id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11025v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11025v1 | Temporal Data Meets LLM -- Explainable Financial Time Series Forecasting | 2023-06-19T15:42:02 | 2023-06-19T15:42:02 | Xinli Yu, Zheng Chen, Yuan Ling, Shujing Dong, Zongyi Liu, Yanbin Lu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-fin.ST, F.2.2; I.2.7; I.2.1 | This paper presents a novel study on harnessing Large Language Models' (LLMs)
outstanding knowledge and reasoning abilities for explainable financial time
series forecasting. The application of machine learning models to financial
time series comes with several challenges, including the difficulty in
cross-sequence reasoning and inference, the hurdle of incorporating multi-modal
signals from historical news, financial knowledge graphs, etc., and the issue
of interpreting and explaining the model results. In this paper, we focus on
NASDAQ-100 stocks, making use of publicly accessible historical stock price
data, company metadata, and historical economic/financial news. We conduct
experiments to illustrate the potential of LLMs in offering a unified solution
to the aforementioned challenges. Our experiments include trying
zero-shot/few-shot inference with GPT-4 and instruction-based fine-tuning with
a public LLM model Open LLaMA. We demonstrate our approach outperforms a few
baselines, including the widely applied classic ARMA-GARCH model and a
gradient-boosting tree model. Through the performance comparison results and a
few examples, we find LLMs can make a well-thought decision by reasoning over
information from both textual news and price time series and extracting
insights, leveraging cross-sequence information, and utilizing the inherent
knowledge embedded within the LLM. Additionally, we show that a publicly
available LLM such as Open-LLaMA, after fine-tuning, can comprehend the
instruction to generate explainable forecasts and achieve reasonable
performance, albeit relatively inferior in comparison to GPT-4. | [
-0.0320552886,
0.0798094943,
-0.0131887523,
0.0021274753,
-0.0041278731,
0.012841708,
0.0134901609,
0.0049335742,
0.0014166711,
-0.0001337954,
0.0095714964,
-0.0008124036,
-0.0268889908,
0.0276706442,
0.0169108007,
-0.0232635234,
0.0177655146,
-0.0469084606,
0.0303982198,
-0.0190785863,
0.0091014607,
0.002601451,
0.0572410412,
0.0269700307,
0.0181816332,
-0.0216231011,
-0.0495014787,
-0.0030982452,
-0.009177655,
-0.0191741697,
-0.0456923135,
-0.0453739725,
0.0368828475,
0.0425301641,
0.0000021295,
-0.0252757277,
-0.0254220478,
0.0035612674,
-0.0387409441,
0.0032627417,
-0.0006017969,
-0.0312069748,
0.0603276603,
0.0072384449,
-0.0448079444,
0.0250267386,
0.0575755835,
0.0516884401,
0.057074111,
0.0896338373,
-0.0043044202,
-0.0656885952,
0.0202083718,
-0.0616260432,
0.0267800372,
-0.1019410416,
0.0017816332,
0.0012583137,
0.0182688627,
0.0255556926,
-0.0201213248,
0.0227245893,
0.0090114949,
0.0043129604,
-0.001334128,
0.0148353698,
0.0328757688,
0.0323876925,
-0.0178340357,
0.0279775355,
0.0347759165,
-0.0135478638,
0.0341307297,
-0.0086787827,
-0.0191830955,
0.0416579954,
-0.0565660186,
0.0097004231,
0.011430135,
0.0549605936,
0.0493394025,
-0.0136767067,
0.0359733589,
0.0173499379,
-0.0367970578,
0.0939880461,
-0.0520930402,
0.0046788384,
-0.0148098748,
0.0082724988,
0.0095512085,
-0.0502812415,
-0.0421444699,
0.038334012,
-0.0042372937,
0.0111792469,
0.0162789486,
0.011784913,
-0.0433519222,
-0.0320619904,
0.0159571897,
0.0585102588,
-0.0037902985,
0.0483686589,
-0.0506832749,
0.0169587154,
0.0043946505,
-0.047721304,
0.0132529214,
-0.0224732067,
-0.0928129405,
0.0029674738,
0.0179454125,
0.0436008126,
-0.0156744216,
0.0112177338,
-0.0624035783,
-0.0001777205,
-0.0077841342,
0.0372751243,
0.0193456486,
-0.0196212344,
-0.0352039114,
-0.0393558666,
-0.0468065329,
-0.0413284823,
-0.0124216648,
0.0292094983,
-0.0283001009,
-0.0298635978,
0.0078341216,
-0.0037408704,
-0.0327519849,
0.0219845306,
0.0164284408,
0.1062171012,
0.0427741446,
0.002007962,
-0.0838640258,
-0.0826539919,
0.0113464259,
-0.0428544767,
-0.0353691094,
0.0107084606,
-0.0264580194,
-0.0097223334,
0.0087891351,
0.0216784235,
0.0124786505,
-0.0326985866,
-0.0350757912,
0.0880570412,
0.0143136438,
-0.0080057932,
-0.0005467469,
-0.030660402,
0.0192942172,
0.060752403,
0.0064459229,
0.0295046065,
0.0506417155,
-0.0188893788,
-0.0135558937,
-0.0075996774,
0.024921624,
-0.0653186291,
-0.0259849094,
0.0334193744,
-0.0540220849,
-0.0064809509,
0.041247163,
-0.0187533889,
0.0107489871,
0.0085560931,
0.0503147319,
0.0179479234,
0.0361774638,
0.0308738425,
0.0259939227,
-0.0185695924,
0.0006351058,
-0.0303194001,
-0.0128329229,
0.031372115,
-0.0447571613,
0.0492447913,
-0.0253594983,
0.0299496893,
-0.0360005572,
-0.0601966679,
0.0048161154,
-0.0288172178,
-0.061669074,
0.0052832747,
0.054749947,
-0.0846818611,
-0.0524012819,
0.0599967986,
0.0390715413,
0.013231528,
-0.0162761472,
-0.0396584123,
0.0643305555,
0.0775319412,
0.0025577233,
-0.0199496839,
0.0096046701,
-0.0248716343,
-0.0105632106,
0.0062774331,
-0.0258378722,
0.0158697031,
-0.0370377302,
-0.0650364086,
-0.0460363626,
0.0097595081,
0.030664213,
0.041048523,
-0.0550242402,
0.0078492416,
0.0116948355,
-0.0287044961,
0.0039989073,
0.0042634485,
-0.0229933634,
-0.0648360252,
0.0160953905,
-0.0254366379,
0.0222684368,
0.0400405414,
0.0009849162,
-0.0032774217,
-0.0178174842,
-0.0019753966,
-0.0310303103,
0.0291005671,
-0.0551033169,
-0.004441916,
-0.0335405469,
-0.0109333834,
0.0044128671,
-0.0084755048,
-0.0551143698,
-0.0574205928,
0.0314094611,
-0.0227614772,
0.0469519719,
-0.0625160486,
-0.0581469089,
0.0135116596,
0.0209637042,
0.014601714,
0.0440349579,
-0.0014055438,
-0.0141450316,
-0.004670457,
0.0019054854,
0.0011382407,
-0.0063625094,
0.0321195349,
0.0306299292,
0.0049562124,
0.0014767187,
0.0054381052,
-0.0286474992,
0.015274385,
-0.0010505582,
-0.049834881,
-0.0258522928,
-0.0239104126,
0.0494776033,
0.0067553315,
-0.0207703076,
0.0031997808,
-0.0186672788,
-0.0096905604,
0.0278604645,
-0.0022468723,
-0.0149945691,
0.0628521815,
-0.0112158759,
-0.0361626223,
-0.012187941,
-0.0048817033,
-0.0343661793,
0.0709938481,
0.0346701369,
-0.0072728526,
0.0062509859,
-0.0331636406,
-0.0212615058,
-0.0231088419,
-0.0213506259,
0.0205045585,
-0.0160381868,
-0.0038564047,
-0.0099373963,
0.0678525418,
-0.0088476399,
0.0296890065,
-0.0355197117,
-0.0192680154,
-0.0172311198,
0.0106298076,
-0.0092205126,
0.0104768882,
-0.0397922546,
-0.0115465829,
-0.0009593648,
0.0668393373,
-0.0180557333,
-0.0008953143,
-0.0719569996,
0.0510648526,
0.0006281378,
0.0278852545,
-0.0489756353,
-0.0103675947,
-0.0009624857,
0.0618812852,
0.0053016283,
-0.0843619332,
0.043322932,
-0.0346302055,
-0.0184845254,
0.0515982434,
-0.0368223116,
-0.10054598,
0.0408875048,
-0.0310037769,
0.0023940962,
0.0077002393,
-0.0252797343,
0.0150796017,
-0.0321526937,
0.0273327343,
-0.0176779088,
0.0510377064,
-0.0342425443,
0.006879257,
0.0377259739,
0.0268329345,
0.0165662821,
-0.0271908697,
-0.0564105585,
0.0279397462,
0.0184585489,
-0.0370933115,
-0.0218721852,
0.0502287559,
-0.0091831442,
-0.0358869582,
-0.0038372723,
-0.0363145396,
0.0266127177,
0.0108160963,
0.0432727858,
-0.0165619757,
0.0221591797,
-0.0475667901,
0.0714401156,
-0.0314161554,
0.0776530132,
0.0022692094,
-0.0401400626,
0.0123433163,
-0.0241913665,
-0.0223667957,
-0.0242960211,
0.0423763469,
-0.0029149023,
-0.0455358773,
0.0271659195,
0.0912772939,
-0.008935106,
0.0058145286,
0.0173563771,
0.0502036549,
-0.0276046973,
-0.0356815644,
0.0284210425,
-0.0721776336,
-0.0272626113,
0.0144233992,
0.0392430723,
0.0071677812,
-0.0535848625,
-0.0208497234,
-0.1158562452,
0.0674952716,
-0.0061860089,
-0.0136334905,
-0.0140368231,
-0.0780744031,
-0.0061809695,
-0.0705065131,
0.005696815,
-0.0103307394,
-0.0135096125,
0.0570528433,
0.0437350422,
-0.0820370391,
-0.0570997223,
0.011587807,
0.0316474997,
0.000602032,
0.0235206466,
0.021607969,
-0.0012230072,
-0.0052070692,
-0.0584354401,
-0.0213174112,
0.0592224747,
-0.0105145536,
0.0446008407,
-0.0035009636,
-0.0353292041,
-0.0045123328,
0.0836324915,
-0.0011164061,
0.0567983799,
-0.0041570743,
0.0430231765,
-0.029877495,
-0.0354075804,
0.0342792384,
-0.001364502,
-0.0030375952,
0.0557463206,
0.0134105319,
0.0124645103,
-0.0580628403,
-0.0449722037,
-0.0270785261,
-0.0488801636,
-0.0040759267,
-0.0009655128,
-0.0143569373,
-0.0297215618,
-0.0433649197,
-0.0434994325,
-0.0228932016,
0.0570838749,
0.0068802363,
0.0468071252,
0.0160501022,
0.0225440934,
-0.022725556,
0.0055933199,
0.0123552391,
0.0252891816,
-0.0248902813,
0.037425302,
0.038782239,
-0.0379041396,
-0.0296109822,
0.027423162,
-0.062016435,
-0.0541563071,
0.018100502,
0.0028359573,
0.0312852003,
0.0126750125,
0.0156359728,
0.0152838817,
0.0706805289,
0.0807471946,
-0.0232656449,
-0.0283906721,
0.0495296568,
0.038494464,
0.019302208,
0.0431301929,
-0.0170051996,
0.0360698216,
-0.0380459055,
-0.0412768088,
-0.0359465256,
0.0104278997,
-0.0342223868,
0.0074968031,
0.0111044189,
0.0204408094,
-0.0396003239,
0.005804142,
-0.0077545117,
0.0188249778,
0.0169301499,
-0.0285838414,
-0.025463786,
0.0288177337,
-0.0330839753,
-0.0278785937,
-0.0024750193,
0.0202748384,
-0.0555551127,
-0.0533317886,
0.0586770847,
-0.0296805594,
0.0366356857,
-0.0098038679,
0.0039021138,
0.0186764132,
-0.0312596709,
0.0255246628,
-0.0055518104,
0.0188738126,
0.048814185,
-0.0086595705,
0.047594592,
-0.0046608523,
-0.0524561293,
-0.080888316,
-0.0658737049,
0.0161279757,
0.0337685496,
0.0185115542,
-0.0391865671,
0.0337658562,
-0.0266703777,
0.0437440723,
0.0505412295,
0.0748275742,
0.0256671477,
-0.0123535618,
0.0154178869,
-0.007779567,
-0.0904165283,
-0.0216506645,
0.0750768483,
0.0299341138,
0.0282377731,
-0.006370754,
-0.0357804485,
-0.0212287437,
-0.03627038,
0.0663025156,
-0.0112915272,
0.0048021744,
-0.0065228515,
-0.060135778,
-0.0378872752,
0.0003541126,
-0.0249950532,
-0.009524703,
-0.0228966251,
-0.0032082843,
0.0558345765,
0.0215673335,
0.0346078239,
-0.0126637341,
-0.0000203145,
-0.0323841497,
0.0024243866,
-0.0368343256,
-5.933374592e-33,
-0.0099273119,
-0.0231773891,
0.0075935023,
-0.0231008511,
0.0101640951,
0.0384300649,
-0.0603244305,
-0.0538690984,
0.0137707377,
0.0132232439,
0.0156171117,
0.034250617,
0.0104938764,
0.0103270495,
0.0479537323,
-0.0215117,
0.043400418,
-0.0103656212,
0.011261316,
0.0102084773,
0.0642499179,
0.0684378892,
0.0544755161,
0.0017559533,
0.0372552313,
0.0006451948,
-0.0553454049,
-0.0397782251,
0.037634518,
0.0442464203,
0.0098781502,
0.0343587361,
0.0158468373,
-0.1005385444,
-0.0271108728,
-0.0184084568,
0.000146371,
-0.0489936471,
0.0353872962,
-0.0130457142,
0.0220305566,
-0.0008190641,
0.0155715467,
0.0146250445,
0.0187641867,
0.012970008,
0.0241656117,
-0.0024417383,
0.0248756818,
-0.0494651422,
-0.0140087167,
0.0457656831,
-0.0266497638,
0.0301641487,
0.0411862954,
0.0659625307,
0.0103101227,
0.0686001703,
-0.0082254997,
0.0357104726,
0.0389603116,
0.0102184108,
0.0429314561,
0.0072025247,
0.0131486859,
0.0281199217,
-0.0078934468,
-0.0034994923,
-0.0279912148,
0.0622216389,
-0.0120987035,
0.089210555,
0.0214131176,
0.0097126486,
0.0536690913,
-0.0161375701,
-0.0611516647,
0.0060566333,
0.0274612531,
0.0332938619,
0.034155149,
0.0155682387,
-0.036078617,
-0.0305542611,
0.0225761961,
-0.0129943555,
-0.0015768997,
-0.0108251683,
0.0056516435,
-0.0117356144,
-0.0150908912,
0.0347575918,
0.0091029508,
-0.0386110991,
-0.0493271314,
0.0133142089,
-0.0011110894,
-0.0048305439,
0.0144372564,
-0.0118453242,
-0.0533276759,
-0.0465452187,
-0.0185846966,
-0.0080780275,
0.0023707736,
-0.0595997386,
0.007341743,
0.0538664423,
-0.028526159,
-0.0234644301,
-0.0342083238,
0.0082932254,
-0.0052721873,
-0.0487897396,
0.05125352,
-0.0042388421,
-0.016201077,
0.0211115777,
0.0045534912,
0.0249374714,
0.0428898633,
-0.0372786932,
-0.0257457811,
0.0057738959,
0.0263456628,
-0.0240366068,
0.0277506672,
0.0017076264,
0.0097733866,
-0.0448119529,
-0.0226421282,
0.0610134415,
2.848e-7,
0.0379144847,
0.0502071716,
-0.0069769104,
0.0505710505,
0.0288810767,
0.0363866575,
-0.0434482992,
-0.0125999227,
-0.0431614816,
-0.0089587206,
0.0634167343,
0.0143326763,
0.0705729946,
0.034020517,
-0.0341789052,
-0.052834481,
-0.0575444065,
0.0208806098,
-0.1092395112,
0.0211127419,
0.0373784825,
0.0640350506,
0.0039720414,
-0.0157225113,
0.0475217439,
-0.0404010043,
0.0296536423,
-0.045906011,
-0.0228783097,
0.0111402543,
0.0488985926,
0.0150826965,
-0.0273783561,
0.0053937109,
-0.0060116514,
0.0084161358,
-0.0329188518,
0.0147295538,
0.0138213299,
0.0334935673,
0.0120143965,
-0.0075901691,
-0.0240078103,
-0.0616210364,
0.0757053345,
-0.0246399287,
-0.0629680529,
-0.0448550433,
-0.0474039502,
0.0159428399,
-0.0039915843,
0.0187569559,
0.0261110701,
0.0430449769,
-0.0414960124,
-0.0552201942,
0.0261593368,
-0.0592643842,
-0.0516937301,
0.0250018202,
-0.0429621823,
0.0303029194,
-0.0668358132,
0.0011824236,
0.0535160452,
-0.0515079461,
0.0135312723,
2.355015229e-34,
0.0786591098,
-0.0164406709,
-0.0524179637,
0.0584367588,
0.0544783287,
0.0231361464,
-0.0275089592,
0.0416584797,
0.0295142829,
-0.0724998415,
-0.0254291613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11020v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11020v1 | Dual-Gated Fusion with Prefix-Tuning for Multi-Modal Relation Extraction | 2023-06-19T15:31:34 | 2023-06-19T15:31:34 | Qian Li, Shu Guo, Cheng Ji, Xutan Peng, Shiyao Cui, Jianxin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-Modal Relation Extraction (MMRE) aims at identifying the relation
between two entities in texts that contain visual clues. Rich visual content is
valuable for the MMRE task, but existing works cannot well model finer
associations among different modalities, failing to capture the truly helpful
visual information and thus limiting relation extraction performance. In this
paper, we propose a novel MMRE framework to better capture the deeper
correlations of text, entity pair, and image/objects, so as to mine more
helpful information for the task, termed as DGF-PT. We first propose a
prompt-based autoregressive encoder, which builds the associations of
intra-modal and inter-modal features related to the task, respectively by
entity-oriented and object-oriented prefixes. To better integrate helpful
visual information, we design a dual-gated fusion module to distinguish the
importance of image/objects and further enrich text representations. In
addition, a generative decoder is introduced with entity type restriction on
relations, better filtering out candidates. Extensive experiments conducted on
the benchmark dataset show that our approach achieves excellent performance
compared to strong competitors, even in the few-shot situation. | [
0.0128432661,
0.071972549,
0.0087732701,
0.0772682801,
-0.0135424407,
0.0312847868,
-0.0088287313,
0.0119236372,
0.0038558007,
-0.0487959757,
-0.0071979198,
0.0002002522,
0.0090744216,
0.0725985393,
0.0105490396,
-0.0692422614,
0.0305437073,
0.0164027084,
-0.0138877332,
0.0352800973,
0.0254096314,
0.0406492762,
-0.0073444722,
0.0365290605,
-0.0641394258,
-0.0028377685,
0.0055094096,
0.0043408391,
0.0512852892,
-0.0411912985,
-0.0424549952,
0.0228043105,
0.0439046323,
-0.0438975953,
0.0000019796,
-0.0368911251,
-0.0321432427,
0.0080127912,
0.0070611127,
-0.0628510863,
0.0064600827,
-0.0622209534,
0.0149617614,
-0.0141277658,
-0.0119670229,
-0.0483829156,
0.0564784333,
0.0962232798,
0.0342318192,
0.0593229644,
-0.0524438918,
-0.0454550125,
0.0737957954,
-0.0226852167,
0.0102556869,
-0.023504898,
0.0132676093,
-0.0021117786,
-0.0113862446,
0.0083578331,
-0.0472092405,
0.0310196467,
0.0164956059,
-0.0011808818,
0.042742528,
0.0559151508,
0.0391465575,
-0.0124171451,
-0.0237649474,
0.0953275859,
-0.0120828021,
0.0380633958,
0.0084134042,
0.0021980221,
-0.0361667387,
0.0380127579,
-0.0013624323,
-0.0102327447,
-0.048929926,
0.028179016,
-0.0068876916,
0.0067379884,
-0.0123377368,
-0.0147827854,
-0.0076690703,
-0.0254595205,
0.0176369548,
0.0024106179,
-0.0150680346,
0.0615711063,
-0.0272461697,
-0.047036618,
0.0064820014,
0.0120319817,
0.0214957949,
0.0013847104,
-0.0497994684,
-0.0354515985,
-0.0291959699,
-0.0208624322,
-0.0360922888,
-0.0011126909,
-0.0556161255,
0.0754397959,
-0.0434526466,
0.0091833118,
-0.0153220473,
0.0135847777,
-0.0057523288,
-0.0309037752,
-0.047194168,
0.0090548294,
-0.0164087247,
0.010592198,
-0.0331370011,
-0.0518058799,
-0.0055109896,
0.0010331168,
0.0008095023,
0.003638722,
0.015982965,
0.0182853192,
-0.0244262405,
-0.0171566848,
-0.0261325426,
0.0261310879,
-0.0499858856,
0.0205865316,
-0.0213744286,
-0.0354243591,
-0.0088632079,
0.0038423627,
0.0591191091,
-0.0541902818,
-0.0243763812,
0.0890804529,
-0.0781395957,
-0.0638700202,
-0.0353146307,
-0.0537449345,
0.0052328729,
-0.0153378621,
0.0157102291,
-0.0023667037,
0.0686944127,
0.0247308724,
0.0036340491,
-0.0267136414,
0.0117951892,
-0.0274864193,
-0.0336478725,
0.0722781047,
-0.0100267399,
-0.0376172066,
0.0006053309,
0.0256132819,
0.0228844285,
0.0758086294,
0.029319752,
0.0347663611,
0.0315032601,
0.0299527794,
-0.0100440951,
0.0163547266,
-0.0043094484,
-0.0322947539,
-0.0114625292,
-0.0054473351,
0.0249047298,
-0.0257899519,
0.0534989797,
0.0297577586,
-0.0419157818,
-0.0029068585,
0.0155052505,
0.0165637769,
0.0179914404,
0.0355390646,
0.0374706127,
-0.0144898035,
-0.0073235473,
0.0122515783,
-0.0233988613,
0.0575019456,
-0.0249890331,
-0.0108189778,
-0.032569889,
0.0967493728,
-0.0124554979,
0.0099682231,
0.0543516092,
-0.0186503716,
-0.0027159506,
-0.0052008419,
0.0760383904,
0.0027870364,
-0.0682594776,
0.0186527651,
0.0191175099,
-0.0115766199,
0.0031848249,
-0.0010139176,
-0.0019823157,
0.0189530179,
0.0559363589,
-0.0132144829,
-0.0072415732,
-0.0233053565,
-0.0439291187,
0.0063141105,
-0.0162874945,
-0.0143949464,
0.0462093502,
-0.0463721566,
-0.0825522244,
-0.0050084107,
-0.0096209254,
0.0236277971,
-0.0140293892,
0.0417438298,
0.0178419594,
0.0529411994,
0.0610851645,
0.047778558,
0.0313715525,
-0.0101418011,
0.0004454317,
0.0484802611,
-0.0091479477,
0.0163292717,
-0.0281985477,
-0.0205843709,
0.0111233862,
-0.0477126315,
0.0119570065,
0.0207247343,
-0.0581369475,
-0.0579682998,
-0.0109174885,
-0.0412789434,
-0.036397215,
-0.0374478847,
-0.0300199799,
-0.0427416377,
-0.0113931457,
-0.0106526883,
0.0532154404,
-0.0200000294,
-0.0101214573,
0.0441537648,
0.0419703461,
-0.0063528353,
0.079120785,
-0.001473335,
-0.0444086529,
0.0096825426,
-0.0336765088,
0.0072670639,
0.0143988123,
-0.0051549939,
0.0124385748,
0.0124331294,
-0.0200099722,
0.0261766519,
-0.0028120335,
-0.0445347056,
-0.0521765575,
-0.085180901,
-0.0176897086,
-0.0024556401,
-0.0034883125,
-0.0100578675,
0.0092125442,
0.0005065099,
-0.0318858065,
-0.0235133376,
0.0181920901,
-0.0005350764,
0.0055325143,
0.0363770723,
0.0412947871,
-0.0060021104,
-0.0017067312,
-0.0103512406,
-0.017336674,
0.0762244537,
0.0397582538,
-0.0465558767,
0.0072112754,
0.0160254762,
-0.0218761507,
0.0324590728,
-0.0163205005,
0.0005519686,
-0.0151681118,
-0.0090183252,
0.0712272897,
0.0532925799,
0.0112171238,
0.0649680421,
-0.0275893286,
-0.0554552451,
-0.0380208455,
0.0278365258,
-0.0147585031,
0.0266872309,
-0.0060963216,
0.0063617444,
-0.0387512892,
0.0390089341,
-0.0019231708,
0.023218073,
-0.0197059102,
-0.0085005313,
0.0550985672,
-0.0300306752,
-0.0531309694,
0.0087685268,
0.0315231457,
-0.0022261129,
-0.0681718215,
-0.0238274299,
0.0772371292,
-0.0073047052,
-0.0166740119,
0.024665935,
-0.001779986,
-0.0679407194,
0.0863563567,
0.0095953494,
0.0130452467,
0.0273921508,
-0.0283580925,
-0.0349347666,
0.0147818821,
0.0358907729,
0.0029165254,
0.0485988408,
-0.030311795,
0.0306875724,
-0.0400234535,
-0.0232713521,
-0.026163375,
-0.0357424654,
-0.0062743044,
-0.0257765632,
-0.0085979775,
0.0073272185,
-0.0051736054,
0.013224829,
0.0037654585,
0.0009260525,
-0.0027715194,
-0.0208276231,
-0.0252119713,
0.1074570417,
0.0777589977,
0.0150659662,
-0.0557714403,
-0.027698582,
0.00837762,
0.026824072,
-0.0418938771,
-0.0461699143,
-0.0141484989,
0.0288568214,
-0.0036843503,
0.0268049352,
0.0031699308,
-0.0115656424,
0.0430132672,
-0.0651230142,
-0.0011662284,
0.059044648,
0.0107060634,
-0.0626340732,
-0.0425636172,
0.0572558455,
0.0234820005,
0.0110091297,
0.0129138064,
-0.0554258265,
-0.0514722988,
-0.0000201591,
-0.0598091111,
0.0227624904,
-0.0261471905,
-0.0262523983,
-0.0747647882,
0.0000186981,
-0.0240251012,
0.0140597373,
-0.0386840031,
-0.0522187985,
0.0073288106,
-0.0211651027,
-0.039062839,
-0.0448332913,
-0.0135601684,
-0.0059044682,
-0.0127288084,
0.0511507727,
-0.0541667677,
0.0000433447,
-0.0445019081,
-0.0118670799,
0.046599064,
0.03132293,
-0.0090263588,
-0.0371418223,
0.0032929829,
0.0066185337,
-0.0178117249,
-0.0059398944,
0.0715952218,
-0.0769169256,
-0.0266021341,
-0.0227788668,
0.0075063212,
-0.0035339256,
-0.0175195802,
-0.0123758893,
0.0641227067,
0.008368996,
0.0083876438,
-0.0387404151,
-0.0404276922,
0.0047062626,
0.0421717875,
-0.0185999665,
-0.0255586412,
-0.0196182206,
-0.0092191901,
0.0347306505,
-0.0293141715,
-0.0103558563,
-0.0229250807,
-0.0320021026,
-0.0197522864,
-0.0400176272,
-0.0246532075,
0.0301401597,
0.0414493941,
-0.0141421901,
-0.0061538825,
-0.011744488,
0.0162937846,
-0.0608290024,
0.0331123434,
0.010875321,
0.0206910688,
-0.0285019781,
0.034929052,
0.0428828932,
-0.0238191132,
-0.0331182592,
0.0039651217,
-0.0664656758,
-0.005676032,
-0.0559485778,
0.0421669371,
0.0039290837,
0.0447580665,
0.0127928257,
-0.0056365328,
-0.0260473527,
0.0682557076,
-0.0579747446,
-0.0172043815,
-0.014987017,
-0.0225156974,
-0.026160907,
-0.011020218,
-0.0365730189,
0.0339684635,
-0.0219401438,
0.0053479667,
-0.0206368677,
-0.0614724644,
0.0114039565,
-0.0052757212,
0.071065791,
-0.0163201559,
0.0351527445,
-0.0762642398,
-0.0029900519,
-0.0352137163,
0.0213349927,
-0.0630586818,
0.0584637076,
0.0172032472,
0.0064427871,
-0.0073039178,
0.0335633233,
0.0483122021,
0.0164760407,
-0.016245598,
0.0077303927,
0.0311344713,
0.0098877214,
-0.0166492183,
0.0072943857,
0.0077347392,
0.0068562916,
0.0344035216,
0.0000649367,
-0.0423782654,
0.0696684122,
0.0157651827,
-0.0222831201,
-0.0228981152,
0.011302989,
-0.0106631946,
0.0541482568,
-0.0603144728,
0.042640321,
0.0571191013,
-0.0006637252,
0.0212666281,
0.0100609176,
-0.0004322695,
0.0247407593,
0.0612796843,
-0.0180794112,
-0.00592423,
0.0412702672,
-0.0029490802,
-0.0236363783,
0.0044792332,
0.0621371642,
-0.0375020951,
0.0325339548,
0.0050609498,
-0.0384164415,
-0.0438668989,
-0.0045951991,
0.048418358,
-0.0007075966,
0.0061830077,
0.0570355617,
-0.0365375243,
-0.0261287633,
0.0143668847,
-0.0270331223,
-0.0190595873,
0.0524897948,
0.0409996845,
0.0001402399,
0.0185210425,
-0.0472788885,
-0.025052432,
0.0027926629,
-0.0155463517,
-0.0052397675,
0.003312489,
-6.17371984e-33,
-0.0570797138,
-0.0181800108,
0.0131882541,
-0.0203258507,
-0.0356388465,
0.0569911748,
-0.0168612916,
-0.0300297886,
-0.0189511515,
0.0073579308,
0.0169352386,
-0.0229191072,
0.0041200095,
0.0291898958,
-0.0109107858,
0.0114096496,
0.046647463,
0.0157773551,
0.0320686735,
0.0103241364,
0.057662867,
0.0525515378,
0.0417311639,
-0.098491624,
0.0065159271,
0.0260855444,
-0.0231011864,
-0.0050500394,
0.0718411729,
0.045505248,
-0.0568172373,
-0.0068143522,
0.026364116,
-0.012328106,
-0.0037473741,
0.0262012538,
-0.1541694701,
-0.0254748408,
-0.019330794,
-0.0108155012,
-0.064183481,
-0.016601216,
0.0042421459,
0.0023701962,
0.0544617623,
-0.0552730151,
0.0659667477,
-0.0218756832,
0.004869075,
-0.0586572662,
-0.0392811932,
0.0391717851,
-0.0115465391,
-0.0042800885,
0.0565520786,
0.016801862,
0.0726885498,
0.0096058501,
-0.0083582764,
-0.0245264079,
-0.00295763,
-0.0018186634,
0.0361082964,
0.0529594235,
0.0102880867,
0.0809237733,
-0.0105656339,
-0.0349526517,
-0.0455583446,
0.0151592363,
0.0050293468,
0.0785052702,
-0.017879406,
0.0703275427,
0.045774091,
-0.0056874757,
-0.0840920731,
0.0410057418,
0.0248422753,
0.0281623993,
-0.04167898,
0.0120391324,
0.0142671298,
0.0263577048,
-0.0026803955,
-0.0159223229,
-0.0243297014,
-0.0399324894,
0.0274412967,
0.0639933348,
-0.015419892,
0.0613292493,
0.0631283,
-0.017562449,
-0.0163929258,
0.0296227671,
-0.0208055712,
0.0395465903,
0.0152279455,
-0.0125331739,
-0.0356508344,
-0.037404418,
0.0757797584,
-0.0298249964,
0.0097991414,
-0.0083192391,
0.0476683229,
-0.0293286555,
-0.0690952018,
-0.008781448,
-0.0258130897,
0.0038195592,
-0.0116234701,
0.0149718486,
0.0097207408,
0.0076458766,
-0.0599859767,
0.048859898,
0.0177791305,
0.0432805866,
-0.030620411,
-0.0138643365,
0.0162264165,
0.0514256097,
0.0426073298,
-0.0024623154,
-0.0208714046,
-0.0519898795,
0.0461967178,
-0.0510864221,
-0.0158685632,
0.0200338662,
2.716e-7,
0.0154465511,
0.0159010757,
0.0776252598,
-0.0154655343,
-0.003190245,
0.0379030779,
0.0116766803,
0.0665359572,
-0.0045638368,
-0.0252588447,
0.0017512633,
0.0091898907,
-0.0003255647,
0.0297305807,
-0.011037223,
0.0107596442,
-0.0481309295,
-0.0427407771,
-0.0598208383,
-0.0053666434,
0.1041986793,
0.0641831979,
0.0021072663,
0.0164955407,
0.0029246036,
-0.0080261929,
0.0964197963,
-0.0123308701,
-0.0011846154,
0.0278642233,
-0.0137241408,
0.0123545863,
-0.0234441087,
0.0454197973,
-0.014922956,
0.0248371735,
0.0480766222,
0.0398895964,
-0.0316401571,
-0.0411319397,
-0.0063189091,
0.022227969,
-0.0232556127,
0.0054947496,
0.0929386392,
-0.0324237943,
-0.0106232315,
-0.0292452537,
-0.0601076074,
0.029056076,
0.0078134425,
0.0182770956,
-0.0508457795,
0.0556087829,
0.0426088944,
-0.0151864011,
-0.0531123951,
-0.1139288619,
0.0180803053,
0.0368173867,
-0.0088223917,
0.0121878376,
-0.0173761472,
-0.0240119789,
0.0404580459,
-0.0391835906,
-0.0425567627,
2.445551942e-34,
-0.01366325,
-0.0163440313,
-0.0132373497,
0.027986737,
0.0514883846,
-0.0488298237,
-0.0993575752,
-0.0002368509,
-0.0204853304,
-0.0633399338,
0.0046109511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10985v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10985v1 | LARG, Language-based Automatic Reward and Goal Generation | 2023-06-19T14:52:39 | 2023-06-19T14:52:39 | Julien Perez, Denys Proux, Claude Roux, Michael Niemaz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO | Goal-conditioned and Multi-Task Reinforcement Learning (GCRL and MTRL)
address numerous problems related to robot learning, including locomotion,
navigation, and manipulation scenarios. Recent works focusing on
language-defined robotic manipulation tasks have led to the tedious production
of massive human annotations to create dataset of textual descriptions
associated with trajectories. To leverage reinforcement learning with
text-based task descriptions, we need to produce reward functions associated
with individual tasks in a scalable manner. In this paper, we leverage recent
capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) and introduce \larg,
Language-based Automatic Reward and Goal Generation, an approach that converts
a text-based task description into its corresponding reward and goal-generation
functions We evaluate our approach for robotic manipulation and demonstrate its
ability to train and execute policies in a scalable manner, without the need
for handcrafted reward functions. | [
0.0589863956,
0.0476680771,
0.0035371848,
0.0207039565,
-0.0343552828,
0.0120364754,
0.0154214064,
-0.0202736259,
-0.0135280238,
-0.0190297253,
-0.0285981409,
-0.0254091602,
-0.0180233493,
0.0236235652,
0.0198570881,
-0.0778452754,
0.0448745564,
-0.0751217976,
-0.0044913758,
0.0082387496,
0.0022984273,
-0.0010702731,
0.000172767,
0.056973476,
-0.0276540536,
0.0021176536,
-0.0281086396,
-0.0106709581,
0.0237497184,
-0.0383504629,
-0.0192146637,
0.0047132196,
0.0714253858,
0.0573855974,
0.0000021309,
-0.060505379,
0.0060367705,
-0.0180371087,
0.0090085054,
-0.0518794656,
0.0837244242,
-0.00486858,
-0.0116768302,
0.02765017,
-0.0071069011,
-0.0066418243,
0.0425799638,
0.041609399,
0.0554527044,
0.0821739137,
0.0011436563,
-0.0246984735,
-0.0234367996,
-0.0165988822,
0.0594280697,
-0.0384044088,
0.0322291926,
0.0532106832,
0.0604629144,
0.0262405537,
-0.016836144,
-0.0052830824,
0.0330744535,
-0.0594823398,
-0.0175324455,
0.0582473837,
0.00832952,
-0.0283488072,
-0.0065435558,
0.024011394,
-0.022505559,
-0.0088510774,
0.0162200704,
0.0086375624,
0.0233228989,
0.0195602905,
-0.0187776573,
0.076450564,
0.0063010701,
0.0248114225,
-0.0125976633,
-0.0348504707,
0.0129727162,
0.0032824848,
-0.0265791044,
0.0869283527,
-0.0016084809,
-0.0054356721,
0.0147658354,
-0.0135347955,
-0.0104021421,
-0.0765950605,
0.0185970552,
0.0437951423,
-0.0460677519,
0.0050714179,
-0.0790627524,
-0.0042511425,
-0.0036284714,
-0.0339853056,
0.043617893,
0.0140773989,
0.0124602942,
0.0377408639,
-0.0281411726,
0.0792566761,
-0.0352089629,
0.0244674534,
-0.0518906824,
0.0014374519,
-0.0543370545,
0.0135290986,
-0.0480686612,
0.0290474482,
-0.0166583639,
-0.0174189452,
-0.0357568525,
0.0665825084,
-0.0169998612,
0.0360666104,
-0.0089770034,
-0.0066125235,
-0.0321107022,
-0.0221544188,
-0.0587190129,
-0.0219892543,
-0.0062408913,
0.0360765532,
0.0281633958,
0.0417668596,
-0.0028499055,
0.0403836519,
0.0135628749,
-0.0312031154,
0.0172647852,
0.0987219959,
-0.0085870251,
0.0062168869,
-0.0001054988,
-0.0347861946,
0.0086947065,
-0.027825024,
0.0034350688,
-0.0795411244,
-0.0018161555,
-0.011463183,
-0.0132420445,
-0.0132265072,
0.0176683776,
0.0333090164,
-0.0055008945,
0.0728714317,
0.0355536006,
0.0095663229,
0.0239372402,
-0.0301195327,
-0.0202262271,
0.0439162068,
0.0624737926,
0.0880859271,
0.0101124384,
0.0350108184,
0.0029040109,
0.0696213022,
-0.0525365844,
-0.0089849103,
0.0062410827,
-0.0225823633,
0.062086504,
0.0447123386,
0.0259267613,
0.0370197669,
-0.0353956968,
0.0533377118,
0.0607413873,
0.0772775635,
-0.0196016803,
-0.0209280699,
0.0485736951,
0.0091269296,
-0.037299756,
-0.0558380634,
-0.0418424346,
0.0388085246,
0.003859194,
-0.0136570865,
-0.021727385,
0.0236278716,
-0.021685442,
-0.032308761,
-0.0053096502,
-0.0320160873,
0.0445690714,
0.0106428936,
0.0832793117,
0.0128212245,
-0.044351168,
-0.0297192018,
0.0391723849,
-0.0142418286,
0.0286751781,
-0.0294140074,
-0.006134985,
0.0578988232,
0.0020734624,
-0.039171204,
-0.016863279,
-0.046559453,
0.0097824205,
0.0756238922,
-0.0036339939,
-0.0204156488,
-0.0453932099,
-0.004501007,
-0.0267838296,
0.0059678899,
-0.0153118316,
0.0177429821,
0.0182129238,
0.0077845305,
-0.0078586405,
0.0092218155,
-0.0595171638,
0.0455634743,
-0.0224696565,
-0.0220262483,
0.0508534946,
-0.0095198536,
0.0365219638,
-0.0047831787,
-0.014985255,
0.0044214707,
0.0229182914,
-0.0425797738,
-0.0198554266,
0.0206364803,
-0.0189307872,
-0.0034002552,
0.0413518734,
0.0077186883,
-0.004992432,
0.0231132973,
-0.0088077849,
-0.0336163677,
-0.0156873669,
-0.0167724974,
0.0168280471,
0.0285218917,
0.0220679399,
0.0087122312,
-0.0857886672,
-0.0448681936,
0.0294556618,
0.0188132394,
-0.0028515167,
0.0113327438,
0.0019796805,
-0.0205226596,
-0.0414752737,
-0.0537312627,
0.0337443724,
-0.0039554727,
0.0296174474,
0.066226624,
0.0622440428,
-0.0180231445,
-0.0385387316,
-0.0480789952,
-0.0159408748,
-0.0025717814,
0.0067693139,
0.0225861613,
-0.0143659357,
-0.0098805614,
-0.0165581033,
-0.0102507919,
0.0174420215,
-0.0102051888,
0.0003468238,
0.0264189523,
0.0239158999,
-0.018145103,
-0.0326107107,
-0.00142283,
-0.0240480117,
-0.00780656,
0.0515192449,
0.0158621166,
-0.0837941244,
0.0766009912,
-0.01599201,
0.0339544415,
-0.0181792378,
-0.0274447091,
0.0413111933,
-0.0425199196,
0.0312859006,
0.0793557912,
-0.0189298447,
0.0179605018,
0.0849844441,
-0.0055833175,
-0.0522560887,
0.0130737145,
-0.0657992661,
-0.0506637692,
-0.0544994548,
-0.0206068605,
0.0337592773,
0.0510840341,
-0.0130857583,
0.0097529273,
-0.0673266947,
-0.0228719544,
-0.0664621964,
-0.0202464797,
-0.0424229093,
0.0136787044,
-0.0702439919,
-0.0048824945,
-0.037796028,
-0.0721706972,
0.0545186885,
0.0130336313,
-0.006828323,
0.0019859322,
-0.0340046808,
-0.026431106,
0.0940817595,
0.0322589353,
0.0379028097,
-0.0116692018,
-0.0232214853,
-0.0073141591,
0.0288941003,
0.0181336552,
-0.0028954248,
0.0237969439,
-0.061288964,
0.0235302523,
0.0071477592,
-0.0575893596,
-0.0449681617,
0.007349683,
-0.0067747491,
0.0052716513,
-0.0047982782,
-0.068118155,
-0.0231246129,
-0.0268530603,
0.0791005865,
0.0389076136,
-0.0271205511,
-0.0112840421,
-0.0410703532,
-0.0428685695,
0.0658283159,
0.0003836846,
-0.0800815597,
-0.0394096151,
-0.0144423228,
0.0157544799,
0.0304124132,
-0.0287753046,
-0.0149380313,
0.0014745264,
0.0349615738,
-0.0414826423,
0.0204059687,
0.0308388211,
0.0467534699,
-0.0353207737,
-0.0566934235,
0.1058922634,
0.0293243043,
-0.0428356417,
-0.0078229243,
-0.0154473158,
0.0341496319,
0.0195631292,
0.0299775917,
-0.0708794519,
-0.0219964441,
-0.0083916932,
0.0020775315,
0.030702915,
-0.0098340521,
0.0059660142,
-0.1216540635,
0.013223731,
0.0132090049,
-0.0601228215,
-0.0493359491,
-0.0427066796,
-0.0145606399,
-0.0267773457,
-0.0383901708,
0.0258097667,
-0.0076895803,
-0.0020858746,
0.0273307357,
-0.003201057,
-0.0389533415,
0.0035937887,
-0.0526198484,
0.0216829535,
0.085645102,
0.0092888521,
-0.0575383268,
0.0033384613,
0.0002674564,
0.0738658309,
-0.019823635,
0.0014206565,
-0.0260741729,
-0.0042547719,
-0.0331781581,
-0.0074323774,
0.0602054074,
-0.0304202773,
-0.0503817759,
0.0171754695,
0.0718595013,
-0.0144093204,
0.0099528395,
-0.0061797146,
-0.0547909103,
0.0284846835,
0.0699976534,
-0.0375283137,
-0.0769719407,
-0.023255052,
-0.0319429822,
-0.0900256187,
-0.0141562037,
-0.0632432997,
-0.0166854076,
-0.0433847904,
0.0194160752,
-0.0593930334,
-0.0363451354,
0.078704372,
0.0078551853,
0.0090871528,
-0.0094490247,
0.0547804907,
-0.001253602,
-0.0461368859,
0.012253209,
-0.0311379153,
0.0232109819,
-0.0698530897,
-0.0431381166,
0.0027852166,
-0.021651702,
-0.0244759396,
0.0031944884,
-0.035996858,
-0.065249525,
-0.0224410761,
0.0620668754,
0.0135074724,
0.0133810118,
0.0041964049,
-0.0216197148,
0.023236705,
0.0229763482,
-0.0101932222,
0.0337582752,
-0.0003006002,
0.0616492592,
0.0124121662,
0.0432770811,
-0.0596047714,
0.0230163913,
-0.0254963692,
0.0165138487,
-0.0090910457,
0.0071202782,
0.0406544954,
-0.0063930131,
0.0148813706,
-0.0220416728,
-0.0062197298,
-0.0547647215,
-0.0245973226,
-0.0451368764,
-0.0305203982,
-0.0603260882,
0.0195156652,
0.0214570798,
-0.0057781213,
0.0324562602,
-0.0043755658,
0.0165830124,
0.0024668854,
-0.0244655982,
0.0100047076,
-0.0070215515,
0.0361566506,
0.063763313,
0.0357492752,
0.0152019607,
-0.0285911243,
-0.0180906598,
0.0211877581,
0.0081479037,
0.0420560874,
0.0513971597,
0.0082707051,
-0.0215708837,
-0.0109912558,
-0.0377620533,
-0.0707651973,
0.0006946383,
-0.0141241848,
0.0764364302,
-0.0086684329,
0.0651822612,
-0.0716289952,
-0.0096603474,
-0.0061046239,
0.028851755,
0.0028548704,
-0.0063516949,
0.0289585311,
0.0091681611,
0.002798096,
-0.0265779663,
0.070359461,
-0.0136300419,
0.0426145568,
0.0017048923,
-0.0220023673,
-0.0374131277,
-0.0199456997,
0.0295741279,
-0.0163462535,
-0.0207598638,
-0.00937464,
-0.0289961845,
-0.0429929979,
-0.0382256173,
0.0482429266,
0.003814176,
-0.0003774017,
0.0471781828,
0.0025712925,
-0.0423981398,
-0.0174821652,
-0.041324202,
-0.0203415006,
0.0092414906,
-0.0288215466,
-0.0681507811,
-5.72239356e-33,
-0.0110528823,
-0.0478788838,
0.0652613118,
0.0297106113,
-0.026180448,
-0.0118443118,
-0.0236001275,
0.0126057724,
0.0270368736,
0.0384209268,
0.020792298,
-0.015700588,
-0.0008654624,
0.0288181975,
0.0575800911,
0.000548143,
0.0306752343,
-0.0389521085,
-0.0419485942,
0.0196172316,
0.0597069226,
-0.0113500617,
0.0288523212,
-0.0428663678,
0.0599200614,
-0.0007286536,
-0.042938035,
0.042963624,
0.0331133902,
0.0402850248,
-0.0149137015,
0.0115170274,
0.0065140259,
-0.0413391441,
-0.0246102232,
0.0445445515,
-0.0543131493,
-0.0485315695,
-0.006113105,
-0.0046866867,
-0.0683245957,
-0.0077754296,
0.010105744,
-0.0151743041,
-0.0277758371,
0.0373844579,
0.0330785811,
0.0035692588,
0.0005128392,
0.0238619484,
-0.0600021295,
-0.0001164874,
0.0186682455,
-0.0432865843,
0.0521515161,
0.0178668629,
-0.0174028892,
-0.0226470195,
0.0098845977,
0.0201167483,
-0.0304230414,
0.0207372643,
0.0218974948,
0.0405069925,
0.0560727529,
0.0602167733,
-0.0256955083,
-0.0141946329,
-0.0071721817,
0.021643769,
0.0185730737,
0.0471445024,
0.0036078317,
0.0183340274,
0.0017300451,
0.0119207175,
-0.0444602557,
0.0088495128,
-0.0195918903,
0.083058618,
0.0185048245,
0.0170843434,
-0.0185811184,
-0.0023458737,
-0.044679746,
0.0306886248,
0.0010761233,
-0.0179247502,
0.0458035469,
0.0373121165,
0.024110062,
-0.0347626954,
0.0242366865,
-0.0026783475,
-0.0477770306,
0.0109020574,
-0.0207320824,
0.0301789641,
-0.0183999799,
-0.0177081656,
-0.0701155961,
-0.0286736563,
-0.0231904797,
-0.0389491245,
0.0117682833,
0.0411750749,
0.0028095946,
0.0523233078,
-0.0434485897,
0.0223659128,
-0.0571134686,
0.0056221369,
0.0183464009,
0.0080069378,
0.0644656494,
-0.0081917476,
-0.0008141114,
0.0637270585,
0.0156638566,
-0.0794420019,
-0.0081714727,
0.0007357192,
-0.0177648105,
0.0114139719,
-0.0394947976,
0.0078964541,
-0.0251636729,
0.0732236803,
0.0337148681,
-0.0666742995,
0.0197675228,
-0.0160728823,
2.794e-7,
0.005865322,
0.0633684918,
-0.0144323362,
0.08008378,
0.0083357925,
0.0539585426,
-0.0137431929,
0.0371020325,
-0.0147078102,
0.0340606198,
0.001400825,
0.0364580899,
0.0085031036,
-0.0098763015,
-0.0856319293,
0.0130681098,
-0.0030051903,
-0.0379032269,
-0.0373594202,
-0.0133241853,
0.0590181947,
0.057769645,
0.0374182872,
0.0140087157,
0.0113416035,
-0.039019756,
0.0442679562,
-0.0744270682,
0.003136083,
0.0065745264,
-0.0095550297,
0.0088398801,
-0.019760821,
-0.0200355649,
0.0026837965,
-0.0062615988,
-0.0031916439,
0.0789339319,
-0.0223658141,
0.0388988554,
-0.0061763036,
-0.0091443518,
0.002823896,
-0.0338992476,
0.0259819292,
-0.0730937496,
0.0077303578,
-0.0304504987,
0.0362886116,
-0.0202088114,
-0.0044537871,
-0.0039052179,
-0.0213467255,
-0.0050987294,
0.0129239811,
0.0322608203,
-0.0025389427,
-0.0687319562,
-0.0111855781,
0.0293342285,
-0.0525194593,
-0.0146415727,
-0.0289211534,
0.0308724213,
-0.0383366048,
-0.0608759783,
0.0213103388,
2.447791809e-34,
-0.0006029889,
-0.0083548408,
0.001786979,
0.0260360725,
0.0286667384,
0.0317858718,
-0.0169210713,
0.0417717323,
0.0548703969,
-0.0421370789,
-0.05504914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10974v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10974v2 | Fine-Tuning Language Models for Scientific Writing Support | 2023-06-19T14:34:49 | 2023-06-21T08:31:48 | Justin Mücke, Daria Waldow, Luise Metzger, Philipp Schauz, Marcel Hoffman, Nicolas Lell, Ansgar Scherp | cs.CL | cs.CL | We support scientific writers in determining whether a written sentence is
scientific, to which section it belongs, and suggest paraphrasings to improve
the sentence. Firstly, we propose a regression model trained on a corpus of
scientific sentences extracted from peer-reviewed scientific papers and
non-scientific text to assign a score that indicates the scientificness of a
sentence. We investigate the effect of equations and citations on this score to
test the model for potential biases. Secondly, we create a mapping of section
titles to a standard paper layout in AI and machine learning to classify a
sentence to its most likely section. We study the impact of context, i.e.,
surrounding sentences, on the section classification performance. Finally, we
propose a paraphraser, which suggests an alternative for a given sentence that
includes word substitutions, additions to the sentence, and structural changes
to improve the writing style. We train various large language models on
sentences extracted from arXiv papers that were peer reviewed and published at
A*, A, B, and C ranked conferences. On the scientificness task, all models
achieve an MSE smaller than $2\%$. For the section classification, BERT
outperforms WideMLP and SciBERT in most cases. We demonstrate that using
context enhances the classification of a sentence, achieving up to a $90\%$
F1-score. Although the paraphrasing models make comparatively few alterations,
they produce output sentences close to the gold standard. Large fine-tuned
models such as T5 Large perform best in experiments considering various
measures of difference between input sentence and gold standard. Code is
provided under https://github.com/JustinMuecke/SciSen. | [
0.0659227148,
0.0070831566,
0.00761599,
-0.0136761945,
-0.0398482233,
-0.0074131852,
0.0366994105,
0.012884086,
-0.0089394189,
-0.1008548513,
-0.0323088393,
0.0499559231,
0.0098838564,
-0.0032906553,
0.031980522,
-0.0710050911,
0.0268183984,
-0.0060189813,
0.0810811371,
0.0211896468,
0.0197103061,
0.011089013,
0.0179916415,
0.0395989493,
0.0518100373,
-0.0436652564,
0.0544535145,
0.0072902087,
0.0407097153,
-0.0187344365,
0.0516433194,
0.0502449349,
0.0075729885,
0.054188557,
0.0000016473,
-0.0444775894,
-0.0311191063,
0.0299050082,
0.0224114712,
0.0565385595,
0.0503638834,
-0.0339650996,
0.007586265,
0.0250110514,
-0.012491107,
0.009989175,
0.0327273048,
0.0254907422,
0.0480583794,
0.0527632125,
-0.0250222404,
-0.0620881803,
0.0567036457,
0.0235021282,
0.0210475735,
0.0142343994,
0.0516207479,
0.0252973326,
0.0353428684,
0.0617757514,
0.0216481853,
0.0377269611,
-0.0010191721,
-0.0310505554,
0.0663061738,
0.0173433516,
-0.0775482878,
0.0208819248,
0.0107639786,
0.0359464437,
-0.0160065927,
-0.0824120343,
0.0539082028,
-0.0107221361,
-0.0395140909,
0.0405088626,
-0.0532801822,
-0.0032250516,
-0.0216406491,
-0.0357165858,
0.0526034981,
0.0060930895,
0.0112404041,
0.0765971169,
0.0161602516,
0.0433111824,
0.0392119475,
-0.0586409792,
-0.0315674171,
-0.0004032251,
-0.027442744,
-0.0488835759,
0.0499945506,
0.0131736351,
-0.0048147137,
0.0026205361,
-0.0687917918,
-0.0721530318,
0.0401736051,
-0.0335611887,
0.0029542868,
-0.0050468482,
0.0238762405,
0.0141739612,
-0.0218255222,
0.0493212231,
-0.0268128719,
0.0171583891,
-0.0238300636,
0.0068695699,
-0.0508443117,
-0.038261421,
-0.0234004501,
0.0015574854,
-0.0032081529,
-0.0380352549,
-0.0550050028,
-0.0124626085,
0.0188137479,
-0.0086923204,
0.0058553219,
-0.0126036694,
-0.0480506495,
0.0347916,
0.0251604486,
0.0295107663,
0.0007354236,
0.0263956748,
0.0076895724,
-0.0017462966,
-0.0094430353,
0.0317058638,
0.0159068126,
-0.0271412414,
0.0017808191,
-0.0117792711,
0.0103386603,
-0.0355907939,
0.0154787404,
-0.0273618232,
-0.0415922813,
-0.045690462,
0.0288977046,
-0.0541314557,
0.0003296196,
0.0152948964,
-0.0119646592,
-0.0451481976,
0.0001152023,
0.0268320963,
-0.0426616706,
0.0133134732,
-0.0485513881,
-0.0156223569,
0.0562148802,
-0.0154338013,
0.0058468948,
-0.016552899,
0.0560164638,
-0.00059225,
0.0477044061,
-0.0097273095,
0.0404876806,
-0.0135970302,
0.0047693211,
-0.0144087709,
0.0166241992,
0.0155574074,
-0.0117824832,
0.0566978939,
-0.034571901,
0.0564186536,
-0.0159164425,
0.0364263542,
0.0477545559,
0.0553446934,
0.0008564725,
0.0272416975,
0.0160104763,
0.0277765747,
0.0457593389,
0.0146035329,
-0.0109650278,
0.0273951534,
-0.0049006641,
0.0377430506,
0.0320969857,
-0.0040890155,
-0.0027464,
-0.0414501131,
-0.0280326325,
0.0100936349,
-0.0199595168,
-0.0105167935,
0.0356766135,
0.0000515954,
-0.0375928655,
0.0013610882,
0.0104322294,
-0.0416988432,
0.0176009722,
-0.0093449019,
0.0367303155,
0.0300102048,
0.0727636367,
-0.0608970597,
-0.009367452,
-0.0308181494,
0.0174066499,
0.027725365,
0.0369295478,
-0.0065225917,
-0.0131860841,
-0.0295625571,
-0.0079505201,
-0.0361294746,
0.027722165,
-0.0228542481,
0.0093702879,
-0.0133620985,
0.015243059,
-0.0179345589,
-0.0678147152,
0.0719868988,
-0.0414235294,
-0.0179254711,
-0.0059562316,
-0.0222568475,
0.0208374243,
-0.0106025832,
-0.0302547365,
0.0431957357,
0.0291253924,
-0.0378025658,
-0.0004438354,
0.029901091,
0.0014853348,
-0.0378670879,
0.0179339293,
-0.0485473871,
0.006311961,
0.0315918289,
-0.0010311701,
-0.0391102806,
0.0171907805,
-0.0524462871,
-0.0042313277,
0.00552165,
0.0065254224,
-0.0423166081,
-0.0050656791,
-0.0497412272,
0.0318731591,
0.0361268483,
0.0556786135,
0.0335123837,
-0.0453884415,
0.0292521231,
-0.0172782857,
-0.0322542973,
-0.0356403887,
0.0133221978,
-0.0085281981,
0.0567338057,
-0.0250953212,
-0.0243842918,
-0.0393705368,
-0.0572567657,
0.0096320948,
-0.0122638056,
0.0045058145,
0.0380456895,
-0.0313546099,
0.0161589459,
0.0224805512,
0.0209781658,
-0.0259946678,
-0.0154300109,
-0.0203637369,
0.0740552396,
0.0045786658,
-0.0047549587,
-0.0778322294,
-0.0296879523,
-0.0670696497,
0.0630167797,
0.0664682537,
-0.001454805,
-0.0406914949,
0.0180778839,
0.0121779293,
-0.044051785,
0.0024308078,
-0.030794898,
0.0006767084,
-0.0146169886,
-0.0058397283,
0.1075435653,
0.0347702876,
-0.019164823,
0.0489233173,
0.0438641943,
-0.0089384848,
-0.0300075859,
-0.0033487275,
0.037323501,
0.0014684759,
-0.0261308774,
0.0493025221,
0.0327168293,
0.0034923593,
-0.0125901829,
-0.0338531695,
0.0385466889,
-0.004772854,
-0.0027891211,
0.0448177643,
-0.0212339479,
0.0066997199,
0.0391918421,
0.0100874221,
-0.0287178922,
0.0686582178,
-0.0424342304,
-0.0182754137,
-0.0892823935,
-0.0144879445,
-0.0414708965,
-0.0147650177,
-0.0037289434,
0.0160200559,
0.0394251607,
0.0134344026,
-0.02499469,
-0.0408056118,
-0.0035109902,
-0.0056884191,
-0.029726848,
-0.0670756623,
0.0172133557,
0.0063702771,
-0.0286277439,
0.0108686378,
-0.0534724593,
-0.0175396781,
0.0610489249,
0.0243158564,
-0.041324161,
-0.0630181879,
-0.0043994323,
0.0665153489,
0.0538732,
-0.0774669945,
-0.0066558821,
-0.0559171773,
0.0300997775,
0.0795146599,
-0.0119165294,
0.0018419869,
-0.0449929386,
-0.0162370093,
0.0026621071,
-0.0102305887,
0.0558264218,
-0.0500838533,
-0.0523080043,
0.000070626,
-0.0788790584,
-0.0283041857,
-0.0057747108,
0.0477998592,
-0.0439641029,
-0.0175060723,
0.1274747252,
0.0173723139,
-0.0274669416,
-0.0428552553,
-0.0196956899,
0.0197292846,
0.010899514,
0.0399804562,
-0.0395996235,
-0.0186396036,
-0.0067152497,
0.0166225079,
-0.0068707205,
-0.0054552238,
-0.0130353468,
-0.0213545877,
0.0117699541,
0.0198482033,
-0.0571343526,
-0.0258440822,
-0.0489173196,
-0.0157202445,
0.0018589738,
-0.0165208299,
-0.0093025453,
-0.038641192,
0.01665649,
0.0098837391,
-0.0553571768,
-0.0710354,
-0.0228775814,
-0.0463874899,
0.0199887119,
0.049345538,
0.0634990484,
-0.0212487094,
-0.003984469,
0.0115983672,
-0.0261497349,
-0.0164373163,
-0.0027758966,
0.0352918766,
-0.0222235024,
0.0348216146,
-0.0228468813,
0.0619191565,
-0.0192229412,
-0.0141516263,
0.0530614033,
0.0563668944,
-0.0068941591,
-0.021469783,
-0.078289941,
0.0340976119,
-0.0085237548,
0.0694584996,
0.035063982,
-0.0225917641,
-0.1010509878,
-0.035315901,
0.0275449641,
-0.0196218509,
-0.0225442443,
-0.0435792059,
-0.0435150266,
0.0166934244,
-0.0900412053,
-0.0145633863,
0.0107302079,
0.0050575593,
0.0326464958,
0.0331919044,
0.0120030623,
-0.0114337122,
-0.0441333689,
-0.0081488602,
0.0133489724,
0.0318695009,
-0.0124851512,
0.0067744362,
0.0947366878,
-0.0037651013,
-0.0296839066,
-0.0123464353,
0.0025967839,
-0.0640416741,
-0.0269940253,
0.0389809608,
0.0208002497,
0.0109575745,
0.0069407336,
-0.0510782562,
0.0314302295,
0.0278333593,
0.0038862207,
0.0148862079,
0.0166476965,
-0.0264670663,
-0.0232559126,
-0.0274860896,
-0.0391906761,
0.0037391344,
-0.011706451,
0.0165606719,
-0.0383870676,
-0.0171555001,
0.0232302696,
0.0270254817,
0.0400082171,
-0.0342310406,
-0.0119031249,
-0.0002082923,
-0.0048786174,
-0.0162167531,
-0.0041147154,
-0.0130597549,
0.0208833721,
0.0206907075,
0.0298572592,
-0.0118879722,
0.0512603782,
-0.050018616,
0.0255052187,
-0.0383136943,
0.0505200587,
-0.0220516399,
0.0414698385,
-0.0077115418,
-0.0143728415,
-0.0348501541,
-0.0270577054,
-0.0349653251,
0.0168805029,
-0.0042171539,
0.004687855,
0.0443572178,
-0.0107571939,
-0.0167277902,
0.0361211598,
-0.1622158885,
0.0228806306,
-0.0262712128,
0.0172347184,
0.0125778224,
-0.0054163025,
0.0693622753,
-0.0444611683,
-0.0495553277,
-0.0522210337,
0.0906529576,
0.0209514108,
0.0309010558,
0.0406454839,
0.0084145423,
-0.0078689549,
-0.0392242037,
0.05405223,
0.0586473867,
0.0032707152,
0.0224012323,
-0.0482054539,
-0.0321552381,
-0.0222961679,
-0.0231646374,
0.022049576,
0.005846838,
-0.0207983349,
-0.0287797879,
0.0196957309,
0.047628127,
0.0164116193,
0.0126088783,
-0.0588194355,
0.0274995789,
0.0385385193,
-0.0284727477,
-0.0442187786,
-0.0460444838,
0.0454619601,
-0.0090127308,
-0.0590644889,
-0.0587867126,
-5.194602841e-33,
0.0002410665,
-0.0108906776,
-0.0148664927,
0.0599416345,
-0.0128676118,
0.037136998,
-0.0764123276,
-0.0286258478,
-0.0123191988,
0.0304765012,
-0.0234104414,
0.0068352171,
-0.0066778464,
0.0125322035,
0.0054340381,
0.0366590694,
0.0673494115,
-0.0104362536,
-0.0403772481,
0.0168043189,
0.0041524642,
0.0164262485,
0.0355064496,
-0.0768761635,
0.0113349976,
-0.0258560833,
0.012434762,
-0.0310196001,
0.0023989889,
0.0353501178,
-0.0172455087,
0.0140446266,
0.0057572434,
-0.0239408277,
-0.0180920176,
0.0491238385,
-0.0555074178,
0.0253884345,
0.0346819162,
-0.0290832352,
-0.0365215354,
-0.0730569661,
0.0511725917,
-0.0315905437,
-0.0189717077,
-0.0200696755,
0.1127876565,
-0.0305013172,
-0.0195850916,
-0.0693679377,
-0.0612848885,
0.0135622406,
-0.0288110729,
0.0037482223,
0.0220275391,
0.0500273667,
-0.0223450568,
0.1026412547,
-0.0023238743,
0.0395321995,
0.001647146,
0.0511428043,
-0.0033926952,
-0.0201647263,
0.0220721867,
0.0279403497,
0.0067305332,
0.0164364595,
0.0376154222,
-0.043048393,
0.0344184898,
0.019108979,
0.075218901,
0.0612164587,
0.0476640351,
0.0118557196,
-0.0498301871,
0.0231060758,
0.021150779,
0.006904827,
0.0450029112,
0.00039013,
0.0099011017,
-0.0197027177,
-0.0176316425,
-0.0264801327,
0.0002001939,
-0.0041477713,
0.0083590569,
-0.0223432481,
-0.020021962,
0.036304079,
0.0210682955,
-0.044988852,
-0.0183630176,
0.0379057117,
-0.0301273279,
0.0617900938,
0.0022614433,
0.0087070456,
-0.069835633,
-0.0224063285,
0.0098512117,
0.0265378039,
0.0364311002,
-0.0109413713,
0.0379721299,
0.0066846265,
-0.0240230598,
0.004815557,
0.0152979065,
-0.0466122888,
0.0081393542,
0.0211036187,
-0.0292040482,
0.0417920686,
0.0432703905,
0.011570557,
0.0166537073,
0.0301272422,
0.00514257,
0.0094491299,
0.0089625642,
0.0433388874,
-0.0282415934,
-0.0211574566,
-0.0200370811,
0.0428518094,
-0.0302588399,
-0.0510866307,
0.0065484755,
-0.0202461351,
2.394e-7,
0.0689113215,
0.1057999581,
0.0095435008,
-0.0344225764,
0.0397270583,
0.0177445617,
-0.0118942587,
0.0375720449,
-0.0051459582,
0.0299014486,
0.021011943,
-0.0252459142,
0.0372892022,
-0.0238179173,
-0.1024197116,
-0.0273254681,
-0.0950573683,
-0.0379406326,
-0.0641997531,
-0.0011422536,
0.0197324716,
0.0382835232,
-0.0059473799,
0.0109069496,
-0.0237130914,
-0.0408076458,
0.0526635274,
-0.0349178016,
0.0272229873,
0.0652265325,
-0.0094656562,
0.0189348012,
-0.0099525405,
0.0125619965,
-0.0304097943,
0.0053229202,
0.0190780535,
0.0621276498,
0.0001504473,
0.0075996178,
0.0407005213,
0.0088359984,
0.0247680917,
-0.0556172803,
0.0216999054,
-0.0428063832,
-0.0157473683,
-0.0580009669,
-0.0479205102,
-0.0075647882,
0.0260181911,
-0.0214654915,
-0.0131698549,
0.0129342955,
-0.0202160701,
-0.0248005223,
-0.0009891243,
-0.0552606545,
-0.0402667373,
0.0500681996,
-0.0249791536,
-0.0148345781,
-0.0237232633,
-0.0270400308,
0.0348656476,
-0.0809466764,
0.0095487367,
2.468784026e-34,
0.0706910938,
-0.0166011006,
-0.0143248811,
0.030523885,
0.0094038183,
0.0062416927,
-0.0058998065,
0.0179000366,
0.0190699864,
-0.0414291769,
0.0166975837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10968v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10968v2 | BayLing: Bridging Cross-lingual Alignment and Instruction Following through Interactive Translation for Large Language Models | 2023-06-19T14:30:52 | 2023-06-21T11:31:50 | Shaolei Zhang, Qingkai Fang, Zhuocheng Zhang, Zhengrui Ma, Yan Zhou, Langlin Huang, Mengyu Bu, Shangtong Gui, Yunji Chen, Xilin Chen, Yang Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable prowess in language
understanding and generation. Advancing from foundation LLMs to
instructionfollowing LLMs, instruction tuning plays a vital role in aligning
LLMs to human preferences. However, the existing LLMs are usually focused on
English, leading to inferior performance in non-English languages. In order to
improve the performance for non-English languages, it is necessary to collect
language-specific training data for foundation LLMs and construct
language-specific instructions for instruction tuning, both of which are heavy
loads. To minimize human workload, we propose to transfer the capabilities of
language generation and instruction following from English to other languages
through an interactive translation task. We have developed BayLing, an
instruction-following LLM by utilizing LLaMA as the foundation LLM and
automatically constructing interactive translation instructions for instructing
tuning. Extensive assessments demonstrate that BayLing achieves comparable
performance to GPT-3.5-turbo, despite utilizing a considerably smaller
parameter size of only 13 billion. Experimental results on translation tasks
show that BayLing achieves 95% of single-turn translation capability compared
to GPT-4 with automatic evaluation and 96% of interactive translation
capability compared to GPT-3.5-turbo with human evaluation. To estimate the
performance on general tasks, we created a multi-turn instruction test set
called BayLing-80. The experimental results on BayLing-80 indicate that BayLing
achieves 89% of performance compared to GPT-3.5-turbo. BayLing also
demonstrates outstanding performance on knowledge assessment of Chinese GaoKao
and English SAT, second only to GPT-3.5-turbo among a multitude of
instruction-following LLMs. Demo, homepage, code and models of BayLing are
available. | [
0.0027405294,
-0.0112543032,
-0.0075350534,
0.0208199788,
-0.0407867096,
0.0395296812,
0.0095155574,
-0.0287680458,
0.0060603973,
-0.0356139429,
-0.0495250747,
-0.0291110482,
0.00673154,
-0.0280110817,
0.0368271209,
-0.0571427159,
0.0501703508,
-0.0188605487,
-0.0226872526,
-0.0042275554,
-0.0085566705,
0.0172591805,
-0.029027041,
0.0201409683,
0.0201143697,
-0.0314794406,
-0.0338059328,
0.0078549972,
0.0448633805,
-0.0357462279,
-0.009166142,
0.0406516567,
0.0108071342,
0.017648397,
0.0000022294,
-0.0504104607,
-0.0067212642,
-0.0164216571,
-0.009295769,
0.0580582544,
0.0732715353,
0.0047278753,
-0.0147955548,
0.0134180626,
-0.0361758433,
-0.0218606237,
0.0478438027,
0.007092,
0.0570233725,
0.0869320184,
0.0218144841,
-0.0180186871,
0.0268695634,
-0.0032485807,
0.0239089057,
-0.0477808677,
0.0073115667,
0.040810205,
0.0230604988,
0.0243786499,
-0.035049133,
0.0431125537,
0.0246217698,
0.0094545251,
-0.0062242756,
0.0142328516,
0.0082479334,
-0.0019536701,
-0.0119414618,
0.0593729578,
-0.0067106867,
-0.008227285,
-0.02543189,
-0.008431972,
0.0009350479,
-0.0124169374,
-0.0675092787,
0.0590754785,
0.0010480102,
0.0109263621,
0.0664855391,
-0.0492733195,
0.0119066043,
-0.0035061645,
-0.0159082226,
0.06712275,
0.046297662,
-0.0382552445,
-0.0172531027,
0.0157060102,
-0.0214935429,
-0.0547161251,
0.0023712467,
0.0299522951,
-0.0584602393,
0.0509551615,
-0.046531979,
0.0016889013,
0.0322218984,
-0.075148508,
0.0373046398,
0.0810900554,
-0.005742861,
0.0096501224,
-0.0187986642,
0.0901797488,
-0.0111457277,
0.0185675435,
-0.0964841172,
0.0310088601,
-0.0490222424,
0.0125340037,
-0.0183114242,
0.015718434,
-0.0509103499,
-0.0028861486,
-0.0854365081,
0.0290656313,
-0.0085759759,
0.0343949273,
0.0159955509,
-0.0363352112,
-0.0618032664,
-0.0076830578,
-0.0230759531,
0.0636684746,
-0.0334308445,
-0.0063719973,
0.0029895545,
-0.0499594323,
0.019797219,
0.024837343,
-0.0313210934,
-0.0278969072,
0.0068540941,
0.0571594089,
-0.0359820724,
-0.0142714335,
-0.042371057,
-0.0207544807,
0.0149839502,
-0.0552025735,
0.0076241405,
-0.0711848587,
0.0390817598,
0.0016313465,
-0.0015222086,
-0.0273969565,
0.0298222173,
0.0376839712,
0.0193071757,
0.0134271784,
0.0308584962,
-0.0024646856,
0.0171637125,
-0.0104806172,
-0.009718392,
0.0861292928,
0.0223536417,
0.0144156395,
0.0089793848,
-0.0223095622,
-0.0367556289,
0.0523411445,
0.0036890956,
0.0276646204,
-0.007655907,
0.0024390742,
0.0534222797,
0.0544663183,
0.0099743651,
0.0286217425,
-0.0097771995,
0.0160943475,
0.03407152,
-0.0015587497,
-0.0005939056,
0.0322148688,
0.0768781602,
0.02650786,
-0.0049346732,
0.0348518528,
-0.0580441132,
0.0331483781,
-0.0452043936,
0.0176328253,
0.0024970651,
0.056604173,
-0.0159960072,
-0.0548812598,
0.007135184,
0.013958496,
-0.030010758,
0.0308134444,
0.0293356013,
-0.0221269485,
-0.0464423373,
0.0478902757,
0.0614917912,
-0.0439583771,
0.0309043806,
-0.0305284057,
-0.0020386635,
0.0781099871,
0.0286808833,
0.0171721466,
-0.0760017782,
0.005122636,
-0.0000388953,
0.0689798295,
0.0618611388,
-0.0086020054,
-0.0286417995,
-0.0683175549,
-0.0210245848,
-0.0127712479,
-0.0136758182,
0.053442169,
-0.0070624123,
0.0176049657,
0.0176386442,
-0.0118397567,
-0.0473822951,
0.0415337048,
-0.0631305426,
-0.0777116418,
-0.0202595834,
-0.0073148604,
0.0288432632,
0.025721319,
-0.0027166884,
0.0151066398,
0.0120842438,
-0.0027237036,
0.0172586292,
-0.0041723074,
-0.0377521552,
-0.0272301212,
0.0768384114,
-0.0265707541,
-0.0144468406,
-0.0225659367,
-0.0454963818,
-0.0544186682,
-0.0005818508,
-0.0039381832,
-0.0048939576,
-0.01852048,
0.0621459261,
-0.0007698042,
-0.0040720035,
-0.0463556424,
0.0610021427,
0.0108824652,
0.0157086737,
0.0311459769,
0.0128769297,
0.0083390186,
-0.0441293418,
-0.0175565351,
0.0053156726,
0.0148683628,
0.0023392711,
0.0117205866,
0.0471744761,
-0.0779976547,
-0.0386763737,
-0.0852411762,
0.0507486947,
-0.0015304394,
0.0417262241,
0.0584782101,
-0.0128993737,
-0.0156259388,
0.0183659829,
-0.0699442849,
-0.0100528486,
0.0078496505,
-0.0004763131,
-0.0231713578,
0.0031064784,
-0.0375825539,
-0.0271365922,
-0.017706072,
-0.0198519249,
-0.0480860025,
0.0405132733,
0.0285755116,
-0.0820944533,
0.0560778044,
-0.0347459875,
-0.0002784537,
0.0243929047,
-0.0443411916,
0.0059388308,
-0.0240852907,
0.0531012602,
0.0449493788,
-0.0056231502,
-0.0076862299,
0.0582742132,
-0.0221385043,
-0.054092247,
0.018519707,
-0.0322735757,
-0.0367716253,
-0.0517085679,
-0.0766411349,
-0.0160780791,
0.0511348248,
0.0120567773,
-0.0130751915,
-0.0794116929,
-0.0301097259,
-0.055613175,
-0.0014508099,
-0.0321760625,
0.0408779345,
-0.0097279614,
0.0169621985,
-0.0198663734,
-0.0314077213,
0.0739659443,
-0.0364116766,
-0.0032885927,
-0.0848816633,
0.0127434423,
-0.0258081574,
0.011951291,
-0.0133715011,
0.017429648,
-0.0360822231,
-0.0011245975,
-0.0520967878,
0.0168621261,
0.0200291034,
-0.0348868221,
0.0300271716,
-0.0716946051,
-0.0182760116,
-0.029930884,
0.007912647,
-0.0254824031,
0.0239038952,
0.0179128647,
0.0015715471,
0.0300749037,
-0.0339238122,
-0.0115905004,
-0.0123156486,
0.0254651383,
-0.0015358147,
-0.0442285761,
-0.0077507133,
-0.0394827314,
-0.0208623447,
0.0346888527,
-0.0025622097,
-0.0057178233,
-0.058955159,
0.0216918383,
0.0220174827,
0.0854244977,
-0.0266772192,
0.0076113003,
0.0157098882,
0.056867931,
-0.057092946,
-0.0186446495,
0.0413968898,
0.0537551232,
-0.0611081906,
0.0041225553,
0.1227394268,
0.0205627717,
-0.0337537564,
-0.0195229594,
-0.0237315986,
0.0140796732,
0.0137378247,
0.0554620661,
-0.1018390954,
0.0143315354,
-0.0173667781,
0.0201365482,
0.0054672295,
0.0010319442,
-0.0116565349,
-0.1274856329,
0.0521471612,
0.0546301752,
-0.037094567,
-0.0214022752,
-0.0004194821,
-0.0204721671,
0.0034539835,
0.049681861,
0.0070285476,
-0.0052044932,
0.0121488534,
0.0434043892,
0.0417409539,
-0.0558048896,
0.0312365033,
-0.0337245949,
0.0495195687,
0.0221499857,
0.026998898,
0.0181415901,
-0.0757831633,
0.0096829357,
0.0048244791,
-0.0123647116,
-0.0266731866,
-0.011474546,
0.0119346185,
-0.0111749768,
-0.000097925,
-0.0123722916,
-0.0090995785,
0.0215830319,
0.0492419153,
0.1006881595,
-0.0164456889,
0.0269225389,
0.014850447,
0.0133141121,
-0.0016566805,
0.0445491076,
0.0141429612,
-0.0389971361,
0.0030505816,
-0.0340828709,
-0.0239130221,
-0.0614370033,
-0.0032957282,
0.0493196882,
-0.0697404742,
-0.0214626901,
-0.0672859102,
-0.042799484,
0.0500773229,
0.0410834514,
0.050072521,
0.0264028218,
0.0210617539,
-0.0335357636,
-0.0112879379,
0.0235717818,
-0.0447109267,
0.0186504759,
-0.0702461675,
-0.0694555193,
-0.014840465,
-0.0237968341,
0.0057709655,
0.0250715874,
-0.053739205,
-0.086215876,
0.0007605422,
0.066771701,
0.0107798306,
0.0364822634,
0.0257612038,
-0.007278407,
-0.047901269,
-0.0389235206,
0.0038162251,
0.0302197728,
-0.0069023124,
0.0073697185,
0.0024278662,
0.0105574699,
-0.0066397921,
0.0109931277,
0.0038643307,
0.0508867875,
-0.0112391263,
-0.0188907869,
0.0535943471,
0.0696434826,
-0.0140643725,
-0.0518192276,
-0.01496094,
-0.0271409322,
0.0178041868,
-0.0521971062,
-0.0086911665,
-0.0253071636,
-0.031000711,
0.054899361,
-0.0222517718,
0.0296278503,
0.01898757,
-0.0300242361,
-0.0257502403,
-0.0114534665,
0.0420481302,
-0.0184840932,
0.0418954007,
0.018273484,
0.017116515,
-0.0215909425,
-0.0299836434,
0.0317230672,
0.078856647,
-0.0137992185,
0.1093290672,
-0.0058663585,
0.007819267,
-0.0136416126,
0.0155689679,
0.0173670333,
-0.0425568558,
-0.0040356563,
0.0270788036,
0.0765704587,
0.0273850877,
0.0718953013,
-0.0355340801,
-0.0122156497,
-0.0038936299,
0.0346106738,
-0.0112764807,
-0.0328573659,
0.0314324014,
0.0119908843,
0.0214483105,
-0.0324144438,
0.0344522409,
-0.0040302421,
0.016460361,
-0.0058462787,
0.0183013175,
-0.0354952328,
-0.0287183542,
0.0206363145,
0.0011452283,
-0.0159508754,
-0.0024122349,
-0.0462528095,
-0.0483258739,
-0.041628018,
0.0530281439,
-0.0106289005,
-0.044801496,
0.0467561148,
0.0426241681,
-0.040529266,
-0.0215471499,
-0.048990272,
0.0166385435,
-0.0059755025,
-0.0231812894,
-0.0042176247,
-6.680930224e-33,
-0.0788829252,
-0.0050129648,
0.0851452723,
-0.016054159,
-0.0227978285,
-0.0424610414,
-0.0203979816,
0.0153219504,
-0.000344378,
-0.0038103717,
0.0120452624,
-0.020398194,
0.0115722939,
0.0052457107,
0.0237547345,
0.0050201332,
0.0205306783,
-0.0137185492,
-0.0059081181,
0.0558588654,
0.0299565736,
0.0036989793,
0.076904349,
-0.0315623097,
0.0327371657,
-0.0110269347,
0.0040425602,
0.0121425521,
-0.0499408469,
0.0322967134,
-0.0011064427,
0.0233437754,
-0.0005491087,
-0.036479298,
-0.0265803374,
-0.0007900708,
-0.0407868102,
-0.0523374826,
0.0530579649,
0.0392516218,
0.0049122926,
-0.0763844848,
0.0140907448,
-0.01364836,
-0.0474129431,
-0.0096397819,
0.0206968207,
-0.0270456616,
-0.0162134357,
0.0285564903,
-0.0873829424,
0.0118513787,
-0.016152069,
-0.0061197085,
-0.005497558,
0.0499930419,
-0.0167885683,
-0.0402815044,
-0.0149771282,
0.0244045872,
0.0544700772,
0.0449438542,
0.1006001607,
0.0333675444,
0.0042071193,
0.0064547812,
0.0519504808,
-0.0001376783,
0.0269111004,
0.0247080307,
0.0380669534,
-0.0002289958,
0.0332835726,
0.0408177637,
0.0126009667,
0.0076065552,
-0.0560132787,
0.0439361855,
0.0650619268,
0.0170332566,
0.0204973593,
-0.0200076103,
-0.0344563015,
-0.0191379953,
-0.0328295343,
0.0164229106,
-0.0279460941,
-0.055618789,
0.0494761616,
-0.0094268983,
-0.020388566,
-0.0448157005,
0.0367032364,
-0.0086678844,
-0.0009969107,
-0.0041833171,
-0.026771348,
0.0137595413,
-0.0426944494,
0.0211481322,
-0.0609618127,
-0.0653234273,
-0.01332107,
-0.04818004,
0.0069189342,
0.0114288386,
0.0050623142,
0.0135153951,
-0.0368741155,
0.0289967116,
-0.0617865995,
0.0053945477,
0.0392011069,
-0.0017755606,
0.0259998534,
0.0145143736,
-0.0009882421,
0.0365586951,
0.018489534,
-0.0372175053,
-0.0204651374,
-0.036619246,
-0.0035852995,
0.0280657783,
-0.0260298047,
0.0314973108,
-0.0448637158,
0.0264136121,
0.0057095741,
-0.0554306805,
-0.0215563439,
0.0426589586,
2.967e-7,
0.0499253534,
0.0522546992,
0.0081608864,
0.0367814153,
-0.0187635552,
-0.0007235133,
-0.0384012833,
-0.0159857124,
0.067893818,
0.0134909647,
0.0287144072,
0.0367242172,
0.04363361,
0.0232998598,
-0.0520247333,
-0.0321583785,
0.0151820295,
0.0352544263,
-0.0564283505,
0.0326813981,
0.0435642935,
0.0706126168,
-0.0120649869,
0.0028703171,
0.0051345685,
0.0021486545,
0.0543654375,
-0.0151143484,
-0.0434927605,
0.0320914425,
-0.0329772495,
0.0095466916,
-0.0381177217,
0.018671643,
-0.011685905,
0.000695977,
-0.0280663203,
0.0964404121,
0.0117407106,
0.0043226895,
0.0402694941,
-0.0015795814,
-0.025312949,
-0.0425079241,
0.0342966281,
-0.0196881592,
0.003650683,
-0.0035914772,
-0.0202400032,
-0.0054168785,
-0.0067012412,
-0.02316048,
-0.0010804994,
0.0390295833,
0.0225639865,
-0.0349812731,
-0.0236707292,
-0.0026776416,
-0.0217212643,
0.0455060862,
-0.020316191,
-0.0546589196,
-0.0430317521,
-0.0084311897,
-0.0257798489,
-0.0157379303,
-0.0129698804,
2.787890105e-34,
0.0224704538,
-0.0368779935,
0.0482582003,
0.0173676834,
0.0100618061,
-0.0218146872,
-0.0444196872,
0.0538306125,
0.0256584529,
-0.0721802637,
-0.0372347683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10964v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10964v1 | Multilingual Few-Shot Learning via Language Model Retrieval | 2023-06-19T14:27:21 | 2023-06-19T14:27:21 | Genta Indra Winata, Liang-Kang Huang, Soumya Vadlamannati, Yash Chandarana | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based language models have achieved remarkable success in
few-shot in-context learning and drawn a lot of research interest. However,
these models' performance greatly depends on the choice of the example prompts
and also has high variability depending on how samples are chosen. In this
paper, we conduct a comprehensive study of retrieving semantically similar
few-shot samples and using them as the context, as it helps the model decide
the correct label without any gradient update in the multilingual and
cross-lingual settings. We evaluate the proposed method on five natural
language understanding datasets related to intent detection, question
classification, sentiment analysis, and topic classification. The proposed
method consistently outperforms random sampling in monolingual and
cross-lingual tasks in non-English languages. | [
0.0220523085,
0.0262355655,
-0.0041880878,
0.0505658574,
-0.0500300005,
0.0223356467,
0.0504030436,
-0.0111725377,
0.0120417243,
-0.0668226704,
-0.0628526285,
-0.0668602586,
-0.0250066724,
-0.0364165641,
-0.0016068093,
-0.0212805606,
0.0362015888,
-0.0164553951,
0.0120530697,
0.0006318236,
-0.0033055185,
0.0201217439,
-0.0015657826,
0.0324326158,
0.019386014,
-0.0134333279,
0.0055503733,
0.0189185701,
0.0138396891,
-0.0109867398,
0.0231207591,
0.0372714028,
0.0238956138,
0.0369379446,
0.0000018782,
-0.0499379933,
-0.0468145981,
-0.0023479671,
-0.0273928884,
-0.0689819008,
0.080187507,
-0.0542431772,
0.0152672213,
0.0147025641,
-0.0320036188,
-0.0298462901,
0.0475687981,
0.0346141718,
0.0168617591,
0.0541000701,
-0.0182517599,
-0.046674069,
-0.0157347303,
-0.0135931531,
0.0452737696,
-0.0577891171,
0.0317474231,
-0.0053234487,
-0.0101674497,
0.0449918061,
-0.0159205366,
0.0382914282,
0.0042977873,
0.01324399,
-0.0390354544,
0.0146252699,
-0.0151407793,
-0.0257612523,
-0.01729968,
0.0653224364,
-0.0330396034,
-0.0164166372,
-0.0208060909,
-0.0138997249,
-0.0212531872,
-0.0051251468,
-0.0559429228,
0.0187210813,
-0.0079106875,
0.0044115549,
0.0221722014,
0.0003124106,
0.0161478743,
0.0001802658,
-0.0329466201,
0.0287874751,
0.0170444362,
-0.0127569558,
-0.0202019513,
0.0099139046,
0.0048212586,
-0.0222870726,
-0.0164743625,
0.021621637,
-0.0247124415,
0.0454596877,
-0.010824441,
-0.0385248624,
0.0224162266,
-0.0287878122,
0.0139402039,
0.0388610139,
-0.0388793088,
0.0921442136,
-0.0174394231,
0.0140424436,
0.0036104654,
0.0323915333,
-0.0584642626,
-0.0475057214,
-0.0710993931,
-0.0043076244,
-0.0536452718,
0.0378574468,
-0.01503231,
0.0241289958,
-0.0246650949,
0.0154863643,
0.0024324683,
-0.0029986866,
-0.0108025372,
-0.0413757302,
-0.0385840647,
-0.0142664406,
0.0176089704,
0.0993676186,
-0.0114429332,
0.0186156351,
-0.0141885551,
-0.0649727285,
-0.0264568217,
0.004297582,
0.024488166,
-0.0421506613,
0.0160427317,
0.039140135,
0.00224276,
-0.0921952501,
-0.0378038958,
-0.001453063,
-0.0280193631,
-0.0411444046,
-0.029549215,
-0.0644105375,
0.0587760098,
0.0131068369,
0.0041438481,
-0.0282336064,
0.0093005514,
0.0321634896,
-0.0288901385,
0.0960525274,
0.0066866032,
-0.0123366993,
0.0259195529,
-0.0041934322,
-0.0062003494,
0.107531473,
-0.0256741513,
0.0145960478,
0.073586829,
0.0128326248,
0.008788907,
0.0336823203,
0.0062358747,
0.0033575392,
-0.0115492465,
0.0182873793,
0.0229369774,
-0.0165749751,
-0.0122165009,
0.0223872103,
-0.0411811993,
-0.0039618104,
0.031048445,
0.042127803,
0.0096009001,
-0.0282993838,
0.0342505462,
0.0210894048,
-0.0471298322,
-0.0149165234,
-0.0045346087,
0.026343016,
-0.0226650424,
-0.0074309292,
-0.0058456636,
0.0349074602,
-0.0468043908,
-0.0131614413,
0.0070430688,
-0.0356830098,
-0.0051612351,
0.0344500244,
0.0965098813,
0.033267919,
-0.0367472544,
0.0594155118,
0.0447948799,
-0.0269994624,
-0.0164836925,
-0.0171605814,
0.0243065227,
0.0122223459,
0.004551087,
-0.0361690968,
-0.0484217815,
-0.0527561605,
0.0223413389,
0.014270802,
0.0445863046,
-0.0217196979,
0.0588676073,
-0.0377859622,
-0.0222522579,
-0.0085103633,
0.0021621652,
0.0318378955,
-0.016186405,
0.0225269329,
0.0056691421,
-0.0508285873,
0.0173069984,
0.0110350922,
-0.0513507016,
-0.0335816294,
0.047915902,
0.017237002,
0.0156125827,
0.0179428626,
-0.0077667465,
-0.0187930968,
0.0124623263,
-0.0423384234,
-0.0102640046,
0.0210994836,
-0.022754699,
-0.1104625389,
0.0145484749,
0.015585768,
-0.0207222737,
-0.010750398,
-0.0444789156,
-0.0363483466,
-0.0049305107,
0.0177224614,
0.0125052836,
-0.0400572009,
-0.0091482047,
-0.0271858573,
0.0149006359,
-0.0459699333,
0.0402876697,
0.0275326911,
0.0431040712,
0.0307391174,
-0.0088453665,
0.0423621275,
-0.0000097623,
-0.044798214,
0.0252368245,
-0.0243474916,
0.0063636308,
0.0490652509,
0.0259508826,
-0.0360432416,
-0.0136704911,
-0.0752867684,
0.0086443722,
-0.0342356972,
-0.0091001345,
0.0203811545,
0.0408045799,
0.006166026,
-0.0405446999,
-0.024281973,
-0.0120482808,
-0.014610908,
0.0476702824,
0.0241694823,
0.014928109,
0.0156709831,
-0.0181692876,
0.0055597476,
-0.0203962419,
0.0644572675,
-0.0105719958,
-0.0211999882,
-0.043972224,
0.0187222343,
-0.0157831255,
0.0083203157,
-0.0228696857,
-0.0164454188,
-0.0042770826,
-0.0363049768,
0.0189832039,
0.0601479486,
-0.0129082436,
0.0193748809,
0.0242325198,
0.0185897164,
-0.0635062382,
0.011381832,
-0.0227036495,
-0.0233734455,
-0.0154313436,
-0.0263914205,
0.0213641915,
0.0680591092,
0.0111788055,
-0.0037114827,
-0.045007199,
0.0027803772,
-0.0275027454,
-0.001009102,
-0.0727364048,
0.062053781,
0.003755501,
0.0318390802,
-0.0072579482,
0.0016527411,
0.081017442,
-0.0051394501,
-0.0254560225,
-0.072877489,
-0.0137915015,
-0.0183912944,
0.0503736176,
-0.0160380155,
0.0382976346,
0.0370759591,
-0.0114280405,
-0.053728912,
-0.0111671565,
0.0259873383,
-0.0123005044,
0.0436439849,
0.0082827238,
0.0162298474,
-0.0265331529,
-0.0514421463,
-0.0354661718,
-0.0745429546,
-0.0337062925,
0.0181914922,
-0.0321014561,
0.0275622681,
-0.0182549339,
0.0179194305,
0.0576938093,
0.0293488558,
-0.021479765,
-0.0312271509,
-0.0035829407,
0.0560795926,
0.0541552752,
-0.0387747437,
-0.0039858809,
-0.0098363832,
0.0818587169,
0.015920803,
0.0178719405,
0.0092932507,
-0.002242056,
-0.0177518036,
0.0549815595,
0.0017897442,
-0.0110748289,
-0.0014609658,
0.0651896521,
-0.0209548585,
-0.0384342782,
0.1055805758,
0.0200251602,
-0.0868396834,
-0.0382250808,
-0.0486888997,
-0.0272771791,
0.0392260477,
0.0282929055,
-0.0946681574,
-0.0608060807,
-0.0205243006,
0.0161063559,
0.0053497115,
0.0015152614,
-0.0116168354,
-0.1309739053,
0.0188230183,
-0.0207770914,
-0.0760135874,
-0.0074173105,
-0.0568979569,
0.0074404394,
-0.0172854476,
0.0184437949,
0.0017200803,
0.0078319991,
-0.0168429613,
-0.0140069854,
0.0396009684,
-0.0622395538,
0.0411432311,
-0.0166805331,
0.0226820018,
0.0300476495,
0.0206465498,
-0.0180936363,
-0.0013371611,
0.0060613654,
-0.0318123922,
-0.0109444037,
-0.0053172526,
0.0379240029,
-0.0172304064,
-0.0311528165,
0.0247526355,
-0.0011423832,
-0.0376696959,
-0.0283208322,
-0.0074543227,
0.0518287197,
-0.0062482888,
0.0067972918,
0.006774195,
-0.0157594066,
0.0337185524,
0.1043440774,
0.0125602623,
-0.0614914484,
0.0230541825,
-0.0193244331,
0.0172944367,
-0.0395468697,
-0.0236660521,
0.012096758,
-0.016361,
-0.0136553943,
-0.0357934646,
-0.0497930124,
0.0382873081,
0.04021677,
-0.0155661739,
0.0254882034,
0.0236499216,
-0.0082205273,
-0.0181125551,
-0.0041779028,
-0.0388608687,
0.0095339902,
-0.0188273452,
-0.0050279489,
0.0726825744,
-0.0426173359,
-0.0155194961,
-0.0242575631,
-0.0854656324,
-0.0391679481,
-0.0117294304,
0.0572781675,
0.0066418303,
0.0435718633,
-0.0240994561,
-0.0189648066,
0.0082608135,
0.0605244339,
0.0046745506,
-0.0217841286,
0.0244121347,
0.0431958884,
-0.0219302792,
0.0471485108,
-0.0692430362,
0.0299205165,
0.0373740979,
0.0404111929,
-0.076969929,
-0.010497489,
0.0385156199,
-0.0066598551,
0.0801376551,
-0.0019723952,
-0.0335075408,
-0.0209014192,
0.0170781352,
-0.0057168696,
-0.0380981974,
-0.0252746642,
-0.0234917775,
0.0101944944,
-0.0775989965,
-0.0094272355,
0.0002130951,
-0.0368360505,
0.0479931273,
-0.0186127126,
-0.0037017809,
0.0526533835,
0.0131690009,
0.0033042596,
0.0068615037,
-0.0161133911,
0.0072287885,
0.0301286187,
0.0180133022,
-0.0476686247,
0.0847998559,
0.0139324991,
-0.0319581814,
0.0006080503,
0.0245014224,
-0.0488120429,
-0.0157867111,
0.0033378962,
-0.007143436,
0.0564939752,
-0.0278047863,
0.0223886091,
0.0101236217,
-0.0111868409,
-0.0242097918,
0.0383627228,
0.0041753878,
-0.0419111997,
0.060562551,
0.0222921614,
-0.0042441427,
0.0173667129,
0.0952532738,
-0.0481162332,
0.0246297084,
0.0350891463,
0.0214186069,
-0.0330769978,
0.0379061773,
0.0395954624,
0.0057372176,
-0.0059457398,
-0.0072620544,
-0.0473671034,
-0.0388183855,
0.0286544375,
-0.0514462478,
-0.019789584,
0.0133768907,
0.0145667037,
0.0893932134,
0.0131720304,
0.0197409615,
-0.060642004,
0.0159790237,
-0.0067553548,
-0.0118636331,
-0.0069697504,
-6.103988781e-33,
-0.0198631156,
-0.0029821293,
0.0098560266,
-0.027844971,
0.047428418,
0.0038504726,
-0.0389085226,
-0.0067568012,
-0.0531043522,
0.0034675992,
-0.0038822216,
0.0126601867,
0.0106620044,
0.0476797074,
0.0076255384,
-0.0288444534,
0.038844265,
0.0064323638,
-0.0018369331,
0.0077530527,
0.049941469,
0.0542514287,
0.0899849012,
-0.0220309552,
0.0160284899,
-0.0052799056,
0.0044736736,
0.0263918489,
0.054047931,
0.0625823662,
0.0105427075,
0.062493477,
0.0371906608,
-0.089184612,
0.0029213212,
0.0140649313,
-0.0598451197,
-0.0476956069,
-0.0088984799,
0.0267499946,
0.0043649147,
-0.0135506615,
0.0052228197,
-0.0493758246,
0.0379621834,
-0.0092021469,
0.0127947805,
-0.0123954043,
-0.0225967597,
-0.0503984913,
-0.0503430441,
-0.0026491727,
0.003628541,
-0.0324452892,
0.0263238773,
0.0927756801,
0.0151333474,
0.0789880231,
-0.0659552589,
0.0066134688,
-0.0550129786,
0.0118532293,
0.0136847384,
0.0136390971,
0.0006366771,
0.0488342494,
0.0107465237,
0.0122110751,
0.017494794,
-0.0180489384,
0.0384559482,
0.0118688326,
0.0089054229,
0.1187757254,
0.0264814142,
-0.00475968,
-0.0832090452,
0.0287733264,
0.0340848155,
0.0369092077,
0.0332879052,
-0.0007912668,
-0.018344216,
-0.0090778777,
-0.042213507,
-0.0659802258,
-0.0547271967,
-0.0109752379,
0.006335895,
0.0055923937,
-0.0236326531,
0.004096956,
0.0927897915,
-0.0680018365,
-0.0212456286,
0.0521387607,
-0.0221808869,
0.0169091746,
0.0068237474,
0.0461289361,
-0.0514372997,
-0.0225472376,
-0.012425513,
0.0357441008,
0.0011364659,
0.0420580693,
0.0680356622,
0.0015329116,
-0.0627469346,
-0.0093434472,
-0.0298020113,
-0.0072198706,
-0.0357264578,
0.0374912396,
0.0109289521,
0.0475537553,
-0.0141806724,
0.0737761185,
0.0477997325,
-0.0348599404,
0.004706468,
-0.0150034828,
-0.0296038594,
0.0213056337,
-0.0247341879,
-0.0035943983,
0.002749572,
0.0157971717,
0.0305277798,
-0.0499157086,
-0.0036534707,
0.0158751979,
2.673e-7,
0.0426901691,
0.049685128,
-0.0460229218,
0.0212599542,
0.0101074707,
0.0742464215,
-0.0213648546,
0.0140023557,
0.0176493973,
-0.0055610891,
-0.0032087089,
-0.0035867007,
0.0071345638,
0.0367704853,
-0.1045323908,
0.0389323719,
-0.0282549765,
0.0182558987,
-0.007229866,
0.0169182755,
0.0653683543,
0.1314075738,
0.0076173106,
-0.0001300472,
-0.0369314365,
-0.0429136753,
0.0761613622,
-0.0375747494,
-0.0112206126,
0.014840371,
-0.0072991825,
0.0139438184,
0.0162172746,
-0.0008667223,
-0.0290133748,
0.0074633453,
0.0005629247,
0.0453759916,
0.0001760315,
-0.0477311984,
-0.0046618972,
-0.0059043625,
-0.0042887386,
-0.0733216256,
0.0984822735,
-0.0935802013,
-0.0131751746,
-0.0511284173,
-0.019036971,
0.0146137169,
0.0342190079,
-0.0141981328,
-0.0487353764,
0.0243165903,
0.0352270827,
0.0098251337,
-0.0159958191,
-0.0584633388,
0.009913424,
0.0101729557,
0.0147598926,
0.0137143163,
0.0085418262,
-0.0398884453,
0.013942604,
-0.067304045,
0.0259638242,
2.166075864e-34,
0.0171809401,
-0.0099532045,
-0.0136518618,
0.036155127,
-0.0100621758,
-0.0330170318,
-0.0430035219,
-0.0050439653,
0.0187654179,
-0.0579469465,
0.0041864617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10869v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10869v1 | Grammatical gender in Swedish is predictable using recurrent neural networks | 2023-06-19T11:42:47 | 2023-06-19T11:42:47 | Edvin Listo Zec, Olof Mogren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The grammatical gender of Swedish nouns is a mystery. While there are few
rules that can indicate the gender with some certainty, it does in general not
depend on either meaning or the structure of the word. In this paper we
demonstrate the surprising fact that grammatical gender for Swedish nouns can
be predicted with high accuracy using a recurrent neural network (RNN) working
on the raw character sequence of the word, without using any contextual
information. | [
0.0249186587,
0.0485261157,
-0.0093520964,
0.0718591586,
-0.0270252954,
-0.0248517133,
-0.0192837566,
-0.0204115864,
-0.0671174601,
-0.0214064047,
0.0367047414,
-0.0967222005,
0.0727932379,
-0.0006865589,
0.0353717022,
-0.0132506359,
0.0206527822,
-0.0349932127,
-0.0179937743,
-0.0226976182,
-0.0060755862,
0.0277719088,
-0.0022211573,
0.0538058206,
0.0137484269,
-0.0122858044,
-0.0004568029,
-0.0152876703,
-0.0358202383,
-0.005740826,
0.0338654481,
0.0197452847,
-0.022311369,
0.0776656196,
0.0000013475,
-0.0583229214,
0.0536031984,
-0.0355258659,
-0.018001819,
0.0335584208,
0.0025468073,
0.0168664753,
-0.0128979953,
0.000533792,
-0.0058866525,
-0.0320749842,
0.0500633754,
0.0366247855,
0.0097773243,
0.0246982481,
0.0060134185,
-0.0592649654,
-0.0172477309,
-0.0574980304,
-0.0209340099,
0.0146518499,
0.0410380848,
-0.028230723,
-0.0170307104,
-0.0279128402,
-0.0421856679,
0.019469548,
0.0040127779,
0.0158988219,
-0.050947804,
0.0464203507,
0.0069535989,
-0.0290011782,
0.020827638,
0.0742006749,
-0.031124372,
0.0020283218,
0.0047667581,
0.0206375588,
-0.0246712212,
-0.031761162,
0.0118370717,
0.0225884505,
-0.0025520884,
-0.0079784933,
0.0672024935,
-0.0388341881,
0.0338171497,
0.0498115569,
-0.0171063393,
0.0748536512,
-0.0142800659,
-0.0337272808,
0.030542722,
-0.0129209356,
0.0067158239,
-0.0510050431,
-0.0055097323,
0.0269545522,
0.0024095927,
0.0122980522,
0.0067276717,
-0.0793618485,
0.0266491026,
-0.068774946,
0.0197832491,
-0.0014858879,
-0.0015958261,
0.0100291371,
-0.030970782,
0.0110892775,
-0.0258781034,
-0.0389054529,
-0.0129946591,
-0.0266697053,
-0.0289397743,
-0.0342729576,
-0.0364510529,
0.0347136855,
-0.007219865,
0.0074110585,
-0.066766426,
-0.0176529754,
0.0029537452,
-0.0190548394,
-0.0159043986,
0.0429596044,
-0.0594002903,
0.0365294404,
-0.0203951616,
0.0074457517,
-0.0112334471,
0.0166613497,
-0.0422030762,
-0.0209370479,
0.032831043,
0.0090826852,
0.0273697376,
-0.0078794854,
-0.0014730126,
0.0348266102,
0.0300354846,
0.0007775701,
-0.0216719452,
-0.0541207679,
-0.0155133838,
-0.072434485,
0.0080845077,
-0.0625747219,
-0.0069832997,
-0.0085844612,
-0.0407932103,
-0.0281107724,
0.043575611,
0.0048219101,
0.0053575728,
0.0909453481,
0.0408867635,
-0.0159855615,
0.017821297,
-0.0126155624,
0.0115274452,
0.0387588553,
0.0271006618,
0.0416506827,
0.0230336692,
-0.0261262767,
0.0436940864,
0.0616549514,
0.001395839,
-0.0508811101,
-0.0357073583,
-0.0183120705,
-0.0032775609,
0.0658734068,
0.0283369385,
0.013360179,
0.0561413392,
-0.0277767088,
0.0319613479,
0.0826612636,
0.0529436432,
0.0648134872,
0.0753315091,
-0.0012807805,
-0.0223937929,
-0.004062973,
-0.024594117,
-0.0135223307,
-0.0143846869,
0.031575121,
-0.0654910877,
0.0281229261,
-0.0037296722,
-0.0498667397,
-0.0066017457,
-0.003506986,
0.007500167,
-0.004201869,
0.0287601277,
0.013370296,
-0.0296961237,
0.0324369147,
0.0040384065,
-0.008485835,
0.0151937017,
0.0018590287,
0.0467303768,
0.0043993508,
0.0059867273,
-0.0351056121,
-0.0579521507,
-0.0539785028,
-0.0153125124,
0.0182322524,
0.0536618643,
-0.0107259778,
0.0609465614,
-0.0475272387,
0.0387471728,
0.0821082145,
0.0141883064,
0.0759011731,
-0.0307003707,
0.059322793,
0.0124208545,
-0.0163939856,
-0.0606576726,
0.0287181661,
-0.0281803105,
-0.0238988586,
0.0522444434,
0.0289989077,
0.0362145677,
0.027398305,
0.0031097305,
0.034832105,
0.0407697,
-0.0499336608,
-0.0530017614,
0.0577766374,
-0.0228579491,
-0.0413520299,
0.0175521467,
-0.0278133433,
-0.0458091348,
0.0247644186,
-0.0180998184,
-0.0276789442,
0.1260919273,
-0.0387652889,
-0.0105323819,
-0.0321839713,
-0.0140058817,
0.0239786096,
0.0948396251,
0.0212200657,
-0.0174430944,
-0.0405777134,
0.0316637121,
-0.0320280418,
-0.0366029553,
-0.0188522972,
-0.0925733894,
-0.0550658554,
0.07785815,
-0.0048857681,
0.0125608025,
-0.0026568854,
-0.0206124429,
-0.0032737362,
-0.0270369407,
0.0030927169,
-0.0074144821,
-0.0258715004,
0.036667686,
-0.0139879528,
0.0195678081,
0.0073537477,
-0.0351146385,
-0.0528593175,
0.0190737676,
0.0177359302,
0.0275928192,
0.0747270584,
0.0076144272,
-0.0219867472,
-0.0181580335,
-0.0448676199,
-0.0362006314,
0.0390483253,
-0.0038621544,
-0.0409860723,
-0.0347375646,
-0.0041158721,
-0.0124974018,
0.0488144904,
-0.0064844899,
-0.0590729266,
0.0032101201,
0.0004032855,
0.0558313914,
0.0628919452,
-0.0137427226,
-0.0083450777,
-0.0013995357,
-0.0178376473,
-0.0079558706,
0.0002614266,
-0.0273306612,
0.0391008034,
-0.0073064263,
-0.0398434065,
-0.0175748989,
0.0679246262,
-0.0122603681,
-0.0000075143,
0.0036472958,
0.0471878424,
-0.0110965362,
0.0139367012,
-0.04605655,
-0.0019384724,
-0.0047163269,
0.0634569377,
-0.0245872512,
0.0119645149,
0.0532367006,
-0.0254844483,
-0.026512729,
-0.0143680722,
-0.040632762,
-0.0658024251,
0.0613645278,
-0.0030633959,
-0.011452063,
0.0114901969,
-0.029667275,
-0.0350099728,
-0.0629488006,
0.0035114428,
-0.0210687704,
0.0302351303,
-0.0304141231,
-0.0312128719,
0.0091134813,
-0.0258212052,
-0.0123624867,
-0.0208424982,
-0.0584174059,
-0.0029137477,
-0.0693820938,
-0.0196225997,
-0.0166287255,
0.0139003005,
-0.0321706496,
0.0200371835,
-0.0223917905,
0.0176415276,
-0.0425738692,
0.0424514413,
0.006426645,
0.0235058144,
-0.0135234697,
0.0341596454,
0.009140647,
-0.0085846446,
-0.0363585576,
0.0587157458,
-0.0331670009,
-0.0061626048,
0.0194304362,
-0.0197393224,
-0.0393924601,
-0.0277732555,
-0.0262760874,
-0.1000130847,
0.0168263726,
0.0571778603,
-0.016441511,
0.0013376443,
0.0102048069,
0.0273556188,
-0.0091868276,
0.0366560221,
0.0410275683,
-0.0336170457,
-0.0144027835,
0.0084882807,
0.0038890273,
-0.0025373038,
-0.0620824285,
-0.0394520983,
-0.1065585762,
0.0177943408,
0.0016767713,
-0.0738986805,
-0.0506765097,
-0.0018918618,
-0.0386714749,
-0.061167676,
-0.0128390901,
0.006531415,
-0.0043369741,
0.0146995131,
0.0256445762,
-0.0733692423,
-0.016675882,
0.0331999362,
-0.0691400319,
0.0258223955,
0.0649597645,
0.046538841,
-0.0771723986,
-0.05010226,
0.0329803526,
-0.017802313,
-0.0257964022,
-0.004781927,
0.0219688676,
-0.0081924917,
-0.0208231639,
-0.0519615486,
0.0497806333,
-0.0177845359,
0.0099159908,
0.0068714824,
0.0774126053,
0.0434003137,
-0.0518119894,
0.0141883809,
0.0036873887,
0.0277154632,
0.0331303291,
0.022937268,
-0.0400518477,
-0.0518167205,
-0.0557437092,
-0.0092061143,
-0.0247709248,
-0.0078335553,
-0.0241736006,
0.0336560719,
-0.0358914696,
-0.0669888854,
-0.0722867921,
0.0319698676,
0.0238795336,
0.0260389131,
-0.0203410219,
0.0296684578,
0.0071297167,
-0.0866508111,
-0.0008653415,
0.0380330496,
0.0237854496,
0.0002649286,
0.02479502,
0.0629115328,
-0.0229141358,
-0.0086475108,
-0.0138163706,
-0.0218566582,
-0.0796525404,
0.0400460064,
0.0213945229,
0.0158158895,
0.0713065118,
-0.0274631977,
-0.0622822046,
0.012466534,
0.0169036519,
-0.0062181964,
0.0153955435,
0.0654112399,
0.0534754507,
0.0010844006,
0.0234958977,
0.0116889477,
0.0184233189,
-0.0168227833,
-0.0403158478,
0.0031042199,
-0.0119917048,
-0.011707182,
0.0388115309,
0.0046718838,
-0.0447644554,
0.0178938732,
-0.0561016351,
0.0087946672,
0.047404252,
-0.0133541133,
0.0036926921,
-0.0060340827,
0.0242705978,
0.0182687361,
-0.0279652495,
-0.0125921015,
-0.0187562983,
-0.0157394614,
0.0098765716,
0.0166681428,
0.0631503388,
0.0285270419,
0.0235780589,
0.0400079601,
0.0148057695,
0.0267877355,
-0.0065179756,
0.0684555694,
-0.0234630127,
-0.0136225158,
0.0037597055,
0.042152252,
-0.0400349833,
-0.0086438609,
-0.0298970267,
0.0389497802,
-0.0057645226,
-0.0208859928,
0.0354034416,
-0.0365738459,
0.0096598696,
-0.0356359333,
0.0324758701,
-0.0090996213,
0.0479022041,
-0.0267888382,
-0.0061424617,
0.037353836,
0.0217393544,
-0.0287134051,
0.0052960897,
0.0356838033,
0.0393157899,
0.0541503467,
0.0350894667,
0.0023699286,
-0.0222017877,
0.0257836487,
0.0110884858,
-0.0360130593,
-0.0280690379,
0.0095509654,
-0.0671194568,
-0.0629933551,
0.0524077415,
-0.0093020014,
0.0353052579,
0.0150640486,
-0.0049986322,
0.0390002169,
0.0459636673,
0.0085501336,
-0.0594765618,
0.0227830913,
-0.016310716,
-0.0495107807,
-0.0495631769,
-5.362200418e-33,
-0.005537163,
-0.0235259552,
-0.0179366618,
0.0110831894,
0.0194084961,
0.0175956264,
-0.0160650834,
-0.0193645265,
0.0257199723,
0.0324545354,
-0.0178977363,
0.0102149453,
0.0233632922,
0.0140108876,
0.0243608374,
-0.0388502479,
0.0508935712,
0.0037063176,
0.033432994,
-0.0550543033,
-0.0004121522,
0.0647196174,
0.1134736016,
-0.0144446203,
0.0468525551,
-0.0235303789,
-0.0186781418,
0.0486445054,
0.003497354,
0.0150277633,
-0.0260789208,
0.0594099164,
0.0306753218,
-0.0311371386,
0.0024238853,
0.0404562205,
-0.0773082897,
-0.0700098351,
-0.0047746748,
0.0394987874,
-0.0236960258,
-0.0054889754,
0.0628748015,
-0.0235191863,
-0.0172106642,
0.0446571149,
0.0333549306,
0.0327778794,
0.0103344284,
0.0017327976,
-0.0261745919,
-0.0027430386,
-0.0263931006,
0.0001228675,
0.059654206,
-0.0005753787,
0.0008644015,
-0.0311330967,
-0.0974089876,
0.0175539199,
-0.0215207804,
0.0083283531,
0.0183746498,
0.0428204723,
-0.0097266575,
0.003909539,
0.0956982598,
0.0313789696,
-0.0602026619,
0.022632543,
0.0473209545,
-0.0048118304,
0.0714691505,
0.0368886665,
0.0935310051,
-0.0084800664,
-0.0567777939,
-0.0393663272,
0.0418553129,
0.0612770058,
-0.000924379,
-0.0678510666,
-0.0539684817,
-0.0314976797,
-0.0171272904,
-0.0846530646,
-0.0251045525,
0.0136595415,
0.0117657306,
-0.0335702263,
-0.0032719912,
0.0128800534,
-0.0262017865,
-0.0563742258,
-0.0167398881,
0.0012904529,
0.0260204896,
-0.0198386163,
0.0088231917,
0.0154218236,
-0.0272752419,
-0.0113881482,
-0.0332547873,
0.0397747755,
0.0268922541,
0.020271901,
0.0431840681,
0.0096147489,
-0.0516966768,
-0.0170846712,
-0.0472661331,
0.0345366895,
0.0314190425,
0.0296966024,
0.0251917001,
0.0176726896,
-0.0294788517,
0.000829965,
0.0401543379,
0.0243801866,
-0.0424255989,
-0.0351175703,
0.0082618529,
0.0518448018,
-0.0297142435,
-0.0464771278,
0.0159641746,
0.0128669823,
0.0464219525,
0.0003525029,
0.0103832353,
-0.0194825362,
2.175e-7,
0.0178212449,
0.0364236943,
0.0555669926,
-0.0121934889,
0.0065914621,
0.0197056197,
-0.0170081891,
0.0355144814,
-0.0025859703,
0.0056928112,
0.0068325372,
-0.0081257634,
0.0058959746,
0.0390771739,
-0.1132037714,
-0.0307779033,
-0.0450141281,
0.0458306111,
-0.0262256302,
0.001980305,
-0.0127078705,
0.1336953342,
0.0566358119,
-0.0138759706,
-0.0370023958,
-0.0469593965,
-0.0118664065,
0.0210583899,
0.0202455763,
-0.0036634011,
0.0446128696,
0.0071309637,
0.02982831,
-0.0317549109,
0.0129140206,
0.0356752574,
-0.0001643646,
-0.0132282143,
-0.0205863789,
-0.0010993163,
-0.0084720599,
-0.0117137227,
-0.0480686799,
0.0169852804,
0.014234785,
-0.0587486066,
-0.0741826966,
0.0026126006,
0.0387415029,
0.0650554672,
0.0614352152,
-0.0153114423,
0.00339521,
0.0256617349,
0.0225205775,
-0.0404213034,
-0.0185411479,
-0.0444157049,
-0.0397035703,
0.0026280922,
-0.0072777299,
0.0125302412,
-0.0088604521,
0.0071729273,
0.0305539221,
-0.0270023812,
0.0140081495,
1.142108934e-34,
0.0258769896,
0.0212046802,
-0.0411098301,
0.0318255089,
0.0058517721,
-0.0122862319,
0.02504104,
0.0429275446,
0.036392305,
0.0094461683,
-0.044786945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.17181v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.17181v4 | Unsupervised Text Embedding Space Generation Using Generative Adversarial Networks for Text Synthesis | 2023-06-19T10:22:12 | 2023-10-17T10:41:12 | Jun-Min Lee, Tae-Bin Ha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Generative Adversarial Networks (GAN) is a model for data synthesis, which
creates plausible data through the competition of generator and discriminator.
Although GAN application to image synthesis is extensively studied, it has
inherent limitations to natural language generation. Because natural language
is composed of discrete tokens, a generator has difficulty updating its
gradient through backpropagation; therefore, most text-GAN studies generate
sentences starting with a random token based on a reward system. Thus, the
generators of previous studies are pre-trained in an autoregressive way before
adversarial training, causing data memorization that synthesized sentences
reproduce the training data. In this paper, we synthesize sentences using a
framework similar to the original GAN. More specifically, we propose Text
Embedding Space Generative Adversarial Networks (TESGAN) which generate
continuous text embedding spaces instead of discrete tokens to solve the
gradient backpropagation problem. Furthermore, TESGAN conducts unsupervised
learning which does not directly refer to the text of the training data to
overcome the data memorization issue. By adopting this novel method, TESGAN can
synthesize new sentences, showing the potential of unsupervised learning for
text synthesis. We expect to see extended research combining Large Language
Models with a new perspective of viewing text as an continuous space. | [
0.0198890958,
0.076331757,
-0.0131809535,
0.0214970727,
-0.0043390151,
-0.0053196764,
0.0189141687,
-0.0088222455,
0.0183177851,
-0.0194490906,
0.0053097662,
-0.0276989788,
-0.0001143481,
0.0422441959,
0.0751889423,
-0.0693212748,
-0.0023578114,
0.0203000382,
-0.0028233842,
-0.0193570163,
-0.0052726865,
0.0066880505,
0.0016128718,
0.0303804427,
-0.0451408699,
-0.0220147092,
-0.0086445203,
-0.0113638546,
0.0365786962,
-0.0216335747,
0.005501254,
0.0097557539,
0.0150772119,
0.035959743,
0.0000019508,
0.0051291455,
0.022140149,
-0.0237600878,
0.0080115739,
0.0067696953,
0.0317993872,
-0.015002857,
-0.0235363394,
0.0132085467,
-0.0642087311,
-0.0671627745,
0.034605585,
0.0537156835,
0.0747286528,
0.0726188347,
-0.0343425199,
-0.0668165237,
0.0277433172,
-0.0652187467,
0.0256018229,
0.0059551154,
-0.0138222259,
0.016514428,
-0.014258028,
0.0244097505,
-0.0400898941,
0.0415532887,
0.0565422662,
-0.0343866646,
0.0330588035,
0.0856355578,
0.0042320918,
0.0003589443,
-0.0052071977,
0.0479437038,
-0.0486844108,
-0.0331241265,
0.0110180294,
-0.0240536146,
0.0129098417,
-0.0296864323,
-0.0297107529,
0.0280270539,
-0.0056708413,
0.0399315655,
-0.0308954418,
0.007546701,
0.0186510533,
-0.0307886824,
-0.0094364118,
-0.0409043357,
0.0201776288,
-0.0064635966,
-0.0550059527,
-0.0160250776,
-0.0372282527,
-0.0701277629,
0.015376484,
0.0295283385,
-0.0103204744,
-0.0122266682,
-0.0756556019,
-0.0323889926,
-0.0074187405,
-0.0109107215,
0.0307526495,
-0.0007117514,
0.0049640196,
0.0095778452,
-0.0693777278,
0.0590802059,
-0.0306882877,
-0.0053175814,
-0.0567273907,
0.0106062302,
-0.0354672186,
-0.0638167709,
-0.0356846005,
0.0311967954,
-0.0359710231,
-0.0674362779,
-0.043421492,
0.0484365225,
0.003655761,
0.0408509672,
0.0013259723,
0.0660233051,
-0.0609345622,
-0.0047965162,
0.0002977471,
-0.0645656958,
-0.0201347135,
0.0156431105,
0.0326970071,
-0.0168905854,
-0.0140915737,
0.0352830142,
0.0198616572,
0.0313238092,
-0.0174222738,
0.0937508717,
-0.0530363768,
0.0302157402,
-0.0311988909,
-0.0319667943,
-0.0264661573,
-0.0439649448,
0.0389784947,
-0.031504862,
0.0113037648,
-0.0256340429,
-0.0350733809,
-0.0590270273,
0.0081582842,
0.0187288411,
0.0157985333,
0.0577554069,
0.0058709346,
-0.029107675,
0.0419442765,
-0.0026599711,
0.0577935129,
0.0202280562,
0.0557784736,
0.0853360891,
-0.0120823896,
0.0221322291,
0.0305722933,
0.0101904692,
0.0354482755,
-0.0104004983,
-0.0509868674,
-0.0149219669,
-0.0112301307,
0.0615628101,
0.0101942029,
0.050361935,
-0.0226444304,
0.0065912567,
0.0388080031,
0.0234695207,
0.0378475152,
0.0552839004,
0.0733564124,
0.0086988872,
-0.0077437158,
0.0345027931,
0.0140392361,
0.0491932072,
0.0340178721,
0.0255967434,
0.0299361218,
0.0294218585,
-0.0462431014,
-0.0477823354,
0.0470147282,
0.0020915959,
-0.0155742606,
-0.0653769001,
0.024203727,
0.0592360087,
-0.0640059784,
-0.0377477072,
-0.0252798088,
-0.0474988557,
0.0148426909,
-0.0061919857,
0.0467600264,
0.0716048256,
0.0439873524,
0.0039911931,
0.0351714231,
-0.0103665199,
0.0066536502,
0.0527221113,
0.0034868964,
0.0023336986,
0.0017680713,
-0.0549542792,
-0.008877134,
-0.0591777526,
0.0064896788,
0.0417036004,
-0.0174050275,
0.0379344486,
0.0302062072,
-0.015177764,
-0.0141227357,
0.0631360486,
-0.0290187225,
-0.0428967886,
0.0351203866,
0.0044341544,
0.0112900259,
-0.002338548,
-0.0234666131,
0.0275344122,
0.0062857829,
-0.0664957166,
-0.0557612963,
0.017093651,
-0.0631990284,
-0.1140254885,
-0.0192494094,
-0.0810663253,
0.0128250644,
-0.0017052842,
-0.0397947282,
-0.0428671949,
0.0351239145,
-0.0449198112,
0.0034633456,
-0.0655732751,
-0.0289781727,
0.0395132676,
0.0233892743,
-0.0124740507,
0.044507511,
-0.0174893402,
-0.01117412,
0.0219889041,
0.0576830693,
0.045124162,
-0.023750633,
0.0131232115,
-0.0019643644,
0.0101064341,
0.0092348978,
0.0229690168,
0.0232042912,
0.0026870959,
-0.0341537893,
-0.0370031595,
0.0064222235,
-0.0076170745,
-0.0198382735,
0.034968622,
0.0085643418,
0.0069734352,
-0.0085790521,
-0.0589012839,
0.0108409179,
0.0227768496,
-0.0332709402,
0.0680952966,
-0.0053801732,
0.0298498105,
-0.0026720287,
0.0092923231,
0.0302149653,
0.085243471,
0.0203695558,
-0.0093905032,
-0.0465761833,
0.0000336393,
-0.0001698443,
0.0178969931,
-0.0176852625,
-0.0473083965,
0.0161119569,
0.0188943464,
0.0833797902,
0.0964885727,
0.0433593616,
0.0399809256,
0.0069003645,
0.0240730867,
-0.026345022,
-0.0137464553,
-0.042507004,
0.0327206552,
0.0323585011,
-0.0274388622,
0.0426919237,
0.0403432287,
0.0539462343,
0.000475321,
-0.0625109598,
0.0591869913,
0.0184184741,
-0.0541100278,
-0.0270345844,
0.0080828974,
-0.0406948812,
-0.0337963961,
-0.0335953385,
-0.0752716511,
0.0281865485,
-0.0325073153,
0.0001341007,
0.0073964144,
-0.0086606303,
0.0119716721,
0.0371987112,
0.049423974,
0.0480180085,
0.0361535624,
0.0008308668,
-0.0520154312,
0.0237730257,
0.020981377,
-0.0181287024,
-0.0112579009,
0.0011075699,
-0.0113995075,
0.0005681384,
-0.0035312695,
-0.0691106096,
-0.0284270477,
0.0457314663,
0.0038975836,
0.0281505473,
-0.0249973554,
-0.0019281604,
-0.0117270136,
0.0065362691,
0.0406696349,
-0.0246361233,
-0.0048169489,
-0.035697192,
0.0779301375,
0.043194104,
-0.0536310039,
-0.0365557447,
-0.0249375142,
0.0127244154,
0.049197901,
-0.0187280793,
0.0621037371,
-0.0370691083,
-0.0114753023,
-0.0367292315,
0.0530600399,
0.0006462898,
0.0117359189,
0.0127625605,
-0.0145428712,
-0.0216369331,
0.0474787802,
0.0030614391,
0.0130958809,
0.0224872008,
0.0579301082,
0.0235713646,
-0.0083177658,
0.0107750455,
-0.0780227557,
-0.0040565892,
-0.0256977733,
0.0014944779,
0.0058143949,
0.0131472275,
-0.0416200534,
-0.079613395,
0.0341239311,
0.0240627676,
-0.0156506766,
-0.0240144096,
0.0259629078,
-0.0516225211,
0.0225025229,
-0.0327307172,
-0.0027624406,
0.0149345649,
0.0262887627,
0.0305961464,
-0.0239612628,
-0.0409533978,
-0.0708457679,
-0.0168051887,
0.0358667485,
0.0589210764,
0.0705579966,
0.0122858724,
-0.0428008214,
0.0141552491,
0.0017755249,
-0.003287727,
0.0034321672,
0.066181995,
0.0042727701,
-0.0119832186,
0.0179819278,
0.0690240934,
-0.0045068273,
-0.0100998599,
0.0320216715,
0.0042852522,
-0.0174158979,
-0.0288382433,
-0.0368583165,
0.0227361098,
0.0262989309,
0.0322576277,
0.0359587818,
-0.0516541302,
-0.0557500832,
-0.0384488069,
0.0281949788,
-0.0844400078,
-0.0395177417,
-0.0070998454,
0.0071436288,
0.0017438213,
-0.0979483575,
-0.0268093925,
0.0002615024,
0.0602170229,
0.0149364211,
-0.0254658535,
-0.0396906547,
-0.042240344,
-0.0386170894,
-0.0358937047,
-0.0050117564,
0.0093006454,
0.0078513464,
-0.0393509194,
0.0320022479,
-0.052326601,
-0.0284154844,
0.0140383951,
-0.0440552607,
-0.0536066592,
-0.0101512345,
0.0436107405,
0.0031884292,
0.0340887532,
0.0150580751,
0.005327241,
0.1332844496,
0.0806409717,
-0.0100374362,
0.0022252193,
0.0179737415,
0.0225389414,
0.0044469978,
0.0135088358,
-0.0024287116,
0.0315279365,
0.0404187329,
0.0014849807,
0.0148251876,
0.0162877478,
0.0190522876,
-0.0558617339,
-0.0059995707,
-0.068556115,
0.0225760695,
-0.0499105193,
-0.0116179269,
-0.0374538079,
0.0059611704,
-0.0797615126,
0.0172403399,
0.0177813862,
0.0272584446,
-0.0097623058,
0.0124213677,
0.0146536771,
0.0421890244,
-0.0135816736,
-0.0303100348,
0.0109954942,
0.0603743941,
0.0032590383,
0.012996546,
-0.0084119085,
-0.0172913279,
-0.046025347,
-0.0058984016,
-0.0080984244,
0.0176873691,
0.0581098907,
-0.0002722763,
-0.0417491607,
0.0430563577,
-0.0712165907,
0.0061123436,
-0.0697795078,
0.0171354134,
0.0591439791,
0.0117800254,
0.0009853927,
-0.0458232127,
0.0093092127,
-0.0074118827,
0.0430615135,
0.0022951677,
-0.0466104709,
-0.0061683315,
-0.0179388076,
-0.0390487835,
-0.0376954265,
0.0990967453,
0.0482789017,
0.0147768566,
-0.025778072,
0.0160117839,
-0.0637549981,
-0.0082872668,
0.0309978575,
-0.0069049769,
0.0235407632,
0.0276684593,
0.0089893835,
-0.0466925949,
-0.0088446867,
0.0408042297,
0.0121975467,
0.0258257054,
0.0565825887,
0.0204521623,
-0.0094659934,
0.0113667436,
-0.0115752369,
0.0497036129,
0.008157514,
-0.0383730195,
-0.03009912,
-5.74438008e-33,
-0.0139941676,
-0.0563475117,
-0.0048547746,
-0.0243990645,
-0.0397847779,
-0.022340348,
-0.0567161664,
-0.0298135206,
0.061449144,
0.0134800272,
-0.0057290024,
-0.0088516232,
-0.0056966138,
0.065689519,
-0.0032309506,
0.0194320995,
0.0785505623,
-0.0236293189,
-0.0252098814,
0.0418715142,
0.024364369,
0.0347871743,
-0.0029727926,
-0.0549042635,
-0.0156753808,
-0.0267614368,
-0.0330983028,
-0.0147318449,
0.0239348523,
0.0179171599,
-0.0347744077,
0.0165124591,
0.0023191038,
-0.0232939329,
-0.0364457108,
0.0445611179,
-0.048024524,
-0.0279120933,
-0.031843558,
-0.0228826646,
-0.0813211501,
-0.0445017554,
0.0280921962,
-0.0473288037,
-0.0075144861,
0.0143399267,
0.0565519258,
-0.0282341037,
-0.0202491377,
-0.0376447029,
-0.0582127087,
-0.0235079713,
-0.0205594338,
-0.0100537743,
-0.0068089152,
-0.0049286122,
0.0310729165,
-0.0114994599,
-0.0528191365,
0.0399936773,
-0.0134469895,
0.0363614932,
0.0258162413,
0.0431159958,
0.0484986492,
0.0578672811,
0.0366337337,
-0.0386320539,
-0.0587588958,
0.0141289243,
0.0051057013,
0.0069342516,
0.0451494865,
0.0619944595,
0.0386462621,
-0.0634414852,
-0.0469314307,
0.0214447789,
-0.0501953252,
-0.024371177,
0.0403099507,
0.0277286209,
0.0264681727,
-0.0209410135,
-0.0129777547,
-0.0446762145,
0.0188331325,
-0.0223234314,
0.0313366614,
0.0461420305,
-0.0274795946,
-0.0490370467,
-0.0037014256,
-0.0302717946,
-0.0094111888,
0.0239389036,
-0.0374826193,
-0.0029034493,
0.0083194524,
0.0168491565,
-0.0382557288,
-0.0230558347,
0.0639066249,
0.0611719601,
-0.0004569005,
0.0166618731,
0.0341661237,
0.0346553437,
-0.0548089482,
0.0211068466,
-0.0310669709,
0.0286563206,
0.0134499576,
-0.0174885206,
-0.0019914669,
-0.0096787522,
-0.0307283495,
-0.0165963918,
-0.0136779929,
-0.0084783332,
-0.0118995784,
0.0103549063,
-0.0066123675,
0.037123058,
-0.048897326,
0.0123775499,
-0.0216252878,
0.0207874272,
0.0737744048,
-0.0984790847,
-0.004471086,
-0.0058428696,
2.56e-7,
-0.0187101662,
-0.0036452319,
0.0525812134,
-0.0104593914,
0.031513337,
0.0299061853,
-0.0077476143,
0.0476427637,
-0.020701563,
0.0241129138,
0.0097491452,
0.0117142005,
0.0336756147,
0.0064621563,
-0.0690884367,
0.0965994075,
-0.0739104748,
0.0126072885,
-0.0434496514,
-0.0166320894,
0.0338583328,
0.0639274418,
-0.0027729291,
0.0121312002,
0.0281828474,
-0.0406879522,
0.0728750825,
0.012911167,
0.0258989837,
-0.0039654179,
0.0317914858,
0.0321782678,
-0.0106489826,
-0.0342673659,
-0.0242294818,
-0.0203118343,
0.0463105813,
0.0106781498,
0.0116438959,
-0.0002718511,
-0.0112812193,
-0.0064089578,
-0.00308684,
-0.0288489945,
0.0372758433,
-0.0815001726,
-0.0184707157,
-0.0197710712,
0.0071121836,
0.0121250851,
0.0380477123,
-0.0129278991,
-0.0347390212,
0.0098196147,
0.0349895358,
0.035169743,
0.0366208218,
-0.051658988,
-0.0275964104,
-0.0283860639,
-0.0782757178,
0.0172899347,
-0.051337637,
0.0474301986,
0.0424712487,
-0.0085219666,
-0.0067640152,
2.081821847e-34,
-0.0046661301,
-0.0032059245,
-0.0112813376,
-0.0436352231,
-0.0104114348,
-0.0223991722,
0.0574167073,
-0.0005600144,
0.0246416554,
-0.0203861147,
-0.04843558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10821v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10821v1 | Comparison of L2 Korean pronunciation error patterns from five L1 backgrounds by using automatic phonetic transcription | 2023-06-19T10:10:46 | 2023-06-19T10:10:46 | Eun Jung Yeo, Hyungshin Ryu, Jooyoung Lee, Sunhee Kim, Minhwa Chung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper presents a large-scale analysis of L2 Korean pronunciation error
patterns from five different language backgrounds, Chinese, Vietnamese,
Japanese, Thai, and English, by using automatic phonetic transcription. For the
analysis, confusion matrices are generated for each L1, by aligning canonical
phone sequences and automatically transcribed phone sequences obtained from
fine-tuned Wav2Vec2 XLS-R phone recognizer. Each value in the confusion
matrices is compared to capture frequent common error patterns and to specify
patterns unique to a certain language background. Using the Foreign Speakers'
Voice Data of Korean for Artificial Intelligence Learning dataset, common error
pattern types are found to be (1) substitutions of aspirated or tense
consonants with plain consonants, (2) deletions of syllable-final consonants,
and (3) substitutions of diphthongs with monophthongs. On the other hand,
thirty-nine patterns including (1) syllable-final /l/ substitutions with /n/
for Vietnamese and (2) /\textturnm/ insertions for Japanese are discovered as
language-dependent. | [
0.0597606413,
0.0155761195,
-0.0070120059,
-0.0109963035,
-0.008133729,
0.0098309573,
0.0118451109,
0.0016392345,
-0.0004202242,
0.0066400133,
-0.0284800045,
-0.0232337229,
0.0999487862,
-0.0641401038,
0.008585033,
-0.0469180867,
0.0034107964,
-0.0303213503,
0.0327402204,
-0.0072219106,
0.0000289359,
0.0080064889,
-0.0496938601,
0.0442202166,
-0.0368086435,
0.0480394475,
-0.0047902437,
0.0478801094,
0.0142507488,
-0.0555961579,
-0.0252708346,
0.0197921973,
-0.0116733564,
0.0305750445,
0.0000019259,
-0.0398379117,
0.0293662362,
-0.0092987334,
-0.0620226637,
-0.0080408752,
-0.0026856677,
0.052494783,
-0.0322285667,
0.0130325565,
0.0253686421,
-0.0499134734,
0.0865404829,
-0.0100078732,
-0.0087361727,
0.0044512954,
0.0052400706,
-0.026559256,
-0.0169016179,
0.0290888157,
0.0022187054,
-0.026733296,
0.0428985655,
-0.0132893622,
-0.0476755537,
-0.1281013191,
-0.0257293936,
-0.0063830027,
-0.0694521442,
-0.0038435911,
-0.0411643088,
-0.0159822032,
-0.011474669,
-0.0639890358,
0.0073853545,
0.0392807685,
-0.0181050338,
-0.0195633005,
-0.0279312041,
0.0023703962,
-0.0121560525,
-0.0157500934,
0.0467311293,
-0.0077525973,
-0.0302085951,
-0.0404113755,
0.0533749871,
-0.0133717004,
0.0166804269,
-0.0492788218,
-0.0253957771,
0.0295816027,
0.0310290698,
-0.0771363005,
0.0080963513,
-0.0048121237,
0.0212728325,
0.0009579711,
0.0377735794,
0.016556114,
-0.0456451289,
0.0446585342,
0.0303861946,
-0.0406610034,
-0.0079319943,
-0.0010297009,
0.0478533544,
0.02859772,
-0.0525300317,
-0.0571621545,
-0.0144150229,
0.0586079285,
0.0193505343,
0.0237305444,
-0.0363692269,
0.0229614228,
0.0349105932,
0.0249443296,
-0.0396747813,
-0.0065330844,
-0.0061332025,
0.0361340977,
-0.0761703104,
-0.0022659497,
-0.0425655246,
0.0398406088,
0.0255894009,
-0.01809383,
-0.0546272434,
0.0229646079,
0.0131704081,
-0.0199501868,
0.0302952528,
0.0720733926,
-0.0222327914,
-0.0689992458,
0.0601298809,
0.0133637972,
0.0425436944,
0.0372395292,
0.0240908433,
0.0194972903,
0.012694628,
0.0243478268,
-0.0212948062,
0.027829688,
-0.0677345693,
-0.0089332368,
-0.0619804263,
-0.0255779047,
0.0178366937,
-0.0281023495,
0.0279160663,
0.0113563603,
-0.0039032751,
-0.0270871222,
-0.0140041634,
0.0370503403,
-0.0010088165,
0.0397352166,
0.0855949521,
-0.0079205241,
0.0149658816,
-0.0180727299,
0.0232937373,
-0.0738381296,
0.0252324454,
-0.0557905436,
0.0182147808,
0.0357038863,
0.0020001342,
-0.0044141444,
-0.0167915244,
-0.046327997,
-0.005752916,
0.0130971773,
0.0010650709,
0.0622304082,
-0.0225678459,
0.0083429031,
0.0027988115,
0.0584861189,
0.0382296965,
0.0151178539,
0.0574129261,
-0.0012929549,
0.0276448689,
0.0280422829,
0.0024452019,
-0.0626396537,
-0.0603621304,
0.0186466388,
-0.0028137157,
0.0325508304,
-0.0229354668,
-0.011082531,
-0.0571882948,
-0.0376804285,
0.0000488586,
0.0108999452,
0.0418645963,
-0.0062671476,
-0.0485734791,
0.0238119047,
-0.0108642671,
-0.0202829447,
-0.0290265959,
-0.0193025935,
0.0139567209,
0.0559201986,
-0.0141266985,
0.0038348923,
-0.0173305329,
-0.0067040967,
-0.0668947399,
-0.0123389494,
0.0295937471,
-0.0376552604,
0.0315787829,
-0.0362704396,
0.0050237486,
0.120965898,
0.0178875718,
0.0429821312,
-0.0225442834,
0.017925594,
0.0112358276,
-0.0219246522,
-0.01911561,
-0.0156405345,
-0.0377451926,
0.015691841,
-0.0077142436,
0.0175236929,
0.0586700812,
0.0525550582,
-0.0176949315,
0.0086645177,
0.0099795386,
0.0193602201,
0.0290091317,
0.0500993282,
-0.0201652665,
-0.0150398677,
0.0629056767,
-0.0123663759,
-0.0178809855,
0.0228456967,
0.0159193277,
-0.0745924562,
-0.0001884931,
-0.0278484486,
0.0209037401,
-0.0453916006,
0.0865396112,
-0.0220713019,
0.0161729902,
0.0271850005,
-0.0272768419,
-0.0087363124,
0.0345337838,
0.0422569029,
0.0020351119,
-0.0239303894,
-0.0839936137,
-0.0344398394,
0.0169512909,
-0.0575468354,
0.0280648824,
-0.021588238,
-0.0116885416,
-0.0413388126,
-0.0071194819,
-0.0415786579,
-0.0019395286,
0.0184588488,
0.0237428993,
-0.0209834799,
-0.0112052672,
-0.0263317097,
-0.0210439377,
0.0100851031,
0.0106807947,
0.0146788256,
0.0103346836,
-0.0173070859,
0.012665825,
-0.0321543813,
-0.0360843875,
-0.0083146561,
0.0013622569,
-0.0548725985,
-0.0226854533,
-0.028945772,
-0.0820720494,
0.0312517136,
0.0064328415,
-0.0267536566,
0.0422628298,
-0.0415186621,
-0.0087600024,
-0.0018181913,
0.0435819253,
-0.0182133578,
-0.0459442548,
0.0304592419,
0.0161722414,
-0.0544961356,
-0.0117888711,
-0.0186411478,
0.0103183202,
-0.0251182411,
-0.0360230431,
-0.0695095658,
-0.0611959882,
0.0264634583,
0.0444016904,
0.0196070634,
-0.0215393044,
-0.0573024377,
-0.0339551903,
-0.0226510391,
0.0480768271,
-0.0535826311,
-0.0342106298,
0.0411145091,
-0.0114034479,
0.0088588335,
0.0506025068,
-0.0675451532,
-0.0439122431,
-0.065740861,
-0.002632868,
0.0116614914,
-0.025697019,
-0.031546291,
-0.0140605457,
0.0054654889,
-0.0955568403,
-0.0051741716,
-0.0024933082,
0.0234268382,
-0.0659721792,
0.0295063294,
-0.0149357654,
-0.0428374037,
-0.0230723452,
0.0012334131,
0.006886533,
0.0251093823,
-0.0325479135,
-0.0138766076,
0.0101821246,
-0.0071494244,
0.065228194,
0.0141212931,
-0.0317498557,
-0.0314992368,
0.0186297148,
0.0198903084,
0.0004410631,
0.0441433452,
0.0106732612,
0.0344824158,
-0.0282891821,
-0.0258810576,
0.085967958,
-0.0327426307,
0.0078432914,
0.0452202223,
0.0042841979,
0.0336860195,
0.0455520153,
0.0403844267,
0.0117473602,
0.0147509808,
0.0400884897,
-0.0035925226,
0.0643456057,
0.0569449626,
0.0080246003,
-0.0229896642,
-0.0000076635,
0.0014787958,
-0.0190086626,
0.0109331608,
-0.0124563295,
-0.0099317133,
0.0122060832,
0.0751716346,
0.0418660454,
-0.0230010115,
0.0484933108,
0.0061111259,
-0.1195100024,
0.0116601614,
0.033091452,
-0.0307695959,
-0.0458709262,
-0.0114736184,
-0.0087496303,
-0.0234293938,
0.0276356395,
0.034740895,
0.0426076949,
-0.049775403,
0.0712670013,
-0.1072005332,
-0.0674672797,
0.018129969,
-0.0166588072,
0.0669145063,
0.0130559457,
0.0213773455,
-0.0303688459,
-0.0382387079,
0.0233229809,
-0.0171980709,
0.0073800986,
-0.0257460047,
0.0274167247,
0.0745837316,
-0.0121563347,
-0.0318146013,
0.0185485203,
0.003389186,
0.0327832811,
0.0034708166,
0.0467064492,
0.0234409478,
-0.0299704168,
0.0467356555,
0.0242116619,
0.0196009222,
-0.0065913359,
0.026137989,
-0.0505795069,
0.0186302867,
0.0045429077,
0.0627277642,
-0.0338504463,
0.054912556,
0.0461086072,
-0.0076957522,
-0.0664273426,
-0.0428692326,
-0.0153700216,
-0.0302454699,
0.0137483422,
0.0601969361,
0.0005490893,
-0.0525908656,
0.0548444875,
-0.0037054464,
-0.0600562505,
0.0533421338,
0.051181104,
-0.0200862065,
-0.0106927231,
-0.029059086,
0.0033314535,
0.0198065042,
-0.0283627361,
-0.0042553963,
-0.0369683579,
0.0825734362,
-0.0057528922,
0.0139971031,
0.0598814562,
-0.0397162922,
0.0001315677,
-0.0257768501,
-0.0035407923,
-0.0008994106,
-0.0137564158,
0.0361175127,
-0.0284464788,
-0.00236415,
0.0164739192,
-0.0310865752,
-0.0030539532,
-0.0403628387,
0.0187865291,
-0.0576795004,
-0.1103057191,
0.0131140845,
0.0569864735,
0.0108740674,
-0.0166502129,
0.0105263898,
-0.0297762901,
0.0263410248,
0.0298483651,
0.031985864,
0.0206179079,
-0.039964553,
0.0546847023,
-0.0068730158,
-0.0017799722,
-0.0126444045,
-0.0286157168,
-0.0480344296,
0.0458508246,
0.0425635912,
0.0600509234,
0.1571407169,
0.0201273076,
0.0334643014,
-0.0612895042,
-0.0082946392,
0.0220659319,
0.0219141524,
0.0204778444,
-0.0241882317,
-0.0380949415,
-0.0101105077,
0.0311423838,
-0.0171705745,
0.0384207033,
-0.0203742702,
0.0016096144,
-0.0431391634,
0.1001148522,
0.0117770163,
0.0474618822,
-0.0067743938,
0.0118878335,
-0.0593068302,
0.0019725999,
-0.0563477613,
-0.0082198549,
0.0044884807,
-0.0082381703,
-0.0119152088,
0.0079658022,
0.0027626446,
0.0094136959,
0.0336033143,
-0.0407838561,
-0.0223300625,
0.0127869518,
0.0017560668,
-0.0103029776,
0.0110032847,
-0.0761464015,
-0.0564159788,
-0.0575378798,
-0.0798130929,
0.0065185181,
0.0344357714,
0.0652165189,
0.0063559529,
-0.0577313714,
0.0093706399,
-0.0103525398,
0.0274775662,
0.000770667,
-0.0318475813,
-0.0123265563,
0.0179425888,
0.0693628564,
-5.715499653e-33,
-0.0038922986,
-0.0086525977,
0.0147889974,
0.0059196772,
-0.0345134474,
-0.0170523282,
-0.023092201,
0.0191634372,
-0.0402871482,
-0.0016202105,
-0.0081586549,
-0.0261110645,
0.0188596025,
-0.0406340621,
0.0342868231,
0.0336425453,
0.0393921062,
0.0131201968,
0.0315995179,
-0.0337947235,
0.0509697795,
0.0603125058,
0.0305566303,
-0.0369108692,
0.0524159744,
0.0192077123,
-0.0198188387,
-0.0151768597,
-0.0055926461,
0.0282465387,
-0.0000524189,
0.084821023,
-0.017866496,
0.0247780215,
-0.0673686042,
-0.0285775214,
-0.0883449391,
-0.0109138759,
-0.0080640167,
0.1004895717,
0.0277127251,
0.0127896564,
-0.0038673498,
0.0035677312,
-0.0197794437,
0.00321954,
0.005398551,
-0.0521103367,
-0.0008405542,
0.029555425,
0.0159109384,
0.0273392852,
-0.0051237126,
-0.0020159788,
0.077580899,
0.0318888426,
-0.0594526567,
-0.0350185484,
-0.0519466177,
0.0372600667,
0.0103402454,
0.0179328285,
0.0212938245,
0.0050586737,
-0.047958672,
-0.0384071358,
0.0929641575,
-0.0578789227,
0.0511920154,
-0.0593831763,
0.0081946887,
0.0467823595,
-0.0083318232,
0.0007999868,
0.0625275895,
-0.0890406147,
-0.000527316,
-0.0238258541,
0.0067318357,
0.0040917285,
-0.0162294619,
0.0230377577,
-0.0318578593,
-0.0177040361,
-0.0082957502,
-0.0115391677,
-0.0222811829,
-0.0217197016,
0.0167588666,
-0.0261849985,
0.0176344588,
0.00669637,
0.0334471017,
-0.023101287,
0.0200550314,
-0.0241324175,
0.009752051,
-0.0015819544,
-0.0328938663,
0.0016086879,
-0.0319228582,
-0.0293094404,
0.0046708826,
0.0142100891,
0.0194754638,
0.0078976518,
0.002950913,
0.0452311672,
-0.0425797328,
0.0200081784,
-0.0014590226,
-0.0536803603,
-0.0123692034,
-0.0086938515,
0.0097294264,
0.0080926791,
0.0084152333,
0.0103083141,
0.0120397946,
0.0368802249,
-0.0270667262,
0.0125528602,
-0.0278067552,
-0.0039521856,
-0.0123101706,
-0.0125772543,
0.0092358273,
0.0103264116,
-0.0009348058,
0.0149077317,
-0.0025604297,
-0.0029944817,
2.78e-7,
-0.0079113515,
-0.0201660022,
0.0730285645,
-0.0145093491,
0.01951758,
-0.0143525088,
-0.0552142262,
-0.0408326499,
0.0339790955,
0.0902066901,
0.0630555525,
-0.0606905557,
0.0957552195,
0.044876717,
-0.0310198832,
-0.0073671197,
-0.01771437,
0.0366513133,
-0.0101833167,
0.0473389737,
0.0052314573,
0.0131616974,
-0.025130596,
-0.0541705154,
-0.017170785,
0.0336950757,
-0.0214920212,
-0.0183840301,
0.0483944155,
-0.0124865733,
0.0602447018,
-0.0432913713,
0.0489218459,
0.0421618707,
-0.0611527152,
0.0304231439,
-0.0043864721,
0.0070759086,
-0.0246236734,
-0.0213901009,
0.014547511,
0.0506620146,
-0.0622377284,
-0.0158961415,
-0.0093625989,
0.0781833902,
0.0007276853,
0.0060024695,
-0.020678388,
0.0008633043,
-0.0190480445,
-0.0052021677,
0.0277492013,
0.0171612278,
-0.0019915695,
0.0140140587,
-0.0352283716,
0.0294357501,
0.0170161985,
0.0430153385,
-0.017142944,
-0.0334776156,
0.0463191681,
0.0035526911,
0.0214567576,
0.0167017858,
0.0054681157,
1.935443643e-34,
0.0018802824,
-0.015795663,
0.0305459201,
0.016414335,
0.0045530302,
-0.0366188772,
0.014724113,
0.0633918121,
-0.0096156634,
0.0088738799,
-0.0550807416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.17180v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.17180v1 | Replace and Report: NLP Assisted Radiology Report Generation | 2023-06-19T10:04:42 | 2023-06-19T10:04:42 | Kaveri Kale, pushpak Bhattacharyya, Kshitij Jadhav | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Clinical practice frequently uses medical imaging for diagnosis and
treatment. A significant challenge for automatic radiology report generation is
that the radiology reports are long narratives consisting of multiple sentences
for both abnormal and normal findings. Therefore, applying conventional image
captioning approaches to generate the whole report proves to be insufficient,
as these are designed to briefly describe images with short sentences. We
propose a template-based approach to generate radiology reports from
radiographs. Our approach involves the following: i) using a multilabel image
classifier, produce the tags for the input radiograph; ii) using a
transformer-based model, generate pathological descriptions (a description of
abnormal findings seen on radiographs) from the tags generated in step (i);
iii) using a BERT-based multi-label text classifier, find the spans in the
normal report template to replace with the generated pathological descriptions;
and iv) using a rule-based system, replace the identified span with the
generated pathological description. We performed experiments with the two most
popular radiology report datasets, IU Chest X-ray and MIMIC-CXR and
demonstrated that the BLEU-1, ROUGE-L, METEOR, and CIDEr scores are better than
the State-of-the-Art models by 25%, 36%, 44% and 48% respectively, on the IU
X-RAY dataset. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first attempt to
generate chest X-ray radiology reports by first creating small sentences for
abnormal findings and then replacing them in the normal report template. | [
0.0477911793,
0.0127306068,
0.0336971879,
-0.0369725637,
-0.0239794087,
0.0215860326,
-0.0045335833,
0.0520458855,
-0.0077906265,
-0.0361991413,
0.0265831221,
-0.0021889613,
0.0157955848,
0.0324684456,
0.0036561247,
-0.1143560335,
-0.0178341866,
0.0016914351,
0.01739504,
0.0107598491,
-0.0007399152,
0.0180836413,
0.0076478948,
0.0356415398,
-0.0527192988,
0.0284959301,
0.0158858076,
0.0294899438,
0.0181798898,
-0.0461393893,
-0.026956493,
0.0523618981,
0.0048480565,
-0.0211182944,
0.0000019303,
-0.018900536,
-0.0342773646,
0.0401268899,
0.0455119796,
-0.033335004,
0.0581962429,
-0.0681199059,
0.0026706238,
-0.0054137018,
-0.0008770074,
-0.0517725758,
0.045912534,
0.0775837153,
0.0944996849,
0.0527517013,
-0.0459142439,
-0.0181398541,
-0.0293147881,
0.0134832822,
0.0266076364,
-0.0309738405,
0.0035603363,
0.0401971936,
0.0345732681,
0.0067953034,
-0.0124232005,
0.0485859215,
-0.0159667414,
-0.0234310757,
0.0290663205,
0.0822447613,
-0.0142817935,
-0.0355165079,
-0.0087259207,
0.0410692282,
-0.0373495929,
0.0003544108,
0.0090657221,
0.0022498178,
-0.0089283008,
-0.0225278996,
-0.0221140422,
0.0261357352,
-0.0281409435,
-0.0037432367,
0.0009019569,
-0.0066002579,
-0.0429691561,
-0.0097385999,
-0.0182512496,
-0.0451105572,
0.0067390963,
-0.0070627313,
-0.0316506624,
0.0251751784,
0.0036568427,
-0.072705552,
0.0340286568,
0.0475233607,
-0.0397267081,
0.015613867,
-0.0533515774,
-0.0525068641,
0.0616343319,
-0.041599568,
-0.0381941088,
-0.0209304616,
-0.0483275093,
0.0675159842,
-0.0422135144,
0.0302574951,
-0.0111508556,
0.0565324835,
-0.0455702469,
0.027410794,
-0.0465419441,
-0.0176541433,
-0.0401902534,
0.0373009704,
0.0150113869,
-0.0371748172,
-0.0614755265,
-0.0096051497,
-0.0031526817,
0.0279974416,
0.0467063896,
0.0361888744,
-0.0483899713,
0.0538155735,
0.0188664738,
0.036210455,
0.0233933441,
-0.0332488976,
0.0108024618,
-0.0000716534,
0.0224342048,
0.0566950776,
0.0145938583,
0.0191388987,
-0.0124754151,
-0.001596262,
-0.0255849417,
-0.0052704597,
0.0184390917,
-0.0575501919,
-0.0519152842,
-0.0044299504,
0.0276587717,
-0.0601238571,
0.0280113462,
0.0271514282,
0.024410069,
0.0135128833,
0.0286914762,
0.0221359003,
-0.0321804918,
0.0519902594,
-0.0534149148,
0.0158542115,
0.0420194454,
0.0154349478,
0.0503577292,
-0.0187125877,
0.013278109,
0.0057500554,
0.0076210583,
-0.006422678,
0.0391395204,
-0.0056029405,
-0.0243131965,
-0.0415841565,
-0.0315363556,
-0.0113964872,
0.0182899609,
0.0688525587,
0.0082609756,
0.0621119402,
-0.014957251,
0.0229899045,
0.0330344141,
0.0358595997,
0.0239795689,
0.0253042392,
0.0569477864,
-0.0199369825,
-0.0293667167,
0.0186896529,
0.0010472013,
0.0264556166,
0.0436515547,
0.0253348649,
-0.0234443229,
-0.022161996,
-0.0364175029,
-0.0141629707,
-0.0443510227,
0.0004057448,
-0.0218193289,
-0.0353178866,
0.0364967547,
0.0267084949,
-0.0642796382,
0.0628827438,
0.0261203572,
-0.0217442885,
-0.0175604634,
-0.0649924725,
-0.0412964821,
0.0632392988,
0.0863492936,
-0.0190116875,
-0.0391593054,
-0.0012692898,
0.0360131562,
0.0441551954,
0.0414759107,
0.0057940222,
-0.0118725551,
-0.0327523611,
-0.0242265426,
0.0167929847,
0.0070123058,
-0.0051758108,
-0.0090738637,
-0.0055477046,
-0.0104256188,
-0.0359853953,
-0.081365332,
0.0544305071,
0.005138685,
-0.0027692658,
0.0060177497,
0.0224254746,
-0.0366482511,
0.0013333533,
-0.0388036333,
0.0206734799,
0.0080880783,
0.029860612,
-0.0663919002,
0.0471274778,
-0.0235006381,
-0.034153793,
0.0194499306,
-0.0873758271,
0.0054066773,
-0.0349036045,
-0.0180494953,
-0.0213560667,
-0.0573103875,
-0.0848096088,
-0.0018230581,
-0.008401515,
0.0481289737,
0.072243005,
-0.0183718372,
-0.0098130275,
0.0570297278,
0.0216551963,
0.0155143039,
0.0373102576,
-0.0237884857,
0.0188984852,
-0.0218211915,
-0.0172198415,
0.0193521399,
-0.0064538321,
-0.025534438,
0.0216879137,
0.0574737862,
0.0043924539,
-0.0404328033,
-0.0421509594,
-0.0290932599,
0.0215856936,
-0.0456634238,
0.048286166,
0.0271459688,
0.0185852237,
-0.0379265472,
-0.0480955094,
-0.0421171673,
0.0554784499,
0.0040169158,
0.0787903517,
0.0273577012,
-0.0271699,
-0.0221426263,
-0.0001827754,
-0.0189764407,
0.026266491,
0.0781264678,
-0.0454714224,
-0.036289271,
0.0341582224,
-0.0216530021,
-0.0114516476,
0.0351121351,
-0.0508027971,
0.0158420559,
-0.021021707,
-0.0153199332,
0.0420401655,
0.0191907212,
0.0370204411,
0.031654004,
-0.0021633685,
-0.0043123094,
0.0147368852,
-0.0550927222,
-0.0388789028,
0.0510466918,
-0.0966507494,
0.0154934488,
0.0315956026,
0.019592138,
0.0353420079,
-0.0181044135,
-0.0703234598,
-0.0026180607,
0.0139895752,
-0.0456832647,
-0.007667107,
-0.0152236251,
0.0164437145,
0.0035026006,
-0.0293769091,
0.0805705041,
0.0024744326,
0.0031476689,
-0.0902354568,
0.0139021762,
-0.0418037996,
0.0407302491,
0.0122869397,
0.0599987693,
0.0471722409,
-0.0300690215,
-0.0010925592,
0.0028559968,
0.0383987986,
-0.042402532,
-0.0322554074,
-0.0246402957,
0.0102346139,
-0.0205714777,
-0.0124192489,
-0.0276550744,
-0.0045078383,
0.0489544533,
-0.0153157087,
-0.0129298372,
-0.0006080862,
-0.0815157071,
0.0775171742,
0.0187312774,
0.0320939608,
-0.0093093049,
-0.0315812007,
0.0079013063,
0.0966686234,
0.0124227144,
-0.0206308383,
-0.0576533712,
-0.0152098071,
0.0026498581,
0.0532628596,
-0.0291838739,
0.0732582808,
-0.0278376546,
-0.0075790929,
-0.0170374233,
-0.0072931801,
-0.0078335321,
0.0015975618,
0.0142613426,
-0.0248670354,
-0.0366966799,
0.0763638988,
0.040469557,
0.0267232899,
-0.0257342588,
0.0382659249,
-0.0238326471,
0.0011329603,
0.0148592805,
-0.0160332657,
0.0283297468,
0.0039081192,
0.0345523916,
-0.0220119767,
0.012488368,
0.0028832208,
-0.0204018634,
0.0470637195,
-0.0117621059,
-0.0212398488,
-0.0428788215,
-0.0484121069,
-0.02669576,
0.0136027457,
-0.063276723,
-0.0097182784,
0.0030764975,
-0.0062719001,
0.0116172442,
-0.0662504137,
-0.0501318797,
-0.0311751124,
-0.0524318591,
-0.0249542631,
0.0501192957,
0.0545645095,
-0.0450186916,
-0.029471904,
-0.0215404443,
0.0488990843,
0.0146165155,
-0.0014806004,
0.0950107425,
0.0046601295,
-0.0429213867,
-0.039489042,
0.0160146821,
0.022119768,
-0.0111792944,
-0.0240159053,
0.0301531386,
-0.0216698609,
-0.0225789696,
-0.0808351263,
0.0635185465,
0.0319604799,
0.0304967016,
0.0032223384,
0.0080782948,
-0.0339760296,
-0.0043642772,
0.0739632323,
-0.0668874159,
-0.0131157469,
0.0471147336,
-0.0995341316,
-0.0972295702,
-0.0628906116,
-0.0017186012,
0.0489082746,
0.0367237963,
0.025706647,
-0.0081512686,
-0.0285170916,
0.0093372827,
-0.0592047535,
0.0253497213,
0.0341252536,
0.0030946536,
-0.0051049972,
-0.0469078533,
0.0805961341,
0.0161956996,
-0.0054483111,
0.038475927,
-0.0216198675,
0.0170478858,
-0.0093776435,
0.0428767577,
0.0215641558,
-0.0307584945,
0.0038852158,
0.0130718928,
0.0482325144,
0.0786981881,
0.0008639112,
-0.0077645956,
-0.0427215025,
-0.0563900359,
-0.0308993533,
-0.0229871217,
-0.0335850492,
0.0077167065,
-0.004793989,
0.0446836613,
-0.0160560794,
-0.0404822193,
0.0549832843,
0.0410047136,
0.0004295406,
-0.0632416531,
-0.0086371265,
0.0020662257,
-0.0274413321,
-0.0289893188,
-0.0132964328,
-0.0166115407,
0.0472413152,
0.0151016889,
0.0094546387,
0.0018435197,
0.024105195,
-0.0655372068,
-0.0045984653,
-0.0434599668,
0.0281913001,
-0.0016088054,
-0.0507811308,
0.0120176459,
-0.0233004149,
-0.0266519673,
-0.0645746812,
0.0318043381,
-0.0162432063,
-0.0056397589,
0.0328100733,
0.0369315706,
0.045339521,
-0.0197487138,
0.0220074784,
0.0009854611,
0.0182636995,
-0.0640652478,
0.0053560352,
0.0244805161,
0.013129958,
-0.00705032,
-0.0598819628,
-0.0194395129,
-0.001210778,
0.0623210296,
0.0010822797,
-0.0115509965,
0.0489415899,
-0.0176911764,
0.0333983116,
-0.0263253618,
0.0766414106,
0.0051481342,
0.01753713,
-0.0083005261,
-0.0694262385,
-0.065518178,
0.0011337179,
0.0328560174,
-0.0274776965,
-0.0244652759,
-0.0083967624,
-0.0259057283,
-0.0169048868,
0.0203454979,
-0.012020112,
0.011310515,
-0.0120384507,
0.0673580393,
0.042562589,
0.0333252847,
-0.0142834205,
-0.0126531757,
0.0333475322,
0.0094484892,
-0.0010755543,
0.014125458,
-5.367724506e-33,
-0.0134558743,
-0.079485774,
0.0089568673,
-0.018220244,
0.0094824927,
0.0500183254,
-0.026312599,
-0.017299952,
0.0246822294,
0.0024846657,
-0.0036679218,
-0.0607954562,
0.0319941528,
0.0280063227,
0.0099962233,
-0.0031326453,
0.035844136,
-0.0066328035,
-0.0319606625,
0.0119424444,
-0.0149174081,
0.026260417,
0.053489197,
-0.0924059898,
-0.0298806727,
0.0074951127,
-0.030755423,
-0.040150281,
0.0441346988,
0.0200392213,
-0.0254273396,
0.0045583243,
0.0173542537,
-0.0507632755,
0.0043960093,
0.0115288701,
-0.0650316104,
0.014515562,
0.0143919196,
0.0209241156,
-0.0351887234,
0.0011444434,
0.02161026,
-0.0430232361,
0.0430698358,
-0.0257017035,
0.0573722161,
-0.0121053224,
0.0099744275,
-0.0458497368,
-0.0381630659,
0.0394928381,
-0.0111939199,
-0.045914229,
-0.0153026106,
-0.0115976194,
-0.0276833698,
0.0332804695,
-0.0057991757,
0.0208526067,
0.0827025399,
0.0250364915,
0.0260620322,
-0.0235727616,
-0.0326987207,
0.0205295105,
0.0599075109,
-0.0202837978,
0.0114093479,
0.0250794645,
-0.0637438148,
0.0634741783,
0.0292464588,
0.0002976721,
0.0203645471,
-0.0183687918,
-0.0372597873,
0.0715871379,
-0.0615515448,
0.0546577014,
0.0165475439,
-0.026026072,
-0.0326527171,
0.0297652725,
0.0351510979,
-0.0257131271,
-0.0184636135,
-0.0212192964,
0.025305789,
0.0604469478,
-0.0328596383,
0.0510160699,
0.0107032638,
0.0526955426,
0.0093294494,
-0.0585949682,
0.0282758567,
0.0670397133,
-0.0824439898,
-0.0326966606,
0.0231474042,
-0.053084828,
0.071986571,
0.0274409968,
0.0372736901,
0.0255010631,
0.0459764414,
0.0200718231,
-0.07001739,
0.0122492174,
0.0290524252,
-0.0358798131,
-0.040769089,
0.019260155,
0.0204978809,
-0.0014090459,
-0.0164499748,
0.0059836251,
-0.0078895697,
0.0209070295,
-0.0254660752,
-0.0652881563,
0.015813794,
-0.0026824335,
-0.0539164692,
-0.0133682555,
-0.0184378698,
0.0037396033,
0.0541243814,
-0.0190221835,
-0.0344631113,
0.0072802003,
2.715e-7,
0.0641428456,
0.0284093805,
0.0492282547,
-0.0033972717,
0.0097280601,
-0.0093503995,
-0.0345131122,
0.0142880604,
-0.0024635715,
-0.0167932585,
0.0438349023,
-0.0519650392,
-0.0132616917,
0.017938327,
-0.0682844669,
-0.0138799399,
-0.030658979,
-0.008793545,
-0.0104449233,
-0.0140592791,
0.1054045409,
0.0380743518,
-0.0507807098,
-0.0328622349,
0.0016783917,
-0.0198996942,
0.0353264995,
-0.0187034439,
-0.0039855507,
-0.0002034994,
0.0434714779,
0.04491283,
-0.00098737,
0.0367154963,
-0.0162199289,
-0.0317152292,
0.0309309885,
0.0431830585,
-0.0411214717,
0.0155570721,
0.0254564248,
0.0043629054,
0.0192330331,
-0.0474383831,
0.0344928503,
-0.0555354394,
-0.0020763136,
-0.0132438187,
-0.0446858704,
0.0339401215,
0.0317962803,
-0.0599126518,
-0.0707879663,
0.0565676838,
0.0153472479,
0.0225443505,
-0.0591140129,
-0.065351449,
-0.0019370178,
0.0036073432,
0.0034103529,
-0.0093948571,
0.0331164971,
-0.003048212,
0.0074529937,
-0.0600392856,
-0.0145133641,
2.70816289e-34,
0.019318223,
0.0076721604,
-0.0251284558,
0.021227682,
0.0168777537,
-0.0220928416,
-0.0177628528,
0.0244377051,
-0.0107372003,
-0.0345873274,
-0.0185753237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10790v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10790v1 | Preserving Commonsense Knowledge from Pre-trained Language Models via Causal Inference | 2023-06-19T09:06:44 | 2023-06-19T09:06:44 | Junhao Zheng, Qianli Ma, Shengjie Qiu, Yue Wu, Peitian Ma, Junlong Liu, Huawen Feng, Xichen Shang, Haibin Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Fine-tuning has been proven to be a simple and effective technique to
transfer the learned knowledge of Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) to
downstream tasks. However, vanilla fine-tuning easily overfits the target data
and degrades the generalization ability. Most existing studies attribute it to
catastrophic forgetting, and they retain the pre-trained knowledge
indiscriminately without identifying what knowledge is transferable. Motivated
by this, we frame fine-tuning into a causal graph and discover that the crux of
catastrophic forgetting lies in the missing causal effects from the pretrained
data. Based on the causal view, we propose a unified objective for fine-tuning
to retrieve the causality back. Intriguingly, the unified objective can be seen
as the sum of the vanilla fine-tuning objective, which learns new knowledge
from target data, and the causal objective, which preserves old knowledge from
PLMs. Therefore, our method is flexible and can mitigate negative transfer
while preserving knowledge. Since endowing models with commonsense is a
long-standing challenge, we implement our method on commonsense QA with a
proposed heuristic estimation to verify its effectiveness. In the experiments,
our method outperforms state-of-the-art fine-tuning methods on all six
commonsense QA datasets and can be implemented as a plug-in module to inflate
the performance of existing QA models. | [
0.0294849165,
0.1090819165,
-0.0184645597,
0.0038347172,
-0.0031410896,
0.0176297054,
-0.0399032906,
-0.0132517274,
0.0267401598,
-0.0603869446,
-0.0108437007,
0.0341584757,
-0.011773577,
0.005356553,
0.0414929315,
-0.0216162317,
0.0844354555,
-0.0120626576,
-0.0264886785,
-0.0110534141,
0.0078756958,
-0.0116065573,
0.0159078352,
0.0168973114,
-0.0099551883,
0.0038275728,
0.0219062734,
-0.0191058964,
0.0073375884,
0.0256052837,
0.0205704402,
0.0604494885,
0.0233240463,
-0.0054286998,
0.0000020634,
-0.0542893969,
-0.0173685309,
-0.0300173573,
0.0096650114,
0.018050449,
0.0202035289,
-0.0023182954,
0.0168125648,
0.0128911231,
-0.0342889763,
-0.0074782106,
0.0406163521,
0.015418076,
0.0409258604,
0.0685192123,
-0.0085843997,
-0.0457809754,
0.0265568178,
-0.0303778723,
0.0366697125,
-0.0719246268,
0.0589859821,
0.0278373454,
-0.0356491543,
-0.0530381016,
-0.052670747,
0.0395693928,
0.0210452676,
-0.0041145729,
0.0031085014,
0.0206599552,
-0.019818306,
0.0223089419,
-0.0223038122,
0.1077982783,
0.0032539763,
-0.0602445379,
0.0161335673,
-0.0083531924,
0.0223093145,
0.0414740667,
-0.0445471145,
-0.0183839537,
0.0411571227,
0.0178635865,
0.0338314734,
-0.0498239473,
0.0324504636,
0.0380881391,
-0.029298991,
0.0307386573,
0.0259156525,
-0.0080971913,
0.0053158728,
0.0301852934,
-0.027075734,
-0.0046153851,
0.0056558545,
0.0262623746,
-0.0075185727,
0.0335165039,
-0.0178764518,
-0.0096436338,
0.00611261,
-0.0250069723,
0.0486761667,
0.0403477326,
-0.0290522594,
0.0442964099,
-0.0556382611,
0.0335170962,
-0.0028708864,
0.082530506,
-0.0268062279,
0.02882923,
-0.062926285,
-0.0182836633,
-0.0358171463,
0.0322969258,
0.0166102182,
0.0113615654,
-0.0121401642,
0.0004380007,
-0.0088301683,
-0.0141536668,
0.0091635222,
0.0154658062,
-0.037598867,
-0.0318608098,
-0.0105819087,
0.056027405,
-0.0545519479,
0.0869340152,
0.006967965,
-0.0123650506,
-0.0459663309,
-0.0076695895,
0.0504916012,
-0.0176020525,
0.010544722,
0.0427960269,
-0.0216398891,
-0.0331668667,
-0.0578598417,
-0.0029682314,
-0.0004290068,
-0.0301202182,
-0.0157665573,
-0.039024435,
0.0221098009,
0.0115265837,
0.0086021479,
-0.0347041711,
-0.0063954215,
-0.0132277673,
-0.0741378963,
0.0648740232,
-0.0129839974,
0.0220389944,
-0.0126982797,
-0.0040921466,
0.0343914703,
0.0512915999,
-0.0118277119,
-0.0288129989,
0.0200103391,
-0.0143098356,
0.013681422,
0.0107464734,
0.059416946,
0.0118745128,
-0.0242119674,
-0.0157557279,
0.0085928002,
0.0060305404,
0.0403647125,
-0.00002747,
-0.0370605811,
0.0175501648,
0.0611178242,
0.0399938375,
-0.0082419068,
0.0376653969,
0.0035636595,
-0.0178115033,
0.0068193227,
0.0296786074,
-0.0927246436,
0.0047503435,
-0.0489143953,
-0.0228266511,
-0.0203412417,
-0.0294884518,
-0.0415577479,
0.0043581333,
0.0348230042,
-0.0152543159,
0.0300994441,
-0.0213924944,
0.0532560311,
0.0615906343,
-0.0376484282,
0.074246265,
0.050010249,
-0.0678298399,
0.0453824624,
-0.0160598848,
0.0194986593,
0.0312507376,
0.034775082,
-0.0429388396,
-0.0413032472,
0.0153775038,
0.01698507,
-0.0160100833,
0.0459435694,
-0.0256957076,
0.0225494821,
-0.0537348352,
-0.0314745903,
-0.0055242567,
0.0401638672,
0.002203899,
0.027803883,
-0.0080915885,
0.0098372055,
-0.0558810011,
-0.0221848674,
0.0292001814,
-0.0446355455,
-0.0336460695,
-0.0482911952,
-0.0119609712,
0.0135410344,
-0.0004870582,
0.0082583399,
0.0074133994,
0.0158141311,
-0.014774546,
-0.000700724,
0.0524788946,
-0.0443729386,
-0.0518799238,
0.0237024147,
-0.0312303957,
-0.0085659772,
0.075269483,
-0.0491121635,
-0.0608037189,
0.0573456697,
0.0182674136,
0.0512325764,
-0.0423237197,
-0.0139908008,
-0.015464684,
-0.0296603218,
0.0002906679,
0.0753161386,
-0.0077727977,
-0.004869286,
-0.0214721002,
-0.0352349319,
-0.0250799451,
-0.0195500962,
-0.0077974675,
-0.034603823,
-0.0286414083,
0.0209439658,
0.033636637,
0.0070957872,
-0.0550416708,
0.0218996312,
-0.0729520693,
-0.008062317,
-0.0175164565,
0.0109306676,
0.0185107589,
-0.0001149365,
-0.0021623268,
-0.0372078344,
-0.021443082,
0.0286892131,
-0.0088607604,
0.0230948236,
0.0076711429,
0.0001598053,
0.034558557,
-0.0464384519,
0.0000230666,
-0.0241431259,
0.0136577664,
-0.0000207375,
0.0370305628,
-0.0143684214,
0.0392436199,
-0.025708193,
0.0200736448,
-0.0226332434,
-0.0679471567,
-0.0244110841,
-0.0264368244,
0.0115144048,
0.0767189637,
-0.033687856,
-0.0062528807,
0.0409150459,
-0.027134832,
-0.0475800037,
0.0105567658,
-0.0659533739,
-0.0359494202,
-0.0193841457,
0.0225304868,
-0.0247439891,
0.0693936124,
0.0009630181,
-0.0164951459,
-0.0758880526,
0.0041803913,
-0.0157742836,
0.0010775317,
-0.0456671156,
0.0143449875,
-0.0340649448,
0.0040717763,
-0.0349401906,
-0.0562738553,
0.0600260235,
0.0337317213,
0.0329809971,
-0.0201813579,
0.0388058499,
-0.0108423429,
0.0445097275,
0.0021304537,
-0.0027260599,
-0.0086889295,
-0.0331869945,
-0.0813042745,
-0.0218108445,
0.0267320331,
-0.0144694373,
0.0298365094,
-0.0566645265,
0.0346666425,
-0.0141937407,
-0.0462642014,
-0.0343381912,
-0.05631404,
-0.0038807199,
0.0008826794,
0.0055789528,
-0.002177695,
-0.004126959,
-0.0311894957,
0.0164715759,
0.0641553774,
-0.0081970124,
0.0116373906,
-0.0181724895,
0.0218496379,
0.0389514007,
0.0099345157,
0.0186264962,
-0.00282752,
-0.0279154088,
0.0265317746,
0.0573064983,
-0.016099669,
0.0252384283,
0.0249939319,
0.0184680633,
-0.0101312697,
-0.0124968896,
0.0222317055,
0.0773862526,
-0.0384240746,
-0.0447683483,
0.056593176,
0.0333496407,
-0.0178838074,
0.0016113148,
0.0289042275,
0.0046045682,
0.0182279702,
-0.0055194451,
-0.0951378644,
-0.0658565015,
0.0229420383,
0.0323435776,
0.0211929046,
-0.0743808225,
0.0307475496,
-0.1161024272,
-0.0126158921,
0.0155635616,
-0.0885821804,
-0.0056499862,
-0.0446579829,
-0.000408166,
-0.0314127356,
-0.0036976889,
0.016385803,
-0.0105527192,
0.0110429693,
0.0045235171,
0.0029858605,
-0.0812918097,
0.0197766535,
-0.023088906,
0.0647927746,
0.0598958582,
0.0323465914,
0.0003912013,
-0.0396630131,
0.0440245643,
-0.0501578376,
0.0102602141,
-0.006514295,
0.0240928847,
-0.0044550793,
-0.0264381897,
0.0148136448,
0.0954628885,
-0.0669278428,
-0.0289523695,
-0.0011572933,
0.044159282,
0.0165338926,
-0.0370534509,
0.0216757283,
-0.0266881809,
0.0000960608,
0.0900034159,
0.0473723747,
0.0071934508,
-0.0527651273,
-0.0269638579,
0.0056237914,
-0.0568162352,
-0.0403850004,
-0.0116836922,
0.0163137186,
0.007041818,
-0.08528056,
-0.0325601622,
0.0283086319,
-0.0014581578,
0.0204685107,
0.0117293,
0.0158029459,
-0.0074234232,
-0.0459438264,
0.075225085,
-0.0870946348,
-0.0356937163,
-0.0390770696,
-0.0158934891,
0.0171297677,
-0.0031888387,
-0.0185723174,
0.0074363975,
-0.0685825869,
-0.070101738,
0.0138600692,
0.0941483378,
0.0163772963,
0.0587436445,
-0.0442174487,
-0.0522625931,
0.0508178845,
0.0370531827,
-0.0498363189,
-0.0027287113,
0.0567636639,
-0.0365658291,
0.002928918,
0.078203015,
-0.0332329758,
-0.0073012486,
0.045223631,
0.0634917915,
-0.0149127003,
0.0272181854,
0.0040306863,
0.00115097,
0.0529732816,
-0.005450014,
0.0288962591,
-0.0500767678,
-0.0136120496,
-0.0116855651,
-0.0230136961,
-0.0339451246,
0.0143717211,
0.058967635,
0.015063595,
-0.0129823098,
-0.0151909916,
-0.0326863378,
0.0584850982,
-0.0533856414,
0.0064823939,
0.053300485,
0.0267317649,
0.0491442531,
-0.002130633,
-0.011235008,
0.0093004536,
-0.0089871353,
0.0248938426,
-0.0238855071,
0.0449850634,
0.0280763209,
-0.0154014137,
-0.0372329839,
-0.0192754325,
-0.0603867769,
-0.0201614406,
-0.0047794115,
0.0496128015,
0.0538838059,
-0.034438923,
0.0252939016,
-0.0098339133,
-0.0215060543,
-0.0176870972,
0.0665410832,
0.0243888274,
0.0097850384,
0.0303347912,
0.0084882407,
-0.0144330952,
0.0236329678,
0.0793776736,
-0.0373582914,
0.0766515359,
-0.0203420632,
0.0095590465,
-0.0089855585,
-0.0541104823,
0.0307667404,
0.0494846702,
-0.0129861282,
0.0460018106,
-0.056850642,
-0.0756961629,
-0.0177033916,
-0.0231825206,
0.0112099508,
-0.0071374895,
0.0164641403,
0.0294553712,
-0.0269814134,
-0.0132286167,
-0.012149347,
-0.0044486378,
-0.0625664592,
0.0051615946,
0.0020111413,
-7.095793772e-33,
-0.0198995508,
0.0086105885,
-0.0023689265,
-0.0164989624,
-0.00699068,
0.0045706076,
-0.0604546368,
-0.0192142613,
-0.0305732619,
0.0093942396,
-0.0154720517,
0.0371174254,
-0.0020103501,
0.0302786604,
0.0077781673,
-0.0202099383,
0.0223169122,
0.0156626571,
-0.0425353274,
0.0172947757,
0.0635644719,
0.0370715484,
0.0838002488,
0.0004915503,
0.0313246474,
0.0062630288,
-0.0044546146,
0.0289427228,
-0.0447275192,
0.0287763402,
-0.0069624316,
0.0506378524,
0.0225455537,
-0.0242903903,
-0.0090511618,
0.0480754748,
-0.0889797285,
-0.0743293166,
0.0631036535,
-0.0229513701,
-0.0243935082,
-0.033101391,
0.0329863057,
-0.0051932256,
0.0106493086,
0.0073971362,
0.0259174723,
-0.0244467054,
-0.0173227973,
-0.0121648274,
-0.0496891625,
0.0073695197,
-0.0126016056,
-0.0349323526,
-0.0302206445,
-0.0235565398,
-0.0001861585,
0.0001501706,
-0.0453778282,
0.0011122088,
0.0281864982,
0.0235059559,
0.0261390861,
0.0060121925,
0.0220841393,
0.0444298573,
-0.0435444824,
0.0088936826,
-0.0064917565,
0.0219943058,
0.0590724982,
0.0280355252,
0.0396640822,
0.0506073125,
0.0298484154,
-0.0361144431,
-0.0569006503,
0.0158274882,
-0.0349069312,
0.0742729381,
-0.0049166987,
0.0132616321,
-0.0023997808,
-0.0417456701,
-0.08200261,
-0.016574733,
-0.0273598172,
0.0234794728,
0.0209452286,
0.0141872922,
-0.0527213328,
-0.0029850022,
0.019641703,
-0.0398814715,
-0.0039060512,
0.0549933091,
-0.0394540429,
-0.0106244339,
-0.0163636338,
0.0196895935,
-0.1004002169,
-0.0226584636,
0.0280489828,
-0.0016792264,
0.0104003707,
0.0353821591,
0.0730734915,
0.0222393014,
-0.0211664718,
-0.0079029724,
-0.0133088026,
-0.0099680331,
0.0110330144,
-0.0196442138,
0.0662372634,
0.0469830148,
0.0167732965,
0.0400855988,
0.0585769415,
0.0092195431,
0.0028237251,
0.0046904623,
0.0083672786,
0.0238054115,
-0.0243707132,
-0.010743089,
-0.0283361208,
-0.0201566555,
0.0240591411,
-0.0459080562,
-0.0037659649,
0.0149134388,
2.72e-7,
0.0476089306,
0.0267879721,
0.0228367262,
-0.0192079544,
0.0127140777,
0.0415343754,
-0.0191518925,
0.0300894491,
0.0269907881,
0.0189456977,
0.0239641704,
0.0500257947,
0.054097455,
-0.0184948593,
-0.0737572759,
0.0346782096,
-0.0654868409,
0.0137203895,
-0.0211633965,
-0.0313725062,
0.028340783,
0.0707659647,
0.0306527577,
-0.0067092385,
-0.0083632246,
-0.0685720369,
0.0721131638,
-0.0421783999,
-0.0087424358,
-0.0057884934,
-0.0174131189,
0.0354221836,
-0.0174236428,
0.031680163,
-0.0248637907,
0.0240469147,
-0.0110349888,
0.0579784662,
-0.0105047934,
-0.0405776165,
-0.0402175784,
-0.0350897051,
0.0164588522,
-0.0448235087,
0.0918641314,
-0.1030076742,
-0.0131791858,
-0.0020160528,
-0.0258062072,
0.0080865826,
0.01718897,
-0.0031868524,
-0.01896392,
-0.0070300489,
0.0029583368,
0.041889403,
-0.0235474315,
-0.0861382112,
-0.0198634602,
0.0441953093,
0.0316555612,
-0.0673942193,
-0.0087706801,
-0.0532151274,
0.0015638698,
-0.1038763002,
0.0445868038,
2.308600421e-34,
0.0026123798,
-0.001811145,
0.0290990677,
-0.0128018931,
0.0261989329,
-0.022597773,
-0.0137111023,
0.0202031955,
0.0384099558,
-0.0645742267,
0.012803698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10787v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10787v1 | Adaptive Ordered Information Extraction with Deep Reinforcement Learning | 2023-06-19T08:58:56 | 2023-06-19T08:58:56 | Wenhao Huang, Jiaqing Liang, Zhixu Li, Yanghua Xiao, Chuanjun Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Information extraction (IE) has been studied extensively. The existing
methods always follow a fixed extraction order for complex IE tasks with
multiple elements to be extracted in one instance such as event extraction.
However, we conduct experiments on several complex IE datasets and observe that
different extraction orders can significantly affect the extraction results for
a great portion of instances, and the ratio of sentences that are sensitive to
extraction orders increases dramatically with the complexity of the IE task.
Therefore, this paper proposes a novel adaptive ordered IE paradigm to find the
optimal element extraction order for different instances, so as to achieve the
best extraction results. We also propose an reinforcement learning (RL) based
framework to generate optimal extraction order for each instance dynamically.
