id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16055v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16055v1 | Stolen Subwords: Importance of Vocabularies for Machine Translation Model Stealing | 2024-01-29T11:04:01 | 2024-01-29T11:04:01 | Vilém Zouhar | cs.CL | cs.CL | In learning-based functionality stealing, the attacker is trying to build a
local model based on the victim's outputs. The attacker has to make choices
regarding the local model's architecture, optimization method and, specifically
for NLP models, subword vocabulary, such as BPE. On the machine translation
task, we explore (1) whether the choice of the vocabulary plays a role in model
stealing scenarios and (2) if it is possible to extract the victim's
vocabulary. We find that the vocabulary itself does not have a large effect on
the local model's performance. Given gray-box model access, it is possible to
collect the victim's vocabulary by collecting the outputs (detokenized subwords
on the output). The results of the minimum effect of vocabulary choice are
important more broadly for black-box knowledge distillation. | [
-0.3245429992675781,
-0.8715391755104065,
0.1945732682943344,
-0.29225173592567444,
-0.42918720841407776,
-0.0020715727005153894,
0.4799000918865204,
-0.7143985033035278,
0.03666675090789795,
0.7218464612960815,
-0.29937979578971863,
0.04977358132600784,
-0.9751372337341309,
-0.03062734194099903,
-0.8777610659599304,
1.0406110286712646,
0.17185230553150177,
-0.004121543373912573,
-0.05340394005179405,
0.1601244956254959,
-0.62676602602005,
-0.9293138384819031,
-0.5957077741622925,
-0.5089787840843201,
0.5566803812980652,
-0.1512819230556488,
0.7428811192512512,
0.5758801698684692,
0.6207902431488037,
0.3466900885105133,
-0.25332731008529663,
-0.2695482671260834,
-0.566800594329834,
-0.0674389973282814,
-0.5883653163909912,
-0.9221397638320923,
-0.23735247552394867,
-0.0758095309138298,
-0.061876408755779266,
0.3773640990257263,
-0.09561994671821594,
0.30016300082206726,
-0.16983662545681,
0.8369497060775757,
-0.6555083990097046,
-0.003038642229512334,
-1.0183855295181274,
0.10752362012863159,
-0.2801576256752014,
-0.29271185398101807,
-0.16479669511318207,
0.055211931467056274,
0.4037759602069855,
-0.3018955886363983,
0.42454537749290466,
-0.24245934188365936,
0.899350643157959,
0.3218497335910797,
-0.18678374588489532,
-0.4115366041660309,
-0.67188960313797,
0.8749273419380188,
-0.5518990159034729,
0.1652023196220398,
0.6294397711753845,
0.2771937847137451,
-0.2747899889945984,
-0.7442046403884888,
-0.44148576259613037,
0.04605093598365784,
-0.1098979040980339,
0.1485995650291443,
-0.46177196502685547,
-0.00024557867436669767,
0.2165115773677826,
0.5523346066474915,
-0.11189636588096619,
0.1537351906299591,
-1.068320870399475,
-0.19233731925487518,
0.6210355162620544,
-0.05599844455718994,
0.49116265773773193,
-0.49900999665260315,
-0.5717381238937378,
0.1286882907152176,
-0.7773314714431763,
0.008807153441011906,
0.42137131094932556,
0.2539941370487213,
-0.0009099991875700653,
0.8091946244239807,
0.11543340235948563,
0.6744968891143799,
-0.20377345383167267,
-0.376083642244339,
0.3495347201824188,
-0.4631408751010895,
-0.40325531363487244,
0.12949785590171814,
0.4806112051010132,
0.055672578513622284,
0.3028974235057831,
-0.309126615524292,
-0.2728741765022278,
-0.12929323315620422,
0.8859859108924866,
-0.5689199566841125,
-0.04389023408293724,
0.5580230951309204,
-0.5384343862533569,
-0.3874747157096863,
0.0547669343650341,
-0.680141270160675,
-0.27130818367004395,
-0.2570570707321167,
0.44613680243492126,
-0.3694204092025757,
-0.36562690138816833,
0.14619606733322144,
-0.761990487575531,
0.3619672358036041,
0.06229887902736664,
-0.7992253303527832,
0.08289998024702072,
0.7565420269966125,
1.043515920639038,
-0.17024311423301697,
-0.2524377405643463,
-0.34064704179763794,
-0.02609732560813427,
-0.44720056653022766,
0.3950051963329315,
-0.17428705096244812,
-0.7311795949935913,
0.019538553431630135,
0.21328948438167572,
0.07633691281080246,
-0.7170754075050354,
0.22775544226169586,
-0.5239901542663574,
-0.05523586645722389,
-0.304688960313797,
-0.5488719344139099,
-0.4258989095687866,
-0.09218712151050568,
-0.6610043048858643,
0.8782122135162354,
0.08066908270120621,
-0.7014642953872681,
0.35481518507003784,
-0.5695726275444031,
-0.5912840366363525,
0.2968084216117859,
0.006771850399672985,
-0.2778994143009186,
0.6721929907798767,
-0.06577172130346298,
0.5824557542800903,
0.0897870808839798,
-0.1154526025056839,
-0.16967755556106567,
-0.11572233587503433,
0.32606765627861023,
-0.2853796184062958,
0.9878973960876465,
0.3059791028499603,
-0.3224509656429291,
-0.415842205286026,
-0.47897398471832275,
-0.3027742803096771,
0.2999171316623688,
-0.3078823387622833,
-0.7308685183525085,
0.24451568722724915,
-0.11352380365133286,
0.17024348676204681,
0.41065987944602966,
-0.6091729998588562,
-0.09853854775428772,
-0.6079249978065491,
0.33361393213272095,
0.5628129243850708,
0.2308264672756195,
0.3597548305988312,
-0.4168185889720917,
0.7427027821540833,
0.1751890480518341,
0.23546066880226135,
0.26546043157577515,
-0.5621123313903809,
-0.40587908029556274,
-0.5246357321739197,
0.6202018857002258,
0.8063715696334839,
-0.8623859882354736,
0.044213905930519104,
0.1033082827925682,
-0.7099059224128723,
-0.6970346570014954,
0.3465729057788849,
0.4370592534542084,
0.2782546877861023,
0.38395920395851135,
-0.3454698622226715,
-0.5551337003707886,
-1.0949043035507202,
-0.2530301809310913,
0.016667602583765984,
0.17520946264266968,
0.09738769382238388,
0.748005747795105,
-0.20552223920822144,
0.9576813578605652,
-0.4006190299987793,
-0.648661732673645,
-0.5845434665679932,
0.055877309292554855,
-0.10502529889345169,
0.30199581384658813,
1.0219968557357788,
-1.0591503381729126,
-0.2139499932527542,
0.0010211932240054011,
-0.7615849375724792,
-0.13492035865783691,
-0.09489292651414871,
-0.25494423508644104,
0.14364391565322876,
0.6856101751327515,
-0.6637789011001587,
0.6878438591957092,
0.4997987449169159,
0.08211607486009598,
0.5669881105422974,
-0.09240646660327911,
-0.40712738037109375,
-1.4072128534317017,
0.0735708549618721,
-0.22841480374336243,
-0.15280579030513763,
-0.677450954914093,
0.38097599148750305,
-0.37279775738716125,
0.09740724414587021,
-1.0099645853042603,
0.6184141635894775,
-0.41400864720344543,
-0.15149638056755066,
-0.4877265393733978,
0.3026486039161682,
-0.22841159999370575,
0.21997825801372528,
0.0477055162191391,
0.6245144605636597,
0.502181887626648,
-0.6432645916938782,
0.30977383255958557,
-0.006923303008079529,
-0.45763880014419556,
0.32747310400009155,
-0.7818686962127686,
0.05026110261678696,
-0.162766233086586,
-0.5193833708763123,
-0.6148905158042908,
0.040028806775808334,
0.03501688688993454,
-0.5092935562133789,
0.4738677144050598,
-0.29485249519348145,
-0.28064829111099243,
-0.18489199876785278,
0.047497838735580444,
-0.08193519711494446,
0.4227198660373688,
-0.25175711512565613,
0.5266565680503845,
0.8932309746742249,
-0.07041770219802856,
-0.9912384748458862,
-0.8603295683860779,
0.0103137893602252,
-0.24453359842300415,
0.06984146684408188,
0.29178881645202637,
0.23226121068000793,
-0.3523963391780853,
0.09727343171834946,
-0.2517484426498413,
0.05148090049624443,
0.7010982036590576,
0.19000665843486786,
0.16178174316883087,
0.30754637718200684,
0.17006532847881317,
0.03929125890135765,
-0.03917379304766655,
0.07660885155200958,
-0.15476511418819427,
0.6715440154075623,
0.0747586265206337,
-0.0724017545580864,
-0.04857148230075836,
0.671413004398346,
0.4626735746860504,
-0.3839986324310303,
0.7975444793701172,
0.3661614656448364,
-0.46980831027030945,
-0.24425996840000153,
-0.16908836364746094,
-0.07083384692668915,
-0.45785483717918396,
0.8644506335258484,
-0.4621087312698364,
-0.6855350136756897,
0.41849541664123535,
0.17700304090976715,
0.2671714723110199,
0.4194130599498749,
0.722735583782196,
-0.16983714699745178,
0.7376130819320679,
0.8291118144989014,
-0.25715258717536926,
0.7430317997932434,
-0.3316127359867096,
0.30232709646224976,
-0.6223800778388977,
-0.006791089195758104,
-0.5687539577484131,
-0.40146973729133606,
-0.6049007773399353,
-0.14771324396133423,
0.20578332245349884,
0.18830549716949463,
0.3727298974990845,
0.6690456867218018,
-0.4536641240119934,
0.4669625163078308,
0.8432233333587646,
-0.04826917126774788,
0.15686339139938354,
0.27906063199043274,
-0.2171563059091568,
0.07531052827835083,
-0.7055500149726868,
-0.5509069561958313,
1.0172381401062012,
0.3062831163406372,
0.5715615749359131,
0.19923222064971924,
0.86189204454422,
0.48472583293914795,
-0.09898838400840759,
-1.0710885524749756,
0.6049699187278748,
-0.22080190479755402,
-0.9415930509567261,
-0.14025941491127014,
-0.39070290327072144,
-1.4833484888076782,
0.34114870429039,
-0.17184489965438843,
-1.0250742435455322,
0.2999863028526306,
-0.03019496239721775,
-0.22880224883556366,
0.19681645929813385,
-0.8922780156135559,
0.7816065549850464,
-0.3040791451931,
0.18361154198646545,
-0.27288854122161865,
-0.3421362340450287,
0.24037840962409973,
-0.13395221531391144,
0.1898491233587265,
0.1726367175579071,
0.12686090171337128,
0.7283425331115723,
-0.4308147132396698,
1.0011066198349,
-0.1293201595544815,
0.051637452095746994,
0.5003786683082581,
0.4620918333530426,
0.18500426411628723,
-0.23837009072303772,
0.34065625071525574,
0.6115763783454895,
0.5081559419631958,
-0.5270225405693054,
-0.4118916094303131,
0.1463373601436615,
-0.8061305284500122,
-0.9101009368896484,
-0.49603909254074097,
-0.3770941495895386,
0.11094081401824951,
0.34750548005104065,
0.6694299578666687,
0.4509778916835785,
0.02626155875623226,
0.6045297384262085,
0.4434848725795746,
-0.07971002906560898,
0.5717273354530334,
0.22655406594276428,
-0.39385509490966797,
-0.10825269669294357,
0.9018014073371887,
0.4946267306804657,
0.4686834216117859,
0.5480044484138489,
0.23465469479560852,
-0.03388978913426399,
-0.7723719477653503,
-0.2766278088092804,
0.18803425133228302,
-0.6206774115562439,
-0.1535845249891281,
-0.5789185166358948,
-0.3291796147823334,
0.016703467816114426,
-0.21663159132003784,
-0.4003889858722687,
-0.5009589791297913,
-0.30688267946243286,
-0.4470767676830292,
0.16783952713012695,
0.5755576491355896,
-0.04040924459695816,
0.3605826497077942,
-0.9762938618659973,
0.36626964807510376,
0.37555164098739624,
-0.39435842633247375,
-0.03624590113759041,
-0.42082974314689636,
-0.5467076897621155,
-0.04244653880596161,
-0.33691903948783875,
-1.1789684295654297,
0.5720037221908569,
-0.16095057129859924,
0.821932315826416,
0.19698338210582733,
-0.10317759960889816,
0.39122000336647034,
-0.26191672682762146,
0.837577760219574,
0.035755980759859085,
-0.9747925400733948,
0.6185286045074463,
-0.044429436326026917,
0.3239314556121826,
0.24336202442646027,
0.5281683802604675,
-0.43164998292922974,
-0.512470543384552,
-0.7841320633888245,
-0.8946870565414429,
0.5509654879570007,
0.05773711949586868,
0.27673909068107605,
-0.11676260083913803,
0.4501762390136719,
0.0625763013958931,
0.6044155359268188,
-0.9357941746711731,
-0.2875407338142395,
-0.22234712541103363,
0.017257608473300934,
0.10537676513195038,
-0.32776498794555664,
-0.11297442764043808,
0.07536319643259048,
0.7353249788284302,
-0.07778161019086838,
0.1871308535337448,
0.27832552790641785,
-0.26279231905937195,
0.11508441716432571,
0.18964754045009613,
0.2687884569168091,
0.5611363649368286,
0.06879153102636337,
-0.034895285964012146,
0.14762204885482788,
-0.8142527341842651,
-0.21376921236515045,
-0.1423393338918686,
-0.6154694557189941,
0.09984559565782547,
0.46578067541122437,
0.49795958399772644,
-0.11716772615909576,
-0.7186200618743896,
0.44264501333236694,
0.2689754366874695,
-0.09687601029872894,
-0.3798512816429138,
0.2723665237426758,
-0.050456803292036057,
0.33593958616256714,
0.32994896173477173,
0.27037274837493896,
0.21623679995536804,
-0.7944245934486389,
0.17979305982589722,
0.6566908359527588,
-0.4541018009185791,
-0.3234178125858307,
0.2920602560043335,
-0.22293581068515778,
-0.5438899993896484,
0.24804387986660004,
-0.10646452754735947,
-0.7409355640411377,
0.5395426154136658,
0.4708232283592224,
0.9275947213172913,
-0.2599256634712219,
0.18057569861412048,
0.09514652192592621,
0.6856389045715332,
0.06446972489356995,
0.40306761860847473,
0.04673188924789429,
-0.783687949180603,
-0.2014296054840088,
-0.7215455174446106,
-0.15148919820785522,
0.30590635538101196,
-0.7145326137542725,
0.1646513044834137,
-0.3401646614074707,
-0.47113463282585144,
0.03421904891729355,
-0.22975188493728638,
-0.4533435106277466,
0.16043530404567719,
0.07674983143806458,
0.7604745030403137,
-0.3613382577896118,
0.8394012451171875,
0.5829988718032837,
-0.5608037710189819,
-0.5609741806983948,
-0.4025665819644928,
-0.07142424583435059,
-0.6879380345344543,
0.8821253180503845,
-0.21744687855243683,
-0.08060434460639954,
-0.33155784010887146,
-0.4436990022659302,
-0.8426637053489685,
0.859125018119812,
0.2859354615211487,
-0.4990309774875641,
-0.270525187253952,
0.2145930379629135,
0.6001959443092346,
-0.3070741295814514,
-0.18199026584625244,
0.4784141480922699,
-0.02855369634926319,
-0.10600144416093826,
-0.9133760929107666,
-0.3710591495037079,
0.07271959632635117,
0.08124692738056183,
0.387625128030777,
-0.42668241262435913,
0.8189592957496643,
-0.10126934200525284,
-0.37544652819633484,
-0.13123835623264313,
0.44604548811912537,
-0.040483079850673676,
-0.15806497633457184,
0.3083622455596924,
0.4775489270687103,
0.5215240716934204,
0.013755006715655327,
1.3347951173782349,
-0.04496794566512108,
0.22664502263069153,
1.2195897102355957,
0.07052052021026611,
1.2046446800231934,
0.5529643297195435,
-0.049658916890621185,
0.35312512516975403,
0.36675745248794556,
-0.010832035914063454,
0.6955147385597229,
0.11876621097326279,
0.2280067503452301,
-0.196555495262146,
0.14891250431537628,
-0.26609236001968384,
0.9182759523391724,
0.5889807343482971,
-0.572574257850647,
-0.25116750597953796,
0.014520532451570034,
0.20741230249404907,
-0.13991829752922058,
-0.3660924732685089,
0.9740009307861328,
0.4855135977268219,
-0.534323513507843,
0.43465736508369446,
0.11002367734909058,
0.28921282291412354,
-0.6965023875236511,
0.18789996206760406,
-0.050397761166095734,
0.3622102737426758,
-0.22086171805858612,
-0.2879279553890228,
0.6272081732749939,
-0.08909916877746582,
-0.21904759109020233,
-0.06213108450174332,
0.8965049386024475,
-0.15517666935920715,
-0.46865129470825195,
0.6140516400337219,
0.8715410828590393,
0.1198139414191246,
-0.20110347867012024,
-0.9636433720588684,
-0.4935937225818634,
-0.0889507308602333,
-0.2923416793346405,
0.631541907787323,
0.3055054843425751,
0.025386707857251167,
0.6337150931358337,
0.8354099988937378,
0.4767390191555023,
0.4800669550895691,
-0.2984541356563568,
0.4314642548561096,
-0.5694043040275574,
-0.43205171823501587,
-1.032875895500183,
0.2818603217601776,
-0.004075834061950445,
-0.28188320994377136,
1.0129626989364624,
0.5055186748504639,
1.1076078414916992,
-0.1984606236219406,
0.9931429624557495,
-0.03628301993012428,
0.5959651470184326,
-0.572684109210968,
0.6142024993896484,
-0.8617411851882935,
0.19073721766471863,
-0.2936803698539734,
-0.7250313758850098,
0.19768542051315308,
0.3572300672531128,
-0.3551424443721771,
-0.19680757820606232,
0.6876014471054077,
0.7347398400306702,
0.20314805209636688,
-0.15385718643665314,
0.5176745653152466,
0.25256580114364624,
0.17367178201675415,
0.23938553035259247,
0.6280871629714966,
-0.5651549100875854,
0.6429364681243896,
-0.2046148180961609,
-0.12283238023519516,
-0.11476418375968933,
-0.7102715969085693,
-1.0399924516677856,
-0.6316360831260681,
-0.3321686089038849,
-0.34750616550445557,
-0.20838508009910583,
0.8069973587989807,
0.7267611026763916,
-0.6453713178634644,
-0.2688472270965576,
0.06204814091324806,
0.4386012554168701,
-0.674119234085083,
-0.26494935154914856,
0.08433122932910919,
-0.4274928867816925,
-0.8754494190216064,
0.2968848943710327,
0.36653125286102295,
0.2775701880455017,
-0.38063254952430725,
0.3972800374031067,
-0.3764183521270752,
0.36208078265190125,
0.7979273796081543,
0.20835678279399872,
-0.7886102795600891,
-0.12270460277795792,
0.02016422152519226,
-0.01238952949643135,
-0.19345131516456604,
0.8643866181373596,
-0.7164553999900818,
0.5039654970169067,
0.6078359484672546,
0.7959470152854919,
0.4580208361148834,
-0.09354458749294281,
0.5702051520347595,
-0.8964228630065918,
0.1577247679233551,
0.06487701833248138,
0.7035121917724609,
0.1769871711730957,
-0.41769787669181824,
0.4585925340652466,
0.6643028259277344,
-0.2895309329032898,
-0.8667510151863098,
0.540948212146759,
-0.6955893039703369,
-0.7394808530807495,
1.0958609580993652,
-0.1476464569568634,
-0.5662424564361572,
-0.5852713584899902,
-0.29639673233032227,
-0.0023933968041092157,
-0.13530193269252777,
0.8332025408744812,
0.9406254887580872,
0.3124125301837921,
-0.11646907031536102,
-0.9467930197715759,
0.5398951768875122,
0.26237252354621887,
-0.6042284369468689,
-0.1228557750582695,
0.21824005246162415,
0.1402990221977234,
0.5157093405723572,
0.30113258957862854,
-0.4880222976207733,
0.23683303594589233,
0.10127533227205276,
0.06724441796541214,
-0.16375832259655,
-0.3207729756832123,
-0.10828995704650879,
0.540589451789856,
-0.16517962515354156,
-0.28228381276130676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07909v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07909v1 | Prompt4Vis: Prompting Large Language Models with Example Mining and Schema Filtering for Tabular Data Visualization | 2024-01-29T10:23:47 | 2024-01-29T10:23:47 | Shuaimin Li, Xuanang Chen, Yuanfeng Song, Yunze Song, Chen Zhang | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB | Data visualization (DV) systems are increasingly recognized for their
profound capability to uncover insights from vast datasets, gaining attention
across both industry and academia. Crafting data queries is an essential
process within certain declarative visualization languages (DVLs, e.g.,
Vega-Lite, EChart.). The evolution of natural language processing (NLP)
technologies has streamlined the use of natural language interfaces to
visualize tabular data, offering a more accessible and intuitive user
experience. However, current methods for converting natural language questions
into data visualization queries, such as Seq2Vis, ncNet, and RGVisNet, despite
utilizing complex neural network architectures, still fall short of
expectations and have great room for improvement.
Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and GPT-4, have established new
benchmarks in a variety of NLP tasks, fundamentally altering the landscape of
the field. Inspired by these advancements, we introduce a novel framework,
Prompt4Vis, leveraging LLMs and in-context learning to enhance the performance
of generating data visualization from natural language. Prompt4Vis comprises
two key components: (1) a multi-objective example mining module, designed to
find out the truly effective examples that strengthen the LLM's in-context
learning capabilities for text-to-vis; (2) a schema filtering module, which is
proposed to simplify the schema of the database. Extensive experiments through
5-fold cross-validation on the NVBench dataset demonstrate the superiority of
Prompt4Vis, which notably surpasses the state-of-the-art (SOTA) RGVisNet by
approximately 35.9% and 71.3% on dev and test sets, respectively. To the best
of our knowledge, Prompt4Vis is the first work that introduces in-context
learning into the text-to-vis for generating data visualization queries. | [
-0.25335991382598877,
-0.9535006880760193,
0.7801235318183899,
0.20128411054611206,
-0.3120213449001312,
0.029868990182876587,
-0.15544533729553223,
0.08232424408197403,
0.12346179038286209,
0.7207717895507812,
-0.6363112330436707,
-1.0551801919937134,
-0.09281280636787415,
0.32391923666000366,
-0.40790319442749023,
0.7763264179229736,
0.06133851036429405,
-0.010065962560474873,
-0.6366065740585327,
-0.12597131729125977,
-0.8275400400161743,
-0.3475087285041809,
-0.6118997931480408,
0.1572275310754776,
0.41947343945503235,
0.897605836391449,
0.30270421504974365,
0.5487377643585205,
0.22051872313022614,
0.31132373213768005,
0.16194362938404083,
0.2719253897666931,
-0.5389045476913452,
0.8882249593734741,
0.06808369606733322,
-0.5318069458007812,
-0.18713998794555664,
-0.11579562723636627,
0.5710102915763855,
0.5805973410606384,
-0.26910167932510376,
-0.03240057826042175,
-0.0323324017226696,
0.5743717551231384,
-0.0367831327021122,
0.6138249635696411,
-0.6556926965713501,
-0.03288011997938156,
-0.3636472821235657,
-0.5338180065155029,
-0.49048060178756714,
-0.46341410279273987,
0.20000684261322021,
-0.8772561550140381,
0.14049901068210602,
0.5668903589248657,
0.5337233543395996,
0.28787916898727417,
-0.5327624082565308,
-0.35227227210998535,
-0.15048940479755402,
0.6510443687438965,
-0.6284940242767334,
0.3367899954319,
0.25010403990745544,
0.6412484645843506,
-0.44352424144744873,
-1.0989328622817993,
-0.6945461630821228,
-0.16994018852710724,
0.1039283499121666,
-0.011109520681202412,
-0.22977247834205627,
-0.03174567595124245,
0.7984879612922668,
0.07465323805809021,
-0.8366296291351318,
0.12485851347446442,
-0.4194936156272888,
-0.044757187366485596,
0.22170111536979675,
0.4200083613395691,
0.3132268786430359,
-0.4931087791919708,
-0.38888078927993774,
-0.11149865388870239,
-0.9386803507804871,
0.09777835756540298,
0.2542649209499359,
0.5311797857284546,
-0.018973885104060173,
0.3312451243400574,
-0.48546522855758667,
1.1313261985778809,
-0.1707293540239334,
0.07002768665552139,
0.29265469312667847,
-0.36824092268943787,
-0.1714383363723755,
-0.07231803238391876,
0.7017152905464172,
0.5979188680648804,
0.11250744014978409,
0.004335894715040922,
0.013328156433999538,
0.015303078107535839,
0.10373435169458389,
-1.0368255376815796,
-0.36469051241874695,
0.034694854170084,
-0.23577529191970825,
-0.31918075680732727,
-0.20239856839179993,
-1.2395344972610474,
-0.8912169933319092,
-0.5339307188987732,
0.08434081077575684,
-0.37089118361473083,
0.07614041864871979,
-0.0724736675620079,
-0.13090509176254272,
0.4682866334915161,
0.44036421179771423,
-0.8497958779335022,
0.26737138628959656,
0.5764290690422058,
0.8235489726066589,
-0.39194127917289734,
-0.1464550793170929,
-1.0436257123947144,
-0.01359131745994091,
-0.5663164854049683,
0.8595319390296936,
-0.7195444107055664,
-0.38210728764533997,
0.11028648167848587,
0.012892953120172024,
0.16397611796855927,
-0.34551700949668884,
0.667661726474762,
-0.5253352522850037,
0.1852087527513504,
-0.7792131304740906,
-0.6332272291183472,
-0.13256675004959106,
0.46606841683387756,
-0.6098928451538086,
1.0016045570373535,
0.018524181097745895,
-0.7893190383911133,
0.5644558668136597,
-0.5900062918663025,
-0.22013475000858307,
0.3019237220287323,
-0.6138579249382019,
-0.2845427393913269,
-0.3489552438259125,
0.6008824706077576,
0.675667941570282,
-0.6626232266426086,
0.35053372383117676,
-0.2327597439289093,
-0.27023106813430786,
-0.1478782594203949,
-0.2102852463722229,
0.5354792475700378,
0.24399642646312714,
-0.16649477183818817,
0.5672150254249573,
-0.6598013639450073,
-0.15505479276180267,
0.07508326321840286,
0.013838420622050762,
-0.3825737535953522,
-0.0700855627655983,
-0.16843920946121216,
0.3790542781352997,
-0.08456499874591827,
-0.38107651472091675,
0.3387621343135834,
-0.3991556763648987,
0.6292191743850708,
0.5647125840187073,
0.42970243096351624,
0.6032024025917053,
0.24568885564804077,
0.8637632131576538,
0.022329898551106453,
0.21066255867481232,
-0.7553809285163879,
-0.7578819990158081,
-0.6199559569358826,
-0.2133054882287979,
0.07286232709884644,
0.414298951625824,
-1.4494296312332153,
0.09349796921014786,
-0.3483778238296509,
-0.4584755301475525,
-0.1615523099899292,
0.06049706041812897,
-0.11786425113677979,
1.140872836112976,
0.42280423641204834,
0.19582004845142365,
-0.6010240912437439,
-1.032944679260254,
-0.24591661989688873,
-0.07904587686061859,
-0.06339365243911743,
0.29439154267311096,
0.3524671196937561,
-0.1378391534090042,
1.07030189037323,
-0.5705779790878296,
-0.32070642709732056,
-0.4338347315788269,
0.007051050662994385,
0.5154195427894592,
0.31250330805778503,
0.6831170916557312,
-0.7579523921012878,
-0.47218066453933716,
-0.10111895203590393,
-0.9118055105209351,
-0.23357579112052917,
-0.09627974778413773,
-0.23353587090969086,
0.031256914138793945,
0.9168393015861511,
-0.45679041743278503,
0.5004869699478149,
0.24117504060268402,
-0.4959961771965027,
0.2730430066585541,
-0.2630835771560669,
0.3007725477218628,
-1.0360232591629028,
-0.06505214422941208,
0.12713494896888733,
-0.32204166054725647,
-0.8796235918998718,
-0.19401945173740387,
0.29988929629325867,
-0.41928067803382874,
-0.2143218070268631,
0.5015956163406372,
-0.5200515389442444,
-0.048993077129125595,
0.015718797221779823,
0.23085716366767883,
0.2983815371990204,
0.3087320625782013,
-0.24764634668827057,
0.6940690875053406,
0.9741737842559814,
-0.48457664251327515,
0.6218502521514893,
0.5492932200431824,
-0.3734627068042755,
0.8774715662002563,
-0.635848879814148,
-0.19663384556770325,
-0.18281403183937073,
0.43494927883148193,
-1.0638688802719116,
-0.2989281415939331,
0.2613832950592041,
-0.1672063022851944,
0.1765507608652115,
-0.18466395139694214,
-0.4955686032772064,
-0.5307744741439819,
-0.3910333514213562,
0.009556152857840061,
0.4018454849720001,
-0.9031013250350952,
0.6190531849861145,
0.34076806902885437,
-0.329994261264801,
-0.45398804545402527,
-0.6370226144790649,
0.5345801711082458,
-0.49168723821640015,
-0.7009276151657104,
0.2338809370994568,
-0.06159694120287895,
-0.09390592575073242,
-0.340087890625,
-0.04086882248520851,
0.028864456340670586,
-0.06558246165513992,
0.3307740092277527,
0.4168839156627655,
0.08148457109928131,
0.33502689003944397,
0.17716538906097412,
-0.03938668966293335,
0.19159600138664246,
-0.1991298943758011,
0.43664097785949707,
-0.16466814279556274,
-0.38173532485961914,
-0.43577656149864197,
0.2581317722797394,
0.38357630372047424,
-0.2880111634731293,
0.38905632495880127,
0.3004750609397888,
-0.2872575521469116,
-0.505777895450592,
-0.47327762842178345,
-0.4241332411766052,
-0.5146937966346741,
0.19705970585346222,
-0.47790101170539856,
-0.7942385673522949,
0.5367851853370667,
-0.1093958243727684,
0.02801705151796341,
0.2546352744102478,
0.3843097388744354,
-0.01699419878423214,
0.8356925249099731,
0.29733362793922424,
0.22071607410907745,
0.48970624804496765,
-0.3117877244949341,
0.39368557929992676,
-0.5777391195297241,
-0.4262005388736725,
-0.5066859126091003,
-0.055568352341651917,
-0.5445179343223572,
-0.6309686899185181,
0.5028981566429138,
-0.4460372030735016,
-0.11374989151954651,
0.0422871932387352,
-0.473211407661438,
0.46333977580070496,
0.5539807081222534,
-0.1703367680311203,
0.2205946296453476,
0.10961427539587021,
-0.18067479133605957,
-0.2860841155052185,
-0.8514212369918823,
-0.3786887526512146,
1.0766055583953857,
0.0891583189368248,
0.7112517952919006,
-0.2898883819580078,
0.5540886521339417,
0.35824456810951233,
0.07716353237628937,
-0.4941295087337494,
0.6886435747146606,
0.31144052743911743,
-0.217834010720253,
-0.30389919877052307,
-0.5614164471626282,
-1.0722870826721191,
0.3596840500831604,
-0.2937355637550354,
-0.35797736048698425,
0.37024199962615967,
0.3302881717681885,
-0.18564783036708832,
0.10269556194543839,
-0.8474783301353455,
1.1395697593688965,
-0.07804396748542786,
-0.4760981798171997,
0.04987412691116333,
-0.6041485071182251,
0.3508053421974182,
0.1592121422290802,
0.25023525953292847,
-0.012281704694032669,
0.0006093148840591311,
0.6183721423149109,
-0.27004677057266235,
0.7013550400733948,
-0.5616201758384705,
0.09297630935907364,
0.333431601524353,
0.06934840977191925,
0.5789849162101746,
0.3416860103607178,
-0.15996916592121124,
-0.06499934196472168,
-0.3122803568840027,
-0.20754224061965942,
-0.696744978427887,
1.2096059322357178,
-0.05126449465751648,
-0.5821613073348999,
-0.5022481679916382,
-0.37285852432250977,
-0.16703251004219055,
0.15053048729896545,
0.0471821203827858,
0.7537544369697571,
-0.07672000676393509,
0.3007676303386688,
0.6471954584121704,
-0.4966282844543457,
0.2565211057662964,
0.3011692464351654,
-0.42413246631622314,
-0.24634970724582672,
0.8941128849983215,
0.08889871090650558,
-0.20267334580421448,
0.17718376219272614,
0.031574200838804245,
-0.6123086214065552,
-0.6563079953193665,
-0.5885263681411743,
0.08197182416915894,
-0.9344581365585327,
-0.4350444972515106,
-0.6163427829742432,
0.30968987941741943,
-0.33752429485321045,
0.01817222312092781,
0.09617886692285538,
-0.34917357563972473,
-0.3915869891643524,
-0.2843874990940094,
0.790986180305481,
0.6931056380271912,
0.3578541874885559,
0.22691351175308228,
-0.2925877869129181,
0.3587893843650818,
0.4717744290828705,
0.3351163864135742,
-0.1370505541563034,
-0.37991389632225037,
-0.01187764573842287,
-0.30617526173591614,
-0.13092565536499023,
-1.073386549949646,
0.5042574405670166,
0.05841857194900513,
0.6737403273582458,
0.30281609296798706,
0.09208627045154572,
0.5020460486412048,
-0.7220398783683777,
0.8659151196479797,
0.06685815006494522,
-0.7857332825660706,
0.722391664981842,
-0.48076093196868896,
0.08518141508102417,
0.6098996996879578,
0.1567709743976593,
-0.644294261932373,
-0.014605676755309105,
-0.3156175911426544,
-1.1362268924713135,
0.7532928586006165,
0.14996540546417236,
-0.21776261925697327,
-0.11956855654716492,
0.43159279227256775,
0.24629606306552887,
0.3850456476211548,
-0.38543859124183655,
-0.25784754753112793,
-0.4156728982925415,
-0.27072975039482117,
-0.08371366560459137,
-0.1386687010526657,
0.10447490960359573,
-0.27549290657043457,
0.4112411439418793,
-0.34885260462760925,
-0.1256105601787567,
0.14737701416015625,
-0.18700560927391052,
0.4531814455986023,
0.13190960884094238,
0.26516708731651306,
0.7018714547157288,
-0.04744279757142067,
0.05610870197415352,
0.30411234498023987,
-0.05964184179902077,
-0.11665119975805283,
0.19042153656482697,
-0.22793306410312653,
-0.009138792753219604,
0.057711586356163025,
1.1713887453079224,
0.23402194678783417,
-0.6577351093292236,
0.704501211643219,
-0.41954582929611206,
-0.032985299825668335,
-0.19413571059703827,
-0.08321551978588104,
0.09986315667629242,
0.14587998390197754,
0.3402414917945862,
-0.15159745514392853,
0.5770450830459595,
-0.28725963830947876,
0.12521454691886902,
0.39973679184913635,
-0.1156669333577156,
-0.22879481315612793,
0.806796133518219,
0.22356244921684265,
-0.013987327925860882,
0.5723696947097778,
-0.23536424338817596,
-0.3428639769554138,
0.41156622767448425,
0.3176862895488739,
0.428994357585907,
-0.21252678334712982,
0.2988317608833313,
0.4504135251045227,
0.1848262995481491,
-0.029340514913201332,
0.4375620484352112,
-0.21574287116527557,
-0.12539216876029968,
-0.364065557718277,
-0.3103548586368561,
-0.5178372859954834,
-0.11973601579666138,
-0.5101391673088074,
0.5471923351287842,
-0.18983182311058044,
-0.005692451726645231,
-0.21326549351215363,
-0.18771223723888397,
-0.9348304867744446,
0.01032392866909504,
0.03203587606549263,
0.844897449016571,
-1.0075135231018066,
0.6543216705322266,
0.479929119348526,
-0.35797494649887085,
-0.49878811836242676,
-0.349357932806015,
-0.1746072769165039,
-0.43030989170074463,
0.5192838311195374,
0.3659168481826782,
0.2698199152946472,
0.007477771490812302,
-0.6011142730712891,
-0.7344235181808472,
1.144400954246521,
0.4152921140193939,
-0.5082018971443176,
-0.0744868665933609,
-0.07319997996091843,
0.4983147084712982,
-0.40882471203804016,
0.2469167560338974,
0.9286819100379944,
0.6857650279998779,
0.07357611507177353,
-0.2559247612953186,
0.28856322169303894,
-0.3164219260215759,
0.12212017923593521,
-0.01489222515374422,
-0.12938186526298523,
0.8046081066131592,
-0.10596514493227005,
-0.1533241868019104,
-0.19500400125980377,
0.7616110444068909,
0.4917272925376892,
0.4926811754703522,
0.5738217234611511,
0.29067444801330566,
1.0403876304626465,
-0.38950395584106445,
1.1638069152832031,
-0.06625489890575409,
-0.19581322371959686,
1.0554646253585815,
-0.5974681377410889,
0.5247854590415955,
0.6470863819122314,
0.2279021441936493,
0.5234281420707703,
0.6663691997528076,
-0.12454217672348022,
0.5032719373703003,
0.30548354983329773,
0.14951178431510925,
-0.16955041885375977,
-0.03126176446676254,
-0.33701756596565247,
0.3057681918144226,
0.6626030206680298,
-0.11062164604663849,
-0.27484697103500366,
0.2737981677055359,
-0.07542379200458527,
0.2351202815771103,
-0.11748594045639038,
0.5394312739372253,
-0.08828555792570114,
-0.6436145901679993,
0.420021116733551,
-0.34565871953964233,
0.43258142471313477,
-0.5533150434494019,
-0.3227193057537079,
-0.3143180310726166,
-0.3373583257198334,
-0.13057276606559753,
-0.7513756155967712,
-0.08245384693145752,
0.1102486103773117,
0.023366300389170647,
-0.3842880427837372,
0.5938558578491211,
-0.4515165388584137,
-0.28918933868408203,
0.1565900444984436,
0.6214647889137268,
0.19272655248641968,
-0.08842691034078598,
-0.4518466293811798,
0.12764185667037964,
0.21106283366680145,
-0.3934295177459717,
0.13102388381958008,
0.6066603064537048,
-0.3331467807292938,
0.8344221115112305,
0.7962616086006165,
0.094253771007061,
0.07230587303638458,
0.4514669179916382,
1.081486701965332,
-0.7300508618354797,
-0.8803626298904419,
-0.7831848859786987,
0.3543180823326111,
-0.5743861198425293,
-0.11269574612379074,
1.0065062046051025,
0.6449428200721741,
0.12565487623214722,
-0.04438576102256775,
0.7796149849891663,
0.18982110917568207,
0.5835234522819519,
-0.5379999876022339,
0.6213799715042114,
-0.4230020046234131,
0.44999900460243225,
-0.30239757895469666,
-0.9773252010345459,
-0.5794171094894409,
0.4387392997741699,
-0.40945306420326233,
-0.1718357652425766,
0.623117983341217,
0.7665960788726807,
0.12268466502428055,
0.05952075123786926,
0.23742744326591492,
0.35416755080223083,
0.8295285701751709,
0.12432891130447388,
0.8055874705314636,
-0.17230786383152008,
0.7523971796035767,
0.07163538038730621,
-0.28871950507164,
-0.1570671945810318,
-1.0484800338745117,
-1.055846929550171,
-0.7703438997268677,
-0.08347711712121964,
0.05468743294477463,
-0.16804750263690948,
0.7721395492553711,
0.5714261531829834,
-0.6329556703567505,
0.013509321957826614,
-0.19581395387649536,
0.15478210151195526,
0.14206703007221222,
-0.2076372504234314,
0.557527482509613,
-0.4669012725353241,
-0.7075581550598145,
0.9029441475868225,
0.37080836296081543,
-0.09706185013055801,
-0.1620332896709442,
0.06986787915229797,
-0.006401107646524906,
-0.09825558215379715,
0.547460675239563,
0.10420471429824829,
-0.5374572277069092,
0.13648249208927155,
0.06523719429969788,
0.15779656171798706,
0.20956571400165558,
0.6849641799926758,
-1.204264760017395,
0.7227811813354492,
0.743995726108551,
0.5406240224838257,
0.7155774831771851,
0.07925784587860107,
0.5823956727981567,
-0.8013802766799927,
0.1786184161901474,
0.2793932855129242,
0.6450939178466797,
0.7900805473327637,
-0.26061156392097473,
0.3139486610889435,
-0.08925299346446991,
-0.6935282349586487,
-1.0630611181259155,
0.24783791601657867,
-0.9280312657356262,
-0.04236931726336479,
1.0586416721343994,
0.1534658819437027,
-0.213751420378685,
-0.18515419960021973,
-0.5549996495246887,
0.15072810649871826,
-0.8403197526931763,
0.38904261589050293,
0.3152332603931427,
-0.1177067831158638,
0.08475508540868759,
-0.972038209438324,
0.7483044862747192,
0.09723667055368423,
-1.072086215019226,
0.22782111167907715,
0.7663568258285522,
0.10050235688686371,
-0.23554299771785736,
0.4296644628047943,
0.12272873520851135,
0.055238377302885056,
-0.2876126170158386,
0.10255491733551025,
-0.20205886662006378,
-0.36633917689323425,
-0.5061354041099548,
0.2397206425666809,
-0.08108215034008026,
-0.06275177747011185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16458v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16458v1 | Credit Risk Meets Large Language Models: Building a Risk Indicator from Loan Descriptions in P2P Lending | 2024-01-29T10:11:05 | 2024-01-29T10:11:05 | Mario Sanz-Guerrero, Javier Arroyo | q-fin.RM | q-fin.RM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Peer-to-peer (P2P) lending has emerged as a distinctive financing mechanism,
linking borrowers with lenders through online platforms. However, P2P lending
faces the challenge of information asymmetry, as lenders often lack sufficient
data to assess the creditworthiness of borrowers. This paper proposes a novel
approach to address this issue by leveraging the textual descriptions provided
by borrowers during the loan application process. Our methodology involves
processing these textual descriptions using a Large Language Model (LLM), a
powerful tool capable of discerning patterns and semantics within the text.
Transfer learning is applied to adapt the LLM to the specific task at hand.
Our results derived from the analysis of the Lending Club dataset show that
the risk score generated by BERT, a widely used LLM, significantly improves the
performance of credit risk classifiers. However, the inherent opacity of
LLM-based systems, coupled with uncertainties about potential biases,
underscores critical considerations for regulatory frameworks and engenders
trust-related concerns among end-users, opening new avenues for future research
in the dynamic landscape of P2P lending and artificial intelligence. | [
0.30944278836250305,
-0.40901947021484375,
0.6843909621238708,
0.28570088744163513,
0.08789337426424026,
0.07343759387731552,
-0.2606099545955658,
-0.7477731704711914,
-0.0823395699262619,
0.4385771155357361,
-0.06065773963928223,
-0.21307572722434998,
-0.8766928911209106,
-0.49103251099586487,
-0.5052171349525452,
1.4343093633651733,
-0.23577025532722473,
-0.13872630894184113,
-0.3489409387111664,
0.3276531994342804,
-0.20185229182243347,
-0.0020114241633564234,
-0.8562255501747131,
-0.18054483830928802,
0.37746313214302063,
0.30007699131965637,
0.6831632852554321,
0.13763393461704254,
0.7591581344604492,
0.16867151856422424,
0.21085882186889648,
-0.3946537375450134,
-0.2842428386211395,
-0.07865482568740845,
-0.2579565942287445,
-0.5952867269515991,
-0.3762672543525696,
0.09617376327514648,
0.7724850177764893,
0.5446044206619263,
0.0915687084197998,
0.42274734377861023,
0.2869114279747009,
0.6211551427841187,
-0.6573176383972168,
0.47429969906806946,
-0.601498544216156,
-0.16280868649482727,
0.059820711612701416,
-0.1021779328584671,
-0.5065752863883972,
-0.3042721748352051,
0.7217374444007874,
-0.2928928732872009,
0.19790048897266388,
0.19453750550746918,
0.9478327631950378,
-0.020397013053297997,
-0.309003084897995,
-0.43270814418792725,
-0.8528478741645813,
0.43692538142204285,
-0.4035648703575134,
-0.058663055300712585,
0.5613422393798828,
0.37822622060775757,
0.06766729801893234,
-0.6303073763847351,
-0.3172653913497925,
-0.3079468011856079,
-0.2988978922367096,
-0.12316808104515076,
-0.010057471692562103,
-0.3128426969051361,
-0.030169058591127396,
0.4264393746852875,
-0.16853901743888855,
0.34092456102371216,
-0.6951693296432495,
-0.5045292973518372,
0.9720833897590637,
-0.2471853792667389,
-0.07976878434419632,
0.04001355171203613,
-0.7957230806350708,
-0.19649545848369598,
-0.6430109143257141,
0.37884756922721863,
0.7159833312034607,
0.30769583582878113,
-0.46044379472732544,
0.6828718781471252,
0.36918509006500244,
0.30756452679634094,
-0.006005790084600449,
0.10582984238862991,
0.044390950351953506,
-0.159308061003685,
0.20293208956718445,
0.3330644369125366,
0.8430331349372864,
0.6080510020256042,
0.018870234489440918,
0.1492445170879364,
-0.30950090289115906,
-0.46927669644355774,
0.12091240286827087,
-0.5316592454910278,
-0.20808641612529755,
0.3561346232891083,
-0.5877529978752136,
-0.5567216873168945,
0.6173688173294067,
-1.0086796283721924,
-0.7890586256980896,
0.11394102871417999,
0.5260990262031555,
-0.2800370156764984,
-0.27695798873901367,
-0.22126904129981995,
-0.16729862987995148,
0.48466014862060547,
0.12901172041893005,
-0.5024176239967346,
0.3939542770385742,
0.6034272909164429,
1.0119760036468506,
-0.15453435480594635,
-0.13639456033706665,
-0.6218079328536987,
0.3655691146850586,
0.15484793484210968,
0.37000733613967896,
-0.5122082233428955,
-0.391340047121048,
0.15993241965770721,
-0.1289438009262085,
0.20111611485481262,
0.007061723154038191,
0.46512794494628906,
-0.3213707208633423,
0.2735787034034729,
0.34627124667167664,
-0.6111006736755371,
-0.05296551063656807,
0.05089378356933594,
-0.5671412944793701,
0.8725340366363525,
0.3888603746891022,
-0.5990163683891296,
0.21037669479846954,
-0.4289105236530304,
-0.479478657245636,
0.004868878051638603,
0.2497895359992981,
-0.8709622621536255,
0.3876677453517914,
-0.07664219290018082,
0.5868487358093262,
-0.3603287637233734,
0.2729625701904297,
-0.23302675783634186,
-0.2812492847442627,
0.7586314678192139,
-0.4392971694469452,
0.48745930194854736,
0.07241974771022797,
-0.34997886419296265,
0.2588677704334259,
-0.6708788871765137,
-0.2726454734802246,
0.18820111453533173,
-0.32006698846817017,
-0.2600206732749939,
0.2252841293811798,
0.49633705615997314,
0.08182995021343231,
0.6640565395355225,
-0.47419285774230957,
-0.22119659185409546,
-0.39223936200141907,
0.6500738859176636,
0.9060384035110474,
-0.3273175358772278,
0.38685891032218933,
-0.5886244773864746,
0.27768343687057495,
-0.2012394219636917,
0.03724347800016403,
-0.3082349896430969,
-0.6954935789108276,
-0.5959814190864563,
-0.4018820822238922,
0.21546801924705505,
0.5550206899642944,
-0.08840236812829971,
0.6026499271392822,
0.028786061331629753,
-0.5263186097145081,
-0.40290430188179016,
0.041274309158325195,
0.32028305530548096,
0.018157698214054108,
0.270084947347641,
-0.3912617862224579,
-0.49691134691238403,
-0.6309422850608826,
-0.34611639380455017,
-0.5115140676498413,
-0.1602037400007248,
0.5453274250030518,
0.21143296360969543,
-0.18792174756526947,
0.5668139457702637,
-0.7905411124229431,
-0.6423305869102478,
-0.4325583577156067,
-0.01515611819922924,
0.22307397425174713,
0.43165987730026245,
0.2115713506937027,
-0.747403621673584,
-0.7723391056060791,
0.181410014629364,
-0.20644724369049072,
-0.12931422889232635,
-0.6020961403846741,
0.3014984130859375,
0.20929941534996033,
0.5272045731544495,
-0.6339508891105652,
0.29007238149642944,
0.6992404460906982,
-0.8036177754402161,
0.5021795630455017,
-0.7399173974990845,
-0.17563311755657196,
-1.1395280361175537,
0.1775394231081009,
0.3076840937137604,
-0.24320265650749207,
-0.21380071341991425,
0.13825806975364685,
-0.16795971989631653,
-0.3069620430469513,
-0.056227441877126694,
0.6319934129714966,
-0.5008570551872253,
-0.2345651537179947,
-0.34176671504974365,
0.17144861817359924,
-0.08552093803882599,
0.04025138169527054,
-0.09336220473051071,
0.3778839409351349,
0.8238252997398376,
-0.2908504903316498,
0.5130589008331299,
0.11838901042938232,
-0.3575642704963684,
0.47738632559776306,
-0.6854227185249329,
-0.03908749297261238,
-0.0768902376294136,
0.4080391824245453,
-1.1491727828979492,
-0.12671610713005066,
0.14192092418670654,
-0.3454214632511139,
0.3970238268375397,
-0.15642796456813812,
-0.1829083114862442,
-0.33471381664276123,
-0.2756684422492981,
0.37739408016204834,
0.5237070918083191,
-0.22966371476650238,
0.858165442943573,
0.23402179777622223,
-0.48924094438552856,
-0.4652332067489624,
-0.16419388353824615,
0.12671202421188354,
-0.48457199335098267,
-0.4056257903575897,
0.31605276465415955,
0.41504111886024475,
-0.23871992528438568,
-0.07248421013355255,
0.0040842825546860695,
-0.27841511368751526,
0.3817806839942932,
0.7710588574409485,
0.6516625285148621,
-0.04134005308151245,
0.14332269132137299,
-0.16944395005702972,
-0.30701377987861633,
0.37108078598976135,
-0.7789098620414734,
0.5595848560333252,
0.056015316396951675,
-0.11949983239173889,
-0.4711267352104187,
0.19055096805095673,
0.4841190576553345,
-0.17683890461921692,
0.8879554867744446,
0.5117515921592712,
-0.05384086072444916,
-0.265017032623291,
-0.4781321883201599,
0.15176177024841309,
-0.4537828266620636,
0.30616432428359985,
-0.11467283964157104,
-0.9014363884925842,
0.46275630593299866,
-0.025277160108089447,
-0.11237626522779465,
0.46330976486206055,
0.5701037049293518,
-0.4525783658027649,
0.2298462986946106,
0.9942147731781006,
-0.22945265471935272,
0.6027184724807739,
0.14696477353572845,
0.35274043679237366,
-0.33197125792503357,
-0.44034478068351746,
-0.5605133771896362,
-0.4598742425441742,
-0.6643412113189697,
-0.8474129438400269,
0.16373834013938904,
-0.2042425274848938,
0.005241789389401674,
0.5749690532684326,
0.0693327933549881,
0.4913052022457123,
0.4472271203994751,
0.18915292620658875,
0.27014482021331787,
-0.12822337448596954,
0.2826818823814392,
0.11356988549232483,
-0.04603198543190956,
-0.3940378725528717,
1.5898178815841675,
0.9575480818748474,
0.7950010299682617,
0.254190593957901,
0.33727166056632996,
0.5801899433135986,
0.1712072640657425,
-0.6627042293548584,
0.18960615992546082,
-0.158722922205925,
-0.5462680459022522,
-0.3613954484462738,
-0.5236395597457886,
-0.6302823424339294,
-0.2863674759864807,
-0.5158714056015015,
-0.6359935998916626,
0.06252958625555038,
0.253235399723053,
-0.298089861869812,
0.12477215379476547,
-0.583331823348999,
0.661198079586029,
-0.47578901052474976,
-0.5549541115760803,
-0.4083575904369354,
-0.7961649894714355,
0.16240288317203522,
-0.4848569929599762,
0.4063150882720947,
0.06330431997776031,
0.0027672199066728354,
0.24663202464580536,
-0.1235734075307846,
0.9133914113044739,
-0.2067096084356308,
-0.37101224064826965,
0.44336262345314026,
0.10615991801023483,
0.963902473449707,
0.1537352055311203,
0.05926714092493057,
0.13088130950927734,
-0.06327468156814575,
-0.4160875082015991,
-0.24750204384326935,
0.7928805947303772,
-0.7051420211791992,
-0.23033849895000458,
-0.34948277473449707,
-0.6765623092651367,
-0.2093483954668045,
0.03955875709652901,
-0.17715102434158325,
-0.12387426942586899,
-0.2555485963821411,
0.14301398396492004,
0.4069887399673462,
-0.6321624517440796,
0.29230761528015137,
0.546133816242218,
-0.17563797533512115,
0.13972818851470947,
1.0505942106246948,
-0.45136886835098267,
0.37822169065475464,
0.3141825497150421,
0.4857625365257263,
-0.45989367365837097,
-0.5594056844711304,
0.08533595502376556,
0.20952869951725006,
-0.39569786190986633,
-0.04306440055370331,
-0.2965487539768219,
-0.08620552718639374,
-0.16824160516262054,
-0.2903754413127899,
-0.25100967288017273,
-0.4928940534591675,
0.033478304743766785,
-0.3561885952949524,
0.22492805123329163,
0.6326501369476318,
0.06599219143390656,
0.4444783627986908,
-0.8109230995178223,
0.15281115472316742,
0.13927792012691498,
0.8152649402618408,
-0.1708170771598816,
-0.6745191812515259,
-0.2590772807598114,
-0.3134441375732422,
0.07181773334741592,
-0.6211085319519043,
0.2651781141757965,
0.5394743084907532,
0.42848125100135803,
0.5970233082771301,
0.022260667756199837,
0.03635450452566147,
-0.38855645060539246,
0.4742094576358795,
0.4043155014514923,
-1.0050456523895264,
0.6244871020317078,
-0.38773366808891296,
-0.36419057846069336,
0.5490536093711853,
0.5546337366104126,
-0.3938065767288208,
-0.5787647366523743,
-0.5969732999801636,
-1.199510097503662,
0.6625158786773682,
0.04620452597737312,
0.34808093309402466,
0.3618796765804291,
0.26343023777008057,
0.3356899917125702,
0.09031640738248825,
-1.06436026096344,
0.10725398361682892,
-0.18047799170017242,
-0.3848448395729065,
-0.40672922134399414,
-0.5010444521903992,
-0.014662043191492558,
0.14607171714305878,
0.7850320339202881,
-0.13458701968193054,
0.04804335907101631,
-0.09878254681825638,
-0.2674108147621155,
-0.1064334437251091,
0.1968616396188736,
0.2716200053691864,
0.38851088285446167,
-0.3210570812225342,
0.24907633662223816,
-0.3165285289287567,
-0.32084086537361145,
0.054537128657102585,
0.22632776200771332,
-0.15556389093399048,
-0.13388973474502563,
0.395781934261322,
0.6138960123062134,
0.1270979642868042,
-0.9810146689414978,
1.0471627712249756,
0.16549088060855865,
-0.07479701191186905,
-0.6050702333450317,
-0.21991300582885742,
-0.036165062338113785,
0.3686671257019043,
0.24856910109519958,
0.04799885302782059,
0.12383320927619934,
-0.7704499959945679,
0.32159584760665894,
0.3803960978984833,
-1.0302788019180298,
-0.1985785812139511,
0.38655632734298706,
0.4808366298675537,
-0.2158018946647644,
0.6245321035385132,
0.4307110607624054,
-0.15354660153388977,
0.5372556447982788,
0.5659196376800537,
0.9182892441749573,
-0.06342945992946625,
0.3210040032863617,
0.23520684242248535,
0.3414466381072998,
-0.2777070701122284,
-0.16165012121200562,
0.0308220274746418,
-0.6535244584083557,
-0.42549583315849304,
-0.8661156296730042,
-0.15802419185638428,
-0.2190939337015152,
-0.5984963774681091,
0.512319028377533,
-0.959651529788971,
0.001498501398600638,
-0.10456088930368423,
-0.44006025791168213,
-0.34959498047828674,
-0.14418208599090576,
0.5421349406242371,
0.6648043394088745,
-1.0035512447357178,
0.6669141054153442,
0.5347665548324585,
-0.16622041165828705,
-0.5989543795585632,
0.13688787817955017,
0.09236815571784973,
-0.7759628295898438,
0.7242751121520996,
0.38618215918540955,
0.14105811715126038,
-0.24506251513957977,
-0.18220119178295135,
-0.638735830783844,
0.9875670075416565,
0.12336156517267227,
-0.7491048574447632,
-0.14503352344036102,
0.2770272195339203,
0.5392240285873413,
-0.36148393154144287,
0.10218074172735214,
0.5237415432929993,
0.46895670890808105,
0.06182902678847313,
-1.0424751043319702,
0.18151696026325226,
-0.0025892446283251047,
-0.16107593476772308,
0.299174040555954,
-0.32594966888427734,
0.5448598861694336,
-0.5619828701019287,
-0.03546353802084923,
0.09713365882635117,
0.47417572140693665,
-0.2026847004890442,
0.41348782181739807,
0.43011564016342163,
0.17732089757919312,
0.4884707033634186,
-0.1464262455701828,
1.0492594242095947,
-0.26396340131759644,
0.5044625997543335,
1.2017822265625,
-0.3640575408935547,
0.9087806344032288,
0.5940055847167969,
-0.47711580991744995,
0.5188281536102295,
0.10611968487501144,
-0.3768395483493805,
0.2148570716381073,
0.570022463798523,
-0.16710001230239868,
-0.2044212818145752,
-0.12071172147989273,
-0.05823477357625961,
0.6581950783729553,
0.3771283030509949,
-0.9612575769424438,
0.03570657595992088,
-0.1270502358675003,
-0.19156543910503387,
0.3858530521392822,
-0.4263906180858612,
0.8660688400268555,
0.28211286664009094,
-0.2977563142776489,
-0.3189561069011688,
0.18114043772220612,
0.6633538007736206,
-0.7967942953109741,
0.006796897854655981,
0.1254943460226059,
0.4712701439857483,
-0.3005143105983734,
-0.8896123170852661,
0.5408233404159546,
-0.10034184902906418,
-0.20144324004650116,
-0.5506414771080017,
0.6405537128448486,
-0.39311474561691284,
-0.7782354950904846,
0.45387303829193115,
0.20652233064174652,
0.2111797332763672,
-0.12138183414936066,
-0.4177436828613281,
-0.28382062911987305,
-0.1957213133573532,
0.22743777930736542,
0.5652614235877991,
0.2657460868358612,
-0.16492094099521637,
0.7142525911331177,
0.6886099576950073,
0.2853054106235504,
-0.16329768300056458,
-0.14880968630313873,
0.5634657740592957,
-0.4573899209499359,
-0.526478111743927,
-0.8970442414283752,
0.525769054889679,
-0.011451618745923042,
-0.17081542313098907,
0.6870450973510742,
0.5161661505699158,
0.7112519145011902,
-0.1371293067932129,
0.6376009583473206,
-0.29860636591911316,
0.3834531009197235,
-0.3953785002231598,
0.9021887183189392,
-0.20007503032684326,
0.7124120593070984,
-0.398133248090744,
-1.1102150678634644,
-0.10807608813047409,
0.6933436989784241,
-0.3359496593475342,
-0.3888346552848816,
0.4316112995147705,
0.3178178668022156,
0.22600270807743073,
-0.1974538415670395,
-0.014185138046741486,
0.17705655097961426,
0.17810241878032684,
0.7415687441825867,
0.9221007823944092,
-0.4954128563404083,
0.8195070028305054,
0.010118684731423855,
-0.12558168172836304,
-0.33596691489219666,
-0.973372757434845,
-0.8674832582473755,
-0.4388796091079712,
-0.4523274600505829,
-0.6059791445732117,
-0.17817986011505127,
0.8910540342330933,
0.1037905141711235,
-1.0231090784072876,
-0.5434120297431946,
0.09445852041244507,
0.11879275739192963,
-0.2731866240501404,
-0.24398168921470642,
0.2862308919429779,
-0.2619169056415558,
-0.29043200612068176,
0.09749466180801392,
0.31610170006752014,
0.03251373767852783,
-0.33700379729270935,
-0.06278771907091141,
0.1184672862291336,
-0.02988825924694538,
0.436397522687912,
-0.11377182602882385,
-0.2935848832130432,
-0.4413083493709564,
-0.6157222986221313,
-0.013627314940094948,
-0.29872187972068787,
1.0260086059570312,
-0.2585851550102234,
0.19662140309810638,
0.39025962352752686,
0.7804840207099915,
0.5700501799583435,
-0.06518680602312088,
0.999589204788208,
-0.6450331211090088,
0.10160177201032639,
0.15269319713115692,
0.33395159244537354,
0.3039683699607849,
-0.5977964997291565,
0.13074754178524017,
0.07487203180789948,
-0.25612401962280273,
-0.579740047454834,
0.27512335777282715,
-0.9418665766716003,
-0.44777560234069824,
1.0830222368240356,
-0.5390363335609436,
0.1019292026758194,
-0.2849369943141937,
-0.3019190728664398,
-0.18487592041492462,
-0.4758646488189697,
0.9544711709022522,
0.6617302298545837,
0.47799062728881836,
-0.1835184544324875,
-0.42247235774993896,
0.5089278221130371,
0.0952964648604393,
-0.5307466387748718,
0.27799105644226074,
0.5288791060447693,
0.3571392297744751,
0.3544619381427765,
0.3980563282966614,
-0.0788487046957016,
0.17037951946258545,
-0.1305609792470932,
-0.09076143801212311,
-0.13126243650913239,
-0.4316255450248718,
-0.23607902228832245,
0.4715426564216614,
0.3523859679698944,
0.24382764101028442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16012v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16012v1 | Finding Challenging Metaphors that Confuse Pretrained Language Models | 2024-01-29T10:00:54 | 2024-01-29T10:00:54 | Yucheng Li, Frank Guerin, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Metaphors are considered to pose challenges for a wide spectrum of NLP tasks.
This gives rise to the area of computational metaphor processing. However, it
remains unclear what types of metaphors challenge current state-of-the-art
models. In this paper, we test various NLP models on the VUA metaphor dataset
and quantify to what extent metaphors affect models' performance on various
downstream tasks. Analysis reveals that VUA includes a large number of
metaphors that pose little difficulty to downstream tasks. We would like to
shift the attention of researchers away from these metaphors to instead focus
on challenging metaphors. To identify hard metaphors, we propose an automatic
pipeline that identifies metaphors that challenge a particular model. Our
analysis demonstrates that our detected hard metaphors contrast significantly
with VUA and reduce the accuracy of machine translation by 16\%, QA performance
by 4\%, NLI by 7\%, and metaphor identification recall by over 14\% for various
popular NLP systems. | [
-0.30796173214912415,
-0.6335440278053284,
0.6467132568359375,
0.23725852370262146,
-0.459033727645874,
0.07141583412885666,
0.15288978815078735,
-0.5197460651397705,
0.054350752383470535,
0.5405008792877197,
-0.6674857139587402,
0.03250129520893097,
-0.7903580665588379,
0.31452319025993347,
-0.45613741874694824,
0.6950131058692932,
-0.18451382219791412,
-0.2489742934703827,
-0.17235852777957916,
-0.2154187113046646,
-1.215006947517395,
-0.6110213994979858,
-0.4307284951210022,
-0.5463314652442932,
0.624961793422699,
-0.20765018463134766,
0.8225703835487366,
0.6378722190856934,
0.5403459668159485,
0.3792414367198944,
-0.23831424117088318,
-0.09488894045352936,
-0.40869757533073425,
0.364736944437027,
-0.37014663219451904,
-0.7117973566055298,
0.059279195964336395,
0.00780207896605134,
0.36193549633026123,
0.6456681489944458,
-0.0027255890890955925,
0.20402126014232635,
-0.09300337731838226,
0.5962207317352295,
-0.8644824624061584,
0.27290505170822144,
-1.152994990348816,
0.24703358113765717,
-0.4640088677406311,
-0.2696056663990021,
-0.16483278572559357,
0.05625329166650772,
0.2846892178058624,
-0.664722204208374,
0.16576674580574036,
0.12370088696479797,
1.301612138748169,
0.5326870679855347,
-0.40230274200439453,
-0.16406424343585968,
-1.0657912492752075,
0.7817971110343933,
-0.5247237682342529,
0.34100550413131714,
0.19818221032619476,
0.39456990361213684,
-0.1548643857240677,
-0.7268725037574768,
-0.8377265334129333,
-0.06745617091655731,
0.0021731359884142876,
-0.0901135578751564,
-0.6600985527038574,
-0.2205459028482437,
0.5803864598274231,
0.1625925898551941,
-0.4831984341144562,
0.33906424045562744,
-0.6044518351554871,
-0.15317852795124054,
0.12678496539592743,
0.2358856052160263,
0.18535543978214264,
-0.3285372257232666,
-0.42770594358444214,
-0.3439473807811737,
-0.7974407076835632,
-0.09626349061727524,
0.32241055369377136,
0.2758740782737732,
0.13196462392807007,
0.5720851421356201,
0.10313133895397186,
0.6623745560646057,
-0.4645957946777344,
0.2388422191143036,
0.5074436664581299,
0.052282676100730896,
-0.38503918051719666,
-0.2387094646692276,
0.5733557343482971,
0.10417190194129944,
0.4113498330116272,
-0.1503417044878006,
-0.4893352687358856,
0.4511009752750397,
0.6404438018798828,
-0.3093307912349701,
-0.15197782218456268,
0.0755494236946106,
-0.036112718284130096,
-0.2225395143032074,
-0.1893867701292038,
-0.37912383675575256,
-0.5128353238105774,
-0.4976525902748108,
0.7307654023170471,
-0.48893120884895325,
-0.12438391894102097,
0.20531032979488373,
-0.461625337600708,
0.32928451895713806,
0.4149460196495056,
-0.5864558219909668,
0.14387404918670654,
0.8211307525634766,
0.6319263577461243,
-0.0656951293349266,
-0.21118862926959991,
-0.4795495271682739,
-0.13507291674613953,
-0.25992274284362793,
0.8480132222175598,
-0.5792149901390076,
-0.07079610973596573,
-0.06532327085733414,
-0.18338407576084137,
-0.23953457176685333,
-0.8368932008743286,
0.511476457118988,
-0.43194159865379333,
0.3027998208999634,
-0.31185784935951233,
-0.6109369993209839,
-0.27314460277557373,
0.30188611149787903,
-0.8435067534446716,
1.1397314071655273,
0.24249690771102905,
-0.8179221749305725,
0.23172196745872498,
-0.3038616180419922,
0.06048670411109924,
0.13694918155670166,
-0.43405017256736755,
-0.04120592772960663,
0.43642303347587585,
0.04874255880713463,
0.43405765295028687,
-0.7092812657356262,
0.2583343982696533,
-0.06690291315317154,
-0.3403223752975464,
0.30878719687461853,
-0.15925981104373932,
0.6902756690979004,
0.3347592055797577,
-0.332136869430542,
0.08639759570360184,
-0.5530217885971069,
0.03700723871588707,
0.3764905631542206,
0.34464511275291443,
-0.7228495478630066,
-0.15753813087940216,
0.09848250448703766,
0.5337944030761719,
-0.1669008433818817,
-0.17060814797878265,
0.24459169805049896,
-0.4344411790370941,
0.4266355335712433,
0.8871411681175232,
-0.4486868381500244,
0.0424533411860466,
-0.31410717964172363,
0.9191866517066956,
0.20780719816684723,
-0.0935550406575203,
-0.04056248813867569,
-0.636276364326477,
-0.8548786044120789,
-0.04639462009072304,
0.5509840846061707,
0.7362902760505676,
-1.0256164073944092,
0.3028324246406555,
-0.39816638827323914,
-0.6143807172775269,
-0.9723349809646606,
0.139688640832901,
0.2865971326828003,
0.6182889342308044,
0.4843266010284424,
-0.49682116508483887,
-0.3982360064983368,
-1.0608179569244385,
-0.49548351764678955,
-0.3215887248516083,
-0.44747379422187805,
0.18476064503192902,
0.7117104530334473,
-0.11268717795610428,
1.0306755304336548,
-0.42174413800239563,
-0.2949197590351105,
-0.026705358177423477,
0.53053218126297,
0.14235734939575195,
0.365274578332901,
0.6293548345565796,
-0.9541985392570496,
-0.00698246480897069,
-0.44370898604393005,
-0.6470969915390015,
-0.31451377272605896,
-0.11918807774782181,
0.19415999948978424,
-0.19634579122066498,
0.4569835066795349,
-0.7295304536819458,
0.37053048610687256,
0.41919827461242676,
-0.2699583172798157,
0.5995879173278809,
-0.12420929968357086,
-0.08537004888057709,
-0.7801961302757263,
0.13197548687458038,
0.025061214342713356,
0.0983990952372551,
-0.4584576189517975,
0.4163740575313568,
-0.020735345780849457,
0.03648447245359421,
-0.7707733511924744,
0.5166802406311035,
-0.2077455222606659,
0.21623460948467255,
-0.026571229100227356,
0.09357395768165588,
0.017774492502212524,
0.12495166063308716,
0.21720212697982788,
0.5650566816329956,
0.5065001249313354,
-0.5882313251495361,
0.41985198855400085,
-0.07070349901914597,
-0.17967700958251953,
0.21275748312473297,
-0.7717353105545044,
0.4639417827129364,
-0.3059769868850708,
0.22291795909404755,
-0.6857569813728333,
0.1157902330160141,
0.1688442975282669,
-0.105274498462677,
0.042133498936891556,
0.11725340783596039,
-0.6062259078025818,
-0.3747333288192749,
-0.11361096799373627,
0.6483277678489685,
0.5199037194252014,
-0.26484215259552,
0.514944314956665,
0.11443537473678589,
0.22646616399288177,
-0.8203923106193542,
-0.46628570556640625,
0.15968476235866547,
-0.5322250723838806,
-0.354949951171875,
0.4315154552459717,
0.1638161540031433,
-0.2936767041683197,
-0.21402683854103088,
-0.012402120977640152,
-0.22692257165908813,
0.29306742548942566,
0.2516951858997345,
0.1853989213705063,
-0.2052539587020874,
0.22136935591697693,
-0.3051421642303467,
-0.02772854082286358,
0.2097986489534378,
-0.08981402963399887,
0.5925240516662598,
-0.2596733868122101,
-0.16247762739658356,
-0.37680837512016296,
0.16321083903312683,
0.599162757396698,
-0.19361479580402374,
0.7442741394042969,
0.649838924407959,
-0.6278110146522522,
-0.06337114423513412,
-0.6703587174415588,
-0.15163706243038177,
-0.5085046291351318,
0.19205418229103088,
-0.5144020318984985,
-0.6766895055770874,
0.604474663734436,
-0.21499089896678925,
-0.1753862202167511,
0.5272156000137329,
0.222236767411232,
-0.09914560616016388,
0.6258769035339355,
0.5414032340049744,
-0.16768254339694977,
0.13005635142326355,
-0.24429833889007568,
0.4529587924480438,
-0.5304763317108154,
-0.07209116965532303,
-0.9749791622161865,
-0.3055184781551361,
-0.7774937748908997,
-0.6844117641448975,
0.03421039134263992,
-0.017836332321166992,
-0.04034050181508064,
0.667634904384613,
-0.43731454014778137,
0.33264538645744324,
0.4570586383342743,
-0.43615996837615967,
0.2682884931564331,
-0.14697065949440002,
-0.07232287526130676,
-0.2667873203754425,
-0.7334206104278564,
-0.5933493971824646,
0.8384684920310974,
0.42166879773139954,
0.5397292971611023,
-0.16493579745292664,
0.44439247250556946,
0.21174772083759308,
0.2053249627351761,
-0.6930226683616638,
0.5132327079772949,
0.02104123868048191,
-0.7838833332061768,
0.02353055588901043,
-0.4311944842338562,
-1.2827006578445435,
0.2635069191455841,
-0.5629745125770569,
-0.7408015727996826,
0.010762136429548264,
0.1781613975763321,
-0.15625134110450745,
0.2751523554325104,
-0.6412368416786194,
1.0368174314498901,
-0.04985126852989197,
0.08923333883285522,
-0.09076137095689774,
-0.6688898801803589,
0.30803513526916504,
-0.3168118894100189,
0.3103440999984741,
-0.16166181862354279,
0.07246700674295425,
0.5790742635726929,
-0.31781265139579773,
0.4466443359851837,
0.1468285173177719,
-0.1243465468287468,
0.2552393078804016,
0.1308041214942932,
0.40774357318878174,
-0.46796342730522156,
0.0593450590968132,
0.38995304703712463,
0.1235424354672432,
-0.45535793900489807,
-0.7432984113693237,
0.2882957458496094,
-0.5596776008605957,
-0.596626341342926,
-0.626462459564209,
-0.4898569881916046,
-0.23310574889183044,
0.07295432686805725,
0.561265766620636,
-0.18294115364551544,
-0.03863110765814781,
0.16906572878360748,
0.3983530104160309,
-0.23467180132865906,
-0.06815071403980255,
0.30533459782600403,
-0.08481871336698532,
0.4056212902069092,
0.8236281871795654,
0.21335646510124207,
-0.01685132272541523,
0.2675383388996124,
0.164385125041008,
-0.21560218930244446,
-0.5584944486618042,
-0.36119455099105835,
0.11678043752908707,
-0.4752841293811798,
-0.15993650257587433,
-0.44916433095932007,
-0.16949643194675446,
-0.33830419182777405,
0.15746186673641205,
-0.5129727125167847,
-0.36685582995414734,
-0.3565605878829956,
-0.011388873681426048,
0.15217530727386475,
0.5981159210205078,
0.5445497035980225,
0.2934718132019043,
-0.7050502896308899,
0.42726704478263855,
0.3739391565322876,
0.07115979492664337,
-0.12857140600681305,
-0.4821387529373169,
0.18020382523536682,
-0.22129803895950317,
-0.31197047233581543,
-1.1891324520111084,
0.5345825552940369,
0.003144781803712249,
0.16369207203388214,
0.2703287899494171,
0.23551321029663086,
0.6403851509094238,
-0.5411532521247864,
0.7974791526794434,
0.2728533446788788,
-1.1278122663497925,
0.5731903314590454,
-0.2795328199863434,
0.24488165974617004,
0.3733072280883789,
0.4452350437641144,
-0.5263156294822693,
-0.672497570514679,
-0.6859177350997925,
-1.1436100006103516,
0.19253310561180115,
0.6828548312187195,
0.48253750801086426,
0.04478665068745613,
0.5754048824310303,
0.2331497222185135,
0.39475056529045105,
-0.9413002729415894,
-0.3342139720916748,
0.0355105958878994,
0.05141749605536461,
-0.006913030985742807,
0.019123855978250504,
0.07409457862377167,
-0.2723778784275055,
0.5351911187171936,
0.11603011935949326,
-0.030132105574011803,
-0.1758178323507309,
-0.10535737872123718,
-0.047203972935676575,
0.3820548951625824,
0.1424149125814438,
0.5912070870399475,
-0.10082711279392242,
0.1530018150806427,
0.20430335402488708,
-0.27512454986572266,
0.21634165942668915,
0.058270931243896484,
-0.2881712317466736,
0.3188074827194214,
0.474312961101532,
1.0082257986068726,
-0.04422452673316002,
-0.908039927482605,
0.37009352445602417,
-0.11427053064107895,
0.04752663895487785,
-0.41929733753204346,
0.3081270754337311,
-0.011672575026750565,
0.10827284306287766,
0.4706583321094513,
0.04671841487288475,
0.13273568451404572,
-0.519245445728302,
-0.18905174732208252,
0.3023485541343689,
-0.34709659218788147,
-0.30053725838661194,
0.6193209886550903,
0.11722816526889801,
-0.5551127791404724,
0.8145876526832581,
-0.17054951190948486,
-0.5737362504005432,
0.7013500332832336,
0.4159473180770874,
0.8527148365974426,
-0.318851113319397,
-0.035066939890384674,
0.040696289390325546,
0.6826821565628052,
-0.13815955817699432,
0.054450783878564835,
0.32082507014274597,
-0.9035698771476746,
-0.4276356101036072,
-0.5432841181755066,
-0.3449367880821228,
0.872098445892334,
-0.8080023527145386,
0.48588699102401733,
-0.13219040632247925,
-0.43992412090301514,
0.22540967166423798,
-0.4303000867366791,
-1.2730282545089722,
0.4728796184062958,
0.2502965033054352,
0.751926839351654,
-1.2346055507659912,
0.8297847509384155,
0.7560487389564514,
-0.2595807611942291,
-0.9585737586021423,
-0.05656114220619202,
-0.14347580075263977,
-0.3086310029029846,
0.7520644068717957,
0.3439697027206421,
-0.2603696286678314,
-0.19162330031394958,
-0.4081040024757385,
-0.5662614703178406,
0.7443628907203674,
0.8347301483154297,
-0.44342827796936035,
-0.3067001700401306,
0.24363650381565094,
0.8438464999198914,
-0.23483003675937653,
0.31540557742118835,
0.5447054505348206,
0.48938238620758057,
-0.1920238882303238,
-1.2623438835144043,
0.08595871180295944,
-0.4528235197067261,
0.1284717172384262,
0.03982171416282654,
-0.2803909480571747,
1.0492085218429565,
0.09301618486642838,
-0.2068861573934555,
-0.18165439367294312,
0.7950184345245361,
0.27216842770576477,
0.5859089493751526,
0.9998763799667358,
0.5530601143836975,
0.6597004532814026,
-0.05833881348371506,
0.8774158954620361,
0.21211357414722443,
0.32090821862220764,
1.1384505033493042,
-0.3380559980869293,
0.7989823222160339,
0.869621217250824,
-0.2240101546049118,
0.5385354161262512,
0.6422443985939026,
0.0025618926156312227,
0.05535465106368065,
0.6948437690734863,
-0.010406110435724258,
-0.3234839141368866,
-0.15237750113010406,
-0.6434854865074158,
0.8506693243980408,
0.37493187189102173,
-0.2168368250131607,
-0.18598823249340057,
0.09504523128271103,
-0.11141672730445862,
0.20541511476039886,
0.04893571510910988,
0.3000897765159607,
0.1619093269109726,
-0.8287883400917053,
0.8430120944976807,
0.1429784595966339,
0.6715685725212097,
-0.685847818851471,
-0.2139708697795868,
0.11386362463235855,
-0.11936622858047485,
0.24842050671577454,
-0.22295328974723816,
0.401956707239151,
0.07454521209001541,
0.10635232925415039,
-0.22046801447868347,
0.6005521416664124,
-0.18987953662872314,
-0.26804447174072266,
0.5279697775840759,
0.8858372569084167,
0.28711259365081787,
-0.5081582069396973,
-0.8083290457725525,
0.05844363570213318,
-0.2661679983139038,
-0.27051806449890137,
0.31769728660583496,
0.6050369143486023,
-0.23662036657333374,
0.9041274189949036,
0.391363263130188,
0.0057019260711967945,
-0.019395235925912857,
-0.1431291550397873,
0.8493447303771973,
-0.68535315990448,
-0.6323800086975098,
-0.668984591960907,
0.14329244196414948,
0.12176262587308884,
-0.6027121543884277,
0.5048165321350098,
0.2737465500831604,
0.9083633422851562,
-0.3885912001132965,
0.417301744222641,
0.11450859159231186,
0.34731611609458923,
-0.5941711664199829,
0.662634015083313,
-0.6982529759407043,
0.48666301369667053,
-0.5873625874519348,
-0.9767032861709595,
-0.1494865119457245,
0.6295203566551208,
-0.14979736506938934,
0.035053517669439316,
0.8335444331169128,
0.4693058729171753,
-0.1785157322883606,
-0.01940268464386463,
0.10585217922925949,
0.35076943039894104,
0.1862250119447708,
0.5417892932891846,
0.9700396060943604,
-0.46028122305870056,
0.3693998456001282,
-0.4104987382888794,
0.2848748564720154,
-0.09861677139997482,
-1.314706563949585,
-0.5936257243156433,
-0.822719931602478,
-0.507891058921814,
-0.44149500131607056,
0.036240894347429276,
0.8558169603347778,
0.6362081170082092,
-0.7564666867256165,
-0.17842735350131989,
-0.17896169424057007,
0.25642722845077515,
-0.47055014967918396,
-0.25633081793785095,
0.31324344873428345,
-0.26069584488868713,
-0.7361282706260681,
0.37282904982566833,
-0.044801779091358185,
0.0428088940680027,
-0.1900428682565689,
0.31382066011428833,
-0.17994530498981476,
0.32136455178260803,
0.3569470942020416,
0.21192114055156708,
-0.8455756306648254,
-0.5298478603363037,
-0.09447432309389114,
-0.07561022788286209,
-0.08679451793432236,
0.9929488897323608,
-1.2091403007507324,
0.476932168006897,
0.3919731378555298,
0.5600790977478027,
0.43809568881988525,
-0.16051426529884338,
0.7037747502326965,
-0.8527141213417053,
0.2831144630908966,
0.5407105684280396,
0.2501673102378845,
0.2863102853298187,
-0.2086716890335083,
0.5468911528587341,
0.6093180179595947,
0.007727148476988077,
-1.1462492942810059,
0.3042258620262146,
-0.9803376793861389,
-0.4238826632499695,
0.8937119841575623,
-0.2301907241344452,
-0.25330138206481934,
-0.19266203045845032,
-0.008154361508786678,
0.28823742270469666,
0.07416541129350662,
1.1153593063354492,
1.016973853111267,
0.07520037889480591,
0.2017669826745987,
-0.9338499903678894,
0.5362638831138611,
0.8876667618751526,
-0.5044516324996948,
-0.1416768878698349,
0.35455551743507385,
0.20961876213550568,
0.25379738211631775,
0.4124497175216675,
0.23333372175693512,
0.07304716855287552,
-0.2856556475162506,
-0.010941002517938614,
0.05575983226299286,
-0.19535811245441437,
-0.35806548595428467,
0.28166553378105164,
-0.10273732244968414,
0.027157507836818695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01738v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01738v1 | C4Q: A Chatbot for Quantum | 2024-01-29T09:44:45 | 2024-01-29T09:44:45 | Yaiza Aragonés-Soria, Manuel Oriol | cs.CL | cs.CL, quant-ph | Quantum computing is a growing field that promises many real-world
applications such as quantum cryptography or quantum finance. The number of
people able to use quantum computing is however still very small. This
limitation comes from the difficulty to understand the concepts and to know how
to start coding. Therefore, there is a need for tools that can assist
non-expert in overcoming this complexity. One possibility would be to use
existing conversational agents. Unfortunately ChatGPT and other Large-Language
Models produce inaccurate results. This article presents C4Q, a chatbot that
answers accurately basic questions and guides users when trying to code quantum
programs. Contrary to other approaches C4Q uses a pre-trained large language
model only to discover and classify user requests. It then generates an
accurate answer using an own engine. Thanks to this architectural design, C4Q's
answers are always correct, and thus C4Q can become a support tool that makes
quantum computing more available to non-experts. | [
-0.17180834710597992,
-0.9685422778129578,
0.9267714619636536,
0.033559899777173996,
-0.1168309822678566,
0.7778045535087585,
0.07990199327468872,
-0.5178287625312805,
0.16142238676548004,
0.4014967381954193,
-0.2803138196468353,
-0.138615220785141,
-0.31706932187080383,
-0.026270456612110138,
-0.46519121527671814,
0.6887825727462769,
0.45732322335243225,
0.14064429700374603,
-0.2607085704803467,
0.2668464183807373,
-0.36747995018959045,
-0.5765478014945984,
-0.957137942314148,
-0.1229509487748146,
0.2534502148628235,
0.6108535528182983,
1.3697823286056519,
-0.052768275141716,
0.3063321113586426,
0.35936209559440613,
0.17364756762981415,
-0.13991041481494904,
-0.509600043296814,
-0.07819332182407379,
0.013013649731874466,
-0.9567270874977112,
-0.21657812595367432,
-0.22205300629138947,
0.3917977809906006,
0.3696574568748474,
-0.21679164469242096,
-0.009618708863854408,
-0.027719669044017792,
0.7318333387374878,
-0.47369658946990967,
0.19424469769001007,
-0.5597654581069946,
0.1164422482252121,
-0.18372973799705505,
-0.3608517348766327,
-0.24792209267616272,
-0.6330410242080688,
-0.17573167383670807,
-0.9575260877609253,
0.26847606897354126,
0.3480347990989685,
0.5581826567649841,
0.2389160394668579,
-0.6382490992546082,
-0.27804529666900635,
-0.8421135544776917,
0.8774082064628601,
-0.6231352686882019,
0.8025428056716919,
0.359983891248703,
0.6171995401382446,
-0.4137263894081116,
-0.6083334684371948,
-0.7344658374786377,
-0.403645783662796,
0.18612328171730042,
0.2017417550086975,
-0.49569183588027954,
0.22860267758369446,
0.2129671424627304,
0.28223490715026855,
-0.5945528745651245,
-0.13723856210708618,
-0.5532260537147522,
-0.3948726952075958,
0.29871684312820435,
0.12183256447315216,
0.5125339031219482,
0.12663128972053528,
-0.08259761333465576,
-0.08868926763534546,
-0.6699816584587097,
0.13246245682239532,
0.32494786381721497,
-0.05391252785921097,
0.04399010166525841,
0.39821577072143555,
-0.525479793548584,
0.6796747446060181,
0.3960177004337311,
0.1862945854663849,
-0.06864704191684723,
-0.18523579835891724,
0.14871767163276672,
0.16323146224021912,
0.8580031991004944,
0.2569687068462372,
0.06295192986726761,
-0.1536380499601364,
0.04624359309673309,
0.04266657680273056,
0.5564529299736023,
-0.5406327843666077,
-0.6545683741569519,
0.7021106481552124,
-0.04441361874341965,
-0.2252708077430725,
-0.549583911895752,
-0.6349106431007385,
-0.48391661047935486,
0.011124106124043465,
0.4043179452419281,
-0.2892040014266968,
-0.26513567566871643,
0.0017212001839652658,
-0.48551514744758606,
0.3012201488018036,
0.5000358819961548,
-0.8494956493377686,
0.3999992907047272,
0.69352787733078,
0.5827279686927795,
0.28460508584976196,
0.09146138280630112,
-0.4645448327064514,
0.06058580055832863,
-0.6769686341285706,
0.6510782837867737,
-0.5023486018180847,
-0.3897078037261963,
-0.21731117367744446,
-0.3193654716014862,
0.47255098819732666,
-0.16089701652526855,
0.3749431371688843,
-0.9250703454017639,
0.42048195004463196,
-0.05152182653546333,
-0.6461735963821411,
-0.053254783153533936,
0.3740902841091156,
-0.6695370674133301,
0.48455747961997986,
0.048094768077135086,
-0.7856076955795288,
-0.2167835831642151,
-0.8160980343818665,
0.061324261128902435,
0.7463939189910889,
-0.4739045202732086,
-0.18054501712322235,
-0.0035941842943429947,
0.1259094923734665,
0.06397431343793869,
-0.36987414956092834,
0.009554672054946423,
-0.3837215304374695,
-0.5292938351631165,
0.7352743148803711,
-0.23847845196723938,
0.7224430441856384,
0.3500874936580658,
-0.10546647757291794,
0.08063152432441711,
-0.4749181568622589,
0.4267996549606323,
0.11433228850364685,
-0.21223045885562897,
0.0736783817410469,
0.17062565684318542,
-0.24938659369945526,
-0.03264587000012398,
0.6463249921798706,
-0.780276358127594,
-0.19084729254245758,
-0.48608124256134033,
0.8477597236633301,
0.5494281649589539,
0.08962943404912949,
0.5711555480957031,
-0.4382830560207367,
0.860062837600708,
-0.08978823572397232,
0.34445667266845703,
0.2418348491191864,
-0.8495579957962036,
-0.6326661109924316,
-0.03104831837117672,
0.35342901945114136,
0.7301158308982849,
-1.1846016645431519,
0.11123213917016983,
-0.001434900565072894,
-0.7862461805343628,
-0.487550288438797,
-0.02131708897650242,
0.21303121745586395,
0.2954310476779938,
0.24393348395824432,
-0.1001412570476532,
-0.33304592967033386,
-0.9650651216506958,
-0.4624520242214203,
-0.4608383774757385,
-0.1824294924736023,
0.15322017669677734,
0.033927492797374725,
-0.2933841645717621,
0.6836554408073425,
-0.5422970056533813,
0.23514051735401154,
0.07885967195034027,
-0.20685046911239624,
0.3268871605396271,
0.5957136750221252,
-0.09379749745130539,
-0.8625768423080444,
-0.25570711493492126,
0.07899066060781479,
-0.7237766981124878,
0.4750570058822632,
-0.17451150715351105,
-0.5847505927085876,
-0.05713363736867905,
0.4044341742992401,
-0.819310188293457,
0.11054959148168564,
0.6501714587211609,
-0.06470140814781189,
0.3575775623321533,
-0.07208447903394699,
0.30791953206062317,
-0.8975768685340881,
-0.1885029822587967,
-0.18104276061058044,
-0.6096059679985046,
-0.5375145673751831,
0.33515164256095886,
0.2704293131828308,
-0.5079454779624939,
-0.3129817843437195,
0.4738582372665405,
-0.2038724422454834,
0.05838112160563469,
-0.2977326810359955,
0.3048555850982666,
-0.0989985540509224,
0.5382082462310791,
-0.05107547342777252,
0.6928934454917908,
0.5593167543411255,
-0.6902179718017578,
0.8035229444503784,
0.3719543218612671,
-0.05445847660303116,
0.5209247469902039,
-0.7762482762336731,
0.3733978867530823,
0.270944744348526,
0.2542475461959839,
-0.8845290541648865,
-0.16637560725212097,
0.44845134019851685,
-0.8682783246040344,
-0.1062844768166542,
0.005571383982896805,
-0.5551942586898804,
-0.4798038899898529,
-0.19403575360774994,
0.49573156237602234,
0.7294772267341614,
-0.38659393787384033,
0.5204773545265198,
0.5819745659828186,
0.08076845854520798,
-0.4316388964653015,
-0.3325698673725128,
0.19337619841098785,
0.052068132907152176,
-0.5613715052604675,
0.14262843132019043,
-0.483805775642395,
-0.029147563502192497,
-0.029335932806134224,
-0.09701720625162125,
-0.503099262714386,
0.3605944812297821,
0.3389558792114258,
0.1669323891401291,
-0.08113720268011093,
0.253720223903656,
-0.029268069192767143,
-0.021746112033724785,
0.11622855812311172,
-0.2125188708305359,
0.3975973427295685,
-0.5180822014808655,
-0.25799089670181274,
-0.6648874878883362,
0.28140076994895935,
0.30679476261138916,
-0.028811130672693253,
0.1838098019361496,
0.24240098893642426,
-0.3786020278930664,
-0.0011318582110106945,
-0.3228376805782318,
-0.3510502278804779,
-0.6046314239501953,
0.2852330505847931,
-0.5031208992004395,
-1.2964874505996704,
0.1265895664691925,
-0.022374941036105156,
0.21750378608703613,
0.21727439761161804,
0.6983035206794739,
-0.25280553102493286,
1.457935094833374,
0.5319403409957886,
0.291288822889328,
0.5267881751060486,
0.3216398358345032,
0.5977808833122253,
-0.4854937493801117,
0.020321710035204887,
-0.5646950006484985,
0.04083880037069321,
-0.8101654648780823,
-0.29475465416908264,
0.5093643069267273,
0.30815160274505615,
-0.46950817108154297,
0.333853542804718,
-0.9001337289810181,
0.45368432998657227,
0.8549965620040894,
0.23477473855018616,
0.29996901750564575,
-0.2578892111778259,
0.2632516920566559,
0.27750930190086365,
-0.9387480616569519,
-0.4924453794956207,
0.8477964401245117,
0.36345693469047546,
0.785990297794342,
0.36751919984817505,
0.7678631544113159,
0.34616100788116455,
-0.1632203757762909,
-0.6749517917633057,
0.48015084862709045,
0.6185634732246399,
-0.9787116050720215,
-0.5214693546295166,
-0.6324355006217957,
-1.129506230354309,
-0.03196035698056221,
-0.3526398539543152,
-0.44384974241256714,
-0.0016395504353567958,
0.562557578086853,
-0.6547352075576782,
-0.14237380027770996,
-0.7824758887290955,
0.9116834402084351,
-0.2458208054304123,
-0.12363763898611069,
-0.48107394576072693,
-0.41514497995376587,
0.47684013843536377,
-0.2685171067714691,
0.3585626780986786,
-0.03038032352924347,
0.024420250207185745,
0.5691525340080261,
-0.40750962495803833,
0.7982433438301086,
-0.03292810171842575,
-0.08689507097005844,
0.49801716208457947,
0.43131911754608154,
0.2740797996520996,
0.34276890754699707,
0.2515628933906555,
0.031133748590946198,
0.7655553221702576,
-0.808480441570282,
-0.6706467866897583,
0.7364308834075928,
-1.05352783203125,
-0.8732184171676636,
-0.544060230255127,
-0.06507179886102676,
-0.512448251247406,
0.08696722984313965,
0.05216125398874283,
0.23404225707054138,
-0.2491925060749054,
0.03743617609143257,
0.49449801445007324,
-0.4478462040424347,
0.028656572103500366,
0.5475680828094482,
-0.25925081968307495,
-0.12155985087156296,
0.9582414627075195,
-0.32797375321388245,
0.07123401761054993,
0.49408194422721863,
0.2852705121040344,
-0.2929517924785614,
-0.26248958706855774,
-0.6393507122993469,
0.08907683193683624,
-0.723833441734314,
-0.3192542493343353,
-0.5558542609214783,
-0.3320925533771515,
-0.40368035435676575,
-0.23623313009738922,
-0.394350528717041,
-0.6896530985832214,
-0.09317460656166077,
0.060657478868961334,
0.4940199553966522,
0.5147785544395447,
0.007065358571708202,
0.3367069959640503,
-1.289061188697815,
0.45439085364341736,
0.8985835909843445,
0.2001577913761139,
-0.1047031506896019,
-0.17591159045696259,
-0.429177463054657,
0.326496958732605,
-0.6570515632629395,
-1.0687919855117798,
0.01109014730900526,
0.21114036440849304,
0.5521105527877808,
-0.026148220524191856,
0.3344654440879822,
0.3811638653278351,
-0.3899381756782532,
0.9699040055274963,
0.4870469868183136,
-1.268521785736084,
0.4615483283996582,
-0.32414406538009644,
0.6572331786155701,
0.30180075764656067,
0.4565112590789795,
-0.8757665753364563,
-0.8071977496147156,
-0.8684089183807373,
-0.2746574282646179,
0.4694109857082367,
0.43890243768692017,
0.38065871596336365,
-0.07642389833927155,
0.3366785943508148,
-0.32774466276168823,
0.31380677223205566,
-0.648348331451416,
0.16654172539710999,
-0.5397707223892212,
-0.4198414385318756,
0.13582074642181396,
-0.03473550081253052,
-0.15265695750713348,
0.17663860321044922,
0.8274591565132141,
-0.27068182826042175,
0.5947653651237488,
0.04464335739612579,
0.003906337544322014,
-0.3581499755382538,
0.27020594477653503,
0.11996635794639587,
0.8234409689903259,
0.07904138416051865,
0.21288618445396423,
0.13787701725959778,
-0.2492092102766037,
-0.13472428917884827,
-0.1353386491537094,
0.0509895458817482,
-0.3733021914958954,
0.08965998142957687,
0.37127384543418884,
0.2785654664039612,
-0.9868282079696655,
0.6299725770950317,
-0.48927509784698486,
-0.1561918705701828,
-0.7820188999176025,
0.5394949913024902,
0.41706401109695435,
0.5541544556617737,
0.2429829090833664,
-0.00712461955845356,
0.5009355545043945,
-0.6935693025588989,
0.1367688775062561,
0.4788896143436432,
-0.46995455026626587,
-0.2563738226890564,
0.9026539921760559,
0.40423473715782166,
-0.5603926181793213,
0.756386935710907,
-0.2981959283351898,
-0.6816366314888,
0.47195497155189514,
0.323018342256546,
0.46176040172576904,
-0.041616056114435196,
0.3301572799682617,
0.5250862836837769,
0.04058002308011055,
0.05284687131643295,
0.4665695130825043,
-0.2922024428844452,
-0.8642427921295166,
-0.44209712743759155,
-0.41334787011146545,
-1.041944146156311,
-0.549306333065033,
-0.2975139915943146,
0.25494861602783203,
-0.7825229167938232,
-0.2093719244003296,
0.23790866136550903,
0.169991135597229,
-0.66095370054245,
0.10867048054933548,
0.2621404230594635,
0.33019953966140747,
-0.26924583315849304,
0.8461723327636719,
0.5107667446136475,
-0.2290164679288864,
-0.6425469517707825,
-0.5083125233650208,
-0.11608321219682693,
-0.889359712600708,
0.3179936110973358,
-0.17528769373893738,
-0.12222275137901306,
0.3091791868209839,
-1.2020344734191895,
-0.874163806438446,
0.7978823781013489,
0.15413928031921387,
-0.8508886694908142,
0.10444182902574539,
0.046372298151254654,
0.5277839303016663,
0.18641477823257446,
0.4341510534286499,
0.1162385642528534,
0.23848290741443634,
0.11336949467658997,
-0.887395441532135,
0.12603947520256042,
-0.24558614194393158,
-0.1589466780424118,
0.42313605546951294,
-0.7090769410133362,
0.7749186158180237,
0.08702976256608963,
-0.2701798677444458,
0.10917722433805466,
0.7240864038467407,
0.47580769658088684,
0.13748829066753387,
0.5404549837112427,
0.10634629428386688,
1.0420511960983276,
0.07755432277917862,
0.9799423813819885,
-0.70529705286026,
0.2653961777687073,
0.7818077802658081,
0.0331643708050251,
0.7774378061294556,
0.18268252909183502,
-0.34161701798439026,
0.5219734311103821,
0.6705285906791687,
0.1302666962146759,
0.18555404245853424,
0.20238056778907776,
-0.3735080063343048,
-0.6399440169334412,
0.36084282398223877,
-0.08588916063308716,
0.26864832639694214,
0.4798652231693268,
0.30224448442459106,
0.07046882063150406,
-0.14814110100269318,
0.0014625885523855686,
-0.03196290507912636,
-0.3132077753543854,
0.685165286064148,
0.29213282465934753,
-0.5360028147697449,
0.6617023944854736,
0.10840404778718948,
0.31893011927604675,
-0.33525756001472473,
-0.24580565094947815,
0.10315101593732834,
0.032643817365169525,
-0.19888252019882202,
-0.7354936599731445,
0.17461331188678741,
-0.15972833335399628,
0.06223404034972191,
0.17915819585323334,
0.5816835165023804,
-0.18800289928913116,
-0.470274418592453,
-0.1988546997308731,
0.6091246008872986,
0.5058357119560242,
-0.33976826071739197,
-1.0033053159713745,
-0.18616363406181335,
0.14881014823913574,
0.24527326226234436,
0.16924230754375458,
0.4373689293861389,
-0.1479092538356781,
0.7906347513198853,
0.7653652429580688,
-0.3515297472476959,
0.185771644115448,
-0.5258535742759705,
0.6889154314994812,
-0.9425011277198792,
-0.7498002648353577,
-0.5781760215759277,
0.10138344764709473,
-0.07663790881633759,
-0.210581436753273,
0.996724009513855,
0.48395538330078125,
0.49364688992500305,
0.1557040512561798,
0.7559230923652649,
0.18940109014511108,
0.705599844455719,
-0.3377871811389923,
0.4190323054790497,
-0.41780972480773926,
0.02688400261104107,
0.09899076819419861,
-0.7731314301490784,
-0.1606142371892929,
0.6214067935943604,
-0.03906538709998131,
-0.1701590120792389,
0.545695424079895,
0.8056867122650146,
0.22398479282855988,
0.5253693461418152,
0.6041814088821411,
0.25594693422317505,
0.5705810189247131,
0.8553836941719055,
1.340935468673706,
-0.2764214873313904,
0.6632720828056335,
-0.166533961892128,
-0.29363176226615906,
-0.3194750249385834,
-0.47986194491386414,
-0.7779912352561951,
-0.5110911726951599,
-0.4972107410430908,
-0.40101978182792664,
0.036605820059776306,
0.7448680400848389,
0.6735581159591675,
-0.5741308331489563,
-0.2546239197254181,
-0.144704207777977,
0.25004860758781433,
-0.10172812640666962,
-0.16858883202075958,
0.004010993987321854,
-0.425247460603714,
-0.6979158520698547,
0.4644116163253784,
-0.06072897091507912,
-0.05711457505822182,
-0.2987469732761383,
-0.10861676931381226,
0.2666250169277191,
0.31982627511024475,
0.3914567232131958,
0.6824125051498413,
-0.36630743741989136,
-0.34894564747810364,
-0.06528118252754211,
-0.22122900187969208,
0.19463574886322021,
0.4659326672554016,
-0.8857173919677734,
0.5480321645736694,
0.34947407245635986,
0.6451876163482666,
0.5225780606269836,
-0.1934746503829956,
0.8312135338783264,
-0.30114656686782837,
-0.12806500494480133,
0.5140196084976196,
0.03128857910633087,
0.31559500098228455,
-0.7445625066757202,
0.2356855720281601,
-0.10693297535181046,
-1.03154456615448,
-0.49582377076148987,
0.23635897040367126,
-1.0546553134918213,
-0.520545244216919,
0.8234100937843323,
0.2661178410053253,
-0.598970890045166,
-0.29366734623908997,
-0.33839234709739685,
0.2524668872356415,
-0.7175454497337341,
0.6239007711410522,
0.49284645915031433,
-0.35234013199806213,
-0.4078194499015808,
-0.9037518501281738,
0.6489054560661316,
0.3529994785785675,
-0.5726290345191956,
-0.26569536328315735,
0.6075541377067566,
0.24813194572925568,
0.2668425738811493,
0.9565640687942505,
0.06607574224472046,
0.6308396458625793,
0.1887906789779663,
0.3159697651863098,
0.33799421787261963,
0.2193351536989212,
-0.20296035706996918,
0.09469487518072128,
0.6669408082962036,
-0.21676646173000336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01737v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01737v2 | Assistive Large Language Model Agents for Socially-Aware Negotiation Dialogues | 2024-01-29T09:07:40 | 2024-06-18T13:10:16 | Yuncheng Hua, Lizhen Qu, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | We develop assistive agents based on Large Language Models (LLMs) that aid
interlocutors in business negotiations. Specifically, we simulate business
negotiations by letting two LLM-based agents engage in role play. A third LLM
acts as a remediator agent to rewrite utterances violating norms for improving
negotiation outcomes. We introduce a simple tuning-free and label-free
In-Context Learning (ICL) method to identify high-quality ICL exemplars for the
remediator, where we propose a novel select criteria, called value impact, to
measure the quality of the negotiation outcomes. We provide rich empirical
evidence to demonstrate its effectiveness in negotiations across three
different negotiation topics. The source code and the generated dataset will be
publicly available upon acceptance. | [
-0.3634859621524811,
-0.6180739998817444,
0.42239657044410706,
0.0209950003772974,
-0.1892075091600418,
0.15509718656539917,
-0.3816966414451599,
-0.9697535037994385,
0.4662095904350281,
0.5559138059616089,
-0.3022819757461548,
-0.343991756439209,
-0.4877132773399353,
-0.03913341090083122,
0.06387637555599213,
0.9285414218902588,
0.3639295995235443,
0.14374372363090515,
0.028060661628842354,
-0.30740976333618164,
-0.4337279200553894,
-0.396394282579422,
-1.1490556001663208,
-0.5135664343833923,
0.40386927127838135,
0.5190894603729248,
0.9807348251342773,
0.15358363091945648,
0.28979575634002686,
0.4013965427875519,
-0.4016267955303192,
-0.019127773120999336,
-0.4011964499950409,
0.24701480567455292,
-0.5592243671417236,
-0.21397583186626434,
-0.7605813145637512,
0.25423336029052734,
0.5905184745788574,
0.46994349360466003,
-0.35420337319374084,
0.10755307227373123,
-0.02705717831850052,
0.4359656572341919,
-0.3186178207397461,
0.5237094163894653,
-0.9999470114707947,
-0.1297397017478943,
0.26896607875823975,
0.08231198787689209,
-0.6814774870872498,
-0.33132097125053406,
0.08858887851238251,
-0.6769230365753174,
-0.30236634612083435,
-0.0003668104764074087,
0.6777639985084534,
0.2605002224445343,
-0.5526501536369324,
-0.29990968108177185,
-0.3015226721763611,
0.5859997868537903,
-0.7611442804336548,
0.32072579860687256,
0.5266565084457397,
0.38796043395996094,
-0.4213675856590271,
-0.7510321736335754,
-0.3552076518535614,
-0.5375798344612122,
-0.21260569989681244,
0.13158898055553436,
-0.32170987129211426,
0.28899726271629333,
0.326102614402771,
0.2201663702726364,
0.03540458157658577,
0.3041874170303345,
-0.3633746802806854,
0.03705022484064102,
1.0178920030593872,
0.09396883100271225,
0.10632569342851639,
-0.1503228098154068,
-0.15122593939304352,
0.30492645502090454,
-0.5238034725189209,
0.19861406087875366,
0.18585556745529175,
0.538047194480896,
-0.07727133482694626,
0.37680482864379883,
-0.185842826962471,
0.6714879870414734,
0.20126262307167053,
-0.09166460484266281,
0.06523352861404419,
-0.2262333184480667,
-0.34024542570114136,
0.08989231288433075,
0.4039905071258545,
0.3259454369544983,
0.4318057596683502,
-0.06352973729372025,
-0.27791428565979004,
-0.34075412154197693,
0.2706226110458374,
-0.5755767226219177,
0.06477359682321548,
0.1529434323310852,
-0.6609915494918823,
-0.3413342535495758,
-0.23696431517601013,
-0.5886848568916321,
-0.28226664662361145,
-0.5141704678535461,
0.452088862657547,
-0.18490424752235413,
-0.328983873128891,
-0.114468514919281,
-0.05101335421204567,
0.6633176207542419,
0.5526313781738281,
-0.6819226741790771,
0.47020989656448364,
0.417222261428833,
0.6063240170478821,
0.2574528157711029,
-0.23476682603359222,
-1.0583744049072266,
0.3480408787727356,
-0.33435794711112976,
0.6618816256523132,
-0.6400766968727112,
-0.6719781160354614,
0.003751708660274744,
0.08990271389484406,
0.18580912053585052,
-0.7307993769645691,
0.4520229697227478,
-0.7284277081489563,
-0.3792194426059723,
-0.23713073134422302,
-0.43251699209213257,
-0.14932948350906372,
0.5274726748466492,
-0.7862486243247986,
0.4791419506072998,
0.2159462571144104,
-0.21395106613636017,
0.5507424473762512,
-0.7738993763923645,
-0.5442628264427185,
0.5334264039993286,
-0.15265189111232758,
-0.40082165598869324,
0.1369209885597229,
-0.08297641575336456,
0.3435046970844269,
-0.4078081250190735,
0.1757371425628662,
-0.20304758846759796,
-0.3164389431476593,
0.47211354970932007,
-0.304797887802124,
0.642985999584198,
0.14495494961738586,
-0.2768491208553314,
0.5121431350708008,
-0.5847464799880981,
-0.05530839040875435,
0.06390009075403214,
-0.4495766758918762,
-0.16708795726299286,
-0.09678061306476593,
0.13259007036685944,
0.34738606214523315,
0.140298992395401,
-0.4491989016532898,
0.18695023655891418,
-0.19426189363002777,
0.2791653871536255,
1.0344257354736328,
-0.1461396962404251,
0.2531146705150604,
-0.3110118508338928,
0.6340620517730713,
-0.31819480657577515,
0.28157326579093933,
0.2586013972759247,
-0.3716460168361664,
-0.5292311310768127,
-0.5037066340446472,
0.18869246542453766,
0.18756309151649475,
-0.7799632549285889,
0.14212730526924133,
-0.1913318783044815,
-0.41043251752853394,
-0.6615309119224548,
0.018944313749670982,
0.48681211471557617,
0.2522067129611969,
0.21976499259471893,
0.05407162755727768,
-0.2350185066461563,
-0.8747878670692444,
-0.3979029655456543,
-0.12656757235527039,
0.16004236042499542,
0.35715895891189575,
0.29721447825431824,
-0.07324302941560745,
0.9570610523223877,
-0.18111909925937653,
-0.4577920436859131,
-0.4589286148548126,
0.1451280564069748,
-0.00013506482355296612,
0.30451828241348267,
0.5097954869270325,
-0.8892888426780701,
-0.7930087447166443,
0.08076632022857666,
-0.3338751494884491,
0.1452179104089737,
0.09669318050146103,
0.036699507385492325,
0.6737696528434753,
0.6795011162757874,
-0.30782192945480347,
0.5346300601959229,
0.41778483986854553,
-0.4681594669818878,
0.3955534100532532,
-0.4958551526069641,
0.11036209017038345,
-1.2095341682434082,
0.010832054540514946,
0.1796400099992752,
-0.42969053983688354,
-0.6371187567710876,
-0.2130422592163086,
0.011354345828294754,
-0.30646055936813354,
-0.5472031831741333,
0.5983285307884216,
-0.5657283067703247,
-0.2763077914714813,
-0.36188405752182007,
0.4403049945831299,
-0.31800320744514465,
0.29586610198020935,
0.356268048286438,
0.6896694302558899,
0.16239292919635773,
-0.7134894132614136,
0.1242896169424057,
0.42808324098587036,
-0.5619484186172485,
0.8853169083595276,
-0.8084905743598938,
0.1462707668542862,
-0.09166593104600906,
0.4467577040195465,
-0.672066867351532,
-0.23235586285591125,
0.4151621162891388,
-0.15223626792430878,
0.3713344633579254,
-0.4788039028644562,
-0.30718737840652466,
0.04931497201323509,
-0.17167511582374573,
0.3142825663089752,
0.3238767981529236,
-0.6821829676628113,
0.6710397601127625,
0.604195773601532,
-0.27005431056022644,
-0.4976603090763092,
-0.5266677141189575,
0.24089184403419495,
-0.15446002781391144,
-0.5412304997444153,
0.3391847312450409,
-0.37978488206863403,
-0.39248406887054443,
-0.10359461605548859,
0.30912455916404724,
0.031168926507234573,
0.15256783366203308,
0.07091070711612701,
0.07315542548894882,
0.26377803087234497,
0.0913301631808281,
0.06720523536205292,
-0.43767231702804565,
0.01671687327325344,
0.15042981505393982,
0.26307904720306396,
-0.22370052337646484,
-0.4628482758998871,
-0.262199342250824,
0.445555716753006,
0.7348976135253906,
-0.5256336331367493,
0.8330458402633667,
0.20483744144439697,
-0.38963782787323,
-0.009869188070297241,
-0.5259731411933899,
-0.08919324725866318,
-0.4699503481388092,
0.41385963559150696,
-0.6383864879608154,
-0.839423656463623,
0.5325047969818115,
-0.0770590677857399,
0.13065877556800842,
0.07007966190576553,
0.436931312084198,
0.4701348543167114,
1.1271227598190308,
0.6147081255912781,
-0.09415368735790253,
0.5857399106025696,
-0.07025927305221558,
0.3722913861274719,
-0.7617440819740295,
-0.37469518184661865,
-0.38059279322624207,
-0.28034308552742004,
-0.5386372208595276,
-0.3176868259906769,
0.4933834969997406,
-0.09138046205043793,
-0.03344878554344177,
0.04795315861701965,
-0.33522650599479675,
0.6209341883659363,
0.47270137071609497,
0.051450278609991074,
0.40536949038505554,
-0.2928849756717682,
0.2724452018737793,
0.02039961703121662,
-0.44432809948921204,
-0.48033589124679565,
0.5619217157363892,
0.44924238324165344,
0.7127349376678467,
0.5328481793403625,
0.23194541037082672,
0.14116501808166504,
0.6206904053688049,
-1.120723843574524,
0.6877515912055969,
0.17496421933174133,
-0.5027891397476196,
-0.6228826642036438,
-0.3077671527862549,
-0.9271615147590637,
0.24501460790634155,
-0.2156396359205246,
-0.8753719329833984,
0.2262476235628128,
-0.010901953093707561,
-0.13203147053718567,
0.12577034533023834,
-0.40610820055007935,
0.7481851577758789,
-0.3053015172481537,
-0.43514060974121094,
-0.6758685111999512,
-0.5867612957954407,
-0.026470936834812164,
0.008409794420003891,
0.3200536370277405,
-0.07853606343269348,
0.05985110625624657,
0.5402690768241882,
-0.2580941617488861,
0.9515500664710999,
-0.3521084189414978,
-0.2394787073135376,
0.04718579724431038,
0.2187390923500061,
0.774996817111969,
0.09876242280006409,
-0.4124496281147003,
0.03559539094567299,
-0.16383500397205353,
-0.41858914494514465,
-0.5321804285049438,
0.5484479069709778,
-0.4884583652019501,
-0.7634932398796082,
-0.33688050508499146,
-0.7028766870498657,
-0.23182924091815948,
0.05211542919278145,
-0.02662263810634613,
0.15268903970718384,
-0.3214165270328522,
0.3544306457042694,
0.3132859468460083,
-0.058385301381349564,
0.3888881802558899,
0.9218360185623169,
-0.0077062747441232204,
-0.4973268508911133,
0.7744414806365967,
0.40761855244636536,
0.39360281825065613,
0.05693155527114868,
0.13695594668388367,
-0.34273213148117065,
-0.49342066049575806,
0.0238705575466156,
0.20758365094661713,
-0.8743424415588379,
-0.41954487562179565,
-0.32711416482925415,
-0.2545568346977234,
-0.4002011716365814,
-0.5356824398040771,
-0.13824234902858734,
-0.16394633054733276,
-0.08589386194944382,
-0.4595150947570801,
0.47715622186660767,
0.8296269774436951,
-0.32903048396110535,
0.15324585139751434,
-0.7651169896125793,
0.006397624965757132,
0.5255531668663025,
0.5437582731246948,
-0.04076134413480759,
-0.45182251930236816,
-0.7417283654212952,
-0.020512444898486137,
-0.1059855967760086,
-0.678132951259613,
0.37575429677963257,
-0.07289052754640579,
0.9562482237815857,
0.28558287024497986,
0.30660340189933777,
0.38258710503578186,
-0.15609847009181976,
0.9065577387809753,
0.000893669668585062,
-1.306935429573059,
0.59356290102005,
-0.23052583634853363,
-0.07481179386377335,
0.43974974751472473,
0.2586311399936676,
-0.5234495997428894,
-0.1606748253107071,
-0.6393679976463318,
-1.026784062385559,
0.859150230884552,
-0.12334936112165451,
-0.022721847519278526,
-0.17057105898857117,
0.44496992230415344,
-0.022915294393897057,
0.22560574114322662,
-0.7858743667602539,
-0.018497809767723083,
0.05148306116461754,
-0.05434234067797661,
-0.15103331208229065,
-0.6585437059402466,
-0.15544246137142181,
-0.10337568819522858,
0.8780497312545776,
-0.3653353750705719,
-0.21019309759140015,
0.08974351733922958,
-0.2219763696193695,
-0.135858952999115,
0.4245692789554596,
0.38304418325424194,
0.746239960193634,
-0.021150611340999603,
-0.1277707815170288,
0.35942214727401733,
0.05471539497375488,
0.16333076357841492,
0.25363969802856445,
0.289913147687912,
-0.2369837462902069,
0.016264302656054497,
0.5948625206947327,
0.38905081152915955,
-0.8729844093322754,
0.37234067916870117,
-0.24413754045963287,
-0.4243248403072357,
-0.43706583976745605,
-0.252235472202301,
-0.028855066746473312,
0.7887614965438843,
0.030414748936891556,
-0.6675161719322205,
0.24877026677131653,
-0.3773164451122284,
0.2240256667137146,
0.7172766923904419,
-0.7050575017929077,
-0.04208057373762131,
0.47775834798812866,
0.47944876551628113,
-0.7163137793540955,
0.6563562154769897,
-0.13802899420261383,
-0.37984082102775574,
0.43783172965049744,
0.5763998627662659,
0.7215981483459473,
-0.3489142656326294,
0.35798460245132446,
-0.05229858309030533,
0.272279292345047,
0.1915694773197174,
0.3114822506904602,
-0.19488021731376648,
-0.6991010308265686,
-0.36497026681900024,
-0.030913831666111946,
-0.7659161686897278,
0.030270805582404137,
-0.7144625186920166,
0.36352989077568054,
-0.25843527913093567,
-0.06472235918045044,
-0.11572728306055069,
0.28729864954948425,
-0.5500513315200806,
0.025359351187944412,
-0.1542348712682724,
0.9883618950843811,
-0.5606500506401062,
0.9345934987068176,
0.8129997849464417,
-0.8010669946670532,
-0.8450531363487244,
0.10106270015239716,
-0.23894141614437103,
-0.4459609091281891,
0.8565226793289185,
-0.10924503207206726,
-0.3226239085197449,
0.06098034977912903,
-0.6218907833099365,
-0.6413806676864624,
1.2132607698440552,
0.8288061022758484,
-0.3959934115409851,
0.11949630826711655,
0.033725809305906296,
0.2856997549533844,
-0.2731306254863739,
0.3811342418193817,
0.5152198672294617,
0.6401634216308594,
0.1075257882475853,
-1.0457515716552734,
0.1828482449054718,
-0.21544955670833588,
0.05090179666876793,
0.020020725205540657,
-1.2671462297439575,
0.5412664413452148,
-0.02401219680905342,
0.29695454239845276,
0.07631148397922516,
0.5339382886886597,
0.3493598699569702,
0.33849355578422546,
0.6571955680847168,
0.13987381756305695,
0.8669204115867615,
0.2531592547893524,
0.8149797916412354,
-0.46188732981681824,
0.2298433780670166,
1.0930932760238647,
-0.39883020520210266,
0.6943691372871399,
0.38316839933395386,
0.2938644587993622,
0.24377010762691498,
0.5039120316505432,
0.29753223061561584,
0.19746308028697968,
0.5195872783660889,
-0.5230448246002197,
-0.401112824678421,
-0.5441871285438538,
-0.15108679234981537,
0.5241051316261292,
0.5311251878738403,
-0.22209839522838593,
0.044241879135370255,
-0.10037427395582199,
0.08341706544160843,
0.1290089637041092,
-0.3813593089580536,
0.9664186239242554,
0.22186020016670227,
-0.43943464756011963,
0.24011826515197754,
-0.05016320198774338,
0.4295099675655365,
-0.6713621020317078,
-0.28836527466773987,
-0.0930025577545166,
0.13495074212551117,
-0.1773597002029419,
-0.680523157119751,
0.2990201413631439,
-0.38444939255714417,
-0.19182464480400085,
-0.3106679916381836,
0.709396243095398,
-0.5595394968986511,
-0.14886946976184845,
0.677498459815979,
0.29527559876441956,
0.2226705700159073,
0.023459769785404205,
-0.6840357780456543,
0.11966155469417572,
-0.27017244696617126,
-0.4340759217739105,
0.5850054025650024,
0.5439916253089905,
-0.08284568041563034,
0.6466931104660034,
0.33049720525741577,
-0.04718814045190811,
-0.5156229138374329,
0.13056707382202148,
0.8445896506309509,
-0.6307741403579712,
-0.5105481743812561,
-0.36782190203666687,
0.7691634297370911,
-0.3561190962791443,
0.038182582706213,
0.5756420493125916,
0.40448108315467834,
0.7461452484130859,
0.197146475315094,
0.7081684470176697,
0.2881959080696106,
0.32154563069343567,
-0.6260680556297302,
0.8871392011642456,
-0.5729112029075623,
0.23262661695480347,
-0.3443126678466797,
-0.5504359602928162,
-0.1326671689748764,
0.813027560710907,
-0.3900883197784424,
0.09534728527069092,
0.348535418510437,
0.7557255029678345,
-0.06971023231744766,
0.07273874431848526,
0.8093026876449585,
0.1427241712808609,
0.7187749743461609,
0.2513487637042999,
0.6912757754325867,
-0.12994644045829773,
0.6983281373977661,
0.07588914781808853,
-0.35319602489471436,
-0.40481674671173096,
-0.9762842059135437,
-0.7727941274642944,
-0.597511351108551,
-0.5155969858169556,
-0.5279462337493896,
0.09038711339235306,
1.4720560312271118,
0.8326546549797058,
-0.26106691360473633,
-0.4668527841567993,
0.18105298280715942,
0.3193533420562744,
-0.23152393102645874,
-0.21137438714504242,
0.16436778008937836,
-0.46126458048820496,
-0.8928033709526062,
0.6584266424179077,
0.2974109947681427,
0.042054709047079086,
-0.10319267213344574,
-0.3070576786994934,
-0.1640172153711319,
0.3302624821662903,
0.8314415812492371,
0.24605132639408112,
-0.5033202171325684,
-0.5205973386764526,
-0.4932600259780884,
0.2668648362159729,
-0.014192690141499043,
0.9745047688484192,
-0.635457456111908,
0.3327435851097107,
0.007988984696567059,
0.6282154321670532,
0.38799184560775757,
-0.42923563718795776,
0.7130681872367859,
-0.49369749426841736,
0.37802785634994507,
0.24837440252304077,
0.4123183488845825,
0.08370304852724075,
-0.501980185508728,
0.47985294461250305,
-0.14326603710651398,
-0.6720876693725586,
-0.594952404499054,
0.5556513071060181,
-0.7082056403160095,
-0.31458309292793274,
1.0828455686569214,
-0.25346076488494873,
-0.001722079934552312,
-0.2500397861003876,
-0.3738173246383667,
0.16410693526268005,
-0.6538751721382141,
0.6509337425231934,
0.5942720770835876,
-0.15083624422550201,
-0.2476385533809662,
-0.12637530267238617,
0.5000870823860168,
0.24126626551151276,
-0.8041418194770813,
0.1243094876408577,
0.7702229022979736,
0.11382423341274261,
-0.045067135244607925,
0.9911791682243347,
0.0024172819685190916,
0.12007112056016922,
-0.19613809883594513,
0.019426537677645683,
-0.0291390772908926,
-0.28405359387397766,
-0.522781252861023,
0.051958899945020676,
0.6706274151802063,
0.03189057856798172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01736v1 | SADAS: A Dialogue Assistant System Towards Remediating Norm Violations in Bilingual Socio-Cultural Conversations | 2024-01-29T08:54:21 | 2024-01-29T08:54:21 | Yuncheng Hua, Zhuang Li, Linhao Luo, Kadek Ananta Satriadi, Tao Feng, Haolan Zhan, Lizhen Qu, Suraj Sharma, Ingrid Zukerman, Zhaleh Semnani-Azad, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | In today's globalized world, bridging the cultural divide is more critical
than ever for forging meaningful connections. The Socially-Aware Dialogue
Assistant System (SADAS) is our answer to this global challenge, and it's
designed to ensure that conversations between individuals from diverse cultural
backgrounds unfold with respect and understanding. Our system's novel
architecture includes: (1) identifying the categories of norms present in the
dialogue, (2) detecting potential norm violations, (3) evaluating the severity
of these violations, (4) implementing targeted remedies to rectify the
breaches, and (5) articulates the rationale behind these corrective actions. We
employ a series of State-Of-The-Art (SOTA) techniques to build different
modules, and conduct numerous experiments to select the most suitable backbone
model for each of the modules. We also design a human preference experiment to
validate the overall performance of the system. We will open-source our system
(including source code, tools and applications), hoping to advance future
research. A demo video of our system can be found
at:~\url{https://youtu.be/JqetWkfsejk}. We have released our code and software
at:~\url{https://github.com/AnonymousEACLDemo/SADAS}. | [
-0.4097168743610382,
-0.8475602865219116,
0.3736593425273895,
0.6420698761940002,
-0.2230558842420578,
0.3016972243785858,
0.06716590374708176,
-0.46456947922706604,
0.7867311835289001,
0.4853251874446869,
-0.49096155166625977,
-0.29071876406669617,
-0.613364040851593,
0.351299911737442,
-0.19911430776119232,
0.8746423721313477,
0.1804421842098236,
0.2684541940689087,
-0.07958196103572845,
-0.2991909682750702,
-0.6121973395347595,
-0.13558094203472137,
-0.8304591178894043,
0.09538121521472931,
0.3440781533718109,
0.6586348414421082,
0.8055350184440613,
0.16547663509845734,
0.2913684844970703,
0.3953271210193634,
-0.4174811840057373,
0.3753342032432556,
-0.4717654287815094,
0.3366067409515381,
-0.18453451991081238,
-0.4889012575149536,
-0.8964905738830566,
-0.2978653907775879,
0.5697399377822876,
0.4264206290245056,
-0.20154239237308502,
0.32647719979286194,
-0.018599478527903557,
0.8475514054298401,
-0.690726637840271,
0.1759108304977417,
-0.12810266017913818,
0.08189620077610016,
-0.18598465621471405,
0.02865581214427948,
0.02156306430697441,
-0.6981422305107117,
0.15780113637447357,
-0.47539713978767395,
-0.3241458535194397,
-0.2446194440126419,
0.7520546913146973,
0.34493622183799744,
-0.7278789281845093,
-0.2345980852842331,
-0.8586191534996033,
0.6053494215011597,
-0.6674487590789795,
0.5132681131362915,
0.5631347894668579,
0.5725364685058594,
-0.21978232264518738,
-0.3538198173046112,
-0.6871233582496643,
0.19349059462547302,
0.24200016260147095,
0.15687163174152374,
-0.2850099503993988,
0.015287124551832676,
0.0924314633011818,
0.4091431796550751,
-0.4762691259384155,
-0.12683521211147308,
-0.7831196188926697,
-0.4280204772949219,
0.6636838316917419,
0.25642481446266174,
0.5171476006507874,
-0.34808772802352905,
-0.21665839850902557,
0.3739880621433258,
-0.5258061289787292,
0.2151900678873062,
0.3406829833984375,
0.20725663006305695,
-0.4029959440231323,
0.26911866664886475,
-0.583514392375946,
0.49713650345802307,
0.006520290393382311,
-0.15484391152858734,
0.29298779368400574,
-0.11880974471569061,
-0.2675008475780487,
-0.010946923866868019,
0.5747594237327576,
0.5356263518333435,
0.3006991147994995,
0.11480839550495148,
-0.36130738258361816,
0.562095046043396,
0.16956157982349396,
-0.6940559148788452,
0.023937586694955826,
0.0838886946439743,
-0.5059807896614075,
-0.4239286780357361,
-0.48409008979797363,
-0.7293378114700317,
-0.46017026901245117,
-0.5117263793945312,
0.42326968908309937,
-0.13827621936798096,
-0.30994975566864014,
0.25138506293296814,
0.0026414894964545965,
0.16061381995677948,
0.5133914947509766,
-0.5225865244865417,
0.5160287618637085,
0.36258208751678467,
0.9216253757476807,
0.20253531634807587,
0.0026992512866854668,
-0.5813620090484619,
0.13885481655597687,
-0.37227171659469604,
0.7798357605934143,
-0.539731502532959,
-0.5996811985969543,
0.018676508218050003,
0.0388534851372242,
0.35257112979888916,
-0.7133417129516602,
0.7382388114929199,
-0.7447941303253174,
-0.07536020129919052,
-0.49642303586006165,
0.0021728796418756247,
-0.034452199935913086,
0.47821375727653503,
-0.6098147630691528,
0.7076091766357422,
-0.3212498128414154,
-0.48654821515083313,
-0.07101518660783768,
-0.8221825957298279,
-0.4472041428089142,
-0.09475568681955338,
-0.23521070182323456,
-0.2181931585073471,
-0.23807887732982635,
0.170070618391037,
0.06591466069221497,
-0.49672237038612366,
0.416001558303833,
-0.12635619938373566,
-0.40050262212753296,
0.15617693960666656,
-0.4467267692089081,
1.152408480644226,
0.6922023296356201,
-0.26784321665763855,
0.33263248205184937,
-0.7695774435997009,
-0.3894160985946655,
0.1735529899597168,
-0.23040851950645447,
-0.41402432322502136,
-0.068502277135849,
-0.06283169984817505,
0.2885867655277252,
0.3883618712425232,
-0.7770010232925415,
-0.16164900362491608,
-0.1318802833557129,
0.336745947599411,
1.1057204008102417,
-0.09438668191432953,
0.3466825485229492,
-0.381992906332016,
0.7122602462768555,
0.16048146784305573,
0.745023787021637,
0.10598913580179214,
-0.5063204765319824,
-0.7087181210517883,
-0.6305987238883972,
0.029335035011172295,
0.7635788321495056,
-0.6911954283714294,
0.3828432559967041,
-0.06073101982474327,
-0.4979642629623413,
-0.4228098392486572,
0.27108752727508545,
0.32264405488967896,
0.26600325107574463,
0.013065347447991371,
-0.8109250664710999,
-0.8468424081802368,
-0.8464532494544983,
-0.014017409645020962,
-0.37804338335990906,
-0.019763490185141563,
0.21444441378116608,
-0.049668051302433014,
-0.7789663076400757,
1.2709414958953857,
-0.44002604484558105,
-0.4681279957294464,
-0.05725857987999916,
-0.03751518204808235,
-0.10363069176673889,
0.3521159589290619,
0.3850095272064209,
-0.8520696759223938,
-0.48960351943969727,
-0.2659977078437805,
-1.0205357074737549,
-0.45171627402305603,
0.2298526167869568,
-0.3838539123535156,
0.02827606536448002,
0.43364718556404114,
-0.38675829768180847,
0.49920034408569336,
0.6478239297866821,
-0.32963475584983826,
0.7592430710792542,
0.03833405673503876,
0.24409270286560059,
-1.306860089302063,
-0.1351361721754074,
-0.12913839519023895,
-0.2602459490299225,
-0.634181797504425,
-0.43309199810028076,
-0.2822299003601074,
-0.4363134801387787,
-0.362970769405365,
0.26015666127204895,
-0.25738462805747986,
-0.19349269568920135,
-0.12337799370288849,
0.3371746838092804,
0.052592381834983826,
0.477580726146698,
-0.18771801888942719,
0.7930312156677246,
0.7344763278961182,
-0.5982950925827026,
0.4376680850982666,
0.6258907914161682,
-0.24619868397712708,
1.0452874898910522,
-0.7225729823112488,
0.09591508656740189,
-0.07188715785741806,
0.5344212055206299,
-0.7623447179794312,
0.010008897632360458,
0.3651042878627777,
-0.32967498898506165,
-0.26085224747657776,
-0.007815240882337093,
-0.29996898770332336,
0.11271420121192932,
-0.32417428493499756,
0.7218635678291321,
0.345209538936615,
-0.3930535912513733,
0.7189815044403076,
1.0304160118103027,
-0.6957041025161743,
-0.523648202419281,
-0.2161419540643692,
0.41310954093933105,
-0.03904160112142563,
-0.8956372737884521,
-0.29579848051071167,
-0.2877674698829651,
-0.3681896924972534,
-0.37957078218460083,
-0.13544665277004242,
-0.12397640943527222,
0.24149255454540253,
0.32260215282440186,
0.25260791182518005,
-0.18797114491462708,
-0.053682807832956314,
0.466409295797348,
-0.1557493805885315,
0.1386641263961792,
0.09650356322526932,
0.5312630534172058,
-0.6218090653419495,
-0.30903130769729614,
-0.9149643182754517,
0.7511616349220276,
0.9978296756744385,
-0.455600380897522,
0.3677493631839752,
0.2818656861782074,
-0.396585077047348,
0.25785180926322937,
-0.4615144729614258,
-0.010131984017789364,
-0.5609713196754456,
0.0701189935207367,
-0.45209094882011414,
-0.7386952638626099,
0.7831340432167053,
-0.2739119231700897,
0.05493771284818649,
-0.11937791109085083,
0.5050337910652161,
-0.08410319685935974,
1.2605291604995728,
0.762822151184082,
-0.08527345210313797,
0.6584901809692383,
-0.08548460900783539,
0.5305601954460144,
-0.7672485113143921,
-0.2703419625759125,
-0.46886807680130005,
-0.40311166644096375,
-0.48715725541114807,
-0.4234411120414734,
0.6974048614501953,
-0.20515720546245575,
-0.2354070246219635,
0.06604566425085068,
-0.09799032658338547,
0.3597135543823242,
0.3883184790611267,
0.017226994037628174,
0.46724289655685425,
-0.36032792925834656,
0.09983265399932861,
-0.0003928082878701389,
-0.4285265803337097,
-0.8644460439682007,
0.6192328929901123,
0.4952055811882019,
1.0773168802261353,
0.6682734489440918,
0.6752743721008301,
0.6727622151374817,
0.20756256580352783,
-0.8485971093177795,
0.949916660785675,
0.11188399791717529,
-0.49246346950531006,
-0.3017706573009491,
-0.3596084713935852,
-1.0006651878356934,
0.13805916905403137,
0.04537324234843254,
-0.7836735248565674,
0.8036842942237854,
0.17132630944252014,
-0.36184683442115784,
0.12739317119121552,
-0.6168391704559326,
0.8126710057258606,
-0.020526355132460594,
-0.1622781604528427,
-0.47627052664756775,
-0.8349612951278687,
0.27682656049728394,
0.12286844849586487,
0.3824058771133423,
-0.19737330079078674,
0.3669253885746002,
0.8016877770423889,
-0.2410125434398651,
1.2348337173461914,
-0.22994734346866608,
-0.4322929382324219,
0.2206142544746399,
0.5076141953468323,
0.3396638333797455,
0.07128099352121353,
0.1896725445985794,
0.31852155923843384,
0.3537295162677765,
-0.5959475040435791,
-0.518760621547699,
0.458425909280777,
-1.0268774032592773,
-0.7420139908790588,
-0.387905091047287,
-0.7507064342498779,
-0.2962262034416199,
0.1378667801618576,
-0.45839694142341614,
0.4825841188430786,
-0.44027188420295715,
-0.052165862172842026,
0.700440526008606,
-0.12775461375713348,
-0.21359197795391083,
0.8015425801277161,
-0.4619543254375458,
-0.1868162602186203,
0.9817941188812256,
0.08442763984203339,
0.34916821122169495,
-0.07288175821304321,
0.13774485886096954,
0.03686104342341423,
-0.13463175296783447,
-0.4989437460899353,
0.27984732389450073,
-0.7610529661178589,
-0.31505805253982544,
-0.7079450488090515,
0.04535173252224922,
-0.9209826588630676,
-0.24477814137935638,
-0.3763400614261627,
-0.45681777596473694,
0.07938677072525024,
-0.10373806208372116,
0.11869634687900543,
0.5675060749053955,
-0.440470814704895,
0.13523194193840027,
-0.9056223630905151,
0.4953414797782898,
0.7049265503883362,
0.35400164127349854,
-0.2868799865245819,
-0.444708913564682,
-0.2718238830566406,
0.2285664975643158,
-0.42838606238365173,
-1.0949723720550537,
0.16128569841384888,
-0.026681337505578995,
0.3218635320663452,
0.761152446269989,
0.24746552109718323,
0.6453385353088379,
-0.49645382165908813,
0.7222878336906433,
0.002595720114186406,
-1.1130361557006836,
0.7171270251274109,
-0.28602731227874756,
0.0734940692782402,
0.39975935220718384,
0.10853379964828491,
-1.011229157447815,
-0.7698199152946472,
-0.5482648015022278,
-0.6513897776603699,
0.8149901628494263,
0.05826196074485779,
0.19745343923568726,
-0.14015930891036987,
-0.09065621346235275,
-0.17868982255458832,
0.0448925755918026,
-0.3331223428249359,
-0.05271460860967636,
-0.1943904012441635,
-0.16329321265220642,
0.06442994624376297,
-0.417236328125,
-0.6315940022468567,
0.07791714370250702,
0.8881980180740356,
-0.13200126588344574,
0.015996823087334633,
0.21820488572120667,
-0.35472068190574646,
-0.31857067346572876,
0.4108175039291382,
0.5122610330581665,
0.568267822265625,
-0.22746942937374115,
0.09498616307973862,
0.1621941775083542,
-0.4885528087615967,
0.18423716723918915,
-0.1041627824306488,
-0.2549911141395569,
-0.020191704854369164,
-0.42389875650405884,
0.5279530882835388,
-0.0789814218878746,
-1.065651535987854,
0.44224563241004944,
-0.41236603260040283,
0.39758074283599854,
-0.22308604419231415,
-0.10742159932851791,
-0.10326827317476273,
0.530346155166626,
-0.0800551027059555,
0.3529609739780426,
0.5500593781471252,
-0.7915360927581787,
0.10428595542907715,
0.27615490555763245,
-0.3963242769241333,
-0.49815604090690613,
0.17317304015159607,
0.7005394101142883,
-0.7119606137275696,
0.19041885435581207,
-0.15592904388904572,
-0.7402373552322388,
0.4877469539642334,
0.6699716448783875,
0.8829545974731445,
-0.5871506929397583,
0.7436748743057251,
-0.0046729352325201035,
0.42509031295776367,
0.23381584882736206,
0.4875592291355133,
-0.5158160924911499,
-0.9473384618759155,
0.00847561750560999,
-0.6268637776374817,
-0.6398568749427795,
-0.4477015733718872,
-0.9700599312782288,
0.21047210693359375,
-0.48730018734931946,
-0.14172297716140747,
-0.20291569828987122,
-0.19663503766059875,
-0.3208143711090088,
0.11855581402778625,
0.034909121692180634,
1.041012167930603,
-1.5124322175979614,
0.47131776809692383,
0.7299599647521973,
-0.4249475598335266,
-0.40389180183410645,
-0.03459684178233147,
0.37500765919685364,
-0.6448460221290588,
0.6202612519264221,
-0.199728325009346,
-0.7778970003128052,
-0.33624833822250366,
-0.284874826669693,
-0.7188143134117126,
0.8295353055000305,
0.46673059463500977,
-0.2090708315372467,
0.22228215634822845,
0.01142597384750843,
0.5816947817802429,
-0.04454412683844566,
0.014012251980602741,
0.7945566177368164,
0.25098302960395813,
-0.11336299777030945,
-1.197089672088623,
0.11987072229385376,
-0.5630336403846741,
0.054797668009996414,
0.10711297392845154,
-0.9899893403053284,
0.32076162099838257,
0.0053571355529129505,
-0.22253325581550598,
0.06397034227848053,
0.6235446333885193,
0.2340930700302124,
0.5562019944190979,
0.9213806986808777,
0.31566524505615234,
0.7581212520599365,
0.18978765606880188,
0.5709435343742371,
0.016809849068522453,
-0.05192272365093231,
0.7198185324668884,
-0.5880618691444397,
0.49477332830429077,
0.5147027373313904,
-0.08661126345396042,
0.6531043648719788,
0.5148907899856567,
0.7028737664222717,
0.4007362127304077,
-0.05190766230225563,
-0.4834207594394684,
-0.30688485503196716,
-0.6303995847702026,
-0.16272878646850586,
0.536103367805481,
0.5243477821350098,
0.2565852999687195,
-0.15645375847816467,
0.19305697083473206,
-0.06620906293392181,
0.21581250429153442,
-0.03622664138674736,
1.0340113639831543,
0.030215216800570488,
-0.47318875789642334,
0.4815058410167694,
0.05573217570781708,
0.5124569535255432,
-0.7322643995285034,
0.18238508701324463,
-0.6025697588920593,
0.07905520498752594,
-0.2314397096633911,
-0.48027434945106506,
0.4330345690250397,
0.27611976861953735,
-0.2769293785095215,
-0.12124956399202347,
0.5152904987335205,
-0.36674609780311584,
-0.16211864352226257,
0.3505253195762634,
0.45986998081207275,
0.3451836109161377,
0.4469987750053406,
-0.7184547781944275,
0.5548957586288452,
-0.09418521821498871,
0.23463337123394012,
0.2960677742958069,
0.5238856673240662,
-0.4676456153392792,
0.8017256259918213,
0.5805779099464417,
0.1082729622721672,
-0.06694325059652328,
0.4185042679309845,
0.872922420501709,
-0.3145274519920349,
-0.962516188621521,
-0.21637210249900818,
0.3742157816886902,
-0.15019293129444122,
-0.22782422602176666,
0.6440101861953735,
0.6271131634712219,
0.5357494354248047,
0.30097144842147827,
0.555871307849884,
-0.02712869457900524,
0.4721281826496124,
-0.12301117926836014,
0.43647250533103943,
-0.5590939521789551,
0.43357983231544495,
-0.47166091203689575,
-0.5964733958244324,
-0.20106863975524902,
0.630716860294342,
-0.33456116914749146,
-0.28863900899887085,
0.20338629186153412,
1.330986499786377,
-0.1046510562300682,
0.45393121242523193,
0.40867719054222107,
0.45425644516944885,
0.6722262501716614,
0.17859528958797455,
1.0240861177444458,
-0.23103147745132446,
0.6379069089889526,
0.11029800772666931,
-0.7484350204467773,
-0.23247407376766205,
-0.25946226716041565,
-0.40418821573257446,
-0.6067936420440674,
-0.23716436326503754,
-0.24422481656074524,
0.42929336428642273,
1.030867576599121,
0.5250791311264038,
-0.6909518837928772,
-0.6678488850593567,
0.3778086304664612,
0.26365265250205994,
-0.3590894341468811,
-0.2106429487466812,
0.15155504643917084,
-0.40489187836647034,
-0.9767880439758301,
0.4147277772426605,
0.6409702301025391,
-0.26462322473526,
-0.4770161211490631,
-0.23304283618927002,
-0.4391445517539978,
0.5638397336006165,
0.7797666192054749,
0.5017267465591431,
-0.5322692394256592,
-0.3233253061771393,
-0.11064434051513672,
-0.19590948522090912,
-0.029128341004252434,
0.7591952681541443,
-0.5556298494338989,
0.8425832986831665,
0.6020873785018921,
0.8191345930099487,
0.009522640146315098,
-0.2790158689022064,
0.7813544869422913,
-0.5882192850112915,
0.32426753640174866,
0.3377251923084259,
0.4797510504722595,
0.35733768343925476,
-0.24969977140426636,
0.1789349466562271,
0.2011861652135849,
-0.5950446724891663,
-1.1359659433364868,
0.6253576278686523,
-1.0804213285446167,
0.06701729446649551,
0.8458455204963684,
-0.07500459998846054,
-0.10428876429796219,
-0.5012535452842712,
-0.6940838694572449,
0.42933425307273865,
-0.5057400465011597,
1.328864574432373,
0.40799254179000854,
0.048916351050138474,
0.28132185339927673,
-0.3078451156616211,
0.29682010412216187,
0.9161587357521057,
-0.8846185207366943,
-0.007973899133503437,
0.7646577954292297,
0.35592836141586304,
0.4394649267196655,
1.110512137413025,
-0.20132659375667572,
0.7266559600830078,
-0.5003107190132141,
0.07491067051887512,
0.36900874972343445,
-0.458638072013855,
-0.3343380391597748,
-0.2948291003704071,
-0.1856057047843933,
-0.4886009395122528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15966v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15966v1 | Response Generation for Cognitive Behavioral Therapy with Large Language Models: Comparative Study with Socratic Questioning | 2024-01-29T08:53:41 | 2024-01-29T08:53:41 | Kenta Izumi, Hiroki Tanaka, Kazuhiro Shidara, Hiroyoshi Adachi, Daisuke Kanayama, Takashi Kudo, Satoshi Nakamura | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Dialogue systems controlled by predefined or rule-based scenarios derived
from counseling techniques, such as cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), play an
important role in mental health apps. Despite the need for responsible
responses, it is conceivable that using the newly emerging LLMs to generate
contextually relevant utterances will enhance these apps. In this study, we
construct dialogue modules based on a CBT scenario focused on conventional
Socratic questioning using two kinds of LLMs: a Transformer-based dialogue
model further trained with a social media empathetic counseling dataset,
provided by Osaka Prefecture (OsakaED), and GPT-4, a state-of-the art LLM
created by OpenAI. By comparing systems that use LLM-generated responses with
those that do not, we investigate the impact of generated responses on
subjective evaluations such as mood change, cognitive change, and dialogue
quality (e.g., empathy). As a result, no notable improvements are observed when
using the OsakaED model. When using GPT-4, the amount of mood change, empathy,
and other dialogue qualities improve significantly. Results suggest that GPT-4
possesses a high counseling ability. However, they also indicate that even when
using a dialogue model trained with a human counseling dataset, it does not
necessarily yield better outcomes compared to scenario-based dialogues. While
presenting LLM-generated responses, including GPT-4, and having them interact
directly with users in real-life mental health care services may raise ethical
issues, it is still possible for human professionals to produce example
responses or response templates using LLMs in advance in systems that use
rules, scenarios, or example responses. | [
-0.5069158673286438,
-0.899829089641571,
0.8322610259056091,
0.18477685749530792,
-0.3070984184741974,
-0.013957759365439415,
-0.24192599952220917,
-0.5118848085403442,
0.1171429231762886,
0.5448847413063049,
-0.6011319160461426,
-0.42237454652786255,
-0.23732835054397583,
0.18975414335727692,
-0.103024423122406,
1.2925883531570435,
0.09688469022512436,
0.4245476722717285,
-0.020632300525903702,
0.14190086722373962,
-0.6337956190109253,
-0.6760500073432922,
-0.9342584013938904,
-0.44212043285369873,
0.3939075171947479,
0.22188429534435272,
0.5228159427642822,
-0.3902866542339325,
0.2889900803565979,
0.2847042381763458,
0.07936541736125946,
-0.047681305557489395,
-0.34535741806030273,
0.22615787386894226,
-0.02751411683857441,
-0.3229585289955139,
-0.7723011374473572,
-0.00933131668716669,
0.11079276353120804,
0.2704666554927826,
-0.3002179265022278,
0.22084881365299225,
0.0948863998055458,
0.34211084246635437,
-0.22989171743392944,
0.09485623985528946,
-0.556452214717865,
0.28338727355003357,
0.3058014214038849,
-0.13869847357273102,
-0.2443419247865677,
-0.5709303617477417,
0.2956492006778717,
-0.361672967672348,
0.3291730284690857,
0.0005400512600317597,
0.44629520177841187,
-0.0496184304356575,
-0.6297509074211121,
-0.398467093706131,
-0.9921977519989014,
0.4820985794067383,
-1.1142014265060425,
0.0773172527551651,
0.3864792287349701,
0.4008774757385254,
-0.23729397356510162,
-0.5544970631599426,
-0.5440165996551514,
-0.2759930193424225,
0.006975436583161354,
0.6493080258369446,
-0.10814075171947479,
0.22338876128196716,
0.47689390182495117,
0.27376487851142883,
-0.463371604681015,
-0.19759932160377502,
-0.34582898020744324,
-0.2617046535015106,
0.609453558921814,
0.707684338092804,
-0.01029641181230545,
-0.2580392062664032,
0.0044324048794806,
0.2232159972190857,
-0.5258967876434326,
0.17174330353736877,
0.12986354529857635,
0.004289934411644936,
-0.01815684512257576,
0.5816156268119812,
-0.018008461222052574,
0.4103533923625946,
0.3959070146083832,
-0.4993059039115906,
-0.3566255569458008,
-0.3107646107673645,
-0.19793300330638885,
0.16244277358055115,
0.8606245517730713,
0.7971929311752319,
0.12399888038635254,
0.015066646039485931,
-0.0670696496963501,
0.13223928213119507,
0.5295997262001038,
-0.8480476140975952,
-0.018897971138358116,
0.27687448263168335,
-0.3864174485206604,
-0.3140568137168884,
-0.2456638067960739,
-0.6339174509048462,
-0.21541307866573334,
-0.4668324291706085,
0.050249870866537094,
-0.52208411693573,
-0.3277801275253296,
0.0953901931643486,
0.18579542636871338,
0.6466026902198792,
0.5207102298736572,
-0.7230974435806274,
0.45100677013397217,
0.4778002202510834,
0.7962349653244019,
-0.17831002175807953,
0.3592562973499298,
-0.37521666288375854,
0.17982374131679535,
-0.3282683789730072,
0.7252895832061768,
-0.31286299228668213,
-0.7504993081092834,
0.14981651306152344,
-0.18169479072093964,
0.07502050697803497,
-0.6096150279045105,
0.3913055956363678,
-0.2968665361404419,
0.4019160270690918,
-0.4077216386795044,
-0.33086326718330383,
0.23697617650032043,
0.6265986561775208,
-0.20352812111377716,
0.7996052503585815,
0.21010662615299225,
-0.7908241748809814,
0.057531945407390594,
-0.6548064351081848,
-0.4463549256324768,
0.14385288953781128,
-0.4808007478713989,
-0.20616650581359863,
0.15055394172668457,
0.13589589297771454,
0.3067796230316162,
-0.5355324149131775,
0.4889151453971863,
-0.3138890564441681,
-0.32711365818977356,
0.721506655216217,
-0.4054814577102661,
0.5137761235237122,
0.2558302879333496,
-0.41724953055381775,
0.07102877646684647,
-0.6155039668083191,
0.23308901488780975,
0.24789515137672424,
-0.5476783514022827,
-0.04379599913954735,
-0.2261488288640976,
-0.07581336796283722,
0.4087042808532715,
-0.07296035438776016,
-0.8045707941055298,
-0.18344973027706146,
-0.28170815110206604,
0.5370628237724304,
0.8099332451820374,
0.42055538296699524,
-0.07678013294935226,
-0.5073304772377014,
0.9020963311195374,
0.055347852408885956,
0.31108009815216064,
0.01613396592438221,
-0.5934864282608032,
-0.42549964785575867,
-0.16897019743919373,
-0.41204917430877686,
0.3224293291568756,
-0.8286710977554321,
0.221868634223938,
-0.02268034592270851,
-0.4697025716304779,
-0.47870948910713196,
-0.31533730030059814,
0.48478972911834717,
0.6766287088394165,
0.24603968858718872,
-0.42476555705070496,
-0.34908348321914673,
-0.7664276361465454,
-0.1800665706396103,
-0.28581759333610535,
-0.04050600156188011,
0.5542166829109192,
0.10626722872257233,
-0.049496911466121674,
1.0397111177444458,
-0.5885489583015442,
0.13955922424793243,
-0.36503130197525024,
0.04279693588614464,
-0.02041870914399624,
0.137874573469162,
0.3126926124095917,
-0.42627477645874023,
-0.5633677840232849,
-0.2187071442604065,
-0.6868478059768677,
-0.2390897125005722,
0.047517649829387665,
-0.11815916746854782,
0.1491892784833908,
0.22759340703487396,
-0.6557092666625977,
0.4437796473503113,
0.3854426145553589,
-0.23840117454528809,
0.932956337928772,
0.0727972686290741,
0.30550551414489746,
-1.268884539604187,
-0.02003202959895134,
-0.2062554508447647,
-0.3111288845539093,
-0.7036356329917908,
-0.409166157245636,
-0.3184386193752289,
-0.5155697464942932,
-0.5980204343795776,
0.31490129232406616,
-0.08824624121189117,
-0.2679518461227417,
-0.20237110555171967,
0.22355718910694122,
-0.22451969981193542,
0.6348463296890259,
-0.030143752694129944,
0.597968578338623,
0.21809454262256622,
-0.47088921070098877,
0.5820183157920837,
0.5008409023284912,
-0.20891621708869934,
0.9232755899429321,
-0.6933301091194153,
0.5600255727767944,
0.014622384682297707,
0.6707766056060791,
-0.8701407313346863,
-0.20257028937339783,
0.4655124843120575,
-0.31455856561660767,
-0.05461052432656288,
0.15395942330360413,
-0.3222447335720062,
-0.4290960729122162,
-0.4797372817993164,
0.371440589427948,
0.5424174070358276,
-0.1898086965084076,
0.3720163404941559,
-0.10655033588409424,
-0.45785656571388245,
-0.22050045430660248,
-0.5232362151145935,
-0.013268105685710907,
-0.31939393281936646,
-0.5853617787361145,
0.15335509181022644,
-0.5056997537612915,
-0.24480648338794708,
-0.1303238570690155,
-0.21424071490764618,
0.3683582544326782,
-0.10537870973348618,
0.30167683959007263,
0.3509860634803772,
-0.2427891343832016,
0.09162554889917374,
0.27658170461654663,
0.014628967270255089,
0.41562092304229736,
-0.00651133619248867,
0.775033175945282,
-0.33450812101364136,
-0.49624571204185486,
-0.24439699947834015,
0.4121148884296417,
0.25492334365844727,
-0.26096975803375244,
0.43366390466690063,
0.6809408068656921,
-0.13404670357704163,
0.21000319719314575,
-0.5365797877311707,
-0.41292184591293335,
-0.4318486154079437,
0.058289434760808945,
-0.30562087893486023,
-1.1372106075286865,
0.410186767578125,
-0.07720263302326202,
0.1804584413766861,
-0.060686275362968445,
0.9157865047454834,
-0.03459271416068077,
1.3272267580032349,
-0.0024205094669014215,
0.28050968050956726,
0.6296531558036804,
-0.08117924630641937,
0.5084935426712036,
-1.2061207294464111,
-0.0013548401184380054,
-0.24225233495235443,
-0.13314346969127655,
-0.6963076591491699,
-0.10708456486463547,
0.6824275255203247,
-0.2546340227127075,
-0.4806172549724579,
-0.09519445896148682,
-0.38532036542892456,
-0.06794928759336472,
0.301430344581604,
0.45547544956207275,
0.5712917447090149,
-0.13113760948181152,
-0.22069640457630157,
-0.16281332075595856,
-0.4891003370285034,
-0.675392746925354,
1.1867138147354126,
0.10079287737607956,
0.7267264127731323,
0.3560880124568939,
0.6835628747940063,
0.011625702492892742,
0.7377521395683289,
-0.9424290657043457,
0.8108075857162476,
0.4188312292098999,
-0.719667375087738,
-0.13628849387168884,
-0.33135855197906494,
-1.0154699087142944,
0.37889447808265686,
-0.1974988430738449,
-0.8494743704795837,
-0.17978350818157196,
0.073130764067173,
-0.47110453248023987,
-0.08502746373414993,
-0.36349689960479736,
0.4173283576965332,
-0.2640409767627716,
-0.29279279708862305,
-0.235724538564682,
-0.6321731209754944,
0.6181675791740417,
-0.29622596502304077,
0.05140208452939987,
-0.19018466770648956,
0.334897518157959,
0.5108770132064819,
-0.3769617974758148,
0.8466456532478333,
-0.12214960902929306,
-0.342237263917923,
0.40043774247169495,
0.20539714395999908,
0.2691439092159271,
0.4452812969684601,
0.04082043096423149,
-0.40553149580955505,
0.33214664459228516,
-0.23511938750743866,
-0.8015499711036682,
0.610924482345581,
-0.859261155128479,
-0.9552980661392212,
-0.3370800316333771,
-0.4029512405395508,
-0.5504123568534851,
0.03544137626886368,
0.3175015151500702,
0.6728436350822449,
-0.43625155091285706,
0.052856896072626114,
0.46715426445007324,
-0.5847762227058411,
0.022546445950865746,
0.9262715578079224,
-0.3449344336986542,
-0.5260756611824036,
0.47334277629852295,
-0.09765812009572983,
0.456286758184433,
-0.19970358908176422,
0.3229838013648987,
-0.0747203454375267,
-0.18890437483787537,
-0.062039535492658615,
0.4011542499065399,
-0.6697888970375061,
-0.3562984764575958,
-0.43519386649131775,
-0.23752041161060333,
-0.6797885894775391,
-0.17807964980602264,
-0.10175366699695587,
-0.11354226619005203,
0.19461870193481445,
-0.3613618314266205,
0.2756725251674652,
0.7245594263076782,
0.16641183197498322,
0.15131622552871704,
-0.7555611729621887,
0.20557384192943573,
0.3759976625442505,
0.13046230375766754,
0.17094458639621735,
-0.16766101121902466,
-0.3250596523284912,
0.2103593498468399,
-0.8842583298683167,
-1.0626517534255981,
0.23286642134189606,
-0.16282741725444794,
0.31526461243629456,
0.35437771677970886,
0.23201775550842285,
0.5973492860794067,
-0.3811262547969818,
1.1476761102676392,
0.3550280034542084,
-0.7047450542449951,
0.6381604075431824,
-0.5575307011604309,
0.37540924549102783,
0.1996627300977707,
0.18309900164604187,
-0.6995843648910522,
-0.732672393321991,
-0.6588853597640991,
-0.7056068181991577,
0.9135457277297974,
0.2302776575088501,
0.36265870928764343,
-0.3957720398902893,
0.6105236411094666,
0.010855214670300484,
0.28533321619033813,
-0.6437229514122009,
0.07019630819559097,
-0.3270827531814575,
-0.2988131642341614,
0.014809710904955864,
-0.08941071480512619,
-0.43650931119918823,
-0.040193527936935425,
0.5874707102775574,
-0.26556020975112915,
0.7067375183105469,
0.5212060809135437,
0.12350758910179138,
-0.41758760809898376,
0.4733794331550598,
0.40705594420433044,
0.27960067987442017,
-0.19437259435653687,
0.025326842442154884,
0.2626264691352844,
-0.3722885549068451,
0.2671175003051758,
-0.2032427191734314,
0.06873783469200134,
-0.2989884912967682,
0.16435706615447998,
0.7139456272125244,
0.16110166907310486,
-0.7668675780296326,
0.2892616093158722,
-0.3501085937023163,
-0.27777978777885437,
-0.40473857522010803,
0.18517805635929108,
0.1749511957168579,
0.44839486479759216,
-0.1361650675535202,
-0.38964784145355225,
0.36083945631980896,
-0.7400029897689819,
-0.237899050116539,
0.4836448132991791,
-0.26819631457328796,
-0.42906785011291504,
0.43943220376968384,
0.14871245622634888,
-0.5571348071098328,
0.7163479328155518,
0.21489280462265015,
-0.36681532859802246,
0.34604278206825256,
1.0245740413665771,
0.7001656293869019,
-0.24050423502922058,
0.43019023537635803,
0.3098889887332916,
-0.0904521569609642,
0.13193932175636292,
0.27997785806655884,
-0.21102745831012726,
-0.9452511072158813,
-0.1047961637377739,
-0.262912392616272,
-0.6417421102523804,
0.4081735610961914,
-1.0267400741577148,
0.00564519502222538,
-0.6388702988624573,
-0.609336256980896,
-0.302325040102005,
0.046977654099464417,
-0.7736609578132629,
0.14110690355300903,
0.10390642285346985,
0.42504504323005676,
-0.5410745739936829,
0.5691248178482056,
1.0343445539474487,
-0.4797084629535675,
-1.0308763980865479,
0.23488372564315796,
0.05872580409049988,
-0.6623556613922119,
0.17307838797569275,
0.016298750415444374,
-0.3427791893482208,
0.045370426028966904,
-0.6235628128051758,
-0.5901033878326416,
1.4719151258468628,
0.5031728744506836,
-0.1305362582206726,
0.008985046297311783,
0.33961227536201477,
0.8907860517501831,
-0.38090503215789795,
0.4442395567893982,
0.6396297812461853,
0.3095279335975647,
0.119339220225811,
-0.852613627910614,
0.3972059190273285,
-0.1682550460100174,
0.34275782108306885,
-0.035676009953022,
-0.8399330377578735,
0.40381452441215515,
-0.034538500010967255,
-0.11786960810422897,
0.17903335392475128,
0.1852932721376419,
0.5581247210502625,
0.3220110237598419,
0.30500519275665283,
0.18821075558662415,
0.47581493854522705,
0.1788433939218521,
1.0663164854049683,
-0.29947155714035034,
0.23204264044761658,
1.0204145908355713,
-0.583500325679779,
0.5819780826568604,
0.3661993741989136,
-0.14313554763793945,
0.38332700729370117,
0.7003769278526306,
0.24295948445796967,
0.2713017463684082,
0.2069583535194397,
-0.5181178450584412,
-0.1336570680141449,
-0.2066056877374649,
-0.26453956961631775,
0.12249863147735596,
0.3230786621570587,
-0.09425550699234009,
-0.025706611573696136,
0.10245789587497711,
0.12952524423599243,
-0.029399963095784187,
-0.035272326320409775,
1.084718108177185,
0.5264061093330383,
-0.8833853602409363,
0.4860076606273651,
0.16151948273181915,
0.3253335654735565,
-0.55805903673172,
0.17998039722442627,
-0.5783029198646545,
0.00966484285891056,
-0.15853574872016907,
-0.6595087647438049,
0.1791977882385254,
0.28435367345809937,
0.12291185557842255,
-0.08981666713953018,
0.7921877503395081,
-0.2839108109474182,
-0.22834086418151855,
0.3018176555633545,
0.6447638869285583,
0.2748422622680664,
0.1694241613149643,
-0.7430142760276794,
-0.1640174239873886,
-0.08376366645097733,
-0.5572571158409119,
0.6137471199035645,
0.375600129365921,
-0.21701832115650177,
0.5177013874053955,
0.5898219347000122,
-0.1324460208415985,
-0.06585036218166351,
0.214586079120636,
1.0095361471176147,
-0.7285649180412292,
-0.2662249803543091,
-0.5273950099945068,
0.3182040750980377,
0.025462809950113297,
-0.10390080511569977,
0.5318970084190369,
0.24496829509735107,
0.35255369544029236,
-0.05001409724354744,
0.9110268950462341,
-0.059585828334093094,
0.3756772577762604,
-0.5475308895111084,
0.13485568761825562,
-0.27168726921081543,
0.2164241224527359,
-0.4326295554637909,
-1.0446767807006836,
-0.024301452562212944,
0.5678966045379639,
-0.6537482142448425,
0.22300311923027039,
0.7555793523788452,
0.7195508480072021,
0.19241251051425934,
0.22142761945724487,
0.4435335695743561,
0.3189074397087097,
0.8247194886207581,
0.6218720078468323,
1.130529761314392,
-0.020591845735907555,
0.46743690967559814,
0.0901544988155365,
-0.18465904891490936,
0.0041112033650279045,
-0.5628634095191956,
-0.8965700268745422,
-0.26436319947242737,
-0.059278424829244614,
-0.4272750914096832,
-0.0010245430748909712,
1.2446963787078857,
0.19092929363250732,
-0.5457955598831177,
-0.19252024590969086,
-0.009166012518107891,
-0.48607248067855835,
-0.0398775115609169,
-0.24977120757102966,
0.029378077015280724,
-0.19788758456707,
-0.3839609920978546,
0.16718831658363342,
0.17485211789608002,
0.03542504832148552,
-0.2597731649875641,
-0.29685285687446594,
0.2556260824203491,
0.30386975407600403,
0.8364747166633606,
-0.13576559722423553,
-0.770875096321106,
-0.4216406047344208,
0.06653005629777908,
-0.06822829693555832,
0.17286191880702972,
1.0718817710876465,
-0.5825926065444946,
0.28924986720085144,
0.10464579612016678,
0.2607768177986145,
0.8226678967475891,
0.20849817991256714,
0.8667512536048889,
-0.3791286051273346,
-0.22580203413963318,
0.2931857109069824,
0.19196878373622894,
0.33852091431617737,
-0.4634518325328827,
0.4247617721557617,
-0.011210378259420395,
-0.6189588904380798,
-0.5090631246566772,
0.5716909766197205,
-1.0292779207229614,
-0.029314635321497917,
1.2057350873947144,
-0.38296324014663696,
0.15071585774421692,
-0.20316308736801147,
-0.8977593779563904,
0.4288580119609833,
-0.5843787789344788,
0.8408211469650269,
0.7661073803901672,
-0.684985339641571,
-0.1811784952878952,
-0.5400329232215881,
0.3960059583187103,
0.40691903233528137,
-0.8647160530090332,
-0.15313629806041718,
0.576657235622406,
0.5426939129829407,
-0.09900202602148056,
1.0415242910385132,
-0.41050752997398376,
0.1671496331691742,
-0.3752492666244507,
0.02967730723321438,
0.09197127819061279,
0.4252314567565918,
-0.1680145412683487,
-0.26505643129348755,
0.3046512305736542,
0.37836745381355286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15963v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15963v2 | NoFunEval: Funny How Code LMs Falter on Requirements Beyond Functional Correctness | 2024-01-29T08:47:31 | 2024-02-02T18:11:27 | Manav Singhal, Tushar Aggarwal, Abhijeet Awasthi, Nagarajan Natarajan, Aditya Kanade | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Existing evaluation benchmarks of language models of code (code LMs) focus
almost exclusively on whether the LMs can generate functionally-correct code.
In real-world software engineering, developers think beyond functional
correctness. They have requirements on "how" a functionality should be
implemented to meet overall system design objectives like efficiency, security,
and maintainability. They would also trust the code LMs more if the LMs
demonstrate robust understanding of requirements and code semantics.
We propose a new benchmark NoFunEval to evaluate code LMs on non-functional
requirements and simple classification instances for both functional and
non-functional requirements. We propose a prompting method, Coding Concepts
(CoCo), as a way for a developer to communicate the domain knowledge to the
LMs. We conduct an extensive evaluation of twenty-two code LMs. Our finding is
that they generally falter when tested on our benchmark, hinting at fundamental
blindspots in their training setups. Surprisingly, even the classification
accuracy on functional-correctness instances derived from the popular HumanEval
benchmark is low, calling in question the depth of their comprehension and the
source of their success in generating functionally-correct code in the first
place. We will release our benchmark and evaluation scripts publicly at
https://aka.ms/NoFunEval. | [
-0.3391658067703247,
-0.5891463756561279,
0.40368446707725525,
0.33264338970184326,
0.05235063657164574,
0.07947062700986862,
-0.15036383271217346,
-0.42995378375053406,
0.021464888006448746,
0.4464070796966553,
-0.4538007080554962,
-0.43098217248916626,
-0.11386636644601822,
0.20058274269104004,
-0.6363986134529114,
1.123335838317871,
-0.15438632667064667,
-0.1675945371389389,
-0.7245108485221863,
-0.37342506647109985,
-0.5038508772850037,
-0.47998058795928955,
-0.015384241938591003,
-0.1721154749393463,
0.5344253778457642,
0.8215532302856445,
0.6629122495651245,
0.23866111040115356,
0.19457381963729858,
0.10993057489395142,
0.23767349123954773,
0.1238493099808693,
-0.5711159706115723,
0.04254387319087982,
0.2365099936723709,
-0.686428427696228,
-0.27797871828079224,
-0.2279013693332672,
0.14219120144844055,
0.5571351647377014,
0.04329129680991173,
0.21597573161125183,
-0.005311068147420883,
0.7003936171531677,
-0.8447034955024719,
0.2759416699409485,
-0.46922755241394043,
0.2630046606063843,
0.16062040627002716,
-0.25599515438079834,
-0.39310580492019653,
-0.67901211977005,
-0.1955796480178833,
-0.33023306727409363,
0.2840781807899475,
-0.08227254450321198,
0.9492036700248718,
0.24289970099925995,
-0.21505102515220642,
-0.4913887083530426,
-0.37829476594924927,
0.7531549334526062,
-0.43742644786834717,
0.5463536381721497,
0.58509361743927,
0.23286791145801544,
-0.014459687285125256,
-0.4288240373134613,
-0.475158154964447,
-0.7532005310058594,
0.21754252910614014,
-0.32025226950645447,
-0.1235126405954361,
-0.0793442502617836,
0.5101733207702637,
0.5217722058296204,
-0.4253215491771698,
-0.1642618030309677,
-0.22738288342952728,
-0.20581290125846863,
0.6659163236618042,
0.023931704461574554,
0.1313362866640091,
0.059511132538318634,
-0.5941261649131775,
0.1944763958454132,
-0.8830187320709229,
0.2276989370584488,
0.3097712993621826,
-0.0652090460062027,
-0.3853530287742615,
0.3694647252559662,
-0.13675515353679657,
0.6233303546905518,
-0.06706912070512772,
0.03211696073412895,
0.4033914804458618,
-0.19675956666469574,
-0.4847836494445801,
-0.2747260332107544,
0.4298546016216278,
0.43634313344955444,
0.40512415766716003,
-0.4159516990184784,
-0.44306445121765137,
0.18341182172298431,
0.5096933245658875,
-0.4553108513355255,
-0.4096929430961609,
0.3926595151424408,
-0.18558631837368011,
-0.5466180443763733,
-0.05273875221610069,
-0.429210901260376,
-0.4867037236690521,
-0.05344267562031746,
0.42212826013565063,
-0.4510239362716675,
-0.22211076319217682,
0.08080323785543442,
0.21808941662311554,
0.32387641072273254,
0.3269319236278534,
-0.6341640949249268,
-0.02469027414917946,
0.4663607180118561,
0.6022603511810303,
0.0842602550983429,
-0.08369941264390945,
-0.5985602140426636,
-0.3890678882598877,
-0.4795854687690735,
0.7528823018074036,
-0.4096611440181732,
-0.5551252961158752,
0.06941699981689453,
-0.10900118201971054,
-0.18549314141273499,
-0.6354709267616272,
0.5832074880599976,
-0.4126076400279999,
-0.441037118434906,
-0.26865503191947937,
-0.4705530107021332,
-0.028004378080368042,
0.35855984687805176,
-0.2860681712627411,
0.9309626817703247,
0.1364896297454834,
-0.3760751783847809,
0.3260197043418884,
-0.7065178155899048,
-0.47076869010925293,
0.14625197649002075,
-0.5855743288993835,
-0.2871701717376709,
0.2700285017490387,
-0.24193480610847473,
0.35288816690444946,
-0.19429680705070496,
0.250053346157074,
-0.48491987586021423,
-0.6421067118644714,
0.7888292074203491,
-0.3073860704898834,
0.6279882788658142,
0.38079336285591125,
-0.4410041272640228,
0.002189570339396596,
-0.6746997833251953,
0.36373379826545715,
0.11154766380786896,
-0.16112151741981506,
0.03727530315518379,
-0.19256609678268433,
-0.06287679076194763,
0.17765814065933228,
0.15395265817642212,
-0.24938848614692688,
0.09396890550851822,
-0.3599952459335327,
0.5326483249664307,
0.5305520296096802,
-0.08443155139684677,
0.3090226650238037,
-0.607474684715271,
0.664690375328064,
-0.33287861943244934,
0.3476037383079529,
-0.21313118934631348,
-0.47160255908966064,
-1.0831489562988281,
-0.05628170073032379,
0.13136783242225647,
0.463152140378952,
-0.8803961873054504,
0.3279692828655243,
0.11262200772762299,
-0.4146600663661957,
-0.25970396399497986,
0.4869776964187622,
0.5169804692268372,
0.38429489731788635,
0.32778868079185486,
-0.5048457980155945,
-0.4089173376560211,
-0.6798262000083923,
-0.18113361299037933,
-0.18686510622501373,
0.04518537595868111,
0.36002904176712036,
0.49605873227119446,
-0.2658122777938843,
0.8492293357849121,
-0.30058521032333374,
-0.061399850994348526,
-0.12960770726203918,
0.1340072751045227,
0.08451876789331436,
0.24635827541351318,
0.5753595232963562,
-0.7752459645271301,
-0.13558907806873322,
-0.09827432036399841,
-0.7274186015129089,
-0.14279906451702118,
0.13621677458286285,
0.06354589760303497,
0.5797116756439209,
0.4203202426433563,
-0.12488415837287903,
0.29803454875946045,
0.3806147277355194,
0.08492141216993332,
0.6581322550773621,
-0.08846450597047806,
0.2035166174173355,
-0.3157176375389099,
0.6029840707778931,
-0.2294711172580719,
-0.22995997965335846,
-0.41690343618392944,
0.39051875472068787,
0.24734367430210114,
-0.33007004857063293,
-0.5029004812240601,
0.2994985282421112,
-0.3625746965408325,
0.04335688427090645,
-0.2071138471364975,
0.09493127465248108,
0.07604174315929413,
0.5252072215080261,
-0.1480604112148285,
0.7093742489814758,
0.5073478817939758,
-0.8412750363349915,
0.18234951794147491,
0.0011357888579368591,
-0.4871152341365814,
0.656771719455719,
-0.528907299041748,
0.30874767899513245,
0.11111705005168915,
-0.12508751451969147,
-0.9994875192642212,
-0.09317349642515182,
0.19654038548469543,
-0.6182409524917603,
0.07029551267623901,
-0.04719456285238266,
-0.4859482944011688,
-0.48421645164489746,
-0.3233354687690735,
0.2001357227563858,
0.5612064003944397,
-0.1264115869998932,
-0.26164212822914124,
0.18757417798042297,
0.2924633026123047,
-0.7341242432594299,
-0.913872241973877,
0.09484650939702988,
0.15014514327049255,
-0.4346853196620941,
-0.27319085597991943,
-0.27785250544548035,
0.08360054343938828,
0.022513320669531822,
-0.8000814318656921,
-0.40132662653923035,
0.417919397354126,
0.4272299110889435,
0.1952100545167923,
-0.43149304389953613,
0.15577882528305054,
-0.1667463332414627,
-0.08315203338861465,
0.24433478713035583,
-0.16878639161586761,
0.22786511480808258,
-0.3425982594490051,
-0.6702502965927124,
-0.3253825306892395,
-0.13373757898807526,
0.5560583472251892,
-0.14380963146686554,
0.47481438517570496,
0.33047184348106384,
-0.2365684062242508,
-0.3984801173210144,
-0.6702020168304443,
-0.07060382515192032,
-0.42471739649772644,
-0.07788898050785065,
-0.39246392250061035,
-1.0386550426483154,
0.31983256340026855,
0.08555085211992264,
0.0776047632098198,
0.134482279419899,
0.283663809299469,
-0.18467432260513306,
0.5785776376724243,
0.6732534170150757,
0.20507313311100006,
0.15485741198062897,
-0.376811146736145,
0.4302118718624115,
-0.28928548097610474,
-0.3962632119655609,
-0.842231273651123,
0.008886369876563549,
-0.16522377729415894,
-0.8049129247665405,
0.17274649441242218,
0.38379907608032227,
-0.11091309040784836,
0.5945104956626892,
-0.30711156129837036,
0.6011036038398743,
0.04126778617501259,
-0.03525426611304283,
0.30638179183006287,
0.18379630148410797,
-0.5283937454223633,
0.10073898732662201,
-0.8553494215011597,
-0.5652320384979248,
0.7913951277732849,
0.3868226110935211,
0.8202493786811829,
0.010861783288419247,
0.7763755321502686,
0.6310284733772278,
0.5776686668395996,
-0.706002414226532,
0.4174465239048004,
0.18683800101280212,
-0.45810675621032715,
0.1394835114479065,
-0.4660668671131134,
-0.6907728910446167,
-0.2448962777853012,
-0.0720655769109726,
-0.5763842463493347,
0.44588547945022583,
0.36312124133110046,
-0.5363783836364746,
0.05932662636041641,
-0.6822677254676819,
1.120355486869812,
-0.3399624824523926,
-0.6239417195320129,
-0.022146044299006462,
-0.6141027808189392,
0.48202645778656006,
-0.07862868160009384,
0.4317011535167694,
-0.21624460816383362,
-0.2136348932981491,
0.19429637491703033,
-0.5375105142593384,
0.8722553849220276,
-0.09543734788894653,
-0.4165833592414856,
0.5121655464172363,
0.483561635017395,
0.027313143014907837,
0.1803864687681198,
-0.2760843336582184,
0.1995929777622223,
0.03198941424489021,
-0.5577361583709717,
-0.6385653018951416,
0.8363339304924011,
-0.4829111695289612,
-0.44817259907722473,
-0.32856497168540955,
-0.09901228547096252,
-0.5031947493553162,
0.1250290423631668,
0.1956874281167984,
0.42202839255332947,
-0.1810821145772934,
0.2788901627063751,
0.829268753528595,
-0.18907025456428528,
0.15736088156700134,
0.42343127727508545,
-0.0780889019370079,
-0.29942935705184937,
1.0552572011947632,
-0.0551663376390934,
0.41571107506752014,
0.3993311822414398,
-0.22443529963493347,
-0.4414035677909851,
-0.2546384632587433,
-0.6758224964141846,
-0.09321959316730499,
-0.7790572643280029,
-0.5190103650093079,
-0.4534485638141632,
-0.23072968423366547,
-0.07431397587060928,
-0.424716055393219,
-0.17308194935321808,
-0.37081149220466614,
0.003316757269203663,
-0.006555342115461826,
0.3064870834350586,
0.7414218783378601,
0.09728064388036728,
-0.24178378283977509,
-1.0383148193359375,
0.09175051003694534,
-0.07060833275318146,
0.635077953338623,
0.22671601176261902,
-0.30905255675315857,
-0.41079261898994446,
0.10698246955871582,
-0.5504628419876099,
-0.8563573360443115,
-0.20182199776172638,
-0.037949007004499435,
0.8235419988632202,
0.46417495608329773,
0.3634800910949707,
0.49783244729042053,
-0.036237556487321854,
0.6900800466537476,
0.3563087284564972,
-1.3519725799560547,
0.5642178058624268,
-0.1357337236404419,
0.0727713331580162,
0.7924389839172363,
0.36775895953178406,
-0.6436091065406799,
-0.4150843918323517,
-0.49676328897476196,
-0.6705288290977478,
0.722793459892273,
0.4307352900505066,
0.24618858098983765,
-0.3138658404350281,
0.2960307002067566,
0.2239854335784912,
0.6308101415634155,
-0.7702426910400391,
-0.35884198546409607,
-0.30707189440727234,
0.04307733103632927,
0.12721465528011322,
-0.1779160350561142,
-0.044870708137750626,
0.068071648478508,
0.4285103678703308,
-0.2977781593799591,
0.5795859098434448,
0.45256540179252625,
-0.483079731464386,
-0.1316191405057907,
0.39103963971138,
0.9218086004257202,
0.760036289691925,
0.003942090552300215,
0.12265236675739288,
0.2742358148097992,
0.0486995093524456,
0.2686130702495575,
-0.371181845664978,
-0.021886751055717468,
-0.14628030359745026,
0.3010348975658417,
0.7546200156211853,
0.6622558236122131,
-0.8167855143547058,
0.6879181861877441,
0.11051229387521744,
-0.322333961725235,
-0.12174702435731888,
0.5068901777267456,
0.1100650504231453,
-0.18951962888240814,
0.1928672045469284,
0.4002240300178528,
0.014796515926718712,
-0.5632445812225342,
0.46882370114326477,
0.136331245303154,
-0.6035153865814209,
-0.20708219707012177,
0.7097007632255554,
0.5040901303291321,
-0.24153639376163483,
0.36445152759552,
-0.4752602279186249,
-0.2888276278972626,
0.8536770343780518,
0.32539674639701843,
1.018084168434143,
0.05396642908453941,
0.42137256264686584,
0.2096855342388153,
0.4371916651725769,
0.16921775043010712,
0.4586738049983978,
-0.6146231889724731,
-0.4012780487537384,
-0.3733510375022888,
-0.6311115026473999,
-0.553803026676178,
-0.006228289101272821,
-0.4877309799194336,
0.5123804807662964,
-0.8325183391571045,
0.015207633376121521,
-0.450117290019989,
-0.19147291779518127,
-0.5112085342407227,
0.08688657730817795,
0.15179286897182465,
1.269454002380371,
-0.6069170832633972,
0.7498641014099121,
0.714746356010437,
-0.7053793668746948,
-0.7746384739875793,
0.1920827031135559,
-0.12716247141361237,
-0.8827744722366333,
0.4283481538295746,
0.2913471758365631,
-0.4941898286342621,
-0.3105233311653137,
-0.5907208323478699,
-0.29011648893356323,
0.8501661419868469,
0.5559366345405579,
-0.5593854188919067,
0.2834417223930359,
0.25814664363861084,
0.639802873134613,
-0.3600490391254425,
0.20687547326087952,
0.146098792552948,
0.38556790351867676,
0.21144945919513702,
-0.9215598702430725,
0.10343223065137863,
-0.34820571541786194,
-0.06301291286945343,
0.13335585594177246,
-0.6663074493408203,
0.47880131006240845,
-0.6292162537574768,
-0.26304495334625244,
0.43034082651138306,
0.20335394144058228,
0.1389564573764801,
0.7835568785667419,
0.4260687530040741,
0.2787328064441681,
0.725314736366272,
-0.0565834641456604,
1.0253207683563232,
-0.5393008589744568,
0.6230666041374207,
0.7222307920455933,
-0.5581527352333069,
0.7381004691123962,
0.20085318386554718,
-0.10130522400140762,
0.5739622712135315,
0.4337804615497589,
-0.10228171199560165,
0.025214187800884247,
0.48756709694862366,
-0.14475636184215546,
-0.3269059360027313,
-0.0887843668460846,
-0.6654733419418335,
0.035022709518671036,
0.14420972764492035,
-0.11309487372636795,
-0.18614228069782257,
-0.16636019945144653,
0.017270520329475403,
0.15287503600120544,
-0.11524845659732819,
0.4073883295059204,
0.3538156747817993,
-0.5429129600524902,
1.2503511905670166,
0.14564217627048492,
0.3658303916454315,
-0.5603316426277161,
0.1660987287759781,
-0.5536842942237854,
0.07119066268205643,
-0.6667274832725525,
-0.6208735108375549,
0.4621829092502594,
0.20787575840950012,
0.06537333875894547,
-0.12216968089342117,
0.5197439193725586,
-0.2234436422586441,
-0.18534956872463226,
0.2937898337841034,
0.3952072858810425,
0.3286247253417969,
0.08507958799600601,
-0.8097962141036987,
0.2656153440475464,
0.0404212512075901,
0.4214994013309479,
0.09813963621854782,
0.39548757672309875,
-0.030755816027522087,
0.675679624080658,
0.6186758875846863,
-0.3977281153202057,
-0.07609694451093674,
0.14023397862911224,
0.7047588229179382,
-0.6459486484527588,
-0.40407055616378784,
-0.6362348794937134,
0.3548893630504608,
0.12442462891340256,
-0.34485986828804016,
0.8254122138023376,
0.53158038854599,
0.8597391247749329,
-0.2956235706806183,
0.5620037913322449,
-0.19865845143795013,
-0.184258371591568,
-0.43977999687194824,
0.7564624547958374,
-0.8905166387557983,
0.42401161789894104,
-0.29285842180252075,
-0.8817134499549866,
-0.45648083090782166,
0.6738708019256592,
-0.3119206726551056,
0.1830441951751709,
0.8548126220703125,
0.8506546020507812,
-0.07798774540424347,
0.28776171803474426,
0.7268161773681641,
0.22302724421024323,
-0.035403087735176086,
0.721040666103363,
1.0385358333587646,
-0.42235803604125977,
0.6645337343215942,
-0.03737262636423111,
-0.18153806030750275,
-0.6021227836608887,
-0.8917700052261353,
-0.7237630486488342,
-0.3609551787376404,
-0.5237613320350647,
-0.5812680721282959,
0.3173660933971405,
0.8598405122756958,
0.675112783908844,
-0.990099310874939,
-0.44428887963294983,
-0.38208872079849243,
0.502835750579834,
-0.15014614164829254,
-0.259513258934021,
-0.26978012919425964,
-0.6924262642860413,
-0.22097164392471313,
0.3475574553012848,
0.42896199226379395,
-0.1747264862060547,
-0.20895227789878845,
-0.31386685371398926,
-0.0002102917933370918,
0.1699126809835434,
0.41776585578918457,
0.6629278659820557,
-0.5231996178627014,
-0.27935439348220825,
0.24688172340393066,
-0.20279978215694427,
0.14264097809791565,
1.1046937704086304,
-0.5919931530952454,
0.2618100643157959,
0.4035284221172333,
0.798109233379364,
0.011470056138932705,
-0.42241165041923523,
0.37268781661987305,
-0.6546053886413574,
-0.12732456624507904,
0.21453694999217987,
0.16687026619911194,
0.2500489354133606,
-0.27660536766052246,
0.3929516077041626,
0.45004868507385254,
-0.5496346950531006,
-1.017789602279663,
0.3833787441253662,
-0.7353317737579346,
-0.0034779561683535576,
0.8600239753723145,
-0.3680497705936432,
-0.4013909101486206,
-0.45909297466278076,
-0.1529850959777832,
-0.21746790409088135,
-0.3631020486354828,
0.6124314069747925,
0.6275742650032043,
-0.35158607363700867,
-0.03681643679738045,
-0.5044099688529968,
0.5265529155731201,
0.7935643196105957,
-0.5296120047569275,
0.174672931432724,
0.440114825963974,
0.6069717407226562,
0.1899125576019287,
0.709674596786499,
-0.18890896439552307,
0.6737579107284546,
0.03781023621559143,
0.15002065896987915,
-0.12399236857891083,
-0.4269149601459503,
-0.4390122592449188,
0.3125533163547516,
0.5533782839775085,
-0.1481710523366928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01735v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01735v2 | VIALM: A Survey and Benchmark of Visually Impaired Assistance with Large Models | 2024-01-29T08:28:32 | 2024-02-10T14:08:55 | Yi Zhao, Yilin Zhang, Rong Xiang, Jing Li, Hillming Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Visually Impaired Assistance (VIA) aims to automatically help the visually
impaired (VI) handle daily activities. The advancement of VIA primarily depends
on developments in Computer Vision (CV) and Natural Language Processing (NLP),
both of which exhibit cutting-edge paradigms with large models (LMs).
Furthermore, LMs have shown exceptional multimodal abilities to tackle
challenging physically-grounded tasks such as embodied robots. To investigate
the potential and limitations of state-of-the-art (SOTA) LMs' capabilities in
VIA applications, we present an extensive study for the task of VIA with LMs
(VIALM). In this task, given an image illustrating the physical environments
and a linguistic request from a VI user, VIALM aims to output step-by-step
guidance to assist the VI user in fulfilling the request grounded in the
environment. The study consists of a survey reviewing recent LM research and
benchmark experiments examining selected LMs' capabilities in VIA. The results
indicate that while LMs can potentially benefit VIA, their output cannot be
well environment-grounded (i.e., 25.7% GPT-4's responses) and lacks
fine-grained guidance (i.e., 32.1% GPT-4's responses). | [
-0.2727971374988556,
-0.7139544486999512,
0.8596491813659668,
0.404107004404068,
-0.18246373534202576,
-0.37360256910324097,
0.029913311824202538,
-0.7677412629127502,
0.01947082206606865,
0.4876583218574524,
-0.7111528515815735,
-0.6519609093666077,
-0.6336867213249207,
0.44809094071388245,
-0.49689000844955444,
0.3793284595012665,
-0.01708161272108555,
0.5063191652297974,
-0.044240642338991165,
-0.24563123285770416,
-0.9182741641998291,
-0.5847304463386536,
-0.457305371761322,
0.20345619320869446,
0.5474671125411987,
0.48042935132980347,
0.6437147855758667,
0.1792334020137787,
0.6120880246162415,
0.38999977707862854,
-0.08452139049768448,
0.1218574196100235,
-0.28834718465805054,
0.038749586790800095,
-0.3077712059020996,
-0.36830365657806396,
-0.7959964871406555,
-0.1664753556251526,
0.777319610118866,
0.6147148609161377,
0.05148378014564514,
0.0837954506278038,
0.25547653436660767,
0.5456934571266174,
-0.6061567068099976,
0.10627789795398712,
-0.47315073013305664,
0.32894402742385864,
-0.15413415431976318,
-0.19895723462104797,
-0.2799240052700043,
-0.13452157378196716,
0.25831174850463867,
-0.8172541856765747,
0.13496406376361847,
0.3273724615573883,
0.7689794898033142,
0.4371204376220703,
-0.21757788956165314,
-0.16322176158428192,
-0.5395410060882568,
0.7661338448524475,
-0.609374463558197,
0.6407500505447388,
0.3431781828403473,
0.407290518283844,
-0.30141597986221313,
-0.40205082297325134,
-0.50156569480896,
-0.5374308824539185,
0.20683127641677856,
0.19039662182331085,
-0.08449967205524445,
0.10261791199445724,
0.5332081913948059,
0.07247741520404816,
-0.43771615624427795,
0.3074844777584076,
-0.5345563292503357,
-0.21424853801727295,
0.31612518429756165,
0.2333676964044571,
0.38368895649909973,
-0.5556386709213257,
-0.700125515460968,
-0.13777507841587067,
-0.8063734769821167,
-0.12546800076961517,
-0.13993500173091888,
0.14278218150138855,
-0.1185612827539444,
0.9704115390777588,
-0.1959085613489151,
0.8360294103622437,
-0.36045295000076294,
0.10454190522432327,
0.3767099380493164,
-0.5804490447044373,
-0.43472912907600403,
-0.14252232015132904,
0.5824213027954102,
0.5476146340370178,
0.27403128147125244,
-0.21034228801727295,
-0.2894473969936371,
-0.33689171075820923,
0.16924399137496948,
-0.7247358560562134,
0.07866792380809784,
0.06545834243297577,
-0.32264840602874756,
0.42250800132751465,
0.0000703092518961057,
-0.962907612323761,
-0.8187919855117798,
-0.41893213987350464,
0.7672547101974487,
-0.3479926884174347,
-0.0004698646953329444,
0.222831130027771,
-0.2694791853427887,
0.37370771169662476,
0.6823902130126953,
-0.41685751080513,
0.08895980566740036,
0.2802897095680237,
1.0916975736618042,
-0.19988276064395905,
-0.0842972919344902,
-0.9523049592971802,
0.23675844073295593,
-0.21713179349899292,
0.6798232197761536,
-0.2805787920951843,
-0.6125261783599854,
-0.12426966428756714,
0.4164828956127167,
0.17027996480464935,
-0.5641470551490784,
0.6031000018119812,
-0.18407392501831055,
-0.08545839786529541,
-0.45522719621658325,
-0.1074773445725441,
-0.11972904950380325,
0.2878355085849762,
-0.7988349199295044,
0.7462168335914612,
-0.13925376534461975,
-0.4110146760940552,
0.7901948094367981,
-0.7043954730033875,
0.004021001979708672,
0.29318276047706604,
-0.3161754608154297,
-0.28905004262924194,
0.341617226600647,
0.22669477760791779,
0.6117185354232788,
-0.3358548879623413,
0.16339728236198425,
-0.4040856957435608,
-0.3944389820098877,
0.231153205037117,
-0.5039563179016113,
0.556311309337616,
-0.3504479229450226,
-0.4706709682941437,
0.6361663937568665,
-0.9778338074684143,
-0.26192542910575867,
-0.15894392132759094,
-0.11382419615983963,
-0.3196098804473877,
0.16512545943260193,
0.34166276454925537,
0.3523842990398407,
0.19882014393806458,
-0.5546260476112366,
0.10651426762342453,
-0.27487537264823914,
0.41237059235572815,
1.020132064819336,
-0.3483668863773346,
0.2669398784637451,
0.22067849338054657,
0.48913007974624634,
-0.233388289809227,
0.28686344623565674,
-0.06340552121400833,
-0.6305075883865356,
-0.9109711647033691,
-0.5928078889846802,
0.03154847025871277,
0.5801263451576233,
-0.9816370010375977,
0.4180396795272827,
-0.18378259241580963,
-0.18406876921653748,
-0.032755643129348755,
0.19642268121242523,
0.4352647662162781,
0.43384718894958496,
0.6487084031105042,
-0.40851321816444397,
-0.2527347803115845,
-1.1039557456970215,
0.19431988894939423,
0.04429756850004196,
-0.5636435151100159,
0.47732093930244446,
0.5165520310401917,
-0.2532980442047119,
0.6931251883506775,
-0.30274224281311035,
-0.7253655195236206,
0.01149731408804655,
-0.1501055806875229,
0.09340855479240417,
0.44541627168655396,
0.3078886866569519,
-0.9988358020782471,
-0.023618701845407486,
-0.06994310766458511,
-0.8519803285598755,
-0.08345338702201843,
0.11336781084537506,
0.013408022932708263,
0.22776667773723602,
0.59987473487854,
-0.5154165029525757,
0.8431143164634705,
0.5121973752975464,
-0.675503671169281,
0.5090259313583374,
-0.8368238210678101,
0.17456887662410736,
-0.7317731380462646,
0.15226341784000397,
0.32470813393592834,
-0.279090017080307,
-0.42565396428108215,
-0.007926015183329582,
0.06980383396148682,
-0.1994347721338272,
-0.3307662904262543,
0.5127389430999756,
-0.6970807909965515,
-0.46653708815574646,
-0.03900374844670296,
0.16114868223667145,
-0.20080064237117767,
0.4200451672077179,
0.33934107422828674,
0.639284610748291,
0.6836708784103394,
-0.6113998889923096,
0.5270012021064758,
0.31432151794433594,
-0.23839259147644043,
0.676673173904419,
-1.041585087776184,
-0.16812215745449066,
-0.04575156420469284,
0.0022806504275649786,
-1.1702122688293457,
-0.4041687250137329,
0.4362466037273407,
-0.05264270678162575,
0.17463858425617218,
0.21083316206932068,
-0.7320331931114197,
-0.26503419876098633,
-0.38440755009651184,
0.40567097067832947,
0.39226898550987244,
-0.43019092082977295,
0.9596614837646484,
0.03800089657306671,
-0.16842129826545715,
-0.1541147232055664,
-0.6705924868583679,
0.3597254455089569,
-0.5718859434127808,
-0.6813597083091736,
0.13710764050483704,
-0.1862107217311859,
-0.017901843413710594,
-0.3446657061576843,
-0.18134905397891998,
0.0751534253358841,
-0.04577676206827164,
0.5283345580101013,
0.5262858867645264,
-0.09803672134876251,
0.09608879685401917,
-0.3822287917137146,
-0.24216040968894958,
-0.007856824435293674,
-0.018934613093733788,
0.2239333987236023,
-0.20096427202224731,
-0.6306458115577698,
-0.6031960844993591,
0.32293370366096497,
0.6698406338691711,
-0.2115374505519867,
0.5913114547729492,
0.35624179244041443,
-0.3439321219921112,
-0.016671864315867424,
-0.5288749933242798,
-0.0408666767179966,
-0.4702426791191101,
0.549214780330658,
-0.3566988706588745,
-0.5878032445907593,
0.34080418944358826,
0.117686428129673,
0.09702357649803162,
0.21757423877716064,
0.32396531105041504,
0.1630903035402298,
1.036732792854309,
0.769567608833313,
0.2877251207828522,
0.5064294934272766,
-0.18210840225219727,
-0.10860945284366608,
-0.9318212866783142,
-0.6493576169013977,
-0.6468654274940491,
-0.3780524432659149,
-0.255204439163208,
-0.7106434106826782,
0.6365110874176025,
0.0675586685538292,
-0.027045883238315582,
0.4635295867919922,
-0.610991358757019,
-0.20141834020614624,
0.628855288028717,
0.3848908543586731,
0.5106139183044434,
0.004224515985697508,
-0.03000572882592678,
-0.13232406973838806,
-0.8066855072975159,
-0.5880223512649536,
0.9397794008255005,
0.278189092874527,
0.786217212677002,
0.2170734852552414,
-0.09389756619930267,
0.17215046286582947,
0.28068220615386963,
-0.8433765172958374,
0.9636046290397644,
0.012636201456189156,
-0.4767775535583496,
-0.5962244272232056,
-0.3772464990615845,
-0.848911464214325,
0.12700870633125305,
-0.5157210230827332,
-1.0874091386795044,
0.3428685665130615,
0.32358837127685547,
-0.20090816915035248,
0.04193725809454918,
-0.8478953242301941,
0.9625279307365417,
-0.3004138767719269,
-0.8297728896141052,
-0.18617761135101318,
-0.747771143913269,
0.15967196226119995,
-0.31348511576652527,
0.07360173016786575,
-0.03684774413704872,
-0.275628000497818,
0.5179429054260254,
-0.2734162509441376,
0.7785127758979797,
-0.2591749429702759,
-0.2953758239746094,
-0.19032952189445496,
-0.3404133915901184,
0.2079818844795227,
0.1408413052558899,
-0.052507396787405014,
0.34214136004447937,
-0.028565600514411926,
-0.3837845027446747,
-0.5115067958831787,
0.5270842909812927,
-0.35079026222229004,
-0.8894994854927063,
-0.548303484916687,
-0.5403956174850464,
-0.41374772787094116,
0.11100376397371292,
0.16190451383590698,
0.8511649966239929,
0.019053960219025612,
0.39040616154670715,
0.6210978031158447,
-0.7005636692047119,
0.39205291867256165,
0.5148984789848328,
-0.23926779627799988,
-0.11100447922945023,
0.7557448744773865,
0.3058375120162964,
0.3058021664619446,
0.29742175340652466,
0.026065552607178688,
-0.5023439526557922,
-0.9205374717712402,
-0.8968595266342163,
-0.03832326829433441,
-0.4764048159122467,
-0.010093866847455502,
-0.21255865693092346,
-0.019827833399176598,
0.1529594212770462,
-0.058963362127542496,
-0.006398604717105627,
-0.1545579582452774,
-0.3047821521759033,
-0.02837211638689041,
0.19112777709960938,
0.7064998149871826,
0.21495719254016876,
-0.0761476457118988,
-0.7041109204292297,
0.6320146322250366,
0.38911929726600647,
0.4015587866306305,
-0.07049250602722168,
-0.17774944007396698,
-0.019006913527846336,
0.04026125371456146,
-0.24523110687732697,
-0.8802098631858826,
0.15603148937225342,
0.024510417133569717,
0.5380379557609558,
0.43519076704978943,
-0.10959473252296448,
0.9280133247375488,
-0.7440071702003479,
0.9016543030738831,
0.47678205370903015,
-0.7787992358207703,
0.572431743144989,
-0.16080191731452942,
0.27284932136535645,
0.17713738977909088,
0.340694397687912,
-0.01668405905365944,
-0.4570162296295166,
-0.29717200994491577,
-1.0528433322906494,
0.6762493848800659,
0.39208775758743286,
-0.032430198043584824,
0.33680886030197144,
0.15981416404247284,
-0.04224324971437454,
0.04753725230693817,
-0.6940097808837891,
0.1845235526561737,
-0.17319826781749725,
0.054643869400024414,
-0.10899192839860916,
-0.18935541808605194,
-0.06674900650978088,
-0.33301252126693726,
0.4911327660083771,
-0.023509450256824493,
-0.040545303374528885,
0.5858919024467468,
-0.034351274371147156,
0.2581387162208557,
0.1159340962767601,
0.5130393505096436,
0.9345638155937195,
-0.013644516468048096,
0.0035384544171392918,
0.5316210389137268,
-0.37171223759651184,
-0.07977306842803955,
0.3146742582321167,
-0.15296579897403717,
-0.06784652173519135,
0.4032236933708191,
0.6820502281188965,
0.37816566228866577,
-1.1993794441223145,
0.562119722366333,
-0.15888576209545135,
-0.03830286115407944,
-0.2639310956001282,
0.32002484798431396,
-0.13350056111812592,
0.36052414774894714,
0.6182101964950562,
0.06577447801828384,
0.3778131306171417,
-0.5465782880783081,
-0.09415457397699356,
0.7120090126991272,
-0.6264945268630981,
-0.3835359811782837,
0.9098944664001465,
0.3458021581172943,
-0.45945772528648376,
0.35509493947029114,
0.10727614909410477,
-0.09652070701122284,
0.6250677108764648,
0.27020931243896484,
0.606709361076355,
0.019811512902379036,
-0.023415643721818924,
0.2460375428199768,
0.14698167145252228,
-0.15246357023715973,
0.1872444450855255,
-0.2970391511917114,
-0.3845445215702057,
-0.3859160542488098,
-0.5471888184547424,
-0.3307110667228699,
0.174983412027359,
-0.441351979970932,
0.36722975969314575,
-0.39576250314712524,
-0.2914244830608368,
-0.03264022246003151,
-0.21072621643543243,
-0.6734901666641235,
0.258587121963501,
-0.044462088495492935,
1.0614341497421265,
-0.3793485760688782,
0.45624396204948425,
0.7447159886360168,
-0.4201502501964569,
-0.7759316563606262,
-0.013215802609920502,
0.0018176415469497442,
-0.5150913000106812,
0.7333217859268188,
0.342939168214798,
-0.5403568148612976,
-0.16889117658138275,
-0.48146942257881165,
-0.4728529751300812,
1.081853985786438,
0.45740562677383423,
-0.5528932809829712,
-0.24879957735538483,
-0.016384797170758247,
0.4640122652053833,
0.09452949464321136,
0.16697576642036438,
0.10819138586521149,
0.6474932432174683,
0.2650488615036011,
-1.0983741283416748,
0.13545000553131104,
-0.21071748435497284,
0.31695643067359924,
-0.01348924171179533,
-0.5956383943557739,
0.3287043869495392,
0.01457423996180296,
-0.2852192521095276,
0.8506399989128113,
0.586560070514679,
0.5858207941055298,
0.3376604914665222,
0.6687555313110352,
0.10933569818735123,
0.48969608545303345,
-0.1122407466173172,
0.8997510671615601,
-0.00013976989430375397,
-0.1060560867190361,
0.7374264597892761,
-0.21639156341552734,
0.8322166204452515,
0.6094154119491577,
0.09356220811605453,
0.30697181820869446,
0.319783478975296,
-0.08820521086454391,
0.22891578078269958,
0.3266940414905548,
-0.2109389454126358,
-0.24111010134220123,
0.014702606946229935,
-0.46663978695869446,
0.41076698899269104,
0.3922145366668701,
-0.2749425768852234,
-0.1403416097164154,
0.26077497005462646,
-0.4653583765029907,
0.07926830649375916,
-0.6656206250190735,
0.4531364440917969,
0.1233103945851326,
-0.45455557107925415,
0.3641577661037445,
-0.1019369438290596,
0.6232116222381592,
-0.8675838708877563,
-0.40196502208709717,
0.1333814561367035,
0.2802256643772125,
-0.221334308385849,
-0.663747251033783,
0.0768214538693428,
0.22759103775024414,
0.062152788043022156,
-0.34605148434638977,
0.6087397933006287,
0.011020520702004433,
-0.743421733379364,
0.44808825850486755,
0.3963385224342346,
0.3023998439311981,
0.05229674652218819,
-0.3674294352531433,
0.17197513580322266,
-0.2834038734436035,
-0.25647807121276855,
0.1207306832075119,
0.7244560718536377,
-0.3062398433685303,
1.0025701522827148,
0.5127195119857788,
0.20770101249217987,
0.11261466890573502,
-0.025325071066617966,
0.8463550806045532,
-0.7903884649276733,
-0.2719416320323944,
-0.7654315829277039,
0.6190366744995117,
-0.3225938677787781,
-0.5525407791137695,
1.1581647396087646,
0.5514066815376282,
0.41506317257881165,
-0.143331378698349,
0.19161321222782135,
0.05147876590490341,
0.0620000883936882,
-0.9916225671768188,
0.4835337996482849,
-0.8960867524147034,
0.37810736894607544,
-0.613317608833313,
-1.0713549852371216,
-0.4580398201942444,
0.725151002407074,
-0.3678005635738373,
0.039584796875715256,
0.4500810503959656,
0.9034376740455627,
-0.20313660800457,
-0.16077600419521332,
0.48334020376205444,
0.2638557553291321,
0.15638796985149384,
0.7103486061096191,
1.0186232328414917,
0.11323664337396622,
0.5900375843048096,
0.5202365517616272,
-0.4755696952342987,
-0.08287370204925537,
-0.8453684449195862,
-0.882055401802063,
-0.47515830397605896,
-0.09918015450239182,
-0.12996937334537506,
0.11304604262113571,
0.5613672137260437,
1.1136786937713623,
-0.5058877468109131,
-0.0755474790930748,
-0.39453187584877014,
0.0009475277620367706,
-0.0020676113199442625,
-0.12353810667991638,
0.3542066812515259,
0.14991094172000885,
-0.8646700978279114,
0.4225013554096222,
0.6911880970001221,
0.03204750642180443,
-0.8628901839256287,
-0.12997590005397797,
0.12014023959636688,
-0.10104423016309738,
0.7278558611869812,
0.13340811431407928,
-0.7594772577285767,
-0.5345789194107056,
0.08178264647722244,
0.12526565790176392,
0.19168272614479065,
0.4949790835380554,
-1.013748288154602,
0.548585832118988,
0.37018516659736633,
0.39755865931510925,
0.4970534145832062,
-0.0034093239810317755,
0.6869394779205322,
-0.5524078011512756,
0.329061895608902,
0.09324721246957779,
0.6294442415237427,
0.4868791997432709,
-0.24379132688045502,
0.4782716631889343,
0.15840153396129608,
-0.40273040533065796,
-0.643880307674408,
0.3187033534049988,
-1.275917649269104,
-0.2476770132780075,
1.191406011581421,
-0.11325670033693314,
-0.2488524317741394,
-0.301726758480072,
-0.6169671416282654,
-0.14878979325294495,
-0.29440632462501526,
0.7122911214828491,
0.6675747632980347,
-0.014094265177845955,
-0.07999557256698608,
-0.8287171125411987,
0.2580454647541046,
0.30384498834609985,
-0.9706388115882874,
-0.12566494941711426,
0.941267728805542,
0.20562949776649475,
0.3146817982196808,
0.5727033019065857,
-0.05671224743127823,
0.35608717799186707,
-0.3359473645687103,
-0.13946814835071564,
-0.18501228094100952,
-0.5698434114456177,
-0.4551540017127991,
0.3829645812511444,
0.10558469593524933,
-0.23766757547855377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01734v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01734v2 | CFTM: Continuous time fractional topic model | 2024-01-29T08:07:41 | 2024-02-07T03:51:42 | Kei Nakagawa, Kohei Hayashi, Yugo Fujimoto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.CP, stat.AP | In this paper, we propose the Continuous Time Fractional Topic Model (cFTM),
a new method for dynamic topic modeling. This approach incorporates fractional
Brownian motion~(fBm) to effectively identify positive or negative correlations
in topic and word distribution over time, revealing long-term dependency or
roughness. Our theoretical analysis shows that the cFTM can capture these
long-term dependency or roughness in both topic and word distributions,
mirroring the main characteristics of fBm. Moreover, we prove that the
parameter estimation process for the cFTM is on par with that of LDA,
traditional topic models. To demonstrate the cFTM's property, we conduct
empirical study using economic news articles. The results from these tests
support the model's ability to identify and track long-term dependency or
roughness in topics over time. | [
-0.5136566162109375,
-1.5090768337249756,
0.645135760307312,
0.31855130195617676,
-0.625058650970459,
-0.13876865804195404,
-0.15521307289600372,
-0.11079088598489761,
0.40311580896377563,
0.3718443512916565,
-0.3690635859966278,
-0.40506479144096375,
-0.5209702253341675,
-0.4038560092449188,
-0.7923633456230164,
1.1250516176223755,
0.06139584630727768,
0.11149218678474426,
0.01845615543425083,
0.09701624512672424,
-0.3714850842952728,
-0.4936318099498749,
-0.8609434366226196,
-0.09705711901187897,
0.7222278118133545,
0.08037606626749039,
0.886084258556366,
0.8045467138290405,
0.7455371618270874,
0.281953901052475,
-0.4587782919406891,
-0.8166142106056213,
-0.2628801465034485,
0.05171756446361542,
-0.4724901020526886,
-0.19875949621200562,
-0.35614216327667236,
0.254361093044281,
0.8031610250473022,
0.9239630699157715,
-0.7866119742393494,
-0.2095024287700653,
-0.26183032989501953,
0.5096880793571472,
-0.31322863698005676,
-0.043608978390693665,
-0.4669122099876404,
0.20587655901908875,
-0.31038299202919006,
-0.4302027225494385,
-0.0007887308020144701,
-0.20003856718540192,
0.28168848156929016,
-0.09456242620944977,
0.7452036738395691,
-0.08630257099866867,
0.6634628176689148,
-0.16729143261909485,
-0.9443833231925964,
-0.4971911311149597,
-0.6180741786956787,
1.0407384634017944,
-0.5555546283721924,
0.8005557656288147,
0.2568129897117615,
0.3151066303253174,
-0.031640782952308655,
-0.8007952570915222,
-0.6608569025993347,
-0.5240234732627869,
0.054047293961048126,
-0.08410608768463135,
0.24615830183029175,
0.09207764267921448,
0.08202899992465973,
0.589668333530426,
-0.32576826214790344,
-0.3977586030960083,
-0.2993054986000061,
0.04654659703373909,
0.3955588638782501,
0.5475974082946777,
0.1554218828678131,
-0.4116116464138031,
-0.8056453466415405,
0.31420066952705383,
-0.05032156780362129,
0.08651050925254822,
0.29999178647994995,
0.32057619094848633,
-0.24699971079826355,
0.44286438822746277,
0.014917831867933273,
0.580958902835846,
0.16664107143878937,
-0.645433783531189,
-0.3005177080631256,
-0.5875959992408752,
-0.0012297024950385094,
0.10309090465307236,
0.3974364399909973,
0.13189782202243805,
-0.34177374839782715,
-0.20716241002082825,
-0.32851698994636536,
-0.24729900062084198,
0.05244464799761772,
-0.9241940975189209,
-0.021704383194446564,
0.23124420642852783,
-0.7707816362380981,
-0.40514934062957764,
0.2575136125087738,
-1.1443846225738525,
-0.17956039309501648,
-0.5513780117034912,
0.10433807969093323,
-0.23374688625335693,
-0.5078610777854919,
0.18400314450263977,
-0.03974589332938194,
-0.05595013499259949,
0.5094342827796936,
-0.8637412190437317,
0.5427942276000977,
1.0186069011688232,
1.20619797706604,
-0.3750508725643158,
-0.07604919373989105,
-0.46454834938049316,
0.25583550333976746,
-0.19159163534641266,
1.097616195678711,
-0.6125040054321289,
-0.41884845495224,
-0.05592311918735504,
0.009762398898601532,
0.011978626251220703,
-0.25829562544822693,
0.17531462013721466,
-0.6350128054618835,
0.4894735515117645,
-0.3055078983306885,
-0.6241030097007751,
0.047713760286569595,
0.48670071363449097,
-0.7379489541053772,
0.6784729361534119,
0.35076749324798584,
-1.2920671701431274,
0.516789436340332,
-0.6865009069442749,
-0.2742615044116974,
-0.40545257925987244,
-0.03888383135199547,
-0.08683063089847565,
0.07925690710544586,
-0.36580392718315125,
0.46219053864479065,
-0.4169374704360962,
0.9695687294006348,
-0.7001372575759888,
-0.26652979850769043,
0.5785167813301086,
-0.7747898697853088,
0.5109637975692749,
0.454057902097702,
-0.05759953707456589,
-0.10235486924648285,
-0.7728173136711121,
-0.7735596299171448,
-0.26006630063056946,
-0.54747474193573,
-0.18177178502082825,
0.30179548263549805,
0.2565310299396515,
0.3507135212421417,
0.39724743366241455,
-0.2530055046081543,
0.06808358430862427,
-0.007022511214017868,
0.4646213948726654,
0.9114068150520325,
0.7173106074333191,
0.40390288829803467,
-0.6194556355476379,
0.5795274376869202,
0.6625828146934509,
0.26628196239471436,
-0.3008822798728943,
-0.24151021242141724,
-0.7752575874328613,
-0.4829481244087219,
0.5284522771835327,
0.45221996307373047,
-0.2349088490009308,
0.25307780504226685,
0.012222589924931526,
-0.26393675804138184,
0.318238765001297,
-0.11692915111780167,
-0.33053088188171387,
0.519967794418335,
0.14780846238136292,
-0.5203201770782471,
0.07374320924282074,
-0.7869271039962769,
0.05916843190789223,
-0.1593352109193802,
0.15149079263210297,
-0.13610488176345825,
0.216947540640831,
0.19786570966243744,
1.1422598361968994,
-0.7640752792358398,
-0.09977106004953384,
0.04021868109703064,
0.7072170376777649,
0.3789586126804352,
0.578334391117096,
0.7200546860694885,
-0.969017744064331,
-0.20214129984378815,
-0.30613818764686584,
-0.32654690742492676,
0.20279842615127563,
-0.2948012053966522,
-0.3477795720100403,
0.28172463178634644,
0.426252543926239,
-0.5422606468200684,
0.3222329914569855,
0.13751044869422913,
-0.7299780249595642,
0.25446197390556335,
0.017928292974829674,
0.21163009107112885,
-1.3512104749679565,
0.26500633358955383,
0.4204683303833008,
-0.2857935428619385,
-0.3964226543903351,
-0.10596694052219391,
-0.24693085253238678,
-0.4982113540172577,
-0.6877122521400452,
0.7587270736694336,
-0.20715902745723724,
0.17723999917507172,
-0.3048825263977051,
0.13050609827041626,
-0.23857522010803223,
0.4888136088848114,
0.30254483222961426,
0.48405537009239197,
0.175479918718338,
-0.5219802856445312,
0.34337660670280457,
-0.2095557600259781,
-0.16437183320522308,
0.8197354674339294,
-0.4393291473388672,
-0.08786814659833908,
-0.195226788520813,
0.3494233191013336,
-0.8432198762893677,
-0.05385778099298477,
0.03981560096144676,
0.07202596217393875,
0.4488714635372162,
-0.223140150308609,
-0.7137565016746521,
-0.15642935037612915,
-0.31176134943962097,
0.11057212948799133,
0.393754243850708,
0.04921717196702957,
0.46023082733154297,
0.15425418317317963,
-0.5937257409095764,
-0.2305109053850174,
-0.5850427746772766,
-0.24760133028030396,
-0.44638171792030334,
-0.5803749561309814,
0.24203018844127655,
-0.36323902010917664,
-0.45096638798713684,
0.058210935443639755,
-0.1222040057182312,
-0.5318222641944885,
0.25392407178878784,
-0.02598174847662449,
-0.06996265798807144,
-0.4268057942390442,
0.038228072226047516,
0.2648428678512573,
-0.2700715959072113,
-0.022297196090221405,
0.15983305871486664,
0.5897995233535767,
0.239714115858078,
-0.2991804778575897,
-0.7192864418029785,
0.6423811912536621,
0.3572119474411011,
-0.00352016044780612,
0.9555666446685791,
0.6051254272460938,
-0.5429169535636902,
0.2922428250312805,
-0.8179171085357666,
-0.12082081288099289,
-0.49480244517326355,
0.20296570658683777,
0.11268345266580582,
-0.717887818813324,
0.7044066786766052,
0.0958365872502327,
-0.23883122205734253,
0.49330130219459534,
0.4471592903137207,
0.1067911833524704,
0.778526782989502,
0.8713069558143616,
0.005254283547401428,
1.1045846939086914,
-0.2273779958486557,
0.1058531254529953,
-0.33912670612335205,
-0.3093906044960022,
-0.5721961855888367,
-0.2221815586090088,
-0.42086008191108704,
-0.4486341178417206,
0.11134239286184311,
0.5862669348716736,
-0.4500334560871124,
-0.2544480562210083,
-0.1553337723016739,
0.15308871865272522,
0.3348819315433502,
0.18025356531143188,
0.4082600772380829,
-0.1201775074005127,
0.03654658794403076,
-0.18689614534378052,
-0.15276458859443665,
-0.4944094717502594,
0.574447751045227,
0.5690001845359802,
0.7216924428939819,
0.19337910413742065,
0.4279320538043976,
0.7038722634315491,
0.901528537273407,
-0.667240560054779,
0.45185431838035583,
-0.2593163847923279,
-0.9051597118377686,
-0.25122103095054626,
-0.4050745964050293,
-0.44621890783309937,
-0.11981821060180664,
0.02175164222717285,
-0.5765241980552673,
0.36483070254325867,
0.06110050529241562,
-0.23313772678375244,
0.3530460000038147,
-0.1644948571920395,
0.7375233769416809,
-0.2533773183822632,
-0.42165669798851013,
-0.31734657287597656,
-0.2896220088005066,
0.47089770436286926,
-0.4013685882091522,
0.138803169131279,
-0.4248696565628052,
-0.41735225915908813,
0.8670282363891602,
-0.44977205991744995,
0.725374698638916,
-0.36329272389411926,
-0.299373596906662,
0.3174130618572235,
0.080097496509552,
0.2437288910150528,
0.7041113972663879,
-0.4200281500816345,
-0.06748256087303162,
0.06997630000114441,
-0.7445876002311707,
-0.6028294563293457,
0.804673433303833,
-0.38070207834243774,
-0.8019078969955444,
-0.7880943417549133,
-0.41826826333999634,
0.030153704807162285,
0.26457053422927856,
-0.1654357761144638,
0.6721315979957581,
-0.45364829897880554,
0.16138096153736115,
0.36981260776519775,
0.022481517866253853,
0.7005370259284973,
0.7759814858436584,
-0.42411938309669495,
-0.8059651851654053,
0.8499568104743958,
0.3668573796749115,
0.11394228041172028,
0.6442915201187134,
0.11588770896196365,
-0.004656880162656307,
-0.7584590315818787,
-0.08523150533437729,
0.34326252341270447,
-0.4598052203655243,
-0.15391495823860168,
-1.0497925281524658,
-0.18693502247333527,
-0.20811769366264343,
-0.5765079855918884,
-0.30242958664894104,
-0.49844837188720703,
-0.7280674576759338,
-0.02574474923312664,
0.2553333044052124,
0.5108798742294312,
-0.1615939736366272,
0.3835795223712921,
-0.6898313760757446,
0.33582645654678345,
0.47179028391838074,
0.45179349184036255,
0.22719618678092957,
-0.495625376701355,
-0.32040268182754517,
0.19198627769947052,
-0.9366341829299927,
-0.7766146063804626,
0.39116862416267395,
-0.23290131986141205,
0.545200765132904,
0.7992535829544067,
0.11913394182920456,
0.5596919059753418,
-0.09779375791549683,
1.2623692750930786,
0.45334768295288086,
-1.1928675174713135,
0.5984129309654236,
-0.7877256274223328,
0.09222696721553802,
0.4645245671272278,
0.5286712050437927,
-0.5936241745948792,
-0.44415193796157837,
-0.740764319896698,
-0.7762899398803711,
0.5986958146095276,
0.06407485902309418,
0.4425521790981293,
-0.4907328188419342,
0.4026066064834595,
0.33523181080818176,
0.5437284111976624,
-0.5153521299362183,
-0.006307837553322315,
-0.30600473284721375,
-0.19004744291305542,
0.1405467987060547,
-0.6939822435379028,
0.05561249703168869,
-0.13689449429512024,
0.43669965863227844,
-0.05787452682852745,
0.6024967432022095,
0.08923424035310745,
0.1668451875448227,
-0.30837923288345337,
0.2308616191148758,
0.9007927775382996,
0.957474946975708,
-0.8162499666213989,
0.10292599350214005,
0.11253897845745087,
-0.40517547726631165,
0.1073988601565361,
0.5088727474212646,
0.1891433596611023,
0.12117115408182144,
0.4478684365749359,
0.4001913368701935,
0.5285297632217407,
-0.27301353216171265,
0.743782103061676,
-0.023879066109657288,
-0.13092462718486786,
-0.5447794198989868,
0.03105567768216133,
0.242466539144516,
0.2751498222351074,
0.621410071849823,
-0.13131262362003326,
0.16676238179206848,
-0.9577054381370544,
0.5194469690322876,
0.11166589707136154,
-0.8653468489646912,
-0.43395301699638367,
0.8067336082458496,
0.19521880149841309,
-0.31489044427871704,
0.7659842371940613,
0.04277103394269943,
-0.42605969309806824,
0.9071730971336365,
0.5945108532905579,
0.4763040244579315,
-0.22675491869449615,
0.30389487743377686,
0.006425151601433754,
-0.3245154619216919,
-0.39572960138320923,
0.5023260712623596,
-0.12893566489219666,
-0.250935435295105,
-0.005997357424348593,
-0.8217954039573669,
-0.44567984342575073,
0.0592285692691803,
-1.0015945434570312,
0.6604668498039246,
-0.6480583548545837,
-0.36571183800697327,
0.2107875943183899,
0.42910635471343994,
-0.3493507504463196,
0.4055545926094055,
-0.14872995018959045,
1.2847357988357544,
-0.7910910844802856,
0.8826237320899963,
0.4454647898674011,
-0.6024150252342224,
-0.14632004499435425,
0.3616998493671417,
-0.1520615965127945,
-0.07885215431451797,
0.5520211458206177,
-0.16005876660346985,
0.4985511004924774,
-0.11464288830757141,
-0.5400610566139221,
-0.8626053333282471,
1.4081730842590332,
0.4239695370197296,
-0.3855835795402527,
-0.02859811671078205,
0.03216314688324928,
0.6362425684928894,
-0.2626003324985504,
0.12493894249200821,
0.02620393969118595,
0.5028883218765259,
0.2562254071235657,
-0.5521448254585266,
0.01699124462902546,
0.025591835379600525,
0.07280291616916656,
0.6697719693183899,
-1.300977110862732,
1.0662084817886353,
0.06896577030420303,
-0.08403942734003067,
0.19908004999160767,
1.1330134868621826,
0.3216930031776428,
0.8801940679550171,
0.5392678380012512,
0.2819981575012207,
0.3630964159965515,
0.1033664122223854,
0.8377901315689087,
-0.5232691764831543,
0.9127048254013062,
0.6518775820732117,
-0.14613476395606995,
0.8331180810928345,
0.46467140316963196,
-0.30873605608940125,
0.43212637305259705,
0.8409724235534668,
0.09384243935346603,
0.8856063485145569,
0.315774530172348,
-0.4700375497341156,
-0.18697071075439453,
-0.2895717918872833,
-0.6407140493392944,
0.021755216643214226,
0.40434497594833374,
-0.5910329818725586,
-0.30773860216140747,
0.07914191484451294,
0.4476693570613861,
-0.2205425649881363,
0.019063524901866913,
0.4621509611606598,
0.45585864782333374,
-0.29873549938201904,
0.008546323515474796,
0.26694416999816895,
0.6962761282920837,
-0.6132473945617676,
-0.10911604017019272,
-0.8562465906143188,
0.0034728648606687784,
0.24220992624759674,
-0.574652373790741,
0.47964397072792053,
-0.07380431890487671,
-0.592630922794342,
-0.11113380640745163,
0.34925177693367004,
-0.5300336480140686,
-0.8686022758483887,
0.06719233840703964,
0.3155214786529541,
-0.15539491176605225,
0.20246824622154236,
-0.9606170058250427,
-0.04307210072875023,
-0.3466450870037079,
-0.7146744728088379,
0.4608888030052185,
0.8714276552200317,
-0.09051419049501419,
0.5906444787979126,
0.49261894822120667,
-0.09536827355623245,
-0.34574511647224426,
-0.2332095354795456,
0.8176795840263367,
-1.4265422821044922,
-0.7315912246704102,
-0.6066800951957703,
0.29031071066856384,
0.04387441277503967,
-0.35935282707214355,
0.15718837082386017,
0.6547702550888062,
0.41953837871551514,
0.267252117395401,
0.3832787871360779,
-0.10113900899887085,
0.47927460074424744,
-0.807343602180481,
0.8163887858390808,
-0.6724746227264404,
0.37596896290779114,
-0.25015607476234436,
-0.9632181525230408,
-0.15872648358345032,
0.3577670156955719,
-0.13056212663650513,
0.44053423404693604,
1.2677968740463257,
0.6025828123092651,
-0.6713832020759583,
0.4802832305431366,
0.26521381735801697,
0.1811375766992569,
0.416979044675827,
0.04556967690587044,
0.8319663405418396,
0.11572501808404922,
0.16873124241828918,
-0.9854793548583984,
0.024664942175149918,
-0.3196583092212677,
-1.3174748420715332,
-0.8785677552223206,
-0.7757607102394104,
-0.6627215147018433,
-0.26256853342056274,
0.1713205724954605,
0.9258269667625427,
0.679993748664856,
-0.7258278727531433,
-0.18059879541397095,
-0.02766522206366062,
0.23997288942337036,
-0.09919104725122452,
-0.3761049509048462,
0.5951215028762817,
0.027149593457579613,
-0.5595780611038208,
-0.22430506348609924,
0.1366003304719925,
0.4549512565135956,
-0.5182510018348694,
0.45396798849105835,
-0.3823097050189972,
0.4866320788860321,
0.4683195948600769,
-0.25172853469848633,
-0.4642654359340668,
-0.3042009770870209,
-0.2303476333618164,
-0.24882104992866516,
-0.06731797009706497,
1.3058830499649048,
-0.4447062313556671,
-0.13956080377101898,
0.5700440406799316,
-0.045256663113832474,
0.3952665328979492,
0.19303575158119202,
0.6069954037666321,
-0.11026142537593842,
0.4537495970726013,
0.025015849620103836,
0.2547681927680969,
0.2069125920534134,
-0.497376024723053,
0.446340948343277,
0.6953006982803345,
-0.3431915044784546,
-0.9318351745605469,
-0.07093196362257004,
-1.3094251155853271,
-0.31047335267066956,
1.0063520669937134,
-0.030986856669187546,
-0.35101816058158875,
-0.19401875138282776,
-0.19180162250995636,
0.27208685874938965,
-0.7730560898780823,
1.0437055826187134,
0.9687809944152832,
-0.026714129373431206,
-0.2648915648460388,
-0.6334494352340698,
0.10501398891210556,
-0.0024287067353725433,
-0.504460871219635,
-0.2338980734348297,
0.4228309094905853,
0.6082490682601929,
0.009128217585384846,
0.93996661901474,
-0.1660108119249344,
0.09434334188699722,
0.04051530733704567,
-0.41052326560020447,
0.06773889809846878,
-0.2350708693265915,
-0.039947159588336945,
0.5452893376350403,
-0.042721256613731384,
0.3034857511520386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15927v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15927v1 | E-EVAL: A Comprehensive Chinese K-12 Education Evaluation Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-01-29T07:34:37 | 2024-01-29T07:34:37 | Jinchang Hou, Chang Ao, Haihong Wu, Xiangtao Kong, Zhigang Zheng, Daijia Tang, Chengming Li, Xiping Hu, Ruifeng Xu, Shiwen Ni, Min Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the accelerating development of Large Language Models (LLMs), many LLMs
are beginning to be used in the Chinese K-12 education domain. The integration
of LLMs and education is getting closer and closer, however, there is currently
no benchmark for evaluating LLMs that focuses on the Chinese K-12 education
domain. Therefore, there is an urgent need for a comprehensive natural language
processing benchmark to accurately assess the capabilities of various LLMs in
the Chinese K-12 education domain. To address this, we introduce the E-EVAL,
the first comprehensive evaluation benchmark specifically designed for the
Chinese K-12 education field. The E-EVAL consists of 4,351 multiple-choice
questions at the primary, middle, and high school levels across a wide range of
subjects, including Chinese, English, Politics, History, Ethics, Physics,
Chemistry, Mathematics, and Geography. We conducted a comprehensive evaluation
of E-EVAL on advanced LLMs, including both English-dominant and
Chinese-dominant models. Findings show that Chinese-dominant models perform
well compared to English-dominant models, with many scoring even above the GPT
4.0. However, almost all models perform poorly in complex subjects such as
mathematics. We also found that most Chinese-dominant LLMs did not achieve
higher scores at the primary school level compared to the middle school level.
We observe that the mastery of higher-order knowledge by the model does not
necessarily imply the mastery of lower-order knowledge as well. Additionally,
the experimental results indicate that the Chain of Thought (CoT) technique is
effective only for the challenging science subjects, while Few-shot prompting
is more beneficial for liberal arts subjects. With E-EVAL, we aim to analyze
the strengths and limitations of LLMs in educational applications, and to
contribute to the progress and development of Chinese K-12 education and LLMs. | [
-0.3705618977546692,
-1.1863760948181152,
0.6306154727935791,
0.2505464255809784,
-0.059861309826374054,
0.32843926548957825,
-0.5771108865737915,
-0.47568798065185547,
-0.11859357357025146,
0.1729094237089157,
-0.23617902398109436,
-0.6091941595077515,
-0.46397387981414795,
-0.009036525152623653,
-0.4436700940132141,
0.7163020372390747,
-0.14445923268795013,
0.20965325832366943,
-0.06590256094932556,
0.2409764528274536,
-0.08680099993944168,
-0.4636538028717041,
-0.634820282459259,
-0.3460931181907654,
0.2787110507488251,
0.1311602145433426,
0.1758449226617813,
0.3315512239933014,
0.5209701061248779,
0.2335599958896637,
-0.04185646399855614,
0.2566939890384674,
-0.43721669912338257,
-0.20533201098442078,
-0.09094946086406708,
-0.3498879671096802,
-0.6083396077156067,
0.018851201981306076,
0.8558582067489624,
0.8653873205184937,
-0.2634090185165405,
0.2737281322479248,
0.40931057929992676,
0.6431141495704651,
-0.8288517594337463,
-0.1552838236093521,
-0.3481238782405853,
0.1019279733300209,
-0.03194687142968178,
0.06267980486154556,
-0.5555668473243713,
-0.596703827381134,
0.3002517521381378,
-0.5248429179191589,
-0.19203361868858337,
0.07918620109558105,
0.8752903342247009,
-0.17853066325187683,
-0.4625439941883087,
-0.006878605578094721,
-0.6117097735404968,
1.0203005075454712,
-0.4100063741207123,
0.6292599439620972,
0.29532161355018616,
0.3888288140296936,
-0.038206737488508224,
-0.8404843807220459,
-0.4325368106365204,
-0.4446665346622467,
0.19175146520137787,
0.4609215259552002,
0.15948700904846191,
0.262817919254303,
0.07810799777507782,
0.3140225410461426,
-0.7606056332588196,
0.18442925810813904,
-0.28547847270965576,
-0.1831553429365158,
0.6079345345497131,
0.4625447690486908,
0.3232688009738922,
0.10206053406000137,
-0.6248629093170166,
-0.21430441737174988,
-0.822011411190033,
0.28386208415031433,
0.19744111597537994,
0.17387168109416962,
-0.026954738423228264,
0.32795336842536926,
-0.18139705061912537,
0.6224669814109802,
-0.11835488677024841,
-0.01679227314889431,
0.11279937624931335,
-0.3630751967430115,
-0.3521328568458557,
-0.12510153651237488,
0.7156355381011963,
0.453088641166687,
0.12093938142061234,
0.2763698995113373,
-0.40915176272392273,
0.17241789400577545,
-0.16882522404193878,
-0.8346905708312988,
-0.22210659086704254,
0.22459477186203003,
-0.43689170479774475,
-0.0817776620388031,
0.10353080928325653,
-0.8335620164871216,
-0.05563511699438095,
-0.3874701261520386,
0.40085551142692566,
-0.2542569041252136,
-0.14827822148799896,
0.07854165881872177,
0.21802890300750732,
0.6588643193244934,
0.5082345604896545,
-0.7282642722129822,
0.6458773016929626,
0.9335197806358337,
0.7463648319244385,
-0.3534799814224243,
-0.6085731387138367,
-0.27958303689956665,
-0.30409330129623413,
-0.48889344930648804,
0.8226385116577148,
-0.7294209003448486,
-0.19294016063213348,
0.19339372217655182,
-0.027383383363485336,
-0.10909690707921982,
-0.5930998921394348,
0.6662073135375977,
-0.39035624265670776,
0.07426732033491135,
-0.184670552611351,
-0.8659190535545349,
-0.13637205958366394,
0.6074418425559998,
-0.5444962382316589,
1.128360390663147,
-0.12670853734016418,
-0.0024181976914405823,
0.14490048587322235,
-0.5659937858581543,
-0.12193667143583298,
0.13322241604328156,
-0.24071432650089264,
-0.1435309648513794,
-0.157608762383461,
0.17114347219467163,
0.24993804097175598,
-0.765138566493988,
0.45762982964515686,
-0.29516908526420593,
-0.5838691592216492,
-0.0353279747068882,
-0.6840155124664307,
0.8198774456977844,
0.12174816429615021,
-0.19681550562381744,
-0.03522660583257675,
-0.7693437337875366,
0.656795859336853,
0.18343184888362885,
-0.33876875042915344,
-0.3032882511615753,
-0.10170990973711014,
0.3244211673736572,
0.26804953813552856,
0.4669710695743561,
-0.5066712498664856,
0.01694503240287304,
-0.36763378977775574,
0.10647673159837723,
0.948259174823761,
-0.13725195825099945,
0.14806172251701355,
-0.2025545984506607,
0.41896796226501465,
-0.32054874300956726,
0.15974605083465576,
-0.3967929780483246,
-0.3043728172779083,
-0.7749204635620117,
0.06686794012784958,
0.38969311118125916,
0.47070878744125366,
-0.4729447662830353,
0.5056638121604919,
-0.1376618593931198,
-0.7571854591369629,
-0.6689587831497192,
0.12304418534040451,
0.5406415462493896,
0.16242475807666779,
0.20260871946811676,
0.08564247936010361,
-0.25867804884910583,
-0.8538088202476501,
-0.44246289134025574,
-0.24389714002609253,
-0.19364069402217865,
0.2953955829143524,
0.6928187012672424,
0.25152403116226196,
0.49679210782051086,
-0.5209441781044006,
0.026116790249943733,
-0.2891138195991516,
-0.05773373320698738,
-0.0030355979688465595,
0.14225231111049652,
0.3843821585178375,
-0.6691432595252991,
-0.8382603526115417,
0.1555664986371994,
-0.4871159493923187,
-0.4025125205516815,
-0.049028925597667694,
-0.34487050771713257,
0.07072799652814865,
-0.05052777752280235,
-0.20535041391849518,
0.15262572467327118,
0.5712637901306152,
-0.4285331964492798,
0.8311794400215149,
-0.09774091094732285,
0.2480461299419403,
-0.48948463797569275,
0.11408193409442902,
0.18941618502140045,
0.009090171195566654,
-0.7305611968040466,
0.20933926105499268,
0.5171258449554443,
0.04659849777817726,
-0.6776247024536133,
0.6328427791595459,
-0.2514383792877197,
-0.03704691305756569,
-0.31130778789520264,
0.621049165725708,
0.2684115171432495,
0.4673963189125061,
0.1253918707370758,
0.45902514457702637,
0.45909804105758667,
-0.5708405375480652,
0.4551090896129608,
-0.25451818108558655,
-0.5034204125404358,
0.6790431141853333,
-0.6277166604995728,
0.1950894296169281,
0.16950362920761108,
0.13916197419166565,
-0.7211798429489136,
-0.031499966979026794,
-0.016152068972587585,
-0.15209123492240906,
-0.010746150277554989,
0.4868530333042145,
-0.26488950848579407,
-0.3243868350982666,
-0.5994402766227722,
0.25779807567596436,
0.5563617944717407,
-0.9103958010673523,
0.42111074924468994,
0.058054711669683456,
0.048322033137083054,
-0.5056412220001221,
-0.407715380191803,
0.014383558183908463,
-0.048285748809576035,
-0.5759060978889465,
0.3938676714897156,
-0.3618026375770569,
-0.31918200850486755,
0.15916460752487183,
0.016921518370509148,
-0.3389131426811218,
0.1529516726732254,
-0.3908398747444153,
0.7098582983016968,
-0.39725732803344727,
0.028594564646482468,
-0.015083207748830318,
0.0885334461927414,
0.26526954770088196,
0.013468299992382526,
0.5799150466918945,
-0.3757351338863373,
-0.6029517650604248,
-0.3117403984069824,
-0.028154095634818077,
0.4414251446723938,
-0.1580296903848648,
0.4050666093826294,
0.21059155464172363,
-0.6322838068008423,
-0.541919469833374,
-0.4475361108779907,
-0.04985552653670311,
-0.4529728591442108,
0.769179105758667,
-0.22138148546218872,
-0.5900329351425171,
0.22043271362781525,
-0.20045100152492523,
0.25488948822021484,
0.40399155020713806,
0.47316044569015503,
0.2349218726158142,
0.914596676826477,
0.43489962816238403,
-0.14485834538936615,
0.1997566670179367,
-0.1940331757068634,
0.19494880735874176,
-1.055551290512085,
-0.11367682367563248,
-0.21015039086341858,
-0.22768057882785797,
-0.4286297857761383,
-0.25573861598968506,
0.2698947787284851,
0.016849765554070473,
-0.5193105936050415,
0.05780067667365074,
-0.40258675813674927,
0.705499529838562,
0.22431857883930206,
0.002650048118084669,
0.32375869154930115,
-0.2510194778442383,
0.02012663707137108,
-0.020286645740270615,
-0.317171186208725,
-0.8261833190917969,
1.1761858463287354,
0.30310994386672974,
0.702281653881073,
-0.0225903932005167,
0.5699263215065002,
0.09120988100767136,
0.4214428663253784,
-0.787937581539154,
0.7273486852645874,
-0.24656152725219727,
-0.46190908551216125,
-0.37141239643096924,
-0.08321357518434525,
-0.767854630947113,
0.7496632933616638,
0.0031947516836225986,
-0.6250209808349609,
-0.3031213879585266,
-0.2992023527622223,
-0.42900609970092773,
0.39267435669898987,
-0.634596586227417,
0.7237019538879395,
-0.7472169995307922,
-0.6185266971588135,
-0.1457098126411438,
-0.18391376733779907,
0.6144061088562012,
-0.3903132379055023,
0.23427636921405792,
-0.0017159780254587531,
-0.2262621819972992,
0.7887659072875977,
-0.2141207754611969,
0.6313544511795044,
-0.0326022133231163,
-0.022453516721725464,
0.570294201374054,
-0.20955251157283783,
0.4077497124671936,
-0.3653146028518677,
-0.0646100714802742,
0.09957770258188248,
0.031534239649772644,
-0.270408034324646,
-0.670168936252594,
0.7578237652778625,
-0.9037489295005798,
-0.7591326236724854,
-0.39426612854003906,
-0.04919895529747009,
0.04686945304274559,
0.16643935441970825,
0.00865191500633955,
0.1512340009212494,
-0.5458459258079529,
0.24568194150924683,
0.3427474796772003,
-0.5619387626647949,
0.4429008960723877,
0.8135526180267334,
-0.5448647141456604,
-0.3989320993423462,
1.122941493988037,
0.48928359150886536,
0.5031342506408691,
0.2692880928516388,
0.4360082447528839,
-0.23117275536060333,
-0.1988438218832016,
-0.361320436000824,
-0.12079143524169922,
-0.835347056388855,
0.09564127773046494,
-0.46677160263061523,
-0.707068145275116,
-0.10533377528190613,
-0.30675002932548523,
-0.5905851125717163,
0.07183566689491272,
0.14857187867164612,
-0.1592998504638672,
-0.3512115180492401,
0.7548146843910217,
0.21536388993263245,
-0.1593470573425293,
-0.5658626556396484,
0.2002871334552765,
0.22786535322666168,
0.5555073618888855,
0.30237966775894165,
-0.4836033880710602,
-0.28699901700019836,
-0.06134127080440521,
-0.660335898399353,
-0.5736970901489258,
0.3850252032279968,
0.3250533938407898,
0.7320769429206848,
0.44110092520713806,
0.013037165626883507,
0.6505544781684875,
-0.5364248156547546,
1.2421818971633911,
0.08218967914581299,
-1.0783852338790894,
0.48387783765792847,
0.0894429013133049,
0.12138783186674118,
0.13500577211380005,
0.06452346593141556,
-0.6976236701011658,
-0.38344037532806396,
-0.39434656500816345,
-0.8676320910453796,
0.6954452991485596,
-0.0384695790708065,
-0.04539033770561218,
-0.046203017234802246,
-0.0958954468369484,
0.26322364807128906,
0.046480901539325714,
-0.7785539627075195,
-0.559779167175293,
0.06492561101913452,
0.010198228992521763,
0.13933199644088745,
-0.14953802525997162,
0.21634924411773682,
-0.27606603503227234,
0.5815694332122803,
0.0972980186343193,
-0.0975867435336113,
0.08764786273241043,
-0.09342004358768463,
-0.14178846776485443,
0.5641477704048157,
0.4967195391654968,
0.5903275012969971,
0.03568022698163986,
0.0960002914071083,
0.5115249156951904,
-0.6297467350959778,
0.22349651157855988,
-0.17859181761741638,
-0.16055457293987274,
-0.22291211783885956,
0.4046502113342285,
0.5928400158882141,
0.20669880509376526,
-0.9492141604423523,
0.47940725088119507,
0.09392020106315613,
-0.17933432757854462,
-0.4126981496810913,
-0.03315419703722,
-0.13962100446224213,
-0.007287728134542704,
0.37782666087150574,
-0.4810592830181122,
0.2347104698419571,
-0.49197065830230713,
0.15203744173049927,
0.1766171157360077,
0.017827529460191727,
-0.5582041144371033,
0.5021112561225891,
0.2885887622833252,
-0.31762346625328064,
0.4256129860877991,
-0.15507230162620544,
-0.7303071618080139,
1.0894172191619873,
0.7641869783401489,
1.0960092544555664,
-0.44836533069610596,
0.1258072853088379,
0.727397620677948,
0.4840608239173889,
-0.117237389087677,
0.30781155824661255,
0.1295788586139679,
-0.7231451272964478,
-0.38828757405281067,
-0.5227748155593872,
-0.6748738884925842,
0.38134196400642395,
-0.6174591183662415,
0.5437686443328857,
-0.6147093772888184,
0.14059025049209595,
-0.2847456634044647,
0.24766460061073303,
-0.8554015755653381,
0.2479056864976883,
0.48647981882095337,
0.8499231338500977,
-0.8296751976013184,
0.7663153409957886,
0.7396988272666931,
-0.06851132214069366,
-0.7793148756027222,
-0.045708563178777695,
0.11482148617506027,
-0.6904999613761902,
0.8945040106773376,
0.3422831594944,
-0.04495997726917267,
-0.09303098917007446,
-0.4771580994129181,
-0.8763217926025391,
1.173682451248169,
0.09275951981544495,
-0.843279242515564,
0.3670766055583954,
0.22635959088802338,
0.7497609853744507,
-0.4540659189224243,
0.7395651340484619,
0.742921769618988,
0.6975694298744202,
-0.22064106166362762,
-0.9531717300415039,
-0.15087513625621796,
-0.38530850410461426,
-0.08183422684669495,
0.11113829910755157,
-1.0928843021392822,
0.9842661619186401,
0.0221884585916996,
-0.46051210165023804,
0.010022022761404514,
0.3936653733253479,
0.5460999608039856,
0.6026456356048584,
0.261621356010437,
0.40477487444877625,
0.8856493234634399,
-0.25892457365989685,
0.8880409002304077,
-0.7013995051383972,
0.5165966153144836,
0.8714743256568909,
-0.5964788198471069,
1.0659724473953247,
0.31178897619247437,
-0.6210106611251831,
0.20483049750328064,
0.7697601914405823,
-0.0801839828491211,
0.35023233294487,
0.2704101502895355,
-0.34082669019699097,
-0.38460659980773926,
-0.31298643350601196,
-0.3776201903820038,
0.40744656324386597,
0.4935953617095947,
-0.13480405509471893,
-0.2947176992893219,
-0.09904222935438156,
-0.37781304121017456,
0.2531075179576874,
-0.51622474193573,
0.3584924638271332,
0.2345237284898758,
-0.666138768196106,
0.43068110942840576,
0.030383700504899025,
0.7011026740074158,
-0.5123441219329834,
-0.2263902872800827,
-0.02738480642437935,
0.0018909862264990807,
-0.0785459503531456,
-0.9497463703155518,
-0.1143304705619812,
0.20166367292404175,
0.29611289501190186,
0.03530111908912659,
0.8158506751060486,
-0.5561736226081848,
-0.4932493567466736,
0.5981531143188477,
0.6619415879249573,
0.2070881575345993,
0.3162350654602051,
-0.6013516187667847,
0.17151089012622833,
-0.21448975801467896,
-0.8299037218093872,
0.3398919105529785,
0.29974275827407837,
0.025838207453489304,
0.6788224577903748,
0.619826078414917,
0.269948273897171,
-0.048962775617837906,
0.21211642026901245,
0.6419856548309326,
-0.7883073091506958,
-0.32974961400032043,
-1.1017645597457886,
0.41564735770225525,
-0.03838963806629181,
-0.35123515129089355,
0.6311414241790771,
0.6269838809967041,
1.0553371906280518,
0.1786341518163681,
1.0493797063827515,
0.06320537626743317,
0.19053323566913605,
-0.3260936439037323,
0.6623498201370239,
-0.46525952219963074,
0.3923121988773346,
-0.15005198121070862,
-1.1919448375701904,
-0.12269118428230286,
0.4963739812374115,
-0.49540215730667114,
0.2340174913406372,
0.9580186009407043,
0.4196398854255676,
0.42807263135910034,
0.16068942844867706,
0.8883890509605408,
0.0032094630878418684,
0.4800465404987335,
0.9530090689659119,
1.1453794240951538,
-0.5271543860435486,
0.4047107398509979,
-0.5001761317253113,
-0.22104963660240173,
0.0366019569337368,
-0.56912761926651,
-0.898436427116394,
-0.2973082363605499,
-0.07666807621717453,
0.07468615472316742,
-0.024062378332018852,
1.3497179746627808,
0.07814627885818481,
-0.5745506286621094,
-0.3715437054634094,
0.16773048043251038,
0.13728021085262299,
-0.318735808134079,
-0.2808934152126312,
0.670806884765625,
-0.30771127343177795,
-1.1421757936477661,
0.26868078112602234,
0.4230884313583374,
-0.23708736896514893,
-0.48203685879707336,
-0.1480260044336319,
-0.0054413736797869205,
0.1060146614909172,
0.8688568472862244,
0.0890873372554779,
-1.0196075439453125,
-0.45672881603240967,
0.3282455503940582,
-0.3322238028049469,
-0.06590007245540619,
0.4093741178512573,
-0.5421273112297058,
0.6649536490440369,
0.32363271713256836,
0.7871869206428528,
-0.06680843234062195,
-0.1508888453245163,
0.36070048809051514,
-0.19895632565021515,
-0.3353976011276245,
0.08152419328689575,
0.3623194992542267,
0.12489595264196396,
-0.11386577039957047,
0.48479077219963074,
0.042575545608997345,
-0.7732663154602051,
-0.8712343573570251,
-0.20908726751804352,
-0.562726616859436,
-0.13214333355426788,
1.086786150932312,
-0.3012305498123169,
-0.3077699542045593,
0.0016632749466225505,
-0.2109212875366211,
0.015177890658378601,
-0.22558088600635529,
0.8071310520172119,
1.171552062034607,
-0.048615146428346634,
-0.15294142067432404,
-0.7316752076148987,
-0.03354957327246666,
0.5373214483261108,
-0.7808499932289124,
0.0927518755197525,
0.20665498077869415,
0.05375409871339798,
-0.09117315709590912,
0.4994913637638092,
-0.030792701989412308,
0.4296567142009735,
0.10162030160427094,
0.07830777764320374,
0.18260708451271057,
-0.3429122567176819,
-0.3897900879383087,
0.20444819331169128,
0.10928584635257721,
-0.05447310581803322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16454v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16454v1 | KAUCUS: Knowledge Augmented User Simulators for Training Language Model Assistants | 2024-01-29T06:57:02 | 2024-01-29T06:57:02 | Kaustubh D. Dhole | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2.7; H.3.3 | An effective multi-turn instruction-following assistant can be developed by
creating a simulator that can generate useful interaction data. Apart from
relying on its intrinsic weights, an ideal user simulator should also be able
to bootstrap external knowledge rapidly in its raw form to simulate the
multifarious diversity of text available over the internet. Previous user
simulators generally lacked diversity, were mostly closed domain, and
necessitated rigid schema making them inefficient to rapidly scale to
incorporate external knowledge. In this regard, we introduce, Kaucus, a
Knowledge-Augmented User Simulator framework, to outline a process of creating
diverse user simulators, that can seamlessly exploit external knowledge as well
as benefit downstream assistant model training. Through two GPT-J based
simulators viz., a Retrieval Augmented Simulator and a Summary Controlled
Simulator we generate diverse simulator-assistant interactions. Through reward
and preference model-based evaluations, we find that these interactions serve
as useful training data and create more helpful downstream assistants. We also
find that incorporating knowledge through retrieval augmentation or summary
control helps create better assistants. | [
-0.2645662724971771,
-0.6724532246589661,
0.4309951364994049,
0.39737656712532043,
0.05283280462026596,
0.27572932839393616,
-0.24553652107715607,
-0.4454001486301422,
0.42231374979019165,
0.2766887843608856,
-0.28885790705680847,
-0.012132460251450539,
-0.5598433613777161,
-0.05795915052294731,
-0.3043988347053528,
0.9107904434204102,
0.16287341713905334,
0.31299760937690735,
-0.4282967746257782,
-0.04396651312708855,
-0.5129882097244263,
-0.8859352469444275,
-0.6009894013404846,
-0.12486768513917923,
0.5502603650093079,
0.5608795881271362,
0.6293017268180847,
0.1506655067205429,
0.12667809426784515,
0.3510527014732361,
0.05937902629375458,
0.2516319751739502,
-0.14505535364151,
0.10992113500833511,
-0.03290858119726181,
-0.532707154750824,
-0.22299198806285858,
-0.02262169122695923,
0.5177498459815979,
0.5612481832504272,
-0.1402081847190857,
-0.08667801320552826,
0.035674817860126495,
0.46927839517593384,
-0.6355236768722534,
-0.06622672080993652,
-0.3377809226512909,
-0.2190253883600235,
0.05909595265984535,
-0.2736371159553528,
-0.48714515566825867,
-0.3959571421146393,
0.2666488587856293,
-0.92137211561203,
-0.014992195181548595,
-0.33799082040786743,
0.904848575592041,
-0.0471157468855381,
-0.5457316040992737,
-0.5385887026786804,
-1.0142419338226318,
0.6752539873123169,
-0.744809091091156,
0.6336265206336975,
0.3716554045677185,
0.7120669484138489,
-0.29352742433547974,
-0.7102965116500854,
-0.6216755509376526,
-0.49117639660835266,
-0.24238237738609314,
0.0992925688624382,
0.34536364674568176,
0.09741055965423584,
0.06672170013189316,
0.5140908360481262,
-0.011860554106533527,
-0.21798264980316162,
-0.5156874656677246,
-0.14459773898124695,
0.5255091190338135,
0.08067832142114639,
0.7357705235481262,
0.1041070744395256,
-0.32659417390823364,
-0.4430880844593048,
-0.6637471914291382,
0.1326480507850647,
1.0071173906326294,
0.4873155653476715,
-0.20293423533439636,
0.5370579361915588,
-0.2552017271518707,
0.5271424055099487,
-0.20497466623783112,
-0.37607821822166443,
0.3956819474697113,
-0.14484116435050964,
-0.25091254711151123,
-0.204141765832901,
0.6076751947402954,
-0.20656150579452515,
-0.02097548171877861,
-0.46710726618766785,
-0.08728859573602676,
0.13962174952030182,
0.5200451612472534,
-0.5372455716133118,
-0.6207489371299744,
-0.04241488501429558,
-0.13860012590885162,
-0.32542136311531067,
-0.06327954679727554,
-0.8194029927253723,
-0.26603493094444275,
-0.6160479784011841,
0.5622832179069519,
-0.658042848110199,
-0.5200243592262268,
-0.2138998657464981,
-0.3065537214279175,
0.18422293663024902,
0.7083186507225037,
-1.1315383911132812,
0.7323389053344727,
0.24608728289604187,
0.6701012253761292,
-0.22960981726646423,
-0.49465838074684143,
-0.6486350297927856,
0.1989913433790207,
0.06730539351701736,
0.7623031139373779,
-0.762373685836792,
-0.6968811750411987,
-0.043059784919023514,
-0.1171972006559372,
-0.21234600245952606,
-0.2542816400527954,
0.28996792435646057,
-0.6289780139923096,
0.22154362499713898,
-0.42628592252731323,
-0.5833695530891418,
-0.16407328844070435,
0.1470344066619873,
-0.7786118388175964,
1.0733380317687988,
0.2757066786289215,
-0.5311485528945923,
0.34515973925590515,
-0.9653171896934509,
-0.6046422719955444,
0.08664003759622574,
-0.3695243000984192,
-0.07595140486955643,
-0.20769408345222473,
0.19701166450977325,
0.15421807765960693,
0.05622188374400139,
-0.12952545285224915,
-0.07286892831325531,
-0.17959198355674744,
-0.05918585881590843,
-0.10614611953496933,
0.8150210976600647,
0.06265249103307724,
-0.03132912889122963,
0.35664916038513184,
-0.3919769823551178,
-0.30439767241477966,
0.10627710819244385,
-0.5530041456222534,
-0.6463562250137329,
-0.23098090291023254,
0.057940129190683365,
0.2937796711921692,
0.01815582811832428,
-0.43702903389930725,
0.56270432472229,
-0.09406255930662155,
-0.21839699149131775,
0.5798958539962769,
-0.019905537366867065,
0.7364184260368347,
-0.13292165100574493,
0.7761883735656738,
-0.019055580720305443,
0.26380130648612976,
0.011229942552745342,
-0.6440837383270264,
-0.8221335411071777,
-0.3435222804546356,
0.26475462317466736,
0.45670539140701294,
-1.0600016117095947,
0.08666981756687164,
-0.0037067425437271595,
-0.46761655807495117,
-0.7668614983558655,
0.5477558970451355,
0.1343214511871338,
0.4840170741081238,
0.4214482605457306,
-0.11237844079732895,
-0.39124733209609985,
-0.7118262648582458,
-0.15986718237400055,
-0.20666736364364624,
-0.04365474730730057,
0.4911978840827942,
0.3825704753398895,
-0.09738773852586746,
0.6596457362174988,
-0.30757537484169006,
-0.48429569602012634,
-0.5402973294258118,
0.2255040407180786,
-0.5178606510162354,
0.5987097024917603,
0.5573586225509644,
-0.9005973935127258,
-0.2896248996257782,
0.10374951362609863,
-0.6686699390411377,
0.3161575496196747,
-0.34241679310798645,
-0.3429243266582489,
0.19915080070495605,
0.3345657289028168,
-0.5509604215621948,
0.30038294196128845,
0.5502792000770569,
-0.1937798261642456,
0.6085379719734192,
-0.4113020598888397,
0.400488018989563,
-1.1871110200881958,
0.2671287953853607,
-0.13913577795028687,
-0.030610665678977966,
-0.7178568840026855,
0.2211383879184723,
0.12273843586444855,
0.2089599221944809,
-0.5316870212554932,
0.630865752696991,
-0.48066291213035583,
-0.37804368138313293,
-0.2895863950252533,
0.10714652389287949,
-0.080490343272686,
0.6415742635726929,
0.24865184724330902,
0.9795995950698853,
0.3294151723384857,
-0.8422191143035889,
0.326191782951355,
0.2683447599411011,
-0.18252943456172943,
0.1908571720123291,
-0.5205861330032349,
0.17017562687397003,
0.23182910680770874,
0.09529341757297516,
-0.827795147895813,
-0.44302403926849365,
0.1526549905538559,
-0.4514336585998535,
0.17218196392059326,
-0.35762831568717957,
-0.9037225842475891,
-0.17743715643882751,
-0.12425640970468521,
0.5145348906517029,
0.6492199301719666,
-0.7480895519256592,
1.0622164011001587,
0.4646202623844147,
-0.09882292151451111,
-0.5079886317253113,
-0.44775745272636414,
-0.16446851193904877,
-0.11404246091842651,
-0.4279288947582245,
-0.009237058460712433,
-0.0780753567814827,
0.08624621480703354,
-0.11875757575035095,
0.3880746364593506,
0.04223201423883438,
0.1998792588710785,
0.23604314029216766,
0.4985431134700775,
0.13455839455127716,
0.2613532543182373,
0.5597317218780518,
0.30358952283859253,
0.07446981221437454,
0.07093827426433563,
0.5503793358802795,
-0.1666637510061264,
-0.5468174815177917,
-0.51020747423172,
0.10356380045413971,
0.4551492929458618,
-0.16715162992477417,
0.6765047907829285,
0.5306107401847839,
-0.35725027322769165,
0.16252364218235016,
-0.5030384063720703,
-0.336437463760376,
-0.47928228974342346,
0.17212936282157898,
-0.4339761734008789,
-0.4638405740261078,
0.5857366323471069,
-0.2453652173280716,
0.445657879114151,
0.27314725518226624,
0.5739017724990845,
0.20345036685466766,
1.1647251844406128,
0.8863665461540222,
-0.06148224323987961,
0.5066768527030945,
-0.3407975435256958,
0.03231128677725792,
-0.9667502045631409,
-0.6399083733558655,
-0.38018912076950073,
-0.1592637300491333,
-0.08914563804864883,
-0.19744320213794708,
0.146637424826622,
0.28271806240081787,
0.1327042281627655,
0.3484121263027191,
-0.28427404165267944,
0.307395875453949,
0.788918673992157,
0.054002273827791214,
0.38855576515197754,
-0.03323964774608612,
-0.34370502829551697,
0.1532932072877884,
-0.7097005844116211,
-0.693240225315094,
1.083622694015503,
0.2884317934513092,
0.8792178630828857,
0.13457335531711578,
0.6745858788490295,
0.3373609185218811,
0.8845304846763611,
-0.8736256957054138,
0.36126992106437683,
0.22975796461105347,
-0.5199183225631714,
-0.24800105392932892,
-0.3854421377182007,
-0.49348634481430054,
0.13150283694267273,
-0.27709031105041504,
-0.8345405459403992,
-0.04172077029943466,
0.6106770634651184,
-0.3521754741668701,
0.5351027846336365,
-1.2145177125930786,
0.8178157806396484,
-0.21157847344875336,
-0.2183711975812912,
-0.17332115769386292,
-0.5223247408866882,
0.5922841429710388,
0.23496116697788239,
0.020908815786242485,
0.15335297584533691,
0.014178457669913769,
0.6784834861755371,
-0.6011601090431213,
0.658643364906311,
-0.2679459750652313,
-0.12361834943294525,
0.3537299931049347,
0.14796558022499084,
0.21217790246009827,
0.18907645344734192,
0.16437649726867676,
-0.16910941898822784,
-0.06246703863143921,
-0.5665456652641296,
-0.7488739490509033,
0.9105180501937866,
-1.0714714527130127,
-0.5028757452964783,
-0.2021700143814087,
-0.8631448149681091,
-0.24537897109985352,
-0.023191457614302635,
-0.0946018174290657,
0.2689622938632965,
-0.1983811855316162,
-0.31885650753974915,
0.3223135471343994,
-0.2295425534248352,
-0.03305087983608246,
0.2537083625793457,
-0.4377090632915497,
-0.35705041885375977,
1.1426981687545776,
-0.19443178176879883,
0.5128020644187927,
0.1366434097290039,
0.02743203565478325,
-0.30252403020858765,
-0.02127908356487751,
-0.8706769347190857,
0.020170997828245163,
-0.7630220055580139,
-0.14986185729503632,
-0.8846335411071777,
-0.2047089785337448,
-0.4710919260978699,
-0.3033476173877716,
-0.32730692625045776,
-0.4722072184085846,
-0.08286028355360031,
-0.07481621205806732,
0.6902392506599426,
0.8771304488182068,
-0.06709423661231995,
0.7311411499977112,
-0.5965772271156311,
0.35883834958076477,
0.6070641279220581,
0.41386982798576355,
0.21128474175930023,
-0.2954820692539215,
-0.3046680986881256,
0.25829604268074036,
-0.36503127217292786,
-0.7698110938072205,
0.2967090904712677,
-0.17130820453166962,
0.6653207540512085,
0.3811649978160858,
-0.19375748932361603,
0.5080453157424927,
-0.19097895920276642,
0.8254554271697998,
0.0378446951508522,
-0.7348502278327942,
0.5743194818496704,
-0.0400736927986145,
0.19742681086063385,
0.5882952213287354,
0.3880196511745453,
-0.4263094663619995,
-0.7732143402099609,
-0.625707745552063,
-0.8220483064651489,
0.9733187556266785,
0.4661101996898651,
0.3486713469028473,
-0.053603410720825195,
0.16172698140144348,
0.32641372084617615,
0.04918163642287254,
-0.4198952913284302,
-0.42636537551879883,
-0.3540097177028656,
-0.2493857741355896,
0.3234978914260864,
0.021858319640159607,
-0.05329722538590431,
-0.21689392626285553,
1.0708591938018799,
-0.046020977199077606,
0.30897173285484314,
0.018092606216669083,
-0.29159629344940186,
0.101642906665802,
0.07706515491008759,
0.5625358819961548,
0.44741880893707275,
-0.24545612931251526,
-0.15561966598033905,
0.34075263142585754,
-0.7309534549713135,
-0.0051322621293365955,
0.26135167479515076,
0.01673663780093193,
0.12374693900346756,
-0.1811998337507248,
0.5193303227424622,
0.07973910123109818,
-0.7322704792022705,
0.34193283319473267,
-0.49011367559432983,
-0.13256080448627472,
-0.4211452305316925,
0.2875347137451172,
0.26334241032600403,
0.04669037088751793,
0.45062342286109924,
0.07318554818630219,
0.3257907032966614,
-0.44334566593170166,
0.05599677190184593,
0.3624535799026489,
-0.05228051915764809,
-0.3990706205368042,
0.69912189245224,
0.5235745310783386,
-0.28612765669822693,
0.5315064191818237,
-0.15596623718738556,
-0.46749383211135864,
0.622046172618866,
0.44229426980018616,
0.6190913915634155,
-0.6290687322616577,
0.23605401813983917,
0.3406922221183777,
0.10475895553827286,
-0.08516190201044083,
0.3490561544895172,
-0.25433337688446045,
-0.5184139609336853,
-0.2304733246564865,
-0.277129203081131,
-0.6437022686004639,
0.38282158970832825,
-0.6868199706077576,
0.4891621172428131,
-0.47515612840652466,
-0.02352386713027954,
0.11710137873888016,
-0.14109128713607788,
-0.7458040714263916,
0.08474277704954147,
-0.1075357124209404,
0.9699563384056091,
-1.0715912580490112,
1.0248284339904785,
1.1697971820831299,
-0.7561218738555908,
-0.8649423718452454,
-0.188927561044693,
-0.2211889773607254,
-0.4974082410335541,
0.6514332890510559,
0.020303502678871155,
-0.11929968744516373,
-0.14762826263904572,
-0.3324488401412964,
-0.4679383337497711,
1.1151554584503174,
0.3522789478302002,
-0.10167349874973297,
-0.3579871654510498,
0.07567933946847916,
0.4965769052505493,
-0.40943676233291626,
0.5170432329177856,
0.49226003885269165,
0.11574633419513702,
0.20576979219913483,
-0.821038544178009,
-0.0995430052280426,
-0.36078283190727234,
-0.13063742220401764,
0.19079367816448212,
-0.46179428696632385,
0.5597986578941345,
-0.2841488718986511,
-0.04908547177910805,
0.2744097113609314,
0.8327884674072266,
0.24455823004245758,
0.018829869106411934,
0.6899617910385132,
0.4146880805492401,
0.5639107823371887,
0.24567273259162903,
1.1837353706359863,
-0.5023249983787537,
0.03614502772688866,
1.3456412553787231,
-0.10441558808088303,
0.6727839112281799,
0.7098072171211243,
0.11173950880765915,
0.714836597442627,
0.2041247934103012,
0.31008243560791016,
0.4877469539642334,
-0.2429179847240448,
-0.45264649391174316,
-0.25583213567733765,
-0.07252555340528488,
-0.35081616044044495,
0.18434534966945648,
0.5608804225921631,
-0.3471677005290985,
-0.26335790753364563,
0.05819912627339363,
-0.11296011507511139,
0.12565170228481293,
-0.07974624633789062,
0.8631135821342468,
0.0031491443514823914,
-0.535518229007721,
0.16045290231704712,
0.06089584529399872,
0.3784030079841614,
-0.8109190464019775,
-0.4158949553966522,
-0.22717884182929993,
0.03158973157405853,
-0.040951404720544815,
-0.6019371747970581,
-0.0025383802130818367,
-0.08767855912446976,
0.2143324613571167,
0.011477834545075893,
0.8413701057434082,
-0.6365408301353455,
-0.48081308603286743,
0.23210060596466064,
0.630371630191803,
0.18984374403953552,
0.2532076835632324,
-0.36453136801719666,
-0.1797315627336502,
-0.18954327702522278,
-0.23937053978443146,
0.4179550111293793,
0.2764800786972046,
-0.10184425860643387,
0.7644522190093994,
0.757956326007843,
0.09394647926092148,
0.05447143316268921,
0.316498726606369,
1.3025749921798706,
-0.11035704612731934,
-0.709672212600708,
-0.37075456976890564,
0.49637383222579956,
-0.3750769793987274,
-0.3894845247268677,
0.7538298964500427,
0.6821538805961609,
0.9346442222595215,
-0.2946402430534363,
1.0482982397079468,
-0.1397123783826828,
0.4313180148601532,
-0.3253648579120636,
0.8397255539894104,
-0.5316047072410583,
0.19097109138965607,
-0.43265408277511597,
-0.6934340000152588,
0.0451229065656662,
0.39074841141700745,
-0.39604708552360535,
0.26485633850097656,
0.1497907042503357,
0.5939394235610962,
-0.547746479511261,
0.1214059516787529,
0.30885517597198486,
-0.3288203775882721,
0.40965279936790466,
0.4263787865638733,
0.885424017906189,
-0.4942292869091034,
0.6205941438674927,
-0.6081743836402893,
-0.17441871762275696,
-0.39107218384742737,
-0.361097127199173,
-1.2221996784210205,
-0.6596781015396118,
0.00683937082067132,
-0.10474489629268646,
0.18405365943908691,
1.1279157400131226,
0.8726106882095337,
-0.6990055441856384,
-0.36904534697532654,
-0.12107302248477936,
0.1335744708776474,
-0.05457073077559471,
-0.27333512902259827,
0.333138108253479,
-0.7170670628547668,
-0.8027428984642029,
0.2422502189874649,
-0.05465137958526611,
0.5063236355781555,
-0.34434887766838074,
-0.492552787065506,
-0.5284966826438904,
-0.023306382820010185,
0.6833680272102356,
0.6463813781738281,
-0.450838565826416,
-0.02730577625334263,
-0.03534345701336861,
-0.12715278565883636,
-0.10766226798295975,
1.0006088018417358,
-1.2430765628814697,
0.5744081139564514,
0.2375013679265976,
0.8855171799659729,
0.11407880485057831,
0.1892070472240448,
0.9491450786590576,
-0.8844814300537109,
0.284229576587677,
0.061967168003320694,
0.3344448208808899,
0.5298953652381897,
-0.5909170508384705,
0.24464884400367737,
0.006490746047347784,
-0.2340255230665207,
-0.7135825157165527,
0.026217110455036163,
-0.8290578722953796,
-0.008475243113934994,
1.2456954717636108,
-0.36433786153793335,
0.07246473431587219,
-0.05425887927412987,
-0.5370987057685852,
0.46435976028442383,
-0.7356009483337402,
0.9706840515136719,
0.4662061035633087,
-0.10193891823291779,
-0.0007423756178468466,
-0.77149897813797,
0.8350715637207031,
0.3969343900680542,
-1.3973932266235352,
-0.04719502106308937,
0.38567692041397095,
0.232953280210495,
0.22861488163471222,
0.5615507364273071,
-0.0263376384973526,
0.47905856370925903,
-0.03456535190343857,
0.26994606852531433,
-0.19772140681743622,
-0.6316823363304138,
-0.026405295357108116,
-0.3073851764202118,
0.2722811698913574,
-0.2657608091831207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01733v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01733v1 | Development and Testing of Retrieval Augmented Generation in Large Language Models -- A Case Study Report | 2024-01-29T06:49:53 | 2024-01-29T06:49:53 | YuHe Ke, Liyuan Jin, Kabilan Elangovan, Hairil Rizal Abdullah, Nan Liu, Alex Tiong Heng Sia, Chai Rick Soh, Joshua Yi Min Tung, Jasmine Chiat Ling Ong, Daniel Shu Wei Ting | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Purpose: Large Language Models (LLMs) hold significant promise for medical
applications. Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) emerges as a promising
approach for customizing domain knowledge in LLMs. This case study presents the
development and evaluation of an LLM-RAG pipeline tailored for healthcare,
focusing specifically on preoperative medicine.
