0.48593616485595703, -0.050353020429611206, 0.4174787104129791, 0.39064231514930725, 0.8532888889312744, 0.693625271320343, 0.44404706358909607, 0.2190639227628708, -0.48391497135162354, -0.039796896278858185, -0.6736730337142944, -0.01290944218635559, -0.012164904735982418, -0.7558324933052063, 0.10789421945810318, -0.06010156869888306, 0.7686382532119751, 1.0093032121658325, -0.300101101398468, 0.308212548494339, 0.10827086865901947, 0.7896043658256531, -0.8047584891319275, 0.07404046505689621, -0.2882848083972931, 0.06489720195531845, -0.0041479687206447124, -0.5854707360267639, -0.36447006464004517, -0.789479672908783, -0.01813964731991291, -0.7688996195793152, 0.10784422606229782, -0.01673322729766369, 0.8694348335266113, 0.44040268659591675, -0.5553274750709534, -0.5809605121612549, -0.9153277277946472, 0.5827625393867493, -0.5584098100662231, 0.3826415538787842, 0.25651422142982483, 0.23774422705173492, -0.20082683861255646, -0.7083450555801392, -0.7501736879348755, -0.045978400856256485, -0.2100113481283188, 0.16771171987056732, -0.3470592796802521, 0.0872948169708252, 0.4100613296031952, 0.41215091943740845, -0.5256568789482117, -0.5277274250984192, -0.7395224571228027, -0.34546685218811035, 0.35006406903266907, 0.13010653853416443, 0.4771471619606018, -0.19249245524406433, -0.5079138875007629, -0.04990610107779503, -0.703592836856842, 0.30939045548439026, 0.42452558875083923, -0.0927649512887001, 0.10626647621393204, 0.46482065320014954, -0.34961897134780884, 0.316542387008667, -0.1293458789587021, -0.165686696767807, 0.07196127623319626, -0.797883152961731, -0.23167437314987183, -0.0032686577178537846, 0.5183065533638, 0.27152368426322937, 0.010335607454180717, -0.3074685335159302, 0.11560315638780594, -0.3888668715953827, -0.08204866200685501, -0.6448873281478882, -0.2349822074174881, 0.24777191877365112, -0.5869539976119995, -0.050008729100227356, 0.19952848553657532, -0.21764546632766724, -0.6395443677902222, -0.42455461621284485, 0.7099281549453735, -0.38254839181900024, -0.38146480917930603, 0.5147653818130493, -0.5591888427734375, 0.30119308829307556, 0.3727062940597534, -0.39562296867370605, 0.4710681140422821, 0.5012844204902649, 0.5462372303009033, -0.08177182823419571, -0.09242256730794907, -0.17402447760105133, 0.1270168274641037, -0.3467949628829956, 0.6048985123634338, 0.05021696910262108, 0.022188564762473106, -0.20269811153411865, -0.1318267583847046, -0.06747382879257202, -0.6855082511901855, 0.80069500207901, -0.5329761505126953, 0.5276671051979065, -0.4023998975753784, -0.5889385342597961, -0.35828959941864014, 0.17862342298030853, -0.9453564882278442, 0.8872076869010925, -0.13626395165920258, -1.3917453289031982, 0.18022841215133667, -0.34779053926467896, 0.006882745772600174, 0.14668510854244232, -0.1356961727142334, -0.2199486792087555, -0.03174920752644539, -0.2783468961715698, 0.25308912992477417, -0.607875645160675, 0.31488731503486633, -0.1031351089477539, -0.43932291865348816, 0.34709930419921875, -0.5482983589172363, 0.8555787205696106, 0.006539830006659031, -0.05421418324112892, -0.14281216263771057, -0.7285665273666382, 0.18964862823486328, 0.053141962736845016, -0.5562739968299866, -0.6264697909355164, -0.017934298142790794, -0.00470897788181901, 0.13741080462932587, 0.25595974922180176, -0.585625171661377, 0.03754246234893799, -0.22164085507392883, 0.2705397307872772, 0.3634844720363617, 0.21329538524150848, 0.34770071506500244, -0.47069376707077026, 0.5563555359840393, 0.01672540046274662, 0.46933552622795105, -0.19262480735778809, -0.49506402015686035, -0.7521152496337891, -0.16789941489696503, 0.5516560673713684, 0.6159363389015198, -0.8962620496749878, -0.004735375288873911, -0.2816159725189209, -0.3334413766860962, -0.815107524394989, 0.03192108869552612, 0.44013264775276184, 0.6759423613548279, 0.41756945848464966, 0.005564667284488678, -0.3674551546573639, -1.1236486434936523, -0.6451617479324341, -0.3415314555168152, -0.3799254298210144, 0.03761424869298935, 0.1365077793598175, -0.039325322955846786, 0.9128679037094116, -0.2770686149597168, 0.21315526962280273, -0.1920928806066513, 0.26764222979545593, 0.10373979061841965, 0.39987319707870483, 0.1622275412082672, -1.2191766500473022, 0.10594270378351212, -0.4531485438346863, -0.775447428226471, -0.11787080019712448, -0.3351133465766907, -0.06164441630244255, -0.3423507809638977, 0.5090495347976685, -0.41328901052474976, 0.8034075498580933, 0.4183856248855591, -0.4353815019130707, 0.6722644567489624, -0.056787654757499695, 0.27227476239204407, -0.9483867287635803, 0.34796759486198425, -0.5004503130912781, -0.18393175303936005, -0.7401615381240845, -0.051637616008520126, 0.16205595433712006, 0.2857077717781067, -0.2747204303741455, 0.5532823801040649, -0.283051460981369, 0.01945311762392521, 0.0955168753862381, 0.17564734816551208, 0.3830549120903015, 0.3292539417743683, -0.2870275378227234, 0.5969812273979187, 0.13278178870677948, -0.7735212445259094, 0.1515485644340515, 0.3408728837966919, -0.24516060948371887, 0.4362398386001587, -0.6054836511611938, -0.006509687285870314, -0.5694676637649536, 0.28544870018959045, -1.2452507019042969, -0.5068027377128601, 0.3358142673969269, -0.5011599659919739, -0.17142264544963837, 0.17495864629745483, -0.647683322429657, 0.050663623958826065, -0.7360210418701172, 0.868243932723999, 0.012036493048071861, -0.3828471601009369, 0.6066654324531555, 0.39758506417274475, -0.7494679689407349, -0.6181188821792603, -0.8564026355743408, 0.08230994641780853, 0.07873059064149857, -0.7354695200920105, 0.16484765708446503, -0.5451969504356384, -0.5441193580627441, 0.03839142993092537, -0.19039718806743622, -0.562870442867279, 0.31124967336654663, 0.2918756902217865, 0.08313993364572525, -0.04157407954335213, 0.7712865471839905, 0.49206656217575073, 0.11707193404436111, 0.07136956602334976, 0.17840969562530518, 0.37959110736846924, -0.0720684826374054, -0.20944775640964508, -0.7821050882339478, 0.6245909333229065, 0.1770683228969574, 0.10358301550149918, 0.7152418494224548, 0.11669926345348358, -0.43635624647140503, 0.14365755021572113, -0.48266762495040894, -0.16812118887901306, -0.40591907501220703, 0.24580082297325134, -0.2671317756175995, -0.6086224317550659, 0.3941722810268402, -0.17921702563762665, -0.10431431978940964, 0.5388223528862, 0.26263725757598877, -0.30990898609161377, 0.7751965522766113, 0.9447936415672302, 0.4333086907863617, 0.2768176198005676, -0.11316052824258804, 0.14922679960727692, -0.44018521904945374, -0.7925158739089966, -0.5438152551651001, -0.05508715659379959, -0.12523680925369263, -0.313076376914978, 0.5677142143249512, 0.6293426752090454, 0.0219557024538517, 0.02526341937482357, -0.12836854159832, 0.5808007121086121, 0.7580336332321167, 0.21046803891658783, 0.6309000253677368, -0.17506831884384155, -0.008143661543726921, 0.12146107852458954, -0.87406325340271, -0.65003502368927, 0.7510294914245605, 0.45780235528945923, 0.7404637336730957, 0.1523270159959793, 0.6461195349693298, 0.33930474519729614, 0.2590809464454651, -0.8697027564048767, 0.38068294525146484, 0.4005795419216156, -0.37782666087150574, -0.2563394010066986, -0.883956789970398, -0.7090253233909607, -0.3364464044570923, -0.19617179036140442, -0.29741838574409485, 0.2133660614490509, 0.23172597587108612, -0.32573387026786804, 0.14403478801250458, -0.7371948957443237, 0.6753518581390381, 0.02846089005470276, 0.07154282182455063, 0.03647070750594139, -0.9325872659683228, 0.49700435996055603, -0.19331665337085724, 0.5007270574569702, 0.24411052465438843, -0.23259763419628143, 1.0437437295913696, -0.3712834119796753, 0.3990626931190491, 0.16476970911026, -0.23259243369102478, 0.17364796996116638, 0.09227854758501053, 0.09132568538188934, -0.041241373866796494, -0.09672871232032776, 0.07220043987035751, 0.42613115906715393, -0.606357753276825, -0.7587101459503174, 0.20650053024291992, -0.4862804114818573, -0.22055648267269135, -0.1443513184785843, -0.5898652672767639, -0.07418695092201233, 0.1654076874256134, 0.4563223123550415, 0.4353111982345581, -0.16601642966270447, 0.06578002870082855, 0.8179327249526978, -0.28916043043136597, 0.23808833956718445, 0.46743276715278625, 0.06499853730201721, -0.2760292589664459, 0.5555757880210876, 0.04613925516605377, 0.3341065049171448, 0.4025413393974304, 0.20275729894638062, -0.26788267493247986, -0.5205991864204407, -0.4108349680900574, 0.40420907735824585, -0.9747124314308167, -0.23750843107700348, -0.5375290513038635, -0.2323189377784729, -0.237929105758667, 0.5194738507270813, 0.12002524733543396, -0.9500495791435242, -0.220583975315094, -0.17316466569900513, -0.041109371930360794, 1.1262463331222534, 0.035411469638347626, 0.14245028793811798, -0.8239803314208984, 0.37459346652030945, 0.28732627630233765, 0.08711390942335129, -0.32186904549598694, -0.5426918864250183, -0.12495596706867218, 0.05296226963400841, -0.04943158105015755, -1.2698949575424194, -0.08631753921508789, 0.28215092420578003, 0.34988367557525635, 0.32057318091392517, 0.3315344750881195, 0.2855810821056366, -0.07858356833457947, 0.6119603514671326, 0.1948026418685913, -1.0381622314453125, 0.35366737842559814, 0.006548815406858921, 0.37225547432899475, 0.6182872653007507, 0.4938826262950897, -0.767512321472168, -0.3805728852748871, -0.602074146270752, -0.8321735262870789, 0.7486065626144409, 0.4394074082374573, -0.033060669898986816, 0.2947760224342346, 0.6545045971870422, 0.11177428811788559, 0.43755537271499634, -0.6739187836647034, -0.3642997443675995, 0.06380744278430939, -0.5347579121589661, 0.5027045011520386, -0.5125629901885986, -0.3467979431152344, 0.2026677131652832, 0.5538398623466492, -0.1411304920911789, 0.07155561447143555, 0.3519303798675537, -0.11405523121356964, -0.0005828667199239135, 0.4349161684513092, 0.3045188784599304, 0.5164604783058167, 0.11926119029521942, 0.3104730248451233, -0.0872267410159111, -0.4475207030773163, 0.10207144916057587, 0.2665918469429016, -0.5259449481964111, 0.18739674985408783, 0.5226033926010132, 0.5084596276283264, 0.0922229140996933, -0.991460382938385, 0.9935836791992188, -0.5639863610267639, -0.10004374384880066, 0.07009664177894592, -0.21261334419250488, -0.004613286349922419, 0.02458079718053341, 0.6088402271270752, 0.2566486895084381, 0.8181264996528625, -0.6187018156051636, 0.24153313040733337, 0.09740009158849716, -0.3122972548007965, -0.36833611130714417, 0.29304179549217224, -0.11780432611703873, -0.26044341921806335, 0.021979209035634995, -0.16201066970825195, -0.5112589001655579, 0.8362984657287598, 0.06564442068338394, 0.591559112071991, -0.26743021607398987, 0.46762391924858093, 0.23782531917095184, 0.3452002704143524, -0.2294430285692215, 0.6593043804168701, -0.22835834324359894, -0.2852669656276703, -0.2189658284187317, -0.2916018068790436, -0.5482054948806763, 0.027028795331716537, -0.8524744510650635, 0.12683068215847015, -0.39366742968559265, -0.03169650584459305, 0.054126620292663574, -0.30707934498786926, -0.5928241610527039, 0.203120619058609, 0.03600176051259041, 1.1409852504730225, -0.7510495185852051, 0.30186429619789124, 0.4767957925796509, -0.5556461811065674, -1.0450491905212402, 0.5117177367210388, -0.06804051250219345, -0.3508278429508209, 0.782334566116333, 0.18296551704406738, -0.3276456594467163, -0.23621319234371185, -0.8030924797058105, -0.9355827569961548, 1.044836401939392, 0.8285858035087585, -0.326076477766037, -0.1862255334854126, 0.34903067350387573, 0.5143650770187378, 0.2347482442855835, 0.45539453625679016, 0.3664291799068451, 0.35913994908332825, -0.06866585463285446, -1.1577768325805664, 0.2499728798866272, -0.33409449458122253, -0.27685490250587463, 0.21459151804447174, -0.510040283203125, 0.9232959151268005, -0.4129333794116974, -0.7736908793449402, 0.3665861189365387, 0.3304566442966461, -0.2249014526605606, 0.6004232168197632, 0.5078797936439514, 0.23304305970668793, 1.057025671005249, -0.02295559085905552, 0.9578741192817688, -0.22589066624641418, 0.29761311411857605, 1.0922945737838745, 0.4322698414325714, 0.8750337362289429, 0.6539794206619263, 0.10582538694143295, 0.39654046297073364, 0.4030679166316986, 0.6056422591209412, 0.34958451986312866, 0.42993825674057007, -0.37690189480781555, -0.14215856790542603, -0.4695344567298889, -0.2667814791202545, 0.24288880825042725, 0.3132106065750122, -0.28317293524742126, -0.21099400520324707, 0.03656146675348282, 0.08136970549821854, 0.06465627253055573, -0.30001556873321533, 0.9383258819580078, -0.11446574330329895, -0.5636834502220154, 0.5935741066932678, -0.08457799255847931, 0.24512086808681488, -0.5252529382705688, -0.22789792716503143, -0.3808067739009857, -0.03168767690658569, -0.27616527676582336, -0.6796306371688843, 0.15160447359085083, -0.180545836687088, -0.2906050682067871, 0.11565162241458893, 0.5340762734413147, -0.9208801984786987, -0.2509145736694336, 0.3408401608467102, 0.45054754614830017, 0.2622213363647461, -0.17034538090229034, -0.6225971579551697, 0.02336237207055092, 0.02771506831049919, 0.035062842071056366, -0.1325133889913559, 0.5313705205917358, 0.0032634055241942406, 0.893467366695404, 0.3084524869918823, -0.018644019961357117, 0.2948422431945801, -0.13590870797634125, 1.0882048606872559, -0.669130265712738, -0.2686810791492462, -0.46064242720603943, 0.2591177821159363, -0.2189728170633316, -0.4126323461532593, 0.6674911379814148, 0.683260977268219, 0.5900257229804993, 0.0483497679233551, 0.948796808719635, 0.23851963877677917, 0.8120973110198975, -0.7118915319442749, 0.6786653995513916, -0.5983836650848389, 0.4397525191307068, 0.014493581838905811, -0.4428284466266632, -0.16507577896118164, -0.1011090874671936, 0.12710943818092346, -0.27192673087120056, 0.6751514077186584, 0.6474018096923828, 0.006498279981315136, 0.0659656673669815, 0.09239844232797623, 0.33920758962631226, 0.10338068753480911, 0.6518400311470032, 0.9797195196151733, -0.8670411705970764, 1.038282036781311, -0.10874728858470917, -0.6026437282562256, -0.22076961398124695, -0.6343424320220947, -0.5302106738090515, -0.6213576793670654, -0.3281388580799103, -0.24482300877571106, 0.1613919883966446, 0.614439070224762, 0.3803001344203949, -0.5676664710044861, 0.07201199978590012, -0.012395387515425682, 0.3243521749973297, 0.02207857184112072, -0.22576360404491425, 0.32147324085235596, -0.17799335718154907, -0.49695315957069397, 0.2849234640598297, 0.3345322608947754, 0.20601607859134674, -0.23967960476875305, -0.015475152060389519, 0.016527876257896423, 0.5644738674163818, 0.1806630790233612, 0.43702971935272217, -0.4553234279155731, 0.2162908911705017, -0.023058880120515823, -0.3150171935558319, -0.08146663755178452, 0.8003259897232056, -0.7944693565368652, 0.6553781032562256, 0.8332421183586121, 0.7994723916053772, -0.05736105516552925, 0.1544121503829956, 0.6860188245773315, -0.8337132334709167, -0.0660112276673317, 0.2654673755168915, 0.15271645784378052, 0.5669898986816406, -0.26745861768722534, 0.4171712100505829, 0.08449971675872803, -0.3097115457057953, -0.9200218915939331, 0.31252118945121765, -0.936528205871582, -0.2404937893152237, 1.0297605991363525, -0.40723225474357605, -0.08181150257587433, -0.47100797295570374, -0.49119049310684204, 0.20233815908432007, -0.21234600245952606, 0.9903771281242371, 0.664376437664032, 0.04216906428337097, 0.05151822790503502, -0.2628205120563507, 0.9732822775840759, 0.5314515829086304, -1.2226589918136597, 0.1411861628293991, 0.34030312299728394, 0.2519206404685974, 0.4760023355484009, 0.7315776944160461, 0.05863853171467781, 0.5736392736434937, -0.1855185180902481, -0.024011356756091118, 0.13093870878219604, -0.2784002721309662, -0.5993834137916565, 0.2717629671096802, -0.054180946201086044, -0.04911196231842041 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16421v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16421v2	Two Stones Hit One Bird: Bilevel Positional Encoding for Better Length Extrapolation	2024-01-29T18:59:07	2024-06-17T06:18:13	Zhenyu He, Guhao Feng, Shengjie Luo, Kai Yang, Liwei Wang, Jingjing Xu, Zhi Zhang, Hongxia Yang, Di He	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML	In this work, we leverage the intrinsic segmentation of language sequences and design a new positional encoding method called Bilevel Positional Encoding (BiPE). For each position, our BiPE blends an intra-segment encoding and an inter-segment encoding. The intra-segment encoding identifies the locations within a segment and helps the model capture the semantic information therein via absolute positional encoding. The inter-segment encoding specifies the segment index, models the relationships between segments, and aims to improve extrapolation capabilities via relative positional encoding. Theoretical analysis shows this disentanglement of positional information makes learning more effective. The empirical results also show that our BiPE has superior length extrapolation capabilities across a wide range of tasks in diverse text modalities.	[ -0.26058682799339294, -0.5624045729637146, 0.3608977496623993, 0.4824009835720062, -0.41876980662345886, 0.23400230705738068, -0.09792604297399521, -0.7565715909004211, 0.2071424126625061, 0.006256729364395142, -0.2592475116252899, -0.04078008979558945, -0.6195462942123413, 0.022722439840435982, -0.49331703782081604, 0.797747015953064, 0.4320922791957855, 0.3432186245918274, 0.1668330430984497, 0.09475794434547424, -0.30755913257598877, -0.7746404409408569, -0.3028651773929596, -0.11774797737598419, 0.5904449224472046, 0.4052886962890625, 0.6664157509803772, 0.630078136920929, 0.5974652767181396, 0.2508218586444855, -0.08522627502679825, 0.3320549726486206, -0.25137799978256226, -0.05282396450638771, -0.20380301773548126, -0.5773653984069824, -0.20093488693237305, -0.08410213142633438, 1.1265078783035278, 1.1031523942947388, 0.05026581138372421, -0.09554287791252136, -0.050328921526670456, 0.9301103949546814, -0.37236863374710083, -0.03667531907558441, -0.5255005359649658, -0.07341388612985611, -0.44793465733528137, -0.5137161016464233, -0.42906635999679565, -0.48923778533935547, 0.09570232033729553, -0.4617299735546112, 0.12995721399784088, 0.1442011147737503, 1.0698776245117188, -0.013396244496107101, -0.3197064697742462, -0.27678152918815613, -0.7170201539993286, 0.6282703876495361, -0.5857066512107849, 0.8361984491348267, 0.4569206237792969, 0.23682616651058197, -0.07086434960365295, -0.4059533178806305, -0.6625366806983948, 0.15401023626327515, -0.02536792680621147, -0.06897249817848206, 0.2593587636947632, -0.07391808182001114, 0.01527517382055521, 0.35467955470085144, -0.5322174429893494, 0.02015615999698639, -0.7500274181365967, -0.047458067536354065, 0.7995229959487915, -0.15909501910209656, 0.3997736871242523, 0.017341433092951775, -0.29404059052467346, -0.43976637721061707, -0.7640819549560547, 0.10285971313714981, 0.8059648871421814, 0.3118513822555542, -0.007348113227635622, 0.6776885390281677, 0.03978383168578148, 0.7454450130462646, 0.48047763109207153, -0.05238456651568413, 0.49344345927238464, -0.012368390336632729, 0.0046265316195786, 0.48025786876678467, 0.31523510813713074, 0.31512004137039185, 0.0711086094379425, -0.12583059072494507, 0.11266663670539856, -0.17582708597183228, 0.03122907690703869, -0.5629713535308838, -0.24283933639526367, 0.022839462384581566, -0.26644784212112427, 0.13357560336589813, 0.2964993715286255, -0.749676525592804, -0.3764217495918274, -0.2966872453689575, 0.019574439153075218, -0.8077806830406189, -0.1273340880870819, 0.16764967143535614, -0.357697993516922, 0.6312738060951233, 0.07509530335664749, -1.2539856433868408, 0.19358330965042114, 0.7774242162704468, 0.9524698257446289, 0.1296485811471939, -0.6123582720756531, -0.672899603843689, 0.4723953306674957, -0.4684715270996094, 1.1903315782546997, -0.8444874286651611, -0.569577157497406, -0.011371975764632225, 0.03942257910966873, 0.17512358725070953, -0.22547771036624908, 0.39222240447998047, -0.7053854465484619, 0.3657993972301483, -0.4610756039619446, -0.6066553592681885, -0.47670620679855347, 0.39926090836524963, -0.625364363193512, 0.9785742163658142, 0.30375632643699646, -0.7269449234008789, 0.5399321913719177, -0.4227425754070282, -0.7169954180717468, 0.12947867810726166, -0.3878701329231262, -0.055794857442379, 0.41409799456596375, 0.05232599005103111, 0.045640017837285995, -0.31294241547584534, -0.15884257853031158, -0.04058976098895073, -0.3671906590461731, 0.27898308634757996, -0.46529388427734375, 0.6151929497718811, -0.07612072676420212, -0.005665741395205259, 0.04823869466781616, -0.7731814980506897, 0.23881177604198456, -0.028848689049482346, -0.8488439917564392, -0.6007373929023743, -0.01593271642923355, 0.16019046306610107, 0.3282525837421417, 0.11893649399280548, -0.6653720736503601, 0.3057997524738312, -0.7529833316802979, 0.14693690836429596, 0.6264392733573914, -0.0638352707028389, 0.6398606896400452, -0.14702393114566803, 0.2523857653141022, -0.0673147439956665, 0.09626442939043045, -0.028075462207198143, -0.4536624252796173, -0.4687514305114746, 0.069401815533638, 0.5146921277046204, 0.4098447859287262, -0.5074309706687927, 0.3016636073589325, -0.41365960240364075, -0.21324938535690308, -0.363549143075943, -0.04213114082813263, 0.6137132048606873, 0.4477749764919281, 0.43837642669677734, -0.5995973944664001, -0.6284143328666687, -0.6901945471763611, -0.31451913714408875, -0.42701947689056396, 0.0489802248775959, -0.2426634430885315, 0.2122204750776291, 0.14067478477954865, 0.8884168267250061, -0.4410113990306854, -0.10378721356391907, -0.2874492406845093, 0.17954140901565552, 0.03041909821331501, 0.6194016933441162, 0.5005043745040894, -0.8986943960189819, -0.9112821221351624, -0.09431426227092743, -0.5030941367149353, 0.11798545718193054, -0.12591981887817383, -0.19844117760658264, 0.16978023946285248, 0.2099245935678482, -0.20153193175792694, 0.3043927848339081, 0.38717347383499146, -0.44614067673683167, 0.6957364678382874, -0.6102662086486816, 0.19597767293453217, -0.5906878113746643, -0.0502476692199707, -0.10561073571443558, -0.08682993054389954, -0.6778194308280945, -0.20594201982021332, 0.3559764623641968, -0.005154257640242577, -0.522359311580658, 0.40988197922706604, -0.921470046043396, -0.3877430856227875, -0.3658249080181122, 0.21852098405361176, 0.3732813000679016, 0.7456744909286499, 0.26876360177993774, 0.7992069721221924, 0.38499563932418823, -0.5679678916931152, 0.26862281560897827, 0.4124762713909149, -0.5044787526130676, 0.6197816729545593, -0.6209039688110352, 0.26294711232185364, -0.09124970436096191, 0.07329463213682175, -0.8956371545791626, -0.19625672698020935, 0.0785888209939003, -0.4668083190917969, 0.7475683093070984, -0.3310023546218872, -0.5356238484382629, -0.19128990173339844, -0.5792672038078308, 0.48575419187545776, 0.39564618468284607, -0.4816441237926483, 0.0529588907957077, 0.6070210933685303, -0.26622408628463745, -0.5514692068099976, -1.0153204202651978, -0.020709525793790817, -0.17594026029109955, -0.559912919998169, 0.6307926774024963, 0.013432342559099197, -0.05081462487578392, -0.20196370780467987, -0.08120515197515488, -0.16987450420856476, -0.2991785407066345, 0.06807427853345871, 0.17423667013645172, -0.08245456963777542, 0.2406138777732849, 0.25883930921554565, -0.21903233230113983, -0.13719798624515533, -0.29585257172584534, 0.9549316763877869, -0.13107728958129883, -0.5701768398284912, -0.39627915620803833, 0.7366419434547424, 0.35698965191841125, -0.23410587012767792, 0.6887617707252502, 0.527876079082489, -0.3258661925792694, -0.04241540655493736, -0.369541198015213, 0.06110939756035805, -0.4828709661960602, 0.47121694684028625, -0.48895585536956787, -0.3286004960536957, 0.23852066695690155, -0.007486952934414148, -0.1403585970401764, 0.09997586905956268, 0.16137872636318207, -0.1696128100156784, 1.3327475786209106, 1.0134989023208618, -0.05615638196468353, 0.6242872476577759, -0.4243168532848358, 0.2596985995769501, -1.3524906635284424, -0.7017912864685059, -0.5335759520530701, -0.40461844205856323, -0.10388390719890594, -0.5839037299156189, 0.3036753833293915, 0.5568794012069702, -0.09222511947154999, 0.21959613263607025, -0.6930014491081238, 0.6108769774436951, 0.6848000884056091, 0.042372751981019974, 0.04663907364010811, 0.18340745568275452, -0.31317389011383057, -0.17450451850891113, -0.6782001852989197, -0.3202052116394043, 0.6899771094322205, 0.3059925138950348, 0.794455885887146, 0.30079755187034607, 0.13925884664058685, 0.45358988642692566, -0.2592551112174988, -0.7258322238922119, 0.3105487525463104, -0.15496563911437988, -0.5341786742210388, -0.4077798128128052, 0.11047379672527313, -0.7778026461601257, 0.16193275153636932, 0.13056331872940063, -0.8059709668159485, 0.7047363519668579, 0.11646470427513123, -0.24768094718456268, 0.2246883511543274, -0.6334224343299866, 0.5693398118019104, -0.7078049778938293, -0.40704119205474854, -0.13790097832679749, -0.8483988046646118, -0.14204959571361542, 0.26263436675071716, 0.1356247216463089, -0.13937188684940338, -0.027617357671260834, 0.9530656933784485, -0.6778654456138611, 0.8454115390777588, -0.15170790255069733, -0.1892690807580948, 0.24561704695224762, 0.05121411010622978, 0.44335368275642395, -0.006448405794799328, -0.16703680157661438, 0.21473072469234467, 0.08593635261058807, -0.7110884189605713, -0.5059151649475098, 0.4587831497192383, -0.7840785980224609, -0.5121234655380249, -0.42945289611816406, -0.3849482238292694, -0.44129669666290283, 0.09050267189741135, 0.5248644351959229, 0.8670627474784851, -0.0993511751294136, -0.03277625888586044, 0.3894319534301758, -0.15679502487182617, 0.6051331162452698, 0.4439461827278137, -0.049692727625370026, -0.352763831615448, 0.8435702919960022, -0.05116816610097885, 0.06585338711738586, 0.856742262840271, 0.18825091421604156, -0.8976230025291443, -0.7878198623657227, -0.5780664086341858, 0.5165343880653381, -1.0119537115097046, -0.024364270269870758, -0.3774069547653198, -0.14958329498767853, -0.6295182704925537, -0.3751361668109894, -0.3720053732395172, -0.5994624495506287, 0.15205059945583344, -0.13314536213874817, 0.11872213333845139, 0.6160890460014343, -0.5340209603309631, 0.40050041675567627, -1.021729588508606, 0.009393553249537945, 0.23416262865066528, 0.18380071222782135, -0.22873172163963318, -0.709743320941925, -0.4271746575832367, 0.08129361271858215, -0.05980442836880684, -1.1921144723892212, 0.4932161271572113, 0.501873254776001, 0.7155686616897583, 0.44659605622291565, -0.1346137970685959, 0.9568386077880859, -0.6658592820167542, 0.7820678949356079, 0.6844346523284912, -0.957445502281189, 0.5827429294586182, 0.07024304568767548, 0.3992687463760376, 0.6631921529769897, 0.4574856758117676, -0.9556789994239807, 0.09373448044061661, -0.13785196840763092, -0.8028301000595093, 0.841895341873169, -0.034283045679330826, 0.07913017272949219, -0.3106860816478729, 0.1351010948419571, 0.38783589005470276, 0.07947074621915817, -0.2905229926109314, -0.1556454300880432, -0.3394755423069, -0.22583045065402985, 0.013068449683487415, -0.6970875859260559, -0.1855766326189041, -0.2113828808069229, 0.8066274523735046, -0.1287849098443985, 0.6007316708564758, 0.46636417508125305, -0.5719195008277893, 0.025939730927348137, 0.1541140228509903, 0.6421298980712891, 0.8512560129165649, -0.04441022500395775, 0.3563717007637024, -0.03923392668366432, -0.7251453995704651, 0.1629505455493927, 0.15525293350219727, -0.02494504302740097, 0.22969317436218262, 0.5940679907798767, 0.6677260994911194, 0.093749038875103, -0.713828444480896, 0.5200394988059998, 0.11919791996479034, 0.15714995563030243, -0.25562384724617004, -0.2366492599248886, -0.2293369174003601, 0.3220045268535614, 0.438650518655777, -0.1521959900856018, 0.235206738114357, -0.7578094601631165, 0.08916771411895752, 0.14772653579711914, -0.7081487774848938, -0.7259387373924255, 0.5542423725128174, 0.4106070399284363, -0.666546642780304, 0.6940925121307373, -0.08957313746213913, -0.9052131772041321, 0.5370839238166809, 0.7983571887016296, 0.4635760486125946, -0.2507201135158539, 0.23154371976852417, 0.4152998626232147, 0.1481386423110962, 0.1410851925611496, 0.3283376693725586, -0.3470899760723114, -0.6291816234588623, -0.3965008854866028, -0.6744571924209595, -0.3433879315853119, -0.2095700353384018, -0.579241931438446, 0.2180803269147873, -0.3978666365146637, 0.267507940530777, -0.3041304349899292, 0.15558217465877533, -0.4067198634147644, 0.289699912071228, 0.39339351654052734, 0.9610870480537415, -0.4785511791706085, 1.1883927583694458, 1.0765385627746582, -0.4719604551792145, -0.9336548447608948, -0.14547890424728394, -0.08112135529518127, -0.6716814041137695, 0.8383855223655701, 0.23142856359481812, -0.3490482270717621, -0.28114932775497437, -0.07357838749885559, -0.9572077393531799, 0.8852664828300476, 0.06813908368349075, -0.7447570562362671, -0.33719727396965027, 0.4635906517505646, 0.3853333294391632, -0.16440576314926147, 0.2022344172000885, 0.42598092555999756, 0.38838738203048706, -0.03848378732800484, -0.817826509475708, -0.10251264274120331, -0.5369739532470703, 0.1195565015077591, 0.30494025349617004, -0.6848700642585754, 0.6212074756622314, -0.07482656836509705, -0.21331004798412323, -0.2303999364376068, 0.5811924338340759, 0.13612718880176544, 0.038213010877370834, 0.46506115794181824, 0.1696944236755371, 0.898023247718811, 0.1832590252161026, 1.0570216178894043, -0.4742204546928406, 0.13133765757083893, 1.4793181419372559, -0.21502484381198883, 0.7146432399749756, 0.5524522662162781, -0.23630644381046295, 0.7297365069389343, 0.7089516520500183, 0.2918183505535126, 0.8879231810569763, -0.19903884828090668, -0.1933717280626297, -0.019755488261580467, 0.23722952604293823, -0.7467402815818787, 0.4776315689086914, 0.44920387864112854, -0.4152413308620453, -0.06653694808483124, 0.08861718326807022, 0.05682848393917084, 0.18118490278720856, -0.19337521493434906, 0.5659899711608887, -0.22691625356674194, -0.621478796005249, 0.5373313426971436, 0.09130623191595078, 0.5586361289024353, -0.8210397958755493, -0.10083544999361038, -0.24578465521335602, 0.2263989895582199, -0.05162985622882843, -0.8336626291275024, 0.43079662322998047, -0.1982729434967041, -0.22457844018936157, -0.11164868623018265, 0.7895893454551697, -0.5094993710517883, -0.3035902976989746, 0.32257238030433655, 0.1338922530412674, 0.4661022424697876, -0.07659152895212173, -0.7042710185050964, 0.1288585513830185, -0.10811741650104523, -0.20017768442630768, 0.21165919303894043, 0.4645039439201355, -0.05718674883246422, 0.4099105894565582, 0.6231000423431396, 0.14854533970355988, 0.6405186057090759, 0.061210546642541885, 0.7973745465278625, -0.7811791896820068, -0.8717270493507385, -0.7356367707252502, 0.3333861529827118, -0.44805383682250977, -0.3853742480278015, 0.8128415942192078, 0.8210704922676086, 1.0868942737579346, -0.08100119233131409, 0.7413530349731445, -0.3823137581348419, 0.45057612657546997, -0.4711091220378876, 0.4202842712402344, -0.5308255553245544, 0.3514544367790222, -0.05080632120370865, -0.9426593780517578, -0.20363354682922363, 0.7281185388565063, -0.6213601231575012, -0.26166993379592896, 0.8395758271217346, 0.5691027641296387, -0.12791354954242706, -0.07559933513402939, 0.4790020287036896, 0.005789496470242739, 0.30838683247566223, 0.5552935004234314, 1.0088467597961426, -0.46603068709373474, 0.7142059206962585, -0.6666349172592163, -0.16579821705818176, -0.42280933260917664, -0.6202248930931091, -0.7782526016235352, -0.8869163393974304, -0.20737479627132416, -0.09567466378211975, 0.0726901963353157, 0.6277215480804443, 1.183287501335144, -0.629260778427124, -0.16566835343837738, -0.059439901262521744, 0.03648281469941139, -0.4212612211704254, -0.15919752418994904, 0.6468989849090576, -0.28632819652557373, -0.9006929993629456, 0.6488514542579651, 0.6619535088539124, -0.003931023646146059, -0.15791510045528412, -0.4102882146835327, -0.771374523639679, 0.21461063623428345, 0.651570737361908, 0.6231540441513062, -0.391588419675827, -0.5532612204551697, -0.2309560924768448, -0.05311600863933563, 0.34171411395072937, 0.9801819324493408, -0.5685331225395203, 0.28441527485847473, 0.8695344924926758, 0.3513071537017822, 0.5258731245994568, 0.27764856815338135, 0.6216905117034912, -0.7944384217262268, 0.43983742594718933, 0.1958017349243164, 0.3924701511859894, 0.6044067740440369, -0.49978455901145935, 0.6005486845970154, 0.15336699783802032, -0.35196515917778015, -0.735302746295929, 0.3620148003101349, -1.1340909004211426, -0.5457687973976135, 1.0763390064239502, -0.40331384539604187, -0.5912349224090576, -0.3049771189689636, -0.3727611303329468, 0.40849703550338745, -0.1593651920557022, 0.6661576628684998, 0.5327398777008057, -0.30046483874320984, -0.11737596243619919, 0.11574380099773407, 0.25086691975593567, 0.42157164216041565, -0.7017155289649963, -0.318884015083313, 0.4791395962238312, 0.3271206319332123, 0.3526034951210022, 0.604293704032898, -0.368193656206131, 0.29822438955307007, 0.38422146439552307, -0.03995834290981293, -0.2147798091173172, -0.6502446532249451, -0.24663624167442322, 0.2297719568014145, 0.2458709180355072, -0.48817178606987 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16420v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16420v1	InternLM-XComposer2: Mastering Free-form Text-Image Composition and Comprehension in Vision-Language Large Model	2024-01-29T18:59:02	2024-01-29T18:59:02	Xiaoyi Dong, Pan Zhang, Yuhang Zang, Yuhang Cao, Bin Wang, Linke Ouyang, Xilin Wei, Songyang Zhang, Haodong Duan, Maosong Cao, Wenwei Zhang, Yining Li, Hang Yan, Yang Gao, Xinyue Zhang, Wei Li, Jingwen Li, Kai Chen, Conghui He, Xingcheng Zhang, Yu Qiao, Dahua Lin, Jiaqi Wang	cs.CV	cs.CV, cs.CL	We introduce InternLM-XComposer2, a cutting-edge vision-language model excelling in free-form text-image composition and comprehension. This model goes beyond conventional vision-language understanding, adeptly crafting interleaved text-image content from diverse inputs like outlines, detailed textual specifications, and reference images, enabling highly customizable content creation. InternLM-XComposer2 proposes a Partial LoRA (PLoRA) approach that applies additional LoRA parameters exclusively to image tokens to preserve the integrity of pre-trained language knowledge, striking a balance between precise vision understanding and text composition with literary talent. Experimental results demonstrate the superiority of InternLM-XComposer2 based on InternLM2-7B in producing high-quality long-text multi-modal content and its exceptional vision-language understanding performance across various benchmarks, where it not only significantly outperforms existing multimodal models but also matches or even surpasses GPT-4V and Gemini Pro in certain assessments. This highlights its remarkable proficiency in the realm of multimodal understanding. The InternLM-XComposer2 model series with 7B parameters are publicly available at https://github.com/InternLM/InternLM-XComposer.	[ -0.3000294268131256, -0.5485731363296509, 0.527358889579773, 0.32134875655174255, -0.4873148798942566, 0.11222761124372482, -0.1572510153055191, -0.7540023326873779, -0.06405138969421387, 0.6349557042121887, -0.2781640291213989, -0.3413276970386505, -0.48738908767700195, -0.17009980976581573, -0.6965897083282471, 0.8240112066268921, -0.15751007199287415, 0.06281241029500961, -0.5548818707466125, -0.428488165140152, -0.5500179529190063, -0.2714114785194397, -0.7102743983268738, -0.25650158524513245, 0.7227712273597717, 0.5094456076622009, 0.6991198062896729, 0.6049159169197083, 0.7329293489456177, 0.2425931692123413, -0.06294341385364532, 0.1565776914358139, -0.5084836483001709, -0.04627394676208496, -0.3073301613330841, -0.7614914178848267, -0.4077819585800171, -0.12637022137641907, 0.8369778990745544, 0.3987694978713989, 0.14927679300308228, 0.12933605909347534, 0.055981382727622986, 0.671084463596344, -0.5165185928344727, 0.3746480941772461, -0.810975193977356, -0.13479971885681152, -0.16500520706176758, -0.05709276348352432, -0.5775788426399231, 0.2848148047924042, 0.03208492696285248, -0.902023434638977, -0.03701728954911232, 0.3552444279193878, 0.7908118367195129, 0.4144580364227295, -0.36631470918655396, -0.1889607310295105, -0.38277360796928406, 0.6830657720565796, -0.21789641678333282, 0.2924734354019165, 0.1772240847349167, 0.4648648500442505, 0.44035130739212036, -1.119239330291748, -0.877853274345398, -0.2819055914878845, -0.07509694248437881, 0.3497176170349121, -0.20349401235580444, -0.03387003019452095, -0.0741906389594078, 0.4258922040462494, -0.6055240631103516, 0.13692322373390198, -0.5479361414909363, 0.17369335889816284, 0.32347357273101807, 0.16865046322345734, 0.5335890650749207, -0.20260562002658844, -0.7215719819068909, -0.2299998253583908, -0.8062666654586792, 0.12814439833164215, 0.04926161468029022, -0.20135179162025452, -0.29161787033081055, 0.8070936799049377, 0.06699392199516296, 0.5243729948997498, -0.3400391638278961, 0.09100409597158432, 0.05509503185749054, -0.4922212064266205, -0.15005093812942505, -0.22161608934402466, 0.5637233853340149, 0.5724263787269592, 0.03378906473517418, -0.06305266171693802, -0.28590506315231323, 0.343190461397171, 0.22013285756111145, -0.6192534565925598, -0.20592249929904938, 0.09086421877145767, -0.5956085920333862, -0.36731788516044617, -0.04118028283119202, -0.6624656319618225, -0.3871615529060364, -0.6205813884735107, 0.7801197171211243, -0.5951086282730103, -0.17210596799850464, 0.11591134965419769, -0.24371740221977234, 0.31599026918411255, 0.384816974401474, -0.6236417889595032, 0.2437969595193863, 0.5496461987495422, 0.9876750707626343, -0.5093076229095459, -0.45265433192253113, -0.46646180748939514, 0.3599954843521118, -0.31949397921562195, 0.8542749881744385, -0.4011963903903961, -0.21260692179203033, 0.006133249960839748, -0.2610047459602356, 0.03472716361284256, -0.48069921135902405, 0.5892350077629089, -0.6250482797622681, 0.22914442420005798, 0.03815464302897453, -0.40549007058143616, -0.41300085186958313, 0.37303054332733154, -0.9043390154838562, 0.964120090007782, 0.28438493609428406, -0.8999364376068115, 0.11338962614536285, -1.0160924196243286, -0.22160176932811737, 0.3265785276889801, -0.3134780526161194, -0.14809109270572662, 0.1636010855436325, -0.0006481555756181479, 0.10922348499298096, -0.4380728304386139, 0.003745299531146884, 0.2227623611688614, -0.3723040521144867, 0.4819697141647339, -0.3785921335220337, 0.6459765434265137, 0.022132249549031258, -0.2553515136241913, 0.5172072052955627, -1.006417155265808, -0.016407813876867294, 0.20574182271957397, -0.1393318623304367, -0.4178793132305145, 0.10313951224088669, 0.5247412919998169, 0.4136326313018799, 0.3897896409034729, -0.5397089123725891, -0.15514123439788818, -0.3225652277469635, 0.47284746170043945, 0.6533020734786987, -0.5142825245857239, 0.5472033619880676, -0.461044043302536, 0.5118122100830078, 0.13001666963100433, 0.29799970984458923, -0.6249557733535767, -0.4351707994937897, -1.17861807346344, -0.4651956856250763, -0.004333218559622765, 0.6671136617660522, -1.1165869235992432, 0.0066072335466742516, -0.35560616850852966, -0.6231105923652649, -0.44126731157302856, 0.10512524098157883, 0.604623556137085, 0.6387401223182678, 0.5138424634933472, -0.18648800253868103, -0.48837849497795105, -0.9213985204696655, 0.007390255574136972, -0.19564135372638702, 0.24747474491596222, 0.06659232079982758, 0.5783259868621826, -0.2668304741382599, 1.0068459510803223, -0.5279619097709656, -0.7469937205314636, -0.632980465888977, 0.21544022858142853, 0.009422625415027142, 0.48305636644363403, 0.7396199107170105, -1.0135830640792847, -0.8136385679244995, 0.1552022099494934, -0.7473269701004028, -0.02045941911637783, 0.02324030175805092, -0.09301718324422836, 0.42003223299980164, 0.5454137325286865, -0.6644526720046997, 0.41943877935409546, 0.7442270517349243, -0.5521500706672668, 0.5977734923362732, -0.34147515892982483, -0.0865180566906929, -0.9382386803627014, 0.24004380404949188, -0.10959061235189438, -0.4013066589832306, -0.6119266152381897, 0.505727231502533, 0.2898009419441223, -0.02510915882885456, -0.7436813116073608, 0.8799779415130615, -0.43772488832473755, 0.17292268574237823, -0.5203188061714172, 0.16238445043563843, 0.13848842680454254, 0.3828583359718323, 0.17634347081184387, 0.8294057846069336, 0.6546539664268494, -0.1681465059518814, 0.25158873200416565, 0.5121517181396484, -0.9326089024543762, 0.5847839117050171, -0.8766191005706787, 0.02882304973900318, -0.4138863980770111, 0.10100986063480377, -1.1172080039978027, -0.1522359997034073, 0.2721676826477051, -0.22422803938388824, 0.15486553311347961, -0.037966642528772354, -0.6775187849998474, -0.22001859545707703, -0.2809551954269409, 0.4975200295448303, 0.6040767431259155, -0.5223597288131714, 0.8181328177452087, 0.11339078098535538, -0.39156490564346313, -0.4238978922367096, -0.848675012588501, 0.24523314833641052, 0.052430395036935806, -0.7491175532341003, 0.6135490536689758, -0.2672930955886841, -0.3911444842815399, 0.14231865108013153, 0.3672041893005371, -0.026054324582219124, -0.2891812324523926, 0.3326413929462433, 0.6205836534500122, -0.12283019721508026, -0.14742456376552582, 0.10856355726718903, -0.4498988687992096, -0.14044195413589478, -0.08992046117782593, 0.5393102169036865, 0.06889533996582031, -0.3986176550388336, -0.35349857807159424, 0.80667644739151, 0.796394407749176, -0.5527079701423645, 0.6834043264389038, 0.5891581773757935, -0.059273917227983475, -0.031741708517074585, -0.46770817041397095, 0.028076762333512306, -0.45265960693359375, 0.6234115362167358, -0.40867146849632263, -0.8356253504753113, 0.35256069898605347, 0.5538384318351746, 0.1996135115623474, 0.21271368861198425, 0.6047252416610718, -0.2023235410451889, 1.0438237190246582, 0.9188949465751648, 0.37252333760261536, 0.5739325881004333, -0.38645946979522705, 0.0762779712677002, -0.8935397267341614, -0.39713335037231445, -0.1701732724905014, -0.471346914768219, -0.08500693738460541, -0.8261287212371826, 0.5140992999076843, -0.4051147401332855, -0.08757328987121582, 0.0484195202589035, -0.22359004616737366, 0.6114544868469238, 0.8347131013870239, 0.07239820063114166, 0.5721537470817566, 0.14896918833255768, -0.0014672797406092286, -0.06869515776634216, -0.47472715377807617, -0.4860925078392029, 0.8773990869522095, 0.2396283894777298, 0.8140268921852112, 0.014889762736856937, 0.07436733692884445, 0.061358172446489334, 0.26622357964515686, -0.8043696284294128, 0.637395441532135, -0.49903419613838196, -0.5294487476348877, -0.03805215656757355, 0.11758275330066681, -0.5715732574462891, 0.577081561088562, -0.0026629723142832518, -0.5900391936302185, 0.07294891029596329, 0.16336584091186523, -0.225808784365654, 0.33949407935142517, -0.5065668225288391, 0.8036905527114868, -0.3860901892185211, -0.4042534828186035, -0.47244006395339966, -0.9422398209571838, 0.3126186430454254, -0.06853767484426498, 0.10939686000347137, -0.0720180869102478, -0.5121226906776428, 0.48857325315475464, -0.1220942884683609, 0.8611618280410767, 0.004533011466264725, -0.14794054627418518, 0.2575203478336334, 0.049222126603126526, 0.3272547721862793, 0.08001987636089325, -0.1055530309677124, 0.11098106950521469, 0.09437660872936249, -0.18467868864536285, -0.4963153302669525, 0.6308896541595459, -0.8773033618927002, -0.4209693372249603, -0.3603218197822571, -0.7399588227272034, 0.11140603572130203, 0.28076183795928955, 0.49157029390335083, 0.6390899419784546, -0.14791564643383026, 0.4795556664466858, 0.5756745934486389, -0.15093526244163513, 0.5626774430274963, 0.4868800938129425, -0.45337092876434326, -0.7310773134231567, 0.9728732109069824, 0.04753498360514641, 0.3939224183559418, 0.7441297173500061, -0.11284071952104568, -0.4180270731449127, -0.5506552457809448, -0.48448488116264343, 0.19136010110378265, -1.0719257593154907, -0.19408464431762695, -0.6990510821342468, -0.1826229691505432, -0.0005300616612657905, -0.25398921966552734, -0.33213332295417786, -0.3473549783229828, -0.5157366394996643, 0.1618237942457199, 0.09061375260353088, 0.5065588355064392, 0.031114058569073677, 0.5695662498474121, -0.7696250081062317, 0.688396692276001, 0.11650912463665009, 0.2986868917942047, -0.12285695225000381, -0.557217538356781, -0.22589582204818726, -0.1083868220448494, -0.301531583070755, -0.6065066456794739, 0.3574681282043457, 0.31491339206695557, 0.4100272059440613, 0.5202205181121826, -0.22328640520572662, 0.4540414810180664, -0.500727117061615, 0.8802298903465271, 0.5315084457397461, -1.01321280002594, 0.30281150341033936, -0.2993490397930145, 0.4304359257221222, 0.5438438057899475, 0.14624403417110443, -0.7064383625984192, -0.2780967354774475, -0.15630732476711273, -0.8273704051971436, 0.7166824340820312, 0.2830250859260559, 0.3815141022205353, 0.09884440898895264, 0.15818168222904205, 0.3574405908584595, 0.1056084930896759, -1.0512712001800537, -0.159820556640625, -0.5513254404067993, -0.4600139260292053, -0.015927232801914215, -0.6182042956352234, -0.04514335095882416, -0.3576699197292328, 0.6138509511947632, -0.3385186791419983, 0.22337843477725983, 0.16902171075344086, -0.45498934388160706, 0.1471702754497528, 0.050237931311130524, 0.6178227066993713, 0.9121529459953308, 0.20234298706054688, 0.2513047456741333, -0.2126990258693695, -0.4277908504009247, 0.20053048431873322, 0.04830807447433472, -0.46591076254844666, -0.0707935318350792, 0.38592222332954407, 0.9475837349891663, 0.2089793086051941, -1.0574573278427124, 0.6731411218643188, -0.02503490075469017, -0.37132513523101807, -0.5120670199394226, 0.07922618836164474, -0.002050127135589719, 0.13494297862052917, 0.32988572120666504, 0.16149665415287018, -0.02058269828557968, -0.4411494731903076, -0.07643324881792068, 0.35238832235336304, -0.6142831444740295, -0.44217827916145325, 0.9256963729858398, 0.1378708779811859, 0.18544483184814453, 0.5883380770683289, -0.04776385799050331, -0.3913697302341461, 0.5248309373855591, 0.8593974113464355, 0.531167209148407, 0.24217769503593445, 0.3076993227005005, 0.03317537531256676, 0.3294021189212799, 0.1019572913646698, 0.7108840942382812, 0.09628081321716309, -0.6631029844284058, -0.6282984018325806, -0.42473676800727844, -0.33476048707962036, -0.023535655811429024, -0.42563921213150024, 0.502778172492981, -0.33186089992523193, 0.23631292581558228, -0.1759733408689499, -0.31759247183799744, -0.5279957056045532, 0.12407299131155014, 0.17388556897640228, 1.335087537765503, -0.6121132969856262, 0.8968129754066467, 0.9536237120628357, -0.6682543158531189, -0.5230032205581665, -0.3867519199848175, -0.12825460731983185, -0.8202670216560364, 0.8440667390823364, 0.3471563756465912, -0.07540541887283325, 0.16921710968017578, -0.5609148144721985, -0.8154414892196655, 1.241998314857483, 0.3541422188282013, -0.5376577973365784, -0.21757912635803223, 0.23702365159988403, 0.3638554513454437, -0.20794618129730225, 0.162592813372612, 0.2565261721611023, 0.5935076475143433, 0.256818026304245, -0.6473239660263062, -0.180186465382576, -0.44557711482048035, 0.1777035892009735, 0.06004389747977257, -0.8334862589836121, 0.8620808124542236, -0.19240236282348633, -0.1337316334247589, 0.8191683888435364, 0.775877058506012, 0.07055370509624481, 0.23664630949497223, 0.4726572036743164, 0.6674684286117554, 0.3517223000526428, -0.06158589571714401, 1.0229086875915527, -0.27940425276756287, -0.04244699701666832, 1.2640113830566406, -0.36510029435157776, 0.9792495369911194, 0.6608015298843384, 0.26745107769966125, 0.6558102369308472, 0.13672411441802979, -0.03175509721040726, 0.6694318652153015, -0.07636357843875885, -0.5301634073257446, -0.06838639080524445, -0.18945114314556122, -0.16955998539924622, 0.7658974528312683, 0.2988627851009369, -0.35583236813545227, -0.042677443474531174, 0.4880176782608032, -0.16141395270824432, 0.0963376834988594, -0.2514685094356537, 0.827559769153595, 0.06490685790777206, -0.8285959362983704, 0.20659613609313965, 0.1445443034172058, 0.6559768915176392, -0.8043067455291748, 0.08914916962385178, -0.09476824104785919, 0.44394439458847046, 0.036571938544511795, -1.1620289087295532, 0.26102733612060547, -0.10756981372833252, -0.32755517959594727, -0.2719408869743347, 0.8068510890007019, -0.5097298622131348, -0.6265208721160889, 0.34772777557373047, 0.4041122496128082, -0.1368502378463745, -0.3507227301597595, -0.4515027701854706, 0.3159829080104828, -0.19632583856582642, 0.08762368559837341, 0.11470707505941391, 0.17839203774929047, -0.17063269019126892, 0.6839843392372131, 0.577740490436554, 0.012232518754899502, 0.058855678886175156, 0.23268096148967743, 0.8692171573638916, -0.42820602655410767, -0.5768618583679199, -0.8316656947135925, 0.7595359086990356, -0.12388574331998825, -0.23541544377803802, 0.44856560230255127, 0.7109562158584595, 0.7902857065200806, -0.4148193597793579, 0.897489070892334, -0.13611991703510284, 0.21406131982803345, -0.5394323468208313, 0.8393860459327698, -0.8461211919784546, -0.329337477684021, -0.021163038909435272, -0.9657747745513916, -0.6152762174606323, 0.4040553569793701, 0.08498872816562653, -0.4125874638557434, 0.7913475036621094, 0.8463314771652222, -0.16527976095676422, -0.10638528317213058, 0.5155150294303894, 0.15413866937160492, 0.499098539352417, 0.4341374933719635, 1.1454493999481201, -0.29925820231437683, 0.8174108862876892, -0.10207519680261612, -0.4008958339691162, -0.1848440319299698, -0.9116755723953247, -0.9447197318077087, -0.8245253562927246, -0.2599411606788635, 0.17120113968849182, -0.0951274186372757, 0.7551541924476624, 0.7178957462310791, -0.39704835414886475, -0.10629546642303467, -0.09757058322429657, -0.11899755895137787, -0.23378819227218628, -0.1942596435546875, 0.2571107745170593, -0.3444007337093353, -0.8613150119781494, 0.2905081510543823, 0.7953429818153381, 0.20205248892307281, -0.49865493178367615, -0.07051602751016617, 0.08748577535152435, 0.18404163420200348, 1.1174490451812744, -0.007219241000711918, -0.8934913277626038, 0.0033226716332137585, 0.13691453635692596, -0.1178557500243187, 0.33973968029022217, 0.8312333822250366, -0.7158898115158081, 0.37995728850364685, 0.7234855890274048, 0.34051036834716797, 0.28080329298973083, -0.24933373928070068, 0.3527835011482239, -0.46179941296577454, 0.3207830786705017, -0.04674654081463814, 0.5906988382339478, 0.48783597350120544, 0.013177539221942425, 0.4433606266975403, 0.02589120902121067, -0.3280344009399414, -0.5062316060066223, 0.21549153327941895, -1.4830808639526367, -0.3576786518096924, 1.1983197927474976, 0.044458456337451935, -0.19132882356643677, 0.07079710811376572, -0.8785594701766968, 0.025300124660134315, -0.01239010039716959, 0.607147753238678, 0.42418909072875977, 0.12395033240318298, -0.626632034778595, -0.46853721141815186, -0.01236165501177311, 0.4126805365085602, -1.0111244916915894, -0.10817661136388779, 0.44575175642967224, 0.0914628803730011, 0.2036791443824768, 0.6584535837173462, -0.481106162071228, 0.4858573377132416, -0.22888627648353577, -0.057116441428661346, -0.22405759990215302, -0.5902401804924011, 0.10256854444742203, 0.38371017575263977, 0.08086220175027847, -0.22157755494117737 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16467v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16467v2	ReGAL: Refactoring Programs to Discover Generalizable Abstractions	2024-01-29T18:45:30	2024-06-06T17:31:07	Elias Stengel-Eskin, Archiki Prasad, Mohit Bansal	cs.SE	cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL	While large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being used for program synthesis, they lack the global view needed to develop useful abstractions; they generally predict programs one at a time, often repeating the same functionality. Generating redundant code from scratch is both inefficient and error-prone. To address this, we propose Refactoring for Generalizable Abstraction Learning (ReGAL), a gradient-free method for learning a library of reusable functions via code refactorization, i.e., restructuring code without changing its execution output. ReGAL learns from a small set of existing programs, iteratively verifying and refining its abstractions via execution. We find that the shared function libraries discovered by ReGAL make programs easier to predict across diverse domains. On five datasets -- LOGO graphics generation, Date reasoning, TextCraft (a Minecraft-based text-game) MATH, and TabMWP -- both open-source and proprietary LLMs improve in accuracy when predicting programs with ReGAL functions. For CodeLlama-13B, ReGAL results in absolute accuracy increases of 11.5% on LOGO, 26.1% on date understanding, and 8.1% on TextCraft, outperforming GPT-3.5 in two of three domains. Our analysis reveals ReGAL's abstractions encapsulate frequently-used subroutines as well as environment dynamics.	[ -0.13971439003944397, -0.3893186151981354, 0.1316262185573578, 0.40637290477752686, 0.02071484550833702, 0.512134313583374, -0.17267979681491852, -0.3289451599121094, -0.03152792900800705, 0.3061240315437317, -0.43789932131767273, -0.7408879399299622, -0.15870043635368347, -0.28598061203956604, -0.3081701993942261, 0.926372230052948, -0.2563283443450928, -0.22637654840946198, -0.2424524575471878, -0.3232388198375702, -0.3093017339706421, -0.09834369271993637, -0.6528447270393372, -0.4985772967338562, 0.5179661512374878, 0.34796279668807983, 0.5548290014266968, 0.6735379099845886, 0.22632794082164764, 0.35648512840270996, 0.3632158637046814, 0.10938205569982529, -0.8426980376243591, 0.06284341961145401, -0.35145050287246704, -0.316438227891922, -0.48115426301956177, -0.22589056193828583, 0.5593133568763733, 0.661476194858551, -0.12553875148296356, 0.23832736909389496, 0.27662497758865356, 0.9821121096611023, -0.87131667137146, 0.6356025338172913, -0.6414982676506042, 0.107928067445755, 0.16083571314811707, -0.6645361185073853, -0.3026736378669739, -0.38446763157844543, -0.09829046577215195, -1.0048242807388306, 0.33629173040390015, 0.19452473521232605, 0.6663395166397095, 0.3910962641239166, 0.012548796832561493, -0.29032036662101746, -0.7637977600097656, 1.1835054159164429, -0.22696352005004883, 0.5718615651130676, 0.20564576983451843, 0.30098164081573486, -0.24668101966381073, -1.1234157085418701, -0.1941966563463211, -0.3704451620578766, -0.08195369690656662, -0.01996137574315071, -0.404691219329834, 0.1476515680551529, 0.07250743359327316, 0.5451425909996033, -0.5501580238342285, -0.14907081425189972, -0.796861469745636, -0.31614139676094055, 0.5210950970649719, -0.05020342394709587, 0.2915244400501251, 0.3992822468280792, -0.20586861670017242, 0.10440928488969803, -0.9167842268943787, 0.040728941559791565, 0.26282405853271484, 0.16037000715732574, 0.037908900529146194, 0.1026616320014, -0.04626477137207985, 0.3222043812274933, 0.1790369749069214, -0.19203360378742218, 0.298973947763443, 0.08436160534620285, -0.5552743673324585, -0.3646511733531952, 0.1878332793712616, 0.2756328284740448, 0.48799383640289307, -0.5041500926017761, -0.3048519492149353, -0.23712711036205292, 0.39079925417900085, -0.6324467658996582, -0.5025960206985474, 0.506331205368042, -0.37610381841659546, -0.22150754928588867, -0.18528206646442413, -0.38347241282463074, -0.23461191356182098, -0.8960612416267395, 0.0986584946513176, -0.5299743413925171, 0.19978341460227966, -0.05265183374285698, 0.07862194627523422, 0.4307122230529785, 0.46968117356300354, -0.8937860727310181, 0.1290847361087799, 0.9325605630874634, 0.5878990292549133, -0.23607853055000305, -0.3802890479564667, -0.7950562834739685, 0.14453479647636414, -0.6904606819152832, 0.5782777070999146, -0.47714293003082275, -0.4231421649456024, 0.09360455721616745, -0.0020169250201433897, 0.2209305316209793, -0.8219892978668213, 0.22621992230415344, -0.7240138649940491, -0.14200443029403687, 0.001442856271751225, -0.33289459347724915, -0.16441793739795685, 0.26111656427383423, -0.6554096937179565, 0.6669957041740417, 0.3983823359012604, -0.5553260445594788, 0.35030922293663025, -0.40463659167289734, -0.2833935022354126, -0.01741396263241768, -0.43089714646339417, -0.32385432720184326, 0.2448119819164276, 0.031128132715821266, 0.035379890352487564, -0.011423967778682709, 0.2894192337989807, -0.1308218389749527, -0.6915613412857056, -0.042384110391139984, 0.047636259347200394, 0.4759007394313812, 0.35950765013694763, -0.18784473836421967, 0.5546556115150452, -0.7594878077507019, 0.10068084299564362, -0.47418922185897827, -0.613041877746582, -0.036210812628269196, -0.19955556094646454, -0.10194236040115356, -0.11861873418092728, 0.15902835130691528, -0.19917695224285126, 0.2948215901851654, -0.21281246840953827, 0.0411502905189991, 0.9476262331008911, -0.057774100452661514, 0.7993355989456177, -0.6183425784111023, 0.8287762403488159, -0.1706213653087616, -0.02377542480826378, -0.21898221969604492, -0.29199472069740295, -0.8071185350418091, -0.5666811466217041, 0.31970566511154175, 0.48750603199005127, -0.8503580689430237, -0.04501097649335861, -0.20724891126155853, -0.38568171858787537, -0.27891862392425537, 0.30027246475219727, 0.47887396812438965, 0.3993231952190399, 0.5592731833457947, -0.18733642995357513, -0.48776009678840637, -0.8736900091171265, -0.4349978566169739, -0.1847490519285202, -0.2047535628080368, 0.2951306402683258, 0.3024607002735138, -0.4990297555923462, 0.8590068817138672, -0.4711754620075226, -0.1855114847421646, -0.10957136750221252, 0.3410245478153229, -0.14317475259304047, 0.5572301745414734, 0.29044634103775024, -0.48207342624664307, -0.48070621490478516, 0.15901124477386475, -0.6824891567230225, -0.21764284372329712, -0.23964343965053558, -0.053744878619909286, 0.2752956449985504, 0.9468247294425964, 0.021939018741250038, 0.4709087610244751, 0.4407461881637573, 0.20269973576068878, 0.8316752314567566, -0.30648332834243774, 0.18177150189876556, -0.6006999611854553, 0.3650783598423004, -0.17432375252246857, 0.06772886216640472, -0.4528648555278778, 0.6103637218475342, -0.003952350467443466, -0.056853894144296646, -0.3970802128314972, 0.8581095337867737, -0.5641691088676453, -0.06869718432426453, -0.225515678524971, -0.07592090219259262, -0.24359841644763947, 0.6970120668411255, -0.20717273652553558, 0.64750075340271, 0.8150048851966858, -0.6850233674049377, 0.23455072939395905, -0.35905614495277405, -0.36624231934547424, 0.19397777318954468, -0.6286861300468445, 0.12413289397954941, -0.3638284504413605, 0.0885143056511879, -1.034958839416504, -0.2730013430118561, 0.2563651502132416, -0.19789424538612366, 0.49790287017822266, -0.44023147225379944, 0.1733579933643341, 0.048123542219400406, -0.48258504271507263, 0.39880791306495667, 0.5030402541160583, -0.650859534740448, 0.8938425183296204, 0.19426262378692627, -0.11017508804798126, -1.2738349437713623, -0.7753199338912964, -0.3979485034942627, -0.1191544383764267, -0.5810815691947937, 0.6215864419937134, -0.19046621024608612, -0.5472257733345032, -0.07511673122644424, -0.3281458616256714, -0.13351833820343018, 0.028565507382154465, 0.43965858221054077, 0.22205352783203125, -0.04565016180276871, 0.4272705912590027, 0.09362760931253433, -0.08750982582569122, -0.27557915449142456, -0.4966624081134796, 0.3282199800014496, -0.4263588488101959, -0.3372855484485626, -0.138933464884758, 0.037622079253196716, 0.5767433047294617, -0.18744304776191711, 0.3020777702331543, 0.6293774247169495, -0.2433808445930481, -0.8185728788375854, -0.16855914890766144, -0.008440863341093063, -0.5631083846092224, 0.34951817989349365, -0.21806953847408295, -1.064543604850769, 0.6919706463813782, -0.2550111413002014, 0.6563535928726196, -0.04966803640127182, 0.4282572269439697, 0.44069981575012207, 0.2455688714981079, 0.8762226104736328, 0.023908229544758797, 0.44003990292549133, -0.4005439877510071, 0.27566710114479065, -0.6024683713912964, -0.3932039141654968, -0.3225668668746948, -0.625316858291626, -0.8510690331459045, -0.7480000257492065, -0.05734805762767792, 0.21606537699699402, -0.25976094603538513, 0.00261231348849833, -0.42016491293907166, 0.9663496613502502, 0.6100383996963501, -0.20770297944545746, 0.5003155469894409, 0.5087834596633911, -0.195463165640831, 0.08194097876548767, -0.2130248099565506, -0.3684404790401459, 1.3295845985412598, 0.2823673188686371, 1.0918447971343994, 0.048085205256938934, 1.0468581914901733, 0.3775373101234436, 1.004272699356079, -0.9166060090065002, 0.49781057238578796, -0.2167864739894867, -0.22260195016860962, -0.11830009520053864, -0.47081491351127625, -1.0066179037094116, -0.036023952066898346, 0.21039077639579773, -0.7698387503623962, 0.19642780721187592, 0.47606009244918823, -0.47117260098457336, 0.14304675161838531, -0.4975029528141022, 0.5431724786758423, 0.21546728909015656, -0.8225462436676025, -0.3805074393749237, -0.07769130915403366, 0.6765521168708801, -0.25743478536605835, 0.37567606568336487, 0.11957331001758575, -0.08343414962291718, 0.28838858008384705, -0.11797651648521423, 0.5639806389808655, 0.04473133757710457, -0.3634219765663147, 0.4509344696998596, 0.6081418991088867, 0.1693989336490631, 0.1287776529788971, -0.03295702859759331, -0.09094147384166718, -0.206313356757164, -0.2551884353160858, -0.7609460353851318, 1.122635006904602, -0.6097707152366638, -0.6179051399230957, -0.3049885332584381, -0.7121618390083313, -0.27542373538017273, -0.10172533243894577, -0.023137252777814865, 0.7397681474685669, -0.39040741324424744, 0.13366802036762238, 0.47281092405319214, -0.4097376763820648, 0.3392482399940491, 0.3664993941783905, -0.6573152542114258, -0.2984195947647095, 1.0145313739776611, -0.08678846061229706, 0.019023237749934196, 0.40146487951278687, -0.06711805611848831, -0.08213680982589722, -0.5791824460029602, 0.034018125385046005, 0.07072179019451141, -0.8578628897666931, -0.06661295145750046, -0.19388191401958466, -0.005142885260283947, -0.09052415192127228, -0.5118419528007507, -0.16168057918548584, -0.7361072897911072, -0.07842705398797989, -0.06591999530792236, -0.15755458176136017, 0.5954452753067017, -0.45449429750442505, 0.11815059930086136, -0.5359398126602173, 0.26489654183387756, 0.5887711048126221, 0.4987807869911194, 0.1418018341064453, -0.4873534142971039, -0.21817171573638916, -0.186529740691185, -0.67592453956604, -0.28126800060272217, 0.47889021039009094, 0.36095693707466125, 0.5153920650482178, 0.403947114944458, -0.20123954117298126, 0.5182804465293884, -0.5225356221199036, 0.6306611895561218, 0.03309033438563347, -0.8980948328971863, 0.08351195603609085, -0.3174022138118744, 0.3510231077671051, 0.5348569750785828, 0.4523589611053467, -0.37921109795570374, -0.33705905079841614, -0.6003444194793701, -0.8230821490287781, 0.27234315872192383, -0.08714866638183594, 0.025003401562571526, 0.051954224705696106, 0.38151493668556213, -0.018450872972607613, 0.31897005438804626, -0.5604423880577087, -0.2486674040555954, 0.01595490612089634, 0.01814819872379303, 0.06300089508295059, 0.04024084657430649, -0.25462546944618225, -0.30777308344841003, 0.6321079730987549, -0.288587749004364, 0.20486342906951904, -0.1456821858882904, -0.08871156722307205, -0.12211690098047256, 0.4644908905029297, 0.6880561113357544, 1.0599682331085205, -0.23064514994621277, 0.19092786312103271, -0.17013971507549286, -0.24730396270751953, -0.0009509083465673029, -0.1412988305091858, -0.04784652963280678, -0.13911816477775574, 0.38012978434562683, 0.210129052400589, 0.29357677698135376, -0.7664529085159302, 0.19680173695087433, 0.05008889362215996, -0.1717129945755005, -0.23955246806144714, 0.19825367629528046, 0.09873086214065552, 0.22070559859275818, 0.3719896674156189, 0.3022521436214447, 0.18694975972175598, -0.8792504072189331, 0.6091002225875854, 0.37512582540512085, -0.32149067521095276, -0.30087873339653015, 0.5405799746513367, 0.2368142157793045, -0.18314899504184723, 0.8034834265708923, -0.6029113531112671, -0.2207631915807724, 0.4801921844482422, 0.4223584830760956, 1.1906399726867676, -0.15523692965507507, 0.2990691363811493, 0.6577599048614502, 0.12560060620307922, 0.08922292292118073, 0.19877620041370392, -0.04072272405028343, -0.5942267775535583, -0.537960946559906, -0.8418666124343872, -0.30578193068504333, 0.3014751076698303, -0.3771096169948578, 0.1820228546857834, -0.9234573245048523, 0.09879324585199356, -0.1566249281167984, -0.14922137558460236, -0.4859717786312103, -0.033765025436878204, 0.013167948462069035, 0.9086822271347046, -0.5769844055175781, 0.6877907514572144, 0.4347338080406189, -0.2887209355831146, -0.8703617453575134, 0.07998218387365341, 0.1875331848859787, -0.8131171464920044, 0.8983434438705444, 0.034000106155872345, -0.36378777027130127, -0.07110440731048584, -0.7506123185157776, -0.5437412858009338, 1.1191469430923462, 0.4495387375354767, -0.4811932444572449, -0.09506266564130783, -0.07189738005399704, 0.6535829305648804, -0.47509580850601196, 0.042113691568374634, 0.5689547657966614, 0.2926695942878723, 0.3874891400337219, -0.7949996590614319, -0.10242033749818802, -0.21293766796588898, -0.12505728006362915, 0.035067059099674225, -0.4181690514087677, 0.9729840755462646, -0.5760443806648254, -0.41432005167007446, 0.270503968000412, 0.8310222625732422, 0.44710883498191833, 0.32287171483039856, -0.04237335920333862, 0.47226276993751526, 1.0742173194885254, -0.12395425140857697, 1.022371530532837, -0.45976006984710693, 0.31795236468315125, 1.2681344747543335, 0.12363149970769882, 0.6696058511734009, 0.4269978702068329, 0.08720224350690842, 0.9161382913589478, 0.1796020269393921, -0.06862471997737885, 0.49606820940971375, 0.7881104946136475, -0.4417303204536438, -0.17282527685165405, 0.22160643339157104, -0.20266112685203552, 0.19653649628162384, 0.3683967590332031, -0.4174741804599762, -0.4201385974884033, -0.2840474843978882, 0.03288184478878975, -0.002102568279951811, -0.5798894166946411, 0.21204212307929993, 0.16656675934791565, -0.905344545841217, 0.8767079710960388, 0.19116716086864471, 0.5466138124465942, -0.6218602061271667, -0.15206050872802734, -0.6316270232200623, 0.649280846118927, -0.47627806663513184, -0.5090072154998779, 0.4753571152687073, -0.27990424633026123, 0.09501450508832932, -0.17125369608402252, 0.5927403569221497, -0.600340723991394, -0.210257887840271, 0.051841288805007935, 0.5191544890403748, 0.08623432368040085, 0.04586907848715782, -0.6942487359046936, 0.1831955760717392, 0.372537761926651, 0.01990712806582451, 0.43231889605522156, 0.15548861026763916, -0.07673893868923187, 1.1044343709945679, 0.5718634724617004, -0.15530073642730713, 0.03765787556767464, 0.0031286594457924366, 0.7802640795707703, -0.2032138556241989, -0.2746902108192444, -0.44208335876464844, 0.6062318086624146, 0.1322094053030014, -0.16294719278812408, 0.7568040490150452, 0.7429438233375549, 0.9669548273086548, -0.4208924472332001, 0.7491765022277832, 0.18494722247123718, 0.04397765174508095, -0.39014559984207153, 0.6223609447479248, -0.46263694763183594, 0.649096667766571, -0.11086845397949219, -1.0032340288162231, -0.6551282405853271, 0.6069650650024414, -0.3495115637779236, 0.19351933896541595, 0.5805661082267761, 1.3377312421798706, -0.26852819323539734, -0.1270936280488968, 0.1791297048330307, -0.1162140890955925, 0.5014121532440186, 0.4497160017490387, 0.7155701518058777, -0.22715258598327637, 0.41957202553749084, -0.12867522239685059, -0.6109605431556702, 0.023146996274590492, -1.024765968322754, -0.7740767598152161, -0.44425541162490845, -0.7672707438468933, -0.4188741147518158, 0.014992324635386467, 0.8221457600593567, 0.5375656485557556, -0.8659900426864624, -0.5135594606399536, -0.23569254577159882, 0.2012406438589096, -0.3644997477531433, -0.25572699308395386, 0.4575037360191345, -0.7211794257164001, -0.7773359417915344, 0.4188123345375061, 0.3894558250904083, -0.11832761764526367, -0.1681021898984909, -0.29176658391952515, 0.2366623729467392, 0.34569844603538513, 0.5737035274505615, 1.0112053155899048, -0.5313701629638672, -0.34363436698913574, 0.030837740749120712, 0.10957730561494827, -0.03713769093155861, 1.065601110458374, -0.971477210521698, 0.4246993362903595, 0.5588061213493347, 0.49541687965393066, 0.19024570286273956, 0.13389937579631805, 0.5812296271324158, -1.056998610496521, 0.002381575759500265, 0.03557408228516579, 0.3795575797557831, 0.246067613363266, 0.16623835265636444, 0.516551673412323, 0.13877376914024353, -0.6917170286178589, -0.5854582786560059, 0.3865502178668976, -0.823601484298706, -0.4527418315410614, 1.1275662183761597, -0.2671363055706024, -0.2369445413351059, -0.23474854230880737, -0.17765742540359497, 0.004426074214279652, -0.21499696373939514, 1.070483922958374, 0.3671901822090149, -0.20809024572372437, 0.004163818433880806, -0.05814903974533081, 0.9626407027244568, -0.1376974880695343, -0.6485604643821716, 0.44606685638427734, 0.6236863732337952, 0.5374144315719604, 0.5172841548919678, 0.6884471774101257, -0.2356453686952591, 0.4169832468032837, 0.03524606302380562, -0.0001590672618476674, -0.4598080515861511, -0.6406717300415039, -0.20748840272426605, 0.33703407645225525, 0.13696178793907166, 0.06184336170554161 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16405v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16405v2	Scaling Sparse Fine-Tuning to Large Language Models	2024-01-29T18:43:49	2024-02-02T14:53:14	Alan Ansell, Ivan Vulić, Hannah Sterz, Anna Korhonen, Edoardo M. Ponti	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG	Large Language Models (LLMs) are difficult to fully fine-tune (e.g., with instructions or human feedback) due to their sheer number of parameters. A family of parameter-efficient sparse fine-tuning methods have proven promising in terms of performance but their memory requirements increase proportionally to the size of the LLMs. In this work, we scale sparse fine-tuning to state-of-the-art LLMs like LLaMA 2 7B and 13B. We propose SpIEL, a novel sparse fine-tuning method which, for a desired density level, maintains an array of parameter indices and the deltas of these parameters relative to their pretrained values. It iterates over: (a) updating the active deltas, (b) pruning indices (based on the change of magnitude of their deltas) and (c) regrowth of indices. For regrowth, we explore two criteria based on either the accumulated gradients of a few candidate parameters or their approximate momenta estimated using the efficient SM3 optimizer. We experiment with instruction-tuning of LLMs on standard dataset mixtures, finding that SpIEL is often superior to popular parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods like LoRA (low-rank adaptation) in terms of performance and comparable in terms of run time. We additionally show that SpIEL is compatible with both quantization and efficient optimizers, to facilitate scaling to ever-larger model sizes. We release the code for SpIEL at https://github.com/AlanAnsell/peft and for the instruction-tuning experiments at https://github.com/ducdauge/sft-llm.	