Additionally, we propose a co-training framework adapted to RL to mitigate the
exposure bias during the extractor training phase. Extensive experiments
conducted on several public datasets demonstrate that our proposed method can
beat previous methods and effectively improve the performance of various IE
tasks, especially for complex ones. | [
0.0332333073,
0.046450343,
0.0032716193,
0.0533460081,
-0.0225814339,
0.0661584139,
-0.0391254798,
0.0063164257,
0.0198331587,
0.0069346009,
-0.0231616721,
-0.001983349,
-0.0502790771,
0.0239053015,
-0.0434295014,
-0.0610493608,
0.0505280793,
-0.0121611608,
0.0798733085,
0.0475081652,
-0.0038179753,
-0.0100547019,
-0.0530325584,
-0.0227538589,
0.0029938153,
0.0027230936,
-0.0180978887,
-0.033855591,
0.0882615969,
-0.0672985613,
0.0344106406,
-0.0014728337,
0.0128985811,
0.0336647034,
0.0000018311,
-0.0073797111,
-0.0343903489,
0.0021569345,
-0.0358357131,
-0.0400505923,
-0.0228416864,
-0.0279836617,
-0.0307648536,
-0.0225576181,
-0.0467701703,
-0.0597068779,
0.0193891358,
0.0885070115,
0.027052626,
0.0945585668,
-0.023523923,
-0.0193697475,
0.0120814564,
-0.0415486209,
0.011035176,
-0.0320737474,
0.0489662327,
-0.0350898132,
0.0262463223,
0.0137342932,
0.0194175299,
0.0107166776,
0.0537545942,
0.0180057622,
-0.0536986329,
0.0383317396,
-0.0110449167,
-0.0097511951,
-0.0613390841,
0.1048240066,
-0.014497499,
0.0688432828,
0.0615271777,
-0.0483223945,
0.0111865429,
-0.0222815201,
-0.0167531837,
0.0320258141,
-0.0141353868,
0.034952879,
0.0464794971,
0.0370346755,
-0.0054142829,
0.0031815239,
-0.0405434445,
0.0728181973,
-0.0441223793,
-0.0576857403,
0.0137846144,
0.0042471308,
0.0261713155,
0.0125077581,
0.007673556,
0.0053759329,
-0.0055670766,
0.0162757207,
-0.0297489744,
-0.0224537533,
-0.0309375785,
-0.0535562597,
0.0064475155,
-0.0165232699,
-0.0014051623,
0.0761991292,
-0.0210107751,
0.034747988,
-0.0107129002,
0.0401665457,
0.0264924839,
0.0307408459,
-0.0204386786,
0.0074295113,
0.0080160126,
0.0928565636,
-0.0458210446,
0.0040476648,
-0.0253256857,
0.021846693,
-0.0239612032,
0.0096859727,
-0.0203972496,
0.0141677298,
-0.0390359834,
-0.0032967094,
-0.024672728,
-0.0288480725,
-0.0306827445,
0.0051435786,
0.0406289101,
-0.0172087215,
-0.0345068276,
-0.0269077756,
0.0482445732,
-0.0341815874,
0.0157868136,
0.0741943344,
-0.0169528238,
-0.0453695469,
-0.0165298078,
-0.0034003274,
0.0215563476,
-0.0135652833,
0.0081461677,
-0.0357448645,
0.052782122,
-0.0410996601,
-0.044763606,
-0.0123681752,
0.0257813931,
-0.0062016393,
-0.0908799469,
0.0202370342,
-0.001830604,
-0.0343044028,
-0.0143817803,
-0.0031093678,
0.0237031635,
0.0524942316,
0.0745592937,
0.0499530174,
0.0473464578,
0.0358459391,
0.0069583752,
0.0279451497,
-0.0177946016,
-0.0341229625,
0.0398058072,
-0.0035240364,
-0.0452875346,
-0.0069886772,
0.0487599857,
-0.0149858175,
-0.0403003283,
0.0015446232,
0.0136683239,
0.00416889,
0.03241653,
-0.0337091088,
0.0085560372,
0.0011187227,
0.003673475,
0.042685926,
-0.0377583019,
0.0220412351,
0.017207969,
0.0097632604,
-0.0296588894,
0.0128005538,
0.0148039693,
-0.0392365195,
0.0572957136,
-0.0289159734,
0.0089922873,
0.0169371273,
0.0232208651,
-0.0125130638,
-0.0481287539,
-0.0274771284,
0.0492335744,
-0.0090984125,
-0.0278513115,
0.0166128986,
0.0231292341,
0.03620952,
-0.008824422,
-0.1050691903,
-0.0414521359,
0.0179854147,
-0.0168477446,
0.0231424216,
0.0284621436,
-0.0461290926,
0.0636680201,
-0.0093261488,
-0.0362761468,
-0.0005502251,
-0.0096863769,
0.0166409723,
0.0303911008,
0.0174015164,
-0.0048227543,
0.0813428089,
-0.0478362739,
0.027138589,
-0.014701359,
-0.1011491045,
0.0242739767,
0.0200256687,
0.0324031338,
0.0049840091,
-0.0343726724,
-0.0212922469,
0.0455832854,
-0.0253050793,
-0.0290077291,
-0.0065334919,
-0.0646832138,
-0.0506007969,
-0.0100943623,
0.0118119838,
-0.0365181975,
0.0158970933,
-0.065241091,
-0.0050872844,
-0.0408437029,
0.0438188091,
0.0123248063,
-0.0088140154,
-0.0157692675,
0.0743688941,
0.0127381412,
-0.0653089508,
0.072565712,
-0.0103471568,
-0.0279731415,
0.0085035777,
-0.0428888761,
-0.0379915535,
-0.0350878388,
0.0192542002,
0.0409711003,
-0.0102069415,
-0.0190808214,
0.0518353842,
0.0359297432,
-0.0429151431,
-0.0373006836,
-0.0041489662,
0.022971252,
-0.0253486522,
0.0531345457,
0.0246831588,
0.0379807614,
-0.0319813341,
-0.0444358401,
-0.0331096686,
-0.0207268465,
-0.0080255866,
-0.006541606,
0.0508509167,
0.0710453689,
0.0354988128,
-0.0498036481,
0.0119501231,
-0.0365809575,
0.0279672854,
-0.0092322808,
-0.0069133663,
-0.0094476463,
-0.0154674686,
-0.0039161895,
0.0587914884,
-0.0072057354,
-0.0292385332,
-0.0197221469,
-0.0444906242,
0.0022838446,
0.0691318139,
0.022716606,
0.0946340635,
-0.0343313552,
-0.0016827048,
-0.0325233676,
0.0487148613,
-0.0738796666,
0.0580562167,
-0.023109071,
0.0020008241,
0.0402413607,
0.0692939535,
0.0021305922,
0.0562243238,
-0.0070415987,
0.0039208718,
0.0183085911,
-0.056500569,
-0.0102522783,
0.036486689,
-0.0304318089,
-0.012368557,
-0.0691459253,
0.0249707587,
0.0759362504,
0.0405878387,
-0.0062164171,
-0.0553620756,
-0.0328294858,
-0.0560794696,
0.0453689508,
0.007951824,
-0.0005430955,
0.0024326688,
-0.0428361073,
-0.0396653861,
-0.0303945467,
0.0370958708,
-0.0095850723,
0.0226010326,
-0.0123181073,
-0.0245906226,
-0.0311648734,
-0.0544717461,
-0.0561270788,
-0.0517398976,
0.0397179872,
0.0033027956,
-0.0005338446,
0.0031175914,
-0.0252133645,
-0.0308297705,
0.049367249,
0.0697633252,
-0.0213165861,
-0.0084384317,
-0.0467641614,
0.0981171206,
0.0543491729,
0.0208303817,
-0.0031383261,
-0.0218845364,
0.0171858817,
0.0728876069,
0.0208486803,
-0.0053225267,
0.0034117803,
0.0112088434,
0.0170882065,
-0.0889675021,
0.0206379518,
-0.0031855977,
-0.0165214501,
-0.0669331476,
0.0286339,
0.0619489215,
0.0311940759,
-0.0122537995,
-0.0060877232,
0.0314073861,
0.0126927877,
-0.0056716367,
0.0350657254,
-0.0694642365,
-0.0078316778,
-0.0187263861,
0.0060206414,
-0.0014530714,
-0.0638104752,
0.0171948113,
-0.068835102,
0.0156328324,
-0.0215486698,
-0.0379352719,
-0.0549077466,
-0.032005854,
0.0358379073,
-0.0125213545,
0.0007881277,
0.0464104414,
-0.0257334188,
-0.0001574079,
0.0241883714,
-0.0431434661,
-0.0395411812,
-0.0074396692,
-0.0228348654,
-0.0128326695,
0.0666117594,
0.0117030069,
-0.0209304765,
0.0610922724,
-0.0305759385,
-0.0126190707,
-0.046584636,
0.006286507,
0.0664672703,
-0.0371060222,
-0.0167001486,
-0.0254524294,
0.033366669,
0.0256918911,
-0.0096094506,
0.0272968784,
0.0419006385,
0.0182867292,
-0.0336914435,
-0.0045922413,
-0.0638969988,
0.0315795206,
0.0358587019,
-0.0116420379,
-0.0231015868,
-0.0140386298,
0.0007446148,
-0.0072521497,
-0.0994436964,
0.005438298,
0.0021473912,
-0.0101516955,
-0.0222588368,
-0.0825391039,
-0.0779866353,
-0.017881427,
0.0342932343,
-0.0201744772,
-0.0139149819,
0.0496457741,
0.0120755592,
-0.0428736918,
-0.0024841584,
0.0056664948,
-0.0411611013,
-0.0378290117,
-0.0180372093,
-0.0002222074,
-0.0160363819,
-0.0545398816,
0.0076527675,
-0.0076067122,
-0.028283583,
0.0162400007,
0.0317994542,
-0.007207456,
0.0539303459,
0.0197812151,
-0.005079133,
0.0637261346,
0.0015331444,
-0.0561361425,
-0.0276991874,
0.0628307611,
-0.0075068357,
0.0038451955,
0.0085731363,
-0.047808703,
0.0536225326,
-0.0179331731,
0.018523043,
-0.0492090695,
-0.0095492378,
0.0107419034,
0.0044329846,
0.0621172898,
0.0202177856,
-0.039322108,
-0.0747597441,
0.0387761034,
-0.0250425506,
-0.0216411483,
-0.0210126061,
0.0378841758,
0.000613237,
0.019840816,
-0.0189694129,
0.0211060271,
0.0532081909,
-0.0078684799,
-0.0577533245,
0.0328421071,
0.0313127935,
0.0245359764,
0.0018510896,
0.0114846183,
-0.0010555026,
0.0580324419,
0.0046936111,
0.0542646386,
-0.0481262058,
0.0134782111,
0.0552356914,
-0.0273185745,
0.0013523349,
0.0332263634,
-0.059333995,
0.0440270752,
-0.014130841,
0.0028794589,
0.0440787412,
-0.0193822514,
0.0252470728,
-0.0130309053,
0.0014653256,
0.0045031672,
0.010219356,
-0.0189254116,
0.0349572003,
-0.0030644936,
0.0382858478,
-0.0089567984,
0.0374584422,
0.063004978,
-0.0094479909,
0.0237292871,
0.0089593893,
0.015722001,
-0.0545384549,
-0.0034797452,
0.021691069,
0.0326829143,
-0.0346597359,
-0.0110046584,
-0.0004877454,
0.0288003646,
0.0192284454,
0.014132686,
0.0021653296,
-0.0141199557,
0.0377304628,
0.0362405777,
0.003267311,
-0.0103874281,
-0.0701169223,
-0.0206262693,
0.005427903,
-0.0410244986,
0.0027124688,
-5.882614909e-33,
-0.0303027965,
0.0060095331,
0.0181900915,
0.0357893929,
-0.0072276099,
0.0379849188,
-0.0124916667,
-0.0330044888,
-0.0011436829,
0.0173271168,
0.0001409185,
-0.0508484878,
0.0238605626,
-0.0032641368,
-0.0082268575,
-0.0273724254,
0.004119765,
0.0047748354,
-0.0172791295,
0.0168566387,
0.0517516583,
0.0781370401,
0.0811079368,
-0.0888525099,
0.0047338991,
0.0286001563,
0.0158813782,
0.001514144,
0.040001031,
0.0532677807,
0.0228541829,
-0.0177758578,
0.0229612924,
-0.0596514903,
0.0320473313,
0.0194886401,
-0.1391735226,
-0.0423217043,
-0.0461837165,
-0.0046732295,
-0.048140768,
-0.0190746076,
-0.0060292655,
-0.0042882999,
0.0555830896,
-0.0168258157,
0.0328380726,
-0.0054797046,
0.0095255105,
-0.0234684907,
-0.0446282215,
0.0365289003,
0.0007915929,
0.0252554771,
0.0637669861,
0.013016995,
0.0184078161,
0.0238956325,
-0.0225120727,
-0.0071551381,
-0.0023755203,
0.0448275805,
-0.0161807723,
0.0284078494,
-0.021743536,
0.0707404017,
0.0101244226,
-0.0284204744,
-0.0001492134,
0.0102511989,
-0.0019073561,
0.0663126782,
-0.0534108877,
0.0390363857,
-0.0019850738,
0.0345692188,
-0.1122153848,
0.0325537659,
0.0818448365,
0.0090148998,
-0.0308699571,
0.0009057923,
-0.0785839036,
0.0457559936,
0.0332583599,
0.0422056727,
0.013014528,
-0.0140360566,
0.0187602788,
0.0351407342,
-0.0306770857,
0.0155975027,
0.022912262,
-0.0037449638,
-0.0184451528,
0.0122830365,
-0.0378816053,
0.0166413113,
-0.0132281687,
-0.0257432051,
-0.0883404687,
-0.0453748778,
-0.0032475572,
-0.0064170691,
0.0272495653,
0.0191582385,
0.0486516431,
-0.0002642086,
-0.0457153507,
0.0018761884,
0.0180809386,
0.0568370223,
0.0089185629,
0.0215386543,
-0.0265126489,
-0.0189462081,
-0.010127251,
0.0308981873,
0.0414344333,
0.0058433865,
-0.0212993287,
-0.0205508415,
-0.0022917092,
0.0244969074,
0.0180901345,
0.0007990806,
-0.0176073331,
0.02574444,
-0.0355370715,
-0.052353546,
0.0113270767,
0.0248198826,
2.557e-7,
-0.0337054767,
0.0230818298,
0.0640260503,
0.031815961,
0.0061455625,
0.0364741273,
0.0082883425,
0.0235133953,
-0.0358721316,
0.0444531143,
0.0377980396,
0.0209511388,
-0.0120274229,
-0.000467763,
-0.0725752115,
-0.036209438,
-0.0708929896,
-0.0283111762,
-0.0477830507,
-0.0503858514,
0.0015703979,
0.0594367422,
0.0344653018,
0.0087277917,
-0.0402223542,
-0.0111694019,
0.0034960543,
0.0183008946,
-0.0008447965,
0.0160307586,
0.0033860877,
0.0108234389,
-0.0538407825,
0.0029496283,
-0.0259429459,
0.0496393293,
-0.0170784574,
0.0624827333,
-0.0187542755,
-0.0380403586,
0.0203888547,
-0.0106098587,
0.0214269124,
-0.0022422918,
0.0574871451,
-0.0733709335,
-0.0033028612,
0.0093569625,
-0.0514256395,
0.0047511719,
-0.0712023675,
-0.0125369579,
-0.0276654996,
0.0273766536,
0.0255300142,
-0.0081184702,
-0.0436657891,
-0.0709062889,
0.0179778542,
0.0452457927,
0.0268472414,
-0.0061467504,
-0.0093244929,
0.0007391686,
-0.0080802971,
-0.0569940358,
-0.0204654615,
2.269149729e-34,
-0.0279019363,
0.0049609747,
-0.029240042,
0.045775827,
0.0196117572,
0.0011989633,
-0.0526688211,
0.0059507033,
0.0037020019,
-0.0224312488,
-0.0107621914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10786v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10786v1 | AMRs Assemble! Learning to Ensemble with Autoregressive Models for AMR Parsing | 2023-06-19T08:58:47 | 2023-06-19T08:58:47 | Abelardo Carlos Martínez Lorenzo, Pere-Lluís Huguet Cabot, Roberto Navigli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this paper, we examine the current state-of-the-art in AMR parsing, which
relies on ensemble strategies by merging multiple graph predictions. Our
analysis reveals that the present models often violate AMR structural
constraints. To address this issue, we develop a validation method, and show
how ensemble models can exploit SMATCH metric weaknesses to obtain higher
scores, but sometimes result in corrupted graphs. Additionally, we highlight
the demanding need to compute the SMATCH score among all possible predictions.
To overcome these challenges, we propose two novel ensemble strategies based on
Transformer models, improving robustness to structural constraints, while also
reducing the computational time. Our methods provide new insights for enhancing
AMR parsers and metrics. Our code is available at
\href{https://www.github.com/babelscape/AMRs-Assemble}{github.com/babelscape/AMRs-Assemble}. | [
-0.0128112212,
0.0864699557,
0.0106945401,
-0.0233396627,
-0.0066962517,
0.0264052339,
0.0065252283,
-0.0488611534,
-0.0109665468,
-0.0169316977,
0.0063961362,
-0.0446768552,
0.0143631669,
0.0217800383,
-0.0071430136,
-0.0029696997,
0.0387535132,
-0.0144878551,
-0.0001264438,
0.004223791,
0.0040047388,
0.0263797976,
0.0098083885,
0.0537742712,
-0.028455697,
-0.0166386738,
-0.0031724472,
-0.0150428191,
0.0108848708,
-0.0221774001,
-0.0181318074,
0.0310855526,
-0.0243789591,
0.0583467484,
0.0000018559,
-0.0283687115,
-0.0799353495,
0.0443104953,
-0.0264205374,
-0.0647235885,
0.041778896,
-0.0047082002,
-0.0069508557,
0.0318955928,
-0.0485703275,
-0.0660330802,
0.0427638106,
0.0071277865,
0.0519930832,
0.0910360143,
-0.0294934511,
-0.0438006148,
0.0126928044,
-0.0190218557,
-0.0483397059,
-0.0040243459,
-0.0030847136,
0.0114262011,
-0.027123129,
-0.0407678075,
-0.0415055864,
0.0341352969,
-0.0040787188,
-0.0038177993,
0.0515620224,
0.007984804,
-0.0268786605,
-0.0230640899,
-0.0114834411,
0.0432690978,
0.0103125582,
-0.0170443095,
0.0146223577,
0.0009732738,
-0.0289780255,
0.0406068079,
-0.0499791354,
0.0365406834,
-0.0414824225,
0.044455003,
-0.0123588806,
0.0251062084,
0.0330516398,
0.0045899595,
-0.0175326038,
0.0945036486,
-0.0106099956,
-0.0256233606,
0.0333484262,
0.0491721928,
-0.0606711619,
0.0064088958,
0.0348232314,
-0.0347480513,
-0.0337858796,
-0.002605764,
-0.0165219065,
-0.039943181,
-0.0197896007,
0.0696266443,
0.073596552,
0.0084617948,
-0.0006212492,
0.0186110791,
-0.0072585009,
0.0531974435,
0.0058692074,
-0.0342913307,
-0.035498701,
0.0108807972,
-0.0883425847,
0.0218208358,
-0.0421474054,
0.0290499441,
-0.0205855649,
-0.0357280374,
-0.0664952472,
0.011687926,
-0.0146627631,
0.0331780612,
0.094900839,
0.0132433241,
-0.0241509881,
0.0096410057,
0.0257019494,
0.0552977286,
0.016399201,
-0.0069206124,
0.0176752042,
-0.0287649594,
-0.0317512825,
0.0592315905,
0.026515929,
-0.0343055278,
-0.0167207643,
0.019847054,
0.0013770167,
0.0214213468,
0.0412396342,
-0.0366421603,
-0.0394181646,
-0.0235606655,
0.0283159427,
-0.0558066107,
0.0335842334,
0.0271962695,
0.0501399897,
-0.000167551,
0.0010875495,
-0.0062499684,
0.0296857506,
0.0472794883,
-0.0108405063,
0.0000351213,
-0.0414851122,
-0.0295691546,
-0.034611918,
0.0419766903,
0.0291397385,
0.0426167324,
0.0035782233,
-0.0018309654,
0.0133118099,
0.0173453204,
-0.028939832,
-0.0218911264,
0.0172462035,
-0.0000995394,
-0.0456966795,
0.0049528428,
0.0106907729,
0.0605889745,
-0.0065109138,
-0.0147326468,
0.008537136,
0.0115520628,
0.0007624623,
0.0456864946,
0.0306334905,
0.0010513193,
-0.0081698168,
-0.0097034825,
-0.0231489744,
0.0099323243,
-0.0633812174,
0.0616525412,
-0.0261181295,
0.0582626462,
0.0193954799,
-0.0312659964,
-0.032386668,
-0.0145900119,
-0.0217894819,
0.0013948893,
0.055785019,
0.0014132238,
-0.0418443009,
0.053653501,
-0.022883201,
-0.0514421239,
-0.0013585574,
-0.0266900938,
-0.0395914987,
0.0095132962,
0.0390255935,
-0.028950708,
-0.0038792859,
-0.059284728,
0.0032945825,
0.0111790393,
-0.0272849873,
-0.0039650528,
0.0064191432,
-0.0598931983,
-0.040084254,
0.0268217232,
0.0308478344,
0.004210359,
0.0031276082,
-0.010342557,
-0.0120773623,
-0.019408375,
-0.0464035496,
-0.0057891705,
-0.0046115262,
0.0113396673,
-0.0129982978,
0.01966618,
0.0359982289,
0.0388984457,
-0.02157766,
0.0336428173,
0.0319202431,
-0.0449803136,
-0.0412929319,
0.0763358027,
-0.0775694698,
-0.073677808,
0.0580299869,
-0.0530818962,
-0.0222344995,
0.0006335137,
-0.0306813903,
-0.0577499494,
0.0183364693,
-0.0787727833,
0.0380511917,
0.0070703458,
0.0560124181,
0.032668978,
0.0039638374,
-0.0059769,
0.0702046975,
-0.0517012514,
-0.0074899136,
-0.0407682471,
-0.0368155986,
0.0012671893,
-0.0275307056,
-0.0203993395,
0.0115477815,
0.0068354872,
0.0055317702,
0.0343417488,
-0.0396383032,
-0.0470756367,
-0.0236762259,
-0.0375456288,
-0.0252183005,
-0.0431816541,
0.0606643371,
0.0022193366,
0.0168022439,
0.0258359145,
0.0211763885,
0.00369857,
-0.0183420554,
0.0113881361,
0.0111214472,
0.0103804655,
-0.0088188257,
-0.0434140079,
-0.0029509151,
-0.0363340862,
-0.0446100421,
0.0814577043,
0.0104907192,
-0.0893115997,
-0.0135098137,
0.0069849365,
-0.0023597379,
-0.005014997,
-0.0246432219,
-0.0257481001,
0.0055166557,
-0.0567725562,
-0.0064976783,
0.0315569639,
-0.0402030014,
0.0564923771,
0.0099881105,
-0.0186837446,
-0.0119383996,
-0.0106095457,
0.020734448,
0.0153879663,
-0.0178208482,
-0.0688140094,
0.0247282125,
0.0719458237,
0.0096154995,
0.0132127665,
-0.0296106227,
-0.0126637332,
-0.0569522344,
-0.0401651934,
0.0088255526,
-0.0133411475,
0.0057332222,
-0.0150175961,
-0.0296142623,
-0.0308130551,
0.093701601,
-0.0300033726,
-0.0633078739,
-0.0110217938,
-0.0358178131,
-0.0708198249,
0.026593348,
0.0160703305,
0.0037249455,
0.0369523093,
-0.0738388598,
-0.0108983768,
-0.0100958571,
0.0625124872,
-0.038579043,
0.0506603159,
0.0043075536,
0.0354556441,
0.0030969472,
-0.0182402879,
0.0146745043,
-0.0333908573,
-0.0286269523,
0.0564724207,
-0.0049781161,
-0.0369742624,
-0.0845342726,
0.0387876518,
0.0009469584,
-0.0223157015,
-0.0355921723,
-0.009444057,
-0.0109869922,
0.0453912802,
0.0692032948,
-0.0024880609,
0.0060563269,
-0.0500799045,
0.0669500008,
0.0175964385,
0.0477400571,
-0.0073355292,
-0.0714331716,
0.0258104242,
-0.0021027194,
-0.0034982373,
0.0079404656,
-0.0513578653,
0.0552363805,
-0.0202180557,
0.0191324316,
0.0775896311,
0.0300804153,
0.0002995453,
-0.0073461276,
0.0215119086,
0.0681610331,
0.0236667618,
-0.0124703115,
-0.0957748815,
-0.0261039324,
0.0075716707,
0.0337526761,
0.0166844297,
-0.0713228881,
0.0187533926,
-0.1075801253,
0.0063233296,
0.0480767526,
-0.0278628692,
-0.0223918781,
-0.0133736646,
-0.0361198336,
-0.0904972851,
0.0354637429,
0.0157812182,
-0.047033444,
0.0134241059,
0.0475752652,
-0.021661574,
-0.0396555029,
-0.0261635054,
-0.0311733261,
0.0274312925,
0.0338429175,
0.0082808826,
-0.0219962001,
-0.002865674,
-0.0088703576,
-0.0069364002,
0.0293636844,
-0.0294330455,
0.0091313785,
0.0220141243,
-0.0056510195,
-0.0182306673,
-0.0180457458,
-0.0045945523,
-0.0072040567,
-0.0336054042,
0.1017512158,
-0.0089414259,
-0.0276210681,
0.0251220167,
-0.0317559205,
0.0056635845,
0.0264274385,
0.0238926318,
0.0621439964,
-0.0642877519,
-0.065008536,
0.0412491933,
-0.0681747273,
0.0416898541,
0.0442613252,
-0.008779482,
-0.035021089,
-0.0359159559,
-0.0460324101,
0.0630261898,
0.0198480729,
-0.0455052294,
0.0052430183,
0.0086519672,
0.0113092884,
-0.0460073352,
0.0454179347,
0.0165035911,
0.0328085832,
-0.0516352355,
-0.02786313,
0.0248075984,
0.0342429094,
-0.0274265371,
-0.0279684588,
-0.0634117052,
-0.0886693075,
0.0167972408,
0.0409851633,
0.0223895628,
0.0098662032,
-0.0226153526,
-0.0338906273,
0.0233204979,
0.057564944,
-0.0129440576,
-0.0053000362,
0.0605416745,
-0.0014603402,
-0.0298919529,
0.0122813368,
-0.0363222137,
0.0298399292,
-0.0435652286,
0.0810818821,
-0.0415998287,
-0.0116172098,
0.0651500896,
0.0713085309,
0.0347509757,
-0.0159956105,
-0.0340601541,
0.0054831933,
-0.0034382411,
0.000317433,
-0.0271412078,
-0.0197328106,
0.0520550273,
0.0337157063,
-0.0161911398,
0.0014013301,
0.0569083467,
0.009416149,
0.0090329917,
-0.0133137079,
0.0893405527,
0.030186139,
-0.0194297191,
0.0241137296,
0.0388504677,
-0.0352733992,
-0.0043178829,
0.0591119044,
0.0208546855,
0.0174611602,
-0.0209741741,
-0.004320649,
0.0277022012,
-0.0474244505,
0.0314594135,
-0.0493670888,
0.0286625605,
0.000657366,
0.0164305549,
0.0441102907,
-0.0183522608,
0.117552653,
0.0260085408,
0.0242669806,
-0.0388190821,
0.0375738293,
0.0135455774,
0.0046722107,
0.0359924957,
0.0256100241,
-0.0089338785,
-0.0048337448,
0.0487479679,
-0.0259865522,
0.024247976,
0.0060719685,
-0.0318307616,
-0.0549283773,
-0.0159492139,
-0.0534483828,
-0.048952952,
-0.0115506835,
-0.0209394787,
-0.0274640098,
-0.0535669066,
0.0083618071,
0.0051124096,
0.0424048193,
-0.0084424652,
-0.0257635023,
0.0230015106,
0.0319778956,
-0.0232003387,
-0.0131789055,
-0.0208247174,
-0.0348465815,
0.0020668402,
-0.0431447104,
-6.160256022e-33,
-0.0325946361,
-0.0450333096,
-0.0160962529,
-0.0739945173,
-0.0317501128,
-0.0233622491,
-0.0452499986,
-0.0149690127,
0.0165196043,
0.0268272255,
-0.0210500769,
0.0020045347,
0.0345790945,
-0.0035811146,
0.0312107261,
0.0087576732,
0.0691799819,
0.0066836574,
-0.0020863318,
-0.0209974609,
0.0264578257,
0.0498538576,
0.0367442109,
0.0202780273,
-0.0162027776,
0.0124568064,
-0.0428874455,
-0.004850009,
0.01680962,
0.0753434598,
0.033656612,
0.0492438935,
0.0162939169,
0.0189363025,
-0.0348491073,
-0.0114391996,
-0.0881116167,
-0.0156284329,
0.0138030238,
0.0168030038,
0.0124580534,
0.0018905686,
0.0336711146,
-0.0408760495,
0.0136398645,
-0.0429455005,
0.0373286866,
-0.0102158505,
-0.0087791709,
-0.0346397385,
0.0162605438,
0.0511379614,
0.0072467425,
0.0465886071,
0.0783225894,
0.0380177125,
0.0319364443,
-0.0005890059,
-0.0123808114,
0.0273731276,
-0.0047699008,
0.0596752316,
0.0462704375,
0.0457792617,
0.015228319,
0.0354694948,
0.0049540936,
-0.0384959392,
0.0224364176,
0.0177408941,
-0.0384252407,
0.0547398329,
0.0080729891,
-0.026003547,
-0.0115697701,
0.0112142749,
0.0067612915,
-0.0027315631,
0.0648225993,
0.074827686,
-0.0457554795,
0.0309856702,
-0.0569526516,
-0.0195829365,
0.0277355928,
-0.0266390406,
-0.0157475006,
-0.0110019473,
0.0031251265,
0.0067810467,
-0.0229201391,
0.0718257427,
0.0251078736,
-0.0243284553,
-0.0269523188,
-0.0027933167,
0.0347598307,
0.0265688505,
-0.0156697556,
0.0327835344,
-0.0059807091,
0.0016304916,
0.0221495926,
0.0180407036,
0.0391148888,
-0.01804219,
0.0203151368,
0.0382204168,
-0.067038022,
0.0052946252,
-0.0378536806,
0.0230576955,
-0.009176732,
-0.0037867962,
0.0283611584,
0.0207607187,
-0.0368750766,
0.0195767116,
-0.007873131,
0.0515178442,
-0.025112465,
0.0561613701,
0.0021548227,
0.0066636396,
-0.0316231139,
-0.0022365493,
0.0172279291,
-0.0050410642,
0.0634414777,
-0.0173681471,
-0.0619115531,
0.0046108137,
2.606e-7,
0.0535518117,
0.0529784523,
0.0546433851,
-0.006744361,
-0.0272892769,
-0.0010286954,
-0.0845350921,
-0.0168746188,
-0.0071533783,
0.0079589505,
-0.0141419685,
-0.022363212,
0.0523812436,
0.0632158816,
-0.0427333713,
0.0299492776,
-0.0860430524,
0.0085694827,
-0.0104289977,
-0.0000643623,
0.043145258,
0.0634254143,
-0.0157758463,
0.0135901272,
-0.0516486727,
-0.0311094485,
0.0093918452,
0.0307168923,
-0.0126652988,
-0.0051559312,
0.0087758349,
-0.0622546412,
-0.0178900529,
-0.0088264327,
0.016403934,
0.017970223,
0.0179706942,
0.0264258869,
-0.0388127863,
0.0218402985,
0.030206982,
-0.0005112584,
0.0030400646,
0.012220229,
0.0274759512,
-0.0465817824,
-0.0208041184,
-0.0560045391,
-0.0887846798,
0.0210351534,
0.0074428115,
0.0367241204,
0.004052042,
0.0251829792,
0.0214516111,
-0.0248608142,
-0.0081319185,
-0.0442732647,
-0.034683533,
0.0314094014,
0.0000647249,
-0.0657044575,
0.0206736214,
0.0446923971,
0.001043739,
-0.0449092314,
-0.0377035625,
2.6039583e-34,
0.0839279145,
0.0202504992,
0.0236308202,
0.0490019992,
0.0390233137,
-0.0466898978,
-0.058913555,
0.0483873188,
-0.0243565515,
-0.1108039692,
-0.0286481977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10769v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10769v1 | Gender Differences in Abuse: The Case of Dutch Politicians on Twitter | 2023-06-19T08:23:24 | 2023-06-19T08:23:24 | Isabelle van der Vegt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Online abuse and threats towards politicians have become a significant
concern in the Netherlands, like in many other countries across the world. This
paper analyses gender differences in abuse received by Dutch politicians on
Twitter, while taking into account the possible additional impact of ethnic
minority status. All tweets directed at party leaders throughout the entire
year of 2022 were collected. The effect of gender and ethnic minority status
were estimated for six different linguistic measures of abuse, namely,
toxicity, severe toxicity, identity attacks, profanity, insults, and threats.
Contrary to expectations, male politicians received higher levels of all forms
of abuse, with the exception of threats, for which no significant gender
difference was found. Significant interaction effects between gender and ethnic
minority status were found for a number of abuse measures. In the case of
severe toxicity, identity attacks, and profanity, female ethnic minority
politicians were more severely impacted than their ethnic majority female
colleagues, but not worse than male politicians. Finally, female ethnic
minority politicians received the highest levels of threats compared to all
groups. Given that online abuse and threats are reported to have a negative
effect on political participation and retention, these results are particularly
worrying. | [
0.0631154776,
0.0416602418,
-0.0386862233,
-0.0054107737,
-0.0069299745,
0.0092905806,
0.0625487342,
0.0032223866,
0.0475529544,
0.0055999965,
0.0731321499,
-0.0496118031,
0.0123028019,
0.0023252587,
0.0748998672,
-0.0775214657,
0.0336147621,
0.0400212146,
0.0487109721,
-0.0415395983,
0.0601728074,
0.0111580165,
0.024373401,
0.0340561196,
-0.007639315,
0.0251538306,
0.0228359569,
0.0298968218,
0.0711882263,
0.0161698442,
0.0021089851,
-0.0040669232,
0.0091962274,
0.0040735858,
0.0000015977,
-0.0704033077,
0.0148825618,
0.0143861081,
-0.0053791744,
-0.0477949977,
0.0647854656,
-0.0233571697,
-0.0580198355,
0.0506250821,
0.0033305653,
-0.0146193663,
0.0056664553,
-0.0009447331,
0.0964260995,
0.01715542,
-0.0048609357,
0.0384188034,
-0.0365522653,
-0.0022343686,
-0.0015256364,
0.0622472689,
0.0335571319,
-0.0702620968,
-0.0717020854,
0.0108738346,
0.0296465456,
0.0037157258,
-0.0074239937,
-0.0084911482,
-0.0322577842,
-0.0117953438,
-0.0369910263,
-0.0493327491,
0.0440878458,
0.000107043,
0.0002893085,
0.0278967973,
-0.0034719359,
0.0308370013,
0.0005942495,
0.0333520733,
-0.0242904965,
0.0333042853,
-0.049456913,
-0.026335381,
0.005479224,
0.0342184268,
-0.0094559425,
0.0709156841,
0.0055831377,
0.0312748104,
-0.0019975603,
-0.0527546704,
0.0140755251,
-0.0544351973,
0.0131510636,
-0.0221103709,
-0.0199789628,
-0.0068563581,
0.0409304462,
-0.0095370281,
0.0051277806,
-0.0462475084,
0.0472946018,
-0.0825216025,
-0.0093601765,
0.0333662145,
-0.0011394591,
0.0009047171,
0.0436840877,
0.0108508114,
-0.0074884561,
-0.00761403,
0.0248461869,
-0.0336687304,
-0.0100399526,
0.0251491591,
0.0195866805,
-0.0248018224,
0.0197278652,
0.0573171414,
-0.0485235937,
0.0151326768,
-0.0357045606,
0.0217323676,
-0.0047138119,
-0.0254143104,
-0.0209777001,
-0.0199928544,
-0.0141791999,
0.0246510357,
-0.0721152574,
-0.0109322434,
-0.0593277067,
-0.0724659786,
0.0186189637,
0.0293725096,
0.0154236443,
-0.0361047536,
0.0192584395,
0.0759572461,
0.0061928467,
-0.0066927872,
0.0014544607,
-0.0001222663,
-0.0184121486,
-0.0311706606,
0.0214136653,
-0.0278426893,
0.0226232074,
0.0187485032,
-0.0312369466,
-0.02044544,
0.0457243584,
0.0106476564,
-0.0068318779,
0.0085113822,
-0.0026024189,
0.0509819277,
0.0579727031,
0.044933103,
-0.0287973676,
0.0211158786,
0.0140701532,
0.0045444327,
0.0161486249,
0.0048330408,
-0.0059834179,
0.0624641143,
0.0181213841,
0.0389767848,
-0.0065958113,
0.0319483131,
-0.0384447053,
-0.081515342,
0.0359782279,
-0.014855233,
0.0023802964,
0.0140530737,
0.0180805605,
0.0399875455,
0.0012729258,
0.0528003462,
-0.000581718,
0.006760417,
-0.0293925591,
-0.0215352606,
-0.0254696719,
-0.0379182287,
0.0133233741,
-0.0153973242,
0.025892796,
0.0650781915,
-0.0169637315,
0.0080522345,
0.0150763504,
0.0205944106,
0.0685004219,
-0.0207588822,
0.0110507039,
0.0188529827,
-0.0021087544,
0.0038091785,
0.0464689806,
-0.0514133312,
-0.0035483958,
-0.0202301051,
-0.0051228427,
0.0336003378,
-0.0568934865,
0.035287533,
0.0207232069,
-0.0722453669,
0.0089601353,
0.0493300185,
0.0051343855,
0.0120209111,
-0.0149004022,
0.0142563051,
0.0286441576,
0.069845207,
-0.0173596907,
0.0503083095,
0.0823658183,
0.0518178791,
-0.0087698735,
0.0405335203,
-0.034102153,
-0.0097193662,
0.0241840724,
-0.0269725695,
-0.0035466242,
0.0218313262,
0.0511085279,
-0.0088280682,
-0.0431904793,
-0.058608681,
-0.0053812135,
-0.0208117329,
0.0125252763,
-0.0188883729,
-0.0182904713,
0.0326424949,
0.0098180184,
-0.0207076855,
-0.0650587454,
-0.0147806769,
0.0221616719,
0.0477403887,
0.1355798393,
0.0147300316,
-0.0622442402,
0.0064933165,
-0.0474518575,
-0.0541047305,
-0.0126384012,
0.0059393453,
0.0491719618,
-0.0489593595,
-0.0337159596,
-0.001906284,
-0.0500158668,
0.0202816091,
-0.0114376936,
-0.0396268256,
-0.0470035076,
-0.0190078523,
-0.0006505555,
-0.0231601428,
-0.0167084951,
-0.0329221673,
-0.0023827457,
-0.0104010953,
0.001694189,
-0.0215198006,
0.0193526614,
0.0245622359,
0.0723351836,
-0.0211037062,
0.0481272116,
0.0178552847,
-0.0837637186,
0.030555306,
0.0218461324,
-0.0130722011,
-0.0336541273,
-0.0346067622,
-0.0388089269,
-0.0062078657,
-0.0504900105,
0.0134112276,
-0.0199986752,
-0.1354858726,
0.0784696862,
-0.0032127055,
-0.0469091274,
0.0057097636,
-0.0495267324,
-0.0570119992,
0.0343135074,
0.007580549,
0.0262194928,
0.0309500154,
0.1004432142,
0.0788106099,
-0.0061381902,
-0.0104304636,
-0.0242688823,
-0.0058235903,
-0.0300269965,
0.038374722,
0.0158357434,
-0.0441496111,
0.0043378095,
0.0079458086,
0.0034335004,
0.016169928,
-0.0024217227,
0.0306270067,
-0.0689060763,
-0.0042248722,
-0.0713712797,
-0.0277323499,
0.0000154241,
-0.0361302979,
0.0015873713,
-0.0096838418,
-0.0234646127,
0.0100144716,
0.0334710926,
0.0367247835,
-0.0705631599,
0.0110984109,
0.0822972879,
-0.0088486765,
0.0195111483,
0.0181990657,
-0.0088853501,
0.0069202348,
-0.0623919815,
0.063957423,
-0.0174219739,
-0.0033585869,
0.012845234,
0.0383805521,
-0.0458528847,
-0.001598477,
-0.0058253198,
-0.0900325924,
-0.0066465917,
-0.002042867,
-0.0176723972,
-0.0149148908,
-0.0170312468,
0.0333016738,
0.04762128,
-0.0919084251,
0.0001379281,
-0.0032734158,
0.0069470229,
-0.016252812,
-0.0483787358,
-0.0333776101,
0.0108104823,
-0.0125580803,
-0.0308364239,
0.0112789106,
-0.0630097985,
-0.0087955687,
0.0124299657,
-0.0072179311,
0.0134406751,
-0.0107128937,
0.0095668379,
-0.0478677303,
0.0113855144,
-0.0088620009,
0.0216464289,
0.0304066613,
0.0088151684,
0.0499221943,
-0.0240163151,
-0.0160234571,
0.0260492433,
0.0387226492,
-0.0163821336,
-0.0784911886,
0.0797825456,
0.0247491244,
-0.0347312093,
-0.0706148222,
0.0021349259,
-0.0408757702,
-0.0499148443,
-0.0040539862,
0.0002637474,
-0.0186796486,
-0.0105335629,
0.0159618277,
0.0097680055,
0.0188899469,
0.02068891,
0.0096440911,
0.0370261706,
-0.0062757656,
-0.0052503692,
-0.1242984906,
-0.0158621278,
-0.0175274219,
-0.0464247502,
0.0280407593,
-0.0086093647,
0.0694001615,
-0.0289549083,
0.0485316217,
0.0438745469,
-0.0385323651,
-0.0264936462,
-0.0113587389,
0.0440057404,
-0.0457617715,
0.0061964043,
-0.051883284,
0.0307976641,
0.0647000074,
0.0040796292,
0.0009618972,
-0.0110158427,
0.0535669737,
0.0020527763,
-0.0149933966,
0.0036522904,
0.0541324206,
-0.0085705286,
0.0265733879,
0.0044852034,
0.0090000052,
-0.0828650445,
-0.0358653143,
0.0114791589,
-0.078569442,
-0.0259619728,
-0.0057669003,
-0.0208666567,
0.0125943664,
-0.0341509916,
0.0009464134,
0.0006498694,
-0.0009145151,
-0.0144268461,
0.0034449957,
-0.0131261582,
0.0079017989,
-0.0193174705,
0.0155190211,
0.0255166832,
0.0702015087,
-0.0086117638,
-0.0510341451,
0.0340910107,
-0.0141117824,
-0.0129447877,
-0.031481944,
-0.021832373,
0.0691300929,
-0.018960353,
0.0207370445,
0.0378750227,
0.0277952198,
-0.0159018543,
-0.0129106781,
0.0299875084,
0.0016990304,
0.0004162234,
0.0229758602,
0.0704843178,
0.0362025499,
-0.0078170542,
0.0070081721,
0.0434019193,
0.0763332918,
-0.0882457197,
-0.0703566894,
0.0232623648,
-0.0247063469,
-0.0155483987,
-0.02064435,
-0.0020707785,
-0.0921459869,
-0.011509696,
-0.0462197177,
0.0105093662,
-0.0451834537,
0.0294003841,
-0.023686491,
-0.0034485445,
0.0270802528,
0.010573566,
-0.0321908668,
-0.0542774759,
0.0178767294,
-0.047715418,
0.0275717881,
0.0338044837,
0.0205921736,
0.009778766,
-0.0183491725,
0.0373058133,
0.0095448503,
-0.0034466304,
-0.0202306453,
-0.0141614033,
-0.0382360406,
-0.0234952718,
0.0016825204,
0.0309362225,
-0.0156476069,
-0.0016137226,
-0.0106337769,
-0.0127578983,
-0.0126895672,
-0.0290751904,
0.0091108102,
0.0573813953,
0.0380669273,
0.0035837269,
0.0045845904,
0.0084713688,
-0.0548309535,
-0.0373151749,
0.0237415228,
0.0136258211,
-0.0267704409,
0.0296312515,
0.0134397717,
0.0286510438,
0.0030788502,
0.0355561823,
-0.0093924347,
0.0132695762,
0.0029517603,
-0.0089624785,
-0.0085203918,
0.0145289414,
-0.039594613,
-0.0335485823,
-0.0058527058,
-0.016566243,
-0.0272299163,
0.0063222647,
0.034829583,
-0.0180339422,
0.0215985086,
0.0266005136,
0.0567337722,
0.0016412596,
0.0191692319,
-0.0007583362,
-0.0746815503,
0.0038007498,
-5.279902221e-33,
-0.0195062533,
-0.0399679244,
-0.0128034921,
-0.0461466834,
-0.0184020698,
-0.0242815819,
0.0263641011,
0.0202447791,
-0.0355040058,
-0.0068829441,
0.005417217,
0.0137217119,
0.0172845554,
-0.0283180606,
-0.0341762416,
-0.0457382128,
0.0054704929,
0.0108847227,
0.0008121605,
-0.0249414444,
0.0401819982,
-0.0148714408,
0.0006441074,
-0.0696678311,
0.0561707541,
0.0128273033,
-0.024693286,
-0.0250652861,
0.0487135164,
0.0058154329,
0.0102019999,
0.017269589,
0.0221812315,
-0.0081368824,
0.0204265546,
0.1353100836,
-0.0450300351,
-0.0243296921,
-0.0240388792,
0.0023297875,
0.026373921,
-0.0185272954,
-0.0015520771,
0.0191905741,
-0.0472298488,
-0.0442992225,
0.0394266285,
0.0562468283,
0.0405395776,
-0.0153708756,
-0.0347361639,
0.0251941737,
-0.0483690463,
0.0398331732,
-0.0491123274,
0.0603507645,
0.0498231575,
-0.0200217217,
-0.0860599726,
0.0321483836,
-0.0461957604,
-0.0078026876,
-0.0120119406,
-0.0239694007,
-0.0028923862,
-0.0108216181,
0.0490913391,
0.0731795654,
-0.0244454239,
0.0022263413,
0.0424654931,
-0.0106063159,
0.0037286398,
0.0265625529,
0.002619881,
-0.0936845616,
-0.0883330256,
-0.0548895523,
0.0731500089,
0.009262355,
-0.0219550934,
-0.0287439264,
-0.0290914085,
-0.0388220139,
0.0170202237,
-0.0910724625,
-0.0210440625,
-0.0592039898,
0.0165673569,
0.0039235554,
0.0100864619,
-0.0254195686,
0.0830803141,
-0.0065615843,
-0.0290474426,
-0.0220575407,
-0.0324480757,
0.0171645023,
0.0343870893,
0.0165871289,
0.0053154626,
-0.0133927148,
-0.0226555914,
0.0276841782,
0.0220017955,
-0.0089153834,
0.0508050956,
0.0273423046,
-0.0571008027,
0.0003934315,
0.0280978214,
0.0183673147,
-0.0131566562,
0.0740519986,
0.0217884965,
0.0337720104,
0.0053180205,
-0.0743922591,
0.0649462044,
-0.0024301466,
0.0083897626,
0.0193709284,
-0.0441704057,
-0.0211300701,
0.0033131847,
0.0076877815,
-0.0290186647,
0.0418483727,
0.0187169928,
0.0053556147,
0.0043321433,
-0.0995536447,
2.313e-7,
-0.0227965713,
0.0665909797,
-0.0212177522,
0.0177467912,
0.0384536199,
-0.0087487865,
0.0796404928,
0.0237951986,
0.0147029692,
-0.0397168286,
-0.0391700082,
-0.033306051,
-0.0137241222,
0.0639962032,
-0.0489780046,
-0.0081819277,
-0.0869175941,
-0.0237695388,
-0.044026386,
0.036350064,
-0.0342202596,
0.0082873469,
0.0410534143,
-0.0269729961,
-0.0428583473,
0.0007958846,
0.0256424788,
-0.0194879472,
-0.0713914037,
0.0140949208,
0.0343762338,
0.0311605614,
0.0274550281,
0.0394977257,
0.0359084979,
0.0332045369,
0.0095064389,
-0.0165383983,
0.0004174833,
0.0437229984,
0.029661309,
-0.0271925498,
0.0194940437,
-0.0141636012,
0.0445141159,
0.0452926196,
-0.0409845039,
-0.047778599,
-0.0150856031,
-0.018313352,
0.0550458059,
0.0054820222,
-0.0227481369,
0.0108058127,
0.0437247008,
-0.01720264,
-0.0197987799,
-0.013479989,
-0.0146258017,
-0.034086097,
0.0136701092,
-0.0774244443,
-0.0159672145,
0.0408982188,
0.03444691,
0.0510271378,
0.0024352376,
1.827149044e-34,
-0.0250612535,
0.0305956993,
0.0041763918,
-0.0393242016,
0.0378203802,
0.0367240459,
0.014235015,
-0.0190456994,
-0.0018564658,
0.02810877,
0.0064718844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10765v1 | Path to Medical AGI: Unify Domain-specific Medical LLMs with the Lowest Cost | 2023-06-19T08:15:14 | 2023-06-19T08:15:14 | Juexiao Zhou, Xiuying Chen, Xin Gao | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Medical artificial general intelligence (AGI) is an emerging field that aims
to develop systems specifically designed for medical applications that possess
the ability to understand, learn, and apply knowledge across a wide range of
tasks and domains. Large language models (LLMs) represent a significant step
towards AGI. However, training cross-domain LLMs in the medical field poses
significant challenges primarily attributed to the requirement of collecting
data from diverse domains. This task becomes particularly difficult due to
privacy restrictions and the scarcity of publicly available medical datasets.
Here, we propose Medical AGI (MedAGI), a paradigm to unify domain-specific
medical LLMs with the lowest cost, and suggest a possible path to achieve
medical AGI. With an increasing number of domain-specific professional
multimodal LLMs in the medical field being developed, MedAGI is designed to
automatically select appropriate medical models by analyzing users' questions
with our novel adaptive expert selection algorithm. It offers a unified
approach to existing LLMs in the medical field, eliminating the need for
retraining regardless of the introduction of new models. This characteristic
renders it a future-proof solution in the dynamically advancing medical domain.
To showcase the resilience of MedAGI, we conducted an evaluation across three
distinct medical domains: dermatology diagnosis, X-ray diagnosis, and analysis
of pathology pictures. The results demonstrated that MedAGI exhibited
remarkable versatility and scalability, delivering exceptional performance
across diverse domains. Our code is publicly available to facilitate further
research at https://github.com/JoshuaChou2018/MedAGI. | [
0.0408239104,
0.0559174903,
-0.0191502962,
-0.0187128913,
-0.0215466432,
0.0232888181,
0.0457110554,
0.0465054177,
0.0540798195,
-0.0019275283,
-0.0331597775,
-0.0448321551,
-0.0286061522,
0.0605987571,
0.0224323776,
-0.0434726737,
0.0191144217,
0.007601839,
0.0454018414,
-0.0059561878,
-0.0057118754,
0.0212194156,
-0.0354772359,
0.0655260831,
0.0112214228,
0.0042925184,
0.0190070495,
-0.0365452096,
0.0179009493,
-0.0591734424,
-0.0079143383,
0.0228425991,
0.014717482,
-0.0235645007,
0.0000023254,
-0.0541048087,
-0.05246149,
0.0118322354,
-0.0022860921,
-0.0719382986,
0.0405596867,
-0.0136340372,
0.0179207828,
0.0223989375,
-0.0618408881,
-0.0238142479,
0.0401946008,
0.0172023848,
0.0650310218,
0.0568956286,
-0.0214669295,
0.0002433745,
0.0408658311,
-0.0294112042,
0.0021427397,
-0.0704068393,
0.0397926159,
-0.0260473154,
0.0322560854,
-0.0258533843,
0.0086530158,
0.0250369124,
-0.0323196761,
0.0274929982,
0.0349698365,
0.0407143235,
0.0238039661,
-0.0270234924,
-0.0415446945,
0.0602058172,
-0.0079402449,
0.0157349091,
0.0204489175,
0.0140304603,
0.0099830059,
0.0653010681,
-0.0286652353,
-0.0011803983,
-0.0344586037,
-0.0166465659,
0.0052891239,
-0.0179359168,
0.0241142269,
0.024288578,
-0.0182483718,
0.0338282064,
0.0052830428,
0.005630956,
0.0381865613,
-0.009344561,
-0.0121525535,
-0.0577995926,
0.0421885327,
0.06066937,
-0.0748079643,
-0.0131758275,
-0.0262559894,
-0.0510869771,
0.0638518706,
0.0092382412,
0.0361252315,
-0.0035322267,
0.010358288,
0.0582225285,
0.0047346,
-0.003394403,
-0.0228131469,
0.030228762,
-0.0263299942,
-0.0249354746,
-0.0529642589,
-0.0019107998,
0.0033712857,
0.0607852191,
-0.002931972,
0.0066877338,
-0.0811476335,
0.0162502863,
-0.0386809371,
0.0013513784,
0.0111844484,
0.0455438569,
-0.017699033,
0.0043599214,
-0.0506412946,
-0.0022979905,
-0.01632425,
0.031897787,
-0.0200459342,
-0.0220364965,
0.0211441573,
0.0113458019,
-0.0124118077,
-0.011257981,
0.0309234411,
0.1109512746,
0.0207118522,
-0.009428801,
-0.0077319713,
-0.0482275598,
-0.006448728,
-0.0307960678,
0.0571969077,
-0.0439130217,
0.0490770116,
0.0141131161,
0.018492464,
-0.0745145753,
-0.004406739,
0.0054104142,
-0.0426259451,
0.0582040474,
-0.0285046194,
0.0164422691,
0.0439198315,
0.037099272,
-0.0228324011,
0.0174035765,
0.0146039426,
-0.0422402844,
0.0159077886,
-0.0173499361,
0.0368568264,
0.0023262855,
0.0066057378,
-0.0174609981,
-0.0007702413,
0.0166524351,
0.0084202457,
0.0765249655,
-0.0231060721,
0.0433405675,
0.0058693639,
-0.0309441909,
0.0229249801,
0.0962812901,
0.00923438,
0.037733458,
0.0230315235,
-0.0316753052,
-0.0013212175,
-0.0349078998,
0.0140267564,
0.0241800547,
-0.0390878841,
-0.0357635058,
-0.0409498699,
0.0269219745,
-0.0341299549,
-0.0119781354,
-0.0122718569,
-0.0402090326,
-0.0271970443,
0.0176587533,
0.0520482212,
-0.0187619254,
-0.0040853601,
0.040953923,
0.0455827005,
-0.032197006,
-0.047395695,
-0.0882110447,
-0.0088999094,
0.0613843277,
0.0451984815,
-0.0617929138,
-0.0504394919,
-0.0243518017,
0.0008126586,
-0.0056795129,
0.0300141405,
-0.0073560192,
0.0212768484,
-0.0510745272,
-0.0357784741,
0.0280692764,
0.012471877,
-0.0006524809,
0.0075937849,
0.0465478785,
-0.041645743,
-0.0190971624,
0.0166675486,
0.049426917,
-0.0756435171,
-0.0015809182,
0.01980328,
0.0115070082,
0.0723517612,
-0.0022937197,
-0.0077088843,
0.0005430307,
0.0330513045,
-0.0521540791,
-0.0440459065,
0.0073897298,
-0.0125577226,
0.016958978,
0.0099014658,
-0.0672383308,
-0.0060125357,
-0.019621795,
-0.0499477796,
-0.0282237101,
-0.0108973496,
-0.0390533321,
-0.0000294851,
-0.0243384242,
-0.0056433356,
0.0291877054,
0.0058949185,
-0.0439960323,
0.0341203772,
-0.009329957,
-0.0652015284,
0.005601808,
-0.0354948565,
0.0077381809,
-0.0206475519,
-0.0032869088,
-0.008162885,
0.0030766784,
0.0193259642,
-0.0185233969,
0.011081174,
-0.0295691583,
-0.0330155008,
-0.0969431549,
0.0085015576,
0.0345529094,
-0.0278760865,
-0.0001704002,
0.0183266271,
-0.0053452994,
-0.037250448,
-0.0467010476,
0.0310435854,
0.0339508839,
-0.0046851146,
0.0484183952,
0.0360103995,
0.0014724823,
-0.0155871827,
0.0022217538,
-0.0397161692,
0.0216808729,
0.01871939,
-0.010727155,
-0.0060242573,
0.0071357368,
-0.0727466866,
0.0220512878,
0.0025803063,
-0.0330196992,
0.0039864057,
-0.0440765657,
-0.0324242339,
0.0681629553,
-0.0071904566,
0.0152847907,
0.0371500701,
0.0068007545,
-0.0204641968,
0.0141519625,
-0.0175171681,
-0.0333451033,
0.0106486781,
-0.0244102515,
0.0239470303,
0.0500764325,
-0.003725782,
0.0028982847,
-0.0360295475,
0.0434137508,
-0.0114098657,
-0.00367838,
-0.0300744995,
0.0343823992,
0.0063042385,
0.0515688248,
0.006049016,
-0.0425975882,
0.1274780184,
0.0364427306,
0.0467905626,
-0.0677104294,
-0.0266625676,
-0.046780318,
0.0193126183,
-0.026473986,
0.0532933623,
0.0322210826,
0.0041949819,
-0.0307444856,
0.0192005876,
0.0017405782,
-0.0647579804,
0.0150362058,
-0.0452567823,
0.021823192,
0.0356598087,
-0.0738725737,
-0.0468417257,
-0.0020314085,
-0.0256142579,
-0.0068482547,
-0.0422616936,
0.0162021406,
-0.0789535493,
0.0103484178,
0.0024730423,
0.0315309614,
0.0233312789,
-0.0178543497,
0.0095230257,
0.0101151755,
0.0166800544,
0.0291445553,
-0.0506276153,
0.0060248398,
0.0102487681,
0.0651852712,
0.0165045727,
-0.0047186711,
0.002819834,
0.0216168333,
0.005091703,
-0.0399531275,
-0.0038270208,
0.0200927053,
0.0125040524,
-0.0558303148,
0.0091485092,
0.0812835172,
0.0285659041,
-0.0922169685,
-0.0006036708,
0.0011655451,
-0.0363995135,
-0.0148466183,
0.0293565337,
-0.0806488171,
-0.0422218777,
-0.0112027097,
0.0369108468,
-0.0235933345,
-0.0383141451,
0.0204681568,
-0.0538972914,
0.0444859453,
-0.0157946721,
-0.0452820733,
-0.0321346894,
-0.0484896861,
0.0426318832,
-0.0060759559,
-0.0041621984,
-0.028707765,
-0.0146664949,
-0.0320810489,
-0.0009812347,
-0.0447963849,
-0.1118582189,
0.0276323222,
-0.0055589136,
0.014891387,
0.0649998039,
0.0360608771,
-0.030841276,
-0.054352317,
-0.0087533211,
0.058879856,
0.024936378,
-0.0441572592,
0.101114139,
0.012952636,
0.0066403775,
-0.0419683643,
0.0638011396,
-0.0319297798,
0.0015704737,
0.025531346,
0.1058397517,
-0.0541522317,
-0.0080842115,
-0.0561066344,
-0.0093812915,
0.0311315209,
0.0582263656,
-0.0223617107,
-0.0614285544,
-0.0391622148,
-0.0095942244,
0.0503461026,
0.0029219436,
-0.0288775116,
0.0458034202,
-0.0192306768,
-0.0409625508,
-0.0485994667,
-0.0029531082,
0.0520074591,
-0.0139704728,
0.0638035387,
0.0069063818,
0.0316917598,
0.0129351057,
-0.0678952634,
0.0465225838,
0.0053790896,
0.0062716799,
-0.0533452444,
-0.045986075,
0.0737806931,
-0.0232269131,
-0.0149352448,
0.0047346465,
0.0022920545,
-0.0115009248,
-0.0049768095,
0.068596974,
0.0250833221,
-0.0145835914,
-0.0398719795,
-0.056445431,
0.0574932583,
0.0184856057,
-0.0649989694,
-0.0086815329,
0.0207334198,
-0.032493148,
-0.0175102036,
0.0172880534,
-0.0195879005,
0.0228666328,
0.0259190444,
-0.0201737303,
-0.0194474999,
-0.0265407823,
0.0157555472,
0.0509946868,
0.0201431084,
-0.0237825811,
-0.0196219664,
-0.0217141435,
0.0195070952,
0.020549085,
0.0259630959,
-0.0392072611,
0.0185351931,
0.0130758276,
-0.0253104493,
0.0330824442,
-0.0107036596,
-0.029677609,
-0.058434546,
-0.0642448887,
0.0375629105,
0.0191132687,
0.0212878175,
0.047725942,
0.0003192296,
-0.0089697996,
-0.0009691816,
0.0049241004,
0.0339162499,
-0.0161884259,
0.0874823704,
0.0055477098,
0.0358660445,
-0.012792157,
0.0599326827,
-0.0213663653,
-0.0750937909,
0.0239024404,
0.0676992312,
0.0576437674,
0.0322102904,
0.0039130291,
-0.0165308081,
0.0012942902,
-0.0263045188,
0.0340739191,
-0.0501163229,
0.0308471788,
0.0211946499,
0.0129719861,
0.0074336864,
-0.0006115776,
0.1031869426,
-0.006035483,
0.0384269431,
-0.0378293432,
-0.0433695428,
-0.0701831803,
-0.0276890695,
0.0298155341,
0.0151406163,
-0.0426759869,
0.0112214126,
-0.0529475361,
-0.049796775,
-0.0051118587,
-0.0422189832,
-0.0504954197,
-0.0042499043,
0.0669535249,
0.0566126294,
0.002436314,
-0.0218308307,
-0.0170442387,
0.0460431054,
-0.0533972047,
-0.0172995199,
0.0277404208,
-6.34576152e-33,
0.0286454652,
-0.0263392273,
0.0246845055,
-0.0302516408,
0.0187336262,
0.0314627998,
-0.0229057521,
0.0003238119,
0.0013680707,
0.0014916512,
-0.0198577959,
-0.0146728149,
-0.003183776,
0.0270806253,
0.0280365329,
-0.0084607573,
0.0252794735,
-0.004915975,
-0.0147967413,
0.0509554483,
-0.0076642046,
0.060803853,
0.0192354601,
-0.1276715249,
-0.0287677553,
0.0437957384,
0.0105438037,
-0.0003855346,
-0.0539473593,
0.0851904973,
-0.0233848654,
0.0039493861,
0.0507365875,
0.0096566603,
0.0134453522,
-0.0038459057,
-0.0639716089,
-0.0204367042,
-0.0474322066,
-0.0061930171,
-0.0574518703,
-0.0409126431,
0.0405334271,
-0.0264686979,
-0.0048366208,
-0.0334157199,
0.0442937911,
-0.0337213874,
-0.0209127404,
-0.0317580961,
0.0056132129,
0.035176497,
0.0013865907,
0.0080808448,
-0.0157986432,
-0.0122169163,
-0.0357933939,
0.0493209735,
0.00608822,
0.0049681803,
0.0228837412,
-0.0220681429,
-0.0001663816,
-0.0188957993,
-0.0216479115,
0.0625293627,
0.0245688055,
-0.0400689058,
0.002737093,
-0.0161119048,
-0.0523130447,
0.0629313216,
0.0285360254,
0.0108638341,
0.0085876891,
-0.0221482124,
-0.1073060781,
0.0360369943,
-0.0237015262,
0.0614677332,
0.0050487258,
-0.0232665855,
-0.0437053032,
0.0298492387,
0.0027427489,
0.0102118021,
-0.0221134387,
-0.0131948246,
0.0206119455,
-0.0104462784,
-0.0179171879,
0.0347791612,
0.0114704231,
-0.0104434993,
0.0117092915,
-0.036458049,
0.046033714,
-0.003033624,
-0.0172391683,
0.0172769912,
-0.0386117212,
-0.0313969702,
0.0020152521,
-0.0278576687,
0.0685055405,
0.0170380808,
0.011519568,
-0.0133209266,
-0.0438032374,
-0.00802931,
0.0117144072,
0.0031522661,
0.0145409768,
0.0687080622,
0.036073532,
0.0415434614,
0.0076267924,
0.0330190584,
0.0140120815,
0.0049422001,
-0.0832285434,
-0.0308986735,
-0.0000620745,
-0.0243954472,
-0.0613279603,
-0.03215703,
-0.0308496244,
-0.0030123256,
0.0442129821,
-0.0533370525,
-0.0197431799,
-0.0186574012,
3.169e-7,
0.0732459277,
0.0473108813,
-0.0530148484,
-0.0154629732,
0.0298603997,
0.0367434435,
-0.0078542,
0.004333952,
0.0011676794,
0.0171809494,
0.0273375437,
0.0313111469,
0.0317206271,
0.0385461748,
-0.0508785285,
-0.0148212966,
-0.0097871339,
-0.0002611874,
-0.0470330454,
0.013447565,
0.0299602728,
0.060510505,
0.0084030787,
-0.0555674657,
0.0344768539,
-0.050233718,
0.0574894212,
-0.0340093859,
0.0168035217,
0.0351995602,
0.0228474755,
0.040777877,
-0.0159941223,
0.0614416078,
-0.0198647734,
0.0014568043,
-0.0177264232,
0.0962022096,
-0.0470903032,
0.0004507317,
0.0417954624,
0.0085657611,
0.0198352747,
-0.0249749273,
0.0530966409,
-0.0389984287,
-0.0397712924,
-0.0193305071,
0.0417549796,
-0.028140679,
0.0599255823,
-0.0490656048,
-0.0241082795,
0.021342922,
0.0188826155,
-0.0028386076,
-0.0288814101,
-0.07249026,
0.0092331478,
0.0241821297,
-0.0451667793,
-0.0281314757,
0.0393504351,
-0.0246571805,
0.0113700638,
-0.0793020353,
0.0385538191,
2.906430905e-34,
-0.0034517664,
0.0066915662,
-0.0127868941,
0.0527648404,
0.0160316713,
-0.0121307718,
-0.0224698521,
0.0069747712,
-0.0010780077,
-0.0377012268,
-0.0132515952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10763v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10763v2 | Guiding Language Models of Code with Global Context using Monitors | 2023-06-19T08:13:50 | 2023-11-03T11:13:15 | Lakshya A Agrawal, Aditya Kanade, Navin Goyal, Shuvendu K. Lahiri, Sriram K. Rajamani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PL, cs.SE, I.2.2; I.2.7; I.2.5 | Language models of code (LMs) work well when the surrounding code provides
sufficient context. This is not true when it becomes necessary to use types,
functionality or APIs defined elsewhere in the repository or a linked library,
especially those not seen during training. LMs suffer from limited awareness of
such global context and end up hallucinating.
Integrated development environments (IDEs) assist developers in understanding
repository context using static analysis. We extend this assistance, enjoyed by
developers, to LMs. We propose monitor-guided decoding (MGD) where a monitor
uses static analysis to guide the decoding. We construct a repository-level
dataset PragmaticCode for method-completion in Java and evaluate MGD on it. On
models of varying parameter scale, by monitoring for type-consistent object
dereferences, MGD consistently improves compilation rates and agreement with
ground truth. Further, LMs with fewer parameters, when augmented with MGD, can
outperform larger LMs. With MGD, SantaCoder-1.1B achieves better compilation
rate and next-identifier match than the much larger text-davinci-003 model.
We also conduct a generalizability study to evaluate the ability of MGD to
generalize to multiple programming languages (Java, C# and Rust), coding
scenarios (e.g., correct number of arguments to method calls), and to enforce
richer semantic constraints (e.g., stateful API protocols). Our data and
implementation are available at https://github.com/microsoft/monitors4codegen . | [
0.0162472371,
0.1144585907,
-0.029479783,
0.0317148939,
0.0057181814,
-0.0002871879,
-0.0588074625,
0.0283616949,
-0.042830877,
0.0196543597,
0.0011971907,
0.0731312558,
0.033559259,
-0.0222128592,
0.0121661704,
-0.0456361733,
0.046827063,
-0.0313090645,
-0.0533593185,
0.0261457674,
-0.0133330636,
0.0153132863,
0.0091447709,
0.0677138194,
0.0017914131,
-0.0401737578,
0.002665923,
0.0242972448,
-0.0316062197,
0.0325834751,
-0.0026293355,
0.0142598171,
0.0042090719,
0.0067418036,
0.0000024885,
-0.0116371904,
0.0261465237,
0.0236615986,
0.0153902648,
0.0544893146,
-0.0617017969,
-0.0303391945,
0.0236687381,
-0.0033335818,
-0.0114580505,
-0.0476945229,
0.0378112793,
-0.0541301481,
0.024427684,
-0.0231255181,
0.0272788163,
0.0210069865,
0.0156446863,
0.0221183524,
0.0248141922,
-0.0171254706,
-0.0234825388,
0.0597729422,
0.0146664092,
0.0683283284,
-0.0253015086,
0.0197308958,
0.0088683525,
0.0346088745,
0.0122576673,
0.0289054308,
-0.0343392789,
-0.0094597451,
0.0346281901,
0.0201133899,
-0.0108250752,
-0.0510833673,
0.0131652635,
0.0114069385,
-0.0407528058,
-0.0337311737,
0.0098932739,
0.0044981842,
-0.0155892763,
0.0089893071,
0.0170168038,
0.0106297629,
0.0018000519,
0.0048952713,
0.0213484708,
0.0107650263,
-0.0058616893,
0.022306513,
-0.0275772326,
0.0111728664,
0.0374216847,
-0.0629901588,
-0.0014413072,
0.018507896,
0.0276734866,
0.0071235052,
-0.0143934581,
0.0030812819,
0.0463030078,
-0.0431530848,
-0.0894052237,
0.0904301554,
-0.0350743383,
-0.0045583481,
-0.0119100278,
0.0720904097,
-0.0208825711,
-0.0353529416,
-0.020361783,
0.0214536246,
-0.0377464965,
-0.0209284499,
-0.0400526524,
0.0247401446,
0.0385522433,
0.0500590876,
-0.0350240692,
0.0410721153,
0.0394272022,
0.0596368313,
-0.0555120856,
-0.065217264,
-0.0658536032,
0.0071470146,
0.0708355978,
0.0230314024,
-0.037250109,
-0.0366173834,
-0.0244377833,
-0.0546092167,
-0.0129339257,
-0.0178102795,
-0.0675341189,
-0.0070073651,
0.0131810373,
0.054067228,
0.0187288467,
0.0416069701,
-0.0304896981,
-0.0260975659,
0.0380524956,
0.0162697323,
-0.0233355835,
-0.0845118091,
-0.023999311,
0.0417248383,
0.0213966463,
-0.0769799724,
-0.0363338478,
-0.019324569,
0.0161508769,
0.0295724366,
-0.0026951975,
0.0333193578,
0.0102580693,
0.0426759496,
-0.0170880165,
0.0573757179,
-0.0035239756,
-0.0015108496,
0.0077028447,
-0.0580903254,
0.0316013694,
0.0431294441,
-0.0165416617,
-0.0140973367,
-0.0222247373,
0.0433659367,
0.0378904343,
-0.0506098829,
0.0320942998,
0.00473287,
-0.0077094096,
0.0000554191,
-0.0076930076,
0.0358189121,
0.0018590298,
0.0399912149,
0.0306107048,
0.0448442586,
0.0121943234,
0.0036849964,
-0.0250811465,
0.0308848433,
-0.053885866,
0.0380309038,
-0.0154028982,
0.0173690896,
-0.0089630466,
-0.0594942085,
-0.0203535892,
-0.0006839571,
-0.0521628335,
0.010574623,
0.0284836125,
0.004648163,
-0.0220361315,
0.0449842028,
0.0041085277,
-0.0724914894,
-0.0355640613,
-0.0280984025,
0.0433061495,
0.0377188995,
0.0860997215,
-0.0463670827,
-0.0441803932,
0.0012455084,
0.0311410986,
-0.0174093191,
0.0349639729,
-0.015655281,
0.0590973943,
-0.0554067381,
-0.0253098961,
0.0040542339,
0.0039109956,
0.07206209,
-0.008400429,
-0.0141272629,
0.0055280975,
-0.0660238415,
-0.0488623306,
0.0549995005,
0.031275291,
-0.0018197597,
-0.0062647667,
-0.00884292,
-0.0075818575,
-0.0292804949,
-0.0581805706,
-0.0150353247,
0.0555410348,
-0.0171824172,
0.0297428686,
0.0290789492,
-0.0120149758,
0.0338286571,
0.004381096,
-0.0478188246,
-0.0268200058,
-0.0109833209,
-0.0288675241,
0.0042279311,
0.0634530261,
0.0019870666,
0.0416962244,
0.0339228287,
0.0070167356,
-0.0469248369,
-0.0073655546,
-0.010689958,
0.0232241657,
-0.0343152992,
-0.0054419613,
-0.0202769414,
0.0628345385,
0.0273694657,
0.0480160564,
-0.0341101624,
0.0168839637,
-0.0233061034,
0.0582819432,
0.0110592172,
0.0568464845,
0.0299944635,
-0.038547162,
-0.0561156906,
0.0329466313,
-0.0095463125,
0.0381184481,
0.0188688878,
0.0691213757,
0.0077270549,
-0.0108501371,
0.0352938212,
-0.0149539039,
-0.0374439992,
0.003632491,
0.0204302445,
-0.0062752245,
-0.0617966615,
-0.0256517287,
-0.010184383,
-0.0139926421,
0.0347438157,
-0.0499419942,
-0.0550412312,
-0.0927570313,
0.0730871633,
0.044410713,
0.0126538407,
-0.0399994515,
-0.0256870575,
0.0095792646,
-0.0405808017,
0.0541330501,
0.0282241646,
-0.0870885625,
-0.0183528643,
0.042457588,
0.0000053385,
-0.0947642773,
-0.0202744137,
0.0814943686,
-0.0827139542,
0.032125514,
-0.0520223491,
0.0374251343,
0.0677144006,
-0.0142550366,
-0.031260889,
-0.0223915279,
-0.0307268444,
-0.0101110153,
0.0060395519,
-0.0015248958,
-0.0625611842,
0.0204812996,
0.0433248729,
-0.0155897709,
-0.0836045519,
0.0519052856,
-0.0603207387,
-0.028370535,
-0.0246445574,
-0.0000715492,
-0.0497605391,
0.0546092838,
-0.0172438584,
-0.0220929738,
0.0245737713,
-0.0321005099,
0.0339306518,
0.0064397585,
-0.0197393671,
-0.003582628,
0.0438187011,
-0.0535905957,
0.0189468544,
-0.0107723875,
0.0069833999,
-0.0429595672,
0.0487109423,
-0.0171739869,
-0.0110426247,
-0.0413565747,
0.0298586059,
0.0522338711,
0.0391346738,
-0.005806746,
0.0226499531,
0.0539919585,
-0.046300672,
-0.038476117,
-0.0820577368,
-0.0725543872,
-0.0820769444,
-0.0517820865,
-0.0011527869,
-0.0121808005,
0.0303888544,
0.0727929324,
0.0238722563,
-0.0766710266,
-0.0427644141,
0.0759261101,
0.0079124449,
-0.0465961918,
0.0484716259,
0.0615856722,
-0.062791504,
-0.0594263822,
0.0385933295,
0.0254533812,
-0.0907895118,
0.0189887378,
-0.0035977422,
0.0589705482,
0.0521214232,
0.0532385744,
-0.0700909942,
-0.0262271799,
0.0313420482,
0.0134821199,
0.0112145562,
0.0175183546,
-0.033101555,
-0.0376233235,
0.0039724102,
0.0182710215,
-0.0063697225,
-0.0329307504,
-0.0210907664,
0.0105328113,
0.0198298581,
-0.069994919,
0.0239228215,
0.0415525734,
0.0419845469,
0.0011742432,
-0.06316562,
0.0184017457,
0.0204298683,
-0.0350099318,
-0.0110838441,
0.098331742,
0.0071919966,
0.0019744278,
-0.0030477322,
0.0626104102,
-0.0178463943,
0.0071364166,
-0.0551844649,
0.0360826328,
0.0113354623,
-0.001927315,
0.0365363844,
0.0151367588,
-0.0386139378,
0.0046607396,
0.0396375246,
0.0375401191,
-0.0270056259,
0.0140006589,
-0.0412656479,
-0.0001787099,
0.0043277745,
0.0103957877,
0.0530955791,
0.0117803691,
-0.0113698123,
-0.0926264375,
0.0048057968,
-0.0108838854,
0.0001660229,
-0.0183893163,
-0.0133987293,
-0.0617603622,
-0.0067212963,
0.0217614435,
0.0260260925,
0.0254987013,
0.0421141982,
-0.0169787798,
0.0029848721,
-0.0315469839,
-0.0538299643,
0.0114584146,
-0.0264953095,
0.0265369304,
0.0231086258,
-0.0083996179,
0.0283307042,
0.0276892669,
0.0125608929,
0.0605690032,
-0.0297340993,
-0.0297562741,
-0.0471288711,
0.0978128836,
0.0262650903,
0.0060140346,
-0.0742429569,
-0.0384733751,
-0.0934419632,
0.0182264838,
0.000400314,
0.0231067091,
0.0098436167,
0.0008552065,
0.0653265044,
-0.0324186794,
-0.0566548035,
-0.0373712704,
0.0143282916,
-0.0115916077,
-0.0288165323,
0.0118248975,
0.0440663658,
-0.0235564616,
-0.0214581564,
0.016059339,
-0.0163452476,
0.0095931292,
-0.0033167729,
0.002101708,
-0.0114279101,
-0.0515688397,
0.0432106666,
-0.0004170735,
-0.0131657366,
0.0424717925,
0.0067740907,
-0.0532575324,
0.0854013115,
-0.0131772393,
0.0297174305,
-0.0037998008,
0.0565884411,
0.0221018791,
0.0306387637,
-0.01930831,
0.0079726418,
-0.0098375063,
0.0276452377,
-0.0337301604,
0.0191507488,
0.0242819041,
0.0558952577,
-0.0108445855,
-0.0305710044,
-0.0163784623,
-0.0547460914,
0.0308264084,
0.0515725091,
0.0170801338,
0.0150923878,
0.0232823174,
-0.0028435488,
0.0365849622,
-0.004178674,
0.0549632125,
-0.0075962278,
-0.0419980548,
-0.0288245995,
0.0442649983,
0.0109393289,
-0.0652717948,
0.0945143849,
-0.0297343675,
-0.0078039891,
-0.0319341011,
-0.0282904338,
-0.0094618937,
0.0439750403,
0.0300967265,
0.0046105948,
-0.032159891,
-0.0200474728,
-0.0680278093,
-0.0759154409,
-0.0198925082,
0.0019439601,
0.0399395451,
-0.0126967309,
0.0039818012,
0.0663143769,
0.0448438004,
-0.0749741867,
0.0235793088,
0.0248105619,
0.0080232006,
-0.0431651771,
-0.0483043492,
-5.561632952e-33,
-0.0516771302,
0.0032340635,
-0.0056024813,
0.0182179715,
0.0077244672,
0.0121940672,
-0.0319198705,
-0.0340916477,
0.0055387258,
-0.0403359197,
0.0105797229,
0.0254262369,
-0.0245802775,
-0.0797922388,
0.0550264753,
0.0407558382,
0.0404743887,
0.0245255735,
-0.0476597473,
-0.0041004401,
-0.002223182,
0.0363221802,
0.0262833126,
-0.0418532155,
0.0029894835,
-0.0135306455,
0.0412201174,
-0.0214286596,
0.0319571868,
0.0283814501,
0.0061748363,
-0.0244638398,
-0.0080486732,
0.0343262255,
-0.070584856,
-0.0330704935,
-0.0516657494,
-0.0316729806,
0.0358176306,
0.0559996888,
0.0253562704,
-0.0687122941,
0.0456757434,
0.0273620784,
-0.0039249649,
0.0195877291,
-0.0150234159,
0.0079530813,
-0.0194787588,
-0.0370868333,
-0.0082803778,
0.0174953062,
-0.0786382109,
-0.0099078231,
0.0080031669,
0.0268103704,
-0.0091757756,
0.040350128,
0.0309446286,
-0.0130686341,
0.0233515315,
0.0462802239,
0.0691552684,
-0.0177216772,
-0.0005390885,
-0.0143626044,
0.0122034866,
0.0020215418,
-0.0305473171,
0.0049968353,
0.0406984799,
0.0343866833,
-0.0242861267,
-0.0333747268,
0.0322590433,
-0.0243952312,
0.0010984339,
0.0114377793,
0.0140211359,
0.0520566516,
0.0000072734,
0.036054112,
-0.0641345009,
-0.0052042259,
-0.0373258069,
0.0019945742,
-0.0065145828,
-0.0134348851,
0.0292584505,
-0.0352629349,
-0.0192655623,
-0.015364809,
0.0080590099,
-0.040950913,
0.0131468922,
0.0270411205,
-0.0522979796,
0.0176361389,
-0.005605882,
0.0197148789,
0.0210908819,
-0.0228863452,
-0.0169280972,
-0.0115834856,
0.064061977,
-0.0003949662,
-0.0013463747,
-0.0182143655,
-0.0320433974,
-0.0029610107,
-0.0542667247,
-0.0371345654,
-0.0363970287,
-0.0081145866,
0.0200651083,
-0.0052747233,
0.0134815993,
0.0362562537,
0.0007712423,
-0.0165462662,
-0.0310268346,
0.0314479396,
0.019681843,
0.0209065154,
-0.0149484929,
-0.0715122968,
-0.0155497277,
-0.0106426189,
0.0849830583,
-0.0165126547,
-0.0684334561,
0.0416717902,
3.197e-7,
-0.015407308,
0.0101706395,
0.041059833,
0.026955558,
-0.0060592731,
0.0096309492,
-0.0243703537,
0.0030228384,
0.0287025534,
-0.0131054465,
-0.0619199723,
0.0104845511,
0.0188821759,
0.0104135321,
-0.0233837869,
0.0059615644,
0.0600449517,
-0.003652934,
-0.0562830418,
-0.0241828673,
-0.0219378639,
-0.0030617008,
-0.0054290155,
0.021207355,
0.015096534,
0.0010668443,
-0.0233583506,
0.0030298114,
-0.0004845819,
0.0381311737,
-0.0439332314,
0.0116438707,
0.0198193863,
-0.0100672832,
0.0134538105,
-0.0251473505,
0.011001667,
0.060893476,
-0.0049052532,
0.0539916344,
-0.0051494949,
-0.0046230671,
-0.0342807099,
0.0113322847,
0.0272904355,
0.0288548209,
0.0077619446,
-0.0157824028,
-0.0358770937,
0.0166494735,
-0.0645785183,
0.0284844954,
0.0150033105,
0.0281444844,
-0.0169153195,
-0.0061482671,
-0.0456306376,
0.0211550705,
-0.0471377969,
-0.0230248775,
-0.0152679766,
-0.0318917334,
-0.0337199084,
0.0196517278,
-0.01652628,
-0.0157106351,
-0.0032119907,
3.544969767e-34,
0.0425222367,
-0.0536547638,
0.0484734848,
0.0389227048,
0.0183270779,
-0.0392629243,
-0.027101431,
0.0462529212,
0.0311809089,
0.0314037912,
-0.0374360234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10755v1 | Unsupervised Open-domain Keyphrase Generation | 2023-06-19T07:57:13 | 2023-06-19T07:57:13 | Lam Thanh Do, Pritom Saha Akash, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we study the problem of unsupervised open-domain keyphrase
generation, where the objective is a keyphrase generation model that can be
built without using human-labeled data and can perform consistently across
domains. To solve this problem, we propose a seq2seq model that consists of two
modules, namely \textit{phraseness} and \textit{informativeness} module, both
of which can be built in an unsupervised and open-domain fashion. The
phraseness module generates phrases, while the informativeness module guides
the generation towards those that represent the core concepts of the text. We
thoroughly evaluate our proposed method using eight benchmark datasets from
different domains. Results on in-domain datasets show that our approach
achieves state-of-the-art results compared with existing unsupervised models,
and overall narrows the gap between supervised and unsupervised methods down to
about 16\%. Furthermore, we demonstrate that our model performs consistently
across domains, as it overall surpasses the baselines on out-of-domain
datasets. | [
0.0628454462,
0.0400018357,
0.0062536406,
0.0091489851,
-0.0650979131,
-0.0234625768,
0.0073317741,
0.0100878254,
0.0273307972,
-0.0399598293,
-0.0063900934,
0.0081567429,
-0.0427860916,
0.0661602765,
0.0158561133,
-0.035758879,
0.0035282592,
-0.0234864056,
-0.0090987151,
-0.01152643,
-0.0269473866,
0.0214394499,
-0.0140682226,
0.0358483344,
0.0243848935,
-0.007680628,
-0.0340687111,
-0.0242765099,
0.0163768753,
-0.0213673618,
0.035331998,
0.054627303,
0.0022946252,
0.02631291,
0.0000017258,
-0.0611615553,
-0.0314286947,
-0.0317612886,
0.0554328971,
0.0360168628,
0.073272258,
-0.0093628336,
-0.0012419755,
0.0226492025,
-0.0513090529,
0.0206338111,
0.0377037302,
0.0481715016,
0.0732210204,
0.03183797,
-0.0168677419,
-0.0803982392,
-0.0118560167,
-0.0409475155,
-0.0120955706,
-0.0710107237,
0.0181545895,
-0.0413231179,
-0.048658438,
0.015724102,
-0.0045945616,
0.0130682113,
-0.0146642672,
0.0047801756,
0.1014893651,
0.0161102489,
-0.0495255403,
-0.0419610962,
0.0009203471,
0.0850246623,
0.0166974384,
0.020354636,
0.0649912357,
-0.0338731892,
-0.0006815572,
0.0365391485,
-0.0099019688,
0.0456386916,
-0.0023193825,
-0.0074736099,
-0.0405752696,
0.0294146501,
-0.0105251977,
0.0208322071,
-0.0204126332,
0.0221884158,
0.0539027676,
-0.0133970212,
-0.014896906,
-0.0211342052,
-0.069046922,
-0.048939079,
-0.0161754861,
-0.003292731,
0.0086247073,
0.0537670106,
-0.0429958701,
-0.0207410417,
0.0601715744,
-0.0705462396,
0.0106167309,
-0.0408198051,
0.0169996824,
0.0218426883,
-0.026654385,
0.0224007573,
0.0061791665,
0.0028013573,
-0.0280530006,
0.0112570003,
-0.0582489707,
-0.0225502346,
-0.0096263457,
0.0553821847,
0.0249803197,
-0.0339659266,
-0.0578422844,
0.0350981392,
0.0501141995,
0.0030702425,
0.0120564085,
0.0455652289,
-0.0270122942,
-0.0236713998,
-0.0091191772,
-0.0552038439,
-0.0258089285,
0.0023026986,
0.015560084,
-0.0014831073,
0.0172474813,
0.0352047607,
0.0309173893,
-0.0098529067,
0.0105211772,
0.0324318931,
-0.0107172485,
-0.0336716883,
-0.0163339954,
-0.0814749226,
-0.0451916531,
0.0012857208,
0.0185219534,
-0.0643360838,
0.008118446,
0.0137984678,
-0.0016967491,
-0.0571602844,
0.0343455821,
0.0501367114,
-0.0730658993,
0.05164304,
-0.0242334493,
0.0025426601,
0.03439169,
0.0204259288,
0.0399034433,
0.0288719144,
0.0213061552,
0.04590277,
0.0623847023,
0.0041562552,
0.0243308451,
-0.0095994184,
0.0410091765,
0.0139879324,
0.0025186476,
0.0089658741,
-0.0199504886,
0.0211280566,
-0.0250071809,
0.048127465,
0.008218497,
0.0440806225,
0.0381689109,
0.0688822567,
0.0001191899,
0.0571401119,
0.0175194442,
0.0744187161,
0.0129037173,
-0.003754467,
0.0273228418,
0.0069523752,
0.0329295546,
0.0598210618,
0.0783294141,
0.0192046892,
-0.0086863777,
-0.0504205339,
-0.0284543261,
0.0146324513,
-0.0165332854,
-0.0690391734,
0.0525161475,
0.0457517281,
-0.0662785992,
0.0522219166,
-0.0169128608,
-0.0683250353,
-0.0214294214,
-0.0224790908,
0.0023913395,
0.03751266,
0.0658820048,
0.0108657358,
-0.0143695297,
0.0147948368,
0.0340446383,
0.1110862717,
-0.0019937218,
0.0014979579,
-0.0356979147,
-0.066934295,
-0.0565583557,
-0.0454807542,
0.0258742142,
-0.0365327969,
0.0095616188,
-0.0024269379,
0.0572902039,
-0.0346726738,
0.0025072619,
0.0257344674,
-0.0215536207,
-0.0343229808,
0.0316386521,
-0.0141388057,
-0.0024435471,
0.027674567,
-0.0078758029,
0.0378755815,
0.0184827987,
-0.0209824368,
-0.0504584275,
-0.0054468689,
-0.0031183513,
0.0386731625,
0.0177225601,
-0.0604457445,
0.036902789,
-0.0085995756,
-0.0208877847,
-0.0389970616,
0.0337013938,
-0.0422119647,
0.0384299085,
-0.0822402686,
-0.0061292774,
-0.0115090832,
-0.0052079689,
-0.0231578592,
0.0842684954,
0.0192781817,
-0.0123092849,
-0.0260884352,
-0.0340119004,
0.021068668,
0.0196509697,
0.0155291269,
-0.0076174606,
-0.015531146,
0.0191360768,
0.0300508793,
0.0232324004,
-0.0456707776,
-0.0135404766,
-0.0487829521,
0.0021272076,
0.0187992323,
-0.0043249903,
0.0322572924,
0.025244331,
-0.0092064142,
-0.0032090347,
-0.0270685051,
-0.0482456051,
-0.0049705585,
-0.0015985576,
0.0411527008,
0.0120140715,
-0.0281763766,
0.0134093398,
0.0370194316,
-0.0039868765,
0.0472802855,
0.0418718122,
-0.0229117982,
-0.0117699811,
0.0862758607,
-0.018267842,
-0.0574150458,
0.0273792632,
-0.0474144742,
0.0040066889,
0.0174967647,
0.0570598617,
-0.0309345145,
0.0861525536,
-0.0501620248,
0.0320390351,
-0.0105983783,
0.0017303061,
-0.0293722246,
-0.0398879424,
-0.0461444594,
0.0541003644,
-0.0119209308,
0.0831155702,
0.0337631665,
0.0296941437,
0.0009406836,
-0.0640727282,
0.0439299047,
-0.0099889534,
-0.0075444779,
-0.062872,
0.0222098455,
-0.0146020427,
0.048277963,
-0.0028902739,
-0.0309105217,
0.0220790934,
-0.000397025,
0.0375123732,
-0.0633843392,
0.0214253422,
-0.0321634971,
0.0283206329,
-0.0477132089,
0.0443831645,
0.0702629983,
-0.0201284979,
-0.0139558921,
-0.0200345069,
0.0099351993,
-0.0386957563,
0.0322803408,
-0.0374080613,
-0.0157642365,
0.0244659521,
-0.0030641551,
-0.0540002845,
-0.0245263316,
-0.0103358598,
-0.0296169966,
0.0419881009,
-0.0275437701,
0.0324468836,
-0.0007691323,
0.0090912608,
0.0159628615,
-0.0110737421,
-0.0149676036,
0.0079471674,
0.0241083857,
0.080455631,
-0.0390945189,
-0.016743049,
-0.0193962026,
0.0288646668,
0.0231525917,
0.0375813246,
-0.016858222,
0.0119301146,
-0.0198813491,
-0.0124064153,
-0.0436296761,
0.0061742137,
0.0080744652,
0.0141087631,
0.0317285359,
-0.0205334276,
0.110760726,
0.0458720848,
-0.0277006421,
-0.0119961696,
-0.0017804964,
-0.0262136422,
-0.0086218594,
0.0062495139,
-0.0496604927,
-0.0157103278,
-0.0280520078,
0.0520086326,
0.0002880951,
-0.025334172,
-0.041010648,
-0.0922152326,
0.0326930173,
0.0179272518,
-0.0017723189,
-0.0128899785,
-0.0289081428,
-0.0595702417,
-0.0358022302,
-0.0651386976,
-0.0179210864,
-0.0422113203,
0.0388596281,
-0.0326274186,
-0.0500415452,
-0.0480545759,
0.0006734938,
-0.0757252425,
-0.0248588957,
0.0855589136,
0.0296372697,
0.0092703272,
-0.0327706449,
0.0008606773,
-0.0283833649,
-0.0133416187,
0.0234053824,
0.0372343175,
-0.0131473839,
-0.0097212009,
-0.0365188941,
0.0453370772,
-0.0652830303,
-0.0153139066,
0.0622723103,
0.0101541979,
-0.0037499012,
0.016909238,
-0.0217412505,
0.018858714,
-0.0267144926,
0.0900254324,
0.0040028887,
-0.0358689427,
-0.002870081,
0.0053546559,
0.0146920597,
-0.0943861827,
-0.0634421855,
-0.0486403257,
-0.0512898304,
0.0235624257,
-0.1041442379,
-0.0269757379,
0.0083078742,
-0.0026592799,
0.0008100548,
0.0179560203,
-0.0289866216,
-0.0026960049,
-0.0700229779,
-0.0282105953,
-0.0398813039,
-0.03567224,
-0.052753672,
-0.0300149638,
0.0404601991,
-0.0367697962,
-0.0238997303,
0.0214210451,
-0.0065684081,
-0.0390354581,
0.032662116,
0.0092699379,
0.0135574304,
-0.0077034817,
-0.0313013978,
0.0059542782,
0.0970020741,
0.0825259164,
-0.0572845414,
-0.000276382,
0.0169432014,
-0.0060885665,
-0.0144109773,
0.0480568409,
-0.045145303,
0.0001641428,
0.006956419,
0.0675014779,
-0.0130590713,
-0.0597190037,
0.0248400085,
-0.005160227,
0.0571627058,
-0.0642567575,
-0.0097942203,
-0.0326838382,
-0.0166582856,
0.0133666079,
-0.0251424182,
-0.0400256254,
0.0508338585,
-0.002284304,
-0.0105169211,
0.0083004739,
0.0636928529,
-0.0862551257,
0.028618196,
0.0085118683,
-0.0084955702,
0.001589526,
0.0508344434,
-0.0135195246,
-0.0301685929,
-0.0132353138,
-0.0178083517,
-0.04378758,
-0.0058030603,
0.0005161621,
0.0363413095,
-0.006753373,
-0.025295537,
-0.0260965191,
0.0880547911,
-0.0473704636,
0.0128453011,
-0.0641521141,
0.0114329644,
0.0646115467,
0.0054501011,
-0.0112829152,
-0.0422504432,
-0.0055538919,
-0.000735069,
0.069983691,
-0.0124287391,
0.0073678619,
-0.0358986855,
0.0150039559,
-0.0295321625,
-0.0069510378,
0.0729629546,
0.0412338786,
0.0336063355,
-0.0089550521,
-0.0209494662,
-0.0217664242,
0.0105491793,
0.06388776,
0.0247457419,
-0.0095455395,
0.009181438,
-0.0439246595,
-0.0168698728,
0.0522817411,
-0.0065497593,
0.0220978279,
0.0361065306,
0.0664659664,
0.0586094745,
-0.037869174,
-0.0111132236,
-0.0799032003,
0.0053389519,
-0.0315432213,
-0.0243467558,
0.0227142069,
-5.823734397e-33,
0.0001292038,
-0.0496746823,
-0.0083032064,
0.025412254,
0.0259386562,
0.0013878208,
-0.0211498942,
-0.0091796899,
0.0413263254,
-0.0052519152,
-0.0037257643,
-0.005218958,
0.0110733528,
0.0173651706,
0.0450553373,
0.0012897669,
0.030761933,
0.0010310719,
-0.0229237862,
0.038689021,
0.0147281466,
0.0424159989,
0.0378933512,
-0.0447051637,
0.0282237474,
-0.0615627915,
-0.0166980643,
-0.0401442684,
0.0790978298,
0.0555523299,
-0.0086935405,
0.0279355422,
0.0036244513,
-0.0725280568,
0.0003235588,
-0.017839456,
-0.0047175484,
-0.0356851332,
-0.0090841362,
-0.0430411063,
-0.0012072615,
-0.0658178106,
-0.0071672248,
-0.0310977399,
-0.0147667341,
0.0065903547,
0.0603701361,
-0.017158309,
-0.0049072853,
-0.054955963,
-0.0148518551,
0.0290499758,
0.0232040379,
-0.0253794789,
-0.0003269835,
0.0063567921,
-0.0042321864,
0.008502922,
-0.0053591072,
0.0715015531,
0.0391546637,
0.0067740656,
0.0688857436,
0.0511186533,
0.0200560633,
0.0459250361,
-0.0070646647,
-0.0232394282,
-0.0103488192,
0.0451918058,
-0.0294274464,
0.0564207174,
0.0353947394,
0.0879597962,
0.0097034853,
0.0218012091,
-0.0135162203,
0.0643271506,
-0.065867126,
-0.0446794815,
0.0137453377,
-0.0122811683,
-0.0159568861,
0.0182370301,
-0.0038027274,
0.022425741,
-0.0228541158,
-0.0408109576,
0.0206406619,
0.0206130166,
-0.1121040285,
0.0159978252,
-0.0119463988,
-0.0030076508,
0.0250663031,
-0.0046102242,
0.0217031911,
-0.0021838525,
-0.0191363804,
-0.0155830896,
-0.0479243509,
-0.0235938299,
0.0446197018,
0.0325398855,
0.0047929641,
-0.0023206747,
-0.0344668888,
-0.011194854,
-0.0452101603,
-0.001444377,
0.0070235063,
-0.0139848823,
-0.013870893,
-0.0316316001,
-0.0167970117,
0.0114080422,
-0.0282240547,
0.0574430935,
0.0195579305,
-0.0007902915,
0.0115798488,
-0.0106156915,
0.017487295,
0.0481416769,
0.0097350311,
0.0232204907,
-0.0088444874,
-0.0308073722,
0.0151073206,
-0.0133730574,
-0.0319081172,
-0.0280557349,
2.501e-7,
-0.0054577361,
0.0310153216,
0.0319786333,
0.0030851702,
-0.046830412,
0.0591674,
-0.0071622101,
0.0395525098,
-0.0677573457,
-0.0322814211,
0.026356373,
0.034254957,
-0.0066167843,
-0.0152683519,
-0.1226453707,
0.0365192257,
-0.0348890945,
0.0217577107,
-0.0351870768,
0.001137529,
0.0710860193,
0.0243220255,
0.0053465846,
-0.0040444783,
-0.036218822,
-0.0425068922,
0.0364543982,
-0.0013039225,
-0.0382807851,
0.0243069883,
-0.0163299832,
0.035729751,
-0.0287537929,
0.0204316769,
-0.0281945094,
-0.0247151516,
0.0735358149,
0.0185700096,
0.045839414,
-0.0230435133,
-0.0009940226,
-0.0185936559,
0.025889419,
-0.0109957829,
0.0452696197,
-0.0434616208,
-0.0188430808,
-0.0121592153,
-0.0345049202,
0.0452322289,
0.0040830569,
-0.0553761832,
-0.0259495489,
-0.0184171051,
-0.0055782581,
0.0202009007,
0.0032892253,
-0.0337230973,
0.0210965928,
-0.0331927091,
-0.0122842034,
0.0010378442,
-0.0591258258,
0.0398158841,
0.020036824,
-0.0294369403,
0.0270604491,
1.954853304e-34,
0.0314762779,
-0.0243685078,
-0.0401724875,
-0.007330541,
0.015013488,
-0.031763725,
-0.0041852384,
0.0151662538,
0.0128948037,
-0.0089090019,
0.0095372647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10727v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10727v1 | Jamp: Controlled Japanese Temporal Inference Dataset for Evaluating Generalization Capacity of Language Models | 2023-06-19T07:00:14 | 2023-06-19T07:00:14 | Tomoki Sugimoto, Yasumasa Onoe, Hitomi Yanaka | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural Language Inference (NLI) tasks involving temporal inference remain
challenging for pre-trained language models (LMs). Although various datasets
have been created for this task, they primarily focus on English and do not
address the need for resources in other languages. It is unclear whether
current LMs realize the generalization capacity for temporal inference across
languages. In this paper, we present Jamp, a Japanese NLI benchmark focused on
temporal inference. Our dataset includes a range of temporal inference
patterns, which enables us to conduct fine-grained analysis. To begin the data
annotation process, we create diverse inference templates based on the formal
semantics test suites. We then automatically generate diverse NLI examples by
using the Japanese case frame dictionary and well-designed templates while
controlling the distribution of inference patterns and gold labels. We evaluate
the generalization capacities of monolingual/multilingual LMs by splitting our
dataset based on tense fragments (i.e., temporal inference patterns). Our
findings demonstrate that LMs struggle with specific linguistic phenomena, such
as habituality, indicating that there is potential for the development of more
effective NLI models across languages. | [
0.0429405347,
0.0915522501,
-0.0153127844,
0.0358577557,
-0.039356716,
0.025517121,
0.0189239401,
0.0331426039,
-0.0143815409,
-0.0156752449,
-0.0015884297,
-0.0341485403,
0.0043664621,
0.015521219,
-0.0302277002,
-0.055387985,
0.0659921244,
0.022786608,
-0.009244049,
0.0242240801,
0.020958906,
-0.0131539516,
0.0003570191,
0.0397728048,
-0.0397882499,
-0.0232371558,
-0.0016338702,
-0.0349831432,
0.0175342597,
-0.0360408574,
0.0235475954,
0.047620777,
0.0051155528,
0.0163061656,
0.0000019303,
-0.0324987769,
0.0283038318,
-0.0439051688,
0.0030263565,
0.0530627705,
0.0036571543,
0.0009892805,
0.0360299349,
-0.0159497615,
-0.0731591433,
-0.081374459,
0.0243070256,
0.0180136021,
0.0319808349,
0.0665620342,
-0.0359660536,
-0.0223255493,
-0.0305372309,
-0.0457752161,
-0.0375105776,
-0.0381159894,
0.0235424712,
0.000520185,
-0.0025619606,
-0.0853748247,
0.0104066506,
0.0320544951,
0.0332730003,
0.0437304899,
-0.0549100935,
0.0311058722,
-0.02371113,
-0.0056668748,
-0.0086755902,
0.0442878567,
0.0482339151,
-0.05294374,
-0.027438689,
-0.0201458819,
-0.0300143007,
0.0091597904,
-0.0078911688,
-0.0068012327,
-0.0228345264,
0.0222428814,
0.0983438343,
0.052045729,
0.0358992815,
0.024051385,
-0.0366183184,
0.0991930962,
0.0369727202,
-0.0321958512,
-0.0141418139,
-0.0005476628,
0.0151990689,
-0.0418420844,
-0.0050159809,
0.0335382409,
0.0123970294,
0.0422215723,
-0.0327102914,
-0.0270538162,
0.0200523529,
-0.0538578965,
0.0303143617,
0.0175721943,
-0.0280566383,
0.0350850336,
0.003222557,
0.0124720689,
-0.0180370584,
0.016607767,
-0.0594730303,
-0.0079812976,
-0.0268418081,
0.0083478475,
-0.0411201529,
-0.0151215149,
0.0050177276,
0.0094439816,
-0.0536133163,
0.0172391143,
-0.0174866281,
-0.0051096785,
-0.0124561852,
-0.032062497,
-0.0437460802,
0.0017089385,
-0.05353247,
-0.0082574226,
-0.0621058866,
0.0271077659,
-0.0208563879,
-0.0623319931,
-0.007572724,
0.0075298515,
0.0329698697,
-0.0614934154,
-0.0111608207,
0.0352984555,
0.0175902136,
-0.0127921766,
-0.0693768337,
-0.0117684342,
-0.0284864213,
-0.0272157118,
-0.0102736112,
-0.0397107229,
0.0615179017,
-0.0045581819,
0.0119233606,
-0.0478393994,
-0.0053177169,
-0.0073280321,
0.006184082,
0.0386541672,
0.016892232,
0.0284413602,
-0.0197296645,
-0.0162957348,
0.0386668108,
0.0453987233,
0.0017276226,
-0.0248397589,
0.0510770455,
0.0118304007,
-0.0243950598,
0.0777256414,
0.0165102035,
0.0027230135,
-0.054922726,
0.0258034877,
0.0261164419,
0.0434254073,
0.0350842066,
0.0078602806,
-0.0039199521,
-0.0350451134,
0.0186035857,
0.0236816891,
-0.0279005915,
-0.019030707,
0.1066980809,
-0.0484126545,
0.0398432612,
0.0237136111,
-0.0211396199,
-0.0332994573,
-0.0332342014,
-0.0042830152,
-0.040509738,
0.0065110601,
-0.0392533913,
-0.0509666875,
-0.035767816,
-0.0153464684,
-0.0042777169,
-0.0015311248,
0.043665491,
0.0376830809,
-0.0126963193,
0.0744735003,
0.0536981151,
-0.0323736928,
-0.0157335978,
0.000063654,
0.0541695207,
0.0439517908,
0.0197223146,
-0.0389212817,
-0.0303702988,
0.0316069834,
0.0179901179,
0.0229379293,
0.0868550017,
-0.024822941,
0.0438731648,
0.0049965782,
0.0246699639,
0.0019767839,
0.0308604185,
0.0298063774,
0.0596142709,
0.0573947355,
0.0160741583,
-0.0504840352,
-0.0277426224,
0.0673212335,
-0.0657905266,
-0.020864239,
-0.0218960196,
0.0227109026,
0.0507676601,
-0.009940003,
-0.0119440956,
-0.0075130821,
0.0253994241,
-0.0472687595,
0.0417882539,
0.0962934271,
-0.0503407381,
-0.0694293156,
0.0285972245,
0.0196884777,
-0.0395992771,
0.0357386097,
-0.0555094555,
-0.0096827541,
0.0081138322,
0.0679864958,
0.0732671991,
-0.0810609758,
0.0037253452,
-0.012499474,
0.0506107546,
-0.0133823771,
0.0595600456,
-0.0212770589,
0.0023634122,
-0.0151535515,
-0.0125866821,
0.0314775184,
-0.0504597463,
-0.0578683391,
0.0162580907,
-0.0038680939,
-0.0409740731,
0.0037458665,
-0.0033712806,
-0.032977879,
0.0349366069,
-0.0880417377,
-0.0162960589,
-0.0248441063,
0.0048399647,
0.0051352512,
0.0076227034,
-0.0401190855,
-0.0119686518,
0.0104899956,
0.0121224532,
0.0011004759,
0.0270810593,
0.0450165793,
0.0227413494,
0.0175831113,
-0.0751592368,
-0.0019598699,
-0.023246564,
0.0501637012,
-0.0203663781,
-0.0436218381,
0.0061702072,
0.0035934218,
-0.0377993844,
0.0267988779,
-0.0233466607,
-0.0268989019,
0.0122475475,
-0.0448199734,
0.0572747216,
0.0517440513,
-0.0107548544,
0.0159934349,
0.0407998078,
-0.0431778282,
-0.0338246189,
0.0247163419,
-0.022692902,
-0.0208901335,
-0.0327582508,
-0.0243295468,
0.0155632272,
0.101803638,
0.0053758286,
-0.0012265402,
-0.0283775833,
-0.0192465205,
-0.0540562645,
-0.004036013,
0.0043135923,
0.0440823399,
-0.0447561964,
0.045151554,
-0.0335818343,
-0.0413565785,
0.0803402662,
0.0037083002,
0.0025942165,
0.0295836758,
-0.0102070505,
-0.0433631726,
0.1073659211,
0.0250083469,
-0.0181345213,
0.0350018851,
-0.0058237598,
-0.027833052,
0.0063922196,
0.0398794152,
-0.0080068111,
0.0365044847,
-0.0692936033,
0.0137494728,
0.0124085732,
-0.0011082272,
-0.0438245684,
-0.0671581775,
-0.0678679124,
-0.051367484,
-0.0478651449,
0.0306847673,
0.0016408397,
0.029035883,
-0.0749755874,
0.0514735244,
0.0011147124,
0.0205024704,
-0.0059165745,
0.0144865541,
0.0341792554,
-0.0011206133,
-0.0391434431,
-0.0080941059,
0.0029632915,
0.0122872042,
0.0103518199,
0.0076857852,
-0.0653831661,
0.0029162441,
0.0123211406,
-0.0420328006,
0.0016328774,
0.0340494812,
0.0436673313,
-0.0406427756,
-0.0089182891,
0.0904098973,
0.0501138829,
-0.0018050522,
0.0294990111,
-0.002215005,
0.033907488,
0.0090607572,
-0.0073651858,
-0.1026644558,
-0.0433543958,
-0.0009287216,
-0.0426051505,
-0.0193839297,
-0.0275828522,
-0.0081541603,
-0.1465898454,
-0.0239747576,
-0.0131687503,
-0.0381678008,
0.0516947284,
-0.0238847341,
0.0198659766,
-0.0273704715,
0.02865839,
-0.022481719,
0.0010695403,
-0.0064463592,
-0.0093450909,
-0.0790302679,
-0.0776081607,
0.0627277717,
-0.0009289006,
0.0473761335,
-0.0212176777,
0.0367090143,
-0.0163083524,
-0.0263309367,
0.0461386293,
0.0101743704,
-0.0019705046,
-0.0175720267,
0.0305625629,
-0.0009459898,
-0.0079713855,
0.0133431004,
0.0023095727,
0.0250849109,
-0.0313843302,
0.0478867628,
0.0706133395,
0.0249036849,
-0.041803401,
-0.0249009356,
-0.0119653847,
-0.0046252985,
0.0656821206,
0.0202292167,
-0.0356797315,
-0.0309198648,
0.021433413,
-0.0307015758,
-0.0651745349,
-0.0051815119,
-0.0090554878,
-0.019868806,
0.0144291408,
-0.091780819,
-0.0539838634,
0.0093096839,
-0.0022782208,
0.0211886559,
-0.0238816813,
-0.0225472637,
0.0095663676,
-0.0565735735,
0.0598670393,
-0.0233837515,
0.0282458831,
-0.0312360022,
-0.0224583689,
0.0111630308,
0.0148799093,
-0.0090274895,
0.0597212426,
-0.0560674369,
-0.0392877311,
0.0180024281,
0.0538136698,
0.0072191088,
0.062378332,
-0.0194265544,
0.0093464823,
0.0032993981,
-0.0038158782,
0.0090280036,
-0.0052830684,
0.046206478,
-0.0031690253,
0.0134425266,
0.036558982,
-0.0537240319,
0.0094388546,
-0.0036800085,
0.001655724,
-0.0187626462,
-0.025195824,
0.0431407765,
-0.006823034,
0.0294977948,
-0.0035337745,
-0.0031156824,
-0.0442577787,
-0.0077641406,
-0.0348505788,
-0.0311497804,
-0.0175271332,
0.0066568744,
0.041205503,
0.0439759195,
-0.0521076284,
0.0229994357,
-0.0412817486,
0.0320680216,
-0.03266415,
-0.0123502444,
0.0789146274,
0.0386346951,
-0.0062491591,
-0.0059659914,
-0.0340379551,
-0.0335170254,
-0.0281778313,
0.0160546601,
-0.0002682927,
0.0319983065,
0.0086444886,
0.0209530964,
-0.000730103,
-0.0270054769,
-0.0329475291,
0.0335169658,
0.0190498549,
-0.0308743604,
0.0862013549,
-0.0712328777,
0.0543176606,
-0.0266836155,
-0.013206373,
0.0002222532,
0.0535931773,
0.0261642653,
-0.0471469499,
0.0040602051,
0.0000510667,
-0.0169324409,
0.0293988585,
0.0685054734,
0.0143535584,
0.0649478585,
0.029955199,
0.0271718837,
-0.0238778312,
-0.0114446143,
-0.0061659603,
0.0044288058,
-0.0188804884,
-0.0293106586,
-0.0644693971,
-0.0846256018,
0.0059595383,
0.0202555731,
-0.0153564736,
0.0394364111,
-0.0199929196,
0.0583536215,
0.0343237184,
-0.0143723171,
-0.0211997982,
0.0137128467,
0.0214503817,
0.0254303012,
-0.0738784373,
-6.198186286e-33,
-0.0290752891,
0.0126440041,
0.011420452,
0.0088571198,
-0.0107342107,
-0.0022147093,
-0.0527822785,
-0.0139170634,
-0.032085944,
-0.0027508894,
-0.0387934707,
0.0002210792,
0.020681439,
-0.0097246356,
0.0088212667,
0.0056161727,
0.0025864439,
0.0269850791,
-0.0046938299,
-0.0210019574,
0.0237916969,
0.0105920993,
0.0857822523,
-0.0165367089,
0.0246354006,
0.0116586145,
0.0042087422,
0.0242253952,
-0.0264262818,
0.031554684,
-0.0176739264,
0.0358825326,
0.0179519244,
0.0171966758,
-0.0092299562,
-0.0067304904,
-0.1230880842,
-0.0387896784,
0.0473273396,
0.0215438567,
-0.0273918826,
-0.001743066,
-0.0226418544,
-0.0195022523,
0.0017666919,
0.0111622801,
0.0402885973,
-0.0361839533,
0.0057468996,
-0.0372440778,
-0.0511427633,
0.0478745624,
0.0015823656,
0.0279081073,
-0.0157133229,
0.0365008041,
-0.0058834944,
-0.0183716398,
-0.0395009592,
0.0162248164,
0.0046300823,
-0.0043417239,
0.0104310233,
0.0132161574,
0.0112598427,
0.0364513546,
0.0177116711,
0.0032662491,
-0.0143031916,
0.0528111123,
0.0527803153,
-0.0061132051,
-0.0062504965,
0.0750418827,
0.0716306046,
-0.0241754316,
-0.0394475199,
0.0109690102,
0.0706438795,
0.0239376761,
0.0209827181,
-0.0192040484,
-0.030844992,
-0.0199383441,
-0.0178094786,
-0.0006877718,
-0.0148725715,
-0.0123832952,
0.0302880965,
0.002622976,
0.0103062186,
-0.0002485911,
0.016695613,
-0.040645469,
-0.0190476272,
0.0294509996,
-0.0253575202,
-0.0255724862,
0.0041714134,
0.0483968481,
-0.0470790453,
-0.0417712778,
-0.0204443652,
-0.0112353088,
0.0338494256,
-0.0161466282,
0.0346405134,
0.014671348,
-0.0165521428,
-0.0022065926,
-0.0224638991,
-0.04038186,
-0.0146114482,
-0.0206466764,
0.0738176629,
0.0270368345,
-0.0165912677,
0.0227697399,
0.0351404808,
0.0287698116,
-0.0633372366,
-0.0276893489,
0.0180295873,
0.0434090346,
-0.0020400602,
-0.0253678504,
-0.0323279351,
0.0245599952,
0.04581948,
-0.0180385411,
0.0034181227,
0.0115121556,
2.566e-7,
0.0479257889,
0.0064018187,
0.0090033635,
0.0574536026,
-0.0074620531,
-0.0354298539,
-0.0035918697,
-0.0097811809,
0.0205164365,
0.0339380018,
0.0441526882,
0.025166193,
0.0702696294,
0.0182166304,
-0.0606192797,
-0.0157302767,
-0.0729176179,
0.0067639984,
-0.0774785951,
-0.0265213717,
0.0246352665,
0.0970379785,
0.0544564053,
0.014043984,
-0.0087282266,
-0.0596798733,
0.0643233135,
-0.0181312822,
-0.0368746072,
0.0346833095,
0.0304335766,
0.0190982819,
0.0105752964,
-0.0138604855,
-0.001405683,
0.0205279943,
-0.0153666316,
0.0509719923,
-0.0064630532,
-0.0383005664,
-0.031989038,
-0.0145199839,
-0.0474267751,
-0.0323340036,
0.1056616455,
-0.0813858211,
-0.0134354448,
-0.0017101878,
-0.0233706031,
0.0265390202,
0.0184355248,
0.0341365226,
-0.0016625305,
0.0386670902,
0.0402266756,
-0.0210724026,
-0.0605543554,
-0.0520851873,
-0.0587030053,
0.0303264074,
-0.0092921844,
-0.0097603863,
-0.0310926139,
-0.0505784005,
0.0108589493,
-0.0417950228,
0.0429579802,
2.029666402e-34,
0.0230579954,
0.0170275383,
-0.0023838631,
0.0260163229,
0.0457899906,
-0.049459856,
0.0120918313,
0.0221416242,
0.0198658071,
-0.0244152453,
0.0096960003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10723v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10723v2 | Fine-tuning Large Enterprise Language Models via Ontological Reasoning | 2023-06-19T06:48:45 | 2023-09-18T21:37:37 | Teodoro Baldazzi, Luigi Bellomarini, Stefano Ceri, Andrea Colombo, Andrea Gentili, Emanuel Sallinger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.LO | Large Language Models (LLMs) exploit fine-tuning as a technique to adapt to
diverse goals, thanks to task-specific training data. Task specificity should
go hand in hand with domain orientation, that is, the specialization of an LLM
to accurately address the tasks of a given realm of interest. However, models
are usually fine-tuned over publicly available data or, at most, over ground
data from databases, ignoring business-level definitions and domain experience.
On the other hand, Enterprise Knowledge Graphs (EKGs) are able to capture and
augment such domain knowledge via ontological reasoning. With the goal of
combining LLM flexibility with the domain orientation of EKGs, we propose a
novel neurosymbolic architecture that leverages the power of ontological
reasoning to build task- and domain-specific corpora for LLM fine-tuning. | [
0.0591611788,
0.0200124234,
-0.0177196339,
0.0465834066,
-0.0042621894,
0.0289022289,
-0.0016982113,
0.0183003917,
0.0302104894,
-0.0242146403,
-0.0336594023,
0.0197641533,
-0.0123649081,
0.0919717774,
0.0527192727,
-0.0082346955,
0.0455824025,
-0.0002325273,
0.0019229599,
-0.0264049489,
-0.0120360143,
0.0335288085,
-0.0147712743,
-0.0113763381,
0.0305878464,
0.0081799645,
0.0028902199,
-0.0110647352,
-0.0052648196,
0.0067395186,
-0.0044479766,
0.0050131641,
0.0282814708,
-0.0176252294,
0.000002068,
-0.0646344721,
0.00181465,
-0.0028051883,
-0.0462878533,
-0.0499641187,
0.0368777402,
-0.0111077884,
0.0097088041,
-0.0097982381,
-0.0496465191,
0.020018898,
0.0213226825,
0.0502067618,
0.0144449295,
0.073515974,
-0.0165669601,
-0.0352480933,
-0.0049913134,
-0.029434029,
-0.0131888427,
-0.0288761053,
0.0337611325,
0.0043557654,
0.0435357168,
0.018641727,
-0.0056354185,
0.014920651,
0.0026204246,
0.023137752,
0.0466767177,
0.0279002637,
0.0405658707,
0.015724225,
0.0085803345,
0.0281251054,
0.0278778523,
0.0061109387,
0.0117450552,
0.011183436,
0.0061888914,
0.0043645808,
-0.0162192695,
0.0108035039,
-0.0153832119,
0.0064658765,
0.0192024,
-0.0502663814,
0.0382313803,
0.0373410769,
-0.041356463,
0.1276766658,
-0.0016929612,
-0.00697438,
0.0426079743,
-0.0125961639,
-0.017000759,
-0.0231958423,
0.0237855632,
0.0366408862,
-0.033243522,
0.0440658964,
-0.0245705098,
0.0387226529,
-0.0332487598,
-0.02779481,
-0.0170183443,
0.0233725458,
0.0525859259,
0.0346750878,
-0.0180228874,
0.0204341542,
-0.0352782384,
0.018004816,
-0.0407839231,
-0.032137908,
-0.1008699685,
-0.0078573879,
-0.0223194472,
0.0252269413,
-0.0271274596,
-0.0338199213,
-0.0689781606,
0.0552412681,
-0.0323883407,
0.0094333347,
0.037975993,
0.0491598174,
0.0140285529,
-0.0418480821,
-0.0718652457,
0.0178910233,
0.0051793391,
0.0324986726,
0.007927129,
0.0099612987,
0.0324468836,
-0.0092337038,
-0.027519742,
-0.0283444449,
0.0348633602,
0.0866342857,
0.0613368824,
-0.0030195797,
-0.0930301547,
-0.0452565625,
-0.0269570053,
-0.0147377532,
0.0559111722,
-0.0483572818,
0.0097283972,
0.0160257798,
-0.011855986,
-0.096199587,
-0.0100107472,
-0.0406635329,
-0.0860487521,
0.0803978816,
-0.0569760092,
0.0067132362,
0.0199959688,
-0.0007745511,
-0.0077326111,
0.0575453267,
0.0340971649,
0.0072498638,
0.0429472551,
0.0243908279,
-0.0611473024,
0.0132724494,
-0.00384306,
-0.0234574582,
-0.0245319437,
0.0035505733,
-0.0580185875,
0.036966417,
0.0653994307,
-0.0217175055,
-0.004443794,
0.0251459256,
0.0478910692,
0.025443716,
0.0358222835,
0.0025230309,
0.0050210664,
-0.0179807507,
-0.0337109566,
-0.0357517265,
-0.0606459454,
0.0479947701,
-0.0047386107,
0.0038550545,
-0.0188795254,
-0.0280781984,
-0.0087405983,
-0.0281804986,
0.0159882288,
0.0061788894,
-0.0097135836,
0.0442213118,
0.0613584369,
-0.0169754606,
-0.0141111026,
0.0990483761,
0.0369678698,
0.0007556969,
0.0255787596,
-0.0248617474,
-0.0220837444,
0.1020265967,
0.0459026843,
-0.0437244438,
-0.0532948002,
0.0196594521,
-0.0266141947,
0.0975088179,
0.0481586903,
-0.0197512228,
-0.0112335095,
-0.0540597923,
-0.0331762061,
-0.0344159529,
-0.0082718199,
-0.0077765044,
-0.0056275371,
0.0166688114,
-0.0145758903,
-0.0616097413,
-0.0295560304,
0.0056810048,
-0.0553951822,
0.0038207904,
-0.0297051277,
0.0244485419,
0.036573559,
0.0282729268,
-0.001123156,
0.0351551846,
0.0025628444,
-0.0343147293,
-0.0377698727,
-0.0069096796,
-0.0217778943,
0.0039444207,
0.0331140198,
0.024786301,
-0.0017871147,
-0.0084720217,
-0.0406579711,
-0.0365769938,
0.0381985568,
0.0114352601,
0.0502786823,
-0.0285896808,
-0.0202695783,
-0.0248387773,
-0.0391875245,
-0.0068274955,
0.0140876388,
0.0323680267,
0.0037319812,
-0.0201959051,
-0.0111781759,
0.0261755381,
-0.0369232669,
-0.0168746132,
0.0204172358,
0.0127074318,
0.0256786216,
0.0162361842,
-0.0330907628,
-0.0614516586,
0.0026475277,
-0.0848598778,
0.0162155833,
0.0393932983,
0.040201202,
0.0388227738,
-0.0023691875,
0.0000511876,
-0.0052867499,
-0.0270071588,
0.0300765485,
0.0194250271,
0.0044813203,
0.0206749737,
-0.002887368,
-0.0109686274,
0.0208152179,
-0.0080817295,
-0.0319252871,
0.0180700496,
-0.010350341,
0.014706796,
-0.0870531499,
0.063927412,
-0.0626742989,
0.0404962897,
0.0082068807,
-0.0008493439,
0.0164373275,
0.0082364287,
-0.0105000278,
0.0658573881,
-0.0300904792,
-0.0002399016,
0.0405095741,
-0.0212742686,
0.0071508694,
-0.0194199681,
-0.0316181965,
0.0326456837,
-0.0628699511,
0.0005175405,
0.0068991068,
0.0626622364,
0.016263064,
-0.0266085491,
-0.0598980971,
0.0346843377,
-0.0495828725,
-0.0005066442,
-0.0354648232,
0.0114167007,
-0.0013504544,
0.0519340038,
-0.0257805493,
-0.015264119,
0.0589167438,
0.0252588317,
0.0332238749,
-0.0140359858,
0.0017833164,
-0.031307824,
0.0652839318,
-0.0346554965,
0.0105567798,
0.0382013693,
-0.03190713,
-0.0606280044,
-0.0097844116,
-0.0025287275,
-0.0247885846,
0.0348327458,
-0.060399279,
0.0194997359,
0.040577054,
0.0047941064,
-0.0321034938,
0.0693898499,
-0.0644662827,
0.0745076388,
0.0383278467,
-0.0094298339,
-0.0434730873,
0.0071688914,
0.0084106,
-0.0011510887,
-0.009480848,
-0.0380205922,
-0.0072784545,
-0.0014109926,
0.0578208715,
0.0335861407,
0.0335436314,
-0.0080728829,
-0.0266226903,
0.0230011791,
-0.005669578,
-0.0559951589,
-0.0337921903,
0.0178511161,
0.0147965597,
-0.0743785203,
-0.0243995078,
0.0094068423,
-0.0016486931,
-0.0283128656,
-0.0015425102,
0.1292964667,
0.0058227042,
-0.0023027933,
0.0149418162,
0.0007893284,
-0.0070332936,
0.0481419303,
0.064762719,
-0.0672751665,
-0.0361042209,
-0.0187823195,
0.056251578,
0.0499465913,
-0.0578544587,
-0.013851,
-0.0667216405,
0.0362778679,
-0.0012767027,
-0.0209339559,
-0.0382925309,
-0.0200899225,
0.0230273195,
-0.0344147198,
-0.0052900603,
0.030078344,
-0.011534011,
-0.0218696222,
0.0519190729,
0.0060287756,
-0.0960160196,
0.0292639658,
-0.0388604142,
0.0665732995,
-0.0109443907,
0.0220518876,
-0.0001552037,
-0.0067296433,
-0.0257849768,
0.0076209293,
0.0317020044,
-0.0352279432,
0.0403288938,
0.0192967951,
-0.0095721548,
-0.0119074397,
-0.0125873797,
-0.073138386,
-0.013579512,
-0.0105806412,
0.0697820112,
-0.037302006,
0.00466689,
0.015308911,
-0.0132523235,
-0.0184610151,
0.0592611171,
-0.0109357135,
-0.0216285922,
-0.0066939467,
-0.0101459753,
-0.052950222,
-0.0298556276,
-0.0233277176,
0.0350820906,
-0.0358716324,
-0.0119900843,
-0.0547463372,
-0.029505942,
0.049683556,
0.0161880236,
0.0347284377,
0.0078942273,
0.0938965827,
-0.0496749431,
-0.0493353121,
-0.0050951326,
-0.0514361449,
0.0412446372,
-0.0562259518,
-0.0034980159,
0.012622417,
-0.0220008418,
-0.0120746875,
-0.0174727123,
-0.0228356495,
-0.0727925003,
0.0066542556,
0.0037341649,
0.029974794,
0.0295231249,
-0.007798472,
-0.0445400327,
0.0448687933,
0.0276189651,
-0.0850271955,
-0.0017361351,
0.0183565691,
0.0117708957,
-0.0182341747,
0.0488729104,
-0.0787019506,
0.0227863267,
0.0374287218,
0.0460078493,
0.0034798402,
-0.0497962087,
-0.0035183891,
0.0501042679,
0.0005421371,
-0.0094167646,
-0.023178678,
-0.0923207775,
-0.0261735693,
0.0189671088,
-0.0055808956,
-0.0311915725,
-0.0192285124,
-0.0033421074,
-0.0128519656,
0.0144672841,
0.0257341079,
-0.0015549132,
-0.0249827877,
-0.0275241565,
-0.0206768196,
-0.0233376268,
-0.0061297719,
0.0022825908,
0.0045331037,
0.0059762732,
0.0095340041,
0.0124960421,
0.0431682542,
-0.0584447049,
0.0840370953,
0.0329105631,
-0.0251193475,
-0.0748227909,
0.0271449946,
-0.0245412495,
-0.0480118357,
0.0794971436,
-0.0134194707,
0.0558368154,
-0.0182374939,
0.0560541973,
-0.068522945,
0.0148492372,
0.0120721608,
0.0448646098,
0.0015375796,
0.0079909312,
0.0277953371,
0.0304593053,
-0.00114634,
-0.0282345973,
0.0642901585,
0.0183992051,
0.0370595902,
-0.0350230262,
-0.0435599387,
-0.0341672264,
-0.0317831375,
0.0545475893,
0.0020424924,
-0.04716352,
0.0300675649,
-0.0614147447,
-0.074720338,
0.0029006731,
0.0219450295,
-0.0363407657,
-0.0331952162,
0.0546249822,
0.0367285348,
0.0256966874,
-0.0306425188,
-0.004890345,
0.0079857763,
-0.0370503142,
0.0100586331,
-0.026479017,
-6.002850349e-33,
-0.0068571405,
-0.0193573758,
0.0458697416,
0.0137079386,
-0.0237023514,
-0.004431291,
-0.0199484844,
-0.0071111238,
-0.0375742204,
0.0124030393,
-0.0222745519,
0.0098560043,
-0.003360694,
-0.0222379789,
0.0337109677,
0.0122827496,
0.0048222761,
0.0062604612,
0.0046462752,
0.0215401035,
0.0677680746,
0.0334314406,
0.0785396919,
-0.0307766329,
0.0319529586,
0.0351886116,
0.0139138335,
0.0662828982,
-0.0085769938,
0.0398669094,
0.0027950797,
0.0558530726,
0.0354429744,
-0.0613780022,
0.000528461,
-0.0342772938,
-0.0635212734,
-0.060785193,
0.0555803776,
0.0153963463,
0.009493487,
-0.0218378976,
0.0408754982,
0.0037148541,
0.0209227633,
-0.0100706816,
0.0375129506,
-0.0642404109,
-0.025084354,
-0.0127359955,
-0.0572309457,
-0.0008995074,
0.0335382782,
-0.0046434626,
0.0044600456,
-0.0465253852,
-0.0309154168,
-0.0389973782,
-0.0610153489,
0.0432080179,
-0.0280460641,
0.0135660442,
0.0763577595,
0.0364788622,
-0.0066254325,
0.0319762602,
-0.0288472045,
0.0423143134,
0.0146039771,
0.0339712761,
0.0261023678,
0.0881023183,
-0.0063835178,
-0.0377540663,
-0.014068298,
-0.0294894408,
-0.0481174029,
0.0065987408,
0.0104638971,
0.0515777357,
0.0334023871,
0.0191541277,
0.0038137154,
-0.0726683661,
-0.0096672401,
0.0570776239,
-0.0335973911,
-0.0187770426,
0.003205725,
-0.0410516188,
0.0005573114,
0.0269444194,
-0.0190829597,
-0.057533592,
0.0013087144,
0.0221299473,
0.0157951228,
-0.0169438701,
0.0160626099,
-0.0107865399,
-0.0778968707,
-0.046077624,
-0.017742021,
-0.0214487184,
-0.0009062646,
-0.0000981932,
-0.0049542338,
0.028802285,
-0.0046811136,
-0.0071364199,
-0.0662022978,
0.0035582981,
0.016399866,
-0.0089647919,
-0.0074894135,
0.0515856296,
0.0097236624,
0.0241288114,
0.0209132098,
-0.034140449,
-0.0257649645,
0.0637293383,
0.0303854011,
0.0514668338,
-0.026438212,
0.0041634836,
-0.0172955729,
0.0130761107,
-0.0197948422,
-0.0299029052,
-0.0433833189,
-0.0054168785,
2.84e-7,
0.0556217544,
0.0467321128,
-0.019437857,
0.0392948613,
0.0393547527,
0.0318049043,
-0.0064002494,
-0.0225931145,
-0.0131178228,
-0.0514793061,
-0.0019406447,
0.0551341437,
0.0374297313,
0.0132147288,
-0.0427992828,
-0.0209316909,
0.0433913656,
-0.0107420441,
-0.0245287064,
0.031531658,
0.0371673629,
0.0194853004,
0.0597684942,
-0.0270018298,
0.0097945426,
-0.0557850637,
0.0328453742,
-0.0075678872,
0.0409014076,
0.0255703442,
-0.0101220338,
0.0227312688,
-0.0255855918,
0.0627050027,
0.0116822235,
0.0231191032,
-0.0297907051,
0.0332198702,
-0.0384130329,
0.0264756288,
0.006445644,
-0.0691321343,
-0.0303683244,
-0.0652551576,
0.0210850798,
-0.1115156412,
-0.0704934523,
0.0060534151,
-0.0096208788,
-0.000941441,
-0.0492819585,
-0.0074603558,
-0.0113135697,
-0.046995867,
0.0116379522,
-0.0196358897,
-0.0279710405,
-0.0263251085,
0.0392279141,
0.067223914,
-0.0309641678,
-0.0479640774,
-0.010690161,
-0.0136288442,
0.0383588038,
-0.0505582504,
0.0125823496,
2.330304822e-34,
-0.0028822569,
0.0500598624,
-0.0226327218,
-0.0146242846,
0.0383737534,
-0.0137874857,
-0.0026372029,
-0.0032117201,
0.0200569034,
-0.0881852061,
-0.0305355843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.05493v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.05493v1 | Cases of EFL Secondary Students' Prompt Engineering Pathways to Complete a Writing Task with ChatGPT | 2023-06-19T06:45:04 | 2023-06-19T06:45:04 | David James Woo, Kai Guo, Hengky Susanto | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | ChatGPT is a state-of-the-art (SOTA) chatbot. Although it has potential to
support English as a foreign language (EFL) students' writing, to effectively
collaborate with it, a student must learn to engineer prompts, that is, the
skill of crafting appropriate instructions so that ChatGPT produces desired
outputs. However, writing an appropriate prompt for ChatGPT is not
straightforward for non-technical users who suffer a trial-and-error process.
This paper examines the content of EFL students' ChatGPT prompts when
completing a writing task and explores patterns in the quality and quantity of
the prompts. The data come from iPad screen recordings of secondary school EFL
students who used ChatGPT and other SOTA chatbots for the first time to
complete the same writing task. The paper presents a case study of four
distinct pathways that illustrate the trial-and-error process and show
different combinations of prompt content and quantity. The cases contribute
evidence for the need to provide prompt engineering education in the context of
the EFL writing classroom, if students are to move beyond an individual
trial-and-error process, learning a greater variety of prompt content and more
sophisticated prompts to support their writing. | [
0.0520378649,
-0.0953781605,
-0.0422490984,
-0.0373001359,
-0.0544979051,
-0.0024897628,
0.0385137722,
-0.0170021933,
0.07734707,
-0.0247083772,
0.011497668,
-0.0201106761,
0.0364461914,
0.0492325313,
-0.0033442911,
-0.0446091369,
-0.0035291817,
0.0052547157,
-0.0040783207,
0.0228966437,
0.0449729711,
0.0535119995,
-0.0460968837,
0.066745691,
-0.052518785,
-0.0695022792,
-0.0658942387,
-0.0037058229,
-0.0081216004,
-0.0031563856,
0.0478787795,
0.0681392401,
-0.0272898916,
0.0227982216,
0.0000020416,
-0.0303243175,
-0.0067776884,
-0.0313656554,
-0.0552459396,
-0.0000820169,
0.0253500398,
0.0721338838,
-0.0411497466,
0.0280904099,
-0.0399760604,
0.0406307206,
0.0718798488,
0.0052065081,
0.0195082072,
0.0291260686,
0.0061831754,
0.0376162603,
0.0237328075,
0.029088553,
0.0416105948,
0.0205807239,
-0.040885929,
-0.0162497479,
0.1184966862,
0.0475682355,
-0.0205487981,
0.0428518616,
0.0417965092,
-0.0605198145,
-0.0075965617,
0.0409114771,
0.0133382389,
-0.0608536042,
-0.0109291244,
0.0345945358,
0.0722066537,
-0.0021267964,
-0.016510278,
-0.0042040804,
0.0198764652,
0.045988135,
-0.0336849764,
0.029465178,
-0.0554919839,
-0.0261692349,
-0.0138059007,
-0.0775502175,
-0.0586643815,
0.0202783495,
0.0611979403,
-0.0301639587,
0.0028541845,
-0.0112341763,
-0.0234169681,
0.0187884606,
0.0462259911,
-0.0445608646,
0.0285838228,
0.0799155384,
-0.0353683345,
-0.0012687332,
-0.0289993919,
-0.0336673856,
-0.0174672063,
0.0156508517,
-0.0005809894,
0.073388122,
-0.0027985617,
0.0108854277,
0.0109590208,
0.0479486547,
0.0171739906,
0.0677763224,
-0.0184948165,
0.0512301587,
-0.0371649005,
-0.0534978807,
-0.0660540685,
0.0306336582,
-0.0097064869,
-0.0099659208,
-0.0228521135,
0.0292339753,
0.0068354025,
0.0356864966,
-0.01681263,
-0.0087005384,
-0.0202097129,
-0.0115886619,
0.0191188212,
-0.0072637787,
-0.0083140722,
-0.0041533723,
0.0025725476,
-0.0670473427,
0.0169742908,
-0.0031724744,
0.0118989525,
-0.0127617419,
-0.0079337228,
0.0133597786,
-0.0385241769,
-0.0301770829,
-0.011598153,
-0.0302116945,
-0.0103152413,
-0.0314616039,
-0.0155819785,
-0.0257528927,
-0.0087354667,
0.0345208496,
-0.0172776002,
-0.0302540343,
-0.0058923252,
0.0425674394,
0.0314394832,
0.0147899808,
-0.0397831537,
-0.0029232642,
0.0647439286,
0.0162777677,
-0.0500821918,
-0.0094119441,
0.03326286,
0.0184669923,
-0.0075379545,
-0.0173442885,
0.0571676642,
0.039412763,
-0.0560878366,
-0.0230391733,
0.0286043491,
-0.0391369835,
0.0359081179,
0.0074794781,
-0.0358785726,
0.0142837511,
-0.0070762797,
0.1090496704,
0.0390258133,
0.0376276262,
-0.0166572016,
-0.0114292083,
0.0102500739,
0.0083132684,
0.0231043268,
0.0527099781,
-0.0081531806,
0.0206676126,
-0.0027126351,
-0.0111375153,
0.0053003905,
0.000939136,
-0.0070771193,
-0.0257919133,
-0.0063738753,
0.0044275108,
-0.0002194717,
0.0084911902,
0.0086790631,
0.0061601861,
-0.0225539096,
-0.0114281764,
-0.0135523714,
-0.0507017225,
0.0080371303,
-0.0422164351,
0.0487928875,
0.0942180231,
0.0376408845,
-0.0281717591,
-0.0275559593,
-0.0169701967,
0.0293762237,
0.0392873771,
0.0213259123,
-0.0009499534,
-0.0375001319,
-0.0009830978,
-0.010932981,
-0.0399575531,
-0.0254023224,
-0.0252181571,
-0.0227277633,
0.0469726436,
0.0013142433,
0.0585167445,
-0.0342038572,
0.0282605905,
-0.0560743026,
-0.0341556408,
-0.0330612622,
0.0302675478,
-0.0319221206,
0.0474509783,
-0.0243548844,
0.0165202413,
-0.0313021503,
0.0092934435,
0.0007494629,
0.0078902515,
-0.0358994864,
-0.0200472865,
0.0344876871,
-0.0514716282,
-0.0316044576,
0.0086006969,
0.0202232935,
-0.0082035968,
-0.0045016394,
-0.0281525869,
0.0372872762,
0.0070197578,
0.0263300464,
-0.0378941745,
-0.0580945425,
-0.0252076816,
-0.0198451653,
0.0479684323,
0.0221970417,
0.0168429315,
0.0547784828,
0.0090520149,
-0.0021946209,
-0.0156147927,
0.069014959,
-0.0042415345,
0.0272068456,
0.0024118423,
0.0438997634,
-0.0634176135,
-0.0263477918,
-0.0775683671,
-0.0348913558,
-0.002556595,
-0.0228986181,
0.0585592017,
-0.0335792825,
-0.0243592039,
-0.0070583522,
-0.0380957276,
-0.0241729971,
0.0039382204,
0.0003247146,
0.0199641455,
-0.0257955045,
-0.0041853343,
-0.0068621156,
-0.0009222154,
-0.0257501435,
0.0028707653,
0.0694830045,
-0.0580034144,
-0.0562210828,
0.0368907116,
0.0382954814,
-0.0611599721,
0.0200867616,
-0.0266318489,
0.0420225672,
-0.0139634218,
0.0811896101,
0.0400936902,
0.0162649844,
0.0423465446,
0.0235298704,
-0.0207703672,
-0.0139456429,
-0.0008821317,
0.0231513735,
0.0096741188,
0.0422549918,
-0.0716154426,
-0.0155194141,
0.0053163134,
0.0268358327,
0.012170258,
-0.0537207499,
0.0707239509,
-0.0474406295,
0.0230435934,
-0.0674885511,
-0.0570057295,
-0.0446287282,
0.0252073761,
-0.0037030329,
-0.0538029149,
0.0349105783,
-0.0188875124,
-0.0232584532,
-0.0477356315,
-0.0030053763,
0.0152112916,
0.0733886138,
-0.0688358322,
0.0418603048,
0.043888744,
-0.0591892302,
-0.0517135672,
0.0152782882,
0.037431322,
-0.0056094369,
-0.0225274339,
-0.0460594222,
0.0023196551,
-0.0206735395,
0.0076467046,
-0.0146830315,
-0.0435369201,
-0.0136560313,
-0.0094763134,
0.0155702494,
-0.0167170223,
-0.0003788486,
-0.0123320492,
0.0597190075,
0.0524619371,
-0.0362866335,
-0.0027876727,
-0.0206861757,
-0.0166189093,
0.0035349068,
-0.0124632744,
-0.0003280316,
-0.0405550338,
0.064260304,
0.044282686,
-0.0025645802,
-0.0050277477,
0.0173949264,
-0.0304600019,
0.0281408429,
-0.028411923,
-0.0528149754,
0.011358805,
0.0790136606,
-0.0499435514,
-0.0163403489,
0.0635991842,
0.0033438271,
-0.0216122437,
-0.0110175367,
-0.0203038678,
-0.0092791589,
-0.0208220892,
0.0424737222,
-0.0658131093,
0.0286061019,
0.0150269065,
0.0368748419,
-0.0259542596,
-0.006911261,
-0.0420972109,
-0.0452836044,
0.0412524417,
-0.0022730615,
-0.056463737,
-0.018776061,
-0.0003363442,
-0.0257774554,
0.0736429319,
0.0342269205,
-0.0003446628,
-0.0076206801,
0.0393310413,
0.0351668596,
-0.0505772308,
0.0117272334,
0.0012581075,
0.0150105534,
0.0617929287,
0.0093493126,
-0.0031784947,
0.0040851901,
0.0144857923,
0.0399002619,
0.018582724,
0.0109759457,
-0.0113893291,
-0.0051053944,
-0.0045042248,
0.0034461592,
-0.0453781821,
0.0202554036,
-0.0249907319,
-0.0582639985,
0.0484219268,
0.0375479683,
-0.0411828533,
0.0044650445,
-0.007726267,
0.0308383442,
0.0358673967,
0.0082923574,
0.0109908925,
-0.0542522334,
-0.0098881405,
-0.0303820167,
0.0196678787,
-0.0011140839,
-0.0346113183,
0.0100785894,
-0.0314640403,
0.0176179521,
-0.0086717969,
-0.1056929603,
0.0879442394,
0.0617311448,
0.0387443192,
0.0327924229,
0.0138180014,
0.0311764032,
0.0170633383,
0.0193588119,
0.0014330732,
0.0340531841,
-0.0672260299,
-0.0178447869,
-0.0556238033,
-0.0621514805,
0.0284656379,
-0.0349360071,
0.0056654243,
-0.0422924533,
0.0296284501,
0.0250098314,
0.02197068,
-0.0284681134,
0.0205965471,
-0.0271888375,
-0.0325837918,
-0.0009421491,
0.0176492855,
0.0066486862,
-0.0150768738,
0.0362381488,
-0.0046590441,
-0.0129920943,
0.0197492875,
-0.0372078158,
0.0046284418,
0.01855845,
0.0085347621,
-0.0625961646,
0.0457622446,
0.0588073246,
-0.0029139442,
-0.0453583784,
-0.0292183161,
-0.0559112243,
0.0050984081,
0.0119848885,
-0.0221940186,
-0.0280877501,
-0.0220841132,
-0.0328354426,
-0.0321175791,
0.0244133174,
-0.0152330752,
-0.0664997995,
0.0439478979,
-0.0222154707,
0.0648688897,
-0.0386075005,
0.0482131094,
0.0266490821,
0.0086884797,
-0.0197895113,
0.0403849557,
0.0132175293,
0.0349469744,
0.0416277722,
0.0904851928,
0.0071584247,
-0.0138352187,
0.0577962324,
0.0285539366,
-0.0267744102,
-0.0815696269,
0.0151593992,
0.0468918905,
0.0131103117,
-0.0085075656,
-0.0088193994,
-0.0267205276,
0.0198259801,
-0.0249625333,
0.0282322783,
0.0090206712,
-0.0246655419,
-0.0134082288,
-0.0203725044,
0.0226509683,
-0.0597448014,
0.035953816,
-0.0963508189,
0.0244369414,
0.0341799445,
0.0071051749,
-0.0350852981,
-0.0263567474,
0.0515374541,
-0.0100616012,
0.0140269753,
-0.0067700152,
-0.0380026661,
-0.0128653487,
-0.0206587482,
-0.0084084682,
-0.0450744964,
-0.0413298905,
0.035466522,
0.0261067916,
-0.0158555917,
0.0039313408,
-0.0180933457,
0.0263200141,
-0.0140633928,
-0.0090473527,
-0.0091440752,
-5.448427704e-33,
-0.0210413989,
-0.0773475096,
0.0411842689,
0.0526626818,
-0.0169161651,
0.0177526474,
-0.0164542645,
0.0773845986,
-0.0005225872,
0.0042566219,
-0.04879421,
0.006132016,
0.0056986446,
0.0179110486,
0.0236266218,
-0.0050656055,
0.0419992134,
0.0304677803,
-0.0190117378,
0.0137697905,
0.0168215744,
0.0069171912,
0.0498458631,
-0.0188970342,
0.0878888518,
-0.0505643971,
-0.0235487726,
-0.0403453782,
-0.0090181381,
-0.0037570584,
0.0075604217,
0.0402629115,
0.0247895811,
-0.0102087632,
-0.0291495174,
0.1106817871,
0.0075687608,
-0.0647612065,
-0.0112991873,
0.0402324982,
-0.01928748,
-0.0631015375,
-0.0042750784,
-0.0495412908,
-0.0290351082,
0.0163924079,
0.0424218625,
0.0466451906,
0.0178478248,
0.0454537086,
-0.0662861019,
-0.0047518671,
-0.0522909462,
-0.0749533623,
-0.0368063785,
0.0693086758,
0.0068034003,
-0.0920833647,
-0.0486839414,
0.0574990809,
-0.0009340945,
0.0060399934,
0.0437163487,
-0.0207154751,
-0.0353969224,
0.0384518169,
0.001849979,
0.0456533507,
-0.026464384,
-0.0063062077,
0.0168911144,
-0.025855422,
0.0215321891,
0.0229578074,
-0.0178795662,
-0.0106799658,
-0.0038954874,
0.0421118587,
0.0715778172,
-0.0122562032,
-0.0185356084,
-0.0338612907,
-0.0302510541,
-0.0549846031,
-0.0197674856,
0.0528472289,
0.0140604777,
-0.0688016042,
0.026692111,
-0.0543072335,
0.0014637554,
-0.0998834446,
-0.0282696225,
0.0062977271,
-0.0188125614,
-0.0563429482,
-0.0309267864,
0.0425500609,
-0.0071457047,
0.0445393696,
-0.0143806338,
-0.0036252986,
0.001423512,
0.0134254992,
0.0132232262,
0.0620715097,
-0.0247926265,
0.0375048779,
-0.0428652056,
-0.0044802409,
-0.0127554731,
0.0352425613,
0.0194091816,
-0.0419228114,
0.0312375519,
0.0017240796,
-0.0246763974,
0.016304424,
0.0273912922,
-0.0057004704,
-0.0465919375,
-0.0031201548,
-0.0294012651,
-0.0413503647,
-0.0138226217,
-0.0150453774,
-0.0551255383,
0.0644805729,
0.0125400033,
-0.0250173118,
0.0080786832,
-0.0408814065,
2.662e-7,
0.020268945,
0.004256112,
0.0239095502,
0.0253411513,
-0.0047797905,
0.005317702,
0.0050797118,
0.0073392154,
0.0246273447,
0.0334736817,
0.0037739761,
0.0036624051,
0.0038141962,
0.0146638751,
-0.0631912574,
-0.0287110303,
-0.0401027054,
0.0316346176,
-0.0511317253,
0.0741161183,
0.108038865,
-0.0366018489,
-0.0051079257,
-0.0280650463,
-0.0286720172,
-0.007889417,
-0.0022614421,
-0.0158934537,
0.027815856,
0.0046069515,
-0.0189941991,
-0.017884044,
0.031749405,
0.0604367107,
0.0177913997,
-0.0787288398,
0.0224971399,
0.0381560363,
0.018074438,
0.0276926663,
0.0569860488,
0.041784171,
-0.0149851236,
-0.07011877,
0.0487588383,
-0.0071619907,
0.0026453456,
0.0121734003,
0.0006879059,
-0.0542422533,
0.0340572558,
-0.0139204077,
0.0073029129,
0.0144856796,
-0.0177043378,
-0.0132905301,
0.0124931335,
0.0181783475,
0.0008638243,
0.0078707878,
-0.0104597947,
-0.0495617837,
-0.051183328,
-0.0210214593,
-0.0105200894,
-0.0463657491,
-0.0044148867,
2.020966826e-34,
-0.0438423939,
-0.0210547727,
0.0572670065,
0.0406951942,
0.0037614277,
0.0424427874,
0.1098695546,
0.0447151698,
0.0472749062,
0.014450212,
-0.0446080603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10658v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10658v1 | Distributed Marker Representation for Ambiguous Discourse Markers and Entangled Relations | 2023-06-19T00:49:51 | 2023-06-19T00:49:51 | Dongyu Ru, Lin Qiu, Xipeng Qiu, Yue Zhang, Zheng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Discourse analysis is an important task because it models intrinsic semantic
structures between sentences in a document. Discourse markers are natural
representations of discourse in our daily language. One challenge is that the
markers as well as pre-defined and human-labeled discourse relations can be
ambiguous when describing the semantics between sentences. We believe that a
better approach is to use a contextual-dependent distribution over the markers
to express discourse information. In this work, we propose to learn a
Distributed Marker Representation (DMR) by utilizing the (potentially)
unlimited discourse marker data with a latent discourse sense, thereby bridging
markers with sentence pairs. Such representations can be learned automatically
from data without supervision, and in turn provide insights into the data
itself. Experiments show the SOTA performance of our DMR on the implicit
discourse relation recognition task and strong interpretability. Our method
also offers a valuable tool to understand complex ambiguity and entanglement
among discourse markers and manually defined discourse relations. | [
0.0238101482,
0.0571132042,
-0.0022786136,
0.0590524971,
-0.0203280952,
0.0190121662,
-0.0022237175,
0.0038770135,
0.0424859002,
-0.0703793019,
-0.007369963,
0.0252096523,
-0.0112661924,
0.0014843175,
-0.0382973813,
-0.0448232926,
0.0284025483,
-0.0240666475,
0.0108995717,
-0.0146416808,
-0.0043560495,
0.0053032609,
-0.0339614414,
0.0162194967,
-0.0557317883,
-0.064676486,
0.0024304911,
-0.003648784,
0.0457089022,
-0.055866275,
0.004910666,
0.0399294607,
0.0508470796,
0.0151770087,
0.000001693,
-0.0197257008,
-0.0111440457,
-0.0208884832,
-0.0204033945,
0.0563216917,
-0.0470691696,
-0.0209370889,
0.0194896013,
-0.0075179324,
-0.0317151621,
-0.0180285592,
-0.0284483917,
0.0715044513,
0.0496717356,
0.0103818085,
-0.0297889765,
-0.0090331277,
-0.0186397377,
0.0014863287,
-0.0439099558,
-0.0299602915,
0.0214406606,
0.0501651652,
-0.0214578994,
0.0637519956,
-0.0247740913,
0.0369458199,
0.0013810745,
-0.0272861216,
0.0091840187,
0.0366776995,
0.0011076125,
0.0205146261,
-0.0143416589,
0.0820038617,
0.0579769537,
0.0098178945,
0.0201987121,
-0.0187535994,
-0.0143871158,
0.0323720984,
-0.001762721,
-0.0190042127,
-0.0341880992,
0.0533058532,
0.0142211923,
0.0107650161,
0.0185226053,
-0.0020331927,
0.0147919366,
0.0477004088,
-0.0250477288,
0.0173875093,
-0.0332113728,
0.010799814,
-0.0665631071,
-0.0082812607,
0.0474723987,
0.0225998349,
-0.0061842217,
0.0103969993,
-0.0117634786,
-0.0510459766,
0.0229285639,
-0.0656008348,
0.0727066845,
0.0053011221,
-0.0333743431,
0.0789252594,
-0.0481601693,
0.0434956253,
-0.0344328433,
-0.0476324521,
0.0033107987,
-0.0238086414,
-0.0427127071,
-0.0132082822,
-0.0254898891,
0.0690884218,
-0.0973328501,
-0.0374125093,
-0.005604587,
0.0200681128,
-0.0060214172,
-0.0086753229,
0.0132491412,
0.0212658513,
-0.0187301487,
0.0334350765,
-0.0172240809,
-0.0048560095,
-0.0760690719,
0.0246809926,
-0.0557195842,
-0.001197911,
-0.006192741,
0.0302068461,
0.0346805714,
0.0019481505,
-0.0274096914,
0.0824006423,
-0.0141058471,
-0.0159644,
0.0031896627,
-0.0064618131,
-0.0032273782,
-0.0191626959,
-0.0016508764,
-0.0272897091,
0.0139780128,
0.0117398137,
-0.0071460316,
-0.0155069213,
0.0312487353,
-0.0157408658,
-0.0180981178,
0.0551823676,
0.0031652101,
-0.0167048741,
0.0428864844,
0.0267980564,
-0.0110212527,
0.0598114878,
0.0537474789,
0.0133741936,
0.0314689726,
0.0251848437,
-0.0317459702,
-0.033914078,
0.0255937707,
0.0125850402,
0.0269214716,
0.0308420248,
-0.0075764055,
0.0102478303,
-0.0140698636,
0.0755020157,
-0.0486982614,
-0.0723004565,
0.0282594133,
0.0450985171,
-0.0394473821,
-0.0108717773,
0.0490747578,
0.0159153026,
0.0091112945,
0.0274224281,
0.0197125543,
-0.0042035077,
0.0240587369,
-0.0534974858,
0.0066944119,
0.0026211725,
-0.0217628498,
-0.0518647544,
0.0053691249,
-0.0051240325,
0.0248356145,
-0.0317334309,
0.0308650471,
-0.0045744088,
-0.0546878427,
0.0406410396,
0.055330094,
0.013112667,
-0.0142486338,
-0.0044217599,
0.0323836096,
0.0114364214,
0.0150893033,
-0.0359648801,
-0.0066427523,
-0.0419763885,
0.0590194948,
0.062962234,
-0.0219886024,
-0.0203883443,
0.0357142985,
-0.0127528692,
-0.0234146137,
-0.0134364171,
0.0291017927,
0.0522144325,
0.0213601477,
-0.0126996608,
0.0086644227,
-0.0011795474,
0.0266070403,
0.0033964231,
-0.0033549413,
-0.0137231573,
0.0422254093,
-0.0144135803,
0.0388105363,
0.0400358811,
0.0065366253,
-0.0174501315,
0.0743656158,
-0.0652111769,
-0.028127471,
0.0112205502,
-0.0744069964,
-0.0379930511,
0.0142415063,
-0.0570259839,
-0.0443064384,
-0.0165580586,
-0.0270554479,
-0.054450728,
0.0298343878,
-0.0404450186,
0.0257832725,
-0.0141980415,
-0.0643373281,
0.0246701036,
0.0273850448,
-0.0156060448,
0.0779240206,
-0.0178103577,
0.0120250154,
0.0294888876,
-0.041693598,
0.056067735,
0.0246632919,
0.0279950202,
-0.0193285588,
0.0268517397,
-0.0008006258,
0.0266702808,
-0.0026529997,
-0.0249296874,
-0.0346271545,
-0.1117047817,
-0.0001731931,
-0.0008776954,
0.032304734,
0.0539504848,
-0.0174501874,
0.0199948289,
-0.0335339904,
-0.0046164156,
-0.0235764366,
-0.027948631,
-0.0054031373,
0.0870713145,
0.015096562,
-0.0015040839,
-0.020504415,
0.0120712249,
-0.0283912607,
0.049690485,
0.0223269183,
-0.0560884885,
-0.0711188242,
-0.0156690497,
-0.0173150469,
0.0079125809,
-0.0238167457,
-0.0197285153,
0.0477605537,
0.0141836228,
0.051679831,
0.0328879766,
-0.00879444,
0.1229684576,
0.0212531704,
-0.032534603,
-0.0452018678,
0.0252661351,
-0.0261271968,
0.0931354314,
-0.0501303636,
0.0436651967,
-0.050904654,
0.0747148469,
0.0190109257,
0.0213825516,
-0.0299616046,
0.0130974045,
-0.0167454481,
-0.0117316311,
-0.03688078,
-0.0064050662,
0.0117509561,
0.0199683998,
-0.0141629977,
-0.0152941421,
0.0519620106,
-0.0178176947,
0.014736291,
-0.0274007507,
-0.0499636605,
-0.0352388509,
0.0699903741,
-0.028254671,
-0.0046172561,
-0.0334011018,
-0.0694945678,
-0.0299467016,
-0.0195205621,
0.0399450697,
0.0083722025,
0.0197549444,
-0.040418338,
0.0257490892,
0.0090251733,
-0.0451790169,
-0.0282588154,
-0.0802417696,
0.001519275,
0.0291558392,
-0.0450723879,
-0.0208553337,
-0.0093390169,
-0.0173042398,
-0.0023586599,
0.0145441517,
-0.0067387591,
-0.0023462505,
-0.0626008138,
0.0740778819,
0.0351633132,
0.0040148343,
-0.0078886375,
-0.0056941365,
0.0039373524,
0.0492409393,
-0.0652042925,
0.0016855786,
-0.0278194677,
0.0109425355,
-0.0386158526,
-0.006128076,
-0.0211525019,
-0.0344837196,
0.0619715899,
-0.0227798875,
-0.0025173516,
0.0733771697,
0.0144940224,
-0.0239777211,
0.0017198068,
-0.0117422221,
0.033452604,
0.0052609001,
-0.000722007,
-0.0847061053,
-0.0027230373,
-0.0178791583,
-0.0203746986,
-0.0127143729,
-0.0581814423,
0.0393058881,
-0.0356097147,
-0.0192416981,
-0.0262392815,
-0.0017182557,
0.0084694931,
-0.0804828182,
0.0359481089,
0.0199469533,
0.0223823693,
-0.0394058079,
0.0161463488,
-0.0083889142,
0.0009289788,
0.0344859697,
-0.0312947035,
0.0290245228,
0.0069776447,
0.0301093515,
-0.0153858038,
0.0636892915,
0.031638287,
0.0151424967,
0.0190588888,
-0.0516396649,
-0.024900401,
-0.0368620306,
0.0303357653,
-0.0043624709,
-0.0281474758,
-0.0455687903,
0.0260033533,
-0.0797308311,
-0.0255316142,
-0.0027971733,
0.0855294243,
-0.0236400031,
0.0019829317,
-0.018497983,
-0.0098700505,
0.0324558243,
0.0613704957,
0.0284115933,
0.0001274643,
-0.0317197703,
-0.0067959311,
0.0451020338,
0.0149842678,
0.0327815488,
-0.0128308805,
0.0227259025,
0.0337040201,
-0.0804606453,
-0.064788036,
0.0043115551,
0.0102627203,
-0.0094991857,
0.0316903405,
0.0195243042,
-0.0108969864,
-0.0488827452,
0.0088034542,
-0.0221554507,
-0.0194934681,
-0.0036673893,
-0.0391249694,
0.0558214597,
0.0120345196,
-0.0541686006,
-0.0101176258,
-0.0700430423,
-0.0527874529,
-0.0144398604,
0.0196439717,
0.0138442889,
0.0482571162,
-0.0353705995,
0.0274175853,
0.0387205631,
0.0642929226,
-0.0465168282,
0.0331879146,
0.0431812704,
0.0484019667,
-0.010189563,
0.0393481776,
-0.011847442,
0.0397162959,
-0.0121417418,
0.0445220061,
-0.0922266766,
-0.0293555632,
-0.0070401435,
-0.0198579989,
0.045367226,
0.026992498,
-0.0064693131,
-0.032435596,
0.0214525647,
-0.0608049035,
-0.0291152745,
-0.048027683,
0.0235289279,
-0.0097147645,
-0.0362917744,
-0.0475679748,
0.0082148453,
-0.0011490918,
0.0810465664,
-0.0008439427,
0.014776987,
0.0305022933,
0.0125166103,
-0.0174777899,
-0.0024564245,
-0.0039622183,
0.0415275395,
-0.0200493596,
0.0132381208,
-0.0009970724,
0.0288409349,
0.0248626601,
-0.0131757613,
-0.0005019599,
-0.0120122451,
-0.0985865369,
0.0213941354,
-0.0018260202,
0.0362670496,
0.0458366051,
0.0026956561,
0.0741234496,
-0.0154299848,
0.0043426733,
0.0020353294,
0.0878265798,
-0.0041165347,
-0.0103776213,
0.0365220122,
0.0380279496,
-0.0046736719,
0.0426253751,
0.0776298046,
-0.0347792208,
0.0595971271,
0.0445478819,
0.001015159,
-0.0731523111,
-0.038055636,
0.0013293332,
0.0094321342,
0.0193234887,
0.0586066358,
0.0120336479,
-0.018814357,
0.0704180449,
-0.0219229739,
-0.0270602852,
-0.0053287456,
-0.0060702474,
0.0018900509,
0.0380144194,
-0.0249658301,
-0.0772090331,
0.0073612495,
0.0023820137,
-0.0337227918,
-0.0611910038,
-6.319791177e-33,
-0.071929127,
-0.0575219058,
-0.0321656764,
0.0289502367,
0.0012349604,
0.0563978255,
-0.0686804131,
-0.0139902774,
0.0205543693,
0.0514271855,
0.0195927694,
0.0437647514,
0.0157278404,
0.0356267244,
-0.0160999969,
-0.0601784773,
0.0409240313,
0.0080735581,
0.0342996754,
0.0238964185,
0.1022196785,
0.0178046264,
0.0378701575,
-0.1085414886,
0.0096203312,
-0.0339242779,
0.0007980569,
0.0362737589,
0.0113688614,
0.0591215566,
-0.0385666713,
0.0156378075,
0.0070557892,
0.0613858439,
-0.0032852928,
-0.0144840749,
-0.1359498948,
-0.0507701226,
-0.0010931629,
-0.0007283207,
-0.0540184714,
-0.023177851,
-0.0002479017,
0.0036324998,
0.0434393249,
-0.018496789,
0.0519071408,
-0.0016771198,
-0.0221277252,
-0.0359929316,
-0.0286842398,
0.0225032531,
-0.041805122,
0.0220113955,
0.0090505797,
0.0273895599,
0.0489669628,
-0.0278299451,
-0.0536476076,
-0.0406183414,
-0.0565346181,
-0.002078708,
-0.0261892732,
-0.0119709447,
0.0334635898,
0.0811515823,
-0.0275212284,
-0.0214778911,
-0.0520959683,
0.0043832967,
-0.0004523446,
-0.0080010099,
-0.0107118385,
0.0107528744,
-0.0069969785,
0.0436101258,
-0.0924455449,
-0.0258493386,
0.024602171,
0.0208004043,
0.0063218051,
0.028678108,
-0.0090494454,
-0.009719328,
-0.0252913404,
-0.0565184988,
-0.002022004,
-0.0363458879,
0.0177976396,
-0.0135758277,
-0.0405572467,
0.024223404,
0.0227174498,
-0.0214925986,
-0.0626994073,
0.0201988239,
0.0145100197,
-0.0017512292,
0.0384277999,
0.0066580758,
-0.0235854946,
-0.0401479006,
0.0101448027,
-0.016135186,
0.048588261,
0.0177422315,
0.0245455801,
-0.039951209,
-0.0376480892,
-0.0238502659,
-0.0150279161,
-0.0082477462,
-0.0501063727,
0.016971007,
0.0232063346,
0.0188022815,
-0.0174322743,
0.0767983869,
-0.0003808225,
0.0461352579,
0.0123830177,
0.0173191447,
-0.037011113,
0.047044415,
-0.0249837153,
-0.0323235244,
-0.0154877594,
0.0390885919,
0.0238460805,
-0.0456348583,
0.020155495,
0.0153299188,
2.32e-7,
0.018287817,
0.0394022055,
0.0522114597,
-0.0056407847,
0.0262777414,
-0.0072272816,
-0.0001695603,
0.0338468924,
-0.0183185115,
-0.0831398517,
-0.015056123,
0.0360698737,
0.024338346,
0.0431461483,
-0.0616315976,
-0.0138717256,
-0.0438094549,
-0.05208252,
-0.0228099395,
0.0259300247,
0.0775785893,
0.0393675342,
0.0282375198,
0.0199124031,
-0.012108814,
0.0106896767,
0.0812220126,
-0.0252787229,
0.0122094387,
-0.0250437558,
-0.0249745995,
-0.0203114022,
0.0157908499,
0.0203163885,
0.0123472828,
0.0153137501,
0.0129472027,
0.074690178,
0.0220839921,
0.0004851986,
-0.0248670168,
0.0040958049,
0.023884628,
0.0359685533,
0.0368348435,
-0.0360231437,
-0.0645840988,
0.0054914248,
-0.0315167233,
-0.0222455077,
0.0364827514,
0.0204832852,
-0.0080577862,
0.0311346967,
-0.00740036,
-0.0358050801,
0.0308927335,
-0.0648552924,
0.0256437212,
-0.0332754515,
-0.046545241,
0.0272385627,
-0.0030133908,
-0.0092443042,
0.0121963099,
-0.0359278843,
0.0141165387,
1.953785487e-34,
0.0342939496,
-0.0316875875,
-0.0292572845,
0.025190752,
0.041257754,
-0.0352444537,
-0.0100764958,
0.0123688066,
0.0337902717,
-0.0711769909,
0.0296995044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.00009v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.00009v2 | Comparison of Machine Learning Methods for Assigning Software Issues to Team Members | 2023-06-18T20:06:58 | 2023-08-23T12:24:02 | Büşra Tabak, Fatma Başak Aydemir | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SE | Software issues contain units of work to fix, improve, or create new threads
during the development and facilitate communication among the team members.