Methods: We developed an LLM-RAG model using 35 preoperative guidelines and
tested it against human-generated responses, with a total of 1260 responses
evaluated. The RAG process involved converting clinical documents into text
using Python-based frameworks like LangChain and Llamaindex, and processing
these texts into chunks for embedding and retrieval. Vector storage techniques
and selected embedding models to optimize data retrieval, using Pinecone for
vector storage with a dimensionality of 1536 and cosine similarity for loss
metrics. Human-generated answers, provided by junior doctors, were used as a
comparison.
Results: The LLM-RAG model generated answers within an average of 15-20
seconds, significantly faster than the 10 minutes typically required by humans.
Among the basic LLMs, GPT4.0 exhibited the best accuracy of 80.1%. This
accuracy was further increased to 91.4% when the model was enhanced with RAG.
Compared to the human-generated instructions, which had an accuracy of 86.3%,
the performance of the GPT4.0 RAG model demonstrated non-inferiority (p=0.610).
Conclusions: In this case study, we demonstrated a LLM-RAG model for
healthcare implementation. The pipeline shows the advantages of grounded
knowledge, upgradability, and scalability as important aspects of healthcare
LLM deployment. | [
-0.15052352845668793,
-0.512111485004425,
0.8602550029754639,
-0.19026893377304077,
-0.42382562160491943,
0.1436358541250229,
-0.0333825945854187,
-0.44923368096351624,
0.3349461853504181,
0.7882081866264343,
-0.2600044310092926,
-0.5960067510604858,
-0.5921304225921631,
0.12392693758010864,
-0.47761252522468567,
1.1413545608520508,
-0.11197502166032791,
0.3008783161640167,
-0.11685076355934143,
0.05617151036858559,
-0.3156408369541168,
-0.7647188305854797,
-0.3746529519557953,
-0.37032413482666016,
0.3780473470687866,
0.11240997910499573,
0.6176291108131409,
0.5747370719909668,
0.906938374042511,
0.2754289507865906,
-0.07922128587961197,
0.08694279193878174,
-0.44548943638801575,
0.08336082100868225,
-0.13663144409656525,
-0.3094652593135834,
-0.561250627040863,
-0.11967679113149643,
0.5383135080337524,
0.6890869736671448,
-0.5603044033050537,
0.3120747208595276,
-0.09841929376125336,
0.7700963020324707,
-0.6238253116607666,
-0.236756831407547,
-0.583692729473114,
0.18599778413772583,
-0.26763296127319336,
-0.3314001262187958,
-0.32199034094810486,
-0.4831193685531616,
0.3260713517665863,
-0.6074360609054565,
0.1844387799501419,
0.25903597474098206,
0.8695430159568787,
0.283003568649292,
-0.3883143663406372,
-0.7136853933334351,
-0.6823566555976868,
0.5913279056549072,
-0.8159501552581787,
0.4666760563850403,
0.3386048972606659,
0.3891971707344055,
-0.12106350064277649,
-1.2794219255447388,
-0.37316495180130005,
-0.34433794021606445,
-0.19335906207561493,
0.23547427356243134,
0.025612231343984604,
0.23063057661056519,
0.2153264284133911,
0.5480606555938721,
-0.7196168899536133,
0.09461577236652374,
-0.2963554561138153,
-0.109114870429039,
0.4835936427116394,
0.41463688015937805,
0.22110804915428162,
-0.5163266062736511,
-0.4461125135421753,
0.1455010026693344,
-0.827145516872406,
-0.34800979495048523,
0.0588701069355011,
-0.056623488664627075,
-0.006857392378151417,
0.8141695261001587,
-0.046430446207523346,
0.7346733212471008,
-0.019502710551023483,
-0.324556827545166,
0.39318323135375977,
-0.37710902094841003,
-0.37763169407844543,
-0.09573354572057724,
0.6024361848831177,
0.19448906183242798,
0.08081549406051636,
-0.011246144771575928,
-0.3997846841812134,
-0.03768714517354965,
0.7848730683326721,
-0.8664243221282959,
-0.0834314301609993,
0.20272180438041687,
-0.7806710004806519,
-0.5150100588798523,
-0.21810922026634216,
-0.44053277373313904,
-0.5953770279884338,
-0.3168814480304718,
0.352840781211853,
-0.20050503313541412,
-0.13448844850063324,
0.19461864233016968,
0.14188021421432495,
0.36354464292526245,
0.194292351603508,
-0.5962386131286621,
0.36586132645606995,
0.7381431460380554,
0.7197878360748291,
-0.5615665912628174,
0.13574448227882385,
-0.5101684331893921,
0.006503652315586805,
-0.6450595259666443,
0.780503511428833,
-0.1913997232913971,
-0.5810220241546631,
0.1455114781856537,
0.03459600359201431,
0.00975008588284254,
-0.9464470148086548,
0.7851152420043945,
-0.6181351542472839,
0.14403842389583588,
0.13479462265968323,
-0.6733266115188599,
0.10423378646373749,
0.2909785211086273,
-0.48829057812690735,
0.5012689232826233,
0.372036337852478,
-0.7610408663749695,
0.27297714352607727,
-0.6048149466514587,
-0.3803820312023163,
0.34670695662498474,
-0.47497233748435974,
-0.6048893928527832,
0.25921717286109924,
0.21104185283184052,
0.5627959370613098,
-0.6216139793395996,
0.2969520092010498,
0.02077750861644745,
-0.4467403292655945,
0.09307537972927094,
-0.2011113464832306,
0.38805657625198364,
0.44545778632164,
-0.13107885420322418,
0.05463038384914398,
-0.6878420114517212,
0.04765240103006363,
0.12409317493438721,
-0.5982524752616882,
-0.23931269347667694,
-0.13310115039348602,
-0.10155673325061798,
0.08307740837335587,
0.25057271122932434,
-0.5605499744415283,
0.1212073564529419,
-0.4963156282901764,
0.01882784254848957,
0.5354835391044617,
0.2170558124780655,
0.3435101807117462,
-0.5529405474662781,
0.7990373373031616,
-0.14127062261104584,
0.23740971088409424,
-0.12442274391651154,
-0.3307408094406128,
-0.5040956139564514,
-0.1348751336336136,
0.29513922333717346,
0.5568059086799622,
-0.9057813882827759,
0.12255343794822693,
-0.23640896379947662,
-0.3306646943092346,
-0.7026404738426208,
-0.06444460898637772,
0.5939458012580872,
1.0282291173934937,
0.2752969563007355,
-0.3507002592086792,
-0.6670976877212524,
-0.8991015553474426,
-0.06250933557748795,
-0.12616698443889618,
-0.2947498559951782,
0.729712724685669,
0.3121936023235321,
-0.8287752270698547,
0.5072662830352783,
-0.7594984769821167,
-0.3410271406173706,
-0.17984624207019806,
0.02902866341173649,
0.5818194150924683,
0.38856613636016846,
0.3253368139266968,
-0.665103018283844,
-0.40979933738708496,
0.20762179791927338,
-0.7331537008285522,
-0.1413075178861618,
0.20989514887332916,
-0.1557391881942749,
0.4720325469970703,
0.339038610458374,
-0.44041356444358826,
0.576659083366394,
0.8086268305778503,
-0.06401162594556808,
0.852183997631073,
-0.4672242999076843,
0.432636559009552,
-1.380637526512146,
0.38954687118530273,
-0.3247714936733246,
-0.4456721544265747,
-0.5775806307792664,
0.15754039585590363,
0.05211035534739494,
-0.38422051072120667,
-0.5350698828697205,
0.4958966076374054,
-0.5426266193389893,
-0.17115819454193115,
-0.25271397829055786,
-0.1750263124704361,
0.05496035888791084,
0.09211177378892899,
0.11388975381851196,
0.8296730518341064,
0.21813341975212097,
-0.5587319731712341,
0.17331087589263916,
0.27598416805267334,
-0.4899692237377167,
0.4769940674304962,
-0.9256045818328857,
0.23915503919124603,
-0.04573538526892662,
0.1311069279909134,
-0.7053734660148621,
-0.3344910740852356,
-0.13035640120506287,
-0.33415138721466064,
0.4766196310520172,
-0.28846099972724915,
-0.27418139576911926,
-0.5588258504867554,
-0.05124940350651741,
0.21576279401779175,
0.8066868782043457,
-0.4114817678928375,
0.6344520449638367,
0.5439683198928833,
-0.39747852087020874,
-0.47251465916633606,
-0.3795798122882843,
-0.05264654383063316,
-0.19873522222042084,
-0.4531750977039337,
0.3893434405326843,
-0.11994139105081558,
-0.18848423659801483,
-0.147214874625206,
-0.11116603016853333,
-0.07892494648694992,
-0.14130839705467224,
0.0723474845290184,
0.5133069157600403,
-0.16836126148700714,
0.22901582717895508,
0.0385727658867836,
-0.0073775933124125,
-0.021388590335845947,
-0.09788878262042999,
0.6656109690666199,
0.12326695770025253,
-0.43516114354133606,
-0.24596233665943146,
0.38232648372650146,
0.41080787777900696,
-0.1743534803390503,
0.5303263068199158,
0.5803549289703369,
-0.4352721869945526,
0.08935554325580597,
-0.8920037746429443,
-0.15393850207328796,
-0.4530446529388428,
0.37666699290275574,
-0.1747569590806961,
-0.8913409113883972,
0.4708917737007141,
-0.40471407771110535,
0.08156539499759674,
0.384792298078537,
0.7612289786338806,
-0.31356993317604065,
0.892741858959198,
0.4062463343143463,
0.32581445574760437,
0.2813807725906372,
-0.31886497139930725,
-0.02853827178478241,
-1.1369211673736572,
-0.17817087471485138,
-0.4135229289531708,
0.05320456624031067,
-0.7058400511741638,
-0.8292134404182434,
0.8231945037841797,
0.03640167415142059,
-0.2578677535057068,
-0.10663542151451111,
-0.5972296595573425,
0.20673732459545135,
0.16830474138259888,
0.26052096486091614,
0.16083382070064545,
-0.019536545500159264,
-0.2704639434814453,
-0.06142605468630791,
-0.631526529788971,
-0.5135557055473328,
1.4266295433044434,
0.4100284278392792,
0.9624472856521606,
0.012600450776517391,
0.9821317195892334,
0.1365663856267929,
0.5841416120529175,
-0.7260675430297852,
0.29807791113853455,
-0.5137038230895996,
-0.5015069842338562,
-0.0862668976187706,
-0.4316706359386444,
-1.2045924663543701,
0.14622575044631958,
-0.4384080767631531,
-0.37044695019721985,
-0.12162204086780548,
0.09908221662044525,
-0.5655016303062439,
0.17482538521289825,
-0.7459885478019714,
0.5958664417266846,
-0.2728290855884552,
-0.32174691557884216,
-0.0852731466293335,
-0.6081417798995972,
0.3435087502002716,
-0.5480991005897522,
0.17629635334014893,
0.28840410709381104,
-0.2296578288078308,
0.638999342918396,
-0.610894501209259,
0.3455318510532379,
-0.07610400021076202,
-0.10054805129766464,
0.11469564586877823,
-0.08897222578525543,
0.6321464776992798,
0.05501051992177963,
-0.21059772372245789,
0.1366247981786728,
0.08442000299692154,
-0.0698864534497261,
-0.711940586566925,
0.7405593991279602,
-0.6638173460960388,
-0.723080575466156,
-0.439251184463501,
-0.47922682762145996,
-0.2854235768318176,
0.2701205611228943,
0.19971591234207153,
0.610786497592926,
-0.10379099100828171,
0.26530590653419495,
0.7690913081169128,
-0.7323645353317261,
0.008422449231147766,
0.7918820977210999,
-0.506883978843689,
-0.5105586051940918,
0.6767764091491699,
0.1099889874458313,
0.21651342511177063,
0.3160257041454315,
0.5181590914726257,
-0.4236207604408264,
-0.8042474389076233,
-0.44459855556488037,
0.43092116713523865,
-0.44886329770088196,
-0.20243139564990997,
-0.6600377559661865,
-0.4832506477832794,
-0.5366837382316589,
-0.10831368714570999,
-0.45274102687835693,
-0.0008542329305782914,
-0.3892056345939636,
0.043726228177547455,
0.13764531910419464,
1.1646058559417725,
0.10720961540937424,
0.1612280309200287,
-0.9798555374145508,
0.5601763129234314,
0.035619620233774185,
0.4885489344596863,
-0.2020050436258316,
-0.570933997631073,
-0.40824735164642334,
-0.09490618854761124,
-0.29386550188064575,
-0.854743480682373,
0.7441743016242981,
-0.02805953659117222,
0.5536742806434631,
0.09534500539302826,
-0.012202279642224312,
0.8106510043144226,
-0.9550281167030334,
0.7824435234069824,
0.26450005173683167,
-0.5640610456466675,
0.5918766856193542,
-0.3653044104576111,
0.4361862540245056,
0.30004388093948364,
0.47086334228515625,
-0.2534666359424591,
-0.0027171068359166384,
-0.5514628887176514,
-0.9957600831985474,
0.3464842140674591,
-0.11258716136217117,
-0.083475761115551,
-0.09948916733264923,
0.6585042476654053,
-0.05194412171840668,
0.366323322057724,
-0.1934850513935089,
-0.1842777281999588,
0.24550199508666992,
-0.012970059178769588,
-0.31477949023246765,
-0.48245278000831604,
-0.24882997572422028,
-0.11878415942192078,
0.3577176332473755,
-0.11134656518697739,
0.35960155725479126,
0.35410425066947937,
-0.020763950422406197,
0.06339501589536667,
0.35910192131996155,
0.6262022256851196,
0.8855977058410645,
-0.17634478211402893,
-0.19501818716526031,
0.1927584856748581,
-0.8583610653877258,
0.048920322209596634,
0.2073047161102295,
0.13167081773281097,
0.0895838737487793,
0.34158244729042053,
0.6305068135261536,
0.07313777506351471,
-0.6085476875305176,
0.5267065763473511,
-0.206144317984581,
-0.15700803697109222,
-0.5730608105659485,
-0.3402128517627716,
0.12778304517269135,
0.09725300967693329,
0.3688141405582428,
-0.16484805941581726,
0.4276256561279297,
-0.2855251729488373,
0.48624125123023987,
0.26157477498054504,
-0.17261381447315216,
0.0026706650387495756,
0.5614310503005981,
0.017869122326374054,
-0.17133355140686035,
0.5769298672676086,
0.09453925490379333,
-0.24839773774147034,
0.33478930592536926,
0.5894940495491028,
0.6089535355567932,
-0.29313337802886963,
0.15818049013614655,
0.3903962969779968,
0.08616955578327179,
0.0066076316870749,
0.36348286271095276,
0.26616933941841125,
-0.4686359763145447,
-0.64722740650177,
-0.919621467590332,
-0.3324432671070099,
0.06225356459617615,
-0.7805345058441162,
0.12516918778419495,
-0.26189732551574707,
-0.40666571259498596,
-0.3016413152217865,
0.17614635825157166,
-0.8463720083236694,
0.3341827094554901,
-0.1134888082742691,
0.6644757986068726,
-0.36393463611602783,
0.7397310733795166,
0.773389458656311,
-0.35900911688804626,
-1.22685968875885,
-0.0069252257235348225,
-0.11896003037691116,
-0.9515454173088074,
0.7592812776565552,
-0.2145031988620758,
0.06547743827104568,
-0.02743219956755638,
-0.203363299369812,
-0.8654646873474121,
1.1839839220046997,
0.34906601905822754,
-0.8200456500053406,
-0.28775250911712646,
0.11407337337732315,
0.9091575145721436,
-0.3847161829471588,
0.27605921030044556,
0.5144808888435364,
0.001903122290968895,
0.25210830569267273,
-1.2846601009368896,
-0.20408882200717926,
-0.1231168657541275,
0.20163291692733765,
0.14668171107769012,
-0.1880224496126175,
0.8704741597175598,
-0.2734209895133972,
-0.10925616323947906,
0.17028208076953888,
0.16878455877304077,
0.632178783416748,
0.2339174896478653,
0.3593473732471466,
0.8185731768608093,
0.743873119354248,
0.027664635330438614,
1.6742373704910278,
-0.40860119462013245,
0.12561838328838348,
0.9554184675216675,
-0.3972400724887848,
0.9146228432655334,
0.5092608332633972,
-0.052584245800971985,
0.5908582806587219,
0.35933917760849,
0.5766967535018921,
0.40463024377822876,
0.5404782295227051,
-0.3479805886745453,
0.07765814661979675,
-0.3057616353034973,
-0.5056279301643372,
0.2546592950820923,
0.3407086133956909,
-0.6448989510536194,
0.1436309963464737,
0.19004400074481964,
0.011398018337786198,
0.007296051364392042,
-0.4074781537055969,
1.1811305284500122,
0.1519443392753601,
-0.8183380365371704,
0.8773490190505981,
-0.31092843413352966,
0.5983768701553345,
-0.7474713921546936,
-0.3013063371181488,
-0.19630368053913116,
0.36034804582595825,
-0.3963926434516907,
-0.7978969812393188,
0.34518685936927795,
0.1089433878660202,
-0.14171575009822845,
-0.2343655526638031,
0.7641125321388245,
-0.21690943837165833,
-0.5059845447540283,
0.13158512115478516,
0.5554879307746887,
0.3171946704387665,
0.3059212863445282,
-0.6145368218421936,
0.3637106716632843,
-0.04392702132463455,
-0.34223178029060364,
0.4978560507297516,
0.22379828989505768,
-0.050102442502975464,
0.6616626381874084,
0.797905445098877,
0.6695878505706787,
0.058936916291713715,
0.22077201306819916,
1.0974565744400024,
-0.28709664940834045,
-0.23650164902210236,
-0.41085973381996155,
0.43513938784599304,
0.13226793706417084,
-0.044082533568143845,
0.6005297899246216,
0.6046328544616699,
0.5735549330711365,
-0.2175718992948532,
0.6410886645317078,
0.10257068276405334,
1.1154299974441528,
-0.5408622026443481,
0.9533243775367737,
-0.7169464826583862,
0.26950138807296753,
-0.4472367465496063,
-0.553479790687561,
-0.3282456398010254,
0.5851624608039856,
-0.33060556650161743,
-0.043116793036460876,
0.694678544998169,
0.8634604215621948,
0.10027788579463959,
-0.4243236184120178,
0.5291054844856262,
0.07073017954826355,
0.49090224504470825,
0.4169344902038574,
0.6576046943664551,
-0.3243483603000641,
0.2676563858985901,
-0.028260255232453346,
-0.26744937896728516,
-0.041940975934267044,
-0.7618090510368347,
-0.5461079478263855,
-0.30486738681793213,
0.030697396025061607,
-0.5982266664505005,
0.24313203990459442,
0.9270278811454773,
0.808295726776123,
-0.5949885249137878,
-0.34649455547332764,
0.1409088373184204,
-0.13758939504623413,
0.16615866124629974,
-0.16126365959644318,
0.5097806453704834,
-0.21219521760940552,
-0.5143712162971497,
0.3186202049255371,
0.12046578526496887,
0.000021927995476289652,
-0.31584104895591736,
-0.3289390802383423,
-0.2639419734477997,
-0.13980762660503387,
0.7024242877960205,
0.07537335902452469,
-0.6001291275024414,
-0.007148372009396553,
0.2964595854282379,
-0.19223856925964355,
-0.09194894134998322,
0.9394526481628418,
-0.7512545585632324,
0.7677453756332397,
0.4223036766052246,
0.8976988792419434,
0.6079645156860352,
0.2213362753391266,
0.6939699053764343,
-0.5448304414749146,
0.02831348031759262,
0.7110855579376221,
0.416868656873703,
0.3199889361858368,
-0.5263844132423401,
0.5078827738761902,
0.08510909229516983,
-1.018294095993042,
-0.9242128729820251,
0.1574685126543045,
-0.661004900932312,
0.018185526132583618,
1.2118897438049316,
-0.3426928222179413,
-0.09354428946971893,
-0.07107807695865631,
-0.4047788083553314,
0.22410085797309875,
-0.07999099045991898,
0.528526246547699,
0.2660985589027405,
-0.2892487347126007,
-0.10547944158315659,
-0.7306848168373108,
0.6479806900024414,
0.23816069960594177,
-0.939582347869873,
-0.3663119971752167,
0.4604753255844116,
0.4011043310165405,
0.13696298003196716,
1.033847689628601,
-0.4662015736103058,
0.3265988826751709,
-0.31721609830856323,
0.15612320601940155,
0.10843639820814133,
-0.06621053069829941,
-0.4090726673603058,
0.054830025881528854,
0.1297682225704193,
-0.02366594411432743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15884v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15884v2 | Corrective Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-01-29T04:36:39 | 2024-02-16T19:10:36 | Shi-Qi Yan, Jia-Chen Gu, Yun Zhu, Zhen-Hua Ling | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) inevitably exhibit hallucinations since the
accuracy of generated texts cannot be secured solely by the parametric
knowledge they encapsulate. Although retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) is a
practicable complement to LLMs, it relies heavily on the relevance of retrieved
documents, raising concerns about how the model behaves if retrieval goes
wrong. To this end, we propose the Corrective Retrieval Augmented Generation
(CRAG) to improve the robustness of generation. Specifically, a lightweight
retrieval evaluator is designed to assess the overall quality of retrieved
documents for a query, returning a confidence degree based on which different
knowledge retrieval actions can be triggered. Since retrieval from static and
limited corpora can only return sub-optimal documents, large-scale web searches
are utilized as an extension for augmenting the retrieval results. Besides, a
decompose-then-recompose algorithm is designed for retrieved documents to
selectively focus on key information and filter out irrelevant information in
them. CRAG is plug-and-play and can be seamlessly coupled with various
RAG-based approaches. Experiments on four datasets covering short- and
long-form generation tasks show that CRAG can significantly improve the
performance of RAG-based approaches. | [
-0.23281514644622803,
-0.8137139081954956,
0.4376221001148224,
-0.08618125319480896,
-0.2294643074274063,
0.42951110005378723,
-0.47122541069984436,
-0.5487759113311768,
0.13077867031097412,
0.46207037568092346,
-0.11353200674057007,
-0.37627139687538147,
-0.5160712003707886,
0.1452115923166275,
-0.5405279397964478,
0.8690543174743652,
0.16992999613285065,
-0.2024589478969574,
-0.43289583921432495,
-0.02469824068248272,
-0.6190251708030701,
-0.4615909457206726,
-0.5182366967201233,
-0.42563822865486145,
0.5032554864883423,
0.29216983914375305,
0.5884302258491516,
0.6048072576522827,
0.47149187326431274,
0.22974927723407745,
-0.17961685359477997,
0.6913169026374817,
-0.6928058862686157,
0.4768352806568146,
-0.4593782424926758,
-0.3781549334526062,
-0.46495768427848816,
-0.33264660835266113,
0.4586651921272278,
0.456842839717865,
-0.31214672327041626,
0.30097028613090515,
0.1364017277956009,
0.6212120652198792,
-0.894475519657135,
-0.21097736060619354,
-1.188005805015564,
-0.38916391134262085,
-0.3410818576812744,
-0.6167331337928772,
-0.6500694155693054,
-0.34049248695373535,
-0.10315540432929993,
-0.41718733310699463,
0.66464763879776,
0.2812839150428772,
0.9099891781806946,
0.11774518340826035,
-0.2580772340297699,
-0.5377411842346191,
-0.6336722373962402,
0.9526129961013794,
-0.6975961327552795,
0.5816277265548706,
0.5734644532203674,
0.19020219147205353,
-0.46506577730178833,
-0.8647425770759583,
-0.493791788816452,
-0.3765874207019806,
-0.08900493383407593,
-0.21176886558532715,
0.11604292690753937,
-0.05459108203649521,
0.2873647212982178,
0.4078579545021057,
-0.6818490028381348,
-0.08090338110923767,
-0.34284621477127075,
-0.3783935606479645,
0.7395793795585632,
0.03164313733577728,
0.28451642394065857,
-0.28242388367652893,
-0.15035784244537354,
-0.03544509783387184,
-0.7815083861351013,
-0.20314277708530426,
0.4915665090084076,
0.7039011716842651,
0.3180086612701416,
0.72923344373703,
-0.21904268860816956,
0.9409094452857971,
0.4113321304321289,
-0.6124405264854431,
0.35851722955703735,
-0.34440338611602783,
-0.0018015893874689937,
-0.0031061789486557245,
0.4266532361507416,
0.06456339359283447,
-0.0005453189951367676,
-0.13620682060718536,
-0.6296660900115967,
0.006950042210519314,
0.5883388519287109,
-0.7236177325248718,
-0.21504414081573486,
0.2182822823524475,
-0.21756602823734283,
-0.4858131408691406,
-0.25998860597610474,
-0.8489217758178711,
-0.4250888526439667,
-0.41925787925720215,
0.4139874279499054,
-0.5365484952926636,
-0.05143878981471062,
-0.13295814394950867,
-0.09128155559301376,
0.17717979848384857,
0.31689414381980896,
-0.7421923875808716,
-0.04152298718690872,
0.6447224617004395,
0.49991774559020996,
-0.13167451322078705,
-0.031528376042842865,
-0.8707563877105713,
0.3208017945289612,
-0.4545581638813019,
1.0393368005752563,
-0.6413597464561462,
-0.4660167694091797,
0.3588580787181854,
-0.2619434595108032,
0.12006165087223053,
-0.7298688292503357,
0.7208142876625061,
-0.8257378339767456,
0.3682563006877899,
-0.1061105951666832,
-0.37486517429351807,
0.09559702128171921,
0.4997669756412506,
-0.49416616559028625,
1.142110824584961,
0.28299373388290405,
-0.8237423896789551,
0.49654603004455566,
-0.1773204654455185,
-0.5840547680854797,
0.3798344135284424,
-0.27716004848480225,
-0.4320158362388611,
-0.002599096857011318,
0.2514490783214569,
0.2192983627319336,
-0.37550631165504456,
0.2941795885562897,
-0.11711385846138,
-0.22675111889839172,
-0.20466451346874237,
-0.27857911586761475,
0.3391057252883911,
0.2699931561946869,
-0.22246280312538147,
-0.2474161833524704,
-1.0762993097305298,
0.19379055500030518,
0.1373572051525116,
-0.7242359519004822,
-0.4083978235721588,
-0.03325788676738739,
-0.14792302250862122,
-0.09257258474826813,
0.5244652628898621,
-0.32324787974357605,
0.014415641315281391,
-0.4104050397872925,
-0.07127011567354202,
0.6241124868392944,
0.2564541697502136,
0.4911690056324005,
-0.386433482170105,
0.564832866191864,
-0.22599923610687256,
-0.1788681000471115,
0.042622510343790054,
-0.1510271579027176,
-0.7022490501403809,
-0.3721312880516052,
0.5447072386741638,
0.39841073751449585,
-1.198591709136963,
0.4104571044445038,
-0.293915331363678,
-0.4879419803619385,
-0.3413749933242798,
0.40466994047164917,
0.5783416032791138,
0.7086851596832275,
0.33221665024757385,
-0.08925620466470718,
-0.6447422504425049,
-0.6332300305366516,
-0.3617658317089081,
-0.3431116044521332,
-0.018963899463415146,
0.3332373797893524,
0.13240304589271545,
-0.3632110059261322,
0.7829006910324097,
-0.43442174792289734,
-0.0679745301604271,
-0.3187228739261627,
0.2290646731853485,
-0.16809770464897156,
0.2866863012313843,
0.4171614348888397,
-0.9787987470626831,
-0.2759334146976471,
0.09957326948642731,
-0.5819689631462097,
-0.3636433482170105,
-0.05684129521250725,
-0.14048205316066742,
0.5460113883018494,
0.3125751316547394,
-0.6750611662864685,
0.42360225319862366,
0.3599868714809418,
-0.14389437437057495,
0.668781578540802,
-0.16177910566329956,
0.3037644028663635,
-0.9671696424484253,
0.3003768026828766,
-0.2152855545282364,
-0.36615148186683655,
-0.5450199246406555,
0.1965029388666153,
0.021388741210103035,
-0.030081715434789658,
-0.25603073835372925,
0.5505765676498413,
-0.5076144933700562,
-0.0673302412033081,
-0.4017271399497986,
0.47585394978523254,
0.3267571032047272,
0.049137189984321594,
-0.25797319412231445,
1.0011872053146362,
0.13963358104228973,
-0.6802533864974976,
0.143541157245636,
0.25021684169769287,
-0.2346455454826355,
0.48441052436828613,
-0.3575983941555023,
0.13535703718662262,
-0.3911404311656952,
0.11995342373847961,
-0.8059874773025513,
-0.5864019393920898,
-0.12678299844264984,
-0.7283768057823181,
0.6410767436027527,
0.01138155534863472,
-0.4521998465061188,
-0.2388731837272644,
-0.2996181547641754,
0.3240443170070648,
0.46764907240867615,
-0.7935442924499512,
0.908738374710083,
0.43752479553222656,
-0.20699995756149292,
-0.8005313277244568,
-0.45091739296913147,
0.09880062937736511,
-0.08050420135259628,
-0.6100229024887085,
0.22555066645145416,
0.04939990118145943,
-0.35194069147109985,
-0.17828170955181122,
-0.07000625878572464,
0.01141759566962719,
-0.13261106610298157,
-0.017636870965361595,
0.3752846121788025,
0.1005849838256836,
0.26588428020477295,
0.026509741321206093,
0.2589578926563263,
-0.30034637451171875,
0.23134993016719818,
0.8010002374649048,
0.2037779688835144,
-0.1414935141801834,
0.12400112301111221,
0.21811112761497498,
0.4687153100967407,
-0.49206939339637756,
0.44349679350852966,
0.6840956807136536,
-0.35800063610076904,
-0.5531795024871826,
-0.9278454184532166,
0.014662820845842361,
-0.513866662979126,
0.2186698168516159,
-0.44945812225341797,
-0.8162915706634521,
0.325309157371521,
-0.06343233585357666,
0.11236201226711273,
0.43747881054878235,
0.6872788667678833,
0.09295495599508286,
0.9746890664100647,
0.5198236703872681,
0.24906237423419952,
0.4265548884868622,
-0.11374006420373917,
0.3313528895378113,
-0.9007089734077454,
-0.43394365906715393,
-0.6555148363113403,
0.10712111741304398,
-0.31017181277275085,
-0.2802315652370453,
0.13677003979682922,
0.43818894028663635,
-0.06849876046180725,
0.32206666469573975,
-0.7681459188461304,
0.23779387772083282,
0.4265091121196747,
0.12987825274467468,
0.30945438146591187,
0.2901904881000519,
-0.013425408862531185,
0.12711238861083984,
-0.7943647503852844,
-0.6553787589073181,
1.0512546300888062,
0.004529484082013369,
0.7376229166984558,
0.12027138471603394,
0.8801742792129517,
0.5420910716056824,
0.34289878606796265,
-0.6574704647064209,
0.6893287301063538,
0.016640696674585342,
-0.5391989350318909,
-0.049951862543821335,
-0.6833212971687317,
-1.0745500326156616,
0.13446423411369324,
-0.4360426664352417,
-0.5276130437850952,
0.3311534523963928,
0.29883092641830444,
-0.25076761841773987,
0.13125652074813843,
-0.6160663962364197,
0.2580763101577759,
-0.14427371323108673,
-0.4769197404384613,
-0.133955180644989,
-0.4372154176235199,
0.6044672727584839,
-0.42847883701324463,
0.26637202501296997,
0.17184756696224213,
0.03473754972219467,
0.43825703859329224,
-0.4223718047142029,
0.44719240069389343,
-0.05762079730629921,
-0.20861855149269104,
0.6595298647880554,
0.41346871852874756,
0.8089385032653809,
-0.12886269390583038,
-0.19343318045139313,
-0.266860693693161,
-0.11798867583274841,
-0.2667228579521179,
-0.6707666516304016,
0.8907778859138489,
-0.4610721170902252,
-0.7740927338600159,
-0.3523944318294525,
-0.6990499496459961,
-0.2724728584289551,
0.25754880905151367,
0.26949912309646606,
0.564590573310852,
0.07947494089603424,
0.15632374584674835,
0.5983649492263794,
-0.2156408578157425,
0.20091550052165985,
0.3309536576271057,
-0.27572518587112427,
-0.7223352789878845,
1.0472447872161865,
0.18480858206748962,
0.3583754003047943,
0.15476107597351074,
0.01860850490629673,
-0.33643749356269836,
-0.6665381193161011,
-0.3135058283805847,
0.3290344774723053,
-0.688197135925293,
-0.5748705863952637,
-0.5542827248573303,
-0.03135436028242111,
-0.7507202625274658,
-0.2441074699163437,
-0.0665445402264595,
-0.39143475890159607,
-0.4228878319263458,
-0.027913803234696388,
0.24309687316417694,
0.5647125840187073,
-0.15603817999362946,
-0.03154946118593216,
-0.8514153361320496,
0.5492604374885559,
0.21315336227416992,
0.14319460093975067,
-0.043095797300338745,
-0.7411683797836304,
-0.19945542514324188,
-0.04511520266532898,
-0.3570097088813782,
-0.5170409679412842,
0.518287181854248,
0.25540950894355774,
0.5666860938072205,
0.05666310712695122,
0.1690676063299179,
0.8555300831794739,
-0.5520303249359131,
0.9504730105400085,
-0.016237186267971992,
-0.6101507544517517,
0.5686599016189575,
-0.418232262134552,
0.03341522067785263,
0.6588136553764343,
0.1384798139333725,
0.08936234563589096,
-0.35982438921928406,
-0.6652575731277466,
-1.0235674381256104,
0.2822962999343872,
0.08061745762825012,
-0.04191948100924492,
-0.2773076891899109,
0.578130841255188,
-0.026572884991765022,
0.2353173792362213,
-0.3366280794143677,
0.21122294664382935,
0.05963168293237686,
-0.22237686812877655,
0.17928552627563477,
-0.4910704493522644,
-0.17395490407943726,
0.1338527798652649,
0.9569482207298279,
-0.053954318165779114,
-0.045139770954847336,
0.3787974417209625,
-0.05975016951560974,
-0.3563394844532013,
0.31060582399368286,
0.5339543223381042,
0.8964585065841675,
-0.28768596053123474,
0.1965206116437912,
0.1971207559108734,
-0.46129310131073,
0.08467990905046463,
-0.03349977731704712,
-0.32934293150901794,
0.24663102626800537,
0.3727773427963257,
0.3191942274570465,
-0.2526697516441345,
-0.9716350436210632,
0.47382932901382446,
0.1301288604736328,
-0.11043351143598557,
-0.2772088944911957,
0.02982988767325878,
-0.34416741132736206,
0.23992368578910828,
0.5376712679862976,
0.022715948522090912,
0.21155674755573273,
-0.5554947257041931,
0.46544724702835083,
0.5316247344017029,
0.027075545862317085,
-0.08889215439558029,
0.4784817099571228,
0.11967100203037262,
-0.5901381373405457,
0.3548990786075592,
-0.3859410881996155,
-0.552830159664154,
0.20104210078716278,
0.7399790287017822,
0.6723462343215942,
-0.19122876226902008,
0.020199770107865334,
0.48288583755493164,
0.2270553708076477,
-0.28751885890960693,
0.2661976218223572,
0.06518865376710892,
-0.5094330310821533,
-0.6337581872940063,
-0.845005452632904,
-0.22999686002731323,
0.05018002167344093,
-0.601187527179718,
0.29698848724365234,
-0.2827620506286621,
-0.3021586835384369,
-0.38890209794044495,
0.0913584753870964,
-0.45093482732772827,
0.4444659650325775,
-0.026105690747499466,
0.8424413800239563,
-0.3990914225578308,
0.6232699155807495,
0.5447050929069519,
-0.3822319507598877,
-0.8646056652069092,
0.05395827069878578,
-0.3077361285686493,
-0.6026621460914612,
0.7670028805732727,
-0.20163589715957642,
-0.2435327023267746,
-0.11486664414405823,
-0.6885349154472351,
-0.8477299213409424,
1.0870177745819092,
0.33093515038490295,
-0.5278650522232056,
-0.2410232126712799,
0.049292270094156265,
0.5632553100585938,
-0.21863435208797455,
-0.09636501222848892,
0.5167203545570374,
0.30170759558677673,
0.21757028996944427,
-0.8785555362701416,
0.0727466493844986,
-0.026588929817080498,
0.15367279946804047,
0.3430037200450897,
-0.5660885572433472,
0.6631830930709839,
-0.04093411937355995,
-0.38110148906707764,
0.23619873821735382,
0.592064380645752,
0.7409844994544983,
0.4162968695163727,
0.5100106000900269,
0.7468060255050659,
0.829983115196228,
0.11480313539505005,
1.2258659601211548,
-0.5143663287162781,
0.2194877415895462,
1.142844796180725,
-0.31032833456993103,
1.0310899019241333,
0.5708757042884827,
0.1813807338476181,
0.46291279792785645,
0.23843929171562195,
0.1849185824394226,
0.4987167418003082,
0.12222249060869217,
-0.503051221370697,
-0.35741305351257324,
-0.34554848074913025,
-0.2825092375278473,
0.29907456040382385,
0.382293701171875,
-0.48601457476615906,
-0.33845481276512146,
0.0007674318039789796,
-0.03205033019185066,
0.4703790843486786,
-0.37235018610954285,
0.7510109543800354,
-0.027590801939368248,
-0.7593937516212463,
0.9041998982429504,
-0.05510016158223152,
0.57575923204422,
-0.4090922176837921,
-0.33120599389076233,
-0.18404315412044525,
0.1209859549999237,
-0.4498855173587799,
-0.5754514932632446,
0.19720038771629333,
0.14588096737861633,
-0.2291574329137802,
0.09284114837646484,
1.3760733604431152,
-0.5976952314376831,
-0.45223626494407654,
0.08470048755407333,
0.44691452383995056,
0.029467051848769188,
0.14145991206169128,
-0.4725050628185272,
0.2899593114852905,
0.18078285455703735,
-0.34270477294921875,
0.3664247393608093,
0.5749949216842651,
-0.042001377791166306,
0.6972198486328125,
0.8393417000770569,
0.31752267479896545,
0.08817684650421143,
-0.03950387239456177,
1.0178273916244507,
-0.34577837586402893,
0.001692550373263657,
-0.48525622487068176,
0.483650803565979,
-0.12857352197170258,
-0.006699614226818085,
0.7878422737121582,
0.6552426815032959,
0.7818562984466553,
0.09904975444078445,
0.8110634088516235,
-0.21549174189567566,
0.934670627117157,
-0.3887008726596832,
0.6175112724304199,
-0.6347904205322266,
0.3946238160133362,
-0.08005640655755997,
-1.148066520690918,
-0.4285539984703064,
0.3523734211921692,
-0.23315660655498505,
0.029241997748613358,
0.3469823896884918,
1.1049129962921143,
0.10511698573827744,
-0.4819866418838501,
0.3983721137046814,
0.018194036558270454,
0.5144270062446594,
0.11356502771377563,
0.65043705701828,
-0.5017216801643372,
0.7610868215560913,
-0.028562702238559723,
-0.15371116995811462,
-0.15540841221809387,
-0.7142038345336914,
-0.8283494114875793,
-0.3539148271083832,
-0.09367910027503967,
-0.7563028335571289,
0.28790128231048584,
0.9806286096572876,
0.3664429187774658,
-0.5363859534263611,
0.09343075752258301,
-0.009618569165468216,
-0.025361742824316025,
0.38515031337738037,
-0.3246676027774811,
0.31430530548095703,
-0.9181497693061829,
-0.6376402974128723,
0.5826379656791687,
0.038028065115213394,
-0.1001197099685669,
-0.1957104504108429,
0.024117300286889076,
-0.3240787386894226,
0.2939705550670624,
0.7313268184661865,
0.3569403290748596,
-0.6009097695350647,
-0.6035617589950562,
-0.19187140464782715,
-0.21495293080806732,
-0.026575639843940735,
0.6416822075843811,
-0.9604030847549438,
0.5463644862174988,
0.7749537229537964,
0.8681759834289551,
0.27948102355003357,
0.5035990476608276,
0.5794796347618103,
-0.8903262615203857,
0.019537560641765594,
0.4536953270435333,
0.33166056871414185,
0.5694661736488342,
-0.5044681429862976,
0.5558555126190186,
0.1455751657485962,
-0.9864376783370972,
-1.243455171585083,
0.23860830068588257,
-0.8882591724395752,
-0.1724662035703659,
1.4140223264694214,
0.09779290854930878,
-0.3574787676334381,
-0.10004052519798279,
-0.3469795286655426,
0.22427211701869965,
-0.4300832152366638,
0.9661884903907776,
0.43231645226478577,
0.06492512673139572,
-0.05816222354769707,
-0.343967080116272,
0.6083143949508667,
0.3765791952610016,
-0.6426031589508057,
0.14943459630012512,
0.7814419269561768,
0.16961149871349335,
0.5362156629562378,
0.3616703450679779,
-0.28729259967803955,
0.14654439687728882,
0.001510745263658464,
0.29128679633140564,
0.014496561139822006,
-0.4125480651855469,
-0.03688022866845131,
0.4257736802101135,
0.38324323296546936,
0.12664823234081268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15861v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15861v3 | BPDec: Unveiling the Potential of Masked Language Modeling Decoder in BERT pretraining | 2024-01-29T03:25:11 | 2024-06-08T10:37:52 | Wen Liang, Youzhi Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | BERT (Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers) has
revolutionized the field of natural language processing through its exceptional
performance on numerous tasks. Yet, the majority of researchers have mainly
concentrated on enhancements related to the model structure, such as relative
position embedding and more efficient attention mechanisms. Others have delved
into pretraining tricks associated with Masked Language Modeling, including
whole word masking. DeBERTa introduced an enhanced decoder adapted for BERT's
encoder model for pretraining, proving to be highly effective. We argue that
the design and research around enhanced masked language modeling decoders have
been underappreciated. In this paper, we propose several designs of enhanced
decoders and introduce BPDec (BERT Pretraining Decoder), a novel method for
modeling training. Typically, a pretrained BERT model is fine-tuned for
specific Natural Language Understanding (NLU) tasks. In our approach, we
utilize the original BERT model as the encoder, making only changes to the
decoder without altering the encoder. This approach does not necessitate
extensive modifications to the encoder architecture and can be seamlessly
integrated into existing fine-tuning pipelines and services, offering an
efficient and effective enhancement strategy. Compared to other methods, while
we also incur a moderate training cost for the decoder during the pretraining
process, our approach does not introduce additional training costs during the
fine-tuning phase. We test multiple enhanced decoder structures after
pretraining and evaluate their performance on the GLUE tasks and SQuAD tasks.
Our results demonstrate that BPDec, having only undergone subtle refinements to
the model structure during pretraining, significantly enhances model
performance without escalating the finetuning cost, inference time and serving
budget. | [
-0.6448363661766052,
-0.6464685797691345,
0.2853817045688629,
0.2609311044216156,
-0.5238714814186096,
0.1352715641260147,
-0.18555553257465363,
-0.6081624031066895,
0.1631307750940323,
0.45642828941345215,
-0.7410393357276917,
-0.29311397671699524,
-0.701517641544342,
0.1160280704498291,
-0.18096867203712463,
0.9249930381774902,
0.011985983699560165,
0.044255830347537994,
-0.023893781006336212,
0.3910321593284607,
-0.407090425491333,
-0.8310465216636658,
-0.4609302580356598,
-0.32841354608535767,
0.27727481722831726,
-0.09778023511171341,
0.4040571451187134,
0.38949182629585266,
0.3465045988559723,
0.21076133847236633,
-0.23680371046066284,
0.3047865629196167,
-0.5033522844314575,
-0.019016502425074577,
0.029402265325188637,
-0.14873260259628296,
-0.620070219039917,
0.027067936956882477,
0.5850786566734314,
0.7860897183418274,
0.06184077635407448,
-0.27966049313545227,
0.342638224363327,
0.5733834505081177,
-0.8856314420700073,
0.3056390881538391,
-0.6641643047332764,
-0.10079190880060196,
-0.05542752146720886,
0.05821123719215393,
-0.5116536021232605,
-0.23481208086013794,
0.27242311835289,
-0.20991510152816772,
0.3994691073894501,
-0.36586084961891174,
0.9459247589111328,
0.2229679524898529,
-0.2787761390209198,
-0.11606096476316452,
-0.827911376953125,
0.5283222794532776,
-0.6779305934906006,
0.4389078915119171,
0.4323819875717163,
0.09529643505811691,
-0.0803297609090805,
-0.6475133895874023,
-0.4906339645385742,
-0.21804435551166534,
0.01897774077951908,
0.27079296112060547,
-0.1403350979089737,
0.4898168742656708,
0.16223521530628204,
0.3361356258392334,
-0.3729090690612793,
0.27085980772972107,
-0.19616137444972992,
-0.21376223862171173,
0.4108460545539856,
-0.2072589099407196,
0.004842453170567751,
0.04457133635878563,
-0.3957867920398712,
-0.13201475143432617,
-0.5687211155891418,
0.16548413038253784,
0.5386868715286255,
0.20060434937477112,
0.1464262157678604,
0.24012504518032074,
-0.19071677327156067,
0.7429664731025696,
0.06508554518222809,
0.43589916825294495,
0.0993465706706047,
-0.18583333492279053,
-0.17741964757442474,
0.3241254687309265,
0.21482479572296143,
-0.0417984239757061,
0.35867840051651,
-0.27796420454978943,
-0.40411096811294556,
0.23974518477916718,
0.5596832633018494,
-1.0037689208984375,
-0.5925905108451843,
0.02231099270284176,
-0.5696398615837097,
-0.2618037462234497,
0.25672459602355957,
-0.33549126982688904,
0.025452634319663048,
-0.43552806973457336,
0.4942033886909485,
-0.49535396695137024,
-0.41014134883880615,
0.4614860713481903,
0.006364527624100447,
0.4727758765220642,
0.31875333189964294,
-0.9929428696632385,
0.25153329968452454,
0.8736729621887207,
0.5900772213935852,
0.04101964458823204,
-0.08858464658260345,
-0.3065323829650879,
0.0344049334526062,
-0.34103402495384216,
0.8626620173454285,
-0.6612191796302795,
-0.1509181410074234,
0.1904517263174057,
0.10311718285083771,
-0.06062052398920059,
-0.3924969434738159,
0.6088016033172607,
-0.6629102230072021,
-0.14330825209617615,
-0.16031451523303986,
-0.618221640586853,
-0.15184469521045685,
-0.039430100470781326,
-0.701314389705658,
0.829539954662323,
-0.04028233885765076,
-0.7071980834007263,
0.3442489802837372,
-0.7198887467384338,
-0.6585506796836853,
0.1470017433166504,
0.22013676166534424,
-0.37125012278556824,
0.36595654487609863,
0.5451955795288086,
0.494370698928833,
0.08208224922418594,
0.23937854170799255,
-0.11504163593053818,
-0.4823009967803955,
0.2105691283941269,
-0.33229878544807434,
0.8425222039222717,
0.23001578450202942,
-0.3710900545120239,
0.12575402855873108,
-0.7024878263473511,
0.06184980645775795,
-0.13501976430416107,
-0.26715096831321716,
-0.36527395248413086,
-0.038508687168359756,
-0.10538069903850555,
0.16872148215770721,
0.2024303525686264,
-0.6300426721572876,
-0.14275357127189636,
-0.602911651134491,
0.287082314491272,
0.9628231525421143,
-0.23633244633674622,
0.49299150705337524,
-0.1570848673582077,
0.29733940958976746,
-0.14586526155471802,
0.0887831300497055,
-0.30504581332206726,
-0.3340626657009125,
-0.7041586637496948,
-0.7248208522796631,
0.7084454298019409,
0.3286360204219818,
-0.5760242938995361,
0.9066358208656311,
-0.0265700351446867,
-0.2512725293636322,
-0.8654407858848572,
-0.18018238246440887,
0.4007316529750824,
0.35641172528266907,
0.3070765733718872,
-0.6973721981048584,
-0.7598184943199158,
-0.9258584976196289,
-0.03200908005237579,
0.12795470654964447,
-0.32545727491378784,
0.044202253222465515,
0.3520718514919281,
-0.3661816716194153,
0.9986304044723511,
-0.3279941976070404,
-0.19702276587486267,
-0.5260254144668579,
0.15861880779266357,
0.1381416767835617,
0.7183588743209839,
0.6061745882034302,
-0.4228595495223999,
-0.3141428232192993,
-0.41614195704460144,
-0.3419611155986786,
-0.21533069014549255,
-0.06442476809024811,
-0.38023674488067627,
0.36294013261795044,
0.3197411298751831,
-0.48161107301712036,
0.6312099695205688,
0.5882471799850464,
-0.12446827441453934,
0.7362707257270813,
-0.5421463251113892,
-0.029684126377105713,
-0.5786487460136414,
0.04981062188744545,
-0.4300249218940735,
-0.20363007485866547,
-0.9039777517318726,
-0.012006125412881374,
0.2840142250061035,
-0.18831107020378113,
-0.22192710638046265,
0.1132756918668747,
-0.6001957654953003,
0.09116110950708389,
-0.5111265182495117,
-0.07523638010025024,
0.0663754940032959,
0.6372577548027039,
0.3854200541973114,
0.5754332542419434,
0.6838504672050476,
-0.6536409854888916,
0.20415078103542328,
0.25998279452323914,
-0.6685158610343933,
0.10899694263935089,
-0.8396428823471069,
0.5619689226150513,
-0.4694400727748871,
0.3289734721183777,
-0.8046587109565735,
0.1821729987859726,
0.0555470809340477,
-0.2674514949321747,
0.5347631573677063,
-0.10498932749032974,
-0.5533066391944885,
-0.31728002429008484,
-0.32298028469085693,
0.2078590840101242,
0.6518375873565674,
-0.7612730860710144,
0.3845464289188385,
0.33136770129203796,
0.017410023137927055,
-0.44315680861473083,
-0.5371415019035339,
-0.026270940899848938,
0.2220798134803772,
-0.771400511264801,
0.6824783086776733,
-0.22957976162433624,
0.1707238405942917,
-0.09325148165225983,
-0.4230393171310425,
-0.2580606937408447,
0.22569896280765533,
0.05500011518597603,
0.4344954788684845,
-0.24744051694869995,
0.017625246196985245,
0.11363201588392258,
-0.21125158667564392,
0.10653716325759888,
-0.46389439702033997,
0.7526815533638,
0.004721710458397865,
-0.17780756950378418,
-0.4578620195388794,
0.5129346251487732,
0.1495133638381958,
-0.6954846978187561,
1.1265422105789185,
0.7072808742523193,
-0.3859620690345764,
-0.17761868238449097,
-0.7205948829650879,
-0.47806525230407715,
-0.4829522669315338,
0.49000054597854614,
-0.5691370368003845,
-0.8324128985404968,
0.47370824217796326,
-0.1507955938577652,
-0.04598952829837799,
-0.02904972992837429,
0.46833544969558716,
-0.19076275825500488,
1.096482753753662,
0.9794034957885742,
0.05970655009150505,
0.7543415427207947,
-0.21260513365268707,
0.4211618900299072,
-0.8706951141357422,
-0.23489922285079956,
-0.5441707372665405,
-0.2779414653778076,
-0.37481889128685,
-0.3968759775161743,
-0.0375358983874321,
0.24071311950683594,
-0.23993632197380066,
0.4399000406265259,
-0.5595101714134216,
0.5686663389205933,
0.6322830319404602,
0.32843419909477234,
0.06006103754043579,
0.06648799031972885,
-0.11573589593172073,
-0.07011846452951431,
-0.5907678604125977,
-0.5784526467323303,
1.0121833086013794,
0.4477349519729614,
0.8379498720169067,
-0.14433051645755768,
0.7593566179275513,
0.09270646423101425,
-0.09414955973625183,
-0.6042011976242065,
0.45233842730522156,
-0.29806405305862427,
-0.6495348811149597,
-0.12590928375720978,
-0.21270759403705597,
-0.9072962999343872,
0.29863622784614563,
-0.14988504350185394,
-0.4938453733921051,
0.5554961562156677,
0.1325971931219101,
-0.27732932567596436,
0.2564953565597534,
-0.8830933570861816,
0.9423524737358093,
-0.2967187166213989,
-0.16452722251415253,
-0.23813088238239288,
-0.6422293186187744,
0.04519757628440857,
-0.10789504647254944,
-0.167805477976799,
-0.0036559104919433594,
0.23922625184059143,
0.6799067854881287,
-0.2990635633468628,
0.7885673642158508,
-0.3637821078300476,
-0.29295894503593445,
0.02784288115799427,
0.0009192519937641919,
0.6768877506256104,
-0.10587987303733826,
-0.015727611258625984,
0.2227066308259964,
-0.1064155325293541,
-0.6220870614051819,
-0.5537219643592834,
0.3380517363548279,
-0.7114661931991577,
-0.5872897505760193,
-0.16426226496696472,
-0.4307984709739685,
-0.18457664549350739,
0.15146513283252716,
0.16160859167575836,
0.5448521375656128,
-0.18701918423175812,
0.2779107689857483,
0.9529333710670471,
-0.14960961043834686,
0.3655370771884918,
0.5105448961257935,
0.273450642824173,
-0.03026307001709938,
0.6306449770927429,
-0.19995315372943878,
0.3314040005207062,
0.48059791326522827,
-0.19354842603206635,
-0.2726249694824219,
-0.8156115412712097,
0.11463229358196259,
0.22897745668888092,
-0.5029554963111877,
-0.10738874971866608,
-0.6987618803977966,
-0.5019038915634155,
-0.7068885564804077,
-0.1436523199081421,
-0.6055023074150085,
-0.2828434407711029,
-0.36614173650741577,
-0.11871060729026794,
-0.042655542492866516,
0.4771609604358673,
-0.24833723902702332,
0.3721562325954437,
-0.6593436598777771,
0.35092461109161377,
0.43416261672973633,
0.5754703879356384,
-0.02784053049981594,
-0.4794677197933197,
-0.3589320480823517,
0.23754605650901794,
-0.09989845752716064,
-0.7178599834442139,
0.4620850086212158,
0.24020805954933167,
0.7213333249092102,
0.5201254487037659,
0.41234272718429565,
0.6470332145690918,
-0.6205580234527588,
0.40153589844703674,
-0.0566219687461853,
-1.0294259786605835,
0.6977720260620117,
0.13465604186058044,
0.25856083631515503,
0.3599753677845001,
0.27969399094581604,
-0.08567687124013901,
-0.24802111089229584,
-0.41523849964141846,
-0.8078298568725586,
0.9608559608459473,
0.40857380628585815,
0.24132230877876282,
0.08394737541675568,
0.18218955397605896,
0.21688252687454224,
0.15680699050426483,
-0.5700528025627136,
-0.0966528058052063,
-0.5521128177642822,
-0.0774405375123024,
-0.1003168374300003,
-0.7174327373504639,
0.09952349215745926,
-0.41115331649780273,
0.5768892765045166,
0.1522279530763626,
0.6182257533073425,
0.25806841254234314,
-0.4243178963661194,
0.21955467760562897,
0.23576705157756805,
0.4824106693267822,
0.5053865313529968,
-0.6976178288459778,
0.2027408331632614,
-0.013545040972530842,
-0.5595004558563232,
-0.21791648864746094,
0.35795047879219055,
0.14362291991710663,
0.09776674211025238,
0.3795408606529236,
1.1996862888336182,
0.16428987681865692,
-0.5226763486862183,
0.3201165199279785,
-0.05419117957353592,
-0.18954074382781982,
-0.08747389167547226,
-0.06708455830812454,
-0.22876912355422974,
0.2023998349905014,
0.26431718468666077,
0.0892445370554924,
-0.04181566461920738,
-0.48701056838035583,
0.14485254883766174,
0.5337395668029785,
-0.3979661166667938,
-0.4904606342315674,
0.3995858430862427,
0.46246621012687683,
-0.12382823973894119,
0.6837441325187683,
-0.20243534445762634,
-0.8530771136283875,
0.4893953502178192,
0.8056349754333496,
1.0583627223968506,
-0.332350492477417,
0.13449332118034363,
0.16513115167617798,
0.6470922231674194,
0.11388039588928223,
-0.016521725803613663,
-0.48633503913879395,
-0.8614063858985901,
-0.5478977560997009,
-0.7049794793128967,
-0.18534907698631287,
0.10947860777378082,
-0.6422385573387146,
0.14495843648910522,
-0.24586006999015808,
-0.0017992835491895676,
-0.2523736357688904,
0.11842158436775208,
-0.7680292129516602,
-0.09064711630344391,
0.3683963716030121,
0.8840776681900024,
-0.6211321353912354,
1.220800757408142,
0.5882378220558167,
-0.18134234845638275,
-0.4729554355144501,
0.033008962869644165,
-0.49648913741111755,
-0.6499963998794556,
0.7678337693214417,
0.2672055959701538,
-0.2155235856771469,
0.18572837114334106,
-0.38268858194351196,
-0.5048141479492188,
0.6174532771110535,
0.5536424517631531,
-0.4487418830394745,
-0.26537442207336426,
0.1707080751657486,
0.47557494044303894,
-0.5534988641738892,
0.2828315794467926,
0.7857036590576172,
0.27257904410362244,
0.07399917393922806,
-0.8936678767204285,
0.003158648032695055,
-0.18311728537082672,
0.35725167393684387,
-0.13566716015338898,
-0.11692818254232407,
0.8655447363853455,
-0.08645492047071457,
-0.42504599690437317,
-0.012962906621396542,
0.5255916118621826,
-0.045657895505428314,
-0.2571548819541931,
0.3941085636615753,
0.32549065351486206,
0.5367001295089722,
-0.08878985047340393,
0.9496262669563293,
-0.1359340399503708,
0.21131837368011475,
0.9254228472709656,
-0.20000901818275452,
0.5595411062240601,
0.15531982481479645,
-0.1260739117860794,
0.4909473657608032,
0.5582451820373535,
0.15442083775997162,
1.0058406591415405,
0.16762524843215942,
-0.2964950501918793,
-0.5398491024971008,
-0.07616882026195526,
-0.47262442111968994,
0.42874500155448914,
0.16571639478206635,
-0.21443066000938416,
-0.24641336500644684,
0.25212186574935913,
-0.20053596794605255,
0.002241414738819003,
-0.19404542446136475,
0.8370361924171448,
-0.0844479501247406,
-0.2951999008655548,
0.8634374737739563,
-0.03218908980488777,
0.9505821466445923,
-0.8333513736724854,
0.026476699858903885,
-0.3642546236515045,
0.39756810665130615,
0.050016168504953384,
-0.433321088552475,
0.30761244893074036,
-0.059753384441137314,
-0.12917357683181763,
-0.6046473979949951,
0.933689296245575,
-0.48417094349861145,
-0.2105238437652588,
0.34445568919181824,
0.168304443359375,
0.10314532369375229,
-0.5173876881599426,
-0.43421345949172974,
0.21430130302906036,
-0.013614561408758163,
0.1297941505908966,
0.35125747323036194,
0.4302796423435211,
0.4174352288246155,
0.38237935304641724,
0.6902551054954529,
0.10210426896810532,
0.17889387905597687,
0.27123749256134033,
0.9614501595497131,
-0.4921700358390808,
-0.6276658177375793,
-0.6237783432006836,
0.5166268348693848,
-0.09105540812015533,
0.21325558423995972,
0.5546988844871521,
0.39022135734558105,
0.980648398399353,
-0.4327222406864166,
0.4962936341762543,
0.1001659631729126,
0.38337016105651855,
-0.5168580412864685,
0.8985196352005005,
-0.1344861090183258,
0.28326430916786194,
-0.43158242106437683,
-1.0302754640579224,
-0.1319701224565506,
0.9418593645095825,
-0.12716738879680634,
-0.005671733524650335,
0.6693449020385742,
0.8033837676048279,
0.06887213885784149,
0.12193886190652847,
0.2888796627521515,
0.06261178851127625,
0.45932748913764954,
0.5901870727539062,
0.9116761684417725,
-0.3000955879688263,
0.5240647792816162,
-0.47797131538391113,
-0.4512277841567993,
-0.18639744818210602,
-0.7621942162513733,
-1.2319835424423218,
-0.6189744472503662,
-0.30678215622901917,
-0.015106657519936562,
0.3250281810760498,
0.8227612972259521,
0.8950439095497131,
-0.959538459777832,
-0.08379603922367096,
-0.12319573014974594,
0.018047872930765152,
-0.37697067856788635,
-0.178230881690979,
0.4152158498764038,
-0.6483664512634277,
-0.935723602771759,
0.39106592535972595,
0.06165760010480881,
0.13491620123386383,
-0.03320906311273575,
0.029356228187680244,
-0.2645411789417267,
0.04735361039638519,
0.8353635668754578,
0.06632816791534424,
-0.5311641097068787,
-0.31098639965057373,
-0.054694872349500656,
0.07138098776340485,
-0.014497604221105576,
1.0221649408340454,
-1.1137278079986572,
0.6539871096611023,
0.40618038177490234,
0.8411136865615845,
0.7184487581253052,
-0.02691842056810856,
0.6875012516975403,
-0.7508994936943054,
0.39598894119262695,
0.4219870865345001,
0.179243803024292,
0.08027860522270203,
-0.12564262747764587,
0.18914267420768738,
-0.03953666612505913,
-0.3058760166168213,
-0.9713228344917297,
0.2064443826675415,
-0.7770357131958008,
-0.4490198493003845,
0.6446382403373718,
-0.26302486658096313,
-0.11233533173799515,
-0.2989746034145355,
-0.3391669690608978,
0.41628894209861755,
-0.3582553565502167,
0.9054440259933472,
0.5705195069313049,
0.000015784784409333952,
-0.16898858547210693,
-0.31358957290649414,
0.5271790027618408,
0.549690306186676,
-0.6226702928543091,
0.2102455496788025,
0.2958999276161194,
-0.03175501525402069,
-0.08944561332464218,
0.3370140790939331,
-0.09690536558628082,
0.08102197200059891,
-0.10667955875396729,
0.14046648144721985,
-0.31653645634651184,
-0.4753548204898834,
-0.4296640157699585,
-0.077195905148983,
-0.11602334678173065,
-0.5597221851348877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15854v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15854v2 | LSTM-based Deep Neural Network With A Focus on Sentence Representation for Sequential Sentence Classification in Medical Scientific Abstracts | 2024-01-29T03:05:35 | 2024-05-31T08:37:04 | Phat Lam, Lam Pham, Tin Nguyen, Hieu Tang, Michael Seidl, Medina Andresel, Alexander Schindler | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Sequential Sentence Classification task within the domain of medical
abstracts, termed as SSC, involves the categorization of sentences into
pre-defined headings based on their roles in conveying critical information in
the abstract. In the SSC task, sentences are sequentially related to each
other. For this reason, the role of sentence embeddings is crucial for
capturing both the semantic information between words in the sentence and the
contextual relationship of sentences within the abstract, which then enhances
the SSC system performance. In this paper, we propose a LSTM-based deep
learning network with a focus on creating comprehensive sentence representation
at the sentence level. To demonstrate the efficacy of the created sentence
representation, a system utilizing these sentence embeddings is also developed,
which consists of a Convolutional-Recurrent neural network (C-RNN) at the
abstract level and a multi-layer perception network (MLP) at the segment level.
Our proposed system yields highly competitive results compared to
state-of-the-art systems and further enhances the F1 scores of the baseline by
1.0%, 2.8%, and 2.6% on the benchmark datasets PudMed 200K RCT, PudMed 20K RCT
and NICTA-PIBOSO, respectively. This indicates the significant impact of
improving sentence representation on boosting model performance. | [
-0.0741441398859024,
-0.6074916124343872,
0.8106311559677124,
0.31432387232780457,
-0.6934237480163574,
0.1909252554178238,
-0.38824212551116943,
-0.48051777482032776,
0.36069437861442566,
0.24610088765621185,
-0.31690236926078796,
-0.668207585811615,
-0.6566368341445923,
0.4218918979167938,
-0.4368349015712738,
0.9879008531570435,
-0.007675612345337868,
0.46339091658592224,
-0.4350228011608124,
-0.05435095727443695,
-0.5247750282287598,
-0.557655394077301,
-0.601893424987793,
-0.470222532749176,
0.8005027174949646,
0.10063695907592773,
0.3532617688179016,
0.4626707136631012,
0.615061342716217,
0.30190545320510864,
-0.2618110775947571,
0.2570800185203552,
-0.0943688303232193,
0.4200667440891266,
0.026941902935504913,
-0.2644670605659485,
-0.2048787921667099,
-0.4495609998703003,
0.8025850057601929,
0.8474512696266174,
-0.07156100124120712,
-0.27751028537750244,
0.1598050594329834,
0.6267980933189392,
-0.2729523181915283,
0.24354568123817444,
-0.24185721576213837,
0.5304827094078064,
-0.10167275369167328,
-0.291919469833374,
-0.49466848373413086,
-0.3399917185306549,
0.5130441188812256,
-0.2877019941806793,
-0.21093939244747162,
-0.04121104255318642,
0.5377806425094604,
0.17796194553375244,
-0.5914378762245178,
-0.1371840387582779,
-0.3953590989112854,
0.45310255885124207,
-0.9415202736854553,
0.21724499762058258,
-0.35741740465164185,
0.0444345623254776,
-0.1581616997718811,
-0.8893545866012573,
-0.13070262968540192,
-0.5409512519836426,
-0.193067729473114,
0.2728022038936615,
0.262127548456192,
0.29288724064826965,
0.026565244421362877,
0.36835360527038574,
-0.7576306462287903,
0.3933195471763611,
-0.39094600081443787,
-0.025882115587592125,
0.481862872838974,
0.5047461986541748,
0.18932682275772095,
-0.0028651913162320852,
-0.6710374355316162,
0.3364827334880829,
-0.5031541585922241,
-0.2127682864665985,
-0.35716283321380615,
0.29415827989578247,
0.047966983169317245,
0.5718255043029785,
-0.2020253688097,
0.556687593460083,
-0.0140665452927351,
0.24580597877502441,
0.6064543724060059,
-0.47646066546440125,
-0.2771971523761749,
0.5731857419013977,
0.9762166738510132,
0.2872638702392578,
0.30791381001472473,
0.07668297737836838,
-0.02664937637746334,
0.015779348090291023,
0.39967551827430725,
-0.9582111239433289,
0.019126811996102333,
0.3053961396217346,
-0.7498713731765747,
-0.5144174098968506,
0.05362043157219887,
-0.3664252460002899,
-0.44346216320991516,
-0.3272131383419037,
0.021565096452832222,
-0.41442665457725525,
0.1573602706193924,
0.2772964537143707,
0.1872105896472931,
-0.06414077430963516,
0.28282761573791504,
-0.49482274055480957,
0.41643744707107544,
0.38004258275032043,
1.2823851108551025,
-0.4977476894855499,
-0.17138318717479706,
-0.20753493905067444,
-0.09347166121006012,
-0.3191980719566345,
0.6447731852531433,
-0.24735213816165924,
-0.2749609053134918,
0.0522395595908165,
0.06345407664775848,
-0.1861293613910675,
-0.33311018347740173,
0.5134820938110352,
-0.4596322476863861,
0.156051367521286,
0.40294820070266724,
-0.9981891512870789,
-0.0957823321223259,
0.19119799137115479,
-0.4931485950946808,
0.5360816121101379,
-0.3410094082355499,
-0.5471446514129639,
-0.052722807973623276,
-0.4384964406490326,
-0.6515167951583862,
0.18168216943740845,
-0.40186014771461487,
-0.5432894229888916,
0.31093984842300415,
0.22472649812698364,
0.8868452310562134,
0.0871579721570015,
0.5543105602264404,
-0.20364844799041748,
-0.34187281131744385,
0.4204321503639221,
-0.2090441733598709,
0.2622399628162384,
0.23717467486858368,
-0.06832347065210342,
0.3789788484573364,
-0.5446553826332092,
0.1224726140499115,
-0.04193875193595886,
-0.43232476711273193,
-0.34287649393081665,
-0.2588244676589966,
-0.0032874506432563066,
0.33707699179649353,
0.2740703821182251,
-0.5968115925788879,
0.18160025775432587,
-0.7894725799560547,
0.4067351818084717,
0.620131254196167,
0.34418725967407227,
0.36770099401474,
-0.13681069016456604,
0.1668425351381302,
0.3992822766304016,
-0.14586734771728516,
-0.47774815559387207,
-0.5091674327850342,
-0.5351792573928833,
0.003545961109921336,
0.332590788602829,
0.6073591709136963,
-0.394925981760025,
0.6085306406021118,
-0.32534047961235046,
-0.11856023967266083,
-0.33584874868392944,
-0.2848454415798187,
0.30610617995262146,
0.5047317743301392,
0.4544660151004791,
-0.4087637662887573,
-0.735534131526947,
-1.130171298980713,
-0.21270880103111267,
0.3359344005584717,
0.15795233845710754,
0.13552722334861755,
0.6673911809921265,
-0.10752090066671371,
0.5143047571182251,
-0.5355739593505859,
-0.491542249917984,
-0.3712491989135742,
0.07671213895082474,
0.37513142824172974,
0.6575935482978821,
0.01423925906419754,
-0.6317344903945923,
-0.37150728702545166,
0.06230275705456734,
-0.8929529786109924,
-0.011401426047086716,
-0.3832659125328064,
0.18383432924747467,
0.08119651675224304,
0.7695571184158325,
-0.6423653364181519,
0.5186288356781006,
0.13228239119052887,
-0.3709510862827301,
0.37802398204803467,
-0.4098871648311615,
0.01916239969432354,
-1.1337072849273682,
0.005245971493422985,
0.1960267573595047,
-0.4912927448749542,
-0.6026602387428284,
-0.17660146951675415,
-0.03160345181822777,
-0.11331093311309814,
-0.5113170146942139,
0.21778763830661774,
-0.30989551544189453,
0.0663231760263443,
-0.47717994451522827,
0.02061178721487522,
0.022546079009771347,
0.581519365310669,
0.2913375496864319,
0.2745208144187927,
0.224748432636261,
-0.5595747232437134,
0.14909367263317108,
0.2635371685028076,
-0.5692891478538513,
0.10460904985666275,
-0.8769608736038208,
-0.11265353858470917,
-0.1946370005607605,
0.5536016225814819,
-0.6303811073303223,
0.08800283819437027,
0.18024681508541107,
-0.36430826783180237,
0.38317161798477173,
0.22738368809223175,
-0.4237062931060791,
-0.2447475790977478,
-0.057650234550237656,
0.49825310707092285,
0.24947670102119446,
-0.0973786935210228,
0.2473158985376358,
0.07003629207611084,
-0.29766902327537537,
-0.47632426023483276,
-1.0244020223617554,
0.20278407633304596,
0.180984228849411,
-0.41828376054763794,
0.710228681564331,
0.22667516767978668,
0.10986745357513428,
0.07852265238761902,
-0.1325533092021942,
0.24878427386283875,
-0.03825252130627632,
0.333557665348053,
0.18922092020511627,
-0.3607371151447296,
0.4069865047931671,
0.281421035528183,
-0.11078440397977829,
0.09522521495819092,
-0.3949943780899048,
0.5789180397987366,
-0.21869398653507233,
-0.04099692776799202,
-0.7638492584228516,
0.5784432888031006,
0.444950670003891,
-0.1353800892829895,
0.6761521697044373,
0.34081584215164185,
-0.5259639024734497,
-0.20182320475578308,
0.047700949013233185,
-0.239650160074234,
-0.37766921520233154,
0.7214919328689575,
-0.029292777180671692,
-1.0508800745010376,
0.2953239679336548,
-0.3334610164165497,
-0.26188626885414124,
0.48666495084762573,
0.643631637096405,
-0.32657524943351746,
0.888940155506134,
0.14190338551998138,
0.07193797826766968,
0.42131245136260986,
-0.21939148008823395,
-0.03059622272849083,
-0.8525072932243347,
-0.4631807506084442,
-0.2703862488269806,
-0.5030133724212646,
-0.2718428373336792,
-0.48747631907463074,
0.2779909670352936,
-0.10286097228527069,
-0.6210331320762634,
-0.08405830711126328,
-0.727604329586029,
0.2513490617275238,
0.3099685311317444,
0.45644840598106384,
0.20556409657001495,
-0.039087340235710144,
-0.5474873781204224,
-0.005267676897346973,
-0.5879766345024109,
-0.4648805558681488,
1.006387710571289,
0.5847669243812561,
0.4925837814807892,
-0.25132158398628235,
0.8366374373435974,
0.486625075340271,
0.11109580099582672,
-0.7625383734703064,
0.7016749978065491,
-0.45128586888313293,
-0.105216845870018,
0.025454167276620865,
-0.3870960772037506,
-0.7973911166191101,
0.38190972805023193,
-0.29640519618988037,
-0.46130794286727905,
0.2776053249835968,
-0.3868943750858307,
-0.7448188066482544,
0.16199244558811188,
-0.3758864402770996,
0.7171469330787659,
-0.5584882497787476,
-0.18086132407188416,
-0.3506465554237366,
-0.855985164642334,
0.23439298570156097,
0.3322552442550659,
-0.15738095343112946,
0.02919461578130722,
-0.21482551097869873,
0.7314729690551758,
-0.5855626463890076,
0.8379208445549011,
-0.2192898839712143,
0.21552711725234985,
-0.024372125044465065,
-0.18356916308403015,
0.4050503671169281,
0.251119464635849,
0.11663950979709625,
0.14696326851844788,
-0.1899060606956482,
-0.18533602356910706,
-0.5957292318344116,
0.8965277075767517,
-0.4891735315322876,
-0.3886001706123352,
-0.9349796175956726,
-0.24082252383232117,
-0.1659456491470337,
0.34258997440338135,
0.07075560092926025,
0.3801681399345398,
-0.23895838856697083,
0.39892321825027466,
0.6835131049156189,
-0.36453676223754883,
0.37809354066848755,
0.029154593124985695,
-0.21737511456012726,
-0.7211942672729492,
0.44164350628852844,
-0.042699750512838364,
0.0654505267739296,
0.5626978278160095,
0.13917924463748932,
-0.26534467935562134,
-1.014007329940796,
-0.37510594725608826,
-0.06392557919025421,
-0.48948290944099426,
-0.3703547716140747,
-0.6538147330284119,
-0.5150120258331299,
-0.08071904629468918,
0.02418021857738495,
-0.039043620228767395,
-0.475412517786026,
-0.3629284203052521,
-0.33998623490333557,
0.2717915177345276,
0.6687152981758118,
0.22162047028541565,
0.27570292353630066,
-0.7853493690490723,
0.2648424804210663,
-0.372381329536438,
0.44242292642593384,
0.22853179275989532,
-0.47183728218078613,
-0.5549272298812866,
-0.01736808754503727,
-0.22757986187934875,
-0.6095742583274841,
0.4823004901409149,
0.3564085364341736,
0.3917360007762909,
0.24579007923603058,
-0.30001798272132874,
0.5687630772590637,
-0.7368327379226685,
0.6835260987281799,
0.4583505094051361,
-0.4955446422100067,
0.7271842956542969,
-0.019904637709259987,
0.5225808620452881,
0.5947270393371582,
0.2715674638748169,
-0.4982868432998657,
-0.42837244272232056,
-0.2403184026479721,
-1.082664132118225,
0.570924699306488,
0.23682674765586853,
0.010995821096003056,
-0.1647995561361313,
0.5216354131698608,
0.10727039724588394,
0.2292487621307373,
-0.6248844265937805,
-0.34659239649772644,
-0.21478049457073212,
-0.6339847445487976,
0.015968604013323784,
-0.16608025133609772,
0.14202913641929626,
-0.25298818945884705,
0.47024935483932495,
-0.11502037942409515,
0.48746657371520996,
0.7776022553443909,
-0.1816459596157074,
0.2844909727573395,
0.32741019129753113,
0.9438756108283997,
0.12970471382141113,
-0.2871910333633423,
0.1050240769982338,
0.11503344029188156,
-0.6388203501701355,
0.1563194990158081,
0.31420421600341797,
-0.16657643020153046,
0.16133037209510803,
0.49415701627731323,
0.9205400943756104,
0.4152239263057709,
-0.5256742238998413,
0.41826674342155457,
-0.023782305419445038,
-0.11760207265615463,
-0.4324168562889099,
-0.20512805879116058,
0.15809737145900726,
0.2622963488101959,
0.47862449288368225,
0.4941342771053314,
0.3089393973350525,
-0.26386234164237976,
0.4867962598800659,
0.14174394309520721,
-0.34079599380493164,
0.06495247781276703,
0.3220292031764984,
0.17133796215057373,
-0.03321867808699608,
0.6168640851974487,
0.35235193371772766,
-0.4195908010005951,
0.7505375146865845,
0.520283579826355,
0.8289594054222107,
-0.10429943352937698,
0.15155665576457977,
0.4852781593799591,
0.022773759439587593,
-0.2042699009180069,
0.29225683212280273,
0.23659716546535492,
-0.46155843138694763,
-0.45052599906921387,
-0.5568701028823853,
-0.010954082012176514,
0.0435604453086853,
-0.38675713539123535,
0.04240543767809868,
-0.693625807762146,
-0.16289712488651276,
0.009690183214843273,
-0.00198210752569139,
-0.44672802090644836,
0.3521195650100708,
0.5355867743492126,
0.9958176016807556,
-0.44067883491516113,
0.9104525446891785,
0.5718967914581299,
-0.5028781294822693,
-0.4071989059448242,
-0.20588122308254242,
-0.26558759808540344,
-0.36017170548439026,
0.7234865427017212,
0.44093751907348633,
-0.028809787705540657,
-0.2652403712272644,
-0.2596585750579834,
-0.672531008720398,
1.2077325582504272,
-0.024454087018966675,
-1.0767266750335693,
-0.16230276226997375,
0.34031298756599426,
0.9165122509002686,
-1.0076173543930054,
0.13851934671401978,
0.062307827174663544,
0.26395443081855774,
-0.12199388444423676,
-0.7595863938331604,
0.4158335030078888,
-0.28111886978149414,
0.24754548072814941,
-0.033368486911058426,
-0.34049129486083984,
0.6284274458885193,
-0.2599695026874542,
-0.1805759072303772,
0.3698168396949768,
0.7392640709877014,
0.3628288209438324,
0.5511504411697388,
0.22730723023414612,
0.6348528861999512,
0.765522837638855,
-0.1559401899576187,
0.9463358521461487,
-0.07131563127040863,
0.15418045222759247,
1.3671873807907104,
-0.35621556639671326,
0.8382968902587891,
0.5387048125267029,
0.12031038105487823,
0.8942041397094727,
0.6986351013183594,
-0.05733379349112511,
0.7369547486305237,
0.6358922123908997,
-0.3569337725639343,
-0.18227708339691162,
-0.04274722933769226,
-0.6074436902999878,
0.12423163652420044,
0.5362722277641296,
-1.1005483865737915,
-0.07408507913351059,
0.3614318370819092,
-0.32062724232673645,
0.21153424680233002,
-0.6641505360603333,
0.9663851857185364,
0.6804674863815308,
-0.3665216267108917,
0.41968461871147156,
-0.07943165302276611,
0.7056465148925781,
-0.6117687821388245,
0.029289552941918373,
-0.15035371482372284,
0.4430758059024811,
-0.4740811288356781,
-0.950727105140686,
0.3202155530452728,
-0.39470887184143066,
-0.22751688957214355,
-0.13568095862865448,
0.8486605882644653,
-0.6190654039382935,
-0.5897942185401917,
0.24867966771125793,
0.3929370045661926,
-0.008349553681910038,
0.12062487751245499,
-0.7178542613983154,
0.15584808588027954,
-0.36638981103897095,
-0.34744301438331604,
0.3451557755470276,
0.3049226999282837,
-0.11621078848838806,
0.6405580639839172,
0.49111875891685486,
0.2606556713581085,
-0.1448114663362503,
0.41622403264045715,
0.7420889735221863,
-0.9310320615768433,
-0.6471371650695801,
-0.9612306952476501,
0.549060046672821,
-0.2943425476551056,
-0.13476429879665375,
0.3921113610267639,
0.732759952545166,
0.42493778467178345,
-0.3353811502456665,
0.7017226815223694,
0.25251585245132446,
0.3391532301902771,
-0.6035497784614563,
0.7824292778968811,
-0.3570396304130554,
0.21259696781635284,
0.018986979499459267,
-0.4002460241317749,
-0.7843380570411682,
0.5020082592964172,
-0.08723630011081696,
-0.01065456960350275,
0.9902281761169434,
0.3475003242492676,
0.10187288373708725,
0.23524492979049683,
0.09986819326877594,
0.4057336449623108,
0.018963655456900597,
0.8089746236801147,
0.8215169310569763,
-0.4074002802371979,
0.3703868091106415,
-0.1331154704093933,
0.10576741397380829,
-0.24256961047649384,
-0.739859402179718,
-0.759925901889801,
-0.4613722264766693,
-0.44712695479393005,
-0.509660005569458,
0.24830539524555206,
1.1251914501190186,
0.5309703946113586,
-0.9536735415458679,
-0.03017600253224373,
-0.42428284883499146,
0.059033289551734924,
-0.37394002079963684,
-0.18650956451892853,
0.7106153964996338,
-0.5412464737892151,
-0.18085360527038574,
0.4778176546096802,
0.4329736530780792,
-0.06752411276102066,
-0.2375161498785019,
-0.1154947355389595,
-0.5015181303024292,
-0.23034369945526123,
0.8290420174598694,
0.007439373526722193,
-0.6103938221931458,
-0.046540647745132446,
0.00406925892457366,
-0.3509194254875183,
0.12289268523454666,
1.1649341583251953,
-1.1284459829330444,
0.1381944715976715,
0.4478793144226074,
0.7613989114761353,
0.4297080636024475,
-0.27925312519073486,
0.7342321872711182,
-0.7285516262054443,
-0.14672669768333435,
0.7678753733634949,
0.5225924849510193,
0.1337951272726059,
-0.48134294152259827,
0.27443769574165344,
0.08949282765388489,
-0.6268829107284546,
-0.6816821098327637,
0.032448284327983856,
-1.238793969154358,
-0.5823171138763428,
0.9009455442428589,
-0.18748527765274048,
-0.13566552102565765,
-0.21687905490398407,
-0.30275025963783264,
0.24516069889068604,
-0.6197089552879333,
0.4732320010662079,
0.3915306031703949,
-0.2868548333644867,
-0.3689633309841156,
-0.3713800609111786,
0.4845294654369354,
0.41728052496910095,
-0.672870934009552,
-0.312468022108078,
0.3366970717906952,
0.07586975395679474,
0.18803437054157257,
0.4316091239452362,
-0.4336164891719818,
0.38754746317863464,
-0.6155219078063965,
-0.12857957184314728,
-0.33164843916893005,
-0.1710849404335022,
-0.7250102758407593,
0.42755308747291565,
-0.30711793899536133,
-0.3058183789253235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15847v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15847v3 | Muffin or Chihuahua? Challenging Multimodal Large Language Models with Multipanel VQA | 2024-01-29T02:43:40 | 2024-06-27T15:38:17 | Yue Fan, Jing Gu, Kaiwen Zhou, Qianqi Yan, Shan Jiang, Ching-Chen Kuo, Xinze Guan, Xin Eric Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Multipanel images, commonly seen as web screenshots, posters, etc., pervade
our daily lives. These images, characterized by their composition of multiple
subfigures in distinct layouts, effectively convey information to people.
Toward building advanced multimodal AI applications, such as agents that
understand complex scenes and navigate through webpages, the skill of
multipanel visual reasoning is essential, and a comprehensive evaluation of
models in this regard is important. Therefore, we introduce Multipanel Visual
Question Answering (MultipanelVQA), a novel benchmark comprising 6,600 triplets
of questions, answers, and multipanel images that specifically challenge models
in comprehending multipanel images. Our evaluation shows that questions in the
MultipanelVQA benchmark pose significant challenges to the state-of-the-art
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) tested, even though humans can attain
approximately 99% accuracy on these questions. Distinctively, the MultipanelVQA
benchmark features synthetically generated multipanel images specifically
crafted to isolate and assess the impact of various factors, such as the
layout, on MLLMs' multipanel image comprehension abilities. As a result, in
addition to benchmarking the capabilities of MLLMs in understanding multipanel
images, we analyze various factors of the multipanel image that affect MLLMs'
performance with synthetic data and offer insights for enhancement. Code and
data are released at https://sites.google.com/view/multipanelvqa/home. | [
-0.7450955510139465,
-0.9684247970581055,
0.5048587918281555,
0.517769455909729,
0.16319933533668518,
0.2594009041786194,
-0.2624087631702423,
-0.4893064498901367,
-0.3814001977443695,
0.4455970525741577,
-0.6483705043792725,
-0.28170719742774963,
-0.4121581017971039,
0.17122158408164978,
-0.16937023401260376,
0.4985848367214203,
-0.08631211519241333,
0.1212863102555275,
-0.44718310236930847,
-0.23368772864341736,
-0.30351880192756653,
-0.19169218838214874,
-0.4724619686603546,
0.0750465989112854,
0.6590476632118225,
0.36391881108283997,
0.8411574363708496,
0.3535279631614685,
0.2742186188697815,
0.4511649012565613,
0.2086647003889084,
0.3014844059944153,
-0.1428336352109909,
0.1580534279346466,
0.15807025134563446,
-0.3989623785018921,
-0.04588952288031578,
-0.24667756259441376,
0.49760696291923523,
0.7353708744049072,
0.05824662372469902,
0.16645392775535583,
-0.23786413669586182,
0.3759336471557617,
-1.0218390226364136,
0.25764280557632446,
-0.5017181038856506,
-0.006677171681076288,
-0.11872448772192001,
-0.03910963609814644,
-0.40405815839767456,
-0.18244308233261108,
0.018750108778476715,
-0.7249751091003418,
0.24696099758148193,
0.1046004518866539,
0.7455249428749084,
0.17331503331661224,
-0.7683749794960022,
-0.17310184240341187,
-0.44590529799461365,
0.760299801826477,
-0.21770618855953217,
0.44919440150260925,
0.4549162685871124,
0.7582204341888428,
-0.2416674941778183,
-0.7176592350006104,
-0.9577490091323853,
-0.30617383122444153,
0.14961519837379456,
0.20504425466060638,
-0.2127971053123474,
-0.3838207423686981,
0.371168851852417,
0.2242535501718521,
-0.9113026857376099,
-0.13866791129112244,
-0.2278228998184204,
-0.2740895450115204,
0.25098752975463867,
0.2423408329486847,
0.4969068467617035,
-0.17999403178691864,
-0.4479537010192871,
-0.49164897203445435,
-0.2778504192829132,
0.4261555075645447,
0.18046748638153076,
-0.06971319019794464,
0.03508973866701126,
0.7492714524269104,
-0.18795382976531982,
0.607994556427002,
-0.20975205302238464,
-0.15972517430782318,
0.41263335943222046,
-0.47187554836273193,
-0.10579079389572144,
-0.39426299929618835,
0.7288700342178345,
0.5644363760948181,
0.3824806213378906,
0.11786859482526779,
0.04281788319349289,
0.09992744773626328,
0.0662619099020958,
-0.6653451919555664,
-0.3288871645927429,
0.23595067858695984,
-0.3842332363128662,
0.07120290398597717,
-0.11726852506399155,
-0.9016238451004028,
-0.6246724724769592,
-0.09958391636610031,
0.38688546419143677,
-0.5221360325813293,
-0.3714182674884796,
0.21550527215003967,
-0.3493608236312866,
0.5311310291290283,
0.5983980894088745,
-0.7825753092765808,
0.007186995819211006,
0.4150083661079407,
0.38552114367485046,
0.24397000670433044,
-0.6729609966278076,
-0.4598237872123718,
-0.00786357931792736,
-0.3339037299156189,
0.9210289120674133,
-0.7546135187149048,
-0.13246825337409973,
-0.13521084189414978,
0.17181983590126038,
-0.12839548289775848,
-0.39758792519569397,
0.24293719232082367,
-0.518629789352417,
0.2124994844198227,
-0.42666271328926086,
-0.10692090541124344,
-0.09093830734491348,
0.6019390821456909,
-0.9294624328613281,
0.6914655566215515,
0.1239391341805458,
-0.699985146522522,
0.31956422328948975,
-0.5596330761909485,
-0.2386603057384491,
-0.1400710642337799,
-0.3394758701324463,
-0.19590240716934204,
0.005561109632253647,
0.763113260269165,
0.4402454197406769,
-0.31432291865348816,
-0.11170852184295654,
-0.5436134934425354,
-0.11975643783807755,
0.5960712432861328,
-0.70055091381073,
0.7224614024162292,
0.11278955638408661,
-0.14381790161132812,
0.03239140659570694,
-0.840323805809021,
0.2876570224761963,
0.3579350411891937,
-0.24184073507785797,
-0.17397630214691162,
-0.264528751373291,
0.3110595941543579,
0.40259984135627747,
0.011656630784273148,
-0.5128079652786255,
0.14220188558101654,
0.27626723051071167,
0.3031109869480133,
0.6558719873428345,
-0.14627665281295776,
0.2584463059902191,
-0.3261929154396057,
0.6980322599411011,
0.04965221881866455,
0.3563191592693329,
-0.627577543258667,
-0.6020180583000183,
-0.5544402003288269,
-0.5549477338790894,
0.26549050211906433,
0.33822718262672424,
-1.2223693132400513,
-0.30190351605415344,
-0.31394585967063904,
-0.5553496479988098,
-0.5061119198799133,
-0.01933484897017479,
0.40414875745773315,
0.38915345072746277,
0.5605460405349731,
-0.14134012162685394,
-0.21259455382823944,
-1.2028882503509521,
0.005130348727107048,
0.21314488351345062,
-0.13225404918193817,
0.22064445912837982,
0.5254998803138733,
-0.2710495591163635,
0.6137588620185852,
-0.40690356492996216,
0.15085633099079132,
-0.1316516250371933,
0.39322829246520996,
-0.2361420840024948,
0.4091035723686218,
0.6849225759506226,
-1.0496954917907715,
-0.6778174042701721,
0.004220066126435995,
-0.44463610649108887,
0.020359542220830917,
-0.24404972791671753,
0.02383320778608322,
0.015295635908842087,
0.5755264163017273,
-0.6277116537094116,
0.3026318848133087,
0.7484810948371887,
-0.20130179822444916,
0.9239808320999146,
-0.1350756734609604,
0.6031781435012817,
-0.8087265491485596,
0.0014397070044651628,
0.1812257021665573,
-0.22075042128562927,
-0.4036887586116791,
0.17648573219776154,
0.5687426924705505,
-0.11882547289133072,
-0.6900728940963745,
0.48058611154556274,
-0.5090245604515076,
-0.09718303382396698,
-0.05488123372197151,
-0.13457173109054565,
0.4434962868690491,
0.6952160596847534,
-0.16105373203754425,
1.0889956951141357,
0.6940081119537354,
-0.43689873814582825,
0.6554717421531677,
0.2997395992279053,
-0.7254781723022461,
0.5250177979469299,
-0.5792444944381714,
-0.09356582164764404,
-0.2657991647720337,
0.34758785367012024,
-1.2569897174835205,
-0.32139521837234497,
0.01872291974723339,
-0.3813760280609131,
0.1804276704788208,
0.24531380832195282,
-0.6555618047714233,
-0.42596006393432617,
-0.4367188513278961,
0.6299422979354858,
0.08372101932764053,
-0.7471888065338135,
0.6296454071998596,
0.23239806294441223,
0.004192517139017582,
-0.8298812508583069,
-0.7076287269592285,
0.2479483038187027,
-0.012946464121341705,
-0.7921479344367981,
0.3432903289794922,
-0.3375348746776581,
-0.10567609965801239,
-0.03426877409219742,
0.03433637693524361,
-0.19152721762657166,
-0.05468305945396423,
0.045411963015794754,
0.07616076618432999,
-0.3633340001106262,
0.0985131487250328,
-0.12457507103681564,
0.07859402149915695,
0.03721807524561882,
0.3724732995033264,
0.5453395843505859,
-0.5579996109008789,
-0.49862921237945557,
-0.26973122358322144,
0.7220677137374878,
1.0557935237884521,
-0.44767555594444275,
0.700117290019989,
0.9418476223945618,
-0.17857947945594788,
-0.07881341129541397,
-0.778642475605011,
0.14694927632808685,
-0.4752179682254791,
0.6149003505706787,
-0.9806019067764282,
-0.6844634413719177,
0.6237172484397888,
-0.07249155640602112,
-0.220016747713089,
0.11659733206033707,
0.6234451532363892,
-0.1825564205646515,
1.4827512502670288,
0.36589622497558594,
0.39555254578590393,
0.3089854419231415,
0.05098547041416168,
-0.04500234127044678,
-0.9746249318122864,
-0.3771137595176697,
-0.5438280701637268,
-0.12640364468097687,
-0.6879355907440186,
-0.6157833337783813,
0.37598609924316406,
-0.20973487198352814,
-0.2337850034236908,
0.31685277819633484,
-0.07364410907030106,
0.683883011341095,
0.6667575836181641,
0.16254054009914398,
0.25303852558135986,
-0.25752559304237366,
-0.3021051287651062,
0.12554503977298737,
-0.6171768307685852,
-0.27761366963386536,
1.0240310430526733,
0.16579940915107727,
0.9030147790908813,
0.3614691495895386,
-0.07396196573972702,
0.05988382175564766,
0.03442598879337311,
-0.47072380781173706,
0.5083209872245789,
0.12263176590204239,
-0.5238032937049866,
-0.18534696102142334,
-0.4813377261161804,
-1.1810706853866577,
0.6371081471443176,
-0.35135170817375183,
-0.653640627861023,
0.12109389901161194,
-0.07224715501070023,
-0.2587907910346985,
0.11598701030015945,
-1.0691750049591064,
1.2823843955993652,
-0.4572893977165222,
-0.3920993208885193,
-0.014497926458716393,
-0.678221583366394,
0.6189836263656616,
0.01618865877389908,
0.25555846095085144,
-0.06455209851264954,
-0.07516133785247803,
0.12429167330265045,
-0.08337529003620148,
0.4790510833263397,
0.1613934487104416,
-0.029650259763002396,
0.01413380540907383,
0.08059848099946976,
0.0820578783750534,
0.09129415452480316,
0.07012032717466354,
-0.011469458229839802,
0.4732789099216461,
-0.7306655645370483,
-0.9327535033226013,
0.7582759261131287,
-0.8633016347885132,
-0.5373964905738831,
-0.30373966693878174,
-0.5523999333381653,
-0.5326090455055237,
-0.003248968394473195,
0.11016099900007248,
0.5839004516601562,
-0.15381906926631927,
0.47681665420532227,
0.4622768759727478,
-0.6557316780090332,
0.5216453075408936,
0.2608332633972168,
-0.376345694065094,
-0.2976306974887848,
0.7409289479255676,
-0.23227904736995697,
0.28773099184036255,
0.47899389266967773,
0.12503914535045624,
-0.592697262763977,
-0.24539797008037567,
-0.6838986277580261,
-0.03532103821635246,
-0.9936593174934387,
-0.04380553960800171,
-0.732580304145813,
0.0017741222400218248,
-0.45783933997154236,
0.07851063460111618,
-0.4657646417617798,
-0.32307711243629456,
0.062293827533721924,
0.3729683756828308,
-0.21778298914432526,
0.3123638927936554,
0.16670498251914978,
-0.10197115689516068,
-0.850662887096405,
0.5913974046707153,
0.8159031271934509,
0.29218000173568726,
0.06252329796552658,
-0.04383913055062294,
-0.04640848934650421,
0.06148579344153404,
-0.29587042331695557,
-0.7757244110107422,
0.03033490665256977,
-0.12440785020589828,
0.6459872126579285,
0.18446658551692963,
0.035656727850437164,
0.8570999503135681,
-0.5142298340797424,
0.7044579982757568,
0.4013715386390686,
-0.9140598177909851,
0.2778688669204712,
-0.2333551049232483,
0.7627778053283691,
0.47003719210624695,
0.4005434811115265,
-0.6050294637680054,
-0.27498283982276917,
-0.18782944977283478,
-0.4840153157711029,
0.31804394721984863,
0.2468118518590927,
0.19665175676345825,
-0.12633207440376282,
-0.18130692839622498,
0.18150538206100464,
0.2810386121273041,
-0.8288996815681458,
-0.01747165434062481,
-0.5119288563728333,
0.03570789843797684,
0.08477942645549774,
-0.10862165689468384,
0.02148684673011303,
-0.2370765209197998,
0.369254469871521,
-0.27877211570739746,
0.14390221238136292,
-0.022103751078248024,
-0.33161023259162903,
0.11662881076335907,
0.2928774058818817,
0.9138403534889221,
0.8507382273674011,
-0.025386502966284752,
0.36717480421066284,
-0.04341094195842743,
-0.17394983768463135,
-0.013494564220309258,
-0.0035793802235275507,
0.306192547082901,
-0.2474931925535202,
0.46270331740379333,
0.7284781336784363,
0.031202660873532295,
-1.0167666673660278,
0.7935994267463684,
-0.709814190864563,
-0.14219848811626434,
-0.23357020318508148,
-0.0079806512221694,
-0.05430161580443382,
0.3759096562862396,
0.25747576355934143,
0.22253364324569702,
-0.00212827674113214,
-0.6676241755485535,
0.013416471891105175,
0.5813162922859192,
0.07310666143894196,
-0.025957144796848297,
0.3910594582557678,
0.06831589341163635,
0.00924484059214592,
0.5334792733192444,
-0.07059018313884735,
-0.5288631916046143,
0.8248206973075867,
0.46929416060447693,
0.42540860176086426,
-0.06348916888237,
0.2539454400539398,
0.3576221168041229,
0.551047146320343,
0.1538488268852234,
-0.02023346535861492,
-0.12886610627174377,
-0.8310731053352356,
-0.518385112285614,
-0.31428030133247375,
-0.5077546238899231,
0.4218004643917084,
-0.48105087876319885,
0.1439279317855835,
-0.28352493047714233,
-0.04215407744050026,
0.24602505564689636,
-0.2949252426624298,
-0.8843601942062378,
0.11988019198179245,
0.41379186511039734,
0.7647438645362854,
-0.6308482885360718,
0.7193740606307983,
0.5939222574234009,
-0.4759342074394226,
-0.5584800839424133,
0.07265858352184296,
-0.05261813476681709,
-0.7205084562301636,
0.2838876247406006,
0.3416597247123718,
-0.19283179938793182,
-0.28364458680152893,
-0.5967270135879517,
-0.7321582436561584,
0.8761981725692749,
0.24535596370697021,
-0.26956573128700256,
0.22882607579231262,
0.2683996558189392,
0.38603004813194275,
-0.14829450845718384,
0.753717839717865,
0.3844248354434967,
0.7470026612281799,
0.06327863782644272,
-1.0131148099899292,
0.054529983550310135,
-0.6064558029174805,
0.13653364777565002,
-0.03530804067850113,
-0.6012283563613892,
1.1209068298339844,
-0.12017421424388885,
-0.05371373891830444,
0.1728038638830185,
0.38112422823905945,
0.2319452315568924,
0.25428539514541626,
0.6028075814247131,
0.41904518008232117,
0.6294919848442078,
-0.012260300107300282,
1.2694573402404785,
0.10006432235240936,
0.17998607456684113,
1.2343868017196655,
-0.24778248369693756,
0.7303056120872498,
0.5026599764823914,
-0.094489187002182,
0.3365592062473297,
0.6177288293838501,
-0.13202866911888123,
0.439688503742218,
0.26928168535232544,
-0.2977733016014099,
-0.5227755308151245,
0.010309409350156784,
-0.5683162212371826,
0.8223090171813965,
0.3088844120502472,
0.06964641064405441,
-0.5256866216659546,
0.572273313999176,
-0.3239009976387024,
0.22004279494285583,
-0.17497950792312622,
0.46392178535461426,
-0.3788549602031708,
-0.8357165455818176,
0.5849552750587463,
0.21659763157367706,
0.3674840033054352,
-0.5829676389694214,
-0.010703745298087597,
-0.2870267629623413,
0.10693147033452988,
0.07263698428869247,
-0.8671371340751648,
0.10887455940246582,
-0.11256865411996841,
-0.1306440532207489,
-0.11125031858682632,
0.3457491397857666,
-0.4146561026573181,
-0.46175718307495117,
0.11730696260929108,
0.6872333884239197,
-0.25771307945251465,
-0.31890666484832764,
-0.9893214702606201,
0.27414393424987793,
-0.16411827504634857,
-0.36249250173568726,
0.30328768491744995,
0.604689359664917,
-0.1451248973608017,
0.8977470397949219,
0.6809045672416687,
-0.4765445590019226,
0.3412339687347412,
0.22681637108325958,
0.9746344089508057,
-0.48692092299461365,
-0.33103230595588684,
-0.6464893817901611,
0.5337991118431091,
-0.15878844261169434,
-0.2804325520992279,
0.7649550437927246,
0.5048783421516418,
0.8943527340888977,
-0.3114383816719055,
0.6879367828369141,
0.0972348302602768,
0.11309823393821716,
-0.6103790998458862,
0.5359106063842773,
-0.904463529586792,
-0.029316933825612068,
-0.2952769994735718,
-0.839433491230011,
-0.4399067759513855,
0.5729331970214844,
-0.29602235555648804,
0.07474241405725479,
0.9822856783866882,
1.0517932176589966,
-0.3261905908584595,
0.14115266501903534,
0.5699647068977356,
0.007871372625231743,
0.5166823863983154,
0.8251490592956543,
1.4852279424667358,
-0.39783304929733276,
0.8402351140975952,
-0.3547036945819855,
-0.18341024219989777,
0.0068869758397340775,
-0.8062744140625,
-0.939111053943634,
-0.8239743113517761,
-0.3555729389190674,
-0.21967241168022156,
-0.33588021993637085,
0.7477607727050781,
0.7159875631332397,
-0.6735435724258423,
0.07478325814008713,
0.0595674030482769,
0.12980327010154724,
-0.23847603797912598,
-0.23804005980491638,
0.29943177103996277,
-0.08753831684589386,
-0.9190323948860168,
0.3361835181713104,
0.2559541165828705,
0.011903947219252586,
-0.3148408532142639,
0.11703898757696152,
-0.4373740255832672,
0.05761273577809334,
0.7556467652320862,
0.30184274911880493,
-0.7780427932739258,
-0.3496580719947815,
0.057250186800956726,
-0.36196330189704895,
0.1376553177833557,
0.651743471622467,
-0.5975645780563354,
0.785941481590271,
0.4283120930194855,
0.8755291700363159,
0.7268348336219788,
0.0022618246730417013,
0.25779181718826294,
-0.6753888726234436,
0.13032199442386627,
0.1700727343559265,
0.4694051742553711,
0.4507034122943878,
0.03941125422716141,
0.10969478636980057,
-0.11190811544656754,
-0.3547033965587616,
-0.5731804966926575,
0.24910467863082886,
-1.063429832458496,
-0.7147709131240845,
0.999651312828064,
-0.010448891669511795,
-0.5084244608879089,
-0.23227371275424957,
-0.43237757682800293,
-0.14728422462940216,
-0.15290303528308868,
0.7395613193511963,
0.7955676913261414,
-0.019472913816571236,
-0.7919875383377075,
-0.6500343680381775,
0.14384041726589203,
0.39384663105010986,
-0.863028883934021,
-0.1690991371870041,
0.7297153472900391,
0.15338633954524994,
0.28373318910598755,
0.5427893400192261,
0.059684086591005325,
0.5866556763648987,
0.1552007794380188,
0.026253148913383484,
-0.23535467684268951,
-0.4626771807670593,
0.10667984187602997,
0.6047349572181702,
-0.3086990714073181,
-0.4998299479484558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15840v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15840v1 | Emergent Explainability: Adding a causal chain to neural network inference | 2024-01-29T02:28:39 | 2024-01-29T02:28:39 | Adam Perrett | cs.CL | cs.CL | This position paper presents a theoretical framework for enhancing
explainable artificial intelligence (xAI) through emergent communication
(EmCom), focusing on creating a causal understanding of AI model outputs. We
explore the novel integration of EmCom into AI systems, offering a paradigm
shift from conventional associative relationships between inputs and outputs to
a more nuanced, causal interpretation. The framework aims to revolutionize how
AI processes are understood, making them more transparent and interpretable.
While the initial application of this model is demonstrated on synthetic data,
the implications of this research extend beyond these simple applications. This
general approach has the potential to redefine interactions with AI across
multiple domains, fostering trust and informed decision-making in healthcare
and in various sectors where AI's decision-making processes are critical. The
paper discusses the theoretical underpinnings of this approach, its potential
broad applications, and its alignment with the growing need for responsible and
transparent AI systems in an increasingly digital world. | [
-0.11535457521677017,
-0.7334958910942078,
0.8843255043029785,
0.12516583502292633,
0.16585682332515717,
-0.1639394611120224,
0.009105096571147442,
-0.7915433049201965,
0.1539524793624878,
-0.04452476650476456,
-0.7120233774185181,
0.03459708020091057,
-0.4790634512901306,
-0.113413967192173,
-0.6259704232215881,
0.8652204275131226,
0.050122570246458054,
-0.16057124733924866,
-0.28505849838256836,
-0.02499678172171116,
-0.18742728233337402,
-0.20134249329566956,
-1.4215033054351807,
-0.6808269023895264,
0.82000732421875,
0.28547772765159607,
0.8065271973609924,
1.0594043731689453,
0.17455896735191345,
0.35497909784317017,
0.18814726173877716,
0.15579216182231903,
-0.07875221967697144,
0.15196962654590607,
-0.3153138756752014,
-0.9311190843582153,
-0.30919185280799866,
-0.06779689341783524,
0.5435065031051636,
0.745262622833252,
-0.04538440331816673,
-0.031919803470373154,
0.16966906189918518,
0.4131462275981903,
-0.4859846532344818,
0.4211973547935486,
-0.20463307201862335,
0.2633798122406006,
0.23871631920337677,
-0.5664516091346741,
-0.5754066705703735,
0.08821506798267365,
0.40476194024086,
-0.842393159866333,
-0.16267678141593933,
0.14493361115455627,
0.48418155312538147,
0.4954766035079956,
-0.49741676449775696,
-0.217513307929039,
-1.2457987070083618,
0.3254144489765167,
-0.6471870541572571,
0.267589271068573,
0.016108980402350426,
0.503091037273407,
0.06154431030154228,
-1.2542871236801147,
-0.521439790725708,
-0.11939143389463425,
-0.1251877099275589,
0.4135572910308838,
-0.5117626190185547,
0.4048667848110199,
-0.03184148669242859,
0.007636325433850288,
-0.001605351222679019,
0.33845773339271545,
0.02104596234858036,
0.3158828914165497,
0.6232413053512573,
0.3287326991558075,
0.637398362159729,
0.30211034417152405,
-0.1790924221277237,
0.2746506929397583,
-0.7702040672302246,
0.06229369342327118,
0.10184936225414276,
0.14364342391490936,
-0.4626336693763733,
0.17833712697029114,
0.004303689114749432,
0.46295323967933655,
0.08849502354860306,
0.30621442198753357,
-0.1343850940465927,
-0.31246891617774963,
-0.3348325192928314,
0.30048513412475586,
0.47272276878356934,
0.13290166854858398,
-0.04313554987311363,
-0.25596004724502563,
0.3151727318763733,
-0.13380375504493713,
0.49385300278663635,
-0.6907469034194946,
-0.38253867626190186,
0.627591609954834,
-0.7446868419647217,
-0.691064178943634,
0.20043329894542694,
-0.547532856464386,
-0.5362362861633301,
-0.5800464749336243,
0.4320107102394104,
-0.2422209084033966,
-0.28321903944015503,
-0.4581820070743561,
-0.16188068687915802,
0.1963263303041458,
0.4249860346317291,
-0.7313006520271301,
0.26018038392066956,
0.6229691505432129,
1.0220870971679688,
0.15566770732402802,
-0.3549477159976959,
-0.019985539838671684,
0.41394492983818054,
-0.33040499687194824,
0.5094573497772217,
-0.2980850338935852,
0.13060727715492249,
-0.15164025127887726,
-0.07293061912059784,
-0.27355411648750305,
-0.12905725836753845,
0.2191636860370636,
-0.29399171471595764,
-0.1224626675248146,
0.32146579027175903,
-0.3396582007408142,
-0.3475295901298523,
0.15611423552036285,
-0.718129575252533,
-0.028776273131370544,
-0.175837904214859,
-0.6299920082092285,
0.4545876979827881,
-1.1595609188079834,
-0.4820234775543213,
-0.06517855077981949,
-0.4507228136062622,
-0.3941005766391754,
0.08977487683296204,
-0.08811116963624954,
0.44860541820526123,
-0.43415573239326477,
0.5729736685752869,
-0.4403511583805084,
-0.085385762155056,
0.535507321357727,
-0.8409623503684998,
0.9897450804710388,
0.24725565314292908,
-0.8320519328117371,
0.4509682357311249,
-0.9921597838401794,
0.07915773242712021,
-0.08948100358247757,
0.15723848342895508,
-0.36148956418037415,
0.45411887764930725,
-0.30712640285491943,
0.5340176224708557,
-0.04687919840216637,
-0.3302384614944458,
-0.31094682216644287,
-0.45851394534111023,
0.9030702710151672,
0.9283369183540344,
0.07349277287721634,
0.5783819556236267,
-0.4384649991989136,
0.307672917842865,
0.1229550838470459,
0.5584079027175903,
-0.37164393067359924,
-0.6036461591720581,
-0.7171258926391602,
-0.1298595517873764,
0.0022665956057608128,
0.40248584747314453,
-0.734508752822876,
0.17748723924160004,
-0.05440923199057579,
-0.35381948947906494,
-0.6455109715461731,
-0.3333801031112671,
0.22740362584590912,
0.5927171111106873,
0.03912784159183502,
0.2741817831993103,
-0.7038153409957886,
-0.907149076461792,
-0.24376404285430908,
-0.5764020681381226,
-0.03161757066845894,
0.654674232006073,
0.43065571784973145,
-0.28432950377464294,
0.7450764775276184,
-0.24658088386058807,
0.11704982072114944,
-0.19301185011863708,
0.25712987780570984,
0.054628580808639526,
0.82231205701828,
0.05417418107390404,
-1.0906928777694702,
0.10058168321847916,
0.3546155095100403,
-1.2191752195358276,
0.0933680459856987,
-0.7012651562690735,
0.09872148931026459,
-0.2929860055446625,
0.7285813689231873,
-0.37589406967163086,
0.8385259509086609,
0.4427657723426819,
-0.5526870489120483,
0.3595428764820099,
-0.5161538124084473,
0.27234581112861633,
-1.1567952632904053,
0.309400349855423,
-0.17041905224323273,
-0.0425860621035099,
-0.8829911351203918,
0.22590123116970062,
-0.28569579124450684,
-0.13118913769721985,
-0.415134459733963,
0.49563565850257874,
-0.24561373889446259,
0.03773168846964836,
-0.22291219234466553,
-0.09207546710968018,
0.020968038588762283,
0.340922087430954,
-0.2392803579568863,
0.41061046719551086,
0.4026893377304077,
-0.8090380430221558,
0.03928748145699501,
0.2871462404727936,
0.13661183416843414,
0.4761658012866974,
-1.2068777084350586,
-0.2935183048248291,
-0.13134793937206268,
0.3199068307876587,
-1.0174309015274048,
-0.22860676050186157,
0.47548794746398926,
-0.6856430172920227,
0.11404454708099365,
-0.013602616265416145,
-0.2107781171798706,
-0.06183508038520813,
0.12606152892112732,
0.7199837565422058,
0.27426955103874207,
-0.8049217462539673,
0.8417177200317383,
0.2891111373901367,
0.18169626593589783,
-0.1397712379693985,
-1.095961570739746,
0.33692803978919983,
-0.28477713465690613,
-0.8486549258232117,
0.563277542591095,
-0.06738455593585968,
-0.5140490531921387,
-0.000783365685492754,
0.12441504746675491,
-0.2827819287776947,
0.5196335315704346,
0.6573007702827454,
-0.019725225865840912,
-0.2074902355670929,
0.15593105554580688,
0.38487687706947327,
-0.3051071763038635,
0.6018711924552917,
-0.6710312962532043,
-0.05007359758019447,
0.0471208281815052,
-0.47260308265686035,
-0.9269761443138123,
0.5801449418067932,
0.7499145865440369,
0.0994994193315506,
1.0185860395431519,
0.3776834011077881,
-0.5423744916915894,
-0.25750666856765747,
0.21148085594177246,
-0.3107824921607971,
-0.3947320580482483,
0.01875084638595581,
-0.12607218325138092,
-0.5995124578475952,
0.7964743971824646,
-0.36233997344970703,
0.03204997256398201,
0.5520087480545044,
0.49752259254455566,
0.00045948184560984373,
1.6364604234695435,
0.6348319053649902,
0.46434035897254944,
0.46518924832344055,
-0.21833385527133942,
0.5056256651878357,
-0.6988810300827026,
-0.6972245573997498,
-0.3362441062927246,
-0.23217876255512238,
-0.9334701895713806,
0.04623675346374512,
0.3149024248123169,
-0.3126368224620819,
-0.6061916351318359,
-0.07601334899663925,
-0.35966160893440247,
-0.07853783667087555,
0.6250972151756287,
0.47291406989097595,
0.357798308134079,
-0.4852690100669861,
-0.032343655824661255,
0.38332244753837585,
-1.2115824222564697,
-0.2627897560596466,
0.8673520684242249,
0.5813175439834595,
0.6870146989822388,
0.15983867645263672,
0.428340345621109,
0.38794419169425964,
0.32814767956733704,
-0.5874934196472168,
0.0888030081987381,
0.2668232321739197,
-0.6367450952529907,
-0.2760752737522125,
-0.3947244882583618,
-1.1037784814834595,
0.018380677327513695,
-0.3242615759372711,
-0.8068984746932983,
0.4731743037700653,
0.2847384810447693,
-0.6300645470619202,
0.4684517979621887,
-0.74879390001297,
0.543677806854248,
-0.1337231993675232,
-0.5669503808021545,
-0.34911203384399414,
-0.9736285209655762,
0.5452746748924255,
-0.04352352395653725,
0.009989166632294655,
0.2705303728580475,
-0.1572074145078659,
0.8788459897041321,
-0.5462372303009033,
1.2132155895233154,
0.1968357115983963,
0.029273012652993202,
0.24156305193901062,
-0.24932539463043213,
0.2337656468153,
0.3418469727039337,
-0.08971651643514633,
0.3783029317855835,
-0.19059036672115326,
-0.2015291303396225,
-1.2043544054031372,
0.7024393081665039,
-0.9583420157432556,
-0.4261236786842346,
-0.294394314289093,
-0.6641432642936707,
0.1251794397830963,
0.28045082092285156,
0.09936586022377014,
0.6335443258285522,
-0.28051522374153137,
-0.02632489614188671,
0.5434698462486267,
-0.17673856019973755,
0.38935020565986633,
0.24197882413864136,
0.267033189535141,
-0.1791435033082962,
0.7173855304718018,
0.13198970258235931,
0.16721992194652557,
0.3918501138687134,
0.2857015132904053,
-0.036771081387996674,
-0.48291319608688354,
-0.24530230462551117,
-0.2458619624376297,
-0.6068774461746216,
0.07107145339250565,
-0.7101395726203918,
-0.5188035368919373,
-0.22856482863426208,
-0.3134492039680481,
-0.1639600247144699,
-0.5529444813728333,
-0.4463944137096405,
0.0034350715577602386,
-0.03520836681127548,
1.1249895095825195,
-0.35040247440338135,
0.5928628444671631,
-0.3920424282550812,
0.029230479151010513,
0.13738319277763367,
0.2436511218547821,
0.536037802696228,
-0.44003716111183167,
-0.44197413325309753,
0.32245197892189026,
-0.21326550841331482,
-0.7946886420249939,
0.2536936104297638,
0.1491958051919937,
0.7574295401573181,
1.116631031036377,
0.018082231283187866,
0.5947493314743042,
-0.4618590772151947,
0.5676569938659668,
0.1968873143196106,
-0.9317631721496582,
0.7530884146690369,
-0.29986274242401123,
0.04386095330119133,
0.2748199701309204,
0.3915926218032837,
-0.20319226384162903,
-0.26552248001098633,
-1.1784367561340332,
-0.902880072593689,
0.39487728476524353,
0.41838937997817993,
-0.16564835608005524,
0.030102023854851723,
0.39765289425849915,
0.02466239593923092,
0.15008585155010223,
-0.36793744564056396,
-0.6254750490188599,
0.1697818487882614,
-0.1556742787361145,
-0.07688043266534805,
0.14235658943653107,
-0.5110388994216919,
-0.2793648838996887,
0.595487117767334,
-0.0789405032992363,
0.8038311004638672,
0.4488147497177124,
0.058690156787633896,
0.15073853731155396,
-0.0011601330479606986,
0.590756893157959,
0.9926428198814392,
0.09866613894701004,
0.36068207025527954,
-0.3469081521034241,
-0.041961345821619034,
0.3143424391746521,
0.17646557092666626,
-0.35389289259910583,
-0.34259241819381714,
0.6522049903869629,
0.6119590401649475,
0.3223266005516052,
-0.2750050127506256,
0.26978182792663574,
-0.09107163548469543,
-0.015111074782907963,
-0.46586692333221436,
0.06359447538852692,
-0.2442823201417923,
0.6364840865135193,
0.28842025995254517,
0.5322038531303406,
0.45961448550224304,
-0.6291898488998413,
0.5796108841896057,
0.13307268917560577,
-0.7106741666793823,
-0.5021359324455261,
1.1344239711761475,
0.4151311218738556,
-0.3726264238357544,
0.7454123497009277,
0.27702468633651733,
-0.12271971255540848,
1.0952775478363037,
0.8399163484573364,
0.9149522185325623,
-0.2096654176712036,
0.4344434142112732,
0.08028151839971542,
0.3942107558250427,
0.31831106543540955,
-0.1049671322107315,
-0.1192246526479721,
-0.8105515837669373,
-0.4441133737564087,
0.3053899109363556,
-0.4644014835357666,
-0.12223619967699051,
-0.7260759472846985,
-0.19296300411224365,
-0.6564367413520813,
0.012486218474805355,
0.353255033493042,
-0.2968701124191284,
-0.6257378458976746,
0.3810591697692871,
0.17799469828605652,
0.8469170331954956,
-1.2007800340652466,
0.315123975276947,
0.40419909358024597,
-0.6901515126228333,
-0.7841102480888367,
-0.09499892592430115,
0.2532113492488861,
-1.037588357925415,
0.45212721824645996,
0.10855768620967865,
0.05517077445983887,
0.0978742316365242,
-0.7224746346473694,
-0.6013956069946289,
1.3866606950759888,
0.18132951855659485,
-0.03813313692808151,
-0.0799221321940422,
-0.22108478844165802,
0.5370824933052063,
-0.8708889484405518,
0.8392174243927002,
0.7070146799087524,
0.5067145228385925,
-0.07973845303058624,
-0.21816220879554749,
0.4892372786998749,
-0.49781930446624756,
-0.15648990869522095,
-0.05337713286280632,
-0.5443206429481506,
0.5977399349212646,
-0.7067135572433472,
-0.22619330883026123,
0.06823277473449707,
0.8153231739997864,
0.045422691851854324,
0.881878137588501,
0.22498740255832672,
0.2666512727737427,
0.7203965783119202,
0.08069798350334167,
1.2878408432006836,
-0.33617642521858215,
-0.24744737148284912,
1.1408456563949585,
0.17145009338855743,
0.41355130076408386,
0.7099512219429016,
0.011533419601619244,
0.8630098700523376,
0.6730482578277588,
0.27166548371315,
0.20730052888393402,
0.16248926520347595,
-0.4128206670284271,
0.10921166092157364,
-0.4793083369731903,
-0.07826583832502365,
0.5187014937400818,
0.5255404710769653,
-0.9358371496200562,
-0.03355567157268524,
-0.09234273433685303,
-0.038643304258584976,
-0.2951053977012634,
-0.5040023326873779,
0.6949813365936279,
0.221402108669281,
-0.5689276456832886,
-0.1298193782567978,
-0.20495480298995972,
-0.048448268324136734,
-0.4700228273868561,
-0.5277904868125916,
0.16998398303985596,
0.24192358553409576,
-0.46204301714897156,
-0.7487069368362427,
0.4167718291282654,
-0.6343457698822021,
-0.39455780386924744,
-0.07534555345773697,
0.6449244022369385,
-0.3297913670539856,
-0.21928007900714874,
0.34770429134368896,
0.7365512251853943,
0.1153390184044838,
0.14035305380821228,
-0.9881333708763123,
-0.17406430840492249,
-0.06610195338726044,
0.06700322031974792,
0.08187802881002426,
0.45480164885520935,
-0.11173003166913986,
1.0451892614364624,
0.7416951060295105,
0.034779734909534454,
-0.21179573237895966,
-0.008374840021133423,
0.7518028020858765,
-0.3824046552181244,
-0.9185209274291992,
-0.9329088926315308,
0.672481894493103,
-0.24082207679748535,
-0.23671160638332367,
0.6779871582984924,
-0.017776748165488243,
0.3380138874053955,
0.3669273555278778,
1.1290777921676636,
-0.20753727853298187,
-0.3081618547439575,
-0.2798258066177368,
1.0297569036483765,
-0.37932053208351135,
0.24304667115211487,
-0.11164331436157227,
-0.41682758927345276,
-0.3973928391933441,
0.3143281042575836,
-0.12074575573205948,
0.2759878933429718,
0.7452453970909119,
0.5025231242179871,
-0.04112281650304794,
0.17335885763168335,
0.45498332381248474,
0.5257462859153748,
0.42653846740722656,
0.47802799940109253,
0.7891470193862915,
-0.45756301283836365,
0.29135313630104065,
-0.1859084516763687,
-0.6663551926612854,
0.03688398748636246,
-0.9437200427055359,
-0.6011422276496887,
-0.6579508185386658,
-0.4418279230594635,
-0.45496049523353577,
0.24508719146251678,
0.6232249736785889,
0.944469153881073,
-0.7304528951644897,
0.075932078063488,
-0.5983901023864746,
0.5535480976104736,
-0.7246842980384827,
-0.2102801650762558,
0.34748736023902893,
-0.21002216637134552,
-0.30105143785476685,
0.39114809036254883,
0.4522583782672882,
0.023051520809531212,
-0.22474853694438934,
-0.1202155128121376,
-0.3370310366153717,
0.31059566140174866,
0.6493510007858276,
0.6799595952033997,
-0.43657955527305603,
-0.2810004949569702,
-0.3924390375614166,
0.45011061429977417,
-0.05995139107108116,
1.0945326089859009,
-0.707227349281311,
0.5946202278137207,
0.4161038398742676,
0.9636561870574951,
-0.034192513674497604,
-0.05763856694102287,
1.2029565572738647,
-0.19463665783405304,
-0.0425940677523613,
-0.0016696464736014605,
0.28641989827156067,
0.03764955699443817,
-0.8408629298210144,
0.5057913661003113,
0.07556262612342834,
-0.6298980712890625,
-0.5100799202919006,
0.27066031098365784,
-0.6577372550964355,
-0.26201099157333374,
0.7859596014022827,
-0.427476704120636,
-0.3832860589027405,
-0.479491263628006,
0.31082457304000854,
0.6750968098640442,
-0.07695553451776505,
0.7746712565422058,
0.01707771234214306,
-0.5635025501251221,
-0.19211427867412567,
-0.42281007766723633,
0.4115820527076721,
0.3475031852722168,
-1.1610840559005737,
-0.022528652101755142,
0.06204387545585632,
-0.06969988346099854,
0.09308148175477982,
0.3224550485610962,
-0.14242352545261383,
0.45379579067230225,
0.3095357120037079,
-0.18203197419643402,
-0.22964385151863098,
-0.6883221864700317,
-0.6606789827346802,
-0.03766997158527374,
-0.11865793168544769,
-0.31149449944496155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15798v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15798v1 | UnMASKed: Quantifying Gender Biases in Masked Language Models through Linguistically Informed Job Market Prompts | 2024-01-28T23:00:40 | 2024-01-28T23:00:40 | Iñigo Parra | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) have become pivotal in the realm of technological
advancements. While their capabilities are vast and transformative, they often
include societal biases encoded in the human-produced datasets used for their
training. This research delves into the inherent biases present in masked
language models (MLMs), with a specific focus on gender biases. This study
evaluated six prominent models: BERT, RoBERTa, DistilBERT, BERT-multilingual,
XLM-RoBERTa, and DistilBERT-multilingual. The methodology employed a novel
dataset, bifurcated into two subsets: one containing prompts that encouraged
models to generate subject pronouns in English, and the other requiring models
to return the probabilities of verbs, adverbs, and adjectives linked to the
prompts' gender pronouns. The analysis reveals stereotypical gender alignment
of all models, with multilingual variants showing comparatively reduced biases. | [
-0.2137497216463089,
-0.48433250188827515,
0.42276307940483093,
0.13699279725551605,
0.1640554815530777,
0.2881086468696594,
-0.12548892199993134,
-0.21099454164505005,
-0.041482653468847275,
0.8125438094139099,
-0.9647970795631409,
-0.38608843088150024,
-0.6349797248840332,
0.1498078554868698,
-0.4019782245159149,
0.9270250797271729,
0.3550812304019928,
0.4566761255264282,
-0.19756652414798737,
0.14467264711856842,
-0.7578572034835815,
-0.4765609800815582,
0.10433138161897659,
-0.3758520185947418,
0.32273048162460327,
0.13482517004013062,
0.8218430876731873,
0.5488662123680115,
0.05736842751502991,
0.19967573881149292,
-0.02405628003180027,
0.1886323094367981,
-0.155162051320076,
0.2849878668785095,
-0.1688590794801712,
-0.3377029597759247,
-0.18649843335151672,
0.42327880859375,
0.4394529461860657,
1.3583768606185913,
0.049996212124824524,
0.5807616710662842,
0.26386162638664246,
0.6466495394706726,
-0.6386544704437256,
0.21207335591316223,
-0.9257885813713074,
0.032396335154771805,
-0.1373678743839264,
0.1427585482597351,
-0.5479089021682739,
-0.20762740075588226,
0.2981695532798767,
-0.1537046730518341,
0.473895400762558,
-0.015002870932221413,
0.5090196132659912,
0.012510321103036404,
-0.713172435760498,
-0.3615807890892029,
-0.836654782295227,
0.8736253380775452,
-0.41164642572402954,
0.48993170261383057,
0.36802494525909424,
0.4061734676361084,
-0.11455416679382324,
-0.2594717741012573,
-0.17260272800922394,
0.01319139450788498,
-0.14854708313941956,
-0.25974175333976746,
-0.3388858735561371,
-0.11320476233959198,
0.31685975193977356,
0.047431424260139465,
-0.40865588188171387,
0.27496036887168884,
-0.42672401666641235,
-0.15592841804027557,
0.4450813829898834,
-0.05580361559987068,
0.2550024092197418,
-0.021719248965382576,
-0.08248487859964371,
0.01724890246987343,
-0.760262668132782,
-0.003766103647649288,
0.9872573614120483,
0.6262990236282349,
0.19276656210422516,
0.5961322784423828,
-0.11846519261598587,
0.7475559115409851,
0.1070566326379776,
-0.07143114507198334,
0.11439646780490875,
0.024624083191156387,
-0.2146437019109726,
0.15102994441986084,
0.6470500826835632,
0.16280581057071686,
0.42712318897247314,
-0.1324693262577057,
-0.282701313495636,
0.011870675720274448,
0.3271516263484955,
-0.35860881209373474,
-0.00830934289842844,
0.20243169367313385,
-0.5062656402587891,
-0.4482923150062561,
0.17990078032016754,
-0.7851929664611816,
-0.8541649580001831,
-0.17265905439853668,
0.3638373613357544,
0.22249676287174225,
-0.39009568095207214,
0.19543899595737457,
-0.3223222494125366,
-0.15096186101436615,
0.04557333141565323,
-0.9219845533370972,
-0.07701379060745239,
0.6971216797828674,
0.3406631052494049,
0.22374112904071808,
0.03356253355741501,
-0.3005598187446594,
-0.060095157474279404,
-0.388264536857605,
0.3173448145389557,
-0.7915393114089966,
-0.24460391700267792,
0.3367011249065399,
0.09462743997573853,
-0.1434420794248581,
-0.5849432945251465,
0.3044164180755615,
-0.22997063398361206,
0.7218331694602966,
-0.35031858086586,
-0.32617703080177307,
-0.1932794451713562,
0.09287574887275696,
-0.771432101726532,
1.09977126121521,
-0.04370839521288872,
-0.6704779267311096,
0.4889165461063385,
-0.6933968663215637,
0.08419763296842575,
-0.19701030850410461,
-0.45700156688690186,
-0.277313768863678,
0.21874570846557617,
0.36052781343460083,
0.5536882281303406,
-0.34525439143180847,
0.7761697173118591,
-0.05621195584535599,
-0.13083642721176147,
0.6575608849525452,
-0.5861702561378479,
1.0337799787521362,
0.03930509462952614,
-0.5955666303634644,
0.05771955847740173,
-0.6384188532829285,
-0.5460543632507324,
0.03934808447957039,
0.23267194628715515,
-0.35851243138313293,
-0.2565240263938904,
-0.32009828090667725,
0.47609323263168335,
-0.007481471169739962,
-0.6151480078697205,
-0.15120887756347656,
-0.21847476065158844,
0.20764777064323425,
0.8564742803573608,
-0.4407006800174713,
0.5462630391120911,
-0.11998739093542099,
0.7132331728935242,
0.05630908161401749,
0.17668554186820984,
-0.2810010313987732,
-0.6534550189971924,
-0.47581538558006287,
-0.4569184482097626,
0.3918664753437042,
0.3672351837158203,
-0.5331236124038696,
0.31435418128967285,
0.004097154829651117,
-0.3625696897506714,
-0.9299755096435547,
0.07498698681592941,
0.45524364709854126,
0.361466646194458,
-0.18358705937862396,
0.12778498232364655,
-0.570395827293396,
-1.4000589847564697,
-0.7410933375358582,
-0.028950294479727745,
-0.36529046297073364,
0.12222371995449066,
0.5161410570144653,
-0.20772993564605713,
1.0867325067520142,
-0.45586609840393066,
-0.1753598153591156,
-0.1292390525341034,
0.24346990883350372,
0.4527604877948761,
0.3138068914413452,
0.5283641219139099,
-0.41261857748031616,
-0.1361446976661682,
-0.312791109085083,
-0.5399970412254333,
-0.38181665539741516,
-0.10677169263362885,
-0.025073854252696037,
0.07730407267808914,
0.3474811315536499,
-0.5318017601966858,
0.29539066553115845,
0.8883675336837769,
-0.47499486804008484,
0.7014238834381104,
-0.021816765889525414,
-0.13306774199008942,
-0.8266674280166626,
0.21209992468357086,
0.08965744823217392,
-0.2510666251182556,
-0.7296202778816223,
-0.1936003863811493,
-0.10536068677902222,
-0.22987781465053558,
-0.3064517676830292,
0.5892969965934753,
-1.039755940437317,
-0.4582798480987549,
-0.20776623487472534,
-0.08829669654369354,
0.10339490324258804,
0.3738589584827423,
0.10053516179323196,
0.6236644387245178,
0.5840396881103516,
-0.3912706971168518,
0.04627309739589691,
0.09800804406404495,
-0.5273559093475342,
0.23395849764347076,
-0.546608030796051,
0.3094850480556488,
-0.46403968334198,
0.12897153198719025,
-0.9558124542236328,
0.01789170689880848,
0.1651034951210022,
-0.35726088285446167,
0.17076809704303741,
-0.15884913504123688,
-0.41076987981796265,
-0.37720322608947754,
-0.28095173835754395,
0.45756086707115173,
0.5050793290138245,
-0.44939538836479187,
0.4938931167125702,
0.6169377565383911,
-0.07407131791114807,
-0.9726921916007996,
-0.7182772159576416,
0.11297060549259186,
-0.11688953638076782,
-0.38993915915489197,
-0.025135274976491928,
-0.06811933219432831,
-0.6294395923614502,
-0.47481536865234375,
-0.015748418867588043,
-0.11588934063911438,
0.12782122194766998,
0.3439774215221405,
0.4042876660823822,
0.08458714932203293,
-0.018962740898132324,
0.06821385771036148,
-0.05880165100097656,
0.3213760554790497,
-0.3704233765602112,
0.47000229358673096,
0.09172363579273224,
-0.4574517011642456,
0.06564772129058838,
0.3416919708251953,
0.4908597767353058,
-0.07409904897212982,
0.9303826689720154,
0.679341197013855,
-0.5331350564956665,
-0.14861905574798584,
-0.690746545791626,
-0.40299808979034424,
-0.44651469588279724,
0.21801553666591644,
-0.0820704996585846,
-1.0942459106445312,
0.638543963432312,
0.17955182492733002,
0.257883220911026,
0.3086562752723694,
0.5937612056732178,
0.10017351806163788,
1.425870418548584,
0.5943974256515503,
0.14611615240573883,
0.25816798210144043,
0.17666147649288177,
0.2551841139793396,
-0.5209398865699768,
-0.47524961829185486,
-0.7300810813903809,
-0.21545332670211792,
-0.860075056552887,
-0.4157882332801819,
0.38360658288002014,
-0.2895215153694153,
-0.10037235170602798,
0.0035413813311606646,
-0.5464082360267639,
0.5008328557014465,
0.8554259538650513,
-0.025603298097848892,
0.053372573107481,
0.04280461370944977,
-0.16358177363872528,
-0.23557138442993164,
-0.6309667229652405,
-0.7829878926277161,
1.2134909629821777,
0.7346257567405701,
0.5390124917030334,
0.10717974603176117,
0.07363740354776382,
0.4414365291595459,
-0.01938639022409916,
-0.30602526664733887,
0.5169747471809387,
-0.2755858600139618,
-1.1359821557998657,
-0.18836839497089386,
-0.22215700149536133,
-1.0265287160873413,
0.37010905146598816,
-0.3571789264678955,
-0.7764742970466614,
0.4998359978199005,
0.10666672140359879,
-0.057913728058338165,
0.24707737565040588,
-0.4536958932876587,
0.7652515769004822,
-0.062058184295892715,
-0.11365899443626404,
0.28522437810897827,
-0.6823546886444092,
0.6811152100563049,
-0.31910616159439087,
0.5077072978019714,
-0.36424076557159424,
0.17417587339878082,
0.7568001747131348,
-0.2977384924888611,
1.2548177242279053,
-0.19293498992919922,
-0.46724241971969604,
-0.18794168531894684,
0.11962305754423141,
0.40577375888824463,
-0.14584647119045258,
-0.14327532052993774,
0.6038756370544434,
-0.22459369897842407,
-0.3565862774848938,
-0.22640110552310944,
0.4150550961494446,
-0.6851290464401245,
-0.5061351656913757,
-0.369899183511734,
-0.7467259764671326,
-0.36586642265319824,
0.1755349189043045,
0.18571092188358307,
0.5252869129180908,
-0.27563026547431946,
-0.018848327919840813,
0.8178718090057373,
-0.5378162860870361,
0.17011846601963043,
0.5251738429069519,
-0.38551896810531616,
0.047019585967063904,
0.3187195360660553,
0.0022813845425844193,
0.20716172456741333,
0.18107594549655914,
0.2292359620332718,
-0.43279382586479187,
-0.044166259467601776,
-0.42374512553215027,
0.27102458477020264,
-0.6769813299179077,
0.06968913972377777,
-0.74783855676651,
-0.09991136938333511,
-0.6628813147544861,
0.12461875379085541,
-0.42603740096092224,
-0.42486435174942017,
-0.20418313145637512,
-0.24853800237178802,
0.08848261088132858,
0.8418145179748535,
0.08807689696550369,
0.22625716030597687,
-0.553524374961853,
0.20142532885074615,
0.4239517152309418,
0.07819756865501404,
-0.31247514486312866,
-0.5357533097267151,
-0.12221723049879074,
0.5005026459693909,
0.14351794123649597,
-1.1583703756332397,
0.4383135139942169,
0.04159282147884369,
0.6639069318771362,
0.3458239734172821,
0.0218674149364233,
0.21059361100196838,
-0.2828776240348816,
0.992699146270752,
0.08481192588806152,
-0.9335940480232239,
0.45522505044937134,
-0.6298118233680725,
0.3202096223831177,
0.20504523813724518,
0.27209851145744324,
-0.5554976463317871,
-0.7089101076126099,
-0.49112942814826965,
-0.5739302039146423,
0.7285743355751038,
0.35480058193206787,
0.3692393898963928,
-0.02901458367705345,
0.09661994874477386,
0.6669681072235107,
0.7820149064064026,
-0.7279201149940491,
-0.5372985005378723,
0.006561699323356152,
-0.1909276843070984,
0.045341577380895615,
-0.5724546909332275,
-0.10554653406143188,
-0.1532636284828186,
0.6787522435188293,
-0.08007434755563736,
0.36625754833221436,
-0.31963494420051575,
-0.408832311630249,
0.05150702968239784,
0.3643200695514679,
0.8315669894218445,
0.7821339964866638,
-0.36994388699531555,
0.3966418504714966,
-0.18041422963142395,
-0.34730321168899536,
0.11130598932504654,
-0.11794845014810562,
-0.31834524869918823,
0.6142798662185669,
0.20878304541110992,
1.0473861694335938,
-0.018574019894003868,
-0.729994535446167,
0.4696868658065796,
-0.02642468363046646,
-0.08682947605848312,
-0.3817555904388428,
-0.2981909215450287,
-0.1786203533411026,
0.2643226981163025,
0.5308947563171387,
0.10904703289270401,
0.16078104078769684,
-0.6363518238067627,
-0.1896391212940216,
0.7063419222831726,
-0.5393831133842468,
-0.39666664600372314,
0.6847948431968689,
0.26829391717910767,
-0.09253845363855362,
0.473903626203537,
0.04471743851900101,
-0.4736001193523407,
0.440409392118454,
0.3497627079486847,
1.188012957572937,
-0.4723515212535858,
0.5329006910324097,
0.21117982268333435,
0.7862716317176819,
-0.1491188406944275,
0.04076046869158745,
0.43448835611343384,
-0.9456199407577515,
-0.07154908776283264,
-0.31859666109085083,
-0.20612062513828278,
0.1971176266670227,
-0.7170413732528687,
0.21203964948654175,
-0.07063032686710358,
-0.2696945369243622,
0.10059047490358353,
-0.42406463623046875,
-0.8884332180023193,
0.02637716382741928,
0.2228957861661911,
0.605248212814331,
-1.2807624340057373,
0.47609883546829224,
0.7429813146591187,
-0.047007493674755096,
-0.38704797625541687,
-0.18374763429164886,
0.3623245358467102,
-1.0393521785736084,
0.7934609651565552,
0.3001207113265991,
-0.02062765695154667,
-0.21801415085792542,
-0.26346272230148315,
-0.6080204844474792,
0.714369535446167,
0.8755941987037659,
-0.541496992111206,
0.10034402459859848,
0.7193189263343811,
0.27003103494644165,
-0.6843361258506775,
0.7630252838134766,
0.5851361751556396,
0.44024670124053955,
-0.3619377315044403,
-1.1854629516601562,
-0.1679650992155075,
-0.12949883937835693,
0.21390320360660553,
0.023969681933522224,
0.04186483100056648,
0.9899090528488159,
-0.0009197377366945148,
-0.09100955724716187,
-0.46446335315704346,
0.35964909195899963,
0.23371009528636932,
0.18678292632102966,
0.6606482267379761,
-0.10978799313306808,
0.945283055305481,
-0.09930714964866638,
0.6959945559501648,
-0.2510650157928467,
0.15009602904319763,
0.8702174425125122,
-0.28655654191970825,
0.1766546070575714,
0.36087241768836975,
-0.05998590588569641,
0.5323501825332642,
0.5139804482460022,
0.11586003750562668,
0.20209787786006927,
0.18105560541152954,
-0.15264061093330383,
-0.3046862781047821,
-0.5742013454437256,
-0.2855498790740967,
0.5534763336181641,
0.11658880114555359,
-0.8142699599266052,
-0.18696662783622742,
0.33620738983154297,
0.33895671367645264,
0.08153025060892105,
-0.23798540234565735,
0.5232408046722412,
-0.00853629782795906,
-0.5767137408256531,
0.23017753660678864,
0.07872732728719711,
0.743472158908844,
-0.5413979291915894,
0.11967344582080841,
-0.3375213146209717,
-0.0231853686273098,
-0.04846348613500595,
-0.6804383397102356,
0.1239866390824318,
0.19321180880069733,
-0.5312222242355347,
-0.5810475945472717,
0.8735552430152893,
-0.9492387175559998,
-0.8364262580871582,
-0.015018852427601814,
0.7622421383857727,
0.21554633975028992,
-0.4302261769771576,
-0.7732623815536499,
0.1202649399638176,
0.1335463523864746,
-0.012000713497400284,
0.4294952154159546,
0.20643793046474457,
-0.265318363904953,
0.7773644924163818,
0.5341553688049316,
-0.13306786119937897,
0.22195333242416382,
0.3273090422153473,
0.33146044611930847,
-0.5075013041496277,
-0.5061600804328918,
-0.8428552150726318,
0.6323623657226562,
-0.04087233915925026,
-0.14990967512130737,
0.934561550617218,
0.4846518933773041,
0.5776219367980957,
-0.44965383410453796,
0.6659460663795471,
0.6466975808143616,
0.6414474844932556,
-0.5138134360313416,
0.6305405497550964,
-0.20419546961784363,
0.6195582747459412,
-0.4832373857498169,
-0.9856808185577393,
-0.08710276335477829,
0.34852391481399536,
-0.12711656093597412,
0.43473610281944275,
0.31875374913215637,
0.9277195930480957,
0.16096189618110657,
-0.04797443374991417,
0.37611573934555054,
0.07024738192558289,
0.07967950403690338,
0.08399573713541031,
0.8860211968421936,
-0.3297036588191986,
0.15165948867797852,
-0.13556598126888275,
-0.0894540473818779,
-0.19594056904315948,
-1.0759342908859253,
-1.1286661624908447,
-0.6028555631637573,
-0.6887475252151489,
-0.20302323997020721,
0.004806046839803457,
0.9863727688789368,
0.7251692414283752,
-0.5664516091346741,
-0.4829499423503876,
0.37497180700302124,
0.2526244521141052,
-0.17100617289543152,
-0.21185697615146637,
0.08917539566755295,
0.013799051754176617,
-0.7124453783035278,
0.3345552086830139,
0.06743292510509491,
-0.1165492907166481,
-0.7830734848976135,
0.08192700147628784,
-0.023006455972790718,
0.27945476770401,
0.48298659920692444,
-0.2566111981868744,
-0.8792327046394348,
-0.15506669878959656,
0.2104036509990692,
-0.05958398059010506,
-0.3623991310596466,
0.9739819169044495,
-0.6775227189064026,
0.6143040657043457,
0.4127403497695923,
0.2240467369556427,
-0.0719650387763977,
-0.2026410847902298,
1.0701487064361572,
-1.4019709825515747,
0.19419361650943756,
0.0050805420614778996,
0.3784444332122803,
0.4593593180179596,
-0.41634273529052734,
0.3644147515296936,
0.19064877927303314,
-0.25301459431648254,
-1.2504323720932007,
0.2592601180076599,
-0.5821934938430786,
-0.7381958961486816,
1.2724297046661377,
0.22455747425556183,
0.004421768244355917,
-0.3260197043418884,
-0.047502532601356506,
0.1290046125650406,
-0.27929577231407166,
0.6799052953720093,
0.6717705130577087,
0.31988874077796936,
-0.4271220564842224,
-0.7726168632507324,
0.4478011429309845,
0.3766125440597534,
-0.41155779361724854,
0.2651682496070862,
0.6220072507858276,
0.24417945742607117,
0.029205141589045525,
0.40329796075820923,
0.010904097929596901,
-0.03494052588939667,
-0.2287633717060089,
0.4035414159297943,
-0.16898766160011292,
-0.24766805768013,
-0.5572937726974487,
-0.03789176791906357,
0.013875200413167477,
-0.3554915189743042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15780v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15780v1 | Fine-Tuned Large Language Models for Symptom Recognition from Spanish Clinical Text | 2024-01-28T22:11:25 | 2024-01-28T22:11:25 | Mai A. Shaaban, Abbas Akkasi, Adnan Khan, Majid Komeili, Mohammad Yaqub | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The accurate recognition of symptoms in clinical reports is significantly
important in the fields of healthcare and biomedical natural language
processing. These entities serve as essential building blocks for clinical
information extraction, enabling retrieval of critical medical insights from
vast amounts of textual data. Furthermore, the ability to identify and
categorize these entities is fundamental for developing advanced clinical
decision support systems, aiding healthcare professionals in diagnosis and
treatment planning. In this study, we participated in SympTEMIST, a shared task
on the detection of symptoms, signs and findings in Spanish medical documents.
We combine a set of large language models fine-tuned with the data released by
the organizers. | [
0.05020127072930336,
-0.5280542969703674,
0.7937033176422119,
0.43583306670188904,
-0.37347280979156494,
-0.24890698492527008,
-0.34237930178642273,
-1.0079301595687866,
0.6587403416633606,
0.609114408493042,
-0.4458848237991333,
-0.8328152894973755,
-0.978442907333374,
0.3955968916416168,
-0.49426236748695374,
1.1061644554138184,
-0.14889457821846008,
0.3151264190673828,
0.007532102987170219,
-0.06181815639138222,
-0.4835609793663025,
-0.4307049512863159,
-0.9050793051719666,
-0.32373282313346863,
0.43455594778060913,
0.18916559219360352,
0.46312248706817627,
0.2802094519138336,
0.8909794688224792,
0.3157151937484741,
0.1927131712436676,
0.05836177617311478,
-0.23029106855392456,
0.5378177165985107,
-0.38075074553489685,
-0.3964782953262329,
-0.502566933631897,
-0.3823263347148895,
0.3511783480644226,
0.520483136177063,
-0.11966031044721603,
0.11543238162994385,
0.14066678285598755,
0.2878224551677704,
-0.26788434386253357,
0.5890060663223267,
-0.36653557419776917,
0.18748733401298523,
-0.3735954761505127,
-0.17615601420402527,
-0.3129357695579529,
-0.27006927132606506,
0.09616144746541977,
-0.35351261496543884,
0.40092945098876953,
-0.23729906976222992,
0.9137423634529114,
0.4294869601726532,
-0.4982859194278717,
-0.7036762237548828,
-0.6352660059928894,
0.5642045736312866,
-0.5537626147270203,
0.5871415138244629,
0.4503389596939087,
0.18119503557682037,
-0.3273688554763794,
-0.9264850616455078,
-0.29478365182876587,
-0.14303097128868103,
-0.22483161091804504,
0.05347171053290367,
-0.6781222820281982,
0.0795658528804779,
0.23116016387939453,
0.4733017683029175,
-0.8944424390792847,
0.36651021242141724,
-0.39300715923309326,
-0.532770574092865,
0.5167821645736694,
0.4766599237918854,
0.5031269192695618,
-0.28800076246261597,
0.04363080486655235,
0.2051890343427658,
-0.5423586368560791,
-0.1686752438545227,
-0.34886106848716736,
0.1458902359008789,
-0.18684418499469757,
0.45730483531951904,
-0.25270822644233704,
0.7301985025405884,
-0.2577912211418152,
-0.23024998605251312,
0.2634352147579193,
0.08154479414224625,
-0.4125416874885559,
0.23997320234775543,
1.0480740070343018,
0.20177096128463745,
-0.08589021861553192,
-0.15083903074264526,
-0.3066188395023346,
0.1874178647994995,
0.15742596983909607,
-0.6460789442062378,
-0.49389320611953735,
0.31118616461753845,
-0.67964768409729,
-0.1619352251291275,
-0.1397748589515686,
-0.9364804029464722,
-0.8463356494903564,
-0.4125250577926636,
0.1414753794670105,
-0.3001350462436676,
-0.17922255396842957,
0.4309297800064087,
0.008262766525149345,
-0.23278355598449707,
0.6043448448181152,
-0.6442930698394775,
0.4738825261592865,
0.5703284740447998,
0.7897082567214966,
-0.11331004649400711,
0.17664405703544617,
-0.6187931299209595,
0.01803654246032238,
-0.05283891409635544,
0.86078941822052,
-0.3568302392959595,
-0.34099456667900085,
-0.04804769158363342,
0.34363093972206116,
-0.2848273515701294,
-0.6863016486167908,
0.5948068499565125,
-0.02522740513086319,
0.26084548234939575,
-0.09348031133413315,
-0.4807909429073334,
0.13384327292442322,
0.0693836435675621,
-0.9720581769943237,
0.8886910676956177,
0.18505822122097015,
-0.5439831614494324,
0.19784285128116608,
-0.44920089840888977,
-0.5234331488609314,
0.33027616143226624,
-0.09428462386131287,
-0.3633148968219757,
0.42921972274780273,
-0.055907249450683594,
0.8438382744789124,
-0.6472936868667603,
0.3292860984802246,
-0.0006187160615809262,
0.229490727186203,
0.2824352979660034,
-0.2337741106748581,
0.4630873501300812,
0.3676184117794037,
-0.11318358778953552,
0.18286281824111938,
-0.8248133063316345,
-0.23040543496608734,
0.20560325682163239,
-0.14431917667388916,
-0.6669549942016602,
0.09600034356117249,
0.3022844195365906,
0.22043932974338531,
0.43483152985572815,
-0.4091356098651886,
0.1615762710571289,
-0.49843910336494446,
0.3138609826564789,
0.26488423347473145,
0.3401895761489868,
-0.07928355783224106,
-0.13109667599201202,
0.8760149478912354,
-0.04080146923661232,
0.17203006148338318,
-0.03363854065537453,
-0.6153237819671631,
-0.3521970808506012,
-0.6833008527755737,
-0.061874136328697205,
0.4716358780860901,
-0.3045826554298401,
0.4490731656551361,
-0.10990931838750839,
-0.5545337200164795,
-0.38086703419685364,
-0.029502540826797485,
0.5815104246139526,
0.4698401987552643,
0.35905328392982483,
0.17046904563903809,
-0.6885234117507935,
-0.5247026681900024,
-0.058359675109386444,
0.15975604951381683,
-0.22775281965732574,
0.03071158193051815,
0.5713295340538025,
-0.42528364062309265,
0.28832539916038513,
-0.8757951259613037,
-0.66389399766922,
-0.34979820251464844,
0.02289288304746151,
0.35710030794143677,
0.22188836336135864,
0.5792737603187561,
-0.616767942905426,
-0.48148080706596375,
0.5997527241706848,
-0.7093897461891174,
-0.5261744856834412,
0.15784956514835358,
0.13393786549568176,
-0.024639321491122246,
0.8425343036651611,
-0.5225072503089905,
0.5126839876174927,
0.7653768062591553,
-0.7051445841789246,
0.3603067100048065,
-0.38078510761260986,
0.0753706619143486,
-1.3572278022766113,
0.18000759184360504,
0.11382946372032166,
-0.4815034866333008,
-0.44365203380584717,
-0.045315470546483994,
0.12341190874576569,
-0.057018108665943146,
-0.15338778495788574,
0.7402235269546509,
-0.21438921988010406,
0.42841053009033203,
-0.04632190987467766,
-0.2616933584213257,
0.35204392671585083,
-0.0915643647313118,
0.10484733432531357,
0.2182433009147644,
0.5745372176170349,
-0.5521885752677917,
0.41554927825927734,
0.1106967031955719,
-0.38020291924476624,
0.5171874761581421,
-0.7859638333320618,
-0.3192652463912964,
-0.13687121868133545,
-0.05661271512508392,
-0.7532111406326294,
-0.6605764031410217,
0.3395400941371918,
-0.18401497602462769,
0.22878043353557587,
0.12015332281589508,
-0.39992520213127136,
-0.4554939866065979,
0.15736299753189087,
0.34072721004486084,
0.14039991796016693,
-0.28633514046669006,
0.4632042348384857,
0.5770865082740784,
-0.4657505750656128,
-0.11671919375658035,
-0.4369664192199707,
-0.08045538514852524,
-0.25079476833343506,
0.005214654840528965,
0.40260031819343567,
0.31979498267173767,
-0.09734237194061279,
-0.14967656135559082,
-0.13612420856952667,
-0.26200398802757263,
0.1320122927427292,
0.7425164580345154,
0.23174551129341125,
-0.21429061889648438,
0.5352235436439514,
0.33497536182403564,
-0.08322285860776901,
0.07759234309196472,
0.00959540531039238,
0.9681128263473511,
0.021936262026429176,
-0.3824947476387024,
-0.7534910440444946,
0.5096882581710815,
0.8400800228118896,
-0.36552414298057556,
0.7114744186401367,
0.36594799160957336,
-1.0034089088439941,
0.027646735310554504,
-0.3525155484676361,
-0.03766760602593422,
-0.32124942541122437,
0.41599538922309875,
-0.37790653109550476,
-0.6821230053901672,
0.9884563088417053,
-0.008312923833727837,
-0.41154342889785767,
0.5697073340415955,
0.6669021248817444,
-0.06877366453409195,
1.2936440706253052,
0.4877427816390991,
-0.13528087735176086,
0.3283887505531311,
-0.04627886041998863,
0.1557295322418213,
-0.5024047493934631,
-0.47844886779785156,
-1.0780200958251953,
0.04391675442457199,
-0.3029109239578247,
-0.15229368209838867,
0.5315484404563904,
-0.07038846611976624,
0.09245351701974869,
0.24945807456970215,
-0.43264278769493103,
0.33567026257514954,
0.15911158919334412,
0.48551034927368164,
0.38530704379081726,
-0.11350744217634201,
-0.1445625126361847,
-0.36230576038360596,
-0.4704384207725525,
-0.5117098093032837,
0.7938538193702698,
0.45069652795791626,
0.574586033821106,
0.10953103005886078,
0.8782349824905396,
0.24726372957229614,
0.20638281106948853,
-1.0169059038162231,
0.3337620794773102,
-0.6063947677612305,
-0.24259822070598602,
0.03427499532699585,
-0.28057146072387695,
-1.4646193981170654,
-0.1567516177892685,
-0.41503363847732544,
-1.073143720626831,
0.37978577613830566,
0.043805286288261414,
-0.5235487818717957,
-0.3406895399093628,
-0.7606981992721558,
1.2704849243164062,
0.03734948858618736,
0.2940410375595093,
-0.4074324071407318,
-0.3103691339492798,
0.07982363551855087,
-0.11878606677055359,
0.38889122009277344,
-0.06789325177669525,
0.14748625457286835,
0.9294482469558716,
-0.40325263142585754,
0.829054594039917,
0.07684678584337234,
-0.2183024138212204,
-0.24093890190124512,
0.35205066204071045,
0.2794756591320038,
0.20796558260917664,
0.10083537548780441,
0.21130366623401642,
0.4116429090499878,
-0.08486919850111008,
-0.4802614748477936,
0.6349223256111145,
-0.4761073887348175,
-0.2503995895385742,
-0.48509296774864197,
-0.45315176248550415,
-0.19622063636779785,
0.39971932768821716,
0.4264713525772095,
0.7083961367607117,
-0.4538132846355438,
-0.09912920743227005,
0.46216386556625366,
-0.4289911985397339,
0.07214409112930298,
0.7691373229026794,
-0.38266754150390625,
-0.24936580657958984,
0.7188707590103149,
-0.21443115174770355,
0.1182684525847435,
0.35770103335380554,
0.3073621690273285,
-0.2146901935338974,
-0.6189703941345215,
0.08930362015962601,
0.49523836374282837,
-0.4662814140319824,
-0.5001827478408813,
-0.8444868922233582,
-0.12745578587055206,
-0.48801836371421814,
0.09435036778450012,
-0.23380428552627563,
-0.16529829800128937,
-0.5843240022659302,
-0.02706989459693432,
0.4432228207588196,
0.8450115323066711,
0.0805332288146019,
0.5459513664245605,
-1.2726441621780396,
0.48509013652801514,
-0.23186105489730835,
0.1871923804283142,
-0.2027348130941391,
-0.08201858401298523,
-0.42735570669174194,
-0.04413563758134842,
0.0812426209449768,
-1.2724213600158691,
0.9174259901046753,
0.3654569685459137,
0.39083725214004517,
0.7639132738113403,
-0.026311159133911133,
0.7189908027648926,
-0.29076483845710754,
0.46372169256210327,
0.35428357124328613,
-0.9793603420257568,
1.0083459615707397,
-0.19947919249534607,
0.2951865792274475,
0.3452337980270386,
0.6164116859436035,
-0.7075017094612122,
-0.7736949324607849,
-0.5940651297569275,
-0.6663318872451782,
0.6087415218353271,
-0.10135067254304886,
-0.16252876818180084,
-0.34007376432418823,
0.20461419224739075,
0.18470680713653564,
-0.045578733086586,
-0.632523775100708,
0.2483040690422058,
0.24089315533638,
-0.8705313801765442,
-0.08373720198869705,
-0.07997418940067291,
-0.23992307484149933,
-0.3870185315608978,
0.25413110852241516,
-0.0182284377515316,
0.1880861073732376,
0.43509748578071594,
-0.36261656880378723,
-0.22328437864780426,
0.1319853663444519,
0.4093986451625824,
0.5810954570770264,
-0.029126180335879326,
0.1936621069908142,
-0.20165832340717316,
-0.8337447643280029,
-0.23295599222183228,
0.29568806290626526,
0.22949934005737305,
0.3547240197658539,
0.7459333539009094,
0.8329940438270569,
0.358198881149292,
-0.9042426347732544,
0.5206277370452881,
-0.13374614715576172,
0.11335056275129318,
-0.24413150548934937,
0.17275691032409668,
-0.23047073185443878,
0.49060535430908203,
0.014966707676649094,
0.11095453798770905,
0.5353902578353882,
-0.4805091321468353,
0.02844737283885479,
0.44084352254867554,
-0.471547931432724,
-0.5100981593132019,
0.4796643853187561,
-0.020097114145755768,
-0.20755866169929504,
0.45244359970092773,
-0.03198235481977463,
-0.6558348536491394,
0.7448256611824036,
0.6404513120651245,
0.3865600824356079,
-0.5903295278549194,
0.5164565443992615,
0.30535662174224854,
-0.036367639899253845,
-0.47499173879623413,
0.46094152331352234,
0.2734568119049072,
-0.6652314066886902,
-0.3841738700866699,
-0.9169947504997253,
-0.050298795104026794,
0.1794261336326599,
-1.0003547668457031,
0.474306583404541,
-0.22629526257514954,
-0.31987103819847107,
0.4337916076183319,
-0.2212645262479782,
-0.734307050704956,
0.2677261531352997,
0.11742598563432693,
0.6518228054046631,
-1.2368425130844116,
0.879630982875824,
0.8441203832626343,
-0.3153941035270691,
-0.8921926021575928,
-0.23673789203166962,
0.042748745530843735,
-0.8077666163444519,
0.5192532539367676,
0.10525229573249817,
0.3264281451702118,
0.05304914712905884,
-0.08202748745679855,
-0.7104727625846863,
0.7908346056938171,
0.5099247097969055,
-0.6575237512588501,
-0.06712857633829117,
0.1445932388305664,
0.9558955430984497,
-0.3352205455303192,
0.18537114560604095,
0.6007801294326782,
0.34933486580848694,
0.06951667368412018,
-1.5355719327926636,
0.24606837332248688,
-0.2576828896999359,
-0.45041900873184204,
0.574740469455719,
0.10127181559801102,
0.7419697642326355,
-0.05059359222650528,
-0.3339700698852539,
0.034614197909832,
0.10944885015487671,
-0.005914787761867046,
0.5042052268981934,
0.1385274976491928,
0.4873090982437134,
1.1856553554534912,
-0.04923994094133377,
1.0005202293395996,
-0.30630382895469666,
0.3526262044906616,
0.9289050698280334,
-0.29481422901153564,
0.8010302782058716,
0.2119402289390564,
-0.12814918160438538,
0.5716943740844727,
0.4306959807872772,
0.21648985147476196,
0.33800092339515686,
-0.27413269877433777,
-0.47207725048065186,
-0.20069271326065063,
-0.3951703608036041,
-0.4908529818058014,
0.5138686895370483,
0.9396266937255859,
-0.7315393090248108,
-0.3425617218017578,
0.6024787425994873,
0.22891539335250854,
0.08892331272363663,
-0.63575279712677,
0.8611240386962891,
0.09465500712394714,
-0.5322588086128235,
0.5631145238876343,
-0.19751198589801788,
0.14233003556728363,
-0.5549619197845459,
-0.06491424888372421,
0.03166486695408821,
0.20902013778686523,
-0.3820045292377472,
-0.6717445850372314,
0.6420794725418091,
0.14902983605861664,
-0.36560341715812683,
-0.08701391518115997,
0.7781824469566345,
-0.3581954538822174,
-0.6968091130256653,
0.3293263018131256,
0.40823453664779663,
0.3584471344947815,
-0.5250623822212219,
-0.4613783061504364,
0.0979175716638565,
-0.18876145780086517,
0.11395830661058426,
0.2502967119216919,
0.8075679540634155,
-0.40271806716918945,
0.48790624737739563,
0.5063670873641968,
0.5399094820022583,
-0.13446517288684845,
0.3803931474685669,
0.6679392457008362,
-0.6468298435211182,
-0.4146117568016052,
-0.9368898868560791,
0.4020058214664459,
-0.15392059087753296,
-0.3718736469745636,
0.3633735477924347,
0.3763793110847473,
0.2468724548816681,
-0.43900981545448303,
0.43210747838020325,
-0.07257401943206787,
0.5714687705039978,
-0.55661940574646,
0.719977080821991,
-0.5300232768058777,
0.09867417812347412,
-0.3828220069408417,
-0.44992101192474365,
-0.8048470616340637,
0.5843177437782288,
-0.18231292068958282,
-0.565640926361084,
0.9571807384490967,
0.7040937542915344,
0.07912720739841461,
-0.12138430029153824,
0.14720112085342407,
0.6090916991233826,
0.28365588188171387,
0.8019187450408936,
0.448058545589447,
-0.29775241017341614,
0.0820920467376709,
-0.06989116221666336,
-0.22383734583854675,
-0.28025132417678833,
-0.652360200881958,
-0.7162139415740967,
-0.8823473453521729,
-0.49189531803131104,
-0.3651655912399292,
0.05618182197213173,
1.1295630931854248,
0.3805375099182129,
-1.1384968757629395,
0.025338079780340195,
-0.027056356891989708,
0.09281530231237411,
-0.2395951747894287,
-0.24549902975559235,
0.37760767340660095,
-0.06145410239696503,
-0.5387468934059143,
0.1493164747953415,
0.4006603956222534,
0.20554156601428986,
0.1624625027179718,
0.11693321168422699,
0.21994560956954956,
-0.4452028274536133,
0.7287609577178955,
0.37652984261512756,
-0.4852234125137329,
0.03444370627403259,
0.003688205499202013,
-0.3561631441116333,
-0.266652911901474,
0.8210533261299133,
-0.698357880115509,
0.2759300172328949,
0.533734142780304,
0.1831013560295105,
0.24028703570365906,
-0.526865541934967,
0.49869632720947266,
-0.3283970355987549,
0.44706010818481445,
0.4901014566421509,
0.6218311786651611,
-0.015240941196680069,
-0.5693767666816711,
0.20715314149856567,
0.1575242280960083,
-0.35489052534103394,
-0.932465672492981,
0.1092943400144577,
-1.2844083309173584,
-0.21538107097148895,
0.9481827616691589,
-0.1999334692955017,
-0.16015011072158813,
-0.3926275670528412,
-0.4939723014831543,
0.19499069452285767,
-0.17352715134620667,
0.8596019148826599,
0.49655771255493164,
-0.46810150146484375,
-0.10629899799823761,
-0.5568825006484985,
0.6560239195823669,
-0.023656994104385376,
-0.8535299897193909,
-0.15410737693309784,
0.646752119064331,
0.1584090143442154,
0.018503688275814056,
0.7692562341690063,
-0.2422669529914856,
0.4011780023574829,
-0.47396501898765564,
0.18599285185337067,
0.3650779724121094,
-0.22723573446273804,
-0.36215245723724365,
0.1674821525812149,
0.057099953293800354,
0.017660195007920265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15777v1 | cantnlp@LT-EDI-2024: Automatic Detection of Anti-LGBTQ+ Hate Speech in Under-resourced Languages | 2024-01-28T21:58:04 | 2024-01-28T21:58:04 | Sidney G. -J. Wong, Matthew Durward | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper describes our homophobia/transphobia in social media comments
detection system developed as part of the shared task at LT-EDI-2024. We took a
transformer-based approach to develop our multiclass classification model for
ten language conditions (English, Spanish, Gujarati, Hindi, Kannada, Malayalam,
Marathi, Tamil, Tulu, and Telugu). We introduced synthetic and organic
instances of script-switched language data during domain adaptation to mirror
the linguistic realities of social media language as seen in the labelled
training data. Our system ranked second for Gujarati and Telugu with varying
levels of performance for other language conditions. The results suggest
incorporating elements of paralinguistic behaviour such as script-switching may
improve the performance of language detection systems especially in the cases
of under-resourced languages conditions. | [
-0.5165814757347107,
-0.546747088432312,
0.2755793631076813,
0.15329474210739136,
-0.4801320731639862,
0.4065439999103546,
-0.21128715574741364,
-0.44886109232902527,
0.08457682281732559,
0.24913980066776276,
-0.3681725263595581,
-0.2801399230957031,
-0.7871001362800598,
0.4464646577835083,
-0.6216265559196472,
0.9941996932029724,
-0.02293781191110611,
0.31321242451667786,
0.18212823569774628,
-0.22211633622646332,
0.03445199877023697,
-0.5632291436195374,
-0.5989367961883545,
0.03704364225268364,
0.4228820502758026,
0.022511402145028114,
0.4559326171875,
0.017608923837542534,
0.4987473487854004,
0.26623427867889404,
0.14865536987781525,
-0.017176559194922447,
-0.21378542482852936,
0.04277844727039337,
-0.32007476687431335,
-0.2545261085033417,
-0.2664497196674347,
-0.051512766629457474,
0.6003406643867493,
0.16314341127872467,
0.033948030322790146,
0.10868382453918457,
0.18856608867645264,
0.2001851201057434,
-0.5730801224708557,
0.07581624388694763,
-0.6384680867195129,
0.036935944110155106,
-0.5050851702690125,
-0.07648563385009766,
-0.4116291105747223,
-0.2430199831724167,
-0.35012415051460266,
-0.23728938400745392,
0.3475246727466583,
-0.07441696524620056,
0.5530483722686768,
0.2618548572063446,
-0.45763012766838074,
-0.2741643488407135,
-0.7347638010978699,
0.8150768280029297,
-0.47725892066955566,
0.9437622427940369,
0.2864249050617218,
0.15158210694789886,
0.23523171246051788,
-0.29364171624183655,
-0.7406611442565918,
0.29015836119651794,
-0.09241008013486862,
-0.048626482486724854,
-0.24785469472408295,
-0.05079507455229759,
0.004896288271993399,
-0.004462558310478926,
-0.4563474655151367,
0.024350836873054504,
-0.45447346568107605,
-0.15395916998386383,
0.7445312142372131,
-0.15434511005878448,
0.39878174662590027,
-0.4922073185443878,
-0.033277157694101334,
0.24775223433971405,
-0.2188883274793625,
-0.1313185691833496,
0.4782625138759613,
0.7315080761909485,
0.02158447541296482,
0.10128388553857803,
0.32445457577705383,
0.2530879080295563,
0.14425675570964813,
-0.0018897708505392075,
0.44736456871032715,
-0.08255381137132645,
-0.1062900722026825,
-0.06049920618534088,
0.7650752067565918,
0.3257240951061249,
0.4078926742076874,
-0.0561576671898365,
-0.26570549607276917,
0.5964754223823547,
0.3314904272556305,
-0.475405216217041,
-0.056459974497556686,
-0.15425747632980347,
-0.2524902820587158,
-0.24731828272342682,
-0.22875702381134033,
-0.9587929844856262,
-0.7227770686149597,
-0.030931895598769188,
0.08125603944063187,
-0.538675844669342,
-0.5659882426261902,
-0.14025966823101044,
-0.0019848921801894903,
0.13822798430919647,
0.25451141595840454,
-0.7030661106109619,
0.40411603450775146,
0.5971592664718628,
0.7010436654090881,
-0.5778922438621521,
-0.16569465398788452,
-0.35680091381073,
0.013284082524478436,
0.07855236530303955,
0.7615777850151062,
-0.946617841720581,
-0.44291019439697266,
0.2849175035953522,
0.2117730975151062,
-0.2863977253437042,
-0.34746184945106506,
0.735283374786377,
-0.5846464037895203,
0.5023856163024902,
-0.14899109303951263,
-0.27960583567619324,
0.04410713538527489,
0.16452713310718536,
-0.4700099527835846,
1.086983561515808,
0.229731023311615,
-1.0176364183425903,
0.40939804911613464,
-0.617541491985321,
-0.3265572190284729,
0.29338538646698,
-0.054981231689453125,
-0.33223220705986023,
-0.22263705730438232,
-0.12806537747383118,
0.291980504989624,
-0.2502932846546173,
0.26484963297843933,
-0.39316752552986145,
-0.29306814074516296,
0.16349197924137115,
-0.19726009666919708,
0.662308394908905,
0.46049419045448303,
-0.5291131138801575,
0.28521475195884705,
-0.5559682846069336,
-0.03349354863166809,
-0.06450198590755463,
-0.3000551462173462,
-0.5444204807281494,
-0.025462491437792778,
0.5874252915382385,
0.3423285186290741,
-0.19585347175598145,
-0.8685609698295593,
-0.25592443346977234,
-0.21507208049297333,
0.21755988895893097,
0.804279088973999,
-0.2618762254714966,
0.3220241069793701,
0.12870484590530396,
0.7096858024597168,
0.0880921483039856,
0.4857967793941498,
0.7310986518859863,
-0.6005368828773499,
-0.8434893488883972,
-0.04456331953406334,
-0.1392640322446823,
0.6372057199478149,
-1.0850180387496948,
0.34200751781463623,
0.028505409136414528,
-0.21032869815826416,
-0.57295823097229,
0.13614223897457123,
0.47453340888023376,
0.0029615398962050676,
0.39878717064857483,
-0.13091857731342316,
-0.9278513789176941,
-0.7323386669158936,
-0.5488713383674622,
-0.5338541865348816,
0.1323210895061493,
0.08609927445650101,
0.32536181807518005,
-0.5216975212097168,
0.5464110970497131,
-0.10113544017076492,
-0.022745974361896515,
-0.32014116644859314,
0.12374251335859299,
-0.08713346719741821,
0.06098661944270134,
0.5615859031677246,
-1.2126580476760864,
-1.0151574611663818,
-0.3321533501148224,
-0.4402237832546234,
-0.5752484202384949,
0.2532290816307068,
-0.029459191486239433,
0.5282730460166931,
0.6912126541137695,
-0.19441890716552734,
0.31013253331184387,
0.47369134426116943,
-0.5071864128112793,
0.19471047818660736,
0.5576979517936707,
0.4442833960056305,
-1.156410574913025,
-0.2987707853317261,
0.3752135932445526,
-0.29316404461860657,
-0.7725426554679871,
-0.031030962243676186,
-0.0698290541768074,
0.026253825053572655,
-0.6948302388191223,
0.31351402401924133,
-0.18246735632419586,
0.31014135479927063,
-0.2902151048183441,
-0.15104076266288757,
-0.5841609239578247,
0.3859749138355255,
0.14265292882919312,
0.6373011469841003,
0.4330102503299713,
-0.4845956861972809,
0.443591445684433,
-0.024408364668488503,
-0.025553390383720398,
0.595561683177948,
-0.15876655280590057,
0.1729678362607956,
-0.18265968561172485,
0.028801411390304565,
-1.0998116731643677,
-0.060364555567502975,
0.46825146675109863,
-0.4163966476917267,
0.19291748106479645,
-0.014864933677017689,
-0.2476503998041153,
-0.584801435470581,
-0.49224016070365906,
0.5226163268089294,
0.28913137316703796,
-0.25049737095832825,
0.6041402220726013,
0.6578322052955627,
0.02550862729549408,
-0.3492661714553833,
-0.6941669583320618,
0.06162584200501442,
-0.4624568223953247,
-0.26085418462753296,
0.0032057531643658876,
-0.17073547840118408,
-0.41518938541412354,
0.05079139396548271,
0.22208453714847565,
-0.29480981826782227,
-0.03698309138417244,
0.3511894643306732,
0.08205483108758926,
-0.004761330783367157,
0.11795935779809952,
0.0010125996777787805,
0.21026009321212769,
0.1749809831380844,
-0.03376622870564461,
0.7283704876899719,
-0.3965558111667633,
-0.2588118016719818,
-0.15221376717090607,
0.388470321893692,
0.5736361742019653,
0.21869255602359772,
0.6648838520050049,
0.9819471836090088,
-0.36131373047828674,
-0.27786436676979065,
-0.4267129600048065,
-0.06746754795312881,
-0.4642300605773926,
0.24927933514118195,
-0.18830962479114532,
-0.9918145537376404,
0.4191876947879791,
0.21536605060100555,
-0.2383023053407669,
0.48026666045188904,
0.6293549537658691,
0.095205157995224,
0.777592658996582,
0.9333166480064392,
-0.0195396039634943,
0.6983921527862549,
0.17254014313220978,
0.4989997148513794,
-0.4274257719516754,
-0.01725255884230137,
-0.5465279817581177,
0.0016404688358306885,
-1.0467442274093628,
-0.5615134835243225,
0.43906745314598083,
-0.4879484176635742,
-0.10397975891828537,
0.6855296492576599,
-0.5228267312049866,
0.4428228437900543,
0.1454882174730301,
-0.055596332997083664,
-0.02207322232425213,
-0.05281723663210869,
0.16855807602405548,
-0.4119328260421753,
-0.4193764925003052,
-0.40275809168815613,
0.8139450550079346,
0.34344014525413513,
0.6291466951370239,
0.29006272554397583,
0.6025075316429138,
0.8252342343330383,
0.517533540725708,
-0.5510931015014648,
0.7320564389228821,
-0.33432260155677795,
-0.7748709321022034,
-0.3052089810371399,
-0.1544310301542282,
-0.6588597893714905,
0.13683754205703735,
-0.08081459999084473,
-0.6611148715019226,
0.41168543696403503,
-0.18703193962574005,
-0.2112514227628708,
0.6184605956077576,
-0.6781333088874817,
0.4643615484237671,
-0.043296653777360916,
-0.40507590770721436,
-0.17030155658721924,
-0.5271855592727661,
0.25078821182250977,
-0.5861638188362122,
0.5818615555763245,
-0.0579848475754261,
0.049659281969070435,
0.8581663966178894,
-0.03262123093008995,
1.0415664911270142,
-0.2331203818321228,
-0.20820952951908112,
0.23809899389743805,
-0.028447674587368965,
-0.04048381745815277,
-0.30193763971328735,
-0.3557743728160858,
0.157821923494339,
-0.09987042099237442,
-0.2601862847805023,
-0.24082724750041962,
0.5154380202293396,
-0.7870633006095886,
-0.424121618270874,
-0.4861581027507782,
-0.4481760263442993,
-0.3162097930908203,
0.06856675446033478,
0.21850578486919403,
-0.021799704059958458,
-0.28361883759498596,
0.027202943339943886,
0.5832479596138,
-0.3196460008621216,
0.552757203578949,
0.6672388911247253,
-0.30516237020492554,
-0.23414279520511627,
0.7890424132347107,
0.24021826684474945,
0.05831122025847435,
0.12764038145542145,
0.12170509248971939,
-0.4195282459259033,
-0.2576223909854889,
-0.41383281350135803,
0.31313052773475647,
-0.7872600555419922,
-0.09703636914491653,
-0.8357681632041931,
-0.2983132600784302,
-0.835965633392334,
-0.13534978032112122,
-0.21255479753017426,
-0.19028674066066742,
-0.0858268067240715,
0.061908114701509476,
0.2409229278564453,
0.8672124743461609,
-0.07160218805074692,
0.2640376091003418,
-0.5676450133323669,
0.32891330122947693,
0.318955659866333,
0.6084038615226746,
-0.334424763917923,
-0.8585102558135986,
-0.1915094256401062,
-0.17387737333774567,
-0.2505674362182617,
-0.906851589679718,
0.4416767656803131,
0.3257147967815399,
0.37141725420951843,
0.1793348640203476,
0.3085156977176666,
0.3279498815536499,
-0.2849140763282776,
0.6666228175163269,
0.11717608571052551,
-0.9428585171699524,
0.41824615001678467,
-0.39822807908058167,
-0.1684526801109314,
0.32012394070625305,
1.0985357761383057,
-0.7872037887573242,
-0.7515614628791809,
-0.5280333161354065,
-0.6120880246162415,
0.8974674344062805,
0.08714329451322556,
0.1521778404712677,
-0.14238937199115753,
0.11293806880712509,
0.09974244982004166,
0.26724857091903687,
-1.1084460020065308,
-0.12124767154455185,
-0.3702414333820343,
-0.3176572024822235,
0.08814433962106705,
-0.4114494323730469,
0.024624072015285492,
-0.6161219477653503,
0.7949625849723816,
-0.007794354576617479,
0.19909335672855377,
-0.18107080459594727,
-0.19782871007919312,
-0.45753994584083557,
0.4891531467437744,
0.21973657608032227,
0.47586655616760254,
-0.20139677822589874,
0.435161828994751,
0.2777594327926636,
-0.5792868733406067,
0.2195712774991989,
-0.0007156562060117722,
-0.16263256967067719,
0.19098959863185883,
0.19032855331897736,
0.7754132747650146,
-0.09089428186416626,
-0.26610368490219116,
0.5125455260276794,
-0.10870608687400818,
0.15475435554981232,
-0.18750403821468353,
0.0028301700949668884,
-0.10791779309511185,
0.2015198916196823,
0.2670692503452301,
-0.05996708571910858,
0.22840261459350586,
-0.751753032207489,
0.45942214131355286,
0.21847063302993774,
-0.5444580316543579,
-0.5946198105812073,
0.5970044732093811,
0.48982957005500793,
-0.5665264129638672,
0.08887124061584473,
-0.47242262959480286,
-0.8967387676239014,
0.09815102815628052,
0.6059141755104065,
1.0488097667694092,
-0.808574914932251,
0.4806710183620453,
0.22110188007354736,
0.39575740694999695,
0.3163200616836548,
0.35379377007484436,
0.11737892776727676,
-1.0764014720916748,
-0.0948709174990654,
-0.8489695191383362,
-0.1816977858543396,
0.1290218085050583,
-0.49341532588005066,
0.5851317048072815,
-0.6415218114852905,
-0.27539774775505066,
0.32894209027290344,
-0.3208341896533966,
-0.2895446717739105,
0.08868046849966049,
0.6691743731498718,
0.4612131118774414,
-1.4013396501541138,
0.9720925688743591,
0.8342628479003906,
-0.1747012734413147,
-0.27057066559791565,
0.15235349535942078,
0.3672045171260834,
-0.7370831370353699,
0.6172849535942078,
0.00027176240109838545,
-0.5673714280128479,
-0.17856796085834503,
-0.5470076203346252,
-0.49966907501220703,
0.22448141872882843,
0.2115757018327713,
-0.37158986926078796,
0.26434728503227234,
0.5618502497673035,
1.069987177848816,
-0.18646448850631714,
0.3370915949344635,
0.6553664803504944,
0.37858596444129944,
-0.13774102926254272,
-1.1132361888885498,
0.008824377320706844,
-0.6169739961624146,
-0.11883995682001114,
0.4424416720867157,
-0.6908983588218689,
0.9015941023826599,
0.3965114653110504,
-0.4190792143344879,
-0.536228597164154,
0.34956812858581543,
-0.29562076926231384,
0.4976261556148529,
0.8976667523384094,
0.38525155186653137,
0.32970842719078064,
-0.02281367965042591,
0.6666819453239441,
-0.21215087175369263,
0.2527298629283905,
0.6498112082481384,
-0.43556132912635803,
0.6235688328742981,
0.3498358726501465,
-0.36060991883277893,
0.5636582970619202,
0.5073806643486023,
0.09657252579927444,
0.3409607708454132,
0.15508677065372467,
-0.5245790481567383,
-0.3015744984149933,
-0.7555150985717773,
-0.22095930576324463,
0.36658909916877747,
0.4570589065551758,
-0.2016814947128296,
-0.24503202736377716,
0.4023861587047577,
0.012723836116492748,
0.4011380672454834,
-0.1346895843744278,
0.6934095025062561,
-0.020701706409454346,
-0.3108179271221161,
0.8171655535697937,
0.0372312106192112,
1.2926489114761353,
-0.39694270491600037,
0.22842730581760406,
-0.05471799895167351,
0.1678532361984253,
-0.44415608048439026,
-0.9086198806762695,
0.709435760974884,
0.40502655506134033,
-0.20151811838150024,
-0.4722725450992584,
0.8260607719421387,
-0.6336319446563721,
-0.601431131362915,
0.7876914143562317,
0.3622376620769501,
0.24127162992954254,
-0.03506002202630043,
-0.8924505710601807,
0.2595358192920685,
0.0914793312549591,
0.08925259113311768,
0.29731860756874084,
0.5299623608589172,
-0.47345995903015137,
0.49424782395362854,
0.2595568001270294,
-0.14013753831386566,
0.216807022690773,
0.4476441442966461,
1.0225450992584229,
-0.49230432510375977,
-0.4430238902568817,
-0.7007556557655334,
-0.029479913413524628,
0.012876339256763458,
-0.10642847418785095,
0.9681643843650818,
0.4803818166255951,
0.9772397875785828,
-0.023777291178703308,
0.8215698599815369,
-0.24248550832271576,
0.7822261452674866,
0.041473180055618286,
0.5176163911819458,
-0.49143436551094055,
-0.010505851358175278,
-0.8430731296539307,
-0.7505939602851868,
-0.32695716619491577,
0.2692795693874359,
-0.438424676656723,
-0.16274988651275635,
0.7580649256706238,
0.8481111526489258,
-0.2740366756916046,
0.1923590451478958,
0.2947660982608795,
0.1950284242630005,
0.43765127658843994,
0.333911657333374,
0.8269110321998596,
-0.42325904965400696,
0.5556812286376953,
-0.15886496007442474,
-0.06291564553976059,
0.016136638820171356,
-0.4502483308315277,
-0.8180510401725769,
-0.7916819453239441,
-0.5275888442993164,
-0.6178314685821533,
0.02079884149134159,
0.9183952808380127,
0.37471553683280945,
-1.2024484872817993,
-0.38981083035469055,
0.03080607019364834,
0.16930562257766724,
0.4196301996707916,
-0.30613255500793457,
-0.008062650449573994,
-0.046566128730773926,
-0.8686103820800781,
0.18446071445941925,
0.21242660284042358,
-0.07063834369182587,
-0.24255281686782837,
-0.0923769474029541,
-0.7554377913475037,
0.17896248400211334,
0.6824735999107361,
0.16717343032360077,
-0.5502292513847351,
-0.3710285723209381,
-0.12539614737033844,
-0.13876551389694214,
-0.10773774981498718,
0.7686818242073059,
-0.45147570967674255,
0.26067882776260376,
0.5507897734642029,
0.4622523784637451,
0.1593628078699112,
-0.062198419123888016,
0.21185089647769928,
-0.7391815781593323,
0.43577250838279724,
0.3124644160270691,
0.13195189833641052,
0.5711708068847656,
-0.427304744720459,
0.5521905422210693,
0.8053380846977234,
-0.3221854269504547,
-1.0427595376968384,
0.2238379716873169,
-0.5732136964797974,
-0.18772278726100922,
1.4275442361831665,
0.2518458366394043,
-0.33190497756004333,
-0.6721192002296448,
-0.1439705491065979,
0.4750868082046509,
-0.5522091388702393,
0.9641790986061096,
0.6575741171836853,
-0.0715453177690506,
-0.18753592669963837,
-0.14744122326374054,
0.8941566944122314,
0.3488258123397827,
-0.6266408562660217,
-0.0036482438445091248,
0.3262477219104767,
0.18462133407592773,
0.36008426547050476,
0.7288084626197815,
-0.06164601445198059,
0.1281820386648178,
-0.3145045340061188,
0.2808856666088104,
0.36605897545814514,
-0.24602480232715607,
-0.36894142627716064,
0.08394188433885574,
-0.27199050784111023,
-0.13488256931304932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15770v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15770v3 | PILOT: Legal Case Outcome Prediction with Case Law | 2024-01-28T21:18:05 | 2024-04-13T01:59:17 | Lang Cao, Zifeng Wang, Cao Xiao, Jimeng Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine learning shows promise in predicting the outcome of legal cases, but
most research has concentrated on civil law cases rather than case law systems.
We identified two unique challenges in making legal case outcome predictions
with case law. First, it is crucial to identify relevant precedent cases that
serve as fundamental evidence for judges during decision-making. Second, it is
necessary to consider the evolution of legal principles over time, as early
cases may adhere to different legal contexts. In this paper, we proposed a new
framework named PILOT (PredictIng Legal case OuTcome) for case outcome
prediction. It comprises two modules for relevant case retrieval and temporal
pattern handling, respectively. To benchmark the performance of existing legal
case outcome prediction models, we curated a dataset from a large-scale case
law database. We demonstrate the importance of accurately identifying precedent
cases and mitigating the temporal shift when making predictions for case law,
as our method shows a significant improvement over the prior methods that focus
on civil law case outcome predictions. | [
0.11936260014772415,
-0.47073495388031006,
0.9575623869895935,
0.23902970552444458,
-0.3503386676311493,
0.1699748933315277,
0.10334961116313934,
-0.3096013069152832,
0.0972495898604393,
0.5765888690948486,
-0.46074166893959045,
-0.4087221324443817,
-0.4186672866344452,
-0.550180196762085,
-0.6035064458847046,
0.7832574844360352,
0.2629719078540802,
0.4690138101577759,
-0.17109264433383942,
-0.13301722705364227,
-0.8621755838394165,
-0.6976121068000793,
-0.6336815357208252,
-0.26214221119880676,
0.5410177707672119,
0.19933469593524933,
0.36212044954299927,
0.7148939967155457,
0.4711299240589142,
0.12491821497678757,
-0.25464367866516113,
-0.6061508655548096,
-0.08849930763244629,
-0.15356425940990448,
0.2277667373418808,
-0.7713274359703064,
-0.21461009979248047,
-0.10979896038770676,
0.29889553785324097,
0.629856526851654,
-0.535369873046875,
-0.11505618691444397,
-0.39595672488212585,
0.8596633076667786,
-0.6227587461471558,
0.14635078608989716,
-0.6465358138084412,
0.5802953243255615,
-0.38391703367233276,
-0.28121569752693176,
-0.4698163568973541,
-0.3350543677806854,
-0.026226643472909927,
-0.6796112656593323,
0.3741002678871155,
0.34201401472091675,
0.5631493926048279,
0.1858109086751938,
-0.674653172492981,
-0.08906395733356476,
-0.6862649917602539,
0.3356509506702423,
-0.7982125878334045,
0.0701352208852768,
0.08532832562923431,
1.2063612937927246,
-0.3132880926132202,
-0.8362146019935608,
-0.4760104715824127,
-0.40754052996635437,
0.005529970861971378,
0.374738484621048,
0.13447605073451996,
0.06111732870340347,
0.31903988122940063,
-0.114242784678936,
-0.8533636331558228,
0.5109956860542297,
-0.5989482998847961,
-0.24166639149188995,
0.5273410081863403,
0.4413069486618042,
-0.08319114148616791,
-0.09940151870250702,
0.11801648885011673,
0.17230097949504852,
-0.7275171875953674,
0.595615804195404,
0.4818769097328186,
0.49362272024154663,
-0.12579670548439026,
0.662677526473999,
-0.22027795016765594,
0.44208666682243347,
0.058994490653276443,
0.231297567486763,
0.17579779028892517,
0.04892142489552498,
-0.20197449624538422,
0.3549143671989441,
0.3819679915904999,
0.4087529182434082,
0.2626926302909851,
0.18618400394916534,
-0.001033492968417704,
0.03841151297092438,
0.32080262899398804,
-0.4779832065105438,
0.11590750515460968,
0.4308291971683502,
-0.7785386443138123,
-0.5308736562728882,
0.3613891899585724,
-0.5563084483146667,
-0.7707747220993042,
-0.30227112770080566,
-0.09399330615997314,
0.028473347425460815,
-0.15860040485858917,
0.3616988956928253,
-0.3650263249874115,
0.32061588764190674,
0.5162623524665833,
-0.2670212984085083,
0.17108651995658875,
1.1392438411712646,
0.44935113191604614,
0.06486248224973679,
-0.04310079291462898,
-0.9529978632926941,
0.2621375024318695,
-0.3743892312049866,
0.4528287649154663,
-0.6563405990600586,
-0.22259512543678284,
0.3514464497566223,
0.1563556045293808,
0.16517487168312073,
-0.2791295647621155,
0.728001594543457,
-0.5947198271751404,
-0.09052498638629913,
-0.1457023024559021,
-0.6302626132965088,
-0.2069287896156311,
-0.051055870950222015,
-0.6316913366317749,
0.21244503557682037,
-0.10044460743665695,
-0.6319148540496826,
1.3040273189544678,
-0.6184718012809753,
-0.9561129808425903,
0.37548956274986267,
-0.40903276205062866,
-1.0505249500274658,
0.3925294578075409,
-0.0008451594621874392,
0.5360751748085022,
-0.11490882933139801,
0.8211261034011841,
-0.6610729694366455,
-0.41244858503341675,
-0.04428483545780182,
0.052114930003881454,
0.6393703818321228,
0.3229365050792694,
-0.3346262276172638,
0.13098230957984924,
-0.44313013553619385,
-0.23686407506465912,
0.09321807324886322,
-0.21676233410835266,
-0.029725272208452225,
0.48395997285842896,
-0.019535062834620476,
0.13234016299247742,
-0.10662142187356949,
-0.4257599413394928,
0.16179344058036804,
0.21616601943969727,
0.5609077215194702,
0.7482030391693115,
0.06289279460906982,
0.20416028797626495,
-0.5007072687149048,
0.6834141612052917,
0.2303781509399414,
0.4389646351337433,
0.17588916420936584,
-0.6247655153274536,
-0.34113454818725586,
0.07220372557640076,
0.4649972915649414,
0.4945257604122162,
-0.21180860698223114,
0.16977760195732117,
-0.3714678883552551,
-0.38171645998954773,
-0.14378683269023895,
-0.27457183599472046,
0.045562583953142166,
0.08499818295240402,
0.04829150065779686,
-0.21937328577041626,
-0.9496489763259888,
-0.7100910544395447,
-0.5815351009368896,
-0.6347431540489197,
0.27793848514556885,
0.5816290974617004,
0.5312622785568237,
-0.25552597641944885,
0.869140625,
-0.37814781069755554,
-0.308273583650589,
-0.139116108417511,
0.4324983060359955,
0.5864291191101074,
0.40851449966430664,
0.4857438802719116,
-1.041361689567566,
-0.445666640996933,
0.3781318664550781,
-0.6799976825714111,
0.20348995923995972,
-0.505445122718811,
0.03978355601429939,
0.018109191209077835,
0.9002254009246826,
-0.10405092686414719,
0.7654712200164795,
-0.2650986909866333,
-0.6055408120155334,
0.658273458480835,
0.11128731817007065,
0.17227403819561005,
-0.6098002195358276,
-0.08146271109580994,
-0.07040910422801971,
-0.3088777959346771,
-0.4124161899089813,
-0.4012754559516907,
0.1921997368335724,
-0.04542459920048714,
-0.5155048370361328,
0.3145330548286438,
-0.12975142896175385,
-0.40090662240982056,
-0.08080870658159256,
-0.599581778049469,
-0.24328552186489105,
0.1303146630525589,
0.24672549962997437,
0.5154120326042175,
0.28253617882728577,
-0.4374946057796478,
0.10383161902427673,
-0.10779375582933426,
-0.6763814687728882,
0.3686175048351288,
-0.49153706431388855,
-0.2861768901348114,
-0.25048691034317017,
0.0667540654540062,
-0.3390372693538666,
-0.1537036895751953,
-0.22027376294136047,
-0.269516259431839,
0.2873638868331909,
-0.7675662636756897,
-0.3731131851673126,
-0.7460020780563354,
0.025457186624407768,
0.162191241979599,
0.47601553797721863,
-0.05229773744940758,
0.7707383036613464,
0.24353840947151184,
-0.12645642459392548,
-0.4879494905471802,
-0.5005225539207458,
0.03620489314198494,
-0.5875996947288513,
0.09309753775596619,
0.1335344761610031,
0.20907625555992126,
-0.14507067203521729,
0.31009986996650696,
0.038521088659763336,
-0.21876834332942963,
0.35658028721809387,
0.6801967620849609,
0.08630040287971497,
-0.32021620869636536,
0.23699386417865753,
0.3624117970466614,
0.09426411241292953,
0.3479595184326172,
-0.30033084750175476,
0.2632739543914795,
0.19074733555316925,
-0.5562125444412231,
-0.2430666834115982,
0.2938774526119232,
0.7411812543869019,
-0.004836598411202431,
0.38633838295936584,
0.1463616043329239,
-0.41660070419311523,
0.2286795675754547,
-0.8030626773834229,
0.21223793923854828,
-0.36219555139541626,
0.30306485295295715,
-0.5910100340843201,
-0.5849263668060303,
0.4554821252822876,
-0.23356446623802185,
0.22413398325443268,
0.49453434348106384,
0.38344958424568176,
-0.3756100833415985,
0.5929542779922485,
0.7505673766136169,
-0.6101963520050049,
0.905771791934967,
-0.2041972428560257,
-0.017695339396595955,
-0.6039295792579651,
-0.3350415527820587,
-0.46508532762527466,
0.09828006476163864,
-0.3455020785331726,
-0.17100027203559875,
0.316611111164093,
0.0977555587887764,
-0.3454921543598175,
0.5358502268791199,
-0.08654522895812988,
0.32873839139938354,
0.5301254391670227,
0.053802091628313065,
0.33906081318855286,
-0.1256202757358551,
-0.4862825572490692,
0.2154911309480667,
-0.70039302110672,
-0.2276209443807602,
1.625185251235962,
-0.03337270766496658,
0.3064398169517517,
0.029322702437639236,
0.7061421275138855,
0.7594922184944153,
0.3634454905986786,
-0.3246293067932129,
0.20864103734493256,
-0.11604844778776169,
-0.661937415599823,
-0.13366104662418365,
-0.3916594386100769,
-1.1136469841003418,
-0.07324507087469101,
-0.44534832239151,
-0.5347696542739868,
0.10020708292722702,
-0.1970052421092987,
-0.6472727656364441,
-0.0664014220237732,
-0.3537070155143738,
0.6656036376953125,
-0.3362361788749695,
-0.314214825630188,
-0.48796164989471436,
-0.7467825412750244,
0.10877028852701187,
-0.16218164563179016,
0.3831360638141632,
-0.2708928883075714,
0.43400415778160095,
0.6114364266395569,
-0.5037420988082886,
0.6756737232208252,
-0.3779751658439636,
0.6338991522789001,
0.36336183547973633,
-0.03417407348752022,
0.46816521883010864,
0.3008478581905365,
-0.2124989628791809,
-0.20394381880760193,
0.21349041163921356,
-0.2677469551563263,
-0.5715972185134888,
0.5581152439117432,
-0.5121640563011169,
-0.6678555011749268,
-0.6682446002960205,
-0.2724660634994507,
0.13348475098609924,
0.1301460713148117,
0.05157234147191048,
0.21775245666503906,
-0.42564576864242554,
0.11040154099464417,
-0.11882388591766357,
0.023045893758535385,
0.5244100093841553,
0.8875428438186646,
-0.04104195535182953,
-0.2573072612285614,
0.5210248231887817,
0.051224853843450546,
-0.5058935284614563,
0.5390792489051819,
0.5313606858253479,
-0.30008724331855774,
-0.8920449614524841,
-0.2748089134693146,
-0.16323065757751465,
-0.49960315227508545,
-0.22123336791992188,
-0.5534695982933044,
-0.06860460340976715,
-0.49893099069595337,
-0.3750380873680115,
-0.16064463555812836,
-0.3607034981250763,
-0.07432076334953308,
-0.04119179770350456,
0.26941826939582825,
0.6524636745452881,
0.25573617219924927,
0.05494061857461929,
-0.4002632796764374,
-0.03199601173400879,
0.15103279054164886,
0.32842138409614563,
-0.4334716796875,
-0.5212996006011963,
-0.24652184545993805,
-0.29632246494293213,
-0.11321910470724106,
-0.3855297863483429,
0.11925368010997772,
0.1301945596933365,
0.6815347671508789,
0.5359875559806824,
0.04967459291219711,
0.7468143701553345,
-0.9346156716346741,
0.46984046697616577,
0.23814724385738373,
-0.5737050771713257,
1.0192590951919556,
-0.2559293508529663,
-0.201646089553833,
0.6680822968482971,
0.05532020330429077,
-0.4129142165184021,
-0.12487517297267914,
-0.6570546627044678,
-0.4658830463886261,
0.364796906709671,
0.27142465114593506,
-0.2933960556983948,
0.4329891502857208,
0.7125526070594788,
0.3082250952720642,
0.4527987241744995,
-0.3109916150569916,
0.3391335904598236,
-0.15893404185771942,
0.0173165462911129,
-0.3324934244155884,
0.08238380402326584,
0.12651103734970093,
-0.636046290397644,
0.3757238984107971,
-0.15940970182418823,
0.36831527948379517,
-0.12682300806045532,
-0.08535186201334,
-0.04341309890151024,
0.009336229413747787,
0.5887498259544373,
0.5572214722633362,
-0.2531241476535797,
-0.5239028334617615,
-0.08517928421497345,
-0.20158766210079193,
0.22677193582057953,
0.10283966362476349,
-0.08707315474748611,
-0.007329835556447506,
0.5785556435585022,
0.6830008029937744,
-0.022253990173339844,
-0.6128478646278381,
0.5733983516693115,
-0.19036756455898285,
-0.25110775232315063,
-0.9929822087287903,
-0.09074847400188446,
-0.1587029993534088,
0.5371307134628296,
0.3517562747001648,
0.09054815769195557,
0.5812723636627197,
-0.61878502368927,
0.34353846311569214,
0.2536306381225586,
-0.4354172945022583,
0.06781801581382751,
0.9275956749916077,
0.18017719686031342,
-0.14003397524356842,
0.40702497959136963,
0.014189423993229866,
-0.40246251225471497,
1.2147012948989868,
0.05424788221716881,
0.9043839573860168,
0.3295412063598633,
-0.018624838441610336,
0.010169870220124722,
-0.06930151581764221,
-0.3601238429546356,
0.42270416021347046,
0.033632196485996246,
-0.4057502746582031,
-0.41055580973625183,
-0.3039226233959198,
-0.4738411605358124,
0.005677691660821438,
-0.9060648679733276,
0.4844647943973541,
-0.6293064951896667,
-0.37584787607192993,
-0.02784651331603527,
0.24596716463565826,
-0.8078947067260742,
0.09402225911617279,
-0.06876813620328903,
0.9653136134147644,
-0.9922517538070679,
0.9535969495773315,
0.6721111536026001,
-0.167777881026268,
-0.2873634994029999,
0.08731787651777267,
0.3503783941268921,
-0.5139110088348389,
0.602140486240387,
0.3452579081058502,
0.21070359647274017,
-0.4170764684677124,
-0.09176322817802429,
-0.32060712575912476,
1.1976783275604248,
0.08758629113435745,
-0.9666922092437744,
0.0730442926287651,
0.0715218037366867,
0.4054761230945587,
-0.5134470462799072,
-0.10899098217487335,
0.5454002618789673,
0.28931692242622375,
0.19250935316085815,
-0.6157495975494385,
0.027161546051502228,
-0.2898452579975128,
0.20749925076961517,
0.17852617800235748,
-0.21747851371765137,
0.6092466711997986,
-0.47257429361343384,
-0.021142039448022842,
0.24124152958393097,
0.7401829957962036,
0.13206377625465393,
0.8882398009300232,
0.5093767642974854,
0.5089725852012634,
0.7058858275413513,
-0.40928488969802856,
1.226251482963562,
-0.3838520050048828,
0.17951539158821106,
1.0307363271713257,
-0.5648903250694275,
0.655321478843689,
0.5105476975440979,
-0.2419314682483673,
0.5105543732643127,
0.7003449201583862,
-0.17770709097385406,
0.8030264377593994,
0.48090746998786926,
0.0509025901556015,
-0.42512401938438416,
0.16163553297519684,
-0.39769452810287476,
0.25729233026504517,
0.17966745793819427,
-0.2085234522819519,
0.2942522168159485,
0.07775172591209412,
-0.29628607630729675,
0.17404255270957947,
-0.3198627233505249,
0.7556479573249817,
-0.28380030393600464,
-0.6077627539634705,
-0.2587592601776123,
-0.10810135304927826,
0.2376125007867813,
-0.2027677744626999,
-0.2665620446205139,
-0.22275544703006744,
0.4155021905899048,
-0.0733693391084671,
-0.7752863764762878,
0.16775844991207123,
-0.42767664790153503,
-0.3139021098613739,
-0.008550754748284817,
0.3364681005477905,
0.1477852761745453,
-0.6424769163131714,
0.42690181732177734,
0.3567107915878296,
-0.10810526460409164,
-0.2264464646577835,
-0.758976399898529,
-0.030335642397403717,
-0.3396652042865753,
0.03400970995426178,
0.1530384123325348,
0.5542382001876831,
-0.4043862521648407,
0.7905441522598267,
0.6912392377853394,
0.3236794173717499,
0.24397386610507965,
0.20879901945590973,
0.8855984807014465,
-0.9510128498077393,
-0.6905493140220642,
-0.6225828528404236,
0.4412102699279785,
-0.3306366205215454,
-0.2770603597164154,
-0.024061324074864388,
0.7742711305618286,
0.5525946021080017,
-0.14606861770153046,
0.8546426296234131,
-0.10922504961490631,
0.48839476704597473,
-0.7317863702774048,
0.4428599774837494,
-0.4597941040992737,
0.14949800074100494,
-0.0599820651113987,
-0.39530232548713684,
-0.3364678621292114,
0.3399089574813843,
-0.2797303795814514,
-0.06488797068595886,
0.6550381183624268,
0.444173663854599,
-0.053094249218702316,
-0.008891317993402481,
0.3299335241317749,
-0.21735745668411255,
0.4279339611530304,
0.671386182308197,
0.6397314071655273,
-0.28759443759918213,
0.48723822832107544,
-0.04574928805232048,
-0.11032775044441223,
-0.8675654530525208,
-0.7984609007835388,
-0.9393702149391174,
-0.26108676195144653,
-0.2504822015762329,
-0.1365879476070404,
0.5429123044013977,
0.4826067388057709,
0.8845990896224976,
-1.0559426546096802,
-0.3668624758720398,
-0.5510134100914001,
0.1070801317691803,
-0.6090909242630005,
-0.2077070027589798,
0.1831163763999939,
-0.3208160996437073,
-0.16801224648952484,
0.3916122019290924,
0.16398723423480988,
0.12185212224721909,
0.3733382523059845,
-0.1960025131702423,
-0.13701340556144714,
-0.16480819880962372,
0.41405898332595825,
0.5121935606002808,
-0.8215399980545044,
-0.2863260507583618,
-0.4429711699485779,
0.085635706782341,
0.0733950287103653,
1.5685765743255615,
-0.680837094783783,
0.37074539065361023,
0.06132996082305908,
0.5700937509536743,
0.9124615788459778,
-0.20172908902168274,
1.0050727128982544,
-0.46912482380867004,
0.333305686712265,
0.33994197845458984,
0.8704345226287842,
-0.2986499071121216,
-0.5123654007911682,
0.6603339910507202,
0.21997083723545074,
-0.21025949716567993,
-0.583575963973999,
0.21410006284713745,
-0.7749233841896057,
-0.4163776636123657,
0.5476412177085876,
-0.2916109263896942,
-0.1207185834646225,
-0.34096190333366394,
0.023751866072416306,
0.20860221982002258,
-0.5569692850112915,
0.8051186203956604,
0.5253515243530273,
-0.0041215685196220875,
-0.3772123157978058,
-0.9103981852531433,
0.14467547833919525,
0.42705661058425903,
-0.6052142381668091,
-0.08001625537872314,
0.5340582728385925,
0.3168954849243164,
-0.1398373395204544,
0.32697197794914246,
-0.25409823656082153,
0.5992190837860107,
-0.10507287085056305,
0.0016312857624143362,
-0.21012836694717407,
-0.48674502968788147,
-0.41118666529655457,
0.10704648494720459,
-0.1322302520275116,
-0.1587432324886322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15724v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15724v3 | RE-GAINS & EnChAnT: Intelligent Tool Manipulation Systems For Enhanced Query Responses | 2024-01-28T18:26:31 | 2024-06-20T10:47:47 | Sahil Girhepuje, Siva Sankar Sajeev, Purvam Jain, Arya Sikder, Adithya Rama Varma, Ryan George, Akshay Govind Srinivasan, Mahendra Kurup, Ashmit Sinha, Sudip Mondal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) currently struggle with tool invocation and
chaining, as they often hallucinate or miss essential steps in a sequence. We
propose RE-GAINS and EnChAnT, two novel frameworks that empower LLMs to tackle
complex user queries by making API calls to external tools based on tool
descriptions and argument lists. Tools are chained based on the expected
output, without receiving the actual results from each individual call.
EnChAnT, an open-source solution, leverages an LLM format enforcer, OpenChat
3.5 (an LLM), and ToolBench's API Retriever. RE-GAINS utilizes OpenAI models
and embeddings with a specialized prompt based on the $\underline{R}$easoning
vi$\underline{a}$ $\underline{P}$lanning $(RAP)$ framework. Both frameworks are
low cost (0.01\$ per query). Our key contribution is enabling LLMs for tool
invocation and chaining using modifiable, externally described tools. | [
-0.13874484598636627,
-0.976332426071167,
0.39786452054977417,
0.18408022820949554,
-0.12047421187162399,
0.44600075483322144,
-0.1416095644235611,
-0.5024327039718628,
0.6212120056152344,
0.6286368370056152,
-0.7339887619018555,
-0.3615333139896393,
-0.27962028980255127,
0.003809290938079357,
-0.5849303603172302,
0.5961272120475769,
-0.013335928320884705,
-0.11565161496400833,
-0.16690735518932343,
0.006351586896926165,
-0.37983909249305725,
-0.41883277893066406,
-0.7327377200126648,
-0.23893475532531738,
0.748815655708313,
0.1740090250968933,
0.9102389216423035,
0.35323089361190796,
0.6146758794784546,
0.3432007133960724,
0.291113018989563,
0.4657187759876251,
-0.48869413137435913,
0.6105486750602722,
-0.35393500328063965,
-0.7739217877388,
-0.5313191413879395,
-0.1685114949941635,
0.1753341555595398,
0.5939821004867554,
-0.16100738942623138,
0.12943749129772186,
0.04326945170760155,
0.33047929406166077,
-0.712706983089447,
-0.23554857075214386,
-0.9020543098449707,
-0.1328984797000885,
-0.2908570468425751,
-0.4601297974586487,
-0.4923529028892517,
-0.4837283790111542,
0.03156580775976181,
-0.5469461679458618,
-0.15616320073604584,
0.329333633184433,
0.6272091865539551,
0.3306070566177368,
-0.17341536283493042,
-0.36513304710388184,
-0.554286003112793,
0.6499951481819153,
-0.9320107102394104,
0.7166885137557983,
0.4829096496105194,
0.36201632022857666,
-0.6271911263465881,
-1.2137393951416016,
-0.29912126064300537,
-0.22511664032936096,
-0.17241020500659943,
0.04769781976938248,
-0.08803073316812515,
-0.056016724556684494,
0.3312704563140869,
0.28812965750694275,
-0.31633156538009644,
0.19835880398750305,
-0.2195187658071518,
-0.0457986518740654,
0.6528290510177612,
0.369333952665329,
0.3186914324760437,
0.3585669994354248,
-0.3035818338394165,
0.07990046590566635,
-1.1412532329559326,
0.001122129731811583,
0.49968940019607544,
0.43729984760284424,
0.02181820012629032,
0.8517276644706726,
-0.07785657048225403,
0.7864490747451782,
0.16158775985240936,
0.10102467238903046,
-0.049601711332798004,
-0.1359998732805252,
-0.3907049000263214,
-0.19339725375175476,
0.7742367386817932,
0.22194568812847137,
0.18771152198314667,
-0.6337316036224365,
-0.4233618974685669,
-0.5797742009162903,
0.2219824194908142,
-0.9299585223197937,
-0.11834163218736649,
0.23635528981685638,
-0.40106698870658875,
-0.2216775119304657,
0.2793716788291931,
-0.6474053263664246,
-0.7708009481430054,
-0.37150999903678894,
0.45977941155433655,
-0.11181986331939697,
-0.32737424969673157,
0.1522003710269928,
-0.24891047179698944,
0.2347768247127533,
0.37920844554901123,
-0.6657530665397644,
0.383917897939682,
0.7524401545524597,
0.9502981901168823,
-0.2165459841489792,
-0.11037957668304443,
-0.7918484807014465,
0.20182669162750244,
-0.1642305999994278,
0.6223490834236145,
-1.0371190309524536,
-0.47007492184638977,
0.15285153687000275,
0.41586264967918396,
0.14111670851707458,
-0.5042247772216797,
0.30319008231163025,
-1.0665749311447144,
0.08836843073368073,
-0.4231680929660797,
-0.4048443138599396,
-0.09327064454555511,
0.3020412027835846,
-0.6957607865333557,
0.9487151503562927,
-0.11434537917375565,
-0.6867450475692749,
0.30689650774002075,
-0.6093538403511047,
-0.5024943351745605,
-0.10199635475873947,
-0.07610878348350525,
0.10974929481744766,
0.06309183686971664,
0.2231626659631729,
0.1819000393152237,
-0.665946900844574,
-0.12456795573234558,
-0.7092547416687012,
-0.4187799394130707,
0.21717441082000732,
-0.40997612476348877,
0.5937180519104004,
-0.019926492124795914,
-0.03909619152545929,
0.5049303770065308,
-0.4988287389278412,
0.09103042632341385,
0.16214971244335175,
-0.6160415410995483,
-0.436876505613327,
0.17278891801834106,
-0.14173342287540436,
-0.028841964900493622,
0.3941556513309479,
-0.8341919183731079,
0.49819958209991455,
-0.8362369537353516,
0.3266098201274872,
0.8140632510185242,
-0.08358565717935562,
0.2664739787578583,
-0.0836462527513504,
0.6868260502815247,
-0.29665425419807434,
-0.2072688639163971,
-0.13530486822128296,
-0.17057999968528748,
-0.6536149382591248,
-0.09905464947223663,
0.27365607023239136,
0.6829172372817993,
-0.8793874382972717,
0.17941594123840332,
-0.19287143647670746,
-0.635269284248352,
-0.6770115494728088,
0.233888179063797,
0.11826195567846298,
0.2734415531158447,
0.2150038331747055,
-0.3096672594547272,
-0.5817363262176514,
-0.8358219861984253,
-0.800810694694519,
-0.08134512603282928,
-0.4614929258823395,
0.24037860333919525,
0.1456255167722702,
-0.18495982885360718,
0.9650048017501831,
-0.503795325756073,
0.007480147294700146,
0.025353599339723587,
0.0033494969829916954,
0.3048992455005646,
0.24285872280597687,
0.2703648805618286,
-0.7869084477424622,
-0.3554461598396301,
0.07197984308004379,
-0.5579333305358887,
-0.12625953555107117,
-0.10928954929113388,
-0.4305219352245331,
-0.07656214386224747,
0.7519896030426025,
-0.604944109916687,
0.4469338655471802,
-0.039686646312475204,
-0.15210388600826263,
0.719537079334259,
0.15774211287498474,
0.08321182429790497,
-1.0008760690689087,
-0.0005153042729943991,
-0.11122198402881622,
-0.5317175984382629,
-0.2842828333377838,
0.303209513425827,
-0.09656001627445221,
0.17133960127830505,
-0.477333128452301,
0.6768021583557129,
-0.357126384973526,
-0.16679084300994873,
-0.3434809446334839,
0.16898113489151,
-0.0979490578174591,
0.41858917474746704,
-0.266853928565979,
0.7427300810813904,
0.4491005539894104,
-0.46434563398361206,
1.007627010345459,
0.008524030447006226,
0.1591232866048813,
0.44975942373275757,
-1.0437928438186646,
0.47608596086502075,
0.2717873156070709,
0.219195157289505,
-0.8852463960647583,
-0.3304922878742218,
0.422942191362381,
-0.43456876277923584,
0.20640090107917786,
-0.3460376262664795,
-0.857123613357544,
-0.3542737364768982,
-0.642450749874115,
0.19124549627304077,
0.18054354190826416,
-0.882800817489624,
0.9653946757316589,
0.16390320658683777,
-0.16139961779117584,
-0.5435753464698792,
-0.7868906855583191,
0.10089264065027237,
-0.2041681557893753,
-0.6856420636177063,
0.21825507283210754,
-0.10368974506855011,
-0.2763310670852661,
-0.04540370777249336,
-0.10710286349058151,
0.0005292164860293269,
-0.07498188316822052,
0.30229032039642334,
0.025576429441571236,
-0.20975974202156067,
0.5086869597434998,
0.11701120436191559,
0.20048880577087402,
0.23849493265151978,
-0.23462337255477905,
0.8068838119506836,
-0.14633795619010925,
-1.0613189935684204,
-0.10619128495454788,
0.24103517830371857,
0.7572755217552185,
-0.6715163588523865,
0.4207793176174164,
0.6830598711967468,
-0.39214685559272766,
0.05245262756943703,
-0.5264601707458496,
-0.5227033495903015,
-0.5906298160552979,
0.3197603225708008,
-0.7199113965034485,
-0.8755905032157898,
0.6356355547904968,
-0.4301739037036896,
0.7754669189453125,
0.08507012575864792,
0.7328392863273621,
0.14466281235218048,
1.2442576885223389,
0.3254856467247009,
-0.1105329692363739,
0.47247791290283203,
-0.0397920124232769,
0.2689799666404724,
-0.8077709674835205,
-0.11698385328054428,
-0.2429882138967514,
-0.6158084869384766,
-0.41274699568748474,
-0.12384673207998276,
0.12619780004024506,
0.10892050713300705,
-0.44098594784736633,
0.19478099048137665,
-0.3904903829097748,
0.47894933819770813,
0.6361495852470398,
0.13722194731235504,
0.37152886390686035,
0.26933568716049194,
-0.11095951497554779,
0.0674106702208519,
-0.498008131980896,
-0.23467612266540527,
1.017652153968811,
0.29975801706314087,
1.5162159204483032,
0.37804847955703735,
0.48682478070259094,
0.25296467542648315,
0.31429216265678406,
-1.1128721237182617,
0.5587268471717834,
0.14947229623794556,
-0.26215532422065735,
-0.3039266765117645,
-0.19174990057945251,
-1.0877536535263062,
0.4920644760131836,
0.1041099950671196,
-0.7707192301750183,
0.40834736824035645,
-0.043121032416820526,
-0.3137705624103546,
0.7364128828048706,
-0.6074927449226379,
0.22781692445278168,
-0.3531063497066498,
-0.8655063509941101,
-0.0317901149392128,
-0.49264106154441833,
0.25992605090141296,
0.05149957910180092,
-0.05622496455907822,
0.12506188452243805,
-0.27008363604545593,
0.4409671127796173,
-0.5075200200080872,
0.9785996079444885,
-0.16448350250720978,
-0.27933236956596375,
0.24106226861476898,
0.6582818627357483,
0.7992014288902283,
0.12030328065156937,
-0.2717258930206299,
-0.4421493709087372,
0.02157663367688656,
-0.02785392850637436,
-0.985430121421814,
0.8482632040977478,
-0.379680871963501,
-0.890143096446991,
0.12882091104984283,
-0.5170812010765076,
-0.1570885181427002,
0.3701232671737671,
-0.09659720957279205,
0.7479769587516785,
0.22489875555038452,
0.42187801003456116,
0.17102326452732086,
-0.19461588561534882,
0.19698220491409302,
0.6784460544586182,
-0.5317596793174744,
-0.13115018606185913,
0.8262824416160583,
0.019998613744974136,
0.4159790277481079,
0.18330474197864532,
0.03582948446273804,
-0.4234961271286011,
-0.09586574137210846,
-0.4777553379535675,
0.2184106856584549,
-0.6676952838897705,
-0.4621376097202301,
-0.5728569030761719,
0.025236614048480988,
-0.4422556459903717,
-0.15771929919719696,
-0.34492117166519165,
-0.2833903431892395,
-0.10289602726697922,
-0.15797391533851624,
0.7862776517868042,
0.6159365177154541,
0.04526907578110695,
0.2650889754295349,
-0.5967998504638672,
0.16650089621543884,
0.21080105006694794,
0.5435208082199097,
0.15105366706848145,
-0.32218417525291443,
-0.10383283346891403,
0.2728325426578522,
-0.5100849270820618,
-0.9672642350196838,
0.5097262859344482,
0.2313835769891739,
0.28084152936935425,
0.2985747456550598,
0.3866029679775238,
0.7933238744735718,
-0.37737739086151123,
0.7653263211250305,
-0.061741624027490616,
-0.6734891533851624,
0.6585167050361633,
-0.2676209807395935,
-0.006631135940551758,
0.1782807558774948,
0.3689993917942047,
-0.6363517642021179,
-0.5271889567375183,
-0.2394934445619583,
-1.2215334177017212,
0.657331645488739,
-0.27108681201934814,
0.12605850398540497,
-0.08322752267122269,
0.2985648214817047,
0.10146810859441757,
0.2091076672077179,
-0.4640869200229645,
0.07035769522190094,
-0.016197217628359795,
-0.11096855998039246,
0.7529968619346619,
0.08721844106912613,
-0.3120407462120056,
-0.19271746277809143,
0.5282833576202393,
-0.3054838180541992,
0.04559139162302017,
0.23592029511928558,
-0.21868768334388733,
-0.1521155685186386,
0.27476269006729126,
0.03208831697702408,
0.7116207480430603,
-0.1826765537261963,
0.1205420196056366,
0.4194141924381256,
-0.1398380845785141,
-0.0801975280046463,
-0.002102060243487358,
0.15441244840621948,
-0.2468404322862625,
0.3020540177822113,
0.5372665524482727,
0.3760465681552887,
-0.773638129234314,
0.18228080868721008,
-0.08832769840955734,
0.19304391741752625,
-0.25633350014686584,
-0.04336105287075043,
0.2460603564977646,
0.4394434094429016,
0.09437026083469391,
-0.2286343276500702,
0.3378964960575104,
-0.46082955598831177,
0.1496354043483734,
0.49838006496429443,
-0.4010254740715027,
-0.38628390431404114,
0.6599106192588806,
0.26263749599456787,
-0.6183870434761047,
0.6221486330032349,
-0.0277792289853096,
-0.17727839946746826,
0.3599737584590912,
0.7299029231071472,
0.8262232542037964,
-0.02428186871111393,
-0.19016319513320923,
0.14809824526309967,
0.28755491971969604,
0.07319829612970352,
0.36607062816619873,
0.06326243281364441,
-0.5478479862213135,
-0.43523940443992615,
-0.4816518723964691,
-0.465474933385849,
-0.1564875841140747,
-0.6748469471931458,
0.381442129611969,
-0.5260690450668335,
-0.16467837989330292,
-0.2774692475795746,
-0.4539046883583069,
-0.7479068636894226,
-0.3353111743927002,
-0.5492191314697266,
1.1790926456451416,
-0.21843358874320984,
0.5099380612373352,
0.9085890650749207,
-0.6763260364532471,
-0.6831986904144287,
-0.07934105396270752,
0.1900898963212967,
-0.745983898639679,
0.6505171060562134,
-0.03625046834349632,
-0.6062631607055664,
0.10245335102081299,
-0.8282831311225891,
-0.7595549821853638,
1.0235233306884766,
0.49932584166526794,
-0.3838711380958557,
-0.10627508908510208,
-0.09706229716539383,
0.2415516972541809,
-0.2999522089958191,
0.42383772134780884,
0.7136276960372925,
0.5607559084892273,
0.2457738220691681,
-0.8879727125167847,
0.31716179847717285,
-0.25937771797180176,
-0.2973119020462036,
0.3188497722148895,
-0.47143393754959106,
0.6658355593681335,
-0.13646486401557922,
-0.4544678330421448,
0.20841066539287567,
0.4496750235557556,
0.23359838128089905,
0.041273877024650574,
0.42541810870170593,
0.4930884540081024,
0.6616198420524597,
-0.12124498188495636,
1.236197590827942,
-0.24926306307315826,
0.030021363869309425,
1.2884477376937866,
-0.32531946897506714,
1.0177396535873413,
0.3780943751335144,
-0.31441164016723633,
0.4717366099357605,
0.7646673917770386,
0.07558070123195648,
0.2115389108657837,
0.3413310647010803,
-0.15560300648212433,
-0.3322199881076813,
-0.1819959580898285,
-0.466668039560318,
0.27397096157073975,
0.5402087569236755,
-0.3176616132259369,
-0.2998667061328888,
-0.09657882899045944,
0.10364280641078949,
-0.15177492797374725,
-0.05298314988613129,
0.7366398572921753,
0.20828354358673096,
-0.45896387100219727,
0.5234104990959167,
0.1185511127114296,
1.0691003799438477,
-0.7644326090812683,
-0.09953757375478745,
-0.09594762325286865,
0.19152145087718964,
-0.3881252706050873,
-0.8116945624351501,
0.35935884714126587,
-0.16557100415229797,
-0.036069098860025406,
-0.06950201839208603,
1.1528133153915405,
-0.4815463423728943,
-0.47651538252830505,
0.44958609342575073,
0.485419899225235,
0.13617707788944244,
-0.22265589237213135,
-0.6768693923950195,
-0.020834697410464287,
-0.11088641732931137,
-0.3770160377025604,
0.07975061982870102,
0.4790521264076233,
-0.050523191690444946,
0.9947870969772339,
0.8902272582054138,
0.16858674585819244,
0.15167519450187683,
0.3926687240600586,
1.1195639371871948,
-0.5303860902786255,
-0.1695815473794937,
-0.9699099063873291,
0.3476564288139343,
-0.12101071327924728,
0.04218444600701332,
0.9096484780311584,
0.5133985877037048,
0.651691734790802,
0.01463807001709938,
0.5882735252380371,
-0.049903515726327896,
0.6425367593765259,
-0.4281160235404968,
0.7356058359146118,
-0.8849626779556274,
0.5440496206283569,
-0.08878928422927856,
-0.6509814262390137,
-0.20706602931022644,
0.15317565202713013,
-0.3927551805973053,
0.0415269210934639,
0.09652867168188095,
1.2565289735794067,
-0.22889159619808197,
0.019048497080802917,
0.04612411931157112,
0.19664797186851501,
0.8711268305778503,
0.13843195140361786,
0.8408581614494324,
-0.037964485585689545,
0.45808082818984985,
0.361832857131958,
-0.08866751194000244,
-0.2003408968448639,
-0.4054790437221527,
-0.6533036828041077,
-0.18259936571121216,
0.12346044182777405,
-0.19359427690505981,
0.06070792302489281,
1.3131954669952393,
0.7151618003845215,
-0.5863383412361145,
-0.3664778470993042,
0.10658172518014908,
0.34637585282325745,
0.02408028393983841,
-0.29963982105255127,
0.3272179663181305,
-0.565044641494751,
-0.6416009664535522,
0.63255375623703,
0.28706514835357666,
-0.21541477739810944,
-0.5007133483886719,
-0.09564662724733353,
-0.18889637291431427,
0.13259664177894592,
0.8799896240234375,
0.34121569991111755,
-1.0631648302078247,
-0.1804674118757248,
0.13449682295322418,
0.3699372410774231,
-0.15734142065048218,
1.0193099975585938,
-1.042015552520752,
0.6402357220649719,
0.7216614484786987,
0.9508184194564819,
0.11521512269973755,
-0.002851713914424181,
0.8597792983055115,
-1.0638200044631958,
0.014228816144168377,
0.11102112382650375,
0.40133655071258545,
0.25072920322418213,
-0.352237731218338,
0.6671656966209412,
0.10593970865011215,
-0.31761929392814636,
-0.8931592106819153,
0.5491806864738464,
-0.4905657172203064,
-0.11685770750045776,
0.9192427396774292,
-0.1363832950592041,
-0.026475023478269577,
-0.19696979224681854,
-0.4658770263195038,
0.011166826821863651,
-0.502156674861908,
0.36173221468925476,
0.49439916014671326,
-0.25685372948646545,
-0.11777091026306152,
-0.5102219581604004,
0.14094792306423187,
0.25746020674705505,
-0.7588628530502319,
0.2808206081390381,
0.4064457416534424,
0.24322155117988586,
0.15447303652763367,
0.272004634141922,
-0.4396502673625946,
0.029761560261249542,
-0.27169671654701233,
-0.024150824174284935,
-0.303057461977005,
-0.15549007058143616,
0.1952478438615799,
0.015132439322769642,
0.12998220324516296,
-0.17975762486457825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15717v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15717v1 | Check News in One Click: NLP-Empowered Pro-Kremlin Propaganda Detection | 2024-01-28T17:51:47 | 2024-01-28T17:51:47 | Veronika Solopova, Viktoriia Herman, Christoph Benzmüller, Tim Landgraf | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many European citizens become targets of the Kremlin propaganda campaigns,
aiming to minimise public support for Ukraine, foster a climate of mistrust and
disunity, and shape elections (Meister, 2022). To address this challenge, we
developed ''Check News in 1 Click'', the first NLP-empowered pro-Kremlin
propaganda detection application available in 7 languages, which provides the
lay user with feedback on their news, and explains manipulative linguistic
features and keywords. We conducted a user study, analysed user entries and
models' behaviour paired with questionnaire answers, and investigated the
advantages and disadvantages of the proposed interpretative solution. | [
-0.4002583920955658,
-0.5681001543998718,
0.4682042598724365,
0.44893723726272583,
-0.7002211213111877,
0.07887924462556839,
-0.04369896277785301,
-0.2546093165874481,
0.3427477180957794,
0.7102120518684387,
-0.7948907613754272,
-0.735565185546875,
-0.5222206115722656,
0.23574355244636536,
-0.7157751321792603,
0.9399473667144775,
0.06272220611572266,
0.2688165009021759,
-0.17325371503829956,
0.022704362869262695,
0.15977466106414795,
-0.1978820264339447,
-0.5357459783554077,
-0.16801244020462036,
0.3669610917568207,
0.6040429472923279,
0.771618127822876,
0.06507870554924011,
0.45825570821762085,
0.28095757961273193,
-0.01067750807851553,
-0.0966215506196022,
-0.21676331758499146,
-0.3127199113368988,
-0.21415336430072784,
-0.7118093967437744,
-0.0568857304751873,
0.20342619717121124,
0.46815863251686096,
0.17289815843105316,
-0.000854450510814786,
0.42144346237182617,
0.19342613220214844,
0.755155622959137,
-0.3261299133300781,
-0.19517463445663452,
-0.4425235688686371,
-0.026285380125045776,
-0.3683996796607971,
-0.18067528307437897,
-0.4191308915615082,
-0.47108909487724304,
0.0665530413389206,
-0.5781771540641785,
0.0729513168334961,
-0.1792801022529602,
0.842878520488739,
0.22124534845352173,
-0.6555020809173584,
-0.343177855014801,
-0.36625686287879944,
0.7556886076927185,
-0.41069355607032776,
0.551772952079773,
0.4874255061149597,
0.06873848289251328,
-0.24982856214046478,
-0.5254713892936707,
-0.5441128015518188,
-0.21601548790931702,
-0.2698683738708496,
0.3406508266925812,
-0.48195141553878784,
-0.34521353244781494,
-0.20852607488632202,
-0.1777842491865158,
-0.6351053714752197,
-0.03326236456632614,
-0.3916153907775879,
-0.6007688641548157,
0.39960765838623047,
-0.15681137144565582,
0.15271775424480438,
-0.5499499440193176,
-0.8165973424911499,
0.297331303358078,
-0.4781138300895691,
0.11782956123352051,
0.795595109462738,
0.057573024183511734,
-0.2552572190761566,
0.46463972330093384,
-0.6881911158561707,
0.8096119165420532,
0.31852486729621887,
-0.22175948321819305,
-0.04617118835449219,
-0.3168511688709259,
0.021138256415724754,
0.2261883169412613,
0.7098842859268188,
0.4668727219104767,
0.11578261852264404,
0.18376630544662476,
0.09105205535888672,
0.2769879102706909,
0.3531627357006073,
-0.7281792759895325,
-0.07916641980409622,
0.5753060579299927,
-0.6074251532554626,
-0.7547703981399536,
0.15472936630249023,
-0.8930292129516602,
-0.2684170603752136,
-0.1598135083913803,
0.5314868092536926,
-0.38397544622421265,
-0.27510979771614075,
0.664251446723938,
0.12258593738079071,
-0.2553792893886566,
0.3058012127876282,
-0.5009452700614929,
0.16979648172855377,
0.3848779797554016,
0.6260676383972168,
-0.07155288010835648,
-0.19280873239040375,
-0.9079053997993469,
-0.6654773950576782,
-0.08155029267072678,
0.9109488129615784,
-0.22558598220348358,
-0.2583601474761963,
0.4555641710758209,
0.06913972645998001,
0.40462541580200195,
-0.46895793080329895,
0.6823202967643738,
-0.7868683338165283,
0.42460501194000244,
-0.19987645745277405,
-0.18818151950836182,
-0.14056648313999176,
0.34271708130836487,
-0.640205979347229,
0.921176016330719,
0.09545783698558807,
-0.8858224153518677,
0.7335382103919983,
-0.45883652567863464,
-0.3461126983165741,
0.23238006234169006,
0.2932387888431549,
-0.37577247619628906,
-0.06485231220722198,
0.23282678425312042,
0.19261567294597626,
0.4259917736053467,
0.044536054134368896,
-0.0346476174890995,
0.145343616604805,
0.32022780179977417,
-0.0800398588180542,
0.8102915287017822,
0.17736907303333282,
-0.15698380768299103,
0.21726644039154053,
-0.6918753981590271,
-0.22290080785751343,
-0.22104349732398987,
-0.8482233285903931,
-0.40629562735557556,
0.17928661406040192,
0.22057735919952393,
0.5281220078468323,
0.49719011783599854,
-0.7596591114997864,
0.3841947615146637,
-0.3141593635082245,
-0.05619453638792038,
0.4589371383190155,
0.026852233335375786,
0.44345277547836304,
0.0704096332192421,
0.6961592435836792,
0.40049558877944946,
0.5554157495498657,
-0.08906643837690353,
-0.3210853338241577,
-0.5849454998970032,
-0.14670827984809875,
0.46422046422958374,
0.5205299854278564,
-0.8794996738433838,
0.2415740042924881,
0.036435022950172424,
-0.37114784121513367,
-0.5133708119392395,
0.3910321295261383,
0.12037861347198486,
0.20159506797790527,
0.13715632259845734,
-0.006496267858892679,
-0.7089371085166931,
-0.7784824371337891,
-0.5754558444023132,
-0.2543228268623352,
-0.010359504260122776,
-0.24157552421092987,
0.602457582950592,
0.12223557382822037,
0.9835952520370483,
-0.30784842371940613,
-0.5226446390151978,
-0.40293142199516296,
0.15041422843933105,
0.10292661935091019,
-0.0424547903239727,
0.13358348608016968,
-1.1778026819229126,
-0.7587153911590576,
0.024775974452495575,
-0.3174779713153839,
-0.1867474913597107,
-0.3104895353317261,
0.11263107508420944,
0.26467204093933105,
0.4664192795753479,
-0.5209268927574158,
0.37747707962989807,
0.7899566888809204,
-0.6977317929267883,
0.4865782558917999,
0.0968857929110527,
0.26347580552101135,
-1.0088258981704712,
-0.02804790623486042,
0.17680829763412476,
-0.6187528967857361,
-0.6388269066810608,
-0.004705792758613825,
0.21240012347698212,
0.05094758793711662,
-0.9816763401031494,
0.5799564123153687,
0.006819493602961302,
0.14013637602329254,
-0.202170729637146,
0.4868675470352173,
-0.19081354141235352,
0.03623934090137482,
-0.04061214253306389,
0.5490916967391968,
0.561296820640564,
-0.5660686492919922,
0.1838771551847458,
0.32884344458580017,
-0.7322870492935181,
0.43551480770111084,
-0.3689960241317749,
-0.31615108251571655,
-0.26373326778411865,
0.25693652033805847,
-1.150259256362915,
-0.36872076988220215,
0.3744320273399353,
-0.6934027075767517,
-0.18042117357254028,
-0.1441381722688675,
-0.5256000757217407,
-0.12460137903690338,
-0.3485717475414276,
-0.19135472178459167,
0.16269345581531525,
-0.5900770425796509,
0.35122016072273254,
0.2531787157058716,
0.08100646734237671,
-0.4830467700958252,
-0.15864162147045135,
0.15477795898914337,
-0.1639169603586197,
-0.43591487407684326,
0.16987423598766327,
0.2148616909980774,
-0.33590465784072876,
0.20369280874729156,
-0.26351603865623474,
0.029022105038166046,
-0.013567304238677025,
-0.02399427816271782,
0.16447477042675018,
0.012261604890227318,
0.3467963635921478,
-0.21872267127037048,
-0.3739950954914093,
-0.09786342084407806,
-0.27709850668907166,
0.6650893092155457,
0.09786269068717957,
-0.29570266604423523,
-0.7406147122383118,
0.44079506397247314,
0.811282753944397,
-0.46817547082901,
0.5135631561279297,
0.9807270765304565,
-0.12817831337451935,
0.04743117839097977,
-0.37781772017478943,
-0.5041477084159851,
-0.4354908764362335,
0.3185044527053833,
0.12592226266860962,
-0.6867170929908752,
0.36212605237960815,
-0.5144790410995483,
-0.22456255555152893,
0.502981424331665,
0.48654797673225403,
0.06333808600902557,
1.4565093517303467,
0.6698709726333618,
-0.30200302600860596,
0.28918275237083435,
-0.04685205593705177,
0.17772912979125977,
-0.08203000575304031,
-0.3878300189971924,
-0.628336489200592,
-0.3460676372051239,
-0.3564518392086029,
0.18061335384845734,
0.4448986351490021,
0.2248278260231018,
0.10213221609592438,
0.27640262246131897,
-0.5794076323509216,
0.3186052441596985,
0.665239155292511,
0.331402063369751,
0.42306190729141235,
0.17400160431861877,
-0.02786366268992424,
-0.4171082079410553,
-0.5935913324356079,
-0.556594967842102,
0.6305346488952637,
0.0888393223285675,
1.0563435554504395,
0.14386574923992157,
0.6914242506027222,
0.3386012017726898,
0.46418747305870056,
-0.8598576784133911,
0.6738661527633667,
-0.19688960909843445,
-0.9049556255340576,
-0.23270027339458466,
0.18515796959400177,
-0.9476448893547058,
0.07756596803665161,
-0.5241853594779968,
-0.9291529655456543,
0.026296772062778473,
0.1792294979095459,
-0.28188151121139526,
0.4181482195854187,
-0.4008917510509491,
0.8629596829414368,
-0.2296116054058075,
-0.20393137633800507,
-0.5505675077438354,
-0.3960700035095215,
0.33172231912612915,
0.0639667734503746,
0.16992366313934326,
0.015881629660725594,
-0.4072711765766144,
0.5193101763725281,
-0.16407766938209534,
0.9872912764549255,
-0.131612166762352,
0.17759490013122559,
0.10802619159221649,
0.06339523196220398,
0.5124880075454712,
0.18759116530418396,
0.1644560843706131,
0.09952982515096664,
-0.09362996369600296,
-0.2892197072505951,
-0.06987704336643219,
0.6514639258384705,
-0.46718674898147583,
-0.5457621216773987,
-0.338810533285141,
-0.20881858468055725,
0.3059616982936859,
0.2933383285999298,
0.5376405119895935,
0.5384306311607361,
-0.29610443115234375,
0.5386732816696167,
0.4853134751319885,
0.18306972086429596,
0.33259889483451843,
0.9332256317138672,
-0.9115747213363647,
-0.15212945640087128,
0.48898690938949585,
0.12020013481378555,
0.1287226676940918,
0.3785242438316345,
0.3640534281730652,
-0.35926520824432373,
-0.2979623079299927,
-0.7735446095466614,
-0.006233529187738895,
-0.4193183183670044,
0.010564899072051048,
-0.5262101292610168,
0.44746726751327515,
-0.04657124727964401,
-0.21889238059520721,
-0.3229702115058899,
-0.07370468974113464,
-0.30710718035697937,
0.22641029953956604,
0.27624112367630005,
0.6139835119247437,
-0.1683981567621231,
0.4778043031692505,
-0.7574741244316101,
0.6136877536773682,
0.27077198028564453,
0.3699360489845276,
-0.6601480841636658,
-0.20545411109924316,
-0.6503390669822693,
-0.25120308995246887,
-0.6409285664558411,
-1.384355068206787,
0.33815997838974,
-0.08444342017173767,
0.41292959451675415,
0.7730453610420227,
0.15318843722343445,
-0.060505274683237076,
-0.10049013048410416,
1.1350795030593872,
0.04249872267246246,
-0.864950954914093,
0.7190632820129395,
-0.33761462569236755,
0.5843716263771057,
0.4533592760562897,
0.912322998046875,
-0.47431010007858276,
-0.41885897517204285,
-0.5282418131828308,
-0.38450729846954346,
0.6320971250534058,
-0.015432608313858509,
0.07063033431768417,
-0.19540996849536896,
-0.17410218715667725,
0.07393646240234375,
0.09868428111076355,
-0.7288860082626343,
-0.3772776424884796,
-0.2177499383687973,
0.07002076506614685,
0.1689431369304657,
-0.4293677508831024,
-0.09558533132076263,
-0.03209330141544342,
0.9216366410255432,
-0.3306039869785309,
-0.20059236884117126,
0.6233229637145996,
-0.12328871339559555,
-0.33436939120292664,
0.45475783944129944,
0.6844854354858398,
0.6562500596046448,
-0.02913004904985428,
-0.13038580119609833,
0.05585943162441254,
-0.7154923677444458,
-0.03744824230670929,
-0.20003141462802887,
-0.43909868597984314,
0.6111181974411011,
0.09690231829881668,
0.3301870822906494,
0.410906046628952,
-0.6041539907455444,
0.7289170622825623,
0.06834243983030319,
-0.65117347240448,
-0.29398852586746216,
-0.30339890718460083,
0.23043125867843628,
0.2004312425851822,
0.4741779863834381,
0.1805090606212616,
0.09899920225143433,
-0.52724689245224,
0.3657274544239044,
0.6230497360229492,
-0.6626286506652832,
-0.3588046431541443,
0.6791561841964722,
0.2761097252368927,
-0.6221552491188049,
0.2250940352678299,
-0.3758818805217743,
-0.9696035981178284,
0.3098038136959076,
0.5140187740325928,
0.6203272342681885,
-0.5431126356124878,
0.8245057463645935,
0.434077650308609,
0.7319996953010559,
0.0010287098120898008,
0.6057808995246887,
0.23715810477733612,
-0.749313473701477,
-0.5686283707618713,
-0.3049895465373993,
-0.4156544506549835,
0.5601192712783813,
-0.7469934225082397,
0.6341525912284851,
-0.05578441917896271,
-0.22656981647014618,
0.16628070175647736,
0.2110673487186432,
-0.5117159485816956,
0.25033193826675415,
0.02685539983212948,
1.2028210163116455,
-0.8891064524650574,
0.6563284397125244,
0.9255545735359192,
-0.07013358175754547,
-0.16168493032455444,
-0.03663855046033859,
0.5393401980400085,
-0.42451703548431396,
0.490752249956131,
0.2470712810754776,
-0.1017400249838829,
0.014406656846404076,
-0.7364665865898132,
-0.5612120032310486,
0.39510026574134827,
0.28452759981155396,
-0.30696600675582886,
0.5473887324333191,
0.07442685216665268,
0.1612742692232132,
-0.3153742551803589,
-0.4131338894367218,
0.6977224946022034,
0.8452391624450684,
-0.5958141684532166,
-0.733995258808136,
-0.25923460721969604,
-0.013679740019142628,
-0.9107670783996582,
0.6692511439323425,
-0.7043349742889404,
0.5876870155334473,
0.07040532678365707,
-0.4395807981491089,
-0.2890211045742035,
0.33468541502952576,
-0.4696260392665863,
0.3938511610031128,
0.935350239276886,
0.48223236203193665,
0.15703164041042328,
0.11529102921485901,
0.9117417931556702,
-0.5952327251434326,
0.36234980821609497,
0.6364996433258057,
0.1492847055196762,
0.8951712250709534,
0.6172767877578735,
-0.2841494083404541,
0.5941721200942993,
0.3193749189376831,
0.17470531165599823,
0.5418409705162048,
-0.06063242629170418,
-0.7322958707809448,
-0.5908262133598328,
-0.3570737838745117,
0.1638505756855011,
0.8088475465774536,
0.3017342686653137,
0.009320690296590328,
-0.6782858371734619,
0.23822620511054993,
0.15344193577766418,
0.4457753896713257,
-0.40377670526504517,
0.5843856334686279,
-0.23577605187892914,
-0.7328218817710876,
0.14105767011642456,
0.111088328063488,
0.7527070641517639,
-0.9904786944389343,
0.1573820412158966,
0.05133657902479172,
0.169468492269516,
-0.5048208832740784,
-0.7501363754272461,
0.14417052268981934,
-0.006939910817891359,
-0.18717746436595917,
-0.11485498398542404,
1.1985669136047363,
-0.5552082061767578,
-0.4382527470588684,
0.18990972638130188,
0.7012185454368591,
0.1251935213804245,
-0.4525613486766815,
-0.6550858616828918,
0.011602582409977913,
0.24054281413555145,
-0.5126863121986389,
0.3712611496448517,
-0.18955393135547638,
-0.02849685028195381,
0.7575593590736389,
0.9276204109191895,
0.28284791111946106,
-0.11388585716485977,
-0.1164565235376358,
0.7158263921737671,
-0.29184690117836,
-0.5154598951339722,
-0.727878749370575,
0.6712773442268372,
-0.1445121318101883,
-0.5557253360748291,
1.0295829772949219,
0.6731833815574646,
0.9508711695671082,
-0.25926473736763,
0.6922863125801086,
0.1453121304512024,
0.6455928683280945,
-0.38012775778770447,
0.701938807964325,
-0.6928408145904541,
-0.39189356565475464,
0.1006874218583107,
-0.4004063606262207,
-0.37777355313301086,
0.18348738551139832,
-0.19354376196861267,
-0.5262141227722168,
0.7415630221366882,
0.9316860437393188,
-0.1535358875989914,
-0.21317708492279053,
0.4886527359485626,
-0.00836309976875782,
-0.30276399850845337,
-0.02382723055779934,
0.6554396152496338,
-0.2064102292060852,
0.8132323026657104,
-0.41446638107299805,
-0.040219493210315704,
-0.6638569831848145,
-1.0629732608795166,
-0.7787578701972961,
-0.5766302347183228,
-0.2527967393398285,
-0.34114572405815125,
-0.23541392385959625,
0.894476592540741,
0.6476621627807617,
-0.6233155727386475,
0.07326168566942215,
0.3871265947818756,
0.3145397901535034,
-0.20302808284759521,
-0.22696857154369354,
0.38196617364883423,
-0.2521706521511078,
-0.7657948136329651,
0.18660402297973633,
0.4911903142929077,
-0.3186509311199188,
-0.6856734752655029,
0.20349957048892975,
-0.3707077205181122,
0.1762162744998932,
0.5913032293319702,
0.2584238350391388,
-0.8837616443634033,
-0.35144248604774475,
0.19085857272148132,
-0.12029960751533508,
-0.21552829444408417,
0.7938998937606812,
-1.0271600484848022,
0.6519150733947754,
0.6003482341766357,
0.20288825035095215,
0.27606502175331116,
0.1278274804353714,
-0.07314243167638779,
-0.6419462561607361,
0.29458391666412354,
-0.13600078225135803,
0.18337485194206238,
0.15034788846969604,
-0.5643652677536011,
0.17429378628730774,
0.032270535826683044,
-0.5894539952278137,
-0.4220137894153595,
0.33751896023750305,
-0.9006576538085938,
-0.1545039564371109,
0.9915856719017029,
0.12408038973808289,
-0.16340678930282593,
-0.4188520610332489,
-0.5273202061653137,
-0.05464835837483406,
-0.501297116279602,
0.7830365300178528,
0.892915666103363,
0.21157556772232056,
0.05359791964292526,
-0.9505277276039124,
0.654018759727478,
0.47240912914276123,
-0.682972252368927,
-0.5077379941940308,
0.2279832810163498,
0.26833969354629517,
0.30324476957321167,
0.5023786425590515,
0.04459762945771217,
0.6505491733551025,
0.044263485819101334,
0.15209834277629852,
0.02717813290655613,
-0.392412394285202,
-0.4915226399898529,
0.0901416540145874,
-0.33870765566825867,
-0.3930415213108063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15713v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15713v2 | Contrastive Learning and Mixture of Experts Enables Precise Vector Embeddings | 2024-01-28T17:34:42 | 2024-05-30T19:55:58 | Logan Hallee, Rohan Kapur, Arjun Patel, Jason P. Gleghorn, Bohdan Khomtchouk | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The advancement of transformer neural networks has significantly elevated the
capabilities of sentence similarity models, but they struggle with highly
discriminative tasks and produce sub-optimal representations of important
documents like scientific literature. With the increased reliance on retrieval
augmentation and search, representing diverse documents as concise and
descriptive vectors is crucial. This paper improves upon the vectors embeddings
of scientific literature by assembling niche datasets using co-citations as a
similarity metric, focusing on biomedical domains. We apply a novel Mixture of
Experts (MoE) extension pipeline to pretrained BERT models, where every
multi-layer perceptron section is enlarged and copied into multiple distinct
experts. Our MoE variants perform well over $N$ scientific domains with $N$
dedicated experts, whereas standard BERT models excel in only one domain.