[ -0.44235727190971375, -0.9273166656494141, 0.3626087009906769, 0.6119613647460938, -0.35831987857818604, -0.2490023821592331, -0.6796860098838806, -0.17258308827877045, 0.21423251926898956, 0.5434818267822266, -0.5106585621833801, -0.40580883622169495, -0.7650084495544434, -0.016212288290262222, -0.3485099971294403, 1.180455207824707, -0.03869221359491348, -0.04952281340956688, 0.272169291973114, -0.3326450288295746, -0.27866414189338684, 0.08423546701669693, -0.792910635471344, -0.026110103353857994, 0.9262439608573914, 0.5273398756980896, 0.6783677339553833, 1.2508445978164673, 0.1667914241552353, 0.25223246216773987, -0.3137153089046478, 0.37322646379470825, -1.0170040130615234, 0.14116112887859344, 0.0036465057637542486, -0.18683212995529175, -0.5485270023345947, -0.29636120796203613, 1.0025690793991089, 0.7687510848045349, -0.352297306060791, 0.3524818420410156, 0.2119511067867279, 0.5433121919631958, -0.6042640209197998, 0.12814469635486603, -0.8250298500061035, -0.3146255612373352, -0.2214186191558838, -0.4847787618637085, -0.2570170760154724, -0.3270922005176544, 0.0018153948476538062, -0.6994118690490723, 0.20273450016975403, 0.07816939800977707, 0.8270475268363953, 0.7046002149581909, -0.23242969810962677, -0.2429221123456955, -0.5284758806228638, 1.03606379032135, -0.6748983263969421, 0.2942301630973816, 0.250818133354187, 0.09278476983308792, -0.3922964036464691, -0.6335576772689819, -0.13461878895759583, -0.3475835621356964, 0.11193671077489853, -0.416934072971344, -0.07914556562900543, 0.2639476954936981, 0.30308997631073, 0.4499882161617279, -0.374080091714859, 0.20551612973213196, -0.3485736846923828, -0.23156607151031494, 0.6907138228416443, 0.07263059914112091, 0.03475804254412651, 0.5361763834953308, -0.2041371762752533, -0.016326794400811195, -0.9285485744476318, -0.3023354709148407, 0.36153772473335266, 0.541111946105957, 0.11208681762218475, 0.40848371386528015, -0.09391118586063385, 0.7335431575775146, 0.44838955998420715, -0.2865510880947113, -0.020290110260248184, 0.08268705755472183, -0.1594388782978058, 0.16784444451332092, 0.3888227939605713, 0.320568710565567, 0.20986460149288177, -0.11622726172208786, -0.3582135736942291, -0.1485091745853424, 0.09052137285470963, -1.1759669780731201, -0.2551952302455902, 0.03648955374956131, -0.15986880660057068, -0.1017095297574997, -0.4926961064338684, -0.7331082820892334, -0.49395057559013367, -0.3415416181087494, 0.9539294838905334, -0.48950856924057007, -0.2010662704706192, 0.3698081970214844, 0.2757960557937622, 0.15196077525615692, 0.635921835899353, -1.1364433765411377, 0.34576699137687683, 0.770897626876831, 0.7376899719238281, -0.04816479608416557, -0.6050964593887329, -0.8101713061332703, 0.08438804000616074, -0.4113825261592865, 0.7823154330253601, -0.2983393669128418, -0.06591179221868515, -0.25829458236694336, 0.10413412004709244, -0.16946622729301453, -0.6987242698669434, 0.38483744859695435, -0.1830769181251526, -0.6074004173278809, -0.17676809430122375, -0.5398626327514648, 0.04386201500892639, -0.06866740435361862, -0.6442443132400513, 1.2417370080947876, 0.07872361689805984, -0.5574747920036316, 0.47147101163864136, -0.15966711938381195, -0.5229543447494507, -0.0837479904294014, 0.07698255777359009, -0.5050249695777893, 0.3502255380153656, -0.033479273319244385, 0.7262996435165405, -0.3286764621734619, 0.2718064486980438, -0.40684330463409424, -0.8564291596412659, -0.02259034477174282, -0.4355499744415283, 0.3769616186618805, 0.23800884187221527, -0.28799301385879517, 0.25437575578689575, -0.9967747330665588, -0.056497734040021896, -0.10342812538146973, -0.3995708227157593, -0.07948948442935944, 0.15206415951251984, -0.17031937837600708, -0.42381659150123596, 0.6037858128547668, -0.3339969217777252, 0.07604245841503143, -0.5167219042778015, 0.6493251323699951, 0.8953947424888611, -0.023914972320199013, 0.667389988899231, -0.3817821741104126, 0.09541084617376328, -0.21650971472263336, 0.013801275752484798, -0.14414997398853302, -0.12638217210769653, -1.0660208463668823, -0.8849839568138123, 0.32279202342033386, 0.1887492537498474, -0.10615728795528412, 0.39240747690200806, -0.16960828006267548, -0.5778964161872864, -0.624427080154419, 0.2632543742656708, -0.11187402158975601, -0.0805661603808403, 0.29273658990859985, 0.15598271787166595, -0.15419137477874756, -0.8848847150802612, -0.11705432832241058, 0.13196110725402832, -0.054092928767204285, 0.450012743473053, 0.23452939093112946, -0.15750214457511902, 0.5525108575820923, -0.49423426389694214, -0.0546979084610939, -0.13443110883235931, 0.12007001042366028, 0.06085874140262604, 0.6150196194648743, 0.5757244229316711, -0.2513852119445801, -0.5692916512489319, 0.2424498051404953, 0.01596112735569477, -0.32648029923439026, -0.048311997205019, -0.037074845284223557, -0.020243247970938683, 0.4602382779121399, -0.3103078305721283, 0.06508037447929382, 0.5369191765785217, -0.14438535273075104, 0.29462361335754395, -0.6134830713272095, -0.03917935863137245, -0.990941047668457, -0.042611896991729736, 0.16813217103481293, -0.22728049755096436, -0.5585868954658508, 0.1806228905916214, 0.21639621257781982, 0.01577908731997013, -0.15826253592967987, 0.5559735298156738, -0.27997997403144836, -0.00949819665402174, -0.21140636503696442, -0.13580848276615143, -0.24935778975486755, 0.6265613436698914, -0.1873309463262558, 0.8956078290939331, 0.752940833568573, -0.5134663581848145, 0.04872581735253334, -0.3717515170574188, -0.33093246817588806, 0.2839865982532501, -0.6885697841644287, -0.06808879226446152, -0.20178672671318054, 0.12591107189655304, -0.9790080189704895, -0.2450234591960907, -0.03661223500967026, -0.0777716264128685, 0.4982118308544159, -0.20033353567123413, -0.6696568131446838, 0.351502388715744, -0.31234225630760193, 0.17493219673633575, 0.1086045578122139, -0.5363271236419678, 0.5980733633041382, 0.2994251549243927, -0.48303458094596863, -0.4062381386756897, -0.37262025475502014, -0.17783154547214508, -0.5717350244522095, -0.5422165393829346, 0.13249994814395905, -0.22265198826789856, -0.0387050062417984, -0.3978845775127411, -0.31175461411476135, -0.20434078574180603, 0.2316073477268219, 0.07958316057920456, -0.09859567135572433, -0.44841888546943665, -0.08017922192811966, 0.5554128885269165, -0.13087525963783264, -0.407685786485672, -0.16830046474933624, 0.5141109824180603, -0.31122493743896484, 0.05550196394324303, -0.3285039961338043, 0.32663121819496155, 0.784946084022522, -0.237059086561203, 0.8257903456687927, 0.6200524568557739, -0.29434922337532043, -0.7768116593360901, -0.550912082195282, -0.2602592408657074, -0.49333512783050537, 0.6104438900947571, -0.38428887724876404, -1.2627742290496826, 0.5422531962394714, -0.535373866558075, 0.17643344402313232, 0.29806339740753174, 0.746764063835144, 0.17159494757652283, 1.1122233867645264, 0.8759094476699829, 0.02085467241704464, 0.3628803789615631, -0.23830677568912506, 0.16279691457748413, -0.43366342782974243, 0.25666671991348267, -0.5926332473754883, -0.4223968982696533, -0.5989375114440918, -0.5567623376846313, 0.32554730772972107, 0.3685072064399719, -0.4977896809577942, 0.48655879497528076, -0.4184992015361786, 0.6575014591217041, 0.15787793695926666, -0.003184125293046236, 0.110528364777565, 0.23949484527111053, 0.10331424325704575, -0.025611512362957, -0.7892464995384216, -0.3133324086666107, 0.785355806350708, 0.599224865436554, 0.9131751656532288, -0.09653878211975098, 0.6086373925209045, -0.09075930714607239, 0.22952082753181458, -0.7701924443244934, 0.6004352569580078, -0.546457827091217, -0.34212926030158997, -0.6357651948928833, -0.57855623960495, -0.7261559963226318, 0.2888928949832916, -0.1868818998336792, -0.7897362112998962, 0.17788729071617126, 0.1785472333431244, -0.705496609210968, 0.08069242537021637, -0.8465642333030701, 0.8418030738830566, -0.04208262637257576, -0.5569322109222412, -0.6029033660888672, -0.4492531418800354, 0.006263617891818285, -0.2917235791683197, -0.10406985133886337, -0.41977614164352417, -0.16804452240467072, 0.4400235116481781, -0.4563729763031006, 0.7726672887802124, -0.055173199623823166, -0.4993589222431183, -0.04451541602611542, 0.28479769825935364, 0.6633427739143372, 0.3118740916252136, -0.19007615745067596, 0.18198831379413605, 0.5247139930725098, -0.43973496556282043, -0.6677101850509644, 1.1656509637832642, -0.9769772887229919, -0.35898593068122864, -0.14834465086460114, -0.8442589044570923, -0.22933606803417206, 0.012159421108663082, -0.05590110272169113, 0.495790034532547, 0.1050671935081482, 0.3282022476196289, 0.9540849924087524, -0.3505704402923584, -0.04676775634288788, 0.7827692031860352, 0.15391013026237488, -0.33486494421958923, 1.3860461711883545, 0.40645861625671387, 0.3054330050945282, 0.25991734862327576, 0.20038443803787231, -0.06746979802846909, -0.6918202638626099, -0.762614905834198, 0.4313756227493286, -0.2887135148048401, -0.30078819394111633, -0.31671661138534546, -0.1944572627544403, -0.031212322413921356, -0.34233707189559937, -0.5886082649230957, -0.4169413447380066, -0.45557987689971924, 0.1357838213443756, 0.6785885691642761, 0.531004786491394, -0.10890091210603714, 0.6048434376716614, -0.3253440260887146, 0.045701269060373306, 0.16780294477939606, 0.6614845991134644, 0.000994482426904142, -0.7137073874473572, -0.4247550964355469, -0.08930706977844238, 0.042014677077531815, -0.47176647186279297, 0.2768380343914032, 0.5542583465576172, 0.2627319097518921, 0.43054285645484924, -0.1501302421092987, 1.1611998081207275, -0.5958517789840698, 0.3638271391391754, -0.2907666862010956, -0.7050549387931824, 0.25621137022972107, -0.4664542078971863, -0.05703142657876015, 0.6608969569206238, 0.17173486948013306, -0.08893488347530365, -0.5224630236625671, -0.2682608366012573, -0.9191768169403076, 0.8438799381256104, -0.10566527396440506, 0.23266130685806274, 0.08343137800693512, 0.6692469716072083, 0.30132970213890076, 0.056019026786088943, -0.40520334243774414, -0.29646989703178406, 0.14762726426124573, -0.3068595230579376, -0.27253231406211853, -0.4645664691925049, -0.04878068342804909, -0.29381075501441956, 0.6768428683280945, -0.20130757987499237, -0.09571345150470734, -0.25019416213035583, -0.0828230082988739, -0.5077077150344849, 0.16349798440933228, 0.6947360038757324, 0.46797409653663635, -0.38123220205307007, 0.14968359470367432, 0.5741817355155945, -0.4671054780483246, 0.09454895555973053, 0.3307482600212097, -0.094007708132267, -0.37636902928352356, 0.04266197606921196, 0.9704718589782715, 0.5962627530097961, -0.7655222415924072, 0.3988458514213562, -0.050936587154865265, -0.30640581250190735, 0.04441282898187637, 0.3306722640991211, 0.04022923484444618, 0.47718730568885803, 0.27275052666664124, 0.02661011554300785, -0.1301703006029129, -0.27829840779304504, 0.24830369651317596, 0.1440366953611374, -0.1642511934041977, -0.24321678280830383, 0.4797017574310303, -0.022323671728372574, 0.025308432057499886, 0.03943578153848648, -0.13806699216365814, 0.06920670717954636, 0.40222999453544617, 0.7677194476127625, 0.4983704388141632, -0.1251564919948578, 0.06352308392524719, 0.4488043785095215, 0.36778974533081055, -0.47518351674079895, 0.11492414772510529, -0.18369442224502563, -0.5422044992446899, -0.7316775918006897, -1.1590907573699951, 0.010550271719694138, 0.31156831979751587, -0.43375518918037415, 0.26432880759239197, -0.7916014790534973, 0.1822660267353058, 0.016082022339105606, 0.40222975611686707, -0.098136767745018, 0.01670883409678936, -0.096924789249897, 1.1033785343170166, -0.8216604590415955, 1.0316742658615112, 0.5604093074798584, -0.08051149547100067, -0.9843870401382446, -0.021310649812221527, -0.32334861159324646, -0.694709837436676, 0.2668516933917999, -0.02638104557991028, -0.14531299471855164, 0.5294466614723206, -0.43503329157829285, -1.0225751399993896, 1.1046391725540161, 0.9497880339622498, -0.7864759564399719, 0.2100709229707718, 0.05660233274102211, 0.5050069093704224, -0.08169423043727875, -0.05742385983467102, 0.8763505220413208, 0.2657845914363861, 0.19560547173023224, -0.9878514409065247, -0.07928206771612167, 0.08039052039384842, -0.01497261319309473, 0.5870683193206787, -0.9655215740203857, 0.9434804320335388, 0.027324773371219635, -0.1900450438261032, 0.5378930568695068, 0.7839378714561462, 0.380835622549057, 0.021767374128103256, 0.615632951259613, 0.7476161122322083, 0.7841198444366455, 0.03641979768872261, 0.44552507996559143, -0.6760180592536926, 0.4967306852340698, 0.8345636129379272, -0.3758692145347595, 0.8688827157020569, 0.5064656734466553, -0.03539060428738594, 0.025148088112473488, 0.6622998118400574, 0.18735474348068237, 0.4039001166820526, 0.4849736988544464, -0.4060952365398407, -0.3454812169075012, 0.006479203235358, -0.21921131014823914, 0.15469063818454742, 0.6062055230140686, -0.07289233058691025, -0.3951455354690552, -0.23075348138809204, 0.03835562244057655, -0.06308525800704956, -0.6823566555976868, 0.6564294695854187, 0.02692633680999279, -0.45781150460243225, 0.8705267310142517, 0.3339957892894745, 0.5334882140159607, -0.7501189112663269, -0.017457112669944763, -0.460103839635849, 0.35088443756103516, -0.01760648377239704, -0.33283618092536926, 0.19465555250644684, 0.1304970383644104, -0.034837014973163605, -0.15579107403755188, 0.6766909956932068, -0.6824700236320496, -0.4702538847923279, 0.11453265696763992, 0.12421873211860657, 0.19221782684326172, 0.005548412445932627, -0.5732181072235107, 0.4441024959087372, -0.029604585841298103, -0.0947885513305664, 0.675676167011261, 0.8356251120567322, -0.061695583164691925, 0.6764734387397766, 0.4063020944595337, 0.5422372221946716, 0.3071853518486023, 0.029562346637248993, 0.8680035471916199, -0.3266746699810028, -0.34108972549438477, -0.6995335221290588, 0.055637337267398834, 0.37517842650413513, -0.3275611996650696, 0.6757490634918213, 0.6153924465179443, 0.5754884481430054, 0.16301773488521576, 0.2828420400619507, 0.19024589657783508, 0.5129223465919495, -0.3412696123123169, 0.7203601598739624, -0.7381793856620789, 0.2630551755428314, -0.08839606493711472, -0.9722689986228943, -0.4268035888671875, 0.8717931509017944, -0.15235359966754913, -0.22618368268013, 0.2142467200756073, 1.4696348905563354, -0.2604541480541229, -0.17355138063430786, 0.44680678844451904, 0.5438916087150574, -0.23275309801101685, 0.3608475923538208, 0.6681841015815735, -0.21560685336589813, 0.42517682909965515, -0.027584705501794815, -0.40236130356788635, -0.29111695289611816, -0.6491292119026184, -0.7095432281494141, -0.47205236554145813, -0.20031596720218658, -0.1918075829744339, 0.31643015146255493, 1.0236735343933105, 0.7817937731742859, -0.7407417297363281, -0.32006630301475525, -0.06577294319868088, -0.2636343538761139, -0.25431790947914124, -0.18935461342334747, 0.40593063831329346, -0.4500029981136322, -0.6879317760467529, 0.4916223883628845, 0.5976837873458862, -0.1885063648223877, -0.45619556307792664, -0.2065121978521347, 0.12889426946640015, 0.33616453409194946, 0.5625258088111877, 0.16832923889160156, -0.5544115304946899, -0.4652262330055237, -0.17363426089286804, -0.1284731775522232, -0.2017515003681183, 0.6529533267021179, -0.31650227308273315, 0.0787016898393631, 0.28396284580230713, 0.7006881237030029, 0.6453198790550232, -0.2732420265674591, 0.6065601110458374, -0.8633888363838196, 0.2712464928627014, -0.022280555218458176, 0.23064732551574707, 0.11469002068042755, -0.18731138110160828, 0.15112704038619995, -0.12199677526950836, -0.7768324017524719, -1.0135544538497925, 0.07814621925354004, -0.9475072622299194, -0.22206437587738037, 1.163952350616455, 0.04281122609972954, -0.32937178015708923, 0.25640949606895447, -0.5398783683776855, 0.15667502582073212, -0.4493776559829712, 0.708984375, 0.4279971718788147, 0.1717950403690338, -0.2150387316942215, -0.6547662019729614, 0.6650367379188538, 0.5748604536056519, -0.27850183844566345, 0.40959522128105164, 0.47107285261154175, 0.5155340433120728, -0.3409116268157959, 0.545881986618042, 0.25944289565086365, 0.16167476773262024, -0.029799453914165497, -0.3726918697357178, 0.14472515881061554, -0.6028627753257751, -0.4494333267211914, 0.1390129029750824, 0.390529602766037, 0.2285851240158081 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16403v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16403v2	ViLexNorm: A Lexical Normalization Corpus for Vietnamese Social Media Text	2024-01-29T18:41:39	2024-01-31T07:59:16	Thanh-Nhi Nguyen, Thanh-Phong Le, Kiet Van Nguyen	cs.CL	cs.CL	Lexical normalization, a fundamental task in Natural Language Processing (NLP), involves the transformation of words into their canonical forms. This process has been proven to benefit various downstream NLP tasks greatly. In this work, we introduce Vietnamese Lexical Normalization (ViLexNorm), the first-ever corpus developed for the Vietnamese lexical normalization task. The corpus comprises over 10,000 pairs of sentences meticulously annotated by human annotators, sourced from public comments on Vietnam's most popular social media platforms. Various methods were used to evaluate our corpus, and the best-performing system achieved a result of 57.74% using the Error Reduction Rate (ERR) metric (van der Goot, 2019a) with the Leave-As-Is (LAI) baseline. For extrinsic evaluation, employing the model trained on ViLexNorm demonstrates the positive impact of the Vietnamese lexical normalization task on other NLP tasks. Our corpus is publicly available exclusively for research purposes.	[ -0.20587101578712463, -0.6505157947540283, 0.30058974027633667, 0.23264066874980927, -0.547238826751709, -0.1600128412246704, -0.5191848874092102, -0.17431631684303284, 0.4452739357948303, 0.8285328149795532, 0.054233282804489136, -1.067314863204956, -0.8253887891769409, 0.25884056091308594, -0.4948378801345825, 1.116667628288269, 0.28395548462867737, -0.09095332771539688, 0.19496524333953857, -0.45256516337394714, -0.2271496057510376, -0.6481368541717529, -0.7543105483055115, 0.5078778862953186, 0.7680895924568176, 0.23854835331439972, 0.8058810234069824, 0.5882888436317444, 0.7130060791969299, 0.23643259704113007, -0.12541286647319794, 0.4165213406085968, -1.0882822275161743, -0.04551002010703087, -0.4465385675430298, -0.2555072009563446, -0.39604488015174866, -0.018502317368984222, 0.8736028671264648, 0.7078906893730164, 0.04111221432685852, 0.34952783584594727, 0.13492576777935028, 0.7511734962463379, -0.7625297904014587, -0.0042625791393220425, -0.7664642333984375, -0.34844890236854553, -0.1881706863641739, -0.0887487530708313, -0.01650385372340679, -0.6143277883529663, -0.07211233675479889, -0.5023084878921509, -0.058408088982105255, -0.37509119510650635, 0.852366030216217, 0.3043138086795807, -0.4434616267681122, -0.12123477458953857, -0.9544821977615356, 0.8700545430183411, -0.6715072393417358, 0.4129321277141571, 0.16740018129348755, 0.2811802923679352, 0.170889213681221, -0.6461818218231201, -0.3850827217102051, -0.06712033599615097, 0.047120191156864166, 0.16052454710006714, -0.5801577568054199, 0.16131319105625153, -0.17361171543598175, 0.1829776018857956, -0.6334716081619263, -0.05299242585897446, -0.8769094944000244, -0.18177521228790283, 0.648841917514801, -0.26036229729652405, 0.3647666275501251, -0.40162572264671326, -0.5672174692153931, 0.05768490210175514, -0.28538084030151367, -0.3318127989768982, 0.11548598855733871, 0.5111842751502991, -0.3036253750324249, 0.7184411883354187, -0.12347739934921265, 0.4645571708679199, -0.7346770763397217, -0.13713911175727844, 0.12485332041978836, -0.3172433078289032, -0.34037938714027405, 0.13700120151042938, 0.6949038505554199, 0.8646565675735474, 0.49111559987068176, -0.1520959585905075, -0.39141717553138733, 0.5137909650802612, 0.484062135219574, -0.34813863039016724, -0.12695305049419403, 0.17534878849983215, -0.4555129408836365, -0.34216606616973877, 0.28347304463386536, -0.48046866059303284, -0.21861803531646729, -0.592697262763977, 0.40738627314567566, -0.538333535194397, -0.38725316524505615, 0.10674993693828583, -0.08104769140481949, 0.013174072839319706, 0.4071289300918579, -0.34177929162979126, 0.47130507230758667, 1.01461660861969, 1.0501878261566162, -0.6796844601631165, -0.03604739531874657, -0.8383959531784058, 0.11315423250198364, -0.509166419506073, 0.8278643488883972, -0.1743638515472412, -0.3502121865749359, 0.32237786054611206, -0.049290817230939865, 0.005711214616894722, -0.8033894896507263, 0.9810099601745605, -0.37289711833000183, -0.20766818523406982, 0.07988687604665756, -0.5429835915565491, -0.3650939464569092, 0.2571784555912018, -0.6050453186035156, 0.8668009638786316, 0.4930651783943176, -0.6676379442214966, 0.09120900928974152, -0.361619770526886, 0.039559558033943176, 0.26268765330314636, 0.014257989823818207, -0.09598524123430252, 0.15946121513843536, -0.03905346244573593, 0.5923929214477539, -0.15852290391921997, 0.14737579226493835, -0.23350177705287933, -0.278341680765152, -0.04761170223355293, -0.20035044848918915, 0.9269771575927734, 0.3833743929862976, -0.10067135840654373, 0.25015708804130554, -0.8343901038169861, -0.19028215110301971, -0.16969622671604156, -0.14804014563560486, -0.785283088684082, -0.4429202973842621, 0.6000314354896545, 0.15695534646511078, 0.10403463989496231, -0.6423887610435486, -0.06856777518987656, -0.5719211101531982, 0.01393410935997963, 0.640159010887146, -0.0788494423031807, 0.5794802308082581, -0.5527248978614807, 0.3135262727737427, -0.1746332049369812, -0.05627550929784775, 0.13746999204158783, -0.6867700815200806, -0.6987259387969971, -0.4397757053375244, 0.12686970829963684, 0.649452269077301, -0.43731826543807983, 0.1796545833349228, -0.4583750069141388, -0.7771800756454468, -0.48441213369369507, 0.47112545371055603, 0.21920156478881836, 0.354051411151886, 0.509158194065094, 0.005966302007436752, -0.738078773021698, -0.8384503722190857, -0.30648666620254517, -0.2563733458518982, -0.22226862609386444, 0.05385412275791168, 0.04125579446554184, -0.9558664560317993, 0.807883083820343, -0.4325689971446991, -0.813794732093811, -0.27420830726623535, 0.18975825607776642, 0.14296190440654755, 0.2115575075149536, 0.6116235256195068, -0.7572710514068604, -0.4572019875049591, 0.13399985432624817, -0.5883023142814636, -0.5255027413368225, -0.06584789603948593, -0.2679699957370758, 0.48167818784713745, 0.7839037775993347, -0.07787693291902542, 0.44310101866722107, 0.5929139256477356, -0.1323549896478653, 0.5837864279747009, -0.2610834240913391, 0.04024506360292435, -0.9912385940551758, -0.03436736762523651, 0.02293049730360508, -0.4453350305557251, -0.556164562702179, 0.013191984966397285, 0.020009154453873634, 0.010825845412909985, -0.6629244685173035, 0.7739143967628479, -0.029530437663197517, 0.4139351546764374, -0.2760884165763855, 0.23832939565181732, -0.29160624742507935, 0.19547590613365173, -0.06764635443687439, 0.3691406846046448, 0.30315300822257996, -0.8065754175186157, 0.30516737699508667, -0.12413107603788376, 0.2506639063358307, 0.5109204053878784, -0.5348442792892456, 0.007465838920325041, -0.33296266198158264, -0.27089354395866394, -1.1141467094421387, 0.011352659203112125, 0.11448201537132263, -0.4842916429042816, -0.19429323077201843, -0.12336989492177963, -0.2336454540491104, 0.10810637474060059, -0.5848068594932556, 0.206439808011055, 0.3630625307559967, -0.3049272298812866, 0.34571442008018494, 0.7891263365745544, -0.09896134585142136, -0.055914513766765594, -0.28143924474716187, 0.3724527657032013, -0.359323650598526, -0.6488643288612366, 0.3134363293647766, 0.2019830346107483, -0.7862347364425659, -0.1241377741098404, 0.21707536280155182, -0.2185366004705429, -0.16014356911182404, 0.08251790702342987, 0.45236724615097046, -0.3768737018108368, 0.23555469512939453, 0.12787866592407227, -0.31199735403060913, 0.0579376183450222, -0.5704867243766785, 0.43618252873420715, -0.23978306353092194, 0.18472938239574432, -0.4367767572402954, 0.4678712785243988, 0.2691807746887207, 0.12949813902378082, 0.47196081280708313, 1.0351836681365967, -0.6834875345230103, -0.0510544516146183, -0.760451078414917, 0.1441066563129425, -0.39172056317329407, 0.25504258275032043, 0.07118670642375946, -1.0131855010986328, -0.026723390445113182, -0.01514500379562378, 0.3290448486804962, 0.5890771150588989, 0.45466887950897217, -0.016788430511951447, 0.6187477111816406, 0.7311065196990967, -0.08433663845062256, 0.0257850494235754, -0.1814740002155304, 0.04108235239982605, -0.4400171637535095, 0.28606459498405457, -0.3674383759498596, -0.129704549908638, -1.0549243688583374, -0.8684619665145874, 0.416263610124588, -0.012417202815413475, -0.06540816277265549, 0.33496206998825073, -0.6558772921562195, 0.02017873525619507, 0.5332271456718445, -0.14789918065071106, 0.4177732765674591, 0.2016787827014923, 0.09105364233255386, -0.30947425961494446, -0.32385843992233276, -1.0542809963226318, 1.2788934707641602, 0.22257402539253235, 0.5562713742256165, 0.2999667823314667, 1.036821722984314, 0.43177926540374756, 0.2804562747478485, -0.7747834920883179, 0.6156043410301208, -0.8254634737968445, 0.023709144443273544, -0.29315292835235596, -0.48398008942604065, -1.1503852605819702, -0.12507757544517517, -0.3794231414794922, -0.676787257194519, -0.1558714509010315, -0.24546292424201965, -0.571203351020813, 0.30848878622055054, -0.5850995182991028, 0.42990174889564514, 0.013795869424939156, -0.2025369107723236, -0.10764060169458389, -0.4762086868286133, 0.3048115670681, -0.07358615845441818, 0.5205097794532776, -0.333518385887146, -0.5158506631851196, 0.9497091174125671, -0.3623960614204407, 0.5806193947792053, -0.0053038508631289005, -0.1392749398946762, 0.30095452070236206, 0.1794050931930542, -0.08348629623651505, 0.6069281697273254, 0.0839538648724556, 0.5229303240776062, 0.3958507776260376, -0.2985215485095978, -0.42064064741134644, 0.7366887331008911, -0.9676104784011841, -0.39096611738204956, -0.3277257978916168, -0.3991730511188507, 0.0841403678059578, 0.47067156434059143, 0.25618287920951843, 0.11664924025535583, -0.4218810200691223, 0.20838521420955658, 0.751258134841919, -0.20249047875404358, -0.03778159245848656, 0.06462472677230835, -0.7496294379234314, -0.563840925693512, 1.1252614259719849, 0.31087368726730347, 0.21120165288448334, 0.6229336261749268, 0.4452351927757263, -0.2503606677055359, -0.2670125365257263, -0.20843277871608734, 0.33933812379837036, -0.5232373476028442, -0.1201489046216011, -1.1568021774291992, -0.5286312699317932, -0.8574414849281311, -0.3854283094406128, -0.4476572573184967, -0.6238008141517639, -0.2915394604206085, 0.08299555629491806, 0.23883244395256042, 0.8734115362167358, -0.5819671750068665, 0.1349702924489975, -0.933936595916748, 0.7359291315078735, 0.42411354184150696, -0.0036924274172633886, -0.6618659496307373, -0.3824324607849121, 0.1283559650182724, 0.21711650490760803, 0.028208551928400993, -0.6114342212677002, 0.6970472931861877, 0.27836158871650696, 0.12266020476818085, 0.6528345346450806, 0.1496107578277588, 0.28460070490837097, -0.14042061567306519, 0.5731973052024841, -0.02114739827811718, -0.44715505838394165, 0.5041249394416809, -0.6233101487159729, 0.32347914576530457, 0.48474740982055664, 0.4132334887981415, -1.0038728713989258, -0.5566097497940063, -0.5366336107254028, -0.9428385496139526, 0.30685198307037354, 0.44922906160354614, 0.4300486147403717, -0.20751594007015228, 0.4213023781776428, 0.32281196117401123, -0.04380403459072113, -0.3810765743255615, -0.34066516160964966, 0.031703848391771317, -0.009295831434428692, -0.39201611280441284, -0.5427110195159912, 0.03307696431875229, -0.26626262068748474, 0.5573533177375793, 0.10746060311794281, 0.24136695265769958, 0.32512426376342773, -0.35487785935401917, 0.292676717042923, 0.11026106029748917, 0.5361273884773254, 0.5630911588668823, -0.37079936265945435, 0.5774256587028503, 0.23942482471466064, -0.8282203078269958, -0.05888873711228371, 0.06303171068429947, -0.21845556795597076, 0.564221203327179, 0.18301057815551758, 0.29584816098213196, 0.27343031764030457, -0.6072047352790833, 0.4388715326786041, -0.21663179993629456, -0.038649335503578186, -0.5413280129432678, 0.09174764156341553, 0.18556439876556396, -0.2209443747997284, 0.3232458829879761, -0.0029380524065345526, 0.31494608521461487, -0.33469563722610474, 0.4560360014438629, 0.196449413895607, -0.9329829216003418, -0.14583925902843475, 0.6942477226257324, -0.16728194057941437, -0.38521242141723633, 0.31567779183387756, -0.4621788263320923, -0.26509368419647217, 0.2994126081466675, 0.393452525138855, 0.9813802242279053, -0.27498918771743774, 0.5991175174713135, 0.686041533946991, 0.41478171944618225, 0.17970536649227142, 0.3104894757270813, 0.1297079622745514, -0.6636249423027039, 0.044074200093746185, -1.0209211111068726, -0.19140557944774628, 0.053771115839481354, -0.5260269641876221, 0.8234829902648926, -0.4525259733200073, -0.012740605510771275, 0.03828833997249603, -0.20841826498508453, -0.47363296151161194, 0.3274123966693878, 0.4930340051651001, 0.7006118893623352, -0.4379713535308838, 0.5243653059005737, 0.9011836647987366, -0.040414344519376755, -0.5194031596183777, -0.2639766037464142, 0.27683451771736145, -0.6667221784591675, 0.458827942609787, 0.28426021337509155, -0.2035987228155136, 0.10484487563371658, -0.3846414387226105, -0.8230013847351074, 0.5668301582336426, 0.4625820815563202, -0.2621408700942993, 0.18464228510856628, 0.8433457612991333, 0.5685476660728455, -0.30266430974006653, 0.17786146700382233, 0.5058255791664124, 0.21980024874210358, -0.12299975752830505, -0.7155812978744507, -0.06458398699760437, -0.3711391091346741, 0.5886902213096619, -0.08533859252929688, -0.363651305437088, 0.8974012732505798, 0.04751967266201973, -0.48220959305763245, -0.09485791623592377, 0.8736423254013062, 0.20474742352962494, 0.11612033098936081, 0.5851334929466248, 0.4411517381668091, 0.7292100787162781, 0.1812659502029419, 0.6830074787139893, -0.1372188925743103, 0.11875224113464355, 1.1256088018417358, 0.06518961489200592, 0.786857008934021, 0.46916767954826355, 0.03717530518770218, 0.17480997741222382, 0.3251414895057678, 0.4963286519050598, 0.00053351407404989, 0.2692470848560333, -0.4335556626319885, 0.022217826917767525, -0.2923564612865448, -0.23483891785144806, 0.5929464101791382, 0.39033302664756775, -0.1152779683470726, -0.6408699750900269, 0.12532015144824982, 0.3451462388038635, 0.5294084548950195, -0.5223101377487183, 0.9691101908683777, 0.2626798152923584, -0.38883426785469055, 0.8666329383850098, 0.24643093347549438, 0.9022098779678345, -0.5536192655563354, 0.003768432419747114, -0.13065196573734283, 0.3450707495212555, -0.35686248540878296, -0.5946271419525146, 0.991367518901825, -0.06042831018567085, 0.12022098898887634, -0.23105734586715698, 0.9534510970115662, -0.4119103252887726, -0.8681308627128601, 0.6325151920318604, 0.5239588618278503, 0.1900971680879593, -0.6603208780288696, -0.39016804099082947, -0.03393205627799034, -0.1904469132423401, 0.23041796684265137, 0.1066356897354126, 0.5538939833641052, -0.30842021107673645, 0.21522101759910583, 0.8358786106109619, 0.2804611623287201, 0.25231698155403137, 0.06821534782648087, 0.7653730511665344, -0.6000456213951111, -0.44171521067619324, -0.8657949566841125, 0.22505342960357666, -0.104249507188797, -0.5857923626899719, 0.7998019456863403, 0.7583048343658447, 1.0060838460922241, 0.0030014305375516415, 0.8667021989822388, 0.3506990075111389, 0.7251821756362915, -0.23497961461544037, 1.190564513206482, -0.4517262578010559, 0.03297300264239311, -0.5110260844230652, -1.0056428909301758, -0.7073500156402588, 0.5013257265090942, -0.003051069797948003, -0.5325804948806763, 0.6183106899261475, 0.9661396741867065, 0.002834354992955923, 0.06090303137898445, 0.7042786478996277, 0.22637654840946198, 0.20100709795951843, 0.18008576333522797, 0.517436683177948, -0.40995341539382935, 0.5531231164932251, -0.6829803586006165, -0.6178856492042542, -0.13920028507709503, -0.5227309465408325, -0.7160821557044983, -0.871863603591919, -0.27294793725013733, -0.4472755789756775, 0.23178018629550934, 1.169864296913147, 0.19357900321483612, -0.9021797180175781, -0.6679152250289917, -0.02491110749542713, 0.18435361981391907, -0.16994185745716095, -0.22364982962608337, 0.2340407520532608, -0.7514199018478394, -0.7481870055198669, -0.1861279010772705, 0.7177041172981262, -0.33580654859542847, -0.22013580799102783, 0.192360058426857, -0.4875729978084564, 0.030594397336244583, 0.9292934536933899, -0.1264709234237671, -0.2872633635997772, -0.17708969116210938, 0.14434179663658142, -0.5494738817214966, 0.21064266562461853, 0.47234028577804565, -0.5862777829170227, 0.5462325215339661, 0.3878379166126251, 0.5882274508476257, 0.10582497715950012, -0.3239234983921051, 0.5358454585075378, -0.3087008595466614, 0.0768737941980362, 0.4731426537036896, 0.18368573486804962, 0.3712023198604584, -0.33062252402305603, 0.7626218795776367, 0.31436121463775635, -0.2955314815044403, -0.6559314727783203, -0.2457592636346817, -1.225960612297058, -0.0027339381631463766, 1.8160589933395386, 0.11709903180599213, -0.5964087247848511, -0.5103588104248047, -0.7108818292617798, 0.5067203640937805, -0.3566465377807617, 0.8597739934921265, 0.36442720890045166, 0.5012747645378113, 0.09153696149587631, -0.63015216588974, 0.6215542554855347, 0.23775361478328705, -0.635470986366272, -0.08203762024641037, 0.14055980741977692, 0.051329150795936584, 0.2371034175157547, 0.7899776101112366, -0.2399311512708664, 0.317364901304245, -0.38803815841674805, -0.1398411989212036, 0.5458861589431763, 0.10918225347995758, -0.2580409646034241, 0.10125207901000977, -0.3076895475387573, 0.043924517929553986 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16380v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16380v1	Rephrasing the Web: A Recipe for Compute and Data-Efficient Language Modeling	2024-01-29T18:19:08	2024-01-29T18:19:08	Pratyush Maini, Skyler Seto, He Bai, David Grangier, Yizhe Zhang, Navdeep Jaitly	cs.CL	cs.CL	Large language models are trained on massive scrapes of the web, which are often unstructured, noisy, and poorly phrased. Current scaling laws show that learning from such data requires an abundance of both compute and data, which grows with the size of the model being trained. This is infeasible both because of the large compute costs and duration associated with pre-training, and the impending scarcity of high-quality data on the web. In this work, we propose Web Rephrase Augmented Pre-training ($\textbf{WRAP}$) that uses an off-the-shelf instruction-tuned model prompted to paraphrase documents on the web in specific styles such as "like Wikipedia" or in "question-answer format" to jointly pre-train LLMs on real and synthetic rephrases. First, we show that using WRAP on the C4 dataset, which is naturally noisy, speeds up pre-training by $\sim3x$. At the same pre-training compute budget, it improves perplexity by more than 10% on average across different subsets of the Pile, and improves zero-shot question answer accuracy across 13 tasks by more than 2%. Second, we investigate the impact of the re-phrasing style on the performance of the model, offering insights into how the composition of the training data can impact the performance of LLMs in OOD settings. Our gains are attributed to the fact that re-phrased synthetic data has higher utility than just real data because it (i) incorporates style diversity that closely reflects downstream evaluation style, and (ii) has higher 'quality' than web-scraped data.	[ -0.42867931723594666, -0.9434493184089661, 0.3114827871322632, 0.1266932338476181, -0.4095129072666168, 0.26724791526794434, -0.37091323733329773, -0.45572638511657715, 0.38857072591781616, 0.5826498866081238, -0.4418884217739105, -0.29295092821121216, -0.3973808288574219, 0.23088133335113525, -0.5659346580505371, 0.7931265234947205, -0.041632384061813354, -0.03220546990633011, -0.36683228611946106, 0.0741606280207634, 0.15551258623600006, -0.6381665468215942, -0.43305400013923645, -0.13920317590236664, 0.851416289806366, 0.4805062711238861, 0.7598679065704346, 1.0219902992248535, 0.3701586425304413, 0.33043748140335083, 0.1883106678724289, 0.251844197511673, -0.6877253651618958, 0.10934074223041534, -0.2391841560602188, -0.5026503801345825, -0.3674745559692383, 0.1945367306470871, 0.600588321685791, 0.8946583271026611, -0.4511966109275818, 0.2057465761899948, 0.01597651280462742, 0.479047954082489, -0.8146152496337891, -0.2855871617794037, -0.8104638457298279, -0.215585395693779, -0.21015998721122742, -0.219061017036438, -0.3330587148666382, -0.39580124616622925, 0.13040152192115784, -0.8571763634681702, 0.2747497856616974, 0.17832224071025848, 0.8991937041282654, 0.14165441691875458, 0.006942401174455881, -0.1643013209104538, -0.5165152549743652, 0.8754982948303223, -0.7719007134437561, 0.5755656957626343, 0.3609943389892578, 0.14708051085472107, -0.12473252415657043, -1.061066746711731, -0.8469882607460022, -0.1005171462893486, 0.1439037322998047, 0.07337640970945358, -0.11531361192464828, -0.13288211822509766, 0.14172622561454773, 0.563962996006012, -0.5336154699325562, 0.33773133158683777, -0.3622671067714691, -0.08231742680072784, 0.6022086143493652, 0.028924336656928062, 0.4184799790382385, 0.1971811056137085, -0.1897912621498108, -0.2020883858203888, -0.7515150904655457, -0.2624805271625519, 0.5512047410011292, 0.34984079003334045, -0.027072476223111153, 0.6422736644744873, -0.33641448616981506, 0.8415856957435608, -0.021639898419380188, -0.3508508503437042, 0.32797810435295105, -0.2738598883152008, -0.1891411542892456, -0.17073000967502594, 0.6343114972114563, 0.375296413898468, 0.4114648997783661, -0.29265427589416504, -0.11713665723800659, -0.10500206798315048, 0.6380506753921509, -0.8607068657875061, -0.3595028817653656, 0.1029411181807518, -0.2712700366973877, -0.054314229637384415, -0.012919861823320389, -0.8474298715591431, -0.2125082165002823, -0.6054067611694336, 0.13953949511051178, -0.44341742992401123, -0.30452314019203186, 0.311231404542923, -0.20517371594905853, 0.25567251443862915, 0.37805482745170593, -0.6817045211791992, 0.23674394190311432, 0.7142782807350159, 0.709631621837616, -0.11186196655035019, -0.5059686303138733, -0.43148505687713623, 0.007593763060867786, -0.44656264781951904, 0.8129605054855347, -0.667590320110321, -0.2124350666999817, 0.09164087474346161, -0.09520990401506424, 0.029644310474395752, -0.5868446826934814, 0.3295987844467163, -0.7385680675506592, 0.25289762020111084, -0.06646588444709778, -0.6473087072372437, 0.21120327711105347, 0.20569786429405212, -0.788406252861023, 0.8017667531967163, 0.08675224334001541, -0.8214911818504333, 0.2397855967283249, -0.3325476348400116, -0.6878741383552551, -0.14954635500907898, 0.1984264999628067, -0.3696235120296478, 0.21326082944869995, 0.1874075084924698, 0.25192081928253174, -0.4706297516822815, -0.07293111830949783, -0.3491068184375763, -0.36544278264045715, 0.3915853202342987, -0.4240693747997284, 0.3683598041534424, 0.40309375524520874, -0.02784551866352558, -0.13063420355319977, -0.9557495713233948, 0.22932051122188568, 0.08863775432109833, -0.7567800879478455, -0.2533678412437439, -0.22650329768657684, -0.008216138929128647, -0.05325975641608238, 0.3709986209869385, -0.47015294432640076, 0.24960291385650635, -0.5294782519340515, 0.3446122407913208, 0.6510329246520996, -0.263320654630661, 0.5418756604194641, -0.45013225078582764, 0.9006825685501099, -0.2895057201385498, 0.003928706515580416, -0.11918781697750092, -0.03100600093603134, -0.7429987192153931, -0.4209780991077423, 0.3988335430622101, 0.5700476765632629, -0.9730324149131775, 0.05554172769188881, -0.5137424468994141, -0.6881888508796692, -0.837578535079956, 0.3811052143573761, 0.6192713379859924, 0.527494490146637, 0.7364511489868164, -0.22758260369300842, -0.7465746402740479, -0.8694475889205933, -0.5400195717811584, 0.2348080724477768, -0.12281689792871475, 0.009773781523108482, 0.19909319281578064, -0.09273584187030792, 0.9251301884651184, -0.5693845748901367, 0.24547560513019562, -0.4522569179534912, 0.34168750047683716, -0.03365299850702286, 0.369123637676239, 0.1850658804178238, -0.7686455845832825, -0.43357786536216736, -0.29313433170318604, -0.4235663115978241, -0.41270744800567627, 0.0924166589975357, -0.056739382445812225, 0.2626570463180542, 0.6390045285224915, -0.6270251870155334, 0.2697851359844208, 0.5015265345573425, 0.18808259069919586, 0.8659855127334595, -0.320809930562973, 0.029784973710775375, -1.1100404262542725, 0.036217767745256424, -0.06480316072702408, -0.14197728037834167, -0.5153084993362427, 0.2503744661808014, -0.16170156002044678, -0.10663817077875137, -0.5066901445388794, 0.5800949335098267, -0.6998472809791565, -0.015792783349752426, -0.43677884340286255, 0.30701911449432373, 0.23853357136249542, 0.35721954703330994, 0.05701140686869621, 0.9460769891738892, 0.2166626751422882, -0.6227205395698547, 0.4326607584953308, -0.029592949897050858, -0.42496445775032043, 0.4126105010509491, -0.5608276128768921, 0.15393167734146118, -0.020218823105096817, 0.2694501578807831, -0.8896642327308655, -0.3512125611305237, -0.04794495180249214, -0.3656635880470276, 0.29859307408332825, -0.18733899295330048, -0.736271858215332, -0.31206732988357544, -0.37494730949401855, 0.44360440969467163, 0.5325565338134766, -0.6486734747886658, 0.5662848949432373, 0.39105531573295593, -0.10161673277616501, -0.6421070098876953, -0.7697703838348389, 0.15179111063480377, -0.3227885365486145, -0.37972700595855713, 0.6030478477478027, -0.04580553621053696, -0.30946946144104004, -0.05760326236486435, 0.01636277697980404, -0.3095921576023102, 0.17659112811088562, -0.05855967104434967, -0.02003532648086548, -0.17332811653614044, 0.17851099371910095, -0.20838499069213867, 0.1711394339799881, -0.03996506333351135, -0.27324730157852173, 0.9178298711776733, 0.004622127395123243, -0.27681854367256165, -0.4777684211730957, 0.23038162291049957, 0.470913290977478, -0.29720762372016907, 0.840369701385498, 0.40708526968955994, -0.09109414368867874, -0.23017019033432007, -0.7025643587112427, -0.08007292449474335, -0.47612789273262024, 0.1937946081161499, -0.5304560661315918, -0.7594303488731384, 0.35078588128089905, -0.118281289935112, 0.11867572367191315, 0.1809023767709732, 0.3179378807544708, -0.3929317891597748, 0.7078556418418884, 0.5787957310676575, 0.025218209251761436, 0.6326515674591064, -0.07910098135471344, 0.24165569245815277, -0.6975374817848206, 0.028506137430667877, -0.46231958270072937, -0.40570753812789917, -0.6167129278182983, -0.5835283994674683, -0.05496353283524513, 0.47791019082069397, -0.23146489262580872, 0.2909720540046692, -0.36644449830055237, 0.4666229486465454, 0.7105035781860352, 0.1252678781747818, 0.35546398162841797, 0.3661090135574341, -0.058289784938097, 0.05647885054349899, -0.7627969980239868, -0.4516356885433197, 1.2618459463119507, 0.02174891158938408, 0.9970254302024841, 0.12801191210746765, 0.7579467296600342, 0.07680823653936386, 0.276639461517334, -0.5549466013908386, 0.5979817509651184, -0.24851810932159424, -0.18567527830600739, -0.21879252791404724, -0.5016249418258667, -1.2866190671920776, 0.1957351118326187, -0.16934876143932343, -0.3396568298339844, -0.052067264914512634, 0.495242714881897, -0.19917602837085724, 0.32353317737579346, -0.6934713125228882, 0.6098906993865967, -0.2537681758403778, -0.5276839733123779, -0.4555843472480774, -0.5085317492485046, 0.11147820204496384, 0.037962835282087326, 0.3390458822250366, 0.2712995409965515, -0.15341511368751526, 0.6644001603126526, -0.7258956432342529, 0.8381322026252747, 0.18071241676807404, -0.1431409865617752, 0.34866195917129517, 0.0918508991599083, 0.31433919072151184, -0.27584773302078247, -0.011081185191869736, 0.006911516655236483, -0.09196734428405762, -0.5950842499732971, -0.8937168121337891, 0.5892847180366516, -0.6636431813240051, -0.836009681224823, -0.2288312166929245, -0.45997750759124756, -0.26016828417778015, 0.13910669088363647, 0.32082852721214294, 0.497579425573349, 0.04191397875547409, 0.26069334149360657, 0.605872631072998, -0.3602140247821808, 0.15860527753829956, 0.5410484671592712, -0.44321155548095703, -0.52875816822052, 0.9270750880241394, 0.27609479427337646, 0.5736675262451172, 0.4860733151435852, 0.15035276114940643, -0.2979070842266083, -0.47966331243515015, -0.36204129457473755, 0.3822280764579773, -0.682401180267334, -0.18577347695827484, -0.7067505717277527, -0.12456630170345306, -0.4670534133911133, -0.2834060788154602, -0.3587995767593384, -0.6324222087860107, -0.3227335810661316, -0.25248628854751587, 0.5458511114120483, 0.41012251377105713, -0.13068410754203796, 0.546556830406189, -0.5052347779273987, 0.4090140163898468, 0.14373362064361572, 0.3687782287597656, 0.045391034334897995, -0.664901077747345, -0.3408006727695465, 0.2904607057571411, -0.09334229677915573, -0.6231141686439514, 0.4282930791378021, 0.1471530646085739, 0.5072504281997681, 0.14445100724697113, -0.09323693066835403, 1.0803536176681519, -0.5353220701217651, 0.631238579750061, 0.16420306265354156, -0.7193218469619751, 0.29530805349349976, -0.13822869956493378, 0.3577069938182831, 0.5880377888679504, 0.6066168546676636, -0.34216323494911194, -0.35175007581710815, -0.6737947463989258, -1.1147459745407104, 0.3541721701622009, -0.20066557824611664, 0.44014668464660645, -0.23138213157653809, 0.5313876867294312, 0.07430003583431244, 0.4404449760913849, -0.5580692291259766, -0.054061178117990494, -0.331849604845047, -0.22264598309993744, 0.06777981668710709, -0.3646990954875946, 0.022103894501924515, -0.34302401542663574, 0.6543033123016357, -0.06382782757282257, 0.007307775318622589, 0.04186812415719032, -0.44919493794441223, 0.1834489405155182, 0.3509761095046997, 0.36915072798728943, 0.895288348197937, 0.0225350484251976, 0.3887920379638672, 0.11669495701789856, -0.3677901029586792, -0.03892778605222702, 0.07498233765363693, 0.06815151125192642, -0.1357780247926712, 0.6301589012145996, 0.5644962191581726, 0.3491865396499634, -0.9759705066680908, 0.13467004895210266, 0.09541527181863785, -0.06904194504022598, -0.2018989771604538, 0.08574225008487701, 0.2841036915779114, -0.04981018602848053, 0.20942389965057373, -0.3248409926891327, -0.06745174527168274, -0.8126084804534912, 0.24191783368587494, 0.2645576000213623, 0.12898753583431244, -0.22414137423038483, 0.346518337726593, 0.11703188717365265, -0.36266472935676575, 0.8331201672554016, -0.15775752067565918, -0.5063053965568542, 0.38171568512916565, 0.6746936440467834, 0.4332824647426605, -0.30808308720588684, 0.05545130372047424, 0.2998402714729309, 0.029335867613554, -0.19496041536331177, 0.3858024477958679, -0.010669316165149212, -0.8100672364234924, -0.5156884789466858, -0.9716244339942932, -0.3050664961338043, 0.2624032199382782, -0.6789213418960571, 0.14366686344146729, -0.6646724939346313, -0.047939732670784, -0.21431294083595276, -0.04247462376952171, -0.5936961770057678, 0.4576028287410736, -0.035326141864061356, 1.0119378566741943, -0.5711925625801086, 0.8644156455993652, 0.6042699217796326, -0.5780885219573975, -0.8129531145095825, 0.07696264237165451, -0.31519457697868347, -0.7575197219848633, 0.4914005994796753, 0.11640165001153946, -0.4024372696876526, 0.22446250915527344, -0.5159130692481995, -0.9335339665412903, 0.8234913349151611, 0.5468223094940186, -0.6416668891906738, 0.013957048766314983, 0.21403305232524872, 0.8441194295883179, -0.35797789692878723, 0.15437477827072144, 0.5673935413360596, 0.3545148968696594, 0.12189865857362747, -0.9298189878463745, -0.10594857484102249, -0.2957631051540375, -0.07595083117485046, 0.012930427677929401, -0.31329524517059326, 1.020973801612854, -0.12554104626178741, -0.32715317606925964, 0.1484191119670868, 0.7015612721443176, 0.25226080417633057, 0.03254154697060585, 0.4479626715183258, 0.8864399194717407, 0.8602783679962158, 0.15693557262420654, 1.3917889595031738, -0.38447707891464233, 0.011957112699747086, 1.4822065830230713, -0.25675153732299805, 1.0597890615463257, 0.5261503458023071, -0.24279431998729706, 0.7452613711357117, 0.5972535014152527, 0.14252081513404846, 0.36021190881729126, 0.6177338361740112, -0.07909172028303146, -0.3607138693332672, -0.16143052279949188, -0.25558820366859436, 0.43055903911590576, 0.23090776801109314, -0.2917364537715912, -0.2873261868953705, 0.11480941623449326, 0.2715218961238861, 0.5985763072967529, -0.30543020367622375, 0.744040310382843, 0.1075533777475357, -0.7713704705238342, 0.9020001292228699, 0.05358903855085373, 0.7472636103630066, -0.5591310858726501, -0.010072259232401848, -0.2832212746143341, 0.05980921536684036, -0.14510899782180786, -0.7456439733505249, 0.3533462882041931, 0.13244567811489105, -0.2011656016111374, -0.4475558400154114, 0.3715820014476776, -0.5677632689476013, -0.6068927645683289, 0.278449147939682, 0.4892301857471466, 0.18735216557979584, -0.09682752192020416, -0.6952083110809326, 0.14911437034606934, -0.18464148044586182, -0.39459407329559326, 0.46008729934692383, 0.36279672384262085, -0.061717674136161804, 0.957779049873352, 0.8958426713943481, 0.2079702466726303, 0.25292152166366577, 0.20200775563716888, 1.0602750778198242, -0.4835713505744934, -0.4244832694530487, -0.9498410820960999, 0.2710364758968353, -0.2011767029762268, -0.12060674279928207, 0.838764488697052, 0.7907654643058777, 0.936303973197937, 0.05094540864229202, 0.7425615191459656, 0.1461399793624878, 0.7075590491294861, -0.7157708406448364, 0.502876877784729, -0.7026385068893433, 0.18848831951618195, -0.008001605980098248, -0.8579732179641724, -0.20221754908561707, 0.5039250254631042, -0.44583359360694885, 0.02597745694220066, 0.455634742975235, 0.8806509375572205, -0.18963034451007843, -0.21436001360416412, 0.041273873299360275, 0.332963764667511, 0.16055238246917725, 0.152028888463974, 0.7631174325942993, -0.06404762715101242, 0.5969365239143372, -0.36885949969291687, -0.006061466410756111, -0.2263173609972, -0.8698369860649109, -0.6628631949424744, -0.5288797616958618, -0.274883896112442, -0.4163878262042999, 0.07064086943864822, 0.8838455080986023, 0.5996192693710327, -0.466632217168808, -0.28506579995155334, -0.13750289380550385, 0.13082469999790192, -0.1608869433403015, -0.23001500964164734, 0.25156378746032715, -0.49893718957901, -0.7283574938774109, 0.5041747689247131, 0.047026388347148895, 0.0014442680403590202, -0.16139867901802063, 0.21396397054195404, -0.4375726878643036, 0.32256531715393066, 0.5410492420196533, 0.3576643466949463, -0.712522566318512, -0.09345925599336624, -0.10993880778551102, -0.06278134882450104, 0.08393627405166626, 0.8135104179382324, -0.8433523178100586, 0.39918965101242065, 0.4151715338230133, 0.8531854748725891, 0.45513394474983215, 0.4057488739490509, 0.8268400430679321, -0.7466743588447571, 0.05808192119002342, 0.04011336714029312, 0.26166820526123047, 0.5782710313796997, -0.18770338594913483, 0.3332224488258362, 0.11926952004432678, -0.32414916157722473, -0.8872636556625366, 0.39627760648727417, -0.6702890396118164, -0.649492084980011, 1.0763251781463623, -0.3347106873989105, -0.3304488956928253, -0.09550293534994125, -0.01643483154475689, 0.29267507791519165, -0.08073918521404266, 0.8702785968780518, 0.6131868958473206, 0.08967915177345276, -0.3190458416938782, -0.31208494305610657, 0.5092769265174866, 0.3205036520957947, -0.8307076692581177, 0.19229745864868164, 0.5028052926063538, 0.5120711326599121, 0.11303252726793289, 0.4424813389778137, 0.10306069999933243, 0.12489814311265945, -0.15723532438278198, 0.2380416840314865, -0.29014110565185547, -0.33460256457328796, -0.11315783113241196, 0.20823892951011658, 0.02895447053015232, 0.017722520977258682 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16367v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16367v1	TQCompressor: improving tensor decomposition methods in neural networks via permutations	2024-01-29T18:07:56	2024-01-29T18:07:56	V. Abronin, A. Naumov, D. Mazur, D. Bystrov, K. Tsarova, Ar. Melnikov, I. Oseledets, S. Dolgov, R. Brasher, M. Perelshtein	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL	We introduce TQCompressor, a novel method for neural network model compression with improved tensor decompositions. We explore the challenges posed by the computational and storage demands of pre-trained language models in NLP tasks and propose a permutation-based enhancement to Kronecker decomposition. This enhancement makes it possible to reduce loss in model expressivity which is usually associated with factorization. We demonstrate this method applied to the GPT-2$_{small}$. The result of the compression is TQCompressedGPT-2 model, featuring 81 mln. parameters compared to 124 mln. in the GPT-2$_{small}$. We make TQCompressedGPT-2 publicly available. We further enhance the performance of the TQCompressedGPT-2 through a training strategy involving multi-step knowledge distillation, using only a 3.1% of the OpenWebText. TQCompressedGPT-2 surpasses DistilGPT-2 and KnGPT-2 in comparative evaluations, marking an advancement in the efficient and effective deployment of models in resource-constrained environments.	[ -0.26128527522087097, -0.3734629452228546, 0.37735864520072937, 0.21495217084884644, -0.4994136393070221, 0.2243804782629013, -0.2179643213748932, -0.056597813963890076, 0.10716498643159866, 0.1489633321762085, -0.4397580325603485, -0.14094816148281097, -0.7225334644317627, -0.019184095785021782, -0.3940153121948242, 0.6532654166221619, 0.12238623946905136, 0.41243162751197815, -0.15836438536643982, 0.16970135271549225, -0.31470128893852234, -0.8641899228096008, -0.8596212863922119, -0.6317890286445618, 0.470213919878006, 0.00754123879596591, 0.6527094841003418, 0.48324891924858093, 0.6360567212104797, 0.4171750843524933, -0.3575596511363983, 0.03578603267669678, -0.6150850057601929, 0.3218540847301483, 0.049572743475437164, -0.25933584570884705, -0.31861612200737, -0.0319000706076622, 0.6427949666976929, 0.5948728322982788, -0.40631866455078125, 0.35039570927619934, 0.13458465039730072, 0.39762794971466064, -0.696876585483551, 0.10439454764127731, -0.44534721970558167, 0.303519606590271, 0.15614162385463715, -0.11323346197605133, -0.24598342180252075, -0.30362606048583984, -0.10376662760972977, -0.6449154615402222, 0.33260220289230347, -0.04097270220518112, 0.665015459060669, 0.5967336893081665, -0.2495516836643219, 0.31333309412002563, -0.6615007519721985, 0.7016628384590149, -0.6131044626235962, 0.5786170363426208, 0.12114761769771576, 0.25540047883987427, -0.13878120481967926, -1.0353957414627075, -0.7246532440185547, 0.019396232441067696, -0.10642632842063904, 0.1895347237586975, -0.4823760986328125, 0.19243477284908295, 0.27756842970848083, 0.6305137872695923, -0.5731008052825928, 0.0970558449625969, -0.38363999128341675, -0.19886700809001923, 0.21724361181259155, 0.06942960619926453, 0.0345454066991806, -0.13924390077590942, -0.19692891836166382, -0.5425270199775696, -0.5317567586898804, -0.501621425151825, 0.5373989939689636, 0.03118903748691082, 0.32378461956977844, 0.5289118885993958, -0.3630595803260803, 0.4576167166233063, 0.01252245344221592, 0.23415349423885345, 0.019854851067066193, -0.3261188268661499, -0.3841235935688019, -0.2559240460395813, 0.7861546277999878, 0.12308106571435928, -0.44348540902137756, -0.32168903946876526, -0.4492001533508301, -0.02801545336842537, 0.2846534550189972, -1.1768798828125, -0.7775850892066956, 0.1507958620786667, -0.7405276298522949, -0.4236070513725281, -0.07027709484100342, -0.3623906970024109, -0.35592350363731384, -0.34900325536727905, 0.6233752369880676, -0.35831549763679504, -0.5999359488487244, 0.34277182817459106, -0.399135947227478, -0.08172810077667236, 0.1844235509634018, -0.7696263194084167, 0.3670814633369446, 0.9126490354537964, 0.9016298651695251, 0.11373504996299744, -0.045705750584602356, -0.427469938993454, -0.2377653867006302, -0.14267343282699585, 0.5027578473091125, -0.09463280439376831, -0.07979978621006012, -0.13341102004051208, -0.5218592882156372, 0.13593803346157074, -0.6622398495674133, 0.540228545665741, -0.6210099458694458, 0.2717742323875427, -0.17581692337989807, -0.46359091997146606, -0.3014824390411377, 0.19494719803333282, -0.7205924391746521, 0.9885331392288208, 0.46390920877456665, -0.5072964429855347, 0.022612115368247032, -0.824397623538971, -0.15840962529182434, 0.06586027145385742, 0.18939165771007538, -0.46841105818748474, 0.6019124984741211, 0.15319645404815674, 0.5225022435188293, -0.5242816805839539, 0.17323768138885498, -0.25743868947029114, -0.3463596701622009, 0.3462753891944885, -0.2671496570110321, 1.006510853767395, 0.33787789940834045, 0.012439156882464886, 0.017107242718338966, -0.5576141476631165, 0.359035462141037, 0.22693617641925812, -0.4753510653972626, -0.18521949648857117, -0.1953759491443634, 0.12329979240894318, 0.46649688482284546, 0.18146948516368866, -0.39051708579063416, 0.31900107860565186, -0.008046441711485386, 0.666221559047699, 0.7233983874320984, -0.09520568698644638, 0.38522377610206604, -0.07091967761516571, 0.6573941707611084, 0.058672063052654266, 0.369975745677948, 0.3447810411453247, 0.0347672738134861, -1.0025537014007568, -0.17038407921791077, 0.7672708034515381, 0.30528393387794495, -1.2015433311462402, 0.418244332075119, -0.40564727783203125, -0.4969601035118103, -0.5162047743797302, -0.21339784562587738, 0.5223166942596436, 0.3857375979423523, 0.49722206592559814, -0.2704850137233734, -0.6715443730354309, -0.8256641030311584, -0.011903966777026653, -0.2364310771226883, -0.2740257978439331, -0.2607068419456482, 0.2848052382469177, 0.06663772463798523, 0.4370945990085602, -0.6314564347267151, -0.15625962615013123, -0.20906971395015717, 0.4125921428203583, 0.16719771921634674, 0.7439893484115601, 0.3931419551372528, -0.7088264226913452, -0.27187380194664, -0.27807900309562683, -0.5591970682144165, 0.03460647538304329, 0.1922367811203003, -0.11706247180700302, -0.10423179715871811, 0.5433844327926636, -0.6945324540138245, 0.17599566280841827, 0.6709261536598206, -0.21599508821964264, 0.6286718845367432, -0.10330409556627274, -0.1444641798734665, -1.0304282903671265, -0.04291335493326187, -0.2798401117324829, -0.23677949607372284, -0.8367279171943665, 0.5260733366012573, -0.07347343862056732, -0.26802629232406616, -0.4028845727443695, 0.054075032472610474, -0.47845259308815, 0.11399824172258377, -0.11622586101293564, -0.43391817808151245, -0.1726534366607666, 0.490820050239563, 0.048381004482507706, 0.6213415265083313, 0.3626088798046112, -0.3230030834674835, 0.3274061977863312, 0.47847023606300354, -0.3094543218612671, 0.04173620417714119, -0.8623369932174683, 0.5552002787590027, -0.08121173828840256, 0.31330570578575134, -0.7667662501335144, -0.035854849964380264, 0.4131583869457245, -0.46081340312957764, 0.3614608645439148, -0.4194299578666687, -0.8252663016319275, -0.23755106329917908, -0.41291043162345886, 0.47452113032341003, 0.5302231311798096, -0.5712388753890991, 0.5742589235305786, 0.18363343179225922, -0.03573905676603317, -0.4416380226612091, -0.6771600842475891, 0.11738117039203644, -0.13403794169425964, -0.35547709465026855, 0.4603341519832611, -0.09713208675384521, 0.02935120463371277, 0.17244741320610046, -0.36591267585754395, -0.08600107580423355, 0.14567233622074127, 0.12621162831783295, 0.19253528118133545, -0.3633214831352234, 0.17766375839710236, 0.026456870138645172, -0.25627344846725464, 0.004911032970994711, -0.851263701915741, 0.9516670107841492, 0.05880558118224144, 0.07049018144607544, -0.43774813413619995, 0.549750804901123, 0.09676190465688705, -0.1560463309288025, 0.7066152691841125, 1.0702121257781982, -0.2709945738315582, 0.03795634210109711, -0.5687295198440552, -0.3806475102901459, -0.5434794425964355, 0.5797895789146423, -0.3401752710342407, -1.1935126781463623, 0.2472175657749176, -0.24664422869682312, -0.35085639357566833, 0.346686989068985, 0.400240957736969, 0.007105620112270117, 1.0540802478790283, 0.6978465914726257, -0.09112150222063065, 0.8045640587806702, -0.597072184085846, 0.4966369867324829, -0.9620957374572754, 0.07300844043493271, -0.6017372608184814, -0.6043594479560852, -0.7005909085273743, -0.4164084494113922, 0.3948851227760315, 0.2887510061264038, -0.42303264141082764, 0.2555864751338959, -0.9111919403076172, 0.811725914478302, 0.8577889204025269, 0.27919554710388184, 0.01892201043665409, 0.26497894525527954, 0.128414586186409, 0.19996294379234314, -1.1810880899429321, -0.07016580551862717, 1.0747464895248413, 0.15037406980991364, 0.2702881693840027, 0.30467140674591064, 0.9119227528572083, -0.09811487793922424, 0.16386628150939941, -0.8960654139518738, 0.6231547594070435, -0.4178626239299774, -0.42889609932899475, -0.187718465924263, -0.8482963442802429, -0.625542402267456, 0.33976247906684875, -0.3302893042564392, -0.6328110694885254, 0.19767001271247864, 0.0824461281299591, -0.5274539589881897, 0.231710284948349, -0.8018351197242737, 0.531296968460083, 0.06725339591503143, -0.23728486895561218, -0.31436896324157715, -0.4286448061466217, 0.31206464767456055, 0.1030549481511116, -0.5798764228820801, 0.07088685780763626, -0.01830866187810898, 0.8370072245597839, -0.9531945586204529, 0.39512181282043457, -0.4229263365268707, 0.23011982440948486, 0.022214079275727272, 0.23179705440998077, 0.4146535098552704, 0.020783353596925735, -0.08636791259050369, 0.30647116899490356, -0.09967406839132309, -0.3951302170753479, -0.9160447716712952, 0.4724176824092865, -0.8999977111816406, -0.5947234630584717, -0.37866804003715515, -0.4864353537559509, -0.15906310081481934, 0.21527157723903656, 0.3318871557712555, 0.5175804495811462, 0.24018731713294983, 0.35128164291381836, 0.44590288400650024, -0.038354482501745224, 0.5307102203369141, 0.13508009910583496, -0.001417274004779756, -0.7156937122344971, 0.9043736457824707, 0.10389592498540878, 0.15809014439582825, 0.4339216947555542, 0.23407238721847534, -0.4934995472431183, -1.0932295322418213, 0.1597507894039154, 0.09507079422473907, -0.7851065993309021, -0.7077741622924805, -0.406297892332077, -0.24309632182121277, -0.31126829981803894, 0.1831202358007431, -0.4970177412033081, -0.9363223314285278, -0.15325665473937988, -0.024331005290150642, 0.1640678346157074, 0.6153939962387085, -0.30634185671806335, 0.6800814270973206, -0.5571833848953247, 0.4144861400127411, 0.4771119952201843, 0.4529942572116852, 0.09033803641796112, -0.2880125939846039, -0.32130420207977295, -0.12104987353086472, -0.32667478919029236, -0.5409751534461975, 0.40514764189720154, 0.03231015428900719, 0.23286128044128418, 0.15307408571243286, 0.1309739649295807, 0.7924613356590271, -0.22548183798789978, 0.7611818909645081, 0.44451743364334106, -0.9553773403167725, 0.09226733446121216, -0.30077874660491943, 0.388395220041275, 0.5376831889152527, 0.322225958108902, -0.3627457320690155, -0.226067453622818, -0.7696123719215393, -0.992072343826294, 0.8359076976776123, 0.4686223864555359, 0.18879158794879913, 0.2892123758792877, 0.41553977131843567, -0.11879301816225052, 0.24171122908592224, -0.6973888874053955, -0.24292337894439697, -0.4545784890651703, -0.006014563608914614, -0.11032413691282272, -0.6795186400413513, -0.09285478293895721, -0.5683193206787109, 0.8847576379776001, -0.02234204113483429, 0.8594462871551514, 0.14184464514255524, -0.19405438005924225, 0.33150532841682434, -0.020277805626392365, 0.4607725441455841, 0.2980153560638428, -0.23938465118408203, 0.37963494658470154, -0.11148145794868469, -0.6270442605018616, 0.35187944769859314, 0.48943477869033813, -0.2228037714958191, 0.10748888552188873, 0.08162534236907959, 0.7835540175437927, -0.12852221727371216, 0.15087178349494934, 0.18315617740154266, -0.510168731212616, -0.28257352113723755, -0.12429391592741013, 0.012868735007941723, 0.0037425903137773275, 0.5939788222312927, 0.3370722532272339, 0.1978168785572052, 0.4437490403652191, -0.0482168085873127, -0.25779950618743896, 0.1489807516336441, -0.2689334452152252, -0.24906162917613983, 0.6284600496292114, -0.07200530171394348, -0.2617056965827942, 1.0047651529312134, -0.4809921085834503, -0.7198778390884399, 0.18643710017204285, 0.603839635848999, 1.1172009706497192, -0.266914427280426, 0.08335110545158386, 0.5168262124061584, 0.17959198355674744, -0.3769185543060303, 0.2949499487876892, -0.2082885205745697, -0.8080987334251404, -0.6252075433731079, -0.5722662806510925, -0.271146297454834, 0.34955886006355286, -0.6401271820068359, -0.023034607991576195, -0.4609639048576355, -0.43273261189460754, 0.11080881208181381, 0.10167131572961807, -0.6932742595672607, -0.13455520570278168, -0.04928397759795189, 0.650916337966919, -0.5114663243293762, 1.008270502090454, 0.5509210228919983, -0.39897897839546204, -1.0892702341079712, -0.06558552384376526, -0.138833150267601, -0.213301882147789, 0.7198000550270081, -0.1879320591688156, -0.06620956212282181, 0.2426673173904419, -0.43123602867126465, -0.691990315914154, 1.145066261291504, 0.8624372482299805, -0.21608297526836395, 0.037799984216690063, 0.13694772124290466, 0.47616609930992126, 0.11350379139184952, 0.2990897595882416, 0.5157099366188049, 0.4329390525817871, -0.07511309534311295, -0.6982697248458862, 0.16859307885169983, -0.6043146848678589, 0.38857269287109375, 0.3184678256511688, -0.5493045449256897, 0.9287021160125732, 0.3453691005706787, -0.07718493044376373, 0.20342469215393066, 0.5768477320671082, -0.09780712425708771, -0.28563690185546875, 0.47256535291671753, 0.5541651844978333, 0.7516129016876221, -0.3740253746509552, 1.170904517173767, 0.14486093819141388, 0.5808693170547485, 1.1081960201263428, 0.21093705296516418, 0.8652967214584351, 0.6844862103462219, -0.3002150356769562, 0.16161617636680603, 0.46933117508888245, 0.04460867866873741, 0.5062950253486633, 0.35558784008026123, -0.35039228200912476, -0.35461506247520447, -0.1619405746459961, -0.3455308973789215, 0.6359569430351257, -0.02497703582048416, -0.2910119891166687, -0.05843135714530945, -0.3204248249530792, 0.14659956097602844, -0.34113484621047974, -0.23158681392669678, 0.8014812469482422, 0.01820223219692707, -0.4771779179573059, 1.0524790287017822, 0.11193762719631195, 0.620081901550293, -0.4187563359737396, 0.11295008659362793, -0.17959411442279816, 0.25560232996940613, -0.14932730793952942, -0.3588780462741852, 0.30964118242263794, -0.330534964799881, -0.20479866862297058, -0.6270772218704224, 0.8714886903762817, -0.4266834259033203, -0.4988151788711548, 0.0729248896241188, 0.4593537747859955, -0.008272824808955193, -0.4709269404411316, -0.5024599432945251, 0.0751362293958664, -0.07748206704854965, -0.34618496894836426, 0.3100689649581909, 0.23493517935276031, 0.3338072896003723, 0.4126876890659332, 0.7708246111869812, 0.04205287992954254, 0.03995947539806366, -0.026404928416013718, 1.1572717428207397, -0.29869115352630615, -0.30114343762397766, -0.7550073862075806, 0.36339902877807617, -0.22219355404376984, -0.1783314049243927, 0.46017807722091675, 0.568067729473114, 0.8069981932640076, -0.4050638675689697, 0.5829773545265198, -0.11349846422672272, 0.11751465499401093, -0.6278848052024841, 0.9549273252487183, -0.45430395007133484, 0.0670178085565567, -0.02176063135266304, -0.9022183418273926, -0.6732226014137268, 0.6173102855682373, -0.14987562596797943, -0.03465777635574341, 0.7291358113288879, 0.7395144104957581, -0.1830766350030899, -0.07153347879648209, 0.279243141412735, 0.10861139744520187, 0.17338955402374268, 0.5302353501319885, 1.1348731517791748, -0.6085477471351624, 0.5996330380439758, -0.6532005071640015, 0.11415013670921326, -0.07695426791906357, -0.979802668094635, -0.7058679461479187, -0.8113135695457458, -0.529913604259491, -0.3355056941509247, 0.09898857772350311, 0.924669086933136, 0.980367124080658, -0.5361344814300537, -0.16225887835025787, -0.17358916997909546, 0.03568372502923012, -0.507392942905426, -0.157476544380188, 0.38806718587875366, -0.2987419366836548, -0.51442551612854, 0.30799490213394165, -0.02129209227859974, 0.027458827942609787, -0.13310854136943817, -0.04258901625871658, 0.05196637287735939, -0.3695557415485382, 0.814743161201477, -0.11726074665784836, -0.2108970284461975, -0.2810482084751129, 0.028419852256774902, 0.335981160402298, 0.08137791603803635, 1.0320870876312256, -0.7118468284606934, 0.13520100712776184, 0.837576687335968, 0.49423396587371826, 0.6395264863967896, -0.21735689043998718, 0.5859823226928711, -0.9366145133972168, 0.3001479506492615, 0.4781606197357178, 0.41907933354377747, 0.30439862608909607, -0.2268640547990799, 0.7443068623542786, 0.04734361171722412, -0.4531559348106384, -0.828321099281311, 0.055203020572662354, -0.9245707988739014, -0.22921010851860046, 1.1194827556610107, -0.10498793423175812, -0.058118533343076706, 0.12774300575256348, -0.0653567761182785, 0.6625581979751587, -0.36430808901786804, 0.8551453948020935, 0.5736179351806641, 0.005092207808047533, -0.27893319725990295, -0.4299301505088806, 0.4960941672325134, 0.5636101365089417, -0.57484370470047, -0.045976802706718445, 0.41885605454444885, 0.1175229474902153, 0.18185847997665405, 0.40236347913742065, -0.1712428480386734, 0.255400687456131, 0.17365169525146484, 0.2446860671043396, -0.6520398259162903, -0.08529044687747955, -0.7070366740226746, 0.38520529866218567, 0.06512106209993362, -0.30997154116630554 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16349v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16349v1	ConFit: Improving Resume-Job Matching using Data Augmentation and Contrastive Learning	2024-01-29T17:55:18	2024-01-29T17:55:18	Xiao Yu, Jinzhong Zhang, Zhou Yu	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.CY	A reliable resume-job matching system helps a company find suitable candidates from a pool of resumes, and helps a job seeker find relevant jobs from a list of job posts. However, since job seekers apply only to a few jobs, interaction records in resume-job datasets are sparse. Different from many prior work that use complex modeling techniques, we tackle this sparsity problem using data augmentations and a simple contrastive learning approach. ConFit first creates an augmented resume-job dataset by paraphrasing specific sections in a resume or a job post. Then, ConFit uses contrastive learning to further increase training samples from $B$ pairs per batch to $O(B^2)$ per batch. We evaluate ConFit on two real-world datasets and find it outperforms prior methods (including BM25 and OpenAI text-ada-002) by up to 19% and 31% absolute in nDCG@10 for ranking jobs and ranking resumes, respectively.	[ -0.4162040650844574, -0.45403844118118286, 0.31696343421936035, 0.16759401559829712, -0.12051462382078171, -0.2507206201553345, -0.1923326849937439, -0.6719207167625427, 0.15328694880008698, 0.325278639793396, -0.6873842477798462, -0.20442140102386475, -0.42414727807044983, 0.023329894989728928, -0.3629298806190491, 1.0951133966445923, 0.3605507016181946, -0.042372386902570724, -0.49875548481941223, -0.2586348056793213, -0.8970355987548828, -0.2212897539138794, -0.8857549428939819, -0.33942389488220215, 0.4250008165836334, 0.7248206734657288, 0.7964016199111938, 0.451732337474823, 0.5613693594932556, 0.2874171733856201, 0.3391825258731842, 0.5372950434684753, -0.774357259273529, 0.34709975123405457, -0.31540581583976746, -0.2465006709098816, -0.05629633367061615, -0.027912933379411697, 0.49310365319252014, 1.067357063293457, -0.07719407975673676, 0.01595023088157177, 0.40138888359069824, 0.7896713018417358, -0.654039204120636, 0.04122772067785263, -0.6693730354309082, -0.24051295220851898, -0.29318270087242126, -0.11918428540229797, -0.08739035576581955, -0.14140324294567108, 0.11936552822589874, -0.8482831716537476, 0.7632603049278259, 0.20234966278076172, 0.8935741186141968, 0.20219966769218445, -0.3143639862537384, -0.18379414081573486, -0.5115824937820435, 0.6820049285888672, -0.42258912324905396, 0.5610976219177246, 0.4006401002407074, 0.33435386419296265, -0.32635244727134705, -0.6786124110221863, -0.5185660719871521, -0.1733199656009674, -0.41057002544403076, 0.1725783348083496, 0.22655819356441498, 0.18080024421215057, 0.2860950529575348, 0.7146227359771729, -0.7029898166656494, 0.22428275644779205, -0.44869139790534973, 0.0987091213464737, 0.3062934875488281, 0.07701711356639862, -0.04765068739652634, 0.4774894118309021, -0.41184520721435547, -0.3825896084308624, -0.5736217498779297, 0.03560484200716019, 0.6015840768814087, 0.28730300068855286, -0.06740279495716095, 0.4404653012752533, -0.3131249248981476, 1.0942078828811646, 0.3203688859939575, 0.26877984404563904, 0.3200414180755615, -0.3851505219936371, -0.32011377811431885, -0.11012035608291626, 0.2720729410648346, 0.47226178646087646, -0.023515714332461357, -0.20601879060268402, -0.37888985872268677, 0.1400943398475647, 0.416214257478714, -0.6042439937591553, -0.4548720419406891, 0.03201311081647873, -0.2553348243236542, -0.11849300563335419, 0.4420942962169647, -0.5458753705024719, -0.7140273451805115, -0.3613723814487457, 0.5572381019592285, -0.34715282917022705, 0.07055458426475525, 0.16554675996303558, -0.35219690203666687, 0.12796631455421448, 0.5093553066253662, -0.7755995392799377, 0.5344886779785156, 0.9396485686302185, 0.741598904132843, -0.228790283203125, -0.005575774237513542, -0.970289945602417, -0.12887118756771088, -0.21776676177978516, 0.8615012764930725, -0.7981663942337036, -0.1813000589609146, 0.1780884712934494, 0.2909584045410156, -0.099891796708107, -0.8781150579452515, 0.7050139307975769, -0.5730338096618652, 0.08858209103345871, -0.20501860976219177, -0.5462085008621216, -0.2646583616733551, 0.44688713550567627, -0.9918037056922913, 0.9137755036354065, 0.5380938053131104, -0.6077212691307068, 0.4564474821090698, -0.40168315172195435, -0.2869868874549866, 0.007676883600652218, -0.3769333064556122, -0.41840311884880066, 0.01378664467483759, -0.14224794507026672, 0.5146149396896362, -0.011110978201031685, -0.2006169855594635, -0.19087348878383636, -0.9510407447814941, 0.12115540355443954, -0.09256336092948914, 0.3773876428604126, 0.06050395220518112, 0.17379696667194366, -0.38050514459609985, -0.5830420851707458, -0.5026889443397522, -0.2970154285430908, -0.49044209718704224, -0.31630703806877136, -0.3758435547351837, 0.1326252818107605, 0.30281850695610046, 0.16175109148025513, -0.5901215076446533, 0.011238737031817436, -0.69212406873703, -0.33844953775405884, 0.45881810784339905, 0.04738317430019379, 0.4341825842857361, -0.7765740156173706, 0.41127777099609375, 0.27566078305244446, -0.16209889948368073, -0.15089021623134613, -0.17704109847545624, -0.5821845531463623, -0.13697156310081482, 0.3592227101325989, 0.7074236869812012, -0.8971520662307739, 0.3776298463344574, -0.14746809005737305, -0.6013680696487427, -0.52744060754776, 0.3121488094329834, 0.5220721364021301, 0.9040189385414124, 0.6828092336654663, -0.5486065745353699, -0.8497681617736816, -0.9840711951255798, -0.4966285228729248, 0.528733491897583, -0.28057610988616943, 0.2694098949432373, -0.002435900503769517, -0.2767634093761444, 0.6119989156723022, -0.41469308733940125, -0.5986585021018982, 0.08651968836784363, -0.21983899176120758, 0.7362930178642273, 0.9810243248939514, 0.555493175983429, -0.9940071105957031, -0.5060304403305054, 0.08327001333236694, -0.34883913397789, 0.25744059681892395, -0.29091471433639526, -0.04591919481754303, -0.2475198358297348, 0.35884222388267517, -0.5011010766029358, 0.22590626776218414, 0.44191262125968933, -0.2441323697566986, 0.2974242866039276, -0.3647482693195343, 0.3193213939666748, -0.9381008148193359, 0.26214274764060974, 0.7271575331687927, -0.3482262194156647, -0.6153275966644287, -0.19615639746189117, -0.03520317003130913, -0.18352554738521576, -0.38630586862564087, 0.6121716499328613, -0.41318193078041077, -0.026471924036741257, -0.2745976150035858, 0.22029384970664978, 0.10318060219287872, 0.38273072242736816, -0.29998958110809326, 0.7493361830711365, 0.3506626486778259, -0.6983317732810974, 0.5051622986793518, 0.5853411555290222, -0.45192116498947144, 0.8700447678565979, -0.5233766436576843, 0.032559581100940704, -0.26981663703918457, 0.5625659823417664, -1.3990415334701538, -0.4256795644760132, 0.10634126514196396, -0.15312960743904114, 0.3559761047363281, -0.32704874873161316, -0.41786351799964905, -0.13535942137241364, -0.507676899433136, 0.561347484588623, 0.4859931170940399, -0.7273609638214111, 0.055755749344825745, 0.15696635842323303, -0.17591409385204315, -0.870576024055481, -0.8452235460281372, -0.2018572986125946, -0.09432614594697952, -0.49393150210380554, 1.0200139284133911, -0.006024227477610111, -0.1121445968747139, -0.3913949429988861, -0.34924882650375366, -0.6161516308784485, 0.18288515508174896, 0.14505670964717865, 0.39980652928352356, -0.02264810912311077, -0.014230512082576752, 0.1261395364999771, -0.16705937683582306, -0.506564199924469, 0.02073412761092186, 0.3854226768016815, 0.1655188947916031, -0.2555244266986847, -0.44545724987983704, 0.17576029896736145, 0.1443060338497162, 0.27979791164398193, 0.7882543206214905, 0.7869811654090881, -0.395443856716156, 0.0732497051358223, -0.893648087978363, -0.18638010323047638, -0.5157288908958435, 0.18115530908107758, -0.2942076027393341, -0.7409831285476685, 0.40376603603363037, -0.30826306343078613, 0.17386607825756073, 0.5153648853302002, 0.018431736156344414, -0.20314940810203552, 0.65213543176651, 0.6350103616714478, 0.05053851380944252, 0.8143317699432373, -0.3077147901058197, -0.05528270825743675, -0.62796950340271, -0.47055381536483765, -0.40854912996292114, -0.6875790953636169, -0.7931111454963684, -0.06732719391584396, 0.22667726874351501, -0.10647270828485489, 0.0008305701776407659, 0.5761228799819946, -0.7040349245071411, 0.56879723072052, 0.5831342935562134, 0.672150731086731, 0.005326237995177507, -0.1078571230173111, 0.21393835544586182, -0.08081832528114319, -0.4534298777580261, -0.09049801528453827, 0.6850494742393494, -0.06068652495741844, 0.7346664071083069, -0.05089224502444267, 0.41630715131759644, 0.4743323028087616, -0.014620620757341385, -0.2589973509311676, 0.12523294985294342, -0.8415133357048035, -0.0493091344833374, -0.0226962398737669, -0.23021088540554047, -1.0842180252075195, 0.10055704414844513, -0.7015599608421326, -0.3288191854953766, 0.7307001352310181, 0.5488207936286926, -0.49478399753570557, -0.19272549450397491, -0.7328853607177734, 0.8866937160491943, 0.16130824387073517, -0.49895933270454407, -0.33334219455718994, -0.8052669763565063, 0.2752547860145569, -0.05274959281086922, 0.15456390380859375, 0.10088023543357849, -0.16562703251838684, 0.4912320077419281, -0.3847144842147827, 0.5763143301010132, -0.34285110235214233, 0.3242572546005249, -0.202518492937088, 0.07858674973249435, 0.6013966798782349, -0.0011155364336445928, -0.692374050617218, -0.07652353495359421, 0.14674139022827148, -0.5979527831077576, -0.5799738168716431, 1.0151962041854858, -0.31023117899894714, -0.2363143116235733, -0.08580531924962997, -0.7130904197692871, -0.28726789355278015, 0.037145406007766724, 0.27831748127937317, 0.47402676939964294, -0.2816736400127411, 0.6414188742637634, 0.827199399471283, -0.09013284742832184, -0.213119775056839, 0.18652619421482086, 0.49804365634918213, -0.3186422884464264, 1.0077176094055176, 0.08557070791721344, -0.21662677824497223, 0.42312127351760864, -0.23314641416072845, -0.2822158932685852, -0.04017698019742966, -0.1377948373556137, 0.20921924710273743, -0.5147231817245483, -0.41651034355163574, -0.38077089190483093, -0.17250436544418335, -0.45714086294174194, -0.37329670786857605, 0.13616570830345154, -0.542039692401886, -0.12325602769851685, 0.20951753854751587, 0.25673002004623413, 0.5334466695785522, -0.11999703198671341, 0.5094777345657349, -0.5216337442398071, 0.47760745882987976, 0.27004414796829224, 0.5329206585884094, -0.4113882780075073, -0.5304256677627563, -0.5739694833755493, 0.10657291114330292, -0.31787005066871643, -0.5521444082260132, 0.09538089483976364, 0.6313715577125549, 0.7465918064117432, 0.3233458995819092, -0.06000499427318573, 0.6717804074287415, -0.24679982662200928, 0.6261805891990662, 0.10729621350765228, -0.4964505136013031, 0.3252020478248596, -0.11449283361434937, -0.045677196234464645, 1.1015493869781494, 0.6435428857803345, -0.579657256603241, 0.0123326750472188, -0.9164467453956604, -0.8158285021781921, 0.48630625009536743, 0.22440007328987122, 0.10617119073867798, -0.08081503212451935, 0.7714685797691345, 0.5983834862709045, 0.21039152145385742, -0.29891014099121094, -0.14883583784103394, -0.04475850984454155, -0.6329395174980164, -0.14077284932136536, -0.16524510085582733, 0.03220003470778465, -0.1830306053161621, 0.6822645664215088, 0.09425559639930725, -0.021604327484965324, 0.0377531498670578, -0.17113906145095825, 0.2969941198825836, -0.14030398428440094, 0.49538102746009827, 0.38104352355003357, -0.12565162777900696, 0.29444119334220886, 0.4159400761127472, -0.27649202942848206, -0.041980743408203125, 0.45957979559898376, 0.2713489234447479, 0.3398978114128113, 0.002564979949966073, 0.5162943601608276, 0.2995939254760742, -0.813116729259491, 0.9516842365264893, 0.030575115233659744, -0.1427544504404068, -0.24417544901371002, 0.4810042083263397, -0.32916614413261414, 0.34875041246414185, 0.3106718361377716, 0.3881109058856964, 0.3761448562145233, -0.3498128056526184, 0.39503198862075806, 0.6643935441970825, -0.4960869550704956, -0.04864091798663139, 0.5296590328216553, 0.2557089328765869, -0.323585569858551, 0.6673611402511597, 0.0315357968211174, 0.03728750720620155, 0.7208642363548279, 0.6048226952552795, 0.430285781621933, -0.3066844940185547, -0.23668959736824036, 0.5178285241127014, -0.23366910219192505, -0.6421911716461182, 0.09413991868495941, -0.24889738857746124, -0.5894767045974731, -0.2490699142217636, -0.12740713357925415, -0.736069917678833, 0.2430555373430252, -0.5999385118484497, 0.5757810473442078, -0.5437039732933044, 0.21460402011871338, -0.07231142371892929, 0.15735410153865814, -1.1289137601852417, 0.575465738773346, -0.24076461791992188, 0.834273099899292, -1.1042125225067139, 0.36559829115867615, 0.7563756108283997, -0.6120715141296387, -0.1988806128501892, -0.0999021977186203, -0.5647255182266235, -0.5628489255905151, 0.4671008288860321, 0.6157453060150146, 0.07599571347236633, 0.08948444575071335, -0.4992768466472626, -0.5161553621292114, 1.0757008790969849, 0.7322974801063538, -0.5478723645210266, 0.03358729928731918, -0.2596697211265564, 0.26851630210876465, -0.2865768074989319, 0.24319493770599365, 0.5792569518089294, 0.3255018889904022, -0.07703987509012222, -0.7248903512954712, 0.056514181196689606, -0.3021056652069092, 0.0023280710447579622, -0.1250382512807846, -0.5441005229949951, 0.6912485361099243, 0.2442912608385086, -0.16806082427501678, 0.1132420226931572, 0.5782310962677002, 0.2666876018047333, 0.44526511430740356, 0.7492796778678894, 0.4071945250034332, 0.857161283493042, 0.10556085407733917, 0.7937952876091003, -0.442615807056427, 0.27086108922958374, 1.134600281715393, -0.06016276031732559, 0.5672359466552734, 0.3926891088485718, -0.06646127253770828, 0.9914623498916626, 0.8111213445663452, -0.37075531482696533, 0.48726576566696167, 0.2339400351047516, -0.44415283203125, -0.3679623007774353, -0.1661866456270218, -0.34428679943084717, -0.018358329311013222, 0.44912442564964294, -0.2018762081861496, -0.4063357412815094, 0.15197689831256866, -0.33035194873809814, 0.4696260988712311, 0.006985330488532782, 0.8370780348777771, -0.01954130083322525, -0.6165499687194824, 0.42908892035484314, -0.021331893280148506, 0.880557119846344, -0.38857319951057434, -0.6711946129798889, -0.4064217507839203, 0.2447241246700287, -0.6647049188613892, -0.7870513200759888, 0.4198506474494934, -0.31270235776901245, -0.2376730889081955, 0.08553311228752136, 0.9103496670722961, -0.7682363390922546, -0.20401722192764282, -0.15625408291816711, 0.275298148393631, 0.1788787841796875, -0.16840539872646332, -0.6345521807670593, -0.13642433285713196, -0.3998112380504608, 0.2667621672153473, 0.4705473482608795, 0.4568731188774109, 0.2146061807870865, 0.415394127368927, 0.5944015383720398, -0.14969144761562347, -0.4451347291469574, -0.1345268338918686, 0.8494585156440735, -0.149815171957016, -0.6576799154281616, -0.6009162664413452, 0.39076459407806396, -0.44991007447242737, -0.14878909289836884, 0.401742160320282, 1.0178778171539307, 1.0905776023864746, -0.19009292125701904, 0.6195061206817627, 0.06279362738132477, 0.7862778902053833, -0.3242981433868408, 0.24118486046791077, -0.4574476182460785, 0.30410534143447876, -0.3160898983478546, -1.0389020442962646, -0.33269280195236206, 0.7069708704948425, -0.25628846883773804, 0.180347740650177, 0.28542211651802063, 1.1402254104614258, -0.6953225135803223, -0.5551419854164124, 0.34597817063331604, -0.24369525909423828, -0.12207590788602829, 0.5504249334335327, 0.38557273149490356, -0.8463424444198608, 0.6174134016036987, -0.2573654353618622, -0.2221720814704895, -0.6076582074165344, -0.6490486860275269, -0.49360719323158264, -0.525550901889801, -0.4579801559448242, -0.6736913919448853, 0.27120649814605713, 0.8751036524772644, 0.7595298290252686, -0.71114182472229, -0.20671133697032928, -0.23686844110488892, 0.08027631789445877, -0.6364850401878357, -0.2553122341632843, 0.2119065374135971, -0.4345625936985016, -0.6064674854278564, 0.7867377996444702, -0.10366478562355042, 0.021379709243774414, 0.11206182092428207, -0.032565291970968246, -0.2559569478034973, -0.03382406011223793, 0.29338136315345764, 0.5405961871147156, -0.24193282425403595, -0.3296390175819397, -0.4881785809993744, -0.06179254874587059, 0.17107392847537994, 0.809036374092102, -1.052708387374878, 0.3088167905807495, 0.5663586258888245, 1.10078763961792, 0.48030272126197815, 0.5051548480987549, 0.5458778142929077, -1.2851684093475342, 0.39713022112846375, -0.07941058278083801, 0.31652992963790894, 0.6483848690986633, -0.7175357937812805, 0.7439368963241577, 0.32188278436660767, -0.46304410696029663, -0.6507003307342529, 0.1742909550666809, -1.16162109375, -0.028055528178811073, 0.7580989599227905, -0.018641138449311256, 0.23716384172439575, -0.39273950457572937, -0.2765907645225525, 0.36660921573638916, -0.2703161835670471, 0.8282579183578491, 0.18543753027915955, -0.18579837679862976, -0.029298648238182068, -0.4528067409992218, 0.6091853380203247, 0.3915785849094391, -0.5412237644195557, -0.2811562716960907, 0.5766602754592896, 0.3501775562763214, -0.1509697586297989, 0.5409302711486816, 0.3051794171333313, 0.7749276757240295, 0.014170389622449875, -0.1808796375989914, -0.1572783887386322, -0.09354689717292786, -0.2710201144218445, 0.11001080274581909, 0.05419708788394928, -0.5420015454292297 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16348v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16348v2	Improving the TENOR of Labeling: Re-evaluating Topic Models for Content Analysis	2024-01-29T17:54:04	2024-02-20T03:10:58	Zongxia Li, Andrew Mao, Daniel Stephens, Pranav Goel, Emily Walpole, Alden Dima, Juan Fung, Jordan Boyd-Graber	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC	Topic models are a popular tool for understanding text collections, but their evaluation has been a point of contention. Automated evaluation metrics such as coherence are often used, however, their validity has been questioned for neural topic models (NTMs) and can overlook a models benefits in real world applications. To this end, we conduct the first evaluation of neural, supervised and classical topic models in an interactive task based setting. We combine topic models with a classifier and test their ability to help humans conduct content analysis and document annotation. From simulated, real user and expert pilot studies, the Contextual Neural Topic Model does the best on cluster evaluation metrics and human evaluations; however, LDA is competitive with two other NTMs under our simulated experiment and user study results, contrary to what coherence scores suggest. We show that current automated metrics do not provide a complete picture of topic modeling capabilities, but the right choice of NTMs can be better than classical models on practical task.	