Assigning an issue to the most relevant team member and determining a category
of an issue is a tedious and challenging task. Wrong classifications cause
delays and rework in the project and trouble among the team members. This paper
proposes a set of carefully curated linguistic features for shallow machine
learning methods and compares the performance of shallow and ensemble methods
with deep language models. Unlike the state-of-the-art, we assign issues to
four roles (designer, developer, tester, and leader) rather than to specific
individuals or teams to contribute to the generality of our solution. We also
consider the level of experience of the developers to reflect the industrial
practices in our solution formulation. We collect and annotate five industrial
data sets from one of the top three global television producers to evaluate our
proposal and compare it with deep language models. Our data sets contain 5324
issues in total. We show that an ensemble classifier of shallow techniques
achieves 0.92 for issue assignment in accuracy which is statistically
comparable to the state-of-the-art deep language models. The contributions
include the public sharing of five annotated industrial issue data sets, the
development of a clear and comprehensive feature set, the introduction of a
novel label set, and the validation of the efficacy of an ensemble classifier
of shallow machine learning techniques. | [
0.0813511461,
0.0621660575,
-0.0320501551,
0.0061836969,
-0.0248636995,
-0.011377885,
0.0433762185,
0.0084238956,
-0.0216666963,
-0.0782928169,
0.0628386363,
-0.0201122928,
-0.0238018967,
0.0561692603,
-0.0084279804,
-0.0648433119,
0.0152037973,
0.0038143909,
0.0554644428,
0.014001172,
0.0131980553,
0.0289858896,
-0.0108770644,
0.0813412443,
-0.046220649,
-0.0246707425,
0.013217737,
-0.0265341438,
0.005411495,
-0.0008053571,
0.0184142832,
0.074107036,
0.0064962069,
0.0223541986,
0.0000019717,
-0.0546859726,
-0.0291231349,
-0.021763375,
0.0258973073,
0.0089632906,
-0.0016458855,
-0.0271525253,
-0.0064626108,
0.0241667759,
-0.0180766042,
0.0125774629,
0.0747982115,
0.0721095949,
0.0568280853,
0.0327951275,
-0.0199701935,
0.0072722263,
-0.0324731879,
-0.0087497467,
-0.0016946597,
-0.1139400229,
-0.0036230588,
-0.0264205858,
0.0118824402,
0.01812586,
0.0298560262,
0.01331368,
0.001702726,
-0.0095585501,
0.0469605103,
0.0298998877,
-0.0531628355,
-0.0160198901,
0.0090359719,
0.0680664107,
-0.0191060416,
0.003419064,
-0.0210123733,
-0.0537558906,
-0.0033102995,
0.0116062043,
0.0347753987,
-0.012959036,
-0.0141196921,
-0.0230205208,
-0.0055182972,
0.0022112837,
-0.0211201292,
-0.0090709887,
-0.0002571553,
0.0513348207,
-0.0184108764,
-0.0072276504,
-0.0054649701,
0.0109494263,
0.0061013964,
-0.0576206855,
0.0151147656,
0.0199322738,
-0.036973644,
0.0358243436,
-0.0065669175,
-0.0332607143,
0.0045531983,
-0.0547800176,
-0.0263948943,
-0.0028050477,
-0.0125548048,
0.0424167477,
-0.005828165,
0.0123232286,
0.0091178846,
0.0189712327,
0.0165979434,
-0.0064077559,
-0.0842301548,
-0.0087781046,
-0.0577909052,
0.0485855602,
-0.0130736176,
-0.0042294776,
-0.0107695889,
0.0240841173,
-0.0215109009,
0.0106735909,
0.0053545707,
0.0359944552,
-0.0419094786,
0.0112680085,
-0.0370714813,
0.0260664374,
-0.0384426862,
0.0293120686,
-0.0158963669,
0.0099219736,
0.0469355248,
-0.0205480438,
-0.0087018553,
0.0090086786,
0.0190980472,
0.0291384421,
0.0083693834,
0.0131636821,
0.0026693037,
-0.0377553217,
-0.033594586,
0.0028227535,
-0.0695633814,
-0.0783756077,
-0.0385521762,
0.0102054849,
-0.0112931794,
-0.0703055561,
0.0080808764,
0.0010000714,
-0.026367601,
0.0720588416,
-0.066020906,
0.02127924,
0.0597479418,
0.0489755608,
0.0240570568,
0.0320583247,
0.0339799561,
0.0640667081,
0.0419040024,
-0.0115815997,
0.0499009676,
-0.0066183377,
-0.0549251549,
-0.0019463676,
0.0231228918,
-0.022002751,
-0.048531279,
-0.0048622387,
-0.0606810376,
0.0445227884,
0.0322326422,
0.0207625479,
0.0183775593,
0.0123811839,
0.0447871909,
0.05161421,
0.0074504819,
0.0297143422,
-0.0334228724,
-0.0573402792,
0.0292495955,
0.073916994,
0.0174387284,
-0.0464209057,
0.014474378,
-0.0196866598,
-0.0360970125,
-0.0622962154,
-0.0102852294,
0.0149241975,
-0.0307852011,
0.0332349092,
0.0459821075,
0.0005786905,
-0.04389764,
0.0420657545,
0.0058545074,
-0.0320281424,
-0.0167421475,
0.0258559342,
0.046592392,
0.0692298412,
0.0043568597,
-0.0919394866,
-0.0809042305,
-0.013837521,
0.0043362011,
-0.011466044,
0.0726867914,
-0.0132158101,
-0.0262456704,
-0.0113345506,
-0.0391104482,
0.0052040564,
-0.0182651281,
0.0500778183,
-0.0302305259,
0.0031137478,
-0.0203397255,
-0.0036394945,
-0.0532607809,
0.0316707343,
0.0189387798,
0.0030004492,
0.0453136936,
0.0058485577,
0.011233204,
0.0338630229,
-0.0151452217,
-0.0193642434,
0.0355806984,
-0.0456231982,
-0.0554767884,
-0.0234275255,
-0.0114228902,
0.0265134871,
-0.006772805,
-0.0469855517,
-0.0209296383,
0.0172876772,
-0.0578162,
0.0055215331,
0.0421124212,
-0.0148972906,
-0.0636973158,
-0.0067736828,
-0.0083641773,
-0.0306205805,
-0.0000966735,
-0.0639705434,
0.0496342219,
0.0340585895,
0.0069479593,
-0.032121554,
0.0185619239,
0.0208929237,
-0.0290420726,
-0.0319058225,
0.0622430332,
-0.0158739034,
0.0343546942,
0.0404738262,
0.0135168787,
-0.0071156053,
-0.0287284795,
-0.0779771581,
-0.0328814313,
-0.0141207399,
-0.0116834585,
-0.0251663662,
0.0144093474,
0.0180887338,
-0.0178027302,
-0.0491291024,
-0.0237763971,
0.0023952301,
-0.0026426683,
0.0397132114,
0.032427717,
0.002591823,
-0.0197240282,
-0.0178250838,
-0.0521737859,
0.0191878453,
0.0425198562,
-0.0649278611,
-0.0876621604,
0.0474483073,
-0.0534252785,
-0.0003104082,
0.01237546,
-0.0093019214,
0.0008946693,
0.0186500754,
-0.0045068352,
-0.0190968923,
0.0324695259,
0.0781453326,
0.0027520584,
0.0253418796,
-0.0169252753,
0.0150595438,
0.0038282271,
-0.0281641204,
-0.0049257809,
-0.0275733173,
0.0399255641,
0.0445468687,
-0.004751741,
-0.0195741206,
-0.057447046,
0.073512055,
-0.0136611825,
0.0121249445,
-0.0030466705,
-0.0357797742,
0.0270265378,
0.0419179276,
-0.0226255972,
-0.0322939381,
0.0812435523,
-0.0036507861,
0.0122660035,
-0.0902109072,
-0.05771235,
-0.0501245968,
0.0794215724,
-0.0661230758,
0.0273745675,
0.0079849865,
-0.0501894876,
-0.040756464,
0.0111757852,
0.027791867,
-0.0088438522,
0.0362256132,
-0.0521655902,
0.0342703462,
-0.0224580858,
0.0013574599,
-0.0240822639,
-0.0467857234,
-0.0306882653,
0.0435017832,
0.0622683614,
0.017749805,
-0.0223129243,
0.0605666786,
0.0007446552,
0.0133831035,
0.0782666206,
-0.0365322866,
-0.0005106094,
-0.060038358,
0.0015006934,
0.030972084,
-0.0136126671,
0.0013167112,
0.0226012524,
0.0004587877,
0.0394872129,
0.0114286058,
-0.0565626398,
0.0015398591,
-0.0083817067,
-0.0461995937,
-0.0059401719,
0.0101619288,
0.0420835651,
-0.0462767109,
0.0128595652,
0.074018158,
0.0384679772,
-0.0470700301,
0.0076446575,
0.0408607163,
-0.0116382958,
0.0692939013,
0.0269681718,
-0.0758619085,
-0.0056563267,
-0.0106164692,
0.0028119297,
-0.0034356189,
-0.0367082544,
0.0025972072,
-0.0684243292,
0.0092222458,
-0.0336302705,
-0.0432280749,
0.0038157348,
-0.0233937874,
0.0111211771,
-0.023668278,
-0.0084800133,
-0.0290406179,
0.0327138975,
-0.0205513164,
0.0394150317,
-0.0857902914,
-0.0437593274,
0.0788570493,
-0.0586556382,
0.0178938266,
0.0791748986,
0.0291375816,
0.0103366207,
0.0249079634,
0.0045193443,
-0.0043165688,
0.0198962744,
-0.0010236161,
0.0686092228,
-0.0144633511,
-0.0169628114,
0.0774112791,
-0.0174358003,
-0.0529823862,
0.0209226236,
0.0384043492,
0.0484769642,
-0.0251043048,
0.0117436191,
0.0022024894,
0.0177977867,
0.0482847542,
0.0296224393,
0.0123357894,
-0.0454660356,
-0.0449116938,
-0.0389348865,
0.009057642,
-0.0381495468,
-0.0230037421,
-0.0043799505,
-0.0375043713,
-0.0369534828,
-0.06364768,
-0.0510183014,
0.0582359806,
0.0406581908,
0.0186767802,
0.0234195367,
0.0097438432,
0.0434690751,
-0.0389174186,
0.0028470785,
0.0439081155,
0.0398566648,
-0.0250308495,
-0.0316177979,
-0.00999464,
0.0240960568,
-0.0226142239,
0.0253806002,
-0.0233688559,
-0.0358294994,
-0.0344635807,
0.0162534527,
0.0096839992,
-0.0306555871,
-0.0310820304,
-0.1188892797,
-0.0050735273,
0.0609230213,
-0.0139811542,
-0.0154029867,
-0.0028311762,
-0.0110860458,
-0.0414751321,
0.0139240148,
-0.0845585018,
0.0362884551,
0.0225894712,
0.0081050741,
-0.0475117825,
-0.0421317294,
0.0245055538,
-0.0230343286,
0.0146543076,
0.0175135415,
-0.0938537717,
-0.0393868126,
0.0085770804,
0.0108617451,
-0.0419828035,
-0.0428106301,
0.028464999,
-0.0163060836,
-0.0385335498,
0.0315232016,
0.0259714574,
-0.0203211047,
0.0505357347,
0.0069662426,
0.0784862787,
0.0472327694,
0.019915089,
-0.0035200794,
0.0300939009,
-0.0025442962,
-0.0218167305,
0.0136180436,
0.0321765579,
0.0079235742,
0.0009165979,
0.0123200836,
0.0534539782,
-0.0019802805,
0.0105405459,
-0.0140298558,
-0.0644495264,
-0.0002581807,
-0.0039709546,
0.0475691929,
0.0105143283,
-0.0240638498,
-0.0263099801,
0.0034057682,
-0.0254002437,
0.0456091389,
-0.0398600698,
-0.0110743269,
-0.0003942953,
0.0294908565,
-0.0154932225,
0.0179671254,
0.0561246462,
0.0073048989,
-0.0271044578,
-0.0180568546,
-0.037369322,
-0.04121878,
0.03649728,
0.0564329103,
0.0271998327,
-0.0204318594,
0.0064846175,
-0.0536159426,
-0.0120794764,
0.044353351,
-0.0650722533,
0.045068454,
0.0002039744,
0.0081382487,
0.1116264686,
0.0060806,
0.0155602219,
-0.0491605625,
-0.0573422052,
-0.0265154634,
-0.0198611356,
-0.0676937625,
-5.342693824e-33,
-0.0264628623,
-0.0524957776,
0.0061159716,
-0.0165510494,
0.0227811858,
0.0311268792,
-0.0035753446,
0.0209578443,
0.0162161104,
0.0133264232,
-0.0052283709,
0.0015035544,
-0.0000161245,
-0.0208916944,
0.0562151074,
-0.008530857,
0.0499887615,
0.0428668931,
-0.0092401514,
0.0764794052,
0.0381892212,
0.0257063955,
0.037994124,
-0.0814480186,
0.0173414014,
0.0385515988,
0.0219382439,
0.0124993371,
0.0467591099,
0.0506684445,
0.0174844526,
0.0220044088,
0.0455416553,
-0.0614195168,
-0.0034198591,
0.0047267019,
-0.0201444495,
0.0008919081,
-0.0247891825,
-0.0225467198,
0.0358884707,
-0.0141050201,
0.0387802683,
0.0093069552,
0.0160221532,
-0.0310109314,
0.098965928,
-0.0050054258,
0.0142812422,
-0.0523479767,
-0.0731777325,
0.0331762806,
-0.0399882868,
-0.0086334655,
0.0037827024,
-0.0002799515,
-0.0201763641,
0.0241365414,
-0.0386217274,
-0.0177681055,
-0.0136811435,
0.0381143279,
0.0459010266,
0.0123844845,
-0.0594091266,
0.0063269138,
0.0132984724,
0.076730825,
-0.0296306089,
-0.0247273259,
0.008219149,
0.0860399753,
0.0678599402,
0.0274755787,
0.0351455547,
-0.0050824936,
-0.0427565575,
0.0271662809,
-0.01810381,
0.012373725,
0.0228089057,
0.0537580885,
-0.0613735057,
-0.0252008662,
-0.0017450951,
0.0000943101,
-0.0414467156,
-0.0297932662,
0.0261943899,
-0.0132782925,
-0.0307495315,
0.0642234161,
0.0633327141,
-0.0466007441,
0.0031439799,
-0.0215716176,
-0.0091506094,
0.0212178752,
-0.0138542661,
-0.0143625531,
-0.0664155409,
-0.0069737271,
0.0206613299,
0.0598553978,
0.0477041192,
-0.0195253082,
0.030670438,
-0.0131470552,
-0.0364531018,
0.0129733672,
-0.0145987934,
0.0145346783,
-0.0245876797,
0.0645654276,
-0.0350034758,
-0.0023077258,
0.0144689446,
0.0058997702,
0.0021275855,
-0.0307523366,
-0.0361086428,
0.0172388963,
-0.0632712618,
-0.0171160772,
-0.011251213,
-0.0458041057,
-0.0156794507,
0.0157699008,
0.0609455481,
-0.0094228704,
-0.0500525236,
-0.0169891044,
2.619e-7,
0.011909904,
0.0353821814,
0.0311817601,
-0.0206670072,
0.0052283611,
0.0356397256,
0.0439095199,
0.0426381156,
0.0040459922,
0.0036277848,
0.0368740037,
0.0040198285,
0.0211321637,
0.0305273496,
-0.0449969843,
-0.0348593891,
-0.0344784819,
0.0150070554,
-0.0792362764,
0.0303672161,
0.0579388551,
0.0555680431,
0.049755469,
-0.0061358181,
-0.0012904927,
-0.0287173185,
-0.0173241384,
0.00840466,
0.0242816433,
0.0757934973,
0.0258631147,
0.0113505833,
-0.0428783707,
0.0554765463,
-0.0135214059,
-0.0495947339,
0.0335547738,
-0.0287584364,
-0.0511307679,
-0.0026973244,
-0.0385568067,
0.0179138612,
-0.0024783134,
-0.0094278641,
-0.0089474041,
-0.0715360194,
-0.0349562541,
0.0282423738,
0.021461647,
-0.0318875201,
-0.008055645,
0.0322811976,
0.0448229313,
0.0015617497,
0.0012959038,
-0.0426960029,
-0.0230944473,
-0.0915801153,
0.0199029297,
0.0553554334,
-0.0423498303,
-0.0129183708,
0.0197455678,
-0.0088157682,
0.034184739,
-0.0150941228,
0.0541611686,
2.283767185e-34,
-0.0080925701,
0.0231220182,
-0.0501177311,
0.0044111186,
0.0200772975,
0.0130862491,
-0.0184393395,
0.0032480964,
0.0120665664,
-0.0025958365,
0.0137533937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10555v1 | Summarization from Leaderboards to Practice: Choosing A Representation Backbone and Ensuring Robustness | 2023-06-18T13:35:41 | 2023-06-18T13:35:41 | David Demeter, Oshin Agarwal, Simon Ben Igeri, Marko Sterbentz, Neil Molino, John M. Conroy, Ani Nenkova | cs.CL | cs.CL | Academic literature does not give much guidance on how to build the best
possible customer-facing summarization system from existing research
components. Here we present analyses to inform the selection of a system
backbone from popular models; we find that in both automatic and human
evaluation, BART performs better than PEGASUS and T5. We also find that when
applied cross-domain, summarizers exhibit considerably worse performance. At
the same time, a system fine-tuned on heterogeneous domains performs well on
all domains and will be most suitable for a broad-domain summarizer. Our work
highlights the need for heterogeneous domain summarization benchmarks. We find
considerable variation in system output that can be captured only with human
evaluation and are thus unlikely to be reflected in standard leaderboards with
only automatic evaluation. | [
0.028887175,
-0.0314604901,
0.0176170338,
0.0186058357,
0.0030866661,
-0.0082805371,
-0.0134565681,
-0.0361038037,
-0.0033327332,
-0.0531692505,
-0.0304402504,
-0.0254371781,
0.0137398448,
0.0375896953,
0.0070049237,
-0.133020401,
0.0216592774,
-0.0102509474,
-0.0226140786,
0.0162955709,
0.0310563445,
-0.0119743282,
-0.0055844923,
0.0534991547,
0.007832271,
0.0073940023,
-0.0022298195,
-0.0157783851,
0.0487446785,
-0.0251931418,
-0.0097400462,
0.0004463613,
0.0103569897,
0.0169698875,
0.0000018104,
-0.0368693136,
-0.0268883519,
-0.0032880548,
-0.0002408963,
0.0409800857,
0.0280634407,
-0.0141176516,
0.0356714427,
-0.0075720488,
-0.0131813204,
0.0204178095,
-0.0086067086,
0.0231811255,
0.0975968912,
0.0166886412,
-0.0105105033,
-0.0405845121,
-0.0297562424,
-0.0129415793,
-0.0367607735,
-0.0680241808,
-0.0240799151,
0.048517596,
0.0240943749,
-0.0392145291,
-0.0068511772,
0.0333199725,
-0.022938462,
0.0148327025,
0.0102531128,
0.0220802557,
-0.03785263,
-0.0022250805,
0.0112405624,
0.0721844807,
0.0200487785,
0.0471402295,
0.0288021993,
0.0151617285,
0.0118122669,
-0.0178195611,
-0.0847282335,
0.0417219549,
-0.0091756321,
-0.0037177627,
-0.0385331437,
0.0893933326,
-0.0443493091,
-0.0002176368,
-0.0269520599,
0.0156317372,
-0.01486455,
0.0026821541,
-0.0186079219,
0.0407480113,
-0.0391777456,
-0.0793360174,
0.0289359372,
0.0163436569,
-0.0278375056,
-0.0177166443,
-0.0254779961,
-0.0491331741,
0.0283379722,
-0.0224186983,
0.0315944441,
-0.0129652256,
0.0436406843,
0.0385987908,
-0.008910262,
0.0384679884,
0.0390853882,
0.0022700294,
-0.04879741,
-0.0098149404,
-0.0463251509,
0.0019755193,
-0.008276457,
0.0811308995,
-0.0362518579,
-0.0191735364,
-0.0805944949,
0.0302110519,
0.003401021,
0.0186706036,
0.0373854414,
0.0139010614,
0.0014122719,
0.019249849,
-0.0147314928,
0.0251905955,
-0.0674047098,
-0.0582622215,
0.0303613916,
0.0079361992,
0.0068042497,
0.0109187774,
-0.0022913669,
0.0253211483,
-0.0167278629,
0.0703872368,
-0.0113346186,
-0.0284223873,
0.0210372601,
-0.0440979712,
-0.0326384008,
-0.0429894999,
-0.0068060495,
-0.0419725738,
-0.0057952907,
0.0441835448,
-0.0066621834,
0.0148572512,
0.0031956951,
0.0174267292,
-0.0300527122,
0.0104575129,
-0.0083812345,
-0.0251083151,
0.0409836099,
-0.0031832082,
-0.0370863825,
0.0579578243,
0.0247351117,
0.0643588454,
0.0434535667,
0.0440629125,
0.0027670281,
0.0141270738,
-0.0274068769,
-0.0137291728,
0.0092238812,
0.0106698852,
-0.056891229,
-0.0135450866,
0.0299958698,
0.0427991152,
-0.0403430089,
0.0070550772,
0.060151767,
0.067638807,
0.0222531296,
0.016394766,
0.0419124775,
0.0277837422,
0.0626324788,
0.0473827869,
0.0101014711,
0.0484827459,
0.0005390804,
0.0705306306,
0.0598642267,
0.0316209719,
-0.0072363783,
-0.0552401617,
0.0197125506,
0.0092866095,
-0.0301565062,
0.009978272,
0.0345585421,
-0.0124052931,
-0.039100334,
0.043130137,
-0.0327101313,
-0.0665366501,
0.0077231126,
-0.0282453708,
-0.0229294375,
0.0535677001,
0.0302289259,
-0.0523804426,
-0.0088101709,
-0.0227215849,
-0.0081113866,
0.0246374831,
0.0407246202,
-0.0195080582,
-0.0152784856,
-0.0436833575,
-0.0474946387,
0.0078492574,
0.0030004429,
0.0239964519,
-0.0349112004,
-0.0094345799,
0.0237454902,
-0.0270490423,
-0.040388599,
0.0107855173,
0.0384531096,
0.0184823554,
-0.0245155096,
-0.0310714822,
0.0169868693,
0.0530814715,
-0.0187465269,
0.0244387276,
0.0093713291,
-0.0213696957,
-0.0244558901,
-0.0015439221,
-0.0340208709,
-0.0256517753,
0.0374971181,
-0.0655416772,
0.0131845949,
0.0422414504,
-0.029277917,
-0.03972698,
-0.007555793,
-0.0484403633,
-0.0320822112,
-0.0004080092,
0.0262715463,
0.017557228,
-0.0221922062,
-0.0307992361,
0.0822157338,
0.0238153972,
-0.0253145453,
0.0509220585,
-0.0307477377,
-0.0075920383,
-0.0236933585,
-0.0083441902,
0.0203608125,
-0.0022835559,
0.0184745882,
0.0342506804,
-0.024247285,
-0.0370222516,
0.0134299351,
-0.1023698002,
0.0030545811,
-0.0036855426,
0.0163049027,
0.0237101614,
0.0188252423,
0.0037173561,
0.0055524465,
-0.0205965117,
-0.0414382815,
0.0169698205,
0.0214252323,
0.0163706727,
0.031223271,
0.0464919992,
-0.0681784749,
-0.0134556228,
0.0119272387,
0.0683806017,
0.0129480567,
-0.0701809376,
-0.0314872675,
0.0284827948,
-0.0525390878,
-0.0287754647,
0.0168913677,
0.0218584631,
-0.0168085732,
0.0090247309,
0.0438863412,
0.0343631469,
0.0485655107,
0.0166998003,
0.010458448,
-0.0198948085,
-0.0495287552,
-0.0066622114,
-0.0124911033,
0.0240552276,
0.0296691153,
-0.0101689054,
0.0553305112,
0.0583577491,
0.0273975804,
0.025371708,
-0.0310429875,
0.0184919424,
-0.0415485017,
0.0085837673,
-0.089629814,
-0.0211818386,
-0.0356267579,
0.0111138858,
0.004661127,
0.0261297841,
0.0443844497,
-0.0096235517,
0.0126921805,
-0.0394756868,
0.0251176395,
-0.048823528,
0.0126444586,
-0.0066295345,
0.0382183306,
-0.0047837971,
-0.0243247319,
-0.0340304263,
-0.0080956286,
0.0681711733,
-0.0539689586,
0.0883837789,
-0.0304303262,
0.0027280892,
-0.0540120713,
-0.0151957003,
-0.0196741167,
-0.0115764169,
-0.0472679175,
0.0336447656,
0.0581412427,
0.0190080963,
-0.0788225085,
0.0362016633,
0.0562090315,
0.0391613655,
-0.0239000395,
-0.0405497439,
0.0132668978,
0.0540835634,
0.0432768092,
-0.0058895824,
0.0521940216,
-0.0555807464,
0.0181028228,
0.0401391312,
0.0401184596,
-0.0502633937,
0.0310653374,
-0.0322597027,
-0.0109105846,
-0.0931774378,
-0.0103387078,
0.015063893,
0.063040778,
-0.0120124845,
0.0474630408,
0.1022870317,
0.0203086752,
-0.0144882733,
-0.0221181381,
0.0309203491,
0.0114068771,
0.0066961879,
0.0086355926,
-0.0509751178,
-0.0255059507,
0.0033615814,
0.0394482985,
0.031267982,
-0.0323887654,
-0.0079804379,
-0.0803434104,
0.0359833315,
0.0054025915,
-0.0442451127,
-0.0079098456,
-0.0133113107,
0.0009232764,
-0.0263152439,
-0.0082270345,
0.0092072468,
-0.0347795449,
0.0302116945,
0.0285716467,
-0.1023651585,
0.0132677257,
-0.0313463695,
-0.0241014734,
-0.0057762139,
0.0644156039,
0.0316164903,
0.0189929213,
0.028656112,
-0.0006347886,
-0.0281020999,
0.0222482346,
-0.0000720552,
0.0929603651,
-0.0139252599,
0.0032956696,
-0.0458815172,
-0.0136533808,
0.0197869334,
0.0322697684,
0.0234210975,
0.0145169934,
0.0415559299,
0.000565341,
-0.0472480953,
0.0536788516,
-0.0406976789,
0.05405147,
0.0364837013,
0.0022454646,
-0.0349948965,
-0.0440396108,
-0.0188209992,
-0.0799172819,
-0.0785420015,
-0.0119058043,
-0.0112762377,
-0.0215924811,
-0.0902076438,
-0.0630233139,
0.0223712903,
-0.0013834166,
-0.0241824444,
-0.0043477528,
-0.0453538559,
0.0375382788,
-0.0260981601,
-0.0263250247,
-0.0135414517,
0.0036760827,
-0.0409257449,
0.0073834588,
0.0780257434,
-0.0137286484,
-0.0351593643,
0.0391867124,
-0.0225028079,
-0.0304289442,
-0.0044566602,
0.0678199977,
0.0260434598,
0.0139536569,
0.0233063027,
0.0075540026,
0.0304336343,
0.0316023082,
0.0123075526,
0.0077639711,
-0.0096019069,
0.0382453389,
-0.033553645,
-0.0010019877,
-0.0699497163,
0.0505000688,
-0.0518396944,
0.0631201267,
0.002775532,
-0.0332137682,
-0.0092205787,
0.0267445147,
-0.0025321615,
-0.0246096309,
-0.0513938367,
0.0165964123,
-0.0325931981,
-0.0417341553,
-0.0215055496,
-0.026774073,
0.0383755863,
-0.0314276256,
-0.0000114192,
-0.0018337969,
0.0939893946,
0.0021160867,
0.0102114035,
-0.0720900595,
-0.005219657,
-0.0347959548,
-0.0206349734,
-0.0582783334,
-0.0037261287,
-0.0558941141,
-0.0547328927,
0.0150175961,
0.0147600556,
-0.0021257233,
0.0160087552,
-0.0029365206,
-0.0042061131,
-0.0127082272,
0.0717575103,
-0.0824999064,
0.0232216027,
-0.0573067106,
0.0180378295,
0.0736411586,
-0.0008384043,
0.0712464601,
0.0098815309,
-0.0010516011,
-0.0007829911,
0.0099384766,
0.0529987514,
0.0171995535,
-0.0786485001,
0.0265579373,
0.0194908474,
-0.034121491,
0.0852229446,
-0.0381056517,
-0.0289133731,
0.0016865963,
-0.0335622206,
-0.0558747537,
-0.0441327654,
-0.0329804048,
0.0272052009,
0.0073425374,
-0.0843040645,
-0.0970623642,
-0.0173177812,
0.0543146394,
0.0076289321,
0.0238892902,
-0.0219088327,
0.0496367738,
0.0097750779,
0.0352229401,
0.0024588688,
-0.0310668387,
-0.0112936208,
-0.0384488031,
0.0400045291,
-0.0311407689,
-5.407349319e-33,
-0.0571975112,
-0.004459586,
-0.0406906269,
0.0048774066,
-0.0310302097,
0.0058127684,
-0.01566061,
-0.0047443025,
0.044264771,
-0.0100719472,
-0.0156337805,
-0.0088637434,
0.0347276405,
-0.0137805305,
0.0029154439,
-0.0001509814,
0.0686829239,
-0.0212637205,
-0.0647751093,
0.0239686538,
0.0293925274,
0.0245941915,
0.0241546091,
-0.063040182,
0.0278274678,
-0.0015327227,
-0.0084574856,
-0.0509752668,
0.0738780349,
0.0235147364,
0.0114804301,
0.0371420756,
0.0200922377,
-0.0578665957,
-0.0584262311,
-0.0005073329,
-0.0602190644,
-0.0068174414,
0.0261723064,
-0.0146490736,
-0.0174064953,
-0.0081018396,
0.0184526164,
-0.0067151398,
-0.0051050596,
-0.0453522913,
0.0569760911,
-0.0376691334,
-0.014737864,
-0.1083439514,
-0.0120545421,
0.044660043,
-0.0379760377,
-0.0039980616,
0.0405215584,
0.0788794011,
0.023394037,
-0.0236284621,
-0.014475151,
0.0580659471,
0.0210947711,
0.0091806566,
0.078280054,
0.0404162183,
-0.0065378961,
0.0740150735,
0.0133145591,
0.0075849332,
0.0117560979,
-0.0194432866,
-0.0269771125,
0.0041052736,
0.0561131462,
0.0187164377,
0.0172227751,
0.0564092658,
-0.0244542155,
0.1109923497,
-0.0135279996,
-0.035719201,
0.0152169056,
0.0018373979,
-0.027511999,
0.0186003502,
0.0054228073,
0.0404348075,
-0.0135348402,
-0.0369159058,
0.0088365003,
-0.0050654463,
-0.0522509739,
0.0066299932,
0.0091557289,
-0.0023673598,
0.0103667807,
-0.0028460901,
0.0231009834,
0.0397259817,
0.0002317826,
-0.0612866692,
0.0081229359,
0.0265799463,
0.0048005302,
0.0459791571,
-0.0094451383,
-0.0210368056,
0.0132186254,
0.0128282597,
-0.0222295094,
0.0076636588,
0.020892866,
0.0148231946,
-0.0522779673,
0.040761061,
-0.007380499,
-0.0212071892,
-0.0203762092,
0.0490159057,
-0.0251660012,
-0.0265313685,
-0.0050757923,
0.0363978297,
0.0224997588,
0.0099486178,
-0.0056414385,
0.0119170258,
-0.0207407419,
0.0337353759,
0.0348177403,
-0.010091559,
-0.0277223382,
-0.0210726485,
2.38e-7,
0.0610267408,
0.0308081806,
0.0512590408,
-0.0117326919,
-0.020842094,
0.0268348437,
0.0347425789,
0.0106698219,
0.0472812206,
0.0199864525,
0.021462379,
0.0162536949,
0.0341371857,
0.0502310209,
-0.0953926146,
-0.0787856206,
-0.0386449993,
-0.0455864742,
-0.0217864309,
0.0061691692,
0.0777651072,
0.0228063222,
-0.0453786999,
0.0151194548,
-0.0078684324,
-0.0101242559,
0.0312037691,
-0.0147158736,
-0.0192097593,
0.0205013491,
-0.0047194143,
-0.0140863871,
-0.0385495722,
0.0077170692,
-0.0125821484,
-0.0127111897,
0.0922183096,
0.0380778201,
0.0166314486,
-0.0053839735,
-0.0031095524,
0.0000101817,
0.0480366088,
0.0252876785,
0.0210782718,
-0.0868228078,
-0.0004861879,
-0.0014442438,
-0.0509080626,
-0.0051588388,
-0.0363411568,
0.0081112217,
-0.0379449204,
0.0599100627,
-0.0363205224,
0.0108311195,
0.0019651905,
-0.0553632416,
-0.0511850528,
-0.0005284647,
0.0068432065,
-0.0387038663,
-0.044358179,
-0.0066404282,
-0.0180568695,
-0.0461365096,
-0.0298218224,
2.300924351e-34,
0.0612953901,
0.0072472347,
-0.0183984395,
-0.0350108854,
0.026544977,
-0.0180730727,
-0.0137743941,
-0.0101920068,
0.0208028816,
-0.0352818705,
-0.0149800377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14911v1 | "You might think about slightly revising the title": identifying hedges in peer-tutoring interactions | 2023-06-18T12:47:54 | 2023-06-18T12:47:54 | Yann Raphalen, Chloé Clavel, Justine Cassell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Hedges play an important role in the management of conversational
interaction. In peer tutoring, they are notably used by tutors in dyads (pairs
of interlocutors) experiencing low rapport to tone down the impact of
instructions and negative feedback. Pursuing the objective of building a
tutoring agent that manages rapport with students in order to improve learning,
we used a multimodal peer-tutoring dataset to construct a computational
framework for identifying hedges. We compared approaches relying on pre-trained
resources with others that integrate insights from the social science
literature. Our best performance involved a hybrid approach that outperforms
the existing baseline while being easier to interpret. We employ a model
explainability tool to explore the features that characterize hedges in
peer-tutoring conversations, and we identify some novel features, and the
benefits of such a hybrid model approach. | [
0.0405913927,
0.0240348093,
-0.0372785851,
0.0478385612,
-0.0031564846,
0.0031982081,
0.0664327145,
-0.0262405109,
-0.0377295949,
0.0016559268,
-0.0075293039,
0.0047802385,
-0.0013671278,
0.015655905,
0.0334487148,
-0.1052010655,
0.0031505313,
0.0189598147,
0.0372558981,
0.0148919448,
0.0622789823,
-0.0092197349,
-0.0313298553,
0.071037218,
-0.0102255782,
-0.0447650403,
-0.0585667118,
-0.005576699,
0.0118063623,
0.0046523311,
0.0434742309,
0.0405661352,
0.0009310382,
-0.0390276611,
0.0000022548,
-0.0192643814,
-0.0388343222,
-0.0401804373,
-0.0185033921,
-0.0046145646,
0.0144411279,
0.0148830125,
0.0420227647,
0.0007980617,
-0.0590313897,
0.0377569087,
0.0195998698,
0.0042509343,
0.0761946961,
0.0194422845,
0.0203453396,
-0.0057197451,
-0.0037754329,
0.0030458118,
0.0089106504,
-0.0666294992,
-0.0084998393,
0.0242186449,
-0.0433023944,
-0.0008383361,
-0.0556490347,
-0.0070154704,
0.0010523271,
-0.0618758909,
0.0507484041,
-0.0321829133,
0.0241012778,
-0.0284491219,
-0.0132463509,
0.0519077294,
0.0404893123,
0.0027020411,
0.0075868848,
-0.0253836662,
0.0593079403,
0.1136545315,
-0.0599600635,
-0.0246450454,
-0.0013536055,
-0.00397339,
-0.0105425352,
0.0179555584,
0.0031369617,
0.0208588131,
0.0649056658,
0.0295446552,
-0.0555347838,
0.0147081679,
-0.007672614,
0.0069276043,
0.0217729323,
-0.0411415137,
-0.0058875065,
0.0556589104,
-0.0247050319,
0.0213206504,
0.0110722166,
-0.0017415577,
-0.0172279254,
0.0509507768,
0.0224630162,
0.0369552635,
-0.0004992415,
0.0021478478,
0.0171901695,
-0.0052126367,
0.0150709776,
-0.0025451879,
0.0402544029,
0.0433607437,
-0.087712951,
-0.0247690547,
-0.0370416827,
0.0162830595,
0.0099769356,
-0.0139693161,
0.0226624981,
0.0173592065,
-0.0746628046,
0.0275012031,
-0.0065191379,
0.0094301095,
-0.0126509964,
0.0086802877,
-0.0267510023,
0.0352265574,
-0.0438728668,
0.0115892943,
0.0096753268,
-0.0678390265,
0.002649331,
-0.0133608682,
0.0152586503,
-0.0086353049,
-0.0395500697,
0.0649159774,
-0.010097201,
-0.0014668396,
-0.0163597018,
-0.0795319006,
-0.0285622925,
-0.0252033826,
0.0118878828,
-0.0117554553,
0.0130173536,
-0.0213338546,
0.0049309628,
-0.0712692887,
-0.0033376978,
-0.041592326,
0.0090469876,
0.083477594,
-0.0102539761,
0.0085016275,
0.0224515423,
0.0653493851,
-0.0898115113,
0.0385246538,
0.0132103143,
-0.0127075315,
0.0765357614,
-0.0693246573,
0.0219513252,
-0.0072601666,
0.0618711151,
0.0081334906,
0.0563698262,
-0.0362712741,
0.0050131395,
-0.0079966774,
-0.0083549693,
-0.0403776988,
-0.0142889796,
-0.0635071024,
0.0496783145,
0.0364135765,
-0.0430386551,
0.0483816117,
0.0100793755,
0.0518317409,
-0.0109457467,
0.0634165406,
-0.0367219523,
0.0223017503,
-0.0073458841,
-0.0322019085,
0.0036152035,
-0.0016019047,
-0.0413207635,
-0.0573884733,
0.002620972,
0.0122301383,
0.0004224254,
0.0128048435,
-0.0026506106,
0.0006178239,
-0.0488460064,
0.0108510051,
-0.008549056,
-0.0415917821,
0.0254820026,
-0.0575751215,
0.0299670324,
0.0558137782,
0.0234709922,
-0.03323441,
-0.0468925871,
-0.012837572,
0.038841825,
-0.0236526094,
0.023792984,
-0.0391751714,
0.0448257402,
-0.0146318441,
-0.0203610938,
-0.0290595833,
0.0219579246,
0.0094771311,
0.0047371262,
-0.0270202514,
-0.0097934017,
0.0202613156,
-0.0078866305,
0.0247250758,
-0.0174760781,
-0.0230978802,
-0.0371206664,
0.0182197597,
0.0465508476,
-0.0046681082,
0.017110303,
-0.0122368019,
0.0143927932,
0.0328624398,
0.0178897697,
0.0608110316,
-0.0502658635,
-0.0085526882,
0.0297446698,
-0.02750808,
-0.0119609339,
-0.0077007078,
-0.0170730241,
-0.0101737631,
0.0957402512,
-0.0103188632,
0.0388673656,
0.0197295975,
0.008922263,
-0.0349273831,
0.0114954719,
0.0246631037,
-0.03281473,
0.0084702261,
-0.0121573647,
-0.0423189066,
-0.0041056746,
-0.0070828404,
-0.0282623451,
0.0595958233,
-0.0580594838,
-0.0228806175,
-0.0148019372,
-0.0041569043,
-0.0194454826,
-0.0460113399,
-0.0127699096,
-0.0545463003,
-0.0461296774,
0.0004169513,
0.0014040354,
-0.0005030395,
-0.0554129817,
0.0102512883,
0.0023021768,
-0.0102156876,
0.0063413526,
-0.0055386778,
-0.0174789373,
0.0395353734,
0.0397975557,
-0.0298632029,
-0.0509883985,
0.0002256272,
-0.025060609,
0.0828683749,
0.0120676048,
-0.0094842669,
-0.0272968393,
0.0040453146,
-0.0044616852,
0.025347203,
-0.0500535518,
-0.0441187844,
0.0091986367,
0.0384334587,
0.0239427909,
0.0777264237,
0.0122412741,
0.1018832475,
0.021343898,
-0.0452368781,
-0.059197221,
-0.0032467353,
-0.0009066905,
-0.022350749,
-0.0317479372,
-0.0883584395,
-0.0441116169,
0.0436278656,
-0.0061245146,
-0.00736266,
-0.0403887667,
0.0667267367,
0.045308657,
-0.0241031609,
-0.0566564426,
-0.0876374915,
0.0258376915,
0.0000779776,
-0.0052394737,
-0.0236617848,
0.054622367,
-0.0125929071,
-0.0165687818,
0.0455445834,
-0.0088446066,
-0.0014247838,
0.0504203811,
-0.0425766893,
-0.0204276238,
-0.0512395911,
0.0087899519,
-0.0142848054,
-0.049747698,
0.0869686007,
-0.0036795575,
-0.0446922779,
-0.0785870105,
-0.0475934185,
0.0212703589,
0.0322280973,
-0.0137940431,
-0.0387729406,
-0.0177533627,
0.0062139225,
0.0337121561,
-0.0175492391,
0.0233015772,
-0.0045978748,
-0.0201937817,
-0.0321409479,
-0.0424550548,
-0.003623904,
0.0014445421,
-0.0230235141,
-0.0165958833,
-0.0195942055,
0.026329156,
-0.0553586446,
0.0842818245,
0.0439796969,
0.0259389803,
-0.0557188727,
-0.0497657992,
-0.0041871881,
-0.0176822729,
0.0190629791,
-0.015499061,
0.0174756888,
0.0607754141,
-0.0563842803,
-0.0001723351,
0.0492796339,
0.0202147327,
-0.0388318598,
0.0260377601,
-0.0230855737,
0.0219388325,
-0.0185695067,
-0.0242493786,
-0.0625790209,
-0.0269450285,
-0.0378498659,
0.0292122178,
-0.0145525271,
-0.0391221754,
-0.0175904538,
-0.0377317183,
0.0578736253,
-0.004166462,
-0.0208471585,
0.0258969925,
-0.0341754407,
-0.026757367,
-0.0011323377,
0.005171454,
-0.0080272481,
0.0248209741,
0.0182822496,
0.0491119362,
-0.0327651165,
0.0046114987,
-0.0030669216,
0.0014509195,
0.0235071648,
-0.030689748,
0.0139149008,
0.0365922265,
-0.0549913794,
-0.0110932104,
0.0441268384,
0.0074769119,
0.0000965856,
0.0829595625,
-0.0317878947,
0.0154214315,
0.0048401393,
0.0574346334,
-0.0117364917,
-0.0132180965,
0.0600675792,
0.0607031286,
-0.0394175872,
0.0147214755,
0.0111484788,
0.063900657,
0.0845105425,
0.0536141396,
0.0427797735,
-0.0082499543,
0.0104190838,
0.0102986395,
0.0182208009,
-0.0544726253,
-0.0235233549,
-0.0041910117,
0.0200337023,
0.0203198288,
-0.0004158233,
-0.0465109348,
0.0063164965,
0.0079305004,
-0.0086411657,
-0.0081988145,
-0.027226137,
0.0410642438,
-0.0227757469,
0.0607198738,
0.0342542529,
-0.000042269,
-0.0222993642,
-0.0322156362,
-0.0344586819,
-0.0488128327,
0.005757005,
-0.0169755947,
-0.032420747,
-0.0295557566,
-0.0436511524,
0.0532363355,
0.0281947609,
0.0329419523,
0.0681991801,
-0.0173054356,
-0.0800736472,
-0.0216895305,
-0.0088352747,
-0.0006688581,
0.0572442226,
-0.0114063853,
0.0197500736,
0.021319326,
0.0242828354,
-0.0126941083,
0.0184809417,
-0.055171933,
-0.0663575754,
-0.0046904222,
-0.0123379398,
-0.0345758386,
0.0549858846,
0.0100926012,
-0.0257212594,
-0.0226045772,
0.0134904208,
-0.021036502,
-0.0097526452,
-0.0333297774,
-0.0016802944,
-0.0143328086,
-0.0137269516,
0.0136692785,
-0.0329015143,
-0.0328541212,
0.0447942391,
-0.030990256,
0.0771540701,
-0.0185849089,
-0.0141192321,
-0.0253754072,
0.0516950674,
0.0028457609,
-0.0090284469,
0.0382958502,
0.0319556482,
0.0405050553,
0.0974124297,
0.0487604178,
0.0227140784,
0.0255780481,
0.0035692253,
-0.014352046,
-0.0669518486,
0.0060262233,
0.0417301245,
-0.0323317908,
-0.0161408205,
0.02771491,
-0.0026947896,
0.0049226107,
0.0224389248,
0.0873105451,
-0.0149799669,
-0.0814364702,
0.0418308489,
0.0079648085,
-0.0081175631,
0.02812621,
0.0487617217,
-0.0051221289,
0.0299348701,
-0.0043735923,
-0.0252144784,
-0.0042426679,
0.0057082372,
0.085504137,
0.0762725845,
0.0445730314,
0.0141444821,
-0.0741806105,
-0.0150932856,
-0.110329248,
0.0163116921,
-0.0118999472,
-0.0244606212,
-0.0007259722,
0.0297426991,
-0.0041005989,
-0.0295753684,
-0.0396692045,
0.0428406186,
-0.0331359766,
0.0050394163,
0.0075264042,
-5.980079187e-33,
-0.0253723841,
-0.1177119315,
0.0088118138,
0.0607294962,
-0.0042444761,
0.0187661629,
-0.0510223247,
0.0124326749,
-0.0287789889,
0.0403818376,
0.0295065846,
0.0342869759,
-0.0048227757,
-0.0149936145,
0.0267770514,
0.0396319851,
0.0145457732,
0.0170224588,
0.0017621149,
0.0257306416,
0.0158598199,
-0.0090673584,
0.0342109166,
-0.0953636169,
0.0750252381,
-0.0202727523,
-0.0264770724,
0.0027605558,
-0.0452422053,
0.0102310432,
0.0101780789,
0.0069176797,
-0.0068839677,
-0.0256505758,
0.008586552,
0.0239294972,
-0.0357420892,
-0.0433261208,
0.0185428634,
0.0101964604,
-0.0577745438,
-0.0473499224,
-0.0060010715,
0.0152675696,
-0.0275921728,
-0.0317887254,
0.0472593978,
0.0067746257,
0.0139844101,
0.0618568845,
-0.0295372494,
0.0134441536,
-0.0961501524,
-0.0770321637,
0.0263610277,
0.0569160767,
0.0109698689,
-0.0191673562,
-0.0267508533,
0.0446083322,
0.0126921358,
0.0036273708,
0.0430754088,
-0.0103646573,
0.0233506709,
0.0610603318,
0.0238857772,
0.0609481707,
0.0168030001,
-0.0505066626,
0.0014306449,
0.0708296373,
0.072305277,
0.0139759304,
-0.0108462013,
-0.0148985917,
-0.038127169,
0.0245541204,
0.0528994724,
0.0016002047,
-0.037334729,
0.0097028939,
-0.0325876065,
-0.0473003387,
-0.0213120505,
-0.0673100427,
0.0367252529,
-0.0408078022,
0.0211600177,
-0.0100159775,
-0.0050065448,
0.0303479265,
0.0069370144,
-0.0380252935,
0.0050708121,
0.0183934439,
-0.0009093523,
0.00446478,
-0.0046019671,
-0.0411589146,
-0.0121264318,
-0.045982033,
-0.0048307735,
-0.0557475537,
0.071663931,
0.0064643375,
0.0265099257,
0.0071753059,
0.03195896,
-0.0242535137,
-0.0457088575,
0.0318889245,
0.0019358587,
-0.0024927729,
-0.0225820448,
-0.0067699947,
-0.053654559,
0.0711577386,
0.0119850365,
0.0135577861,
-0.0263803508,
-0.0186203849,
-0.0348600224,
-0.0220562648,
-0.0138282804,
-0.0403154157,
0.0190294329,
-0.0246844701,
0.0227537584,
-0.016425956,
-0.0001050633,
-0.0759800822,
2.861e-7,
0.0060247551,
0.0562326089,
0.0297371615,
-0.0549305715,
0.017554773,
0.0540551357,
-0.0060489448,
0.0118694268,
0.031504374,
-0.0585485846,
0.0575988851,
0.0134168621,
0.0520505384,
0.0411355384,
-0.0090253064,
-0.0642717853,
-0.0467004925,
-0.0580150783,
0.0043839328,
-0.0028794527,
0.0310233049,
-0.0209758524,
0.0381874405,
0.0205394235,
0.0052493345,
0.0163557399,
-0.0068827164,
-0.0553797707,
-0.0159752332,
0.0355989635,
0.043824859,
-0.0833912715,
0.0199652873,
0.0688265115,
-0.0012757629,
0.0278522223,
-0.06372118,
0.0432944782,
-0.0266690571,
-0.0176792517,
0.0049201697,
0.0302342493,
-0.0169366058,
-0.0403661206,
0.0017731736,
-0.0191444475,
-0.0344813094,
0.0500189066,
-0.0589473993,
-0.0366613716,
-0.0060389875,
0.0012281042,
0.0232814644,
0.0152129903,
-0.0145359309,
-0.0406115875,
0.0269015618,
-0.0333195701,
-0.0134132225,
0.0003409873,
-0.0281675551,
-0.0316369869,
0.0120869698,
-0.022882618,
-0.0009903844,
-0.0263424702,
-0.0179456323,
2.133488268e-34,
-0.0133295888,
0.0157845709,
0.0512657948,
0.0211810227,
0.0855150446,
-0.0040941541,
-0.0068510151,
0.0370134301,
0.0816183165,
0.0195086189,
-0.0413421914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10543v1 | UniMC: A Unified Framework for Long-Term Memory Conversation via Relevance Representation Learning | 2023-06-18T12:30:50 | 2023-06-18T12:30:50 | Kang Zhao, Wei Liu, Jian Luan, Minglei Gao, Li Qian, Hanlin Teng, Bin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Open-domain long-term memory conversation can establish long-term intimacy
with humans, and the key is the ability to understand and memorize long-term
dialogue history information. Existing works integrate multiple models for
modelling through a pipeline, which ignores the coupling between different
stages. In this paper, we propose a Unified framework for Long-term Memory
Conversations (UniMC), which increases the connection between different stages
by learning relevance representation. Specifically, we decompose the main task
into three subtasks based on probability graphs: 1) conversation summarization,
2) memory retrieval, 3) memory-augmented generation. Each subtask involves
learning a representation for calculating the relevance between the query and
memory, which is modelled by inserting a special token at the beginning of the
decoder input. The relevance representation learning strengthens the connection
across subtasks through parameter sharing and joint training. Extensive
experimental results show that the proposed method consistently improves over
strong baselines and yields better dialogue consistency and engagingness. | [
0.0543178804,
0.0484865457,
-0.0021649573,
-0.0069334214,
-0.0264947563,
-0.0131782116,
-0.0329767913,
-0.0452427939,
-0.0027497238,
-0.0253428742,
-0.0052304179,
-0.0588096716,
0.0277250595,
0.0460552536,
-0.0118521126,
-0.0875355378,
0.0493493006,
-0.0053340984,
0.0370947905,
0.023784617,
-0.0118328538,
-0.0130701959,
-0.0265195612,
0.0364758968,
-0.0198460389,
0.0227089394,
-0.0387056731,
0.0049111624,
-0.0011346218,
-0.0381084979,
-0.0172204152,
0.0057472428,
0.0394337699,
-0.0335723124,
0.0000016799,
-0.0463866889,
-0.0352558754,
-0.050038673,
-0.0004189255,
-0.048524633,
0.021855738,
0.0141164316,
0.0096973078,
0.0132366205,
-0.0610209405,
0.0111907208,
0.0460320748,
0.0478078574,
0.0673921183,
0.0569778532,
0.0010086029,
0.0010916124,
0.0077111232,
-0.0299411304,
0.0686919615,
-0.0522992499,
-0.0011557399,
0.0256658047,
0.0035187854,
-0.008154084,
0.0013459643,
0.0164883919,
0.0256094635,
-0.0272341408,
0.0483682752,
0.0370007567,
0.0104301162,
0.0045724092,
0.0079264184,
0.0838046893,
0.0497035831,
0.0178377051,
-0.0206143633,
0.0385337546,
0.0263080634,
-0.0304554459,
-0.0980322212,
0.0032052412,
-0.0171863809,
0.0238977913,
-0.0620145574,
0.0332874954,
-0.0096181361,
-0.0087516569,
-0.0319015123,
0.034772791,
-0.0147005692,
-0.0126597276,
-0.0238781497,
-0.0167783108,
0.0054291785,
-0.045004759,
0.0194570981,
0.0615784191,
-0.018420402,
0.0300746057,
-0.0204445887,
0.0138056837,
0.0065722764,
-0.0396524332,
-0.0252123848,
0.024996588,
0.0055052624,
0.0437381603,
-0.0112669943,
0.0275401734,
0.016472226,
-0.0331357457,
-0.0389873423,
-0.0113927387,
-0.0723581165,
-0.0105529111,
-0.0429884866,
0.0465026945,
-0.0325981341,
-0.0438444801,
-0.0307448283,
0.0592765994,
0.0125718787,
-0.0274677966,
-0.0142066739,
0.0469084717,
-0.044772435,
0.0207042992,
-0.0407826863,
0.0678882748,
-0.0438955761,
-0.0188410934,
0.0390545502,
-0.0497146398,
-0.0425880775,
0.0399014503,
0.0198629517,
-0.0210742,
-0.0460496619,
0.037956804,
-0.0488647707,
-0.0407783315,
-0.0236410946,
-0.0494140945,
-0.0413843654,
-0.041189108,
0.0397696532,
0.0055112909,
0.0352094732,
-0.0230806284,
-0.0280467123,
-0.0424344838,
0.003746079,
0.0165948607,
-0.0153333675,
0.0408541597,
0.0265679192,
-0.0216837469,
0.052501563,
0.0246749613,
0.0037654049,
0.0452379659,
0.0336745754,
0.0338869244,
0.0141638294,
-0.00281299,
0.0004714002,
-0.0358818732,
0.0379505828,
-0.0067902179,
0.0171801876,
0.018686058,
0.0142319193,
0.0515882708,
0.0441289656,
0.0341323391,
-0.0463691168,
-0.0247728508,
0.0505551882,
0.0337023884,
0.0189026929,
0.010222231,
0.0024493991,
0.0430957489,
-0.0010485094,
0.048058562,
-0.0442309976,
0.0633351281,
0.0096278675,
0.0238554347,
0.0558108799,
-0.0129305767,
-0.0412854515,
-0.0433132201,
0.0510148183,
-0.0127274496,
0.0452618636,
0.0035752815,
0.0243204348,
0.038708102,
-0.066368036,
0.060697142,
0.0021938945,
-0.0607565343,
0.0131922392,
-0.060180977,
0.0240570065,
0.0779205635,
0.0574644282,
0.0005872955,
-0.0236783046,
-0.0176092461,
0.003532521,
0.0150089562,
0.0167302229,
-0.015623264,
0.0358567685,
-0.0563150793,
-0.0377215706,
-0.0248073861,
-0.0061753374,
0.0294447988,
0.0177227817,
-0.0112266494,
0.0346943513,
0.0031802726,
0.0312830433,
-0.0045765103,
-0.007411594,
-0.0122106932,
0.0232178625,
-0.0043554581,
0.0097564152,
0.0241631586,
0.0128916465,
0.0365336388,
0.0470960476,
-0.0009573741,
0.0010005943,
0.0323788449,
-0.1086791828,
-0.0255294107,
0.0206360873,
0.0027276573,
0.0355451517,
-0.0437280573,
0.0078301663,
-0.0698090047,
0.0774538964,
-0.0608110987,
0.0812138394,
-0.0294701252,
0.0079686046,
0.0216168184,
0.013074846,
-0.0334128253,
0.0449984558,
-0.0067292904,
-0.0400175191,
0.0517385267,
0.0039117876,
-0.0110740345,
-0.0766628608,
0.0265717469,
0.0131862666,
-0.0118015306,
-0.0066183684,
0.0423624404,
0.0033062999,
-0.0769357532,
-0.0352715924,
-0.1297037303,
0.0025475339,
0.0053278557,
-0.006293444,
0.0160818361,
0.0252541974,
0.0042578951,
-0.0256911609,
-0.0550986379,
0.0026928631,
0.0228914395,
0.0227987412,
0.0148155401,
0.0507665612,
-0.0001082553,
-0.0488642976,
0.0039737099,
0.0162691064,
0.0508015975,
0.023768777,
-0.0472705439,
-0.0180681925,
-0.0011733709,
-0.0407099463,
0.0280885082,
-0.0474549569,
-0.0007719029,
0.0042227334,
-0.01680132,
0.0629763901,
0.0848480463,
0.0586376674,
0.0298391767,
-0.0056242966,
-0.0606382601,
-0.052872818,
0.0298297144,
-0.0672607198,
-0.0085137077,
-0.0280081015,
-0.0056614582,
0.0131482678,
-0.0063384562,
0.0176600907,
0.0284974705,
-0.0369747244,
-0.0153860962,
0.0370955169,
-0.0347058587,
-0.0191057436,
-0.0247126091,
-0.0374689549,
-0.0023875639,
-0.0294118002,
-0.0414462946,
0.0753741115,
-0.0213768613,
-0.0073752962,
-0.0358568951,
-0.0037671509,
-0.0332057364,
0.0763138235,
-0.0360803939,
0.0082519436,
-0.0154904826,
-0.0621730313,
-0.0320480056,
-0.0134875672,
0.009683324,
-0.0250072088,
0.0182650108,
-0.0423582643,
0.008030666,
0.0340602398,
0.0118611334,
-0.0558188297,
0.0000288164,
-0.0135687245,
0.0268717278,
-0.0111354012,
-0.0189735983,
-0.0772506595,
0.0176355466,
0.025534302,
-0.0054680682,
-0.0256761201,
-0.0108949384,
-0.0095729874,
0.0403940119,
0.0477448031,
0.0100475121,
-0.0005651856,
-0.0104018264,
0.0463900305,
0.0508067645,
0.036903616,
-0.0136444559,
0.0090450579,
-0.0155771812,
-0.0329196863,
-0.0158068072,
0.0226609986,
0.0136759654,
0.0185779855,
-0.0384618118,
-0.0422797129,
0.1022819132,
0.0230645873,
-0.0565104596,
-0.0431279987,
-0.0310036186,
0.0332264416,
-0.0150500359,
-0.0034170302,
-0.060364306,
-0.0300930943,
0.001852837,
0.0258049481,
0.0012235809,
-0.0355955549,
-0.0422166772,
-0.0788131207,
-0.0073400396,
0.0304225422,
-0.0335876718,
-0.0235769376,
-0.0449907109,
-0.0267355889,
0.0101347966,
0.0283943415,
0.0181730501,
-0.0011163303,
-0.0036230374,
-0.0012274666,
0.0125134941,
-0.0123509467,
0.014559445,
0.0127197485,
0.0179566275,
0.0795748383,
0.0502167307,
0.0686110258,
0.0105297053,
0.0483812913,
-0.0103885988,
0.0189808439,
-0.0121339867,
0.0775725543,
-0.0215636212,
0.0373985991,
-0.0475599431,
0.0332054682,
0.0006296019,
0.0056335055,
0.0156869199,
0.0336620621,
-0.0758657381,
0.000081201,
-0.0125245983,
0.0420229323,
0.0458906032,
0.0715919733,
0.0413442254,
-0.0131018432,
-0.0233477633,
-0.0090036299,
0.0428816564,
-0.0435807034,
0.0130072897,
-0.0225546174,
0.0238052346,
0.0311190542,
-0.0740611479,
-0.060500104,
0.009966772,
-0.0011913321,
-0.0308021251,
0.0088127218,
-0.0031605263,
0.0108965058,
-0.0558612421,
0.0088646738,
-0.0500548258,
-0.0007712695,
-0.0443584882,
-0.014333602,
0.0366419628,
-0.0500015914,
0.0128422081,
0.0397311077,
-0.0698479861,
-0.0446695052,
-0.0298483577,
0.0618388094,
0.0289865844,
0.0957263112,
0.0203314163,
-0.0088468995,
0.0111763487,
0.0041335416,
-0.019533908,
0.0186592247,
0.0007412676,
0.0570908636,
-0.0148426397,
0.0070961225,
-0.0297537446,
-0.0086035114,
-0.0410897359,
0.0434168726,
-0.0015915035,
-0.0973946303,
0.0169794988,
-0.0079951072,
0.0155702941,
0.0446010791,
-0.0078535136,
-0.0014155572,
0.0219525192,
-0.0274430458,
0.0140590584,
-0.0586760081,
0.0109606711,
0.000720854,
-0.0171466582,
0.032886412,
-0.0394819677,
-0.0282593183,
0.0414987579,
0.0042980099,
-0.0528719351,
0.0036342596,
-0.0440444015,
-0.0013415969,
-0.0041950499,
-0.0191596374,
0.0249036849,
0.0102457125,
0.009154805,
-0.0022559389,
0.0583342314,
-0.0049765394,
-0.0402899645,
0.0060560964,
0.0112417713,
-0.0988738015,
-0.0256029498,
-0.0235226173,
0.0096479068,
0.0283054207,
0.0397927128,
0.0267506428,
-0.0201036129,
0.0492928699,
-0.0157243833,
0.0516513251,
0.0001943141,
-0.0407795608,
0.0208406597,
0.0252391789,
-0.0004691299,
0.0134722814,
0.0561927855,
-0.013859503,
0.0246467609,
-0.0065376796,
-0.0234565083,
-0.045703467,
-0.068065092,
0.0146406218,
0.0848908275,
-0.01831498,
-0.0080335876,
-0.0231018644,
0.009012633,
0.0006854452,
-0.0260381568,
0.0055477805,
-0.0075042942,
0.0767594576,
0.0304512084,
-0.0287009478,
-0.0268006232,
-0.0372230262,
0.016354287,
-0.0091674458,
-0.0030275602,
-0.0395547152,
-5.57956769e-33,
-0.0311278123,
-0.0536615327,
0.042064663,
-0.0017377854,
-0.086300768,
-0.0308860242,
-0.0674321204,
0.0055922261,
-0.0236200914,
-0.0342075974,
0.0073452997,
0.0504039302,
0.0146842096,
0.049513001,
-0.0307609998,
-0.0187020153,
0.0628897995,
0.0142407482,
-0.0061378567,
0.0915749744,
0.0858888626,
0.0447238348,
0.0127418162,
-0.0523428693,
0.0291095804,
0.0042362628,
0.0011616924,
0.0483055674,
0.0430689976,
0.0459251478,
-0.0292644687,
0.0355930403,
0.013310506,
-0.028713638,
-0.0368092544,
0.0455285609,
-0.0759888366,
-0.0160892773,
0.0240571909,
-0.0208347719,
-0.0341576338,
-0.0354092754,
0.0243194886,
-0.0070077688,
0.0633812621,
-0.0386211164,
0.0186902341,
-0.0248886552,
-0.0550962202,
0.008723285,
-0.0190705676,
0.0017803904,
-0.0135023976,
-0.0388493799,
-0.0148475394,
0.0361404754,
0.0450339541,
-0.0038214244,
-0.0088732634,
0.038175948,
-0.0466019958,
0.032407973,
0.0315052494,
0.0329822861,
0.0013305569,
0.0680547878,
0.0154375331,
-0.00346497,
-0.0305330008,
-0.0513116047,
-0.0056101051,
0.0298574474,
-0.0119398274,
0.0223942604,
0.0079035116,
0.0082936147,
-0.0372800119,
0.0339522734,
0.0175197665,
0.0687319636,
-0.0152596692,
0.0185613688,
-0.0014945209,
-0.0218568742,
-0.0351143293,
0.0401314348,
-0.0112963971,
-0.0561820306,
0.0264726989,
0.044110138,
-0.0094971089,
-0.0345595479,
0.0391943827,
-0.0110093281,
0.0362646393,
0.0698331296,
-0.0122707477,
-0.0081441123,
-0.0080680335,
-0.0237808023,
-0.0204832237,
0.0047995355,
0.0653367192,
-0.0118185738,
-0.0150168957,
0.0187876783,
-0.0110326707,
0.0025146839,
-0.0282531325,
0.0083572576,
-0.0308761131,
0.0513549671,
-0.03236375,
0.0092404513,
0.0001133203,
0.0382843278,
-0.0316665769,
0.068898797,
-0.0214994363,
0.0241567455,
-0.0200703461,
-0.0395070612,
0.0248682331,
0.0097273421,
-0.0121896183,
0.0009226969,
-0.0213679634,
0.0080614137,
0.0122722117,
-0.0447570719,
-0.0070050443,
0.0131027913,
2.512e-7,
-0.0215289854,
0.0080621466,
0.0741971433,
0.0069100619,
0.0179543681,
0.0115137203,
0.013900728,
0.0246043839,
0.0440220349,
-0.0274414588,
0.0306732822,
0.0507922433,
0.0274164192,
0.0035919624,
-0.0972192809,
-0.0394752324,
-0.0568895899,
-0.0648789704,
-0.0149840694,
-0.0346226133,
0.090751186,
0.0447569937,
0.0070780762,
0.0063629365,
0.011166187,
-0.0532549396,
0.0788040012,
-0.0406435318,
-0.0229623858,
0.0285674948,
0.0094543369,
0.0026356878,
-0.0134955989,
0.0000689153,
-0.0006928139,
-0.0085510379,
-0.0025136892,
0.0374714173,
0.018957153,
-0.095065847,
0.0048278868,
0.0222492069,
0.0061951242,
-0.0009170962,
0.031076625,
-0.08243981,
-0.0307395812,
0.0260701459,
-0.0291653927,
-0.0077197575,
0.0081332084,
0.0069450857,
-0.0168653578,
0.0081083942,
-0.0056852251,
0.0610424615,
0.0497927926,
-0.104188174,
-0.0152185122,
-0.0164251439,
-0.0695665032,
-0.0428910367,
-0.0108876415,
-0.0337960832,
0.0067452686,
-0.0557549223,
-0.0040664389,
1.940364188e-34,
0.0443339162,
0.0040255315,
0.0044717095,
0.0280802213,
0.0197024159,
-0.0013610759,
0.0028967962,
0.0079570077,
0.0678099692,
-0.0996657312,
-0.0370980501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.17177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.17177v1 | Leveraging ChatGPT As Text Annotation Tool For Sentiment Analysis | 2023-06-18T12:20:42 | 2023-06-18T12:20:42 | Mohammad Belal, James She, Simon Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis is a well-known natural language processing task that
involves identifying the emotional tone or polarity of a given piece of text.
With the growth of social media and other online platforms, sentiment analysis
has become increasingly crucial for businesses and organizations seeking to
monitor and comprehend customer feedback as well as opinions. Supervised
learning algorithms have been popularly employed for this task, but they
require human-annotated text to create the classifier. To overcome this
challenge, lexicon-based tools have been used. A drawback of lexicon-based
algorithms is their reliance on pre-defined sentiment lexicons, which may not
capture the full range of sentiments in natural language. ChatGPT is a new
product of OpenAI and has emerged as the most popular AI product. It can answer
questions on various topics and tasks. This study explores the use of ChatGPT
as a tool for data labeling for different sentiment analysis tasks. It is
evaluated on two distinct sentiment analysis datasets with varying purposes.
The results demonstrate that ChatGPT outperforms other lexicon-based
unsupervised methods with significant improvements in overall accuracy.
Specifically, compared to the best-performing lexical-based algorithms, ChatGPT
achieves a remarkable increase in accuracy of 20% for the tweets dataset and
approximately 25% for the Amazon reviews dataset. These findings highlight the
exceptional performance of ChatGPT in sentiment analysis tasks, surpassing
existing lexicon-based approaches by a significant margin. The evidence
suggests it can be used for annotation on different sentiment analysis events
and taskss. | [
0.0408537462,
0.0398916379,
0.0088673411,
0.0363902859,
-0.0415301248,
0.0265612919,
-0.0197785366,
-0.0104635218,
0.0578276962,
-0.0838012323,
-0.0256841909,
0.0093135526,
-0.0374704711,
0.0389739126,
-0.0509861074,
-0.0331703648,
0.0239405297,
0.0729214028,
0.0660121366,
0.0249347482,
0.0262236968,
0.0332893133,
-0.0171000138,
0.0136853689,
-0.0318729095,
-0.0315471254,
0.0305946935,
-0.0122284163,
0.0328990817,
-0.0099212397,
0.0457020849,
0.032529965,
-0.0389296822,
0.0519168749,
0.000001905,
-0.0101804212,
0.0212767106,
-0.0123116327,
0.0256883558,
-0.006095591,
0.1096262783,
0.0045532235,
-0.0050471267,
0.0005299348,
-0.0538350269,
-0.0155128669,
0.0518049113,
0.075392589,
0.0783760399,
0.0749213696,
-0.0337402932,
-0.0228458345,
-0.0410875753,
0.0084140105,
-0.016355155,
-0.0224503651,
0.0197063312,
0.0129478378,
-0.030374866,
-0.0162864644,
0.0098842746,
0.0210480411,
-0.0229816698,
-0.0056660464,
0.0108892834,
0.0097224778,
-0.040429987,
-0.0149420556,
-0.0256704222,
0.0592860989,
0.0215241946,
-0.0078594945,
-0.024419345,
-0.0178969447,
-0.0246533025,
-0.0501414388,
0.0104262466,
0.0071269856,
-0.0056683701,
0.0499667078,
-0.0053928853,
0.0365265235,
0.0031197465,
0.0452490225,
0.018521117,
0.0617388263,
-0.042841956,
-0.0372015275,
0.0413013659,
0.055735942,
-0.0064062793,
-0.0118442578,
0.0182030685,
-0.0184291732,
0.0190370325,
0.0310326237,
-0.0015204342,
-0.0164240431,
-0.00103231,
-0.1215665564,
-0.023996057,
0.0261424165,
-0.0312075354,
0.0384922437,
0.0108884778,
-0.0280612875,
0.0199168045,
0.0146730747,
-0.0297798011,
0.00003898,
-0.0797761157,
0.0190449134,
0.0143889962,
0.0240643416,
-0.0056041358,
-0.0425137542,
-0.074897252,
-0.0049739727,
-0.0244783498,
0.0051507843,
0.0280872304,
-0.0008933228,
0.0038013407,
0.0239339769,
-0.0376802869,
0.0279256925,
-0.0510745645,
0.0555161834,
-0.0226809792,
-0.040358305,
0.016167393,
0.0462793745,
0.0162626561,
0.008661476,
-0.0047541102,
0.0323456749,
0.0280457586,
-0.0408093035,
-0.058379285,
-0.0196323209,
-0.0249965154,
-0.0294405092,
-0.029195562,
-0.0362644941,
0.0227879267,
-0.007870052,
-0.0171003919,
0.0279121846,
0.0364827625,
0.0127470605,
-0.0369981974,
0.0728290975,
-0.0664122328,
-0.0504625216,
0.0133119039,
-0.0082495222,
0.0180579219,
0.0488024354,
0.0188003592,
0.0652426481,
0.0637049377,
0.0286682509,
0.0281626545,
-0.0048469738,
0.0023016371,
-0.0397698656,
-0.0236586221,
-0.0088466667,
-0.0528075323,
-0.0044429675,
-0.0193771813,
0.0319764987,
0.0057851877,
0.0078884019,
0.0343541875,
0.0083840583,
-0.0440259688,
0.0471719727,
-0.0413646214,
0.0248164013,
0.0222524777,
-0.0258014109,
-0.0071553406,
0.0216631405,
-0.016426675,
-0.0007682013,
0.0092915148,
-0.0303787142,
-0.0148975523,
-0.0712835193,
-0.0481593423,
-0.0282839648,
0.0431403555,
-0.0210807715,
0.0307294223,
-0.0026115179,
-0.040934395,
-0.0211000629,
0.0495544337,
-0.0741160437,
-0.0288268421,
-0.0207706708,
0.0119730532,
0.0762007535,
-0.0065739392,
-0.0241452828,
-0.0555084608,
-0.0268913414,
-0.0033153286,
0.0536478274,
0.0694046095,
0.0094659394,
-0.0319428146,
-0.050990168,
0.0097667295,
-0.0091993883,
-0.0120810913,
0.0068638599,
0.0182901118,
0.0210989267,
-0.0117126005,
-0.0168526005,
-0.0377278887,
0.0135409553,
0.0496993177,
-0.0443526432,
0.0260083023,
-0.0067043323,
0.0747940466,
0.060037557,
-0.0108805345,
-0.0296826214,
-0.0032456918,
0.0066657877,
-0.0759844184,
0.0212853868,
-0.0004254331,
-0.0606257394,
0.005799863,
-0.0386894196,
-0.0439389385,
0.0447562486,
-0.0751396492,
-0.0189540759,
0.001365685,
-0.0087407622,
0.0142071834,
-0.0465552621,
-0.0557963774,
-0.0292790532,
0.0234039389,
0.0041700797,
0.0757088512,
0.0066201785,
-0.0328948125,
-0.041668009,
-0.0318054259,
0.0134875467,
0.023462845,
-0.0520883277,
0.003361979,
0.0371470377,
0.014348642,
0.0230871737,
0.0029877962,
-0.0370643362,
-0.0293462984,
-0.1235526502,
0.0191981401,
0.0135887405,
0.0225182846,
0.0108602112,
0.0074211452,
-0.020496333,
0.015296543,
-0.0390240997,
0.012215157,
-0.0062781181,
0.0074766227,
0.0432437211,
0.0225952826,
0.0422388278,
-0.0449592322,
0.0235748906,
-0.024827078,
-0.0190611612,
0.0456212014,
-0.0666977912,
0.0058708168,
0.0381758735,
-0.0519099012,
0.0246852823,
0.0203027967,
-0.041542232,
-0.0080656232,
0.0093703633,
-0.026828656,
0.0115597658,
0.016174037,
0.0312424097,
-0.0113951536,
0.0044225096,
-0.0049246419,
0.0284007695,
-0.0566524118,
0.0115173589,
0.0145094329,
0.0115385065,
0.0055846907,
0.0564063042,
0.0123133538,
-0.0038251602,
-0.0423043072,
-0.0335353613,
-0.0393833444,
0.0149520608,
-0.0077067181,
0.0006180205,
-0.0019828377,
-0.0042197714,
0.0216944013,
-0.0297195055,
0.0544456579,
0.0374902487,
0.0085318107,
-0.0881560743,
-0.0119073978,
-0.0523972213,
0.0513277426,
-0.0377388,
-0.0098426836,
-0.0475538634,
0.0087104198,
0.0372540206,
-0.0413494632,
-0.0117644658,
-0.0228659026,
-0.0050140372,
-0.0036562865,
0.0134978406,
0.0312761255,
-0.0276874658,
0.006136999,
-0.0130449198,
-0.0638251454,
-0.0103702871,
0.0541329533,
-0.0072764065,
0.0116716661,
-0.009418807,
-0.0302643981,
-0.0278111678,
-0.0083524948,
-0.0279357098,
0.0262518916,
-0.0087394491,
0.0197048541,
-0.0196414683,
0.0388504155,
0.036464937,
0.0101362932,
0.0603760555,
0.0008784014,
-0.010397655,
-0.0276743453,
-0.0350481234,
0.0043319357,
-0.024668308,
0.0091628442,
-0.047111962,
0.0099164043,
-0.0096197696,
0.0222806297,
0.1151891202,
0.0474523418,
-0.0534098558,
0.0009686811,
0.0242154505,
-0.0125750145,
0.0230035167,
0.0032767851,
-0.0608040392,
-0.0384401157,
-0.0352725498,
0.0432886519,
-0.0117221586,
-0.0243420973,
-0.004590814,
-0.0970988274,
0.0244962946,
-0.023380382,
-0.0305085778,
-0.0233175084,
-0.0279402342,
-0.0005808484,
-0.055883266,
-0.0089817606,
-0.0632118806,
0.0325913839,
0.011412357,
0.0230888892,
-0.0609306991,
-0.0393693671,
0.0239845738,
-0.005179123,
0.0444199741,
0.0362431444,
0.0921549425,
-0.0042735641,
-0.0004097476,
0.0450072065,
0.013300458,
0.0059424113,
-0.0429748334,
0.0977459326,
-0.0487149879,
-0.0367220975,
-0.0039800969,
0.0221871696,
-0.0812408254,
0.0222281981,
0.0064610648,
0.0067455345,
-0.0155104632,
-0.0126130963,
-0.015598774,
0.052866146,
0.0357524045,
0.0562095232,
-0.0193186216,
-0.0472155362,
-0.0129085053,
-0.025994312,
0.0060475869,
-0.0427719839,
-0.0484407991,
-0.0199205931,
-0.0144752916,
-0.0495762303,
-0.0560461618,
-0.0625924245,
0.0213294812,
0.0079708491,
-0.0165915005,
-0.0375278927,
0.0133501934,
0.0267202482,
-0.0204187073,
0.0015556971,
0.0116215842,
-0.0117987972,
0.0214326344,
-0.05156691,
0.0497520752,
0.0058623091,
-0.0110710859,
0.0226926506,
-0.0399064384,
-0.0164073724,
0.008130529,
0.0279993638,
0.0107419509,
-0.0006391779,
-0.0145987822,
-0.0044687791,
-0.004540686,
0.0907659829,
-0.039079994,
-0.0270767678,
0.0163831636,
0.103762649,
0.0222399235,
0.008078604,
-0.0210527815,
0.0468967333,
-0.003544691,
-0.0024760766,
-0.0173981581,
-0.0261716656,
0.0072705424,
-0.009273841,
0.0763826445,
0.0191583112,
-0.0204413086,
-0.0440488942,
-0.0176023729,
-0.0073017473,
-0.0467432886,
-0.0201928243,
-0.0180068165,
-0.0093186358,
-0.000630601,
-0.0950368792,
0.0156640578,
-0.0345145576,
-0.0060067582,
-0.0252390914,
0.0504464693,
0.0392010882,
0.0252796654,
-0.0473167077,
0.0035842233,
-0.028883731,
-0.0049229246,
0.0251159165,
-0.0079697184,
0.0131191947,
0.0451637097,
0.0208217092,
-0.0046902341,
0.0197542366,
0.016053047,
-0.0208112393,
0.0186186191,
-0.048487328,
0.0567234121,
-0.0122645739,
-0.028329486,
0.0212052651,
-0.0820469782,
0.0130234817,
0.0190162752,
0.0092838351,
-0.015984768,
-0.0274867285,
-0.0149591099,
-0.0354770608,
-0.0563246571,
-0.0125424555,
0.0296987984,
-0.079285033,
0.0327213705,
0.0444851592,
-0.0343440175,
-0.0535888672,
-0.00409046,
0.0382525139,
-0.0006229977,
0.0364988036,
0.0367611609,
-0.0463720374,
-0.031627249,
0.0537885167,
-0.0395133309,
0.0268445853,
0.010672288,
0.0438666232,
0.0585818291,
0.0073145563,
0.0273969155,
-0.0495390519,
-0.0059800837,
-0.0528482161,
-0.0274826586,
-0.0249871686,
-6.021789032e-33,
0.0010343505,
-0.0214133486,
-0.0377260521,
0.0746292844,
0.0139975213,
0.0140611408,
0.0038823285,
0.0325424597,
0.0274073258,
0.05929593,
0.0141999228,
0.0506382957,
0.0099571534,
0.0357215889,
0.0288282,
-0.043706879,
0.0062631448,
-0.0195593517,
0.0037339702,
0.0222045835,
0.0451553315,
0.0065203016,
0.0721419081,
-0.1386771947,
0.0666575953,
-0.0024146098,
-0.0350800902,
-0.0146481469,
0.0420131609,
0.0434289724,
-0.0285852905,
0.1051019728,
0.0231847651,
0.0018242756,
0.0333802849,
0.0309081953,
0.0193926301,
-0.0289382152,
-0.0199783873,
0.0252732877,
-0.0465828218,
0.0057831383,
0.0003726985,
0.0163140874,
-0.0576406047,
0.036560975,
0.043041382,
-0.0199903287,
0.0337922238,
-0.0566840544,
-0.0625270829,
0.045208849,
-0.0200194009,
-0.023626022,
0.0190134849,
0.0354007259,
-0.0023215781,
0.0241021104,
-0.0635010153,
0.0079806745,
-0.0299862958,
-0.0086967275,
-0.0035962621,
-0.0411727615,
-0.002468182,
0.0721453205,
0.0125359539,
0.0256088376,
-0.0199528597,
0.0395066142,
-0.0161781665,
0.0045950492,
0.0233393982,
0.0535544865,
-0.0006324062,
-0.04287095,
-0.0135408686,
0.0331994779,
0.0613960773,
-0.0229347907,
0.0418815427,
0.0062545077,
-0.04404708,
0.0021908192,
0.0548434407,
-0.0340909101,
-0.0354036279,
0.0000267201,
-0.0054772804,
-0.022169916,
-0.0266919769,
0.0102591468,
-0.0234885775,
-0.0439298302,
-0.0054904697,
-0.0053249868,
-0.0262220874,
0.0556777455,
-0.0105107883,
-0.0219673719,
-0.0520445965,
-0.0211911835,
-0.0096204868,
0.0349158421,
0.0190806761,
-0.0255940277,
0.0429303609,
0.0370968282,
-0.0570993349,
-0.0133843441,
0.0000064655,
0.0339479931,
-0.0170005951,
0.015167187,
-0.0067066043,
-0.0020511143,
0.0024296606,
0.0634997264,
0.0307297818,
0.0651219115,
-0.0104852403,
-0.0389832705,
-0.0055730804,
-0.0390406139,
-0.0341683105,
-0.0266475677,
0.0363614932,
-0.0236519855,
-0.0574533902,
-0.0609698668,
0.0028991192,
0.0037176458,
2.653e-7,
0.0703641549,
0.1039580032,
0.0087633347,
-0.0041265325,
0.0221133288,
0.0355357118,
0.0366626605,
0.0183066614,
-0.0080496464,
-0.0220403317,
0.0446275957,
-0.0067481725,
0.0292441603,
0.0345354453,
-0.0941393152,
-0.0003156942,
-0.0436840616,
0.0100844083,
-0.0223861858,
0.0479016788,
0.098875545,
0.0976677835,
0.0569085814,
0.0037921085,
-0.0099983132,
-0.0000285487,
0.0234677922,
-0.0443474092,
-0.0061175358,
0.0327147022,
0.0148107298,
0.0251750052,
-0.0303429998,
-0.0135769695,
-0.010337173,
-0.0041640666,
0.0471053012,
0.0352896675,
0.0125430049,
-0.0400128178,
0.0090315519,
0.0201973617,
0.0299181398,
0.0060592666,
0.034823481,
-0.0608477332,
-0.0572435595,
-0.0909052342,
0.0277325045,
0.0309866611,
0.0750700757,
-0.0133391237,
-0.023940593,
0.0206095167,
-0.0021160673,
-0.0200067144,
-0.0629142448,
-0.0640126318,
0.00202016,
-0.0096380133,
-0.0060874354,
-0.020418318,
0.0218451098,
0.0369583331,
0.0402549244,
0.0120444763,
0.0265468936,
1.904591967e-34,
0.0306073893,
-0.03618332,
-0.0170084406,
0.0156317838,
0.0485594086,
0.0404396057,
-0.0089995479,
-0.0034238214,
0.0120064411,
-0.0019178295,
0.0184789114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14910v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14910v1 | The Importance of Human-Labeled Data in the Era of LLMs | 2023-06-18T12:12:03 | 2023-06-18T12:12:03 | Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | The advent of large language models (LLMs) has brought about a revolution in
the development of tailored machine learning models and sparked debates on
redefining data requirements. The automation facilitated by the training and
implementation of LLMs has led to discussions and aspirations that human-level
labeling interventions may no longer hold the same level of importance as in
the era of supervised learning. This paper presents compelling arguments
supporting the ongoing relevance of human-labeled data in the era of LLMs. | [
0.0483574606,
0.0368228108,
-0.0226782467,
0.0091169085,
-0.0083566979,
0.041708231,
0.0460665338,
0.0016430389,
0.0157475621,
-0.068298392,
-0.0449455157,
-0.0112176025,
-0.020188598,
-0.0159492306,
0.0526518673,
-0.0572681874,
0.0434295088,
-0.021665968,
0.0118005173,
0.000800229,
-0.0305800606,
-0.0156426802,
0.0108968429,
0.0137951802,
-0.0225504357,
0.006203921,
0.0253737252,
-0.0243048165,
-0.010568222,
-0.0291243438,
-0.0137760174,
0.0898214206,
0.0248163268,
0.0392298847,
0.0000016118,
-0.0515340716,
0.0231775958,
-0.0028942272,
-0.0741597265,
0.0086875856,
0.0406568237,
-0.0290659796,
-0.0097521404,
-0.0184214581,
-0.0048870631,
-0.0073437002,
0.0668206438,
0.024753429,
0.0244328845,
0.0400026888,
0.0018617607,
-0.0333210416,
0.0275218654,
-0.0225143339,
0.0479387455,
-0.0408181101,
0.0494050235,
0.0026108157,
0.0148832435,
0.0209522564,
-0.0115455054,
0.0665409938,
-0.0042304546,
-0.0020470053,
0.0277705714,
0.0396489725,
-0.0132285133,
-0.0305719078,
0.0021334398,
0.0702357888,
0.0342997499,
-0.006443386,
0.0115726907,
0.0021586015,
0.0012554488,
0.0027619263,
-0.0322887897,
0.036372751,
-0.0031813532,
0.0350608714,
0.0281917844,
-0.0256992932,
0.0467770845,
0.0357394964,
0.0050328304,
0.0954950228,
-0.0250087641,
-0.0171436127,
0.0575319864,
0.0280648116,
-0.0057291621,
-0.0571471006,
0.0104698492,
0.0083466209,
0.0067964462,
0.0162549317,
-0.042192664,
-0.0403845645,
0.0166461393,
-0.0313490294,
0.0241858624,
-0.0050666686,
-0.0268222187,
0.0307501312,
-0.0055876574,
0.0182727389,
0.0124879293,
0.0579209849,
-0.0505136661,
0.0104274591,
-0.0414616168,
-0.0178929679,
-0.0436095931,
-0.0012124416,
-0.0000196812,
0.017751554,
-0.048937764,
0.0415953957,
-0.0128114382,
-0.0028781078,
-0.018788036,
-0.0293182936,
-0.0289030727,
0.0080071399,
-0.0088974517,
-0.0298127215,
-0.0057387901,
0.0238023475,
0.0086236531,
-0.0589474253,
0.0325733647,
0.03538239,
-0.0246869773,
-0.0267722905,
0.0142725222,
0.0681720227,
-0.0059328889,
-0.0488115996,
-0.0399507321,
0.0071187131,
-0.0346908718,
-0.0410429724,
0.0009797497,
-0.0535059199,
0.0059499238,
0.0147986691,
-0.0054910202,
-0.0525948182,
-0.0060134423,
0.0034761121,
-0.0639916062,
0.0830967799,
-0.0460042804,
0.0334660783,
0.0477872305,
-0.0191165302,
0.0071551772,
0.0266868994,
0.0329201892,
-0.0035290481,
0.0724434629,
-0.0324982889,
0.0485491157,
0.0648943335,
-0.0170932766,
-0.0067077968,
-0.064884387,
-0.0408416651,
0.022188697,
0.034062583,
0.0323360823,
0.050696183,
0.0037205066,
-0.008255275,
0.0885497555,
0.0492839105,
-0.0175736491,
0.0077898875,
-0.001513504,
0.0107984282,
0.034952648,
0.0055465926,
-0.0414061993,
-0.0148247732,
-0.0150015317,
0.0072691627,
0.0063013276,
-0.0348537676,
-0.0336415656,
-0.0348380506,
-0.0575018413,
0.0024168631,
0.0000367668,
0.0173966661,
0.0709828585,
-0.0209974144,
0.0263851024,
0.0464363843,
0.0343380608,
-0.017158635,
0.0218958594,
-0.0818846375,
0.0062992177,
0.0357737057,
0.0135742733,
-0.0417767428,
0.0162124541,
0.0063101775,
0.0480526015,
0.0488171913,
0.051498834,
-0.0236274283,
-0.0165455304,
-0.023324335,
-0.032757096,
0.0327309109,
0.0114540989,
-0.0176061057,
0.0317218266,
-0.0373452418,
-0.0152202481,
-0.0639349297,
-0.0746205375,
0.079560414,
-0.0013273618,
-0.0509437211,
-0.0009545628,
-0.0051550013,
-0.0099184141,
0.0379163325,
-0.0156244747,
0.0207858719,
0.031158274,
0.0008512711,
0.0279340278,
-0.0422982648,
-0.0080827586,
0.0070628864,
0.0302551202,
-0.0119139347,
-0.0668204501,
0.001693123,
-0.0486562178,
-0.0199673213,
-0.0638773888,
-0.0711023808,
0.00770583,
-0.0245959833,
0.0066323872,
0.0019404945,
-0.0259938594,
-0.0793821737,
0.051856,
-0.0071404781,
0.0081580346,
0.0042387675,
-0.0141131571,
-0.026091801,
-0.0504863523,
-0.0373520628,
0.0461005978,
0.0086632771,
0.0144150499,
0.0033032936,
0.0090275919,
-0.0374747477,
-0.0042567342,
-0.0670994893,
-0.0520563982,
-0.0005823008,
-0.0123223132,
0.0045845434,
-0.0361852646,
-0.0190462731,
-0.0251624119,
-0.0281730294,
-0.0009627562,
0.0068933843,
0.0390918329,
0.0412863009,
0.0089743808,
-0.0457662717,
-0.024477249,
-0.027612675,
-0.0032883005,
0.0017843458,
0.0401878878,
-0.0717473701,
-0.0644138306,
0.0082518384,
-0.0184165034,
0.0108028976,
-0.0009368577,
0.0080381986,
0.0199198313,
0.0225379821,
0.0287203006,
0.0496618114,
-0.0090294201,
0.0523266532,
0.0566615537,
0.0241544917,
-0.0099140154,
-0.0246713553,
-0.0398885272,
-0.0697067678,
-0.0271530859,
-0.0527757406,
0.0193251874,
0.0708620995,
-0.0246477928,
0.0144933993,
-0.0033168655,
-0.0007736521,
-0.0294600334,
-0.0509910323,
-0.0855654329,
-0.0011123318,
-0.0654259548,
0.0419652127,
-0.0242477879,
-0.0860503465,
0.0614963323,
0.0032881917,
-0.007446304,
0.0040213899,
-0.0367344171,
-0.0026600771,
0.0480440073,
0.0306740776,
-0.0006515595,
-0.0176368076,
-0.0312124137,
-0.0215426441,
0.0073422263,
0.0059323185,
-0.0366297401,
0.0541449487,
-0.0879723206,
0.02942756,
0.0177944787,
-0.0161119364,
-0.0362684205,
-0.0139431255,
-0.0440105088,
0.0029310153,
0.0083038304,
0.0193857439,
-0.0383979455,
0.0120396214,
0.0545661338,
0.0395563208,
0.0088557256,
0.0149074141,
-0.015525464,
0.0246211179,
0.0116563272,
0.0243198108,
0.0062826453,
-0.036169067,
-0.0169279985,
0.010569253,
0.0344918743,
0.0013469725,
0.0340563767,
0.0373980328,
0.0584377609,
-0.0152758528,
-0.0379226394,
0.0296995919,
0.0272989497,
-0.0364862792,
0.0032797856,
0.1014446765,
0.0279039331,
-0.0655864477,
0.0027237914,
-0.0050454708,
0.0068733031,
0.0170679055,
0.0051002819,
-0.034898676,
-0.0241668448,
0.0265328102,
0.0469775349,
-0.0202122238,
-0.0352256075,
-0.0040543349,
-0.066506438,
0.0578293316,
0.0177824497,
-0.0720870122,
-0.0053271768,
-0.0414338633,
0.0102951629,
-0.0234547909,
0.0233879667,
0.0060881893,
-0.0252783466,
-0.0169565473,
0.0629664212,
-0.0449965894,
-0.0577444099,
-0.0115643507,
-0.057109978,
0.0763279423,
0.0522732995,
0.0085099628,
-0.0398352854,
-0.06286899,
0.0629068911,
0.0436866134,
0.0114491489,
-0.0218458585,
0.0830187276,
-0.0330459364,
-0.0136954328,
-0.0381503776,
0.0406724587,
-0.0279561188,
-0.0363249891,
-0.034018565,
0.0499128513,
-0.0136334412,
0.0047402424,
0.005564204,
-0.011652085,
-0.0018070948,
0.0782145411,
0.0379355885,
-0.0583401285,
0.0027114195,
-0.0456931703,
0.027045384,
0.0105360756,
-0.0594031326,
0.0529567413,
-0.0953400135,
-0.0870634019,
-0.0457482934,
-0.0579824448,
0.0755942985,
-0.0059594489,
0.0210972242,
0.0095755858,
0.0009697002,
-0.0121969292,
-0.0391552225,
0.0531256758,
-0.0403711461,
0.0084501617,
-0.1176262051,
-0.0764958113,
0.030445572,
-0.0018365935,
-0.0081714848,
0.0430128574,
-0.0322898887,
-0.0648816451,
0.0715552419,
0.0218910947,
0.0252193902,
0.0173635744,
0.0408730023,
-0.0900079161,
0.0354952738,
0.057905443,
0.0126565155,
0.032190159,
0.0043376707,
0.0095018158,
-0.0144852512,
0.0169115327,
-0.0295570865,
0.0462218486,
0.0297959857,
0.014381852,
-0.045568306,
-0.0461471118,
0.0107072638,
0.0260970443,
0.1012558565,
-0.0366934612,
-0.0095098205,
-0.0374257267,
-0.0294133667,
0.0165908318,
-0.0297941137,
-0.0077236444,
-0.0281647909,
0.0153336301,
0.0355218686,
-0.0373076871,
0.0166012142,
-0.0150289023,
0.0448302403,
0.0028199514,
0.0115994653,
-0.0304290224,
0.028000813,
-0.0024446032,
0.032446824,
-0.0026912533,
0.0778687522,
0.0030031577,
0.0441465266,
0.0461605117,
0.0247197878,
0.0156228645,
-0.011657563,
-0.0033268409,
0.0126546314,
-0.0366908163,
-0.0594706647,
-0.0487109795,
0.022428643,
0.0202095248,
-0.0012944432,
0.0359108187,
-0.0275835767,
-0.0474581197,
-0.02837402,
-0.0108374218,
-0.00149211,
-0.0119830016,
0.0375556648,
0.007218603,
-0.0435003042,
-0.0118386531,
0.0514678136,
0.0591087267,
0.0313635245,
-0.0401763581,
-0.0340014435,
-0.018722374,
0.0037137684,
0.0240588672,
-0.0340675041,
-0.0211782306,
-0.0031321654,
-0.0616758801,
-0.0592960082,
0.0108194966,
0.0177228544,
-0.0002081093,
-0.0200242493,
0.0426745266,
0.0423733667,
-0.015539661,
-0.0279163718,
-0.0565642528,
0.0472958758,
0.027650794,
-0.0291657541,
0.0016496846,
-5.615843446e-33,
-0.03442996,
-0.0536405109,
0.0113397175,
0.0054936046,
-0.0016838318,
0.0028348609,
-0.0035243474,
0.0522862226,
0.0196353719,
0.0394761972,
-0.0038543099,
-0.0209552571,
0.0315944664,
-0.0125806816,
0.0340296254,
-0.0262729637,
0.0262898915,
-0.0420418084,
0.0042275293,
-0.0138040278,
-0.0067413095,
0.0160426889,
0.0788277239,
-0.0916746482,
0.0839297324,
0.0066583282,
0.0190163739,
0.0293269977,
0.0123450821,
0.0333607458,
-0.0375504829,
0.0405415073,
0.0408168323,
-0.0204089917,
-0.0084575657,
0.0379399434,
-0.0815589577,
-0.0038180125,
0.0147803845,
0.0332497805,
-0.0329409838,
-0.038385652,
0.0510781482,
-0.0187404435,
-0.0551051274,
0.044244267,
0.0406585708,
-0.0373834707,
-0.0475292839,
0.0050973152,
-0.0354561917,
0.0333007053,
0.0292808451,
0.0169142,
0.0606433041,
-0.0021200688,
-0.032819666,
0.0281005781,
-0.0698108748,
0.027959777,
0.0304243397,
0.0131760305,
0.0746843889,
0.0713311136,
0.0010686503,
0.0310088228,
0.0767207444,
0.0137765836,
-0.0033691982,
-0.030813124,
0.0312851369,
0.0187460314,
0.0248810835,
0.0279913377,
-0.0049753939,
-0.0079757608,
-0.0212536566,
0.0211478658,
-0.0445172228,
-0.0250432584,
0.0056631039,
0.0240913518,
-0.0575348213,
-0.0324231498,
-0.0221586637,
-0.0151117397,
-0.0193507038,
0.0272841826,
0.0071976632,
-0.0120161586,
-0.0374163724,
0.0036945934,
0.0098482082,
-0.0228662658,
-0.0283883326,
-0.0710127056,
0.0304795764,
0.0622887053,
-0.0075338786,
-0.0263101514,
-0.0813966691,
-0.0452188626,
-0.0204471126,
0.0223898385,
0.0406895317,
-0.0129850172,
0.0430502631,
0.0045729442,
-0.0374679752,
0.005176926,
-0.0195174422,
-0.0011561676,
0.0354724824,
-0.0107624764,
0.0503126532,
-0.0023812864,
0.0096995635,
0.0597536154,
0.0293989778,
-0.0255214833,
-0.0034906459,
-0.0129104415,
-0.020002611,
0.0006481393,
-0.0138003128,
0.016056275,
-0.0075269039,
0.0243699811,
0.0511937365,
-0.0230540317,
0.011825799,
-0.0060924948,
2.305e-7,
0.0650446787,
0.0764350817,
0.0350864604,
0.0056625572,
0.0114787491,
0.035910286,
-0.0103065008,
-0.0002018819,
0.0087847654,
-0.0348378196,
0.031789571,
0.010281588,
0.058068227,
0.0080232564,
-0.0479346886,
-0.0187596325,
-0.0509564653,
0.024501415,
-0.0480683222,
0.0315704569,
0.0320696756,
0.0732277706,
0.0200764779,
-0.0238315277,
-0.0361581445,
-0.0408226289,
0.0346724205,
-0.0991047844,
0.02480972,
0.0160086267,
0.0631323382,
0.0348462984,
-0.0148082199,
0.045660954,
-0.0004632402,
-0.0181220304,
0.0412012003,
0.0690894797,
-0.018493047,
0.0113326218,
-0.023954168,
-0.0028100195,
0.0037442078,
-0.0318833254,
0.0423253998,
-0.0610651337,
-0.0203087647,
0.0071503613,
0.004963438,
-0.0116167096,
0.0114853345,
-0.0338013843,
-0.0003416698,
0.0261516199,
0.0283696447,
-0.0174608845,
-0.02336099,
-0.0497579463,
0.0010265004,
0.0211202335,
-0.0538911074,
-0.048534289,
-0.0112395985,
0.0096813533,
-0.0200850144,
-0.053175468,
0.0042291232,
1.600424194e-34,
0.0012168178,
0.0016252648,
0.0025084638,
0.0203857515,
0.0143075688,
0.021115981,
-0.0297149122,
0.029129304,
-0.0214413069,
-0.0891698077,
0.0295940768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10530v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10530v1 | Gender Bias in Transformer Models: A comprehensive survey | 2023-06-18T11:40:47 | 2023-06-18T11:40:47 | Praneeth Nemani, Yericherla Deepak Joel, Palla Vijay, Farhana Ferdousi Liza | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Gender bias in artificial intelligence (AI) has emerged as a pressing concern
with profound implications for individuals' lives. This paper presents a
comprehensive survey that explores gender bias in Transformer models from a
linguistic perspective. While the existence of gender bias in language models
has been acknowledged in previous studies, there remains a lack of consensus on
how to effectively measure and evaluate this bias. Our survey critically
examines the existing literature on gender bias in Transformers, shedding light
on the diverse methodologies and metrics employed to assess bias. Several
limitations in current approaches to measuring gender bias in Transformers are
identified, encompassing the utilization of incomplete or flawed metrics,
inadequate dataset sizes, and a dearth of standardization in evaluation
methods. Furthermore, our survey delves into the potential ramifications of
gender bias in Transformers for downstream applications, including dialogue
systems and machine translation. We underscore the importance of fostering
equity and fairness in these systems by emphasizing the need for heightened
awareness and accountability in developing and deploying language technologies.
This paper serves as a comprehensive overview of gender bias in Transformer
models, providing novel insights and offering valuable directions for future
research in this critical domain. | [
0.0492329597,
0.0712601021,
-0.0490933582,
0.0206528232,
-0.0167418495,
0.0138158984,
0.0623174906,
-0.039104782,
-0.0148802754,
-0.0576781705,
-0.0048550139,
-0.0290185604,
0.0326127112,
-0.0011848902,
0.0183681697,
-0.0453209355,
0.0123760104,
0.029241452,
0.0104963109,
-0.0221473146,
-0.0053123962,
0.0446402244,
0.013426492,
0.0863784924,
-0.0021015676,
-0.0236248355,
0.0373541489,
0.0185916256,
-0.0064188763,
0.0261304602,
0.0283445902,
0.0383613966,
-0.0188587867,
0.0287967995,
0.0000020624,
-0.0982458666,
-0.00127828,
0.024659073,
-0.0246102307,
-0.0376878381,
0.0067515126,
-0.021502994,
-0.0321534239,
0.037410479,
-0.0464103632,
0.0093332473,
0.0456905663,
0.0319435,
0.0423351191,
0.0044699227,
-0.0205356032,
0.0211704094,
-0.022214409,
-0.0059080236,
-0.0348471813,
0.0001705393,
-0.00379998,
-0.0282021798,
-0.0385039113,
-0.0197322071,
-0.0355626158,
0.0216645766,
0.0150738358,
-0.0141432937,
-0.0365720093,
0.020774655,
-0.0382508561,
-0.0594678372,
-0.0187800061,
0.021340996,
0.0273130182,
0.0285058077,
-0.008956857,
0.0038486165,
0.0290248487,
0.0172363706,
-0.0453333408,
0.0419292711,
-0.0034712653,
-0.0353609435,
-0.0062873918,
-0.0139028262,
0.000845719,
0.0391282775,
-0.0382878259,
0.1134045124,
0.0020994421,
-0.043486651,
0.0048683728,
0.0037513676,
0.0112951072,
-0.0503672957,
0.014204341,
0.0006811372,
-0.0184918791,
0.000435223,
0.0020584243,
-0.0414488241,
0.0201000907,
-0.0449795835,
-0.0030812516,
0.0558701493,
0.0377168208,
-0.0108951703,
0.0053403918,
0.0694563016,
0.0037721936,
0.0299454406,
-0.045805499,
-0.0556348674,
-0.0302374605,
-0.0380740836,
-0.0337972455,
-0.0089771189,
-0.0255307462,
0.0180762,
-0.0283769164,
0.0180800818,
-0.044135537,
-0.0205918048,
0.0280837081,
0.0188111495,
-0.0141155496,
0.0056640282,
0.0012803724,
0.0348972306,
-0.06155359,
0.0275524389,
-0.0059845294,
-0.1185337752,
-0.0008885972,
0.0038480312,
-0.0191091746,
-0.0368439443,
-0.008901909,
0.030899059,
0.0082400199,
-0.0478156842,
0.0203456935,
-0.0139345815,
-0.0265226047,
-0.0530677587,
0.010293249,
-0.054230541,
0.0151163675,
0.0794986561,
0.0237777997,
-0.0208122041,
-0.0038272038,
0.0127878375,
-0.0080795698,
0.0298776049,
0.0717288181,
0.0310179293,
0.0746207759,
0.0104710674,
-0.0244254414,
0.0713297725,
0.0896321535,
-0.0081024487,
0.0346562564,
-0.0107287038,
-0.0024225526,
0.027548939,
0.0004445689,
0.0301426407,
-0.0075032748,
0.0229475982,
-0.0431956947,
0.0252813138,
0.0552109629,
0.0268294495,
0.0221071821,
0.0079401787,
0.0675197095,
0.0939590409,
0.0455253832,
0.0713089257,
0.0209970511,
-0.0061911959,
-0.0126224747,
0.0061946949,
-0.0459529907,
0.0083276089,
0.0058801924,
-0.0328269154,
-0.0261467546,
0.0415757746,
-0.0055154539,
-0.060543973,
-0.0018112385,
0.0137293432,
0.0307644606,
0.0149195651,
0.0165787302,
0.0550917089,
0.001676682,
0.0687418878,
-0.011108662,
-0.0767230541,
-0.0296026412,
-0.0779204592,
-0.0236414187,
0.0374660231,
0.0085368492,
-0.0016265565,
-0.0058090962,
-0.0421989411,
-0.0431940891,
0.0468997769,
0.0411180109,
0.0274768025,
-0.0153928995,
-0.0345377363,
-0.0236503761,
0.0456493646,
0.0150609659,
0.0116125876,
0.0079530422,
0.0559924506,
0.0032051513,
-0.0279434249,
-0.0458293483,
0.0185670238,
-0.0095295878,
-0.0074834535,
0.0302849058,
0.0170458406,
0.0050563132,
0.0098439278,
-0.0306054465,
0.0151139107,
0.001866073,
-0.0181742851,
-0.0368641056,
0.0577824079,
-0.0191828087,
0.0521755405,
0.0025496788,
-0.0819570422,
-0.0490029044,
0.0592499636,
0.0271437112,
-0.0028165812,
0.051053822,
-0.0603718944,
-0.0099559613,
-0.0147574712,
0.0311260987,
-0.0174849927,
0.037292473,
-0.0396679491,
-0.0094655426,
-0.0517712981,
-0.049166888,
0.0145324785,
-0.0332459249,
-0.0090193842,
-0.0700499639,
-0.0554091111,
0.047118023,
-0.0055297995,
0.0206942838,
0.0384842306,
-0.0251332503,
-0.0206254907,
-0.0610518195,
-0.079698205,
-0.0251031294,
-0.0080443285,
-0.004867631,
-0.0264417157,
0.0351293497,
-0.0317591354,
0.0006054888,
0.004054823,
-0.022371443,
0.0214201938,
0.0375049412,
0.0277332105,
-0.0139235184,
-0.0086290054,
-0.0224089324,
-0.0373864584,
-0.0443036035,
0.0516185574,
0.042879615,
0.0091808494,
-0.0565629415,
-0.0180492569,
-0.0089161796,
-0.026414372,
-0.0139234373,
-0.0331267603,
0.0388777554,
0.0441068485,
0.0685902387,
0.0805839971,
0.0496602915,
0.0295783672,
0.030909067,
0.0004575418,
-0.0556793846,
-0.0175440088,
0.0185561851,
0.0110914037,
0.0103798108,
-0.07077948,
0.0119652012,
0.0323565416,
0.004079015,
-0.0140990838,
-0.0388202518,
0.0681760386,
-0.051973369,
-0.0566945598,
-0.0002097413,
-0.0287262518,
0.0071074711,
0.0436309166,
-0.0216637757,
-0.0403836034,
0.029709341,
-0.008728764,
-0.0001967377,
-0.0229435861,
-0.0209380668,
-0.0553606674,
0.0351355188,
-0.0481247343,
0.0117584206,
0.0168304276,
-0.0169119071,
-0.0858147889,
-0.0285196844,
-0.0016769948,
-0.0311588924,
0.0684721619,
-0.020082593,
0.0018175892,
0.0000995075,
-0.0468441248,
-0.0387881324,
-0.0040070619,
-0.0030986369,
0.0271309502,
0.048330497,
-0.0119504901,
-0.0372713134,
0.0451621301,
-0.002843678,
0.0483761877,
0.0029638556,
-0.0252324603,
-0.0214393418,
-0.0407103933,
0.0322349966,
0.0358867757,
0.0639013276,
-0.0003285102,
0.0237096529,
0.0209915396,
-0.0076042693,
0.0088950247,
0.0021543081,
0.0122557366,
0.0525818579,
-0.0555504151,
-0.0061994065,
-0.0204519369,
0.0086123776,
-0.0599836186,
0.0145424232,
0.0931142867,
0.0104344096,
-0.0564486794,
0.0073477225,
-0.0453980863,
0.0145284245,
0.0412391499,
0.0143774096,
-0.0655023158,
0.0295768641,
0.0374087431,
0.0077839871,
-0.0463181026,
-0.0352576002,
-0.0200807601,
-0.1001388058,
-0.0001348894,
-0.0125430655,
-0.044994738,
-0.0536481068,
-0.0007467617,
-0.0218359083,
-0.0203194469,
0.0633412749,
-0.0117979823,
-0.0075108977,
-0.0182012413,
-0.0112121925,
-0.0449296124,
-0.0085808393,
0.0308895223,
-0.0801217854,
0.03953024,
0.0589316487,
0.0527463779,
-0.0178736392,
-0.0013492313,
-0.0130351083,
0.0085336464,
0.0026848631,
-0.0128848078,
-0.0069879987,
-0.0276383758,
-0.0097564524,
-0.0573493317,
0.0017507315,
0.0351290889,
0.0216653626,
0.0159505475,
0.024403993,
-0.0118111875,
-0.0298052859,
-0.0650299042,
-0.0233267192,
0.0215805192,
0.0546832532,
0.0086454805,
-0.045341555,
-0.0567905717,
-0.0359591246,
0.0141763501,
0.0415507928,
-0.0895032138,
0.0036289927,
0.0570357777,
-0.0443009213,
-0.0292102471,
-0.0632438138,
-0.005492568,
-0.0066646379,
0.0103326607,
-0.0747760162,
0.0367198326,
0.0177995302,
-0.0592339225,
0.0203483384,
0.0061540138,
0.0257583093,
-0.0221520495,
-0.0135180745,
-0.0329653248,
-0.0448836014,
-0.0026358326,
0.0132196536,
-0.019537095,
-0.0211543515,
0.058319211,
0.0541201718,
0.0314076096,
0.0123764994,
0.0060057114,
-0.0433384404,
0.0140704829,
0.0257105622,
-0.010244811,
0.0339107066,
0.055106543,
0.0128329434,
0.0068701752,
0.0402265191,
-0.035876371,
0.0260482859,
-0.0244860444,
0.0278857723,
-0.0352631696,
-0.0618554391,
0.0228215586,
0.0019236136,
0.0099446215,
-0.0311589595,
0.0261788145,
-0.0316287465,
0.0014578017,
-0.0216922369,
-0.033692088,
-0.0263306517,
-0.0511947088,
0.0204390027,
0.0425954014,
0.0065018986,
0.0152895367,
-0.0540736057,
-0.0225749165,
-0.0129551915,
0.0370279923,
-0.0016575089,
0.0540398434,
-0.0259206798,
0.0166974533,
0.0254502073,
-0.0119739361,
-0.0035347342,
0.0396463349,
0.0391381569,
0.046356488,
-0.0019837082,
0.0173074715,
-0.0346286334,
0.0415994637,
-0.0559069924,
-0.0249706861,
0.0212773532,
0.0066687372,
0.0003481704,
-0.0156285428,
0.0711811557,
-0.0092507834,
0.0098231472,
0.0110380324,
-0.0074727805,
0.020772947,
0.0277097411,
0.0110979853,
0.0129542751,
0.0160170011,
-0.0139802694,
0.01714403,
0.0071778693,
0.0542229302,
-0.0464173481,
-0.0357445292,
-0.0112909405,
-0.0525369532,
-0.004855196,
-0.0852967203,
-0.014615926,
-0.014677085,
-0.1018624976,
-0.0484341495,
0.0058257519,
-0.024468679,
0.0427271277,
-0.0368577763,
-0.0084848097,
0.0653489381,
-0.0162337963,
-0.0743159279,
-0.036698781,
-0.0207566395,
-0.0141584277,
0.0013822808,
-0.0182408392,
-6.05401521e-33,
-0.0297389906,
-0.0579015687,
0.0174992643,
0.0137169762,
-0.0328927375,
-0.0043772045,
-0.0020088425,
0.0182523504,
-0.0293072797,
0.0245928075,
-0.023234807,
0.0453391448,
0.0095457807,
-0.0146084223,
0.0261011031,
0.0149647947,
0.057245817,
0.0279808566,
-0.0395530052,
-0.0467890836,
-0.0156099871,
0.0032617457,
0.0191268101,
-0.0682969838,
0.1077769175,
-0.0156555753,
0.0046980199,
-0.0013284258,
-0.0333988219,
0.0266015101,
0.0236047246,
0.0674086735,
0.0244411733,
-0.0689305887,
0.0153660458,
0.0828796998,
-0.0598257668,
0.0008023544,
-0.0034798863,
0.064186044,
0.0468772091,
-0.0307233147,
0.0337756313,
0.033183068,
-0.0708992183,
-0.0413069166,
0.0577897318,
0.020039266,
0.0744568855,
0.0207591131,
-0.0631899014,
0.001032208,
-0.0657254606,
-0.0117941685,
0.0262880381,
0.0514145531,
-0.0058596279,
0.0053239302,
-0.0786380395,
0.0487698838,
-0.0220615566,
-0.0225014444,
0.0682985783,
0.0026580943,
0.0136083914,
0.0010585466,
0.0733622462,
0.0450020172,
-0.0402986556,
-0.0815151259,
0.0390431434,
-0.0060705333,
0.0419919863,
0.0192030426,
0.0203249454,
0.0251480546,
-0.0273998138,
-0.0437416956,
0.0187168755,
0.0525219925,
0.032880675,
-0.0151442848,
-0.0888103545,
-0.0294791088,
-0.0310273934,
-0.059451662,
-0.0097370241,
-0.0168998968,
0.0159683004,
-0.0065147593,
-0.0418799482,
0.0089253318,
0.0077789999,
-0.0842080489,
-0.003185306,
-0.0036871806,
-0.0130093554,
-0.0287780054,
0.0285210405,
0.0066749081,
-0.0334041826,
0.0199659895,
0.0279778186,
0.0574172996,
0.0332851037,
0.028073648,
-0.0265155099,
0.0045340201,
-0.0537890755,
-0.027617503,
-0.0113895088,
0.014314889,
-0.0145942736,
0.0237423517,
0.0040096538,
0.0419027284,
-0.0108243478,
-0.0059022079,
0.0379060432,
0.0374693722,
-0.0482217595,
0.0180035997,
-0.0164142083,
0.0151347024,
-0.0189609881,
-0.0034428467,
-0.0229289643,
0.0507957861,
0.0393861122,
-0.043693807,
-0.0203565396,
-0.0424484052,
2.704e-7,
0.0015063151,
0.0586437657,
0.0296277963,
0.0453122035,
0.0056226784,
0.026639685,
0.0243877694,
0.0398386419,
0.0833507106,
0.0431869403,
-0.0290054232,
0.0422511399,
0.0077119661,
0.0374712087,
-0.063667357,
-0.0275650453,
-0.090500623,
0.0239431523,
0.0097862361,
0.0340248682,
0.004564127,
0.046247866,
0.0201471802,
-0.0075039575,
-0.0407461971,
0.0077767591,
0.0056028306,
-0.0171612035,
0.038914986,
0.0453566462,
0.0137992427,
0.0164893009,
0.0317594111,
0.0561092384,
0.0416512564,
0.026359437,
0.0189430267,
0.0040298533,
-0.0269690044,
0.0070331423,
-0.0021525407,
-0.0131287295,
-0.0175232533,
-0.0549263954,
0.034307085,
-0.0214226171,
-0.0457468927,
-0.0208038036,
-0.0021353948,
0.0079533299,
0.0970553085,
-0.0218692254,
-0.0162194185,
0.0222564042,
0.0351335406,
0.0075194002,
0.0238478053,
-0.0396630913,
-0.0167466905,
-0.0393483117,
-0.0006324358,
-0.0687963814,
-0.0166056659,
0.017362399,
0.0131580494,
-0.0101382146,
0.0102350246,
2.147848584e-34,
-0.0260077957,
0.0478113443,
0.0291424692,
0.0328888893,
0.0253085047,
-0.0016688098,
0.0251689609,
-0.0027786645,
0.0487279035,
-0.0077130753,
-0.0176118948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10514v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10514v1 | Evolutionary Verbalizer Search for Prompt-based Few Shot Text Classification | 2023-06-18T10:03:11 | 2023-06-18T10:03:11 | Tongtao Ling, Lei Chen, Yutao Lai, Hai-Lin Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances for few-shot text classification aim to wrap textual inputs
with task-specific prompts to cloze questions. By processing them with a masked
language model to predict the masked tokens and using a verbalizer that
constructs the mapping between predicted words and target labels. This approach
of using pre-trained language models is called prompt-based tuning, which could
remarkably outperform conventional fine-tuning approach in the low-data
scenario. As the core of prompt-based tuning, the verbalizer is usually
handcrafted with human efforts or suboptimally searched by gradient descent. In
this paper, we focus on automatically constructing the optimal verbalizer and
propose a novel evolutionary verbalizer search (EVS) algorithm, to improve
prompt-based tuning with the high-performance verbalizer. Specifically,
inspired by evolutionary algorithm (EA), we utilize it to automatically evolve
various verbalizers during the evolutionary procedure and select the best one
after several iterations. Extensive few-shot experiments on five text
classification datasets show the effectiveness of our method. | [
0.0567751378,
0.0362315029,
-0.0152855078,
0.0072477181,
-0.033743605,
0.0100001441,
0.0551309809,
0.0394647978,
-0.0028199661,
-0.0551382191,
-0.0361452475,
0.0021394808,
-0.0367250741,
0.0236634929,
-0.0009481918,
-0.0253956262,
0.0580161512,
-0.0061763604,
-0.0033302787,
0.0213396121,
0.0007173753,
-0.0100710578,
0.0162915476,
0.0235868823,
0.0541315712,
0.0267273597,
-0.0107150851,
0.0062804758,
0.0014195603,
-0.0356068499,
0.03362564,
0.0471255668,
0.0167728215,
0.0607448928,
0.0000019426,
-0.0890137479,
-0.0374316461,
-0.0222540814,
-0.055874873,
-0.0325236768,
0.0573125184,
0.005672398,
0.0257926602,
-0.0008211089,
-0.0286101401,
-0.0354290418,
0.0316749103,
0.0098527474,
0.0517649315,
0.0908861682,
0.0080036838,
-0.054044839,
0.0098191947,
-0.0007505449,
0.0248340555,
-0.0511667542,
0.0432239175,
-0.0582588464,
0.0235005971,
0.04737138,
-0.0172968935,
0.0257766284,
-0.0230913404,
-0.015433548,
0.0250542592,
0.0015222121,
0.0120955138,
-0.0321400687,
-0.0049657403,
0.0395028479,
-0.0384244882,
-0.0540828221,
0.0182004217,
-0.0319618769,
0.0225838423,
-0.0317471735,
0.0039015564,
-0.0046678497,
-0.0271658245,
-0.0024543758,
-0.0036814061,
0.0259002298,
-0.0296808276,
0.0064068376,
-0.0053499723,
0.0208376609,
-0.0049506822,
-0.0355106294,
-0.0314350948,
-0.052907072,
-0.0541925542,
-0.0669972971,
0.0086083068,
0.0351049677,
-0.0255217608,
-0.0159818642,
-0.0756921694,
-0.0919513777,
0.0185313504,
0.042422168,
0.0396331735,
0.031357076,
0.0241036862,
0.0400948897,
-0.0410861336,
0.0249417983,
0.0368929021,
-0.0007979958,
-0.0579414368,
-0.0041434639,
-0.069607012,
-0.0148251122,
-0.0505793057,
0.0686774999,
-0.0172157548,
-0.0037089561,
-0.0132584097,
0.0211748891,
0.0480973832,
-0.0196891353,
-0.0330472551,
-0.001163856,
0.0021959082,
0.0167947765,
-0.0258579031,
-0.0332937166,
-0.0273983106,
0.0029492392,
-0.0012186287,
0.0212030783,
-0.0004542334,
0.0137624852,
0.0411792696,
-0.0109644597,
0.0185299795,
0.0249887332,
-0.0206151139,
-0.0756656826,
-0.0306975469,
0.0138663845,
-0.0371414237,
0.0153495437,
-0.0268852375,
0.0122626657,
0.0292681884,
-0.0161897074,
-0.037438415,
-0.0164859202,
0.0017216948,
0.0136843678,
-0.0038089957,
0.0798385888,
-0.0209657326,
-0.0212673526,
0.1104885936,
-0.0195733085,
-0.0163446069,
0.0458812863,
-0.0170112997,
0.0147345848,
0.0321315564,
-0.0103349723,
0.0230720378,
0.0032845598,
-0.0002962964,
-0.0111845266,
0.0354845785,
0.0292731728,
0.0422139056,
0.0313691273,
0.0108630937,
0.0279104244,
-0.0379717052,
-0.0107920477,
0.0158812124,
0.0600308366,
0.0342575535,
0.0115996152,
0.0427180268,
0.0633952692,
-0.0429450646,
-0.0185945071,
0.0166405383,
0.0008749493,
-0.0717389509,
-0.0388543345,
0.0234326422,
-0.0105555207,
-0.0236837938,
-0.0552317314,
0.0028067119,
0.0276062824,
0.0026354012,
-0.0166718252,
0.023794584,
0.0084884642,
-0.0585196279,
-0.0241880491,
0.0155460043,
-0.019468721,
-0.0333266743,
-0.0721066296,
0.0555475615,
0.0303227603,
0.033407677,
-0.020290019,
-0.0174464602,
-0.0349084325,
0.0536265261,
0.04418898,
0.0465192273,
-0.0183881,
-0.029974062,
-0.0362708122,
-0.0342875794,
-0.0179977603,
0.0022035067,
-0.0066432045,
-0.026540583,
0.0189214777,
0.030371435,
0.0619140454,
-0.0250913892,
0.0596479587,
-0.0013236704,
-0.0612345748,
0.0641218424,
0.0111750662,
0.0147343613,
-0.0172531754,
-0.0215094984,
-0.004202934,
-0.0194756165,
-0.0263786037,
-0.024054544,
-0.0308087897,
0.0056952843,
-0.0645318031,
-0.0037991342,
0.0129730469,
0.0233757179,
-0.0154583706,
-0.0437006988,
-0.0274629854,
-0.0231125653,
-0.0447295345,
0.0299084298,
-0.0402062908,
0.0440263338,
-0.0644578934,
-0.0162985455,
-0.0851176977,
0.0526798069,
0.0469639301,
0.0056571765,
-0.0134315863,
0.0202467851,
0.0549947098,
-0.0282119587,
-0.0307706296,
-0.0432230681,
-0.0200443529,
-0.0070692669,
0.0537015833,
0.0497394986,
-0.025411142,
-0.0267183855,
-0.0974585265,
0.0338545255,
-0.0009977379,
0.0171951372,
0.0198841691,
-0.0079116886,
-0.0111145284,
-0.0105457222,
-0.0355159007,
0.014718649,
-0.0218700022,
-0.0370679609,
0.0536718033,
-0.0015021401,
-0.001853899,
-0.0115118735,
0.013903874,
-0.0306178704,
0.0497797914,
0.0247843321,
-0.0425837412,
-0.0784033462,
0.0288809855,
0.0166073814,
0.0023560475,
0.0153366458,
-0.019638719,
-0.011744827,
0.0045815166,
-0.0110561838,
0.0828251615,
0.043494273,
-0.0190435257,
0.0052830861,
0.0618040413,
-0.0304337759,
0.0298006739,
-0.0195722915,
-0.0115093933,
0.001000425,
-0.009820235,
0.0709446669,
0.0619717054,
-0.0052919891,
-0.0186999924,
-0.0731163397,
0.0658628866,
-0.0118987253,
-0.0031276313,
-0.04656386,
-0.0063003772,
-0.0117463125,
0.0113643948,
-0.0221311878,
-0.0155258318,
0.0861803889,
0.0158248469,
0.0153728435,
-0.0831758678,
-0.0137288459,
-0.0396636203,
0.031302087,
0.004112469,
0.0185465608,
0.0608391427,
-0.0022859855,
-0.0505561754,
-0.0080919378,
0.0244828463,
0.0101044653,
-0.0089496849,
-0.0213976316,
0.0024806452,
-0.0179317351,
-0.085737206,
-0.0164122991,
-0.0869388059,
-0.0103214364,
-0.001727521,
0.0526927896,
0.0135677578,
-0.0420328602,
0.0242350716,
-0.0041415677,
0.0726917759,
-0.0291249044,
-0.0143148182,
-0.0350278318,
0.0346172526,
0.0732266903,
0.0250875186,
-0.0205231197,
-0.0040091882,
0.0853807703,
0.0140782017,
0.0259491093,
0.0137520088,
0.0065059937,
0.0068623479,
0.0347290486,
-0.0582956225,
-0.0337471552,
-0.0129204784,
0.0507995449,
-0.0382229313,
0.0093975933,
0.1040948257,
0.0414747,
-0.0291587636,
-0.0161268767,
-0.0458898544,
0.0102408649,
0.0378613062,
0.072877422,
-0.0620922334,
-0.0676615015,
-0.0162374824,
0.0423565768,
-0.0376756042,
-0.0278585441,
-0.0032595212,
-0.1101625413,
0.0092636403,
-0.0074875928,
-0.0351589546,
0.0455107465,
-0.0251362361,
0.0171342194,
0.0001283085,
-0.0154718589,
0.0120522678,
0.0167228859,
-0.0073328242,
0.0027426071,
-0.0178650003,
-0.035010267,
0.037393108,
-0.0211598556,
0.0178651195,
0.0556730069,
0.0016020056,
0.0021389015,
-0.0220375955,
0.0442304984,
-0.0183278881,
0.0092678471,
-0.0239867177,
0.0322576948,
-0.0406522118,
0.0107444022,
-0.0009383981,
0.0369574279,
0.0168847423,
-0.0021897568,
0.038859196,
0.0255834945,
-0.0084179537,
-0.0243965611,
-0.040716555,
-0.0366431735,
0.0057459702,
0.0714369714,
0.0262284651,
-0.1155829951,
-0.0449425131,
-0.0169891492,
-0.0180066712,
-0.0983978435,
-0.0333699882,
-0.0225828104,
-0.0063146302,
-0.0191016253,
-0.0714551583,
0.0280124098,
0.059948165,
0.0443754867,
0.0130493436,
-0.0179333482,
-0.030251516,
-0.0168398675,
-0.0426706932,
-0.0014776756,
0.0109722726,
-0.0116459634,
-0.0834346414,
-0.0039105816,
0.0795224831,
-0.0686197579,
-0.0238977373,
0.0085823005,
-0.0684728846,
-0.0360024348,
-0.0401909724,
0.0598776266,
0.0072966693,
0.0307372008,
-0.0245698597,
-0.0923527926,
0.1072148085,
0.0589494631,
-0.0097034117,
0.0012435596,
0.0008584827,
0.0281658787,
-0.0453942828,
0.0019221408,
-0.0274224207,
0.0280590206,
0.0313654132,
0.002345945,
-0.0204565898,
0.012540332,
0.0170174837,
0.0282406788,
0.0604797304,
-0.032227084,
-0.0471731424,
-0.0118726501,
0.0182798095,
0.0240396392,
-0.0470658094,
-0.0141337244,
-0.0084293652,
-0.0046522608,
-0.0349247269,
-0.0114215156,
0.0099174622,
-0.0236891136,
0.0646528825,
-0.0412832312,
0.0110504171,
0.0114397909,
0.0587659143,
0.0197603628,
-0.0118202092,
-0.0007674305,
0.0166732706,
0.0295065064,
0.027258845,
-0.0404392295,
0.0615631752,
0.0240386538,
-0.0047833077,
-0.0154075809,
0.0574326888,
-0.0555149056,
-0.005568516,
-0.0566854663,
-0.0206420235,
0.0166421514,
0.0128273154,
-0.0429925062,
0.0307752825,
-0.0440916084,
-0.0013549057,
0.0041444963,
-0.0179245453,
-0.0358328447,
0.0132585531,
0.0147731723,
-0.047593981,
0.0005910414,
0.0447082631,
0.0040468695,
0.0278352946,
0.0138337659,
0.0033671001,
-0.0713238642,
0.0487703942,
0.030559415,
0.0592247061,
0.0173648652,
0.0193312131,
-0.0308324248,
0.0015451112,
0.0403413177,
0.0004777858,
-0.0281091984,
0.030040415,
0.035813611,
0.0131459879,
-0.029159829,
-0.0344949476,
-0.0311906543,
0.0011213904,
0.0255186614,
-0.0166338589,
-0.0072754649,
-5.601976286e-33,
0.0059323623,
-0.0236246549,
0.0102461874,
0.0404811166,
0.0290708616,
-0.0257196389,
-0.0081093181,
0.0081710657,
-0.0182767808,
-0.0448408537,
-0.0015041509,
-0.0178793333,
-0.0102058034,
0.0243465044,
-0.003939731,
-0.0190501586,
0.0163797531,
-0.043685142,
-0.0370657817,
0.0076426296,
-0.0028067001,
0.0531827956,
-0.0021706892,
-0.0078159813,
-0.01745129,
0.0340458937,
0.002673612,
0.0291472822,
0.0220661554,
0.0570581481,
-0.0074955123,
0.0416119955,
0.0093574096,
-0.0243499298,
0.0092662266,
0.040040154,
-0.0576905236,
-0.0502033494,
-0.0492351502,
-0.0142303826,
-0.0251180883,
-0.0798484907,
-0.001356843,
-0.009849906,
-0.0222225804,
0.0340620838,
0.0520450398,
-0.0178990494,
-0.0033936892,
-0.0484645255,
-0.0113596926,
0.0146359038,
-0.0161369983,
-0.0288363919,
0.0126152346,
0.0487014279,
0.0189561658,
0.0301397648,
-0.0523410663,
0.0267884899,
0.0040186029,
-0.0022860174,
0.0149455443,
0.0385243446,
0.0211665798,
0.0430778749,
0.0427223183,
0.0200965684,
0.0018903083,
0.0052140756,
0.0314046852,
0.0078836484,
0.0369805805,
0.0364278182,
0.0312549546,
-0.023339279,
-0.0558422543,
0.0287467912,
0.0252437629,
-0.028579643,
0.0194697417,
0.0396212116,
-0.0113846632,
-0.0369185135,
-0.0331854597,
-0.0292746872,
-0.0492296182,
0.0262051318,
0.033909373,
0.022746291,
-0.0297593549,
-0.0025448576,
0.0405159444,
-0.0233650785,
0.0132070687,
-0.0263131056,
-0.0196152292,
0.004707051,
0.030397512,
0.0170180984,
-0.0274518337,
-0.0529419333,
0.0259965844,
0.0011700221,
0.0296511911,
0.004024236,
0.0262069702,
0.0169641245,
-0.0678636581,
0.0040053935,
0.0235111099,
0.015277124,
0.0009067561,
0.035217654,
-0.0131393904,
0.0508997217,
0.0105706174,
0.0354502462,
0.0669889376,
-0.0228444841,
-0.0378463976,
0.029080892,
-0.0140753398,
0.0080602393,
0.0129458588,
0.0266380981,
0.0441302694,
0.0482051186,
-0.0138257137,
-0.0498555079,
0.0032396922,
0.0310618896,
2.724e-7,
0.0515407622,
0.0703506097,
-0.0316923112,
-0.0166972131,
0.0076437425,
0.0616542399,
0.0166933853,
0.0107622882,
-0.0186740514,
-0.0153810363,
0.0105076237,
-0.0249629281,
0.0328041539,
-0.00508988,
-0.1108133495,
0.0164821856,
-0.0228094719,
0.032864809,
-0.0627465695,
0.035716828,
0.091880247,
0.0926947296,
0.0251824837,
0.0028816964,
-0.0083708409,
-0.0358383991,
0.0250508972,
0.0022116823,
0.0277329925,
0.0470587611,
-0.0029298586,
-0.0078821741,
-0.0219109021,
0.0447841473,
-0.0429332815,
0.0493231416,
-0.0170198008,
0.0458906405,
0.0072515514,
-0.0419711955,
0.0211817287,
0.0410767011,
0.0046599112,
-0.0383925401,
0.1156586409,
-0.0678182989,
0.0006642976,
-0.0106466422,
-0.0195306297,
-0.0089722704,
-0.0133801205,
-0.040237546,
-0.0168852974,
0.0253490657,
0.0404985137,
0.0085338065,
-0.0164083336,
-0.110676229,
0.008240981,
-0.0024737159,
-0.0473554321,
-0.0342185237,
-0.0465550609,
0.027278088,
0.0624020323,
-0.0663227588,
0.0320667773,
2.440168774e-34,
0.0118078915,
-0.0285485424,
0.0114864027,
0.0014835879,
0.0224271286,
0.0227073152,
0.0108249523,
0.0193318557,
0.0749450028,
-0.0845784843,
-0.0005799746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10512v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10512v2 | Efficiently Measuring the Cognitive Ability of LLMs: An Adaptive Testing Perspective | 2023-06-18T09:54:33 | 2023-10-28T13:02:24 | Yan Zhuang, Qi Liu, Yuting Ning, Weizhe Huang, Rui Lv, Zhenya Huang, Guanhao Zhao, Zheng Zhang, Qingyang Mao, Shijin Wang, Enhong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs), like ChatGPT, have shown some human-like
cognitive abilities. For comparing these abilities of different models, several
benchmarks (i.e. sets of standard test questions) from different fields (e.g.,
Literature, Biology and Psychology) are often adopted and the test results
under traditional metrics such as accuracy, recall and F1, are reported.
However, such way for evaluating LLMs can be inefficient and inaccurate from
the cognitive science perspective. Inspired by Computerized Adaptive Testing
(CAT) used in psychometrics, we propose an adaptive testing framework for LLM
evaluation. Rather than using a standard test set and simply reporting
accuracy, this approach dynamically adjusts the characteristics of the test
questions, such as difficulty, based on the model's performance. This allows
for a more accurate estimation of the model's abilities, using fewer questions.
More importantly, it allows LLMs to be compared with humans easily, which is
essential for NLP models that aim for human-level ability. Our diagnostic
reports have found that ChatGPT often behaves like a ``careless student'',
prone to slip and occasionally guessing the questions. We conduct a
fine-grained diagnosis and rank the latest 6 instruction-tuned LLMs from three
aspects of Subject Knowledge, Mathematical Reasoning, and Programming, where
GPT4 can outperform other models significantly and reach the cognitive ability
of middle-level students. Different tests for different models using efficient
adaptive testing -- we believe this has the potential to become a new norm in
evaluating large language models. | [
0.0087345215,
0.0253963899,
-0.0386071652,
0.0328626782,
-0.0421104655,
0.0215703305,
0.001311835,
0.0198298246,
0.0625840798,
-0.05085003,
-0.0257781465,
-0.0152411126,
-0.014864523,
-0.0119054671,
0.0390913747,
-0.0123904627,
0.0621733442,
-0.0199173801,
0.0282968488,
-0.0008030038,
-0.0358204618,
-0.0261769779,
-0.022363482,
0.0317066722,
0.049738355,
-0.0413815305,
0.008694116,
-0.0361308046,
-0.0133416438,
-0.0285736658,
0.0119773559,
0.0548942834,
-0.0101177748,
0.0239253752,
0.0000020416,
-0.0644940287,
0.010713947,
-0.0011161042,
-0.0183064602,
0.0124273291,
0.0125385029,
0.0511717275,
0.0026435705,
0.0398885682,
-0.0488072895,
0.0069493409,
-0.0007499928,
0.0146764182,
0.0435416363,
0.0580724999,
0.0128358947,
0.0038030432,
0.0636982322,
0.0034624771,
0.0657814741,
-0.0607068129,
0.0152634261,
0.027456183,
0.015255549,
0.003791874,
-0.0053494689,
0.0199382175,
0.0263331868,
0.0328884125,
-0.0247221403,
0.0114192255,
-0.0427954011,
0.0185068008,
-0.001643558,
0.0137199201,
-0.0112653701,
-0.0088215293,
-0.0084725711,
0.0107076215,
0.0294626914,
0.0567976087,
-0.073643811,
0.0218520612,
-0.0141781401,
-0.0406020544,
0.0394477323,
-0.0248519704,
0.0289503913,
0.0140351756,
0.0201735701,
0.0911114663,
-0.0003057707,
-0.0647924095,
0.029400479,
0.0089924168,
-0.0636322573,
-0.0272503234,
0.0000949291,
0.0413629524,
-0.0318037756,
0.0112682814,
-0.0071814731,
-0.0063762525,
0.0324038416,
-0.0460004583,
0.0568802767,
0.0646277517,
0.0088242497,
0.0392852463,
-0.0399342887,
0.109940201,
0.0308573581,
0.0502917729,
-0.0082158986,
0.0285529401,
-0.0705002025,
-0.0314893089,
-0.0110028805,
0.0355815403,
0.0212327112,
0.004149118,
-0.0714696273,
0.0267175678,
-0.0174923092,
-0.0004258532,
-0.0053430786,
-0.0333198048,
0.0098040178,
0.0272833779,
-0.0730028301,
-0.0185737945,
-0.0140637746,
-0.0069083525,
0.0068511339,
-0.0266772117,
-0.0111425938,
0.0065148165,
-0.0346387401,
-0.0127139352,
0.0149238491,
0.0807529092,
0.0073371874,
-0.0146418959,
-0.0250361022,
-0.0338855051,
-0.0111661078,
-0.0507634915,
0.047019694,
-0.0656184182,
0.0091341883,
0.0507722087,
-0.0011837735,
-0.0506734587,
-0.0171093456,
0.0416543558,
-0.0095981471,
0.041774448,
0.0307330247,
0.0078025432,
0.0125673795,
0.0092363358,
-0.0452600196,
0.0585256293,
0.0329102352,
-0.0230873767,
0.0308909193,
-0.0270261019,
0.0091022942,
0.0412982292,
-0.0168280303,
-0.0162984859,
0.0072679231,
0.0070071653,
0.026520839,
0.0318906233,
-0.0095790857,
0.0542394444,
-0.0065470794,
-0.0041456684,
0.0426434651,
0.0604590476,
0.024571646,
0.0367713906,
0.0352187529,
0.0198573526,
0.047038693,
0.0460473076,
-0.0626493618,
0.0182353836,
-0.0843355656,
0.0085569061,
0.0134037659,
0.0028060137,
-0.0049908068,
-0.0706325173,
-0.0340876244,
0.0300658811,
0.02063445,
0.0114765288,
0.0319554098,
-0.0212334506,
-0.0200060252,
0.0535282604,
0.0135216359,
-0.0514110997,
-0.0168466158,
-0.0840767026,
-0.0075019393,
0.0253801662,
0.054765366,
-0.0323973037,
-0.033217568,
0.0267839171,
-0.0063947146,
0.0357038826,
0.0690942854,
-0.0041277651,
-0.0243892018,
-0.0136270514,
0.0031576268,
-0.0137902619,
0.019600261,
-0.0262796227,
0.0130247995,
-0.0117510557,
-0.0055247662,
-0.0500110947,
-0.0417626649,
0.0393483974,
-0.0762592778,
-0.0291037578,
-0.0489161499,
-0.016738005,
0.0293271225,
-0.019444624,
0.0296706948,
0.0339497365,
0.0290517174,
-0.0051100175,
-0.0193503778,
-0.000466368,
-0.0374336466,
-0.0335176624,
0.0413222387,
0.0041291933,
-0.0317031033,
0.0374545567,
-0.012709124,
-0.0290801451,
0.0509700514,
-0.0387847833,
0.0291822217,
-0.015357146,
0.044583708,
-0.0392424762,
-0.0158878472,
-0.036072623,
0.088266097,
-0.0000368297,
0.0815581158,
0.0068489299,
-0.0013640956,
0.0175344981,
-0.0366786458,
-0.0410100557,
-0.0271676369,
-0.0148779899,
0.0316762365,
-0.0039203628,
0.0264463481,
-0.0859954432,
-0.0371257141,
-0.0628663525,
0.0204522572,
-0.0071587418,
0.0427475497,
0.0086926306,
-0.0532275327,
-0.020904012,
0.0290319305,
-0.0329409093,
0.006603437,
0.0075840447,
0.0228484347,
0.0302197766,
-0.0193781592,
-0.007250478,
-0.0314956643,
-0.0103061572,
-0.0726716891,
0.0203844234,
0.0249317568,
0.0244698375,
-0.0253287312,
0.0526760593,
-0.0190688204,
0.0012513795,
-0.0110449325,
-0.0281725787,
0.047330834,
0.0036099725,
0.056263119,
0.1202639192,
-0.0061503351,
0.0243017282,
0.0040210309,
-0.002390035,
-0.0352474935,
0.0399036147,
-0.0015724082,
-0.0415090024,
-0.0217321664,
-0.0483686253,
-0.0060492069,
0.0679845065,
-0.001006702,
-0.0004446234,
-0.0447530933,
0.0499143787,
-0.0504090041,
0.0031596541,
-0.0487568043,
0.0334108658,
-0.0161062926,
0.0246919971,
-0.0242555104,
-0.0288683865,
0.0617887378,
-0.0132779041,
0.0116990125,
-0.0414809212,
0.0189136043,
-0.0422349796,
0.0471390635,
0.0214243904,
-0.0274842605,
0.0018645154,
-0.0008272152,
-0.0721725002,
-0.0107858339,
0.0071146097,
-0.0589862168,
0.0451249778,
-0.0671741962,
-0.0082689067,
0.0174783897,
-0.0355233215,
-0.044265341,
0.0235885903,
-0.0007924857,
0.0382374376,
0.0176182818,
-0.0341383331,
-0.0611893311,
-0.0095945951,
0.0254588723,
-0.0054972339,
-0.0400395393,
-0.0304179918,
-0.0037510232,
0.0120931184,
0.0236425772,
0.0360130034,
0.0242882706,
-0.0679572076,
0.0243528467,
0.0635311678,
0.0201827306,
0.0177566893,
0.0029405546,
0.0352241993,
0.0158065539,
-0.055411458,
-0.0129985791,
0.03047725,
0.0545241646,
-0.0650287494,
-0.0211376473,
0.1392081082,
0.0547667742,
-0.020122109,
0.0102134766,
-0.0281064399,
0.0172151364,
0.0434765555,
0.030273512,
-0.0246403068,
-0.0333662108,
-0.0057472507,
0.025378488,
-0.0298582297,
-0.0397973284,
-0.0025097018,
-0.0928047746,
0.002465392,
-0.0028734142,
-0.0322986245,
0.0111599956,
-0.0382674001,
0.0185528938,
-0.0076747378,
0.0446664281,
0.0264368858,
-0.018876357,
0.0133551806,
0.0165586807,
-0.0736637115,
-0.0348261669,
0.0805859715,
-0.0117207393,
0.0628354102,
0.0091207065,
0.0219997875,
-0.038801413,
-0.058328703,
0.0479982793,
-0.0330218486,
0.0143793002,
-0.010245136,
0.0225589145,
-0.0049549155,
0.0264774319,
-0.0394945815,
-0.0037444315,
-0.0219114833,
-0.0064310157,
0.0361601114,
0.0867035612,
0.0094224773,
-0.0251434576,
-0.0136439456,
0.0151473256,
-0.0451194532,
0.090062879,
0.0395227,
-0.0477141738,
-0.0214646142,
-0.064107053,
-0.0269457195,
-0.0338048637,
-0.0700681657,
0.053339038,
0.0288017523,
0.0207528044,
-0.0451593027,
-0.0366780311,
0.0574563704,
-0.0147103667,
-0.0105169723,
0.007693287,
0.0112244068,
0.0004394304,
-0.038273409,
0.0452110171,
-0.004658449,
-0.0038817578,
-0.078873612,
-0.0170796197,
0.0205675587,
-0.0205979738,
-0.0365134664,
0.0115684895,
-0.0619848818,
-0.0563334487,
0.0027147573,
0.025070386,
0.0254220665,
-0.0393701605,
-0.0051191361,
-0.0429869294,
-0.0264400728,
0.0014186917,
-0.0275014695,
0.0344364606,
-0.0014558221,
0.018124124,
0.0096905446,
0.0171802696,
-0.017494427,
0.0003402579,
0.0023341023,
0.05637905,
0.0060263756,
-0.0424217246,
0.0370976403,
0.0509825759,
0.0123628601,
0.0227120239,
-0.0183131248,
0.0078035593,
-0.0226513725,
-0.0092625199,
-0.0121620297,
-0.0030694099,
-0.0246383622,
-0.0034858752,
-0.0125087323,
-0.0093322229,
-0.0392398983,
-0.0480914526,
0.0134792328,
-0.0588397644,
0.0331755169,
-0.0358746126,
0.0005555322,
-0.0065863938,
-0.0097748004,
-0.02566172,
-0.0329141207,
-0.0283057559,
0.0655672774,
-0.0040859315,
0.089123413,
-0.0072181663,
0.0231912509,
0.0128073171,
0.0031196189,
-0.0618066378,
-0.0541456826,
0.017598452,
0.0665171221,
0.0255188514,
0.0226246063,
0.0298527796,
-0.0525387488,
0.0129540432,
-0.0378385484,
-0.0173779689,
0.0133550409,
-0.0209616683,
0.0443131924,
0.0380833186,
0.006184781,
-0.0305062514,
0.0646620989,
0.0115952063,
0.0021912805,
-0.0029197214,
-0.0142452484,
-0.0414385237,
-0.0174742844,
0.0022261436,
0.0121416077,
-0.0061920946,
0.0193012431,
-0.0805989578,
-0.082227394,
0.012724448,
0.0450234115,
0.0312570892,
-0.0336641148,
0.0021910544,
0.0777839944,
-0.033834029,
-0.0446480401,
-0.0095812799,
0.0225794483,
-0.0455871783,
-0.0129423365,
-0.0342092104,
-6.084950915e-33,
-0.0343142822,
-0.0459136292,
0.0534658656,
0.0082645584,
0.024899723,
-0.0327163748,
-0.0316695236,
0.0520537719,
-0.0369127057,
-0.0162826274,
-0.0165484566,
0.0094110081,
0.0017909567,
0.0012856417,
-0.0009364007,
-0.0063317227,
-0.0189177524,
-0.0062568253,
-0.0375436023,
-0.0041106027,
-0.001705141,
-0.0244969893,
0.0671073869,
-0.0286117569,
0.0346656702,
-0.019118702,
0.0347556397,
-0.0050544171,
-0.048450686,
0.0657950416,
-0.0023592,
0.0566664711,
0.053746812,
-0.0149970679,
0.0138813732,
-0.0225143693,
-0.0374281183,
-0.0580492727,
0.0435960852,
0.0009267327,
-0.0305810086,
-0.0271859597,
0.0653894171,
-0.0050812839,
-0.0685863122,
-0.0380841345,
0.0426716357,
-0.0364845321,
-0.0185520668,
0.0192842633,
-0.0354676843,
0.0182162765,
-0.0201020055,
-0.0025289219,
-0.043443501,
0.0332055539,
-0.0422381796,
0.0066680391,
-0.0317016169,
0.0090158675,
0.0082712015,
0.047387749,
0.0545403399,
-0.0275442731,
0.0006625426,
0.0593566597,
0.012035992,
0.0343938656,
0.0312978141,
-0.0277527403,
0.0619850904,
0.0325996503,
0.0749834925,
0.0082934024,
0.0597008616,
-0.0036155717,
-0.0634727404,
0.0391389653,
0.0706072897,
0.0306833368,
0.0332881398,
-0.012446533,
-0.0702578798,
-0.0267463923,
-0.0457856506,
0.0401531905,
-0.0307074934,
-0.0410922132,
0.0612796918,
-0.0540839955,
0.0199382715,
-0.0545478873,
0.0116600841,
-0.0345496461,
0.002394458,
-0.038556505,
-0.0288806148,
0.034184102,
-0.0166206118,
0.0525409654,
-0.048108235,
-0.0291912332,
-0.0112723131,
0.0247992184,
0.0508415811,
0.002064998,
0.0179437418,
-0.0003389396,
-0.037426535,
-0.0214718916,
-0.0430097319,
-0.0047145565,
0.0182507355,
0.0134056993,
0.0420637131,
0.0163231064,
0.0077766813,
-0.0021360153,
-0.0173906591,
-0.0482305996,
-0.0654511526,
0.0036210928,
-0.0180059858,
0.0013687001,
-0.007380147,
0.0010337021,
-0.0140187405,
0.0354424715,
-0.023948079,
-0.0571021773,
-0.0001304227,
0.0218178295,
2.724e-7,
0.0545925796,
0.076219596,
-0.0378336646,
0.0485504344,
0.0125014437,
0.010835004,
-0.0594338328,
-0.0297490265,
0.0641808808,
-0.0007861296,
-0.0369829126,
0.0473653562,
0.0618321747,
0.017168209,
-0.0646563321,
-0.0161173902,
-0.0265479144,
0.0138880396,
-0.0268834736,
0.0346439183,
0.0700902492,
0.020044947,
-0.0104478942,
0.0021004532,
-0.0382335633,
-0.0832846537,
0.0485517867,
-0.0253349915,
-0.0338721983,
0.0118092,
0.0138788354,
0.0372947603,
0.0365597457,
0.0676880702,
-0.003453718,
-0.0012430259,
-0.0069286386,
0.0479046032,
0.0025650044,
-0.0065980325,
0.0139694391,
-0.0236248747,
0.015870424,
-0.040997494,
0.0619086809,
-0.0463457294,
-0.0514990948,
0.0289424118,
-0.0041199327,
-0.0271587223,
0.0118515799,
0.0073223012,
-0.0268346649,
0.0189090297,
0.020651456,
-0.0248822495,
0.0000234193,
-0.0299345721,
-0.0252384171,
0.0227251761,
-0.0322838165,
-0.0911914185,
-0.0423595794,
-0.0223250538,
0.0061314479,
-0.0573330708,
-0.0087360963,
2.816627958e-34,
0.0399375334,
0.0066238614,
0.0563279837,
0.0038960353,
0.0470393337,
0.016911367,
0.040303167,
0.0332684591,
0.0050557558,
-0.07552398,
-0.0103419609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10493v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10493v1 | MOSPC: MOS Prediction Based on Pairwise Comparison | 2023-06-18T07:38:17 | 2023-06-18T07:38:17 | Kexin Wang, Yunlong Zhao, Qianqian Dong, Tom Ko, Mingxuan Wang | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | As a subjective metric to evaluate the quality of synthesized speech, Mean
opinion score~(MOS) usually requires multiple annotators to score the same
speech. Such an annotation approach requires a lot of manpower and is also
time-consuming. MOS prediction model for automatic evaluation can significantly
reduce labor cost. In previous works, it is difficult to accurately rank the
quality of speech when the MOS scores are close. However, in practical
applications, it is more important to correctly rank the quality of synthesis
systems or sentences than simply predicting MOS scores. Meanwhile, as each
annotator scores multiple audios during annotation, the score is probably a
relative value based on the first or the first few speech scores given by the
annotator. Motivated by the above two points, we propose a general framework
for MOS prediction based on pair comparison (MOSPC), and we utilize C-Mixup
algorithm to enhance the generalization performance of MOSPC. The experiments
on BVCC and VCC2018 show that our framework outperforms the baselines on most
of the correlation coefficient metrics, especially on the metric KTAU related
to quality ranking. And our framework also surpasses the strong baseline in
ranking accuracy on each fine-grained segment. These results indicate that our
framework contributes to improving the ranking accuracy of speech quality. | [
-0.0142125394,
0.0163904596,
0.028083086,
-0.0170667842,
-0.0068271058,
-0.0241233855,
0.0202547498,
-0.0117051061,
-0.0270902719,
-0.0402808562,
-0.0583508611,
-0.0175108444,
0.0348366648,
0.0133737102,
-0.0031676881,
-0.0437951759,
0.0149141867,
-0.024235867,
0.0296124052,
-0.0223510955,
0.0237148274,
-0.0013650097,
-0.0376277305,
0.0169561375,
-0.0202450249,
0.0053426083,
0.0280054547,
0.0129659437,
0.0498881042,
-0.0216976553,
-0.0179339591,
0.0505971126,
-0.0332522392,
0.0441424735,
0.000001973,
-0.0393655151,
-0.0151293818,
0.0354045928,
0.0204438921,
0.0273036398,
0.0090961764,
0.1070958599,
-0.0618062876,
0.0255588908,
-0.0329561792,
-0.0239126012,
0.0230543334,
0.0036196196,
0.0839717239,
0.0454142503,
-0.0023608443,
-0.0264243167,
-0.0275538415,
-0.0018912529,
-0.0081323767,
0.0168548897,
-0.0337847173,
0.046187494,
-0.0206655134,
-0.0214089528,
0.005506563,
0.0331554227,
-0.02937508,
-0.0088781249,
0.0474053919,
0.0080747204,
-0.0630825907,
-0.0337941386,
0.0020092314,
0.0590676665,
-0.0004160025,
0.0221682545,
0.0252735671,
0.0161703955,
0.0043351538,
-0.0056579616,
-0.032043945,
-0.0351149663,
0.0047871899,
0.0071632736,
-0.0471190065,
0.0645910278,
0.0205225945,
-0.0316641927,
0.0474133603,
0.0104023442,
0.0117763551,
-0.0435847044,
0.0323980413,
0.0090670846,
-0.011981138,
-0.0006912842,
0.0267450325,
-0.0293033253,
-0.0252273828,
-0.0375148319,
0.0076800818,
-0.0343145169,
-0.0318445377,
-0.0588215031,
0.0236221887,
-0.0021298095,
-0.0126305316,
0.0319979563,
-0.0304224733,
0.0328398161,
0.0320065916,
-0.0113526825,
-0.0554221198,
-0.0142974909,
-0.0303314161,
0.0255837105,
0.0134831192,
0.0486685634,
-0.0055228672,
-0.0129608447,
-0.0767183453,
-0.0396405868,
-0.0787034035,
0.0078395801,
0.060765706,
0.0177541319,
0.0058038449,
0.0139085623,
-0.0395439602,
0.0126673272,
-0.0197371002,
0.029939916,
0.0022179626,
-0.0245497674,
0.0277434252,
0.0264475513,
0.0213155393,
0.0301079229,
0.0405010469,
0.0292437039,
0.0255635753,
0.0351736471,
0.0348288603,
-0.0396975353,
-0.0407218374,
-0.0313422643,
-0.0404411741,
-0.0839303136,
0.0081059113,
-0.0181980487,
-0.0071380255,
0.0312654376,
-0.0134442067,
-0.0071021277,
0.0274323002,
0.0065690354,
-0.0051222062,
-0.0015587689,
0.0126225436,
0.0001610126,
0.0006719625,
-0.0049212514,
0.0453655571,
0.0055492274,
0.0180295724,
-0.0174520835,
0.0220291689,
0.0377332121,
-0.0174792893,
-0.0071268026,
0.002091686,
-0.0303796604,
-0.0093476539,
0.0592080951,
0.0514731556,
0.0576237589,
-0.0270667821,
-0.0068734954,
0.0634745881,
-0.0218136143,
0.1061499715,
0.0157779753,
0.0522811785,
0.0180740654,
-0.0019869641,
0.0346985757,
0.0285769869,
0.0578839406,
-0.0056271479,
0.019830605,
0.1235703528,
0.0294104349,
-0.0018000989,
-0.0731378794,
0.019567132,
-0.0171787757,
-0.0212009177,
-0.0330867879,
0.0048348363,
0.0125595899,
-0.0168611519,
0.010158685,
-0.005072596,
-0.0878844187,
-0.0090607442,
-0.0440568179,
0.0241872203,
0.094800666,
-0.0081776474,
-0.0127734169,
0.0124500589,
-0.0260299519,
-0.0601749793,
-0.00388159,
0.0095678214,
-0.0461770557,
0.0224104393,
-0.0584291741,
-0.0189771652,
0.014014191,
-0.0283191428,
0.0087269209,
-0.0670751929,
0.0200620089,
0.0182886031,
-0.0424617566,
-0.0022083824,
-0.0247517023,
0.0568442121,
0.0178764779,
0.0173438061,
0.0066286507,
0.0732673258,
0.0587731004,
-0.0293021165,
0.0444156304,
0.0373124518,
-0.0343751758,
-0.0169129837,
0.0258385371,
-0.0748904124,
-0.0727886334,
0.0267359931,
-0.0579027869,
0.0272885989,
0.009168095,
-0.0161191262,
-0.068707563,
0.0365417302,
-0.0132561801,
0.0385224037,
-0.0282596312,
0.0153681422,
0.0076642022,
-0.0243712515,
0.0210804511,
0.0258635152,
-0.0169009157,
0.0136262272,
0.0119427713,
0.0080595016,
0.0292772949,
-0.0117527917,
-0.0428525656,
0.0212389659,
0.0051735952,
0.0452168845,
-0.0082935663,
-0.0023083813,
-0.0438109599,
-0.027723942,
-0.1238288805,
0.0119001474,
0.0075004678,
-0.0172473174,
-0.0138612697,
-0.0221923925,
0.0144984256,
0.0104453983,
-0.0284618493,
-0.0601350628,
-0.0350187086,
-0.0029994587,
-0.0295068529,
0.0106891897,
-0.009893938,
-0.0090685552,
-0.0137174595,
0.0122733414,
0.0194795057,
-0.029361343,
0.0022273553,
-0.0247951355,
0.0406597257,
-0.0599475801,
-0.0206318349,
0.0300179664,
-0.0363050513,
0.0020926073,
0.0168656316,
0.043778725,
0.0442786627,
0.0086004045,
-0.0167366453,
0.0663597211,
-0.0238775015,
-0.0365774743,
-0.0116549954,
0.0391432643,
0.0624787398,
0.0161853675,
-0.0065100868,
-0.0500944816,
-0.0012582148,
0.0536607727,
0.0121816657,
-0.0297144167,
0.0057863467,
-0.0377303101,
-0.0159776546,
0.0023275637,
-0.0088838059,
-0.0507899225,
0.0192741789,
0.0102602132,
-0.0413807631,
0.0422763787,
-0.0514984205,
-0.0236715134,
-0.0387588032,
-0.0117974347,
-0.0050404742,
-0.0336362608,
-0.0363301747,
0.0270426981,
-0.0677203834,
0.0137501024,
-0.0683794022,
0.0140825501,
0.0456427,
-0.1065918431,
-0.0313816629,
-0.0052912761,
-0.0188887585,
0.0245529935,
-0.0063473317,
0.0278808959,
0.0380813107,
-0.0233749133,
0.0059871925,
0.0299320202,
-0.0181032326,
0.0702236667,
0.0480975844,
0.0054600355,
0.0072473842,
-0.0130490465,
0.015175744,
0.0391814038,
0.0610372052,
0.01294374,
0.0268865693,
0.0014292225,
-0.0092971912,
0.0146459751,
-0.0058542439,
0.0514111742,
0.0283571463,
-0.0551665574,
-0.0366431959,
0.003311425,
0.0491165444,
-0.0577573888,
0.0082568955,
0.0284557547,
-0.0218440648,
0.0452858768,
0.0842741877,
0.0090416791,
0.0200036839,
-0.0214430094,
0.0314287245,
0.0272282306,
0.0361070149,
-0.0151037294,
-0.0254793838,
-0.0061954507,
0.0141155273,
0.0555152521,
-0.036704991,
-0.000410761,
-0.0088868616,
-0.1072767377,
0.0306076612,
0.0226728693,
-0.0193164423,
0.0053947284,
-0.0424587093,
-0.019124385,
-0.0209090058,
0.007346828,
-0.0004562061,
0.020945197,
0.0155370198,
0.057157442,
-0.0714449137,
-0.0174647439,
0.0227919333,
-0.0510965548,
0.117708303,
0.0653430894,
0.0654516071,
-0.0073029757,
-0.0374876335,
0.0213658195,
-0.0259995442,
0.0071522854,
-0.0017614671,
0.0346596055,
0.0009842931,
0.0082652951,
-0.0196108203,
0.0007813463,
0.0776386485,
0.0205143746,
-0.0203706194,
0.0477588885,
0.0003114927,
-0.0222187862,
-0.0222068354,
0.0849881023,
-0.0166527573,
0.0539316051,
0.0376652479,
-0.0736279488,
0.0415499099,
-0.0025506623,
0.0122044301,
-0.0462920628,
-0.0221161526,
0.0187217779,
0.0008663224,
-0.0375676006,
-0.1075639352,
0.0138705485,
-0.008198699,
0.0364878848,
-0.0232625548,
0.0398232564,
-0.0611711629,
0.0161868539,
-0.0108383419,
-0.0214661602,
0.050458733,
0.0116533572,
-0.0466182604,
-0.008016021,
0.0430398919,
-0.0240414534,
-0.0517366715,
0.0167088322,
-0.0125119081,
-0.0497215018,
0.0123214852,
0.0704774037,
0.0088053215,
0.0260144044,
0.0067012585,
-0.0175737496,
0.0509198904,
0.029186435,
0.0059602745,
0.0301453173,
0.0735438615,
0.022999486,
-0.0166168511,
0.0156538188,
-0.069470793,
0.039795775,
-0.0227487553,
0.0040082415,
0.0176441334,
-0.0483381785,
0.0097982036,
0.0330734253,
0.0556253605,
-0.0123290671,
0.0340031125,
-0.0202938318,
0.0196024086,
-0.0241140872,
-0.0229692608,
-0.039829921,
0.0474129841,
-0.0016688387,
0.0304510593,
-0.0289484411,
0.0315685496,
-0.0167064443,
-0.0266725756,
0.0182677582,
0.0362910666,
0.0015490573,
-0.0133112483,
0.0122323576,
-0.004619542,
-0.0032630358,
0.0024889163,
0.0340734161,
0.0167893525,
0.0072815628,
-0.0217878893,
0.021768732,
0.0158895403,
0.0296287406,
0.083430253,
-0.0182972215,
0.018287817,
-0.0581181608,
0.0151539138,
0.008733443,
0.0055979453,
0.0921885595,
0.0276376382,
0.0160113778,
-0.0260241926,
0.0277383085,
-0.0024253288,
-0.0089636417,
-0.0419947989,
0.0056497776,
-0.0070373453,
0.0335647017,
0.0340739526,
-0.0802659839,
-0.0199562684,
-0.0430285223,
0.0099497698,
-0.0284133479,
0.0049017854,
-0.0836997777,
0.0010782703,
0.0166703966,
-0.0285944827,
-0.0481316298,
-0.025482757,
0.0569359064,
-0.0035221227,
0.030159656,
-0.0135310842,
0.0436970145,
0.0261414219,
-0.0497039966,
0.0511900596,
-0.0006560726,
-0.1178569719,
-0.0059317183,
-0.0168303214,
0.0302807782,
-5.574016418e-33,
-0.050077796,
-0.0062537892,
-0.050689172,
-0.0013138312,
-0.0171573162,
-0.0037407728,
-0.0029301627,
0.0029790264,
-0.0029885848,
0.0048770853,
0.0148579786,
-0.0063591083,
0.0191258676,
-0.0090451576,
-0.0164119191,
0.0163318459,
0.0581934117,
0.0033466315,
-0.0398457684,
0.0139041012,
0.0568950847,
0.0248315372,
0.0365387984,
-0.1044628248,
-0.027121583,
0.0241907891,
-0.0488772579,
-0.021823585,
-0.0034330338,
0.0592116043,
0.0422205068,
0.0659566596,
-0.0054260083,
-0.0265803225,
-0.0179928262,
-0.0190784577,
0.0232674573,
-0.0142178144,
-0.0080292542,
-0.0144216679,
-0.0080200657,
-0.0030727375,
0.0252465941,
0.0205959659,
-0.0916034877,
-0.0300181974,
0.0431023091,
-0.0452470072,
-0.0264328774,
-0.0895781219,
0.0146270758,
0.0250161961,
-0.0275563225,
-0.0448514521,
0.0334405154,
0.0115201995,
-0.0200209338,
-0.0128651131,
-0.015257135,
0.0844536796,
-0.0222208723,
0.0810119957,
0.0396540947,
0.0065279016,
-0.0009496672,
0.0619503111,
0.0422624759,
-0.0634841546,
0.061371468,
-0.0267851315,
-0.0058473703,
0.0325990915,
0.0565194264,
0.0532327406,
0.035570506,
-0.0408242792,
0.0103684328,
0.0485371612,
-0.0075053996,
-0.0194217917,
0.0030141736,
0.0351947397,
-0.0394190364,
-0.0090168016,
-0.0626548827,
-0.0307232067,
-0.039291326,
-0.0337306187,
0.0262007639,
-0.029074287,
-0.0205440912,
-0.0257170945,
0.0140682431,
-0.0222960915,
0.0208086465,
-0.032200437,
-0.0792797431,
0.0248667058,
-0.0068618446,
-0.0144331539,
-0.0247583129,
0.0008787395,
0.0634448528,
0.0406198353,
0.0295260567,
-0.0358803794,
0.0049861693,
0.0266853962,
-0.070696719,
-0.0069359378,
0.0201745816,
-0.0104489662,
-0.0326382071,
-0.0429899581,
-0.0026232461,
-0.008443431,
-0.0237666015,
0.0416238606,
-0.0173874646,
0.0690615103,
-0.0249146167,
-0.0310586635,
0.0137917753,
-0.0215534437,
-0.042179808,
0.0176446736,
0.0258232486,
-0.0717725381,
0.0426282398,
-0.0302300937,
-0.0543961599,
-0.0143097499,
2.847e-7,
-0.0072985683,
0.0329414718,
-0.0382691249,
-0.0485549085,
0.0074383901,
0.029430341,
-0.0152807469,
-0.0145887649,
0.0175921489,
-0.0139058186,
0.0345740803,
-0.0481885485,
0.0420752652,
0.0369198397,
-0.0789002702,
0.0105024893,
-0.1098260283,
-0.0160202887,
-0.0093085486,
-0.0031225467,
0.0230462477,
0.0586202145,
-0.0112479366,
-0.0078729233,
0.0114209307,
0.0099576609,
0.0164217725,
0.000701622,
-0.0054849018,
-0.0413968787,
0.0376494154,
-0.0192291923,
-0.0217540022,
0.0196802057,
-0.0376682989,
0.0177217554,
0.0934312344,
0.0301947985,
0.0132909613,
-0.0807335675,
0.0275572017,
0.0498495437,
-0.041436106,
0.0292127877,
0.0429054163,
0.0228512418,
-0.0125687588,
-0.0642545894,
-0.0544292219,
0.0243262351,
0.0037379102,
-0.0014873771,
-0.0151352575,
-0.0090377573,
-0.0204706099,
0.0163928047,
0.0116490787,
-0.0161635876,
-0.0195668079,
0.0058154776,
-0.0081846202,
-0.1131338999,
0.0303457659,
-0.012936228,
0.0258471463,
-0.0438266955,
-0.011306975,
1.935532034e-34,
0.0668893233,
-0.0212812331,
0.0631220266,
-0.0334721506,
0.0091657164,
-0.020215407,
-0.0207259487,
-0.017819304,
-0.0013452667,
0.010542837,
-0.0205684546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.17176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.17176v1 | News Verifiers Showdown: A Comparative Performance Evaluation of ChatGPT 3.5, ChatGPT 4.0, Bing AI, and Bard in News Fact-Checking | 2023-06-18T04:30:29 | 2023-06-18T04:30:29 | Kevin Matthe Caramancion | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | This study aimed to evaluate the proficiency of prominent Large Language
Models (LLMs), namely OpenAI's ChatGPT 3.5 and 4.0, Google's Bard(LaMDA), and
Microsoft's Bing AI in discerning the truthfulness of news items using black
box testing. A total of 100 fact-checked news items, all sourced from
independent fact-checking agencies, were presented to each of these LLMs under
controlled conditions. Their responses were classified into one of three
categories: True, False, and Partially True/False. The effectiveness of the
LLMs was gauged based on the accuracy of their classifications against the
verified facts provided by the independent agencies. The results showed a
moderate proficiency across all models, with an average score of 65.25 out of
100. Among the models, OpenAI's GPT-4.0 stood out with a score of 71,
suggesting an edge in newer LLMs' abilities to differentiate fact from
deception. However, when juxtaposed against the performance of human
fact-checkers, the AI models, despite showing promise, lag in comprehending the
subtleties and contexts inherent in news information. The findings highlight
the potential of AI in the domain of fact-checking while underscoring the
continued importance of human cognitive skills and the necessity for persistent
advancements in AI capabilities. Finally, the experimental data produced from
the simulation of this work is openly available on Kaggle. | [
0.0597060695,
-0.0024238157,
-0.017989628,
0.0347951055,
-0.0668902025,
0.0127430996,
0.011704105,
-0.0113023175,
0.0723663643,
-0.0489424579,
0.0069768284,
0.0072462847,
0.0022182313,
0.047021348,
-0.0252356939,
0.0088847084,
0.0743182898,
0.0045893569,
0.094682537,
-0.0144415479,
-0.0059173577,
0.0384680368,
-0.0378358327,
0.0258735064,
-0.0514065288,
-0.0150051648,
0.0190122314,
-0.0406097881,
0.0158796813,
-0.0315853767,
-0.010724498,
0.0515119545,
0.0009145295,
0.0965051129,
0.0000020045,
-0.044037044,
0.0032831931,
0.0204710774,
-0.0721697137,
0.0220569205,
0.0005006656,
0.0069753034,
-0.0362112001,
0.0191523153,
-0.0300581511,
-0.0275505483,
0.0227231104,
0.0466520116,
0.0718242452,
0.1092130467,
-0.0146367177,
0.000264151,
0.0439450629,
0.0192955937,
-0.0124224694,
-0.0603230707,
0.0464142002,
0.0522723645,
-0.0259807892,
-0.0004244294,
0.0332221091,
0.0222361255,
0.0359910168,
-0.0237549953,
-0.0739923194,
0.0607809126,
-0.0570657253,
-0.0170649253,
-0.0209266879,
0.0151484357,
0.0127883544,
-0.0514781885,
-0.0211168379,
0.0011853797,
-0.0006114834,
0.0262307655,
-0.0060473629,
0.0420750827,
-0.0540735349,
-0.0274809208,
0.0139913401,
-0.0232790709,
0.0176900122,
0.0552175678,
0.0128351497,
0.0604712516,
-0.0132386293,
-0.0401455648,
0.033075735,
0.0160585716,
0.0186127722,
-0.0678417906,
-0.0060231443,
0.0159339104,
-0.0077662081,
0.0151286814,
-0.0265683904,
0.0038575041,
0.0425852612,
-0.1079115346,
-0.0259726197,
0.0231118314,
-0.061249271,
0.0669795349,
-0.0299845263,
0.0335479788,
0.0028337531,
0.0303704776,
0.0195319187,
-0.0254659597,
-0.0107937008,
0.0137878526,
-0.015454012,
0.0236419514,
-0.0011835068,
-0.019750189,
-0.0326076858,
-0.0279073827,
-0.0075118765,
0.0358249918,
-0.0072208387,
-0.0051054372,
-0.0069030565,
-0.0224092044,
-0.0816865712,
0.0275411289,
-0.0185690019,
0.0362109467,
-0.0006331548,
-0.0636460632,
0.0050814492,
0.0192461163,
-0.0296970084,
0.0009673223,
0.0247133411,
-0.0169772152,
-0.0236464627,
-0.0004144224,
-0.0492255501,
-0.0037054862,
-0.0230716523,
-0.0920187458,
-0.0014547816,
-0.0489914566,
0.0011700791,
0.0013871631,
-0.0180809628,
0.0111033572,
-0.0196018759,
0.0172808003,
-0.0249230377,
0.0249710679,
-0.0055840076,
0.0057016052,
0.0554021038,
0.0072432538,
-0.0334129855,
0.0729458332,
0.0210067574,
0.0697690323,
0.0504586622,
0.0358622149,
-0.0036562283,
-0.0316801481,
0.0056429589,
0.019187618,
0.0230220966,
0.0074334512,
-0.0159447081,
-0.0023438067,
-0.0220965762,
0.0600559451,
-0.0286490824,
-0.0242202599,
0.0933939293,
-0.0155308722,
0.0003382062,
0.0050235894,
0.0293484107,
-0.0080598854,
0.0765948072,
0.0288500804,
-0.0419552661,
0.0355330519,
-0.0319956988,
-0.0173641201,
-0.0294784829,
0.0707218796,
-0.0044454015,
-0.0313563086,
-0.0215101857,
0.0039769718,
0.0060634855,
0.0100159543,
-0.0130952112,
-0.0261454377,
-0.0457860306,
0.0058550751,
0.0102299228,
-0.0225857664,
-0.0217182152,
-0.0953119248,
0.0522139519,
0.0315395854,
0.0354060568,
0.0182495937,
0.0060002375,
-0.0143214986,
0.0101606371,
0.0335560217,
0.0879971161,
-0.0046847779,
-0.0400379002,
-0.0173974764,
0.0020460587,
-0.0418417677,
0.0309363492,
0.0292979348,
0.0538999811,
0.0486804098,
-0.0127089862,
0.0156564135,
-0.0346374214,
0.0264073089,
0.0031209069,
0.0067550661,
-0.0226621032,
0.0091336248,
0.0177629013,
0.0088124285,
-0.0251263399,
-0.0136557845,
0.0217848402,
0.0238223039,
-0.0275983084,
-0.0267692581,
0.0263044313,
0.0273365546,
0.0114568844,
-0.0350971743,
-0.0362991169,
0.0663371384,
-0.002321444,
0.005051008,
-0.0386092067,
-0.030502988,
0.0022514106,
-0.0636213124,
-0.0110250199,
-0.0551930964,
0.0023679184,
0.0209814701,
0.0851357058,
-0.0130376685,
-0.0274969637,
-0.0285522472,
-0.000516807,
0.012595566,
-0.0224034041,
-0.023020573,
0.014660215,
0.0265038572,
0.0412621237,
0.0034237499,
-0.0245385412,
-0.0277119074,
-0.0104249474,
-0.0826297849,
0.0086238459,
-0.0054673334,
-0.0042681233,
0.027926432,
-0.0458307825,
-0.021199001,
0.0334899239,
-0.0034074683,
0.0022987351,
0.0236018524,
0.0244316664,
0.0055318791,
-0.0070008878,
0.0023969472,
-0.0156070255,
0.0355615541,
-0.0371099338,
0.0017596595,
0.0570734181,
-0.0474419221,
-0.027003184,
-0.0096996939,
-0.0528059937,
0.0186058041,
-0.0133195557,
-0.0440133773,
0.032863576,
0.0085713826,
-0.0200586729,
0.0662823915,
0.0546745174,
0.0257842224,
0.0387964584,
0.0256183352,
-0.0105439704,
0.0188907944,
-0.0149994325,
0.0114781354,
-0.026227165,
-0.0257532075,
0.0387602188,
-0.0082012676,
0.03526498,
0.0208312273,
-0.0053941831,
0.0348886363,
0.0003700799,
-0.0252296869,
0.0331650265,
-0.0453623123,
-0.0055864593,
0.0705661699,
-0.0318389945,
-0.0395401902,
0.0768872127,
-0.0362220034,
0.0611002892,
-0.0509338528,
-0.012935278,
-0.0071938001,
0.0100244833,
-0.0463129394,
0.0381718129,
-0.0201408509,
0.0054933,
-0.0202008411,
-0.0321675576,
0.0451665036,
-0.0347874314,
0.0268041771,
-0.0267193262,
0.0187067762,
0.0421227477,
-0.0268157553,
-0.0597389266,
-0.0509246401,
-0.0357495174,
-0.0271162074,
0.0078450656,
-0.0296967868,
-0.0843306631,
0.0070339297,
0.0540613048,
0.0313801765,
-0.0154339764,
0.0043484271,
0.0267675314,
0.0009878657,
0.0221211575,
0.032545805,
0.0988401175,
0.023727268,
0.0074508288,
0.0668628961,
-0.0184238963,
0.0111950235,
-0.0318163596,
-0.0495770164,
-0.0200559683,
-0.0415235572,
-0.0007663113,
-0.0074717961,
-0.0129533252,
-0.0355815664,
0.0071028573,
0.0716306269,
0.0162159987,
-0.0151018482,
-0.0199061744,
0.0173530504,
-0.0506698824,
0.017920671,
0.0133638754,
-0.1017773896,
-0.0092290891,
-0.007904714,
-0.0313053653,
-0.0467762128,
-0.0123643316,
-0.0278276745,
-0.0892534629,
0.0478637852,
-0.0160500035,
-0.0054283543,
-0.0347641483,
-0.0636811182,
-0.003374293,
0.009664678,
0.0182380062,
0.0153158689,
0.0443873294,
-0.045201201,
-0.0189641453,
0.0025202804,
-0.0420618281,
0.0661980882,
-0.0128810424,
0.0320842899,
0.0288214739,
0.0387676395,
-0.0284898467,
-0.036612682,
-0.0043423991,
0.0073119509,
-0.0227332842,
0.0198677722,
0.0734888539,
-0.0426518731,
0.0262395255,
-0.0323318131,
-0.0148309832,
0.0547928549,
0.0087850858,
0.0085768709,
0.0530989245,
-0.0031457504,
-0.0594478399,
-0.0227057915,
0.011912711,
-0.0009885996,
0.0592851713,
0.0064819227,
0.0407898203,
-0.0236125588,
0.0015479621,
-0.0222743805,
-0.0172566529,
-0.0409295224,
0.0749853104,
-0.0066020824,
-0.0787599012,
-0.0493473373,
-0.0124318572,
-0.0100326659,
0.0226964299,
-0.031457983,
-0.0257627852,
0.0587033853,
0.0280620251,
0.0025976992,
-0.0088902619,
-0.0279522464,
0.019008616,
-0.0239869691,
0.0031962143,
0.0116855167,
-0.0194096509,
-0.0022274405,
0.0352759473,
-0.0575828552,
-0.0213188399,
0.0251909532,
0.0123193832,
0.0243312847,
0.0188762378,
-0.0548740923,
0.0201644879,
0.0279800463,
0.0297127832,
-0.0497979708,
0.0140911406,
-0.0076561333,
-0.0355717242,
0.012460297,
-0.0137854107,
-0.0197604224,
0.0436263345,
-0.0088895867,
-0.0383796394,
-0.0243972726,
-0.0313042067,
0.0548996478,
0.0578525402,
0.0188491642,
0.0007625694,
0.0203294158,
-0.0305179935,
-0.0038580061,
-0.0083503397,
-0.0200083051,
0.0405760929,
-0.0170541871,
0.0115621341,
-0.0112918606,
-0.0030284491,
0.0099290693,
-0.0402879603,
-0.001370232,
-0.0381999202,
-0.0099713216,
0.0113405306,
0.0647294596,
-0.017892085,
-0.0416946076,
-0.0609770045,
0.004905811,
-0.0129828565,
0.0286595523,
0.0107507259,
0.0241407733,
0.0093804216,
-0.0471518114,
0.021924559,
-0.0098470179,
-0.1072202921,
-0.0263786148,
-0.0144969802,
0.043836195,
0.0489787161,
0.0194891784,
-0.001790437,
-0.0333350115,
-0.020859573,
-0.0013577692,
-0.0366880745,
0.0420921184,
-0.0062311506,
0.0111105917,
0.0068191304,
-0.0321302563,
0.0154674277,
0.0521197617,
-0.0325991325,
0.0522383973,
0.0241607744,
-0.0737548992,
-0.0299147181,
-0.0900669023,
-0.0495513678,
0.031338457,
0.0002848707,
-0.013580652,
-0.0666426197,
-0.0280775595,
0.0102014467,
0.0366948135,
0.0688037202,
-0.0272921529,
-0.0346248969,
0.1015009955,
0.0490223914,
-0.019320609,
-0.0275272783,
-0.0097169382,
-0.0520580262,
0.0079437848,
-0.0001735666,
-6.403568659e-33,
-0.0037283835,
-0.0588411242,
0.0104590105,
-0.0014522155,
0.0090181129,
0.0547213256,
-0.01405928,
-0.0294131543,
-0.081043683,
0.0468519889,
0.0110517442,
0.0458380952,
0.0195724592,
-0.0672170147,
-0.0296108648,
-0.0083466927,
0.034593612,
-0.0137630869,
-0.0488564521,
0.0049197441,
0.0378309153,
-0.052191563,
0.0289267991,
-0.0595820136,
0.0370814539,
-0.0045608133,
-0.0500087626,
-0.0006949871,
-0.0493865609,
0.0569778606,
0.0217690058,
0.0377344042,
0.0595725775,
-0.0244774297,
0.0321872979,
0.0116608981,
-0.040039774,
-0.0065585985,
0.0523052365,
-0.0037974517,
0.0147553012,
0.0112777632,
0.0099972617,
0.0018102109,
-0.0282195751,
-0.005814272,
0.0057493709,
-0.0290428251,
0.0147594744,
0.0001437845,
-0.0423153266,
0.0087020667,
0.0181503855,
-0.0058799377,
-0.0556452498,
0.0391721949,
-0.0122698545,
0.007441429,
-0.090627715,
0.0253253262,
-0.0118228663,
-0.0123336604,
0.0459413566,
-0.0372630619,
-0.0431249216,
0.0569136888,
0.0087682353,
0.0315272026,
-0.0734505057,
0.0043668225,
0.0215541832,
0.0312569477,
0.0629678294,
0.0954167396,
0.0166858342,
-0.0774565563,
-0.0814820826,
0.0284602195,
0.0843056068,
0.0144185368,
0.0294067692,
-0.0298397988,
-0.0476725064,
0.0188141782,
-0.0021649764,
0.0134588871,
-0.0413549207,
-0.0179095771,
0.0152039342,
0.0217183009,
-0.0249559637,
0.0113075385,
0.0076782205,
-0.0380205698,
0.072812289,
0.0178380311,
-0.0437289178,
0.0205011051,
-0.0044595767,
0.024774503,
-0.0990702882,
0.0216364264,
0.0270640329,
0.0696510449,
0.0033281236,
0.0160349719,
0.0451891571,
0.0070627569,
-0.0290292613,
0.0253572129,
-0.0009528795,
0.0433516838,
0.0344652943,
-0.0372362882,
0.0251175649,
-0.012905404,
-0.0060939677,
-0.0116742142,
-0.0137813706,
0.0300854966,
-0.0143525442,
-0.0155688655,
-0.0063349139,
0.0231434312,
-0.0208370686,
-0.0039093732,
-0.042036999,
-0.0101838624,
-0.0438407138,
-0.0799576491,
-0.0030783815,
0.0350768007,
2.849e-7,
-0.0134086004,
0.0499746315,
0.0060691228,
0.0452310815,
0.0127240475,
0.0241937898,
0.0173299871,
-0.0058446787,
0.0006859711,
-0.0680800676,
-0.0245019644,
0.0592759848,
0.0211475659,
0.0767873004,
-0.030364627,
-0.01455303,
-0.0660030097,
-0.0049746456,
-0.0821884423,
0.0096650068,
0.0397463441,
0.0276143998,
0.0234919712,
-0.0238950998,
-0.0059284423,
-0.0352833122,
0.0286845267,
0.057179831,
-0.0554937534,
0.010166157,
0.0578981936,
0.0243093856,
-0.0011666819,
0.0580017827,
-0.0168892108,
0.00286768,
-0.0109596048,
0.0561411567,
0.0055923453,
0.0121498229,
-0.0007757591,
-0.0136362249,
0.0226275902,
-0.0635417104,
0.0820542946,
-0.0097895814,
-0.0398556106,
-0.067847155,
-0.0303870589,
-0.0153361792,
0.0229459312,
-0.0286104549,
-0.0113404477,
0.0167948827,
-0.0195020959,
0.0029614619,
0.0127901789,
-0.001423746,
0.0137751503,
-0.0072140852,
-0.0310898852,
-0.0683064908,
0.0154028339,
-0.0414726026,
0.0394060053,
-0.0544511415,
0.0499809831,
2.219428384e-34,
0.0287186801,
-0.0057379268,
0.0112519749,
-0.0186827742,
0.0938006416,
0.0601196662,
-0.0219636224,
-0.0311536435,
-0.0062129041,
-0.0088110287,
-0.006477599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10469v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10469v1 | Transferring Neural Potentials For High Order Dependency Parsing | 2023-06-18T03:58:41 | 2023-06-18T03:58:41 | Farshad Noravesh | cs.CL | cs.CL | High order dependency parsing leverages high order features such as siblings
or grandchildren to improve state of the art accuracy of current first order
dependency parsers. The present paper uses biaffine scores to provide an
estimate of the arc scores and is then propagated into a graphical model. The
inference inside the graphical model is solved using dual decomposition. The
present algorithm propagates biaffine neural scores to the graphical model and
by leveraging dual decomposition inference, the overall circuit is trained
end-to-end to transfer first order informations to the high order informations. | [
-0.0200721007,
0.0840980858,
-0.0061696055,
0.0217083972,
-0.038426809,
0.019244384,
0.011859403,
-0.0044666347,
0.0346522182,
-0.0235826913,
-0.0183769688,
-0.007833777,
0.0078647612,
0.0618561208,
-0.0103960093,
-0.0577757731,
0.0190795474,
-0.0193883814,
-0.0225948598,
-0.008732656,
-0.0332771353,
0.000447391,
-0.0485524125,
0.0421909913,
-0.0850895867,
-0.024657717,
0.0041729487,
0.0086765718,
0.0082801757,
-0.0143685434,
-0.0098580811,
0.0447745807,
0.0173229799,
0.0034763126,
0.0000020584,
-0.0291268807,
-0.0318518505,
0.0154673606,
-0.0227878485,
-0.0340401158,
-0.0259325225,
-0.0602930188,
-0.0112948008,
-0.0482922643,
-0.0299196597,
-0.0151399439,
0.0082636597,
0.0151718305,
0.0440174006,
0.0585734881,
-0.0245468952,
-0.1089045778,
0.0585229471,
-0.0063894712,
-0.0374299474,
-0.0344638787,
-0.001301398,
0.0105871996,
-0.0060803182,
-0.0295031536,
-0.017755419,
0.0146363787,
0.0301218648,
-0.0201716293,
0.0395684168,
0.0222994331,
0.0346510373,
0.0587795861,
-0.0113495039,
0.0694100931,
0.0186371226,
0.0223644096,
-0.010322147,
-0.0119589604,
-0.0169006158,
0.0246937275,
-0.0359768756,
0.0092228008,
-0.0400239378,
0.0330929123,
0.001399394,
-0.055563122,
-0.0020430533,
-0.0333023109,
-0.0013112326,
0.1099436283,
-0.0039293049,
-0.0366059616,
0.0315626115,
0.0367214121,
-0.0482676961,
0.0416812263,
0.0583883822,
-0.0324174985,
0.0370961353,
-0.0018819716,
-0.0093553318,
-0.0175198931,
-0.0558476113,
-0.0563094243,
0.0212888736,
0.0076732081,
-0.0450593196,
0.0008475524,
-0.0508778505,
0.0355484039,
-0.0105739217,
-0.0047910567,
-0.0524967499,
0.0430470146,
-0.0585713163,
-0.01811097,
-0.0525662042,
0.0896097869,
-0.06782417,
-0.0206892956,
-0.0384732671,
-0.0365890451,
-0.0521243513,
-0.0075876475,
0.0603414215,
0.0368941352,
0.0057559465,
0.0024292259,
-0.0298599973,
0.0690587386,
-0.0479348339,
0.0123477904,
-0.0070209904,
-0.0167360809,
0.0032601596,
0.010304017,
0.0139280995,
-0.0143621136,
-0.0123078106,
0.0686646625,
0.0239514224,
-0.0277065095,
-0.0413205437,
-0.0279387012,
-0.0056863045,
-0.0076187593,
0.0438600853,
-0.0466791317,
0.0246781465,
0.0072789141,
-0.000090918,
-0.0349810757,
-0.0008096188,
0.0141021926,
-0.001553503,
0.0280460026,
0.0140731586,
-0.0320068374,
-0.0301358104,
-0.0445525944,
-0.023652425,
0.0366477519,
0.0349227935,
-0.0144085959,
-0.0357435346,
-0.0006576321,
-0.0257875826,
0.0121207098,
-0.010407621,
-0.0407924429,
-0.0458037034,
-0.0673459843,
-0.0313665606,
0.0153181059,
0.0658778176,
0.0500456057,
-0.0089110071,
-0.0030693922,
0.0291852616,
0.0354159884,
-0.0071261516,
0.0192333199,
0.0786395594,
0.0055966279,
-0.008732846,
0.0549488664,
-0.0576718189,
0.0183984973,
-0.0026352112,
-0.0022694317,
-0.041830074,
0.0223203674,
0.0213179756,
-0.0577330142,
0.0228223391,
-0.0283477679,
-0.0089202402,
-0.0538505651,
0.0338172801,
0.0047577806,
-0.0541479066,
0.0682235211,
0.0117240064,
-0.0220802613,
-0.0232516695,
-0.0082833422,
-0.0293824356,
0.0725316256,
0.0082729347,
-0.0183192063,
0.0206013266,
0.0159134846,
-0.0470658503,
-0.020129364,
-0.0412866622,
-0.0006793813,
0.0229707006,
0.0045721112,
-0.0339036435,
0.0288906787,
0.0269414037,
0.0263946243,
-0.0872733966,
-0.0736823007,
-0.0060287369,
0.062362954,
-0.0236343034,
-0.0047835009,
0.0177788287,
0.0279897675,
-0.0029145712,
0.031695649,
-0.0026414725,
0.0309993923,
0.0105308406,
0.0286505874,
0.020711055,
-0.0584879108,
0.014935514,
0.0107988277,
-0.0628676191,
-0.0572074242,
0.0189572182,
-0.0766336024,
0.0122423824,
0.0245309155,
-0.0077330051,
-0.022825893,
0.0251115933,
-0.0397941656,
0.0085852025,
0.0066027357,
0.0082055908,
0.0399180241,
-0.0078782858,
-0.0240325443,
0.0922218785,
-0.0229874812,
0.0040401621,
-0.0689401031,
-0.023018593,
-0.0136068631,
-0.0216781888,
-0.020112671,
-0.0023642827,
0.0210096464,
-0.0294399932,
-0.0175604858,
-0.0090580648,
-0.0174316466,
0.0106085539,
-0.0670078471,
-0.0570110753,
-0.0070275343,
0.0307484716,
0.0517170988,
0.0068334611,
0.028947439,
-0.0039821113,
0.0012071409,
0.0560281463,
-0.0206979048,
-0.0126846284,
0.033004079,
-0.0001280471,
-0.0107965134,
0.0115700979,
-0.0446168333,
-0.0665234327,
0.0700751245,
0.0033332831,
-0.068089813,
-0.0183906332,
0.0475503616,
0.0175276119,
0.0460752212,
0.0261410065,
-0.0233072154,
0.0380800255,
-0.0327947363,
0.0086154919,
0.0601493642,
-0.0349895954,
-0.0346879028,
0.0165487155,
-0.0301339887,
-0.0065730535,
0.0231383536,
0.0148925753,
0.0721766576,
-0.0453379229,
-0.0007382996,
-0.034845382,
0.0734212399,
0.0287489332,
0.0014073192,
-0.0270086471,
-0.0154219512,
-0.0144898798,
-0.0124598201,
0.004050571,
-0.0497261621,
-0.021720456,
-0.0276475511,
-0.0261228271,
-0.0153978514,
0.076982379,
-0.0162493791,
-0.0234004539,
0.0013977225,
0.0188138727,
-0.0389471985,
0.0532138273,
0.0629211962,
0.0140066389,
0.0180848539,
-0.0462323315,
-0.0338866599,
0.0386199467,
0.0158553012,
0.0068179439,
0.0663010627,
-0.0447576977,
0.0399153009,
0.0097480677,
-0.0427326746,
-0.0103136972,
0.00234405,
0.0028109062,
0.0583197996,
0.0271705277,
-0.012815224,
0.0448011272,
0.017569378,
-0.0005449323,
0.0332244486,
-0.0120510766,
-0.015472997,
-0.0380350538,
0.0804997981,
0.0168840885,
0.0090334611,
0.0320941508,
-0.011340946,
0.0113585312,
0.0337103531,
0.006882749,
0.0224061012,
-0.0719527677,
0.0244930591,
-0.0251930673,
0.030115772,
-0.0424370915,
-0.0280665848,
-0.0277867131,
-0.0543191545,
-0.0078639174,
0.0438176133,
0.0008612808,
-0.0552106388,
0.0329909213,
0.003674628,
0.0325421542,
0.014526925,
0.0345863439,
-0.078788802,
0.0003528741,
0.0052161491,
0.0170102287,
0.0209316313,
-0.0552027412,
0.0377124511,
-0.1161335111,
0.0145656941,
0.0230917837,
0.0233609993,
-0.0131165478,
0.0204823762,
-0.0041842861,
0.0060180696,
-0.0401840657,
0.0197175108,
-0.0308869649,
-0.0255738795,
0.0321562439,
-0.0406021997,
-0.0430495813,
-0.0103424983,
-0.0130006392,
-0.0188199077,
0.0418573357,
-0.0025606649,
-0.0279510859,
-0.0055830986,
0.0320866518,
0.0113991229,
0.0497159436,
-0.0199812129,
0.0176720191,
0.0411350764,
-0.0089948326,
-0.0280333385,
0.0090649091,
-0.0049538035,
0.0032656216,
-0.0571317151,
0.0792660937,
-0.0472502299,
-0.0130470255,
0.0154084628,
-0.0190281682,
0.0110343816,
0.0000408791,
0.0405824594,
-0.0200747307,
-0.0501786992,
-0.0409182943,
0.0085732387,
-0.085058935,
-0.0009766395,
0.04867208,
0.0320875421,
-0.0287128724,
-0.0805081353,
-0.0197255798,
-0.0021278891,
0.021695327,
-0.0311797187,
-0.0374956504,
0.0496699996,
-0.0494927131,
0.0239873268,
0.0546089374,
0.0366519354,
0.0122527471,
-0.0436208583,
-0.0118484981,
0.0240364913,
0.0011418558,
-0.0535472669,
-0.0248432532,
-0.0252259597,
-0.015406182,
0.0146846324,
0.0699543953,
0.007136683,
-0.0200487711,
-0.034752205,
-0.0384179503,
-0.0309596024,
0.0726676807,
-0.0527961813,
0.0178712904,
0.0200872775,
0.0159006715,
0.0042165387,
0.0250974428,
0.0319187641,
0.0237449091,
-0.0191350933,
0.0527686775,
-0.0221190546,
-0.000462451,
0.058750201,
0.0704393759,
0.0573167354,
0.0204700455,
0.0364277959,
-0.0352454856,
0.0423768945,
-0.0472669154,
-0.0054201293,
-0.0488941856,
-0.0048718876,
0.0213391073,
0.0319496542,
0.0157554429,
-0.0743499398,
0.0785803944,
-0.0323773362,
-0.036836829,
0.025984196,
0.0596485212,
0.0349423327,
-0.0175518449,
0.0068524759,
-0.0152369626,
-0.0220951587,
0.0307524074,
0.0393515043,
-0.0416291691,
0.0197870973,
0.0060105845,
-0.0398122482,
-0.0791027099,
0.0105640851,
-0.0231783371,
0.0042659175,
0.006631285,
-0.0180609152,
0.0898651704,
-0.0009004773,
0.0809263065,
0.0130827362,
0.0312046986,
-0.0041104965,
0.0483733565,
0.0369806774,
-0.005879736,
0.043331407,
0.0091131441,
0.0262808148,
-0.0424334444,
0.0287291687,
-0.029259894,
0.0163423643,
-0.0734988078,
0.0042991391,
-0.0236063376,
-0.0468313433,
-0.0472323485,
-0.0093148779,
-0.0629630461,
0.0133152213,
-0.0675023273,
-0.0234247763,
0.0000802428,
0.0231327657,
0.0128520029,
-0.0222928096,
0.072132282,
-0.004169987,
-0.0072426079,
-0.0792371109,
-0.0110018877,
0.0073936386,
0.01636572,
-0.0223254021,
-0.0227122717,
-6.062611747e-33,
-0.0405214168,
-0.0057823006,
0.0142606702,
-0.0013276601,
-0.0514124483,
0.0216042548,
-0.0199909098,
0.0088347951,
0.0081346361,
0.0023063535,
0.0042920779,
-0.026447909,
0.0150456876,
0.0234345756,
0.0629209429,
-0.0184958633,
0.0302469451,
-0.0148453657,
0.0143900765,
-0.0120750545,
0.0935245678,
0.0783608407,
0.0886320993,
-0.0381766967,
-0.0080704428,
0.0107460925,
-0.0102657257,
0.0222258605,
-0.0296111125,
0.0118988752,
-0.0114104869,
-0.0164793748,
0.0435671248,
0.0191205367,
-0.0081097409,
-0.0111740706,
-0.0805366263,
0.0096420832,
0.003473643,
0.0221089926,
-0.0389760919,
-0.0276930481,
0.0900699794,
0.025689207,
-0.0086079948,
-0.0258267447,
0.0182706434,
-0.0494037643,
0.0415501818,
0.024122728,
-0.0514618158,
-0.0009695885,
-0.0028255905,
0.0568334907,
0.0331709646,
0.093443349,
-0.0370244831,
-0.0287133027,
-0.0150150694,
0.0095571196,
-0.003214702,
0.033742439,
0.0322312675,
-0.0307466742,
0.010606776,
0.0526931323,
0.0417551249,
-0.0604667142,
-0.0402913131,
0.0256001335,
0.0376066379,
0.1027796268,
-0.00823709,
-0.0327358395,
0.0224786103,
0.0122611541,
-0.0787347034,
0.0270628706,
0.0267886706,
0.0903119072,
-0.0334581174,
0.0095386012,
-0.0394431613,
-0.0091236606,
0.0123152705,
-0.009233118,
-0.0028951163,
-0.0476637296,
-0.0165025145,
-0.0295974817,
-0.0033014501,
0.0256771352,
0.0315964594,
-0.019835189,
-0.016803164,
0.022797754,
0.0327976309,
0.0628184155,
-0.0119051561,
0.0176431406,
0.0019038876,
-0.0309455041,
-0.0294870269,
-0.0085035972,
0.0638127401,
-0.0088831587,
0.0203147996,
0.0271201637,
-0.0337385759,
-0.0039444095,
-0.0535246767,
-0.052445583,
0.0008776323,
0.0692882389,
0.0516776107,
0.0166756157,
-0.0218979549,
0.0490584485,
-0.0484513417,
0.0347770341,
-0.0161407329,
0.0200930946,
0.0203878842,
0.0673371851,
-0.0059695663,
-0.0288849268,
0.0036993916,
0.0011414695,
-0.0038935072,
-0.0345134139,
-0.0360735692,
0.0578002334,
2.861e-7,
0.0599450134,
0.0055232681,
0.0564660095,
-0.0015027263,
0.0205860119,
-0.0190013275,
-0.0379951485,
0.0098965513,
-0.0291455556,
0.0036717681,
0.0081571806,
-0.0076225628,
0.0196031574,
0.0266178586,
-0.0906182751,
-0.0363677479,
-0.003078558,
-0.0370275229,
-0.0061799227,
0.0034232659,
0.0573548973,
0.0160291959,
-0.0336339027,
-0.0091363816,
-0.0160811488,
0.0130461203,
0.0274797659,
0.0262511391,
0.0110438736,
-0.0397206023,
-0.0416438654,
-0.0671321526,
-0.0113000218,
0.0841906071,
0.0227513537,
0.0166815333,
0.0238068849,
0.0230845809,
0.0029960612,
0.0158969555,
0.0376310796,
0.0062650554,
0.0065536844,
0.0116799409,
0.0414405018,
-0.0268792193,
-0.0079259695,
0.0047144927,
-0.0672254264,
-0.0132804587,
-0.020079026,
0.0119916899,
0.0201627892,
0.0093633281,
0.0058952775,
-0.0425118692,
-0.0041077808,
0.003880691,
0.0151823126,
0.0874564201,
0.0060569914,
-0.0161065627,
0.0103771379,
0.0168406647,
0.0335786641,
0.0154846516,
-0.0446982794,
2.47854591e-34,
-0.0052053225,
-0.0263611246,
0.0603615493,
0.0536195152,
0.0282972194,
-0.018243352,
-0.062199235,
-0.0028113881,
-0.0120194536,
-0.1106907725,
-0.0124655701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10452v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10452v1 | MISMATCH: Fine-grained Evaluation of Machine-generated Text with Mismatch Error Types | 2023-06-18T01:38:53 | 2023-06-18T01:38:53 | Keerthiram Murugesan, Sarathkrishna Swaminathan, Soham Dan, Subhajit Chaudhury, Chulaka Gunasekara, Maxwell Crouse, Diwakar Mahajan, Ibrahim Abdelaziz, Achille Fokoue, Pavan Kapanipathi, Salim Roukos, Alexander Gray | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the growing interest in large language models, the need for evaluating
the quality of machine text compared to reference (typically human-generated)
text has become focal attention. Most recent works focus either on
task-specific evaluation metrics or study the properties of machine-generated
text captured by the existing metrics. In this work, we propose a new
evaluation scheme to model human judgments in 7 NLP tasks, based on the
fine-grained mismatches between a pair of texts. Inspired by the recent efforts
in several NLP tasks for fine-grained evaluation, we introduce a set of 13
mismatch error types such as spatial/geographic errors, entity errors, etc, to
guide the model for better prediction of human judgments. We propose a neural
framework for evaluating machine texts that uses these mismatch error types as
auxiliary tasks and re-purposes the existing single-number evaluation metrics
as additional scalar features, in addition to textual features extracted from
the machine and reference texts. Our experiments reveal key insights about the
existing metrics via the mismatch errors. We show that the mismatch errors
between the sentence pairs on the held-out datasets from 7 NLP tasks align well
with the human evaluation. | [
0.048954092,
0.0467020459,
-0.0048899907,
0.0256555844,
-0.043419484,
0.0312636159,
-0.0064198584,
0.0097232014,
0.0133242253,
-0.0845638588,
-0.0420657396,
-0.0287845153,
0.0564614944,
0.0071448889,
0.0449240245,
-0.0545980781,
0.0404661596,
0.017179843,
0.0030958767,
0.0301958956,
0.0220862236,
0.0216555782,
-0.0121379588,
0.0397959985,
-0.0123896096,
-0.008546548,
0.0222174283,
0.0293351784,
0.0397205241,
-0.0121668419,
0.0680194795,
0.0590023436,
-0.0354566239,
0.0454889573,
0.0000017931,
-0.014243748,
0.0221897699,
0.0024167632,
-0.0054609547,
0.0204408709,
0.0249320026,
-0.0174338408,
-0.012560484,
-0.0094391648,
-0.0222204179,
-0.0297719948,
0.0323310606,
0.0697174221,
0.0449845791,
0.0855913162,
-0.0029317411,
0.0211837366,
-0.007146378,
-0.0152762625,
0.0058554406,
-0.0332662091,
0.0146308076,
-0.001999828,
-0.0106401015,
0.0386355594,
0.0266839489,
-0.0119284336,
-0.0080783628,
0.0269760247,
0.0272684116,
0.0095403949,
-0.035470292,
0.0024253426,
-0.0298801288,
0.0775374323,
-0.0109901521,
-0.0401059203,
0.0017233477,
-0.0301990304,
0.0100171734,
-0.0120302895,
0.0231830012,
-0.0163470041,
-0.0074904826,
0.0522412509,
0.0094392756,
0.0115155624,
0.0257587973,
0.0348033495,
0.0315067731,
0.0253533609,
0.0068611996,
-0.0638813376,
-0.0317617804,
0.0493848808,
-0.0158350375,
-0.0463204533,
0.0175441261,
0.0039360002,
-0.0453833081,
-0.0374362879,
-0.0799002647,
-0.0438987687,
0.0402808525,
-0.0469697081,
0.0392654575,
-0.0106259994,
-0.0306517016,
0.0529839434,
-0.0363441147,
0.1093332618,
0.0221762899,
0.0199809577,
-0.0441121645,
-0.0191995203,
-0.0263213217,
0.0206019972,
-0.0070797619,
0.0031573437,
-0.0381858237,
-0.0137816928,
-0.051258903,
-0.0210201256,
-0.0695298687,
0.0331700519,
0.0081579629,
0.0409990139,
-0.020181302,
-0.0398734063,
-0.0828514621,
-0.0000656914,
-0.033279907,
0.0304791648,
-0.0038768824,
-0.0439492874,
-0.0041787955,
0.0404607579,
0.0016069935,
-0.0134410448,
0.0149250198,
0.0644880533,
0.0110342968,
-0.0125891883,
-0.0285229161,
-0.0122181177,
-0.0212676488,
-0.037288066,
-0.0329253972,
-0.0716291741,
0.0203367434,
-0.0185503159,
-0.0061605186,
-0.0418266021,
0.0044443496,
0.0375864916,
-0.0426793694,
0.0573745593,
-0.0157451481,
0.0153804775,
0.0010283873,
-0.037311472,
0.0041128369,
0.0244422406,
0.0247837175,
0.0265178587,
0.0384169035,
0.0146756582,
0.0260709431,
0.0113693066,
-0.0072873835,
-0.0208876822,
-0.029124612,
-0.0013741152,
-0.0148152411,
0.059428297,
0.0517409518,
0.0941235945,
-0.0396099947,
0.0021098992,
0.0688035935,
0.0163112152,
0.0081741894,
0.0014811315,
0.0626273677,
0.0070208698,
-0.0077651795,
0.0288540553,
-0.077289097,
0.0034914799,
-0.0404421873,
-0.0006954747,
0.0770076662,
0.023594223,
-0.0217576511,
-0.0532134809,
-0.0201812238,
-0.0112254694,
0.0214481205,
-0.0267696958,
0.0296419766,
0.0324354135,
-0.0367894284,
0.0284788646,
-0.0060769427,
-0.0230966303,
0.0115052853,
-0.0188749451,
-0.0156261567,
0.0801064968,
0.0444550067,
-0.0005312006,
-0.0100823482,
-0.0010586885,
-0.0300573502,
0.0412039161,
0.1044831276,
-0.0195566323,
-0.0189574771,
-0.0420653261,
0.0036144513,
0.0061291414,
0.0448419526,
-0.0333880521,
0.0451847315,
-0.001137784,
0.0490496121,
-0.0667451918,
-0.0561270602,
0.0387977287,
0.0097229667,
-0.0311234202,
-0.0098797716,
0.0214589946,
0.0132317003,
0.0032621915,
-0.0156818368,
0.0395552814,
0.009660624,
0.0024538867,
-0.0347119831,
-0.0282804314,
-0.016969597,
-0.0337813646,
0.0256701615,
-0.0515677668,
-0.0577672273,
0.0432703979,
-0.058164265,
-0.0236226451,
-0.0158058647,
-0.0453958511,
-0.0199023094,
-0.048793193,
0.0424539819,
0.0072442633,
0.007752513,
-0.0569835417,
0.0621089227,
0.0045862878,
0.0678642765,
-0.0114912735,
-0.0067988266,
0.0015396907,
-0.026411077,
-0.0435933322,
-0.0257765651,
-0.0228337813,
0.0441975296,
0.0153172985,
0.0060196035,
-0.0680085793,
-0.0527958125,
-0.0820325762,
0.0075869961,
-0.0150658283,
0.0251382422,
0.0585680678,
-0.0394058675,
-0.0007348483,
-0.0220810175,
-0.0322103351,
-0.0222958028,
0.0392693058,
0.0073457728,
0.0756338537,
-0.0403236263,
0.0528243147,
-0.0358074009,
-0.0060983016,
-0.0324264243,
0.0449433997,
-0.0027141313,
-0.0047963839,
-0.1027849689,
0.0679817498,
-0.024225913,
0.0211440474,
0.0370002463,
-0.0464752354,
0.0012715426,
0.0014703936,
0.0272987299,
0.0293643419,
0.0004596412,
0.0062090727,
0.014469116,
-0.0125268502,
-0.0467612334,
-0.0127123622,
-0.0210681166,
0.0082927868,
-0.005565051,
-0.0434258915,
-0.0057796817,
0.0256493613,
0.0126508744,
-0.0037147983,
-0.0358920433,
0.0527894981,
-0.0443476811,
-0.0047576409,
0.0045298738,
-0.0053627784,
0.0052605718,
0.0475460812,
-0.0613353103,
-0.0201598722,
0.0969612673,
-0.0304590371,
0.0363462158,
-0.0631435812,
0.0035170531,
-0.0159216002,
0.0189067367,
0.0020873721,
0.0206610113,
-0.0018987797,
-0.0089055914,
-0.0577658564,
-0.0090924362,
0.0091551449,
-0.0280737896,
0.0643361136,
-0.0484723561,
0.0036549289,
0.0048207161,
-0.0574323349,
-0.0269236322,
-0.0543353893,
-0.0114594204,
-0.0116508966,
0.0210990533,
-0.0146867847,
-0.0375275798,
-0.0165753737,
-0.0235203858,
0.0149674565,
-0.0240861289,
-0.0077589215,
-0.0358309373,
0.0611771829,
0.03760463,
0.0615639016,
0.027751755,
-0.0179879963,
-0.0227054749,
0.0140483398,
0.0270714723,
0.049460154,
-0.0244119056,
0.0072118589,
0.0411865264,
-0.020597076,
-0.0390930176,
0.0167216565,
0.0676709712,
-0.0441590957,
-0.0241962411,
0.1033016816,
0.0355178006,
-0.0354768932,
-0.005071518,
-0.0065397178,
0.0123201963,
0.00221629,
0.0291826855,
-0.0433414765,
-0.04299891,
0.0261432994,
-0.0002305677,
-0.0193599276,
-0.0160722882,
0.0220886208,
-0.1446711868,
0.0141219525,
0.0235217493,
-0.0411476605,
-0.0965281352,
-0.0136504034,
0.0288368389,
-0.0149596334,
0.0408244319,
0.0173515156,
-0.0108101582,
0.011512287,
0.0166800041,
-0.0068890951,
-0.1065194234,
0.0305012874,
-0.0484548323,
0.0986650288,
0.0614813007,
0.0379129127,
0.0052931858,
-0.0420585684,
0.0074894726,
-0.0182283651,
0.0029475021,
0.0385663845,
0.0838821456,
-0.002361028,
-0.0223101079,
-0.0378103778,
-0.0097703282,
-0.0120415017,
-0.02498045,
-0.0561885238,
0.0406134985,
-0.0177830886,
-0.0096239904,
-0.0016841787,
0.0164827947,
0.0331627205,
0.0617855228,
0.028688794,
-0.0344257541,
-0.0768992156,
-0.0183724463,
0.021020446,
-0.0651588812,
0.0076046805,
0.045980271,
0.0054416046,
-0.0058953441,
-0.0822515637,
-0.0982252061,
-0.0007408382,
-0.0131878043,
0.007931768,
-0.0310934298,
0.0143204154,
-0.0340204835,
-0.0186226051,
0.0344541632,
-0.00572201,
0.0494706258,
-0.0409002118,
0.0157637633,
-0.0239040684,
0.0081962626,
-0.0082519865,
0.0374149978,
-0.1034709439,
-0.0428747125,
-0.0037239776,
0.0289382506,
0.013084908,
0.0138636231,
-0.0528832413,
-0.0549837016,
0.0160091072,
0.0656923205,
-0.0411446281,
0.0274941865,
0.0003067661,
-0.016270401,
-0.0189512912,
0.0290904231,
-0.0364480205,
0.0190354083,
-0.0034544084,
0.0462878197,
-0.0014104252,
-0.0481567718,
0.0344531052,
0.0092810271,
0.063193813,
-0.0092880968,
0.0188109055,
-0.0289882123,
-0.0268657953,
0.0107760187,
-0.0424037501,
-0.0107558388,
-0.015422943,
0.0155368047,
0.0195066519,
-0.0122029223,
0.0147516206,
-0.0192058049,
0.0355727039,
-0.0317530632,
-0.0402348153,
0.0367309526,
0.0444965698,
-0.0050819712,
0.013972586,
-0.0370336063,
0.0099166827,
-0.0263327006,
0.0347670279,
-0.0204218365,
0.0176594853,
0.040948011,
0.0131830489,
-0.0260524433,
0.0311797019,
-0.0366496593,
-0.0087805046,
-0.0644934252,
-0.0067617996,
0.0726231784,
-0.0191600565,
0.0547097623,
0.0060445978,
-0.0202377588,
-0.0230518319,
0.0184521489,
0.0087360134,
0.0033488334,
0.004067447,
0.0165258627,
-0.0015852703,
-0.0060214084,
0.0784041286,
-0.020758735,
0.0450228713,
0.001338702,
-0.0250205379,
-0.022507973,
-0.0123801306,
-0.0289590452,
-0.0163167696,
-0.0112599283,
-0.0203189533,
-0.0584380217,
-0.0912317336,
0.043519903,
0.0523907281,
0.0272275582,
0.0075350176,
0.0177888274,
0.0363145284,
-0.0097447168,
0.033170253,
-0.0626426786,
-0.0100876167,
0.009553575,
-0.0195256174,
-0.0821033791,
-6.359486151e-33,
-0.0375636928,
-0.0761784762,
-0.0093793869,
-0.0551244467,
-0.0093845027,
0.0074956943,
-0.0002952382,
-0.0065964051,
-0.0021089769,
0.028380679,
0.0011442236,
0.010974233,
0.0142233055,
0.0192139521,
0.0210494753,
-0.0226029959,
0.0465751328,
-0.0051258923,
-0.0030134188,
-0.0123300888,
0.0274259187,
0.0053297435,
0.0381674469,
-0.066177316,
0.0667092502,
0.0070568197,
-0.04178112,
0.0168752559,
0.0127741694,
0.0596392117,
-0.0108084874,
0.0673679411,
0.0399786904,
-0.0054624677,
-0.0224494208,
0.0103774089,
-0.0630698651,
-0.0552377999,
-0.006288202,
-0.0026863741,
-0.0185240749,
-0.0125202099,
0.0453277901,
-0.0284603611,
-0.036865741,
0.0293734781,
0.0579975061,
-0.0302147754,
0.0097668003,
0.0266958456,
-0.0470767021,
0.0203253813,
0.0200615525,
-0.013568894,
0.0032600402,
0.0720659271,
-0.0117415385,
0.0227021147,
-0.0761906877,
0.009833823,
-0.0003699464,
0.0486946739,
0.0049634357,
-0.007121468,
-0.0360268541,
0.0814943686,
0.0174666382,
0.00650978,
-0.0441983081,
-0.0242277868,
0.0192226712,
0.0210083071,
0.0597739592,
0.0866715908,
0.0400489122,
-0.0162685476,
-0.0291925427,
0.0526110008,
-0.0391595587,
0.0224270709,
0.0052808113,
-0.0208268445,
-0.0391911641,
-0.0095081255,
-0.0514851213,
-0.0335211158,
-0.0684198439,
0.0033463188,
0.0275509264,
0.0024792892,
0.0387665741,
0.0220986102,
-0.0180374533,
-0.046521686,
-0.0006117377,
-0.0099668521,
-0.0210973918,
-0.0120149711,
0.0064542941,
0.0188489631,
-0.0348410718,
-0.0453436263,
0.0185375903,
0.0644024014,
0.0356338508,
-0.0014286155,
0.0391266644,
-0.0079610674,
-0.0736873671,
0.0436995551,
-0.0158697143,
0.0035896783,
-0.0115121547,
-0.0180872716,
0.0248396099,
-0.0134327132,
-0.0159308296,
0.0022463964,
0.0137414262,
0.0155261029,
0.0094071943,
0.0079961186,
-0.0042935838,
0.0265354309,
0.0012514996,
0.0103753014,
-0.0312838256,
-0.0120980116,
0.0069207423,
-0.0050779455,
0.0223319549,
0.0039580464,
2.541e-7,
0.0158351455,
0.0655059665,
0.0266883262,
-0.0060257986,
0.0045847949,
0.0576422587,
-0.0057931864,
0.0332746617,
-0.0193516836,
0.0297380742,
0.0261867642,
-0.0071337041,
0.0742375776,
0.0182426088,
-0.060315609,
0.0345034972,
-0.0682775229,
0.0127666574,
-0.0110924607,
-0.0239478443,
0.0816667452,
0.0373090282,
0.0293923784,
-0.0026287488,
-0.0069841817,
-0.0359891951,
0.0447480902,
-0.0310409795,
-0.0205449089,
0.0160449985,
0.0530125275,
0.0088374382,
0.0040427237,
0.0619166382,
-0.0032712456,
-0.0382158533,
0.0702846199,
0.039381355,
-0.0037511559,
-0.0205623023,
-0.0570528954,
-0.0094663305,
-0.0014929627,
-0.0599525422,
0.0411092602,
-0.0508223362,
-0.0163472984,
-0.0347917154,
-0.0368576124,
0.0153871365,
0.0474569872,
-0.0033193761,
-0.0564701073,
0.0060817967,
0.0414506868,
0.0417660512,
-0.0449462086,
-0.062185064,
-0.0408566669,
0.0405230336,
-0.0045217937,
-0.036929328,
-0.0219541769,
0.0080316318,
0.0495931692,
-0.0641486347,
0.0110628409,
2.231778192e-34,
0.0591348596,
-0.013193978,
0.0131919933,
-0.0372330695,
0.0336658321,
0.0222049151,
-0.0294225495,
-0.0029027509,
-0.0063013863,
-0.0290963836,
0.0238309707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10448v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10448v1 | Generation of Radiology Findings in Chest X-Ray by Leveraging Collaborative Knowledge | 2023-06-18T00:51:28 | 2023-06-18T00:51:28 | Manuela Daniela Danu, George Marica, Sanjeev Kumar Karn, Bogdan Georgescu, Awais Mansoor, Florin Ghesu, Lucian Mihai Itu, Constantin Suciu, Sasa Grbic, Oladimeji Farri, Dorin Comaniciu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Among all the sub-sections in a typical radiology report, the Clinical
Indications, Findings, and Impression often reflect important details about the
health status of a patient. The information included in Impression is also
often covered in Findings. While Findings and Impression can be deduced by
inspecting the image, Clinical Indications often require additional context.