Notably, extending just a single transformer block to MoE captures 85% of the
benefit seen from full MoE extension at every layer. This holds promise for
versatile and efficient One-Size-Fits-All transformer networks for numerically
representing diverse inputs. Our methodology marks significant advancements in
representing scientific text and holds promise for enhancing vector database
search and compilation. | [
-0.44261571764945984,
-0.1241484209895134,
0.3975549638271332,
0.06045878306031227,
-0.23555216193199158,
0.34800708293914795,
-0.16128674149513245,
-0.26363271474838257,
0.5913257598876953,
0.25062093138694763,
-0.24430149793624878,
-0.5109462738037109,
-0.7558643817901611,
0.11130064725875854,
-0.30073240399360657,
0.8898519277572632,
0.2061156928539276,
0.3116941452026367,
-0.6957191824913025,
-0.3299693167209625,
-0.1666373610496521,
-0.35380494594573975,
-0.039901550859212875,
-0.49383509159088135,
0.7626684904098511,
-0.04852917790412903,
0.40606871247291565,
0.32665005326271057,
0.6259387135505676,
0.32725951075553894,
0.010538488626480103,
0.27401959896087646,
-0.6255080699920654,
0.29011476039886475,
-0.5287986993789673,
-0.4181307554244995,
-0.12159615010023117,
-0.12208728492259979,
0.3652530014514923,
0.947089672088623,
0.23927150666713715,
-0.3491215109825134,
0.27943721413612366,
0.29581958055496216,
-0.4961242377758026,
0.017041802406311035,
-0.8108692765235901,
0.1721251904964447,
-0.07640670984983444,
-0.34674668312072754,
-0.43836072087287903,
-0.08142123371362686,
0.6280428171157837,
-0.8940118551254272,
0.6367251873016357,
0.04764167219400406,
0.790916919708252,
0.40606945753097534,
-0.36628782749176025,
-0.03780410811305046,
-0.39805635809898376,
1.1087586879730225,
-0.297526478767395,
0.3818327784538269,
-0.14409326016902924,
0.03652327507734299,
-0.12282952666282654,
-0.8633639216423035,
-0.286596417427063,
0.011617626063525677,
-0.21876706182956696,
0.3274325430393219,
-0.27349796891212463,
-0.11636921018362045,
-0.3613327145576477,
0.19946426153182983,
-0.43749377131462097,
0.12415079027414322,
-0.5814616680145264,
-0.24702100455760956,
0.4881874918937683,
-0.10755669325590134,
0.07576330751180649,
0.010338549502193928,
-0.3479144871234894,
-0.27375417947769165,
-0.4382443428039551,
-0.31203195452690125,
0.16308805346488953,
0.08075830340385437,
0.17723459005355835,
0.3206194341182709,
0.2216649353504181,
0.4109385013580322,
0.10021505504846573,
0.15994763374328613,
0.5206853151321411,
-0.24574506282806396,
0.029309915378689766,
-0.14004196226596832,
0.7902134656906128,
0.20574836432933807,
0.020137084648013115,
-0.5143416523933411,
0.10502101480960846,
-0.2510910630226135,
0.5642204284667969,
-0.5742659568786621,
-0.6581989526748657,
0.15160630643367767,
-0.5278852581977844,
-0.3236711323261261,
0.13638070225715637,
-0.6551808714866638,
-0.3268108367919922,
-0.3271126449108124,
0.4115750193595886,
-0.7570905685424805,
-0.025696326047182083,
-0.10738806426525116,
-0.4327223300933838,
-0.054015375673770905,
0.2814072370529175,
-0.6222929954528809,
0.32854029536247253,
0.6945117115974426,
0.8001738786697388,
-0.49607354402542114,
-0.14951933920383453,
-0.17275792360305786,
0.22394615411758423,
-0.14901311695575714,
0.8261081576347351,
-0.8708404898643494,
-0.6725217700004578,
-0.18291521072387695,
-0.37428760528564453,
-0.051285360008478165,
-0.7339214086532593,
0.6311333179473877,
-0.6612418293952942,
0.13016821444034576,
-0.3335161805152893,
-0.6529961228370667,
-0.3002561628818512,
0.05128411576151848,
-0.5711753964424133,
0.92414790391922,
0.21355599164962769,
-0.867192268371582,
0.307390421628952,
-0.4661546051502228,
-0.37791433930397034,
0.16398687660694122,
-0.5833398103713989,
-0.5080748200416565,
0.039988648146390915,
0.3592032790184021,
0.650530993938446,
0.015317043289542198,
0.32223767042160034,
-0.46264612674713135,
-0.15536990761756897,
0.3021206557750702,
-0.052037667483091354,
0.6414769887924194,
0.19785037636756897,
0.014912042766809464,
0.25751250982284546,
-0.7973343729972839,
-0.24583260715007782,
-0.24367007613182068,
-0.1116923913359642,
-0.9518702626228333,
-0.034709345549345016,
0.08145583420991898,
0.03169644996523857,
0.13324376940727234,
-0.7641499042510986,
0.11908986419439316,
-0.13236133754253387,
0.5159080028533936,
0.6540470719337463,
0.05643397197127342,
0.5229712724685669,
-0.42355626821517944,
0.25055602192878723,
0.43942496180534363,
-0.32092124223709106,
-0.21949835121631622,
-0.5808489322662354,
-0.522510826587677,
-0.656782865524292,
0.5085081458091736,
0.25586819648742676,
-0.8138154149055481,
0.9055219292640686,
-0.6317492127418518,
-0.6633538603782654,
-0.8888504505157471,
0.10330531001091003,
0.15307240188121796,
0.7803320288658142,
0.9148454666137695,
-0.3675999939441681,
-0.6301504373550415,
-1.1306840181350708,
-0.21256522834300995,
0.30081504583358765,
-0.3762487769126892,
0.5419340133666992,
0.5680904388427734,
-0.34704768657684326,
1.1495651006698608,
-0.49107709527015686,
-0.23576921224594116,
0.1316780298948288,
0.19071099162101746,
0.23651394248008728,
0.7726729512214661,
0.6999624371528625,
-0.8412734866142273,
-0.5471983551979065,
0.11954090744256973,
-0.8579050898551941,
0.058297641575336456,
-0.013410783372819424,
-0.3729172945022583,
-0.6369907855987549,
0.4102832078933716,
-0.2307358831167221,
-0.07966846227645874,
0.3734741508960724,
-0.09923368692398071,
0.24837803840637207,
-0.2829212546348572,
0.00016987277194857597,
-1.0374764204025269,
0.08305665105581284,
0.16106170415878296,
-0.24761858582496643,
-0.38565659523010254,
0.12603874504566193,
0.00012803360004909337,
0.054575446993112564,
-0.18468382954597473,
0.27051177620887756,
-0.29783958196640015,
0.20055779814720154,
-0.014262748882174492,
-0.031132247298955917,
0.14634136855602264,
0.18584367632865906,
-0.024518033489584923,
0.5993852019309998,
0.6983128786087036,
-0.5483984351158142,
0.1792818307876587,
0.5207321643829346,
-0.2837240993976593,
0.5134717226028442,
-0.9655601382255554,
-0.001468634931370616,
-0.31783223152160645,
0.5318986177444458,
-0.8108359575271606,
-0.10778610408306122,
0.0052308193407952785,
-0.3703089952468872,
0.3137482702732086,
0.1616889089345932,
-0.052065324038267136,
-0.2969210147857666,
-0.4627314805984497,
0.35248517990112305,
0.7404802441596985,
-0.5672697424888611,
0.8385307192802429,
0.30213308334350586,
-0.3957819640636444,
-0.7812127470970154,
-0.809236466884613,
-0.16171494126319885,
-0.0246073380112648,
-0.6452597379684448,
0.9796923995018005,
0.08959303796291351,
-0.11020152270793915,
0.4491345286369324,
0.044975943863391876,
-0.12584763765335083,
-0.04434162750840187,
0.02958003804087639,
0.2651406526565552,
-0.40197283029556274,
0.3416171967983246,
0.4947264790534973,
0.03635086491703987,
-0.15005719661712646,
-0.45254456996917725,
0.3544919788837433,
0.29380419850349426,
-0.35729774832725525,
-0.0460268072783947,
0.6450808048248291,
0.2605144679546356,
-0.24167634546756744,
0.6434102058410645,
0.7769392728805542,
-0.1132754310965538,
-0.17682266235351562,
-0.3676537275314331,
-0.329071044921875,
-0.43404528498649597,
0.5268881320953369,
-0.3510461747646332,
-0.9951727390289307,
0.5108737945556641,
-0.14917030930519104,
0.15278859436511993,
0.8453531265258789,
0.4246160089969635,
-0.3351166844367981,
0.358625590801239,
0.4502301514148712,
0.06013418734073639,
0.30750924348831177,
-0.29697537422180176,
0.04966679587960243,
-0.8879329562187195,
-0.5061632394790649,
-0.5412824749946594,
-0.6481663584709167,
-0.3299407660961151,
-0.869229793548584,
0.531817615032196,
-0.10138503462076187,
-0.05723080784082413,
0.10989764332771301,
-0.8161013722419739,
0.33356165885925293,
0.7003501057624817,
0.5193976759910583,
0.047061581164598465,
0.3740760385990143,
-0.6257725358009338,
-0.33818039298057556,
-0.800443172454834,
-0.4155784845352173,
1.2391142845153809,
0.28486719727516174,
0.7825323939323425,
-0.2435726523399353,
0.8638774752616882,
0.25132352113723755,
0.4401818811893463,
-0.6219250559806824,
0.21394947171211243,
-0.5261673331260681,
-0.4918954074382782,
-0.020137973129749298,
-0.21007229387760162,
-0.9900693297386169,
0.5694249868392944,
-0.5146595239639282,
-0.25552234053611755,
0.8059751987457275,
-0.0393088199198246,
-0.5813783407211304,
0.2820758819580078,
-0.49709612131118774,
0.34956520795822144,
0.10859296470880508,
-0.38018304109573364,
-0.30148452520370483,
-0.7075644135475159,
0.02245924063026905,
-0.255696177482605,
-0.11345482617616653,
0.18279799818992615,
-0.321539044380188,
0.8585104942321777,
-0.34730982780456543,
0.8432543873786926,
-0.05415979400277138,
0.2651943862438202,
0.13842016458511353,
-0.24573113024234772,
0.16056615114212036,
-0.10375624150037766,
-0.36112695932388306,
0.2591346204280853,
-0.33552566170692444,
-0.6939703226089478,
-0.4061996638774872,
0.8620407581329346,
-1.1257449388504028,
-0.41703158617019653,
-0.25896427035331726,
-0.6170340776443481,
-0.24850408732891083,
0.09958823025226593,
0.37126776576042175,
0.33178895711898804,
-0.24831938743591309,
0.7610852718353271,
1.0530438423156738,
-0.2888956069946289,
0.1596856713294983,
0.22203585505485535,
0.31810951232910156,
-0.42547595500946045,
0.8906468152999878,
0.09858386218547821,
-0.2716832756996155,
0.6837782263755798,
0.05186186358332634,
-0.1182803362607956,
-0.6327173113822937,
0.12528647482395172,
0.1657639741897583,
-0.6500756740570068,
-0.3149813711643219,
-1.3751128911972046,
-0.19936533272266388,
-0.5071874260902405,
-0.44709858298301697,
-0.24663615226745605,
-0.29718783497810364,
-0.566163957118988,
-0.05103934183716774,
0.43048837780952454,
0.7885879874229431,
-0.023170895874500275,
0.23655372858047485,
-0.864448606967926,
0.1625760793685913,
0.3116816580295563,
0.22716236114501953,
0.24583502113819122,
-0.4291788637638092,
-0.23008033633232117,
-0.2851875424385071,
-0.49452072381973267,
-0.6183054447174072,
0.43378880620002747,
0.4451155364513397,
0.9970531463623047,
0.39827027916908264,
0.03445346653461456,
0.3662390410900116,
-0.7153375148773193,
0.7199039459228516,
0.27339890599250793,
-0.650516152381897,
0.17574389278888702,
-0.3287942111492157,
-0.18544051051139832,
0.6022213697433472,
0.9688264727592468,
0.05171250179409981,
-0.27652862668037415,
-0.6926113367080688,
-1.017042875289917,
0.05070785805583,
0.26602837443351746,
0.19239899516105652,
0.07184618711471558,
0.15072253346443176,
0.8601146340370178,
0.041272688657045364,
-0.2641603946685791,
-0.28129494190216064,
-0.39657077193260193,
-0.5622155070304871,
-0.11375796794891357,
0.04197116941213608,
-0.3470037877559662,
-0.4495525360107422,
0.6121220588684082,
-0.0384317971765995,
0.5149316787719727,
0.471003919839859,
-0.08775486052036285,
0.26300400495529175,
0.19506148993968964,
0.32757100462913513,
0.5369353890419006,
-0.10867401212453842,
0.23228003084659576,
-0.07134390622377396,
-0.4691593050956726,
-0.03253588825464249,
0.3847252428531647,
-0.09007753431797028,
0.3820877969264984,
0.5270357131958008,
0.5765249729156494,
0.4128105938434601,
-0.38501492142677307,
0.37968143820762634,
0.23547989130020142,
-0.42822548747062683,
0.09192889928817749,
0.12327301502227783,
0.17939867079257965,
0.26539289951324463,
0.7726969122886658,
0.6650611162185669,
0.3285410702228546,
-0.20756706595420837,
0.49787473678588867,
0.2659451365470886,
-0.34325793385505676,
-0.33909255266189575,
0.7125664949417114,
0.6174058318138123,
0.0822598785161972,
0.3563712537288666,
0.1629873514175415,
-0.48081323504447937,
0.5074719786643982,
0.35899800062179565,
0.6410228610038757,
-0.10983407497406006,
0.06799698621034622,
0.3410453200340271,
-0.08464613556861877,
0.02188429981470108,
-0.007101986091583967,
0.011022004298865795,
-0.7649062871932983,
-0.28708329796791077,
-0.4489917755126953,
-0.4246726632118225,
-0.0971653088927269,
-0.6277840733528137,
0.2241879254579544,
-0.2166401594877243,
-0.08826149255037308,
0.3943046033382416,
-0.32440003752708435,
-0.9767574667930603,
0.13690273463726044,
-0.12051171809434891,
0.8016133308410645,
-0.8782913088798523,
0.8498973250389099,
0.8024628758430481,
-0.411723256111145,
-0.34409233927726746,
-0.1467997133731842,
-0.5000035166740417,
-0.6423044204711914,
0.7742063403129578,
-0.08991305530071259,
0.1352318674325943,
-0.06661149859428406,
-0.6319675445556641,
-0.7006260752677917,
1.0426644086837769,
0.2805667519569397,
-0.7957813739776611,
-0.16029417514801025,
-0.3164387047290802,
0.7422772645950317,
-0.6671857833862305,
0.4207659959793091,
0.13217629492282867,
0.15394775569438934,
0.13418610394001007,
-0.5086595416069031,
-0.09617559611797333,
-0.40872564911842346,
-0.1299554705619812,
-0.3484562933444977,
-0.5345514416694641,
1.0236079692840576,
0.08907441794872284,
0.3254706859588623,
-0.0748264491558075,
0.9256899356842041,
0.3369506001472473,
0.18118077516555786,
0.29523661732673645,
0.42062845826148987,
1.0534659624099731,
-0.045725900679826736,
1.1113673448562622,
-0.2327985167503357,
0.2871963083744049,
0.9983627200126648,
-0.16056014597415924,
0.7257639765739441,
0.5636729001998901,
-0.3294847309589386,
0.8822616934776306,
0.6178157329559326,
-0.3647363483905792,
0.6790897250175476,
0.12422160804271698,
-0.19468200206756592,
-0.41428256034851074,
-0.18763616681098938,
-0.7440580725669861,
0.10363712161779404,
0.4600774645805359,
-0.7902555465698242,
-0.08019915968179703,
0.15707482397556305,
-0.36052271723747253,
0.32796770334243774,
-0.23562441766262054,
0.4832376539707184,
0.2251289337873459,
-0.334833562374115,
0.1894625872373581,
-0.2613614797592163,
1.2611242532730103,
-0.42700961232185364,
0.06702839583158493,
0.01871350221335888,
0.10486149787902832,
-0.2968597710132599,
-0.6965842247009277,
0.0855298638343811,
-0.33880048990249634,
-0.32630276679992676,
-0.12307176738977432,
0.8660617470741272,
-0.5985921621322632,
-0.5104600787162781,
0.29949066042900085,
0.5313829183578491,
0.15122923254966736,
0.28991615772247314,
-0.5343145132064819,
-0.2400311827659607,
-0.12145914137363434,
-0.05774897336959839,
0.17380541563034058,
0.4266158938407898,
0.18905973434448242,
0.49465078115463257,
0.47934189438819885,
0.03787898272275925,
0.1894988715648651,
-0.018889889121055603,
1.2559610605239868,
-0.3984425663948059,
-0.5599048137664795,
-0.5583295822143555,
0.3967556059360504,
-0.3653571903705597,
-0.14177356660366058,
0.5565706491470337,
0.6149752140045166,
0.7929995656013489,
-0.5205374956130981,
1.1251277923583984,
0.15088064968585968,
0.703978955745697,
-0.07736632972955704,
0.7737553119659424,
-0.45477524399757385,
0.031607262790203094,
-0.11079619824886322,
-0.6713907122612,
-0.4179222285747528,
0.6547963619232178,
-0.19658850133419037,
0.16493402421474457,
0.6415646076202393,
0.3755405843257904,
-0.42237114906311035,
-0.15353353321552277,
0.23330123722553253,
0.1785009205341339,
0.46611613035202026,
0.32943907380104065,
0.4262267053127289,
-0.29840582609176636,
0.5037094354629517,
-0.14178995788097382,
-0.06600907444953918,
-0.42119497060775757,
-0.7674879431724548,
-1.0058882236480713,
-0.4332565367221832,
-0.4545458257198334,
-0.09266362339258194,
0.008406753651797771,
1.107419729232788,
0.8704676032066345,
-1.1383622884750366,
0.37381914258003235,
0.12369745969772339,
-0.09224789589643478,
-0.19548799097537994,
-0.18295001983642578,
0.4412708878517151,
-0.3841764032840729,
-0.7388936281204224,
0.38035327196121216,
0.2868705093860626,
-0.07037781924009323,
-0.39513570070266724,
-0.04058791697025299,
-0.2982195019721985,
0.09713443368673325,
0.5067614912986755,
0.02038969099521637,
-0.5560122132301331,
-0.07331805676221848,
0.07949493080377579,
-0.26602795720100403,
0.2747023105621338,
0.8165907263755798,
-1.0842649936676025,
0.5647415518760681,
0.6802772879600525,
1.1422640085220337,
0.2921414077281952,
-0.047214049845933914,
0.7132944464683533,
-0.9293270707130432,
0.14869104325771332,
0.6289048790931702,
0.45853129029273987,
0.5237134099006653,
-0.30956482887268066,
0.45147860050201416,
0.4469340443611145,
-0.4336560368537903,
-0.4242381453514099,
-0.09654180705547333,
-1.2479281425476074,
-0.34963521361351013,
0.7975124716758728,
-0.4459839165210724,
-0.09883479028940201,
-0.4273957312107086,
-0.15726503729820251,
0.25227972865104675,
-0.6087008118629456,
0.748155415058136,
0.6647449135780334,
-0.06747418642044067,
0.07624398916959763,
0.04235207289457321,
0.12338124215602875,
0.6646052598953247,
-0.48269709944725037,
-0.6406060457229614,
0.02313200756907463,
0.3423673212528229,
0.5196669101715088,
0.2271089106798172,
-0.12930627167224884,
0.014149583876132965,
0.09959746152162552,
0.1054716557264328,
-0.19684921205043793,
-0.07007881999015808,
-0.16586294770240784,
0.45670580863952637,
-0.3029293119907379,
-0.06483788043260574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15670v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15670v1 | YODA: Teacher-Student Progressive Learning for Language Models | 2024-01-28T14:32:15 | 2024-01-28T14:32:15 | Jianqiao Lu, Wanjun Zhong, Yufei Wang, Zhijiang Guo, Qi Zhu, Wenyong Huang, Yanlin Wang, Fei Mi, Baojun Wang, Yasheng Wang, Lifeng Shang, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Although large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated adeptness in a range
of tasks, they still lag behind human learning efficiency. This disparity is
often linked to the inherent human capacity to learn from basic examples,
gradually generalize and handle more complex problems, and refine their skills
with continuous feedback. Inspired by this, this paper introduces YODA, a novel
teacher-student progressive learning framework that emulates the
teacher-student education process to improve the efficacy of model fine-tuning.
The framework operates on an interactive \textit{basic-generalized-harder}
loop. The teacher agent provides tailored feedback on the student's answers,
and systematically organizes the education process. This process unfolds by
teaching the student basic examples, reinforcing understanding through
generalized questions, and then enhancing learning by posing questions with
progressively enhanced complexity. With the teacher's guidance, the student
learns to iteratively refine its answer with feedback, and forms a robust and
comprehensive understanding of the posed questions. The systematic procedural
data, which reflects the progressive learning process of humans, is then
utilized for model training. Taking math reasoning as a testbed, experiments
show that training LLaMA2 with data from YODA improves SFT with significant
performance gain (+17.01\% on GSM8K and +9.98\% on MATH). In addition, we find
that training with curriculum learning further improves learning robustness. | [
-0.1655104011297226,
-1.172071099281311,
0.4093991219997406,
-0.3573249876499176,
-0.13248473405838013,
0.45188039541244507,
-0.39808669686317444,
-0.08195451647043228,
-0.0018162406049668789,
0.332750141620636,
-0.6284070014953613,
-0.3928437829017639,
-0.3067043125629425,
-0.15017040073871613,
-0.0672474205493927,
0.7598204612731934,
0.10131806135177612,
0.362481027841568,
-0.01529154647141695,
0.028788410127162933,
-0.7165129780769348,
0.11281492561101913,
-0.6321104168891907,
-0.6737477779388428,
0.270283967256546,
0.6326676607131958,
0.6421933174133301,
0.7157849669456482,
0.12528440356254578,
0.39121755957603455,
0.0563603900372982,
-0.044371794909238815,
-0.49513205885887146,
0.5399414896965027,
-0.24658295512199402,
-0.8403226733207703,
-0.5036512613296509,
0.02989538386464119,
0.7244836688041687,
1.057438850402832,
-0.6077443957328796,
-0.03150208666920662,
-0.09131108969449997,
0.6040605306625366,
-0.4148199260234833,
0.19014640152454376,
-0.49916020035743713,
-0.0007627261220477521,
-0.07292758673429489,
0.24973292648792267,
-0.2407304048538208,
-0.5856356620788574,
0.10589399933815002,
-0.6870584487915039,
0.07526499032974243,
-0.6817715167999268,
0.6171473860740662,
0.13174203038215637,
-0.3960055410861969,
-0.3975698947906494,
-0.6210101246833801,
0.6860788464546204,
-0.5580671429634094,
0.6395675539970398,
0.486666738986969,
0.5060088634490967,
-0.1246865764260292,
-0.755736768245697,
-0.6822970509529114,
-0.318853497505188,
0.5987023115158081,
-0.043419599533081055,
0.3703933656215668,
0.1279386729001999,
0.22342483699321747,
0.44969895482063293,
-0.20304042100906372,
0.1320900171995163,
-0.48755887150764465,
-0.10687506943941116,
0.3547652065753937,
0.2988169193267822,
0.1361140012741089,
0.12808331847190857,
-0.2107161432504654,
-0.23484498262405396,
-0.7323957681655884,
0.3786362409591675,
0.5770203471183777,
0.2489580661058426,
0.03550015017390251,
0.4259384572505951,
-0.2360488772392273,
0.8678980469703674,
-0.09126344323158264,
-0.6780949831008911,
0.3089577257633209,
-0.08294382691383362,
-0.1985730528831482,
-0.43459567427635193,
0.34157609939575195,
-0.030501589179039,
0.5662882924079895,
-0.20917771756649017,
-0.30448856949806213,
0.5196108818054199,
0.4194152355194092,
-0.8169244527816772,
-0.19479891657829285,
-0.28821682929992676,
-0.07422951608896255,
-0.39019593596458435,
0.18221130967140198,
-0.854202389717102,
-0.14994187653064728,
-0.5890595316886902,
0.4591730535030365,
-0.4400857985019684,
-0.7139229774475098,
0.2777631878852844,
0.20072759687900543,
0.29074135422706604,
0.494765043258667,
-0.8424204587936401,
0.36526167392730713,
0.8487592935562134,
0.6594992280006409,
0.07552353292703629,
-0.3302637040615082,
-0.6465973854064941,
-0.19799600541591644,
-0.4653218388557434,
0.5622815489768982,
-0.9608073830604553,
-0.4660781919956207,
-0.0816386342048645,
-0.266267865896225,
-0.021790338680148125,
-0.38458073139190674,
0.2216821163892746,
-0.6421577334403992,
0.2623288631439209,
-0.261900395154953,
-0.5251553058624268,
-0.2361355572938919,
0.38691189885139465,
-0.40012598037719727,
0.8460175395011902,
0.4314363896846771,
-0.24820275604724884,
0.07497653365135193,
-0.6247259378433228,
-0.284710168838501,
0.09427279978990555,
-0.18629370629787445,
-0.4394112527370453,
0.031849492341279984,
-0.14320404827594757,
0.346221387386322,
-0.264434278011322,
0.4919303059577942,
-0.24537016451358795,
-0.5218101143836975,
0.05599294230341911,
-0.30869171023368835,
0.5953247547149658,
0.24831536412239075,
-0.2522549331188202,
0.23140335083007812,
-0.9131562113761902,
0.08276910334825516,
0.23130233585834503,
-0.6967768669128418,
-0.3148321211338043,
-0.40364909172058105,
-0.2543948292732239,
-0.06267213076353073,
-0.11843849718570709,
-0.38173189759254456,
0.547559380531311,
-0.5117572546005249,
0.6278752684593201,
1.051680326461792,
-0.128217414021492,
0.6764243841171265,
-0.2668171525001526,
0.921992838382721,
-0.10177537053823471,
-0.08138761669397354,
-0.7371023297309875,
-0.5776912569999695,
-0.7994364500045776,
-0.04415038228034973,
0.3441033661365509,
0.21657085418701172,
-0.7690476775169373,
-0.04580153152346611,
-0.1522539108991623,
-0.3661210238933563,
-0.7374705672264099,
0.5382764935493469,
0.3667483329772949,
1.0686386823654175,
0.22255049645900726,
-0.6670250296592712,
-0.23155967891216278,
-0.3905286192893982,
0.07275550812482834,
-0.3998430073261261,
0.06636729091405869,
-0.1327909678220749,
0.4406262934207916,
-0.49725136160850525,
0.9204857349395752,
-0.6012899279594421,
-0.012437612749636173,
-0.19582095742225647,
0.018883327022194862,
0.03922707587480545,
0.45553097128868103,
0.16129714250564575,
-0.8326169848442078,
-0.4789387583732605,
-0.23455022275447845,
-0.3392159342765808,
-0.030609428882598877,
-0.039677418768405914,
-0.0981873869895935,
0.09165417402982712,
0.3572450578212738,
-0.23086178302764893,
0.12539739906787872,
0.11634445190429688,
-0.5444989204406738,
0.6414551138877869,
-0.20107217133045197,
-0.15098541975021362,
-1.0386768579483032,
-0.2167254239320755,
-0.04267677664756775,
-0.36872655153274536,
-0.638619601726532,
0.32259440422058105,
0.13943220674991608,
-0.11838100105524063,
-0.04489579796791077,
0.2224820852279663,
-0.25680914521217346,
0.08449432998895645,
-0.3890915513038635,
-0.02718404121696949,
-0.08746956288814545,
0.5586301684379578,
-0.1570892482995987,
0.9099860787391663,
0.575330913066864,
-0.44247084856033325,
0.35099974274635315,
-0.057598818093538284,
-0.2729877829551697,
0.8119587898254395,
-0.677699863910675,
0.5056822299957275,
-0.18604935705661774,
-0.14091919362545013,
-0.9906681180000305,
-0.23562762141227722,
0.19244635105133057,
-0.4268864691257477,
0.49458348751068115,
0.022127939388155937,
-0.2534056007862091,
-0.22723741829395294,
-0.43108996748924255,
-0.014188261702656746,
0.6706617474555969,
-0.3959500193595886,
0.6103477478027344,
0.3301190733909607,
-0.028508001938462257,
-0.5615594983100891,
-0.529071569442749,
-0.125575989484787,
0.10734516382217407,
-0.4094926118850708,
0.07394426316022873,
-0.3182940185070038,
-0.25187352299690247,
0.047886043787002563,
-0.23341861367225647,
-0.1492307037115097,
0.42526569962501526,
0.22990302741527557,
0.3407954275608063,
-0.39699897170066833,
0.34771978855133057,
0.1395908147096634,
-0.15070950984954834,
0.04424933344125748,
-0.20491275191307068,
0.7465722560882568,
-0.5188244581222534,
-0.41568851470947266,
-0.2615582346916199,
0.13286693394184113,
0.47196534276008606,
-0.29887279868125916,
0.552077054977417,
0.5827189087867737,
-0.38099443912506104,
-0.27902841567993164,
-0.4966452121734619,
-0.3962646424770355,
-0.514726459980011,
0.6047768592834473,
-0.6383177638053894,
-0.8684799671173096,
0.30872783064842224,
-0.37929567694664,
0.0011533843353390694,
0.1419653594493866,
0.6511394381523132,
0.06754595041275024,
0.7795875668525696,
1.0146498680114746,
0.03695337101817131,
0.6453437805175781,
-0.6909194588661194,
-0.11816415935754776,
-0.7170629501342773,
-0.661124587059021,
-0.3687889575958252,
-0.20242583751678467,
-0.2756989896297455,
-0.41535159945487976,
0.017240317538380623,
0.4749891757965088,
-0.6376594305038452,
0.20295517146587372,
-0.26178452372550964,
0.6556193828582764,
0.3721722662448883,
0.054094068706035614,
0.42110303044319153,
-0.17315879464149475,
-0.2924197018146515,
-0.17752815783023834,
-0.4379582703113556,
-0.492908239364624,
1.2109155654907227,
0.4922869801521301,
0.8622837066650391,
0.18243175745010376,
0.6374765038490295,
0.04342947155237198,
0.5192806720733643,
-0.740320086479187,
0.5667125582695007,
0.4083174169063568,
-0.442312091588974,
-0.12387511879205704,
-0.5249403715133667,
-0.6754556894302368,
0.09842997044324875,
-0.032375648617744446,
-0.40977758169174194,
-0.05525420233607292,
-0.229414165019989,
-0.059202853590250015,
0.2732519209384918,
-0.8837426900863647,
0.5489912033081055,
0.07934128493070602,
-0.5165119171142578,
-0.3652949929237366,
-0.6441202759742737,
0.2792580723762512,
-0.17207156121730804,
0.12291219085454941,
0.004958081524819136,
-0.3699946701526642,
0.5716279745101929,
-0.3544950783252716,
1.086600661277771,
-0.32024672627449036,
-0.13930149376392365,
0.2841818034648895,
0.27267804741859436,
0.2731982171535492,
0.3040957748889923,
-0.19260579347610474,
-0.26266196370124817,
-0.48175039887428284,
-0.5024675726890564,
-0.5615715980529785,
0.8627630472183228,
-0.8080618381500244,
-0.7630479335784912,
-0.28184205293655396,
-0.6234042048454285,
-0.2954450249671936,
0.2304069846868515,
-0.3052581548690796,
0.1358456313610077,
0.16532465815544128,
-0.027008697390556335,
0.7589516639709473,
0.23515154421329498,
0.3591511845588684,
0.7452641725540161,
-0.2450234293937683,
-0.5552874803543091,
0.792792558670044,
0.2243853658437729,
0.4693988561630249,
0.05503231659531593,
0.36735162138938904,
-0.3837738633155823,
-0.3190867304801941,
-0.4081057906150818,
0.2868538796901703,
-0.9854802489280701,
-0.31968092918395996,
-0.3330685794353485,
-0.057727474719285965,
-0.27347254753112793,
-0.315020889043808,
-0.38589516282081604,
-0.3179898262023926,
-0.40100574493408203,
-0.2607920169830322,
0.09588468074798584,
0.9992702007293701,
0.07720229774713516,
0.3927312195301056,
-0.009908482432365417,
0.3221079111099243,
0.7557094693183899,
0.5262888669967651,
0.281342476606369,
-0.6856284737586975,
0.012485794723033905,
0.11387839913368225,
-0.8022418022155762,
-0.8582577109336853,
0.10923174768686295,
0.5802565217018127,
0.44585248827934265,
0.6286007761955261,
-0.1303468495607376,
0.832048773765564,
-0.2993515133857727,
0.5364741086959839,
0.4223501682281494,
-1.0658706426620483,
0.7757952809333801,
-0.08689134567975998,
0.2259856015443802,
0.47883835434913635,
0.323347806930542,
-0.409017950296402,
-0.3081008493900299,
-0.5123335719108582,
-0.632270097732544,
0.5097545385360718,
-0.30393117666244507,
0.5687532424926758,
0.18495196104049683,
0.7736837863922119,
0.47231924533843994,
0.35124585032463074,
-0.6504267454147339,
-0.09780146926641464,
-0.3714470863342285,
-0.27878350019454956,
-0.02569865621626377,
-0.10536777228116989,
0.10807554423809052,
-0.5855374932289124,
0.4598561227321625,
-0.4392216205596924,
0.033217813819646835,
-0.019787756726145744,
-0.03277048468589783,
-0.3500955104827881,
0.33180972933769226,
0.5437779426574707,
0.9826611876487732,
0.04164491221308708,
0.08637043088674545,
0.2543448805809021,
-0.8543827533721924,
0.40108904242515564,
-0.13608099520206451,
-0.18292050063610077,
-0.354462206363678,
0.5175373554229736,
0.6343004107475281,
0.2003593146800995,
-0.7117155194282532,
0.3074222505092621,
-0.04929797723889351,
0.009932197630405426,
-0.13636621832847595,
0.690217912197113,
0.3111892640590668,
0.44888585805892944,
0.5548201203346252,
0.22185596823692322,
-0.1775808334350586,
-0.7215613722801208,
0.17454081773757935,
0.1369340866804123,
-0.421550989151001,
-0.7511793375015259,
0.7479515075683594,
0.09264414757490158,
-0.7754502892494202,
0.6148360967636108,
-0.09986866265535355,
-0.5639446377754211,
0.6288240551948547,
0.9369407296180725,
0.5793572664260864,
-0.49445033073425293,
0.4751911163330078,
0.35179540514945984,
-0.07654222100973129,
-0.34743520617485046,
0.5248451828956604,
-0.5097377896308899,
-0.5657417178153992,
-0.547561764717102,
-0.576473593711853,
-0.6037834286689758,
-0.0053871809504926205,
-0.7217389345169067,
0.3258031904697418,
-0.671890377998352,
-0.09752238541841507,
-0.09221678972244263,
0.3814789056777954,
-0.5593419075012207,
0.02251780964434147,
-0.0007270919741131365,
0.919468343257904,
-0.755057156085968,
1.4501357078552246,
0.986400306224823,
-0.5696130394935608,
-0.9040626883506775,
0.06349648535251617,
-0.17400045692920685,
-0.8580639362335205,
0.5959017276763916,
0.29927825927734375,
-0.05508828163146973,
0.2796369791030884,
-0.3987009525299072,
-0.34737178683280945,
1.2674825191497803,
0.8431490659713745,
-0.8737941384315491,
-0.0707286074757576,
0.01567542552947998,
0.6065390706062317,
-0.44400620460510254,
0.3655679523944855,
0.4746985137462616,
0.13948102295398712,
0.33773183822631836,
-0.5738286972045898,
-0.17588955163955688,
-0.2442692220211029,
0.18928386270999908,
0.1751290112733841,
-0.5302913188934326,
0.9907587766647339,
-0.6953020095825195,
0.1098966971039772,
-0.07753746211528778,
0.8387508988380432,
0.2499343901872635,
0.4461953938007355,
0.6116118431091309,
0.7825756669044495,
1.0979938507080078,
-0.054018307477235794,
0.7144337296485901,
0.18740080296993256,
0.476266473531723,
0.8028168082237244,
-0.06843137741088867,
0.8105912208557129,
0.5382378101348877,
-0.3708842992782593,
0.8303943276405334,
0.45283758640289307,
0.20680390298366547,
0.6996309757232666,
0.2134595364332199,
-0.26576074957847595,
-0.40790024399757385,
0.09472161531448364,
-0.43967869877815247,
0.3039877414703369,
0.3273386061191559,
0.06469215452671051,
-0.36006441712379456,
0.3676171898841858,
0.09298810362815857,
0.5617574453353882,
-0.4650375545024872,
0.4628763794898987,
0.11659185588359833,
-0.6403781771659851,
0.5871146321296692,
0.1915334165096283,
0.8184566497802734,
-0.7164732217788696,
-0.15932591259479523,
-0.35193854570388794,
0.37869367003440857,
0.08373317867517471,
-0.690285325050354,
0.24266356229782104,
0.05744848772883415,
-0.06710812449455261,
-0.0976850837469101,
0.6471490859985352,
-0.5279755592346191,
-0.43568155169487,
0.10874392837285995,
0.3249702453613281,
-0.30387410521507263,
0.33282795548439026,
-0.7201380729675293,
0.16705355048179626,
-0.030071794986724854,
-0.3664235770702362,
0.2825133800506592,
0.3108341693878174,
0.007860474288463593,
0.9348458647727966,
0.7280526757240295,
0.15986812114715576,
-0.04811897873878479,
0.1513855904340744,
1.237580418586731,
-0.5570454597473145,
-0.45048433542251587,
-0.8011900782585144,
0.508842945098877,
0.19067803025245667,
-0.49529150128364563,
0.42580053210258484,
0.2367570549249649,
1.1516218185424805,
0.02264104224741459,
0.32004526257514954,
0.06125583127140999,
0.3104107975959778,
-0.27447760105133057,
0.5085448026657104,
-0.31218022108078003,
0.6072802543640137,
-0.0049323877319693565,
-0.8980650901794434,
-0.12008073180913925,
0.9212295413017273,
-0.26689642667770386,
0.19442826509475708,
0.30564042925834656,
0.6293022632598877,
-0.2290787249803543,
0.11255205422639847,
0.3400699198246002,
0.13050119578838348,
0.5617162585258484,
0.6751468181610107,
0.7206854224205017,
-0.42383113503456116,
0.3078571856021881,
-0.43683212995529175,
-0.10389247536659241,
0.0001444879308110103,
-0.4257684051990509,
-1.060474157333374,
-0.8380592465400696,
-0.43071579933166504,
-0.26332464814186096,
0.2334711104631424,
1.0396766662597656,
0.7844592928886414,
-0.5789890289306641,
-0.14883045852184296,
-0.49891310930252075,
0.31460756063461304,
-0.07263670116662979,
-0.2013673335313797,
0.18315351009368896,
-0.631903886795044,
-0.9076653718948364,
0.4105219841003418,
-0.0010171853937208652,
0.01154278963804245,
-0.7148386836051941,
-0.5490005016326904,
-0.04485657438635826,
-0.07219201326370239,
0.2586931884288788,
0.2501099407672882,
-0.6103466749191284,
-0.05020865797996521,
0.20511455833911896,
-0.07175713032484055,
0.1458890289068222,
0.7374938130378723,
-1.2564542293548584,
0.824641764163971,
0.28354939818382263,
0.7967020273208618,
0.45004311203956604,
-0.17901863157749176,
0.39278849959373474,
-0.6059062480926514,
0.2723448872566223,
0.38841259479522705,
-0.09740660339593887,
0.33280330896377563,
-0.12972605228424072,
0.46912267804145813,
0.49224206805229187,
-0.36409544944763184,
-1.2112551927566528,
0.23996572196483612,
-0.7413163781166077,
-0.2166752815246582,
0.9327749013900757,
-0.3592638075351715,
-0.1771518737077713,
-0.16634036600589752,
-0.16230401396751404,
0.27867811918258667,
-0.4518309235572815,
0.8306549191474915,
0.5183862447738647,
0.30018723011016846,
-0.13558876514434814,
-0.6717877388000488,
0.07713742554187775,
0.3063202500343323,
-0.5030026435852051,
-0.3556673526763916,
0.0674910768866539,
0.7096423506736755,
-0.05102008953690529,
0.5496353507041931,
0.010882032103836536,
0.37667903304100037,
-0.13320551812648773,
-0.19897347688674927,
-0.6386358141899109,
-0.5424854159355164,
-0.5442463755607605,
0.41725942492485046,
0.19952555000782013,
-0.20499224960803986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15656v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15656v3 | LLsM: Generative Linguistic Steganography with Large Language Model | 2024-01-28T13:21:44 | 2024-04-08T03:50:39 | Yihao Wang, Ruiqi Song, Ru Zhang, Jianyi Liu, Lingxiao Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Linguistic Steganography (LS) tasks aim to generate steganographic text
(stego) based on secret information. Only authorized recipients can perceive
the existence of the stegos and extract secrets, thereby preserving privacy.
However, existing LS methods do not consider the controllable generation of
stegos containing specific discourses such as style, genre, and theme. And they
are difficult to simulate high-quality natural texts. As a result, the stegos
are easily perceived and detectable, compromising covert communication. This
paper proposes the LLsM, the first LS work with the Large Language Model (LLM).
Regarding open-source LLMs, we reconstruct the token generator of LLM to the
"stego generator" so that it can control the generation of stego based on the
secret. In this "stego generator", the candidate pool is encoded by range
coding, and the adjustment factor for the interval length is also given. The
secret determines the interval, thereby determining the next token. This better
simulates the distribution of natural texts and controls the adjustment of the
embedding rate. In addition, we preliminarily built an LLsM-c architecture for
closed-source LLMs. It encodes discourse to obtain high-quality prompts
containing discourse based on secrets, and generates pure natural texts
containing discourse. Experiments show that LLsM performs superior to prevalent
LS and related-task baselines regarding various kinds of concealment and
anti-steganalysis. LLsM's MAUVE surpasses baselines by 60%-80% and
anti-steganalysis exceeds baselines by 20%-30%. Notably, LLsM can also generate
longer stegos with high quality, showing its advantages in understanding and
coherence. | [
-0.17314916849136353,
-0.9178792238235474,
0.4659828841686249,
0.14308276772499084,
-0.6530908346176147,
0.0919950008392334,
-0.5109556317329407,
-0.34179791808128357,
0.4135681688785553,
0.7154070734977722,
-0.436024934053421,
-0.956399142742157,
-0.7032597661018372,
0.2819339334964752,
-0.6029167771339417,
0.6974486708641052,
0.015702182427048683,
0.16748613119125366,
0.24643252789974213,
0.14270935952663422,
0.04075867310166359,
-0.6061708927154541,
-0.506213366985321,
0.1355607956647873,
0.4038529098033905,
-0.1613035351037979,
0.721942663192749,
0.6973528861999512,
0.4258282780647278,
0.32232534885406494,
-0.44960278272628784,
0.31981638073921204,
-0.8044642806053162,
0.5774139761924744,
-0.12694332003593445,
-0.633938729763031,
-0.16832566261291504,
-0.349793940782547,
0.9715163707733154,
0.29989954829216003,
-0.058966100215911865,
-0.04492256045341492,
0.14685362577438354,
0.5432990193367004,
-0.4410474896430969,
0.21207481622695923,
-0.7435566782951355,
0.21933527290821075,
-0.6027655005455017,
-0.19607318937778473,
-0.5112630128860474,
-0.36338576674461365,
-0.4152302145957947,
-0.4914182424545288,
0.01519877277314663,
0.24274426698684692,
0.69505375623703,
0.09880651533603668,
-0.08784886449575424,
-0.3562052845954895,
-0.7506402134895325,
0.782626211643219,
-0.8302914500236511,
0.43877726793289185,
0.31568774580955505,
0.1825961172580719,
-0.18808463215827942,
-0.6292892098426819,
-0.3900708556175232,
-0.3773278594017029,
0.1909375935792923,
-0.04789711907505989,
-0.24296094477176666,
0.11459677666425705,
0.2817590832710266,
0.6663033962249756,
-0.4302736520767212,
0.3893696069717407,
-0.35935720801353455,
-0.40133678913116455,
0.46967560052871704,
0.14513914287090302,
0.1644742786884308,
-0.1269679069519043,
-0.434639036655426,
0.10172121971845627,
-1.0376569032669067,
-0.32243913412094116,
0.4896892011165619,
0.21026194095611572,
-0.053055357187986374,
0.754652202129364,
-0.15937285125255585,
0.436263769865036,
-0.2670978009700775,
-0.32520341873168945,
-0.05322464555501938,
-0.2558259963989258,
-0.32887229323387146,
-0.18049609661102295,
1.0296061038970947,
-0.04666439816355705,
0.176412895321846,
-0.0525309219956398,
-0.35541635751724243,
0.016086991876363754,
-0.00484928023070097,
-0.7466387748718262,
0.20154835283756256,
-0.18422165513038635,
-0.465871125459671,
-0.48864975571632385,
-0.14682549238204956,
-0.6986104846000671,
-0.3618127107620239,
-0.1768532544374466,
0.16351163387298584,
-0.3632945716381073,
-0.03584759682416916,
0.05931475758552551,
0.11515875905752182,
0.07639668136835098,
0.2964514195919037,
-0.764680802822113,
0.39700114727020264,
0.6123570799827576,
1.009213924407959,
-0.2977544069290161,
0.14220097661018372,
-0.5008063912391663,
0.3094833493232727,
-0.5064091086387634,
0.32223638892173767,
-0.32787543535232544,
-0.3897896409034729,
0.2337290346622467,
0.03776947408914566,
0.429362952709198,
-0.3978624939918518,
0.42780184745788574,
-0.7061460018157959,
0.1592901051044464,
-0.1171964704990387,
-0.7631711959838867,
0.22227387130260468,
-0.03866947814822197,
-0.7714279890060425,
0.8105261921882629,
-0.21798935532569885,
-0.6796863675117493,
0.05032755807042122,
-0.5013184547424316,
-0.20313061773777008,
0.4023919105529785,
-0.28718018531799316,
-0.4662841558456421,
0.053931526839733124,
-0.00555694242939353,
0.5144908428192139,
-0.30622759461402893,
0.5716213583946228,
-0.24729855358600616,
-0.39544677734375,
0.41504478454589844,
-0.7481691241264343,
0.8384456634521484,
0.38598060607910156,
-0.3527529239654541,
0.16717760264873505,
-0.2809676229953766,
-0.10886200517416,
0.36961260437965393,
-0.5218188166618347,
-0.25442349910736084,
-0.19578209519386292,
-0.33437469601631165,
-0.34884563088417053,
0.3023325204849243,
-0.532214343547821,
0.13180813193321228,
-0.6918660402297974,
0.4337288737297058,
0.8892252445220947,
0.06589408218860626,
0.5179219245910645,
-0.04949137941002846,
0.4401491582393646,
-0.33405250310897827,
0.3066641688346863,
-0.1679982990026474,
-0.6746043562889099,
-0.5995283126831055,
-0.4907004237174988,
0.25338852405548096,
0.3841571509838104,
-0.814982533454895,
0.4760051369667053,
-0.24272660911083221,
-0.2749195396900177,
-0.38159650564193726,
0.4265047609806061,
0.6033540368080139,
0.09997814893722534,
0.09194527566432953,
-0.2576947510242462,
-0.44250181317329407,
-0.9019564390182495,
-0.14424727857112885,
0.03550234064459801,
-0.05998590216040611,
0.09977744519710541,
0.4602079689502716,
0.09136682748794556,
0.5708523988723755,
-0.49306803941726685,
-0.35524091124534607,
-0.20976583659648895,
-0.08790037781000137,
0.19186878204345703,
0.21390534937381744,
0.41275814175605774,
-0.48674753308296204,
-0.2381047010421753,
-0.22026188671588898,
-0.8716912865638733,
-0.165796160697937,
0.3246340751647949,
-0.21479813754558563,
0.3117949068546295,
0.6463131904602051,
-0.6114048361778259,
0.3602498769760132,
0.6700868010520935,
-0.09010986983776093,
0.6531557440757751,
-0.16201603412628174,
-0.14285272359848022,
-1.1942740678787231,
-0.021484054625034332,
-0.2395886331796646,
-0.27996841073036194,
-0.7575235962867737,
0.3906812071800232,
-0.03458020091056824,
-0.338512659072876,
-0.6205013990402222,
0.5327087044715881,
-0.7291184663772583,
-0.17174801230430603,
-0.1998356580734253,
-0.029651837423443794,
-0.12497115135192871,
0.5134153962135315,
0.028152858838438988,
0.7035498023033142,
0.5921846628189087,
-0.34092262387275696,
0.5044282674789429,
0.1320129632949829,
-0.5066773295402527,
0.11333609372377396,
-0.37777090072631836,
0.2805291712284088,
-0.10039898008108139,
0.34609904885292053,
-0.7328881025314331,
-0.23303847014904022,
0.46606698632240295,
-0.25640836358070374,
0.403618186712265,
-0.22425375878810883,
-0.7820354104042053,
-0.22104576230049133,
-0.2965366840362549,
0.053292643278837204,
0.8003494739532471,
-0.3405473530292511,
0.17336973547935486,
0.3188450336456299,
-0.3282381594181061,
-0.6554340720176697,
-0.6959617137908936,
0.4208108186721802,
-0.08694488555192947,
-0.4663214385509491,
0.3246273696422577,
-0.068977490067482,
-0.2977834641933441,
-0.1325596421957016,
0.06316637247800827,
0.04621932655572891,
-0.1001570075750351,
0.3076048195362091,
0.29413968324661255,
-0.2297760248184204,
0.1454780101776123,
0.44405660033226013,
0.10183263570070267,
0.09774599969387054,
-0.22265717387199402,
0.7755342721939087,
-0.10019007325172424,
-0.618809700012207,
-0.4624069631099701,
0.41246992349624634,
0.3885299861431122,
-0.09916844218969345,
0.8236061334609985,
0.4315827786922455,
-0.39238229393959045,
-0.3846246302127838,
-0.39296773076057434,
-0.23713867366313934,
-0.511231005191803,
0.267915278673172,
-0.2349511682987213,
-1.110113501548767,
0.278803288936615,
-0.061019282788038254,
0.2782655656337738,
0.2916826903820038,
0.5814060568809509,
-0.04321233555674553,
0.6118550896644592,
0.3352755606174469,
-0.13460424542427063,
0.5201018452644348,
-0.3507959842681885,
-0.018230203539133072,
-0.5833526849746704,
-0.23870457708835602,
-0.3812108039855957,
-0.18147872388362885,
-0.1866508573293686,
-0.6985698342323303,
0.3722279667854309,
0.2688537836074829,
-0.19088619947433472,
0.15383878350257874,
-0.5175342559814453,
0.41436412930488586,
0.5642116665840149,
0.2795155942440033,
0.4777657687664032,
0.44056594371795654,
-0.1870308369398117,
-0.1863819658756256,
-0.4456152617931366,
-0.657067596912384,
1.1093525886535645,
0.5301623940467834,
1.0197194814682007,
0.09319822490215302,
1.0735231637954712,
0.36011743545532227,
0.452431321144104,
-0.6402519345283508,
0.9474397301673889,
-0.33999279141426086,
-0.5146867036819458,
-0.5360637307167053,
-0.41659194231033325,
-0.8476392030715942,
0.23580288887023926,
-0.20548802614212036,
-0.5008271932601929,
-0.12257598340511322,
0.0012535935966297984,
0.006333388853818178,
0.5942564606666565,
-0.28609415888786316,
0.23491787910461426,
-0.15182781219482422,
-0.490598201751709,
-0.03370916470885277,
-0.5731022357940674,
0.5155507922172546,
0.01114623062312603,
0.42160481214523315,
-0.06093200668692589,
-0.23285840451717377,
0.8567715883255005,
-0.26835450530052185,
1.3050018548965454,
-0.18597786128520966,
-0.5710324645042419,
0.20897601544857025,
0.42488569021224976,
0.8092710971832275,
0.008511531166732311,
-0.05353712663054466,
0.47017431259155273,
-0.5245599746704102,
0.02009066380560398,
-0.3891761004924774,
0.8335540890693665,
-0.49689364433288574,
-0.9018654823303223,
-0.032190583646297455,
-0.3529514968395233,
0.15899896621704102,
0.3487847149372101,
0.40052738785743713,
0.28876006603240967,
-0.28044775128364563,
0.3090352416038513,
0.9393274188041687,
-0.3199716806411743,
0.3472122550010681,
0.14772580564022064,
-0.44161197543144226,
-0.5879876017570496,
0.766757607460022,
-0.08532660454511642,
0.5183156728744507,
0.40044721961021423,
0.22430986166000366,
-0.31000086665153503,
-0.7025119066238403,
-0.49796760082244873,
0.3992276191711426,
-0.8883945345878601,
-0.4180620610713959,
-0.4327109456062317,
-0.5131378769874573,
-0.2623889148235321,
-0.16435521841049194,
-0.3566652834415436,
-0.23016369342803955,
-0.6060523986816406,
0.026004446670413017,
0.3210008442401886,
0.6644995808601379,
0.07782353460788727,
0.17784549295902252,
-0.5669450759887695,
0.5351568460464478,
0.24257902801036835,
0.20958681404590607,
-0.2899382412433624,
-0.6375710964202881,
0.03367433696985245,
0.15435558557510376,
-0.12484430521726608,
-1.1889392137527466,
0.5689493417739868,
0.0024332660250365734,
0.4630630612373352,
0.5967177152633667,
-0.08909755200147629,
0.3231694996356964,
-0.33829206228256226,
0.8384823203086853,
0.4214067757129669,
-1.0333482027053833,
0.48403170704841614,
-0.3608796298503876,
0.0040376861579716206,
0.10201618075370789,
0.13020087778568268,
-0.24200290441513062,
-0.8784711360931396,
-0.2679855227470398,
-0.6606109738349915,
0.5104517340660095,
0.5057346224784851,
0.34768587350845337,
0.14594429731369019,
0.28567782044410706,
0.26820164918899536,
0.2970696985721588,
-1.0883734226226807,
-0.25301530957221985,
-0.14080661535263062,
-0.28126341104507446,
0.04515942931175232,
-0.4047156572341919,
-0.49308282136917114,
-0.007849608547985554,
0.35470831394195557,
-0.05291955545544624,
0.36982715129852295,
-0.02510244958102703,
-0.12463244050741196,
-0.12308986485004425,
0.47437143325805664,
0.6940785646438599,
0.16081449389457703,
0.15760323405265808,
0.48735079169273376,
0.22138944268226624,
-0.35290759801864624,
0.13961105048656464,
-0.3130281865596771,
-0.41599804162979126,
0.20517799258232117,
0.4513183534145355,
0.9872719049453735,
0.18246722221374512,
-0.6041203141212463,
0.6208456754684448,
0.3488643169403076,
-0.4556393623352051,
-0.25612178444862366,
0.20223495364189148,
0.2833899259567261,
0.21198312938213348,
0.3041456639766693,
-0.20011992752552032,
-0.030526818707585335,
-0.5060217380523682,
-0.06706789135932922,
0.6979228258132935,
-0.04391824081540108,
-0.22094440460205078,
0.5904117226600647,
0.11141893267631531,
-0.4763730466365814,
0.17146353423595428,
-0.26089802384376526,
-0.45938992500305176,
0.45189929008483887,
0.8751475214958191,
0.7546718716621399,
-0.39375537633895874,
0.22522105276584625,
0.2655967175960541,
0.4385847747325897,
-0.16731354594230652,
0.3205576539039612,
-0.08998486399650574,
-0.4606928825378418,
-0.3204496204853058,
-0.9419335126876831,
-0.2101876586675644,
0.3096567988395691,
-0.3500629961490631,
0.11943157762289047,
-0.5895902514457703,
0.037315525114536285,
-0.41823503375053406,
-0.32544028759002686,
-0.28581157326698303,
-0.12878067791461945,
0.3688214123249054,
0.811980128288269,
-0.7249347567558289,
0.8356068730354309,
0.07843365520238876,
0.02727477252483368,
-0.49387961626052856,
-0.2228640764951706,
-0.12121356278657913,
-1.2371625900268555,
0.7614821791648865,
-0.11874828487634659,
-0.17320920526981354,
0.019627971574664116,
-0.841492235660553,
-0.8993195295333862,
1.206036925315857,
0.6358856558799744,
-0.9342116117477417,
-0.2655584514141083,
0.30238351225852966,
0.5809201598167419,
-0.31262168288230896,
-0.419204980134964,
-0.030306022614240646,
0.488440603017807,
0.1605587601661682,
-0.7482810020446777,
0.4553709328174591,
0.06933815777301788,
0.11371508240699768,
0.2408217042684555,
-0.3715861439704895,
0.8080924153327942,
-0.10389336198568344,
-0.6549148559570312,
0.3118593096733093,
0.5421927571296692,
0.45314863324165344,
0.08506245166063309,
0.2382693588733673,
0.4031701385974884,
0.5847316980361938,
-0.06597006320953369,
0.8183726668357849,
-0.17365971207618713,
0.23496167361736298,
0.768165111541748,
-0.14346134662628174,
0.7317068576812744,
0.46483859419822693,
-0.17518466711044312,
0.4133290648460388,
0.195834681391716,
-0.09865811467170715,
0.5116904973983765,
0.5612828135490417,
-0.4138365089893341,
-0.05979589372873306,
0.03764808177947998,
-0.5644017457962036,
0.08701135963201523,
0.5710141062736511,
-0.8055946826934814,
-0.10541632771492004,
0.11371783912181854,
0.08080223202705383,
0.04941389709711075,
-0.29412826895713806,
0.8090638518333435,
0.38418281078338623,
-0.3727817237377167,
0.8569567799568176,
0.11998442560434341,
0.7662727236747742,
-0.8423769474029541,
0.07660942524671555,
-0.13447248935699463,
-0.15819427371025085,
-0.041883472353219986,
-0.87274169921875,
0.10095880925655365,
0.12719674408435822,
0.25117024779319763,
-0.5205246210098267,
0.9936379194259644,
-0.5110344886779785,
-0.30137383937835693,
0.31869223713874817,
0.36238399147987366,
0.3491052985191345,
0.0013167751021683216,
-0.5576827526092529,
0.39942705631256104,
-0.028231637552380562,
-0.379840612411499,
0.23551827669143677,
0.22501561045646667,
-0.11265718936920166,
0.6545745730400085,
0.947661817073822,
0.39038383960723877,
0.23622030019760132,
0.20930160582065582,
0.8957078456878662,
-0.5600830912590027,
-0.4748390316963196,
-1.0257574319839478,
-0.053237397223711014,
-0.18079112470149994,
0.022166330367326736,
0.7443559169769287,
0.46091198921203613,
0.38343846797943115,
-0.2011900395154953,
0.6786847710609436,
0.23453104496002197,
0.10965070128440857,
-0.8729777932167053,
0.6815449595451355,
-0.41241246461868286,
0.3352281153202057,
-0.16152971982955933,
-0.9324840903282166,
-0.3001026511192322,
0.21137075126171112,
-0.07662410289049149,
-0.22323352098464966,
0.637284517288208,
0.9740187525749207,
0.02410038933157921,
-0.086543969810009,
0.5287076234817505,
0.2831820547580719,
0.24982888996601105,
0.4343406558036804,
0.929635226726532,
-0.03266908600926399,
0.64275062084198,
-0.02335580624639988,
-0.2922803461551666,
-0.2116381824016571,
-0.5493858456611633,
-0.9603248834609985,
-0.4483676254749298,
0.08685022592544556,
-0.2590077221393585,
0.2304561883211136,
0.42794591188430786,
0.4727470874786377,
-0.42157989740371704,
-0.23242315649986267,
-0.36844855546951294,
0.09475371986627579,
0.08710993826389313,
-0.2207079976797104,
0.30660760402679443,
-0.08776255697011948,
-0.6937382817268372,
0.5723954439163208,
0.5805379748344421,
0.3704407513141632,
-0.786041796207428,
-0.26163458824157715,
0.15897175669670105,
0.11488361656665802,
0.4923943281173706,
0.16957569122314453,
-1.106581449508667,
0.02241830714046955,
0.14297117292881012,
-0.3260522186756134,
-0.06431054323911667,
0.7901474237442017,
-0.17520467936992645,
0.27241480350494385,
0.4342718720436096,
0.34631288051605225,
0.699022114276886,
-0.35914626717567444,
0.3415955603122711,
-0.860061526298523,
0.0922192707657814,
0.3097623884677887,
0.46604061126708984,
0.12118881195783615,
-0.4232596457004547,
0.11947010457515717,
0.3591206669807434,
-0.2546537220478058,
-0.9828290939331055,
0.47769472002983093,
-0.8665018081665039,
-0.4835119843482971,
1.512413501739502,
-0.2910057604312897,
-0.3065054416656494,
-0.03868390992283821,
-0.3220171332359314,
0.31451287865638733,
-0.35939884185791016,
0.5890672206878662,
0.4624665677547455,
0.3466378152370453,
-0.046393316239118576,
-0.3277558982372284,
0.4867123067378998,
0.29546427726745605,
-0.8428570032119751,
0.15235354006290436,
0.48542454838752747,
0.35225674510002136,
0.1877700239419937,
0.8186666965484619,
-0.30313900113105774,
-0.16120685636997223,
-0.0031877632718533278,
-0.053303491324186325,
-0.29066190123558044,
-0.2597073018550873,
-0.21051792800426483,
0.576617419719696,
-0.07973406463861465,
-0.08398091793060303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15641v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15641v2 | PRE: A Peer Review Based Large Language Model Evaluator | 2024-01-28T12:33:14 | 2024-06-03T11:11:13 | Zhumin Chu, Qingyao Ai, Yiteng Tu, Haitao Li, Yiqun Liu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | The impressive performance of large language models (LLMs) has attracted
considerable attention from the academic and industrial communities. Besides
how to construct and train LLMs, how to effectively evaluate and compare the
capacity of LLMs has also been well recognized as an important yet difficult
problem. Existing paradigms rely on either human annotators or model-based
evaluators to evaluate the performance of LLMs on different tasks. However,
these paradigms often suffer from high cost, low generalizability, and
inherited biases in practice, which make them incapable of supporting the
sustainable development of LLMs in long term. In order to address these issues,
inspired by the peer review systems widely used in academic publication
process, we propose a novel framework that can automatically evaluate LLMs
through a peer-review process. Specifically, for the evaluation of a specific
task, we first construct a small qualification exam to select "reviewers" from
a couple of powerful LLMs. Then, to actually evaluate the "submissions" written
by different candidate LLMs, i.e., the evaluatees, we use the reviewer LLMs to
rate or compare the submissions. The final ranking of evaluatee LLMs is
generated based on the results provided by all reviewers. We conducted
extensive experiments on text summarization tasks with eleven LLMs including
GPT-4. The results demonstrate the existence of biasness when evaluating using
a single LLM. Also, our PRE model outperforms all the baselines, illustrating
the effectiveness of the peer review mechanism. | [
-0.2757534086704254,
-0.5962746143341064,
0.8636397123336792,
0.3500167727470398,
-0.36977896094322205,
-0.011997606605291367,
-0.5636709332466125,
-0.27732613682746887,
0.16787798702716827,
0.4379562437534332,
-0.1766277402639389,
-0.47015678882598877,
-0.7162566781044006,
0.5416618585586548,
-0.47017356753349304,
1.1831059455871582,
-0.18296018242835999,
0.25234755873680115,
-0.3554029166698456,
0.06431834399700165,
-0.17316974699497223,
-0.40570327639579773,
-0.3929443955421448,
-0.5349960327148438,
0.33356934785842896,
-0.03141225129365921,
0.4427657723426819,
0.11221124231815338,
0.650169312953949,
0.3618135452270508,
-0.19331671297550201,
-0.061331942677497864,
-0.5006861686706543,
-0.12612180411815643,
-0.22509686648845673,
-0.2564318776130676,
-0.7576251029968262,
0.2890579402446747,
0.9077913761138916,
0.545579195022583,
-0.0554874986410141,
0.3899708688259125,
0.3679905831813812,
0.6297999620437622,
-0.4776301383972168,
0.13228879868984222,
-0.6419754028320312,
-0.05198834463953972,
-0.12801353633403778,
0.051221899688243866,
-0.4722716212272644,
-0.5985466241836548,
0.16759692132472992,
-0.2652972638607025,
-0.010628446005284786,
-0.0906410962343216,
0.5974447131156921,
0.11916173994541168,
-0.18929670751094818,
-0.1958368420600891,
-0.5562710165977478,
0.6740792393684387,
-0.9106869101524353,
0.3227936327457428,
0.11887916922569275,
0.17355631291866302,
0.07918663322925568,
-0.6847391724586487,
-0.6737924218177795,
-0.5038590431213379,
-0.00601500179618597,
0.009238443337380886,
0.20433618128299713,
0.0811052918434143,
0.032117266207933426,
0.4253609776496887,
-0.63729327917099,
0.15661638975143433,
-0.12696702778339386,
-0.1722673624753952,
0.5607174038887024,
0.05408501625061035,
-0.012059773318469524,
-0.295317143201828,
-0.2548106908798218,
0.18774303793907166,
-0.7572424411773682,
-0.14678485691547394,
0.46324941515922546,
0.0658901184797287,
0.10866179317235947,
0.4461859464645386,
-0.1497236043214798,
0.7673397064208984,
0.08294694125652313,
-0.10099051892757416,
0.3921656310558319,
-0.4437972903251648,
-0.2549516558647156,
-0.24320201575756073,
1.101433515548706,
0.2053043693304062,
0.2985460162162781,
0.007296067196875811,
-0.4770296812057495,
-0.009766573086380959,
0.23766294121742249,
-0.9392662644386292,
0.06308167427778244,
0.1602233201265335,
-0.6802422404289246,
-0.45733633637428284,
-0.022249169647693634,
-0.7139996290206909,
-0.24983760714530945,
-0.22210854291915894,
0.5782055258750916,
0.1493356078863144,
-0.13844579458236694,
0.152169331908226,
0.2914028763771057,
-0.06366836279630661,
0.411903977394104,
-0.5038225054740906,
0.3646964430809021,
0.615397572517395,
0.8508375287055969,
-0.3323647379875183,
-0.33586373925209045,
-0.41247156262397766,
0.022019239142537117,
-0.19519376754760742,
0.7533921599388123,
-0.6550344824790955,
-0.3243217468261719,
-0.07163860648870468,
-0.06038656085729599,
0.22687815129756927,
-0.3887747526168823,
0.6751114130020142,
-0.703540027141571,
0.3022612929344177,
-0.1823229193687439,
-0.5434858202934265,
0.054524388164281845,
0.5051472783088684,
-0.6437548398971558,
0.635340690612793,
-0.010781900957226753,
-0.7659271359443665,
0.40798184275627136,
-0.617431640625,
-0.2604992389678955,
0.20717675983905792,
-0.19521699845790863,
-0.5964190363883972,
0.03027363494038582,
0.27675747871398926,
0.5481855869293213,
-0.695794939994812,
0.6149898767471313,
-0.3094059228897095,
-0.5512254238128662,
0.07576556503772736,
-0.32218635082244873,
0.5048650503158569,
0.13393917679786682,
-0.27434593439102173,
0.3989160358905792,
-0.5711820721626282,
0.027876636013388634,
0.06648003309965134,
-0.634628176689148,
-0.14013276994228363,
-0.023075928911566734,
-0.02667776495218277,
0.05746224522590637,
0.41377314925193787,
-0.5010321736335754,
0.21124088764190674,
-0.31205427646636963,
0.5435960292816162,
0.8360190987586975,
-0.09042321890592575,
0.3997074365615845,
-0.3309969902038574,
0.6433351039886475,
-0.451321005821228,
0.22333122789859772,
-0.3084137737751007,
-0.29754823446273804,
-0.6414873600006104,
-0.1774362325668335,
0.5094549655914307,
0.35052767395973206,
-0.599414050579071,
0.7200835347175598,
-0.39109882712364197,
-0.5970253944396973,
-0.38092535734176636,
0.37489956617355347,
0.5950556397438049,
0.2517209053039551,
0.07806101441383362,
-0.42351987957954407,
-0.4128651022911072,
-0.7938623428344727,
-0.2639554440975189,
-0.43123292922973633,
-0.08297299593687057,
0.2114279568195343,
0.5002134442329407,
-0.1473749577999115,
0.9264401793479919,
-0.28902944922447205,
-0.3406412899494171,
-0.42449668049812317,
0.140459805727005,
0.4751564860343933,
0.2958116829395294,
0.3401951193809509,
-0.5674996972084045,
-0.3915709853172302,
-0.3329024016857147,
-0.6473246216773987,
-0.5630148649215698,
-0.05049237981438637,
0.07809783518314362,
-0.03830457851290703,
0.4993947744369507,
-0.5380979776382446,
0.025699641555547714,
0.6239852905273438,
-0.205061674118042,
0.8618812561035156,
-0.27121788263320923,
0.17744123935699463,
-0.7247027158737183,
0.2112770974636078,
0.17380467057228088,
-0.3807799518108368,
-0.15583723783493042,
0.062271732836961746,
0.12394147366285324,
-0.08035970479249954,
-0.3557298481464386,
0.5361250042915344,
-0.46456900238990784,
-0.12397542595863342,
-0.28429052233695984,
0.301615446805954,
0.15861693024635315,
0.2120772749185562,
0.1409400999546051,
0.599632978439331,
0.2285301685333252,
-0.4112999439239502,
0.29267480969429016,
0.11119182407855988,
-0.6693469285964966,
0.42096564173698425,
-0.9385926127433777,
0.23038384318351746,
-0.2617819905281067,
0.5572138428688049,
-0.8739228844642639,
0.10416606068611145,
0.026241594925522804,
-0.088551364839077,
0.26373735070228577,
-0.047874514013528824,
-0.5662452578544617,
-0.43823108077049255,
-0.38993996381759644,
0.26568377017974854,
0.38899338245391846,
-0.34995830059051514,
0.6439812779426575,
0.41322019696235657,
-0.5709900259971619,
-0.49910423159599304,
-0.35785219073295593,
0.2977636456489563,
-0.007131744641810656,
-0.42129525542259216,
0.09714636951684952,
-0.2816940248012543,
-0.2986536920070648,
-0.07244528084993362,
0.02054661139845848,
0.222415953874588,
-0.009883569553494453,
0.08409955352544785,
0.37571296095848083,
-0.025084007531404495,
0.18648047745227814,
0.014060217887163162,
-0.08411723375320435,
0.16566163301467896,
-0.35234516859054565,
0.4999846816062927,
-0.23417121171951294,
-0.48583361506462097,
-0.3314993381500244,
-0.014706369489431381,
0.5640273094177246,
-0.4189266562461853,
0.3631764352321625,
0.212257981300354,
-0.07095397263765335,
-0.2625846862792969,
-1.0045181512832642,
-0.12024728208780289,
-0.45430782437324524,
0.6413019895553589,
-0.3101813793182373,
-0.9222376942634583,
0.20336923003196716,
-0.11852434277534485,
0.17737886309623718,
0.3096218407154083,
0.7860335111618042,
0.26158007979393005,
0.7744445204734802,
0.4962039589881897,
-0.2209593653678894,
0.3248229920864105,
-0.04401760175824165,
0.2578752934932709,
-0.7975246906280518,
-0.144077867269516,
-0.616468608379364,
-0.28237980604171753,
-0.2368454933166504,
-0.45412084460258484,
0.5129452347755432,
0.05153024569153786,
-0.22865718603134155,
0.1875106245279312,
-0.4734525680541992,
0.6886946558952332,
0.11718303710222244,
-0.04191625118255615,
0.6563973426818848,
-0.3127664625644684,
-0.2161189317703247,
0.03952658921480179,
-0.39056554436683655,
-1.0908448696136475,
1.3750859498977661,
0.5714861750602722,
0.834246039390564,
-0.05686706304550171,
0.6769110560417175,
0.3613588809967041,
0.9984777569770813,
-0.6135109663009644,
0.7776110172271729,
-0.11368546634912491,
-0.573897123336792,
-0.44458070397377014,
-0.4570416808128357,
-0.3997155427932739,
0.5374311208724976,
-0.2441844344139099,
-0.4814075231552124,
-0.10883520543575287,
-0.064226895570755,
-0.23369261622428894,
0.23648540675640106,
-0.5613923668861389,
0.7620530128479004,
-0.3833133578300476,
-0.49953433871269226,
-0.19974331557750702,
-0.3485810458660126,
0.4640887379646301,
-0.5965101718902588,
0.4413520097732544,
-0.09794489294290543,
-0.19380828738212585,
0.8608472943305969,
-0.26821473240852356,
0.7432459592819214,
-0.20564033091068268,
-0.20339776575565338,
0.19751808047294617,
0.11381211131811142,
0.5444391369819641,
0.23111502826213837,
-0.3297058045864105,
0.2801057696342468,
-0.060850776731967926,
0.015311196446418762,
-0.5596174001693726,
0.6345091462135315,
-0.626496434211731,
-0.7314413189888,
-0.4098531901836395,
-0.2635091543197632,
-0.3148646950721741,
0.38937807083129883,
0.0745762288570404,
0.11991333216428757,
-0.4495258331298828,
0.04231265187263489,
0.2839920222759247,
-0.2940731942653656,
0.37353190779685974,
0.8764693140983582,
-0.6105425357818604,
-0.3559812903404236,
0.6395284533500671,
-0.15151485800743103,
0.12312769144773483,
0.27507561445236206,
0.421561598777771,
-0.29872995615005493,
-0.8985958099365234,
-0.30597707629203796,
0.3237282335758209,
-0.6230753064155579,
-0.09531443566083908,
-0.7889772653579712,
-0.06856703013181686,
-0.3335226774215698,
-0.025790294632315636,
-0.30950120091438293,
-0.08204055577516556,
-0.04320650175213814,
-0.10129912942647934,
-0.25303351879119873,
1.086151361465454,
0.1146080493927002,
0.16436375677585602,
-0.8161931037902832,
0.1534838229417801,
0.4437360167503357,
0.4824512004852295,
0.1725817620754242,
-0.6406424641609192,
-0.0864279493689537,
-0.30836057662963867,
-0.3244464695453644,
-0.6865601539611816,
0.2666429281234741,
0.17183181643486023,
0.5794031023979187,
0.47076359391212463,
-0.16231520473957062,
0.24260585010051727,
-0.8066138625144958,
0.7497915625572205,
0.10949833691120148,
-1.2579329013824463,
0.3708205223083496,
-0.26269808411598206,
0.1776106059551239,
0.6838983297348022,
0.4310685396194458,
-0.23758049309253693,
-0.5682267546653748,
-0.2996830344200134,
-0.7083564400672913,
0.5080094933509827,
0.11997830122709274,
0.16290703415870667,
0.1660497635602951,
0.40315935015678406,
0.23229055106639862,
0.4046809673309326,
-1.0282883644104004,
0.1087309718132019,
0.040697257965803146,
-0.09930982440710068,
-0.4617334306240082,
-0.5750554203987122,
0.090054951608181,
-0.11589473485946655,
0.8085662126541138,
-0.07467391341924667,
-0.13150456547737122,
0.1696179360151291,
-0.2510674297809601,
-0.03522864729166031,
0.5191416144371033,
0.2644819915294647,
0.9225193858146667,
-0.24885982275009155,
0.07392942160367966,
0.20366273820400238,
-0.451982706785202,
0.31509116291999817,
0.11210454255342484,
-0.3014833331108093,
0.016913453117012978,
0.4532806873321533,
0.38673919439315796,
0.24885690212249756,
-0.7645509243011475,
0.8388652801513672,
-0.17737258970737457,
-0.11301838606595993,
-0.2605530023574829,
-0.2291431427001953,
0.18911252915859222,
0.21767477691173553,
0.3111075758934021,
-0.32919925451278687,
0.15993136167526245,
-0.4309747815132141,
0.2607947885990143,
0.45535632967948914,
-0.1975848227739334,
-0.34776249527931213,
0.6028001308441162,
0.6494583487510681,
-0.2157224416732788,
0.26104506850242615,
-0.29254505038261414,
-0.7176971435546875,
0.3555205166339874,
0.38081350922584534,
0.8019721508026123,
-0.2294953465461731,
0.20868627727031708,
0.24433040618896484,
0.5263254642486572,
-0.3042699992656708,
0.18382878601551056,
-0.028136758133769035,
-0.6695072650909424,
-0.8521735072135925,
-1.0578125715255737,
-0.4556969404220581,
0.3086364269256592,
-0.38853731751441956,
0.37837961316108704,
-0.46692219376564026,
-0.36541926860809326,
-0.10488399118185043,
0.09381649643182755,
-0.5155551433563232,
0.005582242738455534,
0.14304588735103607,
0.9105610847473145,
-0.9741976261138916,
0.6830765604972839,
0.7133683562278748,
-0.28200992941856384,
-0.4740229547023773,
0.07823003828525543,
-0.13844557106494904,
-0.5367733836174011,
0.9103986024856567,
0.18152499198913574,
-0.10278597474098206,
-0.16325953602790833,
-0.35203295946121216,
-0.6794002056121826,
0.7144694328308105,
0.4417383670806885,
-0.9876624941825867,
-0.19853830337524414,
-0.052602894604206085,
0.664138913154602,
-0.3610267639160156,
0.6270432472229004,
0.44480210542678833,
0.6361792683601379,
-0.1775103062391281,
-1.332721471786499,
0.0560016930103302,
-0.35006842017173767,
-0.02144179493188858,
0.015738679096102715,
-0.7025366425514221,
0.8737016320228577,
-0.11877881735563278,
-0.017735455185174942,
0.08619433641433716,
0.4946866035461426,
0.3478643596172333,
0.11098834127187729,
0.6342232823371887,
0.4400732219219208,
0.4634060263633728,
0.0450860820710659,
1.0772712230682373,
-0.4566255211830139,
0.4925777316093445,
1.2100070714950562,
-0.7195546627044678,
0.7561901211738586,
0.346405953168869,
-0.4633502662181854,
0.4027383327484131,
0.24769161641597748,
-0.07321077585220337,
0.2801542282104492,
0.5921900868415833,
-0.1002906933426857,
-0.3627272844314575,
-0.08115442842245102,
-0.2321518361568451,
0.4130396246910095,
0.03893427550792694,
-0.46867796778678894,
-0.2305918186903,
-0.05146829038858414,
-0.0661691203713417,
0.22750572860240936,
-0.303687185049057,
0.6764770150184631,
0.1633109748363495,
-0.5995942950248718,
0.2519195079803467,
0.18674275279045105,
0.911686360836029,
-0.7714858055114746,
0.03513927012681961,
0.1626378297805786,
0.12951748073101044,
-0.21838931739330292,
-0.6425446271896362,
0.1035858541727066,
0.30484291911125183,
-0.09885919839143753,
-0.42234739661216736,
0.6674461960792542,
-0.30991190671920776,
-0.6463025808334351,
0.2949892282485962,
0.6900025606155396,
0.14329840242862701,
-0.1363002508878708,
-0.5002723336219788,
0.41079947352409363,
-0.22414030134677887,
-0.5009725689888,
0.3046557605266571,
0.14299672842025757,
0.028778811916708946,
0.6042270064353943,
0.6079049706459045,
0.5641563534736633,
-0.38179293274879456,
0.28235819935798645,
0.7700111865997314,
-0.3531140983104706,
-0.7121052742004395,
-0.9219512343406677,
0.18178516626358032,
-0.01854253187775612,
-0.1911795735359192,
0.7442301511764526,
0.584886908531189,
0.7883865833282471,
0.0836545079946518,
0.9339642524719238,
0.1418522149324417,
0.6333332657814026,
-0.4786280393600464,
1.0060572624206543,
-0.39900949597358704,
0.48356929421424866,
-0.6193650364875793,
-1.3491246700286865,
-0.21702006459236145,
0.7054910659790039,
-0.6084874272346497,
0.3322337865829468,
0.7297102808952332,
0.5464756488800049,
0.26364073157310486,
0.00474646408110857,
0.24835781753063202,
0.3366736173629761,
0.4568853974342346,
0.5311422944068909,
0.9067769050598145,
-0.06505117565393448,
0.40798577666282654,
0.09071066230535507,
-0.4006955623626709,
-0.02236466109752655,
-1.2140780687332153,
-1.12697172164917,
-0.42374810576438904,
-0.1341017335653305,
-0.2248600721359253,
0.08053229749202728,
0.9422142505645752,
0.6693992614746094,
-0.7372603416442871,
-0.2968859076499939,
0.15878428518772125,
0.020642632618546486,
0.24927130341529846,
-0.19347810745239258,
0.42359083890914917,
-0.24444690346717834,
-0.8935635089874268,
0.29412317276000977,
0.2945133447647095,
-0.17925159633159637,
-0.6963216662406921,
-0.09144158661365509,
0.08419244736433029,
-0.005920717492699623,
0.5608469247817993,
-0.2474212646484375,
-0.636268138885498,
-0.04624234512448311,
-0.44432172179222107,
-0.05117901787161827,
-0.20291782915592194,
0.9702152013778687,
-0.9004173874855042,
0.39179250597953796,
0.6218822002410889,
0.6510704159736633,
0.269249826669693,
-0.11527467519044876,
0.6025812029838562,
-0.26384761929512024,
-0.10463248193264008,
0.46113601326942444,
0.45303305983543396,
0.3519064784049988,
-0.17930778861045837,
0.3585290312767029,
0.028912797570228577,
-0.6661574244499207,
-0.9105892181396484,
-0.017250962555408478,
-0.6282037496566772,
-0.20229782164096832,
1.1727449893951416,
-0.28009194135665894,
-0.04164482653141022,
0.04173269867897034,
-0.10384170711040497,
-0.01979399099946022,
-0.3792802691459656,
0.8862464427947998,
0.8523287773132324,
0.15874870121479034,
0.05088145285844803,
-0.3106289803981781,
0.356153666973114,
0.44874057173728943,
-0.8688976168632507,
-0.03208799660205841,
0.44406813383102417,
0.4646465480327606,
0.15974083542823792,
0.9017267823219299,
-0.3663274943828583,
0.005336377304047346,
-0.4880318343639374,
0.21068893373012543,
-0.32101380825042725,
-0.25732895731925964,
-0.6145755052566528,
0.32276493310928345,
0.3335610628128052,
0.48420649766921997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15635v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15635v2 | RecDCL: Dual Contrastive Learning for Recommendation | 2024-01-28T11:51:09 | 2024-02-19T03:09:40 | Dan Zhang, Yangliao Geng, Wenwen Gong, Zhongang Qi, Zhiyu Chen, Xing Tang, Ying Shan, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Self-supervised learning (SSL) has recently achieved great success in mining
the user-item interactions for collaborative filtering. As a major paradigm,
contrastive learning (CL) based SSL helps address data sparsity in Web
platforms by contrasting the embeddings between raw and augmented data.
However, existing CL-based methods mostly focus on contrasting in a batch-wise
way, failing to exploit potential regularity in the feature dimension. This
leads to redundant solutions during the representation learning of users and
items. In this work, we investigate how to employ both batch-wise CL (BCL) and
feature-wise CL (FCL) for recommendation. We theoretically analyze the relation
between BCL and FCL, and find that combining BCL and FCL helps eliminate
redundant solutions but never misses an optimal solution. We propose a dual
contrastive learning recommendation framework -- RecDCL. In RecDCL, the FCL
objective is designed to eliminate redundant solutions on user-item positive
pairs and to optimize the uniform distributions within users and items using a
polynomial kernel for driving the representations to be orthogonal; The BCL
objective is utilized to generate contrastive embeddings on output vectors for
enhancing the robustness of the representations. Extensive experiments on four
widely-used benchmarks and one industry dataset demonstrate that RecDCL can
consistently outperform the state-of-the-art GNNs-based and SSL-based models
(with an improvement of up to 5.65\% in terms of Recall@20). The source code is
publicly available (https://github.com/THUDM/RecDCL). | [
-0.5719749927520752,
-0.35056960582733154,
0.26457884907722473,
0.07317662984132767,
-0.28475287556648254,
0.20105251669883728,
-0.07394368201494217,
-0.4173519015312195,
0.1364993005990982,
0.5269469618797302,
-0.7003262042999268,
-0.6645370125770569,
-0.09303753823041916,
-0.05279402434825897,
-0.20983098447322845,
1.4280675649642944,
0.1326463371515274,
0.06040428578853607,
-0.3093990981578827,
-0.5476746559143066,
-0.7947113513946533,
-0.5657227039337158,
-0.6993582248687744,
-0.4747118055820465,
0.5570216774940491,
0.38244950771331787,
0.48108264803886414,
0.400954931974411,
0.42454424500465393,
0.3313443958759308,
0.12169981002807617,
0.4051682651042938,
-0.8489586114883423,
0.3931160271167755,
-0.5911478400230408,
-0.026069331914186478,
-0.01453788485378027,
-0.02460814267396927,
0.11542053520679474,
0.623619556427002,
-0.44498154520988464,
0.008386311121284962,
0.6043053865432739,
1.0737557411193848,
-0.6127803325653076,
-0.038070306181907654,
-0.5338010787963867,
0.12163103371858597,
0.1484735906124115,
-0.006783396005630493,
-0.2720463275909424,
-0.1655736267566681,
0.4295262396335602,
-0.5708214640617371,
0.535879909992218,
0.21314001083374023,
0.38581231236457825,
0.12194807082414627,
-0.31769654154777527,
-0.3072004020214081,
-0.5753699541091919,
1.0377824306488037,
-0.30369481444358826,
0.573666512966156,
0.3165558874607086,
0.2928462028503418,
0.09442394226789474,
-0.8904294371604919,
-0.22684340178966522,
-0.16016730666160583,
-0.370484858751297,
0.20726031064987183,
-0.11663537472486496,
-0.14242689311504364,
-0.03500870242714882,
0.5525161027908325,
-0.6490204334259033,
0.16007398068904877,
-0.3337138891220093,
-0.2108796238899231,
0.5323809385299683,
0.19695954024791718,
-0.037576958537101746,
0.29276469349861145,
-0.8123406767845154,
-0.09427805244922638,
-0.4484136402606964,
-0.03846303001046181,
0.1153794527053833,
0.4713042080402374,
-0.2961047887802124,
0.023790733888745308,
-0.031639281660318375,
0.37542960047721863,
0.586211621761322,
0.4033830463886261,
0.422134667634964,
-0.7697222232818604,
-0.21563273668289185,
-0.13202893733978271,
0.6694268584251404,
0.5642125606536865,
0.11525752395391464,
-0.04213881492614746,
-0.286477267742157,
-0.07259339839220047,
0.45130059123039246,
-0.6059108376502991,
-0.7252200841903687,
0.1642271727323532,
-0.46364185214042664,
-0.3744119703769684,
-0.047799840569496155,
-0.7394329309463501,
-0.7002778649330139,
-0.35139545798301697,
0.26259782910346985,
-0.22603334486484528,
-0.11053342372179031,
-0.10706932097673416,
0.13851311802864075,
-0.3041714131832123,
0.27907511591911316,
-0.9863612651824951,
0.41649723052978516,
0.36210814118385315,
0.6373785734176636,
-0.406282514333725,
-0.27323615550994873,
-0.5457105040550232,
-0.07358048111200333,
-0.10588539391756058,
0.7509488463401794,
-0.36652708053588867,
-0.6182103753089905,
0.2224169671535492,
-0.1738395094871521,
0.4426572918891907,
-0.6019731760025024,
0.31714722514152527,
-0.4264265298843384,
0.1690058708190918,
-0.5025796294212341,
-0.35483282804489136,
-0.3061738610267639,
0.08701998740434647,
-0.7942973971366882,
0.8304595947265625,
0.1253044456243515,
-0.6620543003082275,
0.5539936423301697,
-0.24346251785755157,
-0.4648180305957794,
0.07050859928131104,
-0.24399448931217194,
-0.5724213719367981,
-0.22286738455295563,
0.2697802484035492,
0.5288514494895935,
-0.266489177942276,
0.03422003611922264,
-0.6977230310440063,
-0.4921972155570984,
0.08017286658287048,
-0.3661186993122101,
0.44980353116989136,
0.3933335244655609,
-0.09091650694608688,
0.3265768885612488,
-0.554103672504425,
-0.2661125957965851,
0.12212628871202469,
-0.16207227110862732,
-0.2809807062149048,
-0.09541507065296173,
0.25396010279655457,
0.21358412504196167,
0.31561461091041565,
-0.38870668411254883,
-0.09273476898670197,
-0.3046509027481079,
0.22021888196468353,
0.8715900182723999,
0.04475156590342522,
0.3194980323314667,
-0.5393186211585999,
0.0034020082093775272,
0.29902923107147217,
-0.09978786110877991,
-0.01446083839982748,
-0.22599540650844574,
-0.46855685114860535,
-0.17734168469905853,
0.05651802942156792,
0.24933792650699615,
-0.640038788318634,
0.5517529845237732,
0.2756199836730957,
-0.12547051906585693,
-0.6851294040679932,
0.6652004718780518,
0.6782488226890564,
0.46223318576812744,
0.7254242300987244,
-0.5467674732208252,
-0.6672141551971436,
-0.8024534583091736,
0.09883791953325272,
-0.007283010054379702,
0.0497797355055809,
0.6051453351974487,
-0.08908232301473618,
-0.3361363112926483,
0.7879815697669983,
-0.5617104172706604,
-0.8509266376495361,
-0.3505743741989136,
0.0893949344754219,
0.11061744391918182,
0.402749240398407,
0.45690566301345825,
-0.902616560459137,
-0.6393004059791565,
0.002036965684965253,
-0.5962143540382385,
-0.058256831020116806,
-0.21856588125228882,
0.10753645747900009,
0.4152093231678009,
0.18257799744606018,
0.0626412108540535,
0.38557764887809753,
0.4063471853733063,
-0.40769150853157043,
0.4803301990032196,
-0.7567117810249329,
0.14090870320796967,
-0.8885908126831055,
-0.11859524995088577,
0.4832262694835663,
-0.3142048716545105,
-0.49325495958328247,
-0.17819654941558838,
0.04234037548303604,
0.04882725700736046,
-0.22734560072422028,
0.35413122177124023,
-0.24020615220069885,
0.01888691447675228,
-0.3179713785648346,
0.2650755047798157,
0.05596363544464111,
0.8486141562461853,
0.017635153606534004,
0.641590416431427,
0.22635628283023834,
-0.5619895458221436,
0.4278726279735565,
0.08536195009946823,
0.018348325043916702,
0.8714967966079712,
-0.41936951875686646,
0.05065206438302994,
0.11060606688261032,
0.27386370301246643,
-1.428760051727295,
0.44182145595550537,
0.21353739500045776,
0.06109200417995453,
0.2354278564453125,
-0.17251533269882202,
-0.22658365964889526,
-0.2823171317577362,
-0.6274334788322449,
0.5417279601097107,
0.4503774642944336,
-1.129356861114502,
0.23279494047164917,
0.2364727407693863,
0.17079326510429382,
-0.6099814772605896,
-0.7145118713378906,
-0.4077637791633606,
-0.0783471092581749,
-0.3588167130947113,
0.5374033451080322,
-0.4775637686252594,
-0.01990640163421631,
0.03267215937376022,
-0.23106835782527924,
0.016999555751681328,
0.025870509445667267,
0.3948391079902649,
0.4656235873699188,
-0.06579311937093735,
0.24798545241355896,
-0.13604110479354858,
-0.3499910831451416,
-0.20193147659301758,
-0.43279707431793213,
0.5348541736602783,
-0.3749840557575226,
-0.36529362201690674,
-0.5880324840545654,
0.34199216961860657,
0.15274009108543396,
0.058090195059776306,
0.49192410707473755,
0.9361213445663452,
0.05330255255103111,
-0.3958721160888672,
-0.833051323890686,
-0.291974812746048,
-0.5445125102996826,
0.4010598361492157,
-0.28688815236091614,
-0.8145517110824585,
0.3612830340862274,
0.2749916613101959,
0.21766886115074158,
0.31109878420829773,
0.5954170227050781,
-0.2805931568145752,
0.6263608336448669,
0.44777166843414307,
-0.3186301290988922,
0.42203763127326965,
-0.4482160806655884,
0.014309942722320557,
-0.9411532878875732,
-0.2000415325164795,
-0.08620604872703552,
-0.46916463971138,
-0.7046164870262146,
0.07618372142314911,
-0.1075890064239502,
-0.07862432301044464,
-0.29977914690971375,
0.3589087724685669,
-0.7152385115623474,
0.2500035762786865,
0.7204891443252563,
0.423111230134964,
0.20460206270217896,
0.03892020136117935,
-0.503985583782196,
-0.09528451412916183,
-0.38418111205101013,
0.14251510798931122,
1.0200765132904053,
0.015088295564055443,
0.7710199952125549,
0.04853196069598198,
0.801287829875946,
0.8172717690467834,
-0.10360980778932571,
-0.3723185360431671,
0.4136076867580414,
-0.6533178091049194,
-0.1723373383283615,
-0.008263843134045601,
-0.26953649520874023,
-0.9224911332130432,
0.4355602264404297,
-0.5322349071502686,
-0.31379061937332153,
0.42682549357414246,
0.41660624742507935,
-0.38579151034355164,
0.3001694679260254,
-0.633321225643158,
0.8522161841392517,
-0.2530307471752167,
-0.726199746131897,
-0.662218451499939,
-0.5469955801963806,
-0.008370268158614635,
0.021167883649468422,
-0.012139612808823586,
0.16476599872112274,
0.18032394349575043,
0.39121273159980774,
-0.0957605391740799,
0.7551984190940857,
-0.06567609310150146,
0.14708587527275085,
0.09008458256721497,
0.23536933958530426,
0.49006661772727966,
0.055231913924217224,
0.10764190554618835,
0.19538412988185883,
-0.12010172009468079,
-0.14638911187648773,
-0.6746779084205627,
1.322013258934021,
-0.6425356268882751,
-0.6753458380699158,
-0.3618983030319214,
-0.39019155502319336,
-0.09469487518072128,
0.15745393931865692,
-0.09749285876750946,
0.6431684494018555,
-0.07383675128221512,
0.32119497656822205,
0.4364258944988251,
-0.08202152699232101,
0.3066769540309906,
0.6083115339279175,
-0.24215158820152283,
-0.7491565346717834,
1.2300437688827515,
-0.05529915168881416,
0.16986671090126038,
0.3215227425098419,
0.13467545807361603,
-0.5624668598175049,
-0.7439911365509033,
-0.11586589366197586,
0.24751640856266022,
-0.7352737784385681,
-0.011201235465705395,
-0.3351474106311798,
-0.19822163879871368,
-0.3183787167072296,
-0.49633172154426575,
-0.09258376806974411,
-0.15298384428024292,
-0.5680479407310486,
-0.1368756890296936,
0.06525891274213791,
0.6875097751617432,
-0.23571953177452087,
-0.28368327021598816,
-0.24627967178821564,
0.5421785712242126,
0.45247599482536316,
0.5515546798706055,
0.1854841113090515,
-0.3194064199924469,
-0.31012433767318726,
-0.032522786408662796,
-0.40823662281036377,
-0.2973976135253906,
0.36070969700813293,
-0.1490985006093979,
0.6182601451873779,
0.6764197945594788,
0.2597600817680359,
0.6620408296585083,
-0.285387247800827,
0.5964769721031189,
0.4205167889595032,
-0.3514518439769745,
0.17790119349956512,
0.05004444345831871,
0.14532572031021118,
0.7853091955184937,
0.3195708096027374,
-0.36854150891304016,
-0.13123609125614166,
-0.4480465054512024,
-0.7880871295928955,
0.710092306137085,
0.13839004933834076,
-0.20823808014392853,
0.047281816601753235,
0.15384043753147125,
0.37671181559562683,
0.044658955186605453,
-0.5204699635505676,
-0.6622714400291443,
-0.2864135503768921,
-0.40618273615837097,
-0.2092820256948471,
-0.5545294284820557,
0.13712768256664276,
0.04912877082824707,
0.6841269731521606,
0.23185864090919495,
-0.004349307622760534,
0.191466823220253,
-0.05998779460787773,
0.10703002661466599,
0.025889016687870026,
0.2779322862625122,
0.4410925805568695,
-0.467134028673172,
0.051616571843624115,
0.24395422637462616,
-0.2952369451522827,
-0.050500597804784775,
0.09066998958587646,
0.16711825132369995,
-0.37227457761764526,
-0.039665598422288895,
0.4341694116592407,
0.4551212191581726,
-0.3778347671031952,
0.37037765979766846,
-0.016072792932391167,
-0.062044285237789154,
-0.30000460147857666,
0.028935134410858154,
-0.09372934699058533,
0.3184448182582855,
0.17752505838871002,
0.2957440912723541,
0.45619896054267883,
-0.5708015561103821,
0.4820156991481781,
0.5986331701278687,
-0.7034720778465271,
-0.08318830281496048,
0.3712826669216156,
0.6144578456878662,
-0.1203470304608345,
0.7811603546142578,
-0.05946502834558487,
-0.20940279960632324,
0.2534993588924408,
0.7149784564971924,
1.0658352375030518,
-0.0561433807015419,
0.08940311521291733,
0.3007436692714691,
-0.28993749618530273,
0.07879206538200378,
-0.16901901364326477,
-0.5499736666679382,
-0.7340282201766968,
0.3384571969509125,
-0.3301343619823456,
-0.31018510460853577,
-0.14203405380249023,
-0.7779484391212463,
0.3981466293334961,
-0.6050387024879456,
0.1364976018667221,
0.04555246978998184,
0.3931635916233063,
-0.8654563426971436,
0.10818031430244446,
0.17538240551948547,
0.4178381860256195,
-0.4768548905849457,
0.9636497497558594,
0.4243958592414856,
-0.623344898223877,
-0.3003702461719513,
-0.29057255387306213,
0.2778237462043762,
-0.7668675780296326,
0.5341994762420654,
0.2250824123620987,
-0.5625475645065308,
-0.24971126019954681,
0.1256340891122818,
-0.3334731459617615,
1.279257893562317,
-0.03861013427376747,
-0.6518950462341309,
0.32389962673187256,
-0.17337369918823242,
0.6945083141326904,
-0.6412444710731506,
0.26239997148513794,
0.25058433413505554,
0.058655451983213425,
0.37053173780441284,
-0.5157447457313538,
0.3062799572944641,
-0.14796796441078186,
0.09967541694641113,
0.09811261296272278,
-0.5736329555511475,
0.5728108882904053,
-0.3537794351577759,
-0.30147019028663635,
0.11468267440795898,
0.7194532752037048,
0.3558425009250641,
0.5971251726150513,
0.49995091557502747,
0.46839770674705505,
0.6115068793296814,
0.2923200726509094,
0.951724112033844,
-0.13516950607299805,
0.3854273855686188,
1.2842848300933838,
-0.49016448855400085,
0.7213451266288757,
0.14291445910930634,
-0.33076831698417664,
0.7703390717506409,
0.5015515089035034,
-0.5856828093528748,
0.802934467792511,
-0.11206309497356415,
-0.13208132982254028,
-0.26128843426704407,
-0.0010566548444330692,
-0.2865990400314331,
-0.21979627013206482,
0.21909579634666443,
-0.4189423620700836,
-0.25690537691116333,
-0.11763961613178253,
-0.5460854172706604,
0.37616440653800964,
-0.16551131010055542,
0.9748867154121399,
0.19066281616687775,
-0.3206714689731598,
0.5842500925064087,
-0.2692950963973999,
0.9020957350730896,
-0.49156904220581055,
-0.3051816523075104,
-0.44485369324684143,
0.4863595962524414,
-0.2999405562877655,
-0.9311475157737732,
-0.08020365983247757,
-0.32401242852211,
-0.5254945755004883,
-0.1473584920167923,
0.6471965909004211,
-0.6524580121040344,
-0.2738020718097687,
0.549340009689331,
-0.05900181829929352,
-0.14400418102741241,
0.2715298533439636,
-0.917716920375824,
-0.256240576505661,
0.17997227609157562,
0.4120318293571472,
0.6229186058044434,
-0.02139005810022354,
0.2321334332227707,
1.0257344245910645,
0.7188100218772888,
0.02267715521156788,
-0.5067378878593445,
0.18067803978919983,
0.6650461554527283,
-0.6099833250045776,
-0.7307847738265991,
-0.8672341704368591,
0.3889212906360626,
-0.09130427986383438,
-0.05390267074108124,
0.6764220595359802,
0.5085945725440979,
0.9024891257286072,
-0.010041099973022938,
0.572442889213562,
0.4163409173488617,
0.4544869363307953,
-0.4988655745983124,
0.517282247543335,
-0.5399576425552368,
0.8041577935218811,
-0.03936558589339256,
-0.7269600033760071,
-0.3104259967803955,
0.4065406024456024,
-0.0954352542757988,
0.4888358414173126,
0.7310070395469666,
0.7958962917327881,
-0.14441223442554474,
-0.01736614853143692,
0.47085249423980713,
0.04045068472623825,
0.1290491670370102,
0.7215726971626282,
0.4970967471599579,
-0.07251987606287003,
0.7555711269378662,
-0.4738251864910126,
0.058420419692993164,
-0.42958199977874756,
-0.5207894444465637,
-1.0863724946975708,
-0.7598670721054077,
-0.5076355338096619,
-0.4471730887889862,
0.3252546489238739,
1.2022784948349,
0.7095064520835876,
-1.1794558763504028,
-0.4110012948513031,
-0.024285348132252693,
0.39670994877815247,
-0.5718070864677429,
-0.21818755567073822,
0.649632453918457,
-0.47112417221069336,
-0.38509055972099304,
0.29159724712371826,
0.32498812675476074,
-0.013670718297362328,
-0.4932842254638672,
-0.1619824767112732,
-0.13675938546657562,
-0.23139601945877075,
0.37710848450660706,
0.20124320685863495,
-0.8691602945327759,
-0.1785835474729538,
-0.6032863259315491,
-0.21672511100769043,
0.061334334313869476,
0.8247697949409485,
-1.1389442682266235,
0.6873244643211365,
0.45196762681007385,
0.5196967720985413,
0.4412384033203125,
0.24679957330226898,
0.6636407971382141,
-0.7173736095428467,
-0.19224344193935394,
-0.11609530448913574,
0.6096867918968201,
0.35612621903419495,
-0.4289780557155609,
0.45966485142707825,
0.30398157238960266,
-0.6389976143836975,
-0.4262886941432953,
0.2615991532802582,
-1.1964449882507324,
-0.4159383773803711,
0.9481697082519531,
-0.18940019607543945,
0.4232111871242523,
-0.33871448040008545,
-0.40447548031806946,
-0.06787455826997757,
-0.7145254611968994,
0.9767397046089172,
0.4182538688182831,
-0.01925724558532238,
-0.14216983318328857,
0.05060393735766411,
0.4994717538356781,
0.2970329225063324,
-0.04344932734966278,
0.20274566113948822,
0.4822130501270294,
0.3213164508342743,
-0.08342942595481873,
0.3084886372089386,
0.13908155262470245,
0.47364094853401184,
-0.16572187840938568,
-0.07294688373804092,
-0.5579367280006409,
-0.3980739712715149,
-0.5905789732933044,
0.33851170539855957,
-0.04560751095414162,
-0.2704346477985382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12973v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12973v1 | C Analyzer : A Static Program Analysis Tool for C Programs | 2024-01-28T11:43:16 | 2024-01-28T11:43:16 | Rajendra Kumar Solanki | cs.PL | cs.PL, cs.CL | In our times, when the world is increasingly becoming more dependent on
software programs, writing bug-free, correct programs is crucial. Program
verification based on formal methods can guarantee this by detecting run-time
errors in safety-critical systems to avoid possible adverse impacts on human
life and save time and money.
This project work tries to leverage Abstract Interpretation techniques for
static analysis of C programs. C Analyzer is a tool developed for static
analysis of C programs. This implementation of C Analyzer provides a
plug-and-play domain architecture for multiple abstract domains to be used. C
Analyzer supports four abstract domains - Interval, Octagon, Polyhedra, and Bit
Vector. We use these different domains for required precision in program
verification. C Analyzer tool uses LLVM C/C++ compiler frontend Clang API to
generate and traverse the Control Flow Graph (CFG) of a given C program. This
tool generates invariants in different abstract domains for statements in basic
blocks of CFG during CFG traversal. Using these invariants, some properties of
a program, such as dividing by zero, modulus zero, arithmetic overflow, etc.,
can be analyzed. We also use a source-to-source transformation tool, CIL
(Common Intermediate language), to transform some C constructs into simpler
constructs, such as transforming logical operators, switch statements, and
conditional operators into if-else ladders and transforming do-while and for
loops into while loops.
Using C Analyzer, C program constructs such as declarations, assignments,
binary operations (arithmetic, relational, bitwise shift, etc.), conditions
(if-else), loops (while, do while, for loop), nested conditions, and nested
loops can be analyzed. Currently, this tool does not support arrays,
structures, unions, pointers, or function calls. | [
-0.3355552554130554,
-0.898013174533844,
0.44485485553741455,
0.30916687846183777,
-0.3770087957382202,
0.5757743716239929,
0.07216566801071167,
-0.6448445916175842,
-0.027352770790457726,
0.38745930790901184,
-0.26489925384521484,
-0.7312130928039551,
-0.5392324924468994,
0.041220877319574356,
-0.2640840411186218,
0.8087561130523682,
-0.29455482959747314,
0.013975974172353745,
-0.2318500578403473,
-0.12698547542095184,
-0.5599128007888794,
-0.4513522684574127,
-0.6364461779594421,
-0.11865179240703583,
-0.09921883791685104,
0.4545397460460663,
0.4395732581615448,
0.5706841349601746,
0.7630071640014648,
0.4711787700653076,
0.09819933027029037,
-0.1448546051979065,
-0.5915507078170776,
-0.026862993836402893,
0.051194753497838974,
-0.40601640939712524,
-0.3227798044681549,
-0.3664757311344147,
0.6429107189178467,
0.31476789712905884,
0.07253524661064148,
0.39311689138412476,
-0.12441664189100266,
0.7721865773200989,
-0.6933480501174927,
0.49305039644241333,
-0.41881483793258667,
-0.07944995164871216,
-0.5894221067428589,
-0.49295637011528015,
0.05175388231873512,
-0.7490037083625793,
-0.2073335200548172,
-0.38015085458755493,
0.32665395736694336,
0.2176458239555359,
0.8437066674232483,
0.7412854433059692,
-0.35840216279029846,
-0.25279536843299866,
-0.6396158933639526,
0.6779669523239136,
-0.6589111685752869,
0.2877051532268524,
-0.3754405081272125,
0.46636250615119934,
-0.32680079340934753,
-0.6817576289176941,
-0.5166030526161194,
-0.33167505264282227,
-0.044556573033332825,
-0.0031330513302236795,
-0.1469118744134903,
0.32705503702163696,
0.4225863516330719,
0.8002276420593262,
-0.36896786093711853,
-0.2649289667606354,
-0.8922995924949646,
-0.2801724970340729,
0.5860930681228638,
0.5417503714561462,
0.6593899130821228,
0.2863464951515198,
-0.3620331883430481,
0.012729615904390812,
-0.7647117972373962,
0.48772624135017395,
0.27975666522979736,
-0.3259979486465454,
-0.31511688232421875,
0.49023309350013733,
-0.09047088027000427,
0.7833752632141113,
0.2370828241109848,
-0.2058486044406891,
0.1370757669210434,
-0.013056601397693157,
-0.3437725901603699,
0.1628587245941162,
0.47625622153282166,
0.26233720779418945,
0.18718796968460083,
0.15205106139183044,
-0.08589334040880203,
0.15321417152881622,
0.14307016134262085,
-0.9477736353874207,
-0.4433981478214264,
0.27618253231048584,
-0.4965065121650696,
-0.37894967198371887,
0.21558892726898193,
-0.67107754945755,
-0.10807354003190994,
-0.35558658838272095,
-0.28603097796440125,
-0.32485097646713257,
-0.1980447918176651,
0.07996556907892227,
-0.1732042282819748,
0.7095184326171875,
0.04545751214027405,
-0.3484940826892853,
0.6225867867469788,
0.7486414909362793,
0.7420349717140198,
-0.5363093018531799,
0.05482291057705879,
-0.42954516410827637,
-0.12650616466999054,
-0.43850696086883545,
0.7810302376747131,
-0.3860485255718231,
-0.5474390983581543,
-0.32155802845954895,
0.20244748890399933,
-0.03593945503234863,
-0.5269894599914551,
0.3154318928718567,
-0.6787275075912476,
-0.4267023205757141,
-0.025967752560973167,
-0.37211376428604126,
-0.2665766179561615,
0.21223647892475128,
-0.4767952263355255,
1.1598910093307495,
0.16125670075416565,
-0.8735815286636353,
-0.008034908212721348,
-0.8111001253128052,
-0.3249327540397644,
0.40126311779022217,
-0.5334336757659912,
-0.2977357804775238,
0.26367369294166565,
-0.2074495106935501,
0.12443620711565018,
-0.22951547801494598,
0.1795678585767746,
-0.35508424043655396,
-0.8359203934669495,
0.3106471002101898,
-0.1109209731221199,
0.9648323655128479,
0.30293798446655273,
-0.5212689638137817,
0.22283422946929932,
-0.8111235499382019,
0.3416607081890106,
-0.0029170201160013676,
-0.556189775466919,
-0.1895320564508438,
0.2737223207950592,
-0.06984783709049225,
0.18156248331069946,
0.45128077268600464,
-0.6813133955001831,
0.00769761111587286,
-0.6130852699279785,
-0.07609428465366364,
0.5397133231163025,
0.34491318464279175,
-0.07750093936920166,
0.07885830104351044,
1.0075021982192993,
-0.18936453759670258,
-0.12342268973588943,
0.13897567987442017,
-0.3098600506782532,
-0.7943263053894043,
-0.0896858349442482,
0.07039991021156311,
0.8452326655387878,
-0.6971966028213501,
0.41209134459495544,
-0.21743305027484894,
-0.3458200991153717,
-0.25249215960502625,
0.03680145740509033,
0.566155195236206,
0.1488223671913147,
0.1463158130645752,
-0.2427385449409485,
-0.5153009295463562,
-0.7987323999404907,
-0.056123025715351105,
-0.2667165696620941,
0.10510444641113281,
-0.04260188341140747,
0.40017393231391907,
-0.051866285502910614,
0.6339279413223267,
-0.8916847109794617,
0.2686600685119629,
-0.12493541836738586,
0.09211960434913635,
0.12085870653390884,
0.35251155495643616,
0.5631847977638245,
-0.48905783891677856,
-0.550312340259552,
0.2600429058074951,
-0.5205672383308411,
-0.4467751085758209,
-0.1356545388698578,
-0.095204196870327,
0.052714984863996506,
0.6425923705101013,
0.1305733621120453,
0.4930473864078522,
0.7354278564453125,
-0.39600783586502075,
0.9467594623565674,
0.10161974281072617,
0.2917217016220093,
-0.33533623814582825,
0.5016752481460571,
-0.28955090045928955,
-0.267428457736969,
-0.3010018765926361,
0.6057119369506836,
-0.09858785569667816,
-0.2371237725019455,
-0.545357882976532,
0.3573579788208008,
-0.5249959230422974,
-0.06584697216749191,
-0.28090301156044006,
-0.31199294328689575,
-0.19282634556293488,
0.38692668080329895,
-0.02075175568461418,
0.9270389676094055,
0.6836277842521667,
-0.6007583141326904,
0.13188175857067108,
-0.35927024483680725,
-0.2628200352191925,
0.4468332827091217,
-0.7566239833831787,
0.40335920453071594,
0.042377158999443054,
-0.19535373151302338,
-0.9167967438697815,
-0.06325385719537735,
0.6407981514930725,
-0.4817861020565033,
0.31059858202934265,
-0.17465540766716003,
-0.04805704578757286,
-0.17823395133018494,
-0.6594548225402832,
0.4694121778011322,
0.18935678899288177,
-0.42794352769851685,
0.4934494197368622,
0.30176079273223877,
-0.14472493529319763,
-0.7544397115707397,
-0.3320589065551758,
-0.14423908293247223,
-0.08128330111503601,
-0.8080983757972717,
0.23883970081806183,
-0.5107118487358093,
-0.6775639057159424,
0.12311182171106339,
-0.504830002784729,
-0.4777260720729828,
0.027414513751864433,
0.5478022694587708,
0.768808901309967,
-0.35190069675445557,
-0.5586047768592834,
0.33513590693473816,
-0.1591058224439621,
0.27018430829048157,
0.06463048607110977,
0.20631130039691925,
-0.718864917755127,
-0.44122639298439026,
-0.2942194938659668,
0.21456211805343628,
0.917814314365387,
-0.11331939697265625,
0.37732622027397156,
0.30998679995536804,
-0.18572095036506653,
0.006769001949578524,
-0.42422205209732056,
0.49367716908454895,
-0.5428991913795471,
0.1420348733663559,
-0.6154046654701233,
-0.9730185866355896,
0.4578026533126831,
-0.19245588779449463,
0.28004562854766846,
0.510263204574585,
0.7084769010543823,
0.323224276304245,
0.8731292486190796,
0.570616602897644,
-0.2340565323829651,
0.17157217860221863,
-0.19312511384487152,
0.37618526816368103,
-0.6358397603034973,
-0.24712803959846497,
-0.6579519510269165,
-0.16146942973136902,
-0.3876236379146576,
-0.3553319573402405,
0.4343481659889221,
0.12904125452041626,
-0.02461683563888073,
0.01394979190081358,
-0.8197579383850098,
0.8444947004318237,
0.020411640405654907,
-0.3420681953430176,
0.2376813143491745,
-0.25620272755622864,
-0.16519954800605774,
-0.04467932507395744,
-0.09961544722318649,
-0.5729115009307861,
0.5810858011245728,
0.44734880328178406,
0.7513832449913025,
-0.0927300825715065,
0.7085164189338684,
0.28568798303604126,
0.510103702545166,
-1.1202534437179565,
0.4940391778945923,
-0.14349830150604248,
-0.6606721878051758,
0.05178801715373993,
-0.2464657723903656,
-0.4942685067653656,
0.2297455370426178,
0.276362806558609,
-0.8986634016036987,
0.5317819118499756,
0.3174339532852173,
-0.19186195731163025,
0.15885575115680695,
-0.46852120757102966,
0.7037696242332458,
-0.3319728374481201,
-0.15192030370235443,
-0.20378492772579193,
-0.3400120735168457,
0.9610932469367981,
0.07528325170278549,
0.03384379670023918,
0.03272903710603714,
0.2138429433107376,
0.5240775346755981,
-0.5031725764274597,
0.5988041758537292,
-0.15695349872112274,
-0.1052798181772232,
0.7232128977775574,
0.5363096594810486,
0.37970098853111267,
0.15621785819530487,
-0.05794774740934372,
0.4393681585788727,
0.6238059401512146,
-0.1470332145690918,
-0.1940620094537735,
0.7549508810043335,
-0.5743110179901123,
-0.5294072031974792,
-0.7623869776725769,
-0.24214214086532593,
0.30082061886787415,
0.16622574627399445,
0.18758486211299896,
0.27295708656311035,
-0.40546637773513794,
0.332473486661911,
0.3210645020008087,
-0.04793880879878998,
0.22790369391441345,
0.5175328254699707,
-0.031045841053128242,
0.04534514248371124,
0.639273464679718,
-0.38170284032821655,
0.17333932220935822,
0.4023185968399048,
-0.10439013689756393,
-0.06548304110765457,
-0.9132503271102905,
-0.25982388854026794,
-0.08561135083436966,
-0.6906648278236389,
-0.37152332067489624,
-0.2599422037601471,
-0.3149481415748596,
-0.06788773089647293,
-0.44040447473526,
-0.11139397323131561,
-0.4377093017101288,
0.030997326597571373,
0.17737038433551788,
-0.11923964321613312,
0.336515337228775,
0.016665302217006683,
0.37699612975120544,
-0.7716400623321533,
0.41780853271484375,
-0.01705259270966053,
0.12145375460386276,
-0.27171775698661804,
0.09757363051176071,
-0.20566177368164062,
-0.4269561767578125,
-0.6937170028686523,
-0.947778046131134,
0.12711365520954132,
-0.0768650695681572,
0.37167122960090637,
0.7211638689041138,
-0.12351460754871368,
0.6838605403900146,
-0.3056630790233612,
0.7616060972213745,
0.13618238270282745,
-1.3507946729660034,
0.07245757430791855,
-0.13674396276474,
0.2521781027317047,
0.6986331343650818,
0.05721051245927811,
-0.459567666053772,
-0.5840544104576111,
-0.3351863622665405,
-0.6564412117004395,
0.6440258026123047,
0.22929689288139343,
-0.38878995180130005,
0.07888022065162659,
0.4024868905544281,
-0.220580592751503,
-0.14498765766620636,
-0.6348656415939331,
-0.5000841021537781,
-0.10003432631492615,
0.027038222178816795,
0.3949390649795532,
-0.02821657434105873,
-0.007216064725071192,
-0.1772340089082718,
0.5443939566612244,
-0.1498703956604004,
0.22646385431289673,
0.167681023478508,
-0.04128764197230339,
-0.30037814378738403,
0.45945361256599426,
0.2912324070930481,
1.0544735193252563,
-0.4352484941482544,
0.2788275182247162,
0.4200582802295685,
-0.5711862444877625,
-0.016132880002260208,
0.03670512139797211,
0.036521296948194504,
-0.15767301619052887,
0.2844460904598236,
0.12146113812923431,
-0.07504744082689285,
-0.7588032484054565,
0.2792724370956421,
-0.06875158846378326,
-0.08052115887403488,
-0.41061821579933167,
0.5582736730575562,
0.11059977114200592,
0.03350702300667763,
0.08656301349401474,
0.11047577112913132,
0.7130119800567627,
-0.3242078125476837,
0.07597298920154572,
0.2921091914176941,
-0.32457223534584045,
-0.35810360312461853,
0.533329963684082,
0.015458636917173862,
-0.24155306816101074,
0.372770220041275,
-0.5033248066902161,
-0.5896317362785339,
1.0333898067474365,
0.5942233204841614,
0.8680639266967773,
-0.32753807306289673,
-0.051000628620386124,
0.3865412771701813,
0.26815900206565857,
0.24995435774326324,
0.5151832699775696,
-0.16742050647735596,
-0.5456602573394775,
-0.607765793800354,
-0.6888867020606995,
-0.45282891392707825,
0.1967972218990326,
-0.41876330971717834,
0.44417691230773926,
-0.8506717085838318,
0.218867227435112,
0.31497523188591003,
0.04209030047059059,
-0.6257537007331848,
0.06164529547095299,
-0.048653822392225266,
0.8370977640151978,
-0.6676587462425232,
0.8120861649513245,
0.8146393299102783,
-0.04815330728888512,
-0.7088254690170288,
-0.07756374776363373,
0.5202862620353699,
-0.43068233132362366,
0.6342745423316956,
0.03086152859032154,
-0.8748301267623901,
-0.16844697296619415,
-0.7140868306159973,
-0.7025043368339539,
0.9699480533599854,
0.1268167793750763,
-0.6736879944801331,
0.40257659554481506,
-0.0766698569059372,
0.5330720543861389,
-0.37137341499328613,
-0.05883728340268135,
0.8128619194030762,
0.5394043326377869,
0.2923097312450409,
-0.5438681840896606,
0.42552247643470764,
-0.36075711250305176,
-0.07098749279975891,
0.5782034397125244,
-0.2960194945335388,
0.6916312575340271,
-0.005426686257123947,
-0.5206314921379089,
-0.022330602630972862,
0.3454206883907318,
0.5378018021583557,
0.6083739995956421,
0.4336012899875641,
0.1062086671590805,
0.5392001271247864,
-0.07075471431016922,
0.8197424411773682,
-0.6101341247558594,
0.3378354609012604,
0.919743537902832,
-0.054000332951545715,
0.43021488189697266,
0.3303607106208801,
-0.34779730439186096,
0.7234047055244446,
0.48586177825927734,
-0.20219428837299347,
0.21968892216682434,
0.5896130204200745,
-0.5092712640762329,
0.0029461216181516647,
0.3587664067745209,
-0.34155765175819397,
0.256741464138031,
0.711940586566925,
0.051356468349695206,
-0.25062695145606995,
-0.8650596141815186,
0.08431964367628098,
-0.27667495608329773,
-0.03737392649054527,
0.2604384124279022,
0.0918562263250351,
-0.4690645635128021,
0.6681916117668152,
0.4949105679988861,
0.4571959376335144,
-0.5155366063117981,
-0.35771477222442627,
0.14701257646083832,
0.2795774042606354,
-0.43744397163391113,
-0.498468816280365,
0.9191250205039978,
0.04230461269617081,
0.1511755734682083,
0.26395249366760254,
1.0776029825210571,
0.12920403480529785,
-0.5167741179466248,
0.1223897635936737,
0.3330470323562622,
0.5741764903068542,
0.01900441013276577,
-0.817284107208252,
0.26412031054496765,
0.289048433303833,
-0.002733469707891345,
-0.16712036728858948,
0.19558919966220856,
-0.18240664899349213,
0.5044071078300476,
0.8045446872711182,
0.23558741807937622,
0.13776810467243195,
-0.19489137828350067,
0.8716575503349304,
-0.7112243175506592,
-0.3455071747303009,
-0.8910693526268005,
0.6797394156455994,
-0.09992938488721848,
-0.166761577129364,
0.41725707054138184,
0.8806049227714539,
0.4764157831668854,
-0.06786397844552994,
0.7363640666007996,
-0.5402580499649048,
-0.04381892830133438,
-0.44027161598205566,
0.30616867542266846,
-0.12079790234565735,
0.5281463861465454,
-0.16296374797821045,
-0.9712119102478027,
-0.36828723549842834,
0.3896458148956299,
-0.2962428629398346,
-0.4485909044742584,
1.1003292798995972,
0.8959652781486511,
-0.2517378330230713,
-0.26262181997299194,
0.15125826001167297,
-0.005069670267403126,
0.5042729377746582,
0.4093925356864929,
0.8845502138137817,
-0.009082570672035217,
0.6190774440765381,
-0.003909866791218519,
-0.5847254395484924,
-0.052435796707868576,
-0.7320631146430969,
-0.8658626079559326,
-0.11839701235294342,
-0.5090504884719849,
-0.3746793270111084,
0.05209062248468399,
0.5851266384124756,
0.5146602988243103,
-0.889670193195343,
-0.48703673481941223,
-0.020311765372753143,
0.32751742005348206,
-0.2219666987657547,
-0.4132005274295807,
0.4351103901863098,
-0.2954852879047394,
-0.6397805213928223,
0.5127666592597961,
0.3920627236366272,
-0.22982513904571533,
-0.2275637686252594,
-0.08275618404150009,
0.20985421538352966,
0.04361435025930405,
0.3395613431930542,
0.8921443819999695,
-0.5155598521232605,
-0.35500481724739075,
-0.08145464956760406,
0.26069876551628113,
0.22140242159366608,
1.1962289810180664,
-0.31178534030914307,
0.4358576834201813,
0.7680523991584778,
0.45771801471710205,
0.5542306900024414,
0.18368485569953918,
0.40158355236053467,
-0.5751298666000366,
-0.11765102297067642,
-0.02728564292192459,
0.3609525263309479,
-0.08115772902965546,
-0.8676895499229431,
0.3527956008911133,
0.03275611624121666,
-0.6989961266517639,
-0.3379861116409302,
0.129923477768898,
-1.099435567855835,
-0.3783772885799408,
0.7537041902542114,
-0.30296704173088074,
-0.14155907928943634,
-0.592326283454895,
-0.39341121912002563,
0.2051234245300293,
-0.3077079653739929,
0.8567749857902527,
0.7085742354393005,
-0.6902009844779968,
0.1502269059419632,
-0.5855011343955994,
0.38121679425239563,
-0.32872599363327026,
-1.0747954845428467,
-0.25606194138526917,
0.7202814221382141,
0.8101655840873718,
0.34172874689102173,
0.9043934941291809,
-0.5714305639266968,
0.23623494803905487,
-0.03789642080664635,
0.4191611707210541,
-0.1327645182609558,
-0.1366634964942932,
-0.5110730528831482,
0.10790669918060303,
0.15440592169761658,
-0.590079665184021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15626v1 | TA&AT: Enhancing Task-Oriented Dialog with Turn-Level Auxiliary Tasks and Action-Tree Based Scheduled Sampling | 2024-01-28T11:02:23 | 2024-01-28T11:02:23 | Longxiang Liu, Xiuxing Li, Yang Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Task-oriented dialog systems have witnessed substantial progress due to
conversational pre-training techniques. Yet, two significant challenges
persist. First, most systems primarily utilize the latest turn's state label
for the generator. This practice overlooks the comprehensive value of state
labels in boosting the model's understanding for future generations. Second, an
overreliance on generated policy often leads to error accumulation, resulting
in suboptimal responses when adhering to incorrect actions. To combat these
challenges, we propose turn-level multi-task objectives for the encoder. With
the guidance of essential information from labeled intermediate states, we
establish a more robust representation for both understanding and generation.
For the decoder, we introduce an action tree-based scheduled sampling
technique. Specifically, we model the hierarchical policy as trees and utilize
the similarity between trees to sample negative policy based on scheduled
sampling, hoping the model to generate invariant responses under perturbations.
This method simulates potential pitfalls by sampling similar negative policy,
bridging the gap between task-oriented dialog training and inference. Among
methods without continual pre-training, our approach achieved state-of-the-art
(SOTA) performance on the MultiWOZ dataset series and was also competitive with
pre-trained SOTA methods. | [
-0.10291090607643127,
-0.8360551595687866,
0.5808635950088501,
0.008630727417767048,
-0.18797722458839417,
0.20219583809375763,
0.02098667435348034,
-0.21174076199531555,
0.23251037299633026,
0.5877102017402649,
-1.0334383249282837,
-0.2952258884906769,
-0.49166354537010193,
0.022857561707496643,
-0.18451502919197083,
1.0353666543960571,
0.13449133932590485,
-0.1413833051919937,
0.09594219923019409,
0.1462576985359192,
-0.582168459892273,
-0.5767261385917664,
-0.9950870871543884,
-0.5210541486740112,
0.38352170586586,
0.28153830766677856,
0.5205864906311035,
0.3265051245689392,
-0.07479303330183029,
0.2298966497182846,
0.057790324091911316,
0.2716650068759918,
-0.35582080483436584,
0.232034370303154,
0.13730576634407043,
-0.511463463306427,
-0.552482545375824,
-0.22644738852977753,
0.4531572163105011,
0.4475034773349762,
-0.2982880473136902,
0.03158820793032646,
0.21713393926620483,
0.15674583613872528,
-0.7185220122337341,
0.41458648443222046,
-0.5871067643165588,
0.21343474090099335,
-0.2782028615474701,
-0.7374110221862793,
-0.5638010501861572,
-0.19760246574878693,
0.06919042021036148,
-0.7878190279006958,
0.12203045189380646,
-0.08098538964986801,
0.8247337341308594,
0.31576845049858093,
-0.5321854948997498,
-0.1650903820991516,
-0.6945340633392334,
0.8107677102088928,
-0.7164116501808167,
0.24270273745059967,
0.5378735661506653,
0.17781884968280792,
-0.25384700298309326,
-0.2709694504737854,
-0.5887377858161926,
-0.07541199028491974,
0.1474924236536026,
0.3458043336868286,
-0.3120523691177368,
0.518559455871582,
0.2907208800315857,
0.23557627201080322,
-0.1971464306116104,
-0.008990048430860043,
0.02188851684331894,
-0.27885210514068604,
0.20469322800636292,
0.341947078704834,
0.06390561908483505,
-0.2957163453102112,
-0.13042202591896057,
-0.25419875979423523,
-0.7320701479911804,
0.17517276108264923,
0.44569268822669983,
0.45502278208732605,
0.08356134593486786,
0.6269529461860657,
-0.19313757121562958,
0.812488853931427,
0.28197184205055237,
-0.11837949603796005,
0.15428467094898224,
-0.495400607585907,
-0.4824241101741791,
-0.08180969208478928,
0.716335654258728,
0.06933964788913727,
0.07969964295625687,
0.009876223281025887,
-0.3072238266468048,
0.03247097134590149,
0.4529745876789093,
-0.5331488251686096,
0.1797330677509308,
0.2773458957672119,
-0.44675904512405396,
-0.21350432932376862,
-0.177744522690773,
-0.6381179094314575,
-0.15095804631710052,
-0.5345586538314819,
0.36111634969711304,
-0.3676871061325073,
-0.2514530420303345,
0.06542463600635529,
0.029141951352357864,
0.005514407530426979,
0.5744675993919373,
-0.429979145526886,
0.2930145561695099,
0.5395633578300476,
0.38148632645606995,
-0.18043237924575806,
-0.19160760939121246,
-0.8173379302024841,
0.3258794844150543,
-0.1795264333486557,
0.6743040680885315,
-0.7859057784080505,
-0.5205650329589844,
0.2685346305370331,
0.10269518941640854,
-0.2556389570236206,
-0.48358240723609924,
0.1753615438938141,
-0.4547388255596161,
0.21780265867710114,
-0.28929540514945984,
-0.1082989051938057,
-0.027101892977952957,
0.6631954312324524,
-0.3485300540924072,
0.9762237071990967,
0.11667800694704056,
-0.5444239974021912,
0.5031569004058838,
-1.1281377077102661,
-0.5332566499710083,
-0.13436292111873627,
-0.27489471435546875,
-0.28724706172943115,
0.03439914435148239,
0.5506575107574463,
0.23141998052597046,
-0.2478870004415512,
0.42555198073387146,
0.041114576160907745,
-0.12603025138378143,
0.08527077734470367,
-0.6474217772483826,
0.9047229290008545,
0.3134922683238983,
-0.34079790115356445,
0.5263699293136597,
-0.28039100766181946,
0.14055737853050232,
-0.1485639363527298,
-0.37905022501945496,
0.0331476591527462,
0.1814129501581192,
-0.06052708998322487,
0.07392621040344238,
0.06331324577331543,
-0.849870502948761,
0.22212332487106323,
-0.10937517136335373,
0.5272457599639893,
0.6312681436538696,
0.3524624705314636,
0.08254692703485489,
-0.318652868270874,
0.8690799474716187,
0.32814815640449524,
0.24910444021224976,
-0.38055023550987244,
-0.19745737314224243,
-0.8835326433181763,
-0.0005685809883289039,
-0.019557852298021317,
0.6105082631111145,
-1.374401330947876,
0.6034592986106873,
-0.2694135308265686,
-0.019996175542473793,
-0.33055463433265686,
-0.4278765022754669,
0.6033574342727661,
0.31116539239883423,
0.35397493839263916,
-0.5096675157546997,
-0.509904682636261,
-0.6573671102523804,
-0.06951577216386795,
-0.2296501249074936,
0.15021510422229767,
0.3944104015827179,
0.20643669366836548,
-0.02951173111796379,
1.0319037437438965,
-0.45488306879997253,
-0.3359818756580353,
-0.5490115880966187,
0.41395866870880127,
0.06485726684331894,
0.4062957167625427,
0.15505747497081757,
-0.4092634916305542,
-0.3282960057258606,
-0.2057894915342331,
-0.3843309283256531,
0.055011481046676636,
-0.3179164230823517,
-0.12089437246322632,
0.319929301738739,
0.31127020716667175,
-0.7332726716995239,
0.48476916551589966,
0.376584529876709,
-0.4399600327014923,
0.3299809694290161,
-0.05629285052418709,
0.4181954562664032,
-1.0272560119628906,
-0.2761634588241577,
-0.1385199874639511,
-0.4229137897491455,
-0.6826523542404175,
-0.2353164702653885,
-0.4807358980178833,
-0.45595595240592957,
-0.3290225565433502,
0.14026769995689392,
-0.48352497816085815,
-0.12122129648923874,
-0.36290618777275085,
-0.6847622990608215,
-0.08811414986848831,
0.9620493054389954,
0.2509114146232605,
0.8924708366394043,
0.4379322826862335,
-0.6431007385253906,
0.011755828745663166,
0.22613240778446198,
-0.13452382385730743,
0.6285754442214966,
-0.3780520260334015,
0.30474185943603516,
-0.3275020122528076,
0.7045298218727112,
-0.517732560634613,
-0.0659455955028534,
0.38807228207588196,
-0.30823591351509094,
0.34226539731025696,
-0.24932478368282318,
-0.3813464939594269,
-0.24672850966453552,
-0.004733670502901077,
0.26790040731430054,
0.5313025116920471,
-0.20001734793186188,
0.9609344005584717,
0.6050958037376404,
-0.05248111113905907,
-0.5935812592506409,
-0.4723302721977234,
-0.05889669805765152,
-0.09787703305482864,
0.07965201884508133,
0.20052959024906158,
0.28236091136932373,
0.1603631228208542,
-0.07425114512443542,
-0.5509220361709595,
-0.09456562995910645,
-0.39612647891044617,
0.31878525018692017,
-0.07841021567583084,
-0.0025396221317350864,
-0.19004619121551514,
0.07076263427734375,
-0.19254866242408752,
0.09122014790773392,
-0.42868489027023315,
0.8565876483917236,
0.1858210563659668,
-0.7390789985656738,
-0.6382346153259277,
0.6044473052024841,
0.641838550567627,
-0.25424060225486755,
0.1589505672454834,
0.28879424929618835,
-0.3703921139240265,
0.12871694564819336,
-0.5679600834846497,
-0.2652547061443329,
-0.42471185326576233,
0.4186195135116577,
-0.5006118416786194,
-0.6855360865592957,
0.017269762232899666,
0.16025547683238983,
0.48264816403388977,
0.07141542434692383,
0.3645803928375244,
-0.25724950432777405,
0.9691166281700134,
0.5223292708396912,
-0.0003775902441702783,
0.9420380592346191,
-0.2803255617618561,
0.2032707929611206,
-0.565290093421936,
-0.16402114927768707,
-0.340328574180603,
-0.14184542000293732,
-0.1467265784740448,
-0.6272839307785034,
0.4731173515319824,
-0.21698226034641266,
-0.3788991868495941,
0.3776465654373169,
-0.4010709524154663,
0.11527113616466522,
0.806281328201294,
0.2810797393321991,
0.24668768048286438,
0.14723585546016693,
0.574998676776886,
-0.11755699664354324,
-0.8561757206916809,
-0.3738895058631897,
0.9312072992324829,
0.3389139473438263,
0.7125898599624634,
-0.31090083718299866,
0.9120431542396545,
0.3710591197013855,
0.24499517679214478,
-0.8236148953437805,
0.7505669593811035,
-0.0827241986989975,
-0.42393940687179565,
-0.5314059257507324,
-0.23761780560016632,
-0.9803494215011597,
0.0510028600692749,
-0.006212281063199043,
-0.7809189558029175,
0.3891946077346802,
0.6842584013938904,
-0.512990415096283,
0.21153856813907623,
-0.7831223011016846,
0.7830424308776855,
-0.0183667354285717,
0.03754188492894173,
-0.4128035604953766,
-0.49465954303741455,
-0.0794815868139267,
0.4521704912185669,
-0.16652674973011017,
-0.1935431808233261,
0.2860543727874756,
0.6434360146522522,
-0.3651435673236847,
1.2396522760391235,
-0.8204994201660156,
-0.001266599167138338,
0.792149007320404,
0.02209087833762169,
0.7114981412887573,
-0.23692013323307037,
0.29272228479385376,
-0.16094425320625305,
0.1775653064250946,
-0.34921255707740784,
-0.4660133123397827,
0.1545426845550537,
-0.6829674243927002,
-0.6265904903411865,
-0.3406597673892975,
-0.7846831679344177,
-0.512162983417511,
-0.044206030666828156,
0.2553029954433441,
0.8521825671195984,
-0.0366806723177433,
0.06002461537718773,
0.5315430760383606,
-0.13684199750423431,
0.429322212934494,
0.30648544430732727,
0.1342884749174118,
-0.11673574149608612,
1.1617363691329956,
-0.029090702533721924,
0.31282666325569153,
0.6355844140052795,
-0.019622918218374252,
-0.14183378219604492,
-0.45944681763648987,
-0.3156284987926483,
-0.3407088816165924,
-0.3607906401157379,
-0.4442836344242096,
-0.9042221307754517,
-0.16371870040893555,
-0.2982138991355896,
0.10388994216918945,
-0.35291868448257446,
-0.11147627234458923,
-0.07491382211446762,
0.009208306670188904,
0.35673943161964417,
0.5537602305412292,
0.17266607284545898,
0.6180382370948792,
-0.6622969508171082,
0.44154444336891174,
0.21182195842266083,
-0.061830129474401474,
-0.031049707904458046,
-0.1626502126455307,
0.034491751343011856,
0.26484236121177673,
-0.49025946855545044,
-0.9179847836494446,
0.2728612422943115,
0.12730059027671814,
0.3857707381248474,
0.21753138303756714,
0.14323103427886963,
0.9647675156593323,
-0.5297923684120178,
0.6638618111610413,
0.21281839907169342,
-0.818467915058136,
0.6225937008857727,
-0.40486961603164673,
0.6116984486579895,
0.6272059082984924,
0.024759165942668915,
-0.4627341628074646,
-0.8137751221656799,
-0.6870062947273254,
-0.753404438495636,
1.1359533071517944,
0.25082477927207947,
0.14582736790180206,
-0.07187998294830322,
-0.2096836417913437,
0.15694399178028107,
0.3428182005882263,
-0.6192039847373962,
0.09919356554746628,
-0.5467652082443237,
-0.35313689708709717,
0.15062375366687775,
-0.21209177374839783,
-0.2876323461532593,
-0.004874641541391611,
0.6328150629997253,
-0.3538450002670288,
0.5881857872009277,
0.14651528000831604,
0.005388063844293356,
0.12393293529748917,
0.7176166772842407,
0.3365994095802307,
0.43284890055656433,
0.010069641284644604,
-0.0637180283665657,
0.136140376329422,
-0.5817952752113342,
0.1380005031824112,
0.0588211715221405,
-0.19339202344417572,
-0.08464522659778595,
0.1471528857946396,
1.0662287473678589,
0.015016183257102966,
-0.6638018488883972,
0.32541799545288086,
0.2822745144367218,
-0.0007365838391706347,
-0.383680135011673,
0.009674502536654472,
-0.29322540760040283,
0.16085600852966309,
0.3780297040939331,
0.04900537058711052,
0.2587001621723175,
-0.6731858849525452,
-0.14635899662971497,
0.35385429859161377,
-0.5128801465034485,
-0.3357120156288147,
0.19107036292552948,
0.5007041692733765,
-0.42652463912963867,
0.5108566880226135,
-0.3179726004600525,
-0.3967300355434418,
0.6281268000602722,
0.5655617117881775,
0.8845784664154053,
0.0902467668056488,
0.19775648415088654,
0.29574111104011536,
0.1960449516773224,
0.12814348936080933,
0.7690285444259644,
-0.5395943522453308,
-0.8304977416992188,
-0.6639181971549988,
-0.34441524744033813,
-0.37369927763938904,
0.34558847546577454,
-0.8131493330001831,
-0.12767161428928375,
-0.14790351688861847,
-0.4559028446674347,
-0.5610281229019165,
-0.28169429302215576,
-0.6656914353370667,
0.21515198051929474,
-0.18402689695358276,
0.6304466128349304,
-0.8494201302528381,
0.8027365207672119,
0.6395151019096375,
-0.12486869096755981,
-0.726723849773407,
0.3582388162612915,
-0.057428792119026184,
-0.864687979221344,
0.48266687989234924,
0.15847721695899963,
-0.20630568265914917,
0.19190719723701477,
-0.3441507816314697,
-0.6945972442626953,
0.7763994336128235,
0.1281762272119522,
-0.5489359498023987,
-0.4567500650882721,
-0.03461875766515732,
0.29281601309776306,
-0.4118691682815552,
0.30405378341674805,
0.7621878385543823,
0.37475964426994324,
0.12840832769870758,
-1.0572235584259033,
-0.03220990672707558,
-0.1319272518157959,
0.10989809036254883,
0.46858635544776917,
-0.25999578833580017,
0.5261223316192627,
-0.09349821507930756,
-0.45120325684547424,
-0.22965267300605774,
0.6700242757797241,
0.38720789551734924,
0.1291971355676651,
0.9903104901313782,
0.3963336944580078,
0.1893366128206253,
-0.4353170096874237,
1.0218273401260376,
-0.2608455717563629,
-0.07370045781135559,
1.3203893899917603,
-0.1582639217376709,
0.6001168489456177,
0.7702688574790955,
-0.08862917125225067,
0.10364991426467896,
0.5792390704154968,
0.33014607429504395,
0.6563071608543396,
-0.06516549736261368,
-0.35678061842918396,
-0.5125775933265686,
-0.5052891969680786,
-0.07113982737064362,
0.40787437558174133,
0.6038573980331421,
0.08733532577753067,
-0.4862257242202759,
0.35486236214637756,
-0.039217010140419006,
-0.10135679692029953,
-0.3012908101081848,
0.9145764112472534,
-0.22618195414543152,
-1.0423343181610107,
0.19400916993618011,
-0.3099781572818756,
0.8127240538597107,
-0.6804097294807434,
-0.25804468989372253,
0.13505922257900238,
-0.039229996502399445,
-0.0636407881975174,
-0.6608558297157288,
0.385775089263916,
0.10698039084672928,
-0.012740977108478546,
-0.8903370499610901,
0.4011509120464325,
-0.5668964982032776,
-0.08993372321128845,
-0.13609230518341064,
0.5704126954078674,
0.14251987636089325,
0.08468572050333023,
-0.5946521162986755,
0.11995754390954971,
0.2247989922761917,
-0.3110414743423462,
-0.08978144824504852,
0.3560524582862854,
-0.277763307094574,
0.38718247413635254,
0.44483768939971924,
-0.00508772861212492,
0.074610635638237,
0.4007645845413208,
0.7884528636932373,
-0.423468679189682,
-0.647846519947052,
-0.3140186369419098,
0.5600854158401489,
-0.05216394364833832,
-0.3320283591747284,
0.19506250321865082,
0.2807638347148895,
0.6785686612129211,
-0.09719540923833847,
0.7419719696044922,
-0.42765894532203674,
0.5225067734718323,
-0.6600266695022583,
0.2549937665462494,
-0.31727755069732666,
-0.1395118236541748,
0.12758828699588776,
-0.8810756802558899,
0.4371873736381531,
0.3505033254623413,
-0.29158008098602295,
0.12228162586688995,
0.608746349811554,
0.6106528043746948,
-0.03908073157072067,
0.041949160397052765,
0.06253159791231155,
-0.04239625111222267,
0.593763530254364,
0.7938188910484314,
0.9282453060150146,
-0.08067023009061813,
0.6082778573036194,
-0.046855099499225616,
-0.23697537183761597,
0.026425229385495186,
-0.6017350554466248,
-0.8027681708335876,
-0.5467075705528259,
-0.31303367018699646,
-0.20093561708927155,
0.4216642677783966,
1.0400868654251099,
0.9788060188293457,
-0.8597347736358643,
-0.34930670261383057,
-0.4088808000087738,
-0.26419389247894287,
-0.35120701789855957,
-0.2628370225429535,
0.07684550434350967,
-0.5447753667831421,
-1.0415143966674805,
0.5811080932617188,
0.22897107899188995,
0.16126467287540436,
-0.14019860327243805,
0.07150150835514069,
0.02663853019475937,
-0.16307947039604187,
0.6357148289680481,
0.5434897541999817,
-0.9571388363838196,
-0.3016324043273926,
-0.0727856382727623,
0.015068811364471912,
0.15907035768032074,
1.3605289459228516,
-0.8102079033851624,
0.43236979842185974,
0.24305230379104614,
0.6401561498641968,
0.7415347695350647,
0.09643162786960602,
1.0313676595687866,
-0.9113145470619202,
0.335563063621521,
0.659098744392395,
0.1536571979522705,
0.08431027829647064,
-0.3692384362220764,
0.2672376334667206,
-0.08928610384464264,
-0.1327710598707199,
-0.8434987664222717,
0.5892431735992432,
-0.9188717007637024,
0.006362463813275099,
1.0496492385864258,
-0.05865452438592911,
0.04831849783658981,
-0.4910958707332611,
-0.34410563111305237,
0.33485427498817444,
-0.7532839179039001,
0.3309924900531769,
0.522599995136261,
-0.5276564359664917,
-0.1729486733675003,
-0.5975317358970642,
0.5016915798187256,
0.5463510155677795,
-1.1051307916641235,
0.10283708572387695,
0.5233654975891113,
-0.06364653259515762,
0.16226153075695038,
1.2588096857070923,
-0.031506530940532684,
0.23453885316848755,
0.030451787635684013,
0.13326701521873474,
-0.3303869664669037,
-0.5298926830291748,
0.06374302506446838,
0.03280085697770119,
-0.04898038133978844,
-0.7091626524925232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01730v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01730v1 | Evaluating LLM -- Generated Multimodal Diagnosis from Medical Images and Symptom Analysis | 2024-01-28T09:25:12 | 2024-01-28T09:25:12 | Dimitrios P. Panagoulias, Maria Virvou, George A. Tsihrintzis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Large language models (LLMs) constitute a breakthrough state-of-the-art
Artificial Intelligence technology which is rapidly evolving and promises to
aid in medical diagnosis. However, the correctness and the accuracy of their
returns has not yet been properly evaluated. In this work, we propose an LLM
evaluation paradigm that incorporates two independent steps of a novel
methodology, namely (1) multimodal LLM evaluation via structured interactions
and (2) follow-up, domain-specific analysis based on data extracted via the
previous interactions. Using this paradigm, (1) we evaluate the correctness and
accuracy of LLM-generated medical diagnosis with publicly available multimodal
multiple-choice questions(MCQs) in the domain of Pathology and (2) proceed to a
systemic and comprehensive analysis of extracted results. We used
GPT-4-Vision-Preview as the LLM to respond to complex, medical questions
consisting of both images and text, and we explored a wide range of diseases,
conditions, chemical compounds, and related entity types that are included in
the vast knowledge domain of Pathology. GPT-4-Vision-Preview performed quite
well, scoring approximately 84\% of correct diagnoses. Next, we further
analyzed the findings of our work, following an analytical approach which
included Image Metadata Analysis, Named Entity Recognition and Knowledge
Graphs. Weaknesses of GPT-4-Vision-Preview were revealed on specific knowledge
paths, leading to a further understanding of its shortcomings in specific
areas. Our methodology and findings are not limited to the use of
GPT-4-Vision-Preview, but a similar approach can be followed to evaluate the
usefulness and accuracy of other LLMs and, thus, improve their use with further
optimization. | [
-0.211700439453125,
-0.8389597535133362,
1.0964429378509521,
0.2517468333244324,
-0.44118037819862366,
-0.07875411212444305,
-0.35403159260749817,
-0.5425888299942017,
0.2889147102832794,
0.3277968764305115,
-0.5362696647644043,
-0.7360143065452576,
-0.6802006959915161,
0.39410150051116943,
-0.2312956303358078,
0.8949069380760193,
-0.13265059888362885,
0.3426586389541626,
-0.4611783027648926,
-0.08236809819936752,
-0.3979104459285736,
-0.18182872235774994,
-0.7267934679985046,
-0.2842673361301422,
0.5079095363616943,
-0.1017734631896019,
0.613946259021759,
0.43950554728507996,
0.8713842630386353,
0.3463512659072876,
0.009284576401114464,
0.3816627264022827,
-0.12183436006307602,
0.13112777471542358,
0.0400380864739418,
-0.006615056190639734,
-0.6712948083877563,
0.12082938849925995,
0.6448968052864075,
0.4917272627353668,
0.07081987708806992,
0.00018245077808387578,
0.10513025522232056,
0.41734015941619873,
-0.37752965092658997,
0.3438480496406555,
-0.3370884954929352,
0.3347608745098114,
-0.17240653932094574,
-0.4606945216655731,
-0.3662864565849304,
-0.13231799006462097,
0.12681405246257782,
-0.583443820476532,
-0.0389501117169857,
-0.2353007197380066,
0.7523696422576904,
0.17871254682540894,
-0.6156820058822632,
-0.456013560295105,
-0.5155463814735413,
0.5245798230171204,
-0.5977605581283569,
0.3674641251564026,
0.02867208607494831,
0.5012069344520569,
-0.2102186530828476,
-0.8057717680931091,
-0.484198659658432,
-0.5659786462783813,
-0.035616472363471985,
0.536350667476654,
-0.18169167637825012,
0.08196710795164108,
0.19133295118808746,
0.262501060962677,
-0.6127691864967346,
0.10128035396337509,
-0.3023703396320343,
-0.5097342133522034,
0.5682971477508545,
0.5130854249000549,
0.48195603489875793,
-0.3638022243976593,
-0.6044298410415649,
0.141240656375885,
-0.5541936755180359,
-0.2751004695892334,
-0.11517710983753204,
0.00439245393499732,
-0.1858385056257248,
0.5793226361274719,
-0.08310146629810333,
0.8086510896682739,
-0.09041640162467957,
-0.8401167392730713,
0.4147653579711914,
-0.6990612745285034,
-0.26224926114082336,
-0.31676429510116577,
1.00883948802948,
0.6974132657051086,
-0.019243577495217323,
-0.007186982315033674,
-0.2028794139623642,
0.12772676348686218,
0.060245778411626816,
-0.6916242837905884,
-0.16128718852996826,
0.4394019842147827,
-0.778296947479248,
-0.30484941601753235,
-0.49738991260528564,
-0.9161104559898376,
-0.6557013988494873,
-0.271275132894516,
0.48715755343437195,
-0.5744688510894775,
-0.23970261216163635,
-0.038552530109882355,
0.09024028480052948,
-0.05802256241440773,
0.596947431564331,
-0.45478227734565735,
0.09996180236339569,
0.25994470715522766,
0.8312685489654541,
-0.4428839683532715,
-0.10892738401889801,
-0.4202640950679779,
0.17706972360610962,
-0.2293435037136078,
0.9751362800598145,
-0.5950660705566406,
-0.36698460578918457,
-0.17216894030570984,
-0.07753936201334,
-0.34077560901641846,
-0.6214792132377625,
0.40700602531433105,
-0.25629091262817383,
0.0912119597196579,
-0.12204904109239578,
-0.41925734281539917,
-0.07679402828216553,
0.668401837348938,
-0.7349835634231567,
0.6459740400314331,
0.07773581892251968,
-0.6181348562240601,
0.4554597735404968,
-0.6920494437217712,
-0.13978922367095947,
0.20810700953006744,
-0.450284481048584,
-0.26745060086250305,
-0.18073448538780212,
0.5077948570251465,
0.7014850378036499,
-0.37631022930145264,
0.497124582529068,
-0.22776097059249878,
-0.047251470386981964,
0.13863541185855865,
-0.4610953629016876,
0.4603719413280487,
-0.01133020780980587,
-0.23003138601779938,
0.2120417207479477,
-0.7569615840911865,
0.005560426507145166,
0.2702432870864868,
-0.4064933657646179,
-0.027545789256691933,
0.007749252021312714,
-0.24261264503002167,
0.3076898455619812,
0.3442363142967224,
-0.501377522945404,
0.3316688537597656,
-0.4098590612411499,
0.1320079118013382,
0.6586058139801025,
0.18805187940597534,
-0.006644006818532944,
-0.31244295835494995,
0.7370190024375916,
0.510651707649231,
0.46394652128219604,
-0.3851107358932495,
-0.8620169758796692,
-0.48827052116394043,
-0.5282028317451477,
0.020955046638846397,
0.4690617024898529,
-0.8723130226135254,
-0.05200476199388504,
-0.3487783372402191,
-0.37308382987976074,
-0.38687554001808167,
0.016963902860879898,
0.6054571866989136,
0.5544270277023315,
0.4356558620929718,
-0.35172590613365173,
-0.38203707337379456,
-1.0339521169662476,
-0.09994453936815262,
-0.011268621310591698,
0.15878517925739288,
0.43078893423080444,
0.47142618894577026,
-0.6454796195030212,
0.48635682463645935,
-0.4049162268638611,
-0.3882691264152527,
-0.13980917632579803,
-0.02296285331249237,
0.26425042748451233,
0.229281947016716,
0.47168874740600586,
-0.45336616039276123,
-0.2281412035226822,
0.2731379270553589,
-0.794883131980896,
-0.023319141939282417,
0.03119044378399849,
0.22625111043453217,
0.25302228331565857,
0.22338129580020905,
-0.5465196967124939,
0.4614756405353546,
0.7662109136581421,
-0.28256505727767944,
0.7679740190505981,
-0.2549704611301422,
0.43926021456718445,
-1.121584177017212,
-0.12449490278959274,
0.21101385354995728,
-0.19760799407958984,
-0.29388609528541565,
0.11112134903669357,
0.027068452909588814,
-0.03019937314093113,
-0.2325199693441391,
0.6250287294387817,
-0.4237399399280548,
-0.14922942221164703,
0.11791659146547318,
0.2297479212284088,
0.06117759272456169,
0.2372480034828186,
-0.14419668912887573,
0.49298375844955444,
0.5634864568710327,
-0.2974525988101959,
0.4603820741176605,
-0.061912309378385544,
-0.23812361061573029,
0.3708278238773346,
-0.3757306933403015,
0.14842593669891357,
-0.17686827480793,
0.07878763228654861,
-1.192490577697754,
-0.28758737444877625,
0.4679049253463745,
-0.2766440510749817,
0.34855353832244873,
-0.07831962406635284,
-0.6362509727478027,
-0.39254623651504517,
-0.3010587990283966,
0.5324896574020386,
0.20249682664871216,
-0.3582066297531128,
0.923332929611206,
0.12635503709316254,
-0.19486001133918762,
-0.37858346104621887,
-0.3640901744365692,
0.03968994691967964,
-0.06703495979309082,
-0.9064821004867554,
0.3881435990333557,
-0.21227537095546722,
-0.24703136086463928,
-0.024738891050219536,
0.053875040262937546,
-0.08767654746770859,
-0.0764438733458519,
0.230274960398674,
0.4691101908683777,
-0.2711041569709778,
0.06313125789165497,
0.060354914516210556,
-0.1275797188282013,
0.04277936741709709,
0.1477169692516327,
0.48477697372436523,
-0.2663451135158539,
-0.7658321857452393,
-0.4107527434825897,
0.16371935606002808,
0.6638708710670471,
-0.14069940149784088,
0.09035400301218033,
0.6482468247413635,
-0.3576009273529053,
0.13006004691123962,
-0.47272536158561707,
-0.055676039308309555,
-0.39436978101730347,
0.4437209367752075,
-0.35312923789024353,
-0.6283746957778931,
0.5632158517837524,
-0.30376359820365906,
-0.18688561022281647,
0.4730338752269745,
0.934792160987854,
-0.06396349519491196,
1.1853058338165283,
0.4286041259765625,
0.2203238606452942,
-0.09745638817548752,
-0.1681780368089676,
0.3589962124824524,
-0.8781901597976685,
-0.7152063250541687,
-0.09574016183614731,
-0.051366668194532394,
-0.35793668031692505,
-0.523515522480011,
0.9864093661308289,
-0.28026482462882996,
0.2695145905017853,
-0.21070770919322968,
-0.3713293671607971,
0.18848612904548645,
-0.046159833669662476,
0.4104257822036743,
0.47286897897720337,
-0.013815541751682758,
-0.5709608793258667,
-0.14298748970031738,
-0.5694862008094788,
-0.6005801558494568,
1.3079885244369507,
0.3791809380054474,
0.39393559098243713,
0.12531813979148865,
0.4601120352745056,
0.16541878879070282,
0.6068244576454163,
-1.1054317951202393,
0.6159635186195374,
-0.18701806664466858,
-0.3445935547351837,
0.026041630655527115,
-0.2997777462005615,
-1.0601298809051514,
0.416431188583374,
-0.28283247351646423,
-0.8176715970039368,
-0.181838721036911,
0.19947154819965363,
-0.5016276836395264,
0.03784501180052757,
-0.6597443222999573,
0.8295146822929382,
-0.4845805764198303,
-0.09542558342218399,
-0.1722773015499115,
-0.5742307901382446,
0.7071659564971924,
-0.2937389612197876,
0.4038895070552826,
-0.13443872332572937,
-0.11353455483913422,
0.7392956018447876,
-0.009129773825407028,
0.6705349087715149,
-0.07285185158252716,
-0.23699864745140076,
-0.21950602531433105,
0.14879187941551208,
0.03967621177434921,
0.11269872635602951,
0.04126264899969101,
0.10799072682857513,
0.21929745376110077,
-0.06382839381694794,
-0.8019787073135376,
0.5824623703956604,
-0.5543620586395264,
-0.5124126672744751,
-0.37057065963745117,
-0.6285709142684937,
-0.5352309942245483,
0.26043152809143066,
0.08244310319423676,
0.8059576749801636,
0.030185706913471222,
-0.2942434251308441,
0.3246089220046997,
-0.47544172406196594,
0.2875201106071472,
0.5433070659637451,
-0.43973463773727417,
-0.38535213470458984,
0.756024181842804,
-0.044328514486551285,
0.1278458535671234,
0.093075230717659,
0.40159857273101807,
-0.2763342261314392,
-0.8680649399757385,
-0.4278871417045593,
0.3698597252368927,
-0.9269078969955444,
-0.2242719531059265,
-0.5414425730705261,
-0.14781832695007324,
-0.32483670115470886,
0.2873312830924988,
-0.1655733436346054,
0.13285697996616364,
-0.02195010334253311,
0.21192175149917603,
0.0525551401078701,
0.754266083240509,
0.10184170305728912,
-0.04617822542786598,
-1.0420643091201782,
0.3154030740261078,
-0.009129631333053112,
0.25316256284713745,
-0.04820965975522995,
-0.1754918247461319,
-0.08663704991340637,
0.03082985244691372,
-0.45663559436798096,
-0.9959167242050171,
0.3245474696159363,
0.2176118642091751,
0.7043434977531433,
0.570044219493866,
-0.37580353021621704,
0.8794595003128052,
-0.4305729269981384,
0.8503759503364563,
0.45180511474609375,
-0.649485170841217,
0.6381938457489014,
-0.23561258614063263,
0.10617180913686752,
0.1380891650915146,
0.49053409695625305,
-0.16346825659275055,
-0.3796446621417999,
-0.4128875732421875,
-0.7121014595031738,
0.35062265396118164,
0.09689021855592728,
-0.13534337282180786,
-0.23608848452568054,
0.3274153769016266,
0.0513407438993454,
-0.13720901310443878,
-0.6438868045806885,
-0.14972348511219025,
0.062002018094062805,
-0.27870455384254456,
-0.05038166418671608,
-0.2778153717517853,
-0.4813165068626404,
-0.48793113231658936,
0.24590635299682617,
-0.3140788674354553,
0.5751012563705444,
0.3962332606315613,
-0.12778401374816895,
0.08726292848587036,
0.15463271737098694,
0.6388603448867798,
0.9526911377906799,
-0.017700519412755966,
0.03747008740901947,
-0.009656243957579136,
-0.5514540672302246,
-0.09043102711439133,
0.11499986052513123,
0.2002144455909729,
0.0978202223777771,
0.6509500741958618,
0.6268890500068665,
0.06657111644744873,
-0.8872362375259399,
0.897193968296051,
-0.06302789598703384,
-0.29182907938957214,
-0.17390640079975128,
-0.24092531204223633,
0.053614016622304916,
0.5272833704948425,
0.27748343348503113,
0.16756728291511536,
0.31406378746032715,
-0.39211466908454895,
0.14661145210266113,
0.5805560946464539,
-0.1589060127735138,
-0.34391483664512634,
0.32537388801574707,
0.12207947671413422,
0.13483403623104095,
0.7832175493240356,
-0.13415442407131195,
-0.40878692269325256,
0.7053839564323425,
0.5963795185089111,
0.4414096176624298,
-0.020066261291503906,
0.20034708082675934,
0.22378766536712646,
0.3017851412296295,
0.1884385347366333,
0.3738272488117218,
0.13846561312675476,
-0.9364873766899109,
-0.7953705787658691,
-0.6226806044578552,
-0.15282994508743286,
0.4521671235561371,
-0.546896755695343,
0.2510659992694855,
-0.39979124069213867,
-0.4592728018760681,
0.28001293540000916,
-0.11372204124927521,
-0.5582071542739868,
0.41994285583496094,
0.1454288363456726,
0.7664464712142944,
-0.6443135142326355,
0.7003554701805115,
0.7869348526000977,
-0.3867476284503937,
-0.899547815322876,
0.09732779115438461,
0.23315000534057617,
-1.182278037071228,
0.7912997007369995,
0.253333181142807,
-0.023363851010799408,
-0.1500241607427597,
-0.3919799029827118,
-0.7652097940444946,
1.2439773082733154,
0.4584489166736603,
-0.4891399145126343,
0.08698034286499023,
-0.0800064206123352,
0.5624581575393677,
-0.4058082103729248,
0.43643346428871155,
0.5544767379760742,
0.6226686835289001,
0.20548346638679504,
-1.2646063566207886,
0.2833270728588104,
-0.4642236530780792,
-0.04040950909256935,
0.21671006083488464,
-0.2810528874397278,
0.6997320055961609,
-0.4080710709095001,
-0.2437538504600525,
0.17004472017288208,
-0.02177748829126358,
0.45766982436180115,
0.44624754786491394,
0.37590211629867554,
0.6581212878227234,
0.6167701482772827,
-0.0272707287222147,
1.3180400133132935,
-0.5843304395675659,
0.3748668432235718,
0.4723159372806549,
-0.3414597511291504,
0.6302304863929749,
0.5212838053703308,
-0.2652878761291504,
0.3833670914173126,
0.6587337851524353,
-0.13855355978012085,
0.3712281584739685,
-0.007062262389808893,
-0.2738805413246155,
-0.24619264900684357,
-0.010723309591412544,
-0.41412705183029175,
0.5165383815765381,
0.5278147459030151,
-0.5376440286636353,
-0.43292132019996643,
0.03570277616381645,
-0.16053937375545502,
-0.29860854148864746,
-0.31541091203689575,
0.7771187424659729,
-0.041580088436603546,
-0.4033403694629669,
0.5635731220245361,
0.03026995249092579,
0.593366801738739,
-0.4417596459388733,
-0.2562761902809143,
-0.11346682161092758,
-0.039480239152908325,
-0.3083120882511139,
-0.7729170322418213,
0.3304082453250885,
-0.13822296261787415,
-0.0940735787153244,
0.05256893113255501,
0.7507063746452332,
-0.20701506733894348,
-0.5767006278038025,
0.40304136276245117,
0.7153961062431335,
0.4449528157711029,
0.09111963212490082,
-0.7152023911476135,
0.1769651621580124,
-0.21032533049583435,
-0.04504077881574631,
0.4280247092247009,
0.18408158421516418,
-0.15621709823608398,
0.7815330624580383,
0.5818358659744263,
0.18639010190963745,
-0.15000933408737183,
0.18368619680404663,
0.9778571724891663,
-0.3761293888092041,
0.007062597665935755,
-0.9529861211776733,
0.5216818451881409,
0.0403129942715168,
-0.15595635771751404,
0.44290679693222046,
0.3364545702934265,
0.5317195653915405,
-0.07734541594982147,
0.7495031356811523,
0.10157955437898636,
0.12042997032403946,
-0.7687258124351501,
0.5186211466789246,
-0.7786504030227661,
0.2865579426288605,
-0.40277260541915894,
-0.6297973394393921,
-0.44309741258621216,
0.3419851064682007,
-0.34627047181129456,
0.2686280906200409,
1.0385783910751343,
0.8280050754547119,
0.02705187164247036,
-0.1459815800189972,
0.4391807019710541,
0.4042922258377075,
0.11534184962511063,
0.6509020924568176,
0.924677312374115,
-0.09080728143453598,
0.4450594186782837,
-0.1783943772315979,
-0.45615559816360474,
-0.12826260924339294,
-0.9454571604728699,
-0.7099818587303162,
-0.5388091206550598,
-0.26593682169914246,
-0.33869925141334534,
0.10816539078950882,
0.6800512075424194,
0.7087001204490662,
-0.40212196111679077,
0.1371118128299713,
0.4570120871067047,
-0.13238397240638733,
-0.18209215998649597,
-0.1973336935043335,
0.4970431625843048,
-0.20485767722129822,
-0.48970964550971985,
0.48565223813056946,
0.6925240159034729,
-0.027733052149415016,
-0.32837915420532227,
0.03351211920380592,
0.2274889498949051,
-0.3950634002685547,
1.0482828617095947,
-0.320793479681015,
-0.9913241863250732,
-0.05981709063053131,
-0.12496939301490784,
0.026397792622447014,
0.18533670902252197,
0.6666476726531982,
-0.734475314617157,
0.5957587361335754,
0.1005152240395546,
0.6098463535308838,
0.19325090944766998,
-0.11301276832818985,
0.38744738698005676,
-0.28534623980522156,
-0.11301736533641815,
0.4133223295211792,
0.5604076385498047,
0.1978338062763214,
-0.5294181108474731,
0.18714721500873566,
0.47124481201171875,
-0.27952840924263,
-0.4784504771232605,
0.373049795627594,
-1.2773497104644775,
-0.14920172095298767,
1.3929064273834229,
-0.33855271339416504,
-0.20028305053710938,
-0.10145820677280426,
-0.22184698283672333,
0.04764622449874878,
-0.16339696943759918,
0.6662967205047607,
0.4960990846157074,
-0.6607852578163147,
-0.3145221173763275,
-0.4694245755672455,
0.24522481858730316,
0.1945381760597229,
-0.8508084416389465,
-0.6754183173179626,
0.6960278749465942,
0.611696183681488,
0.19722247123718262,
0.9150406122207642,
-0.5885108113288879,
0.3518889546394348,
-0.3101571500301361,
-0.17442436516284943,
-0.18349918723106384,
-0.22926215827465057,
-0.32050254940986633,
0.24232229590415955,
0.012854484841227531,
-0.15418948233127594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01729v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01729v3 | Contextualization Distillation from Large Language Model for Knowledge Graph Completion | 2024-01-28T08:56:49 | 2024-02-24T07:01:22 | Dawei Li, Zhen Tan, Tianlong Chen, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While textual information significantly enhances the performance of
pre-trained language models (PLMs) in knowledge graph completion (KGC), the
static and noisy nature of existing corpora collected from Wikipedia articles
or synsets definitions often limits the potential of PLM-based KGC models. To
surmount these challenges, we introduce the Contextualization Distillation
strategy, a versatile plug-in-and-play approach compatible with both
discriminative and generative KGC frameworks. Our method begins by instructing
large language models (LLMs) to transform compact, structural triplets into
context-rich segments. Subsequently, we introduce two tailored auxiliary tasks,
reconstruction and contextualization, allowing smaller KGC models to assimilate
insights from these enriched triplets. Comprehensive evaluations across diverse
datasets and KGC techniques highlight the efficacy and adaptability of our
approach, revealing consistent performance enhancements irrespective of
underlying pipelines or architectures. Moreover, our analysis makes our method
more explainable and provides insight into generating path selection, as well
as the choosing of suitable distillation tasks. All the code and data in this
work will be released at
https://github.com/David-Li0406/Contextulization-Distillation | [
-0.5067619681358337,
-0.7385112643241882,
0.8032587170600891,
-0.06189810484647751,
-0.44214364886283875,
0.18872159719467163,
-0.47186464071273804,
-0.02271934412419796,
0.09982074797153473,
0.552848756313324,
-0.5215831995010376,
-0.7181559205055237,
-0.7122414112091064,
0.17777425050735474,
-0.266915500164032,
1.1811641454696655,
-0.3427514433860779,
-0.2497343122959137,
-0.5248793959617615,
-0.04867132753133774,
-0.7230342030525208,
-0.26728537678718567,
-0.3960719406604767,
-0.49316754937171936,
0.6210048198699951,
0.38179805874824524,
0.35299888253211975,
0.6388593912124634,
-0.05629955604672432,
0.25239086151123047,
-0.3446568250656128,
0.4499031603336334,
-0.7678139805793762,
0.3182552456855774,
0.13053813576698303,
-0.15425825119018555,
-0.15182821452617645,
0.03082168474793434,
0.5561738014221191,
1.0941989421844482,
-0.038972508162260056,
0.080958791077137,
0.45373567938804626,
0.8201231360435486,
-0.6754207015037537,
0.554388701915741,
-0.6051722764968872,
-0.08814995735883713,
-0.21548907458782196,
-0.14206521213054657,
-0.4142145812511444,
-0.4025110602378845,
0.36985093355178833,
-0.7652718424797058,
0.11204344779253006,
-0.059431061148643494,
0.2840953767299652,
0.36851805448532104,
-0.9265432953834534,
-0.3634871244430542,
-0.9042432904243469,
0.4110279083251953,
-0.5904324650764465,
0.2765929698944092,
0.465585857629776,
0.4316524565219879,
-0.21363504230976105,
-1.1032878160476685,
-0.5938581824302673,
-0.16514445841312408,
-0.3983057737350464,
0.12423764914274216,
-0.023326514288783073,
0.01857643760740757,
0.3583746552467346,
0.2731527090072632,
-0.21711471676826477,
-0.26755714416503906,
-0.4885948598384857,
-0.15888069570064545,
0.2148982286453247,
-0.1361665427684784,
0.08473137766122818,
-0.3385051190853119,
-0.15743891894817352,
-0.13028861582279205,
-0.738934338092804,
-0.2188318818807602,
0.2640129029750824,
0.25263774394989014,
0.15018725395202637,
0.5479804277420044,
-0.44843554496765137,
1.0119526386260986,
0.05312687158584595,
-0.4271070063114166,
0.3572499752044678,
-0.44724059104919434,
0.05491446703672409,
0.26139527559280396,
0.7862715125083923,
0.1701211780309677,
0.09224072098731995,
-0.38946565985679626,
0.14122427999973297,
-0.45302656292915344,
0.2833331525325775,
-0.8255236744880676,
-0.5373850464820862,
0.17432810366153717,
-0.07450691610574722,
-0.244954913854599,
-0.11783725768327713,
-0.5058851838111877,
-0.42984211444854736,
-0.5421611666679382,
0.03860795125365257,
-0.6267085671424866,
-0.2499755471944809,
-0.08755484223365784,
-0.32212284207344055,
-0.2976713478565216,
0.11124688386917114,
-0.9238662719726562,
-0.12470492720603943,
0.5807411074638367,
0.9368023872375488,
-0.04823077470064163,
-0.30660882592201233,
-0.44257649779319763,
0.6291592121124268,
-0.3463207185268402,
0.4879607558250427,
-0.12254063040018082,
-0.48915597796440125,
-0.0625220388174057,
-0.10197307914495468,
0.08426252007484436,
-0.601291835308075,
0.4962388873100281,
-0.8938361406326294,
0.05430407077074051,
-0.5237897038459778,
-0.5230904221534729,
-0.3778213858604431,
0.2846584916114807,
-0.8613254427909851,
1.1119829416275024,
0.2695872485637665,
-1.024160623550415,
0.6693122982978821,
-0.6704174876213074,
-0.8167582154273987,
0.13913211226463318,
0.05745210871100426,
-0.10888063907623291,
-0.011577123776078224,
0.26459741592407227,
0.6130399703979492,
-0.08572529256343842,
0.7264400124549866,
-0.4059319496154785,
0.10611996799707413,
-0.21354353427886963,
-0.2718513607978821,
0.7580054402351379,
0.3210768401622772,
-0.18605956435203552,
-0.05393337830901146,
-0.9570658206939697,
-0.17286550998687744,
-0.05292767286300659,
-0.5895923972129822,
-0.6035524606704712,
0.2032395750284195,
-0.16878312826156616,
0.2132786512374878,
0.3824993669986725,
-0.3182568848133087,
0.3261253237724304,
-0.22084160149097443,
0.6673189997673035,
0.5049212574958801,
-0.06548290699720383,
0.4436236619949341,
0.26530981063842773,
0.18806315958499908,
0.014841529540717602,
-0.09741751849651337,
0.07397648692131042,
-0.34406089782714844,
-0.5191178917884827,
-0.453965961933136,
0.2571830153465271,
0.26956841349601746,
-1.1922316551208496,
0.5239030122756958,
-0.6313483119010925,
-0.47174885869026184,
0.00003306583676021546,
0.2977030277252197,
0.19624067842960358,
1.0505456924438477,
0.35756251215934753,
-0.01034808624535799,
-0.6467899680137634,
-0.6573443412780762,
0.16033793985843658,
-0.1678161323070526,
-0.23754248023033142,
0.34950733184814453,
0.38686156272888184,
-0.1975562572479248,
1.405784010887146,
-0.9387200474739075,
-0.2777058780193329,
-0.3476969301700592,
0.2882278859615326,
0.23924048244953156,
0.18159475922584534,
0.6214603185653687,
-1.070353388786316,
-0.8859403729438782,
0.17702379822731018,
-0.8088249564170837,
-0.3451458215713501,
0.4654495120048523,
-0.23003177344799042,
-0.1985912322998047,
0.681341290473938,
-0.42491614818573,
0.2059241533279419,
0.5095852613449097,
-0.21282382309436798,
0.4357043504714966,
-0.2220132201910019,
0.21796531975269318,
-1.417621374130249,
0.4396774470806122,
-0.4056266248226166,
-0.44161054491996765,
-0.7906532287597656,
-0.3074367940425873,
0.045746635645627975,
0.017819393426179886,
-0.26879820227622986,
0.2746947109699249,
-0.407283216714859,
0.09167447686195374,
-0.29416418075561523,
0.4157625138759613,
0.35771986842155457,
0.3634567856788635,
-0.11731255054473877,
0.4231088161468506,
0.3085974454879761,
-0.6066835522651672,
0.7085561156272888,
0.3170892298221588,
-0.5607327222824097,
0.3534528613090515,
-0.40614086389541626,
-0.027257299050688744,
-0.2336033135652542,
0.5679181218147278,
-1.0879848003387451,
-0.49715951085090637,
0.14303137362003326,
0.005566698499023914,
0.4239424765110016,
-0.4661150276660919,
-0.6384643912315369,
-0.3741616904735565,
0.05441742390394211,
0.4700224995613098,
0.49680671095848083,
-0.7309700846672058,
0.7889533042907715,
0.4112553894519806,
-0.09721287339925766,
-0.5152763724327087,
-0.5234694480895996,
0.07721089571714401,
-0.43175235390663147,
-0.6677830219268799,
0.5093623995780945,
-0.11345358192920685,
0.0066068898886442184,
-0.03296074643731117,
-0.09072177857160568,
-0.017667479813098907,
0.2519778907299042,
0.1164366751909256,
0.3094117045402527,
0.15260282158851624,
-0.02753256820142269,
0.16978247463703156,
-0.023160066455602646,
-0.12103382498025894,
-0.8263922929763794,
0.6255303621292114,
0.389341801404953,
-0.27046677470207214,
-0.03251931816339493,
0.02658637799322605,
0.6143838167190552,
0.008645135909318924,
0.8599963188171387,
0.6807988286018372,
-0.1682085394859314,
0.04985825717449188,
-0.6266623735427856,
-0.011689591221511364,
-0.44793063402175903,
0.3993940055370331,
-0.25424742698669434,
-1.076865315437317,
0.5121256709098816,
-0.3888365626335144,
-0.043293245136737823,
0.3584456145763397,
0.32779908180236816,
0.09925388544797897,
0.9075831770896912,
0.4795905351638794,
-0.24699437618255615,
0.4990147352218628,
-0.24739208817481995,
0.38240498304367065,
-0.7676381468772888,
-0.25021877884864807,
-0.25820010900497437,
-0.09830048680305481,
-0.38301530480384827,
-0.29579272866249084,
0.7508960366249084,
0.6198691129684448,
0.2076379358768463,
0.3539302945137024,
-0.3191179931163788,
0.5765944123268127,
0.4951034188270569,
-0.1797177642583847,
0.4547562003135681,
0.10140272229909897,
-0.4781284034252167,
0.20463931560516357,
-0.8682515621185303,
-0.4050885736942291,
1.161603331565857,
0.05923913046717644,
0.15826641023159027,
0.13550947606563568,
0.8262737393379211,
0.0505630299448967,
0.40279579162597656,
-0.6514785289764404,
0.30849647521972656,
-0.22317828238010406,
-0.553142786026001,
-0.32961124181747437,
-0.7053977847099304,
-0.6151385307312012,
0.20900751650333405,
-0.05995118245482445,
-0.7745396494865417,
-0.02018153667449951,
0.37737202644348145,
-0.37934190034866333,
0.2614409625530243,
-0.824607789516449,
1.0858272314071655,
0.06277285516262054,
-0.2807164192199707,
-0.039905697107315063,
-0.5867407321929932,
0.48925474286079407,
-0.3144529461860657,
0.337981641292572,
0.04691227152943611,
0.3550439774990082,
0.6181442737579346,
-0.5463630557060242,
0.7485445141792297,
-0.4054974913597107,
-0.3591271638870239,
0.40388184785842896,
-0.01740124449133873,
0.7181050181388855,
0.05234396830201149,
0.1965886354446411,
0.15183743834495544,
0.04694643244147301,
-0.15149709582328796,
-0.7479145526885986,
0.7263498902320862,
-0.49248984456062317,
-0.5534869432449341,
0.14749987423419952,
-0.49538299441337585,
-0.3379017114639282,
0.5325933694839478,
0.25467485189437866,
0.5184537172317505,
-0.3813711106777191,
0.2878350615501404,
0.5728670954704285,
-0.01157532911747694,
0.38413023948669434,
0.39062124490737915,
-0.32939842343330383,
-0.5440162420272827,
0.8676465749740601,
0.24446895718574524,
0.32412785291671753,
0.3486100137233734,
0.10165770351886749,
-0.3858329653739929,
-0.7745519876480103,
-0.4114023745059967,
-0.09427954256534576,
-0.8713954091072083,
-0.039318349212408066,
-0.7110963463783264,
-0.04038091376423836,
-0.6505493521690369,
0.007911097258329391,
-0.33573371171951294,
-0.2459518313407898,
-0.2968239486217499,
-0.21286335587501526,
0.34844163060188293,
0.892783522605896,
-0.11125896871089935,
0.3346571624279022,
-0.8069817423820496,
0.32411932945251465,
0.5081287622451782,
0.27579957246780396,
0.1116071566939354,
-0.18797379732131958,
-0.5284491777420044,
0.08576761186122894,
-0.20913976430892944,
-0.6662776470184326,
0.39644309878349304,
0.03758811205625534,
0.38127070665359497,
0.42409810423851013,
0.16581083834171295,
0.7204176187515259,
-0.8628577589988708,
0.7192379832267761,
0.22152701020240784,
-0.7077401280403137,
0.46672457456588745,
-0.39338091015815735,
0.31581827998161316,
0.8173531889915466,
0.47266122698783875,
-0.535804033279419,
-0.12076947093009949,
-0.18326309323310852,
-1.2611215114593506,
0.7756523489952087,
0.24343839287757874,
-0.23611398041248322,
-0.09962096065282822,
0.39614856243133545,
0.018505793064832687,
0.3484418988227844,
-0.6126611232757568,
-0.26448601484298706,
-0.3302352726459503,
-0.3011908233165741,
-0.2957840859889984,
-0.5120607614517212,
-0.5504807233810425,
-0.2009185403585434,
0.7323228716850281,
-0.3370002508163452,
-0.45320212841033936,
0.028049597516655922,
-0.32940083742141724,
0.35735785961151123,
0.03525109961628914,
0.2734663486480713,
0.659773051738739,
-0.19887492060661316,
0.3458455801010132,
0.09830611944198608,
-0.573798656463623,
-0.049151163548231125,
0.3623015284538269,
-0.21211083233356476,
-0.0633627250790596,
0.45435646176338196,
0.973051905632019,
0.22447319328784943,
-0.400550901889801,
0.3967728018760681,
0.042916830629110336,
-0.14929212629795074,
-0.18460464477539062,
-0.02624495141208172,
0.2731640636920929,
0.3078564405441284,
0.38106784224510193,
-0.14830218255519867,
0.1767377406358719,
-0.2686818838119507,
-0.04734746739268303,
0.3281944692134857,
-0.16323943436145782,
-0.1826678365468979,
0.5364894270896912,
0.14792823791503906,
0.2852010428905487,
0.5602595806121826,
-0.3347546458244324,
-0.525053083896637,
0.27235427498817444,
0.28974366188049316,
0.8363604545593262,
0.21523217856884003,
0.1940368264913559,
0.4084279537200928,
-0.09227228164672852,
-0.16848720610141754,
-0.3266216516494751,
-0.5262141227722168,
-0.7212567329406738,
-0.6375296115875244,
-0.8409727811813354,
0.17981956899166107,
0.03684471920132637,
-0.4935747981071472,
0.1546739935874939,
0.015353163704276085,
-0.18008846044540405,
0.023515518754720688,
-0.06618563830852509,
-0.44048190116882324,
-0.14118145406246185,
0.15275518596172333,
0.6542686820030212,
-0.8014513254165649,
1.0843727588653564,
0.41696488857269287,
-0.20981696248054504,
-0.8633780479431152,
0.06982090324163437,
-0.05477337911725044,
-0.32481682300567627,
0.8486629724502563,
0.019466545432806015,
0.016575390473008156,
0.13966219127178192,
-0.26886633038520813,
-1.0293163061141968,
1.5882676839828491,
0.4421173334121704,
-0.4229249954223633,
-0.05935002490878105,
0.27767232060432434,
0.40528440475463867,
-0.3775755763053894,
-0.04649067297577858,
0.7149853110313416,
0.5370219945907593,
0.5070646405220032,
-0.9383926391601562,
-0.038741908967494965,
0.0028617321513593197,
0.3445565104484558,
0.049577705562114716,
-0.2845989763736725,
0.5344047546386719,
0.14828075468540192,
-0.3670833706855774,
-0.279920756816864,
0.5253795385360718,
0.2772783041000366,
0.14830076694488525,
0.628398597240448,
0.5838474631309509,
0.7623956203460693,
-0.09214319288730621,
0.9278829097747803,
-0.5741683840751648,
0.35940149426460266,
1.304720401763916,
-0.45912492275238037,
0.4280112683773041,
0.7209654450416565,
-0.13617095351219177,
0.4620610773563385,
0.460616797208786,
0.35717907547950745,
0.9461315274238586,
-0.040927428752183914,
-0.3902142643928528,
0.02067231573164463,
-0.12216804176568985,
-0.2540853023529053,
0.3716919422149658,
0.12982280552387238,
-0.30227750539779663,
-0.2705041766166687,
0.10163035988807678,
0.08133469521999359,
-0.1435692012310028,
-0.10079298913478851,
0.9893465042114258,
-0.06817612051963806,
-1.059148907661438,
0.6550683379173279,
-0.13659031689167023,
0.457248717546463,
-0.8887549638748169,
0.02852160669863224,
-0.00013092684093862772,
-0.07208725064992905,
-0.1348458081483841,
-0.4687221050262451,
0.33037906885147095,
-0.10271615535020828,
-0.5120552778244019,
-0.5073153376579285,
0.7239131927490234,
-0.7312726974487305,
-0.24941037595272064,
0.46635398268699646,
0.4016178548336029,
-0.08198823779821396,
-0.027653176337480545,
0.00750472629442811,
-0.171372652053833,
0.2320471853017807,
-0.3446406424045563,
0.2633415162563324,
0.5862210392951965,
0.17113980650901794,
0.43166470527648926,
0.7197471261024475,
-0.016512952744960785,
0.031339842826128006,
0.28158149123191833,
1.1053522825241089,
-0.1869448721408844,
-0.4070201516151428,
-1.0270804166793823,
0.6075834035873413,
-0.3050486147403717,
0.018535925075411797,
0.7791804671287537,
0.6025799512863159,
0.9798328876495361,
-0.1405499428510666,
0.8783202171325684,
-0.4145635962486267,
0.2568201720714569,
-0.6463072896003723,
0.895871639251709,
-0.4176076054573059,
0.4161614179611206,
-0.3856969177722931,
-0.9434201717376709,
-0.01878916472196579,
0.2890399694442749,
-0.45686063170433044,
0.023352380841970444,
0.692777156829834,
0.48027050495147705,
-0.2786315679550171,
-0.08717022836208344,
0.24087926745414734,
0.31715983152389526,
0.3548409938812256,
0.21293333172798157,
0.6153008341789246,
0.011457333341240883,
0.6318719983100891,
-0.3412601053714752,
-0.38800060749053955,
-0.034713320434093475,
-1.1933000087738037,
-0.7493672370910645,
-0.8052561283111572,
-0.23838934302330017,
-0.4852544963359833,
-0.32076123356819153,
0.5559975504875183,
0.6756162643432617,
-0.5827847123146057,
-0.07384926080703735,
-0.21284128725528717,
0.21961963176727295,
-0.004695602227002382,
-0.2312132865190506,
0.4073122441768646,
-0.33535999059677124,
-0.6570329666137695,
0.5124706625938416,
0.2376326620578766,
-0.09403123706579208,
-0.3040386140346527,
0.026484590023756027,
-0.16355091333389282,
-0.41735926270484924,
0.8208102583885193,
0.019030915573239326,
-0.5727192163467407,
-0.2633450925350189,
-0.389978289604187,
0.13033434748649597,
-0.07220757752656937,
0.9042477011680603,
-0.8631812334060669,
0.6263437867164612,
0.5488288402557373,
0.43601366877555847,
0.8485044240951538,
-0.20584747195243835,
0.7351461052894592,
-1.2903176546096802,
0.1479937881231308,
-0.07719103991985321,
0.5336129665374756,
0.41128799319267273,
-0.31390348076820374,
0.47431546449661255,
0.3351229131221771,
-0.2661266326904297,
-0.7555262446403503,
0.4112522602081299,
-0.7582976222038269,
-0.4350758492946625,
1.2140235900878906,
-0.3489563763141632,
-0.15508872270584106,
-0.12404780089855194,
-0.2123962789773941,
0.6997063755989075,
0.002498284913599491,
0.7931999564170837,
0.9370863437652588,
0.1930665373802185,
0.4634290635585785,
-0.6108325123786926,
0.6324300765991211,
-0.10610194504261017,
-0.4974918067455292,
0.35579338669776917,
0.8723558783531189,
0.4965534210205078,
0.4275682270526886,
0.6187087893486023,
0.024546615779399872,
-0.34058740735054016,
-0.23198382556438446,
-0.06458430737257004,
-0.40017399191856384,
-0.2806708514690399,
-0.005517159588634968,
0.41486936807632446,
0.015686159953475,
0.1996743083000183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15585v1 | Evaluating Gender Bias in Large Language Models via Chain-of-Thought Prompting | 2024-01-28T06:50:10 | 2024-01-28T06:50:10 | Masahiro Kaneko, Danushka Bollegala, Naoaki Okazaki, Timothy Baldwin | cs.CL | cs.CL | There exist both scalable tasks, like reading comprehension and
fact-checking, where model performance improves with model size, and unscalable
tasks, like arithmetic reasoning and symbolic reasoning, where model
performance does not necessarily improve with model size. Large language models
(LLMs) equipped with Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting are able to make accurate
incremental predictions even on unscalable tasks. Unfortunately, despite their
exceptional reasoning abilities, LLMs tend to internalize and reproduce
discriminatory societal biases. Whether CoT can provide discriminatory or
egalitarian rationalizations for the implicit information in unscalable tasks
remains an open question.
In this study, we examine the impact of LLMs' step-by-step predictions on
gender bias in unscalable tasks. For this purpose, we construct a benchmark for
an unscalable task where the LLM is given a list of words comprising feminine,
masculine, and gendered occupational words, and is required to count the number
of feminine and masculine words. In our CoT prompts, we require the LLM to
explicitly indicate whether each word in the word list is a feminine or
masculine before making the final predictions. With counting and handling the
meaning of words, this benchmark has characteristics of both arithmetic
reasoning and symbolic reasoning. Experimental results in English show that
without step-by-step prediction, most LLMs make socially biased predictions,
despite the task being as simple as counting words. Interestingly, CoT
prompting reduces this unconscious social bias in LLMs and encourages fair
predictions. | [
-0.3296412229537964,
-0.6973809003829956,
0.7928952574729919,
0.34179380536079407,
-0.016583317890763283,
0.12415818870067596,
-0.27477651834487915,
-0.2827744483947754,
-0.2677139937877655,
0.353040486574173,
-0.8461169004440308,
-0.4015199542045593,
-0.707547128200531,
0.33332785964012146,
-0.5845192074775696,
0.8262489438056946,
-0.11413531750440598,
0.29668495059013367,
-0.26526784896850586,
0.13089364767074585,
-0.846145749092102,
-0.43737688660621643,
-0.40537604689598083,
-0.4948132038116455,
0.4263882040977478,
0.1740744709968567,
0.5514628291130066,
0.4604588449001312,
-0.09857795387506485,
0.29220110177993774,
-0.3778781294822693,
0.30302733182907104,
-0.3983273506164551,
0.24533677101135254,
-0.26321277022361755,
-0.5816295742988586,
-0.35521042346954346,
0.19504529237747192,
0.6361885070800781,
0.924126148223877,
0.04341914877295494,
0.49902573227882385,
0.33892595767974854,
0.8074952960014343,
-0.6606724858283997,
0.2803276479244232,
-0.7573499083518982,
0.06709155440330505,
0.12532386183738708,
-0.10885243117809296,
-0.5634585618972778,
-0.18519486486911774,
0.0824011042714119,
-0.07866491377353668,
0.23594941198825836,
0.3541580140590668,
0.09554953128099442,
0.03967677429318428,
-0.4706369638442993,
-0.33634692430496216,
-0.5150559544563293,
0.9098747968673706,
-0.3967496454715729,
0.48975419998168945,
0.5138126611709595,
-0.08175896108150482,
-0.4229726195335388,
-0.11819197982549667,
-0.43504104018211365,
-0.3771510422229767,
-0.007616743911057711,
-0.2949991226196289,
-0.34761330485343933,
-0.05302652716636658,
0.7229768633842468,
-0.16945363581180573,
-0.14261263608932495,
-0.009565931744873524,
-0.40122294425964355,
0.09151628613471985,
0.5179657936096191,
0.0038943623658269644,
0.19404743611812592,
-0.06793873012065887,
-0.2865659296512604,
0.061303701251745224,
-0.7388035655021667,
-0.03757651895284653,
0.5771873593330383,
0.5024107098579407,
-0.14725401997566223,
0.5871305465698242,
-0.15351992845535278,
0.4841628074645996,
0.4709920883178711,
0.12181636691093445,
0.09540630877017975,
-0.14744506776332855,
-0.12581273913383484,
0.4689590334892273,
0.6857157945632935,
0.17549295723438263,
0.5666276812553406,
-0.01676127314567566,
-0.3036040961742401,
0.2070378214120865,
0.3314703702926636,
-0.5499304533004761,
0.213891863822937,
0.12421593815088272,
-0.2623901963233948,
-0.27425774931907654,
-0.12167995423078537,
-0.8803767561912537,
-0.6361045241355896,
-0.3868587017059326,
0.269080251455307,
-0.059898100793361664,
-0.05276117101311684,
-0.10780104994773865,
-0.14296568930149078,
-0.08193625509738922,
0.5758376717567444,
-0.8777639269828796,
0.25914502143859863,
0.7134602665901184,
0.7374138236045837,
0.04745705798268318,
-0.1994335800409317,
-0.6287113428115845,
-0.033245544880628586,
-0.5875608325004578,
0.5373305678367615,
-0.6292644143104553,
-0.3436170816421509,
-0.09788955003023148,
0.07616054266691208,
-0.023762132972478867,
-0.24318000674247742,
0.23643392324447632,
0.0005882208934053779,
0.0205013919621706,
-0.7562729716300964,
-0.24049127101898193,
-0.049426138401031494,
0.30134591460227966,
-0.4997718036174774,
1.0448927879333496,
-0.26166829466819763,
-0.8996337056159973,
0.4997115135192871,
-0.48405808210372925,
-0.19171108305454254,
-0.31817948818206787,
-0.6682081818580627,
-0.01711227372288704,
0.21159426867961884,
0.39416995644569397,
0.2711097002029419,
-0.6379594206809998,
0.45078855752944946,
-0.3778838515281677,
-0.36228421330451965,
0.4987357556819916,
-0.7401068210601807,
0.6637014746665955,
-0.23708559572696686,
-0.8188089728355408,
0.162643700838089,
-0.3284033536911011,
-0.20061306655406952,
-0.11460012942552567,
0.08907415717840195,
-0.3942069113254547,
0.058846041560173035,
-0.4993513524532318,
0.31058332324028015,
0.042867034673690796,
-0.6546545028686523,
-0.023946745321154594,
0.0033601841423660517,
0.1685733050107956,
1.387263536453247,
-0.5099294781684875,
0.5525608658790588,
-0.2440977841615677,
0.5131098628044128,
-0.1490856558084488,
0.07515859603881836,
0.14506107568740845,
-0.6552982926368713,
-0.5156283378601074,
-0.30572476983070374,
0.2444693148136139,
0.1766338348388672,
-0.6313245296478271,
0.18518100678920746,
-0.1521483212709427,
-0.26838546991348267,
-0.32488444447517395,
0.18076257407665253,
0.6627156734466553,
0.2738983631134033,
0.10753276199102402,
-0.02167513594031334,
-0.3666752874851227,
-0.806709885597229,
-0.6205317974090576,
-0.37228289246559143,
-0.1799127608537674,
0.29866689443588257,
0.8107685446739197,
-0.08769254386425018,
0.6771517395973206,
-0.37681788206100464,
-0.11180295795202255,
-0.3010035753250122,
0.5088050365447998,
0.17065246403217316,
0.2577982246875763,
0.045549631118774414,
-0.3452274799346924,
0.04232905060052872,
-0.2005230039358139,
-0.5186740756034851,
-0.4151287376880646,
0.09020514786243439,
-0.39233699440956116,
0.2682495713233948,
0.4892383813858032,
-0.5332612991333008,
0.49877697229385376,
0.6455984711647034,
-0.6431344747543335,
0.6555017828941345,
-0.30375558137893677,
0.24723435938358307,
-0.43154653906822205,
-0.0046331617049872875,
0.025511404499411583,
-0.18744993209838867,
-0.37600839138031006,
-0.2203650027513504,
0.05178084224462509,
0.20500554144382477,
-0.4858510196208954,
0.6180936694145203,
-0.7472917437553406,
-0.4658324420452118,
-0.15950258076190948,
0.06289171427488327,
-0.2223701775074005,
0.3490314781665802,
0.05090222507715225,
0.7743666172027588,
0.2091563194990158,
-0.6262251734733582,
-0.25470322370529175,
0.05422382056713104,
-0.1858513355255127,
0.44876039028167725,
-0.5194294452667236,
0.3310760259628296,
-0.4950290322303772,
0.5449383854866028,
-1.0028953552246094,
0.1540743112564087,
-0.0345599427819252,
-0.35028621554374695,
-0.01993553526699543,
-0.04268621653318405,
-0.52947598695755,
-0.5253660082817078,
-0.44428905844688416,
0.5922814607620239,
0.38203370571136475,
-0.5847629308700562,
0.6592725515365601,
0.24861209094524384,
0.06657253950834274,
-0.6872338056564331,
-0.6279230713844299,
-0.30713310837745667,
0.057594992220401764,
-0.18533459305763245,
-0.023877492174506187,
-0.019293218851089478,
-0.47408291697502136,
-0.360166072845459,
-0.40197333693504333,
0.20455703139305115,
-0.13998688757419586,
0.5212193727493286,
0.5748997330665588,
0.37138545513153076,
0.23356321454048157,
0.2744816541671753,
0.13479895889759064,
0.5378360152244568,
-0.2787845730781555,
0.7122126221656799,
-0.24690471589565277,
-0.32569125294685364,
0.11862555891275406,
0.14584070444107056,
0.653684675693512,
0.0786234587430954,
0.7908598184585571,
0.3975728452205658,
-0.5130019783973694,
-0.3668164908885956,
-0.5294925570487976,
-0.2422575205564499,
-0.4626579284667969,
0.08846700191497803,
-0.23045895993709564,
-0.9621107578277588,
0.40085795521736145,
0.007860878482460976,
0.09322207421064377,
0.345490038394928,
0.48878276348114014,
-0.07898009568452835,
1.3767285346984863,
0.2625276446342468,
0.06597461551427841,
0.15795741975307465,
-0.0769755020737648,
0.061800889670848846,
-1.039389729499817,
-0.22631357610225677,
-0.688200831413269,
-0.41105321049690247,
-0.7775307297706604,
-0.7771556973457336,
0.31113943457603455,
-0.23547478020191193,
-0.6306549906730652,
0.06839124113321304,
-0.4042050838470459,
0.44701269268989563,
0.4194532632827759,
0.2982219457626343,
0.22129963338375092,
-0.09669173508882523,
-0.29578036069869995,
0.11882498860359192,
-0.5936937928199768,
-0.5316141247749329,
1.156602144241333,
0.3517427444458008,
0.8702377676963806,
-0.16493548452854156,
0.2755184769630432,
0.6295942068099976,
0.2728338837623596,
-0.500997006893158,
0.8022603988647461,
-0.31595584750175476,
-0.7343284487724304,
-0.3145923912525177,
-0.4275429844856262,
-0.852293848991394,
0.27153468132019043,
-0.30473777651786804,
-0.9952878952026367,
0.3486235439777374,
0.22740790247917175,
0.05583934858441353,
0.4039223790168762,
-0.1365511566400528,
0.3928167521953583,
-0.15456853806972504,
-0.47408241033554077,
-0.24021051824092865,
-0.2878626883029938,
0.5202689170837402,
-0.23146666586399078,
0.5544165968894958,
-0.27058783173561096,
-0.01592450961470604,
0.8996396064758301,
-0.3068549931049347,
1.1153253316879272,
-0.030433781445026398,
-0.3316681683063507,
0.0475526861846447,
0.25428083539009094,
0.6358150839805603,
-0.2429804503917694,
-0.10754483938217163,
0.4948514699935913,
-0.09843998402357101,
-0.1574150025844574,
-0.39296215772628784,
0.6336066722869873,
-0.5881096720695496,
-0.7566471099853516,
-0.6287428736686707,
-0.7210995554924011,
-0.30602431297302246,
0.06388126313686371,
0.14734676480293274,
0.4467855989933014,
0.0593390017747879,
0.09713923931121826,
0.7894302010536194,
-0.30737170577049255,
0.24756988883018494,
0.26759687066078186,
-0.49563539028167725,
-0.05354249104857445,
0.18130791187286377,
0.18214040994644165,
0.5273242592811584,
0.20318718254566193,
0.40225034952163696,
-0.5527290105819702,
0.06224389374256134,
-0.5133016109466553,
0.2366151362657547,
-0.6758137941360474,
0.10311660170555115,
-0.7014800906181335,
0.044959571212530136,
-0.1780281960964203,
-0.22867631912231445,
-0.37866687774658203,
-0.0757080614566803,
0.049338966608047485,
-0.26684141159057617,
0.38145768642425537,
0.9443423748016357,
0.2858906090259552,
-0.01935269497334957,
-0.3507581353187561,
0.28521615266799927,
0.41889050602912903,
0.20879004895687103,
0.3960838317871094,
-0.48208874464035034,
0.26423612236976624,
0.24599038064479828,
-0.03458896651864052,
-0.9126114249229431,
0.2558082044124603,
-0.3415960967540741,
0.36414510011672974,
0.17245201766490936,
0.20207777619361877,
0.6146815419197083,
-0.6316636204719543,
0.6318017840385437,
0.40785446763038635,
-1.1721704006195068,
0.576217532157898,
-0.3893525302410126,
0.4798426032066345,
0.3324531018733978,
0.22995918989181519,
-0.41902682185173035,
-0.7212755680084229,
-0.4151693880558014,
-0.6750854849815369,
0.661537766456604,
0.27880313992500305,
0.11582056432962418,
-0.2641060948371887,
0.06923393905162811,
0.3444834053516388,
0.5873907208442688,
-0.5992761850357056,
-0.2541773021221161,
0.3182083070278168,
0.08934611827135086,
0.10199473053216934,
-0.28717443346977234,
-0.03441913053393364,
-0.38562846183776855,
0.4548225402832031,
-0.21510452032089233,
0.5040534138679504,
0.16874253749847412,
-0.1370915323495865,
-0.3755720853805542,
0.5169680118560791,
0.4405214190483093,
0.7866136431694031,
-0.07922361046075821,
0.36978498101234436,
0.5791093707084656,
-0.4240472912788391,
0.40902525186538696,
-0.44562408328056335,
-0.2336810976266861,
0.05743144080042839,
0.2979024648666382,
0.9348379969596863,
0.298410564661026,
-0.7022362351417542,
0.367312490940094,
-0.13339582085609436,
-0.23401570320129395,
-0.24063903093338013,
-0.011808004230260849,
-0.06470523029565811,
0.2533310055732727,
0.3478401005268097,
0.010874451138079166,
0.1481083333492279,
-0.8578936457633972,
-0.15522202849388123,
0.5668200850486755,
-0.4929332137107849,
-0.05351773276925087,
0.7713875770568848,
0.12430613487958908,
-0.1564386636018753,
0.5113481283187866,
-0.0821831077337265,
-0.6276416182518005,
0.7082601189613342,
0.6035653948783875,
1.0251706838607788,
-0.13670967519283295,
0.29330974817276,
0.4029814898967743,
0.5523343682289124,
-0.39211976528167725,
0.28173571825027466,
-0.08378735929727554,
-0.5971050262451172,
-0.3474864661693573,
-0.5085660219192505,
-0.30218639969825745,
-0.0661097913980484,
-0.5618473291397095,
0.21770085394382477,
-0.5982818007469177,
-0.32551902532577515,
-0.10326430201530457,
-0.30839452147483826,
-0.8338283896446228,
0.22049380838871002,
0.4011367857456207,
0.8279659152030945,
-0.9050127267837524,
0.37950485944747925,
0.5599703192710876,
-0.005124371498823166,
-0.8612841367721558,
0.20547842979431152,
0.2753641903400421,
-0.8371038436889648,
0.8544992208480835,
0.5060214996337891,
-0.4148929715156555,
-0.4204382598400116,
-0.3372981548309326,
-0.7729803919792175,
0.972084105014801,
0.5478160977363586,
-0.9153953790664673,
-0.01976403221487999,
0.251348078250885,
0.3895471692085266,
-0.42901450395584106,
0.6644778251647949,
0.5780956745147705,
0.571007251739502,
0.07647447288036346,
-1.1378673315048218,
0.5054622888565063,
-0.04535750672221184,
0.25095832347869873,
0.2617931067943573,
-0.2512935698032379,
1.1068830490112305,
-0.299223929643631,
0.005397375673055649,
-0.31690460443496704,
0.48429757356643677,
0.6786214113235474,
0.22328011691570282,
1.0123506784439087,
-0.023481307551264763,
0.9657174944877625,
-0.12592998147010803,
1.049729347229004,
0.004324999172240496,
-0.007803587708622217,
1.089237928390503,
-0.30047470331192017,
0.6615074276924133,
0.4212052524089813,
-0.31897830963134766,
0.6079851984977722,
0.3082475960254669,
0.3892855644226074,
0.017558343708515167,
0.3476269543170929,
-0.23561301827430725,
-0.19994418323040009,
-0.33469706773757935,
-0.2536952495574951,
0.47053271532058716,
0.2272288054227829,
-0.5954103469848633,
-0.030710449442267418,
-0.2498284876346588,
0.2723117768764496,
-0.1138172522187233,
-0.7191643118858337,
0.42232805490493774,
0.18382637202739716,
-0.846226155757904,
0.43721309304237366,
-0.19267067313194275,
0.7181052565574646,
-0.4133220911026001,
-0.05010828748345375,
-0.015934500843286514,
0.09785197675228119,
-0.15340614318847656,
-0.9152151942253113,
-0.10838643461465836,
0.34090280532836914,
-0.3225312829017639,
-0.3228454887866974,
0.7363404035568237,
-0.6131753921508789,
-0.786927342414856,
0.48093944787979126,
0.5300045013427734,
0.026627663522958755,
-0.17434541881084442,
-0.5547525882720947,
0.11915379017591476,
0.10104142129421234,
-0.17962303757667542,
0.5196391344070435,
0.35516026616096497,
-0.5652809739112854,
0.916775107383728,
0.7727456092834473,
0.11235048621892929,
-0.04668180271983147,
0.2493729442358017,
0.6077824234962463,
-0.6511295437812805,
-0.5649978518486023,
-1.1036937236785889,
0.30085813999176025,
0.023330118507146835,
0.015945199877023697,
0.6942808628082275,
0.09679244458675385,
0.6341826319694519,
-0.09021986275911331,
0.6491771340370178,
0.1813036948442459,
0.1091197282075882,
-0.3427586555480957,
0.6184495687484741,
-0.33414915204048157,
0.3982946574687958,
-0.6691142916679382,
-0.9482049942016602,
0.25340157747268677,
0.4449976682662964,
-0.6125147342681885,
0.4144769012928009,
0.8612143993377686,
0.5933259129524231,
0.32898885011672974,
0.3168935477733612,
0.2234320193529129,
0.23883040249347687,
0.009859665296971798,
0.24615180492401123,
0.8284395337104797,
-0.06516512483358383,
0.18956400454044342,
-0.04058277606964111,
-0.31953907012939453,
0.20517517626285553,
-1.0535129308700562,
-1.1098837852478027,
-0.27184513211250305,
-0.28423699736595154,
-0.43393710255622864,
0.2815259099006653,
1.2380563020706177,
0.3972834348678589,
-0.5240350961685181,
-0.47557777166366577,
-0.2568197548389435,
0.35275837779045105,
-0.21864520013332367,
-0.1549149751663208,
0.15638558566570282,
-0.023430604487657547,
-0.7751660943031311,
-0.10401805490255356,
0.16193458437919617,
-0.35127896070480347,
-0.4037282168865204,
-0.05661406368017197,
-0.24182124435901642,
0.2871054708957672,
0.787427544593811,
-0.26254308223724365,
-0.8461052775382996,
-0.29824402928352356,
-0.09998630732297897,
0.19752690196037292,
-0.33069267868995667,
0.7353459000587463,
-0.7491515278816223,
0.3951267898082733,
0.4933367073535919,
0.11893781274557114,
0.16429923474788666,
-0.08084500581026077,
0.9811757206916809,
-0.6920261979103088,
-0.09472217410802841,
-0.05420584976673126,
0.5369389653205872,
0.12078120559453964,
-0.5341090559959412,
0.4083663523197174,
-0.03220396488904953,
-0.33064016699790955,
-0.9590128064155579,
0.044111866503953934,
-0.5550263524055481,
-0.3877165615558624,
1.3764784336090088,
0.021855870261788368,
-0.4561925530433655,
0.02503463253378868,
-0.37811046838760376,
0.19885608553886414,
-0.6657736897468567,
0.6710315942764282,
0.7572591304779053,
0.06628664582967758,
-0.19751180708408356,
-0.5992366075515747,
0.30526262521743774,
0.3818487823009491,
-0.6853291392326355,
0.5742864012718201,
0.4967217445373535,
0.03287157416343689,
-0.09559158235788345,
0.6224415898323059,
-0.130581796169281,
0.3414634168148041,
-0.08664049953222275,
0.024443188682198524,
0.09490504115819931,
-0.3609088957309723,
-0.1903851181268692,
-0.11967466026544571,
-0.01728096604347229,
-0.026918869465589523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15579v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15579v1 | MunTTS: A Text-to-Speech System for Mundari | 2024-01-28T06:27:17 | 2024-01-28T06:27:17 | Varun Gumma, Rishav Hada, Aditya Yadavalli, Pamir Gogoi, Ishani Mondal, Vivek Seshadri, Kalika Bali | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | We present MunTTS, an end-to-end text-to-speech (TTS) system specifically for
Mundari, a low-resource Indian language of the Austo-Asiatic family. Our work
addresses the gap in linguistic technology for underrepresented languages by
collecting and processing data to build a speech synthesis system. We begin our
study by gathering a substantial dataset of Mundari text and speech and train
end-to-end speech models. We also delve into the methods used for training our
models, ensuring they are efficient and effective despite the data constraints.
We evaluate our system with native speakers and objective metrics,
demonstrating its potential as a tool for preserving and promoting the Mundari
language in the digital age. | [
-0.3562687635421753,
-0.5163496732711792,
0.10211576521396637,
0.10613410919904709,
-0.1947546750307083,
0.6055700778961182,
-0.3513652980327606,
-0.32323408126831055,
0.365326851606369,
0.2279079407453537,
-0.5476586818695068,
0.15681813657283783,
-0.3857686519622803,
0.21345670521259308,
-0.3995566666126251,
1.1817528009414673,
0.15647847950458527,
-0.3762231767177582,
0.3656936287879944,
-0.30190515518188477,
-0.6651753187179565,
-0.5106322169303894,
-0.6478845477104187,
-0.1662958562374115,
0.2826639413833618,
0.6148541569709778,
0.5615367293357849,
0.339036762714386,
0.11712466180324554,
0.2887694537639618,
-0.25330936908721924,
0.4104692041873932,
-0.4659838378429413,
0.5464781522750854,
-0.1397671401500702,
-0.357822984457016,
-0.32844284176826477,
-0.42485710978507996,
0.47167688608169556,
0.325690895318985,
-0.3175574243068695,
0.3327785134315491,
0.0042054601944983006,
0.5619937181472778,
-0.5712562203407288,
0.05873655155301094,
-0.5050896406173706,
0.027312573045492172,
-0.6295952796936035,
-0.3813841640949249,
-0.2390567660331726,
-0.5132032036781311,
0.06890279054641724,
-0.26995208859443665,
0.08012621849775314,
-0.2586791515350342,
0.2811710834503174,
0.34465715289115906,
-0.4032067656517029,
-0.23203498125076294,
-0.9220300316810608,
0.5749483704566956,
-0.40617281198501587,
0.5509989261627197,
0.359092652797699,
0.46354353427886963,
-0.045881010591983795,
-0.6008448004722595,
-0.6825469136238098,
-0.16657492518424988,
-0.11705523729324341,
0.15310311317443848,
-0.14536067843437195,
-0.07141274213790894,
0.06145288422703743,
0.5973515510559082,
-0.8827943801879883,
-0.28611621260643005,
-0.7611443996429443,
-0.10454723238945007,
0.3280678987503052,
-0.0007122506503947079,
0.24156711995601654,
-0.4739510715007782,
-0.15836310386657715,
0.07728836685419083,
-0.5820203423500061,
-0.029284127056598663,
0.4275849461555481,
0.5348235368728638,
-0.17651152610778809,
0.7884716391563416,
-0.2752779722213745,
0.7824714183807373,
-0.11724379658699036,
-0.330001562833786,
0.054452162235975266,
-0.27341529726982117,
-0.2888084352016449,
0.2418200671672821,
0.8422988057136536,
-0.1683052033185959,
0.39596691727638245,
-0.06834816187620163,
-0.17761929333209991,
0.34667471051216125,
-0.3967750668525696,
-0.6180672645568848,
0.07680540531873703,
-0.09395954012870789,
-0.34635767340660095,
-0.25902387499809265,
-0.5690945982933044,
-0.8187589049339294,
-0.3525773584842682,
-0.3291580379009247,
0.21365150809288025,
-0.6255601644515991,
-0.7954867482185364,
-0.16447697579860687,
-0.23488493263721466,
-0.04566754773259163,
-0.16834071278572083,
-1.2393978834152222,
0.3673284351825714,
0.23385562002658844,
1.1380653381347656,
-0.05675904452800751,
-0.2696631848812103,
-0.3848835527896881,
0.33098918199539185,
-0.21930821239948273,
0.6777676939964294,
-0.5377193093299866,
-0.8358215689659119,
-0.3625425398349762,
-0.42616701126098633,
-0.006895914673805237,
-0.15844644606113434,
0.584417462348938,
-0.0902719497680664,
-0.013754046522080898,
0.17099209129810333,
-0.13822688162326813,
0.073332779109478,
0.11210467666387558,
-0.5658519268035889,
1.0714024305343628,
0.3034074008464813,
-0.6409468650817871,
-0.029993951320648193,
-0.999808669090271,
-0.641952633857727,
0.06401237845420837,
-0.38468313217163086,
-0.14221177995204926,
0.4837348461151123,
0.24047867953777313,
0.2857077419757843,
-0.5805208086967468,
0.263893723487854,
0.28127700090408325,
-0.030153745785355568,
0.32649293541908264,
-1.0690655708312988,
0.5367341041564941,
0.7407476902008057,
-0.1973983496427536,
-0.1444236934185028,
-0.8950173854827881,
0.29484865069389343,
-0.012920491397380829,
-0.5121628046035767,
-0.33492422103881836,
-0.10229577869176865,
0.5577690601348877,
0.10540642589330673,
-0.05406634882092476,
-0.9801409244537354,
0.18567007780075073,
-0.525963306427002,
0.9394795894622803,
0.48548755049705505,
-0.3034648001194,
0.06688243895769119,
-0.3518969714641571,
0.49957185983657837,
-0.29053065180778503,
0.042667120695114136,
-0.48032841086387634,
-0.6497541069984436,
-0.6402421593666077,
-0.09801965206861496,
0.29868149757385254,
0.5348852276802063,
-0.7748361825942993,
-0.18431782722473145,
-0.6117900609970093,
-0.5023424625396729,
-0.42716655135154724,
-0.22777916491031647,
0.35135501623153687,
0.2415136992931366,
0.16650894284248352,
0.04660812020301819,
-0.8606823086738586,
-0.8744770288467407,
0.041302818804979324,
-0.21238914132118225,
0.18085826933383942,
-0.35346513986587524,
0.232647106051445,
-0.06194062903523445,
1.1270052194595337,
-0.2137170135974884,
-0.38314855098724365,
-0.2954556941986084,
0.12599599361419678,
0.039796292781829834,
0.6256024241447449,
0.2591824233531952,
-0.8401743173599243,
-0.5549151301383972,
0.4779876470565796,
-0.3974618911743164,
0.18973466753959656,
0.13799235224723816,
0.18051260709762573,
0.24245649576187134,
0.6540699005126953,
-0.5694599747657776,
0.6399857401847839,
0.9234252572059631,
0.014001568779349327,
0.4329187870025635,
-0.1360580027103424,
0.4092297852039337,
-1.3907123804092407,
0.13999676704406738,
-0.4239545166492462,
-0.45319199562072754,
-0.732072651386261,
-0.4067893326282501,
-0.23175247013568878,
-0.6750405430793762,
-0.4161010980606079,
0.4778382480144501,
-0.5361971855163574,
0.02950284816324711,
-0.28068819642066956,
-0.0504775233566761,
-0.35523322224617004,
0.5514163374900818,
0.021335609257221222,
1.2409840822219849,
0.30470260977745056,
-0.481961190700531,
0.5242066979408264,
0.36999601125717163,
-0.2052067220211029,
0.9736937284469604,
-0.6253933310508728,
0.023336075246334076,
0.06405575573444366,
-0.08550643920898438,
-0.8901814222335815,
-0.259443461894989,
0.12692248821258545,
-0.8186173439025879,
0.5755631327629089,
-0.22302763164043427,
-0.3133315443992615,
-0.39082038402557373,
-0.04810691997408867,
0.653850257396698,
0.16090364754199982,
-0.36556023359298706,
0.7079414129257202,
0.8186901211738586,
-0.4693966805934906,
-0.38065779209136963,
-1.2555791139602661,
0.37580153346061707,
-0.1855660080909729,
-0.5515508055686951,
0.15665635466575623,
0.08680281043052673,
0.1697467714548111,
0.020197883248329163,
0.3310548961162567,
-0.4026035666465759,
-0.33604076504707336,
0.1525966078042984,
-0.1347624808549881,
-0.41903430223464966,
0.23308181762695312,
0.15099406242370605,
-0.25118547677993774,
-0.399714857339859,
-0.5762782096862793,
0.4973452389240265,
-0.2655085623264313,
-0.47897785902023315,
-0.36114394664764404,
0.6905592679977417,
0.7956470847129822,
-0.5643922090530396,
0.13004079461097717,
0.33971065282821655,
-0.6575733423233032,
-0.027529276907444,
-0.49094539880752563,
0.1695936918258667,
-0.4981744885444641,
0.6182854771614075,
-0.7345222234725952,
-0.7360856533050537,
0.1888532042503357,
-0.05851241573691368,
-0.06964833289384842,
0.2696478068828583,
0.6600314378738403,
0.21027900278568268,
0.8834186792373657,
0.8716029524803162,
-0.0005327032995410264,
0.5705223679542542,
-0.14872819185256958,
0.19564726948738098,
-0.8662272691726685,
-0.14504081010818481,
-0.49530649185180664,
-0.19554851949214935,
-0.8573936820030212,
-0.1693507581949234,
0.370572954416275,
-0.46361127495765686,
-0.2820049822330475,
0.40572836995124817,
-1.0355846881866455,
0.5590866208076477,
0.669366717338562,
0.08980029821395874,
0.41666221618652344,
0.1744009107351303,
0.040851376950740814,
-0.2285793423652649,
-0.6297994256019592,
-0.42736729979515076,
1.0350925922393799,
-0.007539643440395594,
1.0289127826690674,
0.4766615927219391,
0.4619237184524536,
0.46030479669570923,
0.2908269762992859,
-0.7739952802658081,
0.13288338482379913,
-0.33563634753227234,
-0.7474543452262878,
-0.45356056094169617,
-0.3615587055683136,
-0.8932628631591797,
0.18971990048885345,
0.13010337948799133,
-0.8852587938308716,
0.24729520082473755,
-0.08879038691520691,
-0.49245795607566833,
0.6631442308425903,
-1.0201486349105835,
0.6214641332626343,
-0.3780440390110016,
0.01309859100729227,
-0.15630246698856354,
-0.7447718381881714,
0.5373512506484985,
-0.058728594332933426,
0.21623913943767548,
0.002887111157178879,
0.20463694632053375,
0.9242064952850342,
-0.6192869544029236,
0.6230050325393677,
0.20640704035758972,
0.2991846203804016,
0.42995867133140564,
0.19171860814094543,
-0.011463846080005169,
-0.0894000232219696,
-0.0621098056435585,
-0.2275969535112381,
0.24811546504497528,
-0.16796627640724182,
-0.35159799456596375,
0.7283580899238586,
-0.7512041926383972,
-0.2620844841003418,
-0.7011423110961914,
-0.5694296956062317,
-0.37018442153930664,
0.19283834099769592,
0.16558203101158142,
0.8842145204544067,
-0.4061731696128845,
0.1667718142271042,
0.5658669471740723,
-0.06513682752847672,
0.663222074508667,
0.05885063856840134,
-0.24042858183383942,
-0.6511733531951904,
1.0970568656921387,
0.26525595784187317,
0.3582726716995239,
0.4640899896621704,
0.4219507873058319,
-0.6091675758361816,
-0.2805570662021637,
-1.0336692333221436,
0.2178729772567749,
-0.8002346158027649,
-0.3534751236438751,
-0.38197335600852966,
-0.44061902165412903,
-0.2952740788459778,
0.14836083352565765,
-0.5514123439788818,
-0.7946867346763611,
-0.17929981648921967,
-0.07639501243829727,
0.663400411605835,
1.2915637493133545,
-0.24962112307548523,
0.5195376873016357,
-0.7622868418693542,
0.16207626461982727,
0.33713871240615845,
0.2745247483253479,
0.014395634643733501,
-0.5149246454238892,
-0.1761448085308075,
0.12694087624549866,
-0.5515206456184387,
-0.9607241749763489,
0.34905311465263367,
0.4963759779930115,
0.32049989700317383,
-0.030866939574480057,
-0.07570566982030869,
0.7425891160964966,
-0.5319646596908569,
0.5258558392524719,
0.49702560901641846,
-1.1531128883361816,
0.7977386116981506,
-0.24871298670768738,
0.30243629217147827,
0.3207107484340668,
-0.13898073136806488,
-1.194740653038025,
-0.3307655453681946,
-0.2084996998310089,
-0.4902871549129486,
0.7816449999809265,
0.44463005661964417,
0.19513192772865295,
0.2192097008228302,
0.024442186579108238,
0.08709267526865005,
0.23971205949783325,
-0.48943769931793213,
-0.3160857856273651,
-0.4812389016151428,
-0.5298193097114563,
0.06487514823675156,
-0.15922915935516357,
0.2957133948802948,
0.08806395530700684,
0.5660911202430725,
-0.11109887063503265,
0.20679157972335815,
0.19455739855766296,
-0.10893206298351288,
-0.08406870067119598,
0.5855484008789062,
0.7605873346328735,
0.668077290058136,
0.07210086286067963,
0.056351132690906525,
0.18998289108276367,
-0.6992707848548889,
0.610877275466919,
0.24723030626773834,
-0.18597334623336792,
0.25691935420036316,
-0.16668283939361572,
0.8679315447807312,
0.12245666980743408,
-0.3372948467731476,
0.34237590432167053,
-0.2614787518978119,
0.34797292947769165,
-0.19621390104293823,
-0.43954184651374817,
0.1027812510728836,
-0.019959380850195885,
0.4942835867404938,
0.5108363628387451,
-0.08804575353860855,
-0.4828248918056488,
0.21551376581192017,
0.21462123095989227,
-0.4640395939350128,
-0.3664301037788391,
0.8465830683708191,
0.37705352902412415,
-0.5640485882759094,
0.11532852053642273,
0.061351560056209564,
-0.49321219325065613,
0.12239871174097061,
0.4233819246292114,
0.7255264520645142,
-0.6082668900489807,
0.2716136872768402,
0.20076778531074524,
0.460401326417923,
0.05387256667017937,
0.4438556134700775,
-0.10840301960706711,
-0.02033088542521,
-0.5765337347984314,
-0.5873425006866455,
-0.4967968761920929,
0.16487035155296326,
-0.26009324193000793,
0.6267611384391785,
-0.15814200043678284,
-0.4133322834968567,
-0.01722624897956848,
-0.38963583111763,
-0.5341004729270935,
0.24445755779743195,
0.31116411089897156,
0.6272192597389221,
-0.601475715637207,
0.8732244968414307,
0.3460191488265991,
-0.8113352060317993,
-0.7629140019416809,
-0.4445909559726715,
-0.06279612332582474,
-0.48414716124534607,
0.6097458004951477,
-0.15839527547359467,
-0.3976486027240753,
0.255479097366333,
-0.07539752870798111,
-1.1926356554031372,
0.5321254134178162,
0.41373783349990845,
-0.34893599152565,
-0.11968588829040527,
0.5034037232398987,
0.4848899245262146,
0.08121034502983093,
0.5832850933074951,
0.6091200709342957,
0.350627064704895,
-0.0947294607758522,
-1.359385371208191,
-0.18587183952331543,
-0.11745310574769974,
0.20804639160633087,
0.30684053897857666,
-0.48305824398994446,
0.9683871269226074,
-0.04328747093677521,
-0.440161794424057,
0.3261161148548126,
0.7532368898391724,
-0.08461037278175354,
-0.1163710430264473,
0.2308845818042755,
0.34386470913887024,
0.7691547274589539,
-0.16118262708187103,
0.9681336879730225,
0.07380060851573944,
0.23969000577926636,
1.0423611402511597,
0.03493008390069008,
0.7686971426010132,
0.4809081256389618,
-0.33412081003189087,
0.07151222229003906,
0.5503605008125305,
0.66982501745224,
0.5709056258201599,
0.371439129114151,
-0.3824446201324463,
0.26001325249671936,
-0.3779090642929077,
-0.6014687418937683,
0.5511345863342285,
0.5763950943946838,
0.2613080143928528,
-0.2917284667491913,
0.3913378417491913,
-0.08085561543703079,
-0.0050193234346807,
-0.15464763343334198,
0.5368489623069763,
0.046084143221378326,
-0.5391193628311157,
0.879973828792572,
-0.11008822172880173,
1.0613572597503662,
-0.8848543167114258,
0.18644841015338898,
-0.20957161486148834,
0.30946436524391174,
-0.24863649904727936,
-0.8760969042778015,
0.671642005443573,
0.19072562456130981,
-0.28309136629104614,
-0.10131487995386124,
0.5508133769035339,
-0.7366174459457397,
-0.5910574793815613,
-0.007034744136035442,
0.7597718834877014,
0.12589651346206665,
0.03643644601106644,
-0.38679954409599304,
0.04157264530658722,
0.04591929540038109,
-0.003111309139057994,
-0.0809413492679596,
0.5769342184066772,
-0.4506863057613373,
0.670903205871582,
0.7362973093986511,
0.4976482391357422,
0.38000524044036865,
-0.01967993751168251,
0.7255889773368835,
-0.4189411699771881,
-0.7517991065979004,
-0.8332570195198059,
0.39326775074005127,
0.13737037777900696,
-0.7085373401641846,
0.4696495532989502,
0.7066609859466553,
0.872227132320404,
-0.04442031309008598,
1.3407862186431885,
-0.3078553080558777,
0.8831444978713989,
-0.23843011260032654,
1.0705897808074951,
-0.5191773176193237,
-0.20384207367897034,
-0.08165115863084793,
-0.6660489439964294,
-0.02618643455207348,
0.39331457018852234,
0.1999773383140564,
-0.12174990028142929,
0.6262896656990051,
0.8734599351882935,
-0.3970727324485779,
0.36078330874443054,
0.6500571966171265,
-0.15535497665405273,
0.5184906721115112,
0.5222110152244568,
1.209128975868225,
-0.5581368207931519,
1.213754653930664,
-0.12624035775661469,
-0.28308331966400146,
0.13590441644191742,
-0.5333350896835327,
-0.5161070227622986,
-0.8089126348495483,
0.001999499509111047,
-0.12212805449962616,
0.1927676647901535,
1.0033313035964966,
0.7924320697784424,
-0.9720163941383362,
-0.6988239884376526,
0.12718309462070465,
0.030636940151453018,
0.13268622756004333,
-0.10845949500799179,
0.37127915024757385,
-0.06331586092710495,
-0.8628401756286621,
0.5102802515029907,
0.3720874488353729,
0.2482708990573883,
-0.4948028028011322,
-0.1799445003271103,
-0.394219309091568,
-0.1374933421611786,
0.5908432006835938,
0.6667546629905701,
-0.6501279473304749,
0.05533381551504135,
0.016679102554917336,
-0.18773983418941498,
0.183416485786438,
1.09042227268219,
-0.7498197555541992,
0.6244184374809265,
0.5362155437469482,
0.8118147253990173,
0.6825628876686096,
-0.2955019474029541,
0.5814183950424194,
-0.8982539176940918,
0.4367276132106781,
0.27485620975494385,
0.44492781162261963,
0.8297990560531616,
0.004957594908773899,
0.45268014073371887,
0.23375679552555084,
-0.42938581109046936,
-0.856232762336731,
0.26525798439979553,
-0.5263376832008362,
0.11148393899202347,
0.9440790414810181,
0.20568102598190308,
-0.26793181896209717,
-0.45479393005371094,
-0.5776457190513611,
0.5754328370094299,
-0.4750789701938629,
0.2157364785671234,
0.3563823103904724,
0.16849133372306824,
0.02597649395465851,
-0.638130247592926,
0.5486540198326111,
0.1584317982196808,
-0.6483042240142822,
0.18730075657367706,
0.2621637284755707,
0.062024883925914764,
0.4097340703010559,
0.9092820882797241,
0.06993196904659271,
0.22185561060905457,
-0.037344228476285934,
-0.060261037200689316,
-0.05186856910586357,
-0.12121636420488358,
-0.1317203938961029,
-0.2878968417644501,
-0.16790927946567535,
-0.62687748670578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15569v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15569v1 | Efficient Tuning and Inference for Large Language Models on Textual Graphs | 2024-01-28T05:12:09 | 2024-01-28T05:12:09 | Yun Zhu, Yaoke Wang, Haizhou Shi, Siliang Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Rich textual and topological information of textual graphs need to be modeled
in real-world applications such as webpages, e-commerce, and academic articles.
Practitioners have been long following the path of adopting a shallow text
encoder and a subsequent graph neural network (GNN) to solve this problem. In
light of recent advancements in large language models (LLMs), it is apparent
that integrating LLMs for enhanced textual encoding can substantially improve
the performance of textual graphs. Nevertheless, the efficiency of these
methods poses a significant challenge. In this paper, we propose ENGINE, a
parameter- and memory-efficient fine-tuning method for textual graphs with an
LLM encoder. The key insight is to combine the LLMs and GNNs through a tunable
side structure, which significantly reduces the training complexity without
impairing the joint model's capacity. Extensive experiments on textual graphs
demonstrate our method's effectiveness by achieving the best model performance,
meanwhile having the lowest training cost compared to previous methods.