[ -0.5321965217590332, -0.8198065757751465, 0.5367526412010193, 0.032493121922016144, -0.5015146732330322, -0.05021003261208534, -0.2746903896331787, -0.46415501832962036, 0.3535090684890747, 0.5229368805885315, -0.2598758339881897, -0.6953641772270203, -0.854763388633728, 0.07070881128311157, -0.649858832359314, 1.0576406717300415, 0.29969990253448486, -0.17353473603725433, -0.6198378801345825, -0.038121674209833145, -0.7590324878692627, -0.30226898193359375, -0.8563231229782104, -0.3037731945514679, 0.5825127959251404, 0.21150414645671844, 0.6461776494979858, 0.4480069577693939, 0.5884405970573425, 0.38942110538482666, -0.49245887994766235, 0.04796791821718216, -0.33967944979667664, 0.17198054492473602, -0.42076268792152405, -0.2592395544052124, -0.6020236015319824, 0.32913219928741455, 0.40281933546066284, 1.1317601203918457, 0.19044280052185059, -0.09720557928085327, 0.015534990467131138, 0.33118677139282227, -0.3907964527606964, 0.051708564162254333, -0.5642336010932922, 0.020226065069437027, 0.09650116413831711, -0.3048783540725708, -0.49741992354393005, -0.1774856299161911, 1.0156561136245728, -0.7050836682319641, 0.3474060893058777, 0.06141320988535881, 0.9621681571006775, 0.43845340609550476, -0.5855996608734131, -0.5503666996955872, -0.40984252095222473, 0.8881644606590271, -0.652635395526886, 0.34763655066490173, 0.5613893866539001, -0.013032739982008934, 0.05702270567417145, -0.7479564547538757, -0.3669854402542114, -0.6093451380729675, -0.11096824705600739, 0.18524232506752014, -0.24537254869937897, -0.08849917352199554, -0.12040247023105621, 0.37346306443214417, -0.4912657141685486, 0.16896219551563263, -0.2390194684267044, -0.22829902172088623, 0.6681303381919861, 0.2764899432659149, 0.4063015282154083, -0.5252265334129333, -0.355278879404068, 0.05137539282441139, -0.1742926836013794, -0.20176446437835693, 0.2148589789867401, 0.2562916576862335, -0.034592609852552414, 0.38779762387275696, -0.1601921170949936, 1.043811321258545, 0.22055688500404358, -0.01159053947776556, -0.14019733667373657, -0.42827028036117554, -0.07456239312887192, 0.019992928951978683, 0.5012832283973694, 0.512035071849823, -0.30729347467422485, -0.4539162516593933, -0.030511777848005295, -0.09902644902467728, 0.6911497116088867, -0.7643349766731262, -0.31812164187431335, 0.3083118498325348, -0.5870752930641174, -0.240295872092247, -0.06061875820159912, -0.6049563884735107, -0.4464872181415558, -0.760958731174469, 0.47678110003471375, -0.1906861811876297, -0.03029012493789196, 0.036693595349788666, -0.3234591782093048, -0.20897310972213745, 0.7065305709838867, -0.8538289666175842, 0.27935847640037537, 0.9536123871803284, 0.9239100813865662, -0.797370970249176, -0.13315433263778687, -0.21830061078071594, -0.2694765329360962, -0.3768998384475708, 1.1420589685440063, -0.3572726845741272, -0.36400681734085083, -0.34048983454704285, -0.06400167942047119, -0.09406225383281708, -0.6233733892440796, 0.576901376247406, -0.7109922766685486, 0.39400526881217957, -0.3792305290699005, -0.8815211057662964, -0.18295662105083466, 0.46790361404418945, -0.9077313542366028, 0.6693307161331177, 0.12813639640808105, -0.8767624497413635, 0.6307529211044312, -0.5608841180801392, -0.10382141917943954, -0.11735393851995468, -0.07950187474489212, -0.24288047850131989, 0.06756141036748886, -0.1099633276462555, 0.3767314553260803, -0.43366920948028564, 0.7813792824745178, -0.033125925809144974, -0.5006392598152161, 0.3414120376110077, -0.461447536945343, 0.6306800246238708, 0.1765618622303009, -0.2712867259979248, 0.5597376227378845, -0.4681068956851959, -0.25820866227149963, -0.40783804655075073, -0.3365432918071747, -0.6226064562797546, 0.08637654036283493, -0.009412123821675777, -0.03181415796279907, 0.2279329001903534, -0.27032169699668884, -0.06276408582925797, -0.4125262498855591, 0.3207235038280487, 0.5906249284744263, 0.15839242935180664, 0.5376195907592773, -0.38569915294647217, 0.26627102494239807, 0.010295533575117588, -0.3213871121406555, -0.06438250839710236, -0.7455955147743225, -0.8140478730201721, -0.3373858332633972, 0.6707019805908203, 0.3329724669456482, -0.48879474401474, 0.7505178451538086, -0.17897635698318481, -0.630840539932251, -0.1953807771205902, -0.20225116610527039, 0.21872597932815552, 0.6172850728034973, 0.28026777505874634, -0.7694342136383057, -0.16229988634586334, -0.8932152986526489, -0.2525157034397125, -0.09572580456733704, -0.12082206457853317, 0.3494684398174286, 0.5177717804908752, -0.05360448360443115, 1.2014963626861572, -0.4921758472919464, 0.017785146832466125, -0.1099805012345314, 0.7550401091575623, 0.05913693457841873, 0.48493731021881104, 0.1889781355857849, -0.9243125319480896, -0.4045713543891907, -0.20844382047653198, -0.6059296727180481, -0.18888285756111145, -0.1842479109764099, -0.07337360084056854, 0.22401627898216248, 0.21236899495124817, -0.31108400225639343, 0.4733114540576935, 0.19304171204566956, -0.6302610635757446, 0.556953489780426, -0.2667849361896515, 0.24229976534843445, -0.7603277564048767, 0.15925811231136322, 0.3001413643360138, 0.011857924051582813, -0.6224983334541321, -0.1928628534078598, -0.17875418066978455, -0.44432374835014343, -0.2544401288032532, 0.7652763724327087, -0.2067570835351944, -0.2826231122016907, -0.7788700461387634, 0.48886585235595703, 0.3386101722717285, 0.20431792736053467, 0.37585026025772095, 0.5933067202568054, 0.292703777551651, -0.4799959063529968, 0.2712966203689575, 0.29128706455230713, -0.4821780025959015, 0.6886728405952454, -0.7580131888389587, 0.10839938372373581, -0.08795220404863358, 0.21363365650177002, -1.052614450454712, -0.11824174225330353, 0.18395474553108215, -0.2557269334793091, 0.5049172043800354, 0.12405521422624588, -0.31737279891967773, 0.07087701559066772, -0.20450091361999512, 0.09628518670797348, 0.11778438091278076, -0.3532419800758362, 0.15723319351673126, 0.47998490929603577, -0.364956259727478, -0.34300631284713745, -0.3798964023590088, 0.3824613690376282, -0.38662058115005493, -0.7220402359962463, 0.8364740610122681, -0.1345367580652237, -0.38165363669395447, 0.1815163642168045, -0.2572946846485138, -0.5400626063346863, 0.42256277799606323, 0.16585563123226166, 0.04364949092268944, -0.0598507784307003, 0.39438340067863464, 0.1182958111166954, -0.44744664430618286, -0.12116914242506027, -0.16836699843406677, 0.23045942187309265, -0.21420349180698395, -0.31760963797569275, -0.6898868083953857, 0.23231497406959534, 0.054856862872838974, -0.2178104817867279, 0.49504509568214417, 0.5618367195129395, -0.4709705114364624, 0.0861358568072319, -0.3931010067462921, -0.37637561559677124, -0.3849020302295685, 0.5136808156967163, -0.04978932440280914, -0.8948058485984802, 0.24169769883155823, -0.046603381633758545, -0.12492892146110535, 0.5920873284339905, 0.33969977498054504, -0.2101065069437027, 0.47290948033332825, 0.7574138045310974, 0.2983858585357666, 0.42622220516204834, -0.358438640832901, 0.050578728318214417, -0.7390438914299011, -0.16743271052837372, -0.6979007720947266, -0.29071044921875, -0.4833279550075531, -0.4866604506969452, 0.23388051986694336, 0.19856563210487366, 0.12763476371765137, 0.28390058875083923, -0.6806703805923462, 0.27947044372558594, 0.4936278462409973, 0.18266071379184723, 0.35579854249954224, -0.006753450725227594, 0.391392320394516, -0.3113141655921936, -0.6738264560699463, -1.0019986629486084, 0.7918974161148071, 0.3650888204574585, 0.38922205567359924, -0.2688628137111664, 0.5854121446609497, 0.5837398767471313, 0.6561115384101868, -0.9284031987190247, 0.5826852917671204, -0.5877488851547241, -0.7158029079437256, -0.5567963123321533, -0.19025710225105286, -0.9136191010475159, 0.5420250296592712, -0.152314230799675, -0.770473301410675, 0.4314240515232086, -0.012271832674741745, -0.4610433876514435, 0.056980885565280914, -0.5434930920600891, 1.2255725860595703, -0.1492200493812561, -0.4862552583217621, -0.08573345094919205, -0.3690607249736786, 0.22970245778560638, -0.1857902854681015, -0.062388528138399124, -0.21657304465770721, -0.29169920086860657, 1.1163488626480103, -0.23328186571598053, 1.0299170017242432, -0.011365704238414764, -0.3001554608345032, 0.49726900458335876, -0.20747263729572296, -0.17640405893325806, 0.06928600370883942, -0.48532065749168396, 0.09669721126556396, 0.003521077102050185, -0.23848827183246613, -0.7079802751541138, 0.6704183220863342, -0.6476277112960815, -0.8581959009170532, -0.36262914538383484, -0.6912294626235962, 0.042492810636758804, 0.12800729274749756, -0.007776703219860792, 0.6197083592414856, -0.24105848371982574, 0.2805222272872925, 0.6036167740821838, -0.40545251965522766, 0.22623898088932037, 0.38429978489875793, 0.07293807715177536, -0.37105074524879456, 1.1199132204055786, 0.21843495965003967, 0.11262531578540802, 0.3278687596321106, 0.3519369661808014, -0.27278241515159607, -0.8149600028991699, -0.2796872556209564, -0.2385880947113037, -0.9353892207145691, 0.18447422981262207, -0.7408580183982849, 0.050002917647361755, -0.16026464104652405, -0.21983179450035095, -0.21627971529960632, -0.5159335732460022, -0.6105834245681763, 0.09757226705551147, -0.0584951676428318, 0.5985435843467712, -0.07124023884534836, 0.43735337257385254, -0.7029409408569336, 0.30864864587783813, 0.348258376121521, 0.0583379864692688, 0.057884786278009415, -0.5781700611114502, -0.20787537097930908, -0.160355344414711, -0.6207621097564697, -1.098329782485962, 0.4689258933067322, 0.041645850986242294, 0.7483230233192444, 0.2181847095489502, 0.11996791511774063, 0.202643483877182, -0.09992659091949463, 0.8252928853034973, -0.20037700235843658, -1.1108496189117432, 0.5268250703811646, -0.20537424087524414, 0.22580896317958832, 0.616966724395752, 0.600094735622406, -0.5043736100196838, -0.3256855309009552, -0.5553166270256042, -0.844598114490509, 0.6396975517272949, 0.20414288341999054, 0.06284619122743607, -0.2977602779865265, 0.43617305159568787, 0.40367165207862854, 0.267570436000824, -0.502901017665863, -0.09052208065986633, -0.3178446590900421, -0.1162235289812088, -0.07389490306377411, -0.3963054418563843, 0.06732962280511856, -0.11360041797161102, 0.5903194546699524, -0.11455316841602325, 0.16024792194366455, 0.42459526658058167, -0.14466819167137146, 0.10972488671541214, 0.27087220549583435, 0.6079699397087097, 0.985236406326294, -0.3994623124599457, 0.26800116896629333, 0.11658363789319992, -0.19712816178798676, 0.1635696291923523, 0.1907636523246765, -0.2899554967880249, 0.23330017924308777, 0.5069393515586853, 0.8145238757133484, 0.5735916495323181, -0.48822301626205444, 0.26166170835494995, -0.14232248067855835, 0.0322379544377327, 0.11432920396327972, 0.07350142300128937, 0.4146667718887329, 0.127534419298172, 0.1988137811422348, -0.14321264624595642, 0.2979065477848053, -0.608647346496582, 0.5209113359451294, 0.29637250304222107, -0.659889280796051, -0.17269392311573029, 0.3750704228878021, 0.354466050863266, -0.48805660009384155, 0.5945655703544617, -0.3230767846107483, -0.6232010722160339, 1.15530526638031, 0.3409023582935333, 0.777084231376648, 0.00379610201343894, 0.43466976284980774, 0.3419874906539917, 0.31084689497947693, 0.3332595229148865, 0.03445839136838913, -0.17149898409843445, -0.48703280091285706, -0.3445398509502411, -0.5905847549438477, -0.7103888988494873, -0.13750337064266205, -0.7146239876747131, 0.037297192960977554, -0.06092417240142822, -0.392169326543808, 0.4418613910675049, 0.4817492663860321, -0.25214874744415283, 0.5612062811851501, -0.15629996359348297, 0.9087536931037903, -0.6848352551460266, 0.7150530815124512, 0.7496439814567566, -0.29552653431892395, -0.09102035313844681, 0.1455315202474594, -0.276278018951416, 0.12274328619241714, 1.0429166555404663, 0.3209807574748993, 0.3804819583892822, -0.08285972476005554, -0.3349135220050812, -0.7731460332870483, 1.1967235803604126, 0.07883676141500473, -0.2664908170700073, 0.11874786764383316, -0.01943305879831314, 0.8126577734947205, -0.3762573003768921, 0.4248768389225006, 0.33064860105514526, 0.5469437837600708, 0.02920536883175373, -0.8271009922027588, -0.05383085831999779, 0.02218356728553772, -0.001686139963567257, -0.11505764722824097, -0.3899148404598236, 0.8259570598602295, 0.04998139664530754, -0.09811671078205109, 0.1993560940027237, 0.935265839099884, 0.3279811143875122, 0.7451356649398804, 0.7027484774589539, 0.528201162815094, 0.8574392199516296, -0.18642322719097137, 1.0368950366973877, -0.1327553540468216, 0.34478995203971863, 1.3162157535552979, -0.30472633242607117, 0.7006415724754333, 0.32586193084716797, 0.051094502210617065, 0.23343484103679657, 0.9791456460952759, -0.026605501770973206, 0.5996472239494324, 0.5418031811714172, -0.10980033129453659, -0.3449944257736206, -0.45484524965286255, -0.26348361372947693, 0.40737730264663696, 0.37650418281555176, -0.20521211624145508, -0.4053811728954315, -0.09233506768941879, -0.26621922850608826, 0.20210546255111694, -0.0951874777674675, 0.7076103687286377, 0.15119633078575134, -0.7520591020584106, 0.3658246397972107, 0.38971376419067383, 0.6109268665313721, -0.24518327414989471, -0.006025431677699089, -0.2434779852628708, -0.21705448627471924, -0.06437307596206665, -0.623204231262207, 0.838105320930481, -0.027107231318950653, -0.2926102876663208, -0.152330219745636, 0.9971770644187927, -0.37307009100914, -0.16273050010204315, 0.22334149479866028, 0.3462804853916168, 0.23077954351902008, -0.14047275483608246, -0.7293906807899475, 0.1286027580499649, -0.28894081711769104, -0.25798770785331726, 0.2849672734737396, 0.19766001403331757, -0.25226810574531555, 0.48486968874931335, 0.42134472727775574, -0.3894846439361572, -0.10289359092712402, -0.03211655840277672, 0.6001165509223938, -0.7178647518157959, -0.48468342423439026, -0.5388212203979492, 0.4479909837245941, -0.17510302364826202, -0.34584659337997437, 0.6849437952041626, 0.42662715911865234, 0.6992566585540771, 0.06960209459066391, 0.40036457777023315, 0.14741194248199463, 0.2969130873680115, -0.34282147884368896, 0.9768164157867432, -0.7150651216506958, 0.2863491475582123, -0.20196852087974548, -0.8004994988441467, -0.16653631627559662, 0.5412827134132385, -0.6410393714904785, 0.024539761245250702, 0.721049964427948, 0.40809476375579834, -0.019023623317480087, 0.45786747336387634, 0.42471835017204285, 0.017444465309381485, 0.31626206636428833, 0.3077535629272461, 1.1410045623779297, -0.29759082198143005, 0.0007965540862642229, -0.627543568611145, -0.21882571280002594, -0.1569342166185379, -1.1700026988983154, -0.9659267067909241, -0.590853750705719, -0.720539927482605, 0.0239533893764019, 0.2728949785232544, 0.5786865949630737, 0.9388759732246399, -0.7573649287223816, -0.15761585533618927, 0.010852002538740635, 0.42076727747917175, 0.02992742508649826, -0.23474833369255066, 0.7477959990501404, -0.38285061717033386, -0.904914915561676, 0.480490505695343, 0.17562219500541687, -0.09983307123184204, -0.3382893204689026, 0.15480607748031616, -0.2605416774749756, 0.07587757706642151, 0.5082215070724487, -0.16309316456317902, -0.8155015707015991, -0.20445434749126434, -0.18591631948947906, -0.3419460654258728, -0.06783967465162277, 0.6399304270744324, -0.6629577875137329, 0.5183263421058655, 0.7175900936126709, 0.8294352293014526, 0.32278305292129517, 0.10341523587703705, 0.4400273859500885, -0.3715960383415222, 0.0007391955005005002, 0.24478483200073242, 0.20448747277259827, 0.3380924463272095, -0.26018771529197693, 0.40765440464019775, 0.26330554485321045, -0.4648801386356354, -0.7589797973632812, -0.09028089791536331, -1.0830789804458618, -0.5147064328193665, 0.700118899345398, -0.4594537615776062, -0.19880202412605286, -0.2521064579486847, -0.24165621399879456, 0.3448856472969055, -0.13650138676166534, 0.9778342247009277, 0.7873073816299438, 0.09149159491062164, 0.16848190128803253, -0.6810376644134521, 0.17911873757839203, 0.6800134778022766, -1.1036641597747803, -0.31648990511894226, 0.5218338966369629, 0.16983506083488464, 0.4889157712459564, 0.5897282361984253, 0.151025652885437, 0.2624872922897339, -0.08925944566726685, -0.1267179548740387, 0.01292795967310667, -0.6165726780891418, -0.4596908688545227, 0.2501128017902374, 0.10900387912988663, 0.14257501065731049 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16335v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16335v1	Iterative Data Smoothing: Mitigating Reward Overfitting and Overoptimization in RLHF	2024-01-29T17:43:42	2024-01-29T17:43:42	Banghua Zhu, Michael I. Jordan, Jiantao Jiao	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML	Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is a pivotal technique that aligns language models closely with human-centric values. The initial phase of RLHF involves learning human values using a reward model from ranking data. It is observed that the performance of the reward model degrades after one epoch of training, and optimizing too much against the learned reward model eventually hinders the true objective. This paper delves into these issues, leveraging the theoretical insights to design improved reward learning algorithm termed 'Iterative Data Smoothing' (IDS). The core idea is that during each training epoch, we not only update the model with the data, but also update the date using the model, replacing hard labels with soft labels. Our empirical findings highlight the superior performance of this approach over the traditional methods.	[ -0.47735849022865295, -0.7278544902801514, 0.2795484960079193, -0.061973996460437775, -0.2840973436832428, 0.17051365971565247, -0.2634953260421753, -0.34663450717926025, 0.15148848295211792, 0.4430827498435974, -0.8186929225921631, -0.32978084683418274, -0.6459329128265381, -0.2949415147304535, -0.025444703176617622, 1.2284607887268066, 0.08320904523134232, -0.09134074300527573, -0.24858400225639343, -0.0388316735625267, -0.24367551505565643, -0.5897906422615051, -1.0704138278961182, -0.7955591678619385, 0.7156822085380554, 0.7199889421463013, 0.7238436937332153, 0.9741617441177368, 0.3514954149723053, 0.2648578882217407, 0.14976245164871216, -0.02301422506570816, -0.9729072451591492, 0.1747208684682846, -0.09613925218582153, -0.1634136289358139, -0.04040771350264549, -0.03500688448548317, 0.6756155490875244, 0.6972038745880127, -0.5825507044792175, 0.05396299809217453, -0.023623758926987648, 1.3733073472976685, -0.6802923083305359, 0.4224558472633362, -0.2504292130470276, 0.14899440109729767, -0.34101447463035583, -0.5509268641471863, -0.38981226086616516, -0.5824990272521973, 0.09578406065702438, -0.6771339178085327, -0.09464122354984283, 0.07359104603528976, 0.8994559049606323, 0.6295955181121826, -0.1871085911989212, -0.010378296487033367, -0.7301328778266907, 0.920565128326416, -0.6739569306373596, 0.35455623269081116, 0.7740565538406372, 0.4006699025630951, -0.38401877880096436, -0.5294711589813232, -0.23015061020851135, -0.2751724421977997, 0.14379635453224182, -0.025900142267346382, 0.3578055500984192, -0.005019477568566799, 0.19814205169677734, 0.38721904158592224, -0.36778759956359863, 0.42330777645111084, -0.5611974596977234, 0.12734311819076538, 0.8931811451911926, 0.27623486518859863, -0.1956523060798645, 0.09683963656425476, -0.4402909278869629, -0.5828282237052917, -0.6832805275917053, 0.6146112680435181, 0.5181353688240051, 0.546493411064148, 0.05156247690320015, 0.22049596905708313, -0.46300795674324036, 0.6532272696495056, 0.05600626394152641, -0.4797699749469757, 0.4682419002056122, 0.07273337244987488, -0.04922367259860039, 0.2311909794807434, 0.35202717781066895, 0.3788142204284668, 0.42711859941482544, -0.26047831773757935, -0.4343787431716919, 0.010522245429456234, 0.46945762634277344, -0.8469194173812866, -0.09334785491228104, 0.43396273255348206, -0.5181363224983215, -0.4721969962120056, 0.023658931255340576, -0.6193668842315674, -0.46465736627578735, -0.48991602659225464, 0.2963297367095947, -0.2405148595571518, -0.38687965273857117, 0.13213282823562622, -0.04262972250580788, 0.028263987973332405, 0.11021432280540466, -0.9801347851753235, 0.48185762763023376, 0.8443354368209839, 0.42539140582084656, -0.459339439868927, -0.46932658553123474, -0.8135455846786499, -0.19795797765254974, -0.38555458188056946, 0.8141222596168518, -0.4551958441734314, -0.589748203754425, 0.008817387744784355, -0.20403000712394714, -0.15235081315040588, -0.649587869644165, 0.7814961075782776, -0.7148779034614563, 0.19288423657417297, -0.26411816477775574, -0.7725266218185425, -0.22760100662708282, 0.3194691240787506, -0.7129288911819458, 1.3302035331726074, 0.23350580036640167, -0.5910804271697998, 0.7239102125167847, -0.5979595184326172, -0.3982822597026825, 0.03544284775853157, 0.019853193312883377, -0.8983686566352844, -0.08538038283586502, 0.09508483111858368, 0.13121691346168518, -0.3997763693332672, 0.6649746894836426, -0.30004778504371643, -0.5886287093162537, 0.27577826380729675, -0.21341988444328308, 0.38863807916641235, 0.37638458609580994, -0.3470134139060974, 0.5464442372322083, -0.6764998435974121, 0.1944299042224884, 0.14361059665679932, -0.5804285407066345, -0.21233391761779785, 0.2823323607444763, 0.1487414538860321, 0.3013450503349304, -0.35241976380348206, -0.6021873950958252, 0.39359691739082336, -0.42482492327690125, 0.4110844135284424, 0.9876371622085571, 0.09037744253873825, 0.5473539233207703, -0.6598690152168274, 0.568714439868927, -0.02863067016005516, 0.35356566309928894, -0.20088303089141846, -0.3814067244529724, -0.4883858859539032, -0.26919302344322205, 0.7087136507034302, 0.40092480182647705, -0.6681784391403198, 0.2935011386871338, -0.17826175689697266, -0.27934297919273376, -0.7587084174156189, 0.1069481372833252, 0.2777390480041504, 0.5903424620628357, 0.4152851402759552, -0.5292443037033081, -0.2658894658088684, -0.6352043747901917, -0.1673649251461029, -0.09086184948682785, 0.15526174008846283, 0.11139977723360062, 0.2829292416572571, -0.10393638908863068, 0.7762514352798462, -0.42671599984169006, -0.5339211821556091, -0.02301209792494774, 0.45914286375045776, 0.05220453813672066, 0.7532278299331665, 0.25169408321380615, -0.6770530343055725, -0.29910793900489807, -0.25937601923942566, -0.26916754245758057, 0.27807581424713135, -0.14682906866073608, 0.12462759017944336, 0.4709474742412567, 0.48124387860298157, -0.11094854027032852, 0.6925618648529053, 0.23494938015937805, -0.25311723351478577, 0.16309921443462372, -0.38156765699386597, 0.2832781672477722, -0.22684192657470703, 0.04905413091182709, 0.046385906636714935, -0.23205576837062836, -0.3461635112762451, -0.060117658227682114, 0.018509313464164734, -0.025692766532301903, -0.16411419212818146, 0.6328232288360596, -0.1325700581073761, -0.06170143932104111, -0.5268909335136414, -0.14625124633312225, -0.24481508135795593, 1.02162766456604, 0.0866372212767601, 0.5544271469116211, 0.3833930492401123, -0.6925756931304932, 0.2065676599740982, -0.10529031604528427, -0.2928358316421509, 0.5477063059806824, -0.5114144086837769, 0.11182920634746552, -0.5658350586891174, 0.27128681540489197, -1.065611481666565, -0.07015865296125412, 0.34884485602378845, -0.44704142212867737, 0.5118614435195923, -0.0006195370806381106, -0.22972923517227173, -0.3641129732131958, -0.7695673704147339, 0.4971798062324524, 0.43869271874427795, -0.6144062280654907, 0.34032684564590454, 0.5668103694915771, -0.19444966316223145, -0.5243633389472961, -0.2240350991487503, -0.09859472513198853, -0.39183372259140015, -0.3736218214035034, 0.5642653107643127, -0.08687763661146164, -0.15930713713169098, 0.06453651189804077, 0.08600359410047531, -0.04750613495707512, 0.21148523688316345, 0.3415498733520508, 0.15707215666770935, 0.19803406298160553, 0.2978135049343109, -0.17360122501850128, -0.7602742314338684, -0.07469004392623901, -0.27719005942344666, 0.40888723731040955, 0.2465866208076477, -0.33088621497154236, -0.48800355195999146, 0.40561169385910034, 0.3130263388156891, -0.15698404610157013, 0.5842567682266235, 0.6087924242019653, -0.24192963540554047, -0.10523172467947006, -0.38759419322013855, -0.5830104351043701, -0.45962485671043396, 0.15459878742694855, -0.28131118416786194, -0.5884807109832764, 0.32048162817955017, -0.09471610933542252, 0.26645129919052124, 0.22632604837417603, 0.3829672336578369, 0.04831875488162041, 1.284354567527771, 0.8256844878196716, -0.36814871430397034, 0.7983053922653198, -0.20802508294582367, 0.14683575928211212, -0.33541879057884216, -0.49945181608200073, -0.6443396210670471, -0.4096541702747345, -0.7196522951126099, -0.22235460579395294, 0.3796815574169159, -0.11732716113328934, -0.48835691809654236, -0.34047096967697144, -0.4238511323928833, 0.27713561058044434, 0.8963473439216614, 0.3528415560722351, 0.29333803057670593, 0.03926659747958183, 0.10161271691322327, -0.21688151359558105, -0.814988911151886, 0.11470132321119308, 1.0096089839935303, 0.6093792915344238, 1.032264232635498, -0.2016119509935379, 0.5978786945343018, 0.5822522640228271, 0.24033859372138977, -0.9201706647872925, -0.09422948211431503, 0.00007777217251714319, -0.2934666872024536, -0.5361887812614441, -0.23179839551448822, -0.856450080871582, -0.04170900583267212, -0.21147266030311584, -0.6746281385421753, 0.34849774837493896, 0.3139779269695282, -0.3808973729610443, 0.08127690851688385, -0.4182623326778412, 0.7734700441360474, -0.22048062086105347, -0.5749303102493286, -0.4334235191345215, -0.8004651665687561, 0.18537460267543793, 0.19863608479499817, 0.35653766989707947, -0.09506430476903915, 0.27631497383117676, 0.9511086344718933, -0.5371041893959045, 0.6424357891082764, -0.4677850902080536, -0.05723071098327637, -0.01595030538737774, -0.16642366349697113, 0.6642652750015259, 0.017155347391963005, -0.23369386792182922, -0.280882865190506, -0.16563159227371216, -0.7848135232925415, -0.46013903617858887, 0.6779012084007263, -0.7417401075363159, -0.38031917810440063, -0.520112931728363, -0.5695133805274963, -0.308546781539917, -0.15492410957813263, 0.10146605223417282, 0.5313284993171692, 0.17129486799240112, -0.011001919396221638, 0.8395799398422241, -0.08673305064439774, 0.3379727602005005, 0.2381594181060791, -0.43809422850608826, -0.37605589628219604, 1.0664318799972534, 0.035900890827178955, 0.19274799525737762, 0.18944577872753143, 0.23926721513271332, -0.40838295221328735, -0.4038364589214325, -0.563683271408081, 0.13327042758464813, -0.683279812335968, -0.22265517711639404, -0.290096253156662, -0.12534700334072113, -0.2971300184726715, -0.13127321004867554, -0.5551286935806274, -0.504737377166748, -0.017897652462124825, -0.15169744193553925, 0.657501757144928, 0.8687757849693298, -0.27214184403419495, 0.29954805970191956, -0.376950740814209, 0.2526673972606659, 0.18959923088550568, 0.7268010377883911, 0.10276152938604355, -0.5050851702690125, -0.37340426445007324, 0.018095744773745537, -0.009313945658504963, -0.48784956336021423, 0.4471319019794464, 0.13775570690631866, 0.7652872800827026, 0.38157880306243896, 0.20391976833343506, 0.7835041880607605, -0.02420102246105671, 0.47459882497787476, -0.08185072243213654, -0.5605365633964539, 0.19373819231987, -0.09178825467824936, 0.3360013961791992, 0.7969149351119995, 0.45051705837249756, -0.5556754469871521, 0.09283795952796936, -0.5533977150917053, -1.1515973806381226, 0.9257714748382568, -0.31251364946365356, -0.3282957077026367, 0.4833739399909973, 0.6134108901023865, 0.1857680082321167, 0.3200083076953888, -0.48812347650527954, -0.49750640988349915, -0.26944196224212646, -0.1370057761669159, -0.21471907198429108, -0.35589054226875305, -0.15904803574085236, -0.5002047419548035, 0.9759942889213562, -0.25360798835754395, 0.15316595137119293, -0.03294157236814499, -0.026814011856913567, -0.6231667995452881, 0.08030176162719727, 0.6025041937828064, 0.5816823244094849, -0.414267361164093, -0.20511537790298462, -0.27939385175704956, -0.24671922624111176, -0.02799317054450512, 0.12798967957496643, -0.24669797718524933, -0.4905332326889038, -0.0151586988940835, 1.0796653032302856, 0.2548469007015228, -0.708640992641449, 0.24353821575641632, -0.16271694004535675, -0.18000945448875427, -0.18891875445842743, 0.0535513311624527, -0.19661669433116913, 0.14748486876487732, 0.6105251908302307, -0.17470835149288177, 0.1931358426809311, -0.5793566703796387, 0.48952516913414, 0.21613778173923492, -0.7760354280471802, 0.05511866509914398, 0.46779510378837585, 0.032693035900592804, -0.4681992530822754, 0.813709557056427, -0.12471568584442139, -0.6491736769676208, 0.635212242603302, 0.36677321791648865, 0.6760731339454651, -0.2968968451023102, 0.3790150284767151, 0.5833370089530945, 0.03227755427360535, -0.27447810769081116, 0.2120177447795868, -0.4006107747554779, -0.4497602880001068, -0.4878702461719513, -0.43240517377853394, -0.4338982403278351, -0.040925152599811554, -0.9197319149971008, 0.11976680159568787, -0.46993499994277954, -0.07464194297790527, -0.07716625183820724, 0.15622742474079132, -0.5360247492790222, 0.3147604465484619, 0.0639730840921402, 0.7757422924041748, -0.869767427444458, 0.9929126501083374, 0.3911117911338806, -0.40838268399238586, -0.7553573250770569, -0.18216590583324432, 0.08344971388578415, -0.8525594472885132, 0.8156028985977173, -0.02596491202712059, 0.02050074376165867, 0.32360586524009705, -0.5165131092071533, -0.9399414658546448, 0.8969393968582153, -0.1687682569026947, -0.31227684020996094, 0.11925448477268219, 0.03668671473860741, 0.30438345670700073, -0.3454142212867737, 0.28674620389938354, 1.0458776950836182, 0.6933584213256836, 0.29649895429611206, -0.9108588099479675, -0.14496375620365143, -0.32876700162887573, -0.02835655026137829, 0.34477102756500244, -0.2592933177947998, 0.8655898571014404, -0.3854677975177765, -0.131252259016037, -0.11862261593341827, 0.3535434901714325, 0.384133517742157, 0.21339204907417297, 0.6744294762611389, 0.7438650727272034, 0.7232765555381775, -0.17889666557312012, 1.0817298889160156, -0.051301490515470505, 0.5321032404899597, 0.9526672959327698, -0.21668393909931183, 0.7086079716682434, 0.6292007565498352, -0.24485214054584503, 0.5244722366333008, 1.1049243211746216, 0.31953057646751404, 0.961401104927063, 0.5326539874076843, 0.07719690352678299, -0.15289127826690674, -0.27804067730903625, -0.39206910133361816, 0.12373291701078415, 0.3616843819618225, 0.1891622543334961, -0.5540322661399841, 0.36027565598487854, -0.0054382034577429295, 0.27115142345428467, -0.3263527750968933, 1.0587162971496582, -0.17525997757911682, -0.9270918369293213, 0.8043256402015686, 0.07166227698326111, 0.7590299844741821, -0.5427721738815308, -0.20635491609573364, -0.24667425453662872, 0.32592830061912537, -0.15934951603412628, -0.6054174900054932, 0.03758029267191887, -0.43514660000801086, -0.1228705570101738, -0.43800169229507446, 0.5251264572143555, -0.5956740975379944, -0.20209090411663055, 0.35819539427757263, 0.2166377454996109, -0.19968655705451965, -0.03441028669476509, -0.9832597374916077, 0.3290207087993622, -0.047357406467199326, -0.458102285861969, 0.4660762846469879, 0.018930690363049507, -0.15533994138240814, 0.9926424026489258, 0.5840190052986145, 0.00022626637655775994, -0.08970250934362411, 0.11680057644844055, 0.9523657560348511, -0.846990168094635, -0.9573974013328552, -0.5748693943023682, 0.6969696879386902, -0.028134996071457863, -0.278499037027359, 0.28700199723243713, 0.2903754413127899, 0.8904818892478943, 0.28348979353904724, 0.5109058618545532, 0.20961590111255646, 0.7864686846733093, -0.5477973818778992, 0.29473674297332764, -0.582958459854126, 0.3189849853515625, -0.03929281607270241, -0.47285833954811096, -0.236965611577034, 0.5307809114456177, -0.31364706158638, 0.13035574555397034, 0.5698897838592529, 0.7178381681442261, 0.3095932900905609, 0.09687253832817078, 0.20288126170635223, -0.14271141588687897, 0.2846924364566803, 0.40681153535842896, 0.6428624391555786, -0.4208267331123352, -0.005310057196766138, -0.6586661338806152, -0.20236359536647797, -0.5033842921257019, -0.9104272127151489, -0.4616107940673828, -0.7544547915458679, -0.35404738783836365, -0.3802146017551422, 0.26864299178123474, 1.1542561054229736, 0.8220689296722412, -0.9533219337463379, -0.421137273311615, -0.005115191452205181, 0.41304630041122437, -0.5467108488082886, -0.2753417491912842, 0.4662901759147644, -0.5916944146156311, -0.6550343036651611, 0.22623330354690552, 0.29414597153663635, -0.20088936388492584, -0.5385482311248779, -0.35704541206359863, -0.3071564733982086, -0.197623610496521, 0.31248950958251953, 0.7066270709037781, -0.29537129402160645, -0.12868086993694305, -0.1826581060886383, -0.049452412873506546, 0.30807462334632874, 1.1295199394226074, -1.3093270063400269, 0.4890536665916443, 0.4026271402835846, 0.8983361721038818, 0.831292986869812, 0.287557452917099, 0.5390997529029846, -0.5201540589332581, 0.41310665011405945, 0.034807898104190826, 0.05698341503739357, 0.4299902617931366, -0.5200199484825134, 0.4738181233406067, 0.137862890958786, -0.7289298176765442, -0.956912100315094, 0.16037887334823608, -0.7478099465370178, -0.4769863784313202, 0.8405528664588928, 0.05410432070493698, -0.3127199411392212, -0.38760390877723694, -0.12796787917613983, 0.05790998041629791, -0.796911358833313, 1.2332448959350586, 0.4029262363910675, -0.1849367618560791, -0.0640704333782196, -0.5886886119842529, 1.0715091228485107, 0.5423105955123901, -0.7651561498641968, 0.09160440415143967, 0.3100340664386749, 0.10864774882793427, -0.181965172290802, 0.9073464274406433, -0.05602402612566948, 0.4534895122051239, -0.24070551991462708, -0.06897513568401337, -0.1726338118314743, -0.4619167149066925, -0.6252484917640686, 0.21652652323246002, 0.538021445274353, -0.23812125623226166 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16332v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16332v3	Tradeoffs Between Alignment and Helpfulness in Language Models with Representation Engineering	2024-01-29T17:38:14	2024-05-26T16:07:55	Yotam Wolf, Noam Wies, Dorin Shteyman, Binyamin Rothberg, Yoav Levine, Amnon Shashua	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Language model alignment has become an important component of AI safety, allowing safe interactions between humans and language models, by enhancing desired behaviors and inhibiting undesired ones. It is often done by tuning the model or inserting preset aligning prompts. Recently, representation engineering, a method which alters the model's behavior via changing its representations post-training, was shown to be effective in aligning LLMs (Zou et al., 2023a). Representation engineering yields gains in alignment oriented tasks such as resistance to adversarial attacks and reduction of social biases, but was also shown to cause a decrease in the ability of the model to perform basic tasks. In this paper we study the tradeoff between the increase in alignment and decrease in helpfulness of the model. We propose a theoretical framework which provides bounds for these two quantities, and demonstrate their relevance empirically. First, we find that under the conditions of our framework, alignment can be guaranteed with representation engineering, and at the same time that helpfulness is harmed in the process. Second, we show that helpfulness is harmed quadratically with the norm of the representation engineering vector, while the alignment increases linearly with it, indicating a regime in which it is efficient to use representation engineering. We validate our findings empirically, and chart the boundaries to the usefulness of representation engineering for alignment.	[ -0.16781440377235413, -0.34193164110183716, 0.5937283635139465, 0.041102901101112366, -0.0004587044531945139, -0.1208728700876236, -0.29035937786102295, -0.5641676187515259, 0.12491681426763535, 0.1810440570116043, -0.22319293022155762, -0.07093996554613113, -0.725605309009552, -0.153132364153862, -0.2526906728744507, 0.8256572484970093, -0.09306112676858902, 0.2620585858821869, -0.43378710746765137, -0.22979266941547394, -0.8688850402832031, -0.6711441278457642, -0.4547463059425354, -0.2814399302005768, 0.5994693636894226, 0.06516581773757935, 1.205249547958374, 1.1330900192260742, 0.7509220838546753, 0.3407779037952423, 0.02040073089301586, -0.2894320785999298, -0.4362853169441223, 0.3534369468688965, 0.019711768254637718, -0.5714752078056335, -0.589887797832489, 0.14300864934921265, 0.5239532589912415, 0.7930619716644287, 0.031300731003284454, -0.0545455627143383, 0.33485060930252075, 0.5507681369781494, -0.7122586965560913, 0.16693633794784546, -0.6091233491897583, -0.297414630651474, -0.17444853484630585, 0.12658797204494476, -0.271463543176651, -0.1783997118473053, -0.12036256492137909, -0.6763865351676941, -0.2269083559513092, 0.04201623424887657, 1.0082920789718628, 0.6250078678131104, -0.24491238594055176, -0.14250677824020386, -0.653441846370697, 0.9113187193870544, -0.6988325119018555, 0.5516893267631531, 0.28271862864494324, 0.28844112157821655, -0.1657949835062027, -0.33428657054901123, -0.37319833040237427, -0.3864299952983856, -0.1921270489692688, -0.13551892340183258, -0.27642616629600525, 0.42293956875801086, 0.5131810903549194, 0.17697195708751678, -0.45980483293533325, 0.4033379554748535, -0.06603269279003143, -0.5104169845581055, 0.7019733190536499, 0.0408380851149559, 0.7178182005882263, -0.15605805814266205, -0.4191736578941345, -0.4175651967525482, -0.8321723937988281, 0.1040448546409607, 0.4356483817100525, 0.36702558398246765, 0.14658083021640778, 0.7341580390930176, 0.3066762685775757, 0.6060026288032532, 0.05057673901319504, 0.1529984027147293, -0.0748160257935524, -0.36916089057922363, -0.16407768428325653, -0.08871053904294968, 0.6662193536758423, 0.5200430154800415, 0.33951640129089355, -0.2093140184879303, -0.4324631989002228, 0.4693044126033783, 0.5379770994186401, -0.5048816800117493, 0.021872442215681076, -0.09139002859592438, -0.5920932292938232, -0.19486962258815765, 0.0482262559235096, -0.24340495467185974, -0.4922167658805847, -0.6374192833900452, 0.300293505191803, -0.4343012869358063, -0.1692439615726471, -0.013323583640158176, 0.07621655613183975, 0.3796462416648865, 0.2125914841890335, -1.07293701171875, 0.23778678476810455, 0.8847371935844421, 0.858117938041687, -0.2927403151988983, -0.20053879916667938, -0.6137307286262512, 0.09982888400554657, -0.356389582157135, 0.5405011177062988, -0.5634211897850037, -0.4015156626701355, -0.15493299067020416, -0.2814749777317047, -0.2015516608953476, -0.5147477984428406, 0.5006933808326721, -0.4876462519168854, -0.06915727257728577, -0.4661240577697754, -0.7920212745666504, 0.0013993768952786922, 0.039370011538267136, -0.8548017740249634, 0.7739715576171875, -0.04796364903450012, -0.639181911945343, 0.1805821657180786, -0.46540501713752747, -0.38132765889167786, -0.2127416878938675, -0.4554499685764313, -0.471282958984375, 0.24715526401996613, 0.14467379450798035, 0.35630863904953003, -0.10808030515909195, 0.23295098543167114, -0.6290518045425415, -0.46003445982933044, 0.39050111174583435, -0.18948696553707123, 0.9283129572868347, 0.1655023992061615, -0.3001621961593628, 0.17256556451320648, -0.42388972640037537, -0.12447618693113327, 0.10657384246587753, -0.09665483236312866, -0.6164308190345764, 0.1416158378124237, -0.1509273648262024, 0.23400035500526428, 0.2544935345649719, -0.33243006467819214, 0.411342978477478, -0.5299907922744751, 0.15765978395938873, 1.0113437175750732, -0.26009443402290344, 0.9973746538162231, -0.43836620450019836, 0.8119534254074097, -0.31465014815330505, 0.10135699808597565, 0.24312962591648102, -0.3951496481895447, -0.5085040926933289, -0.31792783737182617, 0.456655353307724, 0.6089896559715271, -0.5314841270446777, 0.39454811811447144, -0.11673084646463394, -0.1842881590127945, -0.6536672115325928, 0.0009221547516062856, 0.32595616579055786, 0.31727972626686096, 0.1890537440776825, -0.20874062180519104, -0.7159982919692993, -1.041002869606018, -0.3811820149421692, -0.4379076659679413, -0.06490769982337952, -0.1812470257282257, 0.15271182358264923, -0.030205417424440384, 0.9069210886955261, -0.20327116549015045, 0.006079234182834625, -0.06265594810247421, -0.2060927003622055, -0.05440765619277954, 0.5933164954185486, 0.8714503645896912, -0.7016551494598389, -0.3667390048503876, -0.05230589210987091, -0.6979265213012695, -0.3639358580112457, -0.20203566551208496, -0.3250068724155426, 0.17359784245491028, 0.3590414524078369, -0.7012376189231873, 0.47719985246658325, 0.5074243545532227, -0.11215197294950485, 0.42612501978874207, 0.08980413526296616, 0.04975063353776932, -1.0930947065353394, -0.025170844048261642, 0.019879823550581932, -0.2172679454088211, -0.8792600035667419, 0.24978679418563843, 0.029789261519908905, -0.20609545707702637, -0.014289507642388344, 0.5229284167289734, -0.565178632736206, -0.14542347192764282, -0.5262726545333862, 0.13949662446975708, -0.1853286772966385, 0.305984765291214, -0.057811181992292404, 0.9362242221832275, 0.48547935485839844, -0.39868003129959106, -0.09453517943620682, 0.08749551326036453, -0.07164518535137177, 0.5977895855903625, -0.7168322205543518, 0.19899670779705048, 0.1049204021692276, -0.29443177580833435, -0.9867562055587769, 0.07530399411916733, 0.33167126774787903, -0.363506942987442, 0.682744026184082, 0.015215083956718445, -0.2941235601902008, 0.0923805683851242, -0.4275396764278412, 0.4258091151714325, 0.439167320728302, -0.39151501655578613, 0.48574116826057434, 0.5290417075157166, -0.22200047969818115, -0.663887619972229, -0.45885664224624634, 0.017565634101629257, -0.38941052556037903, -0.8546218276023865, 0.5956721901893616, -0.054479941725730896, -0.44892510771751404, -0.0489811897277832, -0.2722054123878479, 0.3448028266429901, 0.377715528011322, 0.20385724306106567, 0.46539604663848877, -0.15496490895748138, 0.029651809483766556, -0.004527538549154997, -0.4153580665588379, 0.21939878165721893, -0.003129806835204363, 0.21525433659553528, -0.08757887780666351, -0.6736457943916321, -0.2685084939002991, 0.4596286416053772, 0.3686971962451935, -0.22803927958011627, 0.7489969730377197, 0.18946242332458496, -0.5884392261505127, 0.37036046385765076, -0.3787775933742523, -0.3000561594963074, -0.49939489364624023, 0.4756091833114624, -0.17039313912391663, -0.8346180319786072, 0.5433942079544067, 0.19084618985652924, 0.26678574085235596, 0.3879428207874298, 0.3666806221008301, -0.17342638969421387, 1.5118383169174194, 0.7202898859977722, -0.26452162861824036, 0.7876065969467163, 0.11509980261325836, 0.5454870462417603, -0.8543128371238708, 0.18805620074272156, -0.6834169626235962, -0.4101412892341614, -0.7990128993988037, -0.062333378940820694, 0.18289829790592194, 0.271416574716568, -0.21087096631526947, 0.47837287187576294, -0.6450555324554443, 0.21715863049030304, 0.4851507842540741, -0.20578007400035858, 0.11288692057132721, 0.022342178970575333, 0.10671381652355194, -0.4556511640548706, -0.7021139860153198, -0.8509777784347534, 0.85224449634552, 0.49129894375801086, 0.8571329116821289, 0.32773658633232117, 0.9134870171546936, 0.22634053230285645, 0.37950196862220764, -0.8660023808479309, 0.6307097673416138, 0.020055292174220085, -0.3078150749206543, -0.24528701603412628, -0.3190058469772339, -0.965035080909729, 0.12619321048259735, -0.32371217012405396, -0.8672686219215393, 0.3208109438419342, 0.48616671562194824, -0.06528767943382263, 0.09587139636278152, -0.8935079574584961, 0.8703623414039612, -0.48020562529563904, -0.16663594543933868, -0.12517474591732025, -0.7178022265434265, 0.020493460819125175, 0.14933209121227264, 0.11728406697511673, 0.11472781002521515, 0.041120849549770355, 0.6983584761619568, -0.48095330595970154, 0.8544626235961914, -0.25735437870025635, -0.11738455295562744, -0.11387922614812851, 0.07366497814655304, 0.7820060849189758, -0.3351972997188568, -0.21371343731880188, 0.08043786883354187, 0.07413280010223389, -0.498663991689682, -0.9774942398071289, 0.5256061553955078, -0.8399953842163086, -1.0518429279327393, -0.4989243447780609, -0.7491634488105774, -0.16954481601715088, 0.21420042216777802, 0.10248580574989319, 0.05550497770309448, -0.23633183538913727, -0.052169594913721085, 0.49405190348625183, 0.00797292497009039, 0.27203282713890076, -0.0790480375289917, -0.2560879588127136, -0.2390824407339096, 0.955991804599762, 0.2623530626296997, 0.5276768207550049, 0.29095906019210815, 0.04704837501049042, -0.32310861349105835, -0.6304693222045898, -0.3277098536491394, 0.25600665807724, -0.8117199540138245, -0.25103631615638733, -0.18384341895580292, -0.22963464260101318, -0.4292265474796295, -0.2476671040058136, -0.21716968715190887, -0.5777620077133179, -0.3928156793117523, -0.1672734171152115, 0.03256102278828621, 0.696768581867218, -0.10375247150659561, 0.11563622951507568, -0.4853847622871399, -0.12486892193555832, 0.09811238944530487, 0.13316436111927032, -0.08865385502576828, -0.39322590827941895, -0.44556817412376404, 0.33028924465179443, -0.394721657037735, -1.081454873085022, -0.21608109772205353, -0.07702358067035675, 0.7710062265396118, 0.4014245569705963, 0.023810964077711105, 0.6468752026557922, -0.339209645986557, 0.5929083824157715, 0.1208861842751503, -0.9870455861091614, 0.10619212687015533, -0.218903586268425, 0.08888497203588486, 0.33723098039627075, 0.06503037363290787, -0.5484333634376526, -0.512413740158081, -0.5351186394691467, -0.7019109725952148, 0.4970146417617798, 0.5106890797615051, 0.14974600076675415, 0.11316294223070145, 0.5372162461280823, -0.14949952065944672, -0.007763904519379139, -0.7627273797988892, -0.24189814925193787, -0.32601746916770935, -0.42489176988601685, 0.280693382024765, -0.24290014803409576, -0.053443264216184616, -0.12226156145334244, 0.8690007925033569, -0.06570074707269669, 0.5407789349555969, -0.3290984332561493, -0.3122982978820801, 0.06300131976604462, 0.3044615685939789, 0.7059255242347717, 0.477237343788147, 0.1266132891178131, 0.1274919956922531, 0.04073252156376839, -0.16343802213668823, 0.23770350217819214, 0.5395996570587158, -0.19334502518177032, -0.35073238611221313, 0.5783777236938477, 0.8858165144920349, 0.057655688375234604, -0.26409024000167847, 0.44008955359458923, 0.027363425120711327, 0.16228614747524261, 0.2088390290737152, 0.2830832004547119, 0.16894954442977905, 0.28564026951789856, 0.09204418212175369, 0.12020701169967651, 0.08358944952487946, -0.17717207968235016, 0.07410657405853271, 0.8976149559020996, -0.08954367786645889, -0.24121412634849548, 0.7529260516166687, 0.0010613718768581748, -0.6440660357475281, 0.4338345527648926, -0.007439760956913233, -0.4272361695766449, 0.6541202068328857, 0.6113755702972412, 0.8221162557601929, -0.28362131118774414, 0.06555144488811493, 0.13155639171600342, 0.3982841968536377, 0.07150492072105408, -0.08606332540512085, 0.04114621877670288, -0.9459385275840759, -0.5235050320625305, -0.264273077249527, -0.25869637727737427, -0.1350013017654419, -0.8865678310394287, 0.14169149100780487, -0.07752779871225357, -0.3334023952484131, -0.042539291083812714, -0.1998036801815033, -0.4333423376083374, -0.10342486947774887, 0.23348480463027954, 0.5260052680969238, -0.8690434098243713, 0.5513652563095093, 1.0018174648284912, -0.48438042402267456, -1.0068351030349731, 0.22950682044029236, 0.004677454940974712, -0.8625541925430298, 0.34237271547317505, 0.25387927889823914, -0.20545287430286407, -0.24045152962207794, -0.42018771171569824, -1.074567198753357, 0.886967122554779, 1.0766123533248901, -0.7581528425216675, -0.1399507075548172, 0.28153568506240845, 0.711057722568512, -0.3231954872608185, -0.007303265389055014, 0.33475202322006226, 0.3506987988948822, -0.2566515803337097, -0.7070630788803101, 0.2799549996852875, -0.29053008556365967, 0.49987727403640747, 0.41829827427864075, -0.28891727328300476, 0.41897425055503845, -0.07275866717100143, -0.46401435136795044, 0.1858886480331421, 0.805342435836792, 0.3585253357887268, -0.006567245814949274, 0.7702546119689941, 0.39331451058387756, 0.7519846558570862, -0.1637888103723526, 1.170912504196167, -0.3881782591342926, 0.29137295484542847, 0.8997518420219421, -0.32637929916381836, 0.47846150398254395, 0.7675275206565857, -0.22579538822174072, 0.31183376908302307, 0.7632860541343689, 0.2902747690677643, 0.4797343611717224, 0.039618246257305145, -0.059194061905145645, -0.3580232560634613, -0.08116120100021362, -0.38300198316574097, 0.166758731007576, 0.15990199148654938, -0.24684683978557587, -0.08319050818681717, -0.0077718570828437805, 0.018558882176876068, 0.31044214963912964, -0.057982850819826126, 0.7222971320152283, 0.1832686960697174, -0.6755957007408142, 0.439771443605423, -0.12333965301513672, 0.3032127320766449, -0.4122510254383087, -0.12399947643280029, -0.07645892351865768, 0.04752696305513382, -0.2000879943370819, -0.7723146677017212, 0.4796355366706848, -0.285773903131485, -0.3837857246398926, -0.4395638406276703, 0.9637553095817566, -0.3861246407032013, -0.3455413579940796, 0.42337164282798767, 0.273635596036911, -0.1870943158864975, 0.1081683412194252, -0.8614866137504578, 0.2434656322002411, -0.03386605903506279, -0.18744271993637085, 0.5527788996696472, 0.018503710627555847, -0.29825079441070557, 0.359599769115448, 0.486804336309433, 0.1614847034215927, -0.15500430762767792, 0.04211420193314552, 0.8959436416625977, -0.25758057832717896, -0.3209775686264038, -1.05177903175354, 0.5553204417228699, -0.12022000551223755, 0.13373598456382751, 0.6426065564155579, 0.33560094237327576, 0.7511131763458252, 0.2644871771335602, 0.8605124950408936, -0.1037110835313797, 0.0913781002163887, -0.7186900973320007, 0.4748249053955078, -0.5845507383346558, 0.5404483675956726, -0.3431839942932129, -0.9479860663414001, -0.4996587336063385, 0.9295170903205872, -0.49767374992370605, 0.2591105103492737, 0.4503290355205536, 1.0526418685913086, -0.12657997012138367, -0.06579688936471939, 0.29587027430534363, -0.022827140986919403, 0.48428887128829956, 0.25527867674827576, 0.8026271462440491, -0.2358412891626358, 0.3186083137989044, -0.27533939480781555, -0.241057887673378, 0.03507693484425545, -0.9235755205154419, -0.8157208561897278, -0.7199568152427673, -0.24090313911437988, -0.5219641923904419, 0.16987308859825134, 1.082846999168396, 0.6149272322654724, -0.7319146990776062, -0.2481987178325653, 0.05157212167978287, 0.4035521447658539, -0.4216175675392151, -0.15411734580993652, 0.41781899333000183, -0.37074750661849976, -0.5884736776351929, 0.24786090850830078, 0.3126111924648285, 0.13076438009738922, -0.27637428045272827, -0.3757096230983734, -0.1118633821606636, -0.07188351452350616, 0.3140113949775696, 0.39301156997680664, -0.7405921816825867, -0.6812004446983337, 0.3817654252052307, -0.27698734402656555, 0.32314997911453247, 0.9113019704818726, -0.23610836267471313, 0.4864184260368347, 0.3580843210220337, 0.9918223023414612, 0.01308694388717413, 0.03045516461133957, 1.091262936592102, -0.7692238092422485, -0.007517479360103607, 0.09102983772754669, 0.6569849848747253, 0.5335897207260132, -0.6019858717918396, 0.3284000754356384, -0.06799475848674774, -0.7729654312133789, -0.8140767812728882, 0.5359398126602173, -0.6919664740562439, 0.0714063048362732, 1.0828512907028198, -0.01804889366030693, -0.010290337726473808, 0.17231878638267517, -0.377001017332077, 0.5021184682846069, -0.303312212228775, 0.8919429183006287, 0.8659802079200745, -0.3066914677619934, -0.18702682852745056, -0.14064611494541168, 0.4935351610183716, 0.8537686467170715, -0.7716293334960938, -0.06162896752357483, 0.46052974462509155, 0.07411053031682968, 0.2508276700973511, 0.4205872416496277, 0.17355132102966309, 0.2798213064670563, -0.5474001169204712, 0.16212978959083557, 0.10631125420331955, -0.030372323468327522, -0.5863096714019775, -0.2572370171546936, 0.6257986426353455, -0.29571932554244995 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16313v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16313v1	Machine Translation Meta Evaluation through Translation Accuracy Challenge Sets	2024-01-29T17:17:42	2024-01-29T17:17:42	Nikita Moghe, Arnisa Fazla, Chantal Amrhein, Tom Kocmi, Mark Steedman, Alexandra Birch, Rico Sennrich, Liane Guillou	cs.CL	cs.CL	Recent machine translation (MT) metrics calibrate their effectiveness by correlating with human judgement but without any insights about their behaviour across different error types. Challenge sets are used to probe specific dimensions of metric behaviour but there are very few such datasets and they either focus on a limited number of phenomena or a limited number of language pairs. We introduce ACES, a contrastive challenge set spanning 146 language pairs, aimed at discovering whether metrics can identify 68 translation accuracy errors. These phenomena range from simple alterations at the word/character level to more complex errors based on discourse and real-world knowledge. We conduct a large-scale study by benchmarking ACES on 50 metrics submitted to the WMT 2022 and 2023 metrics shared tasks. We benchmark metric performance, assess their incremental performance over successive campaigns, and measure their sensitivity to a range of linguistic phenomena. We also investigate claims that Large Language Models (LLMs) are effective as MT evaluators by evaluating on ACES. Our results demonstrate that different metric families struggle with different phenomena and that LLM-based methods fail to demonstrate reliable performance. Our analyses indicate that most metrics ignore the source sentence, tend to prefer surface-level overlap and end up incorporating properties of base models which are not always beneficial. We expand ACES to include error span annotations, denoted as SPAN-ACES and we use this dataset to evaluate span-based error metrics showing these metrics also need considerable improvement. Finally, we provide a set of recommendations for building better MT metrics, including focusing on error labels instead of scores, ensembling, designing strategies to explicitly focus on the source sentence, focusing on semantic content and choosing the right base model for representations.	[ -0.03275429829955101, -0.6498226523399353, 0.45095109939575195, 0.2442847043275833, -0.12238875031471252, 0.3803524374961853, -0.08615055680274963, -0.4583413600921631, 0.18205147981643677, 0.4097922146320343, -0.3754126727581024, -0.4902592599391937, -0.9649999737739563, 0.5593822598457336, -0.35279059410095215, 0.8690548539161682, -0.5442561507225037, 0.07260967046022415, -0.3898959755897522, -0.6628499627113342, -0.8755249381065369, -0.5047835111618042, -0.29841867089271545, 0.06931941956281662, 0.38500261306762695, 0.5703037977218628, 0.9483191967010498, 0.9417986273765564, 1.209863543510437, 0.2055622637271881, -0.05127759277820587, 0.551699697971344, -0.08835402876138687, -0.07415595650672913, -0.11685074865818024, -0.5410627722740173, -0.8257794380187988, -0.1207665354013443, 0.5759764909744263, 0.9245108366012573, 0.18978753685951233, 0.3284488320350647, 0.08436834812164307, 0.7557350397109985, -0.5634611248970032, 0.09149010479450226, -0.6493353247642517, 0.07504907250404358, -0.5852490663528442, -0.0926927924156189, -0.4462439715862274, -0.11594771593809128, -0.10202883183956146, -0.3964327871799469, 0.16466915607452393, 0.5205720067024231, 0.8495534062385559, 0.5324606895446777, -0.4813920259475708, -0.45191851258277893, -0.5365164279937744, 0.864540696144104, -0.692503809928894, 0.3647382855415344, 0.5694928765296936, 0.2388218194246292, 0.0637664869427681, -0.5504397749900818, -0.22743964195251465, -0.13394644856452942, -0.08468892425298691, 0.12839266657829285, -0.22469130158424377, 0.05026550963521004, 0.1081315129995346, 0.5608345866203308, -0.5272328853607178, 0.057799819856882095, -0.405864417552948, -0.14697317779064178, 0.3958672285079956, 0.45531025528907776, 0.2768494486808777, -0.2224244475364685, -0.12599104642868042, -0.12116802483797073, -0.6810405850410461, -0.12762843072414398, 0.3322424292564392, 0.3938153386116028, -0.14558131992816925, 0.8028998970985413, -0.024884697049856186, 0.6210290789604187, -0.14420191943645477, -0.07226582616567612, 0.5611497163772583, -0.3964681625366211, -0.08268564194440842, -0.37352418899536133, 0.934475302696228, 0.3311153054237366, 0.1264035999774933, -0.19834572076797485, -0.40330424904823303, -0.03945165127515793, 0.3516363501548767, -0.1955205351114273, -0.023493248969316483, 0.2781921923160553, -0.300660640001297, -0.1912841647863388, -0.05468081682920456, -0.4709649980068207, 0.009345563128590584, -0.3942834436893463, 0.517318844795227, -0.43210291862487793, 0.16911381483078003, -0.04321522265672684, -0.07699694484472275, -0.03773961588740349, 0.07938414067029953, -0.4544897973537445, 0.3298625648021698, 0.4938098192214966, 0.9183820486068726, -0.30694302916526794, -0.583758533000946, -0.8146753907203674, -0.024368569254875183, -0.6760079860687256, 0.5480103492736816, -0.5324856042861938, -0.28794288635253906, 0.10025991499423981, -0.058275315910577774, -0.13208289444446564, -0.5766519904136658, 0.7779892683029175, -0.3260786533355713, -0.03071596845984459, -0.6299186944961548, -0.36727485060691833, -0.15067699551582336, 0.3752190172672272, -0.682181715965271, 1.1014114618301392, -0.01681528240442276, -0.6658155918121338, 0.3360545337200165, -0.9431641697883606, -0.5877859592437744, -0.12753534317016602, 0.19074617326259613, -0.5731343626976013, 0.5094189047813416, 0.4182763695716858, 0.1914832592010498, -0.20388932526111603, 0.11817856132984161, -0.22772246599197388, -0.41367313265800476, 0.14297939836978912, -0.4815722703933716, 0.5070077180862427, 0.14584991335868835, -0.3666350245475769, 0.1198650375008583, -0.47235986590385437, -0.21788577735424042, 0.03223702311515808, -0.19424568116664886, -0.255493700504303, 0.0640701875090599, -0.16117361187934875, 0.043613214045763016, 0.04981451481580734, -0.24816299974918365, 0.04132897034287453, -0.03760046884417534, 0.14550241827964783, 0.6211903095245361, -0.21260949969291687, -0.05346684530377388, -0.3151613473892212, 0.4726092219352722, 0.14924435317516327, 0.233561173081398, -0.11334873735904694, -0.4817712604999542, -0.8622515797615051, 0.06551726162433624, 0.5879071950912476, 0.6331141591072083, -0.9272704720497131, 0.5586636066436768, -0.6311372518539429, -0.3102323114871979, -1.0344725847244263, 0.2212049812078476, 0.6611638069152832, 0.3887839913368225, 0.5809255838394165, -0.4812958836555481, -0.4101179242134094, -0.9562065005302429, -0.5849369764328003, -0.06576273590326309, 0.17080390453338623, 0.1696673482656479, 0.7173177599906921, -0.13759967684745789, 0.5976384878158569, -0.23826982080936432, -0.3638997972011566, -0.13825616240501404, 0.33766230940818787, -0.07062080502510071, 0.289802610874176, 0.33001917600631714, -0.6042267680168152, -0.6207341551780701, 0.12565451860427856, -0.877686619758606, -0.16419735550880432, 0.30142366886138916, 0.14633159339427948, 0.1842833310365677, 0.44776415824890137, -0.23203489184379578, 0.3797808289527893, 0.7707339525222778, -0.1655764877796173, 0.5880314707756042, -0.23880143463611603, 0.5650560855865479, -0.830424427986145, 0.36236387491226196, -0.2879893481731415, -0.4927273988723755, -0.24588437378406525, 0.2768639326095581, 0.13004273176193237, 0.18017883598804474, -0.4344615340232849, 0.26833510398864746, -0.4284078776836395, -0.30863937735557556, -0.19152703881263733, 0.19518816471099854, -0.007501833140850067, 0.4526838958263397, -0.2456815093755722, 0.8525466322898865, 0.0887124314904213, -0.4886220395565033, 0.39215752482414246, 0.2862219214439392, -0.23694998025894165, 0.961625337600708, -0.6985297799110413, 0.41819557547569275, -0.19997182488441467, 0.11571024358272552, -1.0561273097991943, -0.25411805510520935, 0.28468748927116394, -0.48155295848846436, 0.3035275936126709, 0.10154401510953903, -0.7805460095405579, -0.4531345069408417, -0.1785963773727417, 0.5046653747558594, 0.414726197719574, -0.34799841046333313, 0.2564707398414612, 0.22289025783538818, -0.05555371940135956, -0.9124504327774048, -0.6852487921714783, 0.3833274245262146, -0.1316562294960022, -0.28365761041641235, 0.1608186811208725, -0.12191915512084961, -0.37478014826774597, 0.15293636918067932, -0.12505963444709778, 0.1465642899274826, 0.09686090052127838, 0.24324363470077515, 0.0059900968335568905, -0.21796725690364838, 0.2528876066207886, 0.1076320931315422, -0.0826752707362175, -0.028782859444618225, -0.07436530292034149, 0.223246768116951, -0.38539597392082214, -0.6378964781761169, -0.41394904255867004, 0.2421191930770874, 0.7209597229957581, -0.4508516788482666, 0.8429985046386719, 0.5630322098731995, -0.3477407395839691, 0.4676165282726288, -0.6073465347290039, 0.15770651400089264, -0.3129541575908661, 0.5471193194389343, -0.6383256316184998, -0.36824822425842285, 0.5251296162605286, 0.16512884199619293, 0.5243614315986633, 0.9379246234893799, 0.15707702934741974, -0.3134536147117615, 0.837458610534668, 0.3810271918773651, -0.16615508496761322, 0.13030368089675903, -0.07458912581205368, -0.07874079793691635, -0.9771255850791931, -0.06046929955482483, -0.723018229007721, -0.6088014841079712, -0.24162860214710236, -0.5462541580200195, 0.4852159917354584, -0.09398696571588516, -0.018212907016277313, 0.5199261903762817, -0.06725798547267914, 0.6208101511001587, 0.4083636999130249, 0.18249382078647614, 0.49787914752960205, -0.07484278827905655, -0.1260145753622055, -0.44539254903793335, -0.612424910068512, -0.5682112574577332, 1.416396975517273, 0.48021775484085083, 0.09992539882659912, 0.11979137361049652, 0.217906653881073, 0.6692863702774048, 0.7652977705001831, -0.5868765115737915, 0.16726532578468323, -0.43787840008735657, -0.7571065425872803, -0.08059023320674896, -0.6071571111679077, -0.8105548024177551, 0.16948384046554565, -0.2208370566368103, -0.2115018665790558, -0.2786543369293213, 0.23254503309726715, -0.017742929980158806, 0.4627784192562103, -0.5592144131660461, 0.9061117172241211, -0.3302060067653656, -0.19079801440238953, -0.04444402456283569, -1.062255859375, 0.32193076610565186, -0.182732954621315, 0.6029756665229797, 0.02212401106953621, -0.15471698343753815, 0.8263013362884521, -0.32033848762512207, 0.7344520092010498, 0.21966230869293213, 0.07622458785772324, 0.4027148485183716, 0.1357998251914978, 0.6349567174911499, -0.6298878788948059, -0.08177408576011658, 0.4252775311470032, -0.16034723818302155, -0.6496195197105408, -0.27726078033447266, 0.31956592202186584, -0.6759534478187561, -0.24906639754772186, -0.13451635837554932, -0.6355885863304138, -0.3160027265548706, 0.17935210466384888, 0.5127122402191162, 0.39739662408828735, -0.24790233373641968, 0.22020651400089264, 0.38962405920028687, -0.03878599405288696, 0.2961927652359009, 0.29788076877593994, -0.11926714330911636, -0.6340622305870056, 0.8484952449798584, 0.20265857875347137, 0.5069864988327026, 0.66099613904953, 0.03617914766073227, -0.2642429769039154, -0.6660196781158447, -0.73628169298172, 0.23245751857757568, -0.7790164351463318, -0.4456437826156616, -0.5188225507736206, 0.1262965202331543, -0.14607039093971252, 0.1135571300983429, -0.5393620133399963, -0.2645741105079651, 0.14477241039276123, -0.2325819432735443, 0.1484343707561493, 0.8263475894927979, -0.018624210730195045, 0.6350767016410828, -0.9827526211738586, 0.12437169998884201, -0.20251919329166412, 0.3438049852848053, -0.2956390082836151, -0.8017563223838806, -0.4448235332965851, 0.09602399915456772, -0.5669446587562561, -0.9193639755249023, 0.23753462731838226, 0.0167183056473732, 0.35678231716156006, 0.19305501878261566, -0.034005481749773026, 0.7589605450630188, -0.7203758955001831, 0.7967275977134705, 0.034772031009197235, -1.2835525274276733, 0.43081235885620117, -0.19166390597820282, 0.03866784647107124, 0.8313824534416199, 0.3042701482772827, -0.5516281723976135, -0.5137286186218262, -0.6911574006080627, -0.5787066221237183, 0.39544808864593506, 0.3879071772098541, -0.12265367805957794, 0.020607220008969307, 0.4246620535850525, 0.15164485573768616, 0.3162992000579834, -0.7901005744934082, -0.4385547935962677, 0.33589476346969604, -0.48861926794052124, -0.3330526351928711, -0.01068683061748743, -0.16867241263389587, 0.1512020379304886, 0.5328413844108582, -0.0822501927614212, -0.08397483825683594, 0.1374492198228836, -0.44538038969039917, -0.420605331659317, 0.027722524479031563, 0.6473548412322998, 0.7598344087600708, -0.18342451751232147, 0.25048142671585083, 0.5884298086166382, -0.39606842398643494, -0.033863481134176254, -0.3830137550830841, 0.12661263346672058, 0.36795926094055176, 0.742423415184021, 0.692242443561554, 0.18042534589767456, -0.5383644700050354, 0.5513346195220947, 0.27142781019210815, -0.09092830866575241, 0.019078025594353676, -0.48231515288352966, -0.15303529798984528, -0.2957780361175537, -0.0008710068068467081, 0.47144046425819397, 0.18618379533290863, -0.4838501513004303, -0.05212545767426491, 0.4045935571193695, -0.7293533682823181, -0.5129932761192322, 0.7182653546333313, 0.4712582528591156, -0.5648444294929504, 0.6097567081451416, -0.19980227947235107, -0.5921093821525574, 0.5184680819511414, 0.16722452640533447, 0.8142450451850891, -0.4813980758190155, -0.2421700358390808, 0.26255032420158386, 0.9237790107727051, -0.09693831950426102, -0.036647696048021317, 0.27345001697540283, -0.26259204745292664, -0.5488736033439636, -0.21156153082847595, -0.6920256018638611, 0.0995296761393547, -0.6413677930831909, 0.38717469573020935, 0.013905743137001991, -0.14908835291862488, -0.3508296608924866, -0.046520210802555084, -0.8871920704841614, 0.15321440994739532, -0.3078248202800751, 0.8094132542610168, -1.2096248865127563, 0.2551824450492859, 0.7625455260276794, -0.32668760418891907, -0.30825990438461304, 0.08546469360589981, 0.03217333182692528, -0.7973282337188721, 0.3294013440608978, 0.13715925812721252, 0.0994681715965271, -0.4739285409450531, -0.3000124394893646, -0.6910155415534973, 0.8078359365463257, 0.3220323622226715, -0.5824341177940369, -0.009075677022337914, 0.40588757395744324, 0.5258198976516724, -0.12519656121730804, 0.24309797585010529, 0.6481980085372925, 0.5673676133155823, -0.11342372745275497, -1.3044874668121338, -0.09229318797588348, 0.004046404734253883, -0.2281264215707779, 0.3650719225406647, -0.6510661244392395, 0.4052398204803467, -0.2107994109392166, 0.12381290644407272, 0.07340303063392639, 0.5407467484474182, 0.00020293821580708027, 0.6153016090393066, 0.47053253650665283, 0.5922046303749084, 0.5571914315223694, -0.18053637444972992, 1.0345131158828735, 0.004665784537792206, 0.2347073256969452, 0.9637781381607056, 0.05875544995069504, 1.0585137605667114, 0.5546388030052185, -0.49779850244522095, 0.3140351176261902, 0.6547490954399109, 0.29923680424690247, 0.22392919659614563, 0.19606509804725647, 0.15801705420017242, -0.05088786780834198, 0.10605885833501816, -0.39747312664985657, 0.21652565896511078, 0.5440100431442261, -0.29994824528694153, 0.1327415257692337, -0.05165379121899605, 0.0969981998205185, 0.2086188793182373, -0.18751342594623566, 0.5310689210891724, 0.06950812041759491, -0.8076011538505554, 0.23901884257793427, 0.24062828719615936, 0.4083308279514313, -0.3454892039299011, 0.09730525314807892, -0.4915633499622345, 0.20495960116386414, -0.12419512122869492, -0.6205088496208191, 0.7996178865432739, 0.1553928107023239, -0.11482339352369308, -0.08443515747785568, 0.0950481966137886, -0.2980932593345642, -0.6191276907920837, -0.1480894684791565, 0.6388852596282959, 0.5752758383750916, -0.18788844347000122, -0.4444166421890259, 0.2860886752605438, -0.10789185017347336, 0.1292828470468521, -0.00965025369077921, 0.5474163293838501, -0.039747461676597595, 0.4977869391441345, 0.2865200340747833, 0.0707465335726738, -0.0014603525632992387, -0.37609371542930603, 0.16211463510990143, -0.6398743391036987, -0.18596239387989044, -0.8965334892272949, 0.6164507269859314, 0.02638331800699234, -0.5493722558021545, 0.733025074005127, 0.6626929044723511, 0.6210890412330627, -0.08886894583702087, 0.5175865888595581, 0.19306987524032593, 0.5402494668960571, -0.4546564221382141, 0.30574294924736023, -0.7426952719688416, 0.396786093711853, -0.416922926902771, -0.9994375705718994, -0.4577164649963379, 0.1845252960920334, -0.3443363606929779, 0.08481666445732117, 0.9020209312438965, 0.2238643914461136, -0.10637646168470383, -0.21657802164554596, 0.2831944525241852, 0.03691161423921585, 0.37409910559654236, 0.6110475659370422, 0.6737379431724548, -1.0708056688308716, 0.7949128150939941, 0.04271605983376503, -0.2616240382194519, -0.5529037117958069, -0.8145623207092285, -0.7463914155960083, -0.5957077145576477, -0.45064476132392883, -0.5173189640045166, 0.28077957034111023, 0.8116434812545776, 0.552309513092041, -0.6869974732398987, -0.17902231216430664, -0.09387373179197311, 0.2813602089881897, -0.6240764260292053, -0.15139970183372498, 0.5971522331237793, -0.547135591506958, -0.9861619472503662, 0.193521186709404, 0.25360599160194397, 0.024249853566288948, 0.10157380998134613, -0.1013144701719284, 0.19998541474342346, 0.08741062879562378, 0.4933895766735077, 0.13840918242931366, -0.8034479022026062, -0.3591848611831665, 0.15127405524253845, -0.3079181909561157, 0.18924447894096375, 0.5563063025474548, -0.3565434217453003, 0.49286648631095886, 0.25672218203544617, 0.816740870475769, 0.14751087129116058, -0.07986687868833542, 0.519069254398346, -0.975434422492981, -0.3209131956100464, 0.10099707543849945, 0.427727073431015, 0.46665269136428833, 0.01007632352411747, 0.6916874051094055, 0.5297075510025024, -0.44700512290000916, -1.1036726236343384, 0.09029114991426468, -0.672696053981781, 0.04613236337900162, 0.9327605962753296, -0.20772556960582733, -0.031306251883506775, -0.02914828062057495, -0.1777808666229248, 0.04183262214064598, 0.16087126731872559, 0.8133686780929565, 1.1055747270584106, 0.006257285829633474, 0.09323765337467194, -0.6050186157226562, 0.27441149950027466, 0.789463996887207, -0.9272899627685547, 0.10971012711524963, 0.22934268414974213, 0.22071023285388947, 0.42428186535835266, 0.325683057308197, -0.33699488639831543, 0.26944711804389954, 0.1794809252023697, -0.03224197030067444, -0.04753965511918068, -0.5327410697937012, -0.29528313875198364, -0.0670328214764595, 0.19192887842655182, -0.5597493052482605 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16293v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16293v1	Textual Entailment for Effective Triple Validation in Object Prediction	2024-01-29T16:50:56	2024-01-29T16:50:56	Andrés García-Silva, Cristian Berrío, José Manuel Gómez-Pérez	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DL	Knowledge base population seeks to expand knowledge graphs with facts that are typically extracted from a text corpus. Recently, language models pretrained on large corpora have been shown to contain factual knowledge that can be retrieved using cloze-style strategies. Such approach enables zero-shot recall of facts, showing competitive results in object prediction compared to supervised baselines. However, prompt-based fact retrieval can be brittle and heavily depend on the prompts and context used, which may produce results that are unintended or hallucinatory.We propose to use textual entailment to validate facts extracted from language models through cloze statements. Our results show that triple validation based on textual entailment improves language model predictions in different training regimes. Furthermore, we show that entailment-based triple validation is also effective to validate candidate facts extracted from other sources including existing knowledge graphs and text passages where named entities are recognized.	