The cognitive task of interpreting medical images remains the most critical and
often time-consuming step in the radiology workflow. Instead of generating an
end-to-end radiology report, in this paper, we focus on generating the Findings
from automated interpretation of medical images, specifically chest X-rays
(CXRs). Thus, this work focuses on reducing the workload of radiologists who
spend most of their time either writing or narrating the Findings. Unlike past
research, which addresses radiology report generation as a single-step image
captioning task, we have further taken into consideration the complexity of
interpreting CXR images and propose a two-step approach: (a) detecting the
regions with abnormalities in the image, and (b) generating relevant text for
regions with abnormalities by employing a generative large language model
(LLM). This two-step approach introduces a layer of interpretability and aligns
the framework with the systematic reasoning that radiologists use when
reviewing a CXR. | [
0.0533588491,
0.0302913375,
0.0137270559,
-0.0013083942,
-0.019619355,
0.0440191366,
-0.0181179959,
0.0338523351,
-0.0065386347,
-0.0101020532,
0.0002590774,
-0.0339521393,
0.0137663921,
0.0482854247,
-0.0014482064,
-0.1055177525,
-0.0151710724,
-0.0239764731,
0.0335592814,
-0.0109372744,
-0.0061742635,
0.0093025891,
0.0123945363,
0.0156516396,
-0.0115089482,
-0.0142077263,
0.0195866749,
0.0147188846,
0.0254004262,
-0.0236533768,
-0.0680423751,
0.0497584566,
0.0153775699,
0.0024965056,
0.0000020015,
-0.019262122,
-0.0105908308,
0.0225531757,
0.0011437093,
-0.0288255084,
0.0672564209,
-0.0632960796,
-0.0284948386,
-0.0166766066,
-0.0398963839,
-0.0580186769,
0.0526969284,
0.0322440453,
0.0890565664,
0.0504155084,
-0.0264995694,
-0.0010054129,
-0.0439413637,
-0.0164672211,
0.0280291177,
-0.0536224023,
0.0154474312,
0.06563472,
0.0431379974,
0.0405628271,
-0.0149345258,
0.0341672972,
0.0169928093,
-0.0395294502,
0.0062698121,
0.0768380985,
0.0312646292,
-0.013915387,
0.0036176071,
0.0666686669,
-0.023214804,
0.0192104559,
0.0083200512,
-0.0117363427,
-0.0213890858,
0.0109952549,
-0.0388142392,
0.0553731583,
-0.0165358651,
-0.0102379499,
0.009565453,
0.0106923068,
-0.0086933104,
0.005594071,
-0.0412942693,
-0.0262009222,
-0.000085177,
-0.0007118371,
-0.0280087944,
0.0262835249,
-0.0337032266,
-0.0878095552,
0.0336077102,
0.0625081509,
-0.06286522,
0.0180738401,
-0.0149414828,
-0.0249048267,
0.0557023473,
-0.0515132919,
-0.0281084403,
-0.0288410056,
-0.032561101,
0.0879973546,
-0.007502568,
0.0212436616,
-0.0387347341,
0.0240942724,
-0.0563487224,
0.0115002487,
-0.0414677486,
-0.0311649293,
-0.0322287939,
0.0114313383,
-0.0176172983,
-0.0464910865,
-0.0729971901,
-0.0003596402,
-0.0176706221,
0.0403901264,
0.0565965362,
0.0540726781,
-0.0613097474,
0.0136141907,
-0.0032600344,
0.0187323894,
-0.003129689,
-0.023017399,
-0.0191567931,
0.0103148334,
0.0165187493,
0.065346159,
0.0151749253,
0.0272046346,
-0.0247761831,
0.0159419887,
-0.0087778028,
0.0267476309,
0.0171147138,
-0.0938955992,
-0.0554846972,
-0.0573206432,
0.0180961955,
-0.0709719434,
0.0185596235,
0.0159360152,
0.0061860969,
-0.0050709625,
0.0136130154,
-0.0044948505,
-0.0207018945,
0.0697685406,
-0.054962635,
0.0100343078,
0.0390478335,
0.0479304418,
0.0422427617,
0.0261293408,
0.0138913365,
0.0546254478,
-0.0021981555,
0.0008682474,
0.0270960238,
0.0150209097,
-0.0334328488,
-0.0500938594,
-0.0286294799,
-0.0044101276,
-0.0203884449,
0.0823411942,
0.0114513133,
0.0587667935,
-0.0199753623,
0.0329697393,
0.0252330396,
0.0397545472,
0.006587503,
0.0225683637,
0.0620932318,
-0.0070631467,
-0.0299611557,
0.0233679861,
-0.0134210913,
0.0442770086,
0.0619433671,
0.0206394605,
-0.0308948774,
-0.0038920462,
-0.0220516957,
-0.0386057273,
-0.0310403798,
-0.0025318689,
-0.013417799,
-0.0017199649,
0.0720855743,
0.0133948699,
-0.0581325442,
0.0059847739,
0.0197256375,
-0.0204781499,
0.0069656521,
-0.0583706796,
0.0208948106,
0.0916707814,
0.0701510906,
0.0060088034,
-0.018186314,
0.0185760427,
0.058468312,
0.0522616804,
0.0184552278,
0.0002625614,
-0.0222397037,
-0.0650178045,
-0.0606325418,
0.0339783803,
0.006914854,
-0.014210497,
-0.003268643,
-0.0087017277,
0.0035265733,
-0.0218054745,
-0.0671221018,
0.0283460785,
-0.0227907952,
-0.0213301461,
-0.0148067987,
0.0163908489,
0.0021925461,
0.0242844373,
-0.0337367915,
0.0151639441,
0.0162314996,
-0.0113376323,
-0.0505565926,
0.0756722391,
-0.0598482415,
-0.013697356,
-0.002334473,
-0.0850819647,
-0.0197380614,
-0.0493586808,
-0.039788086,
-0.0333127379,
-0.0116017796,
-0.0733505711,
-0.0067721405,
-0.0383797362,
0.0159131847,
0.0616028868,
-0.0119843157,
-0.0155708445,
0.0813956037,
0.0024398523,
-0.0023475343,
0.0575832464,
0.0049024397,
-0.0190226603,
-0.0397076719,
-0.0024400058,
0.0318436995,
0.0331868343,
0.0056820046,
-0.0004819428,
0.0363122933,
-0.017250618,
-0.0253134742,
-0.0648070872,
-0.0130152581,
0.0046513244,
-0.0253658947,
0.0559387542,
0.0022492995,
0.0058189174,
-0.0195404626,
-0.0184182525,
-0.0005077398,
0.0607576109,
0.0063147806,
0.0527077653,
0.027254425,
0.0051254309,
-0.0102256555,
0.0007818718,
-0.0097363004,
0.0442059003,
0.0886364281,
-0.0208203625,
-0.0588352233,
0.0620911047,
-0.0134921791,
-0.0092369849,
0.0050208443,
-0.0355696678,
0.0380534232,
-0.0429909825,
-0.0187385175,
0.0691277236,
0.0133630289,
0.0531889535,
0.0229920261,
-0.0299670845,
-0.0130362445,
-0.0174815971,
-0.0394828208,
-0.0556511022,
0.0413258001,
-0.0969272852,
-0.0122637404,
0.0661048517,
0.0266280174,
0.026067378,
-0.0319728665,
-0.0266692024,
-0.0414882116,
-0.0121758943,
-0.0581389777,
-0.0379999653,
0.0118120797,
0.0397342071,
-0.0315597206,
-0.0406418554,
0.0720465109,
-0.0087686591,
0.0142664006,
-0.0571449585,
0.0003502886,
-0.0427181795,
0.0617999509,
0.0054897629,
0.061305549,
0.0255122129,
-0.0334642194,
-0.0165800732,
-0.0162356719,
0.0304900538,
-0.0493714176,
-0.0081125936,
-0.0528108291,
-0.0111733302,
-0.0089059034,
0.0015888733,
-0.015669195,
0.0202111006,
0.0093327677,
-0.0055418964,
0.0303994771,
0.0013085033,
-0.0586115122,
0.0596311763,
0.0164328814,
0.0043724058,
-0.0021996023,
-0.0228431374,
-0.0181420147,
0.0452323779,
0.0520155467,
0.0131127099,
-0.037853837,
-0.059979856,
-0.0052025947,
0.0823478028,
-0.0567118041,
0.0492211729,
-0.0440380499,
-0.0049568838,
-0.006925799,
0.0057962136,
0.0092220781,
0.0015922973,
0.0497054458,
-0.0432612412,
-0.0132242069,
0.0911733285,
0.0358726457,
-0.0271545462,
-0.0251688305,
0.0066150585,
-0.0299413428,
-0.0085037239,
-0.0049430495,
-0.0279409867,
0.0019340694,
-0.0098348139,
0.0210471302,
-0.0186406989,
-0.0159495417,
-0.002899898,
-0.0357045047,
0.1009640023,
0.002770602,
-0.0273030698,
-0.0456838533,
-0.0459072515,
-0.0086729713,
-0.0118441321,
-0.0449809358,
-0.001287748,
0.0045791725,
0.0057592466,
0.0100665195,
-0.0258707255,
-0.053266976,
-0.0045909439,
-0.0683559477,
-0.0221347082,
0.0598196909,
0.047046639,
-0.0074323602,
-0.0181718674,
-0.037884213,
0.048732426,
0.0328197852,
-0.0039893314,
0.0638715625,
0.0244224276,
-0.0190219563,
-0.060284853,
0.0308925901,
-0.0220304374,
-0.0100362133,
0.0007145501,
0.0326158442,
-0.0304677803,
-0.0458268672,
-0.0585908592,
0.0729544163,
0.0408932269,
0.0508270226,
0.0199233983,
0.020493079,
-0.0391767658,
-0.0085628349,
0.0831159428,
-0.0513301827,
-0.0265576877,
0.0206767302,
-0.0324939489,
-0.0436707996,
-0.0637241974,
-0.0238939207,
0.0522139743,
0.0343156084,
0.0098945694,
0.0225867666,
-0.0116363373,
-0.0221788865,
-0.0632988289,
0.046653863,
0.0051258593,
0.0065458645,
0.0011026263,
-0.0437925458,
0.0491154753,
-0.0227165502,
-0.0073897983,
0.0693972185,
-0.0449412465,
0.008715448,
-0.0203008614,
0.0401059538,
0.02682174,
-0.0228543207,
0.0048573101,
-0.0275994465,
0.0626738966,
0.0390184373,
0.0099029345,
0.0002469155,
-0.0427397527,
-0.0383415408,
-0.0328181349,
-0.0005407832,
-0.0095291864,
0.023579726,
0.0066875261,
0.0417947881,
-0.0625975132,
-0.0470712855,
0.0221277326,
0.0145039614,
-0.0184717756,
-0.0623216033,
-0.0338209011,
-0.0142347002,
-0.0257720016,
-0.025232546,
0.0026998112,
-0.0218692608,
0.0257990938,
0.0223363712,
-0.0105862655,
0.0123263085,
0.0201982856,
-0.035595987,
-0.0250142701,
-0.036671564,
0.0593850315,
0.0146320974,
-0.02954638,
0.0641312972,
-0.0251721386,
-0.0043936209,
-0.0410536118,
-0.0280187409,
0.0021365359,
0.0168723259,
0.0487190671,
0.0270875506,
0.0246128011,
-0.0193958227,
0.0306238681,
0.0025624156,
-0.0497786514,
-0.042846512,
0.0346202664,
0.0533778816,
0.012986959,
0.0012238035,
-0.0499043986,
-0.0005643615,
-0.0078691747,
0.0636248142,
0.0007463068,
-0.0323662758,
0.0427674912,
0.0047561969,
0.0368998796,
-0.0353292711,
0.0976859033,
-0.0148738688,
0.0206725094,
-0.0124886213,
-0.0639161095,
-0.0619356707,
-0.0396397971,
-0.0030039488,
-0.0136775896,
-0.0361491293,
0.0284311306,
-0.0315245092,
-0.0518269762,
0.0035747325,
0.025733823,
-0.0005864378,
0.0075124195,
0.0607350692,
0.0675239041,
0.0041745231,
-0.0244914331,
-0.0208625738,
0.0507895835,
-0.0154074933,
-0.0122547606,
-0.0005017996,
-5.659304043e-33,
-0.0119030736,
-0.0963755399,
0.0494393632,
-0.0422907732,
0.0107897539,
0.0297476593,
-0.0546968877,
-0.0090718819,
0.0375782698,
0.0207521822,
0.003002095,
-0.0360165983,
0.0265730992,
0.0209964383,
-0.0060194442,
0.0236694198,
0.0444723815,
-0.0085618487,
-0.0253089145,
0.0258526057,
-0.0058197817,
0.0056809094,
0.0240458716,
-0.090123415,
-0.0022913164,
-0.0043424037,
-0.0181071814,
0.0101102125,
0.0223824326,
0.0342771374,
-0.0398358069,
0.0132224755,
0.0215274375,
-0.0608071201,
-0.0198950022,
0.0435970947,
-0.057557866,
-0.0051229391,
0.0368896313,
-0.0017399882,
-0.0629004613,
-0.0185406376,
0.0190369692,
-0.0343341939,
0.0424710326,
-0.020312665,
0.0561610684,
-0.0130126011,
-0.0083552357,
-0.0175658688,
-0.0580195412,
0.0503706187,
-0.0086924452,
-0.0230166595,
0.0212554876,
-0.059521243,
-0.0250966419,
0.0288802311,
-0.0123766512,
0.0458098277,
0.075181812,
0.0221659821,
0.0485729314,
-0.0175662525,
-0.018064633,
0.0259893741,
0.0571258739,
-0.0287357029,
-0.0413157754,
0.0151446611,
-0.0466251448,
0.0689920262,
0.0107358303,
0.044024583,
0.0265663508,
0.0064075119,
-0.0584131964,
0.0441353545,
-0.0892480165,
0.082301572,
0.0408392884,
-0.011860515,
-0.0326754339,
0.0037925453,
0.0124464557,
-0.0092652757,
-0.0267339926,
-0.0330677778,
0.005875682,
0.0453572981,
-0.0350277685,
0.0330511145,
0.0275190808,
0.0112043163,
0.0279522762,
-0.0192764867,
0.0463586301,
0.0360471532,
-0.0422408506,
-0.0201532841,
-0.0073033823,
-0.0203682389,
0.0632792711,
0.0105068479,
0.021332249,
0.0433002561,
0.0258457772,
0.0127278734,
-0.0233988613,
0.008954267,
-0.0129369553,
-0.0068597631,
-0.0453625061,
-0.0016835213,
0.0319482051,
-0.0005082335,
-0.0233144164,
-0.0066620768,
-0.0112066381,
0.0258712545,
-0.0151616745,
-0.0295753889,
-0.0080934875,
-0.0103494078,
-0.0649838671,
-0.0122670215,
-0.0057636201,
-0.0084392494,
0.0611795448,
-0.020232439,
-0.0236840416,
0.0359903313,
2.718e-7,
0.0471180342,
0.0329873078,
0.0304863025,
0.0350667909,
0.0258198176,
-0.0153079983,
-0.0195388012,
-0.0048493943,
0.0203285981,
-0.0282885693,
0.0454124063,
0.0321961157,
-0.0013951053,
0.0247897841,
-0.0518456399,
0.0048476807,
0.0007473172,
-0.01681678,
-0.0128597114,
-0.0056090495,
0.0863912106,
0.03579114,
-0.0676908568,
-0.0323136449,
0.03001743,
-0.0412850454,
0.0438166335,
-0.0359095968,
0.0227201302,
0.0108102001,
0.0239054896,
0.0059209731,
-0.0092123505,
0.0707002953,
0.0083869416,
-0.0607839525,
0.027777588,
0.0545016117,
-0.0420166403,
0.0350938328,
0.0140916705,
-0.0008559882,
0.0194391534,
-0.0547694303,
0.0348561332,
-0.0840051621,
-0.028623892,
-0.0261921752,
-0.0254507735,
0.0037779263,
0.0103463074,
-0.0489937104,
-0.012316185,
0.0450468883,
0.0270170327,
0.0037754811,
-0.0328055173,
-0.0645749643,
0.0122341979,
0.0013552813,
-0.0426010452,
-0.0278374292,
0.0059521091,
-0.0221714769,
-0.0035739813,
-0.0472592302,
-0.0050002583,
2.206308995e-34,
0.0345145687,
0.0232921802,
-0.033420682,
0.005115767,
0.0358992144,
0.0006027053,
-0.0291031618,
0.0227699112,
0.0022224784,
-0.0490997992,
-0.019435253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10444v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10444v1 | Universal Information Extraction with Meta-Pretrained Self-Retrieval | 2023-06-18T00:16:00 | 2023-06-18T00:16:00 | Xin Cong. Bowen Yu, Mengcheng Fang, Tingwen Liu, Haiyang Yu, Zhongkai Hu, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li, Bin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Universal Information Extraction~(Universal IE) aims to solve different
extraction tasks in a uniform text-to-structure generation manner. Such a
generation procedure tends to struggle when there exist complex information
structures to be extracted. Retrieving knowledge from external knowledge bases
may help models to overcome this problem but it is impossible to construct a
knowledge base suitable for various IE tasks. Inspired by the fact that large
amount of knowledge are stored in the pretrained language models~(PLM) and can
be retrieved explicitly, in this paper, we propose MetaRetriever to retrieve
task-specific knowledge from PLMs to enhance universal IE. As different IE
tasks need different knowledge, we further propose a Meta-Pretraining Algorithm
which allows MetaRetriever to quicktly achieve maximum task-specific retrieval
performance when fine-tuning on downstream IE tasks. Experimental results show
that MetaRetriever achieves the new state-of-the-art on 4 IE tasks, 12 datasets
under fully-supervised, low-resource and few-shot scenarios. | [
0.0366699584,
-0.0188590232,
0.0129786478,
0.0391174369,
-0.0251787473,
0.0195465088,
-0.027991442,
0.0122766308,
-0.0169374663,
-0.0429806411,
-0.07292974,
0.0426454507,
-0.0521073304,
-0.0029010056,
0.0050137579,
-0.0040301611,
0.0363093205,
0.0096148634,
0.0071154884,
0.0159962121,
0.0014746782,
0.0074371397,
0.0143378489,
-0.0247729961,
0.0055824281,
-0.0031698616,
-0.0092713619,
-0.0144013939,
0.0175246857,
-0.0344250686,
0.0403244123,
0.0012845879,
0.0183348525,
-0.0145287942,
0.000002056,
-0.028757209,
-0.0562640317,
-0.0049568913,
-0.049810905,
-0.0447699614,
0.0118589159,
-0.0180122685,
0.0285021961,
0.0020485483,
-0.0365821496,
-0.0421764776,
0.0029809177,
0.0422662869,
0.0101840775,
0.0866151005,
-0.017138537,
-0.0347510129,
0.0123174302,
-0.0307718143,
0.0425916202,
-0.0378558002,
0.0395486169,
0.0056975391,
-0.0102067115,
0.030965386,
0.0351370201,
0.0494893156,
-0.0038934147,
0.0173387956,
0.0184185207,
0.0170064569,
-0.014634666,
-0.0119714318,
-0.0377960056,
0.1025015637,
0.0031802529,
-0.011448266,
0.0167414267,
0.0011163312,
0.0055958447,
0.0183924884,
-0.0233653933,
0.020550143,
-0.032907702,
0.0022929437,
0.0009000876,
0.038302049,
0.0081533361,
-0.0197124444,
-0.0518999472,
0.0664996058,
0.0009123301,
-0.0409322791,
0.0245627705,
-0.0046703457,
0.0336642489,
-0.0003155849,
-0.009548218,
0.024104476,
0.0444167443,
0.0095225824,
-0.0362207927,
-0.0685164481,
-0.0046152743,
-0.0506992266,
0.0473341383,
0.0385679789,
-0.0403075181,
0.0724689737,
-0.032962326,
0.0192005951,
-0.0388944894,
-0.0035874657,
-0.0342461914,
-0.0197687745,
-0.0829015821,
0.023457991,
-0.0492064059,
0.0695534647,
-0.0320272744,
0.0220383871,
0.0087820338,
0.0272204839,
0.0113120014,
-0.0162134897,
0.0311156008,
-0.0152956164,
-0.0538212545,
-0.0323664472,
-0.0048988047,
0.0169805102,
-0.0359029435,
-0.0194572248,
0.0131613221,
-0.0179638248,
-0.0092719048,
-0.0047756643,
0.04226733,
-0.0382450856,
0.0423075259,
0.0607519709,
-0.0179251973,
-0.0507558845,
-0.0656334087,
-0.0342972949,
0.0120804729,
-0.0697262138,
0.0070111863,
-0.0150580537,
0.0766306967,
0.0025652479,
-0.046477519,
-0.0149610732,
0.0015755609,
-0.0223813858,
-0.0283764191,
0.0600608252,
-0.0597375073,
0.0074081076,
0.0094474871,
-0.0134298103,
-0.01265625,
0.0568464026,
0.0132986577,
0.0439103581,
0.0588137135,
0.0205047969,
0.0031150954,
0.0122795654,
0.0411919095,
-0.0325795263,
0.0367524363,
0.03872329,
-0.0059581995,
-0.0456419066,
0.0302072074,
0.0170558505,
-0.0358274095,
0.0297945663,
0.0224527977,
-0.0296624769,
0.0573160313,
0.0193507336,
0.0599238984,
0.0198010113,
0.0135271633,
0.0170317311,
-0.0443379469,
0.0178831518,
-0.0602710135,
0.0345583744,
-0.0103215696,
0.0233282987,
-0.0439887345,
-0.0413193107,
0.0377134904,
-0.0256026443,
-0.0384715833,
0.0288550872,
0.0953019559,
0.0365387574,
-0.0439323112,
0.0284893457,
0.0353830978,
-0.0792255104,
0.0272835717,
-0.0097796526,
0.0147195691,
0.0372615531,
0.0149369407,
-0.0715871304,
-0.0448071659,
0.022667028,
0.0132320439,
0.0129266754,
0.0014967932,
-0.041664876,
0.0386377536,
-0.0377447121,
-0.0423607901,
-0.0155448383,
0.0014280452,
0.0297758672,
0.0318390876,
0.0131295277,
0.0498841293,
-0.0775811672,
-0.004408027,
0.0516491048,
-0.0373816825,
-0.0538475551,
0.0217437409,
0.0179002397,
-0.0114434222,
0.0151006347,
-0.0498960018,
-0.0133130038,
0.0647673011,
-0.0536172837,
-0.0045658797,
-0.0085649183,
-0.0527139232,
-0.052903261,
0.0268918797,
-0.0064735138,
0.0002854868,
0.0028769842,
-0.0387687311,
-0.0426350906,
-0.0368017703,
0.0744815767,
0.0576349497,
-0.0570032559,
-0.0027803655,
0.0294866096,
-0.0092376247,
-0.0392450392,
0.0759527907,
0.0414511375,
-0.0363863446,
0.0030033092,
-0.0479212329,
0.0273209102,
-0.0286320373,
-0.0288077425,
0.021167472,
-0.0027089221,
0.0172527395,
0.0459458195,
0.0050845724,
-0.0433166474,
-0.0436855555,
-0.1017881781,
0.0125616081,
-0.0334669538,
0.0427313186,
0.0310391877,
0.0392168984,
-0.0191123225,
-0.0530643873,
-0.0270740651,
0.0101664234,
-0.0158838034,
0.0144613767,
0.0253254622,
0.0607260019,
0.0526679084,
-0.0404689498,
-0.0172706526,
0.0324540511,
0.0123230144,
0.003893286,
-0.0296697691,
-0.0145555753,
0.0293668695,
-0.0243443083,
0.0386478379,
-0.0350146033,
-0.0047385995,
-0.0414929539,
-0.0533278398,
0.0223680642,
0.0340139382,
0.0105450824,
-0.0212087855,
0.014105266,
-0.0017981579,
-0.0591202006,
0.0384447314,
-0.042553883,
-0.0001939344,
-0.0257065278,
0.0285050217,
0.0367364772,
0.0486719832,
-0.0004980239,
0.0077884309,
-0.0133628361,
0.003716964,
-0.0013406969,
-0.0190447532,
-0.0393176824,
0.0352924317,
0.0146753369,
0.0221811421,
-0.0268908963,
-0.0092108306,
0.0560638644,
-0.0232941192,
-0.0095035834,
-0.0056227441,
-0.0196922813,
-0.0459443033,
0.0777041763,
-0.0171741731,
0.0320431218,
0.0453806892,
-0.0067469683,
-0.0442860126,
-0.0247891564,
0.0343179889,
-0.025652159,
0.0207021832,
-0.0011918227,
0.0468746647,
-0.0176382475,
-0.0512100458,
-0.0624976717,
-0.0415905863,
0.0192849487,
-0.0146827176,
-0.0154297343,
0.0200334359,
-0.0227654874,
0.006986225,
0.0346466601,
0.0399009064,
-0.0377463028,
-0.0109975766,
-0.0057219542,
0.0422788933,
0.0243253801,
-0.0103196912,
-0.0494399332,
-0.0012896595,
0.0035268636,
0.0352772661,
0.0124954851,
-0.0274954531,
0.0065872045,
0.0015485054,
0.0205615908,
-0.0563128926,
0.0038303838,
-0.0108652757,
0.0030763661,
-0.0613719709,
-0.0053208559,
0.0951473266,
0.015653532,
-0.0211802647,
-0.0516473353,
0.0097211795,
-0.0100209359,
0.0124965338,
0.048210986,
-0.0394591428,
-0.0184315722,
-0.0084651671,
0.0306976233,
0.0337522849,
-0.0231061168,
-0.0038655458,
-0.0531708449,
-0.0040821196,
0.0040818341,
-0.0167890303,
-0.0558677651,
0.0068824952,
0.0029190516,
-0.0225688256,
-0.0004902115,
0.0569659546,
-0.0594354197,
0.0170493834,
0.0085359877,
-0.0271725524,
-0.0444824733,
0.0094926367,
-0.0137917213,
0.0058798301,
0.0656204596,
0.0036441148,
0.0081516923,
0.0120912362,
0.038677875,
0.0118854716,
-0.0018362263,
-0.0195946395,
0.0954581276,
-0.0540857166,
0.0034493075,
-0.0060255989,
-0.0156797357,
-0.0182957388,
0.0290108081,
0.0295253545,
0.0285495855,
0.0045769131,
0.0004121277,
0.005141018,
-0.0526504591,
0.0239151288,
0.0764329582,
-0.0056658708,
-0.0071324268,
-0.0139755812,
0.0238442346,
-0.0069716303,
-0.0719682574,
-0.0039160582,
0.0562552065,
-0.02945536,
-0.0039211707,
-0.0746872351,
-0.0706086457,
0.0409010351,
0.0688573495,
-0.0026622128,
0.0048507005,
0.0153647559,
0.010896029,
-0.0950679928,
-0.0030338352,
-0.0588746332,
-0.0765495598,
-0.046978794,
-0.0459576882,
0.0394009687,
-0.0539895296,
-0.0077940426,
-0.0104940813,
-0.0091936858,
-0.0307259634,
-0.0078650583,
0.0552908182,
0.0131175248,
0.0703202114,
0.0109738372,
-0.001088395,
0.1083960906,
0.0096869012,
-0.0927372575,
-0.0091090528,
0.0520130508,
-0.0356513597,
-0.014375248,
0.0466612689,
-0.0797438398,
0.0489925109,
0.0085248454,
0.0208273828,
0.0111772288,
-0.0191947781,
0.0596166067,
0.0562415682,
0.0501105413,
0.0156128313,
0.0127804652,
-0.0729725659,
-0.0031298855,
-0.0300096162,
-0.0324948393,
-0.0702489316,
0.0365507714,
0.0238127112,
-0.0302202832,
0.0208768602,
0.0434233434,
-0.0123552252,
0.0180618409,
0.005208001,
-0.0161504112,
-0.0441042781,
0.0677892566,
0.0237657577,
-0.0103477994,
-0.0289477743,
0.0401131734,
0.0443519317,
0.0081395898,
-0.0579407774,
0.030679103,
0.0205548219,
-0.0024068363,
-0.0376118645,
0.0541778989,
-0.039272327,
-0.0043487018,
-0.0347988047,
-0.0002687878,
0.0363804847,
-0.005117882,
0.0359663032,
-0.0131773939,
-0.0175569542,
-0.0263706911,
0.0259825289,
0.0108191017,
0.0263523534,
-0.0042466563,
-0.0053201574,
-0.0438957065,
0.0022456467,
0.0834196284,
-0.0111788278,
0.0172358118,
0.0242071692,
0.0037486777,
-0.065452598,
0.0041050822,
-0.0216538645,
0.0288083106,
-0.0268721841,
-0.0175136924,
-0.0234345067,
-0.0228219293,
0.0532979481,
0.0277947579,
-0.0588827468,
0.0164279975,
0.0353222378,
0.0721936971,
0.0155678159,
-0.0406257473,
-0.0404722244,
0.0179000776,
0.0020711436,
0.006679649,
0.0160143059,
-6.724385312e-33,
-0.0730914697,
0.0108655496,
0.0405900031,
-0.0004589845,
-0.0096394271,
0.0041080178,
-0.0276868381,
-0.0143101625,
-0.0361299925,
-0.009616917,
-0.0314410813,
-0.0062645944,
0.0242794007,
0.0348393284,
-0.0028531461,
-0.0129984803,
0.0453617275,
-0.0019237392,
-0.0130048133,
0.0313131325,
0.0542791262,
0.0921522602,
0.0649126247,
-0.0688964874,
0.0183841269,
-0.00589203,
0.0358216017,
0.0022538721,
0.0758108571,
0.0271591116,
0.003847732,
0.0488040484,
0.0391856171,
0.0067584589,
-0.010922621,
-0.0033474704,
-0.1605878323,
-0.0462130383,
0.0001478777,
-0.0420187935,
-0.064407073,
-0.0084202997,
0.015268892,
-0.0479467958,
0.0565949008,
-0.0154981343,
0.0439691618,
-0.0158754103,
0.007666179,
-0.0007333447,
-0.0595451072,
0.0265663452,
0.0504200906,
0.002221032,
0.0723058283,
0.0294086318,
0.0281880107,
-0.0101952562,
-0.0312860943,
-0.0031473602,
-0.0377900004,
0.0408728831,
0.0079103401,
0.0339356661,
0.0309309736,
0.0295712966,
0.0329659022,
0.0216984842,
-0.0004980323,
-0.0089053167,
-0.0028684868,
0.0723851398,
-0.0554272011,
0.0815585703,
0.0100379558,
-0.0093570752,
-0.0634811223,
0.0505851246,
0.0163192581,
0.0196673963,
-0.0428851321,
-0.0099496404,
-0.0379682928,
0.0140967099,
-0.0034590089,
0.0049531017,
-0.0190352425,
-0.0429412685,
0.0458337478,
0.0403487757,
-0.0047816345,
0.0156760719,
0.0415491685,
-0.0070320307,
0.0162290595,
0.0346378535,
-0.0183451157,
-0.0147320265,
-0.0272749793,
0.0089333132,
-0.0564959273,
-0.0464167111,
0.0007969848,
0.0100164991,
-0.023880193,
0.0203104597,
0.0339124426,
0.0077002766,
-0.0535076819,
-0.004377434,
-0.0196081158,
0.0322085023,
0.0131095275,
-0.0035625543,
-0.0021193014,
0.056338761,
-0.0220393445,
0.0345532931,
0.0347013474,
-0.0250057131,
-0.0285392907,
-0.0224378407,
0.0603202805,
0.0352876261,
0.0237988662,
0.0205510482,
-0.053611286,
0.0252395254,
0.0206057988,
-0.0412500724,
0.0260438621,
0.0285555627,
2.794e-7,
0.0521152765,
-0.0045236992,
0.0467950217,
-0.001434992,
-0.0156025151,
0.0280285291,
-0.0167736076,
0.0111045241,
-0.0045423983,
-0.022746047,
0.0327038206,
0.0192032736,
0.0129211955,
0.0154828066,
-0.0640439913,
0.0176969115,
0.0056423726,
-0.0310356095,
-0.031968955,
-0.0247237459,
0.027051229,
0.0360664763,
0.0015203544,
0.0210055914,
-0.0278379284,
-0.0722921267,
0.0786441714,
-0.0270374864,
-0.0261856262,
0.0553106666,
0.002620603,
0.0435676351,
-0.0666475669,
0.0262907892,
-0.0130607355,
0.0354470462,
0.0176341273,
0.041203931,
-0.0089207953,
-0.0262688715,
0.0182756335,
-0.0239351243,
0.0039399429,
0.0026775987,
0.0753090158,
-0.0833231062,
0.0198910907,
0.0076115029,
-0.038684953,
0.0475222878,
-0.0534742698,
0.0123085855,
-0.0232161209,
0.0333016217,
0.0341970325,
0.0021097809,
-0.0475231931,
-0.1004390121,
0.0204382241,
0.0193649083,
-0.013976234,
-0.0212596282,
-0.0150328251,
-0.0111147612,
0.0257989261,
-0.0801137164,
0.0334632173,
2.27867881e-34,
-0.0279086754,
0.0113673676,
-0.0154622383,
-0.0156899039,
-0.0060358816,
-0.0394310094,
-0.0883060917,
-0.0286941398,
-0.0351226851,
-0.0503787994,
-0.0074376264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.17175v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.17175v2 | RECAP-KG: Mining Knowledge Graphs from Raw GP Notes for Remote COVID-19 Assessment in Primary Care | 2023-06-17T23:35:51 | 2023-10-09T13:23:53 | Rakhilya Lee Mekhtieva, Brandon Forbes, Dalal Alrajeh, Brendan Delaney, Alessandra Russo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Clinical decision-making is a fundamental stage in delivering appropriate
care to patients. In recent years several decision-making systems designed to
aid the clinician in this process have been developed. However, technical
solutions currently in use are based on simple regression models and are only
able to take into account simple pre-defined multiple-choice features, such as
patient age, pre-existing conditions, smoker status, etc. One particular source
of patient data, that available decision-making systems are incapable of
processing is the collection of patient consultation GP notes. These contain
crucial signs and symptoms - the information used by clinicians in order to
make a final decision and direct the patient to the appropriate care.
Extracting information from GP notes is a technically challenging problem, as
they tend to include abbreviations, typos, and incomplete sentences.
This paper addresses this open challenge. We present a framework that
performs knowledge graph construction from raw GP medical notes written during
or after patient consultations. By relying on support phrases mined from the
SNOMED ontology, as well as predefined supported facts from values used in the
RECAP (REmote COVID-19 Assessment in Primary Care) patient risk prediction
tool, our graph generative framework is able to extract structured knowledge
graphs from the highly unstructured and inconsistent format that consultation
notes are written in. Our knowledge graphs include information about existing
patient symptoms, their duration, and their severity.
We apply our framework to consultation notes of COVID-19 patients in the UK
COVID-19 Clinical Assesment Servcie (CCAS) patient dataset. We provide a
quantitative evaluation of the performance of our framework, demonstrating that
our approach has better accuracy than traditional NLP methods when answering
questions about patients. | [
0.0483308583,
0.006039755,
-0.0019521215,
-0.0168126356,
-0.0288232714,
0.0054699392,
-0.0625547394,
0.0239096358,
0.0723689646,
-0.0139439972,
0.0482757241,
-0.0074616708,
-0.001025594,
0.0627255365,
-0.0301811583,
-0.047952652,
0.0122149279,
0.0432770848,
0.0470274836,
0.0253801718,
0.0099838525,
0.0168005135,
-0.0318162292,
0.0491922088,
-0.0273890346,
0.0126965111,
0.013113291,
-0.012084634,
0.0391771384,
-0.0723313764,
-0.0014279392,
-0.0043277787,
-0.0497598909,
-0.0437666848,
0.0000019079,
-0.0429067574,
-0.0458883531,
0.0148934042,
-0.0370740145,
-0.0794115141,
0.0347970761,
-0.0550457276,
0.0242980924,
0.032691922,
-0.0612562671,
-0.0767162517,
0.0228641797,
0.0368255414,
0.0374530591,
0.0702658221,
-0.0423237495,
0.0124416752,
-0.0064627891,
0.0117873494,
0.0309425425,
-0.0380577892,
0.0432176329,
0.0294932276,
0.0343813002,
-0.0212222151,
0.019869227,
0.0098985899,
-0.0494115502,
0.0031525234,
0.0048938505,
0.0399634354,
-0.0111845359,
-0.0167031195,
-0.0117270909,
0.0579534285,
0.0332519896,
0.015337334,
0.0479626134,
-0.0250114556,
0.0011652667,
0.041226197,
-0.0020218026,
-0.0510507785,
-0.0660686716,
0.0266249292,
0.0251638163,
0.0010768087,
0.0323051848,
-0.0315259397,
0.0011117398,
0.0472488292,
-0.0182086471,
-0.0190780908,
0.0357786901,
-0.0008632847,
-0.0169939399,
-0.0390516631,
0.0270104297,
0.0447922461,
-0.045247931,
0.0407933407,
0.0033502248,
-0.0268060919,
0.072514236,
-0.0663785711,
0.0051239459,
-0.0246244166,
0.0413367748,
0.0020711378,
0.0174910631,
-0.0259226505,
-0.0064237835,
0.0234317183,
-0.0245253351,
0.0018853623,
-0.061724294,
-0.014235639,
-0.0242448132,
0.0162372645,
0.0378092676,
0.0038505662,
-0.079358466,
-0.0071548196,
-0.029435927,
0.042149961,
0.0610592254,
0.0556102917,
0.0039943103,
0.0309870653,
-0.0168126486,
0.0086586671,
0.0089676837,
-0.0169532932,
0.0000631029,
-0.0319885015,
0.0560897142,
-0.0217900928,
0.0724656433,
0.0303759761,
0.0025594376,
0.028214369,
0.0319316536,
0.0043680202,
0.0016825028,
-0.0617998093,
-0.0445254557,
0.0227480996,
-0.0007998379,
-0.0562433116,
0.0282870885,
0.0248876587,
-0.0225143097,
-0.0562831052,
0.0276341885,
0.0106099788,
-0.0640995502,
-0.0041950266,
-0.0952348709,
0.022429131,
-0.006608482,
0.0048685176,
-0.0055639651,
-0.0145297898,
0.0274751261,
-0.0188944936,
0.0312642902,
-0.0056057111,
0.0120553533,
0.0011967965,
0.0450493209,
-0.0264816936,
0.0326844975,
0.0076443222,
-0.0204611551,
0.0457602367,
-0.0575211532,
0.0645237863,
0.0245062262,
-0.006956927,
-0.0123130055,
-0.0120206727,
0.0355505385,
-0.0100133661,
0.0212361272,
0.0224320609,
-0.0175872892,
0.001958828,
0.0086847618,
-0.03832414,
0.0117804473,
0.0121293478,
-0.0269794408,
-0.0077567045,
0.0086466726,
-0.0417667441,
-0.0545638725,
-0.0021395232,
0.0098637436,
-0.0259132832,
0.0343816392,
-0.0167609472,
-0.0334419608,
0.0172455646,
0.0511110798,
0.0061030402,
-0.0182455815,
-0.0375076383,
-0.0226120837,
0.0927343965,
0.0552447438,
-0.0336343609,
-0.0972774997,
0.0025456422,
-0.0367195643,
-0.0273204558,
0.0400032476,
-0.0459510349,
0.0012874898,
-0.0185190104,
-0.0142663168,
0.0470025837,
0.0020774424,
-0.0406857245,
-0.001188117,
0.017122291,
-0.0030372441,
-0.040207766,
-0.0413143486,
0.0315833278,
0.0066495175,
-0.0103767859,
0.0101498701,
-0.0092966389,
0.0640111268,
0.0396741182,
0.0198751166,
0.0605986118,
0.0544929728,
-0.0218941588,
-0.0336475,
0.0279712882,
-0.0201347359,
-0.0479680672,
0.0173337534,
-0.0196208544,
0.0324524455,
-0.0318773836,
-0.050175935,
-0.0222608689,
-0.0062148552,
-0.0191780683,
0.0337564982,
0.0118631711,
-0.0273436904,
0.0640733689,
-0.0223443191,
0.0042965142,
0.0224440284,
-0.0191216394,
0.0151930396,
-0.0439627357,
-0.089379169,
-0.0091210119,
-0.0192522444,
0.0362980217,
-0.0138459327,
-0.0098960968,
0.0151007129,
-0.0189850293,
0.0186992902,
-0.028206449,
0.019811295,
-0.1529216915,
-0.0158502199,
0.0270993896,
0.0482196771,
0.0507553145,
0.0216210429,
-0.0273318179,
-0.0236442443,
-0.060178332,
0.0124866441,
0.0437627137,
0.012964081,
0.0370103195,
0.0757866576,
0.0115439873,
-0.004730219,
-0.0082651069,
-0.0554328859,
0.0207827147,
0.0311809331,
-0.0419587865,
0.0374741852,
-0.0061510811,
-0.0647129714,
-0.0100083016,
0.0277544428,
0.012327441,
0.0014397408,
-0.0441393442,
0.012589721,
-0.0338652618,
-0.0181894265,
0.037597958,
0.0078090359,
-0.0303941667,
-0.0250241477,
0.0149397617,
-0.0798009634,
0.0030143852,
-0.0021357129,
-0.0658533126,
-0.0024776363,
0.0192651991,
0.0544254035,
-0.01234922,
-0.0436363332,
0.00039054,
-0.0365099907,
0.0438156463,
-0.0649411976,
0.0183123779,
0.0126319909,
0.0277591106,
0.0013249395,
-0.0298672989,
0.0699559376,
-0.0066996822,
0.0721853822,
-0.0600155406,
-0.0326182581,
-0.0449910499,
0.0205666143,
0.0154639408,
0.027468117,
0.0427773297,
0.0037473692,
0.0320444703,
-0.0396864638,
0.0083177844,
-0.0484554172,
-0.0021311359,
-0.0259078052,
0.0323745348,
0.0460618846,
-0.0231524818,
-0.0343627483,
-0.0085315946,
-0.0407087654,
0.0164557099,
0.0089998227,
0.0092368387,
-0.0140138064,
0.0136236465,
-0.0378993675,
0.067560643,
0.0322183147,
-0.0203661341,
0.0426539928,
0.0181507897,
0.0487139598,
-0.0337147936,
0.0150087932,
0.0114428392,
0.0136045972,
0.0544246137,
-0.0105248783,
0.0025341767,
0.0166942086,
0.0011725307,
-0.0577488206,
-0.0381540135,
-0.0248671528,
0.0259963106,
0.0013257535,
-0.0733876005,
0.0022323937,
0.065383181,
0.0448776148,
-0.0141023798,
0.046852883,
-0.0138025908,
-0.019982215,
-0.0351110213,
0.0157873333,
-0.051586017,
-0.0238345601,
-0.0337955616,
0.0445317253,
-0.0470626242,
-0.0748417974,
0.0111999726,
-0.0008200434,
0.0419958904,
-0.0159347802,
-0.0079241423,
-0.0039668735,
-0.0473416932,
0.0097924462,
-0.0082365638,
-0.0818756893,
-0.0448407121,
-0.004120755,
0.0236333534,
0.0084038973,
-0.0895580798,
-0.0460148528,
0.0204210412,
0.0186926853,
0.0038525527,
0.0040097977,
0.045750048,
0.0057971305,
-0.0179068074,
-0.0154091259,
0.0086807478,
0.0197331309,
-0.0356334746,
0.0704870746,
0.0289783888,
0.0072781923,
-0.0702906325,
0.018672904,
-0.0607437417,
-0.0402004011,
0.0442690924,
0.1113401577,
-0.0502607822,
-0.0635281503,
-0.0321039855,
0.0480664074,
0.0570864938,
0.0269488823,
-0.0109539498,
0.0274898857,
-0.0160092711,
0.0293903612,
0.0629424527,
0.0055482811,
-0.0048345961,
0.0296307486,
-0.0242541321,
-0.008422384,
-0.0714033097,
-0.0316690058,
0.0747178867,
-0.004930642,
-0.0026212311,
-0.0384017229,
0.030629525,
-0.0079320008,
-0.0764890388,
0.0064587547,
0.0411988012,
0.0166315734,
-0.0474202,
-0.0342125483,
0.0374510437,
0.0324995592,
-0.0036937499,
-0.0146117844,
-0.0040043793,
-0.0182309579,
0.0176186021,
0.0256262887,
0.0224824287,
-0.0151238404,
0.0108433003,
0.055563949,
0.0730072781,
0.0495334864,
-0.0397049896,
-0.0566419512,
-0.0056711319,
-0.0071448274,
-0.0144386711,
0.0266877692,
-0.0170736071,
-0.0013166304,
-0.0171543993,
0.0337729491,
-0.0323547199,
0.0029028577,
0.015181764,
0.0422785804,
0.0178414956,
-0.009187514,
-0.0200629663,
-0.0594956465,
-0.0051684068,
0.0057875789,
-0.001773436,
-0.0160337947,
0.0105500873,
-0.0368791446,
-0.0109158317,
-0.0057680071,
0.004594171,
-0.0734818056,
-0.0369778946,
-0.0160098057,
0.0301826317,
0.0549259707,
0.0010738487,
0.0700381026,
-0.0399514511,
0.0190371759,
0.0215850882,
0.0074978527,
0.0021119365,
0.0209974386,
0.0148665458,
-0.0072911037,
0.0171269998,
-0.0348472707,
0.0169557817,
-0.0406390838,
-0.047724992,
-0.032342419,
-0.0045803678,
0.0269043576,
0.0080473237,
0.0231182966,
-0.0473151766,
-0.0012852681,
-0.0280350968,
0.0517860204,
-0.0173094906,
-0.026007792,
0.0276907049,
-0.0063530216,
-0.0326404646,
-0.0265572555,
0.0930103734,
0.0068694274,
0.0506110787,
0.0242074355,
-0.074749656,
-0.0494409166,
-0.031055687,
0.0093504786,
0.0152720055,
-0.0374072902,
0.011217216,
-0.0863523483,
-0.044945091,
0.0417594947,
-0.0174089633,
-0.0210560057,
0.0001463608,
0.0436984226,
-0.0046262541,
0.0273691714,
-0.0086831255,
-0.0593258999,
0.0571000539,
-0.0712759346,
0.0049116174,
0.0193485059,
-5.765562121e-33,
0.0001361988,
-0.052753292,
0.0068203993,
0.0142367724,
0.0315953009,
0.0247424152,
-0.0072297542,
-0.0134655228,
0.0185132828,
0.0481376983,
0.009621595,
-0.0049309791,
0.0045081531,
0.031894207,
0.0087248385,
-0.0267034341,
0.0249238852,
-0.0004715163,
0.0042411531,
0.0268546883,
0.0525490679,
0.0485800095,
0.0369335786,
-0.0886365324,
0.0237922631,
-0.0024399704,
0.0135552529,
0.0199100878,
0.0036830974,
0.0443528555,
0.0124539565,
0.0611364916,
0.0481397323,
0.0213890988,
0.0162996575,
0.0209455732,
-0.0625532269,
-0.0555472486,
-0.0128442524,
-0.0466578901,
-0.0175354294,
-0.0218825862,
0.0354316346,
0.0072872704,
0.0238576159,
-0.0272501968,
0.0170304589,
-0.0174542405,
-0.0279810783,
-0.0720514879,
0.0070738844,
0.0493397862,
-0.0057559749,
0.025302697,
-0.0491117984,
0.0162447151,
-0.0289562996,
-0.0217193384,
-0.0095222602,
0.0165289734,
0.0267820079,
-0.0001912881,
0.0043336484,
-0.031396471,
-0.0037853986,
0.0371982753,
-0.0318636745,
-0.0382787436,
-0.0385758355,
0.0486133397,
-0.0821868479,
0.0701151937,
-0.0093711289,
0.0002144801,
0.0252733342,
-0.0354329757,
-0.1018817946,
0.0511426926,
-0.051164344,
0.0639124811,
0.0019384387,
-0.033119224,
-0.0422966033,
-0.0355314873,
0.0027038078,
-0.0128433052,
-0.0119777825,
-0.0573549345,
0.0203762725,
0.0059466185,
0.0112508247,
0.0344190821,
-0.0479881763,
-0.0054614074,
0.0034885528,
-0.0089701666,
0.0412418582,
-0.0058414722,
-0.0414091833,
0.0027340695,
-0.0432363339,
-0.0242463853,
0.0150763001,
-0.0123460526,
0.0298407692,
0.0385498665,
0.0339183994,
-0.0227136537,
-0.0220083445,
-0.0049203942,
0.048448801,
0.0353836045,
-0.0493839793,
0.0383779407,
0.0490726382,
0.0347572863,
-0.0147238867,
0.0581528805,
0.0219274536,
0.0494677946,
-0.0036868881,
-0.0325619802,
-0.0020319368,
0.0027976308,
-0.0287496503,
-0.0134220757,
-0.0525563993,
-0.0103139374,
0.0482150316,
-0.005420981,
0.0107513219,
-0.0179548822,
2.814e-7,
0.1058856249,
0.0402750336,
-0.0052939272,
-0.0263729412,
0.0279472061,
0.0039562425,
0.0260963123,
0.0039396309,
-0.0120031452,
-0.0001488241,
0.0612366199,
-0.0126446523,
-0.0127157578,
0.1009702906,
-0.0533470288,
-0.015006749,
-0.0442457683,
-0.0531260334,
-0.013517593,
0.005421761,
0.0792206079,
0.0463649258,
-0.0058466401,
-0.0206668731,
0.0059533645,
0.0139529742,
-0.0022618214,
-0.0355848409,
-0.0111160502,
0.0241578333,
0.0618205443,
-0.0338475704,
0.0262779295,
0.077228196,
-0.0231584776,
-0.0152644189,
-0.0183907542,
0.0669021457,
-0.0358966514,
0.0340651684,
0.014262611,
-0.0481128544,
0.0503396653,
-0.0028626665,
0.0512231365,
-0.0726715326,
-0.0537477247,
0.0376147665,
-0.028096674,
0.0084057664,
0.0122977057,
-0.0333310887,
-0.0366881788,
0.0353615917,
0.0022666645,
0.0109694786,
-0.0153793525,
-0.0402887464,
-0.0121028237,
0.0428433418,
0.006275631,
-0.0349182859,
0.0677123517,
-0.0029551608,
-0.0145619912,
-0.050256487,
0.0336866975,
2.232941289e-34,
0.0168589875,
0.0700953156,
-0.0504351221,
-0.0395024009,
0.0202534106,
-0.0400278866,
0.0139518566,
0.0125135928,
0.0097468784,
-0.0528140403,
-0.0139373224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10419v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10419v1 | Multilingual Multiword Expression Identification Using Lateral Inhibition and Domain Adaptation | 2023-06-17T20:28:32 | 2023-06-17T20:28:32 | Andrei-Marius Avram, Verginica Barbu Mititelu, Vasile Păiş, Dumitru-Clementin Cercel, Ştefan Trăuşan-Matu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Correctly identifying multiword expressions (MWEs) is an important task for
most natural language processing systems since their misidentification can
result in ambiguity and misunderstanding of the underlying text. In this work,
we evaluate the performance of the mBERT model for MWE identification in a
multilingual context by training it on all 14 languages available in version
1.2 of the PARSEME corpus. We also incorporate lateral inhibition and language
adversarial training into our methodology to create language-independent
embeddings and improve its capabilities in identifying multiword expressions.
The evaluation of our models shows that the approach employed in this work
achieves better results compared to the best system of the PARSEME 1.2
competition, MTLB-STRUCT, on 11 out of 14 languages for global MWE
identification and on 12 out of 14 languages for unseen MWE identification.
Additionally, averaged across all languages, our best approach outperforms the
MTLB-STRUCT system by 1.23% on global MWE identification and by 4.73% on unseen
global MWE identification. | [
0.0084605962,
0.0320662931,
-0.001395712,
0.0783399716,
-0.0508109666,
0.0067458618,
0.0235473793,
-0.0117840394,
0.004752886,
-0.0450112857,
-0.0748388469,
-0.0443599075,
-0.0420412831,
0.0120240878,
0.0381214879,
0.0071754986,
0.0775973946,
0.02799692,
-0.0053738826,
0.0062441719,
0.0199893415,
0.0175492372,
0.0030198775,
0.0367042907,
-0.0142016904,
0.0025684973,
0.0488919169,
-0.0115574896,
0.017238684,
-0.0353415199,
0.0044354596,
0.0066132522,
0.0397584029,
0.0118934577,
0.0000020295,
-0.0557333119,
-0.0617907047,
-0.0136153577,
0.0022992908,
-0.0396226086,
0.082738176,
-0.0502785109,
0.0014771394,
-0.0084023252,
-0.0125193754,
-0.0375466123,
0.0406583995,
0.0694853812,
0.0452087373,
0.0505372062,
-0.0250512902,
-0.0245613288,
-0.0108118812,
-0.0115800044,
-0.036570359,
-0.101087369,
0.0367232561,
-0.0399201475,
-0.0327112116,
-0.0548254624,
-0.0445003882,
0.0051694303,
-0.0274597891,
0.014829088,
-0.0569852628,
-0.0074364678,
0.0303961206,
-0.0193634219,
-0.0101664076,
0.0675057694,
-0.0328164846,
0.0046298504,
-0.024507476,
0.0024146987,
-0.0138899898,
-0.0053312732,
-0.0283218473,
0.0213112049,
0.0204860624,
0.0183284897,
-0.002788459,
-0.0010239976,
0.0140961176,
0.0326380953,
-0.0078241713,
0.0567089543,
0.0337458737,
-0.0378377587,
0.0323015787,
-0.0126596894,
-0.0401330963,
0.0166327599,
0.0482004061,
-0.022173008,
-0.0239823069,
0.0281854272,
-0.0443395562,
-0.1080257148,
-0.0113482112,
-0.0793341845,
-0.0188117232,
0.0339047872,
-0.0462411456,
0.0857861564,
-0.067260541,
0.0268566366,
-0.0507785641,
-0.0138716362,
-0.0122882267,
-0.0369392857,
-0.0198043138,
0.0044255699,
-0.0136795603,
0.0297583733,
-0.032858111,
-0.0332237557,
-0.029938167,
0.0065655895,
-0.0239936188,
-0.0150963282,
-0.0619332008,
-0.0089176781,
-0.0176164974,
-0.014649936,
0.0309192948,
0.0421694331,
-0.0265213009,
0.0163849648,
-0.0334645212,
-0.0567336977,
-0.0572181456,
0.0933661535,
-0.0018622546,
-0.061109364,
0.0352789462,
0.071098268,
-0.0396664739,
-0.0384322107,
-0.0495466664,
-0.0481197275,
-0.0215700436,
-0.0311435778,
0.0484078117,
-0.0229723621,
0.0365407951,
-0.0209805816,
-0.0000410298,
-0.0789828375,
0.0066003334,
-0.0180919655,
-0.0231704861,
0.0906047523,
0.0544070117,
-0.0571510494,
-0.0043558762,
0.0337867513,
-0.0122052729,
0.0703304559,
-0.0038620364,
0.005354004,
0.0612514541,
-0.00955074,
-0.0270845219,
0.0492058508,
0.005197254,
0.0254557543,
-0.0382900648,
-0.0052886787,
0.0186910816,
-0.0047038114,
0.0294678491,
0.0298100114,
-0.0240988694,
0.0061811181,
-0.0087942099,
-0.004611332,
-0.053579703,
0.0231750421,
0.048398491,
0.0200143289,
-0.0339097828,
0.0297126807,
-0.0015420704,
0.011712661,
-0.0088681364,
0.0091435127,
0.0135627314,
0.0187043324,
-0.0053869062,
0.0199627839,
-0.0205472875,
-0.0463608876,
0.0265856497,
-0.039115984,
0.0794185773,
0.0105723161,
-0.0478280149,
0.0534489788,
0.0504340604,
-0.0428508855,
0.0323451385,
-0.0329528153,
-0.03087846,
-0.0354384147,
0.0402510241,
-0.0578487962,
-0.0162183456,
-0.0233716685,
0.0307087973,
0.0889789686,
0.0500626676,
0.0179085303,
0.0380513519,
-0.0708683133,
-0.0322548002,
-0.0240159146,
0.0108356643,
0.0520357601,
-0.036592856,
0.0291752443,
0.0083673187,
-0.0190028604,
0.0508985482,
0.0557952747,
-0.0133251511,
-0.0588849746,
0.0294536352,
0.0303422585,
0.046976842,
0.0135286171,
-0.0085697807,
0.0024873307,
0.0344920494,
-0.0279565863,
-0.0090395361,
0.0304555334,
-0.0410537161,
-0.0442050993,
0.0493143834,
-0.0427296646,
-0.0404137522,
0.023999963,
-0.021562513,
-0.0477661826,
0.056205336,
0.0061518732,
0.0440787151,
-0.0521097109,
-0.0034644043,
-0.0141364094,
0.051033996,
-0.0037662049,
0.0816234127,
0.0055227811,
0.0138614988,
0.0102987178,
-0.0506176315,
0.0650669038,
0.0149461636,
-0.0306403786,
0.0099098617,
-0.0307216365,
-0.0400618389,
-0.0008471599,
0.0047755023,
-0.0374887325,
-0.0050327028,
-0.0242211204,
-0.0023495888,
-0.0287762526,
0.0379394814,
-0.0014842491,
0.0220350865,
-0.0017232245,
-0.0414869376,
-0.0169971865,
-0.0132996263,
0.0214538164,
0.0391822904,
0.0193933379,
-0.0125460234,
0.0098044304,
-0.0334493667,
0.0305831097,
-0.0551354177,
0.0526080728,
-0.0602923147,
-0.0646194965,
-0.0072174659,
-0.0019012059,
-0.012423791,
0.0415197201,
-0.0094035864,
-0.0358122028,
0.0060581467,
-0.0130573045,
0.0410050303,
0.0324836113,
-0.0263377167,
0.0034372681,
0.035033036,
-0.0112493299,
-0.0136279175,
0.0530225225,
0.0134044047,
0.0521049015,
-0.022654457,
0.0205438435,
0.0059260083,
0.0628495812,
0.0385901257,
0.0149810025,
-0.0205543563,
-0.0064818985,
-0.0079577044,
-0.0509239435,
-0.0078183925,
-0.0140628954,
-0.0340703763,
-0.046387203,
-0.011626035,
0.0129103968,
0.0808327496,
-0.0215889476,
-0.0391639136,
-0.0825080201,
-0.0014590197,
-0.0186949223,
0.0422199853,
-0.0254855193,
0.0333773755,
0.0158735272,
-0.0330118798,
-0.0549299903,
-0.0204337705,
0.0198112018,
0.0017340046,
0.0218781587,
-0.0155519797,
-0.0367886536,
-0.0281223357,
-0.0088176252,
-0.0288030282,
-0.0378467292,
-0.0087249354,
-0.0130801452,
0.0167299435,
0.0352750383,
-0.0844774395,
0.0048244246,
0.0277515762,
-0.0125074154,
-0.0130154584,
0.0299711395,
-0.0164781678,
0.0322386809,
0.0443646349,
0.0371504687,
0.0314876065,
-0.0245834813,
-0.0030877644,
0.0171878953,
-0.0253001545,
-0.0324603431,
0.0186864175,
-0.0023008271,
0.0393986292,
-0.0243768115,
-0.0217112582,
-0.0488179922,
0.0345708616,
-0.0369591266,
0.0083847512,
0.1024591923,
0.0051512308,
-0.0301489681,
-0.0029886251,
-0.0311790425,
0.0020704945,
0.020578742,
-0.0087714735,
-0.0557691827,
-0.0743738413,
0.0057810307,
-0.0300131403,
0.0201899,
-0.0016102828,
-0.0133783445,
-0.0967956707,
-0.0139912171,
0.0037870617,
-0.0411386453,
-0.0164769981,
-0.0118838185,
-0.00968247,
-0.0152611434,
0.0130345831,
-0.0505226664,
0.01633952,
-0.0163391456,
-0.0170677081,
-0.0143766077,
-0.0746681914,
0.0373477675,
-0.0467621535,
-0.0103400527,
0.0484725609,
0.0323994011,
-0.0434420221,
-0.0562961623,
0.0764144957,
-0.0186237432,
-0.0289088115,
-0.029437298,
0.0149120698,
-0.0272288118,
-0.0206577182,
0.0320023969,
0.009788773,
-0.041828163,
-0.0122698126,
-0.0092418566,
0.0968143567,
0.0108052939,
0.0213802811,
-0.0085555976,
-0.0164955761,
0.0178150591,
0.0690555498,
-0.0090231653,
-0.0354877897,
-0.019510407,
-0.0159869492,
0.028581731,
-0.0275893826,
0.0003506209,
0.0041848994,
-0.0490528233,
0.0265275128,
-0.0311231799,
-0.050635878,
0.0256998483,
0.0310699362,
0.0068119424,
0.0167183392,
-0.0381911173,
0.0043825642,
-0.0246021599,
-0.0042415089,
0.0035998684,
0.0189244226,
-0.0314889997,
0.0210222639,
0.0099429218,
-0.0250474419,
-0.0232069027,
0.0084357606,
-0.0420440063,
-0.0407046154,
-0.0295155589,
0.0108293984,
0.0051990664,
0.0056569367,
-0.0537509918,
-0.0107025569,
0.0086110067,
0.0197856463,
-0.0434810445,
0.0079269866,
0.0618818887,
-0.034231931,
-0.0407759994,
0.0378713757,
-0.0327904224,
0.0351504609,
0.0377066247,
0.0386137366,
0.0381949693,
0.0057185059,
0.0014369721,
0.042973686,
0.0552275628,
-0.0140340822,
-0.0171261188,
-0.0429375619,
-0.0316620655,
0.0123815881,
-0.0467771888,
0.0007020709,
0.0206046179,
0.0347558782,
-0.0377018936,
-0.0132719651,
0.0137047386,
-0.0066444729,
0.0003876637,
-0.005256345,
0.0545138083,
0.0619660206,
0.002608235,
-0.0606417395,
0.0382566601,
-0.01216878,
0.0120355589,
0.0027614657,
-0.00286983,
-0.0244156737,
0.0505037755,
-0.0308923163,
-0.0175381638,
-0.0002845667,
0.0159689598,
0.0144472923,
0.077016294,
-0.0251737069,
-0.0073397788,
0.0746628419,
-0.0391466841,
0.1036081538,
0.0171366334,
-0.0138224475,
-0.0305614937,
0.0187313557,
-0.0313050859,
-0.0210843291,
0.0593381114,
-0.0041337465,
-0.0305445492,
-0.0211577807,
0.0522983894,
-0.0094146729,
0.0601457357,
0.0286418702,
-0.0181990191,
-0.0737475082,
-0.0426758863,
0.0630468056,
0.038561549,
-0.0161576718,
0.0324524157,
-0.0481612943,
-0.0272738021,
0.0217372887,
-0.0148710981,
-0.0078589795,
0.0098874308,
0.0030534405,
0.0793270916,
0.0346413627,
-0.0434734039,
-0.026791906,
0.0184940845,
-0.0045937025,
-0.003917865,
-0.0329543613,
-5.861065159e-33,
-0.0101065272,
0.0147367222,
-0.0101890815,
-0.0064099547,
-0.0242777783,
-0.0089885527,
-0.0337099209,
-0.0047464892,
-0.0548032075,
0.0285676885,
0.0253017265,
-0.0253868066,
0.0198874865,
-0.0044290996,
0.0161953382,
-0.014002406,
0.0227432884,
0.0104544256,
-0.0263447426,
-0.0178700164,
0.0486225896,
0.065971069,
0.1187320575,
-0.0485175177,
0.0348704495,
0.0202472806,
-0.0429748408,
0.015517802,
0.0184742156,
0.1013955101,
-0.0177710224,
0.0374973305,
0.0167693477,
-0.0019128927,
-0.0143453041,
0.0130601516,
-0.0411013067,
-0.0475949943,
0.0207500122,
0.0292431284,
-0.0226378813,
-0.0297861136,
0.0315559395,
-0.0251521021,
0.0021326707,
0.0352812558,
0.0348783955,
-0.0258648358,
0.0020555591,
0.02546902,
-0.1067180037,
0.0378034525,
0.0417826325,
-0.0087143267,
0.0424865857,
0.0398217253,
0.0341872387,
0.0148123633,
-0.0987953767,
0.0005524227,
-0.0925423801,
0.0109117087,
0.0294001233,
-0.0047735712,
0.0164553951,
0.0694077462,
-0.0016420837,
-0.0209014416,
0.0409528576,
-0.0124074807,
0.0516458265,
0.0409512334,
0.0626289025,
0.0897185281,
0.0304555353,
-0.0205846857,
-0.0621145293,
-0.0064785169,
0.042682752,
0.0865596458,
0.0135242809,
0.0126337409,
0.0008455203,
0.0095655099,
-0.0013094551,
-0.0204259846,
-0.0332147181,
-0.0290909316,
0.0426517315,
0.0021624044,
-0.0403056554,
0.0188117176,
0.058507178,
-0.0112291565,
-0.0110550113,
-0.0149408877,
-0.0006790828,
-0.0101489611,
0.028133912,
0.0461524762,
-0.043076057,
-0.0483365282,
-0.007465546,
-0.0170169175,
0.0390090048,
0.0023358462,
0.0741817206,
-0.0087914383,
-0.0619672276,
0.0005451566,
-0.0204013344,
-0.0034462584,
-0.0126654971,
0.0452917777,
0.0087054232,
0.000253108,
0.0006648978,
0.0355267823,
0.0547301657,
-0.0417163409,
-0.0158820972,
-0.0143420091,
0.0092611229,
0.0257381499,
-0.0219849106,
-0.007742255,
0.0048888563,
-0.0147952596,
0.0249667522,
-0.0543256029,
0.0186207332,
0.0022540693,
2.735e-7,
0.049065046,
0.0147902351,
0.009576695,
0.0147052454,
0.0076897726,
0.049528271,
-0.0592431724,
0.044260595,
-0.0672032014,
0.0271576438,
-0.0225250553,
0.0001041865,
0.0354866832,
0.0236236919,
-0.0500600003,
0.0456109755,
-0.0221927613,
0.0280999597,
-0.0128622763,
0.0200684574,
0.0530919358,
0.1033534706,
-0.0023656134,
0.0136443507,
-0.0544707328,
-0.0798121989,
0.0841634572,
0.0095652975,
-0.0359109342,
0.0029456411,
-0.0371526331,
-0.0020550007,
-0.0107649062,
-0.0010361031,
-0.0382600166,
0.0242171716,
0.0415262729,
0.070406355,
-0.0102915494,
0.0032781176,
0.0198232178,
-0.0028589582,
0.0064597675,
0.0090440223,
0.07351771,
0.0036534513,
0.0059409142,
-0.0351113677,
0.0052141706,
0.0237093531,
0.0687972531,
-0.008477916,
-0.0499916226,
-0.0045609805,
0.045248881,
-0.0338531211,
-0.0382397883,
-0.0598696396,
-0.0133636063,
-0.0036170008,
-0.0371917561,
0.0135066211,
0.0086304042,
-0.0160721429,
0.0536348522,
-0.0346640125,
-0.0106018428,
2.420159886e-34,
0.0268975962,
-0.0281298235,
0.0085591255,
0.020179756,
0.0287229363,
-0.0089486791,
-0.0524418391,
0.0028359301,
0.0009069443,
-0.0233728439,
0.0074136322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10414v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10414v1 | KEST: Kernel Distance Based Efficient Self-Training for Improving Controllable Text Generation | 2023-06-17T19:40:57 | 2023-06-17T19:40:57 | Yuxi Feng, Xiaoyuan Yi, Laks V. S. Lakshmanan, Xing Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL | Self-training (ST) has come to fruition in language understanding tasks by
producing pseudo labels, which reduces the labeling bottleneck of language
model fine-tuning. Nevertheless, in facilitating semi-supervised controllable
language generation, ST faces two key challenges. First, augmented by
self-generated pseudo text, generation models tend to over-exploit the
previously learned text distribution, suffering from mode collapse and poor
generation diversity. Second, generating pseudo text in each iteration is
time-consuming, severely decelerating the training process. In this work, we
propose KEST, a novel and efficient self-training framework to handle these
problems. KEST utilizes a kernel-based loss, rather than standard cross
entropy, to learn from the soft pseudo text produced by a shared
non-autoregressive generator. We demonstrate both theoretically and empirically
that KEST can benefit from more diverse pseudo text in an efficient manner,
which allows not only refining and exploiting the previously fitted
distribution but also enhanced exploration towards a larger potential text
space, providing a guarantee of improved performance. Experiments on three
controllable generation tasks demonstrate that KEST significantly improves
control accuracy while maintaining comparable text fluency and generation
diversity against several strong baselines. | [
0.002639469,
0.0158877764,
0.0123277493,
-0.0014510409,
-0.0029990703,
-0.0051256442,
0.0318458565,
0.0078070415,
0.005154314,
-0.0177324172,
-0.0451990739,
-0.0252879672,
-0.0325947627,
0.0763355196,
0.0498897135,
-0.034211915,
0.0227169283,
-0.0293829925,
-0.0064383601,
-0.0092564886,
-0.0006784421,
0.0181953181,
-0.0290485527,
0.0079425257,
-0.067535378,
-0.0184006598,
-0.0253940299,
0.0091176918,
0.0132716354,
-0.0390332192,
0.0552379973,
0.0567667522,
0.0338167399,
0.0266540125,
0.0000019932,
-0.0187126044,
-0.0190024264,
-0.0216354188,
0.0071572019,
0.0215546861,
0.0310890824,
-0.0145432521,
-0.0215155948,
0.0210941955,
-0.0042565884,
-0.0225471761,
0.0501834527,
0.0763510093,
0.0478305295,
0.0655048266,
-0.0090663275,
-0.0177832581,
-0.0394591987,
-0.0523770154,
0.0361251645,
-0.0091168154,
-0.0128296204,
0.009685507,
-0.0165220369,
-0.0076680062,
-0.0106019918,
0.0681733191,
0.049095273,
-0.046748016,
0.0263480358,
0.0747776777,
-0.0050137383,
-0.0338391811,
-0.0082075913,
0.0634375513,
-0.0390555039,
-0.0440152884,
0.0799448565,
-0.0414820947,
-0.030797204,
-0.0077238102,
0.021387361,
0.0148539776,
-0.016731035,
0.0270192139,
0.0101968711,
0.0108338324,
0.0174924228,
0.0043283971,
-0.0045483569,
0.0171103533,
0.0068118898,
-0.0536731631,
-0.0018419753,
0.0031113429,
-0.0262092222,
-0.0442035943,
0.0255227797,
0.0280978791,
-0.0046817213,
0.0120173013,
-0.083441101,
-0.0264444798,
0.0233399291,
-0.0461629666,
0.019012833,
0.028483741,
-0.0109371794,
-0.0203503966,
-0.0392935015,
0.0154627431,
0.005654355,
0.0353331231,
-0.0329258665,
0.0566740446,
-0.0550977588,
-0.0309733525,
-0.0607022345,
0.0255662892,
-0.0201312602,
0.0018626039,
-0.068087846,
0.0333456025,
0.0044817342,
-0.0009740709,
0.0357153341,
0.0218238793,
-0.0563353151,
-0.0050171381,
0.0213443153,
0.0032156168,
-0.023083698,
-0.0257870778,
0.03593098,
-0.0015967446,
-0.0192393921,
0.0301534403,
0.0447465517,
-0.0123889204,
-0.0100641204,
0.0280681513,
-0.0749838725,
-0.0351256952,
-0.0401511379,
-0.0528905988,
-0.0535641611,
-0.0542231239,
-0.0006008121,
-0.0357103683,
0.0035955152,
-0.0192638356,
-0.0331671126,
-0.0611833744,
0.0174692795,
-0.0176506657,
0.0309821237,
0.0151243536,
-0.0510911979,
-0.0003256774,
0.0861752778,
0.0193367396,
0.0101525085,
0.0669058263,
0.0128235184,
0.0615862161,
-0.0150562059,
0.001766209,
-0.000404718,
0.0133060394,
0.0589254126,
-0.0196206141,
-0.0285720248,
-0.0424060747,
-0.0047944891,
0.0552303419,
0.0583359078,
0.0306212306,
-0.031751968,
0.0191732608,
0.055481907,
0.0066446653,
0.0413202718,
0.0442060605,
0.0828003287,
0.0468082726,
-0.0168984514,
0.0097022066,
-0.0100364136,
0.0378567949,
0.0037001888,
0.0419641957,
0.0429502167,
0.0056369761,
-0.0536391772,
-0.0591182187,
0.0141738532,
-0.0336115956,
-0.0148958303,
-0.0212613679,
0.0540460832,
0.0479621738,
-0.0311256945,
0.0321413912,
0.0235022381,
-0.0679388717,
0.0510916673,
-0.0034121054,
0.0310760774,
0.0564389974,
0.0232905913,
-0.0097727189,
-0.0202960745,
-0.0109714167,
0.0020594094,
0.0761602968,
0.0352394469,
-0.0014830373,
0.0164874606,
-0.0702098832,
-0.0135165537,
-0.0259367805,
0.004280535,
0.0137143899,
-0.0499779209,
0.0510109179,
0.051909212,
-0.0265026391,
-0.0193682462,
0.0308719706,
-0.0323857851,
-0.0422968976,
0.0349683538,
0.0132219288,
-0.002084252,
0.006687291,
-0.0430040583,
0.0196731836,
0.0016520919,
-0.0449157432,
-0.0540636256,
0.0058708941,
-0.0939582214,
-0.0729599074,
0.0015482986,
0.0172145832,
-0.0131938932,
-0.0315886661,
-0.0098523041,
-0.0727580637,
0.0604627989,
-0.0465490259,
-0.0045149676,
-0.0605067685,
-0.0028903345,
0.0470764786,
0.0015877931,
-0.027365597,
0.0571642295,
0.032084208,
0.0121289017,
-0.0317288563,
0.0413060039,
0.0259210225,
-0.0228870194,
0.002321868,
0.0018765875,
-0.0259313583,
0.0153507283,
0.0370878018,
0.0458001308,
-0.0411081724,
-0.033356633,
-0.0308434181,
-0.0027496687,
-0.0533203706,
0.0043060775,
0.0509465821,
0.0011423441,
-0.004525518,
-0.0053368001,
-0.0477794185,
0.0036122515,
0.0495572276,
-0.0336056091,
0.023601925,
0.0259564724,
0.006997223,
-0.0237512961,
0.0025626346,
0.0196469557,
0.0238131974,
0.0110109579,
0.0336787924,
-0.0355761833,
0.0600042269,
-0.055036854,
0.0211092681,
0.0125656901,
-0.0441225693,
0.0163101554,
-0.013752847,
0.0721062422,
-0.0031849272,
0.0511830151,
0.0095776543,
0.0295815356,
0.0023748421,
-0.0361512601,
0.0159749389,
-0.0474740192,
-0.001838215,
-0.0140696298,
-0.020280702,
-0.0078793857,
0.0908074081,
0.059900403,
0.0126456162,
-0.1209091842,
-0.024089748,
0.0014850592,
-0.064537473,
-0.0285020284,
0.0359242484,
-0.0043277284,
0.0078331744,
-0.04337053,
-0.0374227464,
0.0503527001,
-0.0206818711,
-0.0073228343,
-0.0206824578,
-0.0353551805,
0.0018869916,
0.0440656431,
0.0087088821,
0.0383954309,
0.0782115012,
-0.008443037,
-0.0174103584,
0.0011986131,
0.0245280974,
-0.008208449,
0.0308386981,
-0.0313512981,
0.0325268693,
0.0160961468,
-0.0206630472,
-0.045074746,
-0.0381405614,
0.0454967655,
-0.0240447521,
0.0013745382,
-0.0145828649,
0.0314930156,
-0.0160158724,
0.0275405869,
0.0819515437,
-0.0047643594,
-0.0100681884,
-0.0149515495,
0.0405013375,
0.0541103967,
-0.0016691566,
-0.0337514207,
-0.0375563242,
0.0210205298,
0.0202203076,
0.0369796269,
0.0090373866,
-0.0108292382,
0.00797641,
-0.0335872956,
-0.0245517306,
-0.0043395716,
0.0305280499,
0.0689196959,
-0.0354052112,
-0.080237411,
0.1127623543,
0.0054307939,
-0.0094834091,
0.0199078377,
0.0106139686,
0.0751611516,
0.0127487518,
0.0138915395,
-0.0158812422,
0.008527224,
-0.0322802179,
0.0379307158,
-0.0156804435,
-0.0043441826,
-0.0113152107,
-0.0485592894,
0.0104695763,
0.0199234821,
-0.0622739494,
-0.0312997736,
-0.0133825988,
-0.0469948463,
0.0115719028,
-0.0414110869,
0.0103288339,
-0.0171769988,
0.0386491306,
0.070127137,
0.0109203197,
-0.0684260726,
-0.0447079092,
-0.0121361278,
0.0484665222,
0.0505690128,
0.02308934,
0.0070943637,
-0.041911155,
-0.0012654577,
-0.0510290675,
0.0065228865,
-0.0214661378,
0.0496166311,
0.0146166757,
-0.036000289,
0.0240656454,
0.0395091139,
-0.0289305653,
0.0038843816,
0.0054725367,
0.0205943994,
-0.012210438,
-0.0413012691,
0.0311432499,
0.0181176718,
0.0653566569,
0.0336565971,
0.0462410115,
-0.0149916438,
-0.0387382954,
-0.0036114235,
0.0319046266,
-0.0926090106,
-0.0122307017,
-0.0044096103,
-0.0072884229,
-0.0156132383,
-0.0793011487,
-0.051831454,
0.0041566705,
0.0743796676,
-0.0153186331,
0.0267788228,
-0.0050715483,
-0.0264648981,
-0.069812566,
-0.007306491,
-0.0174729433,
-0.0363133028,
-0.0402798057,
-0.0706655011,
0.0205084868,
-0.0555421002,
0.0003021942,
0.0207079165,
-0.0634163618,
-0.0981417447,
0.0126761151,
0.0596073419,
0.011277657,
0.0399198458,
0.0165032614,
-0.0585624687,
0.1042957455,
0.0660535023,
-0.0301509332,
0.0172342304,
0.0297974125,
0.0039072377,
-0.0095807333,
0.0353498757,
-0.0219906252,
0.0426451154,
0.0113715408,
0.0149957268,
0.0140226576,
-0.0328909233,
0.0061833481,
-0.014439513,
-0.0178950224,
-0.049472563,
0.0361114666,
-0.0583726056,
-0.0297974963,
-0.0225856528,
0.0219717976,
-0.0546142533,
0.0152379759,
0.0178414155,
-0.002112577,
-0.0083672358,
0.0253455564,
-0.0225927923,
0.0486690514,
-0.0182892531,
-0.0073100226,
-0.046273198,
0.0470027886,
0.0125601133,
0.0039576897,
-0.0008763168,
0.0193102583,
0.0148951449,
0.0189489983,
-0.0163024161,
0.0566857196,
0.0157194491,
0.0147775803,
0.0193957053,
0.0293823071,
-0.0431577787,
-0.0055207843,
-0.0558797084,
-0.0032923222,
0.0463169478,
0.0090328157,
0.0740348846,
-0.0518643148,
0.0102171507,
-0.0052964729,
0.058564581,
-0.0225254074,
-0.0353043526,
0.0102733513,
-0.004242627,
-0.0144274021,
-0.0466676503,
0.0783967152,
0.0585265867,
0.0237010196,
0.0238176025,
0.0451261699,
-0.0506089553,
-0.0028062148,
-0.0273891725,
-0.0025648058,
-0.0159682911,
0.0059419908,
0.0049282867,
-0.0796194226,
0.056852255,
0.0121413134,
0.0000048256,
0.0067734476,
0.0890766978,
0.0104807308,
-0.0306083001,
0.02236416,
-0.0546337627,
0.0222093258,
0.0180347599,
-0.016509464,
-0.0156491753,
-6.568184888e-33,
-0.0457156152,
-0.0544399135,
0.0128682554,
-0.0369506776,
-0.040164344,
0.0090455683,
-0.0650092587,
0.0259878412,
0.0583938956,
0.0152232256,
0.014393352,
-0.0079131946,
0.0021791279,
0.0575777516,
0.0043744501,
-0.0011865414,
0.0832271576,
-0.0526307821,
-0.0093219439,
0.0612416454,
0.0486300662,
0.0548776537,
0.0306473207,
-0.0499087982,
-0.010501869,
0.007672363,
-0.0090589868,
-0.0258708391,
0.0167357586,
0.0174219478,
-0.0422777794,
0.0460971557,
0.0191604439,
-0.0083851116,
-0.0258943625,
-0.012481153,
-0.0422222577,
-0.0463801175,
-0.033429984,
-0.0472197048,
-0.0484320782,
-0.018634757,
0.04478921,
-0.0446693525,
-0.0150773851,
0.0387564898,
0.0164150484,
0.0200240668,
-0.0268819854,
-0.0431574695,
-0.0629149675,
0.0124837589,
-0.0294433087,
-0.0388551615,
0.0276428703,
0.0323607959,
0.0079272054,
-0.051393874,
-0.03125415,
0.0034890838,
-0.0224947967,
0.0508460887,
0.0505000576,
0.037457969,
0.0190509241,
0.035170678,
0.0323628299,
0.0253042299,
-0.0268455278,
0.0014435775,
0.0315479562,
0.0140310023,
0.0094087711,
0.0488182269,
0.0146416631,
-0.0611774884,
-0.0350130238,
0.0395803973,
-0.0461129323,
-0.0440010354,
0.0174719412,
0.0043330411,
-0.0106677609,
0.0008651908,
-0.0302078947,
-0.0306054894,
-0.0087608164,
-0.0408227444,
0.0425169505,
0.0801522285,
-0.0254103802,
0.0013800041,
0.005879458,
0.0275944881,
0.011589922,
-0.0273417365,
-0.0267739724,
0.0121399164,
0.0037292636,
-0.0001943011,
-0.0912003294,
-0.0763849095,
0.042773556,
0.0654165596,
0.0021609084,
-0.0034487995,
0.014048784,
0.023517387,
-0.0460886583,
0.0334848091,
-0.0464329012,
0.0627118498,
0.0011197911,
-0.0298320279,
0.0111235362,
-0.0199818555,
-0.0317520723,
0.0248851068,
0.0326493829,
-0.0409413241,
-0.0071581691,
-0.0038383752,
0.0015914002,
0.05590472,
-0.0211981256,
0.0175058488,
-0.037149597,
-0.001299003,
0.0431433655,
-0.0674179718,
0.0095089581,
0.0010367373,
2.659e-7,
0.0058927331,
0.0103297494,
0.0321978517,
-0.0105126854,
0.0205804333,
0.0311153643,
0.010447708,
0.043205969,
-0.026498016,
-0.033188168,
0.0157131273,
0.0213424023,
0.0388817415,
0.0073954081,
-0.0214960184,
0.0259715877,
-0.0622064173,
0.0309811439,
-0.0309219006,
-0.0016210446,
0.0737254694,
0.0357072428,
-0.0202350859,
-0.0052113165,
0.0547401458,
-0.0134212757,
0.0743731558,
0.0310329255,
0.0074871886,
0.0057613766,
0.026967423,
-0.0103279809,
-0.0298894886,
-0.0083370106,
-0.0535080507,
-0.0288800802,
-0.0063661886,
0.0209314376,
0.0140436487,
-0.0359324068,
0.0515566655,
0.042807702,
0.0167028271,
-0.0351962708,
0.0383392051,
-0.0685679242,
-0.0049863076,
0.0174561422,
0.0073806532,
0.020246312,
0.0061934246,
-0.054736115,
-0.0406942666,
0.0266242102,
0.0083921039,
0.0135099487,
0.0155691709,
-0.0689931288,
-0.0518040136,
0.0211239178,
-0.0606362037,
0.0376990102,
-0.1221255064,
0.0167191792,
0.0201621801,
-0.0044987402,
-0.0291229412,
2.036758169e-34,
-0.0069706971,
-0.0443632193,
-0.0144987227,
-0.0370922908,
-0.0085035963,
0.0030762742,
0.011047042,
0.0181291159,
-0.0002443572,
-0.0124459714,
-0.0281022787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10354v1 | LLMVA-GEBC: Large Language Model with Video Adapter for Generic Event Boundary Captioning | 2023-06-17T13:55:54 | 2023-06-17T13:55:54 | Yunlong Tang, Jinrui Zhang, Xiangchen Wang, Teng Wang, Feng Zheng | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Our winning entry for the CVPR 2023 Generic Event Boundary Captioning (GEBC)
competition is detailed in this paper. Unlike conventional video captioning
tasks, GEBC demands that the captioning model possess an understanding of
immediate changes in status around the designated video boundary, making it a
difficult task. This paper proposes an effective model LLMVA-GEBC (Large
Language Model with Video Adapter for Generic Event Boundary Captioning): (1)
We utilize a pretrained LLM for generating human-like captions with high
quality. (2) To adapt the model to the GEBC task, we take the video Q-former as
an adapter and train it with the frozen visual feature extractors and LLM. Our
proposed method achieved a 76.14 score on the test set and won the first place
in the challenge. Our code is available at
https://github.com/zjr2000/LLMVA-GEBC . | [
0.0160024818,
-0.0036885862,
0.0303402171,
0.0595995039,
0.0190984923,
0.0005665298,
-0.0261245538,
0.0121023739,
0.006226371,
-0.0621702112,
-0.0125578055,
-0.0609519817,
-0.0242130943,
0.083258979,
0.0058746873,
-0.1359750181,
0.0114682633,
-0.0398641154,
-0.0131622935,
0.01316565,
0.0232573077,
0.0193273779,
-0.0307028294,
0.0138286455,
-0.0226367023,
0.0038238906,
-0.0142527325,
-0.0117611596,
0.0551682636,
-0.0569707006,
-0.0449065082,
0.043332018,
0.1037067845,
-0.0170492511,
0.0000017573,
-0.0420450084,
0.0001566425,
-0.0038004231,
0.0148841403,
0.0240100194,
0.0301910937,
-0.0862241834,
-0.0063843695,
0.0125715043,
-0.0232960787,
-0.0300201382,
0.0700173676,
0.0488668568,
0.0407280289,
0.0390267409,
-0.0379479527,
-0.0692035481,
-0.0162378922,
-0.0311381258,
-0.0122466004,
-0.0889268368,
-0.0047373269,
0.038090948,
0.0141188847,
-0.0354138575,
-0.0430143885,
0.0320655592,
-0.0068846922,
-0.0272454061,
-0.0098163402,
0.056325607,
-0.0582956299,
-0.0153345028,
-0.0398583189,
0.0750890002,
0.0373255126,
0.0557001382,
-0.0043436675,
0.0157023091,
-0.0224640723,
-0.0115929237,
-0.064018786,
0.0403401628,
0.02620041,
0.0046482687,
-0.0249270946,
0.0637625009,
0.0040171985,
-0.0190573856,
-0.0065279766,
-0.0225827675,
0.0291640554,
0.0318923816,
-0.0540082529,
0.000970547,
-0.0179971904,
-0.0667901188,
0.0275957733,
0.0206292626,
0.0173883196,
-0.0045199608,
-0.0631649569,
0.0218362827,
-0.0339642987,
-0.0427884534,
0.020151291,
0.0114811836,
-0.0361686684,
0.0741064325,
-0.0217226539,
0.0616181344,
-0.0078623919,
0.0347266607,
-0.0365332477,
0.0058717825,
-0.0289195869,
0.0229712408,
-0.02473858,
0.0088300435,
-0.0245831218,
-0.0144083798,
-0.0196917057,
0.0016214257,
-0.0173277706,
0.0124659566,
-0.0131032607,
0.0156397484,
-0.0234692097,
-0.0372923017,
-0.0432491526,
0.0177485514,
-0.0106902104,
0.0057855956,
-0.0227192752,
-0.0408503897,
-0.0206707008,
0.0500243418,
0.0148944734,
-0.0068441508,
-0.0093218973,
0.0536437593,
-0.053569112,
-0.0218545869,
-0.0148648415,
0.0303642992,
-0.0448806249,
-0.0011622699,
0.0046721976,
-0.0320609994,
0.0376791395,
-0.0375759676,
0.012504017,
-0.0043734047,
0.0196778681,
-0.0258747637,
0.0146084223,
0.0749984235,
-0.0229565334,
0.0241566543,
0.0337578245,
0.007296043,
0.0114118494,
0.0635404885,
0.0545335971,
0.0236417167,
0.0357550122,
0.0231333748,
0.0494010076,
0.0594684221,
-0.0219550263,
0.0270712133,
-0.0805144981,
-0.0157439522,
0.0292545799,
0.0273867119,
0.076019235,
0.0366484076,
-0.0055231587,
0.0142225996,
0.0701753646,
0.0275888387,
-0.0512632839,
-0.001817606,
0.0476205759,
0.0088343937,
-0.0043017981,
0.0143264104,
0.0001377574,
0.0778697804,
0.0336687528,
0.0123713501,
-0.0057483995,
0.0036404082,
-0.0617096238,
-0.0457028225,
-0.0115187047,
-0.0145390946,
-0.0075299218,
-0.009017068,
0.0454156175,
-0.0037890193,
-0.0511841998,
0.0602843501,
-0.0439807624,
-0.0086066546,
0.0516621657,
-0.0463758074,
-0.0038471536,
0.0539011955,
0.013088448,
-0.0183272418,
-0.0566286147,
-0.0205665231,
0.0439553857,
0.0390924849,
0.0582393631,
-0.0083941789,
0.0174265131,
-0.0566536784,
-0.011352309,
-0.002689519,
0.0067640953,
0.0289798789,
-0.0413414687,
0.0046598422,
0.0209769867,
0.0365309678,
-0.0547672026,
0.055944439,
0.0626546443,
-0.0354318805,
-0.0223535411,
-0.004969229,
0.0054374509,
0.0149580147,
-0.0367012359,
-0.0226620864,
0.0364735126,
-0.0304395538,
-0.0096824244,
0.0807342529,
-0.0337941051,
-0.0672531053,
0.02838617,
-0.0543347523,
-0.0054685557,
0.0105326641,
-0.0523620732,
-0.0499674082,
0.0026977789,
0.0140059618,
-0.0097218296,
-0.0520006008,
0.0176940747,
0.0133086611,
-0.0206872839,
-0.0074021742,
0.0229896288,
0.0026092557,
-0.0449451432,
0.0346297175,
-0.010602612,
-0.0137313474,
-0.0842628926,
-0.0470933281,
0.0408745408,
0.0105766635,
-0.0140752234,
-0.0000916993,
0.0229530819,
-0.0287255645,
-0.0007001235,
-0.0933973789,
-0.0095255766,
-0.0255662482,
0.006309561,
0.0194743201,
-0.0003578108,
-0.0095222546,
-0.0183561221,
-0.0412365235,
-0.0624879152,
0.0122430045,
-0.026743615,
0.0311167501,
0.0353335626,
-0.0222740993,
-0.0291912779,
0.0248985253,
0.0175601672,
0.040990714,
0.0141665973,
-0.0570994131,
-0.0366857648,
0.0071909437,
0.0238476582,
0.0232956689,
-0.024573829,
-0.0240524244,
-0.0207084827,
0.0413803682,
0.0109614581,
0.0225573462,
0.0394470692,
0.0347230583,
0.0242938399,
-0.0084263999,
0.0075600864,
0.0313188471,
-0.0248740576,
-0.0685071945,
-0.0120155625,
-0.0080741746,
0.0058015371,
-0.0138761774,
-0.0233931523,
0.0632214025,
-0.0723640621,
-0.0265564024,
-0.0025241151,
-0.0365026705,
-0.0435085818,
-0.0157497786,
-0.0684836134,
0.0089786127,
-0.0221460257,
-0.0532511286,
-0.0045869206,
-0.0523839332,
-0.0481392033,
-0.0047170646,
-0.0162222814,
-0.0490470901,
0.1005416438,
-0.0037943181,
0.0308475904,
-0.0439025462,
-0.0347933285,
-0.0419330485,
-0.0144929821,
-0.0095941452,
-0.0142547041,
0.0544668362,
-0.0556595623,
0.0107801463,
-0.0232861787,
0.0182755869,
-0.0150120016,
-0.0064668087,
-0.029655192,
-0.0101453271,
-0.0540683903,
0.0202429984,
-0.0074503082,
0.0608634613,
0.0007738539,
0.0350545906,
-0.0140713137,
0.0421733819,
-0.0107366666,
0.050908111,
0.0655000657,
0.0702855438,
-0.0561908372,
-0.0454640202,
0.0504808649,
0.0292229243,
0.0321985818,
-0.0066163512,
-0.021936398,
0.0243691895,
0.0432331562,
-0.0076984218,
-0.0161426775,
0.0206865687,
0.0814699233,
-0.0625237525,
0.0423641503,
0.1153790578,
0.0032767816,
-0.0295866262,
-0.0100626284,
0.0383460149,
0.0027706528,
0.0335867815,
0.0061205537,
-0.0801067054,
-0.0230408702,
-0.0011784753,
-0.0094029102,
0.0259954277,
0.0460400246,
-0.0499910042,
-0.0460902974,
0.0706616417,
0.0410591885,
-0.0208993889,
-0.0491220169,
0.0306019802,
0.0039193095,
-0.0225691833,
-0.0206384677,
-0.0032207021,
-0.0050278995,
-0.0040681642,
0.0268589575,
-0.0429723077,
-0.0640767664,
0.00700576,
-0.0601307712,
0.048034966,
0.0664403588,
0.0087791542,
-0.0439578854,
-0.0307841338,
0.0063683945,
-0.049135901,
0.0008952346,
0.0113815283,
0.0265257992,
-0.0403444432,
-0.0312629752,
0.0267129466,
0.0256872699,
0.0293149538,
-0.0422975644,
0.0255426858,
0.0332682393,
-0.0111302445,
-0.0022412098,
-0.0033721484,
0.0303180106,
-0.0030388341,
0.0682750642,
0.0070457486,
-0.0021338221,
0.0016559695,
0.0135236857,
-0.0122914305,
-0.0488454513,
-0.0491371229,
-0.0015830928,
-0.0300113708,
-0.0526538305,
-0.0377358533,
0.0090619652,
0.0885480344,
0.0383544229,
-0.0032716088,
0.0178334583,
-0.0129186101,
0.0388758816,
-0.030551875,
0.0650745407,
-0.0452199318,
0.0018042468,
-0.0418326333,
-0.0039989231,
0.0539313219,
0.0118812453,
-0.0293038581,
0.0740443915,
-0.0096567869,
-0.0185863227,
-0.0260702427,
0.0459703356,
0.0188539475,
0.0559909157,
0.0235200468,
-0.0076072612,
-0.016170891,
-0.0030897388,
0.0510364808,
0.0358449146,
-0.0177657921,
-0.0152034899,
-0.0562821962,
0.0123993112,
-0.0411562845,
0.0118133677,
-0.039783828,
0.0616963357,
-0.0341500677,
-0.0423727334,
-0.0033532414,
-0.0189270992,
0.0061436454,
-0.0488564037,
-0.0274967384,
-0.0464573912,
-0.0087261414,
0.0087422663,
0.0116033293,
-0.0638108328,
0.0322034769,
0.0063955844,
0.0222760197,
-0.0024168747,
-0.0233919956,
-0.047853522,
-0.0218966417,
-0.0163364746,
0.002402693,
-0.0049921661,
-0.0186488088,
0.0041670175,
0.0459036492,
-0.0063226959,
0.0431745201,
0.0138348062,
0.00030723,
0.0035417289,
0.0193132255,
-0.0015661858,
-0.0113826711,
0.0018549031,
0.0571360588,
0.0006915434,
0.0280037802,
-0.065148212,
0.0714056045,
0.1064262465,
-0.0153795388,
0.0387739725,
0.016182851,
0.0091917384,
-0.0109737897,
0.0413225032,
-0.01336361,
-0.051013574,
0.085232012,
-0.0153515032,
-0.0387418903,
0.0029675309,
0.039024204,
0.0138382716,
0.0451655909,
0.0145295579,
-0.0002473049,
-0.0194449686,
-0.0123115275,
0.0218009744,
-0.0373501964,
-0.031823162,
0.0152425244,
-0.0418800265,
-0.0131840361,
0.0641623363,
-0.0238438509,
-0.0172956716,
0.0000729762,
0.0510557257,
-0.012480475,
0.0071483687,
0.0038073089,
-0.0105865877,
-0.0261936709,
0.0002391205,
-0.0001812033,
-0.0138556631,
-5.421983856e-33,
-0.0657193735,
-0.0396633483,
0.0172586888,
-0.0115925167,
-0.0615962073,
0.0214884318,
-0.0031882345,
0.0211212859,
0.0169113576,
0.0042695277,
0.0334066898,
-0.0282460172,
0.0452501997,
-0.0014719564,
-0.0136381229,
-0.0536558777,
0.0513542593,
-0.0284275189,
0.0047671837,
-0.0065353396,
-0.0170876998,
0.0125978375,
0.029254796,
-0.0671570599,
-0.0054147472,
-0.0157275386,
-0.0525770672,
0.0004700201,
0.0964529142,
0.0461806618,
0.000400762,
-0.0144863958,
0.0182710513,
-0.0428932011,
-0.0165084787,
0.0084497482,
-0.0129329562,
0.0146503104,
0.0327446684,
0.0569990687,
-0.0134824337,
-0.0414797403,
0.0106055113,
-0.0052732439,
-0.0385745801,
-0.0164377522,
0.037119668,
-0.0346024185,
0.0121053504,
-0.0456901118,
-0.0381308086,
0.0415095538,
-0.009972075,
-0.0249514021,
0.0397062413,
0.0021119018,
0.0163047276,
-0.0157933496,
-0.0405968316,
0.0160762705,
0.0017675728,
0.0348195769,
0.0933344662,
0.0259025879,
-0.0047743963,
0.0447014794,
-0.0270024184,
-0.0376852155,
-0.0371460989,
0.0051270742,
0.0228346065,
0.0555079356,
0.0302588027,
0.0412300527,
0.006706473,
-0.0078111743,
-0.0308533777,
0.0587201342,
-0.060889516,
0.031668473,
0.0035108726,
0.0323920697,
0.0267568342,
0.0189443491,
-0.0445190743,
0.0248761028,
-0.0048013194,
-0.0244181361,
0.038637843,
0.0145982401,
0.0209693853,
0.0187944695,
0.0653214678,
-0.0013936122,
0.0630922318,
-0.0416445248,
-0.0081394846,
0.0627830327,
-0.0059648375,
0.0050018947,
-0.0104538631,
-0.0576977357,
0.0488543361,
-0.0088172127,
0.0333449095,
0.002822418,
0.0082283942,
0.0630943105,
-0.0099772718,
-0.0054274881,
0.002419333,
-0.0150411185,
-0.0172928981,
0.0593563989,
-0.0086119566,
-0.0057481127,
-0.0551862307,
0.0273858141,
-0.0244086683,
0.0069669802,
0.0148944641,
-0.0264500882,
0.017943874,
0.0686866194,
-0.0446663685,
0.059893921,
0.0008480153,
-0.0106864162,
0.0062446622,
-0.0241316371,
-0.042279873,
0.0010617427,
2.452e-7,
0.0214184932,
0.0277261678,
0.0253930427,
-0.0005450504,
-0.0197416376,
0.0137657644,
-0.0407113545,
0.0460174903,
0.0113750733,
-0.0187640246,
0.0621863678,
0.0419839844,
0.0307588819,
-0.0129587632,
-0.0819710195,
-0.0133215375,
-0.0413696989,
-0.0033338773,
-0.0204457492,
-0.0190206021,
0.0663101822,
0.0832374245,
-0.0017785996,
0.0126197189,
0.0192995165,
-0.0701588839,
0.0683970675,
-0.0141258501,
-0.0454039611,
0.0144519266,
0.0346069857,
0.0667336807,
-0.0801009387,
0.0132516297,
-0.0198579784,
0.0028105264,
0.0413833112,
0.0642305762,
-0.0325960852,
-0.0000258106,
-0.0210237075,
0.0686768517,
-0.02104537,
-0.0116951754,
0.0768290237,
-0.0252913982,
-0.0040058489,
-0.0390157178,
-0.0306191761,
0.0157073736,
-0.008439295,
-0.0399284959,
-0.0133631667,
0.0395410955,
0.0426230989,
-0.0076468792,
-0.0711297169,
-0.0821162239,
0.0053568413,
-0.0035784002,
-0.0349928476,
-0.0239561144,
-0.05111105,
-0.0206404645,
0.0201760959,
-0.0040498688,
-0.0300552789,
1.98543705e-34,
0.0289824419,
-0.0092974072,
-0.0448503979,
0.0182860605,
-0.0017511332,
0.0042232359,
0.0066028507,
-0.001400789,
-0.0117402654,
-0.0551678166,
-0.0109280236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10348v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10348v1 | Typo-Robust Representation Learning for Dense Retrieval | 2023-06-17T13:48:30 | 2023-06-17T13:48:30 | Panuthep Tasawong, Wuttikorn Ponwitayarat, Peerat Limkonchotiwat, Can Udomcharoenchaikit, Ekapol Chuangsuwanich, Sarana Nutanong | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, I.2.7 | Dense retrieval is a basic building block of information retrieval
applications. One of the main challenges of dense retrieval in real-world
settings is the handling of queries containing misspelled words. A popular
approach for handling misspelled queries is minimizing the representations
discrepancy between misspelled queries and their pristine ones. Unlike the
existing approaches, which only focus on the alignment between misspelled and
pristine queries, our method also improves the contrast between each misspelled
query and its surrounding queries. To assess the effectiveness of our proposed
method, we compare it against the existing competitors using two benchmark
datasets and two base encoders. Our method outperforms the competitors in all
cases with misspelled queries. Our code and models are available at
https://github. com/panuthept/DST-DenseRetrieval. | [
0.0374871977,
0.0351656638,
-0.0033363174,
0.0153512787,
-0.0152394241,
0.0128595913,
-0.0295521058,
0.0335764587,
0.010490478,
-0.0658546016,
-0.0172193274,
-0.0402140059,
0.0167040564,
0.0541698001,
0.0260952115,
-0.0566270836,
0.0399190933,
0.0316624828,
-0.0350480787,
-0.0094147706,
0.0250035226,
0.0196457785,
-0.002889412,
0.0299825165,
0.0101387594,
0.0056472709,
0.0011941772,
0.0531260446,
0.0022589259,
0.001785527,
0.0587812737,
0.0656774864,
0.0438355207,
0.0847107172,
0.0000019272,
-0.0088842968,
-0.0657284707,
0.004558064,
0.0027687091,
0.0139150787,
-0.0081283608,
-0.0350051709,
-0.0007176505,
0.0211705845,
0.0054544434,
0.0099941324,
0.0640729889,
0.0308939423,
0.0290612224,
0.0393353999,
-0.0132025629,
-0.004163614,
0.0619784296,
0.0041234419,
0.0173245817,
-0.0211418197,
0.0477878228,
-0.0569024831,
-0.0188981406,
-0.0164125226,
-0.0114746904,
0.0272022597,
-0.0303148702,
-0.0117066903,
0.0572364554,
-0.0186121296,
-0.0559212379,
-0.0011626577,
-0.0073440587,
0.0639339834,
-0.030402381,
-0.0153405936,
0.0030320529,
0.0382697247,
-0.0149806933,
-0.020731559,
0.0087991068,
-0.0328608267,
0.0003570784,
0.0244595837,
-0.0332737006,
-0.0040563429,
0.0259045027,
0.038383238,
-0.0056572785,
-0.0124327727,
0.0354636945,
-0.056838192,
-0.0180312172,
0.0535892062,
-0.0016491039,
0.0124864681,
0.0644387677,
0.0199442394,
-0.0377301052,
-0.0310297739,
-0.04761317,
-0.0580905005,
0.0161736887,
-0.0512151457,
0.0049207807,
0.0111054033,
-0.0251747444,
0.0268936306,
-0.0022528651,
0.0700873658,
0.0362842567,
0.0545200966,
0.0153337885,
-0.0218159538,
-0.0021584043,
0.0072774054,
-0.0415631346,
0.0509438179,
-0.0305641592,
0.0039014453,
-0.0520653948,
-0.0202292558,
-0.0211475212,
0.0012993377,
0.0029123456,
0.0334039517,
-0.0531774983,
-0.0421566293,
0.0086540254,
0.0349090286,
0.0407225676,
0.0076138694,
-0.0062918328,
-0.0398671702,
-0.0296733584,
0.0115630878,
0.0320700519,
-0.0519369952,
0.0116105312,
0.0047258185,
-0.0157745462,
-0.0837478861,
-0.0258906074,
0.007673224,
0.0016282531,
0.0341056772,
-0.0574070401,
-0.0559946969,
-0.0082267439,
-0.0302769691,
0.0076759974,
-0.0831772834,
-0.0044969912,
0.0131950863,
-0.0128211454,
0.0853674635,
-0.0792278796,
-0.0159810539,
0.0438885875,
-0.007908809,
0.0330173299,
0.0261524618,
0.0030760081,
0.0239530895,
0.0287411213,
0.003874829,
0.0470855348,
-0.003293345,
0.0076828469,
-0.0039656139,
-0.0596977919,
0.012954508,
-0.041395057,
0.0335313119,
0.0521667004,
0.0700698197,
-0.0290260054,
-0.0146555919,
0.0581172667,
-0.0003954273,
0.0257681627,
-0.0266049784,
-0.0236067977,
-0.0141984913,
-0.0182501562,
-0.0151232388,
-0.0309409164,
0.0065640616,
-0.0906009078,
-0.0250518881,
0.0712870955,
0.0198144838,
-0.0290721394,
-0.0112708444,
-0.0010310473,
0.0272273161,
-0.0287685338,
-0.0037116986,
0.0218260773,
0.0140734781,
-0.0375881717,
0.0311279353,
0.0058777602,
-0.0104680993,
0.007100862,
-0.0289113671,
-0.020968115,
0.0866563991,
0.0794755518,
-0.0127911307,
-0.0262156967,
-0.0235870667,
-0.0575241819,
0.0130484048,
0.030603651,
-0.0183635522,
0.0195344891,
-0.0616175905,
-0.0425518975,
0.0462288186,
0.032286182,
-0.0198848993,
0.0204265937,
0.0374758206,
0.0426030904,
-0.0724852979,
-0.0121959997,
0.0090434821,
0.0277320258,
-0.0410765633,
-0.0251655355,
0.024072621,
-0.0174839683,
-0.0040280046,
-0.0187961739,
0.000578388,
0.0054332679,
-0.00521651,
-0.0453408025,
-0.0690791607,
-0.0315684006,
-0.0401141942,
0.0256967805,
-0.0427240171,
-0.0276270211,
0.0246909056,
-0.0255134627,
-0.0200952608,
-0.0255480707,
-0.0692081451,
-0.0031238468,
-0.0659326985,
0.0347828716,
-0.0076737935,
0.0198661983,
-0.0627492666,
0.0650986955,
-0.0337379016,
0.0321467817,
-0.0268243346,
-0.0287053976,
0.0015698258,
-0.0549852178,
-0.0489147082,
-0.0140645131,
0.0121119404,
0.0510090403,
0.022210924,
0.0321279243,
-0.0249519311,
-0.0045396006,
-0.0266906526,
-0.0136823682,
-0.049611263,
-0.0220231749,
0.0033137503,
0.0582838245,
0.000008389,
-0.032116618,
-0.020716859,
-0.0176991615,
0.0255394559,
0.0232972037,
0.0473434925,
-0.0025500958,
-0.004931306,
-0.0705828816,
-0.033850953,
0.020828627,
-0.0067004333,
-0.0409459658,
-0.0731401816,
-0.0169274621,
0.0392258242,
-0.0005662244,
0.0268225837,
0.0293619074,
-0.0364571363,
-0.0190783814,
-0.0612797812,
0.0098099541,
0.0703612566,
0.0126464656,
0.040891815,
0.0042449161,
0.0011050245,
-0.0597665459,
0.0131472526,
-0.0185578708,
0.0124960179,
-0.0133248912,
-0.0071643339,
0.0069232718,
-0.0167821608,
-0.0114673013,
0.0067895292,
-0.0248839557,
-0.0474709198,
0.0183836538,
0.0021900607,
-0.0637035668,
0.0214105509,
-0.0059616179,
0.0403499901,
-0.0208228454,
-0.0485052355,
0.0744562522,
0.0080552148,
0.0330864973,
-0.0106250476,
-0.0062485808,
-0.02514828,
-0.0160994232,
-0.046175994,
0.0160897579,
-0.0380698666,
-0.0933255255,
-0.034812171,
0.0035506017,
0.0271111373,
-0.0397166051,
0.0498721711,
-0.0166251715,
0.0405079052,
0.0195773691,
-0.0605382621,
-0.0229781941,
-0.0051905927,
-0.0219181087,
-0.0255020224,
-0.0008901717,
-0.0388769992,
-0.0757692531,
0.0154476501,
-0.0148794604,
0.0469916761,
-0.0025429102,
-0.0243271086,
0.0016221448,
-0.0015368244,
0.053143613,
0.0188332405,
0.0326156951,
0.0001831319,
-0.0060099401,
0.0674989223,
-0.0086176274,
-0.0448556058,
0.0020036614,
0.0329873487,
0.0925688818,
-0.0218901075,
-0.0367102511,
-0.0035668712,
0.0381117202,
0.0003288796,
-0.0620855205,
0.093217425,
0.0341529213,
-0.0856384784,
-0.009429723,
0.0198601056,
0.0647628084,
0.0063343183,
0.026452411,
-0.0152225168,
-0.033575885,
0.0318970419,
0.0490585715,
0.0241920985,
-0.0425818041,
0.04733897,
-0.1149087101,
0.0225704815,
0.0270282067,
0.0902276337,
-0.1109758615,
-0.0211135931,
0.0172900427,
-0.0283814296,
0.051093366,
0.0500813276,
-0.0132329352,
-0.0007857562,
0.0234326068,
0.0260627121,
-0.0740012228,
-0.0148131652,
-0.0233376138,
0.0034388469,
0.0561281107,
0.0145626459,
0.0135713071,
-0.0455163904,
-0.0188310314,
-0.017365979,
-0.0223452933,
-0.021667555,
0.0586758777,
-0.0068657207,
-0.0214140993,
-0.0166406203,
-0.0060869493,
-0.0664255619,
0.0140459863,
-0.0526711941,
0.0354802422,
-0.0393172726,
0.0635533407,
-0.0407520495,
-0.0320490301,
0.000750271,
0.0379031338,
-0.000430974,
0.0343166031,
-0.0626393706,
-0.0293154623,
0.0238828696,
0.0008042922,
0.0093775075,
0.0232537035,
-0.0404618755,
-0.0239956882,
-0.0566051379,
-0.0500957146,
0.0254138,
0.0458709747,
-0.0262743849,
-0.0098996796,
-0.0700425804,
-0.0036929862,
-0.0162442755,
0.0002023342,
-0.0128708445,
0.0197950285,
-0.0695560724,
0.0202573221,
-0.0463126116,
-0.0018267109,
-0.0201452728,
-0.0264612902,
-0.0329823829,
-0.0477207415,
0.0177286733,
0.0096406434,
0.0125732366,
0.0069297659,
-0.0383089297,
-0.08525002,
0.0665356144,
0.0610746928,
-0.0035650288,
-0.0055300691,
0.0059075369,
-0.0741146579,
-0.0149118835,
0.0342563912,
-0.0609595887,
0.0210913513,
-0.0315723047,
0.0530161187,
-0.0209760573,
-0.042695161,
0.0593827553,
0.00052047,
0.1175496951,
-0.0236959364,
0.0386285819,
-0.0351423472,
0.003109995,
-0.0129581429,
-0.0117177824,
-0.0154793765,
0.0429673642,
0.0215776674,
0.0095351534,
-0.01768036,
0.0207312256,
0.0282678027,
0.0364460386,
-0.0497264825,
-0.0144932996,
0.0517809987,
-0.003990253,
0.0143533489,
0.0178909637,
0.0073859631,
0.0756132379,
0.0443949811,
0.0489060655,
-0.0109475497,
-0.0405705944,
0.0078623546,
0.043325197,
-0.0244855713,
0.0185416117,
-0.0630681142,
-0.0025631678,
-0.0496890768,
-0.0146830259,
0.0841458887,
-0.0161977876,
0.0225503072,
0.0213659462,
-0.0110709276,
-0.0198295079,
0.0081824791,
0.0178570841,
0.0089450032,
0.021145165,
0.0118389884,
0.00109992,
0.0157267116,
0.0689240918,
0.0006791529,
0.0378381386,
-0.0274463799,
-0.0670731142,
-0.0022121775,
0.0214572847,
0.0265465677,
0.0252684038,
-0.0086249402,
-0.0089877835,
-0.0070066229,
-0.0442254171,
0.0803128332,
-0.0203615967,
0.0180705283,
0.0429318398,
0.0661040619,
0.057312943,
0.0153768593,
0.0131201036,
-0.0468272418,
-0.0313852616,
0.0027413131,
-0.0295456573,
0.0196292289,
-6.555484406e-33,
-0.0152215762,
0.0217509177,
-0.0200680122,
-0.0555374436,
-0.0005338758,
0.0158688594,
-0.0105973948,
-0.0136713805,
-0.0311086886,
0.0455656536,
-0.0160065759,
0.0378177315,
0.0034514957,
0.0104872333,
0.0086197937,
-0.0221137516,
0.0458806083,
0.0374803394,
0.025409339,
-0.001785863,
0.0146709699,
0.0787401795,
0.0423259176,
-0.0386923291,
-0.0153609244,
-0.0121594565,
-0.0388118811,
0.0211725719,
0.0285000969,
0.0362886973,
-0.0024479947,
0.0762287751,
-0.0021810108,
0.07979846,
-0.0284714773,
-0.0637968779,
-0.0568833537,
-0.0167001523,
-0.0599517487,
0.0269708801,
0.0169086158,
-0.0095347734,
0.0628595054,
-0.0367976055,
-0.0386471562,
-0.0134230983,
0.035913296,
-0.0100250393,
-0.04187911,
-0.0320513286,
-0.0229341332,
0.0378449596,
0.0048541026,
0.0057411701,
0.0259060059,
0.025311878,
0.022389153,
0.0072676283,
-0.0726509541,
-0.0053122509,
0.0055183936,
0.0675721616,
-0.0018698818,
-0.0317942426,
-0.0302800965,
0.05671845,
-0.0373062156,
-0.0304508861,
0.0122897113,
0.0284570791,
0.0135848587,
0.0199476667,
0.0375868641,
0.0829883069,
0.0561591685,
-0.0354944021,
-0.0158202909,
0.0547077656,
-0.0706833899,
0.0136435889,
-0.0178915802,
0.0345448218,
-0.0854969174,
-0.0320709646,
0.0174915586,
0.0060194284,
-0.0137951635,
0.0013315062,
0.0291086379,
0.0379739255,
-0.0019283628,
0.0302727148,
-0.0014347116,
-0.0166501869,
-0.0317920372,
-0.0140702035,
-0.0117803095,
-0.0109366644,
0.0231792629,
0.0137913395,
0.011719686,
-0.0331916064,
0.013555523,
0.0371515043,
-0.0509463474,
0.0279154032,
0.0408198982,
0.0201792382,
-0.0468770079,
0.0004345685,
0.0086135268,
-0.0110350139,
-0.0103159649,
-0.0030074958,
0.0185813643,
-0.0207221732,
0.0197569355,
0.0301404465,
0.0141826384,
0.0423101932,
-0.0128556052,
-0.0138491886,
0.0139070479,
0.0363168493,
0.0144152306,
0.0025798709,
-0.0516088605,
-0.0361547135,
0.0241259076,
-0.0505910851,
-0.0046924185,
-0.0097474456,
2.703e-7,
0.0480548702,
0.0613742396,
0.0299701877,
-0.0179114938,
-0.0301463734,
0.0198145509,
0.0028891901,
0.0607304312,
0.0041515832,
0.0014631663,
0.0375902802,
-0.0028789523,
0.0174467862,
-0.0246516448,
-0.0714311227,
-0.0023770637,
-0.0783872977,
0.0119143119,
-0.0210284498,
-0.0338812545,
0.074190937,
0.0616757683,
-0.0105432002,
-0.0402004123,
0.0189299937,
-0.0240990929,
0.0413819179,
0.031791158,
0.027903948,
-0.0042871521,
0.073320359,
0.0359449163,
0.0473056622,
-0.0290978961,
-0.0454087518,
-0.0002969923,
0.0749714002,
0.0176702142,
-0.0495708622,
-0.0363239609,
-0.0152100213,
-0.0167477429,
0.0114184469,
-0.0446068831,
0.0400103144,
0.0658777207,
0.0377306938,
0.0277066361,
-0.0871509388,
0.0050272704,
0.0418552905,
-0.0151199726,
-0.0204663277,
-0.0088095004,
0.0449940525,
0.0430237614,
-0.0264791865,
-0.0770199522,
0.0050783735,
-0.0329494439,
0.0104070269,
0.033940956,
-0.0037428555,
-0.0008255695,
-0.0203167517,
0.0114184255,
-0.0313410163,
2.613538809e-34,
0.0412321799,
-0.005736595,
0.0226213057,
-0.0052992147,
-0.0053441236,
0.0029873427,
0.0293563716,
-0.0089524696,
-0.0088490909,
-0.0608735606,
-0.0002390345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.17174v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.17174v1 | Empowering NLG: Offline Reinforcement Learning for Informal Summarization in Online Domains | 2023-06-17T13:00:54 | 2023-06-17T13:00:54 | Zhi-Xuan Tai, Po-Chuan Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Our research introduces an innovative Natural Language Generation (NLG)
approach that aims to optimize user experience and alleviate the workload of
human customer support agents. Our primary objective is to generate informal
summaries for online articles and posts using an offline reinforcement learning
technique. In our study, we compare our proposed method with existing
approaches to text generation and provide a comprehensive overview of our
architectural design, which incorporates crawling, reinforcement learning, and
text generation modules. By presenting this original approach, our paper makes
a valuable contribution to the field of NLG by offering a fresh perspective on
generating natural language summaries for online content. Through the
implementation of Empowering NLG, we are able to generate higher-quality
replies in the online domain. The experimental results demonstrate a
significant improvement in the average "like" score, increasing from 0.09954378
to 0.5000152. This advancement has the potential to enhance the efficiency and
effectiveness of customer support services and elevate the overall user
experience when consuming online content. | [
0.1134293601,
0.0034506943,
-0.0099820299,
-0.0422974229,
-0.0142822294,
-0.001155366,
0.0049476763,
0.0073137577,
0.0341714509,
-0.0369353667,
0.0468699411,
-0.0155847082,
0.006797588,
0.0515073761,
-0.0170985553,
-0.075901106,
-0.0160193034,
-0.0050864019,
0.0487195179,
-0.0068496587,
0.0313396119,
0.0156027162,
0.0130226677,
0.0385278799,
0.0185315106,
0.0169654563,
-0.0074683679,
0.0193804372,
0.0012572051,
-0.0335063562,
0.0339788757,
-0.0059188828,
-0.0044695167,
0.0184051655,
0.0000018921,
-0.04781368,
-0.0191472284,
-0.012946683,
0.0218277797,
-0.0206114948,
0.0664638877,
-0.0020115373,
0.0077634905,
0.0634974688,
-0.0595366135,
0.0160200577,
0.0353837907,
0.0474846587,
0.0515787974,
0.0838550553,
-0.0076836459,
-0.0141476141,
0.001573843,
-0.0171617996,
0.0154923955,
-0.0177632179,
-0.0217241198,
0.0155843114,
0.0174664948,
-0.0242375769,
0.0144855529,
0.0212901421,
0.011034864,
-0.0279768966,
0.0253932644,
0.051773034,
0.0030564854,
-0.0147551158,
-0.0070893811,
0.0470690243,
-0.0171046201,
-0.0020653047,
0.0485163368,
-0.0018062098,
0.0077939522,
0.0156403258,
-0.0464126803,
0.0928106681,
-0.0389523692,
0.0039803195,
-0.0265777148,
0.0227132421,
-0.0204636659,
0.0197664779,
-0.0058032307,
0.0057395934,
-0.0152810114,
-0.0474810638,
-0.0309656989,
0.0195583273,
-0.0065646763,
-0.0454079844,
0.0133120595,
0.051226005,
-0.0561294891,
0.0125955129,
-0.0291645769,
-0.0310911927,
0.0377505384,
-0.0235673413,
0.0517454334,
0.0092355171,
0.0555219874,
0.0059894975,
-0.0560147129,
0.010037614,
0.0215349346,
-0.0078332443,
-0.0311221946,
0.0360808261,
-0.0496815555,
-0.0454192571,
-0.0396648124,
0.0900335237,
-0.0570141114,
-0.0380434021,
-0.0434869304,
0.0412139818,
0.0350346044,
0.0173463915,
0.0228295773,
0.0374488905,
-0.0444390774,
0.0254209507,
-0.0298161004,
-0.0282484945,
-0.0525131188,
-0.0264290031,
0.0437572747,
-0.0740464181,
0.021144975,
0.0024517339,
0.0409831628,
0.0219931472,
-0.0104495985,
0.0493088588,
-0.0368356779,
-0.0246219523,
-0.0327972174,
-0.0738169402,
-0.0023766498,
-0.0301041827,
-0.0273432359,
-0.0650449544,
0.0006093396,
-0.0150133427,
-0.0225812942,
0.0142270261,
0.0147045963,
0.0676534176,
-0.0295443907,
-0.0059186947,
-0.0695368424,
-0.004480483,
0.0279256757,
-0.0015465565,
0.0369050503,
0.0344309732,
0.0239368547,
0.0591413751,
0.068167612,
0.0291583203,
0.0333116576,
-0.0312675275,
0.0090014376,
-0.0232003573,
0.0251260344,
-0.0239229053,
-0.0537098609,
0.0175639726,
0.0195034388,
0.0473085009,
-0.0217291415,
0.0592859834,
0.0416265801,
0.0420712382,
0.0016979062,
0.0305387154,
0.0289170854,
0.0868162736,
-0.0004630955,
0.0336711928,
0.0063577374,
0.03631524,
-0.0326151177,
0.0599479116,
0.0550218672,
0.0373597592,
-0.0053364844,
-0.0532472394,
0.0121163959,
0.0057330732,
0.0583032221,
0.0013990258,
0.0067884983,
0.0340066664,
-0.0522997603,
-0.0456602685,
0.0236267168,
-0.0474457629,
0.0167968217,
-0.0361391753,
0.0129282288,
0.0866385177,
0.058888413,
0.0047500501,
-0.0270988308,
-0.0321666598,
-0.0199953597,
0.1161695942,
0.004381875,
0.0033670214,
-0.0506258421,
-0.0458649248,
-0.0409898348,
-0.0096004419,
-0.0018288617,
0.0117777595,
0.026046373,
0.0279722586,
0.0473379418,
0.0253207237,
-0.0877710506,
0.0170612186,
-0.0061294422,
-0.0097471885,
0.0307354126,
-0.017821854,
0.0040280446,
0.0177878197,
-0.0228536781,
0.0260194875,
-0.0194518771,
-0.0019573923,
-0.0757947266,
0.0153963752,
-0.0171503946,
-0.0168482829,
0.0035770976,
-0.0738674924,
0.045901794,
0.0153393243,
-0.0162961073,
-0.0273357183,
0.0077401842,
-0.0802639872,
0.0380836055,
-0.0436102711,
-0.0152083011,
0.0333230607,
0.0120312255,
-0.0382925421,
0.0404991806,
0.0136655299,
0.048899956,
0.0318257734,
-0.0301130377,
-0.0097676096,
-0.0364903435,
0.0212870929,
-0.0113337403,
-0.0163880438,
0.0369332619,
0.071190238,
0.0528683737,
-0.0169262514,
-0.0187485088,
-0.0685226247,
-0.0180825461,
-0.0046536475,
0.0057414887,
0.0618039034,
0.0244378261,
-0.0149781918,
-0.0450298078,
-0.0451593809,
-0.0139164049,
0.0479954407,
0.0144902123,
0.0326758549,
0.0057499041,
0.0109971724,
-0.0259221941,
-0.0008432145,
0.0117173949,
0.0077620829,
0.0494361706,
-0.0091647767,
-0.0808425397,
-0.0201912932,
-0.0417695343,
-0.0280300863,
0.0099684438,
-0.058095552,
-0.0042849183,
-0.0057680388,
0.0085019963,
0.0437156409,
0.0737595484,
0.0436939001,
0.0074868542,
0.0169461686,
-0.0379898772,
0.0042962553,
-0.0504555255,
-0.0094992854,
-0.0005447203,
-0.0425747856,
0.0657742843,
0.0340343192,
0.0318204351,
0.0278810952,
-0.0449453555,
0.0289698187,
-0.0158223007,
-0.0309163686,
-0.0264270455,
0.0314065851,
-0.0280413963,
0.0214833599,
-0.0152778374,
-0.0251798239,
0.063564077,
0.0429591499,
0.0128618591,
-0.0966182575,
-0.0293932948,
-0.0268444177,
0.0093748327,
0.0154931415,
0.0546237528,
0.0259204172,
-0.0382765085,
-0.0336519666,
-0.0022371355,
0.0668233037,
-0.0336484984,
-0.0120586585,
-0.0024391508,
0.0008811582,
0.005694929,
-0.0181254633,
-0.0322518051,
-0.0690248981,
-0.023890486,
-0.0101139229,
0.0311793108,
-0.0390449651,
-0.0414987579,
0.0065780217,
0.0276596099,
0.0580143631,
-0.0393054597,
-0.05337511,
-0.0021479614,
0.0550128706,
0.0703132898,
0.0241186209,
0.0123193879,
-0.0213546399,
0.0246050209,
0.0580496341,
-0.0061236448,
-0.0302759763,
0.0328713581,
-0.0275240801,
0.0084321974,
-0.087738499,
-0.0178813357,
0.0356354751,
-0.0246388018,
-0.0292059891,
-0.0142159183,
0.0892473683,
0.0519078784,
-0.0376124009,
-0.0030465764,
-0.0021445563,
0.0397077203,
0.0037029749,
0.0526195057,
-0.0519924127,
-0.0139829675,
-0.0033666426,
0.0792762563,
-0.0267404485,
-0.0252703335,
-0.0222593341,
-0.1219232306,
0.0169107132,
-0.0276952256,
-0.0502836704,
0.0008862086,
-0.0182226133,
-0.021427663,
0.0257551949,
-0.0066783554,
0.0325390026,
-0.0580624118,
0.0143268872,
0.0293524917,
-0.0334838815,
-0.0061112065,
-0.0597213544,
-0.0167432912,
0.0434183665,
0.0789996609,
0.0263889432,
0.0096903192,
0.0123726856,
-0.0160032362,
0.0010816364,
0.0272298772,
-0.0339390375,
0.0551004186,
-0.0049532056,
0.0117936935,
-0.0581012517,
0.0080032442,
-0.0107873334,
0.0168844145,
0.0246056374,
-0.0080852937,
0.0190025792,
-0.0382956341,
-0.0370651558,
0.0360370092,
0.0143571431,
0.0537043996,
0.0022635134,
-0.0654376745,
-0.0693389028,
-0.0339260586,
0.0006120593,
-0.0462491438,
-0.0264129378,
-0.0297520347,
-0.0285428986,
0.0082603469,
-0.1256649792,
-0.043611344,
-0.0151200006,
0.0215985253,
0.0031855572,
-0.030020887,
0.0305964928,
0.0382617116,
-0.0584512651,
-0.0647198185,
-0.0271020159,
-0.010701973,
-0.0291694608,
-0.0064134398,
0.0409708768,
-0.0671642572,
-0.0008858722,
-0.0336792804,
-0.0270324871,
-0.041102279,
-0.0133659346,
0.0392450206,
0.0218287315,
0.0406399034,
-0.0091822101,
-0.0383045971,
0.0667310581,
0.0742717832,
-0.0554978848,
-0.0032332232,
0.0105887027,
0.0644063279,
0.0103874747,
0.012912645,
-0.0689326152,
-0.0055760611,
-0.0614719838,
0.0492143892,
-0.0134879127,
-0.0081242165,
0.0284458641,
0.0318499953,
-0.0482677817,
-0.0242470987,
-0.0232925955,
-0.0087176971,
0.0097812405,
-0.0084316069,
-0.0059585748,
-0.0339016318,
0.0360819213,
-0.0354333334,
0.0110690398,
0.0343242623,
0.0648735464,
-0.0311917197,
0.0389368422,
-0.01767914,
-0.04083094,
-0.0323312432,
-0.0019620114,
-0.0117512289,
0.0083064297,
-0.0361787006,
-0.0051059052,
0.0148189086,
0.0388495773,
-0.0038989219,
0.0380908251,
0.0302346013,
-0.0359088592,
-0.0008038848,
0.0281481091,
-0.0764738694,
-0.0085195471,
-0.0728605092,
0.0174795315,
0.0265720077,
0.0024367427,
0.0616999902,
-0.0293657649,
0.0195492096,
0.0015632948,
0.0314141735,
-0.0049886918,
-0.0157134198,
-0.0299221296,
0.0065674474,
-0.0206790995,
-0.0074528703,
0.0930655897,
-0.0259095784,
-0.034046106,
0.0036370538,
-0.0196974054,
-0.0485697985,
-0.0158206858,
-0.0106451893,
0.0842630565,
0.0123774465,
-0.0311609376,
-0.024698548,
-0.0169763509,
-0.0145115983,
0.0192454141,
0.0338006616,
-0.0135908071,
0.074806042,
0.0131116286,
0.0188099742,
0.0206263885,
-0.0705046952,
0.0049416875,
-0.0239721704,
0.0016070164,
-0.0240578894,
-6.111223581e-33,
-0.0015643183,
-0.0768383071,
-0.0134972073,
0.02941099,
-0.0231948867,
-0.0015947571,
-0.0365865827,
0.0122523149,
0.0794263706,
-0.0045976266,
-0.0143974423,
0.0004010934,
0.017063085,
0.0454076305,
-0.0069834562,
0.00034858,
0.0508238003,
-0.0146483602,
-0.0217378959,
0.0575801805,
0.0355909094,
0.0211613011,
-0.012772155,
-0.0334837474,
0.0250802655,
-0.0243549999,
-0.0356828757,
-0.0095839379,
0.0375109799,
0.0399551764,
-0.0094560422,
0.0172711331,
0.0269920956,
-0.024306396,
-0.0130086578,
0.0434225872,
-0.0611544624,
-0.0332952254,
0.0121900477,
-0.0173951797,
-0.0444884822,
-0.0255939644,
0.0477887914,
-0.0344235487,
0.006091712,
0.0373584852,
0.0585470647,
-0.0296474956,
-0.0280552022,
-0.0816428438,
-0.0472808741,
0.002843282,
-0.0117470166,
0.0044032461,
-0.0160073806,
0.0458432175,
0.0003607373,
-0.0038154239,
-0.0178011917,
0.0425677858,
-0.0153255621,
0.0137677295,
0.0297383927,
-0.0046807863,
0.0013386331,
0.04907557,
-0.0173672866,
0.0216563791,
-0.0380513258,
0.0158380866,
-0.0052880007,
-0.0233375765,
0.003497404,
0.0401825123,
0.0618076697,
0.004479669,
-0.0135952178,
0.0706185922,
0.0639833286,
0.0158059001,
0.0617806278,
-0.043332465,
-0.0241041575,
-0.000823131,
0.0005365469,
0.0115084928,
-0.0170914251,
-0.0694189444,
0.0080190068,
0.0607472211,
-0.0693291351,
-0.0813400596,
-0.0396225676,
-0.0373208672,
-0.0043809018,
-0.0043188254,
-0.0127920555,
0.0033485391,
-0.0055864695,
-0.0709932894,
-0.0361239463,
-0.0102935033,
-0.0044077719,
-0.0141877905,
-0.0352384187,
0.0045660525,
0.0058363513,
-0.000782022,
-0.0831236914,
0.0478294045,
0.011669402,
0.0626934096,
-0.0011608449,
-0.0121227494,
0.0133516723,
-0.023871623,
-0.0276547745,
0.0468227118,
0.0015781217,
0.0026649998,
-0.0366074406,
0.0230901018,
0.031476222,
0.0284505729,
-0.0332722925,
0.0299544092,
-0.0364747271,
0.0248893257,
-0.0024150342,
-0.0462511182,
-0.0204803217,
-0.0018689922,
2.658e-7,
-0.0198545456,
0.0680966452,
0.0434882268,
0.0172151625,
0.0047303429,
0.0211488064,
0.0567341596,
0.0281497389,
0.0005530482,
0.0215895697,
0.027206704,
0.0064582434,
0.0300181359,
0.0127334092,
-0.1135889813,
-0.0090842191,
-0.078184858,
-0.0003630093,
-0.0067470102,
-0.0106841633,
0.0363359377,
0.0107184248,
0.0055572903,
-0.0008633225,
0.0025606907,
-0.0229873564,
0.0239758957,
0.0245401487,
0.0077549117,
0.0065612043,
0.0558629595,
0.0371971913,
-0.0080802655,
-0.032796625,
0.0036057141,
-0.0098865973,
0.0215763208,
0.0229568891,
0.0446300022,
-0.0191497896,
0.0222982578,
-0.0349582769,
0.0529964268,
-0.0150711471,
0.0155603206,
-0.0703251958,
0.0002052544,
-0.0004127136,
-0.0302137285,
-0.0432306901,
-0.0098394332,
-0.038641382,
-0.0630417988,
0.0212701019,
-0.0144420955,
0.018487066,
0.0258139074,
-0.031244671,
-0.0078316517,
0.0314187147,
-0.00362209,
-0.035168916,
-0.0329105556,
0.0373951234,
-0.0090997349,
-0.0399333313,
-0.00093629,
2.392254063e-34,
0.0463575982,
-0.0044367076,
-0.0173250902,
0.0125932768,
-0.0189823825,
0.0227597971,
-0.0042696428,
-0.0110099884,
0.0705209523,
-0.0656919777,
-0.01356644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10339v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10339v1 | Persian Semantic Role Labeling Using Transfer Learning and BERT-Based Models | 2023-06-17T12:50:09 | 2023-06-17T12:50:09 | Saeideh Niksirat Aghdam, Sayyed Ali Hossayni, Erfan Khedersolh Sadeh, Nasim Khozouei, Behrouz Minaei Bidgoli | cs.CL | cs.CL | Semantic role labeling (SRL) is the process of detecting the
predicate-argument structure of each predicate in a sentence. SRL plays a
crucial role as a pre-processing step in many NLP applications such as topic
and concept extraction, question answering, summarization, machine translation,
sentiment analysis, and text mining. Recently, in many languages, unified SRL
dragged lots of attention due to its outstanding performance, which is the
result of overcoming the error propagation problem. However, regarding the
Persian language, all previous works have focused on traditional methods of SRL
leading to a drop in accuracy and imposing expensive feature extraction steps
in terms of financial resources, time and energy consumption. In this work, we
present an end-to-end SRL method that not only eliminates the need for feature
extraction but also outperforms existing methods in facing new samples in
practical situations. The proposed method does not employ any auxiliary
features and shows more than 16 (83.16) percent improvement in accuracy against
previous methods in similar circumstances. | [
0.0351178385,
-0.0086281477,
0.0129056387,
0.0270557813,
-0.0385169312,
0.0135527859,
-0.0254198126,
-0.0386712328,
-0.0067787827,
-0.0453961864,
-0.0162449349,
-0.0137529112,
-0.0159688722,
-0.0267408509,
-0.0201963708,
-0.0217246506,
0.0567799956,
0.01485309,
0.0649838001,
0.0202276837,
0.0249782335,
0.0054268255,
-0.0431197584,
0.0054856972,
-0.0699880347,
-0.0032712624,
-0.0051947949,
-0.0251266323,
0.0489687324,
-0.0216613244,
0.0203763433,
0.0320809819,
0.0118793221,
-0.0596383885,
0.0000018948,
-0.0614159554,
-0.0769444555,
-0.0233322233,
0.0528278127,
-0.0357206166,
-0.0005069711,
0.0206082463,
-0.0420264862,
0.0433909036,
-0.0121493498,
-0.029268872,
0.0929109082,
0.0539735258,
0.0654962063,
0.0916962251,
-0.0180979464,
-0.0421458445,
-0.0290196277,
0.023247933,
0.012843498,
-0.0566509813,
0.0414630026,
-0.0155316666,
-0.0290009826,
-0.0208462533,
-0.0070854696,
0.0121529698,
-0.0228143968,
-0.042813763,
-0.0137045505,
-0.0325765684,
-0.0598484278,
-0.0049878112,
0.0544686578,
0.0175002236,
-0.0176278483,
-0.0215655398,
0.014979288,
0.0455669872,
-0.0084596882,
0.0596477389,
-0.0126103014,
0.0461472385,
-0.0093902862,
0.0154179623,
0.0906594098,
0.0306551177,
-0.0222792588,
0.0011810838,
-0.0537003502,
0.0830046609,
0.0189972222,
-0.0449189134,
0.0216540061,
0.0064969822,
-0.0244457908,
0.0047627636,
0.0674512237,
0.0226390511,
-0.0346515216,
0.0546882711,
-0.0414206423,
-0.040326003,
-0.0034310238,
-0.0704375654,
0.0038288992,
0.046080254,
0.005430283,
0.0210918542,
-0.0595495477,
-0.0051151514,
0.0471205786,
-0.0158088133,
-0.0652328134,
-0.0260256212,
-0.0570405871,
-0.0139582353,
-0.0698778331,
0.0451684259,
-0.0037791689,
-0.0257685743,
-0.058285024,
0.0220129844,
-0.0040078959,
0.0332232453,
0.0345887318,
-0.0236167945,
0.0012195199,
0.0546880513,
0.005703086,
0.0270954389,
0.0048031905,
-0.0120079815,
-0.0641137585,
-0.0281937066,
-0.0025840858,
0.0262574218,
0.0232240371,
-0.0115176542,
-0.0256854743,
0.0170818139,
-0.000089247,
-0.0441864096,
-0.0074375048,
0.0260016266,
-0.0053499332,
0.00212015,
0.0222980343,
-0.0546408929,
0.0115112346,
0.0087128822,
-0.0014188592,
0.0056307702,
0.0390389375,
0.0358008631,
-0.0130170304,
0.0725422576,
-0.0053155459,
0.0302938391,
-0.0088231144,
-0.0038610173,
0.0399214439,
0.0307737347,
0.0229168311,
0.0047816425,
0.0540569946,
-0.0100929709,
-0.0318869986,
0.0022339416,
-0.0096917134,
-0.0177878141,
0.0582925417,
-0.011598588,
0.0054669101,
0.0223868396,
-0.0301094595,
0.0026014934,
0.0048083053,
0.0335963033,
0.0214200635,
0.0334460214,
-0.0172938332,
0.0237876885,
-0.0001802737,
0.0479791351,
0.0511130579,
0.0068899584,
-0.0034678895,
-0.0332055911,
0.05845052,
0.0293383095,
-0.040387515,
-0.0049219192,
-0.0103679681,
-0.0224181544,
-0.0256512836,
-0.0664257258,
-0.0072874911,
-0.0267199837,
0.0783837214,
0.0398730375,
-0.0216756556,
0.0998931304,
0.060295511,
-0.0189204626,
0.0131381489,
-0.0496121719,
0.0026143498,
0.0402769223,
-0.0123709654,
-0.1097934619,
-0.023958277,
0.0346733555,
-0.0097493827,
-0.0013673431,
0.0156107135,
-0.0246912707,
-0.0183491409,
-0.0186929442,
-0.0253932141,
0.0287713408,
0.0240504742,
-0.0180804767,
-0.0045791706,
0.010840687,
0.0156444237,
-0.0155599201,
-0.0129574835,
0.0318402536,
0.0355189182,
-0.0002626274,
0.006733438,
0.0098360097,
0.0046304767,
0.0225200616,
-0.0213093199,
0.0283061694,
0.0230754595,
-0.0601703413,
0.0014541395,
0.009499304,
-0.0678972527,
-0.044334203,
0.0329217017,
-0.0681072101,
-0.025097115,
0.0771287233,
-0.0293111205,
-0.0495566092,
0.0328952782,
-0.0323984548,
0.0032891654,
-0.029887272,
0.051368691,
0.0314433724,
0.0186356641,
-0.0413989201,
0.039236702,
0.0160810985,
-0.0190411285,
-0.0163140614,
-0.0197511036,
0.0077137561,
0.0046611731,
-0.0215152483,
0.0334726609,
-0.0040785619,
-0.049812872,
0.0613389984,
-0.0021995457,
-0.0130130351,
0.0144828856,
-0.0540319011,
-0.009950947,
-0.0250523593,
0.0777428225,
0.0438940078,
0.0153969694,
0.0178996511,
0.0066651832,
-0.0550801381,
-0.0422276519,
-0.0126605146,
-0.0299084615,
0.0496115796,
-0.0491428673,
-0.0248288251,
-0.0357976034,
-0.0084144026,
-0.0221725646,
0.0301414877,
-0.0053745592,
-0.0371767431,
-0.0018393124,
-0.0238355622,
0.0468208157,
0.0381394066,
0.038548667,
-0.0250822231,
-0.0293076355,
-0.0065623359,
-0.0086259646,
0.0100028627,
-0.0176789686,
0.0095382854,
0.0182660725,
-0.004825437,
0.0080862027,
-0.0008777646,
-0.0137690995,
0.0081246775,
-0.0414484181,
-0.0562906004,
0.0282167178,
0.028265221,
-0.0495640747,
-0.0193970259,
-0.0274605136,
-0.060414996,
-0.0418370217,
0.0205064509,
0.0350568518,
0.0023209143,
-0.0072701587,
0.0259998329,
-0.0054885061,
0.029848421,
-0.000526128,
-0.0221887715,
0.0353333913,
-0.0913333297,
0.0135555109,
-0.0502907448,
0.02137083,
0.0023607868,
0.0331042856,
-0.0307547543,
-0.0351445414,
0.003577553,
-0.0363959782,
0.0165420603,
-0.0062232949,
-0.0323530436,
-0.0363514349,
0.011456809,
-0.0498894304,
0.010623388,
-0.0230737627,
-0.0048192227,
0.0075819073,
0.0361780077,
0.022634482,
-0.0151545014,
0.0098807169,
0.0119702481,
0.0040868889,
0.0058892001,
0.005817506,
0.0432875901,
-0.0033642983,
0.039167244,
0.0256984811,
-0.0268623848,
0.0005871218,
0.0296973474,
0.023773808,
0.0514250547,
-0.0058360389,
-0.0021884213,
-0.0260692798,
-0.0175461024,
0.0502001345,
-0.100117065,
-0.0400383323,
-0.0504183322,
-0.0203685518,
-0.0489089005,
-0.0099730697,
0.128288269,
0.0326225758,
0.0057663373,
0.0037891944,
0.0095611233,
-0.0744237974,
-0.0044758129,
0.0135107981,
-0.0495500304,
-0.0047541093,
0.0345027409,
-0.0124006886,
-0.030690778,
-0.0037042033,
0.0448465012,
-0.1123598516,
-0.0032174182,
-0.0413647145,
-0.0598286688,
-0.0257153194,
-0.0482382812,
0.0059589995,
0.0013422654,
-0.0421340391,
-0.034455236,
-0.0234977808,
0.0091099227,
0.0524742976,
-0.0765926391,
-0.0308539551,
-0.0105924848,
-0.0512175411,
-0.0098580606,
0.076021269,
0.0534777157,
-0.0248694755,
-0.0304451026,
-0.0195317641,
-0.0037475899,
-0.0538686663,
-0.0012776632,
0.0001443095,
-0.0290875211,
-0.0361648947,
0.0167366527,
-0.0122290337,
-0.064755097,
-0.001731107,
-0.0061283363,
0.0356636904,
0.0149844531,
0.0335410126,
0.0222254936,
0.0019340242,
0.0139703359,
0.0405846722,
-0.0305030216,
-0.005994021,
-0.0450527407,
0.0144320726,
-0.0158049911,
-0.0418927781,
-0.0167711787,
0.0151285315,
-0.0604884215,
-0.0606042631,
-0.0783388689,
-0.0119368564,
0.0433996655,
0.0136756171,
0.0017144394,
0.0282577351,
0.0466873422,
0.0085973265,
-0.0590058006,
-0.0513517745,
0.0065711024,
0.0357462093,
-0.0098670805,
-0.0371941403,
0.0421598777,
-0.0297768991,
0.0004388749,
-0.0368269794,
0.0586790182,
-0.0053747385,
0.0753394738,
0.0129628098,
0.0055845683,
-0.0132868495,
-0.0126937013,
-0.0269856025,
0.031171456,
0.0236001071,
-0.0176115669,
-0.0171644073,
0.0325083286,
-0.0054374766,
-0.0315069109,
0.0373775475,
-0.0064206645,
0.0216465276,
0.0000381412,
-0.0015623978,
-0.0218324885,
-0.0160497185,
0.0363656953,
0.0183664318,
0.051546257,
0.0061714808,
0.0116189634,
-0.0171439722,
0.0403934866,
-0.0453613251,
-0.0303542037,
-0.0184809808,
0.0248421524,
0.0368338414,
0.0343035609,
-0.0013075566,
0.0138891973,
0.0330751799,
-0.0335924961,
0.0254096594,
0.0376977026,
0.029948663,
0.0377550647,
-0.0472343005,
-0.0178506095,
-0.0327445716,
-0.054592602,
0.0255439803,
0.0004352355,
-0.008635696,
-0.0179069694,
0.0066600344,
-0.0180956814,
0.0377055109,
0.0348196439,
-0.0116708772,
-0.037326429,
-0.0076493099,
0.0468227528,
0.0726671219,
-0.0767099112,
0.0811004713,
-0.0247452129,
-0.0061297724,
0.0059892656,
0.0323359966,
0.0158677083,
0.0187225398,
-0.0021746692,
-0.0210323799,
0.0109691275,
-0.0273992736,
0.033860445,
0.0071581514,
0.0007370242,
-0.0042367019,
-0.0707418323,
-0.0007919489,
-0.0421055704,
0.0145482859,
-0.0030001323,
-0.0482622348,
-0.0023568179,
-0.0133344075,
-0.0561342053,
-0.0167450346,
0.0069378479,
0.0210516453,
-0.0146601982,
0.0493647344,
0.0386733525,
0.043459665,
-0.0308831707,
-0.0685562864,
-0.0338338166,
-0.0253294129,
0.0242539048,
0.005653068,
-5.756143839e-33,
-0.0422538966,
0.010842938,
-0.0131709399,
0.0354534574,
-0.0018061118,
0.0046611303,
-0.0024861111,
-0.0032419856,
0.0086008599,
0.0583223775,
-0.001102185,
0.0036124727,
0.0441764854,
0.0317486152,
0.024145985,
0.0008467486,
0.0310140885,
0.0198631566,
0.0181007944,
0.0118752085,
0.0837274492,
0.0557320677,
0.1311375052,
-0.0894584209,
-0.0025102117,
-0.018830901,
-0.0081085116,
0.0492398255,
0.0188595895,
0.0105974535,
0.0217618365,
0.0068387687,
0.012028276,
-0.0755572841,
0.0109891742,
0.0391097739,
-0.1179983839,
-0.0241962466,
0.0210536718,
0.0643662214,
-0.0294876695,
-0.0120015545,
-0.0185852349,
0.0091567822,
0.0036075867,
0.0309723988,
0.052296292,
-0.0290316269,
0.0224183127,
-0.067658253,
-0.1073554233,
0.0332437716,
-0.0123231122,
-0.0076653282,
0.015565902,
0.0351019688,
-0.0062759202,
-0.0155423339,
-0.0227366872,
-0.0273775142,
-0.0871992931,
0.0474485159,
0.0352447107,
0.0401866361,
-0.037168093,
0.0160413086,
-0.0131068807,
-0.0337368548,
0.0644957423,
0.0202859845,
-0.0369016901,
0.038678728,
-0.0087789269,
-0.0052777813,
0.028879391,
-0.0124609005,
-0.10114602,
0.0297406837,
0.0283419061,
0.0682884604,
0.0153157767,
-0.0207149591,
-0.0368889794,
-0.0298297796,
0.0138009526,
0.0462311879,
0.0076101748,
-0.0237420853,
-0.0135246301,
-0.0129673416,
-0.0725095496,
0.0814598948,
-0.0082254745,
-0.0302829985,
0.0570508651,
-0.0296043679,
-0.0160918627,
-0.0015700118,
-0.0638639703,
0.00982376,
-0.0751851946,
-0.0860240459,
-0.0165278763,
-0.0245353747,
0.024690792,
0.0293264389,
0.0334006473,
0.0239166208,
-0.0478142835,
0.0227143764,
-0.0362208672,
0.010593826,
-0.0164618623,
0.092008613,
0.0035558245,
0.0062515214,
-0.0186581928,
0.0213179197,
0.047085464,
0.0145723578,
0.0012868943,
-0.0324072763,
-0.0097526815,
-0.0434534214,
-0.0039909771,
0.0106734326,
-0.0560853593,
0.0313717388,
-0.0090649966,
-0.0436218083,
-0.0020004404,
-0.0161842182,
2.746e-7,
0.095628418,
0.0143213747,
0.0158009119,
0.0227387361,
-0.0123033617,
-0.0008103483,
-0.0095970454,
0.0780393109,
0.0110991383,
0.0612840578,
0.0380228721,
0.0217867419,
0.0067610391,
0.0208698194,
-0.1121725887,
-0.0585546158,
-0.0370383933,
-0.0310152918,
-0.0073547196,
0.0524093732,
0.0718358904,
0.0624448247,
0.0007772833,
-0.0086700758,
-0.0064788479,
-0.0346391276,
0.0337294266,
-0.0020307067,
-0.017853586,
0.0581900254,
0.0368359052,
-0.0160782859,
-0.0234366897,
0.0253795069,
-0.0091217561,
0.0157254618,
0.0507505797,
0.0760794729,
0.0020559083,
0.0000728976,
0.0040506762,
-0.0062103416,
0.0606050715,
-0.0055434234,
0.0620107763,
-0.0140347388,
-0.0322184302,
-0.016127022,
-0.0451630652,
0.0376537591,
-0.0171744414,
0.0253967419,
0.0094579728,
0.0303962044,
0.0065030884,
-0.0354338586,
-0.0405204594,
-0.0683194697,
-0.0093327435,
-0.0281124488,
0.0338230245,
-0.038257625,
0.0356317386,
-0.0235274937,
0.0010531282,
0.0107011991,
-0.0024415872,
2.454344731e-34,
0.0077603082,
0.0158059318,
-0.021872025,
0.0297413617,
0.0352012031,
-0.0081077125,
-0.0188488197,
0.0497819297,
-0.0121239359,
-0.0100961793,
-0.0013401123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10322v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10322v3 | CorNav: Autonomous Agent with Self-Corrected Planning for Zero-Shot Vision-and-Language Navigation | 2023-06-17T11:44:04 | 2024-03-14T14:33:51 | Xiwen Liang, Liang Ma, Shanshan Guo, Jianhua Han, Hang Xu, Shikui Ma, Xiaodan Liang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Understanding and following natural language instructions while navigating
through complex, real-world environments poses a significant challenge for
general-purpose robots. These environments often include obstacles and
pedestrians, making it essential for autonomous agents to possess the
capability of self-corrected planning to adjust their actions based on feedback
from the surroundings. However, the majority of existing vision-and-language
navigation (VLN) methods primarily operate in less realistic simulator settings
and do not incorporate environmental feedback into their decision-making
processes. To address this gap, we introduce a novel zero-shot framework called
CorNav, utilizing a large language model for decision-making and comprising two
key components: 1) incorporating environmental feedback for refining future
plans and adjusting its actions, and 2) multiple domain experts for parsing
instructions, scene understanding, and refining predicted actions. In addition
to the framework, we develop a 3D simulator that renders realistic scenarios
using Unreal Engine 5. To evaluate the effectiveness and generalization of
navigation agents in a zero-shot multi-task setting, we create a benchmark
called NavBench. Extensive experiments demonstrate that CorNav consistently
outperforms all baselines by a significant margin across all tasks. On average,
CorNav achieves a success rate of 28.1\%, surpassing the best baseline's
performance of 20.5\%. | [
0.0317048542,
0.00279575,
0.0281943455,
-0.012880954,
-0.0183675196,
0.00878736,
-0.0116029931,
-0.0306720603,
-0.0006921658,
-0.0508346222,
-0.0320924744,
0.0022355667,
-0.015671853,
0.0338873342,
0.0025311918,
-0.0383742154,
0.0339503698,
-0.0642776415,
-0.0103221973,
0.007306512,
-0.016111929,
-0.0094253812,
-0.0390090868,
0.041965425,
-0.001478957,
-0.0042360094,
-0.0464344248,
0.0452106073,
0.0249057077,
-0.0643130764,
-0.0010400229,
0.0193232987,
0.0902769193,
-0.0008782698,
0.0000020978,
-0.0293107014,
0.0162940118,
-0.0466059223,
-0.0032858038,
-0.0420608222,
0.0340808071,
-0.0205348004,
-0.0224692486,
0.0218810532,
-0.0434720665,
-0.0378690548,
0.0489717126,
0.0424105451,
0.0495323241,
0.0664417073,
-0.0104114106,
-0.0290224664,
-0.0485593565,
0.0224677641,
0.0001152423,
-0.0498807244,
-0.0047229663,
0.0197348054,
0.0096792094,
-0.0009564355,
-0.0239981096,
0.0035422444,
0.0240360275,
-0.0269668736,
-0.0001164575,
0.0681955665,
-0.0245964304,
-0.0562475808,
-0.0408335403,
0.0760142431,
-0.0099283475,
-0.0211362243,
0.0033094538,
0.0253509935,
-0.0123859486,
-0.0422471538,
-0.0301383641,
0.0141604235,
-0.0125129046,
-0.0043633417,
-0.0467462018,
-0.0053389627,
-0.0006134081,
-0.0193428304,
-0.0187489223,
0.0563587099,
-0.0005755216,
0.0199973974,
0.0187345054,
0.0023801653,
0.0124250129,
-0.0840818658,
-0.0042140665,
0.06879583,
-0.0600484051,
0.0281709172,
-0.0600020625,
0.0436190702,
-0.0444601364,
-0.0511047766,
0.0419889204,
0.0668116659,
-0.0248971917,
0.0488548204,
-0.0372937731,
0.0662937611,
-0.0135961426,
0.0454559997,
-0.0220858678,
-0.0067193848,
-0.0522613302,
0.0330666155,
-0.033767812,
0.0202196203,
-0.0357440263,
-0.0483335853,
-0.0045413305,
0.0283616465,
-0.0193330869,
0.021407634,
-0.0380052589,
0.055668354,
-0.0339698419,
-0.0034177443,
-0.0391911194,
0.0003839777,
-0.0194305778,
-0.0089787347,
-0.0200961027,
-0.0277777109,
0.0015049307,
0.0270528048,
0.0058873068,
-0.0018254322,
0.0063095554,
0.1296547502,
-0.016013952,
-0.0383775905,
-0.0115003139,
0.0336308666,
-0.0091146156,
-0.0615631118,
0.0140834888,
-0.0525393523,
0.003387392,
-0.0058424054,
-0.0246670712,
-0.0455295667,
0.0148606552,
0.0083010038,
0.0128173605,
0.0670545548,
0.0095661441,
0.0121520227,
0.0330536813,
-0.0022664815,
0.0311694685,
0.0636951253,
0.041113168,
0.052829057,
-0.0066848225,
0.0497652367,
0.0398142859,
0.0424653478,
-0.0534503758,
0.0193166807,
-0.0186944958,
-0.0066143167,
-0.0122720907,
0.0651215985,
0.0154102407,
0.024123596,
-0.0418822318,
-0.0133071216,
0.031850528,
0.0056734402,
-0.0125582358,
-0.0251417011,
0.0850969031,
0.0337876417,
0.0066568786,
-0.0477727503,
-0.0496577658,
0.0741801634,
-0.030765716,
-0.0127080763,
-0.040641278,
0.0156656951,
-0.0400747396,
-0.0540954061,
0.0178800672,
0.007951593,
0.0201052744,
-0.0136458771,
0.0563660637,
-0.0117820418,
-0.0831279829,
-0.0245416909,
0.003548967,
-0.03189224,
-0.0291960426,
-0.0206135791,
0.0224331673,
0.0745059997,
0.0205587838,
0.0083049592,
-0.0803454667,
0.0031575232,
0.008816489,
0.0621951558,
-0.0108795483,
-0.004244063,
0.0579228215,
-0.0280402694,
-0.0578636974,
-0.0065899249,
-0.0154349376,
0.0655515715,
0.0130084362,
0.0264112689,
-0.0075343833,
0.0067153899,
0.0286648721,
0.0533078387,
0.0194704849,
-0.0039253118,
-0.0028320758,
-0.0141063239,
0.016239468,
0.0112489611,
-0.0341667272,
-0.0218537915,
0.0220005214,
0.0006758246,
-0.0077041565,
0.0313692838,
-0.0272059664,
-0.0235764794,
0.0553643145,
-0.0595563948,
-0.0099283429,
0.0635385588,
-0.0148743559,
-0.0389746726,
-0.0042031216,
-0.0154248243,
-0.0194134545,
0.0222876295,
0.0166085083,
0.0175305195,
-0.0125125712,
-0.0172953457,
0.0361571088,
-0.0020977536,
-0.0395168699,
0.0083290245,
0.0221931525,
0.0340344384,
-0.0371591598,
0.0156078273,
-0.0158530902,
0.0300134532,
-0.0316662267,
0.0478573516,
0.0408373065,
-0.0325658135,
0.0102857174,
-0.0868435875,
-0.031431146,
-0.0440523438,
-0.0271020066,
0.0200206526,
-0.0458164923,
0.0043543279,
-0.0224055052,
0.0114076575,
0.0436428934,
0.0188287497,
-0.0350001119,
0.0123649277,
-0.0042851963,
-0.0375887305,
-0.0589861721,
0.0146425925,
-0.0209395289,
-0.0216424875,
0.0151026193,
-0.0411745943,
-0.0212135762,
0.0499657169,
-0.0587181263,
0.0689192787,
-0.0250705704,
-0.0476494469,
0.0346474275,
-0.0314305015,
-0.0021013578,
0.0490968041,
-0.0283041857,
0.0002290627,
0.0581598021,
-0.0243163947,
-0.0399272554,
0.0341075696,
-0.0010455534,
-0.0164242033,
-0.0885724425,
0.0183432177,
-0.0094949072,
0.0365841277,
-0.0203486402,
0.0318192616,
-0.0628126636,
-0.0110605489,
-0.0121752797,
-0.0873356238,
-0.0135841575,
0.0507880896,
-0.0210523196,
0.0538738258,
-0.0385912172,
-0.0047939015,
0.0414123982,
-0.0232247673,
-0.0274426267,
0.0098383501,
0.0144766783,
-0.0037393838,
0.0618158169,
0.0228506401,
0.0133126378,
0.0317998081,
-0.0025602446,
-0.0086488388,
-0.0459647998,
-0.0276138484,
0.0088329893,
0.0486635044,
-0.0935770497,
0.0390424654,
0.0109917913,
-0.0323114395,
-0.0253645163,
-0.0099809151,
-0.0393324904,
0.0203604139,
-0.0500906706,
-0.071228981,
-0.0502738915,
-0.0030040247,
0.0301533584,
0.0931214988,
-0.0173557904,
-0.0393778309,
-0.0176053029,
-0.0197102595,
0.0818841085,
0.0451157801,
0.0076452764,
-0.034728229,
0.0384823941,
0.0372306854,
0.0478313826,
0.0010560435,
-0.0739408955,
0.0322860405,
0.0230145101,
0.0169199724,
0.0087732105,
0.0541562252,
0.036109075,
-0.0492181107,
-0.0313282274,
0.0964766219,
0.0382611677,
0.0082798582,
-0.0072007463,
-0.0805814415,
0.013676797,
0.0498987176,
0.0299001448,
-0.0383494645,
-0.0592351668,
0.0041800141,
-0.0189988874,
0.0142547209,
-0.0281638596,
0.0174719598,
-0.0991495401,
0.0474114902,
0.0222514588,
-0.0785491392,
-0.0086522456,
-0.0051360284,
0.014578566,
-0.0419767871,
-0.0002087255,
0.0161798261,
0.0299982708,
-0.0249399394,
-0.0028341259,
-0.0002419648,
-0.0173013434,
0.0293428358,
-0.0222729649,
0.042043481,
0.071519576,
0.0295511037,
-0.0174810532,
0.0077417647,
-0.008548717,
0.0307470001,
0.0474593267,
-0.0263602734,
0.024973413,
-0.0510480702,
-0.0150985839,
0.0100816488,
0.0045932583,
-0.030936148,
-0.0194228478,
0.0035590362,
0.0069063893,
-0.0464156568,
0.014296975,
-0.0393462293,
0.0276305955,
-0.0065398375,
0.0266320333,
-0.0410648622,
-0.0111915022,
-0.0751666129,
-0.0365993604,
-0.0668917224,
-0.0456241891,
-0.0486181639,
-0.0035645338,
-0.0278478675,
-0.0490207151,
-0.0526589602,
-0.0722044781,
0.0780193061,
0.0790248364,
0.0045074369,
-0.0586386696,
-0.0097867968,
0.0331751704,
-0.0157775618,
-0.0020524454,
-0.0513050556,
0.0046411064,
-0.0271066297,
0.0252896156,
0.0314613171,
-0.0395416543,
0.0100998431,
0.0387882702,
-0.0185379721,
-0.0538262092,
0.0256746393,
0.0751545504,
0.0137646133,
0.0375577696,
-0.0092420932,
-0.0278174877,
0.0492241606,
0.0040845298,
-0.0133970026,
0.0587865412,
0.0345165581,
0.0054802746,
0.0215767659,
0.0263631511,
-0.0544578731,
0.0395293236,
0.0072894068,
0.0262849294,
-0.018374199,
-0.0177760869,
0.0362345986,
-0.0171040669,
0.0330244228,
0.0057376018,
0.0502387546,
0.0100232055,
-0.0164484084,
-0.0406904966,
-0.0163151454,
-0.0614471212,
0.030282924,
0.0196933858,
0.0135911303,
0.0504544415,
0.0313334092,
-0.0478670076,
-0.0129504707,
0.0118876211,
-0.0338794775,
0.0392937474,
0.0001450973,
-0.0087201102,
0.0010210091,
0.0074717272,
0.0045003681,
-0.0015695399,
0.0358676277,
0.0174259879,
0.0590965934,
0.0246968009,
-0.0258843843,
-0.0337451212,
0.0147598498,
-0.0532543212,
-0.0752254501,
0.0174414124,
0.075226292,
0.0677597374,
0.0157532878,
0.0500582717,
-0.0652192235,
0.0243585594,
-0.0154917035,
-0.0364063419,
0.0203535557,
-0.0387358405,
0.0562275164,
0.0240106843,
0.0046830829,
-0.0002183083,
0.0205750018,
0.0191332214,
0.0633205548,
0.0179544501,
-0.0031912834,
-0.0470427237,
-0.0112182712,
0.0268822461,
0.019653488,
0.0007065144,
-0.0130949644,
-0.0205655359,
-0.0154191898,
-0.0003379517,
0.0745886117,
-0.0148193613,
-0.0441354029,
0.0445429422,
0.0186140556,
0.0021875824,
-0.0563085638,
-0.0299353898,
-0.0496491343,
-0.0164148826,
0.0161692183,
-0.0030545129,
-5.537552583e-33,
-0.0631134585,
-0.0281138737,
0.0733781904,
-0.0435366035,
-0.0045018224,
-0.0264925025,
-0.0322983898,
0.0065680458,
-0.039015092,
0.0214295425,
-0.003093479,
0.0262569077,
0.022889087,
0.0134460954,
0.0104975784,
-0.0108161587,
0.0402914174,
-0.0083823791,
-0.0722807646,
-0.0200319346,
0.0198618732,
0.0110615985,
0.0213586446,
-0.0478843786,
-0.0211957935,
-0.0034877725,
-0.0443513021,
0.0382969305,
0.0031641193,
0.0403739437,
0.0105920136,
-0.0005714517,
0.0036396524,
-0.0474679135,
-0.0183350071,
-0.0066537554,
-0.0478480868,
-0.0355467536,
-0.0175621342,
0.0424893163,
-0.0705738217,
-0.0045982674,
0.0344403051,
0.0014115622,
-0.0273137502,
0.0098888725,
0.0317090899,
-0.0138003845,
-0.0226286426,
0.040259134,
-0.0692609176,
0.0142894583,
-0.011748448,
-0.0731502324,
0.0394496657,
0.0752763003,
-0.0089022825,
-0.0097226016,
-0.0388486087,
-0.0013045701,
-0.0294672493,
0.006307641,
0.0657697767,
0.0444257036,
0.0401388891,
0.0622064658,
0.0691476911,
-0.0171961263,
-0.0278951023,
-0.0159843471,
0.0315242074,
0.056493897,
-0.0172335356,
0.0757393092,
0.0026559681,
0.0327664688,
-0.0354437903,
0.0313094668,
-0.0637070686,
0.0998849794,
0.0173286293,
0.0234485008,
-0.0411730036,
0.0100485533,
-0.0266275331,
0.0084012058,
-0.0011377048,
-0.0455323569,
0.0262074713,
0.0214752555,
-0.0022828674,
-0.0348387659,
0.0559042618,
-0.0142802717,
0.0402046144,
0.0203598905,
-0.0422105119,
0.055390913,
-0.0189192612,
0.0397694558,
-0.0521088392,
-0.0278843325,
0.0300669763,
0.0056010955,
0.0054185106,
0.0212472547,
-0.0456374511,
0.0797914118,
-0.0057133366,
-0.0305746235,
-0.0478369445,
-0.0194909163,
0.0284851193,
0.0221610554,
0.0443526357,
-0.0234341137,
-0.0332842022,
0.0308025945,
-0.0080753351,
-0.0910198689,
0.0168551132,
-0.0166102331,
0.0189602338,
0.0087328386,
-0.0309302695,
0.0145389708,
-0.0552616194,
0.0135825025,
-0.005071145,
-0.0497967228,
-0.0087365918,
0.0285472348,
2.808e-7,
-0.0268087517,
0.0442250259,
0.0099340221,
0.0009166399,
-0.0119679533,
0.0775565282,
0.00110786,
0.0370081551,
-0.0283336621,
-0.0312733129,
0.0429576859,
0.0906691402,
-0.0239365082,
-0.01421245,
-0.0533775538,
0.0394712314,
0.0383230858,
-0.0236191507,
-0.0370533168,
0.0074806903,
0.0422693826,
0.0664402843,
0.0089976005,
-0.0013448787,
0.0401973836,
-0.0022163456,
0.0537884533,
-0.0274345912,
-0.0161145199,
-0.0091869803,
0.0169989411,
0.0444552377,
-0.0472839065,
0.0002120065,
0.0348607861,
0.0158974342,
-0.0095131863,
0.0699301809,
-0.0561750196,
-0.0324559473,
0.0064735515,
0.0067180493,
-0.0082330117,
-0.0198307689,
0.0590101928,
-0.0382504873,
-0.0043873787,
-0.0209878031,
-0.0055444944,
0.018083591,
-0.0294072889,
-0.012142051,
-0.015785588,
-0.0372825116,
0.0152165284,
0.0017766661,
-0.0300736278,
-0.0472885333,
0.0141605502,
0.0289850496,
-0.0189404618,
0.008818984,
-0.0266424529,
0.001097302,
0.0312545709,
-0.0515642613,
-0.0387647003,
1.813891443e-34,
-0.0001139841,
0.0017017816,
-0.0031196983,
-0.0163126457,
0.0105080288,
0.0327717215,
-0.039410416,
0.0048570414,
0.0235412773,
-0.0168487765,
-0.034593273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10317v1 | Seen to Unseen: Exploring Compositional Generalization of Multi-Attribute Controllable Dialogue Generation | 2023-06-17T10:50:19 | 2023-06-17T10:50:19 | Weihao Zeng, Lulu Zhao, Keqing He, Ruotong Geng, Jingang Wang, Wei Wu, Weiran Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing controllable dialogue generation work focuses on the
single-attribute control and lacks generalization capability to
out-of-distribution multiple attribute combinations. In this paper, we explore
the compositional generalization for multi-attribute controllable dialogue
generation where a model can learn from seen attribute values and generalize to
unseen combinations. We propose a prompt-based disentangled controllable
dialogue generation model, DCG. It learns attribute concept composition by
generating attribute-oriented prompt vectors and uses a disentanglement loss to
disentangle different attributes for better generalization. Besides, we design
a unified reference-free evaluation framework for multiple attributes with
different levels of granularities. Experiment results on two benchmarks prove
the effectiveness of our method and the evaluation metric. | [
0.0000047754,
0.0556100793,
0.0123012969,
0.0122100711,
0.011510727,
0.0388594642,
0.0338119194,
-0.0221102182,
-0.0114404419,
-0.0026656943,
-0.0186358523,
-0.0604618229,
0.0072671245,
0.0721728727,
0.0398607999,
-0.066726394,
0.023622578,
-0.0136933094,
0.0108734975,
-0.0235739537,
0.0044880891,
-0.0133560225,
-0.0320631638,
0.0297036078,
-0.0103212055,
-0.012771667,
-0.0753476545,
-0.0147044342,
0.0211767741,
-0.0155990208,
-0.00107219,
0.0270940065,
0.0212681424,
0.0034994311,
0.0000017157,
-0.0219185986,
-0.0047420333,
-0.02406024,
0.0010265947,
-0.0368228257,
-0.0213325489,
0.0277256463,
0.0403691866,
0.0249974839,
-0.0256543625,
-0.0343994237,
0.0710664168,
0.0504371673,
0.1063234657,
0.0701589435,
-0.0107597783,
-0.0572825298,
0.0091096982,
-0.0513413884,
0.0628515258,
-0.0375701152,
-0.0213509426,
-0.0111096455,
-0.0120849526,
0.0101031121,
-0.0346587114,
0.0122871911,
0.0433803461,
-0.0193058532,
0.0149017368,
0.0323866047,
0.002094073,
-0.0193370022,
-0.0081669623,
0.1152381077,
0.023828689,
0.0427361764,
0.0283516459,
-0.0189064331,
0.0280692447,
-0.0516820699,
-0.0352749415,
0.0191794932,
-0.0163120236,
-0.0109609263,
-0.0394453295,
0.0505197719,
-0.0123811681,
0.0000697157,
-0.0225405954,
0.0151882097,
0.0180835333,
-0.0188986063,
-0.0332146138,
-0.0018258062,
-0.0212224517,
-0.0618614554,
-0.0124014849,
0.0067910152,
-0.0729022399,
0.0028120747,
-0.0603563823,
-0.0079528773,
-0.0266025923,
0.0228578467,
0.0606153086,
0.0415830687,
0.0100607751,
0.0381462984,
-0.0221582837,
0.0825440511,
-0.0339983366,
0.0122942086,
-0.0062025059,
-0.0035474065,
-0.0713391677,
-0.0293176919,
-0.0383915976,
0.0658535287,
-0.026439555,
-0.0383989327,
-0.0382251851,
0.0202296246,
-0.0402234867,
0.0481438525,
0.0020243642,
0.0385044031,
-0.0481301993,
-0.0037574258,
-0.0207752902,
0.0137353027,
-0.0582285263,
-0.0225198455,
0.0876531303,
-0.0106871156,
-0.0164982639,
0.0270207077,
0.0263710264,
-0.0069656647,
-0.0251565892,
0.0488520823,
-0.0756766424,
-0.011759731,
0.0283714291,
-0.0505652316,
-0.0046406621,
-0.0532882214,
0.0071998807,
-0.0219108481,
0.0606445111,
-0.0214918666,
-0.0279514119,
-0.0602247827,
0.014157068,
-0.0034047095,
0.0000086621,
0.0318911374,
0.0247667693,
-0.0269518755,
0.0332611352,
0.0297962166,
0.0012872926,
0.0576610044,
0.0126061747,
0.0627005473,
-0.0243435781,
0.014385554,
0.0277515985,
-0.0228631757,
0.048519522,
0.0269223452,
-0.0285945982,
0.0087021347,
0.0202644765,
0.0568987392,
-0.0089166062,
0.0660897195,
-0.0776578039,
-0.0184099041,
0.0350158885,
-0.0295809358,
0.0145939486,
-0.0151789449,
0.0717550591,
0.042934861,
-0.0269245133,
0.0137898708,
0.0073746522,
0.0655382052,
0.0180990007,
0.0385760777,
0.0739843026,
-0.0001131094,
-0.0660544485,
-0.0528936237,
0.0714623779,
-0.0005451518,
0.0153179774,
-0.0177009143,
0.0093609644,
0.0486941226,
-0.0745834708,
-0.00903886,
-0.0072950632,
-0.0707791075,
0.0008131828,
-0.0221439619,
0.0139621114,
0.0527393222,
0.0428356417,
0.0197616909,
-0.0441389084,
-0.0430965796,
0.0172853656,
0.0631196052,
0.0029021492,
-0.0227060392,
0.0772662237,
-0.0576591268,
-0.0262013525,
-0.0516173616,
0.0083876839,
0.0580554754,
-0.0341653973,
0.0025389162,
0.039541252,
0.0716180056,
0.0321506672,
0.0010480233,
0.0180586372,
-0.0234985296,
0.0350858122,
0.0234112535,
0.035182897,
0.0035558655,
0.0049536959,
0.0240367912,
-0.0180459339,
-0.043946892,
-0.0552901104,
-0.0002710314,
-0.0532743745,
-0.0864505097,
-0.0232701004,
-0.0236708876,
0.0121421758,
-0.053707432,
-0.0298206415,
-0.0979126319,
0.0469610579,
-0.044810988,
-0.0051514935,
-0.0139568402,
-0.0018618866,
0.0321452357,
0.0140776196,
-0.0130813261,
0.0424241237,
-0.0297599509,
-0.0139190331,
0.0401131324,
0.0955455825,
0.0237898771,
-0.0375745669,
-0.0117065581,
0.032028757,
-0.022396056,
0.0044098762,
0.0244006142,
0.0075223297,
-0.0281020738,
-0.0688046515,
-0.0043942998,
-0.0073099812,
-0.0057487949,
-0.0020241204,
0.0042801788,
0.0109602194,
0.0273781698,
-0.0057900562,
-0.0777765438,
-0.0052008233,
0.0534450859,
-0.0068776812,
0.0398660935,
0.0438834913,
-0.0428581759,
-0.0004571915,
0.0178418923,
0.0413596593,
0.0721706823,
-0.0339930803,
0.0240085721,
-0.0297314283,
-0.0066002249,
-0.0616056249,
0.0219236687,
-0.0029291234,
-0.0268155765,
0.0299340803,
-0.0056214873,
-0.0145260962,
0.0549642704,
0.0126001863,
0.0427485369,
0.0202984661,
-0.0267638434,
-0.0595452972,
0.0513506085,
-0.0400886722,
0.0236680415,
0.0180208869,
0.0127343442,
0.0262678191,
0.0526867807,
0.0214661118,
0.0258015469,
-0.0915380418,
0.0618519858,
0.043860767,
-0.0760223642,
-0.0392310172,
0.0096338093,
-0.0314112864,
0.0532022677,
-0.0327016488,
-0.0317621343,
0.0654207617,
-0.0361527726,
-0.0266715195,
-0.0059693698,
0.0306913704,
-0.0001449417,
0.0661501735,
-0.0068055266,
0.0360955223,
0.0343182087,
-0.0400866829,
-0.0602045096,
0.006452431,
0.0540299304,
-0.0061118235,
-0.0000392038,
-0.0142717808,
-0.005675151,
0.0155917443,
-0.0182006992,
-0.0481251404,
-0.0096958457,
0.0437663756,
0.0026863632,
0.0388001241,
-0.0206263755,
-0.0278256238,
-0.0073310882,
0.021170849,
0.0011006154,
-0.0280304104,
0.0070814285,
-0.0371884741,
0.0613051429,
0.0504258983,
-0.0134598156,
-0.0434296988,
-0.0472001731,
0.0456457026,
0.0154768266,
-0.0283699632,
-0.0114788748,
0.0077270647,
0.0195365362,
-0.0080930153,
0.0127839977,
0.0011588136,
-0.0005433325,
0.0359492414,
-0.0348364338,
-0.0307409652,
0.0750390589,
0.0192520153,
-0.0285645369,
-0.0164910331,
0.037325982,
0.0558835119,
-0.0003324834,
0.0167870801,
-0.101949513,
-0.0081956498,
-0.0192370601,
0.0010905481,
-0.002929417,
-0.0136449533,
-0.0339805335,
-0.0733401179,
-0.020214811,
-0.0010814725,
-0.048656594,
-0.0701018497,
0.0264168233,
-0.0158223491,
0.0078009381,
0.002718569,
0.0122348862,
0.0447897278,
0.0178140495,
-0.0146151995,
0.0283289459,
-0.0358125083,
-0.0146351755,
0.0247916915,
0.0645621717,
0.0800077543,
0.03243066,
0.0439711213,
-0.0252639428,
-0.0547727011,
-0.0531062931,
-0.0073489225,
0.0034655342,
0.0236156955,
0.0047396799,
-0.0420108512,
0.0200102348,
0.052154649,
0.0257807542,
-0.0001209737,
0.0056649204,
-0.0122987116,
-0.0423022993,
-0.0198813453,
0.0071283844,
0.0103626782,
0.0449545234,
0.0622636229,
0.0430288427,
-0.0478944778,
-0.04113888,
-0.0284699425,
-0.0109928949,
-0.0825841576,
0.0300296471,
-0.0060767969,
0.0252138823,
-0.0034672995,
-0.1040184349,
-0.0114701577,
0.0079325056,
0.0672426745,
-0.0301937256,
-0.0313188806,
-0.0113864979,
-0.0058383695,
-0.001406629,
-0.022510834,
0.0181666054,
0.013526734,
-0.0459358655,
-0.0495758802,
0.0132490033,
-0.0500017256,
-0.0233447123,
0.0254865568,
-0.0482751988,
-0.0905614495,
-0.0272241943,
0.0579790436,
0.0185609572,
0.0613942556,
0.0016550279,
-0.0230671931,
0.0181450695,
-0.007278007,
-0.0081738997,
-0.0064570103,
0.0350437015,
0.0812261477,
-0.0198436175,
0.0150908893,
-0.0389671251,
0.0297160856,
0.0094480626,
0.0231983289,
-0.0075111222,
-0.0417523682,
0.0036458224,
-0.0111572603,
-0.0337409303,
-0.0181049109,
0.0550415069,
-0.0053106728,
0.0050661336,
-0.0270671789,
-0.0281544086,
-0.0813553706,
0.0137304263,
0.0098395497,
-0.0241833702,
0.0380611382,
-0.0291677993,
-0.0015363607,
0.0463949479,
-0.0363748744,
-0.0316779539,
-0.0243636835,
0.0137378089,
0.0196464714,
0.01555112,
-0.0004452118,
0.0349079408,
-0.0052813268,
-0.0039716996,
0.0089680376,
0.0750178993,
0.0200651679,
-0.00506309,
-0.0122870989,
0.0218450278,
-0.0356243141,
0.016316466,
-0.0097161727,
0.0251856223,
-0.0159343332,
0.0814160556,
0.016351182,
-0.0084825866,
0.0190659408,
0.0094334064,
0.0888235942,
0.0159525275,
-0.0574909002,
0.0281953681,
0.0162468348,
0.005820367,
-0.0427085012,
0.0992590785,
0.0062519573,
0.0106957927,
-0.0418752991,
0.0596879758,
-0.0576376989,
-0.0257019717,
-0.0070926105,
0.0478812046,
0.0142578054,
0.0322929099,
-0.0296794772,
-0.0089771831,
-0.0330298804,
0.0158585012,
0.0118045183,
0.0267486069,
0.0717316344,
-0.0088386321,
-0.0024121641,
0.0213020984,
-0.0195014514,
-0.0305098407,
0.002616094,
-0.0112455776,
-0.0201024469,
-5.460443827e-33,
-0.0524030961,
-0.013632833,
0.0228257906,
-0.0130048953,
-0.0604013838,
-0.0018254193,
-0.0504599251,
-0.0002409676,
0.0139257507,
0.0016147881,
0.0233348217,
0.0134804891,
-0.016008012,
0.0613529533,
0.011445391,
-0.0120964618,
0.0533065423,
0.0107282894,
-0.0223083738,
0.0868196934,
0.0544151701,
0.0085932836,
-0.0216009859,
-0.0542028286,
-0.0054091387,
-0.0280772392,
-0.0538861081,
0.0227983296,
0.0213286802,
0.0155599769,
-0.0214552842,
-0.0093152216,
-0.0161846001,
-0.0493342169,
-0.0441917144,
-0.0017235121,
-0.0173055846,
-0.0457938462,
-0.0183149818,
-0.0299004335,
-0.0396751016,
-0.034855973,
-0.0134416129,
-0.0118458122,
0.0438946374,
-0.0025522839,
-0.0071542943,
-0.0021041038,
-0.0369566269,
-0.066861026,
-0.0304102357,
0.0085062487,
-0.0405910425,
-0.0640319288,
0.000635269,
0.0515380874,
-0.0031333519,
-0.0326144472,
-0.0029841173,
0.0327509418,
0.0360646583,
-0.0155445598,
0.0465311892,
0.0416609012,
0.0233509336,
0.0547714643,
0.0457229018,
0.0156207941,
-0.0613604635,
0.0114599224,
-0.0483322665,
0.0628338754,
0.0145550184,
0.0796179622,
-0.0065237968,
-0.0145701766,
-0.0042073708,
0.0285746418,
0.0035018581,
0.0468138531,
0.0053796382,
0.008026043,
0.0069043422,
-0.0326692499,
-0.0492482483,
0.0162012596,
-0.0241571646,
-0.0410828963,
0.0270335265,
0.0398328155,
-0.0386931188,
-0.0258731339,
0.0479923934,
-0.013297745,
-0.0005643636,
0.0471146256,
-0.0439580381,
0.0304792468,
-0.0123028681,
-0.0361927897,
-0.026683839,
-0.0762986615,
0.0808847919,
0.0205765311,
-0.0116004134,
0.0337707438,
-0.0025929266,
0.0051537808,
-0.0377291963,
-0.0020489297,
-0.0371414647,
0.0455766842,
-0.0189757086,
0.0015287952,
-0.0136545133,
-0.0108855395,
-0.0559929125,
0.058603812,
-0.0280767102,
-0.0004799813,
-0.0020586466,
-0.0302237011,
0.0297291856,
0.0307275858,
-0.0419615544,
0.0277880281,
0.0035271635,
-0.0548801087,
0.0523004197,
-0.0223039333,
-0.0006502043,
0.0092631551,
2.445e-7,
-0.0470204726,
-0.0083859991,
0.0140249273,
0.0322354883,
0.0191670991,
0.0508643091,
0.0121673802,
0.0296467058,
-0.0245336592,
-0.0301612318,
0.0066725542,
0.0156436339,
0.045446258,
0.0068055037,
-0.0503519252,
0.0248921011,
-0.0666727573,
-0.0312733874,
-0.0408787131,
-0.0517247543,
0.0594892055,
0.0211613402,
-0.0121108936,
0.0377994739,
0.0475788116,
0.0471695513,
0.0776797235,
0.0296795387,
-0.0030159259,
-0.0004825289,
0.0413214304,
-0.008858636,
0.0209646598,
0.0165741891,
0.0012879428,
0.0064947181,
0.0215235874,
0.0434386842,
0.0330037065,
-0.0362888016,
0.0051867468,
0.007884548,
0.0099754529,
-0.0397173315,
0.0440612771,
-0.0862289816,
-0.0177641958,
-0.0028273095,
-0.028140597,
0.0078053954,
0.0290965885,
-0.0201507732,
-0.0150047252,
0.000680012,
0.0028619107,
-0.0096746003,
0.0442766808,
-0.0645123497,
-0.0426691212,
-0.0329127349,
-0.0351765417,
-0.0261646584,
-0.0253844913,
-0.0062561156,
-0.0048270547,
-0.0133068673,
-0.0335104838,
1.7471446e-34,
0.020579109,
-0.0206391662,
0.0134964949,
-0.0014147533,
0.0115592275,
-0.0276996139,
0.0006735928,
0.0061384938,
0.0397905409,
-0.0440503396,
-0.0323713869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10315v1 | FutureTOD: Teaching Future Knowledge to Pre-trained Language Model for Task-Oriented Dialogue | 2023-06-17T10:40:07 | 2023-06-17T10:40:07 | Weihao Zeng, Keqing He, Yejie Wang, Chen Zeng, Jingang Wang, Yunsen Xian, Weiran Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models based on general text enable huge success in the
NLP scenario. But the intrinsical difference of linguistic patterns between
general text and task-oriented dialogues makes existing pre-trained language
models less useful in practice. Current dialogue pre-training methods rely on a
contrastive framework and face the challenges of both selecting true positives
and hard negatives. In this paper, we propose a novel dialogue pre-training
model, FutureTOD, which distills future knowledge to the representation of the
previous dialogue context using a self-training framework. Our intuition is
that a good dialogue representation both learns local context information and
predicts future information. Extensive experiments on diverse downstream
dialogue tasks demonstrate the effectiveness of our model, especially the
generalization, robustness, and learning discriminative dialogue
representations capabilities. | [
0.0528716594,
0.0398567654,
-0.0025182806,
0.0338503458,
-0.0329140313,
-0.0152886417,
-0.0166240335,
0.0023793099,
0.0252311938,
-0.0662135407,
-0.0475766957,
-0.0305264834,
-0.0412030891,
0.037898533,
0.0190763231,
-0.0777397603,
0.0678774863,
-0.0125033576,
0.0203645043,
0.0003490676,
0.016916234,
0.0052424055,
-0.0333837308,
0.0291667711,
-0.0202627685,
-0.0643143207,
-0.028125586,
-0.0246996284,
-0.0077388552,
-0.0232797414,
0.0433110185,
0.0672367066,
0.0271220449,
-0.0140545061,
0.0000018542,
-0.0456449352,
0.0030892009,
-0.0503056832,
-0.0344544053,
-0.0254337657,
0.0174036659,
0.0126819406,
-0.0073830257,
0.0045791436,
-0.0455358922,
-0.0019367335,
0.0137311956,
0.1069714502,
0.0773592144,
0.0671561286,
-0.0068854112,
-0.0212026983,
0.034510538,
-0.0031964383,
-0.0022169282,
-0.0584712699,
0.002925172,
0.0238530468,
-0.0355341695,
0.0544006191,
0.0159917828,
0.0222779531,
-0.0052419789,
-0.0285365153,
-0.007787785,
0.0208868496,
-0.0020640274,
0.0088208793,
-0.0679214597,
0.0886870623,
0.0370290056,
-0.0247052964,
-0.0164771788,
-0.0072635342,
-0.0273150299,
-0.0240068436,
-0.0531932637,
-0.0251122247,
0.0273846444,
0.0174091626,
0.0117101707,
0.058159288,
-0.0157165751,
0.0154587179,
0.0171107408,
0.0570532195,
-0.0099630728,
-0.036814902,
-0.0049031428,
-0.011046554,
0.0161255114,
-0.0545273647,
0.0221830849,
0.0234212168,
-0.0316243842,
0.024570493,
-0.028309226,
-0.0050732084,
0.0130313626,
-0.0293114576,
0.0110086454,
0.0244479645,
-0.0310564283,
0.0559616312,
-0.007626235,
0.0551135167,
-0.0089736711,
0.0109458994,
-0.02911143,
0.0046555013,
-0.040243309,
-0.0049801446,
-0.0581418313,
0.0278242286,
-0.0455433205,
-0.0381373093,
0.0106646121,
0.0534836836,
-0.0185700729,
-0.0239634309,
0.0410955362,
0.03150516,
-0.0448536985,
-0.0441401713,
-0.0480185598,
0.0371486396,
-0.0103563704,
0.0191641375,
-0.0033738222,
-0.0266126096,
-0.0490557551,
0.0075023435,
0.0252705514,
-0.0134181697,
-0.0418789759,
0.0808476582,
-0.0193793327,
-0.014517027,
-0.0372074433,
0.0043161372,
-0.0411862992,
-0.0518110804,
0.0300691146,
0.0174426101,
0.0011756247,
-0.0286154598,
0.0003003398,
-0.032355044,
0.0209530313,
0.000341227,
0.0043738098,
0.090802595,
-0.0082141925,
0.0008642006,
0.0255241059,
-0.0051487018,
-0.0122260172,
0.0715184584,
-0.0057456684,
-0.0186964255,
0.0321780071,
0.0223465934,
-0.0235889107,
0.0064011053,
0.0196337774,
0.0031358392,
0.0154960845,
0.0439843237,
0.006137785,
0.036232695,
0.0181351602,
0.0548077598,
-0.0257494189,
-0.0186786167,
0.0608464144,
0.0488077551,
0.0176783856,
0.0129817566,
0.0253063943,
0.0694898143,
0.0080793966,
0.0238058753,
-0.040290758,
0.023168277,
-0.0012029812,
-0.0186208282,
0.0342389159,
-0.0168332756,
-0.0674723312,
-0.038271755,
0.0135250203,
-0.0061995583,
0.0286299679,
-0.0171403866,
0.028715672,
0.0406699926,
-0.1009277627,
0.0325137153,
-0.0007640597,
-0.0413522534,
-0.0146379536,
-0.0246304255,
0.0371461362,
0.0430700406,
0.0315903686,
-0.0418473631,
-0.0761123523,
-0.0205831844,
0.0068382509,
0.0411040783,
0.0674342737,
-0.0364609584,
0.0460121743,
-0.0294915102,
-0.0128056454,
-0.01422399,
-0.0015162607,
-0.0041953512,
0.0015335613,
-0.0249505565,
0.0287487525,
0.0164153818,
-0.0153076053,
0.0289826486,
-0.0219793543,
-0.043934878,
0.0250617191,
0.0068106861,
0.0250038374,
0.0067046951,
0.0116459969,
0.0097716628,
0.0651513636,
0.0135305859,
-0.0019316712,
0.0383621268,
-0.1134422347,
-0.0942863524,
0.0484728701,
0.0330760963,
-0.0013797798,
0.0226899032,
-0.0204010941,
-0.0620025024,
0.0352973007,
-0.0065076537,
0.0389491431,
-0.0496531054,
0.0157662835,
0.0346932411,
-0.0150914229,
-0.0165079292,
0.0371225029,
0.0173136573,
-0.0231871456,
-0.0095419632,
0.0290077068,
0.0301587805,
-0.0620469041,
-0.0021054039,
0.0005307532,
-0.0041097621,
0.009432409,
0.0407714993,
0.0097199008,
-0.0644634143,
0.0074657379,
-0.0949745104,
-0.0013758439,
-0.0295047574,
0.0032059483,
0.0165799428,
-0.0310698505,
0.01206432,
-0.0506143831,
-0.0377930775,
-0.0140196094,
0.0367403552,
-0.0308405664,
0.0321323127,
0.0472794734,
0.0436298549,
-0.0505354404,
0.0213222578,
0.0078071682,
0.0203153845,
-0.0138796102,
-0.0170275699,
-0.0426457077,
0.0591172613,
0.0050626406,
0.0557474382,
-0.0227644593,
-0.0179747418,
-0.001612733,
-0.0045430157,
0.0533959828,
0.0303057656,
0.0272881109,
0.0014668597,
-0.0170868672,
-0.0476676375,
-0.0376486816,
0.0552014373,
-0.038566567,
-0.0058743786,
-0.0300714858,
0.0158118196,
0.0160775427,
0.0780439451,
0.0058262413,
0.000789645,
-0.0734522715,
-0.0104416693,
0.0137222558,
-0.0282407142,
-0.0020205672,
-0.0104874847,
-0.0391202979,
0.0151981898,
-0.0420712903,
-0.0355298482,
0.0778302401,
-0.0193377826,
-0.027979251,
-0.0548037477,
0.0055488814,
-0.0294739138,
0.0582608767,
-0.0393016115,
-0.000775995,
0.068333067,
-0.03457224,
-0.0427270867,
-0.0039648684,
-0.0240702592,
-0.0109805167,
0.0511053912,
-0.0488679707,
0.0136176394,
0.0227539651,
-0.0484957621,
-0.0571786426,
-0.0428274535,
-0.0016454104,
0.0245799683,
-0.0220711026,
0.0182281137,
0.010856187,
0.0080242623,
-0.0352620967,
0.0450792387,
-0.0304067004,
0.0019215869,
-0.0190041177,
0.0389307998,
0.0367723033,
0.0233287029,
-0.0139701068,
0.0197473764,
0.0607528426,
0.0163847487,
0.0567140169,
-0.0458073281,
-0.0000938961,
-0.0098898318,
0.020322321,
-0.0239309184,
-0.0268239696,
0.0094993273,
0.0550810993,
-0.022479564,
-0.0171911083,
0.1055561677,
0.0270754695,
-0.0075021288,
-0.0071968222,
-0.021296449,
-0.0024769662,
0.0303636119,
0.0130148204,
-0.0640983656,
-0.0350279137,
-0.0249252543,
-0.0266016759,
0.0149203427,
-0.0610203072,
-0.0313299596,
-0.0851522908,
-0.0014125042,
0.0113541121,
0.0129859876,
-0.0025326808,
-0.0066520609,
0.0011260249,
-0.0125843892,
0.0345404446,
0.0087904008,
-0.0072274189,
-0.0133339809,
0.0179635026,
-0.0225377716,
-0.0214310139,
0.0353434831,
0.0044226605,
0.0354354419,
0.0725753903,
0.0788877234,
0.0206523258,
0.03146917,
0.004234259,
-0.0357738025,
0.0087165125,
-0.0175466612,
0.0636391863,
-0.0204411559,
-0.0046384102,
-0.0082372203,
-0.0082540531,
0.0021791535,
-0.0360396169,
0.0080958307,
0.0411237478,
-0.0357589163,
0.0192663446,
0.0170431379,
0.0523193441,
0.0575481728,
0.0688745305,
-0.006700329,
-0.0046152859,
-0.0443635657,
-0.0115401158,
0.038247969,
-0.0448309891,
-0.0248896312,
-0.0414091088,
0.0077512898,
0.0464284047,
-0.0866338089,
-0.0603912994,
0.0117096882,
0.0027697673,
0.0057578841,
-0.0061289365,
-0.0074951593,
0.0100948904,
-0.0253458358,
0.0107268486,
-0.0305144209,
-0.0102863973,
-0.0589112714,
-0.0289574955,
0.070385322,
-0.0155344419,
0.0016097231,
0.0345618092,
-0.0926992223,
-0.060316585,
-0.0434581153,
0.0801027417,
0.0116837462,
0.0562919416,
-0.013502541,
-0.0051558106,
0.0169551857,
-0.0253222398,
-0.0602490641,
-0.011662554,
0.0688002706,
0.041539792,
0.0002235278,
0.0484255999,
-0.0069632316,
0.0379520021,
-0.0047807726,
0.0281028971,
-0.0217543133,
-0.0985820293,
0.0267042387,
-0.0222031288,
0.0811189339,
0.0195790324,
0.0021751779,
-0.0382227786,
0.0121612651,
-0.0447645858,
-0.0210122131,
-0.0629724711,
0.0519025065,
-0.0039149714,
-0.0276593156,
0.0014730709,
0.0372231975,
-0.0527976453,
0.0323389433,
-0.0293411352,
-0.0345462561,
0.0398170948,
-0.0133812763,
-0.0024205775,
0.0179147217,
-0.0089568952,
-0.0144432373,
0.0203423481,
0.0237972904,
0.0042365533,
0.0931857899,
0.0009504567,
-0.0213073343,
0.0026215757,
0.0132273128,
-0.0958848074,
-0.0362817049,
-0.0194733106,
0.0084802313,
0.0053030914,
-0.0022726173,
0.0253937989,
-0.025616277,
0.0253072195,
-0.0216801986,
0.0694929212,
-0.0404008366,
-0.020246882,
0.0297555607,
0.0038945475,
-0.028114181,
0.0349081904,
0.0722525045,
-0.0098834289,
0.0472512022,
0.0141454162,
0.0085180337,
-0.0603037775,
-0.0352943763,
0.0218601208,
0.0475776978,
-0.0041431566,
0.0520661734,
-0.0124947149,
-0.0375193432,
0.036816515,
-0.0103362855,
-0.0202995501,
-0.022993505,
0.0487616062,
0.0459141023,
-0.0341806225,
-0.0154829891,
-0.0370967127,
0.0040771826,
0.0151788173,
-0.0073284521,
-0.0643290505,
-5.794694177e-33,
-0.0501015261,
-0.0061396612,
0.0294404346,
0.0059161019,
-0.0263269655,
-0.007543914,
-0.0415200964,
-0.0150439572,
-0.0368218943,
0.0142536741,
-0.0466581099,
0.0175663028,
0.0170189738,
0.0276450925,
-0.014225808,
-0.0340254419,
0.0758249611,
-0.0305731967,
0.0152746262,
0.0306237303,
0.0163656045,
0.0384160951,
0.0856219605,
-0.0704616904,
0.0439957678,
0.0051734941,
-0.0142845381,
0.0555280373,
0.0475966707,
0.0417300873,
-0.0334305316,
0.0415864214,
0.009572125,
-0.0489259586,
-0.0608404353,
0.0165791418,
-0.0896525159,
-0.0344710685,
0.0477727354,
-0.00127395,
-0.0633916706,
-0.0017813973,
-0.0178029668,
-0.0377542526,
-0.0105325337,
0.0165829919,
-0.0013981643,
-0.0026259515,
-0.0014838387,
0.0156307314,
-0.0605613738,
0.0086271139,
-0.0215810761,
-0.0643236339,
0.0326516777,
0.0636781156,
0.0386890173,
-0.0581332035,
-0.0246772356,
0.0338817425,
-0.00861183,
0.006917648,
0.0066879336,
0.0246969014,
0.0237247329,
0.0820993781,
-0.0018099477,
0.0052888356,
0.0001430338,
-0.014155318,
-0.0071180644,
0.0306885168,
-0.0408944972,
0.0189980101,
-0.0199753251,
0.0013897497,
-0.027375266,
0.013351717,
0.0181041062,
0.0314904153,
-0.0112807993,
0.0273050312,
0.0079774847,
-0.0435836539,
-0.0260416474,
-0.0117819756,
0.025452042,
-0.0300403498,
0.0164226741,
0.0424721986,
0.0159057304,
0.0348360389,
0.0355728567,
-0.0550427437,
0.0060007079,
0.0608979836,
-0.0327713713,
-0.0291477814,
-0.0164429359,
0.0406479202,
-0.0842685401,
0.0089542363,
0.0447760448,
0.0130812628,
-0.0070233508,
0.0001152394,
0.017809134,
0.0095001096,
-0.0555028804,
0.0000636517,
-0.022579832,
0.0352833532,
0.0018109285,
0.0398826897,
0.0172278266,
0.0220011156,
-0.0223731622,
0.0901829898,
0.0238454156,
-0.0478034802,
-0.0426521897,
-0.0125249596,
0.0376211517,
0.0368338116,
-0.0257436354,
-0.0094752032,
-0.0138431732,
-0.0013955418,
-0.0072678961,
-0.0265034307,
-0.0175509881,
0.0023633756,
2.395e-7,
0.0114337793,
0.0217379034,
0.0559852235,
0.0065182126,
0.0294266902,
0.0516123213,
0.0037145766,
0.0146061452,
0.0284110717,
-0.0213045646,
0.034109816,
0.0191478375,
0.0389694609,
-0.0062341513,
-0.096909821,
-0.031462796,
-0.0676468089,
-0.0334060788,
-0.0073659248,
-0.0505227819,
0.0728345141,
0.0772268474,
0.0205138922,
0.0092638219,
-0.0388010964,
-0.0513225682,
0.0812425613,
-0.0241564307,
-0.0022697595,
0.0462186337,
-0.0147943739,
-0.024069922,
-0.0293797832,
0.0111727612,
-0.0105580604,
0.0515299179,
-0.0178782344,
0.0650147796,
-0.0183139015,
-0.0838665739,
-0.0051723151,
0.0188690908,
-0.0072667762,
0.0005305521,
0.0733766183,
-0.071773082,
-0.0045730392,
-0.0426434427,
-0.008882612,
0.0234640613,
-0.0025893238,
-0.0051594088,
-0.0225286633,
0.0267520398,
0.0077122618,
0.0086072749,
0.0081628812,
-0.1070466936,
-0.0164546389,
0.0281679202,
-0.0460091643,
-0.0020275128,
-0.0200162511,
-0.0353398547,
0.0076414729,
-0.062057063,
0.0449494533,
1.878379361e-34,
0.0151092,
0.0104397098,
0.0003906519,
0.0452782772,
0.0136179579,
-0.0204979237,
-0.0021764103,
-0.0086864876,
0.0719400868,
-0.0291640516,
-0.0282967314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10270v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10270v1 | Old and New Minimalism: a Hopf algebra comparison | 2023-06-17T06:31:36 | 2023-06-17T06:31:36 | Matilde Marcolli, Robert C. Berwick, Noam Chomsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, math.QA, math.RA, 68Q70, 16T05 | In this paper we compare some old formulations of Minimalism, in particular
Stabler's computational minimalism, and Chomsky's new formulation of Merge and
Minimalism, from the point of view of their mathematical description in terms
of Hopf algebras. We show that the newer formulation has a clear advantage
purely in terms of the underlying mathematical structure. More precisely, in
the case of Stabler's computational minimalism, External Merge can be described
in terms of a partially defined operated algebra with binary operation, while
Internal Merge determines a system of right-ideal coideals of the Loday-Ronco
Hopf algebra and corresponding right-module coalgebra quotients. This
mathematical structure shows that Internal and External Merge have
significantly different roles in the old formulations of Minimalism, and they
are more difficult to reconcile as facets of a single algebraic operation, as
desirable linguistically. On the other hand, we show that the newer formulation
of Minimalism naturally carries a Hopf algebra structure where Internal and
External Merge directly arise from the same operation. We also compare, at the
level of algebraic properties, the externalization model of the new Minimalism
with proposals for assignments of planar embeddings based on heads of trees. | [
-0.0045814463,
0.0003898704,
-0.026516702,
-0.0194173604,
-0.0541856103,
0.0245617982,
0.0243334323,
0.0300917327,
0.014487775,
-0.0360924862,
-0.0394539796,
-0.0180851948,
-0.0378970169,
-0.0205395576,
0.0560086891,
-0.0430926755,
0.0629869699,
-0.0117485877,
-0.0835040659,
0.021031959,
-0.0171766058,
-0.0547933169,
0.0067462693,
-0.030865524,
-0.0400048643,
-0.0431754813,
-0.0225627292,
-0.0290191751,
0.030438073,
0.0352807418,
-0.0135677336,
0.0194644947,
-0.0590488501,
0.0187893566,
0.0000014858,
-0.0206726529,
0.0131931584,
0.0461675748,
-0.0243880562,
-0.0406985693,
0.0028233957,
0.0411383584,
-0.0134975789,
0.013673164,
0.0160272159,
0.0546171851,
0.0190269761,
0.0509256534,
0.0040807943,
0.0089112427,
0.0274908636,
-0.0734382942,
0.037856672,
0.0132525945,
0.0353247896,
0.0418927819,
0.026483383,
0.0541470386,
-0.0102163507,
-0.0363650993,
0.0091213081,
-0.0813127235,
0.0027466787,
-0.0473963916,
0.0236034095,
-0.0179106109,
0.020306129,
-0.0325066447,
0.0046173716,
-0.0154263712,
0.043359682,
-0.037577536,
-0.0303358324,
0.0642446056,
-0.0035762887,
-0.036117889,
-0.0412348993,
0.0297492091,
0.0405738577,
0.0558435619,
0.0963572785,
-0.0577864014,
-0.0165043268,
-0.0172158908,
-0.0286902338,
0.0659530982,
0.0796404481,
-0.0134790977,
-0.0538150705,
-0.0209229458,
0.053771019,
-0.0417516567,
-0.0261126962,
0.014686048,
0.0042536911,
-0.0145593788,
0.0006079745,
0.0447026119,
-0.0313403048,
-0.0365086235,
-0.04725115,
0.0439841859,
0.0348805413,
0.0209290851,
-0.0291978419,
0.0487489253,
0.0117716044,
0.0043323589,
-0.0010288686,
-0.0207919572,
-0.0083139781,
-0.0216199793,
-0.0666135252,
0.0758325681,
-0.0088683199,
-0.0018743058,
-0.0512264743,
-0.0038830303,
-0.0615285002,
0.009378138,
-0.0421344303,
-0.0621490069,
-0.006189866,
0.0002550914,
-0.0146907093,
-0.0126430625,
-0.0031106633,
-0.0344280042,
-0.0214206111,
-0.001401822,
-0.03426449,
0.0737060905,
-0.0065092659,
-0.0262951851,
-0.0062765027,
0.0339647718,
0.0314460173,
0.0197968818,
0.0649131164,
-0.0053602993,
0.0365127996,
0.0106280483,
-0.021250654,
-0.011678854,
0.0518573895,
-0.0252539609,
0.0159231834,
-0.0606249459,
-0.0213129651,
-0.0272403788,
-0.0260690525,
-0.0535739213,
0.0101926811,
0.0331909843,
-0.0777038634,
0.0124609424,
-0.0267250538,
-0.0352976806,
-0.0272264518,
0.0124736642,
-0.0050983541,
0.0024664698,
0.0419800244,
-0.0135805858,
0.0178030357,
-0.0449404456,
-0.0359175615,
-0.0094435168,
-0.0088614104,
-0.0491915084,
-0.0228671879,
0.0940716714,
-0.0198141411,
0.0108857434,
-0.0339836851,
0.0001645711,
0.0607907102,
0.0404319875,
-0.008745132,
-0.0268996786,
0.0126540512,
0.0332070291,
-0.0409064963,
0.0097150579,
-0.0857633427,
0.0159300584,
-0.0611263476,
0.00587615,
0.0068655196,
-0.0218259525,
-0.0256969891,
-0.0169887058,
0.0141431876,
-0.0239306111,
0.0362472944,
-0.0144278239,
0.0115779424,
0.0429274552,
-0.0179022662,
0.0141079258,
0.0490809567,
-0.0258602817,
0.0032262385,
-0.0272856709,
-0.046971187,
-0.0027382951,
0.0007083575,
-0.0076261265,
-0.0693878606,
0.0504886918,
-0.0088433055,
-0.0317078084,
-0.0370732956,
0.009201969,
0.0250503775,
-0.0057496466,
0.028424779,
-0.0346689895,
-0.0304847285,
-0.0007133401,
0.0185403451,
0.0602806546,
0.025908513,
0.0018767914,
0.0134241292,
-0.0250217412,
-0.0678528026,
0.0846911073,
-0.0134697817,
0.0266034063,
0.0015577096,
0.0603041053,
0.0454510041,
0.0336676165,
-0.0212871954,
0.0301504619,
0.0178059097,
0.0189336166,
0.0535089262,
-0.0252157003,
0.0797820315,
-0.0340923034,
0.012853153,
-0.0104469433,
0.099365212,
0.010705906,
0.0750085115,
-0.0447145253,
0.069483988,
0.0077114017,
-0.0562023968,
0.0219911952,
0.0341768973,
-0.0078697531,
0.044366125,
-0.0134847118,
-0.0584196709,
0.040612489,
0.0256184395,
-0.0273040421,
0.0374324135,
-0.0032762452,
0.012080471,
-0.0002114403,
0.0150838969,
-0.0460047983,
-0.0262561496,
-0.008904512,
-0.0122447219,
0.0008308197,
0.0334078632,
0.0417386033,
0.0620543584,
0.0327213556,
0.035340853,
0.0182318147,
0.0323231146,
0.0076157809,
0.0152333463,
-0.0231518038,
0.0088582421,
-0.0642478168,
0.0306235962,
0.0245905854,
-0.0229174197,
-0.0159761179,
-0.0929764882,
-0.0381196365,
-0.0161561351,
-0.0598168671,
-0.0593015999,
0.0241560899,
-0.0251090992,
-0.0037021632,
0.0092151361,
0.0217308551,
0.0294869896,
-0.0303277243,
-0.0646902844,
0.0317184143,
-0.0172930043,
0.0263442025,
0.0350753665,
0.008326496,
-0.0234554913,
-0.0041310615,
0.0010580812,
0.0234522652,
-0.0118498346,
0.0722166598,
-0.0501321293,
-0.0169319399,
-0.0330393128,
-0.0045892838,
-0.0384726711,
0.0059582638,
-0.0051751612,
-0.0649724752,
-0.0151373586,
0.0173617192,
-0.0337417386,
-0.0236527715,
-0.0018826696,
-0.0160125643,
-0.0468229689,
0.0286402889,
-0.0152358944,
-0.0851519331,
0.0393066779,
0.0471565388,
0.021322852,
0.010445823,
-0.0011383859,
-0.0314801857,
-0.0184782911,
-0.0165873114,
0.0071985885,
0.0037928172,
0.0228014011,
-0.0064548021,
0.0284588505,
0.0209771786,
-0.0204570126,
0.0571454689,
-0.0102764294,
0.0192136262,
-0.012920782,
0.0134622687,
0.0494639277,
0.0483206995,
0.0137572614,
-0.0622700565,
0.0243764762,
0.0551461913,
0.0127350315,
0.0087067634,
-0.0018736029,
0.0419463702,
-0.01013867,
0.0186352823,
0.0167325251,
0.0287229773,
0.0037524097,
-0.0110195335,
0.026489757,
-0.0307689887,
0.0137708653,
-0.0082356408,
-0.0125405183,
-0.0344651639,
-0.0582546778,
0.0519129932,
-0.0043237912,
-0.0468081608,
0.0336219035,
0.0380895622,
0.0361558236,
-0.0906771421,
-0.0044853245,
0.0367066376,
-0.0079130214,
-0.075784862,
0.0515699238,
0.0027606885,
-0.0433320813,
0.0219297968,
0.0001250052,
0.0303268526,
0.0218879096,
-0.0339416564,
0.0763316229,
-0.0815220177,
-0.0536932833,
0.0126745664,
0.0241986122,
0.0232961122,
-0.0253890455,
0.0075946087,
-0.0204290971,
0.0631538406,
-0.0087669985,
0.0252492558,
-0.0183787085,
-0.0996345654,
0.027932208,
-0.0243304931,
0.0259817,
0.0380064175,
0.031266138,
-0.0050922232,
0.0900328979,
-0.0087688966,
-0.0196987372,
-0.0290013701,
-0.1082139462,
0.0542296655,
-0.008767264,
-0.0495170727,
0.0054550036,
0.0517822392,
-0.04849305,
-0.0405462645,
0.0562464558,
-0.0431682207,
-0.0297458824,
0.002425751,
0.0298082549,
0.0214417502,
0.0660179779,
0.0311806202,
0.0368440188,
-0.0177740064,
-0.0027281991,
-0.0400569253,
0.0650704652,
-0.0675166622,
0.0389610827,
0.0281386077,
-0.0139787588,
0.0025349588,
-0.0435252301,
-0.0009049136,
-0.0418015122,
-0.0239222739,
0.0559295677,
-0.0176949315,
-0.0488995351,
-0.0192348566,
0.0052606412,
-0.0425743349,
-0.0053185774,
-0.0034877027,
0.0216334481,
-0.0023919914,
0.0345841646,
-0.059829358,
-0.0526191406,
0.034224879,
-0.0033096981,
-0.00686891,
0.0566478223,
0.0268572103,
-0.0635890216,
-0.02177497,
0.0471201241,
-0.0461964272,
0.0327845998,
-0.0055770553,
0.0716955066,
-0.0219747797,
0.0383678563,
0.0006561758,
0.0188113507,
-0.0012165065,
0.0106177712,
0.0053524165,
0.0118704988,
-0.0082121361,
0.02988795,
0.0037401668,
0.0560227931,
-0.0328579918,
0.0443685018,
0.0134865986,
0.0202762354,
0.0041267681,
-0.0244676322,
-0.0302450974,
-0.0521719791,
-0.0479049385,
-0.0164499674,
0.0168119743,
0.0090749934,
0.0276091397,
0.0765430853,
0.0252637323,
0.0471219495,
0.0112821758,
-0.0371406376,
-0.0574215911,
0.0004395098,
0.0492239483,
0.0387226157,
-0.0425443538,
-0.0344467238,
0.0350424983,
-0.0735755265,
-0.0326685607,
0.0182818715,
0.0119642559,
-0.0355437696,
-0.0252592508,
-0.017891176,
-0.0947735086,
0.004970958,
0.0187757015,
0.009725851,
0.0132894972,
0.0532613918,
-0.0591523945,
-0.0064531304,
-0.0342193097,
-0.0173242185,
0.0319449641,
-0.0168113671,
-0.0028467653,
0.0170444064,
0.038936913,
-0.0127317728,
0.0136420215,
-0.0837453902,
0.0234910026,
-0.0303530786,
0.0005311368,
-0.0490072593,
-0.0341317542,
-0.0103282705,
0.029514594,
0.0559730679,
-0.0317605995,
-0.1200897917,
0.0075775529,
-0.0467516854,
0.0088616339,
-0.0059628147,
-0.0190340318,
-0.0019576806,
-0.0198776629,
-0.0041975402,
-0.0508367158,
0.0140180616,
0.0295309108,
0.0446445011,
-0.009225212,
0.0252046026,
-4.418434207e-33,
-0.0390373245,
0.0017658449,
0.0376822762,
-0.033796452,
-0.0544918738,
-0.0146278171,
-0.0296318848,
0.0154119898,
-0.0224026833,
-0.0166044682,
0.0009581132,
-0.0061447336,
-0.0100103887,
0.0006777965,
-0.0183183327,
0.0428032428,
0.0010326798,
-0.0193300676,
0.0032761134,
-0.0154313724,
-0.0017571308,
-0.0557943843,
0.0140255867,
0.0114461295,
0.0064923638,
-0.0211744756,
-0.0291338563,
0.0440227874,
-0.0090617146,
0.0348768309,
-0.0553680845,
-0.0427448079,
0.0159256458,
0.0326751992,
-0.0097527057,
0.0045831185,
-0.0104890093,
-0.0419869125,
0.0085110608,
-0.0376615152,
0.0426812246,
-0.0197628457,
-0.0111484556,
0.0374129191,
-0.0033626824,
-0.0044451798,
-0.0415102281,
0.0182269122,
-0.0415731259,
0.0821790099,
-0.0585309342,
-0.0046345419,
0.0305089392,
0.0652579814,
0.0244493522,
0.034119945,
-0.0060955985,
-0.0128250849,
-0.0296681337,
0.0498106107,
-0.0148898242,
-0.0266053602,
0.0182385761,
-0.0104129398,
-0.0073319175,
0.030624019,
0.1053666323,
-0.0032606502,
0.010501503,
0.0461339168,
-0.0100692064,
0.0702264756,
0.0329271108,
-0.0029024628,
0.028062135,
0.0706743225,
-0.0023679221,
0.048572991,
0.0221341886,
0.0284045003,
-0.0095094098,
0.0442387685,
-0.0697236359,
-0.0434339158,
0.0173370186,
0.0009169444,
-0.0145080108,
-0.0026698932,
-0.0295578241,
-0.0083066579,
-0.0190836713,
0.0393584445,
0.0087062269,
-0.0424701273,
-0.0345406793,
0.0282620732,
0.0224072356,
0.0598041005,
0.0007309467,
0.0081952699,
0.0408488959,
-0.0214748327,
-0.0630697906,
0.0254366584,
0.0017600561,
-0.0266528074,
-0.0032703432,
0.0335960537,
-0.0279011615,
0.0231433827,
0.0070439405,
-0.0356939174,
0.0202651061,
-0.0138976742,
0.0200700276,
0.0326294713,
0.0263227355,
-0.0456998833,
0.0044400981,
-0.0028947571,
0.0469689853,
-0.0353990905,
0.0160820633,
0.0096714515,
0.0509302355,
-0.0275325589,
0.0237233862,
0.0249451678,
0.0972537547,
0.0161562543,
0.008003219,
-0.0545182079,
2.435e-7,
0.0138850249,
-0.0632905439,
0.0240299255,
0.0529582575,
0.006309283,
-0.0007166596,
0.0034994052,
-0.0343072414,
-0.0411742292,
0.0265657697,
-0.0180931352,
0.0072726682,
-0.042348519,
-0.0388279185,
0.0331782922,
0.0185588747,
0.0312797427,
-0.1140600294,
0.0176643673,
0.0447334796,
0.0538090765,
-0.0213576891,
0.0175706428,
-0.0154213756,
-0.0620674416,
0.0256761406,
0.0411210619,
0.0159003995,
0.0046086707,
-0.0102244476,
-0.0292136613,
0.0115691107,
0.0373622775,
-0.0243985169,
0.0271273647,
0.0162573121,
-0.0223083086,
0.0244728625,
-0.0441012792,
0.0316139273,
-0.0061349194,
-0.0560076721,
-0.0119607877,
0.0041865986,
0.0358881019,
0.0125531228,
0.0278188735,
-0.0372315831,
-0.0249062888,
0.0587614179,
-0.0078112483,
0.003460845,
-0.006958623,
0.0000452521,
0.0109139439,
-0.0017403745,
-0.0099700186,
-0.0131903188,
0.0170888174,
0.0787625164,
-0.0414031819,
-0.0250058975,
0.0224082284,
0.0681660101,
-0.0181034971,
-0.0375649519,
-0.0856598616,
2.65034946e-34,
0.0198237207,
-0.0245997459,
0.102312468,
0.0283930451,
-0.013686222,
-0.020343855,
0.0248851776,
0.0020504205,
0.001799659,
-0.0520021096,
-0.0445822626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10249v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10249v2 | Large Generative AI Models for Telecom: The Next Big Thing? | 2023-06-17T03:45:00 | 2023-12-23T15:46:59 | Lina Bariah, Qiyang Zhao, Hang Zou, Yu Tian, Faouzi Bader, Merouane Debbah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The evolution of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) constitutes a
turning point in reshaping the future of technology in different aspects.