Moreover, we introduce two variants with caching and dynamic early exit to
further enhance training and inference speed. Specifically, caching accelerates
ENGINE's training by 12x, and dynamic early exit achieves up to 5x faster
inference with a negligible performance drop (at maximum 1.17% relevant drop
across 7 datasets). | [
-0.29889941215515137,
-0.8420068025588989,
0.623841404914856,
-0.1592361330986023,
-0.4885830283164978,
0.09452047199010849,
-0.6708893179893494,
-0.46261370182037354,
0.14729952812194824,
0.6153882741928101,
-0.6129364967346191,
-0.6987884044647217,
-0.5249925851821899,
0.1061466634273529,
-0.44806617498397827,
0.8047530651092529,
0.04703604057431221,
-0.12926098704338074,
-0.1940413862466812,
-0.10850028693675995,
-0.18664957582950592,
-0.2611272931098938,
-1.0738625526428223,
-0.352880597114563,
0.8477485179901123,
0.05568535625934601,
0.6850693225860596,
1.0200337171554565,
0.05386222526431084,
0.39223578572273254,
-0.04899151623249054,
0.7850186228752136,
-0.9083577394485474,
0.21957537531852722,
-0.10223804414272308,
-0.357785701751709,
-0.2600477337837219,
-0.2740192413330078,
0.6453852653503418,
0.6233822703361511,
0.05991223081946373,
-0.14865034818649292,
0.14146257936954498,
0.503612220287323,
-0.5725160837173462,
0.29891467094421387,
-0.7968958616256714,
-0.1645454615354538,
-0.30453580617904663,
-0.3634019196033478,
-0.7438862323760986,
-0.19359475374221802,
-0.30141744017601013,
-0.9309977293014526,
0.11346539109945297,
0.12340737879276276,
1.038842797279358,
0.41525670886039734,
-0.47039932012557983,
-0.16355054080486298,
-0.4565800428390503,
0.7509077787399292,
-0.7267656922340393,
0.5718540549278259,
0.41090190410614014,
0.14463315904140472,
-0.26533910632133484,
-1.1782022714614868,
-0.5289041996002197,
0.2868063747882843,
-0.27297672629356384,
0.05330829322338104,
-0.014083690010011196,
0.14331521093845367,
0.09289354085922241,
0.2439962476491928,
-0.511151134967804,
0.5172990560531616,
0.11739548295736313,
-0.005763262510299683,
0.5389708876609802,
0.28390711545944214,
0.33401674032211304,
-0.08332102745771408,
0.14596861600875854,
-0.2547173798084259,
-0.5465602874755859,
-0.3841356933116913,
0.570308268070221,
0.5724478960037231,
0.0876370519399643,
0.35904911160469055,
-0.2954139709472656,
0.8114035725593567,
-0.017533907666802406,
0.210659459233284,
0.1807958036661148,
-0.21006116271018982,
-0.23671579360961914,
-0.06470990180969238,
0.8881829977035522,
0.34541478753089905,
0.495981365442276,
-0.43896594643592834,
-0.14143075048923492,
0.027306342497467995,
0.049819838255643845,
-1.1787272691726685,
-0.36626559495925903,
0.1577693074941635,
-0.21964657306671143,
-0.0690602958202362,
-0.23500579595565796,
-0.8045796155929565,
-0.39598751068115234,
-0.33972567319869995,
-0.011137114837765694,
-0.6175329685211182,
-0.01734984666109085,
0.3272511661052704,
-0.14832085371017456,
0.12492135912179947,
0.3707403540611267,
-1.0714571475982666,
0.22644156217575073,
0.7958288192749023,
0.8312839269638062,
-0.011900401674211025,
-0.19442132115364075,
-0.8722155690193176,
0.41041257977485657,
-0.22729603946208954,
0.6921970248222351,
-0.8996700644493103,
-0.18183141946792603,
-0.027292540296912193,
0.2250288873910904,
-0.3410688638687134,
-0.22244545817375183,
0.49089398980140686,
-0.9202039241790771,
0.10111584514379501,
-0.0021593505516648293,
-0.9088844656944275,
-0.20466138422489166,
0.09850906580686569,
-0.8138353824615479,
1.224349856376648,
-0.18035703897476196,
-0.8600864410400391,
0.2592213749885559,
-0.19284197688102722,
-0.7017815709114075,
0.013839135877788067,
-0.10855349898338318,
-0.5636377930641174,
0.059837792068719864,
0.6917994618415833,
0.43686866760253906,
-0.3001871109008789,
0.18117602169513702,
-0.42887353897094727,
-0.6030471324920654,
-0.16187173128128052,
-0.40885794162750244,
0.6940213441848755,
0.09413919597864151,
-0.14465196430683136,
0.05873711779713631,
-0.6984039545059204,
0.38964155316352844,
0.18705926835536957,
-0.37975940108299255,
-0.553752064704895,
0.3203461766242981,
0.09028419852256775,
-0.23717468976974487,
0.30509617924690247,
-0.2366943061351776,
0.41620898246765137,
-0.545038640499115,
0.701424777507782,
0.7694485187530518,
-0.04470254108309746,
0.2563737630844116,
0.08071170747280121,
0.21434222161769867,
-0.4581336975097656,
-0.2247253805398941,
-0.169113889336586,
-0.45771992206573486,
-0.8808276653289795,
-0.39073309302330017,
0.5680400133132935,
0.31246793270111084,
-0.9824687242507935,
0.5866020321846008,
-0.5045163035392761,
-0.40434926748275757,
-0.35886475443840027,
-0.009506539441645145,
0.3541116416454315,
0.31448113918304443,
0.3126509487628937,
-0.024908969178795815,
-0.35181155800819397,
-0.6291607022285461,
-0.668357789516449,
-0.05601881444454193,
-0.0884762704372406,
0.601813018321991,
0.35935255885124207,
-0.21320553123950958,
0.7177385687828064,
-0.5361993312835693,
0.06945198029279709,
-0.11102643609046936,
0.17518633604049683,
0.2897769808769226,
0.31435427069664,
0.4204674959182739,
-0.6241452693939209,
-0.6841236352920532,
0.362737774848938,
-0.7423620223999023,
-0.2264198511838913,
-0.0931495949625969,
-0.40659868717193604,
0.10087408125400543,
0.5938723087310791,
-0.5963366031646729,
0.2977587580680847,
0.5304101705551147,
-0.1360761523246765,
0.18506284058094025,
-0.32011842727661133,
0.11037221550941467,
-0.9218099117279053,
-0.11469980329275131,
-0.1735617071390152,
-0.5123453140258789,
-0.3651752769947052,
0.1829477697610855,
0.2277199625968933,
-0.021119019016623497,
-0.14732085168361664,
0.820513129234314,
-0.6773436069488525,
0.056859467178583145,
-0.20555488765239716,
0.45574951171875,
0.33382710814476013,
0.6303088068962097,
-0.21899935603141785,
0.8307746648788452,
0.40143704414367676,
-0.5275609493255615,
0.18740743398666382,
0.1570480465888977,
-0.3245990574359894,
0.2343219667673111,
-0.48721110820770264,
0.5228601694107056,
-0.16698315739631653,
0.3070952892303467,
-0.8172457218170166,
-0.2753896117210388,
-0.013491014949977398,
-0.12432309985160828,
0.653407096862793,
-0.34347349405288696,
-0.8266153335571289,
-0.32443371415138245,
-0.19224999845027924,
0.2687351107597351,
0.22495818138122559,
-0.7622336149215698,
0.6500326991081238,
0.21699431538581848,
0.09762701392173767,
-0.27656203508377075,
-0.7122170925140381,
0.31117743253707886,
-0.18459194898605347,
-0.7122588753700256,
0.49116358160972595,
0.08349334448575974,
0.21998180449008942,
0.15444570779800415,
0.0917402133345604,
-0.10320047289133072,
0.0009353492059744895,
-0.22123983502388,
-0.2822609841823578,
-0.2821938991546631,
0.4701835811138153,
0.3656414747238159,
-0.37961605191230774,
-0.365385502576828,
-0.6520817875862122,
0.7017048001289368,
-0.11405254900455475,
-0.2891305088996887,
-0.5337924957275391,
0.19311383366584778,
0.436643123626709,
-0.44695430994033813,
0.9737764000892639,
0.49089887738227844,
-0.36638978123664856,
-0.3373304009437561,
-0.32387351989746094,
-0.2394346445798874,
-0.5527060031890869,
0.6585865020751953,
-0.255496084690094,
-0.7545242309570312,
0.5963454842567444,
-0.1921975016593933,
-0.2664984464645386,
0.44794273376464844,
0.5107080936431885,
0.08371473848819733,
1.0857822895050049,
0.32356441020965576,
-0.11012580990791321,
0.5466189980506897,
-0.3993523120880127,
0.2772102653980255,
-0.7147033214569092,
0.04396785795688629,
-0.6361472606658936,
-0.44027599692344666,
-0.8683763146400452,
-0.47954124212265015,
0.24252645671367645,
0.08800457417964935,
-0.4302903413772583,
0.16350378096103668,
-0.5444209575653076,
0.8506830930709839,
0.2857522666454315,
0.35046154260635376,
0.5110899209976196,
0.17796242237091064,
-0.18675290048122406,
-0.11409994214773178,
-0.758539080619812,
-0.3367163836956024,
0.8710005879402161,
-0.0712491124868393,
0.8141973614692688,
-0.1271386444568634,
0.4976736307144165,
-0.06327153742313385,
0.09279999881982803,
-0.6373842358589172,
0.5793431401252747,
-0.689378023147583,
-0.32165592908859253,
-0.5159609317779541,
-0.5832397937774658,
-0.9824773073196411,
0.34974023699760437,
-0.013099215924739838,
-0.81032395362854,
-0.02421196922659874,
0.12017294764518738,
0.12489048391580582,
0.5401079654693604,
-0.7190905809402466,
1.0002244710922241,
-0.3131243884563446,
-0.7549867630004883,
-0.2420469969511032,
-0.3731757402420044,
-0.04540632292628288,
-0.014338607899844646,
0.03309316188097,
-0.08260390907526016,
-0.17866533994674683,
0.4831852316856384,
-0.6091782450675964,
0.8745267987251282,
-0.16750603914260864,
0.11687236279249191,
0.18430845439434052,
-0.07080372422933578,
1.1671603918075562,
0.10102085769176483,
-0.5114550590515137,
0.09573794901371002,
-0.4798048734664917,
-0.3359333574771881,
-0.8082154393196106,
0.8715454936027527,
-0.7633140087127686,
-0.2836395800113678,
-0.02469882182776928,
-0.4789513349533081,
-0.23308004438877106,
0.6145188212394714,
0.3410256803035736,
0.6478254795074463,
0.013573065400123596,
0.48506662249565125,
0.5635020136833191,
-0.3528774678707123,
0.48359695076942444,
0.19194309413433075,
-0.21059389412403107,
-0.3362075984477997,
0.7621555328369141,
0.11011476069688797,
0.15551218390464783,
0.5228652954101562,
0.20516999065876007,
-0.3597579002380371,
-0.7028830051422119,
-0.7145786881446838,
0.3326960802078247,
-0.7078203558921814,
-0.24184377491474152,
-0.8701159358024597,
-0.21061213314533234,
0.015454648062586784,
-0.20158757269382477,
-0.5653775930404663,
-0.24189601838588715,
-0.5254474878311157,
0.024592647328972816,
0.7940109372138977,
0.5053428411483765,
0.5800313353538513,
0.48457634449005127,
-0.45226776599884033,
0.021480219438672066,
0.20905065536499023,
0.5821934342384338,
0.27240699529647827,
-0.26914942264556885,
-0.5619352459907532,
0.001776170451194048,
-0.04226986691355705,
-0.6633955836296082,
0.3817293345928192,
0.5024664402008057,
0.34253618121147156,
0.21778877079486847,
0.06710241734981537,
0.9471413493156433,
-0.6361537575721741,
0.4511081278324127,
-0.1882151961326599,
-0.7761105895042419,
0.16548095643520355,
-0.6870448589324951,
0.31407761573791504,
0.6439873576164246,
0.23623892664909363,
-0.38200896978378296,
-0.4626199007034302,
-0.1483134627342224,
-1.0872583389282227,
0.46919578313827515,
0.3163732588291168,
0.1317804455757141,
-0.13972653448581696,
0.5442080497741699,
-0.04857633635401726,
0.16205936670303345,
-0.5095035433769226,
0.0077619124203920364,
-0.10938948392868042,
-0.39965909719467163,
-0.1452816277742386,
0.12646716833114624,
0.20587952435016632,
-0.39441072940826416,
0.7142550349235535,
-0.5524436235427856,
0.04338394105434418,
-0.13228853046894073,
-0.19916902482509613,
0.0601341649889946,
-0.023851685225963593,
0.06325357407331467,
0.5181925296783447,
0.07405277341604233,
0.22424064576625824,
0.3188348412513733,
-0.2863563597202301,
-0.14969801902770996,
0.10870757699012756,
-0.1451244354248047,
-0.2174440175294876,
0.4266310930252075,
1.0118286609649658,
0.4941956698894501,
-0.39334067702293396,
0.22534745931625366,
-0.21592770516872406,
0.17800156772136688,
0.19784271717071533,
0.16455045342445374,
0.5256549715995789,
0.16169953346252441,
0.06513205915689468,
-0.42107900977134705,
0.038486991077661514,
-0.2167619913816452,
0.09677887707948685,
0.4015977084636688,
-0.1766147017478943,
-0.05913843214511871,
0.8435795307159424,
0.1501707136631012,
-0.284045547246933,
0.9183251857757568,
-0.2127642035484314,
-0.33488133549690247,
0.5966802835464478,
0.6125443577766418,
1.009021520614624,
0.20563381910324097,
-0.03995024412870407,
0.317844420671463,
0.22054904699325562,
0.15488101541996002,
0.047502197325229645,
0.17300628125667572,
-0.5866286754608154,
-0.682826042175293,
-0.807086169719696,
-0.22558270394802094,
-0.013675590045750141,
-0.4883226156234741,
0.3205496370792389,
-0.19177615642547607,
-0.08930100500583649,
0.03457365930080414,
0.15193615853786469,
-0.6301884651184082,
0.152179554104805,
-0.25187453627586365,
0.7936776280403137,
-0.5220224857330322,
0.9384231567382812,
0.35058891773223877,
-0.01786012202501297,
-0.6771501302719116,
-0.0711299479007721,
-0.25676456093788147,
-0.8042849898338318,
0.20515979826450348,
0.3361622095108032,
-0.3288804888725281,
0.3476278781890869,
-0.4755939841270447,
-0.6787453293800354,
0.9735168814659119,
0.6406142711639404,
-0.883177638053894,
0.025659676641225815,
-0.11213086545467377,
0.7415334582328796,
-0.3537641763687134,
0.4147355556488037,
0.4405522048473358,
0.7466930747032166,
-0.024266637861728668,
-0.46659326553344727,
0.10752817988395691,
-0.35588955879211426,
0.2201615571975708,
0.5356422662734985,
-0.7938172817230225,
0.81414794921875,
0.16420599818229675,
-0.38112571835517883,
0.20306730270385742,
0.5703660845756531,
-0.0030952899251133204,
0.25680112838745117,
0.43627074360847473,
0.6804085373878479,
1.2778582572937012,
-0.20482400059700012,
1.3743828535079956,
-0.5992234349250793,
0.512255847454071,
1.1719260215759277,
-0.22229927778244019,
0.7446390986442566,
0.1922869086265564,
0.0191032811999321,
0.6582362651824951,
0.9269691109657288,
0.1255950927734375,
0.4965686798095703,
0.18297582864761353,
-0.018833598122000694,
-0.48567432165145874,
0.04476134106516838,
-0.4761136472225189,
0.4438612759113312,
0.33047550916671753,
-0.32791438698768616,
-0.1944858431816101,
-0.3915952742099762,
0.1846369057893753,
0.06083158031105995,
-0.17925810813903809,
0.627322256565094,
-0.0332648940384388,
-0.5056731104850769,
0.6930230855941772,
0.1974574327468872,
0.2880619764328003,
-0.6167891025543213,
0.20410260558128357,
-0.24930423498153687,
0.19232456386089325,
-0.2006472647190094,
-0.5226461887359619,
0.07135076075792313,
-0.06243951618671417,
-0.22761985659599304,
-0.2308676838874817,
0.7458533048629761,
-0.46226373314857483,
-0.5930770635604858,
0.5959317684173584,
0.22179126739501953,
0.05574096739292145,
-0.08702351152896881,
-0.35139384865760803,
0.22983728349208832,
-0.2034035176038742,
-0.48005497455596924,
0.2265537530183792,
0.7937955856323242,
-0.045516327023506165,
0.3993711471557617,
0.698133647441864,
-0.045088909566402435,
0.13508397340774536,
0.26379984617233276,
1.1358517408370972,
-0.6219784021377563,
-0.7839373350143433,
-1.023404598236084,
0.4094257354736328,
-0.3617362976074219,
-0.1984369456768036,
0.754676342010498,
0.7695513367652893,
0.6233524680137634,
0.2636842727661133,
0.5944222211837769,
0.3442765474319458,
0.01860501989722252,
-0.9658873081207275,
0.9617684483528137,
-0.7866628766059875,
0.2479127049446106,
-0.2050039917230606,
-0.9165121912956238,
-0.39712339639663696,
0.4595189690589905,
-0.35625362396240234,
0.3204360902309418,
0.748450517654419,
0.8192904591560364,
-0.27505722641944885,
0.26453059911727905,
0.00313446088694036,
0.4067528545856476,
0.45229631662368774,
0.5758491158485413,
0.3949032723903656,
-0.3613826334476471,
0.4632914364337921,
0.11792758107185364,
-0.13026899099349976,
-0.2429913431406021,
-1.171165943145752,
-0.9893262386322021,
-0.26227867603302,
-0.11288220435380936,
-0.29351285099983215,
0.34658050537109375,
0.3325521945953369,
0.8114287853240967,
-0.5147199630737305,
-0.007383143063634634,
-0.27082353830337524,
0.22525423765182495,
-0.023878315463662148,
-0.19992539286613464,
0.5782777070999146,
-0.3826812207698822,
-0.9455329179763794,
0.4434160888195038,
0.4019339382648468,
-0.3137846291065216,
-0.14915914833545685,
-0.19705641269683838,
-0.3048441410064697,
0.11581356078386307,
0.4723513424396515,
0.08380353450775146,
-0.36622917652130127,
-0.5579451322555542,
-0.06362521648406982,
-0.0991545170545578,
0.1253400593996048,
0.7566750049591064,
-0.6859291791915894,
0.6661461591720581,
0.5808086395263672,
0.9209439158439636,
1.2806267738342285,
-0.3106522262096405,
0.5074031352996826,
-0.8911497592926025,
0.2734109163284302,
0.011997995898127556,
0.3793506920337677,
0.4412197470664978,
-0.41263091564178467,
0.597240686416626,
0.18964964151382446,
-0.5077841877937317,
-0.8068203330039978,
0.1930011808872223,
-0.6084091663360596,
-0.34326526522636414,
0.8439784049987793,
0.026514900848269463,
-0.42367833852767944,
0.16085433959960938,
0.07428666949272156,
0.4419909119606018,
-0.3061707317829132,
0.47025027871131897,
0.5879870653152466,
0.012034881860017776,
0.01834023743867874,
-0.5394139885902405,
0.22123900055885315,
0.17098456621170044,
-0.8579976558685303,
0.21444714069366455,
0.38852429389953613,
-0.03827550634741783,
-0.2301032841205597,
0.5065687894821167,
0.235152006149292,
-0.11319049447774887,
0.14017468690872192,
-0.20952683687210083,
-0.29606449604034424,
-0.4571949243545532,
-0.015510995872318745,
0.07071071118116379,
-0.24394088983535767,
0.08362860977649689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15560v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15560v1 | An Analysis of Letter Dynamics in the English Alphabet | 2024-01-28T03:54:41 | 2024-01-28T03:54:41 | Neil Zhao, Diana Zheng | cs.IT | cs.IT, cs.CL, math.IT, 94A15 | The frequency with which the letters of the English alphabet appear in
writings has been applied to the field of cryptography, the development of
keyboard mechanics, and the study of linguistics. We expanded on the
statistical analysis of the English alphabet by examining the average frequency
which each letter appears in different categories of writings. We evaluated
news articles, novels, plays, scientific publications and calculated the
frequency of each letter of the alphabet, the information density of each
letter, and the overall letter distribution. Furthermore, we developed a metric
known as distance, d that can be used to algorithmically recognize different
categories of writings. The results of our study can be applied to information
transmission, large data curation, and linguistics. | [
-0.1516687572002411,
-0.7132686376571655,
0.6387110352516174,
0.194298654794693,
-0.11656412482261658,
0.06515905261039734,
-0.21888554096221924,
-0.653881311416626,
0.6461692452430725,
-0.05158666893839836,
-0.5825372338294983,
-0.5824981331825256,
-0.8428987860679626,
0.2996431589126587,
-0.5935696959495544,
0.2181641012430191,
0.1168961450457573,
-0.006387112196534872,
-0.07117564976215363,
-0.15254837274551392,
-0.06535739451646805,
-0.5471042394638062,
-0.32340916991233826,
0.11955562978982925,
0.6027036905288696,
0.04961319640278816,
0.8102086782455444,
0.7742010951042175,
1.3347184658050537,
0.4454059600830078,
0.08925622701644897,
-0.04187745600938797,
-0.2750771939754486,
0.3005377948284149,
0.39291760325431824,
-0.6837138533592224,
0.03100479766726494,
0.04040642827749252,
0.8880977034568787,
1.1179569959640503,
-0.010346964932978153,
-0.07390187680721283,
-0.2377975434064865,
1.0438321828842163,
-0.11468008160591125,
0.32639092206954956,
-0.11932428926229477,
0.16193875670433044,
-0.8144925832748413,
-0.7573286294937134,
-0.21055424213409424,
-0.8983759880065918,
0.13568365573883057,
-0.900245726108551,
0.019332580268383026,
0.5710834860801697,
0.47991544008255005,
-0.37497350573539734,
-0.20410653948783875,
-1.132320761680603,
-0.7299202680587769,
0.8041426539421082,
0.004861632827669382,
0.8831334114074707,
0.20836342871189117,
-0.039648231118917465,
-0.4668771028518677,
-0.4288523197174072,
-0.3193380534648895,
-0.4254016578197479,
0.0916111022233963,
-0.007068960927426815,
-0.1987268030643463,
0.04945174232125282,
0.2053501009941101,
0.49186399579048157,
-0.7515332102775574,
-0.22136226296424866,
-0.6496995091438293,
-0.04018373042345047,
0.6313305497169495,
0.20544572174549103,
0.9194046854972839,
0.6634558439254761,
0.4660634398460388,
-0.2706128656864166,
-0.5320087671279907,
0.42584505677223206,
0.9317907094955444,
0.09212076663970947,
-0.003921499475836754,
0.46026188135147095,
0.09925301373004913,
0.47893109917640686,
-0.17791366577148438,
-0.4492420554161072,
0.37142184376716614,
-0.22335787117481232,
0.2994382679462433,
-0.014501958154141903,
0.7904619574546814,
0.4743386209011078,
0.28351739048957825,
-0.329546719789505,
-0.005967601202428341,
0.014256070367991924,
0.2936982810497284,
-0.5642136335372925,
-0.06536658108234406,
-0.1438373476266861,
-0.8021919131278992,
-0.41344019770622253,
0.09096100926399231,
-0.8304370045661926,
-0.46849575638771057,
-0.046238236129283905,
0.03630088269710541,
-0.3977062404155731,
-0.29742830991744995,
0.19543491303920746,
-0.46823757886886597,
-0.30306077003479004,
-0.17387789487838745,
-1.247887134552002,
0.5794115662574768,
0.6892185211181641,
0.7407565116882324,
-0.23742130398750305,
-0.5402359366416931,
0.2819094657897949,
-0.026969145983457565,
-0.5102615356445312,
0.7951840758323669,
-0.8600260615348816,
-0.49270033836364746,
0.2412157654762268,
0.1777261346578598,
-0.014052635990083218,
-0.17308193445205688,
0.07536229491233826,
-0.7466689944267273,
0.10439805686473846,
-0.3366106450557709,
-0.708183765411377,
-0.2858095169067383,
-0.1548815369606018,
-0.9659583568572998,
0.7705506682395935,
0.10705043375492096,
-0.616056501865387,
0.6099768280982971,
-0.5949926376342773,
-0.7830544710159302,
0.1374121606349945,
-0.10011811554431915,
-0.12985676527023315,
0.5034847259521484,
-0.5108762383460999,
0.01575513929128647,
-0.2308754324913025,
-0.17336292564868927,
-0.20198988914489746,
-0.6499069333076477,
0.5332677960395813,
-0.33665597438812256,
0.6895206570625305,
0.28120437264442444,
0.05100178346037865,
-0.506673276424408,
-1.0520991086959839,
-0.264514684677124,
-0.38999664783477783,
-0.40398696064949036,
-0.5916765928268433,
0.5039539337158203,
-0.1561485379934311,
-0.3325638175010681,
0.22638383507728577,
-0.5462234020233154,
0.35142046213150024,
-0.6717185378074646,
0.2621697187423706,
0.34563595056533813,
0.39538538455963135,
0.58746737241745,
-0.4555659890174866,
0.6401590704917908,
-0.08245737105607986,
0.10545016825199127,
0.04454101622104645,
-0.7577731609344482,
-0.17634600400924683,
-0.14065693318843842,
0.3189871609210968,
0.49849432706832886,
-0.12149754166603088,
0.22495613992214203,
-0.3094925284385681,
-0.33013078570365906,
-0.6606993079185486,
-0.030351506546139717,
-0.08038952946662903,
-0.03449241816997528,
0.05805995315313339,
-0.4616601765155792,
-0.5153177976608276,
-0.4522392451763153,
-0.5432657599449158,
-0.5600040555000305,
0.049734193831682205,
-0.2318219542503357,
0.1723010092973709,
0.14491382241249084,
0.49094972014427185,
-0.3289896547794342,
0.27715691924095154,
0.24628721177577972,
0.6401355862617493,
0.14610102772712708,
0.18505939841270447,
0.624466598033905,
-0.3598936200141907,
-0.33134976029396057,
-0.03742202743887901,
-0.6165302395820618,
-0.27185431122779846,
-0.05643511936068535,
-0.25168365240097046,
0.023295411840081215,
0.8385645151138306,
-0.24648571014404297,
0.40011852979660034,
0.24639670550823212,
-0.4373985826969147,
0.3124161958694458,
-0.12070923298597336,
0.6306051015853882,
-0.630523681640625,
0.08089544624090195,
0.07663826644420624,
0.0928570032119751,
-0.6533049941062927,
-0.044437475502491,
-0.025905532762408257,
0.015631908550858498,
-0.15215066075325012,
0.3312564492225647,
-0.8383306860923767,
-0.13565494120121002,
-0.07778318971395493,
0.1981298327445984,
-0.42448142170906067,
0.1680680364370346,
0.019125601276755333,
0.582629382610321,
0.5551642775535583,
-0.6633869409561157,
0.45263445377349854,
-0.2397109568119049,
-0.7217994332313538,
0.4820879399776459,
-0.0719505175948143,
-0.3147154152393341,
-0.2698521018028259,
-0.5401950478553772,
-1.2234106063842773,
0.12400331348180771,
0.03206019848585129,
-0.4857248067855835,
0.17602135241031647,
0.3964368999004364,
-0.4077983498573303,
-0.5874482989311218,
-0.5277016758918762,
0.4867725074291229,
0.720313549041748,
0.11028998345136642,
0.044069696217775345,
0.696250319480896,
-0.1979309469461441,
-0.49510303139686584,
-0.5108829140663147,
-0.18615229427814484,
-0.17606042325496674,
-0.6320026516914368,
-0.05892563983798027,
-0.42571333050727844,
-0.8752454519271851,
0.04858202487230301,
-0.22127027809619904,
-0.13333125412464142,
0.39082977175712585,
0.2990732192993164,
-0.175663560628891,
-0.19107738137245178,
0.1793702393770218,
-0.04693335294723511,
0.37223875522613525,
0.4310254752635956,
-0.08490560948848724,
0.37668856978416443,
0.3608212172985077,
-0.2505277991294861,
-0.5038630366325378,
0.2896193265914917,
0.7365385890007019,
0.13685910403728485,
0.7329257726669312,
0.0037775987293571234,
-0.313338041305542,
-0.18803898990154266,
-0.2675279378890991,
-0.11388644576072693,
-0.5296761989593506,
0.31750062108039856,
-0.44502511620521545,
-0.6380099058151245,
0.5915882587432861,
0.3751283586025238,
0.008632179349660873,
0.443690687417984,
0.5066307783126831,
-0.3645886480808258,
0.8422654867172241,
0.8103538751602173,
-0.2549828290939331,
0.6441613435745239,
0.22537605464458466,
0.3386690318584442,
-0.1849735826253891,
-0.3240291476249695,
-0.6818102598190308,
-0.5109331011772156,
-0.6788111329078674,
-0.06128135696053505,
0.2702886462211609,
-0.09806273132562637,
0.044186461716890335,
0.21028932929039001,
-0.33715319633483887,
0.6149082779884338,
0.5022521615028381,
-0.2713986337184906,
0.23130114376544952,
0.3095187544822693,
-0.1759384423494339,
-0.08267897367477417,
-0.24773649871349335,
-0.21302758157253265,
1.1806317567825317,
0.4708511531352997,
0.6654960513114929,
0.314534455537796,
0.572662889957428,
0.5149607062339783,
0.3158012926578522,
-0.8242995142936707,
0.47631728649139404,
-0.27349910140037537,
-0.16447262465953827,
-0.583270788192749,
-0.2974042594432831,
-1.3063901662826538,
-0.22352415323257446,
-0.044527582824230194,
-0.6101531982421875,
0.189237579703331,
-0.377218633890152,
-0.15563152730464935,
0.033683985471725464,
-0.13667160272598267,
0.28088903427124023,
0.1133069396018982,
0.34955787658691406,
-0.27243107557296753,
-0.3618756830692291,
0.26905757188796997,
-0.0583728589117527,
0.659512996673584,
-0.10704325884580612,
-0.05553183704614639,
1.2252877950668335,
-0.430574893951416,
0.3551407754421234,
0.2139623761177063,
-0.3415907621383667,
0.48782435059547424,
0.46534061431884766,
0.17570462822914124,
-0.23483233153820038,
-0.2917746901512146,
0.06517989933490753,
0.22538234293460846,
0.09247233718633652,
-0.500424325466156,
0.5893305540084839,
-0.7124477028846741,
-0.2791745066642761,
-0.6174143552780151,
-0.8755542635917664,
-0.023764749988913536,
0.10572145879268646,
0.180265411734581,
0.6735976338386536,
-0.27426454424858093,
0.36759811639785767,
0.44849956035614014,
0.056937020272016525,
0.8871960043907166,
0.8751921057701111,
0.06605513393878937,
-0.22656194865703583,
0.9299123287200928,
0.7146798372268677,
-0.14194762706756592,
0.7634395956993103,
0.14419102668762207,
-0.43523842096328735,
-0.7662325501441956,
0.07586777210235596,
0.18162088096141815,
-0.5271133780479431,
0.20005866885185242,
-0.3868609368801117,
-0.0003225487598683685,
-0.4411909580230713,
-0.2814098000526428,
0.2200697809457779,
-0.45710936188697815,
-0.09976212680339813,
-0.024530300870537758,
0.5150838494300842,
0.9136782288551331,
0.06756523251533508,
0.4798363149166107,
-0.6979538798332214,
0.15260419249534607,
0.07905764132738113,
0.5188901424407959,
-0.027500374242663383,
-0.40551161766052246,
-0.4258076846599579,
-0.19157008826732635,
-0.25267913937568665,
-1.3531619310379028,
0.2688106894493103,
0.3101285398006439,
0.6929196715354919,
0.38278821110725403,
-0.3249627649784088,
0.3630446493625641,
-0.6391765475273132,
0.8573552966117859,
0.21624188125133514,
-0.7681163549423218,
0.09250044822692871,
-0.45020270347595215,
0.10160914063453674,
0.5894159078598022,
0.5818960666656494,
-1.0854321718215942,
-0.9683461785316467,
-0.46815431118011475,
-0.5897208452224731,
0.43507131934165955,
0.22487984597682953,
-0.19511695206165314,
-0.3959313929080963,
0.36095646023750305,
-0.006157592870295048,
0.3198838233947754,
-0.5687360763549805,
-0.5858342051506042,
0.3834550976753235,
-0.9085456728935242,
0.07550274580717087,
-0.1548202782869339,
0.015048413537442684,
-0.23269890248775482,
0.44239625334739685,
0.33910220861434937,
0.4696311056613922,
-0.06915169954299927,
-0.5444521903991699,
-0.4421687424182892,
-0.046289436519145966,
0.8915038704872131,
1.003553867340088,
-0.09711798280477524,
0.27636444568634033,
-0.28731560707092285,
-1.3814131021499634,
0.33004820346832275,
-0.1540234237909317,
-0.08752357214689255,
0.1907297521829605,
0.6929994821548462,
0.26846906542778015,
0.18924586474895477,
-0.3964438736438751,
0.471194326877594,
0.14074096083641052,
-0.4014121890068054,
-0.16849182546138763,
0.014434076845645905,
0.030739642679691315,
0.047674987465143204,
0.18935692310333252,
-0.2503732740879059,
0.30333882570266724,
-0.9370896220207214,
0.4734964966773987,
0.472425639629364,
-0.2743417024612427,
-0.5530605912208557,
0.5397744178771973,
0.36916545033454895,
-0.5510743260383606,
0.5669431090354919,
-0.41068264842033386,
-0.3006278872489929,
1.1252448558807373,
0.5042378902435303,
0.7271888852119446,
-0.3478441834449768,
0.10552021116018295,
0.2712087035179138,
0.8198947310447693,
-0.40137752890586853,
0.8526732325553894,
0.33575117588043213,
-0.461498886346817,
0.14048968255519867,
-0.847888171672821,
-0.15922284126281738,
0.024232836440205574,
-0.257568359375,
0.2953961491584778,
-0.4582683742046356,
-0.03433186560869217,
0.31417492032051086,
0.23124469816684723,
-0.468131422996521,
0.055957693606615067,
0.1802343726158142,
0.6986282467842102,
-0.8633233904838562,
0.5248913764953613,
0.4027291536331177,
-0.19275765120983124,
-0.5637784004211426,
-0.10193122178316116,
0.10661967843770981,
-1.0187069177627563,
0.8782753944396973,
0.08537692576646805,
-0.25945788621902466,
-0.14207205176353455,
-0.1925923377275467,
-1.198257327079773,
0.9729333519935608,
-0.26925525069236755,
-1.0012954473495483,
0.4532187879085541,
0.4886191785335541,
0.9804091453552246,
-0.38081371784210205,
0.6061187982559204,
0.4715651571750641,
0.6130542159080505,
-0.4856841266155243,
-0.5150108337402344,
-0.2908485233783722,
-0.49637988209724426,
0.002108704997226596,
0.819858193397522,
-0.5778520703315735,
0.765192985534668,
0.34584829211235046,
-0.3573284447193146,
0.06755426526069641,
0.7431746125221252,
-0.11419913917779922,
0.13754618167877197,
0.2620150148868561,
0.3353465795516968,
1.2127883434295654,
-0.1898893415927887,
0.682823657989502,
-1.1903588771820068,
0.21271085739135742,
0.05127918720245361,
-0.16337114572525024,
0.5336431264877319,
0.2797764241695404,
-0.5499933958053589,
0.5481630563735962,
0.6150474548339844,
-0.32124847173690796,
0.4622918367385864,
0.8701825737953186,
-0.4262422025203705,
0.5845419764518738,
0.2713955044746399,
-0.4482991397380829,
0.04730113595724106,
0.3915216624736786,
-0.39731839299201965,
0.24522985517978668,
0.17790749669075012,
0.0032105452846735716,
-0.000468923564767465,
-0.5720508098602295,
0.5059865713119507,
-0.18105074763298035,
-0.5281835794448853,
0.3174577057361603,
0.05902022495865822,
0.4485940933227539,
-0.7048813700675964,
0.0894952341914177,
-0.25042209029197693,
-0.18151122331619263,
0.01673714816570282,
-0.9491386413574219,
0.34826236963272095,
-0.24451319873332977,
-0.24048927426338196,
-0.21025288105010986,
0.493773490190506,
-0.768081545829773,
-0.7017145752906799,
0.03338737413287163,
0.10124360769987106,
0.5805561542510986,
0.3383864164352417,
-0.26853159070014954,
0.22259847819805145,
-0.40411069989204407,
-0.5996351838111877,
0.063559390604496,
0.7849431037902832,
-0.05391368642449379,
0.6052546501159668,
0.23774799704551697,
0.29593732953071594,
0.3328692317008972,
0.07973337173461914,
0.18639527261257172,
-0.8475658893585205,
-0.6433970332145691,
-1.0056700706481934,
-0.1277807056903839,
0.06318901479244232,
-0.3966941237449646,
0.9883154034614563,
0.7498283386230469,
0.2862189710140228,
-0.14138337969779968,
0.6905853152275085,
-0.04933985322713852,
0.45292234420776367,
-0.48780515789985657,
0.9878321886062622,
-0.5328642725944519,
0.20385994017124176,
-0.3065149486064911,
-1.0944957733154297,
-0.46930402517318726,
0.5243918299674988,
-0.04683065414428711,
-0.24064691364765167,
1.4742738008499146,
0.8808913826942444,
0.16498993337154388,
0.22248800098896027,
0.24342665076255798,
0.2255704253911972,
-0.11837552487850189,
0.36797094345092773,
0.6271330714225769,
-0.35929515957832336,
0.280468225479126,
-0.151078000664711,
-0.19330114126205444,
-0.04412515088915825,
-0.6968531608581543,
-0.775964617729187,
-0.7083005309104919,
-0.19692647457122803,
-0.24682460725307465,
0.360108882188797,
0.7859761118888855,
0.16808371245861053,
-0.5844802260398865,
-0.7552453279495239,
-0.12379743903875351,
0.12611070275306702,
-0.3901892900466919,
-0.15774376690387726,
0.3816365897655487,
-0.38535675406455994,
-0.5788279175758362,
0.4527808129787445,
0.27862128615379333,
0.045478157699108124,
-0.17541444301605225,
0.23820830881595612,
-0.01992822252213955,
0.5822831988334656,
0.39876943826675415,
0.4867260158061981,
-0.11239535361528397,
-0.35964152216911316,
0.12479443848133087,
-0.3456347584724426,
0.17764924466609955,
1.0207552909851074,
-0.20500802993774414,
0.2897863984107971,
0.9329771399497986,
0.27531856298446655,
-0.14104589819908142,
-0.21203067898750305,
0.5821658372879028,
-0.7588614225387573,
0.2536935806274414,
-0.10993723571300507,
0.05673353001475334,
-0.35104069113731384,
-0.6199397444725037,
0.3526250720024109,
0.7319526672363281,
-0.49627381563186646,
-0.7967538833618164,
0.21443133056163788,
-0.7228463888168335,
-0.3266243040561676,
1.0458215475082397,
0.26418131589889526,
-0.6040223240852356,
-0.18361926078796387,
0.23684115707874298,
0.0350273959338665,
-0.48089540004730225,
0.9016537666320801,
1.555080533027649,
-0.06185809522867203,
-0.20718006789684296,
-0.5547419190406799,
0.956906259059906,
0.130660742521286,
-0.8303138613700867,
-0.21354806423187256,
0.39720696210861206,
0.25213780999183655,
0.3578577935695648,
0.821295440196991,
-0.24551917612552643,
0.07700934261083603,
0.2438264787197113,
0.09173830598592758,
0.33310458064079285,
-0.6855921745300293,
-0.42936548590660095,
0.4868447482585907,
0.034224774688482285,
0.010148432105779648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15555v1 | Augment before You Try: Knowledge-Enhanced Table Question Answering via Table Expansion | 2024-01-28T03:37:11 | 2024-01-28T03:37:11 | Yujian Liu, Jiabao Ji, Tong Yu, Ryan Rossi, Sungchul Kim, Handong Zhao, Ritwik Sinha, Yang Zhang, Shiyu Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Table question answering is a popular task that assesses a model's ability to
understand and interact with structured data. However, the given table often
does not contain sufficient information for answering the question,
necessitating the integration of external knowledge. Existing methods either
convert both the table and external knowledge into text, which neglects the
structured nature of the table; or they embed queries for external sources in
the interaction with the table, which complicates the process. In this paper,
we propose a simple yet effective method to integrate external information in a
given table. Our method first constructs an augmenting table containing the
missing information and then generates a SQL query over the two tables to
answer the question. Experiments show that our method outperforms strong
baselines on three table QA benchmarks. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/UCSB-NLP-Chang/Augment_tableQA. | [
-0.4169190526008606,
-0.8613190054893494,
0.7198503017425537,
-0.07845239341259003,
-0.2566632032394409,
0.07684189826250076,
0.11277775466442108,
-0.6007255911827087,
0.34114816784858704,
0.438930481672287,
-0.7427783012390137,
-0.2357190102338791,
-0.17080524563789368,
-0.06035352498292923,
-0.5008710026741028,
0.8837581276893616,
0.07629476487636566,
0.17943206429481506,
-0.7995418310165405,
-0.036341652274131775,
-0.6670108437538147,
-0.37865450978279114,
-0.1513618379831314,
-0.0985134094953537,
0.27900323271751404,
0.5714208483695984,
0.6717767715454102,
0.3409744203090668,
0.6153792142868042,
0.22217418253421783,
-0.05574510991573334,
0.6463676691055298,
-0.33218109607696533,
0.09774593263864517,
-0.19470170140266418,
-0.7352886199951172,
-0.3328571915626526,
-0.2949276566505432,
0.48207464814186096,
0.8627731800079346,
-0.05081471428275108,
0.25996577739715576,
0.09507347643375397,
0.6824710369110107,
-0.5335184335708618,
0.40174099802970886,
-0.8300865888595581,
0.14527709782123566,
-0.11395963281393051,
-0.2764222025871277,
-0.19358274340629578,
-0.7146211862564087,
0.12731970846652985,
-0.6013715863227844,
-0.08570191264152527,
0.012947272509336472,
0.48879507184028625,
0.2873232662677765,
-0.4433525502681732,
-0.13663864135742188,
-0.8418514728546143,
0.11936934292316437,
-0.5506362318992615,
0.5014693737030029,
0.3531596064567566,
0.41647520661354065,
-0.2712953984737396,
-0.9610419273376465,
-0.8170093894004822,
-0.5387870073318481,
-0.5566515326499939,
0.13222135603427887,
-0.03200937435030937,
-0.004849341232329607,
0.5603967905044556,
0.640455424785614,
-0.5466783046722412,
-0.46535658836364746,
-0.46061971783638,
0.09016815572977066,
0.36646002531051636,
0.031662844121456146,
0.3932648003101349,
0.04218383505940437,
-0.20311465859413147,
-0.1758148968219757,
-0.6541545391082764,
0.15625151991844177,
0.21005579829216003,
0.4224724769592285,
0.338890016078949,
1.0539121627807617,
-0.5465944409370422,
0.7324129343032837,
0.08029042184352875,
0.5178579688072205,
0.1962512731552124,
-0.6119261384010315,
-0.011470683850347996,
-0.11404604464769363,
0.2761322855949402,
0.304896742105484,
-0.2864167392253876,
-0.25924625992774963,
-0.12821064889431,
-0.1415206491947174,
0.37665507197380066,
-0.41062265634536743,
-0.30967071652412415,
0.3760755956172943,
0.057879380881786346,
0.10833561420440674,
0.09167713671922684,
-0.667574942111969,
-0.477037250995636,
-0.07410949468612671,
0.9937911033630371,
-0.33906129002571106,
-0.1196378543972969,
-0.5984521508216858,
-0.3026461899280548,
0.41425347328186035,
0.3015306890010834,
-0.41088616847991943,
0.3458777666091919,
0.42239564657211304,
0.6764994859695435,
-0.08055562525987625,
0.10250896960496902,
-0.824459433555603,
0.2012227475643158,
-0.4238704741001129,
0.9294202923774719,
-0.35266345739364624,
-0.4835192859172821,
0.04234623536467552,
-0.003705838229507208,
0.27971112728118896,
-0.45801639556884766,
0.5511048436164856,
-0.8459199070930481,
0.3835721015930176,
-0.6659125685691833,
-0.5922893285751343,
-0.29377007484436035,
0.3477032482624054,
-0.9308796525001526,
1.0158978700637817,
0.319387823343277,
-0.7168080806732178,
0.3585154414176941,
-0.9558455348014832,
-0.39975714683532715,
0.25322073698043823,
-0.13296806812286377,
-0.21009863913059235,
0.21111108362674713,
0.5639267563819885,
0.0027358399238437414,
-0.0790182575583458,
0.01287316158413887,
-0.3401075005531311,
-0.25334954261779785,
0.45641669631004333,
-0.02733471244573593,
0.49290964007377625,
-0.13725125789642334,
0.047382231801748276,
0.09639722108840942,
-0.6268819570541382,
0.3805430233478546,
0.15509679913520813,
-0.28470778465270996,
-0.31463000178337097,
-0.026597920805215836,
-0.328538715839386,
0.09016859531402588,
0.37582311034202576,
-0.4996897578239441,
0.3459224998950958,
-0.8229721784591675,
0.14093755185604095,
0.42117366194725037,
0.24776752293109894,
0.5909660458564758,
-0.43903791904449463,
0.3345749080181122,
0.06347859650850296,
-0.08194669336080551,
-0.044021546840667725,
-0.5315048694610596,
-0.7056524157524109,
0.5593271255493164,
0.3822612762451172,
0.6613180041313171,
-1.267869472503662,
0.17116698622703552,
-0.09327857941389084,
-0.536247193813324,
-0.6518323421478271,
0.15401960909366608,
0.1722152829170227,
0.7437591552734375,
0.9393073916435242,
-0.23889009654521942,
-0.6245883703231812,
-0.8326730728149414,
-0.5736712217330933,
-0.15745991468429565,
-0.26107653975486755,
0.46896785497665405,
0.303986132144928,
0.08698981255292892,
0.9706379175186157,
-0.9589278101921082,
-0.2567503750324249,
-0.39837005734443665,
-0.22770994901657104,
0.2400825172662735,
0.6495615243911743,
0.014723402447998524,
-0.5436026453971863,
-0.3385353982448578,
0.08216648548841476,
-0.47348499298095703,
0.11260481923818588,
0.06814137101173401,
-0.23886659741401672,
-0.14173585176467896,
0.3502556383609772,
-0.6953656077384949,
0.5169807076454163,
0.15752092003822327,
-0.10936890542507172,
0.3588627576828003,
-0.24113234877586365,
0.26603949069976807,
-1.0580333471298218,
0.14934445917606354,
-0.25513699650764465,
-0.15084759891033173,
-0.704174816608429,
0.1881629228591919,
0.26183250546455383,
-0.3190563917160034,
-0.2898682951927185,
0.5390625,
-0.550743043422699,
-0.11674617975950241,
-0.04162852466106415,
0.2442263811826706,
0.1237756684422493,
0.47047868371009827,
0.005564554128795862,
0.8913305401802063,
0.08830245584249496,
-0.5921589732170105,
0.3313843011856079,
0.6910557150840759,
-0.3368324041366577,
0.4939241111278534,
-0.5904760956764221,
0.4408128559589386,
-0.23809735476970673,
0.052463844418525696,
-1.2570879459381104,
-0.37205079197883606,
0.4281882047653198,
-0.45580193400382996,
0.3071858584880829,
-0.23388372361660004,
-0.2691023647785187,
-0.5543749332427979,
-0.14103087782859802,
0.2147604078054428,
0.37020623683929443,
-0.7211838364601135,
0.8467149138450623,
0.4545575678348541,
-0.26485517621040344,
-0.6723425984382629,
-0.9567108750343323,
0.0015485557960346341,
-0.09965116530656815,
-0.644894003868103,
0.7174330949783325,
-0.1530553102493286,
-0.2884194850921631,
0.14557088911533356,
-0.24730437994003296,
-0.5461143255233765,
-0.28577056527137756,
-0.0017344129737466574,
0.08215366303920746,
-0.27922919392585754,
0.35922321677207947,
0.4377601146697998,
0.08787867426872253,
0.15440049767494202,
-0.24069806933403015,
0.31110885739326477,
0.011340921744704247,
-0.47913798689842224,
-0.5589813590049744,
0.5030505657196045,
0.29952916502952576,
-0.27085626125335693,
0.7891349792480469,
0.42754870653152466,
-0.5353273749351501,
-0.07345364987850189,
-0.8478245139122009,
-0.526995062828064,
-0.4540245234966278,
0.3391246199607849,
-0.2604031562805176,
-0.35149338841438293,
0.5547337532043457,
0.14206752181053162,
0.16614925861358643,
0.48057782649993896,
0.0882604718208313,
-0.17781174182891846,
0.8805922269821167,
0.5273869037628174,
0.5042932629585266,
0.3621003329753876,
-0.058497339487075806,
0.04390432685613632,
-0.763556718826294,
-0.41228312253952026,
-0.6096879243850708,
-0.0977725237607956,
-0.32077082991600037,
-0.58139967918396,
0.44463133811950684,
-0.21920351684093475,
0.12353681772947311,
0.3930681049823761,
-0.37204423546791077,
0.4881912171840668,
0.7459428310394287,
0.5941611528396606,
0.6786247491836548,
-0.2012641876935959,
0.08306620270013809,
-0.07982674241065979,
-0.7537708282470703,
0.09254328161478043,
1.0285998582839966,
0.06209062412381172,
0.6423938870429993,
0.03412163257598877,
0.5983511805534363,
0.06143497675657272,
0.48691052198410034,
-0.5348283052444458,
0.37327325344085693,
0.2179994434118271,
-0.5791144967079163,
-0.39383041858673096,
-0.5873881578445435,
-0.5493281483650208,
0.22621974349021912,
-0.504221498966217,
-0.34812039136886597,
0.2550663352012634,
0.3633780777454376,
-0.6030283570289612,
0.030082806944847107,
-1.0270992517471313,
0.8257689476013184,
-0.2834153473377228,
-0.4507623612880707,
0.04547474905848503,
-0.528374195098877,
0.4852063059806824,
-0.03409998118877411,
0.008680231869220734,
0.24567516148090363,
-0.1491987109184265,
0.8185678720474243,
-0.7796871662139893,
0.3777889013290405,
-0.4505472481250763,
0.17806608974933624,
0.4044550955295563,
-0.05436185747385025,
0.750170111656189,
0.42108550667762756,
-0.10214626044034958,
-0.20788419246673584,
0.2476699948310852,
-0.12465918809175491,
-1.1380382776260376,
0.4317370355129242,
-0.3043716847896576,
-0.7503340244293213,
-0.19592423737049103,
-0.5571510791778564,
-0.5998677015304565,
0.12130029499530792,
-0.1366576850414276,
0.41998425126075745,
-0.04961118474602699,
0.4175959825515747,
0.4784756004810333,
-0.21109525859355927,
0.11882694065570831,
0.3732454478740692,
-0.09966976195573807,
-0.5227245688438416,
0.5970421433448792,
0.4352758824825287,
0.05045760050415993,
0.546485185623169,
0.2840447723865509,
-0.9560773968696594,
-0.5626437067985535,
-0.5505114197731018,
-0.07782081514596939,
-0.5952620506286621,
-0.47884032130241394,
-0.7273783683776855,
-0.22266314923763275,
-0.3764285445213318,
0.24996046721935272,
-0.020530618727207184,
-0.6952016949653625,
-0.15037870407104492,
-0.23412348330020905,
0.5083820223808289,
0.5102612972259521,
0.02760232612490654,
0.35805898904800415,
-1.043707251548767,
0.28574684262275696,
0.6281050443649292,
0.44816821813583374,
-0.0011110323248431087,
-0.4171939790248871,
-0.0194118469953537,
0.21364976465702057,
-0.18171672523021698,
-1.3914519548416138,
0.33740663528442383,
0.221811443567276,
0.7736555933952332,
0.12788552045822144,
0.23133070766925812,
1.019190788269043,
-0.4238768517971039,
0.569197952747345,
-0.15283183753490448,
-0.8530483841896057,
0.7548887133598328,
-0.04506254568696022,
0.2974603772163391,
0.9163349270820618,
0.4375542104244232,
-0.11764665693044662,
-0.18063539266586304,
-0.5787217617034912,
-0.9404261708259583,
0.5271938443183899,
0.2095438688993454,
0.17282621562480927,
0.24160535633563995,
0.46798640489578247,
0.034686699509620667,
0.40289121866226196,
-1.036313772201538,
-0.06326735019683838,
0.03298156335949898,
0.11505118012428284,
0.2983521521091461,
-0.17829887568950653,
-0.14018011093139648,
-0.3885631561279297,
0.6207163333892822,
-0.022862708196043968,
0.2576768696308136,
0.315869003534317,
-0.28760582208633423,
-0.05840320140123367,
0.18511293828487396,
0.2359364777803421,
0.6169877648353577,
-0.2706586420536041,
-0.13900376856327057,
0.6717022061347961,
-0.3373425006866455,
-0.28749048709869385,
0.4154978394508362,
-0.07454109191894531,
-0.043487321585416794,
-0.0076777213253080845,
0.22174875438213348,
0.04166461527347565,
-0.5945718288421631,
0.39233437180519104,
-0.1631876528263092,
-0.015901371836662292,
-0.1945037692785263,
0.08600202202796936,
0.1938140094280243,
0.2950471341609955,
0.5742639303207397,
-0.2637024223804474,
0.38947057723999023,
-0.6858893632888794,
0.4930030405521393,
0.6918383240699768,
-0.5699440240859985,
0.15831008553504944,
0.5737823843955994,
0.11488587409257889,
-0.3446137607097626,
0.6409236192703247,
-0.19630542397499084,
-0.2659270167350769,
0.41366851329803467,
0.5515623688697815,
0.4327903091907501,
-0.25178396701812744,
0.034249551594257355,
0.42733120918273926,
0.5572488903999329,
0.13778050243854523,
0.6473560929298401,
-0.18952396512031555,
-0.4579648971557617,
-0.6287630200386047,
-0.376507043838501,
-0.6285478472709656,
0.15065303444862366,
-0.4323381185531616,
0.17650611698627472,
-0.09495771676301956,
-0.022669361904263496,
-0.14017552137374878,
0.09909497946500778,
-0.7133446931838989,
0.12593424320220947,
-0.43043234944343567,
0.9367764592170715,
-0.7392992377281189,
0.41491833329200745,
0.4562545418739319,
-0.7645091414451599,
-0.7729659080505371,
0.027544084936380386,
-0.5659542083740234,
-0.6477876901626587,
0.13519497215747833,
0.020472709089517593,
0.4466829001903534,
0.0672723725438118,
-0.3612222969532013,
-0.9956807494163513,
0.8200860023498535,
0.24435703456401825,
-0.2449396252632141,
-0.16560541093349457,
0.18961934745311737,
0.4268442988395691,
-0.0530802421271801,
0.49689826369285583,
0.5156160593032837,
0.659481406211853,
0.2483358383178711,
-0.5792931318283081,
0.35137519240379333,
-0.14796008169651031,
-0.3125115633010864,
0.23618623614311218,
0.08637432754039764,
0.5065512657165527,
-0.366688072681427,
-0.29288461804389954,
-0.1067892387509346,
1.1003857851028442,
-0.232345312833786,
0.3342874050140381,
0.5316518545150757,
0.37802520394325256,
0.8923874497413635,
-0.2347959578037262,
0.7740796208381653,
-0.045998070389032364,
-0.11182044446468353,
1.4347541332244873,
-0.09331383556127548,
0.9568962454795837,
0.40657395124435425,
-0.35348641872406006,
0.5090619325637817,
0.46257561445236206,
0.09205036610364914,
0.3115066885948181,
0.18225468695163727,
-0.07725261151790619,
0.0095971105620265,
0.004781422670930624,
-0.839040219783783,
0.3841133713722229,
0.5471947193145752,
-0.1477643847465515,
-0.3037777543067932,
-0.19480854272842407,
-0.4414569139480591,
-0.0076859560795128345,
-0.40468883514404297,
1.1948224306106567,
-0.05937003344297409,
-0.6962246298789978,
0.15602172911167145,
-0.3168138861656189,
0.03427765890955925,
-0.6134257912635803,
-0.3738546371459961,
-0.3870609402656555,
-0.2784241735935211,
-0.3927057683467865,
-0.898236095905304,
0.7340900301933289,
-0.29102975130081177,
0.11291787028312683,
0.24579329788684845,
0.6380357146263123,
-0.7225091457366943,
-0.3965984880924225,
-0.23380181193351746,
1.067594051361084,
-0.10675743967294693,
-0.3522641062736511,
-0.4939570724964142,
-0.49337151646614075,
-0.14380650222301483,
0.11692818254232407,
0.043148353695869446,
0.20800898969173431,
0.20751027762889862,
0.5213654637336731,
0.8976508975028992,
-0.20849990844726562,
-0.11707586795091629,
-0.21081587672233582,
1.1335841417312622,
-0.4414079189300537,
-0.7560428380966187,
-0.6004076600074768,
0.7274234890937805,
-0.44405850768089294,
-0.05822029337286949,
0.7712969183921814,
0.6174969673156738,
0.5271928906440735,
-0.20852749049663544,
0.49082574248313904,
-0.04409521073102951,
0.5501294732093811,
-0.5808711647987366,
0.6963585019111633,
-0.618478000164032,
0.15482904016971588,
-0.4166332483291626,
-0.9785348176956177,
-0.403169184923172,
0.4879235327243805,
-0.4515840411186218,
-0.018917633220553398,
0.7609298229217529,
0.8928157687187195,
0.13655462861061096,
0.11883778125047684,
0.12687623500823975,
0.18430930376052856,
0.07645601034164429,
0.4183848202228546,
1.063624620437622,
-0.26023411750793457,
0.960947573184967,
-0.44953522086143494,
-0.2814759612083435,
-0.1141289621591568,
-0.7575833201408386,
-0.5963208675384521,
-0.686556339263916,
-0.20713317394256592,
-0.6684402823448181,
-0.013199478387832642,
0.9273116588592529,
0.5154978036880493,
-0.7328763604164124,
0.16490061581134796,
-0.12017004191875458,
0.4473104178905487,
-0.32013481855392456,
-0.24378612637519836,
0.4686022698879242,
-0.2855607569217682,
-0.5144309997558594,
0.6502252817153931,
-0.049032241106033325,
0.18775174021720886,
-0.16688962280750275,
0.5913262963294983,
-0.27689188718795776,
0.12425265461206436,
0.41869890689849854,
0.3392747640609741,
-0.22772525250911713,
-0.12282261997461319,
0.10125084221363068,
0.38206034898757935,
0.33816832304000854,
0.7835987210273743,
-0.9568668603897095,
0.4276156723499298,
0.8500529527664185,
0.9999232292175293,
0.5127994418144226,
0.4370274543762207,
0.6989568471908569,
-0.9717437624931335,
-0.31086093187332153,
0.41976168751716614,
0.19740897417068481,
0.27423736453056335,
-0.6969435214996338,
0.4992567002773285,
-0.08336152881383896,
-0.2811688482761383,
-0.916934072971344,
0.15084794163703918,
-1.0097146034240723,
-0.1317327618598938,
0.6432656645774841,
0.2430892139673233,
-0.20538043975830078,
-0.3291815221309662,
-0.36524417996406555,
0.17812985181808472,
-0.3577035069465637,
0.8810109496116638,
0.40067949891090393,
-0.32783243060112,
0.00605640048161149,
-0.5010914206504822,
0.8175039291381836,
0.2350093275308609,
-1.3562911748886108,
-0.034182656556367874,
0.4939090311527252,
-0.11821149289608002,
0.3337953984737396,
0.5567238330841064,
-0.13781647384166718,
0.45388364791870117,
0.14167115092277527,
-0.31500381231307983,
-0.19063520431518555,
-0.16516385972499847,
-0.14079166948795319,
0.6110755801200867,
0.12406934797763824,
-0.029981637373566628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15545v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15545v1 | PPM: Automated Generation of Diverse Programming Problems for Benchmarking Code Generation Models | 2024-01-28T02:27:38 | 2024-01-28T02:27:38 | Simin Chen, Xiaoning Feng, Xiaohong Han, Cong Liu, Wei Yang | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL | In recent times, a plethora of Large Code Generation Models (LCGMs) have been
proposed, showcasing significant potential in assisting developers with complex
programming tasks. Benchmarking LCGMs necessitates the creation of a set of
diverse programming problems, and each problem comprises the prompt (including
the task description), canonical solution, and test inputs. The existing
methods for constructing such a problem set can be categorized into two main
types: manual methods and perturbation-based methods. However, manual methods
demand high effort and lack scalability, while also risking data integrity due
to LCGMs' potentially contaminated data collection, and perturbation-based
approaches mainly generate semantically homogeneous problems with the same
canonical solutions and introduce typos that can be easily auto-corrected by
IDE, making them ineffective and unrealistic. In this work, we propose the idea
of programming problem merging (PPM) and provide two implementation of this
idea, we utilize our tool on two widely-used datasets and compare it against
nine baseline methods using eight code generation models. The results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our tool in generating more challenging,
diverse, and natural programming problems, comparing to the baselines. | [
-0.5974747538566589,
-0.43131211400032043,
0.21302969753742218,
0.3554408550262451,
0.030953172594308853,
0.40198373794555664,
-0.23728768527507782,
-0.018222898244857788,
-0.5086100101470947,
0.6524158120155334,
-0.48080557584762573,
-0.5502809286117554,
-0.45050159096717834,
0.28063881397247314,
-0.23672650754451752,
0.9634590744972229,
-0.3873578608036041,
0.06062282249331474,
-0.31870773434638977,
0.06801620870828629,
-0.5012366771697998,
-0.5415264368057251,
-0.10562030971050262,
-0.15788862109184265,
-0.021504327654838562,
0.7170693874359131,
0.5197944045066833,
0.4019278585910797,
0.8527641296386719,
0.3811423182487488,
0.25035184621810913,
0.4088722765445709,
-0.3259177803993225,
0.12761130928993225,
-0.016495831310749054,
-0.27982673048973083,
-0.2841474711894989,
0.22419896721839905,
0.5745589137077332,
0.8097068667411804,
-0.03657623752951622,
0.4967725872993469,
0.2844412922859192,
0.6156935095787048,
-0.8407402634620667,
-0.16443967819213867,
-0.5992627739906311,
0.4291996955871582,
0.07640178501605988,
-0.30780258774757385,
-0.07381788641214371,
-0.5500583052635193,
-0.20227788388729095,
-0.24775397777557373,
0.2214995175600052,
-0.27677327394485474,
0.7013190388679504,
0.557420551776886,
-0.46495214104652405,
-0.3335663974285126,
-0.9852147102355957,
0.9795634150505066,
-0.8579682111740112,
-0.27919185161590576,
-0.17431940138339996,
0.4339752495288849,
-0.44813165068626404,
-0.3906790614128113,
-0.6640098094940186,
-0.3891861140727997,
0.26193299889564514,
0.15203848481178284,
-0.09967271983623505,
-0.2906816899776459,
0.46735909581184387,
0.498913049697876,
-0.623968243598938,
0.17746922373771667,
-0.24382293224334717,
-0.1297944337129593,
0.7331896424293518,
0.3958675265312195,
0.3277989625930786,
-0.09573186188936234,
-0.3581651449203491,
-0.1918809562921524,
-0.6447182893753052,
-0.13925738632678986,
0.7857887148857117,
0.1551845669746399,
-0.013023600913584232,
0.7016710042953491,
-0.017641710117459297,
0.88457852602005,
-0.043947603553533554,
-0.11395400762557983,
0.21755079925060272,
-0.7090648412704468,
-0.17915041744709015,
-0.47096917033195496,
0.5677767395973206,
0.5366821885108948,
0.269822359085083,
-0.03911205753684044,
-0.15362051129341125,
0.1706569492816925,
0.23166896402835846,
-0.4725419878959656,
-0.5283389091491699,
0.3935949504375458,
-0.2561399042606354,
-0.6266973614692688,
0.1994623839855194,
-0.7235164046287537,
-0.35045015811920166,
-0.48280683159828186,
0.08363688737154007,
-0.31419527530670166,
-0.25187745690345764,
-0.14679130911827087,
-0.16056297719478607,
0.27801409363746643,
0.24294133484363556,
-0.26824355125427246,
-0.002523380797356367,
0.745403528213501,
0.31712406873703003,
-0.212371364235878,
-0.21074697375297546,
-0.5904335379600525,
0.0694761648774147,
-0.22058165073394775,
0.8197812438011169,
-0.3202228248119354,
-0.6415259838104248,
-0.07139866054058075,
-0.604023814201355,
0.1722198724746704,
-1.044734239578247,
0.03563643991947174,
0.01680992729961872,
0.2240537405014038,
-0.1928454339504242,
-0.5424631834030151,
0.19213998317718506,
0.44881272315979004,
-0.20834104716777802,
1.1636990308761597,
0.40917640924453735,
-0.7163275480270386,
0.3937418460845947,
-0.3380221426486969,
-0.022689813748002052,
0.35895490646362305,
-0.57476407289505,
-0.5751875042915344,
0.11123654991388321,
-0.04377778246998787,
0.1171993538737297,
-0.6820343136787415,
0.44816339015960693,
-0.13076703250408173,
-0.036330848932266235,
0.09080550819635391,
0.01568733900785446,
0.6241483688354492,
0.3800049424171448,
-0.5068445801734924,
0.22244176268577576,
-0.7594061493873596,
0.3759376108646393,
0.13849419355392456,
-0.5792371034622192,
0.017810026183724403,
0.13533706963062286,
-0.0032197237014770508,
0.41872474551200867,
0.389212429523468,
-0.20801961421966553,
0.43949803709983826,
0.20498919486999512,
0.08787056058645248,
0.5727705955505371,
0.20702792704105377,
0.0869913250207901,
-0.6611427664756775,
0.6447187662124634,
0.1881377398967743,
0.2073875218629837,
-0.20277409255504608,
-0.42138195037841797,
-0.6127119064331055,
0.017891690135002136,
0.3754461407661438,
0.8638125658035278,
-0.6871645450592041,
0.7890978455543518,
0.06310924142599106,
-0.6436787843704224,
-0.08905258029699326,
0.6031778454780579,
0.5814175605773926,
0.6662949919700623,
0.2744176387786865,
-0.43120118975639343,
-0.6290759444236755,
-0.9118481278419495,
-0.2296735644340515,
-0.10172878950834274,
-0.40556418895721436,
0.57454514503479,
0.24139449000358582,
-0.19008365273475647,
1.0437335968017578,
-0.636299192905426,
-0.13083969056606293,
-0.15041983127593994,
0.4541711211204529,
0.03435090184211731,
0.928321897983551,
0.45333632826805115,
-0.7752321362495422,
-0.6492366194725037,
-0.1513308733701706,
-0.6154084205627441,
-0.4940616190433502,
-0.1546589583158493,
0.16322176158428192,
0.09482386708259583,
0.560231626033783,
0.1410122662782669,
-0.010426784865558147,
0.6494559049606323,
0.009212273173034191,
0.9715442061424255,
-0.3763076961040497,
0.286361426115036,
-1.0381784439086914,
0.23246437311172485,
0.1165207028388977,
0.11106664687395096,
-0.30214187502861023,
0.348690003156662,
-0.018587011843919754,
-0.5913802981376648,
-0.37354984879493713,
-0.09966162592172623,
-0.6085593700408936,
-0.10969483107328415,
-0.13468781113624573,
0.00920810829848051,
-0.26757508516311646,
0.3639351427555084,
-0.5586878061294556,
0.7681339979171753,
0.49947333335876465,
-0.5680243372917175,
0.4760653078556061,
-0.20193633437156677,
-0.0069010620936751366,
0.4080350399017334,
-0.5334457159042358,
0.4078696072101593,
-0.11375750601291656,
0.24252420663833618,
-1.1585259437561035,
-0.0688820332288742,
0.03156279772520065,
-0.21607472002506256,
0.16455820202827454,
-0.24578848481178284,
-0.8286550641059875,
-0.6404879689216614,
-0.47824418544769287,
0.4100489616394043,
0.7641660571098328,
-0.18364597856998444,
0.29547539353370667,
0.25592240691185,
-0.25944992899894714,
-0.276729941368103,
-0.32382407784461975,
0.1247083768248558,
-0.25112202763557434,
-0.704405665397644,
0.44025468826293945,
-0.23072054982185364,
-0.2402545064687729,
-0.00211701518855989,
-0.3894825577735901,
0.04629156365990639,
0.10527203977108002,
0.007371166720986366,
0.4293998181819916,
-0.16177020967006683,
-0.18451914191246033,
0.0036344637628644705,
-0.36537444591522217,
-0.2535727024078369,
-0.4775049388408661,
0.45558926463127136,
-0.04498109221458435,
-0.36765122413635254,
-0.022749152034521103,
0.6140500903129578,
0.4147338569164276,
-0.3967985510826111,
0.24738548696041107,
0.387045681476593,
-0.2551506459712982,
-0.2718604505062103,
-0.7122958302497864,
0.30836787819862366,
-0.47116750478744507,
0.09507989138364792,
-0.31880903244018555,
-0.7058520317077637,
0.6148930191993713,
-0.735587477684021,
0.2717075049877167,
0.14689402282238007,
0.6003444790840149,
0.06893668323755264,
1.0461281538009644,
0.5966007709503174,
0.05069688707590103,
0.3377993404865265,
-0.34508126974105835,
0.0157986618578434,
-0.5674939751625061,
-0.009341585449874401,
-0.8583555221557617,
-0.3300262689590454,
-0.6177378296852112,
-0.6800369024276733,
0.35199400782585144,
0.4504893124103546,
-0.22049196064472198,
0.6483795642852783,
-0.8587049841880798,
0.5678650736808777,
0.3661078214645386,
-0.2872740924358368,
0.29551830887794495,
-0.02571050263941288,
-0.4927588403224945,
-0.1265968382358551,
-0.6844703555107117,
-0.6766368746757507,
1.3641732931137085,
-0.21390990912914276,
0.39098498225212097,
0.06233556196093559,
0.871897280216217,
0.22024443745613098,
0.5259889960289001,
-0.26721373200416565,
0.5829818844795227,
-0.4186973571777344,
-0.2433718740940094,
-0.016810806468129158,
-0.8280391097068787,
-0.8473058342933655,
0.1331622153520584,
-0.22869466245174408,
-0.7299538850784302,
0.08367028087377548,
0.3803179860115051,
-0.3927226960659027,
0.12699097394943237,
-0.7338459491729736,
0.9963429570198059,
-0.2613283693790436,
-0.25558385252952576,
-0.1379890888929367,
-0.35334596037864685,
0.4020686149597168,
-0.2832314074039459,
0.1261560320854187,
-0.2500053942203522,
-0.07282960414886475,
0.37002798914909363,
-0.7555551528930664,
0.3614511489868164,
-0.23895585536956787,
-0.2612285912036896,
0.32666659355163574,
0.13725997507572174,
0.4020150899887085,
-0.04517979919910431,
-0.02094993367791176,
-0.08492238819599152,
-0.30956459045410156,
-0.516061007976532,
-0.4235416054725647,
0.6587380170822144,
-0.535161018371582,
-0.6039984822273254,
-0.18280494213104248,
-0.7011158466339111,
-0.42287781834602356,
0.22611629962921143,
0.4842261075973511,
0.3991765081882477,
0.10053225606679916,
0.03172212839126587,
0.38418450951576233,
-0.5136264562606812,
0.3565898537635803,
0.5779845714569092,
-0.12373827397823334,
-0.3116821348667145,
0.8279217481613159,
0.04785565659403801,
0.18250656127929688,
0.14270706474781036,
0.03349527716636658,
0.3123275339603424,
-0.8566029667854309,
-0.06910675019025803,
-0.2168809175491333,
-0.2613162100315094,
-0.4611406624317169,
-0.1638106405735016,
-0.03484877571463585,
-0.3144551217556,
-0.3751945495605469,
-0.29754936695098877,
-0.06965095549821854,
0.187162384390831,
0.5045289993286133,
-0.16221702098846436,
0.23115189373493195,
-0.1083453819155693,
0.01590200699865818,
-1.0943303108215332,
0.3941163718700409,
0.2985173761844635,
0.33514368534088135,
-0.19237180054187775,
0.16230380535125732,
0.07807139307260513,
-0.1261332929134369,
-0.7481584548950195,
-0.8954536318778992,
0.21921680867671967,
-0.3013400733470917,
0.521179735660553,
0.019308865070343018,
0.151041179895401,
0.51445072889328,
-0.27325496077537537,
0.6076329946517944,
0.39221733808517456,
-1.0694482326507568,
0.808696985244751,
-0.4093257188796997,
0.5006539821624756,
0.7305336594581604,
0.31309717893600464,
-0.426394522190094,
-0.6830251812934875,
-0.5818459987640381,
-1.0529664754867554,
0.5019229650497437,
0.5096370577812195,
-0.21978895366191864,
0.08395803719758987,
0.16123974323272705,
0.029895268380641937,
0.24877381324768066,
-0.3136504590511322,
-0.16490620374679565,
0.05224606767296791,
-0.06254632025957108,
-0.06763221323490143,
0.027048051357269287,
-0.20368370413780212,
-0.24042339622974396,
0.3476593494415283,
-0.20415470004081726,
0.0014240597374737263,
0.07613179087638855,
-0.28021275997161865,
-0.23479008674621582,
0.17283160984516144,
0.5114850997924805,
0.6773163080215454,
-0.15711119771003723,
-0.06794679909944534,
-0.10112159699201584,
-0.14092206954956055,
0.2701996862888336,
0.2596968710422516,
-0.1616065800189972,
-0.20538608729839325,
0.09768376499414444,
0.14331546425819397,
0.09505239874124527,
-0.922269880771637,
0.18537171185016632,
0.16019468009471893,
-0.354022741317749,
-0.26982179284095764,
0.3461892008781433,
0.0013566809939220548,
0.02901272475719452,
0.6497307419776917,
0.18084312975406647,
0.0986570417881012,
-0.5089471936225891,
0.3192702829837799,
0.23550617694854736,
0.11939388513565063,
0.0984700471162796,
0.5751967430114746,
0.4546871483325958,
-0.5158262848854065,
0.7387225031852722,
-0.44570815563201904,
-0.5907251834869385,
1.1632764339447021,
0.38721486926078796,
0.8187916278839111,
-0.09062731266021729,
0.10340908169746399,
0.39061030745506287,
0.11412762850522995,
0.20954054594039917,
0.3011266887187958,
-0.22299699485301971,
-0.6304277181625366,
-0.5389483571052551,
-0.2363143414258957,
-0.660548746585846,
0.15572534501552582,
-0.5584490895271301,
0.25988438725471497,
-0.4978145956993103,
-0.17702651023864746,
0.27911409735679626,
0.25184008479118347,
-0.569076657295227,
0.012087595649063587,
0.19547945261001587,
0.7194445729255676,
-0.6949899196624756,
0.5530118942260742,
1.0359588861465454,
-0.3663657307624817,
-0.8714539408683777,
0.3108696937561035,
0.19304676353931427,
-0.16847969591617584,
0.3169892132282257,
0.013513944111764431,
0.27481094002723694,
-0.06933661550283432,
-0.39681464433670044,
-0.5694636702537537,
0.8617938160896301,
0.411717027425766,
-0.5418227910995483,
0.18937049806118011,
0.2888907194137573,
0.41218283772468567,
-0.36731159687042236,
-0.18084007501602173,
0.5172567367553711,
0.6078274250030518,
0.11617811769247055,
-1.031589150428772,
0.06905929744243622,
-0.599317729473114,
0.32628944516181946,
0.39864596724510193,
-0.3162759244441986,
0.9680008292198181,
-0.07164721190929413,
-0.0934986025094986,
-0.04228780418634415,
0.12896807491779327,
0.5558301210403442,
0.15432189404964447,
0.4451196789741516,
0.28262051939964294,
0.6125709414482117,
-0.1704649180173874,
0.9503394365310669,
-0.7138485908508301,
0.6399785876274109,
1.0091006755828857,
-0.6764985918998718,
0.20396240055561066,
0.2912384271621704,
-0.5047063827514648,
0.24581195414066315,
0.4693987965583801,
-0.5531268119812012,
0.17453034222126007,
0.7474530935287476,
-0.14968709647655487,
-0.24488520622253418,
0.3381139934062958,
-0.6054531931877136,
0.2884127199649811,
0.039983924478292465,
-0.03034239076077938,
-0.7378425598144531,
-0.15976686775684357,
-0.20775984227657318,
0.35539481043815613,
-0.0849551111459732,
0.7138127684593201,
-0.09552331268787384,
-0.9579901695251465,
0.5017601251602173,
0.3147631883621216,
0.7616153955459595,
-0.5065736770629883,
-0.03519929200410843,
-0.3176255226135254,
0.3770611584186554,
-0.2998274266719818,
-0.432661235332489,
0.47151434421539307,
0.188190758228302,
-0.09858284890651703,
-0.28192830085754395,
0.564564049243927,
-0.26029542088508606,
-0.5073056817054749,
0.014846633188426495,
0.5502287745475769,
-0.07586389034986496,
0.04364968463778496,
-0.8709114789962769,
-0.006813716609030962,
0.052792634814977646,
0.33619746565818787,
0.4111911654472351,
0.14512285590171814,
0.045424118638038635,
0.5351547598838806,
0.5835171341896057,
-0.06504694372415543,
0.16080455482006073,
-0.1557730883359909,
0.8312395811080933,
-0.43713483214378357,
-0.4279288649559021,
-0.6281293630599976,
0.5284896492958069,
-0.18883220851421356,
-0.39257892966270447,
0.8567719459533691,
0.7752373218536377,
0.7407063245773315,
-0.28656888008117676,
0.8020840287208557,
-0.12444204092025757,
0.15300419926643372,
-0.20307253301143646,
0.2434033751487732,
-0.2416853904724121,
0.48006582260131836,
-0.6855958104133606,
-1.1297318935394287,
-0.4103694558143616,
0.2772410213947296,
-0.22186923027038574,
0.12409137934446335,
0.510556697845459,
0.6223838329315186,
0.11817241460084915,
-0.40634146332740784,
-0.060848526656627655,
-0.24125641584396362,
0.31587669253349304,
0.9074913859367371,
0.6399509310722351,
-0.1796274036169052,
0.7363932132720947,
-0.17128854990005493,
-0.5011224746704102,
-0.29294702410697937,
-0.9498629570007324,
-0.28649285435676575,
-0.4007490575313568,
-0.9134820699691772,
-0.31588998436927795,
-0.097386933863163,
0.8010591268539429,
0.6521126627922058,
-0.9036843776702881,
-0.43043404817581177,
-0.5539600849151611,
0.17736700177192688,
-0.429745078086853,
-0.22105032205581665,
-0.03819340467453003,
-0.5744693875312805,
-0.8019859194755554,
0.06710943579673767,
0.35419321060180664,
0.14080810546875,
-0.28221720457077026,
0.09824827313423157,
0.09184081852436066,
0.07399237155914307,
0.21816891431808472,
0.4493868052959442,
-0.08424597978591919,
0.023907480761408806,
-0.18684035539627075,
-0.2226770967245102,
0.14928306639194489,
1.3275797367095947,
-0.7006629705429077,
0.28591597080230713,
0.6102555394172668,
0.46591389179229736,
0.37532830238342285,
0.14633724093437195,
0.919471263885498,
-0.8900912404060364,
0.0847160816192627,
0.3323891758918762,
0.21466690301895142,
0.157986581325531,
-0.2056843489408493,
0.47164085507392883,
0.20540446043014526,
-0.3328447937965393,
-0.9819902181625366,
0.5163677334785461,
-0.8039684295654297,
-0.45101064443588257,
0.9211061000823975,
-0.07479405403137207,
0.33823490142822266,
-0.17386740446090698,
-0.07974246889352798,
0.28708523511886597,
0.08673536032438278,
0.8466373085975647,
0.7120105028152466,
-0.33911028504371643,
0.1925347000360489,
-0.1964098960161209,
0.3298397958278656,
0.5170542597770691,
-1.1246623992919922,
-0.09482405334711075,
0.5954101085662842,
0.4004965126514435,
0.28985607624053955,
0.4410437047481537,
-0.42497265338897705,
0.4269584119319916,
0.29524296522140503,
0.2751332223415375,
-0.33041927218437195,
-0.07950427383184433,
-0.1761445850133896,
0.6190940737724304,
0.03543632850050926,
-0.09990353137254715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15535v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15535v1 | Quantifying Stereotypes in Language | 2024-01-28T01:07:21 | 2024-01-28T01:07:21 | Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | A stereotype is a generalized perception of a specific group of humans. It is
often potentially encoded in human language, which is more common in texts on
social issues. Previous works simply define a sentence as stereotypical and
anti-stereotypical. However, the stereotype of a sentence may require
fine-grained quantification. In this paper, to fill this gap, we quantify
stereotypes in language by annotating a dataset. We use the pre-trained
language models (PLMs) to learn this dataset to predict stereotypes of
sentences. Then, we discuss stereotypes about common social issues such as hate
speech, sexism, sentiments, and disadvantaged and advantaged groups. We
demonstrate the connections and differences between stereotypes and common
social issues, and all four studies validate the general findings of the
current studies. In addition, our work suggests that fine-grained stereotype
scores are a highly relevant and competitive dimension for research on social
issues. | [
-0.513590395450592,
-0.8130267858505249,
0.34704092144966125,
0.35178837180137634,
-0.16497543454170227,
0.1595042198896408,
-0.16191290318965912,
-0.33819103240966797,
0.5178488492965698,
0.3233499825000763,
0.06407392024993896,
-0.6415913105010986,
-0.6576518416404724,
0.2891196608543396,
-0.3928239643573761,
0.9725231528282166,
0.1643705666065216,
0.14440542459487915,
-0.5489979982376099,
-0.2086556851863861,
-0.3017452359199524,
-1.0789128541946411,
-0.3132626712322235,
0.028042864054441452,
0.24451708793640137,
0.40287312865257263,
0.7551363706588745,
0.5535878539085388,
0.467765212059021,
0.28336086869239807,
-0.09576752036809921,
-0.11042563617229462,
-0.4175853729248047,
0.0688156709074974,
-0.0375797338783741,
-0.5445417165756226,
-0.2138412594795227,
0.4805874824523926,
0.23797865211963654,
1.0903270244598389,
0.3302401602268219,
0.28962358832359314,
0.06907552480697632,
0.4486512243747711,
-0.33401042222976685,
0.4577275514602661,
-0.349441260099411,
0.11303787678480148,
-0.4463731646537781,
0.18133525550365448,
0.03593951463699341,
-0.9247888922691345,
0.021518761292099953,
-0.4910503923892975,
0.4218895435333252,
0.2817329466342926,
0.7507349848747253,
0.10233626514673233,
-0.5500364303588867,
-0.5017908811569214,
-0.5345985889434814,
0.7619645595550537,
-0.4727884829044342,
0.04131627827882767,
0.6596586108207703,
0.16360355913639069,
0.07900850474834442,
-0.32377126812934875,
-0.3133987784385681,
-0.16939744353294373,
-0.529096782207489,
-0.14876094460487366,
0.031127965077757835,
0.10442481935024261,
0.19451460242271423,
0.5477738976478577,
-0.615794837474823,
0.01354646123945713,
-0.5681317448616028,
-0.2549888491630554,
0.6426037549972534,
0.13559342920780182,
0.6504055261611938,
-0.5409594774246216,
-0.22897343337535858,
0.23068945109844208,
-0.38791027665138245,
0.2997226119041443,
0.6478270888328552,
0.3044787645339966,
-0.2943924367427826,
0.3656482994556427,
-0.30631884932518005,
0.6123681664466858,
-0.14905300736427307,
0.11593783646821976,
0.6717789173126221,
-0.16640345752239227,
0.08240687102079391,
0.10181769728660583,
0.5605291724205017,
0.4837225079536438,
1.1512084007263184,
-0.13339360058307648,
-0.2395866960287094,
0.5251766443252563,
-0.03914962708950043,
-0.45758959650993347,
-0.24144931137561798,
0.025373557582497597,
-0.37858110666275024,
-0.5372838377952576,
0.091249018907547,
-0.9802922606468201,
-0.47153955698013306,
-0.14639000594615936,
0.040022704750299454,
-0.2775040566921234,
-0.015818368643522263,
0.18375062942504883,
-0.3479968011379242,
0.10845482349395752,
0.0006772445631213486,
-0.843858003616333,
0.32279956340789795,
0.6898313164710999,
0.8700874447822571,
0.2596326470375061,
0.03176029771566391,
-0.049136970192193985,
-0.020373692736029625,
-0.3362874984741211,
0.754131555557251,
-0.8043473362922668,
-0.38758721947669983,
0.05669023469090462,
-0.15325671434402466,
0.05782316252589226,
-0.5997499823570251,
0.375415563583374,
0.22268898785114288,
0.26781293749809265,
-0.24930454790592194,
-0.6762813925743103,
0.11731626838445663,
0.3108811676502228,
-0.49700307846069336,
0.7178996205329895,
0.21644878387451172,
-0.9394472241401672,
0.3674637973308563,
-0.39460375905036926,
-0.39184996485710144,
0.12890174984931946,
-0.4254685640335083,
-0.21722643077373505,
0.41481709480285645,
0.02910665050148964,
0.4450110197067261,
-0.09962982684373856,
0.3829011619091034,
-0.44625353813171387,
-0.30399850010871887,
0.48976972699165344,
0.10777687281370163,
0.7619996070861816,
0.4251657724380493,
0.20322492718696594,
-0.0031837692949920893,
-0.7316206693649292,
-0.23585768043994904,
0.19979976117610931,
0.002745152683928609,
-1.0160179138183594,
-0.09103713184595108,
-0.23429644107818604,
0.03964543342590332,
0.35479626059532166,
-0.609024703502655,
0.041573502123355865,
-0.4059593975543976,
0.42367205023765564,
0.6549615859985352,
-0.06451768428087234,
0.5150817036628723,
-0.11127597093582153,
0.47888311743736267,
-0.09714401513338089,
0.35642561316490173,
0.25347694754600525,
-0.5719135999679565,
-0.5550347566604614,
-0.28950926661491394,
0.22350722551345825,
0.575739860534668,
-0.2523060441017151,
0.4867437481880188,
0.16270771622657776,
-0.0926138162612915,
-0.5469358563423157,
0.22947478294372559,
0.4461338520050049,
0.05707397311925888,
0.13242633640766144,
-0.2818812131881714,
-0.763356626033783,
-1.0487414598464966,
-0.5006216764450073,
-0.3724115192890167,
-0.14869043231010437,
0.09152089059352875,
0.4025452136993408,
0.13639701902866364,
1.2928804159164429,
-0.6061869859695435,
-0.51695317029953,
-0.44886380434036255,
0.6470009684562683,
-0.17530688643455505,
0.26718851923942566,
0.7955594062805176,
-0.7142911553382874,
-0.3286733627319336,
-0.3510138988494873,
-0.9012508392333984,
-0.5206654667854309,
0.33602410554885864,
0.15621578693389893,
-0.040106628090143204,
0.811788022518158,
-0.2566628158092499,
0.16345973312854767,
0.5162408351898193,
-0.5497736930847168,
0.4725774824619293,
0.07038753479719162,
-0.03920607268810272,
-0.7947765588760376,
-0.4301062524318695,
0.4352191388607025,
0.003939837217330933,
-0.5323397517204285,
-0.1554451733827591,
-0.38339942693710327,
-0.058940622955560684,
-0.25980904698371887,
0.4028570353984833,
-0.195028617978096,
-0.17093110084533691,
0.22491592168807983,
0.07055015116930008,
0.08416087925434113,
0.09861952811479568,
0.08623040467500687,
0.5194768905639648,
0.41612255573272705,
-0.306445449590683,
0.3780922293663025,
0.008158483542501926,
-0.5349447131156921,
0.2903675436973572,
-0.632281482219696,
0.08065653592348099,
-0.6887901425361633,
0.04347134009003639,
-0.9712126851081848,
-0.21372480690479279,
0.02109869197010994,
-0.3736802935600281,
-0.3291775584220886,
0.0034102622885257006,
-0.5058555006980896,
-0.4444558918476105,
-0.13733965158462524,
0.5798287987709045,
0.45283395051956177,
0.044084180146455765,
0.0032074463088065386,
0.6392589211463928,
-0.3054344654083252,
-0.23784884810447693,
-0.39795562624931335,
-0.19076931476593018,
-0.6270573735237122,
-0.3481997549533844,
-0.10511580854654312,
0.2376626431941986,
-1.0039793252944946,
-0.1642601490020752,
0.08383407443761826,
-0.2509245276451111,
0.08323803544044495,
0.22013188898563385,
0.07503699511289597,
-0.11711103469133377,
0.27041298151016235,
-0.3738400340080261,
-0.09073003381490707,
-0.036082975566387177,
0.15603011846542358,
0.7010543346405029,
-0.3423725664615631,
0.27278274297714233,
0.23984506726264954,
0.4555855393409729,
0.3205435574054718,
-0.2157279998064041,
0.6078090667724609,
0.35783758759498596,
-0.21609720587730408,
-0.04881088435649872,
-0.27448755502700806,
-0.05800297483801842,
-0.3623371124267578,
0.4171779453754425,
-0.4020485281944275,
-0.9683679342269897,
0.5416122674942017,
0.29342418909072876,
-0.2303551882505417,
0.03177035227417946,
-0.05346301570534706,
-0.3292739689350128,
1.020596981048584,
0.6902438402175903,
-0.12870033085346222,
0.26003915071487427,
0.14075860381126404,
0.34722819924354553,
-0.12397349625825882,
-0.11497149616479874,
-0.8401734232902527,
-0.16458170115947723,
-0.5153191685676575,
-0.2710299789905548,
0.26826655864715576,
0.3793981075286865,
-0.29034313559532166,
0.0427502766251564,
-0.32827240228652954,
0.512775719165802,
0.3696596026420593,
-0.2538979649543762,
0.2726184129714966,
-0.24026085436344147,
0.07924741506576538,
-0.22912395000457764,
-0.31949901580810547,
-0.9421178698539734,
0.7524832487106323,
0.4773208796977997,
0.7133013010025024,
-0.02801656909286976,
0.7997855544090271,
0.5856311321258545,
0.27071455121040344,
-0.692884087562561,
0.7977897524833679,
-0.7183296084403992,
-0.8094690442085266,
-0.2563704550266266,
-0.5982173085212708,
-0.6999515295028687,
0.16936826705932617,
-0.14912264049053192,
-0.9669632315635681,
0.3405735492706299,
0.3675071895122528,
-0.15534059703350067,
-0.018152721226215363,
-0.7658408880233765,
1.1111654043197632,
-0.2518908679485321,
0.3000117242336273,
0.12150351703166962,
-0.6862947940826416,
0.5723944306373596,
0.018326234072446823,
0.7774405479431152,
-0.4976555109024048,
0.5073197484016418,
0.8022804856300354,
-0.30136483907699585,
1.0147496461868286,
-0.09808990359306335,
-0.005958876106888056,
0.14759114384651184,
-0.035777997225522995,
0.06696101278066635,
-0.2869285047054291,
0.10987303406000137,
0.19864679872989655,
0.1517128050327301,
-0.5007563233375549,
-0.5173744559288025,
0.254782110452652,
-0.8596470952033997,
-0.4888818860054016,
-0.3080013394355774,
-0.723687469959259,
-0.26719847321510315,
-0.3750104010105133,
0.14886830747127533,
0.3362266719341278,
-0.6295512318611145,
-0.17519702017307281,
0.46170511841773987,
-0.761841356754303,
0.03487470746040344,
0.16911156475543976,
-0.6766595244407654,
0.05813120678067207,
1.0006531476974487,
0.33145391941070557,
0.5091695189476013,
0.18082089722156525,
0.3012571930885315,
-0.11246202141046524,
-0.1253001093864441,
0.04338042438030243,
0.23082461953163147,
-0.616024374961853,
0.2298508882522583,
-0.8311201333999634,
-0.032969024032354355,
-0.8289530873298645,
-0.2459416389465332,
-0.2543003261089325,
-0.38392025232315063,
0.006096826866269112,
-0.24731384217739105,
0.4340071678161621,
0.8648322820663452,
-0.2130100429058075,
0.3117918372154236,
-0.3979755640029907,
0.6076076626777649,
0.4255784749984741,
0.19834522902965546,
-0.3911439776420593,
-0.3386172354221344,
0.09639202058315277,
-0.15936271846294403,
0.3100146949291229,
-0.8308475017547607,
0.49225449562072754,
-0.022954018786549568,
0.5058498382568359,
0.5961228013038635,
0.4132009744644165,
0.3051617443561554,
-0.21062582731246948,
0.7234626412391663,
0.18581680953502655,
-0.9507202506065369,
0.5971896648406982,
-0.09140364825725555,
-0.07842697203159332,
0.43509355187416077,
0.5069629549980164,
-0.8061818480491638,
-0.9343611598014832,
-0.5149680972099304,
-0.876173198223114,
0.3098931312561035,
0.0714675635099411,
0.13489972054958344,
-0.56452876329422,
0.08758918941020966,
0.04669186472892761,
0.23080936074256897,
-0.649761974811554,
-0.4533572494983673,
-0.5989017486572266,
-0.4246552586555481,
-0.45355066657066345,
-0.517219066619873,
0.10747750848531723,
-0.2873156666755676,
0.1914549171924591,
0.2512147128582001,
-0.1723586767911911,
-0.28209570050239563,
-0.28807705640792847,
0.28084874153137207,
0.7270886898040771,
0.26036444306373596,
0.4210667014122009,
-0.7197058200836182,
0.473673552274704,
-0.1696164757013321,
-0.3599550724029541,
0.31795254349708557,
0.00014407829439733177,
-0.1304708868265152,
0.2579750418663025,
0.04907464608550072,
0.6304933428764343,
-0.04866704344749451,
-0.37832507491111755,
0.47405627369880676,
0.08979436755180359,
-0.07185531407594681,
-0.34626197814941406,
-0.24162009358406067,
-0.03459485247731209,
0.01872975192964077,
0.1186947450041771,
-0.10768643766641617,
0.2156703770160675,
-1.0782233476638794,
0.1369221955537796,
0.3063686788082123,
-0.45989230275154114,
-0.2142273634672165,
0.27752184867858887,
0.6125672459602356,
-0.2262505143880844,
0.25154080986976624,
-0.3913821578025818,
-0.5108137130737305,
0.8575747609138489,
0.4499570429325104,
0.5084277987480164,
-0.20091594755649567,
0.7493157982826233,
0.19164325296878815,
0.46649909019470215,
-0.07790100574493408,
-0.08030173927545547,
0.36677247285842896,
-1.1419304609298706,
-0.03583572059869766,
-1.0797958374023438,
-0.08435448259115219,
0.1955215334892273,
-0.891396164894104,
0.0705779418349266,
-0.29504844546318054,
0.010117722675204277,
0.27677595615386963,
-0.249970942735672,
-0.503899097442627,
0.2887367010116577,
0.36017805337905884,
0.5401623249053955,
-1.5596330165863037,
0.7589079737663269,
0.8569507002830505,
-0.7265821099281311,
-0.47632351517677307,
-0.0958111584186554,
0.13893912732601166,
-0.8379436731338501,
1.01218581199646,
0.1811833679676056,
-0.00401455070823431,
-0.16094937920570374,
-0.48767536878585815,
-0.5462403297424316,
0.17222540080547333,
0.258597731590271,
-0.4344036877155304,
-0.2225656658411026,
0.6619697213172913,
0.5738370418548584,
-0.6881982088088989,
0.0467156283557415,
0.9071894288063049,
0.47722434997558594,
-0.2932805120944977,
-0.7601816654205322,
-0.23917275667190552,
-0.18629837036132812,
0.2937963604927063,
-0.007361949421465397,
-0.3804468512535095,
1.0759114027023315,
-0.13496190309524536,
-0.10976062715053558,
-0.087821364402771,
0.40798646211624146,
0.16365861892700195,
0.34707769751548767,
0.6465547680854797,
0.3216831684112549,
0.6727336049079895,
-0.13321256637573242,
0.9401776790618896,
-0.03965546190738678,
0.30659982562065125,
0.9700037240982056,
-0.12117548286914825,
0.166795015335083,
0.3194619417190552,
-0.06804798543453217,
0.26975443959236145,
0.4648531377315521,
0.24864335358142853,
0.4234869182109833,
0.8005776405334473,
-0.2906460762023926,
-0.4649474620819092,
-0.2914001941680908,
-0.3055579960346222,
0.7086790204048157,
0.5451812148094177,
-0.5864185094833374,
-0.29915550351142883,
0.2519451975822449,
0.015130729414522648,
0.5433560013771057,
-0.6297462582588196,
0.6723219156265259,
0.24391794204711914,
-0.02244817279279232,
0.13229864835739136,
-0.23238831758499146,
0.8509144186973572,
-0.2885380983352661,
-0.02357601560652256,
-0.5062367916107178,
0.11314167827367783,
-0.2738589644432068,
-0.7747249603271484,
0.4158737361431122,
0.028261806815862656,
-0.5243476629257202,
-0.1142728254199028,
0.6953756809234619,
-0.5510824918746948,
-0.5911095142364502,
0.15568946301937103,
0.552696704864502,
0.8958078026771545,
-0.061978716403245926,
-0.265697181224823,
-0.018996112048625946,
0.15620559453964233,
0.20646721124649048,
0.40645256638526917,
0.7376319766044617,
-0.3641869127750397,
0.5404433012008667,
0.028810841962695122,
0.2155694216489792,
0.4424348473548889,
0.49112892150878906,
0.2618729770183563,
-0.8526839017868042,
-0.499805748462677,
-0.7364132404327393,
0.21509875357151031,
-0.20426712930202484,
-0.5262733697891235,
0.7699570655822754,
0.4783860146999359,
0.8804110884666443,
-0.00032627524342387915,
1.1200859546661377,
-0.12615956366062164,
0.7762062549591064,
-0.27704015374183655,
0.3366580903530121,
-0.26800811290740967,
0.2829761207103729,
-0.4781975746154785,
-0.6984009146690369,
-0.284628689289093,
1.0942208766937256,
-0.6814139485359192,
-0.17266321182250977,
0.2850153148174286,
0.712592363357544,
0.05184203013777733,
0.19667162001132965,
0.5695544481277466,
0.3734612464904785,
-0.07849486172199249,
0.2022981196641922,
1.0261611938476562,
0.10789273679256439,
0.5863651633262634,
-0.14899325370788574,
-0.22890527546405792,
-0.0362677164375782,
-0.37693285942077637,
-0.935237467288971,
-0.6095360517501831,
-0.45287972688674927,
-0.26538804173469543,
0.3273928463459015,
0.7756643891334534,
0.36455288529396057,
-0.7439669370651245,
-0.44168758392333984,
-0.025746777653694153,
0.16505709290504456,
0.09717825800180435,
-0.3671081066131592,
-0.0969868153333664,
-0.7956070303916931,
-0.668951153755188,
-0.31407222151756287,
0.10627185553312302,
0.09628899395465851,
-0.33566558361053467,
0.15042167901992798,
-0.07331759482622147,
0.2324388474225998,
0.6775824427604675,
0.19407694041728973,
-0.6311643123626709,
-0.681078314781189,
-0.4444371461868286,
-0.2592100203037262,
-0.08267217874526978,
0.884633481502533,
-0.5709777474403381,
0.23475202918052673,
0.27030593156814575,
-0.08615865558385849,
-0.036102715879678726,
0.2009647935628891,
0.8506500124931335,
-1.202284574508667,
0.45415401458740234,
0.07884763926267624,
0.5205397605895996,
0.39529895782470703,
-0.1454552561044693,
0.4541953206062317,
0.36779066920280457,
-0.3508217930793762,
-0.7856245040893555,
0.48230716586112976,
-0.7892696857452393,
-0.5275503396987915,
1.2109817266464233,
-0.2543754279613495,
-0.0786125436425209,
-0.7179771661758423,
-0.0352492555975914,
0.29855772852897644,
-0.43034160137176514,
0.8926075100898743,
0.6243149638175964,
0.1108139380812645,
-0.3916553854942322,
-0.6267735958099365,
0.6620535850524902,
0.2729648947715759,
-0.7754459381103516,
0.12996387481689453,
0.711066722869873,
0.3411404490470886,
0.3270200192928314,
0.5766938328742981,
-0.19595983624458313,
-0.3832670748233795,
0.058798715472221375,
0.4259498119354248,
0.28567031025886536,
-0.18138255178928375,
-0.0010019878391176462,
0.39298370480537415,
-0.1999230682849884,
-0.4224218428134918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15532v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15532v1 | Byte Pair Encoding Is All You Need For Automatic Bengali Speech Recognition | 2024-01-28T00:41:21 | 2024-01-28T00:41:21 | Ahnaf Mozib Samin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Byte pair encoding (BPE) emerges as an effective tokenization method for
tackling the out-of-vocabulary (OOV) challenge in various natural language and
speech processing tasks. Recent research highlights the dependency of BPE
subword tokenization's efficacy on the morphological nature of the language,
particularly in languages rich in inflectional morphology, where fewer BPE
merges suffice for generating highly productive tokens. Motivated by this, our
study empirically identifies the optimal number of BPE tokens for Bengali, a
language known for its morphological complexity, thus enhancing
out-of-distribution automatic speech recognition (ASR) performance.
Experimental evaluation reveals that an excessively high number of BPE tokens
can lead to overfitting, while approximately 500-1000 tokens result in superior
OOV performance. Furthermore, we conduct a comparative analysis of BPE with
character-based and unigram-based tokenization methods. By introducing BPE
tokenization to Bengali ASR, we achieve a substantial reduction in the word
error rate (WER) from 66.44% in our character-based baseline system to 63.80%
on the LB-ASRTD eval set and from 46.34% to 42.80% on the SHRUTI eval set, both
of which include out-of-distribution data. | [
-0.4159983694553375,
-0.25922101736068726,
-0.09608349204063416,
0.3350886106491089,
-0.6918805241584778,
0.19704918563365936,
0.19986021518707275,
-0.5465286374092102,
0.29404306411743164,
0.2682640254497528,
0.365614116191864,
-0.21558800339698792,
-0.6765251755714417,
0.11622694879770279,
-0.2886815071105957,
0.6644678711891174,
0.21723921597003937,
0.4853431284427643,
0.26571568846702576,
-0.1696726232767105,
-0.7830494046211243,
-0.7395170331001282,
-0.6828636527061462,
-0.2948117256164551,
0.19874455034732819,
-0.14622798562049866,
0.28070101141929626,
0.9378279447555542,
0.4841316044330597,
0.22717441618442535,
-0.3028798997402191,
0.16854090988636017,
0.019034817814826965,
0.05523913726210594,
-0.5019733905792236,
-0.3291483223438263,
-0.19792088866233826,
-0.5732066631317139,
0.8974467515945435,
0.941406786441803,
-0.032841529697179794,
0.2651340365409851,
-0.2096693068742752,
0.9433944225311279,
-0.7316557765007019,
0.20070698857307434,
-0.6443609595298767,
-0.24808652698993683,
-0.5075042247772217,
-0.23910610377788544,
-0.3528076410293579,
-0.08312695473432541,
-0.15045228600502014,
-0.014071209356188774,
-0.20853586494922638,
0.5305132269859314,
0.5821808576583862,
0.06744904816150665,
-0.2538543939590454,
-0.35050541162490845,
-0.3750009834766388,
0.3118175268173218,
-0.5827099680900574,
0.7288647890090942,
0.4891437292098999,
0.024559468030929565,
-0.3688843250274658,
-0.28614965081214905,
-0.49773746728897095,
0.07351260632276535,
0.14414842426776886,
0.012869487516582012,
-0.052331820130348206,
0.3345552086830139,
0.02686784416437149,
0.2240608036518097,
-0.60785973072052,
0.12852269411087036,
-0.7003176212310791,
-0.3017708361148834,
0.5484075546264648,
-0.07630650699138641,
0.3936062455177307,
-0.5769770741462708,
-0.25021108984947205,
0.11069663614034653,
-0.27860891819000244,
0.4171599745750427,
0.4903072118759155,
0.47320809960365295,
0.2306530773639679,
0.8433940410614014,
0.11825832724571228,
0.9130489826202393,
0.32011425495147705,
0.14560237526893616,
0.06435921043157578,
-0.5382025241851807,
-0.2523392140865326,
0.6254158020019531,
0.4696292281150818,
0.020489254966378212,
0.15767590701580048,
-0.310855507850647,
-0.39593616127967834,
0.15535791218280792,
0.35768449306488037,
-0.7565762996673584,
0.02695363014936447,
0.40083539485931396,
-0.6362584233283997,
0.21856023371219635,
0.18955321609973907,
-0.6503376364707947,
-0.6252297759056091,
-0.20634986460208893,
0.641713559627533,
-0.8083304166793823,
-0.24644014239311218,
0.3339489698410034,
-0.655890941619873,
0.3046604096889496,
-0.3574664294719696,
-1.1763325929641724,
0.38609352707862854,
0.6779768466949463,
0.9920463562011719,
-0.1913638412952423,
-0.008439570665359497,
-0.7693838477134705,
0.16843271255493164,
-0.5611915588378906,
0.7110068798065186,
-0.6288135051727295,
-0.7305802702903748,
-0.052210308611392975,
-0.3047710657119751,
-0.10471437871456146,
-0.7196006774902344,
0.38140952587127686,
-0.5102562308311462,
-0.5693721175193787,
-0.08478794246912003,
-0.8750534057617188,
-0.06334880739450455,
-0.4467752277851105,
-0.35730788111686707,
0.8959782719612122,
-0.05408066511154175,
-0.6940373778343201,
0.7525628209114075,
-0.8473430275917053,
-0.4981493353843689,
0.4406239986419678,
-0.18715381622314453,
-0.043818846344947815,
0.4443937838077545,
0.19199739396572113,
0.43220534920692444,
0.03915579617023468,
0.11066559702157974,
0.13193784654140472,
-0.7715644836425781,
0.26172319054603577,
-0.23944875597953796,
0.8619220852851868,
0.1562299132347107,
-0.33138275146484375,
-0.018249064683914185,
-1.1462424993515015,
0.14112097024917603,
-0.21745187044143677,
-0.516979455947876,
-0.4030294716358185,
-0.04364974796772003,
0.10003533214330673,
-0.3506219983100891,
0.07639747858047485,
-0.9447095394134521,
-0.005349218845367432,
-0.882909893989563,
0.7109083533287048,
0.5767695903778076,
0.03787490352988243,
0.5731819272041321,
-0.14407961070537567,
0.08725069463253021,
0.292070209980011,
-0.04498140513896942,
-0.26807916164398193,
-0.64020174741745,
-0.46985381841659546,
-0.7881629467010498,
0.5395424365997314,
0.5907869935035706,
-0.5110325217247009,
0.8727390766143799,
-0.08040587604045868,
-0.3079150915145874,
-1.071606159210205,
0.009910530410706997,
0.6342471241950989,
0.2513565421104431,
0.37724924087524414,
-0.8427274823188782,
-0.759661853313446,
-0.8156090378761292,
-0.17192044854164124,
-0.5698865056037903,
0.02637314423918724,
0.05973684787750244,
0.4295685887336731,
-0.1973312497138977,
1.3953566551208496,
0.14852139353752136,
-0.0969577357172966,
-0.2566300332546234,
0.30044859647750854,
0.2512386441230774,
0.7864686250686646,
0.4695677161216736,
-0.8571655750274658,
-0.44544512033462524,
-0.06283829361200333,
-0.19010503590106964,
-0.25648826360702515,
0.0865374505519867,
-0.10206810384988785,
1.127892017364502,
0.1418249011039734,
-0.2957381010055542,
0.6449402570724487,
0.31559187173843384,
-0.21596437692642212,
0.3925054371356964,
-0.48145362734794617,
0.1576126664876938,
-0.7708178758621216,
0.214486226439476,
-0.1360592544078827,
-0.16198188066482544,
-0.6882102489471436,
-0.16442278027534485,
0.13955913484096527,
-0.3515401780605316,
-0.2979629337787628,
0.6516635417938232,
-0.5007030963897705,
-0.369904100894928,
-0.14012819528579712,
0.0920022577047348,
-0.14781677722930908,
0.4249628484249115,
0.1560887098312378,
0.7580093741416931,
0.767779529094696,
-0.4586784541606903,
0.4493115246295929,
0.3775438666343689,
-0.48799097537994385,
0.5747772455215454,
-0.7509152293205261,
0.23389185965061188,
-0.44982630014419556,
0.09272877871990204,
-1.2598565816879272,
-0.13027586042881012,
0.251078337430954,
-0.7173134684562683,
0.8531387448310852,
-0.37982016801834106,
-0.48790109157562256,
-0.24448055028915405,
-0.33406275510787964,
0.5731552839279175,
0.7226875424385071,
-0.6951860189437866,
0.44768545031547546,
0.554896354675293,
-0.044102270156145096,
-0.5014922022819519,
-0.8206461668014526,
0.030781971290707588,
0.024973660707473755,
-0.5524771809577942,
0.24921733140945435,
-0.09909145534038544,
-0.06678332388401031,
-0.03594762086868286,
-0.35946762561798096,
-0.25345730781555176,
-0.531062126159668,
0.3281421959400177,
0.10204942524433136,
-0.007333185989409685,
0.15399497747421265,
-0.17130237817764282,
-0.2562476396560669,
-0.21977978944778442,
-0.6034219264984131,
0.7489767670631409,
-0.09214606881141663,
-0.35310232639312744,
-0.4012446701526642,
0.6562364101409912,
0.343631386756897,
-0.36155349016189575,
0.769627034664154,
0.7517024278640747,
-0.4009689688682556,
0.1883111447095871,
-0.7140780687332153,
0.20786337554454803,
-0.4316091239452362,
0.5617793202400208,
-0.4926720857620239,
-0.39463603496551514,
0.5133581757545471,
0.3112005591392517,
-0.23195797204971313,
-0.12864606082439423,
0.30077239871025085,
-0.17179365456104279,
0.8386456966400146,
0.5046955943107605,
-0.3562478721141815,
0.469140887260437,
0.06008497253060341,
0.4877449572086334,
-0.9581236243247986,
-0.4600984752178192,
-0.38070014119148254,
-0.1012883335351944,
-0.7898222208023071,
-0.3152015209197998,
0.45932257175445557,
0.2627739906311035,
-0.1333898901939392,
0.439247727394104,
-0.6846293210983276,
0.41664960980415344,
0.7010454535484314,
0.09522896260023117,
-0.2868889570236206,
0.04465305060148239,
0.19844423234462738,
0.07709833979606628,
-0.726905107498169,
-0.2558281719684601,
0.8358590602874756,
0.08616768568754196,
0.33733952045440674,
0.03593609109520912,
0.8516517281532288,
0.5242713093757629,
-0.6583368182182312,
-0.804455041885376,
0.581579327583313,
-0.26789113879203796,
-0.7922044992446899,
-0.44151052832603455,
-0.3874759078025818,
-0.9008395075798035,
0.12071272730827332,
-0.270696759223938,
-0.8023719787597656,
0.39106425642967224,
0.29572904109954834,
-0.3504517376422882,
0.2801775336265564,
-0.9490047097206116,
0.5429072976112366,
0.012312554754316807,
-0.1525425910949707,
-0.24876390397548676,
-1.0452513694763184,
-0.14058388769626617,
-0.3018733263015747,
0.14485935866832733,
0.15536293387413025,
-0.2959822118282318,
0.740706205368042,
-0.30269157886505127,
0.7471532821655273,
-0.45933136343955994,
0.3395814895629883,
0.36779797077178955,
-0.1979244202375412,
0.3216499090194702,
-0.16050736606121063,
-0.31229454278945923,
0.5404690504074097,
0.3088105618953705,
-0.8765224814414978,
-0.5486401319503784,
0.07814382016658783,
-0.6744417548179626,
-0.2613394260406494,
-0.5141808986663818,
-0.21005211770534515,
-0.19070471823215485,
0.11104223132133484,
0.43113911151885986,
1.2187217473983765,
0.15286751091480255,
0.10089791566133499,
0.5069001913070679,
-0.4128526449203491,
0.7135629653930664,
0.2916448414325714,
-0.06907054036855698,
-0.7978061437606812,
1.2749385833740234,
0.5297921299934387,
0.1860840916633606,
0.5633333921432495,
0.2697533071041107,
-0.5600048303604126,
-1.0610754489898682,
-0.7623418569564819,
0.307937890291214,
-0.6612975001335144,
-0.11090052127838135,
-0.4260982275009155,
-0.30790409445762634,
-0.7114474773406982,
-0.43740978837013245,
-0.2685951888561249,
-0.31314221024513245,
0.058911945670843124,
0.30988454818725586,
0.26936236023902893,
0.7216200828552246,
-0.3177814781665802,
0.24964697659015656,
-0.9946255087852478,
0.2368379384279251,
0.04041341319680214,
0.5139267444610596,
-0.30105891823768616,
-0.8211418986320496,
-0.2065243124961853,
-0.17503759264945984,
0.37361985445022583,
-0.8786087036132812,
0.32762855291366577,
0.4085181653499603,
0.4375526010990143,
0.1571355164051056,
0.01209894847124815,
0.943268358707428,
-0.6197377443313599,
0.8253316283226013,
0.35617199540138245,
-1.322782278060913,
0.3065686821937561,
-0.06567161530256271,
0.02698860689997673,
0.3639066517353058,
0.3251763582229614,
-0.5654898881912231,
-0.03482584282755852,
-0.31797081232070923,
-1.14090096950531,
0.6377598643302917,
0.1649135798215866,
-0.10805478692054749,
-0.11450162529945374,
0.6352641582489014,
0.28775542974472046,
0.586144208908081,
-0.17754840850830078,
-0.24531380832195282,
-0.40461409091949463,
-0.32168281078338623,
0.2536766231060028,
-0.6292087435722351,
0.5721267461776733,
-0.3679334819316864,
0.7681869864463806,
0.0712076798081398,
0.3360633850097656,
0.15467673540115356,
-0.04243655875325203,
0.016284683719277382,
0.26157429814338684,
0.42956802248954773,
0.4318055510520935,
-0.36422568559646606,
0.025921782478690147,
0.1743379831314087,
-0.6159732937812805,
0.09907572716474533,
-0.14667952060699463,
0.14879663288593292,
-0.006193386856466532,
0.3376196622848511,
0.8870568871498108,
-0.011841545812785625,
-0.8858357667922974,
0.5511143207550049,
0.43876272439956665,
0.2824912965297699,
-0.17217490077018738,
-0.14779403805732727,
-0.26747554540634155,
0.2264081835746765,
0.19081220030784607,
0.16576801240444183,
0.3433230519294739,
-0.7045289874076843,
0.1329512745141983,
0.4848569333553314,
-0.12526489794254303,
-0.31757888197898865,
0.396224707365036,
0.3890235722064972,
-0.6462345123291016,
0.4574204683303833,
-0.5495119094848633,
-0.38827693462371826,
0.4050796329975128,
0.8435901999473572,
0.6902419328689575,
-0.21464142203330994,
-0.12193579226732254,
0.31019964814186096,
0.29537132382392883,
0.06674900650978088,
0.3917381763458252,
-0.23578575253486633,
-0.609603762626648,
-0.3490805923938751,
-1.148857831954956,
-0.3343867063522339,
-0.26082050800323486,
-0.7143195867538452,
0.3047759234905243,
-0.33506760001182556,
-0.03348119929432869,
-0.002667732536792755,
0.0471181683242321,
-0.16884906589984894,
0.19126199185848236,
0.2308390736579895,
0.8237845301628113,
-0.504452109336853,
0.7481944561004639,
0.97151118516922,
-0.4570530652999878,
-0.5956560373306274,
-0.3901941776275635,
-0.2652322053909302,
-1.1770198345184326,
0.9506032466888428,
0.07281362265348434,
-0.2358579933643341,
0.18067429959774017,
0.008792506530880928,
-0.7487868070602417,
0.459043025970459,
0.22169460356235504,
-0.621360719203949,
0.1492968201637268,
0.38090741634368896,
0.4406318664550781,
-0.1287062019109726,
0.20688682794570923,
0.815473198890686,
0.5212499499320984,
0.179952010512352,
-1.0546225309371948,
-0.27100181579589844,
-0.26751798391342163,
0.5177310705184937,
0.5587255954742432,
-0.5905409455299377,
0.3120894432067871,
0.01636255346238613,
-0.15994273126125336,
-0.053256697952747345,
0.5046349167823792,
0.012657319195568562,
0.2434055209159851,
0.6033400297164917,
0.03247387707233429,
0.5888127088546753,
0.26331913471221924,
0.7501645088195801,
-0.4526556432247162,
-0.4424932897090912,
0.5823270082473755,
-0.282368540763855,
1.0745044946670532,
0.48689448833465576,
-0.17072416841983795,
0.019357455894351006,
0.6297560930252075,
0.05793088674545288,
0.43138518929481506,
0.35255303978919983,
-0.17677904665470123,
-0.09480444341897964,
-0.2387062907218933,
-0.042425736784935,
0.6599308848381042,
0.12430921941995621,
0.07650730758905411,
0.3172321319580078,
0.25168633460998535,
-0.21741481125354767,
0.09161465615034103,
-0.7147731184959412,
0.8660459518432617,
-0.05126814544200897,
-0.29703643918037415,
0.7166295647621155,
-0.26386067271232605,
0.8856335282325745,
-0.8334643244743347,
0.16114075481891632,
-0.08742925524711609,
0.09747666120529175,
-0.3016623854637146,
-0.5123513340950012,
0.5337086915969849,
0.12924693524837494,
-0.35582873225212097,
-0.05515165999531746,
0.7515077590942383,
-0.6835020780563354,
-0.32910284399986267,
0.20637285709381104,
0.008042187429964542,
0.7215716242790222,
-0.09887579083442688,
-0.1509600132703781,
0.33504804968833923,
-0.28019604086875916,
0.13383749127388,
0.4716862440109253,
0.40963470935821533,
0.06953700631856918,
0.48798254132270813,
0.4001075029373169,
0.7180191278457642,
0.48732295632362366,
-0.14333809912204742,
0.4808250963687897,
-0.747509241104126,
-0.6025583744049072,
-0.8801935911178589,
0.3760635554790497,
0.006646856665611267,
-0.09560181945562363,
0.5207160711288452,
0.5718650817871094,
0.7240354418754578,
0.018501929938793182,
0.8342368006706238,
-0.15704458951950073,
0.39071109890937805,
-0.45745986700057983,
0.5962482690811157,
-0.6310021281242371,
-0.273843914270401,
-0.10048246383666992,
-0.7379233837127686,
-0.24695982038974762,
0.6449623107910156,
0.24243585765361786,
-0.08296692371368408,
0.661674976348877,
0.7302541732788086,
0.35906240344047546,
0.09039541333913803,
0.5658715963363647,
-0.03571426868438721,
0.21209239959716797,
0.2676895260810852,
0.4190951883792877,
-0.3351207971572876,
0.5133780837059021,
0.08773969858884811,
-0.448656290769577,
-0.21371223032474518,
-0.8810186386108398,
-1.0433862209320068,
-0.8192395567893982,
-0.22351939976215363,
0.023489927873015404,
0.49338579177856445,
1.660916805267334,
0.807475745677948,
-0.8875728845596313,
-0.29523783922195435,
-0.05738290771842003,
-0.37487879395484924,
-0.2785797119140625,
-0.08159490674734116,
0.4383322298526764,
-0.7003988027572632,
-0.8157354593276978,
0.523892879486084,
0.664897620677948,
0.10063870251178741,
-0.03553381934762001,
0.1501055508852005,
0.0011864850530400872,
0.5850415825843811,
0.6718471050262451,
0.2533363699913025,
-0.4444565176963806,
-0.498108446598053,
-0.3558993339538574,
0.12525513768196106,
0.09677231311798096,
0.8425155878067017,
-0.4814381003379822,
0.7935924530029297,
0.8120310306549072,
0.9714336395263672,
0.19783596694469452,
0.1723499596118927,
0.43805992603302,
-0.8130497932434082,
0.3130844831466675,
0.16891798377037048,
0.445246160030365,
0.2915458679199219,
-0.1500694751739502,
0.46580231189727783,
0.47834914922714233,
-0.6463692784309387,
-1.079139232635498,
0.1808568388223648,
-1.0915322303771973,
-0.11961531639099121,
1.1418565511703491,
-0.05775873363018036,
-0.5094733238220215,
-0.5926358699798584,
-0.6113096475601196,
0.3966711759567261,
-0.6868870258331299,
0.7364625930786133,
0.6570146083831787,
-0.3917559087276459,
0.30439165234565735,
-0.022597134113311768,
0.2760734260082245,
0.5419870615005493,
-0.24093161523342133,
0.10918091237545013,
0.2556082308292389,
-0.08528999984264374,
0.2945191562175751,
0.7891924381256104,
0.1150876134634018,
0.03863416239619255,
0.385353147983551,
0.23129524290561676,
-0.40196025371551514,
-0.25535139441490173,
-0.48669636249542236,
0.19266213476657867,
0.056215208023786545,
-0.649965226650238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01728v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01728v1 | Hardware Phi-1.5B: A Large Language Model Encodes Hardware Domain Specific Knowledge | 2024-01-27T22:49:43 | 2024-01-27T22:49:43 | Weimin Fu, Shijie Li, Yifang Zhao, Haocheng Ma, Raj Dutta, Xuan Zhang, Kaichen Yang, Yier Jin, Xiaolong Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.AR | In the rapidly evolving semiconductor industry, where research, design,
verification, and manufacturing are intricately linked, the potential of Large
Language Models to revolutionize hardware design and security verification is
immense. The primary challenge, however, lies in the complexity of hardware
specific issues that are not adequately addressed by the natural language or
software code knowledge typically acquired during the pretraining stage.
Additionally, the scarcity of datasets specific to the hardware domain poses a
significant hurdle in developing a foundational model. Addressing these
challenges, this paper introduces Hardware Phi 1.5B, an innovative large
language model specifically tailored for the hardware domain of the
semiconductor industry. We have developed a specialized, tiered dataset
comprising small, medium, and large subsets and focused our efforts on
pretraining using the medium dataset. This approach harnesses the compact yet
efficient architecture of the Phi 1.5B model. The creation of this first
pretrained, hardware domain specific large language model marks a significant
advancement, offering improved performance in hardware design and verification
tasks and illustrating a promising path forward for AI applications in the
semiconductor sector. | [
-0.4564458429813385,
-0.8849747180938721,
0.28793784976005554,
0.1691162884235382,
-0.5482193231582642,
-0.15028008818626404,
0.23067161440849304,
-0.35252147912979126,
-0.057062383741140366,
0.37936583161354065,
-0.6842311024665833,
-0.33219367265701294,
-0.3639732599258423,
-0.3719111979007721,
-0.24534156918525696,
0.8614165782928467,
0.038844771683216095,
-0.09947948902845383,
0.26740458607673645,
0.21888281404972076,
-0.35849204659461975,
-0.8264641165733337,
-0.4151531457901001,
-0.40623390674591064,
0.33474597334861755,
0.05518687516450882,
0.40393564105033875,
0.5104172825813293,
0.9081248044967651,
0.22718915343284607,
0.23081183433532715,
-0.3901577293872833,
-0.2514735460281372,
-0.1622408628463745,
-0.2121523916721344,
-0.1303556263446808,
-0.993648886680603,
-0.0442538745701313,
0.510534405708313,
0.8349814414978027,
-0.055545005947351456,
0.5616676807403564,
-0.30148184299468994,
0.5681846141815186,
-0.4555306136608124,
0.19323959946632385,
-0.6611844301223755,
0.10297830402851105,
-0.801191508769989,
-0.22598721086978912,
-0.6751169562339783,
-0.22278735041618347,
0.08505824953317642,
-0.7645495533943176,
0.08829103410243988,
0.2277342677116394,
0.793218195438385,
0.26387643814086914,
-0.2866968512535095,
-0.0017619553254917264,
-0.9036864638328552,
0.7366613745689392,
-0.5342098474502563,
0.8644869923591614,
0.3486988842487335,
0.38590219616889954,
-0.019815431907773018,
-0.9629546403884888,
-0.4986465871334076,
-0.09588443487882614,
0.5213472843170166,
-0.4282159209251404,
-0.19778047502040863,
0.07883965224027634,
0.29793182015419006,
0.6514318585395813,
-0.6564432382583618,
0.3210790455341339,
-0.6994495987892151,
-0.28786927461624146,
0.2775481045246124,
-0.1744554191827774,
0.4622727632522583,
0.29260876774787903,
-0.2181466817855835,
0.05486060306429863,
-1.1522022485733032,
-0.17305229604244232,
0.18069276213645935,
0.48354512453079224,
-0.10273398458957672,
0.21681733429431915,
-0.22204793989658356,
0.7408666014671326,
-0.06006620079278946,
-0.19438476860523224,
0.1999783217906952,
-0.14182890951633453,
-0.5903117656707764,
0.344308465719223,
0.4402492046356201,
-0.21976985037326813,
0.11087745428085327,
-0.2300613820552826,
-0.21458332240581512,
0.27052250504493713,
0.40622955560684204,
-1.0075416564941406,
-0.42952826619148254,
0.1963544338941574,
-0.5789459943771362,
-0.31674090027809143,
-0.006310268305242062,
-0.5373013019561768,
-0.3959113359451294,
-0.29622575640678406,
0.31274598836898804,
-0.27820104360580444,
-0.3926447033882141,
0.3054735064506531,
0.09101779013872147,
0.5756726264953613,
-0.06569040566682816,
-1.1337703466415405,
0.26858389377593994,
0.9382066130638123,
0.45160186290740967,
0.03904961422085762,
-0.10168614238500595,
-0.39471691846847534,
0.30397650599479675,
-0.5430766344070435,
0.2523792088031769,
-0.42931678891181946,
-0.2996663451194763,
-0.16001242399215698,
-0.05549538508057594,
0.5249505639076233,
-0.4445382356643677,
0.4741724133491516,
-1.2314040660858154,
-0.20523357391357422,
-0.41691023111343384,
-0.4628789722919464,
-0.06253986805677414,
0.1689133495092392,
-0.6903347969055176,
0.5929176807403564,
0.3318024277687073,
-0.7622151374816895,
0.6024833917617798,
-0.48559805750846863,
-0.748383641242981,
0.2584906220436096,
-0.3894183039665222,
-0.4906865656375885,
0.1475232094526291,
0.022390572354197502,
0.12325894087553024,
-0.677386462688446,
0.2256324291229248,
-0.7703438997268677,
-0.43635571002960205,
0.12508909404277802,
-0.27102357149124146,
0.9555894136428833,
0.16535340249538422,
-0.5665674209594727,
-0.029660725966095924,
-0.9213671088218689,
-0.06814693659543991,
-0.10474523156881332,
-0.07097690552473068,
-0.25727739930152893,
-0.4112372398376465,
0.0257624089717865,
0.2908129394054413,
0.4206630289554596,
-0.9431132078170776,
0.05957411974668503,
-0.3073546290397644,
0.49047940969467163,
1.0220115184783936,
-0.15687346458435059,
0.47642606496810913,
0.11392661929130554,
0.6617083549499512,
0.15874379873275757,
0.25293874740600586,
-0.3459725081920624,
-0.3323674201965332,
-0.44919082522392273,
-0.28181254863739014,
0.7626059055328369,
0.5317520499229431,
-0.5556068420410156,
0.39530307054519653,
-0.1975177824497223,
-0.44564875960350037,
-0.33469828963279724,
0.08996054530143738,
0.4085378348827362,
0.6626319885253906,
0.2715916931629181,
-0.37964320182800293,
-0.5872422456741333,
-1.1477067470550537,
0.35706010460853577,
-0.10565726459026337,
-0.15964964032173157,
0.1312146782875061,
0.26381680369377136,
-0.2708732485771179,
0.6880297064781189,
-0.5041634440422058,
-0.1730998009443283,
-0.252302348613739,
-0.07664734125137329,
0.1579962968826294,
1.0145630836486816,
0.42318490147590637,
-0.5415263175964355,
-0.05734103545546532,
0.27673351764678955,
-1.0542302131652832,
0.31937456130981445,
0.13048723340034485,
-0.2081136405467987,
-0.01768770068883896,
0.690861701965332,
-0.729361891746521,
0.3896040618419647,
0.2943284213542938,
-0.053922053426504135,
0.510628342628479,
-0.29328596591949463,
0.05294852703809738,
-0.9016326665878296,
0.2782474756240845,
0.038213204592466354,
0.04332183301448822,
-0.5314891934394836,
0.18887130916118622,
0.1131727322936058,
-0.7082489132881165,
-0.4878008961677551,
0.8014410734176636,
-0.2507374882698059,
-0.4477919340133667,
-0.14853955805301666,
-0.2283061295747757,
-0.2115764021873474,
0.557602047920227,
-0.055491939187049866,
0.9390880465507507,
0.9862112998962402,
-1.1724135875701904,
0.5051165819168091,
0.09352840483188629,
-0.6852943897247314,
0.5153078436851501,
-1.1263213157653809,
0.16465981304645538,
0.040959831327199936,
0.0957004502415657,
-0.39832809567451477,
-0.12569394707679749,
0.025038117542862892,
-0.1682300716638565,
0.449067622423172,
0.08814611285924911,
-0.5111644268035889,
-0.5673395395278931,
0.2376822978258133,
0.9368934035301208,
0.7263007760047913,
-0.43470004200935364,
0.6019729375839233,
0.8601297736167908,
-0.4475916922092438,
-0.29103386402130127,
-0.8181232213973999,
-0.32046711444854736,
-0.04679349064826965,
-0.7974270582199097,
0.4951266646385193,
0.03341498225927353,
-0.2812943756580353,
-0.4814385175704956,
-0.20532262325286865,
-0.5393312573432922,
0.2297302931547165,
0.07997573167085648,
0.5197493433952332,
-0.740390419960022,
0.3774978220462799,
0.10954973101615906,
-0.5050668716430664,
0.10734650492668152,
-0.8012126684188843,
0.5637155175209045,
-0.05570528283715248,
-0.5800497531890869,
-0.7964654564857483,
0.16374988853931427,
0.6187851428985596,
-0.5876078605651855,
0.39457592368125916,
0.44057416915893555,
-0.5757972598075867,
-0.4165148437023163,
-0.24146299064159393,
-0.39457032084465027,
-0.6153828501701355,
0.6684421300888062,
-0.8882731199264526,
-0.603596568107605,
0.40105918049812317,
-0.3328011631965637,
0.19623969495296478,
0.09702396392822266,
0.24094676971435547,
0.05020073801279068,
0.8715286254882812,
1.0593576431274414,
-0.44382244348526,
0.3419981896877289,
0.05205749720335007,
0.7106417417526245,
-0.6478247046470642,
-0.038551829755306244,
-0.4489998519420624,
-0.4172714650630951,
-0.40404966473579407,
-0.14782674610614777,
0.2346728891134262,
-0.2729898691177368,
-0.8894813060760498,
0.12598422169685364,
-0.3544735014438629,
0.4379279911518097,
0.6311599016189575,
0.38099440932273865,
0.0151104386895895,
0.23143304884433746,
0.09585852921009064,
-0.10153171420097351,
-0.6886781454086304,
-0.44469544291496277,
1.2417470216751099,
0.622394859790802,
0.828647792339325,
-0.007318011950701475,
0.21394111216068268,
0.35512790083885193,
0.0368896909058094,
-0.37916433811187744,
0.5691033601760864,
-0.4088588058948517,
-0.8513222932815552,
-0.3137844502925873,
-0.45058220624923706,
-0.6956189870834351,
-0.5308125615119934,
0.4815760552883148,
-0.5111805200576782,
0.2349659651517868,
0.22466813027858734,
-0.6529398560523987,
0.388772189617157,
-0.4992983639240265,
1.2368806600570679,
-0.3096136152744293,
-0.17634353041648865,
-0.26356449723243713,
-0.32251793146133423,
0.6361924409866333,
-0.291688472032547,
0.1418493688106537,
0.0798954963684082,
0.26645582914352417,
0.7216895222663879,
-0.49910709261894226,
0.5031335353851318,
-0.14690567553043365,
-0.29394492506980896,
0.19232793152332306,
0.11314061284065247,
0.32210272550582886,
-0.022546127438545227,
-0.4435277581214905,
-0.0950230285525322,
-0.32596296072006226,
-0.6952874064445496,
-0.31605374813079834,
0.5886187553405762,
-0.6964896321296692,
-0.3291000723838806,
-0.22323527932167053,
-0.3708743453025818,
-0.6282181143760681,
0.37910425662994385,
0.4262154698371887,
0.947482168674469,
-0.3474794328212738,
0.34795618057250977,
1.5207985639572144,
-0.5042226314544678,
0.1955377459526062,
0.3022862374782562,
-0.38155272603034973,
0.04362421855330467,
1.2275536060333252,
-0.14705370366573334,
0.058035168796777725,
0.290714293718338,
-0.2521418333053589,
-0.1487054079771042,
-0.4391210079193115,
-0.705903172492981,
0.057215794920921326,
-0.6673094034194946,
-0.12208402156829834,
-0.29152899980545044,
-0.4034711718559265,
-0.532984733581543,
-0.22950318455696106,
-0.6673390865325928,
-0.3395991027355194,
-0.1942693144083023,
-0.18895100057125092,
0.0452788881957531,
0.6280179619789124,
0.3257302939891815,
0.5430686473846436,
-0.615557074546814,
0.6278047561645508,
0.6960762739181519,
0.9673007726669312,
-0.051014285534620285,
-0.8470812439918518,
-0.1579633355140686,
-0.04387752339243889,
-0.19435454905033112,
-0.7632992267608643,
0.012464741244912148,
0.07270749658346176,
0.7032425403594971,
0.5208742618560791,
-0.07371383160352707,
0.2956610321998596,
-0.3585403561592102,
0.6483812928199768,
0.17226417362689972,
-1.1185790300369263,
0.822762668132782,
-0.4494561553001404,
0.4276501536369324,
0.44514667987823486,
0.39900633692741394,
-0.10613057762384415,
0.25356972217559814,
-0.5555393695831299,
-0.515846848487854,
0.7086643576622009,
-0.17336919903755188,
0.22369931638240814,
0.38609957695007324,
0.3263646066188812,
0.12017456442117691,
0.38891157507896423,
-0.7314768433570862,
-0.22674573957920074,
-0.1822984218597412,
-0.26086854934692383,
0.31687843799591064,
-0.1463688611984253,
-0.01695100963115692,
-0.2581917643547058,
1.151400089263916,
0.23876507580280304,
0.34030681848526,
-0.2832556962966919,
-0.24129272997379303,
0.17061714828014374,
0.09471749514341354,
0.48887020349502563,
1.0141875743865967,
-0.07955323904752731,
-0.0669722929596901,
-0.16523084044456482,
-0.5972627997398376,
0.19301143288612366,
0.21750791370868683,
-0.48411065340042114,
0.0023741424083709717,
-0.01459316723048687,
0.9209476113319397,
0.2959132790565491,
-0.4513052701950073,
0.23796063661575317,
-0.03581412136554718,
0.016764696687459946,
-0.08189691603183746,
-0.16179588437080383,
-0.2312757521867752,
-0.08750519901514053,
0.3220924735069275,
-0.31797727942466736,
0.09211638569831848,
-0.824263334274292,
0.5594151020050049,
0.4442238509654999,
-0.35616201162338257,
-0.4562271237373352,
0.705498218536377,
0.2996600270271301,
-0.28376418352127075,
0.9987737536430359,
-0.6021115779876709,
-0.4826601445674896,
0.807662844657898,
0.5463701486587524,
0.7857334017753601,
-0.44284987449645996,
0.1465807557106018,
0.4427732527256012,
0.589714527130127,
0.26380932331085205,
0.3706222176551819,
0.014923588372766972,
-0.36926624178886414,
-0.04081415757536888,
-0.9112825989723206,
-0.2570808231830597,
0.25293946266174316,
-0.2527123987674713,
0.5695958733558655,
-1.1935094594955444,
-0.2301173359155655,
0.11211015284061432,
-0.0527460016310215,
-0.685815155506134,
0.5541072487831116,
0.21282611787319183,
0.9240557551383972,
-0.49423742294311523,
1.274179220199585,
0.49041855335235596,
-0.5774506330490112,
-0.971932590007782,
-0.4447009861469269,
-0.3347964584827423,
-0.6117371320724487,
0.9531555771827698,
-0.07895538955926895,
0.21623042225837708,
0.074496328830719,
-0.2584080696105957,
-0.8840255737304688,
0.9169015288352966,
0.48551568388938904,
-0.5327559113502502,
-0.07635888457298279,
0.258084237575531,
0.14712075889110565,
-0.39441725611686707,
-0.08839444816112518,
0.5659100413322449,
0.2535874545574188,
0.0748189240694046,
-0.9979209899902344,
-0.004478751681745052,
-0.4128437340259552,
0.005362735129892826,
0.19959400594234467,
-0.5149053335189819,
1.1340796947479248,
0.06179444491863251,
0.04735496640205383,
-0.29300957918167114,
1.0486080646514893,
0.5278018712997437,
0.15177273750305176,
0.15732502937316895,
0.3863271474838257,
1.0086475610733032,
-0.08483999222517014,
0.9251874685287476,
-0.8126876354217529,
-0.2561221420764923,
1.2637220621109009,
-0.5050114989280701,
0.686939001083374,
0.04683801904320717,
-0.3419207036495209,
0.5303494930267334,
0.6948478817939758,
0.01895664632320404,
0.40710967779159546,
0.3148287832736969,
-0.4862237274646759,
-0.31790587306022644,
0.24396555125713348,
-1.0210795402526855,
0.3397167921066284,
0.376316636800766,
-0.36406704783439636,
0.11316187679767609,
0.22364448010921478,
-0.2782216966152191,
-0.5034787058830261,
-0.5747793912887573,
0.5034595727920532,
0.1401902735233307,
-0.4034634232521057,
0.17158707976341248,
0.3076907694339752,
0.5073026418685913,
-0.7526006102561951,
0.2425578087568283,
-0.2047773152589798,
0.4246419668197632,
0.05374670401215553,
-0.24762962758541107,
0.30781444907188416,
-0.12432513386011124,
-0.3875676989555359,
-0.09533298760652542,
0.831408679485321,
-0.015424606390297413,
-0.8282942771911621,
-0.2770386338233948,
-0.01850789412856102,
0.014447079971432686,
-0.20911476016044617,
-0.4530361294746399,
0.5138877630233765,
-0.24390074610710144,
0.1323457807302475,
0.4485289454460144,
0.6074531674385071,
0.015069781802594662,
0.7650210857391357,
0.5371673703193665,
0.0655110776424408,
0.42668116092681885,
-0.020352093502879143,
0.859859049320221,
-0.47618168592453003,
-0.8909438252449036,
-0.46206215023994446,
0.3113884925842285,
-0.03764484077692032,
-0.46026697754859924,
0.6296216249465942,
0.6795333623886108,
0.6555396914482117,
-0.10056750476360321,
0.9386485815048218,
0.10779105126857758,
0.3121579885482788,
-0.22735171020030975,
0.7822753190994263,
-0.1467684805393219,
0.6497273445129395,
-0.25640183687210083,
-0.7916614413261414,
0.18408873677253723,
0.7037681341171265,
-0.3051702678203583,
0.24311666190624237,
0.544677734375,
0.6883705854415894,
-0.5828731656074524,
0.34972867369651794,
0.12194462865591049,
0.25703537464141846,
0.28735536336898804,
0.5594218373298645,
0.06725490093231201,
-0.8224540948867798,
0.3531266152858734,
-0.26901084184646606,
-0.5453794598579407,
0.10859328508377075,
-0.7235898375511169,
-0.5767196416854858,
-0.5354854464530945,
-0.4490610361099243,
-0.1335109919309616,
0.018000977113842964,
0.651221513748169,
1.1046310663223267,
-0.8525253534317017,
-0.2995139956474304,
-0.4291773736476898,
0.0849817544221878,
0.006174210924655199,
-0.11569780856370926,
0.1540529429912567,
-0.37993675470352173,
-0.16969890892505646,
0.2681412100791931,
0.3965213894844055,
0.08736364543437958,
-0.6998570561408997,
-0.07123793661594391,
0.018590068444609642,
0.28829169273376465,
0.766908586025238,
0.5751419067382812,
-0.37994420528411865,
0.32834407687187195,
0.16713936626911163,
-0.16763831675052643,
-0.15432892739772797,
0.9590033888816833,
-0.8476969599723816,
0.21690866351127625,
0.442935049533844,
1.0675525665283203,
0.4372952878475189,
-0.3512989282608032,
0.9486201405525208,
-0.5424039959907532,
0.42630186676979065,
0.12941865622997284,
0.3832111656665802,
0.2441599816083908,
-0.20581145584583282,
0.08061502128839493,
0.23461446166038513,
-0.5364177823066711,
-1.0069594383239746,
0.5515357851982117,
-0.8287010788917542,
-0.3634531795978546,
0.7880731225013733,
-0.28745609521865845,
-0.37747493386268616,
-0.1797233521938324,
0.1991913914680481,
0.20821097493171692,
0.04244391247630119,
0.901256263256073,
0.6480309367179871,
0.3089354336261749,
-0.09977234899997711,
-0.30864331126213074,
0.6386541724205017,
0.3863186836242676,
-1.0847535133361816,
0.2481629103422165,
0.32238245010375977,
-0.020511111244559288,
0.054251521825790405,
1.0033401250839233,
-0.07552320510149002,
0.6927804350852966,
0.46488526463508606,
-0.03494154289364815,
0.000794652325566858,
-0.626227617263794,
-0.12010134011507034,
0.6314120292663574,
0.06395231187343597,
-0.15607525408267975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15509v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15509v1 | Style-News: Incorporating Stylized News Generation and Adversarial Verification for Neural Fake News Detection | 2024-01-27T21:35:29 | 2024-01-27T21:35:29 | Wei-Yao Wang, Yu-Chieh Chang, Wen-Chih Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI | With the improvements in generative models, the issues of producing
hallucinations in various domains (e.g., law, writing) have been brought to
people's attention due to concerns about misinformation. In this paper, we
focus on neural fake news, which refers to content generated by neural networks
aiming to mimic the style of real news to deceive people. To prevent harmful
disinformation spreading fallaciously from malicious social media (e.g.,
content farms), we propose a novel verification framework, Style-News, using
publisher metadata to imply a publisher's template with the corresponding text
types, political stance, and credibility. Based on threat modeling aspects, a
style-aware neural news generator is introduced as an adversary for generating
news content conditioning for a specific publisher, and style and source
discriminators are trained to defend against this attack by identifying which
publisher the style corresponds with, and discriminating whether the source of
the given news is human-written or machine-generated. To evaluate the quality
of the generated content, we integrate various dimensional metrics (language
fluency, content preservation, and style adherence) and demonstrate that
Style-News significantly outperforms the previous approaches by a margin of
0.35 for fluency, 15.24 for content, and 0.38 for style at most. Moreover, our
discriminative model outperforms state-of-the-art baselines in terms of
publisher prediction (up to 4.64%) and neural fake news detection (+6.94%
$\sim$ 31.72%). | [
-0.11515527218580246,
-0.9485496282577515,
0.3736346364021301,
0.3400459587574005,
-0.4546820819377899,
0.16019980609416962,
-0.33092746138572693,
-0.21825729310512543,
0.5673159956932068,
0.32614701986312866,
-0.3862013518810272,
-0.712365984916687,
-0.6342151165008545,
-0.036217477172613144,
-0.7111417651176453,
1.0089846849441528,
0.3625565767288208,
0.08460640907287598,
-0.06653279811143875,
0.1739426702260971,
-0.26487967371940613,
-0.4922805428504944,
-0.5648736357688904,
-0.189048632979393,
0.5514572858810425,
-0.2765544652938843,
0.7349826693534851,
0.6235715746879578,
0.21891845762729645,
0.28148353099823,
0.07759689539670944,
0.5801857113838196,
-0.36504748463630676,
0.10968057066202164,
-0.09931591898202896,
-0.2982945740222931,
-0.31429731845855713,
0.19926244020462036,
0.2808026671409607,
0.054861847311258316,
-0.11344131827354431,
0.0678059309720993,
-0.1660759001970291,
0.7756810784339905,
-0.6709592938423157,
-0.2865973711013794,
-0.8734071850776672,
0.15416446328163147,
-0.15749794244766235,
-0.5080536603927612,
-0.6859238743782043,
-0.6239299774169922,
-0.3094128966331482,
-0.512535572052002,
0.3120020925998688,
0.15964098274707794,
1.2261770963668823,
0.2207941710948944,
-0.5786283016204834,
-0.42441266775131226,
-0.7710008025169373,
0.31647852063179016,
-0.4920580983161926,
0.4175063669681549,
0.3587554395198822,
0.3836804926395416,
-0.22493667900562286,
-0.7191467881202698,
-0.870719313621521,
-0.23088932037353516,
0.09777481108903885,
0.21294835209846497,
-0.5625396966934204,
-0.42543724179267883,
-0.09391646087169647,
0.09285950660705566,
-0.8279556035995483,
-0.12609612941741943,
-0.4375431537628174,
-0.4501860737800598,
0.6481233239173889,
-0.3567245602607727,
0.4519282281398773,
-0.4275878071784973,
-0.4417632222175598,
-0.01854197308421135,
-0.8164315223693848,
-0.3862936794757843,
1.0966415405273438,
0.17654702067375183,
0.07890225946903229,
0.06664548069238663,
-0.19779974222183228,
0.5982297658920288,
0.2456924468278885,
-0.036771759390830994,
0.20724119246006012,
-0.29018130898475647,
-0.161681666970253,
0.4474523961544037,
0.903221070766449,
0.673814058303833,
0.12781012058258057,
-0.327176034450531,
-0.38110142946243286,
0.30290403962135315,
0.9541944861412048,
-0.49357303977012634,
-0.19871559739112854,
-0.07240698486566544,
-0.6950668692588806,
-0.871806263923645,
0.030783625319600105,
-0.8079826831817627,
-0.6954241991043091,
-0.3610333800315857,
0.7487291693687439,
-0.4960906207561493,
-0.5582574605941772,
0.19915355741977692,
-0.2510020136833191,
-0.12787652015686035,
0.3293530344963074,
-0.4565349519252777,
-0.05810727924108505,
0.6236896514892578,
0.81500643491745,
-0.08091091364622116,
0.00610320083796978,
-0.3106297552585602,
-0.32714229822158813,
-0.8352274894714355,
0.5664590001106262,
0.14443561434745789,
0.25904765725135803,
0.16865015029907227,
-0.17538896203041077,
0.35161691904067993,
-0.3631579577922821,
0.22415600717067719,
-1.0021668672561646,
0.04610297083854675,
-0.2823726236820221,
-0.2873503267765045,
-0.14378927648067474,
0.7001582980155945,
-0.8681860566139221,
0.7493520975112915,
0.24259595572948456,
-0.6952679753303528,
0.5356177091598511,
-0.07272452116012573,
-0.5883797407150269,
-0.02903686836361885,
0.027310213074088097,
-0.5341579914093018,
0.09992331266403198,
0.09789498150348663,
0.18735042214393616,
0.23381267488002777,
0.47887834906578064,
-0.07115812599658966,
-0.342578262090683,
0.5032680034637451,
-0.6152764558792114,
0.7248296141624451,
0.4381681978702545,
-0.466327965259552,
0.18879304826259613,
-0.9516579508781433,
-0.22254669666290283,
0.29657864570617676,
-0.18932002782821655,
-0.4442380964756012,
-0.16432887315750122,
0.07522318512201309,
0.3547076880931854,
0.11398414522409439,
-0.5207962989807129,
0.10495566576719284,
-0.05997622758150101,
0.6015598177909851,
0.6754821538925171,
0.18019990622997284,
0.3430229723453522,
-0.5322902798652649,
0.21890060603618622,
0.25930625200271606,
0.24587881565093994,
-0.07631649821996689,
-0.15187902748584747,
-0.6690384149551392,
0.11512065678834915,
0.5775988101959229,
0.33933931589126587,
-1.1300784349441528,
0.4541621506214142,
-0.13533556461334229,
-0.5134950876235962,
-0.31515219807624817,
-0.1375211775302887,
0.27767708897590637,
0.35469937324523926,
0.3483562767505646,
0.10267774015665054,
-0.8119012713432312,
-0.7955768704414368,
-0.5003594756126404,
-0.11553874611854553,
0.14966259896755219,
-0.29982849955558777,
0.3554792106151581,
0.06633968651294708,
0.6785513162612915,
-0.09175644814968109,
0.052686188369989395,
-0.1676887720823288,
0.2399221509695053,
0.05936489626765251,
0.3903258740901947,
0.7372997403144836,
-1.2181761264801025,
-0.22176727652549744,
-0.33460018038749695,
-0.6707022786140442,
0.12345924228429794,
-0.4726068079471588,
-0.09259571880102158,
0.41979649662971497,
0.5652032494544983,
-0.5986704230308533,
0.6040306687355042,
0.5336424112319946,
-0.4644795060157776,
0.7710475325584412,
-0.06162025406956673,
0.23758527636528015,
-1.1806671619415283,
-0.2626354396343231,
0.34480205178260803,
-0.4763735830783844,
-0.6509431600570679,
0.05605728179216385,
-0.04138651117682457,
-0.057851530611515045,
-0.40245142579078674,
0.37509647011756897,
-0.15625008940696716,
0.18482820689678192,
-0.34952905774116516,
0.05658244714140892,
0.43021664023399353,
0.25381404161453247,
-0.05457521229982376,
0.5975069403648376,
0.2297435700893402,
-0.5277943015098572,
0.5361610054969788,
-0.31279703974723816,
-0.6017150282859802,
0.5286328792572021,
-0.6547988653182983,
0.16160254180431366,
-0.35675811767578125,
0.5348790287971497,
-0.901934027671814,
-0.08678076416254044,
0.44160112738609314,
-0.7479071021080017,
0.3130964934825897,
-0.0014255469432100654,
-1.0081120729446411,
-0.3541187345981598,
-0.05522143840789795,
-0.1155611127614975,
0.4925224184989929,
-0.6067994236946106,
0.5658033490180969,
-0.06529216468334198,
0.40213221311569214,
-0.6070072054862976,
-0.7946550846099854,
0.3647489845752716,
-0.026245569810271263,
-0.6938560605049133,
0.6052071452140808,
0.18074317276477814,
-0.4073106646537781,
0.2640778124332428,
-0.22957593202590942,
0.058619700372219086,
0.04968971386551857,
0.03567741811275482,
0.2464137077331543,
-0.2542768120765686,
0.12936127185821533,
-0.009954681620001793,
0.31338363885879517,
0.26668834686279297,
-0.5103514790534973,
0.6145026087760925,
-0.10327525436878204,
-0.27523073554039,
-0.5796319246292114,
0.17816515266895294,
0.5868701934814453,
-0.20026732981204987,
0.8192383646965027,
0.8892067074775696,
-0.6286710500717163,
-0.7301244139671326,
-0.6169795393943787,
-0.4384758174419403,
-0.45037633180618286,
0.3340722322463989,
0.1440333127975464,
-0.2090356945991516,
0.31823936104774475,
0.2295169085264206,
-0.2898799479007721,
0.4349043369293213,
0.4341953694820404,
0.33238503336906433,
1.0066444873809814,
0.3329659402370453,
0.06906738132238388,
0.3935071527957916,
-0.3366400897502899,
0.18604810535907745,
-0.09335938841104507,
-0.4721108078956604,
-0.16815537214279175,
-0.6614338755607605,
-0.4873500168323517,
-0.05770690739154816,
0.07548011839389801,
-0.0638580396771431,
-0.13329432904720306,
0.5214901566505432,
-0.8004860281944275,
0.42870432138442993,
0.9331103563308716,
0.3079546391963959,
0.23342213034629822,
0.14554394781589508,
0.17556923627853394,
0.03026038594543934,
-0.4175823926925659,
-0.4424440264701843,
1.0388925075531006,
0.34261077642440796,
0.5875701308250427,
0.06969797611236572,
0.6674790978431702,
0.8268772959709167,
0.26217782497406006,
-0.7702395915985107,
0.307643860578537,
-0.236448273062706,
-0.4938489496707916,
0.24709481000900269,
-0.4690539538860321,
-0.25861233472824097,
0.13987797498703003,
-0.28515857458114624,
-0.4288213551044464,
0.34510812163352966,
0.013341538608074188,
-0.5744813680648804,
0.5714433193206787,
-0.37280356884002686,
0.4025719463825226,
-0.21846577525138855,
-0.17227521538734436,
-0.11177082359790802,
-0.3812796473503113,
0.34581708908081055,
-0.08054711669683456,
0.05937429144978523,
0.11412646621465683,
0.19817598164081573,
0.40466248989105225,
-0.16143053770065308,
0.8333075642585754,
-0.015801718458533287,
-0.03999759256839752,
0.3476729989051819,
0.2663115859031677,
0.42516088485717773,
0.22498251497745514,
-0.08394035696983337,
0.30216482281684875,
-0.2507043480873108,
-0.037686560302972794,
-0.6587726473808289,
0.6752795577049255,
-0.6928704977035522,
-0.4477415978908539,
-0.6279558539390564,
-0.5941981673240662,
0.1356085240840912,
0.25307831168174744,
0.8000200390815735,
0.49274367094039917,
-0.20415803790092468,
0.4375345706939697,
0.6614550352096558,
-0.043420419096946716,
0.41155296564102173,
0.4714301526546478,
-0.24157124757766724,
-0.5659117698669434,
1.3213752508163452,
0.2847406268119812,
0.030368881300091743,
0.03671901673078537,
0.18541176617145538,
-0.3057611882686615,
-0.6344442963600159,
-0.6078901290893555,
-0.26356011629104614,
-0.575705885887146,
-0.3920770287513733,
-0.4757281541824341,
-0.6193933486938477,
-0.569053590297699,
-0.2006852924823761,
-0.3968048393726349,
-0.2663240134716034,
-0.443631649017334,
0.15980665385723114,
0.09242691099643707,
0.7985444068908691,
-0.06761302798986435,
0.2825400233268738,
-0.47142478823661804,
0.42165258526802063,
0.17015962302684784,
0.01817222684621811,
-0.24720501899719238,
-0.4851723909378052,
-0.0021915966644883156,
0.29226258397102356,
-0.6530144810676575,
-1.0147099494934082,
0.6413984894752502,
-0.20353080332279205,
0.27263763546943665,
0.5787047743797302,
0.3147416412830353,
-0.11072446405887604,
-0.42694592475891113,
0.8310049772262573,
0.1858191341161728,
-0.7584421038627625,
0.5527631640434265,
-0.518372118473053,
-0.11303701996803284,
0.343035489320755,
0.5279087424278259,
-0.5022484660148621,
-0.35511907935142517,
-0.835155189037323,
-0.4567655622959137,
0.28764808177948,
0.23394452035427094,
0.41177308559417725,
-0.2605401575565338,
0.49961093068122864,
-0.05098714679479599,
0.4646448493003845,
-0.8054201602935791,
-0.24881531298160553,
-0.9483475089073181,
-0.13907359540462494,
0.3936198651790619,
-0.18162184953689575,
-0.2156168669462204,
0.05351509153842926,
0.7571848034858704,
0.0449972040951252,
0.1601685732603073,
0.22080886363983154,
0.08095803111791611,
-0.003558839438483119,
0.13130693137645721,
0.9004812836647034,
0.7048049569129944,
-0.048758409917354584,
0.31393545866012573,
-0.5096597671508789,
-0.42670938372612,
0.11029738187789917,
-0.012307117693126202,
-0.6270431280136108,
0.5251660943031311,
0.23503240942955017,
0.7367473244667053,
-0.22299331426620483,
-0.09342280775308609,
0.8383104801177979,
-0.1483307033777237,
-0.4306357204914093,
-0.5409231781959534,
-0.01916320249438286,
-0.0010723904706537724,
0.16148486733436584,
0.5438113212585449,
0.6110600829124451,
0.16399653255939484,
-0.5297982096672058,
0.30902501940727234,
0.3498740494251251,
-0.4448263645172119,
-0.484915167093277,
0.6710652112960815,
-0.023903682827949524,
-0.40997275710105896,
0.5422914624214172,
-0.6245742440223694,
-0.6549717783927917,
1.0652414560317993,
0.9275974631309509,
0.6528868079185486,
-0.020213661715388298,
0.5997781157493591,
0.30553963780403137,
0.4644922614097595,
-0.30249881744384766,
0.20213523507118225,
0.45527923107147217,
-0.8943083882331848,
-0.09117454290390015,
-0.6970378160476685,
0.010345791466534138,
0.7199673652648926,
-0.575990617275238,
0.39168691635131836,
-0.751575767993927,
-0.41741764545440674,
0.2326209396123886,
0.023549586534500122,
-0.25104856491088867,
0.3280215561389923,
0.3754473030567169,
1.0026984214782715,
-0.729770839214325,
0.5758026242256165,
0.625624418258667,
-0.49089285731315613,
-0.4997612535953522,
0.43178796768188477,
0.5868018865585327,
-0.5494478344917297,
0.7811192274093628,
0.3312360942363739,
0.009220203384757042,
-0.012816838920116425,
-0.6785904169082642,
-0.43494969606399536,
0.7950087189674377,
0.6281654238700867,
-0.5365831851959229,
-0.27835744619369507,
-0.1251966655254364,
0.48899030685424805,
-0.3753126263618469,
-0.46380066871643066,
0.009735172614455223,
0.4391024708747864,
0.17846161127090454,
-0.2523190677165985,
0.16376513242721558,
-0.4427163600921631,
0.0037297760136425495,
-0.06544169038534164,
-0.6130558848381042,
1.0156080722808838,
0.0688297376036644,
-0.14055557548999786,
-0.07225142419338226,
0.9204954504966736,
-0.005474367178976536,
0.46208643913269043,
0.5105535387992859,
0.48595598340034485,
0.5941779613494873,
-0.23450103402137756,
1.0294733047485352,
-0.5529429316520691,
0.11853064596652985,
0.9345776438713074,
0.1921938806772232,
0.44483986496925354,
0.039368290454149246,
0.30897387862205505,
0.9499125480651855,
0.6455094814300537,
-0.431386798620224,
0.599379301071167,
0.42408236861228943,
-0.2718207538127899,
-0.3259844481945038,
-0.40792515873908997,
-0.5088692903518677,
0.7082852721214294,
0.22549793124198914,
-0.6984961628913879,
-0.1309785097837448,
0.017177945002913475,
0.3064223825931549,
0.5716537237167358,
-0.2647213637828827,
0.4631763994693756,
-0.032777514308691025,
-0.6436347365379333,
0.4029909074306488,
0.2727743685245514,
0.7730394005775452,
-0.6008285880088806,
-0.02580869384109974,
-0.06436887383460999,
0.1779932677745819,
-0.19574587047100067,
-0.36249855160713196,
0.379138708114624,
-0.33841386437416077,
-0.451232373714447,
-0.2165418416261673,
1.1044189929962158,
-0.5958775877952576,
-0.3840506970882416,
0.02639102376997471,
0.2619217336177826,
-0.4441981613636017,
-0.571791410446167,
-0.43927201628685,
0.24743469059467316,
-0.40160897374153137,
-0.21348373591899872,
0.2073781043291092,
0.3740888237953186,
0.08326531201601028,
0.2977161407470703,
0.8313774466514587,
0.40197160840034485,
-0.10838915407657623,
0.16859887540340424,
0.8063817620277405,
-0.1363610029220581,
-0.6748597025871277,
-1.0201499462127686,
0.039782121777534485,
-0.39081716537475586,
-0.3080675005912781,
0.7836260795593262,
0.389190673828125,
0.6991376280784607,
-0.06819447875022888,
0.6416730880737305,
0.05572783946990967,
-0.05352655053138733,
-0.5713316798210144,
1.6049647331237793,
-0.6772939562797546,
-0.06630756705999374,
-0.023905843496322632,
-0.6451473832130432,
-0.23894038796424866,
0.29123252630233765,
-0.21547256410121918,
0.11968758702278137,
0.6046906113624573,
0.9095447063446045,
-0.031229719519615173,
0.13395780324935913,
0.13364477455615997,
-0.08242972195148468,
0.040785085409879684,
0.10753117501735687,
0.8234810829162598,
-0.4530094563961029,
0.6061497926712036,
-0.597843587398529,
0.1699225902557373,
-0.3791416585445404,
-1.1547788381576538,
-0.9566465616226196,
-0.7245375514030457,
-0.4028523564338684,
-1.1117947101593018,
0.3578220009803772,
0.7939208745956421,
1.0999072790145874,
-0.6377058029174805,
0.46017956733703613,
-0.1450747400522232,
0.16290749609470367,
-0.4393883943557739,
-0.31479209661483765,
0.4016350507736206,
-0.23685972392559052,
-0.5028684139251709,
0.48440733551979065,
0.04400434345006943,
0.06495893001556396,
-0.6932851076126099,
0.15414604544639587,
-0.14476092159748077,
0.34898415207862854,
0.4544459283351898,
0.008433706127107143,
-0.7871555089950562,
-0.2291659116744995,
0.12266766279935837,
-0.4278357923030853,
-0.17360220849514008,
0.7894424200057983,
-0.654835045337677,
0.27858009934425354,
0.5816888809204102,
0.6159760355949402,
-0.12163639813661575,
0.10745083540678024,
0.44113826751708984,
-1.207717776298523,
0.07291480153799057,
0.1636326014995575,
0.2393253594636917,
0.49376970529556274,
-1.0419442653656006,
0.05621521174907684,
0.6340985894203186,
-0.22232064604759216,
-0.761387050151825,
0.18665361404418945,
-0.5638857483863831,
-0.3940891921520233,
1.204888939857483,
0.0893990769982338,
-0.5760339498519897,
0.056062884628772736,
0.08562402427196503,
0.3777308464050293,
-0.4068511128425598,
1.0667051076889038,
0.5769216418266296,
0.5293992161750793,
0.055851951241493225,
-0.5821834802627563,
0.7620877623558044,
-0.1371663510799408,
-0.674675703048706,
-0.273981511592865,
0.473116934299469,
0.36563926935195923,
0.6591024398803711,
0.4113233685493469,
-0.1494232714176178,
0.552198588848114,
0.36684146523475647,
-0.06395524740219116,
-0.73433917760849,
-0.7914974689483643,
-0.04338445886969566,
0.2952800393104553,
-0.6262123584747314,
-0.14957793056964874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15499v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15499v1 | Semantic Properties of cosine based bias scores for word embeddings | 2024-01-27T20:31:10 | 2024-01-27T20:31:10 | Sarah Schröder, Alexander Schulz, Fabian Hinder, Barbara Hammer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Plenty of works have brought social biases in language models to attention
and proposed methods to detect such biases. As a result, the literature
contains a great deal of different bias tests and scores, each introduced with
the premise to uncover yet more biases that other scores fail to detect. What
severely lacks in the literature, however, are comparative studies that analyse
such bias scores and help researchers to understand the benefits or limitations
of the existing methods. In this work, we aim to close this gap for cosine
based bias scores. By building on a geometric definition of bias, we propose
requirements for bias scores to be considered meaningful for quantifying
biases. Furthermore, we formally analyze cosine based scores from the
literature with regard to these requirements. We underline these findings with
experiments to show that the bias scores' limitations have an impact in the
application case. | [
-0.9172025918960571,
-1.0246431827545166,
0.619507372379303,
0.2950856685638428,
-0.12406477332115173,
-0.3014812469482422,
-0.23429495096206665,
-0.6392756700515747,
0.6257570385932922,
0.3002089262008667,
-0.4081566631793976,
-0.8758510947227478,
-0.8655463457107544,
0.023998646065592766,
-0.4602351188659668,
0.8219090700149536,
-0.14489474892616272,
0.28510886430740356,
-0.5398405194282532,
-0.5881802439689636,
-0.6775431036949158,
-0.4214622974395752,
0.005980719346553087,
-0.05141061544418335,
0.3320387899875641,
0.4063955247402191,
0.9746164679527283,
0.38626569509506226,
0.47584083676338196,
0.1925203651189804,
-0.10618908703327179,
-0.35787269473075867,
-0.46792054176330566,
0.10877233743667603,
-0.28691935539245605,
-0.4418324828147888,
-0.2687424123287201,
0.6182321906089783,
0.17698776721954346,
0.9984523057937622,
0.24881091713905334,
0.2761049270629883,
0.2756827473640442,
0.4081127643585205,
-0.686801552772522,
0.3568592369556427,
-0.5102581977844238,
0.2962421774864197,
-0.1709539145231247,
-0.164997860789299,
-0.24054598808288574,
-0.9109705090522766,
0.5099341869354248,
-0.7306588292121887,
0.45419925451278687,
0.26038479804992676,
0.9469699263572693,
0.09688334167003632,
-0.35018712282180786,
-0.7457258105278015,
-0.168147474527359,
1.1684993505477905,
-0.49153655767440796,
0.5325954556465149,
0.3440544605255127,
0.2789852023124695,
-0.00461375480517745,
-0.06991823017597198,
-0.38725852966308594,
-0.3478408455848694,
-0.10507211834192276,
-0.1797313243150711,
0.23115946352481842,
-0.00436130678281188,
0.4790028929710388,
0.5680158138275146,
-0.40900811553001404,
-0.28153812885284424,
-0.034743472933769226,
-0.41396984457969666,
0.566153883934021,
0.07237859815359116,
0.5886915326118469,
-0.35430020093917847,
-0.2094123363494873,
-0.34435558319091797,
-0.6692379713058472,
0.02787201851606369,
0.6782093644142151,
0.015589377842843533,
-0.23507393896579742,
0.8775293827056885,
-0.37725383043289185,
0.2504715621471405,
0.09972070157527924,
0.2979179918766022,
0.14535436034202576,
-0.19426770508289337,
0.05298236012458801,
0.06037026643753052,
0.5701112747192383,
0.632247805595398,
0.49450796842575073,
-0.2143569141626358,
0.14970140159130096,
0.5384895205497742,
0.11551499366760254,
-0.5077749490737915,
-0.028342178091406822,
-0.04855867847800255,
-0.2639896273612976,
-0.15251827239990234,
0.031005972996354103,
-0.9355025291442871,
-0.35768088698387146,
-0.3074339032173157,
0.340595543384552,
-0.4088437259197235,
-0.2009851336479187,
0.1401463896036148,
-0.6492122411727905,
0.5009680986404419,
0.11492790281772614,
-0.48798754811286926,
0.4778553545475006,
0.7980694770812988,
0.6284877061843872,
-0.06159951537847519,
0.002264041919261217,
-0.12356319278478622,
-0.40248483419418335,
-0.45646145939826965,
0.5838701725006104,
-0.8223220109939575,
-0.33980539441108704,
0.3711133599281311,
-0.13983674347400665,
0.32951459288597107,
-0.4551090896129608,
0.799275279045105,
-0.46727943420410156,
0.48025262355804443,
-0.9980679154396057,
-0.8974099159240723,
-0.43728604912757874,
0.25145813822746277,
-0.7630727291107178,
0.9823206663131714,
0.3299008905887604,
-1.0685486793518066,
0.7972925901412964,
-0.29140907526016235,
-0.09412176162004471,
-0.20240740478038788,
-0.42051300406455994,
-0.36784252524375916,
0.2716849148273468,
-0.011663839221000671,
0.3803638517856598,
-0.34402909874916077,
0.3349596858024597,
-0.8978872299194336,
-0.1316012293100357,
0.0941229984164238,
-0.15035419166088104,
0.7564290165901184,
-0.16735592484474182,
-0.5296977758407593,
-0.2463889867067337,
-0.4158737063407898,
0.18823783099651337,
-0.2830250561237335,
0.05401582643389702,
-0.8689358830451965,
-0.05672214552760124,
0.09442263096570969,
0.07898262143135071,
0.10503149032592773,
-0.7889578342437744,
-0.2190883755683899,
-0.1904364675283432,
-0.1673724502325058,
0.6619307994842529,
-0.15712569653987885,
0.6800832748413086,
-0.22237010300159454,
0.3671177625656128,
-0.23658250272274017,
0.16969139873981476,
0.37562310695648193,
-0.5215169787406921,
-0.7019725441932678,
-0.35062000155448914,
0.1925557255744934,
0.3758551776409149,
-0.5958694815635681,
0.8847013711929321,
-0.22794970870018005,
-0.4394899010658264,
-0.543883204460144,
-0.09123082458972931,
0.34073346853256226,
0.280069500207901,
0.47443491220474243,
-0.5756494402885437,
-0.3963272273540497,
-1.0050981044769287,
-0.8053604960441589,
0.27461668848991394,
0.1155712828040123,
0.7176465392112732,
0.5008893609046936,
0.2345781922340393,
1.3288880586624146,
-0.5764086246490479,
-0.4493817090988159,
0.03427668660879135,
-0.17126820981502533,
0.06954558938741684,
0.1052803248167038,
0.38582053780555725,
-0.42310428619384766,
-0.45385053753852844,
-0.4953460693359375,
-0.9063572287559509,
-0.5246737003326416,
0.29791542887687683,
-0.1475924551486969,
-0.2142326533794403,
0.3973933458328247,
-0.367291659116745,
0.8562692999839783,
0.7905559539794922,
-0.8326444625854492,
0.5007705688476562,
0.1817379891872406,
0.1759462058544159,
-0.7898049354553223,
-0.4380556046962738,
0.6236150860786438,
-0.26855140924453735,
-0.3319244086742401,
-0.060953546315431595,
-0.08787590265274048,
0.13856635987758636,
-0.4354521632194519,
0.3961254060268402,
-0.32880592346191406,
-0.0887095183134079,
0.011374949477612972,
0.35648661851882935,
0.3859422206878662,
0.2962159216403961,
0.0025951587595045567,
0.28215521574020386,
0.24874937534332275,
-0.7356237173080444,
0.24990978837013245,
0.18047742545604706,
-0.6220647096633911,
0.842978835105896,
-0.8967717885971069,
-0.02948344685137272,
0.13711073994636536,
0.2373007982969284,
-0.6717211604118347,
0.08074453473091125,
0.22715796530246735,
-0.35382306575775146,
0.08589563518762589,
0.10902698338031769,
-0.16582149267196655,
0.09778141975402832,
-0.7624741196632385,
0.6360501646995544,
0.1449231207370758,
-0.4469349980354309,
0.18282245099544525,
0.8296747803688049,
0.12396203726530075,
-0.361795574426651,
-0.5665009021759033,
-0.25350266695022583,
-0.46453067660331726,
-0.7819156646728516,
0.5009734034538269,
0.2787518799304962,
-0.442402184009552,
0.3749876916408539,
0.14442314207553864,
0.23984631896018982,
-0.17174474895000458,
0.2364649474620819,
0.10942516475915909,
-0.09409567713737488,
0.11559044569730759,
0.3306497037410736,
-0.0823991447687149,
0.2133895754814148,
0.007679091766476631,
0.6636889576911926,
-0.004735188093036413,
-0.6173063516616821,
-0.3145258128643036,
0.46727409958839417,
0.4736480712890625,
0.02063814364373684,
0.6059373617172241,
0.4986528754234314,
-0.5538422465324402,
-0.13763195276260376,
-0.7321441173553467,
-0.2700427174568176,
-0.4110276997089386,
0.5035029649734497,
-0.3777608871459961,
-1.0906333923339844,
0.49040699005126953,
0.042097724974155426,
-0.45370662212371826,
0.6404719948768616,
0.5795955061912537,
0.2879614531993866,
0.7977214455604553,
0.5059077739715576,
-0.11704941838979721,
0.3048239052295685,
-0.22078369557857513,
0.46936073899269104,
-1.0281763076782227,
-0.13526169955730438,
-0.6554259061813354,
-0.17447225749492645,
-1.2069625854492188,
-0.5352402329444885,
0.5204985737800598,
-0.09446372091770172,
0.02631201595067978,
0.20036889612674713,
-0.7084095478057861,
0.4026428461074829,
0.3133450150489807,
-0.0925452709197998,
-0.11292359977960587,
-0.07676538825035095,
-0.5164982080459595,
-0.27240151166915894,
-0.441933274269104,
-0.6078305840492249,
0.8165662884712219,
0.5790011286735535,
0.784549355506897,
-0.04884539917111397,
0.5292887687683105,
0.5379368662834167,
0.1222362294793129,
-0.8251142501831055,
0.4589764177799225,
0.15669961273670197,
-0.8784284591674805,
-0.5292910933494568,
-0.20256970822811127,
-0.7077782154083252,
0.37270474433898926,
-0.27666938304901123,
-0.6602264046669006,
0.4653407633304596,
-0.21537137031555176,
0.08581764250993729,
-0.10361133515834808,
-0.7113630175590515,
0.7898156642913818,
-0.005418301094323397,
-0.6678803563117981,
-0.5631340146064758,
0.12463684380054474,
0.12122368067502975,
0.42626819014549255,
0.36515891551971436,
-0.6217131614685059,
0.05527852475643158,
0.8857903480529785,
-0.6137869954109192,
0.980490505695343,
-0.3746483325958252,
0.028886282816529274,
0.4243205487728119,
0.10667221993207932,
0.33411943912506104,
0.16332322359085083,
-0.09641746431589127,
0.5537241697311401,
0.3934289813041687,
-0.6079168915748596,
-0.5042930841445923,
0.8970581889152527,
-0.6378318667411804,
-0.5888670086860657,
-0.7347199320793152,
-0.6458781957626343,
-0.2825455069541931,
0.09006001055240631,
0.15231095254421234,
0.30132055282592773,
-0.5684361457824707,
0.014379850588738918,
0.5270993709564209,
-0.7222051024436951,
0.0992213636636734,
0.15518292784690857,
-0.2938251197338104,
-0.2362562119960785,
0.5154238939285278,
0.4743834137916565,
-0.02016020379960537,
-0.12573422491550446,
0.5203511714935303,
-0.5755575895309448,
0.05312642455101013,
-0.1696251928806305,
0.20304544270038605,
-0.7203454375267029,
0.25046882033348083,
-0.28122127056121826,
0.07853583246469498,
-0.4431781768798828,
-0.2924577593803406,
-0.2235085517168045,
-0.3413251042366028,
0.04722459986805916,
-0.09769491106271744,
0.4940948188304901,
0.8738617300987244,
0.1639486849308014,
-0.11225654184818268,
-0.23386342823505402,
0.12330152839422226,
-0.02345776930451393,
0.7399999499320984,
0.12772312760353088,
-0.33058011531829834,
-0.24236275255680084,
-0.028372054919600487,
-0.3579426407814026,
-0.9776535630226135,
0.24720153212547302,
-0.09935019165277481,
0.5389866232872009,
0.24344895780086517,
0.12609325349330902,
0.42920389771461487,
-0.47705718874931335,
0.741294264793396,
0.12809748947620392,
-1.235300064086914,
0.3912426233291626,
-0.17578117549419403,
0.09779814630746841,
0.6229395866394043,
0.6845507621765137,
-0.7129848599433899,
-0.5378702282905579,
-0.5509288907051086,
-0.6799519062042236,
0.3312930762767792,
-0.10181624442338943,
0.33628615736961365,
-0.21935096383094788,
0.4152376651763916,
0.42512011528015137,
-0.17588168382644653,
-0.36980029940605164,
-0.08115560561418533,
-0.15323388576507568,
-0.4523438513278961,
0.19730782508850098,
-0.45513471961021423,
0.14148175716400146,
-0.30206021666526794,
0.46733880043029785,
0.07172466069459915,
0.12028010189533234,
0.38507455587387085,
-0.32679036259651184,
0.3383687436580658,
0.25830844044685364,
0.2613339126110077,
0.38171228766441345,
-0.11444179713726044,
0.16528692841529846,
0.3443259596824646,
-0.564746081829071,
0.018441572785377502,
-0.2398349642753601,
-0.43345439434051514,
0.24795588850975037,
0.36202532052993774,
0.5223734378814697,
0.057105064392089844,
-0.07240020483732224,
0.7135525345802307,
-0.09760822355747223,
0.08608078211545944,
-0.5000865459442139,
-0.05716351047158241,
-0.07441002875566483,
-0.03054501675069332,
-0.015005653724074364,
-0.1450825333595276,
0.43435192108154297,
-0.5714326500892639,
0.3058372139930725,
0.7972157001495361,
-1.1502246856689453,
-0.417802631855011,
0.04332531616091728,
0.20966368913650513,
-0.1722666323184967,
0.3033319413661957,
-0.41265371441841125,
-0.6126022338867188,
0.47582802176475525,
0.16636992990970612,
0.7683294415473938,
-0.15081186592578888,
0.16169504821300507,
0.38172098994255066,
0.2552949786186218,
0.006899725645780563,
0.2987644374370575,
0.012876865454018116,
-0.799788773059845,
-0.2906227707862854,
-0.6230565905570984,
-0.3702743351459503,
-0.28583136200904846,
-0.7937447428703308,
0.6310654878616333,
-0.27271416783332825,
-0.4308253824710846,
-0.09423725306987762,
0.05873822793364525,
-0.9882477521896362,
0.28233325481414795,
0.046642184257507324,
0.8316477537155151,
-1.1344623565673828,
0.526704728603363,
0.36584919691085815,
-0.3612615466117859,
-0.47737008333206177,
-0.13523681461811066,
0.20794890820980072,
-0.6094028353691101,
0.36579182744026184,
0.3834255337715149,
-0.18442894518375397,
-0.519409716129303,
-0.20030847191810608,
-0.9529382586479187,
0.8630797863006592,
0.24762539565563202,
-0.35698315501213074,
-0.027187738567590714,
0.6878325939178467,
0.6916540265083313,
-0.4819706082344055,
0.7330458164215088,
0.4691024422645569,
0.3254695236682892,
-0.35369646549224854,
-0.7699238657951355,
0.3068961799144745,
0.14527401328086853,
0.12162680178880692,
-0.008711082860827446,
-0.4917856752872467,
0.4656597077846527,
0.22469088435173035,
-0.20843589305877686,
-0.26502183079719543,
0.5390608906745911,
-0.012916582636535168,
0.7133195400238037,
0.4516613781452179,
0.8827942609786987,
0.684486448764801,
-0.29592248797416687,
1.4042469263076782,
-0.3774281144142151,
0.6390128135681152,
0.6440134644508362,
-0.09945403039455414,
0.5320106148719788,
0.48793360590934753,
-0.2144748866558075,
0.6411343812942505,
0.5886245965957642,
0.3199096620082855,
0.42280709743499756,
0.65973961353302,
-0.05594892427325249,
0.019525988027453423,
-0.6228118538856506,
-0.35660019516944885,
0.5653077363967896,
0.5528395771980286,
-0.4870826303958893,
-0.12699398398399353,
-0.19809436798095703,
0.2645305097103119,
0.24292974174022675,
-0.098276287317276,
0.36808302998542786,
0.47731971740722656,
-0.6619396209716797,
0.16429674625396729,
-0.07874990254640579,
0.7840392589569092,
-0.2092381864786148,
-0.09283462911844254,
-0.009854069910943508,
0.2740902602672577,
-0.3425985276699066,
-0.7963537573814392,
0.6930561065673828,
-0.20981501042842865,
-0.21904857456684113,
0.046726044267416,
0.7008431553840637,
-0.39309343695640564,
-0.5047659277915955,
0.7051859498023987,
0.5598983764648438,
-0.045027509331703186,
0.008919533342123032,
-0.42092522978782654,
0.3373529613018036,
-0.3105555474758148,
-0.1810188740491867,
0.26619914174079895,
0.5963082313537598,
-0.44315388798713684,
0.3130810260772705,
0.48022276163101196,
0.16167399287223816,
0.26925259828567505,
0.17769016325473785,
0.5583804249763489,
-0.6419408321380615,
-0.3013775646686554,
-0.9625163674354553,
0.10759668797254562,
-0.294077605009079,
-0.3289353847503662,
1.0541489124298096,
0.6350612640380859,
0.8610652685165405,
0.15894360840320587,
0.854792594909668,
-0.042345091700553894,
0.5708237290382385,
-0.27190858125686646,
0.651456892490387,
-0.3184583783149719,
0.20372319221496582,
-0.3855254352092743,
-1.12679922580719,
-0.3263902962207794,
0.7079561352729797,
-0.9953308701515198,
0.1243637278676033,
0.8197160363197327,
0.8940079212188721,
-0.00500913430005312,
0.23313018679618835,
0.3292008936405182,
-0.13274094462394714,
0.29350385069847107,
0.38757434487342834,
0.8279414772987366,
-0.44433003664016724,
0.05374417454004288,
-0.27676814794540405,
-0.4572141468524933,
-0.19233177602291107,
-0.774966299533844,
-0.9502013921737671,
-0.5119859576225281,
-0.4717889130115509,
-0.8005625009536743,
-0.07885638624429703,
0.6862955689430237,
0.49769189953804016,
-0.9445544481277466,
-0.19329293072223663,
0.014022545889019966,
0.49462890625,
0.042763084173202515,
-0.334780752658844,
0.5581159591674805,
-0.3150710165500641,
-0.6651213765144348,
-0.515209972858429,
0.3774901032447815,
-0.43209683895111084,
-0.632534384727478,
-0.20973052084445953,
-0.03687997907400131,
0.5142141580581665,
0.6020494699478149,
-0.1324167549610138,
-0.7249928116798401,
-0.8512504696846008,
0.08529596030712128,
-0.2234017699956894,
-0.17039364576339722,
0.8837783336639404,
-0.5746443867683411,
0.38046377897262573,
0.8887023329734802,
0.37849780917167664,
0.20290619134902954,
-0.30513760447502136,
0.4898427426815033,
-0.5279736518859863,
0.015149843879044056,
0.1662752777338028,
0.4386996030807495,
0.5929093956947327,
-0.24636659026145935,
0.3124508559703827,
0.3319670259952545,
-0.3593771457672119,
-0.3181265890598297,
0.36142629384994507,
-0.8407958745956421,
0.16397841274738312,
1.3060215711593628,
-0.05120372772216797,
-0.40151941776275635,
-0.36367252469062805,
-0.05534536391496658,
0.4070669710636139,
-0.19381269812583923,
1.2388311624526978,
0.9910971522331238,
0.014664963819086552,
0.33584630489349365,
-0.3665531277656555,
0.6458331942558289,
0.5634812116622925,
-0.43036362528800964,
-0.445694237947464,
0.3010936677455902,
0.3066362738609314,
0.40268343687057495,
0.19748958945274353,
-0.5473188757896423,
0.20317229628562927,
0.1112142950296402,
0.22514913976192474,
0.40923917293548584,
0.24521607160568237,
-0.07537893205881119,
0.24230490624904633,
0.09593267738819122,
-0.13485674560070038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15498v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15498v2 | Do We Need Language-Specific Fact-Checking Models? The Case of Chinese | 2024-01-27T20:26:03 | 2024-02-17T13:10:25 | Caiqi Zhang, Zhijiang Guo, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper investigates the potential benefits of language-specific
fact-checking models, focusing on the case of Chinese. We first demonstrate the
limitations of translation-based methods and multilingual large language models
(e.g., GPT-4), highlighting the need for language-specific systems. We further
propose a Chinese fact-checking system that can better retrieve evidence from a
document by incorporating context information. To better analyze token-level
biases in different systems, we construct an adversarial dataset based on the
CHEF dataset, where each instance has large word overlap with the original one
but holds the opposite veracity label. Experimental results on the CHEF dataset
and our adversarial dataset show that our proposed method outperforms
translation-based methods and multilingual LLMs and is more robust toward
biases, while there is still large room for improvement, emphasizing the
importance of language-specific fact-checking systems. | [
0.001621865201741457,
-0.6986960768699646,
0.7481149435043335,
-0.09720732271671295,
-0.07810423523187637,
-0.32841527462005615,
-0.1439303755760193,
-0.34126344323158264,
0.09580100327730179,
0.651576578617096,
-0.15216854214668274,
-0.46833881735801697,
-0.6293357014656067,
-0.03223198652267456,
-0.6620126366615295,
1.1477397680282593,
-0.04707073047757149,
0.2682769298553467,
0.12047956883907318,
-0.19710113108158112,
-0.1923452615737915,
-0.8218685984611511,
-0.7134755253791809,
-0.4823446571826935,
0.737724244594574,
0.21251314878463745,
0.9969267845153809,
0.8155321478843689,
0.478793203830719,
0.2338426411151886,
-0.04100140556693077,
0.3363860249519348,
0.08233700692653656,
-0.26804542541503906,
-0.29500892758369446,
-0.5489447116851807,
-0.39110374450683594,
0.15886510908603668,
0.3289221525192261,
0.49347853660583496,
0.04720683768391609,
0.012558887712657452,
-0.19966788589954376,
0.41428664326667786,
-0.568274736404419,
0.28684642910957336,
-0.5217396020889282,
0.278035968542099,
-0.3030288815498352,
-0.005986364092677832,
-0.34332823753356934,
-0.6055460572242737,
0.047278258949518204,
-0.40922313928604126,
0.4077325761318207,
-0.24519452452659607,
1.0696319341659546,
0.0013265578309074044,
-0.6707367300987244,
-0.34054267406463623,
-0.6310729384422302,
0.5668507218360901,
-0.9541699886322021,
0.37067529559135437,
0.5054342746734619,
0.09685114771127701,
0.019023021683096886,
-0.6607672572135925,
-0.7061609029769897,
-0.244889497756958,
-0.4038284122943878,
0.020446527749300003,
0.3207753300666809,
-0.089097760617733,
0.40349292755126953,
0.4591935873031616,
-0.5752200484275818,
-0.04634303227066994,
0.09313971549272537,
-0.3315546214580536,
0.5271998643875122,
-0.006644158158451319,
0.945120632648468,
-0.19646866619586945,
-0.18275389075279236,
-0.024381639435887337,
-1.0567471981048584,
0.10592427104711533,
0.33492037653923035,
0.4707859754562378,
0.009940177202224731,
0.27077963948249817,
-0.12602171301841736,
0.6605588793754578,
-0.3538464903831482,
-0.10528350621461868,
0.06351114809513092,
-0.5682182908058167,
-0.17915724217891693,
-0.03273152932524681,
0.699465811252594,
0.06122478097677231,
0.038469910621643066,
-0.2759957015514374,
-0.28613051772117615,
0.08094410598278046,
-0.19493186473846436,
-0.601945698261261,
-0.326878160238266,
0.25150325894355774,
-0.08013065159320831,
-0.30364659428596497,
0.34393179416656494,
-0.3648355305194855,
-0.6565207839012146,
-0.09671077132225037,
0.2677861452102661,
-0.3122025728225708,
-0.35951298475265503,
0.021373635157942772,
-0.35924988985061646,
0.42378270626068115,
0.294880211353302,
-0.9479387402534485,
-0.18881021440029144,
0.7319377064704895,
0.7367106080055237,
-0.020934125408530235,
-0.37279555201530457,
-0.48792216181755066,
0.18300074338912964,
-0.802033007144928,
0.5982922911643982,
-0.5719422698020935,
-0.06750241667032242,
0.23062783479690552,
0.19574753940105438,
0.17161719501018524,
-0.3828732669353485,
0.9334931373596191,
-0.5668491125106812,
0.195886492729187,
-1.1690739393234253,
-0.34558820724487305,
-0.320512056350708,
0.575208842754364,
-0.8218097686767578,
0.8523555397987366,
-0.25635653734207153,
-1.0436947345733643,
0.563723623752594,
-0.43299004435539246,
-0.8374689221382141,
-0.03118894249200821,
-0.5625678896903992,
-0.28418174386024475,
-0.11801889538764954,
0.43304675817489624,
0.4738910496234894,
-0.4865024983882904,
0.6756741404533386,
-0.20375500619411469,
-0.33121025562286377,
0.20654639601707458,
-0.6448673009872437,
0.9799099564552307,
0.29264557361602783,
-0.4172840416431427,
-0.0015763159608468413,
-0.5635941028594971,
-0.1915092170238495,
0.25996723771095276,
-0.5952874422073364,
-0.5447627305984497,
0.27938053011894226,
-0.17119191586971283,
0.09300370514392853,
0.4458104968070984,
-0.5763734579086304,
0.2075657695531845,
-0.1285134106874466,
0.22321408987045288,
0.6482192873954773,
-0.33070188760757446,
0.0789264515042305,
-0.41110506653785706,
0.1308218538761139,
0.33131247758865356,
0.07245223969221115,
-0.46456822752952576,
-0.3031405806541443,
-0.7813786864280701,
-0.202215313911438,
0.5510122776031494,
0.7385358214378357,
-1.2735934257507324,
0.287369042634964,
-0.037893638014793396,
-0.18422463536262512,
-0.11028999090194702,
-0.08851791173219681,
0.41374289989471436,
0.3368522524833679,
0.04166721552610397,
-0.2938339114189148,
-0.43541136384010315,
-0.8879154324531555,
-0.5006914734840393,
-0.37491121888160706,
-0.06707516312599182,
0.1509263962507248,
0.26867789030075073,
0.025076953694224358,
0.7790449261665344,
-0.45109719038009644,
0.02964990958571434,
-0.44683268666267395,
-0.2800982594490051,
0.2407130002975464,
0.23975177109241486,
0.6414250731468201,
-1.0975127220153809,
-0.5843625068664551,
0.4315028488636017,
-1.1254395246505737,
-0.08783097565174103,
-0.25177881121635437,
0.18283189833164215,
0.11681320518255234,
0.3812064230442047,
-0.6326241493225098,
0.34115394949913025,
0.5791605710983276,
-0.4819478988647461,
0.4509165287017822,
-0.09632113575935364,
0.38570636510849,
-0.77967768907547,
0.07942713797092438,
0.07882346212863922,
-0.3146081566810608,
-1.0106782913208008,
0.3434079885482788,
0.344573974609375,
0.07848084717988968,
-0.5233535170555115,
0.4799206256866455,
-0.3113652765750885,
0.02936338260769844,
-0.3830126225948334,
0.10063033550977707,
0.09398902207612991,
0.5137606263160706,
0.31245872378349304,
0.5791774392127991,
0.5001469850540161,
-0.5958359241485596,
0.6627739667892456,
-0.21737109124660492,
-0.6258498430252075,
0.1755247861146927,
-0.4590894281864166,
-0.03647974133491516,
0.13512404263019562,
0.19889360666275024,
-0.7296865582466125,
-0.15149571001529694,
0.30911964178085327,
-0.25783514976501465,
0.3970424234867096,
-0.0037116226740181446,
-0.5572900176048279,
-0.22536015510559082,
-0.18171033263206482,
0.10826454311609268,
0.09546457976102829,
-0.9028372168540955,
0.5216997265815735,
0.2969318628311157,
-0.008447131142020226,
-0.9090693593025208,
-0.7586299777030945,
0.30791738629341125,
-0.08984480798244476,
-0.585070788860321,
-0.08586176484823227,
0.12497463822364807,
-0.30569106340408325,
0.03989574685692787,
-0.20276202261447906,
-0.15591157972812653,
0.14959105849266052,
-0.07014595717191696,
0.18841959536075592,
-0.33861324191093445,
0.011797900311648846,
-0.15729205310344696,
0.044786836951971054,
-0.066204734146595,
-0.39014932513237,
0.2543603181838989,
-0.09564393013715744,
-0.5549376606941223,
-0.24411103129386902,
0.11940177530050278,
0.49115628004074097,
-0.1111975684762001,
0.7830100059509277,
0.5906646847724915,
-0.35208195447921753,
-0.15891924500465393,
-0.601915180683136,
-0.2171941101551056,
-0.4667271077632904,
0.5169520378112793,
-0.3345731496810913,
-0.600538969039917,
0.6059608459472656,
0.19068337976932526,
0.18292328715324402,
0.5098690390586853,
0.5620685815811157,
0.5477110147476196,
0.8841177225112915,
0.5455567836761475,
-0.4935113191604614,
0.466439425945282,
0.04592519998550415,
0.4023915231227875,
-0.3645976185798645,
0.12100186944007874,
-0.49207115173339844,
0.15947915613651276,
-0.49081292748451233,
-0.3083585798740387,
0.18431545794010162,
-0.439441978931427,
-0.24154368042945862,
0.28682777285575867,
-0.18074117600917816,
0.6449709534645081,
0.44830700755119324,
0.055781349539756775,
0.453943133354187,
-0.17957623302936554,
-0.3764069378376007,
0.0998343974351883,
-0.886313796043396,
-0.5007395148277283,
0.9078748822212219,
0.2631177306175232,
0.4686858654022217,
0.14253410696983337,
0.0972723737359047,
0.5301606059074402,
0.5637322664260864,
-0.4364334046840668,
0.5186198949813843,
-0.4720011055469513,
-0.8849172592163086,
-0.550268828868866,
-0.6496163010597229,
-0.654405951499939,
0.7386558055877686,
0.0927845910191536,
-0.31889769434928894,
0.08242234587669373,
0.002013490302488208,
-0.0882050171494484,
0.7370157241821289,
-0.677330732345581,
0.67033851146698,
-0.7823349237442017,
-0.32457858324050903,
0.25448668003082275,
-0.24414511024951935,
0.5922340750694275,
-0.21633951365947723,
0.48172643780708313,
-0.036340925842523575,
0.27309149503707886,
0.4918323755264282,
-0.5774215459823608,
0.9816840291023254,
-0.12100517004728317,
-0.5514336824417114,
0.245354562997818,
0.05721472203731537,
0.7840073108673096,
0.080538809299469,
-0.2441778928041458,
0.3783090114593506,
0.16962143778800964,
-0.3287574350833893,
-0.6365649104118347,
0.7522596120834351,
-0.7674206495285034,
-1.055999517440796,
-0.7211705446243286,
-0.45600414276123047,
-0.04323539137840271,
0.3939855098724365,
0.2887375056743622,
0.2075563222169876,
-0.3568592071533203,
0.016532346606254578,
0.5667767524719238,
-0.5082433223724365,
0.1828528344631195,
1.1209220886230469,
-0.19710955023765564,
0.1621425747871399,
1.110866665840149,
0.3450203835964203,
-0.007482060231268406,
0.5439637303352356,
0.38688498735427856,
0.14267060160636902,
-0.38757288455963135,
-0.5608537793159485,
0.08584284782409668,
-0.7599461674690247,
0.09012787789106369,
-0.42276492714881897,
-0.3069382905960083,
-0.44183018803596497,
0.09766408056020737,
-0.48066002130508423,
-0.3713001012802124,
0.11926768720149994,
-0.1187577024102211,
0.013011787086725235,
0.8885393738746643,
-0.21561236679553986,
-0.05426803231239319,
-0.5291177034378052,
0.4895027279853821,
0.24655111134052277,
0.42040273547172546,
-0.006490320898592472,
-0.5352187156677246,
-0.5907480120658875,
0.1776469647884369,
-0.18329285085201263,
-0.8271227478981018,
0.24072036147117615,
-0.16444195806980133,
0.6920696496963501,
0.6010564565658569,
0.15816399455070496,
0.2037459760904312,
-0.4728178083896637,
1.1082828044891357,
0.042118072509765625,
-0.8972492814064026,
0.3535251021385193,
-0.372124046087265,
0.21635891497135162,
0.017891541123390198,
0.345720112323761,
-1.0729390382766724,
-0.526426374912262,
-0.30945226550102234,
-0.8163676261901855,
0.8738064765930176,
0.03260999172925949,
0.016569150611758232,
-0.062431640923023224,
0.5207114219665527,
-0.0402999073266983,
0.008369216695427895,
-1.0026874542236328,
-0.3247515559196472,
-0.3198780119419098,
0.026952723041176796,
-0.18224415183067322,
-0.15265227854251862,
-0.21469393372535706,
0.025438329204916954,
0.8078896999359131,
-0.07649420201778412,
-0.2451050728559494,
0.36814582347869873,
0.03867258131504059,
0.058183420449495316,
0.45557230710983276,
0.3299914002418518,
0.5348222851753235,
0.04046475142240524,
0.31940943002700806,
0.4810999929904938,
-0.4757939875125885,
0.18853461742401123,
-0.2238965779542923,
-0.5355074405670166,
0.10589922964572906,
0.4747053384780884,
0.5900003910064697,
-0.3266030251979828,
-0.49512964487075806,
0.6160560250282288,
-0.133465975522995,
-0.06435737013816833,
-0.1500857025384903,
0.14227032661437988,
0.010102699510753155,
0.15872661769390106,
0.2529423236846924,
-0.1731642335653305,
0.1250711977481842,
-0.7881173491477966,
0.1438904106616974,
0.42544859647750854,
-0.1614665538072586,
-0.469552218914032,
0.37292253971099854,
0.1504504233598709,
0.15760239958763123,
0.30580735206604004,
-0.15123547613620758,
-0.8589813113212585,
0.9288180470466614,
0.2904675304889679,
0.7498343586921692,
-0.405992716550827,
0.28961801528930664,
0.19013909995555878,
0.7025658488273621,
-0.5821557641029358,
0.08272513002157211,
0.12919966876506805,
-0.9965358972549438,
-0.40837207436561584,
-0.14179734885692596,
-0.6041672825813293,
0.46455809473991394,
-0.3473915159702301,
0.2860276401042938,
-0.5764226913452148,
-0.09377553313970566,
-0.20123569667339325,
-0.023662250488996506,
-0.6419795155525208,
0.3761734664440155,
0.1718468964099884,
0.688701868057251,
-0.9901832938194275,
1.0765602588653564,
0.5721309781074524,
-0.344678670167923,
-0.7246494293212891,
0.15637709200382233,
0.19007237255573273,
-0.6983745694160461,
0.8653971552848816,
-0.09962015599012375,
-0.20873691141605377,
-0.8389730453491211,
-0.5229541659355164,
-0.9595749378204346,
0.7861358523368835,
0.5744380354881287,
-0.565157413482666,
0.024626610800623894,
0.21928609907627106,
0.561479389667511,
-0.186097651720047,
0.08345437049865723,
0.7074154019355774,
0.5958852767944336,
-0.04458167776465416,
-0.7696958184242249,
0.29144978523254395,
-0.24238520860671997,
-0.0674685537815094,
0.056290559470653534,
-0.9778376221656799,
1.0895475149154663,
-0.18520008027553558,
-0.32021379470825195,
-0.1866697520017624,
0.5648965835571289,
-0.229295015335083,
0.306095689535141,
0.30533164739608765,
0.32922279834747314,
0.865528404712677,
-0.14924080669879913,
1.251219630241394,
-0.41911524534225464,
0.295960396528244,
1.0286588668823242,
-0.4366481602191925,
0.39384645223617554,
0.016014132648706436,
-0.09215403348207474,
0.42431342601776123,
0.5403797030448914,
-0.053705498576164246,
0.27460116147994995,
0.0715951919555664,
-0.015347661450505257,
-0.3320406675338745,
-0.2253233939409256,
-0.4655725359916687,
0.3196898400783539,
0.4224070906639099,
-0.3334124684333801,
0.010413171723484993,
-0.37646904587745667,
0.3914576768875122,
-0.1244025006890297,
0.003336518071591854,
0.5755254030227661,
-0.06898905336856842,
-0.8002896308898926,
0.35275107622146606,
0.425934374332428,
0.6320939064025879,
-0.7519779205322266,
0.2175881266593933,
-0.5309492945671082,
0.1789899468421936,
-0.38366732001304626,
-0.5673950910568237,
0.0492258295416832,
0.1414126753807068,
-0.23077231645584106,
0.11502774059772491,
0.672328770160675,
-0.6166918277740479,
-0.4193892180919647,
0.27555349469184875,
0.5454698801040649,
0.018509117886424065,
-0.09040338546037674,
-0.5194012522697449,
-0.014724617823958397,
0.17387494444847107,
-0.43141841888427734,
0.3134128153324127,
0.6593844294548035,
-0.1873605102300644,
0.5511573553085327,
0.6765325665473938,
0.40877386927604675,
-0.32021522521972656,
0.2644999623298645,
0.6712036728858948,
-0.7516707181930542,
-0.7062517404556274,
-1.0168293714523315,
-0.10933215171098709,
0.07051564007997513,
0.16957058012485504,
1.209046483039856,
0.4950980842113495,
0.9344037771224976,
0.16950355470180511,
1.4386049509048462,
0.02713930979371071,
0.47966426610946655,
-0.559541642665863,
0.8658197522163391,
-0.6441276669502258,
0.6375165581703186,
-0.3411996364593506,
-0.42175427079200745,
-0.488269567489624,
0.46942830085754395,
-0.50771164894104,
0.1377095729112625,
0.7097421288490295,
0.7683409452438354,
0.028365300968289375,
0.087334543466568,
0.6247796416282654,
0.14529317617416382,
0.5743384957313538,
0.5317498445510864,
0.8490270376205444,
-0.3545808792114258,
0.5254408717155457,
0.13824495673179626,
-0.1636260598897934,
-0.08280154317617416,
-0.8570228219032288,
-1.0255100727081299,
-0.42616185545921326,
-0.2132960706949234,
-0.36135995388031006,
0.11954177916049957,
0.537580668926239,
0.5218173861503601,
-1.040008783340454,
-0.1798732727766037,
0.3437661826610565,
0.666526734828949,
-0.21187734603881836,
-0.16563399136066437,
0.6421021819114685,
-0.3841608464717865,
-0.5385223627090454,
0.1273675113916397,
0.2533583641052246,
-0.08066239207983017,
-0.2040349245071411,
-0.11042306572198868,
-0.12707637250423431,
0.3921392560005188,
0.5045663118362427,
0.4762117564678192,
-0.8069791793823242,
-0.42817023396492004,
-0.1251796931028366,
-0.2548179626464844,
-0.023788606747984886,
1.3828558921813965,
-0.2702130973339081,
0.41020986437797546,
0.5291221141815186,
0.6624810695648193,
0.11199671775102615,
-0.24574142694473267,
0.6375786662101746,
-0.5775768160820007,
0.13480694591999054,
-0.30067557096481323,
0.7118331789970398,
0.5642023682594299,
-0.48534440994262695,
0.4907040297985077,
0.3184623420238495,
-0.4389457106590271,
-0.6668192744255066,
0.43183672428131104,
-0.2263215035200119,
-0.638363242149353,
1.31416916847229,
-0.4687938392162323,
-0.05043765529990196,
-0.32083290815353394,
-0.0679725930094719,
0.4160400927066803,
-0.22603656351566315,
0.8742183446884155,
1.0974012613296509,
0.19812747836112976,
0.01445922814309597,
-0.4552309215068817,
0.7826505303382874,
0.5077189207077026,
-0.6593539714813232,
0.3357839286327362,
0.2767674922943115,
0.32889965176582336,
0.14345359802246094,
0.5528709292411804,
-0.18632443249225616,
0.30008864402770996,
0.05449768528342247,
-0.018616890534758568,
0.026925718411803246,
-0.3930646777153015,
-0.12590326368808746,
0.18033915758132935,
0.12059163302183151,
0.12910999357700348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15496v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15496v3 | Baichuan2-Sum: Instruction Finetune Baichuan2-7B Model for Dialogue Summarization | 2024-01-27T20:20:39 | 2024-04-04T03:15:15 | Jianfei Xiao, Yancan Chen, Yimin Ou, Hanyi Yu, Kai Shu, Yiyong Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) like Llama, Baichuan and Bloom models show
remarkable ability with instruction fine-tuning in many natural language tasks.
Nevertheless, for the dialogue summarization task, which aims to generate
summaries for different roles in dialogue, most of the state-of-the-art methods
conduct on small models (e.g Bart and Bert). Existing methods try to add task
specified optimization on small models like adding global-local centrality
score to models. In this paper, we propose an instruction fine-tuning model:
Baichuan2-Sum, for role-oriented diaglouge summarization. By setting different
instructions for different roles, the model can learn from the dialogue
interactions and output the expected summaries. Furthermore, we applied NEFTune
technique to add suitable noise during training to improve the results. The
experiments demonstrate that the proposed model achieves the new
state-of-the-art results on two public dialogue summarization datasets: CSDS
and SAMSUM. We release our model and related codes to facilitate future studies
on dialogue summarization task. | [
-0.1423470824956894,
-0.7478442192077637,
0.0738704726099968,
0.329153448343277,
-0.45842471718788147,
-0.28390824794769287,
-0.36820945143699646,
-0.10099031031131744,
-0.01008029654622078,
0.7166761159896851,
-0.5087854266166687,
-0.6442627310752869,
-0.5451551675796509,
-0.10673077404499054,
-0.24866129457950592,
1.2560275793075562,
0.31646832823753357,
0.31209796667099,
0.11173190176486969,
0.18810983002185822,
-0.7289817929267883,
-0.23284509778022766,
-0.8303056955337524,
-0.058402929455041885,
0.1656692624092102,
0.6386967301368713,
0.4642043113708496,
0.2769850194454193,
0.36147207021713257,
0.23642650246620178,
-0.3494800925254822,
0.4214615523815155,
-0.8024111390113831,
-0.11669093370437622,
0.030194927006959915,
-0.7654681205749512,
-0.8522481322288513,
0.025660719722509384,
0.6220346093177795,
0.49577799439430237,
-0.23211786150932312,
-0.09297320991754532,
0.22399882972240448,
0.28771835565567017,
-0.27810513973236084,
0.6919602155685425,
-0.47265514731407166,
-0.17277684807777405,
0.20288513600826263,
0.07087498158216476,
-0.35227465629577637,
-0.5498009324073792,
0.2820112407207489,
-0.3556736409664154,
0.3139103949069977,
-0.21228930354118347,
0.5998344421386719,
0.13286879658699036,
-0.31767189502716064,
-0.46412864327430725,
-0.4804932475090027,
0.9917635321617126,
-1.346718192100525,
-0.23080843687057495,
0.1908426433801651,
0.17634712159633636,
-0.041435569524765015,
-0.40324121713638306,
-0.13585202395915985,
-0.07855303585529327,
-0.2971959114074707,
0.3971695899963379,
0.02208246849477291,
0.4601486921310425,
-0.14148962497711182,
0.4713734984397888,
-0.24867360293865204,
0.3176654875278473,
-0.42706090211868286,
0.032215189188718796,
0.7637707591056824,
0.6333110332489014,
0.1727525293827057,
-0.31039339303970337,
-0.07158230990171432,
0.35940971970558167,
-0.6126417517662048,
-0.012834575958549976,
0.14345470070838928,
0.34352079033851624,
-0.6849044561386108,
0.13232222199440002,
-0.2838331162929535,
0.7384364604949951,
0.16608451306819916,
-0.38850975036621094,
-0.4471363425254822,
-0.47871214151382446,
-0.2343684434890747,
0.19885605573654175,
0.47608548402786255,
0.8770037889480591,
0.28155121207237244,
0.029726603999733925,
-0.17523573338985443,
-0.37180161476135254,
-0.18514348566532135,
-1.154160976409912,
-0.38498109579086304,
0.11594890058040619,
-0.5968019962310791,
-0.5274460315704346,
-0.02297847345471382,
-0.5742508769035339,
-0.31282511353492737,
-0.6665967702865601,
0.12138823419809341,
-0.20980204641819,
0.039079699665308,
0.09361466765403748,
0.27623632550239563,
0.2005760222673416,
0.8516185283660889,
-1.1816167831420898,
0.4990047514438629,
0.841771125793457,
0.9964649677276611,
-0.11353097856044769,
-0.12585216760635376,
-0.6807786226272583,
0.008715368807315826,
-0.24066300690174103,
0.6342657208442688,
-0.5684872269630432,
-0.4273819327354431,
-0.05874316394329071,
0.1811884641647339,
-0.2627808749675751,
-0.48995089530944824,
0.11770384013652802,
-0.12144161760807037,
0.32582414150238037,
-0.11260931193828583,
-0.4777703881263733,
-0.4707622528076172,
0.11396293342113495,
-0.370104044675827,
0.4818533957004547,
0.20952542126178741,
-0.5874849557876587,
-0.20005595684051514,
-0.6320914030075073,
-0.5271884202957153,
-0.3225615918636322,
0.0026363558135926723,
-0.4107866585254669,
0.17404471337795258,
0.35498523712158203,
0.7002922296524048,
-0.5650310516357422,
0.3419885039329529,
0.10933296382427216,
-0.6187222003936768,
0.06901773810386658,
-0.35031503438949585,
0.9096496105194092,
-0.014425508677959442,
-0.18320521712303162,
0.28481096029281616,
-0.30682888627052307,
-0.42976197600364685,
-0.16760209202766418,
-0.2281970977783203,
-0.11836656928062439,
-0.09518388658761978,
-0.20570257306098938,
-0.16555245220661163,
0.17429432272911072,
-0.04947339743375778,
0.36797094345092773,
-0.6870654821395874,
0.5545446872711182,
0.6653363704681396,
0.36972901225090027,
0.5114453434944153,
-0.4384428858757019,
0.293455570936203,
0.04356486350297928,
0.2377452850341797,
-0.3921758532524109,
-0.5439165830612183,
-0.8137998580932617,
-0.2654307782649994,
0.4165494441986084,
0.7884159088134766,
-0.15442195534706116,
0.35447627305984497,
-0.044673629105091095,
-0.4543604850769043,
-0.397891640663147,
0.1155267134308815,
0.38005340099334717,
0.4400133788585663,
0.06293363124132156,
-0.4042854607105255,
-0.33018815517425537,
-0.6646381616592407,
0.2233530879020691,
-0.10343405604362488,
-0.04873925447463989,
0.41562366485595703,
0.2978762984275818,
-0.05770674720406532,
0.5651260018348694,
-0.6002601385116577,
-0.4875827133655548,
-0.5858179926872253,
0.29343321919441223,
0.541918933391571,
0.27511394023895264,
0.521806538105011,
-0.41067326068878174,
-0.5977851748466492,
-0.11761967092752457,
-0.4471260607242584,
-0.2975414991378784,
-0.29739028215408325,
-0.031913820654153824,
0.1932937502861023,
0.33249691128730774,
-0.5334744453430176,
0.3788338005542755,
0.3662596046924591,
0.19496506452560425,
0.6289430260658264,
-0.21812784671783447,
0.281622052192688,
-1.2654869556427002,
-0.3534204065799713,
-0.23818489909172058,
-0.0259493887424469,
-0.7244376540184021,
-0.07695382088422775,
-0.25957244634628296,
-0.2197536826133728,
-0.1972489207983017,
0.2481718212366104,
-0.4432123005390167,
0.0459575429558754,
-0.5747937560081482,
0.4559825658798218,
-0.06078878790140152,
0.74341881275177,
0.14687299728393555,
0.779934823513031,
0.5649793744087219,
-0.8020662069320679,
0.4952109456062317,
0.4423946738243103,
-0.4178159236907959,
0.1380954086780548,
-0.9348323941230774,
-0.10477675497531891,
-0.24608367681503296,
0.39745059609413147,
-0.9832820296287537,
-0.426929771900177,
0.22690200805664062,
-0.1849672943353653,
0.3496517241001129,
-0.3652274012565613,
-0.3005008101463318,
0.23501691222190857,
-0.4091442823410034,
0.16381195187568665,
0.5018692016601562,
-0.29312753677368164,
0.3615604341030121,
0.39962127804756165,
-0.7313891053199768,
-0.23971834778785706,
-0.6062523722648621,
-0.15449033677577972,
-0.32869747281074524,
-0.6854444742202759,
0.4478439390659332,
0.12095576524734497,
-0.24454091489315033,
-0.42793384194374084,
0.06255776435136795,
0.07067757844924927,
0.12435899674892426,
0.11594472825527191,
0.31442591547966003,
-0.2863743305206299,
0.014981417916715145,
0.34428471326828003,
-0.1681113988161087,
-0.033468686044216156,
0.02288128435611725,
0.47106948494911194,
-0.040298234671354294,
-0.07427696883678436,
-0.5833543539047241,
0.47271573543548584,
0.39901989698410034,
-0.4858713150024414,
0.5296657085418701,
0.6505824327468872,
-0.22590100765228271,
-0.02474978193640709,
-0.2603938579559326,
-0.4264826774597168,
-0.34384822845458984,
0.6006821990013123,
0.19361847639083862,
-0.7439789772033691,
0.5180538892745972,
-0.20868875086307526,
0.6260239481925964,
0.19908644258975983,
0.8108199834823608,
0.07444006204605103,
0.9054500460624695,
0.39643651247024536,
-0.3522234857082367,
0.5393822193145752,
-0.44268670678138733,
0.3702407777309418,
-0.9231703281402588,
-0.06793510913848877,
-0.22285106778144836,
-0.31262457370758057,
-0.37515079975128174,
-0.5232622027397156,
0.5407651662826538,
0.4552137851715088,
-0.025981741026043892,
0.3435145318508148,
-0.44982653856277466,
0.4294946789741516,
0.5253186821937561,
-0.0013702637515962124,
0.21502813696861267,
-0.06934136152267456,
0.3231014907360077,
0.11657118052244186,
-0.7533752918243408,
-0.5304500460624695,
0.7235373258590698,
0.16790340840816498,
1.1115258932113647,
0.4966469705104828,
0.8348239660263062,
0.18698729574680328,
0.05451228469610214,
-0.71993488073349,
0.5209153294563293,
-0.4193778336048126,
-0.1507897973060608,
-0.39602911472320557,
-0.26950517296791077,
-0.8118106722831726,
0.19853396713733673,
-0.018614068627357483,
-0.9383516311645508,
-0.08617473393678665,
0.16059432923793793,
-0.806837797164917,
-0.12484125792980194,
-0.9141527414321899,
0.7686734795570374,
-0.16606862843036652,
-0.1135663315653801,
-0.5355860590934753,
-0.8205295205116272,
0.5697628259658813,
0.4605620503425598,
0.07963439077138901,
-0.11535991728305817,
0.28192704916000366,
0.5755909085273743,
-0.3175046443939209,
1.2334144115447998,
-0.2793828845024109,
-0.33386874198913574,
0.5665223598480225,
-0.010168502107262611,
0.6378082633018494,
0.5382224917411804,
0.08143796771764755,
-0.11681389808654785,
-0.0659247636795044,
-0.2377624362707138,
-0.7038605809211731,
0.7030670642852783,
-0.6828407049179077,
-0.8271270990371704,
0.04155071824789047,
-0.7059159874916077,
0.15126116573810577,
-0.1349828839302063,
0.19119402766227722,
0.7333699464797974,
-0.2175554484128952,
-0.02967965230345726,
0.9106614589691162,
-0.26997601985931396,
0.3731369972229004,
0.5884052515029907,
-0.1610381007194519,
-0.3523544371128082,
0.874395489692688,
0.06347475200891495,
0.45273905992507935,
0.610821008682251,
0.28554555773735046,
0.11973167955875397,
-0.5329180359840393,
-0.2796096205711365,
0.2873564064502716,
-0.49628257751464844,
-0.24900704622268677,
-0.4581184983253479,
-0.4487681984901428,
-0.6490970253944397,
-0.15673980116844177,
-0.03507141023874283,
-0.4984188377857208,
-0.43623974919319153,
0.10528529435396194,
0.3414278030395508,
0.5495663285255432,
0.10372872650623322,
0.7295811176300049,
-0.8330104351043701,
0.4521442651748657,
0.45854464173316956,
0.08636543899774551,
0.2555621564388275,
-0.7912640571594238,
-0.5334019660949707,
0.27784377336502075,
-0.5370274782180786,
-0.7737616896629333,
0.21919992566108704,
0.295987069606781,
0.428997278213501,
0.635512113571167,
0.07466822862625122,
0.5446820259094238,
-0.29719460010528564,
0.8804024457931519,
0.09710850566625595,
-0.6875842213630676,
0.6488866806030273,
-0.4317137897014618,
0.5553244948387146,
0.20882859826087952,
-0.05043709650635719,
-0.5218198895454407,
-0.5130300521850586,
-0.2618437111377716,
-0.5695220828056335,
1.0781097412109375,
0.3172873258590698,
0.22527477145195007,
0.04516579955816269,
0.13126562535762787,
0.040526703000068665,
-0.07214390486478806,
-0.228356271982193,
0.042667172849178314,
-0.238107830286026,
-0.24795007705688477,
0.015058544464409351,
-0.46451660990715027,
-0.16720999777317047,
-0.25423213839530945,
0.8072589039802551,
0.006999698467552662,
0.43026039004325867,
0.03280480578541756,
-0.17403842508792877,
0.363657146692276,
0.4155045449733734,
0.8954338431358337,
0.21621283888816833,
-0.25935474038124084,
-0.31350207328796387,
0.39913100004196167,
-0.3794458508491516,
-0.2659499943256378,
0.14027225971221924,
-0.2909545302391052,
0.1109766811132431,
0.5118283629417419,
0.9811575412750244,
0.4109218120574951,
-0.39528992772102356,
0.5656986832618713,
-0.07191994786262512,
-0.014097622595727444,
-0.19256508350372314,
0.5044912099838257,
0.2711593508720398,
0.3356950879096985,
-0.0007499691564589739,
-0.018613498657941818,
0.3652127683162689,
-0.536461591720581,
-0.061505675315856934,
0.05738161504268646,
-0.2900351881980896,
-0.34054145216941833,
0.62514328956604,
0.6077715158462524,
-0.2609900236129761,
0.5700598955154419,
-0.1971142292022705,
-0.42161571979522705,
0.6009695529937744,
0.5493534803390503,
0.7604200839996338,
-0.31019479036331177,
0.2429499477148056,
0.5127361416816711,
0.2145441323518753,
0.029440049082040787,
0.09888068586587906,
-0.045139290392398834,
-0.3332294225692749,
-0.43984660506248474,
-0.33225470781326294,
-0.4431634843349457,
0.14082027971744537,
-0.5492305755615234,
0.40842610597610474,
-0.34874558448791504,
0.13816194236278534,
-0.08565806597471237,
0.12291921675205231,
-0.06246744096279144,
0.09051505476236343,
-0.08901920914649963,
0.564621090888977,
-0.6042588353157043,
0.5681911706924438,
0.17672669887542725,
-0.34696948528289795,
-0.5872121453285217,
-0.009616423398256302,
0.09627576172351837,
-0.4677855968475342,
0.14138665795326233,
0.3190891146659851,
0.01064163725823164,
-0.08815623074769974,
-0.458697646856308,
-0.4939488172531128,
1.252511978149414,
0.45326176285743713,
-0.7422586679458618,
-0.40800973773002625,
-0.08846063166856766,
0.2887982726097107,
-0.6978969573974609,
0.38240936398506165,
0.6704391241073608,
0.1183944046497345,
-0.08133678883314133,
-0.7889460921287537,
-0.11955435574054718,
-0.1443410962820053,
0.049034394323825836,
0.05944138765335083,
-1.06972336769104,
0.9545339941978455,
-0.49853840470314026,
-0.1341889202594757,
0.4681527018547058,
0.5899228453636169,
0.054776862263679504,
0.07470761239528656,
0.2818987965583801,
0.09472733736038208,
0.5402815937995911,
-0.1152966320514679,
0.8952133655548096,
-0.34180882573127747,
0.22357752919197083,
1.510384440422058,
0.025894945487380028,
0.24034284055233002,
-0.0919075533747673,
-0.09057258069515228,
0.364734023809433,
0.5433831214904785,
-0.11447818577289581,
0.6027987599372864,
0.22359204292297363,
-0.33457106351852417,
-0.16350342333316803,
-0.16250364482402802,
-0.09113030880689621,
0.4809303879737854,
0.45667392015457153,
-0.40397360920906067,
-0.4661330282688141,
-0.2518343925476074,
0.06730122119188309,
0.04216626286506653,
-0.37329214811325073,
1.0393370389938354,
0.27365434169769287,
-0.7600919604301453,
0.6343990564346313,
0.43607187271118164,
0.40352195501327515,
-0.4197676479816437,
-0.3419511020183563,
-0.5925024151802063,
0.09381410479545593,
-0.28521135449409485,
-0.3530121147632599,
0.2522001564502716,
0.09808342158794403,
-0.19836565852165222,
0.24823956191539764,
0.4329446256160736,
-0.6652026176452637,
-0.4021844267845154,
-0.1359383463859558,
-0.039589494466781616,
0.3438032567501068,
0.1708798110485077,
-0.4537716805934906,
-0.20639744400978088,
0.2294737845659256,
0.10554061830043793,
0.22912545502185822,
0.3863709270954132,
-0.37224215269088745,
0.3920994699001312,
0.18017007410526276,
-0.056140489876270294,
-0.09148440510034561,
0.603445291519165,
0.6475485563278198,
-0.3095203936100006,
-0.5124571919441223,
-0.6758913397789001,
0.47154805064201355,
-0.2390480488538742,
-0.2565505802631378,
0.4867427945137024,
0.631973922252655,
0.48686742782592773,
-0.19589070975780487,
0.7371846437454224,
0.03445063531398773,
0.5156735181808472,
-0.7257032990455627,
0.5828246474266052,
-0.0967111587524414,
0.41582491993904114,
-0.2950473725795746,
-0.8878238201141357,
-0.09596512466669083,
0.6406729817390442,
-0.31360751390457153,
-0.13943177461624146,
0.36626628041267395,
1.2254914045333862,
-0.236023411154747,
0.32108327746391296,
0.1440032571554184,
0.29200443625450134,
0.19796782732009888,
0.7804293036460876,
0.5231067538261414,
-0.5693243741989136,
0.38691145181655884,
-0.17966410517692566,
-0.439258337020874,
-0.5623341798782349,
-0.45458459854125977,
-1.218055009841919,
-0.42269960045814514,
-0.4468839168548584,
0.10728435218334198,
0.010257516987621784,
0.8010565042495728,
0.6695384979248047,
-0.9694774150848389,
-0.4335932731628418,
-0.1463686227798462,
0.22487783432006836,
-0.3971966505050659,
-0.23668266832828522,
0.4985957443714142,
-0.4264604151248932,
-0.9978429079055786,
0.14978419244289398,
0.29001283645629883,
0.17705371975898743,
0.04059584438800812,
-0.3161146342754364,
-0.04987843334674835,
0.2795243263244629,
0.6152576208114624,
-0.2478042095899582,
-0.9452990889549255,
-0.05939014256000519,
-0.12021838128566742,
-0.04540453851222992,
-0.08485183864831924,
0.8058443069458008,
-0.18118129670619965,
0.31058910489082336,
0.36690419912338257,
0.34112149477005005,
0.47962021827697754,
0.17509625852108002,
0.7762303948402405,
-0.6984583735466003,
0.11444692313671112,
-0.028262484818696976,
0.16970501840114594,
0.2056751698255539,
-0.3842504620552063,
0.3897464871406555,
-0.18983985483646393,
-0.44207003712654114,
-0.48726537823677063,
0.3122188448905945,
-0.9528593420982361,
-0.139388769865036,
1.1222018003463745,
-0.3968232274055481,
-0.00031469808891415596,
0.17460890114307404,
-0.76114422082901,
0.5694288611412048,
-0.43736016750335693,
0.9922717213630676,
0.45746710896492004,
-0.08955179899930954,
-0.370114803314209,
-0.30731257796287537,
0.3534926772117615,
0.32181432843208313,
-0.773524820804596,
0.43361008167266846,
0.5119829177856445,
0.1309904307126999,
-0.1323782205581665,
0.5175216197967529,
-0.11448216438293457,
0.5533547401428223,
-0.12783512473106384,
-0.3560880720615387,
-0.09677436202764511,
-0.3507716655731201,
-0.1754760444164276,
-0.255107581615448,
0.000018285587430000305,
-0.16554760932922363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04268v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04268v1 | ProtAgents: Protein discovery via large language model multi-agent collaborations combining physics and machine learning | 2024-01-27T20:19:49 | 2024-01-27T20:19:49 | A. Ghafarollahi, M. J. Buehler | cond-mat.soft | cond-mat.soft, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-bio.BM | Designing de novo proteins beyond those found in nature holds significant
promise for advancements in both scientific and engineering applications.