[ -0.0366460457444191, -0.9837895035743713, 1.0570006370544434, -0.08588936924934387, -0.23121705651283264, -0.26845723390579224, -0.38521111011505127, -0.6203945279121399, -0.3093958795070648, 0.8666556477546692, -0.029071306809782982, -0.9335439205169678, -0.6165881156921387, 0.2987213432788849, -0.5183547735214233, 0.6620573401451111, -0.3058081865310669, -0.2839925289154053, -0.6693442463874817, 0.08636730164289474, -0.8289701342582703, -0.5335206985473633, -0.21344946324825287, -0.28824639320373535, 0.12501046061515808, 0.6477033495903015, 0.4934752583503723, 0.8139582872390747, 0.27931034564971924, 0.1756618320941925, 0.2727963328361511, 0.5053495764732361, -0.29485565423965454, 0.3927702009677887, 0.04399408400058746, -0.5092868208885193, -0.11513664573431015, -0.04213997349143028, 0.3877062201499939, 0.5738080739974976, -0.21599428355693817, -0.06997552514076233, 0.11478382349014282, 0.6390884518623352, -0.8166890740394592, 0.47330203652381897, -0.812671959400177, -0.22836843132972717, -0.22671285271644592, -0.19349361956119537, -0.7453060746192932, -0.907971978187561, 0.5404369831085205, -0.660991370677948, 0.3291240930557251, 0.3580446243286133, 1.0608432292938232, 0.15547515451908112, -0.47660091519355774, -0.6596305966377258, -0.5771355032920837, 0.5924890637397766, -0.6292327046394348, 0.44093939661979675, 0.5570789575576782, 0.29337140917778015, -0.005075457505881786, -0.6145846843719482, -0.636452317237854, -0.550187885761261, -0.5666036605834961, -0.11840732395648956, 0.1141418069601059, 0.06677624583244324, 0.45256873965263367, 0.028943205252289772, -0.33153438568115234, -0.1381719410419464, -0.5173081755638123, -0.39753639698028564, 0.37477776408195496, -0.14539843797683716, 0.3488951027393341, -0.16308295726776123, -0.6176671981811523, -0.10139495134353638, -1.0291271209716797, -0.017297325655817986, 0.29466870427131653, 0.29404497146606445, 0.20106935501098633, 0.7515321969985962, -0.4604305028915405, 0.9754344820976257, 0.15904554724693298, -0.19207605719566345, 0.3445829451084137, -0.35393375158309937, -0.06207098439335823, 0.366355299949646, 0.6835951209068298, 0.32950153946876526, 0.41392722725868225, -0.43607863783836365, 0.19711966812610626, 0.12250185757875443, 0.056375931948423386, -1.037197470664978, 0.09803656488656998, 0.4832168221473694, -0.08584823459386826, -0.09725838899612427, 0.31826353073120117, -1.0024845600128174, -0.4899623394012451, -0.4528064429759979, 0.31098923087120056, -0.9328877329826355, -0.022418612614274025, 0.5141081809997559, -0.35640883445739746, 0.03973567113280296, 0.6390828490257263, -0.7806405425071716, 0.16047757863998413, 0.6605741381645203, 0.7049540877342224, -0.11582432687282562, -0.5130700469017029, -0.5511544942855835, 0.41452908515930176, -0.32408130168914795, 0.8252792358398438, -0.6974824666976929, -0.1144028976559639, 0.27701085805892944, -0.07916157692670822, -0.12915711104869843, -0.5511638522148132, 0.5826541781425476, -0.5429342985153198, 0.26583606004714966, -0.13009464740753174, -0.8163999319076538, -0.5376184582710266, 0.39863845705986023, -0.6678262948989868, 1.0991061925888062, -0.16334587335586548, -0.728365957736969, 0.7680070400238037, -0.5684390068054199, -0.5631783604621887, -0.2195102572441101, -0.18618923425674438, -0.47193121910095215, -0.33489319682121277, 0.3036298453807831, 0.6981669664382935, -0.1310034543275833, 0.5112240314483643, -0.5991360545158386, -0.19043377041816711, -0.07577095180749893, -0.06354470551013947, 0.5787322521209717, -0.08506280183792114, -0.42355024814605713, -0.10284807533025742, -0.7810651659965515, -0.14576680958271027, -0.17463576793670654, -0.30245181918144226, -0.39427676796913147, 0.02663593366742134, -0.600102961063385, -0.18064242601394653, 0.3105847239494324, -0.8304874897003174, 0.03877666965126991, -0.4304809272289276, -0.07743873447179794, 0.3310471475124359, 0.14523765444755554, 0.47357413172721863, -0.16489344835281372, -0.03670915588736534, 0.1059349849820137, -0.1302642971277237, -0.2615834176540375, -0.42600929737091064, -0.43020740151405334, -0.22629109025001526, 0.24607126414775848, 0.5268213748931885, -0.8136722445487976, 0.3658091425895691, -0.13471291959285736, -0.4551953077316284, 0.022484926506876945, 0.012071370147168636, 0.13131938874721527, 0.7037656903266907, 0.4859718680381775, 0.42775875329971313, -0.9238196015357971, -0.8859543800354004, -0.39628365635871887, -0.33883950114250183, -0.0970463827252388, 0.04399675875902176, 0.6626128554344177, 0.01492462120950222, 1.2644509077072144, -0.7445796132087708, -0.26478904485702515, -0.10209103673696518, 0.24154645204544067, 0.19051116704940796, 0.2905139923095703, 0.5345138311386108, -0.7864047884941101, -0.5075564384460449, 0.2027231603860855, -1.0013140439987183, 0.0183400958776474, 0.06599415838718414, -0.14565828442573547, 0.30968043208122253, 0.37933149933815, -0.8081245422363281, 0.6733704209327698, 0.06702350825071335, -0.2693656086921692, 0.5869786143302917, -0.03141864389181137, 0.30036425590515137, -0.70787513256073, 0.032568976283073425, -0.1353323757648468, -0.34080740809440613, -0.6954443454742432, -0.08286257088184357, 0.30804646015167236, 0.17417491972446442, -0.33671438694000244, 0.5571699738502502, -0.4784393012523651, 0.21523572504520416, -0.09144091606140137, 0.5372881293296814, 0.32123810052871704, 0.24255214631557465, 0.5821648836135864, 0.5053170919418335, 0.823180079460144, -0.9583653211593628, 0.43634283542633057, 0.23701028525829315, -0.45609259605407715, 0.5089796781539917, -0.5541351437568665, 0.042723480612039566, -0.32197335362434387, 0.290641188621521, -0.5086977481842041, -0.2907925546169281, 0.0572681799530983, -0.36327800154685974, 0.20174914598464966, 0.11154735833406448, -0.6110585331916809, -0.3619498312473297, -0.34269848465919495, 0.07215037196874619, 0.295871764421463, -0.6669888496398926, 0.8626529574394226, 0.2584443986415863, 0.27175793051719666, -0.8418925404548645, -0.4311084449291229, -0.15200509130954742, -0.28515875339508057, -0.5216318368911743, 0.1263856738805771, -0.04252836853265762, -0.18970265984535217, 0.0439995639026165, -0.04757902771234512, -0.0819704532623291, 0.17829521000385284, 0.1100100725889206, 0.5211072564125061, -0.16153323650360107, 0.367267370223999, -0.46686241030693054, 0.19463972747325897, -0.02178085781633854, -0.4117145240306854, 0.41095396876335144, -0.29572731256484985, -0.36785537004470825, -0.12764257192611694, 0.10352232307195663, 0.3086259365081787, -0.08458477258682251, 0.8540961742401123, 0.5024709105491638, -0.7826594710350037, -0.1651190221309662, -0.9259780049324036, -0.35612326860427856, -0.3390504717826843, 0.28358015418052673, -0.10693828761577606, -0.9145597219467163, 0.26655375957489014, -0.0020305991638451815, 0.03597915172576904, 0.5102179050445557, 0.39586925506591797, 0.1036405861377716, 0.5907831788063049, 0.3484201729297638, 0.5245686173439026, -0.0281666349619627, 0.01588331162929535, 0.14506788551807404, -0.49912798404693604, -0.6713272333145142, -0.6441494822502136, 0.4701702892780304, -0.363811194896698, -0.2282293140888214, 0.46851852536201477, 0.3562871217727661, -0.2815207540988922, 0.5886827111244202, -0.22063595056533813, 0.5783740878105164, 0.43672144412994385, 0.335031121969223, 0.4923568665981293, 0.05416301637887955, -0.03289252892136574, 0.23402351140975952, -0.35122138261795044, -0.8717760443687439, 1.1340240240097046, 0.2028493881225586, 0.22654412686824799, 0.1798611879348755, 0.6600735187530518, 0.16828511655330658, 0.4282975494861603, -0.7093589901924133, 0.6015068292617798, 0.025765085592865944, -0.9078896045684814, -0.5040599703788757, -0.501862645149231, -0.8489968776702881, 0.2875913083553314, -0.34067729115486145, -0.950351893901825, 0.2128504514694214, 0.18760986626148224, -0.49260151386260986, 0.1757127046585083, -0.6637949347496033, 0.6868504285812378, -0.12092757225036621, -0.3326805830001831, -0.14215798676013947, -0.36845675110816956, 0.4580990970134735, -0.1957569569349289, 0.23833876848220825, -0.3606683015823364, -0.03133399412035942, 0.6248753070831299, -0.4274563193321228, 1.0178993940353394, -0.1848292201757431, 0.10648982971906662, 0.6363999843597412, 0.20738857984542847, 0.6805938482284546, 0.18581049144268036, -0.2127905786037445, 0.22711728513240814, -0.03428865224123001, -0.17430314421653748, -0.8212111592292786, 0.36151063442230225, -0.6442805528640747, -0.8692082762718201, -0.2830169200897217, -0.27965956926345825, -0.49003762006759644, 0.521216869354248, 0.17242778837680817, 0.7427752017974854, -0.2526096999645233, 0.5824475288391113, 0.718898594379425, 0.04501661658287048, 0.2736658751964569, 0.7072867751121521, -0.30987223982810974, -0.243323415517807, 0.5557407140731812, 0.057575952261686325, 0.2777475416660309, 0.5327678322792053, 0.4356038570404053, -0.5351626873016357, -0.501610517501831, -0.5530140995979309, 0.19184419512748718, -0.8683769106864929, -0.47271987795829773, -0.7779162526130676, 0.0872558057308197, -0.49319031834602356, 0.025894954800605774, -0.13144616782665253, -0.40721234679222107, -0.16452918946743011, -0.39245104789733887, 0.43460196256637573, 1.0274341106414795, 0.1423521637916565, 0.0892523005604744, -0.6892266869544983, 0.14261513948440552, 0.29020920395851135, 0.46643269062042236, -0.24327893555164337, -0.26586928963661194, -0.2921844720840454, 0.07633677124977112, -0.2888873219490051, -1.1419352293014526, 0.004067222587764263, 0.14784778654575348, 0.6519040465354919, 0.26167547702789307, 0.14722830057144165, 0.4097645580768585, -0.6683286428451538, 0.7320398688316345, 0.225761279463768, -0.9067704081535339, 0.7361453771591187, -0.21248996257781982, -0.2678995728492737, 0.4887383282184601, 0.4028381407260895, -0.17233330011367798, -0.35031431913375854, -0.681946337223053, -0.5589101314544678, 0.6534625887870789, 0.27542048692703247, -0.2786961495876312, -0.21795912086963654, 0.33788299560546875, 0.406902015209198, 0.4696044623851776, -0.6461127996444702, -0.015582222491502762, -0.336190789937973, -0.28883111476898193, 0.4040972888469696, -0.2861882746219635, -0.023087093606591225, 0.1257822960615158, 0.7776175737380981, -0.20304277539253235, -0.2204989194869995, 0.2561136484146118, -0.06498713046312332, 0.23675157129764557, 0.3244197368621826, 0.4540972113609314, 0.6834234595298767, -0.5459480285644531, 0.24888759851455688, 0.4290379285812378, -0.3034319281578064, -0.01615341193974018, -0.1056763157248497, -0.2805286943912506, 0.19955548644065857, 0.5395092964172363, 0.8779591917991638, 0.30044040083885193, -0.41388094425201416, 0.7488953471183777, 0.29337549209594727, -0.3299406170845032, -0.3973402678966522, -0.0762862116098404, -0.1807512789964676, -0.1576825976371765, 0.23237447440624237, 0.421108216047287, 0.30954626202583313, -0.5543800592422485, 0.3859236538410187, 0.20063236355781555, -0.04874025285243988, -0.12921616435050964, 0.4820285737514496, 0.10464467853307724, 0.35703858733177185, 0.26206114888191223, -0.011063482612371445, -0.455942302942276, 0.6767741441726685, 0.5664538145065308, 0.5783451199531555, -0.0807308778166771, 0.22636516392230988, 0.9169483184814453, 0.24406738579273224, -0.7341961860656738, -0.029971376061439514, 0.11080854386091232, -0.8814934492111206, -0.25735023617744446, -0.4989258050918579, -0.4432877004146576, -0.20846103131771088, -0.5063663721084595, 0.777393102645874, -0.29173099994659424, -0.015551455318927765, -0.22010256350040436, -0.2590470314025879, -0.892987072467804, 0.21132051944732666, 0.2995266318321228, 0.8923446536064148, -0.6836453080177307, 0.664315938949585, 0.4424656629562378, -0.5350478887557983, -0.7932453751564026, 0.0155583955347538, -0.1079452633857727, -0.919689953327179, 0.8029506802558899, 0.4162735044956207, -0.3151785135269165, -0.2652612328529358, -0.6743069291114807, -1.1224066019058228, 1.0717437267303467, 0.4752681255340576, -0.1948268711566925, -0.0804479792714119, 0.0013328695204108953, 0.23595184087753296, -0.617308497428894, 0.5841467976570129, 0.5860077142715454, 0.784313440322876, 0.23875980079174042, -0.8254276514053345, 0.2650415003299713, 0.2512171268463135, -0.033488377928733826, -0.11602804809808731, -0.31612643599510193, 0.7639053463935852, -0.4684310257434845, -0.7447291016578674, -0.19270507991313934, 0.9788165092468262, 0.5674213171005249, 0.42565304040908813, 0.6958147287368774, 0.276896595954895, 1.2066410779953003, -0.132636159658432, 1.1500853300094604, -0.2559295892715454, 0.3198494613170624, 1.0534100532531738, -0.6238400936126709, 1.0847322940826416, 0.16108056902885437, -0.008235957473516464, 1.0996979475021362, 0.37911659479141235, 0.1115422248840332, 0.27410027384757996, -0.24241112172603607, 0.12224037945270538, -0.3852975368499756, -0.23438188433647156, -0.29961732029914856, 0.5401889681816101, 0.525460958480835, 0.051489051431417465, -0.29212915897369385, -0.05790531262755394, 0.41855692863464355, 0.3868436813354492, -0.17279788851737976, 0.7279626727104187, -0.2973809242248535, -0.9879046678543091, 0.5780417323112488, -0.36039024591445923, 0.3565397560596466, -0.49960005283355713, -0.3222271800041199, 0.18798580765724182, 0.09374343603849411, -0.37827324867248535, -0.9680137038230896, 0.171603262424469, -0.08810839056968689, -0.2644263505935669, -0.04883716627955437, 0.9110440015792847, -0.8632513284683228, -0.35937440395355225, 0.09985046088695526, 0.41052502393722534, -0.10044502466917038, -0.21596091985702515, 0.012943522073328495, -0.19401419162750244, 0.012164267711341381, -0.06401082128286362, -0.19427736103534698, 0.7558868527412415, -0.02740645967423916, 0.615273118019104, 0.5495988130569458, 0.0008095967932604253, -0.18910832703113556, -0.07474678754806519, 0.6602249145507812, -0.4016490578651428, -0.5013668537139893, -1.153435468673706, 0.3726308345794678, -0.5506254434585571, 0.16836218535900116, 1.0152230262756348, 0.723142683506012, 0.7335876226425171, -0.22051496803760529, 0.9269354343414307, -0.02063758671283722, 0.8254310488700867, -0.9624541997909546, 0.21526870131492615, -0.24509137868881226, 0.2734715938568115, 0.13811756670475006, -0.5896393060684204, -0.4109688103199005, 0.263881653547287, -0.5613184571266174, -0.0066748070530593395, 1.2373669147491455, 0.683424711227417, 0.22760145366191864, 0.48865246772766113, 0.28725510835647583, 0.20898422598838806, 0.06236227974295616, 0.3972867727279663, 0.7848856449127197, -0.2891082763671875, 0.7247992157936096, -0.17416925728321075, -0.13987228274345398, -0.30475708842277527, -1.218292474746704, -1.1120718717575073, -0.5696766376495361, -0.36332398653030396, -0.49530860781669617, -0.038026291877031326, 0.8693515658378601, 0.6759355068206787, -0.9078592658042908, -0.10229713469743729, 0.07548368722200394, 0.21794134378433228, -0.09585206210613251, -0.2363981008529663, 0.574530839920044, -0.48600369691848755, -0.4955591559410095, 0.37232303619384766, 0.22954700887203217, -0.06328582763671875, 0.08532575517892838, 0.13513287901878357, -0.09084677696228027, 0.04229671508073807, 0.5609912276268005, 0.04768887907266617, -0.8989856839179993, -0.6420283317565918, -0.027612807229161263, -0.1686125248670578, 0.05526619777083397, 1.019819736480713, -1.0545988082885742, 0.3432970345020294, 0.5111809372901917, 0.4549282491207123, 0.3199481964111328, 0.22031976282596588, 0.7906255125999451, -0.8196286559104919, 0.059600215405225754, 0.06277361512184143, 0.6696245074272156, 0.589288055896759, -0.6595394015312195, 0.5979287624359131, 0.3706236183643341, -0.3464781641960144, -0.6470532417297363, 0.21495789289474487, -0.6370702981948853, -0.27743300795555115, 1.4363510608673096, -0.18449020385742188, -0.48370182514190674, -0.4088148772716522, -0.17829695343971252, 0.24595384299755096, -0.5005582571029663, 0.5824020504951477, 0.8332651257514954, 0.1342635154724121, 0.034661099314689636, -0.8028514385223389, 0.7067228555679321, 0.11745629459619522, -0.9159757494926453, 0.39444500207901, 0.6059812307357788, 0.2976403534412384, 0.3750799596309662, 0.4166312515735626, -0.030291633680462837, 0.2695326507091522, -0.08300172537565231, 0.2508331537246704, -0.40973523259162903, -0.4177265167236328, 0.3524506688117981, 0.4380987882614136, -0.06772688031196594, -0.06146829575300217 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16287v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16287v1	GAPS: Geometry-Aware Problem Solver	2024-01-29T16:48:34	2024-01-29T16:48:34	Jiaxin Zhang, Yinghui Jiang, Yashar Moshfeghi	cs.AI	cs.AI, cs.CL	Geometry problem solving presents a formidable challenge within the NLP community. Existing approaches often rely on models designed for solving math word problems, neglecting the unique characteristics of geometry math problems. Additionally, the current research predominantly focuses on geometry calculation problems, while overlooking other essential aspects like proving. In this study, we address these limitations by proposing the Geometry-Aware Problem Solver (GAPS) model. GAPS is specifically designed to generate solution programs for geometry math problems of various types with the help of its unique problem-type classifier. To achieve this, GAPS treats the solution program as a composition of operators and operands, segregating their generation processes. Furthermore, we introduce the geometry elements enhancement method, which enhances the ability of GAPS to recognize geometry elements accurately. By leveraging these improvements, GAPS showcases remarkable performance in resolving geometry math problems. Our experiments conducted on the UniGeo dataset demonstrate the superiority of GAPS over the state-of-the-art model, Geoformer. Specifically, GAPS achieves an accuracy improvement of more than 5.3% for calculation tasks and an impressive 41.1% for proving tasks. Notably, GAPS achieves an impressive accuracy of 97.5% on proving problems, representing a significant advancement in solving geometry proving tasks.	[ -0.3887941837310791, -0.7520232796669006, 0.5685367584228516, 0.5246247053146362, 0.22535577416419983, 0.1407974511384964, 0.10097624361515045, -0.5485045313835144, 0.11955345422029495, 0.22022303938865662, -0.6355516910552979, -0.5270429253578186, -0.5695576667785645, 0.07140057533979416, -0.28110551834106445, 0.521852970123291, -0.05815746635198593, -0.08398566395044327, -0.5567911267280579, 0.16761445999145508, -0.7993993163108826, -0.5173262357711792, -0.42652857303619385, -0.1799522042274475, 0.010680940933525562, 0.1807142198085785, 0.7991421222686768, 0.7595456838607788, 0.6319755911827087, 0.4906814694404602, -0.4393133819103241, 0.17832793295383453, -0.25800424814224243, -0.1133575364947319, 0.09645725041627884, -0.48101553320884705, -0.49213892221450806, -0.572687566280365, 0.4642699956893921, 1.124071478843689, -0.3225196599960327, -0.11222601681947708, 0.11769916117191315, 0.7550437450408936, -0.4528150260448456, 0.011351736262440681, -0.5893363356590271, 0.2949102818965912, -0.4248495399951935, 0.23079219460487366, 0.1288951337337494, -0.5858883261680603, 0.10679063946008682, -1.274410605430603, 0.5616112947463989, -0.09764733165502548, 0.771662175655365, 0.5997747778892517, 0.20369623601436615, -0.39921703934669495, -0.7005165815353394, 0.5222076177597046, -0.6355292201042175, 0.5459324717521667, 0.29229477047920227, 0.22936156392097473, -0.5050119757652283, -0.3106260299682617, -0.38770630955696106, 0.34852391481399536, 0.009022481739521027, 0.14387212693691254, -0.23238742351531982, -0.12346771359443665, 0.41892287135124207, 0.7738403081893921, -0.8156070709228516, 0.04338524863123894, -0.6085758209228516, -0.32678622007369995, 0.4834006130695343, 0.23854771256446838, 0.5245888829231262, -0.16727054119110107, 0.0044087013229727745, 0.23257958889007568, -0.5286434292793274, 0.28420478105545044, 0.34236976504325867, 0.05370137095451355, 0.024045158177614212, 0.7491277456283569, -0.19368807971477509, 0.8728716969490051, -0.31261569261550903, 0.22501203417778015, -0.003606568556278944, 0.15133987367153168, -0.1916126012802124, -0.18887852132320404, 0.17809469997882843, -0.049033381044864655, 0.019905544817447662, 0.012623042799532413, 0.0008825000841170549, 0.3711701035499573, -0.05585520714521408, -0.32673707604408264, -0.6007852554321289, 0.16730539500713348, 0.037135910242795944, 0.08908001333475113, -0.16696365177631378, -0.6319230198860168, -0.4542214870452881, -0.28646957874298096, 0.33871859312057495, -0.5861754417419434, -0.15603941679000854, 0.9011642932891846, -0.08727430552244186, -0.22506095468997955, 0.3455207049846649, -0.4611246585845947, 0.23255212604999542, 0.9442682266235352, 0.8741764426231384, 0.2745901346206665, -0.14256609976291656, -0.378012478351593, -0.10728149861097336, -0.3332146108150482, 1.1243339776992798, -0.6306872963905334, -0.6408305168151855, -0.1331387162208557, -0.3315992057323456, 0.04161851108074188, -0.5295601487159729, 0.8531338572502136, -0.16528506577014923, 0.6309479475021362, -0.36964359879493713, -0.9649493098258972, -0.09970634430646896, 0.21587392687797546, -0.6404451727867126, 1.5639032125473022, 0.1326720267534256, -0.4892408847808838, 0.17731249332427979, -0.9073395133018494, 0.25668326020240784, 0.4710445702075958, -0.09723753482103348, -0.6722103953361511, 0.5254783630371094, 0.7059003710746765, -0.16207928955554962, 0.39419716596603394, 0.09001085162162781, -0.2334596961736679, -0.29547226428985596, 0.15748447179794312, -0.06479157507419586, 0.5464386940002441, -0.1549515724182129, 0.08733181655406952, 0.0034518286120146513, -0.7547805309295654, 0.09637999534606934, 0.2983354330062866, -0.3816659450531006, -0.5651803016662598, 0.008112223818898201, -0.28085118532180786, 0.09153959900140762, 0.2241438329219818, -0.7787010073661804, 0.1203249916434288, -0.8233250379562378, -0.08700888603925705, 0.8984563946723938, -0.25543373823165894, 0.17911924421787262, -0.21978053450584412, 0.5106411576271057, -0.3201292157173157, 0.10471027344465256, -0.09521188586950302, -0.5771189332008362, -1.1603370904922485, -0.15797218680381775, 0.3792414367198944, 0.42919379472732544, -0.4529964327812195, 0.6481888890266418, -0.1169554740190506, -0.5656200051307678, -0.12319653481245041, -0.05401476472616196, 0.4868122637271881, 0.652441143989563, 0.52995365858078, -0.1619856357574463, -0.39950472116470337, -0.3709482252597809, -0.5854794979095459, 0.13104383647441864, -0.32778459787368774, 0.23002001643180847, 0.17667007446289062, 0.3402720093727112, 1.1253615617752075, -1.035014271736145, -0.2957218289375305, 0.009414869360625744, 0.0013455661246553063, 0.28872063755989075, 0.4977532923221588, 0.35523471236228943, -0.39998358488082886, -0.3474113941192627, -0.2862567901611328, -0.8009201288223267, -0.38861504197120667, 0.06964195519685745, -0.27345719933509827, -0.07268828898668289, 0.334695041179657, -0.3390299081802368, 0.7471456527709961, 0.5213919281959534, -0.7911101579666138, 0.5809280276298523, -0.09896411746740341, -0.46877509355545044, -0.8185144066810608, -0.2181534469127655, 0.2098684310913086, -0.296382874250412, -0.4361993968486786, -0.17883256077766418, -0.2528344690799713, -0.7469558715820312, -0.15546274185180664, 0.31312984228134155, -0.4577600657939911, -0.31378602981567383, -0.2208779752254486, -0.05835461616516113, 0.29906338453292847, 0.36494624614715576, 0.029058581218123436, 0.7021198868751526, 0.8209477066993713, -0.795207679271698, 0.18662036955356598, 0.5812022089958191, -0.1994432657957077, 0.559635579586029, -1.0166950225830078, 0.18807445466518402, -0.26324501633644104, -0.046652331948280334, -0.774196445941925, -0.12147864699363708, -0.020611586049199104, -0.45243218541145325, -0.09159226715564728, -0.2200329750776291, -0.21545681357383728, -0.5569431185722351, -0.04041901230812073, 0.4815688729286194, 0.18027952313423157, -0.5032384991645813, 0.5569961667060852, 0.246054545044899, -0.4897432327270508, -0.46558570861816406, -0.22686909139156342, -0.05878180265426636, -0.12914477288722992, -0.8058201670646667, 0.45959681272506714, -0.09021595865488052, -0.054075900465250015, 0.3320491909980774, -0.5247189998626709, -0.08302003890275955, 0.11054790765047073, 0.06423233449459076, 0.21530434489250183, -0.1758042573928833, 0.19822874665260315, -0.0793808177113533, -0.5816010236740112, 0.06471114605665207, -0.39732620120048523, 0.7203798890113831, -0.3808748126029968, -0.7300336956977844, -0.3781065046787262, 0.4664267301559448, 0.054889798164367676, -0.5703501105308533, 0.26274573802948, 0.27097636461257935, -0.8673930764198303, -0.09167023748159409, -0.4411051869392395, 0.03962721675634384, -0.5054789185523987, 0.4308582544326782, -0.5992292165756226, -0.8503825664520264, 0.4907853603363037, -0.4082227647304535, 0.19439595937728882, 0.4500134587287903, -0.010616868734359741, -0.05375833809375763, 0.8017683625221252, 0.9979034662246704, 0.22549909353256226, 0.3040850758552551, -0.296943724155426, 0.3409860134124756, -0.7692357301712036, -0.5451293587684631, -0.6322934627532959, -0.3082646131515503, -0.03400721400976181, -0.5394164323806763, 0.8224542737007141, 0.5964487791061401, -0.11704089492559433, 0.4549926519393921, -0.8506882786750793, 0.9801329374313354, 0.333828330039978, -0.10223424434661865, 0.409338116645813, 0.29899895191192627, 0.025131380185484886, -0.5369035005569458, -0.7945840358734131, -0.18678230047225952, 0.7428118586540222, 0.24982371926307678, 0.648987889289856, 0.37993982434272766, 0.3405471444129944, 0.16853632032871246, -0.3516022861003876, -0.6882015466690063, 0.5052658319473267, -0.16782844066619873, -0.3109723627567291, -0.2810199558734894, -0.489200621843338, -0.9123885035514832, 0.18647336959838867, -0.21779745817184448, -0.8198564648628235, 0.22560137510299683, 0.016904516145586967, -0.5841955542564392, 0.495019793510437, -0.38314634561538696, 0.8933013081550598, -0.4008326232433319, -0.18070298433303833, 0.01966829039156437, -0.026765430346131325, 0.01490600686520338, 0.22189386188983917, -0.028907550498843193, -0.4784034490585327, 0.14427992701530457, 0.5291975140571594, -0.7022163271903992, 0.48270466923713684, -0.3163079619407654, -0.06552859395742416, 0.07818470895290375, 0.476418137550354, 0.18701903522014618, 0.26561665534973145, 0.17249983549118042, 0.4513319730758667, -0.3857296407222748, -0.42320019006729126, -0.6905601620674133, 0.36911189556121826, -0.5945030450820923, -0.5578974485397339, -0.5209596157073975, -0.8345857858657837, -0.21567648649215698, 0.3089037835597992, 0.16275352239608765, 0.6031090021133423, -0.09413561969995499, -0.19027157127857208, 0.832553505897522, -0.44086745381355286, 0.596160888671875, 0.40251779556274414, -0.4281294047832489, -0.24661269783973694, 0.7076230049133301, 0.0781908929347992, -0.24553453922271729, 0.059958819299936295, 0.3918200433254242, -0.613049328327179, -0.2501557171344757, -0.5717227458953857, 0.26967599987983704, -0.4526599943637848, -0.4807141423225403, -0.5307590961456299, -0.4688372015953064, -0.0954035297036171, -0.48152562975883484, -0.6697582006454468, -0.8503105044364929, 0.14437806606292725, 0.04438171908259392, 0.4939817190170288, 0.6592448353767395, -0.11510885506868362, 0.3719938397407532, -0.637206494808197, 0.1817696988582611, 0.17949259281158447, 0.6853917241096497, -0.5150275230407715, -0.1477217823266983, -0.008468681946396828, -0.28980863094329834, -0.4349859654903412, -0.5628554224967957, 0.40520888566970825, 0.16883602738380432, 0.3681827485561371, 0.30579647421836853, -0.3340552747249603, 1.134555697441101, -0.4099337160587311, 0.6952228546142578, 0.1774870753288269, -1.419682264328003, 0.7273152470588684, -0.263380229473114, 0.21920561790466309, 0.09217263758182526, 0.16382324695587158, -0.6746066808700562, -0.26044782996177673, -0.5100979804992676, -0.800764799118042, 0.5645435452461243, 0.6731316447257996, -0.1649523377418518, 0.47639477252960205, 0.4124302268028259, 0.03137864172458649, -0.2298976480960846, -0.6515097618103027, -0.04151240363717079, -0.41144266724586487, -0.059145018458366394, 0.4686775505542755, -0.20728620886802673, -0.06951475143432617, -0.15533317625522614, 0.5489089488983154, 0.11666842550039291, 0.294820636510849, 0.5065528154373169, -0.15625272691249847, 0.05103210359811783, 0.34796392917633057, 0.6718042492866516, 1.1980555057525635, -0.005262977443635464, -0.16318586468696594, 0.13831855356693268, -0.30836862325668335, -0.21149203181266785, 0.664052426815033, -0.21993747353553772, 0.5146545767784119, 0.0037703863345086575, 0.4932774007320404, -0.21313419938087463, -0.3544650971889496, 0.2501758635044098, -0.12410058081150055, -0.06614971160888672, -0.5798209309577942, -0.035436201840639114, 0.0143330879509449, 0.05740336701273918, 0.2792659401893616, 0.4024854004383087, 0.32261455059051514, 0.30147111415863037, 0.05955975875258446, 0.21227844059467316, -0.223746195435524, -0.2614087462425232, 0.6576043367385864, 0.22835955023765564, -0.4875192940235138, 0.6016852855682373, -0.27583739161491394, -0.9127543568611145, 0.8008667230606079, 0.8400411009788513, 0.3639206886291504, -0.40330561995506287, 0.07418084889650345, 0.4736168682575226, 0.12180973589420319, 0.15471862256526947, 0.536620557308197, 0.15420959889888763, -0.7165358662605286, -0.6413413882255554, -0.4925340414047241, -0.3502921164035797, 0.1911010593175888, -0.5833824276924133, 0.24613164365291595, -0.4945259392261505, 0.039408884942531586, -0.15760073065757751, -0.060928113758563995, -0.5331262350082397, 0.030636636540293694, 0.3193139135837555, 0.892076313495636, -0.682544469833374, -0.11355677992105484, 0.7642611861228943, 0.025392647832632065, -0.8065882325172424, -0.23515945672988892, 0.23523801565170288, -0.7550117373466492, -0.036180220544338226, 0.39944151043891907, -0.28526240587234497, -0.11429332196712494, -0.1076231300830841, -1.0224355459213257, 0.6716305017471313, 0.3283036947250366, -0.5276079177856445, 0.00158207886852324, 0.4817950129508972, 0.29797035455703735, 0.048003703355789185, 0.04624638333916664, 0.07362896203994751, 0.17076313495635986, 0.0018324959091842175, -0.9222996830940247, -0.22213055193424225, -0.4192800521850586, 0.45009279251098633, 0.5388610363006592, -0.23579901456832886, 0.7611945271492004, 0.05030933395028114, -0.30775099992752075, 0.1745171844959259, 0.9082977175712585, 0.5742915272712708, 0.5017507672309875, 0.599712610244751, 1.2192063331604004, 1.1227794885635376, -0.5083609223365784, 0.7539117336273193, -0.2316441535949707, 0.42417168617248535, 0.9875885248184204, -0.0015682163648307323, 0.3906421661376953, -0.0190271083265543, -0.31350207328796387, 0.7753361463546753, 0.6059528589248657, 0.056170348078012466, 0.04939858987927437, 0.41102713346481323, -0.34102222323417664, -0.39309847354888916, -0.2775275707244873, -0.8763332366943359, 0.7269120812416077, 0.5419577360153198, 0.3321864604949951, -0.6112931370735168, -0.34094199538230896, 0.15336528420448303, 0.520093560218811, -0.5587940216064453, 0.4991277754306793, -0.17296655476093292, -0.22606012225151062, 0.10696364939212799, 0.11962864547967911, 0.5159359574317932, -0.6417313814163208, -0.22819921374320984, -0.35681459307670593, 0.38101550936698914, -0.4894793629646301, -0.8266476392745972, 0.8647502660751343, 0.1598297506570816, -0.09361087530851364, 0.1554015427827835, 0.7224856615066528, -0.37999507784843445, -1.145535945892334, -0.2995309829711914, 0.6300438046455383, 0.134905606508255, -0.2727321684360504, -0.8047746419906616, -0.017285548150539398, -0.4334946572780609, 0.40323320031166077, -0.39380770921707153, 0.6402873992919922, 0.031737182289361954, 0.5561445355415344, 0.9300574660301208, 0.09806225448846817, 0.31538599729537964, -0.009766101837158203, 1.0624135732650757, -0.5294333100318909, -0.8501428961753845, -0.6711447238922119, 0.7520182132720947, -0.41747406125068665, -0.38617438077926636, 0.9306254982948303, 1.217516303062439, 0.9779124855995178, -0.07641085237264633, 0.5553755164146423, -0.005209783092141151, 0.7197770476341248, -0.5700605511665344, 0.2071303278207779, -0.34503015875816345, 0.5543052554130554, -0.1959007978439331, -1.0717077255249023, -0.7015122771263123, 0.7509798407554626, -0.42051997780799866, -0.1410360187292099, 0.558911919593811, 0.5968049168586731, -0.3784182369709015, 0.14163288474082947, 0.017536403611302376, -0.33296072483062744, 0.3724597096443176, 0.8853083848953247, 1.1105334758758545, -0.4596473276615143, 0.6601309180259705, -0.20862598717212677, -0.14636212587356567, 0.2745235860347748, -0.7218223214149475, -0.719802737236023, -0.1536475569009781, -0.30226001143455505, -0.44831582903862, -0.06704704463481903, 0.4527985155582428, 0.7319228053092957, -0.5492185354232788, -0.06036107987165451, -0.6092157363891602, 0.24425171315670013, -0.22475382685661316, -0.31520286202430725, 0.5044131278991699, -0.46467864513397217, -0.7292830944061279, 0.4961305260658264, 0.43324437737464905, -0.06400062888860703, -0.14613991975784302, 0.0980103611946106, 0.30493730306625366, 0.03640768304467201, 0.2678062915802002, 0.5548754334449768, -0.5381966829299927, -0.05995854362845421, 0.325233519077301, 0.4524066150188446, 0.3640817403793335, 1.0638675689697266, -0.7129266262054443, 0.635763943195343, 0.3798344135284424, 0.8870422840118408, 0.33833956718444824, 0.22908365726470947, 0.43252846598625183, -0.9394232630729675, 0.17000125348567963, 0.2925902009010315, 0.5817537903785706, 0.5794616937637329, -0.6615409255027771, 0.5102992653846741, 0.48171812295913696, -0.4832448661327362, -0.4638581871986389, 0.6606776714324951, -0.7500249743461609, -0.20370693504810333, 0.5054926872253418, -0.1431364268064499, -0.05683360993862152, -0.2851096987724304, 0.034688424319028854, -0.018201390281319618, -0.1866300106048584, 1.0141136646270752, 0.5013324618339539, -0.5076128840446472, 0.06435153633356094, -0.1658158153295517, 0.4500291645526886, 0.7998722195625305, -0.9152027368545532, -0.13409991562366486, 0.6344850659370422, 0.2521202266216278, 0.4655102491378784, 0.39834973216056824, -0.36107224225997925, 0.0824340432882309, -0.002294135745614767, 0.1563500314950943, -0.48461857438087463, -0.4824202060699463, -0.31693434715270996, 0.0893750712275505, -0.32120728492736816, -0.33246874809265137 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16285v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16285v1	Capturing Pertinent Symbolic Features for Enhanced Content-Based Misinformation Detection	2024-01-29T16:42:34	2024-01-29T16:42:34	Flavio Merenda, José Manuel Gómez-Pérez	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Preventing the spread of misinformation is challenging. The detection of misleading content presents a significant hurdle due to its extreme linguistic and domain variability. Content-based models have managed to identify deceptive language by learning representations from textual data such as social media posts and web articles. However, aggregating representative samples of this heterogeneous phenomenon and implementing effective real-world applications is still elusive. Based on analytical work on the language of misinformation, this paper analyzes the linguistic attributes that characterize this phenomenon and how representative of such features some of the most popular misinformation datasets are. We demonstrate that the appropriate use of pertinent symbolic knowledge in combination with neural language models is helpful in detecting misleading content. Our results achieve state-of-the-art performance in misinformation datasets across the board, showing that our approach offers a valid and robust alternative to multi-task transfer learning without requiring any additional training data. Furthermore, our results show evidence that structured knowledge can provide the extra boost required to address a complex and unpredictable real-world problem like misinformation detection, not only in terms of accuracy but also time efficiency and resource utilization.	[ -0.015261093154549599, -0.9242286682128906, 0.4664822816848755, 0.5479840636253357, -0.18573378026485443, 0.08508367091417313, -0.14146819710731506, -0.5772977471351624, 0.11426571756601334, 0.31267988681793213, -0.5642905831336975, -0.5096387267112732, -0.9283902645111084, 0.112132728099823, -0.5137341618537903, 0.8548650741577148, 0.1162835955619812, -0.21888600289821625, -0.024289598688483238, -0.10944534838199615, -0.6541457176208496, -0.5812902450561523, -0.42506274580955505, -0.09210064262151718, 0.4192434251308441, 0.2143210768699646, 0.6017582416534424, 0.6832490563392639, 0.3049347996711731, 0.19404476881027222, 0.16267509758472443, 0.5010285377502441, -0.34487220644950867, 0.17409378290176392, -0.1231534406542778, -0.6697681546211243, 0.035907547920942307, 0.07794076949357986, 0.546035647392273, 0.5152419805526733, -0.10600968450307846, 0.18608298897743225, 0.04898069053888321, 0.1593010276556015, -0.7703137993812561, 0.4131617248058319, -0.8983162045478821, 0.037314437329769135, -0.3590086102485657, -0.4152548611164093, -0.4902527332305908, -0.29759544134140015, -0.046407803893089294, -0.7984700202941895, 0.13305985927581787, -0.04778827354311943, 0.9097111225128174, 0.356271892786026, -0.33582285046577454, -0.4154711067676544, -0.6704133152961731, 0.7857556343078613, -0.641512930393219, 0.5232413411140442, 0.5123018026351929, 0.28829747438430786, 0.12649652361869812, -0.5609675049781799, -0.7565516829490662, -0.1476244330406189, -0.27809348702430725, -0.1986461728811264, -0.34770017862319946, -0.3881228566169739, 0.27574771642684937, -0.23052436113357544, -0.5037617087364197, -0.011249789968132973, -0.1466037631034851, -0.5216488838195801, 0.5263561010360718, -0.13905088603496552, 0.5724740624427795, -0.3016279935836792, -0.27480098605155945, -0.362988144159317, -0.7777162790298462, -0.27830779552459717, 0.48717519640922546, 0.4558069109916687, -0.25044018030166626, 0.3740217685699463, 0.0006523646297864616, 0.4027699828147888, 0.20047558844089508, -0.2153952419757843, 0.3171135187149048, -0.32769373059272766, -0.034502312541007996, 0.3358542323112488, 0.658939778804779, 0.03480827063322067, 0.37808218598365784, -0.11767762899398804, -0.31740912795066833, 0.2663256824016571, 0.4295271635055542, -0.5679717659950256, -0.1678149253129959, -0.09804706275463104, -0.3415266275405884, -0.14453379809856415, 0.3112907111644745, -0.3435905873775482, -0.5443513989448547, -0.2652345895767212, 0.18642310798168182, -0.69659423828125, -0.46034643054008484, 0.03556211665272713, -0.3098369836807251, -0.31337395310401917, 0.4031250774860382, -0.6242990493774414, -0.04896348714828491, 0.7701236605644226, 0.635870099067688, -0.10405492037534714, -0.19801059365272522, -0.4058568775653839, 0.3036494851112366, -0.24958163499832153, 0.9643351435661316, -0.7873967289924622, 0.3285931348800659, 0.16883429884910583, 0.10023285448551178, -0.14668673276901245, -0.5834140777587891, 0.6129593253135681, -0.5732860565185547, 0.07890695333480835, -0.4629468023777008, -0.2860030233860016, -0.4380643367767334, 0.5067091584205627, -0.9402801990509033, 0.9566855430603027, 0.21207749843597412, -0.9798780083656311, 0.4541778862476349, -0.4144454300403595, -0.5901897549629211, 0.09032538533210754, -0.25521090626716614, -0.3941670060157776, 0.18235942721366882, 0.18069297075271606, 0.5115363001823425, -0.0007980513619259, 0.32632553577423096, -0.10420768707990646, -0.35484516620635986, 0.5378497242927551, -0.7964279651641846, 0.5377934575080872, 0.41084450483322144, -0.29300475120544434, -0.10961068421602249, -0.4704348146915436, -0.27253469824790955, 0.14557978510856628, -0.27248305082321167, -0.8569640517234802, -0.051033154129981995, 0.00655324338003993, 0.24203722178936005, 0.14351947605609894, -0.39902463555336, -0.03328176960349083, -0.04013524949550629, -0.09871789067983627, 0.4936452805995941, 0.023030150681734085, 0.18408280611038208, -0.3181670010089874, 0.3220236003398895, 0.5214245915412903, 0.16523122787475586, -0.11900855600833893, -0.34516987204551697, -0.22884681820869446, -0.10016407072544098, 0.19678573310375214, 0.6850835680961609, -1.0192756652832031, 0.45489099621772766, -0.35617882013320923, -0.32554110884666443, -0.5148427486419678, 0.19354760646820068, 0.4129897356033325, 0.568886399269104, 0.4916583001613617, -0.18587276339530945, -0.5068894624710083, -0.910744309425354, -0.6878045201301575, -0.2699364721775055, -0.09429109841585159, 0.05853564292192459, 0.2600551247596741, -0.04513893648982048, 0.5309089422225952, -0.3575085997581482, -0.24934056401252747, -0.3030548095703125, 0.39555099606513977, 0.21911883354187012, 0.13695544004440308, 0.6942339539527893, -1.1065698862075806, -0.5505086183547974, 0.056637898087501526, -0.9732779264450073, -0.30771303176879883, -0.5101323127746582, 0.053518250584602356, 0.12630541622638702, 0.25001904368400574, -0.6479435563087463, 0.30001795291900635, 0.3608299493789673, -0.4718951880931854, 0.6726365089416504, 0.08341304212808609, 0.42284029722213745, -0.8869979977607727, -0.023799698799848557, 0.568214476108551, -0.09760051965713501, -0.7671336531639099, -0.16002072393894196, 0.28733593225479126, 0.5595181584358215, -0.5173898935317993, 0.2834068238735199, -0.5343549251556396, 0.31110045313835144, -0.257461279630661, 0.1683369278907776, -0.25541776418685913, 0.3240586817264557, 0.055731479078531265, 0.586932897567749, 0.3804236054420471, -0.6536756157875061, 0.403498113155365, 0.31419700384140015, -0.16466261446475983, 0.765627920627594, -0.2267833650112152, -0.17651179432868958, -0.2580105662345886, 0.15294182300567627, -0.7591078281402588, -0.15195471048355103, 0.545210063457489, -0.5980580449104309, 0.35387182235717773, -0.1018194705247879, -0.8562216758728027, -0.06015775725245476, -0.2302870899438858, 0.35759663581848145, 0.1592920422554016, -0.2557658553123474, 0.5263325572013855, 0.3878483772277832, -0.07967136800289154, -0.8390666246414185, -0.8714215755462646, 0.0685461014509201, -0.36728522181510925, -0.5666451454162598, 0.2930417060852051, 0.30278992652893066, -0.1891547441482544, 0.11040518432855606, -0.5113463997840881, -0.2608916163444519, 0.1184394359588623, 0.20746402442455292, 0.0680464431643486, -0.26099318265914917, 0.4052059054374695, 0.12366997450590134, 0.00788901373744011, 0.09905079007148743, -0.3423069715499878, 0.45292457938194275, 0.26313215494155884, -0.5434558391571045, -0.6238445043563843, 0.16865117847919464, 0.4515213370323181, 0.03852584585547447, 0.8367296457290649, 0.6672680377960205, -0.6446837186813354, -0.41953155398368835, -0.6275161504745483, -0.3822377324104309, -0.3883317708969116, 0.5418364405632019, -0.09729023277759552, -0.564231812953949, 0.3266977369785309, -0.07649741321802139, -0.10609813034534454, 0.5695599317550659, 0.028550857678055763, 0.040675196796655655, 0.816636323928833, 0.6722493767738342, -0.1734614074230194, 0.5030257701873779, 0.009385124780237675, 0.33422985672950745, -0.2851259410381317, -0.4968755841255188, -0.547680139541626, -0.3491021692752838, -0.2854353189468384, -0.3681064248085022, 0.16784313321113586, -0.11398599296808243, -0.13605791330337524, 0.5264957547187805, -0.42948153614997864, 0.25821003317832947, 0.25834906101226807, 0.15875200927257538, 0.43366557359695435, 0.45377877354621887, 0.04174022004008293, -0.19710324704647064, -0.796727180480957, -0.4274994730949402, 0.8508192896842957, 0.40838557481765747, 0.8597331047058105, 0.025438979268074036, 0.054640885442495346, 0.6661149263381958, 0.35730981826782227, -0.47831302881240845, 0.28431665897369385, -0.290977418422699, -0.3522307574748993, -0.15417486429214478, -0.5052934885025024, -0.6602837443351746, 0.09667292982339859, -0.4128996729850769, -0.5888973474502563, 0.12603358924388885, 0.0781979113817215, -0.18258418142795563, 0.36796703934669495, -0.6471579670906067, 0.6725262403488159, -0.42295408248901367, -0.10855723917484283, -0.3401297926902771, -0.6373632550239563, 0.3269776701927185, -0.30701112747192383, 0.12079844623804092, -0.06577131152153015, -0.028807885944843292, 0.508987545967102, 0.16781926155090332, 1.1027785539627075, -0.14230214059352875, -0.24512439966201782, 0.06444162130355835, 0.19226372241973877, 0.5342487096786499, -0.14419806003570557, 0.12538769841194153, 0.30264416337013245, -0.2262822538614273, -0.1184164434671402, -0.7905624508857727, 0.513894259929657, -0.5352777242660522, -0.2990530729293823, -0.3947300314903259, -0.7283982038497925, -0.22645977139472961, -0.03976128622889519, 0.07935979217290878, 0.06278406828641891, 0.07058712840080261, 0.18086515367031097, 0.848761796951294, -0.23671571910381317, 0.20162871479988098, 0.3458137512207031, 0.2227717489004135, 0.06639700382947922, 0.9996193051338196, 0.11581466346979141, 0.002009723102673888, 0.5333476662635803, -0.006150293163955212, -0.47427383065223694, -0.4996998608112335, -0.21739187836647034, 0.4730861783027649, -0.7372849583625793, -0.41729938983917236, -0.8359390497207642, -0.40709811449050903, -0.24678507447242737, 0.2769284248352051, -0.18233339488506317, -0.3519574999809265, -0.2667618989944458, -0.12504318356513977, 0.17424233257770538, 0.7054998874664307, 0.08494286984205246, 0.49255284667015076, -1.0369161367416382, 0.3759506344795227, -0.17188753187656403, 0.10277773439884186, 0.005002552177757025, -0.4445940852165222, -0.26026496291160583, 0.4431774318218231, -0.37727048993110657, -1.1886450052261353, 0.4734281599521637, 0.13424408435821533, 1.0094192028045654, 0.6908470392227173, -0.03113388642668724, 0.5576238036155701, 0.0592544861137867, 0.7067577838897705, 0.2345980405807495, -0.6930233240127563, 0.4758020043373108, -0.01321777980774641, 0.05614711344242096, 0.34824424982070923, 0.9375259280204773, -0.8384830951690674, -0.49779415130615234, -0.6873153448104858, -0.5110414028167725, 0.7218717932701111, 0.25960206985473633, 0.32535114884376526, -0.03944992274045944, 0.16139544546604156, 0.2752794921398163, 0.4170188903808594, -0.7630780339241028, -0.2913861572742462, -0.29273924231529236, -0.4172598719596863, 0.32045143842697144, -0.23574168980121613, -0.04256841912865639, 0.010119671933352947, 0.6896721124649048, -0.24390432238578796, 0.07247752696275711, 0.033473219722509384, -0.6694013476371765, 0.15590530633926392, 0.11893291026353836, 0.43819722533226013, 0.6261732578277588, 0.310326486825943, 0.447799414396286, -0.06323139369487762, -0.7693435549736023, -0.07897857576608658, 0.2037120908498764, -0.21918562054634094, 0.26070159673690796, 0.5188762545585632, 0.5134216547012329, 0.05793013423681259, -0.5486670732498169, 0.6650341749191284, 0.17391251027584076, 0.03901062533259392, -0.006887216120958328, -0.062325093895196915, -0.12313061952590942, 0.3424310088157654, 0.6326874494552612, 0.189296156167984, 0.15365195274353027, -0.5118547081947327, 0.3180253803730011, 0.3647506833076477, -0.4259583055973053, -0.6200796961784363, 0.2972935140132904, -0.018116427585482597, 0.12793999910354614, 0.70904940366745, -0.04100888594985008, -0.6350236535072327, 0.5341072082519531, 0.6534723043441772, 0.679439127445221, -0.4467734396457672, 0.47657841444015503, 0.265241801738739, 0.5894777774810791, -0.2736872136592865, 0.18623700737953186, -0.18496866524219513, -0.9790951609611511, -0.39628252387046814, -0.5463821887969971, 0.33213120698928833, 0.28122150897979736, -0.0011052765185013413, 0.15424148738384247, -0.30699989199638367, -0.03834212198853493, -0.01326407864689827, -0.3834081292152405, -0.5280578136444092, 0.08288392424583435, 0.332819402217865, 1.0479166507720947, -1.1940059661865234, 0.5248947143554688, 0.560841977596283, -0.5195674300193787, -0.8911605477333069, 0.3151487708091736, 0.2230304479598999, -0.6574215292930603, 0.8045929670333862, 0.18333911895751953, 0.06877634674310684, -0.46053555607795715, -0.7095557451248169, -0.6224204897880554, 0.8597841858863831, 0.8439264297485352, -0.2830353379249573, -0.18564896285533905, 0.4079909920692444, 0.4140873849391937, -0.47303441166877747, 0.23723691701889038, 0.4084692597389221, 0.7364625930786133, 0.27284249663352966, -0.8850101232528687, 0.39266160130500793, -0.2308993637561798, -0.08630907535552979, 0.008104976266622543, -0.09836408495903015, 0.7511733174324036, 0.05810946971178055, -0.5705834031105042, -0.4451419711112976, 0.6618601083755493, 0.19905221462249756, 0.36959972977638245, 0.581017792224884, 0.3347764015197754, 0.9303357005119324, -0.15023180842399597, 0.8751861453056335, -0.32255229353904724, 0.16375210881233215, 0.851383626461029, 0.05704641342163086, 0.4989967346191406, 0.3666253387928009, 0.17114289104938507, 0.6174654364585876, 0.5333136916160583, -0.15983912348747253, 0.44484394788742065, 0.1140042245388031, -0.3428195118904114, -0.3803296387195587, -0.46488940715789795, -0.3132445216178894, 0.44975918531417847, 0.7281704545021057, -0.502928614616394, -0.4721265137195587, -0.14397931098937988, 0.12521278858184814, 0.20981599390506744, -0.10083134472370148, 0.6452724933624268, 0.03832714632153511, -0.5324867963790894, 0.5331288576126099, -0.12307578325271606, 0.9281595945358276, -0.8299734592437744, -0.431993305683136, 0.014232015237212181, -0.08833857625722885, -0.5424566864967346, -0.8201192021369934, 0.7030709385871887, -0.15517893433570862, 0.05463952571153641, -0.2962626814842224, 1.1458855867385864, -0.5600616335868835, -0.19866296648979187, 0.1703733503818512, 0.7422529458999634, -0.015486667864024639, -0.6537662148475647, -0.530095636844635, -0.05706070363521576, -0.05927577614784241, 0.1884816586971283, 0.05209021642804146, 0.7528846859931946, -0.34651556611061096, 0.6418176889419556, 0.8325121402740479, 0.1679798662662506, 0.11521802842617035, 0.08258975297212601, 0.7984239459037781, -0.4444824755191803, -0.6898673176765442, -0.7730430364608765, 0.4116538465023041, -0.3965415954589844, 0.022332383319735527, 0.9742259383201599, 0.41103971004486084, 0.9450138211250305, -0.2182076871395111, 1.0459084510803223, 0.012292853556573391, 0.15755805373191833, -0.37636634707450867, 1.103548526763916, -0.4606148898601532, 0.40400806069374084, -0.24736446142196655, -0.869691789150238, -0.4356597363948822, 0.4369707405567169, -0.16567011177539825, -0.04646848142147064, 0.7199592590332031, 0.7459529042243958, -0.43725472688674927, 0.16052700579166412, 0.2952824831008911, 0.3565577268600464, 0.0809316635131836, 0.5518587827682495, 0.9977967739105225, -0.22965659201145172, 0.46256086230278015, -0.032333482056856155, -0.18175138533115387, -0.19046704471111298, -0.7921522855758667, -0.6262325048446655, -0.7150399088859558, -0.3761531412601471, -0.3346741795539856, 0.2626325786113739, 0.6667645573616028, 0.8179802894592285, -0.6592468023300171, 0.10821542888879776, 0.17702823877334595, 0.3029930591583252, -0.47751298546791077, -0.24064864218235016, 0.21508894860744476, -0.2661248743534088, -0.425752192735672, 0.2260279804468155, 0.19154366850852966, -0.049392219632864, -0.1597738116979599, 0.14021442830562592, -0.30552366375923157, 0.14477753639221191, 0.5881198048591614, 0.24266864359378815, -0.5114937424659729, -0.23537325859069824, 0.021341292187571526, -0.3086075782775879, 0.037599388509988785, 0.8283354640007019, -0.7370259165763855, 0.021733535453677177, 0.4624062478542328, 0.8507863283157349, 0.07845541834831238, 0.1257498562335968, 0.3351088762283325, -1.2442588806152344, -0.013351480476558208, 0.2587072551250458, 0.07856650650501251, 0.4830183982849121, -0.7826206684112549, 0.27427592873573303, 0.5889633893966675, 0.13092616200447083, -0.4698556959629059, 0.13210034370422363, -0.9265093803405762, -0.3897676169872284, 1.1617716550827026, -0.10942303389310837, -0.3215147852897644, -0.4118681252002716, 0.005252316128462553, 0.38643598556518555, -0.5089499950408936, 0.9871096611022949, 0.5559126138687134, 0.11014372855424881, -0.055422499775886536, -0.49058130383491516, 0.42284226417541504, -0.018794026225805283, -0.9946677088737488, 0.01777118816971779, 0.6466439962387085, 0.5139139890670776, 0.6052348613739014, 0.21992778778076172, -0.1686154156923294, 0.38713258504867554, 0.008534782566130161, -0.12914146482944489, -0.3400246798992157, -0.6438919901847839, -0.11806226521730423, 0.3795527219772339, -0.3914523124694824, -0.13427577912807465 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16282v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16282v1	MAPLE: Micro Analysis of Pairwise Language Evolution for Few-Shot Claim Verification	2024-01-29T16:39:39	2024-01-29T16:39:39	Xia Zeng, Arkaitz Zubiaga	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG	Claim verification is an essential step in the automated fact-checking pipeline which assesses the veracity of a claim against a piece of evidence. In this work, we explore the potential of few-shot claim verification, where only very limited data is available for supervision. We propose MAPLE (Micro Analysis of Pairwise Language Evolution), a pioneering approach that explores the alignment between a claim and its evidence with a small seq2seq model and a novel semantic measure. Its innovative utilization of micro language evolution path leverages unlabelled pairwise data to facilitate claim verification while imposing low demand on data annotations and computing resources. MAPLE demonstrates significant performance improvements over SOTA baselines SEED, PET and LLaMA 2 across three fact-checking datasets: FEVER, Climate FEVER, and SciFact. Data and code are available here: https://github.com/XiaZeng0223/MAPLE	[ 0.04280586913228035, -0.7392133474349976, 0.5383846163749695, 0.19349385797977448, -0.3273846507072449, 0.2803243100643158, -0.11172805726528168, -0.4116703271865845, 0.39715835452079773, 0.520684003829956, -0.41691693663597107, -0.6036227345466614, -0.5895867347717285, -0.019168207421898842, -0.1932457685470581, 1.186881422996521, 0.022858960554003716, -0.21161234378814697, -0.3056662976741791, -0.45562392473220825, -0.24485203623771667, -0.19284017384052277, -0.6824707984924316, -0.2184908390045166, 0.34437164664268494, 0.764014482498169, 0.5305113792419434, 0.6994255781173706, 0.5977292060852051, 0.12419802695512772, 0.14196458458900452, 0.23035942018032074, -0.21777617931365967, -0.09593479335308075, 0.363375186920166, -0.6255096793174744, -0.7296541333198547, -0.2406424731016159, 0.6754931211471558, 0.30910006165504456, -0.0756380632519722, 0.6973706483840942, 0.04754798859357834, 0.2407887727022171, -0.4482397437095642, 0.18290793895721436, -0.8624044060707092, -0.11606421321630478, -0.8217310309410095, -0.06786362826824188, -0.2616148591041565, -0.30764588713645935, 0.0036526189651340246, -0.18953131139278412, 0.22637483477592468, 0.2704342305660248, 0.7811083793640137, 0.12975595891475677, -0.26980534195899963, 0.09895753115415573, -0.38103345036506653, 0.7157809138298035, -0.8516355156898499, 0.08573368936777115, 0.45110732316970825, 0.5248395800590515, -0.11363715678453445, -0.6515997052192688, -0.757228434085846, 0.039370834827423096, -0.15803411602973938, 0.008860343135893345, -0.23633652925491333, 0.018714478239417076, 0.31083908677101135, 0.03312654048204422, -0.5778246521949768, 0.2525678277015686, -0.2058119922876358, -0.5618601441383362, 0.6043481826782227, 0.1830383837223053, 0.5187765955924988, -0.41277408599853516, -0.34380507469177246, 0.027940286323428154, -0.9622612595558167, 0.33152663707733154, 0.26579099893569946, 0.5743002891540527, -0.45962753891944885, 0.43540099263191223, -0.005864236503839493, 0.48565977811813354, -0.376440167427063, -0.155172660946846, 0.07568836957216263, -0.3653874695301056, -0.26281678676605225, 0.20383833348751068, 0.8268985152244568, 0.3211571276187897, -0.5515080690383911, -0.0005292510613799095, -0.09442462027072906, 0.2220364212989807, -0.43488988280296326, -0.8551851511001587, -0.5869345664978027, 0.3122129738330841, -0.3915747106075287, -0.37488555908203125, -0.28317227959632874, -1.1533180475234985, -0.685691237449646, 0.18145303428173065, 0.3385792076587677, -0.17391908168792725, -0.5352959632873535, 0.04210774973034859, -0.11477595567703247, 0.3123464584350586, 0.014480591751635075, -1.0475181341171265, 0.37600648403167725, 1.1497478485107422, 0.8188766837120056, -0.001343674142844975, -0.11564526706933975, -0.8010382652282715, -0.23432299494743347, -0.4620749056339264, 0.9487356543540955, -0.6080209016799927, -0.004061825107783079, -0.20234353840351105, -0.41296127438545227, 0.08930981904268265, -0.4911428987979889, 0.6858252286911011, -0.5150102972984314, -0.18802210688591003, -0.2014034539461136, -0.23701338469982147, 0.13150057196617126, 0.26818469166755676, -0.41804051399230957, 1.1925091743469238, 0.1535741537809372, -0.9436166882514954, 0.6339755654335022, -0.6608431935310364, -0.15729515254497528, 0.17708337306976318, -0.6786854863166809, -0.6029886603355408, -0.09224560111761093, 0.003861207515001297, 0.1445465087890625, -0.5177184343338013, 0.2448163777589798, -0.6099122762680054, 0.17498160898685455, 0.13430704176425934, -0.06796278059482574, 1.1060878038406372, 0.015002371743321419, -0.35197708010673523, 0.050832349807024, -1.0545639991760254, -0.05654539540410042, 0.24918997287750244, -0.27004873752593994, -0.43498149514198303, -0.029276134446263313, -0.17261403799057007, 0.023117849603295326, 0.22441743314266205, -1.1363338232040405, 0.5132593512535095, -0.45359906554222107, 0.22298410534858704, 0.5154232382774353, 0.021874645724892616, 0.22644223272800446, -0.06941291689872742, 0.4408313035964966, 0.09965021908283234, 0.4175095558166504, -0.006220285780727863, -0.7142693400382996, -0.6889843344688416, -0.2626092731952667, 1.0467839241027832, 0.6677375435829163, -0.7480602264404297, 0.014980846084654331, -0.2680225670337677, -0.12665638327598572, -0.7421526908874512, 0.31816503405570984, 0.26872965693473816, 0.6089146137237549, 0.23586802184581757, -0.10584016144275665, -0.9336364269256592, -1.0926201343536377, -0.22230665385723114, -0.3657214641571045, -0.1318790465593338, 0.17557625472545624, 0.3196040093898773, -0.2617766261100769, 1.3410223722457886, -0.47299742698669434, -0.032634902745485306, -0.2426377385854721, 0.3921970725059509, 0.250338613986969, 0.44402557611465454, 0.9308614730834961, -0.44130727648735046, -0.5881026387214661, 0.050940364599227905, -0.6222943663597107, -0.36198943853378296, -0.1566384732723236, -0.1322103589773178, 0.25756052136421204, 0.14580406248569489, -0.48745590448379517, 0.3371666371822357, 0.8804696798324585, -0.3504466414451599, 0.31005027890205383, -0.0172666534781456, -0.10366839915513992, -0.8111172914505005, 0.0104612335562706, -0.14309221506118774, -0.4533497989177704, -0.5316022634506226, -0.028850993141531944, 0.07506795972585678, 0.21643812954425812, -0.1867665946483612, 0.43780407309532166, -0.2517033815383911, -0.03847722336649895, -0.2811076045036316, 0.10163761675357819, -0.41766631603240967, 0.21703015267848969, -0.3607638478279114, 0.6485373973846436, 0.8261249661445618, -0.45128825306892395, 0.15205435454845428, 0.20869791507720947, -0.32234710454940796, 0.04418561980128288, -0.22047561407089233, 0.3509407341480255, 0.09729328006505966, 0.13250494003295898, -1.1227067708969116, -0.19782331585884094, 0.3735191524028778, -0.6589630246162415, 0.08734194934368134, -0.3254856765270233, -0.6860009431838989, -0.18671000003814697, -0.6057904362678528, 0.3206518292427063, 0.5856078267097473, -0.7390743494033813, 0.5765526294708252, 0.4606054425239563, -0.17814210057258606, -0.3844911754131317, -0.6196290254592896, 0.30493107438087463, -0.3428460359573364, -0.7382288575172424, 0.03125501424074173, 0.13382506370544434, -0.6307822465896606, -0.172944113612175, -0.36116498708724976, -0.0940006896853447, 0.12640950083732605, 0.06052389740943909, 0.49920085072517395, -0.615705668926239, -0.10676734149456024, 0.3009450435638428, -0.287406325340271, 0.1781505048274994, -0.2591794431209564, 0.21966902911663055, -0.04110966995358467, -0.11997993290424347, -0.06554782390594482, 0.03684249520301819, 0.3110698461532593, -0.012942825444042683, 0.5841386318206787, 0.4793449342250824, -0.43632444739341736, -0.14423882961273193, -0.46739810705184937, -0.23953573405742645, -0.41169849038124084, -0.23526979982852936, -0.38408076763153076, -0.9138737916946411, 0.5894556641578674, -0.18014642596244812, 0.44059479236602783, 0.8584622740745544, 0.10660693794488907, -0.021415961906313896, 1.011621117591858, 0.9426262974739075, -0.1161898523569107, 0.05939040705561638, -0.18575303256511688, 0.1646435558795929, -0.7610804438591003, -0.02659064345061779, -0.5890485048294067, -0.23170205950737, -0.507102906703949, -0.40983548760414124, 0.4624883532524109, 0.027579357847571373, 0.05136711150407791, 0.40035757422447205, -0.08541136980056763, 0.723739504814148, 0.27915382385253906, 0.29054611921310425, 0.4696984589099884, -0.24534675478935242, -0.215552419424057, -0.2572254240512848, -0.8476274609565735, -0.6687764525413513, 1.3376882076263428, 0.4190882444381714, 0.37090131640434265, 0.4536970853805542, 1.0050712823867798, 0.3380260169506073, 0.4629075825214386, -0.6771851778030396, 0.6078498363494873, -0.18550646305084229, -0.5562021732330322, -0.25663021206855774, -0.37874239683151245, -0.7965971827507019, 0.03440868481993675, -0.5268207788467407, -1.0760029554367065, 0.014764871448278427, 0.5387212038040161, -0.9599283933639526, 0.19828274846076965, -0.4410248398780823, 0.8904910683631897, -0.5623117685317993, -0.3617708086967468, -0.31753528118133545, -0.8296434879302979, 0.7794320583343506, -0.3576449453830719, 0.1738288849592209, -0.16885890066623688, -0.04032350704073906, 1.0109974145889282, -0.565697193145752, 1.0189601182937622, -0.3816445469856262, -0.13995583355426788, 0.37425675988197327, 0.2475554496049881, 0.5654134154319763, 0.14874471724033356, 0.0031605390831828117, 0.14180080592632294, 0.35120153427124023, -0.41588330268859863, -0.5750195384025574, 0.3092019259929657, -0.387588769197464, -0.5437808036804199, -0.30335667729377747, 0.008504061959683895, -0.37577587366104126, 0.2431890219449997, 0.10169623792171478, 0.27411943674087524, -0.0781090259552002, 0.20947442948818207, 0.5921673774719238, -0.1457080841064453, 0.21787583827972412, 0.5815594792366028, -0.586570680141449, -0.25641995668411255, 0.8576001524925232, -0.07271867245435715, 0.11591421812772751, 0.3194037973880768, 0.7668215036392212, -0.15393097698688507, -0.891766369342804, -0.5242828726768494, 0.1469024419784546, -0.47337689995765686, -0.5226365327835083, -0.6811757683753967, 0.15232707560062408, -0.4937046468257904, 0.3265365660190582, -0.38727015256881714, -0.6274191737174988, 0.20809157192707062, 0.039320580661296844, 0.6017559170722961, 0.6443594694137573, -0.29510343074798584, 0.48032262921333313, -1.0131741762161255, 0.38486653566360474, 0.38517457246780396, 0.39593157172203064, -0.4296935796737671, -0.5061872005462646, -0.12267230451107025, 0.08110418915748596, -0.18680718541145325, -0.7086663842201233, 0.07336924970149994, 0.13818858563899994, 0.42599475383758545, 0.5015143156051636, 0.12977835536003113, 0.55387943983078, -0.37736934423446655, 0.8854851126670837, 0.2674698829650879, -0.8833179473876953, 0.6584711670875549, -0.2869049608707428, -0.28495141863822937, 0.6464420557022095, 0.005355403292924166, -0.38995543122291565, -0.1524476855993271, -1.039343237876892, -0.48925328254699707, 0.7366663813591003, 0.04247921332716942, -0.20144204795360565, 0.31720423698425293, 0.21019472181797028, 0.26218098402023315, -0.21804475784301758, -0.31151652336120605, -0.044371094554662704, 0.20597267150878906, -0.2107938975095749, 0.10461887717247009, -0.4686875641345978, -0.556746244430542, -0.2471206933259964, 0.5252654552459717, -0.40524718165397644, 0.16320954263210297, -0.14622566103935242, -0.023736001923680305, -0.16273270547389984, 0.31061145663261414, 0.5982343554496765, 0.44917216897010803, -0.3482052981853485, 0.33780989050865173, 0.5174688696861267, -0.40721395611763, -0.0917702242732048, -0.0771617591381073, -0.15510223805904388, 0.15855440497398376, 0.26451992988586426, 0.6608986258506775, 0.270993173122406, -0.42348039150238037, 0.7651945948600769, -0.05244382098317146, -0.13636140525341034, 0.1807480752468109, -0.1000274270772934, -0.1405446082353592, 0.4509795606136322, 0.032862138003110886, 0.15216414630413055, 0.21495139598846436, -0.5205258131027222, 0.20659960806369781, 0.4593038558959961, 0.20204727351665497, -0.5842581391334534, 0.4925570487976074, 0.23927965760231018, -0.1975049376487732, 0.3792051672935486, -0.3343554735183716, -0.5198556184768677, 0.7601040601730347, 0.6562142968177795, 0.9121222496032715, 0.13926000893115997, 0.2861577272415161, 0.32348617911338806, 0.5493806004524231, -0.06328288465738297, 0.15352997183799744, -0.21670988202095032, -0.723612368106842, -0.2503938674926758, -0.556343138217926, -0.7309417724609375, 0.17571760714054108, -0.2145049273967743, 0.5388967394828796, -0.6493384838104248, -0.12201187014579773, 0.38241374492645264, -0.10670071095228195, -0.4004858434200287, -0.2747275233268738, 0.2786993384361267, 1.1028108596801758, -1.096163034439087, 1.032338261604309, 0.5489867925643921, -0.2844250202178955, -0.6995776891708374, 0.1569623053073883, 0.5625110864639282, -1.0841782093048096, 0.9202279448509216, -0.17111006379127502, -0.4241201877593994, -0.16381706297397614, -0.896732747554779, -0.6364187002182007, 0.9379057884216309, 0.6128573417663574, -0.42184677720069885, 0.3627128005027771, 0.08340300619602203, 0.5516573786735535, -0.29781442880630493, -0.09148066490888596, 0.8669018745422363, 0.38216710090637207, 0.08436949551105499, -0.9127791523933411, -0.016561657190322876, 0.16097497940063477, -0.22332720458507538, 0.33284884691238403, -0.6820684671401978, 0.6281331181526184, -0.2685096561908722, -0.4568435847759247, 0.04944540187716484, 0.7533072233200073, 0.22422674298286438, 0.6934239864349365, 0.4469674527645111, 0.4785919785499573, 0.8285734057426453, 0.015286792069673538, 0.6701471209526062, -0.27805790305137634, 0.5108150839805603, 1.1401714086532593, -0.2866915762424469, 1.1545915603637695, 0.35301879048347473, -0.48096439242362976, 0.4507385194301605, 0.742904007434845, 0.09392478317022324, 0.15615083277225494, 0.06165630370378494, -0.4191213548183441, -0.202287495136261, 0.04058929532766342, -0.09069430083036423, 0.696037232875824, 0.4626450836658478, -0.06034431606531143, -0.387759268283844, -0.24898464977741241, 0.22207407653331757, -0.20601671934127808, -0.04191543534398079, 0.8498353958129883, -0.1287255585193634, -0.6282862424850464, 0.49681931734085083, -0.14997386932373047, 0.8079755306243896, -0.5943715572357178, -0.2196710705757141, -0.37054431438446045, 0.13699620962142944, -0.7305734753608704, -0.8375913500785828, 0.40387287735939026, 0.35582563281059265, 0.15817871689796448, -0.027399370446801186, 0.9354199171066284, -0.39642131328582764, -0.08539329469203949, -0.001868878724053502, 0.25317928194999695, 0.32031387090682983, 0.22354993224143982, -0.6337259411811829, 0.12521640956401825, -0.026466406881809235, 0.23430617153644562, 0.3570471704006195, 0.3465368449687958, -0.07047061622142792, 0.36207714676856995, 0.48887163400650024, 0.3001224398612976, 0.1484387069940567, -0.12542851269245148, 0.6432651281356812, -0.3610076308250427, -0.19566063582897186, -1.2053157091140747, 0.3521273732185364, -0.18758153915405273, -0.0984901487827301, 0.9906050562858582, 0.9803479909896851, 0.3758767247200012, 0.055346254259347916, 0.8860353827476501, -0.29963114857673645, 0.5506516098976135, -0.6599844694137573, 0.6280706524848938, -0.18080739676952362, 0.3252466917037964, -0.13039681315422058, -0.6083645224571228, -0.6371962428092957, 0.28104978799819946, -0.2650524377822876, -0.5822228789329529, 0.8001135587692261, 0.9521927237510681, -0.22837965190410614, 0.2045411765575409, 0.057906411588191986, 0.2112901508808136, 0.24773292243480682, 0.33207178115844727, 0.6943665146827698, -0.3987337052822113, 0.44067707657814026, -0.03640211373567581, -0.7253159284591675, -0.206465482711792, -1.1298590898513794, -0.6635603904724121, -0.3503669500350952, -0.6884109377861023, -0.6147963404655457, -0.26953667402267456, 1.1475532054901123, 0.48178163170814514, -0.9133145809173584, -0.21735040843486786, 0.05357351526618004, -0.04602167010307312, -0.06928092986345291, -0.15271329879760742, 0.3395920395851135, -0.27545881271362305, -0.06118838116526604, 0.2658589780330658, 0.5539995431900024, 0.036222781985998154, -0.12217798829078674, -0.022124262526631355, -0.10398349165916443, 0.08699764311313629, 0.6331495046615601, 0.8638420701026917, -0.6504552960395813, -0.36862263083457947, -0.2074577510356903, -0.04648973420262337, 0.37877461314201355, 1.0632065534591675, -0.534153938293457, 0.5666970014572144, 0.5791733264923096, 1.0999736785888672, 0.41541820764541626, -0.27409908175468445, 0.19391599297523499, -0.8478063344955444, -0.15887129306793213, 0.06971369683742523, 0.3929205536842346, 0.22085846960544586, -0.19149824976921082, 0.5131306052207947, 0.387351930141449, -0.40519335865974426, -0.9982625246047974, 0.12486862391233444, -1.1368285417556763, 0.3672691583633423, 1.1080352067947388, -0.01656774803996086, -0.4495915472507477, 0.04700302332639694, -0.3271619975566864, 0.13616152107715607, -0.2826109826564789, 0.9281674027442932, 0.7521584630012512, -0.49309033155441284, -0.22811539471149445, -0.6193309426307678, 0.8681922554969788, 0.2901740074157715, -1.0815297365188599, 0.4649731516838074, 0.2585449814796448, 0.40011367201805115, 0.28300708532333374, 0.8797411322593689, -0.0523800253868103, 0.19782137870788574, 0.35145097970962524, -0.15384481847286224, 0.467486709356308, -0.3545989394187927, -0.5126329064369202, -0.16267909109592438, 0.40537169575691223, -0.637158215045929 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01742v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01742v1	Towards Optimizing the Costs of LLM Usage	2024-01-29T16:36:31	2024-01-29T16:36:31	Shivanshu Shekhar, Tanishq Dubey, Koyel Mukherjee, Apoorv Saxena, Atharv Tyagi, Nishanth Kotla	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG	Generative AI and LLMs in particular are heavily used nowadays for various document processing tasks such as question answering and summarization. However, different LLMs come with different capabilities for different tasks as well as with different costs, tokenization, and latency. In fact, enterprises are already incurring huge costs of operating or using LLMs for their respective use cases. In this work, we propose optimizing the usage costs of LLMs by estimating their output quality (without actually invoking the LLMs), and then solving an optimization routine for the LLM selection to either keep costs under a budget, or minimize the costs, in a quality and latency aware manner. We propose a model to predict the output quality of LLMs on document processing tasks like summarization, followed by an LP rounding algorithm to optimize the selection of LLMs. We study optimization problems trading off the quality and costs, both theoretically and empirically. We further propose a sentence simplification model for reducing the number of tokens in a controlled manner. Additionally, we propose several deterministic heuristics for reducing tokens in a quality aware manner, and study the related optimization problem of applying the heuristics optimizing the quality and cost trade-off. We perform extensive empirical validation of our methods on not only enterprise datasets but also on open-source datasets, annotated by us, and show that we perform much better compared to closest baselines. Our methods reduce costs by 40%- 90% while improving quality by 4%-7%. We will release the annotated open source datasets to the community for further research and exploration.	