Wireless networks in particular, with the blooming of self-evolving networks,
represent a rich field for exploiting GenAI and reaping several benefits that
can fundamentally change the way how wireless networks are designed and
operated nowadays. To be specific, large GenAI models are envisioned to open up
a new era of autonomous wireless networks, in which multi-modal GenAI models
trained over various Telecom data, can be fine-tuned to perform several
downstream tasks, eliminating the need for building and training dedicated AI
models for each specific task and paving the way for the realization of
artificial general intelligence (AGI)-empowered wireless networks. In this
article, we aim to unfold the opportunities that can be reaped from integrating
large GenAI models into the Telecom domain. In particular, we first highlight
the applications of large GenAI models in future wireless networks, defining
potential use-cases and revealing insights on the associated theoretical and
practical challenges. Furthermore, we unveil how 6G can open up new
opportunities through connecting multiple on-device large GenAI models, and
hence, paves the way to the collective intelligence paradigm. Finally, we put a
forward-looking vision on how large GenAI models will be the key to realize
self-evolving networks. | [
-0.013369781,
0.0268076994,
-0.0410324894,
-0.053437613,
-0.0325907543,
-0.0328268707,
0.074424915,
-0.0740427524,
-0.0037026238,
-0.0061612562,
0.0208837558,
0.0063982112,
-0.0517546013,
0.0339581482,
0.0168899167,
0.0485106036,
0.0309035387,
-0.0197099857,
-0.0316856354,
-0.010500337,
-0.0446691476,
0.0021034258,
0.0146080172,
0.0024948749,
-0.0726710483,
-0.0030223809,
-0.0057962495,
0.002551229,
-0.0110239908,
-0.025806006,
-0.0145494649,
0.0051637166,
0.043231193,
0.0448353104,
0.0000018129,
-0.0175349582,
-0.0102857091,
-0.0140387658,
0.0025331054,
0.0031215441,
-0.0062423181,
0.0477251634,
-0.0337285884,
0.0280370302,
-0.044023037,
0.0059589092,
0.0374805555,
-0.0069985916,
0.0291754343,
0.0548097789,
-0.0017820558,
-0.0152132604,
0.048599191,
-0.0456006788,
0.0152201355,
-0.0190097746,
-0.0113938013,
-0.003396475,
-0.0066286712,
-0.0094536087,
0.0360947028,
0.0117231905,
0.0547015741,
0.0184366871,
0.0241690148,
0.0150361815,
0.0196599457,
0.0031731785,
-0.0549003258,
-0.0153051484,
-0.0057281028,
-0.0552433729,
0.0142161911,
0.0373763256,
-0.0144665856,
-0.0092335939,
-0.0134760048,
-0.0331643336,
0.0040094797,
0.0322753973,
-0.004747476,
0.033815179,
0.0245130025,
-0.0247871149,
-0.0388098881,
0.0423489399,
0.0139198573,
0.0029098317,
-0.0400069281,
-0.0328234062,
0.0087085096,
-0.019362662,
0.0073741861,
0.035555657,
-0.0059709782,
-0.0388705023,
-0.0347275175,
0.0090343766,
-0.0334127359,
-0.002320518,
0.0450961925,
-0.0062251254,
0.025345698,
0.0028298653,
-0.0142971426,
-0.052798897,
-0.053888917,
-0.0465043262,
-0.029005412,
-0.0504929572,
-0.0709502846,
-0.0511505827,
-0.0167837869,
0.0389990509,
-0.0284492299,
-0.062922135,
-0.0038058423,
0.0198545735,
-0.0503506027,
-0.0290613342,
-0.0290953778,
0.0314312205,
-0.0095350742,
-0.022343602,
0.0229148101,
-0.0432802998,
-0.0389860496,
0.0610653237,
0.0169009306,
-0.0576513931,
0.0176559649,
0.0214586575,
-0.0261383038,
0.0461096019,
-0.0548190922,
0.0741801709,
-0.0270901732,
0.0006486017,
-0.0195382535,
-0.012974035,
0.0500009805,
-0.0385721326,
0.0226439051,
-0.0309548117,
-0.0261250325,
-0.0165192168,
-0.0296766721,
0.0259085409,
-0.0013491889,
-0.0388720259,
0.0018993058,
0.0200143196,
-0.0296972115,
0.051687412,
0.0843216851,
-0.0336059183,
0.049676463,
0.0276954435,
0.0161486398,
-0.0315442234,
0.0154111059,
-0.0048102746,
0.0508881025,
0.0534541458,
0.0395081341,
-0.0141392183,
0.0916177034,
-0.0600580759,
0.0108318431,
0.0278938953,
-0.0198044199,
-0.0019795229,
0.0026422769,
0.0199426487,
0.0415447913,
0.0828642473,
0.079470858,
0.0881031901,
-0.0017877721,
0.0446653068,
-0.0180335976,
-0.0554720834,
-0.0036659108,
0.040119417,
-0.0592911541,
-0.0234224591,
0.0304544047,
0.0786455572,
-0.026693169,
-0.0382838026,
0.051203806,
-0.053465426,
-0.0204839371,
-0.0134421568,
0.0313268639,
0.010065184,
-0.002558752,
-0.0537783839,
0.0162263084,
-0.0441356897,
-0.0410980955,
-0.0669768453,
0.0416631401,
0.0177935828,
0.0486271158,
0.0027142218,
-0.0559454262,
0.0590398312,
-0.0322269946,
0.0028351056,
0.0056583346,
-0.0218321122,
-0.0197651368,
-0.008747289,
0.0271243062,
0.0383179672,
0.0293845888,
-0.0047727805,
-0.0212985426,
-0.0199817941,
-0.0162997246,
0.0277135149,
-0.0154379634,
0.0002585857,
0.0145029034,
0.0263584685,
0.0583836474,
0.0054660561,
0.0270970967,
-0.0049590599,
-0.0153310029,
-0.0253195334,
-0.0108700898,
-0.0425008498,
-0.0252668802,
-0.0018052805,
-0.0320640206,
0.0844643787,
-0.0339885503,
0.0048446585,
0.058065597,
0.0002321521,
0.0348637812,
-0.0401939675,
0.0441319309,
-0.0300466456,
0.0424726978,
-0.0269793626,
-0.0265499074,
0.0133299557,
0.0147964368,
0.0244805552,
0.0450487062,
0.0549353734,
-0.1026317105,
0.0002721275,
0.0347036868,
0.0529877618,
-0.0048713274,
0.0407536477,
-0.0172068365,
-0.0123802945,
0.0133903818,
0.0116569707,
-0.011754985,
0.0645301938,
-0.0452721938,
-0.0616796836,
0.0223528016,
-0.049010314,
0.0423586704,
0.0064404267,
0.0033056764,
0.001743747,
0.0098344954,
-0.0253004208,
0.0584843904,
0.0357235037,
-0.0657207966,
-0.0143897533,
0.023656467,
-0.0303306803,
-0.0583228879,
-0.0156979319,
-0.0225730184,
0.0651993975,
0.0568459295,
0.00066493,
-0.0351699702,
-0.0418630876,
-0.0283363108,
0.0409092121,
-0.0285227541,
-0.0596625358,
0.0420657769,
-0.0043208082,
0.0242833458,
0.0393319502,
0.0546880662,
0.005764605,
-0.0111421011,
-0.0040452192,
-0.0388599895,
0.0106020384,
-0.0072709825,
-0.0062009473,
-0.0179184694,
0.021298727,
0.0323387794,
0.0353365354,
-0.0260451846,
-0.0087274797,
-0.0393386856,
0.0193596836,
0.0302087199,
-0.0789187774,
0.0262452345,
0.0144307157,
0.0179704539,
0.0330246054,
-0.0017148796,
-0.0121042104,
0.0532953888,
0.0304949544,
-0.0016231472,
-0.0114920735,
-0.0258847009,
-0.0314136818,
0.0251542963,
0.0382998176,
0.0471732579,
-0.0050983988,
0.0306229498,
0.0105510596,
0.0474187657,
-0.0199681073,
-0.025145743,
-0.0149748027,
-0.0513700955,
0.0396125987,
0.0380509757,
-0.061716482,
-0.0037274018,
0.0512464158,
0.0315269455,
0.0085375812,
-0.0151769444,
-0.0125582162,
0.0123500507,
0.0051708841,
-0.0171449929,
0.0256615095,
-0.0344936587,
-0.0029477812,
-0.0241400823,
0.0220818464,
0.0053765816,
0.0009077431,
-0.0005471336,
0.0402211212,
0.0147755435,
-0.0127631547,
0.0239052735,
0.0550912991,
-0.0470566414,
0.0351161808,
0.0089702718,
-0.0195014365,
-0.0359960496,
0.0516819693,
0.0452061333,
-0.0233790092,
-0.02860987,
0.0057677594,
0.0083107557,
-0.0181396771,
-0.013986581,
0.0123792859,
-0.0351949148,
-0.0008143528,
0.0338227227,
-0.0743197799,
-0.0091888942,
-0.022305524,
-0.02681702,
-0.0163518023,
0.0226333383,
-0.0014542803,
-0.0957669914,
0.0206814092,
0.0423591137,
0.0019232933,
-0.0059603699,
-0.0027033114,
-0.003492431,
0.0096188812,
0.0082547246,
-0.02955053,
0.0348699838,
-0.0228426866,
0.0047208648,
-0.0312626846,
-0.0844878927,
0.0047695008,
-0.0090316739,
0.077242367,
0.0749308988,
-0.0253745895,
0.0234532151,
-0.0311696157,
0.025786059,
0.0399158895,
-0.00131304,
0.0101967342,
-0.0033078492,
0.015387699,
0.0070177452,
-0.0371332578,
0.0414044373,
0.0095874583,
-0.0183879212,
-0.0277913269,
0.0097173937,
-0.0370896831,
-0.0473426767,
-0.0239807274,
-0.005743809,
0.0363506228,
0.0148770837,
-0.0329814069,
-0.0512286313,
-0.0462785028,
-0.0363296829,
0.0449711382,
-0.0691540018,
-0.0585663766,
-0.0139893675,
0.0561332479,
-0.0465679951,
-0.0295168497,
0.0331634693,
-0.0135335857,
-0.0053112623,
0.0598794892,
-0.0219807699,
0.0464873873,
0.0208079666,
0.0078786956,
-0.0824507773,
0.0082777021,
-0.041276779,
-0.0763359889,
-0.0323708802,
0.0790633708,
-0.0666694939,
0.0081168003,
0.049218405,
-0.0981225967,
-0.0166106243,
0.0271213707,
0.0429590121,
0.0273630098,
0.0077479477,
-0.0254222527,
-0.0316967107,
0.0726452917,
0.0705844909,
-0.0494790189,
0.0200215131,
0.0114665432,
-0.0035766887,
0.0005391983,
0.0549067222,
-0.0206380859,
0.0807796195,
0.0018866222,
-0.0367821828,
-0.0338263437,
0.0185557678,
0.0222578049,
-0.0200395565,
-0.030222211,
0.0340654962,
0.0479760133,
-0.0033768152,
-0.009593647,
0.0069015338,
0.0314521492,
-0.0323013999,
-0.0039617009,
-0.0311251003,
0.0296609066,
0.0516836569,
0.0161896236,
0.1049373522,
-0.00498675,
-0.0408181064,
-0.0422207154,
0.0276609194,
0.0076181567,
-0.022554189,
0.0154951755,
0.015513449,
0.0082131587,
0.0031834517,
0.0059509203,
-0.0400375947,
0.0224406123,
0.0261922479,
-0.0041792253,
-0.0379316956,
0.0311254952,
-0.043496646,
-0.0709562078,
0.0393035524,
0.0844533518,
0.0563340299,
0.0762783214,
-0.0089512635,
-0.0533039458,
0.004654217,
-0.030408185,
-0.0174656566,
-0.0346869342,
0.0112658488,
-0.0257689841,
0.0117221186,
-0.0278908145,
0.0002729954,
-0.0040982165,
-0.0101195006,
0.051411733,
-0.0392815471,
0.0069427295,
-0.0361106806,
-0.006879434,
-0.0112271747,
-0.002474891,
-0.0028939161,
0.038836319,
-0.0176222324,
0.0187493023,
-0.0403355546,
0.0422953442,
0.0536227897,
-0.0428922586,
0.0189021379,
0.0114050126,
-0.0803949535,
-0.0516452193,
0.0175297242,
-0.0621342435,
-0.059496671,
0.0196239892,
0.025255166,
-6.01846422e-33,
0.0544994138,
0.0411343202,
0.0156553295,
0.0520370789,
0.0052564191,
-0.0130668124,
-0.0209805202,
-0.0335614793,
-0.0106680747,
-0.0318036824,
-0.0400550067,
0.0326342359,
-0.0060838158,
0.0766535625,
0.011222777,
0.0083787087,
0.0740293935,
-0.0439201668,
-0.0375952795,
0.0395346321,
0.0194797609,
-0.0028435932,
-0.0423422009,
-0.0199815016,
-0.0393666439,
-0.006029726,
-0.0896918625,
-0.0224551875,
-0.0862885341,
0.0406064913,
-0.0297249015,
-0.0134290429,
0.0244719069,
-0.0218892395,
0.0082451133,
0.0481385924,
-0.0622255765,
0.0222744979,
-0.0398382582,
-0.0052024405,
-0.045061782,
-0.0546172932,
0.0191130172,
0.026865039,
-0.0956822559,
0.0512703657,
0.0428039879,
0.0298469141,
-0.0084571689,
-0.0546016507,
0.0060210596,
-0.045097623,
-0.0110393567,
-0.0504715368,
0.0015746299,
-0.1272744983,
-0.0538338609,
0.0079652565,
-0.0108946674,
0.0492728576,
-0.002117692,
0.006805175,
-0.0029886332,
-0.0186291449,
0.0129469465,
0.0012431768,
0.0292073153,
-0.0410386659,
-0.0550322905,
-0.0344085209,
-0.0274917446,
0.0392979793,
-0.0383810028,
-0.0090251053,
0.002765792,
-0.026072029,
-0.0507956333,
0.0126684699,
0.0268307198,
-0.0213787872,
0.0247140042,
-0.0148376795,
0.0030829199,
0.0162765998,
0.0159638096,
-0.089249365,
0.0084184185,
0.0024500557,
-0.0088696508,
-0.0020387222,
-0.0178439673,
0.0003688849,
0.0050207237,
-0.0613909326,
0.0415911898,
0.0359177776,
0.0047245496,
0.0640563294,
-0.0006715597,
-0.021618003,
-0.055977758,
-0.0112683419,
-0.0031421902,
0.0140601508,
-0.0008463267,
0.0046833996,
-0.0210711937,
0.0818670839,
-0.0303357039,
0.0199053772,
0.0100158509,
0.0524336286,
0.0583836958,
-0.0269634966,
0.0486392155,
-0.0253334902,
0.0212647058,
0.0043105092,
-0.0216961168,
0.0345736742,
0.0076691806,
0.0222258158,
-0.0085858796,
0.0081703747,
-0.0470618121,
0.0480625257,
-0.1081968322,
0.02374506,
0.0104593746,
-0.0111362785,
-0.0332367234,
0.0436093323,
2.784e-7,
-0.0215352401,
0.0169662796,
0.0267112385,
-0.0104854461,
0.0411441028,
0.0438866951,
0.0103251794,
0.0281185452,
0.0139015093,
0.0603988245,
0.011962397,
0.0381565653,
0.0037341344,
-0.0094535667,
-0.0402589515,
0.0563902296,
-0.0413145423,
0.0370195396,
-0.0339269936,
-0.0130891539,
0.030247774,
0.0489212312,
0.0063346229,
0.0081523228,
0.0540806539,
0.0011335051,
0.0444128253,
-0.0005521284,
0.0191190671,
0.0470449701,
-0.0212867744,
0.0599025264,
-0.0846019611,
0.0056144893,
0.0073199836,
0.0407136939,
-0.0314356908,
0.0194407012,
0.0175573919,
-0.0212312713,
-0.0100875357,
0.016594829,
-0.0057445401,
0.0005428841,
0.0242998712,
-0.0470282286,
-0.0248470418,
-0.0003926413,
0.0245488659,
0.0252898913,
-0.0617005825,
-0.0105009545,
-0.0054460112,
-0.0199048836,
-0.0409314856,
0.0267495997,
0.0208923146,
-0.0452826768,
0.0778196082,
0.0451187901,
-0.0204208456,
-0.0013497396,
-0.0399088003,
0.0578684509,
0.1041794866,
-0.0313406028,
0.0758875608,
1.637037973e-34,
0.0048336666,
0.0053250156,
0.0248583183,
-0.0204863399,
-0.0157330129,
-0.0141798873,
-0.0367833562,
-0.0185904223,
0.0152140874,
-0.0147508681,
-0.0059877373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10241v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10241v1 | Snowman: A Million-scale Chinese Commonsense Knowledge Graph Distilled from Foundation Model | 2023-06-17T02:51:33 | 2023-06-17T02:51:33 | Jiaan Wang, Jianfeng Qu, Yunlong Liang, Zhixu Li, An Liu, Guanfeng Liu, Xin Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Constructing commonsense knowledge graphs (CKGs) has attracted wide research
attention due to its significant importance in cognitive intelligence.
Nevertheless, existing CKGs are typically oriented to English, limiting the
research in non-English languages. Meanwhile, the emergence of foundation
models like ChatGPT and GPT-4 has shown promising intelligence with the help of
reinforcement learning from human feedback. Under the background, in this
paper, we utilize foundation models to construct a Chinese CKG, named Snowman.
Specifically, we distill different types of commonsense head items from
ChatGPT, and continue to use it to collect tail items with respect to the head
items and pre-defined relations. Based on the preliminary analysis, we find the
negative commonsense knowledge distilled by ChatGPT achieves lower human
acceptance compared to other knowledge. Therefore, we design a simple yet
effective self-instruct filtering strategy to filter out invalid negative
commonsense. Overall, the constructed Snowman covers more than ten million
Chinese commonsense triples, making it the largest Chinese CKG. Moreover, human
studies show the acceptance of Snowman achieves 90.6\%, indicating the
high-quality triples distilled by the cutting-edge foundation model. We also
conduct experiments on commonsense knowledge models to show the usability and
effectiveness of our Snowman. | [
0.0581077822,
0.0175179951,
-0.0194174405,
0.0350911841,
-0.0232704636,
-0.0311714392,
-0.0275717862,
0.0191104431,
0.0922218934,
-0.0091557475,
0.0013247951,
0.0320450328,
-0.0057463367,
0.0110689504,
-0.0062232227,
-0.0393649004,
0.0494996868,
-0.0119138639,
0.0101566566,
-0.0311160441,
0.0200523045,
0.0104513029,
-0.017509032,
0.0165073778,
-0.0023860156,
-0.0207770057,
-0.0005285662,
-0.0229802821,
-0.0018749562,
-0.0501203239,
-0.0374999307,
0.0577630401,
-0.0280791335,
0.0172174126,
0.0000022848,
-0.0232592765,
0.0060042809,
-0.0288727116,
-0.0045404457,
-0.012606075,
0.015138912,
0.0093476409,
-0.0132256318,
0.0032264432,
-0.0568789728,
0.0000456848,
0.0087183276,
0.0657714158,
0.0633661225,
0.02828913,
-0.0006578354,
-0.0045995861,
0.0448072143,
0.0113480715,
0.0573421344,
-0.0553609505,
0.0402905196,
0.0616560839,
0.0222576689,
-0.0332221426,
-0.0391620286,
0.0073040994,
0.0404573642,
0.0079760002,
-0.0278972834,
0.048145704,
-0.0452789441,
0.0096087186,
-0.0210985355,
0.1167807505,
0.0365751684,
-0.0138095971,
-0.0066417977,
0.0171248112,
0.0603585988,
0.0276499949,
-0.0516414493,
0.0057576005,
-0.0070208707,
0.0127699878,
0.0098398104,
-0.0390375219,
0.0186054818,
0.0419084057,
-0.0071962583,
0.0398432836,
-0.017220512,
-0.0287716258,
0.0296747163,
-0.0109982295,
-0.0416098684,
-0.0398005769,
0.0093407733,
0.0164943393,
-0.0117092263,
0.021507157,
-0.0233863927,
0.033212252,
0.0150841409,
-0.0311973859,
-0.0093361568,
0.0180430617,
0.0070791761,
0.0587681122,
-0.0142121669,
0.0156216426,
-0.0066000638,
0.0325253308,
-0.0350803621,
-0.002354715,
-0.0729304552,
-0.0001627454,
-0.0324626267,
0.0892917812,
-0.0049902061,
-0.0122388089,
-0.0404648222,
0.0168584306,
-0.0387424976,
0.015598096,
0.0283489674,
0.0194312055,
0.0113983871,
0.0051309718,
-0.0572245233,
0.0395227931,
-0.0688160136,
0.0147740711,
0.0131678768,
0.0246481784,
0.0121992799,
-0.0010404312,
0.0411692373,
0.0015770348,
0.0145216556,
0.044360429,
-0.0060519627,
0.0020540569,
-0.0230607465,
-0.0173508637,
0.0287940279,
-0.0071729063,
-0.0026192444,
-0.0662595704,
0.0094673336,
-0.0088423872,
0.0111671593,
-0.0197739843,
0.0241406765,
0.0033007811,
-0.0389894843,
0.0479526557,
-0.0333330855,
-0.0196343958,
-0.0410259366,
0.0137311528,
-0.0127949389,
0.0372054875,
0.0271675959,
-0.0111266403,
0.0638802275,
-0.0095584095,
-0.0001925341,
-0.0012858359,
0.0352780744,
0.0264382996,
-0.0078255692,
-0.004023748,
-0.0451149568,
0.0100116134,
-0.0077657616,
0.0301872492,
-0.0285811722,
0.0123028019,
0.0647796318,
0.0723653436,
-0.034336675,
0.0557269715,
-0.0149100376,
0.0434108749,
0.0083890958,
0.012545526,
-0.0566277392,
0.0257232804,
-0.0901206508,
0.0048272344,
-0.0363532417,
-0.014567933,
-0.0149646429,
-0.0225590356,
0.0196734704,
-0.0053252112,
0.0748616904,
0.0022745619,
0.0230641216,
-0.0166489612,
-0.0204061605,
0.0277971253,
0.0222708303,
-0.063204959,
0.005522273,
-0.0151380068,
0.0254629459,
0.0587309822,
0.0444173068,
0.0078108343,
-0.035168346,
0.0369774848,
-0.0272040218,
0.0441327654,
0.0221736357,
-0.0123769222,
-0.0530304685,
-0.0454412773,
-0.0218550898,
0.0684041977,
-0.0273447577,
-0.0116315195,
0.0068113236,
0.0146773458,
-0.0256981142,
-0.0277670287,
0.0025540723,
-0.0016746806,
-0.0074407156,
0.0242797807,
-0.0408560522,
-0.0254854616,
0.0633092076,
0.0142582925,
0.0191514287,
0.0140737658,
0.0522499681,
-0.0106627792,
-0.075137414,
0.0562066585,
-0.0356299691,
-0.0722023994,
0.0599293076,
-0.0551344305,
-0.007202602,
0.0207044072,
-0.0245520398,
-0.0509181209,
0.0128337322,
0.0038651971,
0.0651939288,
-0.042019289,
-0.0089701386,
0.0016465832,
-0.0443729572,
0.0317844488,
0.1213674396,
-0.0598675311,
-0.009854177,
-0.0205815583,
-0.0119197136,
0.0127887651,
-0.0489820503,
0.0085375663,
-0.0063280384,
0.0017359558,
0.0269451514,
0.0393003114,
0.0454287417,
-0.0166705959,
0.0011403402,
-0.1044398621,
0.0035635841,
0.0269250013,
-0.0122255934,
-0.0020663124,
-0.0221814625,
0.0101705249,
0.0040644319,
-0.0543545522,
0.0406225398,
0.0050739776,
-0.0115121938,
0.0019583614,
-0.0243858863,
-0.0073324,
0.0103776371,
-0.0018622482,
-0.0317025483,
-0.0135754533,
0.0126404483,
0.0365509689,
0.0297674723,
0.0197281819,
-0.0547330305,
0.03167006,
-0.0169203654,
-0.0569835901,
0.0231511053,
-0.0335028246,
-0.0166485906,
0.0218477678,
0.0055748546,
0.0232248437,
0.0139401034,
-0.0375849307,
-0.0211154278,
0.0323146097,
-0.0123320203,
0.0472901873,
-0.0253886655,
0.0007330248,
-0.0176512636,
0.0119213769,
0.0329581648,
0.0079016034,
-0.0832567066,
0.0185847506,
0.0013877662,
-0.0101307994,
-0.0397428647,
0.0175168421,
-0.0216981769,
0.018594861,
-0.0430630483,
0.0287017561,
0.0642534718,
0.0091351131,
0.0242969319,
-0.045419611,
0.0425130017,
-0.0173962712,
0.0818182006,
-0.0251996089,
0.0118229436,
-0.0127667366,
-0.0083288755,
-0.058631666,
-0.0197438207,
0.0397716165,
-0.0369337574,
-0.0061196424,
-0.0256342143,
0.0266106669,
-0.004664592,
-0.045711074,
-0.0235984568,
-0.0226432607,
-0.0003104237,
0.0279182605,
0.0539840385,
-0.0120982062,
-0.0234266426,
0.0084886849,
0.0348087102,
0.0195918325,
0.0116968611,
0.0150805991,
-0.0203571748,
0.0002417677,
0.0355157703,
0.0364757255,
0.0279501416,
0.01322255,
0.0267802402,
0.0804225728,
0.0697469562,
-0.0298294146,
0.0700162128,
0.0344277285,
0.0155260963,
-0.019619124,
-0.0172965769,
0.0329626575,
0.0282037668,
-0.0398587845,
0.020436855,
0.0873957127,
0.027663758,
-0.0148720695,
0.0018121583,
0.0169550255,
-0.0423946716,
0.0202017631,
-0.0186867211,
-0.1225056425,
-0.0504636206,
-0.0144347409,
-0.0062192101,
0.0032715853,
-0.0901487321,
0.0487003066,
-0.1373255998,
0.0007707498,
0.0283453185,
-0.0860500261,
-0.0361584462,
-0.0183590986,
-0.0226221476,
-0.0026303132,
-0.0680382103,
0.0120675499,
-0.004382093,
-0.0030584673,
-0.0235052723,
0.009131087,
-0.0562385321,
0.0474021696,
-0.0147215603,
0.0424871072,
0.0308788363,
0.0609877184,
-0.0365878567,
-0.0620868802,
-0.0161047298,
-0.0448249094,
-0.0252340529,
-0.0264867898,
-0.01045701,
0.0015825612,
0.0058911839,
-0.0569742136,
0.0452719517,
-0.0689609498,
-0.0159123559,
0.0569964349,
0.0825796425,
-0.0077415016,
-0.0409895107,
-0.0333530642,
0.0066428045,
0.0061332332,
0.1067324355,
-0.0037281134,
-0.013068147,
-0.0048289993,
-0.0307605304,
-0.0438708887,
-0.0502713695,
-0.0465853699,
0.0275488719,
0.021785371,
0.0254821312,
-0.1069992185,
-0.0361529626,
0.0165336002,
0.027054064,
0.0112640234,
0.0096488437,
0.0520804226,
0.0282564778,
-0.0114674587,
-0.0033138089,
-0.0122476993,
-0.0433107987,
-0.0912303254,
-0.0042139152,
0.0112598296,
-0.0306204278,
-0.0087249056,
0.060685385,
0.02624112,
-0.0275457911,
-0.0204534568,
0.0389074944,
0.0158353299,
0.0046344539,
-0.0266050436,
0.0288688019,
0.0541805811,
0.0489253849,
-0.0533836037,
-0.0110258553,
0.0294971857,
-0.0131769497,
0.028811058,
0.0446885899,
-0.0412769653,
0.0453402512,
-0.0346506648,
0.0746280327,
-0.0724154338,
0.0297930352,
0.0298503824,
0.0445588566,
-0.0108646955,
0.0198257677,
0.0569636524,
-0.0255518239,
0.0016028752,
-0.0345634185,
-0.06216456,
-0.03570031,
-0.0029210486,
0.0144313443,
-0.0335651785,
-0.0015996649,
0.0268461518,
0.0082118846,
0.0088599725,
-0.0104545429,
-0.0232531037,
0.0190863181,
0.0444325507,
-0.0098013794,
-0.0388643108,
-0.0142205572,
-0.0175283961,
-0.0343448035,
0.0063631455,
-0.0176273435,
0.0933945775,
0.0249778889,
-0.0493863635,
0.0009043976,
0.0072024954,
-0.036344707,
-0.0051291515,
0.0222579408,
0.0719655752,
0.0498728454,
0.0331423245,
0.003674462,
-0.0512618199,
-0.0152338585,
-0.006306428,
0.0257694013,
0.0182419959,
-0.0444203503,
0.0306606293,
0.048005309,
-0.0067741522,
-0.0505129173,
0.0538848191,
-0.0554259196,
0.0148634529,
0.0217790548,
-0.0374588259,
-0.0494520217,
-0.0412669368,
0.0126737505,
0.051842995,
0.0110571105,
0.0597309172,
-0.0969084129,
-0.0437126793,
-0.0315724052,
0.0316323861,
0.0413190834,
-0.0120879021,
0.0269824844,
0.0399811789,
0.0019723501,
-0.0437060148,
0.0019139923,
0.0307106283,
-0.1388436407,
0.0041281534,
0.0000292281,
-6.713680966e-33,
-0.0448300205,
-0.0382662117,
0.0125093246,
0.0154964011,
0.0053300322,
-0.035925243,
-0.047555048,
0.0139742522,
-0.0240329001,
0.0278047156,
-0.02990539,
0.0206702687,
-0.0110623632,
-0.0009016839,
0.006202851,
0.0251919851,
0.0225588083,
0.0008717661,
-0.0049333251,
0.0220014416,
0.0803785101,
-0.0166755859,
0.0687432289,
-0.031836126,
0.0133574437,
-0.0396467932,
0.0161957443,
0.0213926937,
-0.0201133434,
0.0656056702,
0.0084783807,
0.0534453355,
0.0164988264,
0.0043799328,
0.0266116504,
-0.0235405546,
-0.1032417864,
-0.0778631642,
0.044071883,
-0.0052519441,
-0.0328346305,
-0.0009775833,
0.0278963689,
-0.0262192897,
0.0148000307,
0.0131867025,
0.0346022397,
-0.0239775907,
-0.029937936,
-0.0023660352,
-0.0125577254,
0.0047136503,
-0.0047605466,
-0.0142392078,
-0.0597396754,
-0.0154225873,
-0.0179273635,
-0.0638953298,
-0.0647467524,
0.0079368372,
0.0246375147,
-0.0050032786,
0.0115287192,
-0.0294652358,
0.0565957613,
0.0304310415,
-0.0441944674,
0.0046154652,
-0.0086202146,
0.0045850184,
0.0414825492,
0.065681994,
0.0468404666,
0.0756399632,
0.0345232971,
-0.0345349796,
-0.0894096866,
0.0314619355,
0.0285536386,
0.0833401307,
0.005370107,
-0.0037398485,
-0.058897309,
-0.0215327274,
0.0012365786,
-0.0377970785,
-0.0191764776,
-0.0244821478,
0.0149000818,
-0.0223862231,
-0.0608399101,
-0.0091439458,
0.0175939109,
-0.0222298,
-0.0272750203,
0.0734828636,
-0.0040937522,
-0.0029456283,
0.002620813,
-0.0087976055,
-0.0694480613,
-0.0220499244,
-0.0094550867,
-0.0037921399,
-0.0121342996,
0.059410844,
0.0301444009,
0.0048531215,
-0.0037581238,
-0.0252216719,
0.0032506285,
0.0080241337,
0.0015782416,
-0.0330446325,
0.0437606275,
0.0203373972,
0.0092133489,
-0.0301191192,
0.0357368737,
-0.0031411354,
-0.049666509,
0.0312532634,
-0.0058996696,
-0.0020432204,
0.0054688323,
-0.0012664119,
-0.0508353747,
-0.0312190596,
0.0381656997,
-0.0595609918,
-0.0080139507,
0.0310548339,
2.905e-7,
-0.0373363309,
0.0129026594,
0.0160900783,
0.0192787629,
0.019881567,
0.0557462648,
-0.0307668801,
0.003188459,
-0.0102553079,
-0.013996047,
0.0351579301,
0.0594470017,
0.0107248398,
0.0501528494,
-0.0928089768,
0.0146738738,
-0.0289009325,
-0.0378759913,
-0.0124916434,
0.0182545669,
0.0236199778,
0.0222828314,
0.0363115519,
0.0084631899,
0.0084247142,
-0.0600092486,
0.0369475484,
0.0010040699,
0.0316044576,
-0.0143767353,
-0.0187556483,
0.0081302049,
-0.0378889851,
0.0689283609,
0.0383537337,
0.0222659875,
0.0041250032,
0.0208883826,
-0.0163398255,
-0.0059901639,
0.0040066764,
-0.0390710309,
0.019243788,
-0.032789018,
0.0640787929,
-0.057208389,
-0.0292320419,
0.0045930301,
-0.0333101414,
-0.0151303215,
-0.0240741018,
0.0192155093,
-0.021759754,
-0.0224190727,
-0.0019627912,
0.0044853622,
0.0093631139,
-0.034197513,
0.0017548488,
0.0039918004,
0.0039972696,
-0.0775966123,
-0.0214175154,
-0.0433771238,
-0.033480525,
-0.0727982,
0.0088215936,
2.495485426e-34,
0.006227355,
-0.0172974225,
0.0097160004,
-0.0534714684,
0.038778387,
0.0088557405,
0.0003999855,
0.0088931229,
0.0480383635,
-0.0415702201,
-0.0123050753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10231v1 | GLIMMER: generalized late-interaction memory reranker | 2023-06-17T01:54:25 | 2023-06-17T01:54:25 | Michiel de Jong, Yury Zemlyanskiy, Nicholas FitzGerald, Sumit Sanghai, William W. Cohen, Joshua Ainslie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Memory-augmentation is a powerful approach for efficiently incorporating
external information into language models, but leads to reduced performance
relative to retrieving text. Recent work introduced LUMEN, a memory-retrieval
hybrid that partially pre-computes memory and updates memory representations on
the fly with a smaller live encoder.
We propose GLIMMER, which improves on this approach through 1) exploiting
free access to the powerful memory representations by applying a shallow
reranker on top of memory to drastically improve retrieval quality at low cost,
and 2) incorporating multi-task training to learn a general and higher quality
memory and live encoder. GLIMMER achieves strong gains in performance at faster
speeds compared to LUMEN and FiD on the KILT benchmark of knowledge-intensive
tasks. | [
0.0360344388,
0.0373514481,
-0.0035512175,
0.0497231074,
0.0163701959,
0.0050374218,
-0.0425014645,
-0.02398552,
0.0225943811,
-0.0386527926,
-0.0457290895,
-0.0520529784,
-0.0033392673,
0.0311896987,
0.0177321099,
-0.0348080881,
0.0533188172,
-0.0107151484,
0.0066400552,
-0.0003387639,
0.0047027329,
0.0046343636,
0.0139383273,
0.0364020988,
0.0369605385,
0.0115606179,
-0.0275518671,
0.0225783084,
0.0217367988,
0.003028274,
0.0120455502,
0.0269422289,
0.0377180651,
0.0239697918,
0.0000021917,
-0.0224351939,
-0.0228583682,
-0.0333662853,
-0.0295932852,
0.0184692889,
0.0135311354,
-0.0111811031,
0.008742637,
0.0154117355,
-0.0500412472,
-0.0249887072,
0.0336194374,
-0.0166194234,
0.0484050252,
0.0734103918,
-0.0178665388,
-0.0224145632,
0.0436049774,
-0.0494750664,
0.025494203,
-0.01674941,
0.0309819486,
-0.0133434469,
-0.0396240465,
0.0243828297,
-0.0068714069,
0.0551147498,
0.061446663,
-0.0030933572,
0.0553251281,
0.0294044018,
-0.0197771359,
0.0016753399,
-0.0200913884,
0.0564804189,
-0.0745897517,
-0.0086505888,
-0.0228122827,
-0.0065726982,
0.0056147869,
-0.0115744621,
-0.0409509689,
0.0028255954,
0.0338999107,
0.025712546,
-0.0345165096,
0.0217230488,
0.0425130241,
0.0149562331,
-0.0561089702,
0.024540402,
0.0345286019,
-0.017893428,
-0.0094276024,
0.0103925066,
-0.0406554267,
0.029623108,
0.016290037,
0.0206451323,
0.0057051834,
0.0111690369,
-0.0313632488,
-0.0536040179,
0.0110202227,
-0.0620158948,
0.0325789973,
0.0569986515,
-0.0128507083,
0.0298610255,
-0.0423624031,
0.0545714349,
0.0247380175,
0.0312141944,
-0.0373303555,
0.0051279208,
-0.0163544323,
-0.0298387557,
-0.0158358328,
0.0540922061,
-0.0363181196,
-0.0200093277,
-0.0389112905,
0.0263796244,
-0.0028885764,
-0.0190906171,
0.0056090076,
0.0094456058,
-0.0406679772,
0.013195022,
-0.0400493033,
0.026229905,
0.0107041625,
0.0058006928,
0.0144493757,
-0.0347667038,
-0.0402079821,
0.0028884751,
0.013358349,
-0.0487777479,
0.0179602057,
0.0666625276,
-0.0669239759,
-0.0585250333,
0.0061860341,
-0.0106119728,
0.0022182313,
-0.0256165005,
-0.0042014704,
-0.0438581221,
0.0657681674,
-0.006662061,
-0.0172463506,
-0.0325435326,
0.0188392829,
0.0295084435,
-0.0307206083,
0.0465635322,
0.0169541463,
-0.03768415,
0.0005862793,
0.0330624394,
0.0206028521,
0.0447506644,
0.009082797,
0.0423363708,
0.0111223934,
0.0331179574,
-0.0180688202,
0.0393439159,
0.0265766215,
-0.0215916038,
-0.0155106932,
0.0088847196,
0.014427729,
-0.0141670117,
0.0717830434,
0.0162661411,
-0.0769155249,
-0.0410303883,
0.0631704926,
0.0091711208,
0.0236307438,
-0.0168098398,
0.0050717439,
0.0169229433,
0.0059321164,
-0.010087613,
-0.0303670745,
0.051769793,
-0.0139790094,
0.0038737503,
0.0490176976,
0.0530014746,
-0.0184655972,
-0.0357251801,
0.0182137769,
-0.0212998204,
0.0362819396,
0.0229497813,
0.0501908772,
0.013434208,
-0.0433651544,
0.0502725132,
0.0365837775,
-0.0248528719,
-0.0145799285,
-0.0508356914,
-0.0394265205,
0.0950491652,
0.0549823903,
-0.0427150354,
-0.0431047231,
0.0116436593,
-0.0484734997,
0.0374688171,
0.0059387861,
-0.0027178845,
0.0317787081,
-0.0756346285,
-0.0056016515,
-0.025222376,
0.0030292915,
0.0356304459,
0.0555554666,
0.0007696726,
0.04039637,
0.0108745582,
-0.0192885324,
0.0160193518,
-0.0023198267,
-0.0127435485,
-0.0113288192,
-0.0210215971,
-0.0106279887,
-0.0230274368,
-0.0138147008,
0.0229342747,
0.0651974753,
-0.0474153049,
0.0006874194,
-0.0136713022,
-0.0868636742,
-0.0858742371,
0.0228646789,
0.0349133424,
0.0235904753,
0.0896873772,
-0.0265413504,
-0.0562922619,
0.0299673192,
-0.00974424,
0.074398227,
-0.0710104182,
0.0167587642,
0.0112568773,
0.0040088207,
-0.0365245827,
0.0586329773,
-0.0324492082,
0.009594827,
0.0194880404,
0.0046727844,
-0.0375640169,
-0.0457251407,
-0.0554837324,
0.0157084968,
-0.0056612021,
0.0313241184,
0.0120489672,
0.0076169251,
-0.005744278,
-0.0278928392,
-0.0763914064,
0.0060052266,
-0.0320943147,
-0.0236022063,
0.0210987981,
0.0327422991,
0.0359934047,
-0.0312690102,
-0.0063972641,
0.0077607534,
-0.0205776915,
0.0384221412,
0.0060016396,
0.0183574427,
0.0290334262,
-0.013353168,
-0.0337008759,
0.0370042585,
0.0691428185,
-0.0285556484,
-0.060373079,
0.0110412501,
0.0160365496,
-0.0335109718,
0.0156452954,
-0.0439975671,
-0.024057094,
-0.0274658222,
-0.02036516,
0.0418190062,
0.0649083257,
0.0090090008,
0.0514787398,
0.0328169391,
0.0020526745,
-0.067075789,
0.0048452504,
-0.0242106598,
0.0019167915,
-0.026143536,
0.0336736217,
-0.0457614511,
0.0433817655,
-0.0261479877,
-0.0031838205,
-0.0379221588,
0.0145803131,
0.0060773506,
-0.0329012685,
-0.0567239635,
-0.0131144281,
-0.0349381939,
-0.0030520507,
-0.0699964613,
-0.0318516567,
0.061963059,
-0.0261036865,
-0.0344936289,
-0.0254853945,
-0.0142126149,
-0.024426626,
0.0407815501,
0.0101540899,
0.017071953,
-0.0427415967,
-0.038122423,
-0.0369677842,
0.0401561297,
0.0029161868,
-0.0684787631,
0.0443246402,
-0.0106932847,
0.0216843206,
-0.0172404423,
-0.0567064807,
-0.0421894528,
-0.0097128302,
0.034610264,
0.0187340453,
0.0209507253,
-0.0190880392,
-0.0379785448,
0.0209695064,
0.0085537825,
0.0908865705,
-0.0304263588,
0.003808151,
-0.018353695,
0.0417721756,
0.0294146016,
0.0159048866,
-0.002527135,
-0.0291449819,
0.00119437,
0.0719761476,
0.0341614634,
-0.0768760666,
-0.0082574915,
0.0071595949,
0.0180650372,
0.0100703789,
-0.0058445074,
-0.012265821,
0.0096474802,
-0.0883113146,
-0.0568798222,
0.087572597,
0.010524462,
-0.0780315101,
-0.0203558095,
0.0145774763,
0.0486245789,
0.032126233,
0.0279702209,
-0.0542201251,
-0.0316686034,
0.0099486466,
0.0069704428,
0.0179764815,
0.0053676949,
-0.0005321481,
-0.1194444075,
0.0204832219,
0.0176004004,
-0.011266158,
-0.0051184846,
-0.0405960269,
-0.042124629,
0.0157849435,
-0.0080514699,
0.0553218052,
0.0106545798,
0.0010404855,
0.0022994708,
-0.0121772755,
-0.072848469,
0.041764643,
0.0021154436,
0.0224315263,
0.0454469882,
0.0035420211,
0.0337473154,
-0.0445449576,
0.0371072665,
-0.0157213397,
-0.0060813795,
-0.0025283187,
0.0576559529,
-0.0249286219,
-0.0090460433,
-0.0129409218,
-0.0105848406,
-0.0047799964,
-0.0273418128,
-0.0314898528,
0.0374296382,
-0.0053573772,
0.0363199189,
0.0090452014,
-0.0389813483,
-0.02710196,
0.0424911194,
0.0097605195,
-0.009068843,
-0.0157433059,
-0.0103608994,
-0.0034517937,
-0.0470589958,
-0.0634176508,
0.0038879286,
0.038296096,
0.0180993583,
-0.0506562963,
-0.047324203,
0.0221820325,
0.0559361465,
-0.0163044427,
-0.0051098536,
-0.0100204227,
-0.0272459276,
-0.1132648662,
0.0239150077,
-0.0304685067,
-0.006509054,
-0.0121512078,
-0.0294271093,
0.0219973847,
-0.0065860571,
-0.0212074667,
0.0172387455,
-0.0441489145,
-0.0544948876,
-0.0090620322,
0.0895788595,
0.0307566505,
0.058459606,
0.0015536355,
-0.01015158,
0.0369616896,
-0.0039423048,
-0.0658528805,
0.037751738,
0.024494322,
-0.0348756164,
-0.0131011689,
0.028012123,
-0.042194739,
-0.0012737151,
-0.0012769694,
0.0291543454,
0.0161274802,
-0.0155547578,
0.012931563,
0.005079444,
0.0549349599,
0.0104405181,
0.0034442472,
-0.048987437,
0.0647677481,
-0.0342335477,
0.0027721229,
-0.0621259399,
-0.0040730699,
0.0422827154,
0.0259854477,
-0.0094419019,
0.0006595012,
0.061074283,
-0.03217436,
-0.0417793542,
-0.0471325368,
0.0017416601,
-0.0415503979,
0.0226995256,
0.0233044624,
-0.0205546357,
0.0208452456,
0.0082334448,
0.0471713692,
-0.0461139381,
-0.0039082887,
0.0136058601,
-0.0255782381,
-0.0262116026,
0.0507280007,
-0.0887606293,
-0.0468648188,
-0.0704748333,
-0.0027211159,
0.0576218367,
-0.0159288645,
0.0841758102,
0.0392783657,
-0.0011069372,
-0.0125719411,
-0.0189493857,
-0.0123117398,
-0.0702415854,
-0.0139877386,
0.0276803784,
-0.0316366777,
0.0352053083,
0.076687187,
0.0181345139,
-0.0027965275,
0.0074540833,
-0.001493466,
-0.0115741882,
-0.0450363085,
0.0283523519,
0.0529886931,
-0.0161188096,
-0.0411349721,
-0.0116060637,
-0.054755263,
0.0242630653,
-0.0226241089,
-0.0077432552,
0.007295954,
0.0282390155,
0.0406001545,
-0.0044733286,
-0.0219860654,
-0.0371789336,
-0.0143183125,
-0.0143206427,
-0.013911779,
0.0222247336,
-7.096457192e-33,
-0.0540543497,
-0.0036005203,
0.0135486545,
-0.050778497,
-0.0332116596,
0.0423835367,
-0.0319350399,
-0.0239335727,
-0.0000631227,
-0.013332746,
0.0139831696,
0.0201484505,
0.0143309878,
0.0555454865,
-0.0045735855,
-0.0001297163,
0.0498313308,
0.0149824303,
-0.0109217633,
0.0225178376,
0.0246440917,
0.0756767169,
0.0330920629,
0.0047283941,
-0.027096482,
0.0058342679,
0.0292241909,
0.0127620781,
0.027362762,
0.0228730105,
-0.0345244147,
0.0565225109,
0.0168144796,
-0.0594787784,
-0.038860172,
-0.0080948742,
-0.1045551598,
0.0032606048,
-0.0013884581,
-0.009884879,
-0.0439942405,
0.0123883905,
0.0310481228,
0.0021837009,
0.0337698907,
-0.0281174406,
0.0093569662,
-0.0151930694,
-0.0543146171,
-0.0297036842,
-0.0419263169,
0.0122195091,
0.0155751435,
0.0011907442,
0.0530808903,
0.0094553372,
0.0065093376,
0.0147464257,
-0.0836836323,
-0.0088032493,
-0.028480636,
0.0745354816,
0.0295547768,
0.0480770245,
0.0145519776,
0.1070834473,
0.0019661707,
0.0062119509,
-0.002033008,
0.006273041,
0.0690881163,
0.033393383,
0.0341978073,
-0.0017191682,
0.0402182564,
-0.0192363095,
-0.0847668648,
0.0211329851,
0.0491374135,
0.0270177089,
0.0355732776,
0.0547498167,
-0.0125506613,
-0.0486289412,
-0.0076513602,
0.0417216048,
-0.0506811403,
-0.0265468024,
0.0531241782,
0.0581286736,
-0.0228741188,
0.0082126027,
0.0385241993,
-0.0297681205,
0.0203610491,
0.0221488141,
-0.011317079,
0.009994206,
-0.0258372333,
0.0491132513,
-0.0193197373,
-0.021947315,
0.0466759354,
-0.009594799,
-0.0127153145,
-0.0081226407,
0.0437587947,
0.0295489654,
-0.0636845902,
-0.0071551464,
-0.0431204885,
0.0254556816,
0.0125011047,
0.0664017946,
0.0152828647,
0.021044651,
-0.0213747006,
0.067430146,
0.0029699404,
0.0012045179,
-0.0378486663,
-0.036662098,
0.0277265161,
0.0012314066,
-0.0128538916,
0.0265624691,
-0.0330800042,
0.0412375592,
0.0008347575,
-0.072684519,
0.0030098634,
0.0014367584,
2.896e-7,
0.0312182456,
0.0364377052,
0.0235060882,
-0.0125440713,
0.0006756849,
-0.0132012125,
-0.0049326839,
0.055650875,
0.022004772,
-0.0051431637,
0.0220818389,
0.051662568,
0.0413228013,
-0.0034682783,
-0.0895830542,
-0.0169323441,
-0.0892394409,
-0.0304461401,
-0.0268271212,
-0.0820074454,
0.0038935335,
0.0989385769,
-0.0201166943,
0.0031933687,
0.0019627372,
-0.0390755087,
0.0954564363,
0.0009187837,
-0.0236989949,
-0.0207868926,
0.0307499468,
0.0638143942,
-0.0286757331,
0.0219758563,
-0.0403605811,
0.0230852086,
0.0183494724,
0.0789002255,
-0.0420412123,
-0.0725985169,
0.0324897952,
0.0358273871,
-0.0113469623,
-0.0296337418,
0.0703384653,
-0.0585920922,
-0.018157715,
0.0174875353,
-0.0334348977,
0.0052241595,
-0.0024559831,
-0.0020587083,
-0.0110007245,
0.0304079745,
0.0172754768,
0.0179024152,
-0.0040542432,
-0.138077721,
-0.0500258133,
0.0111339884,
-0.0376090109,
-0.0200378913,
-0.0585230999,
-0.0391423665,
0.0022066084,
-0.0398277976,
-0.0031143634,
2.932684377e-34,
0.0518220402,
0.0258707255,
0.0178096127,
0.0713120475,
0.0237904694,
-0.0158808492,
-0.0017282643,
0.0258596204,
-0.0191017203,
-0.0740610361,
-0.0387308747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.05492v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.05492v1 | GPT4 is Slightly Helpful for Peer-Review Assistance: A Pilot Study | 2023-06-16T23:11:06 | 2023-06-16T23:11:06 | Zachary Robertson | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | In this pilot study, we investigate the use of GPT4 to assist in the
peer-review process. Our key hypothesis was that GPT-generated reviews could
achieve comparable helpfulness to human reviewers. By comparing reviews
generated by both human reviewers and GPT models for academic papers submitted
to a major machine learning conference, we provide initial evidence that
artificial intelligence can contribute effectively to the peer-review process.
We also perform robustness experiments with inserted errors to understand which
parts of the paper the model tends to focus on. Our findings open new avenues
for leveraging machine learning tools to address resource constraints in peer
review. The results also shed light on potential enhancements to the review
process and lay the groundwork for further research on scaling oversight in a
domain where human-feedback is increasingly a scarce resource. | [
0.0652409792,
0.0314475298,
-0.0099837659,
-0.0326820724,
-0.0661156997,
-0.0160729997,
0.0246902388,
0.008810061,
-0.0323658139,
-0.0333342627,
-0.0332796574,
0.0118375849,
-0.0199949499,
0.0356553532,
0.0054461486,
-0.0581175834,
0.011756679,
0.0073416815,
0.072945796,
0.0046199905,
-0.0177338291,
-0.0150079289,
0.0295991469,
0.0365127809,
0.022307964,
0.0076094619,
0.0148105556,
-0.0290712453,
-0.0243442822,
-0.0052149305,
-0.0178793203,
0.081733644,
0.0014912091,
0.0931985378,
0.0000018247,
-0.0337060243,
0.0178885479,
0.0448208787,
0.0050935927,
0.0579605438,
0.0601523407,
-0.046507746,
0.0077425609,
0.0146335335,
-0.0224853233,
-0.0338546373,
-0.0038203588,
0.0588792637,
0.002293743,
0.0172516126,
-0.0056577539,
0.0276050214,
0.0331210233,
-0.0362241603,
0.004424809,
-0.034878958,
-0.002796045,
0.0191099029,
0.0331916325,
0.0376033112,
0.0126247089,
-0.0037274475,
0.0395443477,
-0.0451019742,
0.0374013186,
0.0385193303,
-0.0183622222,
-0.0032992985,
-0.0246428773,
0.0229088608,
0.0376994535,
-0.0433829799,
-0.0081692245,
-0.0291746333,
0.0176314767,
0.0874315426,
-0.030996358,
-0.0149618927,
-0.0040410091,
-0.0150743164,
0.0018073274,
0.0000995561,
0.0249293912,
0.0247677956,
0.0623274297,
0.0365140103,
0.0078683197,
-0.0648735911,
0.0423694737,
0.0941360295,
0.0280914027,
-0.0204243455,
-0.0254768487,
-0.0189561211,
-0.0138659561,
-0.0231644474,
0.0397143736,
0.0473440662,
0.0312818699,
-0.0075396877,
0.0381514542,
-0.0453325063,
0.0066706873,
0.0443779975,
0.024177378,
-0.0281015355,
-0.0295112971,
0.0421508066,
0.0312964544,
0.019230444,
-0.0457235798,
0.0052540442,
0.0222282801,
0.0196939502,
0.0074033313,
0.0136203095,
-0.0463461801,
-0.0002994311,
-0.0415472463,
0.0214267559,
0.0637239441,
0.0306890197,
-0.011173361,
0.0074791,
-0.0276636016,
0.0145869972,
-0.0380667001,
0.0379353389,
-0.0369388349,
0.0410327464,
0.005895678,
0.0076166796,
0.0236395411,
-0.0205947608,
0.0197039135,
0.037310116,
0.0454915836,
0.000158743,
0.0237566419,
-0.0101520261,
-0.0047938451,
-0.0595933348,
-0.0288984887,
-0.0402635634,
-0.0193159599,
-0.0068333112,
-0.0250991695,
-0.0195347518,
-0.0519869179,
-0.0306643732,
-0.0137042226,
0.060240414,
-0.0742529333,
0.0062033436,
0.0283584911,
0.0080075879,
-0.0636848733,
-0.0432147533,
-0.0248542484,
0.0004985833,
0.0403100774,
-0.0423064157,
0.0804229751,
-0.0098607522,
0.0018874467,
0.0252576824,
0.0496735685,
-0.0003509926,
-0.0560058802,
-0.0153029123,
-0.0202586241,
0.0441312976,
-0.030683957,
0.0046709995,
0.08472161,
0.0283259917,
-0.0398057401,
0.0514500886,
-0.0061305678,
0.001346287,
0.0121136745,
0.0354241133,
-0.0597220026,
0.0454230048,
-0.0092319446,
-0.0136102969,
0.0083289342,
-0.0148959244,
-0.0194353182,
-0.0472671613,
0.0096167447,
0.0074248305,
-0.0148414029,
0.008609999,
0.0712214187,
-0.0009502132,
-0.0207235925,
-0.0532275438,
-0.0027746491,
0.0000657085,
0.0106643802,
-0.0443520732,
0.0234339889,
0.011950233,
0.0729480088,
-0.0259785131,
0.0148737151,
-0.0390563123,
-0.0180212893,
0.0177219491,
0.0738571808,
-0.0080277286,
-0.0581043176,
-0.0003388673,
-0.0273733884,
0.0032681031,
0.0085521042,
0.0121552395,
0.0339693725,
0.0200727377,
-0.0123603204,
-0.0065048984,
-0.0700578913,
0.0111989118,
0.0330635868,
-0.0209442452,
0.0119779725,
-0.0239807498,
0.0541481674,
0.0563237555,
-0.0394287817,
0.0233969353,
0.0368512012,
0.0317038409,
-0.0551045015,
0.0061654281,
0.0426420495,
0.076499261,
0.008147479,
-0.0357486494,
-0.0193230696,
0.0018155513,
-0.0234090965,
-0.0079181604,
0.0454747602,
0.0135397315,
0.0075535243,
-0.0169321448,
-0.0238410048,
-0.0552827902,
-0.042310752,
-0.0088673439,
0.021411771,
0.0269524064,
0.0247148126,
-0.027213892,
0.0079661626,
0.0223305002,
0.0138031598,
-0.0242059585,
-0.0089829173,
0.0210764986,
0.0202981532,
0.0949893594,
-0.0156782344,
0.0044102855,
-0.0339003354,
-0.0421904959,
-0.0503201485,
0.0036440229,
0.0135384742,
0.01363621,
-0.0522367209,
0.0278754402,
0.0104512256,
0.0000452619,
-0.0349954367,
0.0098298164,
0.000844716,
0.0404206254,
0.0195416659,
-0.002140542,
-0.0688233823,
-0.0205909107,
-0.0390242077,
0.0049494668,
0.1049348935,
-0.0020297021,
-0.0496416353,
0.0251233149,
-0.0015767602,
0.0072747753,
0.0131864725,
0.0014582447,
0.0381283537,
0.0076657869,
-0.0192682818,
0.0172579978,
-0.0200899038,
0.0191801302,
0.0643413439,
0.0356248543,
-0.0054429453,
-0.0036267922,
-0.0110253291,
-0.0265378058,
0.0078794053,
-0.0071054026,
0.0512748994,
-0.0136480965,
0.0031369065,
-0.0147405099,
-0.0546407588,
0.0500783063,
-0.0109730111,
-0.023174556,
0.0149304662,
-0.0573009029,
-0.0118180951,
0.038094189,
-0.0057485583,
-0.0638315827,
0.0383679532,
-0.0172193293,
0.0145501876,
-0.043662142,
0.0236965381,
-0.0387735516,
0.0372180939,
0.0153121892,
0.0033288612,
-0.0401083343,
0.04744827,
0.0050947787,
-0.0005627673,
0.0702617392,
0.0101532033,
0.0066856663,
-0.0463843979,
0.0154819861,
-0.0062453868,
-0.0492418595,
0.0351033397,
-0.0315763131,
-0.0112206517,
0.0276984368,
0.0355582796,
-0.029183371,
-0.0291021187,
0.0238677766,
0.0332711376,
0.0843981951,
-0.0269250162,
-0.0325748064,
0.0118367672,
0.0028891484,
-0.0012570007,
-0.0563417859,
0.0264154542,
-0.0344676785,
-0.0129618244,
0.0196923371,
0.0225193407,
0.0009726865,
-0.043460805,
-0.0362768322,
-0.0206309427,
-0.0671283826,
-0.0128664272,
-0.0003391181,
0.015130884,
-0.0300491732,
0.0243395846,
0.0846885517,
0.019982392,
-0.165655002,
-0.031419497,
-0.0317552462,
-0.0153584937,
0.0098320898,
0.0379887298,
-0.0475744717,
0.0098480228,
0.0202915296,
0.0346938819,
-0.0271027256,
-0.0320068412,
0.0312772319,
-0.0695592538,
0.0846392661,
-0.0115911793,
-0.0250831693,
-0.0411931798,
-0.0484222025,
0.0095842965,
-0.0486911237,
-0.0351210833,
0.0021678437,
0.0167853907,
0.021290997,
-0.0103750126,
-0.0397868119,
-0.0451360047,
0.0496316478,
-0.068458207,
0.0581393763,
0.0452422276,
0.0126559343,
-0.0374686867,
0.0201924238,
0.0328224786,
-0.0019340538,
-0.0011184509,
0.0089416066,
0.0647350922,
0.0059085153,
0.0369310938,
-0.0236971956,
0.0317482501,
-0.0121496944,
0.0379557014,
0.0451472625,
0.0978248268,
-0.019933736,
-0.0434845909,
-0.0386396945,
-0.0233347528,
-0.0229885243,
0.0215480141,
0.0025862516,
-0.0389567651,
-0.07141909,
-0.0048458758,
0.028466126,
0.0015468219,
-0.035853412,
-0.0515603051,
-0.0009462114,
-0.0233444106,
-0.0495045222,
-0.0663391501,
-0.0081580663,
0.0040496807,
0.042836085,
0.0144777782,
0.0116635021,
0.0169143341,
0.0177516136,
0.0140661588,
0.0127367554,
-0.0020121525,
-0.0476621203,
-0.0329814442,
0.0390693136,
0.0281987153,
0.0033237694,
0.0184197295,
0.0330412388,
-0.0351821519,
-0.0458278656,
0.0692223683,
0.0324108191,
0.0336153656,
-0.0289191063,
-0.0431969389,
-0.0376829542,
0.001232913,
-0.0130221713,
-0.0400332026,
0.0194375813,
-0.0553096086,
-0.0359623209,
-0.0369388349,
-0.0297816787,
0.038160868,
0.0055995728,
-0.0528635122,
-0.0089632953,
-0.0318895206,
0.0163598675,
0.0144619448,
0.0264718216,
-0.0125772674,
0.0356866121,
-0.0130029898,
-0.0305768829,
-0.0180303194,
0.0014614804,
-0.0058016158,
-0.0202516001,
0.0146090621,
0.0150073776,
-0.0321734212,
0.054846637,
-0.0259051695,
0.03189395,
-0.0683823228,
0.0563893765,
0.024190506,
0.0385398306,
-0.0329160802,
-0.0277247466,
-0.0337424465,
-0.0311131161,
-0.0078125298,
0.0182856265,
0.0018625961,
0.0376157872,
-0.0231349673,
0.0288040806,
0.0346149281,
0.0121065965,
-0.125412792,
-0.0012874842,
-0.0175856985,
-0.0001821972,
0.035979446,
0.037771672,
0.0142158084,
-0.0260411166,
-0.0198271926,
-0.0249758363,
0.0221068338,
0.0133027667,
0.0539702177,
-0.0008181218,
0.009301682,
-0.0260373522,
-0.0054889601,
0.026053993,
0.0267664455,
-0.0056682411,
-0.0448108613,
-0.0601004623,
-0.0108762216,
-0.054408811,
-0.0386843011,
-0.006875962,
-0.0060215076,
-0.0297969263,
-0.0505291559,
-0.0173597001,
-0.030523682,
0.0336460918,
0.0587479323,
-0.0448389016,
-0.05094897,
0.06176918,
-0.0245512072,
-0.0340204351,
-0.0503913313,
-0.0068186284,
-0.0220817719,
-0.0076041836,
-0.0423446186,
-5.620225468e-33,
0.0060562328,
-0.0520675965,
-0.007639253,
0.0506064706,
0.0142818177,
-0.0053081634,
-0.0347820632,
-0.0290168338,
0.0070693209,
0.0545423515,
-0.0811968446,
0.0167997126,
-0.0119511876,
-0.0531531237,
0.1135584563,
0.0364947505,
0.0797583908,
-0.0421946608,
0.0016722206,
0.0654821545,
-0.06667988,
-0.0317901,
0.0150402617,
-0.0420041643,
0.077677764,
0.0174490139,
-0.0207311269,
-0.0162497293,
-0.0418673456,
0.0364664942,
-0.013612248,
0.0118031977,
0.0334848464,
-0.0325217731,
0.0120709101,
-0.0054393909,
-0.0752581805,
0.0188183319,
0.0187858827,
-0.0370818153,
-0.0137724467,
0.0032055927,
0.0566042997,
-0.0105305808,
-0.0824798569,
0.0064805886,
0.0405945443,
-0.0037716199,
-0.020231463,
-0.0473695695,
-0.0356376991,
0.0264444519,
-0.0131622739,
0.056821771,
0.0011271313,
0.0590269826,
-0.0278598256,
0.0333971716,
-0.0357008763,
0.0169593524,
0.0185490288,
-0.0125282295,
0.0040481817,
-0.0287252218,
-0.0126347924,
0.0203810129,
0.0026279581,
0.0278007854,
-0.0554630235,
-0.0494712442,
0.0140937036,
0.0168768726,
0.1039266512,
0.0871415138,
0.0367761515,
-0.0301388446,
-0.0499157868,
0.0432093367,
0.0305018593,
0.023210872,
0.0864027441,
-0.0594116859,
-0.0338282362,
-0.0214125179,
0.009502002,
-0.0810378268,
-0.0107004307,
-0.0238582771,
-0.0037508865,
0.0136262821,
-0.0034078194,
0.0004751173,
0.007928363,
-0.0518075936,
0.0151752345,
0.0427807495,
-0.0124635557,
0.065171726,
0.0157390721,
-0.0650025383,
-0.0928812698,
0.003920313,
-0.0362897515,
0.0669005439,
0.0365472399,
-0.0280496404,
0.0394972563,
0.0234219041,
-0.0514804758,
0.0236454643,
-0.01838357,
0.0425762944,
0.0484477617,
0.0062922384,
0.0073902421,
0.0012686895,
0.0371431336,
-0.014648742,
-0.0156091135,
0.0648016632,
-0.0254717376,
0.075257048,
-0.0113491006,
-0.00847062,
0.0148705384,
-0.0261922162,
-0.0002471741,
0.0173118711,
-0.0026013532,
-0.032020729,
-0.0089554098,
-0.0192753002,
2.521e-7,
0.0564182848,
0.0612004697,
0.0031384358,
-0.0474112518,
0.0494448841,
0.0125401625,
-0.0270432644,
0.0218388755,
0.0210645739,
0.0202643629,
0.0775077865,
-0.0256326515,
0.0079611801,
0.0369448662,
-0.0446927324,
-0.0359678455,
-0.0857771412,
0.0023257085,
-0.0354473665,
-0.0080590816,
-0.0126003996,
-0.0121822227,
0.015008973,
-0.0056335269,
-0.0397235192,
-0.0420004837,
0.0547076762,
-0.0257734451,
0.0060084327,
0.0079053361,
0.0472316146,
0.0013351692,
-0.0248263776,
0.0306022447,
-0.016450135,
0.022159636,
-0.0268217437,
0.0283299275,
-0.0125150215,
0.022860758,
0.0313175321,
0.0033461151,
0.051699467,
-0.0406326652,
0.0335827507,
-0.016494872,
-0.0468956195,
-0.0516665578,
-0.0241075065,
-0.0420381427,
0.0553566627,
0.0032438149,
-0.0224478021,
0.0080015967,
-0.0516549572,
0.0002803761,
0.0128314085,
-0.0335611068,
0.022158606,
0.0275365282,
0.0032083543,
-0.0405260064,
0.0177335627,
-0.0368841887,
-0.0212706681,
-0.0215566754,
0.0299193412,
2.077867411e-34,
0.1113944724,
-0.0401931144,
0.026346039,
-0.0080483435,
0.0429205559,
0.0443376675,
-0.0370481238,
-0.0223177169,
0.0207937732,
-0.0165110026,
-0.0008688594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10196v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10196v1 | Structured Thoughts Automaton: First Formalized Execution Model for Auto-Regressive Language Models | 2023-06-16T22:04:50 | 2023-06-16T22:04:50 | Tristan Vanderbruggen, Chunhua Liao, Peter Pirkelbauer, Pei-Hung Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.FL, cs.LG | In recent months, Language Models (LMs) have become a part of daily
discourse, with focus on OpenAI and the potential of Artificial General
Intelligence (AGI). Furthermore, the leaking of LLama's weights to the public
has led to an influx of innovations demonstrating the impressive capabilities
of generative LMs. While we believe that AGI is still a distant goal, we
recognize the potential of LMs in solving tasks such as searching complex
documents, compiling reports with basic analysis, and providing assistance in
problem-solving. In this paper, we propose formalizing the execution model of
language models. We investigate current execution models, to find that this
formalism has received little attention, and present our contribution: the
first formalized execution model for LMs. We introduce a new algorithm for
sampling the predictions of LMs, which we use to build a reliable and
inspectable execution model. We introduce a low-level language to write
"cognitive program" for this execution model. We hope to shed light on the need
for execution models for LMs and encourage further research in this area. | [
0.0218523629,
0.0734653175,
-0.0399947576,
0.0388520621,
-0.0423986763,
-0.0045860629,
-0.0126292491,
-0.0222009476,
0.0445581488,
-0.0646893606,
0.0001728814,
-0.031657204,
-0.0066087022,
0.0782999694,
0.0208099931,
-0.0562565625,
0.0288171396,
-0.0741577744,
0.0566834658,
-0.0065579247,
-0.0125987483,
-0.0011888351,
0.0075811045,
0.0391440913,
0.0271252561,
-0.0302102603,
-0.0209299736,
-0.0443085022,
-0.0230841544,
0.0010415235,
-0.018932214,
0.0349840038,
0.0015540122,
0.0571795441,
0.0000023577,
-0.0437915586,
0.0248594172,
-0.003135131,
0.0191538353,
0.0267605726,
-0.001486042,
-0.0317102857,
-0.0090850769,
0.0274303723,
-0.0333821736,
-0.0327594765,
0.0228351355,
-0.0020308222,
0.0633161664,
0.0591179207,
-0.0091078635,
-0.0491818748,
0.059241198,
-0.0066803782,
0.0292159002,
-0.0344308391,
0.0366971269,
0.0147709455,
-0.0016508864,
-0.0166558772,
0.0128150675,
0.0331583656,
-0.00318519,
-0.009786021,
0.002723519,
0.0167572517,
-0.0131012565,
-0.0229205303,
-0.0307846218,
0.0347853228,
0.0053767636,
-0.0377612114,
0.008500712,
-0.0237361863,
-0.005824313,
-0.0364034213,
-0.0401566513,
0.0841312185,
0.0244824942,
0.0436385609,
0.0581001788,
0.0055496832,
0.0338092484,
0.0102014486,
-0.0372335464,
0.1094177961,
-0.0012158528,
-0.0227434933,
-0.0019180371,
0.0154697523,
-0.0046745897,
-0.0697525144,
0.0059785577,
0.0732539669,
-0.0143418955,
0.0056853546,
-0.0318432339,
-0.0703139156,
0.0035763225,
-0.0366788879,
0.0943780094,
0.0582385138,
0.0269861985,
0.0299187433,
-0.0323229171,
0.0638335347,
-0.0353826471,
0.0153769292,
-0.0280932114,
-0.0083200624,
-0.0308271199,
-0.0149694076,
-0.0396977253,
0.0501249097,
-0.0064110863,
-0.0230070166,
-0.0388164707,
0.0690092146,
-0.0585831553,
0.0147740766,
-0.0367254801,
-0.019688908,
-0.030155275,
0.0176938996,
-0.0536335297,
-0.0308904201,
-0.0316397287,
-0.0072910921,
0.0128724873,
-0.0248907395,
-0.0063585611,
0.036850661,
-0.0286168028,
0.0167106427,
-0.0260385294,
0.079693459,
0.004066478,
0.0168702547,
-0.0497681946,
-0.0474892408,
0.0128334314,
-0.0533412173,
0.0255729146,
-0.0815513059,
0.0031898718,
0.0126006482,
-0.0114615299,
-0.0208900683,
-0.0055402708,
0.0228878409,
-0.0249818768,
0.0564618446,
0.0015071308,
0.0162023194,
0.0238642432,
-0.0056447913,
0.0168161299,
0.0888636634,
0.0463870876,
0.0353713557,
0.0087394882,
0.0352854505,
0.0473345257,
0.0730679482,
0.009245907,
-0.0138622085,
-0.0569787994,
-0.0039888243,
-0.0095873075,
0.0347016715,
0.0004624039,
0.085899815,
0.0098221656,
0.041191265,
0.0016349918,
0.0658881068,
-0.0133814774,
0.0459072739,
0.0751240402,
-0.014845592,
0.0235083867,
0.0289742071,
-0.0215376131,
0.030175684,
-0.0626136884,
0.0176245756,
-0.0084206844,
0.0069280351,
-0.0255027302,
-0.0552719906,
-0.0206035543,
-0.0143896416,
0.0054032286,
-0.0340001658,
0.0395529233,
0.022286186,
-0.0185451359,
0.018133251,
-0.0220317692,
-0.040057715,
-0.0484425575,
-0.0899683312,
0.0323359035,
0.0453941897,
0.0548400246,
-0.051393643,
0.0167588815,
0.0208753049,
-0.0286410972,
0.0562055968,
0.0200381763,
-0.0101490915,
-0.0563699901,
-0.0428198464,
0.0064961361,
-0.010202392,
0.030893309,
0.0206760075,
-0.0116782514,
0.0126489401,
0.001096793,
0.0053839725,
-0.0554462522,
0.0434796475,
0.0013985818,
-0.0215244722,
0.0099530993,
0.0084614996,
0.0504764393,
0.0035067988,
0.0096829487,
0.039983239,
0.0297695957,
-0.0178313479,
-0.0392270386,
-0.0088953953,
-0.0116896685,
0.0167017765,
0.0186086558,
-0.0123404879,
0.0019504814,
0.035577815,
-0.0305665955,
-0.0448563322,
0.0638445914,
-0.0127537046,
0.04080851,
-0.0417220034,
0.0083033228,
0.0007811193,
-0.0245606508,
-0.0085832011,
0.0786490217,
-0.0278684199,
-0.0015717415,
0.0411899462,
-0.035079591,
0.02047869,
-0.0330495425,
-0.0665463209,
-0.006511583,
0.0141660795,
0.0363309011,
0.014299565,
0.0275308825,
0.0041018152,
-0.0231779702,
-0.0730767921,
-0.0054955576,
-0.041934479,
0.0079530878,
-0.0050419578,
0.003085121,
-0.009949334,
0.0002401299,
-0.0219305735,
0.0276256483,
0.0590447932,
0.0008958689,
0.0496032126,
0.0174133908,
-0.0269480832,
-0.040336512,
-0.0186110828,
-0.0435081646,
0.0314141512,
0.0114818662,
-0.0436821617,
-0.0610871464,
0.050794851,
-0.058304552,
0.0542732626,
-0.0210134294,
-0.0397815555,
0.0351845175,
-0.0590910837,
0.0189897101,
0.0874892473,
-0.0177333374,
0.0217542667,
0.0634469539,
0.0104039153,
-0.0440439917,
0.0203120634,
0.0036425521,
-0.0072009368,
0.0305747893,
-0.0321774557,
0.0148238679,
0.0891363621,
0.0318311863,
-0.0139653301,
-0.040108718,
0.0169875585,
-0.0051187496,
-0.0243365578,
-0.0051651108,
-0.0397689901,
-0.037350487,
0.0587203093,
-0.0133498274,
-0.0757403597,
0.0822881907,
-0.0220736936,
0.0175096095,
-0.0150775099,
0.0025391066,
-0.0463500954,
0.0874712318,
0.0280437637,
-0.0024727206,
0.0084542315,
-0.0048732515,
-0.0210157968,
0.0266206842,
-0.0280868094,
-0.0218195803,
0.0451092049,
-0.0659628883,
0.0145599274,
0.0098149013,
-0.0146053964,
-0.0530093722,
0.0328206308,
-0.0651437119,
0.0190925263,
0.0496134833,
0.0145744197,
-0.0339506939,
0.0022322654,
0.01134104,
0.0266479887,
-0.0040855384,
-0.0090220692,
-0.0293464977,
-0.0361333042,
0.0263924655,
-0.0193378888,
-0.0091711758,
0.0104312627,
0.0245011337,
0.0460482016,
0.0324435085,
0.0187193491,
-0.0423216596,
-0.0075329677,
0.036170207,
-0.0234892908,
-0.0172444955,
0.0381567888,
0.0189931616,
-0.0430669673,
-0.0293758158,
0.1185859367,
0.0573099852,
-0.0530499294,
0.0033246726,
-0.0265147705,
0.0386005417,
0.036083784,
0.0376875028,
-0.1163021252,
-0.0084166406,
-0.0076244189,
0.0090691224,
-0.0221101493,
-0.0164943431,
0.022052899,
-0.1112548336,
0.0243001934,
0.0025701735,
-0.015575734,
-0.0121736024,
0.0014275698,
-0.0181789789,
0.0205314476,
-0.059575446,
-0.0077968212,
0.0055206344,
0.0123638082,
-0.004488911,
-0.0305882916,
-0.0094515365,
0.0316269584,
-0.0136464322,
0.0493768528,
0.1035742536,
0.0270791464,
-0.0082768891,
-0.0604046471,
0.0281141233,
0.0282303151,
0.0018574268,
-0.0124528632,
0.0113005135,
0.0013947303,
-0.023013154,
-0.0160887428,
0.0383785963,
-0.0507859066,
-0.0036519924,
0.0230940338,
0.1048303396,
-0.0438788086,
-0.0506176651,
-0.0497956797,
-0.003562357,
0.0462388061,
0.0795361102,
0.0183735751,
-0.0292337388,
-0.0397631228,
-0.068477042,
0.0156495422,
-0.0611932762,
-0.0609348714,
-0.0301253069,
0.0331423469,
0.0172103345,
-0.0683597773,
-0.0323430561,
0.0447737388,
0.0064273383,
0.0134725245,
-0.0624439679,
0.0252065789,
-0.0351586565,
-0.0253092404,
-0.0163451638,
-0.0297328588,
0.0152401906,
-0.0699603334,
-0.0404557362,
0.0160678718,
0.0044836551,
-0.0229569133,
0.0505567901,
-0.1000184566,
-0.0760104805,
0.0041285702,
0.0970131829,
0.0336306393,
-0.0100984899,
-0.0343641415,
-0.0285617691,
0.0355575196,
-0.0100661162,
-0.0318431221,
0.0178167373,
0.0187511817,
-0.000087581,
0.0270519741,
0.0500257798,
-0.0258716755,
0.029644927,
-0.0204353109,
0.0192931276,
-0.0181171726,
-0.0505488291,
0.0129629346,
0.0396771394,
0.0211349167,
-0.0015463762,
0.0057732412,
-0.0173872691,
-0.0177092887,
-0.0437331647,
-0.0369735509,
-0.0561416037,
0.037505541,
-0.0038222342,
-0.0047803791,
-0.0041493997,
0.0083768554,
-0.0287571959,
0.0133003043,
-0.0296570808,
-0.0063922983,
0.0138802864,
0.045863267,
0.0199066289,
-0.0033081658,
-0.0121689811,
0.0344791412,
-0.0211296473,
0.0266589858,
-0.0066853873,
0.0414013527,
0.0206731968,
0.0444492735,
-0.0329734683,
-0.0077680047,
-0.0569644533,
-0.0781861842,
0.01309969,
0.051462803,
0.0458415411,
0.0174084883,
0.0123982839,
-0.0562646762,
0.0037452239,
0.0041856766,
0.0194028486,
0.0073721423,
-0.0540964454,
-0.0044153472,
0.0205297191,
-0.0025424473,
-0.0394060686,
0.0842559487,
-0.0261192415,
0.0214285683,
0.0152983489,
-0.0160412937,
-0.051099997,
-0.0255054645,
-0.0073932773,
0.0344966315,
-0.0207215864,
-0.0175985154,
-0.0623048283,
-0.0756090954,
0.044698894,
0.0531076118,
0.0324841961,
-0.0234011393,
0.044772815,
0.0760581717,
0.0243932661,
0.0001629631,
-0.0387128443,
0.0299603175,
-0.0275888238,
-0.0559866838,
-0.033746127,
-6.787386666e-33,
-0.0367739126,
-0.0201581307,
0.0204177871,
0.0383636281,
0.0214783344,
-0.0114271548,
-0.0505071133,
0.0365635753,
-0.0171945095,
0.0053715068,
-0.0045304159,
0.0276786778,
-0.0014779697,
0.0182179436,
0.0264658444,
0.0209778007,
-0.0148803163,
-0.0705932453,
-0.0236097444,
-0.0178516246,
0.0313444771,
-0.0177296363,
0.0036555503,
-0.0257693566,
0.0488805957,
-0.0185054038,
-0.0394755974,
-0.0017363786,
-0.0343454704,
0.057967525,
-0.0471834578,
0.0236268323,
0.0211518947,
0.0241964236,
-0.0105784023,
0.0386733375,
-0.0283699632,
-0.0417540856,
0.0304682478,
0.0042937952,
-0.074148044,
-0.0298927873,
0.0418833196,
-0.02427678,
-0.0481134243,
0.0421150401,
0.0234969649,
-0.0319950543,
0.006331766,
-0.0258007646,
-0.0693322495,
-0.0243167281,
0.0062876586,
0.0063953595,
0.0051838947,
-0.0268482827,
-0.0096452376,
0.0368999355,
-0.0530241616,
0.0156612452,
0.027581634,
0.0260319654,
0.056286186,
0.0037526486,
0.0141118392,
0.0305774715,
-0.0163711291,
0.0046728877,
-0.0887466222,
0.0306107886,
0.021738261,
0.0126524968,
0.0063374541,
-0.0139418878,
0.0078716343,
-0.0137836039,
-0.0469276048,
0.0225356631,
0.0181801654,
0.0401204415,
0.0248692371,
0.0072505488,
-0.0529791601,
-0.0238702819,
-0.014256849,
-0.0559374392,
-0.042793382,
-0.0016856855,
0.0031242238,
-0.0064074588,
-0.0223702714,
-0.0447142348,
0.0082740569,
-0.0524858683,
0.0018671131,
0.0044642352,
-0.0386779048,
0.0358705632,
-0.0005593806,
0.0209943987,
-0.0709298328,
-0.0008652245,
-0.0280449502,
0.021197658,
0.0428250059,
0.0477692671,
-0.0078422008,
0.0307349805,
-0.0503513664,
-0.0031952872,
-0.0517229661,
0.0385188721,
0.0165585056,
0.0121555803,
0.0086203469,
-0.0136778792,
0.0126248486,
0.0291491449,
-0.0062741213,
-0.0212706216,
-0.0346660651,
0.0301726535,
-0.0026601665,
0.0212334767,
-0.0435275026,
-0.0260648038,
-0.0458810292,
0.0338374339,
0.0540610217,
-0.0315960795,
-0.010705635,
0.0392553434,
3.059e-7,
0.0405989327,
0.029181052,
0.0300685484,
0.1019794494,
0.0212225653,
0.0319545716,
-0.0000618973,
0.022090774,
0.0396703072,
-0.0190020129,
-0.0123983296,
0.0435140058,
-0.0030868195,
0.0082143648,
-0.0839734972,
0.0181597471,
-0.0280710384,
-0.0050428249,
-0.0345885381,
-0.0220664144,
0.0133635169,
0.0551227182,
0.0240369309,
0.0199847687,
-0.0317301191,
-0.0384873599,
0.0713329688,
0.0210563224,
-0.0028787493,
0.0449519716,
0.0240370687,
0.0531005897,
-0.0366066992,
-0.0144663276,
0.0252059326,
0.0180895273,
0.023521889,
0.0504366942,
0.016932575,
-0.0024589107,
0.0001439096,
-0.0347122736,
0.0120815123,
-0.0188204646,
0.0538281314,
-0.0362342447,
-0.0180078615,
-0.0114023387,
0.0265057087,
0.0067288582,
0.0113476431,
-0.0046424479,
-0.0102501251,
-0.0028402212,
-0.0042075715,
-0.0070491764,
0.0020590094,
-0.0481204391,
-0.0189539175,
-0.0451383181,
-0.033546295,
-0.0247789118,
-0.0397815183,
-0.0108049931,
-0.007247048,
-0.0693882331,
0.0141507182,
3.04876674e-34,
0.0419267416,
-0.0038773175,
0.0062588472,
0.0271189474,
0.0316746198,
0.0019502103,
-0.0240502059,
0.0316633992,
0.0275426842,
-0.0798300356,
-0.0568041839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10193v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10193v2 | Conformal Language Modeling | 2023-06-16T21:55:08 | 2024-06-01T21:40:33 | Victor Quach, Adam Fisch, Tal Schuster, Adam Yala, Jae Ho Sohn, Tommi S. Jaakkola, Regina Barzilay | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We propose a novel approach to conformal prediction for generative language
models (LMs). Standard conformal prediction produces prediction sets -- in
place of single predictions -- that have rigorous, statistical performance
guarantees. LM responses are typically sampled from the model's predicted
distribution over the large, combinatorial output space of natural language.
Translating this process to conformal prediction, we calibrate a stopping rule
for sampling different outputs from the LM that get added to a growing set of
candidates until we are confident that the output set is sufficient. Since some
samples may be low-quality, we also simultaneously calibrate and apply a
rejection rule for removing candidates from the output set to reduce noise.
Similar to conformal prediction, we prove that the sampled set returned by our
procedure contains at least one acceptable answer with high probability, while
still being empirically precise (i.e., small) on average. Furthermore, within
this set of candidate responses, we show that we can also accurately identify
subsets of individual components -- such as phrases or sentences -- that are
each independently correct (e.g., that are not "hallucinations"), again with
statistical guarantees. We demonstrate the promise of our approach on multiple
tasks in open-domain question answering, text summarization, and radiology
report generation using different LM variants. | [
0.0501608327,
0.0431867354,
0.0047970377,
-0.0007958699,
-0.0313348025,
-0.0031872403,
-0.0260822065,
0.018029023,
-0.0116871921,
-0.0180325191,
0.0093925549,
-0.1108365655,
0.0112212393,
0.0145973917,
0.0259826872,
-0.0677185357,
0.0020424353,
-0.030405255,
0.0108662006,
-0.0370152071,
-0.0044442886,
0.0083182687,
0.0178763755,
0.0360529348,
0.0079216873,
-0.0141312936,
0.0371739008,
-0.0034675535,
-0.0034807716,
0.029625684,
0.0158961713,
0.0838891417,
0.0122949006,
0.0173995979,
0.0000020769,
-0.0055115996,
-0.033114858,
0.0102132168,
0.0344427489,
0.0040045092,
0.037949685,
-0.0346315429,
0.0057064677,
0.0536241271,
-0.0485650636,
-0.0201390199,
0.0401878245,
0.0448631495,
0.0359468237,
0.0596854948,
-0.0049387445,
-0.0361332446,
0.0392203741,
-0.0368345901,
0.021545263,
-0.0054612504,
0.0243954249,
-0.0093656834,
-0.0012450435,
-0.0143223582,
-0.0360750183,
0.0374845304,
0.0117516732,
0.0203782581,
0.0056532314,
0.0725364089,
-0.0043539954,
-0.0104170227,
0.0234146491,
0.0408065319,
-0.0243965723,
-0.0577553436,
0.0011402746,
-0.009155808,
-0.0352122858,
0.0413490348,
-0.0739876404,
0.0529804863,
-0.0027760761,
0.0463664159,
0.0034497031,
-0.0018362878,
-0.0051263548,
-0.0067665167,
-0.0252946913,
0.0158537254,
0.0465663597,
-0.037397638,
-0.0315442868,
0.02586817,
-0.0527660884,
-0.0737724751,
-0.0279470943,
0.0241118986,
-0.0430591404,
0.0082589071,
-0.0707510635,
-0.0126055963,
0.0481441095,
-0.0385900848,
0.0249011666,
0.0012314377,
0.0328989252,
0.0476508625,
-0.0214784145,
0.0553139485,
-0.0098101804,
0.0270312857,
-0.0685495064,
-0.0293996539,
-0.0140934577,
-0.0263502039,
-0.0039275414,
0.0097700348,
-0.0622485355,
-0.0360029228,
-0.050800316,
0.0078269225,
0.0181967113,
-0.0153964609,
0.0509610437,
0.0638668612,
-0.037671566,
-0.0262349006,
-0.0193471536,
0.0392132811,
-0.0270128399,
0.0003277763,
-0.0099746911,
-0.0652537793,
-0.0203895103,
0.0362564176,
0.0039785276,
-0.0044719195,
-0.0014825459,
0.0579922386,
-0.0236120652,
-0.0166011825,
0.0163331889,
-0.0322279669,
-0.0208036359,
-0.0492563918,
0.0484728515,
-0.0878504962,
0.0129947346,
0.0292497184,
0.0084141092,
-0.046234291,
0.0073086377,
0.041687347,
-0.0268856958,
0.0406678021,
0.0215852391,
0.0313769504,
0.0152787082,
0.0024847356,
0.0419482216,
0.0471227765,
0.0251817983,
0.0241106302,
0.0212317184,
-0.0004302305,
0.0601256043,
0.0220269989,
-0.0020163364,
-0.0171356946,
-0.0128146103,
0.0119030522,
0.0378328152,
0.0080283219,
0.0066046021,
0.0885008797,
0.0004584623,
-0.0252055582,
0.0675562322,
0.039722912,
0.0165033694,
-0.0330943726,
0.0281144101,
-0.0210415255,
-0.0054939403,
0.0656406358,
-0.0374322496,
0.0329567641,
-0.0273035932,
0.0290709753,
0.054985296,
0.0157780517,
-0.0341758505,
-0.0328158475,
-0.0188388508,
-0.0042307386,
-0.0084087057,
-0.0114416676,
0.044125665,
0.0167816319,
-0.0647130981,
0.022247402,
0.0545160249,
-0.0261534248,
0.0289769489,
-0.0422099754,
0.0620126985,
0.0480922535,
0.068530798,
-0.0035787995,
0.0187369101,
0.0056832437,
0.0334225632,
0.0496100076,
0.0480645075,
0.0184641555,
0.0187909417,
-0.0457458198,
-0.0166435782,
0.0386537127,
0.0316324122,
0.0214187242,
0.0523813963,
-0.0325592607,
-0.009655267,
-0.0615128726,
-0.0356201716,
0.0384735353,
-0.0469448753,
-0.0450261831,
0.0233993623,
-0.0123853944,
0.0104209874,
-0.0021696251,
-0.024534734,
0.0457554534,
0.0442582481,
-0.059395358,
-0.0561318994,
-0.0269547626,
-0.0349015668,
0.0100952387,
0.0139548331,
-0.0713669285,
0.0214523841,
0.0066244905,
-0.016728377,
-0.0599518903,
0.0270138364,
-0.050343845,
0.042442441,
-0.059552893,
-0.0079594981,
0.0534508899,
0.0371989086,
-0.0370960534,
0.0676037446,
-0.0122577474,
0.0485843457,
0.0135562886,
-0.0163247883,
-0.0080702407,
-0.0194600597,
-0.0653264523,
-0.0115606589,
-0.0219977275,
0.0367152989,
0.0378137454,
-0.0138516556,
-0.0024475961,
-0.0658363178,
-0.0423654467,
0.005415407,
-0.0174441282,
-0.0048504197,
0.0127199311,
0.0085409172,
-0.002781892,
-0.0005752731,
-0.0425685979,
-0.047164727,
0.0636971369,
0.0308310315,
0.0132441577,
0.0022963544,
0.0019031846,
-0.0187095739,
-0.0201127399,
-0.0010548151,
0.0360406227,
0.0101283034,
0.0483324043,
-0.048852466,
0.0306975618,
-0.041713465,
0.0367554836,
-0.0071919467,
-0.0299708173,
-0.0103401178,
-0.044080928,
0.0466025621,
0.0431387238,
0.0391867943,
-0.0184683073,
0.0277194194,
0.0227237754,
-0.0128469039,
-0.0259101205,
-0.0872254074,
-0.0049346644,
0.0096277222,
-0.0808469206,
0.0153301414,
0.0350312106,
0.0593733266,
-0.0089811087,
-0.0837936774,
0.0087935487,
-0.0081376461,
-0.0042854999,
-0.0156932492,
0.0265891925,
-0.0333147496,
0.0398711637,
-0.0128943427,
-0.0484819338,
0.0747350901,
-0.0432582907,
0.0183758121,
-0.0170783531,
-0.0051619033,
-0.0285425447,
0.0271007158,
0.0432822779,
0.0122300396,
0.0519149527,
-0.0078832079,
-0.0626875833,
0.0165262613,
0.0287820641,
-0.0492057353,
0.0481903665,
-0.0306110587,
0.0002639614,
0.0054154098,
-0.019067809,
-0.0512555577,
-0.0440927073,
0.0045536929,
0.0344632156,
0.0207839273,
-0.013411575,
-0.0570020191,
0.0250427946,
-0.0182316396,
0.0250133183,
-0.0484623462,
0.0066902987,
-0.0196620189,
0.0449615754,
0.1067823693,
-0.0017483479,
0.0004520011,
-0.0727756396,
-0.0157147534,
0.0735490024,
0.0068448698,
0.0305970963,
-0.0022696818,
-0.0420380197,
0.0259464309,
-0.0077932402,
-0.0187578909,
0.0356005765,
0.0541434102,
0.0076512666,
-0.0171614829,
0.1373276263,
0.0275813583,
-0.0190724302,
-0.0190086607,
0.0427617989,
0.039051719,
0.0119789233,
0.03388514,
-0.0336890258,
-0.0111690396,
-0.009689237,
0.0462914333,
-0.0002758971,
-0.0188171808,
-0.0080883764,
-0.1030599773,
0.0400786959,
-0.0089157941,
-0.0371933021,
-0.0767138675,
-0.0270307735,
-0.0057248161,
-0.0281425118,
-0.0267045125,
-0.0108116604,
-0.0151336733,
0.0089165252,
0.0376960747,
-0.0423997156,
-0.0223655645,
0.0086408835,
-0.0403153561,
0.0241124071,
0.0733427033,
0.0141617954,
0.0070731766,
-0.0431712307,
-0.0136466185,
-0.0356899127,
-0.0022202495,
0.0029940782,
0.0408274941,
0.0357643589,
0.0002748642,
-0.0129455887,
0.0421232097,
-0.0448004007,
-0.0161516219,
-0.0067989528,
0.075954929,
-0.0108991964,
-0.0660706833,
-0.0324170627,
0.0710796639,
0.0093021188,
0.1068735868,
0.028470099,
-0.0316831358,
-0.0322509706,
-0.0371830352,
0.0560596362,
-0.0443933792,
-0.0054285764,
-0.040227443,
0.0409146138,
-0.0258615464,
-0.1039662957,
0.0144391684,
0.0179800875,
0.0141606908,
-0.0120019093,
0.0147878155,
-0.0292892922,
-0.0074636308,
0.0199643429,
-0.021124782,
-0.0354869403,
0.0006342807,
-0.0730506703,
-0.0190353729,
0.0331843793,
-0.049523782,
-0.0569358729,
0.0344649889,
-0.0941402465,
-0.077925846,
-0.0046223467,
0.0576186776,
0.0274496172,
0.0256257672,
-0.0194021333,
-0.0539140478,
0.0302532837,
0.0532852188,
0.0088538472,
0.0454676934,
-0.0128476266,
-0.0364795215,
-0.0015678209,
0.0286188461,
-0.0127563765,
0.0384084284,
0.0138115697,
0.0276700929,
-0.0156002836,
-0.0623301305,
0.0237217676,
0.0132761542,
0.0160309896,
-0.015663024,
0.0006598852,
-0.0322293341,
-0.0163355879,
0.0050868802,
-0.0041639763,
-0.0268583652,
0.0029109782,
0.0221728887,
-0.017412113,
-0.022569906,
0.0371359549,
-0.0243068058,
0.0468249209,
-0.0586800985,
-0.0433048904,
0.0061089704,
-0.0114233922,
0.0232751686,
-0.0060352311,
-0.0040815943,
-0.0056803613,
-0.016224511,
0.0476841591,
0.0094538974,
0.0284814667,
-0.003150786,
0.0266785529,
-0.0283493791,
-0.0234562531,
-0.1042480916,
-0.0318913087,
-0.0705841333,
0.0636884123,
0.0126558607,
0.0043627545,
0.0291941818,
-0.0410246737,
-0.0086463494,
-0.0405539088,
0.0365981385,
0.0325458646,
0.0012907115,
0.0304714404,
0.0120393904,
0.0036050905,
-0.0375573076,
0.1201854721,
-0.0254713763,
0.0389066674,
-0.0195613857,
-0.0163784195,
-0.048504211,
-0.0336378999,
-0.0254164096,
-0.0082455855,
-0.0101737175,
0.0196394064,
-0.0500437692,
-0.037643943,
0.0546037592,
0.03060578,
0.0090633864,
-0.0205908604,
0.0329834595,
0.0613955893,
-0.0061409082,
0.0220298525,
-0.0456313528,
0.0189330354,
0.0041408488,
0.0014002727,
-0.0300389249,
-6.776018901e-33,
-0.0177805331,
-0.0084140403,
0.0082023609,
-0.0080427611,
0.012409782,
-0.0223162789,
-0.022947168,
-0.0075219912,
0.0207080748,
0.0144012282,
-0.0214838907,
0.0003799297,
0.0038800121,
0.0609755069,
-0.0079391701,
-0.0037759079,
0.0489671119,
-0.0315174386,
-0.0430508032,
0.0253863968,
0.0393289775,
0.0195638519,
0.0342945829,
-0.0239643641,
0.0067466134,
-0.0261170957,
-0.03115068,
0.0307669286,
-0.0080011711,
0.0600534193,
-0.0197394621,
0.0247385353,
0.0131934164,
-0.0545621999,
-0.0244263001,
0.0077618286,
-0.0407556817,
-0.0115871392,
0.0264870599,
-0.0425890759,
-0.013734092,
-0.0129582603,
0.0289097354,
-0.0235109366,
-0.0000517483,
-0.0414515324,
0.05319364,
-0.0202907827,
-0.0455439389,
0.0073016053,
-0.0199014898,
0.0204734728,
0.0269977916,
-0.0432512909,
-0.062087439,
0.0748137683,
0.0003390941,
0.0192890689,
-0.0140176518,
0.0490326956,
0.0539566912,
0.0403110906,
0.0225313231,
-0.0080133136,
0.0005007407,
0.0631643832,
0.0159372576,
-0.0598695874,
-0.0465706959,
-0.0479915254,
-0.0159259457,
0.0083663492,
0.0248380657,
0.0375639871,
0.0222168397,
-0.0106068663,
-0.0430292599,
0.0576915853,
-0.0440806597,
0.0140163638,
0.0696195588,
-0.0327387005,
-0.0424527936,
-0.0353289507,
-0.0149681177,
-0.0137648433,
-0.0193538219,
0.0040451572,
0.0073827845,
0.0502307564,
-0.0509843901,
-0.0414191708,
0.0275392774,
-0.0506791137,
0.044463519,
0.0153502543,
-0.020571623,
-0.0003262846,
-0.0061925123,
0.0017599222,
-0.0270578675,
0.0280554425,
0.0489769205,
-0.0213596635,
-0.050707154,
0.0214922596,
0.0290512517,
0.0024225239,
-0.0675576255,
0.0175463501,
-0.0403206982,
0.0238687601,
-0.0123085333,
0.0254905391,
0.0356370024,
0.0250380952,
-0.0087638069,
0.0057633729,
-0.0308412965,
0.0360312052,
-0.0352442041,
-0.0142258331,
0.0263388716,
0.0149744488,
-0.0469597802,
0.0139597282,
-0.0293902848,
-0.0216534957,
0.0213526022,
-0.0225177556,
-0.0255198982,
0.037818417,
2.745e-7,
0.0775025785,
0.0240566917,
0.0133931879,
0.0259861778,
0.0249067377,
0.0014099776,
0.0116017414,
0.0311195645,
0.0332757421,
0.0273299627,
-0.0166342072,
0.0168826822,
0.0438383669,
0.0223750398,
-0.1005568877,
0.013980669,
-0.0772186443,
0.0122724148,
0.0138744628,
-0.0392447226,
0.0384483375,
0.1127796099,
-0.0013508094,
-0.0256591868,
-0.0031512522,
0.0117596909,
0.0807449147,
-0.0140059032,
-0.0227917153,
0.0015232567,
0.0144777987,
0.0012878656,
0.0183596741,
0.0097953072,
-0.0306579694,
-0.0310900509,
0.0403366722,
0.0689142048,
0.0183953289,
-0.0501139686,
0.0007755855,
-0.0032827947,
0.000174175,
-0.0213973019,
0.0744590312,
-0.0484416708,
-0.0022176146,
-0.0421464369,
-0.0368477926,
0.0109265121,
0.0277353041,
-0.0276661143,
-0.0429026671,
0.0273629576,
0.0066638682,
0.0324290693,
0.0011562511,
-0.0163811129,
-0.0127790114,
-0.0327904969,
-0.0766668767,
-0.0217261538,
-0.0000901783,
-0.0104529979,
-0.007959974,
-0.0563382246,
-0.0088084685,
2.843189538e-34,
0.0403185263,
0.0244368482,
-0.0259339903,
-0.0224874802,
0.0038352818,
-0.0150954509,
0.0321097486,
0.0106963897,
0.0244218409,
-0.1123517752,
-0.0421461798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10169v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10169v1 | Meta-Personalizing Vision-Language Models to Find Named Instances in Video | 2023-06-16T20:12:11 | 2023-06-16T20:12:11 | Chun-Hsiao Yeh, Bryan Russell, Josef Sivic, Fabian Caba Heilbron, Simon Jenni | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large-scale vision-language models (VLM) have shown impressive results for
language-guided search applications. While these models allow category-level
queries, they currently struggle with personalized searches for moments in a
video where a specific object instance such as ``My dog Biscuit'' appears. We
present the following three contributions to address this problem. First, we
describe a method to meta-personalize a pre-trained VLM, i.e., learning how to
learn to personalize a VLM at test time to search in video. Our method extends
the VLM's token vocabulary by learning novel word embeddings specific to each
instance. To capture only instance-specific features, we represent each
instance embedding as a combination of shared and learned global category
features. Second, we propose to learn such personalization without explicit
human supervision. Our approach automatically identifies moments of named
visual instances in video using transcripts and vision-language similarity in
the VLM's embedding space. Finally, we introduce This-Is-My, a personal video
instance retrieval benchmark. We evaluate our approach on This-Is-My and
DeepFashion2 and show that we obtain a 15% relative improvement over the state
of the art on the latter dataset. | [
0.0283697415,
0.0345083252,
0.0129959472,
0.02850236,
-0.0081972117,
-0.0177600812,
0.0474311337,
-0.0107032461,
-0.0139761958,
-0.0653434396,
-0.0324889496,
-0.0072443415,
-0.0705634505,
0.0284074116,
0.0135649275,
-0.0498781949,
0.040071141,
0.0067353747,
-0.0033200895,
0.0176569112,
0.0220597312,
-0.0112933321,
0.0240336657,
0.0426543206,
-0.0707530826,
0.0028921899,
-0.0158592649,
0.0084664952,
0.0376001894,
-0.0238641016,
-0.0075874249,
0.0372069627,
0.0643649325,
0.000098903,
0.0000018672,
-0.0215656962,
0.0015974687,
-0.0276000611,
0.0317946896,
0.0019527595,
0.0258949213,
0.0044404091,
0.0246544871,
-0.004076153,
-0.0323597379,
-0.0606654994,
0.0574919805,
-0.0161658134,
0.0023085531,
0.0349543057,
-0.0385476053,
-0.0131785916,
-0.0136709521,
-0.0083210338,
0.0584382042,
-0.023449786,
-0.0034566813,
-0.036613863,
-0.0009463916,
0.0105209248,
-0.051526133,
0.0556245744,
0.0266085025,
-0.0222624391,
0.065028578,
0.0216211248,
-0.1033244655,
-0.0166150294,
0.0137740411,
0.0492470451,
-0.0461122021,
-0.0182739403,
-0.0186560005,
-0.0024020255,
0.0059248847,
0.0046503278,
-0.0316971801,
0.0173803698,
0.0208778232,
-0.0000537322,
-0.0436476544,
0.0302703083,
0.0070166425,
-0.0029786259,
0.0079946714,
-0.006863568,
0.0401003808,
0.0043437593,
-0.0433090404,
-0.0161833782,
-0.022150835,
-0.0129498895,
0.0053272066,
0.0036183225,
0.00375309,
-0.0245254803,
-0.0532116443,
0.031277515,
-0.0335450247,
-0.0504241288,
0.0636179075,
0.0092035942,
-0.0656644106,
0.0604875535,
-0.0224856921,
0.0452394038,
-0.0104373414,
0.0244909525,
-0.0551533438,
-0.043152906,
-0.0521687642,
0.015878126,
-0.0462661684,
0.016056193,
-0.0210514106,
-0.0283123273,
0.0124930106,
0.0348394625,
-0.0197537635,
-0.0053423787,
-0.0268895328,
0.0360481441,
-0.0007534018,
-0.0232650712,
-0.0010021362,
-0.0140124178,
-0.0462130718,
-0.0146287316,
-0.0235539749,
-0.0563941374,
0.0065096365,
0.0343885235,
0.0414229333,
-0.0203251336,
0.0196149219,
0.0429896377,
-0.0277511869,
-0.1015086174,
0.0107352175,
0.0060894261,
-0.0295591019,
0.0373849943,
0.0062381574,
-0.0725816041,
0.0167161617,
-0.0549442768,
0.0000068606,
-0.0107247615,
0.0195440277,
-0.0029821002,
0.0088881934,
0.0883366093,
0.0036495638,
0.0197548866,
0.0065621557,
-0.0107638622,
0.0581641793,
0.0244125966,
0.0090295793,
0.0718058944,
0.0502039269,
0.002764995,
0.081172213,
0.0188162662,
-0.033784803,
0.016420586,
-0.1093701944,
-0.0038606944,
-0.0071384083,
0.0362767987,
0.0220510382,
0.0286056604,
0.0127082095,
-0.0489443094,
0.0156940799,
0.0661774874,
-0.017788725,
-0.0127986297,
0.0399629846,
0.0082186526,
-0.0253945552,
-0.0310641006,
-0.0230002385,
0.0723864064,
0.0022126695,
-0.0369451568,
0.0190494079,
0.0052617206,
-0.0963239074,
-0.0203568675,
0.0124822259,
-0.0042204768,
-0.0091668786,
0.0480505675,
0.0167983677,
-0.016182309,
-0.0042275679,
0.0225836504,
0.0082744686,
-0.0307925791,
0.0370576195,
-0.0421190485,
0.006714398,
0.0932531133,
0.0299872477,
-0.0183508936,
0.0058766734,
0.0126504116,
0.0346744396,
0.0115883742,
-0.0097450307,
-0.0352957025,
0.0443934277,
-0.0303371176,
-0.032337226,
0.003740665,
0.0128106242,
0.0409417041,
0.016867511,
0.0318662748,
0.0437095873,
-0.0263774954,
-0.0084193498,
0.0485695563,
0.0255975034,
-0.0337320305,
0.0328034312,
0.0482338741,
-0.0277830381,
-0.014151725,
-0.0101611633,
0.0044720462,
0.0423105359,
-0.0247790739,
0.0146155981,
0.0359756202,
-0.0055682864,
-0.0014804746,
0.041735366,
-0.06094639,
0.0372260734,
0.0160223171,
-0.0012757409,
-0.0208796728,
0.0055628237,
-0.0107072778,
0.0481064394,
-0.0596950576,
0.0222243592,
-0.0144460322,
0.0115544004,
-0.0504237078,
0.0057823709,
-0.022782838,
-0.0144247012,
-0.0625404716,
0.0077504599,
0.010514087,
-0.0599875338,
-0.0614979789,
-0.0030522239,
0.0039517567,
0.0343218446,
0.0616837107,
-0.0128811104,
-0.0443588868,
-0.0177132078,
-0.0823720843,
-0.0221844129,
-0.0072933328,
-0.0336892009,
-0.0273071844,
-0.0057976837,
-0.0042876452,
-0.0566204749,
-0.0038134947,
-0.0011578569,
-0.0337992795,
0.0447841994,
0.0259050988,
0.0307644084,
-0.0081161568,
-0.0547537953,
-0.0367508195,
0.0282719005,
0.0357481949,
-0.0111766048,
0.0076517789,
0.02184508,
-0.0092741782,
-0.0170345884,
0.0582094118,
-0.0084379194,
-0.0249203518,
0.0113615831,
-0.0564046688,
0.007070519,
0.086058639,
0.0402490683,
0.0198115986,
0.0168538168,
-0.0064326343,
-0.0492648929,
0.0117161982,
-0.0215626992,
-0.0577885509,
0.0050468897,
0.0108808875,
0.0048142467,
-0.0189382359,
-0.0319754668,
0.0020213076,
-0.0909463242,
0.0335144214,
0.0365265496,
-0.0491418578,
-0.0439874232,
0.0300522484,
0.0278737936,
0.0073166532,
-0.0180407707,
-0.0727838352,
0.0230766553,
0.0132416589,
-0.0037937069,
0.0601720251,
-0.0219766479,
-0.0351805575,
0.1094503105,
0.0277747735,
0.011162214,
-0.0521097779,
-0.0294693559,
-0.0598238446,
-0.0135486443,
0.0068103471,
-0.0061304923,
0.0398682542,
0.0113875726,
-0.0006691627,
0.0211631674,
-0.0212955624,
-0.0465433076,
-0.0368066877,
-0.0177314095,
-0.0255583841,
-0.0566216968,
-0.013791699,
-0.0627470613,
0.0218363386,
0.0058720051,
0.0178560838,
-0.0007489917,
0.0019638843,
0.0078109489,
-0.0170894712,
0.0757710412,
-0.0266474281,
-0.0483061522,
0.0250255093,
0.0035905868,
0.0128899785,
0.0577982813,
0.0050924653,
-0.0557054281,
0.0046863616,
0.0320849866,
-0.002240594,
-0.0118237343,
0.0027740519,
0.018216148,
-0.0192922559,
-0.005166939,
0.0781031325,
0.0257365834,
-0.0536615402,
-0.0166487154,
-0.0023298552,
-0.0246642549,
0.0639642701,
0.0446691588,
-0.0668139383,
-0.0258290637,
-0.0154734869,
-0.0076334891,
0.0417146608,
0.0017806665,
-0.036950279,
-0.0878000334,
0.0234653689,
0.0140821133,
-0.0024856371,
-0.0434331633,
0.0295020808,
-0.0096446872,
-0.0469759218,
-0.0440008715,
0.0035782524,
-0.0177502446,
0.0185549539,
-0.0042080656,
0.041721873,
-0.0273227412,
0.0433518253,
-0.0638563782,
0.0248845611,
0.0293815285,
0.0227812212,
-0.0006539265,
-0.0824045837,
-0.0079558855,
-0.0163680483,
0.0022185612,
-0.007110327,
0.0160749946,
-0.0878343433,
-0.0395419523,
0.0020557733,
0.000385685,
0.0442058295,
-0.0262312293,
-0.0158046857,
0.0397246778,
-0.0192860495,
0.0113678938,
-0.079125993,
-0.0533365384,
0.008872957,
0.0582581423,
-0.0383769795,
-0.0421074964,
0.0387013517,
0.013593168,
-0.0194664467,
0.0122599984,
-0.0379254818,
-0.014664623,
0.0158880465,
-0.0011508995,
-0.0314351842,
-0.0019851215,
0.0725879744,
0.0350332595,
-0.011147893,
-0.0192726906,
-0.0499784797,
0.025806779,
-0.1124584898,
0.0753461719,
-0.036223121,
-0.0139331361,
-0.0581776276,
-0.0049811723,
0.0832471102,
-0.036520265,
-0.0107130716,
-0.007899072,
-0.0019144299,
-0.031069126,
-0.0314426981,
0.078929618,
-0.0011015531,
0.0616511554,
0.0146257235,
-0.0637953281,
0.0476891696,
0.059155263,
0.0140576381,
-0.0015189273,
0.0152965048,
-0.0286279805,
-0.0101324776,
0.0489146598,
-0.0300182831,
0.0278643817,
-0.0042186612,
0.0078712972,
-0.0207936466,
-0.0526645333,
0.0140830642,
-0.0355528668,
0.0807376131,
-0.0392943509,
0.0034953596,
-0.0454745814,
-0.0043543074,
0.0264676996,
0.0218632314,
-0.0706722587,
-0.004237073,
0.0225372389,
-0.0005609815,
-0.000254577,
0.0051301229,
-0.0232081991,
-0.0042659915,
-0.0163792986,
-0.0390885808,
-0.0163613893,
0.0103919106,
-0.0186042134,
0.0663181171,
0.0185624696,
0.0390513428,
-0.003385507,
0.032037016,
-0.0218965281,
-0.0168420393,
0.0018461662,
0.0048414231,
-0.0578647219,
0.0466939844,
0.0106159346,
-0.0184655078,
-0.0205620509,
0.0446974151,
0.047981564,
-0.0740701556,
-0.0446221344,
0.0060223695,
-0.0143462848,
-0.0405351259,
0.0156743787,
-0.0149049647,
-0.0502534918,
-0.0063127372,
0.04011558,
-0.0259161927,
-0.0042287637,
0.0575310625,
0.033198569,
0.022804508,
-0.0141142383,
0.0311748255,
-0.0072580012,
0.0218491871,
0.0654930323,
0.0367413722,
-0.0272478238,
0.0497713126,
-0.0188970938,
-0.0289125983,
-0.0159766991,
0.0123710716,
-0.0485060662,
0.0460524261,
0.0849796236,
0.0331044123,
0.011224458,
-0.0202771463,
-0.0015613254,
-0.0358163714,
0.0367778614,
-0.0411845259,
0.032312531,
-5.641745831e-33,
-0.0310963783,
-0.0136665413,
0.0377085954,
0.0383422785,
0.0112568885,
0.0036678896,
0.01562043,
0.0490481667,
-0.0186154153,
0.0045534489,
-0.0071340757,
0.0072119003,
0.0032904455,
0.0383168794,
0.0415885039,
-0.0244511142,
0.052535139,
0.007257808,
0.0283544008,
-0.0084522814,
0.0187091939,
0.0486473404,
0.0509797595,
-0.0633866712,
-0.0456378348,
0.0077593308,
-0.0095863966,
0.0338603407,
0.0593950115,
0.0723601654,
-0.0023635158,
-0.0122543992,
0.0018895938,
0.0257527977,
-0.0140754096,
-0.0301584303,
-0.0537955016,
-0.0066424883,
0.011442272,
0.0078848489,
-0.043285843,
-0.0323740095,
0.0341688357,
-0.044306919,
-0.0215280913,
0.0093362844,
0.039337948,
-0.0279001836,
-0.0218392797,
0.0097592333,
-0.0242575109,
0.003587126,
0.0086999694,
-0.0311817657,
0.0872247219,
-0.0452409238,
0.0362679102,
0.0019768747,
-0.009472183,
0.0312155429,
-0.0489316657,
0.0442422479,
0.0683848783,
0.0466587022,
0.0391162299,
0.0779145658,
0.0725125223,
-0.0596568584,
0.0309276134,
-0.0242231637,
0.0504003391,
0.0574321114,
0.0132915787,
0.0619489551,
0.0213887542,
-0.0208903439,
-0.0140268551,
0.002069294,
-0.0733219683,
0.0209079981,
0.0011412163,
0.0338117145,
-0.0081098843,
0.0160295852,
-0.0477461927,
-0.0163636077,
-0.0461414307,
-0.0254676957,
0.032318715,
0.0550037399,
-0.031627275,
-0.0167683456,
0.0551454127,
-0.0074706958,
0.0106321825,
0.0048380406,
-0.0087353922,
0.0169040747,
0.0209994148,
0.032619115,
-0.0200767443,
-0.0296195652,
0.0261690579,
-0.0512757525,
-0.0265347436,
0.0349825509,
0.0236592684,
0.0526734143,
-0.048055321,
0.0009131117,
0.0047189514,
-0.0374542177,
-0.0358212329,
0.0082185101,
0.0145848133,
0.0466689132,
-0.0345691592,
0.0465505272,
-0.0061693187,
-0.0063096071,
-0.0292768106,
-0.0425169729,
0.0230901521,
0.0249892157,
0.0115513429,
0.027639702,
-0.0747246966,
-0.0231194384,
0.0520972051,
-0.0259184577,
0.0023019819,
0.0144364834,
2.587e-7,
-0.0121713318,
0.0204801783,
0.0237077009,
0.0111809317,
-0.0050933105,
0.040966332,
0.0166406427,
0.0440837331,
0.0103212902,
-0.0054957275,
0.0202683099,
0.0377897546,
-0.0182938389,
-0.0493845008,
-0.0289027989,
0.0405595601,
-0.0031771746,
-0.0015492046,
-0.0561086237,
-0.0351294465,
-0.0393852964,
0.1372698694,
0.0576623902,
0.0205463842,
0.0211200621,
-0.0768405497,
0.064962551,
-0.0332007557,
-0.0346390046,
-0.0052784709,
-0.0355505422,
0.081489712,
-0.0359475724,
-0.0130271753,
-0.0052824025,
-0.0007092269,
0.0668939874,
0.0416997671,
-0.0510584041,
-0.0385303833,
-0.0293708015,
0.0328573659,
-0.0310802553,
-0.007032692,
0.0666649193,
-0.0039246627,
0.0455742553,
-0.0455250181,
0.0241818652,
0.0286368188,
0.049551595,
-0.0236301199,
-0.0249323193,
0.0322797596,
0.0371008664,
0.0114369625,
-0.0110083614,
-0.110966377,
-0.0013464837,
-0.0344185121,
-0.0178475566,
0.0309430938,
-0.0381140634,
-0.0122093428,
0.0029808637,
0.0073882076,
-0.0298593845,
1.626414328e-34,
0.0155584291,
0.0676544532,
-0.0072598653,
-0.0187018272,
-0.0102029368,
-0.0012086129,
-0.0875822827,
0.0213485193,
0.0225966144,
-0.0266140737,
-0.0459341742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10165v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10165v1 | Data Selection for Fine-tuning Large Language Models Using Transferred Shapley Values | 2023-06-16T20:07:38 | 2023-06-16T20:07:38 | Stephanie Schoch, Ritwick Mishra, Yangfeng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although Shapley values have been shown to be highly effective for
identifying harmful training instances, dataset size and model complexity
constraints limit the ability to apply Shapley-based data valuation to
fine-tuning large pre-trained language models. To address this, we propose
TS-DShapley, an algorithm that reduces computational cost of Shapley-based data
valuation through: 1) an efficient sampling-based method that aggregates
Shapley values computed from subsets for valuation of the entire training set,
and 2) a value transfer method that leverages value information extracted from
a simple classifier trained using representations from the target language
model. Our experiments applying TS-DShapley to select data for fine-tuning
BERT-based language models on benchmark natural language understanding (NLU)
datasets show that TS-DShapley outperforms existing data selection methods.
Further, TS-DShapley can filter fine-tuning data to increase language model
performance compared to training with the full fine-tuning dataset. | [
0.02265599,
0.0948651507,
-0.0014726411,
0.0318263099,
-0.0495812036,
0.0454211608,
0.0166233871,
-0.0062127714,
-0.067341134,
-0.0705984309,
-0.0268936493,
-0.0173485968,
-0.0092745861,
0.0265977308,
-0.0045047887,
-0.0440431349,
0.0810495466,
-0.0186202787,
0.0063030738,
0.002605153,
-0.0166886151,
0.0267844424,
0.0082357144,
0.0425584465,
0.0289173014,
0.0070308358,
0.0238214172,
0.0197099037,
0.0115760174,
0.0046755443,
0.0154175172,
0.0991272032,
0.0001038097,
-0.0014067491,
0.0000020676,
-0.0370100141,
-0.0350168534,
0.0136806387,
-0.0294135921,
0.0519095547,
0.0456858277,
0.0002537987,
0.0104389125,
0.0029326195,
-0.0241606813,
-0.0044142385,
0.0256813243,
0.0277374331,
0.0727076679,
0.0605239347,
-0.0025596716,
-0.0044074086,
-0.0103498325,
-0.0163323581,
0.0095763262,
-0.0575119965,
0.0613683462,
0.014892715,
-0.0440285169,
-0.0197487455,
0.0056379484,
0.0184958521,
-0.0276455656,
0.0034333537,
0.0312569179,
0.0073940116,
-0.069551304,
-0.0079008108,
-0.0026671614,
0.055156175,
-0.0600615218,
-0.0267487895,
0.0042108614,
-0.0234138761,
-0.0000117977,
-0.0119726546,
-0.0216823407,
-0.0290036052,
0.0473120213,
0.0320302732,
0.0420827791,
-0.0444186665,
0.059206944,
0.0666994229,
-0.0178045556,
-0.009829619,
0.0367765054,
-0.0035120165,
0.026088573,
0.0021018565,
-0.0654981285,
-0.0248995982,
0.0009648412,
-0.0044279653,
-0.0373350494,
-0.019880861,
-0.0664308891,
-0.0135890581,
-0.0044596572,
-0.0286373403,
0.0561396517,
0.0245359801,
-0.0014058113,
0.0485803671,
0.0003755933,
-0.0150202587,
0.0317252614,
0.0234800186,
-0.0240814444,
0.0066775712,
-0.0274200886,
0.0158516578,
-0.0689524561,
0.0326367766,
-0.0039474885,
-0.0148654319,
-0.0361149162,
-0.0090136202,
0.0029676345,
-0.0194916986,
0.0032261892,
-0.0115337223,
-0.0349161141,
0.035298083,
0.0060521066,
0.0240932256,
-0.0378997661,
0.0138715506,
-0.0141060809,
-0.0819834247,
-0.0152112776,
-0.0040690196,
0.0289970506,
-0.0588479452,
0.0475573912,
0.0193532873,
0.0056426548,
-0.0708798692,
-0.0222260114,
0.0399505086,
-0.0195752438,
-0.0392973386,
-0.0004762866,
-0.0378751755,
-0.0089008696,
-0.0034381091,
0.0327770337,
-0.0126952194,
-0.0171106178,
0.0004524828,
-0.0677291974,
0.0820452273,
-0.0239751395,
0.0143328421,
-0.0427378491,
-0.0333889052,
-0.027541209,
0.0627772957,
0.0392113887,
0.0010427027,
0.0311285425,
-0.0721365586,
-0.0381644331,
0.0159814805,
0.0345929824,
0.0346751623,
-0.0713806078,
0.0116394321,
-0.0356262065,
-0.0281462297,
-0.0043824683,
0.0254513212,
-0.0238710977,
0.0075869304,
0.0551451705,
0.0393058583,
0.03122494,
0.0344650559,
-0.0065702251,
0.0233832337,
0.011238819,
-0.022267513,
-0.0246860068,
0.0095433379,
-0.045394022,
-0.0231937245,
0.004032203,
0.0318162106,
-0.0127816899,
-0.0317759104,
-0.0187137946,
0.0252317712,
0.0075609521,
0.0442041196,
0.0551196076,
0.0183196552,
-0.0085199522,
0.0659561679,
0.066594094,
-0.0454096012,
0.0464370251,
-0.035285823,
0.0193960052,
0.0837282613,
0.0606792569,
-0.0389462374,
-0.0050819553,
-0.0234041065,
-0.0345045626,
-0.0110011427,
0.0517177396,
-0.0234913044,
0.0443644598,
-0.0603483841,
-0.0313541442,
-0.0050305389,
0.004995463,
-0.0221565273,
-0.0146721071,
-0.0119959628,
-0.0072982619,
-0.0627656356,
-0.0842749253,
0.051112771,
-0.004283397,
-0.0240602195,
-0.0168939978,
0.0175072793,
0.0449812338,
-0.0311183184,
-0.0521471463,
-0.0268597659,
-0.0020611412,
-0.0009016676,
0.0218632631,
-0.0336439684,
-0.0238862205,
-0.0119336359,
-0.0056880764,
-0.0196050592,
-0.0007365207,
0.0687587857,
-0.0590180047,
-0.0196651127,
-0.0063179061,
-0.0489720143,
-0.0235649999,
-0.0634927154,
0.0335328467,
-0.028164329,
0.0243821386,
-0.0424648598,
0.0459579192,
-0.0239699539,
0.0067676031,
-0.0227364227,
-0.0138965081,
0.0397815071,
-0.0089151338,
-0.0466213971,
0.0319566578,
-0.0281989668,
0.0459605493,
0.0394898169,
0.0317408852,
-0.0223709121,
-0.0312224869,
-0.0105492556,
-0.0105973147,
-0.0372249968,
0.012757102,
0.0360276848,
0.0074648489,
-0.0153552722,
-0.0104253497,
-0.0065917801,
-0.000885288,
-0.0202208348,
0.0048955567,
0.0257701054,
0.00697518,
0.0287728123,
-0.0328675583,
-0.0239223186,
0.0067987517,
0.0873800665,
-0.0135372374,
0.0113993157,
-0.0355118848,
0.0127229113,
-0.0034451054,
0.0116304401,
0.0255426522,
-0.0718441531,
-0.0146479029,
-0.024751056,
-0.0179187469,
0.0300098266,
0.0330827832,
0.048749391,
0.0553368367,
-0.008543524,
-0.0423329212,
0.0007353965,
-0.0258268993,
0.0237843748,
-0.0456306897,
-0.0263998304,
0.0141299497,
0.033182811,
-0.0290067568,
-0.0240624249,
-0.0757752508,
0.0385984406,
-0.0073419716,
-0.0160821136,
0.0020757825,
0.0580187812,
0.0038265935,
0.022590423,
-0.0298573803,
-0.0482183844,
0.060038086,
-0.0250934958,
0.0229803082,
-0.0360529646,
0.0018327627,
-0.0093968045,
0.0068334057,
-0.0130446907,
0.0401252694,
-0.0311806668,
-0.034110982,
-0.0420095921,
-0.0136875417,
0.0445963629,
-0.0375195928,
0.0109934676,
-0.0308447368,
0.0647207871,
0.0174458604,
-0.0418380089,
-0.0306442417,
-0.038345132,
-0.0094363447,
0.0224474091,
0.0215651561,
-0.017629981,
-0.0287528206,
0.0052576875,
-0.0345936343,
0.0318638682,
0.0025771931,
0.0007733666,
-0.0139554311,
-0.0138770994,
0.0504571833,
-0.0094189504,
0.0202109758,
0.0013429128,
0.0030617912,
0.0239942111,
0.0449581482,
0.0784074962,
-0.0399392582,
0.0568711087,
0.0662392378,
-0.0499537326,
0.0056565762,
0.0059237829,
0.0139282672,
-0.0408211015,
-0.0429307632,
0.1079232693,
0.0283058602,
-0.0094285225,
0.0109914811,
-0.0280758739,
0.0385494567,
0.0130742304,
0.0136990352,
-0.0897913799,
-0.039271187,
0.003147267,
0.0612879954,
0.006259514,
-0.0488084853,
0.0384091996,
-0.1092418656,
0.0273975302,
0.0245610494,
-0.0206832364,
-0.0031473418,
-0.0205882154,
0.036526572,
-0.0522136167,
0.0554638654,
-0.0167307518,
-0.0263879988,
0.0161603633,
0.0465199426,
0.0236733574,
-0.0715358555,
0.0453152098,
-0.0410037227,
0.0130650569,
0.0948999003,
0.0663170666,
-0.02424361,
-0.0333900787,
-0.0100005195,
-0.0061420971,
-0.0076005175,
-0.0244054478,
0.0635610446,
-0.0014838926,
-0.0466960073,
0.024019856,
0.0263438988,
0.003481609,
0.0020700237,
-0.040383298,
0.0408320688,
-0.0236605946,
-0.0148427747,
0.0125296367,
-0.0166490804,
-0.0028249293,
0.0841282308,
0.0406728759,
-0.0656687245,
-0.0452232137,
0.0219083782,
-0.0498746224,
-0.0275333505,
-0.0031952439,
0.051580023,
-0.0231374949,
-0.0376694798,
-0.0800646096,
-0.0332874916,
0.0484935269,
0.0342794247,
0.0086539211,
0.0188327767,
0.0341918059,
0.008933357,
-0.028274294,
0.0629722252,
-0.0287176389,
0.0095948586,
-0.0481774881,
-0.0211215727,
0.0203598905,
-0.0271895938,
-0.0376428291,
-0.0246600322,
-0.0323860236,
-0.0475438423,
0.0568006039,
0.0646583363,
0.0171710495,
0.0200297236,
-0.0378949903,
-0.0844487175,
0.0664049536,
0.0443658382,
0.0187902395,
-0.0186254587,
0.0344765671,
-0.065363124,
-0.007039824,
0.046801392,
-0.0386490226,
0.0335733443,
0.0611011721,
0.054672651,
-0.0093674148,
0.0189809706,
0.0153166428,
0.0493654758,
0.0569470711,
0.0033756709,
-0.0308940131,
-0.0248708725,
0.0113489553,
0.0234618355,
-0.0235813297,
-0.0694212765,
0.0048411894,
0.0470012277,
-0.0078019355,
-0.0433812812,
0.0171593223,
-0.0053422228,
0.0229940675,
-0.0792951509,
0.0325844288,
0.0225226376,
0.0445128493,
0.0472838394,
-0.0234108213,
-0.0101349335,
-0.0043724477,
0.0273197237,
0.0379169211,
-0.0256142952,
0.0190573949,
0.0328203551,
0.0232620388,
-0.0232676193,
0.0430486389,
-0.0415846035,
-0.0640719682,
-0.0400006026,
-0.0116586499,
0.0219479129,
-0.0366150849,
0.048847802,
-0.0172525495,
-0.0280113202,
-0.0152482102,
0.0307231266,
0.0112273879,
-0.0215272959,
0.0011189943,
0.0123048369,
-0.0312110092,
-0.0048937639,
0.0511467755,
0.0103390887,
0.087765798,
-0.0077768289,
-0.0232074466,
-0.0252625514,
-0.0181119293,
0.0128748138,
-0.0072506433,
-0.0259102043,
0.0386867188,
-0.0036392463,
-0.0833313614,
-0.0351974778,
-0.023819996,
0.0178597551,
-0.0169901159,
0.0024025326,
0.0631522834,
-0.031840831,
-0.0126575409,
-0.0374717675,
-0.0131413769,
0.0089757321,
0.0122024538,
-0.0162723046,
-7.171022472e-33,
0.0068560597,
-0.0104508689,
-0.0126985032,
-0.0254884884,
0.0029638815,
-0.0146231186,
-0.0180749465,
-0.0342199057,
-0.0439830422,
0.00508215,
-0.0172778461,
0.0227353182,
0.0166326668,
0.0459091067,
-0.0106800953,
-0.0484184287,
0.0548901856,
0.0078725787,
-0.0611847267,
0.0405558906,
0.0375139117,
0.0396150872,
0.0971230865,
-0.0177623667,
-0.0343461372,
0.0311720893,
-0.0211147498,
0.0290794671,
-0.0258742329,
0.0020973901,
0.0145672206,
0.0128477663,
0.0011446881,
-0.0149397887,
-0.0083431546,
-0.0157403722,
-0.0755322129,
-0.007476436,
0.0219641607,
0.0229346585,
0.0114252092,
0.0153931864,
0.0372609794,
0.02149521,
0.0056642136,
0.0021124559,
-0.0152309407,
-0.0482971668,
-0.0461752117,
-0.0256219413,
-0.0569799654,
0.0192178395,
-0.0388862453,
-0.0171812922,
0.045575045,
-0.0141349295,
-0.0096508684,
0.0294166524,
-0.038003657,
-0.0150423022,
0.0524923988,
0.0128712254,
0.0249627139,
0.027254669,
0.0032558106,
0.0660367087,
0.0001496446,
-0.0159617644,
0.0668787435,
-0.0354755595,
0.0604684427,
0.0910332724,
0.0215028301,
0.0055393223,
0.0626362264,
-0.0190298762,
-0.0730691478,
0.0140426382,
0.0326353349,
0.0315025039,
0.0374506898,
0.0093042525,
-0.0450818166,
-0.0229750462,
-0.0836955681,
-0.0496094152,
-0.031610392,
0.0039118542,
0.0054827398,
-0.0092293639,
-0.0791764632,
0.0647706315,
0.0180934668,
-0.0102900658,
-0.0234461445,
-0.0089243213,
-0.0400757231,
0.0103406478,
-0.0124661224,
0.0296663549,
-0.0237846673,
-0.05138373,
0.0379066207,
-0.055080384,
0.020632688,
0.0062382072,
0.0687962919,
0.0168027375,
-0.0335754752,
-0.0023891164,
-0.0279787108,
0.0284472127,
-0.0040559662,
0.0580434315,
0.035232272,
0.0136971055,
0.0154619133,
0.0191607177,
0.0300900433,
0.0210748874,
-0.0357369147,
0.0039237072,
-0.0075093857,
0.0136763481,
-0.0173536502,
-0.0162808485,
-0.0475898758,
-0.0491086952,
0.061015632,
-0.0527865626,
-0.0164747126,
0.0117936665,
2.947e-7,
0.057681568,
0.0894193649,
-0.0323918201,
0.0119073,
-0.0220817998,
0.0578839183,
-0.00972973,
0.0211590398,
0.0233305916,
0.0201215278,
0.0209651943,
0.0107442411,
0.0914313719,
0.0259498134,
-0.0220730919,
-0.0493136197,
-0.0733583197,
-0.0100759743,
-0.0335821547,
-0.0148227019,
-0.000530379,
0.0718965009,
0.0299383961,
-0.0389288999,
0.0452436917,
-0.030749796,
0.0327807032,
-0.0478318483,
0.0102503579,
0.0555161946,
0.0147904567,
0.0050125909,
0.0238501616,
0.0282580238,
-0.0420290343,
0.0418578982,
0.0129123153,
0.0404253416,
-0.0417730063,
0.0019195684,
-0.058928024,
-0.0386378393,
0.0319082476,
-0.058557488,
0.0792752653,
-0.063735567,
-0.0316883586,
-0.0457492322,
-0.0404902138,
-0.0216675866,
0.0194542948,
-0.0168111343,
0.0162638668,
0.0443385281,
0.0162196439,
-0.0040585739,
-0.0415760465,
-0.0592150986,
0.0284583196,
0.0080275247,
-0.0000499584,
-0.0181718227,
-0.0062721358,
-0.0253200512,
0.0176864285,
-0.0831564069,
0.0276891477,
2.619494341e-34,
0.0370483175,
-0.0070807603,
0.0262361765,
0.000250634,
0.0537154004,
0.0220373664,
0.0174576454,
-0.0092987875,
-0.0068618567,
-0.0693910345,
-0.0056196493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10153v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10153v1 | Semi-supervised Relation Extraction via Data Augmentation and Consistency-training | 2023-06-16T19:45:42 | 2023-06-16T19:45:42 | Komal K. Teru | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Due to the semantic complexity of the Relation extraction (RE) task,
obtaining high-quality human labelled data is an expensive and noisy process.
To improve the sample efficiency of the models, semi-supervised learning (SSL)
methods aim to leverage unlabelled data in addition to learning from limited
labelled data points. Recently, strong data augmentation combined with
consistency-based semi-supervised learning methods have advanced the state of
the art in several SSL tasks. However, adapting these methods to the RE task
has been challenging due to the difficulty of data augmentation for RE. In this
work, we leverage the recent advances in controlled text generation to perform
high quality data augmentation for the RE task. We further introduce small but
significant changes to model architecture that allows for generation of more
training data by interpolating different data points in their latent space.
These data augmentations along with consistency training result in very
competitive results for semi-supervised relation extraction on four benchmark
datasets. | [
0.0663130805,
0.0844796747,
0.0376734175,
0.0858867243,
0.0005720505,
0.0270733945,
0.004393674,
-0.0080145355,
0.0203211568,
-0.0214919206,
-0.064456284,
-0.0199349485,
-0.0496283732,
0.0186798256,
0.0321256928,
-0.0506584272,
0.0289778914,
0.0248441212,
0.0316855311,
0.0207611006,
-0.005678663,
0.0087820413,
-0.0102241393,
-0.0598393045,
-0.080496043,
0.0008413001,
0.0175574757,
-0.0056702611,
0.0270520076,
-0.0788545609,
0.0213914439,
0.0414240956,
0.0163339842,
-0.0086065885,
0.00000203,
-0.0254853442,
-0.0141132204,
-0.0068285754,
-0.0354006253,
-0.0273615196,
0.0094746873,
-0.0640717,
0.0260715429,
-0.0208327342,
-0.0462263897,
-0.0614852645,
0.0292012263,
0.0605829544,
0.0360950343,
0.0687911958,
-0.0305179115,
-0.0040588854,
0.01448246,
-0.0614168718,
0.0142523581,
-0.0179885775,
0.0258602984,
0.0157377683,
0.0197435617,
0.033363197,
-0.0210422929,
0.0341761746,
0.0468804054,
-0.0146907363,
0.048856806,
0.0407517739,
-0.0566210225,
-0.0293364674,
0.0018782652,
0.1101075411,
0.0276185796,
0.0285168793,
0.0309587307,
-0.0185536649,
-0.0050501362,
0.0054895687,
0.0122536765,
-0.0067315032,
-0.0181375574,
0.0312492754,
-0.0210103765,
0.0192971658,
0.0501624942,
0.010495875,
-0.0067587853,
0.0533377863,
-0.0248677153,
-0.0587959066,
0.0270260088,
0.0473867916,
0.0151342191,
-0.0269990303,
0.0039358954,
0.022587087,
-0.023681147,
0.0397115238,
-0.0633269399,
-0.0480333492,
-0.0169515312,
-0.0263039395,
-0.0449969992,
-0.0252979398,
-0.0249094311,
0.0360070392,
-0.0358419605,
0.0002617465,
-0.008325737,
0.0251324698,
-0.0290249493,
-0.0099167544,
-0.008416079,
0.0113526238,
-0.0119447839,
0.0612289049,
-0.0412830226,
-0.0068840589,
-0.0949615538,
0.0068517281,
-0.03139681,
0.0349726379,
-0.0044478066,
0.0238180552,
-0.0484032221,
-0.0099997651,
0.0106016435,
-0.0297639444,
-0.0212515239,
-0.0016063306,
0.0083684027,
-0.019906925,
-0.0152346119,
-0.0082617942,
0.0744722188,
-0.0555449314,
-0.0065907179,
0.0973836258,
-0.0307436809,
-0.0605565533,
-0.010865273,
-0.0504460819,
0.0058919876,
-0.0507216007,
0.0089675589,
-0.0103838583,
0.0564049855,
0.0122045735,
-0.0334647447,
-0.0498050638,
0.054109551,
-0.0238884185,
-0.0458809286,
0.0563337877,
-0.0770274252,
-0.0266290922,
-0.0200430565,
0.0230067,
0.0193445496,
0.0488476679,
0.0456808396,
0.019075809,
0.0455435775,
0.0365786143,
-0.0014463337,
0.0136268027,
0.0482895561,
-0.0330343321,
-0.0223320425,
-0.005258034,
0.0222828649,
0.0209950283,
0.0389950722,
0.059071634,
-0.0388443172,
-0.0321886353,
0.0303305276,
-0.0176979285,
0.0000208043,
0.0321941786,
0.0380289741,
0.0001938808,
0.0204399712,
0.0335007571,
-0.0661162883,
0.0106563894,
0.0103979651,
0.0319233462,
-0.0076781483,
0.0064281956,
0.0070437267,
-0.0369589217,
0.0164041612,
-0.0348566137,
-0.0017587806,
0.0165823642,
0.0745019615,
0.0383071639,
-0.0130445017,
0.0172290616,
0.0490269512,
-0.0350707695,
0.0140763158,
0.0272357762,
0.0178115498,
0.0191375166,
0.0422146358,
-0.0523391403,
-0.0547760651,
-0.0327052101,
0.0340723209,
0.0431339368,
0.0101333698,
-0.0127399219,
0.0387888663,
-0.0243871789,
-0.068330951,
0.018711675,
-0.0089041134,
-0.0196664594,
0.0574871376,
0.014902981,
0.0520684123,
-0.0165365823,
-0.0049698632,
0.0419262536,
-0.0422840975,
-0.0663494095,
0.0253088083,
0.0260037351,
0.0167883653,
0.0345717072,
-0.0427823216,
-0.0174490009,
0.0596645698,
-0.052703049,
-0.00840367,
0.0089970436,
-0.0728140846,
-0.0500254892,
0.0268659797,
0.0183054656,
-0.0584616326,
-0.0224231053,
-0.0514297858,
-0.0318395495,
-0.0168172661,
0.0045548622,
0.0382604636,
-0.0291675068,
-0.0088939089,
0.0698166341,
0.0234062877,
-0.0249226019,
0.0737537071,
0.004416205,
0.0003178123,
0.0046519144,
-0.0380958207,
-0.0205382574,
-0.0038508556,
0.0101630501,
0.0030739454,
-0.0206742939,
-0.0426964723,
0.0071125999,
0.0176086295,
-0.0432729535,
0.0148288822,
-0.0367915332,
-0.001451997,
0.0115585336,
0.0393476598,
0.0016200772,
0.0442126021,
-0.0131933354,
-0.0349825248,
-0.0030206034,
-0.0237523224,
-0.0133919539,
-0.0205424279,
0.0614621788,
0.0371127501,
-0.0010284022,
-0.045684278,
-0.0060059703,
0.0092638377,
0.043308042,
0.0393592268,
-0.0041699144,
0.0199294146,
0.0280726645,
-0.056964267,
0.0316644683,
0.0037782895,
-0.0087032169,
-0.0312138237,
0.0074001704,
-0.0174254458,
-0.026158886,
0.0106900036,
0.0346393585,
-0.0094298795,
0.0085068494,
-0.0240311567,
0.0425044633,
-0.0385348722,
0.0282883532,
0.0306472573,
-0.0177835152,
0.001012189,
0.0597235858,
-0.0265230443,
0.0005295015,
0.0209292304,
-0.0147230364,
0.0330293477,
-0.0347098336,
-0.0518306382,
0.0305172857,
-0.0007865876,
-0.0037326943,
-0.0747656822,
-0.0432708487,
0.076967746,
0.0084031979,
-0.0114208944,
-0.013878691,
-0.0231882688,
-0.0159905683,
0.0654503107,
0.0065935594,
0.0346087404,
-0.0042213234,
0.0001971186,
-0.0067682792,
-0.0445007458,
0.0290130135,
0.0079394914,
0.011553782,
-0.0594391003,
0.0211910009,
0.0009148495,
-0.0479817092,
-0.0811218098,
-0.0374227203,
-0.0125449188,
-0.017665552,
-0.0016720452,
-0.0216997117,
0.029428089,
-0.0300137494,
0.0166499689,
0.0515905134,
0.0048990888,
-0.020384673,
-0.0183575265,
0.0326710157,
0.0885076895,
0.0051222807,
-0.0250401329,
-0.0268348791,
-0.0088801794,
0.0529574528,
0.0108247064,
-0.0173021387,
0.0102592809,
0.0044898824,
-0.0336763151,
-0.0327886976,
0.0143568758,
-0.0021055036,
0.0330275372,
-0.0438322499,
-0.0346796624,
0.1039971635,
0.0250950605,
-0.0124035859,
0.0209227651,
0.036375314,
0.0225539915,
0.0340610184,
0.0332194977,
-0.08523684,
-0.0159307532,
-0.0362684131,
-0.0115730846,
0.0065594772,
-0.0576561317,
-0.010581227,
-0.0822872072,
0.0099655231,
-0.0077869478,
-0.0988842919,
-0.0301580019,
-0.0409093015,
0.0060732928,
-0.0034234836,
-0.0244625043,
0.0056510712,
-0.0357700624,
0.0074123396,
0.0178833678,
-0.0113590369,
-0.0592447966,
-0.0419541411,
-0.0441343226,
0.033945255,
-0.0030499962,
0.02069824,
-0.0156763662,
0.0093359444,
0.0558024161,
0.0190084651,
-0.0222669933,
-0.0225197971,
0.1140507907,
-0.0401092023,
-0.0299451798,
-0.024812391,
0.0310181212,
-0.0423276722,
-0.0137503864,
-0.0042028404,
0.035833586,
0.0268348902,
0.008604059,
-0.0044128741,
-0.0317553617,
0.0261391811,
0.0311858915,
0.0309482627,
-0.0186803471,
-0.0187511928,
0.0178640131,
0.0405924506,
-0.0508159474,
0.0641967803,
-0.0117427716,
-0.0945172161,
0.0034771732,
-0.065673843,
-0.0602494366,
0.0316783264,
0.0285196267,
-0.0132599957,
-0.005892213,
0.041804973,
-0.0374339186,
-0.0804638416,
-0.0011517789,
-0.0275964867,
-0.0113243302,
0.0056569776,
-0.0307416245,
-0.0194003489,
-0.0506712981,
-0.0093594156,
-0.032192301,
-0.0336914584,
-0.0270698685,
-0.0106932027,
0.0395037457,
0.0113573484,
0.059380237,
0.0120401327,
0.0099001573,
0.0069867335,
0.1133088395,
-0.060032405,
-0.0321975499,
0.0074546663,
-0.0192431957,
0.016777901,
0.0256588049,
-0.0463086478,
0.0364327319,
0.0453943126,
0.0266368091,
-0.0057579884,
-0.0127720367,
0.0142114135,
0.0208194926,
0.048679281,
-0.0108281923,
0.0446535498,
-0.0613627508,
0.0121265072,
-0.0631198511,
-0.0099981939,
-0.0524650849,
0.0472175702,
-0.0039741523,
0.0257532094,
-0.0331197903,
-0.0215733498,
-0.021417493,
0.0683994442,
-0.0294083264,
-0.0291326772,
-0.0367281809,
-0.0293209199,
0.0201418567,
-0.0104392823,
0.0083787162,
0.0374916941,
0.0290731117,
0.0340970755,
-0.0028995075,
-0.0013747934,
0.0245333817,
0.0003399662,
-0.015460426,
0.0009843518,
-0.0371099785,
0.0690111965,
-0.0541244708,
0.0588830002,
0.0509907715,
-0.0333610587,
0.0277254079,
-0.0151291564,
-0.0063763903,
0.0272458456,
0.0486703143,
-0.0302935578,
-0.001091511,
-0.008359368,
0.0171756744,
-0.0334330536,
0.0249381736,
0.0675538033,
0.0100878589,
0.0504311547,
0.0042793686,
-0.0423343815,
-0.0667449981,
-0.0221987367,
-0.0026042145,
0.0093301404,
-0.0110791726,
0.0203863811,
-0.0191693064,
-0.1048781723,
0.0035230219,
-0.0086302664,
-0.0158281922,
0.0196410157,
0.0308870785,
0.0041573001,
0.0230097473,
-0.0214342531,
-0.040582642,
0.0201499183,
0.0095047737,
-0.0324690938,
0.0065681865,
-6.582210739e-33,
-0.0396700799,
-0.0537705906,
0.0185115784,
-0.0222434793,
-0.0517712422,
0.0564496145,
-0.0360680893,
-0.008852059,
0.0289764237,
0.0527314022,
-0.0150655257,
-0.0086190691,
0.0031220284,
0.0452469736,
-0.0116244685,
-0.0220668577,
0.0297614951,
0.0219717436,
0.0093121622,
0.00031395,
0.0284564774,
0.0793866664,
0.0501674041,
-0.1295580715,
0.0173994824,
0.0009950188,
0.0050995336,
0.0029463901,
0.0478460304,
0.0320069157,
-0.0232453961,
0.0245506875,
0.0325236134,
-0.0029884158,
0.0105130794,
-0.0265389979,
-0.1357147396,
-0.014497418,
-0.032801684,
-0.0218368471,
-0.0830865949,
0.0135914963,
0.0356460139,
-0.0188244078,
0.0401207544,
-0.0101623693,
0.0336945765,
-0.0357677266,
-0.0368601084,
-0.0745396093,
-0.0751760229,
0.0149456616,
0.022062812,
0.0055444422,
0.0445138551,
0.0461870618,
-0.0051451651,
-0.006501073,
-0.0234063827,
-0.0488150232,
0.0244903509,
0.0214642398,
0.0440822095,
0.0444343463,
-0.0156913139,
0.0541284569,
-0.009325291,
-0.0077366242,
-0.0343877524,
0.0196307972,
-0.0232554898,
0.0558635443,
-0.0331928991,
0.0412354358,
0.0358053111,
-0.0148649728,
-0.0898673236,
0.0177512132,
0.0301065799,
0.0048456648,
-0.0416560434,
0.0089420676,
-0.0171745513,
0.0104115065,
0.01621438,
0.0434278063,
-0.0017494967,
-0.0332938097,
0.0102745285,
0.0386388265,
-0.0485123023,
0.0640233383,
-0.038816072,
-0.0208279323,
-0.0522021651,
-0.0109229228,
0.0014825169,
-0.0172591154,
0.0204301998,
-0.0512611568,
-0.0731402859,
-0.054527387,
0.0077001164,
0.0328392014,
0.0012825199,
0.00308817,
0.0803959072,
-0.002083845,
-0.0291908886,
-0.0088020116,
-0.0417306647,
0.0315555632,
-0.0041780206,
0.0044665593,
0.005483577,
0.0024453495,
-0.0260607135,
0.0600744449,
0.0323164798,
0.0007089198,
-0.0111218663,
0.0422558524,
0.0078265183,
0.0166106597,
0.0274820849,
-0.0074786129,
0.0024397061,
0.005134217,
0.0053045163,
-0.0741185173,
0.0054355445,
-0.0172694512,
2.669e-7,
0.0271778293,
0.0270330235,
0.0869366601,
0.0152914682,
0.0095484462,
0.0142364074,
0.0333214402,
0.0361422151,
-0.0300505552,
-0.0248787701,
0.0176854115,
0.0182709284,
0.026671553,
0.025499247,
-0.0371092968,
-0.0293469448,
-0.1046446487,
-0.0542166606,
-0.0385354869,
-0.0216631982,
0.1117992476,
0.0422929898,
0.0323325545,
-0.0111061996,
-0.015014166,
0.0030902037,
0.0602192618,
-0.0385327861,
0.0034120395,
0.0336993895,
0.0325354449,
0.0259585399,
-0.0101890368,
0.0404145345,
-0.0386580899,
0.0121793514,
0.0298480168,
0.0478581861,
0.0095198667,
0.0383724533,
0.0290441941,
0.0182061773,
0.0366896763,
0.0106507428,
0.0572450347,
-0.0613415241,
0.0061466852,
0.0231166054,
-0.0383857153,
0.0270742942,
0.0023149059,
-0.0026119375,
-0.0020556352,
0.0328408703,
0.0449951738,
-0.0025520767,
-0.0528197885,
-0.0427728035,
-0.0076071867,
0.0237070825,
-0.0097989021,
0.0174834598,
-0.0113927154,
-0.0072142854,
-0.0195655283,
-0.0108572282,
-0.0136593189,
2.087919724e-34,
-0.0122386366,
0.0055912621,
-0.0190787651,
0.027003957,
0.0182931684,
-0.0270277783,
-0.0336400792,
0.0131061058,
-0.0259502418,
-0.0035484165,
0.0325546861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10015v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10015v1 | Just One Byte (per gradient): A Note on Low-Bandwidth Decentralized Language Model Finetuning Using Shared Randomness | 2023-06-16T17:59:51 | 2023-06-16T17:59:51 | Eric Zelikman, Qian Huang, Percy Liang, Nick Haber, Noah D. Goodman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC | Language model training in distributed settings is limited by the
communication cost of gradient exchanges. In this short note, we extend recent
work from Malladi et al. (2023), using shared randomness to perform distributed
fine-tuning with low bandwidth. The method is a natural decentralized extension
of memory-efficient Simultaneous Perturbation Stochastic Approximation (SPSA).