Current methodologies for protein design often rely on AI-based models, such as
surrogate models that address end-to-end problems by linking protein structure
to material properties or vice versa. However, these models frequently focus on
specific material objectives or structural properties, limiting their
flexibility when incorporating out-of-domain knowledge into the design process
or comprehensive data analysis is required. In this study, we introduce
ProtAgents, a platform for de novo protein design based on Large Language
Models (LLMs), where multiple AI agents with distinct capabilities
collaboratively address complex tasks within a dynamic environment. The
versatility in agent development allows for expertise in diverse domains,
including knowledge retrieval, protein structure analysis, physics-based
simulations, and results analysis. The dynamic collaboration between agents,
empowered by LLMs, provides a versatile approach to tackling protein design and
analysis problems, as demonstrated through diverse examples in this study. The
problems of interest encompass designing new proteins, analyzing protein
structures and obtaining new first-principles data -- natural vibrational
frequencies -- via physics simulations. The concerted effort of the system
allows for powerful automated and synergistic design of de novo proteins with
targeted mechanical properties. The flexibility in designing the agents, on one
hand, and their capacity in autonomous collaboration through the dynamic
LLM-based multi-agent environment on the other hand, unleashes great potentials
of LLMs in addressing multi-objective materials problems and opens up new
avenues for autonomous materials discovery and design. | [
-0.3632049858570099,
-0.8445269465446472,
0.6094344854354858,
-0.18061594665050507,
-0.14484213292598724,
0.43852803111076355,
0.1766892671585083,
-0.3888340890407562,
0.5484179258346558,
0.30254361033439636,
-0.6715796589851379,
-0.26838982105255127,
-0.5921581387519836,
0.38791656494140625,
-0.01640012115240097,
0.5219075679779053,
-0.08385162800550461,
0.1553259640932083,
-0.2697289288043976,
-0.0013502240180969238,
-0.15701399743556976,
-0.1394881159067154,
-0.04327100142836571,
-0.5811089277267456,
0.5660743713378906,
0.1797274351119995,
0.7779303193092346,
0.4140549898147583,
0.6418794393539429,
0.3904029130935669,
0.04132761433720589,
0.33766379952430725,
-0.22628529369831085,
0.3023635447025299,
-0.19700653851032257,
-0.277726411819458,
-0.7913309335708618,
0.11692836880683899,
0.3731514811515808,
0.8464182615280151,
0.27838897705078125,
0.04991891607642174,
0.14185482263565063,
0.6034798622131348,
-0.6162534952163696,
0.344100683927536,
-0.3055313229560852,
0.13870620727539062,
-0.29618746042251587,
-0.09983619302511215,
-0.13277648389339447,
-0.017623472958803177,
0.1731797754764557,
-0.762676477432251,
0.22886954247951508,
-0.2868756651878357,
0.45401817560195923,
0.29516544938087463,
-0.5065662264823914,
-0.32125920057296753,
-0.7966081500053406,
0.670737624168396,
-0.563022792339325,
0.8126433491706848,
0.24094276130199432,
0.24581517279148102,
-0.9695903658866882,
-0.7902117967605591,
-0.5049223899841309,
-0.5642967820167542,
0.2374749779701233,
0.033503610640764236,
0.06892023235559464,
0.19377298653125763,
-0.3750298023223877,
0.3677218556404114,
-1.0821657180786133,
0.1324903666973114,
-0.18433980643749237,
-0.1061747595667839,
0.5673068761825562,
-0.15239615738391876,
0.3946690559387207,
0.18611495196819305,
-0.0829308032989502,
-0.235617533326149,
-0.6000604629516602,
-0.37782949209213257,
0.35034722089767456,
0.4336043894290924,
0.26669976115226746,
0.5981594324111938,
-0.04329243674874306,
0.5702543258666992,
-0.22437162697315216,
0.13817346096038818,
0.376555860042572,
-0.3751354515552521,
-0.15085160732269287,
-0.04344065114855766,
0.8538597226142883,
-0.09961361438035965,
-0.07965917885303497,
-0.1382509022951126,
0.1394275575876236,
-0.16130471229553223,
0.20191778242588043,
-0.7764921188354492,
-0.3191026449203491,
0.70206618309021,
-0.5211154222488403,
-0.29370519518852234,
0.07452897727489471,
-0.7705793380737305,
-0.5778611898422241,
-0.4182892143726349,
0.8346855044364929,
-0.33705592155456543,
-0.38830700516700745,
0.361501544713974,
-0.4096143841743469,
-0.26978686451911926,
-0.02790408954024315,
-0.6345580220222473,
-0.0017468457808718085,
0.39629611372947693,
0.6799392104148865,
0.012267564423382282,
-0.4204363226890564,
-0.5925305485725403,
0.39579761028289795,
-0.12331585586071014,
0.4922700822353363,
-0.7034304738044739,
-0.5088412761688232,
-0.48989588022232056,
0.08679705858230591,
0.24294604361057281,
-0.6164384484291077,
0.341098815202713,
-0.611477255821228,
-0.34269875288009644,
-0.28270697593688965,
-0.4675857722759247,
-0.11162274330854416,
0.059326913207769394,
-0.9573379158973694,
0.4238709807395935,
0.17030872404575348,
-0.5434681177139282,
0.10057508945465088,
-0.5602145195007324,
-0.32432395219802856,
0.4635315239429474,
-0.5019134879112244,
-0.4021638035774231,
0.20942460000514984,
-0.055462658405303955,
0.04168841987848282,
-0.46430251002311707,
0.5242169499397278,
-0.5151490569114685,
-0.293119877576828,
0.46094468235969543,
-0.022310661152005196,
0.3724556267261505,
0.27229568362236023,
-0.22246724367141724,
0.2469228208065033,
-0.8843084573745728,
-0.03304808586835861,
0.18722514808177948,
-0.37846091389656067,
-0.17953772842884064,
0.19093018770217896,
-0.18195638060569763,
0.13442865014076233,
0.1352899968624115,
-0.5319535732269287,
0.6296806931495667,
-0.25302889943122864,
0.478296160697937,
0.5920264720916748,
0.02226872742176056,
0.43659600615501404,
-0.26293307542800903,
0.4270384907722473,
-0.39338240027427673,
0.292759507894516,
0.186701238155365,
-0.3069055378437042,
-0.23898279666900635,
-0.2949453294277191,
0.15238404273986816,
0.4018101394176483,
-0.7004362344741821,
0.3882506191730499,
0.122215136885643,
-0.5718374252319336,
-0.35188180208206177,
0.23442651331424713,
0.15929162502288818,
-0.024196680635213852,
0.4779488444328308,
-0.16350027918815613,
-0.6359859704971313,
-0.9860193729400635,
-0.29815956950187683,
-0.12695254385471344,
-0.3453083038330078,
0.06682855635881424,
0.7009477019309998,
-0.4910857677459717,
0.9862180352210999,
-0.5203798413276672,
-0.38172394037246704,
-0.3334150016307831,
0.09550108015537262,
0.3525557518005371,
0.4293130338191986,
0.4597488343715668,
-0.9958115220069885,
-0.1779731661081314,
-0.09635782986879349,
-0.8635738492012024,
-0.10713047534227371,
0.13814066350460052,
0.003095590742304921,
-0.4644849896430969,
0.24867326021194458,
-0.6701837778091431,
-0.05394163355231285,
0.5677400231361389,
0.10051463544368744,
0.773744523525238,
-0.28029105067253113,
0.04820353537797928,
-1.0117709636688232,
0.21378213167190552,
-0.09354579448699951,
0.14728470146656036,
-0.83150714635849,
0.10529881715774536,
-0.3130853474140167,
-0.2532793879508972,
-0.6809583306312561,
0.6606631875038147,
-0.4863232374191284,
0.024101579561829567,
-0.4857439398765564,
-0.08723319321870804,
0.2920941710472107,
0.22211629152297974,
-0.09490110725164413,
0.6084098815917969,
0.5083622336387634,
-0.7244440317153931,
0.421286016702652,
0.5243256092071533,
0.11035588383674622,
0.11957111954689026,
-0.8606434464454651,
0.24608980119228363,
-0.19856920838356018,
0.4543178379535675,
-0.45414823293685913,
-0.44041189551353455,
0.43176597356796265,
-0.5222488045692444,
0.220999076962471,
-0.08216993510723114,
-0.609569787979126,
-0.5719889402389526,
-0.5359802842140198,
0.42346861958503723,
-0.07058010995388031,
-0.18682797253131866,
0.896418035030365,
0.5664921402931213,
-0.14606685936450958,
-0.3668784201145172,
-0.4753376245498657,
-0.013154760003089905,
0.13478463888168335,
-0.6431628465652466,
0.748509407043457,
-0.35054630041122437,
-0.3232206702232361,
-0.09133590757846832,
-0.23828193545341492,
0.1455698311328888,
0.007146833930164576,
0.12449705600738525,
-0.07519523799419403,
0.23636724054813385,
0.36045509576797485,
-0.006212650332599878,
-0.2530191242694855,
-0.1985640823841095,
-0.6611320972442627,
0.673528254032135,
-0.06276541203260422,
-0.20522071421146393,
-0.35972097516059875,
0.5003893971443176,
0.6639993190765381,
-0.604975700378418,
0.7625429034233093,
0.5223745107650757,
-0.4396156370639801,
-0.2380336970090866,
-0.02572941966354847,
-0.48262616991996765,
-0.5792320966720581,
0.5789000391960144,
-0.5177391171455383,
-0.5364724397659302,
0.5776199698448181,
-0.39921894669532776,
0.047184720635414124,
0.17643265426158905,
0.4668308198451996,
-0.11780942976474762,
0.9069178104400635,
0.7167878150939941,
0.39395686984062195,
0.3682873845100403,
-0.3484150767326355,
0.13315536081790924,
-0.6482471823692322,
-0.3192960023880005,
-0.5665857791900635,
-0.7353488802909851,
-0.5852194428443909,
-0.47717446088790894,
0.7479957938194275,
0.08378154039382935,
-0.3114660084247589,
0.38419580459594727,
-0.3924124836921692,
0.313995897769928,
0.7167928814888,
0.2877902686595917,
0.1729143112897873,
-0.10144605487585068,
-0.2745804786682129,
0.09848237782716751,
-0.45928794145584106,
-0.5050010085105896,
0.8618700504302979,
0.2500138580799103,
0.9525901675224304,
0.16646316647529602,
0.5447296500205994,
0.2951861619949341,
-0.25777870416641235,
-0.5762056708335876,
0.5203041434288025,
-0.3200116455554962,
-0.63381427526474,
-0.13814902305603027,
-0.4247645139694214,
-1.0916459560394287,
0.02386561594903469,
-0.20361360907554626,
-0.5796542763710022,
0.4494747817516327,
0.10840651392936707,
-0.20194889605045319,
0.2874518632888794,
-0.30500373244285583,
0.8435262441635132,
-0.5263398885726929,
-0.5678507685661316,
-0.12648464739322662,
-0.837833821773529,
0.09844426065683365,
-0.4314534366130829,
0.4545860290527344,
-0.052326444536447525,
0.04536466673016548,
0.6411518454551697,
-0.3208455741405487,
0.9328598976135254,
0.037548694759607315,
-0.2866894006729126,
0.5171173214912415,
0.5678239464759827,
0.5086463689804077,
0.19409866631031036,
-0.3382973372936249,
-0.04102537781000137,
-0.24161864817142487,
-0.2583244740962982,
-0.3381962478160858,
0.5824881792068481,
-0.7741597294807434,
-0.4024822413921356,
-0.11837727576494217,
-0.6213757991790771,
0.03718231990933418,
0.5399423837661743,
0.16544263064861298,
0.3554703891277313,
-0.005469672381877899,
0.35572144389152527,
0.5399460196495056,
-0.5625928044319153,
0.20313267409801483,
0.8471515774726868,
-0.22622118890285492,
-0.47986656427383423,
1.0734297037124634,
0.3929571211338043,
0.07661806792020798,
0.525608241558075,
0.2936021089553833,
-0.4186885356903076,
-0.5315760970115662,
-0.22313295304775238,
0.25626954436302185,
-0.3927600681781769,
-0.1263243705034256,
-0.6323949098587036,
-0.022135252133011818,
-0.4623163938522339,
-0.3397723138332367,
-0.7048130631446838,
0.03347967565059662,
-0.21761250495910645,
-0.093673475086689,
0.13781118392944336,
0.46190354228019714,
-0.34164419770240784,
0.14620140194892883,
-1.1368274688720703,
0.5851446986198425,
0.1035136729478836,
0.4619723856449127,
-0.2702251672744751,
-0.059381257742643356,
-0.23326411843299866,
0.1695544719696045,
-0.7886590361595154,
-1.365064263343811,
0.4547026455402374,
0.31265679001808167,
0.9360566139221191,
-0.032120250165462494,
0.32114049792289734,
-0.22638778388500214,
-0.14875292778015137,
0.5025234818458557,
-0.294660359621048,
-0.6203012466430664,
0.810687243938446,
-0.5680680871009827,
0.24905027449131012,
0.24786993861198425,
0.7306627035140991,
-0.2267145961523056,
-0.44076576828956604,
-0.4905834197998047,
-0.9674609899520874,
0.26360031962394714,
0.5475892424583435,
-0.3688427209854126,
-0.0006249838043004274,
0.3811180293560028,
0.54230797290802,
0.32889655232429504,
-0.5240764021873474,
0.007038350682705641,
0.12325160205364227,
-0.24882254004478455,
0.07826313376426697,
0.14288483560085297,
-0.2378004938364029,
0.2533075511455536,
0.7574513554573059,
-0.35299503803253174,
0.1334044486284256,
0.2247786819934845,
-0.19784881174564362,
-0.14559654891490936,
0.17693574726581573,
0.5525901913642883,
0.5430616140365601,
-0.40635859966278076,
0.19039922952651978,
-0.24709928035736084,
-0.5949984192848206,
0.39518019556999207,
0.477969229221344,
-0.13331644237041473,
-0.21745389699935913,
0.3970015347003937,
0.46234285831451416,
-0.37646764516830444,
-0.7029308080673218,
-0.15243424475193024,
0.09195077419281006,
-0.301954060792923,
0.014680715277791023,
-0.08455342054367065,
0.18220821022987366,
0.8026344776153564,
0.7365700602531433,
-0.06170348823070526,
0.22314386069774628,
-0.6011688113212585,
0.557883620262146,
0.37685155868530273,
-0.023659303784370422,
-0.6440780758857727,
0.8599677681922913,
0.4364110231399536,
-0.48951455950737,
0.4885880649089813,
-0.3389335870742798,
-0.33086979389190674,
0.8367447853088379,
0.4715171158313751,
0.8751073479652405,
-0.48648369312286377,
0.37849125266075134,
0.061789967119693756,
0.10044851899147034,
0.13156233727931976,
0.32653939723968506,
0.33947688341140747,
-0.6240058541297913,
-0.15810991823673248,
-0.8285240530967712,
-0.4374123513698578,
0.4290359914302826,
0.06674639880657196,
0.5092531442642212,
-0.09129730612039566,
-0.33362042903900146,
0.15990853309631348,
0.332555890083313,
-0.3726801872253418,
0.002242783550173044,
-0.04643120989203453,
0.5560783743858337,
-0.9004415273666382,
0.7333258986473083,
0.8472976088523865,
-0.6289980411529541,
-0.20347994565963745,
-0.2729432284832001,
0.41793233156204224,
-0.2977132201194763,
0.6581782102584839,
0.25499358773231506,
-0.027726389467716217,
0.07849141955375671,
-0.32930609583854675,
-0.9105573892593384,
1.0826811790466309,
0.6268567442893982,
-0.8720143437385559,
0.035162828862667084,
0.29965347051620483,
0.5936898589134216,
-0.058863334357738495,
0.15290996432304382,
0.30525776743888855,
0.6230594515800476,
0.22875089943408966,
-0.8918431401252747,
-0.07740742713212967,
-0.16553770005702972,
-0.4847652018070221,
0.2865506410598755,
-0.8580427169799805,
0.9095008373260498,
-0.08340423554182053,
0.1280602663755417,
-0.1237415298819542,
0.6015579700469971,
0.7719444632530212,
0.18941980600357056,
0.050935178995132446,
0.20546267926692963,
0.7438634634017944,
0.24898912012577057,
0.6399974822998047,
-0.18781507015228271,
0.1843523532152176,
0.8935081958770752,
-0.5871796011924744,
0.3530714213848114,
0.3883691430091858,
-0.24493631720542908,
-0.044303130358457565,
0.5216200351715088,
-0.12176647037267685,
0.3133450746536255,
0.6653262972831726,
-0.2293887734413147,
-0.17851106822490692,
-0.34345120191574097,
-0.4413118064403534,
0.35477420687675476,
0.3890610933303833,
-0.10778114199638367,
-0.2027454376220703,
0.44548216462135315,
-0.25080081820487976,
-0.17731647193431854,
0.07085558772087097,
0.4139336943626404,
0.10163175314664841,
-0.007365160156041384,
0.31110092997550964,
-0.06245516240596771,
0.42431640625,
-0.710003674030304,
-0.10365177690982819,
-0.43112653493881226,
0.39144715666770935,
0.21046553552150726,
-0.7388450503349304,
0.29395556449890137,
-0.42130473256111145,
-0.27850478887557983,
0.06795614212751389,
0.7258716225624084,
-0.2973552644252777,
-0.49469485878944397,
0.403838574886322,
0.4833349287509918,
0.10767599940299988,
-0.19510464370250702,
-0.5337392091751099,
0.5128055214881897,
-0.4027099609375,
-0.33606991171836853,
0.3417704403400421,
0.17316800355911255,
-0.12304217368364334,
0.8581266403198242,
0.39523714780807495,
-0.20155829191207886,
-0.39046230912208557,
-0.11002429574728012,
1.0954723358154297,
-0.6261444687843323,
-0.07740150392055511,
-0.8200478553771973,
0.3719508647918701,
0.4069024324417114,
0.09275352954864502,
0.26534560322761536,
0.5700123310089111,
0.590825617313385,
-0.36960387229919434,
0.6780815124511719,
-0.030728697776794434,
0.15103191137313843,
-0.31263235211372375,
0.6594518423080444,
-0.7681750655174255,
0.11980333924293518,
-0.32083868980407715,
-1.0358573198318481,
-0.5421015024185181,
0.32106083631515503,
0.38635483384132385,
0.1578884720802307,
0.4306184947490692,
0.7600812911987305,
0.21382637321949005,
-0.15609870851039886,
-0.11066348105669022,
0.32551494240760803,
1.2193230390548706,
0.5822381973266602,
0.613743245601654,
-0.4122098386287689,
0.5206828713417053,
-0.0032846657559275627,
-0.30094870924949646,
-0.4286736845970154,
-0.9115190505981445,
-0.5950751304626465,
-0.6029829978942871,
-0.32027387619018555,
0.03535943850874901,
0.22475837171077728,
1.03400456905365,
0.6363009214401245,
-0.5354703664779663,
-0.19505204260349274,
-0.4785798490047455,
-0.2281472235918045,
-0.11614353954792023,
-0.16930389404296875,
0.4264243245124817,
0.0448785275220871,
-0.8104440569877625,
1.069162368774414,
0.2723994851112366,
0.44801566004753113,
-0.3243228495121002,
-0.1513078361749649,
-0.4695318937301636,
0.1059725433588028,
0.5604131817817688,
0.5578022599220276,
-0.34471383690834045,
-0.019811386242508888,
0.3904787003993988,
0.15705189108848572,
-0.40962210297584534,
0.5328096151351929,
-0.9667777419090271,
0.4557352662086487,
0.8808251023292542,
0.6401311755180359,
0.11601847410202026,
-0.2435256540775299,
1.0312938690185547,
-0.8108131885528564,
0.13954222202301025,
0.19263167679309845,
0.04982418939471245,
0.11303826421499252,
-0.3348039984703064,
0.4915043115615845,
0.429391473531723,
-0.6741800308227539,
-0.7852537631988525,
0.41480129957199097,
-0.8992438912391663,
-0.7872501015663147,
0.9289228916168213,
0.29308512806892395,
-0.19009995460510254,
-0.0011113452492281795,
-0.24359987676143646,
0.6233134865760803,
-0.13867992162704468,
0.6817471981048584,
0.42263105511665344,
-0.35961398482322693,
0.10760007053613663,
-0.6590692400932312,
0.5165199041366577,
0.3134692907333374,
-0.6485902667045593,
0.19587166607379913,
0.3210619390010834,
-0.051977649331092834,
0.25513580441474915,
0.3749133348464966,
0.046068862080574036,
0.013381381519138813,
0.0020462905522435904,
0.24175257980823517,
-0.5119672417640686,
-0.870576024055481,
0.13559336960315704,
0.18636135756969452,
0.06951167434453964,
-0.3099033236503601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15479v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15479v3 | Navigating the Post-API Dilemma | Search Engine Results Pages Present a Biased View of Social Media Data | 2024-01-27T19:04:30 | 2024-04-02T15:28:07 | Amrit Poudel, Tim Weninger | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.SI | Recent decisions to discontinue access to social media APIs are having
detrimental effects on Internet research and the field of computational social
science as a whole. This lack of access to data has been dubbed the Post-API
era of Internet research. Fortunately, popular search engines have the means to
crawl, capture, and surface social media data on their Search Engine Results
Pages (SERP) if provided the proper search query, and may provide a solution to
this dilemma. In the present work we ask: does SERP provide a complete and
unbiased sample of social media data? Is SERP a viable alternative to direct
API-access? To answer these questions, we perform a comparative analysis
between (Google) SERP results and nonsampled data from Reddit and Twitter/X. We
find that SERP results are highly biased in favor of popular posts; against
political, pornographic, and vulgar posts; are more positive in their
sentiment; and have large topical gaps. Overall, we conclude that SERP is not a
viable alternative to social media API access. | [
-0.6006026864051819,
-0.4913160800933838,
0.7238551378250122,
0.28538522124290466,
-0.3997253477573395,
0.5240868926048279,
-0.046278420835733414,
-0.646446704864502,
0.7921083569526672,
0.4928721785545349,
-0.509830892086029,
-0.30256786942481995,
-0.6349992752075195,
-0.018176067620515823,
-0.6436454653739929,
0.7607424855232239,
0.06965548545122147,
0.05018031969666481,
-0.2611282169818878,
-0.17978601157665253,
-0.02159624546766281,
-0.44990116357803345,
-0.8419716954231262,
0.025345798581838608,
0.8416971564292908,
0.17574256658554077,
0.6541393399238586,
0.4213728904724121,
0.4824674725532532,
0.1449999213218689,
-0.0612579844892025,
0.1310928612947464,
-0.8577106595039368,
0.016589663922786713,
-0.4967845678329468,
-0.3284822106361389,
-0.009415799751877785,
0.35193732380867004,
0.3568258583545685,
0.9252760410308838,
0.36501017212867737,
0.5137411952018738,
0.22759327292442322,
0.9299502968788147,
-0.6854804158210754,
-0.038092225790023804,
-0.7071275115013123,
-0.06446420401334763,
-0.2799375057220459,
-0.5950443148612976,
-0.1016278937458992,
-0.6782378554344177,
0.148338183760643,
-0.5052416324615479,
0.42689624428749084,
-0.07187967747449875,
0.6433051824569702,
0.08705952018499374,
-0.44726625084877014,
-0.23897460103034973,
-0.8727885484695435,
0.6014916300773621,
-0.1255473494529724,
0.4285266399383545,
0.5307474136352539,
0.40998855233192444,
-0.15721990168094635,
-0.5981199145317078,
-0.17786937952041626,
0.31488221883773804,
0.3667065501213074,
0.06441977620124817,
-0.2443041056394577,
-0.4208385944366455,
-0.10902798920869827,
0.23397289216518402,
-0.5655633211135864,
-0.32821983098983765,
-0.35905563831329346,
0.043699536472558975,
0.720542311668396,
-0.383123517036438,
0.2389771193265915,
-0.3916882574558258,
-0.22092951834201813,
-0.07835794240236282,
-0.7644653916358948,
0.245075061917305,
0.6878260970115662,
0.49095046520233154,
0.20359092950820923,
0.7040630578994751,
-0.18745748698711395,
0.11786764115095139,
0.10563328117132187,
0.4321308732032776,
0.18356482684612274,
-0.011878889985382557,
0.14536860585212708,
0.032302502542734146,
0.7775813937187195,
0.859035313129425,
0.17338347434997559,
-0.3383200168609619,
-0.041617099195718765,
0.10255742818117142,
0.608002245426178,
-0.3747403621673584,
0.1281691938638687,
0.5970132350921631,
-0.6723000407218933,
-0.22091098129749298,
0.1571120321750641,
-0.8694210648536682,
-0.6705193519592285,
-0.2686399519443512,
0.1043025478720665,
0.12126350402832031,
-0.40854960680007935,
-0.1915353536605835,
-0.5764219164848328,
0.30150797963142395,
0.27389633655548096,
-0.31366783380508423,
0.3526598811149597,
0.844523012638092,
1.1269034147262573,
-0.05898401513695717,
0.18127375841140747,
-0.16883999109268188,
-0.37175846099853516,
-0.49831730127334595,
0.9697484970092773,
-0.739848792552948,
-0.6120046377182007,
0.44157174229621887,
0.32947632670402527,
0.4126991927623749,
-0.6103768944740295,
0.5406965613365173,
-0.9751134514808655,
-0.22508467733860016,
-1.0003362894058228,
-0.376659631729126,
0.07778726518154144,
-0.055163804441690445,
-0.7662227153778076,
0.6828149557113647,
-0.08316854387521744,
-0.804455041885376,
0.4448193609714508,
-0.3430339992046356,
-0.39935407042503357,
-0.11564202606678009,
-0.24242161214351654,
0.014475584030151367,
0.22411690652370453,
0.0495983250439167,
0.11961065977811813,
-0.014931870624423027,
-0.15675987303256989,
-1.1061763763427734,
-0.45434272289276123,
0.31795552372932434,
0.06655111163854599,
0.8625575304031372,
0.31182482838630676,
-0.3180042505264282,
-0.2729679346084595,
-0.6481492519378662,
-0.19844941794872284,
0.21084044873714447,
-0.08867766708135605,
-0.73666912317276,
0.3116930425167084,
0.004595612641423941,
0.1282758116722107,
0.18677347898483276,
-0.6604427099227905,
-0.11547838896512985,
0.03207951411604881,
0.46325862407684326,
1.1884732246398926,
0.016966743394732475,
0.7128474116325378,
-0.42788729071617126,
0.35415706038475037,
-0.5035936832427979,
0.15853646397590637,
0.6797600984573364,
-0.6950600147247314,
-0.263848215341568,
0.32155200839042664,
0.2723584771156311,
0.15153811872005463,
-0.7399675846099854,
0.21975117921829224,
-0.031148841604590416,
-0.654356062412262,
-0.7341346740722656,
-0.23235777020454407,
-0.08752971887588501,
0.4196849465370178,
0.2680496573448181,
-0.14247868955135345,
-0.7605404853820801,
-0.7459912896156311,
-0.5636897087097168,
-0.1272725909948349,
-0.06108330935239792,
0.6525049209594727,
0.14080668985843658,
-0.2288370132446289,
0.7582164406776428,
-0.3311358690261841,
0.03651507571339607,
0.13659730553627014,
0.18754321336746216,
0.14797726273536682,
-0.10456770658493042,
0.5941097736358643,
-0.9531910419464111,
-0.62378990650177,
-0.24452532827854156,
-0.625653862953186,
-0.4014108180999756,
0.27046728134155273,
-0.6156278848648071,
0.09461070597171783,
0.013124595396220684,
-0.5496987700462341,
0.456932932138443,
0.44693467020988464,
-0.05658688023686409,
0.5880064964294434,
0.4161442518234253,
0.6013120412826538,
-0.6022047400474548,
0.26556745171546936,
0.11000928282737732,
-0.30125758051872253,
-0.37821730971336365,
-0.06869838386774063,
-0.0029864024836570024,
-0.2178521305322647,
-0.3655993640422821,
0.6569873094558716,
-0.23901493847370148,
-0.5120810866355896,
-0.670233428478241,
0.02126380242407322,
-0.14278914034366608,
-0.02454807609319687,
0.07724469155073166,
0.8479098677635193,
0.5284243822097778,
-0.5895161032676697,
0.11128802597522736,
0.06772477179765701,
0.013526731170713902,
0.14470918476581573,
-0.6840818524360657,
0.33225399255752563,
-0.23590055108070374,
0.33680349588394165,
-1.2249361276626587,
-0.29627496004104614,
0.1372951865196228,
-0.8712578415870667,
-0.42260146141052246,
-0.1345449984073639,
-0.3390803039073944,
-0.45246613025665283,
-0.9810830354690552,
0.2562747299671173,
0.6376919150352478,
-0.46539273858070374,
0.09002622961997986,
0.8722468018531799,
-0.3611185550689697,
-0.7043570876121521,
-0.3240167796611786,
0.060232050716876984,
0.0749024897813797,
-0.5526273846626282,
0.4145885109901428,
0.15111522376537323,
-0.4334316849708557,
0.41251465678215027,
-0.3461296856403351,
-0.10325071215629578,
-0.2716003358364105,
0.2007111757993698,
-0.09828925132751465,
0.04155626893043518,
-0.05155922845005989,
0.07448429614305496,
0.008958774618804455,
0.18284660577774048,
0.03398330137133598,
0.9711005091667175,
0.07202471792697906,
-0.33891069889068604,
-0.23801885545253754,
0.47520267963409424,
0.4175640940666199,
-0.02738041616976261,
0.2657320499420166,
0.19318316876888275,
-0.40447208285331726,
0.15300139784812927,
-0.4956674873828888,
-0.07656315714120865,
-0.4109116792678833,
-0.34056490659713745,
0.3442646265029907,
-0.5433525443077087,
0.7519402503967285,
0.17807957530021667,
0.21192635595798492,
0.40750229358673096,
-0.004440054297447205,
-0.4849718511104584,
1.1097663640975952,
0.5529515743255615,
0.003184230998158455,
0.5024661421775818,
-0.0984923392534256,
0.34303298592567444,
-0.5526987314224243,
0.12625373899936676,
-0.6751770973205566,
-0.6256775259971619,
-0.8641387820243835,
0.07097356021404266,
0.06477654725313187,
-0.21508467197418213,
0.015337318181991577,
0.1612815260887146,
-0.5447409749031067,
0.1673104166984558,
0.8331178426742554,
0.444755494594574,
0.03451712802052498,
0.16013313829898834,
0.8692294955253601,
-0.14255671203136444,
-0.32115769386291504,
-0.716057300567627,
1.2555201053619385,
-0.05075926333665848,
0.5489844083786011,
0.03879403695464134,
0.7051423788070679,
0.630679190158844,
0.0047436184249818325,
-0.3376138508319855,
0.6088709235191345,
-0.38760504126548767,
-0.5965040922164917,
-0.005028095096349716,
-0.42350295186042786,
-0.935248851776123,
0.07323265075683594,
-0.023092688992619514,
-0.37519392371177673,
0.544013261795044,
-0.09826532006263733,
-0.32382774353027344,
0.30174335837364197,
-0.6579833030700684,
0.48633527755737305,
-0.2912754416465759,
-0.7562811374664307,
-0.0010774265974760056,
-0.6203597784042358,
0.22349976003170013,
0.022972125560045242,
0.38395342230796814,
0.015085773542523384,
-0.07143833488225937,
0.6954737901687622,
-0.4879211187362671,
0.6746951937675476,
-0.2914842367172241,
0.29490211606025696,
0.4548967182636261,
-0.11977197974920273,
0.14976342022418976,
0.016459889709949493,
-0.09301720559597015,
0.114280566573143,
0.1288975477218628,
-0.6177437901496887,
-0.2739376723766327,
0.7739216089248657,
-0.9388220310211182,
-0.12935058772563934,
-0.4589178264141083,
0.02832048572599888,
-0.2403198480606079,
0.27612629532814026,
0.3120599091053009,
0.12474984675645828,
-0.11353418231010437,
0.38271647691726685,
0.5305783748626709,
-0.2749071717262268,
0.2305799424648285,
0.24523836374282837,
-0.4049746096134186,
-0.1863229125738144,
0.8756659030914307,
0.5791539549827576,
-0.1481226682662964,
-0.017844723537564278,
0.1288485825061798,
-0.8406925201416016,
-0.33439427614212036,
-0.08685251325368881,
0.34580424427986145,
-0.3457227945327759,
0.08437478542327881,
-0.5237948894500732,
-0.07703543454408646,
-0.8389500975608826,
-0.24104061722755432,
-0.4269837737083435,
-0.14779765903949738,
-0.30281901359558105,
-0.07193755358457565,
0.16234849393367767,
0.5605915784835815,
-0.42266395688056946,
0.17661839723587036,
-0.560554563999176,
0.5596792101860046,
0.012136631645262241,
0.3928050100803375,
-0.045341573655605316,
-0.1518896371126175,
0.18093889951705933,
0.18818016350269318,
-0.17520588636398315,
-1.107130527496338,
0.01155190821737051,
-0.33547550439834595,
0.27202653884887695,
0.4873434007167816,
0.3299902677536011,
0.8721492886543274,
-0.41891002655029297,
0.6627392172813416,
-0.17960125207901,
-0.2681973874568939,
0.5592057704925537,
-0.5846745371818542,
-0.25010964274406433,
0.7331600785255432,
0.7731541991233826,
-0.6016818284988403,
-0.6109537482261658,
-0.922809362411499,
-0.9951761364936829,
0.31076285243034363,
0.19445829093456268,
0.2103978991508484,
-0.11561759561300278,
0.41510653495788574,
0.2509835362434387,
0.75189208984375,
-0.5325714349746704,
-0.15075139701366425,
-0.28242388367652893,
0.3431306481361389,
0.27215060591697693,
-0.24005566537380219,
0.03150980547070503,
-0.10685961693525314,
0.526818037033081,
0.40845897793769836,
0.17679962515830994,
0.10316650569438934,
0.24351459741592407,
-0.14139612019062042,
-0.01669931598007679,
-0.16540950536727905,
0.9627945423126221,
-0.5764872431755066,
0.4047554135322571,
-0.6741629838943481,
-0.3637278079986572,
0.04148511216044426,
0.226143479347229,
-0.572840690612793,
0.29204124212265015,
0.14391423761844635,
0.17005135118961334,
-0.01464267261326313,
-0.7585363984107971,
0.5880774855613708,
-0.18829675018787384,
-0.1682731807231903,
-0.3425101041793823,
-0.2369784563779831,
0.06603279709815979,
0.3177781105041504,
0.5992595553398132,
0.0052002654410898685,
0.3991100490093231,
-0.8353042006492615,
0.39979755878448486,
0.562265932559967,
-0.24473346769809723,
-0.389884889125824,
0.6370900273323059,
0.27897170186042786,
-0.5400611162185669,
0.1665259301662445,
-0.2682567238807678,
-0.07100656628608704,
0.5472398996353149,
0.1049925908446312,
0.7561564445495605,
-0.05691428855061531,
0.5971412658691406,
0.10455039143562317,
0.05145754665136337,
-0.14045818150043488,
0.3860405385494232,
-0.014482026919722557,
-0.5393918752670288,
-0.33285871148109436,
-0.43360573053359985,
-0.4265531003475189,
0.546050488948822,
-0.7804040312767029,
0.09675215929746628,
-0.8481588363647461,
-0.46619319915771484,
0.09481136500835419,
0.08556844294071198,
-0.4395397901535034,
-0.012741904705762863,
-0.1348288506269455,
0.7630094289779663,
-0.846960186958313,
-0.007649097591638565,
0.7950955629348755,
-0.5219382643699646,
-0.20773543417453766,
0.17147549986839294,
0.3073502779006958,
-0.6678946018218994,
0.14416345953941345,
0.23982030153274536,
-0.3366676867008209,
-0.2387085109949112,
-0.927494466304779,
-0.6229575276374817,
0.48884788155555725,
0.27075281739234924,
-0.3392077386379242,
-0.08878752589225769,
0.23132385313510895,
0.5901651382446289,
0.17532296478748322,
0.06673882156610489,
0.21651606261730194,
0.3092668652534485,
0.02385406196117401,
-0.40764379501342773,
-0.09037702530622482,
-0.34261834621429443,
-0.12538085877895355,
0.023355716839432716,
-0.7193317413330078,
0.7276252508163452,
0.39823704957962036,
-0.5829938054084778,
-0.1998400241136551,
0.3159036338329315,
0.1733308881521225,
0.6704941987991333,
0.4636094570159912,
0.29325592517852783,
0.5658395290374756,
0.005920755211263895,
1.0354515314102173,
-0.1829306036233902,
0.3432815372943878,
0.7573234438896179,
-0.5238030552864075,
1.1235641241073608,
0.732444167137146,
-0.3118365406990051,
-0.080814890563488,
1.3032563924789429,
0.2610156238079071,
0.7617886066436768,
-0.14122052490711212,
-0.24470318853855133,
-0.09767725318670273,
-0.37878018617630005,
-0.5730646848678589,
0.23195502161979675,
-0.12823334336280823,
-0.2393016666173935,
-0.6002246737480164,
-0.3105316758155823,
-0.06807276606559753,
0.06019103154540062,
-0.4572279453277588,
0.5308016538619995,
0.0030601744074374437,
-0.35049957036972046,
0.2846684753894806,
-0.3148787319660187,
0.4074171483516693,
-0.34450262784957886,
0.16541577875614166,
-0.3816269636154175,
-0.0034256866201758385,
-0.3833630084991455,
-1.0819730758666992,
0.732337236404419,
0.11678163707256317,
-0.160588338971138,
-0.2549780011177063,
1.1213533878326416,
0.08503668755292892,
-0.3496338427066803,
0.6381552219390869,
0.7230013608932495,
0.34024500846862793,
-0.6618786454200745,
-0.6995592713356018,
0.16787324845790863,
-0.18032033741474152,
-0.1455964893102646,
0.31400346755981445,
0.24050946533679962,
0.2742995321750641,
0.3616214394569397,
0.8539605736732483,
0.3312665820121765,
0.2066815346479416,
0.1638159155845642,
0.9702198505401611,
-0.5667482614517212,
-0.40282997488975525,
-0.5774877071380615,
0.157933309674263,
-0.46565207839012146,
-0.08820407837629318,
0.8398768305778503,
0.5788026452064514,
0.8662070035934448,
0.24851657450199127,
1.2042313814163208,
-0.42416831851005554,
1.020156741142273,
-0.2314891517162323,
0.7852143049240112,
-1.0728899240493774,
0.014891390688717365,
-0.37144818902015686,
-0.8143601417541504,
-0.05366969853639603,
0.4871513843536377,
-0.44577154517173767,
0.02840857207775116,
0.32193028926849365,
0.5750480890274048,
-0.333485871553421,
0.15261806547641754,
-0.3114003837108612,
-0.09307509660720825,
0.3671042025089264,
0.019757743924856186,
1.0648945569992065,
-0.07674171030521393,
0.5175804495811462,
-0.2805338203907013,
-0.5445380806922913,
-0.5846416354179382,
-0.32228541374206543,
-0.6413552761077881,
-0.4616054892539978,
0.29811927676200867,
-0.6042336225509644,
0.20100551843643188,
0.6045535206794739,
0.329995721578598,
-0.535484790802002,
-0.14573167264461517,
-0.02236257866024971,
0.32176440954208374,
-0.05275948718190193,
-0.28817152976989746,
0.20609402656555176,
-0.39331188797950745,
-0.677661657333374,
0.03688187152147293,
0.07515445351600647,
-0.19265708327293396,
-0.13386358320713043,
0.2617945671081543,
-0.1399749219417572,
0.0514838881790638,
0.6846942901611328,
0.5698379278182983,
-0.41741955280303955,
-0.44818171858787537,
0.472405344247818,
0.013038765639066696,
0.2524476945400238,
0.7589573860168457,
-0.2913378179073334,
0.2676454484462738,
0.7839964628219604,
1.1225330829620361,
0.3184034824371338,
0.4245763421058655,
0.460140585899353,
-0.4797091782093048,
-0.15807044506072998,
0.14216066896915436,
0.3658522665500641,
0.21474212408065796,
-0.13982275128364563,
0.42744898796081543,
0.3548559844493866,
-0.7094234824180603,
-0.9143037796020508,
0.1467261165380478,
-0.8689106106758118,
-0.5059871077537537,
1.3169316053390503,
0.4333738386631012,
-0.39915400743484497,
-0.1387305110692978,
-0.25078558921813965,
0.16245940327644348,
-0.8859259486198425,
1.1850875616073608,
0.8678643107414246,
-0.3816474974155426,
-0.10244057327508926,
-0.9095810651779175,
0.27913472056388855,
0.005590790882706642,
-0.5093713402748108,
-0.04334927722811699,
0.44104254245758057,
0.134669691324234,
0.41615697741508484,
1.0447710752487183,
-0.05748259648680687,
0.15959881246089935,
-0.1616748720407486,
-0.3562638759613037,
0.5769283771514893,
-0.3915838897228241,
0.09689522534608841,
0.17979177832603455,
-0.10111093521118164,
-0.6250077486038208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15476v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15476v1 | To Burst or Not to Burst: Generating and Quantifying Improbable Text | 2024-01-27T18:34:29 | 2024-01-27T18:34:29 | Kuleen Sasse, Samuel Barham, Efsun Sarioglu Kayi, Edward W. Staley | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models (LLMs) are extremely capable at text generation,
their outputs are still distinguishable from human-authored text. We explore
this separation across many metrics over text, many sampling techniques, many
types of text data, and across two popular LLMs, LLaMA and Vicuna. Along the
way, we introduce a new metric, recoverability, to highlight differences
between human and machine text; and we propose a new sampling technique, burst
sampling, designed to close this gap. We find that LLaMA and Vicuna have
distinct distributions under many of the metrics, and that this influences our
results: Recoverability separates real from fake text better than any other
metric when using LLaMA. When using Vicuna, burst sampling produces text which
is distributionally closer to real text compared to other sampling techniques. | [
-0.17827755212783813,
-0.9129617810249329,
0.5305464267730713,
0.3823431134223938,
-0.08004818111658096,
0.6457880139350891,
-0.07453878223896027,
-0.8586883544921875,
0.38530847430229187,
0.6220713257789612,
-0.36580052971839905,
-0.06504717469215393,
-0.574350118637085,
0.2761465907096863,
-0.9154233336448669,
1.110701560974121,
0.08652845025062561,
-0.47762930393218994,
0.05906276777386665,
0.07625455409288406,
-0.5191313624382019,
-0.4620479345321655,
-0.6238527297973633,
-0.07548383623361588,
0.5033232569694519,
0.5146502256393433,
0.4178928732872009,
0.5082590579986572,
0.4384996294975281,
0.2382960170507431,
0.009143495000898838,
0.35371658205986023,
-0.6236050128936768,
0.1440490186214447,
0.06416910886764526,
-0.5741916298866272,
-0.0999453142285347,
0.0017282594926655293,
0.938129186630249,
0.37648528814315796,
-0.07382140308618546,
-0.03784801438450813,
0.033585865050554276,
0.6180861592292786,
-0.5796254873275757,
-0.4241864085197449,
-0.7005760669708252,
0.10300160199403763,
-0.4359554946422577,
-0.3747723698616028,
-0.5494195222854614,
-0.4922516644001007,
-0.06263453513383865,
-0.15437079966068268,
0.3244425356388092,
0.24940668046474457,
1.0059690475463867,
0.10998006165027618,
-0.2705911695957184,
-0.45308488607406616,
-1.2717896699905396,
0.7864990234375,
-0.5152458548545837,
-0.04113186150789261,
0.3697459101676941,
0.4863460659980774,
0.002419618656858802,
-0.8742303848266602,
-0.7843306064605713,
-0.31433141231536865,
0.18270568549633026,
0.09397989511489868,
-0.31305384635925293,
-0.3188186287879944,
0.10783659666776657,
0.7831903696060181,
-0.19418586790561676,
0.3221239745616913,
-0.25420382618904114,
-0.1492777019739151,
0.6691235303878784,
0.36414340138435364,
0.617763102054596,
-0.1805369257926941,
-0.5461714267730713,
-0.13641712069511414,
-0.803422749042511,
-0.24199800193309784,
0.6126563549041748,
0.25339844822883606,
0.08608819544315338,
0.603722870349884,
0.05755305290222168,
0.43953725695610046,
-0.3331579864025116,
-0.5016416907310486,
0.06770925223827362,
-0.5012022256851196,
-0.32312190532684326,
-0.1312377005815506,
0.9122352600097656,
-0.016613395884633064,
0.3136591613292694,
-0.1841290295124054,
-0.3080359101295471,
-0.29523494839668274,
0.4658331274986267,
-0.6441948413848877,
-0.10802894830703735,
0.27817726135253906,
-0.4609162211418152,
-0.3763817548751831,
0.24994432926177979,
-0.6155609488487244,
-0.3388065695762634,
0.22489500045776367,
0.34800687432289124,
-0.433346688747406,
-0.5978834629058838,
-0.033444084227085114,
-0.30098435282707214,
0.031188782304525375,
0.10270190984010696,
-0.747520387172699,
0.2997530996799469,
0.5875316858291626,
1.0530070066452026,
-0.22453419864177704,
-0.24555261433124542,
-0.20542101562023163,
-0.07607776671648026,
-0.6108017563819885,
1.0111641883850098,
-0.10020275413990021,
-0.5151045322418213,
0.09593323618173599,
-0.121036097407341,
0.022368906065821648,
-0.7731252312660217,
0.4722248911857605,
-0.4265068769454956,
0.09290189296007156,
-0.19999682903289795,
-0.7557506561279297,
-0.30612674355506897,
0.24469728767871857,
-1.0736035108566284,
1.0693117380142212,
0.32007843255996704,
-0.861870527267456,
0.46718457341194153,
-0.23108075559139252,
-0.3736107051372528,
0.2731051743030548,
-0.05439288169145584,
-0.5748422741889954,
0.22620756924152374,
-0.3822054862976074,
0.3273651599884033,
-0.33709362149238586,
0.12411010265350342,
-0.17288601398468018,
-0.2792603671550751,
0.6244156360626221,
-0.8315805196762085,
0.6031960248947144,
0.19152003526687622,
-0.16916032135486603,
-0.12407893687486649,
-0.9745244383811951,
0.025863774120807648,
0.13247843086719513,
-0.7354902029037476,
-0.17895452678203583,
0.24139173328876495,
0.40562617778778076,
0.059219349175691605,
0.03367715701460838,
-0.4443666636943817,
0.05726345628499985,
-0.3416290283203125,
0.44719815254211426,
0.5112013816833496,
0.1585925966501236,
0.14661677181720734,
-0.6983019113540649,
0.5478304624557495,
-0.02010272815823555,
-0.28187188506126404,
-0.31974396109580994,
-0.3373592495918274,
-0.7629437446594238,
-0.7689970135688782,
0.17075978219509125,
0.7919390797615051,
-0.7940634489059448,
0.43564948439598083,
-0.14786039292812347,
-0.8465285301208496,
-0.40137147903442383,
0.07867134362459183,
0.4487776756286621,
0.570976197719574,
0.0852365642786026,
-0.39836880564689636,
-0.7892958521842957,
-0.8181449174880981,
-0.4356623888015747,
-0.41895627975463867,
-0.06680101901292801,
0.3858519196510315,
0.3099370300769806,
-0.1537012904882431,
1.1777973175048828,
-0.49877938628196716,
-0.15027697384357452,
-0.7039794921875,
0.23520256578922272,
0.07151832431554794,
0.2543206810951233,
0.6316708922386169,
-0.7094440460205078,
-0.4152294993400574,
-0.32770416140556335,
-0.6441007852554321,
-0.15039101243019104,
-0.42880621552467346,
-0.06918152421712875,
0.27078428864479065,
0.35323601961135864,
-0.2959674000740051,
0.5283808708190918,
0.42263108491897583,
-0.30036303400993347,
0.840042769908905,
-0.18119753897190094,
0.12450669705867767,
-1.4151870012283325,
0.03089592605829239,
-0.07830909639596939,
-0.4948377311229706,
-0.8200539350509644,
-0.0680721178650856,
-0.020471079275012016,
0.3513404130935669,
-0.581810712814331,
0.6184654235839844,
-0.4204367995262146,
-0.19065818190574646,
-0.6623858213424683,
-0.0926692858338356,
-0.09705403447151184,
-0.226568803191185,
0.14590413868427277,
0.8727285265922546,
0.1726168543100357,
-0.8266176581382751,
0.27547410130500793,
0.1515522450208664,
-0.7375146746635437,
0.367489755153656,
-0.7809439301490784,
0.028868643566966057,
-0.013430054299533367,
0.42399662733078003,
-1.320426344871521,
-0.4293331205844879,
0.016452481970191002,
-0.45174720883369446,
0.14809772372245789,
0.13173596560955048,
-0.9880409240722656,
-0.41061413288116455,
-0.19616124033927917,
0.33300918340682983,
0.6953576803207397,
-0.5672836303710938,
0.0944964662194252,
0.552509605884552,
-0.0371946319937706,
-0.5362855792045593,
-0.7808625102043152,
0.3421618342399597,
-0.44887736439704895,
-0.26481977105140686,
0.1020592525601387,
-0.1646117866039276,
-0.5062940120697021,
-0.21341803669929504,
0.45681923627853394,
-0.25344792008399963,
0.28569039702415466,
0.3167106807231903,
0.3768622875213623,
-0.06042853742837906,
0.34126412868499756,
-0.21981565654277802,
0.06902089715003967,
-0.24717959761619568,
-0.21842984855175018,
0.7812023162841797,
0.15825623273849487,
-0.19931550323963165,
-0.30215519666671753,
0.2843746244907379,
0.14156584441661835,
0.3173498511314392,
0.8713319301605225,
0.4355642795562744,
-0.3999866247177124,
-0.295976847410202,
-0.5852729678153992,
-0.12675705552101135,
-0.4324110150337219,
0.21584057807922363,
-0.17846840620040894,
-0.7441619634628296,
0.3110528886318207,
0.1946714222431183,
0.5136288404464722,
0.4006962478160858,
0.8288854360580444,
-0.1895972639322281,
0.4092288315296173,
1.2401549816131592,
-0.043041426688432693,
0.6083266139030457,
-0.020601723343133926,
0.07869413495063782,
-0.5311895608901978,
-0.019916091114282608,
-0.5654008388519287,
-0.4474516212940216,
-0.4591856300830841,
-0.3702201545238495,
0.1052805632352829,
0.047254208475351334,
0.17894598841667175,
0.3929348587989807,
-0.3511791229248047,
0.505807101726532,
0.5996297001838684,
-0.26723986864089966,
0.551118016242981,
0.23886801302433014,
0.24544207751750946,
-0.08619049936532974,
-0.48890018463134766,
-0.8384477496147156,
1.037735939025879,
0.22484011948108673,
0.43856528401374817,
0.05908547341823578,
0.6318516731262207,
0.3701649010181427,
0.685556948184967,
-0.7583325505256653,
0.4577878415584564,
-0.01781446672976017,
-0.9670136570930481,
-0.230905681848526,
-0.6335166096687317,
-1.1890562772750854,
0.13658379018306732,
-0.3043138384819031,
-0.772388756275177,
-0.19570502638816833,
0.12528812885284424,
-0.2699626386165619,
0.8118208646774292,
-0.5300477743148804,
0.18881194293498993,
0.05026395618915558,
0.15516094863414764,
0.10987739264965057,
-0.45330703258514404,
0.6684117317199707,
-0.30535632371902466,
0.2669649124145508,
-0.28267064690589905,
-0.25090116262435913,
0.6618435382843018,
-0.4253787100315094,
0.936802864074707,
0.37923118472099304,
-0.37015417218208313,
0.8208873867988586,
0.2810688614845276,
0.06617265939712524,
-0.11700324714183807,
0.27089130878448486,
-0.09965033829212189,
-0.1474776566028595,
-0.3950609862804413,
-0.19565792381763458,
0.3336159288883209,
-0.7125421762466431,
-0.22212660312652588,
-0.3083464205265045,
-0.5987889766693115,
-0.04752334952354431,
0.1151842251420021,
0.6984832882881165,
0.28787490725517273,
-0.4845733940601349,
0.04082414507865906,
0.4240832030773163,
-0.4255184233188629,
0.9476547837257385,
0.6617798209190369,
-0.20944637060165405,
-0.5574468970298767,
1.0976771116256714,
0.4032760262489319,
0.4216109812259674,
0.6398603320121765,
-0.0003426521143410355,
-0.2504269778728485,
-0.2990555465221405,
-0.3126249611377716,
0.46642568707466125,
-0.4340653419494629,
-0.07958831638097763,
-0.6983909606933594,
-0.5473694205284119,
-0.19900968670845032,
0.0262408796697855,
-0.4274902641773224,
-0.5378293395042419,
-0.5289586782455444,
-0.287681519985199,
0.4375726282596588,
0.8151291012763977,
-0.20239239931106567,
0.40983670949935913,
-1.1931512355804443,
0.07832564413547516,
0.06445176899433136,
-0.05517805367708206,
0.07905735075473785,
-0.7021506428718567,
-0.16977962851524353,
-0.37943002581596375,
-0.36049482226371765,
-0.966249942779541,
0.8310000896453857,
0.22269213199615479,
0.07803691923618317,
0.4131413996219635,
-0.0878833681344986,
0.48357242345809937,
-0.5736146569252014,
0.8580375909805298,
0.2711053192615509,
-0.7469557523727417,
0.46605294942855835,
-0.06418628990650177,
0.05558662489056587,
0.31195056438446045,
0.39010727405548096,
-0.7845344543457031,
-0.4712698459625244,
-0.9383007884025574,
-1.0100914239883423,
0.2500356435775757,
0.28098762035369873,
0.4653359055519104,
-0.3009371757507324,
0.2848576605319977,
0.504462480545044,
0.28340646624565125,
-0.660051703453064,
-0.05477345362305641,
0.18961529433727264,
-0.21285483241081238,
-0.3751816749572754,
-0.43724381923675537,
-0.13735367357730865,
0.42250874638557434,
0.22871717810630798,
-0.00997554138302803,
0.12268607318401337,
0.12272968143224716,
-0.16372951865196228,
0.033033132553100586,
0.13585801422595978,
0.409463495016098,
0.5732530951499939,
0.15498989820480347,
0.2236681580543518,
-0.08215092867612839,
-0.931632936000824,
0.24495220184326172,
-0.34632787108421326,
-0.43514785170555115,
0.06984269618988037,
0.6493812203407288,
0.6811157464981079,
0.08592646569013596,
-1.1645973920822144,
0.20369021594524384,
-0.12916651368141174,
-0.25356853008270264,
-0.5485495328903198,
0.16147857904434204,
-0.0025556120090186596,
0.04211394488811493,
0.5336021780967712,
-0.1667107343673706,
-0.03817623853683472,
-0.7028806209564209,
0.16330215334892273,
0.20222660899162292,
-0.18091626465320587,
-0.4430769681930542,
0.6234902739524841,
0.022151481360197067,
-0.6642966866493225,
0.7146819829940796,
0.020684750750660896,
-0.051413897424936295,
0.7426627278327942,
0.8371913433074951,
0.8908332586288452,
0.10081280767917633,
0.3959953486919403,
0.38683491945266724,
0.2976648807525635,
-0.3325260877609253,
0.369989275932312,
0.12882740795612335,
-0.8923193216323853,
-0.23337934911251068,
-0.5336416959762573,
-0.46291717886924744,
0.10990715026855469,
-0.5511151552200317,
0.044057223945856094,
-0.5520917177200317,
-0.25600069761276245,
-0.21256622672080994,
0.11676762253046036,
-0.16831590235233307,
0.32211801409721375,
-0.06898017227649689,
0.9949187636375427,
-0.8780301213264465,
0.5892932415008545,
0.24325819313526154,
-0.5039803385734558,
-0.8379669189453125,
0.21593603491783142,
0.03265004977583885,
-0.6708539128303528,
0.3159823715686798,
0.1592930406332016,
0.10819461941719055,
-0.04590323567390442,
-0.7038737535476685,
-0.787653923034668,
1.0669604539871216,
0.2308298945426941,
-0.5335018634796143,
-0.025315849110484123,
0.017071103677153587,
0.5419995784759521,
-0.0626734122633934,
0.2035360336303711,
0.7447186708450317,
0.1609104722738266,
0.1992274522781372,
-0.8216204047203064,
-0.1952398717403412,
0.09216176718473434,
-0.001132919336669147,
0.2824409008026123,
-0.8357672691345215,
0.8520022630691528,
-0.17576439678668976,
-0.6085935235023499,
0.39968249201774597,
0.8759047389030457,
0.5837785005569458,
0.29429352283477783,
0.5103206634521484,
0.6456754803657532,
1.0708695650100708,
-0.06982763856649399,
1.435977578163147,
0.07076215744018555,
0.10140706598758698,
0.9158754348754883,
-0.05115366354584694,
1.1130064725875854,
0.24390766024589539,
-0.33648958802223206,
0.329287052154541,
0.7932273149490356,
0.13264453411102295,
0.08493992686271667,
0.10803521424531937,
-0.3541106879711151,
0.0045421915128827095,
0.06919709593057632,
-0.1459338217973709,
0.3213856816291809,
0.3900512754917145,
-0.5024484395980835,
0.062353506684303284,
-0.14860689640045166,
0.34066712856292725,
0.020387811586260796,
-0.0009179998305626214,
0.7708964347839355,
0.3311668634414673,
-0.7044837474822998,
0.48018118739128113,
-0.1074923649430275,
0.6627275347709656,
-0.30253732204437256,
0.2978585958480835,
-0.40957143902778625,
0.14418096840381622,
-0.21756024658679962,
-0.9278488755226135,
0.5268754363059998,
0.3392173647880554,
-0.40461093187332153,
-0.05227620527148247,
0.7115218639373779,
-0.31225261092185974,
-0.560447096824646,
-0.03732277825474739,
0.7792923450469971,
0.6353748440742493,
0.12886641919612885,
-0.13883909583091736,
0.0675206184387207,
-0.09147421270608902,
-0.26256808638572693,
0.3618779480457306,
0.439280241727829,
0.07576344907283783,
0.8251913785934448,
0.4705424904823303,
0.4313865900039673,
0.28295060992240906,
0.14083026349544525,
0.38859063386917114,
-0.7097858190536499,
-0.39944037795066833,
-1.1578922271728516,
0.22703199088573456,
-0.08294297009706497,
-0.43754419684410095,
0.9266641736030579,
0.5601961612701416,
0.4118959605693817,
-0.007254994008690119,
1.017693281173706,
-0.17324195802211761,
0.9543853998184204,
-0.4801631569862366,
0.7198987007141113,
-0.4811481833457947,
0.14595456421375275,
-0.2817762494087219,
-1.0123286247253418,
-0.05391523987054825,
0.26271629333496094,
0.09520579129457474,
-0.10067560523748398,
0.5882755517959595,
0.47122859954833984,
0.23586714267730713,
-0.15175971388816833,
0.41067975759506226,
0.208355113863945,
0.48019903898239136,
0.6838146448135376,
1.0758142471313477,
-0.22054047882556915,
0.8694555163383484,
0.3190571665763855,
-0.37288182973861694,
-0.3122004568576813,
-0.9207757711410522,
-0.5553964972496033,
-0.6406170725822449,
-0.1212984025478363,
-0.4967024028301239,
-0.38947081565856934,
0.4176419675350189,
0.7632858157157898,
-0.30887386202812195,
-0.28444644808769226,
-0.20550020039081573,
0.14818039536476135,
-0.25512537360191345,
-0.2547469437122345,
-0.07181846350431442,
-0.36054301261901855,
-1.1289029121398926,
0.36952412128448486,
0.39864543080329895,
0.5903575420379639,
-0.4394156038761139,
0.27002257108688354,
0.15516583621501923,
0.6392536163330078,
0.46739381551742554,
0.7701190114021301,
-0.37363871932029724,
-0.15448147058486938,
-0.13588033616542816,
-0.22142043709754944,
0.24623075127601624,
0.8144885897636414,
-0.8271925449371338,
0.1474372297525406,
0.6368079781532288,
0.7387428283691406,
0.30153846740722656,
0.12624573707580566,
0.5405024290084839,
-0.9584232568740845,
0.20761515200138092,
0.3061634302139282,
0.15112251043319702,
0.4711080491542816,
-0.1934705227613449,
0.5700907707214355,
0.42707115411758423,
-0.6362109780311584,
-1.1125274896621704,
0.6084540486335754,
-0.7471440434455872,
-0.39545977115631104,
1.3593116998672485,
-0.14127866923809052,
-0.23485924303531647,
-0.08937689661979675,
-0.27600041031837463,
0.1430964320898056,
0.049436621367931366,
1.0110728740692139,
0.8846022486686707,
0.00774723244830966,
-0.1883196085691452,
-0.6388384103775024,
0.480922669172287,
0.09753203392028809,
-1.1975476741790771,
-0.16823647916316986,
0.39317214488983154,
0.47372767329216003,
0.10441111773252487,
1.0137066841125488,
-0.09964550286531448,
0.025652838870882988,
0.28060266375541687,
-0.13513624668121338,
0.4003193974494934,
-0.5315554738044739,
0.06065187603235245,
0.3415449261665344,
0.01616322062909603,
-0.13723810017108917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15471v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15471v1 | ConvoSense: Overcoming Monotonous Commonsense Inferences for Conversational AI | 2024-01-27T17:51:05 | 2024-01-27T17:51:05 | Sarah E. Finch, Jinho D. Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mastering commonsense understanding and reasoning is a pivotal skill
essential for conducting engaging conversations. While there have been several
attempts to create datasets that facilitate commonsense inferences in dialogue
contexts, existing datasets tend to lack in-depth details, restate information
already present in the conversation, and often fail to capture the multifaceted
nature of commonsense reasoning. In response to these limitations, we compile a
new synthetic dataset for commonsense reasoning in dialogue contexts using GPT,
ConvoSense, that boasts greater contextual novelty, offers a higher volume of
inferences per example, and substantially enriches the detail conveyed by the
inferences. Our dataset contains over 500,000 inferences across 12,000
dialogues with 10 popular inference types, which empowers the training of
generative commonsense models for dialogue that are superior in producing
plausible inferences with high novelty when compared to models trained on the
previous datasets. To the best of our knowledge, ConvoSense is the first of its
kind to provide such a multitude of novel inferences at such a large scale. | [
-0.4535907804965973,
-0.8714931607246399,
0.37730783224105835,
-0.1748439222574234,
-0.3632339835166931,
-0.1920117735862732,
-0.07710418850183487,
-0.12485340237617493,
-0.0620691142976284,
0.47248968482017517,
-0.909220814704895,
-0.36915677785873413,
-0.47601285576820374,
-0.024472223594784737,
-0.22702310979366302,
1.238335132598877,
0.6601443886756897,
0.07897582650184631,
-0.5025508999824524,
-0.09732332080602646,
-0.3664439618587494,
-0.14865528047084808,
-0.9385915994644165,
-0.38238251209259033,
0.3068448603153229,
0.5500627756118774,
0.9756074547767639,
0.11865124106407166,
-0.22126542031764984,
0.4634675681591034,
-0.16205689311027527,
0.5007404685020447,
-0.7088874578475952,
0.06349249184131622,
-0.45690688490867615,
-0.10247528553009033,
-0.08231879025697708,
-0.06759686022996902,
0.31128135323524475,
1.0524073839187622,
-0.2692314684391022,
-0.25579333305358887,
0.17044121026992798,
0.41018006205558777,
-0.40680378675460815,
0.22910600900650024,
-0.8125428557395935,
0.015368492342531681,
0.04917515441775322,
0.15626932680606842,
-0.33627840876579285,
-0.3137223422527313,
0.6979914903640747,
-1.381168007850647,
0.5136925578117371,
-0.012645384296774864,
0.4296332597732544,
0.4356761872768402,
-0.5067699551582336,
-0.3841492235660553,
-0.45772120356559753,
0.7532357573509216,
-0.8575955629348755,
0.18855232000350952,
0.013046224601566792,
0.502413809299469,
-0.3837282359600067,
-1.1017566919326782,
-1.0558351278305054,
-0.3681579530239105,
-0.2857555150985718,
0.10128429532051086,
-0.2904268801212311,
0.29320523142814636,
0.2828901708126068,
0.12472827732563019,
-0.47704726457595825,
-0.10254202783107758,
-0.41394445300102234,
-0.15878605842590332,
0.525398850440979,
0.22140882909297943,
0.07896339893341064,
-0.1936616152524948,
-0.48523905873298645,
-0.03599657490849495,
-0.5474399328231812,
-0.08450622111558914,
0.27567777037620544,
0.12994663417339325,
-0.21640993654727936,
0.0982537567615509,
-0.4378916919231415,
0.9212663173675537,
0.0356634184718132,
0.043587733060121536,
0.20326854288578033,
-0.3962737023830414,
-0.6768964529037476,
0.2207910567522049,
0.7816736698150635,
0.558551549911499,
0.45600613951683044,
-0.07749004662036896,
0.36914417147636414,
-0.013314931653439999,
0.17729204893112183,
-0.613045871257782,
-0.44791918992996216,
0.383419394493103,
-0.1957906037569046,
-0.3034537732601166,
-0.09118394553661346,
-0.9397350549697876,
-0.6778368353843689,
-0.5910776257514954,
0.0906197726726532,
-0.4538714289665222,
-0.43885403871536255,
0.37729722261428833,
-0.5415157079696655,
0.05751236155629158,
0.7634710073471069,
-1.0041437149047852,
0.5754591822624207,
0.976565420627594,
0.6097675561904907,
-0.12526017427444458,
-0.30474740266799927,
-0.5799732804298401,
-0.06745060533285141,
-0.42226123809814453,
0.7668845057487488,
-0.7079208493232727,
-0.4891173541545868,
-0.2476198673248291,
-0.0984431654214859,
-0.030879557132720947,
-0.7780543565750122,
0.6423482894897461,
-0.014711479656398296,
0.10046685487031937,
-0.15955901145935059,
-0.551506757736206,
-0.19601182639598846,
0.372866690158844,
-0.5970127582550049,
0.3594658076763153,
0.14983728528022766,
-0.4800867438316345,
0.513383686542511,
-0.7005622982978821,
-0.45045116543769836,
0.32822445034980774,
-0.20284859836101532,
-0.2377087026834488,
0.06469880044460297,
0.2984605133533478,
0.34662145376205444,
-0.418487012386322,
0.6649112701416016,
-0.34482601284980774,
-0.30207258462905884,
0.4302484095096588,
-1.0567742586135864,
0.6925178170204163,
0.37262019515037537,
0.03687930479645729,
-0.061756681650877,
-0.4530947804450989,
-0.28924307227134705,
-0.1262073665857315,
0.33969050645828247,
-0.38531407713890076,
0.09678085893392563,
-0.17815247178077698,
-0.20483848452568054,
-0.02911214902997017,
-0.6447631120681763,
0.1648053526878357,
-0.34170177578926086,
0.6111519932746887,
0.7463653683662415,
0.34825900197029114,
0.27940165996551514,
-0.47189146280288696,
0.2652602791786194,
0.2019711583852768,
0.3162476122379303,
0.03035012073814869,
-0.6698737740516663,
-0.5013012290000916,
-0.3183068037033081,
-0.29111427068710327,
0.41214945912361145,
-0.997441291809082,
0.02403288148343563,
-0.36559566855430603,
-0.5288339257240295,
-0.5110551714897156,
0.016683079302310944,
0.5551413297653198,
0.8126847743988037,
0.3657672107219696,
-0.078432098031044,
-0.33920812606811523,
-0.9105581045150757,
-0.31646856665611267,
0.32920223474502563,
-0.010880870744585991,
0.3938511908054352,
0.2791457176208496,
0.014690344221889973,
1.0109069347381592,
-0.4516734182834625,
0.010241399519145489,
-0.471678763628006,
0.4507919251918793,
0.5158511996269226,
0.728217363357544,
0.2562917470932007,
-1.070522665977478,
-0.38280513882637024,
-0.03800622746348381,
-0.6421975493431091,
0.13977457582950592,
-0.5243991613388062,
0.021700987592339516,
-0.11494912952184677,
0.6345846056938171,
-0.6717239618301392,
0.23254984617233276,
0.547896683216095,
-0.19224576652050018,
0.6030186414718628,
-0.07782649248838425,
0.11522882431745529,
-1.0576494932174683,
-0.2649003863334656,
0.0801316425204277,
-0.09929230809211731,
-0.7865945100784302,
-0.4548104405403137,
-0.5497082471847534,
-0.2803487777709961,
-0.7793892025947571,
0.8600003123283386,
-0.18626011908054352,
0.31491029262542725,
0.1502021998167038,
0.13418158888816833,
-0.004725965671241283,
0.828386664390564,
0.03807954490184784,
1.0957101583480835,
0.6273452043533325,
-0.6322183609008789,
0.7303832173347473,
0.5105491280555725,
-0.6806219816207886,
0.899445116519928,
-0.8865786790847778,
0.05852428451180458,
-0.1745670884847641,
0.28907719254493713,
-1.2348673343658447,
-0.5346975922584534,
0.2941395938396454,
-0.4039648771286011,
0.051237452775239944,
-0.5530074834823608,
-0.18131275475025177,
-0.093963623046875,
-0.07788661122322083,
0.3276854157447815,
0.2368205338716507,
-0.6623937487602234,
0.4611159861087799,
0.3252383768558502,
-0.29967978596687317,
-0.7025254964828491,
-0.6034382581710815,
0.10790174454450607,
-0.16162148118019104,
-0.426022469997406,
-0.09721918404102325,
-0.07547923922538757,
-0.25002798438072205,
0.003953675273805857,
-0.050499968230724335,
0.08044958114624023,
0.03934408351778984,
0.031914208084344864,
0.030813656747341156,
-0.0013833523262292147,
0.2582200765609741,
0.5122345089912415,
-0.3664175271987915,
-0.1608256846666336,
-0.37987375259399414,
0.46493712067604065,
-0.13194766640663147,
-0.5478414297103882,
-0.6763084530830383,
0.35884687304496765,
0.7583448886871338,
0.08705638349056244,
0.44238802790641785,
0.2476709932088852,
-0.1558985859155655,
-0.37215206027030945,
-0.31057921051979065,
-0.14683398604393005,
-0.5661487579345703,
0.5036892294883728,
-0.5406039357185364,
-0.8557408452033997,
0.22296975553035736,
-0.2812753915786743,
0.016553232446312904,
0.12776468694210052,
0.22006143629550934,
0.013393884524703026,
0.7897229790687561,
-0.18914468586444855,
0.04285662993788719,
0.2252480536699295,
-0.32209306955337524,
0.26417794823646545,
-0.7897089123725891,
-0.24433015286922455,
-0.09646996110677719,
-0.20274832844734192,
-0.9295907616615295,
-0.26846227049827576,
0.6841184496879578,
-0.4679461717605591,
-0.4099568724632263,
0.041252251714468,
-0.6153074502944946,
0.6636146306991577,
0.7604234218597412,
0.30653783679008484,
0.3438975214958191,
-0.10633791238069534,
0.17436596751213074,
0.027061479166150093,
-0.6780449151992798,
-0.2723560929298401,
0.9380594491958618,
-0.11856773495674133,
0.8610406517982483,
0.33173513412475586,
0.38911882042884827,
0.5457287430763245,
0.2765260636806488,
-0.6741016507148743,
0.7933379411697388,
-0.43131133913993835,
-0.4731161296367645,
-0.5449911952018738,
-0.5363350510597229,
-1.0898630619049072,
0.3684396743774414,
-0.17046181857585907,
-0.7458828091621399,
0.06624367088079453,
0.48860257863998413,
-0.4375287890434265,
0.19014467298984528,
-1.0960030555725098,
1.2889395952224731,
0.11517839878797531,
-0.5748693943023682,
-0.23643305897712708,
-0.6496304273605347,
0.5740541815757751,
0.44514185190200806,
0.042053792625665665,
-0.21379806101322174,
0.2510891258716583,
0.38671478629112244,
-0.5241228938102722,
1.1133975982666016,
-0.41414254903793335,
0.10190784931182861,
0.4795059561729431,
0.13608479499816895,
0.37609371542930603,
0.3938373029232025,
-0.055016085505485535,
-0.07693652808666229,
0.029244519770145416,
-0.42474403977394104,
-1.0064435005187988,
0.634533166885376,
-0.6492955684661865,
-0.7319989800453186,
-0.439003586769104,
-0.571359395980835,
-0.266584575176239,
0.03046141006052494,
0.27627304196357727,
0.9764244556427002,
-0.5503795146942139,
0.15991216897964478,
0.7598981261253357,
-0.19855137169361115,
-0.02803684026002884,
0.045479364693164825,
0.35762494802474976,
-0.5874415636062622,
0.9321762323379517,
-0.19994965195655823,
0.6416851282119751,
0.28332412242889404,
0.39884325861930847,
-0.45957884192466736,
-0.6676339507102966,
-0.5828930139541626,
-0.007292276713997126,
-0.6690114140510559,
-0.1915992647409439,
-0.504975438117981,
-0.09369370341300964,
-0.5940788388252258,
-0.3051559627056122,
-0.2478446066379547,
-0.5328547358512878,
-0.017366981133818626,
-0.1987144500017166,
0.4422219693660736,
0.5982398986816406,
-0.14601658284664154,
0.37718409299850464,
-0.5533758997917175,
0.4433952569961548,
0.9647510051727295,
0.03488039970397949,
0.07059244811534882,
-0.3862990438938141,
0.14162024855613708,
0.25273561477661133,
-0.21588777005672455,
-0.6381818056106567,
0.3016805648803711,
0.37069013714790344,
0.6959258317947388,
0.6576562523841858,
0.18250760436058044,
0.5883333086967468,
-0.31313517689704895,
1.0079861879348755,
0.2308371365070343,
-0.9357553720474243,
0.4153645932674408,
-0.5491462349891663,
0.24245049059391022,
0.7177646160125732,
0.24548771977424622,
-0.8581398129463196,
-0.3600061237812042,
-0.8588989973068237,
-0.5050407648086548,
0.5067331790924072,
0.09142468869686127,
0.5738217830657959,
-0.33312100172042847,
0.018642110750079155,
0.46535590291023254,
0.4179233908653259,
-0.3660804033279419,
-0.1172972023487091,
-0.5152681469917297,
-0.37133291363716125,
-0.06382216513156891,
-0.13954181969165802,
-0.3254835903644562,
-0.5114730596542358,
0.5162155032157898,
-0.2603027820587158,
0.23468205332756042,
0.2473709136247635,
0.18359357118606567,
0.4896635115146637,
0.43521586060523987,
0.7504914402961731,
0.5217646360397339,
-0.08950967341661453,
0.34984689950942993,
0.5085293650627136,
-0.36189004778862,
-0.049625374376773834,
0.31422871351242065,
0.043508950620889664,
0.010010840371251106,
0.28998932242393494,
0.8338221907615662,
0.3609395921230316,
-0.77931147813797,
0.39902907609939575,
0.14960379898548126,
-0.1978399008512497,
-0.41315045952796936,
0.5150333046913147,
0.08004669845104218,
0.23949532210826874,
0.10793057829141617,
0.21648934483528137,
0.5558224320411682,
-0.6360779404640198,
0.35863569378852844,
0.5655571818351746,
-0.10045507550239563,
0.026136215776205063,
0.37991175055503845,
0.40571579337120056,
-0.09289447218179703,
0.827102541923523,
-0.6344349384307861,
-0.4043520987033844,
0.5784726738929749,
0.319719523191452,
0.7868182063102722,
-0.0013803312322124839,
0.5681599378585815,
0.5400876998901367,
-0.06331034749746323,
0.075384221971035,
-0.1385960876941681,
-0.5293678641319275,
-1.0507407188415527,
-0.1894688755273819,
-0.14216485619544983,
-1.0878303050994873,
0.33004993200302124,
-0.5111117959022522,
0.002783749485388398,
-0.44539687037467957,
0.28158578276634216,
0.07531674951314926,
-0.09412763267755508,
-0.4182155728340149,
0.19312158226966858,
-0.06514019519090652,
0.8308583498001099,
-0.8802950382232666,
0.6532161831855774,
0.1734314262866974,
-0.30683404207229614,
-0.2958950400352478,
-0.26614609360694885,
0.25633397698402405,
-0.8705092668533325,
0.07332799583673477,
0.04853523522615433,
-0.4134964644908905,
0.07448018342256546,
-1.1085904836654663,
-0.299706369638443,
0.8456713557243347,
0.3036552667617798,
-0.5112912058830261,
0.05498873069882393,
0.25844892859458923,
0.3223736584186554,
-0.16670134663581848,
0.16389915347099304,
0.8320455551147461,
0.47928664088249207,
0.5904443860054016,
-0.6910333633422852,
0.01319255493581295,
-0.3974068760871887,
-0.1411946415901184,
0.020083874464035034,
-0.49407118558883667,
0.6286369562149048,
-0.2362831085920334,
-0.14989709854125977,
0.2921222746372223,
0.559824526309967,
0.40387964248657227,
0.6841424703598022,
0.515929102897644,
0.6716114282608032,
0.876575767993927,
-0.14711132645606995,
0.9373188614845276,
0.24943503737449646,
0.14632132649421692,
1.6916428804397583,
-0.20946340262889862,
0.33453133702278137,
0.2811836302280426,
0.042927518486976624,
0.4291132986545563,
0.3869563639163971,
-0.04387764260172844,
0.6877220869064331,
0.17597582936286926,
-0.7811307311058044,
-0.33949029445648193,
-0.27321311831474304,
-0.13286612927913666,
0.3288714587688446,
0.7993841171264648,
0.09295079857110977,
-0.3685833215713501,
0.18149742484092712,
0.40933069586753845,
0.2101094126701355,
-0.06765712052583694,
1.0009244680404663,
-0.0216000247746706,
-1.0962636470794678,
0.7420374155044556,
-0.6391351819038391,
0.5690415501594543,
-0.664699137210846,
-0.22948211431503296,
-0.5297571420669556,
0.19533738493919373,
0.06287684291601181,
-1.0453054904937744,
0.3337557017803192,
-0.20667526125907898,
0.34400901198387146,
-0.27985939383506775,
0.3491704761981964,
-0.646169126033783,
-0.22134031355381012,
-0.26609137654304504,
0.25422990322113037,
0.2948715090751648,
0.04944011941552162,
-0.6608505845069885,
-0.24963045120239258,
-0.004169501829892397,
0.11591073125600815,
-0.10576168447732925,
1.0441844463348389,
0.25472238659858704,
0.6902216672897339,
0.7620480060577393,
-0.04424202814698219,
-0.07482846081256866,
0.1251305639743805,
1.0627845525741577,
-0.3060964047908783,
-0.31845563650131226,
-0.5899476408958435,
0.653594970703125,
-0.5735914707183838,
-0.6681543588638306,
0.38747042417526245,
0.5782567858695984,
0.9289717078208923,
-0.19593186676502228,
1.0720256567001343,
0.08367587625980377,
0.4384693503379822,
-0.7931029200553894,
0.44561293721199036,
-0.4026948809623718,
-0.04714003950357437,
-0.20065413415431976,
-0.28325849771499634,
-0.0095147043466568,
0.594822108745575,
-0.38265103101730347,
-0.05060769245028496,
0.40215665102005005,
1.017320156097412,
-0.4043380618095398,
0.35769978165626526,
0.522097647190094,
0.2090551257133484,
0.46679264307022095,
0.8517053723335266,
0.910893440246582,
-0.051003482192754745,
0.3651026785373688,
0.02259376086294651,
-0.1631658971309662,
0.04591958597302437,
-0.8860664963722229,
-0.771124005317688,
-0.6098344326019287,
-0.17015710473060608,
-0.24571259319782257,
0.25057652592658997,
1.1015623807907104,
0.7971916794776917,
-0.8750531673431396,
-0.0387788861989975,
-0.6484571099281311,
0.2700687050819397,
-0.4448968470096588,
-0.2780739963054657,
0.16645288467407227,
-0.4989261031150818,
-1.0412718057632446,
0.379656583070755,
-0.06499478220939636,
0.13644643127918243,
0.006328957621008158,
-0.1576286256313324,
-0.1787775158882141,
0.1783463954925537,
0.46356508135795593,
0.4906054735183716,
-0.5814304947853088,
-0.3524567186832428,
-0.30525943636894226,
0.2297167032957077,
0.057573914527893066,
0.8757418990135193,
-0.8059017062187195,
0.8618929982185364,
0.27141430974006653,
0.5019687414169312,
0.7541602849960327,
0.017418015748262405,
0.6469195485115051,
-0.7794261574745178,
0.6248489618301392,
0.27435728907585144,
0.1831609159708023,
0.47718673944473267,
-0.22190707921981812,
0.4410859942436218,
0.4112470746040344,
-0.19535060226917267,
-0.4492934048175812,
0.5428792238235474,
-1.2672545909881592,
-0.35428839921951294,
0.9741249084472656,
0.03318187966942787,
0.12405340373516083,
-0.48664233088493347,
-0.403840035200119,
0.24356746673583984,
-0.6327464580535889,
0.609794020652771,
0.4547242224216461,
-0.18683619797229767,
-0.470734566450119,
-0.4725302755832672,
0.9637964367866516,
0.30909138917922974,
-0.9705649018287659,
0.33761608600616455,
0.5366402864456177,
0.1784195899963379,
0.07118899375200272,
0.7480732202529907,
0.30106842517852783,
0.3934211730957031,
0.2766408920288086,
-0.47444623708724976,
-0.3045389950275421,
-0.2500416338443756,
0.15968133509159088,
-0.02689105086028576,
-0.33575543761253357,
-0.4341789782047272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15463v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15463v1 | DataFrame QA: A Universal LLM Framework on DataFrame Question Answering Without Data Exposure | 2024-01-27T17:06:53 | 2024-01-27T17:06:53 | Junyi Ye, Mengnan Du, Guiling Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper introduces DataFrame question answering (QA), a novel task that
utilizes large language models (LLMs) to generate Pandas queries for
information retrieval and data analysis on dataframes, emphasizing safe and
non-revealing data handling. Our method, which solely relies on dataframe
column names, not only ensures data privacy but also significantly reduces the
context window in the prompt, streamlining information processing and
addressing major challenges in LLM-based data analysis. We propose DataFrame QA
as a comprehensive framework that includes safe Pandas query generation and
code execution. Various LLMs, notably GPT-4, are evaluated using the pass@1
metric on the renowned WikiSQL and our newly developed 'UCI-DataFrameQA',
tailored for complex data analysis queries. Our findings indicate that GPT-4
achieves pass@1 rates of 86% on WikiSQL and 97% on UCI-DataFrameQA,
underscoring its capability in securely retrieving and aggregating dataframe
values and conducting sophisticated data analyses. This approach, deployable in
a zero-shot manner without prior training or adjustments, proves to be highly
adaptable and secure for diverse applications. | [
-0.17560404539108276,
-1.2169969081878662,
0.19107474386692047,
0.4183063209056854,
-0.04135624319314957,
-0.058621373027563095,
0.4536360800266266,
-0.14907094836235046,
0.21384979784488678,
0.6723793148994446,
-0.6257184743881226,
-0.6265878081321716,
-0.037252265959978104,
0.304242342710495,
-0.9284306168556213,
1.061856985092163,
-0.1750670075416565,
-0.15201729536056519,
-0.5295693874359131,
-0.11926084011793137,
0.0002925350854638964,
-0.7606417536735535,
-0.3351653516292572,
0.30294349789619446,
0.3542357087135315,
0.29413917660713196,
0.8487046957015991,
0.4997863173484802,
0.5052861571311951,
0.1862976998090744,
-0.31844568252563477,
-0.2670227587223053,
-0.636725902557373,
0.3807837963104248,
-0.14982262253761292,
-0.8320337533950806,
-0.4576759338378906,
-0.13433955609798431,
0.7673636674880981,
0.9414103031158447,
-0.4136141836643219,
0.4582890272140503,
-0.27223071455955505,
0.9365043044090271,
-0.6541532278060913,
0.19536665081977844,
-0.6845701932907104,
0.325610876083374,
-0.43010953068733215,
-0.29819974303245544,
-0.02189100906252861,
-0.7898296117782593,
-0.16467982530593872,
-0.927014946937561,
0.23006117343902588,
0.3065272271633148,
0.6641850471496582,
0.4467427730560303,
-0.49084749817848206,
0.04554641246795654,
-0.16526736319065094,
0.37325990200042725,
-0.4103223383426666,
0.12529197335243225,
0.3746568262577057,
0.49027514457702637,
-0.43241697549819946,
-0.8148104548454285,
-0.8156197667121887,
0.15762992203235626,
0.14913658797740936,
-0.18564125895500183,
-0.3139384686946869,
-0.01878546178340912,
0.4818466007709503,
0.4590325355529785,
-0.8649705648422241,
-0.021661190316081047,
-0.46446990966796875,
-0.1616157591342926,
0.36875441670417786,
0.5240489840507507,
0.23596219718456268,
-0.3842528462409973,
-0.2729465067386627,
0.1823970228433609,
-0.986209511756897,
0.3673062026500702,
0.4325530529022217,
-0.10416953265666962,
0.23465441167354584,
0.8965645432472229,
-0.8868089318275452,
0.47373396158218384,
-0.12454799562692642,
0.37549346685409546,
-0.008150500245392323,
-0.6124730110168457,
-0.3478464186191559,
-0.07735894620418549,
0.6825132966041565,
0.4483458995819092,
0.3373293876647949,
-0.4390161335468292,
0.05395792797207832,
0.024996675550937653,
0.03780604526400566,
-1.1766083240509033,
-0.2662990689277649,
0.5705851912498474,
-0.2722999155521393,
-0.6280860304832458,
-0.07324477285146713,
-1.1243549585342407,
-0.3408086597919464,
-0.009711611084640026,
0.18569904565811157,
-0.19209913909435272,
-0.46906808018684387,
-0.07977791875600815,
0.003598738694563508,
0.5660445690155029,
0.03614087402820587,
-0.8853846192359924,
0.4034169614315033,
0.6813441514968872,
0.3950338065624237,
-0.2285757064819336,
-0.15088097751140594,
-1.0355767011642456,
0.26421353220939636,
-0.9506710171699524,
0.8033608198165894,
-0.548791766166687,
-0.2891779839992523,
-0.10022236406803131,
0.019894346594810486,
-0.07376307994127274,
-0.6100788116455078,
0.22906450927257538,
-0.9254535436630249,
0.25720369815826416,
-0.3566420376300812,
-0.701532781124115,
-0.4783470928668976,
0.15755681693553925,
-0.6815109252929688,
0.9926248788833618,
0.3514530658721924,
-1.1036357879638672,
0.43877506256103516,
-0.7279658913612366,
-0.2149423062801361,
0.06581083685159683,
-0.1536746770143509,
-0.2564793527126312,
-0.3186624348163605,
0.49797478318214417,
0.5341994166374207,
-0.06925372779369354,
0.25549376010894775,
-0.8234344124794006,
-0.4594306945800781,
0.6761796474456787,
-0.5628520250320435,
0.9648780822753906,
0.11579973250627518,
-0.12471232563257217,
0.12193017452955246,
-0.7976085543632507,
0.32263845205307007,
0.13471046090126038,
-0.2811203896999359,
0.13732101023197174,
-0.42894354462623596,
0.1263917088508606,
-0.1581534445285797,
0.16146183013916016,
-0.44016289710998535,
0.18840663135051727,
-0.2787008583545685,
0.3884880840778351,
0.7142692804336548,
0.20164790749549866,
0.2788352370262146,
0.025383155792951584,
0.9764346480369568,
0.27668043971061707,
0.04220971092581749,
-0.17814160883426666,
-0.4696238338947296,
-0.4235883057117462,
-0.040716659277677536,
0.5453943014144897,
0.8391762971878052,
-0.8700349926948547,
0.17772138118743896,
-0.21527501940727234,
-0.17638227343559265,
-0.3322579562664032,
0.39260393381118774,
0.001255998038686812,
0.5587266683578491,
0.1696896106004715,
-0.114982008934021,
-0.22061312198638916,
-0.639976441860199,
-0.025968322530388832,
-0.41212451457977295,
-0.04753682017326355,
-0.008119693025946617,
0.2996584475040436,
-0.1409926861524582,
1.2187844514846802,
-0.6494215726852417,
-0.007384725380688906,
-0.21971483528614044,
-0.23493541777133942,
0.2753927707672119,
0.36834532022476196,
0.7092337012290955,
-0.9996561408042908,
-0.3383009731769562,
-0.3895084261894226,
-1.057019591331482,
-0.01253656018525362,
0.2971850037574768,
-0.37482720613479614,
0.259754478931427,
0.28577446937561035,
-0.8250383138656616,
0.6705458164215088,
0.22230929136276245,
-0.46183186769485474,
0.5404337644577026,
-0.007484746165573597,
-0.031751617789268494,
-0.9065685868263245,
0.45941704511642456,
-0.09901013970375061,
-0.10685927420854568,
-0.6948630809783936,
0.2573937177658081,
0.21633699536323547,
-0.4941989481449127,
-0.3532377779483795,
0.4704430103302002,
0.04086568206548691,
-0.24257616698741913,
0.1324414163827896,
-0.05417288467288017,
0.22991825640201569,
0.48180025815963745,
-0.23759853839874268,
1.0855259895324707,
0.7366609573364258,
-0.6278721690177917,
0.6703642010688782,
0.6270774006843567,
-0.4449426531791687,
0.7739933133125305,
-0.664454996585846,
0.04639123007655144,
-0.35850396752357483,
0.41843181848526,
-0.9943467378616333,
-0.3700132966041565,
0.5130121111869812,
-0.35282886028289795,
0.31004324555397034,
0.17847147583961487,
-0.5671448111534119,
-0.31432706117630005,
-0.3337794542312622,
0.2624744474887848,
-0.04377464950084686,
-0.5652886033058167,
0.14294913411140442,
0.4033058285713196,
-0.6462459564208984,
-0.8894761800765991,
-0.6912312507629395,
0.31899237632751465,
-0.5866913199424744,
-0.7701445817947388,
0.02724279649555683,
-0.40153801441192627,
-0.2268555462360382,
0.16237270832061768,
-0.2637369930744171,
-0.7372869253158569,
0.42171865701675415,
0.03581249713897705,
0.38123396039009094,
-0.35622355341911316,
-0.1822534203529358,
0.3151869773864746,
-0.25030723214149475,
0.08932319283485413,
0.20501886308193207,
0.035092659294605255,
-0.08630707859992981,
-0.0190131776034832,
-0.7740258574485779,
0.5882166028022766,
0.19909417629241943,
-0.21512548625469208,
0.41143056750297546,
0.5011724829673767,
-0.24750953912734985,
-0.06842560321092606,
-0.3310019373893738,
0.125676691532135,
-0.4667436182498932,
0.4094744622707367,
-0.5698592662811279,
-0.6031210422515869,
0.5301176309585571,
0.2532661557197571,
0.05697142332792282,
0.02536649815738201,
0.4033403992652893,
-0.15993250906467438,
0.7259438633918762,
0.6339560747146606,
-0.3419422507286072,
0.35783931612968445,
-0.20968379080295563,
0.20602908730506897,
-0.47636184096336365,
-0.0803740844130516,
-0.4732651114463806,
0.060456883162260056,
-0.3579745292663574,
-0.2019253671169281,
0.3850495219230652,
0.4452279806137085,
-0.18510887026786804,
0.18816004693508148,
-0.3101246953010559,
0.5663458108901978,
0.36209651827812195,
-0.13248106837272644,
0.40593254566192627,
-0.059446994215250015,
0.12894968688488007,
0.3074885308742523,
-0.5378677845001221,
-0.2513774037361145,
1.6092089414596558,
0.10281642526388168,
0.9391855001449585,
0.06025395542383194,
0.5012114644050598,
0.2432166039943695,
0.23345211148262024,
-0.47078603506088257,
0.5755295753479004,
0.29641959071159363,
-0.8742204904556274,
-0.5701347589492798,
-0.7606261968612671,
-0.877403974533081,
0.47110310196876526,
0.21598854660987854,
-0.6858381032943726,
0.17944397032260895,
-0.22779636085033417,
-0.5103772878646851,
-0.029943373054265976,
-0.6926761865615845,
1.065438151359558,
0.07048738747835159,
-0.12023425102233887,
-0.03730975463986397,
-0.5014007091522217,
0.5851042866706848,
-0.3496263027191162,
0.042018987238407135,
-0.2665247321128845,
-0.18945229053497314,
0.7921064496040344,
-0.20002666115760803,
0.4754672646522522,
-0.35091182589530945,
-0.11250801384449005,
0.24874693155288696,
0.19547335803508759,
0.2701036334037781,
0.3953431248664856,
-0.48272132873535156,
0.14411911368370056,
0.9170778393745422,
-0.5278175473213196,
-0.8697609305381775,
0.41725024580955505,
-0.39621099829673767,
-0.6220763921737671,
-0.23831628262996674,
-0.6183684468269348,
-0.18356844782829285,
0.16648508608341217,
-0.17940102517604828,
0.4486505687236786,
-0.32145506143569946,
0.41176456212997437,
0.6340330243110657,
-0.16235633194446564,
0.0913214236497879,
0.6074450612068176,
-0.468285471200943,
-0.3605208098888397,
0.9243407845497131,
0.34401893615722656,
-0.11415372043848038,
0.586929202079773,
-0.1501973271369934,
-0.7403566241264343,
-0.4042925536632538,
-0.6176934838294983,
0.021414775401353836,
-0.8814287781715393,
-0.37182414531707764,
-0.4153004586696625,
0.012834876775741577,
-0.418788880109787,
0.3923713266849518,
0.25997841358184814,
-1.0403118133544922,
-0.3890365660190582,
-0.4291008412837982,
0.45744144916534424,
0.39303112030029297,
0.09133011102676392,
0.02782614156603813,
-0.5014532804489136,
0.7084007859230042,
0.2549004852771759,
0.3699774444103241,
-0.34850531816482544,
0.00465858168900013,
0.156077042222023,
-0.04432985559105873,
-0.5305299162864685,
-0.8118658065795898,
0.1985844224691391,
0.2443569004535675,
0.6292359828948975,
0.566504716873169,
0.5210435390472412,
0.6116611361503601,
-0.3005256652832031,
0.8736579418182373,
-0.08830123394727707,
-0.8713878989219666,
0.3064025044441223,
-0.2109711915254593,
-0.35197705030441284,
0.4767023026943207,
0.33180710673332214,
-0.49006709456443787,
-0.4478051960468292,
-0.3659566342830658,
-0.6775050759315491,
0.6159732937812805,
0.1660933792591095,
0.12053433805704117,
0.15317443013191223,
0.5989898443222046,
0.2140422910451889,
0.4805399179458618,
-0.5400468707084656,
-0.255092054605484,
-0.5477790236473083,
-0.23933301866054535,
0.17351964116096497,
-0.06798774749040604,
-0.30536210536956787,
-0.2104124128818512,
0.43271276354789734,
-0.6723654866218567,
0.13178132474422455,
-0.06714826077222824,
-0.08946522325277328,
-0.15631280839443207,
0.435927152633667,
-0.0887000560760498,
0.8829808235168457,
-0.20050252974033356,
-0.299500048160553,
0.18255861103534698,
-0.07151263952255249,
0.23307043313980103,
0.37605804204940796,
-0.36519911885261536,
-0.18095740675926208,
-0.255700021982193,
0.4140182435512543,
0.12999142706394196,
-0.6049749255180359,
0.6338217854499817,
-0.29042986035346985,
-0.1093020811676979,
-0.17055091261863708,
0.30378258228302,
0.05954953655600548,
0.1635066419839859,
0.4586513936519623,
-0.49431312084198,
0.20772162079811096,
-0.24643589556217194,
0.3275369107723236,
0.4251643419265747,
0.02533644437789917,
-0.14589029550552368,
1.0593551397323608,
-0.10500294715166092,
0.48172712326049805,
0.7855852842330933,
0.1385284960269928,
-0.1905982494354248,
0.8086497187614441,
0.26662445068359375,
0.5398157238960266,
-0.04349883273243904,
0.5013740658760071,
-0.0790276899933815,
0.0834273248910904,
0.30043452978134155,
0.5074195265769958,
-0.35485076904296875,
-0.5094113945960999,
-0.2217959612607956,
-0.6595914959907532,
-0.9129862189292908,
0.008045462891459465,
-0.8208575248718262,
-0.14439508318901062,
-0.36874452233314514,
0.04176519811153412,
0.00792979821562767,
0.20393705368041992,
-0.5629076361656189,
0.1675843745470047,
-0.2266373634338379,
1.1413520574569702,
-0.34501802921295166,
0.7906046509742737,
0.3238413333892822,
-0.6360293030738831,
-0.46692097187042236,
0.055583637207746506,
-0.1898505836725235,
-0.6810117959976196,
0.5822920203208923,
0.3028036057949066,
0.6204829216003418,
-0.018580621108412743,
-0.6314586997032166,
-0.9416672587394714,
1.1378405094146729,
0.640150249004364,
0.06552285701036453,
-0.34758642315864563,
0.6252124905586243,
0.28723761439323425,
0.22621090710163116,
0.30316007137298584,
0.8339248895645142,
0.5131552815437317,
-0.032733090221881866,
-0.5314870476722717,
0.1800747513771057,
-0.273193895816803,
0.12808401882648468,
-0.31903040409088135,
-0.7279571890830994,
0.39320695400238037,
-0.3452485501766205,
-0.29230767488479614,
0.4915841817855835,
1.0082557201385498,
0.2348015308380127,
0.33329373598098755,
0.17463791370391846,
0.408628910779953,
1.2752773761749268,
-0.030960720032453537,
1.0733147859573364,
-0.40499964356422424,
0.20492254197597504,
0.3338126540184021,
-0.5050224661827087,
0.8680059313774109,
0.4812312126159668,
-0.5960972905158997,
0.2191464602947235,
0.8022148609161377,
0.20818927884101868,
0.47147393226623535,
0.40011072158813477,
-0.11522095650434494,
-0.11929178237915039,
0.13548609614372253,
-0.5778087973594666,
0.17840032279491425,
0.4780634343624115,
0.37014883756637573,
-0.3541494607925415,
-0.16589654982089996,
-0.10411734879016876,
-0.2725977897644043,
-0.1598937213420868,
0.5837812423706055,
0.22867168486118317,
-0.29088613390922546,
0.7707914113998413,
-0.14518940448760986,
0.44989514350891113,
-0.6937103271484375,
0.2872721254825592,
-0.7239651083946228,
-0.10534054040908813,
-0.5014111399650574,
-1.0563827753067017,
0.5020506381988525,
0.2670363783836365,
-0.194098562002182,
0.1281968355178833,
0.19484196603298187,
-0.23371340334415436,
-0.5529135465621948,
-0.10893679410219193,
0.31487587094306946,
0.34036019444465637,
-0.2708178758621216,
-0.7281241416931152,
-0.3026975691318512,
-0.1493065506219864,
-0.6854711771011353,
0.6399269104003906,
0.7467525005340576,
-0.043670814484357834,
1.1771321296691895,
0.8740081191062927,
-0.043524645268917084,
0.39968031644821167,
-0.2532675266265869,
1.017493486404419,
-0.7146490812301636,
-0.6633461713790894,
-0.18353016674518585,
0.08468087762594223,
0.13006220757961273,
-0.0508558489382267,
0.4496651589870453,
0.672798216342926,
0.4957903027534485,
0.2715776860713959,
0.7867550253868103,
0.13321742415428162,
0.7205925583839417,
-0.5576617121696472,
0.902550458908081,
-0.3862077593803406,
0.09153188765048981,
-0.23518294095993042,
-0.9388206005096436,
-0.34678515791893005,
0.38802453875541687,
-0.2770629823207855,
-0.34808725118637085,
0.5430137515068054,
1.0825644731521606,
0.16325703263282776,
0.46398618817329407,
0.2958753705024719,
0.027470752596855164,
0.5876517295837402,
0.42741042375564575,
0.6895319819450378,
-0.4628642201423645,
1.079302191734314,
-0.28602302074432373,
-0.1441396325826645,
0.11440258473157883,
-0.5838822722434998,
-0.5798072814941406,
-0.21220186352729797,
-0.307395339012146,
-0.34729474782943726,
-0.08510090410709381,
0.357587993144989,
0.30575525760650635,
-0.9336824417114258,
-0.08720829337835312,
0.07985898852348328,
0.39774927496910095,
-0.28981730341911316,
-0.41211140155792236,
0.6532438397407532,
-0.5165930986404419,
-0.6807632446289062,
0.5614610314369202,
0.025614896789193153,
-0.20914816856384277,
-0.41550979018211365,
0.11535391956567764,
0.5023624300956726,
0.01507355086505413,
0.2777884900569916,
0.4902956485748291,
-0.28429341316223145,
0.06248603016138077,
-0.0390133261680603,
-0.07814332842826843,
0.13370433449745178,
0.4007358253002167,
-0.7018641829490662,
0.25728362798690796,
0.6095981001853943,
1.068354845046997,
0.4388376474380493,
0.21211224794387817,
0.48840442299842834,
-0.37050533294677734,
0.004365064669400454,
-0.059631362557411194,
0.25791090726852417,
0.3608589172363281,
-0.5909812450408936,
0.5568479895591736,
0.2781696021556854,
-0.4143765866756439,
-0.9723066091537476,
-0.11641678959131241,
-0.907476007938385,
-0.0962599590420723,
1.114515781402588,
-0.30020707845687866,
-0.48227864503860474,
-0.24512317776679993,
-0.08003610372543335,
-0.06173020228743553,
-0.4799233078956604,
0.7014297842979431,
0.5010783076286316,
-0.2057340294122696,
0.007786274887621403,
-0.5527321696281433,
0.3573070764541626,
0.30735331773757935,
-1.1201990842819214,
0.3860144019126892,
0.3415830731391907,
0.6222366094589233,
-0.3447522521018982,
0.8660518527030945,
-0.31103387475013733,
0.3353803753852844,
-0.08087625354528427,
-0.4808625876903534,
-0.15895575284957886,
-0.17186470329761505,
-0.4038800597190857,
0.5956441760063171,
-0.42088082432746887,
-0.22226102650165558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15449v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15449v1 | Learning to Trust Your Feelings: Leveraging Self-awareness in LLMs for Hallucination Mitigation | 2024-01-27T16:19:30 | 2024-01-27T16:19:30 | Yuxin Liang, Zhuoyang Song, Hao Wang, Jiaxing Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We evaluate the ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to discern and
express their internal knowledge state, a key factor in countering factual
hallucination and ensuring reliable application of LLMs. We observe a robust
self-awareness of internal knowledge state in LLMs, evidenced by over 85%
accuracy in knowledge probing. However, LLMs often fail to express their
internal knowledge during generation, leading to factual hallucinations. We
develop an automated hallucination annotation tool, Dreamcatcher, which merges
knowledge probing and consistency checking methods to rank factual preference
data. Using knowledge preference as reward, We propose a Reinforcement Learning
from Knowledge Feedback (RLKF) training framework, leveraging reinforcement
learning to enhance the factuality and honesty of LLMs. Our experiments across
multiple models show that RLKF training effectively enhances the ability of
models to utilize their internal knowledge state, boosting performance in a
variety of knowledge-based and honesty-related tasks. | [
-0.3629136383533478,
-0.5192628502845764,
0.8471798896789551,
0.15986326336860657,
0.017943568527698517,
0.15075808763504028,
-0.12746354937553406,
-0.486604243516922,
0.2739357352256775,
0.5153213143348694,
-0.5844095945358276,
-0.5074580907821655,
-0.6628078818321228,
0.1653234362602234,
-0.06571365892887115,
0.9137508869171143,
-0.10555746406316757,
0.2341134399175644,
-0.49830320477485657,
0.05753996968269348,
-0.4215289354324341,
-0.7510766386985779,
-0.5480900406837463,
-0.6696035861968994,
0.4569912850856781,
0.3001228868961334,
0.40507975220680237,
0.3128364682197571,
0.2420734316110611,
0.277369886636734,
0.337615966796875,
0.30685073137283325,
-0.681294322013855,
0.38483017683029175,
-0.26827359199523926,
-0.638144314289093,
-0.07195304334163666,
0.12929028272628784,
0.10690321028232574,
0.21990160644054413,
-0.324123740196228,
0.06055993214249611,
-0.07141999155282974,
0.8341768980026245,
-0.5881072878837585,
0.33908456563949585,
-0.637615978717804,
0.5658215880393982,
0.5062040090560913,
-0.3970802426338196,
-0.4309718608856201,
-0.7568187713623047,
0.1499774158000946,
-0.5228376388549805,
0.10941369831562042,
0.17664973437786102,
0.666978120803833,
0.7178381085395813,
-0.28268179297447205,
-0.4566972255706787,
-0.5317167639732361,
0.656893789768219,
-0.5437839031219482,
0.7692420482635498,
0.648670494556427,
0.08949397504329681,
-0.09730536490678787,
-0.4274238049983978,
-0.6355825066566467,
-0.5732402205467224,
-0.23175513744354248,
0.21951748430728912,
0.2183922380208969,
0.2082863748073578,
0.2659316956996918,
0.20184117555618286,
-0.43167561292648315,
-0.199821338057518,
-0.1735280156135559,
-0.6927024722099304,
0.5587576627731323,
0.04905806854367256,
0.01408565416932106,
-0.18251992762088776,
-0.6012126207351685,
-0.3291933238506317,
-0.49820077419281006,
0.05719839036464691,
0.4600893259048462,
0.01263403333723545,
0.1573096364736557,
0.5773953795433044,
-0.2937706410884857,
0.3790062665939331,
0.1367010474205017,
-0.42179155349731445,
0.20239828526973724,
0.16007068753242493,
-0.34817516803741455,
0.49400150775909424,
0.7161060571670532,
0.4255991578102112,
0.30592766404151917,
-0.3260481655597687,
-0.28617480397224426,
0.3747992217540741,
0.5726966857910156,
-0.7471005320549011,
-0.18604524433612823,
0.22238187491893768,
-0.34446457028388977,
-0.5382470488548279,
0.133267343044281,
-0.6665728688240051,
-0.7850407361984253,
-0.3898746073246002,
0.7112658023834229,
-0.5600507259368896,
-0.3998631238937378,
0.364183634519577,
-0.012728899717330933,
0.15060102939605713,
0.3282083570957184,
-0.6987391710281372,
0.3474201261997223,
0.5837609171867371,
0.6157243251800537,
-0.34850311279296875,
-0.4956889748573303,
-0.48773810267448425,
0.06270045787096024,
-0.5044804811477661,
0.6532222628593445,
-0.2413552850484848,
-0.47186553478240967,
-0.021319381892681122,
-0.061705201864242554,
-0.11961962282657623,
-0.5157002806663513,
0.54145747423172,
-0.3906644284725189,
0.15528370440006256,
-0.5110763907432556,
-0.7874136567115784,
-0.39915552735328674,
0.5634368658065796,
-0.4457475543022156,
0.8444750905036926,
-0.017060507088899612,
-0.7031344771385193,
0.37793204188346863,
-0.41357582807540894,
-0.4101867079734802,
-0.3354646563529968,
-0.4781721830368042,
-0.3776269257068634,
0.2019595354795456,
0.04478411003947258,
0.5825150609016418,
0.33902642130851746,
0.11594375222921371,
-0.4607873857021332,
-0.2837285101413727,
0.39982640743255615,
-0.12702511250972748,
0.3500364124774933,
0.15344621241092682,
-0.5139333009719849,
0.19793713092803955,
-0.43259599804878235,
-0.09395347535610199,
0.05832662060856819,
-0.09986940026283264,
-0.2405620962381363,
-0.15966449677944183,
-0.548858106136322,
0.25868627429008484,
0.296766072511673,
-0.5562670826911926,
0.028660856187343597,
-0.3968215584754944,
-0.23634172976016998,
1.0222152471542358,
0.2192726731300354,
0.20510166883468628,
-0.4893691837787628,
0.5343024134635925,
0.3323129713535309,
0.17506226897239685,
0.403495192527771,
-0.15147584676742554,
-0.9867932200431824,
0.12244576215744019,
-0.16209162771701813,
0.36120933294296265,
-0.5782433152198792,
0.49669337272644043,
-0.06226147711277008,
-0.3648502826690674,
-0.56952965259552,
0.18317189812660217,
0.4469515085220337,
0.7818433046340942,
0.27978554368019104,
-0.3673776686191559,
-0.5715669393539429,
-0.7930907011032104,
-0.2155240774154663,
-0.502517580986023,
0.44315508008003235,
0.2732175588607788,
0.4804019629955292,
-0.17088629305362701,
0.9528023600578308,
-0.5481041073799133,
-0.6612136363983154,
-0.1423310488462448,
0.1889287233352661,
-0.29881271719932556,
0.3075144290924072,
0.1494392305612564,
-0.6549966931343079,
-0.2790377736091614,
-0.0630268007516861,
-0.9876555800437927,
0.2082231491804123,
-0.10216118395328522,
0.004499742295593023,
0.609290599822998,
0.5619100332260132,
-0.4921001195907593,
0.2955469489097595,
0.6889729499816895,
-0.5670189261436462,
0.6584982872009277,
-0.20553703606128693,
0.41958314180374146,
-0.8759157657623291,
-0.24987353384494781,
-0.14900770783424377,
-0.424632728099823,
-0.2781963646411896,
-0.31412485241889954,
0.015082471072673798,
0.4098188877105713,
-0.35576939582824707,
0.5726699233055115,
-0.2507583200931549,
-0.2380376011133194,
-0.3699644207954407,
0.15021172165870667,
-0.1013273373246193,
0.4972890317440033,
0.35191962122917175,
0.8319622278213501,
0.5313273668289185,
-0.667072057723999,
0.37544864416122437,
0.4122249186038971,
-0.42752182483673096,
0.5484747886657715,
-0.2914796769618988,
0.1994803249835968,
-0.042350273579359055,
0.13647088408470154,
-0.6542395353317261,
-0.10798650234937668,
0.40207383036613464,
-0.7671772241592407,
0.2179601788520813,
0.008135989308357239,
-0.35835620760917664,
-0.12683488428592682,
-0.23069491982460022,
-0.21790577471256256,
0.45751357078552246,
-0.779326319694519,
0.7715925574302673,
0.3437684178352356,
0.16469258069992065,
-0.7979755401611328,
-0.5733286738395691,
-0.1224941611289978,
-0.21894681453704834,
-0.40877652168273926,
-0.10728120058774948,
-0.37406814098358154,
-0.2581748068332672,
-0.06056598201394081,
-0.33276283740997314,
0.15318690240383148,
0.1932007372379303,
0.6367963552474976,
0.13638344407081604,
0.197596475481987,
0.42808404564857483,
-0.0011878754012286663,
-0.11291036009788513,
0.6414336562156677,
-0.37213781476020813,
0.48770153522491455,
-0.38139981031417847,
-0.493429034948349,
-0.4102106988430023,
-0.09349307417869568,
0.36078116297721863,
0.08605442196130753,
0.8401941657066345,
0.6663467884063721,
-0.33525875210762024,
-0.38015955686569214,
-0.8750845789909363,
-0.804145097732544,
-0.42607957124710083,
0.1916702836751938,
-0.532519519329071,
-1.1013423204421997,
0.31496310234069824,
-0.10958538949489594,
-0.3132871091365814,
0.133554145693779,
0.5562543869018555,
-0.16897252202033997,
0.9181587100028992,
0.8203926086425781,
-0.2995551824569702,
0.02081223763525486,
-0.006028438918292522,
0.3066954016685486,
-0.6251233220100403,
-0.38717061281204224,
-0.1931224763393402,
-0.09559450298547745,
-0.5801596641540527,
-0.34245678782463074,
0.3633666932582855,
-0.16892452538013458,
-0.13992856442928314,
-0.11534076184034348,
-0.36247190833091736,
0.3885469138622284,
0.46143853664398193,
0.4846547544002533,
0.45809099078178406,
-0.06901179254055023,
-0.22189471125602722,
-0.262300968170166,
-0.44644466042518616,
-0.37056073546409607,
1.0139446258544922,
0.4476678967475891,
1.0079269409179688,
-0.17690235376358032,
0.9726569056510925,
0.4330363869667053,
0.120675228536129,
-0.8365585803985596,
0.517204999923706,
0.5290644764900208,
-0.5070198178291321,
-0.44302430748939514,
-0.47726085782051086,
-0.3158682584762573,
0.03666684031486511,
-0.28674158453941345,
-0.5111445188522339,
0.10892660170793533,
0.28550851345062256,
-0.41231778264045715,
0.42660316824913025,
-0.44923028349876404,
0.5498338341712952,
-0.3278801143169403,
-0.3816869854927063,
-0.4711497128009796,
-0.6049121618270874,
0.6032996773719788,
-0.0295137707144022,
0.04868284985423088,
-0.13627950847148895,
0.09244881570339203,
0.7340245842933655,
0.07044194638729095,
1.1010798215866089,
-0.2276797741651535,
-0.15846118330955505,
-0.026137543842196465,
0.5743095874786377,
0.6418152451515198,
0.29582858085632324,
0.047388382256031036,
0.11099942773580551,
-0.14812271296977997,
-0.01399304997175932,
-0.6582619547843933,
0.647254228591919,
-0.9310547709465027,
-0.6785460710525513,
-0.7292150259017944,
-0.4302159547805786,
-0.5152775049209595,
-0.10083719342947006,
0.1805432140827179,
-0.11559616029262543,
-0.31660112738609314,
0.1285087913274765,
1.3552637100219727,
-0.04804995283484459,
0.06814847886562347,
0.3286135494709015,
-0.5477725267410278,
-0.4031607210636139,
0.8874351382255554,
-0.23951971530914307,
0.22798681259155273,
0.3140784502029419,
0.37563011050224304,
-0.6324470043182373,
-0.30432751774787903,
0.032951001077890396,
0.44408249855041504,
-0.9739899039268494,
-0.2927253842353821,
-0.925326943397522,
-0.3667948246002197,
-0.6664561629295349,
-0.07694508135318756,
-0.6678839325904846,
-0.32136639952659607,
-0.14972412586212158,
-0.7021392583847046,
0.5528109669685364,
0.8813108205795288,
-0.5597522854804993,
-0.04173476621508598,
-0.4375968873500824,
0.3146359920501709,
0.6095741987228394,
0.48478323221206665,
-0.17009906470775604,
-0.5158348679542542,
-0.2610625922679901,
-0.18572163581848145,
-0.11356746405363083,
-0.7404728531837463,
0.611207127571106,
-0.2876856327056885,
0.6237602233886719,
0.5206142663955688,
0.35451576113700867,
0.40943992137908936,
0.05607854574918747,
0.6629441976547241,
0.11531568318605423,
-0.9870473146438599,
0.49037203192710876,
0.041488002985715866,
-0.3450517952442169,
0.6521424055099487,
0.642310380935669,
-0.5730183720588684,
-0.5244556069374084,
-0.616141676902771,
-0.23775629699230194,
0.37659621238708496,
-0.056312527507543564,
-0.10227005928754807,
0.044374559074640274,
0.3156845271587372,
0.31038782000541687,
0.4511323571205139,
-0.9886854887008667,
-0.2546136975288391,
-0.43922609090805054,
-0.24608094990253448,
-0.17266640067100525,
-0.47242820262908936,
-0.5555149912834167,
-0.14087551832199097,
1.070338487625122,
-0.4882209599018097,
0.26859718561172485,
0.647091805934906,
-0.36010995507240295,
-0.24963359534740448,
0.0800868421792984,
0.7585832476615906,
0.5312947034835815,
-0.23406817018985748,
0.29874467849731445,
0.320649653673172,
-0.42281705141067505,
0.10155186057090759,
-0.2809903919696808,
0.00425464054569602,
-0.24870920181274414,
0.037801068276166916,
0.8304303288459778,
0.11379869282245636,
-0.4664425551891327,
0.5348876714706421,
-0.2787383198738098,
-0.4158115088939667,
-0.5826777815818787,
0.21047092974185944,
0.13089723885059357,
0.3495776355266571,
-0.030100496485829353,
-0.03116690367460251,
0.12193373590707779,
-0.36490821838378906,
0.4005456864833832,
0.42219486832618713,
-0.8526420593261719,
-0.1306210309267044,
0.3136557936668396,
-0.06872204691171646,
-0.008735000155866146,
0.5535996556282043,
-0.18101517856121063,
-0.911186158657074,
0.2712481915950775,
0.4736016094684601,
0.9522331357002258,
-0.279751181602478,
0.5214784741401672,
0.4645053744316101,
0.49589765071868896,
-0.29362139105796814,
0.40951937437057495,
-0.157466858625412,
-1.0549404621124268,
-0.1074443981051445,
-0.6643106341362,
-0.669883668422699,
0.07729832828044891,
-0.656539261341095,
-0.024191197007894516,
-0.48745888471603394,
-0.037991154938936234,
-0.9428002834320068,
0.3005427420139313,
-0.5744599103927612,
0.4711429476737976,
0.0875631794333458,
0.7549775838851929,
-0.8320919275283813,
0.8967389464378357,
0.40350303053855896,
-0.3467298448085785,
-0.939927875995636,
0.03720670938491821,
0.062460314482450485,
-0.9775764346122742,
0.6902849078178406,
0.14592809975147247,
-0.4609537720680237,
0.0701892077922821,
-0.6434239149093628,
-0.6503292918205261,
1.2071222066879272,
0.18470850586891174,
-0.41275814175605774,
0.16969485580921173,
0.1580633968114853,
0.33135920763015747,
-0.5149848461151123,
0.11307096481323242,
0.5853040814399719,
0.567093014717102,
0.04674610495567322,
-0.6624903082847595,
0.15555500984191895,
0.28760483860969543,
-0.29260170459747314,
-0.24770914018154144,
-0.6635676026344299,
0.3756914436817169,
-0.4582030773162842,
0.06057475507259369,
-0.27718454599380493,
1.0440260171890259,
0.5198034644126892,
0.22732070088386536,
0.7800866961479187,
0.7639103531837463,
1.0493136644363403,
0.05343421921133995,
0.7531467080116272,
-0.46918153762817383,
0.21079957485198975,
1.2137888669967651,
-0.32095932960510254,
0.7313492894172668,
0.6752707958221436,
0.25098755955696106,
0.5963212251663208,
0.5424537658691406,
0.12580329179763794,
0.48906391859054565,
0.11787692457437515,
-0.36227717995643616,
-0.4707302153110504,
-0.16206026077270508,
-0.3048062324523926,
0.3337724804878235,
0.36120644211769104,
-0.19887709617614746,
0.10629614442586899,
0.07806547731161118,
0.13212502002716064,
0.20820993185043335,
-0.08770751953125,
0.9757682085037231,
0.23491211235523224,
-0.6983674764633179,
0.1405615210533142,
-0.5582683086395264,
0.6882683634757996,
-0.7230032086372375,
-0.03612902760505676,
-0.47660738229751587,
0.0949346050620079,
-0.26447391510009766,
-0.7086829543113708,
0.14156587421894073,
-0.37831735610961914,
-0.1136743500828743,
-0.35877591371536255,
0.8961630463600159,
-0.396744966506958,
-0.1716090738773346,
0.6170677542686462,
0.5519020557403564,
0.17580746114253998,
-0.2880977690219879,
-0.5602745413780212,
0.3055814206600189,
0.1364043951034546,
-0.32619357109069824,
0.2985245883464813,
0.43472540378570557,
0.4360705018043518,
0.977450966835022,
0.5606789588928223,
0.4063490629196167,
0.10871553421020508,
0.130408376455307,
0.6535126566886902,
-0.8209852576255798,
-0.441215455532074,
-0.5913472175598145,
0.26106685400009155,
-0.1460910141468048,
0.02662314474582672,
0.791999340057373,
0.4326343238353729,
1.1458784341812134,
-0.25567248463630676,
1.056098222732544,
0.2957109212875366,
0.6535263657569885,
-0.6005198955535889,
1.0690068006515503,
-0.4186602830886841,
0.00010951468721032143,
-0.041968781501054764,
-0.7250694632530212,
0.009868673048913479,
0.9635944962501526,
-0.2676553428173065,
0.006031162105500698,
0.9275714755058289,
0.9659140706062317,
0.33921563625335693,
0.01937166601419449,
0.878770649433136,
0.41970741748809814,
0.25650203227996826,
0.39080750942230225,
0.9944157600402832,
-0.18047210574150085,
0.4496811330318451,
-0.8029733300209045,
-0.03936219587922096,
-0.18368059396743774,
-0.9484328031539917,
-1.0172319412231445,
-0.7036070823669434,
-0.33171242475509644,
-0.5865459442138672,
0.19148480892181396,
1.1398652791976929,
0.7230237126350403,
-0.7010024189949036,
-0.36524394154548645,
-0.14842240512371063,
0.32742780447006226,
-0.04524673521518707,
-0.24597938358783722,
0.12859146296977997,
-0.7788472771644592,
-0.38971319794654846,
0.5036060810089111,
0.29732003808021545,
0.1844439059495926,
-0.6086270809173584,
-0.541305422782898,
0.2109726369380951,
0.04059858247637749,
0.47067904472351074,
0.14026816189289093,
-0.6626896858215332,
-0.5427149534225464,
0.1924872100353241,
-0.26144298911094666,
0.04385332390666008,
0.8200181722640991,
-1.0185725688934326,
0.5105961561203003,
0.24154604971408844,
0.6084261536598206,
0.3028162121772766,
-0.0683429166674614,
0.5376889109611511,
-0.3148737847805023,
-0.22202247381210327,
0.2646752595901489,
0.2759667932987213,
0.39630308747291565,
-0.7487050294876099,
0.5343509912490845,
0.3043261766433716,
-0.6541546583175659,
-0.7402695417404175,
0.2284531444311142,
-0.9004461765289307,
-0.2459881603717804,
1.1172696352005005,
-0.02564859576523304,
-0.22636684775352478,
-0.04972080513834953,
-0.22028011083602905,
0.34836438298225403,
-0.4349048137664795,
1.418404221534729,
0.756998598575592,
-0.27595391869544983,
-0.1998179852962494,
-0.4203583598136902,
1.1440047025680542,
0.5107021927833557,
-0.9486210942268372,
0.1318967640399933,
0.41152602434158325,
0.3480491042137146,
0.204481303691864,
0.5851708054542542,
0.03919839486479759,
0.0999346524477005,
-0.17012976109981537,
0.39645275473594666,
-0.12787704169750214,
-0.6980921030044556,
-0.32803431153297424,
0.1507226824760437,
0.20951423048973083,
0.0021234010346233845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15439v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15439v1 | Pre-training and Diagnosing Knowledge Base Completion Models | 2024-01-27T15:20:43 | 2024-01-27T15:20:43 | Vid Kocijan, Myeongjun Erik Jang, Thomas Lukasiewicz | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we introduce and analyze an approach to knowledge transfer from
one collection of facts to another without the need for entity or relation
matching. The method works for both canonicalized knowledge bases and
uncanonicalized or open knowledge bases, i.e., knowledge bases where more than
one copy of a real-world entity or relation may exist. The main contribution is
a method that can make use of large-scale pre-training on facts, which were
collected from unstructured text, to improve predictions on structured data
from a specific domain. The introduced method is most impactful on small
datasets such as ReVerb20k, where a 6% absolute increase of mean reciprocal
rank and 65% relative decrease of mean rank over the previously best method was
achieved, despite not relying on large pre-trained models like Bert. To
understand the obtained pre-trained models better, we then introduce a novel
dataset for the analysis of pre-trained models for Open Knowledge Base
Completion, called Doge (Diagnostics of Open knowledge Graph Embeddings). It
consists of 6 subsets and is designed to measure multiple properties of a
pre-trained model: robustness against synonyms, ability to perform deductive
reasoning, presence of gender stereotypes, consistency with reverse relations,
and coverage of different areas of general knowledge. Using the introduced
dataset, we show that the existing OKBC models lack consistency in the presence
of synonyms and inverse relations and are unable to perform deductive
reasoning. Moreover, their predictions often align with gender stereotypes,
which persist even when presented with counterevidence. We additionally
investigate the role of pre-trained word embeddings and demonstrate that
avoiding biased word embeddings is not a sufficient measure to prevent biased
behavior of OKBC models. | [
-0.7660669088363647,
-0.778497576713562,
0.5823537111282349,
-0.24955129623413086,
-0.09860438853502274,
-0.20837223529815674,
-0.18134944140911102,
-0.44903016090393066,
0.08807960897684097,
0.6812897324562073,
-0.46394768357276917,
-0.6732066869735718,
-0.6469537615776062,
-0.2521594166755676,
-0.46401357650756836,
1.090783953666687,
-0.18497830629348755,
0.07197389006614685,
-0.4416532814502716,
-0.13078473508358002,
-0.5305858850479126,
-0.503946840763092,
-0.3108428120613098,
-0.38809195160865784,
0.21352961659431458,
0.21451552212238312,
0.6424413323402405,
0.46964335441589355,
0.48293235898017883,
0.11432196944952011,
0.19144845008850098,
0.12246895581483841,
-0.5716553330421448,
-0.13472282886505127,
-0.2501223087310791,
-0.28059065341949463,
-0.6474134922027588,
0.2575798034667969,
0.41804084181785583,
1.2999619245529175,
-0.17061030864715576,
0.2966423034667969,
0.1408088207244873,
0.578340470790863,
-0.6211879849433899,
0.4072643220424652,
-0.43185168504714966,
-0.14361990988254547,
-0.1431703120470047,
0.09168416261672974,
-0.2687552571296692,
-0.5768535137176514,
0.45128288865089417,
-0.6899024248123169,
0.38469088077545166,
0.18438385426998138,
0.9910698533058167,
0.1309487372636795,
-0.42608216404914856,
-0.25200361013412476,
-0.8001350164413452,
0.42197972536087036,
-0.6349327564239502,
0.5168307423591614,
0.48454004526138306,
0.1622103452682495,
-0.21589525043964386,
-0.7961859703063965,
-0.5162309408187866,
-0.21521320939064026,
-0.3111240267753601,
-0.0195320937782526,
-0.16432256996631622,
0.07165002077817917,
0.3262036144733429,
0.2424287647008896,
-0.4290682375431061,
-0.15153400599956512,
-0.36379238963127136,
-0.1613861322402954,
0.3029214143753052,
0.007060414645820856,
0.1434669941663742,
0.13355544209480286,
-0.3421400189399719,
-0.14188554883003235,
-0.7757322788238525,
0.07579605281352997,
0.09654689580202103,
0.3044835925102234,
0.22102610766887665,
0.37401604652404785,
-0.08969569951295853,
0.7965005040168762,
0.07561638206243515,
-0.237498939037323,
0.2182546854019165,
-0.33569031953811646,
-0.2832881212234497,
0.15908439457416534,
0.5494289398193359,
0.09064249694347382,
0.5421932339668274,
-0.4900967478752136,
0.17166845500469208,
-0.015358963049948215,
0.29708749055862427,
-0.7728588581085205,
-0.529183030128479,
0.02181216888129711,
-0.764249861240387,
-0.2755966782569885,
0.16609373688697815,
-0.5722135901451111,
-0.27900969982147217,
-0.3724350035190582,
0.754241943359375,
-0.6062934398651123,
-0.4966016411781311,
0.23805470764636993,
-0.17039544880390167,
0.00704137934371829,
0.23081380128860474,
-0.6178236603736877,
0.34484803676605225,
0.238032728433609,
0.37429288029670715,
0.19140559434890747,
-0.268741250038147,
-0.02716342732310295,
0.35573938488960266,
-0.4827899634838104,
0.5944433808326721,
-0.3590674102306366,
-0.2653520405292511,
-0.16567462682724,
0.07999904453754425,
-0.2901516854763031,
-0.5027458667755127,
0.27995678782463074,
-0.6880831718444824,
0.22825032472610474,
-0.5239269137382507,
-0.8092827796936035,
-0.43368029594421387,
0.389281302690506,
-0.5305758714675903,
0.8466420769691467,
0.17735430598258972,
-1.0648916959762573,
0.5957215428352356,
-0.6505187749862671,
-0.4203588366508484,
-0.3519444167613983,
0.07698351889848709,
-0.2158450335264206,
-0.1924244612455368,
0.22613058984279633,
0.5181296467781067,
-0.2321946769952774,
0.4061584770679474,
-0.6242967844009399,
-0.10610132664442062,
-0.2511052191257477,
0.2419494092464447,
0.672692060470581,
0.012147502042353153,
-0.15705029666423798,
-0.1732807755470276,
-0.7269904017448425,
0.14368487894535065,
0.17437225580215454,
0.02208123356103897,
-0.854620099067688,
-0.03039105236530304,
-0.6943758130073547,
0.15360525250434875,
0.25977951288223267,
-0.5516696572303772,
0.43876513838768005,
-0.16999082267284393,
0.017158955335617065,
0.4452327489852905,
-0.037512969225645065,
0.39384183287620544,
-0.22369709610939026,
0.420719712972641,
0.2955610454082489,
0.0666368380188942,
-0.11403218656778336,
-0.40134862065315247,
-0.5352767109870911,
-0.3933364152908325,
0.7525757551193237,
0.6006025075912476,
-0.4727535843849182,
0.5829644799232483,
-0.46659162640571594,
-0.40943798422813416,
-0.5453035831451416,
0.004178504925221205,
0.28380805253982544,
0.8625708818435669,
0.5632598996162415,
-0.5463210940361023,
-0.5443123579025269,
-0.8327166438102722,
-0.07103731483221054,
-0.25605425238609314,
0.054314929991960526,
0.189295694231987,
0.4941728413105011,
-0.14689047634601593,
1.0003288984298706,
-0.6286061406135559,
-0.3680601418018341,
-0.11192990839481354,
0.3321418762207031,
0.0969354435801506,
0.373085081577301,
0.6787440776824951,
-0.30586910247802734,
-0.1678709238767624,
-0.18424056470394135,
-1.005375623703003,
0.11847063899040222,
0.40371447801589966,
-0.3336728811264038,
-0.1572219282388687,
0.7542123794555664,
-0.591116726398468,
0.635747492313385,
0.27816545963287354,
-0.38583362102508545,
0.5855687856674194,
-0.11167245358228683,
0.30696532130241394,
-0.8931370377540588,
0.22740082442760468,
-0.2511330842971802,
-0.2626362442970276,
-0.6105480790138245,
-0.21093840897083282,
0.0448373407125473,
0.07226266711950302,
-0.0384596586227417,
0.44622549414634705,
-0.4107630252838135,
0.09863701462745667,
0.003468279493972659,
0.017330585047602654,
-0.021951014176011086,
0.3063744306564331,
0.21438731253147125,
0.32622063159942627,
0.5516263246536255,
-0.8187159895896912,
0.22130070626735687,
0.5226699113845825,
-0.37348583340644836,
0.39708593487739563,
-0.4973805248737335,
-0.0062022400088608265,
-0.34746143221855164,
0.2171814739704132,
-1.020786166191101,
0.037904106080532074,
0.2559792399406433,
-0.43406054377555847,
0.46669742465019226,
-0.2929553687572479,
-0.40121281147003174,
-0.4892447888851166,
-0.06266430020332336,
0.23906168341636658,
0.5219513773918152,
-0.5912358164787292,
0.453450471162796,
0.1671598106622696,
-0.018186042085289955,
-0.6856411099433899,
-0.3145609200000763,
-0.5341503620147705,
-0.18371181190013885,
-0.7978626489639282,
0.5054269433021545,
0.14947621524333954,
-0.16093580424785614,
0.5906928181648254,
-0.15530122816562653,
-0.24733354151248932,
0.040926482528448105,
0.0370883084833622,
0.46391886472702026,
-0.5440602898597717,
0.42215609550476074,
-0.13290855288505554,
0.17449939250946045,
0.13943539559841156,
-0.4533242881298065,
0.3249448835849762,
-0.08701588213443756,
-0.27824270725250244,
0.023645853623747826,
0.05478135496377945,
0.3341555893421173,
-0.2756645381450653,
1.240992546081543,
0.6271317005157471,
-0.5142526626586914,
0.0007665990269742906,
-0.526388943195343,
-0.3065086901187897,
-0.3325537145137787,
0.2970212996006012,
-0.42573001980781555,
-0.6140599250793457,
0.5329999327659607,
-0.35188326239585876,
-0.0052897133864462376,
0.44275206327438354,
0.23409704864025116,
-0.35133180022239685,
0.8021933436393738,
0.8827176690101624,
-0.13075730204582214,
0.23965279757976532,
-0.21905378997325897,
0.41270264983177185,
-0.5358155369758606,
-0.3546641170978546,
-0.5090564489364624,
-0.037635646760463715,
-0.4291808605194092,
0.08410418778657913,
0.17360343039035797,
0.6750952005386353,
-0.5198243260383606,
0.28942549228668213,
-0.16257458925247192,
0.2618435323238373,
0.5005276203155518,
0.20495417714118958,
0.3634558916091919,
-0.02983102947473526,
-0.21801680326461792,
0.07046658545732498,
-0.7741634845733643,
-0.4471515417098999,
1.5007506608963013,
0.17548254132270813,
0.735691487789154,
-0.04737922176718712,
0.6557043194770813,
0.3243114948272705,
0.6071080565452576,
-0.676372230052948,
0.25714007019996643,
-0.24320122599601746,
-0.8151604533195496,
-0.38571032881736755,
-0.4961884021759033,
-1.0615466833114624,
-0.008010108955204487,
-0.27944105863571167,
-0.7172738313674927,
0.2396538108587265,
0.28127986192703247,
-0.28285104036331177,
0.4704626500606537,
-0.709810197353363,
1.0578933954238892,
-0.05353694036602974,
0.08188404887914658,
-0.02296493574976921,
-0.6126553416252136,
0.7508956789970398,
-0.07870229333639145,
0.2863377034664154,
0.054498299956321716,
0.36457449197769165,
0.977162778377533,
-0.3352706730365753,
0.5218046307563782,
-0.43062829971313477,
0.0036810506135225296,
0.2339801788330078,
0.12230560183525085,
0.31826257705688477,
-0.1981453001499176,
0.15639452636241913,
0.1589231938123703,
0.31313377618789673,
-0.5291817784309387,
-0.639348566532135,
0.30696436762809753,
-0.882352888584137,
-0.46793457865715027,
-0.06008506938815117,
-0.15498003363609314,
-0.6999738216400146,
0.3561999499797821,
0.3683745861053467,
0.4357015788555145,
-0.4363466799259186,
0.04860961064696312,
1.0061143636703491,
-0.020333224907517433,
0.03348133713006973,
0.669895350933075,
-0.39536216855049133,
-0.08764225989580154,
0.6634604334831238,
0.22245030105113983,
0.19687975943088531,
0.13127826154232025,
-0.08313096314668655,
-0.2944038510322571,
-0.45296820998191833,
-0.13305941224098206,
0.3327144682407379,
-0.673265814781189,
-0.19186663627624512,
-0.6628513336181641,
-0.3851906657218933,
-0.6506684422492981,
0.27352991700172424,
-0.46816757321357727,
-0.32427603006362915,
-0.02703922614455223,
-0.032429203391075134,
0.2121923416852951,
0.8090680241584778,
-0.07638311386108398,
0.26433709263801575,
-0.834492027759552,
0.468769371509552,
0.27904537320137024,
0.36646199226379395,
0.16609874367713928,
-0.5772755742073059,
-0.38299471139907837,
-0.018485799431800842,
-0.25113794207572937,
-1.0909669399261475,
0.15833714604377747,
0.11329956352710724,
0.9048334956169128,
0.47818684577941895,
0.25941726565361023,
0.5994126796722412,
-0.18684934079647064,
0.353146493434906,
0.20816241204738617,
-0.7752360701560974,
0.6642175912857056,
-0.263853520154953,
-0.28783664107322693,
0.5927079916000366,
0.9431620240211487,
-0.21113713085651398,
-0.0994015485048294,
-0.865739107131958,
-0.6521489024162292,
0.7283630967140198,
-0.06512767821550369,
-0.33342263102531433,
0.007278879638761282,
0.3879389762878418,
0.23146647214889526,
0.39055970311164856,
-0.3829020857810974,
-0.5668207406997681,
-0.3883223533630371,
-0.28406086564064026,
-0.037395913153886795,
-0.10548534989356995,
-0.2652376592159271,
-0.5407336354255676,
0.9285416603088379,
0.013189643621444702,
0.4302956163883209,
0.2159949541091919,
-0.36959072947502136,
0.11795897781848907,
0.16503731906414032,
0.07158053666353226,
0.7205085158348083,
-0.5932417511940002,
0.026975546032190323,
-0.03588871657848358,
-0.4834033250808716,
0.12458633631467819,
0.3632943630218506,
0.0006394755328074098,
-0.1362464427947998,
0.48143720626831055,
0.7601386904716492,
-0.10467585921287537,
-0.1944221556186676,
0.6759262084960938,
0.08144889026880264,
-0.34270647168159485,
-0.13011141121387482,
-0.11193200945854187,
0.20482194423675537,
0.12614558637142181,
-0.0009067764040082693,
0.14453376829624176,
0.02527383714914322,
-0.6432483792304993,
0.13526006042957306,
0.4611016809940338,
-0.3798128366470337,
-0.35789430141448975,
0.4294413924217224,
0.10945384949445724,
0.32776015996932983,
1.063402533531189,
-0.18265266716480255,
-0.44748663902282715,
0.6253601312637329,
0.42406871914863586,
0.5057560801506042,
-0.19210822880268097,
0.21947529911994934,
0.49341881275177,
0.46021485328674316,
-0.24372151494026184,
0.0988539308309555,
0.06319653987884521,
-1.2029247283935547,
-0.4114464223384857,
-0.5802717804908752,
-0.06386126577854156,
0.6391829252243042,
-0.9094944596290588,
0.39285677671432495,
-0.27434778213500977,
-0.24991080164909363,
0.08899272978305817,
-0.02384253405034542,
-1.0442657470703125,
0.37261682748794556,
0.03914719447493553,
1.0045278072357178,
-1.0621507167816162,
0.9944972395896912,
0.8444067239761353,
-0.5962553024291992,
-0.963350236415863,
0.09312620759010315,
-0.43763551115989685,
-0.7359102368354797,
0.5706397294998169,
-0.0334339439868927,
0.15188118815422058,
0.16818764805793762,
-0.3917248249053955,
-0.8180136680603027,
0.9890203475952148,
0.4397706985473633,
-0.30120545625686646,
-0.2720900774002075,
-0.12377166748046875,
0.3983502686023712,
-0.42312368750572205,
0.3303065896034241,
0.8328931331634521,
0.6506821513175964,
-0.18353913724422455,
-1.1415069103240967,
0.16608382761478424,
0.07516627758741379,
-0.31119847297668457,
0.3413584530353546,
-0.30314505100250244,
0.6964812278747559,
-0.3520449995994568,
0.002612517913803458,
-0.1097995787858963,
0.46431028842926025,
-0.04859461635351181,
0.20787465572357178,
0.5564873218536377,
0.852732241153717,
0.9348966479301453,
-0.0029008127748966217,
0.8785172700881958,
-0.2309751808643341,
0.3542073667049408,
1.0444883108139038,
-0.07696589827537537,
0.6274429559707642,
0.17118144035339355,
-0.43130138516426086,
0.600281834602356,
0.6152082681655884,
0.09633488208055496,
0.7897817492485046,
0.08405481278896332,
0.05583773925900459,
-0.5793241262435913,
0.08482024818658829,
-0.9129495620727539,
0.4682885706424713,
0.3029508888721466,
-0.5938687920570374,
-0.39900609850883484,
0.06717567145824432,
0.032348062843084335,
-0.23282043635845184,
-0.3210543990135193,
0.7667911052703857,
-0.06968788802623749,
-0.5998857617378235,
0.6563666462898254,
-0.13477648794651031,
0.45940157771110535,
-0.8394926190376282,
0.03607812523841858,
-0.187272846698761,
0.19745352864265442,
-0.24763043224811554,
-0.5478624105453491,
0.31897997856140137,
-0.4165843427181244,
-0.5617164969444275,
0.005655939690768719,
1.0660470724105835,
-0.4856727421283722,
-0.25445660948753357,
0.49496105313301086,
1.0933952331542969,
0.15804925560951233,
-0.23313069343566895,
-0.33212733268737793,
-0.5876652002334595,
0.02593619003891945,
-0.3574439585208893,
0.45923128724098206,
0.4967018663883209,
-0.32860860228538513,
0.44639986753463745,
0.4483785927295685,
0.054767925292253494,
0.035296276211738586,
-0.10011406242847443,
0.8378456830978394,
-0.6287125945091248,
-0.28732535243034363,
-0.6292920708656311,
0.1746775060892105,
0.147502139210701,
0.039218153804540634,
0.48148393630981445,
0.2963428199291229,
0.890994131565094,
-0.2089255005121231,
0.9843741655349731,
-0.2264818549156189,
0.6971308588981628,
-0.3933146893978119,
0.7532658576965332,
-0.47190648317337036,
0.13502588868141174,
-0.3008323907852173,
-0.8287885785102844,
0.09715958684682846,
0.5608262419700623,
-0.38643303513526917,
0.15708668529987335,
0.854987621307373,
0.5575827360153198,
-0.3011202812194824,
0.18084800243377686,
0.2184038907289505,
0.3082450330257416,
-0.03853248059749603,
0.39223116636276245,
0.8684272170066833,
-0.2865477204322815,
0.7013229727745056,
-0.19149084389209747,
-0.44188225269317627,
0.11104148626327515,
-0.862382173538208,
-1.0200163125991821,
-0.4267956614494324,
-0.35252729058265686,
-0.4576326906681061,
0.18442502617835999,
0.4769558012485504,
0.9506775140762329,
-0.843529462814331,
0.18088093400001526,
-0.0550103560090065,
0.06918609887361526,
-0.1867751032114029,
-0.2265443056821823,
0.5174492597579956,
-0.3078089654445648,
-0.10351879894733429,
0.15677861869335175,
-0.3517257571220398,
-0.003179382300004363,
-0.12110786885023117,
0.07674653828144073,
-0.08988390117883682,
0.08473062515258789,
0.49087223410606384,
0.29819145798683167,
-0.3662802278995514,
-0.3101932406425476,
-0.04812009632587433,
0.16389526426792145,
-0.04938146099448204,
0.8491485714912415,
-1.1653945446014404,
0.31224265694618225,
0.34068161249160767,
0.49171215295791626,
0.5956641435623169,
0.07056310772895813,
0.5580938458442688,
-0.6012840270996094,
-0.09443046152591705,
-0.11581549793481827,
0.3314826786518097,
0.12768810987472534,
-0.2788870334625244,
0.5235486030578613,
0.49537113308906555,
-0.2921408414840698,
-0.617245614528656,
0.1835264414548874,
-0.5724274516105652,
-0.4909530580043793,
0.7026616334915161,
-0.5806261301040649,
-0.01086211483925581,
-0.33662259578704834,
0.09895721077919006,
0.503362774848938,
-0.13115397095680237,
0.7472829818725586,
1.0049983263015747,
-0.36332592368125916,
0.23907604813575745,
-0.48554980754852295,
0.565161406993866,
0.21224500238895416,
-0.8137032985687256,
-0.06441166251897812,
0.3054596185684204,
0.7542914748191833,
0.20531272888183594,
0.7868686318397522,
-0.2095956653356552,
0.040038906037807465,
0.04447726532816887,
0.32659775018692017,
-0.32758453488349915,
-0.3856811225414276,
0.24662715196609497,
0.2490389198064804,
0.042259037494659424,
-0.2769816219806671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01726v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01726v2 | AI Does Not Alter Perceptions of Text Messages | 2024-01-27T14:32:12 | 2024-02-07T17:04:31 | N'yoma Diamond | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | For many people, anxiety, depression, and other social and mental factors can
make composing text messages an active challenge. To remedy this problem, large
language models (LLMs) may yet prove to be the perfect tool to assist users
that would otherwise find texting difficult or stressful. However, despite
rapid uptake in LLM usage, considerations for their assistive usage in text
message composition have not been explored. A primary concern regarding LLM
usage is that poor public sentiment regarding AI introduces the possibility
that its usage may harm perceptions of AI-assisted text messages, making usage
counter-productive. To (in)validate this possibility, we explore how the belief
that a text message did or did not receive AI assistance in composition alters
its perceived tone, clarity, and ability to convey intent. In this study, we
survey the perceptions of 26 participants on 18 randomly labeled pre-composed
text messages. In analyzing the participants' ratings of message tone, clarity,
and ability to convey intent, we find that there is no statistically
significant evidence that the belief that AI is utilized alters recipient
perceptions. This provides hopeful evidence that LLM-based text message
composition assistance can be implemented without the risk of
counter-productive outcomes. | [
-0.18301521241664886,
-0.7294517755508423,
1.0029222965240479,
0.5764063000679016,
-0.3825714588165283,
-0.10204020887613297,
-0.24680420756340027,
-0.6079868078231812,
0.23788534104824066,
0.3106991946697235,
-0.30257368087768555,
-0.4119887351989746,
-0.8177005052566528,
0.4850783050060272,
-0.5163359642028809,
1.2092335224151611,
-0.09474048018455505,
0.01586068607866764,
-0.5023605823516846,
0.03696202486753464,
-0.7261446714401245,
-0.6109991669654846,
-0.5789017677307129,
-0.3896853029727936,
0.504600465297699,
0.4552071690559387,
0.7168492674827576,
0.2065303474664688,
0.7784590125083923,
0.35101503133773804,
-0.05671016126871109,
0.10080260038375854,
-0.45029884576797485,
0.09658198803663254,
0.16046980023384094,
-0.816432774066925,
-0.662514328956604,
0.1721559464931488,
0.6942354440689087,
0.43750113248825073,
0.08225975930690765,
-0.20220522582530975,
0.26570093631744385,
0.7260921001434326,
-0.5192358493804932,
0.11369073390960693,
-0.6952149271965027,
-0.03468993678689003,
0.00011577309487620369,
-0.03430608659982681,
-0.4524870812892914,
0.11162115633487701,
0.4700610637664795,
-0.6120591163635254,
-0.493855744600296,
-0.012029302306473255,
0.5090872645378113,
0.8183248043060303,
-0.4209255874156952,
-0.7070354223251343,
-1.0467196702957153,
0.7146980166435242,
-0.5534780621528625,
0.024029482156038284,
0.6468343138694763,
-0.007979903370141983,
-0.1335267871618271,
-0.1855088472366333,
-0.7935360074043274,
-0.472819983959198,
-0.23800607025623322,
0.3058652877807617,
-0.1947532445192337,
0.510078489780426,
0.25639864802360535,
0.38011136651039124,
-0.23674216866493225,
0.22555391490459442,
-0.2658216953277588,
-0.06042461469769478,
0.646737277507782,
0.3760456144809723,
0.7055567502975464,
-0.14414240419864655,
-0.2230389565229416,
0.12139438092708588,
-0.5371922254562378,
0.024094026535749435,
0.09720288217067719,
0.04812287539243698,
-0.45839592814445496,
0.8158586621284485,
0.3314395546913147,
0.5759044289588928,
-0.0011205027112737298,
-0.25233569741249084,
0.011134715750813484,
-0.17415912449359894,
-0.6400837302207947,
0.01361175999045372,
0.9022210240364075,
0.5215678811073303,
0.5237445831298828,
0.0552249513566494,
-0.14563150703907013,
0.3113062083721161,
0.4412141442298889,
-0.5996612906455994,
0.04669303447008133,
0.29953327775001526,
-0.48406362533569336,
0.040297046303749084,
0.28274792432785034,
-0.20468375086784363,
-0.6221473217010498,
-0.37215033173561096,
0.3904968202114105,
-0.31114885210990906,
-0.020613564178347588,
0.020079195499420166,
-0.06665554642677307,
-0.16138377785682678,
0.4286227822303772,
-0.7319229245185852,
-0.05197563022375107,
0.6523247957229614,
0.8267484307289124,
-0.31776660680770874,
-0.21930240094661713,
-0.073344886302948,
0.012192347086966038,
-0.3346405327320099,
0.752826452255249,
-0.7714402079582214,
-0.7730664014816284,
-0.16212603449821472,
-0.10080213099718094,
-0.2303028255701065,
-0.47852542996406555,
0.45663803815841675,
-0.03831195831298828,
0.3201740086078644,
-0.29513120651245117,
-0.5741077661514282,
0.0825076550245285,
0.0922933965921402,
-0.5816190242767334,
0.2930978536605835,
-0.16764958202838898,
-0.7199046015739441,
0.3350268602371216,
-0.5817174315452576,
-0.7429929971694946,
-0.12990452349185944,
-0.44709712266921997,
-0.4493411183357239,
0.525941789150238,
0.027351276949048042,
0.35795000195503235,
-0.01862400211393833,
0.06430965662002563,
-0.24127021431922913,
-0.6998221278190613,
0.8777012228965759,
-0.4694732129573822,
0.35261887311935425,
0.11505736410617828,
-0.33937087655067444,
0.07838980853557587,
-0.5077680349349976,
-0.3255525231361389,
-0.2770935297012329,
-0.4883072078227997,
-0.5019606351852417,
0.021153319627046585,
-0.08536116033792496,
0.08007194101810455,
0.2658277451992035,
-0.38870126008987427,
0.1385379433631897,
-0.5915625691413879,
0.2890259921550751,
0.9068286418914795,
-0.1296406388282776,
0.5616084933280945,
-0.5878380537033081,
0.5677053332328796,
0.012463330291211605,
0.016010364517569542,
-0.3031269907951355,
-0.5963220596313477,
-0.6634060144424438,
-0.313809871673584,
-0.0890163704752922,
0.6625748872756958,
-0.5428739190101624,
0.4064393937587738,
-0.05769220367074013,
-0.34316179156303406,
-0.5566321015357971,
0.14904893934726715,
0.5865670442581177,
0.267049640417099,
0.26784592866897583,
0.009772236458957195,
-0.4881296157836914,
-1.0487816333770752,
-0.29754582047462463,
-0.5350070595741272,
0.12169871479272842,
0.6508137583732605,
0.22651690244674683,
-0.3236519992351532,
0.6718207001686096,
-0.3772121071815491,
-0.507602334022522,
-0.23959675431251526,
0.08781536668539047,
-0.191172257065773,
0.3031751215457916,
0.3972720503807068,
-0.6135808229446411,
-0.6153849959373474,
-0.21257270872592926,
-0.6989830136299133,
-0.19425392150878906,
-0.474249929189682,
0.0884261354804039,
0.4159654378890991,
0.36293718218803406,
-0.8914874792098999,
0.47118762135505676,
0.6530234813690186,
-0.368975967168808,
0.23333768546581268,
-0.5013927221298218,
0.3492550849914551,
-0.9810103178024292,
0.000054402109526563436,
0.20186445116996765,
0.13481511175632477,
-0.582347571849823,
-0.3354952037334442,
-0.1086106151342392,
0.09571441262960434,
-0.22086545825004578,
0.5376890301704407,
-0.1523946076631546,
-0.017849434167146683,
-0.8242249488830566,
0.014663155190646648,
0.04608607292175293,
0.04263775795698166,
-0.013676130212843418,
1.0525916814804077,
0.44031625986099243,
-0.47890228033065796,
-0.1685439944267273,
0.29923221468925476,
-0.35863691568374634,
0.822050154209137,
-0.7996430993080139,
0.14582470059394836,
-0.48858141899108887,
0.3213908076286316,
-1.2375476360321045,
-0.29857662320137024,
0.4323287904262543,
-0.4547918140888214,
0.09234738349914551,
0.4618842601776123,
-0.09746885299682617,
-0.11170395463705063,
-0.007266218774020672,
0.20035262405872345,
0.5213499069213867,
-0.20775291323661804,
0.7374563813209534,
0.2501346468925476,
-0.027609074488282204,
-0.3946373760700226,
-1.2009882926940918,
0.3065412640571594,
-0.4303497076034546,
-0.44629785418510437,
0.415647953748703,
-0.3443283140659332,
-0.6895960569381714,
-0.3215210735797882,
-0.07859492301940918,
0.004674563184380531,
0.3380236029624939,
0.7152367234230042,
0.35268932580947876,
0.22653666138648987,
0.48931777477264404,
-0.0007403200725093484,
-0.03272784873843193,
0.22129420936107635,
0.09863511472940445,
0.1446574479341507,
0.22961251437664032,
-0.3973974585533142,
-0.9126660823822021,
0.44711172580718994,
0.7825785875320435,
-0.1513940989971161,
0.7935209274291992,
0.4359734356403351,
-0.22280611097812653,
-0.021957818418741226,
-0.43194976449012756,
-0.1995866596698761,
-0.465476930141449,
0.37088361382484436,
-0.03300221636891365,
-1.0399209260940552,
0.19643481075763702,
0.23929902911186218,
-0.15326297283172607,
0.10225129872560501,
0.4424712061882019,
-0.3911551535129547,
1.2185108661651611,
0.6321123242378235,
-0.2746833264827728,
0.8118104934692383,
0.21141523122787476,
0.2729444205760956,
-0.7771733403205872,
-0.02619253844022751,
-0.7350270748138428,
-0.3550305664539337,
-0.5241779685020447,
0.04246944934129715,
0.4395206868648529,
-0.1840859353542328,
-0.30327901244163513,
-0.11939007043838501,
-0.48618432879447937,
0.12369196861982346,
0.2958536446094513,
0.17713306844234467,
0.2829146683216095,
-0.019743679091334343,
0.42973393201828003,
-0.00986252911388874,
-0.43610119819641113,
-0.7593279480934143,
0.9909687638282776,
0.2687939703464508,
0.6733446717262268,
-0.07190415263175964,
0.5669741630554199,
0.4201182723045349,
0.5690351724624634,
-0.8721936941146851,
0.6112415194511414,
-0.3793741464614868,
-0.5556886196136475,
-0.1499718427658081,
-0.4754614233970642,
-0.8391549587249756,
-0.16470034420490265,
-0.49288588762283325,
-0.9038344025611877,
-0.14445722103118896,
0.2966386377811432,
-0.4079201817512512,
-0.0878891870379448,
-1.0402135848999023,
0.5808249115943909,
-0.46529629826545715,
0.12962624430656433,
-0.2949081361293793,
-0.40857741236686707,
0.09765486419200897,
-0.2011655867099762,
0.2907937467098236,
-0.08584760874509811,
-0.15310579538345337,
0.5250605940818787,
-0.3792077600955963,
1.0369518995285034,
0.015336472541093826,
-0.3837724030017853,
0.39030101895332336,
-0.12793788313865662,
0.6847483515739441,
0.07067999243736267,
-0.3068440556526184,
-0.2117471694946289,
-0.4773000478744507,
-0.1123812273144722,
-0.7333604693412781,
0.7796316146850586,
-0.98409503698349,
-1.0905193090438843,
-0.06030131131410599,
-0.4719080626964569,
-0.09390796720981598,
0.15055249631404877,
0.2890448272228241,
0.3324833810329437,
-0.11478957533836365,
0.2739424705505371,
0.3172959089279175,
-0.3180359899997711,
0.42962321639060974,
0.14537353813648224,
-0.06507478654384613,
-0.37288108468055725,
0.8193196058273315,
0.20792467892169952,
0.32238152623176575,
0.32128363847732544,
0.29099854826927185,
-0.19638153910636902,
-0.5923949480056763,
-0.47512152791023254,
-0.007838888093829155,
-0.7178943157196045,
0.08637157082557678,
-0.6957374215126038,
0.2947211265563965,
-0.1622118204832077,
-0.24676834046840668,
-0.0587259903550148,
-0.17735281586647034,
-0.6957812309265137,
-0.1656901240348816,
0.42031529545783997,
0.7878193855285645,
0.2732892334461212,
0.5971050262451172,
-0.8183805346488953,
0.2582111656665802,
0.2569442689418793,
0.18314430117607117,
-0.06628411263227463,
-0.34873339533805847,
-0.36466944217681885,
0.24452750384807587,
-0.04378373548388481,
-0.6116064786911011,
0.01629386842250824,
0.14888514578342438,
0.4464283883571625,
0.34774088859558105,
0.14315374195575714,
0.4186411201953888,
0.015746023505926132,
1.0527116060256958,
0.12463457882404327,
-1.1060470342636108,
0.37448158860206604,
-0.22547419369220734,
0.4973575472831726,
0.4746026396751404,
0.2658565938472748,
-0.29555386304855347,
-0.8012967705726624,
-0.2362368106842041,
-0.3943132758140564,
0.5709851980209351,
0.26107057929039,
0.7057839632034302,
-0.22594869136810303,
0.4179452955722809,
-0.14133229851722717,
0.30897989869117737,
-0.9565567374229431,
-0.484304815530777,
-0.37397974729537964,
-0.48076340556144714,
-0.17418991029262543,
-0.4904043674468994,
0.1632976233959198,
0.022812532261013985,
0.42553263902664185,
0.24932122230529785,
0.3193385899066925,
0.39079901576042175,
0.19947893917560577,
-0.18707388639450073,
0.4762829840183258,
0.8586582541465759,
0.405224084854126,
0.14024417102336884,
0.09004630148410797,
-0.002046787878498435,
-0.4732871353626251,
0.2264518290758133,
0.017857417464256287,
-0.4294087290763855,
-0.37226977944374084,
0.492672860622406,
0.9674129486083984,
-0.049236200749874115,
-0.7025469541549683,
0.40075141191482544,
-0.12146670371294022,
-0.08076443523168564,
-0.1102554053068161,
0.3622131049633026,
0.005319247953593731,
0.061526935547590256,
0.27598634362220764,
0.18189109861850739,
-0.027119237929582596,
-0.6139083504676819,
-0.34343117475509644,
0.790466845035553,
-0.5052780508995056,
-0.2653648555278778,
0.548491358757019,
0.2633836269378662,
-0.6495897769927979,
0.4737454056739807,
0.04038356989622116,
-0.32850852608680725,
0.5779618620872498,
0.5727661848068237,
0.7924162745475769,
-0.17597486078739166,
0.25009095668792725,
-0.03365226089954376,
0.39274337887763977,
-0.06978869438171387,
0.13759002089500427,
0.05612710490822792,
-0.8601635098457336,
-0.38691774010658264,
-0.0459025613963604,
-0.2643895447254181,
0.08947210013866425,
-0.11107418686151505,
0.09359310567378998,
-0.5321349501609802,
-0.5122177004814148,
-0.10433205217123032,
-0.29455626010894775,
-0.4294407069683075,
0.5726235508918762,
0.22815167903900146,
0.3952726125717163,
-0.6532116532325745,
0.633484423160553,
1.0600497722625732,
-0.28680336475372314,
-0.9760336875915527,
0.44471246004104614,
0.014054975472390652,
-0.6351790428161621,
0.29087573289871216,
0.40166738629341125,
-0.2718457579612732,
-0.16567668318748474,
-0.5839826464653015,
-0.5285344123840332,
0.6149774789810181,
0.27060750126838684,
-0.39202386140823364,
0.15135562419891357,
0.43860748410224915,
0.9548486471176147,
-0.5216553807258606,
0.4323764145374298,
0.12855245172977448,
0.7887827157974243,
-0.04903927445411682,
-0.910480260848999,
0.07250690460205078,
-0.21904617547988892,
-0.011103402823209763,
-0.015086285769939423,
-0.723901629447937,
0.9070170521736145,
-0.17975467443466187,
-0.3921695947647095,
0.18929269909858704,
0.4583170711994171,
-0.027680832892656326,
0.4217361509799957,
0.4125572144985199,
0.3508788049221039,
0.5563576817512512,
0.16880953311920166,
1.2209597826004028,
-0.2536311149597168,
-0.27527573704719543,
0.8425439596176147,
-0.4565774202346802,
0.48786088824272156,
0.6149858832359314,
0.1208878830075264,
0.45914527773857117,
0.10064820200204849,
0.2622315585613251,
0.21837159991264343,
0.13097916543483734,
-0.4070464074611664,
-0.34797677397727966,
-0.3845224380493164,
-0.27036455273628235,
0.7400357127189636,
0.4829583764076233,
-0.6594131588935852,
0.3156670928001404,
0.1778246909379959,
-0.07991504669189453,
0.5432142019271851,
-0.2999027967453003,
1.008982539176941,
0.35455620288848877,
-1.0323163270950317,
0.34616637229919434,
0.11332280933856964,
0.7885699272155762,
-0.12000387907028198,
0.061036620289087296,
-0.13116256892681122,
0.12773436307907104,
-0.4411122798919678,
-0.7349632382392883,
0.44298669695854187,
0.1265634149312973,
-0.27565962076187134,
-0.19317775964736938,
0.8717294335365295,
-0.23991036415100098,
-0.4799884259700775,
0.20122282207012177,
0.6782405376434326,
0.02434261329472065,
-0.19535423815250397,
-0.5460411310195923,
0.3581954538822174,
0.21049533784389496,
-0.10126671940088272,
0.23129802942276,
0.4298611581325531,
0.15351051092147827,
0.6065804362297058,
0.36433762311935425,
-0.05455845594406128,
-0.56281578540802,
-0.09883958846330643,
0.7362796068191528,
-0.3945862352848053,
-0.34552258253097534,
-1.1875412464141846,
0.6217062473297119,
0.018011152744293213,
-0.2496103048324585,
0.7293511033058167,
0.15748660266399384,
0.6794400811195374,
0.08333020657300949,
1.1491968631744385,
0.19874738156795502,
0.2185036987066269,
-0.509863018989563,
0.6919217109680176,
-0.5945904850959778,
0.5714015960693359,
-0.6408120393753052,
-0.9155795574188232,
-0.3033137023448944,
0.6490147709846497,
-0.6891068816184998,
0.3141312003135681,
0.3788621127605438,
0.6353021264076233,
0.33472275733947754,
0.2485109269618988,
0.27616140246391296,
0.03324331343173981,
0.373637855052948,
0.4777687191963196,
1.085290789604187,
0.033519189804792404,
0.5649127960205078,
0.06240076571702957,
-0.22951970994472504,
-0.18333066999912262,
-0.9012905955314636,
-1.338127851486206,
-0.38583481311798096,
-0.1800844520330429,
-0.14788557589054108,
0.02411572076380253,
1.1104775667190552,
0.3489738404750824,
-0.32292649149894714,
-0.09285172820091248,
-0.33878129720687866,
0.34138837456703186,
0.19950264692306519,
-0.15001685917377472,
0.15640978515148163,
-0.17680752277374268,
-0.6230494379997253,
0.28851118683815,
0.4884445369243622,
0.5800243616104126,
-0.34691548347473145,
-0.13904066383838654,
0.2484705150127411,
0.33432596921920776,
0.46356257796287537,
-0.06831479072570801,
-0.545194685459137,
-0.5119213461875916,
0.13161467015743256,
-0.5066871643066406,
0.29705333709716797,
0.8331079483032227,
-0.4255239963531494,
0.2788218557834625,
0.3713415861129761,
0.5584388375282288,
-0.14837759733200073,
0.2885854244232178,
0.7487581968307495,
-0.3813689649105072,
0.09510577470064163,
-0.1136849969625473,
0.2973124086856842,
0.4125503897666931,
-0.7578051090240479,
-0.20009735226631165,
-0.045723240822553635,
-0.5568748116493225,
-0.4890015423297882,
0.18141700327396393,
-0.7868215441703796,
-0.3252183496952057,
1.203870177268982,
-0.15810200572013855,
-0.14866293966770172,
-0.09071777760982513,
-0.5836001038551331,
-0.011452826671302319,
-0.7120823264122009,
1.1196213960647583,
0.9006577134132385,
-0.08826205879449844,
-0.25633272528648376,
-0.032987676560878754,
0.549856960773468,
0.6264070272445679,
-1.0019361972808838,
-0.05356995016336441,
0.6566888093948364,
-0.3306514620780945,
0.053078070282936096,
0.8422445058822632,
0.3140591084957123,
0.11056404560804367,
-0.32513248920440674,
-0.33550310134887695,
-0.0775182843208313,
-0.3661060035228729,
-0.350014865398407,
-0.018189605325460434,
0.28343814611434937,
0.22447457909584045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15422v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15422v2 | A Survey on Data Augmentation in Large Model Era | 2024-01-27T14:19:33 | 2024-03-04T16:55:15 | Yue Zhou, Chenlu Guo, Xu Wang, Yi Chang, Yuan Wu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Large models, encompassing large language and diffusion models, have shown
exceptional promise in approximating human-level intelligence, garnering
significant interest from both academic and industrial spheres. However, the
training of these large models necessitates vast quantities of high-quality
data, and with continuous updates to these models, the existing reservoir of
high-quality data may soon be depleted. This challenge has catalyzed a surge in
research focused on data augmentation methods. Leveraging large models, these
data augmentation techniques have outperformed traditional approaches. This
paper offers an exhaustive review of large model-driven data augmentation
methods, adopting a comprehensive perspective. We begin by establishing a
classification of relevant studies into three main categories: image
augmentation, text augmentation, and paired data augmentation. Following this,
we delve into various data post-processing techniques pertinent to large
model-based data augmentation. Our discussion then expands to encompass the
array of applications for these data augmentation methods within natural
language processing, computer vision, and audio signal processing. We proceed
to evaluate the successes and limitations of large model-based data
augmentation across different scenarios. Concluding our review, we highlight
prospective challenges and avenues for future exploration in the field of data
augmentation. Our objective is to furnish researchers with critical insights,
ultimately contributing to the advancement of more sophisticated large models.
We consistently maintain the related open-source materials at:
https://github.com/MLGroup-JLU/LLM-data-aug-survey. | [
-0.4880346953868866,
-0.9570179581642151,
0.7974782586097717,
-0.17549556493759155,
0.18249620497226715,
-0.006813223008066416,
-0.2606317400932312,
-0.7863248586654663,
-0.13835521042346954,
0.5363436341285706,
-0.5699162483215332,
-0.38090094923973083,
-0.49105799198150635,
-0.11428636312484741,
-0.5271182060241699,
0.44164401292800903,
0.10708130896091461,
0.20054765045642853,
-0.43363556265830994,
0.03147035092115402,
-0.6202979683876038,
-0.8442180752754211,
-0.3756221830844879,
-0.43555334210395813,
0.4575220048427582,
0.12627984583377838,
0.8015674948692322,
0.6215841174125671,
0.6730937361717224,
0.24057257175445557,
-0.20792584121227264,
0.47824907302856445,
-0.5573328733444214,
-0.06384557485580444,
-0.22087182104587555,
-0.281074196100235,
-0.7060664296150208,
0.08247060328722,
0.8270924091339111,
1.1652528047561646,
0.1173572689294815,
0.061451755464076996,
-0.12677530944347382,
0.7615683674812317,
-0.7153217196464539,
0.11304986476898193,
-0.4261864125728607,
-0.0023768360260874033,
-0.24620822072029114,
0.053962890058755875,
-0.3222350478172302,
-0.2174140065908432,
0.08631063252687454,
-0.597291886806488,
-0.021921971812844276,
-0.053323641419410706,
0.3640788197517395,
0.21240609884262085,
-0.6370316743850708,
-0.13121485710144043,
-1.1882072687149048,
0.9247878193855286,
-0.9129733443260193,
0.49797654151916504,
0.2878382205963135,
0.14708390831947327,
-0.30169913172721863,
-0.6599602103233337,
-0.5373135805130005,
-0.2616646885871887,
0.2357640117406845,
-0.050891291350126266,
-0.09974907338619232,
0.01171017810702324,
0.7016944885253906,
0.8293824791908264,
-0.48275279998779297,
0.5607098340988159,
-0.42852678894996643,
0.24757233262062073,
0.9140380620956421,
0.2448587417602539,
0.20570555329322815,
0.18320612609386444,
-0.08701858669519424,
-0.22988517582416534,
-0.8438851237297058,
-0.20132006704807281,
0.5839454531669617,
0.11227920651435852,
0.11538810282945633,
0.8136565685272217,
-0.44708526134490967,
1.1155827045440674,
-0.19622302055358887,
0.17708705365657806,
0.36969801783561707,
-0.5066654682159424,
-0.16261960566043854,
-0.2901509404182434,
0.4485195279121399,
0.3236841857433319,
0.09978920221328735,
-0.015121021308004856,
-0.39808303117752075,
-0.14371633529663086,
0.08330066502094269,
-0.8625646829605103,
-0.005792560987174511,
0.13215824961662292,
-0.4920094907283783,
-0.28002721071243286,
0.08256267011165619,
-0.6355687975883484,
-0.7009302377700806,
-0.6793178915977478,
0.5678644180297852,
-0.13144749402999878,
-0.3926604688167572,
0.31866151094436646,
0.0485803559422493,
0.3522753417491913,
0.5105240941047668,
-0.7063038945198059,
0.005002079531550407,
0.8985357284545898,
0.7863814234733582,
-0.10229561477899551,
0.06961266696453094,
-0.2716721296310425,
0.13748514652252197,
-0.7123295068740845,
0.5598873496055603,
-0.7533086538314819,
-0.4053998291492462,
0.07850063592195511,
0.014701156876981258,
0.2327388972043991,
-0.4536205232143402,
0.6067755222320557,
-0.6429270505905151,
0.2868334949016571,
-0.29796677827835083,
-0.8390476703643799,
-0.5053057074546814,
0.22970059514045715,
-0.808112382888794,
0.6553119421005249,
-0.0003030890948139131,
-0.6036406755447388,
0.23132100701332092,
-0.8758862018585205,
-0.44084298610687256,
-0.1922406256198883,
0.04593043401837349,
-0.3842647671699524,
0.21537983417510986,
0.5151988863945007,
0.68702632188797,
-0.5708731412887573,
0.23921294510364532,
-0.5771253705024719,
-0.43855926394462585,
0.3273448944091797,
-0.5706539750099182,
0.555087685585022,
0.10719333589076996,
0.2581617534160614,
0.08133313804864883,
-0.7724196910858154,
-0.22869868576526642,
0.1940203756093979,
-0.123407281935215,
-0.2428850382566452,
0.023788291960954666,
0.13356539607048035,
0.2091958075761795,
0.3640725314617157,
-0.5927953720092773,
0.35363495349884033,
-0.4121006429195404,
0.5892311930656433,
0.6458589434623718,
0.05963604897260666,
0.5535482168197632,
-0.24066126346588135,
0.2769317924976349,
0.04704086109995842,
0.1782389134168625,
-0.672448456287384,
-0.21105711162090302,
-0.3276977241039276,
-0.1855321228504181,
0.6786605715751648,
0.39749017357826233,
-0.5892951488494873,
0.6606554388999939,
-0.41369327902793884,
-0.577947199344635,
-0.5063651204109192,
0.10612063854932785,
-0.28214868903160095,
0.4006504416465759,
0.4101906716823578,
-0.15792734920978546,
-0.47142353653907776,
-0.9214919209480286,
0.20285366475582123,
0.07890056818723679,
-0.1850212663412094,
0.214114248752594,
0.16505932807922363,
-0.4020603895187378,
0.6769565343856812,
-0.5791394710540771,
-0.021504344418644905,
-0.17861486971378326,
-0.05143137276172638,
0.41109830141067505,
0.6595889329910278,
0.2652997076511383,
-0.8352465033531189,
0.1287682205438614,
0.17817634344100952,
-0.7065592408180237,
0.1676408350467682,
-0.1405608057975769,
0.17607437074184418,
-0.03423707187175751,
0.5171130299568176,
-0.722363293170929,
0.40831923484802246,
0.49557894468307495,
0.18937048316001892,
0.42956286668777466,
-0.36910319328308105,
0.3609619140625,
-0.955084502696991,
0.20480798184871674,
0.25645244121551514,
-0.19837601482868195,
-0.8697616457939148,
0.18335828185081482,
0.05270965397357941,
-0.16288001835346222,
-0.06907015293836594,
0.5097305178642273,
-0.6478517651557922,
-0.4134988784790039,
-0.5727540254592896,
-0.20553846657276154,
0.01478736661374569,
-0.003641549963504076,
-0.0030796655919402838,
0.6333571076393127,
0.6701803207397461,
-0.4523303508758545,
0.6761151552200317,
0.24518533051013947,
-0.5687480568885803,
0.4246732294559479,
-0.789297342300415,
0.24616754055023193,
-0.4603542387485504,
0.5339516401290894,
-0.9956663846969604,
-0.513900101184845,
0.026427801698446274,
-0.3540616035461426,
0.3434692919254303,
-0.045040786266326904,
-0.8324669599533081,
-0.6121771335601807,
-0.22494180500507355,
0.45779773592948914,
0.7339134812355042,
-0.6492584943771362,
0.4174898862838745,
0.44336599111557007,
-0.2760053873062134,
-0.3522421419620514,
-0.688902735710144,
0.32694128155708313,
-0.21473051607608795,
-0.7912928462028503,
0.19539935886859894,
-0.26600682735443115,
-0.2780447006225586,
-0.26936325430870056,
0.1712370067834854,
0.014347380958497524,
-0.11869975179433823,
0.10152950882911682,
0.6614653468132019,
-0.002890633884817362,
0.26497188210487366,
-0.20212438702583313,
0.16114355623722076,
-0.006854145787656307,
-0.22423382103443146,
0.4528520703315735,
0.42180895805358887,
-0.5159438848495483,
-0.3899872601032257,
0.2730160653591156,
0.607339084148407,
-0.3704306185245514,
0.49777472019195557,
0.8408066630363464,
-0.5450114011764526,
0.180125430226326,
-0.8156470656394958,
-0.288203626871109,
-0.4071928560733795,
0.5900495648384094,
-0.09061089158058167,
-0.7935675978660583,
0.30651772022247314,
-0.0763794556260109,
0.2522142827510834,
0.35307684540748596,
0.5006805062294006,
0.03198457509279251,
1.449302077293396,
0.49719300866127014,
-0.2627355456352234,
0.6685033440589905,
-0.30870670080184937,
0.30054864287376404,
-0.9212185740470886,
0.09895447641611099,
-0.27339842915534973,
-0.400301992893219,
-0.3303280174732208,
-0.40643131732940674,
0.35274502635002136,
-0.2932974100112915,
-0.0380961038172245,
-0.19882917404174805,
-0.3933165669441223,
0.20436255633831024,
0.24001729488372803,
0.3169597387313843,
0.40957555174827576,
0.01124517247080803,
0.8760860562324524,
0.09210094809532166,
-0.4887547194957733,
-0.12114425003528595,
1.3042863607406616,
0.6801841855049133,
0.9092784523963928,
-0.246731698513031,
0.06000860407948494,
0.38855284452438354,
0.06317880749702454,
-0.7549522519111633,
0.4720647931098938,
-0.10543939471244812,
-0.6645252108573914,
-0.30226072669029236,
-0.524901807308197,
-0.8044950366020203,
-0.032976143062114716,
-0.4828929305076599,
-0.5016953945159912,
0.39483642578125,
0.13415156304836273,
-0.30400213599205017,
0.4178334176540375,
-0.6227760314941406,
0.4917255938053131,
-0.12124401330947876,
-0.5034837126731873,
-0.4046936631202698,
-0.48702675104141235,
0.7041889429092407,
-0.4252476394176483,
0.13182726502418518,
0.09225942939519882,
-0.0011576993856579065,
0.58901447057724,
-0.27924954891204834,
0.4068225920200348,
-0.33559682965278625,
-0.398408442735672,
0.15256503224372864,
-0.39385727047920227,
0.83915776014328,
-0.23025207221508026,
-0.17380419373512268,
0.1655694544315338,
-0.20872505009174347,
-0.2997896671295166,
-0.6936296820640564,
0.7364740371704102,
-0.4110156297683716,
-0.636242151260376,
0.007009608671069145,
-0.9976856708526611,
-0.5280889272689819,
0.025754159316420555,
-0.1782919317483902,
0.7405433654785156,
0.08383416384458542,
0.5099542737007141,
0.7749016284942627,
-0.3705523610115051,
0.34293895959854126,
0.04337848722934723,
-0.4151592254638672,
-0.2848784029483795,
0.9561596512794495,
0.29114529490470886,
0.4177882969379425,
0.19406376779079437,
-0.06904426217079163,
-0.4622531235218048,
-1.036134958267212,
-0.4099918603897095,
0.21640156209468842,
-0.3735753893852234,
0.025161899626255035,
-0.5306087732315063,
-0.3491549789905548,
-0.45511019229888916,
0.05209360271692276,
-0.3420315980911255,
-0.4587625563144684,
-0.35151249170303345,
-0.12575356662273407,
0.4204030930995941,
0.7018817663192749,
0.06058701500296593,
0.36311787366867065,
-0.69163578748703,
0.30268043279647827,
0.2069740891456604,
0.10670902580022812,
0.21746857464313507,
-0.362732470035553,
-0.4107664227485657,
0.41907939314842224,
0.03693900629878044,
-0.49026307463645935,
0.304738849401474,
-0.20461735129356384,
0.40277326107025146,
0.45911866426467896,
-0.23590756952762604,
0.7688033580780029,
-0.2500486373901367,
0.8183854222297668,
0.1639387309551239,
-0.41249462962150574,
0.30564334988594055,
-0.6159598231315613,
0.19218850135803223,
0.25622695684432983,
0.2530803680419922,
-0.40346765518188477,
0.16662785410881042,
-0.5392528772354126,
-0.9253474473953247,
0.45458370447158813,
-0.1280767023563385,
0.3321906328201294,
0.5482934713363647,
0.458967387676239,
0.052891090512275696,
0.2598951756954193,
-0.3789490759372711,
0.0939163789153099,
0.25955021381378174,
-0.12751030921936035,
-0.2036273032426834,
0.04723220318555832,
0.14695733785629272,
-0.30433523654937744,
0.6044648289680481,
0.03762691095471382,
-0.039233334362506866,
-0.016467854380607605,
-0.08351467549800873,
0.04134082421660423,
0.2782432734966278,
0.29132410883903503,
0.9240846633911133,
-0.15715856850147247,
-0.4614374339580536,
0.0011984711745753884,
-0.30981504917144775,
0.004377619829028845,
0.385684072971344,
-0.26161593198776245,
-0.21708014607429504,
0.202757328748703,
0.8985887169837952,
-0.09460515528917313,
-0.6902579069137573,
0.5674136281013489,
0.2923968732357025,
-0.1576964408159256,
-0.2942923903465271,
0.07281015068292618,
-0.12952834367752075,
0.32712164521217346,
0.5399038195610046,
-0.08607212454080582,
0.3815454840660095,
-0.6860114932060242,
-0.15093426406383514,
0.7375679612159729,
-0.23324370384216309,
-0.27899524569511414,
0.5102955102920532,
-0.047445401549339294,
0.17459355294704437,
0.5383960008621216,
0.18224860727787018,
0.07393551617860794,
0.40293771028518677,
0.3501065969467163,
0.4251828193664551,
-0.23006582260131836,
-0.16406860947608948,
0.36047986149787903,
0.1971321403980255,
-0.39510273933410645,
0.08671295642852783,
0.06189614534378052,
-0.5274741053581238,
-0.8670809864997864,
-0.2936994731426239,
-0.4823785722255707,
0.5544432997703552,
-0.3899993300437927,
0.24110540747642517,
-0.44344180822372437,
-0.2651112675666809,
0.18003562092781067,
-0.03460896760225296,
-0.705535352230072,
0.3038824200630188,
0.39013010263442993,
0.9579306244850159,
-0.6067827343940735,
0.5060141682624817,
0.731213390827179,
-0.2874901294708252,
-0.40118125081062317,
-0.055425047874450684,
-0.1743760108947754,
-0.52320796251297,
0.304147869348526,
0.10584849864244461,
0.2984415590763092,
0.18657661974430084,
-0.7068493962287903,
-0.8593055009841919,
0.9567680954933167,
0.0048688375391066074,
-0.592392086982727,
-0.3470258414745331,
0.06235222890973091,
0.42785635590553284,
-0.35834410786628723,
0.329171746969223,
0.7239630222320557,
0.7754575610160828,
0.2575194835662842,
-0.5677803754806519,
-0.1915779709815979,
-0.06113733723759651,
0.19944539666175842,
0.11232287436723709,
-0.3799830973148346,
0.6730082035064697,
0.0200413316488266,
0.06640008091926575,
0.21103598177433014,
0.6844415664672852,
0.019106930121779442,
0.2262003868818283,
0.6047473549842834,
0.6033226847648621,
0.5803266167640686,
0.017929663881659508,
0.9831624031066895,
-0.041256796568632126,
0.10361823439598083,
0.802655041217804,
-0.40035778284072876,
0.6569246649742126,
0.19904112815856934,
-0.35924991965293884,
0.10337094217538834,
0.8277813792228699,
-0.3220587968826294,
0.11876542121171951,
0.00866515003144741,
-0.18717904388904572,
-0.1740621030330658,
-0.2482239007949829,
-0.5041067600250244,
0.39356544613838196,
0.6719622015953064,
-0.3373624086380005,
-0.04218670353293419,
0.3175102174282074,
-0.24770742654800415,
-0.24557586014270782,
-0.7670584917068481,
0.7260448932647705,
-0.17186518013477325,
-0.3578411638736725,
0.3298666775226593,
0.031659241765737534,
0.6465446949005127,
-0.3920736312866211,
-0.1772642582654953,
0.059599362313747406,
-0.09322816878557205,
-0.29898402094841003,
-0.9327680468559265,
0.10324162989854813,
-0.16825369000434875,
-0.27943935990333557,
0.024565212428569794,
0.8735756874084473,
-0.3413383662700653,
-0.596534788608551,
-0.11781502515077591,
0.6197034120559692,
-0.028968486934900284,
-0.25423675775527954,
-0.3790227770805359,
0.3497842252254486,
-0.16352134943008423,
-0.24534451961517334,
0.18850840628147125,
0.03938305005431175,
-0.024135971441864967,
0.505014181137085,
1.0219435691833496,
0.26494064927101135,
-0.09263730049133301,
0.19558711349964142,
0.8975533246994019,
-0.5757480263710022,
-0.4099676012992859,
-0.6556515693664551,
0.5909327268600464,
-0.3083348572254181,
0.22043131291866302,
0.6855478882789612,
0.5807727575302124,
0.5892404317855835,
-0.035221781581640244,
0.9466933608055115,
0.16393189132213593,
0.7959793210029602,
-0.6009512543678284,
0.3937782049179077,
-0.6008965373039246,
0.00799165666103363,
-0.4097851514816284,
-1.1997466087341309,
-0.35833948850631714,
0.1802179366350174,
-0.8210399150848389,
0.2938160002231598,
0.05253561958670616,
0.8689016103744507,
-0.3267587125301361,
0.17546957731246948,
0.45667392015457153,
0.3329828381538391,
0.23449400067329407,
0.31466084718704224,
1.0692368745803833,
-0.3526496887207031,
0.09498558938503265,
0.12395063042640686,
-0.3459276258945465,
-0.3298822343349457,
-0.5722640156745911,
-0.6466260552406311,
-0.6113789677619934,
-0.11352342367172241,
0.03903261944651604,
-0.003640243085101247,
0.8960802555084229,
0.963401198387146,
-0.4537579417228699,
0.0076342797838151455,
0.14739787578582764,
-0.0629788264632225,
0.09081289172172546,
-0.2071465104818344,
0.22611138224601746,
-0.07289130240678787,
-1.0178521871566772,
0.6496659517288208,
0.18736469745635986,
0.1564604640007019,
-0.611514151096344,
0.18335974216461182,
-0.15660561621189117,
0.10875710099935532,
0.7378950119018555,
0.354240745306015,
-0.24531586468219757,
-0.11079589277505875,
-0.1292436718940735,
0.21756215393543243,
0.17555396258831024,
0.7927241325378418,
-0.5623939037322998,
0.4664998948574066,
0.6096205115318298,
1.1161547899246216,
0.5740054249763489,
0.41948628425598145,
0.5420727133750916,
-0.452542245388031,
0.06808788329362869,
0.04195541888475418,
0.42114973068237305,
0.7874119877815247,
-0.46708783507347107,
0.4484175443649292,
0.040519602596759796,
-0.7596760392189026,
-1.0340577363967896,
0.260225385427475,
-0.8519773483276367,
-0.2510656714439392,
1.0335900783538818,
0.26043975353240967,
-0.2153475135564804,
0.14476880431175232,
-0.2220306396484375,
-0.0023189012426882982,
-0.18414552509784698,
0.5181317925453186,
0.7592403292655945,
-0.13031712174415588,
-0.22313039004802704,
-0.8840113282203674,
0.006971954368054867,
0.0832408219575882,
-1.162285327911377,
0.3066885769367218,
1.0905154943466187,
-0.14063914120197296,
0.07762118428945541,
0.12063434720039368,
-0.33930009603500366,
0.17322759330272675,
-0.3652189075946808,
0.0772852674126625,
-0.3950842022895813,
-0.253065824508667,
-0.7115299701690674,
0.11619065701961517,
0.08716608583927155,
-0.014355769380927086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.16441v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.16441v1 | FaKnow: A Unified Library for Fake News Detection | 2024-01-27T13:29:17 | 2024-01-27T13:29:17 | Yiyuan Zhu, Yongjun Li, Jialiang Wang, Ming Gao, Jiali Wei | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Over the past years, a large number of fake news detection algorithms based
on deep learning have emerged. However, they are often developed under
different frameworks, each mandating distinct utilization methodologies,
consequently hindering reproducibility. Additionally, a substantial amount of
redundancy characterizes the code development of such fake news detection
models. To address these concerns, we propose FaKnow, a unified and
comprehensive fake news detection algorithm library. It encompasses a variety
of widely used fake news detection models, categorized as content-based and
social context-based approaches. This library covers the full spectrum of the
model training and evaluation process, effectively organizing the data, models,
and training procedures within a unified framework. Furthermore, it furnishes a
series of auxiliary functionalities and tools, including visualization, and
logging. Our work contributes to the standardization and unification of fake
news detection research, concurrently facilitating the endeavors of researchers
in this field. The open-source code and documentation can be accessed at
https://github.com/NPURG/FaKnow and https://faknow.readthedocs.io,
respectively. | [
-0.3067227303981781,
-0.6630829572677612,
0.3968096077442169,
0.2913912236690521,
-0.46947023272514343,
0.04719652235507965,
0.0912633165717125,
-0.2256246656179428,
0.40172260999679565,
0.5579258799552917,
-0.3257644474506378,
-0.4662337899208069,
-0.4747467041015625,
-0.08872470259666443,
-0.7852387428283691,
0.9987857341766357,
0.0781979113817215,
0.04514651745557785,
-0.1414220780134201,
-0.4098324477672577,
-0.3165505528450012,
-0.0225900299847126,
-0.17789742350578308,
-0.14623770117759705,
0.3987037241458893,
0.38157325983047485,
0.506834864616394,
0.5981051325798035,
-0.0975741446018219,
0.24138016998767853,
0.32687440514564514,
0.23737463355064392,
-0.28330978751182556,
-0.180738627910614,
-0.22211718559265137,
-0.07482954114675522,
-0.3660530745983124,
-0.02459307760000229,
0.4353688061237335,
0.2568209171295166,
-0.06335179507732391,
0.10542414337396622,
-0.24126172065734863,
0.6145365834236145,
-0.8007017374038696,
-0.27769777178764343,
-0.566612720489502,
-0.07894814759492874,
-0.112439826130867,
-0.08857545256614685,
-0.1817031353712082,
-0.2834346890449524,
0.24957585334777832,
-0.8592026233673096,
0.3940487205982208,
-0.1911013126373291,
0.5987351536750793,
0.011326915584504604,
-0.5662696957588196,
-0.4052215814590454,
-0.41870516538619995,
0.36479079723358154,
-0.6128986477851868,
0.581030547618866,
0.09916915744543076,
0.491580605506897,
-0.15040434896945953,
-0.6456502079963684,
-0.6320793628692627,
-0.16685432195663452,
0.017810767516493797,
-0.12138202041387558,
-0.45017603039741516,
-0.2022494673728943,
-0.24942457675933838,
0.5392998456954956,
-0.7469122409820557,
-0.14970433712005615,
-0.31973797082901,
-0.5282315015792847,
0.6114376187324524,
-0.30535638332366943,
0.4233503043651581,
-0.046942923218011856,
-0.27484503388404846,
0.28611236810684204,
-0.1832095980644226,
-0.41714659333229065,
0.44622722268104553,
0.2610219419002533,
-0.25891196727752686,
0.11798278987407684,
-0.67961186170578,
0.64947909116745,
0.20369887351989746,
-0.05071554332971573,
0.5108502507209778,
-0.08887283504009247,
-0.5334756970405579,
-0.20038700103759766,
0.5464113354682922,
0.14281734824180603,
-0.0074911764822900295,
-0.2771216928958893,
-0.17284978926181793,
0.0007254256634041667,
0.5246102213859558,
-0.32981204986572266,
-0.5474087595939636,
0.2774841785430908,
-0.5352960824966431,
-0.6323457956314087,
0.30322059988975525,
-0.6163961291313171,
-0.6178625822067261,
-0.7125231623649597,
0.5573577284812927,
-0.3188093602657318,
-0.7520257830619812,
0.058626215904951096,
-0.12732957303524017,
-0.08301591128110886,
0.5451963543891907,
-0.20829980075359344,
-0.027631353586912155,
0.8313732147216797,
0.8142105937004089,
-0.07271037995815277,
-0.24272520840168,
-0.6244274377822876,
-0.2073814570903778,
-0.2255338430404663,
0.7885539531707764,
-0.2007218599319458,
0.19310709834098816,
0.10133279860019684,
0.1354857236146927,
0.4744614064693451,
-0.2589634954929352,
0.7231562733650208,
-0.6713084578514099,
0.08672145754098892,
-0.13845381140708923,
-0.6614595651626587,
-0.30975276231765747,
0.2313929945230484,
-0.9958030581474304,
0.8578701019287109,
-0.04884963110089302,
-0.7573384642601013,
0.438699334859848,
-0.6118922829627991,
-0.4312182068824768,
0.25261422991752625,
0.02621760033071041,
-0.4288703501224518,
0.3976360559463501,
0.2862025797367096,
0.5871155261993408,
0.2328002154827118,
0.634284257888794,
-0.3188891112804413,
-0.4174516499042511,
-0.0033050866331905127,
-0.40473777055740356,
1.1219589710235596,
0.43261536955833435,
-0.4637315571308136,
0.3502533733844757,
-0.7661093473434448,
-0.19816550612449646,
0.03598366305232048,
-0.2739238142967224,
-0.6256915330886841,
-0.5115556120872498,
0.05818477272987366,
-0.007644172292202711,
0.11899735778570175,
-0.625903844833374,
0.047910477966070175,
-0.16677379608154297,
0.09611669182777405,
0.8678013682365417,
-0.24560676515102386,
0.5427477359771729,
-0.07198954373598099,
0.11666008085012436,
0.09693096578121185,
0.34267663955688477,
-0.47686493396759033,
-0.34145960211753845,
-0.8003799319267273,
-0.33382752537727356,
0.15215171873569489,
0.32528233528137207,
-0.7991060018539429,
0.4547029733657837,
-0.05203178524971008,
-0.6266820430755615,
-0.402922123670578,
0.16005279123783112,
0.34425386786460876,
0.31576624512672424,
0.3049567937850952,
0.10558303445577621,
-0.8885382413864136,
-0.7479566335678101,
-0.7820682525634766,
0.23816731572151184,
-0.0016552055021747947,
-0.20299102365970612,
0.7861273288726807,
-0.26792988181114197,
1.126063585281372,
-0.09090868383646011,
-0.1962026059627533,
0.12642620503902435,
0.1162528246641159,
0.1858311891555786,
0.3416157364845276,
0.5971590876579285,
-1.2281689643859863,
-0.5387219786643982,
-0.043411411345005035,
-0.843500554561615,
-0.15469218790531158,
0.05019213631749153,
-0.18725091218948364,
0.6836194396018982,
0.4824149012565613,
-0.3786200284957886,
0.610995888710022,
0.6065974235534668,
-0.40410685539245605,
0.9984311461448669,
0.19569793343544006,
0.3078491687774658,
-0.9933925867080688,
0.27559277415275574,
0.034518491476774216,
-0.4012635350227356,
-0.864713728427887,
0.17957939207553864,
0.07418805360794067,
-0.09249516576528549,
-0.33693987131118774,
0.9641014933586121,
-0.1751076728105545,
-0.18923446536064148,
-0.5024945735931396,
-0.17466215789318085,
0.11847412586212158,
0.12087497115135193,
-0.014543513767421246,
0.3147851228713989,
0.5175486207008362,
-0.4748016893863678,
0.6512694954872131,
-0.3578048646450043,
-0.3215022087097168,
0.6680892705917358,
-0.46893903613090515,
0.10101883113384247,
-0.15446269512176514,
0.5565345287322998,
-0.9187914133071899,
-0.6533349752426147,
0.5408329367637634,
-0.8499956727027893,
-0.24405528604984283,
-0.318512886762619,
-0.7117452621459961,
-0.5405032634735107,
-0.19954994320869446,
-0.0681038498878479,
-0.0003222038794774562,
-0.8708634376525879,
0.6442983746528625,
0.3176800310611725,
0.5141144394874573,
-0.8553428649902344,
-0.49505186080932617,
-0.19237224757671356,
0.13762514293193817,
-0.6003677845001221,
-0.029985230416059494,
-0.12994106113910675,
-0.09132787585258484,
0.2844264805316925,
-0.6723928451538086,
-0.4677107036113739,
0.15683281421661377,
0.35198405385017395,
0.15834049880504608,
-0.2726021111011505,
0.3416719138622284,
0.07831911742687225,
-0.04805532097816467,
-0.25607094168663025,
-0.558810830116272,
0.1943248212337494,
-0.23629482090473175,
-0.24905705451965332,
-0.7097533941268921,
0.37525057792663574,
0.7380890846252441,
0.10466868430376053,
0.5404611825942993,
0.8294928669929504,
-0.73280268907547,
-0.43287158012390137,
-0.7516826391220093,
0.05943983420729637,
-0.4980691373348236,
0.046486787497997284,
-0.10151290148496628,
-1.114155650138855,
0.3191934823989868,
0.06900662928819656,
0.2516864538192749,
0.3703450560569763,
0.5887721180915833,
0.060935381799936295,
0.491786390542984,
0.6347432732582092,
-0.2560991644859314,
0.1536269634962082,
0.0916723906993866,
0.037976063787937164,
-0.022596411406993866,
-0.09312393516302109,
-0.15395018458366394,
-0.011903069913387299,
0.12860795855522156,
-0.3577953279018402,
-0.12254878133535385,
0.1991376280784607,
-0.4334990382194519,
0.15178526937961578,
-0.798024594783783,
0.9084936380386353,
0.5332227349281311,
-0.01137351430952549,
0.6690467596054077,
0.6169073581695557,
-0.007683343719691038,
0.10925114154815674,
-0.47305044531822205,
-0.3030344843864441,
1.30694580078125,
0.3641470968723297,
0.39328232407569885,
-0.08904152363538742,
0.5660823583602905,
0.8175660371780396,
0.8559125661849976,
-0.5110926032066345,
0.23911792039871216,
-0.3190678656101227,
-0.9575173258781433,
-0.07690338045358658,
-0.37975481152534485,
-0.6202274560928345,
0.32045456767082214,
0.06804804503917694,
-0.29755863547325134,
0.08066757768392563,
0.28905031085014343,
-0.3287162482738495,
0.66581791639328,
-0.654859721660614,
0.8734129071235657,
-0.06582769006490707,
0.07913573831319809,
-0.2073204666376114,
-0.34666669368743896,
0.7020689845085144,
-0.20835116505622864,
0.42278429865837097,
-0.017855273559689522,
0.10784279555082321,
0.5215964913368225,
-0.3241249918937683,
0.8964433073997498,
-0.3801407217979431,
0.0013378708390519023,
0.24020610749721527,
0.16863010823726654,
0.2480025440454483,
0.21522341668605804,
0.2795000672340393,
0.4932696521282196,
-0.2883533239364624,
-0.45706045627593994,
-0.23782050609588623,
1.043913722038269,
-0.6761347055435181,
-0.06741540133953094,
-0.4905812740325928,
-0.484686017036438,
0.1368202120065689,
0.4968303143978119,
0.2734076976776123,
0.2060009241104126,
-0.3573043942451477,
0.2294807881116867,
0.6853984594345093,
-0.3407899737358093,
0.0032715320121496916,
0.8636583685874939,
-0.5330826640129089,
-0.5075343251228333,
1.0229854583740234,
0.18603770434856415,
-0.21873758733272552,
-0.0027659558691084385,
0.11747395992279053,
-0.1462007761001587,
-0.3421272039413452,
-0.2275209128856659,
0.18435241281986237,
-0.7194848656654358,
-0.2461405098438263,
-0.6525360941886902,
-0.08019036054611206,
-0.7615174055099487,
-0.47507238388061523,
-0.5763029456138611,
-0.06808469444513321,
-0.31576499342918396,
0.11705529689788818,
0.4352739751338959,
0.5999909043312073,
-0.4391772150993347,
0.32618698477745056,
-0.4866747558116913,
0.8207962512969971,
0.32922622561454773,
0.6145089268684387,
0.32966575026512146,
-0.3324173092842102,
-0.2786870300769806,
0.19536343216896057,
-0.10387443751096725,
-0.5628714561462402,
0.4000242352485657,
-0.13066790997982025,
0.656338632106781,
0.4525190591812134,
0.2659878134727478,
0.4536272883415222,
-0.13949213922023773,
0.4399906396865845,
0.2728027105331421,
-0.9170342683792114,
0.5853714346885681,
-0.5375574231147766,
0.1892436295747757,
0.4728776216506958,
0.6944337487220764,
-0.6296314597129822,
-0.1862146407365799,
-0.5401740074157715,
-0.6695723533630371,
0.6416719555854797,
-0.009782449342310429,
0.12571512162685394,
0.20354944467544556,
0.36773955821990967,
0.47496822476387024,
0.2891279458999634,
-0.9310969114303589,
-0.43867945671081543,
-0.7290299534797668,
-0.12465707957744598,
0.38373926281929016,
-0.07161227613687515,
-0.30979055166244507,
-0.38259437680244446,
0.768219530582428,
-0.15155814588069916,
0.2731631398200989,
0.25982052087783813,
-0.4342923164367676,
-0.09005037695169449,
-0.02787955477833748,
0.40264949202537537,
0.711518406867981,
-0.04154742881655693,
-0.17117534577846527,
-0.371836394071579,
-0.4845384955406189,
0.06254106760025024,
-0.01875188574194908,
-0.34691286087036133,
0.4120849668979645,
0.3744552433490753,
0.4756251573562622,
0.1433081030845642,
-0.5037252902984619,
0.6616767644882202,
0.0684366375207901,
-0.4119702875614166,
-0.6615529656410217,
-0.10876532644033432,
0.06996997445821762,
0.38752391934394836,
0.9763744473457336,
0.25408199429512024,
0.2264442890882492,
-0.3792746365070343,
0.7543050646781921,
0.04732413962483406,
-0.32694587111473083,
-0.401975154876709,
0.4332256317138672,
0.44450172781944275,
-0.26435598731040955,
0.38819628953933716,
-0.5067477226257324,
-0.6139869689941406,
0.5648742914199829,
0.3112213909626007,
0.8206298351287842,
-0.2530573010444641,
0.7653770446777344,
0.1792161762714386,
0.27484843134880066,
-0.1662845015525818,
0.07047336548566818,
0.04849125072360039,
-0.8868984580039978,
-0.34759339690208435,
-0.69890958070755,
-0.010852336883544922,
0.7071096301078796,
-0.29872211813926697,
0.3056016266345978,
-0.632530152797699,
0.336147665977478,
0.36067163944244385,
0.14134511351585388,
-0.3970165550708771,
-0.05117933079600334,
0.45686325430870056,
1.1108920574188232,
-0.86279296875,
0.8656764626502991,
0.6613953709602356,
-0.08754222840070724,
-0.42395684123039246,
-0.02748701348900795,
0.8023723363876343,
-0.4218047559261322,
0.6080324649810791,
0.403457373380661,
0.12273591756820679,
-0.1039995402097702,
-0.9550215005874634,
-0.5574375987052917,
1.0137437582015991,
0.3347461521625519,
-0.5198273062705994,
0.1193513497710228,
-0.08270137012004852,
0.3906528353691101,
-0.6090447306632996,
-0.2932799756526947,
0.33713775873184204,
0.49906089901924133,
0.013515706174075603,
-0.7336127758026123,
-0.050939444452524185,
-0.17903770506381989,
-0.4303136169910431,
-0.01921188272535801,
-0.39198803901672363,
0.9454134106636047,
0.13430990278720856,
-0.32488730549812317,
0.10791701078414917,
0.6986215114593506,
0.3579568862915039,
1.0322303771972656,
0.44358351826667786,
0.8331146836280823,
0.7175329327583313,
0.015054871328175068,
0.7948235869407654,
0.12213674187660217,
0.5189554691314697,
1.2797982692718506,
0.10740374028682709,
0.2839541435241699,
-0.03637589141726494,
0.03695422783493996,
0.386332243680954,
0.3874334394931793,
-0.20904386043548584,
0.29509425163269043,
-0.1051282286643982,
-0.3124254643917084,
-0.30923983454704285,
0.09691145271062851,
-0.3391181528568268,
0.16348053514957428,
0.267234742641449,
-0.37170934677124023,
-0.5792139172554016,
0.16742777824401855,
0.24575437605381012,
0.01941954903304577,
-0.6402606964111328,
0.09482673555612564,
-0.13857845962047577,
-0.16694462299346924,
0.4873062074184418,
-0.04273055121302605,
1.0801026821136475,
-0.35748353600502014,
0.005000918637961149,
-0.4035570025444031,
0.04754696041345596,
-0.46069759130477905,
-0.5920674800872803,
0.5727646350860596,
-0.1684097796678543,
-0.38374122977256775,
0.1995505690574646,
1.3421841859817505,
-0.15944744646549225,
-0.19715645909309387,
0.3342988193035126,
0.48675090074539185,
-0.007730306126177311,
-0.5573975443840027,
-0.8398831486701965,
0.33857864141464233,
0.17760208249092102,
-0.20330710709095,
0.2348180115222931,
0.39217087626457214,
-0.04058775678277016,
0.6609453558921814,
1.3223589658737183,
-0.3618716895580292,
0.20716264843940735,
-0.10053779929876328,
0.8864542841911316,
-0.2625492513179779,
-0.6245818138122559,
-0.5621110200881958,
0.594814121723175,
-0.4476533830165863,
-0.44286271929740906,
0.8858062028884888,
0.5140013694763184,
0.8179924488067627,
-0.3518941104412079,
0.8549187183380127,
-0.2362312525510788,
0.6708007454872131,
0.023942142724990845,
0.9998089671134949,
-0.7943811416625977,
0.04235332831740379,
-0.3007296919822693,
-0.8170258402824402,
-0.531941294670105,
0.4609372615814209,
0.13289770483970642,
-0.3513650596141815,
0.18402719497680664,
0.6034665703773499,
-0.4007244408130646,
0.06567373871803284,
0.216970756649971,
0.35804539918899536,
0.16114778816699982,
-0.0359790101647377,
0.4065110683441162,
-0.5102112889289856,
0.5168534517288208,
-0.20930752158164978,
-0.15373915433883667,
-0.6959995627403259,
-0.8296381235122681,
-0.7466880679130554,
-0.7068469524383545,
-0.4533863067626953,
-0.35745641589164734,
0.22155137360095978,
0.6518824100494385,
0.976821780204773,
-0.8041954636573792,
0.0959034413099289,
-0.2600496709346771,
0.3791777193546295,
-0.07450247555971146,
-0.3922376334667206,
0.22257302701473236,
-0.028080249205231667,
-0.33083051443099976,
0.35919058322906494,
0.09194773435592651,
-0.12287615239620209,
-0.4301409423351288,
-0.31989264488220215,
-0.49550026655197144,
0.08853758871555328,
0.6417890787124634,
0.7124267816543579,
-0.7382078170776367,
-0.18572157621383667,
-0.18265853822231293,
-0.0008878244552761316,
-0.36446186900138855,
0.9116783142089844,
-1.0251233577728271,
0.4866787791252136,
0.5603684186935425,
0.6421369314193726,
0.1238100454211235,
-0.13758797943592072,
0.3077298402786255,
-1.016904354095459,
0.25046974420547485,
0.015469839796423912,
0.10494381189346313,
0.13253463804721832,
-0.42980170249938965,
0.5510361194610596,
0.6566530466079712,
-0.5615477561950684,
-1.1539608240127563,
0.0957520380616188,
-0.8808916807174683,
-0.7841391563415527,
0.8789116740226746,
-0.16289694607257843,
-0.26267239451408386,
-0.6400099992752075,
0.04812655970454216,
0.29218214750289917,
-0.7173394560813904,
0.48140546679496765,
0.7732332944869995,
0.23356060683727264,
-0.2876867651939392,
-0.6894319653511047,
0.3479670286178589,
-0.17149201035499573,
-0.5240975022315979,
0.08006762713193893,
0.7395151257514954,
0.7853419780731201,
0.3277135193347931,
0.8215881586074829,
0.010812301188707352,
0.6368936896324158,
-0.04396731033921242,
0.20844921469688416,
-0.4282892644405365,
-0.49688634276390076,
-0.4673677086830139,
0.11363241821527481,
-0.8236228823661804,
0.11457661539316177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15400v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15400v1 | Indexing Portuguese NLP Resources with PT-Pump-Up | 2024-01-27T12:33:07 | 2024-01-27T12:33:07 | Rúben Almeida, Ricardo Campos, Alípio Jorge, Sérgio Nunes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, 68P20, I.7.1 | The recent advances in natural language processing (NLP) are linked to
training processes that require vast amounts of corpora. Access to this data is
commonly not a trivial process due to resource dispersion and the need to
maintain these infrastructures online and up-to-date. New developments in NLP
are often compromised due to the scarcity of data or lack of a shared
repository that works as an entry point to the community. This is especially
true in low and mid-resource languages, such as Portuguese, which lack data and
proper resource management infrastructures. In this work, we propose
PT-Pump-Up, a set of tools that aim to reduce resource dispersion and improve
the accessibility to Portuguese NLP resources. Our proposal is divided into
four software components: a) a web platform to list the available resources; b)
a client-side Python package to simplify the loading of Portuguese NLP
resources; c) an administrative Python package to manage the platform and d) a
public GitHub repository to foster future collaboration and contributions. All
four components are accessible using: https://linktr.ee/pt_pump_up | [
-0.5586217641830444,
-0.2757412791252136,
0.1649039387702942,
0.8098872900009155,
-0.3556164503097534,
0.1017545834183693,
-0.48114606738090515,
-0.38552767038345337,
0.5485891103744507,
0.5915012955665588,
-0.32784974575042725,
-0.5246923565864563,
-0.7206300497055054,
0.3892771005630493,
-0.5185827612876892,
1.0400803089141846,
0.07070866972208023,
-0.1732662171125412,
0.28519928455352783,
-0.17995375394821167,
-0.4212751090526581,
-0.27572891116142273,
-0.7285884022712708,
-0.2565833628177643,
0.6740602254867554,
0.3956905007362366,
0.6939045786857605,
0.6689950227737427,
0.43975311517715454,
0.3349745273590088,
-0.2761441171169281,
-0.03928380087018013,
-0.5482727885246277,
0.2499019205570221,
-0.3158840537071228,
-0.2954833507537842,
-0.2704698443412781,
-0.2449411302804947,
0.9256555438041687,
0.6346444487571716,
-0.37131020426750183,
0.1080971285700798,
0.30904093384742737,
0.7708853483200073,
-0.5425419807434082,
0.4356284439563751,
-0.6615893840789795,
-0.03572689741849899,
-0.4560958743095398,
-0.42577508091926575,
-0.06421848386526108,
-0.3858157992362976,
0.552604079246521,
-0.76988285779953,
0.15772618353366852,
-0.26669245958328247,
0.6171388030052185,
0.41372331976890564,
-0.10015101730823517,
-0.3755977749824524,
-0.3411538600921631,
0.6759893298149109,
-0.3083256483078003,
0.19935837388038635,
0.28726181387901306,
0.36914515495300293,
-0.2232789397239685,
-0.5366551280021667,
-0.3799252212047577,
-0.07099920511245728,
-0.2327558547258377,
-0.06327412277460098,
-0.4856001138687134,
-0.03837765008211136,
0.12669697403907776,
0.2991926968097687,
-0.46590161323547363,
0.21025913953781128,
-0.40352797508239746,
-0.1558256596326828,
0.15267685055732727,
-0.23484490811824799,
0.19576479494571686,
-0.3515613377094269,
-0.19075831770896912,
-0.2522379755973816,
-0.6643885374069214,
-0.44777658581733704,
0.5204541683197021,
0.6607257127761841,
0.11873506009578705,
0.7689828276634216,
-0.21519307792186737,
0.6366212368011475,
-0.19242729246616364,
0.16701756417751312,
0.4227798283100128,
-0.3573150932788849,
0.04290074482560158,
0.38270336389541626,
0.5664188265800476,
0.06768142431974411,
-0.11291932314634323,
-0.045779429376125336,
-0.17461222410202026,
0.01833343505859375,
0.23414191603660583,
-0.5726696848869324,
-0.21723683178424835,
0.25409331917762756,
-0.17638686299324036,
-0.30914410948753357,
0.0672791376709938,
-0.9050281047821045,
-0.32452186942100525,
-0.1631406992673874,
0.47137850522994995,
-0.5578937530517578,
-0.5016354918479919,
0.09142016619443893,
-0.47457748651504517,
-0.0752231776714325,
0.12326359748840332,
-0.7204075455665588,
0.3391725420951843,
1.0163195133209229,
1.1982917785644531,
-0.156420037150383,
-0.23718270659446716,
-0.557955265045166,
0.2489844709634781,
0.17301635444164276,
0.7747069597244263,
-0.4672325849533081,
-0.5459074378013611,
0.30317655205726624,
0.15890847146511078,
0.028589077293872833,
-0.5826762914657593,
0.9735742807388306,
-0.2197847068309784,
0.4920419156551361,
-0.14783743023872375,
-0.25713860988616943,
0.03187395632266998,
0.2547970116138458,
-0.7991995215415955,
1.3338042497634888,
0.20501357316970825,
-1.0618094205856323,
0.03002513013780117,
-1.1278876066207886,
-0.24056826531887054,
0.2558659613132477,
0.08881459385156631,
-0.20357005298137665,
-0.01601145975291729,
0.36257076263427734,
0.22827592492103577,
-0.08323903381824493,
0.0705193355679512,
-0.10213091969490051,
-0.3361477553844452,
0.17085638642311096,
-0.3454151153564453,
0.8953304886817932,
0.2752280533313751,
-0.17054571211338043,
-0.18104293942451477,
-0.8289036750793457,
-0.16369163990020752,
-0.08966228365898132,
-0.4939727485179901,
-0.7656684517860413,
-0.07849617302417755,
0.19290004670619965,
0.18006446957588196,
0.4624909460544586,
-0.3845010995864868,
0.6016440987586975,
-0.7469365000724792,
0.39373669028282166,
0.613325834274292,
-0.07333452999591827,
0.5158873200416565,
-0.06853174418210983,
0.6188306212425232,
0.03389371931552887,
0.10542741417884827,
-0.16816937923431396,
-0.7394965887069702,
-0.8597574830055237,
-0.24276214838027954,
0.40064167976379395,
0.4109654724597931,
-1.082355260848999,
0.3668123483657837,
-0.3459639847278595,
-0.5536612272262573,
-0.9305456280708313,
0.15064950287342072,
0.4408716559410095,
0.5583496689796448,
0.4522605240345001,
-0.4572804570198059,
-0.6151426434516907,
-0.7476091980934143,
0.057346612215042114,
-0.04335615038871765,
-0.6341049075126648,
0.2262301743030548,
0.3102795481681824,
-0.4895738959312439,
0.951759397983551,
-0.6159449219703674,
-0.555257260799408,
-0.09008293598890305,
0.37758713960647583,
0.597761332988739,
0.4342741072177887,
0.6766011714935303,
-0.7962451577186584,
-0.23381200432777405,
-0.16972538828849792,
-0.07795456051826477,
-0.8678573369979858,
0.344252347946167,
-0.2853333353996277,
0.11752152442932129,
-0.1781783103942871,
-0.35909464955329895,
-0.10035096853971481,
0.7923799753189087,
-0.05523427948355675,
0.22586674988269806,
-0.47108080983161926,
-0.12424562871456146,
-1.205251932144165,
0.33115482330322266,
0.08662771433591843,
0.03393726795911789,
-0.3969065546989441,
-0.11405277997255325,
-0.2456125169992447,
-0.4119100272655487,
-0.514365017414093,
0.21949175000190735,
-0.3054065704345703,
-0.2954352796077728,
-0.3665601313114166,
0.4685395061969757,
0.05393745005130768,
0.17216408252716064,
0.3490378260612488,
0.6011256575584412,
0.6534269452095032,
-0.6193066835403442,
0.24883629381656647,
0.17684438824653625,
0.06596943736076355,
0.5341299772262573,
-0.7326840162277222,
-0.028108272701501846,
0.09520890563726425,
0.20252281427383423,
-0.45867592096328735,
0.0061838869005441666,
0.4990994930267334,
-0.1474130004644394,
0.22086754441261292,
-0.65406733751297,
-0.44943565130233765,
-0.31026431918144226,
-0.43335774540901184,
0.10919741541147232,
0.11367183923721313,
-0.5835530757904053,
0.239397794008255,
0.9241310954093933,
-0.4474453628063202,
-1.0045472383499146,
-0.42433127760887146,
0.2378692328929901,
-0.25369805097579956,
-0.4730454683303833,
0.6429702043533325,
0.05864565074443817,
-0.04799865931272507,
0.2791251838207245,
0.2699067294597626,
-0.4215461313724518,
0.007834140211343765,
0.14273056387901306,
0.060903094708919525,
0.04184338450431824,
0.2788250148296356,
0.10036639869213104,
-0.5096027255058289,
-0.01529946643859148,
-0.7061747908592224,
0.7003820538520813,
-0.3751288056373596,
-0.09310871362686157,
-0.12177268415689468,
0.2792319655418396,
0.035502076148986816,
-0.22431939840316772,
0.4794774651527405,
0.632938027381897,
-0.3852326273918152,
-0.2159331738948822,
-0.3705921173095703,
0.11236919462680817,
-0.4773559868335724,
0.17787955701351166,
0.05574779585003853,
-0.8669080138206482,
0.32653355598449707,
-0.3103104829788208,
-0.07202915847301483,
0.580784261226654,
0.8643758893013,
-0.09787920862436295,
0.603869616985321,
0.9897763133049011,
-0.27163103222846985,
0.6232225894927979,
-0.5052087903022766,
-0.017368096858263016,
-0.5554244518280029,
0.09719495475292206,
-1.0250426530838013,
-0.3327597379684448,
-1.0136888027191162,
-0.6376906633377075,
0.5263263583183289,
-0.16254141926765442,
0.23268945515155792,
0.7451849579811096,
-0.870641827583313,
0.6047769784927368,
0.8946818709373474,
-0.2625228464603424,
0.5515143275260925,
-0.030448634177446365,
-0.11606620252132416,
0.062419500201940536,
-0.9240137934684753,
-0.43908241391181946,
0.9894517660140991,
0.10966438800096512,
0.37992963194847107,
0.07746488600969315,
0.8463385105133057,
0.2303457409143448,
0.2466617077589035,
-0.5838618278503418,
0.32884112000465393,
-0.008107232861220837,
-0.4536307156085968,
-0.23080524802207947,
-0.41863158345222473,
-1.3783577680587769,
0.25705841183662415,
-0.4150143563747406,
-0.30452248454093933,
0.3051947355270386,
0.11566022038459778,
-0.04345542937517166,
0.008499814197421074,
-0.7469944953918457,
0.7964757084846497,
-0.20604294538497925,
-0.09868472814559937,
-0.4604015350341797,
-0.5911253690719604,
0.07747885584831238,
-0.29127442836761475,
0.11444023996591568,
-0.006688717287033796,
-0.29587072134017944,
0.608052134513855,
-0.5903035998344421,
0.5089880228042603,
-0.2031990885734558,
-0.05468359962105751,
0.33592042326927185,
-0.13665418326854706,
0.14550268650054932,
0.25127989053726196,
-0.03656718134880066,
0.606388509273529,
0.07364822924137115,
-0.4515746533870697,
-0.4690806567668915,
0.8521340489387512,
-0.8242470622062683,
-0.056375034153461456,
-0.783150851726532,
-0.4256919324398041,
0.1438198983669281,
0.2985403835773468,
-0.07883939892053604,
0.06264123320579529,
-0.07989777624607086,
0.0454694926738739,
0.42177560925483704,
-0.45377054810523987,
0.4724787473678589,
0.8704144358634949,
-0.08750157058238983,
-0.3377148509025574,
0.9232432842254639,
0.1934075653553009,
-0.2557452619075775,
0.5045284628868103,
0.41156649589538574,
-0.567489504814148,
-0.5954932570457458,
-0.2893088757991791,
0.2101149559020996,
-0.23796889185905457,
-0.16083966195583344,
-0.39766910672187805,
0.1955316811800003,
-0.2619553804397583,
0.09364233165979385,
-0.3249415457248688,
-0.8868858814239502,
-0.16850312054157257,
0.1534612476825714,
0.504613995552063,
0.4683365523815155,
-0.403824120759964,
0.38020458817481995,
-0.8893213868141174,
0.158105731010437,
0.07340200245380402,
0.751124918460846,
-0.40892091393470764,
-0.21582242846488953,
-0.46766936779022217,
0.003956424072384834,
-0.42486417293548584,
-1.0516091585159302,
0.824699878692627,
0.2610923647880554,
0.3056590259075165,
0.44543129205703735,
0.04107918217778206,
0.6385079026222229,
-0.5978131294250488,
0.42049628496170044,
-0.0648907795548439,
-0.847046434879303,
1.0485121011734009,
-0.48381707072257996,
0.03102932870388031,
0.6497814059257507,
0.7413951754570007,
-0.7815666794776917,
-0.4027594029903412,
-0.704242467880249,
-0.978611171245575,
0.6631638407707214,
0.4594326913356781,
-0.100827656686306,
-0.10394173860549927,
0.22654089331626892,
0.13817796111106873,
0.435161828994751,
-0.6243512630462646,
0.004930858034640551,
-0.32066816091537476,
0.08556625247001648,
0.030348191037774086,
-0.056463949382305145,
-0.2923566401004791,
0.04792403429746628,
0.9601375460624695,
-0.15621763467788696,
0.12543511390686035,
0.06951644271612167,
-0.10813203454017639,
-0.030681056901812553,
0.43439897894859314,
0.11442416906356812,
0.6243340969085693,
-0.4593326449394226,
0.08142096549272537,
0.05170705169439316,
-0.5773216485977173,
-0.2184925526380539,
0.5812094211578369,
-0.1935827136039734,
0.364499032497406,
-0.06175849214196205,
0.096440888941288,
0.58418208360672,
-0.9627332091331482,
0.45227524638175964,
-0.2552796006202698,
0.358837753534317,
-0.38010966777801514,
-0.12280014902353287,
0.039810702204704285,
0.309737890958786,
0.36302605271339417,
-0.17404764890670776,
0.2423962503671646,
-0.3839434087276459,
0.09851647913455963,
0.0044609070755541325,
-0.21964462101459503,
-0.15522795915603638,
0.36767151951789856,
0.4815009534358978,
-0.46008768677711487,
0.5989525318145752,
-0.28499406576156616,
-0.5019919276237488,
0.21139757335186005,
0.33521655201911926,
0.855832576751709,
-0.004810214042663574,
0.28975406289100647,
0.09189311414957047,
0.35387304425239563,
-0.09930863231420517,
0.3857913911342621,
-0.0763615071773529,
-0.6647328734397888,
-0.6445006132125854,
-0.5450772047042847,
-0.8112561106681824,
-0.18623752892017365,
-0.5203151702880859,
0.5577710270881653,
0.05715726688504219,
-0.17619429528713226,
-0.22211702167987823,
0.40950673818588257,
-0.5218378901481628,
-0.25706836581230164,
0.03800257667899132,
0.8046848177909851,
-0.8263686299324036,
1.0113564729690552,
0.522372305393219,
-0.5292929410934448,
-0.309404581785202,
-0.4122569262981415,
-0.1419149786233902,
-0.8186988234519958,
0.4702851176261902,
0.12559978663921356,
0.13420626521110535,
-0.05926256254315376,
-0.10400724411010742,
-0.784999668598175,
0.9303263425827026,
0.5235537886619568,
-0.4692869186401367,
0.06042635813355446,
0.41068702936172485,
0.9690802693367004,
-0.03695289418101311,
0.4432007670402527,
0.34983155131340027,
0.6096171736717224,
-0.31488609313964844,
-1.0756874084472656,
-0.4226335883140564,
-0.44688647985458374,
0.11151314526796341,
0.41723424196243286,
-0.2943868041038513,
0.5466599464416504,
0.302192360162735,
-0.11800993233919144,
-0.29351961612701416,
0.43649932742118835,
0.2409423142671585,
0.34699177742004395,
0.6459078192710876,
0.8312485814094543,
0.772540807723999,
-0.42069628834724426,
0.9245167374610901,
-0.6707619428634644,
0.4236372113227844,
0.9642453193664551,
0.022675953805446625,
0.995115339756012,
0.45908793807029724,
-0.14756107330322266,
0.3456709384918213,
0.46999451518058777,
-0.11623350530862808,
0.3236547112464905,
0.3149191737174988,
-0.29850760102272034,
0.3357718884944916,
-0.6690295934677124,
-0.55591881275177,
0.5612888932228088,
0.43889161944389343,
-0.17200171947479248,
-0.4418921172618866,
-0.19042612612247467,
0.023474814370274544,
0.1814805269241333,
-0.3208943009376526,
0.5653718709945679,
-0.10561561584472656,
-0.56355881690979,
0.2973737120628357,
0.17688825726509094,
0.8214001655578613,
-0.6982277035713196,
-0.1909882128238678,
-0.029083602130413055,
-0.0019470597617328167,
-0.10723377764225006,
-0.7701140642166138,
0.4771559536457062,
0.33521896600723267,
0.07981649041175842,
-0.78258216381073,
0.7889348864555359,
-0.4899651110172272,
-0.4600154757499695,
0.51719069480896,
0.6951301693916321,
0.40932390093803406,
-0.1384497433900833,
-1.0648692846298218,
-0.06902478635311127,
-0.518849790096283,
0.039039045572280884,
0.46259576082229614,
0.6861201524734497,
0.125654399394989,
0.7247780561447144,
0.7126138210296631,
0.5961614847183228,
0.14185932278633118,
0.41254210472106934,
1.0048656463623047,
-0.285652756690979,
-0.6992313861846924,
-0.6029005646705627,
0.051499418914318085,
-0.3597121834754944,
-0.4566240906715393,
0.6853029727935791,
0.7485069632530212,
1.0259649753570557,
0.1873045712709427,
0.5019550919532776,
-0.03847147524356842,
0.7540728449821472,
-0.055725082755088806,
0.6985421180725098,
-0.13724921643733978,
0.2877245247364044,
-0.5677417516708374,
-1.157740592956543,
-0.36342960596084595,
0.5732741951942444,
-0.11838453263044357,
-0.640425443649292,
0.3481261432170868,
0.8510294556617737,
0.033902719616889954,
-0.10494282841682434,
-0.1677013784646988,
0.3057299554347992,
0.3646062910556793,
0.44033241271972656,
0.6696003079414368,
-0.17717838287353516,
0.8632278442382812,
-0.6108663082122803,
-0.2531678378582001,
-0.32490941882133484,
-1.3570462465286255,
-0.25955164432525635,
-0.5372378826141357,
-0.24769306182861328,
-0.303456574678421,
0.11362361907958984,
1.0613043308258057,
0.31641095876693726,
-0.7081090807914734,
-0.3878795802593231,
-0.04919331893324852,
0.3920736014842987,
-0.3531195819377899,
-0.23913779854774475,
0.4010477662086487,
-0.3118689954280853,
-1.0329307317733765,
0.4496675729751587,
0.5957284569740295,
-0.32900527119636536,
-0.5844454169273376,
0.076148122549057,
-0.3695293068885803,
-0.46920451521873474,
0.42125067114830017,
0.44473573565483093,
-0.1279328167438507,
-0.09456617385149002,
-0.19836470484733582,
0.16191831231117249,
0.11086634546518326,
0.7911396622657776,
-0.9967204928398132,
0.6488266587257385,
0.7580707669258118,
0.7606704831123352,
0.34260693192481995,
-0.22665615379810333,
0.5123616456985474,
-1.1662085056304932,
0.4749670624732971,
0.6156384944915771,
0.647882878780365,
0.2553914785385132,
0.1252879947423935,
0.8353897929191589,
0.35248857736587524,
-0.6317996978759766,
-0.7787551283836365,
-0.14632394909858704,
-1.3231797218322754,
0.10580277442932129,
0.7405935525894165,
0.013995178043842316,
-0.2134472280740738,
-0.14139613509178162,
-0.4851762354373932,
0.38479018211364746,
-0.6462454199790955,
1.1858432292938232,
0.5781830549240112,
0.04079419746994972,
0.2225354164838791,
-0.5523445010185242,
0.3239421844482422,
0.2162289172410965,
-0.5905563235282898,
-0.11572428792715073,
0.45571228861808777,
-0.016684290021657944,
0.47465595602989197,
0.6826722025871277,
-0.00043212634045630693,
0.006131127942353487,
-0.4413868188858032,
0.03797806799411774,
0.06741677969694138,
-0.03414526581764221,
-0.4244203269481659,
0.2801762819290161,
-0.2499154508113861,
-0.039387039840221405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15393v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15393v1 | Semantics of Multiword Expressions in Transformer-Based Models: A Survey | 2024-01-27T11:51:11 | 2024-01-27T11:51:11 | Filip Miletić, Sabine Schulte im Walde | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multiword expressions (MWEs) are composed of multiple words and exhibit
variable degrees of compositionality. As such, their meanings are notoriously
difficult to model, and it is unclear to what extent this issue affects
transformer architectures. Addressing this gap, we provide the first in-depth
survey of MWE processing with transformer models. We overall find that they
capture MWE semantics inconsistently, as shown by reliance on surface patterns
and memorized information. MWE meaning is also strongly localized,
predominantly in early layers of the architecture. Representations benefit from
specific linguistic properties, such as lower semantic idiosyncrasy and
ambiguity of target expressions. Our findings overall question the ability of
transformer models to robustly capture fine-grained semantics. Furthermore, we
highlight the need for more directly comparable evaluation setups. | [
-0.5610324144363403,
-0.46328189969062805,
0.5836796164512634,
0.20699414610862732,
-0.008120045997202396,
0.023657288402318954,
0.18876507878303528,
-0.6255942583084106,
-0.036545105278491974,
0.38722309470176697,
-0.6160351037979126,
-0.19374050199985504,
-1.1193757057189941,
0.1640697568655014,
-0.3796651363372803,
0.755938708782196,
-0.24440138041973114,
-0.20356324315071106,
0.058836985379457474,
-0.500883936882019,
-0.5103939771652222,
-0.5418155193328857,
0.03351663798093796,
-0.3531337082386017,
0.4910973310470581,
0.03261158615350723,
0.7447216510772705,
0.4050467312335968,
0.6931357383728027,
0.3465380072593689,
-0.24881388247013092,
-0.02593284100294113,
-0.31397393345832825,
0.15105637907981873,
0.010714798234403133,
-0.24219867587089539,
-0.3408779203891754,
0.13375653326511383,
0.28446975350379944,
0.9116532206535339,
-0.18155556917190552,
0.20091994106769562,
0.10588666796684265,
0.39290401339530945,
-0.7588923573493958,
0.3101049065589905,
-0.7907248139381409,
0.123519666492939,
-0.34390729665756226,
0.14354802668094635,
-0.6168205142021179,
0.3030248284339905,
0.33782926201820374,
-0.2817501723766327,
0.3177727162837982,
-0.23344556987285614,
1.000900387763977,
0.1805511862039566,
-0.6656606197357178,
-0.1874479353427887,
-0.8103246092796326,
0.8303315043449402,
-0.6413784623146057,
0.6556631922721863,
-0.04108608141541481,
0.3209696412086487,
0.06115196645259857,
-1.0166466236114502,
-0.6342707872390747,
-0.20917609333992004,
-0.5837576985359192,
0.35304126143455505,
-0.6273038983345032,
0.19615179300308228,
0.3880184590816498,
0.3172788918018341,
-0.22612632811069489,
0.002041574800387025,
-0.21728643774986267,
-0.3115321099758148,
0.4000955820083618,
0.37047454714775085,
-0.14792457222938538,
-0.5441917777061462,
-0.6668296456336975,
-0.12571045756340027,
-0.38724958896636963,
0.09250728785991669,
0.08026370406150818,
0.1671185940504074,
-0.19617904722690582,
0.7774257659912109,
0.03754059225320816,
0.5711206197738647,
-0.24739797413349152,
0.0306564774364233,
0.03775126487016678,
-0.315635621547699,
-0.29870307445526123,
-0.42657119035720825,
0.695762574672699,
0.20367957651615143,
-0.14602972567081451,
-0.563925564289093,
-0.35503843426704407,
0.42842236161231995,
0.4739595353603363,
-0.7952144145965576,
0.051782120019197464,
0.17096425592899323,
-0.7771400213241577,
-0.0995415672659874,
0.3631584644317627,
-0.786786675453186,
-0.3019837439060211,
-0.21412116289138794,
0.44041600823402405,
-0.14533305168151855,
-0.1437814086675644,
0.2536146640777588,
-0.5146744847297668,
0.5313401818275452,
-0.10359673947095871,
-0.634282648563385,
0.42688143253326416,
0.4764486849308014,
0.6465446352958679,
-0.046198394149541855,
-0.37820854783058167,
-0.05257841944694519,
0.1756596565246582,
-0.002778824185952544,
0.7378020286560059,
-0.5503237247467041,
-0.7238006591796875,
-0.07154513150453568,
0.11908843368291855,
-0.355655699968338,
-0.409248024225235,
0.5435897707939148,
-0.624510645866394,
0.3324163854122162,
-0.0225676279515028,
-0.711291491985321,
-0.13008320331573486,
0.0004550939192995429,
-0.8384143114089966,
0.9247997403144836,
0.2532522976398468,
-0.6665766835212708,
0.23998455703258514,
-0.9597326517105103,
-0.3932860791683197,
-0.24738529324531555,
-0.053705960512161255,
-0.12454172968864441,
0.7433933615684509,
-0.060773879289627075,
0.5574953556060791,
-0.27032673358917236,
0.2676784098148346,
-0.08798343688249588,
-0.101805679500103,
0.2484263777732849,
-0.8851687908172607,
0.23385846614837646,
0.1555756777524948,
-0.38983720541000366,
0.032917872071266174,
-0.8505162000656128,
-0.1216394379734993,
0.16779886186122894,
-0.09883078187704086,
-0.18696218729019165,
0.23886196315288544,
0.08896675705909729,
0.5268458127975464,
0.2540504038333893,
-0.7899687886238098,
0.44485071301460266,
-0.16571713984012604,
0.36636435985565186,
0.6274955868721008,
-0.17416729032993317,
0.36604610085487366,
-0.2348279058933258,
0.49015095829963684,
0.4174765348434448,
0.04138891026377678,
-0.2645948529243469,
-0.7433733940124512,
-0.5218148231506348,
-0.10315436124801636,
-0.01647150330245495,
0.4937713146209717,
-0.4515514671802521,
0.11227861046791077,
-0.3657125234603882,
-0.6869644522666931,
-0.6872968077659607,
-0.21162280440330505,
0.2609688341617584,
0.25236719846725464,
0.658104419708252,
0.07668810337781906,
-0.29926130175590515,
-1.2583009004592896,
-0.3688379228115082,
0.2652675211429596,
-0.07610315084457397,
0.2992051839828491,
0.40259045362472534,
-0.3265109062194824,
0.9249097108840942,
-0.8111129403114319,
-0.24552036821842194,
-0.10634231567382812,
0.6157876253128052,
0.11650659888982773,
0.10493314266204834,
0.4886179566383362,
-0.8966473340988159,
-0.14130936563014984,
0.02849421091377735,
-0.5173799991607666,
-0.07879983633756638,
0.004646263085305691,
0.07112360000610352,
-0.13804471492767334,
0.4761485457420349,
-1.011462688446045,
0.4814782738685608,
0.8099944591522217,
-0.22186727821826935,
0.3225056827068329,
-0.08919480443000793,
0.11337945610284805,
-1.0635766983032227,
-0.10046868771314621,
0.04145898297429085,
0.08747117966413498,
-0.7649096846580505,
0.31606364250183105,
0.029659554362297058,
-0.06371384859085083,
-0.557255744934082,
0.43291717767715454,
-0.44440531730651855,
0.1681581735610962,
-0.32760676741600037,
0.12992587685585022,
0.2335389107465744,
0.3641102612018585,
-0.01954847201704979,
0.7616307139396667,
0.4725951850414276,
-0.637637197971344,
0.10971421748399734,
0.1331905722618103,
-0.2500750422477722,
0.34562692046165466,
-0.7753580808639526,
0.12285085767507553,
-0.3155417740345001,
0.11390591412782669,
-0.9609362483024597,
-0.15855036675930023,
-0.10243996232748032,
-0.08941057324409485,
0.28299206495285034,
0.051689453423023224,
-0.29720619320869446,
-0.3026469349861145,
-0.20164994895458221,
0.46365901827812195,
0.17337873578071594,
-0.3185153603553772,
1.127509355545044,
0.3599397540092468,
0.34673845767974854,
-0.5351237058639526,
-0.714881420135498,
0.005242562852799892,
-0.32297712564468384,
-0.7193163633346558,
0.7327184081077576,
0.2266654074192047,
-0.27759456634521484,
0.017201686277985573,
-0.21023213863372803,
-0.23516851663589478,
0.19466564059257507,
0.1277083307504654,
0.13095903396606445,
-0.37460461258888245,
-0.046914342790842056,
-0.09511952847242355,
-0.11428538709878922,
0.15840135514736176,
-0.0142015740275383,
0.563562273979187,
-0.2298046499490738,
-0.4970002770423889,
-0.12889592349529266,
0.755092978477478,
0.9381319880485535,
-0.40643638372421265,
0.8980531096458435,
0.653415858745575,
-0.5555066466331482,
0.020026795566082,
-0.3342951536178589,
-0.1323087066411972,
-0.45010703802108765,
0.3127090036869049,
-0.8734223246574402,
-0.8109123110771179,
0.9229468703269958,
-0.1128244698047638,
0.10154479742050171,
1.0072453022003174,
0.25606173276901245,
-0.12537343800067902,
1.2198832035064697,
0.5905554890632629,
0.3063698410987854,
0.11822383850812912,
-0.30277594923973083,
0.4435652494430542,
-1.0151499509811401,
-0.33835557103157043,
-0.7436333894729614,
-0.46023011207580566,
-0.9737353324890137,
-0.19227559864521027,
0.28977257013320923,
-0.038810260593891144,
0.06320924311876297,
0.6802031993865967,
-0.510105550289154,
0.18065282702445984,
0.27342942357063293,
-0.11462302505970001,
0.049746111035346985,
-0.3946402966976166,
0.07011843472719193,
-0.16348455846309662,
-0.6459571123123169,
-0.6742062568664551,
0.5480002760887146,
0.3541264235973358,
0.7418476939201355,
0.3784741759300232,
0.38394156098365784,
0.08648223429918289,
0.32105687260627747,
-1.0089685916900635,
0.34037792682647705,
-0.49890127778053284,
-0.6316707134246826,
0.04616432264447212,
-0.3872694969177246,
-1.1106131076812744,
0.5498656630516052,
-0.12423665076494217,
-0.8434453010559082,
0.3039979934692383,
-0.16082186996936798,
-0.07001752406358719,
0.4158512055873871,
-0.7958808541297913,
1.2404476404190063,
-0.0034579006023705006,
0.17751379311084747,
-0.1702074259519577,
-0.7408357262611389,
0.3620864450931549,
0.013625847175717354,
0.3560687005519867,
-0.06173015013337135,
0.05336705967783928,
0.37151843309402466,
-0.37176263332366943,
0.7149177193641663,
-0.21386109292507172,
-0.2873450815677643,
0.2252146303653717,
0.15497322380542755,
0.3699161112308502,
-0.3940596580505371,
-0.010599412955343723,
0.40036484599113464,
0.2203105241060257,
-0.3721657991409302,
-0.6171845197677612,
0.26655444502830505,
-0.6125880479812622,
-0.3682321012020111,
-0.2714264392852783,
-0.45037731528282166,
-0.32509931921958923,
0.1384139209985733,
0.5376300811767578,
0.6835767030715942,
-0.23651370406150818,
0.11949936300516129,
0.3064042925834656,
0.06743458658456802,
0.5689467787742615,
0.36209914088249207,
-0.06599041819572449,
0.07452835142612457,
0.6548937559127808,
0.19928474724292755,
0.4280644953250885,
0.5291508436203003,
0.28073564171791077,
-0.29101768136024475,
-0.49030357599258423,
-0.45137670636177063,
-0.03709445893764496,
-0.9133532047271729,
-0.30411648750305176,
-0.6504551768302917,
-0.18189451098442078,
0.016778068616986275,
-0.06233416125178337,
-0.4318452775478363,
-0.3704586625099182,
-0.07470013201236725,
-0.03938876837491989,
0.14830608665943146,
1.0986818075180054,
0.4680401682853699,
0.6955317854881287,
-1.2076412439346313,
0.6817699670791626,
0.22133786976337433,
0.4886433482170105,
-0.19437633454799652,
-0.36466485261917114,
-0.13060379028320312,
0.07887561619281769,
-0.3458307087421417,
-1.0602296590805054,
-0.15932902693748474,
0.28403589129447937,
0.6443192958831787,
0.17057940363883972,
-0.18180423974990845,
0.7345944046974182,
-0.6570658683776855,
1.1616066694259644,
-0.009389977902173996,
-1.197063684463501,
0.2875366508960724,
-0.017943881452083588,
0.41504037380218506,
0.3730842173099518,
0.19580796360969543,
-0.585252046585083,
-0.6348364949226379,
-0.7985643744468689,
-0.856874406337738,
0.4861235022544861,
-0.05352042615413666,
0.8057843446731567,
-0.30007389187812805,
0.195532888174057,
0.15087424218654633,
0.2700265645980835,
-0.7749497294425964,
-0.47579872608184814,
-0.2766192853450775,
-0.16264945268630981,
0.4010164141654968,
-0.25919464230537415,
-0.07002296298742294,
-0.04093185439705849,
0.4095233082771301,
-0.23231865465641022,
0.4980832636356354,
-0.02942138910293579,
-0.2682158648967743,
0.1929023265838623,
0.48171666264533997,
0.7299060821533203,
0.5033799409866333,
0.1289934664964676,
0.321687251329422,
0.18821531534194946,
-0.3833930790424347,
0.02162664197385311,
0.11177864670753479,
0.04364122822880745,
0.36961808800697327,
0.5182865858078003,
0.9653500318527222,
0.484128475189209,
-0.32023361325263977,
0.7950845956802368,
-0.16419585049152374,
-0.024465179070830345,
0.04122289642691612,
-0.3145900368690491,
0.002273416146636009,
-0.024491045624017715,
0.21560557186603546,
0.5724918842315674,
0.24284058809280396,
-0.3099367022514343,
0.13242734968662262,
0.628564715385437,
-0.425680547952652,
-0.33758431673049927,
0.628755509853363,
-0.1691562831401825,
0.059474531561136246,
0.5888319611549377,
-0.19717539846897125,
-0.46293002367019653,
0.3703914284706116,
0.37997621297836304,
0.978255033493042,
-0.06950869411230087,
-0.13350923359394073,
-0.069971464574337,
0.45635706186294556,
0.12083801627159119,
0.16057628393173218,
0.12981702387332916,
-1.031816840171814,
-0.5387551188468933,
-0.6484978199005127,
-0.26219117641448975,
-0.1518811732530594,
-0.7902225255966187,
0.39659151434898376,
0.055794402956962585,
-0.29960593581199646,
0.24639496207237244,
-0.7159382700920105,
-0.8703891038894653,
0.10669656097888947,
0.21004678308963776,
1.0883041620254517,
-0.839150071144104,
0.6144683957099915,
0.7382427453994751,
-0.3689796030521393,
-1.1272644996643066,
-0.0908815860748291,
-0.204875186085701,
-0.6147105097770691,
0.4817884564399719,
0.38629862666130066,
-0.5952360033988953,
-0.09436797350645065,
-0.11863425374031067,
-0.6085169315338135,
0.8957924246788025,
0.29789695143699646,
-0.22435548901557922,
-0.22956708073616028,
0.3908066749572754,
0.5128819942474365,
-0.25872671604156494,
0.49909454584121704,
0.584877610206604,
0.7315952181816101,
-0.09150959551334381,
-1.0789095163345337,
-0.19013532996177673,
-0.050948139280080795,
0.15230891108512878,
0.5104351043701172,
-0.4697243273258209,
0.8469021320343018,
0.14852970838546753,
-0.4410833716392517,
-0.07012232393026352,
0.6773989796638489,
-0.4656038284301758,
0.10262947529554367,
0.3059398829936981,
0.6612125039100647,
0.47818630933761597,
-0.43522199988365173,
1.3709813356399536,
-0.5456175208091736,
0.6181959509849548,
0.8095856308937073,
-0.14786171913146973,
0.8146997094154358,
0.42212975025177,
-0.3638850748538971,
0.5957974791526794,
0.11531839519739151,
0.04430323466658592,
0.388234406709671,
-0.027009034529328346,
-0.34438228607177734,
-0.11482582241296768,
-0.09459353983402252,
-0.15634706616401672,
1.1498302221298218,
0.27929064631462097,
-0.29494422674179077,
-0.5064922571182251,
0.17778779566287994,
-0.1684209555387497,
-0.010225837118923664,
-0.10501281917095184,
0.9110224843025208,
0.08220919221639633,
-0.4028765559196472,
0.1556171476840973,
0.26611506938934326,
0.785490095615387,
-0.8707677125930786,
-0.002118003787472844,
0.024852899834513664,
0.009580050595104694,
-0.3120574653148651,
-0.8760764002799988,
0.8806846737861633,
-0.04825207591056824,
-0.3783729076385498,
-0.5014840364456177,
0.670877993106842,
-0.2057787925004959,
-0.46534645557403564,
0.49124085903167725,
0.8505982756614685,
-0.06295724958181381,
-0.15447500348091125,
-0.4139271378517151,
0.04761574789881706,
-0.39398428797721863,
-0.4200618863105774,
-0.013743768446147442,
0.5814377069473267,
0.02329172194004059,
0.29697278141975403,
0.2634696960449219,
-0.17054051160812378,
0.48160549998283386,
0.3442647457122803,
0.6331324577331543,
-0.570774495601654,
0.055929407477378845,
-0.8582760095596313,
0.9569324851036072,
0.18457500636577606,
-0.44182631373405457,
0.6311497688293457,
0.5109136700630188,
0.8108947277069092,
-0.1990816742181778,
0.568286120891571,
-0.17894767224788666,
0.10052160173654556,
-0.48985835909843445,
0.3861366808414459,
-0.4932246804237366,
0.03946586325764656,
-0.20454800128936768,
-1.1221647262573242,
-0.2491409033536911,
0.4644232392311096,
0.055827539414167404,
-0.03797302767634392,
0.7348788976669312,
0.4991684854030609,
-0.4097490906715393,
0.2678951323032379,
0.3521202504634857,
0.1986389011144638,
0.3962875306606293,
0.2432854026556015,
0.9932884573936462,
-0.742181122303009,
0.38282638788223267,
-0.3460104465484619,
0.04914800822734833,
0.22573038935661316,
-0.9890344738960266,
-0.15975099802017212,
-0.5998361706733704,
-0.135983407497406,
-0.19551314413547516,
-0.6831310987472534,
0.7400147914886475,
0.5870636105537415,
-0.8456542491912842,
-0.17480023205280304,
-0.035797055810689926,
-0.010863808915019035,
-0.39361873269081116,
-0.27194908261299133,
0.14200538396835327,
-0.3001014292240143,
-0.6768755912780762,
0.5571021437644958,
0.14456260204315186,
0.08667059242725372,
-0.300766259431839,
0.19502846896648407,
0.18147510290145874,
0.28358885645866394,
1.0343858003616333,
-0.24091756343841553,
-0.8363060355186462,
-0.6803911328315735,
0.34741419553756714,
-0.24751678109169006,
0.21730242669582367,
1.0831818580627441,
-0.6678537726402283,
0.2774477005004883,
0.330518901348114,
0.7505130767822266,
0.42183032631874084,
-0.106556735932827,
0.3413488268852234,
-0.8551464676856995,
-0.011804942041635513,
0.19787567853927612,
0.7867498993873596,
0.1780177503824234,
-0.04545004293322563,
0.04451605677604675,
0.24759168922901154,
-0.20981834828853607,
-0.45968133211135864,
0.719851553440094,
-1.1159285306930542,
-0.30548709630966187,
0.7693220973014832,
-0.04023652523756027,
0.16457125544548035,
0.06526365876197815,
-0.12486601620912552,
0.15829753875732422,
0.3072521984577179,
0.5393070578575134,
1.0977075099945068,
-0.41929441690444946,
0.004514595959335566,
-0.5353362560272217,
0.017193445935845375,
0.3201025426387787,
-0.5885722041130066,
0.11433230340480804,
0.48200279474258423,
0.027771441265940666,
0.5728197693824768,
0.18399012088775635,
-0.16882893443107605,
-0.06322798877954483,
0.09220118820667267,
-0.0959494560956955,
-0.00019668076129164547,
-0.32616087794303894,
-0.3943668007850647,
0.5891196727752686,
0.06754716485738754,
-0.21051226556301117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15391v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15391v1 | MultiHop-RAG: Benchmarking Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Multi-Hop Queries | 2024-01-27T11:41:48 | 2024-01-27T11:41:48 | Yixuan Tang, Yi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) augments large language models (LLM) by
retrieving relevant knowledge, showing promising potential in mitigating LLM
hallucinations and enhancing response quality, thereby facilitating the great
adoption of LLMs in practice. However, we find that existing RAG systems are
inadequate in answering multi-hop queries, which require retrieving and
reasoning over multiple pieces of supporting evidence. Furthermore, to our
knowledge, no existing RAG benchmarking dataset focuses on multi-hop queries.
In this paper, we develop a novel dataset, MultiHop-RAG, which consists of a
knowledge base, a large collection of multi-hop queries, their ground-truth
answers, and the associated supporting evidence. We detail the procedure of
building the dataset, utilizing an English news article dataset as the
underlying RAG knowledge base. We demonstrate the benchmarking utility of
MultiHop-RAG in two experiments. The first experiment compares different
embedding models for retrieving evidence for multi-hop queries. In the second
experiment, we examine the capabilities of various state-of-the-art LLMs,
including GPT-4, PaLM, and Llama2-70B, in reasoning and answering multi-hop
queries given the evidence. Both experiments reveal that existing RAG methods
perform unsatisfactorily in retrieving and answering multi-hop queries. We hope
MultiHop-RAG will be a valuable resource for the community in developing
effective RAG systems, thereby facilitating greater adoption of LLMs in
practice. The MultiHop-RAG and implemented RAG system is publicly available at
https://github.com/yixuantt/MultiHop-RAG/. | [
-0.45152533054351807,
-0.686712920665741,
0.5294828414916992,
0.320141464471817,
-0.19826845824718475,
0.4596284031867981,
-0.0037183023523539305,
-0.5804713368415833,
0.39833348989486694,
0.4564509689807892,
-0.28731927275657654,
-0.1837427318096161,
-0.589154064655304,
0.016110379248857498,
-0.34209319949150085,
0.7972174882888794,
0.1424177885055542,
0.027897553518414497,
-0.13136982917785645,
-0.409040629863739,
-0.34272295236587524,
-0.4455307126045227,
-0.5259377956390381,
-0.08768937736749649,
0.5432643890380859,
0.3845862150192261,
0.472475528717041,
0.3891642689704895,
0.35066351294517517,
0.1897556334733963,
-0.02066095732152462,
0.6920072436332703,
-0.37428414821624756,
0.4504043757915497,
0.07863210141658783,
-0.27614444494247437,
-0.4833235442638397,
0.09507334977388382,
0.5830010175704956,
0.4210052490234375,
-0.03755917027592659,
0.3903725743293762,
-0.04073707014322281,
0.8225352764129639,
-1.013279914855957,
-0.11966745555400848,
-0.8444119691848755,
-0.1606256514787674,
-0.48452749848365784,
-0.2885284721851349,
-0.4786822497844696,
-0.37754589319229126,
-0.2688307464122772,
-0.5294732451438904,
0.14402832090854645,
0.3514114022254944,
0.5555198192596436,
0.16705524921417236,
-0.782651424407959,
-0.431875079870224,
-0.44616690278053284,
0.5799925327301025,
-0.3966292142868042,
0.716958224773407,
0.3358832001686096,
0.5632515549659729,
-0.2730054259300232,
-0.7583186626434326,
-0.5758216381072998,
-0.1458982229232788,
-0.09492319077253342,
0.31948187947273254,
0.18224617838859558,
-0.46513232588768005,
0.39288330078125,
0.28080007433891296,
-0.6019853353500366,
-0.383151650428772,
0.040873199701309204,
-0.12201770395040512,
0.3606332838535309,
0.03134696185588837,
-0.11162712424993515,
-0.26818087697029114,
-0.509604811668396,
-0.17638789117336273,
-0.6512163281440735,
-0.008515242487192154,
0.2510858476161957,
0.3225538730621338,
0.1862206757068634,
0.5266776084899902,
-0.29487165808677673,
0.7423994541168213,
-0.3129536509513855,
-0.5334029793739319,
0.555560290813446,
-0.1766502559185028,
0.07858842611312866,
-0.3395288586616516,
0.6355156302452087,
0.24083642661571503,
0.08741379529237747,
-0.26361170411109924,
-0.10469000786542892,
-0.09458214789628983,
0.24976472556591034,
-0.6689607501029968,
0.07635975629091263,
0.011331752873957157,
-0.31368666887283325,
-0.2677108645439148,
0.03664342686533928,
-1.1601356267929077,
-0.503960907459259,
-0.0025603482499718666,
0.3443940281867981,
-0.3323427140712738,
-0.5396465063095093,
-0.13495518267154694,
-0.4091830551624298,
0.44759485125541687,
0.14305086433887482,
-0.28492408990859985,
0.45906010270118713,
0.7429376244544983,
0.7720313668251038,
-0.15541349351406097,
-0.4643564522266388,
-0.7031282782554626,
0.2850053012371063,
-0.48084771633148193,
0.9769439697265625,
-0.6047185659408569,
-0.19860367476940155,
-0.13339366018772125,
-0.03166284039616585,
-0.05826917290687561,
-0.5779902935028076,
0.8451921939849854,
-0.9184991121292114,
-0.05932607874274254,
-0.35553088784217834,
-0.49428942799568176,
0.10372157394886017,
0.6014527678489685,
-0.73792964220047,
1.2219023704528809,
-0.17186027765274048,
-0.9423324465751648,
0.2670367956161499,
-0.3268561065196991,
-0.49567514657974243,
-0.11825814843177795,
-0.21272926032543182,
-0.4457152187824249,
0.171075239777565,
0.4426646828651428,
0.01636323146522045,
-0.5678336024284363,
0.016294797882437706,
-0.3461688160896301,
-0.25789695978164673,
0.16169200837612152,
-0.4388063848018646,
0.7686641812324524,
0.3891342878341675,
-0.062135569751262665,
-0.42544275522232056,
-0.7932287454605103,
0.2629129886627197,
0.38625386357307434,
-0.3766925036907196,
-0.5052040815353394,
-0.10317303985357285,
-0.0056363921612501144,
0.21154175698757172,
0.07681851089000702,
-0.49166303873062134,
0.2683085501194,
0.04881591722369194,
-0.20322634279727936,
0.45739299058914185,
0.08454976230859756,
0.05512256920337677,
-0.596138596534729,
0.484323650598526,
-0.10514769703149796,
-0.028846735134720802,
-0.49791479110717773,
-0.5902482271194458,
-0.3242815434932709,
-0.18150728940963745,
0.3347236216068268,
0.3777933120727539,
-0.8282061219215393,
-0.22949278354644775,
-0.1326686292886734,
-0.42490264773368835,
-0.44060251116752625,
-0.1552288830280304,
0.435830682516098,
0.6795573830604553,
0.5045319199562073,
-0.004136967472732067,
-0.4515168368816376,
-0.615362286567688,
-0.6712373495101929,
0.14445911347866058,
0.06494145095348358,
0.6829684972763062,
0.12801510095596313,
-0.06639096885919571,
0.730303943157196,
-0.4103681445121765,
-0.11186789721250534,
-0.018067393451929092,
0.21351557970046997,
0.2752412259578705,
0.0750204548239708,
0.3939940631389618,
-0.8793062567710876,
-0.5585190057754517,
-0.24309860169887543,
-0.562362015247345,
-0.2149290293455124,
0.04888966307044029,
-0.2576625347137451,
0.1974991410970688,
0.4166191816329956,
-0.6160821318626404,
0.2590472400188446,
0.7456738948822021,
-0.15565761923789978,
0.9247543215751648,
-0.10132350772619247,
0.49164333939552307,
-1.2595418691635132,
0.18240463733673096,
-0.36294621229171753,
-0.3280929923057556,
-0.45279258489608765,
0.19843129813671112,
0.3584034740924835,
0.02395910769701004,
-0.15206071734428406,
0.6694781184196472,
-0.685932993888855,
-0.4959908723831177,
-0.5212745070457458,
0.21346139907836914,
0.3914569616317749,
0.31855297088623047,
-0.035309966653585434,
1.02432119846344,
0.27171555161476135,
-0.4968072175979614,
0.20648734271526337,
0.22321738302707672,
-0.1661621481180191,
0.4364706575870514,
-0.4327769875526428,
0.3809688091278076,
-0.02891543321311474,
0.40818920731544495,
-0.9147068858146667,
-0.19443391263484955,
0.03459934890270233,
-0.5930585861206055,
0.2758631408214569,
-0.5888208150863647,
-0.5692845582962036,
-0.35635170340538025,
-0.4238780736923218,
0.5603141188621521,
0.29172369837760925,
-0.775151252746582,
0.7627495527267456,
0.5494881272315979,
0.04565415158867836,
-0.9412394762039185,
-0.2773219645023346,
0.14407306909561157,
-0.25969573855400085,
-0.4453682005405426,
0.40856003761291504,
0.02519112080335617,
-0.0992908701300621,
0.0288067813962698,
-0.35054638981819153,
-0.049934472888708115,
-0.2034420371055603,
-0.06883231550455093,
0.1332898885011673,
0.020631274208426476,
0.28933385014533997,
-0.08151978254318237,
-0.15879158675670624,
-0.068153977394104,
-0.11281771957874298,
0.6572775840759277,
-0.05979805067181587,
-0.5843584537506104,
0.38046789169311523,
0.28243064880371094,
0.5394691824913025,
-0.5374704599380493,
0.47743937373161316,
0.7128221988677979,
-0.14703194797039032,
-0.3138594925403595,
-0.8566633462905884,
-0.07266169041395187,
-0.4132401943206787,
0.12089639157056808,
-0.6457654237747192,
-0.6578165888786316,
0.3498156666755676,
-0.6423187255859375,
0.04800384119153023,
0.2852557599544525,
0.482531875371933,
-0.04615439474582672,
0.8011245131492615,
0.2673463821411133,
-0.0003852991503663361,
0.1527305692434311,
-0.0916181355714798,
-0.04839030280709267,
-1.2204197645187378,
-0.13949833810329437,
-0.762880802154541,
-0.2372996062040329,
-0.7959886193275452,
-0.6911513805389404,
0.6309001445770264,
0.2673811614513397,
-0.35857316851615906,
0.01818775199353695,
-0.23522627353668213,
0.5476569533348083,
0.7300946712493896,
0.005190618801862001,
0.6423381567001343,
-0.06799991428852081,
-0.3232588469982147,
0.10443581640720367,
-0.5824131369590759,
-0.24180907011032104,
1.3339245319366455,
-0.03698420152068138,
0.9109954833984375,
0.2426658570766449,
0.6741356253623962,
0.10476461797952652,
0.1410795897245407,
-0.5117267370223999,
0.3448186218738556,
-0.13339228928089142,
-0.6429426670074463,
0.04714509844779968,
-0.7231408953666687,
-0.9771604537963867,
0.5265325903892517,
-0.3242688775062561,
-0.43410226702690125,
-0.025123847648501396,
0.02530309371650219,
0.003931161016225815,
0.35319235920906067,
-0.5376195907592773,
0.502616286277771,
-0.6088436245918274,
-0.46697333455085754,
-0.02423330768942833,
-0.5741806626319885,
0.5499753952026367,
-0.15962514281272888,
0.5196284651756287,
-0.15263856947422028,
-0.015365866012871265,
0.6602153182029724,
-0.1402832716703415,
0.30566903948783875,
-0.37360095977783203,
0.23851116001605988,
0.15947121381759644,
0.13530805706977844,
0.6294062733650208,
0.2580658197402954,
-0.06836915761232376,
0.01516894344240427,
-0.04638766124844551,
-0.2324346899986267,
-0.5240079164505005,
0.6629703640937805,
-0.6741078495979309,
-0.38946640491485596,
-0.6013539433479309,
-0.6264694333076477,
-0.7656127214431763,
0.46388331055641174,
-0.054279569536447525,
0.5217856168746948,
0.0531223863363266,
0.15294389426708221,
0.5659888386726379,
-0.2894870340824127,
0.2020188271999359,
0.653842568397522,
-0.6083866357803345,
-0.4805484116077423,
0.7755159735679626,
0.025468505918979645,
-0.025425909087061882,
0.26363417506217957,
0.46408310532569885,
-0.40938469767570496,
-0.4163583219051361,
-0.4620125889778137,
0.19922754168510437,
-0.4571404457092285,
-0.6050901412963867,
-0.764320969581604,
-0.17277830839157104,
-0.4728131592273712,
0.33247777819633484,
-0.5519739985466003,
-0.5330025553703308,
0.5087727904319763,
0.20036369562149048,
0.4526003897190094,
0.7228585481643677,
-0.2546883821487427,
-0.014719922095537186,
-0.8134685754776001,
0.8846551775932312,
0.2487952560186386,
0.7298293709754944,
0.057624924927949905,
-0.34788522124290466,
-0.2482449859380722,
-0.06607729196548462,
-0.407894104719162,
-0.9801499843597412,
0.2201160341501236,
0.10600245743989944,
0.7718676328659058,
0.07719550281763077,
0.22814859449863434,
0.7939049601554871,
-0.7956233024597168,
0.31547266244888306,
-0.187940314412117,
-0.5166324377059937,
0.4401746094226837,
-0.2843623459339142,
0.10355310887098312,
0.5166852474212646,
0.5259430408477783,
-0.5759639143943787,
-0.2638050317764282,
-0.4978403151035309,
-1.0461167097091675,
0.5760404467582703,
-0.14121520519256592,
-0.14527642726898193,
-0.04966244101524353,
0.30598580837249756,
0.11674107611179352,
0.3005620539188385,
-0.5140620470046997,
-0.34147635102272034,
-0.105406753718853,
0.29533037543296814,
0.15895479917526245,
-0.3196829855442047,
-0.12727797031402588,
0.07002292573451996,
0.74915611743927,
-0.17340533435344696,
0.2960120141506195,
-0.025775335729122162,
-0.09944725036621094,
-0.04635528475046158,
0.1944703608751297,
0.18219217658042908,
0.6934302449226379,
-0.21521948277950287,
0.208020880818367,
0.013978640548884869,
-0.49273034930229187,
0.0759342759847641,
0.3373611271381378,
-0.14538270235061646,
0.0020366560202091932,
0.3287012279033661,
0.35095521807670593,
-0.09072248637676239,
-0.515845537185669,
0.4481174051761627,
-0.22005298733711243,
-0.041005492210388184,
-0.22272241115570068,
-0.24250133335590363,
0.23215706646442413,
0.3767237365245819,
0.6960667371749878,
0.0737384706735611,
0.33252817392349243,
-0.3522321283817291,
0.48920178413391113,
0.6524317860603333,
0.3535727262496948,
0.13306459784507751,
0.5862686634063721,
-0.18080465495586395,
-0.26946303248405457,
0.5349577069282532,
-0.36244770884513855,
-0.4469388723373413,
0.33120402693748474,
0.6802424192428589,
0.565379798412323,
-0.0914652869105339,
0.10357363522052765,
0.45202377438545227,
0.32241198420524597,
-0.0650496557354927,
0.24327032268047333,
0.00504058413207531,
-0.8578118085861206,
-0.6137165427207947,
-0.6958229541778564,
-0.6600444316864014,
0.1107192188501358,
-0.7101947665214539,
0.07440288364887238,
-0.008907955139875412,
-0.11727698147296906,
-0.24949243664741516,
0.1846754401922226,
-0.6150756478309631,
-0.048941757529973984,
-0.01641056314110756,
1.0630208253860474,
-0.6820909380912781,
0.767613410949707,
0.6787724494934082,
-0.2151983082294464,
-0.8893550634384155,
0.46063563227653503,
0.19050820171833038,
-0.9212055206298828,
0.2827206552028656,
0.0958084836602211,
-0.31780076026916504,
-0.14016689360141754,
-0.14633391797542572,
-0.9534009695053101,
1.0068399906158447,
0.2897471487522125,
-0.34481918811798096,
0.09486712515354156,
0.15303854644298553,
0.3364866375923157,
-0.24090038239955902,
0.5115147233009338,
0.49440479278564453,
0.47710731625556946,
0.3842428922653198,
-0.7941628694534302,
-0.19433309137821198,
-0.27523913979530334,
-0.14314649999141693,
0.19473397731781006,
-0.8388955593109131,
0.8230574131011963,
-0.10846367478370667,
0.047520529478788376,
-0.15737035870552063,
0.21161317825317383,
0.789269745349884,
0.4681263566017151,
0.48530706763267517,
0.9229139089584351,
0.7703283429145813,
-0.11071468889713287,
1.1080552339553833,
-0.4347183406352997,
0.27510660886764526,
1.4688385725021362,
-0.3446592092514038,
0.8937318921089172,
0.3728068768978119,
-0.24094468355178833,
0.3292551636695862,
0.20526553690433502,
0.38386866450309753,
0.439358115196228,
0.013689038343727589,
-0.13805490732192993,
0.013733492232859135,
-0.03365321829915047,
-0.5142561197280884,
0.6394426822662354,
0.2527689039707184,
0.09487698972225189,
-0.444133460521698,
-0.11819769442081451,
-0.07544860243797302,
-0.11151771247386932,
-0.08156770467758179,
0.9235514402389526,
-0.11905157566070557,
-0.574317455291748,
0.44024547934532166,
-0.08913786709308624,
0.6172935962677002,
-0.6048816442489624,
-0.1794971376657486,
-0.5320136547088623,
0.07832127064466476,
-0.037289559841156006,
-0.6631597876548767,
0.3635704815387726,
0.09433530271053314,
-0.03722582757472992,
-0.046970952302217484,
0.8766648769378662,
-0.2391076236963272,
-0.6030620336532593,
0.40296563506126404,
1.1593858003616333,
0.13325048983097076,
-0.11584437638521194,
-0.6963164806365967,
0.31065288186073303,
-0.36317434906959534,
-0.5812568068504333,
0.39118310809135437,
0.834723711013794,
-0.04182273522019386,
0.5414619445800781,
0.6967431902885437,
0.28593361377716064,
0.2843075692653656,
0.34119927883148193,
0.9409701228141785,
-0.5811668038368225,
-0.2875424921512604,
-0.5073261857032776,
0.1934209167957306,
-0.15040932595729828,
0.07342837750911713,
0.9474543333053589,
0.7789831757545471,
0.7795308232307434,
0.25010964274406433,
0.7468750476837158,
-0.27678006887435913,
1.2027239799499512,
-0.30842673778533936,
0.5019413828849792,
-0.784710705280304,
0.22643877565860748,
-0.4922838807106018,
-0.9337722659111023,
-0.1716121882200241,
0.46896591782569885,
0.023867851123213768,
0.3881019949913025,
0.5682035088539124,
0.8275659084320068,
-0.15812049806118011,
-0.06783861666917801,
0.300488144159317,
0.09238927066326141,
0.37591102719306946,
0.25572288036346436,
0.8785127401351929,
-0.49130779504776,
0.7198469042778015,
-0.27305126190185547,
-0.40724629163742065,
0.014280962757766247,
-1.026012897491455,
-0.5067337155342102,
-0.4625485837459564,
0.2819196879863739,
-0.2889634966850281,
0.24794666469097137,
0.6687526702880859,
0.5628422498703003,
-0.6477717161178589,
-0.21575725078582764,
0.151223823428154,
0.11634919047355652,
-0.3246987760066986,
-0.19369761645793915,
0.4263951778411865,
-0.7504847645759583,
-0.5043894648551941,
0.5569290518760681,
0.10354655236005783,
-0.39689093828201294,
0.03356412798166275,
-0.07034994661808014,
-0.5506765842437744,
-0.18725216388702393,
0.6437680721282959,
0.17065240442752838,
-0.33080795407295227,
-0.04577192664146423,
0.15505589544773102,
0.1517910361289978,
0.1038607507944107,
1.0133687257766724,
-0.9944846630096436,
0.4062102138996124,
0.2865767478942871,
1.0285403728485107,
0.7780640125274658,
0.2079249918460846,
0.038552943617105484,
-1.0511888265609741,
0.016398800536990166,
0.2911736071109772,
0.35218504071235657,
0.1469307839870453,
-0.10957584530115128,
0.6463463306427002,
0.15212784707546234,
-0.8139720559120178,
-0.6732842922210693,
0.2608397305011749,
-0.6793952584266663,
-0.30002185702323914,
1.0607948303222656,
0.08272852003574371,
0.046924568712711334,
-0.1814804971218109,
-0.11520219594240189,
0.163749560713768,
-0.3159017264842987,
0.7240140438079834,
0.42146599292755127,
-0.32629796862602234,
-0.38571083545684814,
-0.7810379266738892,
0.45302942395210266,
0.14005480706691742,
-0.8620060682296753,
0.3763051927089691,
0.6847912073135376,
0.2570103406906128,
0.18630985915660858,
0.9426138401031494,
-0.2890504002571106,
0.21354728937149048,
0.19550877809524536,
-0.2298455536365509,
-0.2916988432407379,
-0.6519984006881714,
0.1304084211587906,
0.34167200326919556,
0.1931697279214859,
-0.07084693759679794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15385v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15385v1 | Towards Event Extraction from Speech with Contextual Clues | 2024-01-27T11:07:19 | 2024-01-27T11:07:19 | Jingqi Kang, Tongtong Wu, Jinming Zhao, Guitao Wang, Guilin Qi, Yuan-Fang Li, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MM | While text-based event extraction has been an active research area and has
seen successful application in many domains, extracting semantic events from
speech directly is an under-explored problem. In this paper, we introduce the
Speech Event Extraction (SpeechEE) task and construct three synthetic training
sets and one human-spoken test set. Compared to event extraction from text,
SpeechEE poses greater challenges mainly due to complex speech signals that are
continuous and have no word boundaries. Additionally, unlike perceptible sound
events, semantic events are more subtle and require a deeper understanding. To
tackle these challenges, we introduce a sequence-to-structure generation
paradigm that can produce events from speech signals in an end-to-end manner,
together with a conditioned generation method that utilizes speech recognition
transcripts as the contextual clue. We further propose to represent events with
a flat format to make outputs more natural language-like. Our experimental
results show that our method brings significant improvements on all datasets,
achieving a maximum F1 gain of 10.7%. The code and datasets are released on
https://github.com/jodie-kang/SpeechEE. | [
-0.11330793797969818,
-0.7245622873306274,
0.4685960114002228,
0.0004151473112870008,
-0.40778303146362305,
-0.20188015699386597,
-0.4926590323448181,
-0.5421971678733826,
0.3198559880256653,
0.1777147799730301,
-0.8295614123344421,
-0.47041261196136475,
-0.38822901248931885,
0.0071343788877129555,
-0.5259186625480652,
0.9020601511001587,
0.16545063257217407,
-0.309362530708313,
0.18950128555297852,
0.13057008385658264,
-0.6106037497520447,
-0.5686128735542297,
-0.7719151973724365,
-0.24681919813156128,
0.20008905231952667,
0.4746599495410919,
-0.1447148472070694,
0.682219922542572,
0.03745128959417343,
0.15287958085536957,
0.012950262054800987,
0.08007024228572845,
-0.3550450801849365,
0.36205366253852844,
-0.10275017470121384,
-0.17401300370693207,
-0.20502854883670807,
0.1609797477722168,
0.6121311187744141,
0.744701087474823,
-0.14902015030384064,
0.35157790780067444,
-0.17688912153244019,
0.3081459701061249,
-0.6803268790245056,
0.3740583062171936,
-0.9837953448295593,
0.1297694891691208,
-0.46244901418685913,
-0.3957040011882782,
-0.5211993455886841,
0.20246131718158722,
0.2560518980026245,
-0.4716736972332001,
0.38775259256362915,
-0.1484491527080536,
0.9003938436508179,
0.24836568534374237,
-0.2787584364414215,
-0.2696951627731323,
-0.5983006358146667,
0.6408553123474121,
-0.6675267815589905,
0.41274455189704895,
0.0560174398124218,
0.1820811778306961,
-0.43157562613487244,
-1.0390664339065552,
-0.6893618106842041,
0.014140309765934944,
0.2249452769756317,
0.15528182685375214,
-0.05508890002965927,
-0.20818893611431122,
0.34110012650489807,
-0.12373938411474228,
-0.45469456911087036,
-0.0005551177891902626,
-0.12551331520080566,
-0.09887441247701645,
0.8286596536636353,
-0.1480846256017685,
0.5905860066413879,
-0.5595687031745911,
-0.13077348470687866,
-0.2508305311203003,
-0.4673056900501251,
0.15284094214439392,
-0.02716067060828209,
0.5175225138664246,
-0.1906183511018753,
0.4964718520641327,
-0.37617796659469604,
0.37181392312049866,
0.07944241166114807,
-0.10880376398563385,
0.22948582470417023,
-0.41435807943344116,
-0.13121314346790314,
0.7280610203742981,
0.5436025261878967,
0.028950145468115807,
0.3871419131755829,
-0.5269518494606018,
0.01440267264842987,
0.1809103637933731,
-0.1400926262140274,
-0.896419882774353,
-0.09262586385011673,
0.387712299823761,
-0.17060667276382446,
-0.1984165906906128,
0.06025584414601326,
-0.7669681906700134,
-0.03559540584683418,
-0.4358384311199188,
0.2545923590660095,
-0.3632502257823944,
-0.10554856061935425,
0.05335312709212303,
-0.7209271192550659,
0.7626251578330994,
0.13570688664913177,
-0.7373170852661133,
-0.03397334739565849,
0.616936981678009,
0.4478268325328827,
-0.2972579002380371,
0.20041340589523315,
-1.182020902633667,
0.39158114790916443,
-0.1366432160139084,
0.7220039963722229,
-0.5467879772186279,
-0.39424604177474976,
-0.06398677825927734,
-0.12812691926956177,
-0.015150018967688084,
-0.3026840090751648,
0.6524049639701843,
-0.27745142579078674,
0.41594991087913513,
0.11198236793279648,
-0.6248226165771484,
0.14251211285591125,
-0.19743499159812927,
-0.3053000867366791,
0.7938283085823059,
-0.41719764471054077,
-0.47630295157432556,
0.46305039525032043,
-0.6466144919395447,
-0.7917172312736511,
0.24646839499473572,
-0.6514406204223633,
-0.18575988709926605,
0.17026111483573914,
0.49562469124794006,
0.26963961124420166,
-0.05864201858639717,
0.4728158116340637,
-0.016529319807887077,
-0.04128498584032059,
0.05694287270307541,
-0.43709638714790344,
0.5911790132522583,
-0.02285889908671379,
-0.8422188758850098,
-0.043205857276916504,
-1.3981834650039673,
0.14771422743797302,
0.18912039697170258,
-0.22707220911979675,
-0.1399439126253128,
0.49846088886260986,
0.1799161583185196,
0.2170017510652542,
-0.018010633066296577,
-0.7114993929862976,
-0.05844933167099953,
-0.8392547369003296,
0.4619669020175934,
0.42761561274528503,
0.4375699758529663,
0.5232279896736145,
0.20551413297653198,
0.33175796270370483,
-0.07156846672296524,
-0.35457274317741394,
-0.3809347152709961,
-0.607860803604126,
-0.42793092131614685,
-0.36592182517051697,
0.21799999475479126,
0.7244021892547607,
-0.6527585983276367,
0.6172311305999756,
-0.30520638823509216,
-0.0017672234680503607,
-0.09457186609506607,
-0.060248930007219315,
0.3008185029029846,
0.8237597346305847,
0.12325365841388702,
-0.10197433829307556,
-0.9186758995056152,
-0.5717571377754211,
-0.34113603830337524,
-0.06613531708717346,
-0.27764803171157837,
-0.043870944529771805,
0.2685209810733795,
0.11296304315328598,
1.419333815574646,
-0.5179976224899292,
-0.15345486998558044,
-0.28729474544525146,
0.30922576785087585,
0.09335453063249588,
0.40677565336227417,
0.19717289507389069,
-0.9475788474082947,
-0.004409444984048605,
0.1326453536748886,
-0.7405872344970703,
-0.21632952988147736,
-0.1495417058467865,
-0.020120302215218544,
0.17593780159950256,
0.739143431186676,
-0.3844611346721649,
0.6487088203430176,
0.10786916315555573,
-0.4231205880641937,
0.39445751905441284,
0.39933305978775024,
-0.3457350432872772,
-1.2116389274597168,
0.06342422217130661,
-0.15996797382831573,
-0.22836934030056,
-0.885172426700592,
-0.3482844829559326,
-0.2926115095615387,
-0.4085851311683655,
-0.4469575583934784,
0.7936797142028809,
-0.3507669270038605,
-0.06037195026874542,
-0.3281584680080414,
0.566392719745636,
0.062274862080812454,
0.5683493614196777,
0.41612014174461365,
0.4049563407897949,
0.4134848713874817,
-0.5659050345420837,
0.16556012630462646,
0.5814875364303589,
-0.377606064081192,
0.1431024819612503,
-0.5049784779548645,
0.3589708209037781,
-0.24926210939884186,
0.19566303491592407,
-0.6429764628410339,
-0.5727055072784424,
0.08879856020212173,
-0.7766162753105164,
0.320892333984375,
0.05171753093600273,
-0.17159418761730194,
0.12833522260189056,
-0.050071947276592255,
0.08513320237398148,
0.6480168104171753,
-0.5410714745521545,
0.6874047517776489,
0.5556936860084534,
-0.32431191205978394,
-0.3260776102542877,
-0.5791134834289551,
0.22541742026805878,
-0.31911036372184753,
-0.7109983563423157,
0.47388380765914917,
0.23744960129261017,
-0.19641484320163727,
-0.10192782431840897,
-0.48316237330436707,
-0.050502676516771317,
0.09786222875118256,
0.42232754826545715,
0.09575425833463669,
-0.2677781581878662,
0.1406477391719818,
0.058785196393728256,
-0.05993466079235077,
0.16178545355796814,
-0.4800965189933777,
0.18955767154693604,
0.07367083430290222,
-0.14671334624290466,
-0.8067376017570496,
0.7263725996017456,
0.05601750686764717,
-0.32834962010383606,
0.31602242588996887,
0.8763526082038879,
-0.7437757849693298,
-0.30141574144363403,
-0.40389570593833923,
-0.4544861912727356,
-0.40141138434410095,
0.545074999332428,
-0.5732450485229492,
-0.7183225750923157,
0.4725530445575714,
-0.27579760551452637,
0.13392755389213562,
0.3808118402957916,
0.40852802991867065,
-0.052289560437202454,
1.1193478107452393,
0.36241966485977173,
0.20384259521961212,
0.710003137588501,
0.010748888365924358,
0.1275380253791809,
-0.72805255651474,
-0.4020957946777344,
-0.5885071158409119,
-0.056393787264823914,
-0.34552526473999023,
-0.16312849521636963,
0.34034258127212524,
0.2746543288230896,
0.19367162883281708,
0.19749461114406586,
-0.22611649334430695,
0.2220325767993927,
0.5604755878448486,
-0.03254510462284088,
0.04429607093334198,
0.06644311547279358,
0.2568811774253845,
0.04706163331866264,
-0.7887810468673706,
-0.45721864700317383,
0.6065027117729187,
-0.05520167574286461,
0.022554593160748482,
0.05834578350186348,
0.8897127509117126,
0.023487916216254234,
-0.022488314658403397,
-0.6125669479370117,
0.4166492819786072,
0.038368288427591324,
-0.4505312442779541,
-0.5785399079322815,
-0.3578338325023651,
-0.9178140163421631,
0.04083505645394325,
-0.19601434469223022,
-1.0665282011032104,
0.5482437610626221,
-0.04884187504649162,
-0.17832109332084656,
-0.18096934258937836,
-0.7653349041938782,
0.8292158246040344,
0.2613232433795929,
-0.05415612831711769,
0.137231707572937,
-0.8495762348175049,
0.19790981709957123,
-0.08387404680252075,
0.4825928509235382,
-0.3891732692718506,
0.24520441889762878,
0.9004095196723938,
-0.22653716802597046,
0.9375205039978027,
-0.1593729555606842,
0.0008406091365031898,
0.43723002076148987,
-0.1803840696811676,
0.751756489276886,
0.2828935980796814,
-0.05912498012185097,
-0.25081250071525574,
-0.051615212112665176,
-0.3456280529499054,
-0.5510483384132385,
0.3298449218273163,
-0.3365284204483032,
-0.48184067010879517,
0.06496825069189072,
-0.27082371711730957,
-0.41371265053749084,
-0.054497700184583664,
0.3950624465942383,
1.166633129119873,
-0.2773154675960541,
0.06751185655593872,
0.5364789962768555,
-0.07846684753894806,
0.8992584347724915,
0.2554970681667328,
0.2111600637435913,
-0.3057633638381958,
0.8603230714797974,
-0.32575783133506775,
0.04255882650613785,
0.4641566276550293,
0.13525088131427765,
-0.30699384212493896,
-0.38255369663238525,
-0.5814490914344788,
-0.12495357543230057,
-0.6962804198265076,
-0.01257218699902296,
-0.5203958749771118,
-0.1668078452348709,
-0.6449014544487,
-0.17457689344882965,
-0.2445192039012909,
-0.7675562500953674,
-0.5369374752044678,
-0.18541891872882843,
0.0230584517121315,
0.13763770461082458,
-0.16587799787521362,
0.21862880885601044,
-0.8637878894805908,
0.4589289128780365,
0.30038487911224365,
-0.27643728256225586,
-0.26813843846321106,
-0.42273175716400146,
0.1124502569437027,
-0.2356637567281723,
-0.006286030635237694,
-1.0506188869476318,
0.4735569953918457,
0.8361953496932983,
0.6022249460220337,
0.45439255237579346,
0.14490720629692078,
0.7072354555130005,
-0.7655178308486938,
0.8450198173522949,
0.2395419478416443,
-1.0294537544250488,
1.2451928853988647,
-0.13447977602481842,
0.254545658826828,
0.3591722548007965,
-0.03171195462346077,
-0.49792006611824036,
-0.40036740899086,
-0.8685372471809387,
-0.9756537079811096,
0.7477966547012329,
0.5399299263954163,
0.027413778007030487,
-0.30790719389915466,
0.7430886030197144,
-0.1101032942533493,
0.13537900149822235,
-0.5439820289611816,
-0.1949394792318344,
-0.10903612524271011,
-0.31732428073883057,
-0.03609469160437584,
-0.14377941191196442,
-0.024068711325526237,
-0.0011621054727584124,
0.6042824387550354,
-0.1419009119272232,
0.03727496415376663,
0.600925862789154,
-0.2455311417579651,
0.12359881401062012,
0.4899052381515503,
0.5409924387931824,
0.5827648639678955,
-0.3472270667552948,
0.061542343348264694,
0.14958356320858002,
-0.36438098549842834,
-0.1296059787273407,
0.2972720265388489,
-0.16850383579730988,
0.23106302320957184,
0.7800347208976746,
0.9684933423995972,
0.2975344657897949,
-0.9065873026847839,
0.40190672874450684,
-0.08392993360757828,
-0.1714918613433838,
-0.3947542905807495,
0.10399100929498672,
-0.2728569507598877,
0.18474642932415009,
0.5182672739028931,
-0.4300510585308075,
0.36457884311676025,
-0.7340850234031677,
0.6786381602287292,
0.36313483119010925,
-0.560150682926178,
-0.5054669380187988,
0.7825097441673279,
0.42383483052253723,
-0.41685572266578674,
0.4449312388896942,
-0.49584078788757324,
-0.4381686747074127,
0.6306616067886353,
0.6988042593002319,
0.9386837482452393,
0.05984634906053543,
0.027416745200753212,
0.38464272022247314,
-0.022017596289515495,
0.44590145349502563,
0.32968902587890625,
-0.3474659323692322,
-0.6631860733032227,
-0.8407489061355591,
-0.9849575757980347,
-0.19999679923057556,
0.20026060938835144,
-0.7725064158439636,
0.29882872104644775,
0.09739388525485992,
-0.008687821216881275,
0.33175456523895264,
-0.10090946406126022,
-0.29482224583625793,
0.043653491884469986,
0.5682531595230103,
0.8645246624946594,
-0.6302180886268616,
0.8091480731964111,
0.4545885920524597,
-0.18033914268016815,
-0.8087036609649658,
-0.08743684738874435,
0.0185160581022501,
-0.46185392141342163,
0.7779340744018555,
0.27347531914711,
0.018135307356715202,
0.26201626658439636,
-0.34571269154548645,
-0.6709505915641785,
0.731612503528595,
0.25681671500205994,
-0.5361356139183044,
-0.36130425333976746,
0.11356820166110992,
0.1911470592021942,
-0.5032912492752075,
-0.2708054780960083,
0.8088418245315552,
0.38815799355506897,
0.4169853925704956,
-0.6130959391593933,
-0.01179332472383976,
-0.08735424280166626,
-0.011082133278250694,
0.14504387974739075,
0.14389733970165253,
0.12844964861869812,
-0.05649327486753464,
-0.6913312077522278,
-0.009844804182648659,
0.9715790748596191,
0.26752781867980957,
0.6016665697097778,
0.4498298764228821,
0.21762560307979584,
0.7822567820549011,
-0.1359473615884781,
1.0097324848175049,
-0.053481392562389374,
-0.07110387086868286,
1.4745211601257324,
-0.33232998847961426,
0.8451348543167114,
0.5031675100326538,
0.3736306130886078,
0.3730071485042572,
0.43888676166534424,
0.44150710105895996,
0.6668642163276672,
0.15356969833374023,
-0.3913707435131073,
-0.41930848360061646,
-0.14265991747379303,
-0.1354880928993225,
0.8072312474250793,
0.5375729203224182,
0.12312227487564087,
-0.3740684390068054,
0.3143850862979889,
-0.12751375138759613,
-0.015164954587817192,
-0.22145622968673706,
0.9741562008857727,
0.22323980927467346,
-0.4578476846218109,
0.13739682734012604,
-0.14902566373348236,
0.23889552056789398,
-0.5309807658195496,
-0.2241949588060379,
0.03640668839216232,
-0.06072981283068657,
0.07433520257472992,
-0.18007969856262207,
0.40824416279792786,
0.05150311440229416,
-0.28372281789779663,
-0.11719334125518799,
0.8283645510673523,
-0.5103838443756104,
-0.22198626399040222,
-0.07878758013248444,
0.4276151955127716,
0.18699489533901215,
-0.329549640417099,
-0.18187279999256134,
0.09612561762332916,
0.10883919894695282,
-0.3702133297920227,
0.1973091959953308,
0.5281886458396912,
-0.15048706531524658,
0.09495868533849716,
0.7563055157661438,
0.14143317937850952,
0.3502432405948639,
0.3046334683895111,
0.3727720379829407,
-0.7456213235855103,
-0.513809323310852,
-0.7865477204322815,
0.5510560274124146,
-0.3884751796722412,
-0.420893132686615,
0.3288866877555847,
0.45168375968933105,
0.5258740186691284,
0.1070149689912796,
0.6158089637756348,
-0.12835568189620972,
0.3617599904537201,
-0.6190133690834045,
0.24150343239307404,
-0.25008246302604675,
-0.035500142723321915,
0.1035514697432518,
-0.4427773952484131,
-0.1697869598865509,
0.23072300851345062,
0.12610191106796265,
-0.48202624917030334,
0.5259381532669067,
0.33285844326019287,
0.2713190019130707,
0.4048755466938019,
0.2173374444246292,
-0.019466247409582138,
0.583640456199646,
0.4127448499202728,
0.6849344372749329,
-0.42711225152015686,
0.4700106084346771,
0.05867137387394905,
-0.31177499890327454,
-0.06401598453521729,
-0.9648207426071167,
-0.6790753602981567,
-0.9216071367263794,
-0.6330710649490356,
0.02292189933359623,
0.2055465579032898,
0.8346309065818787,
0.9286743998527527,
-0.8807196617126465,
0.07810404896736145,
-0.26443296670913696,
-0.02420702762901783,
-0.10980845987796783,
-0.2794385254383087,
0.5370765328407288,
-0.766006350517273,
-0.8478503227233887,
1.0419785976409912,
0.1539844274520874,
0.06317532807588577,
0.5692217946052551,
0.37303128838539124,
-0.21053463220596313,
0.15887273848056793,
0.7500569224357605,
0.5615648627281189,
-0.5677752494812012,
-0.7046796083450317,
-0.3069605529308319,
0.2575804591178894,
-0.1893768310546875,
0.5296958088874817,
-0.8914312124252319,
0.09751608222723007,
0.30474478006362915,
0.6716639995574951,
0.8502330780029297,
-0.11890784651041031,
0.785000205039978,
-1.3920539617538452,
0.4693954586982727,
0.12259306013584137,
0.3337419033050537,
0.0011091454653069377,
-0.3198526203632355,
0.5170642733573914,
0.2829941511154175,
-0.13398636877536774,
-0.9455386400222778,
0.3904601037502289,
-1.3742811679840088,
-0.15896448493003845,
1.1075708866119385,
0.20981228351593018,
-0.45548078417778015,
-0.03649250045418739,
0.007293446455150843,
0.7145261168479919,
-0.130617156624794,
0.5240001678466797,
0.4290426969528198,
-0.4558137357234955,
0.1675983965396881,
-0.4671272933483124,
0.7873303890228271,
0.2814423739910126,
-0.9341318011283875,
-0.054532457143068314,
0.43055468797683716,
0.05104421079158783,
0.3272540867328644,
0.35885530710220337,
-0.04498821869492531,
0.32175955176353455,
-0.09815457463264465,
0.29978713393211365,
0.09130657464265823,
-0.34964436292648315,
-0.33184006810188293,
0.44604283571243286,
-0.5242214798927307,
-0.4354077875614166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15378v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15378v4 | A RAG-based Question Answering System Proposal for Understanding Islam: MufassirQAS LLM | 2024-01-27T10:50:11 | 2024-02-01T20:28:11 | Ahmet Yusuf Alan, Enis Karaarslan, Ömer Aydin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Challenges exist in learning and understanding religions, such as the
complexity and depth of religious doctrines and teachings. Chatbots as
question-answering systems can help in solving these challenges. LLM chatbots
use NLP techniques to establish connections between topics and accurately
respond to complex questions. These capabilities make it perfect for
enlightenment on religion as a question-answering chatbot. However, LLMs also
tend to generate false information, known as hallucination. Also, the chatbots'
responses can include content that insults personal religious beliefs,
interfaith conflicts, and controversial or sensitive topics. It must avoid such
cases without promoting hate speech or offending certain groups of people or
their beliefs. This study uses a vector database-based Retrieval Augmented
Generation (RAG) approach to enhance the accuracy and transparency of LLMs. Our
question-answering system is called "MufassirQAS". We created a database
consisting of several open-access books that include Turkish context. These
books contain Turkish translations and interpretations of Islam. This database
is utilized to answer religion-related questions and ensure our answers are
trustworthy. The relevant part of the dataset, which LLM also uses, is
presented along with the answer. We have put careful effort into creating
system prompts that give instructions to prevent harmful, offensive, or
disrespectful responses to respect people's values and provide reliable
results. The system answers and shares additional information, such as the page
number from the respective book and the articles referenced for obtaining the
information. MufassirQAS and ChatGPT are also tested with sensitive questions.
We got better performance with our system. Study and enhancements are still in
progress. Results and future works are given. | [
-0.5953291654586792,
-0.8571045398712158,
0.1943260133266449,
0.08471779525279999,
-0.29035481810569763,
0.3445856273174286,
0.11544650793075562,
-0.4721059501171112,
0.05566626042127609,
0.7011545896530151,
-0.5894091725349426,
-0.16468335688114166,
-0.629716694355011,
0.1655372679233551,
-0.26315605640411377,
1.0631499290466309,
0.012736089527606964,
0.10614021122455597,
-0.03851231932640076,
-0.3468785583972931,
-0.20392854511737823,
-0.32298099994659424,
-0.8324267268180847,
-0.08171148598194122,
0.6412016153335571,
0.3316282033920288,
0.8402244448661804,
0.5273746252059937,
0.7396320700645447,
0.4274711012840271,
-0.36617302894592285,
0.48625096678733826,
-0.5363937616348267,
0.43738067150115967,
-0.13868804275989532,
-0.2836599349975586,
-0.3411880433559418,
-0.393030047416687,
0.4629553258419037,
0.4225500226020813,
-0.15128758549690247,
0.5360636115074158,
0.27178919315338135,
0.7649497985839844,
-0.46495315432548523,
-0.22406652569770813,
-0.5559484958648682,
0.15697702765464783,
-0.13681600987911224,
-0.6476436257362366,
-0.13261309266090393,
-0.5801149010658264,
-0.06428243964910507,
-0.3020971715450287,
0.2640959918498993,
0.15500174462795258,
0.6072962284088135,
0.3616054356098175,
-0.5290999412536621,
-0.763958752155304,
-0.8148285746574402,
0.7852298021316528,
-0.46940678358078003,
0.428126722574234,
0.33703720569610596,
0.4502626657485962,
-0.6070651412010193,
-0.13559038937091827,
-0.6357330679893494,
0.18355165421962738,
-0.05998770147562027,
0.2793157398700714,
0.24556584656238556,
-0.042019013315439224,
0.36764228343963623,
0.6358909606933594,
-0.6550750136375427,
-0.4973352551460266,
-0.28283870220184326,
-0.07080262154340744,
0.5157427191734314,
0.23524464666843414,
0.21611183881759644,
-0.3787388503551483,
-0.5614137053489685,
-0.1926872581243515,
-0.593382716178894,
0.24733301997184753,
0.39021602272987366,
-0.22798387706279755,
0.06485854834318161,
0.7471017241477966,
-0.0747334435582161,
0.646909236907959,
-0.1153734028339386,
-0.7591277956962585,
-0.10489224642515182,
-0.0816388726234436,
-0.4522107243537903,
-0.33249562978744507,
0.3698239326477051,
0.20673124492168427,
-0.03791090473532677,
0.08213130384683609,
0.02941390499472618,
-0.07266980409622192,
0.21544091403484344,
-0.8315290212631226,
0.2222745269536972,
0.34262362122535706,
-0.6906546354293823,
-0.2609477639198303,
0.0005477666854858398,
-0.8207418918609619,
-0.6040552854537964,
-0.0012204705271869898,
0.3290329873561859,
-0.4362255334854126,
-0.30091583728790283,
-0.054987143725156784,
-0.23670372366905212,
0.5204222202301025,
0.6194894313812256,
-0.6494330167770386,
0.31132352352142334,
0.5646916627883911,
0.5359571576118469,
-0.16980129480361938,
0.30195149779319763,
-0.21256203949451447,
0.40423038601875305,
-0.1529373675584793,
0.6430578231811523,
-0.45249515771865845,
-0.5915611982345581,
-0.049342650920152664,
-0.2113444060087204,
0.2524288296699524,
-0.535555362701416,
0.8507099747657776,
-0.841128408908844,
0.2850576639175415,
-0.10932864248752594,
-0.6732801198959351,
-0.4995324909687042,
0.2361704260110855,
-0.5767630934715271,
0.8229990601539612,
-0.06979626417160034,
-0.9023616909980774,
-0.14873258769512177,
-0.7412934899330139,
-0.09795896708965302,
0.3642597496509552,
-0.4564085006713867,
-0.40389853715896606,
0.09812567383050919,
0.1377253383398056,
0.32991766929626465,
-0.21616601943969727,
0.1273084580898285,
-0.04248480498790741,
-0.5307315587997437,
0.6141257286071777,
-0.7216280698776245,
0.8475852608680725,
0.7195421457290649,
-0.12268281728029251,
-0.2985548675060272,
-0.47047606110572815,
0.23242932558059692,
0.08072013407945633,
-0.4152739346027374,
-0.1816716194152832,
0.023565011098980904,
-0.15407384932041168,
0.006689063739031553,
0.1776629239320755,
-0.5946426391601562,
0.13478393852710724,
-0.5631861090660095,
-0.39070889353752136,
0.7932072877883911,
0.18712270259857178,
0.10358589142560959,
-0.8132699728012085,
0.681477427482605,
-0.09698734432458878,
0.3105662167072296,
-0.21062585711479187,
-0.6972135305404663,
-0.7770833373069763,
-0.11433909088373184,
-0.07948930561542511,
0.7398179769515991,
-0.8812234401702881,
-0.019495898857712746,
0.1674613207578659,
-0.4758216440677643,
-0.22935055196285248,
0.26127520203590393,
0.582377552986145,
0.4800493121147156,
0.21604754030704498,
-0.17724625766277313,
-0.44767725467681885,
-0.7759533524513245,
-0.49274927377700806,
-0.3774917721748352,
-0.21112805604934692,
0.5717737078666687,
0.39790603518486023,
0.00033323292154818773,
0.5210006237030029,
-0.41327014565467834,
-0.047286733984947205,
0.07118166983127594,
0.12463866919279099,
0.4366563558578491,
0.30744993686676025,
0.17625944316387177,
-1.3789916038513184,
-0.481227308511734,
0.1548178791999817,
-0.548140287399292,
0.06526577472686768,
0.0799286812543869,
-0.2881796956062317,
0.3165890872478485,
-0.003284601727500558,
-0.13838668167591095,
0.8911373615264893,
0.6377686262130737,
-0.45820844173431396,
0.44568467140197754,
0.05323692411184311,
0.526976466178894,
-1.2346025705337524,
-0.08343308418989182,
-0.36668047308921814,
-0.24364712834358215,
-0.5273576378822327,
-0.03410183638334274,
-0.1498989760875702,
0.08537217229604721,
-0.5823558568954468,
0.596433162689209,
-0.10424575954675674,
0.05084572732448578,
-0.5102739334106445,
-0.3005102872848511,
0.06204267963767052,
0.574790894985199,
-0.14527001976966858,
1.0739611387252808,
-0.0005389087018556893,
-0.8009418845176697,
0.3777523636817932,
0.5526429414749146,
-0.323936402797699,
0.5456954836845398,
-0.3257409930229187,
0.17007826268672943,
-0.2707480490207672,
0.05441261827945709,
-0.9421048164367676,
-0.38438650965690613,
0.832747220993042,
-0.7437929511070251,
0.22530195116996765,
-0.10523714125156403,
-0.14945776760578156,
-0.2246493250131607,
-0.10182162374258041,
0.5167153477668762,
0.3974977731704712,
-0.40057942271232605,
0.8438467383384705,
0.5070342421531677,
-0.3555525839328766,
-1.1619020700454712,
-0.17534653842449188,
-0.12182110548019409,
-0.3058907687664032,
-0.5621763467788696,
0.19052325189113617,
-0.26634421944618225,
-0.32922959327697754,
-0.050609290599823,
-0.46037015318870544,
-0.2673136293888092,
0.2131873220205307,
0.5342040061950684,
0.36449888348579407,
-0.122406005859375,
0.36179572343826294,
0.2386578768491745,
0.20735925436019897,
0.14933638274669647,
0.09661062806844711,
0.46087002754211426,
-0.31432750821113586,
-0.4567147493362427,
-0.35642674565315247,
0.734340250492096,
0.12365495413541794,
-0.16670885682106018,
0.7847812175750732,
0.5513443946838379,
-0.24189609289169312,
0.07882794737815857,
-0.7480829358100891,
-0.08228719979524612,
-0.5726675987243652,
0.059776000678539276,
-0.4538198709487915,
-1.0633864402770996,
0.42246532440185547,
-0.3478700518608093,
0.3150590658187866,
0.4373960793018341,
0.8647753596305847,
-0.6846884489059448,
0.7796941995620728,
0.725817084312439,
0.6449241638183594,
0.21757999062538147,
-0.012398098595440388,
-0.1984269917011261,
-0.6939186453819275,
-0.41451364755630493,
-0.7924919724464417,
-0.19664901494979858,
-0.8532798290252686,
-0.5893336534500122,
0.5307331681251526,
0.15337175130844116,
-0.24340024590492249,
-0.11932910978794098,
-0.6091006994247437,
0.4794856011867523,
0.32440459728240967,
0.02734813094139099,
0.48836883902549744,
0.2705746293067932,
-0.04133564978837967,
0.028904110193252563,
-0.49351105093955994,
-0.8369373083114624,
0.9048801064491272,
0.28605350852012634,
0.9993923902511597,
0.6032341718673706,
0.6665764451026917,
0.5863072872161865,
0.6809014678001404,
-0.462763249874115,
0.35825493931770325,
0.09306277334690094,
-0.9263832569122314,
-0.43199869990348816,
-0.5949445962905884,
-0.7874204516410828,
0.3582977056503296,
-0.24020184576511383,
-0.4563402533531189,
-0.018911190330982208,
-0.16624955832958221,
-0.2597983777523041,
0.39346951246261597,
-0.19410888850688934,
0.3314685821533203,
-0.37007641792297363,
-0.2983538508415222,
0.04852782189846039,
-0.5996481776237488,
0.45744216442108154,
-0.16420696675777435,
0.4380357265472412,
-0.20105402171611786,
-0.15891197323799133,
0.9513310790061951,
-0.15966595709323883,
0.5676398277282715,
-0.04605313017964363,
-0.332074910402298,
0.286618709564209,
0.18805865943431854,
0.12057679146528244,
0.15805841982364655,
-0.16326911747455597,
0.04210837557911873,
0.4753698706626892,
-0.3183440864086151,
-0.8382489085197449,
0.44311195611953735,
-0.8446973562240601,
-0.9136600494384766,
-0.6835094094276428,
-0.7678053975105286,
-0.20291206240653992,
-0.018374621868133545,
-0.12310498207807541,
0.24019943177700043,
-0.162505641579628,
0.20696339011192322,
1.026326060295105,
-0.6035034656524658,
-0.08879940956830978,
0.5305197238922119,
-0.7457905411720276,
-0.4606429934501648,
0.7141808867454529,
-0.1602342426776886,
0.09117700904607773,
0.30067282915115356,
0.2392524629831314,
-0.5523732304573059,
-0.33939528465270996,
-0.6355335712432861,
0.29195094108581543,
-0.6856482625007629,
-0.4246921241283417,
-0.6642906069755554,
-0.32231420278549194,
-0.28941401839256287,
0.12088727205991745,
0.17341652512550354,
-0.3095816969871521,
0.028094736859202385,
0.4240349531173706,
0.6716054677963257,
0.9044591188430786,
0.052859075367450714,
0.34821945428848267,
-0.9972319006919861,
0.709073007106781,
0.2777472734451294,
0.3456566035747528,
-0.2779729664325714,
-0.8227511048316956,
-0.04960460588335991,
0.3461608588695526,
-0.6027150750160217,
-1.0905452966690063,
0.10544893890619278,
0.18019406497478485,
0.24445359408855438,
0.5812235474586487,
0.25398483872413635,
0.8125982284545898,
-0.44352543354034424,
0.18648119270801544,
-0.021405166015028954,
-0.7091655135154724,
0.44872450828552246,
-0.21519391238689423,
0.026673370972275734,
0.4054701030254364,
0.6131587028503418,
-0.8539642095565796,
-0.8551707863807678,
-0.5544886589050293,
-0.24505272507667542,
0.5343149900436401,
0.42464879155158997,
0.275510311126709,
0.11733195930719376,
0.730160117149353,
0.3642537593841553,
0.24102628231048584,
-0.4219909906387329,
-0.5667814612388611,
0.01949099637567997,
-0.22866833209991455,
0.3882814645767212,
-0.38929325342178345,
-0.24186772108078003,
-0.10655919462442398,
0.7808231115341187,
0.10858284682035446,
0.19530019164085388,
0.2692274749279022,
0.15375837683677673,
-0.28161320090293884,
0.40664246678352356,
0.585235595703125,
0.7557005882263184,
-0.3446720838546753,
-0.07279623299837112,
0.2673196792602539,
-0.7016543745994568,
0.4880821406841278,
-0.31456631422042847,
-0.24187764525413513,
0.06476136296987534,
-0.1630721539258957,
0.27031853795051575,
-0.3878934383392334,
-0.5221289396286011,
0.4213322103023529,
-0.3695852756500244,
-0.08461673557758331,
-0.7129751443862915,
0.2610623836517334,
0.1288633942604065,
0.45583730936050415,
0.6232573986053467,
0.11046543717384338,
0.23081883788108826,
-0.3096497356891632,
0.30594298243522644,
0.7182701826095581,
-0.0705767348408699,
0.38229644298553467,
0.5138807892799377,
0.0665399432182312,
-0.6727650165557861,
0.10348111391067505,
0.019455183297395706,
-0.5929840207099915,
0.5995919108390808,
0.5732679963111877,
0.3047318160533905,
-0.5721606612205505,
0.4864080846309662,
0.26506686210632324,
0.22041399776935577,
0.3709329664707184,
0.752987265586853,
-0.3763895332813263,
-0.5988115072250366,
-0.6669133901596069,
-1.1201648712158203,
-1.0245120525360107,
0.14254452288150787,
-0.6449997425079346,
-0.012676078826189041,
-0.3580443561077118,
-0.16801303625106812,
-0.22831964492797852,
0.3126716911792755,
-0.669651448726654,
0.2533431649208069,
0.1239624097943306,
0.7615144848823547,
-0.3330763280391693,
0.6559239625930786,
0.4935095012187958,
-0.06792737543582916,
-0.6823697090148926,
-0.16440951824188232,
-0.125106543302536,
-0.8024558424949646,
0.5597518682479858,
0.16171813011169434,
-0.7043623924255371,
-0.11370720714330673,
-0.570237398147583,
-0.8691370487213135,
0.7621186375617981,
-0.02752879448235035,
-0.31151679158210754,
0.05920060724020004,
0.3649601340293884,
0.3557310998439789,
-0.12168287485837936,
0.2846752405166626,
0.07975786924362183,
0.40675845742225647,
0.3558123707771301,
-0.40075719356536865,
-0.050189971923828125,
-0.2419191300868988,
-0.011820323765277863,
0.2760588824748993,
-0.30677905678749084,
0.7059085369110107,
0.04454910010099411,
-0.5748031139373779,
0.42493337392807007,
0.8037760257720947,
0.3033592104911804,
0.4433959722518921,
0.39832180738449097,
0.323142945766449,
0.790776252746582,
0.16096900403499603,
0.8545063138008118,
-0.12857604026794434,
0.1421998143196106,
0.9978782534599304,
0.042183343321084976,
0.7386760115623474,
0.6676443219184875,
-0.27288880944252014,
0.40413808822631836,
0.4172130823135376,
0.1564822942018509,
0.008569424971938133,
0.38912689685821533,
-0.6497969627380371,
-0.039581507444381714,
-0.34807664155960083,
-0.553238570690155,
0.5078689455986023,
0.6439571976661682,
-0.26478779315948486,
-0.21532607078552246,
0.19185896217823029,
-0.08112071454524994,
0.16746164858341217,
-0.1379985511302948,
0.9506808519363403,
-0.049661051481962204,
-0.471171110868454,
0.6848329901695251,
0.1948215663433075,
0.5346082448959351,
-0.5021522045135498,
-0.30425214767456055,
-0.24841395020484924,
-0.07394333928823471,
-0.19584444165229797,
-0.8556069731712341,
0.5426076054573059,
0.28775423765182495,
0.08443260937929153,
-0.19109836220741272,
0.8374685645103455,
-0.2993655502796173,
-0.7139095067977905,
-0.09879220277070999,
0.9730702042579651,
0.6133177876472473,
0.11600424349308014,
-0.7588045001029968,
0.2779007852077484,
0.1455344557762146,
-0.043282605707645416,
0.06032104417681694,
0.44204816222190857,
0.09456285089254379,
0.7283656001091003,
0.8606016635894775,
0.02559208869934082,
-0.12680727243423462,
-0.4244764745235443,
0.8146145343780518,
-0.799406886100769,
-0.011865068227052689,
-0.8140331506729126,
-0.023319117724895477,
0.005217839032411575,
-0.09409919381141663,
0.8603835105895996,
0.572068452835083,
0.7349428534507751,
0.19524171948432922,
0.45544177293777466,
0.04135339707136154,
1.1138887405395508,
-0.32073256373405457,
1.0026296377182007,
-0.8164474368095398,
0.14445136487483978,
-0.20730051398277283,
-1.0785633325576782,
-0.267728716135025,
0.5609617829322815,
0.16442567110061646,
-0.23663891851902008,
0.21107201278209686,
0.9939033389091492,
0.1440049409866333,
0.3534146845340729,
0.4449421465396881,
0.08858972787857056,
0.21073715388774872,
0.33724892139434814,
1.2751456499099731,
-0.5110794305801392,
0.839130699634552,
-0.21168972551822662,
-0.38430914282798767,
-0.10921472311019897,
-0.4694646894931793,
-0.809623658657074,
-0.49753233790397644,
0.08815949410200119,
-0.4730621576309204,
0.10747087746858597,
0.8100792765617371,
-0.009781173430383205,
-0.6513183116912842,
-0.5390039086341858,
0.4984220266342163,
0.43651172518730164,
-0.042049214243888855,
-0.16040253639221191,
0.4359966218471527,
-0.08220107853412628,
-0.6805385947227478,
0.13741637766361237,
0.4278572201728821,
0.09050636738538742,
-0.29087668657302856,
-0.1656951755285263,
-0.19797740876674652,
0.28262025117874146,
0.5001366138458252,
0.36231812834739685,
-0.8288695216178894,
-0.21740329265594482,
0.21009576320648193,
-0.24658261239528656,
0.1725570261478424,
0.5447508692741394,
-0.5783320665359497,
0.34296998381614685,
0.19765424728393555,
1.0141984224319458,
0.3252556324005127,
0.13531796634197235,
0.13886438310146332,
-0.23807068169116974,
0.043506115674972534,
0.4647260308265686,
-0.03618980944156647,
0.05451326072216034,
-0.3344447910785675,
0.40676531195640564,
-0.1411040872335434,
-0.7310178875923157,
-0.7312169075012207,
0.6893317699432373,
-0.7977472543716431,
-0.21116755902767181,
0.7256561517715454,
0.043144628405570984,
-0.49792829155921936,
-0.6672487258911133,
-0.6366812586784363,
0.4471707344055176,
-0.18972720205783844,
0.7995322346687317,
0.7376657724380493,
-0.27695682644844055,
-0.06825950741767883,
-0.5842042565345764,
0.6706249117851257,
0.6108248233795166,
-0.651130199432373,
-0.241733580827713,
0.33295950293540955,
0.12327052652835846,
0.05350073054432869,
0.6386118531227112,
-0.24165305495262146,
0.40614673495292664,
-0.3470631539821625,
-0.026904460042715073,
0.02191302739083767,
-0.2299877256155014,
-0.13921548426151276,
0.1747184842824936,
-0.1055816188454628,
-0.051547855138778687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15371v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15371v2 | LegalDuet: Learning Effective Representations for Legal Judgment Prediction through a Dual-View Legal Clue Reasoning | 2024-01-27T10:28:27 | 2024-02-28T04:38:25 | Pengjie Liu, Zhenghao Liu, Xiaoyuan Yi, Liner Yang, Shuo Wang, Yu Gu, Ge Yu, Xing Xie, Shuang-hua Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most existing Legal Judgment Prediction (LJP) models focus on discovering the
legal triggers in the criminal fact description. However, in real-world
scenarios, a professional judge not only needs to assimilate the law case
experience that thrives on past sentenced legal judgments but also depends on
the professional legal grounded reasoning that learned from professional legal
knowledge. In this paper, we propose a LegalDuet model, which pretrains
language models to learn a tailored embedding space for making legal judgments.