[ -0.36403539776802063, -0.5727735757827759, 0.5579361915588379, 0.024776389822363853, -0.3621364235877991, -0.04526497423648834, 0.03051077388226986, -0.34364035725593567, 0.04181469976902008, 0.664132833480835, -0.5078876614570618, -0.5026863813400269, -0.29889219999313354, 0.11948937177658081, -0.26801398396492004, 0.6289124488830566, -0.15096831321716309, 0.016447177156805992, -0.5945484042167664, -0.1359260529279709, -0.3054390251636505, -0.49907732009887695, -0.8881233930587769, -0.24152076244354248, 0.40364086627960205, 0.5883592367172241, 0.6160716414451599, 0.6980226635932922, 0.8073018789291382, 0.29001277685165405, -0.07817188650369644, 0.5132028460502625, -0.5243619680404663, 0.25815027952194214, 0.16772311925888062, -0.7659789323806763, -0.48729923367500305, 0.10884369909763336, 0.42856380343437195, 0.6462443470954895, -0.2362804263830185, 0.2843562662601471, 0.1681625247001648, 0.8671846985816956, -0.46477818489074707, 0.08951918035745621, -0.5671381950378418, 0.22054423391819, -0.05214455723762512, -0.2648981809616089, -0.1348472386598587, -0.5245596766471863, -0.43256044387817383, -0.7888308167457581, 0.23918160796165466, 0.2646826207637787, 1.0223658084869385, 0.7215625047683716, 0.38656118512153625, -0.36060214042663574, -0.4737875759601593, 0.7996493577957153, -0.7945638298988342, 0.17052847146987915, 0.4022824466228485, 0.047138508409261703, -0.036735594272613525, -0.6498690247535706, -0.36080366373062134, -0.12703990936279297, -0.09600820392370224, 0.4928751289844513, -0.24779905378818512, 0.3113258183002472, 0.26449349522590637, 0.7465291023254395, -0.5804279446601868, 0.40680545568466187, -0.519243061542511, -0.15519507229328156, 0.5337210893630981, 0.32105839252471924, 0.172855406999588, 0.04379724711179733, -0.2781774401664734, 0.17934636771678925, -0.5762909054756165, 0.09101726114749908, 0.45908546447753906, 0.030527113005518913, 0.17165909707546234, 0.9092908501625061, -0.14909015595912933, 0.45290565490722656, -0.11455953866243362, -0.3524746894836426, 0.0515056811273098, -0.6925641894340515, -0.3824417293071747, -0.3612944483757019, 0.4826502501964569, 0.5030357837677002, 0.11300691962242126, -0.16058920323848724, -0.4799657166004181, 0.03064047358930111, 0.4435770511627197, -0.7293665409088135, 0.05437137931585312, 0.5013442635536194, -0.6272808313369751, -0.32268399000167847, -0.2802775204181671, -0.5959437489509583, 0.025894958525896072, -0.43073898553848267, 0.3174227774143219, -0.4817221164703369, 0.3709051012992859, -0.19612036645412445, -0.02717321738600731, -0.09523145854473114, 0.48366594314575195, -0.8019555807113647, 0.28508973121643066, 0.5381433963775635, 1.289361834526062, -0.243815079331398, -0.012485701590776443, -0.7775948643684387, 0.05512002110481262, -0.5320630073547363, 0.6974197626113892, 0.14209726452827454, -0.7641807198524475, -0.12675440311431885, -0.5268765091896057, 0.11250844597816467, -0.733403742313385, 0.7809289693832397, -0.5414201021194458, 0.2981988787651062, -0.10952429473400116, -0.8082559108734131, -0.0332372672855854, 0.12778142094612122, -1.0014629364013672, 1.095297932624817, 0.23072844743728638, -0.5908600091934204, 0.39213037490844727, -0.6743093132972717, -0.36217421293258667, 0.3867543935775757, 0.023202616721391678, -0.7763099074363708, 0.2940642833709717, 0.4003934860229492, 0.5228278040885925, -0.44720029830932617, 0.154989555478096, 0.21042312681674957, -0.45062610507011414, -0.03553289920091629, -0.32241877913475037, 0.6109135150909424, 0.6030405759811401, 0.03276561200618744, 0.16989754140377045, -0.755588710308075, -0.071256622672081, -0.09006442874670029, -0.7576091885566711, -0.06793926656246185, 0.0892246887087822, -0.1850084662437439, -0.25820931792259216, 0.27416953444480896, -0.10654125362634659, -0.1143721267580986, -0.540056586265564, 0.20564685761928558, 0.7134296298027039, 0.023590687662363052, 0.5309039354324341, -0.5376692414283752, 0.7052634358406067, -0.1988375335931778, 0.5886718034744263, -0.13798357546329498, -0.17921903729438782, -0.9161361455917358, -0.5213945508003235, 0.08241184800863266, 0.4248653054237366, -0.7639784216880798, 0.37941986322402954, -0.006092130206525326, -0.2284080535173416, -0.7275600433349609, 0.317566841840744, 0.1278533786535263, 0.5829941630363464, 0.3122285306453705, -0.21759460866451263, -0.20350787043571472, -0.7306686639785767, 0.0611136294901371, -0.40675708651542664, -0.13187526166439056, 0.14027810096740723, 0.02348354458808899, 0.08495363593101501, 0.9678813815116882, -0.5046876668930054, -0.4867825210094452, -0.2643709182739258, 0.22403663396835327, 0.5010120868682861, 0.2847747802734375, 0.34905877709388733, -0.736888587474823, -0.24299117922782898, -0.31642967462539673, -0.7095761895179749, -0.4576277434825897, -0.4385340213775635, 0.004038533661514521, 0.6528001427650452, 0.6607848405838013, -0.4798271059989929, 0.2904190719127655, 0.5651839971542358, 0.06451021134853363, 0.49281585216522217, -0.4497816264629364, -0.010122767649590969, -1.0777465105056763, -0.011044817045331001, -0.013209124095737934, -0.12266958504915237, -0.32137084007263184, 0.06287162750959396, -0.07082431018352509, -0.15486690402030945, -0.40525543689727783, 0.3527377247810364, -0.7412071824073792, -0.3674008548259735, -0.1972738653421402, 0.18355822563171387, 0.34857097268104553, 0.5239735841751099, -0.3501090705394745, 1.4650790691375732, 0.14575102925300598, -0.4941476881504059, 0.2930311858654022, 0.04829714819788933, -0.3573017120361328, 0.6244565844535828, -0.7144737243652344, -0.23010189831256866, -0.35313957929611206, -0.2863257825374603, -0.7760717868804932, 0.25787609815597534, 0.27540069818496704, -0.4523443281650543, 0.27660617232322693, 0.0028517486061900854, -0.6559228897094727, -0.17192311584949493, -0.49461254477500916, -0.24621571600437164, 0.6290672421455383, -0.4869104325771332, 0.7206670641899109, 0.15304729342460632, -0.2824530601501465, -0.4313150644302368, -0.6748896837234497, 0.23484568297863007, -0.28022223711013794, -0.5574694871902466, 0.4608934223651886, -0.16727061569690704, -0.26729801297187805, 0.238470658659935, -0.15973572432994843, 0.2070484459400177, 0.25599145889282227, 0.11325482279062271, 0.44289159774780273, -0.1969744712114334, 0.2227357029914856, 0.10532613843679428, -0.37513604760169983, -0.04701663926243782, -0.41508662700653076, 0.25013288855552673, 0.15389153361320496, -0.5401623249053955, -0.4633341431617737, 0.43453145027160645, 0.3801349103450775, -0.11193813383579254, 0.7011396288871765, 0.7495391964912415, -0.29522907733917236, -0.17145371437072754, -0.843245804309845, 0.10159742832183838, -0.46503129601478577, 0.5397568345069885, -0.2985876202583313, -0.6692591309547424, 0.4458092153072357, -0.14173121750354767, 0.30781954526901245, 0.3892861008644104, 0.5192334651947021, -0.40300336480140686, 0.3069441318511963, 0.3777259588241577, -0.12639401853084564, 0.4407861828804016, -0.4436050355434418, 0.3098870515823364, -0.7801880240440369, -0.2132943719625473, -0.6462989449501038, -0.012691212818026543, -0.5212510824203491, -0.8043030500411987, 0.6437696814537048, 0.45173051953315735, -0.05192819610238075, -0.07932497560977936, -0.4661295711994171, 0.5275789499282837, 0.9401060938835144, -0.07285803556442261, 0.564912736415863, 0.15402010083198547, 0.10756421089172363, 0.07466576993465424, -0.7436441779136658, -0.7779434323310852, 1.21148681640625, 0.32272428274154663, 0.7896992564201355, 0.12171780318021774, 0.6671735644340515, 0.6587637066841125, 0.2312299907207489, -0.7178418636322021, 0.5009737610816956, -0.3079667389392853, -0.013853312470018864, -0.6009854078292847, -0.5500211119651794, -0.7713945508003235, 0.25332581996917725, -0.056970395147800446, -0.5310447216033936, -0.043915312737226486, 0.1431788057088852, -0.1494416743516922, 0.3808578550815582, -0.3822852671146393, 0.4155231714248657, -0.37368327379226685, -0.3454321324825287, -0.3387981057167053, -0.28896716237068176, 0.025707021355628967, -0.17932474613189697, 0.05663267523050308, -0.19203299283981323, -0.43786484003067017, 0.6646668314933777, -0.7664329409599304, 0.5807898640632629, 0.13122570514678955, 0.09095005691051483, 0.3822375237941742, -0.31011971831321716, 0.5844643712043762, -0.03249114006757736, -0.39762115478515625, 0.3755226731300354, -0.2336631715297699, -0.4314076602458954, -0.427219033241272, 0.5927205681800842, -0.9786375164985657, -0.5869953036308289, -0.13372327387332916, -0.32999685406684875, -0.019932596012949944, 0.10996821522712708, 0.5377500057220459, 0.22128528356552124, -0.17883211374282837, -0.3057059943675995, 0.6408694982528687, -0.24086429178714752, 0.6395646333694458, 0.1148809939622879, 0.2606198787689209, -0.740388810634613, 0.8940176367759705, 0.179979607462883, 0.39577239751815796, 0.46276965737342834, 0.13558614253997803, -0.4261501133441925, -1.0379626750946045, -0.3886861503124237, 0.19911733269691467, -0.9006828665733337, -0.46559542417526245, -0.597892165184021, -0.23664383590221405, -0.10247169435024261, -0.3711911737918854, -0.13217122852802277, -0.43436795473098755, -1.0250244140625, -0.2395663559436798, 0.16966669261455536, 0.2681172490119934, -0.10889046639204025, 0.4405732750892639, -0.7050827145576477, 0.2856191098690033, 0.16447864472866058, 0.3488336205482483, 0.04034819081425667, -0.31398215889930725, -0.41644108295440674, -0.16481010615825653, -0.3949449956417084, -0.6516086459159851, 0.5887353420257568, 0.13390301167964935, 0.8098809719085693, 0.3586759865283966, 0.1039627343416214, 0.23605355620384216, -0.13058677315711975, 0.8274985551834106, 0.29318568110466003, -0.8720904588699341, 0.3955956995487213, -0.0029915019404143095, -0.061114221811294556, 0.6299664378166199, 0.3157670795917511, -0.3753593862056732, -0.3043586313724518, -0.35773301124572754, -1.125537395477295, 0.6819013953208923, 0.47183793783187866, -0.0020779443439096212, 0.16771966218948364, 0.5979116559028625, 0.05439550429582596, 0.2725807726383209, -0.43730437755584717, -0.3322135806083679, -0.04436134919524193, -0.3265182077884674, -0.01373734325170517, -0.4906826317310333, 0.02685227431356907, 0.09788832068443298, 0.8365272879600525, -0.10188529640436172, 0.1740991175174713, 0.10622963309288025, -0.1269908845424652, 0.09965235739946365, 0.09056079387664795, 0.47067931294441223, 0.6303065419197083, -0.13210025429725647, -0.16384799778461456, 0.2567223608493805, -0.29795822501182556, 0.03145376592874527, -0.10593840479850769, -0.3782341480255127, 0.3104603886604309, 0.20688283443450928, 0.7215606570243835, -0.4684910178184509, -0.6593668460845947, 0.2590142488479614, 0.11673427373170853, -0.18170642852783203, -0.44957050681114197, 0.07251819223165512, 0.3167573809623718, 0.2924518585205078, 0.30854910612106323, -0.18216516077518463, 0.2599402368068695, -0.0732763409614563, -0.11933062225580215, 0.36833062767982483, -0.05633549764752388, 0.2085309624671936, 0.7475398182868958, 0.4155912697315216, -0.46170270442962646, 0.8401029109954834, -0.05780044570565224, -0.22982943058013916, 0.6997301578521729, 0.13916157186031342, 0.8254527449607849, 0.09280351549386978, 0.14086011052131653, 0.15913642942905426, 0.33446213603019714, 0.0648346021771431, 0.16983753442764282, 0.035951677709817886, -0.6369359493255615, -0.4112304747104645, -0.6551780700683594, -0.7319603562355042, 0.04178608953952789, -0.445967435836792, 0.35465335845947266, -0.32730832695961, -0.2553679049015045, -0.1724434196949005, 0.30754390358924866, -0.5877007842063904, 0.2122272104024887, -0.046752896159887314, 0.6930627822875977, -0.5797504186630249, 0.20956642925739288, 0.20944693684577942, -0.9186309576034546, -0.49326783418655396, -0.34284499287605286, -0.20455703139305115, -0.9140401482582092, 0.48722144961357117, -0.1492195576429367, -0.1263102889060974, -0.038324080407619476, -0.16271521151065826, -0.7952219247817993, 1.30838143825531, 0.27431535720825195, -0.6235331296920776, -0.0879594162106514, 0.19409477710723877, 0.4210016131401062, -0.26111099123954773, 0.23195122182369232, 0.34349963068962097, 0.330497145652771, 0.16914230585098267, -0.3261882960796356, -0.08007188141345978, -0.13961422443389893, 0.28054818511009216, 0.11008638888597488, -0.5844866037368774, 0.8916974067687988, -0.3769581913948059, -0.3928834795951843, 0.08972129970788956, 0.5503576397895813, 0.20710626244544983, 0.45573869347572327, 0.13766317069530487, 0.5040902495384216, 0.8317767381668091, 0.06789849698543549, 0.92251056432724, -0.3073980510234833, 0.2007598727941513, 0.6627064943313599, -0.19198647141456604, 0.6099104881286621, 0.6187105774879456, -0.5355044603347778, -0.029508354142308235, 0.859804630279541, -0.44166240096092224, 0.29019737243652344, 0.5163305401802063, -0.38840368390083313, 0.19663506746292114, -0.2295266091823578, -0.0019501281203702092, -0.14861100912094116, 0.1824803501367569, -0.42853593826293945, 0.089321069419384, -0.21479888260364532, 0.16960687935352325, 0.13853426277637482, -0.16956917941570282, 1.1180235147476196, -0.017544951289892197, -0.5536502003669739, 0.35893914103507996, 0.14837731420993805, 0.7362587451934814, -0.246318519115448, 0.18302075564861298, -0.8663684129714966, -0.1081937775015831, -0.22165966033935547, -0.5455090403556824, 0.5145062208175659, -0.002979058539494872, -0.33526846766471863, -0.41430139541625977, 0.46223121881484985, -0.19627028703689575, -0.7132177352905273, 0.030915191397070885, 0.7356117963790894, 0.36149340867996216, -0.1599910706281662, -0.4066644608974457, 0.07904646545648575, -0.06148211658000946, -0.1285175234079361, 0.23616980016231537, 0.19783218204975128, 0.021010661497712135, 0.6886776089668274, 0.7884620428085327, 0.7333839535713196, -0.2304571121931076, 0.31101900339126587, 0.8141053318977356, -0.46953263878822327, -0.6117224097251892, -0.7583724856376648, 0.4292530119419098, -0.26433703303337097, -0.03737301006913185, 0.14664827287197113, 0.7001002430915833, 0.8590642213821411, 0.20392043888568878, 0.8753902316093445, 0.5721535086631775, 0.31365689635276794, -0.955360472202301, 0.7460957169532776, -0.6846619248390198, 0.612844705581665, -0.04931009188294411, -1.0690343379974365, -0.11921248584985733, 0.3897193670272827, 0.09314262866973877, -0.15874798595905304, 0.6337996125221252, 0.8323038816452026, 0.2605479061603546, -0.034692730754613876, 0.6295593976974487, -0.393239289522171, 0.39115896821022034, 0.272077739238739, 0.5947744846343994, -0.32588863372802734, 0.6019371747970581, -0.20793262124061584, -0.08180585503578186, -0.3491944968700409, -0.8622581362724304, -0.5687617063522339, -0.5694631934165955, -0.5091263055801392, -0.13302990794181824, 0.2986472249031067, 0.756094753742218, 0.48403048515319824, -0.4501822590827942, -0.2766745090484619, -0.07744943350553513, 0.24885252118110657, -0.19836406409740448, -0.23706786334514618, 0.5827136039733887, -0.8014211058616638, -0.6737077236175537, -0.04246169701218605, 0.42112496495246887, 0.23281404376029968, -0.2778930962085724, -0.006264340132474899, 0.09842344373464584, 0.20354719460010529, 0.5320234894752502, -0.08926906436681747, -0.7825910449028015, 0.06892815977334976, 0.16269804537296295, -0.16645783185958862, 0.3148019313812256, 0.658473789691925, -0.24779340624809265, 0.15195593237876892, 0.4363369941711426, 0.900184154510498, 0.5436903238296509, 0.33890411257743835, 0.37483128905296326, -0.6325594186782837, -0.21762970089912415, 0.3808615207672119, 0.4037260413169861, 0.5278782844543457, -0.7401782870292664, 0.792212188243866, 0.1614115834236145, -0.5073772668838501, -0.41579023003578186, -0.12282181531190872, -0.8015204071998596, -0.3100545108318329, 0.8767352104187012, -0.21200843155384064, -0.03575229272246361, -0.01588214375078678, -0.1654461920261383, 0.32086148858070374, -0.37700504064559937, 0.7795424461364746, 0.5583687424659729, -0.5909650325775146, -0.356777548789978, -0.40115851163864136, 0.4482423663139343, 0.48867884278297424, -1.116531252861023, -0.16590924561023712, 0.7522132992744446, -0.04900900274515152, 0.02155388705432415, 0.7147220373153687, -0.044595010578632355, 0.05777043476700783, 0.00931920949369669, 0.38551411032676697, -0.43815264105796814, -0.02027171663939953, -0.3482063412666321, 0.3303695023059845, 0.2954212427139282, -0.6411049962043762 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16265v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16265v1	CO2: Efficient Distributed Training with Full Communication-Computation Overlap	2024-01-29T16:12:31	2024-01-29T16:12:31	Weigao Sun, Zhen Qin, Weixuan Sun, Shidi Li, Dong Li, Xuyang Shen, Yu Qiao, Yiran Zhong	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.DC	The fundamental success of large language models hinges upon the efficacious implementation of large-scale distributed training techniques. Nevertheless, building a vast, high-performance cluster featuring high-speed communication interconnectivity is prohibitively costly, and accessible only to prominent entities. In this work, we aim to lower this barrier and democratize large-scale training with limited bandwidth clusters. We propose a new approach called CO2 that introduces local-updating and asynchronous communication to the distributed data-parallel training, thereby facilitating the full overlap of COmunication with COmputation. CO2 is able to attain a high scalability even on extensive multi-node clusters constrained by very limited communication bandwidth. We further propose the staleness gap penalty and outer momentum clipping techniques together with CO2 to bolster its convergence and training stability. Besides, CO2 exhibits seamless integration with well-established ZeRO-series optimizers which mitigate memory consumption of model states with large model training. We also provide a mathematical proof of convergence, accompanied by the establishment of a stringent upper bound. Furthermore, we validate our findings through an extensive set of practical experiments encompassing a wide range of tasks in the fields of computer vision and natural language processing. These experiments serve to demonstrate the capabilities of CO2 in terms of convergence, generalization, and scalability when deployed across configurations comprising up to 128 A100 GPUs. The outcomes emphasize the outstanding capacity of CO2 to hugely improve scalability, no matter on clusters with 800Gbps RDMA or 80Gbps TCP/IP inter-node connections.	[ -0.5693097710609436, -0.9434742331504822, 0.36855587363243103, 0.18706868588924408, 0.04058140888810158, 0.3380887508392334, -0.5755472779273987, -0.4938662052154541, 0.05365458503365517, 0.12198027968406677, -0.327144593000412, -0.19049401581287384, -0.5836573243141174, -0.20170247554779053, -0.40292710065841675, 0.5171995759010315, -0.057669781148433685, 0.08275507390499115, -0.6936061978340149, -0.006234271917492151, -0.29367607831954956, -0.6649701595306396, -1.0640571117401123, -0.2640644609928131, 0.22792653739452362, 0.6662992238998413, 0.5714289546012878, 0.5990036129951477, 0.765346348285675, 0.3123132884502411, -0.045052725821733475, 0.08367457985877991, -0.6636934280395508, -0.05823437124490738, 0.15045705437660217, -0.4671180248260498, -0.38747355341911316, -0.008390553295612335, 0.8080015182495117, 1.0291277170181274, -0.32721543312072754, -0.14933829009532928, 0.07174327969551086, 0.6442535519599915, -0.6851367354393005, 0.18636703491210938, -0.6766300201416016, 0.0004254092928022146, -0.034276317805051804, 0.1669640690088272, -0.35933855175971985, 0.11197129637002945, -0.028037426993250847, -0.7461621761322021, 0.4567762315273285, 0.07360856235027313, 0.7938218116760254, 0.3824891746044159, 0.03130318596959114, -0.19957135617733002, -0.7381075620651245, 0.5801414251327515, -0.17033939063549042, 0.6108856201171875, 0.028130684047937393, 0.421599805355072, -0.11267376691102982, -0.5340307354927063, -0.7745993137359619, 0.02355586551129818, 0.06492982059717178, 0.552993655204773, -0.31518223881721497, 0.13423937559127808, 0.2563645839691162, 0.35065680742263794, -0.38390079140663147, 0.30870750546455383, -0.37308254837989807, -0.06972716748714447, 0.4897617995738983, -0.033304207026958466, 0.04937456175684929, 0.6057435274124146, -0.5778425931930542, -0.14420020580291748, -0.5439070463180542, 0.06307347118854523, 0.40108051896095276, 0.2529008388519287, -0.5990338921546936, 0.25564098358154297, -0.33473479747772217, 0.722489595413208, 0.03632659837603569, 0.38934648036956787, -0.06051338464021683, -0.15045450627803802, -0.2119138389825821, 0.1140667200088501, 0.6620804667472839, 0.09346486628055573, -0.06545413285493851, -0.4464685916900635, 0.39502039551734924, 0.3602224588394165, 0.12017583101987839, -0.8561536073684692, -0.08403488248586655, 0.45843297243118286, 0.1941523402929306, -0.07898128032684326, -0.06889774650335312, -0.8863701224327087, -0.18360482156276703, -0.46915358304977417, 0.1050553098320961, -0.08213061839342117, -0.2802684009075165, 0.3481276333332062, -0.24326634407043457, -0.32123786211013794, 0.5886765718460083, -1.099793791770935, 0.8149643540382385, 0.8612862229347229, 1.0546228885650635, -0.40619784593582153, -0.3618512749671936, -0.5139464139938354, 0.11971385776996613, -0.32365140318870544, 0.5793847441673279, -0.6036263704299927, -0.036608029156923294, -0.19374054670333862, -0.21787041425704956, -0.11687406152486801, -0.7032221555709839, 0.20675352215766907, -0.561923623085022, 0.06162234768271446, -0.019943198189139366, -0.5770506262779236, 0.013126342557370663, 0.23458704352378845, -0.501333475112915, 1.0000032186508179, -0.009400560520589352, -0.8167556524276733, 0.17277899384498596, -0.6584872007369995, -0.2602066993713379, 0.0011188688222318888, -0.1964910626411438, -0.690444827079773, -0.2435620278120041, -0.01569465361535549, 0.3681133985519409, -0.3406701982021332, 0.3438947796821594, -0.6791215538978577, -0.7181040048599243, -0.4002414643764496, -0.26337704062461853, 0.7447054982185364, 0.13589443266391754, -0.3398888409137726, -0.033982452005147934, -0.7839179635047913, -0.0450797937810421, -0.018204452469944954, -0.30864471197128296, -0.040656112134456635, -0.2366352379322052, -0.08983688801527023, -0.13596591353416443, 0.17322154343128204, -0.6902479529380798, 0.32145956158638, -0.2054990977048874, 0.6767159104347229, 0.36469390988349915, -0.3052454888820648, 0.7398344278335571, 0.04141876846551895, 0.21461276710033417, 0.03644317016005516, 0.18236102163791656, -0.10373146831989288, -0.29920390248298645, -0.9459174275398254, -0.6112108826637268, 0.037802960723638535, 0.4385058283805847, -0.4188697338104248, 0.6986987590789795, -0.40806832909584045, -0.7959673404693604, -0.25699320435523987, -0.04460883140563965, -0.13640621304512024, 0.4103658199310303, 0.4356291592121124, -0.4516279995441437, -0.7394968867301941, -0.3895583152770996, 0.021535633131861687, 0.15276888012886047, 0.32828909158706665, 0.4109013080596924, 0.4955002963542938, -0.34465301036834717, 1.1359198093414307, -0.528510570526123, -0.00799746997654438, -0.012766912579536438, -0.06284444779157639, 0.16955117881298065, 0.5278648734092712, 0.0587698370218277, -0.4795820713043213, -0.6507861018180847, 0.09660109877586365, -0.6820152401924133, 0.20436353981494904, -0.1164497509598732, -0.11365526914596558, 0.013872276060283184, 0.6320006251335144, -0.5922966003417969, 0.24626009166240692, 0.9361137747764587, 0.12827371060848236, 0.2859319746494293, -0.4706515669822693, -0.06002040207386017, -0.974187970161438, 0.219938725233078, -0.4243679642677307, -0.3417971432209015, -0.5459429025650024, 0.07803215086460114, -0.20251689851284027, -0.69540935754776, -0.20764301717281342, 0.497211217880249, -0.4038678705692291, -0.12994793057441711, -0.3330199420452118, 0.23877128958702087, -0.06775020062923431, 0.4705554246902466, 0.36143678426742554, 0.9034413695335388, 0.8596732020378113, -0.6329599618911743, 0.5139846205711365, 0.3724750578403473, -0.07746096700429916, 0.4975801706314087, -0.6410191655158997, 0.42860981822013855, -0.08926719427108765, 0.38300439715385437, -0.7780345678329468, -0.20285223424434662, 0.09028827399015427, -0.39554572105407715, 0.019311828538775444, -0.072359099984169, -0.40038344264030457, -0.27676936984062195, 0.18769578635692596, 0.414106547832489, 0.26067161560058594, -0.8643332719802856, 0.1261477768421173, 0.3641721308231354, 0.22059904038906097, -0.5239229798316956, -0.4885479211807251, 0.2518978416919708, 0.0093474630266428, -0.8017336130142212, 0.26252368092536926, -0.13122211396694183, -0.026669638231396675, -0.11581416428089142, 0.0014356579631567001, -0.2963886857032776, 0.2381933331489563, 0.43371522426605225, 0.04650352522730827, 0.21882449090480804, -0.0045733037404716015, -0.1710658073425293, -0.12212410569190979, -0.3958527743816376, -0.4681396484375, 1.0141282081604004, -0.23592893779277802, -0.39509615302085876, -0.5885674953460693, 0.4835019111633301, 0.30483686923980713, -0.09299863874912262, 0.8341444730758667, 0.684023380279541, -0.31480586528778076, -0.12809225916862488, -0.4205750823020935, -0.2539340555667877, -0.4987274706363678, 0.5000600218772888, -0.13300500810146332, -1.446563959121704, 0.20833486318588257, -0.307277113199234, -0.4201173186302185, 0.19781480729579926, 0.4289977252483368, -0.23905549943447113, 0.4385572671890259, 0.7041301131248474, -0.11260324716567993, 0.5591999292373657, -0.460300475358963, 0.32902956008911133, -0.6399189233779907, -0.03459399566054344, -0.3931840658187866, -0.13113968074321747, -0.3573426902294159, -0.7275829911231995, 0.5051342248916626, 0.4030696749687195, -0.49043580889701843, 0.4934388995170593, -0.4115625321865082, 0.4306747615337372, 0.5298642516136169, 0.19551734626293182, 0.24745751917362213, 0.5112959146499634, 0.009773497469723225, 0.15438701212406158, -1.1047595739364624, 0.07525856792926788, 0.7301008701324463, 0.34148532152175903, 0.6204676628112793, -0.19645832479000092, 0.5730920433998108, 0.24760621786117554, -0.09266979247331619, -0.6094529032707214, 0.4915676712989807, -0.11039216071367264, -0.6100349426269531, -0.29120510816574097, -0.6544975638389587, -1.0971168279647827, -0.07833743095397949, -0.3058847188949585, -0.44264835119247437, 0.08775150030851364, 0.23883801698684692, -0.2683403193950653, 0.42378517985343933, -0.8940070271492004, 0.7008889317512512, -0.027912933379411697, -0.7192237973213196, -0.7254200577735901, -0.46468859910964966, -0.10208647698163986, 0.09575488418340683, -0.001997913932427764, 0.08005334436893463, -0.042522821575403214, 0.5203222036361694, -0.4935654103755951, 0.9281428456306458, -0.26152488589286804, 0.3121016323566437, 0.5023810863494873, -0.3727209270000458, 0.6482900381088257, -0.07810018211603165, 0.13998587429523468, 0.644393801689148, -0.3473522663116455, -0.652961790561676, -0.4895634353160858, 0.3733048141002655, -0.9370579719543457, -0.17444995045661926, -0.388410747051239, -0.5206340551376343, -0.1533174067735672, 0.3213508427143097, 0.058145612478256226, 0.3273385763168335, -0.2731751501560211, 0.21299612522125244, 0.38352170586586, -0.23162998259067535, 0.4285217821598053, 0.40763944387435913, 0.25812143087387085, -0.6009982824325562, 0.7864564061164856, -0.022877806797623634, 0.639431357383728, 0.44037437438964844, -0.06374961137771606, -0.008870749734342098, -0.42294952273368835, -0.3670373857021332, 0.0425075888633728, -0.36465153098106384, 0.0921626016497612, -0.60331791639328, -0.334505558013916, -0.2842288911342621, -0.3881526589393616, -0.7232531309127808, -0.3537740707397461, 0.020532237365841866, 0.3262062966823578, 0.26504096388816833, 0.5688310861587524, -0.17947155237197876, 0.8586162328720093, -0.44098225235939026, -0.10537472367286682, 0.2029399573802948, 0.7094796895980835, 0.13236597180366516, -0.1907959282398224, -0.7232680916786194, 0.012070401571691036, -0.19789457321166992, -0.22644998133182526, -0.024973494932055473, 0.23488466441631317, 0.16904281079769135, 0.24422793090343475, -0.3818848729133606, 0.9426664710044861, -0.5613480806350708, 0.46678459644317627, 0.5194565653800964, -0.9146834015846252, 0.14229576289653778, -0.49321886897087097, 0.1560903638601303, 0.6026915311813354, 0.4431067407131195, -0.8190479278564453, -0.10448207706212997, -0.7375282645225525, -0.6843966841697693, 0.5802637338638306, 0.046374451369047165, -0.006690942216664553, 0.15638218820095062, 0.4618772566318512, -0.03151683509349823, 0.3265679180622101, -0.2480839341878891, 0.01006899494677782, 0.04656826704740524, -0.14748719334602356, 0.020045766606926918, 0.17001870274543762, -0.22580592334270477, -0.5014855861663818, 0.5676007866859436, -0.2684584856033325, 0.6667389869689941, 0.3189713954925537, 0.09278944879770279, 0.03406032174825668, 0.14950786530971527, 0.3243425488471985, 0.24497653543949127, -0.09345979988574982, 0.2545606791973114, 0.1105792224407196, -0.6559422016143799, 0.2534434199333191, -0.009821433573961258, -0.23074959218502045, -0.2662275731563568, 0.2082781195640564, 1.086285948753357, -0.13980858027935028, -0.48039183020591736, 0.6410402655601501, -0.09217873215675354, -0.1569071263074875, -0.3764125406742096, 0.2323385328054428, 0.15607920289039612, 0.26302069425582886, -0.20166563987731934, 0.7877634167671204, -0.17034561932086945, -0.5593527555465698, 0.3241960406303406, 0.6273626685142517, -0.49948060512542725, -0.3148430287837982, 0.7154291868209839, 0.349475622177124, 0.0012316026259213686, 0.6995205879211426, -0.3792409598827362, -0.5167615413665771, 0.6059797406196594, 0.5049810409545898, 0.484503835439682, 0.174219012260437, -0.005053996108472347, 0.7817496657371521, 0.10119421035051346, -0.37855327129364014, 0.056428130716085434, -0.3449278473854065, -0.8681338429450989, -0.38137948513031006, -0.37425005435943604, -0.7828160524368286, -0.23048308491706848, -0.30947405099868774, 0.4354601204395294, -0.7033737301826477, -0.007505275774747133, -0.41479942202568054, 0.21771889925003052, -0.5674347877502441, 0.4481837749481201, 0.39566031098365784, 0.9237613081932068, -0.7452360391616821, 0.8172106146812439, 0.3474356234073639, -0.0506962388753891, -0.5224452018737793, -0.2668095529079437, -0.34531232714653015, -0.9557656645774841, 0.4451338052749634, 0.39959216117858887, -0.18120889365673065, 0.2333025336265564, -0.6569303870201111, -0.8879680037498474, 1.0931528806686401, 0.642520546913147, -0.9855367541313171, 0.06257113814353943, 0.5119739770889282, 0.5247600674629211, -0.19944460690021515, 0.6005262732505798, 0.2657727897167206, 0.18174050748348236, 0.397932231426239, -0.6392476558685303, -0.13767199218273163, -0.08536218851804733, -0.42341849207878113, -0.019796427339315414, -1.2769396305084229, 0.49237045645713806, -0.3063502311706543, -0.3544222414493561, 0.0190817192196846, 0.6023925542831421, 0.010583022609353065, 0.22007976472377777, 0.5861661434173584, 1.0932502746582031, 1.080660343170166, -0.37158098816871643, 0.7369571328163147, -0.2888258099555969, 0.6082995533943176, 1.2442327737808228, -0.19743666052818298, 1.0815569162368774, 0.3326500952243805, -0.4172005355358124, 0.31963294744491577, 0.43910425901412964, -0.13973553478717804, 0.3360798954963684, 0.22299185395240784, -0.5450142621994019, -0.16569557785987854, -0.22968587279319763, -0.16233408451080322, 0.490100622177124, 0.062013495713472366, 0.25303804874420166, -0.1875147670507431, -0.21502673625946045, 0.2099837362766266, -0.05677207559347153, -0.20051376521587372, 0.5415969491004944, -0.0817384123802185, -0.6381248235702515, 0.6881526708602905, -0.20306317508220673, 0.7712460160255432, -0.4827863574028015, 0.11195644736289978, -0.0052165561355650425, 0.45393791794776917, -0.31896451115608215, -0.5060124397277832, 0.5301992893218994, -0.06294268369674683, -0.09052892029285431, -0.11690909415483475, 0.4663008749485016, -0.8095095753669739, -0.1495170146226883, 0.39292415976524353, 0.0742299035191536, 0.10278686136007309, -0.3657228648662567, -0.39145636558532715, 0.32131651043891907, -0.3649032413959503, 0.446159690618515, 0.22766274213790894, -0.059976719319820404, 0.12795133888721466, 0.429552286863327, 0.6083551049232483, 0.2543296217918396, 0.15872664749622345, -0.013853687793016434, 0.8188958764076233, -0.23389671742916107, -0.5508559942245483, -0.7596386075019836, 0.24211271107196808, -0.37760335206985474, 0.10032607614994049, 0.638163149356842, 1.0238769054412842, 1.0521467924118042, 0.21608097851276398, 0.9134058356285095, -0.15521083772182465, 0.23544518649578094, -0.16815908253192902, 0.7125242352485657, -0.47063007950782776, -0.0855172872543335, 0.23341816663742065, -0.6835835576057434, -0.1977246105670929, 0.29559990763664246, -0.3327379524707794, -0.11837542802095413, 0.7428766489028931, 0.6803820729255676, -0.25241780281066895, 0.25337493419647217, 0.09547623991966248, 0.20584484934806824, 0.3766094744205475, 0.5890011191368103, 0.478203684091568, -0.6201072335243225, 0.30001455545425415, -0.23155689239501953, -0.34261101484298706, 0.06265712529420853, -0.5703700184822083, -0.940255343914032, -0.4446832835674286, -0.27437907457351685, -0.24015645682811737, 0.16618555784225464, 0.7710762023925781, 1.1676390171051025, -0.653459906578064, -0.5459690690040588, -0.7962800860404968, -0.39876073598861694, -0.27986064553260803, -0.15808255970478058, 0.3510900139808655, -0.5306914448738098, -0.727016806602478, 0.33493271470069885, 0.4479801654815674, -0.059973519295454025, -0.0803227499127388, -0.1954643726348877, -0.015498709864914417, -0.11268914490938187, 0.372635155916214, 0.1944025456905365, -0.019691715016961098, -0.14788174629211426, -0.016412580385804176, -0.005369230173528194, 0.4823794960975647, 0.6899712681770325, -0.542477011680603, 0.8178015947341919, 0.38259801268577576, 1.0525857210159302, 0.8287554979324341, 0.01089579239487648, 0.39091235399246216, -0.8176745176315308, 0.6185089945793152, -0.027046658098697662, 0.02340506948530674, 0.5076996088027954, -0.25743257999420166, 0.48673292994499207, 0.8331648111343384, -0.6737204790115356, -0.49110010266304016, 0.19080260396003723, -1.3113678693771362, 0.11707448214292526, 1.0680104494094849, -0.06606470048427582, -0.2054113745689392, 0.027689523994922638, -0.09222661703824997, 0.5129937529563904, -0.30430006980895996, 0.8017294406890869, 0.6657737493515015, -0.11596392840147018, -0.10564247518777847, -0.414165735244751, 0.3231978714466095, 0.49973833560943604, -1.092895269393921, 0.20248597860336304, 0.08695217221975327, 0.18243233859539032, 0.15977464616298676, 0.5830405950546265, 0.1713745892047882, 0.023978596553206444, 0.3757900297641754, 0.2718364894390106, -0.14731325209140778, -0.4363577663898468, -0.2531938850879669, 0.15146876871585846, -0.21477189660072327, -0.15126217901706696 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01741v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01741v2	Development and Testing of a Novel Large Language Model-Based Clinical Decision Support Systems for Medication Safety in 12 Clinical Specialties	2024-01-29T16:03:29	2024-02-17T21:13:16	Jasmine Chiat Ling Ong, Liyuan Jin, Kabilan Elangovan, Gilbert Yong San Lim, Daniel Yan Zheng Lim, Gerald Gui Ren Sng, Yuhe Ke, Joshua Yi Min Tung, Ryan Jian Zhong, Christopher Ming Yao Koh, Keane Zhi Hao Lee, Xiang Chen, Jack Kian Chng, Aung Than, Ken Junyang Goh, Daniel Shu Wei Ting	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Importance: We introduce a novel Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)-Large Language Model (LLM) framework as a Clinical Decision Support Systems (CDSS) to support safe medication prescription. Objective: To evaluate the efficacy of LLM-based CDSS in correctly identifying medication errors in different patient case vignettes from diverse medical and surgical sub-disciplines, against a human expert panel derived ground truth. We compared performance for under 2 different CDSS practical healthcare integration modalities: LLM-based CDSS alone (fully autonomous mode) vs junior pharmacist + LLM-based CDSS (co-pilot, assistive mode). Design, Setting, and Participants: Utilizing a RAG model with state-of-the-art medically-related LLMs (GPT-4, Gemini Pro 1.0 and Med-PaLM 2), this study used 61 prescribing error scenarios embedded into 23 complex clinical vignettes across 12 different medical and surgical specialties. A multidisciplinary expert panel assessed these cases for Drug-Related Problems (DRPs) using the PCNE classification and graded severity / potential for harm using revised NCC MERP medication error index. We compared. Results RAG-LLM performed better compared to LLM alone. When employed in a co-pilot mode, accuracy, recall, and F1 scores were optimized, indicating effectiveness in identifying moderate to severe DRPs. The accuracy of DRP detection with RAG-LLM improved in several categories but at the expense of lower precision. Conclusions This study established that a RAG-LLM based CDSS significantly boosts the accuracy of medication error identification when used alongside junior pharmacists (co-pilot), with notable improvements in detecting severe DRPs. This study also illuminates the comparative performance of current state-of-the-art LLMs in RAG-based CDSS systems.	[ 0.13067319989204407, -0.7773752212524414, 0.8388990163803101, 0.34594494104385376, -0.08987751603126526, 0.3453643321990967, -0.16634376347064972, -0.4982612431049347, 0.23115582764148712, 0.5420320630073547, -0.27750808000564575, -0.7548559904098511, -0.7180626392364502, 0.24225389957427979, -0.14336878061294556, 0.8046655058860779, -0.10611443966627121, 0.40005815029144287, -0.006742770783603191, -0.05352318286895752, -0.6383036971092224, -0.754642903804779, -0.7269938588142395, -0.1898474544286728, 0.5998917818069458, 0.26894256472587585, 0.5577449202537537, 0.0877302959561348, 1.172699213027954, 0.30683207511901855, -0.0770355686545372, 0.4401419758796692, -0.1330840289592743, -0.0006425594328902662, -0.10572594404220581, -0.35806038975715637, -1.0284652709960938, -0.19907796382904053, 0.1229931190609932, 0.48087745904922485, -0.6734650731086731, -0.15321943163871765, -0.00566653348505497, 0.5686496496200562, -0.8350881934165955, -0.10073675960302353, -0.28304240107536316, 0.0919402688741684, -0.06593409925699234, -0.08964106440544128, -0.6624574065208435, -0.2551458179950714, 0.22162537276744843, -0.6728165149688721, 0.14756537973880768, 0.07252363115549088, 0.6386154294013977, 0.271103173494339, -0.5265006422996521, -0.5818872451782227, -0.6784560084342957, 0.6856939792633057, -0.8336759209632874, 0.3707231879234314, 0.2002122849225998, 0.6531970500946045, -0.5449785590171814, -0.751815676689148, -0.4795476198196411, -0.12141060829162598, -0.11846806854009628, 0.24280217289924622, 0.3407096862792969, 0.23166964948177338, 0.09025461226701736, 0.30763620138168335, -0.5110366344451904, 0.21727026998996735, -0.21422754228115082, -0.15462066233158112, 0.40277621150016785, 0.46531566977500916, 0.12001734226942062, -0.2354501485824585, -0.7064040303230286, -0.0321563296020031, -0.5736343860626221, -0.19620785117149353, -0.36108362674713135, 0.305987149477005, -0.29872336983680725, 0.40541088581085205, 0.21617652475833893, 0.6515370607376099, 0.07235246151685715, -0.587630569934845, 0.383562296628952, -0.23963525891304016, -0.5576039552688599, -0.03945651277899742, 0.8378681540489197, 0.35315144062042236, 0.09286601841449738, 0.15398956835269928, -0.2340281456708908, 0.067601278424263, 0.2635836601257324, -0.14345316588878632, -0.1200220137834549, 0.17982400953769684, -0.5227710008621216, -0.544815182685852, -0.17521989345550537, -0.690740168094635, -0.7843321561813354, -0.3451905846595764, 0.39925119280815125, -0.30528178811073303, -0.1693004071712494, 0.40076977014541626, 0.1380113810300827, 0.12471693754196167, 0.5218977928161621, -0.5908101201057434, 0.4938732087612152, 0.6175890564918518, 0.6201822757720947, -0.6596609354019165, 0.007305039092898369, -0.24450114369392395, 0.2329973429441452, -0.6402000188827515, 0.8818275332450867, -0.19784854352474213, -0.5249364376068115, 0.054679445922374725, 0.257161021232605, -0.31869617104530334, -1.003358006477356, 0.8372793793678284, -0.405544251203537, -0.13640820980072021, -0.3202979564666748, -0.40688356757164, 0.01496421080082655, 0.21185316145420074, -0.4845731854438782, 0.5530825257301331, 0.16134391725063324, -0.4164275527000427, 0.4196125566959381, -0.3222234547138214, -0.22374854981899261, 0.14784368872642517, -0.39115309715270996, -0.5789072513580322, 0.0688595101237297, -0.01603446528315544, 0.35777992010116577, -0.4484001100063324, 0.6114394664764404, -0.32905611395835876, -0.3170955777168274, 0.2747902572154999, -0.5491425395011902, 0.5988968014717102, 0.21957406401634216, 0.06770365685224533, 0.11318064481019974, -0.8796753287315369, -0.016977107152342796, 0.08006186038255692, -0.7846870422363281, -0.20611974596977234, -0.3414837121963501, 0.2161227911710739, 0.3540736734867096, 0.1525719314813614, -0.38043588399887085, 0.0465020015835762, 0.11815895140171051, -0.1568475365638733, 0.7185079455375671, 0.23156754672527313, 0.1565103977918625, -0.25864773988723755, 0.5395060181617737, 0.09323395043611526, 0.4399190843105316, 0.10371695458889008, -0.3077184855937958, -0.5458630919456482, -0.4186198115348816, 0.5509917140007019, 0.9391143918037415, -0.6703068614006042, 0.49096643924713135, 0.05458242818713188, -0.11471017450094223, -0.06305288523435593, -0.006154196802526712, 0.5967512726783752, 0.7295885682106018, 0.2598209083080292, -0.38029325008392334, -0.4083126187324524, -0.8669987916946411, -0.025568969547748566, -0.004635898396372795, 0.19709201157093048, 0.30260857939720154, 0.3084472119808197, -0.6024508476257324, 0.4924125671386719, -0.5808188915252686, -0.6596987843513489, -0.3626689314842224, -0.2595531940460205, 0.28507763147354126, 0.37103503942489624, 0.35834476351737976, -0.6175636649131775, -0.6174392104148865, 0.0030096645932644606, -0.8576709032058716, -0.12148377299308777, 0.009881719015538692, -0.13200156390666962, 0.47462356090545654, 0.44286665320396423, -0.5219557881355286, 0.5736494064331055, 0.5394939184188843, -0.29194727540016174, 0.41881364583969116, -0.6871729493141174, 0.25511255860328674, -0.9227580428123474, 0.015716390684247017, 0.09392702579498291, -0.05565812811255455, -0.6182074546813965, -0.17698051035404205, 0.3692326247692108, 0.13922826945781708, -0.43966740369796753, 0.12061505019664764, -0.31626415252685547, 0.023907432332634926, -0.06121250241994858, -0.1930721253156662, 0.024372071027755737, 0.248697429895401, 0.016263412311673164, 0.46539703011512756, 0.26351308822631836, -0.4562247097492218, 0.20097506046295166, 0.16327792406082153, -0.2120344489812851, 0.8847885131835938, -0.5652839541435242, -0.3019770383834839, 0.2367369681596756, 0.28981268405914307, -0.7692460417747498, -0.4559418559074402, 0.22714141011238098, -0.0506553091108799, 0.83705073595047, -0.1434956043958664, -0.4125005006790161, -0.4287300705909729, 0.09193243086338043, 0.27618852257728577, 0.42272377014160156, -0.15739180147647858, 0.549651563167572, 0.4652350842952728, -0.307756632566452, -0.7679857015609741, -0.5485745668411255, 0.21075838804244995, -0.10696402192115784, -0.3744027018547058, 0.04965098202228546, 0.048076603561639786, -0.3496161699295044, -0.3326457440853119, -0.1149720549583435, -0.08074866980314255, -0.04666070267558098, 0.11740200221538544, 0.6853141188621521, -0.04327024891972542, 0.3645840585231781, 0.1341511756181717, -0.22398151457309723, -0.0053531876765191555, 0.2109743356704712, 0.24681320786476135, -0.13839535415172577, -0.48402097821235657, -0.35588890314102173, 0.4236502945423126, 0.586682140827179, -0.09681254625320435, 0.6786556839942932, 0.3639068901538849, -0.26172611117362976, -0.25340330600738525, -0.6554197669029236, -0.11117380112409592, -0.4700971245765686, 0.18163138628005981, -0.03694680705666542, -0.43855148553848267, 0.4368358552455902, -0.22727257013320923, -0.24363663792610168, 0.2633974850177765, 0.46606940031051636, -0.18170098960399628, 0.5560010671615601, 0.35918131470680237, 0.4052770435810089, -0.10046655684709549, -0.18086867034435272, 0.32475602626800537, -0.7056143879890442, -0.39043015241622925, -0.20445935428142548, -0.03697805851697922, -0.44993072748184204, -0.7013378143310547, 0.9396515488624573, -0.11828825622797012, -0.41352057456970215, -0.17637544870376587, -0.5015437006950378, 0.048535775393247604, 0.20412889122962952, 0.3556535840034485, 0.3541882634162903, 0.05427558720111847, -0.4622040390968323, 0.018221013247966766, -0.5755560398101807, -0.372684508562088, 1.2657074928283691, 0.311389684677124, 0.931690514087677, 0.05476204678416252, 0.5839172005653381, 0.32040926814079285, 0.39405372738838196, -0.6334349513053894, 0.5408135056495667, -0.6404702663421631, -0.5696263909339905, 0.09866133332252502, -0.23438811302185059, -0.6594768166542053, 0.1679847240447998, -0.5382199287414551, -0.24312466382980347, 0.43875712156295776, -0.04726569354534149, -0.6996736526489258, 0.204274982213974, -0.8810920119285583, 0.734716534614563, -0.3486326336860657, -0.30734777450561523, -0.07212653756141663, -0.7829664349555969, 0.3322198987007141, -0.4224685728549957, 0.5346717238426208, 0.040497057139873505, -0.17646390199661255, 0.5507300496101379, -0.5766068696975708, 0.7715242505073547, -0.06552452594041824, -0.3427186906337738, 0.2121121883392334, -0.00994743499904871, 0.3881126642227173, -0.20750144124031067, 0.1257316768169403, 0.29892486333847046, 0.08435003459453583, -0.06415816396474838, -0.6128238439559937, 0.8896574378013611, -0.5472269654273987, -0.6208453178405762, -0.7079166173934937, -0.5004128217697144, -0.37376290559768677, 0.32418474555015564, -0.002606642432510853, 0.7325182557106018, 0.143318772315979, 0.04960170015692711, 0.8144188523292542, -0.6182684898376465, 0.08354075998067856, 1.0283334255218506, -0.10372193157672882, -0.6129875183105469, 0.6261871457099915, 0.30412396788597107, 0.3972800076007843, 0.3311418890953064, 0.15400466322898865, -0.2564564347267151, -0.7025560736656189, -0.38268208503723145, 0.38662299513816833, -0.7825567126274109, -0.21600675582885742, -0.6016764640808105, -0.20602202415466309, -0.5489299297332764, -0.026878375560045242, -0.2398618757724762, -0.2031743973493576, -0.09229359030723572, -0.06422766298055649, 0.27005812525749207, 0.8445078134536743, -0.1559314876794815, 0.2150859385728836, -0.9170947670936584, 0.4215582609176636, 0.005633157677948475, 0.5036460161209106, -0.2775239646434784, -0.18221637606620789, -0.23952297866344452, -0.3354848325252533, -0.4385019540786743, -0.9160383939743042, 0.33075863122940063, -0.18973439931869507, 0.5568883419036865, 0.24809645116329193, 0.1966576874256134, 0.6167519688606262, -0.5041207075119019, 0.6333327889442444, 0.26644259691238403, -0.5677237510681152, 0.3661847710609436, -0.6115928292274475, -0.0076619465835392475, 0.5062739849090576, 0.10570625960826874, -0.379547119140625, -0.12333422154188156, -0.20985309779644012, -0.9000509977340698, 0.6335731744766235, -0.177972674369812, -0.5142830610275269, -0.1467256098985672, 0.41872650384902954, -0.12939852476119995, 0.04388046637177467, -0.32602185010910034, -0.4435686469078064, 0.4637773334980011, -0.6018213629722595, -0.25998684763908386, -0.34708210825920105, -0.22190003097057343, 0.09200096875429153, 0.5992792248725891, -0.14154702425003052, 0.153516948223114, 0.5159156322479248, 0.2710891664028168, -0.3268517553806305, 0.6557838320732117, 0.5893657207489014, 0.7789168953895569, -0.22076217830181122, -0.04195317625999451, 0.24702809751033783, -0.9665302634239197, 0.24662773311138153, 0.169401615858078, 0.015403482131659985, -0.11336107552051544, 0.1586533933877945, 0.24829865992069244, 0.22282880544662476, -0.8304042816162109, 0.38244444131851196, -0.1743272840976715, 0.056984640657901764, -0.5003407597541809, -0.07052420824766159, 0.0081922747194767, 0.22329294681549072, 0.36079639196395874, 0.4093248248100281, 0.21753345429897308, -0.2790536880493164, 0.19937355816364288, 0.3297520875930786, -0.3121504783630371, 0.131272092461586, 0.12175312638282776, 0.01574065163731575, -0.23377454280853271, 0.07982143759727478, 0.09088350832462311, -0.282477468252182, 0.7373391389846802, 0.569972574710846, 0.5394626259803772, -0.46289125084877014, 0.29636821150779724, 0.2548159658908844, 0.10538574308156967, -0.25105953216552734, 0.3677789866924286, 0.3384995460510254, -0.4865926504135132, -0.32101675868034363, -0.42338934540748596, -0.507522702217102, -0.05706010386347771, -0.6939623355865479, 0.439040869474411, -0.5994712114334106, -0.4771534204483032, -0.2610335946083069, -0.054736822843551636, -0.2916933596134186, 0.4140245318412781, 0.04708576947450638, 0.7602664232254028, -0.5472960472106934, 0.5097758769989014, 0.8319224715232849, 0.004737267270684242, -1.0316028594970703, -0.19826550781726837, 0.3711324632167816, -0.5274873971939087, 0.5368751287460327, -0.2750941812992096, -0.12269259989261627, -0.5157953500747681, -0.21859735250473022, -0.7881187200546265, 1.2730298042297363, 0.03319886699318886, -0.8338662981987, -0.25123512744903564, 0.2527587413787842, 0.8305850028991699, -0.22654271125793457, 0.15270471572875977, 0.6984688639640808, 0.14358733594417572, 0.26826781034469604, -1.3462255001068115, 0.010689225047826767, -0.026828456670045853, -0.20200064778327942, 0.39714229106903076, -0.455820232629776, 0.872356116771698, -0.33658576011657715, 0.020886288955807686, 0.2636626362800598, -0.07915474474430084, 0.7161257863044739, 0.6778748631477356, 0.32105445861816406, 0.809010922908783, 0.7656316757202148, -0.09712941199541092, 1.096927523612976, -0.10115572065114975, 0.16878977417945862, 0.9899776577949524, -0.534904420375824, 0.9060351252555847, 0.38661327958106995, -0.35178712010383606, 0.7718448042869568, 0.29405051469802856, 0.2958657145500183, 0.5849514603614807, 0.01133579108864069, -0.37787213921546936, -0.42514950037002563, 0.012389309704303741, -0.3788072466850281, 0.03047199733555317, 0.8578613996505737, -0.5433717370033264, -0.060613904148340225, 0.2094680368900299, -0.17620694637298584, -0.00996467936784029, -0.14916910231113434, 0.9155752062797546, 0.34787237644195557, -0.5818418264389038, 0.7797910571098328, -0.1577136367559433, 0.4469825327396393, -0.7649050951004028, -0.1017950028181076, -0.022933710366487503, 1.0267081260681152, -0.4727236330509186, -0.6109028458595276, 0.07375429570674896, -0.07214287668466568, -0.14531300961971283, 0.18205907940864563, 0.7291462421417236, -0.13619275391101837, -0.6882463097572327, 0.26410841941833496, 0.4545767605304718, -0.1301032155752182, 0.5785202383995056, -0.7592865228652954, 0.336780846118927, -0.12495923787355423, 0.11547073721885681, 0.3396834135055542, 0.31686756014823914, -0.26493406295776367, 0.6239466071128845, 0.5210343599319458, 0.27333614230155945, -0.07511051744222641, 0.1681445986032486, 0.5981109142303467, -0.40276163816452026, -0.3454534113407135, -0.4385177195072174, 0.2748183310031891, 0.06112300977110863, -0.04301397502422333, 0.7634122371673584, 0.17864890396595, 0.2310653179883957, -0.19638164341449738, 0.5795624852180481, 0.25606465339660645, 1.0255602598190308, -0.40168410539627075, 0.6147093772888184, -0.42303985357284546, 0.770005464553833, -0.5063160061836243, -0.5790466070175171, -0.5664346218109131, 0.5138685703277588, -0.4836411774158478, 0.07413627952337265, 0.6577500700950623, 0.8562467694282532, 0.15559613704681396, 0.058092888444662094, 0.27217361330986023, 0.34175145626068115, 0.3750021755695343, 0.8163214921951294, 0.8570773601531982, -0.5513385534286499, 0.2851225435733795, -0.24304676055908203, -0.35893815755844116, -0.18167228996753693, -0.3960229158401489, -0.6643056273460388, -0.014399140141904354, -0.3130851984024048, -0.6741132140159607, 0.21828359365463257, 1.137892723083496, 0.5399631261825562, -0.8902403116226196, -0.07520049065351486, 0.037357185035943985, 0.15080644190311432, -0.09087332338094711, -0.2120489925146103, 0.5670270919799805, -0.25408732891082764, -0.3375532925128937, 0.3203790485858917, 0.4225596785545349, 0.16368509829044342, -0.16484732925891876, -0.22495223581790924, -0.14371217787265778, -0.051223527640104294, 0.4978697597980499, -0.017490021884441376, -0.6739767789840698, 0.17195671796798706, 0.2613467276096344, -0.4795801639556885, -0.10914646834135056, 0.8926227688789368, -0.6324983239173889, 0.5108787417411804, 0.32503804564476013, 0.27298280596733093, -0.07472970336675644, -0.20053702592849731, 0.41127586364746094, -0.018098702654242516, -0.19990795850753784, 0.23720288276672363, 0.4684952199459076, 0.29676052927970886, -0.483690470457077, 0.37043070793151855, 0.4466257095336914, -0.7550806999206543, -0.6766314506530762, 0.018929189071059227, -1.0016717910766602, -0.20462073385715485, 1.255513310432434, -0.3595639765262604, -0.11546870321035385, -0.5770504474639893, -0.5301827192306519, -0.21954278647899628, -0.30429011583328247, 0.5923689603805542, 0.26765182614326477, -0.14469386637210846, 0.009021563455462456, -0.5644642114639282, 0.6071246266365051, 0.1893249899148941, -0.702614426612854, -0.1675335168838501, 0.7166568040847778, 0.49402180314064026, 0.39720821380615234, 0.7403623461723328, -0.4606921374797821, 0.5046989917755127, -0.29897287487983704, -0.1590770184993744, 0.12214676290750504, -0.23965571820735931, -0.4253743886947632, 0.1480686515569687, -0.10111363977193832, 0.05556480586528778 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16247v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16247v1	Towards Red Teaming in Multimodal and Multilingual Translation	2024-01-29T15:49:40	2024-01-29T15:49:40	Christophe Ropers, David Dale, Prangthip Hansanti, Gabriel Mejia Gonzalez, Ivan Evtimov, Corinne Wong, Christophe Touret, Kristina Pereyra, Seohyun Sonia Kim, Cristian Canton Ferrer, Pierre Andrews, Marta R. Costa-jussà	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.CY, I.2.7	Assessing performance in Natural Language Processing is becoming increasingly complex. One particular challenge is the potential for evaluation datasets to overlap with training data, either directly or indirectly, which can lead to skewed results and overestimation of model performance. As a consequence, human evaluation is gaining increasing interest as a means to assess the performance and reliability of models. One such method is the red teaming approach, which aims to generate edge cases where a model will produce critical errors. While this methodology is becoming standard practice for generative AI, its application to the realm of conditional AI remains largely unexplored. This paper presents the first study on human-based red teaming for Machine Translation (MT), marking a significant step towards understanding and improving the performance of translation models. We delve into both human-based red teaming and a study on automation, reporting lessons learned and providing recommendations for both translation models and red teaming drills. This pioneering work opens up new avenues for research and development in the field of MT.	[ -0.35413724184036255, -0.648448646068573, 0.34263136982917786, 0.44062837958335876, 0.09707270562648773, 0.48308300971984863, -0.3863565921783447, -0.6528857946395874, 0.0898117646574974, 0.21939606964588165, -0.6671003699302673, -0.42986223101615906, -0.7954718470573425, 0.6333656907081604, -0.4689299166202545, 0.9051071405410767, -0.24038714170455933, 0.10510087013244629, -0.3500083386898041, -0.7513243556022644, -0.7436959743499756, -0.6330529451370239, -0.6164610385894775, -0.41297492384910583, 0.2919832766056061, 0.17872971296310425, 0.7030267715454102, 0.3048604428768158, 0.703754186630249, 0.3759220838546753, 0.2651013731956482, 0.3107839524745941, -0.34249410033226013, 0.17124444246292114, -0.08401885628700256, -0.7044802904129028, -0.5220972299575806, 0.30726757645606995, 0.5679363012313843, 0.5374858379364014, -0.14313851296901703, -0.0012196836760267615, -0.17512176930904388, 0.700225293636322, -0.38502058386802673, 0.15593983232975006, -0.4922330677509308, 0.1746995598077774, -0.10418416559696198, -0.2836535573005676, -0.6084199547767639, -0.03661831095814705, 0.20123475790023804, -0.6025066375732422, 0.3530713617801666, 0.19412702322006226, 0.5634331107139587, 0.5371827483177185, -0.3498901128768921, -0.06152781471610069, -0.5574689507484436, 0.9498862028121948, -0.359122633934021, 0.27011874318122864, 0.43885377049446106, 0.6254477500915527, 0.04107292741537094, -0.6088247895240784, -0.6812323331832886, -0.15600578486919403, -0.32110247015953064, 0.3496841788291931, -0.5100014209747314, 0.08889289945363998, -0.13242261111736298, 0.1530264914035797, -0.6664657592773438, 0.12795639038085938, -0.37997451424598694, -0.21216948330402374, 0.7394481301307678, 0.13528133928775787, 0.794658362865448, 0.0007563933031633496, -0.5414385795593262, -0.2508070766925812, -0.1314869225025177, -0.36999890208244324, 0.10515788197517395, 0.37066859006881714, -0.5023796558380127, 0.6078214049339294, -0.2649093270301819, 0.6332380175590515, -0.29889214038848877, 0.28146204352378845, 0.3241262435913086, -0.8045352101325989, -0.19428694248199463, -0.23454080522060394, 0.8314162492752075, 0.6059337258338928, 0.23709066212177277, -0.5106236338615417, -0.4706396162509918, 0.5124211311340332, 0.47418978810310364, -0.20916898548603058, -0.35495999455451965, 0.12087017297744751, -0.2113606035709381, -0.2485528588294983, -0.03717692941427231, -0.6040132641792297, -0.18254749476909637, -0.4111912250518799, 0.4716539978981018, -0.40923067927360535, -0.4846082925796509, -0.003762352280318737, -0.32406699657440186, 0.03435307368636131, 0.2592868506908417, -0.6499014496803284, 0.2741616666316986, 0.5145370960235596, 0.7625013589859009, -0.5634403228759766, -0.8549447655677795, -0.6369025707244873, -0.03935309499502182, -0.14311954379081726, 0.6695341467857361, -0.2219943404197693, -0.08954665064811707, -0.09961159527301788, -0.16115371882915497, -0.2609136998653412, -0.45725247263908386, 0.31461167335510254, -0.45349085330963135, 0.3493604362010956, 0.21501627564430237, -0.03966585919260979, -0.2648274004459381, 0.5741255879402161, -0.612985372543335, 0.8436772227287292, 0.2655681371688843, -0.5729302763938904, 0.5828691124916077, -1.186889886856079, -0.6711511015892029, 0.09377244114875793, 0.05134454742074013, -0.2923567593097687, -0.08129073679447174, 0.12764044106006622, 0.28341108560562134, -0.4670287072658539, 0.2525063753128052, 0.07101898640394211, -0.13703738152980804, 0.17042730748653412, -0.3805634081363678, 0.607746422290802, 0.028343522921204567, -0.38884326815605164, 0.5601642727851868, -0.32230252027511597, 0.2245136946439743, 0.10035745799541473, -0.2618429362773895, -0.3017086088657379, -0.1805332899093628, 0.20294612646102905, 0.14259882271289825, -0.06366971135139465, -0.24485179781913757, 0.02413966879248619, -0.09446831792593002, 0.6531800031661987, 0.550994336605072, -0.32228004932403564, 0.6109191179275513, -0.28408917784690857, 0.7094240784645081, -0.2014717161655426, 0.20252791047096252, 0.01673891395330429, -0.4620877206325531, -0.6835052967071533, -0.2524414360523224, 0.5481809377670288, 0.6259620189666748, -1.1600664854049683, 0.070454902946949, -0.3006514310836792, -0.26403215527534485, -1.0387765169143677, 0.19805780053138733, 0.6381017565727234, 0.15415364503860474, 0.7525169253349304, -0.30576297640800476, -0.7407042384147644, -1.0521881580352783, -0.2094157338142395, -0.13141342997550964, 0.13842687010765076, 0.018445679917931557, 0.6788427829742432, -0.8023386001586914, 1.0399093627929688, -0.061845481395721436, -0.431933730840683, -0.8238237500190735, 0.6574726700782776, -0.0351022444665432, 0.5576369166374207, 0.33388078212738037, -1.2081987857818604, -0.6896295547485352, 0.2536236643791199, -0.7897239923477173, -0.0572202168405056, -0.12165901064872742, -0.1552782654762268, 0.5888792276382446, 0.2543347477912903, -0.46281448006629944, 0.282586932182312, 1.1483296155929565, -0.25295042991638184, 0.45155778527259827, -0.300802081823349, 0.43204131722450256, -0.7858246564865112, 0.21794641017913818, 0.1967255175113678, -0.5667203068733215, -0.6635873913764954, 0.1578086018562317, 0.06966819614171982, 0.034167561680078506, -0.5741094946861267, 0.4854336678981781, -0.48767733573913574, -0.16952799260616302, -0.0976913645863533, 0.25932520627975464, -0.07979739457368851, 0.5257503390312195, 0.011275822296738625, 1.0174942016601562, 0.08061977475881577, -0.43330174684524536, 0.2844168543815613, 0.13161343336105347, -0.22030045092105865, 0.619425356388092, -0.5668806433677673, 0.0565144419670105, -0.013189571909606457, 0.13173028826713562, -0.739847719669342, -0.33112549781799316, 0.2526462972164154, -0.675980806350708, 0.3973900377750397, -0.1905367076396942, -0.7356247305870056, -0.24337787926197052, -0.08834586292505264, 0.6129153370857239, 0.27501603960990906, -0.2007133662700653, 0.3964424431324005, 0.6725947260856628, -0.08173154294490814, -0.3254918158054352, -0.7063024044036865, 0.4433482885360718, -0.059506047517061234, -0.8097788095474243, 0.5638701319694519, 0.04670339450240135, -0.5109232068061829, -0.06737744063138962, 0.06325417757034302, -0.5629017353057861, 0.3965659439563751, 0.0072640590369701385, 0.3950311541557312, 0.04219676926732063, -0.08253215998411179, -0.13952971994876862, -0.39254873991012573, -0.17564040422439575, 0.12014149129390717, 0.4832130968570709, -0.3596319258213043, -0.09989659488201141, -0.739736795425415, 0.37724146246910095, 0.7741482257843018, -0.4139770269393921, 0.6662829518318176, 0.69488525390625, -0.25448471307754517, -0.040587376803159714, -0.5020877122879028, -0.11856500804424286, -0.34636300802230835, 0.61855548620224, -0.14557969570159912, -0.5409919619560242, 0.08128076791763306, 0.129817396402359, -0.020977098494768143, 0.6563078761100769, 0.45504099130630493, -0.38696524500846863, 1.1085532903671265, 1.1028153896331787, 0.022793162614107132, 0.1548442840576172, -0.18548116087913513, -0.11541919410228729, -0.7293038964271545, -0.06249633803963661, -0.23871789872646332, -0.39365601539611816, -0.36755746603012085, -0.5511199235916138, 0.5372275114059448, -0.08200841397047043, 0.30695322155952454, 0.5735979676246643, -0.3261617124080658, 0.48473984003067017, 0.4169621169567108, -0.19070854783058167, 0.4143584072589874, -0.36261188983917236, -0.06477582454681396, -0.12273277342319489, -0.9597305655479431, -0.41442111134529114, 0.8240090608596802, 0.2650185823440552, 0.08615167438983917, 0.17414678633213043, 0.37436535954475403, 0.7259155511856079, 0.7980527877807617, -0.5727245807647705, 0.31498241424560547, 0.07974055409431458, -0.7449151873588562, -0.5034664869308472, -0.6486319303512573, -0.8859860301017761, 0.467957079410553, -0.49862492084503174, -0.021845581009984016, -0.48949384689331055, 0.07863075286149979, -0.1965160071849823, 0.09954389184713364, -1.0552681684494019, 1.120505452156067, -0.594174861907959, -0.22090496122837067, -0.3673483431339264, -0.8551486730575562, 0.3265427350997925, 0.08597161620855331, 0.22568394243717194, 0.12584280967712402, 0.17630840837955475, 0.7285147309303284, 0.14597535133361816, 0.8372823596000671, -0.054021529853343964, 0.17303726077079773, -0.06738490611314774, 0.1935797482728958, 0.3127779960632324, -0.1156289130449295, -0.033473722636699677, 0.3741728961467743, -0.002826317446306348, -0.42076894640922546, -0.5533117651939392, 0.26388242840766907, -0.6672748923301697, -0.4042922854423523, -0.3958269953727722, -0.8275914788246155, -0.2252555787563324, 0.32620295882225037, -0.008660969324409962, -0.04315279424190521, -0.24417106807231903, 0.0645197406411171, 0.21785402297973633, -0.2094593048095703, 0.3149799108505249, 0.48185375332832336, -0.10290434956550598, -0.6239853501319885, 0.9728919863700867, -0.23523782193660736, 0.49277615547180176, 0.5205337405204773, -0.02998400665819645, -0.29706811904907227, -0.6788273453712463, -0.8203960657119751, 0.28505948185920715, -0.38695481419563293, -0.11169008910655975, -0.5230890512466431, 0.14792123436927795, -0.15321500599384308, -0.20721609890460968, -0.6643235087394714, -0.31851428747177124, -0.00012562745541799814, 0.12235768139362335, -0.024082383140921593, 0.6182041168212891, 0.13635534048080444, -0.12391651421785355, -0.9372334480285645, 0.2728964686393738, 0.26063570380210876, 0.18101584911346436, -0.22129373252391815, 0.003137951483950019, -0.2551487982273102, 0.32455500960350037, -0.2795189619064331, -0.493317574262619, 0.5549414157867432, -0.1727922558784485, 0.7253382205963135, -0.22802288830280304, 0.1952938288450241, 0.6035169959068298, -0.27664580941200256, 0.5395564436912537, 0.4943264126777649, -0.9248440265655518, 0.47056299448013306, -0.267923504114151, 0.016794556751847267, 0.7949086427688599, 0.3630841374397278, -0.760925829410553, -0.28146281838417053, -0.41353026032447815, -0.7048936486244202, 0.775760293006897, 0.6138434410095215, -0.2881273627281189, 0.154659241437912, 0.004764690529555082, 0.10725834220647812, 0.3103225827217102, -0.8970094323158264, -0.27664580941200256, -0.0003747546288650483, -0.07500708103179932, -0.5028432011604309, 0.046137530356645584, -0.41270822286605835, -0.13903012871742249, 0.377667099237442, -0.10897114872932434, 0.27417197823524475, 0.17312180995941162, -0.6758913397789001, -0.07708505541086197, 0.27390149235725403, 0.9369423389434814, 0.7337437868118286, -0.09133581817150116, 0.01769002340734005, 0.3740156590938568, 0.08208766579627991, 0.1417672038078308, -0.11058245599269867, 0.13523755967617035, -0.07187259197235107, 0.5903298854827881, 0.39674341678619385, 0.17862951755523682, -0.7642444372177124, 0.6240301132202148, -0.10809081792831421, -0.23952150344848633, -0.13823138177394867, -0.1477673202753067, -0.28970545530319214, 0.16318318247795105, 0.20117893815040588, 0.4860537350177765, -0.1646731197834015, -0.7585142850875854, 0.17821720242500305, 0.3360292315483093, -0.7600453495979309, -0.5509708523750305, 0.5700754523277283, 0.7631368637084961, -0.4787635803222656, 0.6690286993980408, -0.36264362931251526, -1.0367273092269897, 0.48460668325424194, 0.4130331873893738, 0.8458979725837708, 0.09538575261831284, 0.191598579287529, 0.11693300306797028, 0.526946485042572, -0.03263568878173828, -0.1712072193622589, -0.2384507954120636, -0.6427546739578247, -0.5932363271713257, -0.28674381971359253, -0.5905611515045166, -0.5094082951545715, -0.6397270560264587, 0.10964612662792206, 0.14301840960979462, -0.17489419877529144, -0.3673246204853058, -0.158548966050148, -0.5229160189628601, -0.019874025136232376, -0.06831818073987961, 0.7290945649147034, -0.7539569139480591, 0.7944899797439575, 0.9118416905403137, -0.5713925361633301, 0.14663438498973846, -0.06328555941581726, -0.009950980544090271, -0.6676193475723267, 0.9619815349578857, 0.13423864543437958, -0.2747981548309326, -0.07237901538610458, 0.023433782160282135, -0.3404594957828522, 1.057765007019043, 0.13075922429561615, -0.1676986813545227, -0.004002281464636326, 0.13419856131076813, 0.6303882598876953, -0.10685426741838455, 0.0914759486913681, 0.5662845373153687, 0.7946644425392151, -0.3645637333393097, -1.2329859733581543, -0.1987205445766449, -0.31970643997192383, -0.2598981261253357, 0.37806788086891174, -0.6269807815551758, 0.5448393821716309, -0.3741590976715088, -0.5977354049682617, 0.01089838519692421, 0.3938882052898407, -0.03466477990150452, 0.40556055307388306, 0.5541572570800781, 0.4848504066467285, 0.5663350224494934, -0.10772520303726196, 1.4475748538970947, 0.0053262957371771336, 0.16325093805789948, 0.9651600122451782, -0.22976413369178772, 0.8587971329689026, 0.6406353116035461, -0.4070926904678345, 0.06014889106154442, 0.11659632623195648, 0.11492951214313507, 0.4552806615829468, 0.006163674406707287, -0.1240905374288559, -0.3172832429409027, -0.001083497074432671, -0.20387236773967743, 0.46405932307243347, 0.0397656112909317, -0.1638668179512024, -0.03148604556918144, -0.11263269186019897, -0.19109860062599182, 0.32434695959091187, 0.07277348637580872, 0.7617331147193909, -0.12298870831727982, -0.9252647757530212, 0.5425838828086853, 0.3277011513710022, 1.0114134550094604, -0.315177321434021, -0.11546273529529572, -0.19742430746555328, 0.049297090619802475, -0.06349235773086548, -0.6630831360816956, 0.6572252511978149, 0.08255551755428314, -0.5491819977760315, -0.7162615656852722, 0.15042434632778168, -0.3470448851585388, -0.2567933201789856, 0.4399062395095825, 0.5577503442764282, -0.16771617531776428, -0.14843161404132843, -0.6368116140365601, 0.07998161017894745, 0.16956035792827606, 0.4188137352466583, 0.4173533022403717, 0.15821580588817596, 0.03458515554666519, 0.9111565351486206, 0.7489027380943298, -0.03202439844608307, 0.08347106724977493, -0.15115563571453094, 0.4455733001232147, -0.7352139353752136, -0.21361547708511353, -0.9105014204978943, 0.7085672616958618, 0.05015247315168381, -0.3786477744579315, 0.6445710062980652, 0.4919712543487549, 0.8593128323554993, 0.006906827446073294, 0.8562695980072021, 0.011396036483347416, 0.4115976095199585, -0.506763219833374, 1.1107739210128784, -0.5583667159080505, -0.0071098399348556995, -0.250647634267807, -0.6763626933097839, -0.6709408760070801, 0.475695937871933, -0.142799511551857, -0.30736199021339417, 0.7673746943473816, 0.5596989989280701, 0.024551019072532654, -0.03128927946090698, 0.46835121512413025, 0.10568548738956451, 0.44837144017219543, 0.4625720679759979, 1.0466984510421753, -0.5611920952796936, 0.779276967048645, -0.2610345780849457, -0.2326856255531311, -0.11584634333848953, -0.7869399785995483, -0.7538742423057556, -0.6917443871498108, -0.2833082973957062, -0.01720389537513256, 0.21218422055244446, 0.9059041142463684, 0.7472803592681885, -0.5384230017662048, -0.27355843782424927, -0.17030446231365204, 0.31624630093574524, -0.3731052279472351, -0.18323718011379242, -0.01630271226167679, -0.43212050199508667, -0.9438818693161011, 0.6620481014251709, 0.3591613173484802, 0.08619559556245804, -0.2799358665943146, -0.44232696294784546, -0.3461412489414215, -0.5759177207946777, 0.7863202691078186, 0.32657966017723083, -0.7782840132713318, 0.0367625467479229, -0.13251623511314392, -0.08266349136829376, 0.050166793167591095, 0.6089920401573181, -0.7075909972190857, 0.6173502206802368, 0.2441311776638031, 0.9705693125724792, 0.2974766790866852, -0.0436774305999279, 1.1742602586746216, -0.630526065826416, -0.030740661546587944, 0.43216994404792786, 0.23626254498958588, 0.39101532101631165, 0.22128193080425262, 0.864829957485199, 0.3422771394252777, -0.3955802321434021, -1.0818225145339966, 0.004768093582242727, -0.7695044279098511, 0.05782710388302803, 0.9719507098197937, -0.022747274488210678, 0.11295618116855621, -0.19337204098701477, -0.0862891748547554, 0.2569173276424408, -0.19304615259170532, 0.8517469763755798, 0.5749773979187012, -0.1452024132013321, 0.04155594855546951, -0.8117303252220154, 0.16121569275856018, 0.683100163936615, -0.9304537177085876, -0.031757909804582596, 0.21194766461849213, -0.020829614251852036, 0.32236215472221375, 0.36932840943336487, 0.0732622891664505, 0.5917060375213623, -0.1951250582933426, 0.3287433981895447, -0.11031850427389145, -0.4558551013469696, -0.12033599615097046, 0.06240161135792732, -0.14543859660625458, -0.2609076499938965 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01740v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01740v3	Reducing Selection Bias in Large Language Models	2024-01-29T15:43:23	2024-06-15T13:23:21	J. E. Eicher, R. F. Irgolič	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.0	Large Language Models (LLMs) like gpt-3.5-turbo-0613 and claude-instant-1.2 are vital in interpreting and executing semantic tasks. Unfortunately, these models' inherent biases adversely affect their performance Particularly affected is object selection from lists; a fundamental operation in digital navigation and decision-making. This research critically examines these biases and quantifies the effects on a representative list selection task. To explore these biases, we experiment manipulating temperature, list length, object identity, object type, prompt complexity, and model. We isolated and measured the influence of the biases on selection behavior. Our findings show that bias structure is strongly dependent on the model, with object type modulating the magnitude of the effect. With a strong primacy effect, causing the first objects in a list to be disproportionately represented in outputs. The usage of guard rails, a prompt engineering method of ensuring a response structure, increases bias and decreases instruction adherence when to a selection task. The bias is ablated when the guard rail step is separated from the list sampling step, lowering the complexity of each individual task. We provide LLM applications and theoretically suggest that LLMs experience a form of cognitive load that is compensated for with bias.	[ -0.5708276629447937, -0.6972284913063049, 0.6455870866775513, 0.11066121608018875, -0.20691075921058655, -0.23368597030639648, -0.3320921063423157, -0.45835480093955994, -0.12800286710262299, 0.6893543601036072, -0.4745981693267822, -0.32543227076530457, -0.708611011505127, -0.1307104378938675, -0.3560214042663574, 1.170332670211792, -0.013406778685748577, -0.061489686369895935, -0.18783386051654816, 0.15864090621471405, -0.4500369727611542, -0.6078605055809021, -0.6321256160736084, -0.7264801263809204, 0.41763049364089966, 0.16543477773666382, 0.7686741948127747, 0.57316654920578, 0.5495864152908325, 0.16048629581928253, -0.39427486062049866, -0.01302514411509037, -0.6141517162322998, 0.2910262644290924, -0.4192854166030884, -0.43440771102905273, -0.5835181474685669, -0.029713379219174385, 0.6054293513298035, 0.5793998837471008, 0.14701038599014282, 0.19472722709178925, 0.24674038589000702, 0.7233737707138062, -0.7589340806007385, 0.3654133677482605, -0.7841191291809082, -0.037062544375658035, -0.3177878260612488, -0.06332667171955109, -0.6413688659667969, 0.2591823935508728, 0.4243442416191101, -0.40216800570487976, 0.2947935163974762, 0.24184446036815643, 0.571117639541626, 0.28001412749290466, -0.3357233703136444, 0.0158887580037117, -0.881473958492279, 1.0105923414230347, -0.39770177006721497, 0.509916365146637, 0.573662519454956, -0.12081913650035858, -0.15151704847812653, -0.14065879583358765, -0.17639178037643433, -0.427511990070343, 0.04201040789484978, -0.07071999460458755, 0.25231993198394775, 0.27505064010620117, 0.540364146232605, 0.03648868575692177, -0.4923762381076813, 0.2799263298511505, -0.3648315966129303, -0.14881372451782227, 0.4303857982158661, 0.027779487892985344, 0.31108689308166504, -0.09373149275779724, 0.06906154751777649, -0.23483619093894958, -0.9682870507240295, -0.14276374876499176, 0.33444657921791077, 0.2112104296684265, 0.11202383041381836, 0.5738763213157654, -0.13864734768867493, 0.7332366704940796, -0.0032295435667037964, -0.12401983886957169, -0.0169246643781662, -0.06512616574764252, -0.3522310256958008, -0.08885367959737778, 0.5191494822502136, 0.5000576376914978, 0.5379291772842407, -0.029297998175024986, -0.18770286440849304, 0.12001810222864151, 0.11370713263750076, -0.7760809659957886, -0.3172394335269928, 0.07324449717998505, -0.5332245826721191, -0.03262876346707344, -0.0493098720908165, -0.6830196976661682, -0.5304474234580994, -0.3169282078742981, 0.012638691812753677, -0.1030375212430954, -0.035465918481349945, 0.06994513422250748, -0.11508195847272873, 0.08101528882980347, 0.33989885449409485, -1.0026888847351074, 0.3899374008178711, 0.48036855459213257, 0.6115735769271851, -0.3168814480304718, -0.2060922384262085, -0.7128406167030334, 0.42117223143577576, -0.30302155017852783, 0.6740911602973938, -0.8788983821868896, -0.5992487668991089, -0.2250993847846985, -0.2536236643791199, -0.0321255587041378, -0.6681817770004272, 0.5384212136268616, -0.6544623374938965, 0.2059258222579956, -0.33090633153915405, -0.289434552192688, -0.06357019394636154, 0.12990768253803253, -0.7907937169075012, 0.7922067642211914, -0.19371163845062256, -0.8208327293395996, 0.6577830910682678, -0.485350638628006, -0.4606896638870239, -0.4369131326675415, -0.32792848348617554, -0.314077764749527, 0.006131250411272049, 0.3753131926059723, 0.4791005849838257, -0.3903775215148926, -0.006293335929512978, -0.5329052805900574, -0.37785908579826355, 0.12312633544206619, -0.19314047694206238, 0.3153126835823059, 0.10331913828849792, -0.3948412537574768, 0.2157019078731537, -0.32218480110168457, -0.17053045332431793, 0.08779828995466232, -0.5012944936752319, -0.5352671146392822, 0.4745849072933197, -0.09492085874080658, 0.35051047801971436, -0.001659981906414032, -0.21481451392173767, 0.31748080253601074, -0.2971976101398468, 0.12795643508434296, 1.086017370223999, -0.10533244907855988, 0.7363703846931458, -0.3321007490158081, 0.3674752712249756, 0.019949892535805702, 0.23027896881103516, 0.35469040274620056, -0.4584713876247406, -0.7470859289169312, -0.14853540062904358, 0.09856479614973068, 0.48357173800468445, -0.5580905079841614, 0.24255046248435974, -0.23269103467464447, -0.15910153090953827, -0.10594867169857025, 0.41224172711372375, 0.358738511800766, 0.1901811957359314, 0.3233107626438141, -0.12079916894435883, -0.4272543787956238, -1.0107157230377197, -0.24389685690402985, -0.17352962493896484, -0.20125186443328857, 0.24554294347763062, 0.24222998321056366, -0.15969182550907135, 0.8320626020431519, -0.5883802175521851, -0.2439952939748764, -0.3096030354499817, -0.3860671818256378, 0.2309710830450058, 0.3674614429473877, 0.5383489727973938, -0.5742670297622681, -0.3309304714202881, -0.06064789369702339, -0.2832844853401184, -0.14813902974128723, -0.18184217810630798, -0.4275696277618408, 0.3348398208618164, 0.4026065170764923, -0.921829104423523, 0.4646182060241699, 0.2718368172645569, -0.33413252234458923, 0.3387490510940552, 0.04560999199748039, -0.16304342448711395, -0.6062827706336975, -0.049338456243276596, 0.2971768081188202, -0.0430668443441391, -0.45493394136428833, -0.07342866063117981, 0.0853310078382492, 0.25562798976898193, -0.3691566586494446, 0.7540501356124878, -0.608816385269165, -0.27720731496810913, -0.30586814880371094, 0.20433025062084198, 0.04038524627685547, 0.27492114901542664, 0.330241322517395, 0.670642614364624, 0.4293411672115326, -0.984968364238739, -0.0939343273639679, 0.3153381645679474, -0.21690936386585236, 0.1407582312822342, -0.4295964241027832, 0.2018902599811554, -0.27830737829208374, 0.4217890501022339, -0.5406920909881592, 0.07079067081212997, 0.27278706431388855, 0.12123887985944748, 0.44209226965904236, -0.2971501052379608, -0.3967686593532562, -0.337414026260376, -0.4374655485153198, 0.12525567412376404, 0.4673713147640228, -0.2622615694999695, 0.29198122024536133, 0.3160243630409241, -0.07615157961845398, -0.6666346788406372, -0.7172428369522095, -0.2472822219133377, -0.20929445326328278, -0.30220773816108704, 0.2541690170764923, -0.34372806549072266, -0.6184852719306946, -0.33027613162994385, -0.5677010416984558, 0.2819399833679199, 0.12408701330423355, 0.049735791981220245, 0.6817052364349365, 0.09939740598201752, 0.2475469559431076, -0.03914599493145943, 0.1763187050819397, 0.1749912053346634, -0.40446704626083374, 0.8525285124778748, 0.18494293093681335, -0.41408097743988037, -0.007322793360799551, 0.10809037834405899, 0.7047637701034546, -0.33162710070610046, 0.8100888729095459, 0.36125075817108154, -0.03956849128007889, -0.5034478306770325, -0.6723223924636841, -0.40466687083244324, -0.4771670401096344, 0.5687856674194336, -0.4185124337673187, -0.8270232677459717, 0.34593328833580017, 0.4370192587375641, 0.1723669469356537, 0.2818361222743988, 0.609010636806488, 0.3485477566719055, 1.0788612365722656, 0.29546216130256653, -0.5093012452125549, 0.8141486048698425, -0.057016417384147644, 0.2624451816082001, -1.1300079822540283, -0.1064118891954422, -0.4802667796611786, -0.3668726980686188, -0.5044320821762085, -0.3860389292240143, 0.323158323764801, -0.1558707356452942, -0.35928356647491455, -0.16437941789627075, -0.7182345390319824, 0.43006235361099243, 0.42116662859916687, 0.36959928274154663, 0.12396806478500366, 0.1253432333469391, -0.03228706121444702, 0.09401702880859375, -0.6324236989021301, -0.5141914486885071, 1.4132297039031982, 0.22289492189884186, 0.9993835687637329, -0.009180156514048576, 0.40534305572509766, 0.3483673334121704, 0.10853219777345657, -0.7399466037750244, 0.8961367011070251, -0.2453090399503708, -0.6843644976615906, -0.3153083324432373, -0.41187843680381775, -0.8360170125961304, 0.47069865465164185, -0.17702770233154297, -0.9126981496810913, -0.16120308637619019, 0.12358961254358292, -0.1840697079896927, 0.38832080364227295, -0.7105253338813782, 0.5568047165870667, -0.29618608951568604, -0.6389088034629822, -0.405394047498703, -0.18515893816947937, 0.41893959045410156, -0.03661256283521652, 0.10887753218412399, -0.23386013507843018, -0.0034035269636660814, 0.7541579604148865, -0.05663122609257698, 0.8781715631484985, -0.13576820492744446, -0.0011883463012054563, 0.039407745003700256, 0.4019171893596649, 0.8901205062866211, -0.054957661777734756, -0.2682427167892456, -0.1666017770767212, -0.26146531105041504, -0.3761310875415802, -0.3554670810699463, 0.7698560953140259, -0.8870185613632202, -1.0228809118270874, -0.1868896186351776, -0.6916298270225525, -0.3610181510448456, 0.055018164217472076, 0.10576443374156952, 0.33118748664855957, 0.013411286287009716, 0.09682305157184601, 0.9423115253448486, -0.25468865036964417, 0.36841487884521484, 0.3912753760814667, -0.4851190745830536, 0.10644407570362091, 0.4933008849620819, 0.46056053042411804, 0.5643230080604553, 0.2595181465148926, 0.1356220692396164, -0.20900003612041473, -0.8305186629295349, -0.19950604438781738, 0.29825592041015625, -0.7951453924179077, 0.25123152136802673, -0.6359106302261353, -0.1534091979265213, -0.36341923475265503, 0.04099918529391289, -0.056762468069791794, -0.42723479866981506, -0.4333527088165283, -0.267031192779541, 0.33242082595825195, 0.7200186848640442, 0.4410116970539093, 0.24456579983234406, -0.4751708209514618, 0.3181563913822174, 0.34245455265045166, 0.29827967286109924, 0.002861079527065158, -0.572237491607666, -0.04451393336057663, -0.16926898062229156, -0.14776787161827087, -0.4304356873035431, 0.20408602058887482, 0.12845958769321442, 0.7792378067970276, 0.3966601490974426, 0.11713467538356781, 0.4542708396911621, -0.4325042963027954, 0.668420672416687, -0.02485974133014679, -0.8640184998512268, 0.6317886710166931, -0.5520365834236145, 0.4421156644821167, 0.151755228638649, 0.08140316605567932, -0.30126768350601196, -0.4095245897769928, -0.4589111804962158, -0.8426899909973145, 0.8011689186096191, 0.08962953090667725, -0.0987873375415802, -0.00362996943295002, 0.18182961642742157, 0.005485678091645241, 0.12238705903291702, -0.755291223526001, -0.2594788074493408, 0.12017016857862473, 0.19767846167087555, -0.09631261229515076, -0.4889833927154541, 0.016851181164383888, -0.07514675706624985, 0.838327169418335, 0.0017214725958183408, 0.009188557043671608, 0.12331582605838776, -0.2544533610343933, -0.05643489211797714, 0.44984692335128784, 0.7597883939743042, 0.7013967037200928, -0.2267974317073822, 0.09862038493156433, 0.293458491563797, -0.5005282163619995, -0.08652377128601074, -0.20308712124824524, -0.48723870515823364, -0.09316607564687729, 0.19911155104637146, 0.8119757175445557, 0.016286078840494156, -0.4616287350654602, 0.032763462513685226, 0.1959063708782196, 0.12530633807182312, -0.0689912661910057, 0.3728613257408142, -0.1981390416622162, 0.15017925202846527, 0.13510136306285858, 0.19544807076454163, 0.14077217876911163, -0.48317793011665344, 0.012184487655758858, 0.7469260096549988, -0.0843123272061348, -0.11793043464422226, 0.5315117835998535, 0.2884729504585266, -0.10497070103883743, 0.5784682035446167, 0.05340428277850151, -0.4571402668952942, 0.5167694687843323, 0.456540584564209, 0.6856831312179565, -0.11246200650930405, 0.11615591496229172, 0.1465373933315277, 0.6850001811981201, -0.5031010508537292, -0.10523710399866104, 0.01315448060631752, -0.8621113300323486, -0.4695737659931183, -0.4651363790035248, -0.4255937337875366, 0.30691319704055786, -0.5238725543022156, 0.10198379307985306, -0.6948516964912415, -0.4345248341560364, -0.5047463178634644, -0.13956741988658905, -0.7629917860031128, 0.14535988867282867, 0.525820791721344, 0.7500100135803223, -0.7546257376670837, 0.8829901814460754, 0.654573917388916, -0.3091360628604889, -0.7406767010688782, 0.12714186310768127, 0.06811926513910294, -0.6056393384933472, 0.9137359261512756, 0.021710461005568504, -0.062172286212444305, -0.22504191100597382, -0.2997379004955292, -0.9590293765068054, 0.6613675355911255, 0.34622570872306824, -0.5747057199478149, -0.10704373568296432, 0.13614054024219513, 0.2678205966949463, -0.22900231182575226, 0.5541400909423828, 0.8278161883354187, 0.6792966723442078, -0.12490285187959671, -1.2262176275253296, 0.08932352066040039, -0.022592993453145027, 0.16979846358299255, 0.31225988268852234, -0.6821152567863464, 0.898276686668396, 0.18456311523914337, 0.10886001586914062, -0.26956719160079956, 0.20366813242435455, 0.583138108253479, -0.1001708060503006, 0.5039339661598206, 0.3230728209018707, 0.7481025457382202, 0.07443983107805252, 1.0666275024414062, -0.13650116324424744, 0.09028079360723495, 1.0757761001586914, -0.6885550618171692, 0.7547149062156677, 0.7575158476829529, -0.22486913204193115, 0.31921136379241943, 0.5328308939933777, 0.1556302309036255, 0.426636666059494, 0.4125594198703766, -0.23373590409755707, -0.393149197101593, -0.1694682240486145, -0.3338955044746399, 0.2884112298488617, 0.4766649007797241, -0.4342307150363922, -0.09042882919311523, -0.00872758124023676, 0.2968927323818207, -0.25332289934158325, -0.5946919918060303, 0.5021541118621826, 0.1443481147289276, -0.7490526437759399, 0.5013594031333923, -0.25188592076301575, 0.6795003414154053, -0.6592445373535156, 0.209293931722641, -0.09806565940380096, 0.3436656892299652, -0.31353166699409485, -0.7998130321502686, 0.010117384605109692, -0.03182995691895485, -0.5698608756065369, -0.3815793991088867, 0.8430159091949463, -0.24521739780902863, -0.4178069233894348, 0.5644518136978149, 0.5183504819869995, -0.06060151383280754, -0.377683162689209, -0.4917498230934143, 0.3966987133026123, 0.13605454564094543, -0.7597203254699707, 0.5996623039245605, 0.20125573873519897, -0.35967177152633667, 0.9869651198387146, 0.6791892051696777, 0.3322787880897522, 0.04270966351032257, 0.0708913579583168, 1.0001801252365112, -0.40807345509529114, -0.38780173659324646, -1.0373973846435547, 0.32395613193511963, -0.2490127682685852, 0.07152217626571655, 0.7192026376724243, 0.4928882122039795, 0.8672121167182922, -0.29701587557792664, 0.992721676826477, 0.10405084490776062, 0.35028237104415894, -0.8404866456985474, 0.7705543637275696, -0.13037918508052826, 0.7857054471969604, -0.27244120836257935, -1.3123855590820312, -0.23435580730438232, 0.5172284841537476, -0.883613646030426, 0.13165849447250366, 0.8028473854064941, 0.7983388304710388, -0.10220204293727875, -0.4463467001914978, 0.3568131923675537, 0.24225914478302002, 0.3571084141731262, 0.43206143379211426, 0.8146616220474243, -0.057581935077905655, 0.6553640961647034, -0.1115393191576004, -0.01813756301999092, -0.20453110337257385, -0.6743044853210449, -1.3806613683700562, -0.11290346831083298, -0.21020443737506866, -0.3421271741390228, 0.06107514724135399, 1.1037074327468872, 0.8105253577232361, -0.7897769212722778, -0.41172870993614197, 0.07820461690425873, 0.36431884765625, 0.1151840090751648, -0.22815409302711487, 0.28269314765930176, -0.25839096307754517, -0.5765666961669922, 0.3256276547908783, 0.14515021443367004, -0.16061018407344818, -0.14842550456523895, -0.08636157959699631, -0.10401122272014618, -0.0048800501972436905, 0.7579147219657898, 0.030759552493691444, -0.9126117825508118, -0.4360824525356293, -0.04005562514066696, 0.013915576972067356, 0.024344857782125473, 0.74686598777771, -0.8015438318252563, 0.19296929240226746, 0.498056560754776, 0.4668498933315277, 0.5753971934318542, -0.22225786745548248, 0.6146613955497742, -0.45493030548095703, 0.3538161814212799, 0.04560873657464981, 0.5579211115837097, 0.039283715188503265, -0.37759530544281006, 0.4818660318851471, 0.0947418212890625, -0.6453211903572083, -0.5503465533256531, 0.4215724766254425, -0.8298011422157288, -0.4363454282283783, 1.5205174684524536, 0.29787102341651917, -0.23976057767868042, -0.04594877362251282, -0.44005826115608215, -0.011255568824708462, -0.6040017008781433, 0.7900127172470093, 0.9768813252449036, -0.042708586901426315, -0.28744450211524963, -0.7440186142921448, 0.5421803593635559, 0.7065547108650208, -0.608955442905426, 0.15652935206890106, 0.8382362723350525, 0.25486430525779724, -0.1875562220811844, 0.36759379506111145, 0.14022351801395416, 0.08018829673528671, -0.40796470642089844, 0.21821148693561554, 0.06071794778108597, -0.2573254704475403, -0.1415003091096878, 0.06605177372694016, 0.44999849796295166, 0.013805986382067204 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16240v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16240v2	Combining Hierachical VAEs with LLMs for clinically meaningful timeline summarisation in social media	2024-01-29T15:42:57	2024-02-16T12:42:28	Jiayu Song, Jenny Chim, Adam Tsakalidis, Julia Ive, Dana Atzil-Slonim, Maria Liakata	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	We introduce a hybrid abstractive summarisation approach combining hierarchical VAE with LLMs (LlaMA-2) to produce clinically meaningful summaries from social media user timelines, appropriate for mental health monitoring. The summaries combine two different narrative points of view: clinical insights in third person useful for a clinician are generated by feeding into an LLM specialised clinical prompts, and importantly, a temporally sensitive abstractive summary of the user's timeline in first person, generated by a novel hierarchical variational autoencoder, TH-VAE. We assess the generated summaries via automatic evaluation against expert summaries and via human evaluation with clinical experts, showing that timeline summarisation by TH-VAE results in more factual and logically coherent summaries rich in clinical utility and superior to LLM-only approaches in capturing changes over time.	