Each iteration, each machine seeds a Random Number Generator (RNG) to perform
local reproducible perturbations on model weights and calculate and exchange
scalar projected gradients, which are then used to update each model. By using
a (machine, sample) identifier as the random seed, each model can regenerate
one another's perturbations. As machines only exchange single-byte projected
gradients, this is highly communication efficient. There are also potential
privacy benefits, as projected gradients may be calculated on different
training data, and models never access the other's data. Our approach not only
drastically reduces communication bandwidth requirements but also accommodates
dynamic addition or removal of machines during the training process and retains
the memory-efficient and inference-only advantages of recent work. We perform
proof-of-concept experiments to demonstrate the potential usefulness of this
method, building off of rich literature on distributed optimization and
memory-efficient training. | [
0.0246008318,
0.0935574919,
-0.0084872171,
0.0336615145,
-0.0260357838,
-0.0149564156,
0.0372883454,
-0.0312960707,
-0.0501666404,
0.0061124344,
-0.0493475199,
-0.0495536402,
0.027142508,
-0.0261906404,
0.0277880579,
-0.0318601653,
0.0317877717,
-0.0258992631,
-0.039865274,
-0.064835526,
-0.0023912273,
-0.0031370665,
0.0169328488,
0.0004735258,
0.004681712,
-0.0376268029,
-0.0320123844,
0.0168653205,
-0.0037630384,
0.0228288285,
0.0431769341,
0.0717763454,
0.0132008288,
0.0461778976,
0.0000020169,
-0.0114616202,
-0.0090698125,
0.0281832702,
0.0016709801,
0.0465803631,
0.0349429958,
-0.0068810508,
-0.0390656069,
0.0251346286,
-0.0052798102,
-0.0128046442,
0.0814329088,
-0.0215746909,
0.0402682461,
0.0510314405,
0.012524032,
-0.0200534314,
-0.0344646685,
-0.0518852361,
-0.0518688336,
-0.0406791158,
0.0181248672,
0.003329359,
-0.0222664103,
0.0071865483,
-0.0304477029,
0.0322696194,
0.0057071391,
0.0214553438,
0.0143110901,
0.0186406653,
-0.0495350771,
-0.0260201227,
-0.0319241285,
0.0588547774,
-0.0271225106,
-0.0272985641,
0.0086859353,
0.0125077264,
-0.0332980119,
0.0026845154,
-0.0130002871,
0.011693866,
0.0093957204,
0.0453391783,
-0.0186329819,
-0.063081041,
0.0699161813,
0.0198533051,
0.0148922568,
0.0488053709,
0.014225916,
-0.0000820851,
-0.0529436916,
-0.0142225884,
-0.0529535376,
-0.0400840789,
0.0072922995,
0.0058995215,
0.0031392043,
0.0040243603,
-0.0812889934,
-0.063038595,
-0.008888023,
-0.0159394648,
0.0903958604,
-0.0097286673,
0.0345791131,
0.0469802581,
-0.0100364154,
-0.0167103745,
-0.0020569321,
0.0073283101,
0.0244657677,
0.0107949357,
-0.0096028661,
0.0049027004,
-0.0323039517,
0.0483597964,
-0.073981829,
0.0134968488,
-0.0121339578,
0.0288921073,
-0.0096601574,
-0.0015856662,
0.0145336697,
0.0071302406,
-0.0585011058,
-0.0133833513,
0.0323359333,
0.0354933366,
-0.0451856889,
0.0222030692,
0.02095614,
-0.0685790256,
-0.0345445834,
-0.0033288433,
0.0045412593,
0.0198155288,
0.016043948,
0.0633293688,
-0.0270942207,
-0.0008097225,
-0.0431555919,
-0.0475489013,
0.0247128606,
-0.0598970279,
-0.0469262674,
-0.0653913543,
0.008286518,
-0.0011776113,
0.0059586903,
-0.0674237162,
0.0071697319,
-0.0193577427,
-0.0367107578,
0.0738823116,
-0.0612422563,
0.0000423361,
0.0019144933,
0.0003805089,
-0.0097011272,
0.0898709744,
0.0470717475,
0.0173817761,
0.0561727174,
0.005531068,
-0.0632339492,
0.0484895892,
0.0754568204,
0.02326441,
-0.0095690582,
-0.0467059165,
0.0420782603,
0.0274647698,
0.0164988637,
0.0714644715,
-0.0389872231,
-0.0265667532,
0.0966525078,
0.0775279626,
-0.0187719669,
0.0369502455,
-0.0001158766,
0.017376462,
-0.0325448178,
0.0050658779,
-0.0543058962,
-0.010437483,
0.0143216671,
-0.0006216354,
0.0478461571,
0.0686589405,
-0.0395020097,
0.0072423033,
-0.0148847476,
-0.035971716,
-0.0280354451,
0.008827934,
0.057615824,
0.0041286256,
-0.0255675595,
0.0433560982,
0.0683388636,
-0.0525966398,
0.0115834689,
-0.0187340621,
0.0039848201,
0.0370207317,
0.0488203242,
0.0150352083,
0.0118023399,
-0.036322549,
0.0542524755,
0.0005220618,
0.0364504717,
0.0022756841,
0.0341299102,
-0.0432932936,
-0.0052918266,
0.0469377302,
0.0009376027,
0.0294284597,
0.0221285485,
-0.0002660388,
-0.004026595,
0.0136522567,
-0.0241868254,
-0.0032437583,
-0.0309472904,
0.0021850532,
0.0065064719,
0.0026427775,
0.0576474555,
-0.0349170305,
-0.0523432419,
-0.0079382686,
-0.0065315273,
-0.0058754915,
0.0014266403,
-0.0030284449,
0.0049630357,
-0.0196365826,
0.0217476953,
0.0149917584,
0.0242338944,
0.0327453837,
-0.0331674367,
-0.0277320873,
0.0686074346,
0.012907452,
0.001081064,
-0.0314690657,
0.0049869572,
-0.0302264653,
0.0512082353,
-0.0080804368,
-0.0125387637,
-0.0178922992,
0.0203980934,
-0.0171832796,
0.0101336036,
0.0301785972,
-0.041182451,
-0.0137905534,
-0.0018432377,
0.0075921211,
0.0465687215,
-0.016290158,
0.0139266094,
0.0355535075,
-0.0320625454,
-0.0412698202,
0.0063124849,
-0.0542282611,
0.0580241196,
0.0395483151,
0.0394668803,
0.0050318856,
-0.0279199071,
0.0053464831,
0.0273984969,
-0.0393091701,
0.034190502,
-0.0128794154,
0.0178364813,
-0.0367329903,
-0.0058025662,
-0.0524613,
0.0403618738,
0.0413847752,
0.010052884,
-0.0101314196,
-0.0852984115,
0.0094664991,
-0.052291207,
0.064773269,
-0.0242985301,
-0.0643885434,
0.0068393378,
0.0250142589,
0.035683915,
0.0799236372,
-0.0409162119,
0.0047096889,
0.0284120478,
0.0058193742,
-0.0325060338,
0.0137040904,
-0.0173144396,
-0.0413550809,
-0.0562380105,
-0.0167496316,
-0.0208402555,
0.068130888,
-0.0251359902,
-0.0558663569,
-0.0202393495,
0.0297855381,
-0.0112227947,
-0.0505552515,
-0.0402226448,
0.0105198892,
0.0002671912,
0.0197502319,
-0.0179360081,
-0.0708201975,
0.0736201853,
-0.0237659756,
-0.0025867305,
-0.0189560391,
-0.0512935668,
-0.0007955526,
0.0474504419,
-0.0216338821,
0.0370868593,
-0.0569578744,
-0.0059497398,
-0.0582301617,
-0.0039659776,
0.0700704977,
-0.0084287934,
-0.0205984265,
-0.0313393474,
0.0382888503,
-0.025498135,
-0.0889717638,
0.0277859494,
-0.0528960265,
-0.0418545231,
0.0353809111,
0.0282771327,
-0.0510886163,
0.0106862662,
0.0504714921,
0.0061143544,
0.024737766,
-0.0405088961,
0.0227010678,
-0.0166573003,
-0.0183107462,
0.0390533954,
-0.0380188823,
-0.0011037072,
-0.039446272,
-0.0130063836,
0.0328610763,
0.0620505325,
-0.0016271069,
-0.0250228085,
-0.0228268709,
0.0096012847,
-0.0066577629,
-0.0167100038,
0.0009227208,
0.0931301415,
-0.0310042147,
-0.0481615402,
0.075722374,
0.0014643034,
-0.0552109107,
0.0069738948,
-0.0112371808,
0.0895957947,
-0.0113817453,
0.015467613,
-0.0446113944,
-0.0403108597,
0.0343174785,
0.0462678932,
0.0135571975,
-0.0193905234,
-0.0333548971,
-0.0623813421,
-0.0055465358,
0.0247734226,
-0.0585978813,
-0.0374711491,
-0.0314174257,
0.0176142529,
-0.0115174241,
0.0239365622,
0.0201552529,
0.0130731575,
0.0212572385,
0.0195996538,
0.0170449801,
-0.0602981411,
-0.0049945242,
-0.0526431352,
0.0639686808,
0.0738447011,
-0.0624198504,
0.0116263954,
-0.0330291912,
0.0540118478,
0.0188586153,
-0.007186959,
-0.0029523394,
0.0134787345,
-0.0013338461,
-0.035882324,
0.0193168223,
0.0091736754,
0.0256623123,
0.0191228781,
-0.017755853,
0.0352708958,
0.0095412517,
0.0020616588,
0.0409977883,
-0.0116651421,
0.0450320244,
0.023286989,
0.0192828886,
-0.0531000458,
-0.0197779667,
-0.0108094597,
-0.0017241101,
0.0097372103,
0.0156660844,
-0.0177972503,
-0.0265194923,
-0.0044373511,
-0.0285170097,
-0.002781796,
0.0095655154,
0.0207745619,
0.0149865802,
0.0136632463,
0.075846523,
0.0156735349,
-0.0503522418,
-0.0059893383,
-0.0614564456,
0.0057846494,
-0.0460756384,
-0.0178724565,
0.0633586049,
0.0319916494,
-0.0162357762,
0.0095488681,
-0.1386259347,
-0.0907496512,
0.0132584954,
0.0345422626,
0.0135669531,
0.043847885,
-0.0113991536,
-0.1063083485,
0.0269114487,
0.0392138548,
-0.013937044,
0.0737500191,
0.0353564024,
-0.0493880957,
0.0154969506,
0.0647991896,
-0.0350621566,
0.0297407918,
0.0592352562,
0.0085777612,
0.0043332358,
-0.0395201445,
-0.0627190098,
0.0086601237,
0.0073775561,
-0.0000415591,
0.0043231603,
-0.0261163022,
0.0403262116,
0.0272159185,
0.0075371331,
-0.0561467409,
-0.0136130126,
-0.0118618254,
-0.0252849292,
-0.0064168083,
0.0005565011,
0.0778898373,
0.0248264559,
0.0150710158,
-0.0088896155,
-0.0158336274,
-0.0062744608,
0.0705347136,
0.0254729763,
0.0205892287,
0.0184488781,
0.0160917081,
0.0272739101,
-0.0265168566,
-0.0081685362,
0.0235439651,
-0.0023150465,
-0.0274854582,
0.0001018557,
-0.0422029272,
-0.1101012304,
-0.0199948717,
0.0336887315,
0.0686063021,
0.0843550712,
0.0150032071,
-0.0057188147,
-0.0220266469,
-0.0332776792,
0.0405456685,
-0.023842359,
-0.013484234,
0.0322505534,
0.0050167106,
-0.0148907136,
0.0641097575,
0.0748597309,
0.002520144,
0.0228748973,
-0.0085082948,
-0.0022852318,
-0.0189565439,
-0.0033356056,
-0.0313764699,
0.0358250104,
-0.0340093486,
0.0054503428,
0.0183123853,
-0.0776322037,
-0.0031064118,
0.0167400874,
0.0045272536,
-0.0064613656,
0.0279302895,
0.0427607,
-0.0218455009,
0.0172222629,
-0.0315481909,
-0.00430504,
0.0268314611,
-0.0220230743,
-0.0047161467,
-7.00754133e-33,
0.0002202922,
0.0068559665,
0.0027746102,
-0.0052705286,
-0.002048319,
-0.0002897453,
-0.0172002818,
-0.0014014425,
-0.0272917319,
0.0197767373,
-0.0453436375,
0.0406712443,
0.0299311914,
0.0478490852,
-0.0028665825,
-0.0124665881,
0.0721174777,
-0.0415612049,
-0.0316384658,
0.0358446576,
0.0286510978,
0.0599396825,
0.054804191,
-0.0079134209,
-0.0025679704,
-0.0057171406,
-0.0275006499,
0.0072671245,
-0.009701889,
0.0082921488,
-0.0015388585,
0.0167544708,
-0.0276746936,
-0.0308649167,
-0.0412553214,
-0.0091255391,
-0.0502955131,
-0.0191202033,
-0.0024212715,
0.0095165269,
-0.0517253913,
0.0030216023,
0.0085021444,
-0.0139211519,
-0.0082443943,
-0.002844183,
-0.0024274937,
0.0188046508,
-0.0514821522,
-0.0026382187,
0.0216266178,
0.0127222352,
0.0374797769,
0.0005253195,
0.024929544,
-0.0596933998,
-0.0217543207,
-0.012558355,
-0.0277145747,
0.0072698747,
0.0308185462,
0.0710417032,
0.0280704442,
0.0253826268,
0.0454049371,
0.0285334419,
0.053649731,
0.0092316503,
0.0085891476,
-0.0027548398,
0.03381069,
0.0008581645,
0.0139178941,
0.0482032895,
0.0109976362,
-0.00635387,
-0.0692242607,
-0.0709697753,
0.0343936011,
0.0055549094,
0.0218037069,
0.0047638379,
-0.0204954427,
-0.0348755121,
-0.0693164468,
-0.0717964545,
-0.0103277275,
-0.0289090592,
-0.007831485,
0.0429103784,
-0.0196944643,
0.0180631503,
0.0354454853,
-0.0539567992,
-0.0475466214,
0.0292137917,
0.0494756326,
0.0079610636,
0.0004914231,
-0.0078960303,
-0.0787377208,
0.0017309063,
-0.0472443141,
0.0024243598,
0.0018091544,
0.0058647958,
0.0634470433,
0.0194600597,
-0.0558858849,
0.0026952147,
-0.0298480541,
0.0520424694,
0.0010657808,
0.0255796984,
0.0498027578,
-0.0199206285,
0.0066288374,
0.0303077232,
0.0333321728,
0.0238005966,
0.0118644275,
0.022262048,
-0.0186161064,
0.0214153957,
-0.0167683885,
0.026239235,
-0.063110128,
0.0493558198,
0.0314736776,
-0.0242557172,
0.0006707583,
-0.0205444079,
2.838e-7,
-0.0103719877,
0.001594292,
-0.0080665927,
0.0030619642,
0.0413050652,
0.0007103675,
-0.0211028215,
0.0191495325,
0.0005598392,
-0.002364018,
-0.0152268736,
0.0371771194,
0.0465919375,
-0.0199478529,
-0.0972127467,
-0.0387536697,
-0.0685692877,
0.081345439,
-0.0120259272,
-0.0924232379,
-0.0854279846,
0.0853257328,
0.0710459724,
-0.0107903546,
-0.0188072585,
-0.0302956346,
0.037940722,
-0.0127849327,
-0.022527229,
0.0252236687,
0.0221569724,
0.0326406471,
-0.0241131168,
-0.0104652233,
-0.0287093911,
0.0022620475,
-0.0735933259,
0.0516982786,
0.0048533883,
0.0338848494,
0.005093562,
-0.0187270418,
-0.0508386195,
0.017951604,
0.034706559,
-0.0209321994,
-0.0290308762,
-0.0406286307,
0.0480973162,
-0.0396446176,
0.0427399501,
-0.0337125994,
-0.0148846749,
-0.0018086091,
0.0166557431,
0.0134886522,
-0.016907759,
-0.074498646,
0.0126167946,
-0.0020614762,
-0.0162698254,
-0.0977121219,
-0.0139368484,
-0.0152573679,
0.0231103916,
-0.0381597281,
0.0255009308,
2.371475364e-34,
0.0869345143,
-0.0253781043,
-0.0003575647,
0.0626947954,
0.0075927186,
-0.0538596995,
0.011095915,
-0.0204815827,
0.0062040314,
-0.0516375676,
-0.0274736136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10012v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10012v3 | MagicBrush: A Manually Annotated Dataset for Instruction-Guided Image Editing | 2023-06-16T17:58:58 | 2024-05-15T18:20:28 | Kai Zhang, Lingbo Mo, Wenhu Chen, Huan Sun, Yu Su | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Text-guided image editing is widely needed in daily life, ranging from
personal use to professional applications such as Photoshop. However, existing
methods are either zero-shot or trained on an automatically synthesized
dataset, which contains a high volume of noise. Thus, they still require lots
of manual tuning to produce desirable outcomes in practice. To address this
issue, we introduce MagicBrush (https://osu-nlp-group.github.io/MagicBrush/),
the first large-scale, manually annotated dataset for instruction-guided real
image editing that covers diverse scenarios: single-turn, multi-turn,
mask-provided, and mask-free editing. MagicBrush comprises over 10K manually
annotated triplets (source image, instruction, target image), which supports
trainining large-scale text-guided image editing models. We fine-tune
InstructPix2Pix on MagicBrush and show that the new model can produce much
better images according to human evaluation. We further conduct extensive
experiments to evaluate current image editing baselines from multiple
dimensions including quantitative, qualitative, and human evaluations. The
results reveal the challenging nature of our dataset and the gap between
current baselines and real-world editing needs. | [
0.0304420944,
0.0405460224,
0.0260153841,
0.0179224778,
-0.0057452805,
0.0042202221,
0.0361164398,
0.0117069455,
-0.0448361933,
-0.0701611638,
-0.0471157618,
0.0063613937,
-0.0103388401,
-0.0250723287,
0.0038841788,
-0.0794983432,
0.0002142496,
-0.0171551611,
-0.0455175042,
0.0354876779,
0.0107482271,
-0.0040446678,
-0.0303652175,
0.0203470364,
-0.0415429622,
-0.0297006704,
-0.0326956697,
0.0850417912,
0.0107568996,
-0.0159186255,
0.0117726242,
0.0834636763,
0.0270774271,
0.0317517184,
0.0000019039,
-0.0032158492,
0.0113580506,
-0.0043609394,
0.0041447906,
0.0496564955,
0.0416042693,
-0.0238758046,
-0.0523615889,
-0.0635693148,
-0.0098087667,
0.0253909454,
0.055426769,
0.0473156273,
0.1238847673,
0.0742601007,
-0.0030779829,
-0.0359743163,
-0.047797747,
-0.0349806771,
0.0178752989,
-0.0057028821,
0.0256377384,
-0.0055725151,
-0.042234052,
0.010519309,
-0.031450294,
0.0406725258,
0.0346410051,
-0.0387542024,
0.0435537435,
0.0218909606,
-0.0405966081,
-0.0116196824,
-0.0040637217,
0.0475716181,
-0.0863565281,
0.0313200243,
-0.0273700748,
-0.0381948352,
-0.0086584482,
-0.0198122524,
-0.0390680656,
-0.0201217141,
0.0037734422,
-0.0054034204,
-0.111143738,
-0.0059945513,
-0.0058266483,
-0.0318867974,
0.0438575447,
-0.0055874945,
0.0152279753,
-0.0066314824,
-0.0173807014,
0.0047982493,
-0.0313705131,
-0.0604832545,
0.0113981469,
-0.009570891,
0.0095149642,
-0.0287340265,
-0.0729693994,
-0.0116714425,
0.0016650682,
-0.0207750238,
0.0606640764,
0.0137758953,
-0.0288425349,
0.0712235793,
-0.0197864138,
0.0030515371,
0.0257389974,
0.0466035493,
-0.0126027819,
0.0355496295,
-0.055693578,
0.026479302,
-0.0540221147,
-0.0145730469,
-0.0622891821,
0.0125454394,
-0.0423080586,
-0.0285364538,
-0.0362444632,
0.0165689401,
0.0208637789,
0.0414582193,
-0.0757228956,
-0.0168305151,
-0.0215305109,
-0.0140974633,
0.0015708483,
0.0499332659,
-0.0015385483,
-0.0073468196,
-0.0084297583,
0.0069683916,
0.029431982,
-0.0296823364,
0.0192473568,
0.0618681088,
-0.0549125113,
0.0039365324,
-0.0329653323,
0.0144297918,
0.0265047457,
-0.0089757461,
0.003210118,
-0.0322983414,
0.0197520368,
-0.0329212397,
-0.0058406084,
-0.074530378,
0.0083523002,
0.0377167761,
-0.0166205596,
0.0712017268,
-0.0017904335,
-0.0034955167,
0.0379246585,
0.0335590281,
-0.0575049967,
0.0349367447,
0.017865967,
0.0482081287,
0.0632643029,
-0.0210491903,
0.0256837867,
0.0447277427,
0.010363549,
-0.011120908,
-0.0148043139,
-0.001382189,
-0.0030047346,
0.0117935557,
0.0503677949,
0.0228581354,
-0.0693165213,
-0.0141797541,
0.0804879442,
-0.0080865314,
0.0233448017,
0.039241571,
0.0378085263,
0.0114713171,
0.0195429958,
-0.0025577405,
-0.0487187095,
0.0644482598,
0.004217728,
0.0257894881,
0.0199971385,
0.0129036549,
-0.0400495939,
-0.0487139188,
-0.0016118541,
0.0093552088,
0.0129451919,
-0.0509306826,
0.0325175188,
0.0396539494,
-0.0456325263,
-0.0408759974,
-0.0223281365,
-0.0626620278,
-0.0291440673,
-0.0177226551,
-0.0159336627,
0.0698566511,
0.027142439,
-0.0030267765,
-0.0019568573,
-0.0272567179,
0.0589940697,
0.0162438676,
-0.014244495,
-0.0241927449,
0.0486848429,
-0.0623376928,
-0.0440568328,
-0.0724693239,
0.0167994183,
0.0078995144,
0.0198210515,
-0.0351843648,
-0.0051854127,
0.016620189,
-0.0410461761,
0.0479882509,
0.0173379276,
-0.0860093534,
0.0158095174,
0.0225874092,
-0.0221539903,
-0.0062450664,
-0.0454550609,
-0.0160356797,
-0.007396155,
-0.0011809603,
0.0104841618,
-0.0228313077,
-0.000027338,
0.0022993367,
0.002363875,
-0.0556517839,
-0.0442372561,
0.019205451,
-0.0380575657,
-0.0203781817,
-0.0520181395,
0.0378381126,
-0.0255008414,
-0.0270809531,
-0.0023457115,
0.0248171762,
-0.0131991478,
-0.0403979458,
0.0174863227,
0.0009805807,
-0.0143437665,
0.0330309942,
0.0353900269,
-0.0262237787,
-0.0138636315,
-0.0235050637,
-0.0613768101,
0.0108049363,
-0.019865118,
-0.0195232872,
0.0611499995,
-0.0639402568,
-0.0213085525,
-0.0306292325,
-0.0111467429,
-0.0183687899,
-0.0183319598,
0.0453859493,
0.0006417166,
-0.0151415523,
-0.0480372123,
-0.0027689859,
-0.0066004843,
-0.0647194237,
0.000115396,
0.0281850938,
0.0055236039,
0.0199173968,
-0.0767217651,
0.0018722446,
0.0311408713,
-0.0148183648,
0.0460617244,
-0.0337341316,
-0.0174071565,
0.039137058,
0.0079648448,
0.0303673465,
0.0045410185,
-0.0274143293,
-0.028923383,
-0.0085268505,
0.0271105021,
0.1188019291,
-0.0056842356,
0.00429131,
0.022477828,
-0.027219465,
-0.0296577811,
0.0188420229,
0.0063175494,
-0.0213300176,
0.0293514226,
-0.0262922738,
-0.0133360969,
0.0558281504,
0.0016502399,
0.0282945726,
-0.0432989188,
0.0115668252,
-0.0131810103,
0.0216152724,
-0.0105457893,
0.0243775472,
0.0110519929,
0.0037099181,
-0.0752862096,
-0.0857027769,
0.0570944771,
-0.00393209,
-0.0494090095,
0.0196794495,
-0.0002951972,
0.0264823008,
0.0262135044,
0.0039238515,
0.010279147,
0.00169676,
0.0139800906,
-0.0602104031,
-0.0028069555,
0.0775941014,
0.0113315908,
0.020197548,
-0.080254145,
0.010601134,
-0.0663762763,
-0.0086682132,
-0.0192657802,
-0.0034309423,
-0.0069097592,
-0.0103417495,
0.020536229,
-0.0358829424,
0.0160909556,
0.0156698544,
0.0267514903,
0.0995407477,
-0.0007322824,
-0.0412955731,
-0.0010175611,
-0.0057741203,
0.0352686122,
-0.0316692255,
-0.0513058268,
-0.015476496,
0.0462570526,
0.0519258007,
0.020619683,
-0.0179188028,
-0.0450650528,
0.0448512733,
-0.0083452351,
-0.0300266929,
0.0140127148,
0.0343100801,
0.0907906815,
-0.0263056755,
-0.0325906947,
0.0734901801,
0.0372588262,
-0.0197219178,
-0.0248610564,
0.0291654654,
-0.0096636619,
0.0798165277,
0.0180190857,
-0.0856938735,
-0.0506619811,
-0.0014489209,
0.0312770717,
0.0099531207,
0.0141857872,
-0.0148308454,
-0.0389602892,
0.0846383125,
0.0304785389,
-0.010028136,
-0.0218861103,
0.0081239669,
0.0326720662,
-0.045978073,
-0.0360582434,
0.020176854,
-0.0161140691,
0.0079628788,
-0.0077024032,
0.0119624715,
-0.0331791043,
0.0019741175,
-0.0209622514,
0.0024800773,
0.0692874864,
-0.0210018754,
0.0315252505,
-0.0374361798,
0.0610820428,
0.0661268756,
-0.0080169002,
-0.0232726168,
0.1116318032,
0.011227034,
0.0104653146,
0.0009542606,
0.0646581799,
-0.0045454428,
-0.0181119014,
0.0389264971,
-0.0132114599,
-0.0093408991,
0.0447666757,
-0.015485649,
-0.037130218,
0.0064773373,
-0.0151622435,
0.0433471054,
-0.0162094235,
-0.0259220861,
-0.0779132545,
0.0017754156,
-0.0930931643,
-0.0370052047,
0.0092202695,
-0.0378933996,
-0.022534078,
-0.0507419258,
-0.0241844915,
0.0933502764,
0.0355272666,
0.0117053529,
-0.0672738329,
-0.0114829689,
0.0120944818,
-0.0593247786,
0.0306398366,
0.0072730989,
0.0253661461,
-0.0690427274,
-0.0598279126,
0.0310454778,
0.0001804271,
-0.0080744214,
0.0126337362,
-0.0560792834,
-0.0403127223,
0.0009691051,
0.0929027274,
0.0095632654,
0.0443401784,
0.0184878167,
-0.0659642369,
0.0007607042,
0.0198671315,
-0.0108630415,
-0.0066151805,
0.0416339077,
0.0166614894,
-0.0016301068,
0.0294476319,
-0.038971018,
0.0212160982,
0.0247907508,
0.0037041083,
-0.0303208493,
-0.0148817189,
0.0085774055,
-0.0208515506,
0.0507052913,
-0.0042290511,
0.0316398777,
-0.0343449116,
0.0280437004,
-0.026069073,
-0.0137510961,
-0.0787973329,
0.0125001557,
0.0033451186,
0.0074087684,
-0.0217083544,
0.0137714138,
0.0023155429,
0.0153809562,
-0.0661487952,
-0.0137639381,
-0.0127537483,
0.0406068228,
0.0121611962,
0.0231555868,
0.0172358658,
0.0348669551,
0.0130288778,
0.0329343118,
0.0279713962,
0.0516771041,
0.0174717363,
0.0371230617,
-0.0271072481,
0.0422150716,
-0.0306285415,
-0.001491031,
-0.0883075297,
-0.0008068372,
0.0729778409,
-0.0433393717,
0.0515062511,
0.0171043128,
-0.047395274,
-0.0004492272,
0.0632848442,
0.0084380219,
-0.0252874363,
0.0135249551,
-0.0055733328,
0.0259603988,
-0.0006538749,
0.0738540962,
-0.0420958512,
0.0507680699,
-0.0019714574,
-0.001223877,
-0.0397116505,
0.0086275125,
0.0246061515,
0.0140866535,
0.0059247795,
0.0111810863,
-0.0049512819,
-0.0200750493,
-0.0253896248,
0.0339443125,
-0.0064580697,
0.0165615696,
0.0509691648,
-0.0061022816,
-0.0353339911,
-0.0266607553,
-0.0045357975,
-0.0188435595,
0.0072696758,
-0.0039008472,
-0.0368492194,
-5.387722971e-33,
-0.0300778039,
-0.0017116604,
0.0229681768,
0.0266075525,
0.0072271586,
-0.0250523761,
0.001896848,
0.0269753132,
0.0239700675,
0.0270958915,
-0.0080835158,
-0.0194289014,
0.0014956803,
0.0249693766,
0.0417494625,
0.0302374475,
0.0715239644,
-0.0204886291,
-0.0284720175,
0.0117752897,
-0.0105218375,
0.0115205636,
0.0580144785,
-0.0618260503,
-0.0433812067,
0.0125539145,
-0.0302421935,
-0.0267026573,
-0.0155609921,
0.0499463305,
0.0400079153,
-0.0334364846,
-0.034547776,
-0.0402568467,
-0.0076910118,
-0.0623879507,
-0.0549811609,
-0.0351064317,
-0.0751431212,
0.0510018319,
-0.0476004928,
-0.028738277,
0.0583670996,
-0.0098130275,
0.006373405,
-0.0337026604,
0.0594800562,
-0.0331431925,
0.0382184014,
-0.0232242458,
-0.0144304931,
0.0104299709,
-0.0314386599,
-0.0722826198,
0.0424342118,
0.0020236124,
0.0271707159,
-0.0190783497,
-0.1151578575,
-0.0003592653,
0.0298928674,
0.0424985066,
0.0657623038,
0.0117611159,
0.0189405698,
0.0012033575,
0.0249432195,
-0.002200129,
0.039044518,
0.0372632518,
-0.0090611922,
0.0582139231,
-0.0102493996,
0.039350275,
0.0417550877,
0.0226933733,
-0.0189647544,
0.0478418507,
-0.0673634633,
0.0254277121,
-0.0373268127,
0.0409251116,
0.0353776291,
0.0331916995,
-0.0207194369,
-0.0250171386,
-0.0341661163,
-0.0250660814,
0.0349850245,
0.0241852142,
0.0075136321,
0.0154430903,
0.0343262255,
0.0270313509,
-0.0033326449,
-0.060792014,
-0.0482093617,
0.076184608,
-0.0096237995,
-0.0466112345,
-0.0194034614,
-0.0118422313,
0.0515622571,
0.0406311341,
0.0247559994,
0.0053389906,
0.0387263447,
0.0396052934,
-0.0532533266,
0.0002831854,
-0.0292862095,
0.0310454462,
-0.0027661603,
0.0232996922,
-0.0381256007,
-0.0031711182,
-0.0636073202,
0.0501640625,
-0.0079444489,
-0.0021572739,
-0.0424651131,
-0.0381544456,
0.0139639908,
-0.0086267367,
-0.0134247132,
0.0256879348,
-0.033741679,
-0.0320510864,
0.0352380536,
-0.027132323,
-0.0392713472,
0.0100285579,
2.396e-7,
0.007430248,
0.0472753942,
0.0186944716,
0.029464893,
-0.0248715673,
0.0350537039,
-0.057533741,
-0.027826691,
0.0059123659,
-0.0033250432,
0.0395706333,
0.0284325499,
0.0149661703,
0.0193112474,
0.0021667753,
0.0113190729,
0.004269443,
0.042245511,
-0.0187811852,
-0.020134123,
0.0387580544,
0.0410898067,
0.0042802612,
-0.0069166175,
0.0662326813,
0.0242040269,
0.0674179345,
-0.0171058271,
0.0564773753,
-0.018033931,
0.0369997248,
0.0111454939,
-0.019966621,
0.0215300787,
-0.0314012878,
-0.0277187712,
0.0137422755,
0.0872553065,
-0.0618465357,
0.0134421773,
0.0300011132,
0.028328279,
0.0040751384,
-0.0408667773,
0.0368424766,
-0.0518634282,
0.0219179783,
-0.0174231194,
-0.0521018691,
0.0715783611,
0.0239264425,
-0.0209434722,
-0.0135707678,
0.0081039956,
0.0441648997,
0.0438543335,
-0.046553459,
-0.0448616594,
-0.0327024236,
-0.0257621091,
0.0080863861,
-0.0207036473,
-0.0708215088,
-0.0225542877,
-0.0274209064,
0.0029626614,
-0.0509725064,
1.918440186e-34,
-0.0044422122,
0.0126045784,
0.0678740889,
0.0173615776,
0.0220978353,
0.0379254632,
-0.0072686225,
-0.0206915606,
0.0087481262,
-0.0334168561,
-0.0424593911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10098v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10098v1 | Differentiable Instruction Optimization for Cross-Task Generalization | 2023-06-16T17:49:34 | 2023-06-16T17:49:34 | Masaru Isonuma, Junichiro Mori, Ichiro Sakata | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Instruction tuning has been attracting much attention to achieve
generalization ability across a wide variety of tasks. Although various types
of instructions have been manually created for instruction tuning, it is still
unclear what kind of instruction is optimal to obtain cross-task generalization
ability. This work presents instruction optimization, which optimizes training
instructions with respect to generalization ability. Rather than manually
tuning instructions, we introduce learnable instructions and optimize them with
gradient descent by leveraging bilevel optimization. Experimental results show
that the learned instruction enhances the diversity of instructions and
improves the generalization ability compared to using only manually created
instructions. | [
0.0137330946,
0.0110509554,
-0.0007639893,
0.0276129991,
0.0331925787,
0.0438699834,
0.017790271,
0.0086333202,
0.0165307373,
-0.021200221,
-0.0386677422,
-0.0036613094,
-0.0235793199,
-0.038656909,
0.0262549967,
-0.0923806652,
0.0412294492,
0.005191518,
-0.050098557,
-0.0040793237,
0.0074967137,
-0.010535121,
-0.0096294926,
-0.0033225063,
-0.0205582194,
-0.0159892254,
-0.0137264132,
0.0319823436,
0.0710102096,
-0.0050074584,
0.0428723171,
-0.0088251298,
0.0499061495,
0.0001944938,
0.0000020045,
-0.0085133035,
-0.0117916763,
-0.0050702849,
-0.0012572351,
-0.0219729636,
-0.0021799246,
-0.035293363,
0.0132823149,
0.0134153012,
-0.0125151258,
-0.0188999418,
0.0314998701,
0.0280776042,
0.0678037181,
0.109242022,
0.0099096792,
-0.0434317067,
-0.0036286609,
0.0054625301,
0.0627030209,
-0.0269333888,
-0.0178394858,
0.0085936682,
-0.0211447347,
-0.0091162212,
-0.039839264,
0.0115506919,
0.0331019051,
0.0441202931,
0.0381684676,
0.0185509175,
0.0021660805,
0.0106283175,
-0.0670596585,
0.0461531356,
-0.0391056389,
0.0207133796,
0.0097035021,
0.0004268022,
-0.007858607,
-0.0310410131,
-0.0292213671,
0.0040569371,
-0.0433490425,
-0.0087800398,
-0.0286650695,
-0.029624654,
-0.0158096477,
-0.0639375597,
0.0333000347,
0.0772052929,
-0.0148218442,
-0.0187629946,
0.0394343324,
0.0100431042,
-0.0377091654,
-0.0048542018,
-0.0004356541,
0.0675408319,
-0.0791968033,
0.0070599387,
-0.0511455797,
-0.0406592339,
-0.0347221084,
-0.0063280645,
0.1297580004,
0.0230177566,
-0.027257964,
-0.0014492535,
-0.0341020375,
0.0749589577,
-0.0355708711,
0.0139921475,
-0.0149453627,
0.0434453674,
-0.1089486554,
0.0255530048,
-0.029683657,
0.0424777977,
-0.0387567766,
0.0021798532,
-0.0469695963,
0.0190750584,
-0.0376710594,
-0.0146448798,
0.0709645525,
0.0119370054,
-0.0581067614,
-0.0038165655,
-0.0251657516,
-0.0528100058,
-0.0740079507,
0.0215580147,
-0.0184556581,
-0.0002804629,
-0.0044941315,
0.0143917268,
0.0055425661,
-0.0230769739,
0.0356281735,
0.0892078206,
-0.0547911078,
0.0193788577,
-0.0649507493,
-0.0068595191,
0.0258314405,
-0.0485021658,
0.0359641574,
-0.0112059275,
0.0293394085,
-0.0099792909,
0.0000855502,
0.009612686,
0.0001940259,
-0.0076837633,
0.0078312755,
0.0548690967,
-0.007141998,
-0.0355699919,
0.0388983749,
-0.0034260214,
-0.0519971699,
0.0716947541,
-0.0030394592,
0.0312451161,
0.0136968661,
-0.0048938771,
0.0074367695,
-0.0041030291,
0.0199132599,
-0.0016180029,
0.0380910672,
-0.0089801727,
0.0217818525,
0.0082087032,
0.0521696769,
0.0272903554,
-0.0175404921,
0.0061931191,
0.0221288651,
0.0024992968,
0.0393577963,
0.0226947907,
0.1366829276,
0.0361297354,
-0.0173151083,
0.0477346517,
-0.065115273,
0.0409969203,
-0.0065521081,
-0.0197816771,
-0.02221076,
-0.0037141007,
-0.0635829791,
-0.0619835369,
0.0259492453,
-0.0057927589,
0.0066659027,
0.0132723888,
0.0057355906,
-0.0069185845,
-0.0503344275,
0.0026351807,
0.0453052521,
-0.0220545977,
-0.0194016304,
-0.0408596061,
0.0077618146,
0.0300179627,
-0.0370827019,
-0.0193744265,
0.000526903,
-0.0210261345,
0.0401653126,
-0.0208688118,
0.0186575595,
-0.0276347492,
0.0519658551,
-0.0536521375,
-0.0214835592,
-0.0614298955,
0.0114904335,
0.0636981353,
0.0363730304,
-0.0037609346,
0.0240326766,
-0.0049031852,
-0.0201703794,
0.0275891181,
-0.0180285294,
-0.0707056522,
0.0228290241,
0.0306494664,
-0.0017546,
-0.0158974379,
-0.0024229526,
-0.0431531966,
-0.0250356067,
-0.0293900799,
0.0014570432,
-0.0286268331,
-0.0130806742,
-0.0052824905,
0.0180638917,
-0.0820869729,
0.002406378,
0.0254221223,
-0.0294665806,
-0.0228952877,
0.0145129301,
-0.035027571,
0.0243653655,
0.0196595471,
0.0024232825,
-0.0032624889,
-0.0171876065,
0.0036256912,
0.06293495,
0.007934791,
0.003589706,
-0.0181562882,
0.0022284992,
0.0079968227,
-0.0377969742,
0.0090545071,
-0.0479282327,
-0.0138335656,
0.0401725583,
0.0385483243,
0.0405467004,
-0.0032836241,
-0.0096799769,
-0.0967602283,
0.0379505977,
-0.0578974858,
0.000330432,
0.0153300054,
0.0056627737,
0.0242863446,
-0.0456498116,
-0.0153040849,
0.0354083776,
-0.0744984671,
0.0018027246,
0.0116448747,
0.0322542414,
-0.0022990333,
-0.0191268679,
-0.0199347511,
0.0022355323,
-0.025803417,
-0.0301053021,
0.0577174798,
-0.0527901538,
0.0389392227,
-0.0112092188,
0.0364016816,
-0.0268802326,
0.0089903502,
0.0053595682,
0.0052945591,
0.0167646185,
0.1247295737,
-0.0114902966,
0.0306098461,
0.0020247491,
0.0181227643,
-0.0447675772,
0.0543819405,
-0.0027681675,
-0.031770654,
-0.0309109148,
-0.0098185735,
0.0006351973,
0.0777587369,
-0.0071875346,
0.0131721599,
-0.076347366,
-0.0053771255,
-0.0109490957,
-0.07092987,
-0.0363466851,
0.0244967435,
-0.0247762576,
-0.0324461348,
-0.0277616009,
-0.0566366501,
0.0421727411,
0.0277782995,
0.004048462,
-0.0531196222,
-0.0454197004,
-0.0319819376,
0.0353963859,
-0.0005438051,
0.0051806848,
-0.0153771602,
-0.0413770564,
-0.066734083,
0.0125590963,
0.0564042032,
-0.0017692139,
0.0345436223,
-0.0321487784,
-0.0423850641,
-0.0228382256,
-0.0255738739,
-0.0184106976,
0.0540166311,
0.0480589829,
0.0073284823,
0.0808077604,
-0.035670802,
-0.0284464434,
-0.0291902442,
0.0352621414,
0.0394846536,
-0.0369220972,
-0.0235306565,
-0.053653758,
-0.0340185426,
0.0190776307,
-0.0196862351,
-0.0767854974,
-0.0616340265,
-0.0256303363,
-0.0201543849,
0.0418833084,
-0.0658863187,
-0.0512558557,
0.0685481802,
0.0088928482,
-0.0447373986,
-0.0311048348,
0.0537824109,
0.1058966368,
-0.0443818085,
-0.0296060964,
0.0315769166,
0.0267744195,
-0.0487462655,
-0.0284660924,
0.0219874959,
-0.0152630247,
0.0367481075,
0.0537011102,
-0.0255634412,
-0.0307949558,
-0.0332987383,
0.0340644866,
0.0177038014,
0.0051006237,
-0.0176483989,
-0.0743498057,
0.0070512975,
0.004106055,
-0.0430291705,
-0.0866683871,
-0.025170194,
0.0046751699,
-0.0301767085,
0.0372085907,
-0.0155870896,
-0.0408436507,
0.0054548602,
0.0505563579,
-0.0169139244,
-0.028085364,
-0.0268997233,
-0.0242364164,
-0.0281392224,
0.0710882246,
-0.0153516578,
0.0123523585,
-0.0258849133,
0.016644299,
0.0308588687,
0.0276827961,
-0.0289901197,
0.0526839718,
-0.015478557,
0.0019660271,
0.0060712439,
0.052992221,
0.0188217442,
0.0449192487,
0.0477238111,
0.0696113333,
-0.0042936066,
-0.0247777384,
-0.0186829623,
-0.0215032529,
0.0813727677,
-0.0156295653,
0.0118161207,
-0.0517627858,
-0.0418896228,
-0.0535096824,
-0.0123230312,
-0.113483116,
0.0167040508,
0.006532222,
-0.0491698645,
-0.0316493101,
-0.0221742392,
-0.0206181705,
0.0085227014,
0.0513648093,
0.0233902037,
-0.0484621935,
0.018862363,
0.0368695632,
-0.0716378987,
-0.016249137,
0.0131237358,
0.0104860747,
-0.0322942548,
-0.0761538371,
0.0249624215,
-0.0125111258,
-0.0091824401,
0.0077285646,
-0.0745830536,
-0.050308682,
-0.029329773,
0.0781224295,
0.00072474,
0.0859367326,
0.01260693,
-0.0251042526,
0.0432380885,
0.0143801803,
-0.010637044,
0.0060594822,
0.0778834522,
-0.0151042491,
0.0137375304,
-0.0037924189,
-0.0633224323,
0.0451959372,
0.0445371233,
-0.0000967984,
-0.0342501998,
0.0697608292,
0.0062388964,
-0.0334738195,
-0.008476167,
-0.0077838399,
-0.003802018,
-0.01722496,
0.0101397522,
0.0349075645,
0.0140658859,
-0.0429716632,
0.0277235378,
0.0049274662,
0.016191192,
0.0023157664,
0.0251281336,
0.0499788336,
-0.0212651826,
-0.0934209675,
0.044316221,
-0.0053618001,
0.0698808506,
0.0270718001,
0.0272565745,
-0.0193426348,
0.0268108211,
0.0344863348,
0.0364662148,
0.0231269076,
0.0376090854,
0.0045483555,
0.0485371165,
-0.0550056063,
0.0116347997,
-0.0425168611,
-0.0378154442,
-0.0638438389,
-0.0039792149,
0.0449945703,
-0.029194396,
0.0039650537,
0.0042151571,
-0.0060347035,
-0.0025354694,
0.032273829,
-0.0187065154,
0.0283063967,
-0.0139880897,
0.0090601481,
0.0319551528,
-0.0207267608,
0.066614233,
-0.0256906655,
0.0312108956,
-0.0420619287,
0.0207913239,
-0.0737878978,
-0.0072314083,
0.0585758984,
0.0012846792,
0.0220272336,
0.0138016352,
0.0555380285,
-0.0334069058,
-0.0007960997,
0.0108813364,
0.0327571593,
0.0175237767,
0.0730557814,
0.0366928913,
-0.0211638082,
-0.0323978625,
-0.0194886066,
-0.011331968,
0.0203478131,
0.0133457705,
-0.0184483677,
-5.498619843e-33,
-0.0133428471,
0.0442232527,
0.0003865546,
-0.0131290071,
-0.0019189994,
-0.0009807862,
-0.0117098168,
-0.0093416013,
-0.0066607706,
0.0095779765,
0.0156518556,
0.0158030186,
0.0155133596,
-0.0053226454,
0.0661028475,
-0.0186542533,
0.0464056842,
-0.0245581586,
-0.0271947924,
0.0456515588,
0.0536053479,
0.0443236865,
0.0294962674,
-0.0477651097,
0.0060178414,
0.0337406732,
0.0151648568,
-0.0000099729,
0.0178862922,
0.028764898,
0.0080388002,
0.0019024209,
0.0030518337,
-0.0463788286,
-0.0265758857,
0.0133044226,
-0.0518943965,
-0.054724589,
-0.0232970994,
0.0107838176,
-0.0937483162,
-0.0534620434,
0.0251715221,
-0.0106859915,
-0.0462592877,
-0.046458479,
0.0697512701,
0.0373523347,
0.0040623411,
-0.0501151495,
-0.0841297954,
-0.0045237774,
0.0091893543,
-0.0202087648,
0.0291737076,
0.0383603759,
-0.0039738333,
-0.037519563,
-0.0294548068,
0.0159495678,
-0.0210732892,
0.0288564116,
0.0092088412,
0.0468357652,
-0.0085566407,
0.0071600024,
0.0534964614,
-0.003884203,
0.0128364116,
0.0216992106,
-0.0162517503,
0.03926697,
-0.0125679839,
-0.0158814583,
0.0476840548,
-0.0263061915,
-0.0519403182,
-0.0077410433,
0.0030317812,
0.0319712572,
-0.0112420777,
0.0145908333,
-0.0252712984,
0.0204097703,
0.002685314,
-0.0039566183,
0.0042832484,
-0.0345385224,
0.0281032957,
0.0376004837,
-0.024658164,
0.0177592952,
0.0386869274,
-0.0167106725,
0.0556309819,
-0.0158703085,
0.017273277,
0.0005731578,
0.0504849479,
-0.0133004747,
-0.0383620411,
-0.0880326927,
0.0117872562,
-0.001708194,
0.0599163286,
0.0004336872,
0.0324594043,
-0.0035544995,
-0.0403633639,
-0.0013996731,
-0.0354277715,
0.0349867716,
0.0364296809,
0.0665223524,
0.0174232461,
0.0175895486,
-0.0196407549,
0.060333401,
-0.0407086574,
-0.0256610289,
-0.0428255387,
-0.031650912,
-0.0214125067,
0.0377792716,
-0.0292565804,
0.0137792611,
-0.0351636298,
-0.0128378784,
-0.0506144427,
-0.0583494045,
-0.0237090234,
0.0435452238,
2.616e-7,
-0.030850593,
0.0139719136,
-0.004394901,
0.0435366482,
-0.003557682,
-0.0051164222,
-0.004547304,
0.0461265557,
-0.0264142659,
-0.061180979,
-0.0032700985,
0.0398153812,
0.0334188342,
0.0171983447,
-0.0429310836,
-0.0252389312,
0.003821281,
0.0597744323,
-0.0351192281,
0.0482578911,
-0.0148615679,
0.0697742403,
-0.0100630866,
0.0331483036,
0.0357774012,
0.043136172,
0.0177144371,
0.0119979298,
0.0098378053,
0.0167657267,
-0.0135094356,
0.0460513569,
-0.0289427899,
0.0296576582,
-0.0463231206,
0.0360391214,
-0.0042944979,
0.0529816188,
-0.0102921883,
-0.0103906039,
0.0143108396,
0.021128444,
0.0098525612,
0.0062844465,
0.0556157641,
-0.0287690368,
0.0372224227,
-0.0233530216,
0.0020312765,
0.0257320534,
0.0294678211,
-0.0236377679,
0.0383379497,
-0.0085806018,
0.0316625498,
0.004459993,
-0.0435754098,
-0.0610296763,
0.014289652,
0.0887441859,
-0.0182904601,
-0.0586033612,
-0.0353806317,
0.0253886264,
0.0215438996,
-0.0109319799,
0.0014090794,
1.812456513e-34,
0.0059741102,
-0.0173602682,
0.034391962,
-0.0077822749,
0.0122520477,
-0.0165243521,
-0.0770199597,
-0.0087273391,
0.0556091592,
-0.0177976154,
-0.0312550403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09996v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09996v2 | Investigating Prompting Techniques for Zero- and Few-Shot Visual Question Answering | 2023-06-16T17:47:57 | 2024-01-09T21:51:04 | Rabiul Awal, Le Zhang, Aishwarya Agrawal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In this paper, we explore effective prompting techniques to enhance zero- and
few-shot Visual Question Answering (VQA) performance in contemporary
Vision-Language Models (VLMs). Central to our investigation is the role of
question templates in guiding VLMs to generate accurate answers. We identify
that specific templates significantly influence VQA outcomes, underscoring the
need for strategic template selection. Another pivotal aspect of our study is
augmenting VLMs with image captions, providing them with additional visual cues
alongside direct image features in VQA tasks. Surprisingly, this augmentation
significantly improves the VLMs' performance in many cases, even though VLMs
"see" the image directly! We explore chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning and find
that while standard CoT reasoning causes drops in performance, advanced methods
like self-consistency can help recover it. Furthermore, we find that text-only
few-shot examples enhance VLMs' alignment with the task format, particularly
benefiting models prone to verbose zero-shot answers. Lastly, to mitigate the
challenges associated with evaluating free-form open-ended VQA responses using
string-matching based VQA metrics, we introduce a straightforward LLM-guided
pre-processing technique to adapt the model responses to the expected
ground-truth answer distribution. In summary, our research sheds light on the
intricacies of prompting strategies in VLMs for VQA, emphasizing the
synergistic use of captions, templates, and pre-processing to enhance model
efficacy. | [
0.0311924722,
0.0175941028,
-0.0115668513,
0.0400225855,
-0.0275488421,
0.014578023,
0.0340285338,
0.0083549572,
0.0116595803,
-0.0752410591,
-0.011773508,
-0.015110747,
-0.0121070743,
0.0328223556,
0.030050844,
-0.0531373657,
0.0515667275,
-0.0569401346,
0.0035781772,
-0.0067592887,
0.0209322181,
-0.0108013395,
-0.0155914044,
0.0248106811,
-0.0185817908,
-0.049955897,
-0.0298072807,
0.0254595801,
0.0029778576,
-0.0334229767,
-0.0421134531,
0.0473891757,
0.0229607709,
-0.0169541351,
0.0000021126,
-0.0309510026,
0.0355989896,
-0.0043095388,
-0.0227478724,
-0.0016811534,
-0.0242053028,
-0.0075762239,
0.0402528085,
0.0292987358,
-0.0437672734,
-0.0087446151,
0.054634504,
0.0455822311,
0.0517494902,
0.0081993854,
-0.0060622753,
0.0063723382,
-0.015082784,
0.0029706543,
0.048157122,
-0.0148038194,
-0.0088406987,
0.032358788,
0.0123492815,
0.0029637739,
-0.0561122969,
0.0603412539,
0.0212889295,
0.006401483,
0.0096554663,
0.0588150471,
-0.0447952934,
-0.0394247435,
-0.0317558758,
0.0793590024,
0.0219582636,
-0.0174649283,
-0.0069716582,
-0.0134385685,
0.0256519746,
0.0126026804,
-0.0767966881,
0.0353228673,
-0.0055802171,
-0.0155438744,
-0.0563720725,
0.0229648668,
-0.0138741639,
0.0051165386,
-0.0039512059,
-0.0070050331,
0.0028661587,
-0.0069456338,
-0.0228485055,
0.015659675,
-0.0277359951,
-0.0944159105,
-0.0489237122,
0.0592542291,
-0.0031154167,
0.008114635,
-0.0332904607,
-0.0091947308,
0.0020170531,
-0.0096163852,
0.0625411943,
0.0440684482,
-0.0526903532,
0.0607634559,
-0.0463481918,
0.0731035843,
-0.0101689771,
0.0341288708,
-0.0429593101,
-0.0044781216,
-0.0332334675,
-0.0313935429,
-0.0471367314,
0.0349786542,
-0.033431001,
-0.0469958484,
0.0078696543,
0.0406519137,
-0.010176898,
-0.0058846972,
-0.0035063359,
0.0483284406,
0.0219016168,
0.0041980664,
-0.0833534822,
0.053767778,
-0.0292775538,
0.0014202984,
-0.0079506561,
-0.0672034025,
-0.0193676148,
0.0265857745,
0.0163088031,
-0.0156761929,
0.0039563454,
0.0580224805,
-0.0326890834,
-0.0299368184,
-0.0076869149,
-0.0244931448,
-0.0194718167,
-0.0245605446,
0.0348633118,
-0.0708747208,
0.0054418729,
0.0249391701,
-0.0166271869,
0.0218868274,
0.0143946651,
0.0422936343,
-0.0302035231,
0.0776982307,
-0.0106964326,
0.0133574232,
-0.0043177954,
0.0065195151,
-0.0067792377,
0.0667076558,
0.015565333,
0.0245933719,
0.0324190632,
-0.01065352,
0.0504775643,
0.0232633427,
-0.003079091,
-0.001805629,
-0.0536764637,
0.0467315614,
0.0131032411,
0.0115721766,
0.0502773598,
0.0376921482,
-0.0171628483,
-0.0188395064,
0.0691654682,
0.066093348,
0.003972549,
-0.0292748902,
0.0327176824,
-0.0189401992,
0.0116681177,
0.0352510847,
-0.0614797212,
0.0970174894,
-0.0243094806,
0.0152109535,
-0.0117424,
0.0249835756,
-0.0511380583,
-0.0448261686,
-0.0211563986,
0.0311768074,
-0.007552024,
0.0579742603,
0.0110513195,
0.0137235587,
-0.0416432396,
0.0120870024,
-0.0240670647,
-0.0393630192,
-0.0246647801,
-0.0438019633,
0.0564571507,
0.053153418,
0.0514711998,
0.0404781885,
-0.0524585135,
0.0158381276,
0.0428555869,
0.0358144902,
0.0096941954,
0.0199373923,
0.0053918548,
-0.0297280513,
-0.0325519927,
-0.0281779189,
-0.0080350162,
-0.0085856067,
-0.0051388289,
-0.0113736195,
0.0029316123,
-0.0270770807,
0.0072572753,
0.0288633071,
0.0447069779,
-0.0332857743,
-0.0268795136,
0.0233988632,
-0.0258631613,
-0.0167410281,
-0.0066205584,
0.0219230037,
0.0102844518,
-0.0136195458,
0.00507901,
0.0049323286,
-0.0485997126,
-0.0333243124,
0.0178787392,
-0.03489279,
-0.0186447073,
-0.0061309575,
-0.0338974893,
-0.0232007932,
0.0005047721,
-0.0256979968,
-0.0236403383,
-0.068336308,
-0.0160214696,
0.0312772058,
0.0013043527,
-0.0172738191,
0.0491883792,
-0.0158147439,
-0.0120575838,
0.0350758359,
-0.0209047608,
0.0254277345,
-0.040512722,
0.0085065169,
-0.0097933486,
-0.0017065875,
0.0011766561,
0.0085946294,
0.0262512453,
-0.0630916655,
0.0077565652,
-0.1011531651,
-0.022384638,
-0.0189575516,
-0.0120059764,
0.0063009877,
0.0030885257,
-0.01293696,
-0.0435185656,
-0.0568759441,
0.016122628,
0.0170414504,
0.0278685037,
0.0441821553,
-0.0058807833,
0.0085927788,
-0.0145204067,
0.0021788192,
0.0088619543,
0.0602026395,
0.0103558386,
-0.014199608,
-0.0132709322,
0.018436363,
-0.0631971583,
0.0442633443,
-0.0070760716,
-0.0062316037,
0.0324435681,
-0.0056384499,
0.0274191555,
0.0765331984,
-0.0134135569,
-0.0278175641,
0.0354807898,
-0.0136689851,
-0.0504356325,
0.0175046623,
0.0235579871,
-0.062677443,
0.0238060802,
-0.030914478,
-0.0279013962,
0.0211511347,
-0.0213456359,
-0.0005635041,
-0.0761854425,
0.0508976839,
0.0301457699,
-0.0584844947,
-0.0838237926,
0.0111285187,
0.0139405308,
0.0668299496,
-0.030596761,
-0.0662685111,
0.0482642762,
-0.0519228242,
-0.0108970078,
0.0408720374,
0.0261875428,
-0.035163261,
0.0850935876,
0.0144394198,
-0.0058753151,
0.0231353343,
0.0239101481,
-0.074609898,
-0.038829729,
0.0012194833,
-0.0134773841,
0.0532193705,
-0.0501488894,
0.0123238377,
-0.0401759483,
-0.0113233775,
-0.0616056472,
-0.0202015899,
-0.0403017439,
0.0163209196,
-0.0881629363,
0.0161057487,
0.0088104308,
0.0286648441,
0.0456046723,
0.0089101912,
-0.0171148386,
-0.0129873203,
-0.0234045722,
0.0352455825,
0.0788820907,
0.0427328236,
0.0045991777,
-0.0188477486,
0.0439095385,
0.0723191574,
0.0297666024,
0.0090086116,
-0.0428452194,
0.0088076275,
0.030875314,
0.0253074802,
0.0012710768,
0.0575016811,
0.0579173118,
-0.0541151427,
-0.0015640326,
0.0988698676,
0.0335648656,
-0.0093106423,
-0.0179621354,
-0.0361434482,
0.0427020527,
0.0578080416,
0.0433739536,
-0.1020965651,
-0.0449574925,
-0.009051769,
-0.0065950421,
-0.0149712749,
-0.0064346958,
-0.0293122828,
-0.099569127,
0.0573109277,
-0.019576069,
0.0111053195,
0.0094826436,
0.0087312413,
-0.0040039164,
0.0250653382,
-0.0221257638,
-0.0027032632,
-0.0235211123,
0.0330794305,
-0.0001303524,
0.0131786019,
0.0088230753,
0.0370815285,
-0.0635825619,
-0.0094231805,
0.0579204969,
-0.0230014306,
0.0042613647,
-0.0830812007,
0.0172683503,
-0.0313091613,
0.0422767289,
-0.0233246442,
0.0556103401,
-0.0188278053,
-0.0336764231,
-0.0026284286,
0.0017251653,
-0.0060804933,
-0.0116010047,
0.0072546159,
0.0483782738,
-0.0247440245,
-0.0133155175,
-0.0526123233,
0.0112463264,
-0.0347022451,
0.0561698452,
0.0454871133,
-0.0193452947,
-0.0422601849,
-0.0040808306,
-0.0186431091,
-0.0489572957,
-0.0426517203,
-0.0107550835,
0.0489858016,
0.0214165952,
-0.0760470927,
-0.0334538668,
0.0702584162,
0.0549018532,
-0.0354450084,
-0.008622624,
-0.041354984,
0.0336354561,
-0.0405445881,
0.0627029315,
-0.0442869142,
0.0330982096,
-0.046824649,
0.0272392742,
0.0088964552,
-0.0455081016,
-0.0190459155,
0.0057877991,
-0.0708259419,
-0.0075112735,
-0.0521152504,
0.0813168511,
0.0173675176,
0.0113559449,
0.0327226892,
-0.0433579758,
0.0165371615,
0.0518346354,
0.0374857932,
0.0433165729,
-0.0038967112,
-0.0160695724,
0.0044472665,
0.0149934785,
-0.0533985943,
0.0029813994,
0.0142508838,
0.0406262949,
-0.0086167399,
-0.0204141643,
0.0296873935,
0.0303880423,
0.0392848365,
0.0023920392,
0.0258395113,
0.0199904926,
0.0354094058,
-0.0042581498,
0.0009591001,
-0.0684723482,
0.0021498334,
-0.0091686435,
0.0147761554,
0.0116998069,
-0.0148263453,
-0.0504261851,
0.0345855616,
-0.0519967638,
-0.0333105214,
0.0201005656,
-0.0245752148,
-0.0254331883,
0.0078159943,
-0.0114073241,
-0.0004572091,
-0.000376516,
0.0397660658,
0.0132458303,
0.0982085988,
0.0139621468,
-0.0064468174,
-0.0416854993,
0.0473086946,
-0.0348197073,
-0.0612651855,
0.0162920188,
0.0370717868,
0.0340603814,
0.002937665,
-0.03547417,
0.0013565639,
-0.0106149334,
0.0022918803,
-0.0117607657,
0.0218230058,
-0.0290346667,
0.0914502665,
0.0419330224,
-0.0009235506,
-0.0321319215,
0.0496944375,
0.0113735255,
0.0187044982,
-0.0004226402,
-0.0025947399,
0.00033663,
-0.0296680816,
0.0250523686,
-0.0201742314,
0.018307833,
0.0438069291,
-0.0767499432,
-0.0661651939,
0.0070912242,
0.0365775451,
-0.0103047304,
-0.0083826855,
0.0517581925,
0.039188467,
0.0462166183,
-0.0387772322,
0.0055571506,
-0.0110795712,
-0.0158894472,
0.0072775851,
-0.0215300228,
-6.349797874e-33,
-0.0284472592,
-0.0518341027,
0.0655190721,
-0.0209474303,
-0.0044012615,
0.0176247638,
-0.0141138211,
0.0173980966,
-0.0222596638,
-0.0148729607,
-0.0091755567,
-0.0127716539,
-0.0006949067,
0.0216906331,
-0.009259223,
-0.0351241753,
0.019313978,
-0.0019789746,
-0.0299679395,
-0.041180741,
0.0032818597,
-0.0164484698,
0.0020006495,
-0.0094692651,
-0.0051637203,
0.0056308103,
-0.0100824591,
0.0189421121,
-0.0088663753,
0.074812673,
-0.013678709,
0.0084671844,
0.0265946537,
0.004990269,
-0.0218511,
0.0309108607,
-0.059267018,
-0.0407586507,
0.0800249875,
-0.0017324863,
-0.0962540805,
0.0063060783,
0.0091788704,
-0.0066985036,
-0.0023737077,
-0.0495161377,
0.0326398835,
-0.0089277131,
-0.0062329718,
0.0095655723,
-0.0111491038,
-0.0192208234,
0.0029251024,
-0.0599700361,
0.0203061774,
0.0786277205,
0.0122258542,
0.0479007773,
-0.0203109048,
0.0128188711,
0.0229747407,
0.0079422351,
0.1185145453,
0.0536705479,
0.0033671726,
0.0424562395,
0.0099669164,
-0.0230914056,
-0.0808563307,
-0.0448756889,
0.0076081618,
0.0376560465,
0.0759598687,
0.0238280296,
0.0312182251,
0.0608143359,
-0.0409332141,
0.0159479212,
-0.0755005181,
0.0747370124,
0.0039869277,
-0.0024347084,
-0.0147685753,
-0.0025293846,
-0.0636941493,
0.0008304054,
-0.0767498016,
-0.0047107539,
0.0678657293,
0.0211519375,
-0.0036023371,
0.0244108699,
0.0708877668,
-0.029711321,
0.0208878778,
0.0060898494,
-0.0174032338,
0.0581160672,
0.0124061713,
0.025516022,
-0.0212070011,
0.0468741171,
0.0717170238,
0.0055109006,
-0.0007042994,
0.0305351317,
0.0284667127,
-0.00298505,
-0.0438033938,
-0.0257728882,
-0.0466644876,
0.0094718672,
-0.0407965146,
-0.0224411786,
0.0179913174,
0.0361000299,
-0.0669168979,
0.0156366024,
-0.0360802449,
-0.0612607747,
-0.0340370126,
0.0059150322,
-0.02311836,
0.0197249446,
-0.0299946498,
0.0141880773,
-0.033626873,
0.0041809333,
-0.0078634871,
-0.0612235405,
-0.0224934798,
0.0716816038,
2.674e-7,
0.0203883089,
0.0082743466,
0.0056834444,
0.0415053442,
0.0060230745,
0.0571301132,
-0.0255990848,
0.0008359106,
0.0382213704,
-0.0577985272,
-0.0038594329,
0.0696443245,
0.0186078846,
-0.0144325066,
-0.007879423,
0.0575900562,
-0.0405110605,
-0.000415729,
-0.0375446789,
-0.0061170934,
0.0639740005,
0.0361609533,
-0.0436726324,
-0.0081302961,
0.0373035409,
-0.0362307504,
0.0701047555,
-0.0222897138,
0.0041605723,
-0.0423291512,
0.0109321605,
-0.0006622765,
0.011076292,
0.0390884653,
0.0055532344,
-0.0217142478,
0.0249677245,
0.0033464595,
-0.0238010902,
-0.0310405232,
-0.0493188314,
0.0072302488,
0.004043187,
-0.0703330338,
0.1169769093,
-0.0544131733,
0.0000633659,
-0.0067848219,
-0.0319953635,
0.0135051291,
0.0179343317,
0.0068909773,
-0.0349594466,
0.0186105371,
0.0369824246,
-0.011230438,
-0.0340209156,
-0.0598858669,
-0.023619134,
-0.0288113523,
-0.0101936646,
-0.0347403176,
-0.0719440356,
-0.0031748395,
0.0280362424,
-0.0137898056,
-0.075402759,
2.210271467e-34,
0.0228315704,
-0.0106039252,
0.0377174281,
0.0304676816,
0.0020522447,
-0.0151411593,
-0.0203120057,
-0.0123257721,
0.0204040222,
-0.0925114453,
-0.0178163014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09992v1 | Rewriting the Script: Adapting Text Instructions for Voice Interaction | 2023-06-16T17:43:00 | 2023-06-16T17:43:00 | Alyssa Hwang, Natasha Oza, Chris Callison-Burch, Andrew Head | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | Voice assistants have sharply risen in popularity in recent years, but their
use has been limited mostly to simple applications like music, hands-free
search, or control of internet-of-things devices. What would it take for voice
assistants to guide people through more complex tasks? In our work, we study
the limitations of the dominant approach voice assistants take to complex task
guidance: reading aloud written instructions. Using recipes as an example, we
observe twelve participants cook at home with a state-of-the-art voice
assistant. We learn that the current approach leads to nine challenges,
including obscuring the bigger picture, overwhelming users with too much
information, and failing to communicate affordances. Instructions delivered by
a voice assistant are especially difficult because they cannot be skimmed as
easily as written instructions. Alexa in particular did not surface crucial
details to the user or answer questions well. We draw on our observations to
propose eight ways in which voice assistants can ``rewrite the script'' --
summarizing, signposting, splitting, elaborating, volunteering, reordering,
redistributing, and visualizing -- to transform written sources into forms that
are readily communicated through spoken conversation. We conclude with a vision
of how modern advancements in natural language processing can be leveraged for
intelligent agents to guide users effectively through complex tasks. | [
0.0236684456,
0.0096091181,
-0.031357307,
-0.0231709145,
-0.018199468,
-0.0212957617,
-0.0016015869,
0.0301053114,
0.0190094989,
-0.0398603566,
0.0145534975,
0.0070821331,
0.0400763042,
0.0103047825,
-0.0274278857,
-0.10371162,
-0.0168308578,
-0.015324383,
0.0506134555,
0.0248434339,
0.0271487907,
0.0171318483,
-0.0388446823,
0.0474815145,
-0.0017261237,
-0.00062379,
-0.0294670109,
0.0117997564,
0.0009040591,
-0.0389018245,
-0.0268008839,
0.0460675731,
0.0018071687,
-0.0239514895,
0.0000018028,
-0.0243161209,
0.0380126163,
-0.0200397652,
-0.0647490695,
0.003210742,
0.0297304951,
0.0153990379,
-0.0136657609,
0.0223698728,
-0.0310605988,
0.0222058278,
0.0589658134,
0.0784716234,
0.0052611101,
0.0562547557,
0.0045306468,
-0.0283447765,
-0.0141111463,
0.0150067974,
0.0444016755,
0.0001415833,
-0.0449787788,
-0.0352234431,
0.0812002793,
0.0065064374,
-0.0093216803,
0.0667485073,
0.0213840343,
-0.0107368445,
-0.0128670372,
0.0531070381,
-0.0178047121,
-0.0345719159,
-0.0328379013,
0.0684272945,
0.0296926796,
0.0232784953,
0.0117167979,
-0.0025887885,
-0.0154651171,
0.0268999729,
-0.036821872,
0.0013959801,
-0.0187896155,
-0.0182939507,
-0.0509434864,
0.0123954415,
0.0151094729,
-0.0224266946,
0.0711691901,
0.0300865676,
-0.0024152566,
-0.0274650771,
-0.0113731958,
0.0094742533,
0.0297923889,
-0.0784869194,
0.0314884037,
0.0420597419,
-0.0096832793,
0.0347946249,
-0.0209738091,
-0.0200053584,
-0.007132384,
0.0067799161,
0.0960539803,
0.0429101214,
-0.0503452308,
0.0050727595,
0.033150956,
0.0336796977,
0.0146700684,
-0.0161162633,
-0.0653109699,
0.0578244478,
-0.0320591293,
-0.0207294021,
-0.0398103893,
0.003380687,
-0.0655824542,
-0.0321461968,
0.0264548603,
-0.0036657655,
0.0000962352,
0.0181427728,
-0.0123809278,
0.0491307825,
-0.0247878041,
0.0053072129,
-0.0209628064,
0.0180529952,
-0.0454128012,
0.0518644638,
-0.0019810053,
-0.0170513373,
0.0066728014,
-0.0201084763,
0.0467357598,
0.0629286319,
0.0010455626,
0.028218057,
-0.0455175601,
-0.0425505824,
0.0113057988,
-0.0243661217,
-0.033761844,
-0.0285061654,
-0.0003749105,
-0.0315178782,
0.0555243008,
0.0025705681,
-0.0014768714,
-0.0107077528,
0.0192368142,
0.059124101,
-0.0403706506,
0.0615802705,
0.040278282,
0.0376200564,
0.0618263558,
0.0506787002,
-0.0414828137,
-0.0158024076,
0.0632596761,
-0.0084459465,
0.0324062891,
-0.0109419059,
0.0595238395,
0.0086699082,
-0.0380048305,
0.0259838253,
0.0042790305,
-0.0237153322,
-0.0634957477,
0.0191493258,
-0.0108694518,
0.0516360104,
-0.0017521717,
0.0487953611,
0.1167396531,
0.1002812833,
0.0050054989,
0.0000321401,
0.0314746425,
0.0454359241,
0.0349782631,
0.0171943791,
-0.0186406691,
0.0122250151,
-0.0376896821,
-0.0056092418,
0.000533209,
-0.0392535105,
-0.0268893968,
-0.0479115024,
-0.0039839349,
-0.012132871,
0.0661230832,
-0.0056024236,
-0.009143129,
0.0248494409,
-0.0259975679,
-0.0665448084,
-0.0081570912,
-0.094138734,
-0.0015811569,
-0.0093951747,
0.0324070491,
0.1212745234,
0.0153192831,
-0.0094934395,
0.0208500177,
0.0129656093,
0.0485346988,
0.0123226708,
-0.0091954414,
-0.0195099525,
0.0225745607,
-0.013890761,
-0.0222375765,
0.0013488198,
0.0104040578,
0.006104649,
-0.0125540905,
-0.0005410793,
0.010307312,
-0.0088720983,
-0.0119740041,
0.0079815127,
-0.0035250564,
-0.0629699454,
-0.0139378905,
0.0248885173,
-0.0246359874,
0.0609230734,
-0.0071778325,
0.0021926942,
0.0015336332,
-0.0137386788,
-0.0146575486,
0.0335079618,
-0.03937646,
0.0273389891,
-0.0391412452,
-0.0673613623,
0.0176434238,
0.0281503219,
0.014690618,
-0.0338384956,
0.0206247773,
-0.0535080843,
0.0006966719,
0.04182541,
-0.003355935,
0.0356196165,
-0.021004729,
0.0178058445,
0.0140840169,
-0.0091108326,
-0.0130305868,
0.0097634308,
0.012993251,
-0.0464949422,
-0.0363983586,
0.0297913477,
0.0140377348,
0.0173095986,
0.0395208821,
0.0222588927,
0.0227549523,
-0.0354307666,
-0.0158232357,
-0.1022969112,
-0.0303151701,
-0.0283197034,
-0.0315898471,
0.0426065139,
0.0217164438,
-0.0055629346,
-0.0462206826,
-0.0292839538,
0.000686245,
-0.0267824996,
0.0040515456,
0.0013777058,
0.0258297641,
-0.0348357409,
-0.0364583619,
0.0041960063,
0.0054396084,
-0.0107296798,
0.0282090511,
-0.0013744708,
-0.0811204836,
-0.0388993472,
0.0041065034,
0.0085076308,
-0.0205173325,
0.0062401886,
0.0140710566,
0.0115344543,
0.0219396148,
0.0485690236,
-0.0019673249,
0.0478895903,
0.0337034576,
-0.0193471964,
-0.015497976,
0.0062782578,
0.0011381606,
0.0333578214,
-0.0427895598,
-0.0417284109,
0.0341462679,
0.0106546218,
0.0593209974,
0.0822893679,
-0.0372068435,
-0.0308913123,
-0.0291480105,
-0.0603367537,
-0.0011412972,
-0.0443095565,
-0.0454151742,
0.058544971,
0.0025378473,
-0.0344201066,
0.0461067371,
-0.0407438911,
-0.0233780909,
-0.0677571967,
-0.0512640923,
-0.0163923036,
0.0710501075,
-0.0155149866,
0.0329824872,
0.017750401,
-0.0324820317,
-0.0337293819,
0.0028155113,
0.0003633901,
-0.0450500995,
0.076507628,
-0.0836362466,
-0.0337362289,
0.0243707299,
-0.0376255512,
-0.0129489694,
-0.0259246845,
-0.0393961817,
-0.0159265324,
0.035218928,
-0.0274190828,
-0.035707131,
-0.018463444,
0.0238759685,
0.073548384,
0.0646663532,
-0.0082798842,
-0.0249911156,
-0.0138737839,
0.0193894319,
0.0122400774,
-0.0623576082,
0.0074101849,
0.0682764798,
0.0237186588,
0.0518072546,
-0.0297464468,
-0.00446501,
0.029446112,
0.0404047891,
-0.0225328375,
-0.0379300155,
0.0729433075,
0.0717269629,
-0.0434967093,
0.0150173223,
0.07776317,
0.0141520081,
-0.0392092057,
0.028643202,
-0.0106752822,
-0.022950843,
-0.0027272766,
0.0312496182,
-0.0815539584,
-0.021455247,
0.0267888289,
0.0549116619,
-0.0148063656,
-0.0054593217,
-0.0270026177,
-0.106096454,
0.0313520692,
-0.0013667946,
-0.039697323,
-0.0290349349,
-0.0256449021,
0.0133326305,
0.017147474,
0.0362650827,
-0.0187733509,
-0.0494009256,
-0.0119049707,
-0.0156942755,
-0.0299750753,
0.024620533,
0.0255706124,
-0.0344124511,
0.0534468703,
0.0756903738,
0.0258022435,
0.0186444744,
0.012593112,
-0.0263250526,
0.0006049685,
0.0559350662,
-0.0031245202,
0.0682804063,
-0.007670227,
-0.0063930107,
-0.0101650106,
0.0636271313,
-0.0058177221,
-0.0355266407,
0.0384911485,
0.0140878092,
-0.012735148,
-0.0295329597,
-0.008845103,
0.0461258292,
0.0658136606,
0.0234860312,
0.0171537977,
-0.0581600033,
-0.0214955751,
-0.0383856855,
-0.0066198022,
-0.0163587444,
-0.041720368,
0.0369880795,
-0.0400427692,
-0.0301334988,
-0.0758117437,
-0.0686580762,
0.0526649989,
0.0205270834,
0.0482235625,
-0.0159785207,
0.0539824031,
0.0537921824,
0.0050031296,
-0.0279150233,
-0.0092351474,
0.0123703806,
-0.0341160409,
-0.0629002601,
-0.0168626532,
-0.0482451618,
0.0284038298,
0.0200379081,
-0.037392322,
-0.0434716791,
0.0295759626,
0.0394906215,
0.0226906929,
0.0629151687,
-0.0030773049,
-0.0645825863,
0.0157776754,
-0.0121267531,
-0.0650966391,
0.0358231701,
0.0077294335,
0.0191558059,
0.0125067113,
0.0119758826,
-0.0508456007,
0.0286509618,
-0.0616451986,
0.0216568336,
-0.0686975047,
-0.0838965848,
0.0029803172,
0.0019527599,
0.0213978328,
-0.0024661624,
0.057935603,
-0.02278536,
0.0270595048,
-0.0253661703,
-0.0092932908,
-0.0403525755,
0.0070760897,
-0.0084013557,
0.0144903902,
0.011009099,
0.0266609248,
-0.0320663452,
-0.0037092706,
-0.064010717,
0.0156758949,
0.0067501031,
0.0178357102,
0.0071411794,
0.0296349581,
-0.0046021943,
0.0634767041,
-0.0061856327,
0.0305173937,
0.0410569645,
0.0481433198,
-0.0045188908,
-0.0361544676,
-0.0489308126,
0.0447727032,
-0.0587702654,
-0.083108522,
0.0354188085,
0.0242036898,
-0.0152562223,
-0.0439935997,
0.03858383,
-0.0182663091,
0.0369356126,
-0.0022189287,
0.0372410305,
-0.0026395808,
-0.0145526137,
0.0273453034,
0.0080011999,
0.0185973421,
0.0056885658,
0.0469396114,
-0.0454808362,
0.068516992,
0.0058699651,
0.0008009255,
-0.0433727391,
-0.0358906686,
0.0256090797,
0.0162131023,
-0.0317515172,
-0.0392982587,
-0.03610548,
-0.002542601,
0.0093570203,
-0.0352395065,
0.0137102846,
-0.0782084316,
0.0488011166,
0.0035146764,
-0.0113888578,
-0.0174447726,
-0.0092617702,
-0.0183513127,
-0.0866805092,
-0.0108695738,
0.0111280242,
-5.591538263e-33,
-0.0058410391,
-0.0499309935,
0.0175336935,
0.0298098475,
0.0127960974,
-0.0051990515,
-0.0288217254,
0.0296243764,
0.0259463768,
0.0129139731,
-0.0135601209,
-0.0106194001,
0.0151076689,
0.0105848853,
0.0243463702,
-0.0597079657,
0.0538025945,
-0.006029706,
-0.0363291204,
0.0277251676,
0.0281553641,
-0.0095387036,
-0.0099690491,
-0.0972879454,
0.0108978366,
0.0018168676,
-0.015816899,
-0.0265170746,
0.0303981174,
-0.0012516041,
-0.0137096914,
0.0391906276,
0.006792923,
-0.01858945,
-0.0179611184,
0.1023630053,
-0.0394899957,
-0.0402552523,
0.0019819317,
0.0234790854,
-0.0858612657,
-0.0240034182,
-0.0017792231,
0.0173143763,
-0.0080379648,
0.0282851383,
0.0402969718,
0.0118596507,
0.0128338793,
0.0118754553,
-0.0730625913,
-0.006811243,
-0.0388466008,
-0.0760458857,
0.0068803304,
0.0738946497,
0.0357793607,
-0.0501696318,
-0.0791575611,
0.0417265669,
-0.0000528429,
0.0030156975,
0.0305579659,
-0.0041897255,
-0.0471607111,
0.0402942672,
0.0149848033,
-0.0163049791,
-0.0462815352,
0.0008064476,
-0.0365343243,
0.0721123219,
-0.0039293431,
-0.0051870747,
0.0255025867,
-0.0188919399,
0.0338013694,
0.03191939,
-0.0250191689,
0.0028646826,
-0.0189681668,
0.0391793996,
-0.07377363,
-0.0015901595,
-0.0495484285,
-0.021236049,
-0.0145459594,
-0.038321238,
0.0255997553,
0.0297511145,
-0.0203689709,
-0.0255331285,
-0.018003257,
0.0193600524,
0.0279597454,
-0.0548867583,
-0.0350489505,
0.0340929963,
-0.0188098811,
-0.0389629416,
-0.058231201,
-0.0053119855,
0.0382805392,
0.0679962635,
0.0429910682,
0.0072528664,
-0.0056774104,
0.0641191974,
-0.0362334438,
-0.0124128927,
0.0118628507,
0.0272795968,
0.0395912714,
-0.0144594125,
0.0468654893,
0.0106605925,
-0.0353973322,
0.0595634878,
-0.0035855542,
-0.0214484204,
-0.0238147359,
-0.0253199823,
0.0185676273,
-0.0714369491,
-0.0377470702,
0.0144661935,
-0.0470949784,
0.0149587924,
0.0776458234,
-0.0310995728,
-0.0095476583,
-0.003947075,
2.659e-7,
0.0201341752,
0.0324318334,
0.0485149212,
0.0140516357,
-0.0062460341,
0.0493472815,
0.0247449614,
0.0404267535,
-0.0236046538,
-0.0053980267,
0.0360524692,
0.0048353835,
0.0311384071,
0.0193041321,
-0.0718646795,
-0.0583691597,
-0.0626222566,
0.038398385,
-0.0464010797,
0.0136944354,
0.0937553868,
0.0224176943,
0.0102060921,
-0.0060796253,
-0.0317350924,
-0.0340588912,
0.0193784274,
-0.0412372425,
0.0594114885,
-0.055855915,
0.0107814949,
-0.0052585648,
-0.0247238614,
-0.0306344889,
-0.0328403041,
-0.0095377201,
0.0181930512,
0.0728078708,
-0.0151801761,
-0.0286233928,
-0.0178481229,
0.0336371735,
-0.0104991235,
-0.002088567,
0.0307023749,
-0.0357092768,
-0.0288670212,
0.0340971611,
0.0288073365,
-0.0012254198,
-0.014759453,
-0.0096307024,
0.0022463803,
-0.0048598591,
-0.0139223114,
-0.0066879452,
-0.0176240504,
-0.0630987808,
-0.0213739313,
0.034164872,
-0.0139423935,
-0.0243084934,
-0.0450331531,
0.0085208267,
-0.0319775566,
-0.0621886477,
-0.00406245,
1.626322607e-34,
-0.0186546538,
0.0051016738,
0.0132816704,
0.0308138039,
0.0202362109,
0.0240043662,
0.0082459617,
0.028626034,
0.0457610488,
-0.075164102,
-0.0448454618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10097v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10097v1 | CML-TTS A Multilingual Dataset for Speech Synthesis in Low-Resource Languages | 2023-06-16T17:17:06 | 2023-06-16T17:17:06 | Frederico S. Oliveira, Edresson Casanova, Arnaldo Cândido Júnior, Anderson S. Soares, Arlindo R. Galvão Filho | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL | In this paper, we present CML-TTS, a recursive acronym for
CML-Multi-Lingual-TTS, a new Text-to-Speech (TTS) dataset developed at the
Center of Excellence in Artificial Intelligence (CEIA) of the Federal
University of Goias (UFG). CML-TTS is based on Multilingual LibriSpeech (MLS)
and adapted for training TTS models, consisting of audiobooks in seven
languages: Dutch, French, German, Italian, Portuguese, Polish, and Spanish.
Additionally, we provide the YourTTS model, a multi-lingual TTS model, trained
using 3,176.13 hours from CML-TTS and also with 245.07 hours from LibriTTS, in
English. Our purpose in creating this dataset is to open up new research
possibilities in the TTS area for multi-lingual models. The dataset is publicly
available under the CC-BY 4.0 license1. | [
-0.0308318697,
0.0227097888,
-0.004993116,
0.029422801,
-0.0260477085,
-0.0451070927,
0.0233241897,
-0.0363058336,
-0.0182854272,
0.0087794615,
-0.0725174174,
-0.033704713,
0.0420280695,
-0.0088822963,
0.0653219968,
-0.0759421512,
0.0177318603,
-0.0619583316,
-0.0559186377,
-0.0184791256,
-0.0020132088,
0.0542864054,
-0.007388453,
0.0301966146,
0.0212455057,
0.0049950839,
-0.0024816205,
-0.0021631762,
0.0183429327,
0.0082702311,
-0.0423297212,
-0.0221508741,
0.010776585,
0.0023747589,
0.0000020296,
-0.0641069263,
-0.0218005199,
-0.0195087381,
0.0022906996,
-0.022475604,
0.0572387241,
-0.0137736844,
-0.0213108193,
0.0219672285,
-0.0064819092,
0.0155133605,
0.0012361438,
-0.0051574628,
0.0151048051,
0.0758463293,
-0.0068005305,
-0.0511271916,
-0.0007409732,
-0.0005403555,
-0.0147799682,
0.0273296647,
-0.0385403782,
0.0061058979,
0.0249047969,
-0.0364725962,
-0.0245016292,
0.0449207723,
0.0001189084,
0.017335495,
-0.0500515066,
-0.011247566,
-0.0211570151,
-0.0603509732,
-0.006146892,
0.0722833648,
-0.0001917405,
-0.0245413743,
0.0063959984,
0.0250014234,
0.0030818509,
-0.0299936477,
-0.0037399291,
0.0221465901,
-0.0013488862,
-0.005762591,
0.0329382941,
0.0246782023,
0.0184945203,
-0.054714229,
0.0142457187,
0.0064054825,
0.0361891203,
-0.0467831269,
0.0282298811,
-0.0306561757,
0.0369961075,
-0.0018492509,
0.0219075121,
0.0185928866,
-0.022300642,
0.0014573935,
-0.0483259782,
-0.0330570005,
-0.0281609241,
-0.0336250104,
0.0208906401,
0.0033851175,
-0.0284473095,
-0.0049214838,
-0.0124331443,
0.0042702383,
-0.0275420323,
-0.0085732006,
-0.0563340709,
-0.0401365533,
-0.003740774,
0.0272667445,
-0.0440846197,
0.0077768518,
-0.0519392379,
0.0191694312,
-0.0344392285,
-0.0188550986,
-0.0230191275,
0.0204774756,
0.0264745299,
-0.0055125435,
-0.0379336067,
-0.0384180136,
0.041817911,
0.0250758864,
0.0081649693,
0.0282275174,
-0.0247368254,
-0.0662989244,
0.0201511551,
0.0157080106,
0.0182140972,
-0.0186611619,
0.0425017364,
0.0658660904,
-0.0076139919,
-0.0051999507,
-0.050168477,
-0.0448607542,
-0.0076529314,
-0.064447321,
-0.0057336846,
-0.0787063241,
0.0609390698,
-0.0311607383,
-0.0087071573,
-0.005634597,
-0.0287169199,
-0.0136628179,
0.0224763639,
0.0357363746,
-0.0320350975,
0.0230822172,
0.0303940848,
-0.0058626756,
-0.008252549,
0.0733465701,
0.0822490379,
-0.0332082175,
0.0306272469,
-0.0400006548,
-0.0078451764,
0.0920649618,
0.0053577139,
0.0071734404,
-0.0174033511,
0.0011564535,
-0.0244986024,
0.0338370539,
0.0726293549,
0.0356325321,
-0.0222145766,
0.0263466276,
0.0665417463,
0.0096404431,
0.0715705156,
0.0403220206,
0.0921329632,
-0.0295804422,
0.0224921405,
0.0159324724,
0.0549777336,
-0.0073778704,
-0.0124295009,
0.0483954474,
0.004738695,
0.0703254938,
-0.0280903485,
-0.007337281,
0.0113189854,
-0.0257006641,
-0.0137030706,
-0.0209697988,
0.0240653232,
0.0423549227,
-0.0564382635,
0.058865916,
-0.0131770279,
-0.0904716998,
0.0420345739,
-0.0095243519,
-0.017488515,
0.0594107695,
0.0183946006,
-0.0046381722,
-0.0246372763,
-0.0512383208,
0.0066007674,
0.0493674092,
0.0287742745,
-0.0398409925,
0.062609382,
-0.0859604254,
0.0162040684,
0.009838488,
-0.0383405909,
0.0690774694,
-0.055239737,
0.0457529202,
0.0186195057,
-0.0138054686,
0.0436115637,
-0.0140072182,
-0.059823826,
-0.0030671419,
0.0166137572,
0.0242812149,
0.055125095,
0.0801171809,
-0.0190248266,
0.0240024626,
0.0022733461,
-0.0456350632,
0.0195270255,
0.0579041652,
-0.0330465063,
-0.0450660251,
0.0403645448,
-0.0523169525,
0.0194341037,
0.0283292066,
0.0419110395,
-0.1028020754,
0.0710299462,
-0.0046798135,
0.0447852761,
0.0040954249,
0.0120720482,
0.0224040989,
0.0262209326,
0.0601122566,
-0.0193459187,
-0.0011199231,
0.0366339535,
0.0566052385,
0.0234640539,
0.0391724333,
-0.07239566,
0.0011243162,
0.0332039893,
-0.0188486148,
0.012413688,
0.00622528,
0.0508011207,
-0.0103821829,
-0.0086036716,
-0.0532000028,
0.0040511079,
0.0062407069,
0.0278300662,
-0.0187279675,
0.0362089202,
0.0076289224,
0.0073321918,
-0.0276237931,
-0.0521073118,
0.0261316653,
-0.0143566467,
-0.0303063262,
-0.0231621712,
-0.0476691313,
-0.0269884337,
0.0026294908,
0.0343832448,
0.0045729065,
-0.0465308949,
-0.03624513,
-0.0340491235,
-0.0012739252,
-0.0102062114,
0.0305612162,
0.0102314139,
-0.0372955464,
-0.0081716087,
0.021823056,
0.0988394246,
0.0170495212,
-0.0318237282,
-0.0390307494,
0.0148362406,
-0.0299475268,
-0.0370595455,
0.0235904474,
0.0173179563,
0.0025999371,
-0.0456947125,
-0.0307907425,
0.0260276105,
0.0284732766,
0.0374651998,
-0.0156856477,
-0.0565251559,
-0.0332226381,
0.0095612546,
-0.0319401324,
0.0369086787,
0.0031688453,
-0.0525497943,
0.0062496513,
0.0061310395,
-0.0136138368,
0.0019001225,
-0.0777722299,
-0.0578811355,
-0.0634792969,
-0.0109980982,
-0.0046269153,
0.0070040547,
-0.0217584893,
0.030280415,
-0.0394703448,
-0.0109977005,
-0.0480314456,
0.0245189834,
0.0259438958,
-0.0188498739,
0.0176421162,
-0.0244061425,
-0.0176978502,
-0.0076753618,
-0.0454877354,
0.0119934781,
0.0340765938,
-0.0215922594,
0.019184839,
0.0378697217,
-0.0222876798,
-0.0261852723,
-0.0061804876,
0.0468766876,
0.0502816141,
0.0147910444,
0.0149183804,
-0.0024253787,
0.0341447107,
0.0033719924,
-0.0043204632,
0.008124629,
-0.0204020571,
0.0431803055,
-0.0240787286,
0.0404121913,
-0.008596641,
-0.0348481499,
0.0026964885,
0.0367665626,
0.0331394039,
-0.015414333,
-0.0089888852,
0.0270866435,
-0.0005352804,
0.0037389381,
0.0772666186,
-0.0396033339,
-0.0125265084,
0.0005491769,
-0.0163245834,
0.0404240899,
-0.0118978694,
-0.000752379,
-0.0571947843,
-0.016366275,
0.0499773249,
0.0470991097,
0.0013038792,
0.0359668843,
-0.0391447321,
-0.1306176037,
0.0343872122,
0.0431776717,
-0.0643846914,
-0.0471539907,
-0.0313889198,
-0.0916847959,
-0.0116707273,
0.0096567273,
0.0288111214,
-0.0077092196,
-0.0256701987,
0.0165519565,
-0.0678516254,
-0.0636725426,
0.0042851279,
-0.0223939568,
0.0871615559,
0.0199453216,
0.0638869852,
-0.0130848158,
0.0090399729,
0.0073695444,
-0.0269282572,
-0.0404320508,
0.0153703699,
-0.0263624806,
0.0455985963,
-0.0166511871,
0.022334272,
0.0916007534,
-0.0193853099,
0.0170926228,
0.0398903601,
0.0544280559,
0.00393226,
0.002856791,
0.0173153896,
0.0577040389,
0.0074864835,
0.0454558767,
0.01597468,
-0.056045685,
0.0243790932,
0.003621689,
-0.0100101968,
-0.1101164594,
-0.0134539409,
0.0382154733,
-0.0444337688,
-0.0342261344,
-0.0514759384,
-0.0298921559,
-0.0148935905,
0.0626717135,
0.0366724171,
0.0022482497,
0.0106852716,
0.007869686,
-0.0174052604,
0.0108950119,
0.0039006693,
0.0339413248,
-0.0673877373,
-0.0210980009,
-0.0086807236,
-0.0640677586,
-0.0196776353,
0.0373692922,
-0.0401703157,
-0.0801946893,
-0.0220401827,
0.0406805873,
0.0181043297,
0.0799126029,
0.0172965005,
-0.0155583723,
0.0376973525,
-0.0076811989,
-0.0179730188,
0.0309079643,
0.0799146965,
0.0448987484,
-0.0059912549,
0.0308077484,
-0.035246551,
0.0278793052,
-0.0043483055,
0.0289427862,
0.0052215727,
-0.0358042866,
-0.0295757931,
0.0208332315,
-0.0147133367,
-0.0351071842,
0.0361673497,
-0.0632046685,
0.0041943355,
-0.0099036153,
0.0160875302,
-0.0547363497,
0.0306102354,
0.0542524084,
0.0134457378,
-0.0027663633,
-0.0456642322,
-0.0164323729,
-0.048089508,
0.0373709686,
0.0651069358,
0.0726681203,
0.0159151983,
0.0312388632,
-0.0058762897,
-0.0212504808,
0.0406143814,
-0.023885563,
-0.0033485221,
-0.0189725533,
-0.0155022461,
0.0068058781,
0.0150593314,
-0.0021267987,
0.0191665012,
0.0210439768,
0.0275528617,
-0.0371746086,
-0.0012285435,
0.0597806238,
0.019558426,
0.1439182609,
-0.0080315843,
0.0192534812,
-0.0078733442,
0.0344955474,
-0.0259914733,
0.0016547994,
-0.0371966138,
-0.0344781354,
-0.029092703,
0.0181684121,
0.0836650059,
-0.0067031663,
0.033460632,
0.0040865308,
0.0399511643,
-0.0193622578,
-0.0352744199,
-0.0225340035,
-0.0325486995,
-0.0257674735,
-0.0361949243,
-0.0443991199,
-0.0422418639,
0.0353680551,
0.0234271269,
0.001148003,
-0.0122256447,
0.0327826142,
0.0131639205,
-0.0221754685,
0.0251070373,
-0.0075287316,
-0.0140246414,
0.0092783775,
-0.0407083631,
0.0050100223,
-5.250008665e-33,
-0.0119751152,
0.0331625082,
0.0126683302,
0.0136904754,
-0.0286348369,
-0.0263609271,
-0.0150144137,
-0.0235528909,
-0.0043549403,
0.0029661611,
0.0167068746,
-0.0420313552,
0.0056627207,
0.046970658,
0.0248349793,
0.0429288521,
0.0370155461,
0.0060184868,
-0.0057241218,
0.0224091206,
0.0334094912,
0.0374394581,
0.0613391064,
-0.0412006937,
-0.0081853485,
-0.0468801819,
-0.0121178338,
-0.0196586791,
0.0071549015,
0.0484663844,
0.0079990579,
0.0485201441,
-0.0224603154,
-0.0365683474,
-0.0481665954,
0.0101668201,
-0.0369280279,
-0.0190122556,
0.0393328331,
0.0519462675,
0.0393013284,
-0.0232543442,
0.0149004189,
0.0072550732,
-0.0523391329,
0.0020277221,
0.0025420792,
-0.047116749,
-0.0117667494,
-0.0511030965,
-0.0683985949,
0.0183697008,
-0.0152320508,
-0.0373401493,
0.0512865745,
0.1055071056,
-0.0555681027,
-0.0463101938,
-0.0404373258,
0.0455934256,
-0.022931315,
0.043661736,
0.0563882701,
0.0035973943,
-0.0098226722,
0.0091613326,
0.0473691449,
-0.0527871363,
0.0311957728,
0.0386226252,
0.0397763513,
0.0445788056,
0.0410933867,
0.079064168,
-0.0141541492,
-0.0059116152,
-0.0241315402,
-0.0084437784,
0.017638728,
-0.0133451158,
-0.0017991243,
-0.0103022801,
0.0005970476,
0.0144622531,
-0.0505068414,
-0.0384202935,
0.0087130563,
-0.0230007358,
0.0383918472,
-0.0081672864,
0.036551699,
-0.025978867,
0.0612543039,
0.0090790819,
-0.0200706646,
-0.0137118129,
-0.0503043756,
-0.0086572981,
-0.0080359243,
0.043425262,
-0.0386781357,
-0.0630586147,
0.0351484232,
0.0335286073,
0.0366308168,
0.0031555409,
0.0084473118,
0.0556434989,
-0.0448834449,
0.0094311992,
-0.0343139246,
0.0417925157,
-0.0192656815,
0.0335695297,
0.0281882938,
-0.041203361,
-0.0051319376,
0.0367302895,
0.0084674321,
-0.0286425985,
0.0240845457,
-0.0168317854,
0.020050792,
0.0377368517,
-0.035294354,
0.0176788662,
-0.032799948,
-0.0045572137,
0.0379829034,
-0.0140283266,
-0.0154999271,
-0.0134342052,
2.765e-7,
-0.0254860278,
-0.0267990548,
0.0214236882,
0.0011840841,
0.0192226656,
0.017995853,
-0.0345164761,
0.0142423781,
-0.0442441739,
0.0508688912,
-0.0155903166,
-0.0550208949,
0.0813748762,
0.0274093878,
-0.0906585678,
-0.0500712767,
-0.0552465282,
0.0059043039,
-0.0531845354,
-0.0308471173,
-0.0325270444,
0.0487256572,
-0.0208637174,
-0.0457402654,
-0.0100937355,
-0.0270250943,
0.0170957092,
-0.0394391604,
-0.0429777466,
-0.0289078411,
0.0614234731,
-0.0001715468,
-0.0235454459,
-0.0487705246,
-0.0532852076,
0.0378840715,
0.0270621423,
0.0384958796,
0.017474642,
-0.0382944793,
0.0776358694,
-0.0079235611,
-0.0999635607,
0.0017332626,
0.030178817,
0.0318015069,
0.0091885319,
0.0140571957,
-0.0047693485,
0.0404444002,
-0.0059655346,
-0.0749491602,
-0.0142884264,
0.014583433,
0.0550758317,
-0.0040241247,
-0.0030296468,
-0.0074506588,
-0.0035761755,
0.0451821238,
-0.0389839225,
-0.0423807241,
0.00006266,
0.038051039,
0.0292144269,
-0.037114419,
-0.0121170348,
2.353851214e-34,
0.033197619,
-0.0550123453,
0.0379816294,
-0.0242290255,
0.0154554686,
-0.0614306144,
0.0131124854,
0.0204164553,
-0.0118554477,
-0.0180522427,
-0.0481141694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09968v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09968v1 | ClinicalGPT: Large Language Models Finetuned with Diverse Medical Data and Comprehensive Evaluation | 2023-06-16T16:56:32 | 2023-06-16T16:56:32 | Guangyu Wang, Guoxing Yang, Zongxin Du, Longjun Fan, Xiaohu Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models have exhibited exceptional performance on various
Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks, leveraging techniques such as the
pre-training, and instruction fine-tuning. Despite these advances, their
effectiveness in medical applications is limited, due to challenges such as
factual inaccuracies, reasoning abilities, and lack grounding in real-world
experience. In this study, we present ClinicalGPT, a language model explicitly
designed and optimized for clinical scenarios. By incorporating extensive and
diverse real-world data, such as medical records, domain-specific knowledge,
and multi-round dialogue consultations in the training process, ClinicalGPT is
better prepared to handle multiple clinical task. Furthermore, we introduce a
comprehensive evaluation framework that includes medical knowledge
question-answering, medical exams, patient consultations, and diagnostic
analysis of medical records. Our results demonstrate that ClinicalGPT
significantly outperforms other models in these tasks, highlighting the
effectiveness of our approach in adapting large language models to the critical
domain of healthcare. | [
0.0887185931,
0.0336615033,
0.0052566547,
0.0017728646,
-0.0342911296,
0.0305794086,
-0.0018447519,
0.0141228391,
0.0148806367,
-0.0373990461,
-0.0126848249,
-0.0587298907,
-0.0059654526,
0.0213103835,
0.0201862995,
-0.0537497327,
0.0333031863,
0.0004945192,
0.055510886,
0.0093266098,
0.0046767588,
0.0339392349,
-0.0590375401,
0.0494130328,
-0.0049358117,
-0.0171139762,
0.0205385704,
-0.0200327486,
0.0098023834,
-0.0722202361,
-0.0053486843,
0.0449212305,
0.0122766728,
-0.0051373001,
0.0000017589,
-0.046800565,
0.0143112643,
0.0289806537,
-0.0540841594,
-0.0316787064,
0.0504418574,
-0.041151654,
0.0003481588,
0.0359666348,
-0.0454350002,
-0.0448130444,
0.022297021,
0.0824807063,
0.0697234049,
0.0684219226,
-0.0190394074,
-0.0172650181,
0.0076694689,
-0.0145094329,
-0.0089384383,
-0.0708578825,
0.0352578089,
0.0376582071,
0.0592700876,
-0.0218269564,
0.010599588,
0.0399086736,
-0.0161621533,
0.0235475507,
-0.0028077848,
0.0498192459,
-0.0531694293,
0.0009593616,
-0.0144010494,
0.0687339827,
-0.0154072708,
0.0141558433,
0.0146044381,
0.0082448954,
-0.0206547659,
-0.0371426158,
-0.0359517187,
0.0017247897,
-0.0159523357,
-0.0048115533,
0.0043305987,
-0.0114726573,
0.0336831324,
0.0194669571,
-0.0047410973,
0.0102909533,
0.0259818584,
-0.0238267463,
0.0225079916,
-0.0054432787,
-0.0207435284,
-0.0443576165,
0.0368375778,
0.0396200009,
-0.0798512325,
0.0313886218,
-0.0175457597,
0.006517583,
0.0772427842,
-0.0567891225,
0.0116195818,
0.011764952,
0.0084526679,
0.0662544742,
-0.000721066,
0.0121539608,
-0.0080013173,
0.019316176,
-0.0397104211,
-0.0179734062,
-0.062964797,
-0.0219665281,
-0.0441115946,
0.0079456223,
-0.0307294354,
-0.0146547286,
-0.0521957576,
-0.0002740303,
0.0157489702,
0.0240856595,
0.0475291796,
0.0495276302,
-0.030100286,
-0.0276959222,
-0.0304943901,
0.0252972897,
-0.0126272766,
0.019457845,
-0.0136237508,
-0.0620377809,
0.0064421128,
-0.0050864764,
0.0044076317,
-0.0110108107,
0.0191714186,
0.0624592975,
0.0001199667,
-0.0073101833,
-0.0062003811,
-0.025568882,
-0.034459725,
-0.0502240844,
-0.0126997391,
-0.0548364967,
0.0412155762,
0.0130959125,
0.0129312612,
-0.0367310755,
0.0270907637,
0.0242408067,
-0.0611996427,
0.0826986656,
-0.0364228413,
0.0365768522,
0.0295209065,
0.0333305933,
0.0344794057,
0.0320759304,
0.0388496593,
-0.0574831702,
-0.0179266799,
-0.0412356928,
0.0126573881,
0.0205989778,
-0.004083096,
-0.0551382005,
-0.0119663496,
0.050286226,
-0.003968453,
0.0990826413,
-0.0368976593,
0.0958519727,
-0.0029084452,
0.0008974005,
0.0108334934,
0.063998118,
0.0069992649,
0.0217347778,
0.0310162492,
-0.0059987819,
0.0040965048,
-0.0340888016,
-0.0359030925,
-0.0061437381,
0.026844332,
-0.002630431,
-0.0332146175,
0.010938473,
-0.0221927892,
-0.0087044379,
-0.0562116206,
-0.0023624792,
-0.0194276609,
-0.0064383163,
0.0044014072,
-0.0008443767,
-0.0565935336,
0.0701609254,
0.0432092175,
-0.0179664101,
-0.0120587088,
-0.0462285541,
-0.0166283231,
0.094748117,
0.0684643537,
-0.0288093966,
-0.0488432311,
-0.037826404,
0.0221054964,
0.0370795764,
0.0684095323,
-0.020186875,
0.0148834577,
-0.0524820387,
0.0031847113,
0.0417712517,
0.0101900864,
-0.0171382073,
0.0133333253,
0.0205098838,
-0.0163306389,
-0.0179832783,
-0.0356799662,
0.0380277447,
-0.0597123168,
-0.0493607074,
0.0096236905,
-0.0327418596,
0.0180455707,
0.0211621281,
-0.0212641694,
0.02620361,
0.017055491,
-0.0254495703,
-0.0132609429,
0.0099078547,
-0.0561260283,
-0.0379348062,
0.017667599,
-0.0051598526,
-0.0273735113,
-0.0227373708,
-0.0408762619,
-0.0298593696,
-0.0472235493,
-0.0554123819,
0.0388628356,
-0.0056940652,
0.0080683092,
0.0384768993,
-0.0105462773,
-0.0472233705,
0.0309119057,
0.0009460205,
0.0097077992,
0.0204652045,
-0.0089520225,
-0.0011922589,
-0.0254909843,
-0.0216654651,
0.0245484393,
0.0024530441,
0.0282791033,
-0.015723316,
0.0230216011,
-0.0435583405,
-0.0432110392,
-0.1362766773,
0.0094969776,
0.0047971238,
0.010829322,
0.0224948097,
0.0211137831,
-0.0160291903,
-0.0320065469,
-0.0590293184,
-0.0071122427,
0.0524964072,
0.0160222501,
0.0199466087,
0.036219269,
0.0106404014,
-0.0243643671,
0.0100351833,
-0.0467831157,
0.0071985829,
0.0030593143,
-0.0080253687,
-0.0178766772,
-0.0003055221,
-0.0433922857,
0.0184528977,
0.0075957426,
-0.0246978775,
0.0208982714,
-0.0139384819,
0.0214057136,
0.0397766754,
0.0080771884,
0.0035253812,
0.0231784638,
-0.0212937929,
-0.0199353695,
0.0368710421,
-0.0197920743,
-0.0433632955,
-0.0387837216,
-0.0106402095,
-0.0150475204,
0.0772782192,
0.0268265624,
0.0103857415,
-0.0441053808,
-0.0153289298,
-0.0262410585,
0.0103282146,
-0.0331985913,
0.007592578,
-0.0405108631,
0.0269965902,
0.0010954482,
-0.0059977537,
0.0880000144,
-0.0139265684,
0.0131225893,
-0.1020119786,
-0.018289566,
-0.0370319374,
0.0257140845,
-0.0157324895,
0.0240226537,
0.0059973588,
-0.0453207195,
0.0023938373,
-0.0121124657,
-0.0168106779,
-0.0772227868,
0.0572423674,
-0.0470747575,
0.023578601,
0.0053023794,
-0.0450204983,
-0.0628053322,
-0.0285215173,
-0.0523234867,
0.0135578709,
0.0058226245,
0.0187918562,
-0.0678094402,
0.015979806,
-0.0058777011,
0.0795273408,
0.0272970553,
-0.0218162537,
-0.0077934344,
0.011045821,
0.0414605662,
0.0443235338,
-0.0048152707,
0.0029503996,
0.0464644805,
0.0648100674,
0.0159816686,
0.0214893445,
-0.0133980224,
-0.0034901288,
-0.0124008274,
-0.0492248982,
0.0104212519,
0.0381644331,
0.035028968,
-0.0839085728,
-0.0135222245,
0.1432622373,
0.0393755883,
-0.0544012226,
0.0123440418,
-0.0064499672,
-0.0249093063,
-0.003512322,
0.0233095363,
-0.0718286261,
-0.0521271899,
-0.0161500089,
0.0135813905,
-0.0051398007,
-0.018459348,
-0.0087615643,
-0.0596059784,
0.0124800559,
-0.0011617859,
-0.0207453333,
-0.034840595,
-0.0224338807,
-0.0000981368,
-0.0181988552,
0.0372243635,
-0.0145882452,
-0.0262297336,
-0.0068468815,
0.0040415609,
-0.0457356684,
-0.1003321856,
0.0743768811,
-0.0226893034,
0.0776844323,
0.0666454509,
0.0408578143,
-0.0048409025,
-0.0028552159,
0.0059326375,
0.0052214507,
0.0224363506,
-0.0037081337,
0.0598372705,
0.0108945696,
-0.0046384344,
-0.0512917973,
0.0090281758,
-0.0554885641,
-0.0219277386,
0.0172136426,
0.0855748653,
-0.0441204645,
-0.0230902899,
-0.0214861166,
0.0345436409,
0.034924645,
0.0535732843,
-0.0167328212,
0.00550065,
-0.0315493383,
0.0136536043,
0.0223501865,
-0.000805738,
-0.0429870747,
0.0187120102,
0.018610917,
0.0202586241,
-0.0454053357,
-0.0210858118,
0.0717176273,
-0.0198012833,
0.025394462,
0.0264670737,
0.034348838,
0.0178330094,
-0.044498913,
0.0626539811,
0.016175583,
0.0300487913,
-0.0552961379,
-0.0261205789,
0.0648004785,
0.0149410451,
-0.0189641248,
0.0121218646,
-0.0279611107,
-0.0168975573,
0.0042759823,
0.0325002968,
0.0181976333,
0.0154577568,
-0.032147456,
-0.0353683233,
-0.0021059576,
0.0289784968,
-0.0785265267,
-0.0301750787,
-0.0167520605,
-0.0038449415,
0.0019207853,
0.0231633689,
0.0006680878,
0.0242977217,
-0.0070912517,
0.0410154238,
-0.0243033729,
-0.0299184471,
0.0266543869,
0.02453137,
0.021509124,
0.00254675,
-0.002815885,
-0.0277594421,
0.0174289066,
-0.0191977676,
0.0065721157,
-0.0206716973,
-0.0040397644,
0.0256240368,
-0.0220119692,
-0.0155259296,
-0.0062591219,
-0.0746877939,
-0.0369961672,
-0.0469266139,
0.032785356,
0.0312160552,
-0.0332263447,
0.059183076,
-0.0201989356,
-0.0081465915,
0.0147705339,
-0.0042517572,
0.0229837988,
-0.0145381112,
0.0894898251,
-0.0234589987,
0.0061631761,
0.0103210052,
0.0471744649,
-0.0353553854,
-0.0555546507,
-0.0056530768,
0.0401103646,
0.0358055532,
-0.0144188656,
0.0167402178,
-0.026061831,
0.0104759159,
-0.0236850455,
0.0141200917,
-0.0226668827,
0.0079229251,
0.0656989962,
0.0291803014,
-0.0031567796,
-0.0253884699,
0.0770754442,
-0.0084242318,
0.0534982868,
0.0078993896,
-0.0252391752,
-0.0550811179,
-0.0317546166,
0.0052720769,
0.0102588851,
-0.0700075105,
0.0488723963,
-0.0560376532,
-0.050538592,
-0.0042810612,
-0.0159284994,
-0.0339822359,
-0.0316458754,
0.0615286529,
0.0449485965,
0.003299397,
-0.0324128792,
-0.0287243687,
0.0518216304,
-0.0092477277,
-0.0099571534,
-0.0023188347,
-5.414865871e-33,
-0.00234368,
-0.028868163,
0.0572230704,
-0.0462269001,
-0.0154671259,
0.0178492013,
-0.0280874725,
0.0037201708,
-0.0201090463,
0.0321624167,
-0.0372999534,
0.0245784875,
0.0103095379,
0.0494215563,
0.0026091516,
-0.0415337421,
0.0392365083,
0.0134546524,
-0.0165281724,
0.0427246131,
-0.0330078416,
0.0551432222,
0.0584530346,
-0.0795096233,
0.0016483848,
0.013340624,
0.0282638986,
0.0193902422,
-0.0299593788,
0.0740044713,
-0.0500800498,
0.0303538721,
0.061731834,
-0.0260982644,
-0.0066137183,
0.0141743831,
-0.0583081469,
-0.0102449963,
0.0373456776,
-0.0069517759,
-0.0414547659,
-0.0133142099,
0.0379407443,
-0.0213597137,
-0.009105891,
-0.0117621766,
0.0051624598,
-0.0394724309,
-0.0052027474,
0.0152972545,
-0.0498480871,
0.0531952456,
0.0015275321,
-0.0256446525,
-0.0103621585,
-0.0115633477,
-0.0493698604,
0.0174303763,
-0.0272628441,
-0.0239745826,
0.0217024833,
0.021424558,
0.0068068714,
-0.047544837,
-0.040486116,
0.0550498776,
-0.0064249737,
-0.0106235007,
-0.0470437035,
0.0079699997,
-0.0530369319,
0.0490549393,
0.0473514497,
0.042375464,
0.0026455224,
-0.0148271751,
-0.0720464811,
0.0020785765,
-0.0454920642,
0.0822305083,
0.0217006095,
-0.0300383698,
-0.0404404961,
0.0006156236,
-0.0430772901,
0.0363823585,
-0.0184016172,
-0.0155910673,
0.0495081283,
0.0028809747,
0.0214137305,
0.0287861992,
-0.0053820815,
-0.0151367942,
0.0077597611,
-0.0078743994,
0.0422669388,
-0.010340726,
-0.0317883492,
0.033113312,
-0.0550502092,
0.0020754063,
0.0262475032,
-0.0204530824,
0.0200123899,
0.0050722165,
0.0056860349,
-0.0144068012,
-0.0692100972,
-0.0001872347,
0.015480089,
0.0268673021,
-0.0177124329,
0.0653702617,
0.022774186,
0.0339982659,
-0.00259941,
0.0583541282,
-0.0122840852,
-0.0280649625,
-0.0364656895,
-0.0498011969,
0.0038129452,
-0.0029960212,
-0.0536802746,
0.0146506494,
-0.0427930951,
0.0338364132,
0.0231333431,
-0.0234873965,
0.0076819882,
0.0071902443,
2.458e-7,
0.0948670581,
0.0667961016,
0.0043011638,
-0.0020379201,
0.0334829651,
-0.0033120108,
-0.0003347797,
0.026965918,
0.0095352689,
-0.0272218436,
0.0037656834,
0.0245668534,
0.0371262729,
0.0458695292,
-0.0714682043,
-0.0308683701,
-0.0738521591,
-0.0158980731,
-0.0568259768,
-0.0293702465,
0.0568435229,
0.1003484577,
-0.0562597997,
-0.0313822553,
-0.0026546696,
-0.0321498103,
0.0362943932,
-0.0107928505,
-0.0212451797,
0.0491319969,
0.0262578372,
0.006408527,
0.0301209986,
0.0643902197,
-0.028637426,
0.0033813301,
-0.0078439768,
0.1230135709,
-0.0653767064,
0.0227424949,
0.0210471284,
-0.0171635598,
0.007045276,
-0.0447184257,
0.0724854544,
-0.0724874511,
-0.0416245833,
-0.0280739404,
0.0054481025,
-0.0236410778,
0.0629815757,
-0.028012814,
-0.0377638713,
0.0263500791,
0.0384839289,
0.0172284674,
-0.0276289564,
-0.0727775395,
-0.0109377019,
0.0285044983,
-0.0372385308,
-0.0210649204,
0.0365965366,
-0.0433412269,
-0.0005031372,
-0.0639319569,
0.0313493982,
1.994559529e-34,
0.0329437405,
0.0140406108,
0.0193154048,
0.0328500122,
0.0451352187,
0.0134862745,
0.0305525437,
0.016578963,
0.0100941947,
-0.0864570215,
-0.0025584551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.00008v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.00008v1 | Investigating Masking-based Data Generation in Language Models | 2023-06-16T16:48:27 | 2023-06-16T16:48:27 | Ed S. Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The current era of natural language processing (NLP) has been defined by the
prominence of pre-trained language models since the advent of BERT. A feature
of BERT and models with similar architecture is the objective of masked
language modeling, in which part of the input is intentionally masked and the
model is trained to predict this piece of masked information. Data augmentation
is a data-driven technique widely used in machine learning, including research
areas like computer vision and natural language processing, to improve model
performance by artificially augmenting the training data set by designated
techniques. Masked language models (MLM), an essential training feature of
BERT, have introduced a novel approach to perform effective pre-training on
Transformer based models in natural language processing tasks. Recent studies
have utilized masked language model to generate artificially augmented data for
NLP downstream tasks. The experimental results show that Mask based data
augmentation method provides a simple but efficient approach to improve the
model performance. In this paper, we explore and discuss the broader
utilization of these data augmentation methods based on MLM. | [
0.0435491204,
0.0511282198,
-0.0266503282,
0.0381458551,
-0.0232700817,
0.0066044028,
0.0184694733,
0.0159871243,
0.0170858204,
-0.087705195,
-0.0146361589,
-0.0141358767,
-0.0189024135,
0.0439252891,
0.0366341881,
-0.0655545965,
0.0419190712,
0.0016591888,
-0.0289501846,
0.0125959497,
-0.020725213,
-0.0018270115,
0.0269270781,
0.0219747387,
-0.0088378899,
0.0212432221,
0.000323241,
-0.0140497657,
0.0087422766,
-0.0206479561,
0.0311659668,
0.037915837,
0.0173143558,
0.0417241007,
0.000001922,
-0.0565385409,
-0.0289487764,
0.0211207028,
-0.0413698666,
-0.0101316702,
0.0133719826,
-0.0537979975,
0.0015655644,
0.032639809,
-0.0544165038,
-0.014402153,
0.0675495863,
0.0738076344,
0.0697262362,
0.0798203275,
-0.0242771339,
-0.0457951315,
0.0474797338,
0.0055589471,
-0.0230540372,
0.0254935883,
0.0427343696,
-0.0228467323,
-0.0540405698,
0.004550253,
-0.0167052466,
0.0352416299,
0.0033685619,
0.0203017872,
0.0424260125,
0.044537589,
-0.0371359065,
-0.0274165552,
-0.0254857,
0.0228771735,
-0.072904259,
-0.0419972353,
-0.018121168,
-0.0235288106,
-0.0060329563,
0.0278391857,
-0.0025811812,
-0.0073896274,
0.0421041697,
0.0291611534,
-0.0029736029,
-0.0038697873,
0.0272353329,
0.0256040897,
-0.0405730903,
0.0390594117,
0.0241941102,
-0.0447571762,
-0.0419654697,
-0.0232807659,
-0.0341057256,
-0.0640050247,
0.0194358751,
0.0505999029,
0.0321756378,
0.0459610298,
-0.0641290694,
-0.1175283641,
0.009932789,
-0.0498335473,
0.0363961831,
0.0427268483,
-0.0354057327,
0.0143620018,
-0.0629865006,
0.0334151797,
-0.0074243341,
0.0371014699,
-0.0295981187,
-0.0239322633,
-0.0127761289,
-0.0462784842,
-0.0736027882,
0.0498329252,
-0.0651924536,
-0.0214180425,
-0.0223606396,
0.01903666,
-0.0097765019,
-0.0034558258,
0.0241754837,
-0.0083541134,
-0.0477136932,
-0.0129024852,
-0.0110195447,
-0.0324215628,
0.0109132808,
0.0216940418,
-0.0244220737,
-0.048843734,
-0.0048732455,
-0.008856819,
0.031080585,
-0.052626729,
0.0240521207,
0.0710537508,
0.0058245426,
-0.0461092368,
-0.0255924426,
0.0084351627,
0.011924345,
0.0024068381,
0.0292579755,
-0.0470972545,
0.0018005501,
-0.0092902072,
0.005124989,
-0.0080021946,
0.0259344671,
0.0122190546,
-0.0264963694,
0.106886521,
-0.0632044226,
-0.0172517933,
0.0243052281,
0.0000781128,
-0.0002926605,
0.0640352964,
0.0424724892,
0.0091197528,
0.0416657515,
-0.0295357443,
0.0211641975,
0.0616322458,
0.0249013752,
0.0013522479,
-0.0226193834,
-0.014952492,
-0.0012300258,
-0.0364892744,
-0.0129037676,
0.0286135599,
-0.0305726398,
-0.0089128176,
0.0520901643,
0.0170894321,
0.0179472193,
0.0455194749,
0.0044702441,
0.0084371539,
0.0196745917,
0.0059820004,
-0.0223240089,
-0.0225177649,
-0.0486528166,
0.0039074346,
-0.0445554443,
0.0371935517,
-0.0115475077,
-0.0444788449,
-0.01519942,
-0.017749954,
0.0619984157,
-0.0013006743,
0.0457463637,
0.0568089932,
-0.0504823849,
0.0645245686,
0.0169127416,
-0.0289866235,
0.0009477845,
-0.0646928847,
-0.0550196432,
0.0300592501,
0.0378412195,
-0.0567677133,
-0.0428577401,
-0.0134037286,
-0.0287199579,
0.0295946952,
0.0049665575,
0.0217071045,
0.0164590199,
-0.0375142731,
-0.0188475605,
-0.0242880061,
0.0163509212,
0.0209570937,
0.0255924426,
-0.0170336999,
0.0262882933,
0.0023700034,
-0.0292729344,
0.0609585233,
-0.0470191501,
-0.0500042252,
0.0210017655,
0.0030080436,
0.0044783028,
0.0015973679,
-0.0191636514,
0.0110013988,
0.0320334285,
-0.0410133898,
-0.0278659426,
0.013939173,
-0.0011957467,
-0.0390670747,
0.0474936441,
-0.0433554761,
0.0188426916,
0.093101576,
-0.0284949932,
-0.0425682627,
-0.0289255083,
-0.0630268231,
0.0641064271,
-0.0479238443,
0.0395489857,
-0.0134558659,
0.0364352465,
-0.036675293,
0.0465323031,
-0.0072567682,
0.0246059354,
-0.0103848353,
0.0209089555,
0.0259868558,
0.0117505454,
-0.0204562452,
-0.0010683445,
0.0008813109,
-0.001827107,
0.0148763191,
-0.0186725631,
-0.0354855433,
-0.0241085794,
-0.0728078187,
-0.0144386748,
-0.0128487209,
-0.0037526402,
0.0194625724,
0.0231511034,
-0.0170548279,
-0.0097354967,
-0.017992286,
-0.0615357421,
-0.0002946868,
0.0079654781,
0.0275107548,
0.0084144576,
-0.0365102366,
-0.0040908461,
-0.020519916,
-0.017606698,
0.0509445593,
-0.0071201776,
-0.0748944059,
-0.0431766585,
-0.0064142738,
0.0111558223,
0.0778230429,
-0.0104420381,
-0.0455002412,
-0.0278667118,
0.0106401304,
0.0558428504,
0.0169397593,
0.0258143581,
0.0019008681,
0.0314397365,
0.016170688,
-0.0188842677,
0.0146270813,
-0.0588079765,
0.0158311855,
-0.0191801898,
-0.0432063155,
0.03425017,
0.0657172129,
-0.0205843933,
-0.029805582,
-0.036634516,
0.0001908395,
-0.004571456,
-0.0396074615,
-0.0222744457,
-0.0371685661,
-0.0397787169,
0.0269341357,
-0.0277721267,
-0.0464841723,
0.0553619005,
-0.0498293042,
-0.0153421098,
-0.047523465,
0.0009421859,
-0.0124553423,
0.0327173471,
0.0522466153,
0.0227423478,
-0.0045751962,
-0.0352699533,
-0.0111949537,
0.0054181847,
-0.0028641794,
-0.0591816418,
0.0007898757,
-0.0193164274,
-0.0184147228,
0.0179837998,
-0.0110657187,
-0.0745041743,
-0.0519229025,
0.0033173256,
0.01578236,
0.0438390896,
-0.0187235847,
-0.0179142598,
0.0093441484,
0.0071287584,
0.070337534,
0.0135352192,
0.0015214486,
-0.0368660688,
0.0230182279,
0.0448847525,
-0.0040968349,
0.0201651342,
0.0047851098,
0.0126132164,
-0.0068155886,
0.0415104851,
-0.0052002575,
-0.0314439237,
0.0131013421,
0.040485654,
-0.0320925526,
-0.0220206007,
-0.0036315667,
0.017152423,
-0.0492438003,
0.0021154773,
0.1141946018,
0.0465593636,
0.0160529334,
0.0054093786,
-0.0144503079,
0.0118272277,
0.0288906358,
0.0347703621,
-0.0711494014,
0.0117254499,
0.0078355893,
0.0052075228,
-0.0577170998,
-0.0066795559,
-0.0129699428,
-0.1368002445,
0.0234673452,
-0.0131617542,
0.0028341969,
-0.0286796205,
-0.0612917393,
-0.0023267616,
0.0131183928,
0.0136116929,
-0.0359907597,
0.0087635396,
-0.0285797529,
0.0394661725,
-0.0411239006,
-0.0615026541,
-0.0336022563,
-0.0322825089,
0.0226397142,
0.0437930413,
0.0168044847,
-0.0471413396,
-0.058479201,
0.0297197588,
0.0234057717,
0.0113487141,
-0.0136996843,
0.0723432675,
-0.0262765158,
-0.0368268862,
0.0102496594,
0.0147656761,
0.0311464854,
-0.0425768569,
-0.0504781753,
0.0364396349,
-0.0059962794,
0.0264209155,
-0.0024166463,
-0.0148227978,
-0.0006540174,
0.0536071695,
0.001189801,
-0.0315720662,
0.031209249,
0.0003206125,
0.0219386984,
-0.0423867479,
0.0071568945,
0.0465020724,
-0.0660209581,
-0.0454280861,
-0.0631771013,
-0.0169768222,
0.0425459184,
0.0270243678,
0.0403539687,
-0.0019470679,
0.0291528739,
-0.0250439383,
-0.0727264285,
0.0340909287,
-0.0225376375,
0.0213815868,
-0.0161869098,
-0.0539283492,
0.0124033466,
-0.0440252461,
-0.0148520358,
0.0192898307,
-0.039132148,
-0.0534760766,
0.0522505902,
0.0796923116,
0.0193957146,
0.0497831367,
-0.0171860885,
-0.0764640272,
0.0492388755,
0.0440511517,
-0.0239457116,
-0.0126427198,
0.051486019,
-0.0432360247,
0.0083362944,
-0.0037913416,
-0.016998196,
0.0292295851,
0.0494690873,
0.0001740233,
-0.0349962376,
0.0022359947,
0.0466662273,
0.0267153922,
0.0924376547,
-0.0344854183,
0.0237380657,
-0.0139741627,
0.0343689695,
-0.043868266,
-0.0365959071,
-0.0285784472,
-0.0091438079,
0.0273354556,
0.0169444755,
-0.0194908697,
0.0537843741,
-0.0487701036,
-0.0040027886,
-0.0520533957,
0.018092392,
-0.0183867496,
0.008746271,
0.0055669085,
0.0193840228,
0.0002215558,
-0.0041756271,
0.0252671242,
0.0102680549,
0.0113849742,
0.0197557062,
0.0332381614,
0.0051223785,
-0.0602293722,
0.0340313092,
-0.0670569167,
-0.005555206,
-0.0614686124,
-0.0000277042,
0.0121373907,
-0.0504220538,
0.0262178145,
-0.0350742489,
-0.0349906273,
0.0241834782,
-0.0005906595,
0.0141488872,
-0.0192435477,
0.0247724392,
-0.0016976051,
-0.0331455953,
-0.0152982138,
0.0581615306,
0.0401364118,
0.0631466955,
-0.0094601437,
-0.0208857823,
-0.039243944,
0.0138337947,
0.0788607299,
0.0355112068,
-0.0113298288,
0.0257478822,
-0.0213257838,
-0.0729149729,
0.0261530429,
-0.0133659737,
0.0241337996,
-0.006761726,
0.0228630882,
0.0191684011,
-0.0063286955,
-0.032311324,
-0.044669006,
0.0239741355,
0.0668862611,
0.0127578387,
0.0108758109,
-6.112071039e-33,
-0.0321626738,
-0.0178271048,
0.0037087656,
0.0331324041,
-0.0064149024,
0.0190996118,
0.0095983325,
-0.0096879853,
-0.0036166348,
0.0096530104,
-0.0247837659,
0.0115076108,
0.0267471932,
0.0373558551,
-0.0535232686,
0.0005260847,
0.0553769767,
0.0011256518,
-0.0071436437,
-0.0462632142,
-0.0187457744,
0.0465265065,
0.0730542541,
-0.0783446133,
0.0044991579,
-0.0038210028,
-0.0330215842,
0.0153697636,
0.0178805273,
0.0440806039,
-0.0180884898,
0.0226850975,
0.021721907,
-0.0623456612,
-0.0268993638,
0.0429952592,
-0.0765662938,
-0.0012365177,
0.0286573917,
0.0462235287,
-0.0290760901,
0.0011786391,
0.0586522333,
-0.013790586,
-0.0052997274,
0.0384908617,
0.0262273774,
-0.0617633946,
0.0051015788,
-0.03651198,
-0.048228763,
0.0217959005,
0.0106767742,
-0.0154792452,
0.0595443957,
0.0230875053,
0.0146437054,
0.0133320121,
-0.0744440928,
-0.0138918534,
0.0943194553,
0.0241944715,
0.0486598685,
0.0690849125,
0.017067669,
0.0464579761,
0.0233339258,
0.0014105929,
-0.0189217106,
0.0287754256,
0.0608264841,
0.0448599271,
0.0658259243,
0.009175892,
0.0513112843,
-0.0199455582,
-0.0177625548,
0.0386210941,
-0.0575909801,
-0.0148729794,
0.0315072201,
0.0158959161,
-0.0099232243,
0.0009848714,
-0.0500689819,
0.0008844585,
-0.0256944485,
0.0230177362,
0.0011597171,
0.0413215384,
-0.0651383474,
0.0780601501,
0.0032498587,
-0.0545215681,
-0.0062202616,
-0.0288356394,
0.0099924589,
0.0182511732,
-0.0183363464,
0.028603781,
-0.0190002918,
-0.059277717,
0.0540950783,
0.0217154082,
0.0063987188,
-0.0167056881,
0.0510133319,
0.0219387077,
-0.0890400484,
0.0194392037,
-0.0247631092,
0.0242250711,
0.0319646336,
0.0342511237,
0.0276045296,
0.0222886074,
-0.0234363675,
0.0092198346,
0.0602532327,
-0.0065713078,
-0.0440964103,
0.0296611954,
0.0008039251,
0.0299231745,
-0.0098357862,
-0.0106402598,
-0.0110790478,
0.0303113852,
0.0685649738,
-0.0484263897,
-0.0186265167,
-0.0075151762,
2.646e-7,
0.0670286268,
0.0621028692,
0.0208594613,
0.0141043905,
0.0049918215,
0.020107422,
0.0155559685,
0.0314692035,
0.0321004763,
-0.0127327163,
-0.0119112041,
-0.0059847864,
0.0119917337,
-0.0082986737,
-0.0235967133,
-0.0552174151,
-0.0392280333,
-0.0052041151,
-0.0335473418,
0.0298145469,
0.0473604165,
0.116502516,
0.0337555185,
-0.0178580061,
0.0041877571,
-0.0218212921,
0.048378814,
-0.0431110114,
-0.0036745896,
0.0275873467,
0.0372471623,
0.0703776553,
0.0096935797,
0.0485341214,
-0.0591820776,
0.049789805,
0.0162822697,
0.0291265715,
-0.0317385942,
0.0232547335,
-0.008701236,
0.0033632719,
-0.0439500511,
-0.0586765334,
0.0651813522,
-0.0408047065,
-0.0196177103,
-0.021112008,
-0.0630959496,
0.0220867489,
-0.0030300142,
-0.0645612106,
-0.0493876152,
0.0365606099,
0.0443510227,
0.0033709675,
-0.0312802792,
-0.0885462612,
-0.0572490282,
-0.0236387774,
-0.0361378267,
-0.0070191422,
-0.0241755508,
-0.0366193429,
0.017973559,
-0.0726699978,
0.0134427082,
2.824386909e-34,
0.0132952388,
0.0030211965,
-0.0143474899,
0.0459705889,
0.0347160399,
-0.0105885537,
0.043819461,
0.0401350781,
-0.0036962798,
-0.0820811912,
-0.0129417423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10095v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10095v1 | AD-AutoGPT: An Autonomous GPT for Alzheimer's Disease Infodemiology | 2023-06-16T16:35:59 | 2023-06-16T16:35:59 | Haixing Dai, Yiwei Li, Zhengliang Liu, Lin Zhao, Zihao Wu, Suhang Song, Ye Shen, Dajiang Zhu, Xiang Li, Sheng Li, Xiaobai Yao, Lu Shi, Quanzheng Li, Zhuo Chen, Donglan Zhang, Gengchen Mai, Tianming Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, 68T01, 68T50, 92C50, I.2.7; I.2.1; J.3 | In this pioneering study, inspired by AutoGPT, the state-of-the-art
open-source application based on the GPT-4 large language model, we develop a
novel tool called AD-AutoGPT which can conduct data collection, processing, and
analysis about complex health narratives of Alzheimer's Disease in an
autonomous manner via users' textual prompts. We collated comprehensive data
from a variety of news sources, including the Alzheimer's Association, BBC,
Mayo Clinic, and the National Institute on Aging since June 2022, leading to
the autonomous execution of robust trend analyses, intertopic distance maps
visualization, and identification of salient terms pertinent to Alzheimer's
Disease. This approach has yielded not only a quantifiable metric of relevant
discourse but also valuable insights into public focus on Alzheimer's Disease.
This application of AD-AutoGPT in public health signifies the transformative
potential of AI in facilitating a data-rich understanding of complex health
narratives like Alzheimer's Disease in an autonomous manner, setting the
groundwork for future AI-driven investigations in global health landscapes. | [
-0.0038907672,
0.0979220048,
-0.0260267761,
-0.0098850522,
-0.0174572095,
0.0188757535,
-0.0202682298,
0.0225399826,
0.0876351669,
-0.0114783207,
0.0567811802,
0.0339108109,
-0.005326645,
0.0733921379,
-0.0368495136,
-0.0780384913,
0.0374376029,
-0.0179732889,
0.0787643865,
0.0120127536,
-0.026526019,
0.0095779048,
-0.0405883491,
0.0203243271,
-0.0200868379,
-0.0498769768,
0.024807319,
-0.0342116319,
0.0490669534,
-0.0666464716,
-0.0306124911,
0.0028996025,
0.034970317,
0.0133563709,
0.0000021573,
-0.031179633,
-0.0111372713,
0.0267063379,
0.0388191119,
-0.0225688517,
0.0036087555,
0.0117818145,
-0.0020115832,
-0.0196468718,
-0.053466253,
-0.0132780271,
0.0639538318,
0.0165374745,
0.0378204212,
0.0379572064,
-0.0197557174,
-0.0041618235,
0.0525715053,
-0.0262144338,
0.011518131,
-0.0277017355,
0.0454924107,
-0.0196929816,
0.0054954085,
-0.0126782572,
0.0181689635,
0.0658804402,
-0.0241592862,
0.0362816267,
-0.0236033984,
0.073552452,
0.0194098037,
-0.0239691138,
-0.0213242527,
0.0314462967,
0.0276547819,
0.0129731689,
0.0540768243,
0.0069147642,
0.0059056235,
0.0444911085,
-0.0765206814,
0.0217432957,
-0.0174217429,
0.0025170143,
0.009131466,
0.0027335526,
0.0223841388,
-0.0164100938,
-0.0252295416,
0.0679854453,
-0.0185550544,
-0.01519165,
0.0094804429,
-0.0300363991,
-0.0420212783,
-0.0419222191,
0.0258669034,
0.0243677925,
-0.0454870462,
0.0048479396,
0.0460619219,
-0.0171252582,
0.0662563965,
-0.053315863,
0.0162849631,
0.0131011205,
-0.0366363116,
0.0462600365,
0.0639773533,
-0.0022853247,
-0.0272085629,
-0.0345004648,
0.0178207681,
0.0179251172,
-0.0605547279,
-0.0034847017,
-0.0500594415,
-0.0023105326,
-0.0318062827,
0.0147745442,
-0.0236005075,
0.0103299161,
-0.0120753162,
-0.0221940707,
-0.0123407403,
0.0326227434,
-0.0203832574,
0.0116050895,
-0.0187821575,
0.0421976447,
-0.086955741,
0.0041643819,
0.0020829476,
-0.0143101849,
0.0393553041,
0.0129059982,
0.0124179209,
-0.0295411181,
0.0038777092,
0.0807057247,
0.0288067851,
-0.0066812681,
-0.0573938675,
-0.0328036621,
-0.0482983477,
-0.047343798,
-0.0079161422,
-0.0733838677,
0.0503625683,
0.0262537319,
0.0248548985,
-0.0343984067,
-0.0101004038,
0.0187609121,
-0.0651243553,
0.0370361283,
-0.0766249225,
-0.0154765882,
0.0747736618,
0.0132958516,
0.0270075463,
0.0347743481,
0.058119256,
0.01728292,
0.036925219,
0.0064368881,
0.0004514016,
0.0113836853,
0.020930877,
0.0273438301,
0.0050177183,
0.0271507725,
-0.0234278236,
0.0405794047,
-0.0357430205,
0.059784025,
0.0335358903,
-0.0008969847,
0.0711700246,
0.0874338672,
-0.03940171,
0.0332413688,
0.009368185,
-0.0169678815,
-0.0188171994,
-0.0201838575,
0.012996315,
0.0099763507,
-0.0193750784,
-0.0039156992,
0.0095833996,
0.0624830499,
0.0203643963,
-0.0428048857,
0.012192646,
-0.0085447365,
0.0320300274,
-0.0435052216,
0.0040106648,
-0.0389874429,
0.0164349061,
-0.0359997153,
0.0237905681,
-0.0150801176,
-0.0339375883,
-0.0379122794,
0.017029779,
0.023447888,
0.020928096,
-0.0617770366,
-0.0091749616,
-0.022522727,
0.0684486851,
0.0065716542,
-0.0157950576,
0.0020215858,
0.0026539783,
0.002473311,
0.0147402501,
0.0168425571,
0.0227607246,
-0.0016463768,
0.014119532,
0.0600061901,
-0.029190395,
-0.041449815,
-0.035756927,
0.0024234403,
-0.0406490788,
-0.01742067,
0.0010885147,
0.0057302732,
0.0328331068,
0.0519239567,
-0.0083453096,
0.0230931882,
0.0301847588,
-0.0330498964,
-0.0279571749,
0.0036490397,
-0.0129207987,
0.0597312748,
-0.0034782062,
-0.0554079711,
0.0002583241,
-0.0365245566,
-0.0377160273,
-0.0217755083,
-0.0071104178,
-0.0272109415,
0.0204727966,
0.0233803298,
-0.0183944255,
0.041547671,
-0.0060522337,
-0.0284115858,
0.0834055021,
-0.0075907428,
-0.0583786927,
0.0431270003,
-0.0413529985,
0.034565296,
0.0024943759,
-0.0042507965,
0.0089556472,
0.017517373,
-0.0048721125,
0.0377512164,
-0.0363349654,
-0.0192527715,
0.0127584068,
-0.09835843,
0.0195355024,
-0.004823816,
0.0198492892,
0.025613714,
0.0295339003,
-0.0436255708,
-0.0130563835,
-0.0009258476,
0.0204343926,
0.0050745392,
0.0281763021,
0.04668203,
0.035941042,
0.0185162723,
-0.0365456901,
0.011744624,
-0.0707705468,
-0.0015369474,
0.0635862797,
-0.0726016909,
0.0035528308,
-0.0385766849,
-0.0481288396,
0.0279328693,
-0.0109934537,
-0.0056828107,
0.0218513887,
-0.0193138607,
0.0491805784,
0.0463157706,
-0.0192013197,
0.0883822218,
0.0624500364,
-0.0354295559,
0.0062451768,
0.0097804414,
-0.0575270168,
0.0381081998,
-0.0227053016,
-0.0248517878,
0.0610032193,
0.0477888286,
0.0557435974,
0.0221700892,
-0.0251172073,
0.0128412973,
-0.0418996736,
0.0405371562,
-0.0318578258,
-0.0086285686,
-0.0328273475,
0.0340997912,
-0.0137031879,
-0.0607584193,
0.036615286,
-0.0122198071,
0.0627372414,
-0.0416840725,
-0.017942505,
-0.0397671685,
0.0616082959,
0.0230464619,
0.0359573923,
0.0181082487,
-0.0157093238,
0.0157758202,
-0.030833466,
-0.0101556117,
-0.0075377971,
0.079948701,
-0.0947509855,
0.0180380065,
0.0401868969,
-0.0278170165,
0.0171075333,
0.0148549024,
-0.0304559078,
-0.0139596285,
0.0341583453,
-0.0603954569,
-0.0788896382,
0.0075384248,
0.0435143448,
0.0640008673,
0.0000156995,
-0.0088594249,
-0.0034966466,
0.0052072541,
0.055484917,
-0.027604714,
-0.0501613952,
0.0186585262,
0.0110264178,
0.0391046964,
-0.0113778841,
0.0256446078,
-0.0269523039,
0.0164232012,
-0.0284925289,
-0.0546660013,
-0.0240198802,
0.0180319045,
0.0228815936,
-0.0027343435,
0.0054862122,
0.1105323061,
0.044434078,
-0.0874752551,
0.0117271673,
-0.0209973957,
0.0015080784,
-0.0032852697,
0.0071380194,
-0.0827520937,
-0.0042072516,
-0.0240370259,
0.0178370643,
-0.0298032351,
-0.0509042963,
-0.0056915092,
-0.0035188785,
0.0648483336,
-0.0070910556,
-0.0363239087,
-0.0036380789,
-0.0422033072,
0.0092348149,
-0.035216473,
-0.033994332,
-0.0570336208,
-0.0141144432,
0.0084331594,
-0.0176815558,
-0.0912704542,
-0.029952677,
0.0112876119,
-0.0260103215,
0.0542313345,
0.0822963268,
0.0944227278,
-0.0111842202,
-0.0270942226,
-0.0081361644,
0.0153520843,
0.0206549708,
-0.0426623896,
0.0935330763,
0.0071618613,
0.0010745763,
-0.0612922609,
0.0352431312,
-0.0131475329,
-0.0117363473,
0.0506016091,
0.1045708284,
-0.0378313065,
-0.0207980219,
-0.0360676199,
-0.0199153312,
0.0327041075,
0.0218550786,
0.0025406955,
0.0174202025,
-0.0148915034,
-0.0205104277,
0.0529829487,
0.0170427561,
-0.0207807831,
-0.0319664851,
-0.0386558808,
-0.0512812585,
-0.0457383022,
-0.0212397873,
0.0794990286,
-0.0113820191,
0.0189866591,
-0.0039363815,
0.0575980954,
-0.0204318371,
-0.0505643226,
0.020250028,
0.0099751716,
0.0203249995,
-0.0325075388,
-0.057790868,
0.0415077284,
0.0467470288,
-0.0075685643,
0.0715436861,
-0.0330839753,
-0.0362747535,
0.055153925,
0.0023714423,
0.0228973255,
0.0053336648,
0.0079560848,
-0.0108684134,
0.0520328395,
0.0692876875,
0.004744675,
-0.024547739,
-0.0447456725,
0.025507709,
0.0036971297,
-0.0084261466,
0.0028409204,
0.0055695758,
-0.0501349792,
0.0061153155,
-0.0516229235,
0.0219762325,
0.0235066134,
0.0121804411,
0.063033171,
-0.0206511188,
0.0050751469,
-0.0406644307,
-0.040288344,
-0.0283463802,
0.0079514738,
-0.0189723987,
0.0175136235,
0.0159803834,
-0.031224763,
-0.0204099491,
0.0297216736,
-0.0433483161,
-0.0554346293,
-0.0733354017,
0.0481931642,
-0.0143277822,
0.0454946235,
0.0225490518,
-0.0334040523,
0.0177276433,
0.0321119428,
-0.0286556128,
0.038349241,
0.0021992819,
0.0458986834,
0.0229598973,
-0.0071941982,
0.0334478654,
0.0341144465,
-0.0462672524,
-0.0737657323,
-0.0210170392,
0.0387315452,
0.0550226234,
0.0023389671,
0.045623295,
-0.0417227671,
-0.0112684723,
0.0071378737,
-0.0343353003,
0.0212429743,
0.009907973,
0.0023409915,
-0.0071478696,
-0.0351070203,
-0.0143012814,
0.0661494434,
-0.0071741343,
0.0461828448,
0.0603525974,
-0.0725712851,
-0.0264797732,
-0.0722535029,
0.0093888715,
-0.0121414019,
-0.0556915179,
-0.0189598389,
-0.016042633,
-0.03759427,
0.019727977,
-0.0071168486,
-0.0281070508,
-0.0043279901,
0.0069576744,
0.023642797,
-0.0076700496,
-0.05976009,
-0.055078771,
0.0297868792,
-0.1135520935,
-0.0432300605,
0.0016156993,
-6.513572155e-33,
-0.009150424,
-0.0391239412,
0.0401924998,
-0.0196737275,
-0.0136839943,
-0.0022457794,
-0.0350763239,
-0.0047041806,
0.0121834949,
0.0587296449,
0.0150900828,
0.0106278155,
0.0051851724,
0.0050060442,
0.0040221899,
-0.0111072343,
0.0129689258,
-0.0113119744,
-0.0031223618,
0.032433264,
-0.0000614096,
0.0080516702,
0.008076096,
-0.0706807822,
0.0505913347,
0.0261004902,
0.0001635419,
0.0067787548,
0.0171799213,
0.0221384801,
-0.0199870039,
0.0439156927,
0.0313064121,
0.0310647767,
-0.0088201715,
0.039490182,
-0.0676161647,
-0.0547092743,
0.0263948906,
-0.0462725349,
-0.0296687074,
-0.0094393184,
-0.0092961285,
0.0137910359,
0.0032833067,
0.0256730001,
0.0449237674,
-0.0386563838,
0.0034461834,
0.0105812466,
-0.0119893113,
0.0295529645,
-0.0285886936,
0.0494163856,
-0.0273672864,
-0.0172173642,
-0.0057672798,
0.0550327078,
-0.0425743051,
0.0311852731,
0.0216770843,
-0.0018041539,
0.0147938756,
-0.044818908,
0.0213256404,
0.0297380947,
0.0116231237,
-0.0330146626,
-0.0510056131,
0.0106964307,
-0.0579530783,
0.0449686348,
0.0320263803,
-0.0256957822,
-0.0053287591,
-0.0020516543,
-0.0575201623,
0.0252156965,
-0.0084615378,
0.0117734941,
-0.0133790979,
-0.0080374805,
-0.0231402628,
-0.0039755763,
-0.0131127946,
-0.0077118371,
-0.0258888658,
-0.0335217342,
0.0083001917,
-0.0473202765,
0.021699816,
0.0368627384,
-0.0141067868,
-0.0147184422,
-0.0199082419,
-0.0103289792,
0.0276590176,
0.0035944954,
0.001259626,
0.0296360776,
-0.0382116102,
0.0057055429,
-0.0395961888,
0.0498444512,
0.039471589,
0.0229226947,
0.01714026,
-0.0194840338,
-0.035696283,
-0.0064216615,
0.00252705,
0.0105944881,
-0.010511674,
-0.0231620297,
-0.0213843789,
-0.0018306882,
0.0142269889,
0.0910100192,
0.0391309857,
0.0182973184,
-0.0087452736,
-0.0126650902,
-0.0589216389,
-0.0143250842,
-0.0174711123,
-0.0259895697,
-0.0408643968,
0.0289690681,
0.0178709161,
-0.0826097354,
-0.0025601031,
-0.0055902679,
2.916e-7,
0.064416565,
0.1005577892,
0.0335162356,
0.0462299697,
0.0235121641,
-0.0276908986,
-0.0039232629,
-0.00176666,
-0.0415936708,
0.0153464954,
0.0360839106,
0.0300690606,
-0.0146529842,
0.0529228337,
-0.0372793786,
0.0378474034,
-0.1135410964,
-0.0440967157,
-0.1214019209,
0.0413582437,
0.0406187363,
-0.002241994,
-0.0218634065,
0.005302141,
0.0348583758,
-0.0018785178,
0.0001000866,
-0.0447501652,
0.0195778366,
0.0297326837,
0.0017720279,
0.0214264542,
0.0048556798,
0.0139708631,
-0.0469941199,
-0.063239485,
-0.0351917632,
0.0498238765,
-0.0243996084,
0.0060522296,
0.0281345043,
-0.0254789665,
0.0185204186,
-0.0305659454,
0.0723443106,
-0.0415588543,
-0.0583705753,
-0.0111356946,
-0.0089916056,
-0.0097049922,
0.041555997,
-0.0440313034,
-0.0299595278,
-0.0178899299,
-0.0131201819,
0.0331037939,
0.0154576506,
-0.0167264324,
0.0192972291,
0.0019976136,
-0.0253397617,
-0.0301522426,
-0.0312494021,
-0.0204726364,
-0.0363607034,
-0.0526665114,
0.0269718692,
2.546733077e-34,
0.0504807793,
0.0163572468,
-0.0224074628,
-0.0618956946,
0.0398685969,
0.0072120675,
0.0106762871,
-0.0085343393,
-0.0212249402,
-0.0474578328,
-0.0275749397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09927v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09927v3 | Trained Transformers Learn Linear Models In-Context | 2023-06-16T15:50:03 | 2023-10-19T20:31:32 | Ruiqi Zhang, Spencer Frei, Peter L. Bartlett | stat.ML | stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Attention-based neural networks such as transformers have demonstrated a
remarkable ability to exhibit in-context learning (ICL): Given a short prompt
sequence of tokens from an unseen task, they can formulate relevant per-token
and next-token predictions without any parameter updates. By embedding a
sequence of labeled training data and unlabeled test data as a prompt, this
allows for transformers to behave like supervised learning algorithms. Indeed,
recent work has shown that when training transformer architectures over random
instances of linear regression problems, these models' predictions mimic those
of ordinary least squares.
Towards understanding the mechanisms underlying this phenomenon, we
investigate the dynamics of ICL in transformers with a single linear
self-attention layer trained by gradient flow on linear regression tasks. We
show that despite non-convexity, gradient flow with a suitable random
initialization finds a global minimum of the objective function. At this global
minimum, when given a test prompt of labeled examples from a new prediction
task, the transformer achieves prediction error competitive with the best
linear predictor over the test prompt distribution. We additionally
characterize the robustness of the trained transformer to a variety of
distribution shifts and show that although a number of shifts are tolerated,
shifts in the covariate distribution of the prompts are not. Motivated by this,
we consider a generalized ICL setting where the covariate distributions can
vary across prompts. We show that although gradient flow succeeds at finding a
global minimum in this setting, the trained transformer is still brittle under
mild covariate shifts. We complement this finding with experiments on large,
nonlinear transformer architectures which we show are more robust under
covariate shifts. | [
-0.0231722537,
0.054670997,
-0.0045409827,
0.0268281344,
0.0147618894,
0.0001366192,
0.0457466356,
-0.0210928563,
-0.039242994,
0.0345755592,
-0.0414289497,
0.0066703097,
0.0144504858,
-0.0058964756,
0.0564047508,
-0.022508543,
-0.0233361647,
-0.0141915753,
-0.0405617394,
-0.048473943,
-0.0092962161,
-0.0571786985,
0.0143698407,
0.0090654986,
-0.0507757515,
-0.0085804015,
0.0042249723,
0.0189264212,
0.003898401,
-0.0047608013,
0.0254675485,
0.0233804751,
0.011285441,
0.0114054047,
0.0000023377,
-0.0218236335,
-0.0031746435,
-0.0342256315,
-0.0175799243,
-0.0625676066,
-0.0376601368,
-0.0149840815,
-0.0111830598,
-0.0021074598,
0.0006773505,
-0.0070873802,
0.0768204331,
0.0532094836,
0.0557070002,
0.0419765413,
-0.0022710753,
-0.008764375,
-0.0017521405,
-0.0541810766,
0.0258203484,
-0.0339819342,
-0.0139155807,
-0.0785324052,
-0.0724241361,
-0.0145079503,
-0.0514407046,
0.0529809073,
0.0376891457,
0.0308806878,
0.0468883291,
0.0823561922,
-0.0365350544,
0.0052276715,
-0.0249532145,
0.0500850305,
-0.0767579898,
-0.0166522786,
-0.0084319869,
-0.0114461305,
0.0508212037,
-0.0045440714,
-0.0295423903,
0.0269811377,
0.0112965703,
0.0094053382,
-0.0648638308,
0.0242802165,
0.0296169706,
-0.0215277132,
-0.0213039592,
0.0447642729,
-0.0221164171,
-0.0228350759,
-0.0113779362,
0.0083669638,
-0.0041030389,
0.0027196754,
-0.0190834422,
0.0376236886,
-0.0342895947,
0.0142713636,
-0.0242834613,
-0.0479445197,
-0.0263790302,
-0.0137321576,
0.0640199333,
-0.0051213335,
-0.0327826999,
0.019732818,
-0.0146172047,
0.1100828797,
-0.054635562,
0.0513099656,
-0.0151747856,
0.0180506483,
-0.0105922604,
-0.0025368354,
-0.0344648324,
0.0484624207,
-0.0037455817,
0.0317339636,
-0.0306295231,
0.0658660904,
0.0104068434,
0.010507891,
0.0047017657,
0.0281371493,
-0.0568477437,
0.0134807304,
-0.0275578927,
0.0200421009,
0.0019643675,
-0.0076259216,
0.01368008,
-0.0134651046,
-0.0559630059,
0.0098415753,
-0.013931212,
-0.0020299635,
0.0074353223,
0.1097567976,
-0.0037267378,
-0.0129510406,
-0.0470438823,
0.0141592715,
-0.0212504175,
-0.0195658002,
0.0609881878,
-0.0415774509,
0.0037454853,
0.0392536484,
-0.0038991859,
-0.0475485921,
-0.0014732167,
-0.0072112018,
-0.0205642078,
0.0758869201,
0.0867745876,
-0.0292917602,
0.0403909013,
-0.0397634208,
-0.0323852897,
0.0477693453,
0.0199800823,
0.0204968862,
0.0046964949,
-0.0185896475,
0.0579363815,
0.0269820504,
0.0379745103,
0.0085708024,
0.0081686247,
-0.0090507027,
-0.0071572019,
0.0372759439,
0.0286965724,
0.0082895923,
0.0047704484,
-0.030300146,
0.0816034898,
0.0398662984,
0.0226883497,
0.0558310524,
0.0112963943,
-0.0065951254,
-0.0491477996,
0.0219904426,
-0.1030452773,
0.0290579945,
0.0100881243,
-0.024586359,
-0.0568733513,
0.0135823134,
-0.0682332739,
-0.0463193096,
0.0265815482,
-0.0382778756,
-0.065336585,
0.0062691444,
0.0474061109,
0.0067761447,
-0.0535899214,
0.0765648708,
0.0003202373,
-0.0062185405,
-0.0270415545,
-0.0528830215,
-0.0008815831,
-0.0302278697,
-0.0054694382,
-0.0273431558,
-0.0046515451,
-0.0563514605,
0.043694526,
-0.0210181922,
0.0021669681,
0.0304667968,
-0.0011915506,
0.0081530809,
-0.02505528,
0.0030966345,
-0.0142442016,
0.0143344626,
-0.0346911214,
-0.025212381,
0.0039824587,
-0.0242927484,
-0.0185273476,
0.0242754389,
-0.062550582,
-0.0613829494,
0.0734446272,
0.015755808,
0.0253083725,
-0.0454742573,
0.0059197876,
0.0009437425,
0.0265393816,
-0.0169669129,
-0.0249725021,
0.0291309804,
-0.0556448922,
-0.0008087099,
0.0026838442,
-0.0455724299,
0.0064450614,
0.030696135,
-0.0037278645,
-0.0221066438,
0.0366365612,
-0.0271591917,
0.0134139182,
0.0151526174,
0.0213423893,
0.0233174432,
0.0593735278,
-0.0483792387,
0.0347057395,
-0.0254198015,
-0.019516455,
0.0050457846,
0.0278778002,
-0.0142226629,
-0.0088534076,
-0.002445284,
-0.0258034095,
-0.0361156166,
0.0282545183,
0.0072176429,
-0.0237080324,
0.0050151804,
-0.0247489978,
0.0254100449,
-0.0030078399,
-0.0438012704,
0.0013684181,
-0.0128123537,
-0.0165179484,
-0.0024370623,
-0.0396105051,
-0.0065064947,
0.0365392007,
0.0090943966,
-0.0293092765,
0.0492295437,
-0.0094433017,
0.0069423956,
-0.0054442505,
-0.0228676684,
0.0104904706,
0.0861137658,
0.0103351455,
0.0109987669,
-0.0514727384,
-0.0143449428,
0.0351949409,
0.0090983622,
-0.0135747539,
0.0000985989,
-0.0591720529,
-0.0031134244,
0.0267270096,
0.1180642471,
0.0221108682,
0.0046470244,
0.0269609075,
0.0094958078,
-0.0157386791,
0.0255476162,
-0.0509908386,
-0.0534563847,
-0.0422738492,
0.0049838005,
0.0503485687,
0.0496353321,
-0.0182280149,
-0.0090621952,
-0.0274363607,
0.0239516236,
0.0278461669,
-0.0165722053,
-0.0356269665,
0.0281685553,
-0.0393640921,
0.0079689575,
-0.0071950536,
-0.0613982007,
0.0497577935,
0.0210735947,
-0.0011013377,
-0.0132715451,
0.0041412185,
-0.0221243799,
-0.0178492665,
-0.0047746054,
-0.0053392816,
0.020491533,
-0.0099524334,
-0.0522931516,
0.0023659552,
0.0221253633,
0.0047830688,
0.0707995445,
-0.0178718306,
-0.0241369382,
-0.0149362255,
-0.0508628227,
-0.0658160374,
-0.055812519,
0.0208277255,
0.0092939511,
0.0376343243,
-0.0302854013,
-0.0428774953,
-0.007758826,
0.0376457907,
0.0520321354,
-0.0420487821,
-0.0421777368,
0.0180590134,
0.0285358634,
-0.0130918622,
0.0360655561,
0.0379131436,
-0.0569278933,
0.0346401595,
-0.0077462681,
0.0536773428,
-0.0259765629,
-0.0548689626,
-0.0014437168,
0.0005636293,
-0.0071928147,
0.016749084,
0.0448917709,
0.0326350853,
-0.0207593776,
-0.0398260579,
0.0413496867,
-0.0063386504,
-0.0857143179,
-0.0225441437,
-0.0027346583,
0.0324146338,
0.0302853715,
0.0517063737,
-0.0202246793,
-0.0149625959,
-0.012068673,
0.0608833395,
0.0201126747,
-0.0110895233,
0.0044969721,
-0.0487218797,
0.038629584,
-0.0073708142,
-0.0407889299,
-0.0152536202,
-0.0259429831,
-0.0118928514,
-0.037834309,
0.0023745468,
-0.0234692935,
-0.051458206,
-0.0291476343,
0.0303569026,
-0.0082354378,
-0.0193252116,
-0.0149995042,
-0.0129498709,
-0.0099513419,
0.0817562938,
-0.0100658182,
-0.0621460527,
-0.0172859412,
0.0366659425,
0.0125102485,
0.020818783,
0.0309858061,
0.0840016827,
-0.0003557911,
-0.0190480482,
0.0045300471,
0.0507871434,
-0.0376618952,
0.0311877728,
0.0146652181,
0.0711253211,
-0.0102652386,
-0.0379507877,
-0.0054298057,
-0.0590255223,
0.03027164,
0.0008951063,
0.0127603672,
-0.0561884083,
-0.0601852797,
-0.0333631672,
0.0179900024,
0.0181649663,
-0.063794218,
0.0323125906,
0.0034440337,
-0.0716057122,
-0.0363299362,
0.000501185,
-0.0271574333,
0.0144719658,
0.0193154942,
-0.0783944353,
0.0190938115,
0.0106097758,
-0.0329919122,
0.0287601184,
0.0103828851,
0.0036362589,
-0.0735998452,
0.0477683172,
0.0699892119,
-0.0741307288,
-0.03055932,
0.0285227709,
-0.1232255474,
-0.026573373,
0.0211718157,
0.0554280579,
0.0056137345,
0.0690524057,
-0.0299777724,
-0.0151209487,
0.0932837501,
0.0639790222,
0.0195220504,
0.0311728641,
0.0744607225,
-0.0288942792,
-0.0223529264,
0.0172506869,
-0.0321959667,
0.0483411476,
0.0473449081,
-0.0426850766,
-0.006024471,
-0.0178141706,
0.0461773388,
-0.0463029742,
0.0979909971,
-0.0047500334,
-0.0017765589,
0.0260071773,
0.0494428501,
0.0994993746,
-0.0073549203,
-0.0126767643,
-0.0363449752,
0.0092577264,
0.021443706,
0.0192138832,
0.0338280909,
0.0455751941,
0.0134206209,
-0.0549174696,
-0.0042235237,
-0.0177349485,
-0.0230154376,
0.0022214747,
0.0492819026,
0.029484015,
0.0093227997,
0.0291074533,
0.0230962783,
0.0423329994,
0.0469204597,
0.0321546346,
0.0281435438,
-0.0300343167,
-0.0363755301,
-0.1041222513,
-0.0443533994,
-0.0131462775,
-0.0290230401,
0.0445103124,
-0.0350069106,
-0.0305168554,
-0.0148575883,
0.0098093962,
-0.0307508018,
0.0037963709,
-0.0225734767,
0.0147032309,
0.0350685716,
-0.0174775459,
0.0106412591,
-0.0196906682,
0.0546253063,
-0.0064579602,
0.0089019993,
-0.0367424898,
0.0250757206,
-0.0409512892,
0.0239344165,
0.011653319,
-0.0229800437,
0.0159869064,
-0.0049516628,
-0.0205789171,
-0.0431132168,
0.0522049852,
-0.0360485464,
0.0558507256,
-0.0382503457,
0.0315674245,
0.0612121336,
-0.0055477531,
0.0171151608,
0.0161910374,
0.0228331629,
0.0084518995,
0.0003653629,
-0.0448359475,
-6.488591431e-33,
0.0323517211,
-0.0481373779,
-0.0156832449,
0.04350565,
0.0391552038,
0.0190421995,
-0.027999334,
0.0037451491,
-0.0191405192,
-0.0011373765,
-0.0579164475,
0.0149505073,
0.0057853148,
0.0469986498,
0.0268841684,
-0.0551428497,
0.0175456535,
-0.0146673741,
-0.0129841389,
0.0345946178,
0.0075397068,
0.0349954441,
0.0672831908,
-0.0499575436,
-0.0433865637,
-0.0270245019,
0.0114162089,
0.0149293458,
-0.0172817465,
0.0313442126,
-0.0200495068,
0.0328357294,
0.0039219265,
-0.068485111,
-0.0252320636,
0.0147136413,
-0.052627217,
-0.0227891952,
-0.0717141777,
0.0099841459,
-0.0487091355,
-0.007438683,
0.0932871178,
0.0170885213,
-0.041982159,
-0.0578826703,
0.0671071559,
0.0063742818,
-0.0436087772,
-0.0394710749,
-0.0092514353,
-0.0113139655,
-0.0313523337,
-0.0552838407,
0.0066864551,
0.0855967179,
-0.0005585501,
0.0391505063,
-0.0382460728,
0.0478725731,
-0.0320268981,
-0.0067413151,
0.0417120531,
0.0624771304,
-0.0070303418,
0.0239848495,
0.0193462558,
0.0054458114,
-0.0405324474,
-0.0869110227,
0.0090515567,
0.0198846683,
0.0390830003,
0.0223070364,
0.028469963,
-0.0292939227,
-0.0619128868,
-0.0061514736,
-0.0179146435,
0.0207498875,
0.0420613065,
-0.0255885851,
0.0096534323,
-0.0317269377,
-0.0437088162,
-0.0310367718,
-0.0116854543,
0.0206224415,
0.0147259906,
0.0147999153,
0.0149050746,
0.0149537483,
0.0264204238,
-0.0347099751,
0.0071170144,
0.0273929723,
0.0128664393,
0.0336665995,
0.0425801314,
0.0108725838,
-0.0410491042,
0.0124112507,
-0.0577765405,
0.0298409592,
0.0222027376,
0.0369619206,
0.047900036,
0.0468767136,
-0.0211327467,
-0.0254569389,
-0.0434907116,
0.0470744893,
0.0028470359,
0.019024156,
0.0488338172,
-0.0044404459,
-0.0090962965,
0.0493641533,
-0.0160869602,
0.0181372091,
-0.0326985046,
0.0874820724,
-0.0242641456,
0.0181354117,
-0.0401500016,
-0.0220523067,
-0.0398986153,
0.0688800067,
0.0127420984,
-0.0827346295,
-0.0126559604,
-0.0169428773,
3.126e-7,
-0.0103773624,
0.0452130176,
0.0117501691,
0.0099535258,
0.0517462194,
0.0276862681,
-0.0461487472,
0.0400395319,
0.0168222804,
-0.0276120529,
0.0233656634,
0.0033271096,
0.0231855344,
-0.0021465409,
-0.0852983519,
-0.0555045642,
-0.0449131504,
0.0642601401,
-0.0159704741,
0.0080013191,
-0.0093000848,
0.0664106682,
0.0025741016,
-0.028924128,
0.0044963048,
0.0270971972,
0.0607009381,
-0.0309087988,
0.0407797918,
-0.0079540107,
-0.0069860937,
-0.0128484108,
-0.0253470186,
0.0324848182,
-0.0331742354,
0.0232903026,
-0.0349486507,
0.0171569902,
0.0109588765,
-0.0461601429,
0.0276453216,
0.0563726388,
0.0240223464,
-0.0152332699,
0.0306495707,
-0.0951296464,
-0.0109413192,
-0.050734546,
-0.0064756447,
0.0253057629,
0.0540043898,
0.0051567331,
0.0213385113,
-0.0235546827,
-0.0018134073,
0.0072543784,
0.0117604453,
-0.0637890399,
-0.025261052,
0.01736922,
-0.0452379808,
-0.0027875679,
-0.0675376952,
-0.0299223755,
0.0635117665,
-0.0009976482,
0.0139226448,
2.799309849e-34,
0.0244065393,
-0.0108024413,
0.0182862803,
-0.0007472339,
-0.0124172755,
-0.0614634752,
0.0292239953,
0.0152692441,
0.0687375143,
-0.0048540412,
-0.0030979377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09922v1 | Learning to Summarize and Answer Questions about a Virtual Robot's Past Actions | 2023-06-16T15:47:24 | 2023-06-16T15:47:24 | Chad DeChant, Iretiayo Akinola, Daniel Bauer | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | When robots perform long action sequences, users will want to easily and
reliably find out what they have done. We therefore demonstrate the task of
learning to summarize and answer questions about a robot agent's past actions
using natural language alone. A single system with a large language model at
its core is trained to both summarize and answer questions about action
sequences given ego-centric video frames of a virtual robot and a question
prompt. To enable training of question answering, we develop a method to
automatically generate English-language questions and answers about objects,
actions, and the temporal order in which actions occurred during episodes of
robot action in the virtual environment. Training one model to both summarize
and answer questions enables zero-shot transfer of representations of objects
learned through question answering to improved action summarization. %
involving objects not seen in training to summarize. | [
0.0269926898,
0.0221142676,
0.0016824562,
-0.0032075564,
-0.004761687,
0.0220605973,
-0.0147781372,
0.0004216909,
-0.0019786013,
-0.0453628972,
0.0194777921,
-0.0216222648,
-0.0129087176,
0.0269416478,
0.0092742695,
-0.0824038833,
0.0598606877,
-0.0233868863,
-0.0185487531,
0.0139906965,
0.0169376973,
0.0066082333,
-0.0299036857,
0.0483024269,
-0.0250799637,
-0.0063569332,
-0.0606154092,
-0.0429412425,
0.0562523231,
-0.0306918751,
-0.031599734,
-0.0053574019,
0.0761859939,
-0.0198592898,
0.0000014794,
-0.0401301943,
0.0001138601,
-0.0256197713,
0.0027180491,
-0.0306730196,
-0.0010001775,
0.008076543,
0.0412276126,
0.0371457636,
-0.0682505369,
-0.0214552041,
0.039150577,
0.0437898263,
0.0898128077,
0.0641519427,
-0.0048436755,
-0.0103153074,
-0.0099580381,
0.0219981559,
0.0304480288,
-0.0296029393,
-0.0191381574,
0.0433747396,
0.0683574975,
0.0013218781,
-0.0174133964,
0.0175519623,
0.0408059545,
-0.0202126224,
-0.0193859767,
0.0543043092,
-0.0044228733,
0.0188295878,
-0.0026714643,
0.068161726,
0.0261599701,
0.0113096666,
0.0237942878,
0.0271016229,
0.0514421128,
-0.0054732701,
-0.0477765761,
0.0626989007,
-0.0141034173,
-0.0431001522,
-0.0138586974,
0.0091957645,
-0.0334759206,
-0.0019546626,
-0.00608182,
0.0127004897,
0.0126079535,
0.002429795,
-0.0703130588,
-0.0129073802,
0.0174585506,
-0.0839577764,
0.0017634185,
0.1109272391,
-0.0353943072,
-0.0003587808,
-0.0297234729,
0.0291077886,
-0.0226022061,
0.0024256527,
0.0023724379,
0.0264940895,
0.0203286614,
0.0515754372,
-0.0334075764,
0.0892596692,
-0.0012633607,
0.029170353,
-0.0498294458,
0.0025295683,
-0.0699153095,
-0.0126894396,
-0.0489465594,
0.0653058514,
-0.0033648286,
-0.0235958286,
0.0130702397,
0.051101286,
0.0015360743,
0.0074087097,
-0.0350803807,
0.0758128911,
0.0062015085,
-0.0145133538,
-0.0542591549,
0.0122356461,
-0.0953895301,
0.0333556756,
0.0198974609,
-0.0300261546,
-0.0328426287,
0.002974926,
0.044317048,
-0.0096800169,
-0.0059060683,
0.0701659471,
-0.03275121,
-0.0162231587,
0.0304432102,
-0.0268749055,
-0.0075097224,
-0.0246574432,
0.0074859527,
-0.0581685603,
0.028478412,
-0.0211820584,
-0.0184264816,
0.0127435131,
0.0055249021,
0.0283135418,
-0.0094870711,
0.0692817718,
-0.0008515185,
0.0184847023,
0.0247677173,
0.0072496319,
0.0527736247,
0.0017695526,
0.0235873852,
0.0207833089,
0.0143026439,
0.0133609278,
0.0493006483,
0.0038675617,
-0.0214101262,
-0.0221818909,
-0.0123540424,
0.0220574141,
-0.0011173586,
0.0455269217,
0.0061041825,
0.0506750904,
-0.0332218967,
-0.0085642682,
0.028226655,
0.0416890606,
-0.0591993555,
-0.0368373618,
0.0505717024,
0.0094494866,
0.0241105296,
0.0197451245,
-0.0143522443,
0.0783926323,
0.0038056828,
0.0220727697,
-0.0182933286,
-0.0075018192,
-0.0698364824,
-0.0435834229,
0.041816622,
-0.0026818933,
0.0242029373,
0.0238142293,
0.0137260426,
0.0328545421,
-0.0522711203,
0.0167042576,
-0.0327654891,
-0.0462830551,
0.0224679559,
-0.0276250392,
0.0541698672,
0.0312012509,
0.010542538,
-0.0402505994,
-0.04822395,
-0.0360065401,
0.0200360306,
0.0265757218,
0.0148364874,
-0.0624752529,
0.0243287869,
-0.0001747852,
-0.0185228921,
-0.0109365201,
-0.0081768641,
0.0285168905,
-0.0061474666,
-0.0121736927,
0.0159069188,
0.0087994337,
0.0053619291,
0.0495174266,
0.0112504773,
-0.0379333645,
-0.0017150678,
0.00885054,
0.0020559209,
0.0302363858,
-0.0137517443,
-0.0014747322,
0.0418216251,
-0.0185747668,
-0.0477097593,
0.030033581,
-0.0225830469,
-0.0607337616,
0.0462818779,
-0.0409028493,
-0.0201934725,
0.0575018153,
-0.0347734392,
-0.0740429983,
-0.0135346185,
-0.0476102531,
0.0075369435,
-0.023213286,
0.0127518531,
0.0329914987,
-0.0144857103,
-0.0433072709,
0.0240452625,
-0.0089152604,
0.0050067408,
0.0369602181,
0.0125405528,
0.0016850401,
-0.0377061032,
0.0140770199,
0.0235032402,
-0.0188908558,
0.0129600484,
0.0789968148,
0.006188842,
-0.0504197665,
0.0147014856,
-0.104686752,
0.0194600448,
0.0106777316,
-0.0080351438,
0.0494659729,
-0.011868502,
-0.0016331634,
-0.0575773306,
-0.0661051273,
0.0113078859,
0.0342254005,
0.0124524059,
0.0627407283,
0.024197232,
0.0006325724,
-0.050154686,
0.0108667659,
-0.0353087112,
0.0061789015,
0.0039587934,
0.0146459974,
-0.0445099548,
0.0136718499,
-0.0535262674,
0.0513199754,
-0.0127845192,
-0.0436873324,
0.0613244325,
-0.0520112179,
0.0089914678,
0.0940500125,
0.0326542705,
0.0104391258,
0.0751784965,
-0.0001796662,
-0.0459582247,
0.0158682987,
-0.0185808148,
-0.0276251826,
0.0071991947,
-0.0017962607,
0.0189608056,
0.0457073636,
0.0066400929,
0.0212887209,
-0.0515038036,
0.0168013405,
0.0088449968,
-0.0283545274,
-0.0372392982,
0.0101757115,
-0.0431112982,
0.0220763534,
-0.0150352782,
-0.0107547175,
0.0524921343,
0.0123557989,
-0.018701721,
0.0057673207,
0.0013344849,
-0.0153143248,
0.0808280483,
0.0381475948,
0.0481251553,
0.0094321333,
-0.0278754216,
-0.0971946642,
-0.0195589904,
0.0151667539,
-0.00068,
0.0124786347,
-0.0584596694,
-0.0068482403,
-0.0106505239,
-0.0071175192,
-0.0497730933,
-0.0331927761,
-0.0402808748,
0.0201405883,
-0.0847375095,
-0.0245861709,
-0.0336291268,
-0.0161893554,
0.0413714051,
0.0167235043,
-0.040963605,
-0.018281579,
-0.0451527908,
0.0518698841,
0.1021879762,
0.0362536274,
-0.0166849047,
-0.0242781471,
0.0584680997,
0.0349509381,
0.0540977903,
0.0089610191,
-0.0357275754,
-0.0091790184,
-0.004093823,
-0.0394798927,
0.0383911654,
0.0484856963,
0.0604170486,
-0.0178670734,
-0.0169382449,
0.1173712611,
0.0292191692,
-0.0116940057,
-0.0026282982,
0.0106590558,
0.0034395265,
0.0406711362,
0.0391311832,
-0.0538446084,
-0.0271002147,
-0.0272412524,
-0.0190905277,
0.0101594329,
-0.0315269716,
-0.0215434227,
-0.1382117569,
-0.0200470556,
-0.0248956885,
-0.0878464729,
-0.0532487743,
0.0013529945,
0.0173527636,
-0.0055113467,
-0.0286936369,
0.0107484339,
-0.0084311161,
-0.0008066929,
0.0045325616,
-0.0400126763,
0.0338646919,
0.0356547795,
-0.0284675211,
0.0432719141,
0.0444421209,
0.0379712619,
-0.0307301525,
0.0173691697,
-0.0246017259,
-0.0021420212,
-0.0010937433,
0.0269582942,
0.0598620251,
-0.0312707983,
-0.0177498944,
-0.0122883664,
0.0222373791,
0.0126312925,
-0.0177345164,
0.0292905625,
0.0247668494,
-0.0187530536,
-0.008770016,
-0.0223724972,
0.0312977359,
-0.0377591662,
0.0582565144,
-0.0017026549,
-0.0126451403,
-0.0359304994,
-0.0142767234,
-0.0360777192,
-0.0276302677,
-0.0499160253,
-0.0346817672,
0.0014283351,
0.0128309699,
-0.1104671285,
-0.0707519948,
0.0570361875,
0.0415631384,
-0.0002638029,
-0.0208141506,
0.0039487001,
0.0487200432,
-0.0563472845,
0.0092153326,
-0.0396497212,
0.0157766175,
-0.0153909568,
0.0198956635,
0.0523282066,
-0.0234369934,
-0.0167069081,
-0.0003155059,
-0.0199957862,
-0.0486042388,
-0.0345048793,
0.1049121991,
0.0214576982,
0.0550956987,
0.0122710755,
-0.0067401752,
0.0177910198,
-0.0122023718,
-0.0102373036,
-0.0259498488,
0.0194604825,
0.0066537601,
-0.0159989186,
0.0042907782,
-0.0477783382,
0.002908984,
-0.0518939495,
0.0412207432,
-0.0941108689,
-0.0657596663,
0.0425719991,
-0.0213613138,
0.0132489745,
-0.0104047637,
0.032695353,
-0.00599223,
-0.0208181757,
-0.0502832495,
0.0133294687,
-0.0568826944,
0.0182144679,
0.0013928235,
-0.0075659123,
0.0393812247,
-0.0030371714,
-0.025270883,
0.0130139915,
0.0158132948,
-0.0656955913,
0.0058543226,
0.0069830115,
-0.0173198022,
0.0259264279,
-0.031214904,
-0.0094068861,
-0.0030186798,
0.056495335,
0.013136751,
0.0865023807,
0.0007509226,
-0.0037618955,
-0.0188869201,
0.0444172025,
-0.0891799107,
-0.0734628811,
0.0113796722,
0.0166802928,
0.0471803024,
-0.0460963175,
0.0224886052,
-0.0053380653,
0.024403125,
-0.0233952049,
0.0572857894,
0.0082732858,
-0.0400728993,
0.0389541388,
0.0448301956,
0.0060629835,
0.0027909421,
0.0750546008,
-0.0196051598,
0.0561036021,
-0.0086726258,
0.0176608656,
-0.0337728038,
-0.0137677696,
-0.002255887,
0.0247278176,
-0.0061075636,
0.0028071571,
-0.0185924899,
-0.045560088,
-0.0411612056,
0.0394354202,
0.0020639214,
-0.0133025274,
0.0595564395,
-0.0189404991,
0.0251225922,
-0.0468235649,
-0.0520010963,
-0.0133158211,
-0.0263793003,
-0.0069664535,
-0.0425831415,
-4.594637871e-33,
-0.0475131273,
-0.0259293579,
0.0340308696,
-0.0242913142,
-0.0365563408,
0.0070616188,
-0.0803705007,
0.0268903989,
-0.041332189,
-0.0081525734,
0.0090658702,
0.0017903959,
0.0042861854,
0.024399735,
0.0212438498,
-0.0347268581,
0.0380511135,
-0.0030431754,
-0.0037724574,
0.0335794277,
0.0315111168,
0.0140323592,
0.0158469975,
-0.0248857513,
-0.0068397857,
-0.0165127888,
-0.0292339027,
0.0465008914,
0.0262888595,
0.0311564934,
-0.0258554555,
-0.0202048831,
0.0196476094,
-0.0404051617,
-0.0341276303,
0.0435104258,
-0.065520443,
-0.0424959958,
0.0102837225,
0.0015976505,
-0.0581525825,
-0.0285793617,
-0.0392392874,
-0.031717252,
0.0439519733,
-0.0256877057,
0.0631956756,
0.0060385102,
-0.0137309367,
-0.0056722285,
-0.0380897485,
-0.0288624763,
-0.0356870778,
-0.0883395672,
0.0118404385,
0.081353277,
0.0257658977,
-0.034998484,
0.0069582635,
0.0207518358,
-0.0131449373,
0.0063984971,
0.0478207506,
0.0308811292,
0.0118754953,
0.064519003,
0.0390940718,
-0.0259238314,
-0.0350760892,
0.0502736345,
-0.0237276275,
0.0437333882,
0.0387819298,
0.0414231047,
0.0213871319,
0.0400975421,
-0.0218626764,
0.0592688359,
-0.0331280418,
0.0819894671,
-0.0352985151,
-0.0059498595,
-0.0071226372,
0.0269594137,
-0.0279869884,
0.0463617891,
0.0017038259,
-0.0290197618,
0.0337981097,
-0.0020095056,
-0.0169771295,
-0.0683607385,
0.0513758771,
-0.0465892442,
0.0314156003,
0.0167947896,
-0.0483847223,
0.0180849116,
-0.0063456986,
0.0275848303,
-0.0098200282,
0.0315212421,
0.0593558848,
-0.0104998872,
-0.0071624368,
0.0441236012,
-0.0082172975,
0.0453302413,
-0.0334847607,
-0.016709784,
-0.0016155074,
-0.0167571399,
-0.0180892572,
0.0197107084,
0.0087810103,
0.0308449771,
-0.0450938269,
0.0558035932,
-0.0401227474,
-0.0413677916,
-0.02600348,
-0.022826219,
-0.0020761897,
0.0086729256,
-0.040698424,
-0.0009219047,
-0.0617086478,
0.0523091145,
0.0060273795,
-0.0392155088,
-0.006511569,
0.0241679568,
2.12e-7,
-0.0254906919,
-0.0175632015,
0.0476257652,
0.04140798,
-0.0259616468,
0.0511726551,
0.0269035902,
0.0524044447,
0.0313591883,
-0.0240554269,
0.035174828,
0.0548872836,
0.0297347289,
-0.0324956365,
-0.061032515,
-0.0416114628,
-0.0208461005,
-0.0510597043,
-0.0312990993,
0.0000515288,
0.0950551108,
0.0657887235,
0.0043698247,
0.0061343452,
0.0050069257,
-0.0457368605,
0.0503246747,
0.0180852693,
-0.0150302947,
-0.0027734865,
0.0239189267,
0.0268499479,
-0.0131661678,
0.0069916486,
-0.0009590213,
-0.0370518565,
0.0093923472,
0.0322615467,
-0.0459680334,
-0.0467790067,
-0.0314810276,
0.0068473415,
0.0237444136,
-0.0082382895,
0.0922295079,
-0.0741118491,
0.018003311,
-0.0263621882,
-0.0144706881,
0.0052906377,
-0.0024803434,
0.0017890483,
-0.0298519228,
0.0354765356,
0.0055579608,
-0.005776891,
0.0101874191,
-0.0820510164,
-0.0323213302,
0.0046909018,
-0.0331782773,
0.0167750102,
0.0084647005,
-0.0171403699,
0.0063674357,
-0.0355500616,
-0.0336267948,
1.183156186e-34,
-0.0143254874,
0.016235698,
-0.0091276811,
0.0555770732,
0.0182805639,
-0.0108242221,
-0.0152038895,
-0.0021122,
0.0538612083,
-0.0562626608,
-0.0324666165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09918v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09918v1 | No Strong Feelings One Way or Another: Re-operationalizing Neutrality in Natural Language Inference | 2023-06-16T15:45:08 | 2023-06-16T15:45:08 | Animesh Nighojkar, Antonio Laverghetta Jr., John Licato | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Natural Language Inference (NLI) has been a cornerstone task in evaluating
language models' inferential reasoning capabilities. However, the standard
three-way classification scheme used in NLI has well-known shortcomings in
evaluating models' ability to capture the nuances of natural human reasoning.