It proposes a dual-view legal clue reasoning mechanism, which derives from two
reasoning chains of judges: 1) Law Case Reasoning, which makes legal judgments
according to the judgment experiences learned from analogy/confusing legal
cases; 2) Legal Ground Reasoning, which lies in matching the legal clues
between criminal cases and legal decisions. Our experiments show that LegalDuet
achieves state-of-the-art performance on the CAIL2018 dataset and outperforms
baselines with about 4% improvements on average. Our dual-view reasoning based
pretraining can capture critical legal clues to learn a tailored embedding
space to distinguish criminal cases. It reduces LegalDuet's uncertainty during
prediction and brings pretraining advances to the confusing/low frequent
charges. All codes are available at https://github.com/NEUIR/LegalDuet. | [
0.0014595137909054756,
-0.42796382308006287,
0.9422739744186401,
-0.000647468026727438,
-0.6052800416946411,
-0.055292628705501556,
0.04116153344511986,
-0.2571904957294464,
0.2539507746696472,
0.6537879109382629,
-0.36349958181381226,
-0.5486761331558228,
-0.3655022382736206,
-0.6506407856941223,
-0.03365103527903557,
0.8488290309906006,
0.08019603788852692,
0.43756547570228577,
-0.1673525869846344,
-0.10431437194347382,
-0.7926955819129944,
-0.5013507008552551,
-0.2557094395160675,
-0.33945807814598083,
0.31353190541267395,
0.2671423554420471,
0.3545839786529541,
0.529136598110199,
0.45712214708328247,
0.12855981290340424,
0.3233639895915985,
-0.24033568799495697,
-0.23534390330314636,
0.1999390870332718,
-0.2510327696800232,
-0.6387041807174683,
-0.3732506334781647,
0.11464425176382065,
0.17005452513694763,
0.27824440598487854,
-0.5739039182662964,
-0.09844467788934708,
-0.3707942068576813,
0.6404427886009216,
-0.7162299156188965,
0.2763950526714325,
-0.5562213063240051,
0.3645987808704376,
-0.3603758215904236,
-0.28322359919548035,
-0.4553988575935364,
-0.32892706990242004,
0.02092011272907257,
-0.7021731734275818,
0.1666945070028305,
0.07199639827013016,
0.5454075932502747,
0.6505000591278076,
-0.7275676727294922,
-0.01636810600757599,
-0.5120643973350525,
0.18429698050022125,
-0.7018609046936035,
0.5553857684135437,
0.259626567363739,
0.7674137949943542,
-0.045682601630687714,
-0.9740878939628601,
-0.3704448342323303,
-0.49691593647003174,
0.09243202209472656,
0.6762840151786804,
0.30286940932273865,
0.12714426219463348,
0.49100685119628906,
0.06013443320989609,
-0.6055898666381836,
-0.05688117444515228,
-0.030065786093473434,
-0.16386327147483826,
0.4331343472003937,
-0.07540067285299301,
-0.11138900369405746,
0.02213895507156849,
-0.2514127790927887,
-0.05113380029797554,
-0.7544516324996948,
0.42968273162841797,
0.46786561608314514,
0.23780697584152222,
-0.00407668249681592,
0.18264484405517578,
0.07184729725122452,
0.5994727611541748,
0.25134676694869995,
0.1412874162197113,
0.2899976372718811,
0.04751688614487648,
-0.16322694718837738,
0.17711816728115082,
0.6907253265380859,
0.5346966981887817,
0.1788497269153595,
-0.011175306513905525,
-0.25635793805122375,
-0.05873658508062363,
0.5658633708953857,
-0.5738585591316223,
-0.2270916998386383,
0.25188496708869934,
-0.27841928601264954,
-0.43056032061576843,
0.40703821182250977,
-0.6308625936508179,
-0.8834791779518127,
-0.3657830059528351,
0.2659543454647064,
-0.41811054944992065,
-0.3094945251941681,
0.34641751646995544,
-0.1427738219499588,
0.09220658987760544,
0.6713742017745972,
-0.415974497795105,
0.08423184603452682,
0.7096695899963379,
0.5219526886940002,
0.4070153534412384,
0.16099052131175995,
-0.9502034187316895,
-0.08875229954719543,
-0.19912198185920715,
0.7549205422401428,
-0.4414518177509308,
0.10108020901679993,
0.24825863540172577,
-0.1712685376405716,
0.008044847287237644,
-0.20874476432800293,
0.8517619967460632,
-0.798173725605011,
0.02736675925552845,
-0.23131871223449707,
-0.4788289964199066,
-0.18756434321403503,
0.46897608041763306,
-0.6159466505050659,
0.574914276599884,
-0.123550184071064,
-1.0216774940490723,
1.102885365486145,
-0.5453877449035645,
-0.49129223823547363,
0.4309200346469879,
-0.5122781991958618,
-0.45485052466392517,
0.043685682117938995,
0.18680043518543243,
0.22333765029907227,
0.10758539289236069,
0.7614349722862244,
-0.30726948380470276,
-0.25513893365859985,
-0.1956518590450287,
-0.11462020874023438,
0.7425848245620728,
0.15464407205581665,
-0.2778109908103943,
0.06697502732276917,
-0.7040393948554993,
-0.22299814224243164,
0.2767908573150635,
-0.24299921095371246,
-0.44323572516441345,
0.2059745341539383,
-0.2605617046356201,
0.3880806267261505,
0.07248056679964066,
-0.4754790663719177,
0.3445512354373932,
-0.529868483543396,
0.18754473328590393,
0.7771226763725281,
0.06394153088331223,
0.27738386392593384,
-0.15310750901699066,
0.7258679866790771,
0.15007883310317993,
-0.1439681202173233,
-0.18706996738910675,
-0.31543752551078796,
-0.5686057806015015,
0.13268950581550598,
0.4460657238960266,
0.9599064588546753,
-0.7474706172943115,
0.32064759731292725,
-0.2764653265476227,
-0.20027567446231842,
-0.293672114610672,
-0.22746248543262482,
0.30108827352523804,
0.40661782026290894,
0.3373546302318573,
-0.40360361337661743,
-0.6387309432029724,
-0.5670062303543091,
-0.8943101763725281,
-0.20572052896022797,
0.24596208333969116,
0.22103233635425568,
0.5611383318901062,
0.27994582056999207,
0.9511446356773376,
-0.2526959776878357,
-0.3824320137500763,
-0.16012296080589294,
0.13466937839984894,
0.5135794281959534,
0.20383207499980927,
0.4887709617614746,
-0.9935559034347534,
-0.43082499504089355,
-0.20820902287960052,
-0.7093976140022278,
-0.09875418245792389,
-0.4445326626300812,
-0.011460124514997005,
-0.4685298800468445,
0.7031328678131104,
-0.15951184928417206,
0.7013264894485474,
-0.19293510913848877,
-0.8581277132034302,
0.6761765480041504,
-0.27210772037506104,
-0.03171772509813309,
-0.9164129495620728,
-0.34736379981040955,
0.0001405261573381722,
-0.5732799768447876,
-0.4174748957157135,
0.28153330087661743,
0.3185654580593109,
0.17882125079631805,
-0.4619894325733185,
0.29090800881385803,
-0.42762821912765503,
-0.002072116592898965,
0.06103171408176422,
0.043016523122787476,
-0.18076595664024353,
0.5201291441917419,
0.17986498773097992,
0.6260844469070435,
0.3565385937690735,
-0.34037718176841736,
0.5257400274276733,
-0.03742215409874916,
-0.5564324855804443,
0.7017942667007446,
-0.30428117513656616,
0.11939927190542221,
-0.2768968343734741,
0.3559171259403229,
-0.5339236855506897,
-0.10523145645856857,
0.21509066224098206,
-0.113998644053936,
0.5334871411323547,
-0.8483350872993469,
-0.5000329613685608,
-0.6578359603881836,
-0.09917236864566803,
0.3400685787200928,
0.3422195613384247,
-0.39230918884277344,
0.6513160467147827,
0.3268262445926666,
0.12446503341197968,
-0.7314361333847046,
-0.576508104801178,
-0.006692580878734589,
-0.3522966504096985,
-0.4487478733062744,
0.1694529801607132,
0.2741581201553345,
-0.1814744621515274,
-0.02288634143769741,
-0.08339637517929077,
0.26324889063835144,
0.08487021178007126,
0.5731910467147827,
-0.017687145620584488,
-0.2329896241426468,
0.492879718542099,
0.06338277459144592,
-0.16547343134880066,
0.3767382800579071,
-0.7801979780197144,
0.45316898822784424,
-0.14153212308883667,
-0.7128849625587463,
-0.18210971355438232,
0.002683967584744096,
0.29912975430488586,
-0.4115232825279236,
0.4548410475254059,
0.21359169483184814,
-0.1944984793663025,
-0.09365261346101761,
-0.7873984575271606,
0.03249331936240196,
-0.3791201412677765,
0.333273321390152,
-0.7223441004753113,
-0.576805055141449,
0.4014115333557129,
-0.34315457940101624,
0.3152993321418762,
0.3832409679889679,
0.55537348985672,
0.16186349093914032,
0.5862300992012024,
0.5244139432907104,
0.1601681411266327,
0.6581226587295532,
-0.21459683775901794,
0.23353978991508484,
-0.5003165602684021,
-0.34521856904029846,
-0.17539043724536896,
0.11544297635555267,
-0.3192879557609558,
-0.5049596428871155,
0.3837134838104248,
-0.05611689016222954,
-0.4798981845378876,
0.2128390073776245,
-0.31881213188171387,
0.48648855090141296,
0.9360052347183228,
0.19994321465492249,
0.19649377465248108,
-0.013942582532763481,
-0.7803918123245239,
-0.18885405361652374,
-0.49159476161003113,
-0.3190036416053772,
1.152931809425354,
0.29464447498321533,
0.5147560834884644,
0.18024273216724396,
0.8843627572059631,
0.31326666474342346,
-0.03284791111946106,
-0.8591790199279785,
0.27289941906929016,
-0.3144596219062805,
-0.4817061424255371,
0.08395805209875107,
-0.30324795842170715,
-0.5294328927993774,
0.42305701971054077,
-0.2786812484264374,
-0.5952614545822144,
0.1589445024728775,
0.05450945720076561,
-0.6973754167556763,
0.28577518463134766,
-0.31390824913978577,
0.9596039652824402,
-0.46357035636901855,
-0.8112525343894958,
-0.2830991744995117,
-0.9200910329818726,
0.36388006806373596,
-0.01765575259923935,
0.4823829233646393,
-0.11951162666082382,
0.41714832186698914,
0.7985801696777344,
-0.7264605760574341,
0.8333277106285095,
-0.6871880888938904,
0.16197200119495392,
0.3228374421596527,
0.2852211892604828,
0.59061199426651,
0.3733425736427307,
0.038661420345306396,
-0.2321062982082367,
0.14731766283512115,
-0.011959179304540157,
-0.5743260979652405,
0.2359352558851242,
-0.47228506207466125,
-0.8337615728378296,
-0.8431714177131653,
-0.5210518836975098,
-0.2990325689315796,
0.34758225083351135,
0.23882775008678436,
0.3826718330383301,
-0.2961479425430298,
-0.14086084067821503,
0.3837108016014099,
0.0012440865393728018,
-0.04050864651799202,
0.6731588840484619,
-0.1148499995470047,
-0.18304485082626343,
0.42355331778526306,
0.09966538101434708,
-0.2542762756347656,
0.437635600566864,
0.37248891592025757,
-0.4358404278755188,
-0.4620617926120758,
-0.5566306114196777,
0.1206936314702034,
-0.9068382382392883,
-0.20363682508468628,
-0.6120010018348694,
-0.1269599348306656,
-0.5138947367668152,
-0.07067465782165527,
-0.3049185872077942,
-0.5131837725639343,
0.37165719270706177,
-0.3045852482318878,
0.34038046002388,
0.5145643353462219,
-0.3365749716758728,
0.23062455654144287,
-0.492581307888031,
0.35665401816368103,
0.5541543364524841,
0.39024579524993896,
-0.301167368888855,
-0.933811366558075,
-0.15442003309726715,
0.15899935364723206,
-0.22176353633403778,
-0.8179306387901306,
0.22191278636455536,
-0.10933457314968109,
0.6084120273590088,
0.6814963817596436,
0.20645266771316528,
0.7498733997344971,
-0.990192174911499,
0.4870125651359558,
0.39041557908058167,
-0.4890406131744385,
0.8769189119338989,
-0.37079963088035583,
-0.013546564616262913,
0.768775224685669,
0.0016249833861365914,
-0.48964956402778625,
-0.297695517539978,
-0.6571457386016846,
-0.7959194183349609,
0.7463269233703613,
-0.12987984716892242,
-0.04558898136019707,
0.4069523513317108,
0.3918631076812744,
0.1961027979850769,
0.1736011952161789,
-0.6689590215682983,
0.07966192811727524,
-0.6702191233634949,
-0.18715550005435944,
0.17963720858097076,
-0.16785003244876862,
-0.10916424542665482,
-0.32949402928352356,
0.4909060299396515,
-0.01981847919523716,
0.24082514643669128,
-0.1412411332130432,
-0.24188867211341858,
0.049673113971948624,
0.2920791208744049,
0.3897700011730194,
0.478691041469574,
-0.5624351501464844,
0.12897779047489166,
-0.10210330039262772,
-0.6560313105583191,
0.2190178483724594,
0.24006196856498718,
-0.10224734246730804,
-0.20998293161392212,
0.5670800805091858,
0.965953528881073,
-0.0651644691824913,
-0.33621108531951904,
0.9318808913230896,
-0.3272227346897125,
-0.321222186088562,
-0.9334156513214111,
-0.014735831879079342,
-0.062485747039318085,
0.4568333923816681,
0.21195228397846222,
0.2742237150669098,
0.24753902852535248,
-0.601564347743988,
0.3428702652454376,
0.2251800149679184,
-0.6036533713340759,
-0.0748644471168518,
0.9979010224342346,
0.12706638872623444,
0.026122922077775,
0.6321263313293457,
-0.42768579721450806,
-0.6513781547546387,
0.6600117683410645,
0.3298538029193878,
0.7498869299888611,
-0.06465882062911987,
0.08363229036331177,
0.3219183683395386,
0.03719203919172287,
-0.3896424472332001,
0.18578316271305084,
-0.24505262076854706,
-0.8899521827697754,
-0.41826802492141724,
-0.5275307893753052,
-0.04913412407040596,
-0.1250070482492447,
-0.7592800855636597,
0.38673409819602966,
-0.6893571019172668,
-0.2458028346300125,
-0.2541736662387848,
0.0757124125957489,
-0.8559412360191345,
0.07563883811235428,
0.18356527388095856,
0.9848950505256653,
-0.864072859287262,
0.906807005405426,
0.8515836000442505,
-0.5836763978004456,
-0.9399631023406982,
0.13665060698986053,
0.37915146350860596,
-0.960746705532074,
0.7961133122444153,
0.3776196837425232,
-0.07114551216363907,
-0.21458424627780914,
-0.3909127116203308,
-0.3616223931312561,
1.0151393413543701,
0.25088006258010864,
-0.9176338911056519,
-0.19152775406837463,
-0.14775560796260834,
0.44777679443359375,
-0.3680327534675598,
0.2934841811656952,
0.5433140397071838,
0.3453039228916168,
0.5689582824707031,
-0.604188859462738,
0.17295844852924347,
-0.3494923710823059,
-0.4046918749809265,
0.2707073986530304,
-0.3088841438293457,
0.6313124895095825,
-0.5635854601860046,
-0.06504139304161072,
-0.2888925075531006,
0.3946179747581482,
0.39137452840805054,
0.498911052942276,
0.6391931176185608,
0.9745606184005737,
0.8089936375617981,
-0.30298975110054016,
0.9676221013069153,
-0.1487724781036377,
0.2547411620616913,
1.333497166633606,
-0.4649727940559387,
0.5054466724395752,
0.5125603675842285,
-0.22744238376617432,
0.9177440404891968,
0.5003385543823242,
-0.10016164928674698,
0.8985819816589355,
0.22920216619968414,
-0.01889214664697647,
-0.7217947840690613,
0.05058594420552254,
-0.36188268661499023,
0.3459419012069702,
0.4790842831134796,
-0.28154298663139343,
-0.128847137093544,
-0.033355794847011566,
-0.07397399842739105,
0.2910633385181427,
-0.2571960985660553,
0.8363040089607239,
0.24758543074131012,
-0.592093825340271,
-0.04097723960876465,
0.024295886978507042,
0.39828675985336304,
-0.41583266854286194,
-0.31396177411079407,
-0.16731679439544678,
0.32589995861053467,
-0.1391110122203827,
-0.9118231534957886,
0.02956049144268036,
-0.1950370818376541,
0.09529867768287659,
-0.4668753743171692,
0.6250653266906738,
-0.16958831250667572,
-0.35214701294898987,
0.3675651252269745,
0.353516548871994,
0.1551489382982254,
-0.2981467545032501,
-0.9412030577659607,
-0.6882943511009216,
-0.09383994340896606,
-0.29366469383239746,
0.08677467703819275,
0.8151741623878479,
-0.35578653216362,
0.46040722727775574,
0.6007415056228638,
0.3551633059978485,
0.05117093771696091,
0.7515017986297607,
0.8973344564437866,
-0.684054434299469,
-1.0967063903808594,
-0.6131146550178528,
0.7813931107521057,
-0.2520991563796997,
-0.03254183009266853,
0.31785348057746887,
0.4372525215148926,
0.5379505753517151,
-0.09835609048604965,
0.6524866223335266,
-0.1477576047182083,
0.6306086778640747,
-0.9647564888000488,
0.5404104590415955,
-0.4854903221130371,
0.2709674537181854,
-0.02100869081914425,
-0.5295655727386475,
-0.45893794298171997,
0.9054145812988281,
-0.7498911023139954,
0.09751903265714645,
0.7095839977264404,
0.49246421456336975,
-0.4343240261077881,
-0.1096704974770546,
0.488570898771286,
0.09921836853027344,
0.30454909801483154,
0.8797253966331482,
0.89694744348526,
-0.33537015318870544,
0.4351603388786316,
-0.1982291340827942,
0.004337893333286047,
-0.44759076833724976,
-0.8876428604125977,
-0.9947171807289124,
-0.30294373631477356,
-0.11338980495929718,
-0.3659113347530365,
0.25375160574913025,
0.7485284805297852,
0.684928297996521,
-0.7229244709014893,
0.09211111813783646,
-0.49531084299087524,
-0.13200296461582184,
-0.17338743805885315,
-0.22175869345664978,
0.4548354744911194,
-0.3156224489212036,
-0.0035133042838424444,
0.3222343623638153,
0.11025184392929077,
-0.1910221427679062,
0.2643992602825165,
-0.09046094864606857,
-0.2541041970252991,
-0.2621365785598755,
0.19491234421730042,
0.081475168466568,
-0.7170853614807129,
-0.19118176400661469,
-0.40273481607437134,
0.10972302407026291,
0.11670609563589096,
1.2400480508804321,
-1.0072252750396729,
0.7172796726226807,
0.3937441110610962,
0.3211919963359833,
0.7696959972381592,
0.1406944841146469,
0.6751940846443176,
-0.840042233467102,
0.7163259387016296,
0.47829288244247437,
0.774251401424408,
0.034305743873119354,
-0.5159250497817993,
0.6603749990463257,
0.38746893405914307,
-0.2506747543811798,
-0.5009995698928833,
0.4944000244140625,
-0.6007111072540283,
-0.31277984380722046,
0.6830940842628479,
-0.4150492548942566,
0.066224604845047,
-0.23053395748138428,
-0.019758883863687515,
0.46377119421958923,
-0.5067785978317261,
0.4959787428379059,
0.5784139037132263,
0.2463507354259491,
-0.4761437475681305,
-0.9843283891677856,
0.40244999527931213,
0.28428542613983154,
-0.38448426127433777,
-0.08931294828653336,
0.5510172247886658,
0.3448474109172821,
0.21554739773273468,
0.6576119661331177,
-0.25214606523513794,
0.525124728679657,
0.23752133548259735,
0.115172378718853,
-0.5367067456245422,
-0.3025001287460327,
-0.3096548616886139,
0.07511574774980545,
-0.0023787389509379864,
0.05162791907787323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15360v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15360v1 | Importance-Aware Data Augmentation for Document-Level Neural Machine Translation | 2024-01-27T09:27:47 | 2024-01-27T09:27:47 | Minghao Wu, Yufei Wang, George Foster, Lizhen Qu, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level neural machine translation (DocNMT) aims to generate
translations that are both coherent and cohesive, in contrast to its
sentence-level counterpart. However, due to its longer input length and limited
availability of training data, DocNMT often faces the challenge of data
sparsity. To overcome this issue, we propose a novel Importance-Aware Data
Augmentation (IADA) algorithm for DocNMT that augments the training data based
on token importance information estimated by the norm of hidden states and
training gradients. We conduct comprehensive experiments on three widely-used
DocNMT benchmarks. Our empirical results show that our proposed IADA
outperforms strong DocNMT baselines as well as several data augmentation
approaches, with statistical significance on both sentence-level and
document-level BLEU. | [
-0.305486261844635,
-0.5386133193969727,
0.5529289841651917,
0.28757092356681824,
-0.3387186527252197,
-0.25018802285194397,
-0.23446854948997498,
-0.29549506306648254,
0.2576146125793457,
0.21318085491657257,
-0.21885691583156586,
-0.562056303024292,
-1.1066813468933105,
-0.11258711665868759,
-0.6666712164878845,
0.9431548118591309,
0.05395367369055748,
0.1488947868347168,
-0.2947792410850525,
-0.18881860375404358,
-0.49089518189430237,
-0.34045371413230896,
-0.7103649377822876,
-0.15945173799991608,
0.4750697910785675,
0.3350955545902252,
0.6509270668029785,
0.9566929936408997,
0.7414222359657288,
0.18659725785255432,
-0.20839345455169678,
0.3670218586921692,
-0.11880599707365036,
0.04720399156212807,
-0.06701774895191193,
-0.46402615308761597,
-0.7511180639266968,
-0.0661051794886589,
0.8282612562179565,
0.9617167115211487,
0.1385064721107483,
-0.07638563215732574,
-0.051716484129428864,
0.531109094619751,
-0.31601807475090027,
0.24720251560211182,
-0.6113666296005249,
-0.02299956977367401,
-0.14547882974147797,
-0.42050644755363464,
-0.11164630949497223,
-0.4310152530670166,
0.06858483701944351,
-0.7076659202575684,
0.2880398631095886,
-0.19103626906871796,
0.9012676477432251,
0.657017171382904,
-0.660800576210022,
-0.11294078081846237,
-0.3877766728401184,
0.35842132568359375,
-0.7510051727294922,
0.47806528210639954,
0.40703925490379333,
-0.13430514931678772,
-0.25533047318458557,
-0.7117437124252319,
-0.5699955224990845,
-0.06612490117549896,
-0.08033157140016556,
0.29867133498191833,
0.013480911031365395,
0.209226593375206,
0.17916670441627502,
0.5481073260307312,
-0.2498280555009842,
0.2660115659236908,
-0.3691025674343109,
0.00045404487173072994,
0.2132015824317932,
0.13885684311389923,
0.25106295943260193,
-0.11860641092061996,
-0.5313681364059448,
-0.1581350564956665,
-0.46494951844215393,
0.04169287532567978,
0.19899873435497284,
0.008683299645781517,
0.013316464610397816,
0.5639045834541321,
0.019189342856407166,
0.5995039343833923,
0.26899057626724243,
0.19646799564361572,
0.49456626176834106,
-0.4998931884765625,
-0.007007913198322058,
0.25527963042259216,
0.5736202001571655,
0.2946074306964874,
-0.30770033597946167,
-0.3514487147331238,
-0.3428804278373718,
-0.30386820435523987,
0.4696556627750397,
-0.8856455087661743,
0.24626068770885468,
0.48579880595207214,
-0.21863369643688202,
-0.3321802318096161,
-0.022217631340026855,
-0.4084434509277344,
-0.40271782875061035,
-0.2923490107059479,
0.5435152649879456,
-0.6820038557052612,
-0.27045974135398865,
-0.06383586674928665,
-0.15761257708072662,
0.004308495670557022,
0.5253131985664368,
-0.8899288773536682,
0.13747629523277283,
0.8962635397911072,
0.9988072514533997,
-0.34990766644477844,
-0.4347769320011139,
-0.6283186674118042,
0.0664171651005745,
-0.6616483926773071,
0.5596407651901245,
-0.4430609941482544,
-0.22635315358638763,
-0.48617562651634216,
-0.09732396900653839,
-0.19796809554100037,
-0.4496631920337677,
0.9380955696105957,
-0.39328423142433167,
-0.03299030661582947,
0.10400903970003128,
-0.7437329292297363,
-0.25996118783950806,
0.3585430085659027,
-0.6437621116638184,
1.1499899625778198,
0.45518186688423157,
-0.5410438179969788,
0.5564461350440979,
-0.9883071184158325,
-0.8009124398231506,
0.09490437060594559,
-0.09831203520298004,
-0.4662936329841614,
0.5180917978286743,
0.30896681547164917,
0.5351702570915222,
-0.21618227660655975,
0.4393366873264313,
0.14774495363235474,
-0.43623968958854675,
0.39450815320014954,
-0.7524212002754211,
0.4472321569919586,
0.040008772164583206,
-0.42760223150253296,
-0.051747363060712814,
-0.9413005113601685,
-0.010781576856970787,
-0.2243518978357315,
-0.564548671245575,
-0.5713847875595093,
-0.4460473656654358,
0.08394119143486023,
0.36409762501716614,
0.4132586717605591,
-0.4301702380180359,
0.261935293674469,
-0.7406256198883057,
0.4948286712169647,
0.6588244438171387,
0.13966462016105652,
0.6508220434188843,
0.07823288440704346,
0.5347398519515991,
0.3033597469329834,
0.06602175533771515,
-0.15711118280887604,
-0.5223148465156555,
-0.7022901773452759,
-0.40119364857673645,
0.7072455286979675,
0.34661728143692017,
-0.3880150318145752,
0.6859710216522217,
-0.7243049740791321,
-0.29539889097213745,
-1.0109806060791016,
0.014517946168780327,
0.22172826528549194,
0.866829514503479,
0.4814700186252594,
-0.4777531027793884,
-0.33579105138778687,
-0.8797420263290405,
0.15115980803966522,
0.1676432192325592,
0.2238800823688507,
0.13722513616085052,
0.10455131530761719,
-0.4456215798854828,
0.710334837436676,
-0.14514362812042236,
-0.4185638725757599,
0.08991874009370804,
0.1129331886768341,
0.474103718996048,
0.6484940052032471,
0.35286980867385864,
-0.9247497916221619,
-0.31897521018981934,
0.29682934284210205,
-0.6504978537559509,
-0.12745694816112518,
-0.36932381987571716,
-0.027834760025143623,
-0.056297510862350464,
0.6015190482139587,
-0.8486271500587463,
0.5588774681091309,
0.46815818548202515,
-0.13649170100688934,
-0.1309603750705719,
-0.6839673519134521,
0.25897416472435,
-1.3964850902557373,
0.21200381219387054,
-0.214427188038826,
-0.1970515102148056,
-0.6789026856422424,
-0.09966321289539337,
0.5885605812072754,
-0.36556941270828247,
-0.2746945321559906,
0.6014319658279419,
-0.6505869030952454,
-0.1385444700717926,
-0.3570096790790558,
0.09669842571020126,
0.13104821741580963,
0.41748765110969543,
-0.15426978468894958,
0.7794727683067322,
0.4421328604221344,
-0.5663108229637146,
-0.26411905884742737,
0.1742565929889679,
-0.21755819022655487,
0.6222471594810486,
-0.45543843507766724,
-0.009861014783382416,
0.009144789539277554,
-0.05773494020104408,
-0.8711047172546387,
-0.032221272587776184,
0.05396803468465805,
-0.6115423440933228,
0.7571631669998169,
-0.35458362102508545,
-0.47475361824035645,
0.044570595026016235,
0.08714433014392853,
0.36636099219322205,
0.2270931750535965,
-0.5229006409645081,
0.4576421082019806,
0.5049449801445007,
-0.10001526027917862,
-0.7017019391059875,
-0.6884600520133972,
0.5468313097953796,
-0.09375858306884766,
-0.5335054397583008,
0.5333564281463623,
0.09383641928434372,
0.16729044914245605,
0.20563942193984985,
-0.27887773513793945,
-0.10258825868368149,
0.49546700716018677,
0.49557703733444214,
0.07559283822774887,
-0.009324735030531883,
0.23872482776641846,
0.5403578877449036,
-0.5253766775131226,
-0.01915070228278637,
-0.7686208486557007,
0.4609147012233734,
0.02555939368903637,
-0.18975897133350372,
-0.2579512596130371,
0.3975980281829834,
0.7803053855895996,
-0.3037024438381195,
0.8273798227310181,
1.0085525512695312,
-0.4766192138195038,
-0.028947073966264725,
-0.252925843000412,
-0.03407912328839302,
-0.37723836302757263,
0.6590598821640015,
-0.2122764140367508,
-0.44978266954421997,
0.2711969316005707,
-0.11200203746557236,
-0.08332289010286331,
0.585690975189209,
0.32221487164497375,
-0.24276483058929443,
0.907031774520874,
0.43344399333000183,
0.03327655792236328,
0.5737550854682922,
-0.5097858905792236,
0.13569018244743347,
-1.104655146598816,
-0.04689821973443031,
-0.25696274638175964,
-0.4372095465660095,
-0.330228716135025,
-0.6267918348312378,
0.6482706069946289,
0.14001259207725525,
0.31624823808670044,
0.29828062653541565,
-0.5851280689239502,
0.25031083822250366,
0.4826396107673645,
0.059593964368104935,
0.2194490283727646,
0.1353059560060501,
0.059660013765096664,
-0.14154937863349915,
-0.7312045097351074,
-0.12623582780361176,
1.3774096965789795,
0.25065457820892334,
0.42291077971458435,
0.027420485392212868,
0.6637200117111206,
0.4036369025707245,
0.13640064001083374,
-0.9334878325462341,
0.30540889501571655,
-0.22579427063465118,
-0.32798537611961365,
-0.3493076264858246,
-0.582482635974884,
-1.1274796724319458,
0.19325220584869385,
-0.14781755208969116,
-0.1841060221195221,
0.4893198311328888,
0.022699059918522835,
0.09329082816839218,
-0.03699096292257309,
-0.8640598058700562,
0.6192221641540527,
-0.3808414936065674,
-0.028353463858366013,
-0.2962206304073334,
-0.6281828880310059,
-0.028079763054847717,
-0.3160263001918793,
-0.03097611851990223,
0.21154078841209412,
-0.6216810345649719,
0.5547405481338501,
-0.8163865208625793,
0.44605404138565063,
-0.21871337294578552,
-0.07548879832029343,
-0.18594777584075928,
-0.27961501479148865,
0.7639660835266113,
0.16866493225097656,
-0.15326498448848724,
0.5241698622703552,
-0.4891566038131714,
-0.4212011396884918,
-0.7637437582015991,
0.9280287623405457,
-0.5877367258071899,
-0.6233879923820496,
-0.40245577692985535,
-0.9213215112686157,
-0.19252055883407593,
0.4847009778022766,
0.3462413251399994,
0.6183291673660278,
-0.03969657048583031,
0.4066721796989441,
0.8213286995887756,
0.308036744594574,
0.3864182233810425,
0.3983440399169922,
0.4075036942958832,
-0.5683231949806213,
1.093754529953003,
0.6080843806266785,
0.2068004608154297,
0.5874578356742859,
-0.10277166217565536,
-0.3212166428565979,
-1.1618531942367554,
-0.7874842882156372,
-0.1530289202928543,
-0.7667397856712341,
-0.08547820895910263,
-1.0973961353302002,
-0.398669958114624,
-0.27513062953948975,
-0.17634975910186768,
-0.4322603940963745,
-0.9795168042182922,
-0.18668894469738007,
-0.28191307187080383,
0.530989944934845,
0.3543800711631775,
-0.21637412905693054,
0.2567261755466461,
-0.621829092502594,
0.3621112108230591,
-0.023833489045500755,
0.3396838903427124,
-0.15792101621627808,
-0.47780972719192505,
-0.6568601131439209,
-0.014436598867177963,
0.06839296966791153,
-0.6554285287857056,
0.30330225825309753,
0.17160087823867798,
0.7632166147232056,
0.201321542263031,
-0.19965580105781555,
0.4648270010948181,
-0.32859867811203003,
0.4155435860157013,
0.21966154873371124,
-0.588223397731781,
0.533783495426178,
-0.25891411304473877,
0.34906068444252014,
0.6647799611091614,
0.16935428977012634,
-0.4488694667816162,
-0.2432379275560379,
-0.7254272699356079,
-1.3274661302566528,
0.6737678050994873,
0.39265528321266174,
0.2310708463191986,
-0.06931750476360321,
0.445000559091568,
0.1448153555393219,
0.3193081021308899,
-0.30551958084106445,
-0.3829914927482605,
-0.2055898755788803,
-0.4518618881702423,
-0.014470512047410011,
0.12850365042686462,
-0.004886295646429062,
-0.106838658452034,
0.638739287853241,
-0.05395474657416344,
0.2451779544353485,
0.41045433282852173,
-0.3209074139595032,
0.1516493409872055,
0.3831542134284973,
0.4990358054637909,
0.40118131041526794,
-0.34099215269088745,
0.0027098506689071655,
0.17791219055652618,
-1.0905834436416626,
0.23460182547569275,
0.5737106800079346,
-0.5811161398887634,
0.21370576322078705,
-0.008083757013082504,
0.8715286254882812,
0.14915676414966583,
-0.32591578364372253,
0.5975054502487183,
-0.18555091321468353,
0.0229948703199625,
-0.02516583725810051,
0.06965706497430801,
0.08743973076343536,
0.022784149274230003,
0.47088825702667236,
0.5251556038856506,
0.241597980260849,
-0.2308179885149002,
0.06717269122600555,
0.07313438504934311,
-0.8209298849105835,
-0.017650393769145012,
0.6182161569595337,
0.24954940378665924,
-0.3384254276752472,
0.3046238124370575,
-0.11159119755029678,
-0.27122393250465393,
0.7576783895492554,
0.4793833792209625,
0.8067432045936584,
-0.10380883514881134,
-0.053249336779117584,
0.22606538236141205,
0.5962076187133789,
0.08347982168197632,
0.12560638785362244,
-0.1019076481461525,
-0.23057624697685242,
-0.1472700536251068,
-0.2549000680446625,
-0.23166322708129883,
0.1637534499168396,
-0.544506311416626,
0.21633316576480865,
-0.36212223768234253,
-0.2784903943538666,
-0.05086701363325119,
-0.06229221448302269,
-0.6858494877815247,
0.41875243186950684,
-0.35702651739120483,
0.8144583702087402,
-0.25520703196525574,
0.989920973777771,
0.49837571382522583,
-0.5573987364768982,
-0.5714574456214905,
0.18928934633731842,
-0.40979763865470886,
-0.5209866166114807,
0.5015810132026672,
0.05401565879583359,
0.05576541647315025,
0.418458491563797,
-0.028382200747728348,
-0.8933310508728027,
1.28599214553833,
0.4914308190345764,
-0.4138094484806061,
0.06970886886119843,
0.21514193713665009,
0.48981568217277527,
-0.38055863976478577,
0.13882878422737122,
0.31577712297439575,
0.4793672561645508,
-0.4580003023147583,
-0.616546630859375,
0.02064315602183342,
-0.5882807374000549,
0.07875766605138779,
0.4500567317008972,
-0.5136325359344482,
0.5953480005264282,
0.01846906915307045,
-0.18855959177017212,
-0.3262881934642792,
0.48173394799232483,
-0.3219425082206726,
0.2998707592487335,
0.496380478143692,
0.7534230947494507,
0.9626564383506775,
-0.05370252579450607,
1.1296098232269287,
-0.3536810278892517,
-0.023462871089577675,
1.2188373804092407,
0.23114566504955292,
0.5027808547019958,
0.5402725338935852,
0.2697780430316925,
-0.07879161089658737,
0.5756015777587891,
0.1068732738494873,
0.4313257038593292,
-0.11856507509946823,
-0.13255715370178223,
0.06258728355169296,
-0.3639485836029053,
-0.8490958213806152,
0.3105448782444,
0.6443401575088501,
-0.7667062282562256,
-0.029370732605457306,
-0.07856477051973343,
0.1007906123995781,
-0.15359924733638763,
-0.4186471104621887,
0.7253925204277039,
0.11978746205568314,
-0.7323828935623169,
0.7968788146972656,
0.23856529593467712,
0.4272506535053253,
-0.6042294502258301,
-0.10327719897031784,
-0.4960602819919586,
0.10633534938097,
-0.24907131493091583,
-0.902376115322113,
0.1760578602552414,
-0.018581129610538483,
-0.4464307427406311,
-0.2787066102027893,
0.672319233417511,
-0.5494067072868347,
-0.46510276198387146,
0.13199982047080994,
0.4026358723640442,
0.09218569099903107,
-0.1319085955619812,
-0.588833749294281,
-0.3693740963935852,
-0.30971482396125793,
-0.08551910519599915,
0.6736637949943542,
0.6674075126647949,
-0.18490298092365265,
0.5133302211761475,
0.7214120030403137,
0.32987719774246216,
0.15220876038074493,
0.16960380971431732,
0.8566275835037231,
-0.45769932866096497,
-0.6825001239776611,
-0.4541265368461609,
0.4084497094154358,
-0.33564040064811707,
-0.5351552963256836,
0.7159225344657898,
0.6944249868392944,
0.5524914860725403,
0.09762933850288391,
0.7686165571212769,
-0.0029049969743937254,
0.0790853425860405,
-0.7034168839454651,
0.993995726108551,
-0.505497932434082,
0.4134975075721741,
-0.12481320649385452,
-0.918422520160675,
-0.18805669248104095,
0.18091203272342682,
-0.25057557225227356,
-0.27220675349235535,
0.6546505093574524,
0.8288682103157043,
-0.4223749041557312,
-0.2317892611026764,
0.43671101331710815,
0.2532421946525574,
0.15099452435970306,
0.47040462493896484,
0.5483524203300476,
-0.8996762633323669,
0.8052927255630493,
-0.08583702147006989,
-0.15971988439559937,
-0.2976616322994232,
-0.7690759897232056,
-0.627988874912262,
-0.743586003780365,
-0.38021120429039,
-0.400320440530777,
0.02936645783483982,
0.9499740600585938,
0.8567004203796387,
-0.47482407093048096,
0.37102341651916504,
-0.20561398565769196,
0.16233038902282715,
-0.4476574957370758,
-0.1544770896434784,
0.6529473662376404,
-0.40908050537109375,
-0.8066853284835815,
0.7157533168792725,
0.5797873735427856,
0.111341692507267,
0.036439742892980576,
-0.17984871566295624,
-0.2787662148475647,
0.07926657050848007,
0.30131351947784424,
-0.02432500198483467,
-0.3317430019378662,
-0.08966604620218277,
-0.08600150793790817,
-0.4449787139892578,
0.471187025308609,
0.7498565316200256,
-0.487260103225708,
0.7271732687950134,
0.5877644419670105,
1.1910268068313599,
0.6042090058326721,
-0.08620204031467438,
0.6487666964530945,
-0.9578971266746521,
0.24511390924453735,
0.13560935854911804,
0.38487717509269714,
0.4652152359485626,
-0.8303898572921753,
0.7726796269416809,
0.26380160450935364,
-0.25036007165908813,
-0.7326974272727966,
-0.20133830606937408,
-1.1923918724060059,
0.03999912366271019,
0.8954245448112488,
-0.38027724623680115,
-0.34840232133865356,
-0.2782056927680969,
-0.24226151406764984,
0.3395755887031555,
-0.46083247661590576,
0.7366002202033997,
0.48565807938575745,
0.35866400599479675,
-0.05403821915388107,
-0.532472550868988,
0.41145846247673035,
0.4890887141227722,
-0.9242725372314453,
-0.10341786593198776,
0.3369651138782501,
0.017342165112495422,
0.09587612003087997,
0.6403092741966248,
-0.2908548414707184,
0.5089746117591858,
0.022303622215986252,
-0.11146457493305206,
-0.5660210251808167,
-0.2947612702846527,
-0.5888526439666748,
0.18221689760684967,
-0.017248012125492096,
-0.2572399973869324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15351v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15351v2 | A Survey on Neural Topic Models: Methods, Applications, and Challenges | 2024-01-27T08:52:19 | 2024-06-24T12:08:06 | Xiaobao Wu, Thong Nguyen, Anh Tuan Luu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Topic models have been prevalent for decades to discover latent topics and
infer topic proportions of documents in an unsupervised fashion. They have been
widely used in various applications like text analysis and context
recommendation. Recently, the rise of neural networks has facilitated the
emergence of a new research field -- Neural Topic Models (NTMs). Different from
conventional topic models, NTMs directly optimize parameters without requiring
model-specific derivations. This endows NTMs with better scalability and
flexibility, resulting in significant research attention and plentiful new
methods and applications. In this paper, we present a comprehensive survey on
neural topic models concerning methods, applications, and challenges.
Specifically, we systematically organize current NTM methods according to their
network structures and introduce the NTMs for various scenarios like short
texts and bilingual documents. We also discuss a wide range of popular
applications built on NTMs. Finally, we highlight the challenges confronted by
NTMs to inspire future research. We accompany this survey with a repository for
easier access to the mentioned paper resources:
https://github.com/bobxwu/Paper-Neural-Topic-Models. | [
-0.4660736322402954,
-0.7772833108901978,
0.6395246982574463,
0.3450019061565399,
-0.08961556106805801,
-0.1472696214914322,
-0.3541673719882965,
-0.11321014165878296,
0.5489047765731812,
0.4718664884567261,
-0.37556466460227966,
-0.45934605598449707,
-0.5645314455032349,
0.01198341604322195,
-0.4860643446445465,
0.6899363994598389,
0.07992415130138397,
0.2349853217601776,
-0.7100356817245483,
-0.15954704582691193,
-0.5710433721542358,
-0.610159695148468,
-0.4467415511608124,
-0.4168355166912079,
0.6034247279167175,
0.21942229568958282,
0.01334268506616354,
0.2894338071346283,
0.4157971739768982,
0.3924095332622528,
-0.6406837105751038,
0.0859057754278183,
0.024903805926442146,
0.29995197057724,
-0.07369951158761978,
-0.5067141652107239,
-0.27328163385391235,
0.15556521713733673,
0.6067865490913391,
1.2770912647247314,
-0.07506542652845383,
0.04231446981430054,
-0.042531806975603104,
0.5369173288345337,
-0.5717900991439819,
-0.24170351028442383,
-0.49390551447868347,
0.11575008183717728,
-0.3050364851951599,
-0.4274865686893463,
-0.20168566703796387,
-0.5761246085166931,
0.6332340240478516,
-0.086465984582901,
0.40820547938346863,
-0.4511634111404419,
0.35952651500701904,
0.008768175728619099,
-0.8333337306976318,
-0.20947378873825073,
-0.49613094329833984,
0.7268337607383728,
-0.6991685032844543,
0.10121487081050873,
0.4620700478553772,
-0.0007618943345732987,
-0.07377741485834122,
-0.834027886390686,
-0.25861963629722595,
-0.18658074736595154,
0.0903763622045517,
-0.14153049886226654,
-0.2741909623146057,
-0.19625236093997955,
-0.09901022166013718,
0.2061907947063446,
-0.6464553475379944,
0.2535707354545593,
0.00741663109511137,
-0.11344003677368164,
0.2528519034385681,
0.4335840940475464,
0.35436633229255676,
-0.3796071708202362,
-0.1834913045167923,
0.2730318307876587,
-0.41789039969444275,
-0.15091806650161743,
0.39974895119667053,
0.24758756160736084,
-0.013655321672558784,
0.4465300440788269,
-0.273177832365036,
1.0420972108840942,
-0.06108792498707771,
0.18391452729701996,
-0.11844620108604431,
-0.5515142679214478,
0.2133539319038391,
-0.14269854128360748,
0.5116235613822937,
0.2836229205131531,
-0.21983787417411804,
-0.3723366856575012,
-0.05659162253141403,
-0.24534720182418823,
0.3272828757762909,
-0.7432214021682739,
0.10273618251085281,
0.0950719490647316,
-0.7493221163749695,
-0.2650715112686157,
-0.42713797092437744,
-0.7958732843399048,
-0.3938869833946228,
-0.35529765486717224,
0.1895759105682373,
-0.103998102247715,
-0.35867199301719666,
0.0655464380979538,
-0.22004520893096924,
-0.1406322419643402,
0.4039219915866852,
-0.8135682344436646,
0.19274745881557465,
0.7419564723968506,
1.3300997018814087,
-0.4012279510498047,
-0.14016224443912506,
-0.06920278817415237,
-0.3672559857368469,
-0.4759301543235779,
0.837344765663147,
-0.20844392478466034,
-0.23066212236881256,
0.04904651641845703,
-0.27585369348526,
-0.08414585143327713,
-0.41899561882019043,
0.2785385549068451,
-0.6731533408164978,
0.4630284011363983,
-0.31230631470680237,
-0.6046527624130249,
-0.02646586112678051,
0.7761934995651245,
-0.5688080191612244,
0.6196826100349426,
-0.23114942014217377,
-0.9106674790382385,
-0.17812146246433258,
-0.8067804574966431,
-0.2905225157737732,
-0.32290926575660706,
0.0442202091217041,
-0.015541396103799343,
0.33872586488723755,
0.05590948089957237,
0.5542583465576172,
-0.7193183302879333,
0.6904576420783997,
-0.04688374325633049,
-0.07528140395879745,
0.33712488412857056,
-0.5654877424240112,
0.8711593151092529,
0.1106426790356636,
-0.04065849632024765,
0.3875200152397156,
-0.4137762188911438,
-0.20742936432361603,
0.08583804965019226,
0.052987292408943176,
-0.5800273418426514,
0.05226628854870796,
0.19949974119663239,
0.09636622667312622,
0.5052615404129028,
-0.31195658445358276,
0.037767745554447174,
-0.3545367121696472,
0.8372676968574524,
0.586655855178833,
0.36748310923576355,
0.7262871861457825,
-0.2518141567707062,
0.4179743528366089,
0.1638232320547104,
-0.04994191974401474,
-0.28488656878471375,
-0.5379222631454468,
-0.4562343657016754,
0.3642042577266693,
0.7947380542755127,
0.1853014975786209,
-0.6702777743339539,
0.3727676272392273,
-0.025579633191227913,
-0.7691553831100464,
0.23715530335903168,
-0.3293410837650299,
-0.019583776593208313,
0.6652374267578125,
0.1130983904004097,
-0.09410545974969864,
-0.0854172334074974,
-0.8241857290267944,
-0.055967140942811966,
-0.18692272901535034,
0.08219483494758606,
0.3291773796081543,
0.329941987991333,
0.04367712140083313,
0.904408872127533,
-0.5343379378318787,
0.00625309394672513,
-0.06986333429813385,
0.4354182481765747,
0.18210498988628387,
0.4148089587688446,
0.6493194699287415,
-1.1111479997634888,
-0.3789697289466858,
-0.405492901802063,
-0.6760020852088928,
0.00651696790009737,
-0.046203263103961945,
-0.02506900392472744,
0.13500024378299713,
0.5351409912109375,
-0.5799791812896729,
0.265678346157074,
0.24574236571788788,
-0.30214136838912964,
0.532231330871582,
-0.26276326179504395,
-0.20590831339359283,
-1.3583073616027832,
0.07217445224523544,
0.39137834310531616,
0.019098494201898575,
-0.5833644270896912,
-0.13141213357448578,
0.10041719675064087,
-0.27141323685646057,
-0.307201623916626,
0.703020453453064,
-0.5479120016098022,
0.08955883234739304,
-0.7004265785217285,
0.005958416499197483,
-0.09538016468286514,
0.22521528601646423,
0.25765693187713623,
0.6190987229347229,
0.5870607495307922,
-0.5916075706481934,
0.32891646027565,
0.2054734230041504,
-0.08138677477836609,
0.3443979024887085,
-0.7676717042922974,
-0.011701542884111404,
-0.10769467055797577,
0.1434340924024582,
-0.7774285674095154,
0.2427302598953247,
-0.006001358851790428,
-0.36183813214302063,
0.3122396469116211,
-0.2642492353916168,
-0.4935053884983063,
-0.023712046444416046,
-0.2890390455722809,
0.40766507387161255,
0.23509110510349274,
-0.25472602248191833,
0.4137681722640991,
0.5495557188987732,
-0.4111361801624298,
-0.5167005062103271,
-0.497765451669693,
0.4350127577781677,
-0.3763638138771057,
-0.5660865902900696,
0.7640302181243896,
-0.17856168746948242,
-0.13624875247478485,
0.23813316226005554,
-0.2182014137506485,
-0.2992132902145386,
0.22957372665405273,
0.00844771508127451,
0.006212153472006321,
-0.5004478096961975,
0.18014787137508392,
-0.1036924347281456,
-0.2844572961330414,
0.1341744363307953,
-0.5395630598068237,
0.5946294069290161,
-0.1729498952627182,
-0.1888202428817749,
-0.05384556204080582,
0.5651463270187378,
0.25333520770072937,
-0.38707175850868225,
0.5692219138145447,
0.32966071367263794,
-0.6406455039978027,
-0.04985828697681427,
-0.49849531054496765,
-0.4693922698497772,
-0.41862305998802185,
0.556567370891571,
0.2239951193332672,
-0.7846866250038147,
0.4637708365917206,
-0.30927911400794983,
-0.21287281811237335,
0.3523908257484436,
0.660567581653595,
-0.008938332088291645,
0.32198160886764526,
0.6995072960853577,
-0.1368476152420044,
0.6589041948318481,
-0.4696861207485199,
0.06375483423471451,
-0.7738656401634216,
-0.29027098417282104,
-0.8646628260612488,
-0.5533908009529114,
-0.6114124655723572,
-0.390145480632782,
0.3150486648082733,
-0.10860203951597214,
0.18399512767791748,
0.1379755288362503,
-0.4539419710636139,
0.41847965121269226,
0.6870497465133667,
-0.10500431805849075,
0.016645189374685287,
0.005329336039721966,
-0.009287038818001747,
-0.19182786345481873,
-0.7523766160011292,
-0.547619104385376,
0.9869056940078735,
0.2325761616230011,
0.3040737807750702,
-0.037246037274599075,
0.5361595153808594,
0.2764783501625061,
0.022605691105127335,
-0.7703813910484314,
0.7316339612007141,
-0.34378957748413086,
-0.7752429842948914,
-0.41087082028388977,
-0.47829902172088623,
-0.8644353151321411,
0.17585605382919312,
0.0277035403996706,
-0.9056806564331055,
0.5656763315200806,
-0.19778969883918762,
-0.22461152076721191,
0.5066842436790466,
-0.3852347135543823,
0.8966841101646423,
-0.4389590620994568,
-0.4491535425186157,
0.07453214377164841,
-0.6481878757476807,
0.03539654240012169,
-0.0528910830616951,
-0.6245969533920288,
-0.13812147080898285,
-0.28942978382110596,
0.9833580255508423,
-0.23686467111110687,
0.7551227807998657,
-0.26811090111732483,
0.16068004071712494,
0.37505635619163513,
-0.31174173951148987,
-0.009164806455373764,
0.3541637659072876,
-0.34054848551750183,
0.43068668246269226,
-0.1616191565990448,
-0.1899321973323822,
-0.5452014803886414,
0.9025806188583374,
-0.5767025351524353,
-0.5336592197418213,
-0.7965930700302124,
-0.6662138104438782,
-0.39844638109207153,
0.5007072687149048,
0.26334241032600403,
0.5718314051628113,
-0.26928621530532837,
0.4366072714328766,
0.673254132270813,
-0.22805556654930115,
0.9521420001983643,
0.318373441696167,
0.0626470297574997,
-0.30922597646713257,
0.8595783114433289,
0.3346790075302124,
-0.2623679041862488,
0.43261393904685974,
0.2229250967502594,
-0.45212146639823914,
-1.1584017276763916,
-0.12240665405988693,
-0.11030787229537964,
-0.4073724150657654,
-0.2549816370010376,
-0.8130509853363037,
-0.3324480652809143,
-0.23261182010173798,
0.09539619088172913,
-0.45540910959243774,
-0.536389172077179,
-0.6470239162445068,
0.09259410202503204,
0.24014365673065186,
0.415029376745224,
-0.05579343065619469,
0.3483976423740387,
-0.4821798801422119,
0.5710053443908691,
0.22682198882102966,
0.2622660994529724,
0.23469403386116028,
-0.2242256999015808,
-0.1001986414194107,
0.05122252181172371,
-0.5796149969100952,
-1.060336947441101,
0.523540735244751,
-0.19827023148536682,
0.6409013867378235,
0.14723676443099976,
0.1483461558818817,
0.23768958449363708,
-0.3786802291870117,
0.7268640995025635,
0.08162165433168411,
-0.55019611120224,
0.37584540247917175,
-0.4866965413093567,
-0.0028830517549067736,
0.4835258722305298,
0.6699649691581726,
-0.7781875133514404,
0.25893929600715637,
-0.4505924582481384,
-1.0917984247207642,
0.805068850517273,
0.42432156205177307,
0.44736790657043457,
0.05229327082633972,
0.5082340836524963,
-0.041031938046216965,
0.35286352038383484,
-0.2815433740615845,
-0.3427528440952301,
-0.15183068811893463,
0.0598037913441658,
-0.15803562104701996,
-0.30571502447128296,
0.1686621457338333,
-0.1299840211868286,
0.5219811201095581,
-0.09859347343444824,
0.4254542291164398,
0.05561663210391998,
-0.045496098697185516,
0.18054188787937164,
0.1222493126988411,
0.8993659615516663,
0.6897259950637817,
-0.36953094601631165,
0.05183028802275658,
-0.09752725064754486,
-0.2521918714046478,
0.33122992515563965,
0.2631283104419708,
-0.5717743635177612,
0.3325956463813782,
0.04350797459483147,
0.6357495784759521,
-0.04458702355623245,
-0.10603169351816177,
0.4008079469203949,
-0.4401000738143921,
-0.2366982251405716,
-0.35923948884010315,
-0.2484513372182846,
0.7283492088317871,
0.24324850738048553,
0.46074604988098145,
0.2458965927362442,
0.09469325840473175,
-0.32356131076812744,
-0.028849199414253235,
0.32477957010269165,
-0.4920143187046051,
-0.21256256103515625,
0.366064190864563,
0.14236843585968018,
-0.5495606660842896,
0.6732310652732849,
0.014289398677647114,
-0.3520953953266144,
1.021959900856018,
0.6647690534591675,
0.9036189913749695,
0.3086666762828827,
0.34581899642944336,
-0.060234539210796356,
0.13887366652488708,
-0.17921222746372223,
0.13592325150966644,
-0.01046546921133995,
-0.5898476243019104,
-0.1478945016860962,
-0.44568049907684326,
-0.5368620157241821,
0.4114669859409332,
-0.4799365997314453,
0.003912523854523897,
-0.20472563803195953,
-0.5325794219970703,
0.3215959072113037,
0.08149003237485886,
-0.16407860815525055,
-0.0006890723016113043,
-0.009043153375387192,
1.0276668071746826,
-0.5481166839599609,
0.5291882157325745,
1.054415225982666,
-0.24115854501724243,
-0.15461242198944092,
0.36558717489242554,
-0.09515811502933502,
-0.012597194872796535,
0.44177117943763733,
-0.08376460522413254,
0.3594152331352234,
-0.059606630355119705,
-0.205353245139122,
-0.6314828395843506,
0.7477346062660217,
0.4350215494632721,
-0.05264100804924965,
-0.41565635800361633,
0.335877388715744,
0.6533809304237366,
-0.24202007055282593,
0.4486229121685028,
-0.086094930768013,
0.27420181035995483,
-0.16253986954689026,
-0.4087352752685547,
-0.2828207015991211,
-0.5733080506324768,
0.37498393654823303,
0.16763146221637726,
-0.6332905888557434,
0.8952796459197998,
0.22846932709217072,
0.5818597078323364,
0.28502941131591797,
0.7219077348709106,
0.25463393330574036,
0.7857481837272644,
0.3055403232574463,
0.13690413534641266,
0.4469442069530487,
-0.10564383864402771,
0.6395924687385559,
-0.401873916387558,
0.12528125941753387,
0.9836233854293823,
-0.2691855728626251,
0.5007565021514893,
0.5285419821739197,
0.18923886120319366,
0.11207935959100723,
1.0017485618591309,
0.0030884486623108387,
0.5554700493812561,
0.29064351320266724,
0.0025709797628223896,
-0.010600518435239792,
-0.3398873507976532,
-0.5807429552078247,
0.504913866519928,
0.2738756835460663,
-0.09579800069332123,
-0.5120400786399841,
-0.01229395903646946,
-0.41267848014831543,
0.23142075538635254,
-0.1936548799276352,
0.6731711626052856,
0.2094467133283615,
-0.49214479327201843,
0.08959255367517471,
0.5917461514472961,
0.9481049180030823,
-0.6489551663398743,
0.08094128966331482,
-0.7054415345191956,
-0.18177826702594757,
0.17850512266159058,
-0.45853161811828613,
0.4978136420249939,
0.07016293704509735,
-0.6094208359718323,
-0.46495017409324646,
1.0907621383666992,
-0.13993875682353973,
-0.3631293773651123,
0.0699886679649353,
0.6653800010681152,
-0.20347268879413605,
-0.41341906785964966,
-0.5792737007141113,
-0.5481961965560913,
-0.31234797835350037,
-0.2831145226955414,
0.4300784170627594,
0.6376799941062927,
-0.4327954351902008,
0.4484937787055969,
0.3539222180843353,
0.2112700343132019,
0.1436464786529541,
-0.1587577909231186,
0.48633426427841187,
-0.9442652463912964,
-0.6825356483459473,
-0.7045621871948242,
0.25633499026298523,
-0.09571616351604462,
-0.5382739305496216,
0.773290753364563,
0.5107048749923706,
0.6124715805053711,
-0.0691506490111351,
0.3571542501449585,
0.2645265758037567,
0.2979329526424408,
-0.3697485029697418,
1.1764754056930542,
-0.8589311838150024,
0.17510449886322021,
-0.19507427513599396,
-0.8906201720237732,
-0.1920287162065506,
0.2531006932258606,
-0.40278390049934387,
0.3427540361881256,
0.5512703657150269,
0.4423834979534149,
-0.25107285380363464,
0.2569241225719452,
0.13830190896987915,
-0.2842574119567871,
0.018249522894620895,
0.29228559136390686,
1.1206609010696411,
-0.18238753080368042,
0.1767912060022354,
-0.723143994808197,
0.3370641767978668,
-0.4220878481864929,
-1.064696192741394,
-0.8066145181655884,
-0.8125589489936829,
-0.4775420129299164,
0.07315725088119507,
-0.021418461576104164,
0.6082199215888977,
1.0420520305633545,
-0.6226416826248169,
-0.28302210569381714,
-0.21704412996768951,
0.4403861463069916,
0.13091003894805908,
-0.15943892300128937,
0.45349061489105225,
-0.04233609139919281,
-0.49198994040489197,
0.39414677023887634,
0.049878526479005814,
0.10129125416278839,
-0.2357645332813263,
0.19909857213497162,
-0.5685872435569763,
-0.11087584495544434,
0.2897937595844269,
0.23337572813034058,
-0.4108397662639618,
0.3753977417945862,
0.3153097629547119,
-0.2345503270626068,
0.07932382076978683,
1.184662938117981,
-0.41970208287239075,
0.06746719777584076,
0.8982297778129578,
0.9531160593032837,
0.5614352226257324,
-0.3382067084312439,
0.4185962975025177,
-0.8515905141830444,
0.18919505178928375,
0.6363434195518494,
0.43375152349472046,
0.2804466187953949,
-0.2579905688762665,
0.4105280935764313,
0.34111955761909485,
-0.20354315638542175,
-0.9703046679496765,
0.004770245403051376,
-0.9132097959518433,
-0.5288059115409851,
0.7161374092102051,
0.09703053534030914,
-0.1626989245414734,
0.029569001868367195,
0.1921016424894333,
0.32714778184890747,
-0.17387129366397858,
0.690359354019165,
0.5169694423675537,
0.10702306032180786,
-0.05836637690663338,
-0.6271513104438782,
0.018115634098649025,
0.7063625454902649,
-0.8113762140274048,
-0.17223770916461945,
0.35888564586639404,
0.270405113697052,
0.3147132694721222,
0.5794256925582886,
-0.07964880764484406,
0.1149822548031807,
-0.21270941197872162,
-0.02188533917069435,
-0.2932664752006531,
-0.6759606003761292,
-0.5898727774620056,
0.5447229743003845,
-0.030101660639047623,
-0.03409701958298683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15347v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15347v1 | A Comprehensive Survey of Compression Algorithms for Language Models | 2024-01-27T08:38:56 | 2024-01-27T08:38:56 | Seungcheol Park, Jaehyeon Choi, Sojin Lee, U Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | How can we compress language models without sacrificing accuracy? The number
of compression algorithms for language models is rapidly growing to benefit
from remarkable advances of recent language models without side effects due to
the gigantic size of language models, such as increased carbon emissions and
expensive maintenance fees. While numerous compression algorithms have shown
remarkable progress in compressing language models, it ironically becomes
challenging to capture emerging trends and identify the fundamental concepts
underlying them due to the excessive number of algorithms. In this paper, we
survey and summarize diverse compression algorithms including pruning,
quantization, knowledge distillation, low-rank approximation, parameter
sharing, and efficient architecture design. We not only summarize the overall
trend of diverse compression algorithms but also select representative
algorithms and provide in-depth analyses of them. We discuss the value of each
category of compression algorithms, and the desired properties of low-cost
compression algorithms which have a significant impact due to the emergence of
large language models. Finally, we introduce promising future research topics
based on our survey results. | [
-0.4439280033111572,
-0.5340684652328491,
0.451551616191864,
0.15981139242649078,
-0.11461880058050156,
0.2720890939235687,
-0.372485488653183,
-0.5007922053337097,
0.1266331821680069,
0.33417344093322754,
-0.480292409658432,
-0.27653804421424866,
-0.7506830096244812,
0.013491845689713955,
-0.4414876103401184,
0.3220917284488678,
0.19740000367164612,
-0.12268431484699249,
-0.21891435980796814,
0.0035375794395804405,
-0.5886226892471313,
-0.8048537373542786,
-0.376211553812027,
-0.007634367328137159,
0.1837559938430786,
0.17107287049293518,
0.4987224340438843,
0.6273301839828491,
0.5010324716567993,
0.3547680675983429,
-0.43941760063171387,
0.20164453983306885,
-0.42875832319259644,
0.30703526735305786,
0.2769789397716522,
-0.1292746663093567,
-0.15357819199562073,
-0.2635044455528259,
0.8024622201919556,
0.8911699652671814,
-0.42746999859809875,
0.24747803807258606,
0.24580255150794983,
0.5784066915512085,
-0.7224178314208984,
0.16383995115756989,
-0.5058149695396423,
-0.2557683289051056,
-0.2940302789211273,
-0.15846580266952515,
-0.49913838505744934,
-0.46343204379081726,
-0.37596625089645386,
0.008724268525838852,
0.3436205983161926,
-0.018274083733558655,
0.611445963382721,
0.36193394660949707,
-0.07079289853572845,
-0.20724748075008392,
-0.8101922869682312,
1.1088645458221436,
-0.7373806238174438,
0.5411046743392944,
-0.06271041184663773,
0.21538032591342926,
0.05551697313785553,
-0.5366460680961609,
-0.2703264057636261,
-0.12069562077522278,
0.09152014553546906,
-0.28983181715011597,
-0.4099222719669342,
0.16849324107170105,
0.10191737115383148,
0.693332314491272,
-0.6796363592147827,
0.3055662512779236,
-0.3155103325843811,
-0.2526698410511017,
0.535028338432312,
0.021727552637457848,
0.42791837453842163,
0.16158448159694672,
0.07834015786647797,
-0.5544265508651733,
-0.7915207743644714,
0.046115443110466,
0.39449915289878845,
0.1545397937297821,
0.0582108348608017,
0.2053135335445404,
-0.43484067916870117,
1.0971331596374512,
-0.5407782793045044,
-0.00844835676252842,
-0.07663924247026443,
-0.48160144686698914,
-0.22803995013237,
-0.2661665081977844,
0.7742398381233215,
0.030436569824814796,
0.036775924265384674,
-0.3093332052230835,
-0.033267393708229065,
0.2106127142906189,
0.015332728624343872,
-0.7696467638015747,
-0.31842586398124695,
0.26259270310401917,
-0.4521845877170563,
-0.25555405020713806,
-0.022142382338643074,
-0.9932268857955933,
-0.23297017812728882,
-0.20319055020809174,
-0.015437732450664043,
0.0064069414511322975,
-0.31754034757614136,
0.4562571942806244,
-0.20512185990810394,
-0.074458047747612,
0.2785574495792389,
-0.8195023536682129,
0.49931633472442627,
0.8365308046340942,
0.9309061169624329,
0.15595826506614685,
0.034703172743320465,
-0.28884389996528625,
-0.24055160582065582,
-0.1398385465145111,
0.815161943435669,
-0.5303356647491455,
-0.24586215615272522,
0.08193867653608322,
-0.3289242684841156,
0.36019793152809143,
-0.47639772295951843,
0.5732091069221497,
-0.4452972114086151,
-0.08344624191522598,
-0.1310756504535675,
-0.5672116279602051,
-0.29589539766311646,
0.2653602659702301,
-0.8838402032852173,
0.5316933989524841,
-0.0723843201994896,
-0.620175302028656,
-0.19896183907985687,
-0.3051322102546692,
-0.1952599734067917,
0.010285682044923306,
0.05997839197516441,
-0.31582000851631165,
0.6827364563941956,
0.4025619626045227,
0.5403938889503479,
-0.8658530116081238,
0.2866787314414978,
-0.3099301755428314,
-0.30899789929389954,
0.2637668550014496,
-0.5931410789489746,
0.9797787666320801,
0.2325633317232132,
0.2073855698108673,
-0.12246711552143097,
-0.5009905099868774,
0.2467496246099472,
0.18301181495189667,
-0.09199459105730057,
-0.2683789134025574,
-0.022907424718141556,
-0.002055814955383539,
0.08409849554300308,
0.40833935141563416,
-0.31683802604675293,
0.6627377271652222,
-0.3546110689640045,
0.5638224482536316,
0.6009396910667419,
0.09901046752929688,
0.3708789646625519,
-0.3247935175895691,
0.720274031162262,
-0.43888095021247864,
0.39312809705734253,
-0.1525423228740692,
-0.3053562045097351,
-0.5978237986564636,
-0.18269050121307373,
0.5746206641197205,
0.2998872995376587,
-0.3265776038169861,
0.4670025110244751,
-0.7349985837936401,
-0.9000069499015808,
-0.4697420597076416,
0.08957097679376602,
0.23572002351284027,
-0.07682466506958008,
0.20172922313213348,
-0.29188108444213867,
-0.576681911945343,
-0.7229449152946472,
-0.28165021538734436,
-0.2575385272502899,
-0.027645917609333992,
0.1137656569480896,
0.09218193590641022,
0.21265378594398499,
0.7610909938812256,
-0.7635847926139832,
0.18265841901302338,
-0.2698812782764435,
0.3663172721862793,
0.12943832576274872,
0.5594034790992737,
0.5139269828796387,
-0.7174724340438843,
-0.25304538011550903,
-0.2618870139122009,
-0.19971728324890137,
-0.25828588008880615,
0.06824225932359695,
0.3885140120983124,
-0.0770225003361702,
0.1665779948234558,
-0.6600416898727417,
-0.009688795544207096,
1.1052919626235962,
0.055072467774152756,
0.5314939618110657,
0.010123899206519127,
0.13536503911018372,
-0.7365297079086304,
-0.04058580845594406,
-0.2370113730430603,
-0.12883497774600983,
-0.6890884041786194,
0.4444209933280945,
-0.09210574626922607,
-0.20177128911018372,
-0.38467565178871155,
0.4922579526901245,
-0.7231221199035645,
0.01814599521458149,
-0.31379234790802,
-0.10080359131097794,
0.019072111696004868,
0.43140915036201477,
0.0788615420460701,
0.5527210235595703,
0.6883363127708435,
-0.6393066644668579,
0.4354217052459717,
0.1605996936559677,
-0.44371142983436584,
-0.23489250242710114,
-0.6151611804962158,
0.4231097996234894,
-0.17273364961147308,
0.27919697761535645,
-0.6198083758354187,
0.01187030877918005,
0.11459218710660934,
-0.3297046720981598,
0.3928471505641937,
-0.29033926129341125,
-0.7652467489242554,
-0.20707769691944122,
-0.4210933744907379,
0.6026837229728699,
0.8874787092208862,
-0.21765954792499542,
0.26506564021110535,
0.5914226770401001,
-0.3726937472820282,
-0.6093501448631287,
-0.48058587312698364,
0.26803895831108093,
-0.2059127539396286,
-0.39011749625205994,
0.19913670420646667,
-0.41792193055152893,
-0.3615879416465759,
0.007337067276239395,
-0.11086045950651169,
-0.19572146236896515,
0.17014698684215546,
-0.022293245419859886,
0.11431330442428589,
0.09291934221982956,
0.11127764731645584,
-0.12395958602428436,
0.05196962133049965,
-0.20961686968803406,
-0.4966013431549072,
0.9542713165283203,
0.0065669710747897625,
-0.12499747425317764,
-0.11694209277629852,
0.5358646512031555,
0.4259018301963806,
-0.23611725866794586,
0.5627089142799377,
0.11272384971380234,
-0.4131915271282196,
-0.22035695612430573,
-0.6655445098876953,
-0.05616706609725952,
-0.42156240344047546,
0.2663428783416748,
-0.15083147585391998,
-1.0609785318374634,
0.38592445850372314,
-0.3017699420452118,
0.136406809091568,
0.34937742352485657,
0.38760027289390564,
0.4134114384651184,
0.9861338138580322,
0.7903572916984558,
-0.2985442280769348,
0.3623606562614441,
-0.13117623329162598,
0.26620757579803467,
-0.3757474422454834,
0.20037177205085754,
-1.2389729022979736,
-0.08309105038642883,
-0.6761265993118286,
-0.5189118981361389,
0.14315688610076904,
0.28517991304397583,
0.16871055960655212,
0.5196070075035095,
-0.8906498551368713,
0.5231339335441589,
0.30591654777526855,
-0.3123851716518402,
0.25173521041870117,
0.23586530983448029,
0.47074687480926514,
0.20682333409786224,
-0.8671826124191284,
-0.2541811466217041,
0.7059805393218994,
0.2934533655643463,
0.7298865914344788,
0.2589760422706604,
0.616714358329773,
0.2621660828590393,
0.04041125625371933,
-0.9107212424278259,
0.4353824853897095,
-0.23085123300552368,
-0.3339347541332245,
-0.2711798846721649,
-0.7622619271278381,
-0.7933811545372009,
-0.07855825126171112,
0.06452348083257675,
-0.7899094820022583,
0.37426260113716125,
0.25262221693992615,
-0.30484962463378906,
0.2868744432926178,
-0.39189982414245605,
0.6412181854248047,
-0.06722936779260635,
-0.04470086097717285,
-0.3724157512187958,
-0.47578269243240356,
0.4580141007900238,
-0.13097214698791504,
0.2873387038707733,
0.054312024265527725,
0.01844676211476326,
0.6389927864074707,
-0.3623650372028351,
0.6788949966430664,
-0.040497783571481705,
-0.11906895041465759,
0.310634970664978,
0.126739963889122,
0.43792879581451416,
-0.32639071345329285,
0.0437861829996109,
0.49151402711868286,
0.2717774212360382,
-0.5809348225593567,
-0.8137161731719971,
0.5450101494789124,
-0.38674187660217285,
-0.36271601915359497,
-0.24656139314174652,
-0.32079097628593445,
-0.3016991913318634,
-0.018932364881038666,
0.31115177273750305,
0.5356265902519226,
-0.23508697748184204,
0.10405737161636353,
0.5667431354522705,
-0.27642640471458435,
0.40938708186149597,
0.09824030101299286,
-0.1044185608625412,
-0.3762384355068207,
1.1397266387939453,
0.1648215502500534,
0.20925921201705933,
0.6017638444900513,
0.23981869220733643,
-0.19912250339984894,
-0.9431979060173035,
-0.15175719559192657,
0.1764819175004959,
-0.642681360244751,
-0.5753953456878662,
-0.5511767268180847,
-0.05190138891339302,
-0.8042553067207336,
-0.09568504244089127,
-0.45272451639175415,
-0.6199162602424622,
0.2132675051689148,
0.24448752403259277,
0.08715562522411346,
0.7935125231742859,
0.04796919971704483,
0.44977110624313354,
-1.2776944637298584,
0.04118289798498154,
0.196287140250206,
0.10863956063985825,
0.11329676955938339,
-0.1099284440279007,
-0.2782013416290283,
0.052692513912916183,
-0.17298869788646698,
-0.9642274379730225,
0.5810112357139587,
0.2164115011692047,
0.27840855717658997,
0.45524460077285767,
0.22534258663654327,
0.7472172975540161,
-0.22084178030490875,
0.9596124291419983,
0.15665268898010254,
-1.046870231628418,
0.19129663705825806,
0.21155792474746704,
0.28715354204177856,
0.4108866751194,
0.2480773627758026,
-0.7921288013458252,
-0.1662258505821228,
-0.7484012842178345,
-0.7687366008758545,
0.32927578687667847,
0.1750277876853943,
0.40315794944763184,
0.19609853625297546,
0.2008126825094223,
-0.031033597886562347,
0.3027040362358093,
-0.5538455247879028,
-0.044657349586486816,
0.119601771235466,
-0.33256709575653076,
0.027661319822072983,
-0.3366333842277527,
-0.004370139911770821,
0.07293043285608292,
0.679274320602417,
-0.0779946967959404,
0.2652198076248169,
-0.17129728198051453,
-0.17973731458187103,
0.2843235433101654,
0.579554557800293,
0.4969715178012848,
0.22247591614723206,
-0.09963042289018631,
0.2220504730939865,
-0.0844319686293602,
-0.35120514035224915,
0.39014264941215515,
0.05058290436863899,
-0.20293380320072174,
-0.016161730512976646,
0.31920284032821655,
0.6944459676742554,
-0.013713989406824112,
-0.9173341393470764,
0.4384819269180298,
-0.3400156497955322,
0.13104285299777985,
-0.08585791289806366,
0.032326020300388336,
-0.02518882229924202,
-0.14697076380252838,
0.012016345746815205,
0.09343346953392029,
0.33531254529953003,
-0.416091650724411,
-0.21219229698181152,
0.5361189246177673,
-0.17343071103096008,
-0.4454677104949951,
0.28004786372184753,
0.12102940678596497,
-0.09398630261421204,
0.7183895111083984,
-0.06131770834326744,
-0.4213851988315582,
0.36072805523872375,
0.17652317881584167,
0.9220511317253113,
-0.2621820271015167,
-0.031793348491191864,
0.30585530400276184,
0.3814258277416229,
-0.5715624094009399,
-0.016278620809316635,
-0.47207003831863403,
-0.6776775121688843,
-0.8794530034065247,
-0.7226768136024475,
-0.3790656626224518,
0.03921416401863098,
-0.39161941409111023,
0.21565665304660797,
-0.3339594900608063,
0.08150225877761841,
-0.2545948028564453,
0.25365009903907776,
-0.4364641010761261,
-0.007483405061066151,
0.22190333902835846,
1.2540532350540161,
-0.7644595503807068,
0.6467148661613464,
0.3948836624622345,
-0.29582124948501587,
-0.8086608648300171,
-0.04395247995853424,
-0.04753277078270912,
-0.282871276140213,
0.252346009016037,
-0.04080899432301521,
-0.2128104865550995,
0.19624578952789307,
-0.7096317410469055,
-0.7743677496910095,
0.4700203239917755,
0.5746685862541199,
-0.7149522304534912,
-0.28514865040779114,
0.09953148663043976,
0.33263808488845825,
-0.009803293272852898,
0.08374679088592529,
0.49376022815704346,
0.5507335662841797,
0.11186131089925766,
-0.6953369975090027,
-0.14109686017036438,
-0.34589698910713196,
-0.002565208123996854,
0.4089297950267792,
-0.45303893089294434,
0.5287438035011292,
0.39606451988220215,
-0.4840310215950012,
0.38082826137542725,
0.3730534017086029,
0.09752669930458069,
-0.1681576669216156,
0.5137696862220764,
0.4637889564037323,
0.6274057030677795,
-0.008604251779615879,
1.122623324394226,
-0.5191145539283752,
0.5696873068809509,
0.7800079584121704,
-0.08497190475463867,
0.689704954624176,
0.3231925368309021,
-0.26968520879745483,
0.10715016722679138,
0.4881591200828552,
-0.12176057696342468,
0.3158298134803772,
0.3673650026321411,
-0.29978808760643005,
-0.3686468303203583,
-0.32741063833236694,
-0.15683458745479584,
0.380375474691391,
0.18121974170207977,
0.1307332068681717,
-0.2378930002450943,
-0.13801082968711853,
-0.05431254208087921,
0.00021401479898486286,
-0.14610587060451508,
0.733073353767395,
-0.03237969055771828,
-0.7591282725334167,
0.7178729176521301,
0.0700780376791954,
0.7016729116439819,
-0.6232630610466003,
-0.08696028590202332,
-0.08156134188175201,
-0.2759876549243927,
0.07443688809871674,
-0.4556077718734741,
0.49074310064315796,
-0.0804208442568779,
-0.05685034021735191,
-0.6885214447975159,
0.7736985683441162,
-0.3250250816345215,
-0.36548665165901184,
-0.0224976297467947,
0.5664059519767761,
0.22959160804748535,
-0.40357810258865356,
-0.3910313844680786,
0.5422698259353638,
-0.07610142230987549,
-0.043348684906959534,
0.1165989488363266,
-0.025856686756014824,
0.15732455253601074,
0.6237426400184631,
0.48892468214035034,
0.6229538917541504,
0.030052343383431435,
-0.0980047956109047,
0.8041794896125793,
-0.5974217653274536,
-0.3289182186126709,
-0.7360951900482178,
0.37429970502853394,
-0.17693547904491425,
0.02212173491716385,
0.4042971730232239,
0.36424198746681213,
0.6740016341209412,
-0.02842610515654087,
0.7149108648300171,
-0.13321466743946075,
0.37861379981040955,
-0.6582235097885132,
0.6192662715911865,
-0.5265174508094788,
0.2607751488685608,
-0.18879273533821106,
-0.8768386244773865,
-0.560772716999054,
0.2557331323623657,
0.061180830001831055,
-0.11071979254484177,
0.4218979775905609,
0.6948647499084473,
-0.003340548137202859,
-0.057009048759937286,
0.3597973883152008,
0.0987352579832077,
0.4662209153175354,
0.4367469549179077,
0.7711716294288635,
-0.2755663990974426,
0.6231216788291931,
-0.4197506308555603,
-0.09900987148284912,
-0.22441934049129486,
-0.9230755567550659,
-0.21069437265396118,
-0.7410609126091003,
-0.5293698310852051,
0.031179172918200493,
-0.21930252015590668,
0.7644686698913574,
1.0833659172058105,
-0.6987037658691406,
-0.21806752681732178,
-0.43424826860427856,
0.23014318943023682,
-0.6877004504203796,
-0.1366012990474701,
0.43854111433029175,
-0.147610604763031,
-1.0838654041290283,
0.5117670297622681,
0.1865469515323639,
0.047135960310697556,
-0.464632511138916,
0.042570680379867554,
0.17095477879047394,
0.20320366322994232,
0.30850309133529663,
0.45473191142082214,
-0.43853235244750977,
-0.06618287414312363,
-0.020996926352381706,
0.02781902253627777,
0.0010606249561533332,
1.1442402601242065,
-0.8391121029853821,
0.18819953501224518,
0.9808061122894287,
0.6940356492996216,
0.15892872214317322,
-0.03446230664849281,
0.5986847877502441,
-0.9459293484687805,
0.21647444367408752,
0.37984994053840637,
0.4577600061893463,
0.4973006546497345,
-0.17572687566280365,
0.44441401958465576,
0.13526366651058197,
-0.575962483882904,
-1.107972264289856,
0.5461360216140747,
-1.039144515991211,
-0.5314599871635437,
0.8397473096847534,
-0.13616546988487244,
-0.30066317319869995,
0.005884566344320774,
-0.18221807479858398,
0.3434988856315613,
-0.15548917651176453,
0.7538828253746033,
0.9200875759124756,
-0.10705403238534927,
-0.6644425988197327,
-0.27812907099723816,
0.47355711460113525,
0.2804585099220276,
-0.7468540072441101,
0.49281787872314453,
0.7010019421577454,
-0.025069918483495712,
0.39435073733329773,
0.24954743683338165,
-0.0643143355846405,
-0.08205283433198929,
0.024884771555662155,
0.3221307098865509,
0.01005102414637804,
-0.2486603856086731,
-0.8845380544662476,
0.6138854622840881,
0.3045419156551361,
0.10261083394289017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01725v1 | Fortifying Ethical Boundaries in AI: Advanced Strategies for Enhancing Security in Large Language Models | 2024-01-27T08:09:33 | 2024-01-27T08:09:33 | Yunhong He, Jianling Qiu, Wei Zhang, Zhengqing Yuan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have significantly
enhanced capabilities in natural language processing and artificial
intelligence. These models, including GPT-3.5 and LLaMA-2, have revolutionized
text generation, translation, and question-answering tasks due to the
transformative Transformer model. Despite their widespread use, LLMs present
challenges such as ethical dilemmas when models are compelled to respond
inappropriately, susceptibility to phishing attacks, and privacy violations.
This paper addresses these challenges by introducing a multi-pronged approach
that includes: 1) filtering sensitive vocabulary from user input to prevent
unethical responses; 2) detecting role-playing to halt interactions that could
lead to 'prison break' scenarios; 3) implementing custom rule engines to
restrict the generation of prohibited content; and 4) extending these
methodologies to various LLM derivatives like Multi-Model Large Language Models
(MLLMs). Our approach not only fortifies models against unethical manipulations
and privacy breaches but also maintains their high performance across tasks. We
demonstrate state-of-the-art performance under various attack prompts, without
compromising the model's core functionalities. Furthermore, the introduction of
differentiated security levels empowers users to control their personal data
disclosure. Our methods contribute to reducing social risks and conflicts
arising from technological abuse, enhance data protection, and promote social
equity. Collectively, this research provides a framework for balancing the
efficiency of question-answering systems with user privacy and ethical
standards, ensuring a safer user experience and fostering trust in AI
technology. | [
-0.2661336660385132,
-1.044793963432312,
0.4845427870750427,
-0.02811894752085209,
-0.08540204912424088,
0.26942697167396545,
-0.09410165250301361,
-0.6527581214904785,
-0.36395227909088135,
0.9241995215415955,
-0.27497056126594543,
-0.27871450781822205,
-0.5447606444358826,
0.06476105004549026,
-0.3082559406757355,
0.9995503425598145,
0.25373801589012146,
0.014647177420556545,
-0.2852853238582611,
-0.05910341069102287,
-0.20416416227817535,
-0.8442503809928894,
-0.6525477766990662,
-0.12365546822547913,
0.5150899291038513,
0.08428680151700974,
0.8162921667098999,
0.8226701021194458,
0.7641894221305847,
0.3488501310348511,
-0.021175255998969078,
0.07304664701223373,
-0.28731828927993774,
0.3561765253543854,
-0.10387858003377914,
-0.4649791121482849,
-0.5176634788513184,
-0.000491164973936975,
0.2762695848941803,
0.1711360365152359,
-0.19972606003284454,
0.21025289595127106,
0.12002721428871155,
0.4577080011367798,
-0.6887373328208923,
-0.1342410445213318,
-0.6583479642868042,
-0.1597067266702652,
-0.2477182149887085,
-0.24195902049541473,
-0.37481212615966797,
-0.3837890028953552,
-0.11886843293905258,
-0.4419567584991455,
-0.28339728713035583,
0.08152857422828674,
0.6434435844421387,
0.23027583956718445,
-0.3442460596561432,
-0.210819810628891,
-0.7510544061660767,
0.8501309156417847,
-0.6862456202507019,
0.39069893956184387,
0.631950855255127,
0.17732881009578705,
-0.021033991128206253,
-0.7473821043968201,
-0.6006167531013489,
-0.26062095165252686,
0.08287715911865234,
-0.11188000440597534,
-0.32105347514152527,
0.22719857096672058,
0.38532066345214844,
0.1532575488090515,
-0.3724895715713501,
0.38068318367004395,
-0.36029791831970215,
-0.19399720430374146,
0.8115400671958923,
0.11349225044250488,
0.4443308115005493,
-0.017845790833234787,
-0.28526851534843445,
-0.09995954483747482,
-1.020822286605835,
0.3372192084789276,
0.8096033930778503,
0.19138263165950775,
-0.027140330523252487,
0.5906399488449097,
0.027165349572896957,
0.29553964734077454,
-0.15542957186698914,
-0.03169507533311844,
0.016169531270861626,
-0.20151996612548828,
-0.22832076251506805,
-0.222456157207489,
0.7048131823539734,
0.37033721804618835,
0.36068329215049744,
-0.08580372482538223,
-0.11803048104047775,
0.03577345982193947,
0.49724215269088745,
-0.7356606125831604,
0.04951006919145584,
0.49319911003112793,
-0.5309001803398132,
-0.5069565773010254,
-0.047552432864904404,
-0.9740254282951355,
-0.7627728581428528,
-0.2943156659603119,
0.2642938792705536,
-0.2934923470020294,
-0.23759643733501434,
0.13385926187038422,
0.20697739720344543,
0.3972589075565338,
0.1478775292634964,
-0.6801190376281738,
0.5267699360847473,
0.7822105884552002,
0.5332075953483582,
0.23572294414043427,
-0.13323280215263367,
-0.7020756006240845,
0.4067647159099579,
-0.18154841661453247,
0.20882408320903778,
-0.8150137066841125,
-0.38945120573043823,
0.1951943337917328,
-0.23154474794864655,
0.11464878171682358,
-0.2804378271102905,
0.5420452356338501,
-0.7793776392936707,
0.20989850163459778,
-0.1861511468887329,
-0.4143664538860321,
-0.08012989163398743,
0.4211098253726959,
-0.5340986251831055,
0.7726765871047974,
-0.3618931174278259,
-0.7481192350387573,
-0.11029085516929626,
-0.9708880186080933,
-0.5623159408569336,
0.17452111840248108,
-0.2429332286119461,
-0.4270954132080078,
-0.11817566305398941,
0.3802293837070465,
0.4291786849498749,
-0.3759586215019226,
0.3308866620063782,
-0.3404235541820526,
-0.20548203587532043,
0.27963805198669434,
-0.5439348220825195,
1.043001651763916,
0.2435087412595749,
-0.451951801776886,
0.3649982213973999,
-0.4489416778087616,
-0.0634976401925087,
0.2489878386259079,
-0.06487864255905151,
-0.46996980905532837,
0.0415286161005497,
-0.014733501709997654,
0.09241273999214172,
0.38790443539619446,
-0.4901490807533264,
-0.23861639201641083,
-0.3773563802242279,
0.7424323558807373,
1.0551271438598633,
-0.033451370894908905,
0.45871680974960327,
-0.4749103784561157,
0.5042093992233276,
-0.1279732584953308,
0.6449978351593018,
-0.08824946731328964,
-0.4557393491268158,
-0.3964742422103882,
-0.20608989894390106,
0.10197093337774277,
1.0127512216567993,
-0.5205069184303284,
0.5800163149833679,
0.0069648935459554195,
-0.3665716350078583,
-0.811689555644989,
0.15410730242729187,
0.2483118772506714,
0.33920910954475403,
0.4288319945335388,
0.07676488906145096,
-0.18956796824932098,
-0.9583994746208191,
-0.36609601974487305,
-0.39836034178733826,
-0.13447067141532898,
0.4381130337715149,
0.4643428921699524,
-0.18342363834381104,
0.7160549759864807,
-0.23040811717510223,
-0.16948409378528595,
-0.08703969419002533,
-0.12860046327114105,
-0.14226603507995605,
0.7440013885498047,
0.26609858870506287,
-1.2276753187179565,
-0.02111326903104782,
-0.09709189832210541,
-0.7521981000900269,
0.011983806267380714,
-0.08247439563274384,
-0.11672886461019516,
-0.07409833371639252,
0.5527552366256714,
-0.6645607948303223,
0.5157061815261841,
0.23903635144233704,
-0.2695278823375702,
0.3037572503089905,
-0.10530059784650803,
0.13372135162353516,
-1.1080889701843262,
0.2254520207643509,
-0.10965083539485931,
-0.18452401459217072,
-0.9922941327095032,
0.5991183519363403,
-0.13596992194652557,
-0.023425748571753502,
-0.48901230096817017,
0.47111034393310547,
-0.19524617493152618,
0.2364499717950821,
-0.17365773022174835,
-0.1293322741985321,
0.03735242038965225,
0.16595128178596497,
-0.2506744861602783,
0.6362996101379395,
0.6139594316482544,
-0.4154874384403229,
0.4588383138179779,
0.32073578238487244,
0.011998997069895267,
0.6007775664329529,
-0.8314645886421204,
0.47425729036331177,
-0.20529374480247498,
0.15068812668323517,
-0.5362057685852051,
-0.13350361585617065,
0.3965495526790619,
-0.49599048495292664,
0.06405211985111237,
-0.0033807754516601562,
-0.5929133892059326,
-0.054871566593647,
-0.769656240940094,
0.6064715385437012,
0.5132510662078857,
-0.21182362735271454,
0.942806601524353,
0.6547499895095825,
-0.3744744658470154,
-0.8850141167640686,
-0.6602820754051208,
0.45992913842201233,
-0.6456117033958435,
-0.6144203543663025,
0.38569530844688416,
-0.21723924577236176,
-0.6540887355804443,
-0.12432056665420532,
0.17423586547374725,
-0.028688902035355568,
0.5898725986480713,
0.1957603245973587,
0.34299102425575256,
0.06922218203544617,
-0.14402297139167786,
0.040503088384866714,
0.11627578735351562,
0.3183557093143463,
-0.04075809195637703,
0.5210631489753723,
-0.25207361578941345,
-0.370617538690567,
-0.34445223212242126,
0.676141619682312,
0.5428808927536011,
-0.6626753211021423,
0.7959935069084167,
0.5758833885192871,
-0.686134397983551,
0.11358517408370972,
-0.7469603419303894,
-0.48122379183769226,
-0.5226292610168457,
0.17858341336250305,
-0.10153106600046158,
-1.2717434167861938,
0.6778486371040344,
0.11544211953878403,
0.4650484621524811,
0.19701701402664185,
0.6922940611839294,
0.019848281517624855,
0.9404308795928955,
0.8010236024856567,
-0.1806396096944809,
0.3522515892982483,
0.18719126284122467,
0.5472739338874817,
-0.9124644994735718,
-0.30029556155204773,
-0.5203585028648376,
-0.03532252833247185,
-0.9075235724449158,
-0.26083314418792725,
0.4024573266506195,
0.036776479333639145,
-0.4364996552467346,
0.06143239513039589,
-0.37386554479599,
0.600264847278595,
0.6191612482070923,
0.21520331501960754,
0.3521987795829773,
-0.19222018122673035,
0.12512032687664032,
0.2605910897254944,
-0.2979792356491089,
-0.8362754583358765,
1.1241792440414429,
0.6402264833450317,
0.770571768283844,
0.36949267983436584,
0.6720700860023499,
0.48551350831985474,
0.14491912722587585,
-0.27341556549072266,
0.6175671815872192,
0.008418286219239235,
-0.720145046710968,
-0.46418634057044983,
-0.40585336089134216,
-0.8749682307243347,
0.22602254152297974,
-0.1543198823928833,
-1.0888499021530151,
0.07407477498054504,
-0.15597060322761536,
-0.6795924305915833,
0.34718164801597595,
-0.3991841673851013,
0.5695205330848694,
-0.3473159670829773,
-0.7096965909004211,
-0.2581392824649811,
-0.9280489087104797,
0.3670896589756012,
-0.08158750087022781,
0.2664303183555603,
-0.12358701974153519,
-0.14736883342266083,
0.5825787782669067,
-0.07302994281053543,
1.0259699821472168,
-0.10279637575149536,
-0.18491770327091217,
0.1804928332567215,
0.07643786817789078,
0.6441499590873718,
0.3911280930042267,
-0.07814439386129379,
0.21198871731758118,
0.020727578550577164,
-0.30137428641319275,
-0.27273836731910706,
0.6060711741447449,
-0.6993579268455505,
-1.054011583328247,
-0.20646022260189056,
-0.6729335188865662,
-0.31387409567832947,
0.33394408226013184,
0.005853018723428249,
0.06680184602737427,
-0.10903213173151016,
0.2698685824871063,
0.8019410967826843,
-0.43343180418014526,
0.26257482171058655,
0.14428208768367767,
0.08790472894906998,
-0.2564098536968231,
0.5614646673202515,
-0.21686036884784698,
0.10281796753406525,
0.1245979592204094,
0.24075214564800262,
-0.46545469760894775,
-0.5646306276321411,
-0.3663213849067688,
0.10099424421787262,
-0.6826164722442627,
-0.38082385063171387,
-0.7166057825088501,
-0.4454711675643921,
-0.6859493255615234,
-0.1187451109290123,
0.02097664773464203,
-0.10712244361639023,
-0.19407488405704498,
-0.18777696788311005,
0.43296077847480774,
0.6127369999885559,
0.02350502833724022,
0.17800314724445343,
-0.7362119555473328,
0.2608889937400818,
0.22759182751178741,
0.20181743800640106,
-0.08776401728391647,
-0.32132911682128906,
0.24263690412044525,
0.06627409905195236,
-0.1716758906841278,
-0.7292502522468567,
0.0409068763256073,
-0.11272376030683517,
0.6200743913650513,
0.10590000450611115,
0.19884011149406433,
0.43380650877952576,
-0.5669727325439453,
0.7230255007743835,
-0.05780084803700447,
-1.0815030336380005,
0.39920756220817566,
-0.44704920053482056,
-0.1738903820514679,
0.5127492547035217,
0.2822250723838806,
-0.5258674025535583,
-0.4766191840171814,
-0.6275092363357544,
-1.0467309951782227,
0.3397368788719177,
0.5265616178512573,
0.4414065182209015,
0.2916523218154907,
0.33307620882987976,
-0.07880479097366333,
0.43418997526168823,
-0.9059115648269653,
0.042624711990356445,
-0.02825266681611538,
-0.2240479290485382,
0.30956605076789856,
-0.06961904466152191,
-0.500592827796936,
-0.046735361218452454,
0.5587340593338013,
-0.05078107491135597,
0.05513106659054756,
0.0023106762673705816,
0.06476978957653046,
0.14036838710308075,
0.4771232604980469,
0.45500487089157104,
0.5563682317733765,
0.2291477918624878,
0.11856970191001892,
0.18773643672466278,
-0.3775792717933655,
0.11774314939975739,
0.3984830379486084,
-0.23765963315963745,
-0.7095280885696411,
0.296811580657959,
0.2820252478122711,
-0.39390426874160767,
-0.6378574371337891,
0.4526408910751343,
-0.0025214538909494877,
0.08963911235332489,
-0.28511765599250793,
0.03904315084218979,
-0.048301730304956436,
0.43072864413261414,
0.3410230576992035,
-0.17142504453659058,
0.15701788663864136,
-0.42807555198669434,
0.26969805359840393,
0.5830075740814209,
0.03594087436795235,
-0.08199211210012436,
0.7422717213630676,
0.23594869673252106,
-0.3262192904949188,
0.5145961046218872,
0.11675769835710526,
-0.5719645619392395,
0.6529019474983215,
0.3789644241333008,
0.7752606272697449,
-0.5233120918273926,
0.11257336288690567,
-0.16283543407917023,
0.786719024181366,
-0.04899197444319725,
0.3514883518218994,
-0.08677797764539719,
-0.8453794121742249,
-0.2744910418987274,
-0.3630469739437103,
-0.42285656929016113,
0.4079039394855499,
-0.6068590879440308,
-0.16244927048683167,
-0.6744211912155151,
-0.19962969422340393,
-0.13141703605651855,
-0.04969923943281174,
-0.5132426023483276,
-0.052769336849451065,
0.2642703652381897,
0.6775232553482056,
-0.6159836649894714,
0.6081061363220215,
0.43503379821777344,
-0.27450031042099,
-0.36025604605674744,
0.03867057338356972,
0.11050935089588165,
-0.8267871141433716,
0.2625734210014343,
0.22455069422721863,
-0.2798703610897064,
-0.1729181706905365,
-0.6680258512496948,
-0.41856446862220764,
0.8225778937339783,
0.28497982025146484,
-0.4670383930206299,
-0.05233009532094002,
0.5787901282310486,
0.5261344313621521,
-0.30354031920433044,
-0.08052761107683182,
0.6645212769508362,
0.5770518183708191,
-0.31678974628448486,
-0.6585949659347534,
0.28028133511543274,
-0.32902511954307556,
-0.025912990793585777,
0.09943520277738571,
-0.5384644269943237,
0.7590106725692749,
-0.14210326969623566,
-0.0663941279053688,
0.1106865257024765,
0.43476060032844543,
0.3092862069606781,
0.2515653073787689,
0.5529635548591614,
0.2912728190422058,
0.9615065455436707,
0.06172272190451622,
0.852854311466217,
-0.3372986316680908,
-0.009642609395086765,
0.671879231929779,
-0.7625704407691956,
0.700164258480072,
0.42671552300453186,
0.0828380435705185,
0.1580040156841278,
0.5305586457252502,
-0.20148654282093048,
0.22118313610553741,
0.42359575629234314,
-0.4157330095767975,
-0.2651674151420593,
-0.5669291615486145,
-0.252694308757782,
0.4873688519001007,
0.43891558051109314,
-0.2739875316619873,
-0.01697351038455963,
0.03028794936835766,
0.22315870225429535,
0.23822017014026642,
-0.20809251070022583,
0.6849632263183594,
0.13282069563865662,
-0.3378047049045563,
-0.00038047772250138223,
0.34101220965385437,
0.6717756986618042,
-0.5429131388664246,
0.013711134903132915,
-0.07414152473211288,
0.07812375575304031,
-0.08678127825260162,
-0.8317570686340332,
0.31959640979766846,
0.4459786117076874,
0.06710032373666763,
-0.3266085088253021,
0.7964533567428589,
-0.3058066964149475,
-0.4488682448863983,
0.38039630651474,
0.5983768105506897,
-0.1851191520690918,
-0.06822197884321213,
-0.9939774870872498,
0.18642638623714447,
-0.27898526191711426,
-0.3165678381919861,
0.2794561982154846,
0.012804965488612652,
-0.3196122944355011,
0.7852864861488342,
1.034327507019043,
0.04160672798752785,
-0.07151924073696136,
0.1722361296415329,
0.8697550892829895,
-0.3724783957004547,
-0.6786599159240723,
-1.283262014389038,
0.3785438537597656,
-0.3904135525226593,
-0.11775325238704681,
0.6735479235649109,
0.40258052945137024,
0.6937500834465027,
0.5236383676528931,
0.8020175099372864,
0.001858934061601758,
0.16942763328552246,
-0.5390424132347107,
0.8350468873977661,
-0.26214471459388733,
0.4727631211280823,
-0.16067591309547424,
-0.6655316352844238,
-0.4441048800945282,
0.37031736969947815,
-0.3258415460586548,
0.24885159730911255,
0.157703697681427,
0.8761519193649292,
0.20572303235530853,
0.06777700036764145,
0.2958487868309021,
0.04389510676264763,
0.7427574396133423,
0.4544278085231781,
0.9627484083175659,
-0.2886550724506378,
0.5075945854187012,
-0.1334322690963745,
-0.22249235212802887,
0.19967377185821533,
-0.7942400574684143,
-0.9958239793777466,
-0.3505137860774994,
-0.003697372507303953,
-0.34369686245918274,
0.20437605679035187,
0.8272890448570251,
0.6365522742271423,
-0.6733164191246033,
-0.3366668224334717,
0.2252722680568695,
0.11880163103342056,
-0.08000635355710983,
-0.21794743835926056,
0.20749984681606293,
0.01827840320765972,
-0.5198606848716736,
0.413483202457428,
0.32090768218040466,
-0.0277057196944952,
-0.489380419254303,
0.08712996542453766,
-0.21853984892368317,
0.3916468322277069,
0.5035912394523621,
0.135242760181427,
-0.7451052665710449,
-0.31283485889434814,
0.12769101560115814,
-0.05876752361655235,
-0.07367359846830368,
0.6954012513160706,
-0.3679168224334717,
0.06541735678911209,
0.2534189522266388,
1.2348856925964355,
-0.1443251073360443,
0.2317350059747696,
0.5346704721450806,
-0.5056772232055664,
-0.13840751349925995,
0.6741595268249512,
0.24930007755756378,
0.3751528561115265,
-0.8740102052688599,
0.4098919928073883,
-0.09729526937007904,
-0.5754380226135254,
-0.9948279857635498,
0.49200186133384705,
-0.571931779384613,
-0.3668685555458069,
1.0158360004425049,
-0.1010526716709137,
-0.22767993807792664,
-0.3030191957950592,
0.04138925299048424,
0.06995827704668045,
-0.36734631657600403,
0.9451857805252075,
0.6431349515914917,
0.05071720480918884,
-0.11924710869789124,
-0.6643116474151611,
0.5417662858963013,
0.31520819664001465,
-1.1588730812072754,
0.5168956518173218,
0.3569272756576538,
0.08524774014949799,
0.13816022872924805,
0.33644405007362366,
-0.4501434564590454,
0.17934353649616241,
-0.4449140429496765,
-0.252366304397583,
-0.21133939921855927,
-0.46626466512680054,
-0.418199360370636,
0.20904332399368286,
-0.15827181935310364,
-0.0439467616379261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15328v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15328v2 | Equipping Language Models with Tool Use Capability for Tabular Data Analysis in Finance | 2024-01-27T07:08:37 | 2024-01-30T06:08:33 | Adrian Theuma, Ehsan Shareghi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited an array of reasoning
capabilities but face challenges like error propagation and hallucination,
particularly in specialised areas like finance, where data is heterogeneous,
and precision is paramount. We explore the potential of language model
augmentation with external tools to mitigate these limitations and offload
certain reasoning steps to external tools that are more suited for the task,
instead of solely depending on the LLM's inherent abilities. More concretely,
using financial domain question-answering datasets, we apply supervised
fine-tuning on a LLaMA-2 13B Chat model to act both as a 'task router' and
'task solver'. The 'task router' dynamically directs a question to either be
answered internally by the LLM or externally via the right tool from the tool
set. Our tool-equipped SFT model, Raven, demonstrates an improvement of 35.2%
and 5.06% over the base model and SFT-only baselines, respectively, and is
highly competitive with strong GPT-3.5 results. To the best of our knowledge,
our work is the first that investigates tool augmentation of language models
for the finance domain. | [
-0.014008662663400173,
-1.2257041931152344,
0.2941439747810364,
0.1803145706653595,
-0.04316644370555878,
0.24732357263565063,
-0.13686330616474152,
-0.655411422252655,
-0.07115143537521362,
0.8688580989837646,
-0.5199509263038635,
-0.36697229743003845,
-0.40606820583343506,
-0.1842224895954132,
-0.5821054577827454,
1.0806766748428345,
0.04931327700614929,
-0.0023511184845119715,
-0.29734018445014954,
0.22714048624038696,
-0.5179871916770935,
-0.5286163687705994,
-0.8701106905937195,
-0.224846750497818,
0.3803151249885559,
0.3588579595088959,
0.9555437564849854,
0.5392603278160095,
1.0021696090698242,
0.37256449460983276,
0.1226654201745987,
0.09906378388404846,
-0.4217548966407776,
-0.0021725816186517477,
-0.1666250377893448,
-0.5070627331733704,
-0.9368698000907898,
-0.0932469442486763,
0.28940609097480774,
0.9134881496429443,
-0.3933242857456207,
0.2125929594039917,
0.007928815670311451,
0.47425931692123413,
-0.21778909862041473,
0.5933037400245667,
-0.8986536860466003,
-0.25537797808647156,
-0.2336404174566269,
-0.16796815395355225,
-0.2748487889766693,
-0.2526303827762604,
0.21873338520526886,
-0.7151209115982056,
-0.002582980552688241,
0.2777058780193329,
0.7689211964607239,
0.46529585123062134,
-0.3494719862937927,
-0.2590513527393341,
-0.5960222482681274,
0.4422716498374939,
-0.7825820446014404,
0.47167545557022095,
0.5723161697387695,
0.380073219537735,
-0.06046763062477112,
-0.8408790230751038,
-0.24100129306316376,
-0.4661415219306946,
-0.20609094202518463,
-0.11293097585439682,
-0.2996487319469452,
0.0784219354391098,
0.44413644075393677,
0.36417803168296814,
-0.3659924566745758,
0.30578064918518066,
-0.6043956279754639,
-0.10861670970916748,
0.593280017375946,
0.3341534733772278,
0.06133144721388817,
0.12977679073810577,
-0.09894692152738571,
-0.19030776619911194,
-0.645179808139801,
0.1625727415084839,
0.509806752204895,
0.686272144317627,
-0.03855229914188385,
0.7771270275115967,
-0.11816505342721939,
0.8259382247924805,
0.030100803822278976,
-0.13495372235774994,
0.022398974746465683,
-0.2305656522512436,
-0.569298505783081,
-0.1747094690799713,
0.29816755652427673,
0.2487485557794571,
0.09264936298131943,
-0.23246443271636963,
-0.26860132813453674,
-0.2466326355934143,
0.3476734459400177,
-0.6223588585853577,
-0.34253227710723877,
0.3236781358718872,
-0.1452031284570694,
-0.13824167847633362,
-0.13701674342155457,
-0.5311007499694824,
-0.5438589453697205,
-0.4256701171398163,
0.38311848044395447,
-0.1791616827249527,
-0.09845788776874542,
0.23766803741455078,
-0.1223636120557785,
0.17312487959861755,
0.412626177072525,
-0.7661946415901184,
0.5077770948410034,
0.9298394918441772,
0.5839030146598816,
-0.030227376148104668,
-0.04506024345755577,
-0.9433016777038574,
0.2507185637950897,
-0.411188542842865,
0.8388348817825317,
-0.6932427883148193,
-0.4619874656200409,
-0.09861983358860016,
-0.021727312356233597,
-0.026988351717591286,
-0.5150795578956604,
0.3743245005607605,
-0.5079327821731567,
0.05446655675768852,
-0.44440916180610657,
-0.5302373170852661,
-0.23502583801746368,
0.250220388174057,
-0.7049789428710938,
1.124691128730774,
0.3030460774898529,
-0.7359429001808167,
0.569657564163208,
-0.9364281892776489,
-0.33298712968826294,
0.1270543932914734,
-0.06474187225103378,
-0.35662373900413513,
-0.1956842541694641,
0.41296643018722534,
0.5315805077552795,
-0.5634433627128601,
0.40711793303489685,
-0.599597692489624,
-0.344026118516922,
0.42394471168518066,
-0.3446474075317383,
0.4854004681110382,
-0.012059572152793407,
-0.12208870053291321,
0.25666698813438416,
-0.625781238079071,
-0.32838138937950134,
0.013769560493528843,
-0.12600085139274597,
-0.3458935618400574,
0.05743100494146347,
0.2571098208427429,
-0.033906757831573486,
0.2812131941318512,
-0.38695481419563293,
0.23672747611999512,
-0.6683317422866821,
0.3435480296611786,
0.7545447945594788,
-0.2761760652065277,
0.20655560493469238,
-0.5744360685348511,
0.6439065337181091,
0.024896962568163872,
-0.13231809437274933,
0.020055221393704414,
-0.33554932475090027,
-0.5889625549316406,
-0.16475388407707214,
0.23044145107269287,
0.7330076098442078,
-0.5071176290512085,
0.0038562570698559284,
-0.09832476079463959,
-0.5860051512718201,
-0.47901979088783264,
0.29470857977867126,
-0.010765732266008854,
0.523017406463623,
0.24399815499782562,
0.019342532381415367,
-0.425027459859848,
-1.2372368574142456,
-0.20446988940238953,
-0.17427197098731995,
-0.07431309670209885,
0.3379172682762146,
0.28502732515335083,
-0.12991884350776672,
0.9053817391395569,
-0.6200487613677979,
-0.22958841919898987,
-0.568332850933075,
0.028318947181105614,
0.39122509956359863,
0.5250591039657593,
0.5986255407333374,
-0.8986734747886658,
-0.3465512692928314,
0.44067418575286865,
-0.4289160966873169,
-0.2405896633863449,
-0.4236796796321869,
0.0920887142419815,
0.15314024686813354,
0.5608984231948853,
-0.39365148544311523,
0.5046031475067139,
0.2861458361148834,
-0.37044790387153625,
0.29824620485305786,
-0.33392831683158875,
0.03686876595020294,
-0.8627939224243164,
0.20027165114879608,
0.3040367662906647,
-0.29853180050849915,
-0.7153981328010559,
0.031582076102495193,
0.03489189222455025,
-0.10068416595458984,
-0.08994913101196289,
0.8090813159942627,
-0.13769902288913727,
-0.19559237360954285,
-0.3483853042125702,
0.13660727441310883,
0.042485713958740234,
0.5054514408111572,
0.00866012740880251,
1.0126768350601196,
0.4598067104816437,
-0.2870081961154938,
0.44045355916023254,
0.33409953117370605,
-0.32859280705451965,
0.37508732080459595,
-0.8388403058052063,
-0.006602137349545956,
0.11469638347625732,
-0.015376310795545578,
-0.99512779712677,
-0.19115498661994934,
0.13841599225997925,
-0.03217468410730362,
0.20806561410427094,
0.07660076022148132,
-0.47609835863113403,
-0.3529171049594879,
-0.017320752143859863,
0.07018867135047913,
0.16065286099910736,
-0.35219717025756836,
0.6467330455780029,
0.480191171169281,
-0.7152740359306335,
-0.5374120473861694,
-0.7395167946815491,
0.10729732364416122,
-0.46163836121559143,
-0.7558014392852783,
0.29293757677078247,
-0.008980768732726574,
-0.6213675737380981,
-0.2041091024875641,
-0.11580415070056915,
-0.1488153636455536,
0.19122560322284698,
0.19470438361167908,
0.7519000172615051,
-0.18353703618049622,
0.25804001092910767,
0.0459277369081974,
-0.07302059233188629,
0.02792251668870449,
-0.19721229374408722,
0.2710082232952118,
-0.2313164919614792,
-0.667204737663269,
-0.1596759408712387,
0.2196032851934433,
0.38446640968322754,
-0.21063430607318878,
0.8988984823226929,
0.32194364070892334,
-0.34266677498817444,
-0.11763163655996323,
-0.9063674807548523,
-0.09072523564100266,
-0.5816853046417236,
0.446372926235199,
-0.5184229016304016,
-1.0537667274475098,
0.9262645244598389,
0.20462864637374878,
0.2580774426460266,
0.5209991335868835,
0.7583208680152893,
0.09911880642175674,
0.7672690153121948,
0.8147148489952087,
0.004088064190000296,
0.3550277650356293,
-0.22874459624290466,
0.3692728877067566,
-0.6417925953865051,
-0.24427226185798645,
-0.5144743323326111,
-0.22877827286720276,
-0.47271642088890076,
-0.44633638858795166,
0.337843120098114,
-0.07724810391664505,
-0.13517941534519196,
0.39848604798316956,
-0.1402999311685562,
0.38189995288848877,
0.4373646676540375,
0.03320182487368584,
0.36893224716186523,
-0.25834769010543823,
-0.06648977100849152,
0.02209283411502838,
-0.7056194543838501,
-0.41263577342033386,
1.1614711284637451,
0.6042319536209106,
0.9748204946517944,
-0.1171378493309021,
0.05400305986404419,
0.3774353563785553,
0.4318310022354126,
-0.547443151473999,
0.32344645261764526,
-0.23931987583637238,
-0.5983992218971252,
-0.4100186824798584,
-0.5213795304298401,
-0.5140748023986816,
0.11336187273263931,
0.051794324070215225,
-1.0857605934143066,
0.23091046512126923,
0.1425786018371582,
-0.5110995173454285,
0.2808613181114197,
-0.820380449295044,
0.9632338881492615,
-0.15647003054618835,
-0.5891387462615967,
0.11749675124883652,
-0.19549493491649628,
0.5141165256500244,
-0.5268898010253906,
0.31160447001457214,
-0.05188533291220665,
0.0979480966925621,
0.5661590099334717,
-0.515475869178772,
0.9411358833312988,
-0.0284076239913702,
-0.597932755947113,
0.24138018488883972,
0.08701019734144211,
0.8974962830543518,
0.13303335011005402,
-0.33899998664855957,
-0.19703753292560577,
0.39868417382240295,
-0.2634141445159912,
-0.6805385947227478,
0.578130841255188,
-0.35634371638298035,
-0.9265342354774475,
-0.05007069930434227,
-1.0763903856277466,
-0.5705425143241882,
-0.31176862120628357,
-0.3939649760723114,
0.4841659367084503,
0.042904507368803024,
0.4463966488838196,
0.03086087852716446,
-0.1172720342874527,
0.23599673807621002,
0.47526341676712036,
-0.4319659471511841,
-0.0032220236025750637,
0.7926704287528992,
0.14972200989723206,
0.2940981388092041,
0.2174651324748993,
0.14412617683410645,
-0.6008957624435425,
-0.5028249025344849,
-0.16778263449668884,
0.015616041608154774,
-0.8078985214233398,
-0.2893521189689636,
-0.4805173873901367,
-0.14068053662776947,
-0.4892638623714447,
-0.22101137042045593,
-0.23382550477981567,
-0.5667561888694763,
-0.1254020631313324,
-0.4642763137817383,
0.7208098769187927,
0.5273599028587341,
-0.13539211452007294,
0.5291383862495422,
-0.865558922290802,
0.2570101022720337,
0.3845042586326599,
0.4771912693977356,
-0.08253614604473114,
-0.5053519606590271,
-0.44966113567352295,
0.19692020118236542,
-0.07504738867282867,
-0.6765652894973755,
0.5048883557319641,
-0.05188317969441414,
0.5785735249519348,
0.2965397238731384,
-0.1069478988647461,
1.0025537014007568,
-0.0035779511090368032,
0.4028222858905792,
-0.2654620110988617,
-0.8877080082893372,
0.3337462246417999,
-0.6600778102874756,
0.10862773656845093,
0.5246089696884155,
0.13356631994247437,
-0.5452680587768555,
-0.7200285196304321,
-0.4702816307544708,
-0.7405664920806885,
0.8288604021072388,
0.21840699017047882,
0.013783683069050312,
0.1576933115720749,
0.42072293162345886,
0.29266321659088135,
0.3682956099510193,
-0.7783215641975403,
0.2387561798095703,
-0.04477817565202713,
-0.08165940642356873,
0.016429420560598373,
0.08421532809734344,
0.11675074696540833,
-0.4768041968345642,
0.8280705809593201,
-0.29531610012054443,
-0.22198374569416046,
-0.050584577023983,
0.038510046899318695,
-0.13986951112747192,
0.2451823353767395,
0.17484304308891296,
0.9411258697509766,
-0.2841680943965912,
-0.32192984223365784,
0.4242181181907654,
-0.26374927163124084,
-0.3030162453651428,
0.5046652555465698,
0.15720894932746887,
-0.44503387808799744,
0.2464333027601242,
0.7943567633628845,
0.24696269631385803,
-1.0513461828231812,
0.21912436187267303,
0.058184340596199036,
-0.2124543935060501,
-0.08371222019195557,
0.1702859103679657,
0.25678884983062744,
0.6126896142959595,
0.48685845732688904,
-0.20379239320755005,
0.23342867195606232,
-0.543117880821228,
0.26208359003067017,
0.6655387282371521,
-0.4284021854400635,
-0.021978380158543587,
0.7367636561393738,
0.047774508595466614,
-0.21615543961524963,
0.5634298920631409,
0.00905944500118494,
-0.4021787643432617,
0.7417698502540588,
0.6031996607780457,
0.6199867725372314,
0.16923248767852783,
0.13698510825634003,
-0.06325193494558334,
0.46408316493034363,
0.002124406863003969,
0.3114161491394043,
0.09304678440093994,
-0.6384522914886475,
-0.7128629684448242,
-0.7403097748756409,
-0.6734715700149536,
0.29345718026161194,
-0.6161877512931824,
0.18293946981430054,
-0.2009269893169403,
-0.12955133616924286,
0.25934210419654846,
0.06631731241941452,
-0.7414304614067078,
0.11348428577184677,
-0.12084853649139404,
0.9341290593147278,
-0.5314121246337891,
0.9049996137619019,
0.5666545629501343,
-0.38002994656562805,
-0.7876805663108826,
-0.36323392391204834,
-0.03467799723148346,
-0.8001124858856201,
0.7402225732803345,
-0.05324957147240639,
-0.04399896785616875,
-0.046352583914995193,
-0.34559300541877747,
-0.6503605842590332,
0.8314650058746338,
0.39807426929473877,
-0.7425390481948853,
-0.11944982409477234,
0.4199087619781494,
0.40937548875808716,
-0.389875590801239,
0.14088663458824158,
0.8591826558113098,
0.6093097925186157,
0.41728559136390686,
-1.2512046098709106,
-0.20870165526866913,
-0.3723607361316681,
-0.25588133931159973,
0.3132195472717285,
-0.28022852540016174,
0.8409942984580994,
-0.1435018628835678,
0.1133958250284195,
-0.08603730797767639,
0.5550918579101562,
0.13550019264221191,
0.28089195489883423,
0.3919207453727722,
0.2978334426879883,
0.8392887115478516,
-0.09193389117717743,
0.9867095351219177,
-0.268677681684494,
0.1977182775735855,
1.3523659706115723,
-0.5699234008789062,
0.9006732106208801,
0.46177777647972107,
-0.3394942283630371,
0.23602451384067535,
0.6203936338424683,
-0.1474379152059555,
0.0601896233856678,
0.28093263506889343,
0.19202378392219543,
-0.46372202038764954,
-0.10365276038646698,
-0.2148691564798355,
0.5992316603660583,
0.49896761775016785,
-0.03219613432884216,
-0.12736710906028748,
0.07343751937150955,
-0.17755404114723206,
0.01750156842172146,
-0.20578186213970184,
0.8056913018226624,
0.09739821404218674,
-0.3528617024421692,
0.019870033487677574,
0.06917199492454529,
0.35740262269973755,
-0.7527216076850891,
0.06001938879489899,
-0.21222659945487976,
0.2013271003961563,
0.10959602147340775,
-0.647135853767395,
0.7324013710021973,
0.17216837406158447,
0.1962447166442871,
-0.25298064947128296,
0.7716864943504333,
-0.36413341760635376,
-1.0759724378585815,
0.21456414461135864,
0.783443033695221,
-0.1486736387014389,
-0.2322463095188141,
-0.5219789743423462,
-0.2328224778175354,
-0.17781996726989746,
-0.2347179800271988,
0.21265654265880585,
0.38073527812957764,
-0.0991925373673439,
1.0061061382293701,
0.9030388593673706,
0.060745105147361755,
-0.17795638740062714,
0.14668680727481842,
1.0836520195007324,
-0.6548735499382019,
-0.6180229783058167,
-0.8620237112045288,
0.5106848478317261,
-0.0904209315776825,
-0.11795232445001602,
0.6275846362113953,
0.712441623210907,
0.580650806427002,
0.11887484043836594,
0.6075344681739807,
0.27398017048835754,
0.6319432258605957,
-0.6167383790016174,
0.5986865162849426,
-0.7155043482780457,
0.7536706924438477,
-0.46063700318336487,
-0.7604249119758606,
-0.2591681182384491,
0.5482428669929504,
-0.7686740756034851,
-0.13380850851535797,
0.43000277876853943,
0.9500053524971008,
-0.2709273099899292,
0.3547326326370239,
0.3355303406715393,
0.13909992575645447,
0.26152560114860535,
0.18010902404785156,
0.6952332258224487,
-0.1265551894903183,
0.5893763899803162,
-0.2470846325159073,
0.07456985861063004,
-0.1671118587255478,
-0.8743059039115906,
-1.0429733991622925,
-0.5810431241989136,
-0.4026259183883667,
0.01992562599480152,
-0.04492366686463356,
1.0053057670593262,
0.42985472083091736,
-0.6657364368438721,
-0.578253984451294,
0.16610771417617798,
0.012910373508930206,
-0.05837615579366684,
-0.21746490895748138,
0.3858376741409302,
-0.424081027507782,
-0.5372042059898376,
0.4787253141403198,
0.4682779610157013,
0.17914198338985443,
-0.38258036971092224,
0.21910080313682556,
-0.020320480689406395,
0.25642845034599304,
0.4670453667640686,
-0.10310567170381546,
-0.6338819265365601,
-0.3005913496017456,
0.2957426905632019,
0.1842212677001953,
0.09772849082946777,
0.8486461639404297,
-0.5500013828277588,
0.16036707162857056,
0.2522270977497101,
0.8571218252182007,
0.5545331835746765,
0.21965599060058594,
0.8198572397232056,
-0.5852494239807129,
0.20456373691558838,
0.06195254623889923,
0.443666934967041,
0.21613731980323792,
-0.37154263257980347,
0.4705694615840912,
-0.13575005531311035,
-0.39498329162597656,
-0.7899655699729919,
-0.1705750823020935,
-0.8955583572387695,
-0.4025977849960327,
0.8873867392539978,
0.15178874135017395,
-0.17819926142692566,
-0.24589021503925323,
-0.4486311078071594,
0.0011091268388554454,
-0.47474655508995056,
0.7231665849685669,
0.8340288400650024,
0.06218178570270538,
-0.1830988973379135,
-0.9199281334877014,
0.5628946423530579,
0.22830280661582947,
-1.2821599245071411,
0.43359947204589844,
0.422443151473999,
-0.06595072150230408,
-0.051804669201374054,
0.5528913736343384,
0.24049128592014313,
0.2470785677433014,
0.06606744229793549,
-0.4452497661113739,
-0.3703303933143616,
-0.24467313289642334,
0.009587646462023258,
0.3279223144054413,
0.09771992266178131,
0.22083567082881927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01724v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01724v1 | CERM: Context-aware Literature-based Discovery via Sentiment Analysis | 2024-01-27T06:40:08 | 2024-01-27T06:40:08 | Julio Christian Young, Uchenna Akujuobi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Driven by the abundance of biomedical publications, we introduce a sentiment
analysis task to understand food-health relationship. Prior attempts to
incorporate health into recipe recommendation and analysis systems have
primarily focused on ingredient nutritional components or utilized basic
computational models trained on curated labeled data. Enhanced models that
capture the inherent relationship between food ingredients and biomedical
concepts can be more beneficial for food-related research, given the wealth of
information in biomedical texts. Considering the costly data labeling process,
these models should effectively utilize both labeled and unlabeled data. This
paper introduces Entity Relationship Sentiment Analysis (ERSA), a new task that
captures the sentiment of a text based on an entity pair. ERSA extends the
widely studied Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) task. Specifically, our
study concentrates on the ERSA task applied to biomedical texts, focusing on
(entity-entity) pairs of biomedical and food concepts. ERSA poses a significant
challenge compared to traditional sentiment analysis tasks, as sentence
sentiment may not align with entity relationship sentiment. Additionally, we
propose CERM, a semi-supervised architecture that combines different word
embeddings to enhance the encoding of the ERSA task. Experimental results
showcase the model's efficiency across diverse learning scenarios. | [
-0.10045729577541351,
-0.9182773232460022,
0.7989680171012878,
-0.15323251485824585,
-0.10085073858499527,
-0.29923689365386963,
-0.031768012791872025,
-0.6020073890686035,
0.6294764876365662,
0.6177923083305359,
-0.2280823439359665,
-0.9710319638252258,
-0.45971426367759705,
0.13427777588367462,
-0.038754288107156754,
1.1216533184051514,
0.04969057813286781,
0.3283347487449646,
-0.6349847316741943,
-0.40340620279312134,
-0.12779659032821655,
-0.570118248462677,
-0.5721135139465332,
-0.20522044599056244,
0.9267107844352722,
0.43737539649009705,
0.5939515233039856,
0.3760982155799866,
0.5518207550048828,
0.17091120779514313,
-0.4390990436077118,
0.31678956747055054,
-0.21040645241737366,
0.45532724261283875,
-0.6745657324790955,
-0.17572344839572906,
-0.6577354073524475,
-0.3748318552970886,
0.13423195481300354,
1.0034215450286865,
-0.0588531568646431,
0.282427042722702,
0.20739971101284027,
0.9780758023262024,
-0.6273177266120911,
0.10291917622089386,
-0.2836063802242279,
0.14165212213993073,
-0.22907814383506775,
-0.04127601161599159,
-0.2751970589160919,
-0.12773162126541138,
0.3563782572746277,
-0.6567692160606384,
0.04714907705783844,
0.283409982919693,
0.8126619458198547,
0.19627048075199127,
-0.6746134757995605,
-0.5237354040145874,
-0.64818274974823,
0.8011422753334045,
-0.5185569524765015,
0.6053416132926941,
0.10588300228118896,
-0.26990312337875366,
-0.3441426157951355,
-0.6070318222045898,
-0.388733834028244,
0.0858459547162056,
-0.05761006474494934,
0.14395305514335632,
-0.03481253981590271,
0.02838674746453762,
-0.1462969332933426,
0.40574711561203003,
-0.33863040804862976,
-0.31895124912261963,
-0.03637257218360901,
0.025647077709436417,
0.32537326216697693,
0.1481025516986847,
0.6147396564483643,
-0.4837464988231659,
-0.5565504431724548,
-0.03591476380825043,
-0.7012022733688354,
0.18467731773853302,
-0.2798585295677185,
0.24065643548965454,
0.01984339952468872,
0.7374868988990784,
0.051654353737831116,
0.5139355063438416,
-0.38178572058677673,
-0.01568417437374592,
0.41764941811561584,
-0.3398303985595703,
-0.3288792371749878,
0.3897886872291565,
0.6742458343505859,
0.6506004929542542,
-0.4166881740093231,
-0.08817901462316513,
-0.03367936611175537,
0.17722965776920319,
0.09137780219316483,
-0.6923892498016357,
-0.26282772421836853,
0.15693019330501556,
-0.6503394246101379,
-0.24794860184192657,
0.26726579666137695,
-1.0166760683059692,
-0.423165500164032,
-0.1992795467376709,
0.056409165263175964,
-0.4250471591949463,
-0.16626682877540588,
-0.05139342322945595,
-0.3043985664844513,
0.1958833634853363,
-0.09759283065795898,
-0.5016076564788818,
0.33377233147621155,
0.5259703397750854,
0.7509108185768127,
-0.04039350897073746,
0.29317620396614075,
-0.3963666558265686,
0.5533962249755859,
-0.04502357169985771,
1.0122973918914795,
-0.9070799350738525,
-0.7833206057548523,
-0.2542175352573395,
0.33556047081947327,
0.009275482967495918,
-0.4820966422557831,
0.9576435089111328,
-0.41073787212371826,
-0.18295548856258392,
-0.983314037322998,
-0.787627637386322,
-0.30840712785720825,
0.26015496253967285,
-0.5995506048202515,
1.0870281457901,
0.10418269783258438,
-1.167909026145935,
0.34261998534202576,
-0.671638011932373,
-0.7763705849647522,
-0.03585463762283325,
-0.38732123374938965,
-0.4233151078224182,
0.18291711807250977,
0.3052718937397003,
0.4451884925365448,
-0.4296836256980896,
0.27312594652175903,
-0.8409057259559631,
0.17812006175518036,
0.27031636238098145,
0.13023440539836884,
0.22094887495040894,
0.35184407234191895,
-0.11895155906677246,
-0.13882113993167877,
-0.3826698064804077,
-0.06820866465568542,
0.1054583489894867,
-0.18883249163627625,
-1.1513818502426147,
0.353399395942688,
-0.03318583965301514,
-0.1865670084953308,
0.31562429666519165,
-0.5456214547157288,
-0.1501135528087616,
-0.58506840467453,
0.24210521578788757,
0.35583823919296265,
0.5430846810340881,
0.7399821877479553,
-0.253377765417099,
0.20819196105003357,
0.23122501373291016,
-0.014340031892061234,
-0.2933471202850342,
-0.44214296340942383,
-0.4825856685638428,
-0.19164444506168365,
0.44681376218795776,
0.508495032787323,
-0.4601319134235382,
0.5951732993125916,
-0.12442659586668015,
-0.3596247136592865,
-0.43024393916130066,
0.011099676601588726,
0.3144441246986389,
0.9276655316352844,
0.6309667825698853,
-0.31991326808929443,
-0.5536792874336243,
-1.0315394401550293,
-0.38672885298728943,
0.02626940794289112,
0.04228196665644646,
0.374390184879303,
0.21150721609592438,
-0.2387927770614624,
0.808314323425293,
-0.6235074996948242,
-0.48274359107017517,
-0.14692683517932892,
-0.032493188977241516,
0.100291408598423,
0.37000587582588196,
0.47653135657310486,
-0.7929338216781616,
-0.2684960663318634,
0.33304402232170105,
-1.1091960668563843,
0.0818893238902092,
0.4887363910675049,
-0.22061581909656525,
-0.07327061891555786,
0.37624889612197876,
-0.057190850377082825,
0.3763933777809143,
0.43332117795944214,
-0.46195653080940247,
-0.16612429916858673,
-0.0547666996717453,
0.24759244918823242,
-1.3032722473144531,
0.12522031366825104,
0.45538774132728577,
0.015758322551846504,
-0.40594327449798584,
-0.007932591252028942,
0.026861034333705902,
-0.01056123897433281,
-0.5652177929878235,
0.5964989066123962,
-0.5776264667510986,
-0.04500248283147812,
-0.16593068838119507,
-0.11209132522344589,
0.2899315059185028,
0.131251722574234,
0.24703827500343323,
0.20691825449466705,
0.5545088648796082,
-0.7351757287979126,
-0.11427942663431168,
0.12615308165550232,
-0.06384237110614777,
0.8686206340789795,
-0.6355283260345459,
0.009483034722507,
-0.16826727986335754,
0.26370739936828613,
-0.571846067905426,
-0.17139528691768646,
0.34713056683540344,
-0.43058761954307556,
0.19627107679843903,
0.09876218438148499,
-0.32885488867759705,
-0.2154061198234558,
-0.29905271530151367,
0.302180677652359,
0.10274612903594971,
-0.34615960717201233,
0.9081587791442871,
0.9869818091392517,
-0.1921822875738144,
-0.3408880829811096,
-0.5161431431770325,
-0.06868436187505722,
-0.17244261503219604,
-0.5205743312835693,
0.6090602278709412,
0.19866888225078583,
-0.40037858486175537,
0.5136894583702087,
-0.4429529011249542,
0.16227596998214722,
0.06356076896190643,
0.5722230672836304,
0.29675349593162537,
-0.09333091229200363,
0.27460727095603943,
0.5249788165092468,
0.20599016547203064,
0.2933819890022278,
-0.24269355833530426,
0.050481993705034256,
-0.17885230481624603,
-0.01713518612086773,
-0.21279418468475342,
0.5791568756103516,
0.4361581802368164,
-0.05336828902363777,
0.8211503028869629,
0.44890275597572327,
-0.7042441964149475,
0.015037991106510162,
-0.12951913475990295,
-0.030335919931530952,
-0.3793334364891052,
0.22433823347091675,
-0.25878775119781494,
-0.5017949938774109,
0.3705134391784668,
-0.1761375218629837,
0.00425774697214365,
0.6198815107345581,
0.35848626494407654,
-0.39535966515541077,
0.8353462815284729,
0.627650260925293,
-0.14387038350105286,
0.16891540586948395,
-0.02077396772801876,
0.14475694298744202,
-1.0793142318725586,
-0.7955119013786316,
-0.6427462697029114,
-0.29859644174575806,
-0.2536962330341339,
-0.4671248495578766,
0.8059293627738953,
-0.16838227212429047,
-0.17065562307834625,
0.12077178806066513,
-0.7963337898254395,
0.3196680247783661,
0.35856929421424866,
0.6105177998542786,
0.30982378125190735,
-0.17792515456676483,
-0.6559655070304871,
-0.008308506570756435,
-0.5556672215461731,
-0.7605604529380798,
0.8528371453285217,
0.36003047227859497,
0.7850871086120605,
-0.06692507863044739,
0.7479006052017212,
0.31362462043762207,
0.37340354919433594,
-0.877027153968811,
0.4434977173805237,
-0.18317751586437225,
-0.6072569489479065,
-0.22074604034423828,
-0.3510749936103821,
-0.7993571758270264,
-0.05795694515109062,
-0.288552850484848,
-0.5596710443496704,
0.33073848485946655,
0.06649988144636154,
-0.3701678216457367,
0.32733237743377686,
-0.5958524346351624,
0.7024426460266113,
-0.35099974274635315,
-0.5771749019622803,
0.20954187214374542,
-0.6653587222099304,
-0.0018054433166980743,
0.24851109087467194,
0.5541046857833862,
-0.13305720686912537,
-0.045325346291065216,
0.9806470274925232,
-0.2835216522216797,
0.7362786531448364,
-0.11335870623588562,
-0.12661167979240417,
0.26832136511802673,
0.14475765824317932,
0.31105682253837585,
0.6372158527374268,
-0.3147684335708618,
-0.05947968363761902,
0.25201356410980225,
-0.39738041162490845,
-0.3725769519805908,
1.2114018201828003,
-0.3868962824344635,
-0.37277793884277344,
-0.6227999925613403,
-0.12073402851819992,
-0.33900636434555054,
0.252969354391098,
0.19141915440559387,
0.1725693941116333,
-0.5520598292350769,
0.019422084093093872,
0.9623450636863708,
-0.30706530809402466,
0.1338755041360855,
0.35126081109046936,
-0.16877184808254242,
-0.36086130142211914,
0.622635543346405,
-0.13943424820899963,
-0.3451528549194336,
0.7169139981269836,
0.057751353830099106,
-0.23585589230060577,
-0.0569402240216732,
-0.18416354060173035,
0.016104931011795998,
-0.5251480340957642,
-0.4257943332195282,
-1.07113516330719,
0.1254187375307083,
-0.3687741160392761,
-0.2936851978302002,
-0.5303888320922852,
0.08902912586927414,
-0.5938106775283813,
-0.12814272940158844,
0.3746205270290375,
0.6437026262283325,
0.023421071469783783,
-0.2836221158504486,
-1.0435328483581543,
0.17928506433963776,
-0.005030388943850994,
0.032944414764642715,
0.11280782520771027,
-0.04782000184059143,
-0.21353623270988464,
0.05365932732820511,
-0.5792262554168701,
-1.4150079488754272,
0.5284185409545898,
0.05725643411278725,
0.42167550325393677,
0.5023046135902405,
0.3066680431365967,
0.16177181899547577,
-0.2499474138021469,
0.708031177520752,
0.3178628981113434,
-0.8267806768417358,
0.6630092263221741,
-0.20026740431785583,
0.034199535846710205,
0.5581314563751221,
0.47492516040802,
-0.5006208419799805,
-0.2694421708583832,
-0.5067394375801086,
-0.9893221259117126,
-0.06397143006324768,
0.05384009703993797,
0.07717276364564896,
-0.4275210201740265,
0.1639104038476944,
0.1412220150232315,
-0.12847425043582916,
-0.3257017135620117,
-0.2547159194946289,
-0.08289700746536255,
-0.41071388125419617,
0.25688865780830383,
-0.2320270836353302,
-0.21551091969013214,
-0.47438105940818787,
0.6950824856758118,
0.033829402178525925,
0.22514018416404724,
0.7200717926025391,
0.09883574396371841,
-0.06830887496471405,
0.6221429705619812,
-0.13651861250400543,
0.23471292853355408,
-0.25722450017929077,
0.29350775480270386,
0.36911842226982117,
-0.1263553649187088,
-0.17235182225704193,
0.10162508487701416,
0.02623830735683441,
0.2064419686794281,
0.11787495762109756,
0.40039077401161194,
0.6603090763092041,
-0.5552926659584045,
0.3528231680393219,
0.048179809004068375,
-0.02270951122045517,
-0.34073036909103394,
-0.0337102934718132,
0.5002713799476624,
0.14721953868865967,
0.33179038763046265,
0.09557195752859116,
0.5764051079750061,
-0.7584086060523987,
0.33379510045051575,
0.36792248487472534,
-0.755578875541687,
-0.5714330673217773,
0.659477949142456,
0.4920554757118225,
0.16302478313446045,
0.3933514356613159,
-0.14251846075057983,
-0.46365123987197876,
0.6710246801376343,
0.4707392156124115,
0.365023136138916,
-0.19744744896888733,
0.415412962436676,
0.27774524688720703,
-0.07284204661846161,
-0.10997164994478226,
0.40308308601379395,
0.0861208438873291,
-0.6886500120162964,
0.05400053411722183,
-0.8219836950302124,
-0.5245728492736816,
-0.18050234019756317,
-0.9657261967658997,
0.5023168921470642,
-0.020449144765734673,
-0.3678147792816162,
0.48137274384498596,
-0.24029146134853363,
-0.9245700240135193,
0.35760533809661865,
0.047265663743019104,
0.6813097596168518,
-0.7968060970306396,
0.7781223058700562,
1.3717097043991089,
-0.28940433263778687,
-0.6862429976463318,
-0.011196336708962917,
0.06942102313041687,
-0.3297123312950134,
0.35795024037361145,
0.022264741361141205,
0.07734107971191406,
-0.3353685140609741,
-0.3830718994140625,
-0.6681225895881653,
1.0169966220855713,
0.10645055025815964,
-0.6190605759620667,
-0.29217055439949036,
-0.30480098724365234,
0.5882875323295593,
-0.7162545323371887,
0.03092484176158905,
0.39744704961776733,
0.5523591637611389,
0.02931717038154602,
-0.4531175494194031,
0.25157687067985535,
-0.16287577152252197,
-0.07056928426027298,
0.31952279806137085,
-0.5246536135673523,
0.5515855550765991,
-0.39687708020210266,
-0.28043365478515625,
-0.14079034328460693,
0.968971848487854,
0.22374193370342255,
1.1914888620376587,
0.34511053562164307,
0.7452253699302673,
0.8861470222473145,
0.12851795554161072,
0.8993176221847534,
-0.2107960730791092,
0.5493432283401489,
1.133034110069275,
-0.7581639885902405,
0.6974795460700989,
0.699634313583374,
-0.15170352160930634,
0.7012654542922974,
1.0066546201705933,
0.16916750371456146,
0.774354875087738,
0.11591272801160812,
-0.3771734833717346,
-0.14282949268817902,
-0.5709843635559082,
-0.5938450694084167,
0.2535325586795807,
0.7366117238998413,
-1.1557022333145142,
-0.1682843267917633,
0.24797724187374115,
0.3063856065273285,
0.3346090316772461,
-0.2951640188694,
0.8171440362930298,
0.4973820149898529,
-0.2997615337371826,
0.013593404553830624,
-0.00008153961243806407,
0.32120612263679504,
-0.040160540491342545,
-0.15855643153190613,
-0.12507343292236328,
-0.10697390884160995,
-0.25935298204421997,
-0.7079517245292664,
0.37438198924064636,
-0.25044628977775574,
-0.4597177803516388,
0.3044750988483429,
0.7865099906921387,
-0.28134018182754517,
-0.688788115978241,
0.5069485306739807,
0.7773929834365845,
-0.07874767482280731,
0.08447659760713577,
-0.5899726748466492,
0.1134239062666893,
-0.07411278784275055,
-0.31837770342826843,
0.23042774200439453,
0.6097686290740967,
0.20716409385204315,
0.15880823135375977,
0.39942800998687744,
0.06222855672240257,
-0.6599614024162292,
-0.2961379289627075,
1.211253046989441,
-0.9352408647537231,
-0.3955191373825073,
-0.7400587797164917,
0.11899489909410477,
-0.24996346235275269,
-0.06546775996685028,
0.47881755232810974,
0.6307336688041687,
0.7707030177116394,
0.011791634373366833,
0.9324297308921814,
-0.29523754119873047,
0.6668502688407898,
-0.5981070399284363,
0.5639368295669556,
-0.6944271326065063,
0.5492210984230042,
-0.24779677391052246,
-0.9381396174430847,
-0.20176228880882263,
0.21161562204360962,
-0.2642793655395508,
-0.18063686788082123,
1.159778356552124,
0.8129702210426331,
-0.13634538650512695,
0.2580025792121887,
0.09087856858968735,
0.016161629930138588,
-0.07027575373649597,
0.5627855658531189,
0.3968193829059601,
-0.10952232778072357,
0.03452668711543083,
-0.18578112125396729,
-0.24321724474430084,
0.004964104387909174,
-0.9047340750694275,
-0.8252584934234619,
-0.5306509733200073,
-0.3132047653198242,
-0.37303733825683594,
0.4005204141139984,
1.0235209465026855,
0.5450454354286194,
-0.789590060710907,
0.33553841710090637,
0.10912571847438812,
0.17519748210906982,
-0.3492714464664459,
-0.2677862346172333,
0.4634019732475281,
-0.2008049041032791,
-0.6426017880439758,
0.40748438239097595,
0.35397085547447205,
-0.12788264453411102,
0.014284566976130009,
0.06253217160701752,
-0.11012192815542221,
0.31833532452583313,
0.5937222242355347,
0.44237783551216125,
-0.38713571429252625,
0.036539170891046524,
0.15105009078979492,
-0.13364413380622864,
-0.0402112640440464,
0.8437181115150452,
-0.6842194199562073,
0.46997931599617004,
0.22589978575706482,
0.6990581750869751,
0.10393065959215164,
-0.012236199341714382,
0.4973790645599365,
-0.5268333554267883,
-0.34396734833717346,
0.2163170427083969,
0.5718629956245422,
0.5572925806045532,
-0.8014253377914429,
0.5508302450180054,
0.13387787342071533,
-0.5814784169197083,
-0.6289117336273193,
-0.10084224492311478,
-1.2852054834365845,
-0.3774520456790924,
1.2924532890319824,
-0.23074454069137573,
-0.7680522203445435,
-0.024877341464161873,
-0.14061810076236725,
0.5250234603881836,
-0.8423654437065125,
0.6675601005554199,
0.4053867757320404,
-0.13589335978031158,
0.3603813350200653,
-0.48384854197502136,
0.31958478689193726,
0.5541191101074219,
-0.9614132046699524,
-0.30451804399490356,
0.3133126199245453,
0.3239513635635376,
0.058070652186870575,
0.29934945702552795,
-0.33909961581230164,
-0.0442764014005661,
-0.46757379174232483,
0.2543708384037018,
0.1792316436767578,
-0.25425609946250916,
0.2718271017074585,
0.3380259871482849,
-0.1338302344083786,
-0.2484126091003418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15316v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15316v3 | UNSEE: Unsupervised Non-contrastive Sentence Embeddings | 2024-01-27T06:29:07 | 2024-02-02T14:06:31 | Ömer Veysel Çağatan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present UNSEE: Unsupervised Non-Contrastive Sentence Embeddings, a novel
approach that outperforms SimCSE in the Massive Text Embedding benchmark. Our
exploration begins by addressing the challenge of representation collapse, a
phenomenon observed when contrastive objectives in SimCSE are replaced with
non-contrastive objectives. To counter this issue, we propose a straightforward
solution known as the target network, effectively mitigating representation
collapse. The introduction of the target network allows us to leverage
non-contrastive objectives, maintaining training stability while achieving
performance improvements comparable to contrastive objectives. Our method has
achieved peak performance in non-contrastive sentence embeddings through
meticulous fine-tuning and optimization. This comprehensive effort has yielded
superior sentence representation models, showcasing the effectiveness of our
approach. | [
-0.34127187728881836,
-0.05854670703411102,
0.6578075289726257,
0.28435736894607544,
-0.5034329295158386,
0.09060582518577576,
-0.07397448271512985,
0.07300058007240295,
0.4222274422645569,
0.6459491848945618,
-0.5309357047080994,
-0.507792055606842,
-0.7368213534355164,
-0.12821851670742035,
-0.6481713056564331,
0.6469456553459167,
-0.10072515159845352,
-0.018913879990577698,
-0.6335915327072144,
-0.36463722586631775,
-0.31301888823509216,
-0.34546345472335815,
-0.27342700958251953,
-0.3151693642139435,
0.03240131214261055,
0.48307397961616516,
0.5759719610214233,
0.6272166967391968,
0.3716602623462677,
0.26563316583633423,
-0.054835785180330276,
0.2735588252544403,
-0.6860167384147644,
0.10934567451477051,
-0.17709508538246155,
-0.3773409426212311,
0.3024579882621765,
-0.001297783455811441,
0.711027979850769,
1.108318567276001,
-0.06452999264001846,
-0.2952975928783417,
0.33676403760910034,
0.647148609161377,
-1.104257345199585,
0.0907800942659378,
-0.5871199369430542,
0.34804677963256836,
-0.11076817661523819,
-0.11508721858263016,
-0.7107360363006592,
0.2331540882587433,
-0.35287073254585266,
-0.6267494559288025,
0.09685684740543365,
0.21679165959358215,
0.6350935697555542,
0.2614103853702545,
-0.8855121731758118,
0.26603230834007263,
-0.4626021981239319,
1.0125811100006104,
-0.4054313898086548,
0.43163299560546875,
-0.09077662974596024,
0.19845274090766907,
-0.4556424915790558,
-0.8613426685333252,
-0.14885461330413818,
-0.12339775264263153,
0.10809631645679474,
0.44432884454727173,
-0.6760967373847961,
0.14801423251628876,
0.1132194772362709,
0.2700992822647095,
-0.4070769250392914,
0.10727569460868835,
0.15610137581825256,
-0.25752049684524536,
0.43558183312416077,
0.11761118471622467,
0.20841079950332642,
-0.0790477842092514,
-0.5711077451705933,
-0.20556987822055817,
-0.49824175238609314,
-0.2990080714225769,
0.06798126548528671,
0.28561699390411377,
-0.04160342365503311,
0.7822542786598206,
-0.37427905201911926,
0.1891160011291504,
-0.03408387303352356,
0.7230689525604248,
0.2720896303653717,
-0.016366418451070786,
-0.5193356871604919,
0.15980814397335052,
0.9984875917434692,
0.4906816780567169,
0.2791443169116974,
-0.5783954858779907,
-0.15024124085903168,
0.2913890480995178,
0.26199206709861755,
-0.8084568977355957,
-0.18514658510684967,
-0.05310734733939171,
-0.6895350813865662,
-0.3615855276584625,
0.3897624611854553,
-0.8314234614372253,
-0.5372299551963806,
0.05200239270925522,
0.2612679898738861,
-0.4026881754398346,
-0.027627216652035713,
-0.006750906817615032,
-0.3506733179092407,
-0.2093447595834732,
0.02765500359237194,
-0.7155138254165649,
0.5455220341682434,
0.3265579044818878,
0.879561722278595,
-0.05457377806305885,
-0.21363565325737,
-0.5749996304512024,
0.21364279091358185,
-0.6706463694572449,
0.8278096318244934,
-0.7043029069900513,
-0.6112302541732788,
0.11661497503519058,
-0.18191851675510406,
-0.30182453989982605,
-0.4917043447494507,
0.9325241446495056,
-0.19479718804359436,
0.010377773083746433,
-0.12904369831085205,
-1.035811185836792,
-0.29209765791893005,
0.051514748483896255,
-0.6637980341911316,
0.8662774562835693,
-0.0028797113336622715,
-0.9440944790840149,
0.10573167353868484,
-0.906317412853241,
-0.2766307592391968,
-0.2070552408695221,
-0.23922467231750488,
-0.3962765336036682,
0.7259368300437927,
0.4560204744338989,
0.5113270878791809,
-0.32054075598716736,
0.017403719946742058,
-0.31067031621932983,
-0.7205759882926941,
-0.06302017718553543,
-0.5607725977897644,
0.553086519241333,
-0.04279450327157974,
-0.5109274983406067,
0.18951165676116943,
-0.5734920501708984,
0.13785243034362793,
0.48308244347572327,
0.11180702596902847,
-0.41241753101348877,
0.018399029970169067,
0.4396953880786896,
-0.001783480285666883,
0.14294737577438354,
-0.7464451789855957,
0.017298121005296707,
-0.24836012721061707,
0.5823382139205933,
0.5525391101837158,
0.03411123529076576,
0.5707175731658936,
-0.008462933823466301,
0.3040347993373871,
0.3863477408885956,
0.10569842904806137,
-0.11667341738939285,
-0.40836429595947266,
-0.75362229347229,
-0.02374742180109024,
0.409580260515213,
0.3255382776260376,
-0.7736107707023621,
0.2931983768939972,
-0.05935093015432358,
-0.4050551652908325,
-0.17063792049884796,
0.07072349637746811,
0.6270723938941956,
0.17074669897556305,
0.5518825054168701,
-0.10340428352355957,
-0.7724475860595703,
-1.2064528465270996,
-0.5228717923164368,
0.01697048544883728,
0.08343735337257385,
-0.059326961636543274,
0.6282982230186462,
-0.4695107936859131,
0.5537796020507812,
-0.6451177000999451,
-0.5354316234588623,
-0.48407071828842163,
0.39461231231689453,
0.04186760261654854,
0.43391984701156616,
0.3365732729434967,
-0.9783321022987366,
-0.5057691931724548,
-0.16672848165035248,
-0.9668855667114258,
0.04214072972536087,
-0.19116157293319702,
-0.08368968218564987,
-0.035464223474264145,
1.1566240787506104,
-0.3386339545249939,
0.636451005935669,
0.8180190324783325,
-0.3791787624359131,
0.2315678596496582,
-0.4056360125541687,
0.08007028698921204,
-1.2517144680023193,
-0.11076788604259491,
0.02253529615700245,
-0.19174446165561676,
-0.3243914842605591,
-0.13759423792362213,
0.2907412052154541,
-0.3558887839317322,
-0.328045129776001,
0.15567278861999512,
-0.8016346096992493,
-0.4088958501815796,
-0.29014185070991516,
0.20393218100070953,
0.14402447640895844,
0.3572550117969513,
-0.04760264977812767,
0.7497460842132568,
0.6773624420166016,
-0.2079232931137085,
0.002752920612692833,
0.4977663457393646,
-0.3711588978767395,
0.35179954767227173,
-0.7189847230911255,
-0.10939256846904755,
-0.21443906426429749,
0.28317373991012573,
-0.7855335474014282,
0.10951688885688782,
-0.036900151520967484,
-0.28079789876937866,
0.21673044562339783,
0.043096087872982025,
-0.48352348804473877,
-0.12133952975273132,
-0.42659875750541687,
0.3593847155570984,
0.4184088408946991,
-0.695915162563324,
0.4042566418647766,
0.05352210998535156,
0.6009590029716492,
-0.4271841049194336,
-1.038069725036621,
0.3892671465873718,
-0.03783980384469032,
-0.3629467785358429,
0.5943825840950012,
0.11387843638658524,
0.03552396968007088,
0.2324543446302414,
-0.1679605394601822,
0.03199542686343193,
-0.10916058719158173,
0.5213279724121094,
-0.02850426360964775,
-0.35263004899024963,
-0.09096240997314453,
0.24779292941093445,
-0.3534463346004486,
-0.004405917599797249,
-0.27177694439888,
0.38754740357398987,
0.2994958758354187,
-0.6345961689949036,
-0.430677592754364,
0.8832674026489258,
0.6285691857337952,
-0.41834738850593567,
0.9383745789527893,
0.2617915868759155,
-0.3758493959903717,
-0.4071647822856903,
-0.14769819378852844,
-0.08789757639169693,
-0.45565614104270935,
0.5296202898025513,
-0.14598771929740906,
-0.8237169981002808,
0.12323131412267685,
-0.6071765422821045,
-0.03917159140110016,
0.43278926610946655,
-0.014157216064631939,
-0.18621553480625153,
0.9993928670883179,
0.8858721256256104,
0.234599307179451,
0.4892689287662506,
-0.169314906001091,
0.17568762600421906,
-1.1207107305526733,
-0.49581944942474365,
-0.3271704316139221,
-0.4735739231109619,
-0.5467196106910706,
-0.7315411567687988,
0.06049862131476402,
0.4478773772716522,
-0.36064639687538147,
0.4258737862110138,
-0.45137929916381836,
0.5465089678764343,
0.5244326591491699,
-0.015652528032660484,
0.085022933781147,
0.06551334261894226,
-0.6282491683959961,
-0.3300930857658386,
-0.6002414226531982,
-0.5411530137062073,
1.0816023349761963,
0.005618976429104805,
0.6216421127319336,
0.07165572047233582,
0.8796214461326599,
0.3725416958332062,
-0.14201335608959198,
-0.5149616003036499,
0.7493331432342529,
-0.7777239084243774,
-0.14260876178741455,
-0.007313757203519344,
-0.5831052660942078,
-1.030771017074585,
0.4066353142261505,
-0.47529053688049316,
-0.9915361404418945,
0.5324865579605103,
-0.13272346556186676,
0.2031882256269455,
0.71858149766922,
-0.710121750831604,
1.1716899871826172,
0.049599796533584595,
-0.05896881967782974,
0.047563184052705765,
-0.3632321059703827,
0.030840329825878143,
0.21412169933319092,
-0.18413598835468292,
0.016166899353265762,
-0.32542315125465393,
0.842980146408081,
-0.2980216145515442,
0.7830246090888977,
-0.06472820043563843,
0.4671793580055237,
-0.03215217962861061,
0.2478484958410263,
0.5257889628410339,
-0.13707248866558075,
-0.06119711697101593,
0.317754864692688,
-0.5609282851219177,
-0.5370198488235474,
-0.7989800572395325,
0.8042194247245789,
-0.7387253046035767,
-0.023328468203544617,
-0.6508097648620605,
-0.5653723478317261,
-0.5604965686798096,
0.3453481197357178,
0.5009899735450745,
0.5560179948806763,
-0.6723985075950623,
0.5779238343238831,
0.6374403238296509,
-0.11744637787342072,
0.8154684901237488,
0.29640546441078186,
0.04018907994031906,
-0.36801618337631226,
0.7192730903625488,
-0.2357596904039383,
0.25147750973701477,
0.9190601706504822,
-0.010793307796120644,
-0.7609001994132996,
-0.9452133774757385,
-0.1261368989944458,
0.00008921213157009333,
-0.7972382307052612,
-0.08073887974023819,
-0.6669498682022095,
-0.20875239372253418,
-0.43596383929252625,
-0.35899099707603455,
-0.645409882068634,
-0.19909025728702545,
-0.5197790861129761,
-0.049762796610593796,
-0.04611044377088547,
1.03258216381073,
-0.1810690313577652,
0.390011191368103,
-0.5464974641799927,
0.27839070558547974,
-0.0692497044801712,
0.3804512321949005,
-0.3179956078529358,
-0.43362024426460266,
-0.07108381390571594,
-0.07910038530826569,
-0.37138116359710693,
-0.7948902249336243,
0.20572930574417114,
0.180128812789917,
0.6937244534492493,
0.7245910167694092,
0.4329834282398224,
0.6306347846984863,
-0.4936685860157013,
0.4535297751426697,
0.591200053691864,
-1.1579711437225342,
0.4912092685699463,
-0.1879001259803772,
0.28358155488967896,
0.7669815421104431,
0.2953197956085205,
-0.36614641547203064,
-0.19134806096553802,
-0.5340327024459839,
-0.815623939037323,
0.4528902471065521,
0.7569998502731323,
0.05009768530726433,
-0.16957131028175354,
0.12660446763038635,
-0.40472251176834106,
0.26000988483428955,
-0.3876814544200897,
-0.29396286606788635,
-0.4818497896194458,
-0.09827463328838348,
-0.5189521312713623,
-0.48777899146080017,
0.2200687974691391,
0.19356200098991394,
0.48755359649658203,
-0.29267624020576477,
0.4725434482097626,
0.20172923803329468,
-0.05183049291372299,
0.05240758880972862,
0.18828071653842926,
0.28089579939842224,
0.22326983511447906,
-0.1953924298286438,
0.033109020441770554,
-0.07456744462251663,
-0.3505239188671112,
-0.08473096787929535,
0.04690501466393471,
-0.25989025831222534,
0.06656474620103836,
0.7395128607749939,
0.9276896119117737,
0.7391713261604309,
-0.6289810538291931,
0.6953560709953308,
-0.3053446114063263,
-0.5136800408363342,
-0.13789412379264832,
-0.1977488249540329,
0.19551071524620056,
0.18420551717281342,
0.14277659356594086,
0.30638131499290466,
0.42985448241233826,
-0.5568655729293823,
0.5172771215438843,
0.4295521080493927,
-0.7840632200241089,
0.33683833479881287,
1.0531822443008423,
0.18667364120483398,
0.04329860210418701,
0.7809110879898071,
-0.046045899391174316,
-0.39967113733291626,
0.6376996040344238,
0.8016263246536255,
0.9620712399482727,
-0.12037751823663712,
0.6500909328460693,
0.1813650280237198,
0.4300059676170349,
-0.20943774282932281,
0.19174058735370636,
0.3274707496166229,
-0.5845229625701904,
-0.25226715207099915,
-0.3196153938770294,
-0.4445825517177582,
-0.3703521490097046,
-1.1314888000488281,
0.14697538316249847,
-0.5804939866065979,
0.326373815536499,
-0.03029598668217659,
-0.08920934051275253,
-0.2554205060005188,
0.5154845714569092,
0.015027581714093685,
0.940737247467041,
-1.1019761562347412,
0.590541422367096,
1.0550215244293213,
-0.49634233117103577,
-0.5487918853759766,
0.37128981947898865,
-0.05959385633468628,
-0.6893963813781738,
0.267848938703537,
0.47583118081092834,
0.0318421833217144,
-0.07393917441368103,
-0.33062368631362915,
-0.5892662405967712,
1.1179901361465454,
0.9238312244415283,
-0.8187437057495117,
0.22320282459259033,
0.2210344672203064,
0.29203712940216064,
-0.5503644943237305,
0.4061907231807709,
0.19547905027866364,
0.376995325088501,
0.4157392978668213,
-0.4598228335380554,
0.20818334817886353,
-0.204106867313385,
0.2258448451757431,
0.434152215719223,
-0.6762201189994812,
0.8061153292655945,
-0.13851191103458405,
-0.2921002209186554,
0.14907406270503998,
0.8089436888694763,
-0.16469624638557434,
0.27274850010871887,
0.5593087673187256,
0.8782525658607483,
0.5935889482498169,
-0.20098526775836945,
1.1744112968444824,
0.1157177984714508,
0.2993820607662201,
1.2002828121185303,
-0.12009645253419876,
1.0263097286224365,
0.44303807616233826,
0.10721682757139206,
0.5670301914215088,
0.4446871280670166,
-0.08450434356927872,
0.7517054677009583,
0.21926309168338776,
-0.04715358093380928,
-0.7528885006904602,
-0.49567750096321106,
-0.23062783479690552,
0.7854130268096924,
0.027640627697110176,
-0.44002336263656616,
-0.6462123990058899,
0.02022496797144413,
-0.1704941987991333,
0.7943893074989319,
-0.34961798787117004,
0.5981166958808899,
0.289424329996109,
-0.11916892975568771,
0.40936747193336487,
0.02811373956501484,
0.5054242610931396,
-0.6258203387260437,
-0.11851663142442703,
-0.32293644547462463,
0.446784645318985,
-0.23111197352409363,
-0.6356683373451233,
0.3398538827896118,
-0.3247700333595276,
-0.21271611750125885,
-0.1694210320711136,
0.4286686182022095,
-0.21825064718723297,
-0.6610738635063171,
0.9328635334968567,
0.34287312626838684,
0.1603461503982544,
-0.5389539003372192,
-0.8982772827148438,
0.27931487560272217,
0.20613856613636017,
0.028259849175810814,
0.5747038722038269,
0.6940087676048279,
-0.14353445172309875,
0.5839298963546753,
0.46020790934562683,
-0.2951047420501709,
-0.22025583684444427,
0.2204122692346573,
1.043961763381958,
-0.9676182270050049,
-0.6527594923973083,
-0.6504710912704468,
0.4809558093547821,
-0.31050172448158264,
-0.2972107231616974,
0.8515884280204773,
0.7575434446334839,
0.3959731161594391,
0.17421786487102509,
0.6387625932693481,
0.28595682978630066,
0.18174347281455994,
-0.4923016428947449,
0.6328267455101013,
-1.0340921878814697,
-0.04915245622396469,
-0.4067642390727997,
-1.1860530376434326,
-0.46671175956726074,
0.36151766777038574,
0.021934092044830322,
0.10820280015468597,
1.179389238357544,
0.4537074565887451,
-0.2767820954322815,
0.14049357175827026,
0.7636958360671997,
0.13004370033740997,
0.13417008519172668,
0.8714499473571777,
0.46558108925819397,
-0.5970402359962463,
0.9188637137413025,
-0.24259783327579498,
-0.2255009412765503,
-0.16549444198608398,
-1.19834566116333,
-1.3478525876998901,
-0.4429810643196106,
-0.5931676626205444,
-0.008000226691365242,
0.2288936972618103,
0.4646541178226471,
0.648859441280365,
-0.9937389492988586,
0.1188080832362175,
-0.5771650671958923,
-0.13420245051383972,
-0.25761035084724426,
-0.11954598873853683,
0.5347992181777954,
-0.21848151087760925,
-0.6446660161018372,
0.7667441964149475,
0.5367873907089233,
0.09464381635189056,
-0.09177657961845398,
0.10635368525981903,
-0.20414718985557556,
0.2401745319366455,
0.396297812461853,
0.19792738556861877,
-0.2879811227321625,
0.12035531550645828,
-0.2568497061729431,
0.14749515056610107,
-0.09024052321910858,
0.9737728238105774,
-0.6271349787712097,
0.3613319396972656,
0.05954878777265549,
0.9035552740097046,
0.3936181366443634,
-0.07610360532999039,
0.4761618673801422,
-0.8482784032821655,
0.36595413088798523,
0.16065001487731934,
0.7756815552711487,
0.4200659394264221,
-0.1601720154285431,
0.3920656740665436,
0.20031999051570892,
-0.2463163137435913,
-0.710485577583313,
0.26087507605552673,
-1.032948613166809,
-0.44794678688049316,
0.9832156896591187,
-0.23891407251358032,
-0.21110032498836517,
-0.1313554346561432,
-0.12215358763933182,
0.0778735876083374,
-0.6276180148124695,
0.3159737288951874,
0.2373293936252594,
-0.1146705150604248,
-0.35068240761756897,
-0.3238614499568939,
0.04788865149021149,
0.7682788968086243,
-0.732431948184967,
-0.0476195327937603,
0.328370600938797,
-0.12116528302431107,
0.18454942107200623,
0.34344491362571716,
-0.18705998361110687,
0.04020361602306366,
0.5375431180000305,
-0.05166051536798477,
-0.33110055327415466,
-0.3727985620498657,
-0.14466063678264618,
0.34937986731529236,
-0.21728527545928955,
-0.8194399476051331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15312v1 | How We Refute Claims: Automatic Fact-Checking through Flaw Identification and Explanation | 2024-01-27T06:06:16 | 2024-01-27T06:06:16 | Wei-Yu Kao, An-Zi Yen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated fact-checking is a crucial task in the governance of internet
content. Although various studies utilize advanced models to tackle this issue,
a significant gap persists in addressing complex real-world rumors and
deceptive claims. To address this challenge, this paper explores the novel task
of flaw-oriented fact-checking, including aspect generation and flaw
identification. We also introduce RefuteClaim, a new framework designed
specifically for this task. Given the absence of an existing dataset, we
present FlawCheck, a dataset created by extracting and transforming insights
from expert reviews into relevant aspects and identified flaws. The
experimental results underscore the efficacy of RefuteClaim, particularly in
classifying and elucidating false claims. | [
-0.40041279792785645,
-0.7573329210281372,
0.8229002952575684,
-0.054069723933935165,
0.06459777802228928,
0.27887165546417236,
0.35131046175956726,
-0.6492359638214111,
0.2594497501850128,
0.7833256125450134,
-0.6922329664230347,
-0.23643098771572113,
-0.44652998447418213,
0.3004664480686188,
-0.5452584624290466,
1.1588232517242432,
-0.29885175824165344,
-0.12309908866882324,
-0.5523926615715027,
0.07193441689014435,
-0.2855331003665924,
-0.16239170730113983,
-0.47200432419776917,
-0.30420005321502686,
0.3907073140144348,
0.7741801142692566,
0.5945589542388916,
0.6286165118217468,
0.5243027210235596,
0.3965657651424408,
0.3201863467693329,
0.5176085233688354,
-0.025364382192492485,
0.07433277368545532,
-0.2773470878601074,
-0.8387811779975891,
-0.23871050775051117,
0.34535664319992065,
0.19964410364627838,
0.3701493442058563,
-0.16084474325180054,
0.29350024461746216,
-0.20049938559532166,
0.6700507402420044,
-0.725153923034668,
-0.0709839016199112,
-0.7301914691925049,
0.22994793951511383,
-0.23707334697246552,
0.11159860342741013,
-0.3892384171485901,
-0.6589168906211853,
0.24850349128246307,
-0.6098350286483765,
1.0015043020248413,
0.2029002159833908,
1.319601058959961,
0.4774238169193268,
-0.5416643619537354,
-0.5109275579452515,
-0.6131145358085632,
0.49007466435432434,
-0.6857972145080566,
0.4052520990371704,
0.3620752692222595,
0.5718001127243042,
-0.05887844040989876,
-0.8060860633850098,
-1.0018575191497803,
-0.09925805032253265,
-0.4229848086833954,
-0.048708874732255936,
-0.11158975958824158,
-0.10634326189756393,
0.22597162425518036,
0.6965205669403076,
-0.530490517616272,
0.04333815723657608,
-0.45463457703590393,
-0.7919183969497681,
0.8548644185066223,
-0.21517157554626465,
0.26565414667129517,
-0.395602822303772,
-0.21426667273044586,
0.0013197242515161633,
-0.969044029712677,
-0.04332522675395012,
0.8077192306518555,
-0.04208026081323624,
0.21082553267478943,
0.5104765892028809,
-0.4480128884315491,
0.32892003655433655,
0.3687104284763336,
-0.19150611758232117,
0.15886777639389038,
-0.07169508934020996,
-0.5099658966064453,
0.30779337882995605,
0.3390551209449768,
0.31983089447021484,
-0.5152795314788818,
-0.049526166170835495,
-0.4026189148426056,
-0.1076095774769783,
0.46583834290504456,
-0.4655020833015442,
-0.15108054876327515,
0.553852915763855,
-0.44326403737068176,
-0.6477147340774536,
0.570945143699646,
-0.9463318586349487,
-0.9608702659606934,
-0.04668109863996506,
0.5047846436500549,
0.019611060619354248,
-0.261628121137619,
0.06845561414957047,
-0.32199835777282715,
-0.25089341402053833,
0.5432383418083191,
-0.11547678709030151,
-0.03783169761300087,
0.6915932893753052,
0.4334871172904968,
0.26641589403152466,
-0.1702156811952591,
-0.44795310497283936,
-0.08805834501981735,
-0.5174142122268677,
1.3152228593826294,
-0.2857823371887207,
0.02096509002149105,
0.1136707216501236,
0.17236292362213135,
0.5484804511070251,
-0.7096190452575684,
0.9835063815116882,
-0.6035396456718445,
0.5437802076339722,
-0.5458769798278809,
-0.32416749000549316,
-0.6408583521842957,
0.6617832183837891,
-1.0079474449157715,
0.6707017421722412,
-0.031051425263285637,
-0.8909654021263123,
0.6158511638641357,
-0.5208336114883423,
-0.37883198261260986,
-0.18941500782966614,
-0.11508022993803024,
-0.7500569224357605,
0.4501687288284302,
0.2858850657939911,
0.023062685504555702,
-0.47133949398994446,
0.14863282442092896,
-0.1203598752617836,
0.11430762708187103,
0.4848443269729614,
-0.5990311503410339,
0.7776913046836853,
0.38001883029937744,
-0.7149661183357239,
-0.15175075829029083,
-0.7003703117370605,
-0.12440717965364456,
0.15818530321121216,
-0.15586337447166443,
-0.3324895203113556,
0.23196053504943848,
-0.566946804523468,
-0.02603200264275074,
0.2793356776237488,
-0.9429762959480286,
0.20827803015708923,
-0.36489173769950867,
0.1666916161775589,
0.6176809072494507,
0.09755770862102509,
-0.03483077883720398,
-0.481554239988327,
0.20105861127376556,
0.3347202241420746,
0.4349888563156128,
-0.28297045826911926,
-0.06924265623092651,
-1.1760869026184082,
0.05246656760573387,
0.7117113471031189,
0.4914846122264862,
-1.0207579135894775,
0.26449504494667053,
-0.1242259070277214,
-0.5012779235839844,
-0.7307109832763672,
-0.1340610384941101,
0.43906107544898987,
0.7710402607917786,
0.33214637637138367,
-0.4276738166809082,
-0.3946409523487091,
-1.339177131652832,
-0.5899477005004883,
-0.5520964860916138,
-0.1394137591123581,
0.07960451394319534,
0.35549452900886536,
-0.11295277625322342,
1.2784192562103271,
-0.49985846877098083,
-0.166057288646698,
0.17266780138015747,
0.7187378406524658,
-0.25379839539527893,
0.301527738571167,
0.4089028239250183,
-1.0989457368850708,
-0.12084595859050751,
-0.37488657236099243,
-0.90269535779953,
-0.4409053325653076,
-0.45505818724632263,
0.36890941858291626,
0.4158507287502289,
0.22563810646533966,
-0.4498201012611389,
0.5744039416313171,
0.3867255747318268,
-0.599445104598999,
0.759151816368103,
-0.012604296207427979,
0.662598192691803,
-0.6168111562728882,
-0.35406967997550964,
0.017844270914793015,
-0.4071153402328491,
-0.19180110096931458,
0.2383560687303543,
-0.06391202658414841,
0.07696130126714706,
-0.2646540403366089,
0.009708624333143234,
-0.565979540348053,
-0.026576776057481766,
-0.5418538451194763,
-0.026693861931562424,
0.3329019248485565,
0.07455592602491379,
-0.16900992393493652,
0.29829141497612,
0.4027210474014282,
-0.452828049659729,
0.4820956885814667,
-0.013914846815168858,
-0.1913071572780609,
0.9245256185531616,
-0.5424066185951233,
0.16002009809017181,
-0.11143692582845688,
0.5194953680038452,
-1.0338828563690186,
-0.5714606642723083,
0.3020017445087433,
-0.5483643412590027,
0.08000480383634567,
-0.5201026201248169,
-0.6621934175491333,
-0.42330366373062134,
-0.27852413058280945,
0.030678682029247284,
0.047096364200115204,
-0.8154034614562988,
0.7121264934539795,
0.4103756248950958,
-0.23369336128234863,
-0.7821647524833679,
-0.7069500088691711,
0.36496201157569885,
-0.14655327796936035,
-0.47916150093078613,
0.5036280155181885,
0.3052053451538086,
-0.5930309295654297,
0.2641380727291107,
-0.4709738492965698,
-0.4228430390357971,
0.002032545395195484,
0.4349637031555176,
-0.07031206041574478,
-0.22406888008117676,
0.020909709855914116,
0.13028304278850555,
-0.2313900738954544,
0.3551713824272156,
-0.07405569404363632,
-0.017517654225230217,
0.16279029846191406,
-0.9377936720848083,
-0.6372218728065491,
0.39444535970687866,
0.6672536730766296,
-0.14457248151302338,
0.17025679349899292,
0.3188879191875458,
-0.3589570224285126,
-0.23006607592105865,
-1.1424480676651,
-0.30507463216781616,
-0.49161383509635925,
-0.0011379094794392586,
-0.04096395894885063,
-0.5516344904899597,
0.31718575954437256,
-0.3790898621082306,
0.6254703402519226,
0.7422183156013489,
-0.20588761568069458,
-0.047373831272125244,
0.6623220443725586,
0.795792281627655,
0.11243002116680145,
-0.06556520611047745,
0.006474789697676897,
0.3850758373737335,
-0.2140180617570877,
-0.08412479609251022,
-0.733410120010376,
-0.3390345275402069,
-0.48524123430252075,
-0.3653258979320526,
0.28851571679115295,
0.11612381041049957,
-0.09647844731807709,
-0.022916650399565697,
-0.48649120330810547,
0.6123989224433899,
0.3616146743297577,
0.14710167050361633,
0.6192404627799988,
0.08280453085899353,
0.1520710289478302,
-0.15297995507717133,
-0.2167453020811081,
-0.5328863263130188,
0.862227737903595,
0.5103144645690918,
0.47916024923324585,
0.31976306438446045,
0.6200160980224609,
0.6970810890197754,
0.5555676221847534,
-0.5956265330314636,
0.37127724289894104,
0.15173307061195374,
-0.9145712852478027,
-0.023368477821350098,
-0.3111061453819275,
-0.2707085907459259,
0.02678494341671467,
-0.33010920882225037,
-0.2320215255022049,
0.40209075808525085,
0.45629265904426575,
-0.3092936873435974,
0.4974590837955475,
-0.5954928994178772,
0.4227951467037201,
-0.40343359112739563,
-0.280312716960907,
-0.5659897923469543,
-0.41154471039772034,
0.5223538279533386,
-0.08107282221317291,
0.3642479181289673,
0.22650904953479767,
0.18762120604515076,
0.6488884091377258,
-0.7831310629844666,
1.0440434217453003,
-0.48414573073387146,
-0.29911187291145325,
0.5015439391136169,
0.48865875601768494,
0.656594455242157,
0.30256572365760803,
0.0796080082654953,
0.20720233023166656,
-0.22533348202705383,
-0.19226206839084625,
-0.7392798066139221,
0.45502161979675293,
-0.4797058701515198,
-0.8439589142799377,
-0.6467199325561523,
-0.011077282950282097,
-0.30220314860343933,
0.3202129900455475,
0.17656971514225006,
0.3807840943336487,
-0.2904101014137268,
0.019109388813376427,
0.8597164154052734,
-0.2755507826805115,
0.3240320086479187,
1.0393232107162476,
-0.20393112301826477,
-0.31044331192970276,
1.0304914712905884,
0.174710214138031,
-0.10928123444318771,
0.18656809628009796,
0.16527096927165985,
-0.20303352177143097,
-0.6499290466308594,
-0.48386988043785095,
0.04774773120880127,
-0.655473530292511,
-0.3981533944606781,
-0.4309011697769165,
-0.1045142114162445,
-0.308260977268219,
-0.1128476932644844,
-0.8178838491439819,
-0.5136209726333618,
0.4435479938983917,
-0.3804279565811157,
0.23444341123104095,
1.1368227005004883,
-0.3352699279785156,
0.0810355693101883,
-0.5976625084877014,
0.5229448080062866,
0.6017932295799255,
0.35858073830604553,
-0.2946256995201111,
-0.29564791917800903,
0.0450177937746048,
0.2289881855249405,
-0.5943576693534851,
-0.9695080518722534,
0.10464742034673691,
-0.14484049379825592,
0.53253173828125,
0.5168662667274475,
0.3321613371372223,
0.721248209476471,
-0.38547006249427795,
1.0943039655685425,
-0.004120014142245054,
-0.8956877589225769,
0.5290377736091614,
0.1493188887834549,
-0.5442596077919006,
0.6304054260253906,
0.5909302234649658,
-0.48307350277900696,
-0.4923967123031616,
-1.1329289674758911,
-0.8327375650405884,
0.33723634481430054,
0.13450296223163605,
-0.22816535830497742,
0.32585206627845764,
0.49534592032432556,
0.4456040561199188,
0.2369024157524109,
-0.6536335349082947,
-0.42979010939598083,
-0.540161669254303,
-0.07168562710285187,
0.4093596041202545,
-0.28124764561653137,
-0.5203239321708679,
0.2211642563343048,
0.7148448824882507,
-0.25607043504714966,
0.3884536027908325,
0.6950676441192627,
-0.49562588334083557,
-0.3160991668701172,
0.26629340648651123,
0.6359601616859436,
0.8722822666168213,
0.2766234874725342,
0.5521034598350525,
-0.06147564947605133,
-0.41848886013031006,
0.21225228905677795,
0.2585632801055908,
-0.37835124135017395,
0.3986750543117523,
0.48363617062568665,
0.22527386248111725,
-0.06954826414585114,
-0.3377646207809448,
0.5039013624191284,
-0.12311596423387527,
-0.20339420437812805,
-0.3166291117668152,
-0.11481713503599167,
-0.2744445204734802,
0.3727191388607025,
0.6643876433372498,
0.2750159800052643,
0.30763837695121765,
-0.6185868382453918,
0.5748113989830017,
0.036820609122514725,
-0.3924044370651245,
-0.3596218526363373,
0.408638060092926,
0.4152807593345642,
-0.11901985108852386,
0.5943124294281006,
-0.34400221705436707,
-0.684101402759552,
0.6685190796852112,
0.1709958016872406,
0.8479329943656921,
-0.2598710358142853,
0.6965756416320801,
0.12180735915899277,
0.5544949173927307,
-0.15024395287036896,
-0.11341818422079086,
0.14274874329566956,
-0.7305095791816711,
-0.3126894235610962,
-0.2352733463048935,
-0.4562418758869171,
0.33610618114471436,
-0.507842481136322,
0.00811013113707304,
-0.6129077076911926,
0.024725820869207382,
0.09938759356737137,
0.17054742574691772,
-0.32752034068107605,
0.3948800563812256,
0.01600627228617668,
0.7935536503791809,
-1.030422329902649,
0.300096333026886,
0.40977832674980164,
-0.5664860010147095,
-0.5386828184127808,
0.6695295572280884,
0.8484875559806824,
-0.640017032623291,
0.669231653213501,
0.026096483692526817,
-0.24080999195575714,
-0.38887476921081543,
-0.8975197076797485,
-0.5345311760902405,
0.888301432132721,
0.43283089995384216,
-0.4186806380748749,
0.15492448210716248,
0.24978120625019073,
0.15946470201015472,
-0.15984989702701569,
0.10302280634641647,
0.1477494090795517,
0.6545414328575134,
0.01775415986776352,
-0.9548783302307129,
0.26877474784851074,
0.0809800997376442,
-0.5565105676651001,
-0.10797031223773956,
-0.6370222568511963,
0.9214221835136414,
-0.12992720305919647,
-0.1586952656507492,
-0.47786107659339905,
0.9724518060684204,
0.02650466375052929,
0.45074358582496643,
1.0500917434692383,
0.738956093788147,
0.9218485951423645,
-0.19801326096057892,
0.7735491991043091,
0.13780032098293304,
0.421205997467041,
1.0808087587356567,
-0.15094704926013947,
0.4386215806007385,
0.21484597027301788,
0.0631178766489029,
0.817737340927124,
0.7870514988899231,
-0.12115804105997086,
0.28276991844177246,
-0.051259417086839676,
-0.08802857995033264,
-0.2703648805618286,
-0.09745301306247711,
-0.038817398250103,
0.40398940443992615,
0.3544463515281677,
-0.23614144325256348,
-0.4945043921470642,
-0.3056802451610565,
0.29268020391464233,
0.03171899542212486,
-0.2716830372810364,
0.763778805732727,
-0.3500356376171112,
-0.9083808660507202,
0.13857348263263702,
0.22895702719688416,
0.5252816081047058,
-0.270590603351593,
-0.46260276436805725,
-0.385666161775589,
0.05472603440284729,
-0.5955129861831665,
-0.8813859224319458,
0.5291407704353333,
0.2585432827472687,
-0.285103440284729,
-0.1631278693675995,
0.6975035667419434,
-0.17947225272655487,
-0.3596610426902771,
-0.4758593738079071,
0.2625478506088257,
-0.047733522951602936,
-0.33746767044067383,
-0.9665023684501648,
-0.08146359771490097,
0.1926676332950592,
-0.053527988493442535,
-0.033396027982234955,
0.6976779103279114,
-0.1057707890868187,
0.5731189250946045,
0.46904468536376953,
-0.02607976272702217,
-0.33065444231033325,
-0.299073725938797,
0.6168432235717773,
-0.5314212441444397,
-0.5370981693267822,
-0.6223600506782532,
0.6841993927955627,
-0.4846271574497223,
-0.044129371643066406,
0.7550013065338135,
0.6380557417869568,
0.7150740623474121,
0.17852339148521423,
1.1378047466278076,
-0.37470361590385437,
0.8388921022415161,
-0.5261207818984985,
0.858165442943573,
-0.6008548140525818,
0.18083444237709045,
-0.11442145705223083,
-0.36503031849861145,
-0.17993669211864471,
0.453235924243927,
-0.12130312621593475,
-0.2940678596496582,
0.8120085597038269,
0.8027462363243103,
-0.2617090940475464,
0.2247539609670639,
-0.16161060333251953,
0.618942379951477,
0.658911406993866,
-0.019146958366036415,
0.7475342750549316,
-0.640670657157898,
0.4302637279033661,
-0.2715536952018738,
-0.15901115536689758,
-0.35768434405326843,
-1.0758601427078247,
-0.4790114760398865,
-0.6122527122497559,
-0.812061607837677,
-0.673346221446991,
-0.1808159351348877,
0.3916463255882263,
0.6399533748626709,
-0.9048919677734375,
0.4086003601551056,
-0.10177557170391083,
0.5480456352233887,
-0.3128441870212555,
-0.22981984913349152,
0.32392948865890503,
-0.11549767106771469,
-0.4247032105922699,
0.287502646446228,
0.04758063703775406,
0.01457580178976059,
-0.5959189534187317,
0.3470362722873688,
0.17491430044174194,
0.26903265714645386,
0.13959434628486633,
0.6674227714538574,
-0.8937798142433167,
-0.7380893230438232,
-0.3625071346759796,
0.09617798775434494,
-0.04177470877766609,
1.3217910528182983,
-0.6578510403633118,
0.32870569825172424,
0.4833810329437256,
0.7562128901481628,
0.06613048911094666,
0.06552181392908096,
0.6733841300010681,
-0.8333802819252014,
-0.040458034723997116,
-0.038700394332408905,
0.19574074447155,
0.47717827558517456,
-0.6483548879623413,
0.2876967787742615,
0.4882756769657135,
-0.45110878348350525,
-1.0447481870651245,
0.43656182289123535,
-0.720397412776947,
-0.44385406374931335,
0.5359187126159668,
-0.3145691156387329,
-0.3330688774585724,
-0.476547509431839,
-0.042573075741529465,
0.018680961802601814,
-0.06047244742512703,
1.4536954164505005,
0.7883117198944092,
-0.061264846473932266,
0.04425770044326782,
-0.557374894618988,
0.8328650593757629,
0.08247241377830505,
-0.7978094220161438,
0.38772308826446533,
0.7313024997711182,
0.6179636120796204,
0.648085355758667,
0.22326327860355377,
-0.2783183455467224,
0.33046963810920715,
0.16861765086650848,
0.1840028017759323,
-0.28296399116516113,
-0.4363311231136322,
0.10199054330587387,
0.44920605421066284,
-0.09224019199609756,
-0.05436544492840767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01723v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01723v1 | An Empirical Study on Large Language Models in Accuracy and Robustness under Chinese Industrial Scenarios | 2024-01-27T03:37:55 | 2024-01-27T03:37:55 | Zongjie Li, Wenying Qiu, Pingchuan Ma, Yichen Li, You Li, Sijia He, Baozheng Jiang, Shuai Wang, Weixi Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent years have witnessed the rapid development of large language models
(LLMs) in various domains. To better serve the large number of Chinese users,
many commercial vendors in China have adopted localization strategies, training
and providing local LLMs specifically customized for Chinese users.
Furthermore, looking ahead, one of the key future applications of LLMs will be
practical deployment in industrial production by enterprises and users in those
sectors. However, the accuracy and robustness of LLMs in industrial scenarios
have not been well studied. In this paper, we present a comprehensive empirical
study on the accuracy and robustness of LLMs in the context of the Chinese
industrial production area. We manually collected 1,200 domain-specific
problems from 8 different industrial sectors to evaluate LLM accuracy.
Furthermore, we designed a metamorphic testing framework containing four
industrial-specific stability categories with eight abilities, totaling 13,631
questions with variants to evaluate LLM robustness. In total, we evaluated 9
different LLMs developed by Chinese vendors, as well as four different LLMs
developed by global vendors. Our major findings include: (1) Current LLMs
exhibit low accuracy in Chinese industrial contexts, with all LLMs scoring less
than 0.6. (2) The robustness scores vary across industrial sectors, and local
LLMs overall perform worse than global ones. (3) LLM robustness differs
significantly across abilities. Global LLMs are more robust under
logical-related variants, while advanced local LLMs perform better on problems
related to understanding Chinese industrial terminology. Our study results
provide valuable guidance for understanding and promoting the industrial domain
capabilities of LLMs from both development and industrial enterprise
perspectives. The results further motivate possible research directions and
tooling support. | [
-0.038756195455789566,
-0.8882728815078735,
0.6174973249435425,
0.3152594268321991,
0.031303923577070236,
-0.15509851276874542,
-0.5704982876777649,
-0.6309155821800232,
-0.3874138593673706,
0.2631388306617737,
-0.22075575590133667,
-0.7302151918411255,
-0.30154696106910706,
0.0577387660741806,
-0.3266242444515228,
0.4786096513271332,
-0.058903805911540985,
0.08207152783870697,
0.09472376108169556,
-0.24306029081344604,
-0.376399427652359,
-0.7868688702583313,
-0.6840696334838867,
-0.19776414334774017,
0.4540662467479706,
-0.09526445716619492,
0.7916163802146912,
0.7718251347541809,
0.6635321974754333,
0.34133848547935486,
-0.08212309330701828,
0.0031415699049830437,
-0.10481017827987671,
-0.061522793024778366,
-0.05449991673231125,
-0.3560156226158142,
-0.831760048866272,
-0.26371657848358154,
0.5430260896682739,
0.5834220051765442,
-0.28620246052742004,
0.19214920699596405,
0.39160510897636414,
0.057931192219257355,
-0.5237072706222534,
0.1356346309185028,
-0.9528248906135559,
-0.13265177607536316,
-0.4144611656665802,
0.19861505925655365,
-0.5128409266471863,
-0.24542118608951569,
-0.03895841911435127,
-0.21770106256008148,
0.1322125792503357,
0.07082892954349518,
0.9391730427742004,
0.139576718211174,
-0.43917492032051086,
-0.1331602931022644,
-0.8519221544265747,
0.9850409030914307,
-1.3736631870269775,
0.31471002101898193,
0.13670282065868378,
0.40665203332901,
-0.4549309313297272,
-0.8569977283477783,
-0.4763159155845642,
-0.19843336939811707,
0.06801465898752213,
0.12276703119277954,
0.280867338180542,
0.19556015729904175,
0.22885599732398987,
0.3735615313053131,
-0.5153584480285645,
0.7236028909683228,
-0.09060791879892349,
-0.20391887426376343,
0.5100148916244507,
0.3653823137283325,
0.5091038346290588,
0.148157998919487,
-0.26489415764808655,
-0.10150143504142761,
-0.7441757917404175,
0.15507812798023224,
0.08846109360456467,
0.5059844255447388,
-0.06451583653688431,
0.34374138712882996,
0.02584071271121502,
0.7201449275016785,
-0.35297009348869324,
-0.6701017618179321,
0.27275899052619934,
-0.28334134817123413,
-0.42139849066734314,
-0.32663217186927795,
1.0055408477783203,
0.29345861077308655,
0.1271437704563141,
-0.04724612087011337,
-0.4624597430229187,
-0.13302159309387207,
0.06928148120641708,
-0.556585431098938,
0.18480327725410461,
0.5564512014389038,
-0.6277604699134827,
-0.0277569442987442,
0.058178212493658066,
-0.47859272360801697,
-0.3472849726676941,
-0.14555825293064117,
0.1514812707901001,
-0.2550153434276581,
-0.4103672504425049,
0.06583040207624435,
0.26339584589004517,
0.5642391443252563,
0.09808576107025146,
-0.956660807132721,
-0.3846757113933563,
1.0404069423675537,
0.9080407023429871,
-0.17879480123519897,
-0.5933168530464172,
-0.1560746133327484,
0.36054831743240356,
-0.43256643414497375,
0.5063062310218811,
-0.1620326191186905,
-0.07939983159303665,
0.38622912764549255,
0.1911969631910324,
-0.07692558318376541,
-0.8221167325973511,
0.6984087824821472,
-0.33666980266571045,
-0.3547511100769043,
-0.16067048907279968,
-0.11014162749052048,
-0.18999287486076355,
0.5449216365814209,
-0.59737229347229,
0.7311320304870605,
-0.2027662694454193,
-0.620232105255127,
0.6045896410942078,
-0.19435161352157593,
-0.4571698009967804,
-0.1515246033668518,
-0.424111008644104,
-0.3572361171245575,
-0.15027612447738647,
-0.24608764052391052,
0.6842626333236694,
-0.30874672532081604,
0.41146522760391235,
-0.7662475109100342,
-0.22209957242012024,
0.3529510796070099,
-0.7711900472640991,
0.7993308901786804,
0.27891698479652405,
-0.4784640371799469,
-0.031329598277807236,
-0.7475565671920776,
-0.0012485256884247065,
-0.06672319769859314,
-0.28487494587898254,
-0.18238408863544464,
0.336956650018692,
0.007616627961397171,
0.3637996315956116,
0.20124012231826782,
-0.4728239178657532,
-0.07644625753164291,
-0.47498613595962524,
0.5689985752105713,
0.7689239382743835,
-0.21291007101535797,
-0.04739253595471382,
-0.2610851228237152,
0.35343125462532043,
-0.06624535471200943,
0.22558821737766266,
-0.033095598220825195,
-0.2883097529411316,
-0.6092063784599304,
-0.21907322108745575,
0.24929238855838776,
0.5624698400497437,
-0.6447374820709229,
0.41096362471580505,
-0.3385576605796814,
-0.5553264021873474,
-0.04848943278193474,
0.08501897007226944,
0.25143963098526,
0.338600754737854,
-0.10558865964412689,
-0.14682450890541077,
-0.26388058066368103,
-0.9424262046813965,
-0.07897548377513885,
-0.3472335934638977,
-0.3906204402446747,
-0.07400812953710556,
0.27422305941581726,
-0.38683828711509705,
0.8013122081756592,
-0.15263605117797852,
-0.25172069668769836,
-0.25215405225753784,
0.1541232317686081,
0.6721788048744202,
0.29939594864845276,
0.6430746912956238,
-0.6102269887924194,
-0.5331270694732666,
0.37148457765579224,
-0.8025979995727539,
-0.042164627462625504,
-0.049649037420749664,
0.03414661064743996,
0.5504069328308105,
0.1965034306049347,
-0.44341298937797546,
0.23441794514656067,
0.84475177526474,
0.18239249289035797,
0.71478271484375,
-0.17285121977329254,
-0.14690876007080078,
-1.0386292934417725,
0.26049020886421204,
0.2532491981983185,
-0.09654281288385391,
-0.6313843131065369,
0.35816138982772827,
0.07716138660907745,
0.12033160030841827,
-0.7118809223175049,
0.23020564019680023,
-0.5023356080055237,
-0.1346321702003479,
-0.2973672151565552,
0.16699904203414917,
-0.24586674571037292,
0.4451032280921936,
0.1506776511669159,
0.9313907623291016,
0.45677879452705383,
-0.8519905805587769,
0.35725677013397217,
-0.1065451130270958,
-0.6265777945518494,
0.3397679924964905,
-0.7705056071281433,
-0.17209382355213165,
0.2588622272014618,
0.0016850476386025548,
-0.7249336242675781,
-0.16072821617126465,
-0.045254070311784744,
-0.19910195469856262,
0.24174386262893677,
0.07092782855033875,
-0.7562345862388611,
-0.25581687688827515,
-0.1699391007423401,
0.12765291333198547,
0.6537842154502869,
-0.3803390860557556,
0.6053439974784851,
0.2285030484199524,
-0.04143426567316055,
-0.6525665521621704,
-0.9672330617904663,
-0.07692530006170273,
-0.35260891914367676,
-1.0119401216506958,
-0.1295778900384903,
-0.17970362305641174,
-0.39417147636413574,
-0.3562236726284027,
-0.20419615507125854,
-0.3850596845149994,
0.39711037278175354,
-0.1258506178855896,
0.18601281940937042,
-0.4661101996898651,
-0.17603397369384766,
-0.5590822696685791,
0.024076709523797035,
0.22094035148620605,
-0.018399596214294434,
0.46302762627601624,
0.021757282316684723,
-0.45891085267066956,
-0.1434589922428131,
-0.2314707338809967,
0.6385743021965027,
-0.17901526391506195,
0.9510420560836792,
0.5759619474411011,
-0.4944586455821991,
-0.5399695038795471,
-0.372470885515213,
0.020875928923487663,
-0.6159802079200745,
0.5260931849479675,
-0.25470176339149475,
-0.427394837141037,
0.8427032232284546,
-0.1283705085515976,
0.5724244117736816,
0.4196145832538605,
0.7041855454444885,
0.09000341594219208,
1.063149333000183,
0.47263699769973755,
-0.1890062838792801,
0.05029115453362465,
0.011321868747472763,
0.565434992313385,
-0.7346270680427551,
-0.11652462929487228,
-0.6634640097618103,
-0.16077549755573273,
-0.6320475935935974,
-0.33697476983070374,
0.444637268781662,
-0.09449002146720886,
-0.4249025583267212,
0.24786929786205292,
-0.11636195331811905,
0.20745369791984558,
0.29776471853256226,
-0.1603613942861557,
0.3189007639884949,
-0.07520373910665512,
-0.06548500061035156,
-0.07352195680141449,
-0.6293564438819885,
-0.8160898685455322,
0.5587804913520813,
0.6518533825874329,
0.8980273008346558,
0.19065451622009277,
0.05770929902791977,
-0.05234239995479584,
0.261930376291275,
-0.656583309173584,
0.3925069272518158,
-0.5129860639572144,
-0.6900176405906677,
-0.4009229838848114,
-0.2484831064939499,
-0.7937707901000977,
0.233818918466568,
-0.08583253622055054,
-0.7136725187301636,
0.20817676186561584,
0.07863207161426544,
-0.3118882179260254,
0.61689692735672,
-0.35937100648880005,
0.8366332650184631,
-0.8266021609306335,
-0.27780237793922424,
0.2235785275697708,
-0.40013501048088074,
0.46131062507629395,
-0.4332538843154907,
0.608975887298584,
-0.22622567415237427,
-0.047683585435152054,
0.27123939990997314,
-0.24003474414348602,
1.0504932403564453,
0.1415945291519165,
-0.7307519912719727,
0.1410914957523346,
-0.03127669915556908,
0.5978027582168579,
-0.3153155744075775,
-0.640079915523529,
0.4645802974700928,
-0.05274873971939087,
-0.2121826857328415,
-0.6183816194534302,
0.5527334213256836,
-0.6775242686271667,
-0.7290127873420715,
-0.5083499550819397,
-0.2987217605113983,
-0.2507525384426117,
0.4309975504875183,
0.41208282113075256,
0.47301045060157776,
-0.11650748550891876,
0.4822041094303131,
0.7350186705589294,
-0.6386784315109253,
0.7257567644119263,
0.5962873101234436,
-0.11538731306791306,
-0.11920387297868729,
0.7523601651191711,
0.40100404620170593,
0.4558238685131073,
0.3444521427154541,
0.05679589882493019,
-0.058950770646333694,
-0.8523789644241333,
-0.5453670024871826,
0.012929474003612995,
-0.6952399015426636,
-0.14348694682121277,
-0.2546479105949402,
-0.5280405879020691,
-0.36469215154647827,
-0.12305580824613571,
-0.4526384472846985,
0.21817785501480103,
-0.046316616237163544,
-0.09401784837245941,
-0.2789800763130188,
0.5277719497680664,
0.15947532653808594,
0.06931344419717789,
-0.8830743432044983,
0.08853106200695038,
0.09877297282218933,
0.5610824227333069,
0.28038859367370605,
-0.4769240617752075,
-0.5249314308166504,
0.4310372769832611,
-0.2792370319366455,
-0.37682583928108215,
0.3126504719257355,
0.1129935011267662,
0.7967173457145691,
0.8299074769020081,
0.2935992479324341,
0.641531229019165,
-0.42272257804870605,
1.1402682065963745,
-0.16144120693206787,
-0.9324224591255188,
0.11692611873149872,
-0.6708862781524658,
0.05588647350668907,
0.3559015095233917,
0.1976948082447052,
-0.5727806091308594,
-0.48304006457328796,
-0.14772765338420868,
-1.050994634628296,
0.57474684715271,
-0.08774206042289734,
0.33186236023902893,
0.19490574300289154,
0.4837634563446045,
0.0372258760035038,
-0.04674617573618889,
-1.0579562187194824,
-0.3633362054824829,
0.2466389387845993,
-0.1282801777124405,
-0.03329680487513542,
-0.23739324510097504,
0.021218031644821167,
0.14043501019477844,
0.7318605780601501,
0.008035298436880112,
0.045717503875494,
-0.07341155409812927,
0.16436529159545898,
0.09997499734163284,
0.23352769017219543,
0.6577474474906921,
1.013127326965332,
-0.2672420144081116,
0.10826241225004196,
0.4778740108013153,
-0.46641767024993896,
0.1262916475534439,
-0.4475204646587372,
-0.16317173838615417,
-0.07112500071525574,
0.6607944369316101,
0.5350305438041687,
-0.1747632771730423,
-0.8489567637443542,
0.4312264919281006,
0.0700947642326355,
-0.03883688896894455,
-0.7376476526260376,
0.08122432231903076,
0.05261237919330597,
0.15241052210330963,
0.27194976806640625,
-0.34351646900177,
0.12353528290987015,
-0.6410576105117798,
-0.1531611680984497,
0.47855284810066223,
0.05113924294710159,
-0.27986273169517517,
0.7674697041511536,
0.29945310950279236,
-0.08540240675210953,
0.5096137523651123,
-0.004449870903044939,
-0.5589030385017395,
0.7886622548103333,
0.6362387537956238,
0.868511974811554,
-0.055690132081508636,
-0.14345982670783997,
0.25504669547080994,
0.7010154128074646,
-0.4155149459838867,
-0.10414878278970718,
0.5858491659164429,
-0.822885274887085,
-0.5003397464752197,
-0.49104592204093933,
-0.657444417476654,
0.4310106635093689,
-0.36984312534332275,
0.5366747975349426,
-0.6098886728286743,
-0.2909024655818939,
-0.5157030820846558,
-0.045477356761693954,
-0.21581421792507172,
0.3352520763874054,
0.2869734764099121,
0.9098455309867859,
-0.6764621734619141,
0.936876654624939,
0.718080997467041,
-0.15774302184581757,
-1.1330212354660034,
0.2230340540409088,
-0.16793407499790192,
-0.7341110706329346,
0.46253764629364014,
0.24768199026584625,
-0.16505910456180573,
-0.5916220545768738,
-0.43072324991226196,
-0.9936223030090332,
1.3711917400360107,
0.35402199625968933,
-0.7772402167320251,
0.32251012325286865,
0.5033919215202332,
0.8128456473350525,
-0.05509966239333153,
0.22730599343776703,
0.4839140474796295,
0.48183032870292664,
0.045660920441150665,
-1.030137062072754,
-0.022533969953656197,
-0.13777151703834534,
0.2618541717529297,
0.026343630626797676,
-1.2301901578903198,
0.9793716073036194,
0.2948436737060547,
-0.43022504448890686,
0.13585536181926727,
0.6032357215881348,
0.4749777019023895,
0.5060721635818481,
0.3744566738605499,
0.23374582827091217,
0.6076549887657166,
-0.10353924334049225,
0.9623985290527344,
-0.6036004424095154,
0.08365951478481293,
0.8025380969047546,
-0.6304786801338196,
1.041390299797058,
-0.06331786513328552,
-0.22332046926021576,
0.5380845665931702,
0.7940258383750916,
-0.14974522590637207,
0.07387650012969971,
0.04841262474656105,
-0.11915704607963562,
-0.204498752951622,
-0.04503263905644417,
-0.46216240525245667,
0.2992742955684662,
0.173407644033432,
-0.31231531500816345,
0.22531788051128387,
-0.23505793511867523,
0.25304535031318665,
-0.1153925359249115,
-0.13388623297214508,
0.34903931617736816,
0.2298954874277115,
-0.4244563579559326,
0.6317312121391296,
0.4071446657180786,
0.9342934489250183,
-0.6840353012084961,
0.2894904613494873,
-0.36250415444374084,
0.41010650992393494,
-0.342218816280365,
-0.6975129842758179,
0.41460782289505005,
0.10268760472536087,
-0.048636097460985184,
0.07597455382347107,
0.6711386442184448,
-0.22705936431884766,
-0.5002166628837585,
0.3592134416103363,
0.1807236224412918,
0.1649385243654251,
0.1920696645975113,
-0.3506438434123993,
0.2485811412334442,
-0.02247609570622444,
-0.19791850447654724,
0.29798412322998047,
0.6978079676628113,
-0.17953655123710632,
0.8417322039604187,
0.4531075358390808,
0.2504403293132782,
0.07692766189575195,
-0.12436811625957489,
0.3879967927932739,
-0.626908004283905,
-0.17937186360359192,
-0.8603930473327637,
0.488727331161499,
0.13405722379684448,
-0.06166467443108559,
1.129472017288208,
0.2961048185825348,
0.8705108165740967,
0.05588362738490105,
0.9581374526023865,
-0.05180252343416214,
0.2128066122531891,
-0.5821247696876526,
0.7764902710914612,
-0.5609356760978699,
0.6781890392303467,
-0.3028866648674011,
-1.1607791185379028,
-0.41259875893592834,
0.3916074335575104,
-0.15871024131774902,
0.19731581211090088,
0.4106132984161377,
0.7608339786529541,
-0.05746620520949364,
-0.36248543858528137,
0.5585160851478577,
0.528117835521698,
0.4657098352909088,
0.5733768343925476,
0.7586157321929932,
-0.27000632882118225,
0.4688694477081299,
-0.3484196662902832,
-0.1566333919763565,
0.05051660165190697,
-1.1815918684005737,
-0.7922156453132629,
-0.2042054384946823,
-0.030921319499611855,
-0.2214551717042923,
-0.32001352310180664,
0.7746086120605469,
0.5514709949493408,
-0.9227811694145203,
-0.6067094206809998,
0.2905789017677307,
-0.05798825994133949,
-0.250501424074173,
-0.16059397161006927,
0.4193425476551056,
-0.3055988848209381,
-0.8752155900001526,
0.1029154509305954,
0.18763768672943115,
0.012478301301598549,
-0.4913184642791748,
-0.014348035678267479,
0.11043734103441238,
0.2180560976266861,
0.6377543807029724,
0.16484826803207397,
-0.7050156593322754,
-0.3491052985191345,
0.16561102867126465,
-0.24404674768447876,
-0.04386856034398079,
0.6132233142852783,
-0.14389733970165253,
0.06499011814594269,
0.562913179397583,
0.5963411331176758,
-0.1091381087899208,
0.04216604679822922,
0.8586523532867432,
-0.5551263689994812,
0.17748484015464783,
-0.18340352177619934,
0.42057159543037415,
0.3544832468032837,
-0.25140580534935,
0.5742497444152832,
0.09271221607923508,
-0.8402974605560303,
-0.7259409427642822,
0.07498467713594437,
-0.6733278036117554,
-0.2911650240421295,
1.3605879545211792,
-0.33488455414772034,
-0.2721537947654724,
-0.1911185085773468,
0.07557578384876251,
0.1794470101594925,
-0.037144627422094345,
0.8013310432434082,
0.7978312373161316,
0.16562262177467346,
0.06053059920668602,
-0.605383038520813,
0.11816973239183426,
0.3435533940792084,
-0.5550686717033386,
0.2206195741891861,
0.34904491901397705,
0.41631582379341125,
0.09459616988897324,
0.2853204011917114,
0.04336658492684364,
0.10067656636238098,
-0.17224721610546112,
0.09832886606454849,
0.09396010637283325,
-0.04320031404495239,
-0.3032856583595276,
0.044063348323106766,
0.7044993042945862,
0.1135198175907135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15269v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15269v3 | Improving Medical Reasoning through Retrieval and Self-Reflection with Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models | 2024-01-27T02:29:42 | 2024-06-18T02:10:15 | Minbyul Jeong, Jiwoong Sohn, Mujeen Sung, Jaewoo Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Recent proprietary large language models (LLMs), such as GPT-4, have achieved
a milestone in tackling diverse challenges in the biomedical domain, ranging
from multiple-choice questions to long-form generations. To address challenges
that still cannot be handled with the encoded knowledge of LLMs, various
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) methods have been developed by searching
documents from the knowledge corpus and appending them unconditionally or
selectively to the input of LLMs for generation. However, when applying
existing methods to different domain-specific problems, poor generalization
becomes apparent, leading to fetching incorrect documents or making inaccurate
judgments. In this paper, we introduce Self-BioRAG, a framework reliable for
biomedical text that specializes in generating explanations, retrieving
domain-specific documents, and self-reflecting generated responses. We utilize
84k filtered biomedical instruction sets to train Self-BioRAG that can assess
its generated explanations with customized reflective tokens. Our work proves
that domain-specific components, such as a retriever, domain-related document
corpus, and instruction sets are necessary for adhering to domain-related
instructions. Using three major medical question-answering benchmark datasets,
experimental results of Self-BioRAG demonstrate significant performance gains
by achieving a 7.2% absolute improvement on average over the state-of-the-art
open-foundation model with a parameter size of 7B or less. Overall, we analyze
that Self-BioRAG finds the clues in the question, retrieves relevant documents
if needed, and understands how to answer with information from retrieved
documents and encoded knowledge as a medical expert does. We release our data
and code for training our framework components and model weights (7B and 13B)
to enhance capabilities in biomedical and clinical domains. | [
-0.10748916119337082,
-0.7651383280754089,
0.9475044012069702,
0.07190047204494476,
-0.10849861055612564,
0.10730404406785965,
-0.04159082844853401,
-0.38729745149612427,
0.28341543674468994,
0.5798531174659729,
-0.3532630503177643,
-0.3859662711620331,
-0.5858517289161682,
0.4455154538154602,
-0.08181539177894592,
1.2423014640808105,
-0.06773541122674942,
0.2545939087867737,
-0.2875300943851471,
-0.258809894323349,
-0.40713250637054443,
-0.6689719557762146,
-0.25766393542289734,
-0.4335458278656006,
0.5913569331169128,
0.015599748119711876,
0.21284396946430206,
0.7097724676132202,
0.6394200325012207,
0.2870115637779236,
0.07748880982398987,
0.21829184889793396,
-0.35216352343559265,
0.4261714816093445,
-0.681873083114624,
-0.11243398487567902,
-0.5120341777801514,
-0.1053951308131218,
0.5076852440834045,
0.5845950245857239,
-0.22117950022220612,
0.36980223655700684,
0.057419806718826294,
0.6298643350601196,
-0.5599310398101807,
-0.053880129009485245,
-0.5003206729888916,
-0.027438972145318985,
-0.24008779227733612,
-0.5287407636642456,
-0.300406277179718,
0.022175850346684456,
-0.11434443295001984,
-0.4903865456581116,
0.5036867260932922,
-0.032162703573703766,
0.49021831154823303,
0.5400072336196899,
-0.3432026207447052,
-0.384160578250885,
-0.5083255171775818,
0.617718517780304,
-0.7181917428970337,
0.4911266565322876,
0.45038118958473206,
0.3307366371154785,
-0.2167760133743286,
-0.8965533375740051,
-0.34029099345207214,
0.08281818777322769,
-0.15225853025913239,
0.31802496314048767,
0.003453726414591074,
0.16249503195285797,
0.15254203975200653,
0.33009785413742065,
-0.816938042640686,
-0.1436588168144226,
-0.6075003743171692,
-0.2705387771129608,
0.5494799017906189,
0.13952180743217468,
0.24423566460609436,
-0.362519770860672,
-0.3348187506198883,
0.1044178307056427,
-0.9022783041000366,
-0.4380294978618622,
-0.12870998680591583,
-0.008971449919044971,
0.27996376156806946,
0.5999987721443176,
-0.14596399664878845,
0.7812434434890747,
0.3601769804954529,
-0.2790050208568573,
0.32711586356163025,
-0.418181836605072,
-0.2221752554178238,
-0.016528012230992317,
0.6452314853668213,
-0.016791006550192833,
-0.17639803886413574,
-0.22770333290100098,
-0.0528450608253479,
-0.10896778851747513,
0.6281682848930359,
-0.9712823033332825,
-0.09390809386968613,
0.5546340942382812,
-0.7129896283149719,
-0.1476505696773529,
-0.5272113680839539,
-0.7739516496658325,
-0.26813650131225586,
-0.1810453236103058,
0.5642708539962769,
-0.4396857023239136,
0.02967623993754387,
0.3732546865940094,
0.025091836228966713,
0.09858588129281998,
0.43340280652046204,
-1.0009902715682983,
0.12568219006061554,
0.6011459231376648,
0.6743122935295105,
-0.15007752180099487,
-0.029969049617648125,
-0.6379135251045227,
0.4868197441101074,
-0.2816962003707886,
1.018392562866211,
-0.4482642710208893,
-0.48732680082321167,
-0.21351630985736847,
-0.008264350704848766,
-0.16372975707054138,
-0.7335286140441895,
0.39748990535736084,
-0.457055926322937,
0.4167175590991974,
-0.1673264503479004,
-0.676612913608551,
-0.05727753788232803,
0.23004625737667084,
-0.25427237153053284,
0.8045353293418884,
0.11675907671451569,
-0.7936583161354065,
0.15449382364749908,
-0.6084426045417786,
-0.3200371563434601,
0.4437287449836731,
-0.6342677474021912,
-0.3410855233669281,
-0.01353366207331419,
0.23847831785678864,
0.6437689661979675,
-0.19184082746505737,
0.4487673044204712,
-0.33499637246131897,
-0.23620784282684326,
-0.1128661260008812,
-0.1798568069934845,
0.5606178641319275,
0.216923788189888,
-0.5374715924263,
-0.16951407492160797,
-0.5784526467323303,
0.13735626637935638,
-0.02577998861670494,
-0.5227712392807007,
-0.33807116746902466,
-0.09588249027729034,
-0.47029852867126465,
0.18123586475849152,
0.2805773615837097,
-0.7321324348449707,
0.22869394719600677,
-0.48025617003440857,
0.19385893642902374,
0.5610471963882446,
0.17009860277175903,
0.18843509256839752,
-0.306296706199646,
0.6989081501960754,
-0.1152036115527153,
-0.03961688280105591,
-0.36983442306518555,
-0.5585032105445862,
-0.1367914378643036,
-0.3525247871875763,
0.22688095271587372,
0.38474735617637634,
-0.7899335622787476,
0.16784793138504028,
-0.045809704810380936,
-0.2544538676738739,
-0.8678256869316101,
0.39537015557289124,
0.7259389758110046,
1.052034616470337,
0.9063933491706848,
-0.10471240431070328,
-0.3384164571762085,
-0.9007493853569031,
-0.2978174388408661,
-0.19440123438835144,
-0.0707809254527092,
0.4769163429737091,
0.5764472484588623,
-0.607631266117096,
0.7312707901000977,
-0.46308213472366333,
-0.2876817286014557,
-0.003780607134103775,
0.23006443679332733,
0.28971222043037415,
0.40019306540489197,
0.5228745341300964,
-0.648927628993988,
-0.3136034905910492,
0.039459340274333954,
-1.0272079706192017,
-0.3599666953086853,
0.038329388946294785,
-0.12027505785226822,
0.22102490067481995,
0.4518454968929291,
-0.564763069152832,
0.4532299339771271,
0.5078849196434021,
-0.32561177015304565,
0.7953705191612244,
-0.5170745849609375,
0.1530962437391281,
-0.9786321520805359,
0.4908163249492645,
-0.09246046096086502,
-0.38918060064315796,
-0.5111544132232666,
0.2478555589914322,
0.15120035409927368,
0.09696341305971146,
-0.0789644792675972,
1.009232759475708,
-0.44470587372779846,
0.08256074041128159,
-0.4177505373954773,
-0.05573974922299385,
0.3268902897834778,
0.2585192918777466,
0.06626658141613007,
0.9931606650352478,
0.19527481496334076,
-0.5298073291778564,
0.06668679416179657,
0.5908756852149963,
-0.02545662596821785,
0.621445894241333,
-0.8682755827903748,
0.27907446026802063,
-0.41114839911460876,
0.4945290684700012,
-0.6997227668762207,
-0.3206329047679901,
0.24505944550037384,
-0.47040414810180664,
0.6108706593513489,
-0.21781201660633087,
-0.27334997057914734,
-0.59501713514328,
-0.09685437381267548,
0.4239351749420166,
0.39890196919441223,
-0.6692696213722229,
0.6728217005729675,
0.3583308160305023,
-0.362691193819046,
-0.9505181908607483,
-0.47211363911628723,
-0.07221155613660812,
-0.04761650785803795,
-0.3957308232784271,
0.5130037069320679,
-0.3180406987667084,
-0.05583404377102852,
-0.10203444957733154,
-0.2567455768585205,
-0.11638756841421127,
-0.1352236419916153,
0.08807046711444855,
0.2425813227891922,
-0.17509476840496063,
0.5440442562103271,
0.31442275643348694,
-0.11966172605752945,
0.2378740906715393,
-0.3514724373817444,
0.2032713145017624,
-0.0456816591322422,
-0.3145448863506317,
0.07424180954694748,
0.42293813824653625,
0.23174767196178436,
-0.36767861247062683,
0.6312528252601624,
0.5925625562667847,
-0.18861816823482513,
-0.2307591289281845,
-0.8464443683624268,
-0.3139377236366272,
-0.4748016893863678,
0.34959712624549866,
-0.47708848118782043,
-1.0259099006652832,
0.3898201882839203,
-0.12661442160606384,
0.02921120449900627,
0.5565145611763,
0.9296066761016846,
-0.42420509457588196,
1.0702195167541504,
0.17999616265296936,
0.23293311893939972,
-0.24760816991329193,
-0.17249347269535065,
0.0035200065467506647,
-1.1197545528411865,
-0.3234035074710846,
-0.4351339638233185,
-0.03683037310838699,
-0.42859211564064026,
-0.6509065628051758,
0.8048423528671265,
-0.08652254939079285,
-0.28919312357902527,
-0.01347977016121149,
-0.8441951274871826,
0.2127886414527893,
0.41133466362953186,
0.3729269504547119,
0.3417626917362213,
-0.09434689581394196,
-0.4557044804096222,
0.056575674563646317,
-0.822540283203125,
-0.4159078001976013,
1.1097878217697144,
0.42044198513031006,
0.8755249381065369,
0.024093186482787132,
1.0036803483963013,
0.1369198113679886,
0.6308004260063171,
-0.42622244358062744,
0.3171333968639374,
-0.2065274715423584,
-1.0694321393966675,
-0.18610051274299622,
-0.6040500998497009,
-1.1477949619293213,
0.35859575867652893,
-0.11976197361946106,
-0.4692407250404358,
0.1740388721227646,
0.4329250454902649,
-0.5822417736053467,
0.11165417730808258,
-0.3488386571407318,
0.7976927161216736,
-0.3641234338283539,
-0.6266447901725769,
-0.2225174456834793,
-0.8506366014480591,
0.2638152837753296,
-0.4035617411136627,
0.2796606421470642,
0.02462107501924038,
-0.03132875636219978,
0.546686589717865,
-0.4609798192977905,
0.7866327166557312,
-0.19499309360980988,
-0.18876495957374573,
0.2948044240474701,
0.16523480415344238,
0.09647303074598312,
-0.0002750399289652705,
-0.1271357238292694,
0.06675168126821518,
0.3657825291156769,
-0.3605392277240753,
-0.7568166255950928,
0.5535009503364563,
-0.4865701198577881,
-0.9112284779548645,
-0.2723934054374695,
-0.3315890431404114,
-0.3059721291065216,
0.2575854957103729,
0.337024450302124,
0.6952597498893738,
0.06372693926095963,
0.21671678125858307,
0.8228886127471924,
-0.5900880694389343,
-0.01014657225459814,
0.7527989149093628,
-0.31931838393211365,
-0.4292967915534973,
0.7932432293891907,
0.12737588584423065,
0.00011252025433350354,
0.34467649459838867,
0.3614587187767029,
-0.5470553636550903,
-0.5511609315872192,
-0.8012576103210449,
0.7277964949607849,
-0.6829946041107178,
-0.6869785189628601,
-0.9316474199295044,
-0.20767782628536224,
-0.5523509383201599,
0.10018264502286911,
-0.13114961981773376,
-0.28410106897354126,
-0.1720161885023117,
-0.00322659476660192,
0.21845008432865143,
0.8969850540161133,
-0.20952415466308594,
-0.06464430689811707,
-1.0890930891036987,
0.492319792509079,
0.20705167949199677,
0.49773550033569336,
-0.21729102730751038,
-0.7823420763015747,
-0.3393881618976593,
-0.033730506896972656,
-0.31519562005996704,
-1.165378451347351,
0.3830656409263611,
0.1907302588224411,
0.7042832970619202,
0.08881582319736481,
-0.20647306740283966,
0.5389161109924316,
-0.9258570671081543,
0.3459557890892029,
-0.13855859637260437,
-0.5607585310935974,
0.6708422899246216,
-0.5959805250167847,
0.17280107736587524,
0.666001558303833,
0.5091813802719116,
-0.20678414404392242,
-0.28390705585479736,
-0.675864577293396,
-0.4775167405605316,
0.1710420399904251,
-0.06412473320960999,
0.11621583998203278,
-0.3426415026187897,
0.9229794144630432,
0.14748898148536682,
0.213137686252594,
-0.5318078398704529,
-0.054000332951545715,
-0.17958860099315643,
-0.5071792006492615,
0.07672969251871109,
-0.25589796900749207,
-0.16854652762413025,
-0.4092006981372833,
0.6643133163452148,
-0.5752545595169067,
0.4165209233760834,
0.695106565952301,
0.06537099927663803,
-0.047160807996988297,
0.21516801416873932,
0.4068010151386261,
0.5215232372283936,
-0.1361503005027771,
0.0771280825138092,
0.14183852076530457,
-0.4856199622154236,
0.13199351727962494,
0.15851598978042603,
-0.0006231095176190138,
-0.043115947395563126,
0.3634915351867676,
0.11047231405973434,
0.15229827165603638,
-0.7070269584655762,
0.565475344657898,
0.1602908968925476,
-0.24937736988067627,
-0.03851604089140892,
0.03361982852220535,
0.020735902711749077,
0.1754889041185379,
0.28977346420288086,
-0.24757304787635803,
0.6021504402160645,
-0.3652264177799225,
0.40686216950416565,
0.5865982174873352,
-0.06807085871696472,
-0.1962296962738037,
0.9527000188827515,
0.07907978445291519,
0.010521434247493744,
0.35924336314201355,
0.05689805746078491,
-0.49254852533340454,
0.2545630633831024,
0.8423981070518494,
0.5565266609191895,
-0.5606494545936584,
0.35366538166999817,
0.47931158542633057,
-0.10109612345695496,
-0.10724551975727081,
0.33798423409461975,
-0.13222701847553253,
-0.5598756670951843,
-0.7465834021568298,
-0.8334611654281616,
-0.390533983707428,
-0.06340937316417694,
-0.43291547894477844,
-0.13656869530677795,
-0.3815995156764984,
-0.3025726079940796,
0.01783372275531292,
-0.03747432306408882,
-0.539906919002533,
0.40698307752609253,
-0.1434514969587326,
0.824760913848877,
-0.34669795632362366,
0.732111930847168,
0.7614408731460571,
-0.47233763337135315,
-0.8199795484542847,
-0.3190826177597046,
-0.17160528898239136,
-0.9359174966812134,
0.8305354714393616,
-0.06276662647724152,
-0.20071934163570404,
-0.07896673679351807,
-0.6091799736022949,
-0.7762778401374817,
0.9188171029090881,
0.2653007209300995,
-0.4752114415168762,
-0.3737674355506897,
-0.09604902565479279,
0.874167263507843,
-0.2588789463043213,
0.2795011103153229,
0.2792741060256958,
0.3435678780078888,
0.0018864489393308759,
-0.9294528365135193,
0.13686393201351166,
-0.36382773518562317,
-0.31312209367752075,
0.04436979442834854,
-0.6176508069038391,
0.5406420826911926,
-0.25976213812828064,
0.08221101015806198,
0.0894569456577301,
0.3747853934764862,
0.6225487589836121,
0.39756613969802856,
0.020008688792586327,
0.4726274311542511,
0.841286301612854,
0.28148919343948364,
1.3771708011627197,
-0.4684208035469055,
0.31653261184692383,
1.1581703424453735,
-0.36536988615989685,
0.760063111782074,
0.30769234895706177,
0.04900089278817177,
0.8220347166061401,
0.24548770487308502,
0.01763645000755787,
0.2975744605064392,
0.05449449270963669,
-0.37425297498703003,
-0.29129549860954285,
0.04995701089501381,
-0.5186973810195923,
0.48685795068740845,
0.4400782585144043,
-0.7280170321464539,
-0.18295536935329437,
0.04618573188781738,
0.029335983097553253,
0.19430890679359436,
-0.16372497379779816,
0.8323072791099548,
0.2518710792064667,
-0.7603391408920288,
0.5412638187408447,
-0.0821080282330513,
0.3671714663505554,
-0.42907533049583435,
-0.3354753851890564,
-0.25693586468696594,
0.1870475560426712,
-0.2343803346157074,
-0.6839878559112549,
0.315445214509964,
0.015286418609321117,
-0.22398339211940765,
-0.3307226896286011,
1.1546145677566528,
-0.3675268590450287,
-0.45258843898773193,
0.27583077549934387,
0.8378409743309021,
0.24731270968914032,
0.09087271243333817,
-0.7808085680007935,
-0.1693311184644699,
-0.20726394653320312,
-0.17141976952552795,
0.3167959451675415,
0.3165852725505829,
0.18846207857131958,
0.7801185846328735,
0.3729836344718933,
0.25913965702056885,
-0.1495380997657776,
-0.12695783376693726,
0.8805371522903442,
-0.5266426205635071,
-0.1743198186159134,
-0.620093822479248,
0.19668124616146088,
-0.02346726693212986,
-0.04159585013985634,
0.6123582720756531,
0.540825366973877,
0.44469016790390015,
-0.04198994114995003,
0.6803061962127686,
0.22810421884059906,
1.182055950164795,
-0.499702125787735,
0.8811349868774414,
-0.6177105903625488,
0.19071857631206512,
-0.13615021109580994,
-0.6482352018356323,
-0.22431622445583344,
0.8431445956230164,
-0.3607643246650696,
0.44128549098968506,
0.6741020083427429,
0.5825903415679932,
-0.012440843507647514,
-0.1949075311422348,
0.25751808285713196,
0.47100916504859924,
0.27325907349586487,
0.3102743327617645,
0.5182012915611267,
-0.31105518341064453,
0.2137010395526886,
0.11443080008029938,
-0.29051265120506287,
0.01772315427660942,
-0.6244185566902161,
-0.8469402194023132,
-0.37349367141723633,
-0.1884203404188156,
-0.6418286561965942,
0.41374555230140686,
0.8196343183517456,
0.7786623239517212,
-0.5397058725357056,
0.14116835594177246,
0.24771933257579803,
-0.1490963101387024,
0.21732284128665924,
-0.1549263894557953,
0.3203633427619934,
-0.6095956563949585,
-0.2955492436885834,
0.6568389534950256,
0.4390327036380768,
-0.11022458225488663,
-0.33120012283325195,
-0.027221065014600754,
0.022441772744059563,
0.13435085117816925,
0.5666065812110901,
0.5294325947761536,
-0.47421905398368835,
-0.3335605561733246,
0.19782516360282898,
-0.2473560869693756,
0.20677191019058228,
0.7450740933418274,
-1.1660735607147217,
0.542502224445343,
0.22080658376216888,
0.9976943731307983,
0.6959841251373291,
0.2618614435195923,
0.6626814007759094,
-0.6128314137458801,
-0.4792029559612274,
0.3515782952308655,
0.3685551881790161,
0.4067409336566925,
-0.5372569561004639,
0.7907887101173401,
0.2522311210632324,
-0.9815133810043335,
-0.5794591903686523,
-0.00434656348079443,
-0.5870556235313416,
-0.42649221420288086,
1.1175241470336914,
-0.13877885043621063,
-0.3303079307079315,
-0.2756206691265106,
-0.20888294279575348,
0.07529360800981522,
0.09756211936473846,
1.0366730690002441,
0.3022150993347168,
-0.4190974831581116,
0.02597007155418396,
-0.654529333114624,
0.6195047497749329,
0.6794456243515015,
-0.959918737411499,
-0.04046179726719856,
0.6317270398139954,
0.5714228749275208,
0.1546575129032135,
1.11530339717865,
-0.4377244710922241,
0.3961229622364044,
-0.35785195231437683,
0.017188267782330513,
0.15056833624839783,
-0.38973984122276306,
-0.34468621015548706,
0.041318196803331375,
-0.21132294833660126,
0.30554062128067017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01722v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01722v1 | Enhancing Large Language Model Performance To Answer Questions and Extract Information More Accurately | 2024-01-27T00:18:07 | 2024-01-27T00:18:07 | Liang Zhang, Katherine Jijo, Spurthi Setty, Eden Chung, Fatima Javid, Natan Vidra, Tommy Clifford | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) generate responses to questions; however, their
effectiveness is often hindered by sub-optimal quality of answers and
occasional failures to provide accurate responses to questions. To address
these challenges, a fine-tuning process is employed, involving feedback and
examples to refine models. The objective is to enhance AI models through
continuous feedback loops, utilizing metrics such as cosine similarity, LLM
evaluation and Rouge-L scores to evaluate the models. Leveraging LLMs like
GPT-3.5, GPT4ALL, and LLaMA2, and Claude, this approach is benchmarked on
financial datasets, including the FinanceBench and RAG Instruct Benchmark
Tester Dataset, illustrating the necessity of fine-tuning. The results showcase
the capability of fine-tuned models to surpass the accuracy of zero-shot LLMs,
providing superior question and answering capabilities. Notably, the
combination of fine-tuning the LLM with a process known as Retrieval Augmented
Generation (RAG) proves to generate responses with improved accuracy. | [
-0.3016549050807953,
-1.0202034711837769,
0.47000887989997864,
-0.19969354569911957,
-0.162942036986351,
0.39035969972610474,
-0.4556763172149658,
-0.5968963503837585,
-0.20602552592754364,
0.7633256912231445,
-0.40994328260421753,
-0.3207911550998688,
-0.4877541661262512,
0.00959017314016819,
-0.3399823307991028,
1.1363487243652344,
0.057761792093515396,
0.08519629389047623,
0.011113417334854603,
-0.058309026062488556,
-0.5102607011795044,
-0.38690266013145447,
-1.180483341217041,
-0.591833770275116,
0.4986625909805298,
0.49900367856025696,
0.7091960310935974,
0.5534043908119202,
0.7625720500946045,
0.26899537444114685,
-0.03545070439577103,
0.3917844295501709,
-0.7507548928260803,
0.11383238434791565,
-0.16215620934963226,
-0.5257065296173096,
-0.589889407157898,
-0.0551009401679039,
0.5881136059761047,
0.49202319979667664,
-0.20217232406139374,
0.4087130129337311,
0.1255321204662323,
0.6688312292098999,
-0.4535446763038635,
0.2563004195690155,
-0.6992738842964172,
-0.39337655901908875,
-0.09890320897102356,
-0.3309991955757141,
-0.33846142888069153,
-0.5909836292266846,
-0.045851513743400574,
-0.4601272940635681,
0.16119243204593658,
0.07031622529029846,
0.9772661328315735,
0.3540307879447937,
-0.06020992994308472,
-0.39842304587364197,
-0.8430027961730957,
0.6555271148681641,
-0.9600324034690857,
0.19945570826530457,
0.2903594672679901,
0.3961193859577179,
-0.20597907900810242,
-0.5672621726989746,
-0.31960973143577576,
-0.5400554537773132,
0.01767965406179428,
-0.029943378642201424,
-0.0009987225057557225,
0.09338530153036118,
0.38054031133651733,
0.489996999502182,
-0.3861183226108551,
0.35041749477386475,
-0.3105775713920593,
-0.08293862640857697,
0.8044055700302124,
0.29655760526657104,
-0.03547258302569389,
0.1536877602338791,
0.05261726677417755,
-0.3470194935798645,
-0.6936580538749695,
0.026416674256324768,
0.47843611240386963,
0.4643954932689667,
0.11070302128791809,
0.6263877153396606,
-0.3045051693916321,
0.717062771320343,
0.1120910793542862,
-0.2266211062669754,
0.07537161558866501,
-0.3462858200073242,
-0.21954770386219025,
-0.36219239234924316,
0.3105964958667755,
0.2920847237110138,
0.66221022605896,
-0.11197992414236069,
-0.4474357068538666,
-0.15029624104499817,
0.19531883299350739,
-0.8276998400688171,
-0.16249746084213257,
0.21113264560699463,
-0.2829265892505646,
-0.24204406142234802,
0.05379588529467583,
-0.7163472771644592,
-0.3072092831134796,
-0.6756686568260193,
0.3859727084636688,
-0.29815399646759033,
-0.10332832485437393,
0.12425484508275986,
-0.19417595863342285,
0.45247524976730347,
0.529351532459259,
-0.8253584504127502,
0.43669161200523376,
0.9777493476867676,
0.5573945641517639,
-0.17309586703777313,
0.04524488374590874,
-0.8353968858718872,
0.16780558228492737,
-0.4302835464477539,
0.756777822971344,
-0.6154892444610596,
-0.18479910492897034,
-0.15285515785217285,
-0.18856625258922577,
0.09312642365694046,
-0.8676601648330688,
0.4020710587501526,
-0.6514037251472473,
-0.047825250774621964,
-0.20679327845573425,
-0.7783454656600952,
-0.08601494133472443,
0.5534301996231079,
-0.45010972023010254,
1.0951414108276367,
0.13009345531463623,
-0.364294171333313,
0.13323931396007538,
-0.752188503742218,
-0.2079751342535019,
0.043465085327625275,
-0.088312529027462,
-0.46913576126098633,
0.24536070227622986,
0.41780832409858704,
0.49565181136131287,
-0.6166543960571289,
0.18523716926574707,
-0.32183343172073364,
-0.4680592715740204,
0.18825367093086243,
-0.5028120875358582,
0.22575321793556213,
0.1598760336637497,
-0.19792312383651733,
0.28185415267944336,
-0.9357767701148987,
0.18619005382061005,
0.19139938056468964,
-0.3923253118991852,
-0.2561083137989044,
-0.1540294587612152,
0.04321737959980965,
-0.20127105712890625,
0.35805898904800415,
-0.30328813195228577,
0.19308553636074066,
-0.6170333027839661,
0.25680187344551086,
0.8389950394630432,
0.1427040547132492,
0.3168928623199463,
-0.4978445768356323,
0.6046812534332275,
-0.17393171787261963,
-0.01394391804933548,
-0.21645650267601013,
-0.1156703382730484,
-0.8143330216407776,
-0.0892147347331047,
0.4699665606021881,
0.5984880328178406,
-0.4613843858242035,
0.12602047622203827,
-0.0947999656200409,
-0.6445462703704834,
-0.5575811266899109,
0.4117574393749237,
0.2338758409023285,
0.48858457803726196,
0.30311232805252075,
-0.1950094997882843,
-0.36688193678855896,
-0.8610266447067261,
-0.2632902264595032,
-0.010951703414320946,
-0.1745457798242569,
0.5167748332023621,
0.40281519293785095,
-0.05033889412879944,
0.5545344352722168,
-0.6057890057563782,
0.09489797800779343,
-0.20293717086315155,
0.26188215613365173,
0.4400191307067871,
0.31714728474617004,
0.3884330093860626,
-0.6424132585525513,
-0.44309842586517334,
0.13559597730636597,
-0.4259951114654541,
-0.13231347501277924,
-0.13584627211093903,
0.14607150852680206,
0.284238338470459,
0.6522628664970398,
-0.3788990378379822,
0.2337884157896042,
0.36913028359413147,
-0.05954616516828537,
0.5026773810386658,
-0.33328577876091003,
0.0669320747256279,
-1.008354902267456,
0.25542551279067993,
-0.08923763781785965,
-0.43460437655448914,
-0.4210362434387207,
0.3394102156162262,
-0.015861541032791138,
0.011592751368880272,
-0.022961417213082314,
0.6968808174133301,
-0.48031488060951233,
-0.1707611083984375,
-0.4778754413127899,
0.27335935831069946,
-0.12799295783042908,
0.3057328462600708,
-0.3543066382408142,
1.0644502639770508,
0.38063982129096985,
-0.5387411117553711,
0.4898817539215088,
-0.02693849243223667,
-0.4517221450805664,
0.3618592619895935,
-0.8789137601852417,
0.2468719482421875,
-0.15443503856658936,
-0.012423256412148476,
-0.8392241597175598,
-0.3128686845302582,
-0.10489951074123383,
-0.19256624579429626,
0.4665429890155792,
0.1541568785905838,
-0.5318443775177002,
-0.2859610617160797,
-0.2704588770866394,
0.12459117919206619,
0.5300705432891846,
-0.42613211274147034,
0.3667014539241791,
0.24197782576084137,
-0.4462641775608063,
-0.537996232509613,
-0.2604845464229584,
0.010417100973427296,
-0.226954385638237,
-0.42920970916748047,
0.017947165295481682,
-0.17115560173988342,
-0.43531420826911926,
-0.2567284405231476,
0.13069891929626465,
0.2242964208126068,
0.3099902272224426,
-0.05483180284500122,
0.3690164089202881,
-0.27112337946891785,
0.2238694429397583,
-0.20335258543491364,
-0.16420719027519226,
-0.19403739273548126,
-0.07329703122377396,
0.7638466358184814,
-0.06494490057229996,
-0.37327829003334045,
-0.27735692262649536,
0.11105214059352875,
0.5956246256828308,
-0.3724989891052246,
0.5544718503952026,
0.4807446599006653,
-0.25523295998573303,
-0.13871139287948608,
-0.6985180974006653,
-0.3687717616558075,
-0.4667905271053314,
0.4467439651489258,
-0.34319278597831726,
-1.2437009811401367,
0.6587908267974854,
-0.2593316435813904,
0.04777982085943222,
0.49373871088027954,
0.810209333896637,
0.03689134493470192,
1.0419200658798218,
0.8361484408378601,
-0.34459155797958374,
0.4459289014339447,
-0.15771876275539398,
0.15052756667137146,
-0.7811061143875122,
-0.03678064048290253,
-0.6467946171760559,
-0.26377230882644653,
-0.620206892490387,
-0.3820590674877167,
0.2800069749355316,
0.38652321696281433,
-0.28451061248779297,
0.19096310436725616,
-0.27953019738197327,
0.5919332504272461,
0.47912320494651794,
-0.04596124589443207,
0.2880525588989258,
-0.09845241159200668,
-0.051901523023843765,
0.16530181467533112,
-0.508776068687439,
-0.6368906497955322,
1.1294922828674316,
0.6271865367889404,
1.029259204864502,
-0.04198042303323746,
0.428055077791214,
0.08655165135860443,
0.38192376494407654,
-0.6676651239395142,
0.3496647775173187,
-0.1060279980301857,
-0.49910563230514526,
-0.4597492814064026,
-0.5338628888130188,
-0.6121761202812195,
-0.121361643075943,
-0.05551474913954735,
-0.8040382266044617,
-0.10585657507181168,
0.12793296575546265,
-0.5409195423126221,
0.02010902389883995,
-0.5028703808784485,
0.6136394739151001,
-0.27291133999824524,
-0.4012001156806946,
-0.4058951437473297,
-0.33570533990859985,
0.2788721024990082,
-0.3818514943122864,
-0.006615906022489071,
-0.27999117970466614,
0.014807775616645813,
0.36743828654289246,
-0.331235408782959,
0.704790472984314,
-0.008607538416981697,
-0.4063454270362854,
0.20836706459522247,
-0.08251237124204636,
0.742743730545044,
0.2088068574666977,
-0.3674660921096802,
-0.06227059289813042,
-0.03880094364285469,
-0.3606158494949341,
-0.6130544543266296,
0.7208203673362732,
-0.684947669506073,
-0.7627847194671631,
-0.005635194480419159,
-0.8591787219047546,
-0.4456759989261627,
0.02146853134036064,
-0.11449744552373886,
0.3310060501098633,
-0.14528198540210724,
0.26958975195884705,
0.4501142203807831,
-0.24203898012638092,
0.34673961997032166,
0.5675461888313293,
-0.3463219702243805,
-0.3827492892742157,
0.618264377117157,
0.07549569010734558,
0.4009706676006317,
0.2960970997810364,
0.1253901571035385,
-0.4290987551212311,
-0.6693081855773926,
-0.36609920859336853,
0.31344130635261536,
-0.47906285524368286,
-0.4534524381160736,
-0.2683592140674591,
-0.40236878395080566,
-0.5829965472221375,
0.09013362228870392,
-0.3159245550632477,
-0.2728966176509857,
-0.2674087584018707,
-0.14071674644947052,
0.4953799843788147,
0.8367772102355957,
-0.11002013087272644,
0.347854882478714,
-0.8579646348953247,
0.35393375158309937,
0.2390161007642746,
0.5811680555343628,
0.14857009053230286,
-0.7096584439277649,
-0.43190380930900574,
0.1251973807811737,
-0.34394314885139465,
-0.4045671820640564,
0.23604469001293182,
0.2272421419620514,
0.3960167169570923,
0.2106069028377533,
-0.17843179404735565,
0.9957518577575684,
-0.48502933979034424,
0.4960528612136841,
-0.24410486221313477,
-0.7574904561042786,
0.6300448179244995,
-0.4570964574813843,
0.41408705711364746,
0.5532776713371277,
0.1715008020401001,
-0.36810362339019775,
-0.6004796028137207,
-0.3851323425769806,
-0.7708418965339661,
0.538458526134491,
0.012046165764331818,
0.2495514154434204,
0.16985589265823364,
0.8530658483505249,
0.09692918509244919,
0.16986730694770813,
-0.418619304895401,
0.05353827029466629,
0.36453357338905334,
-0.18161359429359436,
-0.3546629250049591,
-0.28370144963264465,
0.004101322963833809,
-0.34048986434936523,
0.7828385233879089,
-0.37850895524024963,
-0.23470591008663177,
-0.013674565590918064,
0.1619306057691574,
-0.3280138075351715,
0.22507016360759735,
0.7017729878425598,
0.9688562750816345,
-0.20411276817321777,
-0.2059139907360077,
0.42294609546661377,
-0.1941453367471695,
-0.056362710893154144,
0.18603865802288055,
-0.1551220715045929,
-0.2310963273048401,
0.30166664719581604,
0.7331963181495667,
-0.029722312465310097,
-0.8367077112197876,
0.10937042534351349,
-0.18625715374946594,
0.04686613380908966,
-0.34897708892822266,
0.4607500731945038,
0.13396848738193512,
0.5647653341293335,
0.4161545932292938,
-0.0923725813627243,
-0.005772809498012066,
-0.6196550726890564,
0.33962392807006836,
0.6228375434875488,
-0.21938633918762207,
-0.0020237041171640158,
0.6041244268417358,
-0.043988145887851715,
-0.3852424919605255,
0.6882352232933044,
0.24392016232013702,
-0.35866817831993103,
0.6841223835945129,
0.6218695044517517,
0.5635554194450378,
-0.17089831829071045,
0.01992795616388321,
0.49856075644493103,
0.2543780505657196,
-0.2869020998477936,
0.4324580132961273,
0.11221230030059814,
-0.59763503074646,
-0.8101055026054382,
-0.8672732710838318,
-0.6289626359939575,
0.43914636969566345,
-0.735678493976593,
0.3479255139827728,
-0.5752313733100891,
-0.02181163616478443,
-0.008588545024394989,
0.1818189024925232,
-0.5903956294059753,
0.2701173722743988,
0.10663466155529022,
1.0512614250183105,
-0.42426127195358276,
0.8328275084495544,
0.501271665096283,
-0.3346259295940399,
-1.0030378103256226,
0.01487934309989214,
-0.3153168857097626,
-0.8403075933456421,
0.46089163422584534,
0.06883536279201508,
-0.030147774145007133,
0.16452351212501526,
-0.702372670173645,
-0.8758523464202881,
0.9136164784431458,
0.6138601303100586,
-1.0258837938308716,
0.12444353848695755,
0.38596197962760925,
0.7584388852119446,
-0.33736732602119446,
0.28438517451286316,
0.8382455706596375,
0.4773280918598175,
0.2267962545156479,
-1.018750548362732,
-0.24674130976200104,
-0.06414467096328735,
-0.003304112935438752,
0.3385794460773468,
-0.5955368876457214,
0.6872841119766235,
-0.22605063021183014,
0.060674168169498444,
0.34029993414878845,
0.6414141058921814,
0.3475380539894104,
0.16864293813705444,
0.30492427945137024,
0.7053756713867188,
0.9474501609802246,
-0.2547436058521271,
1.2020869255065918,
-0.4675862491130829,
0.39386478066444397,
1.3726351261138916,
-0.37465202808380127,
1.1375430822372437,
0.33077800273895264,
0.03133711218833923,
0.22634835541248322,
0.6956418752670288,
-0.23724624514579773,
0.2871330976486206,
0.45111024379730225,
-0.04963516816496849,
-0.3382008671760559,
-0.13852344453334808,
-0.20118394494056702,
0.5888479351997375,
0.29290908575057983,
-0.2463042289018631,
-0.1650826334953308,
-0.15645016729831696,
-0.09045742452144623,
0.15871737897396088,
-0.40266215801239014,
1.0128467082977295,
0.14435797929763794,
-0.6945173740386963,
0.48305198550224304,
0.15421056747436523,
0.4537266492843628,
-0.5460497736930847,
-0.1566806137561798,
-0.44011440873146057,
0.45825478434562683,
0.0965910255908966,
-0.6544627547264099,
0.40881747007369995,
0.20200005173683167,
-0.22098487615585327,
-0.07212340086698532,
0.7581746578216553,
-0.41399121284484863,
-0.7248375415802002,
0.3305174708366394,
0.42105039954185486,
0.04885030910372734,
-0.026384679600596428,
-0.7139241695404053,
0.03681926801800728,
-0.14753009378910065,
-0.2495734989643097,
0.16451625525951385,
0.2937849164009094,
-0.002236327389255166,
0.6934069991111755,
0.7641720771789551,
0.3035368025302887,
-0.17336688935756683,
0.31661155819892883,
0.7958253026008606,
-0.642913281917572,
-0.20549258589744568,
-1.0850932598114014,
0.2460586577653885,
-0.17417190968990326,
-0.24437375366687775,
0.6709307432174683,
0.6858091354370117,
0.9765701293945312,
0.03552084043622017,
0.5613727569580078,
0.3498567044734955,
0.8768040537834167,
-0.5071681141853333,
0.6922324299812317,
-0.6499032974243164,
0.4352141320705414,
-0.19527727365493774,
-1.0612949132919312,
-0.24902082979679108,
0.36784103512763977,
-0.35367313027381897,
0.0727991834282875,
0.2305610477924347,
1.0251109600067139,
-0.01385227870196104,
-0.09518363326787949,
0.4582027792930603,
0.4001644551753998,
0.40769314765930176,
0.2948019206523895,
0.7296422719955444,
-0.551815390586853,
0.385552316904068,
-0.02850208431482315,
0.010288103483617306,
-0.16794425249099731,
-0.837639570236206,
-0.845518171787262,
-0.21067842841148376,
-0.2560788691043854,
-0.1672646552324295,
0.07645460218191147,
0.7479485273361206,
0.5278449058532715,
-1.0066611766815186,
-0.45235875248908997,
0.06359318643808365,
-0.04351598769426346,
0.07398617267608643,
-0.2369501292705536,
0.20935560762882233,
-0.6625024080276489,
-0.8137097954750061,
0.3753536343574524,
0.5114440321922302,
0.0494876392185688,
-0.34838956594467163,
-0.06063094362616539,
-0.008853591978549957,
0.3311193585395813,
0.48162922263145447,
0.08757813274860382,
-0.4963234066963196,
-0.5228527188301086,
0.02819439396262169,
-0.0917278453707695,
0.04261482506990433,
0.673175036907196,
-0.46850553154945374,
0.09276626259088516,
0.37576180696487427,
0.9510390162467957,
0.5342073440551758,
0.24451230466365814,
0.7705310583114624,
-0.636390745639801,
0.00347203784622252,
0.20537130534648895,
0.15038485825061798,
0.38017207384109497,
-0.3669375777244568,
0.6356565356254578,
-0.1491059511899948,
-0.8022441267967224,
-0.6948660016059875,
0.0773482695221901,
-0.6994073390960693,
-0.25859054923057556,
1.1167038679122925,
0.05347031354904175,
-0.24860386550426483,
0.05564703792333603,
-0.306100070476532,
0.23186714947223663,
-0.276620090007782,
0.8101415634155273,
0.793854832649231,
-0.1704287976026535,
-0.34252727031707764,
-0.7723181843757629,
0.4904612600803375,
0.43452197313308716,
-1.003279447555542,
0.21775229275226593,
0.3973255455493927,
0.40166255831718445,
0.03140627220273018,
0.4281632900238037,
-0.09036675095558167,
0.169502392411232,
-0.2756797969341278,
-0.23961752653121948,
0.08009037375450134,
-0.20293225347995758,
-0.3551619350910187,
0.2763923406600952,
0.3889981508255005,
0.16160066425800323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15241v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15241v2 | Unlearning Traces the Influential Training Data of Language Models | 2024-01-26T23:17:31 | 2024-06-13T16:28:47 | Masaru Isonuma, Ivan Titov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Identifying the training datasets that influence a language model's outputs
is essential for minimizing the generation of harmful content and enhancing its
performance. Ideally, we can measure the influence of each dataset by removing
it from training; however, it is prohibitively expensive to retrain a model
multiple times. This paper presents UnTrac: unlearning traces the influence of
a training dataset on the model's performance. UnTrac is extremely simple; each
training dataset is unlearned by gradient ascent, and we evaluate how much the
model's predictions change after unlearning. Furthermore, we propose a more
scalable approach, UnTrac-Inv, which unlearns a test dataset and evaluates the
unlearned model on training datasets. UnTrac-Inv resembles UnTrac, while being
efficient for massive training datasets. In the experiments, we examine if our
methods can assess the influence of pretraining datasets on generating toxic,
biased, and untruthful content. Our methods estimate their influence much more
accurately than existing methods while requiring neither excessive memory space
nor multiple checkpoints. | [
0.03781147673726082,
-0.35562533140182495,
0.10629197210073471,
-0.09948673844337463,
-0.19968251883983612,
0.4655309021472931,
-0.2802640497684479,
-0.08173831552267075,
-0.12890778481960297,
0.7540769577026367,
-0.5004148483276367,
-0.45135217905044556,
-0.5517200231552124,
-0.5205318927764893,
-0.8416351079940796,
1.1808918714523315,
0.15270231664180756,
0.22860056161880493,
-0.34686926007270813,
-0.24969860911369324,
-0.3376865088939667,
-0.4657903015613556,
-0.37666359543800354,
-0.5452606081962585,
0.39075809717178345,
0.4696859121322632,
0.3433848023414612,
0.49510467052459717,
0.11082160472869873,
0.2568817138671875,
-0.10380050539970398,
-0.2736319899559021,
-1.0080832242965698,
0.07933448255062103,
-0.12545843422412872,
-0.3940201699733734,
0.2441476583480835,
-0.006561787333339453,
0.7892540097236633,
0.9150683283805847,
-0.33720579743385315,
0.40526559948921204,
0.40591683983802795,
0.7592400908470154,
-0.8619982600212097,
0.15897463262081146,
-0.5939126014709473,
-0.35184258222579956,
-0.40519070625305176,
-0.23410044610500336,
-0.7293940782546997,
-0.07644440978765488,
-0.14292876422405243,
-0.47524771094322205,
0.16044828295707703,
-0.3172830641269684,
0.2808234393596649,
0.29050830006599426,
-0.623150110244751,
-0.09057123214006424,
-1.0679644346237183,
1.0038211345672607,
-0.5568575263023376,
0.4749484956264496,
0.29934510588645935,
0.07926373928785324,
-0.4067458510398865,
-0.9198616743087769,
-0.2674625515937805,
0.018885495141148567,
-0.012965388596057892,
0.1614583283662796,
-0.4685066342353821,
-0.1917342096567154,
0.21149767935276031,
0.20338186621665955,
-0.2879430055618286,
0.34546729922294617,
-0.6658231019973755,
-0.23940302431583405,
0.44115281105041504,
0.09195782244205475,
0.48188233375549316,
0.21988555788993835,
-0.14114262163639069,
-0.06916160881519318,
-1.0356965065002441,
0.2121846228837967,
0.4022687077522278,
0.24453170597553253,
0.2356775403022766,
0.2915695905685425,
-0.14054550230503082,
0.39763763546943665,
-0.4126942455768585,
0.11729195713996887,
0.35112839937210083,
-0.2356053739786148,
-0.019572343677282333,
-0.018851181492209435,
0.8411322236061096,
0.15731018781661987,
0.5000031590461731,
-0.46407100558280945,
-0.15813913941383362,
0.07588239759206772,
0.33480575680732727,
-0.8886656165122986,
-0.40197086334228516,
-0.21847879886627197,
-0.47044432163238525,
-0.38592350482940674,
0.18178091943264008,
-0.9996029138565063,
-0.47085991501808167,
-0.20888175070285797,
0.26650097966194153,
-0.24046747386455536,
-0.23063719272613525,
-0.02093510702252388,
0.014364589005708694,
0.005978330038487911,
0.08707331120967865,
-0.8834767937660217,
0.31086161732673645,
0.34307724237442017,
0.5720643997192383,
-0.06885841488838196,
-0.43742039799690247,
-0.6929275989532471,
-0.18412083387374878,
-0.3454268276691437,
0.7198760509490967,
-0.6916326880455017,
-0.3233700692653656,
0.20418965816497803,
0.127911776304245,
0.10972706973552704,
-0.4874974489212036,
0.4501696228981018,
-0.5442176461219788,
0.20513427257537842,
-0.2487124800682068,
-0.7945974469184875,
-0.3888303339481354,
-0.4936610162258148,
-0.760221004486084,
1.2672017812728882,
0.3080005943775177,
-0.8783684968948364,
0.47731146216392517,
-0.5563473105430603,
-0.49608445167541504,
0.15778326988220215,
0.05928518995642662,
-0.3403113782405853,
0.20979872345924377,
0.06962818652391434,
0.3743928372859955,
-0.4608767330646515,
0.2210017293691635,
-0.32376936078071594,
-0.416197270154953,
0.22446562349796295,
-0.42916733026504517,
1.3283804655075073,
0.0846366360783577,
-0.41766247153282166,
-0.0210258886218071,
-1.0215349197387695,
0.09288676828145981,
-0.000036592107790056616,
-0.4792461693286896,
-0.6329190135002136,
0.14756503701210022,
-0.07496705651283264,
0.13303142786026,
-0.31019729375839233,
-0.7574805021286011,
-0.13107910752296448,
-0.18141500651836395,
0.4266524016857147,
0.6814277768135071,
0.23021557927131653,
0.6108971834182739,
-0.022263500839471817,
0.3842068612575531,
-0.18371018767356873,
0.1222880631685257,
-0.1491549164056778,
-0.31809037923812866,
-0.7533716559410095,
-0.06016030162572861,
0.5892082452774048,
0.23849673569202423,
-0.4613294303417206,
0.024315763264894485,
-0.08498848974704742,
-0.6054684519767761,
-0.7187966704368591,
0.5183592438697815,
0.5804355144500732,
0.5574725866317749,
0.30102086067199707,
-0.43868935108184814,
-0.6002310514450073,
-0.6330893635749817,
-0.6118544340133667,
-0.1606558859348297,
-0.23359601199626923,
-0.20632752776145935,
0.6046498417854309,
-0.24652525782585144,
0.5439454913139343,
-0.24117903411388397,
-0.14862534403800964,
-0.17329096794128418,
0.42815399169921875,
-0.22317907214164734,
0.44743070006370544,
0.4679214060306549,
-0.205376997590065,
-0.5990386009216309,
-0.14629963040351868,
-0.6941744089126587,
-0.1760334074497223,
-0.20853367447853088,
-0.057656578719615936,
0.05607709661126137,
0.812347948551178,
-0.08743582665920258,
0.7096767425537109,
0.46823760867118835,
-0.27127689123153687,
0.2973244786262512,
-0.28972044587135315,
0.013031878508627415,
-0.6257614493370056,
0.24822275340557098,
-0.2648850381374359,
-0.058941613882780075,
-0.8848280906677246,
-0.19784428179264069,
0.13975198566913605,
0.20387041568756104,
-0.5178694128990173,
0.36673739552497864,
-0.5450757741928101,
-0.007264785934239626,
-0.08583515882492065,
-0.16156208515167236,
-0.10975053161382675,
0.508780837059021,
-0.2912670373916626,
0.5994282960891724,
0.684941291809082,
-0.5164142847061157,
0.357877254486084,
0.038012273609638214,
-0.8458728194236755,
-0.0826442763209343,
-0.3504376709461212,
0.2599467933177948,
-0.2530398666858673,
-0.023875009268522263,
-1.0557893514633179,
0.21802709996700287,
-0.21640340983867645,
-0.49914517998695374,
0.2683647871017456,
-0.409635066986084,
-0.6502252817153931,
-0.010052983649075031,
-0.18046627938747406,
0.2630367577075958,
0.74800705909729,
-0.8554941415786743,
0.5267465710639954,
0.5202282667160034,
0.3102889358997345,
-0.7194351553916931,
-0.7222002744674683,
-0.2490234673023224,
-0.34474247694015503,
-0.18792292475700378,
-0.10998235642910004,
0.013317441567778587,
-0.26692110300064087,
-0.12757883965969086,
0.04983906447887421,
-0.16422039270401,
0.10513561218976974,
0.5649253726005554,
0.16031098365783691,
-0.06428536027669907,
0.09589599817991257,
-0.1271008551120758,
-0.07691223919391632,
0.4936472177505493,
-0.16528882086277008,
0.44253841042518616,
0.09407234936952591,
-0.19126726686954498,
-0.4165378510951996,
0.19781643152236938,
0.8164411187171936,
-0.24643684923648834,
0.8659337162971497,
0.2724977433681488,
-0.19928766787052155,
-0.6019704937934875,
-0.294984370470047,
-0.08121512085199356,
-0.46794402599334717,
0.45731332898139954,
0.2922462522983551,
-0.5078882575035095,
0.666765034198761,
-0.2218768298625946,
0.2546454668045044,
0.3222256302833557,
0.6153460144996643,
-0.04775615036487579,
1.0215060710906982,
0.757851779460907,
-0.31282153725624084,
0.6134469509124756,
-0.3208864629268646,
-0.038200635462999344,
-0.6243257522583008,
-0.6460880041122437,
-0.49759432673454285,
-0.24259084463119507,
-0.6917029023170471,
-0.2790040969848633,
-0.10615891218185425,
-0.029404299333691597,
-0.43328720331192017,
0.23937487602233887,
-0.12443419545888901,
0.8130450248718262,
0.634833037853241,
-0.1455521285533905,
0.43573063611984253,
0.15828047692775726,
-0.1548587679862976,
0.03969508409500122,
-0.6245677471160889,
-0.19730660319328308,
1.7066940069198608,
0.3083357810974121,
1.0108720064163208,
0.09131947159767151,
0.12805742025375366,
0.237400084733963,
0.5157555937767029,
-0.4798876643180847,
0.25438112020492554,
-0.338321328163147,
-0.5492834448814392,
-0.2106977254152298,
-0.5343272686004639,
-0.9768902063369751,
0.10192762315273285,
-0.2424868792295456,
-0.8106948733329773,
0.05893538519740105,
0.15202631056308746,
-0.24702458083629608,
0.6590238809585571,
-0.659654438495636,
0.728878378868103,
-0.3297479450702667,
-0.28067848086357117,
-0.2890968918800354,
-0.5537970066070557,
0.2495613545179367,
-0.2717575132846832,
0.1294187307357788,
0.25232169032096863,
0.4342878758907318,
1.2657619714736938,
-0.2733396589756012,
1.117291808128357,
-0.22968780994415283,
0.13135915994644165,
0.4509696066379547,
0.45723822712898254,
0.4809580147266388,
-0.16906586289405823,
0.2770459055900574,
0.3538806438446045,
-0.078309066593647,
-0.3294074535369873,
-0.818386971950531,
0.6020063161849976,
-0.6572712659835815,
0.062285102903842926,
-0.14845511317253113,
-0.4045041501522064,
-0.26472800970077515,
0.4427492320537567,
0.5646885633468628,
0.5299753546714783,
-0.5457012057304382,
0.42560216784477234,
0.6557209491729736,
-0.0014041302492842078,
0.6382355690002441,
0.9567989110946655,
-0.2193787395954132,
0.02764645777642727,
0.900105357170105,
0.07097162306308746,
0.2768605947494507,
0.37046894431114197,
0.20593130588531494,
-0.3967403173446655,
-0.6174501180648804,
-0.3447195887565613,
0.2430988848209381,
-0.7091115117073059,
-0.20205824077129364,
-0.22965757548809052,
-0.08752520382404327,
-0.23060816526412964,
0.15479540824890137,
-0.8900225162506104,
-0.2313641607761383,
-0.33732205629348755,
-0.2444305568933487,
0.2416812926530838,
1.2144501209259033,
-0.20866458117961884,
0.6610262393951416,
-0.5649518966674805,
-0.28805577754974365,
0.2502099573612213,
0.6166603565216064,
0.18439742922782898,
-0.8828932642936707,
-0.3335363268852234,
0.13189908862113953,
-0.10582806169986725,
-0.6003258228302002,
0.3804813623428345,
0.05291236191987991,
0.6126012802124023,
0.9151934385299683,
0.038061369210481644,
0.35491350293159485,
-0.2816851735115051,
0.3887263834476471,
0.20729540288448334,
-0.9513821601867676,
0.1788426637649536,
-0.18410924077033997,
0.09145523607730865,
0.7371235489845276,
0.4369892179965973,
-0.5903193354606628,
-0.3501496911048889,
-0.8045076131820679,
-0.6014153361320496,
0.6364740133285522,
0.11167275905609131,
0.016945453360676765,
0.3414146900177002,
0.32235246896743774,
0.07464095205068588,
0.1370302438735962,
-0.5315900444984436,
-0.36501190066337585,
-0.26106658577919006,
0.17634037137031555,
-0.32989054918289185,
-0.46178409457206726,
0.17135512828826904,
-0.4580387771129608,
0.508729100227356,
0.1653520166873932,
-0.20558887720108032,
-0.5104032754898071,
-0.37509191036224365,
-0.2727936804294586,
0.014168256893754005,
0.18475335836410522,
0.6561892628669739,
-0.22585831582546234,
0.2342292219400406,
0.1172928735613823,
-0.5764752626419067,
-0.04896329715847969,
-0.6082631349563599,
-0.34523218870162964,
-0.07869640737771988,
0.7156063318252563,
0.6657420992851257,
0.4065026342868805,
-0.8474830389022827,
0.6244354844093323,
-0.06243901699781418,
-0.06641267985105515,
-0.2750307321548462,
-0.023562055081129074,
0.04313501715660095,
-0.1002270057797432,
-0.0708981528878212,
-0.07442644983530045,
-0.06488419324159622,
-0.629242479801178,
0.5836244225502014,
0.3570632040500641,
-0.778861403465271,
-0.6086152195930481,
0.4363359808921814,
0.26534900069236755,
-0.05226002261042595,
1.2822165489196777,
0.028515774756669998,
-0.49614089727401733,
0.3760184943675995,
0.5635513663291931,
0.533125102519989,
-0.6739082336425781,
0.4205116033554077,
0.47302910685539246,
0.4225025177001953,
-0.36653459072113037,
-0.1261470764875412,
0.19179247319698334,
-0.6921963691711426,
-0.6372973918914795,
-0.2433999478816986,
0.09429281949996948,
0.594371497631073,
-1.0607610940933228,
0.02565448358654976,
-0.324524462223053,
0.39526230096817017,
0.05992754176259041,
-0.12826736271381378,
-0.6273061633110046,
0.04115666449069977,
-0.06051258742809296,
0.6375433802604675,
-1.3437833786010742,
0.8622276186943054,
0.466128408908844,
-0.4831489622592926,
-0.7862371206283569,
-0.10409392416477203,
0.3281790316104889,
-1.0829849243164062,
0.6171813011169434,
-0.1361568719148636,
-0.1358591467142105,
-0.02873227372765541,
-0.536023736000061,
-0.8686179518699646,
0.6500235795974731,
0.4944230020046234,
-0.37823957204818726,
0.32607221603393555,
0.27065974473953247,
0.6677846312522888,
-0.36276692152023315,
0.44577541947364807,
0.9264630675315857,
0.10348062962293625,
0.13850419223308563,
-0.52125084400177,
-0.03664635121822357,
-0.2230115383863449,
-0.3174256682395935,
0.38901734352111816,
-0.48156630992889404,
0.8818666934967041,
-0.4368114471435547,
-0.5741361975669861,
-0.33462196588516235,
0.5567089915275574,
-0.5418805480003357,
-0.054483041167259216,
0.5190461874008179,
0.5226576924324036,
0.9022315144538879,
0.319214403629303,
0.7398185729980469,
0.11566668003797531,
0.4812034070491791,
1.3735191822052002,
0.028921786695718765,
0.6812086701393127,
0.424519807100296,
-0.005651428364217281,
0.6711095571517944,
0.4178122282028198,
-0.1170167550444603,
0.7810682654380798,
0.44648477435112,
-0.13896387815475464,
-0.2649715542793274,
-0.025877149775624275,
0.10980937629938126,
0.8358247876167297,
0.10535648465156555,
-0.314216673374176,
-0.6386571526527405,
-0.039518002420663834,
0.33308854699134827,
0.07940330356359482,
-0.2696075141429901,
0.6813745498657227,
-0.16934633255004883,
-0.5446608662605286,
0.6283197999000549,
-0.2254723161458969,
0.2471044659614563,
-0.6225054860115051,
-0.07051175087690353,
-0.5861258506774902,
0.450168251991272,
-0.2065754383802414,
-0.6646726727485657,
0.18726596236228943,
0.11002903431653976,
-0.10310478508472443,
-0.3090597093105316,
0.4359360337257385,
-0.5221124291419983,
-0.41599443554878235,
0.7889089584350586,
0.5918589234352112,
0.26973438262939453,
-0.2917296290397644,
-0.4973599314689636,
-0.20186474919319153,
0.4495193064212799,
-0.2962542176246643,
0.8367431163787842,
0.3946799039840698,
-0.18023517727851868,
0.8734338879585266,
0.7305103540420532,
0.18115942180156708,
0.09893647581338882,
0.2703853249549866,
1.0069869756698608,
-0.5463976263999939,
-0.2075471132993698,
-0.7399525046348572,
0.5478832721710205,
0.1736985594034195,
-0.4253532886505127,
0.7333671450614929,
0.6880477666854858,
1.0472123622894287,
0.26426178216934204,
0.7322514057159424,
0.2703394293785095,
0.6969048976898193,
-0.3780444860458374,
1.0505880117416382,
-0.48795127868652344,
0.42385634779930115,
-0.08776732534170151,
-0.5833413600921631,
-0.20180989801883698,
0.3090801239013672,
0.1499306708574295,
-0.00787885021418333,
0.8770974278450012,
0.7826489806175232,
-0.03489893674850464,
0.023518851026892662,
0.2645573318004608,
0.43369260430336,
0.1366652250289917,
0.42122048139572144,
0.928368330001831,
-0.2304113358259201,
0.6102124452590942,
-0.4887825846672058,
-0.42935213446617126,
0.269470751285553,
-0.8742423057556152,
-1.2119754552841187,
-0.7609220743179321,
-0.2387777715921402,
-0.44741135835647583,
-0.2131606787443161,
0.27751046419143677,
0.3603164553642273,
-0.9370886087417603,
-0.3711920380592346,
-0.10211104899644852,
0.07582474499940872,
-0.23349829018115997,
-0.14886049926280975,
0.5759317874908447,
-0.1807616800069809,
-0.5274322032928467,
0.5057095289230347,
-0.10350309312343597,
-0.05371576175093651,
-0.32428810000419617,
0.12181209772825241,
-0.059635937213897705,
-0.19419999420642853,
0.43754562735557556,
0.6332375407218933,
-0.3470195531845093,
-0.0547635480761528,
-0.14666470885276794,
0.3648354709148407,
-0.12535953521728516,
1.447184443473816,
-0.7878900766372681,
0.5648772120475769,
0.3726431429386139,
0.4338453710079193,
0.5361998081207275,
-0.08575256168842316,
0.518109917640686,
-0.9440827369689941,
0.11581408977508545,
0.06648946553468704,
0.2856602072715759,
0.15525580942630768,
-0.26001280546188354,
0.440993070602417,
0.23475362360477448,
-0.5469295382499695,
-1.066059947013855,
-0.125984326004982,
-0.416339248418808,
-0.4731801450252533,
1.249441146850586,
-0.043817970901727676,
-0.24280443787574768,
-0.36398133635520935,
0.47616511583328247,
0.3201359510421753,
-0.4944428503513336,
0.7767836451530457,
0.5139340758323669,
-0.13779635727405548,
0.054046377539634705,
-0.8513134121894836,
0.6756307482719421,
0.37120765447616577,
-0.567885160446167,
0.7626662254333496,
0.28886890411376953,
0.7237382531166077,
-0.1256469190120697,
0.5270237326622009,
-0.18532104790210724,
-0.12535402178764343,
0.19672755897045135,
0.27825671434402466,
-0.08659524470567703,
-0.5969019532203674,
-0.376313179731369,
-0.1625063568353653,
-0.2206254005432129,
-0.2262263298034668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15222v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15222v2 | Transfer Learning for the Prediction of Entity Modifiers in Clinical Text: Application to Opioid Use Disorder Case Detection | 2024-01-26T22:19:31 | 2024-02-05T17:13:41 | Abdullateef I. Almudaifer, Whitney Covington, JaMor Hairston, Zachary Deitch, Ankit Anand, Caleb M. Carroll, Estera Crisan, William Bradford, Lauren Walter, Eaton Ellen, Sue S. Feldman, John D. Osborne | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Background: The semantics of entities extracted from a clinical text can be
dramatically altered by modifiers, including entity negation, uncertainty,
conditionality, severity, and subject. Existing models for determining
modifiers of clinical entities involve regular expression or features weights
that are trained independently for each modifier.