[ -0.1872820407152176, -0.6026200652122498, 0.7583218812942505, 0.40299192070961, -0.3684523403644562, 0.346729040145874, 0.1746225357055664, -0.5846196413040161, 1.0839197635650635, 0.18706460297107697, -0.8407537341117859, -0.667039155960083, -0.6308854818344116, -0.01182627584785223, -0.2739749848842621, 1.0396802425384521, -0.09629058837890625, -0.08387397229671478, -0.07518278807401657, -0.24136826395988464, -0.3040802776813507, -0.5108991265296936, -0.510321319103241, -0.25161343812942505, 0.7343337535858154, 0.10410176217556, 0.6811809539794922, 0.6884874105453491, 0.464516818523407, 0.09121113270521164, -0.16484762728214264, 0.614429771900177, -0.5940643548965454, 0.11939675360918045, -0.1211056187748909, -0.3611149787902832, -1.066346526145935, -0.20537538826465607, 0.3875911235809326, 0.6768165230751038, -0.21812711656093597, 0.4391275644302368, 0.0978802740573883, 0.567345380783081, -0.670332670211792, 0.06536425650119781, -0.1662464737892151, 0.32128989696502686, -0.07522138953208923, -0.7338997721672058, -0.011097762733697891, -0.5063641667366028, -0.2906656265258789, -0.5868697762489319, 0.13143803179264069, -0.5197840332984924, 0.6028169989585876, 0.29582878947257996, -0.5613337755203247, -0.00038195494562387466, -0.9812707901000977, 0.25029218196868896, -0.821987509727478, -0.16212564706802368, 0.42806440591812134, 0.6649488806724548, 0.06987473368644714, -0.917577862739563, -0.3520132005214691, 0.19104601442813873, -0.17908211052417755, 0.36173608899116516, -0.34239789843559265, -0.06995610892772675, 0.08010632544755936, 0.4579262435436249, -0.44635358452796936, 0.2894253730773926, -0.3966241776943207, -0.2831260859966278, 0.7708795666694641, 0.8403405547142029, 0.25131043791770935, -0.37285009026527405, -0.06834600120782852, 0.38722601532936096, -0.4842437207698822, -0.17270785570144653, -0.019303826615214348, -0.3143475651741028, -0.47724074125289917, 0.7187082767486572, 0.08108925819396973, 0.15534283220767975, 0.14483928680419922, -0.676828145980835, 0.050188034772872925, -0.49732843041419983, 0.07413989305496216, -0.07803227007389069, 0.995652437210083, 1.0882282257080078, 0.1272989958524704, -0.12492212653160095, 0.19533954560756683, 0.36228758096694946, 0.12878012657165527, -0.7698993682861328, -0.1359870731830597, 0.4054720997810364, -0.7071038484573364, -0.3745734691619873, -0.06719192862510681, -0.7245233654975891, -0.47456642985343933, -0.26310092210769653, -0.1103055477142334, -0.4585815668106079, -0.21255184710025787, -0.14049352705478668, -0.14527897536754608, 0.15517650544643402, 0.47420498728752136, -0.8015349507331848, 0.3788124918937683, 0.5647943615913391, 1.0186357498168945, -0.1361316591501236, -0.24420149624347687, -0.4744143784046173, 0.5817716121673584, -0.47161638736724854, 0.7566234469413757, 0.01787159964442253, -0.632936954498291, 0.12207160890102386, -0.025155019015073776, 0.27411526441574097, -0.48957908153533936, 0.10323365032672882, -0.2196130007505417, 0.15011096000671387, -0.3020969033241272, -0.4023030996322632, 0.10081546008586884, -0.018512312322854996, -0.43597322702407837, 1.163854718208313, 0.4061531126499176, -0.8850960731506348, 0.4754972755908966, -0.22640280425548553, -0.7481222152709961, 0.1610313355922699, -0.5644707679748535, -0.21817421913146973, 0.06128591671586037, 0.5356706380844116, 0.6483691930770874, -0.09221099317073822, 0.4453338086605072, -0.29933080077171326, -0.32496097683906555, 0.13255555927753448, -0.1963009536266327, 0.6651608943939209, 0.09571360051631927, -0.14292243123054504, 0.21300019323825836, -0.6644470691680908, -0.4149059057235718, 0.2077358067035675, -0.02756570093333721, -0.24169224500656128, 0.1540779024362564, 0.24864578247070312, 0.35838863253593445, 0.27655455470085144, -0.09208798408508301, -0.11475624144077301, -0.21411001682281494, 0.623639702796936, 0.5781649351119995, 0.7199341058731079, 0.05808015540242195, -0.8277231454849243, 0.67132169008255, -0.04184473305940628, 0.31338468194007874, -0.4069921672344208, -0.42478176951408386, -0.1367027908563614, -0.519199550151825, -0.3080229163169861, 0.6038496494293213, -0.5009260773658752, 0.7767760753631592, -0.3687615692615509, -0.5036369562149048, -0.6261520981788635, 0.0933610051870346, 0.07064805179834366, 0.6129624247550964, 0.32232606410980225, -0.4531269669532776, -0.6742191314697266, -0.9237219095230103, -0.1123916357755661, -0.4937443733215332, -0.3505721390247345, 0.1835651695728302, 0.4907338619232178, -0.6056510806083679, 0.8509072065353394, -0.4327261745929718, -0.2780773639678955, -0.24835282564163208, 0.36094579100608826, -0.006939161103218794, -0.08728764206171036, 0.6604741811752319, -0.421537846326828, -0.315231591463089, -0.1359749734401703, -1.2615838050842285, -0.24108931422233582, -0.2693621516227722, -0.019898341968655586, -0.07869305461645126, 0.3775283694267273, -0.5655915141105652, 0.5782299041748047, 0.019009778276085854, -0.09506805986166, 0.5522779226303101, -0.2837521731853485, 0.2530352771282196, -1.4082823991775513, -0.05586732551455498, 0.07869783043861389, -0.7030816078186035, -0.27765193581581116, -0.3039742708206177, -0.1163608580827713, 0.057191699743270874, -0.46717825531959534, 0.33677980303764343, -0.24622851610183716, -0.0019352242816239595, -0.24724295735359192, 0.126258984208107, -0.18000344932079315, 0.3349667489528656, -0.22202686965465546, 0.46121615171432495, 0.25263217091560364, -0.34719714522361755, 0.255277544260025, 0.18762284517288208, 0.12691614031791687, 0.7356956601142883, -0.5412723422050476, -0.08264229446649551, -0.3023757338523865, 0.42152735590934753, -1.0685124397277832, -0.6472154259681702, 0.06373906135559082, -0.5771892666816711, -0.007870842702686787, 0.3893849849700928, -0.7120916843414307, -0.48477473855018616, -0.7588222622871399, 0.3071570098400116, 0.6244105696678162, -0.2126322239637375, 0.6694254875183105, 0.6980901956558228, -0.47242504358291626, -0.022353990003466606, -0.8687829971313477, 0.28459516167640686, -0.38980257511138916, -0.5022634267807007, 0.6915233135223389, 0.16308559477329254, -0.34541016817092896, 0.2816133499145508, -0.09261952340602875, 0.14174912869930267, -0.18334925174713135, 0.32411491870880127, 0.3501415252685547, -0.23987607657909393, -0.26457953453063965, 0.43648087978363037, -0.06444960087537766, 0.3326336443424225, 0.1260596364736557, 0.2777877151966095, -0.06108785420656204, -0.24140046536922455, -0.8294867873191833, 0.8604353070259094, 0.6679300665855408, 0.2142958790063858, 0.567760169506073, 0.7178109288215637, -0.9863511919975281, 0.21242399513721466, -0.46573349833488464, 0.027190588414669037, -0.3165517747402191, 0.16852952539920807, 0.1716073751449585, -0.8755106925964355, 0.7879760265350342, 0.17508921027183533, 0.1449987292289734, 0.7052401304244995, 1.146403193473816, -0.4849521219730377, 1.0823568105697632, 0.5733503699302673, -0.39666852355003357, 0.3372615575790405, -0.28155025839805603, -0.01207802351564169, -0.6179994940757751, -0.3727072477340698, 0.19742938876152039, -0.17215539515018463, -0.6577466130256653, -0.31146717071533203, 0.7964692711830139, 0.012326882220804691, 0.008849005214869976, -0.00009377366950502619, -0.25972235202789307, 0.10913846641778946, 0.04117809236049652, 0.4692865014076233, 0.4879085421562195, -0.07703868299722672, 0.3094116449356079, -0.5336674451828003, -0.5962840914726257, -0.6842007040977478, 0.7758762240409851, 0.4079191982746124, 0.624750018119812, 0.16957306861877441, 0.6675907373428345, 0.6568926572799683, 0.5332597494125366, -0.6979553699493408, 0.4889909625053406, 0.08423458784818649, -0.416490375995636, -0.04660562053322792, -0.21000456809997559, -0.7547854781150818, 0.12088697403669357, -0.17439934611320496, -0.9978174567222595, 0.08988139033317566, 0.07931648194789886, -0.7581110000610352, 0.15083439648151398, -0.260556697845459, 0.25658392906188965, -0.15602022409439087, -0.16049440205097198, -0.4453279376029968, -1.0174157619476318, 0.4907486140727997, -0.046451009809970856, 0.22435112297534943, -0.17620506882667542, -0.4312755763530731, 0.9292125701904297, -0.6352055668830872, 1.0038975477218628, 0.25027593970298767, 0.1741742044687271, 0.16980378329753876, 0.08836772292852402, -0.04288528114557266, 0.4536023736000061, 0.4651927947998047, 0.08764158934354782, 0.12116733193397522, -0.6188035607337952, -0.7679164409637451, 0.5440324544906616, -0.7834348678588867, -0.4692273437976837, -0.5239915251731873, -0.6398879885673523, -0.2696116864681244, 0.02975415624678135, 0.44982922077178955, 0.5368303656578064, -0.5238548517227173, -0.2613227367401123, 0.26093822717666626, -0.05312417820096016, 0.3938283920288086, 0.4128798544406891, -0.19963735342025757, -0.7011668682098389, 0.37832507491111755, 0.1103818267583847, 0.010041927918791771, 0.596778929233551, 0.21196810901165009, -0.0641881600022316, -0.24997073411941528, -0.08610053360462189, 0.7698637247085571, -0.821137547492981, 0.002550196833908558, -0.7869365811347961, -0.426132470369339, -0.598491907119751, -0.5785185098648071, -0.1870999038219452, -0.32808902859687805, -0.33875560760498047, -0.39791586995124817, 0.46699297428131104, 0.838384747505188, -0.37066736817359924, 0.32337522506713867, -0.6860879063606262, 0.7081865668296814, 0.11045985668897629, -0.13232073187828064, 0.04495053365826607, -0.1916235238313675, -0.13005422055721283, -0.2568187415599823, -0.4831656515598297, -1.3060998916625977, 0.5450406670570374, 0.03482577204704285, 0.4719694256782532, 0.5111311078071594, -0.25624582171440125, 0.8606317043304443, -0.3160758912563324, 0.9059850573539734, 0.5927414298057556, -0.49843528866767883, 0.8758249282836914, -0.7592499852180481, 0.4662635326385498, 0.6628285646438599, 0.7133029103279114, -0.5787230134010315, -0.6132221817970276, -0.5442873239517212, -1.1275310516357422, 0.27475857734680176, 0.2134253829717636, -0.1781730055809021, -0.148661807179451, 0.5250222682952881, 0.25313693284988403, 0.08752816915512085, -0.27929481863975525, -0.5363246202468872, -0.1012832447886467, -0.3420197665691376, -0.1811733841896057, -0.49508076906204224, -0.33684754371643066, -0.45253899693489075, 0.34559401869773865, 0.0023295802529901266, 0.37734803557395935, 0.3614572286605835, -0.12336954474449158, -0.27145200967788696, 0.011416054330766201, 0.19233913719654083, 1.042175054550171, -0.5006119012832642, 0.08380123972892761, 0.20824603736400604, -0.37751397490501404, 0.010708588175475597, 0.3088058531284332, 0.02280501276254654, 0.2536444664001465, 0.9466469883918762, 0.5256008505821228, 0.3426171541213989, -0.32593610882759094, 0.54105544090271, -0.18921217322349548, -0.22195552289485931, -0.4374496042728424, -0.14539951086044312, 0.18023918569087982, 0.2978426516056061, 0.335303395986557, -0.263793408870697, 0.41405972838401794, -0.6214762926101685, 0.2685213088989258, -0.243765726685524, -0.24838222563266754, -0.571648120880127, 0.9001848101615906, -0.12222949415445328, -0.4601787030696869, 0.11623630672693253, 0.15222644805908203, -0.047574084252119064, 0.5534090399742126, 0.6020635366439819, 1.0143681764602661, -0.15639860928058624, 0.32141169905662537, 0.23192037642002106, 0.19025564193725586, 0.1323556900024414, 0.41674309968948364, -0.2579112946987152, -0.11825762689113617, -0.45502009987831116, -0.2020340859889984, -0.4730129539966583, 0.24474631249904633, -1.180209755897522, 0.14073485136032104, -0.40423583984375, -0.45763805508613586, 0.3483272194862366, -0.2289598137140274, -0.566231906414032, 0.1172863245010376, 0.16725042462348938, 0.7232085466384888, -0.9560233354568481, 0.3364561200141907, 0.71470046043396, -0.40960001945495605, -0.4130783975124359, 0.18191871047019958, 0.42549461126327515, -0.6518847346305847, 0.030975401401519775, -0.01588759385049343, -0.25363436341285706, -0.29259252548217773, -0.13920021057128906, -0.3696461617946625, 1.4702683687210083, 0.29985886812210083, -0.412177711725235, -0.49991679191589355, 0.09110935777425766, 1.041339635848999, -0.4099922478199005, 0.3485017716884613, 0.6086776256561279, -0.007879535667598248, 0.08063644915819168, -0.748090922832489, 0.08580867201089859, -0.4703787565231323, 0.18845124542713165, 0.12468281388282776, -0.5712270140647888, 0.24915491044521332, -0.3775032162666321, -0.4326234757900238, -0.08658218383789062, 0.8449459075927734, 0.38219335675239563, 0.5922149419784546, 0.12282583862543106, 0.37472549080848694, 0.7929589152336121, 0.3185345530509949, 1.4135078191757202, -0.2795104682445526, 0.04950762167572975, 1.2116152048110962, -0.1249416247010231, 0.5739173889160156, 0.48151513934135437, -0.42048612236976624, 0.3851783871650696, 0.9933630228042603, 0.4094623029232025, 0.5473769903182983, -0.2677832543849945, -0.3072471022605896, -0.05489848181605339, -0.18475094437599182, -0.5552363991737366, -0.010032657533884048, 0.5205422639846802, -0.3146713674068451, -0.5236690044403076, -0.14457111060619354, 0.2839200496673584, 0.06344377249479294, -0.3338159918785095, 0.8326444029808044, 0.6887533068656921, -0.4128597378730774, 0.4433109164237976, -0.11273575574159622, 0.40374571084976196, -0.48376503586769104, 0.181818887591362, -0.29022127389907837, 0.04309424012899399, -0.24196134507656097, -0.7514273524284363, 0.656274676322937, 0.2605297565460205, -0.24255861341953278, -0.18950209021568298, 0.5480776429176331, -0.18884772062301636, -0.5897178649902344, 0.5310961008071899, 0.7222079634666443, -0.03806866705417633, 0.2826206684112549, -0.40000224113464355, -0.3990027904510498, -0.5823837518692017, -0.05984874814748764, 0.1686229109764099, 0.49494630098342896, -0.3613276481628418, 0.4451202154159546, 0.34762266278266907, 0.4423298239707947, -0.162148579955101, 0.35033440589904785, 0.8189146518707275, -0.8908900618553162, -0.9704249501228333, -1.1632705926895142, 0.3203728497028351, -0.04450942575931549, -0.5013200640678406, 0.772599995136261, 0.48425939679145813, 0.3721413016319275, 0.30182117223739624, 0.8465288281440735, 0.12022910267114639, 0.4778498709201813, -0.282370924949646, 0.587807297706604, -0.6828498840332031, 0.1220037043094635, -0.05929222330451012, -0.3732318580150604, -0.285299152135849, 0.08024372905492783, -0.17387834191322327, -0.23317205905914307, 0.7079160809516907, 0.5942036509513855, 0.12724925577640533, -0.028863437473773956, 0.037845928221940994, 0.2982720732688904, 0.21378681063652039, 0.8155326843261719, 0.8743786811828613, -0.1700596958398819, -0.05065295845270157, -0.3055590093135834, -0.6221247315406799, -0.406022310256958, -0.7739872932434082, -1.1319104433059692, -0.5222233533859253, -0.31003352999687195, -0.4564254879951477, 0.2511337101459503, 0.8433398008346558, 0.4954838454723358, -0.5037757158279419, -0.12100280821323395, 0.31274718046188354, -0.15446166694164276, -0.34709933400154114, -0.24413402378559113, 0.4439150094985962, 0.2603659927845001, -0.09467204660177231, 0.08233344554901123, 0.7142066359519958, -0.04820123687386513, -0.36658525466918945, 0.08675488829612732, 0.06977425515651703, -0.03977377340197563, 0.8747087121009827, 0.19588857889175415, -0.7268279790878296, 0.22199909389019012, 0.01805100031197071, -0.4751359522342682, 0.30618157982826233, 1.0290135145187378, -0.5566330552101135, 0.3265440762042999, 0.48108696937561035, 0.4589777886867523, 0.9559990763664246, 0.0918179303407669, 0.6172349452972412, -0.45092934370040894, -0.0489351823925972, 0.5104200839996338, 0.42714276909828186, 0.23952534794807434, -0.7309711575508118, 0.31667423248291016, 0.3186228275299072, -0.17093335092067719, -0.6852946877479553, 0.03945130482316017, -1.2631924152374268, -0.16879642009735107, 1.1593945026397705, 0.017150428146123886, -0.3226219117641449, -0.12175492942333221, -0.03468523174524307, 0.5607260465621948, -0.1901172548532486, 1.0346919298171997, 0.47970765829086304, -0.3763505518436432, 0.1391664743423462, -0.6740960478782654, 0.23693661391735077, 0.07032892853021622, -1.0737369060516357, -0.4843473732471466, 0.5448817610740662, 0.28720352053642273, -0.2776251435279846, 1.2714651823043823, -0.5144937634468079, 0.6512658596038818, -0.057159874588251114, -0.3641006350517273, -0.10152878612279892, -0.19074967503547668, -0.25537824630737305, 0.09010966122150421, -0.31425005197525024, 0.05103774741292 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16209v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16209v1	MultiMUC: Multilingual Template Filling on MUC-4	2024-01-29T15:02:24	2024-01-29T15:02:24	William Gantt, Shabnam Behzad, Hannah YoungEun An, Yunmo Chen, Aaron Steven White, Benjamin Van Durme, Mahsa Yarmohammadi	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	We introduce MultiMUC, the first multilingual parallel corpus for template filling, comprising translations of the classic MUC-4 template filling benchmark into five languages: Arabic, Chinese, Farsi, Korean, and Russian. We obtain automatic translations from a strong multilingual machine translation system and manually project the original English annotations into each target language. For all languages, we also provide human translations for sentences in the dev and test splits that contain annotated template arguments. Finally, we present baselines on MultiMUC both with state-of-the-art template filling models and with ChatGPT.	[ -0.8547255992889404, -0.19235816597938538, 0.5215580463409424, 0.3123495876789093, -0.19142600893974304, 0.38068485260009766, -0.2173868715763092, -0.373468279838562, 0.16717937588691711, 0.21971730887889862, -0.47563037276268005, -0.5765331983566284, -0.4994319677352905, 0.5744578242301941, -0.0222481582313776, 1.1627682447433472, -0.4939117431640625, 0.30071428418159485, -0.2910337746143341, -0.6237927675247192, -0.4044675827026367, -0.7925832271575928, -0.30786895751953125, 0.0792664960026741, 0.7923156023025513, 0.8192338347434998, 0.5626692771911621, 0.5680608749389648, 0.4190305173397064, 0.2711455225944519, 0.2891491949558258, 0.28259971737861633, -0.20417846739292145, -0.19760216772556305, 0.19406606256961823, -0.477349191904068, -0.518047034740448, 0.19408859312534332, 0.6736844778060913, 0.8106915354728699, -0.24797797203063965, 0.17113958299160004, 0.09008518606424332, 0.366775244474411, -0.9064090847969055, 0.21438023447990417, -0.37836429476737976, 0.06207926198840141, -0.8397727012634277, -0.0771627128124237, -0.35259658098220825, -0.12359202653169632, -0.3419461250305176, -0.5448189377784729, 0.1998736560344696, -0.021062450483441353, 0.502435028553009, -0.05449317768216133, -0.8372255563735962, -0.21204286813735962, -0.38797804713249207, 0.864486575126648, -0.365698903799057, 0.6169848442077637, 0.6057000756263733, 0.49360042810440063, 0.004714543931186199, -0.9399117231369019, -0.49564698338508606, 0.04942925646901131, -0.07603881508111954, 0.4861251711845398, 0.23505020141601562, -0.07388737797737122, 0.22722351551055908, 0.5874416828155518, -0.6859708428382874, -0.14360250532627106, -0.8165476322174072, -0.24140386283397675, 0.43220263719558716, 0.21261908113956451, 0.3518010377883911, 0.10637020319700241, -0.3539413809776306, -0.022653069347143173, -0.6478524804115295, -0.10274896770715714, 0.5459314584732056, -0.07842232286930084, -0.4838762581348419, 0.5187088847160339, 0.07682926207780838, 0.8029677271842957, -0.32395467162132263, -0.22847622632980347, 0.5201536417007446, -0.6959479451179504, -0.1262015551328659, 0.008029544726014137, 0.7406660318374634, 0.40869835019111633, 0.09351582080125809, 0.10175222158432007, -0.027126314118504524, -0.07135232537984848, 0.3459134101867676, -0.5217087268829346, -0.32163771986961365, 0.21614927053451538, -0.32624953985214233, -0.013771645724773407, 0.17604564130306244, -0.6313998103141785, -0.2011469304561615, -0.09923365712165833, -0.3934718072414398, -0.48085442185401917, -0.21526414155960083, 0.1942230463027954, 0.08502882719039917, 0.07749263197183609, 0.12821727991104126, -1.0375065803527832, 0.2573398947715759, 0.4896770417690277, 0.9704078435897827, -0.24684655666351318, -0.8857154846191406, -0.5388913750648499, 0.35440942645072937, -0.45895978808403015, 1.1109490394592285, -0.34534817934036255, -0.19298286736011505, 0.19036142528057098, 0.03182901442050934, 0.0014285924844443798, -0.3224639594554901, 0.6619479060173035, -0.13271529972553253, 0.41046151518821716, -0.1645634025335312, -0.30982786417007446, -0.32534417510032654, 0.45426732301712036, -0.9114927053451538, 1.1757469177246094, 0.25860360264778137, -0.8914307355880737, 0.0756588950753212, -0.6368610858917236, -0.4368680715560913, 0.005957994610071182, -0.28793102502822876, -0.2529882788658142, -0.09288893640041351, 0.5135568976402283, 0.43187806010246277, -0.4873589873313904, 0.07158922404050827, -0.3120885491371155, -0.12622204422950745, 0.11534277349710464, -0.2809862792491913, 0.7081505656242371, 0.6899354457855225, 0.01581937074661255, 0.18488283455371857, -0.46609097719192505, -0.0882304459810257, -0.1070156842470169, -0.4694426655769348, 0.08340654522180557, -0.43123435974121094, 0.36656153202056885, 0.5820074081420898, 0.11484446376562119, -0.5297063589096069, 0.39459648728370667, -0.11996456235647202, 0.3015936017036438, 0.4785667955875397, -0.3542062044143677, 0.341126948595047, -0.4486023783683777, 0.7820376753807068, 0.5499735474586487, -0.051161862909793854, -0.6774001717567444, -0.8398439884185791, -0.5629074573516846, -0.6848316192626953, 0.44113197922706604, 0.5123823881149292, -0.7673510313034058, -0.01741882413625717, -0.02918129973113537, -0.6095868349075317, -0.7755016684532166, 0.1086319088935852, 0.18892094492912292, -0.01014382392168045, 0.4597703516483307, -0.11557596176862717, -0.6915788054466248, -1.1176576614379883, -0.07019370049238205, 0.1596154272556305, 0.13814912736415863, 0.07980481535196304, 0.2576408088207245, 0.05700680986046791, 0.19621388614177704, -0.3684254586696625, -0.3960103690624237, -0.5508724451065063, 0.16692522168159485, 0.1852746158838272, 0.5611894726753235, 0.839013934135437, -0.6376323699951172, -0.874456524848938, 0.18394139409065247, -0.5950783491134644, -0.13679081201553345, -0.16623100638389587, -0.1696513295173645, 0.21227051317691803, 0.7848908305168152, -0.4334188997745514, 0.350273072719574, 1.1882126331329346, 0.044475007802248, 0.5299369692802429, -0.3660602569580078, 0.5399782657623291, -1.4635449647903442, 0.12892310321331024, -0.47664856910705566, -0.39971843361854553, -0.5421528220176697, -0.04918232560157776, 0.5752838253974915, -0.22010532021522522, -0.8644711971282959, 0.5601320266723633, -0.8155518770217896, 0.08701906353235245, -0.04974902421236038, 0.040177326649427414, 0.10141362249851227, 0.41235238313674927, -0.40708237886428833, 0.8374161720275879, 0.5224823951721191, -0.5184125900268555, 0.3946787416934967, 0.13661670684814453, -0.3080264925956726, 0.5425946712493896, -0.014097088947892189, 0.34032076597213745, -0.09374716877937317, 0.5250681042671204, -0.9090703129768372, -0.07499666512012482, 0.1693434864282608, -0.2889063060283661, 0.11555102467536926, -0.17946505546569824, -0.6550659537315369, -0.3421817421913147, -0.2857077419757843, 0.8160913586616516, -0.04435497522354126, -0.4181881546974182, 0.4180395007133484, 0.31111568212509155, -0.09504486620426178, -0.6069018244743347, -0.769521176815033, 0.22763530910015106, -0.08822202682495117, -0.48830851912498474, 0.4583911597728729, -0.37828299403190613, 0.1391771137714386, -0.40473097562789917, 0.38470202684402466, -0.10141396522521973, -0.046563275158405304, 0.05244800075888634, 0.2507690489292145, -0.4035569429397583, -0.15975233912467957, 0.06109863892197609, -0.19973954558372498, -0.4173020124435425, -0.4727191925048828, 0.8463538885116577, -0.21744564175605774, -0.5987246036529541, -0.3708609640598297, 0.8881345391273499, 0.6852215528488159, -0.6864017248153687, 0.6803121566772461, 0.6658618450164795, -0.5400930643081665, 0.609067440032959, -0.9655041694641113, 0.1336200088262558, -0.3754154145717621, 0.30483514070510864, -1.1085214614868164, -0.5624355673789978, 0.6440235376358032, 0.06370401382446289, 0.31143835186958313, 0.47370201349258423, 0.9796591997146606, 0.13070574402809143, 1.1932018995285034, 0.5042588114738464, -0.061838943511247635, 0.23462697863578796, -0.12545707821846008, -0.1080547496676445, -0.5092200636863708, -0.0013768422650173306, -0.528670608997345, -0.5020514130592346, -0.7293975353240967, -0.6918454766273499, 0.16675087809562683, 0.16188126802444458, -0.09432259202003479, 0.3287930190563202, -0.18836697936058044, 0.624858558177948, 0.510434627532959, -0.549652636051178, 0.42794448137283325, -0.1469038426876068, -1.0029796361923218, -0.27886638045310974, -0.6162924766540527, -0.4558565318584442, 1.2363425493240356, 0.17312771081924438, 0.34771326184272766, 0.4229891300201416, 0.6536197662353516, -0.31416887044906616, 0.5278379917144775, -0.2713158428668976, 0.06135611608624458, -0.2954307198524475, -0.810457706451416, 0.3864230215549469, -0.1342947781085968, -0.9694452881813049, 0.3116168975830078, -0.061954159289598465, -0.6787033677101135, -0.15274657309055328, -0.08081430941820145, -0.3049178421497345, 0.5796061754226685, -0.7091002464294434, 1.069061279296875, -0.35841289162635803, 0.017954925075173378, -0.31184300780296326, -0.4746026396751404, 0.4590551257133484, -0.13493026793003082, 0.14278936386108398, -0.3161093294620514, -0.19095037877559662, 0.42321470379829407, 0.04929224029183388, 0.27377790212631226, 0.047041065990924835, 0.18264321982860565, -0.003420766443014145, 0.12225097417831421, 0.2617892324924469, 0.34093084931373596, -0.07263617217540741, 0.37317657470703125, 0.24881376326084137, -0.8252577781677246, -0.4735233187675476, 0.6586962938308716, -0.7636793851852417, -0.49953508377075195, -0.7057587504386902, -0.6688111424446106, -0.09751108288764954, 0.40883180499076843, 0.3335261344909668, -0.0039319610223174095, -0.32729223370552063, 0.2418726682662964, -0.03601599112153053, -0.3270932734012604, 0.298828661441803, 0.5627297163009644, -0.5203461647033691, -0.8044611215591431, 0.6468679904937744, -0.04792487621307373, 0.08148819953203201, 0.2397461235523224, 0.10089743882417679, -0.2104124277830124, -0.4422571361064911, -1.0904935598373413, 0.36600613594055176, -0.6588137149810791, -0.2546827793121338, -1.0133497714996338, -0.1828835904598236, -0.6245201230049133, -0.31731876730918884, -0.6981287598609924, -0.27007773518562317, -0.0029186236206442118, -0.12355989962816238, -0.0301927849650383, 0.7479127049446106, -0.25914058089256287, 0.20818054676055908, -1.067899465560913, 0.4080946147441864, -0.3459855318069458, 0.24545547366142273, -0.4854273796081543, -0.07049176096916199, -0.5696409344673157, 0.021139802411198616, -0.7239082455635071, -0.9997175335884094, 0.3065881133079529, -0.009657256305217743, 0.6671292781829834, 0.45284825563430786, -0.23451924324035645, 0.8328235149383545, -0.7529966831207275, 0.7880973815917969, 0.5881896615028381, -0.7262428998947144, 0.13042500615119934, -0.26418399810791016, 0.7287766337394714, 0.4790363907814026, 0.5599101185798645, -1.2233707904815674, -0.6479639410972595, -0.4917807877063751, -0.5531104207038879, 0.7463590502738953, 0.18525828421115875, -0.10585583001375198, -0.19179368019104004, -0.004183316603302956, 0.3476629853248596, 0.11518640071153641, -0.3789139986038208, -0.3825383186340332, -0.5716263651847839, -0.4150071442127228, -0.3269006311893463, -0.2646288573741913, -0.13465897738933563, -0.16164131462574005, 0.3643341660499573, -0.278340220451355, 0.2408321052789688, -0.14037692546844482, -0.1377446949481964, 0.03597993776202202, 0.30260905623435974, 1.1314030885696411, 0.6751745343208313, 0.041401125490665436, 0.2943781614303589, 0.47768881916999817, -0.5082197785377502, 0.11819539219141006, 0.2953272759914398, 0.1968545913696289, -0.04954501986503601, 0.05240581929683685, 0.6893647313117981, 0.2399837225675583, -0.4219871461391449, 0.354000985622406, -0.3349733054637909, -0.08212336152791977, -0.5156149864196777, -0.486758828163147, 0.535913348197937, -0.07692631334066391, 0.1617456078529358, -0.0928172767162323, -0.02561604604125023, -0.32310086488723755, 0.3088398575782776, 0.06573419272899628, -0.37331703305244446, -0.41159912943840027, 0.6968370079994202, 0.20438408851623535, 0.1343027651309967, 0.7335278391838074, -0.16725674271583557, -0.5224828720092773, 0.2305699586868286, 0.6104360818862915, 0.5727764964103699, -0.3980393707752228, -0.14352601766586304, 0.6020207405090332, 0.3091682195663452, 0.08380680531263351, 0.4614199697971344, 0.153807133436203, -0.6246140003204346, -0.37517988681793213, -0.24668534100055695, -0.3088238835334778, 0.2543875277042389, -0.497978150844574, 0.7144366502761841, -0.23316651582717896, -0.13457506895065308, 0.07130575180053711, 0.01805880479514599, -1.063518762588501, -0.11614561080932617, 0.5094261169433594, 0.901908814907074, -0.41643816232681274, 1.2605482339859009, 1.1398162841796875, -0.5757486820220947, -0.6946592926979065, -0.3070235550403595, 0.35207226872444153, -0.5672426223754883, 0.36122551560401917, 0.46087735891342163, 0.10551169514656067, 0.03485266491770744, 0.004095456097275019, -0.8424286842346191, 1.0036696195602417, 0.5017456412315369, -0.18590211868286133, 0.09300055354833603, 0.3917304575443268, 0.0735226422548294, -0.5516319274902344, 0.626244068145752, 0.550104022026062, 0.6330646872520447, -0.40457233786582947, -1.0243043899536133, -0.2714305520057678, -0.3260508179664612, -0.24323870241641998, 0.13340264558792114, -0.5958707332611084, 1.1236050128936768, -0.129343181848526, -0.359112411737442, 0.12250189483165741, 0.839230477809906, 0.4119589626789093, 0.0730009451508522, 0.5473750829696655, 0.5566976070404053, 0.7953217029571533, 0.11895882338285446, 1.1325078010559082, -0.648149311542511, 0.17677506804466248, 1.1988298892974854, -0.31482937932014465, 0.5286940932273865, 0.4827198088169098, -0.1818663477897644, 0.3411322236061096, 0.7937057614326477, 0.13736936450004578, 0.20746870338916779, 0.1266186386346817, -0.31773191690444946, 0.069924496114254, -0.22116334736347198, -0.501886785030365, 0.5806000232696533, 0.2885493338108063, 0.015008747577667236, -0.2032405585050583, 0.13459375500679016, 0.2943017780780792, -0.06638354063034058, 0.15663331747055054, 0.6114837527275085, 0.08695583045482635, -1.0492908954620361, 0.6650259494781494, 0.5025604367256165, 0.5768716335296631, -0.6190049648284912, 0.06037550047039986, -0.5161790251731873, 0.27330508828163147, -0.09291447699069977, -0.7874196767807007, 0.46438679099082947, -0.031680867075920105, 0.02067984826862812, -0.2818807363510132, 0.22084492444992065, -0.7623524069786072, -0.5971640348434448, 0.4012579619884491, 0.804806649684906, 0.4180474579334259, -0.16570539772510529, -0.6768634915351868, -0.1143413856625557, 0.09656083583831787, -0.045621782541275024, 0.3296273648738861, 0.49490830302238464, -0.13940514624118805, 0.4773958623409271, 0.8062378168106079, 0.09189479053020477, 0.3548496961593628, 0.17134007811546326, 0.6782562732696533, -0.7218509912490845, -0.638952374458313, -0.6937047243118286, 0.5162523984909058, 0.06000090762972832, -0.4860910177230835, 0.5276868343353271, 1.1162738800048828, 1.1086715459823608, -0.2826915383338928, 0.791019082069397, 0.0667468011379242, 0.38107535243034363, -0.45817309617996216, 1.0167068243026733, -0.747461199760437, -0.37506040930747986, 0.02644219435751438, -0.9693033695220947, -0.4042342007160187, 0.26179832220077515, 0.2139129787683487, -0.14479762315750122, 1.3461483716964722, 0.699327290058136, -0.4231162965297699, -0.02946132980287075, 0.8482836484909058, -0.23205877840518951, 0.5127988457679749, 0.7318490147590637, 0.8729755878448486, -0.41446825861930847, 1.0411134958267212, -0.6058597564697266, -0.010776692070066929, 0.06827244907617569, -0.7397794127464294, -0.9051382541656494, -0.8198795318603516, -0.07089044153690338, -0.2733590304851532, -0.37852367758750916, 0.9211534857749939, 0.6420723795890808, -1.1251895427703857, -0.530478835105896, 0.4294690191745758, 0.005842259619385004, -0.4703593850135803, -0.11023295670747757, 0.2178158015012741, -0.4392049014568329, -1.201037883758545, 0.5096767544746399, 0.36611419916152954, 0.10380135476589203, -0.44972944259643555, -0.1791880577802658, -0.7682495713233948, -0.24580852687358856, 0.24285945296287537, 0.1400221288204193, -0.8524457216262817, 0.024583173915743828, 0.10404365509748459, -0.5494565367698669, 0.5426577925682068, 1.4137039184570312, -0.47566697001457214, 0.6154068112373352, 0.3326321542263031, 0.6378657221794128, 0.6001592874526978, -0.3666682839393616, 0.9360477328300476, -0.9051609635353088, 0.6749645471572876, -0.015896400436758995, 0.7732470035552979, 0.5409237742424011, -0.038872793316841125, 0.581890881061554, 0.22393646836280823, -0.2433408498764038, -0.629163920879364, 0.23351223766803741, -0.7647752165794373, -0.005711066536605358, 0.877177357673645, -0.4325498044490814, 0.04889991879463196, -0.6062776446342468, -0.33890801668167114, 0.5545594692230225, -0.18047042191028595, 0.4018394947052002, 1.1534672975540161, 0.2939583361148834, -0.37241286039352417, -1.1411689519882202, 0.41522711515426636, 0.4665760099887848, -0.9018267393112183, -0.06809423863887787, 0.3459893763065338, 0.0007958545465953648, 0.15537166595458984, 0.9559462666511536, -0.3145664632320404, 0.42632922530174255, 0.08145616203546524, 0.4483858048915863, -0.037483926862478256, -0.301483154296875, -0.004953241907060146, -0.030796311795711517, -0.03174135088920593, -0.24730701744556427 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16184v5	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16184v5	Realizing Disentanglement in LM Latent Space via Vocabulary-Defined Semantics	2024-01-29T14:29:48	2024-05-26T13:12:35	Jian Gu, Aldeida Aleti, Chunyang Chen, Hongyu Zhang	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.LG	Understanding the latent space of language models (LMs) is important for improving the performance and interpretability of LMs. Existing analyses often fail to provide insights that take advantage of the semantic properties of language models and often overlook crucial aspects of language model adaptation. In response, we introduce a pioneering approach called vocabulary-defined semantics, which establishes a reference frame grounded in LM vocabulary within the LM latent space. We propose a novel technique to compute disentangled logits and gradients in latent space, not entangled ones on vocabulary. Further, we perform semantical clustering on data representations as a novel way of LM adaptation. Through extensive experiments across diverse text understanding datasets, our approach outperforms state-of-the-art methods of retrieval-augmented generation and parameter-efficient finetuning, showcasing its effectiveness and efficiency.	[ -0.14663155376911163, -0.7168715596199036, 0.5357455611228943, -0.08289866149425507, -0.38680076599121094, 0.36940181255340576, -0.15572574734687805, -0.03660101816058159, 0.21948976814746857, 0.23813551664352417, -0.559466540813446, -0.5703790187835693, -0.698519766330719, -0.30742600560188293, -0.5424850583076477, 1.0969429016113281, -0.08391150087118149, -0.09050186723470688, -0.3166334629058838, -0.18593677878379822, -0.3274839222431183, -0.35116544365882874, -0.2574591636657715, -0.329714298248291, 0.7603875398635864, -0.0456327423453331, 0.68748539686203, 0.5273904204368591, 0.6355788707733154, 0.23602378368377686, -0.35259056091308594, 0.17340825498104095, -0.5714304447174072, -0.338041752576828, -0.38378140330314636, -0.7440829873085022, -0.3877754509449005, -0.0013712226646021008, 1.034414291381836, 1.2162926197052002, -0.2589605748653412, -0.16892988979816437, 0.2833322286605835, 0.8835335969924927, -0.7115340828895569, 0.05913688614964485, -1.0628619194030762, 0.13609793782234192, -0.1682821810245514, -0.08798737823963165, -0.3961782455444336, 0.1078115850687027, 0.1950545758008957, -0.7353973388671875, 0.42781394720077515, -0.17938891053199768, 0.8231348991394043, 0.5093029141426086, -0.36387863755226135, -0.3579012155532837, -0.7052822709083557, 0.8128236532211304, -0.4799160063266754, 0.5674566626548767, 0.4178215265274048, 0.2113732248544693, -0.3739146888256073, -0.791370689868927, -0.6983398199081421, 0.197478786110878, -0.3115415871143341, 0.040892429649829865, -0.248109832406044, -0.006822776515036821, -0.12589162588119507, 0.4885247051715851, -0.5625927448272705, 0.22895044088363647, -0.18246135115623474, -0.0125828105956316, 0.4510708749294281, 0.09544654935598373, 0.1367761641740799, -0.1288823038339615, -0.46896642446517944, 0.02297431044280529, -0.5794162750244141, -0.21212156116962433, -0.013965125195682049, 0.27569130063056946, -0.07250302284955978, 0.3029239773750305, 0.23195147514343262, 0.7658906579017639, 0.09538859874010086, 0.07858210802078247, 0.2830156683921814, -0.17234529554843903, -0.05524403229355812, 0.025751778855919838, 0.4459546208381653, 0.3121139705181122, -0.3034653067588806, -0.5309732556343079, -0.1814250499010086, 0.2945743203163147, 0.15533852577209473, -0.5748682022094727, -0.23582300543785095, 0.13061538338661194, -0.36715200543403625, -0.16171985864639282, 0.025445688515901566, -0.5720106363296509, -0.43992048501968384, -0.21848902106285095, 0.5673330426216125, -0.21472221612930298, -0.48457834124565125, 0.37764182686805725, -0.21772123873233795, 0.12655425071716309, 0.166034996509552, -1.1324098110198975, 0.6067278981208801, 0.7678375840187073, 0.9842562675476074, -0.4487418532371521, -0.2363075464963913, -0.32151469588279724, 0.1591651439666748, -0.6782325506210327, 0.2924084961414337, -0.40884530544281006, -0.14431671798229218, -0.20944957435131073, -0.014687588438391685, -0.10325965285301208, -0.5694531202316284, -0.05802812799811363, -0.9415130019187927, 0.1482163816690445, 0.1977011114358902, -0.7877972722053528, -0.17102615535259247, 0.1498556137084961, -0.6770003437995911, 0.8885613679885864, 0.08852797746658325, -0.7624791860580444, 0.3522040843963623, -0.5760619640350342, -0.044595230370759964, -0.09812821447849274, -0.21277356147766113, -0.1360640972852707, 0.40423065423965454, -0.02562003768980503, 0.5554930567741394, 0.032319553196430206, 0.3592839241027832, -0.17408281564712524, -0.17882004380226135, 0.4460356831550598, -0.31272023916244507, 0.5385395288467407, 0.2613457441329956, 0.048510584980249405, -0.13904382288455963, -0.8144317865371704, -0.15484210848808289, 0.08638937026262283, -0.17716485261917114, -0.8766757249832153, 0.30559438467025757, -0.21384017169475555, -0.012556019239127636, 0.37011390924453735, -0.384698748588562, -0.0420442596077919, -0.8631710410118103, 0.42634159326553345, 0.5750179290771484, -0.21101997792720795, 0.8637021780014038, 0.02847365476191044, -0.028227470815181732, 0.4513590931892395, -0.3534032702445984, 0.06134387478232384, 0.03709053620696068, -0.8095051050186157, -0.13757959008216858, 0.43655672669410706, 0.33124205470085144, -0.7955791354179382, 0.7273898124694824, -0.2231651097536087, -0.4853815734386444, -0.28696924448013306, 0.07083841413259506, 0.19299395382404327, 0.4982554018497467, 0.3629961609840393, -0.34666648507118225, -0.19702701270580292, -0.5661149621009827, -0.19499674439430237, -0.0550738126039505, -0.13472019135951996, 0.09433785080909729, 0.39113128185272217, -0.3066152334213257, 1.1311912536621094, -0.6917467713356018, -0.1903146356344223, 0.06591085344552994, 0.00906048808246851, 0.35751622915267944, 0.5346606373786926, 0.4439367949962616, -1.0968108177185059, -0.2271781712770462, -0.0392635315656662, -0.7752472758293152, 0.13225017488002777, -0.16987262666225433, -0.3427153527736664, -0.11850018799304962, 0.8404604196548462, -0.31399479508399963, 0.4822334051132202, 0.7215771675109863, -0.5867368578910828, 0.11533250659704208, -0.3533181846141815, -0.35611146688461304, -1.184359073638916, 0.0021983098704367876, -0.14307701587677002, -0.37813636660575867, -0.7587520480155945, 0.07113945484161377, 0.001399892964400351, 0.05623335763812065, -0.17531350255012512, 0.5744166970252991, -0.5165796875953674, 0.02217078022658825, -0.357901394367218, 0.582368016242981, 0.16577035188674927, 0.33952805399894714, 0.21086253225803375, 0.31419453024864197, 0.6546846032142639, -0.9088529348373413, 0.11351461708545685, 0.29888343811035156, -0.2110772728919983, 0.2233184278011322, -0.5455710291862488, 0.055430155247449875, -0.4812123477458954, 0.13090236485004425, -1.159180998802185, 0.11030159890651703, 0.17784373462200165, -0.3680383265018463, 0.4239308536052704, -0.13213419914245605, -0.19155006110668182, 0.03188256174325943, -0.09811898320913315, 0.47629985213279724, 0.5118056535720825, -0.6481172442436218, 0.5428358316421509, 0.6138444542884827, 0.15238942205905914, -0.6473894715309143, -0.7976733446121216, -0.12926137447357178, -0.501541018486023, -0.26735347509384155, 0.7737994194030762, -0.054101478308439255, -0.41312581300735474, 0.2887273132801056, -0.2732940912246704, -0.28650784492492676, 0.4600151479244232, 0.0331193283200264, 0.20846624672412872, -0.1811654418706894, 0.5997684597969055, 0.20768405497074127, -0.27521657943725586, -0.07074293494224548, -0.5342872142791748, 0.3982846736907959, -0.09503045678138733, -0.4134107530117035, 0.0023016203194856644, 0.0977507084608078, 0.14574363827705383, -0.2157244086265564, 0.9447787404060364, 0.7391049861907959, -0.6778689622879028, -0.3991211950778961, -0.04294421523809433, -0.29725542664527893, -0.48483946919441223, 0.6315106749534607, -0.3335847556591034, -1.3495638370513916, 0.5913151502609253, -0.40110838413238525, 0.046442147344350815, 0.39089691638946533, 0.6015962362289429, -0.11132996529340744, 0.5414121747016907, 1.0194274187088013, 0.12379101663827896, 0.5188735127449036, -0.04267825558781624, 0.3991624414920807, -0.7477482557296753, -0.027810566127300262, -0.30249372124671936, -0.3163963258266449, -0.7896530032157898, -0.8692188262939453, 0.322802871465683, 0.657608687877655, 0.18321780860424042, 0.0823795422911644, -0.35703960061073303, 0.5454921722412109, -0.10343903303146362, 0.11360727995634079, 0.23955461382865906, 0.0800703689455986, -0.2056117206811905, -0.25607892870903015, -0.7993428707122803, -0.5118558406829834, 0.8470674157142639, 0.576850175857544, 0.7801400423049927, 0.6107050180435181, 0.8232818841934204, 0.1823045015335083, -0.10677549242973328, -0.8025631308555603, 0.26258689165115356, -0.47765859961509705, -0.479696124792099, -0.4294855296611786, -0.38092389702796936, -1.2270504236221313, 0.4966781437397003, -0.16014444828033447, -1.1031239032745361, 0.1375979632139206, 0.040512602776288986, -0.160479336977005, 0.043653883039951324, -0.6490052342414856, 0.7567533850669861, 0.13261890411376953, -0.43524229526519775, -0.38748249411582947, -0.5118905305862427, 0.20545251667499542, -0.3564939498901367, 0.3819311559200287, -0.25449514389038086, -0.3501477539539337, 0.9026234745979309, -0.3621898591518402, 0.957005500793457, -0.29926902055740356, -0.133614644408226, 0.3390224277973175, 0.2510830760002136, 0.11624382436275482, 0.13891854882240295, 0.19390004873275757, 0.1907285451889038, 0.2966938018798828, -0.36837437748908997, -0.9283333420753479, 0.7704194784164429, -0.5719059705734253, -0.39411771297454834, -0.16844141483306885, -0.5717658996582031, -0.40448614954948425, 0.1226794496178627, -0.18757264316082, 0.32282865047454834, -0.3888930380344391, -0.011151167564094067, 0.976734459400177, -0.13966141641139984, 0.5445111393928528, 0.5607953667640686, -0.5149036645889282, 0.2053510695695877, 1.0191586017608643, -0.11043970286846161, 0.15133212506771088, 0.7032018303871155, 0.31825751066207886, -0.5257546901702881, -0.4855858087539673, -0.16899120807647705, 0.27024197578430176, -0.7966000437736511, 0.17383447289466858, -0.39162635803222656, -0.20932340621948242, 0.05174132436513901, -0.035720836371183395, -0.5212517380714417, -0.48411527276039124, -0.6147707104682922, -0.08297277987003326, 0.41813525557518005, 0.8254205584526062, -0.2744653522968292, 0.4315720796585083, -0.9116625785827637, 0.15142370760440826, 0.1056608259677887, 0.4675056040287018, 0.18305498361587524, -0.6705454587936401, -0.4172004759311676, -0.16147278249263763, 0.06358097493648529, -0.8653247952461243, 0.14966405928134918, 0.4192293882369995, 0.6795945763587952, 0.16970154643058777, -0.07207600027322769, 0.5733156800270081, -0.7154064178466797, 0.7660065293312073, 0.29869407415390015, -1.113473653793335, 0.440815269947052, -0.21848079562187195, 0.12346044182777405, 0.2067330777645111, 0.5770136117935181, -0.6503696441650391, -0.12132822722196579, -0.6786908507347107, -0.8832026720046997, 0.4372473657131195, 0.07210719585418701, 0.4122205078601837, 0.06411648541688919, 0.586096465587616, 0.2088162899017334, 0.14434294402599335, -0.6366797089576721, -0.2511366307735443, 0.06872980296611786, -0.5082687735557556, -0.4352846145629883, -0.2658570408821106, -0.17874440550804138, -0.18917648494243622, 0.37742769718170166, -0.36793655157089233, 0.29087033867836, 0.01679489016532898, -0.4573768973350525, 0.26726117730140686, 0.09427939355373383, 0.2250392884016037, 0.8395625352859497, 0.06096683442592621, 0.5429446697235107, 0.18151897192001343, -0.4950014352798462, 0.14666259288787842, 0.10721258074045181, 0.19879767298698425, 0.26972565054893494, 0.4008924663066864, 0.695983350276947, 0.18925130367279053, -0.4012937545776367, 0.47620922327041626, -0.12584039568901062, -0.06514161825180054, -0.04891598969697952, 0.08368901908397675, 0.3922109305858612, 0.18111439049243927, 0.2573339343070984, -0.2443627119064331, -0.03346912935376167, -0.13460120558738708, 0.6223276853561401, 0.3324054777622223, -0.5884721875190735, -0.2843455970287323, 0.396193265914917, 0.026268290355801582, 0.11411191523075104, 0.2846694886684418, -0.2234095185995102, -0.11827783286571503, 0.2383381873369217, 0.5607762932777405, 0.5863403081893921, -0.065408855676651, 0.1474296599626541, 0.315313458442688, 0.11478853970766068, 0.21547533571720123, 0.04576025903224945, -0.0899006649851799, -1.2631115913391113, -0.42308780550956726, -0.8417343497276306, 0.13023807108402252, 0.11712567508220673, -0.786687433719635, -0.018901215866208076, -0.5889584422111511, 0.01292955782264471, 0.19067950546741486, -0.2841731309890747, -0.33147820830345154, 0.12640617787837982, 0.17878161370754242, 0.9020986557006836, -0.896592378616333, 0.6717619299888611, 0.649569034576416, -0.11968239396810532, -0.7268911004066467, 0.08705945312976837, -0.054853394627571106, -0.8201046586036682, 0.6134656071662903, -0.20746152102947235, -0.1386299431324005, 0.2955441474914551, -0.407517671585083, -0.9380094408988953, 1.0306332111358643, 0.16229656338691711, -0.7345440983772278, 0.20455436408519745, 0.04386547952890396, 0.5537611842155457, -0.26007080078125, -0.006500147748738527, 0.6669034957885742, -0.05972488224506378, -0.04522935301065445, -0.7714923620223999, -0.15149463713169098, 0.03768552094697952, 0.2184782475233078, 0.3471316397190094, -0.3706265389919281, 0.8256494402885437, 0.09284196048974991, -0.3014032542705536, -0.21160845458507538, 0.853255033493042, -0.021196722984313965, 0.20277145504951477, 0.4740525782108307, 0.569658637046814, 1.0724780559539795, -0.050557367503643036, 0.3978446125984192, -0.2234015166759491, 0.6666116118431091, 1.0573087930679321, -0.054863158613443375, 1.0331931114196777, 0.8385998010635376, -0.22976304590702057, 0.6581697463989258, 0.5562883019447327, 0.4747263193130493, 0.7762712240219116, 0.4472091794013977, -0.4107700288295746, -0.15252234041690826, -0.07611118257045746, -0.18305262923240662, 0.7067309617996216, 0.8806363344192505, -0.3454703986644745, -0.6417508721351624, -0.023465165868401527, -0.07713886350393295, 0.4642503261566162, -0.3452700972557068, 0.9987632632255554, 0.18136081099510193, -0.14726971089839935, 0.7652526497840881, 0.1969611942768097, 0.6541174650192261, -0.6493966579437256, -0.09509187191724777, -0.06981070339679718, 0.387229323387146, -0.3030339479446411, -0.7371155619621277, 0.5761421322822571, -0.06263259798288345, -0.31774237751960754, -0.048089537769556046, 0.8844925761222839, -0.650050938129425, -0.3774070143699646, 0.2815065085887909, 0.74311763048172, 0.41628408432006836, 0.2900107502937317, -0.7473545074462891, 0.11934888362884521, -0.17762555181980133, 0.07020542025566101, 0.521273672580719, 0.6398512721061707, -0.048563409596681595, 0.2804891765117645, 0.38198867440223694, -0.1145908311009407, 0.03985857591032982, 0.029992299154400826, 0.9278410077095032, -0.6212195754051208, -0.6312498450279236, -1.0815848112106323, 0.604766845703125, 0.24230577051639557, -0.14041487872600555, 0.541251003742218, 0.2987506687641144, 0.9450405240058899, 0.05686900392174721, 0.675625741481781, -0.19003283977508545, 0.45389243960380554, -0.9784073233604431, 0.8270692229270935, -0.786798357963562, 0.2535080909729004, -0.14691853523254395, -0.649161696434021, -0.36378034949302673, 0.8930567502975464, -0.29423895478248596, -0.09884631633758545, 0.7377229332923889, 0.9708782434463501, -0.24742290377616882, -0.43472886085510254, 0.39598336815834045, 0.12630872428417206, 0.2995724678039551, 0.6488081812858582, 0.9415984749794006, -0.4470432996749878, 0.0540105476975441, 0.12721721827983856, -0.5322006940841675, 0.05495811253786087, -1.0796318054199219, -0.9380679130554199, -0.9316117167472839, -0.3188927471637726, -0.1905880719423294, -0.10132580250501633, 0.5465930104255676, 0.6160008311271667, -0.5799248218536377, -0.18514277040958405, -0.3746868371963501, 0.368007093667984, 0.04803701490163803, -0.20052634179592133, 0.4606953263282776, -0.44438618421554565, -0.5859998464584351, 0.32427939772605896, 0.21143576502799988, -0.03383979573845863, -0.4354190230369568, -0.24784840643405914, -0.27780863642692566, -0.144894078373909, 0.5132232308387756, -0.13519154489040375, -0.6704668402671814, -0.15057280659675598, -0.31712156534194946, -0.16524724662303925, -0.04693738371133804, 0.6329262852668762, -0.6821873188018799, 0.5025409460067749, 0.32335296273231506, 0.9166157245635986, 0.3898788094520569, -0.22554118931293488, 0.33245906233787537, -1.0342085361480713, 0.6000721454620361, 0.27884793281555176, 0.0409020371735096, 0.262577623128891, -0.3309348225593567, 0.23312649130821228, 0.3076707124710083, -0.1749437004327774, -0.7262946367263794, 0.39030319452285767, -0.7692134976387024, -0.5668313503265381, 0.8820933103561401, -0.29419827461242676, -0.5530970096588135, 0.019194941967725754, 0.2240053117275238, 0.27210497856140137, 0.1065877377986908, 0.524658203125, 0.8325258493423462, 0.00020063309057150036, -0.01421357598155737, -0.16327404975891113, 0.6464977860450745, 0.5478254556655884, -0.48338374495506287, 0.1718326061964035, 0.4261162281036377, 0.2088576853275299, 0.2515353858470917, 0.602592408657074, -0.1497209370136261, 0.00875059887766838, 0.2654689848423004, -0.22246743738651276, 0.28481748700141907, -0.27032920718193054, -0.6781314015388489, -0.23392179608345032, 0.5348531603813171, -0.4146423637866974 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16182v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16182v1	LLaMandement: Large Language Models for Summarization of French Legislative Proposals	2024-01-29T14:23:51	2024-01-29T14:23:51	Joseph Gesnouin, Yannis Tannier, Christophe Gomes Da Silva, Hatim Tapory, Camille Brier, Hugo Simon, Raphael Rozenberg, Hermann Woehrel, Mehdi El Yakaabi, Thomas Binder, Guillaume Marie, Emilie Caron, Mathile Nogueira, Thomas Fontas, Laure Puydebois, Marie Theophile, Stephane Morandi, Mael Petit, David Creissac, Pauline Ennouchy, Elise Valetoux, Celine Visade, Severine Balloux, Emmanuel Cortes, Pierre-Etienne Devineau, Ulrich Tan, Esther Mac Namara, Su Yang	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	This report introduces LLaMandement, a state-of-the-art Large Language Model, fine-tuned by the French government and designed to enhance the efficiency and efficacy of processing parliamentary sessions (including the production of bench memoranda and documents required for interministerial meetings) by generating neutral summaries of legislative proposals. Addressing the administrative challenges of manually processing a growing volume of legislative amendments, LLaMandement stands as a significant legal technological milestone, providing a solution that exceeds the scalability of traditional human efforts while matching the robustness of a specialized legal drafter. We release all our fine-tuned models and training data to the community.	[ -0.4509875774383545, -0.6074113249778748, 0.6255771517753601, 0.2556286156177521, -0.6152268648147583, -0.22922192513942719, -0.2577720582485199, -0.21067266166210175, 0.6801992654800415, 1.1075328588485718, -0.33816272020339966, -0.46920329332351685, -0.7737312912940979, 0.07114095985889435, -0.7489830255508423, 0.7611512541770935, -0.09767162054777145, 0.06573590636253357, 0.19445419311523438, -0.1630091518163681, -0.22504304349422455, -0.47834375500679016, -0.43193331360816956, -0.556080162525177, 0.712744951248169, 0.435352087020874, 0.35246509313583374, 0.6661872863769531, 0.6687747240066528, 0.41920992732048035, -0.12058068811893463, 0.035535380244255066, -0.5699337720870972, 0.15285368263721466, -0.4265133738517761, -0.5743829607963562, -0.8365265727043152, -0.22758255898952484, 0.7154707908630371, 0.5091419816017151, -0.3076113164424896, -0.04444236308336258, -0.0633758157491684, 0.8309539556503296, -0.7596763372421265, 0.3325650095939636, -0.4194910526275635, -0.36764946579933167, -0.4421239197254181, -0.4620930552482605, -0.0685286596417427, -0.48948755860328674, -0.04146680235862732, 0.013729033060371876, 0.08685862272977829, -0.3514764904975891, 0.50882887840271, 0.1624254435300827, -0.4457370340824127, -0.18689383566379547, -0.5448607206344604, 0.4305668771266937, -1.0234848260879517, 0.30364784598350525, 0.3515867590904236, 0.41528788208961487, -0.34998106956481934, -1.0153286457061768, -0.46120843291282654, -0.18699145317077637, 0.15420711040496826, 0.00045561318984255195, -0.26521244645118713, 0.3722449243068695, 0.3122493326663971, 0.47935566306114197, -0.6581950187683105, 0.44141408801078796, -0.5605543851852417, -0.19165140390396118, 0.983143150806427, 0.09633038192987442, 0.3496117889881134, -0.0016398716252297163, 0.3439144194126129, 0.3391733169555664, -0.6390946507453918, -0.3914685547351837, 0.5975977778434753, 0.2576024532318115, -0.32500162720680237, 1.1759620904922485, -0.6060112118721008, 0.7123301029205322, -0.1923646330833435, -0.10899122059345245, -0.14076438546180725, -0.24839866161346436, -0.2343204915523529, 0.22596971690654755, 0.6696060299873352, 0.6434419751167297, 0.4004066288471222, 0.026146957650780678, -0.5170829892158508, -0.08545852452516556, -0.1816527396440506, -1.1716043949127197, -0.41315725445747375, 0.40940114855766296, -0.2621195912361145, -0.267960786819458, -0.20306496322155, -0.5073779225349426, -0.5313600301742554, -0.5890514254570007, -0.14056679606437683, -0.20508989691734314, -0.22213037312030792, 0.24254071712493896, -0.2253495305776596, 0.15205857157707214, 0.759194552898407, -1.087506651878357, -0.04011840745806694, 0.7771437168121338, 0.827818751335144, -0.02283313497900963, -0.08879497647285461, -0.5191197991371155, 0.2535161077976227, -0.177656352519989, 1.1413501501083374, -0.5674943327903748, -0.8754131197929382, 0.021708166226744652, 0.24343636631965637, 0.2896732687950134, -0.431664377450943, 0.42407774925231934, -0.22730089724063873, -0.09500860422849655, -0.12417138367891312, -0.71537184715271, -0.18067315220832825, 0.18405859172344208, -0.746825635433197, 0.15379242599010468, 0.2734496593475342, -0.6442916393280029, 0.5318100452423096, -0.5978625416755676, -0.19647620618343353, 0.265129417181015, -0.28214725852012634, -0.34693482518196106, 0.25323399901390076, 0.22523458302021027, 0.4335499703884125, -0.5752235651016235, 0.5514370203018188, -0.2421277016401291, -0.04058007523417473, 0.015665829181671143, -0.15878333151340485, 0.9430302977561951, 0.10320029407739639, -0.01833050511777401, 0.5005596280097961, -0.6336555480957031, -0.4474295973777771, -0.024287236854434013, -0.49307119846343994, -0.13489215075969696, 0.06417813152074814, 0.12276416271924973, -0.05858124420046806, 0.3556254506111145, -0.511121928691864, 0.35353100299835205, -0.8806589245796204, 0.644263744354248, 0.7136061191558838, 0.31732678413391113, 0.5401145815849304, -0.38308659195899963, 0.49455371499061584, -0.26814815402030945, -0.10094289481639862, -0.3951571583747864, -0.4960074722766876, -0.5200712084770203, -0.4643016755580902, 0.6885082125663757, 0.6009147763252258, -0.2661236822605133, 0.3523116111755371, -0.44345322251319885, -0.41874751448631287, -0.07998998463153839, 0.08314190059900284, -0.01640290394425392, 0.0868755653500557, -0.2550809383392334, -0.48131993412971497, -0.6445178985595703, -1.223624348640442, -0.20346613228321075, -0.009720263071358204, 0.16310390830039978, 0.019421283155679703, 0.8208773136138916, -0.4066907465457916, 0.597616970539093, -0.23681221902370453, 0.0006136847077868879, -0.38347214460372925, 0.3472541868686676, 0.26318836212158203, 0.3590439558029175, 0.7044317126274109, -0.5307638049125671, -0.38257142901420593, 0.2744833827018738, -0.7103956341743469, -0.19420669972896576, 0.2378288060426712, -0.02636498585343361, 0.15405195951461792, 0.7130382657051086, -0.48981088399887085, 0.542885422706604, 0.26669880747795105, -0.1200355738401413, 0.5685136914253235, -0.14275600016117096, 0.082648366689682, -1.251545786857605, -0.13222871720790863, -0.271339476108551, -0.40918633341789246, -0.4827550947666168, 0.2900196611881256, 0.0658191666007042, -0.21444551646709442, -0.628645122051239, 0.8111816048622131, -0.37134233117103577, 0.2023485004901886, -0.45328396558761597, 0.42965322732925415, -0.23747014999389648, 0.09275023639202118, -0.20848868787288666, 0.7759837508201599, 0.5034225583076477, -0.627228856086731, 0.7239381670951843, 0.24196313321590424, -0.32003840804100037, 0.7260400652885437, -0.6465582847595215, -0.257861852645874, -0.365405410528183, 0.34375593066215515, -0.8319938778877258, -0.8778190612792969, 0.05054912343621254, -0.24160784482955933, 0.36519917845726013, -0.2301582545042038, -0.3107703924179077, -0.385453462600708, -0.2779851257801056, 0.3504558503627777, 0.24666011333465576, -0.05468583106994629, 0.5631273984909058, 0.7901049256324768, -0.6897547245025635, -0.39501821994781494, -1.0518946647644043, 0.44571471214294434, -0.03734031692147255, -0.5291275978088379, 0.07340211421251297, 0.18632368743419647, -0.6455197930335999, -0.0792212262749672, 0.13182777166366577, -0.11780545860528946, -0.18625588715076447, 0.17077496647834778, -0.1137545257806778, -0.1423856019973755, -0.03211696445941925, 0.20308217406272888, -0.1783197522163391, -0.020069368183612823, -0.2710535526275635, 0.6230012774467468, 0.41298040747642517, -0.6060410141944885, -0.5834715962409973, 0.4716379642486572, 0.7757118344306946, -0.3919380307197571, 0.5042123794555664, 0.17325831949710846, -0.23825466632843018, -0.2309310883283615, -0.7317587733268738, -0.19234679639339447, -0.44745180010795593, 0.378772109746933, -0.39363473653793335, -0.9940511584281921, 0.4912557601928711, -0.3759523034095764, 0.4545966684818268, 0.3827322721481323, 0.866327702999115, 0.24387645721435547, 0.9451029896736145, 0.7467933893203735, -0.13365599513053894, 0.37508124113082886, -0.3252250552177429, 0.3624342978000641, -0.4980449080467224, -0.14874467253684998, -0.6082006096839905, -0.1928856074810028, -0.888659656047821, -0.3495597243309021, 0.08827314525842667, 0.021267300471663475, -0.04674937203526497, 0.20850525796413422, -0.48603489995002747, 0.530256450176239, 0.5040770769119263, -0.0691850408911705, 0.27092546224594116, 0.016469744965434074, 0.13313986361026764, 0.07284945994615555, -0.28779011964797974, -0.6834557056427002, 1.1940057277679443, -0.002607811475172639, 0.7672175168991089, 0.3561193645000458, 1.0689938068389893, 0.3242291510105133, 0.21213853359222412, -0.9547432065010071, 0.6702855229377747, -0.15746305882930756, -0.33661818504333496, -0.3845483660697937, -0.2515018880367279, -0.9516322612762451, 0.08546880632638931, 0.06761929392814636, -0.9419150948524475, 0.36178794503211975, -0.05021897703409195, -0.26488810777664185, 0.41070228815078735, -0.45128917694091797, 0.5306286215782166, 0.01049822848290205, -0.227575421333313, -0.6021057367324829, -0.08072998374700546, 0.8670194745063782, -0.2866485118865967, -0.08998923748731613, -0.45264554023742676, -0.06809478998184204, 0.6842025518417358, -0.6132450103759766, 0.5473276376724243, -0.061118513345718384, -0.46949878334999084, 0.15563969314098358, 0.36218783259391785, 0.6916689872741699, 0.2667900621891022, -0.2567647099494934, -0.16972967982292175, -0.03686894103884697, -0.40568459033966064, -0.44079867005348206, 0.7992570400238037, -0.5051050186157227, -0.8537763357162476, -0.30289310216903687, -0.7962517738342285, 0.20736418664455414, 0.3302280902862549, 0.33598604798316956, 0.5887682437896729, -0.46683984994888306, 0.1116529032588005, 0.49895864725112915, -0.2922792136669159, 0.6241853833198547, 0.6080470681190491, -0.5080801248550415, -0.39449915289878845, 0.9006627798080444, 0.38212019205093384, -0.2038145661354065, 0.40755167603492737, -0.21437017619609833, -0.5101141333580017, -0.7735193967819214, -0.08839057385921478, 0.618461012840271, -0.6195113658905029, 0.010825865902006626, -0.7365596890449524, -0.4674130082130432, -0.37364616990089417, -0.39099302887916565, -0.23189446330070496, -0.9148334860801697, -0.06810403615236282, -0.06953088939189911, 0.28795698285102844, 0.9130803346633911, -0.234388068318367, 0.37332040071487427, -0.63861083984375, 0.513748049736023, 0.6415344476699829, 0.2254684865474701, -0.4460630416870117, -0.5873120427131653, -0.0901726484298706, 0.13389503955841064, -0.379849374294281, -0.6022124886512756, 0.3760112524032593, 0.10249659419059753, 0.5195810198783875, 0.41954222321510315, 0.047524720430374146, 0.40009555220603943, -0.6093575358390808, 0.8402402997016907, 0.3407684564590454, -0.6782587170600891, 0.9100602865219116, -0.7113736867904663, 0.5803890228271484, 0.21918611228466034, -0.00026728605735115707, -0.2642688453197479, -0.6724220514297485, -0.3609631061553955, -0.9945368766784668, 0.7035295367240906, 0.26305118203163147, 0.2632344961166382, 0.10216959565877914, 0.19631850719451904, -0.07135380804538727, 0.20456463098526, -0.4110459089279175, 0.1825249046087265, 0.24378930032253265, 0.12992700934410095, -0.24958838522434235, -0.667959988117218, -0.45935797691345215, -0.25870367884635925, 0.5678072571754456, 0.1978805512189865, 0.20458856225013733, 0.039088379591703415, -0.2547362148761749, -0.1344369798898697, 0.5499155521392822, 1.2592545747756958, 1.3922078609466553, -0.23959892988204956, 0.021324867382645607, 0.12826856970787048, -0.41608068346977234, 0.42691561579704285, 0.1569228321313858, 0.003335567656904459, 0.26669323444366455, 0.5693169236183167, 0.7064480781555176, -0.0508364737033844, -0.6086506247520447, 0.5798401832580566, -0.09455888718366623, -0.7145858407020569, -0.32716163992881775, 0.05054861679673195, 0.15961854159832, 0.47856006026268005, 0.041075028479099274, -0.06276632100343704, 0.23493987321853638, -0.5583782196044922, 0.4076181948184967, 0.28277280926704407, -0.22104355692863464, -0.1883610486984253, 0.7871289849281311, 0.2845792770385742, -0.5172723531723022, 0.1746777594089508, -0.1254129856824875, -0.018596993759274483, 0.5036436319351196, 0.1722661256790161, 1.113753318786621, -0.5010823607444763, 0.2501019239425659, 0.35289835929870605, 0.2487756609916687, -0.16947729885578156, 0.5006948113441467, -0.038739122450351715, -0.29333043098449707, -0.7194117903709412, -0.8248010873794556, -0.38055214285850525, 0.03840517997741699, -0.43482962250709534, 0.4432167708873749, -0.48505812883377075, -0.4424510896205902, 0.17664194107055664, -0.2964351177215576, -0.2974163293838501, -0.3194328248500824, 0.08479494601488113, 1.0557022094726562, -0.5240119099617004, 0.9784227609634399, 0.3994411826133728, -0.33466440439224243, -0.3827420473098755, -0.11384449154138565, 0.13596583902835846, -0.6234297752380371, 0.6849954128265381, -0.17808566987514496, -0.07356518507003784, -0.01698014698922634, -0.4138621389865875, -0.4964562952518463, 0.858516275882721, 0.8792437314987183, -1.1267656087875366, 0.030879413709044456, 0.32582545280456543, 0.21998131275177002, -0.06549732387065887, 0.1085297092795372, 0.7998771071434021, 0.6382681727409363, -0.13382379710674286, -1.1492565870285034, -0.23397809267044067, -0.16848409175872803, 0.1038706973195076, 0.3884848654270172, -0.5842533707618713, 0.8959746360778809, 0.17960207164287567, -0.07173497974872589, 0.0439392626285553, 0.5769326090812683, 0.09821728616952896, 0.010237756185233593, -0.021135171875357628, 0.6793106198310852, 0.786470890045166, -0.17447178065776825, 1.1494094133377075, -0.5814404487609863, 0.030541136860847473, 1.0395946502685547, -0.3853955566883087, 0.577498197555542, 0.4111999571323395, -0.1415434330701828, 0.2654355764389038, 0.5083587169647217, 0.22354519367218018, 0.40242817997932434, 0.35874542593955994, -0.4644177556037903, 0.09750634431838989, -0.4160725474357605, -0.4599204957485199, 0.5784173011779785, 0.4325701594352722, -0.23073643445968628, -0.6240549683570862, 0.10536722093820572, -0.08224786818027496, 0.20744414627552032, -0.5629941821098328, 0.9103104472160339, 0.36223316192626953, -0.5727801322937012, 0.7292764186859131, 0.16303765773773193, 0.23518536984920502, -0.5416212677955627, -0.10810881108045578, -0.37948378920555115, 0.17533324658870697, -0.23501890897750854, -0.8032957911491394, 0.22977443039417267, -0.015103382058441639, -0.10090762376785278, -0.10427548736333847, 0.34433963894844055, -0.33012357354164124, -0.6438109874725342, 0.3259637951850891, 0.4880894124507904, 0.15282581746578217, -0.028704717755317688, -0.6978139877319336, 0.0665186271071434, -0.03892578184604645, -0.28286755084991455, 0.13671919703483582, 0.7614237666130066, -0.21372416615486145, 0.7452738881111145, 0.24594923853874207, 0.5647597312927246, -0.05037063732743263, 0.5280734300613403, 1.0600097179412842, -0.5029261112213135, -0.5244882106781006, -1.0358631610870361, 0.6905683279037476, -0.22710727155208588, 0.01266950648277998, 0.6787315607070923, 0.7360119223594666, 0.4498416483402252, -0.05058282986283302, 0.9020701050758362, 0.051368847489356995, 0.31019827723503113, -0.4544949233531952, 0.668036162853241, -0.4829081594944, 0.33135563135147095, 0.013433584943413734, -1.3204057216644287, -0.5276151299476624, 0.2000405341386795, -0.44361406564712524, -0.2421664148569107, 0.5078522562980652, 1.215123176574707, -0.39746958017349243, -0.1757248342037201, 0.5367394685745239, 0.24740944802761078, 0.29991236329078674, 0.1688828468322754, 0.6992582082748413, -0.008152162656188011, 0.20733091235160828, -0.2071065753698349, -0.10728273540735245, -0.5211483836174011, -0.4859987497329712, -1.1455777883529663, -0.7359461784362793, -0.108242928981781, -0.05296272411942482, 0.2636212408542633, 0.8990930318832397, 0.5871149301528931, -1.2123116254806519, -0.7335640788078308, -0.4620803892612457, 0.003367186291143298, 0.4864170551300049, -0.17143802344799042, 0.24394577741622925, -0.3024810552597046, -0.8881548643112183, 0.2671452462673187, 0.7198336124420166, 0.12962305545806885, -0.39074811339378357, 0.005079805850982666, -0.297866553068161, 0.36794349551200867, 0.6784659624099731, 0.32113024592399597, -0.8842808604240417, 0.07820428162813187, -0.6678215861320496, -0.14091777801513672, -0.16671796143054962, 1.0162760019302368, -0.1368761658668518, 0.6496864557266235, 0.7721151113510132, 0.4267521798610687, 0.8319988250732422, -0.12769538164138794, 0.9188358187675476, -0.6414007544517517, 0.9531756043434143, 0.15129169821739197, 0.5923619866371155, 0.06527552008628845, -0.13789698481559753, 0.5908761024475098, -0.07025156170129776, -0.7132139205932617, -0.9875246286392212, 0.4331556558609009, -0.6889538764953613, -0.3222218155860901, 0.6915308237075806, 0.08697984367609024, -0.39153173565864563, -0.20431339740753174, -0.5268151164054871, 0.21692243218421936, -0.45909830927848816, 0.5732125043869019, 0.6523221731185913, 0.08725255727767944, -0.5786867737770081, -0.8228181004524231, 0.40944358706474304, -0.12118425965309143, -0.5202110409736633, 0.0021925654727965593, 0.6287296414375305, -0.1073770746588707, -0.13097494840621948, 0.9473606944084167, -0.11350259184837341, 0.336738258600235, 0.07963599264621735, 0.0780143141746521, 0.09668836742639542, -0.13098685443401337, -0.29578137397766113, 0.15108883380889893, 0.24070322513580322, 0.20473535358905792 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16167v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16167v2	"You tell me": A Dataset of GPT-4-Based Behaviour Change Support Conversations	2024-01-29T13:54:48	2024-04-03T09:02:52	Selina Meyer, David Elsweiler	cs.HC	cs.HC, cs.CL	Conversational agents are increasingly used to address emotional needs on top of information needs. One use case of increasing interest are counselling-style mental health and behaviour change interventions, with large language model (LLM)-based approaches becoming more popular. Research in this context so far has been largely system-focused, foregoing the aspect of user behaviour and the impact this can have on LLM-generated texts. To address this issue, we share a dataset containing text-based user interactions related to behaviour change with two GPT-4-based conversational agents collected in a preregistered user study. This dataset includes conversation data, user language analysis, perception measures, and user feedback for LLM-generated turns, and can offer valuable insights to inform the design of such systems based on real interactions.	