In this paper, we argue that the operationalization of the neutral label in
current NLI datasets has low validity, is interpreted inconsistently, and that
at least one important sense of neutrality is often ignored. We uncover the
detrimental impact of these shortcomings, which in some cases leads to
annotation datasets that actually decrease performance on downstream tasks. We
compare approaches of handling annotator disagreement and identify flaws in a
recent NLI dataset that designs an annotator study based on a problematic
operationalization. Our findings highlight the need for a more refined
evaluation framework for NLI, and we hope to spark further discussion and
action in the NLP community. | [
0.0469524786,
0.0864890963,
0.0054268637,
0.0527325645,
-0.0532960631,
0.0513201058,
0.023949746,
-0.0226081312,
0.0219803024,
-0.1105011106,
-0.0370632596,
0.0259965695,
-0.0075184493,
-0.0245226696,
-0.0010800048,
-0.005073057,
0.0323584974,
0.0181004833,
0.0247065518,
0.0052037849,
0.0139393397,
0.0137696024,
-0.0073611056,
0.0265841447,
0.0009355007,
0.0124787716,
0.0238166898,
-0.0092859734,
-0.007135916,
-0.0242469832,
0.025606839,
0.0589917637,
-0.0021757251,
0.03021737,
0.0000018484,
-0.0676061437,
0.0156110302,
0.0115450909,
-0.0269952118,
-0.0361161195,
0.0349281877,
-0.0056481254,
0.0378008932,
0.0161778089,
-0.0411094949,
0.0130328229,
0.0644426867,
0.0656041503,
0.0315663517,
0.0389677659,
-0.0103830853,
-0.0409851409,
-0.0610813387,
-0.0267624389,
-0.0365159698,
-0.0255682319,
0.0290261433,
0.0305895563,
-0.025749106,
-0.0095196338,
0.0100453179,
0.0343319923,
0.0380079076,
0.0234244447,
-0.0169113409,
0.0240980908,
-0.0439204946,
-0.04435049,
0.0367407762,
0.0410246775,
0.0465801768,
-0.0249080975,
-0.0365302488,
-0.021275552,
0.0268152263,
0.0261069275,
0.0058401981,
0.0561497658,
-0.0552554429,
0.0153254736,
0.0687020645,
0.0302169751,
0.019987544,
0.038225323,
-0.006796197,
0.1021095067,
-0.0082121911,
-0.0299876295,
0.0519003272,
0.0570150614,
-0.051301036,
-0.0193383042,
0.0022722944,
-0.0355920531,
0.0282310545,
0.0309869759,
0.0007070388,
0.002633671,
0.0467778184,
-0.0883738399,
0.0041542971,
0.0134873865,
-0.0335513242,
0.0616892055,
-0.0041109473,
-0.0289998204,
0.0075066099,
0.027172694,
-0.0152468784,
-0.0295734443,
-0.0258459356,
-0.0241552573,
0.0155611094,
0.0220357124,
-0.0081561124,
0.0245756432,
-0.0089068003,
-0.0085549252,
-0.0692501888,
-0.030708272,
0.0263656452,
0.0343921222,
-0.0071712495,
0.0065800515,
-0.0808442757,
0.0374461934,
-0.0460981913,
0.071424976,
-0.0557618625,
-0.0730560571,
-0.0121353073,
0.0481465086,
-0.0185046978,
-0.0400246046,
0.0201524161,
0.0616433918,
0.0060625048,
-0.0074603963,
-0.0341659449,
-0.0405928306,
-0.011111334,
-0.0516077168,
-0.0030227797,
-0.0480349436,
0.0301867779,
0.0465755835,
-0.0029842549,
-0.0741505921,
-0.0001804655,
0.010046104,
-0.0496283136,
0.0738730505,
-0.0265056938,
-0.0298232157,
0.0048764539,
0.0067689745,
-0.0461251065,
0.0745917857,
-0.0131818121,
-0.0268955324,
0.0120293321,
0.0362645425,
-0.0191158149,
-0.0001436066,
0.0101867057,
-0.0177243389,
0.0296794735,
0.0200396013,
-0.0392010212,
-0.0255357344,
0.035501752,
0.0309916008,
-0.0132659068,
-0.0653911978,
0.026079135,
0.0425179526,
-0.0279176701,
-0.0113171404,
0.0402399711,
0.0065045869,
-0.0188206583,
-0.0000823725,
-0.0667389408,
0.0249785874,
-0.0646728575,
-0.0303258318,
-0.006051722,
-0.0197350476,
-0.0064904327,
-0.0660873204,
-0.0400660336,
-0.0196933076,
0.034543816,
-0.0103796227,
0.051369343,
0.0201142337,
0.0013242611,
0.0291275363,
0.0481290743,
-0.0623736754,
0.0001531648,
-0.0429733805,
0.0169656668,
0.0202057045,
-0.0122236516,
-0.0139295487,
-0.051008746,
0.0035760396,
0.0021279803,
0.0457923673,
0.0473214872,
-0.0203624368,
0.0312936977,
-0.0263569877,
-0.0102753397,
-0.0257922709,
0.0512333252,
0.0333370231,
-0.0127208903,
-0.02426471,
0.0146748945,
-0.0365157537,
-0.0225720406,
0.0491264202,
-0.0234999172,
-0.0153214391,
-0.0247947648,
0.0309304986,
0.0236739237,
-0.0048642633,
-0.0008916272,
0.0032341678,
0.0080776187,
-0.016967155,
-0.0332770608,
0.0598764233,
-0.0079846475,
-0.0289127808,
0.0028851228,
-0.0341967121,
-0.0373668149,
0.0386090241,
-0.0370879211,
-0.0061498377,
0.0245325081,
-0.0158348475,
-0.0097013423,
-0.0556602702,
-0.007525736,
-0.0135123357,
-0.0138691515,
-0.0373901799,
0.0730597228,
-0.0077207042,
0.030740343,
-0.0066307052,
-0.0096175931,
0.0417286903,
0.0099373125,
-0.060138911,
0.0086563276,
0.0172109772,
-0.0306555387,
0.0382468216,
-0.0165038444,
-0.0381583944,
0.0024456531,
-0.0779873654,
0.0134823825,
-0.0334283113,
0.0337673724,
0.0260103215,
-0.0279708579,
0.0109101702,
-0.0017396593,
0.0120575763,
-0.0420208797,
-0.016553564,
0.0325494409,
0.0384212658,
-0.0134697799,
0.0202225558,
-0.0055350317,
0.0136418641,
-0.0510717668,
0.0266913027,
0.0231342167,
-0.008067959,
-0.0407130569,
0.0184600726,
-0.0651658997,
0.0303575937,
-0.0009667116,
-0.001447831,
0.0295087174,
0.0212755967,
-0.0391863771,
0.0584534556,
-0.0188212395,
0.0251200702,
0.050441727,
-0.0021164913,
-0.0680715293,
0.0170647837,
-0.0203463156,
0.0045537245,
-0.0040612346,
-0.0565603822,
-0.0261664484,
0.0601547286,
-0.0119877839,
-0.0300029553,
-0.0669433698,
0.0239733607,
-0.046916604,
-0.0131559707,
-0.003009619,
-0.0070787915,
0.0253967084,
0.0301194582,
-0.0252980012,
-0.0155928005,
0.0903917924,
0.0011245866,
-0.0126628419,
-0.0579248443,
0.0001126363,
-0.0530244708,
0.0780896246,
-0.0299790371,
-0.031757012,
0.0385378711,
0.011098424,
0.0037169398,
-0.0142233642,
0.050224334,
0.0066300272,
0.0377214737,
-0.0675225109,
0.0364333019,
-0.0282164458,
-0.0507245883,
-0.0334443375,
-0.0326150134,
-0.0519437231,
0.0137431957,
-0.0135107245,
0.0082145054,
0.0013172488,
0.0117188999,
-0.02731332,
0.0147444429,
-0.0060780146,
-0.0025151565,
-0.0043387255,
-0.0146882907,
0.0180376824,
0.0420568585,
0.0345850587,
0.0244301632,
-0.0136946095,
0.0703429282,
-0.0598503686,
0.0422939621,
-0.0317032039,
0.0167695247,
0.0239540599,
-0.01911374,
-0.0279768873,
-0.0243317652,
0.0337205529,
-0.0375491343,
-0.0095048482,
0.0971542746,
0.0367994756,
-0.0274491534,
-0.0006592883,
-0.0203470476,
0.0131728919,
0.0334250629,
-0.0454456061,
-0.0636134818,
-0.056797836,
-0.0089982171,
0.0247850996,
-0.0273992568,
-0.0457620323,
-0.0116496999,
-0.1061267182,
0.0234623197,
-0.0332142748,
-0.0595699996,
0.0006109333,
-0.0925442651,
0.0410375334,
-0.0508835725,
-0.0231186058,
-0.0102436962,
0.0289947074,
0.0367230475,
0.0267582797,
-0.0100781685,
-0.0610179454,
0.0198174175,
-0.0330499411,
0.0465029217,
-0.0164857619,
0.0329996534,
-0.0118305311,
-0.036633268,
0.0465947464,
-0.0243721884,
-0.0256852452,
-0.0399293378,
0.0590187497,
-0.0054136035,
0.0126377745,
-0.0346849971,
0.0215891358,
-0.0344295427,
-0.0039181774,
-0.0107750157,
0.03970946,
-0.0177696552,
-0.0121965855,
-0.0053961836,
0.0365954079,
0.0213601049,
0.1031349301,
0.0100977561,
-0.0134964427,
-0.0304182954,
-0.0065495009,
-0.0079814615,
-0.0228000246,
-0.0325583406,
0.0270773992,
0.0299903471,
-0.0519879758,
-0.0203540735,
-0.090392746,
0.027348699,
-0.0011060428,
-0.0042790272,
0.0154340314,
-0.007299731,
-0.0032224176,
-0.0108840568,
0.0659534112,
-0.0288084298,
-0.007535012,
0.0509253517,
-0.0139155528,
0.0296165682,
0.0123632401,
-0.0510600396,
0.0295880456,
-0.0368141383,
-0.0416353643,
-0.0067817168,
0.0480758622,
0.0236455183,
0.0170625206,
-0.0220937375,
-0.0130125023,
-0.074627623,
0.0778165013,
0.0046524168,
-0.0011623829,
0.0582781546,
0.0186129771,
0.0321750939,
0.0542514585,
-0.0196493901,
0.016278578,
0.0270978734,
0.0295629464,
-0.0163149796,
-0.0018092585,
0.0260874014,
0.009614245,
0.0533414818,
0.0161517262,
-0.0081204847,
-0.0398428217,
-0.0002400336,
-0.0169840157,
-0.0680574104,
-0.0069093248,
0.022587385,
-0.0023841166,
0.0286150184,
-0.0680097044,
0.0181551222,
-0.0126660429,
0.0566934459,
-0.0217868779,
0.0052979579,
0.1042388082,
0.0208158232,
-0.0645702556,
-0.0298803356,
-0.0361460596,
-0.0040732678,
-0.0033199952,
0.0615416355,
-0.0077748103,
0.0309421681,
0.0425866432,
0.0085304324,
-0.0136069776,
-0.0105974376,
-0.0468657203,
-0.0009593713,
0.0004777616,
0.0203911979,
0.0456236005,
-0.0453368016,
0.0574666932,
-0.0091525763,
-0.0020710574,
0.0214416943,
0.0020756193,
0.0198957827,
-0.0303459354,
0.0465529338,
0.0044321017,
-0.0181356557,
0.0165470373,
0.015001555,
-0.0255316887,
0.0524755865,
-0.022091344,
-0.0417062975,
-0.0279499702,
-0.0638092533,
-0.0022190951,
0.0004765553,
-0.001657461,
0.0239247028,
-0.0794077143,
-0.0647409037,
-0.0306363404,
0.009702309,
0.0120389815,
0.0080215698,
0.0059402804,
0.076691322,
0.0017984445,
-0.0665675774,
-0.01977464,
-0.0003754416,
-0.0295779649,
0.0267609823,
-0.0792319626,
-6.51788328e-33,
-0.0047601247,
-0.0272401925,
0.0073479922,
-0.002325685,
0.0050456603,
-0.0184990969,
-0.0102791926,
0.008627031,
-0.0567570776,
0.0307377614,
0.0149664059,
0.0184212383,
0.0244351644,
-0.0045750621,
0.0270910542,
-0.0466448925,
-0.0012742096,
0.0368842334,
-0.0500665382,
-0.0312813036,
0.0506988205,
-0.0322322249,
0.0718057603,
-0.1014094874,
0.0757547617,
-0.0089976396,
0.0023125641,
0.0238256007,
-0.0662210882,
0.0055992985,
0.0090362839,
0.0500519499,
0.0435889512,
-0.0257648136,
0.0464542694,
-0.0140108475,
-0.0482418798,
-0.047838442,
0.050892774,
0.0251864251,
-0.0464930981,
-0.0029676328,
0.0412894525,
0.0305538252,
-0.0359648541,
0.0154350987,
0.050997898,
-0.0094044982,
0.0657655224,
0.0038658162,
-0.0640129671,
0.0296176039,
-0.007360565,
-0.0116618844,
-0.0060482123,
0.0444522873,
-0.0072082626,
-0.0119567849,
-0.0704298466,
-0.0148622757,
-0.010448521,
-0.023257019,
0.0504659005,
-0.0136202434,
-0.0198041499,
0.0616569482,
0.0080331126,
0.0716739818,
-0.0361595489,
-0.0335308537,
0.0132987825,
0.0116298925,
0.0678787529,
0.0153611032,
0.0456428193,
0.0445274599,
-0.0611775741,
0.0169240218,
0.0201658998,
0.0235139932,
0.0302480329,
-0.0143787712,
-0.0677384511,
-0.0388597064,
-0.0426256955,
-0.090257287,
-0.0383090042,
-0.0109534422,
0.0280374493,
-0.0231589992,
-0.0356904007,
0.0437856317,
0.0106424727,
-0.0209044013,
-0.0107388766,
0.0354829468,
0.0012270226,
-0.0171003342,
0.016795909,
0.015034385,
-0.0429924168,
-0.0070046117,
-0.0002172573,
0.0329407752,
0.0499174222,
-0.0143269906,
0.0638790354,
-0.012246538,
-0.0147131244,
-0.0287164785,
-0.0569503196,
-0.0114147579,
-0.0267113354,
0.0046278033,
0.0468992405,
0.0555192493,
0.0080789151,
0.0199756268,
0.0530135222,
0.0360507183,
-0.0549145341,
0.0206398815,
-0.0158720743,
-0.0475290082,
0.0039682826,
-0.0093770334,
0.0154807027,
0.0127463834,
-0.039376799,
-0.0490787886,
-0.01047167,
0.0037633204,
2.534e-7,
0.101012148,
0.0266834907,
-0.0097006308,
0.0226654969,
-0.005446292,
0.0310146492,
0.0053150859,
-0.0138443774,
0.0572059229,
-0.0101530403,
-0.0200110693,
0.0375237316,
0.0100605441,
0.0637898371,
-0.0435765535,
-0.0013813846,
-0.0388979726,
0.0016069255,
-0.0199972019,
0.0085226512,
0.1005463675,
0.0478688255,
0.045554705,
-0.0031533779,
-0.0352227837,
-0.0307093766,
0.0376845188,
-0.0033605467,
0.0258424785,
0.0084217675,
0.0516157299,
-0.0052936939,
0.0248047076,
0.0828231499,
0.0354956873,
0.0153050395,
-0.0048085968,
0.0505497046,
-0.0177405328,
-0.0363106616,
-0.0550092682,
-0.0202835519,
0.0239992589,
-0.0324680135,
0.1019852906,
-0.0465045273,
-0.0629997179,
-0.0236427914,
-0.0198455676,
0.0237492025,
0.0572442561,
0.0183647238,
-0.0260343868,
0.0124535589,
0.0109115718,
-0.0291246306,
-0.0518685728,
-0.0546732284,
-0.0458209701,
-0.0180995129,
-0.0335410796,
-0.0422709472,
0.0098822434,
0.0253412854,
0.0420862064,
-0.035416007,
0.0131475013,
1.910015771e-34,
0.0018163673,
0.0034567385,
0.0272601955,
0.0297666062,
0.0491913967,
0.0167717542,
0.0088736331,
0.0043104989,
0.0002010651,
-0.0417506583,
-0.0011080744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09896v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09896v5 | Is Self-Repair a Silver Bullet for Code Generation? | 2023-06-16T15:13:17 | 2024-02-02T18:31:34 | Theo X. Olausson, Jeevana Priya Inala, Chenglong Wang, Jianfeng Gao, Armando Solar-Lezama | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.PL, cs.SE | Large language models have shown remarkable aptitude in code generation, but
still struggle to perform complex tasks. Self-repair -- in which the model
debugs and repairs its own code -- has recently become a popular way to boost
performance in these settings. However, despite its increasing popularity,
existing studies of self-repair have been limited in scope; in many settings,
its efficacy thus remains poorly understood. In this paper, we analyze Code
Llama, GPT-3.5 and GPT-4's ability to perform self-repair on problems taken
from HumanEval and APPS. We find that when the cost of carrying out repair is
taken into account, performance gains are often modest, vary a lot between
subsets of the data, and are sometimes not present at all. We hypothesize that
this is because self-repair is bottlenecked by the model's ability to provide
feedback on its own code; using a stronger model to artificially boost the
quality of the feedback, we observe substantially larger performance gains.
Similarly, a small-scale study in which we provide GPT-4 with feedback from
human participants suggests that even for the strongest models, self-repair
still lags far behind what can be achieved with human-level debugging. | [
0.0164556783,
0.0698813125,
-0.0407691672,
-0.0012874927,
-0.0090446798,
0.0067961547,
-0.0440554358,
0.0113425693,
0.0258685593,
-0.0274290573,
-0.0114236176,
0.0290077273,
0.0263025239,
0.0328446403,
0.0482076854,
-0.022475671,
0.0314689949,
-0.0498210862,
-0.0080626747,
-0.0039904136,
-0.0136438766,
0.002310236,
-0.0173508804,
0.0383210108,
0.0103228772,
-0.02787444,
-0.0137748271,
0.0051952251,
-0.0188478623,
-0.0104198195,
0.0259290393,
0.0278243497,
-0.0316261351,
0.0167653318,
0.0000020702,
-0.0406057984,
0.0053314273,
-0.0082405461,
0.031380143,
0.0692627877,
-0.0156864692,
-0.0154170971,
-0.0582118593,
0.0594179071,
-0.0342624858,
-0.0091586811,
0.0410827547,
-0.0486814715,
0.0600293837,
0.0572176501,
0.0090172207,
0.0144875441,
0.0185206365,
0.0089372573,
0.0345618762,
-0.0098261684,
-0.0276813582,
0.0439173989,
0.0286016501,
-0.0360582061,
-0.0124889091,
0.0146062206,
0.0528800637,
-0.0420268103,
0.0002049898,
0.0400106534,
-0.0356616788,
-0.0244206134,
0.0081797447,
-0.0032492015,
-0.0595840253,
-0.0354513377,
0.0098245777,
-0.0117430612,
0.0013592918,
-0.0324321352,
-0.0239761211,
0.0393766128,
0.0168379117,
0.011674637,
0.02128838,
-0.0597437322,
0.0331859551,
-0.0304839704,
-0.005984439,
0.0357248746,
-0.000765225,
-0.0011874131,
-0.0529641807,
0.035307359,
-0.0030775361,
-0.0581718162,
-0.0127395373,
0.0527469814,
-0.0119248368,
0.0090368949,
-0.053268075,
0.0047638007,
0.0232873838,
0.0001962019,
0.0170132089,
0.0606134534,
-0.0279788617,
-0.0372040905,
-0.052899085,
0.0210422128,
0.0016537098,
-0.0087928325,
-0.000634898,
0.0396421775,
-0.0437399969,
-0.0337930508,
-0.032888826,
0.0465826206,
0.0390719399,
0.0623297989,
-0.0390547402,
0.056993708,
0.0068273409,
0.040821027,
-0.0221365262,
-0.0217399709,
-0.0456014611,
0.007018026,
0.0152768381,
-0.0059768194,
-0.029495392,
-0.0418494903,
0.0227267183,
-0.0885127187,
0.0041786614,
-0.0220863745,
-0.0476170816,
-0.0309398733,
0.0022644952,
0.0546348877,
-0.0076499223,
0.0189925842,
-0.0492984205,
-0.0517219678,
-0.0126546463,
-0.0520554595,
-0.036568325,
-0.0689604655,
-0.0600545481,
0.0101262517,
-0.0136446487,
-0.0583869442,
0.0173493437,
-0.0115226079,
-0.0054460266,
0.0430019423,
-0.0697726458,
0.0479074456,
0.0142508056,
0.0129622733,
0.0064420183,
0.0407759473,
0.0634765029,
0.0071876398,
0.0126718264,
-0.0337585099,
0.0719421729,
0.0149827013,
-0.0004266085,
-0.0004258947,
0.0084079066,
-0.0156285465,
0.0145360278,
0.0318638831,
0.047231026,
0.0327378809,
0.0011566601,
0.0558146238,
0.0374744907,
0.0084118862,
0.0191430598,
0.0673559085,
0.0399776436,
-0.0110243363,
0.0149591221,
0.019783413,
-0.0647867769,
0.0513662994,
-0.0178194214,
0.0403475165,
-0.0169966482,
0.0276150927,
0.0015124556,
-0.0838455483,
-0.0107193403,
0.0103093758,
-0.0207148623,
0.0039939629,
0.0455916934,
0.0045513371,
-0.0247523133,
-0.0025137882,
0.0008944892,
-0.0814593881,
-0.0376064219,
-0.1173560843,
0.0564149469,
0.0729398057,
0.0597108528,
-0.0223952364,
-0.0507617518,
0.0121157365,
-0.0480234548,
-0.0430879667,
0.0660059974,
0.003942186,
-0.016877668,
-0.0175522342,
0.0065450594,
-0.0493067391,
0.0142191006,
0.0515805483,
0.0277247075,
-0.0205342937,
0.02782836,
0.0197749492,
-0.0516604558,
0.02669001,
-0.0021837906,
0.015169424,
0.0272464901,
-0.0254673027,
-0.0153681813,
-0.0259174425,
-0.0458544977,
0.015539228,
0.0253445823,
0.0130079789,
-0.0221046396,
0.0232666545,
-0.0307512023,
-0.0263236128,
0.0256907158,
-0.0049118027,
-0.0502768792,
0.0481375866,
-0.008470254,
-0.0296018701,
0.0682328865,
-0.0301792454,
0.0053904927,
-0.0113081336,
0.0500275679,
-0.0159718469,
-0.0423666947,
-0.0038679498,
0.0262855906,
0.0320322737,
-0.0156849008,
-0.0403836891,
0.0925010294,
0.0129901143,
-0.0351034999,
-0.013663887,
0.033148028,
-0.0275229402,
0.0341902003,
0.0099461237,
0.0308361109,
-0.0286865868,
-0.0633380413,
-0.06544815,
0.0142515823,
-0.0253886245,
0.0073409574,
0.0371542275,
0.0247992966,
-0.0144691393,
-0.0108452011,
-0.0182065777,
-0.0021064319,
0.0495769158,
0.0303932223,
0.0383187868,
-0.0205507204,
-0.0412747189,
-0.0552557409,
0.0033259445,
-0.0230744909,
-0.0295334868,
0.0104192095,
-0.0105275521,
-0.0886793137,
0.070630759,
0.0003173926,
0.0152720138,
0.0075292219,
-0.0840579793,
0.0352200419,
-0.0189685989,
0.0819847807,
0.0541785955,
-0.0459109545,
0.0129180951,
0.0554046519,
0.004025613,
-0.0283030923,
0.0177521519,
0.0487797894,
-0.0799208805,
0.0014316142,
-0.0475197546,
0.0136679504,
0.0790451169,
-0.0121983308,
-0.0368419662,
-0.0473366305,
0.0465359092,
-0.0006602979,
-0.0125388131,
0.0070868842,
-0.022493124,
0.0058638705,
0.0640389919,
-0.0264704246,
-0.1180666313,
0.0227183364,
-0.0032749188,
-0.009061926,
0.0075072017,
-0.0039299014,
-0.0351858325,
0.0842711031,
0.0040419977,
0.0054968279,
0.0154048055,
-0.0513658077,
-0.0181223284,
0.009028309,
0.0097008236,
-0.0132477377,
0.0365718044,
-0.0860094279,
0.0176278725,
-0.0082313819,
-0.0773216113,
-0.0129770162,
0.011473584,
-0.0332258493,
-0.0377944261,
0.0120307803,
-0.0065965783,
0.0197396316,
-0.0283634141,
0.009478583,
0.0213668868,
-0.0078670187,
-0.0513540544,
0.0168687273,
-0.0345621966,
-0.0441826954,
-0.022201445,
0.001186583,
-0.0291092377,
0.0123519199,
0.0282825567,
0.0730330348,
0.0332287438,
-0.0589242727,
0.0162552856,
0.017262591,
-0.0045896326,
-0.0627174824,
0.0440259129,
0.0870187581,
-0.0513074622,
-0.0545515344,
0.0605761297,
0.0082265064,
-0.0047558658,
0.0269111004,
-0.0318150446,
0.0369200595,
0.0356131978,
0.0631470233,
-0.0444554575,
-0.0120333452,
0.0495845713,
0.0568968095,
-0.0096231643,
-0.0040012542,
0.0084375795,
-0.0876665711,
0.0611949004,
0.0152665311,
-0.0112751964,
-0.0235997662,
-0.0230708383,
-0.0237938054,
-0.0161011163,
-0.0131580178,
0.0503439605,
-0.0148689365,
0.0422884114,
0.0057743061,
-0.0447134003,
0.0038354313,
0.0178761743,
-0.0082580671,
0.0560594425,
0.1094886363,
0.012407124,
0.0239475518,
0.0096602002,
0.0446979925,
0.0080097783,
0.0357949398,
-0.0131288525,
0.0220799595,
0.0393757559,
-0.0259485412,
0.0423087627,
0.0222963095,
-0.0554590374,
-0.015502234,
0.0162576791,
0.0063022193,
-0.004231004,
-0.0030885043,
-0.0208522882,
-0.0427001864,
-0.0456262678,
0.005714559,
0.0324521586,
-0.001635319,
-0.059715312,
-0.0698216856,
-0.0259098411,
-0.0751212612,
-0.041908253,
-0.0136061488,
0.0037618072,
-0.0063980394,
-0.0506985895,
-0.0485750623,
0.0139585976,
0.0388468765,
0.005314074,
-0.042571988,
-0.0030863443,
0.0179168563,
-0.0379845016,
0.0012636952,
-0.0300400313,
0.0171259735,
-0.0430934578,
-0.0163523089,
-0.0055879066,
-0.0186952539,
0.0133550502,
-0.0102159642,
-0.057963755,
-0.0604370907,
0.0193585865,
0.1110220701,
0.0290005654,
0.0012386629,
-0.038815327,
-0.0734205544,
-0.0674895346,
0.0338012986,
-0.0487825982,
0.0372253843,
-0.0016531828,
-0.0112897409,
0.018212948,
-0.0016547251,
-0.0271388236,
-0.0050559184,
0.0153408516,
0.0107822716,
0.0276435725,
0.0058090077,
0.0429569781,
0.0435784981,
0.0093528852,
0.0145899476,
0.0002481036,
0.0030930112,
-0.0097137308,
0.0043207724,
-0.0064068474,
-0.0484891199,
0.0430538915,
0.0190529022,
-0.0284736957,
0.0246100761,
-0.0159970634,
-0.0612474009,
0.0334546603,
-0.0259178076,
-0.0050928839,
-0.0181953218,
0.025499776,
0.0688547939,
0.0253502913,
0.0103091523,
0.0330824032,
0.0300706793,
0.031546399,
0.0005858026,
0.0175662525,
-0.0126141356,
0.0479046665,
0.0172335096,
0.0188973211,
-0.0540597551,
-0.0822427794,
0.012896602,
0.0066880677,
0.0597851686,
0.0483270623,
0.0382060036,
-0.0099486401,
0.0012989528,
-0.0194858089,
0.033466585,
0.0060458062,
-0.0058270087,
-0.0378397591,
0.0041162558,
-0.0193472225,
-0.0640976802,
0.0909745619,
-0.0179365315,
0.0549815632,
-0.0035990905,
0.011381357,
-0.016077375,
-0.0144236106,
0.0283300392,
-0.0442686714,
-0.003443474,
-0.0706399307,
-0.0144848982,
-0.0800226405,
-0.0335657112,
0.0587095171,
0.0412841737,
-0.0337190144,
0.0021028686,
0.0827006698,
0.0020325736,
0.0186024271,
-0.0254393592,
0.0155011648,
-0.0035490487,
-0.0204599649,
0.0175163858,
-5.634929433e-33,
-0.0296832547,
-0.0333092734,
0.0191450603,
-0.0079989759,
-0.0007119425,
-0.0280075781,
-0.0641089231,
0.0448096953,
0.0447637588,
-0.00775305,
-0.0052045588,
0.0309018046,
-0.010071829,
-0.0383044966,
0.0762101635,
0.0545336157,
0.0636317059,
0.0185796302,
-0.0920850337,
0.0172045305,
-0.0354860276,
0.0398465768,
-0.0076853433,
-0.018695984,
-0.0150905792,
0.0002404047,
-0.0057347519,
0.006009636,
-0.0118520753,
0.0307918154,
0.01925111,
0.0056470907,
0.0041287881,
0.0034125946,
-0.0393464528,
-0.0317213088,
-0.0206408035,
-0.0190920196,
-0.0121208057,
-0.0021934677,
-0.0249371622,
-0.0835805237,
0.070436582,
0.0218089055,
-0.0418481566,
0.0142848697,
-0.0041170521,
-0.0092701977,
0.0028008025,
0.0011850107,
-0.0440647677,
0.0276494119,
-0.0515736938,
-0.0477789193,
-0.0170529932,
-0.0073920032,
-0.0052669686,
0.0162454452,
0.0178865585,
0.0053551882,
0.0288398005,
0.0617329553,
0.0499067977,
-0.0496144556,
-0.0175782405,
0.0162910894,
0.0444817469,
0.0441246107,
-0.0028211616,
0.0038886236,
0.0489472747,
0.0187491309,
0.0565146282,
0.0248657614,
0.0409695394,
-0.0251968838,
-0.0263357032,
0.0561892726,
-0.0174582358,
0.0015933429,
-0.0183689184,
0.0589656606,
-0.0150943669,
-0.0088940328,
-0.0457576215,
-0.0270008184,
-0.0181171261,
-0.0604101866,
0.0316995122,
0.0186275952,
-0.0296364091,
-0.0328950509,
-0.0029535259,
0.0020082884,
0.0024274876,
-0.0353304595,
-0.0756493732,
0.0553373359,
-0.0283708014,
0.0191046,
-0.0038192996,
0.0019920366,
-0.02733716,
0.0662380978,
0.0695603937,
0.0109630227,
0.0149135794,
0.0491591468,
-0.0714303255,
0.0239884611,
-0.0622090288,
0.038900312,
-0.0083555384,
-0.0178858694,
-0.0115870768,
-0.010289615,
0.0175579023,
0.0208767466,
0.006596359,
-0.028520098,
-0.0817189962,
0.0452787988,
0.0138707599,
0.002267672,
-0.0104573937,
-0.0402296335,
-0.0461204909,
0.0589040257,
0.0241943635,
-0.0419991128,
-0.0589876287,
-0.008996292,
2.709e-7,
-0.007790071,
0.0373165943,
0.0115956524,
0.0217554718,
0.0366597213,
0.0490625873,
-0.0216397326,
-0.0071668262,
0.0508189909,
0.0380040519,
-0.016314948,
0.0028160154,
0.0446150415,
0.0346791483,
0.0064562405,
0.0427930728,
-0.0395858064,
0.0247885697,
-0.0459009893,
-0.0228952803,
-0.0256655142,
0.0169051383,
0.0121609941,
-0.0048445947,
0.0374358073,
-0.0065511107,
0.0165182073,
-0.0055718906,
-0.0247525442,
0.0293080602,
-0.0413465574,
0.0794761479,
-0.0128808841,
-0.0462194979,
-0.0222966485,
-0.0482640341,
-0.0206202269,
0.0517270304,
0.0081456648,
0.0522571839,
0.0520468019,
0.0190064255,
0.0184812993,
-0.0678238049,
0.0384666324,
-0.0356882289,
-0.0091615375,
0.0003327836,
0.0366978906,
-0.0181714296,
0.013142704,
-0.038978003,
0.0020081613,
0.0275714491,
-0.0137603115,
0.0087956013,
-0.0316904113,
-0.0265058447,
-0.0529944189,
0.0077873962,
-0.0081680408,
-0.0314029492,
-0.0605705827,
0.0299865529,
0.0145707149,
-0.0389879122,
0.0040950323,
2.289989958e-34,
0.0114592025,
-0.0291732885,
0.0290957,
0.0200223867,
0.0695499778,
0.0055208509,
0.0131403254,
0.0280612279,
0.0037297006,
0.0455025844,
-0.0539657548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09877v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09877v1 | Revealing the impact of social circumstances on the selection of cancer therapy through natural language processing of social work notes | 2023-06-16T14:40:39 | 2023-06-16T14:40:39 | Shenghuan Sun, Travis Zack, Christopher Y. K. Williams, Atul J. Butte, Madhumita Sushil | cs.CL | cs.CL | We aimed to investigate the impact of social circumstances on cancer therapy
selection using natural language processing to derive insights from social
worker documentation. We developed and employed a Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers (BERT) based approach, using a hierarchical
multi-step BERT model (BERT-MS) to predict the prescription of targeted cancer
therapy to patients based solely on documentation by clinical social workers.
Our corpus included free-text clinical social work notes, combined with
medication prescription information, for all patients treated for breast
cancer. We conducted a feature importance analysis to pinpoint the specific
social circumstances that impact cancer therapy selection. Using only social
work notes, we consistently predicted the administration of targeted therapies,
suggesting systematic differences in treatment selection exist due to
non-clinical factors. The UCSF-BERT model, pretrained on clinical text at UCSF,
outperformed other publicly available language models with an AUROC of 0.675
and a Macro F1 score of 0.599. The UCSF BERT-MS model, capable of leveraging
multiple pieces of notes, surpassed the UCSF-BERT model in both AUROC and
Macro-F1. Our feature importance analysis identified several clinically
intuitive social determinants of health (SDOH) that potentially contribute to
disparities in treatment. Our findings indicate that significant disparities
exist among breast cancer patients receiving different types of therapies based
on social determinants of health. Social work reports play a crucial role in
understanding these disparities in clinical decision-making. | [
0.0722176582,
0.0537238605,
0.0000349542,
-0.016215194,
-0.0023749247,
0.0404346026,
0.0051235724,
-0.0228161216,
0.0091192406,
-0.074816227,
0.0261739064,
-0.0257775746,
0.0112999436,
0.0470827855,
-0.0057555623,
-0.0450729914,
-0.0150829004,
0.0588346757,
0.0331265293,
0.0133662019,
0.0146193411,
0.0336570069,
0.0191318579,
0.064326793,
0.0075251837,
0.0174234435,
0.0654847547,
-0.0155162262,
0.0185562707,
-0.058157675,
0.0103962878,
0.0445826948,
0.0020869956,
-0.0129951052,
0.0000019557,
-0.0778070018,
-0.0214148927,
0.0326006748,
-0.0190459341,
-0.0547309667,
0.0135408873,
-0.1024419665,
-0.0020342735,
0.0147938086,
-0.0044803089,
0.0068505532,
0.0134041524,
0.0622775257,
0.0037530276,
0.0509791113,
-0.0302524511,
-0.0291418321,
-0.0278704278,
-0.0141862864,
-0.014147005,
0.0016085316,
0.0287863165,
-0.0415738449,
-0.0304348767,
-0.0134570654,
0.0119030187,
0.0221301671,
-0.040420644,
0.0127832415,
0.0265325904,
0.0353593156,
-0.0209450386,
0.0195410158,
0.0079032239,
0.0683049336,
0.0216460153,
0.0465137511,
0.0270456783,
-0.0128667932,
0.0129568512,
0.0709601492,
-0.0043407776,
-0.0141030196,
-0.0345198214,
0.02383692,
-0.0010780798,
0.0302960649,
-0.0246628765,
-0.0198388267,
-0.0028417774,
0.0266648177,
-0.0142525416,
-0.0032967401,
0.0193418264,
0.0048814099,
-0.0042852974,
-0.0575720929,
0.080467239,
-0.0017238605,
0.0082340352,
0.0383612774,
0.0020537486,
-0.0402755253,
0.0533746667,
-0.0828592032,
0.0035671806,
0.0094844457,
-0.0134954359,
0.0131915109,
0.0192829985,
-0.0015747087,
0.0016225599,
0.0420110188,
-0.0428248867,
0.0217291452,
-0.0366527699,
0.0027035952,
-0.0174374916,
0.0183831882,
-0.0269753896,
0.0002708063,
-0.0537930951,
-0.0228699334,
-0.0131212808,
0.0133210532,
0.0755264461,
0.0338534862,
0.0041219722,
0.030156415,
-0.0053250976,
-0.001198234,
-0.0320320614,
0.0072490172,
-0.019908309,
-0.0384683721,
0.055504404,
-0.0101137357,
0.0322305784,
-0.0409418531,
0.0009211728,
0.0577883907,
0.0075971619,
-0.0559693873,
-0.0332404152,
-0.0337595791,
-0.0429453403,
-0.0225959867,
0.0100321192,
-0.0503575429,
-0.0025244788,
0.041418843,
0.0094352644,
-0.0413604341,
0.0027244028,
-0.0027079654,
-0.0713228211,
0.0583582185,
0.0278788526,
-0.0169135071,
0.0520779006,
-0.0016054612,
0.0087469239,
-0.0023316955,
0.0235760026,
-0.0031693173,
-0.005536343,
-0.0460643321,
-0.0031064756,
-0.0195298437,
0.0348337032,
-0.0243579242,
0.0131690577,
0.0327753946,
-0.0401822738,
0.0299252141,
-0.0386888944,
0.0367828496,
-0.0132326866,
-0.0268961564,
0.020454092,
0.0867306739,
0.036712233,
0.0831532031,
-0.0359840803,
0.0207727011,
-0.0399341695,
-0.0217521992,
-0.0190202463,
0.0088953106,
-0.0101495488,
-0.0275439341,
-0.0109121259,
0.000259548,
-0.0040838406,
-0.0492172576,
-0.0281505845,
-0.0119355181,
0.021227682,
-0.0405999199,
0.0309296083,
-0.0146319605,
-0.0433943272,
0.0071124826,
0.0056979544,
-0.0147391493,
-0.0386534221,
-0.0193767659,
-0.0362817422,
0.1240064204,
0.0408846065,
-0.0587605238,
-0.0025165419,
-0.0282680485,
-0.0114887049,
0.0072013466,
-0.0062996647,
0.0075509348,
-0.0234669913,
-0.0052351477,
-0.0391335189,
0.0355222374,
0.0109646488,
-0.0029351814,
-0.0368523188,
0.0431495123,
-0.0330225006,
-0.0265784096,
-0.0074943588,
0.0716063157,
0.0426532179,
-0.0594240837,
-0.0156589225,
0.0133555159,
0.0421673357,
0.0409933962,
-0.0018472199,
0.0576547012,
0.0001360397,
-0.0365622118,
-0.0458290204,
0.0432124138,
-0.0289013013,
-0.0317116007,
-0.0427058153,
-0.0452178232,
0.0119577944,
0.0327498764,
-0.0296440292,
0.0099245505,
0.0386802219,
-0.0666062087,
0.0525488555,
0.0008048005,
-0.0158162098,
0.0268010907,
0.0164899714,
-0.0264390372,
0.0352915674,
-0.0645259768,
-0.0155681064,
-0.0157719366,
-0.0648398176,
-0.0081540523,
-0.0147094009,
0.0253492929,
0.0274655949,
0.0040467493,
-0.009873813,
0.0058369245,
-0.0127997845,
0.0175365563,
-0.016166443,
-0.107188575,
-0.0578900278,
-0.023765998,
0.0120380726,
-0.0000289206,
0.0067720446,
0.017959591,
-0.0456931256,
-0.0501264259,
-0.0380663499,
-0.0007487485,
0.0233308412,
0.0193929505,
0.0123781618,
0.0034876503,
-0.0296428632,
-0.0424449816,
-0.0359832719,
0.0686947554,
0.025314901,
-0.0556418076,
-0.0265825726,
-0.0247385204,
-0.0159164183,
0.0080100307,
-0.0105929272,
-0.0290780216,
0.013070981,
0.0155376224,
-0.0095824813,
0.0109209036,
0.0041986313,
0.0481756106,
0.0200312585,
0.0206043161,
-0.0480232276,
-0.0211683717,
-0.0220284071,
0.0192606263,
-0.0206037927,
-0.0591634624,
0.0106461858,
0.0769682229,
0.0280405171,
-0.016742222,
-0.0409004502,
-0.0501957424,
0.0029011189,
0.0223346334,
-0.0601992682,
-0.0137400618,
-0.0073963706,
0.0021766422,
0.022859009,
-0.030193029,
0.1179679334,
-0.0070323492,
0.0375024229,
-0.1065462753,
0.0075980825,
-0.029316999,
0.0055406936,
0.0005676335,
-0.0044817114,
-0.0204158612,
-0.0156510267,
0.0392939411,
-0.0570083372,
0.0064501306,
-0.0079854252,
0.05692406,
-0.0337012894,
0.0543611571,
0.0169107895,
-0.0124606406,
-0.0243308377,
-0.0695106089,
-0.0170733873,
0.0092407074,
0.042693831,
-0.0128054097,
-0.0576781482,
-0.0084842965,
-0.0213891957,
0.0973694623,
0.0514082871,
-0.0285451412,
-0.0140421232,
-0.010126939,
0.027342638,
0.0058329296,
-0.0098560182,
0.0009102057,
0.0065287659,
0.0306313969,
0.0086133275,
-0.0069777672,
-0.0006710123,
0.0180620626,
0.003850494,
-0.0429359823,
0.0215466358,
0.026565548,
0.0153730074,
-0.0254235622,
0.0083521446,
0.0983934104,
0.0266579147,
0.0034183334,
0.0495102704,
-0.0043663345,
-0.0505291149,
-0.0138605321,
0.0130636273,
-0.0375521258,
-0.0284310151,
-0.0527438521,
0.0333675891,
-0.0334191993,
-0.0323750116,
0.0159044266,
-0.0117814587,
-0.0037739002,
-0.0247832183,
-0.0104581844,
-0.0192770325,
-0.0197305884,
-0.0165793095,
-0.0186782237,
-0.0511577167,
-0.014523482,
0.0034333954,
-0.0167993736,
0.0029490795,
-0.0768315122,
-0.0393655561,
0.0270175058,
-0.0212677401,
-0.0155524472,
0.0645110235,
0.0205436628,
-0.0238317214,
-0.0113601834,
-0.0329855792,
0.0525611304,
-0.0129251154,
0.0163006578,
0.0992349088,
-0.0233602375,
0.0256178603,
-0.0507606566,
0.0312643237,
-0.0622800849,
-0.0187799577,
-0.0430461019,
0.0453109518,
-0.0700792149,
-0.0616015345,
-0.0087760352,
0.0367167182,
0.0352202728,
0.0462422445,
-0.0047405628,
0.0476041213,
-0.0174653027,
-0.014362962,
0.0428010002,
0.0282417629,
0.019214727,
0.0446472205,
-0.0177227147,
-0.07946942,
-0.0858424529,
-0.0449067429,
0.0553302988,
-0.0503804721,
0.0012607431,
-0.0216477253,
0.0790918022,
-0.0097157406,
-0.0726511255,
0.0647336617,
0.0583984219,
0.0280973371,
0.0068684625,
-0.0875244662,
0.0307243671,
0.015387577,
-0.0158926547,
-0.0224712789,
0.0514759608,
0.0081007378,
-0.0075156405,
-0.0040687285,
0.0175265446,
-0.027230667,
0.0109302485,
-0.0578395836,
0.056295339,
0.0120393299,
0.0108398367,
-0.0233232677,
-0.0052226642,
0.0256313849,
0.007487813,
0.0076845866,
-0.0037546072,
0.0331890769,
-0.0220758691,
0.0229906403,
-0.0147047024,
0.0099635087,
0.0120392628,
-0.0044872076,
0.0391383134,
0.00720743,
-0.0131862042,
-0.0589793511,
-0.0085602729,
-0.0139679173,
0.0151406545,
-0.0434009396,
-0.0343806781,
-0.0097482363,
0.0009651125,
-0.0550322719,
0.0190409906,
-0.1029265895,
-0.0345369428,
-0.0486541167,
0.0661549792,
0.0270616077,
0.0077773985,
0.0280301981,
-0.0223218519,
-0.0016918045,
0.0030016375,
-0.0168976709,
0.0235018823,
-0.0193100683,
0.0411923863,
0.01416214,
0.0410671681,
0.0115452101,
0.0454417355,
-0.0487686843,
-0.0650964081,
-0.0573291406,
0.0055780597,
0.0025829813,
-0.0407894254,
0.0544465631,
-0.0348347053,
0.0219688918,
-0.031972073,
0.0152607253,
-0.0039999168,
0.0233062208,
0.0586961061,
0.0057962728,
-0.0134721426,
-0.02847871,
0.0699122772,
0.0129735274,
0.023257589,
-0.0297552664,
-0.0553379394,
-0.0247747991,
-0.0453366302,
0.0311176609,
0.0115011279,
-0.0597437918,
-0.0074469685,
-0.0797593221,
-0.0117919445,
0.0398872159,
-0.0511868633,
-0.0148061672,
-0.0027775308,
0.0681324527,
0.0454232916,
0.0073773102,
-0.0444488525,
-0.0459880233,
0.033690881,
0.0131824724,
-0.030620696,
-0.0201058686,
-5.471978733e-33,
0.0156191783,
-0.0404407717,
-0.0168598704,
-0.0237855483,
0.0597714111,
-0.0001275513,
-0.0385526046,
-0.0207496323,
0.0295963287,
0.0396524258,
0.0237358995,
0.0488568582,
-0.000729343,
0.0329482369,
0.0108504323,
-0.0632656217,
0.0420556664,
-0.0073739314,
-0.0205322802,
-0.0189934317,
0.014578986,
0.0752116665,
0.0451828018,
-0.0718557537,
0.0729517341,
0.0347442515,
0.0357901342,
-0.0238392726,
0.0128383627,
0.0232987963,
-0.0246801637,
0.0724961758,
0.0449490733,
-0.0190851633,
0.0096053723,
0.062023893,
-0.0394586958,
-0.0558997281,
-0.0204487182,
-0.014048513,
-0.0537162609,
-0.0037587595,
0.0665231943,
0.0101920115,
-0.0438191444,
0.013260874,
0.0740438029,
-0.0174118709,
0.0065456852,
-0.0078975754,
-0.0366462283,
0.042620711,
-0.0363290422,
0.0071928794,
-0.0164623335,
0.022692319,
-0.0200798418,
0.047113277,
-0.0052244049,
-0.0049424516,
-0.0155738788,
0.0051995274,
0.019295577,
-0.0631787553,
-0.0113861058,
0.0397553705,
-0.0389340334,
-0.0100691393,
-0.0266865361,
-0.0025356393,
-0.0220237747,
0.017101787,
0.0202299077,
-0.0153818028,
-0.0017051776,
0.0257718489,
-0.0621502288,
0.0112722088,
-0.0366982892,
0.0097412542,
0.0080480585,
-0.0045610084,
-0.0500961766,
-0.0337932631,
-0.0141076455,
0.0150309131,
-0.0023714385,
0.0124054691,
0.0014490371,
0.0099168289,
-0.0143356472,
0.0597673096,
-0.0192423109,
-0.0132055385,
0.0122795971,
0.0073479461,
0.0509192981,
0.0139839239,
-0.0124059394,
-0.0247854814,
-0.0296418518,
0.012104487,
0.0379134081,
-0.029466087,
0.0297716092,
-0.0015646904,
0.0412571356,
-0.0638493076,
-0.0201071631,
-0.0209758412,
0.0192443673,
-0.0017090726,
0.0099431807,
0.0329527482,
0.0100598931,
0.0170151927,
-0.0077477135,
0.0633544177,
0.0042460584,
0.0097293388,
-0.0353810862,
-0.0360021405,
0.013325979,
-0.0069948365,
-0.0565507337,
-0.0081111295,
-0.0203273427,
0.0313964225,
0.0809470788,
-0.0224662144,
0.0130980108,
-0.0033735519,
2.755e-7,
0.1007768959,
0.0850208476,
0.0401884243,
-0.0737227276,
0.0386929512,
0.0166785512,
0.0268009752,
0.0706522241,
-0.0038303423,
-0.0281659756,
0.0388847329,
-0.003751213,
0.0428845324,
0.012264939,
-0.0038627426,
-0.0562467091,
-0.0819312483,
-0.075552702,
-0.0234471802,
0.0103824958,
0.0666578189,
0.0533502772,
-0.0116895195,
0.0053308611,
0.0070656687,
0.0225735307,
0.0270152073,
-0.0479466766,
0.0493147634,
0.0253371336,
-0.0079444237,
-0.0376076214,
-0.0025378133,
0.0524896234,
-0.0300864317,
-0.0189210661,
0.0093779238,
0.0827756822,
-0.0895060152,
0.004467933,
0.0166707207,
-0.0203781463,
-0.010027986,
0.0179589763,
0.0156696048,
-0.056526117,
-0.0568972453,
0.056590531,
0.0057886024,
-0.0178938936,
0.0733308792,
-0.0013972054,
-0.0447496139,
0.0537200756,
0.031180216,
0.0059897481,
0.0192184504,
-0.0615001954,
0.0300410613,
0.0271101817,
-0.0584624335,
-0.0190346781,
0.0241368879,
-0.0087383613,
0.0501956493,
-0.0298647955,
0.0416511036,
2.260002454e-34,
0.0393296853,
0.0515005477,
0.0311738197,
-0.018749835,
0.0374885984,
0.0066704862,
-0.0099063944,
0.0280529726,
0.0165732838,
-0.0858879834,
-0.0021422845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09869v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09869v3 | Energy-Based Cross Attention for Bayesian Context Update in Text-to-Image Diffusion Models | 2023-06-16T14:30:41 | 2023-11-04T18:18:10 | Geon Yeong Park, Jeongsol Kim, Beomsu Kim, Sang Wan Lee, Jong Chul Ye | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite the remarkable performance of text-to-image diffusion models in image
generation tasks, recent studies have raised the issue that generated images
sometimes cannot capture the intended semantic contents of the text prompts,
which phenomenon is often called semantic misalignment. To address this, here
we present a novel energy-based model (EBM) framework for adaptive context
control by modeling the posterior of context vectors. Specifically, we first
formulate EBMs of latent image representations and text embeddings in each
cross-attention layer of the denoising autoencoder. Then, we obtain the
gradient of the log posterior of context vectors, which can be updated and
transferred to the subsequent cross-attention layer, thereby implicitly
minimizing a nested hierarchy of energy functions. Our latent EBMs further
allow zero-shot compositional generation as a linear combination of
cross-attention outputs from different contexts. Using extensive experiments,
we demonstrate that the proposed method is highly effective in handling various
image generation tasks, including multi-concept generation, text-guided image
inpainting, and real and synthetic image editing. Code:
https://github.com/EnergyAttention/Energy-Based-CrossAttention. | [
0.002770141,
0.0380632244,
0.0123922955,
0.0555530302,
0.0151759954,
-0.009795011,
0.016039595,
-0.0044207969,
-0.0540078357,
-0.0193045288,
-0.0028863999,
-0.0517998077,
-0.0030073246,
0.0515052415,
0.0401411243,
-0.0633298233,
-0.0116475774,
-0.0398981869,
-0.0130761527,
-0.0305058919,
-0.0065225842,
0.0044788877,
0.0159151666,
0.0050165006,
-0.0321878903,
-0.0138165951,
-0.0245201364,
0.0697305575,
0.0632650554,
0.003326925,
-0.0076231277,
0.041059915,
0.0338059701,
0.0038996411,
0.0000023106,
-0.00465691,
0.017638877,
0.0066999854,
0.0262337252,
0.0010680858,
0.0796806812,
-0.0476135612,
-0.0345647261,
-0.0652079359,
0.0341667235,
0.0309439041,
0.0830915123,
0.0218151566,
0.0921028331,
0.0210339725,
-0.0167851746,
-0.0442101099,
0.0147622088,
-0.0533313118,
0.1060737297,
-0.0155558186,
0.0222886261,
-0.0073537328,
-0.0464838631,
0.0171212051,
-0.0492560565,
0.0412415825,
0.0450669639,
-0.0410101376,
0.0511285625,
0.0540638715,
0.0699103102,
-0.0326604359,
-0.0311132595,
0.0565945804,
-0.0462114103,
0.0121240411,
-0.0184294675,
-0.0474543869,
-0.0390914083,
0.0083416039,
-0.0330324583,
0.003691141,
0.0306696966,
0.0031654779,
-0.0377636664,
0.0110646077,
0.0299209151,
-0.027717242,
0.0080160834,
-0.0140528437,
0.0535835847,
-0.009529829,
-0.053609129,
0.02067592,
-0.036164511,
-0.0757062733,
0.0334883519,
0.0335257612,
0.0157539025,
0.0070832088,
-0.0791978464,
-0.0524379909,
-0.0172875654,
-0.0045999223,
0.0316908918,
0.0375496633,
0.0204302035,
0.035420347,
-0.0088958656,
-0.0083628548,
-0.0503361933,
-0.0291558802,
-0.0596834272,
-0.0104809534,
0.0276011452,
-0.0179619975,
-0.037426725,
-0.0293847695,
-0.0515947267,
-0.0497001074,
-0.054170575,
0.020284798,
-0.0058701127,
0.0149196144,
0.0107104834,
0.0544703342,
-0.099056527,
-0.0225532055,
-0.0098642521,
0.0103287529,
0.0025517826,
-0.0045494563,
0.0420278274,
0.022449173,
-0.037578281,
0.0251919217,
0.0516049676,
-0.0304419957,
-0.0302837919,
0.0523644798,
-0.0250154827,
0.021089239,
-0.0415908545,
-0.0239397101,
-0.030013131,
-0.0251134187,
0.0319751501,
-0.0435970612,
0.0387291983,
-0.0344228521,
-0.0012056481,
-0.0562096462,
0.0168623868,
0.0085080815,
-0.0305155683,
0.0610833056,
-0.0048439102,
-0.0153530743,
0.0825225562,
0.0068201264,
-0.020084586,
0.0502705909,
0.056932386,
0.0607796311,
-0.0233648438,
0.0116500258,
-0.0117280381,
0.0175446738,
0.0427957699,
0.0544744916,
-0.0426609367,
-0.0340387858,
-0.0046745813,
0.0532736778,
0.0876433924,
0.033937268,
-0.040941108,
-0.0011439949,
0.0753283352,
-0.0039243917,
0.0070309909,
-0.0074850232,
0.0761071369,
0.0155005492,
-0.0733618438,
-0.000812618,
0.012931128,
0.0742877722,
0.0201813877,
0.024609929,
0.0821744353,
-0.0156339146,
-0.04329326,
-0.0317192487,
0.0483703353,
-0.0262819715,
-0.0091982726,
-0.0136587908,
0.0489078611,
0.0195835903,
-0.0577550419,
0.0233682729,
0.0140228178,
-0.0462575443,
0.0063784258,
-0.0015127107,
0.021552084,
0.0769770294,
0.0143672023,
0.0298019592,
0.0108123934,
-0.0178544577,
0.0182317495,
0.0518110283,
-0.025611857,
0.0250859521,
0.0186576378,
-0.0254017487,
-0.0366244689,
-0.0602940507,
-0.0031138205,
0.0125736576,
-0.0597209372,
0.0467606708,
0.0102279754,
0.0112470193,
0.0127060106,
0.0217534173,
-0.012429107,
-0.0110773025,
-0.0082732169,
0.0135014215,
0.0116938781,
-0.0036297131,
-0.0375668891,
0.0168840047,
-0.0004612618,
-0.0509823523,
-0.0256497618,
-0.0009882215,
-0.0536897257,
-0.0407394804,
0.0002289006,
-0.0616222732,
-0.0248294137,
-0.0458755717,
0.0019922724,
-0.0386277102,
0.037673492,
-0.0309558138,
0.0116963768,
-0.0402039066,
-0.010216739,
0.0113050928,
0.0211883914,
0.0258509461,
0.084700115,
-0.0471856929,
-0.0056738099,
0.038941849,
0.0617081262,
-0.0192751028,
-0.0123821693,
0.0037775133,
-0.0564287603,
0.0449241027,
-0.0187500734,
0.0096562849,
-0.0006420252,
-0.0266884416,
0.0120163374,
-0.0138811301,
0.0024978437,
-0.0309277363,
-0.010916939,
0.0440846793,
0.0466963798,
0.005843292,
0.0294692926,
-0.0038846028,
0.0281708725,
-0.0247665606,
0.0130880224,
0.0206208359,
0.0063730148,
0.0396976136,
-0.0225143377,
-0.0029964957,
0.039086204,
0.0554443076,
0.0289108679,
-0.0157113336,
-0.0165963974,
0.0438090637,
0.0056611113,
-0.0044470141,
-0.0196111929,
-0.0136315748,
-0.0310904365,
0.0011247242,
0.0569074713,
0.0714866966,
0.0027897789,
0.0263796058,
0.0065354379,
-0.0278524254,
-0.022594139,
0.0192644801,
-0.0205221586,
0.0144351255,
0.026864145,
-0.0345957838,
-0.0022486874,
0.0594578013,
0.0095981667,
0.0328546166,
-0.0645308942,
0.0221842565,
0.0116719157,
-0.0685035363,
-0.0230642296,
0.0012441454,
-0.0186831374,
-0.0026252165,
-0.0851212889,
-0.0188343488,
0.0726401284,
-0.0248497631,
-0.0090589803,
-0.0069192317,
0.0314851925,
0.0402910821,
-0.0185168274,
0.0229568314,
0.0540582463,
0.0056691337,
0.0118958568,
-0.020773666,
0.0161026735,
0.0348778814,
0.0180977099,
0.0058403048,
-0.0036627469,
-0.0113638416,
-0.0224263575,
-0.002100646,
-0.023563154,
0.0004254268,
0.0218354128,
0.0131988609,
0.0109716887,
0.0123891197,
-0.0253593009,
0.0123824636,
0.0375490002,
0.0218428914,
0.002539438,
-0.0330573358,
-0.0121619133,
0.0662082061,
0.0579457656,
-0.0252674166,
-0.0423309617,
-0.0498465598,
0.0209269095,
0.0568535216,
-0.0082609653,
0.0058148373,
-0.0158280563,
0.0412512273,
-0.0008459937,
0.0467100665,
0.0115843257,
0.0314093232,
0.0990714729,
-0.0701439083,
-0.0277621951,
0.0650003925,
0.0038520328,
-0.0642196536,
-0.0120968567,
-0.0003435487,
0.0440321788,
0.0152162379,
-0.0074230079,
-0.0960100368,
-0.0484143347,
-0.0239793323,
-0.0055836793,
0.0169909373,
0.002140539,
-0.0221652649,
-0.0642058924,
0.0566435792,
0.0252333172,
-0.0123579334,
-0.025749404,
-0.0119890692,
0.0344324969,
0.0419583991,
-0.0192322265,
-0.0172128715,
0.0344417542,
0.0040112808,
0.0260925144,
0.0913846493,
-0.0721893832,
-0.0560750328,
-0.0309133045,
0.0158232041,
0.062074285,
0.016001096,
0.0073972433,
-0.0832318589,
-0.0003065424,
-0.045447614,
0.0080109425,
-0.0002437193,
0.0167683903,
-0.0246350151,
0.0120360143,
0.0191753339,
0.0579860061,
-0.0375047475,
-0.016583411,
-0.0036784939,
0.0719656944,
-0.0010634466,
-0.020882532,
-0.0687696412,
-0.0031973554,
0.0712677315,
0.0183062479,
0.0450344495,
-0.0503515154,
-0.0457098596,
-0.0599306151,
0.0244689658,
-0.0662304536,
-0.0099888565,
0.0002733864,
-0.0018860565,
-0.0882798359,
-0.0239889286,
-0.0336216353,
0.0128015243,
0.0443421155,
-0.0145784169,
-0.0262002237,
-0.0239610244,
-0.0301011372,
-0.0422995016,
0.0044031511,
-0.0130158775,
0.021823993,
-0.0050605461,
-0.0248171296,
0.004411716,
-0.0312264021,
-0.0183620639,
0.0159122869,
-0.0877616853,
-0.0576262288,
-0.0198947936,
0.0587690771,
0.0051042051,
0.063439317,
-0.0099738017,
-0.0494618118,
0.0858078524,
0.0131167714,
-0.0041428455,
0.0267480239,
-0.0084814718,
0.0339109264,
-0.0029516437,
0.0206801854,
-0.0653162524,
0.0225757286,
0.0297327042,
0.0296720341,
-0.0169508047,
-0.0260249283,
-0.0044830358,
-0.0725172311,
-0.0100683132,
-0.0559478402,
0.0293299761,
-0.0338158049,
-0.0001010259,
-0.0032894493,
-0.0288742892,
-0.0724630952,
-0.0186800193,
0.0107592186,
-0.0005543932,
-0.0045446749,
0.0362208933,
0.0191781316,
-0.0032036158,
-0.0588170253,
0.0054778056,
0.035505373,
0.079372324,
0.0197604001,
0.0290470049,
0.0127273509,
-0.0047986866,
-0.0288183559,
0.0223352797,
-0.0040577962,
0.0410705917,
0.0310389455,
-0.0174306221,
-0.0443919636,
0.0404713154,
-0.027369298,
0.0086100185,
-0.0643449053,
0.019545339,
0.0576870441,
0.0203395542,
0.0488034151,
0.0091892835,
-0.030859828,
-0.0175528862,
0.0270724595,
0.0089586303,
-0.0548912436,
0.0508934744,
-0.0013263441,
0.0445059612,
0.0289196465,
0.0711116642,
-0.0311087463,
0.0289311633,
-0.0153739005,
-0.0052783359,
-0.0240197312,
0.0129999742,
0.007813382,
0.0213719849,
0.0051016849,
0.0273581278,
-0.002680674,
-0.0671011433,
0.0157906972,
0.0182924308,
-0.0296717975,
0.0331814922,
0.0736167431,
0.0337921754,
-0.0065399194,
-0.0074790055,
0.0051025683,
0.0254989248,
-0.0251816902,
-0.0125998612,
-0.0024543765,
-6.648446173e-33,
-0.0361030959,
-0.0402095541,
-0.0009202332,
-0.0351807363,
-0.0377969705,
-0.0083358996,
-0.0724820644,
-0.0065020444,
0.0320445411,
0.0221434645,
0.0287622772,
0.0080708638,
0.0001470818,
0.0441519879,
-0.0095323734,
0.0245374944,
0.0494074039,
-0.027536137,
-0.0285344329,
0.0587173514,
-0.0001885514,
0.0249867402,
0.0307591818,
-0.0292984508,
0.0199593268,
-0.0102558071,
0.0074825408,
-0.0198697262,
0.0465136245,
0.0249271821,
-0.0525497384,
0.0423950925,
-0.0163636114,
-0.0309306551,
-0.0330595188,
0.0141704921,
-0.0368337855,
-0.034306746,
-0.0571904182,
-0.0377388149,
-0.1091314778,
-0.0728533193,
0.0670510978,
0.025689194,
0.0062943273,
-0.0050214035,
0.0488182791,
-0.0116126668,
-0.0116012674,
-0.040955238,
-0.0783891231,
0.0072718048,
-0.0447666496,
-0.0203221869,
-0.011677362,
-0.0225458443,
0.0515127145,
0.0535312667,
-0.1017616987,
-0.0058726808,
-0.0120691927,
-0.0046682674,
0.0597878434,
0.0274691004,
0.0230724681,
0.023989588,
0.0166639052,
0.0123585407,
-0.0273650996,
0.0000811048,
-0.0087257791,
0.0206874944,
0.0012687141,
0.0329183154,
0.0277009774,
-0.0176646989,
-0.0503173769,
0.0429410972,
-0.0630233139,
0.0344383307,
0.0279399715,
0.0611708649,
0.0404796451,
-0.0217628982,
-0.0373142287,
-0.0563439988,
-0.0458217487,
-0.025517758,
0.0092127686,
0.0078934049,
-0.0229429007,
-0.0331206135,
0.0469742827,
0.0268250518,
0.0287313107,
-0.0236908253,
-0.0061753266,
0.0532479696,
0.0074686571,
0.012503,
-0.0174793825,
0.0086216945,
0.0555431768,
0.0389647819,
-0.0117185572,
0.0243438575,
-0.00570129,
0.0302438233,
-0.0004873614,
-0.0239102747,
-0.0870821252,
0.0079951501,
0.0150700156,
0.019698821,
0.0025067588,
-0.0225839578,
-0.0157055482,
0.0259680655,
-0.017107578,
0.0133981276,
0.0011266557,
-0.0109739918,
-0.0074039088,
0.0154428836,
-0.0553363599,
0.0155481687,
-0.0316268727,
0.0097569544,
0.0591546185,
-0.0687880218,
-0.047947865,
0.0575270876,
2.945e-7,
0.0420814715,
-0.0123537295,
-0.0006538127,
-0.007510982,
0.0336069912,
0.0425454266,
-0.0187931955,
0.0257484149,
0.0118583124,
-0.069269754,
0.0227144379,
0.0462127663,
0.0228113178,
-0.0146695729,
-0.0293353833,
0.0039723576,
-0.0293681994,
0.0400212221,
-0.0069685765,
-0.0132514043,
0.0065764217,
0.0488075837,
-0.0164317377,
-0.018523436,
0.042385187,
0.0047410559,
0.0938537568,
-0.0076582697,
0.0197887439,
-0.0092937378,
-0.0347339958,
-0.0089585353,
-0.0144313127,
-0.0141221127,
-0.0100752115,
-0.0275393799,
0.0485021286,
0.0201403275,
-0.0533114113,
-0.0401848629,
-0.0105564622,
0.0193183329,
0.0025860472,
-0.0340493396,
0.0544086844,
-0.0511031449,
-0.0183155406,
-0.0320918299,
-0.0372724384,
0.0270140618,
0.0433274209,
-0.0247544665,
-0.0433799699,
-0.0295455176,
0.0385995172,
0.0523473322,
-0.042115014,
-0.0377568789,
0.0029308391,
-0.0171108246,
-0.0551556721,
-0.0178471804,
-0.0743380189,
-0.025545029,
0.017153604,
0.0179943908,
-0.032844279,
2.424098022e-34,
0.0076412633,
-0.0219409373,
0.0109191416,
-0.0300320536,
0.0177103113,
0.0050818841,
-0.0362119973,
-0.0406480543,
0.0270499494,
-0.050218761,
-0.060168568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09841v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09841v3 | Are Large Language Models Really Good Logical Reasoners? A Comprehensive Evaluation and Beyond | 2023-06-16T13:39:35 | 2023-08-08T12:57:18 | Fangzhi Xu, Qika Lin, Jiawei Han, Tianzhe Zhao, Jun Liu, Erik Cambria | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Logical reasoning consistently plays a fundamental and significant role in
the domains of knowledge engineering and artificial intelligence. Recently,
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as a noteworthy innovation in natural
language processing (NLP), exhibiting impressive achievements across various
classic NLP tasks. However, the question of whether LLMs can effectively
address the task of logical reasoning, which requires gradual cognitive
inference similar to human intelligence, remains unanswered. To this end, we
aim to bridge this gap and provide comprehensive evaluations in this paper.
Firstly, to offer systematic evaluations, we select fifteen typical logical
reasoning datasets and organize them into deductive, inductive, abductive and
mixed-form reasoning settings. Considering the comprehensiveness of
evaluations, we include three representative LLMs (i.e., text-davinci-003,
ChatGPT and BARD) and evaluate them on all selected datasets under zero-shot,
one-shot and three-shot settings. Secondly, different from previous evaluations
relying only on simple metrics (e.g., accuracy), we propose fine-level
evaluations from objective and subjective manners, covering both answers and
explanations. Additionally, to uncover the logical flaws of LLMs, problematic
cases will be attributed to five error types from two dimensions, i.e.,
evidence selection process and reasoning process. Thirdly, to avoid the
influences of knowledge bias and purely focus on benchmarking the logical
reasoning capability of LLMs, we propose a new dataset with neutral content. It
contains 3,000 samples and covers deductive, inductive and abductive settings.
Based on the in-depth evaluations, this paper finally forms a general
evaluation scheme of logical reasoning capability from six dimensions. It
reflects the pros and cons of LLMs and gives guiding directions for future
works. | [
0.0429015122,
0.0498604253,
0.0045225867,
0.0533375256,
-0.085278444,
0.0380060263,
0.0519280992,
-0.012747407,
0.0291971527,
-0.0494362935,
0.0156071354,
0.0033347076,
0.0034055414,
0.010055271,
-0.0036951201,
-0.0028142424,
0.0246537812,
-0.042598594,
0.0426248014,
-0.006847532,
-0.0140381185,
0.0143458536,
-0.0111553539,
0.0187075324,
0.0063242884,
-0.0079413923,
0.006213848,
-0.0364408679,
0.0114003848,
-0.0257624518,
-0.0248171128,
0.0227122121,
0.0035471998,
0.0303082801,
0.0000023108,
-0.0571110137,
0.0161252283,
-0.0013439058,
-0.0570395365,
-0.0097231623,
0.0049882331,
0.0061547509,
-0.0072735958,
0.0242447406,
-0.0358878486,
-0.0009097318,
0.0217855517,
0.0794603527,
0.0649607629,
0.0488109142,
-0.0020703967,
-0.0897803456,
0.0150996214,
0.0063808965,
0.0258842502,
-0.0232547484,
0.0406454541,
0.0545054674,
0.0097882962,
0.0033086408,
0.0173061788,
0.0093631344,
0.0137954121,
-0.0086689647,
-0.0410259813,
0.0291759018,
-0.0658427849,
-0.0451244041,
0.0128009189,
0.0592783689,
0.0040719025,
-0.0227598008,
-0.0107181007,
0.0070431004,
-0.014387669,
0.0171091799,
-0.0370774195,
0.0592942797,
-0.0390427038,
0.0199159514,
0.0630072802,
0.0198396612,
0.0427895039,
0.030579336,
-0.0657783672,
0.1391508877,
-0.0166789088,
-0.0289882235,
0.0238890536,
-0.0167436823,
-0.0400727689,
-0.0649657696,
-0.0239006635,
0.0505985357,
-0.0082011204,
0.0439530164,
0.0027317046,
0.02998605,
0.0431386456,
-0.0793472305,
0.0051968251,
0.0299273804,
0.0162076019,
0.0795562863,
-0.048248183,
0.0347123221,
-0.0017369607,
0.0524294898,
-0.0039734873,
-0.0328485668,
-0.060351558,
-0.0247811805,
0.0109052341,
0.0212562773,
0.004454914,
-0.0105265258,
-0.0292928405,
-0.013128466,
-0.0221761409,
0.0327222385,
0.0213394463,
-0.0053275833,
0.0367520526,
-0.043280527,
-0.0930233225,
0.0166633427,
-0.0455181263,
0.0460568294,
0.0058746967,
-0.0420796126,
0.0046028127,
-0.0059130429,
0.0100294538,
-0.0292318668,
0.0398710556,
0.0558969378,
0.0309666321,
-0.0191566329,
-0.0428815857,
-0.0407204591,
-0.0202256516,
-0.0935551599,
-0.0187349208,
-0.0642174557,
0.0196387246,
0.023715172,
-0.0268385597,
-0.0359595455,
0.0203443002,
0.0275351666,
-0.0507546254,
0.0959214866,
-0.0168398209,
0.027682554,
0.0209240634,
-0.0011466154,
-0.0127257099,
0.0485487506,
0.0440099463,
0.0148182632,
0.0189895723,
0.0075253886,
-0.0057411962,
-0.0222412497,
-0.000104439,
-0.0123062925,
-0.0366508961,
0.0330375396,
-0.0588522181,
0.0017512677,
-0.0252656676,
0.0436256789,
-0.0187910683,
-0.0202556252,
0.0219955575,
0.0424515828,
0.0356325842,
0.0002789995,
0.0285839867,
-0.0152182793,
0.0059934179,
-0.0292435791,
-0.0305454433,
0.0164845195,
-0.0177829191,
-0.0164521132,
0.0312129557,
0.0122278212,
-0.0093360376,
-0.0787196606,
-0.0494113155,
-0.0018194586,
0.0267280675,
0.0155887427,
0.0825341493,
-0.0146076595,
-0.0180295724,
0.0491711758,
0.0377069861,
-0.0436733104,
-0.0472220145,
-0.0583931245,
0.0735989511,
0.0255960338,
0.0314156488,
-0.0267896336,
-0.0341003574,
-0.0083423462,
0.019938821,
0.0080074184,
0.0487806648,
0.0040901946,
-0.0116321053,
-0.0508380681,
-0.0181809738,
-0.0064145713,
0.0163191967,
0.0050653811,
-0.0282051526,
0.0035455385,
-0.0094886087,
-0.0227372367,
-0.0012645558,
0.0252196044,
-0.0171153452,
0.0090566454,
-0.0086667659,
-0.01515052,
0.039569702,
-0.0123730516,
-0.0042318087,
0.0217139237,
0.016185496,
-0.0306896102,
-0.0467379205,
0.0143831782,
-0.0214524325,
-0.045308698,
0.0579353459,
-0.0337941572,
-0.0270344242,
-0.0133695258,
-0.0499790087,
-0.0266887061,
0.016080616,
-0.0116554843,
-0.0105928248,
-0.0324788503,
0.0169110969,
-0.020950608,
-0.008476506,
-0.0419072732,
0.108893171,
-0.0074720331,
0.0184750166,
-0.0135617321,
0.0110810744,
0.0485010818,
-0.0230331514,
0.0070161629,
0.0124101117,
-0.0127208428,
-0.0145541281,
0.0035652649,
-0.0214842018,
-0.0290898327,
-0.0315764621,
-0.0532066859,
0.0158990473,
-0.004879442,
0.0208281092,
-0.0056616184,
-0.026204329,
0.0071695666,
0.0126293488,
-0.0318724476,
-0.0023600922,
0.0427354872,
0.0131437695,
0.0553166494,
-0.0188146885,
-0.0032397709,
-0.0036108354,
-0.0190366916,
-0.0378400385,
0.0487665273,
0.0327993892,
0.0108764637,
-0.016481597,
0.0343215317,
-0.0678872466,
-0.0061498852,
-0.0151539696,
-0.0252093803,
0.0226549003,
-0.0157307778,
-0.0230231024,
0.0874319747,
-0.0066212756,
0.0120141627,
0.0468193702,
-0.0134732174,
-0.0318423733,
0.0374410041,
-0.0232609119,
0.0337378085,
-0.0442294702,
-0.044560045,
-0.0188325886,
0.0191676151,
0.0049378071,
-0.0209221728,
-0.0561481528,
0.0523847193,
0.0034079244,
0.0214863308,
-0.0213585254,
-0.0208807141,
0.0358045623,
0.081946142,
-0.00807139,
-0.0182507336,
0.0555680655,
-0.0063455258,
0.0184154846,
-0.0503788888,
-0.0113103287,
-0.0740810409,
0.0607335791,
-0.012228135,
-0.0081828088,
-0.0143030519,
0.0099340724,
0.0072301831,
-0.0454005376,
0.032946527,
-0.0283834338,
0.0189921223,
-0.0444181934,
0.0235690605,
-0.0195608772,
-0.0254291929,
-0.0305925738,
-0.0427860022,
-0.0877518058,
-0.0099302502,
-0.0344176143,
-0.005544364,
-0.0337317809,
0.0298578907,
0.0092551345,
0.0014305895,
0.0051384228,
-0.0011182505,
-0.0135359215,
-0.0248251036,
0.0004788552,
0.0203212034,
0.0330520682,
-0.0007679455,
0.0606882162,
0.0413044691,
-0.0103616584,
0.0247506499,
-0.0408103205,
0.0212297589,
-0.0112209767,
0.0018398643,
-0.0312649421,
-0.0046425574,
0.0518331788,
-0.0753994063,
0.0082546454,
0.1278511137,
0.0270152315,
0.0251650978,
-0.0108420914,
-0.002541577,
-0.0247079823,
0.0203082487,
-0.0074634538,
-0.0728898868,
-0.070840545,
0.0202898923,
-0.0053276271,
-0.0197461545,
-0.0374695137,
-0.009958867,
-0.1300070584,
0.0470804423,
-0.0114964154,
0.0102052223,
-0.0154323494,
-0.0741593093,
-0.0024462754,
-0.0470875502,
-0.0193907935,
-0.0035607221,
0.0221981835,
-0.0097290222,
0.0118303262,
-0.0345906056,
-0.0436093882,
0.0619417876,
-0.0203479491,
0.0467120744,
0.0176797174,
0.0629855171,
-0.0194780249,
-0.069268018,
0.0031257342,
0.0148152029,
-0.0050741467,
0.0015239129,
0.0484082811,
0.0193668827,
0.0038055722,
-0.046674788,
0.0157259908,
-0.0337254219,
-0.0344126597,
0.0170600507,
0.0932656229,
-0.0337633118,
-0.0314808972,
-0.0360027738,
0.0249564853,
-0.0693527982,
0.0964246839,
0.0038073792,
0.0043283263,
-0.0671991855,
-0.0246480126,
-0.0597619563,
-0.0309883282,
-0.0290324539,
0.0565025099,
0.0312445275,
-0.0291427486,
-0.0330026336,
-0.0113307368,
0.0288823135,
0.030938847,
-0.0438185818,
0.0160552636,
0.0272605605,
0.012194979,
-0.0099658323,
0.0257613268,
0.0010696409,
0.0318631008,
-0.0312282741,
0.0497461557,
-0.0007574453,
-0.0235998631,
-0.0316951312,
-0.0064464542,
-0.0430688374,
-0.0549534597,
-0.0169310607,
0.0333700702,
0.0302770026,
-0.000716162,
-0.0230409335,
-0.0377114005,
0.0260461979,
0.0288443509,
0.0144321825,
-0.0233109985,
0.0310853031,
0.0058261752,
0.0137501657,
0.0309897382,
-0.0110052722,
0.0350201316,
0.0164792389,
0.0292235315,
-0.0313478485,
-0.0036725786,
0.0148024885,
0.0291804448,
0.0261495858,
0.0256302524,
-0.0165882371,
-0.0082578221,
0.0118330363,
-0.0549419895,
-0.0359734334,
-0.0163591914,
0.0263762269,
0.0078372508,
-0.0308621284,
-0.0210765973,
-0.056134548,
-0.0311988201,
0.0009792197,
-0.0106393974,
0.0419454798,
0.0347344056,
0.0099344552,
0.0008412529,
-0.0361342095,
-0.0284313541,
-0.0285944417,
-0.0179924909,
0.0362609923,
0.0010935474,
0.0618236586,
0.0490725599,
-0.0160989799,
-0.0199966803,
-0.0088976631,
-0.0890760943,
-0.057230901,
0.0541250184,
0.0016030014,
0.0544920154,
-0.0177842639,
0.0277475473,
-0.0208954494,
-0.0063918522,
0.0012361446,
0.0331645869,
0.0659234747,
-0.0333719812,
0.0392009243,
0.0158596821,
-0.0466550328,
-0.0180604514,
0.0498105064,
-0.0172778368,
0.0373415425,
0.0011458278,
-0.0464529321,
-0.0279365089,
-0.0317458883,
-0.0201035086,
0.0032502851,
-0.0097160656,
0.0119846975,
-0.0646273866,
-0.0604882315,
-0.0078774197,
0.0199707672,
0.0221865345,
-0.0105982004,
-0.0288518388,
0.0561342463,
0.034788508,
-0.0259023197,
-0.0386561751,
-0.000257793,
-0.0503327586,
0.0098302793,
-0.0203462597,
-6.436236382e-33,
0.0180428568,
-0.0329503343,
0.0333392434,
-0.0251157433,
0.0051266537,
-0.0331035294,
-0.0448987745,
-0.0194313582,
-0.0482969433,
0.0459670275,
-0.0171481632,
0.0182234403,
0.0110032167,
0.0020443953,
0.0146531286,
-0.0142187523,
0.0144422781,
0.0349766351,
-0.0112189064,
-0.0081872242,
0.0539262667,
-0.0269316752,
0.0153072039,
-0.0483787768,
0.013648645,
0.0107668675,
-0.0071569281,
0.0414966457,
-0.0757700279,
0.0468840823,
0.0058399187,
0.010452792,
0.0320868082,
-0.0302784033,
0.0184270646,
0.0086298333,
-0.0695291013,
-0.0253890026,
0.0184291285,
-0.0016683216,
-0.0245446954,
-0.0159651972,
0.0364348553,
0.0380866304,
-0.0201478004,
-0.0206574388,
0.01893159,
-0.0487048849,
0.0048745191,
-0.0062400838,
-0.0255388804,
0.0615491383,
-0.0283196196,
-0.0255394559,
0.0079291323,
0.0323249139,
-0.0273030903,
0.0143019846,
-0.0461252443,
0.0124703888,
0.022936767,
-0.0388837643,
0.0675344244,
-0.0236345287,
-0.0024869072,
0.0726009682,
0.0257778559,
0.0158623345,
-0.0593023822,
0.0182369538,
-0.0145181175,
0.0887609571,
0.0610258654,
0.0210260488,
0.0631955937,
0.0121540781,
-0.116126284,
0.0063458658,
0.0004537606,
0.0733997896,
0.074799329,
-0.0008937517,
-0.0535587668,
-0.0146743357,
-0.0467695259,
0.0189228747,
-0.0287306607,
-0.0017914147,
0.0172646958,
-0.0103290407,
-0.0004766565,
-0.0195091777,
0.0200561024,
-0.0583887771,
-0.0033136497,
0.042190399,
0.0030436048,
-0.0153987706,
-0.0046043568,
0.0332026184,
-0.0254094079,
-0.0013450109,
-0.0011717309,
0.0309041198,
0.0190809928,
0.0129458625,
0.02832908,
-0.0147235151,
-0.0283724125,
-0.0237107705,
-0.0422931574,
-0.0136082806,
-0.0185727868,
0.045041088,
0.0442502126,
0.0410396233,
-0.004899329,
0.0142456237,
-0.0031280804,
0.0107215811,
-0.0000222896,
-0.0009853597,
0.0019510161,
-0.0068850955,
-0.0047957134,
-0.0218047071,
-0.0506774262,
-0.0112704039,
0.002096158,
-0.0317672715,
-0.0113572637,
0.0389633514,
2.981e-7,
0.0305249598,
0.0687585995,
-0.0103672668,
0.0594356619,
0.0159537997,
0.0485783331,
-0.018909933,
-0.0233220514,
0.0085176043,
0.0108722514,
-0.022869844,
0.04295009,
0.0467388183,
0.0774235725,
-0.0302582979,
-0.0141360676,
-0.0382800885,
-0.0696536899,
-0.0636699945,
0.0307135191,
0.1291329116,
0.0854637697,
0.0424190871,
-0.0109650157,
0.0086200424,
-0.0465488173,
0.0173161607,
0.0027344055,
0.0073374393,
0.0127159189,
0.0777674094,
0.004095329,
0.0118083972,
0.067416206,
0.0200984776,
0.0086323535,
-0.0286109392,
0.0584690273,
-0.0163509026,
0.0031476142,
-0.0252948962,
-0.0487349518,
0.0256519057,
-0.055209212,
0.1231900379,
-0.0585496053,
-0.0730436891,
-0.0079926075,
0.000276611,
-0.0267219227,
0.0362929292,
0.0140871145,
-0.0068030646,
-0.0036070121,
0.0098305549,
-0.041391246,
-0.0063051716,
-0.096130617,
0.0047576046,
0.0179800279,
-0.0369595885,
-0.0284432266,
0.0032191647,
0.0255522914,
0.0858791471,
-0.0355829932,
0.0074833198,
2.742903799e-34,
0.024927374,
-0.0103858775,
-0.0089847744,
-0.0222737584,
0.0815736949,
0.0330000408,
-0.0053492282,
0.0105631212,
0.0177132674,
-0.0991933271,
0.0026221091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10090v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10090v1 | Improving Audio Caption Fluency with Automatic Error Correction | 2023-06-16T13:37:01 | 2023-06-16T13:37:01 | Hanxue Zhang, Zeyu Xie, Xuenan Xu, Mengyue Wu, Kai Yu | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | Automated audio captioning (AAC) is an important cross-modality translation
task, aiming at generating descriptions for audio clips. However, captions
generated by previous AAC models have faced ``false-repetition'' errors due to
the training objective. In such scenarios, we propose a new task of AAC error
correction and hope to reduce such errors by post-processing AAC outputs. To
tackle this problem, we use observation-based rules to corrupt captions without
errors, for pseudo grammatically-erroneous sentence generation. One pair of
corrupted and clean sentences can thus be used for training. We train a neural
network-based model on the synthetic error dataset and apply the model to
correct real errors in AAC outputs. Results on two benchmark datasets indicate
that our approach significantly improves fluency while maintaining semantic
information. | [
0.0301116146,
0.0613027588,
0.001682417,
0.0137192309,
0.0023314587,
-0.0123266485,
-0.0039858539,
-0.0595241003,
-0.0573964342,
-0.0472465269,
-0.0243981611,
-0.0223634858,
0.0621364266,
0.0192131493,
0.0111332741,
-0.0525268205,
0.0594307035,
-0.0458867252,
-0.0162605736,
0.0101539679,
-0.0148990722,
0.0075450116,
-0.0388438106,
0.0235586353,
-0.0557812043,
0.0150974048,
0.0043436503,
0.0428366885,
0.0036815023,
-0.0143668624,
0.0034347496,
0.0406057276,
0.0124875186,
0.0564765409,
0.0000015658,
0.0174966622,
-0.0061859544,
0.0107905362,
0.0379261896,
0.0063517969,
0.0420915484,
-0.0351539776,
-0.0552079864,
0.0284557771,
0.0018097048,
-0.0502156168,
0.0597782694,
0.0355379693,
0.0757077038,
0.0754395053,
-0.0194422435,
-0.0260400921,
-0.0060869348,
-0.0278593171,
0.0076308041,
-0.0019086928,
0.0152466502,
0.0701649114,
-0.0157806706,
-0.0293075591,
-0.0214257538,
0.0657570511,
-0.002165959,
-0.0255253725,
-0.0057958318,
0.0071269781,
-0.043625962,
-0.0380462296,
-0.0315682404,
0.0715689138,
0.0344383828,
-0.0032917778,
-0.0275225453,
0.0237385761,
0.0296088196,
-0.0227588061,
-0.0173654053,
0.0549215116,
0.007168544,
0.0042205174,
0.0062878504,
0.0219166037,
0.0131568722,
-0.0347380787,
0.023794001,
-0.0394426808,
0.0177375507,
-0.013148861,
-0.0388689265,
-0.0070716338,
-0.0303817019,
-0.0208940785,
0.0465162024,
-0.0216295402,
-0.0189336985,
-0.0183268022,
-0.0725031346,
-0.0447518863,
-0.0080367606,
-0.0418310873,
0.0337809473,
0.0223283283,
-0.066919677,
0.0693237185,
0.0025489912,
0.0469315276,
0.0315162875,
0.0374751464,
-0.0310054328,
0.0175284911,
-0.0442290679,
0.0042521614,
-0.0309993718,
0.0218699202,
-0.0248149727,
-0.0160924271,
-0.0598764941,
-0.0448356532,
-0.0357463062,
0.0514592826,
-0.0001810044,
0.0182462428,
-0.0561710298,
-0.0082276659,
-0.0107460795,
0.0308864042,
0.0302711297,
0.0583649464,
-0.0015256171,
-0.0327451564,
-0.0305619743,
0.0312265493,
0.0324275568,
0.0308557898,
0.013483529,
0.0455298871,
-0.0066849529,
-0.0246276483,
-0.0285914931,
-0.0302352011,
-0.0440730862,
-0.0215445906,
-0.0550851822,
-0.0452198796,
0.0508516878,
-0.0585974976,
-0.0177348927,
-0.0276143402,
0.0211384911,
0.0192477331,
0.0053816764,
0.0956990644,
-0.0465954691,
0.0277706478,
0.0163979698,
0.0087663094,
0.0060915719,
0.034520641,
0.0726498589,
-0.0113899959,
0.0322751291,
0.0080921147,
0.0620070621,
0.0315431766,
-0.0016321142,
-0.0212911144,
-0.0265120286,
-0.0538274646,
-0.039184697,
0.0648253858,
0.0767469332,
0.0785173327,
-0.0164551698,
0.0369572714,
0.0784518719,
-0.0144812502,
-0.0207561087,
0.0333083458,
0.0742538348,
-0.0214057174,
-0.0065826927,
0.0240517966,
-0.0153657543,
0.0082626184,
0.0345907882,
0.0231341626,
0.01876905,
0.0007447852,
-0.0258296262,
-0.0624924153,
0.0070256242,
-0.0367535912,
0.0006801233,
-0.04351677,
0.0197828691,
0.0551559515,
-0.0348196104,
0.0561837628,
-0.0187673923,
-0.0434541106,
0.008220437,
-0.0136001976,
-0.0179408509,
0.0547618531,
0.0562811345,
-0.0126097957,
-0.0358984433,
-0.0583590567,
-0.0012985584,
0.0647867396,
0.060754057,
-0.0271186586,
-0.0013464616,
-0.0389274694,
0.0075726886,
0.0121958172,
0.0305926688,
0.013303821,
-0.0407213308,
-0.0029523764,
0.0386783816,
-0.0205284022,
-0.0767598003,
0.0009630245,
0.047044836,
-0.0149528515,
0.0164561328,
0.0131114488,
0.0409953371,
0.0433781594,
-0.0505467504,
0.0097222133,
0.0034831183,
0.0008535525,
-0.0120504657,
0.0717571676,
-0.071019344,
-0.0715014338,
0.0553112887,
-0.0936428383,
0.0015585033,
0.0177559648,
0.0002103553,
-0.072940141,
0.0107338922,
-0.050047908,
0.0081577543,
-0.0724844411,
0.0414458141,
0.0183174089,
0.0112483585,
0.0318219066,
0.0021536257,
0.0102182934,
-0.0173533577,
0.049470149,
-0.0218090899,
-0.0024592166,
-0.034166459,
-0.0253136195,
0.0088343751,
-0.0086437007,
0.0446776152,
0.0219038632,
0.019525446,
-0.0312553048,
-0.0116612641,
-0.0682612732,
-0.0016384783,
-0.0097159585,
0.0032822294,
0.0195346791,
-0.0079584122,
-0.0068179816,
-0.0315997228,
-0.0072941128,
-0.0208558943,
0.017798828,
-0.0315440297,
0.0123029435,
0.0217459872,
-0.0600724705,
-0.0066498178,
0.0327265635,
-0.0049890266,
-0.0032505605,
0.0081379162,
0.0018016818,
-0.0751241446,
0.0393582247,
-0.005733266,
0.0265486073,
0.0157396104,
-0.0500478856,
-0.028703589,
0.053396292,
0.0184755344,
0.0019445693,
-0.005486419,
0.0226593204,
0.0352493636,
-0.0073534483,
-0.0080760038,
0.0194768067,
0.0155717647,
-0.0172346402,
-0.0019297638,
-0.0304773096,
-0.0328315608,
0.0060854536,
0.0460137688,
0.0458061621,
-0.0231135227,
0.0202092081,
-0.0362373032,
-0.0362804607,
0.0063546747,
-0.0283808075,
-0.0187982377,
0.0270803329,
-0.0235271249,
-0.011806543,
0.0481219552,
-0.0422605351,
-0.0460316427,
-0.0409483798,
-0.0023251541,
-0.0070913373,
0.016804995,
-0.0085141398,
0.0418488234,
0.0247445945,
-0.0526474752,
-0.0327761471,
-0.0336361788,
0.029413037,
-0.0314304307,
0.0339456834,
-0.0792571008,
-0.0034477985,
-0.0147992363,
-0.0389326327,
-0.0143544869,
-0.0582974739,
0.0066978973,
-0.021640176,
-0.0426181853,
-0.0274579376,
-0.0373468287,
0.0368715376,
0.0383510739,
0.0447181612,
-0.0416309834,
0.0099345874,
-0.0210461095,
0.0619085617,
0.0157101229,
0.022702748,
-0.0320032127,
-0.0163314659,
0.0210993625,
0.0183515809,
-0.0226121936,
0.0507930592,
-0.0516589209,
0.0135365343,
0.0074746255,
0.0192160811,
-0.0350593552,
0.0210324544,
0.0560178906,
-0.059339758,
-0.0186630357,
0.0957260802,
0.0119120209,
-0.0099962214,
-0.0082208309,
0.0480528325,
-0.0113551272,
0.0010776838,
0.0075515043,
-0.0566401407,
-0.0240534768,
0.0277310535,
0.0581827089,
0.0142202368,
0.0485352278,
-0.0272601806,
-0.0954575688,
0.054866299,
0.0620519631,
-0.0703493506,
-0.1029113382,
0.0186412409,
-0.018702751,
-0.0143136177,
0.0558361299,
-0.0002460498,
-0.0053773173,
0.0149805862,
0.048019357,
0.011747865,
-0.0976183563,
-0.0346954875,
-0.0398856625,
0.1310383826,
0.0835327432,
0.0210942421,
-0.0442672819,
-0.0293038189,
0.0034861818,
0.0027675303,
-0.0128231514,
0.040970616,
0.0499816723,
-0.0044232048,
-0.0203837901,
0.0478474312,
0.0387222804,
-0.0365792289,
-0.0049788207,
-0.0076157399,
0.0299739651,
0.0122470018,
0.0192933381,
0.0008498511,
0.0606530085,
0.0096044382,
0.0614884123,
0.033395078,
0.0104670338,
0.0224103164,
-0.0346575491,
0.0033899271,
-0.1126035452,
0.0284547731,
0.0402504876,
-0.0060675833,
-0.0611889325,
-0.060548,
-0.0595793165,
0.00657359,
0.0088581452,
0.04742378,
-0.0183071848,
0.0099708205,
0.0258632563,
-0.0088540288,
0.0156220105,
-0.0225538258,
0.0252181515,
-0.0307751317,
-0.0144986408,
0.0501839668,
-0.0222530626,
0.0007347382,
0.0064564361,
-0.0299008545,
-0.0424217135,
0.0174022615,
0.0479656048,
0.0172006972,
0.0657281578,
0.003046202,
-0.0193253085,
-0.0250088219,
0.0551223792,
-0.0130963866,
0.021720184,
0.0418706797,
-0.0327548608,
-0.0415321477,
0.0209220201,
-0.0355170667,
0.0009457763,
-0.0332020707,
0.0554501154,
-0.0122968331,
-0.0498588234,
0.0448718742,
-0.002003547,
-0.0058552632,
-0.0462375581,
0.0195911191,
-0.0538180657,
-0.0037435249,
-0.0193652939,
-0.0217574406,
-0.035565272,
0.0583075359,
0.0223961826,
0.0195178315,
-0.024625577,
-0.0316749848,
-0.0736382231,
-0.0347061642,
0.0140499771,
-0.0063508721,
0.0165440738,
-0.0342046246,
-0.0088174185,
0.003128439,
-0.0062235356,
0.0093000894,
0.0325018317,
0.024763044,
-0.0149820307,
0.0124994898,
0.0009156136,
-0.0139004998,
-0.0152323972,
0.0360333845,
-0.0066110604,
0.0715449825,
-0.0535510182,
0.0590377748,
0.1022334769,
-0.0146873957,
0.0453094766,
-0.0151257366,
0.0039675501,
-0.0066825631,
0.0402415767,
-0.0069286954,
-0.0264475718,
0.0317527615,
-0.0109611377,
0.0151740359,
0.0125470972,
0.0560139418,
-0.0354719348,
0.018147869,
-0.0142165031,
-0.0402613692,
-0.0418783203,
0.0114737861,
-0.021253122,
-0.0315912776,
-0.0354917981,
-0.0177702308,
-0.0161208175,
-0.0809727684,
0.0012594386,
0.0436316766,
0.0442936011,
0.0028827451,
0.0412402712,
0.0288646948,
-0.0056668795,
0.0313764736,
-0.0002391325,
-0.0626722351,
0.0194743928,
0.0129570365,
-0.0275861826,
-4.806289303e-33,
-0.0615055934,
-0.0074531161,
-0.0170323383,
-0.0515040606,
-0.0324515887,
-0.0149408206,
-0.0446218774,
0.0085144751,
0.0563104562,
0.0212736912,
0.0237234626,
0.0107142972,
0.0277418476,
0.0206559133,
0.0251758005,
-0.0012390371,
0.0960740298,
-0.0238871351,
-0.0188088287,
0.00578818,
0.0330969766,
0.0111488085,
0.0236533657,
-0.0557333529,
0.0123806391,
0.0232762396,
-0.0525010303,
0.0268880464,
0.0244572796,
0.0519113801,
0.0312923901,
0.0354893841,
-0.0064206389,
0.0177524127,
-0.0297617987,
-0.0210950226,
-0.0514185354,
0.0008595133,
0.018626241,
0.0673650801,
0.0161982551,
-0.0317210257,
0.0269726254,
-0.0349498354,
-0.0209404994,
0.0161757767,
0.0428371243,
-0.0594428778,
0.0114759924,
-0.0218159854,
-0.0331572518,
-0.0043118461,
-0.0208350196,
-0.0555199049,
0.0233311076,
0.0279946122,
0.0048666005,
-0.0438540094,
-0.0391583219,
0.0419789962,
0.0171539728,
0.0229033995,
0.0571302399,
0.0034764668,
-0.0680726692,
0.0278833453,
0.0189283825,
-0.0551000535,
0.0030050976,
0.0067986757,
-0.0119666606,
-0.0057735015,
0.0272059478,
0.0459107496,
0.0637203828,
-0.035284169,
-0.0175971277,
0.0338402279,
-0.0693625435,
0.0063275271,
0.0095853573,
0.0173399225,
-0.0441569313,
0.013394082,
-0.0491293892,
-0.0140501345,
-0.0114576044,
-0.0373190194,
0.0203908309,
0.0207924992,
-0.0080037275,
-0.0104184486,
0.0296257399,
-0.028672846,
0.0379758812,
-0.0574889258,
-0.0280007422,
0.0240104944,
-0.0316981412,
-0.0040655821,
0.0197833888,
-0.0123333223,
0.0766573325,
0.0535151064,
0.0386387631,
0.0098647131,
0.0445526764,
0.0773142353,
-0.0416609198,
0.0157024041,
0.0052457363,
0.0002571446,
-0.0309163872,
-0.0116347736,
0.0081408974,
0.0422577262,
-0.048077628,
0.0110164043,
-0.0206483509,
0.0405365564,
-0.0309799518,
-0.0234216712,
-0.0287366193,
0.0408185087,
-0.0280936565,
0.0283631012,
-0.0155437086,
-0.0114244493,
0.000878181,
-0.0632492304,
-0.0351808406,
0.0151358582,
2.38e-7,
-0.0105006667,
0.0023166055,
0.0418202654,
-0.0024546469,
0.027292097,
0.0233844873,
-0.059450794,
0.0000746278,
-0.024004044,
0.005973157,
0.0732737705,
-0.0362430401,
0.0678468049,
0.0197254568,
-0.0708848163,
-0.0274429563,
-0.0245399065,
0.0160806868,
-0.015976578,
-0.0263954233,
0.0545021407,
0.0743542686,
-0.0234927926,
-0.0351229012,
0.0102829402,
-0.0514583215,
0.0349217765,
0.0171810985,
-0.0496053174,
-0.0214977451,
0.0456617028,
0.0604624487,
-0.0340614393,
0.032182198,
-0.0371601135,
-0.024459457,
0.0449854881,
0.0131859723,
0.0081556784,
-0.0097251125,
-0.0493301265,
0.0696213022,
-0.0161165614,
0.0272370335,
0.0249733143,
-0.0465014502,
-0.0113479262,
-0.0172728933,
-0.0347476676,
0.0305001903,
-0.0068515991,
-0.0473611057,
-0.0528588071,
-0.0215864759,
0.0560154505,
0.0399338268,
-0.0399891436,
-0.018659927,
0.0067613446,
0.0095238518,
-0.0174396094,
-0.0340290144,
-0.0060948841,
0.0002522635,
0.0229115132,
-0.0558851399,
-0.002557474,
1.956754299e-34,
0.0735072941,
-0.0551750362,
0.023473585,
-0.0451857634,
-0.0013439731,
0.002798649,
0.0128708584,
-0.0052883229,
-0.019598173,
-0.0225241929,
-0.0558147989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09830v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09830v1 | Sheffield's Submission to the AmericasNLP Shared Task on Machine Translation into Indigenous Languages | 2023-06-16T13:15:26 | 2023-06-16T13:15:26 | Edward Gow-Smith, Danae Sánchez Villegas | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper we describe the University of Sheffield's submission to the
AmericasNLP 2023 Shared Task on Machine Translation into Indigenous Languages
which comprises the translation from Spanish to eleven indigenous languages.
Our approach consists of extending, training, and ensembling different
variations of NLLB-200. We use data provided by the organizers and data from
various other sources such as constitutions, handbooks, news articles, and
backtranslations generated from monolingual data. On the dev set, our best
submission outperforms the baseline by 11% average chrF across all languages,
with substantial improvements particularly for Aymara, Guarani and Quechua. On
the test set, we achieve the highest average chrF of all the submissions, we
rank first in four of the eleven languages, and at least one of our submissions
ranks in the top 3 for all languages. | [
0.0116937952,
0.0619731583,
-0.0175385103,
0.0356120616,
-0.030580394,
0.0234055184,
-0.0361902341,
-0.0278483648,
-0.0281353611,
-0.0215576999,
-0.0260488838,
-0.0065624677,
0.0558223017,
-0.0163319539,
0.0362741463,
-0.0637882203,
0.0204350483,
-0.0241999757,
-0.0211066529,
0.0065333089,
-0.0304797385,
0.0339802392,
-0.0344797522,
0.003454302,
-0.0464578643,
-0.0239027049,
0.0230214521,
0.0225818343,
0.0272228867,
-0.0437513404,
-0.0366227813,
0.009839654,
-0.0139479367,
0.0747436285,
0.0000019927,
-0.0627742037,
-0.0481155366,
-0.007210264,
0.0008095354,
0.0080358917,
0.0785116106,
-0.0625977889,
-0.0227166638,
0.0384910628,
-0.0526505485,
-0.0087384982,
0.0671004504,
-0.0226528924,
0.0355580933,
0.057753101,
-0.0154514536,
-0.046380084,
0.004067854,
-0.040507514,
-0.0027726192,
-0.0259612817,
-0.0122733144,
0.0108119482,
-0.0096945064,
-0.0252385642,
-0.0172712263,
0.0799041316,
0.0176091827,
-0.0456212461,
-0.0264907703,
-0.0131275514,
-0.054206904,
-0.0269823,
-0.0044426611,
0.0514649861,
-0.0104157198,
-0.0228982549,
-0.0138075473,
0.0318368077,
-0.0588889904,
-0.0443731695,
-0.0314201415,
0.0169422999,
-0.0049333172,
-0.0073606079,
0.0171329267,
0.0504020229,
0.0459008329,
0.0049826573,
-0.035625197,
-0.0006181866,
0.0503261648,
-0.0075947414,
0.0127901211,
0.0052447049,
0.0441090316,
0.0257210545,
0.0605066754,
0.0117958691,
-0.0250626076,
0.0166384391,
0.0189331528,
-0.010039187,
0.0210540015,
-0.0416850112,
0.0291156936,
0.0600681901,
-0.0175864045,
0.0401140749,
-0.0226430874,
0.0548765697,
0.0002456255,
-0.007621746,
-0.0645669624,
-0.0285689067,
-0.0147547806,
0.0170078781,
-0.0521412678,
-0.0208934881,
-0.0451712944,
0.0296876077,
-0.0041915486,
-0.0333396345,
0.0197520815,
-0.0054986724,
0.0122051127,
-0.0019621744,
-0.086488083,
-0.0255784411,
0.0186478477,
0.0680646077,
0.0004289178,
-0.0060571213,
-0.0135846101,
-0.0841276124,
0.0044646086,
0.0117854374,
-0.0456168465,
-0.0373905525,
-0.0129566332,
0.0754207,
-0.0248411167,
-0.0368329622,
0.0113108819,
0.0017235656,
-0.019712409,
-0.0648661107,
-0.0167399496,
-0.0706189051,
0.0753668621,
-0.0233110562,
0.0581002943,
-0.0395962149,
-0.0023559944,
-0.0187587123,
0.0263375081,
0.0560811944,
0.0144613041,
-0.0043709949,
0.0740754902,
0.0063019693,
-0.0015420645,
0.070934929,
0.0452655591,
0.0624993928,
0.0486350842,
-0.0043023969,
-0.055225119,
0.0323577523,
-0.0202983581,
0.0369419008,
-0.0124979448,
0.0346140489,
0.0273039117,
0.0600227863,
0.038245976,
0.0722968355,
0.0014876195,
0.0269824043,
0.0613671876,
0.0804458931,
0.0006596335,
0.0217823219,
0.0779544488,
-0.0089808842,
0.0186934676,
-0.0241460297,
-0.0646362305,
0.009788679,
0.0088261757,
-0.0001920222,
0.0374329761,
0.0413429849,
-0.0008694641,
-0.0370461009,
0.0130361365,
0.0034210144,
-0.0301812086,
-0.0297447816,
0.0147185121,
-0.0001844124,
-0.0282522701,
-0.0314559937,
-0.0296564046,
-0.0360324979,
0.0419504754,
0.0009622677,
-0.0231669229,
0.0278508943,
0.0432126895,
0.0280877631,
-0.0154270306,
-0.0279691909,
0.0189594757,
0.0549539849,
0.0384633504,
-0.0339644551,
0.0370575003,
-0.0471340045,
0.0117018931,
0.0490006283,
0.0080120498,
0.0048762728,
-0.0067521818,
0.0473954193,
0.0560196526,
0.0012062765,
-0.0722343698,
0.0396400392,
-0.0513642877,
-0.0458607078,
0.0109727783,
-0.004780543,
0.0455474034,
0.0426981002,
0.0159378108,
-0.0312264096,
0.0310709309,
-0.02469467,
0.0112558911,
0.0495528765,
-0.0328098834,
-0.0241011176,
0.0596731044,
-0.1012688056,
-0.0302266199,
0.0119711524,
-0.0242981277,
-0.0510095693,
-0.0033122541,
-0.0332545787,
-0.0077058137,
-0.0529817902,
0.0203671325,
0.0211250894,
-0.0499590561,
-0.0573010854,
-0.0078767296,
-0.0015750248,
-0.0147121763,
0.0000187192,
-0.0932779312,
0.0248227082,
-0.0791231394,
0.004030956,
0.0379699208,
0.0102318134,
-0.000822688,
0.0009747701,
0.0327142403,
-0.0233697146,
-0.0270490907,
-0.0615161508,
0.0047367443,
-0.0340645351,
0.0224614181,
0.0691691935,
0.0512199476,
-0.0050311317,
-0.0050657908,
0.0309718847,
-0.05199394,
0.009231179,
-0.0007198098,
0.0106504513,
0.0060790423,
0.0299852397,
-0.027340157,
-0.0015422942,
0.0122811943,
0.0106958561,
0.0115119368,
-0.08560469,
-0.0568186082,
-0.0147124575,
-0.0169986859,
-0.0383101813,
-0.0006546971,
-0.0750802755,
0.0002563763,
0.0033225021,
0.0259296149,
0.0514668152,
-0.0061583277,
-0.0043555889,
0.015984036,
0.0137804458,
-0.0173604526,
-0.0134044811,
0.0065140766,
-0.0205822233,
-0.0233180635,
-0.0486727096,
0.0366808847,
0.0431845784,
0.0074774772,
-0.0035112977,
-0.0262191333,
-0.0370856822,
-0.0237756558,
-0.0485165231,
-0.0178483613,
0.0309953745,
0.0026954887,
0.0331688039,
-0.0707461536,
-0.0808170214,
0.0724180415,
-0.0328863114,
-0.0130840745,
-0.0819198564,
0.021684764,
-0.0510270037,
0.0323836468,
-0.0121671846,
0.0106192585,
-0.033709418,
-0.0272760577,
-0.0218589194,
0.0170931574,
0.0195465274,
-0.0162344389,
0.02987515,
-0.0885010585,
0.0065879468,
-0.0392519385,
-0.0027515437,
-0.0164420512,
0.0177811738,
0.0190754011,
-0.0079023074,
0.0208734218,
-0.0018445957,
-0.0237764083,
0.0102770505,
-0.0112368707,
0.0219863933,
-0.010346218,
0.0049663559,
0.0124928812,
0.0074471119,
-0.0150558408,
0.0003197447,
0.0030934364,
-0.0353292264,
0.0126485908,
-0.0140542891,
0.0562879443,
-0.0095291901,
0.0221156515,
-0.0045627737,
0.0460722111,
-0.009652311,
-0.0197651032,
-0.0183588061,
0.0565240495,
-0.00745328,
0.001350578,
0.0893572494,
0.0377343334,
-0.0158739798,
-0.0027042497,
-0.0292828269,
0.0207944624,
0.0146336779,
0.018760439,
-0.084540084,
0.0088114822,
0.0121523105,
0.0291475281,
0.0481175855,
-0.001880597,
-0.0302342996,
-0.1141998917,
0.0005067699,
0.0470368005,
-0.053231556,
-0.0597632155,
-0.0092338314,
-0.0600537434,
-0.0869733766,
-0.0009087636,
0.0287741851,
-0.000448618,
0.0141676404,
0.0281020291,
0.0209183935,
-0.032420747,
-0.0577698909,
-0.03897883,
-0.0084456597,
0.0606512092,
0.0258740392,
0.0188369378,
0.013395614,
0.0186066832,
-0.0211136229,
-0.0339783914,
-0.0063920338,
-0.0028893938,
0.0096618552,
-0.0091163618,
0.0113074267,
0.0349144414,
-0.001192331,
0.0480050854,
0.0626586527,
0.0697929636,
-0.0041041686,
0.0106209116,
0.0203573406,
-0.0323061943,
0.016812956,
0.0297338776,
0.0240300931,
0.0149317849,
-0.008246324,
-0.0349768922,
-0.0437399037,
-0.0513463132,
-0.040697623,
0.0098749474,
-0.0521566682,
-0.0097572366,
-0.0883315653,
-0.0708625689,
0.0384868123,
0.0338518731,
0.0488841161,
0.0178779736,
0.0025161698,
-0.0102993492,
-0.0284146704,
0.0535610653,
-0.0461966433,
0.0281270929,
-0.066465877,
-0.0067769303,
0.0296038259,
0.027485108,
0.0271998215,
0.0801868513,
-0.0814167857,
-0.0430148654,
0.0095314495,
0.0640328005,
0.0305193812,
0.0107674282,
-0.0348374099,
-0.0196616538,
0.0031827269,
-0.000308971,
-0.0191750694,
-0.0160068106,
0.0090100067,
-0.0092863487,
-0.0011414281,
0.0493768491,
0.0103744818,
-0.0154423006,
-0.000309221,
0.0565521531,
0.0132340509,
-0.0537845679,
0.0153673152,
0.0241496172,
0.0162474718,
-0.0757888705,
-0.0399830304,
-0.0143863345,
0.0192924216,
-0.0109271435,
-0.016615225,
-0.0106775714,
0.0148863802,
0.0728861019,
0.0477328412,
-0.0153870452,
0.0131594567,
-0.0074665211,
0.0482776985,
-0.0261553135,
0.0477322675,
0.0171191078,
0.0568533242,
0.0008814165,
0.0359149165,
-0.0082091782,
0.0596519634,
-0.0488548055,
0.0495659225,
-0.0242733024,
0.0079022376,
-0.028688604,
0.0528924689,
0.0102432044,
0.0400543138,
0.0227031186,
0.0079070162,
-0.0108824493,
0.0272023063,
0.0925771147,
0.0110068666,
0.0878485516,
0.0376677737,
-0.0284600314,
-0.0195367187,
0.0539587885,
0.021368064,
0.0012611339,
0.004550911,
-0.0124483043,
0.0067931018,
0.0113575384,
0.0447673835,
-0.0413147658,
0.0075173052,
0.0368496403,
0.027452318,
0.0016935946,
-0.0285190791,
-0.0055080079,
-0.0402496494,
-0.0173321404,
-0.0349766985,
-0.0270428415,
-0.0494722202,
0.0301272795,
-0.0174964666,
0.0119914059,
0.0212588925,
-0.0021631471,
0.0714422762,
-0.0228115208,
0.0118734874,
-0.0468308441,
0.0041552554,
-0.0255099498,
-0.0320804492,
-0.0398534499,
-5.422450013e-33,
-0.0358726569,
-0.037064191,
0.0086479755,
-0.0481231287,
-0.0179429725,
-0.043463584,
-0.015832372,
-0.0491483137,
0.027600646,
0.0071944883,
-0.0068259849,
-0.0115967756,
0.0352275781,
0.0013939549,
0.0324455239,
0.0610355847,
0.0451668166,
0.0085446062,
-0.0322589017,
-0.0068738828,
0.0083184605,
0.0359423086,
0.0844039842,
-0.0586516224,
0.0293623991,
-0.008499247,
-0.0157486405,
0.0436844565,
-0.0018832437,
0.0289900322,
-0.0218131505,
0.0006279566,
0.0112990243,
-0.0280277748,
-0.0283442717,
-0.0329245366,
-0.0978213698,
-0.0078984899,
0.0416701473,
0.0418700501,
0.0359122343,
-0.0618575327,
0.0238519069,
-0.0549144745,
-0.0247551817,
-0.0196101423,
0.0007485871,
-0.0531312674,
-0.0146841099,
-0.0039861924,
-0.0648598671,
0.0362102389,
-0.0043311934,
0.0009695988,
0.0122314245,
0.0848622322,
-0.0371371433,
-0.0574278273,
-0.0507996343,
0.0255542379,
-0.0261042565,
0.066011861,
0.0774817765,
0.0006196196,
-0.0313632451,
-0.0176114999,
0.0339883566,
-0.0243153088,
0.0484980792,
0.0666484609,
0.0047809957,
-0.0257780794,
0.0388684645,
0.0764360204,
0.0368246622,
-0.0331169851,
-0.0231820941,
0.0616084784,
0.0050961096,
0.0069100466,
-0.0144432485,
0.0180102699,
-0.0113501493,
0.0137053672,
-0.0470397435,
-0.0497184172,
0.0346962437,
-0.0196936317,
0.0196187533,
0.0033823915,
-0.0139835281,
0.0246654414,
0.0512006693,
-0.0212427489,
0.0184758268,
0.0139908614,
-0.0160757303,
0.0057226485,
-0.0108410632,
0.0449740067,
-0.0509110317,
-0.0053536477,
0.0222959388,
0.0672788918,
0.0208440199,
-0.0563183241,
0.0387588739,
0.0164055917,
-0.0469451137,
0.014687649,
-0.0361019261,
0.0068727317,
-0.0150240799,
0.0731247291,
0.0140126674,
-0.0226785578,
-0.0084610526,
-0.0137935346,
0.0085724071,
-0.0265186559,
0.0001802818,
0.0245197881,
0.0090955989,
-0.0130357742,
-0.0590352789,
0.0255927984,
-0.0135448603,
0.0151508432,
0.0107478797,
-0.0195334796,
-0.0107067665,
-0.0305278599,
2.649e-7,
0.045152612,
0.0375640243,
0.0557898171,
0.0195567869,
0.0015093036,
-0.042123016,
-0.0394934118,
0.022640625,
-0.0069046654,
0.0418540165,
0.0292291548,
0.0097737927,
0.09659978,
0.0440708362,
-0.1184732914,
-0.0557929464,
-0.0211571045,
0.0069397246,
-0.0474012196,
-0.0342953019,
-0.0146128871,
0.0687971711,
-0.0216377974,
-0.0105225034,
-0.0296711717,
-0.025240805,
0.0321099795,
0.0007085638,
-0.0140896551,
-0.0151898246,
0.0474848785,
0.0050824233,
-0.0598182306,
-0.0447673313,
-0.0013475047,
-0.0029645157,
0.0278870296,
0.0869226977,
-0.0097982688,
-0.0069549102,
0.0182680506,
-0.0046520694,
-0.0070855948,
-0.0279532671,
0.0188373905,
0.0273112599,
-0.0346204527,
0.0504658967,
0.0085248342,
0.0290035401,
0.0100254379,
-0.0207035299,
-0.0118051087,
0.0242762901,
0.0480551869,
-0.0462796353,
-0.0345138051,
-0.0627267137,
-0.0335255526,
0.0192935932,
0.0276217069,
-0.0556030907,
0.0000927262,
0.0160799511,
-0.0182334427,
-0.03631033,
-0.0100693461,
2.007251195e-34,
0.0213899054,
-0.012839579,
0.0112195732,
-0.0112102078,
0.0434972346,
-0.0331564546,
0.0117547773,
-0.0060452474,
0.0066422303,
-0.0232116673,
0.0092916405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09824v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09824v1 | Process Knowledge-infused Learning for Clinician-friendly Explanations | 2023-06-16T13:08:17 | 2023-06-16T13:08:17 | Kaushik Roy, Yuxin Zi, Manas Gaur, Jinendra Malekar, Qi Zhang, Vignesh Narayanan, Amit Sheth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models have the potential to assess mental health using social media
data. By analyzing online posts and conversations, these models can detect
patterns indicating mental health conditions like depression, anxiety, or
suicidal thoughts. They examine keywords, language markers, and sentiment to
gain insights into an individual's mental well-being. This information is
crucial for early detection, intervention, and support, improving mental health
care and prevention strategies. However, using language models for mental
health assessments from social media has two limitations: (1) They do not
compare posts against clinicians' diagnostic processes, and (2) It's
challenging to explain language model outputs using concepts that the clinician
can understand, i.e., clinician-friendly explanations. In this study, we
introduce Process Knowledge-infused Learning (PK-iL), a new learning paradigm
that layers clinical process knowledge structures on language model outputs,
enabling clinician-friendly explanations of the underlying language model
predictions. We rigorously test our methods on existing benchmark datasets,
augmented with such clinical process knowledge, and release a new dataset for
assessing suicidality. PK-iL performs competitively, achieving a 70% agreement
with users, while other XAI methods only achieve 47% agreement (average
inter-rater agreement of 0.72). Our evaluations demonstrate that PK-iL
effectively explains model predictions to clinicians. | [
0.0457554683,
0.0655911267,
-0.0108211515,
-0.0279449914,
-0.0063755694,
0.0329389982,
-0.0040226211,
0.0033103353,
0.0350364856,
-0.003846948,
0.0058998363,
0.0176401865,
0.0080192015,
0.0565550365,
-0.0243283305,
-0.0518341251,
-0.0145752719,
0.0261633508,
0.1147646606,
0.0144572984,
0.0050327149,
0.0358600877,
-0.0386705212,
0.0728480294,
-0.006438212,
-0.0245874487,
0.0351783447,
-0.0221534073,
0.0116319023,
-0.0855860338,
-0.0093984427,
0.0355843827,
-0.0278977416,
-0.0105763115,
0.0000018066,
-0.0346889086,
0.0195169467,
0.0076218331,
-0.0068854713,
-0.0441556796,
0.0451959483,
-0.0677835718,
0.0293186996,
0.021874303,
-0.0331055,
-0.0498399623,
0.050161317,
0.0653124675,
0.072765857,
0.03818186,
-0.0351098105,
-0.0095321974,
0.0116202589,
-0.0061882539,
-0.0051894761,
-0.0263019223,
0.057086654,
0.0052167433,
0.0297055971,
-0.0050948975,
0.0347507671,
0.0431262068,
-0.022123741,
0.0061827041,
-0.0320382975,
0.0162531082,
0.0112044094,
-0.0498783402,
0.0306308288,
0.0845591724,
0.0100563671,
0.008080042,
0.0281785224,
-0.0270881392,
0.0048199384,
-0.000263801,
-0.0521436818,
-0.0167724378,
-0.010262968,
0.0119292783,
0.015602746,
0.026230352,
0.0483202487,
-0.0019803173,
0.0210127924,
0.0523787588,
-0.0274982024,
0.0021491507,
-0.0041054501,
0.0116794193,
-0.0234480593,
-0.0264630876,
0.0196046215,
0.0298545863,
-0.0555086657,
0.0332560837,
0.0094373915,
-0.0369402878,
0.036893189,
-0.0469712578,
0.0520226248,
0.0226695668,
-0.0046141716,
-0.0016162219,
0.0384074114,
-0.0332161821,
0.0211560465,
0.0147610568,
-0.009578296,
-0.0045236666,
-0.0951206461,
0.0049826079,
0.0110317087,
-0.0211379584,
0.0449316241,
-0.0035182508,
-0.0641891211,
0.0351780094,
-0.0595039465,
0.0017987388,
0.0098335454,
-0.0113345021,
-0.0036562821,
0.0047107763,
-0.0266490616,
0.0411236957,
-0.009270492,
0.0330395438,
-0.0087690307,
0.0063165212,
0.0294483304,
-0.0196665972,
0.018358184,
-0.0081582377,
-0.0087982733,
0.0291743912,
0.0560728721,
0.0236606617,
-0.0250717476,
-0.0212861374,
-0.0158019755,
-0.0057768011,
-0.0343288966,
-0.0342885666,
0.0330731049,
0.0443738364,
-0.0029028479,
-0.0686958358,
0.0213595498,
-0.0053318893,
-0.0739147365,
0.0961084217,
-0.0733850524,
0.0280912854,
0.0184685402,
0.0428746864,
-0.008104464,
0.0429841504,
0.0092488984,
-0.0203608125,
0.0111960238,
-0.049705863,
0.0284689479,
-0.0215650704,
0.0253339075,
-0.0400211923,
0.0110586751,
-0.0043375967,
-0.0541538373,
0.0125038503,
-0.0414440297,
0.012505752,
0.0244841501,
0.0420128182,
0.0523162484,
0.0711193457,
0.0088845193,
0.0221891273,
0.0282650124,
0.028389696,
-0.0106683969,
-0.0561544001,
-0.0423807874,
-0.0022129642,
0.0013576068,
0.0042122742,
-0.0253523514,
-0.0261100158,
-0.0238867328,
-0.0680068284,
-0.0511197932,
-0.0317076929,
-0.0040989062,
0.0128249675,
-0.0159842111,
-0.004498601,
-0.0102642477,
0.05720599,
0.0607579537,
-0.0224943161,
-0.0262599606,
-0.0569718704,
0.0159272663,
0.0819219276,
0.0230512042,
-0.0641008466,
-0.00983031,
-0.0174394548,
0.0409205854,
-0.0031772261,
0.0149099641,
-0.0154083166,
0.0130328247,
0.010513192,
-0.0159558114,
0.0275863986,
0.0240816399,
-0.0743138492,
0.0192833096,
0.0013283971,
-0.0307816062,
-0.0399892516,
-0.0684161261,
0.0375561602,
-0.0210814923,
-0.0240163933,
0.018268209,
-0.0088715032,
0.0309255142,
0.0055041406,
0.0250036195,
0.0373236276,
-0.0052705435,
-0.0165703129,
-0.0406816229,
0.0186045952,
-0.0059230844,
0.0033447072,
0.0150101287,
-0.0105987154,
-0.0124518964,
-0.0016068016,
-0.065081954,
-0.015353635,
0.0466823168,
-0.0394057296,
0.0256483145,
0.0063094459,
-0.0485620275,
-0.0044845412,
-0.0017963583,
-0.016101053,
0.0367198437,
-0.0360892229,
0.0083684381,
-0.0129855191,
-0.0517198145,
-0.0359388627,
0.0304511562,
-0.0202098321,
-0.0032981383,
-0.0236171558,
0.0149316825,
-0.0221108384,
-0.0041716546,
-0.012504763,
-0.002906566,
-0.1402102858,
-0.0160817374,
-0.0170608666,
-0.0105689541,
0.007824406,
0.0050399499,
-0.0123981405,
-0.0280080307,
-0.0145476628,
0.0223587509,
0.0388823487,
0.0434747897,
0.0335127153,
0.0363644175,
0.0077876928,
-0.0583057106,
-0.0210989881,
-0.0529431179,
0.023549689,
0.0154668214,
-0.0045214389,
-0.029711755,
-0.0092516029,
-0.0717560425,
-0.0407226756,
0.0035359603,
0.0006045263,
0.0350306854,
-0.002610259,
-0.0117898406,
0.016726518,
-0.0063954517,
0.0708259791,
0.0448380485,
0.0160374716,
-0.014900526,
0.0092613213,
-0.060073968,
-0.0369021818,
-0.0368375368,
-0.0276370402,
-0.011693269,
0.0841843337,
0.03400518,
-0.009206133,
-0.0540126599,
-0.0015251852,
-0.0373869985,
0.011564183,
-0.0258672927,
-0.0149622131,
0.0151166571,
0.0161404423,
-0.0255638193,
-0.0319498591,
0.0895112231,
0.0112257944,
0.0253755543,
-0.0467328802,
-0.0379067212,
-0.0158073697,
0.0235468298,
-0.0021624679,
0.0126402415,
0.0034188263,
0.0115084331,
0.0447351448,
-0.0035356057,
-0.0019653954,
-0.0393721946,
0.0136520099,
-0.0564354546,
-0.0017777726,
0.0490383916,
-0.0306405108,
-0.0462592244,
-0.0276552141,
-0.0802809075,
0.0051947809,
-0.0340706296,
-0.0136872474,
-0.0082990257,
0.0010601642,
0.0062219263,
0.0191451292,
0.0197028331,
-0.0549578369,
-0.0079123517,
-0.0132647278,
0.0404751264,
-0.0263591334,
0.0305306371,
-0.0111319181,
0.0443842076,
0.0468546264,
-0.0071271737,
0.0225559473,
-0.01071415,
0.0046003344,
-0.0365326032,
-0.0194478445,
0.0100464886,
0.0351496339,
0.0325302891,
-0.026665926,
-0.0207837094,
0.1154489741,
0.014881853,
-0.0461258143,
0.0368999727,
-0.0103310077,
0.0056918967,
0.0057243817,
-0.0059113619,
-0.0064268326,
-0.0312950052,
-0.0427485369,
0.0475579873,
-0.022934664,
-0.023879353,
0.0229958836,
-0.0217810515,
0.0375484414,
-0.0241425261,
-0.0007632955,
0.003381368,
-0.0654476285,
0.0210780874,
-0.0222712457,
-0.0299021676,
-0.0442742184,
0.0129018808,
0.012468975,
-0.0041967602,
-0.0840134397,
-0.0958827883,
0.0391915664,
0.0116846468,
0.0551045686,
-0.0001102172,
0.0665924102,
0.0051482106,
-0.048995249,
-0.0005010035,
0.0145913213,
0.0042025694,
0.0075629209,
0.0687285438,
0.0349576175,
0.0063351751,
-0.0648030564,
0.0572980866,
-0.0891037136,
-0.0510784127,
-0.0321397893,
0.1126723364,
-0.0322648995,
-0.04623105,
-0.0239959564,
0.0493532084,
0.0665904358,
0.0649323016,
0.0388710015,
-0.0311390571,
-0.0022606479,
-0.0128405858,
0.0205665659,
0.03661751,
-0.0569528863,
0.0016221849,
0.018755056,
-0.0114059066,
-0.0452752747,
-0.0198195204,
0.0429796241,
-0.0146199036,
-0.0006434596,
-0.0109037627,
0.0191384815,
0.0087985173,
-0.0924542546,
0.0635363609,
0.0489153638,
0.0215257369,
0.0074580559,
-0.0135541763,
0.034130957,
0.0425204448,
-0.017466791,
0.0380202495,
-0.0744851008,
-0.010725135,
0.0045718127,
0.0370342247,
0.0188909434,
-0.0038352758,
-0.0200124681,
-0.0649579316,
0.017420236,
-0.0043970719,
-0.0108078551,
-0.0546919219,
0.0053332709,
0.0200246666,
0.0272271261,
0.0460675582,
0.0078048799,
0.0253492631,
0.0331367888,
0.0069432068,
-0.0690907985,
0.0113058956,
-0.0151070263,
0.0047588134,
0.0424657837,
-0.004020982,
-0.0612510145,
-0.014062589,
-0.049351614,
-0.0055778562,
-0.0128925703,
-0.0144765386,
-0.0134818871,
0.0423766263,
-0.0064288559,
-0.0224840436,
-0.033100035,
-0.0243373048,
-0.0409357548,
-0.050334245,
0.0046334234,
0.049398426,
0.0062505105,
0.0160463881,
-0.0089590922,
-0.0135179749,
0.0359879993,
-0.0197273754,
0.0393766947,
-0.0142660858,
0.0742419362,
-0.0103669306,
0.0400449075,
0.0515998267,
0.0306689423,
-0.0536294542,
-0.0970619321,
-0.0140552958,
-0.0046895994,
0.0163390301,
-0.0037639041,
0.0622545555,
-0.0316467509,
0.0088883918,
-0.0129678836,
0.0480415486,
-0.0489069968,
-0.0353199616,
0.0097551662,
0.0118004791,
-0.0214191303,
-0.034713123,
0.065901272,
0.0009675678,
0.0240290426,
-0.0136266798,
-0.0401630737,
-0.0185218398,
-0.0184232984,
0.0090384968,
0.0696013123,
-0.0411071219,
0.0434938632,
-0.0482079051,
-0.0894834697,
0.0277141742,
-0.0546548925,
-0.0294423476,
-0.0306977257,
0.0033933248,
0.0501253642,
0.0203434639,
-0.0013125695,
-0.0620029792,
0.0013520377,
-0.0079834173,
-0.0476839952,
-0.0455070101,
-5.024732887e-33,
0.0119173275,
-0.0355532244,
-0.0022180192,
-0.0025256774,
0.0363033302,
0.0150237661,
-0.0469491631,
0.0214527138,
0.0208299067,
0.0740317181,
0.0218304116,
0.0595696308,
-0.0087837949,
0.0599942654,
0.0162485056,
-0.0049957586,
0.0031814368,
0.002176035,
-0.0098473299,
0.0410606675,
0.0167181529,
0.0433250926,
0.0258950498,
-0.0979345962,
0.0598431155,
0.0417288691,
0.0163581539,
0.0281396192,
0.0237744413,
0.0409478098,
-0.0412936322,
0.0733140782,
0.0595085286,
0.0097220857,
-0.0014750133,
-0.0063276845,
-0.0579673164,
-0.0409099199,
-0.0011389086,
-0.0168827139,
-0.043505542,
0.0185903814,
0.0455688983,
-0.0161406994,
-0.0047308686,
-0.0405331291,
0.0432950072,
-0.0279966518,
0.0400848985,
-0.0058963718,
-0.0194836035,
0.0114869345,
-0.0241030082,
0.0020244604,
-0.015303202,
-0.0001558475,
-0.0315685049,
-0.0023267663,
-0.0813132077,
0.0010394405,
-0.0383563004,
0.0150596024,
0.0312656388,
-0.0456519276,
-0.0322440155,
0.0576875806,
-0.0234485697,
0.0077725737,
-0.0476080291,
0.0460993126,
0.0016718875,
0.0802489519,
0.0501760617,
0.0046485737,
-0.0311073978,
-0.0239630025,
-0.0417132191,
0.0219391938,
-0.0547503568,
0.0346109048,
0.0375098214,
-0.0205863621,
-0.0465186425,
-0.0253834035,
-0.0339763798,
-0.0418236777,
-0.0203673523,
0.0001724627,
-0.0074427994,
-0.014268375,
-0.0265852474,
-0.0021193335,
-0.0196450986,
-0.0381860733,
-0.0238135904,
0.0158534553,
0.0078553082,
0.0173927303,
0.0036468797,
0.002796537,
-0.0269716159,
0.012421296,
-0.0240176804,
-0.0058841999,
0.0614842884,
-0.0038208261,
0.0541409291,
-0.0349953212,
-0.0304167736,
-0.0205374658,
-0.0049127759,
0.0343744159,
-0.0221159719,
0.0460724756,
-0.005507763,
0.0444411114,
-0.0148127638,
0.0187371373,
0.0134529173,
0.0143886032,
-0.0178012643,
-0.0026478693,
-0.0391243882,
-0.011232445,
-0.0232026521,
-0.0684012324,
-0.0331351086,
0.0002035751,
0.0448813327,
-0.0438565463,
-0.0062802476,
-0.0070663616,
2.433e-7,
0.0956564918,
0.0707292631,
-0.0222574342,
0.0122518195,
0.0457939655,
0.0345462412,
0.0194821153,
0.0101800952,
0.0349340141,
-0.0479017496,
0.0276942439,
0.0462109521,
0.0563016832,
0.0656003132,
-0.0055268891,
-0.057951007,
-0.0496173315,
-0.0077069099,
-0.0635818616,
-0.0121286409,
0.056363225,
0.0509056561,
0.0111891786,
-0.0357026309,
0.0186243318,
-0.0008441166,
0.0373174995,
-0.0173323732,
0.0436381139,
0.0594982468,
0.0500030518,
-0.0354938023,
0.0543670021,
0.0098807039,
-0.0284972228,
-0.0470201969,
-0.0049985913,
0.0898693353,
-0.0315852836,
-0.0120766331,
-0.0173545536,
0.0077103204,
0.0558871441,
-0.059596356,
0.0593459234,
-0.0735572353,
-0.0608290918,
-0.0612583943,
0.019234892,
-0.0430831648,
0.051189702,
-0.0057345149,
-0.01856298,
0.0609506145,
0.0122143691,
0.0086098332,
0.0183901973,
-0.0520796217,
-0.0619205497,
0.0248081945,
-0.024454141,
0.0184634794,
0.0139990542,
-0.0427311957,
0.0047735283,
-0.0299981236,
0.0586114377,
1.897540149e-34,
0.0020220771,
0.0415513292,
0.0220082402,
0.0100566903,
0.0382773615,
0.0344487652,
-0.0069690645,
0.0127926935,
0.0105142482,
-0.0580457821,
0.0221793037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09821v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09821v2 | Unlocking the Potential of User Feedback: Leveraging Large Language Model as User Simulator to Enhance Dialogue System | 2023-06-16T13:04:56 | 2023-10-19T16:51:06 | Zhiyuan Hu, Yue Feng, Anh Tuan Luu, Bryan Hooi, Aldo Lipani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue systems and large language models (LLMs) have gained considerable
attention. However, the direct utilization of LLMs as task-oriented dialogue
(TOD) models has been found to underperform compared to smaller task-specific
models. Nonetheless, it is crucial to acknowledge the significant potential of
LLMs and explore improved approaches for leveraging their impressive abilities.
Motivated by the goal of leveraging LLMs, we propose an alternative approach
called User-Guided Response Optimization (UGRO) to combine it with a smaller
TOD model. This approach uses LLM as annotation-free user simulator to assess
dialogue responses, combining them with smaller fine-tuned end-to-end TOD
models. By utilizing the satisfaction feedback generated by LLMs, UGRO further
optimizes the supervised fine-tuned TOD model. Specifically, the TOD model
takes the dialogue history as input and, with the assistance of the user
simulator's feedback, generates high-satisfaction responses that meet the
user's requirements. Through empirical experiments on two TOD benchmarks, we
validate the effectiveness of our method. The results demonstrate that our
approach outperforms previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) results. | [
0.0833938047,
0.0315585881,
-0.0179845747,
0.060051281,
0.0067865457,
0.0133866332,
-0.0114413835,
-0.011403692,
0.0442614816,
-0.0344960354,
-0.0858360156,
-0.0334520005,
-0.037111368,
0.0008829263,
-0.0000498685,
-0.0764461681,
0.0223661326,
-0.0338327102,
-0.0198024902,
0.0067038867,
-0.0131721003,
0.000281517,
-0.0228560716,
0.0744044334,
-0.0211022273,
-0.0043572546,
-0.0286195688,
0.0209971648,
-0.0131482594,
-0.0189366881,
0.0229728241,
0.0658799559,
0.0071704718,
0.044003278,
0.0000021241,
-0.0398118421,
0.0524425469,
-0.0212797634,
-0.024831349,
0.0292159449,
0.0619239509,
0.0921641365,
0.0010810822,
0.014465264,
-0.0429696031,
0.0108981188,
0.0299175978,
0.0499406271,
0.0878599733,
0.0650743619,
0.0015508207,
-0.0289033484,
-0.0091543682,
-0.0098503968,
0.0269657839,
-0.0317077897,
-0.0120589761,
0.0477191061,
0.0392520502,
0.0031750745,
0.0153593989,
0.0122496504,
-0.0026412613,
-0.0498424619,
0.0091350023,
0.0092171524,
-0.0154904835,
-0.0246321782,
-0.0212159678,
0.0931848213,
0.0382572152,
0.0392510034,
-0.0244047828,
0.0103864893,
0.0118351113,
-0.0312592797,
-0.027352294,
-0.0650713667,
-0.0164800547,
-0.0088043241,
-0.0512942635,
0.0118380403,
-0.0132713271,
0.020846419,
-0.0147445444,
0.0399194546,
0.0015911275,
-0.0049488288,
-0.0074221753,
-0.0032831489,
0.0089484118,
-0.0514433645,
-0.0047828862,
0.0344974063,
-0.1041584387,
-0.0155283129,
-0.0061669177,
0.0018980217,
0.002588508,
-0.0532886051,
0.0650546178,
0.0504942872,
0.0033406909,
0.0350983255,
0.0183756333,
0.0569432676,
-0.0374420881,
-0.0307209939,
-0.0553764068,
0.0038318986,
-0.0558953881,
-0.0078211138,
-0.0332214385,
0.0321606211,
-0.0544254221,
-0.0236843266,
-0.0385134406,
0.0652999058,
0.0098823877,
-0.0013700686,
0.0110389162,
0.0391255431,
-0.044105161,
0.0215910319,
-0.0731127039,
0.0160293784,
-0.0364620909,
0.0103810858,
0.0230750144,
-0.0417533405,
0.0104016168,
0.04442662,
-0.014752822,
-0.025133146,
-0.0024537351,
0.0617176779,
-0.0180345885,
-0.0129251964,
0.0133081153,
-0.0116911018,
-0.0335553512,
-0.0487351269,
-0.0161583666,
-0.0323776342,
0.0338308997,
0.0006358663,
-0.0138926962,
-0.0062332158,
0.0115939155,
0.0268384814,
-0.0330237709,
0.0592751987,
-0.0138552887,
0.0143912444,
0.0428217724,
-0.005547347,
-0.0273208432,
0.0306477919,
0.0438660495,
0.0575329997,
0.0227493476,
-0.0143076926,
0.0223704372,
0.0463715419,
-0.0231527667,
0.031952884,
0.0144576421,
0.0276440047,
-0.0336745046,
0.0281595662,
0.0401224047,
0.0540361814,
-0.0222030934,
0.0193853844,
0.0616845042,
0.049303934,
0.0021920861,
0.033001408,
0.0211111065,
0.0471705832,
0.0055123763,
0.0065865335,
-0.020178074,
0.0202337634,
-0.0000565589,
0.0051031122,
0.079961136,
-0.027972227,
-0.0364868753,
-0.0430556983,
-0.0016401547,
-0.0019040527,
0.0280640703,
0.0395258479,
0.027347587,
0.0029894111,
-0.0710205659,
0.0272613745,
0.0211238582,
-0.0417656042,
0.0025570383,
-0.0517323054,
0.0306949243,
0.0793529823,
0.0440318137,
-0.0142137771,
-0.0310725458,
-0.0240438133,
0.0038886061,
0.0811848342,
0.0426096916,
-0.0210034437,
0.0016833297,
-0.0275005791,
-0.0114225829,
-0.0082730986,
-0.0196033213,
0.0529101416,
0.0149645554,
-0.0305587798,
0.0258002337,
-0.0091694919,
-0.0131520126,
0.0030874116,
0.0030114274,
-0.0163377784,
0.0276691187,
0.0045909248,
0.0650110096,
0.0230382718,
0.0006562596,
0.0044122096,
0.0192216318,
-0.0062279557,
-0.009914536,
-0.0088718589,
-0.0577470995,
-0.0464987159,
0.0445122011,
0.0312075894,
0.0081149479,
0.0790744051,
-0.0268557314,
-0.0282185748,
0.0099709984,
-0.035300523,
0.0257915277,
-0.0709454939,
0.0137491534,
0.0079882005,
-0.0056738183,
-0.0698915794,
0.0210332591,
0.0083817532,
0.0213216245,
0.039873708,
-0.0059491517,
0.040079169,
-0.0332921743,
-0.0116758989,
0.0189467054,
-0.0024519293,
0.0188943576,
0.0422710516,
0.0385662131,
-0.0456997417,
-0.0482318513,
-0.1416341215,
-0.0012895399,
-0.0115040131,
0.00877186,
0.0113425329,
0.0200395435,
-0.0180672053,
-0.0394269451,
-0.0330520086,
-0.0192455351,
0.0524914302,
-0.008157501,
0.0407999195,
0.0071666497,
-0.0235778671,
-0.064664416,
0.0108698253,
0.0075855246,
-0.0131475832,
-0.0240219869,
-0.0055491948,
-0.0357634351,
0.0024539945,
-0.0307101589,
0.0393623412,
-0.0014397711,
-0.0470346771,
0.0413426831,
0.0148990676,
0.0600838736,
0.0380187854,
0.0605071448,
0.0446601473,
-0.0063427151,
-0.0268660411,
-0.0716765225,
0.0551925413,
-0.0237405095,
-0.078994371,
-0.043513,
-0.030253876,
0.0342314467,
0.0405117609,
0.0143461125,
0.0293969661,
-0.0701116845,
0.0147071695,
-0.0098240776,
-0.0116187865,
-0.0156862568,
-0.0114098853,
-0.0561886318,
0.0213936884,
-0.0038733718,
-0.0207552109,
0.0730366111,
-0.0235117394,
-0.0206681006,
-0.0407689922,
0.0300029665,
-0.0306553133,
0.0350008644,
-0.0195278954,
0.0208782572,
-0.0178022999,
-0.0321931131,
-0.021377122,
-0.0225500427,
0.0033201652,
-0.0479435399,
0.0290702507,
-0.0207728408,
-0.0063614217,
-0.0176914781,
-0.0484943576,
-0.0523514748,
-0.0347525775,
-0.0193839092,
-0.0158700272,
0.0250736717,
-0.014199621,
-0.0179105904,
0.0231691934,
0.0090057198,
0.0184660889,
-0.020890452,
-0.0126007199,
-0.0094205067,
0.0471127443,
0.054327406,
0.0286302995,
-0.0065505672,
-0.0161917266,
0.0477255248,
0.0174799785,
0.0485165603,
-0.029402364,
-0.0009563955,
-0.0230104495,
0.053879898,
0.0016531972,
0.0088511333,
0.0285028536,
0.0560434684,
-0.0238132309,
-0.0079951063,
0.1253013015,
0.0308368709,
-0.0169686675,
-0.0057748142,
-0.0436354913,
0.0473178215,
0.032205537,
0.0500075929,
-0.0608282462,
-0.0391562358,
-0.0124280667,
0.0433775894,
0.0119773485,
-0.0254112352,
0.0021953427,
-0.1239078939,
0.0459539033,
-0.0191080738,
-0.0226771403,
0.0209854525,
-0.0137119107,
0.0094776638,
0.0232301578,
0.016147038,
0.0129015483,
0.0108372187,
-0.0227666739,
0.0231247302,
-0.012097626,
-0.0204208922,
0.0284450129,
-0.0024432163,
0.0345347412,
0.088621363,
0.0662308782,
0.0182644948,
0.0171760973,
0.0477425084,
0.0220134202,
0.0296153259,
-0.01480556,
0.0299224649,
0.0078720301,
-0.0117507642,
-0.043660108,
0.0149969142,
-0.0175966155,
-0.0142054521,
0.0340398587,
0.0167777278,
-0.0441319346,
0.0356774144,
-0.0259091593,
0.0231300034,
0.0436351225,
0.0596139021,
0.0215659402,
-0.0845005363,
-0.0273304898,
-0.0199854411,
-0.0243551023,
-0.0194505248,
-0.0058834958,
-0.023675574,
0.0126942256,
0.0166219752,
-0.0647577718,
-0.0557036921,
-0.0046804748,
-0.0040870211,
-0.0122918896,
0.004934256,
-0.0294126738,
-0.0035911978,
0.0388592631,
0.0362089463,
-0.0379835702,
0.0205552541,
-0.0711687729,
0.0128794182,
0.0537917838,
-0.0421049297,
0.0183372386,
0.0396589004,
-0.0790918395,
-0.0563230328,
-0.0558247752,
0.0901498795,
0.0148814069,
0.0414956696,
0.0083108768,
-0.0469518416,
-0.0088644996,
0.0095026912,
-0.0350948907,
-0.0191890672,
0.0194136854,
0.064258717,
-0.0397828557,
0.019809125,
-0.0371941142,
0.0222061016,
0.0012350393,
0.0471064635,
-0.0093563059,
-0.0871455446,
0.0087277899,
0.0238147471,
0.0498812944,
0.0024628469,
-0.0513274148,
0.0132079022,
0.028501438,
-0.0393634029,
-0.037711747,
-0.0595242977,
-0.011704307,
-0.0117993206,
-0.0345173292,
0.0049255388,
-0.0314470977,
-0.0542218462,
0.0618146509,
-0.034525793,
-0.0096664969,
0.0066824048,
-0.0433954075,
0.018410204,
0.0075295619,
-0.0342367962,
0.0090748612,
0.042056296,
0.0345809571,
0.0083171679,
0.1133599728,
0.0150743332,
-0.0227544922,
0.0198085662,
0.0350299105,
-0.0250860061,
-0.0545212701,
-0.0280926712,
0.0028909952,
0.0296454113,
0.0167647414,
0.0474477634,
-0.0287046228,
0.0112637468,
-0.0381983705,
0.0296873543,
-0.0219380241,
-0.0283125285,
0.0250295289,
0.0184004437,
-0.0212842096,
0.0108967824,
0.0448721722,
-0.0141068418,
-0.0126426797,
-0.0233977214,
-0.0083880015,
-0.0739480108,
-0.0286280774,
0.0163280685,
0.0348529965,
-0.0162054878,
-0.0150339967,
-0.0205054786,
-0.0320541598,
-0.0051026773,
-0.0068371631,
-0.0222851448,
-0.0194751769,
0.0555342883,
0.0362108685,
-0.0188322421,
-0.0249812026,
-0.056437321,
-0.0223449804,
-0.0229448974,
-0.0342942812,
-0.0438713841,
-5.831904818e-33,
-0.0378412865,
-0.0350506864,
0.0241737328,
0.0299099497,
-0.0501817279,
-0.0505362451,
-0.0289106704,
0.0478167497,
-0.0249697138,
-0.0230290107,
-0.0332456939,
-0.0251414329,
0.0050507863,
0.0334631056,
-0.0121502411,
0.0058069285,
0.0604083352,
-0.0115780942,
-0.0322754718,
0.0297334511,
-0.0002504287,
-0.0086896624,
-0.0065912995,
-0.0694817007,
0.0272520501,
-0.0209028255,
-0.0234568939,
0.0362196714,
0.0269137174,
0.0672318861,
-0.0423955098,
0.0590000898,
0.0141993286,
-0.0443248898,
-0.0045419675,
0.0268610604,
-0.0189436637,
-0.0071257898,
0.0157192089,
0.0065085478,
-0.0096798269,
-0.0201056246,
-0.0206138082,
-0.0038738346,
-0.0350956358,
0.0122155538,
0.0122641968,
0.002146834,
-0.0242093839,
-0.0109033901,
-0.0769989341,
-0.0026302841,
-0.0152382879,
-0.0868580639,
-0.0207897238,
0.0887415111,
-0.012884032,
-0.0305904374,
-0.0062210183,
0.0111847231,
0.0346019715,
-0.017444592,
0.0594346039,
0.0602510795,
0.005551869,
0.0354123637,
0.0013331011,
0.0337663367,
-0.018903235,
-0.0645337403,
0.0025247994,
0.027561171,
0.0037116506,
0.055776231,
-0.0437102169,
-0.0071870042,
-0.0182023179,
0.0481596999,
0.0141106434,
0.0549021997,
0.0646542832,
0.0298967157,
-0.0346530601,
-0.011894837,
-0.0438280813,
0.0320395306,
-0.0383982621,
-0.0578473359,
0.0426060334,
0.0046496559,
-0.0037560484,
-0.0520347208,
0.0564653315,
-0.0292281508,
-0.010398021,
0.008155534,
-0.0459820218,
0.0244584344,
-0.0182867832,
-0.0156831201,
-0.0284682978,
-0.0214103553,
0.0274037048,
0.0015903157,
-0.0117259584,
0.0122902701,
-0.0404337868,
-0.0207975823,
-0.0591903403,
0.0135684907,
-0.0155832563,
0.0445667431,
-0.0368953496,
0.0388549529,
0.0241124388,
-0.0095193787,
-0.0262086578,
0.0994191319,
-0.0229429603,
-0.034293443,
-0.0441619493,
-0.0432663746,
0.0416508652,
-0.0125343446,
-0.0229848549,
0.0232247822,
0.0150217013,
-0.0096833045,
-0.005279379,
0.0094425837,
-0.0372265503,
-0.0055031925,
2.613e-7,
-0.0063869813,
0.0424825661,
0.0154936509,
0.0378882624,
0.0009146178,
0.0546834171,
0.0176608097,
0.0006173976,
0.0659087598,
-0.0030622617,
0.0150875608,
-0.0005899382,
0.0712800175,
-0.001013043,
-0.1095497757,
-0.0146393701,
-0.048098892,
0.0027549854,
-0.0406248979,
-0.0110903885,
0.056749545,
0.0412589237,
-0.0095856646,
0.0016482315,
-0.0243481621,
-0.0223562457,
0.0560620315,
-0.0672329664,
-0.0531375371,
0.0272858925,
0.042546045,
-0.0205939617,
0.0128707737,
0.0053498587,
-0.0013418674,
0.0125540178,
0.0020748125,
0.0681400672,
-0.0048099947,
-0.068265833,
-0.0032987085,
0.022798134,
0.029886201,
-0.0723899305,
0.0099869194,
-0.0625617802,
-0.0216444973,
-0.0330225714,
0.0128896581,
-0.0284707379,
0.0235364456,
-0.0643510446,
-0.0093309432,
0.0140016433,
0.0125200972,
0.0057627074,
0.0052425102,
-0.0262902807,
-0.0050612013,
0.0187112577,
-0.0808417499,
-0.0600275397,
-0.0477642119,
0.0198085811,
-0.0142795853,
-0.0278490204,
0.0099220546,
2.003089669e-34,
0.0234706905,
-0.0001935403,
0.0447526351,
0.0583068989,
0.0407083035,
0.0288834106,
0.0107806725,
0.0260218121,
0.0794660076,
-0.0857057795,
-0.0084144659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09814v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09814v1 | Investigating the Utility of Surprisal from Large Language Models for Speech Synthesis Prosody | 2023-06-16T12:49:44 | 2023-06-16T12:49:44 | Sofoklis Kakouros, Juraj Šimko, Martti Vainio, Antti Suni | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | This paper investigates the use of word surprisal, a measure of the
predictability of a word in a given context, as a feature to aid speech
synthesis prosody. We explore how word surprisal extracted from large language
models (LLMs) correlates with word prominence, a signal-based measure of the
salience of a word in a given discourse. We also examine how context length and
LLM size affect the results, and how a speech synthesizer conditioned with
surprisal values compares with a baseline system. To evaluate these factors, we
conducted experiments using a large corpus of English text and LLMs of varying
sizes. Our results show that word surprisal and word prominence are moderately
correlated, suggesting that they capture related but distinct aspects of
language use. We find that length of context and size of the LLM impact the
correlations, but not in the direction anticipated, with longer contexts and
larger LLMs generally underpredicting prominent words in a nearly linear
manner. We demonstrate that, in line with these findings, a speech synthesizer
conditioned with surprisal values provides a minimal improvement over the
baseline with the results suggesting a limited effect of using surprisal values
for eliciting appropriate prominence patterns. | [
-0.0066856537,
0.0364489183,
-0.0078967549,
-0.0613525435,
-0.0330155753,
-0.0333082303,
0.0124563053,
-0.0041909483,
-0.0438890085,
-0.0139570767,
-0.0151643837,
-0.0421174131,
0.0344581157,
0.0137205152,
0.0683955178,
-0.0786089674,
0.0369497128,
-0.0426036157,
0.007401655,
-0.011485084,
0.0100931004,
0.0113061881,
0.0076508843,
0.0551370643,
-0.0306606721,
0.0153788561,
-0.0052471454,
0.0269373748,
0.0158397537,
-0.0126594463,
-0.027223317,
0.037953686,
0.0107114194,
-0.0252424646,
0.0000020299,
-0.071797967,
0.0251596421,
0.0009344753,
0.0137150809,
0.0388107821,
0.0808271691,
0.0515329167,
-0.060974516,
0.0234782752,
-0.0395929851,
0.0503325127,
0.0415340513,
-0.0029757302,
-0.0396694727,
0.0131667014,
-0.013706171,
-0.0241758954,
0.0135007808,
-0.0092778355,
-0.0176785067,
0.0288288016,
0.0006833072,
-0.0245442539,
0.0351545997,
-0.0145351393,
-0.0126530193,
0.0534977578,
-0.0326342657,
-0.0144184427,
0.025074346,
-0.004811238,
-0.0154701779,
-0.0299341939,
0.0040137698,
0.02921349,
-0.0103318729,
-0.0104716942,
0.0193354022,
0.0158605725,
0.0120131271,
0.0187080428,
-0.0106524797,
-0.0040943967,
0.0274818577,
-0.0022491841,
0.0609540083,
0.0125828125,
-0.0121937012,
-0.0323078297,
0.0065981047,
0.0339375883,
0.0405798145,
-0.042187456,
0.0020516969,
-0.0496039391,
-0.0866470337,
-0.0396446101,
0.0451496392,
0.0030476851,
-0.0290194042,
0.0420057811,
-0.0147282593,
-0.0331245586,
0.0053908234,
-0.0586444326,
0.0150007438,
-0.0019546552,
0.0005178616,
-0.0340399779,
-0.0185752381,
0.0376721844,
-0.0230235569,
-0.0241260286,
-0.0645143315,
0.0159502514,
0.0052125016,
0.0005955077,
-0.031764973,
0.0233124029,
-0.0377321951,
-0.0348878205,
-0.0548962466,
0.0139734456,
-0.0163109209,
-0.0207670461,
0.0045133531,
0.0351062268,
-0.030004466,
-0.0036963359,
0.0325980112,
-0.0057413224,
-0.0269761104,
0.0531752221,
-0.0150724389,
-0.0611714758,
0.0370769128,
0.0011149414,
0.0295058247,
0.0206547286,
-0.0004545472,
0.0296136383,
0.010533805,
-0.0085874433,
-0.0318371914,
-0.0434851237,
-0.0488301776,
-0.009635522,
-0.0629094988,
-0.0620202012,
-0.0436817631,
-0.0031738742,
-0.0115519604,
-0.023249194,
-0.0195332356,
0.0147256618,
-0.0071772402,
0.0079181874,
-0.0061441422,
0.0789395124,
-0.0045647444,
-0.0196446683,
0.0069281487,
0.0327483639,
0.0593562014,
0.0199246481,
-0.0035592623,
-0.0388064273,
0.0045005474,
0.0366812497,
-0.0196808092,
0.0132447882,
-0.0648847669,
-0.0565104149,
-0.0099872798,
-0.001034967,
0.072809428,
0.0454767756,
0.0137754371,
0.0140768019,
0.0965847671,
0.0460640378,
0.0311462581,
0.0228504296,
0.0542502627,
0.0367865451,
-0.0065774913,
0.0249229427,
0.006881488,
-0.0102321059,
-0.0602697805,
0.0332718305,
0.0388904139,
0.020137351,
-0.0099883266,
-0.0277279261,
-0.0126469536,
0.009635943,
-0.0127251223,
0.0169925801,
0.015903797,
0.0350229405,
-0.0855801925,
0.024891533,
0.0371365286,
-0.0743032992,
0.0173084866,
-0.0004934552,
0.0080030151,
0.0754561573,
0.0269020982,
-0.0006922702,
0.0539395772,
-0.0175235868,
-0.0380356759,
0.0724254921,
-0.0293892566,
-0.0275681801,
0.0191781707,
-0.0328531675,
0.0511612222,
0.0364153422,
0.0120674791,
0.0306824353,
-0.0118570225,
0.0387756526,
0.0155835245,
-0.0089524956,
0.0195435435,
-0.0014789067,
-0.0569140911,
-0.0573297814,
-0.0316575095,
-0.0219556782,
0.0294477437,
0.0165594853,
-0.0500065573,
0.0572178848,
0.002248954,
-0.0269757025,
0.0027681726,
0.0389118195,
-0.0640380979,
0.0210936368,
0.0222985707,
-0.0268232804,
0.0461534373,
-0.0080539444,
0.0545753054,
-0.0552695468,
0.0752918348,
-0.0462022461,
0.0777693391,
-0.0399347544,
0.0480032973,
-0.0243845824,
0.0471860915,
-0.0293694325,
-0.0185644384,
0.0015447026,
-0.0025794951,
0.0663707703,
0.0307115391,
-0.0172752254,
-0.0482114106,
0.0001704606,
0.0170405544,
-0.0220112912,
0.0307915658,
0.0169544592,
-0.059659224,
-0.0464427546,
-0.0616103671,
-0.0769907609,
-0.0132913478,
-0.0048787273,
0.003200758,
0.032015536,
-0.0094877761,
-0.0284302458,
0.0390701033,
-0.0128217768,
-0.1149423718,
-0.0213209894,
0.0143451653,
-0.0304043721,
-0.0289539862,
-0.0365816951,
-0.0531750321,
-0.0058645299,
0.0169091858,
-0.0106691597,
0.0097809443,
0.0013180845,
-0.0405640267,
0.051287014,
0.0046558031,
-0.0119380504,
0.0236770008,
-0.052946344,
0.0001658042,
-0.0064642159,
0.1195246726,
0.013326914,
0.0266076103,
-0.0066784611,
0.0445730612,
-0.0330080055,
-0.0104919355,
-0.0263905544,
-0.0594421998,
0.0240659378,
-0.0246770624,
-0.0607927032,
0.0087631466,
0.0286936611,
0.0763827711,
0.0101677645,
-0.0475631692,
0.0194484703,
-0.0169525165,
-0.0560667366,
0.0372457094,
-0.0077351439,
-0.0701027066,
0.0350256264,
0.0085172234,
-0.0437951423,
0.0161527116,
-0.0301971082,
-0.0213328283,
-0.0066131009,
-0.0304524619,
0.0199840534,
-0.0448899306,
-0.043965999,
0.0097229164,
-0.0174301676,
-0.033941742,
-0.0295212101,
-0.0158435367,
0.0005613206,
-0.0651804358,
0.0294284951,
-0.0349910073,
-0.0382551402,
0.0236074105,
-0.0051621348,
-0.0267617069,
-0.0391002037,
-0.0131018506,
0.0273753405,
0.0540700331,
0.0010921898,
0.0559918508,
0.0025168627,
0.0043680645,
-0.0044200909,
-0.0125002731,
0.0143549563,
-0.0105288839,
-0.0062964312,
0.0501746051,
0.0228311028,
0.0084266942,
-0.0104876729,
0.0145014282,
-0.0499699749,
0.0226483159,
0.0448537245,
-0.0378911942,
0.0190110337,
0.0352643244,
-0.0117826462,
-0.0211041588,
0.0599433519,
0.0637811869,
-0.0070638545,
0.0403132737,
0.092501834,
-0.0080086486,
0.0356454551,
0.036603108,
-0.0106880609,
0.0837585852,
0.0122311721,
0.0119542358,
-0.0024242338,
0.0190563388,
0.0401411802,
0.0260421541,
-0.0445156619,
0.0110512953,
-0.0543776192,
-0.0864593908,
0.0826079994,
0.0195609499,
-0.0238575283,
-0.0132025704,
-0.0270712301,
-0.0018229417,
0.0351566523,
0.0078289229,
0.044886142,
-0.0510421507,
-0.0135140764,
0.0356457829,
-0.0793608353,
-0.0278117172,
-0.0020760372,
-0.0287281964,
0.0454505645,
0.0277196597,
0.0397318229,
-0.0235832576,
-0.0576902591,
-0.0114543922,
-0.0358034372,
0.014362826,
-0.001692515,
-0.0013311432,
0.0505529642,
-0.012543086,
-0.0641733855,
0.0408242419,
0.0235236101,
-0.0007738926,
-0.0127772987,
0.0466175526,
-0.0063677244,
-0.0167708043,
-0.0402967855,
0.0598928034,
0.0129955895,
0.0261351466,
0.0696344897,
-0.0704709142,
-0.0129006505,
0.0215104148,
-0.0030469794,
-0.0012669245,
-0.0325168371,
0.0077105104,
-0.0134301996,
-0.0217061304,
-0.1028714553,
0.0141614657,
-0.0038154824,
0.0629993752,
0.0348668285,
0.0388062149,
-0.0246646665,
-0.0227802601,
-0.0355632827,
0.0045733871,
0.0343941115,
0.0350129791,
-0.0534146875,
-0.0373125784,
0.0276530702,
-0.0692539066,
-0.006419776,
-0.0351502784,
0.0065610884,
-0.0785707235,
0.0571675524,
-0.0166129023,
0.0315394774,
0.0098772561,
0.0065642879,
-0.0653182566,
0.0659945309,
0.0317329802,
0.0320531763,
0.0622994192,
0.0522264428,
-0.0054754624,
0.0025607892,
0.0178744178,
-0.0089926692,
0.0670945048,
-0.0176847335,
0.0243068915,
0.0352512896,
-0.0604372472,
-0.0045435843,
0.0313516408,
0.0113507854,
-0.0260638166,
0.0331574604,
-0.045554582,
-0.0491066426,
-0.0186703987,
0.0420536473,
-0.024803482,
0.0249206629,
0.0133574819,
0.0233813394,
-0.0238690265,
-0.0075299996,
-0.0903142542,
-0.0217866059,
0.0290845986,
0.0156908911,
-0.0276430212,
0.0026323458,
0.0302588139,
0.03950442,
-0.0238907896,
0.0378975421,
-0.0508965477,
0.0344792791,
0.0266483855,
-0.0052810041,
-0.0221969038,
-0.006886173,
-0.0240941606,
0.026505366,
-0.0276134387,
-0.0190428309,
0.0032023152,
0.0219802018,
0.0505151562,
-0.0155285662,
0.088046968,
-0.0389404446,
0.042925179,
-0.0268700644,
0.0189076234,
-0.0085137337,
0.0124641322,
-0.0113790557,
0.0054870378,
-0.0343813151,
0.0082761981,
0.0353537612,
-0.0062081795,
-0.0146774203,
-0.0026395712,
0.0143433074,
-0.0031499623,
-0.028463427,
0.0007926049,
0.0146506866,
-0.0193153638,
0.0073186792,
-0.0982599482,
-0.046871502,
0.0146816727,
-0.0101163713,
0.0061946735,
-0.066096209,
0.0414662771,
-0.0214443058,
-0.0606882982,
0.0161482524,
-0.0342028923,
-0.0134471897,
-0.0097557101,
0.0035098786,
0.0274748839,
-6.371361583e-33,
-0.0300669782,
-0.0064086937,
-0.003268949,
0.0272901691,
-0.0452266075,
-0.018352095,
-0.0525310338,
0.0257005729,
-0.0141580859,
0.0263481382,
-0.025841102,
-0.0485576056,
0.0245740972,
-0.0205763523,
-0.0014149921,
0.0212651528,
0.043271374,
0.0406345353,
0.0127709918,
0.0071917702,
0.0375916176,
0.0075773085,
0.0510796495,
-0.082244657,
0.0068924441,
-0.0082154647,
-0.021178294,
-0.0522056669,
0.0379776657,
-0.0006015262,
-0.0052624545,
0.0782822743,
-0.0080633909,
-0.0466472283,
-0.0624671914,
0.0532675982,
0.0055714012,
-0.034842398,
0.0763895586,
-0.0112355035,
-0.0195702147,
-0.0364230685,
0.0339264087,
0.0009026806,
-0.0761481151,
0.0350841582,
0.0244138986,
-0.0229212455,
-0.0461619906,
-0.0480065867,
-0.0825889185,
0.019989701,
0.0092249317,
-0.0259336568,
0.0382423773,
0.0307255555,
-0.003841623,
0.0062365551,
0.0531398244,
0.0465795808,
0.0285504535,
0.0486721583,
0.0298657361,
0.0582166761,
0.0234671533,
0.0442654602,
0.0646299198,
-0.0049053654,
0.0701198429,
-0.0182456505,
0.0580344982,
0.0615709759,
0.0433561206,
0.059438929,
0.0740165412,
-0.042438779,
0.0526058413,
-0.029851947,
0.0154042188,
-0.0654645935,
0.0475232527,
0.0186352171,
-0.015119114,
-0.0488489792,
-0.066316016,
0.0047972878,
-0.004906245,
-0.0217146091,
0.027630182,
-0.0252081603,
0.0344442725,
0.0110292556,
0.0264025461,
-0.0023429857,
0.0115958145,
0.0066115237,
-0.0775727481,
0.026663037,
0.0057567144,
-0.0264183041,
-0.0152789215,
0.0060431683,
0.061785318,
0.0334840864,
0.0181989484,
0.0133210029,
-0.0745557845,
0.03992071,
-0.0530504994,
-0.0005307001,
-0.0124122426,
0.0071615796,
0.0078028655,
-0.0712674558,
0.0283391867,
0.0008539797,
-0.0185666066,
0.0215899143,
0.0067785489,
0.0149660176,
0.0191568621,
0.0055993991,
-0.0057731615,
0.0427281111,
-0.0587776303,
-0.0020978306,
-0.0073851352,
0.0463192165,
0.0584012233,
-0.0196845736,
-0.0450863019,
0.0025093297,
2.956e-7,
-0.0095174853,
0.04483952,
0.0236596707,
-0.0165226143,
0.0358115807,
-0.0016286431,
-0.002056862,
0.0058084698,
0.0523090996,
-0.0127971619,
-0.0108128777,
-0.0346088335,
0.0766406581,
-0.0048518125,
-0.0914457366,
-0.0415670909,
-0.0782476813,
0.0406429209,
-0.0565295368,
0.0211807173,
0.0267370325,
0.0308458973,
-0.0161278974,
-0.035803657,
0.002117163,
0.0249903314,
0.001878581,
-0.0396166742,
-0.0124365119,
-0.0086573297,
0.0142218778,
-0.0070071644,
0.0039845766,
0.0097673722,
-0.0335153639,
0.0231438,
0.022320943,
0.0701489225,
-0.0140609918,
-0.0300025325,
0.0235255025,
-0.0024751849,
-0.047848586,
-0.0265774727,
0.0133462846,
0.0106023671,
0.0010637814,
-0.0411784537,
-0.0327913389,
0.0015681867,
-0.005206727,
-0.0233479198,
-0.0050957277,
0.0255484451,
0.0035025878,
-0.0019129767,
-0.0293427855,
-0.0161657482,
-0.0390907228,
0.0518657379,
-0.0518358685,
-0.057562355,
0.005480607,
-0.0109435953,
0.0151600074,
-0.0621998385,
0.0011345109,
2.58485468e-34,
0.064564757,
-0.0019371998,
0.0610549748,
0.0008491487,
0.0122791883,
-0.0048003145,
0.0342774838,
0.0392140895,
0.0667552277,
-0.055950243,
-0.0384786092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09802v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09802v2 | RED$^{\rm FM}$: a Filtered and Multilingual Relation Extraction Dataset | 2023-06-16T12:29:59 | 2023-06-19T09:25:27 | Pere-Lluís Huguet Cabot, Simone Tedeschi, Axel-Cyrille Ngonga Ngomo, Roberto Navigli | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relation Extraction (RE) is a task that identifies relationships between
entities in a text, enabling the acquisition of relational facts and bridging
the gap between natural language and structured knowledge. However, current RE
models often rely on small datasets with low coverage of relation types,
particularly when working with languages other than English. In this paper, we
address the above issue and provide two new resources that enable the training
and evaluation of multilingual RE systems. First, we present SRED$^{\rm FM}$,
an automatically annotated dataset covering 18 languages, 400 relation types,
13 entity types, totaling more than 40 million triplet instances. Second, we
propose RED$^{\rm FM}$, a smaller, human-revised dataset for seven languages
that allows for the evaluation of multilingual RE systems. To demonstrate the
utility of these novel datasets, we experiment with the first end-to-end
multilingual RE model, mREBEL, that extracts triplets, including entity types,
in multiple languages. We release our resources and model checkpoints at
https://www.github.com/babelscape/rebel | [
0.0286719017,
0.0655237511,
0.0180553813,
0.1158085912,
-0.0087440163,
0.0226528663,
-0.015062727,
0.0002883606,
0.0250910018,
-0.0016737103,
-0.0355547853,
-0.0149792349,
-0.0327940248,
-0.0126610128,
0.0084694754,
-0.0544881634,
0.0401393361,
-0.0036047786,
0.0149613982,
0.0212726165,
0.0013970569,
0.0466712601,
-0.0065996568,
-0.0350672714,
-0.0399988107,
-0.0021957897,
0.02997436,
-0.0374959223,
0.0483360589,
-0.0381625667,
0.0177210364,
0.0432760082,
0.0027930322,
0.0032746647,
0.0000018624,
-0.0568662733,
-0.03394638,
0.0059395018,
-0.0192955825,
-0.0322463997,
-0.018854307,
-0.0490088873,
0.0118944608,
-0.0259185042,
-0.0585123971,
-0.0417053737,
0.0193774793,
0.0449477062,
0.002248863,
0.0455676503,
-0.0323812924,
-0.0478770025,
0.018950507,
-0.0400211513,
0.0019354918,
0.0013779377,
0.0272120405,
0.0217720903,
-0.0152095845,
0.0058668489,
0.0045435759,
0.0219668001,
0.0403555296,
0.0079264129,
-0.0103177633,
0.0267082956,
-0.0530237481,
-0.0345115066,
0.004857718,
0.0976961777,
0.0191168133,
0.0315821469,
0.0179735366,
0.0330236554,
-0.0121849366,
-0.0115150064,
0.0290024448,
-0.0046648928,
-0.0511338823,
0.0137604764,
0.0182059817,
-0.0164179038,
0.0509802252,
0.0064527905,
-0.0150192278,
0.0229045544,
-0.009044772,
-0.0400316902,
0.0513422266,
0.0349090211,
0.013366661,
-0.0156272929,
0.017639393,
-0.0033821005,
0.0068120277,
0.0430631042,
-0.0182883572,
-0.0139974151,
-0.0138034755,
-0.0430494063,
-0.0643687695,
-0.0103491554,
-0.0360890739,
0.058492437,
-0.0400428325,
-0.0104861939,
-0.0222155675,
0.0086861765,
0.0271530915,
-0.0072887652,
-0.0133748399,
0.0295808353,
-0.0122769913,
0.0413461737,
-0.0274084825,
0.040249072,
-0.0396984406,
-0.0314162187,
-0.016882427,
0.0375521444,
0.0195079353,
-0.0160789359,
-0.0140604479,
-0.0206513908,
-0.0181032047,
0.0255364608,
-0.0500359721,
-0.0202277973,
-0.0441736914,
-0.051348526,
-0.0085623749,
-0.037746869,
0.0345108062,
-0.0665345266,
0.0117227538,
0.1004360095,
-0.0086203376,
-0.0521639399,
-0.0262528472,
-0.0385994688,
0.0525807515,
-0.0704525858,
0.0206554607,
-0.0411462821,
0.0772356242,
0.0095089516,
0.0019391112,
-0.0394817516,
0.0532656945,
-0.036214225,
-0.0703826323,
0.0520735271,
-0.0333170779,
-0.0186227355,
-0.0521120578,
0.0130672939,
0.0154338321,
0.0738896802,
0.0385970511,
-0.0274242349,
0.0801694393,
0.0092701148,
-0.0244458858,
0.0700487196,
0.0149502838,
-0.004737176,
0.0155581441,
0.0145460302,
-0.0091474559,
-0.0082184337,
0.0373504199,
0.0310694724,
-0.0345201939,
-0.0476837419,
0.0063172202,
-0.0171538983,
0.0115387384,
0.0681795105,
0.0494448505,
-0.0334963538,
0.038131807,
0.0288389288,
-0.0403168611,
0.0033956512,
0.0115654115,
0.01450139,
-0.0604330525,
0.0692254826,
0.0150411529,
-0.0051655043,
0.0143597769,
0.0019307167,
-0.0310631376,
0.0050526895,
0.0993649289,
0.0312912352,
-0.0169900544,
0.0426362418,
0.05906149,
-0.0385688767,
0.00482861,
0.0390396155,
0.0100233518,
0.0173230246,
0.0352557227,
-0.0624889769,
-0.031445682,
-0.0183516387,
-0.0280256402,
0.0260475613,
0.0329894871,
-0.0353541896,
0.0617787242,
-0.0266665556,
-0.0272524003,
0.0415144227,
-0.0035224571,
0.0147940246,
0.0545399077,
0.0365004689,
-0.008269161,
-0.0132319964,
0.0169853792,
0.0359470919,
-0.0447958559,
-0.0213166773,
0.0035472689,
0.0466927551,
0.0078443447,
0.053349901,
-0.0156550631,
-0.0355959423,
0.0435112715,
-0.047689423,
0.0371153317,
0.0330101363,
-0.0066119879,
-0.0284557007,
0.0321424752,
0.0030146204,
-0.0706968606,
-0.0231634006,
-0.0228897855,
0.0103051281,
-0.0163273122,
0.0434802212,
0.04500027,
-0.0005030694,
-0.0169909745,
0.0262875911,
0.0318994522,
0.0143425828,
0.0852476954,
-0.0073181866,
-0.0212456863,
0.0219901744,
-0.1049240828,
-0.001282239,
0.0211804733,
-0.0079429727,
0.041661378,
-0.0184304193,
-0.0343467519,
0.0141072292,
0.0565865636,
-0.0512843579,
0.0143641587,
-0.0149025014,
0.0234855432,
0.0155323837,
0.0779631138,
-0.0036927504,
0.0359829664,
-0.0177801028,
-0.0123425983,
-0.008611463,
0.0001768475,
-0.0263794065,
-0.015122612,
0.0541410409,
0.0089471405,
-0.0032415024,
-0.0273731947,
-0.0216324963,
-0.0279868692,
0.0484672002,
0.0120427115,
-0.0379808657,
0.0227431431,
0.0374744423,
-0.0461462773,
0.0476258025,
0.0060632736,
-0.0134700369,
-0.0445489325,
-0.0072841793,
0.0404508486,
0.0158338323,
-0.0428566225,
0.0543545857,
-0.010937918,
-0.0163682476,
-0.0309445802,
0.0516205207,
-0.0107287597,
0.0362711661,
-0.018250443,
-0.0098423716,
-0.0439703502,
0.0345008038,
-0.0175721906,
0.0086113149,
0.0119839218,
0.009035592,
0.0243211258,
0.0131199434,
-0.0163211618,
0.0653939918,
0.013029376,
0.0173941571,
-0.0640605986,
0.0244415887,
0.0723981485,
0.0099546593,
-0.0218278617,
-0.0021339557,
0.0172453951,
-0.0491217971,
0.0554714054,
-0.0185242631,
0.0079263756,
-0.0049660332,
-0.0266296528,
-0.033690773,
-0.0326229967,
0.0338359699,
-0.0043534092,
0.031370163,
-0.0514218509,
-0.0015612664,
-0.0235934276,
-0.0379417688,
-0.0369593278,
0.0139080733,
-0.0464948118,
-0.0029657767,
-0.0345803089,
-0.0070963609,
-0.0043915291,
-0.0208159108,
0.046424102,
0.0202478413,
-0.0024906262,
-0.0135655338,
0.0030652946,
0.0700996518,
0.0402561016,
-0.0153016839,
0.0095267519,
-0.0050402465,
0.0356633961,
0.0305430125,
-0.0257916488,
-0.0421778858,
0.0076203081,
0.0290506221,
0.0016636854,
-0.0306009594,
0.0064071137,
-0.0405735634,
0.0212961361,
-0.0827021077,
-0.0148232449,
0.0648189485,
-0.0002858698,
-0.0261235498,
0.0019006658,
0.0204052739,
0.0228206888,
0.0364021249,
0.018095443,
-0.107002601,
-0.0233788025,
-0.0210216865,
-0.0527769662,
0.0131703978,
-0.0645900592,
-0.0054951389,
-0.1035718396,
-0.0078723012,
-0.0204144064,
-0.08140295,
-0.021941958,
-0.0289390031,
-0.0036542248,
-0.050184913,
-0.021835234,
-0.0190811623,
-0.030097995,
0.0043353708,
-0.0162253957,
0.0020091403,
-0.0417390168,
0.0358152278,
-0.0500237569,
-0.0113455234,
0.0094804941,
0.0478326567,
-0.0284570586,
0.0212756433,
0.0053893379,
0.0147078633,
-0.0586823151,
-0.0290087592,
0.0541279837,
-0.0252056271,
-0.0405418947,
-0.0312679261,
0.0084400447,
-0.0615429915,
0.0195966642,
0.0217715539,
0.076106973,
0.051750049,
-0.0167490765,
0.014869947,
-0.0302090645,
-0.011380014,
0.0391322523,
-0.0169751309,
-0.0022500863,
-0.0133240018,
-0.0050267065,
0.0116274916,
-0.0735733584,
-0.0073012561,
0.0051650023,
-0.0787129775,
-0.0170585457,
-0.0492646657,
-0.0811359361,
0.0428428315,
-0.0002553057,
0.0217605978,
0.0038821825,
0.0564076491,
0.0261619482,
-0.0630648807,
0.0152324485,
-0.0178758241,
0.000866172,
0.0051247054,
0.0075546871,
-0.0172626916,
-0.0335514992,
-0.0304174293,
-0.0442557931,
-0.0468433946,
-0.0237886179,
-0.0294744503,
0.0465008281,
0.011263839,
0.0700258985,
-0.0064367964,
0.0149314906,
-0.0425193794,
0.053191904,
-0.0694314539,
-0.0484099388,
0.0258053187,
-0.0095021483,
0.0037315616,
0.0416632332,
-0.0272567477,
0.0067650154,
0.0092232097,
0.0254496466,
-0.0414705053,
-0.0149661386,
0.0129549047,
0.0174997468,
0.037928097,
0.0094679603,
-0.0081269732,
-0.0751133114,
0.0109942136,
-0.0758996233,
-0.019863978,
-0.0323337726,
0.0603634827,
0.0093441578,
0.0162154622,
-0.025754489,
-0.0383319296,
0.0211145487,
0.00999704,
0.0237093698,
0.0029921024,
0.0539148338,
0.0017923616,
0.0161492452,
-0.0249110535,
0.0092341732,
0.0391547121,
0.0112079261,
0.0275493339,
-0.0458137244,
0.0263029467,
-0.0038190049,
-0.0339659266,
0.0396277718,
-0.0069549959,
0.0176413823,
0.0590297021,
-0.0273962412,
0.0352060422,
0.0786572471,
-0.0309149958,
0.0676825419,
-0.0243390352,
-0.0031433497,
0.029610388,
0.0511170551,
-0.0546505041,
0.0183494054,
0.0096531687,
0.0238275714,
-0.0340272225,
0.0174154472,
0.0590009987,
-0.028646972,
0.0520599484,
0.0444989875,
-0.0320327356,
-0.0308728702,
-0.0183246285,
-0.007402665,
-0.0275527425,
-0.0129493028,
0.010094407,
-0.0700828731,
-0.0609470308,
-0.020253228,
-0.007244674,
-0.0333274826,
0.0162875038,
-0.0187771525,
0.0354720019,
0.0363076888,
-0.0512730256,
-0.0486898646,
0.0118364934,
-0.0619541593,
-0.0248016845,
0.0000355829,
-5.782886703e-33,
-0.0330748297,
-0.032770168,
0.0361668989,
-0.0157467369,
-0.0345298089,
0.0452783257,
-0.0203095265,
-0.0165546872,
-0.0389860757,
0.0562322289,
-0.01164864,
-0.0090227071,
0.0182740651,
0.0068910192,
0.0084051611,
-0.0061249011,
0.0032375748,
0.007704468,
0.031910304,
0.0075116362,
0.0447824709,
0.0554549396,
0.1214687079,
-0.0862206966,
0.0119308336,
0.0045087263,
-0.0093459561,
0.0293653179,
0.0240460336,
0.0464366153,
-0.0446267314,
0.0088415779,
0.0188853256,
-0.0196268894,
0.033411283,
-0.0207047481,
-0.1751967669,
-0.0222830363,
-0.0143395448,
0.0287555233,
-0.0447852127,
-0.0082750758,
0.001204064,
0.0069117183,
0.0689884126,
-0.0290795043,
0.0374184549,
-0.0384591594,
0.0035041296,
-0.0429771096,
-0.0566807985,
0.042260386,
0.0175380092,
0.0089602936,
0.0604609251,
0.0306755472,
0.016693633,
-0.0289193261,
-0.0350615978,
-0.0390571877,
-0.0401093811,
-0.0138895027,
0.0297092237,
-0.0199820008,
0.0003514972,
0.0321663581,
-0.0156236496,
-0.0102302646,
-0.0011493727,
0.0308936089,
0.0097407745,
0.0709995627,
-0.0328048952,
0.0732743442,
0.0098861167,
0.0136530753,
-0.0911323875,
0.0016709373,
0.0398417301,
0.045524653,
-0.0586012192,
-0.0408006683,
-0.0203620158,
0.0198348947,
0.014305803,
-0.0194339603,
-0.0085280025,
-0.0369516052,
0.0058725183,
-0.009720996,
-0.0034231276,
0.0411457084,
-0.0107065532,
-0.0149422549,
-0.059392225,
0.0396088213,
-0.0138496794,
-0.0064126155,
0.0071357,
0.0173136648,
-0.0452326871,
-0.0367209837,
-0.0319238827,
-0.0002755543,
0.0379305668,
0.0388836265,
0.0685251877,
-0.0337986834,
-0.0454376712,
-0.0138612008,
-0.0539510846,
0.0372109488,
-0.022700144,
0.0562298149,
0.0006956743,
0.0316553265,
-0.0092551261,
0.0470450297,
0.0786949545,
0.0155477924,
-0.0274465587,
0.0568141416,
0.0083827851,
0.039566014,
0.0404633731,
-0.0344687477,
-0.0331629999,
-0.0136253089,
0.020955516,
-0.0397310555,
-0.0040879967,
-0.0132304076,
2.46e-7,
0.0203037076,
0.0092463633,
0.058522325,
0.0475496128,
-0.0052201147,
0.0410091057,
0.0135208117,
0.0343838632,
-0.0223134849,
-0.0043044607,
-0.0039788992,
-0.0081801107,
0.026271062,
0.0745358616,
-0.063828446,
-0.0476571545,
-0.0636653826,
-0.074180074,
-0.0636976212,
-0.0401410349,
0.0497614816,
0.0481346846,
0.0537762903,
0.0051151128,
-0.080694817,
-0.0052898098,
0.0380309261,
-0.030900484,
-0.0072765849,
0.0333236158,
0.0153969415,
0.0234056599,
-0.015136037,
0.0310144853,
-0.030568257,
0.0250085201,
0.0232735276,
0.0521133207,
-0.0025918153,
0.0235155821,
0.0247866139,
-0.0236528665,
-0.0148316957,
-0.0153834857,
0.0458640195,
-0.009262546,
0.0094883638,
0.0219688397,
0.0028955368,
0.0049342993,
0.0137185752,
-0.0038996101,
-0.0015488996,
0.0502643213,
0.0335157439,
-0.0343013704,
-0.053475108,
-0.037515156,
-0.0021783765,
0.0584897213,
0.0281002093,
0.0101063913,
0.0204138681,
-0.0424852781,
-0.0567695871,
-0.010855983,
0.0038089366,
1.920728267e-34,
-0.0342834108,
-0.0007255063,
-0.0013306825,
0.0343499258,
0.053098619,
-0.0669303909,
-0.0541057959,
-0.0001304533,
-0.0198573545,
0.0055073649,
0.0312213916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09782v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09782v2 | Full Parameter Fine-tuning for Large Language Models with Limited Resources | 2023-06-16T11:37:15 | 2024-06-06T13:22:26 | Kai Lv, Yuqing Yang, Tengxiao Liu, Qinghui Gao, Qipeng Guo, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized Natural Language Processing
(NLP) but demand massive GPU resources for training. Lowering the threshold for
LLMs training would encourage greater participation from researchers,
benefiting both academia and society. While existing approaches have focused on
parameter-efficient fine-tuning, which tunes or adds a small number of
parameters, few have addressed the challenge of tuning the full parameters of
LLMs with limited resources. In this work, we propose a new optimizer,
LOw-Memory Optimization (LOMO), which fuses the gradient computation and the
parameter update in one step to reduce memory usage. By integrating LOMO with
existing memory saving techniques, we reduce memory usage to 10.8% compared to
the standard approach (DeepSpeed solution). Consequently, our approach enables
the full parameter fine-tuning of a 65B model on a single machine with 8 RTX
3090, each with 24GB memory.Code and data are available at
https://github.com/OpenLMLab/LOMO. | [
0.0439976156,
0.08466997,
0.0064035025,
0.0588109456,
-0.0057538506,
0.0104321437,
-0.0276330709,
-0.001513583,
-0.0341107324,
-0.0580093861,
-0.0471978746,
-0.0198852234,
0.0068417806,
-0.0012865632,
0.0240069143,
-0.0617390722,
0.0479720309,
-0.0374781787,
-0.0090483865,
-0.0150234429,
0.0015609747,
0.0246828776,
0.0100182779,
0.0000030326,
0.0282394625,
-0.013801272,
-0.0103073232,
0.0086128619,
0.0160964578,
0.0146884192,
0.0207749791,
0.0280644652,
0.0130991852,
0.0393844582,
0.0000022338,
-0.0464676321,
-0.0145026501,
-0.0190251116,
-0.0265630912,
0.0491518714,
0.0702654123,
-0.0128598334,
-0.0150939412,
0.0220079776,
-0.01737931,
-0.0273119379,
0.0319306068,
0.0016172817,
0.050593432,
0.0902137011,
-0.0016049357,
-0.0384662673,
0.0422236137,
-0.0356147699,
-0.0089951362,
-0.0563337542,
0.0112705948,
-0.0306623392,
-0.0104214801,
-0.020021366,
-0.0386895612,
0.0383442454,
-0.0105902757,
0.0154904658,
-0.0121788103,
0.0132425707,
-0.015596088,
-0.0489366055,
-0.0040936442,
0.0498374663,
-0.0914599523,
-0.0158717837,
0.0200685617,
-0.0220459867,
-0.0269949026,
-0.0425545014,
-0.0177414007,
0.0439968705,
0.0298265405,
0.0005321053,
0.0259235539,
-0.0662351027,
0.0498099588,
0.0332582965,
-0.0138810519,
0.0165679473,
0.031336803,
0.0233172271,
-0.0194472633,
-0.0341616198,
-0.0422727615,
-0.0410219803,
-0.0322854444,
0.0307937376,
-0.0371920243,
0.0046616057,
-0.0575627908,
-0.0406057425,
0.030912159,
-0.0356854722,
0.082151033,
0.0300071761,
0.0379536115,
0.0498592295,
-0.0230620708,
-0.007761579,
-0.0348821096,
-0.0147063788,
-0.029530542,
-0.0063293553,
-0.0002297472,
0.0074755452,
-0.0357276946,
0.0069432948,
-0.0538362823,
-0.0072242715,
-0.0077082259,
0.0099342698,
0.0032910691,
-0.025435036,
0.0040321173,
0.0246574767,
-0.0117585007,
0.0007303397,
0.0024477153,
0.0364030525,
-0.046591308,
0.0035536643,
-0.0306402482,
-0.061220143,
-0.0112227686,
0.0231586304,
0.0350923017,
-0.0226799175,
0.0491618179,
0.0463270098,
0.0108111091,
-0.0548546426,
-0.0649080426,
-0.0111876484,
0.0104425726,
-0.0878874138,
0.0000586988,
-0.0702943802,
0.0283379368,
-0.0165027585,
0.0416677445,
-0.0251801517,
0.0192789119,
0.0197390374,
-0.0368140377,
0.0608107671,
-0.0161041133,
-0.0056132195,
0.0357600525,
-0.0070163184,
0.0451094285,
0.0824014544,
0.0480436049,
0.0331190117,
0.0257087275,
-0.0198767055,
-0.0371571556,
0.0273987409,
0.016385464,
0.0430561826,
-0.011079411,
0.0002134628,
0.0287395138,
0.0623476803,
0.0755423605,
0.0328373089,
-0.0271974374,
-0.0346076004,
0.0484979525,
0.0274145901,
0.0136279091,
0.0424056426,
0.0006699081,
0.0071032252,
-0.0010165989,
-0.0722645372,
-0.027447246,
0.0228670556,
-0.0180010758,
0.0104096187,
0.0519585796,
0.0615467317,
-0.0179043189,
0.0038840494,
-0.0307436697,
-0.026858516,
0.0040763123,
0.0116418013,
0.0292217992,
-0.0024080451,
-0.0405373946,
0.0580033921,
0.0484967642,
-0.0169265568,
-0.0504416227,
-0.0485568978,
0.0072335009,
0.0445930213,
0.0212006867,
-0.0065187495,
-0.0349080674,
-0.0305527952,
0.0428732298,
0.0228356309,
0.0346490443,
0.0261845198,
0.0480351262,
-0.0573539659,
0.0059692673,
-0.0214453712,
-0.0018050813,
0.0143455314,
0.0609405413,
0.0106646512,
0.0198114086,
0.009035321,
-0.0443350114,
0.0150536466,
-0.0196777619,
-0.0450029112,
0.0160637349,
-0.0013800585,
0.0310516674,
-0.0114828805,
-0.0047930297,
-0.0140478658,
0.0328774899,
-0.0399916023,
0.0217622183,
-0.0603341423,
-0.035288129,
0.0105260042,
0.050391309,
0.0120757157,
0.0284806639,
0.0523141697,
-0.0512968861,
-0.0488930978,
0.0242387783,
-0.0464289635,
0.0695922449,
-0.0293818563,
0.0071817073,
-0.0272965487,
0.063692838,
-0.0321064629,
0.0117100654,
-0.0058966083,
-0.003965382,
0.0160862356,
0.0303830113,
-0.0002009575,
-0.0238666292,
-0.0278840382,
0.0095727965,
0.0227277987,
0.0413974002,
-0.0052661342,
0.0306154117,
-0.0319294669,
-0.0270186104,
-0.0639920384,
0.054263927,
-0.0262198895,
0.0045100548,
0.0235534869,
0.0309245791,
-0.0085562076,
0.0002076857,
0.0212537684,
0.0444790237,
-0.0107841138,
0.01470742,
0.0031711597,
-0.0011568484,
-0.0199384671,
-0.0291764569,
-0.0221785288,
0.0366525799,
0.0437039137,
-0.0166911315,
-0.0075605833,
-0.0278147105,
0.0151616065,
-0.0120866401,
0.0437984131,
0.0086175939,
-0.041004397,
-0.0354421623,
-0.0061961445,
0.0242863204,
0.0787701756,
0.0046306103,
0.0035766067,
0.0445047393,
-0.007171385,
-0.0472353436,
0.0170125123,
-0.0122688832,
-0.0761272237,
-0.0179792419,
0.0167289842,
-0.0324901193,
0.0848524794,
-0.0458725765,
-0.0128982114,
-0.0158863217,
0.010727373,
-0.0027098872,
-0.0230706166,
0.0044590798,
0.0363692045,
-0.0220171418,
-0.0101667019,
-0.0044039888,
-0.0775745139,
0.0199476108,
-0.0495875739,
-0.0071287062,
-0.050498724,
-0.0143328113,
-0.0614130013,
0.0286147408,
0.0118344836,
0.0329466686,
-0.0264326651,
0.0040844819,
0.0108903777,
0.0190480966,
0.0071547539,
-0.0083472887,
0.0256226398,
-0.0205240659,
0.0374001227,
-0.0509371087,
-0.0375230573,
-0.005041624,
-0.0018575615,
-0.0366593301,
0.007474496,
0.0421722531,
-0.0603470467,
-0.0377942063,
0.0077628302,
0.0191069134,
0.0516768359,
-0.0136298249,
0.0052280906,
-0.0312381741,
0.0004311356,
0.0769211724,
0.0204399657,
0.0236615855,
0.0091061071,
-0.0003251333,
0.0269023851,
0.0394779444,
0.0188795552,
-0.0534850024,
-0.0025711926,
0.0232875068,
-0.0206231531,
-0.0188345034,
-0.0016388296,
0.023945136,
-0.0765973926,
-0.0127815353,
0.0943112895,
0.0192508847,
-0.0724106282,
0.0006601532,
0.0061192093,
0.0543090999,
0.0264588539,
0.0443238877,
-0.0395328887,
-0.0526288077,
0.0221176054,
0.0285027474,
-0.0025209677,
-0.0036860614,
-0.0287275519,
-0.0940009132,
-0.0009128047,
0.0141477035,
-0.013205979,
-0.0197570287,
-0.0775880739,
-0.0105090607,
-0.0010251012,
0.0244853608,
0.019861633,
-0.0196129903,
-0.0097674215,
0.005150551,
-0.0158128869,
-0.0274414569,
0.0340657309,
-0.0340397768,
0.0323528461,
0.0123901386,
0.0043905703,
0.0240971912,
-0.0045153038,
0.0427051522,
-0.0036103488,
-0.0036915429,
-0.0535041429,
0.0254353601,
-0.0379979573,
-0.0250702631,
0.0183474422,
0.0379165486,
-0.0690324605,
0.0000945443,
-0.0078324573,
0.0625704899,
0.0039427667,
0.0148265678,
0.0008077618,
-0.0291684847,
-0.0192361288,
0.048066996,
0.0206459146,
-0.0390303098,
-0.012085137,
-0.0122418134,
-0.0529469401,
-0.0297182687,
-0.0133901211,
-0.0350139141,
-0.0012402474,
-0.0040709591,
-0.0076893498,
0.0061843321,
0.0544730425,
0.0241432767,
-0.0130257849,
0.0085085202,
-0.0029140515,
-0.0033945651,
-0.0883893669,
0.0637996644,
-0.0697155073,
0.0070407433,
-0.0774835348,
-0.0233454183,
0.0551108457,
0.0219244622,
-0.0032631145,
0.0679265261,
-0.1344426274,
-0.0754627585,
0.0032800611,
0.0500382856,
0.0149897719,
0.0485192761,
0.0193128474,
-0.0768827125,
0.0091826264,
0.0180652551,
-0.0144186178,
0.0845069513,
0.0136857321,
-0.022994291,
0.0002908477,
0.0398048311,
-0.003329155,
-0.0208961647,
0.040197093,
0.0242063794,
0.0122699663,
-0.023123296,
-0.0358457938,
0.0063597304,
0.0045679766,
-0.0299022924,
-0.0155938976,
-0.0199273434,
0.0541506596,
0.0270020161,
0.0218517482,
-0.0271757226,
0.0105037773,
0.0151845394,
-0.007214535,
-0.0249504223,
-0.0169119127,
0.0651306063,
-0.0157664251,
0.0029682096,
0.0152320834,
0.0069835926,
-0.0412930064,
0.0472187698,
0.0038418137,
-0.0141088068,
0.0506286845,
-0.0103050331,
0.0141586941,
-0.0350974649,
0.0105300695,
0.0060562999,
0.0027338678,
-0.0663867816,
0.019100396,
-0.0003521959,
-0.1262163222,
-0.0481737852,
0.0272812787,
0.071145393,
-0.007617407,
0.0359917358,
0.0060546063,
-0.0216620453,
-0.0174379461,
-0.0106649203,
-0.0260171425,
-0.0059361197,
0.0212334916,
0.0089847716,
-0.024784904,
0.0333888419,
0.0626190677,
0.0724885985,
0.0690128654,
0.0288735814,
0.0301173441,
-0.0318689682,
-0.0140453083,
-0.0124587826,
0.0322687775,
-0.0185927134,
0.0007019517,
0.0261369608,
-0.0322677381,
0.0031984649,
-0.0234332923,
-0.0164865945,
-0.0045693354,
0.0399671048,
0.0314152911,
-0.0234714542,
-0.0188752078,
-0.0317936577,
0.016792383,
-0.001179208,
-0.0091294823,
0.0291231591,
-6.91471401e-33,
-0.0041987374,
0.0235730484,
0.0155507261,
-0.0094369594,
-0.0217797104,
0.0089919828,
-0.0124674095,
-0.0058412119,
-0.0319529548,
-0.018922735,
-0.0304707643,
0.0131260138,
0.0143169835,
0.0358944386,
-0.0026662298,
-0.0004265893,
0.0501744933,
-0.0175630953,
-0.0082326205,
0.0372542813,
0.0037078112,
0.05529432,
0.0590760335,
-0.0025467561,
-0.0367905684,
0.0216853991,
0.0045633879,
0.018976761,
-0.0187406857,
0.0283618607,
-0.0691789761,
0.041851908,
-0.0073939916,
-0.0359500982,
-0.0275485758,
0.0117066484,
-0.0811027214,
-0.0046010911,
0.0484492853,
0.0190143697,
-0.0382344685,
-0.0483064204,
0.0297360644,
0.0630358532,
-0.0008930856,
-0.0114141721,
-0.0182771739,
-0.0224050619,
-0.0408965796,
-0.0283354856,
-0.0512210168,
0.0330503136,
0.0383903384,
0.0012185927,
0.0625634193,
-0.0576246418,
-0.0323628262,
0.0286315195,
-0.0397831835,
-0.0324796773,
0.0378819741,
0.0877676681,
0.0611424707,
0.0274814852,
0.0085340459,
0.048611436,
0.0104536945,
0.0080744606,
0.0198863205,
0.0404596031,
0.059589088,
0.0237450171,
0.0157033876,
0.0076578083,
0.0450278334,
-0.0314316265,
-0.0666879416,
-0.0551219396,
0.012291953,
0.0606390983,
0.0357275493,
0.0361101665,
0.0147969136,
-0.0162984822,
-0.0673029721,
-0.0043224604,
-0.041389931,
0.0153421042,
0.0232067704,
0.0522148237,
-0.0462198071,
-0.0254379865,
0.0321940929,
-0.0422375388,
0.0243313052,
-0.0077227508,
0.0341878533,
0.0032902388,
0.0072052842,
0.0144100562,
-0.0379838496,
-0.0569053255,
-0.0102033094,
-0.034339007,
0.0290231425,
-0.0272292681,
0.0141324811,
0.029105708,
-0.085572511,
0.0085807564,
-0.0382185392,
0.0225546528,
0.0069667008,
0.0849963874,
0.0082222195,
-0.0091120237,
0.0225025304,
0.0871525034,
0.0119838389,
-0.0023740761,
-0.0010203365,
-0.0359889381,
0.0141281346,
0.0325379595,
-0.0294941738,
0.0063612666,
-0.0351864062,
-0.0292236842,
0.0383070968,
-0.0798312351,
-0.007955879,
0.0112756826,
2.905e-7,
0.0036944263,
0.080412291,
-0.0214117058,
-0.0237720422,
0.0077239969,
0.0133046946,
0.0337304212,
-0.0004267582,
0.0024183639,
-0.0090299537,
-0.0132584563,
0.0228354894,
0.0331598297,
-0.005429103,
-0.092371501,
0.0077063744,
-0.0559734218,
0.0340134203,
-0.0542362109,
-0.0358705632,
-0.0403412245,
0.1510762274,
0.0216580275,
-0.0239072889,
0.0225670524,
-0.0298790541,
0.0300612319,
-0.0465134829,
-0.0204937439,
0.0219085738,
0.0479880571,
0.0398766398,
-0.0156234996,
-0.0252824742,
-0.0182463713,
0.0263570417,
-0.0556604974,
0.0939701498,
-0.0183520541,
-0.0197078083,
0.0420901254,
-0.0162947383,
-0.0325959101,
-0.0469764657,
0.0515841804,
-0.0199713651,
-0.0203208663,
-0.0819636211,
0.035648834,
-0.0266481396,
0.0527284667,
-0.0578698292,
0.0198891312,
0.0209310856,
0.0286113694,
-0.0262427423,
-0.0444261841,
-0.1084868535,
-0.0117789498,
0.0032915215,
-0.0376366116,
-0.0360939838,
-0.077253297,
-0.0058087129,
0.0565039888,
-0.0645228997,
-0.0038306862,
2.889142413e-34,
0.0621690154,
-0.0347471274,
0.0040512746,
0.0171648264,
0.0271608345,
-0.0019807906,
-0.0108460784,
0.0205466785,
-0.0274563506,
-0.1051554605,
-0.0296137519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09752v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09752v1 | Politeness Stereotypes and Attack Vectors: Gender Stereotypes in Japanese and Korean Language Models | 2023-06-16T10:36:18 | 2023-06-16T10:36:18 | Victor Steinborn, Antonis Maronikolakis, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | In efforts to keep up with the rapid progress and use of large language
models, gender bias research is becoming more prevalent in NLP. Non-English
bias research, however, is still in its infancy with most work focusing on
English. In our work, we study how grammatical gender bias relating to
politeness levels manifests in Japanese and Korean language models. Linguistic
studies in these languages have identified a connection between gender bias and
politeness levels, however it is not yet known if language models reproduce
these biases. We analyze relative prediction probabilities of the male and
female grammatical genders using templates and find that informal polite speech
is most indicative of the female grammatical gender, while rude and formal
speech is most indicative of the male grammatical gender. Further, we find
politeness levels to be an attack vector for allocational gender bias in
cyberbullying detection models. Cyberbullies can evade detection through simple
techniques abusing politeness levels. We introduce an attack dataset to (i)
identify representational gender bias across politeness levels, (ii)
demonstrate how gender biases can be abused to bypass cyberbullying detection
models and (iii) show that allocational biases can be mitigated via training on
our proposed dataset. Through our findings we highlight the importance of bias
research moving beyond its current English-centrism. | [
0.0983754173,
0.0546438135,
-0.040774323,
0.0350080952,
0.0058595967,
0.0288037788,
0.0604952946,
0.0205789711,
-0.0040231436,
-0.0669967681,
-0.0152559327,
-0.0437964313,
0.0508770831,
-0.0161675867,
0.0424155332,
-0.0609117523,
0.0278886203,
0.0311168469,
0.0431752317,
-0.0391636789,
0.0550441444,
0.0079731522,
0.0200111195,
0.0575113669,
-0.0275719315,
-0.0150805777,
0.0310971178,
0.0291214287,
-0.0272804573,
-0.0052242274,
0.0944544896,
0.0592663698,
-0.0041055162,
0.0246096533,
0.0000016184,
-0.088678889,
0.040704973,
0.0222453009,
-0.0149683794,
0.0204143226,
0.0563972667,
-0.0355747603,
-0.0283616725,
0.0344055258,
-0.0246317349,
-0.0400785878,
0.0319292471,
0.0479728989,
0.0701974332,
0.0427324176,
-0.0079535721,
-0.0130109088,
-0.0454471745,
-0.0112466607,
-0.0349026695,
0.0316206254,
0.0430542827,
-0.0638314262,
-0.0747304186,
-0.0037128876,
-0.0052410699,
-0.0277563259,
-0.0366273522,
0.0010256917,
-0.0202786364,
0.0010741015,
-0.0498956814,
-0.0423414521,
0.0109456647,
0.0104892775,
0.0097314427,
-0.0151309045,
0.0075942157,
0.0191003177,
0.0119264433,
-0.0022290857,
-0.0221413672,
0.0153646786,
-0.0061745662,
-0.0186438244,
0.0130211562,
-0.0304291453,
0.0187548585,
0.0674749762,
0.0054666037,
0.0742997304,
0.0008404126,
-0.0594803169,
-0.0195297264,
-0.0252805706,
0.0121584553,
-0.0486047715,
-0.0022751167,
-0.0070529873,
0.0223054048,
-0.009587544,
-0.0026526256,
-0.0245448444,
0.0450356379,
-0.078788735,
-0.0010835259,
0.0133686746,
0.014290737,
-0.0225758422,
-0.0184865259,
0.0194663238,
0.0078158192,
0.0416787453,
-0.0043786126,
-0.0266227014,
-0.0260653049,
-0.0175080597,
-0.0145686809,
-0.0242570359,
0.0254603643,
0.0638706908,
-0.061410632,
-0.0275272708,
-0.0747486129,
-0.0266372282,
0.0230974257,
0.0015681183,
-0.0259847175,
0.0064303749,
0.0126506286,
-0.0028700414,
-0.076256521,
0.0366841294,
-0.0431047454,
-0.0929497331,
0.0139899338,
0.0060886126,
-0.0050288448,
-0.0292732287,
0.007665257,
0.0375150144,
0.0392939001,
-0.022514604,
-0.0150384009,
-0.0239777826,
-0.0615852661,
-0.0313789621,
0.0002364654,
-0.0495292731,
-0.0232990943,
0.0243426319,
-0.0001053923,
-0.0166179612,
0.0047805673,
0.0071236547,
-0.049076423,
0.0482133366,
0.0637925416,
0.0073240106,
0.0576152429,
0.0027014918,
-0.0151026435,
0.0440255776,
0.0332922935,
-0.0359651707,
0.058167275,
0.0179477669,
0.0067242919,
0.0520328656,
0.0361196473,
0.0337655954,
0.0013445386,
0.0187421124,
-0.0224131551,
-0.0137404976,
0.0446094163,
0.0000140013,
0.0280213803,
-0.0191517491,
0.0500185341,
0.0489026904,
-0.0319932923,
0.047867544,
0.0351567082,
0.0274973214,
-0.0132391816,
0.009748023,
-0.0687690154,
-0.0345018357,
-0.0512687229,
-0.0400052182,
-0.0339398347,
0.0349854194,
-0.0156462528,
-0.0287003275,
-0.0368275903,
0.0133568421,
0.0213929191,
-0.0082912492,
0.0227241702,
0.0649560094,
0.0166656505,
0.0541464165,
0.0504291207,
-0.0468245931,
-0.0004894665,
-0.029986294,
-0.0048275776,
0.0197860394,
-0.0213727355,
0.0100949416,
0.0058026738,
-0.0459118448,
-0.0236558635,
0.0101124775,
0.0179942064,
0.0112711582,
0.010747944,
-0.0079366276,
0.0035891612,
0.0450710654,
0.024636643,
0.007805577,
0.0721726194,
0.0318036713,
0.0097951908,
-0.0087182904,
-0.0663881451,
0.0225019213,
0.040503744,
-0.0258814562,
0.0224356763,
0.0347346701,
0.0509455241,
0.0068264217,
-0.037164636,
-0.0130791757,
-0.023649903,
0.0051251776,
-0.0130323423,
0.0373316929,
-0.0163791496,
-0.028056765,
0.0140897352,
-0.0357163921,
-0.0486703627,
0.022633709,
0.0028218569,
0.0132937012,
0.0854924321,
-0.0275309123,
0.0047900225,
-0.0237083714,
-0.004057881,
-0.0540325195,
0.0583426766,
-0.0046206946,
0.0033416168,
-0.0373788476,
-0.0285860561,
0.0189768374,
-0.0333198197,
0.0137453722,
-0.0292280279,
-0.082632035,
0.0175317619,
-0.0161458906,
-0.0010557496,
0.0312247034,
-0.0081314528,
-0.0172339547,
-0.0187324006,
-0.0835084841,
-0.0244350526,
-0.0030102103,
-0.0248562805,
0.0015803109,
0.0102741988,
-0.0372738391,
0.0250514578,
0.0051449663,
-0.0366324224,
0.0180945806,
0.0356567875,
0.023689013,
-0.0369775854,
0.0063474388,
-0.0342691503,
-0.0227992926,
-0.0524166673,
0.0356215946,
0.0070192325,
-0.0449536555,
0.0040372792,
0.0082347495,
-0.0111790318,
0.0299241114,
-0.0038940692,
-0.0791633353,
0.0158514977,
0.0370493457,
0.016903149,
0.0684261397,
0.0551357605,
0.0301003009,
0.0320502706,
-0.0123775136,
-0.0433112681,
-0.0137315225,
0.0160340499,
-0.0015534214,
-0.0092178686,
-0.0921241939,
-0.0105902804,
0.0492482074,
0.0386521667,
-0.0280212965,
-0.037799634,
0.0450682677,
-0.0456056595,
-0.028367158,
-0.0095055485,
-0.0242947377,
-0.0207160991,
0.0220337491,
-0.0178460255,
-0.0627434254,
0.0513157658,
-0.0018862983,
-0.0308564156,
-0.0158213861,
-0.0087718433,
-0.0050406191,
0.0355926119,
-0.0287040211,
0.0364574902,
0.0561112128,
-0.0366090573,
-0.0416643247,
-0.0496108122,
0.0620062798,
0.0093460185,
-0.013402042,
-0.0028159155,
0.0081506539,
0.0287121255,
-0.0511836894,
-0.0347485878,
-0.0513481796,
-0.0156870261,
-0.0136558525,
-0.0039590751,
-0.0199741926,
-0.0017347167,
0.0200730823,
-0.0340462029,
-0.0291418489,
-0.0324678756,
-0.007446941,
0.0087543968,
-0.0038815283,
0.0104225278,
-0.0299843103,
0.0204705615,
0.0000275021,
0.0010098427,
0.0368133821,
-0.0263053216,
0.0304810908,
0.0275519136,
0.0255785249,
0.0513230339,
-0.0068440204,
-0.0070206951,
-0.0220661033,
0.0416353755,
-0.029534528,
-0.0099157812,
0.0858696327,
0.018691726,
-0.0343189724,
0.0113134086,
0.0179950316,
0.0386891402,
0.0411092043,
-0.0103981355,
-0.0122503322,
0.0224692449,
0.0431103185,
-0.003862194,
-0.0735644028,
-0.022284925,
-0.0189642292,
-0.1403421462,
-0.0035946553,
0.0040372964,
-0.0160883516,
-0.0136374487,
-0.0191839896,
0.0021649236,
0.0201948062,
0.0441781804,
-0.0121554835,
0.0064636753,
-0.007321279,
-0.0014393277,
-0.0857398137,
-0.0167393796,
0.0464485064,
-0.0803714469,
0.0727453902,
-0.0068531507,
0.0847418606,
-0.0580150895,
0.0248254798,
0.0177159403,
-0.0075331912,
0.0083332341,
-0.0423034541,
0.0357713811,
-0.0295504555,
-0.0204831511,
-0.053074576,
0.0321813375,
0.0356773846,
0.0217064694,
0.0267103557,
-0.0012757308,
0.0555353053,
-0.0433247052,
-0.0555653684,
-0.0053630122,
0.0103979809,
0.0560679883,
0.0113759553,
-0.0380533785,
-0.0059423591,
-0.0662208423,
-0.0175523553,
0.0388147272,
-0.0591892004,
-0.0086373715,
0.0146126896,
-0.0375804491,
-0.0495615862,
-0.0502437688,
-0.0144524826,
0.0039091269,
0.0342278369,
-0.0609196909,
0.0037505289,
0.0157920476,
-0.0520464405,
-0.0064254967,
0.0064540831,
0.0384039693,
0.0144584328,
-0.010211667,
-0.0058160303,
-0.0038126761,
-0.0237044562,
0.0024618206,
0.0003076263,
-0.0589369051,
0.0382366031,
0.0645526424,
0.0174796749,
0.0491411835,
-0.0021810154,
-0.0717018694,
0.0225055646,
0.0168752149,
-0.0141062131,
0.0296815112,
0.077150628,
-0.0045360061,
0.0316492654,
0.0425024591,
-0.0190321896,
0.0296353363,
0.0119461333,
-0.0336913876,
-0.035983175,
-0.0439773016,
-0.0053011919,
0.0062830872,
0.0077195666,
-0.019857917,
-0.0078412443,
-0.0228144843,
-0.0366473459,
-0.0135586634,
-0.0581133701,
0.0144197037,
-0.0252153967,
-0.0020275954,
0.046335116,
-0.0404336974,
-0.0152310031,
-0.0531244576,
-0.002190158,
-0.018978525,
0.0097196978,
0.0344852246,
0.0775447786,
0.0022547196,
0.0165225994,
0.0094159767,
-0.0133185955,
-0.0082946699,
-0.0043511186,
0.0426953994,
0.0154479528,
-0.0106922686,
0.0137832351,
-0.0419985652,
-0.0253231283,
-0.026430551,
-0.0027803925,
-0.0117078237,
-0.0214305501,
-0.0032171288,
-0.0459546782,
0.0568611473,
-0.0132054295,
-0.0121711669,
-0.0097835315,
0.016709948,
-0.015729893,
-0.0398131795,
0.0221125744,
0.0089421198,
-0.0145453513,
0.0046088826,
0.0475733466,
0.0368741937,
0.0511399209,
0.0082128588,
-0.0562190898,
-0.0126087414,
0.0017097648,
0.0406793952,
0.0055432953,
0.0145082604,
-0.0114137474,
-0.0831532776,
-0.0728156492,
-0.0150729427,
-0.0432956293,
0.0413955413,
-0.0166814383,
-0.0286219213,
0.0638392791,
-0.0124077657,
-0.0262597278,
-0.0534617715,
0.0010005488,
0.0057977359,
-0.0108382879,
-0.0093646338,
-5.203092482e-33,
-0.0132168541,
-0.0406027474,
-0.0525634959,
0.0183949899,
0.0004661815,
-0.0102380542,
-0.0218757652,
0.0146390274,
-0.0363470726,
0.0362444781,
-0.0084546851,
0.0388625599,
0.0141877811,
-0.0247566942,
0.0269838925,
0.0017320039,
0.0411889106,
0.0015103467,
-0.0008598481,
-0.0312645659,
0.0266393553,
0.0158524308,
0.0312130116,
-0.05722031,
0.1372824311,
-0.0223866589,
-0.0405551903,
-0.0025104028,
-0.0160801634,
0.0395012684,
0.0113794496,
0.0979107469,
0.0110438243,
0.0278119296,
0.0215209462,
0.0659766942,
-0.0588192195,
-0.016379863,
0.0054379278,
0.0483548492,
0.0719287097,
-0.0124295931,
0.0095892474,
0.0099066198,
-0.0637292936,
-0.0287794098,
0.0615720451,
0.0383096263,
0.0775700063,
-0.000897201,
-0.0536207445,
0.0065561403,
-0.0486408323,
-0.0067675957,
-0.0002253134,
0.0268729255,
-0.0001265699,
-0.0129874954,
-0.0537425578,
0.0586522669,
-0.0292246584,
-0.0135811046,
-0.0056103677,
-0.0026030682,
0.0166523345,
0.0362652913,
0.1014428437,
0.060421247,
0.0093522966,
-0.0468774959,
0.0537590832,
0.0047257035,
0.005519202,
0.0804407522,
0.0359674357,
-0.0546524078,
-0.0511779673,
-0.0463276505,
0.0774703622,
0.0376813114,
0.01761318,
-0.0289072432,
-0.1032261774,
-0.0926061198,
-0.0054212664,
-0.0890417248,
-0.0233414397,
-0.0155208595,
0.0312520973,
-0.0106031075,
-0.0427573435,
-0.0219907835,
-0.0038323156,
-0.0632651374,
-0.0561766177,
0.0411265232,
-0.0108063314,
-0.0210472848,
0.0399463363,
0.0378246568,
-0.0037106131,
-0.0108574368,
-0.0164444931,
-0.0070417798,
0.0234611575,
0.0139780054,
0.0395612679,
0.0193777196,
-0.0668749437,
-0.0150518306,
-0.0179954413,
0.0059012631,
-0.0209836587,
0.0644692034,
0.0086253257,
0.0448705219,
-0.0251205526,
-0.0349374041,
0.065527007,
0.033384122,
-0.0523148887,
0.021807164,
-0.0328947902,
0.0079497015,
0.0149917901,
-0.0115015656,
-0.018620858,
-0.0021302223,
0.0531073511,
-0.0430942662,
-0.0108018201,
-0.0688030943,
2.396e-7,
-0.0193909444,
0.0648470148,
0.0113303633,
0.0356478579,
0.0372401327,
0.0570526384,
0.0065654069,
0.0305438694,
0.0754182786,
0.028854534,
-0.0481411219,
0.0051206131,
-0.0069236774,
0.0332707055,
-0.088189818,
0.036479678,
-0.0672292486,
0.0099060703,
0.0021555563,
-0.0120429229,
-0.0320741162,
0.0602833554,
0.0448398776,
-0.0207497589,
-0.0281421132,
-0.0212157015,
0.0191017538,
-0.0199912041,
0.0098803882,
0.0224367697,
0.0238865726,
-0.0050971373,
0.0550991744,
0.0335436836,
0.014293991,
0.0131909503,
0.0036909229,
0.0204452034,
-0.0029160623,
0.0302777123,
-0.0009491944,
-0.0110317888,
-0.0439544395,
-0.078741923,
0.0437135957,
0.0126040224,
-0.0357174613,
-0.0440787859,
-0.0086266268,
-0.0054098158,
0.0434821583,
-0.0262983944,
-0.017691154,
0.0290589631,
0.0345848836,
-0.0065142908,
0.0121284304,
-0.0293650515,
-0.0243466217,
-0.0073401737,
0.0023661135,
-0.0647128969,
0.0161791593,
0.0344062336,
0.0358093381,
-0.009534019,
0.0493000261,
1.712796059e-34,
0.0063884435,
0.0285016969,
0.0164612606,
0.0023118211,
0.0429852009,
0.0235316195,
0.0489281788,
0.0211699251,
0.0630875304,
0.0162631627,
-0.0141633814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09737v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09737v2 | Using Natural Language Processing and Networks to Automate Structured Literature Reviews: An Application to Farmers Climate Change Adaptation | 2023-06-16T10:05:47 | 2024-07-03T15:41:20 | Sofia Gil-Clavel, Tatiana Filatova | cs.CL | cs.CL | The fast-growing number of research articles makes it problematic for
scholars to keep track of the new findings related to their areas of expertise.