Methods: We develop and evaluate a multi-task transformer architecture design
where modifiers are learned and predicted jointly using the publicly available
SemEval 2015 Task 14 corpus and a new Opioid Use Disorder (OUD) data set that
contains modifiers shared with SemEval as well as novel modifiers specific for
OUD. We evaluate the effectiveness of our multi-task learning approach versus
previously published systems and assess the feasibility of transfer learning
for clinical entity modifiers when only a portion of clinical modifiers are
shared.
Results: Our approach achieved state-of-the-art results on the ShARe corpus
from SemEval 2015 Task 14, showing an increase of 1.1% on weighted accuracy,
1.7% on unweighted accuracy, and 10% on micro F1 scores.
Conclusions: We show that learned weights from our shared model can be
effectively transferred to a new partially matched data set, validating the use
of transfer learning for clinical text modifiers | [
-0.013531949371099472,
-0.5530087947845459,
0.7336589694023132,
-0.022851577028632164,
-0.28038889169692993,
-0.34054169058799744,
-0.03387676924467087,
-0.6998097896575928,
0.20264488458633423,
0.46111956238746643,
-0.1289312094449997,
-0.7306938171386719,
-0.9107596278190613,
0.1263013780117035,
-0.044100403785705566,
1.0733511447906494,
-0.3799053132534027,
0.31927305459976196,
-0.09690142422914505,
-0.17645616829395294,
-0.8230127692222595,
-0.378802627325058,
-0.3997631072998047,
-0.11430370062589645,
0.40857428312301636,
0.4890773296356201,
0.2405087798833847,
0.41102975606918335,
0.9412005543708801,
0.18954452872276306,
0.42821624875068665,
0.03512983024120331,
-0.26812729239463806,
0.234237939119339,
-0.29541653394699097,
-0.2544776499271393,
-0.7605203986167908,
-0.3456311523914337,
0.07014656811952591,
0.6777713298797607,
-0.2657071650028229,
0.10951342433691025,
-0.0774349644780159,
0.20075267553329468,
-0.7701923847198486,
0.3079623878002167,
-0.7306219935417175,
0.047181762754917145,
-0.05440620332956314,
-0.3147869408130646,
-0.459232896566391,
0.20307657122612,
0.393558144569397,
-0.8577759265899658,
0.36598360538482666,
0.2052917182445526,
0.6860581636428833,
0.30110421776771545,
-0.8101336359977722,
-0.5649219155311584,
-0.43116071820259094,
0.5911122560501099,
-0.31871548295021057,
0.4819234311580658,
0.3918346166610718,
0.10408701747655869,
0.1621362417936325,
-0.7920563220977783,
-0.4818556606769562,
-0.13959403336048126,
-0.2944903075695038,
0.03464300557971001,
-0.014727698639035225,
0.20564574003219604,
0.15463706851005554,
0.21916256844997406,
-0.5928821563720703,
0.044022317975759506,
-0.6579721570014954,
-0.38954952359199524,
0.6581888794898987,
0.38285019993782043,
0.3185778260231018,
-0.1567050814628601,
-0.8442308306694031,
0.16241341829299927,
-0.2980343699455261,
-0.16133518517017365,
-0.1780867576599121,
0.26802781224250793,
-0.09849605709314346,
0.28252673149108887,
0.2858177423477173,
0.4934277832508087,
0.10285761952400208,
-0.2523261606693268,
0.7921619415283203,
-0.4402918517589569,
-0.4632675349712372,
0.2227936089038849,
0.988897442817688,
0.22486573457717896,
-0.2679985463619232,
-0.14871786534786224,
-0.27449503540992737,
-0.18382032215595245,
0.6139516830444336,
-0.7027220129966736,
-0.17644765973091125,
0.041664570569992065,
-0.9231768250465393,
-0.3436211347579956,
0.1481144279241562,
-0.7223381400108337,
-0.57958984375,
-0.3993065655231476,
0.7143582701683044,
-0.7555868625640869,
-0.21304519474506378,
0.5188220143318176,
0.11106003820896149,
-0.16576705873012543,
0.5647953152656555,
-0.6643890738487244,
0.43870261311531067,
0.41041696071624756,
0.7462316155433655,
-0.8847993016242981,
-0.243923157453537,
-0.4636754095554352,
0.20744307339191437,
-0.029227901250123978,
0.7040107250213623,
-0.49237900972366333,
-0.537919282913208,
-0.042589105665683746,
0.3991600573062897,
-0.6562322378158569,
-0.5314487218856812,
1.040584921836853,
-0.23647333681583405,
0.08386651426553726,
-0.042994175106287,
-0.7182154655456543,
-0.1865953505039215,
-0.08371340483427048,
-0.7914244532585144,
0.5783901214599609,
0.3507755696773529,
-0.5938886404037476,
0.6548351645469666,
-0.6937540769577026,
-0.8964090347290039,
0.11528530716896057,
-0.0778217613697052,
-0.7205109000205994,
0.20957429707050323,
-0.03944921866059303,
0.5833562612533569,
-0.007596343755722046,
0.3091144263744354,
-0.1825602650642395,
-0.21680893003940582,
0.10870575159788132,
-0.13702857494354248,
0.3530927896499634,
0.3537535071372986,
-0.16251140832901,
0.17037035524845123,
-0.8281289339065552,
-0.35787513852119446,
-0.18345558643341064,
-0.3452758491039276,
-0.5080314874649048,
-0.2819679081439972,
0.4957621097564697,
0.10385371744632721,
-0.10339783877134323,
-0.6518775224685669,
0.35445594787597656,
0.050676751881837845,
0.08853266388177872,
0.5381271243095398,
0.26879844069480896,
0.3601043224334717,
-0.6927882432937622,
0.721005380153656,
0.42179733514785767,
-0.01920565590262413,
-0.18239600956439972,
-0.5051793456077576,
-0.20026230812072754,
-0.4713299572467804,
0.3422362804412842,
0.6168560981750488,
-0.6949965953826904,
0.4710639715194702,
-0.3137066662311554,
-0.2838006615638733,
-0.5569866299629211,
-0.13090026378631592,
0.33317258954048157,
0.6726272702217102,
0.8983964920043945,
-0.2492515742778778,
-0.6546779274940491,
-0.8531543016433716,
-0.21335463225841522,
0.20958034694194794,
0.0196527186781168,
0.5220418572425842,
0.7912689447402954,
-0.2551325559616089,
0.13355566561222076,
-0.5352468490600586,
-0.9924757480621338,
-0.16815440356731415,
0.34328922629356384,
0.04938885197043419,
0.6369795799255371,
0.5220000743865967,
-0.8136306405067444,
-0.5607438683509827,
0.09080495685338974,
-0.3244158625602722,
-0.13614307343959808,
-0.33250004053115845,
0.08324310928583145,
0.022058885544538498,
0.7935899496078491,
-0.13547298312187195,
0.6376156210899353,
0.5025091171264648,
-0.5276532173156738,
0.22572146356105804,
-0.2593018710613251,
0.5006572604179382,
-1.31211519241333,
0.05640265345573425,
-0.11864184588193893,
-0.27177923917770386,
-0.6056138873100281,
-0.40684670209884644,
0.23158541321754456,
0.18533693253993988,
-0.4397636651992798,
0.42556580901145935,
-0.43012306094169617,
0.2941833436489105,
-0.0909990444779396,
-0.27163979411125183,
-0.11698036640882492,
0.38506463170051575,
-0.009220011532306671,
0.5737183094024658,
0.6131609678268433,
-0.576466977596283,
-0.05800670385360718,
0.2720920443534851,
-0.5414249300956726,
0.7431323528289795,
-0.4739426076412201,
-0.15588675439357758,
-0.10580261051654816,
-0.09880134463310242,
-0.9064094424247742,
-0.10787632316350937,
0.22760184109210968,
-0.2896891236305237,
0.473967969417572,
-0.17840087413787842,
0.07622908055782318,
-0.12399335950613022,
-0.031515490263700485,
0.4286024868488312,
0.22684718668460846,
-0.005627334583550692,
0.8895664215087891,
0.38770610094070435,
0.19409990310668945,
-0.4093817174434662,
-0.7944138050079346,
-0.3141782879829407,
-0.16500039398670197,
-0.22321344912052155,
1.0588252544403076,
-0.009263867512345314,
0.2018478512763977,
0.2613646984100342,
-0.13984641432762146,
-0.3662366569042206,
0.17213019728660583,
0.4747298061847687,
0.3758387267589569,
-0.25353917479515076,
0.6916453838348389,
0.2778432369232178,
-0.0247663427144289,
-0.06898688524961472,
0.011157388798892498,
0.30196836590766907,
0.18622073531150818,
-0.5536994934082031,
-0.5485647320747375,
0.22402052581310272,
0.7534471750259399,
-0.10655584186315536,
0.9319676756858826,
0.7507522106170654,
-0.6269585490226746,
-0.15711703896522522,
-0.2792504131793976,
-0.1284676492214203,
-0.2783229649066925,
0.31874316930770874,
-0.5637763142585754,
-0.867773175239563,
0.5269442796707153,
0.06215157359838486,
-0.1888389140367508,
0.5928811430931091,
0.5824591517448425,
0.07934767007827759,
0.7799496650695801,
0.4779719114303589,
0.17181038856506348,
0.5139680504798889,
-0.12649458646774292,
0.10195136070251465,
-0.8974648714065552,
-0.2523403763771057,
-0.38686609268188477,
-0.495118111371994,
-0.35562360286712646,
-0.4251997470855713,
0.552645742893219,
-0.11462820321321487,
0.02121390402317047,
0.27027297019958496,
-0.4092182517051697,
0.027973955497145653,
0.15668903291225433,
0.5939891338348389,
0.38291823863983154,
-0.09621936827898026,
-0.07403909415006638,
-0.08091466873884201,
-0.16460618376731873,
-0.1873914748430252,
1.6214399337768555,
0.15891601145267487,
0.5130131840705872,
0.229923814535141,
0.5989909172058105,
0.6579336524009705,
0.5443029999732971,
-0.9623351693153381,
0.058833733201026917,
-0.2840544581413269,
-0.3897418975830078,
-0.08829115331172943,
-0.2659708857536316,
-1.0747816562652588,
0.2969152331352234,
-0.6094698309898376,
-0.6278505921363831,
0.5417146682739258,
-0.05864670127630234,
-0.6242102384567261,
0.2545812726020813,
-0.8175010681152344,
1.04267418384552,
-0.11292863637208939,
-0.15568672120571136,
-0.1312713772058487,
-0.4198402166366577,
0.07285178452730179,
-0.2711443603038788,
0.28715983033180237,
-0.08922789245843887,
-0.4629804193973541,
0.6346998810768127,
-0.3017194867134094,
0.6278579831123352,
-0.09973128139972687,
0.06093820556998253,
0.059134792536497116,
0.1289437860250473,
0.18870726227760315,
0.15319043397903442,
-0.07417285442352295,
0.11837416142225266,
0.25487568974494934,
-0.20816291868686676,
-0.4037356674671173,
0.5320672392845154,
-0.557296872138977,
-0.18713757395744324,
-0.4639187157154083,
-0.36130473017692566,
-0.14983661472797394,
0.4636519253253937,
0.27634188532829285,
0.39402857422828674,
-0.157877579331398,
0.3767006993293762,
0.7666661739349365,
-0.09316601604223251,
0.16617442667484283,
0.6953111290931702,
0.1429632157087326,
-0.5565491914749146,
0.5443248152732849,
0.1209162175655365,
0.21181288361549377,
0.5549077987670898,
0.2152722179889679,
0.10456351190805435,
-0.9783378839492798,
-0.28148481249809265,
0.03066985122859478,
-0.40544480085372925,
-0.5242517590522766,
-0.8148730993270874,
0.07780338078737259,
-0.7090402245521545,
0.10258080810308456,
-0.17633023858070374,
-0.11246328800916672,
-0.4507119953632355,
-0.2069857120513916,
0.17369599640369415,
0.6232920289039612,
0.007951389998197556,
0.1811092048883438,
-0.9326473474502563,
0.2779720425605774,
-0.04290512949228287,
0.35210809111595154,
-0.3178260326385498,
-0.6618579030036926,
-0.11522596329450607,
-0.1770305186510086,
-0.32942482829093933,
-1.188578486442566,
0.37528547644615173,
0.2400495707988739,
0.6567016839981079,
0.5267850160598755,
0.3480554521083832,
0.4912959635257721,
-0.3415659964084625,
0.5993940234184265,
0.2383878380060196,
-0.9660525918006897,
0.4050305485725403,
-0.16507938504219055,
-0.12908561527729034,
0.8401534557342529,
0.7361193895339966,
-0.4704779088497162,
0.31598711013793945,
-0.5977939963340759,
-0.48926976323127747,
0.8010015487670898,
0.013222680427134037,
-0.2051231861114502,
-0.06216020882129669,
0.3858644366264343,
0.5223838686943054,
0.270759642124176,
-0.4875611662864685,
-0.4105468690395355,
0.20661520957946777,
-0.6440542340278625,
0.17879541218280792,
-0.30834826827049255,
0.041631974279880524,
-0.2939140796661377,
0.5101044178009033,
-0.3387811779975891,
0.32892903685569763,
0.6570872068405151,
-0.3158924877643585,
-0.14378474652767181,
0.4681621491909027,
0.7725001573562622,
0.7214711904525757,
-0.08259914815425873,
0.1026114895939827,
0.23764480650424957,
-0.9087770581245422,
-0.09637614339590073,
0.1099977046251297,
-0.013562360778450966,
0.07678016275167465,
0.46778374910354614,
1.0278501510620117,
0.20427951216697693,
-0.653320848941803,
0.9508126974105835,
-0.14861445128917694,
-0.5586618781089783,
-0.2225775271654129,
-0.1677587479352951,
-0.37801435589790344,
0.021791543811559677,
0.03183675557374954,
0.38968226313591003,
0.5248825550079346,
-0.4087553918361664,
0.35510170459747314,
0.1914888620376587,
-0.8744723200798035,
-0.49832695722579956,
0.4924027621746063,
-0.041019633412361145,
-0.09608682990074158,
0.3076678514480591,
-0.23539277911186218,
-0.48185235261917114,
0.5119643807411194,
0.4637621343135834,
0.6918501257896423,
-0.48754629492759705,
0.0571499839425087,
0.3893108069896698,
0.13640643656253815,
0.014593894593417645,
0.5279735326766968,
-0.020076487213373184,
-0.971839189529419,
-0.2749011218547821,
-0.40999966859817505,
0.029324311763048172,
0.31436991691589355,
-0.9094253182411194,
0.7513172030448914,
-0.09585471451282501,
-0.28902944922447205,
0.12855882942676544,
-0.4236595928668976,
-0.7393372654914856,
0.09574367851018906,
0.14021740853786469,
0.6517910361289978,
-0.8481954336166382,
0.6836230754852295,
1.1590594053268433,
-0.6146730780601501,
-0.737369954586029,
-0.1724826544523239,
-0.03674264997243881,
-0.681145191192627,
0.5386360287666321,
0.1645084172487259,
0.3321256637573242,
-0.32623863220214844,
-0.22420938313007355,
-0.7393004894256592,
1.099906086921692,
0.067939393222332,
-0.5071741938591003,
-0.2762543857097626,
-0.06427210569381714,
0.629145622253418,
-0.5737026333808899,
0.3721979856491089,
0.37899553775787354,
0.19862231612205505,
0.19685105979442596,
-1.488784670829773,
0.23630572855472565,
0.027019836008548737,
-0.34377092123031616,
0.536561131477356,
-0.009485717862844467,
0.8960548043251038,
-0.35821643471717834,
-0.36275872588157654,
-0.03678874671459198,
0.19046123325824738,
-0.3220173120498657,
0.6016687154769897,
0.617470920085907,
0.6771264672279358,
0.7373941540718079,
-0.017999941483139992,
0.7411390542984009,
-0.48173457384109497,
0.48961442708969116,
1.202572226524353,
-0.37811359763145447,
0.7185753583908081,
0.4032856225967407,
-0.013484560884535313,
0.7131540179252625,
0.23278175294399261,
0.05797193944454193,
0.4980087876319885,
0.023236960172653198,
-0.19248805940151215,
-0.38005736470222473,
-0.2058086097240448,
-0.3174419403076172,
0.49354806542396545,
0.5761272311210632,
-0.9950602054595947,
0.051456645131111145,
0.6509099006652832,
-0.0709635317325592,
0.0003086787473876029,
-0.2872215509414673,
1.0327321290969849,
-0.07988618314266205,
-0.5767929553985596,
0.29817041754722595,
-0.25684547424316406,
0.6513745784759521,
-0.2706236243247986,
-0.34042996168136597,
0.2559967637062073,
0.5252314209938049,
-0.40103793144226074,
-0.6344283223152161,
0.4023376703262329,
-0.6998624801635742,
-0.1890994757413864,
-0.3822261393070221,
0.7670917510986328,
-0.4898017942905426,
-0.26046910881996155,
0.20524103939533234,
0.5396552681922913,
-0.14227336645126343,
-0.038756001740694046,
-0.5721861720085144,
-0.07108243554830551,
0.047325216233730316,
0.019224366173148155,
0.2712402045726776,
0.5971041917800903,
-0.062117431312799454,
0.4040210545063019,
0.4877082109451294,
0.4285440146923065,
-0.04881729930639267,
-0.011168897151947021,
0.6660729050636292,
-0.34216082096099854,
-0.4505937993526459,
-0.490725576877594,
0.36901354789733887,
0.04811254143714905,
-0.4321799874305725,
0.3138261139392853,
0.4976237416267395,
0.9372147917747498,
-0.3046211004257202,
0.6499480605125427,
-0.21552370488643646,
0.8726087808609009,
-0.46865686774253845,
0.508083164691925,
-0.5138993859291077,
0.23551899194717407,
-0.10872281342744827,
-0.30896133184432983,
-0.23182570934295654,
0.4217272102832794,
-0.3622354567050934,
-0.18960990011692047,
1.144724726676941,
0.5012698173522949,
-0.13790878653526306,
0.10307397693395615,
0.43618524074554443,
0.038119394332170486,
0.1702478528022766,
0.8014636039733887,
0.37977543473243713,
-0.7864503860473633,
0.4106503427028656,
-0.40734922885894775,
-0.10253690183162689,
-0.24152511358261108,
-0.6253641247749329,
-0.7920002937316895,
-0.7722018957138062,
-0.5076267719268799,
-0.355753630399704,
-0.027857551351189613,
1.0701522827148438,
0.6597345471382141,
-1.1560559272766113,
0.2883510887622833,
-0.06460858136415482,
0.03730355203151703,
-0.35586443543434143,
-0.26055580377578735,
0.5175692439079285,
-0.24726009368896484,
-0.4637950658798218,
0.11259691417217255,
0.09175541996955872,
-0.0039057456888258457,
0.13578476011753082,
0.1684112846851349,
-0.23617315292358398,
-0.47608375549316406,
0.516819417476654,
-0.15035571157932281,
-0.44910427927970886,
-0.23498356342315674,
0.2138054072856903,
-0.2988104820251465,
0.058206893503665924,
1.3590948581695557,
-0.8082021474838257,
0.5329746007919312,
0.6317543983459473,
0.6904911398887634,
0.1611359715461731,
-0.033737849444150925,
0.39644065499305725,
-0.2420305758714676,
-0.2328886091709137,
0.39464524388313293,
0.600450336933136,
-0.061697203665971756,
-0.4774079918861389,
0.3951476514339447,
0.6095182299613953,
-0.43306565284729004,
-0.6352959275245667,
-0.022154029458761215,
-0.9407727122306824,
-0.3483162224292755,
1.0632596015930176,
-0.20251525938510895,
-0.12364570051431656,
-0.6329318881034851,
-0.3469083905220032,
0.09804762154817581,
-0.6029807329177856,
0.5007809996604919,
0.2843816876411438,
-0.4140622913837433,
-0.04184264689683914,
-0.4915056824684143,
0.6638145446777344,
0.17431464791297913,
-0.7354550361633301,
-0.2711670398712158,
0.4268561005592346,
0.4798271656036377,
0.424628347158432,
0.5064688920974731,
-0.18804199993610382,
0.3008147180080414,
-0.3501993715763092,
0.2168341726064682,
-0.2729962468147278,
-0.18115000426769257,
-0.291287899017334,
0.3124128580093384,
-0.5155197978019714,
-0.3936106562614441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15207v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15207v3 | HiFT: A Hierarchical Full Parameter Fine-Tuning Strategy | 2024-01-26T21:14:32 | 2024-06-17T10:35:06 | Yongkang Liu, Yiqun Zhang, Qian Li, Tong Liu, Shi Feng, Daling Wang, Yifei Zhang, Hinrich Schütze | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Full-parameter fine-tuning has become the go-to choice for adapting language
models (LMs) to downstream tasks due to its excellent performance. As LMs grow
in size, fine-tuning the full parameters of LMs requires a prohibitively large
amount of GPU memory. Existing approaches utilize zeroth-order optimizer to
conserve GPU memory, which can potentially compromise the performance of LMs as
non-zero order optimizers tend to converge more readily on most downstream
tasks. In this paper, we propose a novel optimizer-independent end-to-end
hierarchical fine-tuning strategy, HiFT, which only updates a subset of
parameters at each training step. HiFT can significantly reduce the amount of
gradients and optimizer state parameters residing in GPU memory at the same
time, thereby reducing GPU memory usage. Our results demonstrate that: (1) HiFT
achieves comparable performance to parameter-efficient fine-tuning and standard
full parameter fine-tuning. (2) HiFT supports various optimizers including
AdamW, AdaGrad, SGD, etc. (3) HiFT can save more than 60\% GPU memory compared
with standard full-parameter fine-tuning for 7B model. (4) HiFT enables
full-parameter fine-tuning of a 7B model on single 48G A6000 with a precision
of 32 using the AdamW optimizer, without using any memory saving techniques. | [
-0.7636926770210266,
-1.288057565689087,
0.3262198269367218,
-0.2608051002025604,
-0.4697566330432892,
-0.05583220347762108,
-0.5074080228805542,
-0.3410910367965698,
-0.20457440614700317,
0.5130395293235779,
-0.5528869032859802,
-0.30550137162208557,
-0.45634934306144714,
-0.3003048598766327,
0.046050965785980225,
1.1007148027420044,
0.024286072701215744,
-0.40430790185928345,
0.15825165808200836,
-0.33341658115386963,
-0.38498178124427795,
-0.2617529630661011,
-1.230804204940796,
-0.12303977459669113,
0.559415340423584,
0.3337591588497162,
0.9108525514602661,
1.1512786149978638,
0.5071590542793274,
0.20606477558612823,
-0.20055709779262543,
0.06975936889648438,
-0.6180938482284546,
-0.028639258816838264,
-0.24827814102172852,
-0.16842710971832275,
-0.48931339383125305,
-0.3928605616092682,
0.7779033780097961,
0.45043236017227173,
-0.3740088641643524,
0.4233189821243286,
0.1084914281964302,
0.7529406547546387,
-0.9820443391799927,
0.07586316019296646,
-0.7001785635948181,
-0.14787854254245758,
-0.1440904438495636,
-0.4187847375869751,
-0.14502906799316406,
-0.09647716581821442,
-0.19350720942020416,
-0.5685434937477112,
0.30188900232315063,
0.11067885160446167,
1.1314674615859985,
0.7225215435028076,
0.025131724774837494,
0.5155588984489441,
-0.8981983065605164,
0.7580606937408447,
-0.997025728225708,
0.46941089630126953,
0.010423608124256134,
0.3519485890865326,
-0.11167027801275253,
-0.3058242201805115,
-0.26963648200035095,
0.06308118253946304,
0.2942698001861572,
0.07727709412574768,
-0.21158279478549957,
0.5655336380004883,
0.1795537769794464,
0.3036145567893982,
-0.3650173246860504,
0.1955336183309555,
-0.1594819724559784,
0.010333854705095291,
0.318551629781723,
-0.04053567722439766,
0.16273215413093567,
0.0709088146686554,
-0.317573219537735,
-0.010223416611552238,
-0.6640457510948181,
0.14625106751918793,
0.07508804649114609,
0.7168353796005249,
-0.16680745780467987,
-0.03044392727315426,
-0.11489460617303848,
0.7581683993339539,
0.3313596546649933,
-0.2484314888715744,
-0.18872655928134918,
0.08956962823867798,
-0.6811331510543823,
0.07164400070905685,
0.8627881407737732,
0.0981668010354042,
0.24351419508457184,
-0.11031791567802429,
-0.17146427929401398,
-0.14108002185821533,
0.22751204669475555,
-0.8928159475326538,
-0.09557691961526871,
-0.046969298273324966,
-0.37600940465927124,
0.06809314340353012,
-0.43680527806282043,
-0.9539024829864502,
-0.01879957877099514,
-0.401894748210907,
0.6989891529083252,
-0.25490182638168335,
-0.14624717831611633,
0.12398721277713776,
0.1416158825159073,
0.16205193102359772,
0.4674970507621765,
-1.139817714691162,
0.6471946239471436,
0.42434754967689514,
0.7216981053352356,
-0.2099177986383438,
-0.4975166618824005,
-0.841535210609436,
0.362033873796463,
-0.4325747489929199,
0.5588601231575012,
-0.4774775207042694,
-0.14986783266067505,
-0.1419927477836609,
0.0023256740532815456,
-0.3104572892189026,
-0.5673604607582092,
0.3172984719276428,
-0.4017726480960846,
0.08004854619503021,
-0.11503805220127106,
-0.1359545737504959,
-0.3902970552444458,
0.17617930471897125,
-0.4159950911998749,
1.3174792528152466,
0.12301917374134064,
-0.5333201289176941,
0.2529015839099884,
-0.5889884829521179,
-0.36381569504737854,
0.15508514642715454,
-0.14886951446533203,
-0.5626966953277588,
0.28798428177833557,
0.29998427629470825,
0.30293676257133484,
-0.5228907465934753,
0.16297943890094757,
-0.47385963797569275,
-0.7244747877120972,
-0.6994963884353638,
-0.33774563670158386,
0.3416587710380554,
-0.025466112419962883,
-0.5844089388847351,
0.5393037796020508,
-0.7514282464981079,
-0.16537147760391235,
0.06268180906772614,
-0.49029767513275146,
-0.2690936028957367,
0.04599529132246971,
0.08395133167505264,
0.15888261795043945,
0.41023510694503784,
-0.5309032797813416,
0.1721988171339035,
-0.41165691614151,
0.33804723620414734,
0.7486088871955872,
0.14684320986270905,
0.30557024478912354,
-0.2396622747182846,
0.35518524050712585,
-0.02580648474395275,
0.3954409658908844,
-0.016898145899176598,
-0.4294451177120209,
-0.9140484929084778,
-0.323062539100647,
0.24820281565189362,
0.4329662621021271,
-0.21540763974189758,
0.5170941948890686,
0.0297255739569664,
-0.14584359526634216,
-0.808571457862854,
0.20946888625621796,
0.19282075762748718,
0.6301970481872559,
0.5602721571922302,
0.06352104246616364,
-0.30233320593833923,
-0.886465847492218,
-0.1630321890115738,
-0.242277130484581,
0.05830582603812218,
0.28175362944602966,
0.46545228362083435,
-0.0006176794995553792,
0.5836649537086487,
-0.46153077483177185,
-0.3246028423309326,
-0.011040491051971912,
-0.09530197829008102,
0.32899802923202515,
0.4147547483444214,
0.637736976146698,
-0.184768944978714,
-0.4869566857814789,
0.28392475843429565,
-0.3516315221786499,
0.22852849960327148,
-0.28510916233062744,
-0.3848232924938202,
0.18574132025241852,
0.42920297384262085,
-0.6458309292793274,
0.2765045166015625,
0.434479683637619,
-0.20076797902584076,
0.2823903262615204,
-0.9271741509437561,
0.05957494676113129,
-0.9288507103919983,
-0.08986663073301315,
0.15958307683467865,
-0.03887093812227249,
-0.4334077835083008,
0.4184175431728363,
0.12465877085924149,
0.028150880709290504,
-0.22676056623458862,
0.6337295770645142,
-0.38359004259109497,
0.35066890716552734,
-0.4695742726325989,
-0.2514936327934265,
-0.24520453810691833,
0.9746914505958557,
-0.06548215448856354,
0.6840658187866211,
1.043876051902771,
-0.5646793246269226,
0.03952617198228836,
0.01891203038394451,
0.13441649079322815,
0.15026286244392395,
-0.4998282790184021,
0.08330953866243362,
-0.407796174287796,
-0.16875314712524414,
-1.0646963119506836,
0.05441347509622574,
0.19840563833713531,
-0.05333835259079933,
0.4685562551021576,
-0.3750728368759155,
-0.5042660236358643,
-0.01674669235944748,
-0.28895577788352966,
0.14462001621723175,
0.9372715950012207,
-0.7313566207885742,
0.628277599811554,
0.15374630689620972,
-0.31572458148002625,
-0.3976438343524933,
-0.3987186551094055,
0.14820626378059387,
-0.26499709486961365,
-0.3193795382976532,
0.40227010846138,
-0.04200383648276329,
0.15237699449062347,
-0.15554210543632507,
-0.23473694920539856,
0.034256331622600555,
0.053872618824243546,
-0.035948652774095535,
0.4180845618247986,
-0.6559194326400757,
-0.26492753624916077,
0.4529177248477936,
-0.03772328794002533,
-0.21695180237293243,
-0.3198305070400238,
0.3565872013568878,
-0.15253882110118866,
-0.06234600767493248,
-0.4436633586883545,
0.3630705773830414,
0.7809247374534607,
-0.35877665877342224,
0.7991378307342529,
0.817483127117157,
-0.6280584335327148,
-0.2696361243724823,
-0.579742968082428,
-0.05984111875295639,
-0.5121424794197083,
0.404724657535553,
-0.18136578798294067,
-0.9095675349235535,
0.46325379610061646,
-0.17310549318790436,
0.423645555973053,
0.456932008266449,
0.680438756942749,
0.07834497839212418,
1.1264820098876953,
0.7772015929222107,
-0.40548470616340637,
0.44591251015663147,
0.0022110200952738523,
0.5098724365234375,
-0.6780105233192444,
0.19736020267009735,
-0.6551153659820557,
-0.43718457221984863,
-0.6508830785751343,
-0.34276941418647766,
0.31330960988998413,
0.5578479170799255,
-0.7456793189048767,
0.20216026902198792,
-0.6328549981117249,
0.4733404219150543,
0.5586915016174316,
0.026743100956082344,
0.17310607433319092,
0.2165956348180771,
0.02147512324154377,
0.10620878636837006,
-0.5389956831932068,
-0.06845539063215256,
0.5742417573928833,
0.395056813955307,
0.8689402937889099,
-0.018222885206341743,
0.6345562934875488,
0.035054076462984085,
-0.12221940606832504,
-0.762401282787323,
0.5954099297523499,
-0.29134586453437805,
-0.3074771463871002,
-0.6156132221221924,
-0.37793809175491333,
-0.5904858708381653,
0.4556331932544708,
-0.06422838568687439,
-0.9351968169212341,
0.09244422614574432,
0.21271465718746185,
-0.721878170967102,
0.654816746711731,
-0.4552017152309418,
0.7407371997833252,
-0.06365106999874115,
-0.5929301381111145,
-0.24515725672245026,
-0.6152010560035706,
-0.09258837252855301,
-0.0799531415104866,
0.20531950891017914,
-0.4139585793018341,
-0.03797537460923195,
0.7166805267333984,
-0.048548970371484756,
0.5053810477256775,
-0.5614492893218994,
-0.04099452868103981,
0.20691543817520142,
0.07070285826921463,
0.4708006680011749,
-0.050801560282707214,
-0.046518824994564056,
0.09318339824676514,
0.1665630042552948,
-0.4956320524215698,
-0.5322973728179932,
0.8514143228530884,
-0.8952082395553589,
-0.6827221512794495,
-0.10209640860557556,
-0.752718448638916,
-0.5329853296279907,
0.42846739292144775,
-0.007554343435913324,
0.23374269902706146,
0.04871275648474693,
0.15976348519325256,
0.6795215010643005,
-0.21493756771087646,
0.8234522342681885,
0.2946487367153168,
0.03072931244969368,
-0.3867507576942444,
0.8296815752983093,
-0.16272710263729095,
0.22286854684352875,
0.5275536775588989,
0.5912975072860718,
-0.26505714654922485,
-0.8467339277267456,
-0.9520034193992615,
0.27859094738960266,
-0.35439935326576233,
-0.19336897134780884,
-0.19793738424777985,
-0.3208627998828888,
-0.259786456823349,
-0.28089234232902527,
-0.4989970028400421,
-0.1520061045885086,
-0.16516903042793274,
0.22585202753543854,
0.49024033546447754,
0.10704442858695984,
0.2085733264684677,
0.6610577702522278,
-0.8168048858642578,
0.5821179747581482,
0.09180936217308044,
0.5964347124099731,
0.10052265971899033,
-0.7243422269821167,
-0.33887913823127747,
0.03651995211839676,
-0.28349635004997253,
-0.43511199951171875,
0.2839244306087494,
0.6160817742347717,
0.48668578267097473,
0.5245049595832825,
-0.10676884651184082,
1.2815308570861816,
-0.5165652632713318,
0.552294135093689,
0.27059420943260193,
-0.7090997099876404,
0.410732239484787,
-0.7841933965682983,
0.7592599987983704,
0.7185989618301392,
0.13739678263664246,
-0.24133256077766418,
-0.3147479295730591,
-0.2819030284881592,
-0.6503446102142334,
0.8211262822151184,
-0.0370236411690712,
0.1609847992658615,
0.2727639377117157,
0.5846248865127563,
-0.01647278480231762,
-0.08355773985385895,
-0.24302726984024048,
-0.23677432537078857,
0.19835248589515686,
-0.15114492177963257,
0.09868811815977097,
0.13821156322956085,
-0.055532824248075485,
-0.7111074924468994,
0.6743362545967102,
-0.4364195764064789,
0.06381945312023163,
-0.2621522843837738,
0.3325410783290863,
-0.7063682079315186,
0.42302900552749634,
0.13217884302139282,
0.6398866772651672,
-0.539948582649231,
-0.1376972645521164,
0.3606921136379242,
-0.3493492007255554,
-0.06869399547576904,
0.09220504015684128,
-0.29268357157707214,
-0.01857156492769718,
-0.19649791717529297,
1.0152924060821533,
0.3143864870071411,
-0.5046671032905579,
0.1818125993013382,
0.06331655383110046,
-0.4296826720237732,
0.3835213780403137,
0.25307291746139526,
0.2325206696987152,
0.016570841893553734,
0.29359957575798035,
0.4663270115852356,
-0.04712894931435585,
-0.37005266547203064,
0.10378763824701309,
0.25167417526245117,
-0.3903025686740875,
-0.21030746400356293,
0.9579845070838928,
-0.1672525405883789,
-0.16903632879257202,
0.45627865195274353,
0.18017755448818207,
0.1217450201511383,
0.3052803874015808,
0.6575605273246765,
0.9391885995864868,
-0.5203778743743896,
-0.10452883690595627,
0.5344885587692261,
0.14074157178401947,
-0.2184455692768097,
0.3257497251033783,
-0.11738520860671997,
-0.44911903142929077,
-0.6125940680503845,
-1.1102442741394043,
-0.31768399477005005,
0.28613364696502686,
-0.7930076718330383,
0.3228292763233185,
-0.9775493144989014,
-0.051933158189058304,
0.09121426194906235,
-0.22205427289009094,
-0.3115283250808716,
0.3923063278198242,
0.31840428709983826,
0.7716959118843079,
-0.3168582320213318,
1.0741885900497437,
0.6775630116462708,
0.027193773537874222,
-0.4609653651714325,
0.004072712268680334,
-0.13725371658802032,
-0.6708119511604309,
-0.24092990159988403,
-0.23844799399375916,
-0.36071154475212097,
0.004009632393717766,
-0.2517545521259308,
-1.0458053350448608,
0.6328301429748535,
0.7355189323425293,
-0.8175398111343384,
-0.5794537663459778,
0.033263906836509705,
0.5128347277641296,
-0.03986690193414688,
-0.055448267608881,
0.9097329378128052,
0.32158753275871277,
0.452914834022522,
-0.9388885498046875,
0.18798665702342987,
-0.19973185658454895,
0.18621675670146942,
0.8016757965087891,
-0.6236969828605652,
0.7615442276000977,
-0.3225295841693878,
-0.12481925636529922,
-0.027681488543748856,
0.6207793354988098,
0.2643209993839264,
-0.21858271956443787,
0.4478561282157898,
0.5375935435295105,
0.35355430841445923,
0.027955498546361923,
0.5235866904258728,
-0.626512885093689,
0.5825576782226562,
0.9328896999359131,
-0.05183124542236328,
1.1690233945846558,
0.5465805530548096,
0.005783026572316885,
0.11129315197467804,
0.774793803691864,
-0.06045705825090408,
0.6133019924163818,
0.15587113797664642,
-0.12424017488956451,
-0.4651668071746826,
0.09303327649831772,
-0.2607077360153198,
0.1972266286611557,
0.2591707408428192,
0.10711212456226349,
-0.7213201522827148,
-0.009036333300173283,
0.21169357001781464,
-0.2129986733198166,
-0.5075804591178894,
0.7143957614898682,
0.007904935628175735,
-0.792675793170929,
1.159275770187378,
0.2883933186531067,
0.6523402333259583,
-0.7108473777770996,
-0.07818087935447693,
-0.0976584404706955,
0.6078147888183594,
-0.18331070244312286,
-0.223148375749588,
0.24202604591846466,
-0.16909681260585785,
0.013785921968519688,
-0.11887145787477493,
0.5082972049713135,
-0.5512129068374634,
-0.39382803440093994,
0.4670426547527313,
0.5176265835762024,
-0.33043593168258667,
-0.29901042580604553,
-0.7913700342178345,
-0.13438889384269714,
-0.0839376300573349,
-0.24781395494937897,
0.7173369526863098,
0.08548185229301453,
0.07406619936227798,
0.38652440905570984,
0.6237223148345947,
0.2639450430870056,
0.12440173327922821,
0.17589861154556274,
0.6239334344863892,
-0.6432390809059143,
-0.6646708250045776,
-0.9486695528030396,
0.1745409071445465,
0.4338103234767914,
-0.5307409763336182,
0.6172963976860046,
0.649090051651001,
0.7245323061943054,
0.06550979614257812,
0.7431018948554993,
0.09199853986501694,
0.19591200351715088,
-0.32645681500434875,
0.6628615260124207,
-0.9126963019371033,
-0.13031375408172607,
-0.35314130783081055,
-0.858158528804779,
-0.34395503997802734,
0.31758010387420654,
-0.013700945302844048,
0.08658795803785324,
0.625464677810669,
0.7023860216140747,
-0.3385750651359558,
0.2657318711280823,
0.6018902659416199,
0.14300964772701263,
0.19051910936832428,
0.6457884907722473,
0.3303397595882416,
-0.43412190675735474,
0.34616464376449585,
-0.20883019268512726,
-0.43592569231987,
0.0027631018310785294,
-0.47580236196517944,
-0.8555424809455872,
-0.32342997193336487,
-0.5339890718460083,
-0.016519036144018173,
0.25137829780578613,
0.7560176253318787,
0.9311363697052002,
-0.8699553608894348,
-0.5380364060401917,
0.026025861501693726,
-0.38322052359580994,
-0.5251054763793945,
-0.17661716043949127,
0.5943184494972229,
-0.45185261964797974,
-0.5356012582778931,
0.3314398229122162,
0.7600246071815491,
-0.15369537472724915,
0.003148506162688136,
-0.03859861567616463,
-0.16331467032432556,
0.2542761266231537,
0.570284366607666,
0.29385530948638916,
-0.8104336857795715,
-0.3429887592792511,
-0.0746043398976326,
0.2519228458404541,
0.5596911907196045,
0.5650452375411987,
-0.514381468296051,
0.25237762928009033,
0.36378422379493713,
0.9115777611732483,
0.7838743925094604,
-0.048313207924366,
0.35086581110954285,
-0.3518264889717102,
-0.07661241292953491,
0.039782341569662094,
0.3356867730617523,
-0.06542503833770752,
-0.41983479261398315,
0.06405523419380188,
0.05502631887793541,
-0.40115588903427124,
-0.43324634432792664,
-0.1482483446598053,
-1.1864333152770996,
-0.412479043006897,
0.8730455040931702,
0.2642645239830017,
-0.4375916123390198,
0.12523329257965088,
-0.32250455021858215,
0.2698759138584137,
-0.4478394091129303,
0.7282252311706543,
0.26808130741119385,
-0.3734956979751587,
-0.5767621397972107,
-0.6738268733024597,
0.5037934184074402,
0.3421427011489868,
-0.885901689529419,
0.33022749423980713,
0.16510647535324097,
0.3730335235595703,
-0.0880061611533165,
0.4538954198360443,
-0.04028836637735367,
0.36267513036727905,
-0.056881196796894073,
-0.09566638618707657,
0.015490522608160973,
-0.48593926429748535,
-0.2937723696231842,
0.3948928415775299,
0.0669349730014801,
-0.3336963951587677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15170v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15170v2 | Scalable Qualitative Coding with LLMs: Chain-of-Thought Reasoning Matches Human Performance in Some Hermeneutic Tasks | 2024-01-26T19:25:43 | 2024-02-12T23:04:10 | Zackary Okun Dunivin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Qualitative coding, or content analysis, extracts meaning from text to
discern quantitative patterns across a corpus of texts. Recently, advances in
the interpretive abilities of large language models (LLMs) offer potential for
automating the coding process (applying category labels to texts), thereby
enabling human researchers to concentrate on more creative research aspects,
while delegating these interpretive tasks to AI. Our case study comprises a set
of socio-historical codes on dense, paragraph-long passages representative of a
humanistic study. We show that GPT-4 is capable of human-equivalent
interpretations, whereas GPT-3.5 is not. Compared to our human-derived gold
standard, GPT-4 delivers excellent intercoder reliability (Cohen's $\kappa \geq
0.79$) for 3 of 9 codes, and substantial reliability ($\kappa \geq 0.6$) for 8
of 9 codes. In contrast, GPT-3.5 greatly underperforms for all codes
($mean(\kappa) = 0.34$; $max(\kappa) = 0.55$). Importantly, we find that coding
fidelity improves considerably when the LLM is prompted to give rationale
justifying its coding decisions (chain-of-thought reasoning). We present these
and other findings along with a set of best practices for adapting traditional
codebooks for LLMs. Our results indicate that for certain codebooks,
state-of-the-art LLMs are already adept at large-scale content analysis.
Furthermore, they suggest the next generation of models will likely render AI
coding a viable option for a majority of codebooks. | [
-0.25808650255203247,
-0.5111111402511597,
0.7890914678573608,
0.13913880288600922,
-0.30208083987236023,
0.31706640124320984,
-0.335904985666275,
-0.4360867142677307,
-0.1731540858745575,
0.41146743297576904,
-0.17150069773197174,
-0.5614790916442871,
-0.4952443838119507,
0.35848650336265564,
-0.5512951016426086,
0.9451166391372681,
-0.10896437615156174,
-0.12595660984516144,
-0.3128904402256012,
-0.07537934184074402,
-0.2700924277305603,
-0.991092324256897,
-0.4216913878917694,
-0.2882744371891022,
0.5137115716934204,
0.3334103524684906,
0.7772805690765381,
0.6127517223358154,
0.6458595395088196,
0.2531534731388092,
-0.049509476870298386,
0.3088325262069702,
-0.48618555068969727,
-0.12517529726028442,
-0.2359074354171753,
-0.5467295050621033,
-0.6537984609603882,
-0.15576444566249847,
0.600875973701477,
0.4225836992263794,
-0.29897943139076233,
0.3437890410423279,
0.15076415240764618,
0.7826719880104065,
-0.4381379783153534,
0.21767696738243103,
-0.44607511162757874,
0.07768061757087708,
0.13736814260482788,
-0.6828386783599854,
-0.4952573776245117,
-0.6389158368110657,
-0.10754938423633575,
-0.4555875062942505,
-0.1903831511735916,
0.20450057089328766,
0.610260009765625,
0.2881901264190674,
-0.2913767099380493,
-0.49957993626594543,
-0.7954546213150024,
0.5682286024093628,
-0.7900452017784119,
0.2737129330635071,
0.665564239025116,
0.058838214725255966,
-0.08630435913801193,
-0.72452312707901,
-0.6567171216011047,
-0.13818475604057312,
0.15680699050426483,
0.041000884026288986,
-0.3043212592601776,
-0.07462222129106522,
0.5553773045539856,
0.6356987953186035,
-0.5430183410644531,
0.20716869831085205,
-0.39076295495033264,
0.05657235160470009,
0.5904063582420349,
0.26297426223754883,
0.3471570611000061,
-0.12420342117547989,
-0.1504696011543274,
0.11729834228754044,
-0.6394520998001099,
-0.08419670909643173,
0.22878052294254303,
-0.20962023735046387,
-0.06709662824869156,
0.5558595657348633,
-0.23932155966758728,
0.5237382650375366,
0.1638105809688568,
-0.1548279970884323,
0.20972229540348053,
-0.506565272808075,
-0.19581429660320282,
-0.0190143845975399,
0.6573317646980286,
0.5592973828315735,
0.5251126289367676,
-0.055353257805109024,
-0.24820195138454437,
0.18216463923454285,
0.67464679479599,
-0.6867461204528809,
-0.3010254204273224,
0.10852957516908646,
-0.5890841484069824,
-0.08534757792949677,
-0.1398169845342636,
-0.37275534868240356,
-0.31051090359687805,
-0.46488651633262634,
0.20884272456169128,
-0.5144631266593933,
-0.09698841720819473,
0.48967549204826355,
-0.044678397476673126,
0.40855535864830017,
0.28214529156684875,
-0.826181948184967,
0.1576845496892929,
0.5590813755989075,
0.9562055468559265,
-0.12859950959682465,
-0.23667140305042267,
-0.20638136565685272,
0.19577787816524506,
-0.43856388330459595,
0.6982778906822205,
-0.4204663634300232,
-0.31301024556159973,
0.02184075117111206,
-0.2775813639163971,
0.2839986979961395,
-0.38790223002433777,
0.5885206460952759,
-0.629375696182251,
-0.049983151257038116,
-0.37385207414627075,
-0.6594983339309692,
-0.10158728808164597,
0.33748432993888855,
-0.664950430393219,
1.0126235485076904,
0.3624384105205536,
-0.802846372127533,
0.2847983241081238,
-0.30144840478897095,
-0.3357217311859131,
0.2627737522125244,
-0.34303733706474304,
-0.3464367091655731,
0.001719960942864418,
0.21392129361629486,
0.5353386402130127,
-0.5398267507553101,
0.3893768787384033,
-0.34840884804725647,
-0.7628623843193054,
0.4952072203159332,
-0.3344554305076599,
0.6228055953979492,
0.44562196731567383,
-0.47680506110191345,
0.08067869395017624,
-0.7221832871437073,
0.04323965683579445,
0.012456953525543213,
-0.6499534249305725,
-0.19668863713741302,
0.09843268990516663,
-0.24241775274276733,
0.21529917418956757,
-0.05055201053619385,
-0.13076770305633545,
0.42509695887565613,
-0.008524175733327866,
0.708246648311615,
0.7470779418945312,
-0.08454243093729019,
0.606052577495575,
-0.4815761148929596,
0.6935349702835083,
-0.2216172218322754,
0.1220502182841301,
-0.04467060789465904,
-0.4441421329975128,
-0.5800832509994507,
-0.1405327469110489,
-0.024885348975658417,
0.4433809220790863,
-1.1879106760025024,
0.5359020829200745,
-0.4892021119594574,
-0.28259432315826416,
-0.3326490521430969,
0.12305852770805359,
0.27493804693222046,
0.29766571521759033,
0.33645889163017273,
-0.26841315627098083,
-0.5199716091156006,
-0.6871183514595032,
-0.23292918503284454,
-0.3503877520561218,
-0.27792468667030334,
0.0766386017203331,
0.5341688394546509,
-0.4300260841846466,
0.8452909588813782,
-0.40505436062812805,
0.15590223670005798,
-0.35103440284729004,
0.1468825489282608,
0.2938109338283539,
0.4298762381076813,
0.24779610335826874,
-0.679145336151123,
-0.29198452830314636,
0.11912747472524643,
-1.0203659534454346,
-0.07849982380867004,
-0.39721593260765076,
-0.19056206941604614,
0.04227844253182411,
0.3799741268157959,
-0.4199976623058319,
0.34068235754966736,
0.477769672870636,
-0.34487858414649963,
0.6377368569374084,
-0.42774495482444763,
0.3585207462310791,
-0.9474432468414307,
-0.05306816101074219,
0.09334839135408401,
-0.11974374204874039,
-0.48408380150794983,
0.2013205587863922,
0.2583913803100586,
0.18778149783611298,
-0.14987154304981232,
0.16750569641590118,
-0.4929828643798828,
-0.25347772240638733,
-0.1388697475194931,
-0.06532631814479828,
0.037878625094890594,
0.5786750316619873,
0.006784950848668814,
0.9328909516334534,
0.15359896421432495,
-0.530369222164154,
0.3098953068256378,
0.27113351225852966,
-0.6008517742156982,
0.6834985017776489,
-0.5806280374526978,
0.466042160987854,
-0.03095802664756775,
0.3999224305152893,
-0.5783783197402954,
-0.07393500208854675,
0.1389215588569641,
-0.3286327123641968,
0.06515362113714218,
0.0924624502658844,
-0.8032683730125427,
-0.463045597076416,
-0.44729292392730713,
0.7572664022445679,
0.8504106998443604,
-0.44013723731040955,
0.41396647691726685,
0.3372272253036499,
-0.23236717283725739,
-0.2708006799221039,
-0.7418758869171143,
0.4256342351436615,
-0.33085039258003235,
-0.32534465193748474,
0.03479526937007904,
-0.28756585717201233,
-0.2255958616733551,
-0.07677793502807617,
-0.14705099165439606,
-0.14150923490524292,
-0.009811947122216225,
0.10081584006547928,
0.3126937448978424,
-0.1199452355504036,
0.06691176444292068,
0.004931436851620674,
-0.04684402793645859,
0.22409096360206604,
-0.61822909116745,
0.3698205351829529,
-0.5265665054321289,
-0.3232409358024597,
-0.2587008476257324,
0.3180917501449585,
0.5626684427261353,
-0.25441285967826843,
0.37921416759490967,
0.5932232737541199,
-0.2645161747932434,
-0.18720337748527527,
-0.6242563724517822,
0.14946815371513367,
-0.4997125267982483,
0.17232190072536469,
-0.40544235706329346,
-1.3876961469650269,
0.36002597212791443,
0.0676189586520195,
-0.28624776005744934,
0.21839340031147003,
0.8719452619552612,
-0.3219936490058899,
0.7988572120666504,
0.548281192779541,
-0.06830616295337677,
0.3810703158378601,
-0.31827256083488464,
0.16455011069774628,
-0.9363028407096863,
-0.1863410919904709,
-0.4006311297416687,
-0.11289196461439133,
-0.6528590321540833,
-0.6407884955406189,
0.5352493524551392,
0.08347290754318237,
-0.39689138531684875,
0.052323099225759506,
-0.7033616304397583,
0.49817022681236267,
0.5480272173881531,
0.1869165301322937,
0.603754460811615,
-0.041833605617284775,
0.2168261706829071,
0.2611456513404846,
-0.9702833890914917,
-0.7177864909172058,
1.0804922580718994,
0.4770730137825012,
0.8391467332839966,
0.09838490933179855,
0.6159358024597168,
0.6023749113082886,
0.350236713886261,
-0.6220446825027466,
0.47455161809921265,
0.004212407860904932,
-0.4831843972206116,
-0.23055896162986755,
-0.48871147632598877,
-0.8723488450050354,
0.15441295504570007,
-0.13264302909374237,
-0.5737829804420471,
0.2404250204563141,
0.11539043486118317,
-0.37049147486686707,
0.47404810786247253,
-0.4197078347206116,
0.5361266732215881,
-0.2169140875339508,
-0.28219619393348694,
-0.31904059648513794,
-0.5922790169715881,
0.31605634093284607,
-0.2407897561788559,
0.3506189286708832,
0.0923345535993576,
0.06044133007526398,
0.7336912751197815,
-0.19720368087291718,
0.8897092342376709,
0.3783737123012543,
-0.36619696021080017,
0.5761946439743042,
0.08331005275249481,
0.37637507915496826,
0.008598774671554565,
-0.09095127135515213,
0.29277634620666504,
0.22017477452754974,
-0.571162223815918,
-0.6003885865211487,
0.39719894528388977,
-0.6600337624549866,
-0.5315977334976196,
-0.4389905631542206,
-0.7035625576972961,
-0.011536648496985435,
0.0978880301117897,
0.21130841970443726,
0.4810009002685547,
0.06514200568199158,
0.23049910366535187,
0.7168084383010864,
-0.3384658992290497,
0.27890220284461975,
0.12158152461051941,
-0.012201376259326935,
-0.37170594930648804,
0.8140748143196106,
-0.021887604147195816,
0.3125438094139099,
0.33909258246421814,
0.1447215974330902,
-0.1743440330028534,
-0.8982431292533875,
-0.43267595767974854,
0.11646139621734619,
-0.9389364719390869,
-0.23463377356529236,
-0.5294208526611328,
-0.05140797793865204,
0.02764318324625492,
-0.4314615726470947,
0.0018914011307060719,
-0.10580740869045258,
-0.2008385956287384,
-0.18364208936691284,
0.29875075817108154,
1.0303691625595093,
0.10609287023544312,
0.05096219480037689,
-1.1273211240768433,
0.31895723938941956,
0.26662421226501465,
0.4097328782081604,
0.15751643478870392,
-0.383004367351532,
-0.6070342659950256,
-0.0989345982670784,
0.015903880819678307,
-0.8048778176307678,
0.19874611496925354,
-0.1971157044172287,
0.3828725516796112,
0.10985447466373444,
0.041932690888643265,
0.6323243975639343,
-0.5424122214317322,
0.6942201256752014,
0.1881505846977234,
-1.0950500965118408,
0.31740453839302063,
-0.6208550930023193,
0.6480497717857361,
0.5686981678009033,
0.5467347502708435,
-0.5631257891654968,
-0.41684490442276,
-0.44989314675331116,
-0.5927342176437378,
0.37478458881378174,
0.18584667146205902,
-0.03020193986594677,
-0.24102389812469482,
0.7623054385185242,
0.12568674981594086,
0.25931939482688904,
-0.6661550402641296,
0.306288480758667,
-0.16174322366714478,
-0.3052670657634735,
-0.15917013585567474,
-0.49878716468811035,
0.09342249482870102,
-0.36375054717063904,
0.14894716441631317,
-0.3881223201751709,
0.3989463746547699,
0.24656479060649872,
-0.17085996270179749,
0.017121540382504463,
0.4531976282596588,
0.3037247061729431,
0.9673150777816772,
-0.11209212243556976,
0.3616831302642822,
0.17851439118385315,
-0.4298754930496216,
0.3053514063358307,
-0.2879253625869751,
-0.051885880529880524,
-0.5254207253456116,
0.755342960357666,
0.4875505566596985,
0.29201340675354004,
-0.6939707398414612,
0.32138416171073914,
-0.03195016086101532,
-0.27113258838653564,
-0.28523552417755127,
-0.013972941786050797,
0.0668463259935379,
0.518256425857544,
0.15342015027999878,
-0.16074252128601074,
0.402616411447525,
-0.8177306652069092,
0.10295519232749939,
0.1076689139008522,
-0.10536930710077286,
-0.31284430623054504,
0.4992363452911377,
0.15851740539073944,
-0.276178240776062,
0.8306466341018677,
-0.39819109439849854,
-0.5515057444572449,
0.4593217372894287,
0.5413379669189453,
0.8523519039154053,
0.1401497721672058,
0.137808158993721,
0.25209373235702515,
0.35010820627212524,
-0.4290405213832855,
0.4926292598247528,
-0.2975787818431854,
-0.7957031726837158,
-0.7309830188751221,
-0.6865530014038086,
-0.3934224545955658,
-0.37249955534935,
-0.9230785965919495,
-0.2710563838481903,
-0.47365498542785645,
-0.143821120262146,
-0.4553680121898651,
-0.26343175768852234,
-0.6551928520202637,
0.12104488164186478,
0.4499405324459076,
0.6823095083236694,
-0.5195062160491943,
1.0375473499298096,
0.5873739123344421,
-0.4697416126728058,
-0.9136217832565308,
-0.04829662665724754,
-0.10594412684440613,
-0.8369243741035461,
0.5084227323532104,
-0.18334268033504486,
-0.24919335544109344,
0.0695905089378357,
-0.5340555906295776,
-0.8646523356437683,
1.2661951780319214,
0.1105755865573883,
-0.7976717948913574,
-0.28135818243026733,
-0.027389153838157654,
0.7141963243484497,
-0.3311243951320648,
0.13616688549518585,
0.9053067564964294,
0.23990283906459808,
0.10416919738054276,
-0.9441261291503906,
0.36166882514953613,
-0.26693692803382874,
0.18698497116565704,
0.15374541282653809,
-0.42579469084739685,
0.7842862010002136,
-0.23104390501976013,
-0.08547864854335785,
-0.034445662051439285,
0.4722854197025299,
0.3953275978565216,
0.31338679790496826,
0.26857680082321167,
0.42194050550460815,
0.9363178610801697,
0.14098304510116577,
1.4158661365509033,
-0.16430892050266266,
0.3011453151702881,
0.9122743606567383,
-0.22755496203899384,
0.8399642705917358,
0.3409828245639801,
-0.5741885900497437,
0.6669207811355591,
0.608648419380188,
-0.04591473937034607,
0.15266680717468262,
0.29223108291625977,
-0.002538981381803751,
-0.25056299567222595,
0.10839201509952545,
-0.25921469926834106,
0.26360493898391724,
0.21455901861190796,
-0.12939074635505676,
0.35199207067489624,
-0.15430907905101776,
-0.0026260106824338436,
0.13579872250556946,
-0.49921050667762756,
0.7245948910713196,
0.31495699286460876,
-0.5527958273887634,
0.8445641994476318,
-0.20420153439044952,
0.6728748083114624,
-0.3676341474056244,
-0.09631916135549545,
-0.09383933246135712,
0.041384074836969376,
-0.39393380284309387,
-0.9042991995811462,
0.1733791083097458,
0.09153097122907639,
-0.10312110930681229,
-0.45061421394348145,
0.6632710099220276,
-0.20616352558135986,
-0.3685959279537201,
0.08383457362651825,
0.6424384713172913,
0.03679089993238449,
-0.06945493072271347,
-0.4167541563510895,
0.2307204157114029,
0.006450469605624676,
-0.09211208671331406,
0.35127443075180054,
0.6247897148132324,
-0.1819874793291092,
0.7613406181335449,
0.7158047556877136,
0.10659945011138916,
-0.07096323370933533,
0.2518146336078644,
1.0739490985870361,
-1.0245212316513062,
-0.6680623888969421,
-0.9648160338401794,
0.3611571490764618,
0.04879928380250931,
-0.15918199717998505,
0.8476795554161072,
0.3618150055408478,
0.8101516962051392,
0.04736832529306412,
0.821548581123352,
0.19160118699073792,
-0.059332530945539474,
-0.8545896410942078,
0.4767279028892517,
-0.3545213043689728,
0.5031188726425171,
-0.38876375555992126,
-0.8946037888526917,
-0.31386271119117737,
0.5849475264549255,
-0.409161239862442,
-0.026762207970023155,
0.9406270980834961,
0.2599712610244751,
0.28100407123565674,
0.20539037883281708,
0.2468772977590561,
0.08117445558309555,
0.4987388551235199,
0.765544593334198,
1.3148962259292603,
0.043987687677145004,
0.40526002645492554,
0.07136527448892593,
-0.41020554304122925,
-0.13989725708961487,
-0.8933767080307007,
-0.9885439276695251,
-0.45570749044418335,
-0.19917286932468414,
-0.37946316599845886,
0.03968921676278114,
0.9254900217056274,
0.42198479175567627,
-0.3626168966293335,
-0.39484933018684387,
0.09711458534002304,
0.04640215262770653,
-0.23725606501102448,
-0.10433872044086456,
0.2921577990055084,
-0.26513904333114624,
-0.3496249318122864,
-0.00975250918418169,
0.5678281188011169,
-0.17789721488952637,
-0.26624682545661926,
-0.4217382073402405,
-0.13164567947387695,
0.07432287186384201,
0.9711747169494629,
0.030197588726878166,
-0.7143590450286865,
-0.3800564408302307,
-0.036598436534404755,
-0.09924990683794022,
0.296631783246994,
1.165168046951294,
-0.5728456377983093,
0.28943124413490295,
0.3189068138599396,
0.8901175260543823,
0.6194252371788025,
0.07354384660720825,
0.5341193079948425,
-0.2511657774448395,
-0.1352325826883316,
0.5590307712554932,
0.41740846633911133,
0.22922055423259735,
-0.453778475522995,
0.6339341998100281,
0.02324758656322956,
-0.8425009250640869,
-0.6097270250320435,
0.21928782761096954,
-1.0443434715270996,
-0.35576409101486206,
1.4944995641708374,
-0.24054716527462006,
-0.19472546875476837,
-0.26124492287635803,
-0.21218734979629517,
0.12099058926105499,
-0.20749254524707794,
0.8472421765327454,
0.8175761699676514,
-0.34480002522468567,
-0.30705899000167847,
-0.5734689831733704,
0.43067580461502075,
0.281382292509079,
-1.0018082857131958,
-0.16807925701141357,
0.6324363946914673,
0.10984468460083008,
-0.06210428476333618,
1.0724241733551025,
-0.14844562113285065,
0.41804054379463196,
0.07226400077342987,
0.13669902086257935,
0.0027357840444892645,
-0.07740581035614014,
-0.5574451684951782,
0.1416143923997879,
0.4728969633579254,
0.2494470626115799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15077v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15077v2 | EAGLE: Speculative Sampling Requires Rethinking Feature Uncertainty | 2024-01-26T18:59:01 | 2024-02-04T17:18:34 | Yuhui Li, Fangyun Wei, Chao Zhang, Hongyang Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Autoregressive decoding makes the inference of Large Language Models (LLMs)
time-consuming. In this paper, we reconsider speculative sampling and derive
two key observations. Firstly, autoregression at the feature
(second-to-top-layer) level is more straightforward than at the token level.
Secondly, the inherent uncertainty in feature (second-to-top-layer) level
autoregression constrains its performance. Based on these insights, we
introduce EAGLE (Extrapolation Algorithm for Greater Language-model
Efficiency), a simple yet highly efficient speculative sampling framework. By
incorporating a token sequence advanced by one time step, EAGLE effectively
resolves the uncertainty, enabling precise second-to-top-layer feature
prediction with minimal overhead. We conducted comprehensive evaluations of
EAGLE, including all models from the Vicuna and LLaMA2-Chat series, the MoE
model Mixtral 8x7B Instruct, and tasks in dialogue, code generation,
mathematical reasoning, and instruction following. For LLaMA2-Chat 70B, EAGLE
achieved a latency speedup ratio of 2.7x-3.5x, doubled throughput, while
maintaining the distribution of the generated text. | [
-0.3589456081390381,
-0.9067192673683167,
0.4376562237739563,
0.4067303240299225,
-0.05110101401805878,
0.3680305480957031,
0.05783403292298317,
-1.0566364526748657,
0.5739075541496277,
0.5290047526359558,
-0.4828380048274994,
-0.3039771318435669,
-0.758756160736084,
-0.18542370200157166,
-0.8888705968856812,
0.34749099612236023,
0.19629493355751038,
-0.6869919896125793,
0.5036230087280273,
0.3094562590122223,
0.11379967629909515,
-0.5976431965827942,
-0.8410140872001648,
0.0793679803609848,
0.19900819659233093,
0.40072986483573914,
0.7613973617553711,
1.061671257019043,
0.26862695813179016,
0.27407321333885193,
-0.03500526770949364,
0.22581978142261505,
-0.21848681569099426,
0.15034307539463043,
0.3183075189590454,
-0.7642949819564819,
-0.40615010261535645,
-0.039711810648441315,
0.5136013627052307,
0.6361486911773682,
-0.10938871651887894,
0.2594282031059265,
-0.16435761749744415,
0.5042206048965454,
-0.7461518049240112,
0.19907794892787933,
-0.7354721426963806,
0.06901196390390396,
-0.40244895219802856,
-0.24948909878730774,
-0.440908819437027,
0.2579329311847687,
-0.06474800407886505,
-0.6455439329147339,
0.4431738257408142,
0.4170818030834198,
0.7701256275177002,
0.30769047141075134,
-0.20413827896118164,
-0.09835472702980042,
-0.8512235879898071,
0.8959736227989197,
-0.6938033699989319,
0.30499735474586487,
0.7778875231742859,
0.36471429467201233,
-0.11576152592897415,
-0.7891584634780884,
-0.671871542930603,
-0.17475555837154388,
0.29888057708740234,
-0.2587093710899353,
-0.16477765142917633,
-0.17929555475711823,
-0.18060950934886932,
0.5570160150527954,
-0.2800399959087372,
0.45033910870552063,
-0.27788621187210083,
-0.3400757908821106,
0.7160537242889404,
0.07413143664598465,
-0.1542031317949295,
-0.06683149188756943,
-0.1763904094696045,
-0.5783215165138245,
-0.5753262639045715,
0.4727035462856293,
0.6045973896980286,
0.43591082096099854,
0.15626183152198792,
0.3356741964817047,
-0.3002174198627472,
0.42125099897384644,
0.5021612644195557,
0.17295920848846436,
0.1711627095937729,
-0.028557348996400833,
-0.2342994660139084,
-0.07033940404653549,
0.7949331402778625,
0.04960431158542633,
-0.35563409328460693,
-0.10150931775569916,
-0.17772848904132843,
-0.06982149928808212,
-0.0060398937202990055,
-0.5813711881637573,
-0.21044760942459106,
0.7491666078567505,
-0.4158353805541992,
-0.3007792830467224,
0.005018118303269148,
-0.612715482711792,
-0.042693983763456345,
0.06336529552936554,
-0.11864998191595078,
-0.17169995605945587,
-0.5814833641052246,
0.29868781566619873,
0.14381177723407745,
0.0032650295179337263,
0.2513827383518219,
-1.1964902877807617,
0.21234777569770813,
0.9485484957695007,
0.6454545855522156,
0.03375682234764099,
-0.47500428557395935,
-0.6285214424133301,
0.1633204072713852,
-0.776356041431427,
1.175499677658081,
-0.8515649437904358,
-0.4072975218296051,
-0.12786255776882172,
-0.31788837909698486,
0.29678454995155334,
-0.2884305715560913,
0.3943674862384796,
-0.7278928756713867,
-0.2207377552986145,
-0.46322789788246155,
-0.42176419496536255,
-0.21008288860321045,
0.07534267008304596,
-0.9114822149276733,
1.1737613677978516,
-0.04113199561834335,
-0.66066575050354,
0.7429373860359192,
-0.1747235208749771,
-0.28178367018699646,
-0.059337541460990906,
-0.29028645157814026,
0.06587208807468414,
-0.017363065853714943,
0.6077862977981567,
0.4588225781917572,
-0.16059516370296478,
-0.056658174842596054,
-0.6687976121902466,
-0.7341633439064026,
0.17232614755630493,
-0.40040940046310425,
0.4954599440097809,
0.6911453008651733,
-0.3299124836921692,
-0.3563558757305145,
-0.5859019756317139,
0.14050738513469696,
-0.4559379518032074,
-0.22908663749694824,
-0.15013404190540314,
0.004425669088959694,
0.11121095716953278,
0.11133985221385956,
0.031635358929634094,
-0.4878408908843994,
0.1331217736005783,
-0.5616978406906128,
0.3261401653289795,
0.5386393070220947,
-0.15905757248401642,
0.45640990138053894,
-0.273783802986145,
0.6768943667411804,
0.008941825479269028,
0.037908729165792465,
-0.2766049802303314,
-0.2201564759016037,
-0.6881919503211975,
-0.5824946761131287,
0.2151314914226532,
0.5531810522079468,
-0.7243267893791199,
0.42430293560028076,
0.011056863702833652,
-0.5163846015930176,
-0.6449264287948608,
0.2652342915534973,
0.32062429189682007,
0.09014298766851425,
0.2770078182220459,
-0.0850268080830574,
-0.6065701842308044,
-0.8046525120735168,
-0.38887032866477966,
-0.7409024238586426,
0.26434585452079773,
0.01177630852907896,
0.001659688539803028,
-0.22732366621494293,
0.7854782342910767,
-0.18373756110668182,
-0.10228953510522842,
-0.1550663709640503,
0.5474600791931152,
0.12414400279521942,
0.3436756432056427,
0.704269289970398,
-0.5676259398460388,
-0.3032476603984833,
-0.2406732738018036,
-0.49923670291900635,
-0.020678900182247162,
-0.1523737758398056,
-0.17859670519828796,
0.47374024987220764,
0.7854699492454529,
-0.5734869837760925,
0.25988367199897766,
0.6659589409828186,
0.03141937032341957,
0.17272377014160156,
0.08167072385549545,
0.26484233140945435,
-1.022506833076477,
0.054639872163534164,
-0.02937382645905018,
0.0319642536342144,
-0.27367252111434937,
0.3399461805820465,
-0.13240140676498413,
0.30714452266693115,
-0.325200617313385,
0.5683259963989258,
-0.6073300242424011,
-0.11959150433540344,
-0.5990301370620728,
-0.2379963994026184,
-0.051331810653209686,
0.09345628321170807,
0.09621553868055344,
0.952583909034729,
0.5525649785995483,
-0.5515822172164917,
0.13873833417892456,
-0.0925956666469574,
-0.3417990207672119,
-0.25952577590942383,
-0.4865802228450775,
0.1483401209115982,
0.05735725909471512,
0.45514675974845886,
-1.0306239128112793,
-0.06555992364883423,
0.12038566172122955,
-0.5280619859695435,
0.38548582792282104,
0.06793150305747986,
-0.793146550655365,
-0.3758515417575836,
-0.1824071705341339,
0.4836875796318054,
0.4815073311328888,
-0.2826788127422333,
0.5593674778938293,
0.5865382552146912,
-0.1726151704788208,
-1.256608486175537,
-1.1193411350250244,
0.3074250817298889,
0.04964897781610489,
-0.4676899313926697,
0.010676195845007896,
0.37811559438705444,
-0.287799596786499,
0.13025471568107605,
0.14615364372730255,
0.009706128388643265,
0.018508724868297577,
0.07248544692993164,
-0.09100737422704697,
-0.2240523099899292,
-0.008947381749749184,
0.21872912347316742,
-0.19321632385253906,
0.061071302741765976,
-0.49179989099502563,
0.578648030757904,
-0.287688672542572,
-0.654193103313446,
-0.4054050147533417,
0.5624604225158691,
0.3529718816280365,
-0.10475384443998337,
0.28925469517707825,
0.5193573832511902,
-0.2441151887178421,
-0.37043333053588867,
-0.8926071524620056,
-0.25373655557632446,
-0.48200222849845886,
0.5806218981742859,
-0.43163594603538513,
-0.8526498675346375,
0.778822660446167,
0.34085169434547424,
0.4021674394607544,
0.5321877002716064,
0.4025294780731201,
-0.006976848468184471,
0.7384011149406433,
0.9274976253509521,
-0.19429562985897064,
0.2959853410720825,
-0.4613754153251648,
0.14011350274085999,
-0.6056684851646423,
0.008653147146105766,
-0.37340012192726135,
-0.3028940260410309,
-0.3149760663509369,
-0.6045664548873901,
-0.19813451170921326,
0.11072585731744766,
0.0863189697265625,
0.18715956807136536,
-0.21539203822612762,
0.2567013204097748,
0.6148581504821777,
-0.08723502606153488,
0.32516011595726013,
0.4327238202095032,
0.05433441326022148,
-0.03358908370137215,
-0.6410461664199829,
-0.4263482987880707,
1.2873315811157227,
0.3762785792350769,
0.8497525453567505,
-0.015666538849473,
0.8035880923271179,
0.333610862493515,
0.2793915569782257,
-0.46486982703208923,
0.40685516595840454,
-0.2501373589038849,
-0.7889654636383057,
-0.2922007441520691,
-0.10489898175001144,
-0.6534467339515686,
0.1438644975423813,
-0.11995094269514084,
-0.7051084041595459,
0.5241938233375549,
0.6503089070320129,
-0.8142444491386414,
0.4516412317752838,
-0.5925894379615784,
0.07382164150476456,
-0.002589263254776597,
-0.28308767080307007,
-0.23875516653060913,
-0.3624335527420044,
0.6904817819595337,
-0.3226832151412964,
0.21400539577007294,
0.1023675724864006,
-0.14894092082977295,
0.4494626522064209,
-0.44435229897499084,
1.0258612632751465,
0.054767709225416183,
-0.19944217801094055,
0.6457055807113647,
0.35249003767967224,
0.5775580406188965,
0.13096532225608826,
-0.34832149744033813,
0.0380571186542511,
0.13921934366226196,
-0.4987541437149048,
-0.5852827429771423,
0.5847924947738647,
-0.9393892884254456,
-0.6735407114028931,
-0.4931586980819702,
-0.5287339687347412,
-0.21360108256340027,
-0.2505342662334442,
0.5023407340049744,
0.21667997539043427,
0.08445628732442856,
0.02329605259001255,
0.4161853790283203,
0.0021817784290760756,
0.5343883633613586,
0.38861119747161865,
-0.5450570583343506,
-0.05527191236615181,
0.6518469452857971,
0.24302279949188232,
0.16976980865001678,
0.5575029253959656,
-0.2563420832157135,
-0.5035677552223206,
-0.6352803111076355,
-0.43076854944229126,
0.11644972115755081,
-0.6919081211090088,
0.15704794228076935,
-1.1291471719741821,
-0.19995567202568054,
-0.5144984126091003,
-0.07080100476741791,
-0.7627873420715332,
-0.594386637210846,
-0.3191903829574585,
-0.19909241795539856,
0.5080095529556274,
0.5169813632965088,
-0.3646053075790405,
0.46689727902412415,
-0.8165779709815979,
-0.017807623371481895,
0.10161483287811279,
0.029612259939312935,
0.3008882701396942,
-0.7532775402069092,
-0.29800230264663696,
0.04520978778600693,
0.059705521911382675,
-0.34821534156799316,
0.4915601909160614,
0.2675412893295288,
0.6651832461357117,
0.6125794649124146,
0.12538769841194153,
0.854209303855896,
-0.18364103138446808,
0.8410887718200684,
-0.23566830158233643,
-0.800424337387085,
0.21824869513511658,
-0.12264549732208252,
0.037032339721918106,
0.6557510495185852,
0.0940476655960083,
-0.36984699964523315,
-0.903148353099823,
-0.7951345443725586,
-1.1086928844451904,
0.6481078267097473,
0.045467253774404526,
0.16479654610157013,
-0.1924058496952057,
0.5436074137687683,
0.15143100917339325,
0.28643739223480225,
-0.09756436198949814,
-0.2265341430902481,
-0.3521824777126312,
-0.011303498409688473,
-0.30129367113113403,
-0.4905233085155487,
0.12657086551189423,
0.11645667999982834,
0.5656479001045227,
-0.10865599662065506,
0.3661153018474579,
0.176503986120224,
-0.08179783821105957,
-0.35538822412490845,
0.0628071129322052,
0.39611920714378357,
0.5352663993835449,
-0.3435370922088623,
0.22083164751529694,
-0.06833508610725403,
-0.6268863081932068,
0.02272059954702854,
0.36445194482803345,
-0.09090311825275421,
-0.048343807458877563,
0.7082638144493103,
0.6140210628509521,
-0.013989749364554882,
-0.515770673751831,
0.19400884211063385,
-0.07709503918886185,
-0.19484099745750427,
-0.5399961471557617,
0.20599550008773804,
-0.08948330581188202,
0.505151093006134,
0.8585628867149353,
0.12061755359172821,
0.3812393844127655,
-0.4349048435688019,
0.4201735854148865,
0.3542731702327728,
0.012438899837434292,
-0.24043285846710205,
0.7229080200195312,
0.03508959710597992,
-0.09034246951341629,
0.42122703790664673,
-0.21498927474021912,
-0.26092690229415894,
0.816013514995575,
0.3229992985725403,
0.9230530261993408,
-0.008486148901283741,
0.007952520623803139,
0.1787337213754654,
0.47712916135787964,
-0.3710353672504425,
0.4200447201728821,
-0.06868554651737213,
-0.5990923047065735,
-0.9164009690284729,
-0.6321476101875305,
-0.37593793869018555,
0.23504477739334106,
-0.6705406308174133,
-0.0521148145198822,
-0.6941906213760376,
-0.28560149669647217,
-0.31686002016067505,
0.22694048285484314,
-0.4750235080718994,
-0.004870963748544455,
0.16428561508655548,
1.2658189535140991,
-0.8824595808982849,
0.7359409332275391,
0.5911597013473511,
-0.22597721219062805,
-1.1922760009765625,
0.18354454636573792,
0.13707777857780457,
-0.9786519408226013,
1.0010088682174683,
0.08229835331439972,
-0.486179381608963,
-0.06862173974514008,
-0.5021289587020874,
-1.2477855682373047,
0.9286580681800842,
0.1797611564397812,
-0.6319783926010132,
-0.1321260631084442,
0.06084341183304787,
0.5355412364006042,
-0.5380720496177673,
0.48007938265800476,
0.4192017912864685,
0.16164307296276093,
0.399880051612854,
-0.7627063393592834,
0.0029163958970457315,
-0.6414973735809326,
0.25100988149642944,
-0.1517670601606369,
-0.9550958871841431,
1.2352458238601685,
-0.18045343458652496,
-0.09535699337720871,
0.10076764971017838,
1.2430427074432373,
0.44849908351898193,
-0.11837384104728699,
0.5624694228172302,
0.5171617865562439,
0.8181498050689697,
0.23219801485538483,
1.1563116312026978,
-0.7302888035774231,
0.2281825840473175,
0.9621147513389587,
-0.3590630888938904,
1.2256481647491455,
0.5651180744171143,
-0.11598926782608032,
0.33080148696899414,
1.027276635169983,
0.2046077698469162,
0.3869759738445282,
-0.2972503900527954,
-0.1601765751838684,
-0.5140112638473511,
0.3537907302379608,
-0.6262038946151733,
0.6759540438652039,
0.5936729311943054,
-0.3251732587814331,
-0.16271664202213287,
-0.35852548480033875,
-0.07008195668458939,
-0.17350827157497406,
-0.014689750038087368,
0.3080842196941376,
0.15939414501190186,
-0.7583827376365662,
0.67901611328125,
0.024227170273661613,
0.7203646302223206,
-0.449567973613739,
-0.04250877723097801,
-0.37260740995407104,
0.35483378171920776,
0.021020272746682167,
-0.6075231432914734,
0.2720670998096466,
-0.18946126103401184,
-0.2692984640598297,
0.09077111631631851,
0.22452346980571747,
-0.3692573606967926,
-0.9399283528327942,
0.169936865568161,
0.4301970601081848,
0.22513672709465027,
-0.12186632305383682,
-0.5587174296379089,
0.31888580322265625,
-0.2358090728521347,
-0.46557506918907166,
0.07754073292016983,
0.6790474057197571,
-0.03850226104259491,
0.8718245625495911,
0.8936973214149475,
0.4558839201927185,
0.2809431254863739,
-0.24554595351219177,
0.7578466534614563,
-0.5029646158218384,
-0.8636504411697388,
-0.6631494760513306,
0.1715918332338333,
0.17173147201538086,
-0.3066542148590088,
0.5415473580360413,
0.37932896614074707,
0.7439550757408142,
0.24041137099266052,
0.9274529218673706,
0.07042144238948822,
0.7003163695335388,
-0.7503240704536438,
0.681113064289093,
-0.5204288363456726,
0.81027752161026,
-0.20092074573040009,
-0.6535382866859436,
-0.07655252516269684,
0.5118687748908997,
-0.15623518824577332,
0.1349487602710724,
0.5889416933059692,
0.8871236443519592,
-0.08307315409183502,
0.15557469427585602,
0.0339730829000473,
0.24424712359905243,
0.5409889221191406,
0.48003658652305603,
0.8603516221046448,
-0.6092391610145569,
0.6071151494979858,
-0.3827679455280304,
-0.3156936764717102,
-0.4945598542690277,
-0.9301561713218689,
-0.6961672306060791,
-0.4648888111114502,
-0.022989027202129364,
-0.3872607350349426,
0.022476546466350555,
1.123178243637085,
1.025633454322815,
-0.6990174055099487,
-0.33220174908638,
0.11088097095489502,
-0.5467577576637268,
-0.418860524892807,
-0.1736484318971634,
0.5945525765419006,
-0.5429274439811707,
-0.8008695244789124,
0.2534743547439575,
0.038586508482694626,
0.05543291196227074,
-0.5126342177391052,
0.08048035204410553,
-0.10068387538194656,
0.053248416632413864,
0.30409666895866394,
0.7153283357620239,
-1.1010541915893555,
-0.1349874585866928,
0.32195454835891724,
-0.1701931357383728,
-0.23952797055244446,
0.7864511013031006,
-0.8617115616798401,
0.26629266142845154,
0.13165788352489471,
0.9738498330116272,
0.5770919919013977,
0.06755564361810684,
0.6241269707679749,
-0.4785591661930084,
0.7443312406539917,
0.06191808357834816,
0.1771770566701889,
0.19270935654640198,
-0.7478911280632019,
-0.039704032242298126,
0.07615700364112854,
-0.31831908226013184,
-0.8856714963912964,
0.29649871587753296,
-0.6924999356269836,
-0.2922467291355133,
1.1601437330245972,
-0.06655104458332062,
-0.4596622586250305,
-0.18846367299556732,
0.07042688131332397,
0.12422845512628555,
-0.6494519710540771,
1.0831406116485596,
0.833196759223938,
-0.2509189546108246,
-0.49126413464546204,
-0.4900748133659363,
0.5766566395759583,
0.5239430069923401,
-0.4087863564491272,
0.0781019926071167,
0.23809534311294556,
-0.012478477321565151,
0.23125173151493073,
0.7905111312866211,
0.03656837344169617,
0.2884039878845215,
0.3734067380428314,
-0.05344010889530182,
-0.4361480474472046,
-0.38971176743507385,
-0.007656465750187635,
0.11764652281999588,
0.39794933795928955,
-0.047343358397483826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15068v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15068v1 | Pairing Orthographically Variant Literary Words to Standard Equivalents Using Neural Edit Distance Models | 2024-01-26T18:49:34 | 2024-01-26T18:49:34 | Craig Messner, Tom Lippincott | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a novel corpus consisting of orthographically variant words found
in works of 19th century U.S. literature annotated with their corresponding
"standard" word pair. We train a set of neural edit distance models to pair
these variants with their standard forms, and compare the performance of these
models to the performance of a set of neural edit distance models trained on a
corpus of orthographic errors made by L2 English learners. Finally, we analyze
the relative performance of these models in the light of different negative
training sample generation strategies, and offer concluding remarks on the
unique challenge literary orthographic variation poses to string pairing
methodologies. | [
0.20749624073505402,
-0.7393096685409546,
0.3895127773284912,
-0.5080393552780151,
-0.1943928301334381,
-0.08508061617612839,
-0.27173274755477905,
-0.9438825845718384,
0.515831470489502,
0.7446532249450684,
-0.2172091156244278,
-0.35340315103530884,
-0.49160075187683105,
0.21969765424728394,
-0.32248055934906006,
0.530828595161438,
-0.07931099086999893,
0.5668846964836121,
-0.23141175508499146,
-0.7231984734535217,
-0.48240113258361816,
-0.5386199951171875,
-0.5614580512046814,
-0.5880202651023865,
0.7592249512672424,
-0.15840137004852295,
0.96881103515625,
0.6230303645133972,
0.4474411606788635,
0.2990304231643677,
-0.18374472856521606,
0.34423792362213135,
-0.23095425963401794,
0.34308335185050964,
-0.27427878975868225,
-0.8710036277770996,
-0.3504217267036438,
0.3455297350883484,
0.6386719942092896,
0.8991278409957886,
0.2261793613433838,
0.02412889525294304,
-0.3391006886959076,
0.8294113278388977,
-0.36663153767585754,
-0.5293763279914856,
-0.7101776003837585,
0.11056502163410187,
-0.7394488453865051,
-0.10862509161233902,
-0.256559282541275,
-0.5178229212760925,
0.11042264848947525,
-0.5701794028282166,
0.5071899890899658,
0.085330069065094,
0.8402789831161499,
-0.06424107402563095,
-0.3015349805355072,
-0.3160339891910553,
-0.409714013338089,
0.5342185497283936,
-0.8524422645568848,
0.3797268569469452,
0.32792600989341736,
-0.05131823569536209,
-0.29332759976387024,
-0.6909385323524475,
-0.5254620909690857,
-0.3179081678390503,
-0.24306920170783997,
-0.031280167400836945,
0.19768723845481873,
0.29921478033065796,
0.26512062549591064,
0.2707821726799011,
-0.7068797945976257,
0.19668342173099518,
-0.5575851798057556,
0.03780238702893257,
0.9306553602218628,
0.16396063566207886,
0.5212751626968384,
-0.3212587535381317,
0.08890026807785034,
0.04885940998792648,
-0.7138233184814453,
0.15574730932712555,
0.9808429479598999,
0.40121304988861084,
0.10088348388671875,
0.7868552803993225,
0.14177507162094116,
1.0509018898010254,
-0.03816022723913193,
0.18261095881462097,
0.15307796001434326,
-0.1595090627670288,
-0.08464319258928299,
0.05637332797050476,
0.6374194025993347,
0.5945412516593933,
0.09506351500749588,
-0.2786969542503357,
-0.4672850966453552,
0.0865154042840004,
0.13187693059444427,
-0.18362559378147125,
-0.3795454204082489,
-0.21829819679260254,
-0.4221048355102539,
-0.20051860809326172,
-0.14954444766044617,
-0.5336884260177612,
-0.8372288346290588,
-0.5058704614639282,
0.6813163757324219,
-0.6947081685066223,
0.12624910473823547,
0.1900538057088852,
-0.7506148815155029,
0.025756075978279114,
0.07046129554510117,
-1.1625679731369019,
0.30177170038223267,
0.5063561201095581,
0.6027205586433411,
-0.17346154153347015,
-0.5112664103507996,
-0.12119143456220627,
-0.1067107617855072,
-0.4249729514122009,
0.6385416984558105,
-0.5617819428443909,
-0.5026068091392517,
0.2639245390892029,
-0.43729478120803833,
-0.3516290485858917,
-0.47467178106307983,
0.5139800310134888,
-0.7649662494659424,
0.340347021818161,
-0.20118291676044464,
-0.952489972114563,
-0.3805641829967499,
-0.02116374485194683,
-0.7809814214706421,
1.2536742687225342,
0.25772160291671753,
-0.8702285289764404,
0.06302370876073837,
-0.3972438871860504,
-0.3901062309741974,
0.11829274892807007,
-0.129713237285614,
-0.12118405848741531,
0.3584901690483093,
-0.06637589633464813,
0.0885574072599411,
-0.10264512151479721,
-0.27288714051246643,
-0.26952987909317017,
-0.6384648084640503,
0.23935136198997498,
-0.2931094467639923,
1.1897146701812744,
-0.18455469608306885,
-0.22668930888175964,
-0.0916261300444603,
-0.9947181940078735,
-0.19436486065387726,
0.28914400935173035,
-0.2139892280101776,
-0.9788055419921875,
-0.037815600633621216,
0.33860543370246887,
-0.3782508969306946,
0.5414484143257141,
-0.608658492565155,
0.22829550504684448,
-0.5354920625686646,
0.7586339116096497,
0.4580458700656891,
-0.11319969594478607,
0.5587877631187439,
-0.7252932786941528,
0.6688463091850281,
-0.46365663409233093,
-0.11355193704366684,
0.059350576251745224,
-0.2479231357574463,
-0.6986709833145142,
-0.013502580113708973,
0.8318941593170166,
0.5457481145858765,
-0.5976080298423767,
0.28347885608673096,
0.0054584345780313015,
-0.8201645016670227,
-0.8822202682495117,
0.034957192838191986,
0.23473137617111206,
0.49934759736061096,
0.2639424502849579,
-0.4297640919685364,
-0.627858579158783,
-0.7237204313278198,
-0.7904698252677917,
0.03354111313819885,
0.23039890825748444,
0.24160891771316528,
0.2538725733757019,
0.17350482940673828,
0.860809326171875,
-0.30571088194847107,
0.04867863655090332,
0.06154488027095795,
0.1412988007068634,
0.014728182926774025,
0.5355074405670166,
0.7563632726669312,
-0.6638898849487305,
-0.34529179334640503,
-0.3329426944255829,
-0.45464080572128296,
0.15969908237457275,
-0.0006183341611176729,
-0.04912303388118744,
0.3832375109195709,
0.8139918446540833,
-0.24142752587795258,
0.44929662346839905,
0.5482010841369629,
-0.24056953191757202,
0.7561978101730347,
-0.56437087059021,
0.23129267990589142,
-1.0525681972503662,
-0.1255916804075241,
-0.19518394768238068,
-0.18594075739383698,
-0.5685070753097534,
0.18162952363491058,
0.17065705358982086,
0.18640585243701935,
-0.3254493474960327,
0.4855459928512573,
-0.46434471011161804,
0.23806598782539368,
0.008549811318516731,
0.5491917133331299,
0.14390967786312103,
0.1529873013496399,
-0.023451754823327065,
0.35929757356643677,
0.33476522564888,
-0.06514795124530792,
0.5334805846214294,
0.14181506633758545,
-0.21810485422611237,
0.9880051612854004,
-0.5324186682701111,
0.5116748213768005,
-0.3043975532054901,
0.3846384286880493,
-1.2999441623687744,
-0.2513241767883301,
-0.1830349564552307,
-0.3870527446269989,
0.33785170316696167,
0.1422721892595291,
-0.6050980091094971,
-0.02663315273821354,
-0.5272246599197388,
0.8558061122894287,
0.3535337746143341,
-0.5482025742530823,
0.33364224433898926,
0.013823459856212139,
-0.04021913558244705,
-0.291874498128891,
-0.8402732014656067,
0.10919006168842316,
-0.3535497188568115,
-0.6868094205856323,
0.5321847200393677,
0.10435949265956879,
-0.17577067017555237,
-0.0977177768945694,
0.16373437643051147,
-0.05834254249930382,
-0.22075632214546204,
0.19083616137504578,
0.32868239283561707,
-0.34157276153564453,
0.3714229464530945,
0.1473863571882248,
0.24678289890289307,
-0.15470638871192932,
-0.23635749518871307,
0.2241613119840622,
0.2940225899219513,
-0.1730935126543045,
-0.21236398816108704,
0.5771148204803467,
0.32771581411361694,
-0.38890525698661804,
0.40962180495262146,
0.341054767370224,
-0.46878352761268616,
0.049481477588415146,
-0.7946509718894958,
-0.28212252259254456,
-0.45380130410194397,
0.2415788620710373,
-0.16701948642730713,
-0.8228934407234192,
0.38912835717201233,
0.3641844093799591,
0.1336621344089508,
0.43287530541419983,
-0.10773361474275589,
-0.410335898399353,
0.3604241907596588,
0.46016156673431396,
0.2046089619398117,
0.5863879323005676,
-0.16664351522922516,
0.049239397048950195,
-0.7575483322143555,
-0.10191580653190613,
-0.5859605669975281,
-0.8324216604232788,
-0.6885820031166077,
-0.22316096723079681,
0.272213876247406,
0.2707866132259369,
-0.06690781563520432,
0.6541434526443481,
-0.35239049792289734,
0.7171378135681152,
1.0530768632888794,
0.2286943793296814,
0.34436094760894775,
-0.1297982931137085,
-0.29575902223587036,
-0.2952077090740204,
-0.606238067150116,
-0.4861217141151428,
1.3274778127670288,
-0.07786291837692261,
0.266995906829834,
0.2192373275756836,
0.9242624640464783,
0.10757926106452942,
-0.14673474431037903,
-0.4294722378253937,
0.4306134283542633,
-0.37219247221946716,
-0.7930552363395691,
-0.3392224907875061,
-0.052108436822891235,
-1.059999704360962,
-0.12816567718982697,
-0.45679208636283875,
-0.7806790471076965,
0.0659203827381134,
0.06539991497993469,
-0.6493826508522034,
0.35856616497039795,
-0.5991261005401611,
0.7903769016265869,
-0.13195684552192688,
-0.017224140465259552,
-0.1407293975353241,
-0.857181191444397,
0.16659274697303772,
0.07217617332935333,
-0.05951569601893425,
0.311321496963501,
-0.3129011392593384,
0.7275571823120117,
-0.11353030800819397,
0.7464697957038879,
0.2683197855949402,
0.08607175946235657,
0.19626933336257935,
0.3712230324745178,
0.38627883791923523,
-0.06510257720947266,
-0.5343531370162964,
0.21415817737579346,
0.17400473356246948,
-0.49031558632850647,
-0.4880739748477936,
0.6129986047744751,
-0.6583616733551025,
-0.2530180811882019,
-0.24706324934959412,
-0.7817579507827759,
-0.16289983689785004,
0.2020169347524643,
0.712830126285553,
0.7943854928016663,
-0.29241225123405457,
-0.021426977589726448,
0.2612583339214325,
0.0004689801426138729,
0.7705298066139221,
0.40797534584999084,
-0.013901659287512302,
-0.9166286587715149,
0.48868516087532043,
0.6283705830574036,
0.11730584502220154,
0.5265069007873535,
-0.016982359811663628,
-0.5703853368759155,
-0.6742764711380005,
-0.3677991032600403,
0.35158929228782654,
-0.43850409984588623,
0.10803327709436417,
-0.29241374135017395,
-0.23237141966819763,
-0.5268756151199341,
-0.5901213884353638,
-0.1769789457321167,
-0.6239904165267944,
-0.5573290586471558,
-0.19489021599292755,
0.8449349999427795,
0.869564414024353,
-0.30003076791763306,
0.054740164428949356,
-0.693691611289978,
-0.08493034541606903,
0.28905436396598816,
0.33866551518440247,
-0.2035982459783554,
-0.6582939028739929,
-0.26939380168914795,
-0.133352130651474,
-0.43028873205184937,
-1.1679890155792236,
0.014572410844266415,
0.04785274341702461,
0.17348122596740723,
-0.17499300837516785,
0.13968853652477264,
0.47753986716270447,
-0.717426598072052,
1.181508183479309,
0.33372732996940613,
-0.8056424260139465,
0.22697117924690247,
-0.8436936736106873,
0.08247669041156769,
0.780742347240448,
0.25884875655174255,
-0.7684920430183411,
-0.38112008571624756,
-1.0447543859481812,
-0.8296038508415222,
0.41987505555152893,
0.040671780705451965,
0.3077455163002014,
-0.025275755673646927,
0.5844498872756958,
0.36192211508750916,
0.19935478270053864,
-0.5837463736534119,
-0.3577091693878174,
0.11926353722810745,
-0.2889685332775116,
-0.5687717199325562,
0.009617982432246208,
-0.01845988817512989,
-0.3869037628173828,
0.6482884287834167,
0.32042691111564636,
-0.10737939178943634,
0.5040998458862305,
-0.24085678160190582,
-0.06181343272328377,
-0.049879040569067,
0.9629482626914978,
0.5261561274528503,
-0.12190499901771545,
0.28255876898765564,
0.3169623017311096,
-0.449584037065506,
0.017954381182789803,
0.34951549768447876,
-0.4170292615890503,
0.3813507854938507,
0.42844080924987793,
0.7132519483566284,
0.07394422590732574,
-0.5968206524848938,
0.22869032621383667,
0.36045175790786743,
-0.33076420426368713,
-0.43714284896850586,
-0.06399966031312943,
0.39863017201423645,
0.3951018750667572,
-0.08840063959360123,
0.4240933060646057,
0.18892616033554077,
-0.25912049412727356,
0.07526551187038422,
0.31984254717826843,
-0.5653733611106873,
-0.3846178650856018,
0.604160487651825,
0.26939457654953003,
-1.2497977018356323,
0.37416213750839233,
-0.352741539478302,
-0.19599592685699463,
0.4215385615825653,
0.33665937185287476,
0.9045973420143127,
-0.09614070504903793,
0.13224826753139496,
0.26574498414993286,
0.2963448464870453,
-0.06884898990392685,
0.1371694803237915,
0.26818546652793884,
-0.5386227369308472,
-0.15334606170654297,
-0.3926464021205902,
-0.33776232600212097,
0.4378039836883545,
-0.6113738417625427,
0.4723055064678192,
-0.4683871567249298,
-0.11333178728818893,
0.02155698463320732,
-0.06077145040035248,
-0.43236541748046875,
-0.053126368671655655,
-0.038954589515924454,
0.7970945835113525,
-0.6853421330451965,
0.7371090054512024,
0.9944472312927246,
-0.31628790497779846,
-0.9145632982254028,
-0.18593275547027588,
-0.11286389827728271,
-0.4348863363265991,
0.38652461767196655,
-0.025267865508794785,
0.12677133083343506,
0.10270122438669205,
-0.09212127327919006,
-0.4983613193035126,
0.928226113319397,
0.380378395318985,
-0.517227828502655,
-0.08713404834270477,
0.15727443993091583,
0.8340502381324768,
-0.17158347368240356,
0.3965582251548767,
0.827383816242218,
0.24149547517299652,
-0.2729935944080353,
-0.6755124926567078,
-0.13384540379047394,
-0.14824600517749786,
0.3184206783771515,
0.5256453156471252,
-0.649499237537384,
0.8117176294326782,
0.15773387253284454,
0.25858938694000244,
0.6421632766723633,
0.6326975226402283,
-0.018513217568397522,
0.44740617275238037,
0.3543328642845154,
0.8738068342208862,
0.8255082964897156,
0.2448650598526001,
0.6075698733329773,
-0.28330904245376587,
0.26348283886909485,
1.2552306652069092,
-0.1780133843421936,
1.1445658206939697,
0.5695343017578125,
-0.25672852993011475,
0.37246841192245483,
0.8597341179847717,
-0.011818169616162777,
0.059779588133096695,
0.46824952960014343,
-0.42415887117385864,
0.04903120920062065,
0.01622622460126877,
-0.46528327465057373,
0.41569724678993225,
-0.027181848883628845,
-0.5777912139892578,
-0.16377754509449005,
-0.2212177813053131,
-0.031185805797576904,
0.8645450472831726,
-0.1124681681394577,
0.5662289261817932,
0.04240467771887779,
-0.8417972922325134,
0.5949100255966187,
0.16373950242996216,
0.9574233889579773,
-0.35597604513168335,
0.16172979772090912,
-0.36997923254966736,
-0.10679145157337189,
-0.14706704020500183,
-0.18737353384494781,
0.27047303318977356,
-0.14189524948596954,
-0.3434503972530365,
0.07953545451164246,
0.326378732919693,
-0.7472267150878906,
-0.5932444334030151,
0.19047902524471283,
-0.06266199797391891,
0.026292074471712112,
0.2845042645931244,
-0.5921332240104675,
-0.39417681097984314,
-0.04623858630657196,
0.05805681273341179,
0.13567182421684265,
0.2794868052005768,
0.2842854857444763,
-0.2965319752693176,
0.17753252387046814,
0.39407429099082947,
0.391518771648407,
-0.08103277534246445,
0.03253636881709099,
-0.7140273451805115,
-0.31610578298568726,
-0.7524150609970093,
0.47240206599235535,
-0.16952906548976898,
-0.7535903453826904,
0.5879650115966797,
0.5177813768386841,
0.7555441856384277,
-0.20212404429912567,
0.6731954216957092,
0.18648840487003326,
0.6845616102218628,
-0.5806729197502136,
0.8882642984390259,
-0.76556795835495,
-0.08972956240177155,
-0.2392863780260086,
-1.051429271697998,
-0.3806580901145935,
0.36053162813186646,
-0.4071640074253082,
-0.11695203930139542,
1.0117582082748413,
1.1232041120529175,
0.024047289043664932,
0.29934725165367126,
0.37179961800575256,
0.035557255148887634,
-0.19331227242946625,
0.43295788764953613,
0.5538600087165833,
-0.910406231880188,
0.16969840228557587,
-0.13893315196037292,
-0.103066585958004,
-0.3361663520336151,
-0.9697896242141724,
-0.8908992409706116,
-0.7976211309432983,
-0.43705934286117554,
-0.5290412306785583,
0.415763258934021,
1.107271432876587,
0.2842351198196411,
-0.3839664161205292,
-0.3397648334503174,
-0.34921127557754517,
0.0002085346495732665,
-0.2960127592086792,
-0.13545721769332886,
0.5089553594589233,
-0.2777334451675415,
-0.8027763962745667,
0.31420549750328064,
0.032869067043066025,
0.37889355421066284,
-0.22022561728954315,
0.15180906653404236,
-0.29054051637649536,
0.6541814208030701,
0.17252032458782196,
0.21371248364448547,
-0.7341080904006958,
-0.5389326810836792,
-0.10802598297595978,
-0.3933069705963135,
0.010577531531453133,
0.6782909631729126,
-0.3204266428947449,
0.6417324542999268,
0.8172469735145569,
0.6315273642539978,
0.2578431963920593,
-0.32721492648124695,
0.5570418834686279,
-0.8990265727043152,
0.27797427773475647,
0.45662033557891846,
0.3612203001976013,
0.4784577786922455,
-0.2507498562335968,
0.4705173075199127,
0.6761825084686279,
-0.46797308325767517,
-0.7823078036308289,
0.4652908146381378,
-0.9864584803581238,
-0.11054138839244843,
1.0707931518554688,
-0.12161606550216675,
-0.043684929609298706,
0.13648001849651337,
-0.2704298198223114,
0.27222323417663574,
-0.059732045978307724,
0.8242546319961548,
0.9509471654891968,
0.12475117295980453,
0.32348155975341797,
-0.394999623298645,
0.6688390970230103,
0.7182524800300598,
-0.19473500549793243,
-0.33170968294143677,
0.376151442527771,
0.3051733672618866,
0.36247965693473816,
0.30564403533935547,
-0.011777329258620739,
0.336599200963974,
0.3070870637893677,
0.3626457452774048,
-0.04347095265984535,
0.15302757918834686,
-0.5731518864631653,
0.05674152076244354,
0.20537671446800232,
-0.24219879508018494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01720v1 | Deep Learning Based Amharic Chatbot for FAQs in Universities | 2024-01-26T18:37:21 | 2024-01-26T18:37:21 | Goitom Ybrah Hailu, Shishay Welay | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | University students often spend a considerable amount of time seeking answers
to common questions from administrators or teachers. This can become tedious
for both parties, leading to a need for a solution. In response, this paper
proposes a chatbot model that utilizes natural language processing and deep
learning techniques to answer frequently asked questions (FAQs) in the Amharic
language. Chatbots are computer programs that simulate human conversation
through the use of artificial intelligence (AI), acting as a virtual assistant
to handle questions and other tasks. The proposed chatbot program employs
tokenization, normalization, stop word removal, and stemming to analyze and
categorize Amharic input sentences. Three machine learning model algorithms
were used to classify tokens and retrieve appropriate responses: Support Vector
Machine (SVM), Multinomial Na\"ive Bayes, and deep neural networks implemented
through TensorFlow, Keras, and NLTK. The deep learning model achieved the best
results with 91.55% accuracy and a validation loss of 0.3548 using an Adam
optimizer and SoftMax activation function. The chatbot model was integrated
with Facebook Messenger and deployed on a Heroku server for 24-hour
accessibility. The experimental results demonstrate that the chatbot framework
achieved its objectives and effectively addressed challenges such as Amharic
Fidel variation, morphological variation, and lexical gaps. Future research
could explore the integration of Amharic WordNet to narrow the lexical gap and
support more complex questions. | [
-0.3804798722267151,
-1.66022789478302,
0.17776930332183838,
0.0642654076218605,
-0.14380498230457306,
0.6336585879325867,
-0.20222119987010956,
-0.37970513105392456,
0.37169066071510315,
0.5187936425209045,
-0.6717413663864136,
-0.3981725573539734,
-0.2039886862039566,
0.1698393076658249,
-0.42882511019706726,
0.8110305070877075,
0.09784465283155441,
0.13944528996944427,
-0.18855836987495422,
-0.14867717027664185,
-0.6671808958053589,
-0.6029571890830994,
-1.127125859260559,
-0.34190812706947327,
0.32451120018959045,
0.6635931730270386,
1.0865875482559204,
0.1222551241517067,
0.3112475872039795,
0.3880118727684021,
-0.05753636360168457,
0.1675758957862854,
-0.2589053213596344,
0.18939192593097687,
0.3457280695438385,
-0.650903582572937,
-0.12488365918397903,
-0.144786074757576,
0.25745779275894165,
0.5804321765899658,
-0.19522619247436523,
-0.016092844307422638,
0.036783698946237564,
0.5520548820495605,
-0.41698575019836426,
-0.050316665321588516,
-0.5343356132507324,
0.22851276397705078,
0.01912544295191765,
0.05071262642741203,
0.007937783375382423,
-0.4593404233455658,
0.08070047199726105,
-0.6258098483085632,
0.2118666023015976,
-0.08001553267240524,
0.8175657987594604,
0.2665794789791107,
-0.2917490303516388,
-0.5410600304603577,
-0.7663443684577942,
0.6437313556671143,
-0.6713807582855225,
0.40376296639442444,
0.2501942813396454,
0.5976991653442383,
-0.32737067341804504,
-0.4531543552875519,
-0.8468986749649048,
-0.35991814732551575,
-0.08546749502420425,
0.037472888827323914,
-0.43917855620384216,
0.08502813428640366,
-0.1042790561914444,
0.5075492858886719,
-0.5370003581047058,
0.23245465755462646,
-0.4449703097343445,
-0.2698545753955841,
0.42161256074905396,
0.34567341208457947,
0.3401925265789032,
-0.3632221817970276,
-0.35850057005882263,
0.14545361697673798,
-0.22879184782505035,
0.4738433063030243,
0.4085725247859955,
0.1168801486492157,
-0.15293189883232117,
0.4901807904243469,
-0.4933891296386719,
0.4459005296230316,
-0.08870651572942734,
0.3203532099723816,
0.16222162544727325,
-0.2679159939289093,
-0.2215297669172287,
-0.20183534920215607,
0.7789086103439331,
0.309804767370224,
0.581269383430481,
-0.03623390570282936,
0.11910990625619888,
-0.054629135876894,
0.3029162883758545,
-0.6728434562683105,
-0.2545560300350189,
0.4701654016971588,
-0.3517650067806244,
-0.5407843589782715,
-0.4068901836872101,
-0.7650052309036255,
-0.4679311215877533,
-0.4570619463920593,
0.19346345961093903,
-0.5186424851417542,
-0.2084185928106308,
-0.0930357351899147,
0.16797499358654022,
0.32911860942840576,
0.8314370512962341,
-0.7608272433280945,
0.35599786043167114,
0.5354664921760559,
0.9758673310279846,
-0.21409544348716736,
-0.0245406161993742,
-0.37644675374031067,
-0.34765443205833435,
0.0659039169549942,
0.5443949699401855,
-0.5130182504653931,
-0.507664144039154,
0.24398064613342285,
-0.0342189259827137,
0.057113490998744965,
-0.2807252109050751,
0.4089144766330719,
-0.6421552896499634,
0.16843929886817932,
0.3094525933265686,
-0.7096083164215088,
-0.4065570533275604,
0.4615105092525482,
-0.5779710412025452,
0.77607262134552,
-0.18090295791625977,
-0.49937671422958374,
-0.11189448088407516,
-1.0377470254898071,
-0.5453027486801147,
0.4940226078033447,
-0.4376894533634186,
-0.1459043174982071,
-0.1503424495458603,
0.3936307728290558,
0.6428592205047607,
-0.17237403988838196,
0.298704594373703,
-0.19406430423259735,
-0.3327602446079254,
0.8516474366188049,
-0.7776802182197571,
0.9580527544021606,
0.30467402935028076,
0.014218932017683983,
0.3750956952571869,
-0.375650554895401,
-0.0029165903106331825,
0.062383562326431274,
-0.5488983988761902,
-0.06841008365154266,
-0.1846960186958313,
0.17338189482688904,
-0.0991741418838501,
0.4464956521987915,
-0.6701145172119141,
0.2505263090133667,
-0.4949060082435608,
0.6185053586959839,
0.651298999786377,
-0.01995013654232025,
0.4582803547382355,
-0.08963160216808319,
0.5771525502204895,
0.019217276945710182,
0.3452162444591522,
0.01958031766116619,
-0.8251551389694214,
-0.9261620044708252,
0.10967790335416794,
0.25322264432907104,
0.9195274710655212,
-0.7271493673324585,
0.40990591049194336,
-0.06090448051691055,
-0.5062944889068604,
-0.8615545630455017,
0.373540461063385,
0.1431765854358673,
0.509506344795227,
0.49752840399742126,
-0.1524369865655899,
-0.2801262438297272,
-0.7914247512817383,
-0.06557629257440567,
-0.2385592758655548,
-0.22527070343494415,
0.6723821759223938,
0.6084862351417542,
-0.37255483865737915,
1.0619531869888306,
-0.7215079665184021,
-0.3354410231113434,
-0.2688405513763428,
0.3933531641960144,
0.2469988763332367,
0.47218018770217896,
0.36526933312416077,
-1.133013129234314,
-0.3930443227291107,
-0.059006813913583755,
-0.6893777847290039,
0.03369291126728058,
0.024344878271222115,
-0.006613436620682478,
0.28913161158561707,
0.48984333872795105,
-0.723879873752594,
0.5881956219673157,
0.1772535890340805,
-0.24310259521007538,
0.5903303027153015,
-0.11313395947217941,
0.2694452404975891,
-1.2170449495315552,
0.08669381588697433,
-0.24980390071868896,
-0.14058169722557068,
-0.8123719692230225,
-0.061823226511478424,
-0.20970498025417328,
-0.42863795161247253,
-0.510868489742279,
0.8905417323112488,
0.18108783662319183,
0.3052418529987335,
-0.592557966709137,
0.01901477761566639,
-0.17786090075969696,
0.6660334467887878,
-0.06128950044512749,
0.6654676795005798,
0.34419068694114685,
-0.8352338671684265,
0.8263502717018127,
0.49910902976989746,
-0.08614185452461243,
0.2535000443458557,
-0.7664941549301147,
0.03315526247024536,
-0.03823017328977585,
0.29340168833732605,
-1.2067677974700928,
-0.40092164278030396,
0.5871638059616089,
-0.8048425316810608,
-0.008639774285256863,
-0.1283900886774063,
-0.3374485969543457,
-0.635539710521698,
-0.11020124703645706,
0.15493899583816528,
0.362822949886322,
-0.43521392345428467,
0.7207722663879395,
0.38795021176338196,
-0.24936573207378387,
-0.7986835241317749,
-0.4976153075695038,
0.15698878467082977,
0.14610415697097778,
-0.7068317532539368,
0.013964005745947361,
-0.28326788544654846,
-0.20206362009048462,
-0.08520732820034027,
0.15332844853401184,
-0.35526782274246216,
0.6148296594619751,
0.5300542116165161,
0.2586553692817688,
-0.16295775771141052,
0.39220207929611206,
0.24188604950904846,
0.05389607697725296,
0.03507905825972557,
0.13374444842338562,
0.9623394012451172,
-0.3896450102329254,
-0.10175781697034836,
-0.5611438155174255,
0.49357298016548157,
0.39782238006591797,
-0.09453529864549637,
0.5962755680084229,
0.8270983695983887,
-0.41614001989364624,
0.17103798687458038,
-0.7098224759101868,
-0.4254489243030548,
-0.4929896295070648,
0.3139711916446686,
-0.2366640865802765,
-1.2511012554168701,
0.5714612007141113,
-0.01078961230814457,
0.4643149971961975,
0.15355093777179718,
0.6160550713539124,
-0.3593721389770508,
0.7637368440628052,
0.45474499464035034,
-0.12632465362548828,
0.4543760418891907,
-0.04786606878042221,
0.032784078270196915,
-0.197062149643898,
-0.1001274436712265,
-0.44734427332878113,
-0.3241782784461975,
-0.3860309422016144,
-0.48015764355659485,
-0.05976690724492073,
0.003348195692524314,
-0.08531101047992706,
0.13957367837429047,
-0.33023250102996826,
0.4054582715034485,
0.8154594302177429,
0.1848544329404831,
0.18284253776073456,
0.09870798885822296,
-0.0636386126279831,
0.2577400803565979,
-0.37087392807006836,
-0.6423699259757996,
0.8247365951538086,
0.47232532501220703,
0.7732469439506531,
0.10122478753328323,
0.39827224612236023,
0.6086931228637695,
0.3419801592826843,
-1.0162255764007568,
0.5662685036659241,
-0.17236031591892242,
-0.9480476975440979,
-0.6179503202438354,
-0.46098625659942627,
-0.9759247303009033,
0.10652070492506027,
-0.3849714696407318,
-0.6560083627700806,
-0.13740888237953186,
0.0185644943267107,
-0.4897415339946747,
0.27056753635406494,
-0.6847385764122009,
0.8776880502700806,
-0.27842968702316284,
-0.040601447224617004,
-0.29399532079696655,
-0.8541383147239685,
0.13050442934036255,
0.004598482046276331,
0.17736725509166718,
-0.2617529332637787,
0.18295201659202576,
0.8748720288276672,
-0.2995029091835022,
1.0512689352035522,
-0.13844728469848633,
0.15851274132728577,
0.45200037956237793,
-0.037162896245718,
0.045760706067085266,
0.3145592212677002,
0.03961886838078499,
0.2145950347185135,
-0.08199771493673325,
-0.4400636553764343,
-0.49584153294563293,
0.6438167095184326,
-1.0626883506774902,
-0.7145305871963501,
-0.015586759895086288,
-0.35588526725769043,
-0.16085182130336761,
0.1639668494462967,
-0.019478710368275642,
0.1877790093421936,
-0.5523990392684937,
0.45000648498535156,
0.49596360325813293,
-0.42311182618141174,
0.4253057837486267,
0.5927931666374207,
-0.38647446036338806,
-0.23113007843494415,
0.718969464302063,
0.030482755973935127,
-0.1692580282688141,
0.5479065775871277,
0.30179715156555176,
-0.2775764763355255,
-0.3843856155872345,
-0.7855632901191711,
-0.030798017978668213,
-0.6915407180786133,
-0.43544915318489075,
-0.8925257325172424,
-0.4796982407569885,
-0.6473139524459839,
-0.2567004859447479,
-0.11227088421583176,
-0.23346656560897827,
-0.4215172529220581,
-0.02168267033994198,
0.725439727306366,
0.3821338713169098,
0.228541761636734,
0.6900254487991333,
-0.8650693893432617,
0.30496668815612793,
0.5498989224433899,
0.10530338436365128,
0.02514408528804779,
-0.42784354090690613,
-0.05388016626238823,
0.336103230714798,
-0.4197477102279663,
-0.8342829346656799,
0.30433231592178345,
0.11450633406639099,
0.3601842522621155,
0.39023783802986145,
0.15175947546958923,
0.409772664308548,
-0.21511797606945038,
0.7153666615486145,
0.3290576934814453,
-0.7615363001823425,
0.5418813824653625,
-0.2280624806880951,
0.39403045177459717,
0.7093020081520081,
0.5307667255401611,
-0.7959809303283691,
-0.4588434398174286,
-0.43337756395339966,
-0.7510221004486084,
0.43884754180908203,
0.4893936514854431,
0.7258152365684509,
0.13513116538524628,
0.5702977776527405,
0.1679634004831314,
0.43643805384635925,
-0.6175743341445923,
-0.5164434909820557,
-0.2478950023651123,
-0.28914424777030945,
0.1136411651968956,
0.03176414221525192,
0.23907947540283203,
-0.2775307893753052,
0.5868514180183411,
-0.1371825486421585,
0.2011829912662506,
-0.08544895052909851,
-0.11372510343790054,
-0.03976796567440033,
0.4655998647212982,
0.2865276038646698,
0.25407078862190247,
-0.26388609409332275,
-0.23635241389274597,
0.43532654643058777,
-0.762772798538208,
-0.08360183238983154,
0.14988595247268677,
-0.16598312556743622,
0.10019368678331375,
-0.2250838428735733,
0.5477470755577087,
0.08875387907028198,
-0.7345357537269592,
0.6990576982498169,
-0.5299320816993713,
-0.08346981555223465,
-0.8181358575820923,
0.2717992067337036,
0.1710788905620575,
0.20977912843227386,
0.7121375799179077,
0.05581304803490639,
0.1336367130279541,
-0.4022320806980133,
0.271799236536026,
0.4686242341995239,
-0.5194656848907471,
-0.013810735195875168,
0.6026260256767273,
0.7430170774459839,
-0.5546913743019104,
1.0384056568145752,
0.1105220690369606,
-0.46398377418518066,
0.7163619995117188,
0.11377766728401184,
0.6592636108398438,
-0.32628580927848816,
0.4056907296180725,
0.26787909865379333,
-0.03092038631439209,
0.5606680512428284,
0.3112248182296753,
-0.11275985091924667,
-0.8106192946434021,
-0.3007882237434387,
-0.8710595965385437,
-0.794676661491394,
0.4173409342765808,
-0.1880331039428711,
0.3729095160961151,
-0.6225194931030273,
-0.18587684631347656,
0.3117196261882782,
0.1384739875793457,
-0.8345983028411865,
0.34827035665512085,
0.3041303753852844,
0.7801447510719299,
-0.7221987247467041,
0.766947865486145,
0.8210740089416504,
-0.4854830801486969,
-0.5235947370529175,
-0.30232882499694824,
-0.18000701069831848,
-0.8470619916915894,
0.5091201066970825,
0.4944818913936615,
-0.11638739705085754,
0.014408021233975887,
-0.8927223086357117,
-0.562139093875885,
0.974872887134552,
0.0018778836820274591,
-0.49994078278541565,
-0.16590216755867004,
0.310152530670166,
0.48759913444519043,
-0.32693004608154297,
0.2366580218076706,
0.0818057730793953,
0.22075942158699036,
0.2736414968967438,
-0.7193799018859863,
-0.12781395018100739,
-0.3963874280452728,
-0.5078056454658508,
0.14580762386322021,
-0.5137655735015869,
0.6399327516555786,
-0.08664562553167343,
-0.12838459014892578,
0.3942296802997589,
1.0241496562957764,
-0.041820019483566284,
0.37847837805747986,
0.6230640411376953,
0.22958506643772125,
1.0206047296524048,
0.06064031645655632,
0.5678706765174866,
-0.2898491621017456,
0.15453261137008667,
0.8978466987609863,
0.10729005932807922,
0.8118464946746826,
0.5090339183807373,
-0.09628797322511673,
0.48552826046943665,
0.5554460883140564,
-0.2756701111793518,
-0.08669046312570572,
0.4350624084472656,
-0.4797748923301697,
-0.3642265200614929,
-0.32122859358787537,
-0.09879808127880096,
0.5283284187316895,
0.6537380814552307,
-0.1350070685148239,
-0.16424472630023956,
0.4399564862251282,
0.17975962162017822,
-0.026842575520277023,
-0.36480745673179626,
0.770577609539032,
0.03888295218348503,
-0.560688853263855,
0.2828320562839508,
0.1831972450017929,
0.7896468043327332,
-0.4065849184989929,
0.0252886563539505,
-0.24888791143894196,
0.12615881860256195,
-0.14201949536800385,
-1.0022743940353394,
0.10186947882175446,
0.06203443929553032,
-0.03671742230653763,
0.045228417962789536,
1.0077604055404663,
-0.19722594320774078,
-0.46448174118995667,
0.011578207835555077,
0.7592685222625732,
0.4104737341403961,
-0.09943399578332901,
-1.218654751777649,
-0.3546398878097534,
-0.09017322957515717,
-0.0009549356182105839,
-0.04475778713822365,
0.21389934420585632,
-0.0383235327899456,
0.9323887228965759,
0.7738125324249268,
-0.47789180278778076,
0.05832567438483238,
0.10855380445718765,
0.8450778722763062,
-0.5385615825653076,
-0.5994686484336853,
-0.7409331798553467,
0.19288161396980286,
-0.21430738270282745,
-0.48524367809295654,
0.6911976933479309,
0.4881344437599182,
0.508033275604248,
-0.20398277044296265,
0.7291865348815918,
-0.11366673558950424,
0.5664913654327393,
-0.25841203331947327,
0.8614843487739563,
-0.4374973177909851,
0.06297364830970764,
0.047510433942079544,
-0.4265686273574829,
-0.2628943920135498,
0.6077990531921387,
-0.28333792090415955,
-0.17261311411857605,
0.07746995240449905,
0.6766850352287292,
0.0411498099565506,
0.3916105031967163,
0.32699066400527954,
0.1623600572347641,
0.32277220487594604,
0.3709213435649872,
1.0675584077835083,
-0.2876374125480652,
0.8468188047409058,
-0.2228454202413559,
-0.059818219393491745,
-0.70328289270401,
-0.2505341172218323,
-1.1406402587890625,
-0.5474647283554077,
-0.4344744384288788,
-0.31155717372894287,
0.15035763382911682,
1.0163346529006958,
0.34972459077835083,
-0.9033375382423401,
-0.2659868597984314,
-0.24675104022026062,
0.26308947801589966,
0.1975710242986679,
-0.3320424556732178,
0.24237827956676483,
-0.4906758666038513,
-0.7083500623703003,
0.08850723505020142,
-0.17558623850345612,
0.3700217306613922,
-0.3258094787597656,
0.08673294633626938,
-0.45794475078582764,
0.15366066992282867,
0.42637038230895996,
0.3133440613746643,
-0.7049723863601685,
-0.19708630442619324,
0.3529944121837616,
-0.2299821972846985,
0.07574725151062012,
0.6596385836601257,
-0.9590180516242981,
0.22565917670726776,
0.4743712544441223,
0.8342020511627197,
0.2839738726615906,
0.08476435393095016,
0.5139331221580505,
-0.8378799557685852,
-0.06573979556560516,
0.45595476031303406,
0.1882392019033432,
0.33878907561302185,
-0.41141554713249207,
0.465346097946167,
0.11223462969064713,
-0.48451748490333557,
-0.4339577555656433,
0.14663536846637726,
-1.0269534587860107,
-0.7044838666915894,
1.0292110443115234,
-0.062362190335989,
-0.36737391352653503,
-0.6238145232200623,
-0.4814218580722809,
0.5554071068763733,
-0.8530644178390503,
0.7848328948020935,
0.7169253826141357,
-0.07707999646663666,
-0.02578759379684925,
-0.8071873784065247,
0.37341052293777466,
0.46292513608932495,
-0.6677442193031311,
0.16007660329341888,
0.34352341294288635,
0.16145126521587372,
0.3650006651878357,
0.5274713039398193,
0.263077050447464,
0.3803867697715759,
-0.5233749151229858,
-0.03591950982809067,
-0.0720672607421875,
-0.06019147112965584,
-0.34184136986732483,
0.36536750197410583,
-0.2576068043708801,
-0.26024022698402405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15055v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15055v1 | Deep learning-based approach for tomato classification in complex scenes | 2024-01-26T18:33:57 | 2024-01-26T18:33:57 | Mikael A. Mousse, Bethel C. A. R. K. Atohoun, Cina Motamed | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Tracking ripening tomatoes is time consuming and labor intensive. Artificial
intelligence technologies combined with those of computer vision can help users
optimize the process of monitoring the ripening status of plants. To this end,
we have proposed a tomato ripening monitoring approach based on deep learning
in complex scenes. The objective is to detect mature tomatoes and harvest them
in a timely manner. The proposed approach is declined in two parts. Firstly,
the images of the scene are transmitted to the pre-processing layer. This
process allows the detection of areas of interest (area of the image containing
tomatoes). Then, these images are used as input to the maturity detection
layer. This layer, based on a deep neural network learning algorithm,
classifies the tomato thumbnails provided to it in one of the following five
categories: green, brittle, pink, pale red, mature red. The experiments are
based on images collected from the internet gathered through searches using
tomato state across diverse languages including English, German, French, and
Spanish. The experimental results of the maturity detection layer on a dataset
composed of images of tomatoes taken under the extreme conditions, gave a good
classification rate. | [
-0.34650182723999023,
-0.6947402954101562,
0.45883506536483765,
0.06287619471549988,
-0.32632070779800415,
0.26735180616378784,
-0.1620161086320877,
-0.7161152958869934,
0.06328636407852173,
0.3837699890136719,
-0.6302520036697388,
-0.4843398332595825,
-0.5005242228507996,
-0.041308145970106125,
-0.19897833466529846,
0.8214519619941711,
0.010679149068892002,
0.3007320463657379,
0.025570973753929138,
-0.1459723263978958,
-0.42690396308898926,
-0.20801721513271332,
-0.8253988027572632,
-0.3478737771511078,
0.3908485770225525,
0.8226736783981323,
0.5045493245124817,
0.38047680258750916,
0.576700747013092,
0.41231393814086914,
-0.30649423599243164,
0.19190116226673126,
-0.027064865455031395,
0.5035926103591919,
-0.09971651434898376,
-0.4266180396080017,
-0.03594917058944702,
0.08248171955347061,
-0.020426776260137558,
0.5386825203895569,
0.1907479465007782,
0.23569124937057495,
-0.05859443172812462,
1.0676249265670776,
-0.8064134120941162,
0.2817663550376892,
-0.322086364030838,
0.8301510810852051,
-0.07558678835630417,
-0.11734285205602646,
-0.1566833108663559,
-0.1743580400943756,
-0.09424035996198654,
-0.11436010897159576,
0.2674504220485687,
-0.4104536473751068,
0.6464260816574097,
0.19199934601783752,
-0.37828871607780457,
-0.24749884009361267,
-1.0428448915481567,
0.4926244914531708,
-0.5443888902664185,
-0.13412334024906158,
0.09164054691791534,
0.7824802994728088,
-0.07226552069187164,
-0.7741414904594421,
-0.5877963900566101,
-0.36378949880599976,
0.26848581433296204,
0.28605708479881287,
0.04828207194805145,
-0.010547949001193047,
0.10999268293380737,
0.5598493218421936,
-0.24787266552448273,
0.2686488628387451,
-0.4674372673034668,
-0.030372435227036476,
0.5701861381530762,
0.25691255927085876,
0.3102584481239319,
-0.09319263696670532,
-0.7337441444396973,
-0.00715591199696064,
-0.1037624403834343,
0.3918011784553528,
0.04864351823925972,
0.22649599611759186,
0.016157181933522224,
0.5331648588180542,
-0.5097876191139221,
0.48715388774871826,
0.27962157130241394,
0.2995513081550598,
0.49476930499076843,
-0.3182404637336731,
-0.36529800295829773,
-0.17963948845863342,
0.6766303777694702,
0.6187443733215332,
0.47599563002586365,
0.10349763929843903,
-0.23989754915237427,
0.2811213731765747,
0.20345602929592133,
-0.8139943480491638,
-0.5827602744102478,
0.24627143144607544,
-0.30713480710983276,
-0.5783053636550903,
0.06748205423355103,
-0.7392592430114746,
-0.5628471374511719,
-0.12013206630945206,
0.1179414689540863,
-0.39029642939567566,
-0.0846576914191246,
-0.310326486825943,
0.0013179356465116143,
0.4143594801425934,
0.33775725960731506,
-0.49675923585891724,
0.1921752244234085,
0.38622042536735535,
0.8784509301185608,
0.005489389877766371,
0.1418950855731964,
-0.34673014283180237,
-0.17586617171764374,
-0.577023983001709,
0.5409983992576599,
-0.3948444426059723,
0.321478009223938,
-0.2864117920398712,
0.22982557117938995,
0.03787248209118843,
-0.4723702371120453,
0.6792585253715515,
-0.665738046169281,
0.009962931275367737,
0.3379068076610565,
-0.5477971434593201,
-0.5332760214805603,
0.7524262070655823,
-0.5838289260864258,
0.6115764379501343,
-0.05947623774409294,
-0.5387394428253174,
0.8888323903083801,
-0.5962686538696289,
-0.5487098693847656,
0.33291321992874146,
-0.11492960900068283,
-0.9125795960426331,
0.11247721314430237,
0.20480555295944214,
1.0022183656692505,
0.06890946626663208,
0.4293861985206604,
-0.33938848972320557,
-0.16597744822502136,
0.4663971960544586,
-0.5776693820953369,
0.5177795886993408,
0.8327240347862244,
-0.5813243389129639,
0.35848405957221985,
-0.6791810393333435,
0.22389797866344452,
0.23033569753170013,
-0.33574149012565613,
0.1377587616443634,
0.08261166512966156,
0.2654840350151062,
0.07826913148164749,
0.15843482315540314,
-0.5703140497207642,
0.19417326152324677,
-0.28621888160705566,
0.6334249973297119,
0.36224666237831116,
0.3026239573955536,
0.3797626197338104,
0.12072739005088806,
0.27640876173973083,
0.5314981937408447,
0.5131723284721375,
-0.24678878486156464,
-0.27578651905059814,
-0.8801944255828857,
-0.02737254649400711,
0.2545015215873718,
0.8145734667778015,
-0.6286683678627014,
0.6951055526733398,
0.05380271002650261,
-0.44243165850639343,
0.26738882064819336,
-0.04151907190680504,
0.24941720068454742,
0.11136352270841599,
0.07935161888599396,
-0.5883679986000061,
-0.524035632610321,
-0.7952689528465271,
0.10810551792383194,
0.3501075804233551,
0.06295444816350937,
0.36004358530044556,
0.5096132159233093,
-0.24903994798660278,
0.7538604736328125,
-0.7119119167327881,
-0.680235743522644,
-0.29392269253730774,
-0.03368706628680229,
0.5973150730133057,
0.7597891092300415,
0.6034194827079773,
-1.2670233249664307,
-0.545222282409668,
0.48444148898124695,
-0.855907142162323,
0.486051082611084,
0.03273312374949455,
0.45062965154647827,
0.041177984327077866,
0.7164447903633118,
-0.36075302958488464,
0.29811352491378784,
0.3197852075099945,
-0.46787190437316895,
0.40394142270088196,
-0.28810325264930725,
0.425205260515213,
-1.0187606811523438,
0.064052514731884,
0.2348763346672058,
-0.4303257465362549,
-0.761284589767456,
0.24970053136348724,
0.005945189855992794,
-0.48429057002067566,
-0.6956918835639954,
-0.16510650515556335,
-0.34348487854003906,
-0.046389028429985046,
-0.27392059564590454,
-0.6245754361152649,
-0.06467574089765549,
0.5164247155189514,
-0.1566804051399231,
0.5229215025901794,
0.642001211643219,
-0.5757378339767456,
0.8041651248931885,
-0.46335941553115845,
-0.6141982078552246,
0.28289884328842163,
-0.36077502369880676,
0.04612983763217926,
-0.17170460522174835,
0.09790415316820145,
-1.0266362428665161,
-0.34659698605537415,
0.8581551909446716,
-0.6544362306594849,
0.37047842144966125,
-0.42117229104042053,
-0.05629879608750343,
-0.5181173086166382,
-0.203790545463562,
0.23880501091480255,
0.3820844292640686,
-0.2646854519844055,
0.7243981957435608,
0.13596266508102417,
0.05704730749130249,
-0.3011835813522339,
-0.6940028071403503,
0.1064307764172554,
-0.38157710433006287,
-0.16706663370132446,
0.07119359821081161,
0.27495521306991577,
0.0896674171090126,
0.06948931515216827,
-0.20119598507881165,
-0.6036794185638428,
0.285323828458786,
0.4834251403808594,
-0.27537021040916443,
0.11349759250879288,
0.00035881923395209014,
-0.042946361005306244,
-0.2331661432981491,
0.09941786527633667,
-0.6848907470703125,
0.5805275440216064,
-0.09112339466810226,
0.08320410549640656,
-0.7049204111099243,
0.19331762194633484,
1.1093339920043945,
-0.24844875931739807,
0.6414933204650879,
0.8287640810012817,
-0.47182393074035645,
-0.11284077912569046,
-0.3570558428764343,
-0.06501855701208115,
-0.47607436776161194,
0.3518027067184448,
-0.3726729154586792,
-0.22314950823783875,
0.2809004783630371,
-0.6364083290100098,
-0.13073936104774475,
0.5365127325057983,
0.16438424587249756,
-0.7505569458007812,
0.7123907804489136,
0.49878743290901184,
-0.045398350805044174,
0.6510666012763977,
-0.93135666847229,
-0.17851988971233368,
-0.6679031848907471,
-0.8201900124549866,
-0.4019499719142914,
-0.6029050350189209,
-0.055805549025535583,
-0.6695254445075989,
0.11281129717826843,
0.12995819747447968,
-0.5127753615379333,
0.16217800974845886,
-0.5916704535484314,
0.664889395236969,
0.29875868558883667,
0.7298466563224792,
0.004042286425828934,
0.1508648693561554,
-0.22550134360790253,
0.07093401253223419,
-0.6995704174041748,
-0.18749606609344482,
0.6654435396194458,
0.5318608283996582,
0.482863187789917,
-0.17675405740737915,
0.2551935911178589,
0.7806761264801025,
-0.056405939161777496,
-0.813240110874176,
0.4043545126914978,
-0.5069266557693481,
-0.5306858420372009,
-0.2638528645038605,
-0.601155698299408,
-1.009708046913147,
-0.05844486504793167,
-0.49619850516319275,
-0.4200593829154968,
0.35309407114982605,
0.3474302589893341,
-0.09065548330545425,
0.5067355036735535,
-0.9086185693740845,
0.9845035672187805,
-0.9275184273719788,
-0.3326351046562195,
-0.22780732810497284,
-0.7439086437225342,
0.08544517308473587,
0.3529173731803894,
0.1839255690574646,
-0.20583441853523254,
0.24223639070987701,
0.8125252723693848,
-0.31678086519241333,
1.1571351289749146,
-0.6005074381828308,
0.43127310276031494,
0.37360048294067383,
0.1175110712647438,
0.6529162526130676,
-0.03840063512325287,
0.18204492330551147,
-0.06890591979026794,
-0.47444602847099304,
-0.5178056955337524,
-0.4009895622730255,
0.6960570812225342,
-0.7600257992744446,
-0.1290002316236496,
-0.6254709959030151,
-0.2627553343772888,
0.03743738681077957,
0.20684029161930084,
0.1812756061553955,
-0.12008776515722275,
-0.07562582194805145,
0.29749685525894165,
0.4284297227859497,
-0.007606940343976021,
0.5586722493171692,
-0.04068924859166145,
-0.2253270298242569,
-0.47399383783340454,
0.8853037357330322,
0.3608219623565674,
-0.0584309920668602,
0.2178674042224884,
0.29947325587272644,
-0.01176080945879221,
-0.9659542441368103,
-0.5706765651702881,
-0.5339316129684448,
-0.5172848105430603,
-0.3656637370586395,
-0.4633592367172241,
-0.08239644020795822,
0.006114451214671135,
-0.12663577497005463,
-0.327067494392395,
-0.0816899985074997,
-0.5110884308815002,
-0.20277030766010284,
0.4447067975997925,
0.5490447282791138,
0.4590907394886017,
0.0576598159968853,
-0.716573178768158,
0.29119864106178284,
0.4281339943408966,
0.4277711510658264,
0.09352759271860123,
-0.01153389923274517,
-0.21349506080150604,
0.0227774940431118,
-0.2907698154449463,
-0.9480670690536499,
0.5784446597099304,
0.3443305194377899,
0.22154344618320465,
0.6349447965621948,
-0.03823335841298103,
0.35380807518959045,
0.0062616122886538506,
0.5421727895736694,
0.6655949354171753,
-0.8434745669364929,
0.7424799203872681,
-0.05378929153084755,
0.36703476309776306,
0.58652663230896,
0.5395146608352661,
-0.17029926180839539,
0.014212852343916893,
-0.25326550006866455,
-1.207761526107788,
0.3542599380016327,
0.13713714480400085,
0.11780401319265366,
0.3674068748950958,
0.48540180921554565,
0.08464658260345459,
0.07652731239795685,
-0.8055965304374695,
0.08637676388025284,
0.0098350765183568,
-0.10931659489870071,
-0.15996123850345612,
-0.11917092651128769,
0.03411383181810379,
-0.5150436758995056,
0.05984456092119217,
-0.2637593746185303,
-0.28797855973243713,
0.3748304545879364,
-0.27550891041755676,
-0.155203714966774,
0.20831362903118134,
0.17820875346660614,
0.31166505813598633,
-0.10432574898004532,
0.14757461845874786,
0.38198474049568176,
-0.25505033135414124,
0.46845510601997375,
-0.3102549910545349,
-0.4585445821285248,
-0.43046730756759644,
0.3269210457801819,
0.6096889972686768,
-0.09445998072624207,
-0.4441543519496918,
0.5599857568740845,
0.16929945349693298,
-0.32705143094062805,
-0.799471378326416,
0.3468509316444397,
-0.19117218255996704,
0.7316109538078308,
0.5821915864944458,
0.9305211305618286,
0.4393165707588196,
-0.7450394034385681,
0.4196602702140808,
0.24061349034309387,
-0.7981167435646057,
-0.009125960990786552,
0.27922970056533813,
0.5015172362327576,
-0.16541078686714172,
0.9138058423995972,
-0.20221029222011566,
-0.817754864692688,
1.2901151180267334,
0.203526109457016,
0.8278401494026184,
0.053614530712366104,
0.27019578218460083,
0.24175097048282623,
0.006067602429538965,
0.32098886370658875,
0.30466198921203613,
-0.3526536822319031,
-0.7470235824584961,
-0.5012861490249634,
-0.5762910842895508,
-0.032121896743774414,
0.08220469206571579,
-0.3247409164905548,
-0.21245978772640228,
-0.8652786612510681,
-0.26386895775794983,
0.039469458162784576,
0.10750051587820053,
-0.7648584246635437,
0.8444467186927795,
0.4643135666847229,
0.8915416598320007,
-1.3413817882537842,
0.7780532240867615,
0.9295328855514526,
-0.1901601403951645,
-0.46740075945854187,
-0.10698698461055756,
-0.37553587555885315,
-0.46375343203544617,
0.8091245889663696,
0.5925411581993103,
-0.1509183943271637,
-0.24244332313537598,
-0.5519039630889893,
-0.3825681805610657,
1.0134762525558472,
-0.04226858541369438,
-0.8119038939476013,
0.24271546304225922,
-0.3033645749092102,
0.7194455862045288,
-0.347860187292099,
0.02800457365810871,
0.21783310174942017,
0.6247533559799194,
0.5830909013748169,
-0.2156009078025818,
-0.3381025195121765,
-0.4712042510509491,
-0.02533334121108055,
0.33186662197113037,
-0.6080124378204346,
0.7395594120025635,
-0.3743019104003906,
-0.38198864459991455,
0.018812064081430435,
0.7292068004608154,
-0.4750686585903168,
0.673779308795929,
0.7637147307395935,
0.8161638975143433,
0.48850783705711365,
-0.3133620023727417,
0.6666771769523621,
0.007836072705686092,
0.5421575903892517,
0.6575453877449036,
-0.10878930240869522,
0.5677343606948853,
0.38522061705589294,
-0.09535370767116547,
0.21004177629947662,
0.8607347011566162,
-0.524130642414093,
0.6157930493354797,
0.32784441113471985,
-0.15089771151542664,
-0.23996350169181824,
-0.11549139022827148,
-0.20842616260051727,
0.40697187185287476,
0.5369448065757751,
-0.7216644287109375,
0.015628889203071594,
0.6513554453849792,
-0.14019979536533356,
0.23005801439285278,
-0.7429912686347961,
0.9965391159057617,
-0.08162195980548859,
-0.5965276956558228,
0.10287219285964966,
-0.09106209129095078,
0.585978090763092,
-0.08802224695682526,
-0.14444130659103394,
-0.1492796093225479,
0.6326850056648254,
-0.6004091501235962,
-1.1666922569274902,
0.30962714552879333,
-0.037540603429079056,
-0.37777626514434814,
0.05158693715929985,
0.693716824054718,
-0.11086536943912506,
-0.7783753275871277,
0.4327731132507324,
0.23091132938861847,
0.1331331729888916,
-0.07756683975458145,
-0.7800782918930054,
0.11047236621379852,
-0.10824741423130035,
-0.18950650095939636,
-0.006110864691436291,
0.3248938322067261,
-0.12726332247257233,
0.839454174041748,
0.7204390168190002,
-0.10295475274324417,
0.04389624670147896,
-0.04088015481829643,
1.0052201747894287,
-0.801449179649353,
-0.4231927990913391,
-0.7256761193275452,
0.36542201042175293,
-0.2024771124124527,
-0.17342862486839294,
0.3394700288772583,
0.6097787618637085,
0.7660463452339172,
-0.4712841808795929,
0.43299975991249084,
-0.28108108043670654,
-0.16601154208183289,
-0.725278913974762,
0.5651679635047913,
-0.33442384004592896,
0.16205911338329315,
-0.09920486062765121,
-0.9875142574310303,
-0.5400044322013855,
0.613830029964447,
-0.38847023248672485,
0.23190173506736755,
0.3554541766643524,
0.31531140208244324,
-0.21103744208812714,
-0.4448384642601013,
0.22783900797367096,
0.2952285408973694,
0.06851507723331451,
0.7171310782432556,
0.8398451805114746,
-0.2811514437198639,
0.3811716139316559,
-0.4915390610694885,
-0.3711331784725189,
-0.3510214388370514,
-0.7678681015968323,
-0.45856767892837524,
-0.3551117777824402,
-0.284032940864563,
0.10909635573625565,
0.277325302362442,
0.6518689393997192,
1.1319559812545776,
-0.9698166847229004,
-0.08838371932506561,
-0.5274136662483215,
-0.1399509459733963,
-0.625769853591919,
-0.2777944803237915,
0.20236290991306305,
-0.3830643594264984,
-0.47118082642555237,
0.31405049562454224,
0.430603951215744,
0.014938597567379475,
-0.16579894721508026,
0.12806683778762817,
-0.21353194117546082,
-0.6172336935997009,
0.5597717761993408,
0.3323000967502594,
-0.30772319436073303,
-0.11172190308570862,
-0.28673186898231506,
0.035615187138319016,
0.22862696647644043,
0.7061418294906616,
-0.9503620266914368,
0.47004568576812744,
0.6588571667671204,
0.4068078100681305,
0.9771084189414978,
-0.0007777902646921575,
0.31734389066696167,
-0.7404963374137878,
0.16086368262767792,
0.64617520570755,
0.3229432702064514,
0.2644438147544861,
-0.5959329009056091,
0.4521540403366089,
0.050375062972307205,
-0.4913240969181061,
-0.09499356895685196,
0.40191325545310974,
-1.149944543838501,
-0.7889856100082397,
0.3235071003437042,
-0.5139898657798767,
-0.5161659121513367,
-0.09183749556541443,
-0.2063150852918625,
0.2678776681423187,
-0.2285623997449875,
0.6972461938858032,
0.044560208916664124,
-0.08297933638095856,
-0.5936687588691711,
0.002021732274442911,
0.03863918036222458,
0.2769545912742615,
-0.6898803114891052,
-0.19293087720870972,
0.29563629627227783,
0.2952716648578644,
0.4930186867713928,
-0.09460213780403137,
-0.026236215606331825,
0.23873688280582428,
-0.14955177903175354,
0.0237069521099329,
-0.3308841288089752,
-0.8654083609580994,
-0.256047785282135,
0.8889914155006409,
0.2323058545589447,
-0.7801595330238342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15050v1 | LongFin: A Multimodal Document Understanding Model for Long Financial Domain Documents | 2024-01-26T18:23:45 | 2024-01-26T18:23:45 | Ahmed Masry, Amir Hajian | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document AI is a growing research field that focuses on the comprehension and
extraction of information from scanned and digital documents to make everyday
business operations more efficient. Numerous downstream tasks and datasets have
been introduced to facilitate the training of AI models capable of parsing and
extracting information from various document types such as receipts and scanned
forms. Despite these advancements, both existing datasets and models fail to
address critical challenges that arise in industrial contexts. Existing
datasets primarily comprise short documents consisting of a single page, while
existing models are constrained by a limited maximum length, often set at 512
tokens. Consequently, the practical application of these methods in financial
services, where documents can span multiple pages, is severely impeded. To
overcome these challenges, we introduce LongFin, a multimodal document AI model
capable of encoding up to 4K tokens. We also propose the LongForms dataset, a
comprehensive financial dataset that encapsulates several industrial challenges
in financial documents. Through an extensive evaluation, we demonstrate the
effectiveness of the LongFin model on the LongForms dataset, surpassing the
performance of existing public models while maintaining comparable results on
existing single-page benchmarks. | [
-0.24682801961898804,
-0.648475170135498,
0.615502655506134,
0.34217363595962524,
-0.3458280861377716,
0.0414624847471714,
-0.15717405080795288,
-0.8869593143463135,
-0.08788405358791351,
0.7035309076309204,
-0.5451515316963196,
-0.5153999328613281,
-0.6571890115737915,
0.14901918172836304,
-0.3946245312690735,
0.9678996801376343,
-0.170533686876297,
-0.24544303119182587,
-0.5044368505477905,
-0.10370559990406036,
-0.016409410163760185,
-0.546437680721283,
-0.9718291759490967,
-0.322013258934021,
0.5294352769851685,
0.30731284618377686,
0.6346008777618408,
0.6175034046173096,
0.7865527272224426,
0.3899712562561035,
0.29868897795677185,
0.24088731408119202,
-0.39820975065231323,
-0.12479151785373688,
-0.01978370174765587,
-0.3598884046077728,
-0.7271495461463928,
0.1336662769317627,
0.7283768653869629,
0.5963419675827026,
0.0058728428557515144,
0.029198160395026207,
-0.1488160640001297,
0.8922314047813416,
-0.4652726650238037,
0.7031543254852295,
-0.08374340832233429,
-0.038979921489953995,
-0.5472277402877808,
0.012722892686724663,
-0.42319294810295105,
0.06732932478189468,
0.07368999719619751,
-1.0034183263778687,
0.3000892698764801,
0.16285620629787445,
0.6447791457176208,
0.05189317837357521,
-0.9594530463218689,
-0.7695946097373962,
-0.6377975940704346,
0.581742525100708,
-0.5197577476501465,
0.6954371333122253,
0.656012237071991,
0.6074092984199524,
-0.027988554909825325,
-1.1111736297607422,
-0.7185736298561096,
0.12095600366592407,
-0.04725198820233345,
0.13892513513565063,
-0.3839420676231384,
0.3668507933616638,
0.1510472297668457,
0.3130127191543579,
-0.478452205657959,
0.33735963702201843,
-0.8076674938201904,
-0.0741497278213501,
0.5859825015068054,
0.06708568334579468,
-0.14521943032741547,
-0.17454539239406586,
-0.7971662878990173,
-0.45085686445236206,
-0.05918306112289429,
0.29787471890449524,
0.4821995496749878,
0.3335949182510376,
-0.22517943382263184,
0.31788527965545654,
0.004777871072292328,
0.7612181305885315,
-0.18424279987812042,
-0.5683764219284058,
0.1914827823638916,
-0.3223819434642792,
-0.5352414846420288,
-0.024289382621645927,
0.4419530928134918,
0.26664841175079346,
-0.05196816474199295,
0.06107565760612488,
-0.5420132875442505,
-0.17943958938121796,
0.13081838190555573,
-0.4508507251739502,
0.35213702917099,
0.3520517349243164,
-0.6048659086227417,
-0.09483690559864044,
0.1306818425655365,
-1.0908793210983276,
-0.5055956244468689,
-0.513357937335968,
0.16293811798095703,
-0.3600078523159027,
0.02136595919728279,
0.5371114015579224,
-0.5878618359565735,
0.23564952611923218,
0.3654446303844452,
-0.8502745628356934,
0.32272061705589294,
1.2779170274734497,
0.7240732908248901,
0.042474567890167236,
-0.38845717906951904,
-0.622076690196991,
0.4516013562679291,
-0.0913080945611,
0.8091189861297607,
-0.6338289380073547,
-0.5901249647140503,
-0.044106267392635345,
-0.09881791472434998,
-0.3020889163017273,
-0.3340515196323395,
0.8087570071220398,
-0.5107511878013611,
0.11752475798130035,
0.22135242819786072,
-0.5911654233932495,
-0.34138500690460205,
0.447679340839386,
-1.0990430116653442,
0.6757579445838928,
0.4249477982521057,
-0.6568346619606018,
0.3922419548034668,
-1.194905161857605,
-0.370314359664917,
0.008329462260007858,
-0.17225666344165802,
-0.5139638781547546,
-0.05214688554406166,
0.19496142864227295,
0.6073669791221619,
-0.6568977236747742,
0.2162124365568161,
-0.5801292061805725,
-0.20140430331230164,
0.16603747010231018,
-0.7229064106941223,
0.4018586277961731,
0.16966313123703003,
-0.04257957637310028,
0.21697774529457092,
-1.0317978858947754,
-0.5190677046775818,
0.22091169655323029,
-0.35331791639328003,
-0.5284917950630188,
-0.3297185003757477,
0.46908605098724365,
0.2261519730091095,
0.33538341522216797,
-0.5664103031158447,
0.22223122417926788,
-0.07801613211631775,
0.6756622195243835,
0.97092604637146,
-0.2552347779273987,
0.2224014699459076,
-0.5335991382598877,
0.5782438516616821,
0.1432105004787445,
0.4075034260749817,
-0.39206182956695557,
0.028097739443182945,
-0.5927631855010986,
-0.7457212805747986,
0.16552290320396423,
0.15326908230781555,
-0.4234091341495514,
-0.06189262121915817,
-0.6240996718406677,
-0.32977771759033203,
-0.3667621314525604,
0.34462156891822815,
0.11540360748767853,
0.6253260374069214,
0.08606050163507462,
-0.24423916637897491,
-0.24772459268569946,
-1.217793345451355,
0.1787179857492447,
0.03237822279334068,
0.061666831374168396,
0.32962483167648315,
0.5684098601341248,
-0.4878748655319214,
0.9294006824493408,
-0.4779306650161743,
-0.4414285719394684,
-0.057687729597091675,
0.5600241422653198,
0.44709762930870056,
0.37945061922073364,
0.5490244626998901,
-1.3187384605407715,
-0.14866575598716736,
-0.05629697069525719,
-0.6970854997634888,
0.7402167916297913,
-0.6971288919448853,
-0.17352522909641266,
0.23565979301929474,
0.49145829677581787,
-0.6981896162033081,
0.5613147020339966,
0.442698210477829,
-0.5535571575164795,
0.2273540049791336,
-0.5547603368759155,
-0.06245776265859604,
-1.0345585346221924,
0.30660000443458557,
0.4134020507335663,
-0.44145724177360535,
-0.502739429473877,
0.09180648624897003,
0.47272059321403503,
-0.6702004671096802,
-0.3089517652988434,
0.7196614146232605,
-0.41678881645202637,
-0.4198293685913086,
-0.12581326067447662,
-0.007730040233582258,
0.582873523235321,
0.5758519768714905,
-0.02362857572734356,
0.960347592830658,
0.2905108332633972,
-0.354043185710907,
0.6142937541007996,
0.3132805824279785,
-0.40903428196907043,
0.7667181491851807,
-0.5375707149505615,
0.17292062938213348,
-0.4854983389377594,
0.5579414963722229,
-0.902256429195404,
-0.22247622907161713,
0.04611062631011009,
0.12908747792243958,
0.45119789242744446,
-0.05669865757226944,
-0.5299710631370544,
-0.617486298084259,
-0.3541334569454193,
0.4587680399417877,
-0.08262591809034348,
-0.6785680651664734,
1.0914349555969238,
-0.04268274083733559,
-0.4152243137359619,
-0.49606165289878845,
-0.3660650849342346,
0.23342165350914001,
-0.28721505403518677,
-1.1331502199172974,
0.30708232522010803,
-0.10996595770120621,
-0.27019527554512024,
-0.35917899012565613,
-0.21537090837955475,
-0.12365614622831345,
0.19555634260177612,
0.37338343262672424,
0.4645722508430481,
-0.33674001693725586,
0.3593823313713074,
-0.08176176995038986,
-0.43597397208213806,
0.0424872450530529,
-0.3735501766204834,
0.29309844970703125,
-0.19390630722045898,
-0.5460248589515686,
-0.4437291622161865,
0.6962504982948303,
1.3331753015518188,
-0.6278886198997498,
0.7369650602340698,
0.40548333525657654,
-0.49553123116493225,
-0.004798576235771179,
-0.4791810214519501,
0.4847874641418457,
-0.545070230960846,
0.2331274151802063,
-0.5693188905715942,
-0.5279074907302856,
0.618619978427887,
-0.2880646586418152,
0.291568785905838,
0.88726407289505,
-0.061888646334409714,
-0.1426834613084793,
0.6258859634399414,
1.033798098564148,
-0.1778034269809723,
0.29114389419555664,
-0.3549741804599762,
0.17707125842571259,
-0.4419502019882202,
-0.5598070025444031,
-0.6310917735099792,
-0.14164836704730988,
-0.07928704470396042,
-0.4914238154888153,
0.4961782693862915,
-0.014925951138138771,
-0.19524753093719482,
-0.07717911154031754,
0.0712406262755394,
0.3697068691253662,
0.5179939866065979,
0.11081214994192123,
0.15321902930736542,
-0.11270713061094284,
0.07354501634836197,
0.48786282539367676,
-0.37334951758384705,
-0.3494437038898468,
1.0239899158477783,
0.7892801761627197,
0.8011431694030762,
0.14650386571884155,
0.5805018544197083,
0.6551759243011475,
-0.06618628650903702,
-0.7212405204772949,
0.027060799300670624,
-0.3582603335380554,
-0.5375984907150269,
-0.6193418502807617,
-0.32468125224113464,
-0.895448625087738,
-0.21974238753318787,
0.0031301770359277725,
-0.17116981744766235,
0.5556872487068176,
-0.3579134941101074,
-0.6427320241928101,
0.12375985085964203,
-0.614470899105072,
1.1190108060836792,
-0.7009177803993225,
-0.21527878940105438,
-0.24087873101234436,
-0.3555847108364105,
0.2598303556442261,
-0.6870575547218323,
0.5979317426681519,
-0.06655735522508621,
-0.03872893378138542,
0.9502947330474854,
-0.47382986545562744,
0.9145496487617493,
-0.01688382215797901,
-0.4478064179420471,
-0.01169329509139061,
-0.37549135088920593,
0.7367212772369385,
0.12371720373630524,
-0.5170777440071106,
0.04804704710841179,
0.11186942458152771,
-0.7476954460144043,
-0.7784480452537537,
0.30129700899124146,
-0.5797687768936157,
-0.373130202293396,
-0.5715312957763672,
-0.5088491439819336,
-0.09759102016687393,
0.4570370614528656,
-0.18733566999435425,
0.6178911328315735,
-0.04686741903424263,
0.2308812141418457,
0.281466007232666,
0.06498926877975464,
0.6784490346908569,
0.28364235162734985,
0.06604360044002533,
-0.33445125818252563,
0.6890043020248413,
-0.20902663469314575,
-0.06519719958305359,
0.1712242066860199,
-0.0012368230381980538,
-0.652391791343689,
-0.4138418436050415,
-0.38515356183052063,
0.25906386971473694,
-1.1159321069717407,
-0.22854489088058472,
-0.29462477564811707,
-0.057965509593486786,
-0.6188090443611145,
-0.3762986958026886,
-0.266398161649704,
-0.2858037054538727,
-0.5102686285972595,
-0.21700771152973175,
0.34134089946746826,
0.8802618384361267,
-0.04668488726019859,
0.13921025395393372,
-1.207997441291809,
0.6474496722221375,
0.5926578044891357,
0.8632398247718811,
0.1650983691215515,
-0.13490715622901917,
-0.39104777574539185,
0.10896327346563339,
0.11889506131410599,
-0.4859498143196106,
0.2210969626903534,
0.3207233250141144,
0.6689505577087402,
1.0644885301589966,
0.10089947283267975,
0.7956503629684448,
-0.02906462922692299,
0.3783741593360901,
0.3499966263771057,
-0.8734486103057861,
0.1548081934452057,
-0.5358381271362305,
0.12916935980319977,
0.7407131195068359,
0.6571279168128967,
-0.8104105591773987,
0.24861915409564972,
-0.3713639974594116,
-0.9727627038955688,
0.607196033000946,
-0.025148971006274223,
0.02673676423728466,
0.03434503450989723,
0.3553476333618164,
0.6853151321411133,
0.14566420018672943,
-0.44481346011161804,
0.09937439858913422,
-0.3021296560764313,
-0.3263840675354004,
-0.45758911967277527,
-0.37631210684776306,
-0.17050719261169434,
0.02035224810242653,
0.5471348762512207,
-0.18074920773506165,
0.17986761033535004,
0.02603995054960251,
-0.0805031955242157,
0.23299898207187653,
0.14845187962055206,
0.9993590116500854,
1.117242693901062,
-0.4167749583721161,
-0.08691883832216263,
-0.41779613494873047,
-0.3349847197532654,
-0.14494623243808746,
0.6559617519378662,
0.4492628872394562,
-0.09499955922365189,
0.5132877230644226,
1.0181303024291992,
0.2484132945537567,
-0.6894259452819824,
0.45780447125434875,
-0.2711198031902313,
-0.3846356272697449,
-0.826053261756897,
-0.3165828287601471,
-0.088772714138031,
0.5032846331596375,
0.6480859518051147,
-0.06576897948980331,
0.05071428045630455,
-0.7198154926300049,
0.3454626500606537,
0.033978771418333054,
-0.16355597972869873,
0.17481574416160583,
0.5651840567588806,
0.5313031077384949,
-0.271396279335022,
1.2384874820709229,
0.24430401623249054,
-0.3874991834163666,
0.9190781712532043,
0.5217769145965576,
0.5947127342224121,
0.5443342924118042,
0.009261461906135082,
-0.16567766666412354,
-0.06594090163707733,
-0.19619782269001007,
0.05920156091451645,
-0.2824578583240509,
-0.29151788353919983,
-0.06835965812206268,
-0.796565592288971,
-0.45487478375434875,
0.10696292668581009,
-0.7560518383979797,
0.15331004559993744,
-0.6003713011741638,
-0.2306254655122757,
0.5013161897659302,
-0.00317377015016973,
-0.8594092130661011,
0.15999704599380493,
0.39410826563835144,
1.291153073310852,
-0.5569090247154236,
0.7220956683158875,
0.1383117437362671,
-0.5850037336349487,
-0.17051592469215393,
-0.4457085430622101,
-0.0014291637344285846,
-0.8020686507225037,
0.6698592901229858,
0.35214415192604065,
-0.004921740852296352,
-0.32297763228416443,
-0.190292090177536,
-0.7372936010360718,
1.0705515146255493,
0.13864295184612274,
-0.7797237038612366,
-0.5120853781700134,
0.5312265157699585,
0.15225358307361603,
-0.278155118227005,
-0.04544578120112419,
0.47588881850242615,
0.9501398205757141,
0.05660666525363922,
-0.7462174892425537,
-0.3217252492904663,
-0.5322678685188293,
-0.3098134398460388,
0.3247242867946625,
-0.7809423804283142,
0.9060993194580078,
0.21654629707336426,
0.030010145157575607,
-0.17936185002326965,
0.7802656888961792,
0.008000338450074196,
0.9220466613769531,
0.5637395977973938,
0.4318816661834717,
1.2094414234161377,
0.29890021681785583,
1.198127031326294,
-0.26349589228630066,
0.2016407549381256,
0.9660308957099915,
-0.415208101272583,
0.71897953748703,
0.37712225317955017,
0.04704245179891586,
0.2733137309551239,
0.7136933207511902,
-0.2485690861940384,
0.07158324122428894,
0.03196819871664047,
-0.395447701215744,
-0.37809547781944275,
0.1322447806596756,
-0.2758440673351288,
0.8392845988273621,
0.4044041931629181,
-0.3812352418899536,
-0.27513477206230164,
0.3627210259437561,
-0.13838769495487213,
-0.03316853567957878,
-0.42451030015945435,
0.5454590916633606,
0.15826788544654846,
-0.36660078167915344,
0.2877331078052521,
0.5044914484024048,
0.7443077564239502,
-0.9042379260063171,
-0.05940163508057594,
-0.3687961995601654,
0.1745115965604782,
0.10816226154565811,
-0.5881547927856445,
0.1268237680196762,
0.031953662633895874,
-0.4489130973815918,
-0.5397698879241943,
0.6386558413505554,
-0.09993962943553925,
-0.9471046328544617,
0.2533518970012665,
-0.014609047211706638,
0.048255763947963715,
-0.17711251974105835,
-0.5548259615898132,
-0.12107851356267929,
-0.28588050603866577,
0.001008706516586244,
0.35986530780792236,
0.5035742521286011,
-0.1965589076280594,
0.7062776684761047,
0.9221094846725464,
-0.4121396541595459,
-0.14310917258262634,
-0.06840085238218307,
0.7802903056144714,
-0.8552868366241455,
-0.8541402816772461,
-0.6531330943107605,
0.3885083496570587,
-0.20528799295425415,
-0.37013986706733704,
0.29203933477401733,
1.0173734426498413,
0.67718106508255,
0.05023960769176483,
0.7195113301277161,
0.6900600790977478,
0.21334940195083618,
-0.6914121508598328,
0.8774470090866089,
-0.7078558206558228,
-0.13118988275527954,
0.04291499778628349,
-0.5801041126251221,
-0.1790270209312439,
0.2970182001590729,
-0.154091477394104,
-0.15245305001735687,
0.43003788590431213,
0.25341519713401794,
-0.496931791305542,
0.21011458337306976,
0.24084238708019257,
-0.19151970744132996,
0.4346638321876526,
0.6270002722740173,
0.2666774392127991,
-0.22146044671535492,
0.5755444765090942,
-0.1925445944070816,
0.0676300898194313,
-0.251224547624588,
-0.9635187983512878,
-0.7578223347663879,
-0.8295404314994812,
0.03640180453658104,
-0.0016317750560119748,
-0.005865884944796562,
0.8157020211219788,
0.6041106581687927,
-0.23888017237186432,
-0.3479960262775421,
0.47344493865966797,
-0.018753528594970703,
-0.034785665571689606,
-0.06748268753290176,
0.603338360786438,
-0.1121356263756752,
-0.6373616456985474,
0.5943278670310974,
0.4821533262729645,
0.5413808822631836,
-0.14421901106834412,
-0.13224895298480988,
-0.03160277009010315,
0.3329446315765381,
0.5964314341545105,
0.4613483250141144,
-0.19640439748764038,
-0.12627382576465607,
-0.09923742711544037,
-0.19867272675037384,
0.252202570438385,
0.8647769093513489,
-0.26290345191955566,
0.4389094412326813,
0.32841137051582336,
0.7598037123680115,
0.9419540762901306,
0.05482262372970581,
0.6407421827316284,
-0.3284212350845337,
0.43397724628448486,
0.07454173266887665,
0.5166954398155212,
0.09237829595804214,
-0.6749729514122009,
0.405626118183136,
0.07109644263982773,
-0.09278082847595215,
-0.5106433033943176,
-0.09043759852647781,
-1.2335190773010254,
-0.6112641096115112,
0.6602821946144104,
-0.22738976776599884,
-0.642166256904602,
-0.14253617823123932,
0.08349470794200897,
0.2921447455883026,
-0.5266554951667786,
0.673464834690094,
0.7514185309410095,
0.008518707938492298,
-0.011860346421599388,
-0.4380638897418976,
0.11136176437139511,
0.018399210646748543,
-0.8483338356018066,
0.22707101702690125,
0.6580543518066406,
-0.05961790308356285,
0.1137603148818016,
0.7225982546806335,
0.030076084658503532,
0.44292524456977844,
0.18416307866573334,
-0.1264442801475525,
-0.7980983853340149,
-0.5706450343132019,
-0.4593336284160614,
0.49969181418418884,
-0.06029399111866951,
-0.0930682122707367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15043v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15043v2 | Health Text Simplification: An Annotated Corpus for Digestive Cancer Education and Novel Strategies for Reinforcement Learning | 2024-01-26T18:13:57 | 2024-03-29T19:01:27 | Md Mushfiqur Rahman, Mohammad Sabik Irbaz, Kai North, Michelle S. Williams, Marcos Zampieri, Kevin Lybarger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Objective: The reading level of health educational materials significantly
influences the understandability and accessibility of the information,
particularly for minoritized populations. Many patient educational resources
surpass the reading level and complexity of widely accepted standards. There is
a critical need for high-performing text simplification models in health
information to enhance dissemination and literacy. This need is particularly
acute in cancer education, where effective prevention and screening education
can substantially reduce morbidity and mortality.
Methods: We introduce Simplified Digestive Cancer (SimpleDC), a parallel
corpus of cancer education materials tailored for health text simplification
research, comprising educational content from the American Cancer Society,
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and National Cancer Institute.
Utilizing SimpleDC alongside the existing Med-EASi corpus, we explore Large
Language Model (LLM)-based simplification methods, including fine-tuning,
reinforcement learning (RL), reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF),
domain adaptation, and prompt-based approaches. Our experimentation encompasses
Llama 2 and GPT-4. A novel RLHF reward function is introduced, featuring a
lightweight model adept at distinguishing between original and simplified
texts, thereby enhancing the model's effectiveness with unlabeled data.
Results: Fine-tuned Llama 2 models demonstrated high performance across
various metrics. Our innovative RLHF reward function surpassed existing RL text
simplification reward functions in effectiveness. The results underscore that
RL/RLHF can augment fine-tuning, facilitating model training on unlabeled text
and improving performance. | [
0.055482909083366394,
-0.6814054846763611,
0.645998477935791,
-0.11906171590089798,
-0.517306923866272,
0.03188741207122803,
-0.2589700520038605,
-0.3135863244533539,
0.2781384587287903,
0.42554405331611633,
-0.6910550594329834,
-0.8103301525115967,
-0.8091974258422852,
0.32083261013031006,
-0.03576473146677017,
1.4019811153411865,
-0.0475231297314167,
0.21579529345035553,
-0.22034858167171478,
0.0008539754780940711,
-0.12371435016393661,
-0.2274336963891983,
-0.7770922183990479,
-0.617615282535553,
0.936936616897583,
0.8122196197509766,
0.5206825733184814,
0.9031104445457458,
0.563101053237915,
0.2524067461490631,
-0.3020695745944977,
0.17542247474193573,
-0.7808281779289246,
0.04409220814704895,
-0.28756779432296753,
-0.5078822374343872,
-0.21790553629398346,
-0.222508504986763,
0.2312951683998108,
0.9683952331542969,
-0.28759050369262695,
-0.059061892330646515,
0.21968406438827515,
0.8970819115638733,
-0.6299585103988647,
0.44812771677970886,
-0.14118711650371552,
0.0693369135260582,
-0.041169457137584686,
-0.168193519115448,
-0.3017873764038086,
-0.6257888674736023,
-0.12869468331336975,
-0.9000809788703918,
-0.3438895642757416,
-0.15473943948745728,
0.42705121636390686,
0.4294959604740143,
-0.8116727471351624,
-0.7047657370567322,
-0.500582754611969,
0.6665035486221313,
-0.39435043931007385,
0.1656152904033661,
0.2788960039615631,
0.20996278524398804,
-0.22173215448856354,
-0.993028998374939,
-0.28381282091140747,
0.005523335188627243,
-0.15924158692359924,
0.24536247551441193,
0.004703241400420666,
0.6155709624290466,
0.289393812417984,
0.30110177397727966,
-0.3844079375267029,
0.05670147389173508,
-0.6523118019104004,
-0.17519555985927582,
0.6087346076965332,
0.34933745861053467,
0.2624870240688324,
-0.32366013526916504,
-0.3910468816757202,
-0.3291521966457367,
-0.6721609234809875,
0.3740653097629547,
0.002879178384318948,
0.1357235163450241,
0.07925967127084732,
0.4718708097934723,
-0.49032214283943176,
0.23998203873634338,
-0.1753847599029541,
-0.5468682050704956,
0.18446499109268188,
-0.44346505403518677,
-0.2491028606891632,
0.20933698117733002,
0.5666788220405579,
0.22549355030059814,
0.04871319606900215,
0.049617085605859756,
-0.08814584463834763,
0.12989354133605957,
0.07499995082616806,
-1.01948881149292,
-0.37242329120635986,
0.21682079136371613,
-0.7703266143798828,
-0.4290767014026642,
-0.19968055188655853,
-0.7624247074127197,
-0.5057324171066284,
-0.14118053019046783,
0.4513898193836212,
-0.3655793368816376,
0.19365863502025604,
0.5038619041442871,
-0.042378298938274384,
-0.25012829899787903,
0.5000775456428528,
-0.8477331399917603,
0.5374161601066589,
0.7476291060447693,
0.5129896402359009,
-0.17595691978931427,
-0.11612039804458618,
-0.5098445415496826,
0.3057250678539276,
0.004685296211391687,
0.7148495316505432,
-0.6947827935218811,
-0.5791487693786621,
-0.002690095454454422,
0.08637057989835739,
-0.1279110610485077,
-0.5183951258659363,
1.027396559715271,
-0.0966474786400795,
0.03520943596959114,
-0.3578270375728607,
-0.690930962562561,
-0.4413297474384308,
0.12183227390050888,
-0.7831503748893738,
0.6852102279663086,
-0.048918891698122025,
-0.6528453230857849,
0.1149066612124443,
-0.5147466063499451,
-0.6375707983970642,
-0.012788794934749603,
-0.1259084790945053,
-0.5584629774093628,
-0.15623652935028076,
0.2317579835653305,
0.25738614797592163,
-0.18366985023021698,
0.12326379865407944,
-0.031804196536540985,
-0.3540841042995453,
-0.19500084221363068,
-0.2343345433473587,
0.2948412597179413,
0.4848228991031647,
-0.2945438027381897,
0.4933431148529053,
-0.5572299361228943,
-0.057307202368974686,
0.15712200105190277,
-0.6576391458511353,
-0.3895060122013092,
-0.052706122398376465,
-0.09627164900302887,
0.0839727595448494,
0.23294100165367126,
-0.3517568111419678,
0.4231562614440918,
-0.30328190326690674,
0.13215628266334534,
0.22806784510612488,
0.2980911433696747,
0.3816436529159546,
-0.5773606300354004,
0.6862988471984863,
0.06745867431163788,
0.2991645038127899,
-0.5094622373580933,
-0.567427396774292,
-0.4999411702156067,
-0.30335748195648193,
0.46342068910598755,
0.6299784779548645,
-0.8935363292694092,
0.02451382204890251,
-0.2468474954366684,
-0.4870922565460205,
-0.5530673265457153,
0.3157942295074463,
0.5917360782623291,
0.5979539752006531,
0.5191865563392639,
-0.2065410166978836,
-0.4836439788341522,
-0.5683990120887756,
-0.24985817074775696,
0.001441247179172933,
-0.012000520713627338,
0.3263532519340515,
0.32502099871635437,
-0.23217377066612244,
0.34370970726013184,
-0.5612300038337708,
-0.3758978545665741,
-0.609290599822998,
0.14966772496700287,
0.02363143302500248,
0.25461503863334656,
0.10031481087207794,
-0.659911036491394,
-0.2966880798339844,
-0.05141276866197586,
-0.480108380317688,
-0.2576617896556854,
-0.09728879481554031,
0.1333472579717636,
-0.2630491554737091,
0.567288875579834,
-0.2357388585805893,
0.6464675664901733,
0.37006860971450806,
-0.22552023828029633,
0.25740811228752136,
-0.39580270648002625,
0.2599731683731079,
-0.771653413772583,
-0.00975431315600872,
-0.13344219326972961,
-0.48691603541374207,
-0.5876606702804565,
-0.030031422153115273,
0.284146785736084,
-0.07663649320602417,
-0.5103068351745605,
0.5739678144454956,
-0.299822062253952,
0.3410074710845947,
-0.4672558605670929,
-0.000707002473063767,
-0.018977724015712738,
0.4831393361091614,
0.12731003761291504,
0.5365023016929626,
-0.04978503659367561,
-0.7389485836029053,
0.01416975911706686,
0.23228393495082855,
-0.22255240380764008,
0.2652572989463806,
-0.7080888152122498,
-0.35661110281944275,
-0.2596000134944916,
0.535704493522644,
-0.8324649930000305,
-0.3511558473110199,
0.35634106397628784,
-0.09892529994249344,
0.003695353399962187,
0.07891672849655151,
-0.2507287859916687,
-0.2236509770154953,
-0.34997251629829407,
0.5161651968955994,
0.47478941082954407,
-0.6212896704673767,
0.28374192118644714,
0.3575698137283325,
-0.4367932081222534,
-0.43712297081947327,
-0.5021548867225647,
-0.29113003611564636,
-0.07998152822256088,
-0.41725531220436096,
0.2608916163444519,
-0.14455822110176086,
-0.04281294718384743,
-0.12289451062679291,
-0.0016310730716213584,
0.17787887156009674,
0.17879408597946167,
0.3058848977088928,
-0.15603969991207123,
0.13345873355865479,
0.4301893711090088,
0.5858826637268066,
-0.05475655943155289,
-0.07119213789701462,
0.16589953005313873,
0.3033231496810913,
0.08983694761991501,
-0.2845887839794159,
-0.4803556501865387,
0.4994864761829376,
0.18597498536109924,
0.06290135532617569,
0.5500507354736328,
0.3729122281074524,
-0.3712339699268341,
-0.1859627068042755,
-0.03356253728270531,
-0.5990579724311829,
-0.42295706272125244,
0.2903995215892792,
-0.17325536906719208,
-0.9936047792434692,
0.3558015525341034,
-0.6120675206184387,
-0.10876216739416122,
0.2843960225582123,
0.5793668031692505,
-0.009710089303553104,
0.9265488386154175,
0.4165213108062744,
0.23940545320510864,
0.359027624130249,
-0.08614305406808853,
-0.1132843941450119,
-0.5165984034538269,
-0.6800047159194946,
-0.43216559290885925,
-0.4014759659767151,
-0.5834657549858093,
-0.5365709066390991,
0.44733926653862,
0.11555641144514084,
-0.19650915265083313,
-0.02687026560306549,
-0.4709632396697998,
0.5403749346733093,
0.42022526264190674,
0.5213356614112854,
0.48091498017311096,
-0.16211658716201782,
-0.5477416515350342,
-0.025893544778227806,
-0.7042572498321533,
-0.3781965672969818,
1.2107292413711548,
0.47804832458496094,
0.9269420504570007,
0.2681986689567566,
0.9814381003379822,
0.23457136750221252,
0.21181917190551758,
-0.7516558766365051,
0.2709340751171112,
-0.2690598964691162,
-0.12269262224435806,
-0.2596528232097626,
-0.4626889228820801,
-1.0738561153411865,
0.18729113042354584,
-0.24067816138267517,
-0.4478106200695038,
0.11876985430717468,
-0.03175739571452141,
-0.47751739621162415,
0.07174786925315857,
-0.7275620102882385,
0.731113076210022,
-0.06081175431609154,
-0.41492390632629395,
-0.19356226921081543,
-0.6765747666358948,
0.3524135947227478,
0.14527297019958496,
0.33556613326072693,
0.004408341832458973,
-0.1750171184539795,
0.6573935151100159,
-0.6141098141670227,
0.8500568270683289,
0.028222646564245224,
0.08027094602584839,
0.0476875901222229,
0.07142935693264008,
0.7966667413711548,
0.285217821598053,
-0.08074299246072769,
-0.34221386909484863,
-0.02854139544069767,
-0.44417643547058105,
-0.38713082671165466,
0.5819879174232483,
-0.5387026071548462,
-0.5178366899490356,
-0.3908926248550415,
-0.11130470037460327,
0.00044730279478244483,
0.3555724024772644,
0.13239356875419617,
0.03756193444132805,
-0.31697630882263184,
0.2523314952850342,
1.0253113508224487,
-0.29035070538520813,
0.27732527256011963,
0.285588800907135,
-0.13787513971328735,
-0.3874046504497528,
0.7003412246704102,
-0.3448256254196167,
0.13079819083213806,
0.5039570331573486,
0.4249337613582611,
-0.390572190284729,
-0.3104899227619171,
-0.1333610713481903,
0.272177517414093,
-0.8780230283737183,
-0.23993006348609924,
-0.7723569869995117,
-0.12098126858472824,
-0.4585302174091339,
-0.07034251093864441,
-0.1293431967496872,
-0.3875131607055664,
-0.6035244464874268,
-0.32889601588249207,
0.2536013722419739,
0.9555641412734985,
-0.22646920382976532,
0.46136197447776794,
-0.5239461660385132,
0.15419739484786987,
0.49320298433303833,
0.1399349719285965,
-0.06007251515984535,
-0.32571691274642944,
0.007500271778553724,
0.08532939851284027,
-0.3604098856449127,
-1.1078851222991943,
0.5168405175209045,
0.19301719963550568,
0.4735589325428009,
0.26505109667778015,
0.13831982016563416,
0.3558382987976074,
-0.32356807589530945,
0.5047956705093384,
0.41825106739997864,
-0.8000898957252502,
0.5128574967384338,
-0.3587220013141632,
0.5148314833641052,
0.8614537119865417,
0.5337783098220825,
-0.7552402019500732,
0.004701528698205948,
-0.5565882921218872,
-0.839320182800293,
0.5657262206077576,
-0.06466735154390335,
-0.21795161068439484,
0.013502195477485657,
0.3395316004753113,
0.23935264348983765,
0.27556318044662476,
-0.6326050162315369,
-0.3837992548942566,
-0.21206805109977722,
-0.6819306015968323,
-0.015185006894171238,
-0.6278542876243591,
-0.29039767384529114,
-0.19392426311969757,
0.585144579410553,
-0.24775348603725433,
0.07757594436407089,
0.2468307614326477,
-0.1482653170824051,
0.048529986292123795,
0.5168585181236267,
0.8950198888778687,
0.15882928669452667,
-0.04735579341650009,
0.08763838559389114,
0.11459293216466904,
-0.6768105030059814,
0.052530303597450256,
-0.06951934844255447,
-0.09007934480905533,
-0.10404891520738602,
0.21473892033100128,
0.9097275137901306,
0.5223357081413269,
-0.7428520917892456,
0.7341552376747131,
-0.280481219291687,
-0.15578137338161469,
0.03309227526187897,
0.1689785122871399,
0.3427956700325012,
0.03074714168906212,
0.20917686820030212,
-0.23272867500782013,
0.5175155401229858,
-0.340861439704895,
0.4091587960720062,
-0.03533328324556351,
-0.48924171924591064,
-0.0729675218462944,
0.5948572754859924,
0.3664853274822235,
-0.08821147680282593,
0.24128784239292145,
-0.3095037043094635,
-0.2764292359352112,
0.7364818453788757,
0.4588434100151062,
0.26399701833724976,
-0.1732974350452423,
0.4549189507961273,
0.5128985643386841,
0.2914229929447174,
-0.34560781717300415,
0.3737899363040924,
-0.10785963386297226,
-0.1818128377199173,
-0.2800230383872986,
-0.5467295050621033,
-0.5241064429283142,
0.006546076387166977,
-0.5262845158576965,
0.41025078296661377,
-0.588866114616394,
0.16706125438213348,
0.1457112580537796,
0.24349509179592133,
-0.7133409976959229,
0.4365939795970917,
0.0729830265045166,
0.9095701575279236,
-0.8782235980033875,
0.9601641893386841,
0.6689229011535645,
-0.6117534041404724,
-1.0197523832321167,
0.0788702741265297,
0.3012971580028534,
-0.5698192715644836,
0.5222618579864502,
0.0736040323972702,
0.003637519897893071,
-0.02616814151406288,
-0.32889610528945923,
-0.7953011989593506,
1.1637868881225586,
0.18059535324573517,
-0.6721376776695251,
-0.15975603461265564,
0.22379033267498016,
0.5390626788139343,
-0.4518269896507263,
0.5727123618125916,
0.485634446144104,
0.5791845321655273,
0.27117863297462463,
-0.8050453662872314,
0.046725381165742874,
0.014951050281524658,
-0.052799489349126816,
-0.04832246154546738,
-0.5494492650032043,
0.6767907738685608,
-0.546943187713623,
-0.20256240665912628,
0.11419222503900528,
0.5562497973442078,
0.2649552524089813,
0.6282951235771179,
0.2316054254770279,
0.5769698023796082,
1.0187674760818481,
-0.15244273841381073,
1.053753137588501,
0.01893920823931694,
0.40068134665489197,
0.9394629597663879,
0.05995616689324379,
0.6454896926879883,
0.42150673270225525,
0.11255495995283127,
0.615475058555603,
0.8353254795074463,
0.4760401248931885,
0.8063789010047913,
0.3652517795562744,
-0.36256149411201477,
-0.3026076555252075,
-0.3237434923648834,
-0.2396722137928009,
0.3437708020210266,
0.6374415755271912,
-0.4764023423194885,
-0.38258039951324463,
0.3065272867679596,
0.24465174973011017,
0.4855562150478363,
-0.5256984233856201,
1.009817361831665,
0.19900573790073395,
-0.4862349331378937,
0.42359665036201477,
0.20417803525924683,
0.6418246030807495,
-0.49914780259132385,
-0.12799718976020813,
-0.4049663841724396,
0.16055233776569366,
-0.4110560417175293,
-0.5497728586196899,
0.07972284406423569,
-0.27300190925598145,
-0.10951565206050873,
0.01055821217596531,
0.6363662481307983,
-0.8038524389266968,
-0.44332534074783325,
0.2782241106033325,
0.22604010999202728,
0.1554526537656784,
0.34525489807128906,
-0.733302652835846,
0.3132416307926178,
0.18596723675727844,
-0.21078971028327942,
0.3201886713504791,
0.3269719183444977,
0.006545322481542826,
0.7419596910476685,
0.6105111241340637,
0.21025413274765015,
-0.2515279948711395,
-0.12578849494457245,
0.8299974799156189,
-0.7043645977973938,
-0.7407348155975342,
-0.37476831674575806,
0.18929363787174225,
0.0014845740515738726,
-0.27333542704582214,
0.3365839123725891,
0.4931374192237854,
0.8090239763259888,
-0.09583675861358643,
0.7081993818283081,
0.4168194532394409,
0.8616595268249512,
-0.6559157371520996,
0.7348228096961975,
-0.733217716217041,
0.3314594626426697,
-0.08386266976594925,
-0.36908575892448425,
-0.34506088495254517,
0.36047399044036865,
-0.30074700713157654,
0.1532711684703827,
1.057573914527893,
0.5541754961013794,
0.07999664545059204,
0.0475471168756485,
0.40137290954589844,
0.026220057159662247,
0.09668084233999252,
0.8485549092292786,
0.17799337208271027,
-0.3787459135055542,
0.642162561416626,
-0.4110267460346222,
-0.14001332223415375,
-0.5736777186393738,
-0.6842490434646606,
-0.6159704923629761,
-0.4296916723251343,
-0.3105910122394562,
-0.18233650922775269,
0.48860877752304077,
1.0035699605941772,
0.4310751259326935,
-0.6851624846458435,
-0.05244850739836693,
0.029084764420986176,
0.4087717831134796,
-0.20342165231704712,
-0.13826924562454224,
0.3775065839290619,
-0.11726784706115723,
-0.7254871129989624,
0.4429519474506378,
0.1475885808467865,
-0.0658482164144516,
0.040801212191581726,
-0.2427312135696411,
-0.23203563690185547,
0.17799337208271027,
0.30425378680229187,
0.6320628523826599,
-0.4532012939453125,
0.09653853625059128,
-0.17699283361434937,
-0.6324023604393005,
0.013057040981948376,
0.8842613101005554,
-0.8299973607063293,
0.4204391837120056,
0.43644240498542786,
0.597421407699585,
0.3176119327545166,
0.1246841698884964,
0.19236208498477936,
-0.6351178288459778,
0.17997613549232483,
0.28081759810447693,
0.16245804727077484,
0.2678445279598236,
-0.6519749164581299,
0.3008614480495453,
0.11821167171001434,
-0.5091881155967712,
-0.4522634744644165,
0.30250662565231323,
-0.9540023803710938,
-0.5846690535545349,
1.4712858200073242,
-0.06628693640232086,
-0.5605453848838806,
-0.17282913625240326,
-0.38649511337280273,
0.4380027949810028,
-0.6112145185470581,
0.7659783959388733,
0.2719651758670807,
-0.006054675672203302,
-0.1835828721523285,
-0.16946183145046234,
1.1019271612167358,
0.5659211277961731,
-1.1619696617126465,
-0.1499069184064865,
0.39559364318847656,
0.4246869385242462,
-0.3568843901157379,
0.6735109090805054,
-0.09264801442623138,
0.6445538401603699,
-0.21946299076080322,
0.2321944385766983,
-0.22408807277679443,
-0.39946332573890686,
-0.5885902643203735,
0.26960086822509766,
-0.002784570213407278,
0.07166175544261932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15042v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15042v4 | PROXYQA: An Alternative Framework for Evaluating Long-Form Text Generation with Large Language Models | 2024-01-26T18:12:25 | 2024-06-04T12:46:47 | Haochen Tan, Zhijiang Guo, Zhan Shi, Lu Xu, Zhili Liu, Yunlong Feng, Xiaoguang Li, Yasheng Wang, Lifeng Shang, Qun Liu, Linqi Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have succeeded remarkably in understanding
long-form contents. However, exploring their capability for generating
long-form contents, such as reports and articles, has been relatively
unexplored and inadequately assessed by existing benchmarks. The prevalent
evaluation methods, which predominantly rely on crowdsourcing, are recognized
for their labor-intensive nature and lack of efficiency, whereas automated
metrics, such as the ROUGE score, demonstrate discordance with human judgment
criteria. In this paper, we propose ProxyQA, an innovative framework dedicated
to assessing long-text generation. ProxyQA comprises in-depth human-curated
meta-questions spanning various domains, each accompanied by specific
proxy-questions with pre-annotated answers. LLMs are tasked to generate
extensive content in response to these meta-questions, by engaging an evaluator
and incorporating the generated texts as contextual background, ProxyQA
assesses the generated content's quality through the evaluator's accuracy in
addressing the proxy-questions. We examine multiple LLMs, emphasizing ProxyQA's
demanding nature as a high-quality assessment tool. Human evaluation
demonstrates that the proxy-question method is notably self-consistent and
aligns closely with human evaluative standards. The dataset and leaderboard is
available at \url{https://proxy-qa.com}. | [
-0.43151113390922546,
-0.6462623476982117,
0.779835045337677,
0.43109598755836487,
-0.2718881070613861,
0.28781911730766296,
-0.04853262007236481,
-0.21550752222537994,
0.3634093403816223,
0.6521832346916199,
-0.48494523763656616,
-0.3940214514732361,
-0.32228195667266846,
0.3873869776725769,
-0.5556260943412781,
0.9118114113807678,
-0.21496638655662537,
-0.08838696777820587,
-0.3748113811016083,
0.01922672986984253,
-0.027282437309622765,
-0.4526204764842987,
-0.8086109757423401,
-0.22781093418598175,
0.582124650478363,
-0.027324412018060684,
0.7878199815750122,
0.45892617106437683,
0.06672405451536179,
0.30439284443855286,
-0.0012198686599731445,
0.5229002237319946,
-0.5236047506332397,
0.12519370019435883,
-0.605451762676239,
0.24259020388126373,
-0.5137502551078796,
0.08492518961429596,
0.7900318503379822,
0.7215051651000977,
0.018268372863531113,
0.5739303827285767,
0.17109374701976776,
0.7247092127799988,
-0.7648636102676392,
-0.2924920618534088,
-0.5409510135650635,
-0.21917368471622467,
-0.3650873601436615,
0.0036659755278378725,
-0.3286941945552826,
-0.28011617064476013,
-0.01754128374159336,
-0.26217684149742126,
0.2670159339904785,
-0.03888466954231262,
0.6425034999847412,
0.009517411701381207,
-0.8009065985679626,
-0.49306440353393555,
-0.38471436500549316,
0.5322301983833313,
-0.6489802002906799,
0.5342305302619934,
0.30292582511901855,
0.3620970547199249,
-0.551461935043335,
-1.0159879922866821,
-0.8158340454101562,
-0.29309120774269104,
0.32986611127853394,
0.4629654288291931,
-0.07553456723690033,
-0.17649856209754944,
-0.08604000508785248,
0.2538261413574219,
-0.6196641325950623,
0.1171855553984642,
-0.3016541600227356,
-0.2450851947069168,
0.7896279096603394,
0.2006385773420334,
0.2535087764263153,
-0.5449596643447876,
-0.453841894865036,
-0.07187420129776001,
-0.7309718728065491,
0.10992558300495148,
0.7273899912834167,
0.30545684695243835,
0.12848922610282898,
0.4916384518146515,
-0.49040892720222473,
0.4085666835308075,
-0.0031458477023988962,
0.07178350538015366,
0.1405712068080902,
-0.065623939037323,
-0.13416333496570587,
-0.19598270952701569,
1.0416574478149414,
0.32678642868995667,
0.10623664408922195,
-0.1700068712234497,
-0.4031223654747009,
-0.14937624335289001,
0.4885799288749695,
-0.8386770486831665,
0.05088949576020241,
0.2890889048576355,
-0.43609386682510376,
-0.25528019666671753,
0.2797754406929016,
-1.1232593059539795,
-0.4847097098827362,
-0.12154704332351685,
0.5533403158187866,
0.2662016749382019,
-0.16067421436309814,
0.22666077315807343,
-0.06680915504693985,
0.0699450895190239,
0.21049591898918152,
-0.3550357520580292,
0.4851752519607544,
0.719970703125,
0.8117013573646545,
-0.5785380005836487,
-0.3249489367008209,
-1.0065293312072754,
0.07058356702327728,
-0.5448893308639526,
0.7252548933029175,
-0.2042984962463379,
-0.1933956891298294,
0.3722188472747803,
0.06456281989812851,
0.408231258392334,
-0.5001419186592102,
0.7303544282913208,
-0.7215524911880493,
0.23043271899223328,
-0.15647827088832855,
-0.3763381838798523,
0.173122838139534,
0.03726066276431084,
-0.9960922002792358,
1.2662997245788574,
0.24651601910591125,
-0.44419562816619873,
0.2997101843357086,
-0.3965590000152588,
-0.36736565828323364,
0.1987513154745102,
0.051641419529914856,
-0.3563975989818573,
0.11055964231491089,
0.24167293310165405,
0.5653149485588074,
-0.7274438738822937,
0.7068412899971008,
-0.17002461850643158,
-0.2415868192911148,
0.4295113682746887,
-0.7161683440208435,
0.4741915762424469,
0.08953407406806946,
-0.5503712296485901,
-0.011800527572631836,
-0.7977262139320374,
0.20860649645328522,
-0.05095178261399269,
-0.48186925053596497,
-0.19787968695163727,
0.06903113424777985,
0.09550563991069794,
0.2828981578350067,
0.039388976991176605,
-0.4374452531337738,
-0.08664736896753311,
-0.35432547330856323,
0.44338464736938477,
0.7990506291389465,
0.13418687880039215,
0.23337000608444214,
-0.3174600899219513,
0.540523886680603,
-0.3305622935295105,
0.14610448479652405,
-0.13758783042430878,
-0.2940065562725067,
-0.8396133780479431,
-0.09697974473237991,
0.39774221181869507,
0.11110030114650726,
-1.0648667812347412,
0.2962983548641205,
-0.390346497297287,
-0.7239576578140259,
-0.5347607135772705,
0.36173343658447266,
0.5263069272041321,
0.33950987458229065,
0.4607590436935425,
-0.3417518138885498,
-0.31665492057800293,
-0.8280048966407776,
-0.3483883738517761,
-0.2716292440891266,
-0.2347361147403717,
0.030749792233109474,
0.7262168526649475,
-0.2753109335899353,
0.8729261159896851,
-0.32031309604644775,
0.2231948971748352,
-0.12099942564964294,
0.48616671562194824,
0.12787222862243652,
0.15877239406108856,
0.27287232875823975,
-0.6678571701049805,
-0.32958322763442993,
-0.40763959288597107,
-0.3222474157810211,
-0.5792982578277588,
-0.2851855754852295,
-0.42682263255119324,
0.1643705517053604,
0.33836907148361206,
-0.8188661336898804,
0.27461132407188416,
0.7479270100593567,
-0.2823065221309662,
0.7915515303611755,
0.1649891436100006,
0.24102595448493958,
-1.1407139301300049,
0.19506831467151642,
-0.053316108882427216,
-0.4565688371658325,
-0.5218147039413452,
0.2695258855819702,
0.17955009639263153,
-0.13847029209136963,
-0.49966514110565186,
1.158467411994934,
-0.455747127532959,
-0.03029608353972435,
-0.32181623578071594,
0.35982027649879456,
0.38669636845588684,
0.27575668692588806,
0.09486591815948486,
0.6805211901664734,
-0.013230537064373493,
-0.5190945863723755,
0.443327933549881,
-0.06324782967567444,
-0.47245484590530396,
0.2822320759296417,
-0.7269757986068726,
0.41939786076545715,
-0.14508236944675446,
0.6385906338691711,
-0.9786611199378967,
-0.5158891677856445,
0.10074923187494278,
-0.2931991517543793,
-0.172389954328537,
0.02192600816488266,
-0.5898729562759399,
-0.5234910249710083,
-0.5530204772949219,
0.4773962199687958,
0.49318036437034607,
-0.8417630195617676,
0.4524334669113159,
0.21452338993549347,
-0.26078057289123535,
-0.6189092397689819,
-0.2363767921924591,
0.295767217874527,
-0.17666782438755035,
-0.586417555809021,
0.3531768321990967,
-0.1471596509218216,
-0.26443248987197876,
-0.2942231297492981,
-0.0637718215584755,
-0.1771128922700882,
-0.10012919455766678,
0.27292197942733765,
0.08241826295852661,
-0.08658120781183243,
0.2345130741596222,
0.3940375745296478,
0.23777131736278534,
0.32300853729248047,
0.003056012326851487,
0.5916093587875366,
0.19012729823589325,
-0.4364868998527527,
-0.18979302048683167,
0.4684448838233948,
0.5862327814102173,
-0.121235191822052,
0.32678550481796265,
0.4868830144405365,
-0.1449589729309082,
-0.6582431197166443,
-0.7786535024642944,
0.10413996875286102,
-0.4836510419845581,
0.3064986765384674,
-0.24130386114120483,
-0.8351888060569763,
0.4128720164299011,
-0.31605082750320435,
0.002130404580384493,
0.6057730317115784,
0.6388521790504456,
0.19334223866462708,
1.0058833360671997,
0.16909968852996826,
0.08808507025241852,
-0.20650075376033783,
0.2698798179626465,
-0.07812775671482086,
-0.6417972445487976,
-0.09727279841899872,
-0.5320555567741394,
0.08384578675031662,
-0.4634081721305847,
-0.5475791692733765,
0.3019978702068329,
0.18097275495529175,
-0.49815893173217773,
0.001418899861164391,
-0.1826503872871399,
0.28803491592407227,
0.41754674911499023,
0.0567275695502758,
0.3066456913948059,
-0.2461453527212143,
0.005619356874376535,
0.2465267926454544,
-0.29478710889816284,
-0.834259569644928,
0.980691134929657,
0.5504324436187744,
0.6314845681190491,
0.201576367020607,
0.6788264513015747,
0.6362724304199219,
0.592039942741394,
-0.7071213722229004,
0.5166432857513428,
-0.043562036007642746,
-0.4275858998298645,
-0.4140278697013855,
-0.5501924157142639,
-0.9152705073356628,
0.2625204920768738,
-0.3029618263244629,
-0.35946741700172424,
-0.2144187092781067,
-0.18671175837516785,
-0.321670264005661,
0.00455518439412117,
-0.313689261674881,
0.5102637410163879,
-0.3319883346557617,
-0.6902798414230347,
0.24578708410263062,
-0.31769973039627075,
0.4266306459903717,
-0.6171677112579346,
0.34205499291419983,
0.04470810294151306,
-0.27304741740226746,
0.7715966701507568,
-0.4421224296092987,
0.8763337135314941,
0.0252192672342062,
-0.4046947956085205,
0.5709469318389893,
0.261398583650589,
0.3716430068016052,
0.3669377565383911,
-0.24898698925971985,
0.09905586391687393,
-0.06634645909070969,
-0.3117389678955078,
-0.7606142163276672,
0.5787600874900818,
-0.5637418627738953,
-0.7263284921646118,
-0.2832167446613312,
-0.07928027957677841,
-0.3513348698616028,
0.1809585690498352,
0.10864493995904922,
0.3586701452732086,
-0.38232532143592834,
-0.06921355426311493,
0.2295875996351242,
-0.4953303933143616,
0.3249482810497284,
0.534028947353363,
-0.4361094832420349,
-0.6347929239273071,
0.6942956447601318,
-0.10946905612945557,
0.2111613005399704,
0.10094878822565079,
0.28262361884117126,
-0.48534709215164185,
-0.21648912131786346,
-0.7960489392280579,
0.2085500806570053,
-0.48713839054107666,
-0.5177085995674133,
-0.35265102982521057,
-0.41022011637687683,
-0.5231348276138306,
-0.02360725961625576,
-0.43500322103500366,
-0.043184150010347366,
-0.13971740007400513,
-0.011035927571356297,
-0.1482178270816803,
0.7852179408073425,
0.20905105769634247,
0.17426297068595886,
-0.9872477650642395,
0.4621930420398712,
0.6196380257606506,
0.25645050406455994,
0.10675617307424545,
-0.4014783203601837,
-0.04458077251911163,
0.12279641628265381,
-0.4088535010814667,
-1.0032658576965332,
0.4086628556251526,
0.1919863373041153,
0.47824808955192566,
0.26546812057495117,
0.1892041712999344,
0.7040419578552246,
-0.7559505105018616,
1.2220182418823242,
0.21761350333690643,
-1.4097342491149902,
0.24414627254009247,
-0.3073788285255432,
0.30995848774909973,
0.4462207555770874,
0.6484804153442383,
-0.4920431673526764,
-0.4868500828742981,
-0.34369638562202454,
-0.897284746170044,
0.05472410097718239,
0.27054929733276367,
0.6239624619483948,
-0.4088481366634369,
0.6146309971809387,
0.3725568354129791,
0.21457819640636444,
-0.8452073931694031,
0.3296152949333191,
-0.24334020912647247,
-0.06422677636146545,
0.10261152684688568,
-0.30943167209625244,
0.12847599387168884,
0.07165811210870743,
0.5654892921447754,
-0.23448911309242249,
-0.21951718628406525,
0.28730353713035583,
0.03589693084359169,
-0.17832504212856293,
0.3153897225856781,
0.3580477237701416,
0.9000449180603027,
0.17314639687538147,
0.28074443340301514,
0.16443626582622528,
-0.4285925328731537,
0.1408151090145111,
-0.2420894056558609,
-0.014499637298285961,
0.1853150725364685,
0.6172487139701843,
0.3720528781414032,
0.02142605185508728,
-1.0750526189804077,
0.7921572923660278,
0.03545387461781502,
-0.44161930680274963,
-0.3659527897834778,
-0.13972003757953644,
-0.010281473398208618,
0.38075193762779236,
0.5594835877418518,
-0.682601273059845,
0.2633727490901947,
-0.698491096496582,
0.1673833429813385,
0.35994261503219604,
-0.24803419411182404,
-0.28195086121559143,
0.4842867851257324,
0.37892651557922363,
-0.29723915457725525,
0.5176603198051453,
-0.31438612937927246,
-0.5211664438247681,
0.44982096552848816,
0.620117723941803,
0.7833124399185181,
-0.24723444879055023,
0.5999547839164734,
0.3641766607761383,
0.13479381799697876,
-0.419732004404068,
0.28614598512649536,
0.06570561975240707,
-0.5370778441429138,
-0.6946364641189575,
-1.0096303224563599,
-0.35488957166671753,
0.6660341024398804,
-0.5973848104476929,
0.29262784123420715,
-0.16583919525146484,
-0.4243663251399994,
-0.2125323861837387,
-0.034360371530056,
-0.5342816710472107,
0.2667539715766907,
-0.04938129335641861,
0.9697538018226624,
-0.8758974075317383,
0.3806174695491791,
0.4993864893913269,
-0.2777661085128784,
-0.54246985912323,
0.2419433295726776,
-0.26685699820518494,
-0.41511499881744385,
0.8591859936714172,
0.1632888913154602,
-0.3572598695755005,
-0.3929325342178345,
-0.5948535799980164,
-0.682240903377533,
0.9456373453140259,
0.21034692227840424,
-0.3703076243400574,
-0.13376784324645996,
0.4616452753543854,
0.7859249711036682,
-0.29444199800491333,
0.24288079142570496,
0.3477790355682373,
0.37383005023002625,
-0.10485076904296875,
-0.982117235660553,
0.33476361632347107,
-0.3821009695529938,
0.05131809785962105,
0.22645710408687592,
-0.7792799472808838,
0.8957448601722717,
0.22848200798034668,
-0.39513927698135376,
0.4470500349998474,
0.7801981568336487,
0.3260001242160797,
0.5230382680892944,
0.4727117717266083,
0.20795436203479767,
0.5800163745880127,
0.2649722099304199,
0.8058356046676636,
0.013254395686089993,
0.13519851863384247,
1.2093960046768188,
-0.45360317826271057,
1.0846501588821411,
0.4323602020740509,
0.02258753404021263,
0.5664394497871399,
0.4445112645626068,
0.0877419263124466,
0.17577940225601196,
0.8513879776000977,
-0.21786198019981384,
-0.43731966614723206,
-0.0596618577837944,
-0.012354305014014244,
0.7416456341743469,
-0.0028619859367609024,
-0.40371814370155334,
-0.2497180998325348,
-0.09132026880979538,
-0.01359581295400858,
0.41270723938941956,
-0.3752313256263733,
0.6430025100708008,
0.05667058378458023,
-0.9719999432563782,
0.4750123918056488,
0.18806669116020203,
0.41568422317504883,
-0.32121142745018005,
-0.2940838634967804,
-0.3032080829143524,
-0.47774362564086914,
-0.03147072345018387,
-0.845756471157074,
-0.04631219804286957,
0.4190579950809479,
0.00442473404109478,
-0.11813809722661972,
0.5389620661735535,
-0.2110440880060196,
-0.4134396016597748,
0.22364690899848938,
0.9265889525413513,
0.25806140899658203,
-0.21587122976779938,
-0.469674289226532,
0.06054238975048065,
-0.4052422046661377,
-0.4361630380153656,
0.3357844650745392,
0.4507230818271637,
-0.27597707509994507,
0.5719842910766602,
0.7008278369903564,
0.15780885517597198,
-0.10471789538860321,
0.25515636801719666,
0.8279047012329102,
-0.5294086337089539,
-0.24415583908557892,
-0.8300241231918335,
0.4867040812969208,
-0.2831774652004242,
-0.5852099657058716,
0.6343008875846863,
0.6523211002349854,
0.5669608116149902,
0.05555716156959534,
0.6720408797264099,
0.30326607823371887,
0.6212514638900757,
-0.7499709725379944,
0.7927514314651489,
-0.6334844827651978,
0.07243116945028305,
-0.49102360010147095,
-1.215706706047058,
0.08324261009693146,
0.10167212039232254,
0.022564994171261787,
-0.0015113370027393103,
0.5709456205368042,
0.675295889377594,
-0.035477492958307266,
-0.23080193996429443,
0.23794326186180115,
-0.06250645965337753,
0.3903063237667084,
0.37591296434402466,
1.2321151494979858,
-0.36600545048713684,
0.44960832595825195,
0.16690121591091156,
-0.24601158499717712,
0.18014657497406006,
-1.1119087934494019,
-1.2565932273864746,
-0.9033149480819702,
0.08780223876237869,
-0.4389125108718872,
0.26960840821266174,
0.8344643712043762,
0.45710816979408264,
-0.2861315608024597,
-0.3212758004665375,
0.23079830408096313,
-0.13112768530845642,
0.05656705051660538,
-0.2994333505630493,
0.5860529541969299,
-0.22637908160686493,
-0.9015138149261475,
0.4150339663028717,
-0.012382486835122108,
-0.2170618623495102,
-0.6811627149581909,
-0.05194375663995743,
0.17903046309947968,
0.5129494667053223,
0.9173219203948975,
0.11958816647529602,
-0.6423631906509399,
-0.4211385250091553,
-0.07102742791175842,
-0.24310900270938873,
-0.49278098344802856,
0.7171933054924011,
-0.8165702223777771,
0.27798566222190857,
0.4556933641433716,
0.8208822011947632,
0.33002224564552307,
0.31163766980171204,
0.5565640926361084,
-0.5829530954360962,
-0.45015567541122437,
0.1562238335609436,
0.017756443470716476,
0.23129239678382874,
-0.23533406853675842,
0.42564934492111206,
-0.22106361389160156,
-0.6243101358413696,
-0.8313131928443909,
0.2017984390258789,
-0.9341121315956116,
-0.3750994801521301,
1.4643398523330688,
-0.14757375419139862,
-0.22060531377792358,
-0.04350142553448677,
-0.13602638244628906,
0.2423991709947586,
-0.3964761793613434,
1.1534535884857178,
0.6267285346984863,
0.107872374355793,
0.11190710961818695,
-0.648483395576477,
0.5423160195350647,
0.15005174279212952,
-1.0227898359298706,
0.04239171743392944,
0.6451571583747864,
0.23792539536952972,
0.2006290853023529,
0.5677169561386108,
-0.08428983390331268,
0.2000979334115982,
-0.2955664098262787,
-0.20956110954284668,
0.08553748577833176,
-0.33308735489845276,
0.15361981093883514,
0.33845677971839905,
-0.12165836244821548,
0.4773130714893341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01719v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01719v3 | Measuring Moral Inconsistencies in Large Language Models | 2024-01-26T18:05:47 | 2024-03-01T06:35:29 | Vamshi Krishna Bonagiri, Sreeram Vennam, Manas Gaur, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | A Large Language Model (LLM) is considered consistent if semantically
equivalent prompts produce semantically equivalent responses. Despite recent
advancements showcasing the impressive capabilities of LLMs in conversational
systems, we show that even state-of-the-art LLMs are highly inconsistent in
their generations, questioning their reliability. Prior research has tried to
measure this with task-specific accuracy. However, this approach is unsuitable
for moral scenarios, such as the trolley problem, with no "correct" answer. To
address this issue, we propose a novel information-theoretic measure called
Semantic Graph Entropy (SGE) to measure the consistency of an LLM in moral
scenarios. We leverage "Rules of Thumb" (RoTs) to explain a model's
decision-making strategies and further enhance our metric. Compared to existing
consistency metrics, SGE correlates better with human judgments across five
LLMs. In the future, we aim to investigate the root causes of LLM
inconsistencies and propose improvements. | [
-0.0803617537021637,
-0.740699291229248,
0.8791652321815491,
0.12497289478778839,
-0.3351757228374481,
-0.04388520494103432,
-0.10489939153194427,
-0.3601580858230591,
0.06546945124864578,
0.39967983961105347,
-0.3555726110935211,
-0.4907364845275879,
-0.9902440905570984,
0.028788911178708076,
-0.4101863503456116,
0.7758520245552063,
0.016518808901309967,
0.18841829895973206,
-0.39549726247787476,
-0.5326433777809143,
-0.20841480791568756,
-0.20882467925548553,
-1.0878623723983765,
-0.39622387290000916,
0.5895078182220459,
0.22454942762851715,
1.0642486810684204,
0.8056007027626038,
0.6757459044456482,
0.3564518094062805,
-0.07051195949316025,
0.21175870299339294,
-0.6356330513954163,
-0.07434743642807007,
-0.4587748348712921,
-0.2556420862674713,
-0.47327956557273865,
0.2038126289844513,
0.45759138464927673,
0.5960885286331177,
-0.18848828971385956,
0.1652531921863556,
0.11135237663984299,
0.5822182297706604,
-0.6231743097305298,
0.1869925558567047,
-0.7146852016448975,
-0.023332130163908005,
-0.0020126032177358866,
-0.17897489666938782,
-0.46203532814979553,
-0.8194615244865417,
-0.0320252887904644,
-0.5645586848258972,
-0.04755401238799095,
0.0966101884841919,
0.9207834005355835,
0.3212404251098633,
-0.5685651898384094,
-0.5136370062828064,
-0.5810014009475708,
0.8186219334602356,
-1.0011543035507202,
0.40512919425964355,
0.5548182725906372,
-0.26441994309425354,
-0.2771998345851898,
-0.5192712545394897,
-0.7145920991897583,
-0.4114527106285095,
0.12399210035800934,
-0.003953094128519297,
-0.27495574951171875,
-0.0314936563372612,
0.2321653962135315,
0.021370522677898407,
-0.35710689425468445,
0.2860625088214874,
0.159934863448143,
-0.23138466477394104,
0.570480465888977,
0.4985470771789551,
0.518680214881897,
-0.30289897322654724,
-0.3912196457386017,
-0.3288956880569458,
-0.596589982509613,
0.38778361678123474,
0.7214793562889099,
-0.01433746237307787,
-0.07800384610891342,
0.5498790740966797,
0.24515552818775177,
0.5132054090499878,
0.2560770511627197,
-0.2306126207113266,
-0.013479126617312431,
-0.5140166878700256,
-0.27805033326148987,
0.038622479885816574,
0.9947571754455566,
0.7675778865814209,
0.4545624852180481,
0.04135550558567047,
-0.09284468740224838,
0.058494631201028824,
0.2898489832878113,
-0.6488178372383118,
-0.11335062980651855,
0.2616821527481079,
-0.16237695515155792,
-0.37433019280433655,
0.20712941884994507,
-0.41565757989883423,
-0.7777615189552307,
-0.18983201682567596,
0.03631814941763878,
-0.6871064305305481,
-0.29700493812561035,
0.3817910850048065,
-0.1774371862411499,
0.3157925307750702,
0.46737632155418396,
-0.7424989938735962,
-0.16277123987674713,
0.8268816471099854,
0.732941746711731,
-0.12439576536417007,
-0.35879290103912354,
-0.6381864547729492,
0.28933459520339966,
-0.6405652165412903,
0.4577958285808563,
-0.6545397043228149,
-0.24330008029937744,
-0.1622597873210907,
0.15308202803134918,
-0.01514862198382616,
-0.3043489456176758,
0.8597221374511719,
-0.22751422226428986,
-0.24856778979301453,
-0.41087907552719116,
-0.8468102216720581,
-0.12704959511756897,
0.3564646542072296,
-0.3442574441432953,
0.8229503631591797,
-0.06213659420609474,
-0.8494505286216736,
0.5296308994293213,
-0.012604444287717342,
-0.000763334275688976,
-0.05586368963122368,
-0.2505021393299103,
-0.44986751675605774,
0.16288170218467712,
-0.23519784212112427,
0.4173760712146759,
-0.29094982147216797,
0.8069074153900146,
-0.810711145401001,
-0.35217154026031494,
0.3584311604499817,
-0.688167154788971,
1.0558373928070068,
-0.14463037252426147,
-0.0193518977612257,
0.14441540837287903,
-0.5244079232215881,
0.3015035390853882,
0.2914762794971466,
-0.2685176134109497,
-0.6089445352554321,
0.23797185719013214,
-0.31153008341789246,
0.057346098124980927,
0.5352281928062439,
-0.6366869211196899,
0.09508278965950012,
-0.21327833831310272,
0.4996887743473053,
1.2008696794509888,
-0.34072017669677734,
0.34005123376846313,
-0.5007477402687073,
0.09269480407238007,
-0.00566628435626626,
0.16488970816135406,
0.26704537868499756,
-0.3092966079711914,
-0.7847415804862976,
-0.1105567067861557,
-0.05168383941054344,
0.6637910604476929,
-0.2941626310348511,
0.7113890051841736,
-0.40955880284309387,
-0.5561767220497131,
-0.17848266661167145,
0.08591241389513016,
0.2072206288576126,
0.22822217643260956,
0.08946789801120758,
-0.40317535400390625,
-0.1427726447582245,
-0.6759597659111023,
-0.49361884593963623,
-0.6990357041358948,
0.031281545758247375,
0.4952029883861542,
0.3846440613269806,
-0.22517874836921692,
0.7626253366470337,
-0.10087031126022339,
0.1683872938156128,
0.06001822277903557,
0.01167767122387886,
0.12255404144525528,
0.5131051540374756,
0.39355820417404175,
-0.3658727705478668,
-0.19081340730190277,
0.11756489425897598,
-1.0041658878326416,
0.1061231717467308,
0.1228892132639885,
0.018658213317394257,
0.12819904088974,
0.5554155707359314,
-0.5303581953048706,
0.31912481784820557,
0.5947173237800598,
-0.6113689541816711,
0.58710777759552,
-0.2993085980415344,
0.23438750207424164,
-0.6867855787277222,
-0.20084726810455322,
0.1059374213218689,
-0.25199541449546814,
-0.29722607135772705,
-0.26780790090560913,
0.08641181141138077,
0.3658965826034546,
-0.34581702947616577,
0.6179585456848145,
0.06937092542648315,
-0.01540456898510456,
0.012951262295246124,
0.3604533076286316,
-0.007546471431851387,
0.22678709030151367,
-0.5293814539909363,
0.7380029559135437,
0.5560224056243896,
-0.5652043223381042,
0.5356757640838623,
0.19947104156017303,
-0.2810119688510895,
1.1183148622512817,
-0.6831671595573425,
0.14794443547725677,
-0.3344019651412964,
0.1687413454055786,
-1.0478553771972656,
-0.3388209939002991,
0.17377805709838867,
-0.3069772720336914,
0.1592264622449875,
-0.09089475870132446,
-0.5067985653877258,
-0.14398889243602753,
-0.3759303390979767,
0.430561363697052,
0.39602625370025635,
-0.4991860091686249,
0.7068970203399658,
0.32100820541381836,
-0.17088976502418518,
-0.7104917764663696,
-0.37554284930229187,
0.11913351714611053,
-0.35646551847457886,
-1.0421010255813599,
-0.18027640879154205,
-0.004085770808160305,
-0.5218310356140137,
-0.013908563181757927,
-0.42546236515045166,
0.01071520708501339,
0.1875673532485962,
0.09678851068019867,
0.12422359734773636,
-0.22956907749176025,
0.333238810300827,
-0.2904941141605377,
0.07212541252374649,
0.3250425159931183,
-0.4042286276817322,
0.4324510991573334,
-0.6124945878982544,
-0.5928856134414673,
-0.5652562975883484,
0.02645193785429001,
0.8602159023284912,
0.03734928369522095,
0.46767720580101013,
0.38303259015083313,
-0.00020060395763721317,
0.08830508589744568,
-0.5741451382637024,
0.001690048724412918,
-0.5055835843086243,
0.2397129237651825,
0.06313863396644592,
-0.9362307786941528,
0.7239298224449158,
-0.15877416729927063,
-0.05960816517472267,
0.29936113953590393,
0.05586026608943939,
-0.3511190116405487,
1.0221844911575317,
0.6951084136962891,
0.2618500590324402,
0.4689475893974304,
0.14036282896995544,
0.47743356227874756,
-0.7376623749732971,
-0.16675882041454315,
-0.4633534252643585,
-0.12102322280406952,
-0.8544554114341736,
-0.3074330687522888,
0.35782620310783386,
0.5159915089607239,
-0.9115167260169983,
0.177740216255188,
-0.11177217960357666,
0.623107373714447,
0.34515514969825745,
-0.0050016967579722404,
0.47036346793174744,
-0.14296889305114746,
-0.2748136818408966,
0.22404630482196808,
-0.7221856117248535,
-1.041555643081665,
0.6070939898490906,
0.1466120034456253,
0.8887691497802734,
0.16408753395080566,
0.5235128998756409,
0.24592435359954834,
0.1385592818260193,
-0.7203489542007446,
0.6507066488265991,
-0.44703760743141174,
-0.16662676632404327,
-0.6978521347045898,
-0.5665649771690369,
-1.021984577178955,
0.021498586982488632,
0.020778849720954895,
-1.09530508518219,
0.17086605727672577,
0.07962652295827866,
-0.038396190851926804,
0.6026576161384583,
-0.4486718475818634,
0.950762152671814,
-0.43511056900024414,
-0.4573739171028137,
-0.07249610871076584,
-0.5817614793777466,
0.30038073658943176,
-0.10056174546480179,
0.0267927348613739,
-0.5938921570777893,
0.12431295961141586,
0.646142840385437,
-0.60062575340271,
1.0067203044891357,
0.1564716398715973,
-0.34045666456222534,
0.3573857247829437,
0.23001538217067719,
1.0788195133209229,
0.08521604537963867,
-0.11175332218408585,
0.5261275172233582,
0.14772075414657593,
-0.4727875590324402,
-0.6320960521697998,
0.6149036884307861,
-0.7118815183639526,
-0.7272666692733765,
-0.46616747975349426,
-0.6594889163970947,
-0.38174504041671753,
0.15739493072032928,
0.27084919810295105,
0.2340671569108963,
-0.27560800313949585,
0.2552901804447174,
0.6721235513687134,
-0.4069352447986603,
0.44289731979370117,
0.5939041376113892,
-0.09704732149839401,
-0.169882133603096,
0.7886513471603394,
-0.011387664824724197,
0.5677518844604492,
-0.24170412123203278,
0.4399905800819397,
-0.2600773870944977,
-0.3281565010547638,
-0.5209285616874695,
0.25392431020736694,
-0.8530640602111816,
-0.17361235618591309,
-0.5005928874015808,
-0.18436874449253082,
0.007129383739084005,
-0.4075677990913391,
-0.4869442880153656,
-0.031615667045116425,
-0.25810912251472473,
-0.23528066277503967,
0.49197712540626526,
0.8851879239082336,
-0.07829941064119339,
0.04113015532493591,
-0.8200666904449463,
-0.14084027707576752,
0.15725846588611603,
0.44028884172439575,
0.05348384380340576,
-0.5090631246566772,
0.2138037085533142,
0.3668331801891327,
-0.19006980955600739,
-0.5851755738258362,
-0.1507302224636078,
-0.07729973644018173,
0.4164217412471771,
0.5416625142097473,
0.08395851403474808,
0.6142932772636414,
-0.44407394528388977,
0.651985228061676,
0.6392032504081726,
-1.2511526346206665,
0.27621036767959595,
-0.5592315196990967,
-0.01414856594055891,
0.4015670418739319,
0.17617769539356232,
-0.674585223197937,
-1.0482615232467651,
-0.7590577602386475,
-0.7630127668380737,
0.3031004071235657,
0.14882834255695343,
0.34576356410980225,
-0.33386802673339844,
0.24714778363704681,
0.031778231263160706,
-0.02017076686024666,
-0.5375999212265015,
-0.003873113775625825,
-0.17114931344985962,
-0.32647791504859924,
0.022557150572538376,
-0.16637013852596283,
-0.12243276834487915,
-0.12772805988788605,
0.5001873970031738,
-0.2897113859653473,
-0.12547630071640015,
0.11884413659572601,
0.3175055980682373,
-0.3257916569709778,
0.3516788184642792,
0.5852450728416443,
1.0603615045547485,
-0.023579539731144905,
0.37674680352211,
0.27807027101516724,
-0.4533677399158478,
0.4565795361995697,
-0.4524027407169342,
-0.21042020618915558,
-0.1706715077161789,
0.4827863276004791,
0.7142921686172485,
0.09467539936304092,
-0.61003577709198,
0.7124179601669312,
0.014671588316559792,
0.0926680862903595,
-0.38136568665504456,
0.28371378779411316,
0.265216588973999,
0.3627172112464905,
-0.1395995169878006,
0.18342961370944977,
-0.3234440088272095,
-0.6714563369750977,
0.2901979386806488,
0.8188285231590271,
-0.6165246367454529,
-0.03272916004061699,
0.4826619029045105,
0.018215501680970192,
-0.3276004493236542,
0.867207407951355,
-0.4247332811355591,
-0.17943894863128662,
0.9574838280677795,
0.2830808758735657,
0.8262983560562134,
-0.1357761174440384,
0.542719841003418,
0.33105096220970154,
0.5695478916168213,
-0.48270899057388306,
0.2745620310306549,
0.49247631430625916,
-1.2058074474334717,
-0.4554241895675659,
-0.6385633945465088,
-0.33558768033981323,
-0.10967424511909485,
-0.7405653595924377,
0.13781389594078064,
-0.46180593967437744,
-0.3077695369720459,
-0.24775516986846924,
-0.42859381437301636,
-0.5442480444908142,
0.03155668452382088,
-0.2007673978805542,
0.5588368773460388,
-0.6735221743583679,
0.7174432277679443,
0.24571382999420166,
-0.3262258768081665,
-0.9957885146141052,
0.05082697048783302,
-0.08302286267280579,
-1.1605284214019775,
0.5354735851287842,
-0.007643852382898331,
-0.7063350677490234,
-0.09341626614332199,
-0.9181479811668396,
-0.8745734095573425,
1.0618689060211182,
0.6276445984840393,
-0.6797007322311401,
0.24024885892868042,
0.08071361482143402,
0.5973203182220459,
-0.31014764308929443,
-0.025331338867545128,
0.5350561738014221,
0.7110475897789001,
0.18689672648906708,
-0.9993550777435303,
0.10858593881130219,
0.10952478647232056,
-0.09609653055667877,
0.46436548233032227,
-0.8269490599632263,
0.6469095349311829,
-0.6805094480514526,
-0.4860648512840271,
0.03899075463414192,
0.3137775957584381,
0.297168105840683,
0.6724182963371277,
0.5975305438041687,
0.6882153153419495,
1.5262905359268188,
-0.22089701890945435,
1.1782575845718384,
-0.3714866042137146,
0.6783879995346069,
1.1470609903335571,
-0.5528059005737305,
0.6305861473083496,
0.43548089265823364,
-0.036418333649635315,
0.27949586510658264,
0.47526901960372925,
-0.08481547236442566,
0.0775231122970581,
0.22800442576408386,
-0.11959664523601532,
-0.6817290782928467,
-0.47321557998657227,
-0.02840638905763626,
0.5816696286201477,
0.24520231783390045,
-0.30447468161582947,
-0.18916277587413788,
-0.3111078143119812,
0.2548144459724426,
-0.18682019412517548,
-0.3647250235080719,
0.7935627698898315,
0.2563360929489136,
-0.36034339666366577,
0.6400176286697388,
-0.08663570135831833,
0.3494778871536255,
-0.5315852761268616,
0.1532081812620163,
-0.19146083295345306,
0.034631259739398956,
-0.14135392010211945,
-1.2241085767745972,
0.3748038411140442,
0.013747680932283401,
-0.08626160770654678,
-0.1581297665834427,
0.44724515080451965,
-0.2570788860321045,
-0.5929703116416931,
0.4930984079837799,
0.671858549118042,
0.20268334448337555,
0.4426268935203552,
-0.5568950772285461,
0.16958463191986084,
-0.07739276438951492,
0.11369317024946213,
0.22047075629234314,
0.8323172926902771,
-0.07571377605199814,
0.9195532202720642,
0.5441069602966309,
-0.1788121908903122,
0.05104181542992592,
-0.1250978261232376,
0.396575003862381,
-0.8088178634643555,
-0.24438336491584778,
-1.1361331939697266,
0.22314703464508057,
-0.20103101432323456,
-0.5842311382293701,
0.9054554104804993,
0.21792761981487274,
0.9669837951660156,
0.32551509141921997,
0.6640499830245972,
0.15802133083343506,
-0.2688179612159729,
-0.7459637522697449,
0.4266841411590576,
-0.6375318169593811,
0.3270350992679596,
-0.1998426765203476,
-0.8076298236846924,
0.05800861492753029,
0.8586370944976807,
-0.2509801983833313,
0.001532051945105195,
0.9757402539253235,
0.6696600317955017,
-0.05303839221596718,
0.2526959776878357,
0.45310062170028687,
0.4744342863559723,
0.1925194412469864,
0.5705377459526062,
1.0652087926864624,
-0.1268710494041443,
0.3954618573188782,
0.3475795388221741,
0.071291483938694,
-0.02772764302790165,
-1.152133584022522,
-0.6136891841888428,
-0.30396321415901184,
-0.4917760193347931,
-0.6595383286476135,
0.06731624901294708,
0.7368685603141785,
0.399638295173645,
-0.5803864598274231,
-0.25828513503074646,
-0.3591826856136322,
0.5079253911972046,
-0.24200701713562012,
-0.18448305130004883,
0.30132487416267395,
-0.31734707951545715,
-0.4645572304725647,
0.07948324829339981,
0.7157476544380188,
-0.03086405247449875,
-0.20081879198551178,
-0.18380112946033478,
0.09673263877630234,
0.5794328451156616,
0.4416573643684387,
-0.027908096089959145,
-1.1190063953399658,
-0.958081841468811,
-0.2118067592382431,
-0.5116260647773743,
0.31072571873664856,
0.8451079726219177,
0.048267167061567307,
0.3986470103263855,
0.5162473917007446,
0.558422863483429,
0.07149258255958557,
0.0833107978105545,
0.4207991063594818,
-0.3298746943473816,
-0.3286122977733612,
0.25697582960128784,
0.5608587861061096,
0.44004154205322266,
-0.4526063799858093,
0.5432649850845337,
0.21744899451732635,
-0.7192569375038147,
-0.4741586148738861,
0.6946697235107422,
-1.16072678565979,
-0.10106644034385681,
1.263391137123108,
-0.3913460671901703,
-0.11387008428573608,
-0.16123734414577484,
0.18194451928138733,
-0.03937049210071564,
-0.41325363516807556,
0.6499887704849243,
1.2215168476104736,
-0.13554224371910095,
0.20451782643795013,
-0.5821506381034851,
0.3210960626602173,
0.31119289994239807,
-0.5434320569038391,
0.37997350096702576,
0.6312315464019775,
0.5805811285972595,
0.2288985401391983,
0.616282045841217,
-0.009352250024676323,
0.04209239408373833,
0.02486947551369667,
-0.3071775734424591,
0.21693487465381622,
-0.1386912763118744,
-0.028454557061195374,
0.07770893722772598,
-0.032507747411727905,
0.4067051410675049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15024v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15024v2 | SliceGPT: Compress Large Language Models by Deleting Rows and Columns | 2024-01-26T17:35:45 | 2024-02-09T17:59:40 | Saleh Ashkboos, Maximilian L. Croci, Marcelo Gennari do Nascimento, Torsten Hoefler, James Hensman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models have become the cornerstone of natural language
processing, but their use comes with substantial costs in terms of compute and
memory resources. Sparsification provides a solution to alleviate these
resource constraints, and recent works have shown that trained models can be
sparsified post-hoc. Existing sparsification techniques face challenges as they
need additional data structures and offer constrained speedup with current
hardware. In this paper we present SliceGPT, a new post-training sparsification
scheme which replaces each weight matrix with a smaller (dense) matrix,
reducing the embedding dimension of the network. Through extensive
experimentation, we show that SliceGPT can remove up to 25% of the model
parameters (including embeddings) for LLAMA2-70B, OPT 66B and Phi-2 models
while maintaining 99%, 99% and 90% zero-shot task performance of the dense
model respectively. Our sliced models run on fewer GPUs and run faster without
any additional code optimization: on 24GB consumer GPUs we reduce the total
compute for inference on LLAMA2-70B to 64% of that of the dense model; on 40GB
A100 GPUs we reduce it to 66%. We offer a new insight, computational invariance
in transformer networks, which enables SliceGPT and we hope it will inspire and
enable future avenues to reduce memory and computation demands for pre-trained
models. Code is available at:
https://github.com/microsoft/TransformerCompression | [
-0.6365782022476196,
-0.8301113247871399,
0.2580455243587494,
0.08833754807710648,
-0.4032643139362335,
0.004767607431858778,
-0.15023279190063477,
-0.21375486254692078,
0.2698155343532562,
0.7240105271339417,
-0.38639354705810547,
-0.01469920389354229,
-0.7043696641921997,
-0.20124788582324982,
-0.6704866290092468,
1.0382204055786133,
-0.08508799970149994,
-0.12759016454219818,
-0.10913535207509995,
0.08311079442501068,
-0.24224911630153656,
-0.3787780702114105,
-0.7098178863525391,
-0.4886186718940735,
0.27410250902175903,
0.1690773218870163,
0.7444339394569397,
0.7727819085121155,
0.6183068752288818,
0.31506621837615967,
-0.510615885257721,
0.10978127270936966,
-0.7393226027488708,
0.00948320608586073,
0.16571000218391418,
-0.12767300009727478,
-0.3430611491203308,
-0.013248608447611332,
0.8392904996871948,
0.8025754690170288,
-0.29229825735092163,
0.05420200526714325,
0.05028388276696205,
0.5359740853309631,
-0.5538397431373596,
-0.01436931174248457,
-0.6191566586494446,
0.19628143310546875,
0.0698682889342308,
0.009487519972026348,
-0.43077942728996277,
-0.5478654503822327,
-0.16261416673660278,
-0.46083298325538635,
0.461833655834198,
-0.1498027890920639,
0.8915255665779114,
0.41111114621162415,
-0.27678829431533813,
0.2795935869216919,
-0.8979902863502502,
0.5227176547050476,
-0.5144910216331482,
0.405890554189682,
0.14239200949668884,
0.29347237944602966,
0.0026193438097834587,
-0.7786593437194824,
-0.32382604479789734,
0.053452856838703156,
-0.09057099372148514,
-0.13329878449440002,
-0.6244810819625854,
0.04961510747671127,
0.441155344247818,
0.5076128244400024,
-0.7956004738807678,
-0.05639863759279251,
-0.6768782734870911,
-0.11335409432649612,
0.3110628128051758,
-0.07638317346572876,
0.22164079546928406,
0.18503834307193756,
-0.3593120872974396,
-0.05148446187376976,
-1.1633418798446655,
-0.4217507839202881,
0.33669301867485046,
0.23252642154693604,
0.0970715656876564,
0.5500226020812988,
-0.09122295677661896,
0.6253007650375366,
0.08962268382310867,
0.1554875671863556,
0.2029666304588318,
0.1138165220618248,
-0.6057295203208923,
0.05053414776921272,
0.610720694065094,
0.027098920196294785,
0.14356547594070435,
-0.2673986852169037,
-0.3062865436077118,
0.1719314157962799,
0.3779078423976898,
-1.119761347770691,
-0.5618449449539185,
-0.0951312854886055,
-0.49965134263038635,
-0.16929730772972107,
-0.21504467725753784,
-0.5695217251777649,
-0.3672671914100647,
-0.2450600415468216,
0.3549253046512604,
-0.46045807003974915,
-0.4487393796443939,
0.3275441825389862,
0.004651594441384077,
0.3065376281738281,
0.4104631841182709,
-0.6776275634765625,
0.6885671019554138,
0.8735636472702026,
0.8498114347457886,
0.059892818331718445,
-0.246077299118042,
-0.8365991711616516,
0.034570902585983276,
-0.14615656435489655,
0.7704782485961914,
-0.5248618125915527,
-0.3194960951805115,
-0.21988356113433838,
-0.23724931478500366,
-0.13957788050174713,
-0.7514470219612122,
0.4574156105518341,
-0.6024287939071655,
0.06282536685466766,
-0.20344513654708862,
-0.580776035785675,
-0.1296238750219345,
0.4180712103843689,
-0.8440226316452026,
1.0177863836288452,
0.08502573519945145,
-0.6766793131828308,
0.061436112970113754,
-0.4400852620601654,
-0.6846911907196045,
0.012523697689175606,
0.23540939390659332,
-0.6451786756515503,
0.26499685645103455,
0.40365973114967346,
0.3430614471435547,
-0.4224192798137665,
0.2652212083339691,
-0.2234712690114975,
-0.5392577648162842,
0.038066182285547256,
-0.3661474287509918,
0.5018324851989746,
0.3119778037071228,
-0.22967445850372314,
-0.08883461356163025,
-0.5704306364059448,
-0.06333755701780319,
0.07921212166547775,
-0.4347676634788513,
0.00843447633087635,
-0.13594718277454376,
0.28495797514915466,
0.1611299365758896,
-0.20244836807250977,
-0.5380129218101501,
0.3877585530281067,
-0.5411950945854187,
0.7811033725738525,
0.37641313672065735,
-0.1495388150215149,
0.6597592234611511,
-0.08596153557300568,
0.548265814781189,
-0.014946622774004936,
0.2972380220890045,
-0.025615502148866653,
-0.22924590110778809,
-0.8629996180534363,
-0.5011769533157349,
0.22642673552036285,
0.36069658398628235,
-0.8164241909980774,
0.42054978013038635,
-0.70345538854599,
-0.4785464107990265,
-0.1934046447277069,
-0.0962858572602272,
0.3939993977546692,
0.3609198331832886,
0.6387448310852051,
-0.2209199219942093,
-0.7104104161262512,
-0.8999881148338318,
-0.26507604122161865,
0.23648855090141296,
-0.1488429605960846,
-0.055425018072128296,
0.44874078035354614,
-0.18201054632663727,
0.8795410394668579,
-0.6563478708267212,
-0.13418173789978027,
-0.49482017755508423,
0.04149473085999489,
0.13384273648262024,
0.5490280985832214,
0.2077265977859497,
-0.6971941590309143,
-0.360561728477478,
-0.02579154074192047,
-0.09244003146886826,
-0.01685516908764839,
0.11976110190153122,
0.08902738243341446,
-0.19546067714691162,
0.4676266312599182,
-0.9964441061019897,
0.46472206711769104,
0.48026660084724426,
-0.09729008376598358,
0.35669270157814026,
-0.1587274968624115,
-0.11703255772590637,
-0.9904564619064331,
0.014111265540122986,
0.11375702917575836,
-0.4707320034503937,
-0.7417262196540833,
-0.19018153846263885,
-0.013579669408500195,
-0.4078510105609894,
-0.47049397230148315,
0.43253085017204285,
-0.5616273283958435,
-0.08187206089496613,
-0.21895767748355865,
-0.043855637311935425,
0.2075594961643219,
0.4406549334526062,
0.07347076386213303,
0.7291269302368164,
0.3325493037700653,
-0.45785266160964966,
-0.04392755776643753,
0.33709096908569336,
-0.32543691992759705,
0.1979958713054657,
-0.8566516637802124,
0.06811181455850601,
-0.09654199331998825,
0.5291407108306885,
-0.7640259861946106,
0.031457919627428055,
0.2744961082935333,
-0.0853274017572403,
0.2525606155395508,
-0.49864664673805237,
-0.3717261850833893,
-0.08289399743080139,
-0.06343899667263031,
0.6191641688346863,
0.6631292700767517,
-0.6272779703140259,
0.6767102479934692,
0.5856092572212219,
0.03422040492296219,
-0.39547720551490784,
-0.7852552533149719,
0.0811215490102768,
-0.22069549560546875,
-0.3564755916595459,
0.5065153241157532,
0.17092034220695496,
0.042346641421318054,
-0.026446130126714706,
-0.07310653477907181,
-0.2622958719730377,
-0.10909685492515564,
0.17186890542507172,
0.08865873515605927,
-0.09433113038539886,
0.02957061119377613,
0.11055657267570496,
-0.21658602356910706,
-0.19644317030906677,
-0.31934449076652527,
0.9062501192092896,
-0.03352115675806999,
-0.4368961453437805,
-0.16399520635604858,
0.3512962758541107,
0.40947166085243225,
-0.35573217272758484,
0.6969863772392273,
0.8714818954467773,
-0.34813591837882996,
-0.2678849697113037,
-0.8363942503929138,
-0.13885049521923065,
-0.4499710500240326,
0.4935888350009918,
-0.19675709307193756,
-1.2665009498596191,
0.3829783499240875,
-0.2779369652271271,
-0.23592965304851532,
0.33958402276039124,
0.36581093072891235,
0.25622135400772095,
0.7612210512161255,
0.48786240816116333,
-0.4011712074279785,
0.6111950278282166,
-0.45220276713371277,
0.6073647141456604,
-0.8034789562225342,
0.11181886494159698,
-0.6580429077148438,
-0.290854811668396,
-0.27460479736328125,
-0.7898465394973755,
0.4818025529384613,
0.006993500981479883,
-0.3987565338611603,
0.4641534686088562,
-0.6068684458732605,
0.913434624671936,
0.25369560718536377,
0.2947433888912201,
-0.12196675688028336,
0.15697549283504486,
0.29582852125167847,
0.2571524679660797,
-0.6977003216743469,
-0.10828086733818054,
0.7397942543029785,
0.34352657198905945,
0.6011326909065247,
-0.11213570088148117,
0.6045843958854675,
0.1572239100933075,
0.34550824761390686,
-0.6914893984794617,
0.5236013531684875,
-0.1993342638015747,
-0.29389649629592896,
-0.29692935943603516,
-0.8423813581466675,
-0.8055736422538757,
0.3084458112716675,
-0.10977593809366226,
-0.5981061458587646,
-0.0885666087269783,
0.26464131474494934,
-0.25737887620925903,
0.7071352005004883,
-0.6660404205322266,
0.6530373096466064,
0.2982979416847229,
-0.3219047784805298,
-0.27736470103263855,
-0.44641655683517456,
0.2926431894302368,
0.33445605635643005,
0.03614593669772148,
0.005593361333012581,
0.2545433044433594,
0.7357853651046753,
-0.8087814450263977,
0.909547746181488,
-0.3536800742149353,
0.21807138621807098,
0.31790971755981445,
0.35257038474082947,
0.8965785503387451,
-0.18937653303146362,
0.08371072262525558,
0.07753997296094894,
-0.09294689446687698,
-0.3148753345012665,
-0.6624886393547058,
0.4340037703514099,
-0.6630253791809082,
-0.29920926690101624,
0.04478031024336815,
-0.3860761523246765,
-0.10620684176683426,
0.12899556756019592,
0.15790219604969025,
0.6301568746566772,
-0.4095020294189453,
0.24831745028495789,
0.7879100441932678,
-0.20657682418823242,
0.3267543315887451,
-0.1123303771018982,
-0.2215167135000229,
-0.6189743280410767,
0.7900626063346863,
0.03497443348169327,
-0.02125168964266777,
0.5012027621269226,
0.1864965409040451,
-0.26133936643600464,
-0.7389344573020935,
-0.31092140078544617,
0.3684445917606354,
-0.55799400806427,
-0.5415723919868469,
-0.5838319063186646,
-0.4103284478187561,
-0.4199928045272827,
-0.22843420505523682,
-0.8264548182487488,
-0.5988762378692627,
-0.16595619916915894,
-0.1500939577817917,
0.1335689127445221,
0.7088644504547119,
0.08632035553455353,
0.8681976795196533,
-0.9049268364906311,
0.08870400488376617,
0.2349252551794052,
0.37943029403686523,
-0.12546361982822418,
-0.5959673523902893,
-0.37437355518341064,
-0.17105773091316223,
-0.20479385554790497,
-0.5175693035125732,
0.765605092048645,
0.1429908722639084,
0.29286810755729675,
0.36080244183540344,
-0.247198686003685,
0.8436383605003357,
-0.520787239074707,
0.6709317564964294,
0.39674699306488037,
-1.3823528289794922,
0.10583516955375671,
-0.12966597080230713,
0.35375335812568665,
0.40449005365371704,
0.14672788977622986,
-0.7405889630317688,
0.12289296090602875,
-0.4722370207309723,
-0.8579140901565552,
0.5078746676445007,
0.14813876152038574,
0.10120748728513718,
0.11549531668424606,
0.5201241374015808,
0.09251813590526581,
0.09749186038970947,
-0.7545347809791565,
0.04009474441409111,
-0.04972660169005394,
-0.05208636820316315,
-0.16869652271270752,
-0.6562305688858032,
-0.11148906499147415,
-0.3236108124256134,
0.755575954914093,
0.07090044766664505,
0.3803684711456299,
0.009101721458137035,
-0.3908906579017639,
0.11398730427026749,
0.1698942929506302,
0.4747624695301056,
0.3892718255519867,
0.12381073832511902,
0.4315129518508911,
0.2070351392030716,
-0.5518140196800232,
0.2283167541027069,
0.07257920503616333,
-0.28681230545043945,
-0.1581544429063797,
0.32986903190612793,
1.022955060005188,
0.3885478377342224,
-0.22124485671520233,
0.5781021118164062,
-0.11784843355417252,
-0.4264810085296631,
0.053606703877449036,
-0.05736769363284111,
0.02976449392735958,
0.22256717085838318,
-0.07026973366737366,
0.33823779225349426,
0.317695677280426,
0.09830241650342941,
0.06458790600299835,
0.42527639865875244,
-0.4300253391265869,
-0.4941490590572357,
0.3904537558555603,
-0.021209727972745895,
-0.26550233364105225,
0.8113799691200256,
-0.11827510595321655,
-0.7191087603569031,
0.34059345722198486,
0.4393550455570221,
0.9993534088134766,
-0.30258581042289734,
0.4502435624599457,
0.33596271276474,
0.5017929077148438,
-0.40268224477767944,
-0.21092075109481812,
-0.20629194378852844,
-0.8732180595397949,
-0.6973578333854675,
-0.6948610544204712,
-0.2767172157764435,
0.09449151158332825,
-0.4466209411621094,
0.07989441603422165,
-0.3911149501800537,
-0.048685673624277115,
-0.17740510404109955,
-0.18892359733581543,
-0.6405743956565857,
0.15277446806430817,
0.22618457674980164,
0.8136354088783264,
-1.1342610120773315,
1.0594381093978882,
0.5059759616851807,
-0.032509174197912216,
-0.9803498387336731,
-0.287028968334198,
-0.2567477822303772,
-0.34205418825149536,
0.5007325410842896,
0.1973010152578354,
-0.1800364851951599,
-0.1287129521369934,
-0.3572371006011963,
-0.9102799892425537,
0.6047638654708862,
0.7898005247116089,
-0.2858094274997711,
-0.013592635281383991,
0.47740262746810913,
0.3507086932659149,
-0.0998256728053093,
0.5137227177619934,
0.7326435446739197,
0.5153229236602783,
0.2960949242115021,
-0.7974385023117065,
-0.006145191378891468,
-0.4148734211921692,
0.2044912874698639,
0.4645061492919922,
-0.40603721141815186,
1.0660604238510132,
0.2145763486623764,
-0.08642303943634033,
-0.3758670389652252,
0.4064318537712097,
-0.06681972742080688,
-0.16456526517868042,
0.6680163741111755,
0.8101232647895813,
0.6582203507423401,
-0.16820888221263885,
0.6313409209251404,
-0.10679294914007187,
0.6229802966117859,
0.923295795917511,
-0.48546743392944336,
0.6609277725219727,
0.7380828857421875,
-0.3139357268810272,
0.030029617249965668,
0.48883551359176636,
0.16320671141147614,
0.5241506099700928,
0.3978915512561798,
-0.28386420011520386,
-0.36766302585601807,
0.2439957559108734,
-0.28408142924308777,
0.5352396965026855,
0.06069241836667061,
-0.24947047233581543,
-0.3974360227584839,
0.15213218331336975,
0.3153516948223114,
-0.24284185469150543,
-0.22419080138206482,
0.6736696362495422,
-0.13333149254322052,
-0.5490554571151733,
0.672255277633667,
0.00653820438310504,
0.49309051036834717,
-0.5912976264953613,
0.056761354207992554,
-0.3492773175239563,
0.3948114216327667,
-0.10472538322210312,
-0.2836962938308716,
0.7975256443023682,
-0.09753312170505524,
-0.17574217915534973,
-0.6133060455322266,
0.789487898349762,
-0.42344754934310913,
-0.5186949968338013,
0.18073780834674835,
0.5041292309761047,
0.18549738824367523,
-0.561866819858551,
-0.47040852904319763,
0.4777023494243622,
0.10064145177602768,
-0.7446026802062988,
0.38313761353492737,
0.20942111313343048,
0.18826571106910706,
0.7229841351509094,
0.549021303653717,
0.3128015995025635,
0.09542595595121384,
-0.005354697350412607,
1.4068726301193237,
-0.28464266657829285,
-0.4654111862182617,
-0.8514934182167053,
0.3648312985897064,
-0.06919308751821518,
0.01690581813454628,
0.41873541474342346,
0.9681863188743591,
0.7014840245246887,
-0.1806648075580597,
0.6212708353996277,
0.042137157171964645,
0.41186606884002686,
-0.5263656973838806,
0.7625232934951782,
-0.3805645704269409,
0.2469053417444229,
-0.260442316532135,
-0.9710829854011536,
-0.6551241278648376,
0.5701202750205994,
-0.64764004945755,
0.07294298708438873,
0.5646082162857056,
0.9862474203109741,
-0.5092161893844604,
0.13464142382144928,
0.44144585728645325,
0.024173391982913017,
0.5754135847091675,
0.38270246982574463,
0.6608994007110596,
-0.48810431361198425,
0.6666111350059509,
-0.4272811710834503,
-0.032678887248039246,
-0.141816645860672,
-0.7684125900268555,
-0.8091092705726624,
-0.5470588803291321,
-0.49681246280670166,
-0.20634274184703827,
-0.05625559762120247,
0.7947241067886353,
0.978672981262207,
-0.5767328143119812,
-0.260427325963974,
-0.2161305695772171,
0.04345867782831192,
-0.257262259721756,
-0.17037411034107208,
0.5040974020957947,
-0.09219157695770264,
-0.39496445655822754,
0.4653348922729492,
0.3833467364311218,
-0.20896953344345093,
-0.05339662730693817,
0.1113477498292923,
-0.031855616718530655,
-0.03942453861236572,
0.6882635354995728,
0.097493976354599,
-0.3408374488353729,
-0.3214189112186432,
-0.3120672404766083,
0.11716003715991974,
0.4055972397327423,
1.2057963609695435,
-0.8020808100700378,
-0.11303650587797165,
0.5114839673042297,
0.6985907554626465,
1.112732172012329,
0.00805642455816269,
0.31966739892959595,
-0.7343981266021729,
0.4442199766635895,
0.3935624659061432,
0.4893508553504944,
0.4043607711791992,
-0.2582971751689911,
0.36805692315101624,
0.1464202105998993,
-0.604688286781311,
-0.8946531414985657,
0.22279292345046997,
-0.8570894598960876,
-0.16854849457740784,
0.9883785247802734,
-0.11426115781068802,
-0.46600019931793213,
0.08862076699733734,
-0.20921097695827484,
0.4167255461215973,
-0.1341635137796402,
0.6149204969406128,
0.22455543279647827,
0.1264784336090088,
-0.5481182336807251,
-0.13940219581127167,
0.4697365164756775,
0.38955941796302795,
-0.9561264514923096,
0.3819986879825592,
0.5432991981506348,
0.3298473358154297,
-0.1803908348083496,
0.5743377208709717,
-0.018188435584306717,
-0.1699298918247223,
0.15190275013446808,
0.5449349284172058,
-0.27395644783973694,
-0.3386443257331848,
-0.43837833404541016,
0.5589932799339294,
-0.26009559631347656,
-0.08808045834302902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15006v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15006v2 | Airavata: Introducing Hindi Instruction-tuned LLM | 2024-01-26T17:07:08 | 2024-02-26T12:17:25 | Jay Gala, Thanmay Jayakumar, Jaavid Aktar Husain, Aswanth Kumar M, Mohammed Safi Ur Rahman Khan, Diptesh Kanojia, Ratish Puduppully, Mitesh M. Khapra, Raj Dabre, Rudra Murthy, Anoop Kunchukuttan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We announce the initial release of "Airavata," an instruction-tuned LLM for
Hindi. Airavata was created by fine-tuning OpenHathi with diverse,
instruction-tuning Hindi datasets to make it better suited for assistive tasks.
Along with the model, we also share the IndicInstruct dataset, which is a
collection of diverse instruction-tuning datasets to enable further research
for Indic LLMs. Additionally, we present evaluation benchmarks and a framework
for assessing LLM performance across tasks in Hindi. Currently, Airavata
supports Hindi, but we plan to expand this to all 22 scheduled Indic languages.