[ -0.19879068434238434, -0.7444264888763428, 0.7477656602859497, 0.0674731507897377, 0.09972912073135376, 0.007458322681486607, -0.08877765387296677, -0.5728306770324707, 0.3175640404224396, 0.608037531375885, -0.8633975386619568, -0.33092859387397766, -0.32926225662231445, 0.2069215178489685, -0.3830289840698242, 1.1540226936340332, -0.020108725875616074, 0.17506082355976105, 0.01865237019956112, 0.14355586469173431, -0.9088322520256042, -0.8686127662658691, -0.7764649391174316, -0.6146178841590881, 0.7387704849243164, 0.33581650257110596, 0.727738082408905, -0.15632960200309753, 0.330013245344162, 0.25771987438201904, -0.022845512256026268, -0.10420777648687363, -0.5908616185188293, 0.44468438625335693, -0.3204719126224518, -0.5045719742774963, -0.4726021885871887, 0.3102336823940277, 0.1503588855266571, 0.1554396152496338, -0.41060298681259155, -0.15888413786888123, 0.051151715219020844, 0.3325318992137909, -0.1913035660982132, 0.44880619645118713, -0.4866051971912384, 0.17424267530441284, -0.18989026546478271, -0.12864729762077332, -0.44304147362709045, -0.21597468852996826, 0.08268945664167404, -0.48649466037750244, -0.03186234086751938, -0.2249591052532196, 0.5867069363594055, 0.08772192150354385, -0.6397668123245239, -0.49465855956077576, -1.1136887073516846, 0.5285875201225281, -0.9724084138870239, 0.2026430368423462, 0.6206241250038147, 0.274143248796463, -0.4516693651676178, -0.7878497242927551, -0.7911803126335144, 0.00005575552495429292, -0.40926724672317505, 0.1772526353597641, -0.2757047712802887, 0.11545209586620331, 0.25881606340408325, 0.08733201771974564, -0.5414881110191345, -0.2066122591495514, -0.28172966837882996, -0.35527560114860535, 0.6208308339118958, 0.407247930765152, 0.3565031588077545, 0.022025655955076218, 0.03677704930305481, -0.23564957082271576, -0.6801779866218567, 0.011572097428143024, 0.34321361780166626, 0.11430764943361282, -0.162156343460083, 0.6232733726501465, 0.0010521096410229802, 0.4837624132633209, 0.24116072058677673, -0.10949429869651794, 0.2201332002878189, -0.39819830656051636, -0.22823074460029602, -0.06606422364711761, 0.7863276600837708, 0.6487292647361755, 0.39646291732788086, -0.00772365927696228, -0.2638894021511078, 0.10309351235628128, 0.14486031234264374, -0.9337823987007141, -0.24654600024223328, 0.08088222146034241, -0.308768093585968, -0.26902633905410767, -0.05597572401165962, -0.6719046235084534, -0.6678969264030457, -0.4476688504219055, 0.11842304468154907, -0.44087737798690796, -0.4630771279335022, 0.1924908459186554, 0.10160510241985321, 0.5177854895591736, 0.34703558683395386, -1.0792330503463745, 0.4359554648399353, 0.5894705057144165, 0.7804834842681885, -0.06761530041694641, -0.21206705272197723, -0.31482550501823425, 0.2420351207256317, -0.37929511070251465, 0.6061016321182251, -0.7856571078300476, -0.7060007452964783, 0.18101729452610016, 0.06491336971521378, -0.21660441160202026, -0.4822373688220978, 0.47164076566696167, -0.42352262139320374, 0.5751062035560608, -0.616054117679596, -0.25775957107543945, 0.10113385319709778, 0.5065458416938782, -0.3789987862110138, 0.9019085168838501, 0.09661276638507843, -0.7314304709434509, 0.2387762814760208, -0.8873257637023926, -0.5049450993537903, 0.06915730237960815, -0.3839672803878784, -0.24421699345111847, -0.071165069937706, 0.08108170330524445, 0.3245169222354889, -0.1065831333398819, 0.24517619609832764, -0.08648446947336197, -0.29018715023994446, 0.816170334815979, -0.6184061765670776, 0.22311095893383026, 0.253965824842453, -0.21691793203353882, 0.20605707168579102, -0.45988011360168457, -0.07854519039392471, 0.10554330796003342, -0.44614267349243164, -0.14559747278690338, 0.023832308128476143, 0.11301279067993164, 0.39376088976860046, 0.48742595314979553, -0.523757815361023, 0.24925543367862701, -0.05978330969810486, 0.670324444770813, 0.7426996827125549, 0.18460054695606232, 0.05757027491927147, -0.32411667704582214, 0.6300137639045715, 0.23096923530101776, 0.05878906324505806, -0.21268242597579956, -0.6708654165267944, -0.22124460339546204, 0.015775343403220177, -0.1589159518480301, 0.3682876527309418, -0.9608128070831299, -0.09338316321372986, 0.12020740658044815, -0.0499974824488163, -0.24186831712722778, -0.031088661402463913, 0.37311410903930664, 0.4791099429130554, 0.30970197916030884, -0.13452155888080597, -0.3812459707260132, -0.725207507610321, -0.44204622507095337, -0.5985459089279175, -0.17610976099967957, 0.5084356665611267, 0.3422522246837616, -0.7035163640975952, 1.137254238128662, -0.6453384757041931, -0.1112128272652626, -0.4106614291667938, 0.336095929145813, -0.03949546441435814, 0.18621177971363068, 0.5009168982505798, -0.6719862818717957, -0.45761817693710327, -0.07433172315359116, -0.6544919610023499, -0.28486883640289307, -0.25507044792175293, -0.023356584832072258, 0.15876050293445587, 0.47456094622612, -0.5418052673339844, 0.4174931049346924, 0.546964168548584, -0.8804293274879456, 0.5050318241119385, -0.3936275839805603, 0.3600993752479553, -1.0243332386016846, -0.3819235861301422, 0.04991113021969795, -0.3562783896923065, -0.7959346771240234, -0.6638455986976624, -0.23396871984004974, -0.041942622512578964, -0.2838798463344574, 0.5995197892189026, -0.1991053968667984, -0.13453873991966248, 0.01241537556052208, -0.08672894537448883, -0.20686060190200806, 0.5719895958900452, -0.05588245764374733, 1.1232502460479736, 0.3123983144760132, -0.3496779203414917, 0.08559487015008926, 0.7471930980682373, 0.14350594580173492, 0.9846051931381226, -0.47744861245155334, 0.6050572395324707, 0.12743063271045685, 0.25618845224380493, -1.0043587684631348, -0.5982728004455566, 0.6534817814826965, -0.28937941789627075, 0.006333138328045607, 0.12779617309570312, -0.42672908306121826, -0.44530463218688965, -0.2087959200143814, 0.0014771866844967008, 0.17293189465999603, -0.42814669013023376, 0.6019245386123657, 0.4240134656429291, -0.5498433709144592, -0.10338432341814041, -0.8241056799888611, 0.565391480922699, -0.30426397919654846, -0.3646557331085205, 0.18872708082199097, -0.40065646171569824, -0.32907119393348694, -0.10574761033058167, 0.04155602306127548, -0.1671309918165207, -0.10761833935976028, 0.31334584951400757, 0.1213231310248375, -0.028785036876797676, 0.3739123046398163, -0.01922651194036007, -0.08737886697053909, 0.3477262556552887, -0.11369132250547409, 0.6522863507270813, -0.2524162232875824, -0.2806409001350403, -0.7293978333473206, 0.3878658413887024, 0.5587776899337769, -0.08389992266893387, 0.7263743281364441, 0.5073985457420349, -0.11772482842206955, 0.14415134489536285, -0.17109794914722443, -0.5238098502159119, -0.5423151254653931, 0.2610630691051483, -0.4728997051715851, -0.9730648994445801, 0.3503212630748749, 0.09155544638633728, -0.028451452031731606, -0.021805616095662117, 0.8307797908782959, -0.2821009159088135, 1.2347474098205566, 0.5135748982429504, -0.1077418401837349, 0.6971649527549744, 0.26429975032806396, 0.2395300567150116, -0.49519920349121094, -0.31037598848342896, -0.24523241817951202, -0.44605210423469543, -0.5476014614105225, -0.16004030406475067, 0.18891188502311707, -0.48554742336273193, -0.37301814556121826, 0.042797498404979706, -0.34108367562294006, 0.1972631812095642, 0.2244192361831665, 0.2682507634162903, 0.31847456097602844, -0.15787695348262787, 0.22993960976600647, -0.2968164384365082, -0.16901955008506775, -0.5981736779212952, 1.0946178436279297, 0.1460072547197342, 0.9653107523918152, 0.3509350121021271, 0.49006596207618713, 0.7572101354598999, 0.555375874042511, -0.704888641834259, 0.7215531468391418, 0.45826613903045654, -0.4591180682182312, -0.42789292335510254, -0.4823675751686096, -1.2255674600601196, 0.10809335112571716, -0.08080430328845978, -0.900086522102356, -0.14140240848064423, 0.14977408945560455, 0.0988495796918869, 0.009500675834715366, -0.7696272730827332, 0.6047646999359131, -0.351433128118515, -0.0941377505660057, -0.30010226368904114, -0.2653575539588928, 0.07673078030347824, -0.23040777444839478, 0.030769523233175278, -0.03331213444471359, 0.3209214508533478, 0.9777665734291077, -0.6967839598655701, 1.025988221168518, -0.38207197189331055, -0.2941604554653168, 0.3753935992717743, -0.007617672439664602, 0.6842933297157288, 0.07047484815120697, -0.0001064545358531177, -0.13321615755558014, 0.23027187585830688, -0.19326592981815338, -0.6656493544578552, 0.634223997592926, -0.9171909689903259, -0.6767337322235107, -0.46692538261413574, -0.6261739730834961, -0.5260880589485168, 0.1535821259021759, -0.12137686461210251, 0.44811004400253296, -0.43307316303253174, -0.1645008623600006, 0.43352362513542175, -0.09051499515771866, 0.39492741227149963, 0.9129927754402161, -0.4545489549636841, -0.018512271344661713, 0.6994034051895142, -0.004075055476278067, -0.024404475465416908, 0.019866809248924255, 0.3489598035812378, -0.4226206839084625, -0.24575187265872955, -0.17709507048130035, 0.4281074106693268, -0.5080744624137878, 0.11442927271127701, -0.3706420660018921, 0.015034154988825321, -0.42201611399650574, -0.1144411489367485, 0.041963960975408554, -0.11522723734378815, -0.17349600791931152, -0.43723630905151367, 0.6752306818962097, 1.2975586652755737, 0.015165877528488636, 0.8304213881492615, -0.40684640407562256, 0.15353608131408691, 0.4907732903957367, 0.2716098427772522, -0.33936065435409546, -0.1695510596036911, -0.3709058165550232, 0.18887585401535034, -0.4752919375896454, -1.2744114398956299, 0.6029528379440308, 0.05486404523253441, 0.29975464940071106, 0.317119836807251, -0.09682613611221313, 0.24702978134155273, -0.24215753376483917, 0.8945090770721436, 0.33515578508377075, -0.81414395570755, 0.3541003465652466, -0.6394248008728027, 0.16240635514259338, 0.23844949901103973, 0.01879609003663063, -0.9842818379402161, -0.13906820118427277, -0.5863073468208313, -0.5119104385375977, 0.8705623149871826, 0.4907965064048767, 0.12043106555938721, 0.11026113480329514, 0.6485377550125122, -0.15282855927944183, 0.41015318036079407, -0.6880709528923035, -0.2635270655155182, -0.17249585688114166, -0.49338090419769287, -0.06382451951503754, -0.2797600030899048, -0.16920576989650726, 0.10597468912601471, 0.5543107986450195, -0.28545886278152466, 0.4271939992904663, 0.12588784098625183, 0.08833193778991699, -0.0979226753115654, 0.4781876802444458, 0.49212273955345154, 0.45573434233665466, -0.15732094645500183, -0.024512097239494324, 0.12136843055486679, -0.8248939514160156, 0.3298683166503906, -0.05593442544341087, -0.02629655785858631, -0.201568141579628, -0.03288690373301506, 0.6477708220481873, 0.21481677889823914, -0.5125749707221985, 0.4751584827899933, -0.47171449661254883, -0.1349806934595108, -0.09014211595058441, 0.20418846607208252, 0.1939120590686798, 0.2661903202533722, 0.06162039563059807, -0.10721651464700699, 0.15596912801265717, -0.6364884972572327, 0.28711965680122375, 0.18230216205120087, -0.8079628944396973, -0.8838686347007751, 0.5809419751167297, 0.330237478017807, -0.5344831347465515, 0.3545192778110504, -0.2342061549425125, -0.2617785930633545, 0.3053677976131439, 0.8020384907722473, 0.8004802465438843, -0.4443444311618805, 0.6723794937133789, -0.050261784344911575, -0.05001075193285942, -0.041058242321014404, 0.4679311513900757, -0.035004254430532455, -1.0213261842727661, -0.116917684674263, -0.017528478056192398, -0.8616586923599243, 0.5771774649620056, -0.7300760746002197, 0.20299993455410004, -0.27977487444877625, -0.2544984817504883, -0.1224592998623848, -0.2028234601020813, -0.7754073739051819, 0.3015311658382416, 0.17292748391628265, 0.27417153120040894, -0.8940420150756836, 0.8369844555854797, 0.8785223960876465, -0.3148253262042999, -0.833980143070221, 0.2684899866580963, 0.3809758126735687, -0.7455934882164001, 0.21043634414672852, -0.001142337336204946, -0.29620763659477234, -0.06170785799622536, -0.8373211622238159, -0.4411408007144928, 1.0603690147399902, 0.3692350387573242, -0.5813517570495605, -0.041611988097429276, 0.634588897228241, 0.8005959391593933, -0.3365571200847626, 0.5857479572296143, 0.9831993579864502, 0.6283791065216064, 0.17518970370292664, -0.6388595104217529, -0.033939771354198456, -0.08184132725000381, -0.13796460628509521, -0.006102878134697676, -0.677223801612854, 0.765439510345459, 0.020554030314087868, -0.1012493371963501, -0.2128564715385437, 0.5242478847503662, 0.10959238559007645, 0.4261585474014282, 0.4882693886756897, 0.059302713721990585, 1.204899549484253, 0.029059020802378654, 0.901437520980835, -0.25682613253593445, 0.2657805383205414, 1.1754335165023804, -0.6036767363548279, 0.5931577682495117, 0.2932634949684143, -0.19716325402259827, 0.5256302356719971, 0.5823453664779663, 0.47606149315834045, 0.3745312988758087, 0.10419034957885742, -0.40503236651420593, 0.05900892615318298, 0.08983460813760757, -0.1881193071603775, 0.23111885786056519, 0.7879085540771484, -0.021444078534841537, -0.21586796641349792, 0.06130480021238327, 0.45285654067993164, -0.09872683137655258, -0.1424177885055542, 0.917060911655426, 0.09209401160478592, -0.5137938857078552, 0.21208474040031433, -0.14376872777938843, 0.5386982560157776, -0.6262854933738708, -0.11312942951917648, -0.3574165403842926, 0.20011723041534424, -0.2493702620267868, -1.0984814167022705, 0.21511134505271912, 0.14182743430137634, -0.2553350329399109, -0.5041022896766663, 0.932249903678894, -0.4428609311580658, -0.2963249385356903, 0.2557537853717804, 0.8105700612068176, 0.3556545376777649, -0.1440538763999939, -0.737291693687439, -0.12314359843730927, 0.35570433735847473, -0.5738795399665833, 0.5274364948272705, 0.6249020099639893, -0.34352177381515503, 0.6012663245201111, 0.6376440525054932, 0.0773743987083435, -0.3028281331062317, 0.19531278312206268, 0.920281708240509, -0.9918670654296875, -0.48075273633003235, -0.575568675994873, 0.2166309654712677, 0.041111476719379425, -0.42773616313934326, 0.4783703684806824, 0.23134581744670868, 0.35500624775886536, 0.10021232813596725, 1.2614781856536865, -0.008502145297825336, 0.6206977367401123, -0.5026629567146301, 0.4989149272441864, -0.14838261902332306, 0.3682025671005249, -0.24848005175590515, -0.5326014757156372, 0.13054026663303375, 0.48947328329086304, -0.5946031212806702, 0.04752090945839882, 0.5315713882446289, 0.8826649188995361, 0.19416776299476624, 0.23514677584171295, 0.5368013978004456, 0.7479416728019714, 1.0796922445297241, 0.3554152548313141, 1.0627626180648804, 0.024591892957687378, 0.5051563382148743, 0.40508148074150085, -0.14857140183448792, -0.157637357711792, -0.5719470977783203, -0.9859702587127686, -0.6568186283111572, -0.2946048080921173, -0.37949448823928833, 0.2620302438735962, 0.7779332995414734, 0.27756062150001526, -0.7375284433364868, -0.1048801839351654, -0.20611678063869476, -0.12364230304956436, 0.09179911762475967, -0.22795623540878296, -0.018530821427702904, -0.15287737548351288, -0.5411122441291809, 0.4793045222759247, 0.21561536192893982, 0.16733433306217194, -0.36128634214401245, -0.3832537829875946, 0.07513552904129028, 0.4468361735343933, 0.4121220111846924, 0.4092942774295807, -0.3259221911430359, -0.4400128424167633, -0.03202483057975769, -0.28117835521698, 0.3868217170238495, 0.9282606840133667, -0.8996024131774902, 0.3561192452907562, 0.1246439591050148, 0.2494020164012909, 0.7974017262458801, 0.06929983198642731, 0.9353578686714172, -0.5448629856109619, 0.01039540022611618, 0.000981436693109572, 0.3083665072917938, 0.4944421648979187, -0.6297178864479065, 0.4917236566543579, 0.19922341406345367, -0.647700846195221, -0.4572185277938843, 0.2883254587650299, -0.7673612236976624, -0.007779671344906092, 1.2530832290649414, -0.2157392054796219, 0.02934928610920906, -0.432644248008728, -0.88871830701828, -0.07114502042531967, -0.9045213460922241, 0.5622608661651611, 0.7588905692100525, -0.527025580406189, -0.1542932689189911, -0.42161503434181213, 0.6975216269493103, 0.20977799594402313, -1.1727311611175537, -0.040162939578294754, 0.5241241455078125, 0.2969217896461487, -0.0627986267209053, 0.9249935746192932, 0.09498968720436096, -0.21507588028907776, -0.33414432406425476, 0.03768272325396538, 0.1458185464143753, -0.10012229532003403, -0.2107713520526886, -0.139670267701149, 0.0649285614490509, 0.09401818364858627 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16158v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16158v2	Mobile-Agent: Autonomous Multi-Modal Mobile Device Agent with Visual Perception	2024-01-29T13:46:37	2024-04-18T06:53:38	Junyang Wang, Haiyang Xu, Jiabo Ye, Ming Yan, Weizhou Shen, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Jitao Sang	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.CV	Mobile device agent based on Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLM) is becoming a popular application. In this paper, we introduce Mobile-Agent, an autonomous multi-modal mobile device agent. Mobile-Agent first leverages visual perception tools to accurately identify and locate both the visual and textual elements within the app's front-end interface. Based on the perceived vision context, it then autonomously plans and decomposes the complex operation task, and navigates the mobile Apps through operations step by step. Different from previous solutions that rely on XML files of Apps or mobile system metadata, Mobile-Agent allows for greater adaptability across diverse mobile operating environments in a vision-centric way, thereby eliminating the necessity for system-specific customizations. To assess the performance of Mobile-Agent, we introduced Mobile-Eval, a benchmark for evaluating mobile device operations. Based on Mobile-Eval, we conducted a comprehensive evaluation of Mobile-Agent. The experimental results indicate that Mobile-Agent achieved remarkable accuracy and completion rates. Even with challenging instructions, such as multi-app operations, Mobile-Agent can still complete the requirements. Code and model will be open-sourced at https://github.com/X-PLUG/MobileAgent.	[ -0.44580894708633423, -0.5029745697975159, 0.5179235339164734, 0.40501683950424194, -0.2128310203552246, 0.22252257168293, -0.010542741045355797, -0.6403483152389526, 0.2078145444393158, 0.3108229637145996, -0.3010181486606598, -0.5255144834518433, -0.22944776713848114, -0.09390339255332947, -0.2851279079914093, 0.3836222290992737, 0.03964187204837799, -0.08450231701135635, -0.26588892936706543, -0.33500123023986816, -0.6402493715286255, -0.26129069924354553, -0.5567951202392578, -0.25815725326538086, 0.6506747007369995, 0.29605305194854736, 0.9699458479881287, 0.6621480584144592, 0.3682265877723694, 0.494890421628952, 0.6725397109985352, 0.3742423355579376, 0.1063830703496933, 0.17756986618041992, -0.24257029592990875, -0.30324485898017883, -0.7323984503746033, -0.11147230863571167, 0.17661163210868835, -0.1189219132065773, -0.1387275904417038, 0.16435295343399048, -0.3188652992248535, 0.47985634207725525, -0.7953097820281982, 0.07199401408433914, -0.6729201674461365, -0.18889592587947845, 0.0455872043967247, -0.10207291692495346, -0.49857616424560547, 0.08033459633588791, -0.14972570538520813, -0.5491651296615601, -0.16111883521080017, -0.04598347842693329, 0.5361319184303284, 0.47841647267341614, -1.0373252630233765, -0.23702600598335266, -0.9458345174789429, 0.6382824778556824, 0.1222708523273468, 0.8294802904129028, 0.32942453026771545, 0.4535648822784424, 0.08033338934183121, -0.7345913648605347, -0.7153258919715881, -0.7044840455055237, 0.1393578201532364, 0.0628516748547554, -0.0970558300614357, -0.062429048120975494, -0.17440246045589447, -0.06276679784059525, -0.5956355333328247, -0.1796550154685974, -0.08181630820035934, -0.2814887464046478, 0.8785659074783325, 0.22881674766540527, 0.5554311275482178, 0.17403370141983032, -0.8056212663650513, 0.0734848752617836, -0.33727216720581055, 0.4120834171772003, -0.17951154708862305, -0.0370589904487133, -0.21743880212306976, 0.5715498328208923, -0.5147629976272583, 0.7734171152114868, -0.15737856924533844, -0.4516245424747467, 0.6180680990219116, -0.5751323103904724, -0.49461880326271057, 0.04978255555033684, 0.8500805497169495, 0.532282829284668, -0.10764660686254501, -0.10445154458284378, -0.7605244517326355, 0.12326712906360626, 0.5238950848579407, -0.6073452234268188, 0.08493183553218842, 0.2457635998725891, -0.6403455138206482, -0.37233057618141174, -0.17005011439323425, -0.3226900100708008, -0.7470073103904724, -0.23432403802871704, 0.6508311033248901, -0.2968412935733795, -0.2305307239294052, -0.045110952109098434, 0.06878241151571274, 0.20304815471172333, 0.5294394493103027, -0.41583502292633057, 0.01858532801270485, 0.20321053266525269, 0.8818432688713074, -0.2290721833705902, -0.558053731918335, -0.7112551927566528, 0.27984747290611267, -0.29105278849601746, 0.7012138962745667, -0.6080594658851624, -0.3719327747821808, -0.4252176284790039, -0.03036768175661564, -0.44133099913597107, -0.37816905975341797, 0.7661447525024414, -0.5424864888191223, -0.4105479121208191, 0.15463553369045258, -0.0009742147522047162, -0.5004789233207703, 0.292454332113266, -0.5507602691650391, 0.7743775248527527, 0.03172414377331734, -0.07203809171915054, 0.43846386671066284, -0.8009091019630432, -0.5060986876487732, 0.30474045872688293, -0.17978575825691223, -0.1182723417878151, 0.07734900712966919, 0.10774709284305573, 0.5736069679260254, -0.19420593976974487, -0.3320647180080414, -0.19309945404529572, -0.3629591166973114, 0.23196059465408325, -0.3794654607772827, 0.6036850214004517, 0.3143957257270813, -0.6410688161849976, 0.5555053949356079, -1.0544465780258179, 0.23106655478477478, -0.007326701655983925, -0.21618108451366425, -0.38347920775413513, 0.2261757254600525, 0.4387657642364502, 0.5424301028251648, 0.44413021206855774, -0.560438871383667, 0.2998216450214386, 0.14942680299282074, 0.27446210384368896, 0.32083046436309814, -0.27446720004081726, 0.5667644143104553, -0.06010223552584648, 0.5306475758552551, -0.1231955960392952, 0.5421025156974792, -0.40719616413116455, -0.42437130212783813, -0.5500001311302185, -0.6247861385345459, 0.010936952196061611, 0.8324944376945496, -1.0050526857376099, -0.07893195748329163, -0.19982437789440155, -0.7647198438644409, -0.1713574230670929, 0.14388947188854218, 0.3386911153793335, 0.1012260690331459, 0.05555219575762749, -0.09573795646429062, -0.26528990268707275, -0.760223925113678, -0.19279487431049347, -0.19281618297100067, 0.26932406425476074, 0.4812893867492676, 0.541598916053772, -0.9598546028137207, 0.8207336664199829, -0.04224558174610138, -0.5710887908935547, 0.055627014487981796, 0.03782416507601738, -0.3745223581790924, 0.35367506742477417, 0.6098261475563049, -1.133273720741272, -0.7119997143745422, 0.8154347538948059, -0.9077851176261902, -0.0779227763414383, -0.273152232170105, 0.31223782896995544, 0.38154610991477966, 0.4165637791156769, -0.9736174941062927, 0.4571639597415924, 0.7778615355491638, -0.5068701505661011, 0.6453604698181152, -0.3796589970588684, 0.3312765061855316, -0.7157798409461975, -0.023838799446821213, -0.08912938833236694, -0.5730293393135071, -0.5682751536369324, 0.3812720775604248, 0.36533814668655396, -0.07679682224988937, -0.49162614345550537, 0.6341444253921509, -0.4810192883014679, -0.29212260246276855, -0.5798741579055786, 0.0778673067688942, -0.03063170053064823, 0.23615796864032745, -0.12693071365356445, 1.1508272886276245, 0.527235746383667, -0.6326286196708679, 0.8215533494949341, -0.23155201971530914, -0.2078934907913208, 0.6246090531349182, -0.5159028172492981, 0.02634110301733017, -0.0016995490295812488, 0.054156795144081116, -0.8293356895446777, -0.12884654104709625, 0.32206812500953674, -0.2732991576194763, -0.41674521565437317, -0.12635965645313263, -0.28754618763923645, -0.09770528227090836, -0.036807358264923096, 0.33323052525520325, 0.15829114615917206, -0.4011838734149933, 1.355691909790039, 0.36909791827201843, -0.0024276014883071184, -0.6438194513320923, -0.032141100615262985, 0.3164694011211395, -0.0885663852095604, -0.7570428848266602, 0.32892856001853943, 0.10161571949720383, -0.3622058033943176, -0.0751078724861145, -0.054005105048418045, -0.2820774018764496, -0.03727056458592415, 0.8106376528739929, 0.11389527469873428, -0.19423677027225494, 0.27799859642982483, -0.03763878345489502, -0.16446495056152344, -0.050781235098838806, 0.013819439336657524, 0.426104336977005, -0.5015640258789062, -0.2984769940376282, -0.498117059469223, 0.2105322778224945, 1.2572654485702515, -0.7659915685653687, 0.30220654606819153, 0.6971545815467834, -0.08339829742908478, -0.15476450324058533, -0.5004607439041138, 0.24985426664352417, -0.5789574980735779, 0.34295448660850525, -1.0742250680923462, -0.030053578317165375, 0.47422340512275696, -0.08073922991752625, -0.14975605905056, 0.07625731825828552, 0.728183388710022, -0.046463899314403534, 1.3370529413223267, 0.6463453769683838, 0.11309663206338882, 0.557881772518158, 0.07131139189004898, -0.11978816986083984, -0.3543051779270172, -0.5126035213470459, -0.19183222949504852, -0.015410277992486954, -0.3815279006958008, -0.50352543592453, 0.49078309535980225, -0.019829872995615005, -0.0785222202539444, 0.21625223755836487, -0.20796240866184235, 0.22724340856075287, 0.5140991806983948, 0.28712329268455505, 0.4808644652366638, -0.11021913588047028, -0.18252690136432648, 0.5110862851142883, -0.3603370487689972, -0.6884859204292297, 0.9074791073799133, 0.40974435210227966, 0.8628051280975342, 0.1401563137769699, 0.4046292006969452, 0.5119894742965698, 0.19901975989341736, -0.9600197672843933, 0.7913765907287598, 0.2757994532585144, -0.2867445647716522, -0.28134074807167053, -0.11458083987236023, -0.772189199924469, 0.8903637528419495, -0.16580957174301147, -0.49959656596183777, 0.29163819551467896, 0.04185764491558075, -0.18249250948429108, -0.18962368369102478, -1.1642283201217651, 1.0703133344650269, -0.6045898795127869, -0.4785263240337372, -0.47978127002716064, -0.35984018445014954, 0.20184320211410522, -0.18232911825180054, 0.1863178163766861, -0.1687038540840149, -0.5350617170333862, 0.04201158881187439, -0.3965122103691101, 0.5002066493034363, -0.4353949725627899, -0.20850521326065063, 0.36951297521591187, 0.1798323392868042, 0.6790555715560913, 0.010731124319136143, 0.10949277132749557, -0.20063161849975586, 0.08490509539842606, -0.1444423794746399, -0.8092017769813538, 0.5864591598510742, -0.5560936331748962, -0.13696542382240295, -0.37974435091018677, -0.4749457836151123, -0.03665253520011902, 0.5633134245872498, -0.1265650987625122, 0.4854525029659271, -0.21438585221767426, 0.12987291812896729, 0.14437852799892426, -0.2178415209054947, 0.7696908116340637, 0.57780522108078, -0.6016160845756531, -0.19230389595031738, 1.0901185274124146, -0.10505910962820053, 0.0005121469730511308, 0.38275790214538574, -0.10134326666593552, -0.5422918796539307, -0.5489382147789001, -1.071286678314209, -0.39131104946136475, -0.3150067627429962, 0.038907941430807114, -0.6826781630516052, 0.11989414691925049, 0.1471106857061386, 0.03290407359600067, -0.6643351912498474, 0.02183697186410427, 0.19914963841438293, 0.33802464604377747, -0.05916276574134827, 0.4710414409637451, 0.14543680846691132, 0.510470449924469, -0.7426169514656067, 0.5782065391540527, 0.5208438038825989, 0.3382134437561035, -0.06574241071939468, 0.09331268817186356, -0.3031141757965088, 0.12377429008483887, -0.24976660311222076, -0.6648908257484436, 0.2942478060722351, 0.03771793842315674, 0.5456705093383789, 0.5989899039268494, -0.01828674226999283, 0.4871181547641754, -0.48032963275909424, 0.5820870399475098, 0.2901208996772766, -0.9188057780265808, 0.17284554243087769, -0.46779197454452515, 0.26213324069976807, 0.22655661404132843, -0.05429994687438011, -0.28853660821914673, -0.1562865674495697, -0.12110424786806107, -0.5671578049659729, 0.23921650648117065, 0.09925050288438797, 0.06735948473215103, 0.4948410987854004, -0.18307264149188995, -0.01620546542108059, 0.32181280851364136, -0.6750407814979553, -0.2019423246383667, -0.2753586769104004, -0.10656271129846573, -0.2326568365097046, -0.07866737991571426, 0.07223624736070633, -0.045835230499506, 0.40793317556381226, -0.19108618795871735, 0.21045751869678497, 0.25887519121170044, -0.6680008172988892, 0.27251654863357544, 0.2596781849861145, 1.1972670555114746, 0.8301803469657898, -0.011866385117173195, 0.30564823746681213, -0.08431299030780792, -0.8167711496353149, 0.4641619324684143, 0.1197311133146286, -0.02993018366396427, 0.07868295907974243, -0.0048213559202849865, 0.5499718189239502, -0.29385578632354736, -1.078773856163025, 0.6909880042076111, -0.14922915399074554, 0.09543526917695999, -0.37486258149147034, -0.036789920181035995, -0.22734400629997253, 0.6332334280014038, 0.5940095782279968, 0.4618677794933319, 0.3850764334201813, -0.6074175834655762, 0.22262254357337952, 0.47370344400405884, -0.43877309560775757, -0.2419576197862625, 0.675644040107727, 0.5770878791809082, -0.45148608088493347, -0.022182419896125793, -0.4580356776714325, -0.39489856362342834, 0.6268499493598938, 0.38243138790130615, 0.8592841029167175, -0.5409574508666992, 0.5686368346214294, -0.2592197358608246, 0.5308247804641724, 0.1999729871749878, 0.424825519323349, -0.08095867931842804, -0.7748438119888306, -0.44676968455314636, -0.23784717917442322, -0.01853574626147747, -0.11889226734638214, -0.11406584084033966, 0.09629298746585846, -0.30204635858535767, -0.342438280582428, 0.15923084318637848, -0.2843526303768158, -0.5506638288497925, 0.5653948187828064, -0.051839642226696014, 0.6857439875602722, -0.33022141456604004, 1.0268925428390503, 1.0226194858551025, -0.2746930718421936, -0.6214081645011902, -0.24178871512413025, -0.028174174949526787, -0.6708735823631287, 0.7276692390441895, 0.17417912185192108, -0.8004207611083984, -0.18032866716384888, -0.0595860630273819, -0.48436418175697327, 0.9604966044425964, 0.1750665158033371, -0.5064767003059387, 0.3896808326244354, 0.0300747100263834, 0.22674041986465454, -0.5983429551124573, 0.49781420826911926, 0.2004859298467636, 0.44841518998146057, -0.1946418732404709, -1.2923833131790161, 0.04432649910449982, -0.3582584261894226, -0.09426528215408325, 0.15152250230312347, -0.74713134765625, 0.7387675046920776, -0.409530371427536, 0.0629611611366272, 0.022577231749892235, 0.1670970320701599, 0.014416859485208988, 0.9748576283454895, 0.7362004518508911, 0.1484893560409546, 0.5772009491920471, 0.41142576932907104, 0.7700164914131165, -0.427720308303833, 0.16667711734771729, 0.9410483837127686, -0.5213003158569336, 0.8094756007194519, 0.28839606046676636, 0.21197602152824402, 0.43333107233047485, 0.39598435163497925, 0.09948855638504028, 0.5726258754730225, -0.3519667983055115, -0.7372148633003235, -0.20673327147960663, -0.1050194799900055, -0.2654935419559479, 1.0973055362701416, 0.09842679649591446, -0.44941720366477966, -0.06792625784873962, 0.6189693212509155, -0.4500467777252197, -0.09866965562105179, -0.6950675845146179, 0.48368796706199646, -0.22353442013263702, -0.2852810323238373, 0.5873121023178101, 0.5056948661804199, 0.46504098176956177, -0.38454529643058777, 0.010645720176398754, 0.05698041245341301, 0.33800432085990906, -0.34857049584388733, -0.325640469789505, 0.011172096244990826, -0.2838418185710907, -0.4108423590660095, -0.2276286631822586, 1.2041696310043335, -0.0903606116771698, -0.15789386630058289, 0.1074691191315651, 0.7406497597694397, 0.12123142927885056, -0.6879329085350037, -0.7095052003860474, 0.3865946829319, -0.0069918096996843815, -0.045823823660612106, 0.06777239590883255, 0.34550243616104126, -0.35078030824661255, 1.2748463153839111, 0.5702834129333496, -0.32418525218963623, 0.41081440448760986, -0.3498937487602234, 0.5722441077232361, -0.7375537157058716, -0.5133687257766724, -0.8590067625045776, 0.5791605114936829, -0.17634987831115723, -0.24774885177612305, 0.8629127144813538, 0.9830242395401001, 0.5365747809410095, -0.2909499704837799, 0.7520421147346497, -0.22008556127548218, -0.08311086148023605, -0.15114690363407135, 0.9066486358642578, -0.8215389251708984, -0.000010042624126072042, -0.06603396683931351, -0.8658979535102844, 0.15471310913562775, 0.7273618578910828, -0.05437156930565834, 0.0957530215382576, 0.5549103617668152, 0.8276240825653076, -0.29358014464378357, -0.15533436834812164, 0.6595180034637451, -0.13840526342391968, 0.055265553295612335, 0.26968541741371155, 0.9391189813613892, -0.4967297315597534, 0.626929759979248, -0.026777341961860657, -0.2308724969625473, -0.3123578727245331, -0.5778780579566956, -0.7123981714248657, -0.6663092374801636, -0.018892142921686172, -0.18406707048416138, -0.03804982826113701, 0.9891571402549744, 1.0379570722579956, -0.13489863276481628, -0.32348549365997314, 0.10277242213487625, 0.31947869062423706, -0.5103346109390259, -0.17598234117031097, -0.07306534051895142, -0.03202567994594574, -0.6724616885185242, 0.7941924333572388, 0.4689377546310425, 0.042041268199682236, -0.14996337890625, -0.2536107003688812, 0.21748599410057068, -0.05148359388113022, 1.3100862503051758, 0.22876085340976715, -0.716663658618927, -0.10440748184919357, -0.12450704723596573, -0.43520498275756836, -0.0015475546242669225, 0.6512031555175781, -0.7945269346237183, 0.7008557915687561, 0.0762319415807724, 0.4952407479286194, 0.34124666452407837, 0.01965647004544735, 0.4346943497657776, -0.4383682310581207, 0.3267473578453064, -0.06765104085206985, -0.07816872000694275, -0.20375220477581024, -0.18155622482299805, 0.42117589712142944, 0.10873827338218689, -0.3578873574733734, -0.906299352645874, 0.3107706904411316, -1.265912413597107, -0.15765592455863953, 1.149219274520874, 0.11826589703559875, -0.1514451950788498, -0.3513851463794708, -0.6551061272621155, -0.3586070239543915, -0.7259389162063599, 0.4568302631378174, 0.28596237301826477, -0.2389799952507019, -0.7166494131088257, -0.7942756414413452, 0.21729014813899994, 0.10059583187103271, -0.9131142497062683, -0.2520039677619934, 0.45466551184654236, 0.29348814487457275, 0.18593856692314148, 0.7552549242973328, 0.2621670663356781, 0.4368557631969452, 0.3558276295661926, 0.3498730957508087, -0.4024931490421295, -0.42258933186531067, -0.04943478852510452, 0.3853372633457184, -0.03870886564254761, -0.6957374811172485 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16137v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16137v1	X-PEFT: eXtremely Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for Extreme Multi-Profile Scenarios	2024-01-29T13:13:32	2024-01-29T13:13:32	Namju Kwak, Taesup Kim	cs.LG	cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL	Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) techniques, such as adapter tuning, aim to fine-tune a pre-trained language model (PLM) using a minimal number of parameters for a specific task or profile. Although adapter tuning provides increased parameter efficiency compared to full-model fine-tuning, it introduces a small set of additional parameters attached to a PLM for each profile. This can become problematic in practical applications with multiple profiles, particularly when a significant increase in the number of profiles linearly boosts the total number of additional parameters. To mitigate this issue, we introduce X-PEFT, a novel PEFT method that leverages a multitude of given adapters by fine-tuning an extremely small set of compact tensors for a new profile, which serve as binary masks to adaptively select the given adapters. To efficiently validate our proposed method, we implement it using a large number of trained or untrained (random) adapters. We evaluate the performance of X-PEFT through LaMP and GLUE tasks and demonstrate that it either matches or surpasses the effectiveness of conventional adapter tuning, despite reducing the memory requirements per profile by a factor of 10,000 compared to it.	[ -0.8183382153511047, -0.7997431755065918, 0.4984811246395111, 0.20693646371364594, -0.3850555717945099, 0.3402932584285736, -0.41625556349754333, -0.33070215582847595, -0.01827559806406498, 0.42746201157569885, -0.445204496383667, -0.2715926766395569, -0.3806839883327484, -0.17275746166706085, -0.3399975299835205, 0.8979730010032654, -0.06331905722618103, -0.3875255286693573, 0.3336922824382782, -0.19364337623119354, -0.19228538870811462, -0.34071582555770874, -0.9289423823356628, -0.17931827902793884, 0.3821067214012146, 0.4068783223628998, 0.6160210371017456, 0.7052726149559021, 0.5380468368530273, 0.26471835374832153, 0.02351982891559601, 0.4000251293182373, -0.5553604960441589, -0.13035885989665985, -0.17084729671478271, -0.4239608645439148, -0.36646321415901184, -0.07063642144203186, 0.8757301568984985, 0.5083974599838257, 0.010327184572815895, 0.38695621490478516, -0.07479135692119598, 0.8651920557022095, -0.6959399580955505, -0.1952996850013733, -0.8278908133506775, -0.004182965029031038, -0.2471112161874771, -0.22045475244522095, -0.3245810270309448, -0.011807919479906559, 0.1320686638355255, -0.5212621688842773, 0.4059044420719147, 0.373446524143219, 0.8170288801193237, 0.11065923422574997, -0.26556187868118286, 0.39523473381996155, -0.8131682276725769, 0.7257838249206543, -0.3376658856868744, 0.6306878328323364, 0.04873687028884888, 0.30734148621559143, 0.07977035641670227, -0.6540746688842773, -0.458300918340683, 0.10254374891519547, -0.03643805533647537, -0.05922965705394745, -0.0066245137713849545, 0.25221818685531616, 0.2004777491092682, 0.32510414719581604, -0.5410217642784119, 0.15467596054077148, -0.08413992077112198, 0.004886173643171787, 0.3628872334957123, -0.029368417337536812, -0.20413614809513092, 0.3316996991634369, -0.4345776438713074, -0.44270652532577515, -0.7449368834495544, 0.13660475611686707, 0.543350338935852, 0.37987780570983887, 0.025224020704627037, 0.13188642263412476, -0.22919830679893494, 0.7828179001808167, 0.4112129509449005, -0.10359368473291397, 0.011995724402368069, -0.373871386051178, -0.11290846019983292, -0.09588431566953659, 0.5347586274147034, 0.37444543838500977, 0.08314232528209686, -0.21503587067127228, -0.2646482586860657, -0.05642613023519516, 0.06396792083978653, -0.8517439365386963, -0.5903552174568176, 0.1207059994339943, -0.4547165632247925, -0.32987698912620544, -0.09998774528503418, -0.9693540930747986, -0.20993749797344208, -0.04349612444639206, 0.7038528323173523, -0.42585813999176025, -0.26469308137893677, 0.29540881514549255, -0.2948642373085022, 0.2729353904724121, 0.21579919755458832, -0.8957602977752686, 0.40189293026924133, 0.5613633990287781, 0.9190651774406433, -0.20710670948028564, -0.3100537061691284, -0.8259541988372803, 0.1690189391374588, -0.18018212914466858, 1.0476349592208862, -0.8258243203163147, -0.2568525969982147, -0.4139251708984375, -0.09206827729940414, -0.2409535050392151, -0.5629818439483643, 0.6687732338905334, -0.3499181270599365, -0.17005768418312073, -0.036118101328611374, -0.3953828811645508, -0.1257772594690323, 0.06554143875837326, -0.4785154461860657, 1.063577651977539, 0.394429475069046, -0.04315497353672981, 0.5830099582672119, -0.8255903124809265, -0.2604300379753113, 0.014264095574617386, -0.08331780880689621, -0.6913833618164062, 0.442166805267334, 0.08699747920036316, 0.5831729769706726, -0.24443475902080536, -0.011161325499415398, -0.500010073184967, -0.53246009349823, -0.017853593453764915, -0.42275485396385193, 0.2632603943347931, 0.00944497063755989, -0.5690987706184387, 0.14259934425354004, -1.0771772861480713, 0.1624477207660675, -0.07693977653980255, -0.39607933163642883, -0.3457915186882019, -0.1339443027973175, 0.4068019986152649, 0.4612182676792145, 0.033718712627887726, -0.7061786651611328, 0.08408620208501816, -0.37628012895584106, 0.5855352282524109, 0.9035849571228027, -0.3334464430809021, 0.38521528244018555, -0.5491787195205688, 0.2706369161605835, -0.11869168281555176, 0.1448391079902649, -0.42775261402130127, -0.39165744185447693, -0.555966854095459, -0.46921631693840027, 0.30140718817710876, 0.35639074444770813, -0.2621419131755829, 0.5131831765174866, 0.11051546782255173, -0.726784884929657, -0.35338345170021057, 0.3096187710762024, 0.5905161499977112, 0.5823736786842346, 0.18669366836547852, -0.04477747529745102, -0.6151028275489807, -0.8666675090789795, -0.3770221173763275, -0.09853094071149826, 0.07567795366048813, 0.5301221013069153, 0.25203776359558105, 0.1627369374036789, 0.6425250172615051, -0.6335707306861877, -0.41171881556510925, 0.2291024774312973, -0.06722171604633331, 0.25884610414505005, 0.6429970860481262, 0.9645349383354187, -0.8718812465667725, -0.9830798506736755, 0.18038050830364227, 0.01264723390340805, 0.046182140707969666, -0.4284997582435608, -0.2384682446718216, 0.19165301322937012, 0.37932348251342773, -0.34006398916244507, -0.12342189997434616, 0.8583955764770508, -0.5927523970603943, 0.42637234926223755, -0.5763755440711975, 0.10849185287952423, -0.5015775561332703, 0.2749194800853729, 0.2161576896905899, -0.6619246006011963, -0.5245522856712341, 0.12282744795084, 0.44188255071640015, -0.10363644361495972, -0.5211592316627502, 0.6027357578277588, -0.2645595371723175, 0.528035044670105, -0.23239831626415253, -0.052360810339450836, 0.09529105573892593, 0.5694134831428528, -0.03993183374404907, 0.8616244792938232, 0.8003817796707153, -0.31555256247520447, 0.14228370785713196, 0.16869504749774933, -0.20343941450119019, 0.5992667078971863, -0.4534240961074829, 0.29159054160118103, -0.04642326384782791, -0.01041887141764164, -1.238654375076294, 0.21692097187042236, 0.014627926982939243, 0.1743779182434082, 0.27897924184799194, -0.14881795644760132, -0.6036831736564636, -0.1255558282136917, -0.6892508864402771, 0.3308899998664856, 0.6759088635444641, -0.8078707456588745, 0.7657163143157959, 0.2225397825241089, 0.06317425519227982, -0.20512408018112183, -0.1514347642660141, -0.0007696222746744752, -0.6228465437889099, -0.6259607076644897, 0.8884413838386536, -0.49374669790267944, 0.0538584440946579, -0.25076600909233093, -0.4557379484176636, -0.11823148280382156, 0.2013038992881775, 0.0734221339225769, 0.183126300573349, -0.2611352801322937, -0.3289884328842163, 0.3566080331802368, -0.30132144689559937, -0.28766870498657227, -0.4687221050262451, 0.5511445999145508, -0.2619399130344391, -0.1487773209810257, -0.04015718400478363, 0.5567522644996643, 0.5807693004608154, -0.02783440798521042, 0.7955515384674072, 0.8352105617523193, -0.2480315864086151, -0.25670623779296875, -0.8407967686653137, -0.04444326087832451, -0.5910542011260986, 0.38147467374801636, -0.5846197009086609, -0.9377301931381226, 0.598585844039917, -0.41964486241340637, 0.3404332101345062, 0.09241832792758942, 0.36033374071121216, -0.0338166281580925, 1.5249769687652588, 0.916412353515625, 0.1749069094657898, 0.7115855813026428, 0.10706514120101929, 0.18435649573802948, -0.7475686073303223, 0.06540106981992722, -0.430465966463089, -0.5878548622131348, -0.5408039689064026, -0.10824593156576157, 0.525154709815979, 0.10349011421203613, -0.23483985662460327, 0.46127405762672424, -0.6026902198791504, 0.8765978217124939, 0.6930750608444214, 0.2794274091720581, 0.31489890813827515, -0.10772934556007385, -0.021569591015577316, 0.24589908123016357, -0.48744308948516846, -0.3172054886817932, 1.1461822986602783, 0.08804909139871597, 0.574946403503418, -0.056307099759578705, 0.43712401390075684, -0.10745881497859955, -0.27095699310302734, -0.457553893327713, 0.39984798431396484, -0.7300875782966614, -0.6091144680976868, -0.21790984272956848, -0.18571200966835022, -0.5807361602783203, 0.2964916527271271, -0.3509865403175354, -0.8344268798828125, 0.4027438759803772, 0.5388501286506653, -0.9085419774055481, 0.5245653986930847, -1.003738522529602, 0.6897892951965332, -0.3207131624221802, -0.26816126704216003, -0.32361605763435364, -0.8016874194145203, 0.02776999957859516, -0.9072686433792114, -0.13116730749607086, -0.37329229712486267, -0.2554309070110321, 0.7566213011741638, -0.008767352439463139, 0.6086966395378113, -0.32987236976623535, 0.09876827150583267, -0.23765960335731506, -0.054006949067115784, 0.6849071383476257, 0.31084775924682617, -0.19513031840324402, 0.10164189338684082, 0.5015365481376648, -0.40122437477111816, -0.5176988244056702, 0.8042933940887451, -0.9385806918144226, -0.5099306106567383, 0.08707290887832642, -0.8115877509117126, -0.406666100025177, 0.46397918462753296, 0.14114060997962952, 0.2555750906467438, 0.03971712663769722, 0.296078622341156, 0.874001681804657, -0.07511771470308304, 0.49855393171310425, 0.7091385722160339, -0.13031363487243652, -0.2831478714942932, 1.0418943166732788, 0.20020465552806854, 0.2619110643863678, 0.5500568151473999, 0.38044843077659607, -0.09967782348394394, -0.8441567420959473, -0.35623517632484436, 0.35615161061286926, -0.32645276188850403, -0.2404678612947464, -0.513324499130249, 0.10641304403543472, -0.16671159863471985, -0.41207101941108704, -0.5979889631271362, -0.5469958782196045, -0.029769262298941612, 0.23329809308052063, 0.5027927756309509, 0.1744028627872467, -0.01507493481040001, 0.7578259706497192, -0.7802777886390686, 0.541625440120697, 0.14266377687454224, 0.9825153350830078, -0.5646727085113525, -0.4623602330684662, -0.2760629653930664, -0.30057722330093384, -0.2964787781238556, -0.48699951171875, 0.15796709060668945, 0.9462200403213501, 0.6402252316474915, 0.6243172287940979, 0.1779385656118393, 0.9953374266624451, -0.6190134286880493, 0.33859094977378845, -0.06479938328266144, -0.9188124537467957, 0.49833178520202637, -0.3148747980594635, 0.0806947648525238, 0.7924761176109314, 0.18581339716911316, -0.19341033697128296, -0.2694470286369324, -0.6156076788902283, -0.9773393273353577, 0.7572038769721985, -0.012442182749509811, 0.2560783922672272, 0.2976546585559845, 0.7362474203109741, 0.517658531665802, 0.04549247771501541, -0.16951866447925568, -0.588929295539856, 0.028856275603175163, 0.10220955312252045, -0.1035628616809845, -0.17413124442100525, -0.13105130195617676, -0.4257937967777252, 0.8079505562782288, -0.5117443799972534, 0.2570455074310303, -0.13018612563610077, 0.020180916413664818, -0.4159204661846161, -0.10176480561494827, 0.4962863028049469, 0.622882068157196, -0.5434820055961609, 0.25836437940597534, 0.31814098358154297, -0.3894904553890228, 0.16213536262512207, 0.34780678153038025, 0.05156417563557625, 0.05219106003642082, -0.4131653308868408, 0.784784197807312, 0.22313827276229858, -0.9096353650093079, 0.283643513917923, -0.3091633915901184, -0.2663854658603668, -0.08928065001964569, 0.37360039353370667, -0.14714862406253815, 0.3833150863647461, 0.19317854940891266, 0.6793023943901062, -0.08227192610502243, -0.16203081607818604, 0.42174237966537476, 0.630869448184967, -0.2752021551132202, -0.4429156184196472, 0.7286425232887268, 0.13729749619960785, -0.28473415970802307, 0.3432564437389374, 0.05524997413158417, 0.032073844224214554, 0.2773588299751282, 0.6842474937438965, 0.6254526376724243, -0.16574978828430176, -0.036671824753284454, -0.005180216394364834, 0.21937790513038635, -0.13618223369121552, 0.30147823691368103, -0.09173119068145752, -0.7297835350036621, -0.6456215381622314, -0.6630654335021973, -0.4931591749191284, 0.1543373018503189, -0.48938989639282227, 0.5594170093536377, -0.6760122776031494, -0.05729915201663971, 0.2052222192287445, -0.041023436933755875, -0.6368076205253601, 0.02391090616583824, 0.23327462375164032, 1.2696952819824219, -1.0378069877624512, 1.0714902877807617, 0.9768849611282349, 0.15155842900276184, -0.6565725803375244, -0.2867709994316101, -0.1464916318655014, -1.0105552673339844, 0.0803818553686142, 0.03542071953415871, -0.004720749333500862, 0.3211968243122101, -0.010738366283476353, -0.9322777986526489, 0.8789793848991394, 0.9175472855567932, -0.7577351331710815, -0.24280110001564026, 0.11029593646526337, 0.23198147118091583, -0.06056608259677887, 0.1242675632238388, 1.065849781036377, 0.5784645676612854, -0.11607632786035538, -1.0457566976547241, 0.13607388734817505, -0.41561827063560486, 0.05961651727557182, 0.5630576014518738, -0.9486419558525085, 0.687201976776123, 0.22508245706558228, 0.07075031101703644, 0.07157664746046066, 0.3790413439273834, 0.2701360881328583, -0.16202260553836823, 0.9792186617851257, 0.28660014271736145, 0.7536090612411499, 0.0065609668381512165, 0.6398137211799622, -0.8359558582305908, 0.4797511398792267, 0.749502420425415, -0.25704333186149597, 0.638948380947113, 0.6542342305183411, -0.19124455749988556, 0.13389991223812103, 0.4175092577934265, -0.1402079463005066, 0.6094798445701599, -0.18959887325763702, -0.3824542760848999, -0.5873245000839233, 0.07699990272521973, -0.09318868070840836, 0.4586522877216339, 0.27637574076652527, -0.32847970724105835, -0.30463090538978577, 0.4337082505226135, -0.035088736563920975, -0.17829586565494537, -0.24031342566013336, 0.6279667019844055, -0.00233576912432909, -0.5774282813072205, 0.43522679805755615, -0.03237760066986084, 0.9071161150932312, -0.7062910199165344, -0.10344824939966202, 0.1619768589735031, 0.5957985520362854, -0.2557919919490814, -0.8571359515190125, 0.5040286183357239, -0.29092517495155334, -0.3364039361476898, -0.548997163772583, 0.7736024856567383, -0.17261311411857605, -0.4135647416114807, 0.21530014276504517, 0.4357965588569641, -0.1751561313867569, -0.5919769406318665, -0.7736791968345642, -0.09420308470726013, -0.1382029801607132, -0.41755467653274536, 0.7704624533653259, 0.28864920139312744, 0.03242792561650276, 0.4847832918167114, 0.7190524339675903, 0.2700129449367523, 0.11160637438297272, -0.33741453289985657, 1.011886477470398, -0.4462779462337494, -0.533022403717041, -1.0199148654937744, 0.398721843957901, 0.15948539972305298, -0.5351186394691467, 0.6060919761657715, 0.664627730846405, 0.9476409554481506, 0.10098658502101898, 0.6754227876663208, -0.09129893034696579, 0.38336098194122314, -0.23947513103485107, 0.6184611320495605, -0.4215468764305115, 0.2986508309841156, -0.3875569999217987, -0.9822241067886353, -0.6859534382820129, 0.6209410429000854, -0.05696270242333412, -0.014866017736494541, 0.6203817129135132, 0.8686419725418091, -0.39467740058898926, 0.002822216833010316, 0.6919133067131042, -0.00044526447891257703, 0.45443999767303467, 0.521817684173584, 0.41460153460502625, -0.3464519679546356, 1.0000555515289307, -0.7269874811172485, -0.3954969644546509, 0.03896082565188408, -1.0131208896636963, -0.7808679342269897, -0.5899538993835449, -0.5372062921524048, -0.040087006986141205, 0.09931518882513046, 1.0250381231307983, 1.2898708581924438, -0.9006584286689758, -0.0014970263000577688, -0.13309423625469208, -0.2153565138578415, -0.680527925491333, -0.1473892778158188, 0.45196428894996643, -0.2613025903701782, -0.8640264272689819, 0.4422459900379181, 0.4943178594112396, -0.34991222620010376, -0.016591589897871017, 0.16656149923801422, 0.09110097587108612, 0.10658100992441177, 0.6340764760971069, 0.1190468817949295, -0.36048102378845215, -0.6186628341674805, 0.12341049313545227, 0.49652066826820374, 0.3476492762565613, 0.8297070264816284, -1.0838234424591064, 0.3855387270450592, 0.4175092577934265, 0.6127545237541199, 0.5353934168815613, -0.2513866424560547, 0.5796176791191101, -0.9058015942573547, -0.21067553758621216, -0.08209863305091858, 0.5000797510147095, -0.10249131917953491, -0.4280743896961212, 0.271259069442749, 0.1470462530851364, -0.658402144908905, -0.9144991040229797, 0.09606938064098358, -1.17073392868042, -0.25590500235557556, 0.7692164182662964, -0.23938147723674774, -0.04333816468715668, -0.3394164443016052, -0.5921393632888794, -0.03815358504652977, -0.42013418674468994, 0.9321145415306091, 0.18614284694194794, -0.6162071228027344, -0.46645107865333557, -0.27768611907958984, 0.2911601960659027, 0.5857592821121216, -0.5589846968650818, 0.1342685967683792, -0.07932446897029877, 0.43854019045829773, 0.15393982827663422, 0.3472427725791931, 0.007778616156429052, 0.30327069759368896, -0.10475874692201614, -0.5707264542579651, -0.24167871475219727, -0.26651859283447266, -0.34962332248687744, 0.5626287460327148, 0.1797795593738556, -0.05122755840420723 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16107v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16107v1	Beyond Direct Diagnosis: LLM-based Multi-Specialist Agent Consultation for Automatic Diagnosis	2024-01-29T12:25:30	2024-01-29T12:25:30	Haochun Wang, Sendong Zhao, Zewen Qiang, Nuwa Xi, Bing Qin, Ting Liu	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI	Automatic diagnosis is a significant application of AI in healthcare, where diagnoses are generated based on the symptom description of patients. Previous works have approached this task directly by modeling the relationship between the normalized symptoms and all possible diseases. However, in the clinical diagnostic process, patients are initially consulted by a general practitioner and, if necessary, referred to specialists in specific domains for a more comprehensive evaluation. The final diagnosis often emerges from a collaborative consultation among medical specialist groups. Recently, large language models have shown impressive capabilities in natural language understanding. In this study, we adopt tuning-free LLM-based agents as medical practitioners and propose the Agent-derived Multi-Specialist Consultation (AMSC) framework to model the diagnosis process in the real world by adaptively fusing probability distributions of agents over potential diseases. Experimental results demonstrate the superiority of our approach compared with baselines. Notably, our approach requires significantly less parameter updating and training time, enhancing efficiency and practical utility. Furthermore, we delve into a novel perspective on the role of implicit symptoms within the context of automatic diagnosis.	[ -0.47086188197135925, -0.5126907825469971, 0.8032683730125427, 0.08240596950054169, -0.2520836591720581, 0.01857411488890648, -0.31409478187561035, -0.9848465919494629, 0.3414555490016937, 0.5411767363548279, -0.8320742845535278, -0.5622357726097107, -0.3913117051124573, 0.39310261607170105, -0.1827714741230011, 0.7218553423881531, -0.04121629148721695, 0.28806740045547485, -0.20576772093772888, -0.016130732372403145, -0.30128180980682373, -0.2313845455646515, -1.3581002950668335, -0.49231234192848206, 0.3792865574359894, 0.23405721783638, 0.9039981961250305, 0.4163098633289337, 0.4303607642650604, 0.38599181175231934, 0.34450411796569824, 0.4671962559223175, 0.2938224971294403, 0.41278132796287537, -0.07950650900602341, -0.33549630641937256, -0.7423560619354248, 0.16676393151283264, 0.439836323261261, 0.746496319770813, -0.0949489176273346, -0.5282446146011353, -0.04619225114583969, 0.4930683672428131, -0.2554987370967865, 0.16262194514274597, -0.4606672525405884, 0.2201746255159378, 0.2850050926208496, -0.08068087697029114, -0.4417629837989807, 0.09719277918338776, -0.026899876073002815, -0.9511383771896362, 0.6620492935180664, -0.06502138823270798, 0.507599413394928, 0.7666545510292053, -0.4955316483974457, -0.2698011100292206, -0.833348274230957, 0.4247811436653137, -0.30843058228492737, 0.24335505068302155, 0.21240027248859406, 0.6326044201850891, -0.1662079393863678, -0.2792329490184784, -0.20007264614105225, -0.6397722363471985, -0.09810514003038406, 0.31627294421195984, -0.3658030331134796, 0.2335628867149353, 0.006924122106283903, 0.15473216772079468, -0.36371174454689026, 0.29164138436317444, 0.2817879617214203, -0.12550872564315796, 0.8390979170799255, 0.37721124291419983, 0.266774445772171, 0.12524960935115814, -0.3031773269176483, 0.3775347173213959, -0.6194760203361511, -0.32310229539871216, -0.1317489594221115, 0.25656765699386597, -0.32292094826698303, 0.2467881739139557, -0.26583313941955566, 0.7696483135223389, 0.2856766879558563, -0.2849213778972626, -0.013372702524065971, -0.3625483214855194, -0.11594348400831223, 0.13528455793857574, 0.7838247418403625, 0.07688816636800766, 0.29827845096588135, -0.31742867827415466, -0.13360203802585602, 0.26930922269821167, 0.4713383615016937, -0.06771108508110046, -0.18751664459705353, 0.23295052349567413, -0.37703073024749756, -0.3793366849422455, -0.3582760989665985, -0.4490528702735901, -0.7794497013092041, -0.5164780020713806, 0.10908526182174683, -0.35912764072418213, -0.41541898250579834, 0.12504151463508606, 0.2846263647079468, -0.15313319861888885, 0.6767324209213257, -0.6499586701393127, 0.5649963617324829, 0.345076322555542, 0.44328925013542175, -0.1417778879404068, 0.09233880043029785, -0.456940233707428, 0.4853770434856415, -0.19626353681087494, 1.342930555343628, -0.537067174911499, -0.6375200152397156, -0.3627951443195343, 0.11228452622890472, -0.3403530716896057, -0.8462037444114685, 0.19588123261928558, 0.03593868389725685, -0.2600609064102173, -0.030873818323016167, -0.1124492883682251, 0.1909492164850235, 0.29365643858909607, -0.6164861917495728, 0.6800839900970459, 0.2324569970369339, -0.30737224221229553, 0.35567474365234375, -0.8385074734687805, -0.3052312731742859, 0.18028730154037476, -0.20748457312583923, -0.21933068335056305, -0.14866819977760315, 0.3479015529155731, 0.46256881952285767, -0.7037054300308228, 0.2868730127811432, -0.4061598777770996, -0.00029633217491209507, 0.09578369557857513, -0.30793556571006775, 0.3626082241535187, 0.14713051915168762, -0.07665693759918213, 0.2851654291152954, -0.8155823945999146, -0.2225557118654251, -0.23021157085895538, 0.005925689358264208, -0.23371823132038116, 0.2744465172290802, -0.5611048340797424, 0.11361085623502731, 0.043451860547065735, -0.2977370023727417, 0.491464763879776, -0.8286217451095581, 0.020875927060842514, 0.6585906744003296, 0.35504966974258423, 0.35168418288230896, -0.7086173295974731, 0.7489331364631653, 0.5468248724937439, 0.3876378834247589, 0.03952654078602791, -0.9027575850486755, -0.7971877455711365, -0.6426213383674622, 0.0826762393116951, 0.64645916223526, -0.6625166535377502, 0.4641113579273224, 0.026096995919942856, -0.3010157644748688, -0.857787549495697, -0.08306034654378891, 0.19905316829681396, 0.5664185285568237, 0.39775562286376953, -0.05407379940152168, -0.29432305693626404, -0.8644962310791016, -0.1283896565437317, -0.10564012825489044, -0.04397669807076454, 0.5506076216697693, 0.11080095171928406, -0.7574621438980103, 0.8431380987167358, -0.47760525345802307, -0.492050439119339, -0.06112903356552124, -0.033388376235961914, 0.26477667689323425, 0.4178090989589691, 0.4213661253452301, -0.43134477734565735, -0.6172360181808472, 0.36560285091400146, -0.7777126431465149, -0.39877691864967346, -0.09636253863573074, -0.08903922885656357, 0.49028170108795166, 0.24614500999450684, -0.7097795605659485, 0.6105897426605225, 0.4371475577354431, -0.444729208946228, 0.5546568632125854, -0.7056019902229309, 0.06633435189723969, -1.1379865407943726, -0.09092582762241364, 0.3429349660873413, -0.4242837131023407, -0.3812733590602875, 0.06013897433876991, -0.07563184946775436, -0.12273330986499786, -0.23010358214378357, 0.7725306749343872, -0.5459473133087158, -0.012500960379838943, -0.2919166088104248, -0.06450387835502625, 0.048249680548906326, 0.0012395908124744892, 0.11893366277217865, 0.5120954513549805, 0.8017312288284302, -0.9794546961784363, 0.6877300143241882, -0.061033569276332855, 0.4253554940223694, 0.8614822030067444, -0.4231088161468506, -0.17464964091777802, -0.10342612117528915, 0.23005333542823792, -0.8805427551269531, -0.013155937194824219, 0.7490679621696472, -0.27194905281066895, 0.423186331987381, -0.1450752317905426, -0.49077752232551575, -0.3529209792613983, 0.026403669267892838, 0.40973377227783203, 0.2558024525642395, -0.27748924493789673, 0.7932342886924744, 0.11391593515872955, -0.17824698984622955, -0.25356319546699524, -0.5315958857536316, 0.10665086656808853, 0.06545650213956833, -0.8739964365959167, 0.49178391695022583, -0.2433881312608719, -0.5692608952522278, 0.17481406033039093, 0.07712407410144806, -0.18275237083435059, 0.2216561883687973, 0.38371026515960693, 0.23321934044361115, -0.21987079083919525, 0.34357938170433044, 0.31299319863319397, -0.846804678440094, -0.24412332475185394, -0.15276801586151123, 0.2940479516983032, 0.09451542049646378, -0.9748444557189941, -0.27127397060394287, 0.7319984436035156, 0.32044175267219543, -0.051884815096855164, 0.4666912257671356, 0.16652463376522064, -0.5157135128974915, -0.23126184940338135, -0.4850529432296753, -0.1595836728811264, -0.4910995364189148, -0.18201954662799835, -0.3567168414592743, -0.3673422038555145, 0.7407423853874207, -0.23753629624843597, -0.14549213647842407, 0.5052189230918884, 0.8004876375198364, 0.05183602496981621, 1.4454940557479858, 0.6465171575546265, 0.057373084127902985, -0.13067691028118134, 0.03832352161407471, 0.23891574144363403, -0.5762194991111755, -0.25709134340286255, -0.5166417956352234, 0.14210553467273712, -0.5178316235542297, -0.5088890790939331, 1.029494047164917, -0.34051713347435, 0.05032588168978691, -0.2213132381439209, -0.7610498070716858, 0.21082749962806702, 0.2510077655315399, 0.41531699895858765, 0.5539717078208923, -0.13715073466300964, -0.5128359198570251, 0.04628533869981766, -0.48303887248039246, -0.3181397318840027, 0.8226413726806641, 0.11867231130599976, 0.6802915930747986, -0.05746139958500862, 0.6365643739700317, 0.5615239143371582, 0.505233108997345, -1.1747041940689087, 0.33204278349876404, -0.3666449785232544, -0.21599805355072021, 0.0379779078066349, -0.18316692113876343, -1.2652627229690552, 0.3756120502948761, -0.15704038739204407, -0.42808419466018677, 0.15236645936965942, 0.32182109355926514, -0.39127999544143677, 0.02139965444803238, -0.6475688815116882, 0.6053614616394043, -0.15421642363071442, -0.014183257706463337, -0.3774392604827881, -0.5556776523590088, 0.23214828968048096, -0.1004970371723175, 0.5325990915298462, -0.21956010162830353, -0.2195688933134079, 0.4070185720920563, -0.29225653409957886, 0.936022937297821, -0.27741941809654236, -0.29324933886528015, -0.17225424945354462, -0.08756924420595169, 0.3672384023666382, 0.2469184547662735, -0.2598191201686859, -0.2828183174133301, -0.02904270961880684, -0.21173983812332153, -0.6656139492988586, 0.5471650958061218, -0.9080529808998108, -0.5618770718574524, -0.4794907569885254, -0.4691717326641083, -0.8899366855621338, 0.18735593557357788, -0.007204136345535517, 0.483428955078125, -0.19364619255065918, -0.7333133220672607, 0.7161412835121155, -0.22286538779735565, 0.22671328485012054, 1.1276007890701294, 0.29571354389190674, -0.10760398209095001, 0.6748883128166199, -0.04983697459101677, -0.03809596598148346, 0.18984796106815338, 0.14746247231960297, -0.1864539235830307, -0.4673282206058502, -0.4229988753795624, 0.6065254807472229, -0.7421553134918213, -0.31584277749061584, -0.7309092879295349, -0.18675006926059723, -0.5381085276603699, -0.3249313235282898, -0.26935631036758423, -0.12182627618312836, -0.5821848511695862, 0.3079279661178589, 0.4431246519088745, 0.8681924343109131, -0.193435400724411, 0.2981870174407959, -0.7444968819618225, 0.7035409808158875, 0.008961845189332962, 0.32037806510925293, -0.009865798056125641, -0.0953134074807167, -0.3131577968597412, 0.37366771697998047, -0.20488934218883514, -0.9668031334877014, 0.45956915616989136, 0.22057661414146423, 1.0043284893035889, 0.6501529812812805, 0.3364981412887573, 0.6383289098739624, -0.4056357145309448, 0.5814415812492371, 0.250480055809021, -0.6587824821472168, 0.4837748408317566, -0.2398851066827774, 0.05852106213569641, 0.30154693126678467, 0.4536687135696411, -0.6637834906578064, -0.6847732663154602, -0.5815742611885071, -0.7345349192619324, 0.6731992959976196, -0.4436931610107422, -0.3191594183444977, -0.07707053422927856, 0.4024578034877777, 0.14840282499790192, 0.0002275941806146875, -0.3996485471725464, -0.37225767970085144, 0.0723821297287941, -0.5360960960388184, -0.2393527626991272, 0.18509802222251892, -0.5153260231018066, -0.5781476497650146, 0.6107361912727356, -0.3913964331150055, 0.8064877390861511, 0.39508551359176636, -0.16459740698337555, -0.42466995120048523, 0.16241978108882904, 0.4464796185493469, 0.3992731273174286, 0.33794477581977844, -0.030167106539011, 0.05134958028793335, -0.23153601586818695, 0.30205288529396057, 0.2734602391719818, 0.27486494183540344, 0.06576602160930634, 0.23737315833568573, 0.5788314342498779, 0.3230378031730652, -0.540952205657959, 0.4775058627128601, 0.032395943999290466, -0.3983886241912842, -0.45536890625953674, 0.2646426260471344, 0.004793641623109579, 0.37693268060684204, 0.2906204164028168, 0.3786219358444214, 0.13821734488010406, -0.28043732047080994, 0.33843865990638733, 0.6785631775856018, -0.6167126297950745, -0.33465147018432617, 0.5228942632675171, 0.3393094539642334, -0.3873511254787445, 0.5171195864677429, -0.16516005992889404, -0.03239844739437103, 0.8563624024391174, 0.5734742283821106, 0.791907548904419, -0.23776760697364807, 0.27286097407341003, -0.3171413540840149, 0.18789491057395935, 0.05036576837301254, 0.15532971918582916, 0.02918766252696514, -0.7499653697013855, -0.4248477518558502, -0.3662049174308777, -0.7421354055404663, -0.12897533178329468, -0.4665517508983612, 0.3513162136077881, -0.5209066271781921, -0.10327452421188354, 0.17046427726745605, 0.08890443295240402, -0.469760924577713, 0.30360153317451477, 0.15657895803451538, 0.7502179741859436, -0.7025820016860962, 0.9810221195220947, 0.8291493058204651, -0.15962080657482147, -0.7749001979827881, 0.01381823979318142, 0.12364320456981659, -1.111932396888733, 0.031796108931303024, 0.044516101479530334, -0.04382631927728653, 0.013293796218931675, -0.3070009648799896, -0.6228851079940796, 0.8547927141189575, 0.5937488675117493, -0.15961280465126038, -0.19382530450820923, 0.12223741412162781, 0.7694724798202515, -0.6013339161872864, 0.3986275792121887, 0.31115272641181946, 0.7192838191986084, 0.25796622037887573, -1.1944948434829712, 0.25538861751556396, -0.4073440730571747, -0.40236663818359375, 0.2793950140476227, -0.554558515548706, 0.8554400205612183, -0.1206059679389, 0.034898120909929276, 0.07970821112394333, -0.024026118218898773, 0.242702916264534, 0.38002893328666687, 0.4858451783657074, 0.43643954396247864, 0.9284500479698181, 0.17852577567100525, 1.1306166648864746, -0.747398853302002, -0.06280697137117386, 0.3675720691680908, -0.4717215597629547, 0.25716620683670044, 0.1848728507757187, -0.20320367813110352, 0.41859811544418335, 0.7158471345901489, 0.020637089386582375, 0.2838817834854126, 0.028892124071717262, -0.8095276355743408, -0.5612419843673706, -0.1809493899345398, -0.5940784811973572, 0.11715143173933029, 0.5909810662269592, -0.25580790638923645, -0.5927377343177795, -0.026923896744847298, -0.2632642686367035, -0.09880513697862625, -0.38429516553878784, 0.9611158967018127, 0.08010540157556534, -0.6055701971054077, 0.738960325717926, 0.20889323949813843, 0.6160564422607422, -0.8006865382194519, -0.05603976920247078, 0.12513455748558044, 0.1381656378507614, -0.31328773498535156, -0.24171893298625946, 0.5108664035797119, -0.2564142942428589, -0.4967205226421356, -0.2858596444129944, 0.8841574192047119, -0.25242647528648376, -0.6511085629463196, 0.40270015597343445, 0.713627278804779, 0.3323008418083191, -0.31834676861763, -0.9499843716621399, -0.42069125175476074, -0.38826021552085876, 0.12839393317699432, 0.3922198414802551, 0.41434648633003235, -0.2998117506504059, 0.8672204613685608, 0.40196913480758667, 0.3429841697216034, -0.1397131085395813, 0.17588616907596588, 0.8695205450057983, -0.5692727565765381, -0.47810596227645874, -0.6413694620132446, 0.38162821531295776, 0.26452213525772095, 0.15156340599060059, 0.15859471261501312, 0.003783527296036482, 0.027541376650333405, -0.08145179599523544, 1.0668667554855347, 0.43668133020401, 0.6840419173240662, -0.3499157130718231, 0.6881500482559204, -0.7360647916793823, 0.20476652681827545, -0.1602492332458496, -0.26875704526901245, -0.480898916721344, 0.4886876046657562, -0.13101083040237427, -0.019899936392903328, 0.7762646675109863, 0.8203758001327515, -0.07773292064666748, -0.03339669108390808, 0.3192119896411896, 0.2511877119541168, 0.35982754826545715, 0.6511707901954651, 0.7781955599784851, 0.19424676895141602, 0.07433990389108658, -0.07585984468460083, -0.303657203912735, -0.2777399718761444, -0.7238793969154358, -0.5599380731582642, -0.2090538740158081, -0.38963067531585693, 0.006559289526194334, 0.09921864420175552, 1.0712591409683228, 0.786479115486145, -0.6408200860023499, -0.028544049710035324, -0.08194911479949951, 0.28970828652381897, -0.37669679522514343, -0.18609941005706787, 0.03424205631017685, -0.35446780920028687, -0.488113135099411, 0.7023407220840454, 0.24932698905467987, 0.2920505702495575, -0.37501266598701477, 0.033669207245111465, 0.1571686714887619, -0.1258910894393921, 0.40216466784477234, 0.12204571813344955, -0.6590155959129333, -0.09710042178630829, -0.20505353808403015, -0.005491659976541996, 0.3006579279899597, 0.7440023422241211, -1.1268843412399292, 0.33120912313461304, -0.20255516469478607, 0.36497992277145386, 0.24282170832157135, -0.08937457948923111, 0.7580965757369995, -0.4628429114818573, 0.435334175825119, 0.3872770369052887, 0.2209058403968811, 0.08737099915742874, -0.9278945326805115, 0.29896968603134155, 0.5995763540267944, -0.3429781496524811, -0.6349159479141235, 0.41603440046310425, -1.1255158185958862, -0.25337889790534973, 1.1293067932128906, -0.06146080791950226, -0.055593833327293396, -0.7918475866317749, -0.16517938673496246, 0.39880529046058655, -0.532563328742981, 0.5520696043968201, 0.16292953491210938, -0.877710223197937, 0.1074378564953804, -0.32153505086898804, 0.4102272093296051, 0.2520444989204407, -0.7405717372894287, -0.23990285396575928, 0.41395846009254456, 0.4080715477466583, -0.20237043499946594, 1.2159258127212524, 0.0766783058643341, 0.3750807046890259, -0.17570817470550537, 0.03362520784139633, -0.23232293128967285, -0.2388293296098709, -0.2901800572872162, -0.04578842222690582, 0.2140822857618332, 0.05748873949050903 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01739v2	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01739v2	OpenMoE: An Early Effort on Open Mixture-of-Experts Language Models	2024-01-29T12:05:02	2024-03-27T10:21:24	Fuzhao Xue, Zian Zheng, Yao Fu, Jinjie Ni, Zangwei Zheng, Wangchunshu Zhou, Yang You	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DC, cs.LG	To help the open-source community have a better understanding of Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) based large language models (LLMs), we train and release OpenMoE, a series of fully open-sourced and reproducible decoder-only MoE LLMs, ranging from 650M to 34B parameters and trained on up to over 1T tokens. Our investigation confirms that MoE-based LLMs can offer a more favorable cost-effectiveness trade-off than dense LLMs, highlighting the potential effectiveness for future LLM development. One more important contribution of this study is an in-depth analysis of the routing mechanisms within our OpenMoE models, leading to three significant findings: Context-Independent Specialization, Early Routing Learning, and Drop-towards-the-End. We discovered that routing decisions in MoE models are predominantly based on token IDs, with minimal context relevance. The token-to-expert assignments are determined early in the pre-training phase and remain largely unchanged. This imperfect routing can result in performance degradation, particularly in sequential tasks like multi-turn conversations, where tokens appearing later in a sequence are more likely to be dropped. Finally, we rethink our design based on the above-mentioned observations and analysis. To facilitate future MoE LLM development, we propose potential strategies for mitigating the issues we found and further improving off-the-shelf MoE LLM designs.	[ -0.5352328419685364, -0.7976141571998596, 0.4502318501472473, 0.016653602942824364, -0.33980825543403625, -0.3361407220363617, -0.4615696966648102, -0.45938512682914734, 0.10661453753709793, 0.522190511226654, -0.4833015203475952, -0.349438339471817, -0.6539775729179382, -0.024075398221611977, -0.2115582376718521, 0.5945440530776978, 0.04906422272324562, 0.16115042567253113, -0.22477616369724274, -0.06806032359600067, -0.5866707563400269, -0.26215672492980957, -0.7888591885566711, -0.18370911478996277, 0.6340087056159973, 0.36362946033477783, 0.47614407539367676, 0.6109683513641357, 0.441915899515152, 0.22350314259529114, -0.2335146814584732, 0.22688855230808258, -0.7167789936065674, 0.06142948195338249, -0.2897726595401764, -0.598111629486084, -0.6905474662780762, -0.08456813544034958, 0.36280548572540283, 0.6901334524154663, -0.2746041417121887, -0.09767062216997147, -0.07356687635183334, 0.46332621574401855, -0.8091926574707031, -0.04232640191912651, -0.8006292581558228, -0.10224460810422897, -0.5599526166915894, -0.1509280651807785, -0.6290810108184814, 0.1593046635389328, 0.20691291987895966, -0.44230496883392334, 0.012511705048382282, 0.18165706098079681, 0.5166381001472473, 0.15555179119110107, -0.39076414704322815, -0.35231730341911316, -0.7245988845825195, 0.8704690337181091, -0.9054340720176697, 0.386125385761261, 0.26475629210472107, 0.22932162880897522, -0.35704362392425537, -0.38246363401412964, -0.3867965340614319, -0.018438220024108887, 0.22754870355129242, 0.07456064224243164, -0.07078365236520767, 0.1745738834142685, -0.16906137764453888, 0.6558915376663208, -0.20559115707874298, 0.5099978446960449, -0.3646292984485626, -0.15202589333057404, 0.6079252362251282, 0.13414141535758972, 0.09257184714078903, 0.12847840785980225, -0.42316892743110657, 0.25047075748443604, -0.8403096795082092, -0.05314984917640686, 0.45220044255256653, 0.09745819866657257, -0.06358597427606583, 0.7313157320022583, -0.23728056252002716, 0.722942054271698, 0.0030298358760774136, -0.1320786029100418, 0.02641921304166317, -0.29002127051353455, -0.014928827062249184, -0.1648137867450714, 0.8745563626289368, 0.24497714638710022, 0.2549479603767395, -0.4209083616733551, -0.36418426036834717, -0.5394704341888428, 0.1906285285949707, -0.6261085867881775, -0.29545995593070984, 0.19663143157958984, -0.5819151997566223, -0.26132306456565857, 0.19236648082733154, -0.5936245918273926, -0.19215036928653717, -0.26601138710975647, 0.36818453669548035, -0.46090245246887207, -0.5439705848693848, 0.24167384207248688, 0.08588509261608124, -0.1285252869129181, 0.4813081920146942, -0.7916684150695801, 0.208424374461174, 0.8447613716125488, 0.8980346322059631, -0.2932741641998291, -0.11174909770488739, -0.4497756361961365, 0.2658590078353882, -0.19961512088775635, 0.4969467222690582, -0.6693883538246155, -0.6728209257125854, -0.13357190787792206, -0.4065414071083069, -0.07954525947570801, -0.511874258518219, 0.461408406496048, -0.7117189168930054, 0.2378707379102707, -0.1602378636598587, -0.600351095199585, -0.28718817234039307, 0.10481508076190948, -0.5183103680610657, 0.806826651096344, -0.0006992158014327288, -0.7896044850349426, 0.19771736860275269, -0.9332018494606018, -0.2793276309967041, -0.10764279961585999, -0.16414155066013336, 0.10454066842794418, 0.49024492502212524, 0.23398444056510925, 0.37702441215515137, -0.38991308212280273, 0.03808847814798355, -0.25028952956199646, -0.1528337150812149, 0.18619763851165771, -0.5239341855049133, 0.9287298321723938, 0.32254353165626526, -0.054985396564006805, 0.20771101117134094, -0.6948033571243286, -0.17708273231983185, 0.07028163224458694, -0.44495347142219543, -0.5954801440238953, 0.30055731534957886, -0.23336701095104218, 0.10307039320468903, 0.2217998057603836, -0.6160632967948914, 0.3142809569835663, -0.42530831694602966, 0.43935438990592957, 1.2241418361663818, -0.12975433468818665, 0.6684511303901672, -0.18139739334583282, 0.38627493381500244, 0.44726336002349854, 0.30879345536231995, -0.5215892791748047, -0.9062247276306152, -0.8474346995353699, -0.5551264882087708, 0.37576884031295776, 0.4602060914039612, -0.6176542639732361, 0.35399526357650757, -0.21447798609733582, -0.4364418685436249, -0.7931610345840454, 0.22071808576583862, 0.38772743940353394, 0.45776471495628357, 0.25364619493484497, -0.4964067041873932, -0.3124760389328003, -0.8698518872261047, -0.16266942024230957, -0.20295517146587372, 0.03338458389043808, 0.4182492196559906, 0.3705364167690277, -0.24510538578033447, 1.3362118005752563, -0.5081785321235657, -0.022845372557640076, 0.014284752309322357, 0.011792375706136227, -0.09064672887325287, 0.5095041394233704, 0.556111752986908, -0.5021708011627197, -0.43751072883605957, 0.1611250638961792, -0.39198198914527893, -0.048907358199357986, 0.4307202398777008, -0.4006534516811371, 0.1708143800497055, 0.3702123165130615, -0.7469338774681091, 0.18087756633758545, 0.5166975259780884, -0.049543868750333786, 0.2929629385471344, -0.06549037247896194, -0.12108135223388672, -1.1268686056137085, -0.14020957052707672, -0.13721659779548645, 0.10250968486070633, -0.4636160135269165, 0.18187056481838226, -0.0869348794221878, 0.09081380814313889, -0.5545173287391663, 0.7935579419136047, -0.35910674929618835, 0.18713504076004028, -0.03449692204594612, -0.006449236534535885, -0.3174615204334259, 0.5079280734062195, -0.17688524723052979, 0.8463411927223206, 0.7050557136535645, -0.6115134358406067, 0.20730851590633392, -0.03706475347280502, -0.39695945382118225, 0.4595227539539337, -0.566021740436554, 0.4068993031978607, -0.0693201795220375, 0.09218186140060425, -0.8115960955619812, -0.24787040054798126, 0.6681833267211914, -0.4085977077484131, 0.25872543454170227, -0.18834610283374786, -0.4765155613422394, -0.15629182755947113, -0.08032786101102829, 0.5252184867858887, 0.4821528494358063, -0.2833614945411682, 0.6464775204658508, 0.25547343492507935, -0.2664172947406769, -0.38724443316459656, -0.48939523100852966, -0.07841627299785614, 0.014239568263292313, -0.9502627849578857, 0.15939345955848694, -0.2677072584629059, -0.45266321301460266, 0.18173858523368835, -0.025283055379986763, -0.33628877997398376, 0.2903459966182709, -0.0257613155990839, -0.10385165363550186, -0.5236690640449524, -0.03691670298576355, 0.057170141488313675, -0.23282349109649658, 0.18426533043384552, -0.48032400012016296, 0.48919621109962463, 0.09485302120447159, -0.7370116114616394, -0.25285646319389343, 0.49362874031066895, 0.5891656279563904, -0.5258270502090454, 0.8494299054145813, 0.4432813227176666, -0.16389699280261993, -0.11240849643945694, -0.6448737978935242, -0.18428294360637665, -0.4613044559955597, 0.34796443581581116, -0.31592845916748047, -0.897085964679718, 0.5452719926834106, -0.011302963830530643, 0.38236311078071594, 0.2904755473136902, 0.6618612408638, -0.035895634442567825, 0.9661285281181335, 0.6702982187271118, -0.09007088840007782, 0.5207975506782532, 0.00979459285736084, 0.3887460231781006, -0.7389062643051147, -0.44205769896507263, -0.3837214410305023, -0.22300554811954498, -0.2870117425918579, -0.6659989953041077, 0.347369909286499, 0.3277714252471924, 0.17538060247898102, -0.20900221168994904, 0.02804102748632431, 0.5692091584205627, 0.6864954233169556, 0.09988940507173538, 0.3402293920516968, -0.03786657378077507, -0.20820672810077667, 0.3183615207672119, -0.9865776896476746, -0.4803154468536377, 1.2907487154006958, 0.4167335033416748, 0.6705179810523987, 0.12588858604431152, 0.6571412086486816, 0.09020310640335083, 0.3761013448238373, -0.7525373101234436, 0.6951262950897217, 0.04970848187804222, -0.8431412577629089, -0.26196637749671936, -0.47874170541763306, -0.7270718812942505, 0.37223073840141296, -0.11878697574138641, -0.42382586002349854, 0.025565793737769127, 0.17591215670108795, -0.11219017207622528, 0.6007888913154602, -0.6094741821289062, 0.6589409112930298, -0.23604920506477356, -0.23685307800769806, -0.32236960530281067, -0.5729604959487915, 0.6257349252700806, -0.16022782027721405, 0.2347387820482254, -0.0877874344587326, -0.28045526146888733, 0.593684196472168, -0.5459687113761902, 0.7767441272735596, -0.13440614938735962, -0.3841930329799652, 0.42436981201171875, 0.0865635871887207, 0.46838879585266113, -0.026308756321668625, -0.2995055317878723, 0.44447487592697144, -0.7309927940368652, -0.5824092030525208, -0.4022703170776367, 0.675725519657135, -0.8409152626991272, -0.4777162969112396, 0.16862374544143677, -0.47745373845100403, -0.1503944844007492, 0.270595520734787, 0.43310636281967163, 0.5673516392707825, -0.07482906430959702, 0.3657825291156769, 0.9333755970001221, 0.0004586683353409171, 0.40937620401382446, 0.6538917422294617, -0.14561986923217773, -0.48898816108703613, 0.8188309669494629, 0.15042252838611603, 0.3457622528076172, 0.3225989043712616, 0.3035384714603424, 0.05092505365610123, -1.0091731548309326, -0.4654177129268646, 0.029452085494995117, -0.588411808013916, 0.061198581010103226, -0.5697406530380249, 0.035808876156806946, -0.28597956895828247, -0.08926884084939957, -0.6955727338790894, -0.2022193968296051, -0.39352720975875854, 0.03008994273841381, 0.2622726559638977, 0.7735844254493713, 0.08496710658073425, 0.5863882303237915, -0.9377309679985046, -0.014671506360173225, 0.18250638246536255, 0.5493707060813904, 0.2741149961948395, -0.2994585931301117, -0.5578250288963318, 0.3050025701522827, -0.42086052894592285, -0.6467763781547546, -0.17500953376293182, 0.06737694144248962, 0.8665833473205566, 0.9157078266143799, 0.08362505584955215, 0.39848199486732483, -0.5358927845954895, 0.9320266246795654, 0.277940034866333, -0.7475599050521851, 0.46359121799468994, -0.6322344541549683, -0.10623171180486679, 0.24001410603523254, 0.36596259474754333, -0.13229350745677948, -0.48410582542419434, -0.45955657958984375, -0.9119132161140442, 0.7421349883079529, 0.36778324842453003, 0.05553435534238815, -0.36190205812454224, 0.23108398914337158, 0.5516145825386047, 0.3394242823123932, -0.5068255662918091, -0.3398483693599701, 0.08129540830850601, -0.14039625227451324, -0.06030220165848732, -0.5117166638374329, -0.138349249958992, -0.06665215641260147, 0.5518661737442017, 0.19103248417377472, 0.2695538401603699, -0.15550431609153748, -0.19479316473007202, -0.1730673462152481, 0.2313133329153061, 0.9499232769012451, 0.8016753196716309, -0.19370031356811523, -0.15106435120105743, 0.005014967638999224, -0.1863558441400528, -0.09459652751684189, -0.4677545726299286, -0.2648346424102783, 0.0574055090546608, 0.43640458583831787, 1.0283609628677368, 0.3407057821750641, -0.6139562726020813, 0.675542950630188, 0.2977367639541626, -0.2555002272129059, 0.004986543208360672, 0.21365800499916077, -0.037295807152986526, 0.12873288989067078, 0.3054735064506531, 0.3497442901134491, -0.13625817000865936, -0.30343613028526306, -0.06192617118358612, 0.3509649932384491, -0.24301616847515106, -0.5095972418785095, 0.6175209879875183, 0.8840732574462891, -0.5152197480201721, 0.5875827670097351, -0.050025731325149536, -0.295680969953537, 0.4248909056186676, 0.17316502332687378, 0.9786143898963928, -0.2524522840976715, -0.20360028743743896, -0.05992868170142174, 0.4324081838130951, -0.14716024696826935, 0.1518315225839615, 0.010759244672954082, -0.49501749873161316, -0.672436535358429, -0.3187318742275238, -0.47166815400123596, -0.15626166760921478, -0.6926687955856323, 0.4197458326816559, -0.26711010932922363, -0.1229739710688591, -0.6915116310119629, -0.4534642994403839, -0.5970344543457031, -0.053323958069086075, 0.0532878153026104, 1.1046024560928345, -0.5693622827529907, 0.6786622405052185, 0.9593350291252136, -0.2098681777715683, -0.3633253276348114, 0.012810410931706429, -0.15526746213436127, -0.7581038475036621, 0.5423241853713989, -0.03579437732696533, -0.04024776071310043, 0.12814515829086304, -0.5529056191444397, -0.6087084412574768, 0.9919825196266174, 0.2489122599363327, -0.5094332695007324, -0.20153667032718658, -0.0750979632139206, 0.15628063678741455, -0.3935953378677368, 0.519572377204895, -0.0031786905601620674, 0.3594314754009247, -0.014552650973200798, -1.0507135391235352, -0.3490007817745209, -0.12482383102178574, -0.04104187712073326, 0.40786731243133545, -0.8474411964416504, 1.2519656419754028, -0.12848535180091858, -0.014134924858808517, 0.058327216655015945, 0.8254942893981934, -0.09348154813051224, 0.46388185024261475, 0.5878615379333496, 0.7498580813407898, 0.6692178845405579, 0.0912860706448555, 0.9596881866455078, -0.3962675929069519, 0.11574981361627579, 0.835800051689148, -0.10569144785404205, 0.9941356182098389, 0.5186387300491333, -0.0400211326777935, 0.37196019291877747, 0.5962920188903809, 0.597187876701355, 0.7488458156585693, 0.041963838040828705, -0.31969234347343445, -0.3737052083015442, 0.20149141550064087, -0.5715512037277222, 0.21559488773345947, 0.1983463168144226, -0.213520810008049, -0.31921815872192383, 0.1938798576593399, 0.06691007316112518, -0.27237260341644287, -0.4703749716281891, 0.7126428484916687, 0.0553058460354805, -0.5135967135429382, 0.1514836698770523, 0.2456008791923523, 0.7915806174278259, -0.6854358911514282, 0.2129296511411667, -0.25874048471450806, 0.028177794069051743, -0.07337652891874313, -0.5789583325386047, 0.030886279419064522, -0.11111881583929062, -0.37423112988471985, -0.16824622452259064, 0.4967089295387268, -0.40309154987335205, -0.19975782930850983, 0.21932488679885864, 0.6130725741386414, 0.09929633140563965, -0.20883682370185852, -0.3651272654533386, 0.15815238654613495, -0.154434934258461, -0.4760149419307709, 0.4207976162433624, 0.8372381925582886, -0.006025108974426985, 0.7935509085655212, 0.6903461813926697, -0.005172224249690771, 0.5887541174888611, -0.285190612077713, 0.9172139167785645, -0.4559175670146942, -0.48341310024261475, -0.8294828534126282, 0.8668268322944641, 0.1120205670595169, -0.3746035099029541, 0.7096959948539734, 0.5155728459358215, 1.1377564668655396, -0.24114033579826355, 0.7714908719062805, 0.05933710187673569, 0.3728571832180023, -0.8744781613349915, 0.5081592798233032, -0.7089021801948547, 0.4430576264858246, -0.03824160248041153, -0.9173794984817505, 0.16712088882923126, 0.38984546065330505, -0.17384600639343262, 0.07078593969345093, 0.5959548950195312, 0.7744068503379822, -0.3039487898349762, 0.036781299859285355, 0.08103030174970627, 0.17005407810211182, 0.496427446603775, 0.48507586121559143, 0.8476685881614685, -0.12226865440607071, 0.512494683265686, -0.27563753724098206, -0.22205202281475067, -0.7878254055976868, -0.8507455587387085, -0.9381508231163025, -0.2804398834705353, -0.35430967807769775, 0.060449451208114624, 0.04119665548205376, 0.9911208152770996, 0.8192028999328613, -0.5592862367630005, -0.19772548973560333, -0.15886156260967255, 0.2867696285247803, -0.07354312390089035, -0.17032136023044586, -0.17920155823230743, -0.3115796446800232, -0.7330154180526733, 0.5725532174110413, 0.2958884835243225, -0.14476251602172852, -0.42787638306617737, -0.4372144043445587, -0.022926069796085358, 0.2839893400669098, 0.75824373960495, -0.015186524949967861, -0.9907863140106201, -0.15088480710983276, 0.006773628760129213, -0.12005037814378738, 0.08000913262367249, 1.0597697496414185, -0.3133259117603302, 0.5848519206047058, 0.7536475658416748, 0.6600200533866882, -0.1255170851945877, -0.09222647547721863, 0.7382111549377441, -0.5198580026626587, 0.1602393388748169, 0.22701704502105713, 0.3072243332862854, -0.17580443620681763, -0.05575907230377197, 0.352088063955307, 0.38209596276283264, -0.36755189299583435, -0.9798639416694641, 0.3120805025100708, -0.9355661273002625, -0.1474212408065796, 1.1784025430679321, -0.20911899209022522, -0.15489406883716583, -0.15065117180347443, -0.39922818541526794, -0.12118224054574966, -0.4434097707271576, 0.48045849800109863, 1.1462384462356567, 0.021696750074625015, -0.1730586290359497, -0.5808394551277161, -0.14490506052970886, 0.36691752076148987, -0.36515823006629944, -0.10944381356239319, 0.42685192823410034, 0.25304457545280457, -0.0235147662460804, 0.7968369722366333, -0.009549216367304325, -0.022620201110839844, -0.1358605921268463, 0.08456355333328247, -0.6261551976203918, -0.4618895649909973, -0.046439919620752335, 0.22852599620819092, 0.28630033135414124, -0.38701143860816956 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16092v3	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16092v3	Multilingual Text-to-Image Generation Magnifies Gender Stereotypes and Prompt Engineering May Not Help You	2024-01-29T12:02:28	2024-05-15T15:29:00	Felix Friedrich, Katharina Hämmerl, Patrick Schramowski, Manuel Brack, Jindrich Libovicky, Kristian Kersting, Alexander Fraser	cs.CL	cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG	Text-to-image generation models have recently achieved astonishing results in image quality, flexibility, and text alignment, and are consequently employed in a fast-growing number of applications. Through improvements in multilingual abilities, a larger community now has access to this technology. However, our results show that multilingual models suffer from significant gender biases just as monolingual models do. Furthermore, the natural expectation that multilingual models will provide similar results across languages does not hold up. Instead, there are important differences between languages. We propose a novel benchmark, MAGBIG, intended to foster research on gender bias in multilingual models. We use MAGBIG to investigate the effect of multilingualism on gender bias in T2I models. To this end, we construct multilingual prompts requesting portraits of people with a certain occupation or trait. Our results show that not only do models exhibit strong gender biases but they also behave differently across languages. Furthermore, we investigate prompt engineering strategies, such as indirect, neutral formulations, to mitigate these biases. Unfortunately, these approaches have limited success and result in worse text-to-image alignment. Consequently, we call for more research into diverse representations across languages in image generators, as well as into steerability to address biased model behavior.	