You can access all artifacts at https://ai4bharat.github.io/airavata. | [
-0.14525234699249268,
-0.8831901550292969,
-0.13079267740249634,
0.45781439542770386,
-0.275405615568161,
0.3205282390117645,
-0.34880882501602173,
-0.31057828664779663,
0.441700279712677,
0.2936919033527374,
-0.6159898042678833,
-0.3620530664920807,
-0.5124835968017578,
-0.039776433259248734,
-0.5063165426254272,
0.866665244102478,
-0.4120081067085266,
0.18267102539539337,
0.02063637599349022,
-0.13252942264080048,
-0.9217316508293152,
-0.022156473249197006,
-0.2741760015487671,
-0.18133410811424255,
0.25662434101104736,
1.10395348072052,
0.5571612119674683,
0.6746272444725037,
0.6899978518486023,
0.2134591042995453,
0.17437759041786194,
0.35373982787132263,
-0.2356891930103302,
0.21426808834075928,
0.29899629950523376,
-0.6395832896232605,
-0.3367287814617157,
-0.14336223900318146,
0.7649155259132385,
0.31350621581077576,
-0.628523588180542,
0.28551825881004333,
-0.11534348875284195,
0.8644554615020752,
-0.7403523921966553,
0.2220114767551422,
-0.5286304950714111,
0.04516272619366646,
-0.5366397500038147,
-0.4283531904220581,
-0.21431809663772583,
-0.7947131991386414,
-0.5524991154670715,
-0.7403557300567627,
-0.24961580336093903,
0.17801134288311005,
1.011101484298706,
0.6194252371788025,
-0.12157823890447617,
-0.3704340159893036,
-0.8189618587493896,
0.4673708975315094,
-0.2997560203075409,
0.5159585475921631,
0.43233415484428406,
0.8189928531646729,
-0.0005435378407128155,
-0.3834628164768219,
-0.3892870247364044,
0.1358383744955063,
0.29852938652038574,
0.18631690740585327,
-0.22112582623958588,
-0.0905335322022438,
-0.22451616823673248,
0.650101900100708,
-0.5355730056762695,
0.09824135154485703,
-0.5875266194343567,
0.14041781425476074,
0.3134688436985016,
0.324363112449646,
0.6392753720283508,
0.18295252323150635,
-0.32367727160453796,
0.0972040668129921,
-0.937463641166687,
-0.20010298490524292,
0.6765471696853638,
0.36819368600845337,
-0.3344866931438446,
0.878533661365509,
-0.2967489957809448,
0.9496355652809143,
0.12110969424247742,
0.02008793316781521,
0.13622181117534637,
-0.18299587070941925,
-0.46393707394599915,
0.4847334027290344,
0.21117551624774933,
0.02480747178196907,
0.22800478339195251,
0.021037742495536804,
-0.13292071223258972,
0.05929938703775406,
0.29378271102905273,
-0.4941595792770386,
-0.2599679231643677,
-0.23741470277309418,
-0.10380662232637405,
-0.1484365165233612,
-0.32062986493110657,
-0.8440842628479004,
-0.5203534960746765,
-0.42600592970848083,
0.35316869616508484,
-0.6085721850395203,
-0.5296961665153503,
0.0009333057096228004,
0.29476508498191833,
0.9937975406646729,
0.5349401235580444,
-1.1903756856918335,
0.5162022113800049,
0.6564981937408447,
0.8038756847381592,
-0.15415579080581665,
-0.3373558521270752,
-0.4113430380821228,
0.13730524480342865,
-0.6128026843070984,
1.373871088027954,
-0.959529459476471,
-0.28481730818748474,
-0.07415959239006042,
-0.17598845064640045,
-0.11812235414981842,
-0.6259585022926331,
0.3555033802986145,
-0.43135035037994385,
-0.15820404887199402,
-0.2828599512577057,
-0.4099171757698059,
-0.21479278802871704,
0.05846310034394264,
-0.4045504629611969,
1.1084946393966675,
0.32577788829803467,
-0.45955243706703186,
0.5234521627426147,
-0.8757182359695435,
-0.4233781695365906,
0.2826419770717621,
-0.32352495193481445,
-0.09403477609157562,
0.061568111181259155,
0.2152974158525467,
-0.04980676993727684,
-0.5596929788589478,
-0.015547195449471474,
0.11314842849969864,
-0.603825569152832,
-0.25012508034706116,
-0.23048606514930725,
0.7348410487174988,
0.685597836971283,
-0.05837925523519516,
0.24785375595092773,
-0.6156806945800781,
0.06185531243681908,
-0.10949467867612839,
-0.4558512568473816,
-0.05859323590993881,
-0.1748548448085785,
-0.015311100520193577,
-0.2680799663066864,
0.31805017590522766,
-0.517036497592926,
0.39476627111434937,
-0.527094841003418,
0.08538215607404709,
0.992161214351654,
-0.022089095786213875,
0.19198191165924072,
-0.14973901212215424,
1.016427755355835,
-0.01790294237434864,
0.38089174032211304,
-0.009515020996332169,
-0.5260624289512634,
-0.8839203715324402,
-0.13512328267097473,
0.09858912974596024,
0.8027687668800354,
-0.41624540090560913,
0.03634628653526306,
-0.10332468897104263,
-0.6176187992095947,
-0.9742826819419861,
0.46390679478645325,
0.6385887265205383,
0.3023281693458557,
0.21152541041374207,
-0.02074791118502617,
-0.6340703964233398,
-0.8512214422225952,
-0.39205971360206604,
-0.10386904329061508,
0.5853264331817627,
0.040241267532110214,
0.1467619389295578,
-0.08268936723470688,
0.7236159443855286,
-0.7061101794242859,
-0.33803021907806396,
-0.4146725535392761,
-0.12896743416786194,
-0.0031686131842434406,
0.4149622917175293,
0.3002670705318451,
-0.4859808385372162,
-0.8135659098625183,
0.2080339640378952,
-0.7698146104812622,
-0.22493195533752441,
0.5064200758934021,
-0.4113130569458008,
0.30635660886764526,
0.3779875934123993,
-0.5533379912376404,
0.6266636252403259,
0.5724615454673767,
-0.33481043577194214,
0.21977688372135162,
-0.025143088772892952,
0.36753177642822266,
-1.3666967153549194,
-0.26238366961479187,
-0.44136321544647217,
0.07642248272895813,
-0.3549390435218811,
0.22159676253795624,
-0.005365610588341951,
-0.24531400203704834,
-0.6143397688865662,
0.5930495858192444,
-0.5575933456420898,
-0.17717008292675018,
-0.29282522201538086,
-0.16657662391662598,
-0.26339179277420044,
0.3528914451599121,
-0.38956883549690247,
1.1589629650115967,
0.632924497127533,
-0.581809937953949,
0.35099297761917114,
0.4075835943222046,
-0.3946792185306549,
0.6158492565155029,
-0.5445939898490906,
-0.018938327208161354,
0.017052678391337395,
-0.10155471414327621,
-0.9929139018058777,
-0.8787292242050171,
0.39892908930778503,
-0.653666615486145,
0.537880003452301,
-0.041152793914079666,
-0.637260377407074,
0.05135676637291908,
-0.06935107707977295,
0.33376845717430115,
0.7023745179176331,
-0.6923171877861023,
0.592302680015564,
0.7514156103134155,
0.10430169850587845,
-0.44745397567749023,
-0.8413902521133423,
-0.13138428330421448,
-0.30730363726615906,
-0.30962643027305603,
-0.2948853373527527,
-0.2232339233160019,
-0.44184014201164246,
0.05459504947066307,
-0.27695849537849426,
-0.47972217202186584,
0.037941768765449524,
0.48673319816589355,
0.11606080830097198,
-0.05608956515789032,
0.18381574749946594,
0.3854111135005951,
0.08392221480607986,
-0.30457252264022827,
0.14933057129383087,
0.5130677223205566,
-0.44406071305274963,
-0.4707772135734558,
-0.38761985301971436,
0.012047029100358486,
0.08380071818828583,
-0.22960396111011505,
0.3541273772716522,
0.5502176880836487,
-0.4651062786579132,
0.10575708001852036,
-0.611850917339325,
0.16118976473808289,
-0.5351184010505676,
-0.01670525036752224,
-0.3678576946258545,
-0.5124765634536743,
0.3617807626724243,
-0.14876015484333038,
-0.0035586864687502384,
0.37478315830230713,
0.687407910823822,
0.1482713371515274,
0.7962310314178467,
0.6106052994728088,
-0.0860375240445137,
0.3317350149154663,
-0.012574804946780205,
0.03157604858279228,
-0.9825894832611084,
-0.51305091381073,
-0.5474486351013184,
-0.14027100801467896,
-0.5659089088439941,
-0.2828611433506012,
0.23897257447242737,
0.11163684725761414,
-0.30894559621810913,
0.2510889768600464,
-0.9985037446022034,
0.7807238101959229,
0.28767526149749756,
-0.00923392828553915,
0.28673839569091797,
0.019535230472683907,
-0.15182243287563324,
0.04209823161363602,
-0.42211171984672546,
-0.27114686369895935,
0.9685032367706299,
0.000820201588794589,
1.2148042917251587,
0.3937394618988037,
0.7312240600585938,
0.11117146909236908,
0.3156336843967438,
-0.5891526341438293,
0.4541359543800354,
0.0022737139370292425,
-0.8308804631233215,
-0.05758138373494148,
0.003092072671279311,
-1.1151392459869385,
-0.16527476906776428,
0.2480773776769638,
-0.49435803294181824,
-0.221695676445961,
0.1489366888999939,
-0.07254608720541,
0.2423441857099533,
-1.0475363731384277,
0.5345451235771179,
-0.35424721240997314,
-0.10156318545341492,
-0.16980481147766113,
-0.4783863127231598,
0.7154524922370911,
0.07382875680923462,
0.01700892299413681,
-0.4795628488063812,
-0.27188852429389954,
0.6929588317871094,
-0.48025134205818176,
0.8374273777008057,
-0.49564123153686523,
-0.03518621250987053,
0.47345247864723206,
0.006112860981374979,
-0.0023884973488748074,
0.24996893107891083,
0.03942326083779335,
0.10857080668210983,
-0.13754694163799286,
-0.449786514043808,
-0.5160453915596008,
1.0235670804977417,
-1.1192375421524048,
-0.5239673852920532,
-0.5518335103988647,
-0.31088870763778687,
-0.265301376581192,
0.3603537380695343,
0.15224839746952057,
0.26922839879989624,
0.02910197339951992,
-0.050166256725788116,
0.7309802770614624,
-0.2917349934577942,
0.3800632357597351,
0.8330075740814209,
-0.42162835597991943,
-0.4528838098049164,
0.9504971504211426,
0.13805299997329712,
-0.1095263659954071,
0.5518190860748291,
0.23650608956813812,
-0.15464255213737488,
-0.44159138202667236,
-0.7019900679588318,
-0.1973690390586853,
-0.9041823744773865,
-0.42698347568511963,
-0.3416159749031067,
-0.30832675099372864,
-0.31861984729766846,
-0.04158932715654373,
-0.5672362446784973,
-0.5533483624458313,
-0.3026176989078522,
-0.24494993686676025,
1.1351490020751953,
1.2110836505889893,
-0.07694876939058304,
0.2545599937438965,
-0.4238722324371338,
0.40501174330711365,
0.2170136272907257,
0.747645378112793,
-0.3390847444534302,
-0.46729257702827454,
-0.4266677498817444,
-0.11868095397949219,
-0.4077734053134918,
-0.6439859867095947,
0.28478145599365234,
0.5108882784843445,
0.6551441550254822,
-0.011292222887277603,
-0.2729608714580536,
1.066591501235962,
-0.5401870012283325,
0.7962789535522461,
-0.10940580070018768,
-0.7571682929992676,
1.192564845085144,
-0.370282381772995,
0.6257761716842651,
0.8062080144882202,
0.2217370569705963,
0.00040747251478023827,
-0.3785596191883087,
-0.13705268502235413,
-0.8172550797462463,
0.7572850584983826,
0.1993342787027359,
0.15257209539413452,
-0.16008031368255615,
0.33188194036483765,
0.5216596126556396,
0.23777443170547485,
-0.23219870030879974,
-0.36928847432136536,
-0.4742056429386139,
-0.21122567355632782,
0.22182980179786682,
-0.03206930682063103,
0.021323617547750473,
-0.7125462889671326,
0.551863968372345,
0.06482912600040436,
0.5107614994049072,
-0.060382429510354996,
-0.16448593139648438,
-0.44845137000083923,
0.1918228417634964,
0.7558085918426514,
0.6843107342720032,
-0.2027297466993332,
-0.23889826238155365,
0.1898583471775055,
-0.8588771224021912,
0.3086622953414917,
-0.024518735706806183,
0.022759782150387764,
-0.15859517455101013,
0.09738549590110779,
0.9787636399269104,
0.434833288192749,
-0.6995028257369995,
0.11140482872724533,
-0.17336998879909515,
0.17652861773967743,
-0.8266516923904419,
0.4230130612850189,
-0.10282564908266068,
-0.02823212742805481,
0.34877023100852966,
-0.09993106871843338,
0.15177449584007263,
-0.3255069851875305,
0.18413276970386505,
0.18828421831130981,
-0.4418379068374634,
-0.35169708728790283,
0.8430663347244263,
0.20294184982776642,
-0.3427962064743042,
0.6769654750823975,
-0.09222451597452164,
0.06191347539424896,
0.5249819159507751,
0.5102851986885071,
1.170089840888977,
-0.5668368339538574,
-0.08721056580543518,
0.22855451703071594,
0.5096487998962402,
0.1474037915468216,
0.8654831051826477,
-0.02793424017727375,
-0.37188786268234253,
-0.4428238272666931,
-0.9598966240882874,
-0.6936132907867432,
-0.26852867007255554,
-0.8223448991775513,
0.5705428123474121,
-0.41627970337867737,
0.31418320536613464,
-0.3147149384021759,
0.011066293343901634,
-0.6788000464439392,
0.1600915491580963,
-0.19644629955291748,
1.17626953125,
-0.6852202415466309,
1.2362220287322998,
0.8387233018875122,
-0.6580199599266052,
-1.1083623170852661,
0.05884243920445442,
0.13261890411376953,
-1.3769017457962036,
0.7038113474845886,
0.03909706696867943,
-0.3149140775203705,
0.2434660792350769,
-0.5653945803642273,
-1.0774695873260498,
1.2555739879608154,
0.4451271891593933,
-0.2986966371536255,
0.10901080816984177,
0.1492667943239212,
0.3981000781059265,
-0.3550882637500763,
0.31266993284225464,
0.6256894469261169,
0.7571291923522949,
-0.047873519361019135,
-0.7985944151878357,
-0.2772245705127716,
-0.655990481376648,
-0.0072134630754590034,
0.542997419834137,
-1.0544511079788208,
0.7508662343025208,
-0.06498927623033524,
-0.1782478541135788,
0.05532719939947128,
0.6328343152999878,
0.142568439245224,
0.10041220486164093,
0.21853311359882355,
0.8290749192237854,
0.7160223126411438,
-0.06576644629240036,
1.126295804977417,
-0.4618608355522156,
-0.2391653060913086,
1.2184849977493286,
-0.47977274656295776,
0.7211107611656189,
0.4031718373298645,
-0.12532207369804382,
0.5988916158676147,
0.9016504883766174,
-0.032580260187387466,
0.4894854724407196,
0.03131407871842384,
-0.04032381251454353,
0.21119073033332825,
-0.27761512994766235,
-0.47466564178466797,
0.9733651876449585,
0.4972454309463501,
0.2680574953556061,
-0.4036490023136139,
0.19957976043224335,
-0.06328638643026352,
0.09469818323850632,
-0.3675406873226166,
0.9725942611694336,
-0.24567818641662598,
-0.6704680919647217,
1.0635733604431152,
-0.28550925850868225,
0.523192286491394,
-0.6847147345542908,
-0.4543963670730591,
-0.4102763235569,
-0.05136813968420029,
-0.305763304233551,
-0.7851628065109253,
0.6042442917823792,
0.18971045315265656,
0.15328040719032288,
0.05085527151823044,
0.6878017783164978,
-0.27846822142601013,
-0.513820469379425,
0.09275491535663605,
0.3795965015888214,
0.3372415006160736,
0.41203731298446655,
-0.42683643102645874,
0.5294865369796753,
-0.03031369112432003,
-0.35917091369628906,
0.5335162878036499,
0.2497071921825409,
-0.01929589733481407,
0.7528198957443237,
0.24490195512771606,
0.09304949641227722,
0.5418450832366943,
-0.06302360445261002,
0.9761785864830017,
-0.7223148345947266,
-0.1659630835056305,
-0.6642305850982666,
0.259621798992157,
0.29781845211982727,
-0.6515054702758789,
1.0683460235595703,
0.9000674486160278,
0.6815391182899475,
-0.07762613892555237,
0.8675325512886047,
-0.19488747417926788,
0.5612763166427612,
-0.6768626570701599,
0.5130771994590759,
-0.7422124743461609,
0.40838441252708435,
0.14291709661483765,
-0.8107593655586243,
-0.11305312067270279,
0.30593812465667725,
0.14310738444328308,
0.05828985944390297,
0.6025391221046448,
0.7979708313941956,
-0.17272719740867615,
0.04619230702519417,
0.14159174263477325,
-0.09470433741807938,
0.14433951675891876,
0.45049065351486206,
0.7682988047599792,
-0.32949817180633545,
0.6766697764396667,
-0.4350837171077728,
-0.30527424812316895,
-0.3053780794143677,
-0.5423365831375122,
-0.6582046747207642,
-0.45620736479759216,
-0.16183185577392578,
0.06309277564287186,
0.378309428691864,
0.9910873770713806,
0.5568950176239014,
-0.6638036966323853,
-0.4233623743057251,
-0.4795492887496948,
0.02747880294919014,
-0.11393629014492035,
-0.33426281809806824,
0.22735309600830078,
-0.5998200178146362,
-0.7048481106758118,
0.7841066718101501,
0.3940596878528595,
-0.15824154019355774,
-0.2917677164077759,
-0.15786047279834747,
-0.4402962327003479,
0.41307270526885986,
0.18432585895061493,
0.5456591844558716,
-0.6106782555580139,
0.03546786680817604,
-0.1411048322916031,
-0.0010434072464704514,
0.3874285817146301,
0.5965531468391418,
-0.4785015881061554,
0.7059706449508667,
0.31551897525787354,
0.6043247580528259,
0.27391839027404785,
-0.18045872449874878,
0.40977442264556885,
-1.0066957473754883,
0.383571594953537,
0.09611987322568893,
0.14468981325626373,
0.38701215386390686,
-0.5424715876579285,
0.9251483082771301,
-0.31842684745788574,
-0.7086123824119568,
-1.0089987516403198,
0.07556629925966263,
-0.7957673668861389,
0.009772766381502151,
1.2093641757965088,
0.21456734836101532,
-0.3788023889064789,
0.0740622952580452,
-0.2489129900932312,
0.5082349181175232,
-0.5389946699142456,
0.6270145773887634,
0.6605942249298096,
-0.5125052332878113,
-0.22734519839286804,
-0.866240918636322,
0.49496176838874817,
0.20169535279273987,
-1.2146145105361938,
-0.005846276413649321,
0.27902108430862427,
0.12611420452594757,
-0.2830926775932312,
0.7360840439796448,
-0.35485535860061646,
0.44592195749282837,
0.09224646538496017,
0.2328144609928131,
-0.16746731102466583,
-0.570129930973053,
-0.32573258876800537,
-0.25510138273239136,
0.6090691685676575,
-0.557086706161499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14975v1 | Embedding-based search in JetBrains IDEs | 2024-01-26T16:07:42 | 2024-01-26T16:07:42 | Evgeny Abramov, Nikolai Palchikov | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Most modern Integrated Development Environments (IDEs) and code editors have
a feature to search across available functionality and items in an open
project. In JetBrains IDEs, this feature is called Search Everywhere: it allows
users to search for files, actions, classes, symbols, settings, and anything
from VCS history from a single entry point. However, it works with the
candidates obtained by algorithms that don't account for semantics, e.g.,
synonyms, complex word permutations, part of the speech modifications, and
typos. In this work, we describe the machine learning approach we implemented
to improve the discoverability of search items. We also share the obstacles
encountered during this process and how we overcame them. | [
-0.6127839684486389,
-0.6136036515235901,
0.67696613073349,
-0.03153210133314133,
0.07407274097204208,
0.48085278272628784,
-0.06895147264003754,
-0.13768577575683594,
0.47991836071014404,
0.25273391604423523,
-0.5344170928001404,
-0.9811258912086487,
-0.5058420300483704,
-0.07658687978982925,
-0.2927625775337219,
0.4502802789211273,
-0.578215479850769,
-0.24293363094329834,
-0.1823199838399887,
-0.40418609976768494,
-0.7608130574226379,
-0.4246240258216858,
-0.46678614616394043,
0.06156341731548309,
0.6986369490623474,
0.6274587512016296,
0.3490946292877197,
0.7272290587425232,
0.2667030692100525,
0.1658829152584076,
-0.31684523820877075,
0.5152928829193115,
-0.24713359773159027,
0.407784640789032,
-0.18706685304641724,
-0.45603030920028687,
0.09947598725557327,
-0.15236710011959076,
0.2605118751525879,
0.566409170627594,
0.09285346418619156,
0.10176689177751541,
0.039876703172922134,
0.42797744274139404,
-1.0669924020767212,
0.40012767910957336,
-0.5213756561279297,
0.5163270235061646,
-0.3645898401737213,
-0.3455268442630768,
-0.34082093834877014,
-0.381022572517395,
0.37871241569519043,
-0.6296374797821045,
0.18778832256793976,
-0.1678893119096756,
0.6850399374961853,
0.010710438713431358,
-0.34873607754707336,
-0.6596949100494385,
-0.5573835968971252,
0.5867794752120972,
-0.28282344341278076,
0.6117503643035889,
0.17101405560970306,
0.08644669502973557,
-0.4350956678390503,
-0.6764990091323853,
-0.27773723006248474,
-0.025816041976213455,
-0.11209274083375931,
-0.14176061749458313,
-0.035938091576099396,
0.3854105770587921,
0.25059857964515686,
-0.21062982082366943,
-0.786442220211029,
0.14504997432231903,
-0.21433241665363312,
0.009449089877307415,
0.37843450903892517,
0.06740754097700119,
0.2623063921928406,
-0.06126626208424568,
-0.03548334911465645,
-0.21527452766895294,
-0.712157666683197,
0.1877521127462387,
0.06436802446842194,
0.27509886026382446,
0.47603240609169006,
0.549087405204773,
-0.07997773587703705,
0.7189103364944458,
-0.4443875253200531,
0.2060772031545639,
0.0337696373462677,
-0.005115983076393604,
-0.1804163008928299,
0.09142408519983292,
0.02288234420120716,
-0.2451692372560501,
-0.00886820163577795,
-0.40256646275520325,
-0.2568177878856659,
-0.07411384582519531,
0.41131460666656494,
-0.6217547655105591,
-0.30511489510536194,
0.3540085256099701,
-0.5669534802436829,
-0.1984533816576004,
0.3721189796924591,
-0.22289767861366272,
-0.518889307975769,
-0.29959166049957275,
0.5300941467285156,
-0.48517462611198425,
0.045465804636478424,
-0.31157922744750977,
-0.4459281861782074,
0.09815093874931335,
0.3355053961277008,
-0.47470980882644653,
0.018605943769216537,
0.7455940246582031,
0.8243796825408936,
0.14404186606407166,
-0.35546690225601196,
-0.5835273265838623,
0.1193004697561264,
-0.3584364354610443,
0.8630540370941162,
-0.8195701837539673,
-0.7007998824119568,
0.12193966656923294,
-0.08717457950115204,
-0.1817588359117508,
-0.698716402053833,
0.5396419763565063,
-0.5572195649147034,
0.08796072006225586,
-0.18837906420230865,
-0.9536017775535583,
-0.6937429308891296,
0.20349548757076263,
-0.3627064526081085,
0.8592178225517273,
0.0009189015836454928,
-0.7683024406433105,
0.4849735498428345,
-1.2060418128967285,
-0.4563716948032379,
0.06318625062704086,
-0.5494911074638367,
-0.5968596935272217,
0.346297025680542,
0.2724761664867401,
0.47565212845802307,
0.3101688325405121,
0.21540825068950653,
-0.5746156573295593,
-1.1175904273986816,
0.1758517473936081,
0.0885053351521492,
0.8422687649726868,
0.0851009264588356,
-0.42784300446510315,
0.06740187853574753,
-0.28934958577156067,
0.1447736918926239,
0.15663835406303406,
-0.24704094231128693,
-0.6684596538543701,
0.25361913442611694,
0.04818577691912651,
0.008176124654710293,
0.22605757415294647,
-0.3678228557109833,
0.8173769116401672,
-0.3377119302749634,
0.11890075355768204,
0.7895047068595886,
0.004833995830267668,
0.16808778047561646,
0.033540282398462296,
0.4434950053691864,
0.27435505390167236,
0.3217329978942871,
-0.1426100730895996,
-0.4852769076824188,
-0.7180348634719849,
-0.2568737268447876,
0.32814985513687134,
0.640730619430542,
-0.5600951313972473,
0.5624176263809204,
-0.0034014794509857893,
-0.5997898578643799,
-0.6458603739738464,
0.19662730395793915,
0.28268858790397644,
-0.09777279943227768,
0.16290472447872162,
-0.256090372800827,
-0.9090456366539001,
-0.9030585885047913,
-0.2912346124649048,
-0.011175435036420822,
-0.11471990495920181,
0.5972351431846619,
0.3946686387062073,
-0.7129819989204407,
0.8930724263191223,
-0.7327815294265747,
-0.34810441732406616,
0.2770126461982727,
0.2295791059732437,
0.1181110218167305,
0.4022575914859772,
0.4542888402938843,
-1.1941577196121216,
-0.34055763483047485,
-0.024650296196341515,
-0.9233376979827881,
0.1275792419910431,
0.19646701216697693,
0.026369309052824974,
0.02048247493803501,
0.9737345576286316,
-0.4019773006439209,
0.6691819429397583,
0.37757495045661926,
-0.22006632387638092,
-0.06739895045757294,
-0.0762239620089531,
0.01346795354038477,
-1.0855858325958252,
0.3585110604763031,
-0.08707156777381897,
0.02236868068575859,
-0.23347051441669464,
0.42181652784347534,
0.23619653284549713,
-0.4053427577018738,
-0.3639734983444214,
0.45746004581451416,
-0.46825549006462097,
-0.30956077575683594,
-0.16237013041973114,
0.5587461590766907,
-0.033081814646720886,
0.2534198760986328,
-0.3002762198448181,
1.0001736879348755,
0.7094501852989197,
-0.7330885529518127,
0.2830694615840912,
0.2920445501804352,
-0.10061254352331161,
0.35177725553512573,
-0.15970619022846222,
0.26800280809402466,
-0.38906732201576233,
0.23921900987625122,
-0.7169733047485352,
0.00813492015004158,
-0.10167861729860306,
-0.5006204843521118,
0.2618372440338135,
-0.4760257601737976,
-0.4534528851509094,
-0.431895911693573,
-0.42403697967529297,
0.10530504584312439,
-0.033657774329185486,
-0.9164652228355408,
0.5764835476875305,
0.6349042654037476,
-0.03504886105656624,
-0.5915126800537109,
-0.10336768627166748,
0.2024020105600357,
-0.19401612877845764,
-0.406160831451416,
0.36397498846054077,
-0.1127338856458664,
-0.045222170650959015,
0.24346783757209778,
-0.24237306416034698,
-0.38490647077560425,
0.7003976702690125,
0.5374923944473267,
0.19476516544818878,
-0.25868481397628784,
0.33239203691482544,
0.1904006153345108,
-0.08644647151231766,
-0.18936502933502197,
-0.8150508403778076,
0.2632753849029541,
0.02377370558679104,
-0.5289726257324219,
0.004963715560734272,
0.5011263489723206,
0.5163789987564087,
-0.437233567237854,
0.6058756709098816,
0.6190838813781738,
-0.6462501883506775,
-0.4796851575374603,
-0.3661980628967285,
-0.02945082262158394,
-0.44977691769599915,
0.43106505274772644,
-0.5098395347595215,
-1.0808895826339722,
0.45815160870552063,
-0.4726289212703705,
0.10184337198734283,
0.2369534820318222,
0.11003313213586807,
-0.27289682626724243,
1.303985595703125,
0.9197657108306885,
0.06821700185537338,
0.7293411493301392,
-0.41489601135253906,
0.5173794627189636,
-0.8752887845039368,
-0.37447571754455566,
-0.7016826272010803,
-0.48654553294181824,
-1.0598255395889282,
-0.23303726315498352,
0.561675488948822,
0.1456301361322403,
-0.12249292433261871,
0.574786901473999,
-0.8155250549316406,
0.558452308177948,
0.769058108329773,
0.05852876603603363,
-0.03478880599141121,
-0.05106281861662865,
-0.32937315106391907,
-0.1966172158718109,
-0.7072397470474243,
-0.23065951466560364,
1.1130425930023193,
0.02524195797741413,
0.5441115498542786,
0.06066875904798508,
1.1846160888671875,
0.3008514940738678,
0.2649269104003906,
-0.6463868021965027,
0.4217330515384674,
-0.31535452604293823,
-0.5125125050544739,
-0.0795707106590271,
-0.3305431306362152,
-1.083736538887024,
0.029163427650928497,
-0.1132126897573471,
-0.8726068735122681,
0.16512823104858398,
-0.2087780237197876,
0.03331571817398071,
0.4000644385814667,
-0.6972471475601196,
0.9353517889976501,
-0.20712174475193024,
0.0963113084435463,
-0.3225914537906647,
-0.19474908709526062,
-0.08745916187763214,
0.047821156680583954,
-0.09123807400465012,
0.20842275023460388,
0.0640864372253418,
0.6712810397148132,
0.11496223509311676,
0.2373238503932953,
-0.4498436450958252,
0.255327433347702,
0.17756110429763794,
0.4503442049026489,
0.6530606150627136,
0.1748082935810089,
0.14919567108154297,
-0.03559127077460289,
-0.1581219881772995,
-0.43901437520980835,
-0.7273426055908203,
1.0468171834945679,
-0.536956787109375,
-0.42815062403678894,
-0.3619879186153412,
-0.09839950501918793,
-0.09548771381378174,
0.23433633148670197,
-0.01444284152239561,
0.2779792249202728,
-0.37534090876579285,
0.32709547877311707,
1.002439022064209,
-0.3658217787742615,
0.2859809696674347,
0.5816709995269775,
-0.45500484108924866,
-0.04204074665904045,
1.096293568611145,
0.38264745473861694,
-0.8305857181549072,
0.5672349333763123,
-0.08784233778715134,
-0.15485358238220215,
-0.4940781891345978,
-0.5035918354988098,
-0.1016082614660263,
-0.8411683440208435,
-0.16677190363407135,
-0.6713322997093201,
-0.2933990955352783,
-0.11253196746110916,
-0.5534760355949402,
-0.26662230491638184,
-0.09224536269903183,
-0.45287567377090454,
-0.11082224547863007,
0.2690521776676178,
0.8259481191635132,
0.1549437940120697,
-0.33461102843284607,
-0.7606719136238098,
0.00015349786553997546,
0.18390102684497833,
0.814252495765686,
-0.04408838972449303,
-0.07116000354290009,
-0.796619713306427,
-0.26867663860321045,
-0.5375493168830872,
-0.5576795339584351,
0.1074378490447998,
-0.03744005039334297,
0.5517405271530151,
0.008317383006215096,
-0.18982599675655365,
0.6470701098442078,
-0.05275465548038483,
0.5086060166358948,
-0.4755781292915344,
-1.004067301750183,
0.8270787000656128,
-0.09887627512216568,
0.004824568051844835,
0.5326842665672302,
0.3488832116127014,
-0.532913088798523,
-0.17079921066761017,
-0.7531038522720337,
-0.916045606136322,
0.39756765961647034,
0.33840978145599365,
-0.22494743764400482,
0.309390127658844,
0.3542836308479309,
-0.10548680275678635,
0.16465163230895996,
-0.18815915286540985,
-0.47483906149864197,
0.16739973425865173,
-0.07723883539438248,
0.11551840603351593,
0.1478084772825241,
-0.13717371225357056,
-0.22090792655944824,
0.8036953806877136,
-0.321351021528244,
0.2761622369289398,
0.17130519449710846,
-0.17718645930290222,
0.10594386607408524,
0.1263161450624466,
0.33107468485832214,
0.49519145488739014,
-0.4397764503955841,
-0.013754652813076973,
0.11415377259254456,
-0.14774997532367706,
0.001154775032773614,
0.4200660288333893,
-0.2504628896713257,
0.3448542058467865,
-0.042106349021196365,
0.7442551851272583,
0.24713221192359924,
-1.0871893167495728,
0.5488417744636536,
-0.40410923957824707,
0.10918577760457993,
-0.6089704632759094,
0.22105543315410614,
0.003760351100936532,
0.4439314007759094,
0.16407592594623566,
0.18052825331687927,
0.5480484962463379,
-0.5238991975784302,
0.33164235949516296,
0.4621235728263855,
-0.468161940574646,
0.11389720439910889,
0.5444247126579285,
0.08522158861160278,
-0.4637881815433502,
0.6836104393005371,
-0.29974326491355896,
-0.5461090803146362,
0.4779408574104309,
0.2379758358001709,
1.517500877380371,
0.15774790942668915,
0.18262872099876404,
-0.013475923798978329,
0.15728925168514252,
0.28928691148757935,
0.23660233616828918,
-0.15657947957515717,
-0.38820648193359375,
-0.23890896141529083,
-0.2941080331802368,
-0.7590172290802002,
-0.1567174345254898,
-0.3178357481956482,
0.5394542217254639,
-0.4129980504512787,
0.12756340205669403,
-0.04137982800602913,
0.10855026543140411,
-0.9569864273071289,
0.07869767397642136,
0.26078367233276367,
1.1783379316329956,
-0.5816489458084106,
0.8680844902992249,
1.1652047634124756,
-0.5195162296295166,
-0.7339011430740356,
0.23215028643608093,
-0.12168709933757782,
-0.4659208655357361,
0.5270258784294128,
0.29763537645339966,
0.13503864407539368,
-0.12926369905471802,
-0.3555929660797119,
-0.8648684620857239,
1.1524477005004883,
0.3469514846801758,
-0.20192693173885345,
-0.22205881774425507,
-0.3543076813220978,
0.45487990975379944,
-0.2659478187561035,
0.2666827142238617,
0.3106537461280823,
0.600443422794342,
-0.5852862596511841,
-0.7470191717147827,
-0.36492422223091125,
-0.289784699678421,
0.3261641263961792,
0.4334787428379059,
-0.36628180742263794,
0.6834397912025452,
0.1451694816350937,
-0.1325855702161789,
-0.29528701305389404,
0.416659951210022,
0.120452880859375,
0.5597575306892395,
0.12596982717514038,
0.5924631357192993,
0.9402370452880859,
-0.07216577231884003,
0.8598061800003052,
-0.1706290990114212,
0.6619031429290771,
0.7230391502380371,
-0.0886666551232338,
0.7575732469558716,
0.30636119842529297,
-0.0732065811753273,
0.6180084347724915,
0.681472659111023,
0.018858810886740685,
0.4563376307487488,
0.2674500644207001,
-0.5141759514808655,
-0.04205229505896568,
-0.17140153050422668,
-0.027199892327189445,
0.6284382939338684,
0.5031397342681885,
-0.4445539712905884,
0.00010151329479413107,
0.19777941703796387,
-0.1027522161602974,
0.10054799169301987,
-0.040089093148708344,
1.046655535697937,
-0.10808905959129333,
-0.5001413822174072,
0.3948192894458771,
0.2962014079093933,
0.4651589095592499,
-0.35606813430786133,
-0.23040828108787537,
-0.19645239412784576,
0.19724802672863007,
-0.2428881824016571,
-0.9474889039993286,
0.29642874002456665,
-0.3099226653575897,
-0.21708756685256958,
0.09034845978021622,
0.658684253692627,
-0.07727272808551788,
-0.17399197816848755,
0.6787837147712708,
0.5199519395828247,
-0.06725524365901947,
-0.13275820016860962,
-0.7029359936714172,
0.23856337368488312,
0.11428025364875793,
-0.2112523913383484,
0.29793423414230347,
0.5637214183807373,
0.009030749090015888,
0.7403681874275208,
0.3365729749202728,
-0.0857601910829544,
-0.08621878176927567,
-0.3381347954273224,
0.8905732035636902,
-0.888801634311676,
-0.4678068161010742,
-0.468138188123703,
0.1284298598766327,
0.05830615013837814,
-0.10427844524383545,
0.55759197473526,
0.9211632609367371,
1.1917401552200317,
-0.0073908427730202675,
1.0451278686523438,
-0.09459938108921051,
0.5388535857200623,
-0.4217945337295532,
0.45192667841911316,
-0.6124681234359741,
0.2844855785369873,
-0.3124912679195404,
-1.1259353160858154,
-0.5793744325637817,
0.7000595331192017,
0.10938961803913116,
-0.15343035757541656,
0.44711625576019287,
1.0264140367507935,
-0.5388314127922058,
0.014495997689664364,
0.25175395607948303,
0.1950925886631012,
0.567489743232727,
0.3912760615348816,
0.3694336712360382,
-0.4642764627933502,
0.4594496190547943,
0.0030102974269539118,
-0.02910790406167507,
-0.6796498894691467,
-0.5964574813842773,
-0.5761547684669495,
-0.8494678139686584,
-0.10233979672193527,
-0.5576092600822449,
0.6030429601669312,
1.120026707649231,
0.6174070835113525,
-0.8239156603813171,
-0.09488974511623383,
-0.23516611754894257,
0.5996692776679993,
-0.20998500287532806,
-0.20291724801063538,
0.41021573543548584,
-0.020398184657096863,
-0.5260041356086731,
0.882568359375,
0.510685384273529,
-0.23366855084896088,
-0.4624628722667694,
0.08603266626596451,
-0.14095191657543182,
-0.03074820339679718,
0.38544121384620667,
0.46904268860816956,
-0.5364342331886292,
-0.4772924482822418,
0.04432913661003113,
-0.029492497444152832,
0.13219106197357178,
0.9901984930038452,
-1.0979290008544922,
0.8392585515975952,
0.4191221594810486,
0.9377515316009521,
0.48690178990364075,
-0.4651438593864441,
0.39721444249153137,
-0.9691832661628723,
0.06335771828889847,
0.25838664174079895,
0.43220239877700806,
0.2855280041694641,
-0.11033005267381668,
0.535192608833313,
0.34240928292274475,
-0.6073304414749146,
-0.7119516730308533,
0.12253744900226593,
-0.6355176568031311,
-0.47610151767730713,
0.43432462215423584,
-0.22476275265216827,
0.04033844172954559,
-0.13498468697071075,
-0.5513355135917664,
0.4226064383983612,
-0.20047324895858765,
0.9694750308990479,
0.3696873188018799,
-0.17722895741462708,
0.24433547258377075,
-0.48614421486854553,
0.2870427966117859,
0.19711221754550934,
-0.508467972278595,
-0.13222114741802216,
0.30894625186920166,
0.18594150245189667,
0.22178485989570618,
0.0678778663277626,
0.11661861836910248,
0.3169206380844116,
-0.0785037949681282,
0.1691754311323166,
-0.12242050468921661,
-0.4044639766216278,
-0.24819011986255646,
0.2595563530921936,
0.2533157467842102,
-0.18339359760284424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14931v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14931v1 | Do LLMs Dream of Ontologies? | 2024-01-26T15:10:23 | 2024-01-26T15:10:23 | Marco Bombieri, Paolo Fiorini, Simone Paolo Ponzetto, Marco Rospocher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have recently revolutionized automated text
understanding and generation. The performance of these models relies on the
high number of parameters of the underlying neural architectures, which allows
LLMs to memorize part of the vast quantity of data seen during the training.
This paper investigates whether and to what extent general-purpose pre-trained
LLMs have memorized information from known ontologies. Our results show that
LLMs partially know ontologies: they can, and do indeed, memorize concepts from
ontologies mentioned in the text, but the level of memorization of their
concepts seems to vary proportionally to their popularity on the Web, the
primary source of their training material. We additionally propose new metrics
to estimate the degree of memorization of ontological information in LLMs by
measuring the consistency of the output produced across different prompt
repetitions, query languages, and degrees of determinism. | [
-0.19026510417461395,
-0.4462527632713318,
0.9385554790496826,
-0.36372607946395874,
0.05814033001661301,
-0.047766316682100296,
-0.1820458471775055,
-0.09045588970184326,
0.13657192885875702,
0.8595110774040222,
-0.7117547392845154,
-0.7874546051025391,
-0.4339876174926758,
0.06784834712743759,
-0.5963467359542847,
0.8220679759979248,
0.04160822555422783,
-0.021516134962439537,
-0.2977859079837799,
0.294798880815506,
0.1921333223581314,
-0.7816087007522583,
-0.4430255889892578,
-0.4333759844303131,
0.6621786952018738,
0.12015996873378754,
0.4348318576812744,
0.8201436400413513,
0.45653748512268066,
0.28321707248687744,
0.0591924749314785,
0.09165073931217194,
-0.5159160494804382,
-0.02051023580133915,
-0.24002167582511902,
-1.1426857709884644,
-0.46186208724975586,
0.0688047930598259,
0.8708770275115967,
0.9228716492652893,
-0.30917757749557495,
0.23849712312221527,
0.02345106191933155,
0.5966770052909851,
-0.5480961799621582,
0.10190143436193466,
-1.0411797761917114,
0.6379340887069702,
0.1336064338684082,
-0.49572163820266724,
-0.26669877767562866,
-0.18345648050308228,
0.23551492393016815,
-0.9295461177825928,
0.09899398684501648,
0.05298646539449692,
0.7918664813041687,
0.3810163140296936,
-0.20271199941635132,
-0.6246952414512634,
-0.6517800688743591,
0.9560447335243225,
-0.4321756660938263,
0.3731401264667511,
0.866249144077301,
0.19637258350849152,
-0.03295876830816269,
-0.8653514385223389,
-0.6087231636047363,
-0.20522627234458923,
-0.04329238831996918,
0.2508004903793335,
-0.11909833550453186,
-0.0661226436495781,
0.3687344491481781,
0.23357057571411133,
-0.3217589259147644,
0.3240644931793213,
0.08257672935724258,
-0.21321852505207062,
0.37600699067115784,
0.5422475337982178,
0.30597123503685,
-0.08935058861970901,
-0.6282896399497986,
0.06836384534835815,
-0.6923813819885254,
-0.3168192505836487,
0.13889823853969574,
0.08430454134941101,
0.15516170859336853,
0.5566826462745667,
0.08071715384721756,
0.5707955360412598,
-0.3984355926513672,
-0.6179878115653992,
0.12194667011499405,
-0.426642507314682,
-0.20172911882400513,
-0.1420782506465912,
0.7783328294754028,
0.10192330181598663,
0.5265954732894897,
-0.6132511496543884,
-0.4064670503139496,
-0.03206317126750946,
0.4094758629798889,
-0.19877710938453674,
-0.2154541164636612,
0.05874789506196976,
-0.3151046633720398,
0.09942276030778885,
-0.0711173564195633,
-0.26185548305511475,
-0.365751713514328,
-0.43748486042022705,
0.6601008772850037,
-0.5331401824951172,
0.04285888373851776,
0.18493448197841644,
-0.299450546503067,
0.1429281383752823,
0.48159173130989075,
-0.9479919075965881,
0.21168529987335205,
0.746756374835968,
0.7155412435531616,
-0.008719772100448608,
-0.5804988145828247,
0.12763167917728424,
0.4142167866230011,
-0.47733551263809204,
0.8817238211631775,
-0.3946778178215027,
-0.37096747756004333,
0.26307862997055054,
-0.25134751200675964,
-0.2511252462863922,
-0.5129386782646179,
0.18141035735607147,
-0.6475693583488464,
0.032439615577459335,
-0.5226174592971802,
-0.8690258860588074,
-0.1167796403169632,
0.7556110620498657,
-0.4122309386730194,
0.5562289357185364,
-0.1518845558166504,
-0.7626364827156067,
0.36786848306655884,
-0.18819960951805115,
0.05792772024869919,
-0.24131137132644653,
-0.2248024195432663,
-0.07493164390325546,
0.08752598613500595,
-0.4939398169517517,
0.6093623042106628,
-0.6184829473495483,
-0.15315468609333038,
-0.14353591203689575,
-0.15922565758228302,
0.6768278479576111,
-0.3617554008960724,
0.2566438913345337,
0.1572638601064682,
0.13644719123840332,
-0.19450092315673828,
-0.8365671634674072,
0.12580613791942596,
0.10809913277626038,
-0.6883111000061035,
-0.42118990421295166,
0.028668850660324097,
-0.6844608783721924,
0.19253090023994446,
0.4904600977897644,
-0.45730504393577576,
0.35681089758872986,
-0.32802730798721313,
0.45168280601501465,
0.7776470184326172,
-0.1360388994216919,
0.41750532388687134,
-0.6102098226547241,
0.38679203391075134,
-0.08485521376132965,
-0.18820597231388092,
-0.3230678141117096,
0.022655729204416275,
-1.049686312675476,
-0.16554772853851318,
0.151757150888443,
0.48094359040260315,
-0.40145519375801086,
0.4357827603816986,
-0.412293404340744,
-0.4145580530166626,
-0.18873360753059387,
0.47674599289894104,
0.6105127334594727,
0.3276737928390503,
0.13660922646522522,
-0.3546886146068573,
-0.473493754863739,
-0.5266261100769043,
-0.16537438333034515,
-0.2875327169895172,
-0.1869005411863327,
0.4114917814731598,
0.5772861242294312,
-0.2467256784439087,
0.9998733401298523,
-0.49876636266708374,
-0.7443420886993408,
-0.053882040083408356,
-0.08989237248897552,
-0.09183288365602493,
-0.028079623356461525,
0.3750573694705963,
-0.6081392168998718,
-0.13256114721298218,
-0.09095966070890427,
-1.081681489944458,
0.10270445793867111,
0.025590654462575912,
-0.052448149770498276,
0.2601810395717621,
0.6110844016075134,
-0.6109129786491394,
0.07681859284639359,
0.27701300382614136,
-0.2305806428194046,
0.4671374261379242,
-0.4939597249031067,
-0.284824013710022,
-1.0821410417556763,
-0.06066882610321045,
-0.38987481594085693,
-0.06195225566625595,
-0.5545509457588196,
-0.38441503047943115,
-0.22826789319515228,
0.43611693382263184,
-0.2963220179080963,
0.5621307492256165,
-0.6548985242843628,
-0.4764852821826935,
-0.36637452244758606,
0.5333755016326904,
-0.06627645343542099,
0.23499678075313568,
0.2065308392047882,
0.48111552000045776,
0.4907303750514984,
-0.7958539128303528,
0.20407667756080627,
0.4218759834766388,
-0.5079287886619568,
0.19996346533298492,
-0.23913155496120453,
0.1959720253944397,
-0.21242330968379974,
0.24527807533740997,
-0.9621894955635071,
-0.2514866590499878,
-0.09677012264728546,
-0.44967713952064514,
-0.03229702636599541,
-0.002572356490418315,
-0.687719464302063,
-0.19660726189613342,
-0.054900046437978745,
-0.22623175382614136,
0.6148509979248047,
-0.3495141565799713,
0.5343567728996277,
0.5563576221466064,
0.18653051555156708,
-0.708279013633728,
-0.9081820249557495,
0.04091084748506546,
-0.03736873343586922,
-0.21684719622135162,
0.12108132988214493,
0.14710627496242523,
-0.309828519821167,
0.037406984716653824,
-0.08279258757829666,
-0.1980569213628769,
0.020001867786049843,
0.47322532534599304,
0.1766597032546997,
-0.26651471853256226,
0.6862049698829651,
-0.45336389541625977,
0.01888178288936615,
0.39604344964027405,
-0.7547019124031067,
0.9697126746177673,
0.08292150497436523,
-0.4378843605518341,
-0.18646781146526337,
-0.21841369569301605,
0.17220638692378998,
0.07281769067049026,
0.8517290949821472,
0.2745681405067444,
-0.3190755546092987,
-0.5219528675079346,
-0.5030791759490967,
-0.07737638801336288,
-0.423764169216156,
0.392241507768631,
-0.5285876393318176,
-0.827034592628479,
0.5537542104721069,
-0.10471736639738083,
0.1373007446527481,
0.46912503242492676,
0.40048930048942566,
-0.36840710043907166,
0.5545251965522766,
0.6596658229827881,
0.17450188100337982,
0.2693040370941162,
-0.5274949073791504,
-0.3332470655441284,
-0.5782372951507568,
-0.38674309849739075,
-0.4793611764907837,
-0.16288016736507416,
-0.3801797330379486,
-0.43327298760414124,
0.03513729199767113,
0.1696052998304367,
-0.40501460433006287,
-0.03723578155040741,
-0.04185372591018677,
0.38411474227905273,
0.6156183481216431,
-0.07529177516698837,
0.6364337205886841,
0.20644445717334747,
-0.09866823256015778,
0.18470843136310577,
-0.7429015636444092,
-0.940556526184082,
1.2981255054473877,
0.19171294569969177,
0.7433990240097046,
-0.0933225154876709,
0.7972155809402466,
0.18615643680095673,
0.04353214055299759,
-0.575171172618866,
0.8382776379585266,
-0.43228545784950256,
-0.6411473751068115,
-0.29891568422317505,
-0.47445571422576904,
-1.0827152729034424,
-0.0005536694079637527,
-0.1519363522529602,
-0.6520870327949524,
-0.2108399122953415,
0.4210394322872162,
-0.27462002635002136,
0.6043153405189514,
-0.2972559332847595,
0.6125029921531677,
-0.3052237033843994,
0.1476942002773285,
-0.2173510193824768,
-0.6042336821556091,
0.16008323431015015,
-0.47867026925086975,
0.038556478917598724,
-0.27724143862724304,
-0.5712871551513672,
0.8333989381790161,
-0.347646564245224,
1.0142621994018555,
0.10029876977205276,
-0.34622105956077576,
0.40036043524742126,
-0.09791680425405502,
0.20186111330986023,
-0.1780140995979309,
-0.12901516258716583,
0.25807350873947144,
-0.09102964401245117,
-0.19992949068546295,
-0.5645511746406555,
0.5717192888259888,
-1.032932996749878,
-0.6418632864952087,
-0.24888186156749725,
-0.39592379331588745,
-0.2644321620464325,
0.11809980869293213,
0.49403005838394165,
-0.03420421481132507,
-0.2868056893348694,
-0.08784903585910797,
0.8169046640396118,
-0.2693340480327606,
0.2657371461391449,
0.8896246552467346,
-0.2848784625530243,
0.024219537153840065,
0.9467896819114685,
0.6307602524757385,
0.5671399831771851,
0.6860043406486511,
-0.03196444362401962,
-0.08071912080049515,
-0.46253201365470886,
0.06469804793596268,
0.25860634446144104,
-0.988272488117218,
0.016244111582636833,
-0.9932100176811218,
-0.47052833437919617,
-0.1273851841688156,
0.016895929351449013,
-0.26473909616470337,
-0.5831291079521179,
-0.5199113488197327,
-0.05489181727170944,
0.3183450698852539,
1.0228021144866943,
0.029559439048171043,
0.40615710616111755,
-0.9406046271324158,
0.19377869367599487,
0.3447074294090271,
0.16932840645313263,
0.06437578797340393,
-0.896076500415802,
-0.09582304209470749,
0.034022003412246704,
-0.03968336060643196,
-0.377171128988266,
0.29222536087036133,
0.3940662145614624,
0.6224393844604492,
0.4857245683670044,
-0.10759035497903824,
0.18573857843875885,
-0.5331111550331116,
0.6792140007019043,
0.24067795276641846,
-0.6169843077659607,
0.3921928107738495,
-0.2240334302186966,
0.2554979920387268,
0.3296108841896057,
0.8089691400527954,
-0.3450225293636322,
-0.2301202267408371,
-0.43071144819259644,
-0.47149017453193665,
0.7359086871147156,
-0.23226028680801392,
0.5012493133544922,
-0.07907359302043915,
0.5438433289527893,
0.26093947887420654,
0.3239174783229828,
-0.4849245846271515,
-0.20089004933834076,
-0.02703952230513096,
-0.31460121273994446,
-0.16294629871845245,
-0.4123140275478363,
-0.2291184663772583,
0.25438621640205383,
0.2828071713447571,
0.03452753275632858,
0.31967276334762573,
-0.050608985126018524,
-0.14994578063488007,
0.15024647116661072,
0.26606830954551697,
0.22759409248828888,
0.8574272394180298,
0.02557486481964588,
0.40656647086143494,
0.32836151123046875,
-0.7338021993637085,
0.22629013657569885,
-0.2985178828239441,
-0.24106627702713013,
-0.2014639675617218,
0.45465031266212463,
0.766730010509491,
0.00047085603000596166,
-0.8078200817108154,
0.21287676692008972,
0.014783934690058231,
-0.4099673628807068,
-0.8670768737792969,
0.49041247367858887,
0.24123980104923248,
0.11615177243947983,
0.18266312777996063,
-0.09950108826160431,
-0.18696792423725128,
-0.7556847333908081,
0.07228399068117142,
0.39707931876182556,
-0.553801417350769,
-0.5549455285072327,
0.37245094776153564,
-0.2823169231414795,
-0.2919611930847168,
0.4979798197746277,
-0.029675478115677834,
-0.42318764328956604,
0.47827428579330444,
0.6174585819244385,
0.6670413613319397,
0.03918479382991791,
0.09223340451717377,
0.21487325429916382,
0.19063906371593475,
-0.3417755663394928,
0.43680113554000854,
-0.06234774366021156,
-1.1108286380767822,
-0.0467083640396595,
-1.094792366027832,
-0.36207589507102966,
-0.07410790026187897,
-0.30323538184165955,
0.01768256165087223,
-0.6753770709037781,
-0.485677570104599,
0.11012236773967743,
-0.172602578997612,
-0.7215742468833923,
0.45741066336631775,
0.3266628086566925,
0.7802140712738037,
-0.4186602234840393,
0.9544587731361389,
0.6995003819465637,
-0.5527666211128235,
-0.8430851697921753,
0.12316188961267471,
-0.05278399586677551,
-1.0232123136520386,
1.091766357421875,
-0.06551133096218109,
-0.2840382158756256,
0.13570912182331085,
-0.21799802780151367,
-1.052059292793274,
1.0978108644485474,
0.3953278958797455,
-0.5119383335113525,
-0.43774884939193726,
0.57406085729599,
0.6524165272712708,
-0.3170139789581299,
0.1293964982032776,
0.6212252378463745,
0.34274184703826904,
-0.006640676409006119,
-0.8310830593109131,
-0.35819000005722046,
-0.06451725214719772,
-0.1304951310157776,
0.1055392324924469,
-0.6774445176124573,
1.05412757396698,
-0.4459041953086853,
-0.1769062727689743,
0.0690012201666832,
0.44498729705810547,
0.025173408910632133,
0.18400441110134125,
0.3445660173892975,
0.6078289747238159,
0.8822823166847229,
-0.14303450286388397,
1.004807472229004,
-0.3124833405017853,
0.2034982293844223,
1.1253104209899902,
-0.2676548361778259,
0.9187013506889343,
0.18752725422382355,
-0.3489798903465271,
0.31229591369628906,
0.31323546171188354,
-0.04022403433918953,
0.21596035361289978,
0.3936237096786499,
-0.07401157170534134,
-0.4521322548389435,
-0.23787009716033936,
-0.2373247742652893,
0.6562149524688721,
0.5777835845947266,
-0.6964954137802124,
0.11610621213912964,
0.16599611937999725,
-0.015982046723365784,
0.15010850131511688,
-0.4038863182067871,
1.2517672777175903,
0.38770467042922974,
-0.6680201292037964,
0.622397243976593,
-0.3430582880973816,
0.4780142605304718,
-0.9268761873245239,
0.24708950519561768,
-0.14996208250522614,
0.5308396816253662,
-0.07194026559591293,
-0.9180723428726196,
0.16082391142845154,
-0.03616151958703995,
-0.33782342076301575,
-0.27737200260162354,
0.5700840353965759,
-0.3035673499107361,
-0.30869629979133606,
0.5064023733139038,
0.555864155292511,
0.47314056754112244,
0.11842522770166397,
-0.3712364435195923,
-0.21132247149944305,
-0.08806633204221725,
-0.4269920289516449,
0.5858063101768494,
0.642410159111023,
0.2305094301700592,
0.9562845230102539,
0.3998894691467285,
0.2034466415643692,
0.4269740879535675,
0.036591507494449615,
0.676594078540802,
-0.7991260886192322,
-0.21307601034641266,
-0.8986469507217407,
-0.07100336998701096,
0.08278261870145798,
-0.5958015322685242,
1.0856462717056274,
0.46501800417900085,
1.0916216373443604,
-0.11823917925357819,
0.9042550325393677,
0.3895881474018097,
0.766213595867157,
-0.8372642993927002,
0.8419118523597717,
-0.7269895076751709,
0.42809534072875977,
-0.020563434809446335,
-0.9687876105308533,
-0.1830575317144394,
0.3071446716785431,
-0.3366018533706665,
0.06005162000656128,
0.3369918167591095,
0.6206461191177368,
0.14854636788368225,
-0.03031996451318264,
0.5854887962341309,
0.3436676561832428,
-0.15770165622234344,
0.4877185821533203,
1.2615652084350586,
-0.08533745259046555,
0.7257380485534668,
0.2169284075498581,
0.09991645812988281,
0.004058092832565308,
-0.29127177596092224,
-1.0102853775024414,
-0.4490177035331726,
0.00036205744254402816,
-0.14390714466571808,
0.24833078682422638,
0.7727692723274231,
0.30776745080947876,
-0.44832924008369446,
-0.3971814215183258,
-0.09644918143749237,
-0.10388335585594177,
0.38771194219589233,
-0.03835846483707428,
0.26330050826072693,
-0.7498109936714172,
-0.3518165349960327,
0.06488028913736343,
0.3639727830886841,
0.21910858154296875,
-0.45508164167404175,
-0.126881405711174,
-0.07578486949205399,
0.5180848240852356,
0.4361797869205475,
0.30627742409706116,
-0.8223767876625061,
-0.08845395594835281,
0.24465350806713104,
-0.550119161605835,
-0.018739251419901848,
0.6456934809684753,
-0.6976396441459656,
0.18787109851837158,
0.4738704264163971,
0.44124114513397217,
0.2758597433567047,
-0.1338735669851303,
0.4047853946685791,
-0.6054143309593201,
0.01091755460947752,
0.1466379463672638,
0.34347009658813477,
0.1272026002407074,
0.15146668255329132,
0.4164673388004303,
0.08982928097248077,
-0.49171873927116394,
-0.7266247868537903,
0.26202335953712463,
-0.4119999408721924,
-0.5091593265533447,
1.183916687965393,
-0.6060966849327087,
-0.43497323989868164,
-0.13264520466327667,
0.11258690804243088,
0.14775000512599945,
0.22011637687683105,
0.6952935457229614,
0.6331608295440674,
0.1255318820476532,
0.13941562175750732,
-0.5709562301635742,
0.5718907713890076,
0.47717177867889404,
-0.7650642991065979,
-0.03452787920832634,
0.30321386456489563,
0.3519478738307953,
0.40654730796813965,
0.912745475769043,
0.17544224858283997,
-0.004195917397737503,
0.23893463611602783,
0.11854314804077148,
0.2085859328508377,
-0.4022229313850403,
0.05232349783182144,
0.2091091126203537,
0.15708939731121063,
-0.009745395742356777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14890v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14890v1 | Comparison of parameters of vowel sounds of russian and english languages | 2024-01-26T14:15:20 | 2024-01-26T14:15:20 | V. I. Fedoseev, A. A. Konev, A. Yu. Yakimuk | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS, 68T10, H.2.8 | In multilingual speech recognition systems, a situation can often arise when
the language is not known in advance, but the signal has already been received
and is being processed. For such cases, some generalized model is needed that
will be able to respond to phonetic differences and, depending on them,
correctly recog-nize speech in the desired language. To build such a model, it
is necessary to set the values of phonetic parameters, and then compare similar
sounds, establishing significant differences. | [
-0.20742636919021606,
-0.6562772393226624,
0.49215781688690186,
0.14549492299556732,
-0.3167838752269745,
-0.05087246373295784,
-0.21533061563968658,
-0.733700156211853,
0.3691938519477844,
0.2791546881198883,
-0.4469855725765228,
-0.2827220857143402,
-0.4734979569911957,
0.3181644082069397,
-0.3854057490825653,
0.6011402010917664,
0.0313449427485466,
0.4967578053474426,
0.30136385560035706,
-0.36468663811683655,
-0.5886925458908081,
-0.4070228934288025,
-0.9045878648757935,
-0.31323811411857605,
0.2507050037384033,
0.27846819162368774,
0.49730488657951355,
0.27723103761672974,
0.38154318928718567,
0.4858168065547943,
-0.05283482372760773,
-0.16553129255771637,
0.15244251489639282,
0.6992625594139099,
0.2568027973175049,
-0.48464810848236084,
-0.2019421011209488,
-0.13868585228919983,
1.2289620637893677,
0.6892391443252563,
-0.24353112280368805,
0.023506874218583107,
-0.06414825469255447,
0.30257320404052734,
-0.25593048334121704,
0.013962524011731148,
-0.48643049597740173,
0.21131783723831177,
0.03684031590819359,
-0.34317705035209656,
-0.15271560847759247,
-0.3598278760910034,
0.45689934492111206,
-0.7041445374488831,
0.08329077064990997,
0.06583256274461746,
1.1230236291885376,
-0.32849544286727905,
-0.15423640608787537,
-0.342740535736084,
-0.9863274097442627,
1.1024359464645386,
-0.5711190104484558,
1.1062321662902832,
0.3013741374015808,
0.17932620644569397,
-0.2811957597732544,
-0.6437195539474487,
-0.3551911413669586,
-0.6948915719985962,
-0.017075177282094955,
-0.10650021582841873,
-0.23952415585517883,
0.1402793973684311,
0.3000257611274719,
0.08808621764183044,
-0.866010844707489,
0.0719161182641983,
-0.701024055480957,
-0.40486910939216614,
0.483803391456604,
-0.003173691686242819,
0.51544588804245,
0.12864606082439423,
0.07249040901660919,
-0.020301463082432747,
-0.4318872392177582,
0.27538636326789856,
0.8578383922576904,
0.7441476583480835,
-0.18989190459251404,
0.3037351071834564,
-0.5053513050079346,
0.9655466675758362,
0.10483332723379135,
-0.642468273639679,
0.40523916482925415,
-0.18051429092884064,
-0.17188093066215515,
0.23285183310508728,
0.4956567883491516,
0.32360488176345825,
0.5759579539299011,
-0.08292276412248611,
-0.3430808186531067,
-0.036123547703027725,
-0.12270082533359528,
-0.40660256147384644,
0.018561480566859245,
0.254673033952713,
-0.5295581221580505,
0.2963692247867584,
-0.3448638319969177,
-0.7317914962768555,
0.3029939830303192,
-0.8344097137451172,
0.5528067946434021,
-0.07828040421009064,
-0.5192371010780334,
0.1486680805683136,
-0.3645823001861572,
0.18440482020378113,
0.11899300664663315,
-1.035190463066101,
0.6153959631919861,
0.47502803802490234,
0.8664480447769165,
0.08263963460922241,
-0.6188753247261047,
-0.8357424139976501,
-0.3045250177383423,
-0.32096967101097107,
0.9706586599349976,
-0.8066324591636658,
-0.3992210626602173,
0.15575426816940308,
-0.03105359897017479,
0.03121481090784073,
-0.6060749292373657,
0.2981664538383484,
-0.49011293053627014,
0.2022024691104889,
-0.024524882435798645,
-0.40219399333000183,
-0.22803564369678497,
0.005392134655267,
-0.577055037021637,
0.8585841655731201,
-0.06902115046977997,
-0.5240138173103333,
0.6877366900444031,
-0.2311861515045166,
-0.5244674682617188,
0.2023911029100418,
-0.24118423461914062,
-0.30709701776504517,
0.10035794973373413,
-0.15727180242538452,
0.46928805112838745,
-0.13306261599063873,
-0.036868300288915634,
-0.08639630675315857,
-0.07421540468931198,
0.14546921849250793,
-0.22176337242126465,
0.8046799302101135,
0.4603368043899536,
-0.004757247399538755,
0.15699979662895203,
-1.0777839422225952,
0.3982231318950653,
-0.11196842044591904,
-0.7343354821205139,
-0.48496532440185547,
0.0740044042468071,
0.21533527970314026,
-0.11738515645265579,
0.30847597122192383,
-0.4356609284877777,
-0.032539188861846924,
-0.49719277024269104,
0.4660339057445526,
0.2673133313655853,
-0.046233970671892166,
0.16120804846286774,
-0.30951303243637085,
0.5590264201164246,
-0.25129398703575134,
0.041795890778303146,
0.1138099804520607,
-0.744003176689148,
-0.8401999473571777,
-0.20838268101215363,
0.5520492792129517,
0.8333213925361633,
-0.22668872773647308,
-0.08072797954082489,
0.2615099251270294,
-0.4040006697177887,
-0.867792546749115,
-0.1253552883863449,
0.4284941256046295,
0.14437226951122284,
0.2504933178424835,
-0.07828672975301743,
-0.8286968469619751,
-1.097843050956726,
-0.27186673879623413,
-0.697433352470398,
-0.13867057859897614,
-0.018409598618745804,
0.2689414918422699,
0.38735005259513855,
0.34581226110458374,
-0.27443015575408936,
0.05624067410826683,
-0.1768057942390442,
0.316315233707428,
0.22916705906391144,
0.30148231983184814,
0.48617908358573914,
-0.8651333451271057,
-0.5376431345939636,
0.3464489281177521,
-0.48499181866645813,
-0.13506589829921722,
0.32822346687316895,
0.3969908654689789,
0.2359844595193863,
0.5583356022834778,
-0.3591073751449585,
0.3212440311908722,
0.5258390307426453,
-0.09469948709011078,
0.7576012015342712,
-0.559851884841919,
0.7816871404647827,
-1.0866270065307617,
0.09999776631593704,
0.09601541608572006,
-0.25751957297325134,
-1.0522253513336182,
0.16726301610469818,
-0.17139753699302673,
-0.1537158489227295,
-0.8137705326080322,
0.5296138525009155,
-0.5893329977989197,
-0.39139509201049805,
-0.1920086145401001,
0.17670691013336182,
-0.23387585580348969,
0.16309569776058197,
0.3547338843345642,
0.7257009148597717,
1.0303043127059937,
-1.0046111345291138,
0.7552439570426941,
-0.08938774466514587,
-0.5061246752738953,
0.9038521647453308,
-0.7972314357757568,
0.0366131030023098,
-0.08037448674440384,
-0.47013112902641296,
-1.2729135751724243,
0.05151505395770073,
0.0711163729429245,
-0.8251338601112366,
0.40325114130973816,
-0.3822759985923767,
-0.34799620509147644,
-0.01597823016345501,
0.10828829556703568,
0.5800350904464722,
0.5133956670761108,
-0.25920286774635315,
0.5706738829612732,
0.6260245442390442,
-0.5808214545249939,
-0.6075810194015503,
-0.41172507405281067,
-0.07082270830869675,
-0.6195224523544312,
-0.5347495675086975,
-0.09348779916763306,
-0.1586761623620987,
-0.6097241044044495,
-0.2768090069293976,
0.40701258182525635,
-0.5008870363235474,
0.04518407955765724,
-0.043101534247398376,
0.06893203407526016,
-0.30990922451019287,
0.492547869682312,
0.005856406409293413,
-0.1440751552581787,
-0.12245069444179535,
-0.27869200706481934,
0.47943341732025146,
-0.10528916120529175,
-0.05861702188849449,
-0.5876783728599548,
0.8324392437934875,
0.48831814527511597,
-0.28356999158859253,
0.3006667494773865,
0.35342177748680115,
-0.63116854429245,
0.300102174282074,
-0.6726576089859009,
-0.2433190941810608,
-0.4497120976448059,
0.35723403096199036,
-0.7950921058654785,
-0.5297037363052368,
0.8668952584266663,
0.20533683896064758,
-0.06847018003463745,
0.44135352969169617,
0.45865291357040405,
0.07021662592887878,
1.1643235683441162,
0.475371778011322,
-0.15179266035556793,
0.264756977558136,
0.29506683349609375,
0.11900822073221207,
-0.6461944580078125,
-0.23710426688194275,
-1.2634568214416504,
-0.09528312087059021,
-0.7888492345809937,
0.3195672035217285,
0.17317546904087067,
-0.13752655684947968,
-0.0398033931851387,
0.3053008019924164,
-0.3118738532066345,
0.27354174852371216,
0.7831144332885742,
-0.5011041760444641,
0.29048624634742737,
0.26996758580207825,
-0.6723157167434692,
-0.2656170725822449,
-0.430342435836792,
-0.333658367395401,
0.750924825668335,
0.2024890035390854,
0.8449761867523193,
0.0999237447977066,
0.4420187175273895,
0.1623930186033249,
-0.5167915225028992,
-0.9187218546867371,
0.5488535165786743,
-0.05709546059370041,
-0.6827508807182312,
-0.43270137906074524,
-0.14439848065376282,
-1.4359804391860962,
0.2870247960090637,
-0.4170471727848053,
-1.1370856761932373,
0.185510516166687,
0.012890364974737167,
-0.22329822182655334,
0.12028126418590546,
-0.652864933013916,
0.2444625049829483,
0.043837521225214005,
0.18683111667633057,
-0.26747965812683105,
-0.48089998960494995,
-0.22955800592899323,
0.074351966381073,
0.019089600071310997,
-0.15960292518138885,
0.1356646865606308,
1.0001294612884521,
0.012619500048458576,
0.39607274532318115,
-0.22325071692466736,
0.06506111472845078,
0.21332864463329315,
0.17612901329994202,
0.10025668889284134,
-0.10559840500354767,
-0.02277310937643051,
0.21026961505413055,
0.2544296383857727,
-0.04991478845477104,
-0.41879817843437195,
0.7829297184944153,
-0.9192920923233032,
-0.7112939357757568,
-0.4062321186065674,
-0.32204321026802063,
-0.029614338651299477,
0.41447874903678894,
0.5390197038650513,
0.6624093055725098,
-0.3832005560398102,
-0.08682730048894882,
0.28224191069602966,
-0.0719887837767601,
0.5178638696670532,
1.0747263431549072,
-0.547849178314209,
-0.40214693546295166,
0.611615002155304,
0.711467981338501,
0.13835132122039795,
0.39815327525138855,
0.12508927285671234,
-0.4915076196193695,
-0.7356933951377869,
-0.24648377299308777,
0.1984613537788391,
-0.9266023635864258,
0.05152733623981476,
-0.4736579656600952,
-0.30823877453804016,
-0.3494504988193512,
0.18785037100315094,
-0.16253304481506348,
-0.25406134128570557,
-0.3289314806461334,
-0.006587475072592497,
0.4245961308479309,
0.9639543294906616,
-0.47373268008232117,
0.18106423318386078,
-0.6693598628044128,
0.3632759153842926,
0.5077463388442993,
0.3411065936088562,
-0.11464563757181168,
-0.8291298747062683,
-0.2760324478149414,
0.08688490837812424,
0.11615796387195587,
-1.014804482460022,
0.4760345220565796,
0.3545735478401184,
0.945716142654419,
0.16914749145507812,
-0.3934485614299774,
0.6092041730880737,
-0.8443588614463806,
0.5958361029624939,
0.13471032679080963,
-1.179250955581665,
0.7215513586997986,
-0.22653894126415253,
0.1637413501739502,
0.09079708158969879,
0.5396157503128052,
-0.8193635940551758,
-0.5870081782341003,
-0.49283328652381897,
-0.593380331993103,
0.47448813915252686,
0.14551083743572235,
-0.17232169210910797,
-0.012147252447903156,
0.30714064836502075,
0.19031891226768494,
0.11405506730079651,
-0.387777715921402,
-0.2570279836654663,
0.18391451239585876,
0.2359434962272644,
-0.13009171187877655,
-0.12022474408149719,
0.04955277964472771,
-0.35581037402153015,
0.5293462872505188,
0.2797175645828247,
0.3809449374675751,
-0.040579311549663544,
-0.08445722609758377,
-0.266258180141449,
0.43163034319877625,
1.0423997640609741,
0.7232078313827515,
-0.2659969627857208,
0.047628290951251984,
0.5507128834724426,
-0.6111879944801331,
0.6434083580970764,
-0.06980148702859879,
0.21467652916908264,
0.30519771575927734,
0.35733819007873535,
0.8889540433883667,
-0.030710594728589058,
-0.3806428015232086,
0.09520193189382553,
-0.27002158761024475,
-0.40359941124916077,
-0.4257361590862274,
0.04383577033877373,
-0.12400020658969879,
0.16170792281627655,
0.3844398558139801,
-0.016430795192718506,
0.5520704984664917,
-0.5047586560249329,
0.17702697217464447,
0.45337215065956116,
-0.224938303232193,
-0.5374671220779419,
0.28063949942588806,
0.1624361276626587,
-0.8710120916366577,
0.7990782260894775,
-0.043282363563776016,
-0.43014413118362427,
0.6422730684280396,
0.6116149425506592,
0.8301258087158203,
-1.0472062826156616,
0.14426834881305695,
0.47959354519844055,
0.1915910840034485,
0.002582753077149391,
0.807933509349823,
0.3084624409675598,
-0.7573227286338806,
-0.4298638105392456,
-0.5107603669166565,
-0.3184141516685486,
0.5482162237167358,
-0.9807120561599731,
0.4984169900417328,
-0.3096233606338501,
-0.3391973376274109,
0.4853333532810211,
0.09569334238767624,
-0.7952587604522705,
0.49983468651771545,
-0.14677156507968903,
0.4888874888420105,
-1.0906685590744019,
0.5980658531188965,
0.8754637837409973,
-0.07111814618110657,
-0.6829566359519958,
-0.232960507273674,
-0.1006966233253479,
-0.9334200620651245,
1.043569564819336,
-0.05715455114841461,
-0.541117787361145,
-0.2960839867591858,
0.019631093367934227,
-0.9015203714370728,
0.42571821808815,
0.4535377323627472,
-0.579875111579895,
0.2826480269432068,
0.2214786261320114,
0.7447916269302368,
-0.414297878742218,
0.39727917313575745,
0.5948158502578735,
0.7402284145355225,
-0.1561591625213623,
-1.6323164701461792,
-0.3123292326927185,
-0.19517108798027039,
-0.2677224576473236,
0.3764328062534332,
-0.27973583340644836,
1.2309544086456299,
-0.09944742918014526,
-0.5047162175178528,
0.2010142207145691,
0.34754064679145813,
0.1826714128255844,
-0.02192842774093151,
0.4492076635360718,
0.37207040190696716,
0.8995984196662903,
-0.052278731018304825,
0.5651648640632629,
-0.2765004336833954,
0.1517166644334793,
0.8168564438819885,
-0.2136395424604416,
1.327567219734192,
0.323504239320755,
-0.545987606048584,
0.10571935027837753,
0.8602067828178406,
0.16499194502830505,
0.5363857746124268,
0.28110769391059875,
-0.3916321098804474,
-0.1369692087173462,
-0.05792533606290817,
-0.7152153849601746,
0.7252640724182129,
0.4431460499763489,
-0.11489152163267136,
-0.06882230937480927,
0.236550971865654,
-0.038484133780002594,
-0.10178681463003159,
-0.392800897359848,
1.0362677574157715,
-0.12204699218273163,
-0.793449878692627,
0.8148118853569031,
-0.08600662648677826,
0.37184494733810425,
-0.7133855223655701,
-0.22313153743743896,
-0.04708937183022499,
-0.08137587457895279,
-0.17266231775283813,
-0.794194221496582,
0.20869006216526031,
-0.18310768902301788,
-0.3327011466026306,
0.42350834608078003,
0.6863358020782471,
-0.8283295631408691,
-0.4220653772354126,
0.7493150234222412,
0.2848861813545227,
0.5818334221839905,
0.21700327098369598,
-0.5240780711174011,
0.201602503657341,
-0.06509765237569809,
0.07665751129388809,
0.04461101070046425,
0.12392150610685349,
0.3317061960697174,
0.7553980946540833,
0.3816935420036316,
0.7095234394073486,
0.25492316484451294,
0.09726522862911224,
0.16739949584007263,
-0.40839678049087524,
-0.8845350742340088,
-0.6188252568244934,
0.44892409443855286,
0.24417969584465027,
-0.4402084946632385,
0.5282860994338989,
0.4174370765686035,
0.8402318358421326,
-0.29285967350006104,
0.7911433577537537,
0.5646862387657166,
0.8907111883163452,
-0.9800338745117188,
0.6001443862915039,
-0.7136707901954651,
0.00016800132289063185,
-0.1250014752149582,
-1.2018762826919556,
-0.3804289400577545,
0.9183197021484375,
0.11929647624492645,
0.34923484921455383,
0.7866901159286499,
0.8751712441444397,
-0.03782370686531067,
-0.16767457127571106,
0.786043107509613,
0.11373160779476166,
0.10541922599077225,
0.20386333763599396,
0.9605882167816162,
-0.2689341604709625,
0.3302484154701233,
0.30744192004203796,
-0.047638460993766785,
-0.258922278881073,
-0.8289502263069153,
-0.6820305585861206,
-1.3024669885635376,
-0.5317906141281128,
-0.1950814127922058,
0.5010188221931458,
0.9700425267219543,
0.8987590074539185,
-1.0336705446243286,
-0.7958754897117615,
0.4002256691455841,
0.1425478458404541,
-0.23848406970500946,
-0.06752113252878189,
0.13824480772018433,
-0.2287096232175827,
-1.0266295671463013,
0.552789032459259,
0.32388779520988464,
0.5322890281677246,
-0.27245664596557617,
-0.19527870416641235,
-0.31189727783203125,
0.25401416420936584,
0.21222129464149475,
0.6725026965141296,
-0.9383348822593689,
-0.5905402302742004,
-0.22847451269626617,
0.298878014087677,
0.3725649118423462,
0.6045757532119751,
-0.527262806892395,
0.6500844955444336,
0.900920569896698,
0.012811275199055672,
0.02081683650612831,
-0.7702113389968872,
0.7137472033500671,
-0.7857606410980225,
0.37010255455970764,
-0.11327888816595078,
0.6662336587905884,
0.3941538333892822,
-0.19209426641464233,
-0.1445581316947937,
-0.04464663192629814,
-0.7499223947525024,
-0.6703162789344788,
0.37045273184776306,
-0.7302983999252319,
-0.04287511855363846,
1.0501701831817627,
-0.16140645742416382,
0.19793249666690826,
-0.4973941743373871,
-0.34048569202423096,
0.26917868852615356,
-0.5408965349197388,
0.4957614541053772,
1.2856756448745728,
0.10072527080774307,
-0.2027846872806549,
-0.4349481165409088,
0.753204882144928,
0.1361209601163864,
-0.4262881875038147,
-0.37536606192588806,
0.10501103103160858,
0.4682541489601135,
0.3084341287612915,
0.4835829436779022,
0.24208654463291168,
0.40828466415405273,
0.2841765284538269,
0.0008184222388081253,
0.45100051164627075,
-0.7594425082206726,
-0.532586395740509,
0.03537892922759056,
0.6604815721511841,
-0.5219525098800659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14887v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14887v4 | The Power of Noise: Redefining Retrieval for RAG Systems | 2024-01-26T14:14:59 | 2024-05-01T08:15:07 | Florin Cuconasu, Giovanni Trappolini, Federico Siciliano, Simone Filice, Cesare Campagnano, Yoelle Maarek, Nicola Tonellotto, Fabrizio Silvestri | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has recently emerged as a method to
extend beyond the pre-trained knowledge of Large Language Models by augmenting
the original prompt with relevant passages or documents retrieved by an
Information Retrieval (IR) system. RAG has become increasingly important for
Generative AI solutions, especially in enterprise settings or in any domain in
which knowledge is constantly refreshed and cannot be memorized in the LLM. We
argue here that the retrieval component of RAG systems, be it dense or sparse,
deserves increased attention from the research community, and accordingly, we
conduct the first comprehensive and systematic examination of the retrieval
strategy of RAG systems. We focus, in particular, on the type of passages IR
systems within a RAG solution should retrieve. Our analysis considers multiple
factors, such as the relevance of the passages included in the prompt context,
their position, and their number. One counter-intuitive finding of this work is
that the retriever's highest-scoring documents that are not directly relevant
to the query (e.g., do not contain the answer) negatively impact the
effectiveness of the LLM. Even more surprising, we discovered that adding
random documents in the prompt improves the LLM accuracy by up to 35%. These
results highlight the need to investigate the appropriate strategies when
integrating retrieval with LLMs, thereby laying the groundwork for future
research in this area. | [
-0.512802004814148,
-0.46013951301574707,
0.4865007698535919,
0.17871251702308655,
-0.358396053314209,
0.2648974359035492,
-0.12275159358978271,
-0.6058247089385986,
0.29674455523490906,
0.33941054344177246,
-0.22697778046131134,
-0.07037796825170517,
-0.6999202370643616,
0.15842987596988678,
-0.6663798689842224,
1.070222020149231,
0.3930383026599884,
-0.07358800619840622,
-0.3692445158958435,
-0.13668465614318848,
-0.4571208655834198,
-0.3696106970310211,
-0.6819572448730469,
-0.5185206532478333,
0.7513032555580139,
0.1608387529850006,
0.5562722682952881,
0.4866992235183716,
0.8297023177146912,
0.2954217493534088,
-0.3733481466770172,
0.31417903304100037,
-0.6675353050231934,
0.6132303476333618,
-0.04575279355049133,
-0.5804701447486877,
-0.20774681866168976,
-0.0952933132648468,
0.6567022204399109,
0.576028048992157,
-0.22096320986747742,
0.3383689522743225,
0.20691590011119843,
0.8414594531059265,
-0.6563467383384705,
0.05791812762618065,
-0.8455318212509155,
0.0382019504904747,
-0.6452160477638245,
-0.45183858275413513,
-0.5551754832267761,
-0.1495695412158966,
-0.0568944476544857,
-0.7337475419044495,
0.346964567899704,
0.33782607316970825,
1.0754308700561523,
0.5797480344772339,
-0.09696454554796219,
-0.5106756687164307,
-1.07400381565094,
0.8863797187805176,
-0.07967761904001236,
0.38972315192222595,
0.3947639763355255,
0.11654302477836609,
-0.15262354910373688,
-0.7185083031654358,
-0.33225226402282715,
-0.21348319947719574,
-0.0960710346698761,
0.3157961070537567,
-0.36047688126564026,
-0.03615700453519821,
0.48242345452308655,
0.4335194528102875,
-0.19148090481758118,
-0.2533416152000427,
-0.5047933459281921,
-0.02332204021513462,
0.4021545350551605,
0.028781354427337646,
0.03067651018500328,
-0.11481458693742752,
-0.14547188580036163,
-0.18311451375484467,
-0.39999091625213623,
-0.2817314863204956,
0.32435381412506104,
0.277619332075119,
0.3891826570034027,
0.41044649481773376,
0.07366260886192322,
0.8167287707328796,
0.3536826968193054,
-0.3438641130924225,
0.2457968294620514,
-0.2516079843044281,
0.0010796189308166504,
-0.13328932225704193,
0.519026517868042,
-0.2884853184223175,
-0.053785186260938644,
-0.44204890727996826,
-0.5678255558013916,
-0.5141436457633972,
0.784639835357666,
-0.49502289295196533,
0.26398950815200806,
-0.07373352348804474,
-0.4528163969516754,
-0.3889250159263611,
0.19819119572639465,
-0.8225277066230774,
-0.6373528242111206,
-0.4254842698574066,
0.5271346569061279,
-0.26736530661582947,
-0.423892080783844,
-0.29658737778663635,
-0.3642376661300659,
0.3898778259754181,
0.33914631605148315,
-0.6069977283477783,
0.11130038648843765,
0.9710352420806885,
0.5667688250541687,
-0.1552412360906601,
0.11564952880144119,
-0.5556259751319885,
0.010763381607830524,
-0.6880905628204346,
0.9812146425247192,
-0.48081380128860474,
-0.6650297045707703,
-0.05759081244468689,
-0.32718005776405334,
0.0380522646009922,
-1.1630055904388428,
0.7773467898368835,
-0.9930718541145325,
-0.031045157462358475,
-0.25462308526039124,
-0.34974220395088196,
0.050765663385391235,
-0.014619396068155766,
-0.7423009872436523,
1.0570765733718872,
0.1017792597413063,
-0.52176833152771,
0.3578733801841736,
-0.4957412779331207,
-0.44513827562332153,
0.2159879058599472,
-0.45145779848098755,
-0.4484119415283203,
0.3583087921142578,
-0.21184556186199188,
0.06475788354873657,
-0.46262258291244507,
0.22567354142665863,
0.043817006051540375,
-0.5046258568763733,
0.29874682426452637,
-0.5395466685295105,
0.5214497447013855,
0.6484280824661255,
-0.2273852676153183,
-0.47834551334381104,
-0.71720290184021,
0.011513885110616684,
-0.11934895813465118,
-0.5370897054672241,
-0.48668932914733887,
-0.1935196816921234,
-0.4038274884223938,
-0.3601319491863251,
0.27778467535972595,
-0.391714870929718,
-0.06561107933521271,
-0.2196183055639267,
-0.26866909861564636,
0.7379229068756104,
-0.005499888677150011,
0.6011446118354797,
-0.7501344680786133,
0.6423715353012085,
-0.059281427413225174,
-0.02582872472703457,
-0.2427091896533966,
-0.3948567509651184,
-0.6984228491783142,
-0.28326889872550964,
0.4500725567340851,
0.43064048886299133,
-0.5634039640426636,
-0.013448311015963554,
-0.1508495956659317,
-0.3910374045372009,
-0.7644292712211609,
0.07627605646848679,
0.4044725298881531,
0.60398930311203,
0.2825202941894531,
-0.023363597691059113,
-0.6257147192955017,
-0.6785693168640137,
-0.486591637134552,
-0.30334973335266113,
0.021077971905469894,
0.8322023749351501,
-0.07793969660997391,
-0.08820877224206924,
0.8885345458984375,
-0.3482626676559448,
-0.4296840727329254,
-0.1563832014799118,
0.3705155551433563,
0.44545987248420715,
0.1854132115840912,
0.247101828455925,
-1.0069175958633423,
-0.3768097758293152,
-0.15403304994106293,
-0.8397117853164673,
-0.4834136366844177,
-0.17268648743629456,
-0.06134713441133499,
0.12145993113517761,
0.8017237782478333,
-0.580200731754303,
0.3587163984775543,
0.11848092079162598,
0.02636300027370453,
0.5194403529167175,
-0.21258509159088135,
0.09037411957979202,
-0.7991098165512085,
0.37347787618637085,
-0.4096657335758209,
0.03111397661268711,
-0.48547494411468506,
0.18213237822055817,
-0.1783604919910431,
-0.21598227322101593,
-0.05138200521469116,
0.7454663515090942,
-0.7417052984237671,
-0.2784888446331024,
-0.45805707573890686,
0.16034193336963654,
0.13032041490077972,
0.09900031238794327,
-0.5208830237388611,
1.1191985607147217,
0.09687363356351852,
-0.8369093537330627,
0.09721563756465912,
-0.034464966505765915,
-0.31189197301864624,
0.6855936050415039,
-0.3906700611114502,
0.30287641286849976,
-0.6184260249137878,
-0.026413550600409508,
-0.7453935146331787,
-0.12095494568347931,
-0.1438317745923996,
-0.556136429309845,
0.6678450703620911,
-0.09345342963933945,
-0.39190778136253357,
-0.21827830374240875,
0.08453056961297989,
0.3141179382801056,
0.78423011302948,
-0.46322330832481384,
0.7515134811401367,
0.664591372013092,
-0.08017096668481827,
-0.8264422416687012,
-0.27174142003059387,
0.10720996558666229,
-0.1961894929409027,
-0.432333379983902,
0.2833930552005768,
0.002951237140223384,
-0.7753061056137085,
-0.006618629675358534,
-0.3638775050640106,
-0.07399491965770721,
0.26666343212127686,
0.2513944208621979,
0.19057051837444305,
-0.04157111793756485,
0.543856680393219,
-0.30427849292755127,
-0.259371280670166,
-0.1046840101480484,
-0.09360501170158386,
0.3874284327030182,
0.1125989481806755,
-0.4293728172779083,
-0.042326316237449646,
0.2644854784011841,
0.42783796787261963,
-0.15972676873207092,
0.43224141001701355,
0.8112471699714661,
-0.013727462850511074,
-0.2709806263446808,
-0.8236328959465027,
-0.19777779281139374,
-0.510422945022583,
0.25255921483039856,
-0.40080034732818604,
-0.7038201093673706,
0.39418578147888184,
-0.24529066681861877,
0.042450450360774994,
0.41374891996383667,
0.2679755687713623,
-0.48604637384414673,
0.7031988501548767,
0.7003973722457886,
-0.14141477644443512,
0.7476136684417725,
-0.24213199317455292,
0.18733300268650055,
-0.9393557906150818,
-0.30661436915397644,
-0.9225983619689941,
-0.3793010413646698,
-0.4403587579727173,
-0.4332585334777832,
0.6471958160400391,
0.32484421133995056,
-0.005319833755493164,
-0.16163311898708344,
-0.6376403570175171,
0.509972095489502,
0.7407953143119812,
0.07900126278400421,
0.5058276653289795,
0.22797998785972595,
-0.021673770621418953,
0.0003384193405508995,
-0.7459765672683716,
-0.22970186173915863,
0.9936835169792175,
0.06476911902427673,
0.932891845703125,
0.08092893660068512,
0.9991786479949951,
0.376288503408432,
0.41542354226112366,
-0.7546693086624146,
0.635202944278717,
-0.2967212200164795,
-0.6683081984519958,
-0.39936894178390503,
-0.4508109390735626,
-1.4291108846664429,
0.18514584004878998,
-0.0269356369972229,
-0.28428325057029724,
0.4068843126296997,
-0.15791116654872894,
-0.4451267123222351,
0.2770584225654602,
-0.4027186632156372,
0.010239788331091404,
0.013336194679141045,
-0.25001031160354614,
-0.25841373205184937,
-0.2694046199321747,
0.21427732706069946,
-0.30956387519836426,
0.3316258490085602,
0.04164054989814758,
-0.14060288667678833,
0.8814160227775574,
-0.19592492282390594,
0.5460883975028992,
-0.0768217220902443,
-0.024912191554903984,
0.5607427358627319,
-0.003341286676004529,
0.6057243347167969,
-0.3697858452796936,
-0.3420383334159851,
0.009170589037239552,
-0.346506804227829,
-0.07345885038375854,
-0.6929905414581299,
0.48338407278060913,
-0.720302939414978,
-0.9242739081382751,
-0.49136537313461304,
-0.5578330755233765,
-0.030010906979441643,
0.28245091438293457,
0.2598537504673004,
0.4273419678211212,
0.045763127505779266,
0.40066543221473694,
1.156845211982727,
-0.140817791223526,
0.364098459482193,
0.7570810317993164,
-0.26318997144699097,
-0.26591917872428894,
1.1882433891296387,
0.44274523854255676,
0.146103635430336,
0.2830183506011963,
0.15266163647174835,
-0.13571974635124207,
-0.5559592843055725,
-0.19350320100784302,
0.33198195695877075,
-0.5806367993354797,
-0.3535606265068054,
-0.7723063230514526,
-0.4599640369415283,
-0.2722415030002594,
0.101600781083107,
-0.2557998299598694,
-0.12244647741317749,
-0.640360951423645,
0.14882059395313263,
0.3600742518901825,
0.9412671327590942,
-0.3916986584663391,
-0.1756410151720047,
-0.8391483426094055,
0.638244092464447,
0.3526935875415802,
0.3493058681488037,
0.05289957672357559,
-0.8302518725395203,
-0.33847978711128235,
-0.3137606978416443,
-0.3289875388145447,
-0.6659643650054932,
0.2356293797492981,
0.07148762047290802,
0.8253852128982544,
0.20774580538272858,
0.23892106115818024,
0.8046926259994507,
-0.41364309191703796,
0.5489374995231628,
-0.22263096272945404,
-0.31109875440597534,
0.38864678144454956,
-0.2551690340042114,
0.28713858127593994,
0.576007604598999,
0.18191255629062653,
-0.331394761800766,
-0.5415188670158386,
-0.9935299754142761,
-0.8873934745788574,
0.6216275691986084,
-0.16809192299842834,
0.16770391166210175,
-0.10212841629981995,
0.5372253060340881,
-0.20708495378494263,
0.3489508628845215,
-0.33689597249031067,
-0.3327118158340454,
0.40439391136169434,
-0.045798398554325104,
0.36883094906806946,
-0.4207744598388672,
-0.12374872714281082,
0.18380406498908997,
0.6175068020820618,
0.20512986183166504,
0.4840600788593292,
0.40823090076446533,
0.12871591746807098,
-0.45171093940734863,
0.2756466269493103,
0.43142592906951904,
0.5972564816474915,
-0.11414366215467453,
-0.06170261651277542,
-0.04163966327905655,
-0.9052858352661133,
0.22238489985466003,
0.0007765769842080772,
-0.7231612801551819,
0.4064691960811615,
0.2838130593299866,
0.5585789680480957,
0.018195748329162598,
-0.4856436252593994,
0.2815520465373993,
0.12836208939552307,
-0.0769401416182518,
-0.45695358514785767,
0.19468475878238678,
-0.3811451196670532,
0.3705417513847351,
0.8662810921669006,
0.22947166860103607,
0.20850379765033722,
-0.4917493760585785,
0.36577552556991577,
0.7198968529701233,
-0.42065438628196716,
0.017405644059181213,
0.4331166744232178,
-0.0005930204060859978,
-0.7049806118011475,
0.5097342133522034,
-0.379603773355484,
-0.19393891096115112,
0.6576718688011169,
0.47026097774505615,
0.9457053542137146,
-0.059969935566186905,
0.20299018919467926,
0.3928608000278473,
0.3744578957557678,
-0.14785480499267578,
0.23215705156326294,
-0.02911737747490406,
-0.5367664694786072,
-0.4387351870536804,
-0.830405056476593,
-0.44583240151405334,
0.20942553877830505,
-0.7120254635810852,
0.05004647746682167,
-0.3100510239601135,
-0.30190637707710266,
-0.3153527081012726,
0.13469251990318298,
-0.4619106948375702,
-0.12573471665382385,
-0.028493916615843773,
0.873607873916626,
-0.1875905990600586,
0.373773455619812,
0.4441235363483429,
-0.39845144748687744,
-0.9167975187301636,
0.16196900606155396,
-0.18300199508666992,
-0.808215856552124,
0.9924468994140625,
-0.37746572494506836,
-0.11873593926429749,
0.09410753101110458,
-0.4510693848133087,
-1.2474557161331177,
1.154821515083313,
0.31826722621917725,
-0.40520018339157104,
0.09140942245721817,
-0.1110876128077507,
0.5508954524993896,
0.016304023563861847,
0.37042853236198425,
0.36200588941574097,
0.5387171506881714,
0.308421790599823,
-1.0058176517486572,
-0.2927607297897339,
-0.0655028447508812,
-0.03399965912103653,
0.2803419828414917,
-0.8634029030799866,
0.8256837725639343,
-0.26937243342399597,
-0.5830785036087036,
0.12288593500852585,
0.6384579539299011,
0.2785472869873047,
0.4988912045955658,
0.4150300920009613,
0.659353494644165,
1.085785984992981,
-0.019415168091654778,
1.2242411375045776,
-0.18216706812381744,
-0.10736928135156631,
1.0663946866989136,
-0.12036560475826263,
0.7600761651992798,
0.5537968873977661,
-0.2136785238981247,
0.3063491880893707,
0.1708526760339737,
0.05644973739981651,
0.4452885687351227,
0.2969600260257721,
-0.5557414293289185,
0.028645778074860573,
-0.4762175381183624,
-0.42131301760673523,
0.18959617614746094,
0.36743098497390747,
-0.3757271468639374,
-0.2760039269924164,
0.07502345740795135,
-0.039202380925416946,
0.04092083126306534,
-0.27843689918518066,
1.3328362703323364,
0.10809017717838287,
-0.8533207774162292,
0.6037985682487488,
-0.45058977603912354,
0.46852922439575195,
-0.4500005841255188,
-0.18898962438106537,
-0.5021253228187561,
0.06351519376039505,
-0.16802482306957245,
-0.6123311519622803,
0.4219149351119995,
-0.0280536450445652,
-0.4767257571220398,
-0.3784284293651581,
1.0399343967437744,
-0.203640878200531,
-0.34963446855545044,
0.16959068179130554,
0.6526150703430176,
0.3804436922073364,
0.05817326530814171,
-0.6589934825897217,
0.29731595516204834,
0.02519088424742222,
-0.15303421020507812,
0.5697791576385498,
0.8035879135131836,
0.2293766438961029,
0.7209389805793762,
0.7051424384117126,
0.2810494899749756,
0.09622783958911896,
0.22581090033054352,
0.8851410746574402,
-0.48154380917549133,
-0.10235297679901123,
-0.394370973110199,
0.286670058965683,
-0.016498388722538948,
-0.036331579089164734,
0.7547782063484192,
0.4104193150997162,
0.6111396551132202,
0.3150312602519989,
0.7572162747383118,
0.012760192155838013,
0.9623553156852722,
-0.3162878751754761,
0.7289438247680664,
-0.6164612770080566,
0.7470260858535767,
-0.16050919890403748,
-0.8512173295021057,
0.005769453477114439,
0.46430349349975586,
-0.09766987711191177,
0.17822673916816711,
0.4936651885509491,
1.0581258535385132,
0.18475475907325745,
-0.1125941053032875,
0.5331955552101135,
0.42192012071609497,
0.19576582312583923,
-0.14226318895816803,
0.8556470274925232,
-0.5202974081039429,
0.9843782782554626,
0.07197441160678864,
-0.21859073638916016,
-0.19924798607826233,
-0.6571333408355713,
-0.24186575412750244,
-0.5561158061027527,
-0.07462547719478607,
-0.4165785014629364,
0.24612313508987427,
0.40535545349121094,
0.3933010697364807,
-0.4364059567451477,
-0.31055593490600586,
0.04026457294821739,
0.44801226258277893,
-0.09624910354614258,
-0.27805227041244507,
-0.02301204204559326,
-1.1320374011993408,
-0.5100910067558289,
0.5123722553253174,
0.24839821457862854,
-0.06654094904661179,
-0.24089889228343964,
0.07422370463609695,
-0.10328400880098343,
0.07953653484582901,
0.3877320885658264,
0.4063001871109009,
-0.5409227609634399,
-0.01259929034858942,
0.33515673875808716,
-0.34885555505752563,
0.04626439884305,
0.7897058129310608,
-0.9632870554924011,
0.4366314709186554,
0.5152524709701538,
0.9348936080932617,
0.40633153915405273,
0.20792846381664276,
0.3341505527496338,
-0.7473564147949219,
0.000584403402172029,
0.5749848484992981,
0.01626761443912983,
0.07157494127750397,
-0.4378189742565155,
0.6413182616233826,
0.34979724884033203,
-0.8714243769645691,
-1.018642544746399,
-0.008829344063997269,
-0.6172954440116882,
-0.22590272128582,
1.1978131532669067,
0.07290460169315338,
-0.3186694085597992,
-0.4496462047100067,
-0.23647145926952362,
0.08788936585187912,
-0.43346893787384033,
0.9868308305740356,
0.5881035923957825,
-0.10503286123275757,
-0.17193393409252167,
-0.5491845011711121,
0.6588993668556213,
0.5376206040382385,
-0.4387134313583374,
0.055640626698732376,
0.37842458486557007,
-0.1839233636856079,
0.850014865398407,
0.9782539010047913,
-0.3322868049144745,
0.18480589985847473,
0.14829972386360168,
-0.2041783630847931,
0.0338975191116333,
-0.42067644000053406,
-0.3520640432834625,
0.3572644889354706,
0.2530602216720581,
0.029863890260457993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14869v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14869v1 | F-Eval: Asssessing Fundamental Abilities with Refined Evaluation Methods | 2024-01-26T13:55:32 | 2024-01-26T13:55:32 | Yu Sun, Keyu Chen, Shujie Wang, Qipeng Guo, Hang Yan, Xipeng Qiu, Xuanjing Huang, Dahua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) garner significant attention for their
unprecedented performance, leading to an increasing number of researches
evaluating LLMs. However, these evaluation benchmarks are limited to assessing
the instruction-following capabilities, overlooking the fundamental abilities
that emerge during the pre-training stage. Previous subjective evaluation
methods mainly reply on scoring by API models. However, in the absence of
references, large models have shown limited ability to discern subtle
differences. To bridge the gap, we propose F-Eval, a bilingual evaluation
benchmark to evaluate the fundamental abilities, including expression,
commonsense and logic. The tasks in F-Eval include multi-choice objective
tasks, open-ended objective tasks, reference-based subjective tasks and
reference-free subjective tasks. For reference-free subjective tasks, we devise
new evaluation methods, serving as alternatives to scoring by API models. We
conduct evaluations on 13 advanced LLMs. Results show that our evaluation
methods show higher correlation coefficients and larger distinction than other
evaluators. Additionally, we discuss the influence of different model sizes,
dimensions, and normalization methods. We anticipate that F-Eval will
facilitate the study of LLMs' fundamental abilities. | [
-0.3988346457481384,
-0.9559227228164673,
0.6116556525230408,
0.36530473828315735,
-0.02889689989387989,
0.2935723066329956,
-0.5516119599342346,
-0.29727569222450256,
-0.13355493545532227,
0.4696830213069916,
-0.4220797121524811,
-0.5427500009536743,
-0.599646806716919,
0.3757760524749756,
-0.3881419003009796,
0.8181494474411011,
-0.22402507066726685,
0.2589225769042969,
-0.3396317660808563,
-0.12028719484806061,
-0.27167052030563354,
-0.42851874232292175,
-0.3665193021297455,
-0.27901914715766907,
0.47995635867118835,
0.4414251148700714,
0.45299118757247925,
0.2946569621562958,
0.670989990234375,
0.36191853880882263,
-0.1195635199546814,
0.16636057198047638,
-0.4503275454044342,
-0.2361709624528885,
-0.42683887481689453,
-0.5254898071289062,
-0.649834394454956,
0.10701066255569458,
0.9888066053390503,
0.9023764133453369,
0.17929844558238983,
0.44982263445854187,
0.04347945377230644,
0.9153116345405579,
-0.6955118775367737,
0.33704519271850586,
-0.5385808348655701,
-0.005509374663233757,
-0.010237435810267925,
0.16316725313663483,
-0.41974300146102905,
-0.5907500982284546,
0.050579383969306946,
-0.2577976584434509,
0.06862764060497284,
-0.07314711809158325,
0.6930997967720032,
0.06118292734026909,
-0.340840220451355,
-0.15452492237091064,
-0.5918089747428894,
1.1039303541183472,
-0.6460491418838501,
0.8103976249694824,
0.26823288202285767,
0.36509227752685547,
0.32548627257347107,
-0.49537384510040283,
-0.3635976016521454,
-0.6896951794624329,
0.11966390162706375,
-0.1701277792453766,
-0.24214527010917664,
0.10489960759878159,
0.26298123598098755,
0.5540433526039124,
-0.2526599168777466,
0.08000517636537552,
-0.459976464509964,
-0.10155291855335236,
0.8407350778579712,
0.271890789270401,
0.1934070587158203,
0.11879891902208328,
-0.22675083577632904,
0.07828967273235321,
-0.77442467212677,
0.2283468395471573,
0.3631056547164917,
0.27264174818992615,
-0.1137150377035141,
0.5239949226379395,
-0.4535773992538452,
0.6166698336601257,
0.10204162448644638,
-0.12656737864017487,
0.4285506308078766,
-0.29212188720703125,
-0.11147263646125793,
-0.49491897225379944,
0.782309889793396,
0.2227240949869156,
0.32161298394203186,
-0.46716129779815674,
-0.5000731348991394,
-0.27177342772483826,
0.29351621866226196,
-0.7288230061531067,
0.17523093521595,
0.00041210890049114823,
-0.5252892374992371,
-0.28292185068130493,
0.02605249173939228,
-0.7313050627708435,
0.06064249575138092,
-0.7386808395385742,
0.6464776992797852,
-0.43486738204956055,
-0.24843910336494446,
-0.05698855593800545,
0.1364499181509018,
0.2387017458677292,
0.33076757192611694,
-0.5943813920021057,
0.6782764792442322,
0.9713946580886841,
0.7300136089324951,
-0.23440375924110413,
-0.5096484422683716,
-0.7652439475059509,
-0.5029996633529663,
-0.3118809163570404,
0.6341260671615601,
-0.7631150484085083,
-0.424452006816864,
0.018126921728253365,
-0.06746023893356323,
-0.07034260034561157,
-0.6470729112625122,
0.7902448773384094,
-0.6293312311172485,
-0.1948438286781311,
-0.478805273771286,
-0.5778191685676575,
-0.3595801293849945,
0.10246672481298447,
-0.5035050511360168,
0.8469871282577515,
0.32886943221092224,
-0.334850549697876,
0.07610227912664413,
-0.8393796682357788,
-0.3675064146518707,
-0.08042055368423462,
0.005080145783722401,
0.11511494964361191,
0.4402804672718048,
0.07406622916460037,
0.38550713658332825,
-0.630680501461029,
0.5116308331489563,
-0.3245486319065094,
-0.4450754225254059,
0.39952102303504944,
-0.6021256446838379,
0.5869085192680359,
-0.012754608877003193,
-0.22839343547821045,
0.1089065745472908,
-0.6505043506622314,
0.2059449702501297,
-0.23604249954223633,
-0.34611400961875916,
-0.10275327414274216,
-0.04703902453184128,
-0.07284146547317505,
0.03998122736811638,
0.5161824822425842,
-0.4791799485683441,
-0.07334763556718826,
-0.561244010925293,
0.0006551667465828359,
0.8033212423324585,
-0.31340041756629944,
0.3614276349544525,
-0.2434123307466507,
0.7143925428390503,
-0.3558460474014282,
0.23885871469974518,
0.02698870189487934,
-0.3247809410095215,
-0.7973794341087341,
-0.2950459420681,
0.4425555169582367,
0.6231535077095032,
-0.6548216342926025,
0.7754371762275696,
-0.43209108710289,
-0.7056484222412109,
-0.635037362575531,
0.6896910667419434,
0.9505869746208191,
0.5402240753173828,
0.33937662839889526,
-0.2003416121006012,
-0.2202765941619873,
-1.2216920852661133,
-0.37806621193885803,
-0.032599810510873795,
-0.15653076767921448,
0.35941949486732483,
0.5938732624053955,
-0.1757817268371582,
0.8283720016479492,
-0.4944815933704376,
-0.023373790085315704,
-0.2954384386539459,
0.230962872505188,
0.406968355178833,
0.2672826647758484,
0.6167886257171631,
-0.5460136532783508,
-0.5095160007476807,
0.060902539640665054,
-0.5614033341407776,
-0.6644262671470642,
0.4112228453159332,
-0.14330747723579407,
-0.02400173619389534,
0.2449585348367691,
-0.18097108602523804,
0.02229369431734085,
0.31131425499916077,
-0.3105062246322632,
0.7267388701438904,
-0.11071663349866867,
0.3367267847061157,
-0.23818998038768768,
0.23029734194278717,
0.10930512100458145,
-0.0942835733294487,
-0.682220995426178,
0.39387333393096924,
0.32588306069374084,
0.029052726924419403,
-0.6976715922355652,
0.9575939178466797,
-0.26015570759773254,
-0.17618688941001892,
-0.3321218192577362,
0.0010840108152478933,
0.07677283883094788,
0.4575660228729248,
0.08819815516471863,
0.7970045208930969,
0.46683576703071594,
-0.3852502405643463,
0.12056885659694672,
-0.15151339769363403,
-0.2645789682865143,
0.549058735370636,
-0.5799484252929688,
0.23475143313407898,
-0.002988471882417798,
-0.1096097081899643,
-0.8387309908866882,
0.021470556035637856,
-0.0593474842607975,
-0.07702810317277908,
0.3616570830345154,
0.08792157471179962,
-0.3808836340904236,
-0.476935476064682,
-0.5612857341766357,
0.3383706510066986,
0.47918060421943665,
-0.40050214529037476,
0.682357668876648,
0.11826231330633163,
-0.27724266052246094,
-0.5305355787277222,
-0.48577767610549927,
-0.1912345141172409,
-0.14594802260398865,
-0.5954107642173767,
0.2227310687303543,
-0.21824896335601807,
-0.398466020822525,
-0.09872521460056305,
-0.2017628699541092,
-0.4337283670902252,
0.2757900655269623,
-0.0030647888779640198,
0.33722418546676636,
-0.5519322156906128,
-0.2018793523311615,
0.27701422572135925,
-0.05408451706171036,
0.1287512630224228,
0.24825966358184814,
0.33198219537734985,
-0.7084081768989563,
-0.43370193243026733,
-0.42351993918418884,
0.15728625655174255,
0.5568900108337402,
-0.35918089747428894,
0.3815673887729645,
0.3848671615123749,
-0.2140144258737564,
-0.07014402747154236,
-0.8914024233818054,
0.044858288019895554,
-0.48343998193740845,
0.40769442915916443,
-0.42459216713905334,
-0.7314543128013611,
0.44676050543785095,
-0.000559116480872035,
0.1358538568019867,
0.3419699966907501,
0.4179023802280426,
0.17569231986999512,
0.7248737215995789,
0.24478082358837128,
0.16731667518615723,
0.33629387617111206,
-0.3323032259941101,
0.159755140542984,
-1.1604846715927124,
-0.05825180560350418,
-0.4411899447441101,
-0.25798895955085754,
0.10398279130458832,
-0.7217490673065186,
0.34089383482933044,
0.39059126377105713,
-0.25848841667175293,
0.03215643763542175,
-0.15462762117385864,
0.7887139916419983,
0.27905023097991943,
0.12090457230806351,
0.25937554240226746,
-0.22536997497081757,
-0.19353750348091125,
-0.14910827577114105,
-0.06643445789813995,
-0.8516483902931213,
1.603185772895813,
0.564195454120636,
0.3840066194534302,
0.07798988372087479,
0.5983335971832275,
0.34622952342033386,
1.0598678588867188,
-0.8503116965293884,
0.8279762864112854,
-0.5152681469917297,
-0.44136443734169006,
-0.1656392365694046,
-0.3330208957195282,
-0.4809398651123047,
0.5484039783477783,
-0.026090722531080246,
-0.8608435988426208,
-0.24538439512252808,
-0.12767304480075836,
-0.3656539022922516,
0.08157239109277725,
-0.8560750484466553,
0.7427366375923157,
-0.6417763829231262,
-0.5913838744163513,
-0.37462306022644043,
-0.15308649837970734,
0.6908944845199585,
-0.4007962644100189,
0.38882648944854736,
-0.20328709483146667,
-0.3231016993522644,
0.7296288013458252,
-0.27994436025619507,
0.6987484097480774,
-0.3762221932411194,
-0.09635811299085617,
0.16107575595378876,
0.032137613743543625,
0.00581397907808423,
0.019843690097332,
-0.4203735888004303,
0.44156497716903687,
-0.07713901996612549,
-0.1625744104385376,
-0.6533858180046082,
0.8158194422721863,
-0.7321145534515381,
-0.7672684788703918,
-0.017833486199378967,
-0.3025932013988495,
-0.5800309181213379,
0.16396498680114746,
-0.28037962317466736,
0.3269197642803192,
-0.5366515517234802,
0.3159884512424469,
0.31491783261299133,
-0.35954248905181885,
0.23970437049865723,
1.0258030891418457,
-0.43020933866500854,
-0.6196537613868713,
0.9558767676353455,
0.14148440957069397,
0.2635248303413391,
0.5263470411300659,
0.3886512517929077,
-0.48796549439430237,
-0.5441417098045349,
-0.31953004002571106,
0.28971755504608154,
-0.7072689533233643,
-0.2645460367202759,
-0.6667837500572205,
-0.14742350578308105,
-0.2160005122423172,
-0.42699939012527466,
-0.43809041380882263,
-0.19887873530387878,
-0.005979572422802448,
-0.10486596077680588,
-0.010609173215925694,
0.4418295621871948,
-0.13219818472862244,
0.1975124031305313,
-0.8048689961433411,
0.5446915030479431,
0.3801869750022888,
0.43040505051612854,
0.2962377965450287,
-0.438293993473053,
-0.02099534310400486,
0.10550685971975327,
-0.5719190239906311,
-0.7571303844451904,
0.061481352895498276,
0.19049645960330963,
0.8002498745918274,
0.5807215571403503,
-0.23420245945453644,
0.45197436213493347,
-0.6735813021659851,
0.7195855379104614,
0.07590765506029129,
-1.3541353940963745,
0.46771952509880066,
-0.17629797756671906,
-0.07398293912410736,
0.7285308837890625,
0.2486359030008316,
-0.08881644159555435,
-0.3738067150115967,
-0.5549396872520447,
-0.6398830413818359,
0.7834105491638184,
0.11928709596395493,
0.19944240152835846,
-0.07078053802251816,
0.1834261119365692,
0.38750556111335754,
0.39598551392555237,
-0.6210629343986511,
0.04318867623806,
0.06416478753089905,
-0.10113167017698288,
-0.028135674074292183,
-0.1438547819852829,
0.06283070892095566,
-0.6444364786148071,
0.3895294666290283,
-0.08937098830938339,
0.046496253460645676,
0.010573582723736763,
-0.19740261137485504,
0.13102437555789948,
0.405236154794693,
0.4926494061946869,
0.7349653840065002,
-0.20255500078201294,
-0.19945675134658813,
0.5110749006271362,
-0.1693754494190216,
0.1954720914363861,
0.09786020219326019,
-0.010716467164456844,
-0.11929289251565933,
0.5904046297073364,
0.6980561017990112,
0.7691643238067627,
-1.115789771080017,
0.76472407579422,
0.11508028209209442,
-0.1678031086921692,
-0.20888729393482208,
0.3622988760471344,
0.01532443892210722,
0.2184101790189743,
0.3466680347919464,
-0.16927772760391235,
0.21112020313739777,
-0.5845187306404114,
0.08561558276414871,
0.3966042995452881,
-0.18245261907577515,
-0.6191944479942322,
0.3734288215637207,
0.4121468961238861,
-0.5125129818916321,
0.28224489092826843,
-0.12378668785095215,
-0.5019552111625671,
0.7734182476997375,
0.35509517788887024,
1.1483086347579956,
-0.5445203185081482,
0.2424003928899765,
0.2848864793777466,
0.3029989004135132,
-0.017390869557857513,
0.5154960751533508,
-0.32042500376701355,
-0.6304597854614258,
-0.4092809557914734,
-1.0084404945373535,
-0.4746069312095642,
0.24774283170700073,
-0.6736449599266052,
0.3601255714893341,
-0.517383873462677,
0.06002389267086983,
0.058602821081876755,
0.09428396075963974,
-1.0995131731033325,
0.10796478390693665,
0.033888187259435654,
1.047283411026001,
-0.980311930179596,
0.7002596855163574,
0.6500045657157898,
-0.34932926297187805,
-0.5114730596542358,
-0.07857426255941391,
-0.03293146938085556,
-0.7402855753898621,
1.1613632440567017,
0.2627233862876892,
-0.09549234807491302,
-0.306868314743042,
-0.038307007402181625,
-0.6622475385665894,
0.834482729434967,
0.4801047146320343,
-0.5985332131385803,
-0.08799291402101517,
0.22859473526477814,
0.7769911885261536,
-0.5308399200439453,
0.7208442091941833,
0.8375921249389648,
0.7647519707679749,
-0.3385702669620514,
-1.0845438241958618,
-0.15559205412864685,
-0.21709153056144714,
-0.06111671030521393,
-0.017525099217891693,
-0.7021178603172302,
0.830213189125061,
0.041827525943517685,
-0.042701125144958496,
0.20793551206588745,
0.34366777539253235,
0.17504234611988068,
0.33003363013267517,
0.5079149603843689,
0.32008376717567444,
0.6412534713745117,
-0.05375269055366516,
0.9496336579322815,
-0.4907200336456299,
0.2365005612373352,
0.9035519361495972,
-0.5963698625564575,
1.109923243522644,
0.3652231991291046,
-0.41787096858024597,
0.20728662610054016,
-0.029531355947256088,
0.09897851198911667,
0.39125457406044006,
0.3020189106464386,
-0.2957713305950165,
-0.1887364685535431,
0.015346096828579903,
-0.14981284737586975,
0.4889534115791321,
0.5161639451980591,
-0.3907971978187561,
-0.5083171725273132,
0.13742826879024506,
-0.17548950016498566,
0.2513292729854584,
-0.37452468276023865,
0.592221200466156,
0.06022320315241814,
-0.7331314086914062,
0.7546345591545105,
0.128751739859581,
0.6670302748680115,
-0.5862850546836853,
0.09762218594551086,
-0.19273819029331207,
0.1029277890920639,
0.011073359288275242,
-0.8820431232452393,
0.4379431903362274,
0.4721679389476776,
-0.05550192669034004,
-0.3406051993370056,
0.5560164451599121,
-0.09343799948692322,
-0.6486120223999023,
0.5000783801078796,
0.5690955519676208,
0.13580913841724396,
0.01843809150159359,
-0.6906731128692627,
0.021419938653707504,
-0.02547864243388176,
-0.25016239285469055,
0.18201944231987,
0.32476043701171875,
-0.049834951758384705,
0.46340495347976685,
0.6800734996795654,
0.17485059797763824,
-0.08740541338920593,
0.06389021873474121,
0.7336509823799133,
-0.6544361710548401,
-0.14756755530834198,
-0.8488324880599976,
0.48150634765625,
-0.02394721284508705,
-0.4426996111869812,
0.4357629716396332,
0.7238689661026001,
0.7100493311882019,
-0.33163613080978394,
0.6468154788017273,
0.1556386798620224,
0.612969160079956,
-0.6135262846946716,
0.4758542478084564,
-0.5340005159378052,
0.3365326523780823,
-0.36456459760665894,
-1.1356672048568726,
-0.01032788772135973,
0.553150475025177,
-0.7192972302436829,
-0.051784031093120575,
0.7057949304580688,
0.6419006586074829,
-0.2908238470554352,
0.12157570570707321,
0.49752023816108704,
0.1876329779624939,
0.30511602759361267,
0.6410505175590515,
1.027822494506836,
-0.17066799104213715,
0.0055885338224470615,
-0.31099003553390503,
-0.5800884366035461,
-0.22240996360778809,
-0.7611547708511353,
-1.0199241638183594,
-0.37716376781463623,
-0.192596897482872,
0.20137715339660645,
-0.05550606921315193,
0.9014696478843689,
0.46522030234336853,
-0.7080174684524536,
-0.39255937933921814,
0.11691153049468994,
0.1710590422153473,
-0.20056785643100739,
-0.27735087275505066,
0.23906108736991882,
-0.47768479585647583,
-0.8940885066986084,
0.7071864604949951,
0.3688700795173645,
-0.42053836584091187,
-0.42097413539886475,
-0.11142480373382568,
0.09684839099645615,
0.21408163011074066,
0.747445821762085,
0.18736356496810913,
-1.043473243713379,
-0.367068350315094,
-0.03233608230948448,
0.1944522112607956,
-0.17252479493618011,
0.7297092080116272,
-0.631152331829071,
0.21924246847629547,
0.5149000287055969,
0.7253166437149048,
-0.018726259469985962,
-0.03832727298140526,
0.5691435933113098,
-0.48248717188835144,
0.08444178849458694,
0.34210819005966187,
0.4841223955154419,
0.17107681930065155,
0.010595807805657387,
0.5874345898628235,
-0.13223715126514435,
-0.3817901313304901,
-1.0418189764022827,
-0.08734983950853348,
-0.7299045920372009,
-0.09603755176067352,
1.1993014812469482,
-0.361652672290802,
-0.1265539526939392,
0.13749541342258453,
-0.20307978987693787,
-0.18605227768421173,
-0.20770263671875,
0.6999059915542603,
1.0530186891555786,
-0.09182452410459518,
0.11699417978525162,
-0.6601684093475342,
0.11153796315193176,
0.4393772482872009,
-0.7658949494361877,
0.09417805075645447,
0.48672977089881897,
0.4862186908721924,
0.20954923331737518,
0.7047367691993713,
-0.24030311405658722,
0.38264763355255127,
-0.319463849067688,
-0.21725428104400635,
-0.038351111114025116,
-0.3926701545715332,
-0.3939661383628845,
0.21373572945594788,
0.26405155658721924,
0.1760154664516449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.15127v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.15127v3 | Evaluation of LLM Chatbots for OSINT-based Cyber Threat Awareness | 2024-01-26T13:15:24 | 2024-04-19T09:40:04 | Samaneh Shafee, Alysson Bessani, Pedro M. Ferreira | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Knowledge sharing about emerging threats is crucial in the rapidly advancing
field of cybersecurity and forms the foundation of Cyber Threat Intelligence
(CTI). In this context, Large Language Models are becoming increasingly
significant in the field of cybersecurity, presenting a wide range of
opportunities. This study surveys the performance of ChatGPT, GPT4all, Dolly,
Stanford Alpaca, Alpaca-LoRA, Falcon, and Vicuna chatbots in binary
classification and Named Entity Recognition (NER) tasks performed using Open
Source INTelligence (OSINT). We utilize well-established data collected in
previous research from Twitter to assess the competitiveness of these chatbots
when compared to specialized models trained for those tasks. In binary
classification experiments, Chatbot GPT-4 as a commercial model achieved an
acceptable F1 score of 0.94, and the open-source GPT4all model achieved an F1
score of 0.90. However, concerning cybersecurity entity recognition, all
evaluated chatbots have limitations and are less effective. This study
demonstrates the capability of chatbots for OSINT binary classification and
shows that they require further improvement in NER to effectively replace
specially trained models. Our results shed light on the limitations of the LLM
chatbots when compared to specialized models, and can help researchers improve
chatbots technology with the objective to reduce the required effort to
integrate machine learning in OSINT-based CTI tools. | [
-0.22813916206359863,
-0.8192015290260315,
0.4328264594078064,
-0.03473474457859993,
-0.1897740364074707,
0.3012794256210327,
-0.17216069996356964,
-1.0113235712051392,
0.14819104969501495,
0.34053900837898254,
-0.35623061656951904,
-0.5902929306030273,
-0.8350634574890137,
0.20266585052013397,
-0.5190333724021912,
0.984731137752533,
0.1784520149230957,
-0.30504024028778076,
-0.1508183777332306,
0.018796946853399277,
-0.6659418344497681,
-0.6691539883613586,
-0.7543805241584778,
-0.08324099332094193,
0.23793521523475647,
0.11631856858730316,
0.4529813528060913,
0.03798104450106621,
0.9135463833808899,
0.4559868574142456,
0.033094413578510284,
-0.044983845204114914,
-0.6696768403053284,
0.11511695384979248,
-0.09907069802284241,
-0.5602800250053406,
-0.41943004727363586,
-0.06577089428901672,
0.23009461164474487,
0.10268423706293106,
-0.07211749255657196,
0.07981032133102417,
-0.09654005616903305,
0.11417265236377716,
-0.3745405375957489,
0.37138739228248596,
-1.1917839050292969,
-0.05503186956048012,
-0.2043410688638687,
-0.30700236558914185,
-0.4781182110309601,
-0.37993165850639343,
0.3942878544330597,
-0.548954963684082,
-0.06261783838272095,
0.13315731287002563,
0.6890146136283875,
0.17894096672534943,
-0.05679722875356674,
-0.5108230710029602,
-0.8479430675506592,
0.7559537291526794,
-0.6349801421165466,
0.3634492754936218,
0.1686791181564331,
0.39459916949272156,
-0.17071978747844696,
-0.4542994201183319,
-0.3317514955997467,
-0.3171856105327606,
0.2821767032146454,
0.14180168509483337,
-0.7092900276184082,
0.013402125798165798,
0.2898218333721161,
0.0040862662717700005,
-0.4389275312423706,
0.43731823563575745,
-0.7410821914672852,
-0.3074095547199249,
0.6397163271903992,
0.20046834647655487,
0.18597596883773804,
0.2316385954618454,
-0.5595221519470215,
0.07263639569282532,
-0.5199538469314575,
0.006571892648935318,
0.40369492769241333,
0.3336338698863983,
-0.19577667117118835,
0.5048178434371948,
-0.2821333408355713,
0.4491616487503052,
-0.10400709509849548,
-0.4411623179912567,
0.32209673523902893,
-0.20559924840927124,
-0.16316352784633636,
0.17879539728164673,
1.0049877166748047,
0.47073888778686523,
0.12521986663341522,
-0.2298550307750702,
-0.3023681342601776,
0.18353289365768433,
0.508382260799408,
-0.7444934248924255,
-0.006719059310853481,
0.14427456259727478,
-0.2761463522911072,
-0.38012367486953735,
-0.05684059113264084,
-0.3308357894420624,
-0.5702316761016846,
-0.05148209631443024,
0.5882039070129395,
-0.5448908805847168,
-0.23496386408805847,
-0.007946986705064774,
-0.31769582629203796,
0.2913382947444916,
0.6833957433700562,
-0.3735959827899933,
0.3390480875968933,
0.7494325041770935,
0.8905571103096008,
-0.26160088181495667,
0.08792130649089813,
-0.06611845642328262,
-0.34217002987861633,
-0.19117529690265656,
0.678956151008606,
-0.43864789605140686,
-0.37689492106437683,
-0.21238790452480316,
-0.36017733812332153,
-0.1888771802186966,
-0.32143351435661316,
0.29512518644332886,
-0.6950355768203735,
0.010174807161092758,
0.2843462824821472,
-0.3905113637447357,
-0.310658723115921,
0.5396994948387146,
-0.4586294889450073,
0.765066385269165,
0.1146247461438179,
-0.875685453414917,
0.089876189827919,
-0.7739216685295105,
-0.1815819889307022,
0.4600945711135864,
-0.21544106304645538,
-0.21835893392562866,
-0.01749989204108715,
0.014494454488158226,
0.658967137336731,
-0.6197239756584167,
0.0965123251080513,
-0.38950034976005554,
-0.4891761243343353,
0.4089542031288147,
-0.4535061717033386,
0.5853397250175476,
0.03591952100396156,
-0.4732731878757477,
0.14945225417613983,
-0.40973907709121704,
0.032188914716243744,
0.16347013413906097,
-0.08587788790464401,
-0.2574491798877716,
-0.05351212993264198,
-0.11323148757219315,
0.13447818160057068,
0.2471865713596344,
-0.8159911632537842,
-0.016279036179184914,
-0.37638741731643677,
0.5847225189208984,
0.8022449612617493,
-0.047041039913892746,
0.05002544820308685,
-0.17224951088428497,
0.5382664203643799,
-0.0010938511695712805,
0.3619896173477173,
0.21473369002342224,
-0.8567211627960205,
-0.6319566369056702,
-0.19852271676063538,
0.24201665818691254,
0.8682536482810974,
-0.8426716923713684,
0.32195428013801575,
-0.5735190510749817,
-0.7875665426254272,
-0.46985316276550293,
-0.061571743339300156,
0.25060611963272095,
0.3873079717159271,
0.22306644916534424,
-0.39487725496292114,
-0.40162476897239685,
-0.9360461235046387,
0.0608375258743763,
-0.4640706479549408,
0.001863562618382275,
0.41096609830856323,
0.5842164754867554,
-0.4338834285736084,
0.9689009785652161,
-0.27245643734931946,
-0.16470809280872345,
-0.5167397856712341,
0.17061404883861542,
0.05364377424120903,
0.04401232674717903,
0.5756959915161133,
-0.6426264643669128,
-0.3057820796966553,
0.11109431833028793,
-0.6779904961585999,
0.10908261686563492,
0.2080378383398056,
0.2365204244852066,
0.30912354588508606,
0.38303032517433167,
-0.3524557948112488,
0.6998561024665833,
0.47974446415901184,
0.08148148655891418,
0.3842690587043762,
0.07772249728441238,
0.23843194544315338,
-0.9022620916366577,
-0.02533109113574028,
0.020051883533596992,
-0.22080186009407043,
-0.8334595561027527,
-0.06226658821105957,
-0.11384773254394531,
-0.14458219707012177,
-0.82967209815979,
0.4885643720626831,
-0.11961324512958527,
-0.054606761783361435,
-0.276094526052475,
0.4781014919281006,
-0.6554285287857056,
0.3379894196987152,
0.045642368495464325,
0.7529622316360474,
0.5866783857345581,
-0.638115406036377,
0.4976345896720886,
0.016691060736775398,
-0.494610995054245,
0.5260262489318848,
-0.9518690705299377,
0.40996482968330383,
0.26789620518684387,
0.14247038960456848,
-0.7300871014595032,
-0.11444421857595444,
0.46594348549842834,
-0.5948666930198669,
0.12635982036590576,
-0.021225905045866966,
-0.4397759437561035,
-0.33857646584510803,
-0.32316839694976807,
0.2427985966205597,
0.5021193027496338,
-0.23094677925109863,
0.5990627408027649,
0.5996943712234497,
-0.10303690284490585,
-0.6806365251541138,
-0.5786116123199463,
0.15456263720989227,
-0.3070022463798523,
-0.5869676470756531,
0.11940771341323853,
-0.03900589048862457,
-0.2854290008544922,
-0.1290811002254486,
-0.13147799670696259,
0.04720071330666542,
0.3976577818393707,
0.6280609369277954,
0.4255237877368927,
-0.2583834230899811,
0.02964484505355358,
-0.42973092198371887,
-0.06857053190469742,
-0.007807494141161442,
-0.0723346471786499,
0.6681936383247375,
-0.5821186304092407,
-0.3496286869049072,
-0.6084772348403931,
-0.10128885507583618,
0.33940133452415466,
-0.1706177294254303,
0.7950478196144104,
0.6061491370201111,
-0.350686252117157,
0.18639768660068512,
-0.7924866080284119,
-0.10523899644613266,
-0.4548588693141937,
0.35453322529792786,
-0.3109820485115051,
-1.2305983304977417,
0.35477110743522644,
0.10102390497922897,
0.14068180322647095,
0.5931534171104431,
0.3717077970504761,
0.11538931727409363,
0.6094664335250854,
0.6251384019851685,
-0.37963172793388367,
0.5318238139152527,
-0.11488868296146393,
0.2535366117954254,
-0.5551320910453796,
-0.15644808113574982,
-0.5428221225738525,
-0.15355180203914642,
-0.8955058455467224,
-0.29601067304611206,
0.35577213764190674,
-0.3635033667087555,
-0.024484796449542046,
0.7893400192260742,
-0.3744198679924011,
0.283915638923645,
0.5199492573738098,
0.20577098429203033,
0.10599425435066223,
-0.043587327003479004,
0.300678014755249,
0.40846216678619385,
-0.4490649700164795,
-0.5422710180282593,
1.136998176574707,
0.5997982621192932,
0.7673959136009216,
0.1684981733560562,
0.7274143099784851,
0.3990825414657593,
0.28465262055397034,
-0.927323579788208,
0.8756552338600159,
0.08619386702775955,
-0.4347383975982666,
-0.40356212854385376,
-0.6708220839500427,
-1.113351821899414,
-0.09769438207149506,
-0.3657931089401245,
-1.1513583660125732,
-0.19048306345939636,
-0.22514565289020538,
-0.3699205219745636,
0.32215574383735657,
-0.5301716923713684,
0.5000700354576111,
-0.1762007474899292,
0.15254637598991394,
-0.3391764163970947,
-0.6693524122238159,
0.2757743299007416,
-0.2425764501094818,
0.1303040087223053,
-0.30456024408340454,
-0.10409842431545258,
0.7516122460365295,
0.02470381185412407,
0.943159818649292,
0.01939799077808857,
-0.060473907738924026,
0.4144792854785919,
-0.0785454660654068,
0.3040240705013275,
-0.09455323219299316,
-0.15839752554893494,
0.7408578991889954,
-0.30968767404556274,
0.026869473978877068,
-0.33019211888313293,
0.560748815536499,
-0.8748652935028076,
-0.8008113503456116,
-0.424766480922699,
-0.3232296109199524,
-0.1547410488128662,
0.24445734918117523,
0.1717619001865387,
0.36826151609420776,
-0.34728190302848816,
0.4972236454486847,
0.6617027521133423,
-0.29635924100875854,
0.2857121229171753,
0.44261178374290466,
-0.047710590064525604,
-0.3350711464881897,
0.7501016855239868,
0.08291086554527283,
0.3937528133392334,
0.6582063436508179,
0.0019325321773067117,
-0.045682795345783234,
-0.7203577160835266,
-0.20087365806102753,
0.06804487109184265,
-0.6559006571769714,
-0.457623690366745,
-0.8428361415863037,
-0.6335164308547974,
-0.5054387450218201,
-0.014110500924289227,
-0.1651810109615326,
-0.45047804713249207,
-0.011294695548713207,
-0.016088005155324936,
0.5824759602546692,
0.9045882821083069,
0.4190780520439148,
0.5312550663948059,
-0.6934581995010376,
0.10319377481937408,
0.14788618683815002,
0.262256920337677,
-0.3064749836921692,
-0.46425434947013855,
-0.02468188852071762,
-0.0076247453689575195,
-0.28345391154289246,
-0.9489079117774963,
0.2222670018672943,
-0.0320562906563282,
0.6917778253555298,
0.3747052252292633,
0.18093737959861755,
0.4892001748085022,
-0.2504233419895172,
0.6945475339889526,
0.30321481823921204,
-0.828873872756958,
0.577565610408783,
-0.22337718307971954,
0.030185749754309654,
0.39930838346481323,
0.4518657624721527,
-0.41516560316085815,
-0.4950962960720062,
-0.6911607980728149,
-0.5874271392822266,
0.9872649908065796,
0.46943649649620056,
0.16226007044315338,
-0.09161093086004257,
-0.0041711051017045975,
0.03560612350702286,
0.22910667955875397,
-0.6511725783348083,
-0.08578936755657196,
0.08804488182067871,
-0.09484399855136871,
0.11277574300765991,
-0.03954032063484192,
0.05149870738387108,
0.3713075816631317,
0.7992475628852844,
0.054244235157966614,
0.5903021097183228,
-0.11461609601974487,
-0.09732934087514877,
0.31100356578826904,
0.38293516635894775,
0.5798929929733276,
0.31938475370407104,
-0.24614551663398743,
-0.2012718766927719,
0.4640984535217285,
-0.6375948190689087,
-0.1025877296924591,
0.04242115467786789,
-0.08576425909996033,
-0.12002759426832199,
0.33593040704727173,
0.835985541343689,
0.13398833572864532,
-0.6825107336044312,
0.6444922685623169,
-0.3572826683521271,
-0.017596490681171417,
-0.376198947429657,
0.42227262258529663,
-0.1120041012763977,
0.34426820278167725,
0.10193031281232834,
0.21107709407806396,
0.21566487848758698,
-0.5945232510566711,
-0.2606363296508789,
0.5674132108688354,
-0.4989601671695709,
-0.1535831093788147,
0.26239052414894104,
0.3375146985054016,
-0.4591083824634552,
0.8884854912757874,
-0.15128536522388458,
-0.6608865857124329,
0.6135210990905762,
0.42241549491882324,
0.9098179340362549,
-0.3760126233100891,
-0.020959943532943726,
0.24160973727703094,
0.657111644744873,
0.08626583963632584,
0.09093839675188065,
-0.005093595013022423,
-0.8124345541000366,
0.08000031113624573,
-0.3804486393928528,
-0.6060810685157776,
0.21229228377342224,
-0.333463191986084,
0.5001331567764282,
-0.6481284499168396,
-0.5794370174407959,
0.1262650340795517,
-0.1454666703939438,
-0.9356783032417297,
0.01828853040933609,
0.15896932780742645,
0.7746370434761047,
-0.3728303611278534,
0.501024603843689,
0.5852094888687134,
-0.2606392204761505,
-0.4252118766307831,
-0.1479649692773819,
0.14365582168102264,
-0.8745019435882568,
0.7352750301361084,
0.5773555040359497,
-0.36551880836486816,
-0.40561214089393616,
-0.4961107671260834,
-0.8355233073234558,
1.1142456531524658,
0.061454448848962784,
-0.516200840473175,
-0.04500894248485565,
0.3662935197353363,
0.5769681334495544,
-0.3481592535972595,
0.7298083901405334,
0.2840157449245453,
0.13811300694942474,
0.023873308673501015,
-1.3212970495224,
-0.1428595930337906,
-0.30937591195106506,
0.07377766072750092,
0.2764955461025238,
-0.5108256340026855,
0.5000239014625549,
-0.12178680300712585,
-0.4084933400154114,
-0.052918728440999985,
0.6181461215019226,
0.09849316626787186,
0.4647890329360962,
0.6933969855308533,
0.31803643703460693,
0.5481158494949341,
-0.2414153665304184,
0.7401835322380066,
-0.20919513702392578,
0.03771057724952698,
0.9755014777183533,
-0.31993570923805237,
1.0638504028320312,
-0.0439755916595459,
-0.12829828262329102,
0.4215955138206482,
0.3603767156600952,
-0.02786574698984623,
0.13630035519599915,
0.17061381042003632,
-0.21153007447719574,
-0.08621158450841904,
-0.06202155351638794,
-0.27379775047302246,
0.6777964234352112,
0.7752198576927185,
-0.24596130847930908,
-0.07722249627113342,
0.2431662529706955,
-0.013211739249527454,
-0.3455200791358948,
-0.31652557849884033,
0.9681093096733093,
-0.03903859853744507,
-0.3335738778114319,
0.25100529193878174,
0.18895526230335236,
0.9658229351043701,
-0.6454640030860901,
0.07028688490390778,
0.22409731149673462,
0.09497500956058502,
-0.032326746731996536,
-0.7810122966766357,
0.2364758551120758,
0.34243667125701904,
0.28710612654685974,
0.11959856003522873,
0.9702164530754089,
0.0709417536854744,
-0.20574764907360077,
0.3536681830883026,
0.1666598618030548,
0.5973694324493408,
-0.1890382468700409,
-0.6990256309509277,
0.16539785265922546,
-0.16807834804058075,
0.061587702482938766,
0.19484597444534302,
0.3140317499637604,
-0.24292972683906555,
0.9165254235267639,
0.5868343710899353,
-0.15491336584091187,
-0.13799816370010376,
-0.15845465660095215,
0.7830754518508911,
-0.41565415263175964,
-0.31741687655448914,
-0.8257688283920288,
0.15561343729496002,
-0.24410167336463928,
-0.2553471624851227,
0.7060845494270325,
0.4913162887096405,
0.8532839417457581,
-0.06142580881714821,
0.73868727684021,
-0.1449410617351532,
0.5222600698471069,
-0.26311197876930237,
0.5076248049736023,
-0.1461600959300995,
0.37890082597732544,
-0.25314855575561523,
-0.660088062286377,
-0.010008768178522587,
0.2815767526626587,
-0.5328526496887207,
0.06892898678779602,
0.3410778045654297,
0.7325237989425659,
0.11527848243713379,
0.22471469640731812,
0.5985071063041687,
0.12931203842163086,
0.33165064454078674,
0.5908355712890625,
0.9964835047721863,
-0.47320032119750977,
0.6268191337585449,
-0.21249337494373322,
-0.2686138451099396,
-0.4389379024505615,
-0.800145149230957,
-1.170986533164978,
-0.36594805121421814,
-0.4188375174999237,
-0.14522325992584229,
0.3510693311691284,
1.1136038303375244,
0.5836595892906189,
-0.6352728009223938,
-0.03534984588623047,
0.28059470653533936,
-0.02144567295908928,
0.0059133912436664104,
-0.2126004546880722,
-0.09383314847946167,
-0.14862830936908722,
-0.4762079119682312,
0.38634181022644043,
0.40474575757980347,
0.09685033559799194,
-0.007554875686764717,
0.18204200267791748,
0.10416530817747116,
0.33081352710723877,
0.7468294501304626,
0.15978552401065826,
-0.926965057849884,
-0.25354209542274475,
0.1612699180841446,
-0.2468019425868988,
-0.0903029665350914,
0.3614140748977661,
-0.7511160969734192,
0.24749407172203064,
0.4510507583618164,
0.764801561832428,
0.07852616906166077,
-0.04325837269425392,
0.2460586428642273,
-0.49067074060440063,
-0.09720264375209808,
0.27289074659347534,
0.3940812349319458,
0.29552096128463745,
-0.3618823289871216,
0.7343716025352478,
0.07941992580890656,
-0.47643139958381653,
-0.6494174599647522,
-0.06395569443702698,
-1.0503119230270386,
-0.011530044488608837,
1.1677836179733276,
-0.19144795835018158,
-0.10324537009000778,
-0.24138781428337097,
-0.28528541326522827,
0.14233018457889557,
-0.6751345992088318,
0.6644026041030884,
0.481392502784729,
-0.06562425196170807,
0.07812677323818207,
-0.7126600742340088,
0.08998683840036392,
-0.24149870872497559,
-1.0491186380386353,
-0.14470034837722778,
0.18590426445007324,
0.19343891739845276,
0.43337273597717285,
0.6558051109313965,
-0.1511852890253067,
0.16381974518299103,
-0.00469149649143219,
0.13646557927131653,
-0.03322245180606842,
-0.38578128814697266,
-0.1264892965555191,
-0.02575109712779522,
-0.10973364114761353,
-0.1472761183977127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14818v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14818v1 | ChemDFM: Dialogue Foundation Model for Chemistry | 2024-01-26T12:45:55 | 2024-01-26T12:45:55 | Zihan Zhao, Da Ma, Lu Chen, Liangtai Sun, Zihao Li, Hongshen Xu, Zichen Zhu, Su Zhu, Shuai Fan, Guodong Shen, Xin Chen, Kai Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL | Large language models (LLMs) have established great success in the general
domain of natural language processing. Their emerging task generalization and
free-form dialogue capabilities can greatly help to design Chemical General
Intelligence (CGI) to assist real-world research in chemistry. However, the
existence of specialized language and knowledge in the field of chemistry, such
as the highly informative SMILES notation, hinders the performance of
general-domain LLMs in chemistry. To this end, we develop ChemDFM, the first
LLM towards CGI. ChemDFM-13B is trained on 34B tokens from chemical literature,
textbooks, and instructions as well as various data from the general domain.
Therefore, it can store, understand, and reason over chemical knowledge and
languages while still possessing advanced free-form language comprehension
capabilities. Extensive quantitative evaluation shows that ChemDFM can
significantly outperform the representative open-sourced LLMs. Moreover,
ChemDFM can also surpass GPT-4 on a great portion of chemical tasks, despite
the significant size difference. Further qualitative evaluations demonstrate
the efficiency and effectiveness of ChemDFM in real-world research scenarios.
We will open-source the ChemDFM model soon. | [
-0.3460005521774292,
-0.6969932913780212,
1.0549745559692383,
0.11396951228380203,
-0.12756317853927612,
0.31550681591033936,
-0.23617690801620483,
-0.37032294273376465,
-0.14484760165214539,
0.3478468060493469,
-0.7948346734046936,
-0.8345458507537842,
-0.4070056080818176,
0.1341395527124405,
-0.10319659113883972,
0.703835666179657,
0.12669584155082703,
0.5215563774108887,
-0.5296371579170227,
0.20794138312339783,
0.3010880947113037,
-0.4933984875679016,
-0.544334352016449,
-0.5976582169532776,
0.47365331649780273,
0.19893202185630798,
0.6459840536117554,
0.4127087891101837,
0.4874970316886902,
0.27361398935317993,
-0.01980370655655861,
-0.015083861537277699,
-0.5180990099906921,
-0.10989545285701752,
-0.5543385744094849,
-0.42686912417411804,
-0.495575875043869,
0.18492214381694794,
0.4821995198726654,
0.9129405617713928,
-0.1363036185503006,
-0.4110155403614044,
-0.3298504948616028,
0.7404581308364868,
-0.359179824590683,
0.580053448677063,
-0.4612957835197449,
-0.03243258595466614,
0.2682361900806427,
0.30427441000938416,
-0.2799176871776581,
-0.022878237068653107,
0.14342498779296875,
-0.7047389149665833,
0.10699531435966492,
-0.025768417865037918,
0.5938411951065063,
0.10362900793552399,
-0.4740089774131775,
-0.37956711649894714,
-0.5723225474357605,
0.7466050386428833,
-0.6247816681861877,
0.5568398833274841,
0.09419159591197968,
0.48813024163246155,
-0.6705990433692932,
-0.902545154094696,
-0.7285544872283936,
-0.5920313596725464,
0.2062254101037979,
0.09661807119846344,
-0.11801335960626602,
0.4876249134540558,
0.027290400117635727,
0.6831291317939758,
-0.4843623638153076,
-0.18888621032238007,
-0.21443071961402893,
-0.5481729507446289,
0.28929734230041504,
0.38433441519737244,
0.3430701196193695,
0.12247821688652039,
-0.7513740658760071,
0.008159336633980274,
-0.478386789560318,
-0.34107786417007446,
0.0509716235101223,
0.44310298562049866,
-0.10512808710336685,
0.47434213757514954,
-0.6468791365623474,
0.13855034112930298,
-0.06081457808613777,
-0.03283199295401573,
-0.025205310434103012,
-0.5406354665756226,
-0.5226617455482483,
0.0543229915201664,
0.74083012342453,
0.1676541119813919,
0.3226862847805023,
-0.24674256145954132,
0.05624271556735039,
0.38526278734207153,
-0.0459161214530468,
-1.22939133644104,
-0.4070535898208618,
0.3364815413951874,
-0.15022970736026764,
-0.10300302505493164,
-0.07396731525659561,
-0.6833456158638,
-0.4139244556427002,
-0.46036869287490845,
0.34468474984169006,
-0.4553164541721344,
-0.26634860038757324,
0.05086512863636017,
-0.0991363376379013,
0.21251794695854187,
0.5202596783638,
-0.6736862063407898,
0.6648223996162415,
0.7840296626091003,
0.6721044778823853,
-0.363110214471817,
-0.013133641332387924,
-0.4265817403793335,
0.0873657688498497,
-0.21997280418872833,
0.684893012046814,
-0.7585954666137695,
-0.658083975315094,
-0.1639656126499176,
-0.09950468689203262,
0.010217465460300446,
-0.9343758821487427,
0.22757460176944733,
-0.4046439528465271,
0.16541187465190887,
-0.23610584437847137,
-0.45349255204200745,
-0.039172541350126266,
0.1071808785200119,
-0.6319436430931091,
0.7604811191558838,
0.5402622818946838,
-0.25271496176719666,
0.11425093561410904,
-0.6557769179344177,
-0.196823388338089,
-0.01712639629840851,
-0.19626522064208984,
-0.0683005154132843,
-0.0075867860578000546,
0.04209834709763527,
0.14781269431114197,
-0.6506580114364624,
0.3304763436317444,
-0.3765673339366913,
-0.1770598441362381,
0.5080136656761169,
-0.15569262206554413,
0.6330848932266235,
0.4343898296356201,
-0.07938969880342484,
0.14941811561584473,
-0.817531406879425,
0.06651099771261215,
-0.2820841073989868,
-0.62647545337677,
0.13165804743766785,
-0.4406954348087311,
0.08881444483995438,
0.5665000677108765,
0.15278175473213196,
-0.6102311015129089,
-0.07480930536985397,
-0.4304661750793457,
0.30345478653907776,
0.6005120873451233,
0.2612878680229187,
0.6309996843338013,
-0.2176944762468338,
0.5024121999740601,
0.2744174301624298,
-0.09284726530313492,
-0.2039700746536255,
-0.35900014638900757,
-0.6812167763710022,
-0.5912341475486755,
0.14797590672969818,
0.49794241786003113,
-0.6139772534370422,
0.06549275666475296,
-0.08871088176965714,
-0.6167384386062622,
-0.09506802260875702,
0.5900136828422546,
0.37978067994117737,
0.3848183751106262,
0.33028292655944824,
-0.3503478467464447,
-0.3990747928619385,
-0.9618104696273804,
-0.27935317158699036,
-0.31797903776168823,
0.07879772037267685,
0.13156574964523315,
0.4421848952770233,
-0.6392717361450195,
1.0323355197906494,
-0.4568067193031311,
-0.1305532455444336,
-0.2638784646987915,
0.09125484526157379,
0.19407159090042114,
0.3288097381591797,
0.2861281931400299,
-0.5206581950187683,
-0.3213653564453125,
-0.09940032660961151,
-0.724136471748352,
-0.152183398604393,
0.318961501121521,
-0.7528548240661621,
0.30758047103881836,
0.5835666656494141,
-1.1258574724197388,
0.0724324956536293,
0.3914467990398407,
-0.20359249413013458,
0.37788310647010803,
0.16237963736057281,
0.004575937520712614,
-0.876746416091919,
0.18092577159404755,
0.21841908991336823,
-0.10946422815322876,
-0.7433708310127258,
-0.06802920997142792,
-0.07213762402534485,
-0.5981094837188721,
-0.7989015579223633,
0.8180317282676697,
-0.33864301443099976,
0.34336796402931213,
-0.2618239223957062,
-0.025271570309996605,
-0.21158857643604279,
0.7190236449241638,
0.07003233581781387,
0.44667720794677734,
0.41991767287254333,
-0.7929988503456116,
0.36881497502326965,
-0.04388348013162613,
-0.2862294018268585,
0.7378135323524475,
-0.2588350176811218,
0.0546974241733551,
0.10401086509227753,
0.31965184211730957,
-1.2508023977279663,
-0.5465993881225586,
0.3847879469394684,
-0.21937137842178345,
0.6006723642349243,
0.21497365832328796,
-0.35984379053115845,
-0.22576816380023956,
-0.05042486637830734,
0.11069756001234055,
0.342445433139801,
-0.4251946806907654,
0.8965684771537781,
0.17229275405406952,
-0.20732682943344116,
-0.3047131896018982,
-0.4456031918525696,
-0.07175703346729279,
-0.0029133479110896587,
-0.7082889080047607,
0.17875543236732483,
-0.4131748080253601,
-0.5041072368621826,
-0.1741899847984314,
-0.7323742508888245,
-0.18308213353157043,
-0.04047176241874695,
0.2779306471347809,
0.20114417374134064,
-0.06214210018515587,
0.08457772433757782,
-0.0536368228495121,
-0.1358698308467865,
0.4822601079940796,
-0.17802360653877258,
0.5514847040176392,
-0.07889176160097122,
-0.07572818547487259,
-0.2121249884366989,
0.23553155362606049,
0.825895369052887,
0.06117954105138779,
0.6057039499282837,
0.42294976115226746,
-0.3783634901046753,
-0.5341585874557495,
-0.20179472863674164,
-0.21486136317253113,
-0.527548611164093,
0.5044589638710022,
-0.18841002881526947,
-1.0331088304519653,
0.3806207776069641,
-0.5534053444862366,
-0.449669748544693,
0.4074357748031616,
0.6436830163002014,
0.11615704745054245,
0.8508687019348145,
0.6082767248153687,
0.13121694326400757,
0.24638579785823822,
0.01561049185693264,
0.29806122183799744,
-0.38389283418655396,
-0.5339217185974121,
-0.3337888717651367,
0.03806629031896591,
-0.12674713134765625,
-0.6164751052856445,
0.4125921130180359,
0.012486466206610203,
-0.513427197933197,
0.09540640562772751,
-0.0004400896141305566,
0.4595630168914795,
0.21858549118041992,
0.2181175798177719,
0.35014426708221436,
0.24374091625213623,
-0.6111610531806946,
0.21306666731834412,
-0.37496012449264526,
-0.3325519561767578,
0.865187406539917,
0.4230165481567383,
1.1312503814697266,
0.15676197409629822,
0.580302894115448,
0.2582704722881317,
0.25360971689224243,
-0.9734680652618408,
0.9621650576591492,
0.2903035879135132,
-0.8390942811965942,
-0.1862812340259552,
-0.5024687051773071,
-0.44242385029792786,
0.17973721027374268,
0.10180887579917908,
-0.39813634753227234,
0.014178824611008167,
-0.0638045147061348,
0.05583086237311363,
-0.15615829825401306,
-0.6024133563041687,
0.7072727084159851,
-0.07200771570205688,
-0.5235742926597595,
-0.3240823447704315,
-0.7429341077804565,
0.5472159385681152,
-0.09614201635122299,
0.3205425441265106,
-0.4773137867450714,
-0.03491177037358284,
0.37659168243408203,
-0.6482250094413757,
0.711280107498169,
-0.20353193581104279,
-0.5227470397949219,
0.5122907757759094,
0.44059422612190247,
0.21499580144882202,
-0.05078015476465225,
-0.07741281390190125,
-0.04733899608254433,
-0.10850060731172562,
-0.31727173924446106,
-0.6184282302856445,
0.9531776905059814,
-0.5865439772605896,
-0.8971913456916809,
-0.6228132247924805,
-0.6361682415008545,
-0.5832749605178833,
0.2671149969100952,
-0.08447323739528656,
0.058991290628910065,
-0.6344887614250183,
-0.07538530230522156,
0.6951832175254822,
-0.1560743898153305,
0.40612491965293884,
0.6414903998374939,
-0.41594311594963074,
-0.5571216344833374,
0.930152177810669,
-0.2229803502559662,
0.5973696708679199,
0.6961724162101746,
0.04016505181789398,
-0.41229701042175293,
-0.14211684465408325,
-0.15288139879703522,
0.31671929359436035,
-1.2981786727905273,
-0.1557030975818634,
-0.6550693511962891,
-0.21160286664962769,
-0.3413234055042267,
0.16976244747638702,
-0.07545644044876099,
-0.6290895342826843,
-0.1635342240333557,
-0.2056516408920288,
0.3350186347961426,
0.6196203827857971,
-0.220504492521286,
0.16975651681423187,
-0.5829928517341614,
0.4168674349784851,
0.47310671210289,
0.47181493043899536,
-0.16142365336418152,
-0.017004041001200676,
-0.4055447280406952,
0.006420519202947617,
-0.21279753744602203,
-0.7721173763275146,
0.14857053756713867,
0.36169156432151794,
0.8727675080299377,
0.24052412807941437,
-0.06443438678979874,
0.14156986773014069,
-0.24824030697345734,
0.7849583029747009,
0.1627088040113449,
-0.9572225213050842,
0.3568689525127411,
-0.651208221912384,
0.517410397529602,
0.46624457836151123,
0.6031273007392883,
-0.30219370126724243,
-0.16329437494277954,
-0.27475348114967346,
-0.6196447610855103,
0.6893824338912964,
0.11366196721792221,
0.07887839525938034,
-0.3656593859195709,
0.11195101588964462,
-0.014947614632546902,
0.34373313188552856,
-0.43957874178886414,
-0.28214603662490845,
-0.28563815355300903,
-0.5074343681335449,
0.043620701879262924,
-0.02652449905872345,
-0.2162514328956604,
-0.36462196707725525,
0.8710753917694092,
-0.1941714584827423,
0.42062243819236755,
0.15571099519729614,
-0.34996140003204346,
-0.32458770275115967,
0.48945507407188416,
0.4981028139591217,
0.6409045457839966,
-0.2520342171192169,
0.3862220346927643,
0.13108940422534943,
-0.6994515657424927,
0.3437027037143707,
0.018076328560709953,
0.4606465697288513,
-0.21943801641464233,
-0.099513940513134,
0.4428306221961975,
0.28876155614852905,
-0.9129814505577087,
0.16635645925998688,
0.22703257203102112,
-0.23844146728515625,
0.09241658449172974,
0.623795747756958,
0.43790310621261597,
0.18865063786506653,
0.3430379033088684,
-0.08492980897426605,
0.23778535425662994,
-1.1569544076919556,
0.22087593376636505,
0.5290076732635498,
-0.4930969774723053,
-0.01928480714559555,
0.6290081739425659,
0.17677602171897888,
0.06441951543092728,
0.5061156749725342,
-0.0883273184299469,
-0.6273360848426819,
0.599387526512146,
0.7393878102302551,
0.7488659024238586,
-0.34943848848342896,
0.26996833086013794,
0.3643602430820465,
-0.0759693831205368,
0.12660077214241028,
0.2872151732444763,
-0.13491593301296234,
-0.4270360469818115,
0.10290329903364182,
-0.8957564234733582,
-0.681373119354248,
0.11984764784574509,
-0.1626242697238922,
0.1606307327747345,
-1.0314760208129883,
-0.023351572453975677,
0.022100867703557014,
0.2807700037956238,
-0.6881968379020691,
0.5201636552810669,
0.1832563281059265,
1.1394671201705933,
-0.585852324962616,
0.6750263571739197,
0.5879346132278442,
-0.3990398049354553,
-0.40655991435050964,
-0.21565395593643188,
0.3413543105125427,
-0.6874486804008484,
0.7670084238052368,
0.16318118572235107,
-0.4366551637649536,
0.09026182442903519,
-1.067725658416748,
-1.0182783603668213,
1.213378667831421,
0.4507637917995453,
-0.43339774012565613,
0.17826201021671295,
0.4243054687976837,
0.5133470892906189,
-0.5823774337768555,
0.056587718427181244,
0.783693253993988,
0.5483291149139404,
0.4379073977470398,
-0.6759322881698608,
0.3540760278701782,
-0.6087666749954224,
0.06084279343485832,
0.08025673776865005,
-0.7172171473503113,
0.8626947402954102,
-0.17705878615379333,
-0.35452741384506226,
0.4258742928504944,
0.576104998588562,
0.3494623899459839,
0.3787582218647003,
0.04429974779486656,
0.6881909966468811,
0.7307854890823364,
-0.3818518817424774,
1.0176585912704468,
-0.13132834434509277,
0.055854976177215576,
0.8816569447517395,
-0.5300871133804321,
0.43091726303100586,
0.33215683698654175,
-0.3751194179058075,
0.7985864281654358,
0.4682704210281372,
0.10645043104887009,
0.7328861951828003,
0.565949559211731,
-0.9186574816703796,
-0.48920556902885437,
-0.17992393672466278,
-0.24173708260059357,
0.1597122848033905,
0.6743248701095581,
-0.28646421432495117,
-0.2743845283985138,
-0.08444733172655106,
0.18855366110801697,
0.0628846138715744,
-0.504698634147644,
0.6982563138008118,
0.43227899074554443,
-0.5262819528579712,
0.32726550102233887,
0.16972462832927704,
0.24377815425395966,
-0.7264057397842407,
-0.2135782241821289,
-0.25769323110580444,
0.38550621271133423,
-0.12892268598079681,
-0.6324668526649475,
-0.126132532954216,
-0.3011811673641205,
-0.24203526973724365,
0.23062419891357422,
0.91306072473526,
-0.6649073362350464,
-0.25979283452033997,
0.30477356910705566,
0.5242115259170532,
0.09755748510360718,
-0.2420102208852768,
-0.37738609313964844,
0.0739983543753624,
-0.26382169127464294,
0.08410140126943588,
0.5231553912162781,
0.408606618642807,
0.01362135075032711,
0.6075053215026855,
0.6832134127616882,
-0.4602588713169098,
-0.0728318840265274,
0.051532864570617676,
1.1128321886062622,
-0.8252106308937073,
-0.3876069188117981,
-0.754944920539856,
0.3701733350753784,
0.2287326604127884,
0.07008852064609528,
0.6379083395004272,
0.5671802759170532,
0.7317262887954712,
-0.3542231619358063,
1.053009033203125,
0.366250216960907,
0.22572916746139526,
-0.6269249320030212,
0.6403329372406006,
-0.24739478528499603,
0.012164317071437836,
-0.3718806803226471,
-1.220281720161438,
-0.3113088011741638,
0.4479006230831146,
0.026738926768302917,
0.4015534520149231,
0.9309540390968323,
0.953156590461731,
-0.0477675162255764,
0.14646944403648376,
0.23024584352970123,
0.3583022654056549,
0.4976177215576172,
0.8316278457641602,
0.8636565208435059,
-0.1477758288383484,
0.5471738576889038,
-0.10032538324594498,
-0.00481186481192708,
-0.10322410613298416,
-0.7172051072120667,
-1.2120977640151978,
-0.24553614854812622,
-0.22114793956279755,
-0.4968039393424988,
-0.14820989966392517,
1.1563383340835571,
0.5137912631034851,
-0.7527092695236206,
-0.37322086095809937,
-0.3497847616672516,
-0.02331250160932541,
0.17034034430980682,
-0.23709772527217865,
-0.003259980818256736,
-0.3357393443584442,
-0.7291834354400635,
0.7423781156539917,
0.3997746706008911,
0.19358819723129272,
-0.45617443323135376,
-0.5656664371490479,
-0.1780523806810379,
0.4913269281387329,
0.5287730693817139,
0.44482091069221497,
-0.6297269463539124,
-0.09038001298904419,
0.13415271043777466,
-0.2937637269496918,
0.19324588775634766,
0.7058099508285522,
-0.8442822098731995,
0.5858817100524902,
0.3508607745170593,
0.4440979063510895,
0.613981306552887,
-0.16460870206356049,
0.8289695978164673,
-0.466854065656662,
-0.18058378994464874,
-0.039949022233486176,
0.24480848014354706,
0.4311051666736603,
-0.3073665201663971,
0.6339253783226013,
0.47258251905441284,
-0.3320792615413666,
-0.5254934430122375,
0.295011043548584,
-1.4116851091384888,
-0.40156763792037964,
1.171187400817871,
0.1247713565826416,
-0.2613210380077362,
0.0409991592168808,
-0.4526843726634979,
0.48818260431289673,
-0.6572273373603821,
0.3261968791484833,
1.0187047719955444,
-0.2169714868068695,
-0.2252633422613144,
-0.15472199022769928,
0.7182772755622864,
0.19749560952186584,
-1.028533935546875,
-0.021670522168278694,
0.7368087768554688,
0.4851517677307129,
0.25083014369010925,
0.6612023711204529,
-0.35082533955574036,
0.4331720769405365,
0.09973505884408951,
-0.24960149824619293,
-0.2683843970298767,
-0.5873986482620239,
-0.23352470993995667,
0.16229040920734406,
0.05956333875656128,
0.4147821366786957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14777v1 | Large Language Model Adaptation for Financial Sentiment Analysis | 2024-01-26T11:04:01 | 2024-01-26T11:04:01 | Pau Rodriguez Inserte, Mariam Nakhlé, Raheel Qader, Gaetan Caillaut, Jingshu Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Natural language processing (NLP) has recently gained relevance within
financial institutions by providing highly valuable insights into companies and
markets' financial documents. However, the landscape of the financial domain
presents extra challenges for NLP, due to the complexity of the texts and the
use of specific terminology. Generalist language models tend to fall short in
tasks specifically tailored for finance, even when using large language models
(LLMs) with great natural language understanding and generative capabilities.
This paper presents a study on LLM adaptation methods targeted at the financial
domain and with high emphasis on financial sentiment analysis. To this purpose,
two foundation models with less than 1.5B parameters have been adapted using a
wide range of strategies. We show that through careful fine-tuning on both
financial documents and instructions, these foundation models can be adapted to
the target domain. Moreover, we observe that small LLMs have comparable
performance to larger scale models, while being more efficient in terms of
parameters and data. In addition to the models, we show how to generate
artificial instructions through LLMs to augment the number of samples of the
instruction dataset. | [
-0.18373753130435944,
-0.7138893604278564,
0.2836730182170868,
0.56429523229599,
-0.33964940905570984,
0.18899542093276978,
-0.3980550169944763,
-0.5061705112457275,
-0.08990694582462311,
0.7969517707824707,
-0.5964540839195251,
-0.6520251631736755,
-0.6689477562904358,
-0.01433180458843708,
-0.2835814654827118,
1.3948798179626465,
0.06993074715137482,
0.23410950601100922,
-0.1151028648018837,
-0.004259983543306589,
-0.2884373068809509,
-0.5294041037559509,
-1.1015363931655884,
-0.27380624413490295,
-0.05403120070695877,
0.1057373434305191,
0.6823052167892456,
0.12585562467575073,
0.8091985583305359,
0.30930134654045105,
-0.1445135474205017,
-0.12950898706912994,
-0.4128391444683075,
-0.18815161287784576,
-0.33942943811416626,
-0.43362194299697876,
-0.7791956067085266,
-0.04200401529669762,
0.5474802255630493,
0.7956131100654602,
-0.18974632024765015,
0.10505436360836029,
0.2906271815299988,
1.0466967821121216,
-0.40349307656288147,
0.6291456818580627,
-0.5339435338973999,
0.07252822816371918,
0.19409215450286865,
-0.297545462846756,
-0.6657573580741882,
-0.23489926755428314,
0.726852297782898,
-0.5495568513870239,
0.031171739101409912,
0.09961043298244476,
0.4777006506919861,
0.18665103614330292,
-0.18827904760837555,
-0.7461055517196655,
-0.7921950817108154,
0.9707580208778381,
-0.9534265995025635,
0.1713719218969345,
0.14347349107265472,
0.16792717576026917,
-0.20310978591442108,
-0.4485486149787903,
-0.06453113257884979,
-0.292117714881897,
0.10074564814567566,
0.1132502481341362,
-0.4440977871417999,
0.08883741497993469,
0.04690343141555786,
0.2458803653717041,
-0.17409831285476685,
0.2603715658187866,
-0.0897722989320755,
0.07904301583766937,
0.7264841794967651,
0.11532021313905716,
-0.13878734409809113,
-0.15082521736621857,
-0.47202199697494507,
-0.5095200538635254,
-0.4664696156978607,
0.030916469171643257,
0.3557252883911133,
0.6167067289352417,
-0.41869044303894043,
0.32606738805770874,
-0.03194477781653404,
0.7605847120285034,
0.2055952548980713,
-0.38034602999687195,
0.085944265127182,
-0.09674062579870224,
-0.5221343636512756,
0.11529365181922913,
0.4155823588371277,
0.45608314871788025,
0.5076862573623657,
0.10853677988052368,
-0.4742982089519501,
-0.3065020442008972,
0.3098703920841217,
-0.6474356651306152,
-0.17398281395435333,
0.06423500925302505,
-0.5808078646659851,
-0.3148266077041626,
0.02539638802409172,
-0.9856950640678406,
-0.5256710648536682,
-0.5955110192298889,
0.4047706127166748,
-0.38805198669433594,
0.011277489364147186,
0.6022121906280518,
-0.18226729333400726,
0.7459920644760132,
0.32763874530792236,
-1.1195385456085205,
0.6838545203208923,
0.9937142133712769,
0.6685175895690918,
-0.00036185188218951225,
0.12004291266202927,
-0.7079806327819824,
0.0605306550860405,
-0.18917064368724823,
0.7130816578865051,
-0.5027902722358704,
-0.5623621940612793,
-0.0007080960203893483,
-0.2702278792858124,
-0.3020692467689514,
-0.5147632956504822,
0.4842960238456726,
-0.5948386192321777,
0.17395265400409698,
-0.04380371421575546,
-0.5560338497161865,
-0.266636461019516,
0.152108296751976,
-0.6368529200553894,
0.622109591960907,
0.3962545692920685,
-0.7461761832237244,
0.14998705685138702,
-1.198639988899231,
-0.6563788056373596,
-0.17382359504699707,
0.29661819338798523,
-0.31422004103660583,
0.3591873049736023,
0.4368186593055725,
0.7665615677833557,
-0.6414956450462341,
0.07582488656044006,
-0.5263609290122986,
-0.1419731229543686,
0.6012886166572571,
-0.447142630815506,
0.5193201303482056,
-0.12719957530498505,
-0.21525301039218903,
0.025311186909675598,
-0.8535998463630676,
-0.3215542137622833,
0.049937572330236435,
-0.19778302311897278,
-0.6124451160430908,
0.2516442537307739,
0.1880509853363037,
-0.08540317416191101,
0.2295941263437271,
-0.09574804455041885,
0.18602930009365082,
-1.007097840309143,
0.6052150726318359,
1.0050163269042969,
0.10644036531448364,
0.6036447286605835,
-0.13666975498199463,
0.5647495985031128,
-0.11494069546461105,
0.06847907602787018,
0.15175361931324005,
-0.18469735980033875,
-0.7315318584442139,
-0.2337162345647812,
0.39485594630241394,
0.6386057138442993,
-0.4036577641963959,
0.3647564649581909,
-0.3386315405368805,
-0.1595861315727234,
-0.3969694674015045,
0.3627795875072479,
-0.06724315136671066,
0.3458136320114136,
0.25745296478271484,
-0.21960382163524628,
-0.4942236840724945,
-0.9289067387580872,
-0.21257621049880981,
-0.10924826562404633,
-0.17722253501415253,
0.23799438774585724,
0.4890780448913574,
-0.1965394765138626,
0.763440728187561,
-0.70989990234375,
-0.25801903009414673,
-0.215084969997406,
0.1437389999628067,
0.6103647947311401,
0.19912946224212646,
1.0198434591293335,
-0.7380605936050415,
-0.33563554286956787,
0.20923791825771332,
-0.41925543546676636,
0.043706607073545456,
-0.5573471188545227,
-0.01975894719362259,
0.24960412085056305,
0.4097710847854614,
-0.326066255569458,
0.16182559728622437,
0.8069941401481628,
-0.3548131585121155,
0.2905627489089966,
-0.16293755173683167,
-0.3350282311439514,
-1.3250216245651245,
-0.14954601228237152,
0.5329940319061279,
-0.3151877224445343,
-0.5313431620597839,
0.06527762115001678,
-0.26358625292778015,
0.048234473913908005,
-0.0820639505982399,
0.7149869203567505,
-0.3113122284412384,
-0.28777292370796204,
-0.5387557744979858,
0.1561403125524521,
0.09926434606313705,
0.3695475161075592,
-0.010819789953529835,
0.5814825296401978,
0.6778509020805359,
-0.4729381203651428,
0.4879135191440582,
0.22862371802330017,
-0.3610594570636749,
0.6424726247787476,
-0.5268933773040771,
0.06627137213945389,
0.11808589100837708,
0.2472487986087799,
-0.9671750664710999,
-0.17678570747375488,
0.2402702420949936,
-0.05773824453353882,
0.3875434994697571,
0.004390728659927845,
-0.2118328958749771,
-0.19514040648937225,
-0.4352685511112213,
-0.05040255934000015,
0.3989810645580292,
-0.6230393648147583,
1.0452651977539062,
0.05651131272315979,
-0.7738122344017029,
-0.4775331914424896,
-0.5666481852531433,
0.2378135323524475,
-0.30405157804489136,
-0.6058051586151123,
0.3655765652656555,
-0.13061118125915527,
-0.5345925688743591,
-0.12265293300151825,
-0.07698947936296463,
0.24853824079036713,
0.38047003746032715,
0.28043627738952637,
0.7252350449562073,
-0.6410312652587891,
-0.0028779134154319763,
0.01820782572031021,
-0.08318712562322617,
0.3794498145580292,
-0.5299516320228577,
0.4055524468421936,
-0.2466496378183365,
-0.015815552324056625,
-0.2194100022315979,
0.20073965191841125,
0.5713234543800354,
-0.05437232553958893,
0.9748899340629578,
0.2868165969848633,
-0.23508696258068085,
-0.6299025416374207,
-0.35967910289764404,
0.04719451814889908,
-0.5611236691474915,
0.3598848879337311,
-0.23466724157333374,
-0.9751564860343933,
0.5083174705505371,
-0.155710831284523,
0.08772321790456772,
0.7324233651161194,
0.8482760787010193,
0.03894884139299393,
0.7341757416725159,
0.9475586414337158,
-0.6085867285728455,
0.4543924927711487,
-0.20300473272800446,
0.3616427779197693,
-0.5593428611755371,
0.03879547491669655,
-0.6067271828651428,
-0.31979498267173767,
-0.3599698841571808,
-0.44093355536460876,
0.10977401584386826,
0.06469441205263138,
-0.012261789292097092,
0.07332108169794083,
-0.072599858045578,
0.32082340121269226,
0.2326437383890152,
-0.07264173775911331,
0.13376584649085999,
0.23705869913101196,
0.043248359113931656,
0.1540602147579193,
-0.4276594817638397,
-0.4589286744594574,
1.150041103363037,
0.6729451417922974,
0.8716479539871216,
0.03953884169459343,
0.32626873254776,
0.5498991012573242,
0.6010306477546692,
-0.9060245752334595,
0.30543431639671326,
-0.7917563915252686,
-0.12949927151203156,
-0.17160381376743317,
-0.5207706093788147,
-0.2552033066749573,
-0.11534054577350616,
-0.3325507342815399,
-0.42953452467918396,
0.16684724390506744,
-0.0869036614894867,
-0.6590434908866882,
-0.009335245937108994,
-0.6599166989326477,
0.663885235786438,
-0.2381763607263565,
0.15335245430469513,
-0.19535978138446808,
-0.1899486631155014,
0.35144317150115967,
-0.6068577766418457,
0.527363121509552,
-0.01639433577656746,
0.006246634759008884,
0.7526858448982239,
-0.13048715889453888,
1.2297619581222534,
-0.22987869381904602,
-0.5934529304504395,
0.18889503180980682,
-0.18048694729804993,
0.7113369107246399,
0.08382392674684525,
-0.4861334562301636,
-0.012394270859658718,
-0.03213924169540405,
-0.3509204089641571,
-0.5448338389396667,
0.7770093679428101,
-0.8391724824905396,
-0.6130589842796326,
-0.09051275253295898,
-0.7658347487449646,
-0.6240845322608948,
-0.29713335633277893,
-0.20317867398262024,
0.07212773710489273,
-0.398579865694046,
0.3817872107028961,
0.45680928230285645,
-0.3183344900608063,
0.46802207827568054,
0.4413202106952667,
-0.16518047451972961,
-0.4377937912940979,
0.7430711984634399,
-0.16811470687389374,
0.334469735622406,
0.47509124875068665,
0.417478084564209,
-0.39733973145484924,
-0.6678619980812073,
-0.28748619556427,
0.132477268576622,
-0.9829464554786682,
-0.2684806287288666,
-0.22609001398086548,
-0.13965578377246857,
-0.6294620037078857,
-0.4640655517578125,
-0.15832221508026123,
-0.38586586713790894,
-0.6042319536209106,
-0.3280825912952423,
0.7896420955657959,
0.43466290831565857,
0.15131869912147522,
0.47435736656188965,
-1.002702236175537,
0.5204024314880371,
0.39350348711013794,
0.4407741129398346,
0.09814970940351486,
-0.9018427729606628,
-0.3461408019065857,
-0.05374372377991676,
0.1255384385585785,
-0.6297210454940796,
0.3887859582901001,
0.5003518462181091,
0.2937694489955902,
0.5525139570236206,
-0.027105385437607765,
0.48194989562034607,
-0.07488219439983368,
0.3514181077480316,
0.10098302364349365,
-1.0686063766479492,
0.32928335666656494,
-0.37949153780937195,
0.1241072416305542,
0.40209996700286865,
0.27433153986930847,
-0.3765365183353424,
-0.19538384675979614,
-0.18572263419628143,
-0.7984077334403992,
0.6320472955703735,
-0.24791903793811798,
0.5998849272727966,
0.15927015244960785,
0.8366907835006714,
0.15609319508075714,
0.09404125064611435,
-0.6832162737846375,
0.2669447958469391,
-0.1804511398077011,
-0.6096277832984924,
-0.1583072394132614,
-0.27992090582847595,
-0.1771923303604126,
-0.11123436689376831,
0.7464330196380615,
-0.5611791014671326,
-0.08415473997592926,
-0.19272612035274506,
0.0703081339597702,
-0.19359976053237915,
0.27813756465911865,
0.4079393446445465,
0.5372962355613708,
-0.18589507043361664,
-0.3643430471420288,
0.281428724527359,
-0.294649600982666,
-0.13381586968898773,
0.22175823152065277,
-0.07611659914255142,
-0.282221257686615,
0.5918093323707581,
0.935226559638977,
0.7382120490074158,
-0.8345191478729248,
0.49556633830070496,
0.012708989903330803,
-0.4482084810733795,
-0.3139699399471283,
0.2355390191078186,
0.38150784373283386,
0.5678539872169495,
0.5536080002784729,
0.022792227566242218,
0.0008256473811343312,
-0.6056841015815735,
-0.027358509600162506,
0.4978264272212982,
-0.27263909578323364,
-0.29330235719680786,
0.45367860794067383,
0.2491830289363861,
-0.06952285766601562,
0.5607132315635681,
0.19080525636672974,
-0.32644176483154297,
0.534419596195221,
0.6761801838874817,
1.1889212131500244,
0.043128710240125656,
0.34351423382759094,
0.01019533071666956,
0.10124910622835159,
-0.32145431637763977,
0.2574033737182617,
0.4314109981060028,
-0.7973373532295227,
-0.8530963659286499,
-1.3208413124084473,
-0.5514243841171265,
-0.04221032187342644,
-0.9268938899040222,
0.13194221258163452,
-1.060532569885254,
-0.1422465592622757,
0.3953879475593567,
-0.03381471708416939,
-0.6354050636291504,
0.3493855595588684,
0.40375518798828125,
1.1166845560073853,
-0.8453297019004822,
0.6626973152160645,
0.6243416666984558,
0.1319708228111267,
-0.5055055022239685,
-0.2121330052614212,
-0.06332191079854965,
-0.7356377243995667,
0.4295177161693573,
-0.12098297476768494,
-0.21060888469219208,
-0.04400716349482536,
-0.5712047219276428,
-0.5469609498977661,
0.6714786887168884,
0.408037006855011,
-0.8104393482208252,
-0.1764182597398758,
0.24001117050647736,
0.7577844858169556,
-0.7964496612548828,
-0.5791577696800232,
0.7772583961486816,
0.578678548336029,
0.11009690910577774,
-0.46321800351142883,
-0.16237081587314606,
-0.03211315721273422,
-0.020135236904025078,
0.16654473543167114,
-0.4704015552997589,
0.6864280104637146,
-0.038940589874982834,
0.21993808448314667,
0.08437856286764145,
0.8216935396194458,
0.09328749030828476,
0.28289154171943665,
0.5977146029472351,
0.2865773141384125,
0.6537012457847595,
0.014697792008519173,
1.183456301689148,
-0.35535258054733276,
0.34639397263526917,
1.0194133520126343,
-0.5824815034866333,
1.1844266653060913,
0.36899101734161377,
-0.31502586603164673,
0.5545943379402161,
0.3789548873901367,
-0.4368244409561157,
0.18785355985164642,
0.2166072279214859,
-0.14801035821437836,
-0.23699815571308136,
0.1536165475845337,
0.06722541898488998,
0.6818864941596985,
0.5309242606163025,
-0.6247063279151917,
0.06855886429548264,
0.22855612635612488,
-0.21878869831562042,
0.11275988072156906,
-0.606144368648529,
0.8895740509033203,
0.5092909932136536,
-0.2719358801841736,
0.12492822110652924,
0.5675203800201416,
0.564751386642456,
-0.6834284067153931,
0.2040841281414032,
-0.12375271320343018,
0.3122332990169525,
0.032996855676174164,
-0.39972996711730957,
0.31073009967803955,
0.23262684047222137,
-0.3966083824634552,
-0.28786367177963257,
0.8169314861297607,
0.12776030600070953,
-1.1064587831497192,
0.6542301177978516,
0.24822619557380676,
-0.28877055644989014,
-0.2420697808265686,
-0.799780547618866,
-0.23110263049602509,
0.039201028645038605,
-0.6091306209564209,
0.602115273475647,
0.42285215854644775,
0.021428951993584633,
0.4785286784172058,
0.984992504119873,
0.11379478871822357,
-0.2102297693490982,
0.3166738748550415,
0.8483023047447205,
-1.0414366722106934,
-0.4832454025745392,
-1.0110324621200562,
0.08007670193910599,
0.24187098443508148,
-0.22756309807300568,
0.5162597298622131,
0.308096706867218,
0.6652212738990784,
-0.28822025656700134,
0.7109628915786743,
0.5445476174354553,
0.2714325785636902,
-1.0070067644119263,
0.46995583176612854,
-0.38564532995224,
0.4819490909576416,
-0.42768073081970215,
-1.1619160175323486,
-0.4272165596485138,
0.631480872631073,
-0.5039631724357605,
-0.09278703480958939,
0.21933262050151825,
0.459003210067749,
-0.042843762785196304,
0.4163530170917511,
0.15286587178707123,
0.4268825054168701,
0.0415358729660511,
0.4106042981147766,
0.43487051129341125,
-0.20154771208763123,
0.33042213320732117,
-0.0980982780456543,
0.020957140251994133,
-0.5060691833496094,
-1.086983561515808,
-0.8451197743415833,
-0.027914054691791534,
-0.4576319754123688,
-0.17464500665664673,
-0.18762436509132385,
0.9607729315757751,
0.30417558550834656,
-0.8714922666549683,
-0.32301998138427734,
0.3050733804702759,
-0.11577622592449188,
-0.22337712347507477,
-0.22817163169384003,
0.4151948392391205,
-0.24039804935455322,
-0.5539858341217041,
0.5651170015335083,
0.7144055962562561,
0.19156187772750854,
-0.48345640301704407,
-0.1661939173936844,
0.19402335584163666,
0.5419899225234985,
0.8686627745628357,
-0.05435264855623245,
-0.39681264758110046,
-0.4869649410247803,
0.0487704873085022,
0.10146351903676987,
0.03251465782523155,
0.786406397819519,
-0.21419386565685272,
-0.0197497196495533,
0.3059675693511963,
0.9569947123527527,
0.2913878262042999,
0.13118797540664673,
0.6849976181983948,
-0.682489275932312,
0.06655379384756088,
0.21767690777778625,
0.3129669725894928,
0.3778158724308014,
-0.28015339374542236,
0.2413943111896515,
-0.02705192007124424,
-0.20279517769813538,
-0.5485135912895203,
-0.19312666356563568,
-1.1287760734558105,
-0.5849782824516296,
1.0382230281829834,
-0.050259169191122055,
-0.5166749954223633,
0.2589244842529297,
-0.12430745363235474,
-0.17415645718574524,
-0.20194466412067413,
0.8142945170402527,
0.943992018699646,
0.1783849149942398,
-0.09959965944290161,
-0.7126511931419373,
0.31856921315193176,
0.2695430815219879,
-0.7231031656265259,
0.33996713161468506,
0.3118106722831726,
0.26473844051361084,
0.008311689831316471,
0.4389641582965851,
0.0978485494852066,
0.20114964246749878,
-0.08107616007328033,
-0.07707672566175461,
0.3322572708129883,
-0.20021067559719086,
-0.6885032057762146,
0.4359327554702759,
0.30062294006347656,
0.367264062166214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14717v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14717v1 | Turn-taking and Backchannel Prediction with Acoustic and Large Language Model Fusion | 2024-01-26T08:59:07 | 2024-01-26T08:59:07 | Jinhan Wang, Long Chen, Aparna Khare, Anirudh Raju, Pranav Dheram, Di He, Minhua Wu, Andreas Stolcke, Venkatesh Ravichandran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | We propose an approach for continuous prediction of turn-taking and
backchanneling locations in spoken dialogue by fusing a neural acoustic model
with a large language model (LLM). Experiments on the Switchboard human-human
conversation dataset demonstrate that our approach consistently outperforms the
baseline models with single modality. We also develop a novel multi-task
instruction fine-tuning strategy to further benefit from LLM-encoded knowledge
for understanding the tasks and conversational contexts, leading to additional
improvements. Our approach demonstrates the potential of combined LLMs and
acoustic models for a more natural and conversational interaction between
humans and speech-enabled AI agents. | [
-0.4130104184150696,
-0.8466981053352356,
0.6616538763046265,
0.09129706770181656,
0.03254450485110283,
0.21937398612499237,
-0.3324628174304962,
-0.5277920365333557,
0.19839702546596527,
0.9062790274620056,
-0.8027313351631165,
-0.5213973522186279,
-0.3115534782409668,
-0.3036304712295532,
-0.47197669744491577,
0.46518033742904663,
0.2635614573955536,
0.4952234625816345,
-0.19306130707263947,
0.09550882130861282,
-0.8569799065589905,
-0.47703999280929565,
-0.9052785038948059,
-0.8772866725921631,
0.49852994084358215,
0.46020224690437317,
0.7252730131149292,
0.19650880992412567,
-0.03619471192359924,
0.3335527181625366,
0.0588170625269413,
-0.03992065414786339,
-0.3608895242214203,
0.2687651813030243,
-0.22955013811588287,
-0.4653191864490509,
-0.41213342547416687,
0.12034831941127777,
0.7376262545585632,
0.6748915910720825,
-0.2459535002708435,
-0.2684851288795471,
-0.14748308062553406,
0.3362080752849579,
-0.2483305037021637,
0.12889178097248077,
-0.48624736070632935,
-0.030913695693016052,
0.0759844183921814,
-0.2612799406051636,
-0.5160767436027527,
-0.14109155535697937,
0.3342915177345276,
-0.1921607404947281,
0.14815708994865417,
0.06416811048984528,
0.34232836961746216,
0.41558030247688293,
-0.2945481836795807,
0.02123137377202511,
-1.0491058826446533,
0.8799677491188049,
-0.8966777920722961,
0.81888747215271,
0.4558856785297394,
0.3297896087169647,
-0.31324633955955505,
-0.5290312767028809,
-0.8886680603027344,
-0.35739585757255554,
-0.00761348707601428,
0.12856325507164001,
-0.062126245349645615,
0.3860523998737335,
0.005472048185765743,
0.1313704401254654,
-0.42627954483032227,
0.45737224817276,
-0.3087227940559387,
-0.19771867990493774,
0.9803935289382935,
0.3574267029762268,
0.44153499603271484,
0.11935606598854065,
-0.25903061032295227,
-0.11646361649036407,
-0.8361254930496216,
-0.05649861320853233,
0.17268267273902893,
0.5431823134422302,
-0.23114490509033203,
0.4667716324329376,
-0.09242477267980576,
0.7254602313041687,
0.28604018688201904,
-0.25199368596076965,
-0.0005763127701357007,
-0.5750552415847778,
-0.1760212928056717,
0.35495439171791077,
0.7618638873100281,
0.374247670173645,
-0.04859977588057518,
-0.13430587947368622,
-0.0484086349606514,
-0.1464960277080536,
0.3011121153831482,
-0.4093514084815979,
0.04021015763282776,
0.5527628660202026,
-0.30595409870147705,
-0.08163950592279434,
-0.30570244789123535,
-0.8476365208625793,
-0.28151679039001465,
-0.6756545305252075,
0.4058663845062256,
-0.3359086215496063,
-0.15988531708717346,
0.022013729438185692,
0.11389970779418945,
0.514229416847229,
0.3978206515312195,
-0.9300096035003662,
0.4249962866306305,
0.9325805902481079,
0.7455105781555176,
-0.44563940167427063,
-0.6393579244613647,
-0.5392239093780518,
0.35920435190200806,
-0.17593775689601898,
0.7494015693664551,
-0.5924356579780579,
-0.6457480192184448,
0.101593017578125,
-0.09167452901601791,
-0.1844930499792099,
-0.4464675784111023,
0.22045035660266876,
-0.2743336856365204,
0.3431045114994049,
0.1380894035100937,
-0.42531800270080566,
-0.39821943640708923,
0.12402524054050446,
-0.8256385922431946,
0.6597863435745239,
-0.11521974951028824,
-0.2423456907272339,
0.04946182668209076,
-0.6135221719741821,
-0.8459375500679016,
-0.07016162574291229,
-0.21721799671649933,
-0.4627889096736908,
-0.09089189022779465,
0.2487359344959259,
0.5370839834213257,
-0.40970370173454285,
0.457727313041687,
-0.14475110173225403,
-0.41095829010009766,
0.49043577909469604,
-0.6493446230888367,
0.5992887020111084,
-0.2469690591096878,
-0.48985859751701355,
0.46002858877182007,
-0.44547781348228455,
-0.1431925892829895,
-0.28854382038116455,
-0.33590057492256165,
-0.0019314971286803484,
0.1908748298883438,
-0.007774025201797485,
0.3577231466770172,
0.10634534806013107,
-0.5951895117759705,
0.15918782353401184,
-0.46452048420906067,
0.48261186480522156,
0.5602616667747498,
0.00210616085678339,
0.47524502873420715,
-0.33648034930229187,
0.4449627995491028,
-0.03942347690463066,
-0.04979516565799713,
-0.24665527045726776,
-0.7595623731613159,
-0.8580163717269897,
0.007210189010947943,
0.18608258664608002,
0.799984335899353,
-0.560971200466156,
0.2432546615600586,
-0.08930573612451553,
-0.3920874297618866,
-0.739094078540802,
-0.0054580532014369965,
0.5799513459205627,
0.2470071166753769,
0.3616109788417816,
-0.1055370420217514,
-0.5662625432014465,
-0.8488358855247498,
0.05808371677994728,
-0.242941752076149,
-0.12853705883026123,
0.489538311958313,
0.13441428542137146,
-0.3729182779788971,
0.7119441628456116,
-0.22538049519062042,
-0.18359306454658508,
-0.4116380214691162,
0.36217737197875977,
0.15978825092315674,
0.5380237698554993,
0.08138103783130646,
-0.879268229007721,
-0.3508571684360504,
-0.0011615417897701263,
-0.4130260944366455,
0.18032942712306976,
-0.20212601125240326,
0.10853615403175354,
0.352558434009552,
0.8350200653076172,
-0.6596267223358154,
0.4750884473323822,
0.8284648656845093,
-0.15331828594207764,
0.2993011474609375,
0.037866443395614624,
0.22458559274673462,
-1.133467435836792,
-0.3514847159385681,
-0.01684276945888996,
-0.015716811642050743,
-0.9112115502357483,
-0.4075605869293213,
-0.3084242343902588,
-0.40175604820251465,
-0.473542720079422,
0.6802605390548706,
-0.23646576702594757,
-0.4107509255409241,
-0.17907488346099854,
0.25732848048210144,
-0.3494429290294647,
0.7317883968353271,
0.447927325963974,
0.8416366577148438,
0.26859545707702637,
-0.49937570095062256,
0.628311276435852,
0.23862464725971222,
-0.15552039444446564,
0.4824013113975525,
-0.7452052235603333,
0.33533746004104614,
0.3140083849430084,
0.5649286508560181,
-1.4422539472579956,
-0.13839037716388702,
-0.1277467906475067,
-0.4717174768447876,
0.5218024849891663,
0.007531752344220877,
-0.07896394282579422,
-0.31579670310020447,
-0.0958620235323906,
0.4252634346485138,
0.3098280727863312,
-0.5056777596473694,
0.9826419353485107,
0.46674367785453796,
-0.6142123937606812,
-0.17847155034542084,
-0.6523897051811218,
0.1217576414346695,
-0.025707386434078217,
-0.8601896166801453,
0.5544396042823792,
-0.16442029178142548,
-0.12008202821016312,
-0.5037640333175659,
0.3576134145259857,
-0.0629754438996315,
-0.16258937120437622,
0.5472661852836609,
0.4582749605178833,
-0.2000235617160797,
0.12970657646656036,
0.11266182363033295,
-0.25326842069625854,
0.06659679114818573,
-0.22127822041511536,
0.839062511920929,
-0.104193776845932,
-0.5661524534225464,
-0.6857950687408447,
0.49923574924468994,
0.6733871102333069,
-0.06717942655086517,
0.5127354860305786,
0.6526790261268616,
-0.2732519209384918,
0.14623023569583893,
-0.694044291973114,
-0.5229446887969971,
-0.45370304584503174,
0.4501328468322754,
-0.1973862498998642,
-0.9410765767097473,
0.3555113673210144,
0.006506723817437887,
0.1405298411846161,
0.07333583384752274,
0.8892714977264404,
-0.18151436746120453,
1.296521782875061,
0.6080690026283264,
-0.34862664341926575,
0.44283589720726013,
-0.15610942244529724,
0.3632030487060547,
-0.8793359398841858,
-0.4508443772792816,
-0.5232897400856018,
-0.5162975192070007,
-0.7331565618515015,
-0.44713088870048523,
0.30759376287460327,
-0.32206279039382935,
-0.12125646322965622,
0.11130384355783463,
-0.10546907037496567,
0.18796180188655853,
0.7538822293281555,
0.04488486051559448,
0.3093530833721161,
-0.2383279800415039,
0.03220616281032562,
0.10841498523950577,
-0.7927019596099854,
-0.16403283178806305,
0.9591532945632935,
0.4267415404319763,
0.7136488556861877,
-0.09061810374259949,
0.8038358092308044,
0.027041638270020485,
0.12670668959617615,
-0.8593701124191284,
0.5663880109786987,
-0.029534464702010155,
-0.663114607334137,
-0.811722457408905,
-0.11730384826660156,
-0.9465672969818115,
-0.07029956579208374,
-0.26852476596832275,
-0.9280768036842346,
-0.013615505769848824,
0.12118922173976898,
-0.4497104585170746,
0.1988496035337448,
-0.6217907667160034,
0.5894496440887451,
-0.3540043830871582,
-0.26360535621643066,
-0.5582184791564941,
-0.6258459091186523,
0.23432888090610504,
0.3171031177043915,
0.2538664937019348,
0.031100256368517876,
0.1332741528749466,
0.7561739683151245,
-0.07103639841079712,
1.2603312730789185,
-0.033154070377349854,
-0.33227360248565674,
0.250996857881546,
0.05705208703875542,
0.3321189284324646,
0.01728745549917221,
0.12473494559526443,
0.41623783111572266,
-0.4071233868598938,
-0.1963808536529541,
-0.509994387626648,
0.8592312335968018,
-0.933867871761322,
-0.6215298771858215,
-0.09713485091924667,
-0.8421012759208679,
-0.6602339148521423,
0.01619880646467209,
0.2781166732311249,
0.3608856201171875,
-0.3070315718650818,
-0.018045589327812195,
0.6889793276786804,
-0.1620500385761261,
0.6336103081703186,
0.5656796097755432,
-0.16712714731693268,
-0.43708184361457825,
0.9944977760314941,
-0.09700009226799011,
0.3740750551223755,
0.43448495864868164,
0.1529417186975479,
-0.3027113974094391,
-0.6398305892944336,
-0.22585783898830414,
0.3465070128440857,
-0.3683024048805237,
0.019800178706645966,
-0.3219769299030304,
-0.41700395941734314,
-0.583030104637146,
-0.31710925698280334,
-0.612352192401886,
-0.2273230254650116,
-0.1369786262512207,
-0.014621728099882603,
0.1337159276008606,
0.8506107926368713,
0.020822592079639435,
0.39544689655303955,
-0.9359642267227173,
0.1733042150735855,
0.7868503928184509,
0.3323901891708374,
0.024794254451990128,
-0.4624493718147278,
-0.24550457298755646,
0.38090017437934875,
-0.2836708128452301,
-0.6163395047187805,
0.42886871099472046,
0.0997740849852562,
0.7909129858016968,
0.16674262285232544,
-0.3616287112236023,
0.37991955876350403,
-0.514639139175415,
1.0255001783370972,
0.43246161937713623,
-0.8358248472213745,
0.5941615700721741,
-0.33512383699417114,
0.46320170164108276,
0.2385888397693634,
0.3319462835788727,
-0.8158444166183472,
-0.31158456206321716,
-0.6416472792625427,
-0.6692686676979065,
0.6684455275535583,
0.002080364618450403,
-0.17950031161308289,
0.28763559460639954,
-0.09487862884998322,
0.10712548345327377,
0.21629633009433746,
-0.3495303690433502,
-0.06351163983345032,
-0.021082604303956032,
-0.12569560110569,
-0.5372617244720459,
-0.1564505696296692,
-0.2889414429664612,
-0.2748209536075592,
0.6693874597549438,
-0.15109145641326904,
0.5995413661003113,
-0.1306161731481552,
0.21701563894748688,
-0.42028823494911194,
0.2547406256198883,
0.9689347743988037,
0.66161048412323,
-0.11909381300210953,
-0.1752682477235794,
0.4236401915550232,
-0.38588494062423706,
-0.05673738196492195,
0.06411011517047882,
-0.0603925883769989,
-0.009572084993124008,
0.5662485957145691,
0.9863269925117493,
0.6826205253601074,
-0.622128427028656,
0.15394532680511475,
0.07626057416200638,
-0.06327469646930695,
-0.4435303211212158,
0.07070645689964294,
0.3517577052116394,
0.6293337941169739,
0.24756485223770142,
-0.30083492398262024,
0.07810515910387039,
-0.7421002984046936,
0.21691013872623444,
0.4056573212146759,
-0.6054375767707825,
-0.3638375997543335,
0.1723954826593399,
0.5411162972450256,
-0.8352342844009399,
0.778371274471283,
0.3611980676651001,
-0.6990583539009094,
0.4906323552131653,
0.5979124307632446,
1.1464310884475708,
-0.7171187996864319,
0.13227497041225433,
0.16966521739959717,
-0.039684318006038666,
0.10177939385175705,
0.1636471450328827,
-0.0033900346606969833,
-0.9786423444747925,
-0.6501880884170532,
-0.3977232277393341,
-0.8004543781280518,
0.2917272746562958,
-0.587187647819519,
0.2400675266981125,
-0.3555697798728943,
0.02304553985595703,
0.19553862512111664,
0.008853526785969734,
-0.4268820285797119,
0.12962841987609863,
0.6752451062202454,
0.4636130630970001,
-0.7800477147102356,
1.035851001739502,
0.4801322817802429,
-0.2609364092350006,
-0.815029501914978,
-0.022604571655392647,
0.07349255681037903,
-0.8579358458518982,
0.5360565185546875,
-0.05160389840602875,
-0.35466068983078003,
-0.1972222626209259,
-0.6921300888061523,
-0.8178530335426331,
1.233962893486023,
0.04773706570267677,
-0.8808273077011108,
-0.21227240562438965,
0.14967866241931915,
0.31503093242645264,
-0.632947564125061,
0.03392847254872322,
0.996463418006897,
0.4085070788860321,
0.4662790894508362,
-1.3306951522827148,
-0.2671339809894562,
0.04872923716902733,
0.03440988436341286,
0.3664375841617584,
-0.6892375946044922,
0.9654166102409363,
-0.15498386323451996,
0.1872028261423111,
-0.017846940085291862,
0.8035367131233215,
0.46611422300338745,
0.6141637563705444,
0.388448029756546,
0.40730488300323486,
0.4570161998271942,
-0.17806610465049744,
0.9197700023651123,
-0.13908202946186066,
0.07663920521736145,
1.3223904371261597,
-0.3278801441192627,
1.081960916519165,
0.6021866798400879,
-0.23181606829166412,
0.46303805708885193,
0.33008164167404175,
0.2931026518344879,
0.46244126558303833,
-0.1438448280096054,
-0.1939169317483902,
-0.26928430795669556,
0.07410551607608795,
-0.2917429506778717,
0.840297281742096,
0.6641144752502441,
-0.09366368502378464,
0.18982315063476562,
0.23908483982086182,
-0.059480778872966766,
-0.06602675467729568,
-0.46751534938812256,
0.9651626944541931,
0.07244459539651871,
-0.9624344110488892,
0.5531083941459656,
-0.25320470333099365,
0.6992121934890747,
-0.29283323884010315,
-0.27853649854660034,
-0.13766388595104218,
0.1300065964460373,
-0.09159761667251587,
-0.9445796608924866,
0.08997952938079834,
-0.6002033948898315,
-0.0890050157904625,
-0.15285678207874298,
0.7460036277770996,
-0.9087598919868469,
-0.34216973185539246,
0.422776997089386,
0.2980877161026001,
0.030447861179709435,
0.18733438849449158,
-0.6529415845870972,
0.15748004615306854,
0.1873558908700943,
-0.031139863654971123,
0.4605255126953125,
0.026485418900847435,
0.08539965748786926,
0.7158412933349609,
0.6222184896469116,
0.0743422880768776,
0.06872975826263428,
0.17398658394813538,
0.7891035676002502,
-0.8679894804954529,
-0.6026187539100647,
-0.5711869597434998,
0.42280638217926025,
0.002316675614565611,
-0.1731960028409958,
0.36253929138183594,
0.2749086320400238,
0.7900577187538147,
0.08375885337591171,
0.8194819092750549,
0.425329327583313,
0.6305675506591797,
-0.7758471369743347,
0.40488138794898987,
-0.18177781999111176,
0.17645728588104248,
-0.22969789803028107,
-0.9995453953742981,
0.1529785841703415,
0.510285496711731,
-0.42254653573036194,
0.12129124253988266,
0.472482830286026,
0.8025091290473938,
0.10513099282979965,
0.3623325824737549,
0.5142365097999573,
0.3942268490791321,
0.400113582611084,
0.6665882468223572,
0.8544959425926208,
-0.1449826955795288,
0.27363020181655884,
-0.34088706970214844,
-0.08873875439167023,
-0.5602160692214966,
-0.6022704243659973,
-0.9585829377174377,
-0.8084345459938049,
-0.14193443953990936,
-0.342618465423584,
0.0905839204788208,
0.8243818879127502,
0.8340579867362976,
-0.9813826084136963,
-0.7760608792304993,
-0.010712426155805588,
0.19479545950889587,
-0.20819972455501556,
-0.16726776957511902,
-0.04445689544081688,
-0.11062029004096985,
-0.8732714653015137,
0.8521372675895691,
0.4553532600402832,
0.11967915296554565,
-0.7783305644989014,
-0.38150349259376526,
-0.5780525803565979,
0.20718829333782196,
0.6671627759933472,
0.4601476788520813,
-0.9683769345283508,
-0.5095410346984863,
-0.0019531220896169543,
-0.04723598062992096,
-0.04897652938961983,
1.0354139804840088,
-0.7722930312156677,
0.32248327136039734,
0.31240567564964294,
0.49888232350349426,
0.8870492577552795,
-0.13726557791233063,
1.1898412704467773,
-0.64872807264328,
0.3054426312446594,
0.5361011624336243,
0.13853810727596283,
0.2758118808269501,
-0.33768123388290405,
0.2438553124666214,
-0.14461232721805573,
-0.578272819519043,
-0.5267618298530579,
0.281026154756546,
-1.1679476499557495,
-0.16561229526996613,
1.0937525033950806,
0.08437750488519669,
-0.17889687418937683,
-0.20695984363555908,
-0.31402862071990967,
0.3778678774833679,
-0.5760246515274048,
0.6762989163398743,
0.6573893427848816,
-0.40092629194259644,
-0.3954315185546875,
-0.3172105848789215,
0.40400639176368713,
0.3813195824623108,
-0.7383239269256592,
0.0029726820066571236,
0.5220137238502502,
-0.043738558888435364,
0.5778743028640747,
0.32523515820503235,
0.19381378591060638,
0.4481596350669861,
-0.015570303425192833,
0.0810244083404541,
0.014626848511397839,
-0.5609482526779175,
-0.3812723159790039,
-0.04301395267248154,
-0.13785095512866974,
-0.10013915598392487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01717v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01717v1 | From RAG to QA-RAG: Integrating Generative AI for Pharmaceutical Regulatory Compliance Process | 2024-01-26T08:23:29 | 2024-01-26T08:23:29 | Jaewoong Kim, Moohong Min | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, I.2.7; I.2.1; J.3 | Regulatory compliance in the pharmaceutical industry entails navigating
through complex and voluminous guidelines, often requiring significant human
resources. To address these challenges, our study introduces a chatbot model
that utilizes generative AI and the Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)
method. This chatbot is designed to search for guideline documents relevant to
the user inquiries and provide answers based on the retrieved guidelines.
Recognizing the inherent need for high reliability in this domain, we propose
the Question and Answer Retrieval Augmented Generation (QA-RAG) model. In
comparative experiments, the QA-RAG model demonstrated a significant
improvement in accuracy, outperforming all other baselines including
conventional RAG methods. This paper details QA-RAG's structure and performance
evaluation, emphasizing its potential for the regulatory compliance domain in
the pharmaceutical industry and beyond. We have made our work publicly
available for further research and development. | [
-0.05642835423350334,
-0.7702568769454956,
0.5989385843276978,
-0.10033249855041504,
-0.11290911585092545,
0.03690216690301895,
0.17692255973815918,
-0.4863947033882141,
0.09811915457248688,
1.0316189527511597,
-0.4444655478000641,
-0.29863566160202026,
-0.467829167842865,
0.19384847581386566,
-0.42581772804260254,
1.243497371673584,
0.03273693472146988,
-0.028182514011859894,
-0.4054180085659027,
-0.01331217773258686,
-0.7046130895614624,
-0.42461028695106506,
-0.6075639128684998,
-0.37865445017814636,
0.454233318567276,
0.11299100518226624,
0.4917883574962616,
0.36211884021759033,
0.8941768407821655,
0.38658607006073,
-0.3143908679485321,
0.36103230714797974,
-0.30182042717933655,
0.22011956572532654,
-0.25027403235435486,
-0.6882022023200989,
-0.7380219101905823,
-0.02714744582772255,
0.20732200145721436,
0.1637025624513626,
-0.6372640132904053,
0.3260526657104492,
0.10631948709487915,
0.6695548295974731,
-0.6496354341506958,
0.15458834171295166,
-0.2699596583843231,
-0.25634056329727173,
-0.01975446753203869,
-0.45022785663604736,
-0.48518168926239014,
-0.6091939210891724,
0.17073257267475128,
-1.0377076864242554,
0.22430789470672607,
0.17318442463874817,
1.2305071353912354,
0.6030426621437073,
-0.43754327297210693,
-0.8574103116989136,
-0.9721225500106812,
0.30333879590034485,
-0.6102293133735657,
0.15099959075450897,
0.5558061003684998,
0.40642306208610535,
-0.4790979027748108,
-1.3902039527893066,
-0.7330097556114197,
-0.4064802825450897,
-0.12194537371397018,
0.0449032336473465,
-0.1431846171617508,
0.11915595829486847,
0.10123045742511749,
0.39126893877983093,
-0.37842878699302673,
-0.29735037684440613,
-0.575222909450531,
-0.16686922311782837,
0.34667491912841797,
0.06879917532205582,
0.4432026743888855,
-0.3272213935852051,
-0.318669855594635,
-0.12980563938617706,
-0.3380105793476105,
0.027118481695652008,
0.04717143252491951,
0.21102726459503174,
-0.05664088577032089,
0.5540504455566406,
0.09086251258850098,
0.5589139461517334,
0.1568877249956131,
-0.1128009781241417,
0.2851138114929199,
-0.5070852041244507,
-0.2902417778968811,
-0.22278621792793274,
0.6759604811668396,
0.105016328394413,
-0.1659451723098755,
0.07681451737880707,
-0.3304193615913391,
-0.13428819179534912,
0.8068011403083801,
-0.6308069229125977,
-0.3153284192085266,
0.47187331318855286,
-0.4627925157546997,
-0.2969954013824463,
-0.07502590864896774,
-0.6601420640945435,
-0.6721963882446289,
-0.5497708916664124,
0.5255351066589355,
-0.4100145697593689,
-0.2182369977235794,
-0.043560612946748734,
-0.46754392981529236,
0.7104743719100952,
0.42609548568725586,
-0.6764042973518372,
-0.01244427915662527,
1.0992116928100586,
0.6168553829193115,
-0.006449711974710226,
0.28708934783935547,
-0.518989622592926,
0.16897115111351013,
-0.5747264623641968,
0.9105152487754822,
-0.4719543159008026,
-0.5694782137870789,
-0.2057383805513382,
-0.050195954740047455,
0.0011227451032027602,
-0.754849910736084,
0.7196024060249329,
-0.7561092972755432,
0.22250749170780182,
-0.008255178108811378,
-0.6608226299285889,
-0.22380344569683075,
0.4862200617790222,
-0.5742220282554626,
0.4789454936981201,
0.22699719667434692,
-0.45460081100463867,
0.4238849878311157,
-0.6527636647224426,
-0.07997250556945801,
0.48872509598731995,
-0.3526817858219147,
-0.704821765422821,
-0.22924409806728363,
-0.07733035832643509,
-0.15848243236541748,
-0.5133075714111328,
0.14962957799434662,
0.026752697303891182,
-0.21751855313777924,
0.3775419294834137,
-0.17453502118587494,
1.0032726526260376,
0.48096540570259094,
-0.09293746203184128,
0.4388643503189087,
-0.6499419212341309,
0.17946431040763855,
-0.2786412835121155,
-0.6499838829040527,
-0.17597819864749908,
-0.3404143154621124,
0.22563864290714264,
0.03533706068992615,
0.15011779963970184,
-0.2777283787727356,
0.05659916624426842,
-0.20964813232421875,
0.24566565454006195,
0.7384868860244751,
0.5114124417304993,
0.3144669234752655,
-0.5395777225494385,
0.8254038095474243,
-0.5771018266677856,
0.4456881582736969,
0.10209522396326065,
-0.6283824443817139,
-0.6336921453475952,
-0.37326449155807495,
0.6334465146064758,
0.808329701423645,
-0.8526979088783264,
0.5995056629180908,
0.04328582435846329,
-0.4785188138484955,
-0.7689865231513977,
0.20270706713199615,
0.5575261116027832,
0.7209562659263611,
0.19215743243694305,
-0.3070039451122284,
-0.4482097029685974,
-0.5459150075912476,
-0.10960602760314941,
-0.3833169639110565,
-0.2879208028316498,
0.3831222951412201,
0.413003146648407,
-0.6759858131408691,
0.8113048076629639,
-0.4171190559864044,
-0.6274574995040894,
-0.18039818108081818,
0.32425442337989807,
0.23414282500743866,
0.624085009098053,
0.2566346824169159,
-1.2564418315887451,
-0.4803352653980255,
0.18333886563777924,
-0.7337779998779297,
-0.06283409893512726,
0.039367660880088806,
-0.41308802366256714,
0.30256396532058716,
0.6683586835861206,
-0.574486494064331,
0.46155068278312683,
0.4354710876941681,
-0.3757736384868622,
0.3506793975830078,
-0.4571519196033478,
0.42461100220680237,
-1.3687477111816406,
0.540056049823761,
-0.008746986277401447,
-0.2354310005903244,
-0.8793515563011169,
0.29118311405181885,
0.13528592884540558,
-0.17844203114509583,
-0.40422165393829346,
0.31963616609573364,
-0.19207344949245453,
0.22965815663337708,
-0.4194042682647705,
-0.08533638715744019,
0.23627890646457672,
0.36853355169296265,
-0.5060873627662659,
1.1639612913131714,
0.24880459904670715,
-0.9338980913162231,
0.4415093958377838,
0.6448181867599487,
-0.17653408646583557,
0.8609662652015686,
-0.7598105669021606,
0.05451469123363495,
-0.19767853617668152,
0.2931862771511078,
-0.8314802050590515,
-0.4209844768047333,
0.5335915684700012,
-0.501346230506897,
0.6216728091239929,
-0.3502074182033539,
-0.3362889587879181,
-0.154121994972229,
0.06769533455371857,
0.17573930323123932,
0.9079075455665588,
-0.07573789358139038,
1.054715633392334,
0.7460759282112122,
-0.10773427039384842,
-0.393597275018692,
-0.37751010060310364,
0.07334614545106888,
-0.06078508496284485,
-0.26966989040374756,
0.09166989475488663,
0.019579512998461723,
-0.17271938920021057,
-0.04307234287261963,
0.00969583261758089,
-0.21648330986499786,
-0.053244698792696,
0.22006049752235413,
0.4973788857460022,
-0.14991898834705353,
0.06036509573459625,
-0.3981558680534363,
-0.1529572606086731,
0.10677793622016907,
0.06038286164402962,
0.4705314338207245,
-0.10672875493764877,
-0.09677291661500931,
-0.8172873854637146,
0.08628944307565689,
0.7115899920463562,
-0.40579986572265625,
0.47143295407295227,
0.5116671919822693,
-0.09374874830245972,
0.010654875077307224,
-0.4268691837787628,
-0.05620625615119934,
-0.5686883926391602,
0.08618832379579544,
-0.12839578092098236,
-0.4615168571472168,
0.4588780999183655,
-0.20120415091514587,
0.010676519945263863,
0.5121229290962219,
0.6522873044013977,
-0.2044299989938736,
0.653118908405304,
0.959387481212616,
0.6087656617164612,
0.38861533999443054,
-0.19761960208415985,
0.22945725917816162,
-0.969357430934906,
-0.579615592956543,
-0.6630800366401672,
0.012022350914776325,
-0.9502624869346619,
-0.750479519367218,
0.8733492493629456,
0.008301920257508755,
0.0006912274984642863,
0.31136026978492737,
-0.7203857898712158,
0.24523070454597473,
0.641653835773468,
0.12475378811359406,
0.2314257025718689,
-0.3068099021911621,
0.16877490282058716,
0.3327244520187378,
-0.4884159564971924,
-0.5807318091392517,
0.9959371089935303,
0.214883953332901,
0.8962273001670837,
0.27899616956710815,
0.3703077435493469,
0.6598331332206726,
0.5593424439430237,
-0.5015643835067749,
0.5220385789871216,
-0.24236181378364563,
-0.6282747983932495,
-0.25189459323883057,
-0.4508483409881592,
-0.942254364490509,
-0.002031343523412943,
-0.4658397436141968,
-0.3009827733039856,
0.31561478972435,
0.20832942426204681,
-0.4833829402923584,
0.004087731707841158,
-0.7468559145927429,
0.8234346508979797,
0.06795015931129456,
-0.014769522473216057,
-0.10651353001594543,
-0.5484414100646973,
0.24422094225883484,
-0.3354732394218445,
0.048200152814388275,
-0.30787935853004456,
-0.10327600687742233,
0.503568708896637,
-0.5824606418609619,
0.7942002415657043,
0.11217305809259415,
-0.3051556646823883,
0.4449748694896698,
-0.25195208191871643,
0.33723750710487366,
-0.09553147107362747,
0.09799230843782425,
-0.1738498955965042,
0.31217336654663086,
-0.22448594868183136,
-0.6113219857215881,
0.2825968861579895,
-0.594373881816864,
-0.5402721166610718,
-0.41333627700805664,
-0.5395084023475647,
-0.20306961238384247,
0.4232345521450043,
0.36247435212135315,
0.1807759702205658,
-0.04871829226613045,
0.0183089692145586,
0.9189206957817078,
-0.4258955717086792,
-0.24693481624126434,
0.6834679841995239,
-0.24259372055530548,
-0.38481661677360535,
0.7516474723815918,
-0.07816442102193832,
0.11283183097839355,
0.35332828760147095,
0.14374051988124847,
-0.4842219948768616,
-0.2246878445148468,
-0.4340032935142517,
0.2322748601436615,
-0.6138319373130798,
-0.3577687740325928,
-0.5589341521263123,
-0.4876578152179718,
-0.7164298892021179,
0.13660556077957153,
-0.14170251786708832,
-0.21730230748653412,
-0.33802977204322815,
0.3788932263851166,
0.5246448516845703,
0.938327431678772,
0.2127462476491928,
-0.0031797047704458237,
-1.0141605138778687,
0.6720679998397827,
0.3919529318809509,
0.552086591720581,
-0.35115861892700195,
-0.572709858417511,
0.09380324184894562,
-0.07147503644227982,
-0.5438666343688965,
-0.7275034189224243,
0.07816099375486374,
0.0974293127655983,
0.6515730023384094,
0.1753644198179245,
0.1759769469499588,
0.4275331199169159,
-0.5016681551933289,
0.3863159120082855,
-0.05677797645330429,
-0.6550207138061523,
0.6716663241386414,
-0.35588201880455017,
0.08730713278055191,
0.3742508590221405,
0.20028270781040192,
-0.5840485692024231,
-0.7215485572814941,
-0.3400574028491974,
-0.8319766521453857,
0.4079560339450836,
0.3672029376029968,
0.22614280879497528,
0.34041884541511536,
0.7041822671890259,
-0.17554903030395508,
0.173922598361969,
-0.10197858512401581,
-0.08504024893045425,
0.28618982434272766,
-0.06735115498304367,
0.34926730394363403,
-0.234566330909729,
-0.4217907190322876,
0.12896475195884705,
0.7420451641082764,
0.06235964596271515,
0.005132131278514862,
0.236335888504982,
0.38319098949432373,
0.033296555280685425,
0.4374023973941803,
0.6769712567329407,
0.7225463390350342,
-0.1102740690112114,
-0.5850225687026978,
-0.22768723964691162,
-0.7594956159591675,
0.08732715249061584,
0.2769674062728882,
-0.4484514594078064,
-0.09826049953699112,
-0.015557890757918358,
0.38835570216178894,
-0.32993239164352417,
-0.8109427690505981,
0.3023173213005066,
-0.33218276500701904,
-0.32801151275634766,
-0.4564859867095947,
0.30942171812057495,
-0.32675692439079285,
0.4747278690338135,
0.3607012629508972,
0.19299976527690887,
0.41784825921058655,
-0.5854416489601135,
0.6574390530586243,
0.1869177520275116,
-0.29202067852020264,
0.32778385281562805,
1.0325218439102173,
0.2592822313308716,
-0.591208815574646,
0.649389386177063,
-0.0818188488483429,
-0.30701377987861633,
0.922339141368866,
0.21957926452159882,
0.8832669854164124,
-0.1760832667350769,
0.25966811180114746,
0.3329944610595703,
-0.06473468244075775,
-0.0549197718501091,
0.29948294162750244,
0.07973019033670425,
-0.308322936296463,
-0.4967298209667206,
-0.508385419845581,
-0.885835587978363,
-0.14986304938793182,
-0.8265231847763062,
0.23056380450725555,
-0.44593220949172974,
-0.5432057976722717,
0.14437146484851837,
-0.23295313119888306,
-0.25710931420326233,
-0.10467025637626648,
-0.19020114839076996,
0.6733085513114929,
-0.27696141600608826,
0.5187292695045471,
0.803846538066864,
-0.7874509692192078,
-0.7662110924720764,
0.16997016966342926,
0.038087885826826096,
-0.5863134860992432,
0.2805668115615845,
-0.028879789635539055,
-0.10819193720817566,
-0.2498650848865509,
-0.47994258999824524,
-0.6056230068206787,
1.1628013849258423,
0.04423047974705696,
-0.3175055682659149,
-0.11895564198493958,
-0.012088784947991371,
0.9678757786750793,
0.0763004794716835,
-0.262611985206604,
0.8173714280128479,
0.08701013773679733,
0.42166373133659363,
-1.015015959739685,
-0.17063504457473755,
-0.5396580696105957,
0.08676953613758087,
0.3120870292186737,
-0.5159832835197449,
0.6100785136222839,
-0.14246726036071777,
-0.2186095118522644,
0.3874566853046417,
0.5737999677658081,
0.5025388598442078,
0.26218706369400024,
0.19174639880657196,
0.43062135577201843,
0.817838728427887,
-0.03766458109021187,
1.1578528881072998,
-0.492707222700119,
0.1366581916809082,
1.0327321290969849,
-0.39174285531044006,
1.0058245658874512,
0.3269023597240448,
-0.010383452288806438,
0.7399887442588806,
0.23085197806358337,
-0.15578188002109528,
0.270907998085022,
0.12681454420089722,
-0.23857305943965912,
0.036971159279346466,
-0.47710806131362915,
-0.10902851074934006,
0.37582963705062866,
0.48802435398101807,
-0.19816714525222778,
0.08167574554681778,
0.11399742215871811,
-0.27039384841918945,
0.28778383135795593,
-0.2555330693721771,
1.1965253353118896,
-0.06142255663871765,
-0.9027513861656189,
0.5500826239585876,
-0.06974518299102783,
0.2704654335975647,
-0.707324743270874,
-0.525165319442749,
-0.09345930069684982,
0.4387029707431793,
-0.023091010749340057,
-0.9437463283538818,
0.31756237149238586,
0.20277002453804016,
-0.17919519543647766,
-0.20743092894554138,
0.530286967754364,
-0.4296662509441376,
-0.3544422388076782,
-0.1312759518623352,
0.1935260146856308,
0.06280986219644547,
0.35592883825302124,
-0.8158470392227173,
-0.10334956645965576,
-0.10357507318258286,
0.18759478628635406,
0.029734572395682335,
0.4955812692642212,
0.07152663916349411,
0.8806934356689453,
0.7364988327026367,
0.12639878690242767,
0.0606699138879776,
-0.02834874764084816,
0.836485743522644,
-0.2132808268070221,
-0.6499512791633606,
-0.3828173279762268,
0.4562939405441284,
-0.05086018890142441,
-0.26271381974220276,
0.451730877161026,
0.47846469283103943,
0.4575706422328949,
0.014684608206152916,
0.5687510967254639,
-0.199928417801857,
0.8795467615127563,
-0.6411592364311218,
0.9977156519889832,
-0.6204555630683899,
0.5527116656303406,
0.155274897813797,
-0.4449949562549591,
-0.24940595030784607,
0.3451297879219055,
0.12204467505216599,
0.12075459957122803,
0.22170399129390717,
0.9850417971611023,
0.24673034250736237,
-0.2605004608631134,
0.08381889015436172,
0.02368863672018051,
0.6134855151176453,
0.2814379334449768,
0.533429741859436,
-0.5952118039131165,
0.8778328895568848,
0.015870530158281326,
-0.19659967720508575,
-0.23525948822498322,
-0.6189085841178894,
-0.5871077179908752,
-0.5703822374343872,
-0.21586419641971588,
-0.8553276062011719,
0.12366916239261627,
0.8651514053344727,
0.5133442878723145,
-0.9070385694503784,
-0.13331276178359985,
-0.2552111744880676,
-0.02715360000729561,
-0.1465824991464615,
-0.2853425145149231,
0.2642890512943268,
-0.7405600547790527,
-0.7223643064498901,
-0.07491981983184814,
0.4335884153842926,
0.3202187716960907,
-0.1757185310125351,
-0.16331622004508972,
-0.32484832406044006,
0.287092924118042,
0.16533659398555756,
0.6477422714233398,
-0.6095699667930603,
0.22300125658512115,
-0.06087537854909897,
-0.6889303922653198,
0.09186097979545593,
0.9923279285430908,
-0.3840036988258362,
0.742923378944397,
0.6806944012641907,
0.8890665173530579,
0.1716376543045044,
0.3839084208011627,
0.9242591857910156,
-0.4713656008243561,
-0.09990322589874268,
0.5413364171981812,
0.02369915507733822,
0.07771771401166916,
-0.5065745711326599,
0.7344574928283691,
-0.13374844193458557,
-1.0487663745880127,
-0.6253936290740967,
0.1965382993221283,
-0.8038026690483093,
-0.33800920844078064,
1.0666204690933228,
-0.03137528896331787,
-0.3302021622657776,
-0.3982572853565216,
-0.4228143095970154,
0.3236329257488251,
-0.30314314365386963,
0.9962006211280823,
0.4059952199459076,
-0.29665887355804443,
-0.13198061287403107,
-0.7431855201721191,
0.9948834180831909,
0.2171773910522461,
-1.0380340814590454,
0.12146865576505661,
0.5458874702453613,
0.14814434945583344,
0.39029550552368164,
1.101483702659607,
-0.17089955508708954,
0.6378182172775269,
-0.009076290763914585,
0.0713004395365715,
0.28881099820137024,
-0.05468754842877388,
-0.30319952964782715,
-0.15481527149677277,
0.17479021847248077,
-0.23341365158557892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01716v1 | Bloom-epistemic and sentiment analysis hierarchical classification in course discussion forums | 2024-01-26T08:20:13 | 2024-01-26T08:20:13 | H. Toba, Y. T. Hernita, M. Ayub, M. C. Wijanto | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | Online discussion forums are widely used for active textual interaction
between lecturers and students, and to see how the students have progressed in
a learning process. The objective of this study is to compare appropriate
machine-learning models to assess sentiments and Bloom\'s epistemic taxonomy
based on textual comments in educational discussion forums. Our proposed method
is called the hierarchical approach of Bloom-Epistemic and Sentiment Analysis
(BE-Sent). The research methodology consists of three main steps. The first
step is the data collection from the internal discussion forum and YouTube
comments of a Web Programming channel. The next step is text preprocessing to
annotate the text and clear unimportant words. Furthermore, with the text
dataset that has been successfully cleaned, sentiment analysis and epistemic
categorization will be done in each sentence of the text. Sentiment analysis is
divided into three categories: positive, negative, and neutral. Bloom\'s
epistemic is divided into six categories: remembering, understanding, applying,
analyzing, evaluating, and creating. This research has succeeded in producing a
course learning subsystem that assesses opinions based on text reviews of
discussion forums according to the category of sentiment and epistemic
analysis. | [
-0.536831796169281,
-1.2693977355957031,
0.2603994607925415,
0.45003199577331543,
-0.16832000017166138,
0.26639115810394287,
-0.27739405632019043,
-0.17309896647930145,
0.26080724596977234,
0.06817372143268585,
-0.70023113489151,
-0.5334292650222778,
-0.5541746616363525,
0.1400768756866455,
-0.2968354821205139,
1.3350629806518555,
0.18578028678894043,
0.013943006284534931,
-0.244744211435318,
0.059260398149490356,
-0.033228062093257904,
-0.6842604875564575,
-0.6209185123443604,
-0.03289920836687088,
0.34821125864982605,
0.3583262264728546,
0.19540227949619293,
-0.028239475563168526,
0.8941242694854736,
0.3372962772846222,
-0.4705756902694702,
-0.09468217194080353,
-0.5887094736099243,
0.07150675356388092,
-0.31812039017677307,
-0.4792221784591675,
-0.5194593667984009,
-0.15234103798866272,
0.2784716486930847,
0.7457452416419983,
-0.14061833918094635,
0.40022900700569153,
0.2776733338832855,
0.5417912006378174,
-0.9170295596122742,
0.08943278342485428,
-0.47278401255607605,
0.5547603964805603,
-0.021533554419875145,
-0.620464026927948,
-0.6479756236076355,
-0.4775911867618561,
0.5129840970039368,
-0.44186165928840637,
0.058237507939338684,
0.05088990181684494,
0.7459432482719421,
0.11845842003822327,
-0.2360886186361313,
-0.48064273595809937,
-0.7580727338790894,
1.0880423784255981,
-0.6428489089012146,
0.04026857763528824,
0.21379147469997406,
0.3845151364803314,
0.2622627019882202,
-0.5286502838134766,
-0.4581810534000397,
0.2929241955280304,
0.02749442495405674,
0.6533443927764893,
-0.22893553972244263,
0.12625111639499664,
0.2451051026582718,
0.7943541407585144,
-0.48022910952568054,
-0.08845379203557968,
-0.2667695879936218,
0.018107781186699867,
0.3187245726585388,
0.0898716077208519,
0.28896626830101013,
-0.5170425176620483,
-0.5178273320198059,
0.04144412651658058,
-0.246661975979805,
-0.0587771050632,
0.06793186813592911,
0.4123215675354004,
0.014984406530857086,
0.26152297854423523,
-0.18193596601486206,
0.35411787033081055,
-0.019359562546014786,
-0.18368975818157196,
0.3981390595436096,
-0.28769707679748535,
-0.6035916209220886,
-0.1757265031337738,
0.7444007396697998,
0.41199368238449097,
0.09881789237260818,
0.020747577771544456,
0.19001545011997223,
0.2171810269355774,
0.5535274744033813,
-0.6893003582954407,
-0.130167156457901,
0.2172534316778183,
-0.9229636788368225,
-0.6693387031555176,
0.23927904665470123,
-1.3328131437301636,
0.06668794900178909,
-0.09491603076457977,
0.5712776780128479,
-0.05080752074718475,
-0.32824960350990295,
-0.2261853963136673,
-0.08988335728645325,
0.3125494122505188,
0.7334803342819214,
-0.823482096195221,
0.5918962955474854,
0.6736125946044922,
0.9591819643974304,
-0.36087244749069214,
-0.21016637980937958,
0.07215854525566101,
0.0005591500666923821,
0.05197586119174957,
0.8385639190673828,
-0.5924094319343567,
-0.346601277589798,
0.445068359375,
-0.05763080343604088,
-0.07187691330909729,
-0.3919840157032013,
0.6391393542289734,
-0.6175424456596375,
0.6772858500480652,
-0.35003241896629333,
-1.0092321634292603,
-0.5476257801055908,
0.8102174997329712,
-0.2233940064907074,
0.8484334349632263,
0.15127792954444885,
-1.3278146982192993,
0.3632088303565979,
-0.7649255394935608,
-0.2106165736913681,
0.07244770228862762,
-0.06165287643671036,
-0.533105731010437,
-0.1790042519569397,
0.08723044395446777,
0.5002079010009766,
-0.06245798617601395,
0.016973428428173065,
-0.35810309648513794,
-0.17543308436870575,
0.30028218030929565,
-0.3020634353160858,
0.8428525924682617,
0.25993481278419495,
-0.6793407797813416,
0.17751149833202362,
-0.4589002728462219,
0.21187569200992584,
-0.4344117343425751,
-0.5546252727508545,
-0.20623260736465454,
0.20104636251926422,
0.3049168288707733,
0.15680736303329468,
0.12448957562446594,
-0.5275135636329651,
0.08297742158174515,
-0.3815840184688568,
0.31056249141693115,
0.7452164888381958,
0.4838251769542694,
0.21610644459724426,
-0.28126880526542664,
0.2715250849723816,
0.35040363669395447,
0.4801434576511383,
-0.12299235910177231,
-0.5192750692367554,
-1.1738698482513428,
-0.14177726209163666,
0.05376037210226059,
0.7912330031394958,
-0.3410572409629822,
0.6205169558525085,
-0.12958689033985138,
-0.44614818692207336,
-0.0848536491394043,
-0.20681880414485931,
0.3529931306838989,
0.16739687323570251,
0.5271614789962769,
-0.4361102283000946,
-0.6524715423583984,
-0.39844584465026855,
-0.18015798926353455,
-0.6787026524543762,
0.11436156928539276,
0.1994556039571762,
0.6121242642402649,
-0.7289454340934753,
0.6920558214187622,
-0.691519021987915,
-0.3344924747943878,
0.03499356284737587,
0.5175150632858276,
-0.1335923969745636,
0.25564804673194885,
0.39193835854530334,
-0.5562829971313477,
-0.6860598921775818,
0.14695636928081512,
-0.8183658719062805,
0.1216277927160263,
0.2613409757614136,
-0.2897453308105469,
0.25589433312416077,
0.29242992401123047,
-0.476848304271698,
0.6242696642875671,
0.02077377587556839,
-0.10325384885072708,
0.22219111025333405,
0.16692973673343658,
0.5191977024078369,
-1.2827147245407104,
-0.14708034694194794,
0.04454459995031357,
-0.13135288655757904,
-0.6310235857963562,
0.1660914123058319,
-0.24665218591690063,
0.15627749264240265,
-0.24681483209133148,
-0.08181112259626389,
-0.0011082837590947747,
-0.14413270354270935,
-0.3617798686027527,
-0.03867773339152336,
-0.37146544456481934,
0.6928012371063232,
0.10968133807182312,
0.22189944982528687,
0.668938159942627,
-0.6073310375213623,
0.3653517961502075,
0.32120370864868164,
-0.16995848715305328,
0.46682801842689514,
-0.35200849175453186,
0.13352222740650177,
0.14741730690002441,
-0.010820837691426277,
-1.2521296739578247,
-0.19642598927021027,
0.2627667188644409,
-0.766845703125,
0.0790657177567482,
0.04885205253958702,
-0.3330219089984894,
-0.1887749433517456,
-0.5316933393478394,
-0.07571747899055481,
0.5544607043266296,
-0.3424181044101715,
0.2977353632450104,
0.4940113425254822,
-0.3679955303668976,
-0.35296669602394104,
-0.5161099433898926,
-0.2606290578842163,
-0.416155070066452,
-0.14584791660308838,
0.2649887800216675,
-0.05469756945967674,
-0.41593503952026367,
-0.007021244615316391,
0.3789377510547638,
-0.3369147479534149,
-0.044801659882068634,
0.30374032258987427,
0.27860206365585327,
-0.29232898354530334,
0.08765222877264023,
0.182547464966774,
0.10488447546958923,
0.24248400330543518,
-0.17016848921775818,
0.34369954466819763,
-0.33591175079345703,
-0.3503305912017822,
-0.43825647234916687,
0.2650463581085205,
0.7106887102127075,
0.21168367564678192,
0.9416584372520447,
0.4215299189090729,
-0.5646294951438904,
-0.31657034158706665,
-0.3678985834121704,
-0.13211457431316376,
-0.40371382236480713,
0.2681829035282135,
0.3142756223678589,
-1.012673258781433,
0.25671374797821045,
-0.20317134261131287,
0.514651358127594,
0.49161964654922485,
0.9230471849441528,
-0.3219432830810547,
0.7484418749809265,
0.810408353805542,
-0.35905179381370544,
0.3330190181732178,
-0.11602170765399933,
0.29750707745552063,
-0.34604009985923767,
-0.22811830043792725,
-0.6590079069137573,
-0.08704063296318054,
-0.5910449624061584,
-0.39216628670692444,
0.14248833060264587,
-0.2442384511232376,
-0.4751342833042145,
-0.040343157947063446,
-0.4460050165653229,
0.04055438190698624,
0.1868966817855835,
-0.021931303665041924,
0.2003231793642044,
0.48017868399620056,
0.027823898941278458,
-0.2986225485801697,
-0.49867284297943115,
-0.7195854783058167,
0.9646004438400269,
0.6788131594657898,
0.5438744425773621,
0.47714272141456604,
0.4780133366584778,
0.47441473603248596,
0.6790741086006165,
-1.117327094078064,
0.6567067503929138,
-0.0946984738111496,
-0.516902506351471,
-0.2652856111526489,
-0.5274577140808105,
-0.44557464122772217,
0.208372101187706,
-0.2814221680164337,
-0.6072397828102112,
-0.15171298384666443,
-0.14344656467437744,
-0.24818648397922516,
0.45680299401283264,
-0.343649685382843,
0.7523360252380371,
0.10724624246358871,
-0.2128324955701828,
-0.19562552869319916,
-0.5261082053184509,
0.11906707286834717,
-0.07479166984558105,
0.3750627934932709,
0.44894710183143616,
0.1932937502861023,
0.985152542591095,
-0.4927135109901428,
0.820678174495697,
-0.110910564661026,
0.1446274220943451,
0.3842492997646332,
-0.16448922455310822,
-0.11675945669412613,
-0.20904722809791565,
0.1914900541305542,
-0.11179538816213608,
0.10905234515666962,
-0.15513695776462555,
-0.5870150923728943,
0.42998528480529785,
-1.3600986003875732,
-0.26311424374580383,
-0.526800811290741,
0.15070699155330658,
-0.2673160433769226,
-0.15466247498989105,
0.4798330068588257,
0.17718397080898285,
-0.34623846411705017,
0.1554214507341385,
0.875091552734375,
-0.14921042323112488,
0.24335350096225739,
0.4182630777359009,
-0.6293917894363403,
-0.5169488787651062,
0.8562607169151306,
0.1623382866382599,
0.2328384667634964,
0.6543375849723816,
0.21931327879428864,
-0.07333727926015854,
-0.2743073105812073,
-0.12317480146884918,
-0.04030598700046539,
-0.9923259019851685,
-0.19878515601158142,
-0.8507312536239624,
-0.4826332628726959,
-0.36686497926712036,
-0.12837231159210205,
-0.15337003767490387,
-0.1383245289325714,
-0.42306387424468994,
-0.15764111280441284,
0.35183119773864746,
0.7276117205619812,
0.29841724038124084,
0.503240704536438,
-0.753547728061676,
-0.16209720075130463,
0.4005480706691742,
0.06138390675187111,
0.16614270210266113,
-0.7269773483276367,
-0.06769444793462753,
-0.09236284345388412,
-0.8437665104866028,
-1.080826997756958,
0.31707486510276794,
0.3318905532360077,
0.338701069355011,
0.869346559047699,
-0.17147192358970642,
0.7834080457687378,
-0.2417915165424347,
0.8965373039245605,
0.23173120617866516,
-1.0434283018112183,
1.0345994234085083,
-0.2595759630203247,
-0.09947331249713898,
0.652754545211792,
0.7187716960906982,
-0.378295361995697,
-0.6034623980522156,
-0.7711514830589294,
-0.7154611349105835,
0.6006478667259216,
0.4364624619483948,
0.09115968644618988,
-0.2046138495206833,
0.3193337023258209,
0.1196717694401741,
0.3393345773220062,
-0.7725830078125,
-0.3552638590335846,
-0.2336941957473755,
-0.0841885581612587,
0.10924024134874344,
-0.35654452443122864,
0.12030161172151566,
-0.3019150495529175,
0.8349414467811584,
0.04972922429442406,
0.46766263246536255,
-0.017322484403848648,
0.028204893693327904,
-0.44792667031288147,
0.5404976606369019,
0.08264174312353134,
0.5836684107780457,
-0.30595487356185913,
0.2222151905298233,
0.35188838839530945,
-0.6485693454742432,
0.031236305832862854,
-0.6093782782554626,
-0.2704807221889496,
0.15334215760231018,
0.4300113320350647,
0.47894087433815,
0.43167245388031006,
-0.24618706107139587,
0.7005077004432678,
-0.25457409024238586,
-0.25033870339393616,
-0.37530967593193054,
-0.01795276813209057,
-0.16578049957752228,
-0.12673670053482056,
0.22555197775363922,
0.33869263529777527,
0.4460834860801697,
-0.9437453746795654,
0.25663891434669495,
0.16804984211921692,
-0.5908058881759644,
-0.27545464038848877,
0.010748562403023243,
0.3033594489097595,
-0.31038686633110046,
0.5983469486236572,
-0.12481312453746796,
-0.8458003997802734,
0.3944634199142456,
0.5026335120201111,
0.9194223880767822,
-0.24566097557544708,
0.5140930414199829,
0.7160726189613342,
0.1503697633743286,
-0.08963356167078018,
0.3380158543586731,
-0.14857913553714752,
-0.6523292660713196,
-0.25768956542015076,
-0.9795218706130981,
-0.8023868203163147,
-0.07810180634260178,
-1.0143543481826782,
0.14065499603748322,
-0.6744712591171265,
-0.5196180939674377,
0.13806551694869995,
0.19612911343574524,
-0.08008946478366852,
0.3795011639595032,
-0.10646568983793259,
0.7249557971954346,
-1.1608023643493652,
0.3212001323699951,
1.015118956565857,
-0.23633798956871033,
-0.6060326099395752,
0.3609810173511505,
0.137832909822464,
0.06419002264738083,
0.7385850548744202,
0.23291577398777008,
-0.1053907722234726,
-0.0838840901851654,
-0.4667727053165436,
-0.5382782816886902,
0.7332011461257935,
-0.23176339268684387,
-0.20683610439300537,
0.23059585690498352,
0.02781408652663231,
0.8645917177200317,
-0.2779290974140167,
0.5508357286453247,
0.02955329790711403,
0.03297436609864235,
0.3706461787223816,
-0.7812196612358093,
-0.49006688594818115,
-0.5552284121513367,
-0.051819510757923126,
0.037220440804958344,
-0.6926484107971191,
1.0293081998825073,
0.40183886885643005,
-0.358585387468338,
-0.12137782573699951,
0.820308268070221,
0.21077337861061096,
0.37526318430900574,
0.4001231789588928,
0.6428145170211792,
0.7759788036346436,
-0.21042400598526,
0.4257560968399048,
-0.13720498979091644,
1.230404257774353,
0.5077354311943054,
-0.28333598375320435,
1.3773267269134521,
0.44782403111457825,
-0.842221200466156,
0.7606462836265564,
0.9285802841186523,
0.24076059460639954,
0.4987848699092865,
0.163039892911911,
-0.3703017234802246,
-0.13731731474399567,
0.14882688224315643,
-0.36796945333480835,
0.21016144752502441,
0.5506057739257812,
-0.14520269632339478,
-0.14103423058986664,
0.19839851558208466,
-0.14289714395999908,
0.009883326478302479,
-0.5699071884155273,
1.0003705024719238,
-0.005630045663565397,
-0.735482394695282,
0.11055728793144226,
0.20507560670375824,
0.8640452027320862,
-0.3674142360687256,
0.027136443182826042,
-0.06818173080682755,
0.3485250473022461,
-0.44597327709198,
-0.7159772515296936,
0.5866101980209351,
0.415377676486969,
-0.24809768795967102,
0.021764924749732018,
0.7737748622894287,
-0.08517733961343765,
-0.5461170077323914,
0.38150763511657715,
0.5988819599151611,
0.35016101598739624,
0.39110663533210754,
-0.7815943360328674,
-0.02725302428007126,
-0.07522648572921753,
-0.18791411817073822,
0.23806694149971008,
0.4791259765625,
0.19257725775241852,
0.4291566014289856,
0.37956854701042175,
-0.11654936522245407,
0.14861400425434113,
0.2059888243675232,
0.8981709480285645,
-0.5721867680549622,
-0.6959779262542725,
-1.0597537755966187,
0.2143191397190094,
-0.1999271959066391,
-0.19305795431137085,
1.1398674249649048,
0.6057770848274231,
0.7506391406059265,
-0.11186324805021286,
0.9604201316833496,
-0.15650369226932526,
0.9113966226577759,
-0.36274972558021545,
0.7500663995742798,
-0.32958275079727173,
0.13887867331504822,
-0.9126247763633728,
-0.9590295553207397,
-0.3320414125919342,
1.0588312149047852,
-0.3807907998561859,
0.284434974193573,
0.8254045844078064,
0.5606511235237122,
-0.052326496690511703,
0.7508209943771362,
0.17518065869808197,
0.1257500946521759,
-0.007154380436986685,
0.4716073274612427,
1.3473268747329712,
-0.438510537147522,
-0.08306773751974106,
-0.19762898981571198,
-0.6617810130119324,
-0.46587836742401123,
-0.4977528750896454,
-1.2667582035064697,
-0.3480193614959717,
-0.6609669327735901,
-0.2340087890625,
-0.15464095771312714,
1.0089768171310425,
0.4738236665725708,
-1.0312328338623047,
-0.41839441657066345,
-0.33724793791770935,
-0.06882229447364807,
0.0025234718341380358,
-0.3380940854549408,
0.3548213839530945,
-0.6055831909179688,
-0.40877047181129456,
-0.38736096024513245,
0.6579861044883728,
-0.20709283649921417,
-0.3909238278865814,
0.1443399041891098,
-0.2527599334716797,
0.09534905105829239,
0.9350704550743103,
-0.08156178146600723,
-0.6545294523239136,
-0.35065746307373047,
0.17196454107761383,
-0.1554286777973175,
0.10030978918075562,
0.6882783770561218,
-0.2667790353298187,
0.3981606066226959,
0.601528525352478,
0.5951393246650696,
0.19897112250328064,
0.05288419872522354,
-0.05824042856693268,
-0.42247074842453003,
-0.216988205909729,
0.0661366879940033,
0.11143528670072556,
0.0891772136092186,
-0.33762598037719727,
0.19429297745227814,
0.41371533274650574,
-0.7961027026176453,
-0.7116485834121704,
-0.033108994364738464,
-1.0492407083511353,
-0.31919705867767334,
1.0147868394851685,
-0.590298593044281,
-0.27117905020713806,
-0.23391804099082947,
-0.24299770593643188,
0.3883981704711914,
0.05942334234714508,
1.0162029266357422,
0.8599265217781067,
-0.10363353788852692,
-0.18608437478542328,
-0.4277632236480713,
0.374079167842865,
0.3657616972923279,
-1.4191105365753174,
-0.19865858554840088,
0.26586201786994934,
0.10793332010507584,
0.424227237701416,
0.7718265056610107,
-0.17236895859241486,
0.35703045129776,
-0.22125548124313354,
-0.37663495540618896,
0.703399658203125,
-0.34169432520866394,
-0.18426111340522766,
0.5985687375068665,
-0.06897114962339401,
-0.06397471576929092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14698v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.14698v2 | Under the Surface: Tracking the Artifactuality of LLM-Generated Data | 2024-01-26T07:53:27 | 2024-01-30T05:36:06 | Debarati Das, Karin De Langis, Anna Martin-Boyle, Jaehyung Kim, Minhwa Lee, Zae Myung Kim, Shirley Anugrah Hayati, Risako Owan, Bin Hu, Ritik Parkar, Ryan Koo, Jonginn Park, Aahan Tyagi, Libby Ferland, Sanjali Roy, Vincent Liu, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This work delves into the expanding role of large language models (LLMs) in
generating artificial data. LLMs are increasingly employed to create a variety
of outputs, including annotations, preferences, instruction prompts, simulated
dialogues, and free text. As these forms of LLM-generated data often intersect
in their application, they exert mutual influence on each other and raise
significant concerns about the quality and diversity of the artificial data
incorporated into training cycles, leading to an artificial data ecosystem. To
the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to aggregate various types
of LLM-generated text data, from more tightly constrained data like "task
labels" to more lightly constrained "free-form text". We then stress test the
quality and implications of LLM-generated artificial data, comparing it with
human data across various existing benchmarks. Despite artificial data's
capability to match human performance, this paper reveals significant hidden
disparities, especially in complex tasks where LLMs often miss the nuanced
understanding of intrinsic human-generated content. This study critically
examines diverse LLM-generated data and emphasizes the need for ethical
practices in data creation and when using LLMs. It highlights the LLMs'
shortcomings in replicating human traits and behaviors, underscoring the
importance of addressing biases and artifacts produced in LLM-generated content
for future research and development. All data and code are available on our
project page. | [
-0.288112998008728,
-0.8486058712005615,
0.7736135125160217,
-0.05006138235330582,
-0.06156238168478012,
0.3744141161441803,
-0.20887939631938934,
-0.7129770517349243,
0.11500653624534607,
0.8106804490089417,
-0.43647676706314087,
-0.6952372789382935,
-0.53877854347229,
0.060655828565359116,
-0.5909348726272583,
0.9964621663093567,
-0.11165051907300949,
-0.022257117554545403,
-0.6829814910888672,
-0.18065090477466583,
-0.1813204437494278,
-0.761690080165863,
-0.43617725372314453,
-0.5186940431594849,
0.3781116008758545,
0.2472650557756424,
0.6702134013175964,
0.958216667175293,
0.19390954077243805,
0.2924349904060364,
-0.057207997888326645,
0.6287358999252319,
-0.5686089396476746,
0.12150140106678009,
-0.06693140417337418,
-0.44906607270240784,
-0.5432072281837463,
0.23753610253334045,
0.7478277087211609,
0.7796831130981445,
0.1943591833114624,
0.3344177007675171,
0.33751142024993896,
0.3819981813430786,
-0.2559964060783386,
0.14011387526988983,
-0.5491629838943481,
-0.10840169340372086,
-0.5239441394805908,
-0.11531494557857513,
-0.18444329500198364,
-0.13330067694187164,
-0.3105984926223755,
-0.6767839789390564,
0.1781957596540451,
0.09722157567739487,
0.678075909614563,
0.3143765330314636,
-0.5386093854904175,
-0.5711512565612793,
-0.753553032875061,
0.8635862469673157,
-0.6550406813621521,
0.2531188726425171,
0.5481979846954346,
-0.2045324444770813,
-0.3746965229511261,
-0.6787785887718201,
-0.6191322207450867,
-0.43850836157798767,
-0.14944589138031006,
-0.08573605865240097,
-0.07051533460617065,
-0.03840707987546921,
0.18459200859069824,
0.45837560296058655,
-0.29522350430488586,
0.44635555148124695,
-0.27317091822624207,
-0.20183302462100983,
0.8062654733657837,
0.5129899978637695,
0.6216474771499634,
-0.15799114108085632,
-0.07634557783603668,
0.11246583610773087,
-1.105011224746704,
0.07554510235786438,
0.5904183387756348,
0.23395082354545593,
-0.06286336481571198,
0.8078323006629944,
-0.08256980031728745,
0.46746826171875,
-0.35229969024658203,
-0.06486376374959946,
0.22101013362407684,
-0.33716440200805664,
0.07510488480329514,
-0.05649861320853233,
0.7658464312553406,
0.3448808789253235,
0.3308067321777344,
-0.2788531184196472,
-0.35709667205810547,
0.067774698138237,
0.32680341601371765,
-0.5867408514022827,
0.025345202535390854,
0.17607150971889496,
-0.4239239990711212,
-0.38681966066360474,
0.11542176455259323,
-0.4090805947780609,
-0.6210014820098877,
-0.6865054965019226,
0.06283140927553177,
-0.2259267270565033,
-0.15797090530395508,
-0.22654558718204498,
0.2786685526371002,
-0.07879919558763504,
0.305257648229599,
-0.7285072207450867,
0.5702874064445496,
0.9237464666366577,
0.7549269795417786,
-0.4400985538959503,
-0.29812952876091003,
-0.41963642835617065,
0.21679873764514923,
-0.6183597445487976,
0.5761191248893738,
-0.36124107241630554,
-0.43343180418014526,
-0.011567872948944569,
-0.09837968647480011,
0.2848599851131439,
-0.6806247234344482,
0.4323084354400635,
-0.1621515154838562,
0.15068964660167694,
-0.44559282064437866,
-0.7117851376533508,
0.10919041186571121,
0.008146027103066444,
-0.7043381929397583,
1.3541169166564941,
0.0026336079463362694,
-0.7572599649429321,
0.5125449299812317,
-0.6169850826263428,
-0.28607484698295593,
0.22138850390911102,
-0.6459190249443054,
-0.3310070037841797,
0.1818455159664154,
-0.09143945574760437,
0.407466322183609,
-0.31088557839393616,
0.5380280613899231,
-0.1796700805425644,
-0.3616677224636078,
0.6101818084716797,
-0.41240376234054565,
0.6364562511444092,
0.1274169236421585,
-0.48207637667655945,
-0.012590649537742138,
-0.9553318023681641,
-0.3256453573703766,
0.12939032912254333,
-0.4841315448284149,
-0.45503318309783936,
0.383675217628479,
0.15960679948329926,
0.1971639096736908,
0.2798498272895813,
-0.6565320491790771,
0.18071728944778442,
-0.07418236881494522,
0.3626800775527954,
0.95548415184021,
-0.08562535047531128,
0.33616217970848083,
-0.5916666984558105,
0.350527286529541,
-0.12222937494516373,
-0.08217747509479523,
-0.050533685833215714,
-0.5101783871650696,
-0.6734331846237183,
-0.13764788210391998,
0.008146409876644611,
0.5023305416107178,
-0.5638304948806763,
0.15694108605384827,
-0.3628441095352173,
-0.48588231205940247,
-0.5977820754051208,
0.4432462155818939,
0.42847099900245667,
0.4482135474681854,
0.18401135504245758,
-0.103861004114151,
-0.504101037979126,
-0.9966757893562317,
-0.12855049967765808,
-0.15596038103103638,
-0.37699073553085327,
0.6369054913520813,
0.5616074204444885,
-0.3607242703437805,
1.0484659671783447,
-0.17408496141433716,
-0.13971300423145294,
-0.09749921411275864,
0.2503896951675415,
-0.11187776178121567,
0.6711294054985046,
0.6196542978286743,
-0.5025389790534973,
-0.09623830020427704,
-0.11698412150144577,
-0.9977373480796814,
-0.4362999498844147,
-0.2300753891468048,
-0.16653898358345032,
0.326229989528656,
0.5320302248001099,
-0.7788425087928772,
0.22189810872077942,
0.6531173586845398,
-0.49250328540802,
0.19656413793563843,
-0.17289374768733978,
0.20872898399829865,
-1.0471943616867065,
0.13640648126602173,
-0.09372443705797195,
-0.09356792271137238,
-0.5761692523956299,
-0.18397782742977142,
-0.31384560465812683,
0.08062680065631866,
-0.3223723769187927,
0.7355669140815735,
-0.5443868637084961,
-0.24757759273052216,
-0.1994481086730957,
0.04688382148742676,
-0.056688591837882996,
0.14180389046669006,
0.010654223151504993,
0.8846594095230103,
0.24903760850429535,
-0.39333614706993103,
0.10774388164281845,
0.30999475717544556,
-0.5167254209518433,
0.4313795268535614,
-0.5287078022956848,
0.3323178291320801,
-0.19901183247566223,
0.177636057138443,
-0.8900778889656067,
-0.39200958609580994,
0.2360362559556961,
-0.3133386969566345,
0.05631347745656967,
0.06922469288110733,
-0.9122171998023987,
0.023021215572953224,
-0.23799656331539154,
0.5045181512832642,
0.7094746232032776,
-0.25384747982025146,
0.6011038422584534,
0.64179527759552,
-0.16758151352405548,
-0.31909993290901184,
-0.9375426173210144,
0.35270237922668457,
-0.3596111536026001,
-0.6616025567054749,
0.3752162456512451,
-0.03626270964741707,
-0.6275354623794556,
-0.13033011555671692,
-0.035465389490127563,
0.08918347209692001,
0.24671441316604614,
0.6030277013778687,
0.09571659564971924,
-0.2026534080505371,
-0.07608340680599213,
0.03831174597144127,
0.25624534487724304,
0.3424232304096222,
-0.19541284441947937,
0.4287894070148468,
0.2954387962818146,
-0.4736671447753906,
-0.2370046079158783,
0.3687845766544342,
0.5983166098594666,
0.22519929707050323,
0.7269845008850098,
0.5070642232894897,
-0.4664454758167267,
-0.34701552987098694,
-0.4316330850124359,
-0.028306744992733,
-0.47554531693458557,
0.1419701874256134,
-0.12356812506914139,
-0.8085070252418518,
0.7729179263114929,
0.22980764508247375,
0.26993778347969055,
0.2952583134174347,
0.45098283886909485,
-0.22380244731903076,
0.9801750779151917,
0.5225284099578857,
-0.00365925463847816,
0.355038046836853,
-0.07520928233861923,
-0.20497189462184906,
-0.7862464189529419,
-0.45619747042655945,
-0.3433709442615509,
-0.2105889469385147,
-0.7278229594230652,
-0.440574586391449,
0.16414298117160797,
-0.03796655312180519,
-0.20343153178691864,
-0.17131222784519196,
-0.4350932240486145,
0.27398112416267395,
0.7527149319648743,
0.24494829773902893,
0.3878786563873291,
-0.0741526260972023,
0.25280895829200745,
-0.12562748789787292,
-0.4639086127281189,
-1.0450031757354736,
1.3105970621109009,
0.44087010622024536,
0.6405307054519653,
-0.18312907218933105,
0.6935938596725464,
0.6582825183868408,
0.4119558036327362,
-0.29283690452575684,
0.6060763001441956,
-0.22454851865768433,
-0.48582205176353455,
-0.22551561892032623,
-0.39304083585739136,
-1.1594194173812866,
0.06912039965391159,
-0.2846450209617615,
-0.6320050954818726,
-0.1443433314561844,
0.2784317433834076,
-0.01997535303235054,
0.3390531539916992,
-0.22335602343082428,
0.612982451915741,
-0.47085878252983093,
-0.5153720378875732,
-0.010235284455120564,
-0.3710871636867523,
0.3897964358329773,
-0.23879769444465637,
0.561366856098175,
-0.2556999623775482,
-0.25849658250808716,
0.8708759546279907,
-0.3251344859600067,
1.2578184604644775,
-0.0941159576177597,
-0.4478679597377777,
0.41985559463500977,
0.30668485164642334,
0.45906761288642883,
0.1558876782655716,
0.1852273792028427,
0.42891842126846313,
-0.4703877568244934,
-0.43378058075904846,
-0.15962763130664825,
0.6840720176696777,
-0.8367517590522766,
-0.5519493222236633,
-0.18424463272094727,
-0.7563197612762451,
-0.08208148181438446,
0.1927252858877182,
0.15428200364112854,
0.4724777042865753,
-0.24728363752365112,
0.09345109015703201,
0.7126291394233704,
-0.46970635652542114,
0.12240191549062729,
0.3093857169151306,
-0.14382067322731018,
-0.2432458996772766,
1.1466820240020752,
0.2744954228401184,
0.17475353181362152,
0.08109939843416214,
-0.0014534685760736465,
-0.08302230387926102,
-0.8780313730239868,
-0.4555290937423706,
0.1564004272222519,
-0.5778390169143677,
-0.03751532360911369,
-0.563610851764679,
-0.22552625834941864,
-0.12224197387695312,
-0.17635266482830048,
-0.337419718503952,
-0.25149986147880554,
-0.5992938876152039,
-0.20931243896484375,
0.3584408164024353,
1.1396105289459229,
0.017794571816921234,
0.24481961131095886,
-0.6956140995025635,
0.35680872201919556,
-0.004093547817319632,
0.15496303141117096,
-0.1575407087802887,
-0.3118049204349518,
-0.14734140038490295,
0.38181889057159424,
-0.16011521220207214,
-0.4388931095600128,
0.24589669704437256,
0.023499460890889168,
0.737902045249939,
0.08225373178720474,
-0.22012434899806976,
0.2245262712240219,
-0.4335089325904846,
1.1372969150543213,
-0.27249372005462646,
-0.9829760193824768,
0.28864040970802307,
-0.6852434873580933,
0.08886764943599701,
0.31484362483024597,
0.23347768187522888,
-0.41316479444503784,
-0.8420567512512207,
-0.634731650352478,
-0.9600458741188049,
0.6617699861526489,
0.4537261426448822,
0.45753368735313416,
0.045141104608774185,
0.34970560669898987,
0.3699790835380554,
0.35861751437187195,
-0.7757872343063354,
-0.17136555910110474,
-0.13648881018161774,
-0.4155727028846741,
-0.005258625373244286,
-0.2308645397424698,
-0.13287316262722015,
0.04155115410685539,
0.2652765214443207,
-0.11904153227806091,
-0.06646127998828888,
0.017560936510562897,
-0.2689744830131531,
-0.02836715057492256,
-0.10689608007669449,
0.7537165284156799,
0.7205305099487305,
0.06582947820425034,
0.17486333847045898,
0.16785772144794464,
-0.5222195386886597,
-0.006111591123044491,
-0.1602281928062439,
-0.34979912638664246,
-0.09336594492197037,
0.7410908937454224,
0.6740064024925232,
0.045174628496170044,
-0.9075848460197449,
0.2336803525686264,
0.2574402987957001,
-0.2698286771774292,
-0.5187311768531799,
0.1244930773973465,
0.13794316351413727,
0.21169057488441467,
0.4579288959503174,
-0.2233329862356186,
0.07313769310712814,
-0.5569259524345398,
0.2515070140361786,
0.4802582561969757,
0.049126267433166504,
-0.531634509563446,
0.8718358874320984,
0.25367316603660583,
-0.23741444945335388,
0.8267892003059387,
0.10297244042158127,
-0.1938251256942749,
0.5640224814414978,
0.2103930413722992,
0.48364385962486267,
-0.01755245216190815,
0.13238097727298737,
-0.05816369131207466,
0.3229680061340332,
0.040768977254629135,
0.2609041631221771,
-0.008506660349667072,
-0.7166120409965515,
-0.46039706468582153,
-0.5332770943641663,
-0.3270145356655121,
0.39362403750419617,
-0.37686851620674133,
0.08359704166650772,
-0.30042001605033875,
-0.08432585746049881,
-0.15876856446266174,
-0.14019083976745605,
-0.5876041650772095,
0.17879050970077515,
0.5129610300064087,
0.6809630990028381,
-1.0602103471755981,
0.62507164478302,
0.5546264052391052,
-0.5489362478256226,
-0.37785255908966064,
-0.15393850207328796,
0.07696127891540527,
-1.0236010551452637,
0.7631590366363525,
-0.02222878858447075,
0.0065686325542628765,
-0.19170808792114258,
-0.6481350064277649,
-0.8474997878074646,
1.092852234840393,
0.4521894156932831,
-0.23998406529426575,
-0.15362675487995148,
0.8458279967308044,
0.6857185959815979,
-0.4136749505996704,
-0.0015813530189916492,
0.5568882822990417,
0.41956159472465515,
-0.30572885274887085,
-0.8165931105613708,
0.22602474689483643,
-0.19859255850315094,
0.017217103391885757,
0.09488805383443832,
-0.6339675188064575,
1.0098862648010254,
0.13034290075302124,
-0.27599290013313293,
0.0810905173420906,
0.4719598889350891,
0.37580573558807373,
0.40904566645622253,
0.2384517788887024,
0.34215036034584045,
0.6594582796096802,
-0.039945099502801895,
1.0201990604400635,
-0.2264876663684845,
0.02765633910894394,
0.8798213005065918,
-0.2104816883802414,
0.4093220829963684,
0.5852856040000916,
-0.03620940446853638,
0.3976784646511078,
0.7684638500213623,
-0.14789044857025146,
0.12452365458011627,
0.5267252922058105,
-0.13035359978675842,
-0.09814448654651642,
-0.38800957798957825,
0.003673024009913206,
0.42610102891921997,
0.37270259857177734,
-0.43028590083122253,
-0.034852709621191025,
-0.08435305953025818,
0.14398978650569916,
0.27598264813423157,
-0.20527300238609314,
0.8828184604644775,
0.08535531908273697,
-0.5638734102249146,
0.3912188410758972,
-0.1959090232849121,
0.6786845922470093,
-0.2652595341205597,
-0.21412654221057892,
-0.5172091126441956,
-0.19582803547382355,
-0.32175469398498535,
-0.9732541441917419,
0.20238468050956726,
0.10171482712030411,
-0.17242443561553955,
-0.5509117245674133,
0.43865546584129333,
-0.4957418441772461,
-0.48971959948539734,
0.08422163873910904,
0.7415110468864441,
0.3893810212612152,
0.06183391436934471,
-0.38318997621536255,
0.37816286087036133,
-0.013722334988415241,
-0.5301643013954163,
0.44341135025024414,
0.5211573243141174,
-0.43171319365501404,
0.6617657542228699,
0.707973062992096,
0.31687721610069275,
0.1842936873435974,
-0.08479728549718857,
0.742361307144165,
-0.5551685690879822,
-0.08358943462371826,
-0.9641216397285461,
0.7265313267707825,
-0.1594817042350769,
-0.40257593989372253,
0.6195788979530334,
0.7239317893981934,
0.9299463033676147,
0.14049121737480164,
0.9151822328567505,
0.11430162191390991,
0.512739896774292,
-0.7760841250419617,
0.7598469853401184,
-0.5256165862083435,
0.3312655985355377,
-0.1978456974029541,
-0.8990771770477295,
-0.014966478571295738,
0.242959126830101,
0.11112996190786362,
0.0036712803412228823,
0.23981302976608276,
0.5161087512969971,
-0.24257151782512665,
-0.4059014916419983,
0.12594404816627502,
0.026608426123857498,
0.46625375747680664,
0.2943752408027649,
1.1312159299850464,
-0.10322209447622299,
0.32397472858428955,
-0.07410453259944916,
-0.07672981917858124,
0.09245257079601288,
-0.8416910767555237,
-0.9253407120704651,
-0.7929278016090393,
-0.13516569137573242,
-0.2440725564956665,
-0.1564704030752182,
0.8882757425308228,
0.5317628383636475,
-0.6263551712036133,
-0.43414372205734253,
-0.3084785044193268,
-0.07994463294744492,
0.2750399708747864,
-0.24384760856628418,
0.337507963180542,
-0.22991497814655304,
-0.8910902142524719,
0.3153285086154938,
-0.13969630002975464,
0.3682521879673004,
-0.4091585576534271,
-0.2010335624217987,
0.30587705969810486,
0.22877271473407745,
0.5846301317214966,
0.06361108273267746,
-0.8737707734107971,
-0.2876379191875458,
-0.012889305129647255,
-0.30414214730262756,
-0.09580235928297043,
0.9499452114105225,
-0.674552321434021,
-0.028488751500844955,
0.27485471963882446,
0.7808077931404114,
0.2890012562274933,
0.14193718135356903,
0.7550108432769775,
-0.8422034382820129,
-0.003428112482652068,
0.29170340299606323,
0.323544979095459,
0.4788486361503601,
-0.5127077102661133,
0.42435935139656067,
0.24732933938503265,
-0.6108105778694153,
-1.209989309310913,
0.07112277299165726,
-0.6949505805969238,
-0.47493183612823486,
1.3024325370788574,
0.0753353014588356,
-0.025503704324364662,
-0.07815747708082199,
-0.23538877069950104,
0.23826247453689575,
-0.3570050597190857,
0.9888700246810913,
0.8061622381210327,
-0.5039326548576355,
0.12137465178966522,
-0.8567286729812622,
0.7858237028121948,
0.14633962512016296,
-1.0793448686599731,
0.356536865234375,
0.9325900673866272,
0.4042677879333496,
0.0663088709115982,
0.7095280289649963,
0.03911025449633598,
-0.11827261745929718,
0.11292323470115662,
0.08749343454837799,
-0.29289114475250244,
-0.20082560181617737,
0.028665678575634956,
-0.000037301670090528205,
0.20479682087898254,
-0.03839492425322533
] |
Subsets and Splits