[ -0.39619120955467224, -0.3088673949241638, 0.2812989056110382, 0.5383138060569763, 0.09423233568668365, 0.12670660018920898, -0.014513260684907436, -0.4623664617538452, -0.302933931350708, 0.05205068364739418, -0.8644092082977295, -0.36197420954704285, -0.6755736470222473, 0.4952083230018616, -0.09339379519224167, 0.591683030128479, 0.010050144046545029, 0.5077903270721436, -0.2574475109577179, -0.07591494172811508, -0.965878427028656, -0.20904742181301117, -0.6116976737976074, -0.24303701519966125, 0.4076433777809143, 0.2941928505897522, 0.7886790037155151, 0.4903820753097534, 0.17444711923599243, 0.2031804323196411, 0.025242285802960396, 0.4846719205379486, -0.3727733790874481, 0.13068683445453644, -0.1172391027212143, -0.4469999074935913, -0.28633227944374084, 0.18001186847686768, 0.6177392601966858, 0.7529731392860413, 0.3320591449737549, 0.23693318665027618, 0.02907012403011322, 0.6754114627838135, -0.6039167642593384, 0.21072323620319366, -0.2609482705593109, 0.1641417145729065, -0.15503495931625366, -0.0067735654301941395, -0.6110401153564453, -0.32462331652641296, -0.11295758932828903, -0.3747335970401764, 0.5092906951904297, 0.4062243700027466, 1.0173118114471436, 0.04183438420295715, -0.742317795753479, -0.35913169384002686, -0.48694390058517456, 0.7970359921455383, -0.36619025468826294, 0.4971540868282318, 0.19533981382846832, 0.19072796404361725, -0.10023893415927887, -0.22867144644260406, -0.24710145592689514, -0.08099020272493362, -0.08335891366004944, 0.10571914911270142, -0.20412209630012512, -0.3776106834411621, 0.383312463760376, -0.12274987995624542, -0.7672743201255798, 0.040378134697675705, -0.41817474365234375, -0.2202533632516861, 0.49709251523017883, -0.23654460906982422, 0.5845368504524231, -0.2537188231945038, -0.29915159940719604, -0.18599803745746613, -0.93720543384552, -0.10099026560783386, 0.9108278751373291, 0.48651865124702454, 0.06323938071727753, 0.6165144443511963, 0.2857713997364044, 0.3612712323665619, 0.29348024725914, -0.054288871586322784, 0.4143514037132263, -0.31164485216140747, 0.33925241231918335, 0.13134834170341492, 0.9971358776092529, 0.8658345341682434, 0.34148329496383667, -0.1681540310382843, 0.023612575605511665, -0.07712914049625397, 0.04123452305793762, -1.078616738319397, 0.024180836975574493, -0.09878520667552948, -0.5518576502799988, -0.3463115692138672, -0.06842745840549469, -1.1015069484710693, -0.4996137022972107, 0.11746583133935928, 0.05003596469759941, -0.20826344192028046, -0.5227858424186707, -0.2882990837097168, -0.46047136187553406, 0.13077908754348755, -0.09671106189489365, -1.0297843217849731, -0.2876332104206085, 0.34956517815589905, 0.7861872911453247, 0.08880367875099182, -0.3393700122833252, -0.3870423138141632, 0.05739496275782585, -0.7498117089271545, 0.9258655309677124, -0.5829088091850281, -0.7881973385810852, 0.13403737545013428, 0.06156858801841736, 0.012934083119034767, -0.4233992099761963, 0.39285242557525635, -0.20925302803516388, 0.6110110282897949, -0.6619372963905334, -0.08818300068378448, 0.01323494128882885, 0.12345714867115021, -0.7185686826705933, 1.029822826385498, -0.1714048683643341, -0.7960797548294067, 0.7603341937065125, -0.6891136765480042, -0.3176627457141876, -0.26841047406196594, -0.5664239525794983, -0.6025969982147217, 0.1529478132724762, 0.5820605158805847, 0.18978440761566162, -0.5651677250862122, 0.6674579381942749, -0.3431079685688019, -0.03566892445087433, 0.09833940863609314, -0.4130899906158447, 0.767677366733551, 0.21400092542171478, -0.33726200461387634, -0.17106810212135315, -0.5100087523460388, -0.12876534461975098, 0.2905046343803406, 0.17380046844482422, -0.1352539360523224, 0.07334794849157333, 0.18327686190605164, 0.4542660415172577, 0.05748186260461807, -0.5240090489387512, 0.20870718359947205, -0.06977774947881699, 0.33958929777145386, 0.7300504446029663, -0.39183053374290466, 0.6851005554199219, -0.25904592871665955, 0.46864113211631775, 0.13089050352573395, -0.13265414535999298, -0.5646354556083679, -0.5927808284759521, -0.3687078058719635, -0.1805119812488556, 0.2889169156551361, 0.6004189252853394, -1.000663161277771, -0.1736159324645996, -0.21390856802463531, -0.34647610783576965, -0.6087473630905151, 0.05300488322973251, 0.5898436307907104, 0.5691384077072144, 0.10115975141525269, -0.09738137573003769, -0.37134596705436707, -1.4181424379348755, -0.629825234413147, -0.36047717928886414, -0.14969412982463837, 0.3038578927516937, 0.38996362686157227, -0.0828671008348465, 0.8502458930015564, -0.4025382697582245, -0.1325780600309372, -0.16733092069625854, 0.5706789493560791, 0.005673209670931101, 0.566917359828949, 1.077779769897461, -0.838454008102417, -0.19712068140506744, -0.13155433535575867, -0.9833294153213501, -0.4334345757961273, -0.015254865400493145, -0.3065238296985626, 0.30528557300567627, 0.43754246830940247, -0.5976681709289551, 0.10345134139060974, 0.4348334074020386, -0.4678514003753662, 0.5875968933105469, -0.14026977121829987, 0.5195471048355103, -1.213513970375061, 0.10225027799606323, 0.3273168206214905, -0.22722889482975006, -0.6518253684043884, 0.1373579055070877, 0.4060516059398651, -0.5394326448440552, -0.47812122106552124, 0.8369147181510925, -0.8249772787094116, -0.17660270631313324, -0.294121116399765, -0.20742277801036835, 0.2926163673400879, 0.086411252617836, 0.08889303356409073, 1.196689486503601, 0.5633646249771118, -0.37737157940864563, 0.06536450982093811, 0.4511553645133972, -0.14296525716781616, 0.828704833984375, -0.5375266075134277, 0.32331582903862, -0.4972337484359741, 0.04233841225504875, -1.081659197807312, -0.2678360044956207, 0.3378532826900482, -0.6433554887771606, 0.7545837759971619, -0.026820527389645576, -0.6866374611854553, -0.5263972878456116, -0.3583199977874756, 0.6579753756523132, 0.49297258257865906, -0.7327888011932373, 0.6752029657363892, 0.13031668961048126, -0.27255934476852417, -0.742364764213562, -0.7819538712501526, 0.2384452521800995, -0.12159435451030731, -0.902985692024231, 0.015128578059375286, 0.03013087995350361, -0.15567538142204285, -0.2630278766155243, 0.11873946338891983, -0.06323546916246414, -0.13006339967250824, 0.1739203929901123, 0.3840344548225403, -0.08037510514259338, 0.3041946291923523, 0.31774312257766724, -0.10842049866914749, 0.11662381887435913, -0.2093857377767563, 0.3839411437511444, 0.047399573028087616, -0.28232473134994507, -0.15710273385047913, 0.8747319579124451, 0.406246542930603, -0.2826905846595764, 0.5286708474159241, 0.7999752759933472, -0.257419228553772, 0.14721885323524475, -0.5470473766326904, -0.21779513359069824, -0.5128894448280334, 0.4397719204425812, -0.5491710901260376, -0.5687904953956604, 0.37699082493782043, -0.23166309297084808, 0.3697591722011566, 0.47904258966445923, 0.47380733489990234, -0.3036969006061554, 1.5243490934371948, 0.8166324496269226, 0.2499845027923584, 0.3765459656715393, 0.2664245665073395, 0.21006551384925842, -0.46919071674346924, -0.19648101925849915, -0.7531725168228149, -0.3779810070991516, -0.8799594044685364, -0.16063283383846283, 0.42357170581817627, -0.17682495713233948, -0.1550043672323227, 0.08563844859600067, -0.4491073191165924, 0.34438082575798035, 0.5928889513015747, 0.00886163953691721, -0.008341125212609768, 0.26969608664512634, 0.08901816606521606, -0.4213125705718994, -0.8792237639427185, -0.6855853796005249, 1.0168746709823608, 0.08551709353923798, 0.6135650873184204, 0.05971650034189224, 0.20472308993339539, 0.27916738390922546, 0.3174760043621063, -0.23607304692268372, 0.4965774118900299, -0.34365054965019226, -0.946175217628479, 0.24057075381278992, -0.3831855058670044, -0.7582772374153137, 0.18928930163383484, -0.25644031167030334, -0.5919297933578491, 0.4956328272819519, 0.34040579199790955, 0.21772006154060364, 0.31137505173683167, -1.0145472288131714, 0.8130128979682922, -0.21666958928108215, -0.573110818862915, 0.33838024735450745, -0.5357794761657715, 0.5498648881912231, -0.04137878865003586, 0.5323183536529541, -0.22498226165771484, 0.09847426414489746, 0.36692285537719727, -0.15505021810531616, 0.872641921043396, -0.2679942548274994, -0.27223050594329834, -0.025325333699584007, 0.12390565872192383, 0.28180214762687683, -0.050580378621816635, -0.27416688203811646, 0.5419917106628418, -0.26742300391197205, -0.7049576640129089, -0.26053133606910706, 0.4771411716938019, -0.8234055042266846, -0.5429580807685852, -0.16698509454727173, -0.7718453407287598, -0.19249838590621948, 0.1498946100473404, 0.8305364847183228, 0.5264729261398315, -0.24392201006412506, -0.4026102125644684, 0.4893191158771515, -0.5992793440818787, 0.5242800712585449, 0.002882700879126787, -0.39325085282325745, -0.25977250933647156, 0.9229222536087036, 0.06030302494764328, 0.31542378664016724, 0.2462487369775772, 0.037794239819049835, -0.32933610677719116, 0.10082069784402847, -1.0947190523147583, 0.26700887084007263, -0.7060151100158691, -0.07731008529663086, -0.5332919955253601, 0.19223551452159882, -0.6341550350189209, -0.14819836616516113, -0.5438143014907837, -0.24948261678218842, -0.4450039565563202, 0.07545392215251923, 0.09845046699047089, 0.3429340124130249, 0.07602604478597641, 0.199178084731102, -0.6338000297546387, 0.4799928367137909, 0.17803172767162323, 0.10131597518920898, -0.29691174626350403, -0.28700006008148193, 0.1263946145772934, 0.06586071103811264, -0.5626164674758911, -1.111583948135376, 0.4015875458717346, 0.3247354328632355, 0.26716890931129456, 0.3496716320514679, -0.13406507670879364, 0.5318361520767212, -0.9213576912879944, 0.9376517534255981, 0.5056052207946777, -0.8867806196212769, 0.6186397671699524, -0.38423168659210205, 0.5202628970146179, 0.20819176733493805, 0.25887826085090637, -0.5079519152641296, -0.5714695453643799, -0.28816667199134827, -0.703852117061615, 0.5976219177246094, 0.17082881927490234, 0.29257553815841675, -0.10289235413074493, 0.33559203147888184, 0.49219009280204773, 0.4567859470844269, -0.7443551421165466, -0.38711631298065186, -0.5441367626190186, -0.1531245857477188, 0.04268892481923103, -0.4515267312526703, -0.06933645159006119, 0.2735559046268463, 0.7009717226028442, -0.349174827337265, 0.5582939982414246, 0.04232408106327057, -0.13387978076934814, -0.2281995266675949, 0.34185853600502014, 0.7252002954483032, 0.5535659790039062, 0.1627717912197113, 0.025095259770751, -0.1362462043762207, -0.262849897146225, 0.3981039524078369, 0.17484678328037262, -0.6811782121658325, 0.41394948959350586, 0.3142862319946289, 1.0564005374908447, -0.18501994013786316, -0.5594272017478943, 0.4300210475921631, -0.14052727818489075, -0.47074416279792786, 0.008399751968681812, -0.23307006061077118, -0.04895385727286339, 0.26484039425849915, 0.53128981590271, 0.3099067807197571, 0.16184386610984802, -0.42948800325393677, -0.3103368282318115, 0.5919914841651917, -0.25421780347824097, -0.3172949552536011, 1.0302791595458984, 0.3436274528503418, -0.27017155289649963, 0.616838812828064, -0.3794867694377899, -0.2828434705734253, 0.8307759165763855, 0.5831658244132996, 0.9530125856399536, -0.231191024184227, 0.33814066648483276, 0.6967986822128296, 0.7188840508460999, -0.2522631883621216, 0.30532678961753845, 0.44419223070144653, -0.6441639065742493, -0.234451025724411, 0.08876609802246094, -0.20842419564723969, -0.2971443831920624, -0.4070334732532501, 0.4958460330963135, -0.04378783702850342, -0.46745842695236206, 0.056283529847860336, -0.4304298758506775, -0.7089305520057678, -0.020463183522224426, 0.40432417392730713, 0.6687160730361938, -0.9753022193908691, 0.2763727605342865, 0.866918683052063, -0.20157311856746674, -0.5600233674049377, -0.1315969079732895, 0.23619186878204346, -0.5854519605636597, 0.8715455532073975, 0.6914730668067932, 0.03152945265173912, -0.2153548300266266, -0.6475940942764282, -0.5298536419868469, 0.9008932113647461, 0.7839285135269165, -0.6118124127388, -0.22099018096923828, 0.2642849385738373, 0.12009350955486298, -0.32497984170913696, 0.6241683959960938, 0.1742311418056488, 0.7012869119644165, -0.08691612631082535, -0.8699312806129456, -0.13322409987449646, -0.41090649366378784, 0.3743537664413452, 0.15504537522792816, -0.7410099506378174, 0.7358571887016296, -0.44873398542404175, -0.4098067581653595, 0.08236304670572281, 0.6405105590820312, 0.32536908984184265, 0.5788615942001343, 0.3015478849411011, 0.13015083968639374, 0.6540822982788086, -0.4818243086338043, 1.1207443475723267, -0.19082045555114746, 0.12028472870588303, 0.9066336750984192, -0.41036638617515564, 0.16102442145347595, 0.5459531545639038, 0.0844729095697403, 0.10403086990118027, 0.6815663576126099, -0.3505127727985382, 0.3925360441207886, -0.23994439840316772, -0.048188939690589905, -0.27520695328712463, -0.4382562041282654, -0.5480669736862183, 0.1543736308813095, 0.02665846236050129, -0.5138505697250366, -0.39564481377601624, 0.46306946873664856, -0.009649576619267464, 0.18670451641082764, -0.21755342185497284, 0.43003061413764954, -0.03969082608819008, -0.5292943120002747, 0.3054991662502289, 0.016274387016892433, 0.6881136298179626, -0.2959759831428528, 0.07595892995595932, -0.3514930009841919, -0.1854165941476822, -0.12749327719211578, -0.6104904413223267, 0.10307127237319946, 0.23268793523311615, -0.5642411708831787, -0.555987536907196, 0.7780748605728149, -0.5436964631080627, -0.9721179604530334, 0.08601348847150803, 0.8157402873039246, 0.0971674844622612, 0.15342381596565247, -0.6014122366905212, -0.1326003223657608, 0.05167021229863167, -0.16861611604690552, 0.20807002484798431, 0.32583728432655334, -0.19211629033088684, 0.7001323103904724, 0.4732723832130432, -0.21097464859485626, 0.16067683696746826, 0.23474158346652985, 0.45615270733833313, -0.33939167857170105, -0.29532933235168457, -1.0233672857284546, 0.40222957730293274, -0.06480856239795685, -0.29259634017944336, 0.6263003349304199, 0.5931525230407715, 0.6310965418815613, -0.3780039846897125, 0.7948603630065918, 0.0829111784696579, 0.26068398356437683, -0.4186394214630127, 0.7590680122375488, -0.7690443992614746, -0.08705899864435196, -0.37921085953712463, -1.023640513420105, -0.29512372612953186, 0.3178379237651825, -0.23055920004844666, 0.2663339674472809, 0.5438886284828186, 0.9785668849945068, 0.019788537174463272, 0.01493472047150135, 0.2533767819404602, -0.07622276991605759, 0.4685620665550232, 0.25919100642204285, 0.9344417452812195, -0.649810791015625, 0.5700504779815674, 0.05107232928276062, -0.061563774943351746, 0.04871372506022453, -1.1389853954315186, -1.1238712072372437, -0.42454227805137634, -0.46138909459114075, -0.18019451200962067, 0.1091691255569458, 0.9342115521430969, 0.8231759667396545, -0.33742836117744446, -0.15262243151664734, 0.04601291939616203, 0.08718620985746384, -0.16968891024589539, -0.11662710458040237, 0.1411123275756836, -0.37494954466819763, -1.0883222818374634, 0.10521599650382996, 0.2186257243156433, 0.11583071947097778, -0.1813054382801056, 0.10652332007884979, -0.041809674352407455, -0.13764333724975586, 0.4473041296005249, 0.12360366433858871, -0.5057899355888367, 0.03187946975231171, 0.14126676321029663, -0.160691037774086, 0.2680372893810272, 0.7934487462043762, -0.3364308178424835, 0.6391413807868958, 0.3679124712944031, 0.39068424701690674, 0.14936266839504242, -0.2132178544998169, 0.8762449026107788, -0.9784519672393799, 0.3488328754901886, -0.21426214277744293, 0.34657034277915955, 0.6420539021492004, -0.37053343653678894, 0.3599596619606018, 0.2858099043369293, -0.397551953792572, -0.8503943681716919, 0.44566187262535095, -0.5020222663879395, -0.45203322172164917, 1.2613853216171265, 0.11624908447265625, -0.152732715010643, 0.3540060222148895, -0.5369386672973633, 0.3132719397544861, -0.6341233849525452, 0.6616133451461792, 0.9411071538925171, 0.3019547164440155, -0.5585688948631287, -0.8187414407730103, 0.13450172543525696, 0.4981377422809601, -0.8011831641197205, -0.11549364030361176, 0.6741929054260254, 0.19019384682178497, 0.2655292749404907, 0.3252435624599457, -0.13854627311229706, 0.3866382837295532, -0.004594951868057251, 0.4935915172100067, -0.13443562388420105, -0.2052188515663147, -0.217853382229805, 0.20347553491592407, 0.03064492717385292, -0.12821811437606812 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08783v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08783v1	Image-Text Out-Of-Context Detection Using Synthetic Multimodal Misinformation	2024-01-29T11:55:14	2024-01-29T11:55:14	Fatma Shalabi, Huy H. Nguyen, Hichem Felouat, Ching-Chun Chang, Isao Echizen	cs.CV	cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL	Misinformation has become a major challenge in the era of increasing digital information, requiring the development of effective detection methods. We have investigated a novel approach to Out-Of-Context detection (OOCD) that uses synthetic data generation. We created a dataset specifically designed for OOCD and developed an efficient detector for accurate classification. Our experimental findings validate the use of synthetic data generation and demonstrate its efficacy in addressing the data limitations associated with OOCD. The dataset and detector should serve as valuable resources for future research and the development of robust misinformation detection systems.	[ -0.7298164963722229, -1.0550527572631836, 0.5263847708702087, -0.07456976175308228, -0.31275251507759094, 0.08478124439716339, -0.13779838383197784, -0.6799370646476746, -0.057350654155015945, 0.3969510495662689, -0.5283580422401428, -0.2784970998764038, -0.40003424882888794, 0.19525916874408722, -0.5039264559745789, 0.6948934197425842, -0.06611009687185287, 0.08769382536411285, -0.2696285843849182, -0.263909250497818, -0.7147893309593201, -0.536288321018219, -0.495223730802536, 0.04978799447417259, 0.16449952125549316, 0.7398339509963989, 0.5427467823028564, 0.533036470413208, 0.4811965823173523, 0.26669442653656006, 0.4203490912914276, 0.7714553475379944, -0.2910996973514557, 0.26733696460723877, -0.05650705471634865, -0.3153420388698578, 0.00848517194390297, 0.01666884683072567, 0.8310166597366333, 0.23074838519096375, 0.009953024797141552, 0.050436850637197495, -0.3270307779312134, 0.3847489655017853, -1.0073838233947754, 0.08885455876588821, -0.7579058408737183, 0.15454967319965363, -0.49509623646736145, -0.6663457751274109, -0.7024633288383484, -0.04742775484919548, -0.20636765658855438, -0.7210572361946106, 0.21268072724342346, 0.3413318693637848, 0.48486408591270447, 0.10697595775127411, -0.6812584400177002, -0.6410284042358398, -0.9285573959350586, 0.554515540599823, -0.3196623921394348, 0.4391403794288635, 0.20429851114749908, 0.6513658761978149, -0.413440465927124, -0.6948773264884949, -1.0430430173873901, 0.06825406849384308, -0.02300478145480156, 0.16657030582427979, -0.14196154475212097, -0.3893849849700928, 0.1968541443347931, 0.33174946904182434, -0.6014353632926941, -0.1612677127122879, -0.34077173471450806, -0.2489023357629776, 0.4132556915283203, -0.17964307963848114, 0.5250484943389893, -0.14532388746738434, -0.7060443162918091, -0.1765752136707306, -0.4563966691493988, -0.4000251293182373, 0.3887230157852173, 0.09511340409517288, 0.05203763395547867, 0.7416399717330933, 0.023959750309586525, 0.4747680127620697, 0.2491602748632431, -0.3332103192806244, 0.3766489028930664, -0.441344678401947, -0.0732501968741417, 0.3749244511127472, 0.621078610420227, 0.552097499370575, -0.017684729769825935, 0.07627537101507187, -0.38889655470848083, 0.45671358704566956, 0.13948632776737213, -0.7048038840293884, 0.055525150150060654, -0.13363024592399597, -0.5545899271965027, -0.4017796218395233, 0.2982689440250397, -0.8899874091148376, -0.48361557722091675, -0.11187160760164261, 0.5717086791992188, -0.6031205654144287, -0.21089816093444824, -0.0767168328166008, -0.6096433997154236, -0.28390100598335266, 0.19008222222328186, -0.49448031187057495, 0.029998715966939926, -0.0874514952301979, 0.7806975841522217, -0.34423285722732544, 0.010829850099980831, -0.545112133026123, 0.3098407983779907, -0.32467183470726013, 1.0527631044387817, -0.49649232625961304, -0.3725857138633728, 0.06854969263076782, -0.05702676251530647, 0.0474431999027729, -0.8265165090560913, 0.7335419654846191, -0.4495476186275482, 0.4819349944591522, 0.09865910559892654, -0.3446607291698456, -0.19012047350406647, 0.39747366309165955, -0.8933446407318115, 1.2898083925247192, 0.34936651587486267, -0.8831830620765686, 0.6392696499824524, -0.9069529175758362, -0.36550796031951904, 0.16007640957832336, -0.4495045840740204, -0.4381888508796692, 0.06251689046621323, 0.40652868151664734, 0.12961123883724213, -0.21603253483772278, 0.10607628524303436, -0.2783948481082916, -0.2813800871372223, 0.5650544762611389, -0.6955301761627197, 0.24598969519138336, 0.46837934851646423, -0.29227668046951294, -0.24237734079360962, -0.959754467010498, 0.011250191368162632, 0.19308537244796753, -0.3815726041793823, -0.6038897037506104, -0.06331642717123032, 0.38360416889190674, 0.3164525032043457, -0.0027802179101854563, -0.7973700761795044, 0.12476536631584167, 0.13043944537639618, 0.33218491077423096, 0.3386531174182892, 0.24821650981903076, 0.49755004048347473, -0.3046249747276306, 0.2967628836631775, 0.40945136547088623, 0.16398711502552032, -0.6622826457023621, -0.6629209518432617, -0.30594733357429504, -0.4310024678707123, -0.01482399646192789, 0.4752770960330963, -1.4338064193725586, 0.47347477078437805, 0.04622432962059975, -0.2691768705844879, -0.14225605130195618, -0.08213003724813461, 0.16544650495052338, 0.8918764591217041, 0.5942932963371277, -0.24924620985984802, -0.6097831726074219, -0.8653496503829956, -0.4239130914211273, 0.07072051614522934, 0.08991048485040665, 0.25660455226898193, 0.7429904341697693, -0.634852945804596, 1.191981554031372, -0.5277965664863586, -0.56015944480896, -0.11993417888879776, 0.5487380623817444, -0.21892011165618896, 0.6047987937927246, 0.7133321166038513, -1.2156317234039307, -0.34699469804763794, 0.09634553641080856, -0.7972242832183838, 0.06741589307785034, -0.3056904971599579, -0.06552160531282425, 0.5253288149833679, 0.6888558864593506, -0.5550979971885681, 0.6535841226577759, 0.25807440280914307, -0.07318361103534698, 0.49952319264411926, -0.39071038365364075, 0.5944115519523621, -1.0476478338241577, 0.023496828973293304, 0.11108563840389252, -0.3075546324253082, -0.7119845747947693, -0.19759052991867065, 0.423875093460083, -0.13626593351364136, -0.5447852611541748, 0.25531962513923645, -0.4021313786506653, 0.038037024438381195, -0.31173402070999146, 0.09923402965068817, 0.02461794763803482, 0.10540363192558289, 0.26745933294296265, 0.6372271776199341, 0.33642223477363586, -0.48095378279685974, 0.5964531302452087, 0.19701910018920898, -0.514232873916626, 0.9946050047874451, -0.04576900973916054, 0.09015893936157227, -0.576300323009491, 0.6992163062095642, -1.1398675441741943, -0.8174938559532166, 0.6482677459716797, -0.565626323223114, 0.23961539566516876, 0.03261810913681984, -0.8134967684745789, -0.29128703474998474, -0.31870177388191223, 0.927823543548584, 0.1798449605703354, -0.9205319881439209, 0.5122079849243164, 0.5379471182823181, 0.3233044743537903, -0.2196757048368454, -1.0840437412261963, 0.02998966909945011, -0.3674702048301697, -0.8168851733207703, 0.6062909960746765, 0.002253702376037836, -0.04591739550232887, -0.0013940054923295975, -0.10500398278236389, -0.5224413871765137, -0.4880432188510895, 0.07633152604103088, 0.2499813586473465, -0.2500382363796234, 0.4129055142402649, 0.08571320027112961, 0.10887250304222107, -0.05027441680431366, -0.19534030556678772, 0.5137187838554382, 0.23061980307102203, -0.37030738592147827, -0.646964967250824, 0.6900044679641724, 0.6735310554504395, 0.062278978526592255, 0.6660281419754028, 0.88010174036026, -0.7585801482200623, -0.23721551895141602, -0.4380647838115692, -0.28812381625175476, -0.46861109137535095, 0.22645308077335358, 0.11709243059158325, -0.2188272625207901, 0.23753134906291962, -0.18277141451835632, -0.36517098546028137, 0.42946699261665344, 0.19831088185310364, -0.2330818921327591, 1.2246980667114258, 0.2938781678676605, 0.45936742424964905, 0.5642895102500916, -0.26604214310646057, 0.2263142317533493, -0.5346084237098694, -0.4588136672973633, -0.20724846422672272, -0.20874427258968353, -0.5112252831459045, -0.4052693247795105, 0.673142671585083, 0.007827689871191978, 0.24202243983745575, 0.24183781445026398, -0.4057086408138275, 0.507392406463623, 0.38218918442726135, 0.38038313388824463, 0.4462748169898987, 0.14454664289951324, 0.2359643280506134, 0.028783176094293594, -0.7663065791130066, -0.2788570523262024, 1.0245345830917358, 0.16350547969341278, 0.7726685404777527, 0.023204438388347626, 0.35206979513168335, 0.5274919271469116, 0.40084049105644226, -0.5972110033035278, 0.17785833775997162, 0.046084675937891006, -0.9247599840164185, -0.08072160184383392, -0.35042738914489746, -0.6229351162910461, 0.21195848286151886, -0.6343744993209839, -0.4830562472343445, 0.4443545639514923, 0.31209802627563477, -0.16917015612125397, 0.34329158067703247, -0.9727181792259216, 0.785904049873352, -0.20583437383174896, 0.08922633528709412, -0.0840131863951683, -0.568238377571106, 0.6015100479125977, -0.3825714886188507, 0.5352904200553894, 0.262683629989624, 0.0007792956312187016, 0.4343410134315491, -0.21938775479793549, 0.6051722168922424, -0.1565345674753189, -0.12575019896030426, 0.4721830189228058, -0.16169977188110352, 0.48156487941741943, 0.19158640503883362, 0.2827286720275879, 0.030895590782165527, -0.16554532945156097, -0.17046064138412476, -0.6127366423606873, 0.6032795906066895, -0.2533262073993683, 0.061265770345926285, -0.6563922762870789, -0.8576107621192932, -0.12023703753948212, 0.20769403874874115, 0.7681599259376526, 0.6082456707954407, -0.11454928666353226, 0.29219087958335876, 0.42951831221580505, -0.41357532143592834, 0.48504477739334106, 0.05977571755647659, -0.2110908180475235, -0.5367980599403381, 0.9286849498748779, 0.20450975000858307, 0.37387481331825256, 0.19610394537448883, 0.07841768860816956, -0.6723876595497131, -0.15174010396003723, -0.6662585735321045, -0.13653329014778137, -0.9367766976356506, -0.13372278213500977, -0.17280875146389008, -0.09399186819791794, -0.5123838186264038, -0.03049035184085369, -0.2531558871269226, -0.21332071721553802, -0.2709238529205322, 0.3514378070831299, -0.04666205868124962, 0.6236779093742371, 0.04780036211013794, 0.37473323941230774, -0.9293521046638489, 0.731638491153717, 0.021445026621222496, 0.012708810158073902, -0.5037009716033936, -0.271689772605896, -0.0015977730508893728, 0.4709160327911377, -0.5580053329467773, -1.0384998321533203, 0.5040736198425293, 0.33156004548072815, 0.5409443974494934, 0.6600913405418396, 0.3305656313896179, 0.535872220993042, -0.06631021946668625, 0.5993590950965881, 0.41692662239074707, -0.7973434925079346, 0.6051068305969238, -0.2769255042076111, 0.29503223299980164, 0.17800162732601166, 0.5261812806129456, -0.517686665058136, -0.1492883861064911, -0.516032338142395, -0.6067224740982056, 0.8485303521156311, 0.3633180856704712, -0.2051089107990265, -0.060774993151426315, 0.1742527186870575, 0.3304603397846222, 0.29775938391685486, -0.657448947429657, -0.14172063767910004, -0.1625087708234787, -0.22155892848968506, 0.032256707549095154, 0.03948327898979187, -0.12535807490348816, 0.05904088914394379, 0.47823140025138855, -0.3810504078865051, 0.3636242151260376, 0.4534951150417328, -0.5320901274681091, -0.1992613673210144, 0.02581949345767498, 0.7620323300361633, 0.4269392788410187, -0.12768620252609253, 0.3927850127220154, 0.10755255073308945, -0.6956062912940979, 0.10924600064754486, -0.20618270337581635, -0.2402445673942566, 0.2576596438884735, 0.26521188020706177, 0.3737994134426117, -0.07903432846069336, -0.8093351125717163, 0.6278136372566223, -0.14460915327072144, -0.09677325934171677, -0.4344210922718048, -0.16270233690738678, -0.4845719635486603, 0.14262117445468903, 0.6260820627212524, 0.7848970890045166, 0.4005587697029114, -1.0003796815872192, 0.20191633701324463, 0.38900086283683777, -0.20681139826774597, -0.10064831376075745, 0.4526982009410858, 0.13979467749595642, -0.01705293543636799, 0.40638574957847595, -0.2378830909729004, -0.17484019696712494, 0.6171805262565613, 0.8351010084152222, 0.47254765033721924, -0.18095038831233978, 0.27785778045654297, 0.013241594657301903, 0.1874697059392929, 0.004458153620362282, 0.3641113042831421, -0.09998483955860138, -1.019323706626892, -0.17020177841186523, -0.1852257400751114, -0.0014919016975909472, 0.47169482707977295, -0.5877776741981506, 0.47941410541534424, -0.3541370630264282, -0.42327332496643066, 0.1874479204416275, -0.7074709534645081, -0.3102872669696808, 0.38420137763023376, 0.35019707679748535, 0.8505185842514038, -0.7127015590667725, 0.664191722869873, 0.6162434220314026, -0.20868928730487823, 0.01205281913280487, 0.20007376372814178, 0.31402161717414856, -0.5573815703392029, 0.7695732116699219, 0.5240452289581299, -0.18253958225250244, -0.17971239984035492, -0.6558489203453064, -0.6298705339431763, 0.9456202983856201, 0.48485225439071655, -0.27811622619628906, 0.21106679737567902, 0.3350115418434143, 0.2560039758682251, -0.7307307720184326, 0.21284683048725128, 0.5508293509483337, 0.8310925960540771, 0.3787451684474945, -0.5443060994148254, -0.10958624631166458, -0.09266756474971771, 0.015448005869984627, 0.1908457726240158, -0.12501393258571625, 1.011443018913269, -0.02971353940665722, -0.678015410900116, -0.004545413888990879, 0.32392430305480957, 0.09875709563493729, 0.771806538105011, 0.8097254633903503, 0.35771551728248596, 0.5580990314483643, -0.18872320652008057, 0.8578280210494995, -0.058781806379556656, 0.2853653132915497, 0.8244419693946838, -0.2069697082042694, 0.5805405974388123, 0.5980556011199951, 0.5357145667076111, 0.3512386977672577, 0.7064846754074097, 0.09037671983242035, 0.6728898882865906, -0.127430260181427, -0.47525885701179504, -0.24080966413021088, -0.33267509937286377, -0.4893816113471985, 0.5912541747093201, 0.5544000267982483, -0.5123525857925415, -0.31027939915657043, 0.2999289631843567, -0.2694525122642517, 0.13243688642978668, -0.3108294606208801, 0.48349887132644653, -0.4300062954425812, -0.5761838555335999, 0.5563699007034302, 0.10828109830617905, 0.7294056415557861, -0.20098991692066193, -0.2931465804576874, 0.09020502865314484, 0.567575991153717, -0.36811336874961853, -0.767987072467804, 0.3826099932193756, -0.25837454199790955, -0.06716819107532501, -0.09991827607154846, 1.0020244121551514, -0.8293948173522949, -0.3097603917121887, 0.014605351723730564, 0.23156294226646423, -0.14020995795726776, -0.34953776001930237, -0.20211613178253174, 0.049094200134277344, -0.2738090753555298, 0.24317924678325653, 0.09382005780935287, 0.5090751647949219, -0.3823045790195465, 0.47440969944000244, 0.9148110747337341, -0.2920614778995514, 0.09262828528881073, -0.3416108787059784, 0.971125602722168, -0.3614877760410309, -0.709696352481842, -0.6478039622306824, 0.4176519215106964, -0.37124329805374146, -0.4269731342792511, 0.7177631855010986, 0.7352634072303772, 1.1590931415557861, -0.47792091965675354, 0.990082859992981, -0.16065284609794617, 0.23058591783046722, -0.5841436982154846, 0.5873641967773438, -0.6115556359291077, -0.10716507583856583, -0.2134825736284256, -0.921040415763855, -0.356510192155838, 0.43954795598983765, 0.13426317274570465, -0.0529729463160038, 0.9675424098968506, 0.8704761266708374, -0.40578341484069824, 0.3805437982082367, 0.15372595191001892, 0.011053042486310005, 0.31877246499061584, 0.16469505429267883, 1.2393940687179565, -0.570091187953949, 0.6468162536621094, -0.29559481143951416, -0.30530592799186707, -0.49858418107032776, -0.8653305768966675, -0.8133565187454224, -0.8203161358833313, -0.24826322495937347, -0.1883353590965271, -0.2176760882139206, 0.671475887298584, 0.9456743597984314, -0.8218132257461548, 0.17685896158218384, -0.17589171230793, -0.17108012735843658, -0.018531527370214462, -0.28435221314430237, -0.057700175791978836, -0.2605094313621521, -0.6712562441825867, 0.5834853053092957, 0.3752712905406952, 0.3818734288215637, -0.20054729282855988, -0.10135196149349213, -0.4315297305583954, 0.3486177325248718, 0.6813808083534241, 0.2088460773229599, -0.45082053542137146, -0.336988627910614, -0.15615558624267578, -0.04577948525547981, 0.07807499170303345, 1.0188876390457153, -0.6069560050964355, 0.7262297868728638, 0.5594887733459473, 0.21865594387054443, 0.3456026613712311, 0.21511338651180267, 0.37312155961990356, -1.1969259977340698, 0.38071489334106445, 0.010891741141676903, 0.2495875507593155, 0.23913687467575073, -0.5212953090667725, 0.23054026067256927, 0.6692990660667419, -0.2471546083688736, -0.9675055742263794, 0.24060074985027313, -0.8479872941970825, -0.37146684527397156, 0.955187201499939, 0.19466325640678406, -0.3556029200553894, -0.35248038172721863, -0.8692176342010498, 0.17206192016601562, -0.6166393756866455, 0.8429864048957825, 0.4910399615764618, -0.40421926975250244, 0.180477574467659, -0.31475120782852173, 0.467399537563324, -0.20858973264694214, -1.1785637140274048, -0.3724626302719116, 0.7791617512702942, 0.0056831566616892815, 0.6921841502189636, 0.2538439631462097, -0.11582616716623306, 0.46451422572135925, 0.08201976865530014, 0.02393067069351673, -0.12440051138401031, -0.5435941219329834, 0.11020758002996445, 0.28531843423843384, -0.7414603233337402, -0.6947680711746216 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16086v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16086v1	Non-Fluent Synthetic Target-Language Data Improve Neural Machine Translation	2024-01-29T11:52:45	2024-01-29T11:52:45	Víctor M. Sánchez-Cartagena, Miquel Esplà-Gomis, Juan Antonio Pérez-Ortiz, Felipe Sánchez-Martínez	cs.CL	cs.CL	When the amount of parallel sentences available to train a neural machine translation is scarce, a common practice is to generate new synthetic training samples from them. A number of approaches have been proposed to produce synthetic parallel sentences that are similar to those in the parallel data available. These approaches work under the assumption that non-fluent target-side synthetic training samples can be harmful and may deteriorate translation performance. Even so, in this paper we demonstrate that synthetic training samples with non-fluent target sentences can improve translation performance if they are used in a multilingual machine translation framework as if they were sentences in another language. We conducted experiments on ten low-resource and four high-resource translation tasks and found out that this simple approach consistently improves translation performance as compared to state-of-the-art methods for generating synthetic training samples similar to those found in corpora. Furthermore, this improvement is independent of the size of the original training corpus, the resulting systems are much more robust against domain shift and produce less hallucinations.	[ -0.26284298300743103, -0.706737220287323, 0.36681991815567017, 0.31240639090538025, -0.16794192790985107, 0.23200465738773346, -0.6813427209854126, -0.5768892168998718, 0.525372326374054, 0.43790552020072937, -0.3859519362449646, -0.34012311697006226, -0.6072748899459839, 0.463603675365448, -0.44457411766052246, 1.131965160369873, 0.03987510874867439, 0.34086135029792786, -0.18457579612731934, -0.3260825574398041, -0.5226455926895142, -0.6774904727935791, -0.5269697904586792, -0.10219822824001312, 0.6047363877296448, 0.3516629934310913, 0.6396042704582214, 0.6806932687759399, 0.44697633385658264, 0.3186453580856323, 0.3365013003349304, 0.47570180892944336, -0.5174060463905334, 0.2041054368019104, -0.08620146661996841, -0.6792119741439819, -0.34461334347724915, -0.02248171530663967, 0.7956642508506775, 0.7606594562530518, 0.24628524482250214, -0.1795080006122589, 0.11605056375265121, 0.6196082234382629, -0.46101710200309753, 0.09407193958759308, -0.794796884059906, 0.07098941504955292, -0.23881562054157257, -0.4222243130207062, -0.5448265075683594, 0.032172489911317825, -0.036794036626815796, -0.7402397394180298, 0.7457758188247681, 0.07555700093507767, 0.4688601493835449, 0.22803887724876404, -0.30901074409484863, 0.07327543199062347, -0.6231613755226135, 0.9068622589111328, -0.6290327310562134, 0.44242945313453674, 0.1900774985551834, 0.3341672122478485, -0.27187517285346985, -0.46518674492836, -0.5450289845466614, -0.4393187165260315, -0.1820630133152008, 0.08127226680517197, 0.10752927511930466, 0.013950793072581291, 0.4096639156341553, 0.12348268926143646, -0.6705112457275391, 0.06685084849596024, -0.4320084750652313, -0.40457427501678467, 0.7434194087982178, 0.010897786356508732, 0.32948777079582214, -0.06500112265348434, -0.27617016434669495, -0.39954471588134766, -0.7814861536026001, -0.24082538485527039, 0.41684097051620483, 0.6523963809013367, 0.017813289538025856, 0.7915599942207336, -0.2753809988498688, 0.5808113813400269, 0.06780941039323807, -0.14022836089134216, 0.47550681233406067, -0.6051526069641113, 0.002215389395132661, 0.34988993406295776, 0.7395780086517334, 0.4368489682674408, 0.37881678342819214, -0.6267093420028687, -0.24142864346504211, 0.19152745604515076, 0.3420845866203308, -0.7702921032905579, -0.19260336458683014, 0.15545521676540375, -0.4051511585712433, -0.10641302913427353, -0.1577652245759964, -0.7413801550865173, -0.1393919438123703, -0.3486067056655884, 0.09172498434782028, -0.517738401889801, -0.0805419385433197, -0.17503823339939117, -0.2580588757991791, -0.11855360865592957, 0.015084977261722088, -0.9693582057952881, 0.2993471324443817, 0.29136788845062256, 0.9704460501670837, -0.4953721761703491, -0.6160595417022705, -0.8265194296836853, -0.004379577003419399, -0.6528267860412598, 0.8176323175430298, -0.2482888549566269, -0.31064003705978394, -0.10654337704181671, -0.04359399154782295, -0.38781940937042236, -0.9865405559539795, 0.3403504192829132, -0.3005313575267792, -0.07945115864276886, -0.24349337816238403, -0.20596952736377716, 0.05080157890915871, 0.26369810104370117, -0.7555482983589172, 0.8359829783439636, -0.04164595529437065, -0.3424416780471802, 0.24392874538898468, -0.5967731475830078, -0.8588389754295349, -0.20295464992523193, -0.14190064370632172, -0.2822105288505554, 0.3577048182487488, 0.3080914616584778, 0.18968583643436432, -0.18354743719100952, 0.037187281996011734, -0.17715390026569366, -0.4874644875526428, 0.47810012102127075, -0.45730844140052795, 0.4089204668998718, 0.23141106963157654, -0.38602522015571594, 0.07422202825546265, -0.5616462826728821, 0.3719891309738159, 0.015662334859371185, -0.3608289957046509, -0.24216805398464203, -0.3170294165611267, 0.2708127796649933, 0.35602429509162903, 0.1191549003124237, -0.6434615254402161, 0.14295287430286407, -0.6308646202087402, 0.3573785126209259, 0.28184863924980164, 0.0016487324610352516, 0.8402701020240784, -0.5392906665802002, 0.5048754215240479, 0.15463471412658691, -0.2987545132637024, 0.05176148936152458, -0.5248870849609375, -0.798210084438324, -0.3479907810688019, 0.4420606791973114, 0.5887265801429749, -0.9518930912017822, -0.014133399352431297, -0.40494096279144287, -0.300010621547699, -0.6511231660842896, 0.34713706374168396, 0.5246865749359131, 0.44547003507614136, 0.8277024030685425, -0.16086885333061218, -0.7100138664245605, -1.034935474395752, -0.5257710218429565, 0.12615349888801575, 0.09361628443002701, 0.08331077545881271, 0.3747572600841522, -0.08150740712881088, 0.6445136070251465, -0.2760190963745117, -0.2747538983821869, -0.3258472979068756, 0.19089756906032562, 0.007123370189219713, 0.7022807002067566, 0.5010339021682739, -0.7926768064498901, -0.7428585290908813, 0.10067743062973022, -0.735908567905426, 0.034808989614248276, -0.5357664227485657, -0.2790639400482178, 0.5016993284225464, 0.5342333912849426, -0.8142338395118713, 0.05481338128447533, 0.5219430923461914, 0.29171809554100037, 0.23702824115753174, -0.4166576862335205, 0.20995214581489563, -1.145019769668579, 0.06662831455469131, -0.10793610662221909, -0.09757141023874283, -0.7277615070343018, -0.12294764071702957, 0.14445090293884277, -0.12433285266160965, -0.5654236674308777, 0.3705005645751953, -0.3090824484825134, -0.09159034490585327, -0.37173083424568176, -0.019980911165475845, -0.07437493652105331, 0.5121797323226929, 0.21028846502304077, 0.9488459825515747, 0.25483065843582153, -0.3513556718826294, 0.05784609913825989, 0.22000324726104736, -0.18666763603687286, 0.44701677560806274, -0.44679686427116394, 0.23018676042556763, 0.04284254088997841, 0.171784907579422, -0.5463583469390869, -0.2692127525806427, 0.14408399164676666, -0.6073638200759888, 0.3876425623893738, 0.04527163505554199, -0.6589609980583191, 0.08533986657857895, 0.06309768557548523, 0.3137182593345642, 0.5725032687187195, -0.30240875482559204, 0.19068866968154907, 0.017133265733718872, 0.11312000453472137, -0.6083793640136719, -1.1748573780059814, 0.30483266711235046, -0.20951837301254272, -0.4446200430393219, 0.6508462429046631, 0.08175519853830338, -0.2333260178565979, 0.00861082598567009, -0.060665618628263474, -0.29838040471076965, -0.06519347429275513, -0.05899800360202789, 0.11958049237728119, -0.24257542192935944, 0.23192809522151947, 0.13478566706180573, -0.08830127120018005, -0.0243243295699358, -0.6086804866790771, 0.4544263184070587, 0.05373835191130638, -0.15098190307617188, -0.35544249415397644, 0.73234623670578, 0.6366124749183655, -0.30807730555534363, 0.950533926486969, 0.5562204122543335, -0.3272176682949066, -0.5253610014915466, -0.19761061668395996, -0.4982656240463257, -0.4323120713233948, 0.5102294087409973, -0.5738425254821777, -0.5072524547576904, 0.17490552365779877, -0.0022154399193823338, -0.08560305833816528, 0.4144066572189331, 0.5333999991416931, -0.14718841016292572, 1.0917164087295532, 0.4997127652168274, 0.13885153830051422, 0.26343339681625366, -0.3151057958602905, 0.36240699887275696, -0.5657090544700623, -0.20573532581329346, -0.2998271584510803, -0.5028010606765747, -0.8106681704521179, -0.5914483070373535, 0.41558709740638733, 0.05512659624218941, 0.21365758776664734, 0.6746340990066528, -0.3391355276107788, 0.361060231924057, 0.6476695537567139, 0.043319351971149445, 0.25970980525016785, 0.293435662984848, -0.2191895842552185, -0.21804001927375793, -0.8982217907905579, -0.3841140568256378, 1.243910789489746, -0.13103821873664856, 0.22321325540542603, 0.01321498304605484, 0.848503828048706, 0.11390405893325806, 0.2675991654396057, -0.7608749270439148, 0.48294830322265625, -0.25856268405914307, -0.6670294404029846, -0.15531796216964722, -0.5367354154586792, -0.8671318888664246, 0.26512911915779114, -0.3941324055194855, -0.11345887184143066, 0.07020250707864761, 0.14610572159290314, -0.21977046132087708, 0.20541918277740479, -0.7804198265075684, 0.8422276973724365, -0.4065118730068207, -0.25838056206703186, -0.3025195002555847, -0.5024316310882568, 0.03161795437335968, -0.5167925953865051, -0.11280737072229385, 0.17554502189159393, -0.05757693201303482, 0.47420892119407654, -0.4054800570011139, 0.6927099227905273, -0.14318570494651794, 0.15880949795246124, 0.3160732090473175, -0.01179581880569458, 0.5816136002540588, -0.036663465201854706, -0.14672543108463287, 0.31665918231010437, -0.2198960781097412, -0.6266258358955383, -0.9829522371292114, 0.7681442499160767, -0.6893529891967773, -0.5364717245101929, -0.3158065676689148, -1.1710630655288696, -0.4204919636249542, 0.129677876830101, 0.4890652596950531, -0.032921090722084045, -0.10090834647417068, 0.29725730419158936, 0.4296349287033081, -0.21395491063594818, 0.34346944093704224, 0.33217376470565796, 0.290189653635025, -0.4539783000946045, 0.9531638622283936, 0.2899448275566101, 0.5103214979171753, 0.4726960361003876, -0.1876707673072815, -0.33990803360939026, -0.8514878153800964, -0.7015088200569153, 0.11521004140377045, -0.430551141500473, -0.05105366185307503, -0.7088616490364075, -0.1269339919090271, -0.6464806199073792, -0.11263219267129898, -0.566534698009491, -0.6443061232566833, 0.05579858273267746, 0.011712823063135147, 0.30437836050987244, 0.28661441802978516, -0.1783333420753479, 0.028504328802227974, -0.8894915580749512, 0.17614248394966125, -0.14493116736412048, -0.2508348524570465, -0.39419829845428467, -0.4557022452354431, -0.5729133486747742, 0.376827597618103, -0.11301057785749435, -0.6548718810081482, 0.770020604133606, 0.3101412355899811, 0.6528605222702026, -0.07522162050008774, 0.2221599519252777, 0.7895106077194214, -0.7795129418373108, 0.4568067789077759, 0.11113724857568741, -0.5982679724693298, 0.23264363408088684, -0.40115538239479065, 0.28192827105522156, 0.6834608912467957, 0.37717053294181824, -0.33764028549194336, -0.42898598313331604, -0.2925539016723633, -0.5683390498161316, 0.4442993104457855, 0.5061467289924622, 0.3213680684566498, -0.16409435868263245, 0.2771085500717163, 0.02732384018599987, 0.3436093330383301, -0.5169616937637329, -0.22277268767356873, -0.30994781851768494, -0.31578299403190613, -0.5244033932685852, 0.337703675031662, -0.07935487478971481, -0.05933656170964241, 0.4798457622528076, -0.3236507475376129, 0.38019081950187683, 0.21518422663211823, -0.27519023418426514, -0.15133439004421234, 0.13719597458839417, 0.5364314913749695, 0.13197700679302216, -0.04557215794920921, 0.12871544063091278, 0.5037375092506409, -0.4043187201023102, 0.22000181674957275, 0.10597237199544907, -0.32131728529930115, 0.16487669944763184, 0.4221293032169342, 0.5745927095413208, 0.0993647500872612, -0.797113835811615, 0.22513706982135773, 0.287171870470047, -0.36794033646583557, -0.14502470195293427, 0.005955225322395563, 0.05893109366297722, 0.2772180140018463, 0.06187046691775322, 0.7434996962547302, 0.08525793254375458, -0.5122266411781311, 0.32801496982574463, 0.27000194787979126, -0.13080061972141266, -0.22444048523902893, 0.5760457515716553, -0.04311690479516983, -0.2964191436767578, 0.8675428628921509, -0.22413495182991028, -0.358530730009079, 0.6646439433097839, 0.955155074596405, 0.732340931892395, -0.0191230159252882, 0.2834639549255371, 0.4248868227005005, 0.321467787027359, -0.18267099559307098, 0.14194785058498383, -0.035241998732089996, -0.6749663949012756, -0.5557692646980286, -0.3769582211971283, -0.21350005269050598, 0.09495453536510468, -0.5432755351066589, 0.1757015585899353, -0.29157960414886475, -0.13194984197616577, -0.12885934114456177, -0.14332038164138794, -0.4002094268798828, 0.12997908890247345, 0.06483255326747894, 0.6178010702133179, -0.866911768913269, 1.325147271156311, 0.6882814764976501, -0.41231924295425415, -0.43588966131210327, 0.16963133215904236, -0.26937633752822876, -0.40386879444122314, 0.8268835544586182, 0.2594192922115326, -0.005702114664018154, -0.03697632625699043, -0.10200120508670807, -0.9459996223449707, 0.7427518367767334, 0.7307689189910889, -0.5730406045913696, 0.0017548464238643646, 0.7170534729957581, 0.8697816133499146, -0.3291133940219879, -0.28589820861816406, 0.33583012223243713, 0.37327808141708374, -0.09822627156972885, -0.9409303665161133, 0.0035480211954563856, -0.45143255591392517, 0.013688976876437664, 0.1493133157491684, -0.48298701643943787, 0.9127563238143921, -0.13685262203216553, -0.17501792311668396, 0.272977739572525, 0.5517533421516418, 0.22714810073375702, 0.17048810422420502, 0.3666682839393616, 0.5136977434158325, 0.6600468754768372, 0.019209181889891624, 1.2480930089950562, -0.4585697650909424, -0.08377671986818314, 1.2558751106262207, -0.2782529294490814, 0.9237378239631653, 0.7495540380477905, 0.28319114446640015, 0.28483569622039795, 0.5387778282165527, -0.29413777589797974, 0.7475671172142029, 0.2161269634962082, -0.2799545228481293, -0.3074318766593933, -0.2567771077156067, -0.30040106177330017, 0.5286343097686768, 0.16402505338191986, -0.5527166128158569, -0.10783998668193817, 0.3211352527141571, -0.057040538638830185, 0.3992576003074646, 0.05730016529560089, 0.3342902958393097, 0.14841988682746887, -1.0754504203796387, 1.0481358766555786, 0.19503161311149597, 0.516295313835144, -0.3011488616466522, -0.14134453237056732, -0.2095162719488144, 0.4507814943790436, -0.1754714399576187, -0.22083981335163116, 0.7200853824615479, 0.10991469025611877, -0.30985432863235474, -0.41712889075279236, 0.4210844039916992, -0.5712542533874512, -0.4468688666820526, 0.35843169689178467, 0.7138901352882385, 0.31226807832717896, -0.31645166873931885, -0.6226627826690674, -0.22823956608772278, -0.13663506507873535, 0.12051495909690857, 0.5845934748649597, 0.15139727294445038, -0.30589383840560913, 0.21083346009254456, 0.9446591734886169, 0.29610106348991394, 0.2925582528114319, -0.2239772081375122, 0.6885546445846558, -0.4866533577442169, -0.13878418505191803, -0.6477657556533813, 0.20259997248649597, -0.13782541453838348, -0.376068651676178, 1.0412349700927734, 0.7714571952819824, 1.1908040046691895, -0.20311737060546875, 0.9073389768600464, 0.11149119585752487, 0.24275287985801697, -0.6185295581817627, 0.6641622185707092, -0.4558661878108978, 0.01378061156719923, 0.23351648449897766, -1.1264464855194092, -0.40597862005233765, 0.4692322611808777, -0.3285829722881317, -0.04646913707256317, 1.0619821548461914, 1.0831023454666138, -0.037187784910202026, -0.23386602103710175, 0.3812023103237152, 0.09305029362440109, 0.0877511203289032, 0.5998319387435913, 0.5996053814888, -0.5628957748413086, 0.7426314949989319, -0.49704742431640625, 0.24151496589183807, 0.09922800213098526, -0.5008929967880249, -1.03401780128479, -0.4018703103065491, -0.2325960248708725, -0.44997134804725647, 0.1409233957529068, 0.9840049147605896, 0.8033620119094849, -1.089613437652588, -0.2982460558414459, -0.3807300627231598, -0.3350065052509308, -0.46420910954475403, -0.10812604427337646, 0.2023649513721466, -0.8369614481925964, -1.1637120246887207, 1.1466244459152222, 0.0023201536387205124, 0.21953243017196655, -0.026705201715230942, -0.2379222959280014, -0.1053314357995987, 0.043945346027612686, 0.4784936308860779, 0.25216370820999146, -0.510108470916748, 0.0037064291536808014, 0.573313295841217, -0.2821020483970642, 0.17511115968227386, 0.8464280366897583, -0.7426632642745972, 0.46466264128685, 0.5142303705215454, 0.8946399688720703, 0.5319558382034302, -0.1692461222410202, 0.7976841926574707, -0.8557519316673279, 0.5015076994895935, 0.22919577360153198, 0.21370646357536316, 0.37956297397613525, -0.4337935149669647, 0.42004814743995667, 0.3964087665081024, -0.13521002233028412, -0.6272411346435547, 0.05195850133895874, -0.7095831632614136, -0.30460938811302185, 1.2995463609695435, -0.2058737725019455, -0.2587703466415405, -0.08620825409889221, -0.055536672472953796, 0.5268257260322571, -0.2545936107635498, 0.8890640139579773, 0.4688830077648163, -0.12008495628833771, 0.2970563769340515, -0.8149769306182861, 0.55571049451828, 0.8964523673057556, -0.7148970365524292, -0.29557478427886963, 0.38358062505722046, 0.12488606572151184, 0.28039810061454773, 0.2779865562915802, -0.1400928497314453, 0.2365720421075821, 0.18709255754947662, -0.12616202235221863, -0.11213435232639313, -0.5612441897392273, -0.25108757615089417, 0.08206263929605484, -0.18004007637500763, -0.37476056814193726 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16078v1	http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16078v1	Understanding the effects of word-level linguistic annotations in under-resourced neural machine translation	2024-01-29T11:39:46	2024-01-29T11:39:46	Víctor M. Sánchez-Cartagena, Juan Antonio Pérez-Ortiz, Felipe Sánchez-Martínez	cs.CL	cs.CL	This paper studies the effects of word-level linguistic annotations in under-resourced neural machine translation, for which there is incomplete evidence in the literature. The study covers eight language pairs, different training corpus sizes, two architectures, and three types of annotation: dummy tags (with no linguistic information at all), part-of-speech tags, and morpho-syntactic description tags, which consist of part of speech and morphological features. These linguistic annotations are interleaved in the input or output streams as a single tag placed before each word. In order to measure the performance under each scenario, we use automatic evaluation metrics and perform automatic error classification. Our experiments show that, in general, source-language annotations are helpful and morpho-syntactic descriptions outperform part of speech for some language pairs. On the contrary, when words are annotated in the target language, part-of-speech tags systematically outperform morpho-syntactic description tags in terms of automatic evaluation metrics, even though the use of morpho-syntactic description tags improves the grammaticality of the output. We provide a detailed analysis of the reasons behind this result.	[ -0.39570510387420654, -0.4589683711528778, 0.3095432221889496, 0.41761553287506104, -0.6436774134635925, 0.0743618756532669, -0.27619150280952454, -0.49141669273376465, 0.3632623255252838, 0.3200576603412628, -0.18466222286224365, -0.302779883146286, -0.6924504041671753, 0.40174761414527893, -0.5880661010742188, 1.2396049499511719, -0.05517302453517914, 0.37230703234672546, -0.21982885897159576, -0.18508891761302948, -0.5389708876609802, -0.8099732995033264, -0.43879273533821106, -0.5555886030197144, 0.6456583738327026, -0.20522336661815643, 0.656000554561615, 0.7268898487091064, 0.6415442824363708, 0.3013741374015808, -0.2667640447616577, 0.19058002531528473, 0.07894691824913025, -0.010405170731246471, 0.044974856078624725, -0.39375609159469604, -0.7221282124519348, -0.005799117498099804, 0.8808216452598572, 0.7075865864753723, 0.3621089458465576, 0.18532228469848633, 0.12558513879776, 0.395901083946228, -0.5542134642601013, 0.4363389313220978, -0.6279939413070679, 0.17285016179084778, -0.3780060410499573, -0.28970688581466675, -0.16825532913208008, -0.06489637494087219, -0.020679928362369537, -0.44585952162742615, -0.09905695170164108, -0.0020043582189828157, 0.7664948105812073, 0.6544196605682373, 0.03967399522662163, -0.16886648535728455, -0.541316032409668, 0.5599783062934875, -0.8931870460510254, -0.12354616820812225, 0.5326521992683411, -0.06012250855565071, -0.06976690143346786, -0.30800238251686096, -0.6171027421951294, -0.20947736501693726, -0.6388428211212158, 0.1277991682291031, -0.04500983655452728, 0.4005506932735443, 0.3246098756790161, 0.36911541223526, -0.205897256731987, 0.30970320105552673, -0.3108420670032501, -0.41319727897644043, 0.6557918190956116, -0.05218662694096565, 0.523699939250946, -0.508052408695221, -0.32523113489151, -0.002136902417987585, -0.5581101179122925, -0.284014493227005, 0.4060088098049164, 0.4182119071483612, 0.061505917459726334, 0.7806954383850098, -0.2004573941230774, 0.4357263445854187, -0.427479088306427, 0.08058293163776398, 0.6572350263595581, -0.535954475402832, -0.11602023243904114, 0.2575756907463074, 1.0706385374069214, 0.24334223568439484, 0.44855988025665283, -0.49510857462882996, -0.6101540327072144, 0.1398768126964569, 0.23859186470508575, -0.4975925087928772, 0.09497429430484772, 0.015557910315692425, -0.21747562289237976, -0.06461507827043533, -0.07287643849849701, -0.4757652282714844, -0.32984983921051025, -0.053331002593040466, 0.5824370384216309, -0.4601166546344757, -0.20762501657009125, -0.095087930560112, -0.28452128171920776, -0.10933254659175873, 0.07846685498952866, -0.7742551565170288, 0.23429393768310547, 0.5641603469848633, 0.9875702261924744, -0.05120072886347771, -0.39287957549095154, -0.33040934801101685, -0.2140076905488968, -0.32259151339530945, 0.7544574737548828, -0.4748418629169464, -0.20827744901180267, 0.11665116995573044, -0.15403228998184204, -0.4545046389102936, -0.4642871022224426, 0.5306782126426697, -0.4021590054035187, 0.2242712825536728, -0.23767916858196259, -0.5222095847129822, -0.3800238072872162, -0.031336020678281784, -0.5412256717681885, 0.8205713033676147, -0.10774173587560654, -0.8407834768295288, 0.30546221137046814, -0.8990437388420105, -0.5668191313743591, 0.2939739525318146, -0.18377839028835297, 0.037923961877822876, 0.5796512961387634, 0.12266002595424652, 0.45686599612236023, 0.08940766751766205, -0.04643245041370392, 0.16369695961475372, -0.5478752255439758, 0.6246562600135803, -0.3225916624069214, 0.496320903301239, 0.07038846611976624, -0.530953586101532, 0.04343100264668465, -0.5880870819091797, 0.1056387722492218, 0.1196589544415474, -0.5619512796401978, -0.5326615571975708, 0.02743631787598133, 0.06351345032453537, 0.26585641503334045, 0.11236845701932907, -0.7558977007865906, 0.21031810343265533, -0.6750330924987793, 0.4205573499202728, 0.15830840170383453, -0.03785004839301109, 0.49489936232566833, 0.025048399344086647, 0.5468313694000244, 0.03997214138507843, -0.09559204429388046, -0.17020723223686218, -0.6019036173820496, -0.891337513923645, -0.0035851444117724895, 0.792555570602417, 0.42731088399887085, -0.9823254346847534, 0.33087024092674255, -0.30246636271476746, -0.20994898676872253, -1.0755574703216553, 0.04803251847624779, 0.8500818014144897, 0.2825941741466522, 0.6173294186592102, -0.47510576248168945, -0.32101091742515564, -1.2005176544189453, -0.23116132616996765, -0.30905359983444214, 0.05141787976026535, -0.1539795994758606, 0.5341843366622925, -0.14578397572040558, 0.48178717494010925, 0.0380358062684536, -0.4323422908782959, -0.18546918034553528, 0.4723260998725891, -0.2364766001701355, 0.4715595543384552, 0.41106000542640686, -0.5226193070411682, -0.027143768966197968, 0.06548997014760971, -0.44056233763694763, -0.47558727860450745, -0.21371445059776306, 0.10086779296398163, 0.43355587124824524, 0.303922176361084, -0.6989927291870117, 0.4912905693054199, 0.6029341816902161, 0.03511577844619751, 0.22692713141441345, -0.3823353350162506, 0.17055220901966095, -0.68076092004776, 0.038958221673965454, 0.0061115240678191185, 0.1384529173374176, -0.45512041449546814, 0.03877776488661766, 0.0627409815788269, 0.3330870270729065, -0.3763344883918762, 0.472311407327652, -0.4679594933986664, -0.29279011487960815, -0.6204925775527954, 0.47665587067604065, -0.13587740063667297, 0.5274860262870789, 0.02367953397333622, 0.6899511814117432, 0.12111461162567139, -0.22286368906497955, 0.09371916204690933, -0.0491921566426754, -0.15524671971797943, 0.09944433718919754, -0.5558796525001526, 0.09012466669082642, -0.07146228104829788, 0.1144525557756424, -1.0069446563720703, -0.18498773872852325, 0.5488883852958679, -0.7014392018318176, 0.5325134992599487, -0.22156529128551483, -1.0528723001480103, -0.029721146449446678, -0.017810296267271042, 0.36258551478385925, 0.47093451023101807, 0.006107344292104244, 0.1797855794429779, 0.3920823633670807, 0.12327511608600616, -0.36726686358451843, -1.115165114402771, 0.18500280380249023, -0.08766938745975494, -0.20040880143642426, 0.33792775869369507, 0.25768396258354187, -0.2796517312526703, 0.08332780003547668, -0.01504237949848175, -0.12272997945547104, 0.329830527305603, 0.4261135458946228, -0.0022967460099607706, -0.279849648475647, 0.424317866563797, 0.13877254724502563, -0.27782461047172546, 0.2717639207839966, -0.21295572817325592, 0.554041862487793, -0.2441680133342743, -0.30604493618011475, -0.540756344795227, 0.19497187435626984, 0.28519538044929504, -0.38257476687431335, 0.8289069533348083, 0.9144476056098938, -0.5242748856544495, -0.022018058225512505, -0.3581424653530121, 0.05044710263609886, -0.2731412947177887, 0.548770010471344, -0.17811253666877747, -0.45457014441490173, 0.3767174184322357, 0.3259364366531372, 0.06130020320415497, 0.9542801380157471, 0.28126636147499084, -0.3452979326248169, 0.9389154314994812, 0.2880994379520416, 0.06081207096576691, 0.333292156457901, -0.15616139769554138, -0.04528288543224335, -1.0453249216079712, -0.2534424364566803, -0.5632334351539612, -0.5247265100479126, -0.7122695446014404, -0.43616029620170593, 0.12375707179307938, 0.21018962562084198, 0.218507319688797, 0.5152581930160522, -0.5197323560714722, 0.18732917308807373, 0.5151432752609253, -0.26586318016052246, 0.18392688035964966, 0.009798466227948666, -0.06624247133731842, -0.2836076021194458, -0.7244893908500671, -0.6433207392692566, 0.6369999647140503, 0.3197217583656311, 0.30362436175346375, -0.21934905648231506, 0.6359273791313171, 0.28822675347328186, 0.31730231642723083, -0.8826314806938171, 0.5633458495140076, -0.32209715247154236, -0.5143982768058777, -0.06912034004926682, -0.43582677841186523, -0.7148856520652771, 0.5033370852470398, -0.3261644244194031, -0.5896778106689453, -0.1493605524301529, 0.2605266869068146, -0.29763486981391907, 0.17058555781841278, -0.9491793513298035, 0.7580797076225281, -0.5298517942428589, 0.2421555072069168, -0.25608187913894653, -0.49489545822143555, -0.00611915485933423, -0.3101740777492523, 0.14903026819229126, -0.04463127627968788, -0.38886040449142456, 0.9215878248214722, -0.27670878171920776, 0.7042081356048584, -0.2574421763420105, 0.08054126054048538, 0.16272379457950592, -0.08416711539030075, -0.039474815130233765, -0.30093154311180115, 0.13610069453716278, 0.6329777240753174, -0.06406526267528534, -0.17378677427768707, -0.5259726047515869, 0.6031283736228943, -0.5904538035392761, -0.5027140378952026, -0.41276443004608154, -0.6666630506515503, -0.11933504790067673, 0.17915159463882446, 0.35822975635528564, 0.40419521927833557, 0.39844584465026855, 0.1940753310918808, 0.3347468674182892, -0.3457535207271576, 0.6667515635490417, 0.08495046198368073, -0.25535058975219727, -0.3912030756473541, 0.8161556124687195, 0.5806434750556946, 0.20338723063468933, 0.5042821764945984, 0.07932789623737335, -0.23430581390857697, -0.9728080630302429, -0.6950691342353821, 0.3416075110435486, -0.6393043398857117, -0.10803871601819992, -0.6967256665229797, -0.3340258002281189, -0.14102232456207275, 0.2664812505245209, -0.37710654735565186, -0.7641075849533081, -0.18781791627407074, -0.014128818176686764, 0.09350408613681793, 0.8379324078559875, 0.1202760711312294, 0.5618575811386108, -0.7054309844970703, -0.04634350165724754, -0.3415399491786957, 0.15297167003154755, -0.032717715948820114, -0.6101046204566956, -0.6477640867233276, 0.22884555160999298, 0.0004122231330256909, -0.8188979029655457, 0.1268712282180786, 0.17211273312568665, 0.5018338561058044, -0.06756877899169922, -0.185276597738266, 0.6557143926620483, -0.5074250102043152, 0.820340096950531, 0.06927233934402466, -0.8892073035240173, 0.3799385726451874, -0.21184054017066956, 0.5825000405311584, 0.27127352356910706, 0.28737834095954895, -0.46623969078063965, -0.5044695138931274, -0.441148579120636, -1.0755798816680908, 0.6770380735397339, 0.43352869153022766, 0.3170023560523987, -0.25023698806762695, 0.4019511342048645, 0.03129969537258148, 0.3684324622154236, -0.7542697191238403, -0.36648911237716675, -0.19623754918575287, -0.03891359642148018, -0.10509481281042099, -0.3292815089225769, 0.06753197312355042, -0.042133256793022156, 0.8632067441940308, -0.06702768057584763, 0.1624130755662918, 0.26201608777046204, -0.34541982412338257, -0.08688788115978241, 0.2514665126800537, 0.6744835376739502, 0.4500107765197754, -0.04639296978712082, 0.1642458438873291, 0.14773517847061157, -0.2114223688840866, -0.3206515610218048, 0.37114110589027405, -0.3532017767429352, 0.4737709164619446, 0.7262808680534363, 0.7848930358886719, 0.288542240858078, -0.3743445873260498, 0.4375300109386444, 0.1299535036087036, 0.10173220187425613, -0.14374211430549622, -0.0008524669101461768, 0.18286925554275513, 0.19857434928417206, 0.30480214953422546, 0.15785950422286987, 0.0032103448174893856, -0.24138322472572327, -0.17627117037773132, 0.3629751205444336, -0.3749913275241852, -0.6786967515945435, 0.524291455745697, 0.1720823049545288, -0.41415902972221375, 0.3036987781524658, -0.2601637542247772, -0.6339954137802124, 0.2603493928909302, 0.26695021986961365, 0.9589398503303528, 0.12465032190084457, 0.1619502454996109, 0.150889590382576, 0.6150600910186768, 0.09467899799346924, -0.025793837383389473, -0.15272203087806702, -0.3316372334957123, -0.7032064199447632, -0.8944612145423889, 0.05403037741780281, 0.13364282250404358, -0.5267103314399719, -0.19030755758285522, -0.24815665185451508, -0.5311721563339233, 0.278270959854126, -0.08394758403301239, -0.5906286239624023, 0.18808981776237488, 0.5847258567810059, 0.6974931359291077, -0.6702908277511597, 0.8340376019477844, 1.0936983823776245, -0.8623735904693604, -0.4809674620628357, 0.08706120401620865, -0.1994672566652298, -0.7888292074203491, 1.0183314085006714, 0.09589409828186035, -0.12304908037185669, -0.22703783214092255, -0.07055218517780304, -0.7694924473762512, 0.5622137188911438, 0.3817470669746399, -0.36821791529655457, -0.15977513790130615, 0.5347859263420105, 1.0241765975952148, -0.37423115968704224, 0.1792585402727127, 0.26163312792778015, 0.41399601101875305, -0.24359366297721863, -1.2746800184249878, -0.038560979068279266, -0.20724917948246002, 0.2200804352760315, 0.3700738847255707, -0.37633252143859863, 0.6034387946128845, 0.1863027811050415, -0.38762471079826355, 0.2372971475124359, 0.5507820844650269, -0.3898070156574249, 0.049277178943157196, 0.4358521103858948, 0.44262486696243286, 0.1453908234834671, -0.31015530228614807, 1.0984066724777222, -0.18542280793190002, 0.19027626514434814, 1.0495622158050537, 0.33150601387023926, 0.9563741683959961, 0.6685758829116821, 0.08189060539007187, 0.21178244054317474, 0.5801098346710205, 0.0826645940542221, 0.2895784378051758, 0.45447760820388794, 0.026623331010341644, -0.007354681845754385, -0.3857612609863281, -0.35269930958747864, 0.4594320058822632, 0.3562594950199127, -0.7561215758323669, -0.18051598966121674, -0.1203581914305687, 0.16506336629390717, 0.05181293934583664, -0.35834625363349915, 0.839777946472168, 0.22012855112552643, -0.6560183167457581, 0.6148757934570312, 0.054498009383678436, 0.7914381623268127, -0.4508659839630127, 0.025978798046708107, -0.31980714201927185, 0.056705113500356674, -0.46951404213905334, -0.7093120217323303, 0.5070341229438782, 0.1744004786014557, -0.0913042202591896, -0.35294094681739807, 0.6364393830299377, -0.5229001045227051, -0.3967622220516205, 0.4555775821208954, 0.5952206254005432, 0.48449841141700745, -0.26065242290496826, -0.506155252456665, 0.13674333691596985, -0.21878623962402344, -0.1952957808971405, 0.3266665041446686, 0.6177030801773071, -0.08327259123325348, 0.2858556807041168, 0.19872990250587463, 0.6119946241378784, 0.34551915526390076, 0.11363034695386887, 0.4861954152584076, -0.5326517820358276, -0.011593657545745373, -0.9288238883018494, 0.5894672870635986, -0.0033162408508360386, -0.4439443349838257, 0.8491091132164001, 0.30470821261405945, 1.2540653944015503, -0.044561732560396194, 0.6375661492347717, 0.013608724810183048, 0.10668042302131653, -0.526294469833374, 0.7656236886978149, -0.6208741068840027, 0.2122892141342163, -0.23036810755729675, -1.0316181182861328, -0.3664300739765167, 0.33563366532325745, -0.49989423155784607, -0.023150326684117317, 0.7126041054725647, 0.28792116045951843, 0.23982593417167664, -0.1788599193096161, 0.37032273411750793, 0.19047972559928894, -0.04066023230552673, 0.13661058247089386, 0.9255382418632507, -0.49388083815574646, 0.5913365483283997, -0.5121171474456787, 0.09073757380247116, 0.030900903046131134, -0.6822136044502258, -0.7625463604927063, -0.6599343419075012, -0.4951435923576355, -0.186895951628685, 0.0440046526491642, 0.8417007923126221, 0.44634485244750977, -0.653213381767273, -0.014726892113685608, 0.2543451488018036, -0.12600481510162354, 0.012131229043006897, -0.18083767592906952, 0.2504720091819763, -0.734607994556427, -0.7040783166885376, 0.2508806884288788, 0.37821388244628906, 0.042510952800512314, -0.3692741096019745, 0.15033920109272003, -0.16048435866832733, -0.1808236539363861, 0.45980924367904663, -0.0685330256819725, -1.0833196640014648, -0.2677624523639679, -0.4396153390407562, -0.12153550237417221, 0.04710507020354271, 0.5469809770584106, -0.6099655032157898, 0.4174515902996063, 0.434641569852829, 0.911986768245697, -0.03757145255804062, -0.03386417776346207, 0.4011664390563965, -0.9598585367202759, 0.09085720777511597, 0.1835847795009613, 0.5740260481834412, 0.5837313532829285, -0.14483678340911865, 0.4865720570087433, 0.3224520981311798, -0.34118252992630005, -0.7513802647590637, -0.0659850463271141, -0.6514264941215515, -0.08554960787296295, 1.3594003915786743, -0.32430925965309143, -0.29670265316963196, 0.246572345495224, -0.12598641216754913, 0.5086715221405029, -0.320965051651001, 0.739476203918457, 0.9542542695999146, -0.0018513869727030396, 0.17571844160556793, -0.8401047587394714, 0.5187655091285706, 0.47081366181373596, -0.47059014439582825, -0.1110035851597786, 0.5477844476699829, -0.1611822545528412, 0.696735143661499, 0.40277764201164246, -0.2271541953086853, 0.020224783569574356, 0.02349277399480343, 0.06553013622760773, -0.1410277783870697, -0.15155895054340363, -0.4836983382701874, 0.008544459007680416, 0.19616247713565826, -0.6913015246391296 ]

Subsets and Splits