Furthermore, linking knowledge across disciplines in rapidly developing fields
becomes challenging for complex topics like climate change that demand
interdisciplinary solutions. At the same time, the rise of Black Box types of
text summarization makes it difficult to understand how text relationships are
built, let alone relate to existing theories conceptualizing cause-effect
relationships and permitting hypothesizing. This work aims to sensibly use
Natural Language Processing by extracting variables relations and synthesizing
their findings using networks while relating to key concepts dominant in
relevant disciplines. As an example, we apply our methodology to the analysis
of farmers' adaptation to climate change. For this, we perform a Natural
Language Processing analysis of publications returned by Scopus in August 2022.
Results show that the use of Natural Language Processing together with networks
in a descriptive manner offers a fast and interpretable way to synthesize
literature review findings as long as researchers back up results with theory. | [
0.0258361306,
0.0591790117,
-0.0147035373,
-0.0010476229,
-0.0109474007,
-0.0140201123,
0.0049605286,
-0.0105516622,
0.0286291391,
-0.0787697732,
0.0480033234,
0.0688757002,
0.0248874519,
0.0738051757,
0.0154321752,
-0.0440551303,
0.0103606889,
0.0236398969,
0.0385138094,
0.0425516628,
0.0034658057,
0.0290797632,
0.0041426406,
0.0245847739,
0.0510532223,
0.0265073832,
0.0126510542,
0.0115889674,
0.048190929,
-0.0341361277,
-0.000948744,
0.0305624548,
-0.0038051931,
-0.0049262471,
0.0000019294,
-0.0612556376,
-0.0639375597,
0.0239828862,
0.010576915,
0.029277524,
0.0734551176,
-0.0457133502,
0.0098914364,
0.0070406781,
-0.0298582707,
-0.0179904364,
0.0252380818,
0.0178195965,
-0.0064162076,
0.0223307628,
-0.0100325784,
-0.0590640344,
0.0109073315,
0.0251828618,
-0.051325202,
0.0340582952,
0.0396335088,
0.0047216704,
0.034120895,
0.0429921485,
-0.0090711918,
0.0290174428,
-0.0523868538,
-0.049694851,
0.0459560975,
0.0179637074,
-0.020275088,
0.0096566193,
-0.0017222328,
0.0226315279,
0.0542642958,
0.0362347588,
0.0626978874,
-0.0226125028,
-0.0071168733,
0.089168258,
-0.0373358428,
-0.006522099,
-0.0098226294,
-0.0317343585,
-0.0041894051,
0.0148556428,
-0.0127854422,
0.0134750968,
-0.0204781331,
0.0487177931,
-0.0290626176,
-0.0369398631,
-0.003476596,
-0.0049355743,
0.0668862611,
-0.0430406928,
0.02082715,
0.0118946945,
0.0085027069,
0.0060753268,
0.0553999692,
-0.0309422277,
0.0408656448,
-0.0450386442,
-0.0243850127,
-0.0288378,
0.0232465342,
-0.011087317,
0.0397999026,
-0.0413369983,
-0.0063824104,
-0.0380640216,
0.0045682625,
0.0297591481,
-0.0987720191,
-0.0359832495,
0.0124319727,
-0.0158043616,
-0.0267844796,
0.0214973725,
-0.0158204902,
-0.0252234712,
-0.0220784135,
-0.0254901927,
-0.0182008632,
0.0258586202,
0.0193019472,
-0.0133963749,
-0.0229610372,
0.076043196,
-0.0179914311,
0.0374684893,
-0.0445271991,
0.0161928851,
0.0107372282,
-0.0154309934,
0.0741735995,
0.0337642618,
0.0242293421,
0.0645121783,
0.0455928333,
-0.0235398915,
0.0041205524,
-0.0261093695,
-0.0205388125,
0.000380462,
-0.0202147905,
-0.049847737,
0.0003500537,
0.0336599164,
0.0027250578,
-0.0236915536,
0.0008127883,
0.011409156,
-0.0750772804,
0.0322503746,
-0.0582265966,
-0.0369614363,
0.0198977739,
-0.0319421478,
0.0491871387,
-0.0045177238,
0.0504517928,
-0.0063310252,
0.0120013552,
0.0002646905,
-0.0001165554,
-0.0065596779,
-0.0306039862,
-0.0025374054,
0.0012657725,
-0.0169360079,
-0.0493085422,
-0.0080253724,
-0.0228320956,
-0.0069682454,
-0.0132081127,
0.0476821885,
0.0407296568,
0.0948267579,
-0.0054546301,
0.0642518699,
0.0014791666,
0.0604878515,
0.0152317397,
-0.0113953101,
-0.0026662759,
0.006827285,
-0.0503711887,
0.0163682383,
-0.0129845077,
0.0289039202,
0.012994227,
-0.0505268574,
-0.016023295,
0.0430528522,
0.0414128378,
-0.0316525884,
0.058627516,
0.0148224561,
0.0011179869,
-0.0426881015,
-0.0090220701,
-0.008053096,
0.035238158,
0.0414543301,
-0.024976477,
0.0415851623,
0.0349592939,
-0.0275776815,
0.0059766946,
-0.0230683312,
-0.0105088083,
0.0222582109,
0.0172021296,
-0.0114603899,
-0.0741292685,
0.0014439207,
-0.0325140692,
0.0111751603,
-0.01896853,
0.0062101311,
-0.0423091948,
-0.0214525778,
-0.0171996001,
-0.0018751164,
-0.0431448966,
0.0258524884,
-0.0178201888,
0.0196061991,
-0.0172504801,
-0.0426780023,
0.0139392251,
0.0565467812,
-0.0067196768,
0.0430350751,
0.0177281462,
-0.0299474597,
-0.0808233544,
0.0637513027,
0.0496204793,
0.0500365421,
-0.013918682,
-0.079534404,
-0.0056225518,
0.0060136616,
-0.0208816398,
-0.0363750048,
0.0993768349,
0.0181243625,
-0.0033350033,
0.0448592603,
-0.0348374508,
-0.0081581017,
-0.0034584822,
-0.0220497828,
0.0518316813,
0.0227780603,
0.001931877,
-0.03340609,
-0.1090833247,
0.0255097579,
-0.0034510205,
0.0455672406,
-0.0033698704,
-0.0248326361,
-0.0204215441,
0.0708886907,
-0.0126985898,
-0.0270100087,
0.0046115774,
-0.0120288851,
0.0277333111,
0.0038384325,
0.0320624225,
0.027749056,
-0.0089281285,
-0.0028895431,
0.0270153228,
0.029540332,
0.0284797307,
-0.0092804339,
-0.011453215,
0.0598955415,
-0.0025203407,
0.0304026231,
-0.0553769656,
-0.0017911582,
-0.0715272725,
0.0873821899,
0.0810542703,
-0.0931323171,
-0.0231973585,
-0.018618796,
-0.034686815,
0.002423252,
-0.0139275473,
0.0117377229,
-0.0211443566,
0.0412296541,
-0.0029571245,
-0.0036552695,
0.0010061892,
0.0199526772,
0.0186895113,
-0.0027108153,
-0.0228089876,
0.0005158445,
-0.0208447147,
0.0219756886,
-0.0144819859,
-0.0450940877,
0.0583002716,
0.0036967397,
0.0089310026,
-0.0293211266,
0.0383434482,
0.0372840501,
-0.0268209595,
0.0421256199,
-0.0412397757,
-0.0703286827,
0.0225542784,
0.0421051979,
0.012282514,
-0.0148064578,
0.0248704515,
0.0144803273,
0.0289682057,
-0.1087108925,
-0.0299827997,
-0.0287018586,
0.0614808612,
0.0425722152,
-0.0079229865,
0.0442629941,
-0.0010355434,
-0.0225185268,
-0.049942147,
0.0306128599,
0.039746128,
0.0043163174,
-0.0752215311,
0.0462514423,
-0.0221804492,
0.0261566229,
0.0122059016,
-0.003893466,
-0.0358967148,
0.0570975579,
0.0758437663,
-0.04340652,
-0.010568873,
0.0247987024,
0.0613027476,
0.0088505708,
0.0052871327,
-0.0326322094,
-0.0104217706,
0.0128375953,
0.0079070246,
-0.053694047,
0.0210675821,
0.0326828659,
0.0027993263,
0.0089172479,
-0.0356146954,
-0.0024192145,
-0.0519512855,
-0.0181996766,
-0.0395607948,
-0.0811321884,
0.017105205,
-0.0079185097,
-0.006980218,
-0.0448194854,
0.0340934955,
0.0737364367,
0.0041561504,
-0.0101442877,
0.0035745411,
-0.0547267683,
-0.0243949071,
0.0327012837,
0.0372881182,
-0.0553093068,
0.0335507467,
-0.0250936896,
-0.0052284109,
-0.012316159,
-0.0736321434,
-0.0207800344,
-0.0482574031,
0.0405553915,
-0.0079179956,
-0.054312773,
-0.0040056976,
-0.0554881245,
-0.006923554,
-0.0380974375,
-0.0727364123,
-0.0186616983,
-0.0431346558,
0.0118770339,
0.020487573,
-0.0861577913,
-0.0124993855,
0.0209873952,
-0.0127912899,
0.0277770441,
0.0459971391,
0.0331377536,
-0.0550070778,
0.0309466869,
0.0176790971,
-0.0096362401,
0.0007240361,
0.0166379735,
0.0556137897,
0.0315083191,
0.0115071479,
0.0031562618,
-0.0022653472,
-0.0320133977,
-0.0201335978,
0.0613028631,
0.0801815763,
0.0034664138,
-0.0545301847,
-0.0334023573,
0.0414123386,
-0.000919881,
0.0037509208,
0.0018347789,
-0.0045855227,
-0.0516151041,
-0.0164495185,
-0.0134931728,
-0.0126049574,
-0.0738279521,
-0.0237369426,
-0.0483039916,
-0.0014374813,
-0.0207152572,
-0.0298927408,
0.0453430898,
-0.0044246321,
0.0059815394,
0.0474574827,
0.1530124396,
-0.0313525312,
-0.0428643301,
0.0260129776,
0.00884597,
0.000033216,
0.08103095,
-0.0356391184,
0.0779640973,
0.057648927,
-0.0150669254,
-0.0045088395,
0.0023694674,
-0.0349520855,
-0.0356435552,
0.0043350495,
0.0218641814,
0.0187872853,
0.0288866572,
-0.0163999069,
0.018696446,
0.0418798141,
-0.0015984264,
-0.0202998985,
0.0037434998,
0.0064609144,
-0.0092566218,
-0.0325910673,
-0.0072379275,
0.0327051692,
-0.0443429574,
-0.0038707699,
-0.0413167886,
-0.0214332119,
-0.0012338927,
-0.0325656459,
0.0326735824,
-0.0225983672,
-0.0286647528,
-0.0305593815,
-0.0293591991,
-0.0340403989,
-0.0289664343,
-0.0197114199,
0.0120455604,
-0.0212848261,
0.0380043462,
-0.0067881383,
0.0144985607,
-0.054587312,
0.0462429263,
0.0048451568,
0.0606389605,
0.0077701085,
0.0356429107,
-0.023647273,
-0.0089231478,
0.0051671597,
-0.0520082153,
-0.0163214654,
0.0109844748,
0.0086172223,
-0.0339059196,
-0.0029137994,
-0.0168807153,
-0.057318151,
0.0074032098,
-0.0478104427,
-0.0150773479,
-0.0225807913,
-0.0025709625,
-0.0254542716,
-0.0033577404,
0.0324184969,
-0.0373409241,
-0.0110847354,
-0.0167063791,
0.0221328568,
-0.0194942076,
0.0123820938,
0.0399273373,
0.0131542329,
-0.0555847548,
-0.0076981457,
0.0435247719,
0.0489539057,
-0.0059177685,
0.0178478025,
-0.049894724,
-0.000362461,
-0.0628619269,
-0.0318292156,
0.0014276492,
0.0137108462,
-0.0034832973,
-0.0577806979,
0.0006251383,
0.035985399,
-0.0154124703,
0.021173697,
-0.020647686,
-0.0191779491,
-0.0201831348,
0.0253250096,
-0.0055772425,
0.0046371161,
0.0413877256,
-0.0728804097,
-0.0355213173,
-0.017914461,
-5.998242044e-33,
-0.0289665721,
-0.0996908695,
0.0152899558,
-0.0068966267,
0.004504534,
0.0233629644,
-0.0202308502,
-0.017347753,
0.0035877333,
0.0509280153,
-0.0121949865,
0.0075355968,
0.0073615056,
0.0073788473,
0.0588875152,
0.0426756702,
0.0270667952,
-0.020457739,
0.0209203772,
-0.0314008035,
0.0110496823,
-0.0205763951,
0.0581368878,
-0.0999130756,
0.0837421641,
-0.0093835453,
0.0003856827,
-0.0339853205,
0.0321673825,
-0.0002254421,
-0.0088111274,
0.0307099745,
0.0379839577,
-0.0567406528,
-0.0286220293,
0.0402162783,
-0.0790426955,
-0.0504334979,
0.0204347353,
-0.0410034359,
-0.0416495018,
0.0137164462,
0.0651564673,
0.0400256664,
-0.0109542282,
0.0183061063,
0.088809289,
-0.0465223826,
-0.0352503471,
-0.0549487062,
-0.0619271472,
0.0275134016,
-0.0551144332,
0.080473952,
-0.0689574257,
0.0319226831,
-0.01674968,
0.0477022082,
-0.0442198254,
-0.0105361659,
0.0358054116,
0.0226666126,
0.0098688826,
0.0046985,
-0.0010513829,
0.0396097936,
-0.0600207113,
0.013860045,
-0.0028428112,
-0.0432411693,
0.0066715679,
-0.0189045649,
0.031371709,
0.0711797029,
0.0224376097,
-0.0086779455,
-0.0861487836,
0.046644669,
-0.047499761,
0.0270284116,
-0.0092128282,
-0.0046866043,
0.0533560887,
-0.0337472633,
-0.0183359738,
-0.0413990729,
-0.003540046,
0.0078991093,
-0.0270998646,
-0.0276786201,
-0.0261273049,
0.0332986042,
-0.0103769051,
-0.0340490304,
-0.0057477551,
0.0414459258,
-0.0153484028,
0.0373913608,
0.0191519167,
-0.0009559063,
-0.0492179506,
-0.0025700338,
-0.0477699675,
0.0813556761,
0.0251133628,
-0.0192930065,
0.0034432628,
0.0007058841,
-0.0338820182,
-0.0144436434,
0.0208572075,
-0.0035400002,
-0.0255736336,
0.0027936229,
-0.021287242,
0.0241448916,
0.0432065688,
0.022017533,
0.0577984042,
0.0232202765,
0.0533248186,
0.0491489731,
-0.0166342836,
-0.0173512511,
-0.0057470696,
0.0067811189,
0.0141665563,
0.0265362021,
0.0255012792,
-0.0101788938,
0.0122228432,
-0.0310797598,
2.762e-7,
0.0957045928,
0.0865079388,
0.0141563555,
-0.0367294103,
0.037159428,
-0.0004211132,
0.0449500792,
0.0254679769,
0.0116279805,
0.0284071788,
0.0421678089,
-0.0429715961,
-0.0355800129,
0.0256843064,
-0.0525958426,
-0.0380196311,
-0.0415763222,
-0.0373957083,
-0.0756348297,
-0.0155662736,
0.0452946946,
-0.0322547778,
-0.0106052812,
0.0618205518,
-0.0628944188,
-0.0147368619,
0.0107693365,
-0.0399683602,
0.0255290456,
0.0186640583,
0.0333797634,
-0.0201319251,
-0.0197819714,
0.0128157428,
-0.0309744794,
0.0169228557,
-0.0359889381,
0.0074228072,
-0.0039504203,
0.0115844719,
0.0334903412,
-0.0485024489,
0.0403604433,
0.0060547311,
0.0220356546,
-0.0735703781,
-0.0482230633,
-0.0340199471,
-0.0293429103,
0.0036388724,
0.012398744,
-0.0169800278,
0.0289055668,
0.0425935388,
-0.0382724479,
-0.0145357847,
-0.0325358734,
-0.0504143387,
0.0228851959,
0.0664599016,
0.0040798374,
-0.0445247851,
0.0090304846,
-0.0160023607,
0.0405235291,
0.0050874804,
0.0485262871,
2.342110275e-34,
0.0508418046,
0.0223361775,
-0.0057444037,
-0.0254923701,
0.020451868,
0.0021357362,
-0.0629215688,
0.0415247492,
0.0195712224,
-0.0726206005,
0.0059680715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09725v1 | Discourse Representation Structure Parsing for Chinese | 2023-06-16T09:47:45 | 2023-06-16T09:47:45 | Chunliu Wang, Xiao Zhang, Johan Bos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previous work has predominantly focused on monolingual English semantic
parsing. We, instead, explore the feasibility of Chinese semantic parsing in
the absence of labeled data for Chinese meaning representations. We describe
the pipeline of automatically collecting the linearized Chinese meaning
representation data for sequential-to sequential neural networks. We further
propose a test suite designed explicitly for Chinese semantic parsing, which
provides fine-grained evaluation for parsing performance, where we aim to study
Chinese parsing difficulties. Our experimental results show that the difficulty
of Chinese semantic parsing is mainly caused by adverbs. Realizing Chinese
parsing through machine translation and an English parser yields slightly lower
performance than training a model directly on Chinese data. | [
0.0109207043,
0.0727391765,
0.0123651074,
0.0453938134,
-0.0125071853,
0.0124841025,
0.0062437723,
-0.0201552324,
-0.0184458401,
-0.0454131365,
-0.001159734,
-0.0416088328,
-0.0118662622,
0.0146268066,
-0.0216166656,
-0.0512094013,
0.053986717,
0.0095524034,
0.0406735353,
0.0151203126,
0.0074126716,
0.0044279769,
0.0088601178,
0.0360155851,
-0.0225156955,
-0.0802830905,
-0.0063477051,
-0.0029882167,
0.0297117382,
-0.0640316904,
0.0488607995,
0.0137811415,
-0.0242995825,
0.000686694,
0.0000018246,
-0.0226220712,
-0.0479122549,
-0.0036383145,
-0.0173146334,
0.0488670245,
0.0433912463,
-0.0423154458,
-0.0167551972,
-0.0021491311,
-0.0423869826,
-0.0383970328,
-0.0142658623,
0.0919090062,
0.0552902706,
0.0537923537,
-0.0103802606,
-0.0409644954,
0.0044313711,
-0.0176184308,
-0.0802293569,
-0.0497214273,
-0.015666794,
0.0434814282,
-0.0275918487,
0.0179168172,
-0.0082719242,
0.0367192179,
0.0020634097,
0.0074381279,
-0.0316762403,
0.0311717112,
-0.0251326654,
0.0218156502,
-0.0029833175,
0.0766898021,
0.0131880371,
-0.0040236264,
-0.0168574154,
-0.0161010809,
0.0017390797,
-0.0231777076,
-0.0185621511,
0.0614516549,
-0.0286274664,
0.0725954473,
0.0505364053,
-0.0258990806,
0.0083078546,
0.0106867906,
-0.0144133298,
0.0574782379,
-0.0224884637,
-0.0221518036,
0.0025007417,
-0.015420544,
-0.0491774864,
-0.0200885627,
0.0249461103,
-0.0107351597,
-0.0315048583,
0.0249178037,
-0.0146412002,
-0.0239244346,
0.0063364138,
-0.082894817,
0.0555391349,
0.050384853,
-0.0513084233,
0.0210815836,
-0.0265522078,
0.0404906422,
-0.0241173953,
-0.0083023347,
-0.0655226931,
-0.0159959421,
-0.0538311265,
-0.0455665737,
-0.0654472411,
0.0731368363,
-0.0536681153,
-0.0357858874,
-0.0253560785,
0.0113240099,
-0.00297736,
-0.0257778969,
0.0180439763,
0.0115892692,
-0.0468892716,
0.0493505038,
-0.0232573189,
0.0213203002,
-0.0510928258,
0.0181796532,
-0.022345243,
0.0094776498,
-0.0118809026,
0.0056890077,
0.0092013376,
-0.0111073013,
-0.033082515,
0.0702728257,
0.0151763167,
0.0261785965,
-0.0242555663,
-0.0237676073,
-0.0174559485,
0.0204807241,
0.0289971065,
-0.0420656353,
-0.0108653931,
-0.0033279229,
0.0197667032,
-0.0579417832,
0.019259572,
-0.0089655723,
0.0073611564,
0.0290424339,
0.0138143413,
-0.025797924,
-0.0264940187,
-0.0153971789,
0.0118567646,
0.0616401471,
0.0376437232,
-0.0135390954,
0.0586975217,
0.0313561112,
-0.0914483741,
-0.0025467402,
0.0086493175,
-0.0372181237,
-0.0311823245,
0.0141641339,
-0.0203016046,
0.0070722471,
0.016013518,
0.0510868356,
-0.0384698361,
-0.0184230004,
-0.0108601963,
0.0446944572,
-0.026435487,
0.0077026198,
0.055522535,
0.0228179432,
0.0021843778,
0.0409276746,
-0.0291173868,
-0.0303805955,
0.0200986024,
0.0029998,
-0.0253643431,
-0.0206973776,
0.0118063688,
-0.0631809682,
-0.030263789,
-0.0267052241,
0.0444270074,
-0.0551323369,
0.0183657389,
0.0261501689,
-0.0169428755,
0.066602245,
0.0279392339,
-0.0212026779,
-0.0176406745,
0.0230049659,
-0.0154559873,
0.0339192823,
0.0009469747,
-0.0164934564,
-0.0127064334,
0.0104111666,
0.0584668666,
0.0512061231,
0.0432710461,
-0.0375966765,
0.0098573389,
-0.0224542581,
0.004124694,
-0.0328051001,
0.0324753672,
0.0119182663,
-0.0236957408,
-0.0123328613,
0.0103001241,
-0.0085973246,
-0.0680370107,
0.0381135531,
-0.032305304,
-0.0138814179,
0.0256473459,
-0.003348894,
0.0481068306,
0.0435320996,
-0.0215520244,
0.0311845485,
0.0249805097,
-0.0488422588,
0.0079887342,
0.0565099046,
-0.0653600097,
-0.0413680039,
0.0467298776,
-0.0321860872,
-0.0246813297,
0.0155445728,
-0.0707175061,
-0.0281959474,
0.0176109318,
0.0063354261,
0.0274679307,
-0.0529228412,
-0.005545598,
-0.0055798702,
0.0298433546,
-0.0058245966,
0.0959322602,
-0.005005612,
0.0319311917,
0.0216404274,
-0.0167398658,
0.0503827929,
-0.0188122019,
-0.043591138,
0.0029021802,
0.0368131101,
-0.0204453506,
0.0345241018,
-0.0064430595,
-0.0131251542,
0.0121165225,
-0.1115219295,
0.0217128024,
-0.0320240259,
0.0499722809,
0.0579640791,
-0.020916231,
0.0330509879,
-0.0147232441,
-0.0232649576,
0.0012593125,
-0.0306957494,
-0.0205910299,
0.0494222865,
-0.0001451438,
-0.0049534249,
-0.030367136,
-0.001850496,
-0.0447071269,
0.0216085427,
-0.013247584,
-0.0328991823,
-0.0359303392,
-0.0385453627,
0.0077233603,
0.0313352272,
-0.0114085339,
-0.0660903975,
0.0265614893,
-0.0064253062,
0.0239048731,
0.0420891568,
0.0067040417,
0.0703588203,
0.0057546059,
-0.0017480636,
-0.0312295649,
0.0129420962,
0.01845631,
0.0517842323,
-0.0510004945,
-0.0017261689,
-0.0366985127,
0.1098895147,
0.0202860162,
0.0260306746,
-0.0111348704,
-0.0033241878,
-0.0751460865,
-0.0121364435,
0.0145609779,
0.0011265973,
-0.03984081,
0.0007721538,
-0.0438031703,
0.0281356219,
0.0719601437,
-0.0141467694,
-0.0222865641,
-0.0457966328,
-0.0030145673,
-0.021412883,
0.0652199388,
0.0175777916,
0.0015829386,
-0.0034648769,
-0.0595140681,
-0.0128729735,
-0.0066338419,
0.0186209194,
-0.0130364066,
0.0383740664,
-0.0395927131,
-0.0032029194,
-0.0287306607,
-0.0186531283,
-0.0431320369,
-0.0450052097,
0.0008625372,
0.0655832812,
-0.0104640927,
0.0377234817,
0.0104405833,
0.0276562013,
-0.0405247584,
0.0211537834,
-0.0284052566,
0.0381048098,
-0.0314512625,
0.024828149,
-0.002406663,
0.0133799901,
0.0035760612,
-0.0056251199,
0.0812174454,
0.0472954586,
-0.0150684072,
0.0230802,
-0.0469013788,
0.0109542189,
-0.0087654646,
-0.0350154079,
-0.0598012619,
-0.0113512082,
0.0637368187,
-0.0619567782,
-0.0155527797,
0.1142276451,
0.0276411902,
0.0050777243,
0.0356722474,
-0.0149380937,
-0.0049249227,
-0.0015018085,
-0.0154996533,
-0.1041408107,
-0.0107655907,
0.0001018322,
0.0240616053,
0.0059228088,
-0.0269097835,
0.0373442993,
-0.0863768533,
0.0047267112,
0.0063645276,
0.0090207933,
0.0191500019,
-0.0069528106,
-0.0074357893,
-0.0205419008,
0.0814635828,
-0.011911056,
-0.0284929145,
0.0054334234,
0.0123150302,
-0.0045607798,
-0.0546737649,
0.0172895566,
-0.0406019874,
0.0243073292,
0.0374688245,
0.0442756005,
-0.0197128877,
0.0247633699,
0.0660723597,
-0.0053247069,
0.0015208719,
0.0175270606,
0.0063326382,
0.0024170901,
-0.0146391084,
0.0105882846,
0.0200613663,
-0.0462300926,
-0.0069240015,
0.0143010104,
0.0175251234,
-0.0317685418,
0.00975357,
-0.0175657477,
0.0071394551,
-0.0213838797,
0.0739673153,
0.035017442,
-0.0310806595,
-0.0447842441,
-0.0226616189,
-0.0118957972,
-0.0816256404,
-0.0187933855,
0.0546588711,
-0.0168433972,
0.0264238268,
-0.0981432423,
-0.106713064,
-0.008393392,
-0.0231033098,
-0.0088307094,
0.0062615531,
0.0272272415,
0.0037302242,
-0.0291930884,
0.018479282,
0.0273920596,
-0.001142217,
-0.0391774997,
-0.0314819962,
0.0605060905,
-0.002397398,
-0.0278276559,
-0.0248707086,
-0.0302423835,
-0.0475162379,
0.0094127972,
0.0131012611,
0.0011248419,
0.0591020584,
-0.051218681,
0.0317462981,
-0.0186464489,
-0.0048969183,
-0.0302635375,
-0.0097362967,
0.0525385775,
0.0134006105,
-0.0011081953,
0.0107160592,
-0.0208040774,
0.0564956963,
-0.0352810845,
0.0586548708,
-0.0276640411,
-0.0166741163,
0.0550943986,
0.0193917137,
0.0310393255,
0.0135374954,
-0.0083026737,
-0.0382740349,
0.03423208,
-0.068490237,
-0.0549678393,
-0.0441313498,
0.0310495384,
0.0209162626,
-0.0321075618,
-0.0417358205,
0.0127729112,
-0.0101025989,
0.037387073,
-0.0344972946,
0.0424633957,
0.0192283094,
0.0124967108,
-0.0559137277,
-0.0018245733,
-0.0207078103,
-0.0007750814,
-0.0214260072,
0.0389027186,
-0.0516387261,
0.0264449529,
0.0225975215,
0.0498128086,
-0.0089663947,
0.0136858439,
-0.0482063405,
0.0203523263,
0.0018994338,
-0.0106688645,
0.0791146904,
-0.0550034158,
0.0697326288,
-0.0311676655,
0.0181647744,
-0.0206145812,
0.019732425,
0.0198186468,
-0.0062803268,
0.0080398479,
0.0295722652,
-0.0231477171,
-0.0619104728,
0.0786039382,
0.0089147305,
0.0380176753,
0.0410044156,
0.0162443947,
-0.0484418906,
-0.0515099131,
0.0050433744,
0.0323710404,
-0.0154175442,
0.0222501252,
0.000953763,
-0.015204059,
0.0038560871,
0.0188246761,
-0.0058887899,
-0.0069293729,
0.0025430564,
0.04943626,
0.005489165,
-0.021549413,
-0.0640074611,
-0.0364142284,
0.0002360509,
-0.0068429159,
-0.0543627627,
-5.751754103e-33,
-0.0780441016,
0.0126682846,
-0.0016070716,
0.0140255662,
-0.0175578482,
-0.008725021,
-0.0663474947,
0.0080463402,
-0.0253403299,
0.0477045327,
-0.0242463611,
0.0216248557,
0.0276555028,
0.0438413285,
0.0262398887,
-0.0110869519,
0.0575300306,
-0.0261821467,
0.0216956586,
-0.0058252853,
0.0861266702,
0.0320435502,
0.0377561934,
-0.0431669764,
0.0241668951,
-0.012572825,
0.0322996117,
0.0048473291,
0.0383232012,
0.064408429,
0.0277246553,
-0.0062068687,
0.0548805706,
0.0297167115,
-0.0382504202,
-0.0440468751,
-0.1566424072,
-0.0481397323,
0.0390947945,
0.0478704013,
-0.0441204645,
-0.0321187899,
0.0174156073,
-0.0304636825,
0.0531217381,
0.0313601047,
0.0448045395,
-0.0469065607,
-0.0091304695,
-0.0054810578,
-0.0396231376,
0.0313257463,
-0.000678869,
0.055840265,
0.0165678691,
0.0263435151,
-0.0128161106,
-0.0105420006,
-0.0389089659,
-0.0434263274,
-0.0544972271,
0.0688923523,
-0.0397519358,
0.0230615754,
0.0321714953,
0.0525775552,
-0.0053166989,
-0.041977305,
-0.0343911126,
0.0570194162,
0.029474631,
0.0012543191,
-0.0276542883,
0.0033447105,
0.0388950296,
0.0064689447,
-0.0504675023,
-0.0179686453,
0.0409230702,
0.0406598449,
0.0059202039,
-0.0017013339,
0.0082131727,
-0.0033924296,
-0.0229032952,
-0.0366818532,
0.009401287,
-0.0528104119,
0.0246281493,
-0.0182824023,
-0.0515722558,
0.0022708427,
0.04523037,
-0.0414273404,
-0.0306582935,
0.0500369407,
0.0286972839,
-0.0246341918,
-0.0064825504,
0.0482358336,
-0.0392186344,
-0.0712971538,
-0.0330699869,
-0.0157502126,
0.0322163142,
-0.000777934,
0.0400477722,
-0.0273275208,
0.0046095941,
0.0333368219,
-0.029986402,
-0.0098809116,
-0.0332236364,
0.1137837768,
0.0332551748,
0.0306977388,
0.002165895,
0.0227214545,
0.0168831628,
0.019990094,
-0.0302591044,
0.0068349652,
-0.0236019939,
0.0510763861,
-0.042983178,
-0.0259411298,
-0.0266624838,
0.0731755272,
0.0206679367,
-0.0544893704,
-0.0038429517,
0.0615083389,
2.398e-7,
0.0484711975,
0.0012442793,
0.0733723491,
0.0592225119,
0.0168038961,
-0.0384953618,
-0.0295432266,
0.0284598228,
-0.0041900338,
-0.0326212831,
-0.0167092141,
0.0293558147,
0.0358326957,
0.0567429438,
-0.0999325588,
-0.0311300606,
-0.0503090397,
0.0055009038,
-0.003859811,
0.0384763107,
0.0457940549,
0.0925065577,
-0.0332300253,
0.0664277822,
-0.0145777259,
-0.0190348066,
0.0236076694,
0.0304669868,
0.0303102713,
0.0534119308,
-0.0130517147,
-0.0027280524,
-0.0385641977,
-0.0155764082,
0.0008261665,
0.0510923453,
0.0138127152,
0.0748266205,
0.0219779536,
-0.0362365991,
-0.0152893672,
-0.0333006196,
0.0127925826,
0.0228412338,
0.0383943059,
-0.0308665093,
-0.0392350368,
0.0154444259,
-0.0250677112,
0.0147282062,
-0.0046350984,
0.0030400988,
0.0018872065,
0.0274128225,
0.026267793,
-0.0355669074,
0.0019988113,
-0.0483327322,
-0.0370623432,
0.0122081554,
-0.0124020791,
-0.0068894578,
0.0317679122,
-0.0263419151,
-0.0034991335,
-0.0535633378,
-0.0166834146,
1.697665816e-34,
0.0526849218,
-0.0248548891,
0.0101961922,
0.03876248,
0.0253024418,
-0.0388928466,
0.0006284383,
0.010660707,
-0.0196239445,
-0.0676266477,
-0.0152330669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09719v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09719v2 | Pushing the Limits of ChatGPT on NLP Tasks | 2023-06-16T09:40:05 | 2023-10-09T15:48:23 | Xiaofei Sun, Linfeng Dong, Xiaoya Li, Zhen Wan, Shuhe Wang, Tianwei Zhang, Jiwei Li, Fei Cheng, Lingjuan Lyu, Fei Wu, Guoyin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the success of ChatGPT, its performances on most NLP tasks are still
well below the supervised baselines. In this work, we looked into the causes,
and discovered that its subpar performance was caused by the following factors:
(1) token limit in the prompt does not allow for the full utilization of the
supervised datasets; (2) mismatch between the generation nature of ChatGPT and
NLP tasks; (3) intrinsic pitfalls of LLMs models, e.g., hallucination, overly
focus on certain keywords, etc.
In this work, we propose a collection of general modules to address these
issues, in an attempt to push the limits of ChatGPT on NLP tasks. Our proposed
modules include (1) a one-input-multiple-prompts strategy that employs multiple
prompts for one input to accommodate more demonstrations; (2) using fine-tuned
models for better demonstration retrieval; (3) transforming tasks to formats
that are more tailored to the generation nature; (4) employing reasoning
strategies that are tailored to addressing the task-specific complexity; (5)
the self-verification strategy to address the hallucination issue of LLMs; (6)
the paraphrase strategy to improve the robustness of model predictions.
We conduct experiments on 21 datasets of 10 representative NLP tasks,
including question answering, commonsense reasoning, natural language
inference, sentiment analysis, named entity recognition, entity-relation
extraction, event extraction, dependency parsing, semantic role labeling, and
part-of-speech tagging. Using the proposed assemble of techniques, we are able
to significantly boost the performance of ChatGPT on the selected NLP tasks,
achieving performances comparable to or better than supervised baselines, or
even existing SOTA performances. | [
0.0319584459,
0.0156320576,
0.0244596843,
0.0398843661,
-0.0658846498,
-0.0032484643,
-0.0007484155,
0.0386672877,
0.0685516,
-0.0439152047,
-0.0340909548,
0.0112376623,
-0.0597833022,
-0.0072329664,
0.0255384203,
-0.0453881547,
0.0746603683,
0.0087040262,
-0.0035855388,
-0.0055786544,
0.019215554,
0.0127806086,
-0.0445160866,
0.0443808213,
-0.0441862978,
-0.0128323706,
-0.0035361878,
0.0048376252,
0.0012344943,
-0.037293341,
0.0426151752,
0.0397305153,
0.0359894298,
-0.0028181558,
0.0000016302,
-0.0426453575,
-0.0320032388,
-0.0036423327,
-0.0416078269,
-0.0331582054,
0.0481807888,
0.0330663845,
0.0325862318,
0.0374812223,
-0.0482349023,
-0.0056298673,
-0.0013170497,
0.0818708763,
0.0762717277,
0.0833571106,
0.0140906563,
-0.015114449,
0.0117895612,
-0.0069179782,
0.0494834967,
-0.0405140817,
0.0165266264,
0.0055921618,
0.0379638001,
0.0404693373,
0.0170349162,
0.0263250433,
0.0370007344,
0.0302487146,
-0.0025910069,
0.0305025745,
-0.0662824288,
0.0047937799,
-0.0278730802,
0.0678147376,
-0.0081555257,
-0.0405270271,
0.0219217986,
0.0085016349,
0.0087390915,
0.0081915241,
-0.0423739664,
0.0148585383,
-0.0102656661,
0.0067871683,
0.0142117031,
0.0207426231,
-0.0159479883,
0.0405033752,
0.0255468115,
0.0474360697,
-0.0038706211,
-0.0536598265,
0.0321001932,
0.0229757708,
-0.021756351,
-0.0258889347,
0.0119015276,
0.0290723592,
-0.0597123727,
0.0326029286,
-0.0259592663,
0.0142180249,
0.0443914011,
-0.0475631692,
-0.0074583199,
0.0358749405,
-0.0375672393,
0.0749288499,
-0.0538989417,
0.0626261011,
0.014826634,
0.0802605376,
-0.027511321,
-0.0075616245,
-0.0904598311,
-0.0203622039,
-0.0830342099,
0.0703422055,
-0.0292811897,
-0.0210167523,
-0.0210646465,
0.0025737514,
-0.0030215953,
0.0223695282,
0.040797215,
0.0305175651,
-0.0191440973,
0.0069992361,
-0.0293280389,
0.0024517153,
-0.0453778356,
-0.0129193785,
0.0270194337,
-0.0727995113,
-0.0531278029,
0.0087218424,
-0.0011921623,
-0.0486143157,
0.0306607485,
0.0767923295,
-0.0152387265,
-0.0652678236,
-0.0252953712,
-0.0188041143,
-0.0266137104,
-0.0619893745,
0.0247734636,
-0.0455598421,
0.0589288138,
-0.0086657479,
-0.0290855635,
0.0075070197,
0.0290189609,
0.0565616749,
-0.0053082677,
0.090955399,
0.0097239679,
-0.0201075226,
0.0196664929,
0.0465473756,
-0.0687892735,
0.0720870718,
-0.0000068494,
0.0317261145,
0.0435008779,
0.0331646875,
0.0423030742,
0.0104664071,
0.0206633974,
0.0043883529,
0.0161636136,
0.0185431764,
0.0040107854,
0.0293947905,
-0.0054333471,
0.0657053143,
-0.0485379957,
-0.0100088185,
0.0261572432,
0.0341707915,
-0.0079696216,
-0.0033654361,
0.0312073473,
0.0491849408,
0.0332018584,
0.0283044651,
-0.0566546097,
0.0080560772,
-0.0093187485,
0.0082369437,
0.0189003404,
-0.0026950061,
-0.0306732226,
-0.0346351713,
-0.0203355756,
-0.0091493428,
0.0177337807,
0.0189337563,
0.0142489104,
0.0366577618,
-0.0669226274,
0.0722123012,
0.0317611955,
-0.0415127091,
-0.0034762695,
-0.0779473707,
0.0008875414,
0.0510706194,
0.0665056482,
-0.0652036592,
-0.0452858396,
-0.0053255702,
0.0415966548,
0.0458985046,
0.0457340889,
0.0017015622,
0.0019865176,
-0.0351221636,
0.0006343136,
-0.0211797711,
0.0185788348,
-0.0076503633,
0.0852684602,
-0.0024163397,
0.0090068756,
-0.029292291,
0.0014068012,
0.0303663071,
-0.0139352884,
-0.0470720567,
-0.0101884557,
-0.0052536358,
0.0223327,
0.0226640962,
0.0112836016,
0.0096506448,
0.0145524787,
-0.0280590672,
-0.0439458638,
0.0223632976,
-0.0640471578,
-0.0998080075,
0.0231518522,
-0.0087174876,
-0.0278370716,
0.0290355049,
-0.0576121099,
-0.036957074,
-0.025470648,
-0.033809863,
0.032983765,
-0.0671136752,
-0.0134373242,
0.0360545479,
0.0015845442,
-0.0424428247,
0.0864271894,
0.0097122332,
0.0367714763,
0.0120567856,
0.0296447575,
0.003176966,
-0.0324824452,
-0.0249126107,
-0.0047984323,
-0.0084443847,
0.0124577191,
0.0327635333,
0.0296750888,
-0.0910882428,
-0.0437475704,
-0.1175378859,
0.0551001094,
-0.0088153575,
0.0229522344,
0.0335069373,
-0.01319593,
-0.0269987192,
-0.0172334891,
-0.0369750187,
-0.0356580466,
0.024484314,
0.0071096211,
0.0498965159,
0.0215369929,
-0.0006230187,
-0.0172017757,
0.0187462922,
-0.0277860183,
0.0292102396,
-0.0347112045,
-0.0150513398,
-0.0327035114,
0.0401506834,
-0.0187134091,
0.024919508,
-0.0091836685,
-0.0181929097,
0.0352290533,
-0.015425425,
0.035266947,
0.0453157723,
0.0069481777,
0.0245772805,
-0.0200599767,
-0.0152513124,
-0.083860293,
0.0445782356,
-0.0193111282,
-0.0161119346,
0.0302184466,
0.0186965596,
0.0004016004,
0.0472065769,
0.0142768808,
0.0002893606,
-0.0656247959,
-0.0026022738,
-0.0191231389,
-0.0022483899,
-0.014230554,
0.0186875835,
-0.0394777805,
-0.0315699503,
-0.0455813333,
-0.0053622336,
0.0875141099,
-0.0350333788,
-0.0304404236,
-0.0587332994,
0.0027060842,
-0.0436266474,
0.069189921,
-0.0140961595,
0.003657676,
0.0043659685,
-0.054863289,
-0.0342574976,
-0.0264272895,
0.0078841317,
-0.0569243506,
-0.0009274226,
-0.0268391781,
0.0141393328,
0.0073529691,
-0.0572663993,
-0.0600939728,
-0.0474253334,
0.0154626518,
0.005934448,
-0.0370697156,
0.0150337163,
-0.0203437153,
-0.0321062841,
-0.0031359356,
0.0059879073,
-0.0190400351,
-0.005060934,
-0.0321806371,
0.0211715568,
0.0380734205,
0.0466313921,
-0.0043873428,
-0.0027658842,
-0.0069438601,
0.0630342066,
0.0367499888,
-0.0074697211,
-0.0178829245,
-0.015095544,
-0.0116724251,
-0.0759685859,
0.0033674648,
-0.0054084505,
0.0754041746,
-0.0646274164,
-0.0112693589,
0.1138770282,
0.0275570154,
0.0017181474,
-0.0093542011,
0.0214911457,
0.029350739,
0.0102476059,
0.0225659572,
-0.0801268294,
-0.0438404232,
0.0009809566,
0.0140411798,
-0.0029577811,
-0.0357737616,
-0.0213477556,
-0.1098981872,
0.0312430095,
-0.0191733111,
-0.0294366442,
-0.0094688805,
-0.0423840582,
0.0045632147,
-0.0036323788,
0.0297686793,
-0.0021580686,
-0.0112803616,
0.0191238094,
0.0252404977,
-0.0406777784,
-0.0433815904,
0.0455411263,
-0.0402449295,
0.0381274335,
0.0236157123,
0.0070582121,
0.0199847072,
-0.0247539934,
0.0397079997,
0.0033421174,
0.0070758136,
-0.0211460218,
0.0524189621,
-0.0252683982,
-0.0135996751,
-0.0085575562,
0.0406881124,
-0.028761277,
-0.0268274825,
0.0069700326,
0.0420679748,
-0.0179655384,
-0.0055380017,
-0.0030446625,
0.01995131,
0.0346020423,
0.0998312682,
0.0062142578,
0.0188243873,
-0.0671429411,
-0.0043479558,
0.010060179,
-0.0606491379,
-0.0386504605,
0.0040450227,
0.0175148603,
0.0353384875,
-0.067634441,
-0.064795889,
0.0429268889,
0.0520958602,
-0.0494667962,
0.0277346503,
-0.0424114615,
0.0146913091,
-0.0172902755,
0.0415376648,
-0.0666022822,
-0.0124486499,
-0.0145286098,
-0.026055688,
0.0338812582,
-0.019954348,
-0.0219475087,
0.0123889046,
-0.0910999402,
-0.0407894626,
-0.0261982102,
0.0630800501,
0.0159278046,
0.0275321286,
-0.025625376,
-0.0017018304,
0.0234355144,
0.0752340779,
-0.0600121506,
-0.0201856233,
0.0208148435,
0.0515878536,
-0.0085531417,
0.0294329934,
-0.0247855857,
-0.0093738213,
0.0050793709,
0.0755853131,
-0.0066643031,
-0.0074268612,
0.0412980355,
0.0292930752,
0.0618055537,
-0.0147928772,
0.0057771732,
-0.0228504818,
0.0012316016,
0.0005403543,
-0.0298716128,
-0.0294336081,
0.0314403288,
-0.020875033,
-0.0353855789,
-0.0036484564,
-0.0274494514,
-0.0400526151,
0.0374491848,
-0.0300809313,
0.000707774,
0.0094420705,
-0.0462615676,
-0.005724133,
-0.0011163892,
-0.032348074,
-0.0218792856,
0.000985345,
0.0292115491,
-0.0164467674,
0.0605579168,
0.0431713834,
-0.037217252,
0.0068322727,
0.0350692756,
-0.0509055704,
-0.0307109449,
-0.0074338992,
0.0927930027,
0.0624526292,
-0.0019372278,
-0.0185215361,
-0.0330383629,
-0.0173413828,
0.0099080959,
0.0131038027,
-0.0059228959,
-0.0060626236,
0.0420804583,
0.0270348806,
-0.0076168808,
-0.0196073558,
0.056850899,
-0.0373263061,
0.0488387719,
0.0481359884,
0.0061406926,
-0.0601826608,
-0.0715039149,
0.0045368299,
0.0111475755,
0.0178876705,
0.0010132301,
-0.0309798066,
-0.0461452939,
0.0203785375,
0.0177635178,
-0.0231789071,
0.008568367,
0.0549189821,
0.0644432008,
0.0010726355,
-0.0387070924,
-0.0224900618,
-0.0159703828,
0.0327734612,
-0.0412491933,
-0.0082525807,
-5.601963796e-33,
-0.0348495655,
-0.0094926199,
0.0618537888,
0.0057391967,
-0.0293745976,
0.0031510263,
-0.019289583,
0.0066625606,
-0.0127958013,
0.0025194089,
-0.0491745025,
-0.0064393347,
0.0194345322,
0.0252126213,
-0.0173460376,
-0.0758519545,
0.016389586,
-0.0050140535,
-0.0370355994,
0.0083697643,
0.0099254111,
0.0593149886,
0.0704341382,
-0.0504766777,
0.0332190655,
-0.0062846402,
-0.0101400623,
0.0168898534,
-0.0092759589,
0.0453305393,
-0.0048397109,
0.0344929956,
0.0351438336,
-0.0632352158,
0.0062810238,
0.014730257,
-0.0808561444,
-0.0517753027,
0.0136412336,
0.0158403199,
-0.066803664,
0.0035729092,
0.0278100315,
-0.0378867276,
0.0143549945,
0.012516493,
0.0040806169,
-0.0186995845,
0.0059086252,
0.0058547151,
-0.0201675054,
0.0108630536,
0.0246558916,
-0.0286230668,
-0.0247697383,
0.0282883123,
-0.0069438149,
0.0030039104,
-0.0445632488,
-0.0021558921,
-0.0198088568,
0.0196823068,
0.0123836752,
-0.023348067,
-0.0054788562,
0.0553355627,
0.0023036969,
-0.0164661761,
-0.0410954356,
-0.01755579,
0.0088362284,
0.0629540235,
0.0325289071,
0.015317264,
0.0387891531,
0.0353457928,
-0.0137140369,
0.0429319181,
0.0433146246,
0.0353691913,
0.0110938549,
0.00878458,
-0.0725024268,
-0.0000070099,
-0.005889242,
0.0730321556,
-0.0164603144,
-0.0583863743,
0.0431052968,
0.0301603489,
-0.0352941379,
-0.009163674,
0.0153549863,
-0.037848942,
-0.0136096608,
0.0018151097,
-0.0057409662,
-0.0153897405,
-0.0178437661,
0.0214982554,
-0.0318448283,
-0.0392702296,
0.0232615154,
0.0098696053,
-0.009626111,
-0.0077939248,
0.0214755274,
0.0208598841,
-0.0698653311,
0.0266633183,
-0.0377082191,
0.0518736988,
-0.0168927498,
-0.0251961779,
0.0313859843,
0.019743843,
-0.0062088328,
0.0405581631,
0.0326571055,
-0.0285302456,
-0.0216868091,
0.0250497647,
-0.0026524421,
-0.0157899018,
-0.0091676135,
0.0403282829,
-0.0056963242,
0.0177661162,
-0.0416638553,
-0.0388493575,
0.0188303255,
0.027374994,
2.444e-7,
0.0149440002,
0.0428749733,
0.0251221713,
0.0555193722,
-0.0150855584,
0.0010688808,
-0.0014966057,
0.0241104122,
-0.021601079,
-0.0609966703,
0.0068247244,
0.0696050376,
0.0331826471,
0.0181070697,
-0.1362774968,
-0.020443745,
-0.058563374,
-0.014275155,
-0.0545929968,
-0.0151995458,
0.1086334586,
0.0718603805,
0.0198700447,
-0.0016067594,
-0.0234091897,
-0.0558723621,
0.0597143359,
-0.0021480187,
-0.028849978,
0.0119529329,
0.0301045254,
0.0283379704,
0.020955367,
0.036322996,
0.0137263779,
-0.0196912568,
0.0193448458,
0.0332434252,
0.0374113359,
-0.0632251501,
0.0010186086,
-0.0256766453,
0.0113403825,
-0.0377125479,
0.094409503,
-0.0452620313,
0.0089221997,
-0.0222465359,
-0.0145484908,
-0.0308665093,
0.0124887768,
-0.0116974004,
-0.033139132,
0.0233801175,
0.0076031266,
-0.0158209372,
-0.0127732055,
-0.0932359695,
-0.0084481938,
-0.0196625199,
-0.0470069125,
-0.018653065,
-0.0143026365,
0.0177147612,
-0.0150712086,
-0.0640178621,
-0.0253774896,
2.298165383e-34,
0.0061422973,
-0.0042247614,
0.0316725709,
0.0230083819,
0.0379996076,
0.0205038581,
0.0200876687,
-0.0098259235,
-0.0010761358,
0.0080553275,
-0.0093275867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09712v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09712v1 | Semi-Offline Reinforcement Learning for Optimized Text Generation | 2023-06-16T09:24:29 | 2023-06-16T09:24:29 | Changyu Chen, Xiting Wang, Yiqiao Jin, Victor Ye Dong, Li Dong, Jie Cao, Yi Liu, Rui Yan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In reinforcement learning (RL), there are two major settings for interacting
with the environment: online and offline. Online methods explore the
environment at significant time cost, and offline methods efficiently obtain
reward signals by sacrificing exploration capability. We propose semi-offline
RL, a novel paradigm that smoothly transits from offline to online settings,
balances exploration capability and training cost, and provides a theoretical
foundation for comparing different RL settings. Based on the semi-offline
formulation, we present the RL setting that is optimal in terms of optimization
cost, asymptotic error, and overfitting error bound. Extensive experiments show
that our semi-offline approach is efficient and yields comparable or often
better performance compared with state-of-the-art methods. | [
0.0375455581,
0.0647527501,
0.0201987941,
-0.0538097434,
-0.0319290906,
0.0000439066,
0.0418994538,
0.0161235929,
-0.0407403409,
0.0048401612,
0.0206323266,
-0.0431561284,
-0.0139328288,
0.0431420393,
-0.0128433993,
-0.0427074358,
-0.0064175357,
-0.0389047265,
0.001588352,
-0.0045529902,
0.0074449601,
0.0099856956,
-0.0202121623,
0.0075712982,
0.0071871565,
-0.0099256067,
-0.029300686,
-0.0091016628,
0.0283776205,
-0.0297093783,
0.0008791351,
-0.0011939537,
0.0593350343,
0.0226443317,
0.0000020026,
-0.0303855222,
-0.072386995,
-0.0187456235,
0.0211000592,
-0.0223383363,
0.0549871586,
-0.0034136623,
-0.0258559994,
0.0293357931,
-0.0057068211,
0.0023706858,
0.0661627278,
0.0059735267,
0.0180964097,
0.0876635388,
0.0028832119,
0.0392952971,
-0.0067803189,
-0.0498833247,
0.0384590775,
-0.008441342,
0.0162891224,
-0.002014535,
0.0062851137,
-0.0611971803,
-0.026249731,
0.0000182286,
0.0342491604,
0.0006239264,
0.0039063827,
0.0788076967,
0.0050052386,
-0.0309930015,
0.0163559932,
0.0508192144,
-0.0428716205,
-0.0094913244,
0.0603201017,
-0.0418371633,
-0.0452499315,
-0.0025283257,
-0.0039377101,
0.0896937922,
-0.0450056866,
0.0403583385,
-0.0222800896,
0.0095343031,
-0.0175582059,
0.0216216091,
-0.0240447242,
0.0300463345,
-0.0315349102,
-0.0747618824,
-0.0201458726,
0.0268836282,
-0.0346636251,
-0.0196623299,
0.0148320198,
0.015368267,
-0.0525889322,
0.0175472517,
-0.0653091669,
-0.0159489773,
-0.0260237399,
0.03227593,
0.0577728935,
0.008008169,
0.0668443143,
0.0007913293,
-0.0136262979,
0.026221538,
0.0052559613,
-0.0176210161,
-0.0118154176,
0.0531798899,
-0.065167807,
-0.0065950188,
-0.0658379793,
0.0605648197,
-0.0496279672,
-0.0520376042,
-0.049507577,
0.0082911802,
0.0156012177,
0.0326962061,
0.0059781442,
0.0055561773,
-0.0804494396,
0.0269827526,
-0.0125942323,
-0.0344615318,
-0.0179995578,
-0.0260322019,
0.034107998,
-0.0147661408,
0.0022902817,
0.0059152241,
0.0619400069,
-0.0164244361,
-0.0156221827,
0.0811246037,
-0.0575181209,
-0.0551035143,
-0.0020854839,
-0.0527164899,
0.0033639802,
-0.0528344363,
0.0025614039,
-0.0357627012,
0.0183137078,
-0.046008151,
-0.0284740105,
0.0274395514,
0.0179929156,
0.0269572977,
0.0235844906,
-0.0041918387,
0.0092673525,
-0.0028492559,
0.0270041507,
-0.0173344724,
0.0083233491,
0.0705126375,
0.0404115096,
0.0562805906,
-0.0116757965,
0.0387289375,
0.000055299,
0.0090544214,
0.0763480216,
0.0242824201,
-0.0291548241,
-0.0449796021,
0.0095623536,
0.0738273412,
0.017591292,
0.0198247675,
-0.0822080523,
0.0955664366,
0.0885053203,
0.0057638055,
0.0473353565,
-0.014245755,
0.0380481742,
0.0561938956,
-0.0488699973,
-0.0074572186,
0.0070893471,
0.0458803028,
0.0292970911,
0.0644677803,
0.0377127826,
0.0148070995,
0.0042264946,
-0.0370348543,
0.0082616685,
-0.020517163,
0.0142648155,
-0.0095389346,
0.0143056186,
0.0298998281,
-0.0640285909,
-0.0380682163,
0.0149944071,
-0.0344043672,
0.0165004954,
-0.014438848,
0.0416388102,
0.0504990779,
0.088482894,
0.005534112,
-0.011017344,
-0.0680618286,
-0.0000179139,
0.105504781,
-0.0195216835,
0.0050057285,
-0.0003661159,
-0.0627736375,
-0.003865035,
-0.0292429347,
-0.0164154489,
0.0399650894,
0.0523844101,
0.0543243475,
-0.0048603197,
0.0004958731,
-0.0308385957,
0.016638251,
-0.0203814059,
-0.0460179821,
-0.0095867673,
0.0262026805,
0.0013637656,
-0.0607875399,
-0.0404190607,
0.007957303,
-0.0279574879,
-0.0204798337,
-0.0698930398,
-0.027604701,
-0.0480758324,
-0.0562925972,
-0.0331979021,
-0.0493086353,
0.0464666374,
-0.0250174291,
0.0073691481,
-0.0314186476,
-0.031774573,
-0.0412517078,
0.0416433178,
-0.0048376317,
-0.0038586627,
0.0408991128,
0.0122738602,
-0.0141009027,
0.0514848344,
-0.0319088772,
0.0314160399,
0.0153804654,
-0.0000641751,
-0.0299799126,
-0.0514994822,
0.0023137662,
-0.0096057337,
-0.0143119199,
-0.0066850437,
0.0221218374,
0.0803582072,
-0.0188156217,
-0.0445723832,
0.0067878766,
0.0207563657,
-0.0053561181,
0.0221864711,
0.0546848439,
0.0043108403,
-0.0166923106,
-0.0218704902,
-0.0138025051,
0.0069997823,
0.0068952208,
0.0266238991,
0.0563896932,
0.0174474381,
0.0257562697,
0.0022977896,
0.0009456384,
0.0218229126,
0.0225084443,
-0.0032581547,
0.0106115667,
-0.0288589057,
0.0020837383,
-0.0807992071,
0.0097224824,
0.0109682968,
-0.0153842485,
0.0095844483,
-0.0341200717,
0.0304544996,
0.0653140545,
0.048279535,
0.0390313379,
0.039979849,
0.0125455521,
-0.0651665553,
0.0373806953,
-0.0282310881,
-0.0029706925,
0.0345893465,
-0.0226039253,
0.0511436872,
0.0639788061,
-0.0117988167,
0.0288709309,
-0.0452021211,
0.0455442257,
-0.0128905233,
-0.0421477407,
-0.0046050791,
0.0247234702,
-0.0297132283,
-0.0144978967,
-0.0279517844,
-0.0702851117,
0.0791861266,
0.0293292142,
-0.0111541599,
-0.0504494533,
-0.0155887213,
0.0016969532,
-0.0092829922,
0.014561153,
0.0410888046,
0.0169852972,
-0.0238120127,
-0.0395947546,
-0.023476718,
0.0717004687,
-0.0011917518,
-0.0115503771,
-0.0240373947,
0.0281140301,
-0.0285257306,
-0.0455192737,
-0.0021879598,
-0.0195486601,
0.0256735086,
-0.0496200547,
0.0045871399,
-0.0272743516,
-0.0103576956,
0.016729638,
0.0288500804,
0.0790550038,
-0.0018348688,
-0.0387228914,
-0.0330441333,
0.0482308716,
0.0327357613,
0.0010207136,
-0.0366530642,
-0.0329010934,
0.0136890113,
0.0416608974,
0.0081969332,
-0.0193766076,
0.0472782962,
-0.0062555391,
0.0152536416,
-0.0552831553,
-0.0207656603,
0.0555168092,
0.0091314996,
-0.0324900337,
-0.0684204847,
0.0580772832,
0.0277345795,
-0.0367556922,
-0.0141956238,
0.0108353589,
0.0670685694,
-0.0193583574,
0.0310200099,
-0.0408527292,
0.0052937684,
-0.0109198196,
0.0674674734,
-0.0245914012,
-0.0429939628,
-0.0499397144,
-0.0930225849,
0.0097312704,
-0.0120536592,
-0.0484126508,
0.029039681,
0.0092814546,
-0.0429698788,
-0.0011937913,
-0.0168997496,
0.0381630585,
-0.0149727194,
0.0366342515,
0.02293415,
0.0053746896,
-0.029430246,
-0.0365721695,
-0.0144592077,
0.0161353201,
0.0690764114,
0.0506278835,
0.0215814579,
-0.0151794571,
-0.0032124615,
0.0112952283,
0.0363404267,
-0.0218744129,
0.0260703806,
-0.0094335619,
0.0070142532,
-0.0051260963,
0.0320301689,
0.0222148728,
-0.0093068574,
0.0150996232,
0.0148256933,
0.0172191858,
-0.0173388086,
0.0306200124,
0.0120300464,
0.0637395605,
0.0165870208,
-0.0219792258,
-0.0659484044,
-0.0891782343,
0.000356219,
-0.0249692723,
-0.090052329,
0.0318787359,
-0.065532431,
-0.0100584924,
0.0180553179,
-0.1007392108,
-0.0202779714,
-0.0159392972,
0.1228904054,
-0.0451905206,
-0.0357477665,
-0.0030918177,
0.0126016447,
-0.0309324991,
-0.0225689821,
-0.0395839028,
-0.0006699272,
0.0044994205,
0.0044380641,
0.0094970297,
-0.0654343963,
0.0070610461,
-0.0236214511,
-0.054247167,
-0.0516456924,
-0.0135756591,
0.0270398129,
0.0200277437,
0.0729179531,
0.019513363,
-0.0171714947,
0.0933673009,
0.0341658443,
-0.0164696295,
0.0360170752,
0.0154034179,
0.0608221479,
0.0200060699,
0.031890817,
-0.0183961838,
-0.0161228906,
-0.0070772227,
0.0496511944,
0.0108881937,
0.0656878948,
0.0091813626,
-0.021181846,
-0.0023147091,
-0.0386204459,
-0.0497212484,
-0.0457359701,
0.0099895112,
0.0248469897,
-0.0129860416,
-0.0379597582,
0.0198477916,
0.0141826952,
0.0236832816,
0.0123028588,
0.0457228906,
0.0331809521,
0.0228438471,
-0.0178277604,
-0.0265511759,
0.0044375104,
0.010905127,
0.0652551875,
-0.0006009616,
-0.0146530904,
0.0085197538,
-0.0217547733,
0.037159618,
-0.0069331671,
0.0456476472,
0.0409545489,
0.0185150281,
0.0011798973,
0.0053332062,
-0.029310463,
0.0017151179,
-0.0656355768,
0.0342764221,
0.0302886795,
0.0444229953,
0.051357653,
-0.0289410353,
-0.0092959581,
0.0204569995,
0.0167443156,
-0.0275739823,
-0.0667406917,
-0.016675042,
0.0064923121,
-0.0028017787,
0.0054462268,
0.0849137679,
0.0049446221,
0.0233377665,
-0.0216238145,
0.0183042381,
-0.0556394942,
0.0062633785,
-0.0090177301,
0.0419383086,
0.0232981555,
-0.0326587744,
0.0032569771,
-0.0182589777,
0.0147682019,
0.045013193,
-0.0052758679,
-0.0120776035,
0.0660175607,
-0.007172267,
-0.0002021977,
0.0462522916,
-0.0646618456,
0.0076897633,
-0.0055530746,
0.0049676704,
-0.0127594555,
-5.944282445e-33,
-0.0176349562,
-0.0598322675,
0.0187605321,
-0.0549959131,
-0.0781020001,
0.0319811143,
-0.0137411021,
-0.0176261384,
0.068149969,
-0.0297679286,
-0.0231231097,
-0.030477453,
0.0128595615,
0.0432266966,
-0.0324751325,
-0.0142308837,
0.0375678837,
-0.0032980777,
-0.098625429,
0.0233696084,
0.0465528332,
0.0419198051,
0.0153142335,
0.0018857318,
-0.0014601018,
0.007417731,
-0.0513764992,
-0.0075248946,
-0.0035857735,
0.0302203633,
0.0048372853,
-0.0168352444,
0.0039274753,
-0.02241995,
-0.0173016544,
0.018390635,
-0.0177442543,
-0.0346606225,
-0.0425445363,
-0.0280979034,
-0.062363565,
-0.0068857828,
-0.0082072774,
-0.0242640171,
0.0077743409,
0.0312244724,
0.0115530947,
-0.0054501565,
-0.0642529726,
-0.0410967097,
-0.0681434497,
-0.0003987534,
-0.0062449211,
-0.007396182,
-0.008364873,
0.0374064781,
0.0096053528,
0.0029328295,
-0.0196183156,
0.035582196,
0.0225649569,
0.0286390465,
0.0429767966,
0.0131377485,
0.0286909789,
0.0291928817,
-0.0229358058,
0.002630624,
-0.024398651,
-0.00166353,
0.0111303004,
-0.0240049884,
-0.0165372342,
0.0491767824,
0.0333403163,
0.0232156143,
-0.0213774946,
0.0182890836,
0.0259380601,
-0.0147516448,
0.0588780642,
0.0295779314,
-0.0211061481,
-0.0059606638,
-0.0322612524,
-0.0254492518,
-0.0135984933,
-0.0478517376,
0.051456023,
0.089019008,
-0.0556613877,
-0.0719487742,
-0.0006952187,
0.0103042303,
-0.0031484074,
0.0171177275,
-0.028375892,
0.0286662728,
-0.0203802269,
-0.0359373614,
-0.0869698897,
-0.0644837692,
0.0070556281,
0.007801943,
-0.0236847047,
0.0321488455,
0.0087799998,
0.0387031548,
-0.0686800927,
0.0252404977,
-0.0228093322,
0.055315908,
-0.0080093266,
0.0132057695,
0.0606222488,
-0.0998861641,
-0.0232706387,
0.043191988,
0.03033299,
-0.0397269167,
-0.0162319001,
-0.0077963201,
-0.0188401751,
0.0008490925,
-0.0185457394,
0.0490753688,
-0.0337650739,
-0.0214449912,
-0.0132090831,
-0.0650827214,
0.0110469116,
0.0466300175,
2.672e-7,
-0.0348673277,
0.0274520162,
0.0461107641,
0.0014141201,
0.0260503981,
0.0027018858,
-0.0048519964,
0.0036901389,
-0.0362675413,
0.0312895365,
0.0338185802,
0.0127189169,
0.0418704413,
0.0168207046,
-0.0575751737,
0.0191756748,
-0.0858411863,
0.0170293692,
-0.0491369106,
-0.0510462485,
-0.0142155644,
0.0104394117,
-0.0149629433,
0.015859006,
0.0643662438,
-0.0070098308,
0.0578861348,
0.0239862371,
0.0075194594,
-0.0320742801,
-0.0006877691,
-0.0240647234,
-0.0294317249,
-0.0222880039,
-0.0153792268,
-0.0053952215,
-0.0168988276,
0.0738789663,
0.0461327061,
-0.0070455438,
0.0370074511,
-0.0167580545,
0.0384007432,
-0.0301516224,
0.050946407,
-0.0776428059,
0.0230514519,
0.0135879274,
0.0288383886,
-0.032561861,
0.0271461178,
-0.0635884404,
-0.0349009149,
0.0120590953,
0.0112358518,
0.0446357504,
0.0054337215,
-0.021879036,
-0.0075476626,
0.0140258949,
-0.0054939338,
-0.0592199452,
-0.0790893808,
0.0744783729,
0.0295675993,
-0.0589950569,
-0.0559535883,
2.336024108e-34,
0.0034275474,
-0.020722542,
0.0017178627,
-0.0202762466,
-0.0254540369,
0.0434975401,
0.013860601,
-0.0216731615,
0.0388918817,
-0.044311244,
-0.0329148397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09705v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09705v1 | Reducing Computational Costs in Sentiment Analysis: Tensorized Recurrent Networks vs. Recurrent Networks | 2023-06-16T09:18:08 | 2023-06-16T09:18:08 | Gabriel Lopez, Anna Nguyen, Joe Kaul | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Anticipating audience reaction towards a certain text is integral to several
facets of society ranging from politics, research, and commercial industries.
Sentiment analysis (SA) is a useful natural language processing (NLP) technique
that utilizes lexical/statistical and deep learning methods to determine
whether different-sized texts exhibit positive, negative, or neutral emotions.
Recurrent networks are widely used in machine-learning communities for problems
with sequential data. However, a drawback of models based on Long-Short Term
Memory networks and Gated Recurrent Units is the significantly high number of
parameters, and thus, such models are computationally expensive. This drawback
is even more significant when the available data are limited. Also, such models
require significant over-parameterization and regularization to achieve optimal
performance. Tensorized models represent a potential solution. In this paper,
we classify the sentiment of some social media posts. We compare traditional
recurrent models with their tensorized version, and we show that with the
tensorized models, we reach comparable performances with respect to the
traditional models while using fewer resources for the training. | [
0.0163602158,
0.0848969892,
0.003558937,
0.0354737155,
-0.0186194349,
0.0263162944,
-0.0015874961,
-0.0139838336,
0.0176368244,
-0.0680537522,
-0.0035567232,
-0.0755243525,
-0.0210085697,
0.02501164,
-0.0422095694,
-0.0555505678,
0.0154895997,
0.0418553799,
0.0757706538,
-0.0074455142,
0.0075723277,
0.0124490699,
0.0048048352,
-0.0051939692,
0.0048064878,
0.0235042665,
0.0109421015,
-0.0163593832,
0.0019703219,
-0.0403015874,
0.0436491743,
0.0370643847,
0.0163202062,
0.0508510992,
0.0000017576,
0.0072112181,
0.0068829209,
-0.0535175949,
0.0371365659,
0.0054044835,
0.0713901296,
-0.048678387,
0.0080360435,
0.006063302,
-0.0314901508,
-0.0326725245,
0.0385895073,
0.0555784032,
0.0420556217,
0.0757267699,
-0.0090784822,
-0.0164905321,
0.0105213169,
-0.0130622741,
-0.0049161287,
-0.0115626873,
0.0152357351,
-0.0632148758,
-0.0101361796,
-0.0067994539,
-0.0007391812,
0.0258611962,
-0.0102230087,
0.0226218607,
0.0174920615,
0.0090514747,
0.0314184017,
-0.004395524,
-0.007348414,
0.0411824211,
-0.0289622657,
-0.0406626649,
0.0216082297,
-0.0044371886,
-0.0291888975,
-0.0357404239,
-0.0102848448,
-0.0139488727,
0.0114675919,
0.040850684,
0.0287748445,
0.0367195792,
0.0313675143,
0.031443648,
-0.0196157508,
0.0040201829,
-0.0056267325,
-0.0406241752,
-0.0280425549,
0.0169704854,
0.0197661221,
-0.0177132711,
0.012309392,
0.0213932656,
0.0154988505,
-0.0154094817,
-0.0056965523,
-0.0893882439,
-0.0055702501,
-0.1081112772,
0.0235185847,
0.0049389163,
0.0233256519,
0.0383634791,
-0.0257486999,
0.0041497485,
-0.0102212746,
-0.0409754589,
0.0101040285,
0.0205179993,
-0.0408870541,
0.032141488,
-0.0040562875,
0.0251816381,
-0.0127295442,
-0.0298408885,
-0.0549491011,
0.0044181375,
-0.0308398679,
-0.0059419819,
0.0081108427,
0.0626976714,
0.0273628924,
0.0020918893,
-0.0415429436,
0.0564548969,
-0.0203801021,
0.0125182662,
-0.0703195855,
-0.0204010773,
0.0180697981,
0.0360859334,
0.0615776032,
0.0094675329,
0.0081233457,
0.0596049801,
0.0131031116,
-0.0259932019,
-0.0409934595,
-0.0014233767,
0.0215246715,
-0.0565850437,
0.0179984346,
-0.0465096384,
0.0509978496,
-0.0066497289,
-0.0140760541,
-0.0191497952,
0.0052493145,
-0.0004417327,
-0.0257921331,
0.0463615432,
0.0014964337,
-0.0278654713,
0.015042414,
0.0154941035,
0.0429469012,
0.0171223711,
0.0231606867,
0.0723016933,
0.030951269,
-0.0268994793,
0.0327985324,
-0.0238205083,
0.0024738864,
-0.044780422,
-0.0258509796,
-0.0256296024,
-0.0337133072,
0.0406308994,
0.0098781679,
0.0585225709,
-0.0049223136,
-0.0161405765,
0.0413804576,
0.0185382739,
-0.0043278178,
0.0484891534,
0.0142963193,
0.0076759169,
-0.0069886521,
-0.0369811244,
-0.0438885689,
0.0362608694,
0.0086215492,
-0.019755017,
0.0251374003,
-0.0175864287,
-0.0371150784,
-0.0293433815,
0.0040977551,
-0.0428858623,
0.0748474598,
-0.0142064774,
0.0498724729,
-0.0324745812,
-0.0668783784,
0.0237291101,
-0.0048772478,
-0.0447688885,
-0.0015675435,
0.0047395397,
0.0501955226,
0.0594917759,
-0.0241739377,
-0.0301665273,
-0.0096702566,
-0.0362038687,
-0.0025427677,
0.0235950202,
0.0531281382,
0.0080282735,
0.0129494686,
-0.0623929985,
0.0255343635,
-0.020510368,
0.0082021914,
0.0135382693,
-0.0358498171,
0.0376019143,
0.0179512296,
0.0457894988,
-0.0340234041,
-0.003256612,
0.0086549595,
-0.0653824657,
0.0280478019,
0.0355423093,
0.0673077554,
0.0426759757,
0.027811246,
-0.0053471695,
0.0257349666,
-0.063026689,
-0.0696103126,
-0.0242116004,
-0.0286833961,
-0.0127367424,
0.0114620207,
0.0010984777,
-0.0025666186,
0.0427809581,
-0.0636630952,
-0.0457435697,
0.1176397875,
-0.036882855,
0.0210831705,
-0.0005917842,
-0.0301908962,
-0.0066767288,
0.0175648481,
0.0045762784,
0.0312394146,
-0.0338391252,
-0.0060624206,
-0.017379554,
-0.0657936409,
0.0290616788,
-0.001658001,
-0.0674726367,
0.0177119337,
0.0104728527,
0.0018852605,
0.0412798561,
-0.007539175,
0.0015612525,
-0.0473669209,
-0.116944246,
0.0125966109,
-0.0286444332,
0.0349506252,
-0.0081384601,
-0.002295244,
0.0256396607,
0.0020383729,
-0.0561978519,
-0.0033933397,
0.0071073319,
0.0257518869,
0.0550680272,
-0.0050509968,
0.0003425208,
-0.0395319276,
-0.029040318,
-0.004577294,
0.0083374698,
-0.0060930988,
-0.0311040152,
-0.0096073113,
-0.0266278293,
-0.0453251377,
0.0519463494,
0.0033252074,
-0.0408991724,
-0.0169261266,
-0.0092787966,
0.0278119873,
0.0313920192,
0.0362416692,
0.0371976532,
-0.0078624813,
0.0359415896,
0.0101519404,
0.0220681448,
-0.0368041322,
0.0170381479,
-0.0053421129,
-0.0102903256,
-0.0133922808,
0.0782663077,
0.0139681688,
0.0028181411,
-0.0452566408,
0.0022503224,
-0.0096840207,
0.0107230674,
-0.0053226785,
-0.0112491306,
0.0244085882,
0.0032646866,
0.0177054256,
-0.0230078455,
0.0361594409,
0.0091480631,
0.0104415277,
-0.0485590138,
-0.0496183001,
-0.0664389804,
0.0179702584,
0.0069228839,
0.0054753451,
-0.0597439483,
0.0209487565,
0.0147401812,
-0.0242526643,
-0.0015468922,
-0.0189139824,
0.0019355078,
0.0010707417,
-0.0033986168,
-0.0259460248,
-0.0292751007,
0.0023096104,
-0.0050877957,
-0.045383282,
-0.0169612728,
-0.0013900733,
-0.0219218303,
0.0087747807,
0.0009259849,
-0.0286196247,
-0.0002255571,
-0.0187737048,
0.0159354042,
0.011666338,
0.0711540431,
0.0141677819,
-0.024072459,
0.0006345254,
0.0168816652,
-0.0011786558,
0.0350126959,
0.0212102141,
0.0193317458,
-0.1009080783,
-0.0449023582,
0.011972581,
-0.0230442006,
-0.0166421961,
-0.0161061231,
-0.002707307,
-0.0566335954,
0.032607235,
0.1199955493,
-0.0055695432,
-0.0476404391,
-0.0292149745,
0.0587585643,
-0.03271202,
0.0205104705,
-0.0151792439,
-0.0462993458,
-0.01391441,
-0.032829456,
0.0133424541,
-0.0036566507,
-0.0497885384,
-0.0026362678,
-0.0628697351,
-0.0006259705,
-0.020221686,
0.0080265189,
-0.0507319011,
-0.0368971005,
-0.0220773946,
-0.0272982009,
0.0099376282,
-0.0416461974,
0.0273991358,
-0.0105519546,
0.000855052,
-0.0431765057,
-0.0071036359,
0.010001421,
-0.0075904345,
0.0316427425,
-0.0387144536,
0.0636263117,
-0.0192502085,
-0.0544770993,
0.0438160375,
0.0134690125,
0.0049358243,
-0.0162448138,
0.0358407237,
-0.0313414223,
-0.0219243504,
0.0046942555,
0.0222493615,
-0.079643324,
0.0223234128,
-0.0414338186,
0.0804657042,
-0.008486582,
-0.0967766196,
-0.0352973863,
0.0295908414,
0.0445296057,
0.0454848558,
0.006638932,
-0.0711376816,
-0.0519596674,
0.0213819519,
-0.0041944683,
-0.0465315729,
-0.0025700924,
-0.077013135,
0.0368086137,
-0.0293380022,
-0.0732052624,
-0.0286138058,
-0.0172949061,
-0.0104955984,
-0.0339762829,
0.0206849687,
0.0332639776,
-0.0082999514,
-0.0521661788,
0.0540294051,
0.0162182134,
0.015684057,
-0.0233273171,
-0.0113979746,
0.0412119068,
0.0096872952,
-0.0160941146,
-0.0350927226,
-0.1123969555,
-0.0332051888,
-0.0155498702,
0.0335395299,
0.008133281,
-0.0387904644,
-0.0015069308,
-0.0423699692,
0.0583931208,
0.0217776336,
-0.0529562719,
0.0028465451,
0.0808325335,
0.0628693029,
-0.0104473513,
0.0144139752,
-0.0033154374,
0.0562798232,
-0.0158388894,
-0.0551731735,
-0.0221141763,
-0.0152315432,
-0.0326624513,
-0.0141088236,
0.0798228234,
0.0391418822,
-0.0118295886,
-0.0355311409,
-0.0344517902,
0.0302885976,
-0.0044034771,
-0.025719922,
-0.0061336551,
0.029793594,
0.0205550343,
-0.0773901269,
-0.035622146,
0.0460180119,
-0.010164734,
0.006034479,
0.0596409142,
0.0432268716,
0.0111499885,
0.0168477707,
0.0370149314,
-0.0670666769,
0.0296283811,
-0.0149978716,
-0.0092136245,
-0.0087008737,
0.0247803945,
0.0051999628,
0.0326023474,
-0.0347182006,
0.0424087569,
-0.0252522882,
-0.0560746379,
0.001417103,
0.0180933755,
0.0164076407,
-0.0147356605,
0.0264308695,
-0.0233924091,
0.0245482363,
-0.0076146061,
0.0345114619,
-0.0017476674,
-0.0011556088,
0.0274433568,
0.0046124612,
-0.0317284353,
0.0392330512,
0.0653208569,
-0.0281937197,
0.0203721635,
0.0395858586,
-0.0021148596,
-0.0343847238,
-0.0021151518,
0.0331301689,
0.0355370566,
0.0130890962,
0.0435494632,
-0.0095635625,
-0.0380667597,
0.0717816129,
-0.0480834395,
0.01827465,
-0.0292706508,
0.0312618725,
0.024123095,
0.0217805356,
0.0815350413,
-0.0249102842,
0.0341257453,
-0.0170395449,
-0.0649516359,
-0.0703140125,
-6.219453917e-33,
0.0417146198,
0.0295570455,
-0.0386932828,
0.0193366315,
-0.0145783871,
0.0085869571,
-0.0478698462,
0.0211440176,
0.0095830448,
0.0177365635,
-0.0030805413,
0.0039703604,
-0.0172548704,
0.0423321091,
0.0569753572,
-0.0462351255,
0.0525995903,
-0.0093792994,
0.0175446849,
0.0511936173,
0.0643732026,
0.0229091104,
0.0460821874,
-0.1148267984,
0.0260882098,
-0.0190709997,
0.0082881507,
0.0166800413,
0.0658489764,
0.0183171649,
-0.0358783863,
0.0600800663,
0.0551610924,
-0.0383361988,
0.0094323447,
0.0644596294,
-0.0363942459,
-0.0333282016,
-0.0334817208,
-0.017037401,
-0.0646124557,
-0.0295798462,
0.0151265543,
0.043720983,
-0.0277047083,
0.0122724082,
0.0259501897,
0.0022432774,
-0.0074100196,
-0.0681244433,
-0.0397070609,
0.018956298,
-0.0154663455,
0.0310196914,
0.0070728739,
0.0280126352,
0.0013095181,
0.060546279,
-0.0743524954,
-0.0064677144,
-0.0561480001,
0.0012108681,
-0.0016362823,
-0.0450066812,
-0.0095191989,
0.0263585169,
-0.0042817774,
0.0276666824,
-0.0322240479,
0.0454701073,
-0.0138228312,
-0.0003101018,
0.0708830059,
0.0350829102,
0.0597737916,
-0.0663684085,
-0.035458196,
-0.0083994642,
0.0715641752,
0.0383924767,
0.0539405011,
0.0106523708,
-0.0237796176,
-0.0145957172,
0.0169139393,
-0.066752024,
-0.0216195863,
-0.022809865,
-0.0303774737,
0.0267361403,
-0.0068390728,
-0.0306212828,
0.0067494437,
-0.0403062031,
0.0249718502,
0.0698675662,
0.009424217,
0.0317100361,
0.0206286758,
-0.0077033211,
-0.0663228184,
-0.0052901004,
-0.0212477352,
-0.0154089825,
0.0201086774,
-0.0087211318,
0.0313584916,
0.0519972779,
-0.0548818856,
-0.0108078234,
-0.0222351104,
0.0358802602,
-0.0103099914,
0.0837451592,
0.0017553838,
-0.0046109841,
-0.0060362448,
0.0551893115,
-0.0087469891,
0.0711570308,
-0.0031893514,
-0.0275283214,
0.0124250641,
-0.0157434847,
-0.0433684103,
-0.06331487,
-0.0111034689,
-0.0074357097,
-0.0021129046,
-0.0794837326,
0.0130389109,
-0.0158620439,
2.673e-7,
-0.0043732636,
0.0627489612,
-0.0007136452,
-0.0196013134,
0.0742494911,
0.0551838242,
0.0476332754,
0.0508479252,
0.0141018536,
0.0115270801,
0.0469613113,
0.0243645869,
0.0077437675,
-0.0006119478,
-0.0881337151,
-0.0295752101,
-0.0752746984,
0.0250236299,
0.0011106113,
0.0133809801,
0.0381897353,
0.103385292,
0.0606065914,
-0.0069844504,
0.0057677161,
-0.0314193703,
0.0284488555,
-0.0503624864,
0.020470852,
0.0097237024,
0.045535367,
0.0099291261,
-0.0208697822,
-0.0473968424,
-0.0086815804,
0.0258330833,
-0.0235765129,
0.0462704152,
0.0175304972,
-0.0313046351,
0.0404687487,
-0.0166636109,
0.0094668306,
-0.0046428312,
0.0440831706,
-0.0482353643,
-0.0414886586,
-0.0798081979,
0.0135638695,
0.0024076472,
0.0716020167,
0.000569009,
-0.0131322239,
0.021970097,
0.0155397588,
-0.0482276231,
-0.0110118007,
-0.1104957759,
0.027841581,
0.0328008495,
-0.0272491574,
0.0116865961,
0.0117256884,
0.0283276495,
0.0841374025,
-0.0048358892,
0.0263391193,
1.869560972e-34,
0.0623398125,
-0.040041782,
-0.0182195045,
-0.0015819663,
0.0195749234,
-0.0065486198,
-0.0685360357,
-0.0385622829,
0.0609976836,
-0.048475109,
0.0006517522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09704v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09704v2 | Cross-corpus Readability Compatibility Assessment for English Texts | 2023-06-16T09:15:39 | 2023-09-13T09:43:28 | Zhenzhen Li, Han Ding, Shaohong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text readability assessment has gained significant attention from researchers
in various domains. However, the lack of exploration into corpus compatibility
poses a challenge as different research groups utilize different corpora. In
this study, we propose a novel evaluation framework, Cross-corpus text
Readability Compatibility Assessment (CRCA), to address this issue. The
framework encompasses three key components: (1) Corpus: CEFR, CLEC, CLOTH, NES,
OSP, and RACE. Linguistic features, GloVe word vector representations, and
their fusion features were extracted. (2) Classification models: Machine
learning methods (XGBoost, SVM) and deep learning methods (BiLSTM,
Attention-BiLSTM) were employed. (3) Compatibility metrics: RJSD, RRNSS, and
NDCG metrics. Our findings revealed: (1) Validated corpus compatibility, with
OSP standing out as significantly different from other datasets. (2) An
adaptation effect among corpora, feature representations, and classification
methods. (3) Consistent outcomes across the three metrics, validating the
robustness of the compatibility assessment framework. The outcomes of this
study offer valuable insights into corpus selection, feature representation,
and classification methods, and it can also serve as a beginning effort for
cross-corpus transfer learning. | [
-0.0051171435,
0.0057781748,
-0.0086312583,
0.0336156785,
-0.0450963564,
0.0403238162,
0.0046932194,
-0.0142717371,
0.0302607492,
-0.0437157154,
-0.0464658774,
-0.0184473563,
0.0500672273,
0.0197892357,
-0.010937525,
-0.0365123674,
0.0094250776,
0.015441265,
0.0129014179,
0.0200004596,
0.0433173627,
0.0300029218,
0.0040814271,
0.0391715132,
0.007385368,
-0.0575819537,
0.0313345753,
-0.0036599713,
0.026735438,
0.012140559,
0.0339570306,
0.0240775384,
0.0012685341,
0.047115881,
0.0000020029,
-0.0159225445,
-0.0261924323,
-0.0111334464,
0.0367105417,
-0.0052997284,
0.0980165675,
-0.0202439874,
-0.0187146179,
0.0083964579,
0.013208244,
0.004169947,
0.0555473268,
0.0621062592,
0.0400610045,
0.0764106438,
-0.0227192547,
-0.0152706606,
0.002961067,
0.0371453725,
-0.0159571245,
-0.0066401106,
0.0003117604,
0.0072526573,
0.0334849693,
-0.008001064,
-0.0156410709,
0.0304826293,
-0.0137399565,
-0.0161510017,
0.0029130571,
-0.0144636389,
-0.011476255,
-0.0024713348,
-0.0002580847,
0.0849169642,
-0.0164125673,
-0.0428107828,
-0.0252991691,
0.0239853393,
-0.0154978372,
0.0125289327,
-0.0081509575,
-0.0443949811,
-0.0195175093,
0.032759387,
0.0148399351,
0.0035263656,
0.0220857672,
0.012694858,
-0.010462624,
0.084165737,
0.031739343,
-0.0384352319,
0.0113921473,
0.0175117329,
0.0383217596,
0.0208779089,
0.0806549266,
-0.0283879992,
-0.009628443,
0.0135503393,
-0.0632594898,
-0.0831310526,
0.0074347397,
-0.0239006765,
0.0177904349,
0.0302811023,
-0.0342938192,
0.0188262966,
-0.0278125443,
0.0159961674,
0.0022616289,
0.0326352082,
-0.0294732675,
-0.0032391853,
-0.0286717825,
0.0379530899,
-0.0062865843,
-0.0062217661,
-0.0366790034,
-0.0345870256,
-0.0521000475,
-0.0283450559,
0.026086675,
-0.0365723483,
0.0291882679,
-0.0170133971,
-0.0247288514,
0.0303745512,
-0.0006431146,
0.0313607045,
-0.0137301907,
0.0264577325,
-0.0258107334,
-0.0251111817,
0.0360213593,
0.0169057101,
-0.0036346782,
-0.0380318053,
-0.0205949228,
0.0072146892,
-0.0292271841,
-0.0076927673,
-0.0546900332,
0.0435186625,
-0.0365284234,
-0.0064244419,
-0.0253310762,
-0.0538978539,
0.0171218123,
-0.0304513164,
0.0504902899,
-0.0177898556,
-0.0325805731,
0.0333458595,
-0.0223646089,
0.0497528836,
-0.0075976937,
-0.004786253,
0.0349965654,
-0.0053358627,
0.0221624635,
0.0267664846,
0.0542465597,
-0.0147135025,
0.0530108884,
-0.047817789,
-0.0341342166,
0.018665947,
-0.0619804636,
-0.0006865645,
0.0272392053,
-0.0319573618,
-0.0088454243,
0.0208173972,
0.0281827673,
0.0091634057,
0.0100802518,
-0.0600069761,
0.0687573552,
0.0503104739,
0.083467871,
0.045036111,
0.0416885912,
0.0427794866,
0.0049759103,
0.0189606231,
0.006581312,
-0.0248277988,
-0.020849485,
0.0244141817,
0.0121626584,
0.0496659353,
0.0006850766,
-0.0454361364,
0.00563969,
0.0179920662,
0.0475547723,
-0.0427069217,
0.0335925892,
-0.0267750211,
-0.0507001951,
-0.0265009683,
0.0043620421,
-0.0921347588,
0.007108863,
0.0131289279,
0.0289281923,
0.0752787516,
0.0186908133,
-0.0214534458,
0.0039723143,
0.0202640593,
-0.0293939337,
0.0181346443,
0.0210252758,
0.0165551864,
0.0416436829,
-0.0629448891,
-0.0144080492,
0.0265209246,
-0.0035242888,
0.0363602228,
-0.0584036075,
0.0614297092,
0.0258698259,
-0.0555541255,
-0.0860723704,
0.047524821,
-0.0225555617,
-0.01507043,
0.0217759609,
0.022934271,
0.0499459356,
0.0317428634,
-0.0041706041,
-0.0063846293,
-0.0158999804,
-0.0219842531,
0.0194706023,
0.0394165181,
-0.040709611,
-0.0096833538,
-0.0091139842,
-0.0725263655,
0.0044780793,
0.0714306384,
-0.0089204526,
-0.0297480747,
0.0030892158,
-0.0235644337,
-0.0013171944,
-0.0448320359,
0.0314472876,
-0.0194502696,
0.0263460819,
-0.0308869071,
-0.0246345699,
0.0488543697,
0.0108727748,
-0.0132635282,
-0.0496240482,
0.0257438328,
-0.0108374152,
-0.0433046706,
0.0101324972,
-0.0251225606,
0.0467059873,
0.0263146795,
0.031352818,
-0.0777507722,
-0.011460796,
-0.0890251249,
0.0021809628,
-0.0116926124,
0.0284907389,
-0.0101371016,
-0.0293959398,
-0.0221759137,
0.0127941044,
-0.017260503,
0.0022063204,
-0.052294746,
0.0055346387,
0.0016251137,
-0.0349489525,
0.0334989168,
-0.0453655943,
-0.033715412,
0.0083254185,
0.0639508665,
0.0093582068,
-0.0237083305,
-0.0681312382,
0.0406042896,
0.0199555829,
-0.0167895518,
0.0411657579,
-0.0270067919,
0.0134851644,
0.0093677696,
0.0212929044,
0.0647856742,
0.0088337632,
-0.0172155406,
0.0439630151,
-0.0277295038,
-0.0578058809,
-0.0074638161,
0.014630219,
-0.0027883945,
-0.005019261,
-0.0540871546,
0.0291010384,
0.0400622413,
-0.032321997,
-0.0329683423,
-0.0687672719,
-0.0501786992,
-0.0364614762,
-0.0672179088,
-0.053989172,
0.0048956363,
-0.0038698872,
0.0198985934,
-0.0407961868,
-0.0164314136,
0.0564219169,
-0.0679524839,
0.0057129371,
-0.1160102338,
0.0052339118,
-0.0278797429,
-0.0021579321,
-0.0161304697,
0.0185030382,
0.0109256888,
-0.0572276525,
0.0093314201,
0.021671176,
0.0120623456,
-0.030246079,
0.0186788775,
-0.0347966701,
-0.0170454346,
0.0010547437,
-0.0012679577,
-0.0127339829,
-0.0322193615,
-0.0065871174,
-0.0377991386,
0.0068062455,
-0.0263223071,
-0.0644942597,
0.0164003894,
-0.0307249464,
0.0370971337,
-0.0036654694,
-0.0056703174,
0.0058325841,
0.0158929527,
0.0006458086,
0.0357505716,
-0.008543903,
-0.0115882447,
-0.0022263858,
0.0235658456,
-0.0453560203,
-0.0124446331,
-0.027871348,
0.0219948757,
0.0520312153,
-0.0452439189,
-0.0398208909,
-0.0256442949,
0.0531573109,
-0.1006739214,
0.0053867889,
0.0802093297,
0.0042865402,
-0.0569604076,
-0.0287778024,
-0.0237237215,
0.0261523947,
-0.0461864062,
0.0145154912,
-0.039500542,
-0.0170627609,
0.037668895,
0.045026537,
-0.0099392515,
0.0006893887,
-0.0034425196,
-0.0731232613,
0.009356874,
0.020047769,
-0.0671985745,
-0.0354100727,
-0.0366683044,
0.0277023874,
-0.0046676164,
0.0363728069,
-0.0118120601,
0.0035041927,
-0.0054487013,
0.0019435778,
-0.0479685664,
-0.027906524,
-0.004432051,
0.0140716732,
0.0105972942,
0.0491526164,
0.0578424446,
-0.0096319877,
-0.063279435,
-0.0121334409,
-0.0543942228,
-0.0148992762,
-0.0378206335,
0.0626229867,
-0.0236322582,
-0.011816835,
-0.025846405,
0.0182443466,
0.0045415056,
0.0062834616,
0.0240631886,
0.0174925122,
0.0411852747,
-0.0284782313,
-0.0648191869,
0.0094782347,
0.0361097306,
0.0675476417,
0.0246665999,
-0.0526918434,
-0.0367407463,
-0.0322378688,
-0.0012127393,
-0.0377046987,
-0.014157881,
0.0365363806,
-0.0608793199,
-0.0753191411,
-0.0528232157,
-0.0614125766,
-0.0062276893,
-0.0031274979,
0.0565116741,
0.0169990957,
0.0175209474,
-0.0110204322,
-0.0635665357,
0.0494491793,
0.0116118919,
0.0603072457,
-0.0818811283,
0.0472994186,
-0.0195572618,
-0.0171073247,
-0.0085153123,
-0.0294780415,
0.0049603605,
-0.0203573275,
0.0219043251,
-0.0198953282,
0.0046741343,
-0.0063592987,
-0.0209810529,
-0.0540047698,
0.0359708369,
0.0069662398,
-0.011412234,
-0.0200621802,
0.0447345562,
-0.0271577686,
-0.0140618682,
-0.0089614708,
-0.002439149,
0.0090345563,
-0.0123757748,
0.0076326746,
0.0096263103,
-0.0649961531,
-0.0292841326,
0.0001297437,
0.0370315798,
-0.0158955958,
0.0079284851,
-0.0356131904,
0.0089843255,
-0.0025749439,
0.0240901615,
-0.0432683416,
-0.0142956441,
0.0317321904,
0.0106920023,
-0.041309353,
0.0638347417,
-0.0181557015,
0.0178276412,
-0.0224742219,
0.0662842765,
0.0323808379,
0.0943855047,
-0.0216401126,
0.0151581755,
-0.0576221682,
-0.0143914446,
-0.0278746076,
0.03816697,
0.0345486142,
0.0407221876,
0.0093186582,
0.0093235672,
0.0376887657,
0.0485306904,
-0.0218233708,
0.0703625679,
-0.0178318378,
0.0042938716,
0.0084874509,
-0.0634346232,
0.0801610202,
-0.0079824626,
0.0014153712,
-0.0521555245,
0.0387583561,
0.032917425,
0.0333016142,
0.0112817865,
-0.018595539,
0.0024297168,
-0.0253175292,
0.0598981529,
-0.0160892252,
-0.0617927983,
0.0165933929,
-0.0599029399,
-0.0263989773,
-0.0068589137,
0.0384917818,
0.0277323574,
-0.0211155582,
-0.0111225052,
-0.0368764624,
-0.0523637012,
0.0568768382,
-0.0194046497,
-0.0181554817,
0.029743446,
-0.0180936512,
0.063815698,
-0.0201993156,
0.0309995729,
-0.0360366553,
-0.0063989586,
-0.0331123583,
-0.0370605588,
-0.0081009688,
-5.847085592e-33,
0.001787222,
-0.004808845,
-0.0392287374,
-0.0145599172,
-0.064871043,
0.0145472903,
-0.0357750691,
-0.0173327439,
0.0027401212,
0.0638002753,
0.0023379233,
-0.0013731526,
0.0238654222,
0.0220591445,
-0.0136730308,
0.0017300232,
0.0438743979,
0.0369417034,
-0.0126829697,
-0.0168246776,
0.0603171699,
0.0460134856,
0.0492173061,
-0.103701584,
0.0907776803,
-0.0135189695,
-0.0109587163,
-0.0208291169,
0.0678192675,
0.0372842662,
-0.0207875948,
0.0747717917,
0.0233813543,
-0.0127616869,
0.0008268357,
0.1156262308,
-0.0641764179,
-0.0147943003,
0.0419504344,
0.0247529298,
0.0116164815,
-0.0579840578,
0.0508121513,
0.0260701254,
0.011334545,
-0.0620145276,
0.0671401471,
-0.0639092997,
0.0047214865,
-0.0356232561,
-0.0821885169,
0.0442090258,
-0.030263938,
-0.0100619998,
0.0782671943,
0.0804490522,
-0.012739554,
0.0136474688,
-0.0524996072,
0.0280440114,
-0.0219311249,
0.0221499745,
0.0448180921,
0.0131491143,
-0.0261943284,
0.0324786231,
-0.0342475399,
-0.0193892047,
-0.0039387131,
0.0091955811,
0.0831266716,
0.0207058713,
0.0420932919,
0.0881024599,
0.0417675041,
-0.0012886126,
-0.0343822129,
0.0728707239,
-0.0041797506,
0.0229282007,
0.0078121983,
-0.0010051953,
-0.0666640028,
-0.0162876509,
-0.0146490615,
-0.0018848896,
-0.0326663293,
-0.0238013268,
0.0243154615,
-0.0699663013,
-0.0098612066,
0.0042479751,
0.0117552495,
-0.0394361578,
-0.0097469548,
0.012722509,
-0.0246203505,
-0.0170440301,
-0.0086423904,
0.0464934707,
-0.0219590645,
-0.0108226752,
-0.0082006045,
0.0310279001,
0.0286698304,
-0.0428584367,
0.0312157255,
0.0007601614,
-0.0661054626,
-0.001498876,
0.0175608043,
-0.0035692682,
-0.0160724614,
0.0779153854,
-0.0023243895,
-0.0092457207,
0.001839907,
0.0450905599,
0.001717552,
0.0237755347,
-0.0051659998,
-0.0373254828,
0.0362680256,
0.0232003462,
-0.0432574563,
-0.0183236487,
0.0146220857,
0.0034515313,
0.0270959809,
-0.0266443659,
0.0061411276,
0.0053419969,
2.612e-7,
0.0311893206,
0.0186923891,
-0.0090887696,
-0.0693490729,
-0.013808161,
0.0533073768,
-0.0078255795,
0.07230746,
0.0335169174,
0.0261874087,
0.0318571813,
-0.0186250657,
0.1303272396,
0.0037741656,
-0.0881464556,
-0.0774709806,
-0.024930058,
0.0369351134,
-0.0359794497,
0.0541391782,
0.0969360173,
0.0364151336,
0.0027938953,
-0.0342994034,
0.0379157811,
-0.0227781944,
-0.0071889143,
-0.0762203857,
0.0213193484,
0.014126786,
0.068097502,
-0.0030612883,
0.0189313907,
0.0241120178,
-0.016071856,
0.0168787353,
0.0530917495,
0.0306382105,
0.0118874991,
-0.0074187373,
-0.0041201338,
0.0187279154,
-0.0044635343,
-0.0578984544,
0.0357869193,
0.0012288966,
-0.0283529833,
-0.0122022759,
-0.0529918075,
0.0065072137,
0.0466515794,
-0.0003000353,
-0.0192715861,
-0.0003323717,
0.0498631522,
-0.0476704203,
-0.0136221638,
-0.0527922027,
-0.0135529125,
0.0303323679,
-0.0009475972,
-0.0192355253,
-0.0175100733,
0.0180256683,
0.0468931198,
-0.0634528473,
0.0386284068,
1.951459294e-34,
0.0346342102,
-0.0085092196,
0.0362903364,
-0.0029741898,
-0.0148471799,
-0.0138548948,
0.0217870846,
-0.0216545071,
-0.0061474945,
-0.0565479994,
0.0221858881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09697v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09697v1 | Class-Adaptive Self-Training for Relation Extraction with Incompletely Annotated Training Data | 2023-06-16T09:01:45 | 2023-06-16T09:01:45 | Qingyu Tan, Lu Xu, Lidong Bing, Hwee Tou Ng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relation extraction (RE) aims to extract relations from sentences and
documents. Existing relation extraction models typically rely on supervised
machine learning. However, recent studies showed that many RE datasets are
incompletely annotated. This is known as the false negative problem in which
valid relations are falsely annotated as 'no_relation'. Models trained with
such data inevitably make similar mistakes during the inference stage.
Self-training has been proven effective in alleviating the false negative
problem. However, traditional self-training is vulnerable to confirmation bias
and exhibits poor performance in minority classes. To overcome this limitation,
we proposed a novel class-adaptive re-sampling self-training framework.
Specifically, we re-sampled the pseudo-labels for each class by precision and
recall scores. Our re-sampling strategy favored the pseudo-labels of classes
with high precision and low recall, which improved the overall recall without
significantly compromising precision. We conducted experiments on
document-level and biomedical relation extraction datasets, and the results
showed that our proposed self-training framework consistently outperforms
existing competitive methods on the Re-DocRED and ChemDisgene datasets when the
training data are incompletely annotated. Our code is released at
https://github.com/DAMO-NLP-SG/CAST. | [
0.0443593338,
0.0263681859,
0.0115831653,
0.0434610136,
0.0094505735,
0.0266877543,
-0.0264763068,
0.0144140096,
0.037800476,
-0.0517730936,
-0.0563984253,
0.0216295402,
-0.057276465,
-0.0290451776,
-0.0215583239,
-0.0189309735,
0.0356020033,
0.0335692987,
0.0362461396,
0.0044284514,
-0.0087518105,
-0.0074221715,
-0.0318607502,
-0.0419647582,
-0.028406376,
-0.0181312468,
0.0360539481,
-0.0213355757,
0.0213708226,
-0.0623734035,
0.0429760069,
0.05598104,
-0.0193729084,
0.0025347155,
0.0000016831,
-0.0700018108,
-0.0377482101,
0.0080795987,
-0.0471468233,
-0.0210771933,
0.0043508336,
-0.0350370444,
0.0331076384,
-0.0076211775,
-0.0560251735,
-0.0593349859,
0.0179152638,
0.0811692923,
0.0281139351,
0.0351987444,
-0.0200505853,
-0.0245880373,
0.0219441112,
-0.0373872444,
0.0108761881,
-0.0029263643,
0.0423875041,
0.0201813597,
-0.0082173105,
-0.0071439967,
0.0130057391,
0.0107357092,
0.0037818821,
0.0243744366,
0.0439111851,
0.0450604782,
-0.06393902,
-0.0108343503,
-0.0073089069,
0.0781360567,
0.0352769643,
0.0012744991,
0.0321100503,
-0.0044401065,
-0.0008115293,
0.0203364789,
0.0062077432,
-0.0194562878,
-0.0400350578,
0.040584147,
0.0175644774,
0.043765597,
0.0263061784,
0.0132606486,
-0.0109229656,
0.0456246734,
-0.0382547118,
-0.0472761244,
0.053268481,
0.029422665,
0.014333142,
0.0127167171,
0.025005931,
0.0191443823,
0.047830157,
0.0366942845,
-0.0219894852,
-0.0215675794,
0.0466006212,
-0.0647236034,
-0.030993782,
-0.0328723937,
-0.0315094776,
0.0485868566,
-0.0446597487,
-0.0329803564,
0.0170343164,
0.0279170927,
-0.0022525869,
0.0219191685,
-0.0571163148,
0.0263154339,
-0.048974853,
0.0960924998,
-0.0120068267,
0.0356981009,
-0.0721304864,
-0.0115654236,
-0.0179334059,
0.0152851623,
0.0037627439,
0.0131786549,
-0.0445362739,
0.0140058612,
-0.0175481681,
0.0084620789,
0.0045004599,
-0.0215501301,
-0.0334617645,
-0.0435877219,
-0.0094046909,
-0.0593617782,
0.0357841738,
-0.0320718102,
0.0076938141,
0.0828576982,
0.0056481604,
-0.0649782494,
-0.0173417181,
-0.025649529,
0.0051267506,
-0.0423670113,
0.0119328145,
-0.0251226481,
0.0397910997,
0.0283318553,
-0.0086311195,
-0.020615207,
0.0508016869,
-0.024044944,
-0.0531456284,
0.0776671469,
-0.0393717848,
-0.0185255222,
-0.0002935684,
0.0241006166,
0.0262652077,
0.0716672093,
0.0281676557,
-0.03402761,
0.055101458,
0.0161829274,
0.0280166212,
-0.009973865,
0.0511436239,
-0.0416689031,
0.0223161578,
0.0032817004,
-0.0021597277,
0.0178566929,
0.0388885438,
0.0021859331,
-0.0070654959,
-0.0582223386,
-0.0128856879,
-0.0012335435,
0.0307706203,
0.033446461,
-0.0080618672,
-0.0182250421,
0.0432570055,
0.0279585216,
-0.0458207391,
0.010633301,
-0.0107485037,
0.0335789733,
-0.0385911129,
-0.0086398143,
-0.0055604903,
-0.0212660786,
0.0049097198,
-0.0219382644,
-0.0169148743,
0.0004274464,
0.1066468805,
0.0443708412,
-0.0077101169,
0.04951315,
0.0675876066,
-0.0302841682,
-0.0140951797,
0.0143736014,
0.0074400636,
-0.0159866977,
0.0359859727,
-0.0969188884,
-0.0484782197,
-0.0099947173,
-0.0399079472,
-0.0059369639,
0.0457096994,
-0.0262225736,
0.0519964173,
-0.0227186792,
-0.0253077466,
0.0220295098,
0.0241766833,
-0.0066576642,
0.020086918,
0.0073111267,
0.020154167,
-0.0417200625,
-0.0288176108,
0.059497308,
-0.0328172557,
-0.0600941293,
0.0100317523,
0.008502583,
0.0450990647,
0.0353990793,
-0.0447768196,
-0.017639745,
0.0844835266,
-0.0414062627,
-0.0209247656,
-0.0119607365,
-0.0698961243,
-0.0568348207,
0.0288364086,
0.0116728246,
-0.0405280553,
-0.0269450638,
-0.056530308,
-0.0044387933,
-0.0004172138,
0.024531655,
0.0441709161,
-0.0378098749,
-0.0092523796,
0.0408484079,
0.0153304962,
-0.0157472994,
0.0488984101,
0.0174578801,
0.0125579359,
-0.0386879891,
-0.0696814656,
0.0119627221,
-0.0214449782,
-0.0219301358,
-0.0157893654,
-0.0196085963,
-0.0204797536,
0.0018800999,
0.0003579024,
-0.0789861381,
0.0108162826,
-0.0437142029,
0.0043275622,
0.018314546,
0.0454020016,
0.0163767524,
0.0139107201,
-0.0111342622,
-0.0509178936,
0.005054493,
-0.0209341962,
-0.0450459197,
-0.0063088094,
0.0663934201,
0.0258787591,
0.0343186781,
-0.0199280605,
-0.0017939012,
-0.0362086035,
0.0314423591,
0.0151208211,
-0.013002092,
0.024021076,
0.0254528988,
-0.0280180369,
0.0533881523,
0.0102419509,
-0.0122776479,
-0.0469273292,
0.0135457618,
-0.0352153778,
0.0083476789,
0.0063250558,
0.0448605344,
0.0163928978,
0.0229824986,
-0.0150294676,
0.0258878712,
-0.0416803472,
0.0379885137,
0.0245014485,
-0.0065452214,
-0.0128585137,
0.0562170334,
-0.0064111496,
-0.0021532779,
0.0153313344,
-0.0178577919,
0.0200390108,
-0.0065404773,
-0.0199659057,
0.0603118986,
0.0132016791,
-0.012614185,
-0.0397870205,
-0.011491593,
0.084138006,
0.002374429,
-0.0228204075,
-0.0366542935,
-0.0052946988,
-0.0228679534,
0.0613739192,
0.0184641071,
-0.0005190986,
0.0482927635,
0.0027537234,
0.0116709135,
-0.0433813706,
0.041842062,
-0.0270112865,
0.0225624703,
-0.0127439788,
0.030710429,
-0.0052553732,
-0.0360897295,
-0.063966006,
-0.0325427055,
-0.0144029101,
-0.0040758299,
-0.0554938838,
0.0222339053,
0.0129110282,
0.0194281433,
-0.0126937283,
0.0723526999,
-0.0181090198,
-0.0202335976,
-0.0035896406,
0.0720841289,
0.0384174027,
-0.0119729172,
-0.0018690858,
0.0063063432,
0.0332783051,
0.0561569445,
0.0236213654,
-0.0115037384,
0.0010173769,
-0.0001568186,
-0.0336566381,
-0.0634736121,
0.0284378901,
-0.01177637,
-0.0178575125,
-0.056627214,
-0.0324610807,
0.081527546,
0.0169230234,
-0.0318820551,
0.0092025828,
0.0160179455,
-0.0211382918,
0.0411619879,
0.0342061184,
-0.0750473887,
-0.0156682264,
-0.0308570173,
0.0027689359,
-0.0207189936,
-0.0641800761,
0.0149948448,
-0.0886625573,
0.0087391082,
-0.0017636581,
-0.0707978979,
-0.0170446113,
-0.061548505,
0.0143800844,
-0.0394892506,
-0.0317399204,
0.0062547433,
-0.0538118929,
0.0100366399,
0.0277929492,
-0.0420195125,
-0.051558502,
-0.0148961376,
-0.0283718631,
0.0547825135,
0.0116942916,
0.0154513773,
-0.0206594914,
0.0265014656,
0.0531383641,
-0.0657349974,
-0.0307138972,
-0.0403364524,
0.1335077286,
-0.0174920354,
-0.0069702575,
-0.0058470261,
0.0150301466,
-0.0666180402,
-0.006883733,
0.0206941795,
0.0651948228,
0.0033558232,
-0.0189093892,
-0.0184943099,
-0.0188416913,
0.0004209533,
0.0567583703,
-0.0046954714,
0.0057587139,
-0.0452728979,
0.0319318399,
0.0600260347,
-0.0255070962,
0.0348612554,
0.0233620778,
-0.0861391649,
-0.0207535587,
-0.045357246,
-0.0755426213,
0.0317566507,
0.0285111051,
-0.0104672993,
0.0207580384,
0.0289773941,
0.0175432283,
-0.0829947963,
-0.0062504034,
-0.0136639718,
-0.0692863911,
0.0235354099,
-0.0410874523,
0.0415082797,
-0.0197764877,
-0.0151058212,
-0.0483178273,
-0.0106810229,
-0.0192275401,
0.0057596387,
0.0443435758,
0.0151894428,
0.0719903931,
0.0114997486,
0.0039138589,
0.023942681,
0.1205070317,
-0.0726126134,
-0.0385527276,
0.034917552,
-0.0093496842,
0.002752088,
0.0251126271,
-0.0223995801,
0.0340327285,
0.0119325202,
0.0304118991,
-0.0435968116,
0.0044144583,
0.0537193343,
0.023990985,
0.0792674944,
0.0044611245,
0.0308814757,
-0.0518020317,
0.0268246233,
-0.0368130654,
-0.0036369523,
-0.0260766633,
0.0368140638,
-0.0212864112,
0.0111732995,
-0.0227825418,
-0.034552779,
-0.0469676964,
0.0313114189,
-0.0030402686,
-0.0109273968,
0.0360875763,
-0.0036852055,
0.0031764805,
-0.0355099775,
-0.0076789339,
0.0062376959,
0.0606485344,
0.0188009273,
-0.0190904178,
0.0169928707,
0.0283109043,
0.0303547569,
-0.0276768319,
-0.0266272072,
-0.0317877382,
0.0865503326,
-0.0416712612,
0.052988302,
0.032625936,
-0.0409721024,
0.0259064678,
-0.0263740756,
-0.0077683711,
0.0138076385,
0.0424570553,
-0.0494565964,
0.0429193452,
0.0129673304,
0.0080213454,
-0.0216995552,
0.0406560116,
0.0703587607,
-0.0279674884,
0.0573249534,
0.0395893119,
-0.0493122078,
-0.0451932102,
-0.000824864,
-0.025556121,
-0.0024144845,
-0.0162753221,
-0.0014947406,
-0.0372410081,
-0.0663209856,
0.0311791766,
-0.008530736,
-0.0098694973,
0.008829657,
0.0138481874,
0.0194964334,
0.0254536048,
-0.0578246266,
-0.0487849489,
0.0556812808,
-0.0187757369,
-0.0296529066,
0.0042662304,
-6.10923773e-33,
-0.0419250503,
-0.0400761068,
-0.0077237347,
0.0165620986,
-0.0024673822,
0.0270334836,
-0.0214912705,
-0.0149080213,
0.003653856,
0.0567788407,
-0.0242687818,
-0.0100256745,
0.0088705979,
0.0027456873,
0.0041545713,
-0.0092647457,
0.0191083811,
-0.0115053514,
0.016664654,
0.0019473857,
0.0132877845,
0.0895884857,
0.0627968609,
-0.1180145219,
-0.0193611756,
0.0068979338,
0.0298646204,
0.0138355726,
0.0211627111,
0.0356155001,
-0.0236664172,
0.0350059532,
0.0457257964,
0.0058315331,
0.0347108543,
-0.0428923182,
-0.1957526505,
-0.0344895683,
-0.0529082008,
-0.0069367271,
-0.0201043766,
0.0332062729,
0.0537328571,
0.0012513387,
0.0085733458,
-0.02168753,
0.0353221111,
-0.0501471609,
-0.0283770692,
-0.0416883565,
-0.0275211185,
0.0238792021,
0.0264632832,
0.0115998778,
0.0362786539,
0.0215026811,
-0.0016248327,
0.0194276646,
-0.0396599434,
-0.050546214,
0.0084316852,
0.0189378373,
-0.0148031237,
0.0152867576,
-0.0069547952,
0.0450123772,
0.0459929705,
0.001642704,
0.0100184605,
-0.005203574,
-0.0080797439,
0.0134301931,
-0.0480471477,
0.0258081313,
0.0449856706,
-0.0121186012,
-0.0901006311,
0.0202721842,
0.029606564,
-0.0002651387,
-0.0277585611,
-0.0063761617,
-0.0261333007,
0.0068355063,
0.0176462624,
-0.0245500654,
0.0044578146,
-0.019808298,
-0.0176334325,
0.0016410733,
-0.0198747795,
0.0719293728,
-0.0388514064,
-0.0368972383,
-0.0650200248,
-0.0283407196,
0.0092187822,
-0.0045519578,
-0.0109747183,
-0.0265510641,
-0.0489604957,
-0.0364992768,
-0.0114383325,
-0.0026924303,
0.0333288983,
-0.0022375258,
0.0966872498,
-0.043976374,
-0.0560136773,
-0.0286748912,
-0.0197155848,
0.0339217708,
0.0174908582,
0.011193038,
-0.0183101147,
0.0409186669,
-0.0072646439,
0.0571621433,
0.0661200881,
0.0069786059,
-0.0349386744,
0.0517854728,
0.0072820587,
0.0117857447,
0.0241330862,
-0.0252939537,
0.011294595,
0.0351485349,
-0.0010552828,
-0.0538085848,
0.0042153145,
-0.0119331069,
2.458e-7,
0.0658108145,
0.0339531042,
0.0560704581,
-0.0452928841,
0.0170674231,
0.0393862128,
-0.0065464894,
0.0416272692,
0.0099368775,
-0.0020096621,
0.0316584557,
-0.0040989066,
-0.0114000924,
0.0362802818,
-0.0585417971,
-0.0107413176,
-0.0691638663,
-0.0732744262,
-0.0124460114,
-0.0048149265,
0.0356919728,
0.0437291935,
0.0494876094,
-0.0204000995,
-0.0279058572,
-0.0190389212,
0.0440161601,
-0.0174575914,
0.0195614658,
0.0535733178,
-0.0029935772,
0.0245255865,
-0.0172966104,
0.048016794,
-0.0220192783,
0.0243257191,
-0.007461811,
0.0093880277,
-0.0240224674,
0.0039593298,
0.0379718654,
0.0369691066,
0.0462383367,
0.0030269902,
0.0281703193,
-0.092016302,
-0.0281605907,
-0.0002576736,
-0.0030758984,
0.0068013668,
-0.000884498,
0.0224614423,
0.0010895153,
0.0472780988,
0.024249943,
0.0055281869,
-0.0610150397,
-0.0586993732,
0.0133878114,
0.0690999404,
0.0163867027,
0.0119932387,
0.0271130633,
-0.0064279595,
-0.0112052513,
-0.0546886548,
0.0028978172,
1.934117997e-34,
-0.0117170354,
-0.0058388887,
-0.0403011963,
0.0479548797,
0.0046843886,
-0.0466773547,
-0.0147016197,
0.0072233169,
-0.0170455351,
-0.0003688907,
0.020976061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09657v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09657v1 | Online Distillation for Pseudo-Relevance Feedback | 2023-06-16T07:26:33 | 2023-06-16T07:26:33 | Sean MacAvaney, Xi Wang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Model distillation has emerged as a prominent technique to improve neural
search models. To date, distillation taken an offline approach, wherein a new
neural model is trained to predict relevance scores between arbitrary queries
and documents. In this paper, we explore a departure from this offline
distillation strategy by investigating whether a model for a specific query can
be effectively distilled from neural re-ranking results (i.e., distilling in an
online setting). Indeed, we find that a lexical model distilled online can
reasonably replicate the re-ranking of a neural model. More importantly, these
models can be used as queries that execute efficiently on indexes. This second
retrieval stage can enrich the pool of documents for re-ranking by identifying
documents that were missed in the first retrieval stage. Empirically, we show
that this approach performs favourably when compared with established pseudo
relevance feedback techniques, dense retrieval methods, and sparse-dense
ensemble "hybrid" approaches. | [
0.0440068766,
0.0650574416,
0.003013239,
-0.0287699606,
0.0039766463,
-0.0131056458,
-0.0366760269,
0.0315107144,
-0.0104880054,
-0.0186287798,
-0.0463776141,
-0.0173931345,
-0.0426138863,
0.0274941102,
-0.0059509231,
-0.0184761882,
0.0411155932,
0.0087822238,
0.0098321931,
-0.0146198831,
-0.0126914009,
0.0245124158,
0.015807787,
-0.0001134382,
0.0543299057,
0.0005478238,
-0.0556267127,
0.0408582576,
-0.0345945209,
0.0078725191,
0.0154360672,
0.0231020134,
0.0436649919,
0.0282307267,
0.0000016911,
-0.0395986512,
-0.0462426282,
-0.0133118993,
-0.0327020325,
0.0294806417,
0.0213734228,
0.0243296772,
0.0622372851,
-0.0061260429,
-0.0389402583,
-0.0045687049,
0.0036127386,
0.0173427761,
0.0485460088,
0.0466824137,
0.0126864975,
0.013015613,
0.0300518908,
-0.0358753391,
0.0098220725,
-0.0324221849,
0.0138294455,
-0.0047377762,
0.0295195822,
0.0339950919,
-0.002244537,
0.0300663877,
0.0035702041,
-0.0130755156,
0.0477300696,
-0.0191759448,
-0.0881316811,
-0.0002553868,
0.0252039209,
0.0548417345,
-0.0463282838,
-0.0247344393,
0.0042064893,
0.0080404105,
-0.0201116279,
0.0339555293,
-0.0666456372,
-0.0215379372,
0.011710682,
0.006948668,
-0.0142656807,
-0.014781652,
0.0545594618,
0.0334875807,
-0.0185525045,
0.0776216462,
-0.0006490709,
-0.0346428566,
0.0085565988,
0.0063754059,
-0.053596925,
0.0075935381,
0.050856702,
0.005761622,
-0.0296465885,
0.0122727053,
0.0221647657,
0.0052631656,
0.0076678433,
-0.0681262538,
0.036713168,
0.0135702705,
0.0160614308,
0.0562558845,
-0.0058257394,
0.0532393865,
-0.0181110706,
0.0071617491,
-0.040782731,
-0.0031050558,
-0.0887525454,
-0.0423081778,
-0.0022191845,
0.0830732509,
-0.0227590967,
-0.0276454445,
-0.0073510488,
0.0113857994,
-0.0170984808,
-0.0530587994,
0.0379100777,
0.0366471186,
-0.0681282356,
0.0158645753,
-0.0440349653,
0.0250260402,
0.0061171232,
-0.0066532567,
-0.000961272,
-0.0476966128,
0.0059670233,
-0.0222612433,
0.0067399014,
-0.0010787545,
0.0137312012,
-0.0070794635,
-0.0044755605,
-0.0284960065,
0.0046868115,
-0.053338781,
0.0349886417,
-0.0067936736,
-0.0049376367,
-0.0296720136,
0.0278298464,
-0.0598841459,
0.0128175411,
-0.0528829508,
0.0038397738,
0.0298485961,
-0.0304522589,
0.0321606547,
0.0308805835,
0.0199565254,
0.039764028,
-0.0043159081,
0.0065016253,
0.0514476486,
-0.0149178654,
0.0266129691,
0.0558092296,
0.0219935961,
0.0026807578,
0.007895302,
0.0503626019,
0.0017473426,
-0.0537172928,
-0.0047146236,
-0.0607570037,
0.0391643532,
0.0227859169,
0.0306068026,
-0.0680646375,
0.0101085445,
0.0276089218,
0.0047015236,
0.0883421972,
0.0172388535,
-0.0085828975,
0.0208769534,
-0.0571218356,
0.0149636818,
-0.0411833115,
0.0198425725,
-0.0036674519,
0.0126910424,
0.0630620494,
0.0074203061,
-0.0621183589,
-0.0524943322,
0.0305285733,
0.0554346107,
-0.0414505005,
0.0182851981,
0.045556765,
0.0134432204,
0.0214666184,
0.0396169163,
0.0400424898,
-0.009906685,
0.0678213239,
-0.0648451224,
-0.0223163273,
0.0866856724,
0.0965909138,
-0.0467848703,
0.0047676493,
0.0001897101,
-0.0175626222,
-0.0172730684,
-0.0081182253,
-0.04387917,
0.0036391008,
-0.0359170772,
-0.0423815176,
-0.0189906321,
0.0271505639,
-0.0031763257,
0.0271207243,
0.032057073,
0.0304116681,
-0.0941926092,
-0.0260793027,
0.0236487947,
-0.0341206603,
-0.0431013219,
0.020294942,
0.0125190634,
-0.002956538,
0.0080063138,
-0.0062246346,
-0.0012781487,
0.0476078652,
0.0162688904,
-0.0616134778,
-0.0742813423,
-0.017885603,
-0.012162935,
0.0256172381,
0.0029623844,
0.08855322,
0.0514685176,
-0.0205966011,
-0.007590598,
-0.0182125811,
0.0091250772,
0.0280802753,
-0.0419686213,
0.0092705451,
-0.0300135389,
-0.003017263,
-0.0448911041,
0.0252838861,
-0.0174318384,
0.0554928146,
-0.017380096,
-0.0412528031,
-0.0171307977,
-0.0250626374,
-0.0258542281,
0.0363682844,
-0.0219682436,
0.0364646912,
0.0249878485,
0.0008628357,
-0.0165798478,
0.0166576467,
-0.070022881,
0.0150835179,
-0.0234127678,
-0.0181045942,
0.0357503481,
0.0194117911,
0.0226505604,
-0.0255668908,
-0.0142072542,
-0.0666916743,
0.0053867986,
0.0257386602,
-0.0216527879,
0.0208755154,
0.0392292179,
-0.0384558067,
-0.0887266919,
0.0195290148,
0.0380440205,
-0.05333272,
-0.010533019,
-0.0182117913,
-0.0145257032,
-0.0623366833,
0.0193716772,
0.0036650451,
0.0257209223,
-0.0190752447,
-0.0605151169,
-0.0380916074,
0.0571871512,
-0.0080657937,
-0.0032240243,
0.0509858541,
0.007849331,
-0.1057171002,
0.0051763784,
-0.0455222428,
0.0078891721,
0.0342591181,
-0.0310495589,
0.0012695886,
-0.0138107641,
-0.0285758507,
-0.0022038268,
-0.0225494057,
0.0176631492,
-0.0057713678,
-0.0484733544,
-0.09513551,
0.0110357394,
0.0248713903,
0.0168266781,
-0.0038988625,
-0.0507103764,
0.081083253,
0.0541191213,
0.0159023702,
-0.0417454951,
-0.0344525725,
-0.0203355681,
0.0354531445,
-0.0045713377,
-0.0038130768,
-0.0171348844,
-0.0036749146,
-0.0320501104,
-0.0100408243,
0.0079471171,
-0.0788353086,
0.034700688,
-0.0236138459,
0.0349325463,
0.0316821262,
-0.0372114964,
-0.0038745499,
-0.0758075118,
0.0288790558,
0.0457175188,
0.000077358,
-0.0130825322,
-0.056128595,
0.0224760193,
-0.0047519202,
0.0611208864,
-0.0432346165,
-0.0339322612,
0.0199972373,
0.0537982285,
0.0346554741,
0.0031218538,
-0.0157030616,
-0.0047806129,
0.0169411954,
0.0254569221,
0.0441257842,
-0.0754544437,
-0.0054090372,
-0.005999662,
0.0602958053,
-0.0319230855,
-0.0282158367,
-0.0144916736,
-0.0466658249,
-0.0104473056,
-0.0570299104,
0.0516056865,
0.0302998759,
-0.0688077733,
-0.0058786212,
-0.017826505,
0.0433603637,
0.0119905081,
0.0626477972,
0.0116379252,
0.0185344499,
0.0304216258,
0.0728912801,
0.0132221226,
-0.0011700758,
-0.0090424223,
-0.0901802927,
0.0321332105,
-0.0086015807,
0.0509241633,
0.0183652136,
-0.0397509038,
0.0132752713,
-0.0394874997,
-0.0188487023,
0.0486691855,
0.0038477245,
-0.0023831108,
0.0119292755,
0.0683611706,
-0.0385877043,
-0.014358189,
-0.0182571933,
-0.0158783346,
0.0775898695,
0.0221857782,
0.027316859,
-0.0150340395,
0.0082809832,
-0.0444368422,
0.0330859721,
-0.0187702347,
0.0621607415,
-0.0073859235,
0.0244013239,
-0.019868467,
-0.0068527865,
-0.0251835287,
0.0310714599,
-0.026158819,
0.0543753877,
-0.0309430696,
0.0128902737,
-0.0537074693,
-0.0643564612,
-0.0101523669,
0.0299968962,
-0.0251684301,
-0.0020246652,
-0.0090584205,
-0.0132633513,
0.0136650149,
0.0132405469,
-0.0182477701,
-0.0265382547,
-0.0368725359,
0.0320129134,
-0.0617514588,
-0.0158813484,
-0.039575506,
0.0381417871,
-0.0180362668,
0.0337274075,
0.0145708052,
-0.0110970298,
-0.0377973132,
0.0211231038,
0.0007060539,
0.0109876413,
0.0072796633,
0.0169345681,
0.0734759346,
-0.0195213165,
-0.0460314415,
-0.0574273765,
-0.0345091745,
-0.0387428366,
-0.0131754028,
0.0277306847,
0.026832737,
0.0633821413,
-0.0409047119,
-0.0877332985,
0.0744616613,
0.0766824186,
-0.0279729497,
0.0042448016,
0.0029941918,
-0.0267439447,
-0.0265719183,
0.0171483848,
-0.0689364001,
0.0127045885,
-0.024781242,
0.0412208475,
-0.010091261,
-0.0028746568,
0.0431550182,
0.0176620502,
0.0798350573,
0.0392099321,
0.008697941,
-0.0186574943,
0.0402667038,
0.0273104142,
-0.0339201763,
-0.015520188,
0.0462237373,
0.0497835055,
0.0009448645,
-0.0402319171,
0.0675757378,
-0.005271975,
0.0428883843,
-0.0955064297,
-0.0799558461,
-0.0007649527,
-0.0440994725,
0.0033611692,
0.0158149898,
-0.0227627177,
0.0502147302,
0.0146275628,
0.0482507721,
-0.0526438393,
-0.0230353344,
0.0292460546,
0.0193129368,
-0.0297636669,
0.0426866263,
-0.1272571087,
-0.0440661125,
-0.0726877153,
-0.0082131922,
0.0267245434,
0.005916886,
-0.0038977831,
0.0379485339,
-0.0304222908,
-0.0411321558,
-0.0599647202,
0.0225198288,
0.0071444563,
-0.0122059984,
0.0536900833,
0.0295151379,
0.0493500493,
0.07918562,
-0.0166147761,
0.023437785,
-0.0400532186,
-0.0213203728,
-0.0096817249,
-0.0255274381,
0.0044867396,
0.0883428082,
-0.0239086244,
-0.034990605,
0.018287966,
-0.0065815151,
0.0313279033,
0.0040964955,
0.0028816513,
-0.0650804192,
0.0615788586,
0.063370347,
0.0028556129,
0.0026565553,
-0.0444381461,
-0.0094492203,
-0.0291332807,
-0.0252437368,
-0.0243122429,
-6.269327939e-33,
0.0208257623,
-0.001054909,
-0.0071816831,
-0.0429225042,
-0.0456038639,
0.0059284391,
0.0237515923,
-0.0608607754,
-0.0176970456,
-0.0057209157,
-0.039305713,
0.0790247545,
0.0023359442,
0.0013263577,
0.0071166488,
0.0025471526,
0.0697873235,
-0.0094820773,
-0.0125110662,
0.0509886965,
0.0308998842,
0.0649940893,
-0.0059012966,
-0.0392719507,
0.0067014769,
-0.0361534916,
-0.0161142256,
0.0202821735,
-0.0160188153,
0.0612437315,
0.0088535668,
0.0510455333,
0.040667221,
-0.0224277619,
-0.0062684091,
-0.0160859805,
-0.0678593516,
-0.0266361348,
-0.0245821532,
-0.0542070903,
-0.0084578171,
0.0269789454,
0.0679801106,
0.0016551872,
-0.0164815392,
0.0059259762,
0.0251359791,
0.0094853444,
-0.0896480531,
-0.0695537776,
0.0141958566,
-0.0046007815,
0.0084520476,
-0.0127077783,
0.0062835175,
0.0724380016,
-0.0158488937,
0.0676380694,
-0.0471244566,
0.0275622308,
-0.0305952206,
0.0675552636,
0.0278917588,
-0.0086947484,
-0.0307047125,
0.0477028862,
-0.0078570535,
0.0192209315,
0.0195528958,
-0.0545436256,
0.057339631,
0.0210670047,
0.0109040942,
0.0180854667,
0.0755529404,
0.0029655807,
-0.0279590376,
0.0211137272,
-0.0233754199,
0.0425510257,
0.0437559001,
0.0642012954,
-0.0269273985,
-0.038265124,
-0.0464819558,
-0.0433549955,
-0.0640487671,
-0.0147158774,
0.0183334481,
0.0563389733,
-0.0100275837,
-0.0132309515,
0.0074811843,
-0.037475232,
-0.0077775717,
0.0525697581,
-0.0112162028,
0.0000269668,
0.0221822467,
0.0049300343,
-0.0270143282,
-0.0181617793,
-0.0020902958,
0.0064013884,
-0.0353341028,
-0.022765398,
-0.017552834,
0.0238292702,
-0.0065728202,
0.0035199926,
0.0150758019,
-0.014202158,
-0.0104323095,
0.0259482916,
0.0355069935,
0.0211931672,
-0.0002163129,
0.0555672199,
0.0628427267,
0.0378040448,
-0.0077210884,
-0.0092888437,
0.0385476425,
0.0040143267,
-0.0017137622,
0.0236005019,
-0.003049039,
0.0177605879,
0.004845906,
-0.0666355714,
-0.0302964244,
0.0416103825,
2.58e-7,
0.0170143098,
0.0332233831,
-0.0142417829,
-0.0085096946,
0.0345370993,
-0.0215455089,
-0.0141579378,
0.0078023784,
0.0369273052,
-0.0429373048,
0.0106231319,
-0.0002975345,
0.0431705825,
-0.0032422331,
-0.0489171855,
-0.0336509869,
-0.0626708046,
-0.0308980048,
-0.0299662463,
-0.0614965148,
-0.0001745575,
0.0895126611,
0.0257185325,
-0.0080167474,
0.0073253214,
-0.0535053313,
0.0206310749,
0.025779536,
-0.0038989822,
0.0001640293,
0.0489335507,
0.0198469423,
-0.0091472808,
-0.0239164829,
-0.0177900642,
0.0289636161,
0.0351289921,
0.0259857643,
-0.033542417,
-0.0077958745,
-0.0248233601,
-0.0058480138,
0.0224780776,
-0.0285165999,
0.0606024489,
-0.0211915188,
0.0352412276,
-0.0114559261,
-0.0419839323,
0.0038290946,
0.0546817742,
-0.0401162356,
0.0124315945,
0.0386398584,
-0.0006863072,
0.0461013168,
-0.0262564458,
-0.0633441955,
0.0061963503,
-0.005406253,
-0.0408000015,
-0.0340398438,
-0.0304498933,
-0.0068003824,
-0.0160689428,
-0.0086066443,
0.0112248873,
1.890428523e-34,
0.0607517138,
0.0560949221,
0.0112108327,
0.0107195321,
-0.0180818774,
0.0124534797,
-0.0545468181,
0.0015739769,
0.0278772451,
-0.0918090269,
-0.01513087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09649v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09649v3 | ReactGenie: A Development Framework for Complex Multimodal Interactions Using Large Language Models | 2023-06-16T06:53:26 | 2024-05-02T08:28:19 | Jackie Junrui Yang, Yingtian Shi, Yuhan Zhang, Karina Li, Daniel Wan Rosli, Anisha Jain, Shuning Zhang, Tianshi Li, James A. Landay, Monica S. Lam | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | By combining voice and touch interactions, multimodal interfaces can surpass
the efficiency of either modality alone. Traditional multimodal frameworks
require laborious developer work to support rich multimodal commands where the
user's multimodal command involves possibly exponential combinations of
actions/function invocations. This paper presents ReactGenie, a programming
framework that better separates multimodal input from the computational model
to enable developers to create efficient and capable multimodal interfaces with
ease. ReactGenie translates multimodal user commands into NLPL (Natural
Language Programming Language), a programming language we created, using a
neural semantic parser based on large-language models. The ReactGenie runtime
interprets the parsed NLPL and composes primitives in the computational model
to implement complex user commands. As a result, ReactGenie allows easy
implementation and unprecedented richness in commands for end-users of
multimodal apps. Our evaluation showed that 12 developers can learn and build a
nontrivial ReactGenie application in under 2.5 hours on average. In addition,
compared with a traditional GUI, end-users can complete tasks faster and with
less task load using ReactGenie apps. | [
0.0031742377,
0.0645275488,
-0.0363541059,
0.010978627,
-0.0200575721,
-0.022128839,
0.0354923755,
-0.0063901814,
0.0211568922,
-0.0564129986,
-0.0441764072,
-0.0217732154,
0.0271713231,
0.0636081472,
0.0238794461,
-0.0898755491,
0.0325275622,
-0.0171124563,
-0.0221647136,
0.0525643378,
0.0366793722,
0.0202381909,
-0.0440213829,
0.078156516,
-0.0196026322,
-0.046573028,
-0.0274424162,
-0.006332628,
-0.045537997,
-0.0217637159,
-0.0240342822,
0.0232835766,
0.0296859089,
0.0186724141,
0.0000020628,
-0.0454857759,
0.0382596441,
-0.0095194886,
0.0465219691,
-0.036983449,
0.0334344804,
0.0035749001,
-0.0017952146,
0.0113642653,
0.0035604849,
-0.0489319712,
0.0638452545,
0.0140449386,
0.1110521704,
0.0059124241,
-0.0204952657,
-0.0294996351,
0.0249366462,
0.0523461737,
0.0326417163,
0.0112776728,
-0.0277929269,
-0.0192038212,
0.0878852457,
-0.0352881625,
0.0195103101,
0.0369505845,
0.030907182,
-0.0038594666,
-0.0162413232,
0.0413876809,
0.051545959,
-0.0663045272,
-0.0514325052,
0.0497062281,
-0.0235882644,
0.0450145155,
0.0477522649,
0.0252874419,
-0.0101993,
0.0068223765,
-0.0342760757,
0.0282890275,
-0.0494040735,
-0.0305687711,
-0.0520896241,
-0.0201633293,
0.0030710439,
-0.0194745064,
0.0240244959,
0.0338446796,
0.0312584639,
0.0138830608,
-0.0021709183,
-0.0500310585,
0.0002844185,
-0.0254553352,
0.0574638471,
0.0410717353,
-0.0520395152,
0.0226959921,
-0.052420333,
-0.0813346952,
0.010861991,
-0.0850620568,
0.0415880568,
0.0507990122,
-0.0617631786,
0.0353669859,
0.0255534258,
0.031338308,
-0.0015668948,
-0.032862287,
-0.0173982773,
-0.0173662677,
-0.0418393761,
-0.0543292239,
-0.0277492255,
0.0047842436,
-0.0994058698,
-0.0374802835,
-0.0272010267,
0.0311062522,
-0.0076169167,
-0.0127668167,
-0.0220862087,
-0.0025636873,
-0.0050259051,
0.0182881877,
-0.0356049426,
0.0382388569,
-0.0089238901,
0.009744822,
-0.0045067002,
-0.0484138615,
0.0534737781,
-0.0012160371,
0.0010614637,
-0.0040585571,
-0.0206900146,
0.0856746063,
-0.0243749525,
0.0166645739,
-0.019964667,
-0.0368874297,
-0.0021665879,
0.0008851698,
0.0156383179,
-0.0516793132,
0.0482401066,
0.0201558135,
-0.0092674578,
-0.0455040485,
-0.0002734021,
0.0692793131,
0.0321145318,
0.056402199,
-0.0239138436,
0.0088949921,
0.071483992,
0.0150212804,
-0.022095114,
0.0281103123,
0.0552637056,
0.0168149229,
0.0048310449,
-0.0250868034,
0.0395331457,
0.0566134788,
-0.0619479753,
-0.0723361745,
-0.0112931523,
-0.0362694785,
0.0046064756,
0.0578660853,
-0.0005836837,
0.0325428098,
-0.0186700448,
-0.0050860438,
0.0564457662,
0.0343934484,
0.0151050529,
0.031403482,
0.0419051573,
0.0099769989,
0.0050355936,
-0.0844607726,
-0.0584486946,
0.0765054747,
-0.020028837,
-0.0116099389,
-0.0191134661,
0.0406252407,
0.0241769776,
-0.0137257576,
0.0124523034,
-0.0266116783,
0.0428399704,
-0.0104095349,
0.0257734917,
-0.0179032106,
-0.014362487,
0.0062475596,
-0.002125141,
-0.0665235445,
-0.0043548257,
-0.0298766214,
-0.0006756018,
0.1001332626,
-0.0031515805,
-0.00749911,
-0.0201685894,
0.002620578,
-0.0009026533,
0.011257696,
0.0131040001,
-0.0208656155,
0.0434795544,
-0.0363920853,
-0.0166769866,
-0.0352788605,
-0.0031640967,
0.0177792478,
-0.0464776829,
-0.0083710924,
-0.0052309223,
0.0037987255,
0.0367846228,
0.0248629656,
0.0516605116,
-0.0323126875,
-0.0325092934,
0.0306546334,
-0.0085501373,
0.0123678409,
0.0217528623,
-0.00647124,
0.0100628771,
-0.0229387376,
-0.0092209335,
-0.0098369159,
-0.0358207524,
0.0104964897,
0.0319002569,
-0.0021292071,
-0.0242918674,
0.0279888529,
-0.0123992469,
-0.0028803083,
0.0343223363,
0.0009607482,
0.0209982917,
0.0105115501,
-0.0153887216,
0.0266650245,
-0.0161184035,
-0.0033209047,
0.0280032512,
0.0174852964,
-0.0080985371,
-0.0006429519,
0.0147495307,
0.0032193637,
-0.0264528021,
-0.0047647227,
0.034317635,
-0.0178830381,
0.0378903337,
0.0052025337,
0.0336882174,
-0.0001287551,
-0.0223228689,
-0.0982759446,
-0.0139433257,
-0.0318915397,
-0.0138570545,
0.0089524286,
0.0706708059,
0.0072162799,
-0.0374001339,
0.0009943402,
0.0249809455,
-0.0065601389,
0.0045047612,
0.0056910301,
0.0159771107,
-0.0251349043,
-0.017325243,
-0.0068169781,
-0.0328433178,
0.0308423284,
-0.0082756216,
-0.0488228835,
-0.014357077,
-0.028705962,
-0.0297039282,
0.0466894731,
-0.0071896981,
-0.0090262499,
0.0444699712,
-0.0288115013,
0.0608893819,
0.014991533,
-0.0202456452,
0.033654701,
0.0362736396,
-0.0302828737,
-0.0167180281,
0.0399073847,
0.0358673446,
-0.0035464915,
-0.0227069855,
0.0146261416,
0.0554958917,
0.0876474306,
0.0207133312,
0.037192028,
-0.0017381065,
0.0055378894,
-0.0222424958,
-0.0118160406,
-0.0240079742,
-0.0234192442,
-0.0497827493,
0.0165165905,
-0.0253364872,
-0.0517876595,
0.0512065738,
-0.0580594726,
-0.0535959676,
-0.0066177696,
-0.0427049026,
-0.0241946485,
0.1296630353,
-0.0047939713,
0.0055914973,
0.0164593738,
-0.0353688449,
0.0258656945,
0.0133072156,
-0.0068942155,
-0.0096947541,
0.0435714684,
-0.0889392793,
-0.001644119,
-0.0138963321,
-0.0289525278,
0.0193530153,
0.0060642543,
-0.0447881818,
-0.030402001,
0.0051864618,
0.0108522968,
0.0073587568,
0.0137974694,
0.0447661243,
0.0574792102,
0.0442909151,
-0.0263530184,
-0.0260085911,
-0.0346825831,
0.0108221015,
0.027259985,
-0.1052192822,
0.0006486716,
0.0036202576,
0.0188820139,
0.0166033208,
-0.0220465977,
-0.0809558257,
0.0089056706,
0.0499483235,
-0.0030421189,
-0.0340630002,
0.0707147196,
0.0463233739,
-0.0693226829,
0.0544939004,
0.064995639,
0.0121501945,
-0.0098531973,
0.0191333592,
-0.0178876258,
-0.0124536725,
0.0474128537,
0.04139423,
-0.0799681246,
-0.0564628094,
-0.0131986728,
-0.0053349477,
0.0647388697,
-0.0193319973,
0.002527182,
-0.0552143268,
-0.0331917852,
-0.0206335131,
-0.0595469475,
0.002131257,
0.0044281897,
0.0225009415,
0.0251070652,
-0.0203235094,
0.043768838,
-0.004191664,
0.0038965668,
-0.037195947,
0.0028809563,
0.0030715994,
0.0050376416,
-0.0288681015,
0.014061694,
0.0492421389,
0.0339507349,
0.003322633,
-0.0025638794,
0.0419945791,
0.0255581029,
0.0091348179,
-0.0548151433,
-0.0284650046,
0.0220720079,
-0.0057136463,
-0.0323458686,
0.0270703062,
0.0014323283,
-0.0181077644,
0.0129170483,
0.0894863456,
-0.0130965905,
0.0260721557,
-0.0444673933,
-0.0184573662,
0.0357392356,
-0.0103600873,
0.0022071605,
-0.0278391168,
-0.0733567476,
-0.055287838,
-0.0313658752,
-0.0172660556,
-0.0490574278,
0.0045412136,
0.0412141159,
-0.0007271417,
-0.0432420559,
0.0069049443,
0.0568255223,
0.0413016118,
0.0023814493,
-0.0171325821,
0.0427841246,
0.0629867464,
0.0091438582,
0.0222448334,
0.0433659665,
0.0322806202,
-0.0080684153,
-0.0047409362,
0.0601354912,
-0.0323658772,
0.0042285104,
0.0271373652,
0.0088515151,
-0.0411124043,
-0.0356486812,
0.0694180802,
0.0147994403,
-0.0345755033,
-0.0223530326,
-0.0761408582,
-0.0226281583,
0.0603055768,
-0.091815643,
-0.0141418455,
-0.0007832822,
0.0228960533,
0.0174470879,
-0.0204021223,
-0.0777628347,
-0.0221207757,
-0.0471199714,
0.0393654443,
-0.0140784113,
-0.0444418527,
0.0316704251,
0.0066974894,
0.0245883502,
-0.0277751591,
0.0659094676,
-0.0058761295,
-0.0466299318,
-0.019243218,
0.0084063616,
-0.0630011857,
0.0331303291,
-0.0476951897,
0.0252578706,
0.0484907366,
-0.0059447787,
0.0366723016,
0.023025455,
-0.0141575821,
0.0769451633,
0.0284601357,
-0.0146445641,
0.0168760624,
0.0282917544,
-0.0185048953,
0.02301508,
-0.009497596,
0.0281990673,
-0.0510451347,
0.0712777004,
-0.0121542215,
-0.0489906147,
-0.0475491509,
0.0136795864,
0.0115745561,
-0.0438271314,
0.0217961501,
0.0403944515,
0.0284615066,
0.0473894738,
-0.015865583,
-0.0540650785,
0.0250173993,
-0.0201514754,
0.0684629381,
0.0087937349,
-0.0322553627,
0.0160134584,
0.0123513322,
-0.0024933871,
-0.0782503858,
0.028897332,
-0.029528847,
0.000459158,
0.0083437823,
-0.0405831635,
-0.0464768969,
-0.0277679376,
0.0493889414,
0.0270942971,
-0.0487989523,
-0.0346737728,
-0.0396375172,
-0.0145601267,
0.0040054503,
0.0614864603,
-0.006916556,
-0.0544572249,
0.0462829396,
0.0565363988,
0.027998602,
-0.0319975168,
-0.0281918328,
0.0254895799,
-0.018551413,
-0.0050500915,
-0.0330008343,
-4.780717158e-33,
-0.0212729312,
-0.0168106537,
0.0663624406,
0.0154403858,
-0.024762122,
-0.0455416255,
-0.0505589806,
0.005919721,
0.0371551998,
-0.0542056784,
0.0163260642,
-0.0590573922,
-0.0096121775,
0.0153359408,
0.0334685519,
0.0010730164,
0.0445620492,
0.0260842908,
-0.0225157198,
0.0247539207,
0.0132887419,
0.0393379219,
0.0190405529,
-0.0689794645,
-0.0268020239,
0.0519701578,
0.0164686237,
0.0039223004,
-0.0061032292,
0.0182478242,
-0.0301424675,
0.0470065773,
-0.0091286926,
-0.0573138148,
0.0014980988,
0.0646410957,
-0.0552222133,
-0.0279141683,
0.0229845922,
0.0360348783,
-0.0608217157,
0.0011856412,
0.0589872897,
0.0020181632,
0.0054079029,
0.0376903079,
0.0309886653,
-0.0123373335,
-0.0088325413,
-0.0335199907,
-0.0621152706,
0.0184317324,
0.0160078406,
-0.029343117,
-0.0179810375,
0.0360324234,
-0.0171549637,
0.0062255189,
-0.0567299537,
-0.0097745359,
-0.029944744,
0.0153493248,
0.0516895838,
0.0729604959,
0.0283532403,
0.0328108147,
0.0209001657,
-0.0383398309,
-0.0594114996,
0.0940151066,
0.0269617885,
0.045835048,
-0.0085758949,
0.0610980093,
0.0217911582,
-0.017959889,
-0.0189509541,
-0.0099839643,
0.0249377694,
0.0335959531,
-0.0330826379,
0.0664023906,
-0.0023740586,
0.0049708742,
-0.0186649561,
0.0219848603,
-0.0070205424,
-0.0354275219,
0.0203622263,
-0.0024478848,
0.0373823978,
-0.0194275212,
0.0459212102,
0.0153193399,
-0.0209835842,
-0.0381786041,
-0.0014282856,
0.04824486,
-0.0171112679,
-0.0135667566,
0.0240016524,
-0.0231274888,
-0.0195551943,
-0.0104241977,
0.0893073156,
0.0190010518,
-0.0372913405,
0.0600887351,
-0.016451966,
0.0032606965,
-0.0184502769,
-0.0097237043,
0.0129486984,
0.0390597023,
0.0387338065,
-0.0511028245,
-0.0371200517,
0.0352502428,
-0.0478196591,
-0.028306596,
-0.0360812023,
-0.0777819604,
-0.0038569891,
-0.0238910727,
-0.0616473481,
-0.0222807135,
-0.0779373795,
0.0140415253,
0.0112747364,
-0.0511609428,
-0.0070200013,
0.0265493765,
2.816e-7,
-0.0313207023,
0.0115232309,
-0.0296098627,
0.0091839442,
0.0378026292,
0.0492605492,
-0.0043572965,
0.0266268663,
-0.0212192461,
-0.0537037812,
-0.04976625,
0.0055133156,
0.0342858508,
0.0245735608,
-0.0782261565,
-0.0141965458,
-0.0103882616,
0.0170449186,
-0.0761015415,
0.0883754417,
0.0526319891,
0.0301455762,
0.0119475462,
0.0089509748,
0.0658689588,
-0.0065897051,
-0.0102288956,
-0.0142286383,
0.0098281484,
-0.0141597781,
0.0135939131,
-0.0116753858,
-0.0254005175,
-0.0507775769,
0.0042752572,
-0.0302192308,
0.0295083877,
0.0519008674,
-0.006649639,
0.0410427786,
0.0163400937,
-0.0241902266,
-0.0428428687,
-0.0350437388,
0.0274663214,
-0.0508608036,
0.0099163586,
-0.0019331641,
0.004980478,
-0.01670474,
-0.0579871796,
-0.0353200696,
-0.0033014731,
-0.0192217845,
-0.0099609699,
-0.0609009378,
-0.0268003233,
-0.003061414,
-0.0348901451,
0.0537146032,
-0.0334884897,
-0.011857247,
-0.1059235781,
-0.0087919272,
0.0231877416,
-0.0149892671,
-0.0129911806,
1.999944303e-34,
-0.0134193953,
-0.0162218269,
0.0285364985,
-0.0074488283,
0.0516679287,
0.0274816975,
-0.0162845086,
0.0141294273,
0.0185483843,
-0.0211997777,
-0.0392208733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09642v1 | Cross-Domain Toxic Spans Detection | 2023-06-16T06:10:00 | 2023-06-16T06:10:00 | Stefan F. Schouten, Baran Barbarestani, Wondimagegnhue Tufa, Piek Vossen, Ilia Markov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Given the dynamic nature of toxic language use, automated methods for
detecting toxic spans are likely to encounter distributional shift. To explore
this phenomenon, we evaluate three approaches for detecting toxic spans under
cross-domain conditions: lexicon-based, rationale extraction, and fine-tuned
language models. Our findings indicate that a simple method using off-the-shelf
lexicons performs best in the cross-domain setup. The cross-domain error
analysis suggests that (1) rationale extraction methods are prone to false
negatives, while (2) language models, despite performing best for the in-domain
case, recall fewer explicitly toxic words than lexicons and are prone to
certain types of false positives. Our code is publicly available at:
https://github.com/sfschouten/toxic-cross-domain. | [
0.0225541834,
0.0135881184,
-0.0324837789,
0.0476356819,
0.003785192,
0.0163320992,
0.0025619795,
0.028106181,
0.0300196316,
-0.0646763071,
-0.0222918354,
0.0131958947,
-0.0208256319,
0.0551151372,
-0.0016666249,
-0.0165043902,
0.0240429826,
0.0160222612,
0.0276086852,
0.0126285441,
0.0269266926,
0.0223316476,
0.0106873484,
0.0468342751,
-0.0132893203,
-0.0421617627,
0.0728997067,
0.0010809824,
0.0363080651,
-0.0185316298,
0.038866207,
-0.0031667962,
-0.026006192,
0.0144695556,
0.0000018906,
-0.024314234,
-0.0106447823,
-0.0107763391,
-0.0018788263,
-0.0100157345,
0.0450833999,
0.0115235308,
-0.0402387306,
0.0158088151,
-0.0342897661,
0.0126689281,
0.0484106801,
-0.0053102318,
0.0725842267,
0.0490239039,
-0.0228796527,
0.0427923538,
-0.0262901559,
0.0350929908,
-0.0100459214,
-0.0247830395,
0.0798941851,
-0.0164825693,
-0.0212652627,
-0.035161376,
-0.0176930968,
0.0096759191,
-0.0264286269,
-0.0354051255,
-0.045951169,
-0.0401196219,
0.0086982315,
-0.0357267894,
0.0252821874,
0.076400876,
-0.051439967,
-0.0224086605,
0.0400788672,
0.0023895015,
-0.0135543933,
0.0322799347,
-0.0136546707,
0.0512141511,
-0.0035286529,
-0.0050519845,
-0.0097887591,
0.0313254744,
0.0295563787,
0.031037664,
0.0158923846,
0.0341769159,
0.0075775059,
-0.0291305054,
0.0262196325,
-0.0306225326,
-0.003395194,
-0.0116432365,
0.0227786079,
-0.0328395553,
0.0030322871,
0.0534125082,
-0.0430712402,
-0.0785581321,
0.0352244936,
-0.0518716462,
-0.006811725,
0.0011678935,
-0.041129481,
-0.0014963363,
-0.0105474126,
0.0198916122,
0.0001748833,
0.0193540007,
0.0118053788,
0.0321187973,
0.0119325407,
-0.0229048021,
-0.0159511417,
0.0038995435,
-0.0021158266,
0.0539047569,
-0.0483048782,
0.0309667215,
-0.0804749653,
0.0054048784,
-0.0020047524,
0.0140471924,
0.0138208549,
0.0220644642,
0.0240188967,
0.0008340469,
-0.0387659222,
0.0188806988,
0.0109780664,
-0.0343613289,
-0.0050755441,
0.0496442914,
-0.0562418886,
-0.045369938,
-0.0106438324,
0.1131846607,
0.0391517133,
-0.0196485482,
-0.0803673789,
-0.0744256228,
-0.0655860677,
-0.0072378065,
-0.0052237445,
-0.0317105092,
-0.0391263142,
-0.0050064772,
-0.0024275687,
-0.095483318,
0.0130659463,
0.0234816894,
-0.0758068934,
0.0530581363,
-0.0166401323,
-0.0253043398,
0.0020218799,
0.0310143624,
0.0115627414,
0.0722308904,
0.0054624421,
0.0381245278,
0.0512122922,
-0.0374989137,
-0.0252306852,
0.0370355397,
0.0172397606,
-0.0060364534,
-0.0673802197,
-0.0070412545,
0.0255120881,
-0.0411730781,
0.0007909737,
0.0392966308,
-0.0041129435,
-0.0330611393,
0.0649044365,
0.0455635525,
-0.0445554405,
-0.002371077,
0.0422700867,
-0.0071321898,
-0.0642544106,
0.012968773,
-0.0784591809,
-0.0462865457,
-0.0227974355,
-0.0340095311,
0.0137441922,
0.0440484621,
0.0162974354,
-0.0213936511,
-0.046963729,
-0.0169389229,
0.0313761383,
-0.026660366,
0.0330197997,
0.0412308984,
-0.0424468629,
0.0668974668,
0.0655696541,
-0.0513646305,
0.0161868334,
-0.0148206782,
0.0364839844,
0.0765688419,
0.048249796,
-0.0295542479,
-0.0053822803,
-0.0576054156,
0.0230839103,
-0.0019839231,
-0.0035984761,
-0.0049572312,
-0.0215170346,
-0.0225242991,
-0.0391665958,
0.0085297609,
0.0020027712,
-0.0079064984,
0.0256162547,
0.0062992326,
-0.0092310216,
-0.0693914443,
-0.0556708798,
0.0436766855,
0.0043941298,
-0.0324695632,
-0.0281094611,
0.0340807438,
0.0458589718,
-0.0109868422,
-0.0138742989,
-0.0278613791,
0.0075409897,
-0.0025838446,
-0.0425850824,
0.0035254054,
-0.0428856686,
0.0222381074,
0.0402263515,
-0.0684341192,
0.0116120847,
0.0437987335,
0.0109483646,
0.0161968675,
0.034011595,
-0.0504470207,
-0.0241954699,
-0.0168693569,
0.009696044,
-0.0273855384,
0.032190986,
-0.0368494578,
0.0716538727,
-0.0070256353,
0.0031273381,
-0.0100516714,
-0.0261998381,
-0.0053145802,
0.0170335155,
-0.0141732851,
-0.021138994,
-0.0438479558,
-0.0041812239,
0.0246303771,
-0.0075251036,
-0.0292885192,
-0.0000193804,
0.0363541581,
-0.0161262229,
-0.0158448331,
-0.0037791084,
0.0349980853,
0.0029202222,
-0.0188697688,
0.0339604281,
0.0112597477,
-0.0201414339,
0.014298412,
0.0566985086,
0.0014241529,
-0.0295076463,
0.009310184,
-0.015503224,
0.0074606547,
-0.0390683338,
0.0637054518,
-0.0204472728,
-0.0485878326,
-0.0189431235,
0.0591476075,
-0.0075175106,
0.0092058647,
0.0027555237,
-0.0436962396,
-0.0205765255,
0.0257748775,
0.0074303267,
0.0506633371,
0.0443903841,
0.0577761829,
0.0703000724,
-0.0060372553,
-0.0453586206,
-0.0277601928,
-0.0236232635,
-0.0107898572,
0.0120778047,
-0.0329918042,
0.0571992621,
0.0630564913,
0.0490772389,
0.0053933398,
-0.0401375294,
0.0081443693,
-0.0601443388,
-0.0191177651,
0.0014039413,
-0.1088251099,
-0.0378433578,
0.0136108985,
0.0012049254,
-0.0348444879,
0.0655383915,
0.0059981798,
0.0367050059,
-0.0112732518,
-0.0189725067,
0.0240843128,
-0.0239479579,
-0.0354250036,
0.0405792743,
0.0632018819,
-0.0547079295,
0.0050977753,
-0.0452040322,
0.067871131,
-0.0268304888,
0.0497472398,
-0.0475368984,
-0.0010211827,
0.0300611593,
-0.0384483524,
-0.0789313093,
-0.0474971272,
0.0221115705,
-0.0540242977,
-0.0088767102,
-0.0040462413,
-0.031379763,
0.0328383856,
0.0029203543,
-0.0205970667,
-0.0026820367,
-0.0067116632,
0.0244514085,
0.0017932841,
0.052442167,
-0.0642368495,
0.0163406096,
0.0182960331,
0.0207250211,
0.0971339643,
-0.0368029103,
-0.0006336806,
0.0170425028,
0.0223785508,
0.0158693306,
-0.0062786471,
0.0243450869,
0.0283126403,
0.0340005308,
-0.0165811814,
-0.019705154,
0.0507312939,
0.0317117944,
-0.0240009055,
0.0116853639,
-0.0036601888,
0.0195491649,
0.0397864021,
-0.0206132662,
-0.0845956579,
-0.015065453,
-0.0013716915,
0.0533845946,
-0.0652084649,
-0.0488832407,
0.0146732945,
-0.1189626604,
0.0004581629,
0.014272647,
-0.0273390468,
-0.0130286366,
-0.022308547,
0.0148738865,
-0.0191686116,
0.0412221476,
-0.0392918326,
-0.0186238699,
-0.0285689253,
0.0262180492,
-0.0624173693,
-0.0416072682,
0.0091975816,
-0.0123051982,
0.0193941277,
0.0477650054,
0.0315020122,
-0.0325603187,
-0.0449800156,
0.0581320077,
-0.0514528081,
-0.0076481057,
-0.0201083012,
0.1048753709,
0.0152258398,
-0.019114634,
-0.0020976858,
0.0531191342,
-0.0309744477,
-0.0217659958,
0.0186156444,
0.0955189094,
0.0106701823,
-0.0131966257,
-0.0270602126,
0.0295049101,
0.0580137037,
0.0736359805,
0.0404276662,
-0.0526219346,
-0.005098999,
-0.0487118252,
-0.0187141132,
-0.0112443129,
-0.0760752335,
-0.0222519077,
-0.0356872529,
-0.0500279963,
-0.0764560252,
0.0015699703,
0.01255643,
0.0210739188,
0.0437899604,
-0.0186799616,
-0.0455545671,
0.0149856079,
-0.0411024354,
0.0281893145,
0.0085329013,
0.0269821882,
-0.0336799845,
0.0417699441,
-0.0253048167,
-0.0049217837,
-0.0030569115,
0.0496638753,
0.0047533982,
-0.0595455691,
0.0456567146,
0.0475372635,
0.017491186,
-0.0027213038,
-0.022865789,
-0.0098628569,
0.0451600589,
0.0390994698,
-0.0397066399,
-0.04676494,
0.0500418879,
-0.0213912856,
0.0191962477,
0.0226490218,
-0.0400925018,
0.0078028482,
0.0557798557,
-0.0180668924,
-0.0629976392,
0.0162505712,
0.0340223685,
0.0068005472,
0.0687474757,
-0.0312399734,
-0.0208170842,
-0.025680026,
-0.0333334841,
-0.0175581407,
-0.0459069274,
0.0314959288,
0.0477847196,
0.0180781987,
-0.0292447694,
-0.0073720161,
-0.0004856605,
-0.0682758763,
0.0294549372,
-0.0254739281,
0.02714983,
0.025687553,
0.0576817058,
0.0624280497,
0.0358511098,
-0.0091323815,
0.0201498382,
0.0166953076,
0.04568756,
-0.0108147739,
0.0478796102,
0.0205282234,
0.0073378412,
0.0427768379,
0.0301121622,
0.0120463241,
0.0285563525,
-0.0080242492,
-0.045433037,
-0.0016967029,
-0.0467092246,
0.066846475,
0.0150358174,
-0.0095911976,
-0.0015231371,
0.0087554371,
-0.0031599244,
-0.0409548581,
0.0068623233,
0.0172435008,
-0.0348135233,
-0.0128519479,
0.0495864451,
-0.0177937374,
0.0276284926,
0.0122224046,
-0.0317508392,
-0.017958831,
0.0057744104,
0.0293548461,
0.0247255471,
-0.0130745964,
-0.0333289504,
-0.0861744657,
-0.0866597518,
-0.0097859232,
-0.0448537283,
0.013510352,
0.0179199204,
0.0104474993,
0.0809348449,
0.03444295,
0.0321504883,
-0.0180600509,
0.0204037372,
0.018795874,
-0.0231385287,
-0.0242558066,
-5.791097531e-33,
0.0163650215,
-0.0939973593,
-0.0400155745,
0.0339772478,
0.0076485681,
-0.0208470747,
-0.004741827,
0.014149664,
-0.0111074913,
0.0198717229,
0.0312527418,
-0.0072880494,
-0.0018103482,
-0.0101907095,
0.0073728943,
-0.0416083597,
0.0240648929,
0.006277231,
-0.0521632023,
0.0201486498,
0.101193279,
0.0238787197,
0.0374902859,
-0.1106469706,
0.0438320115,
0.029605642,
-0.0068861633,
0.0063981032,
0.0195567217,
0.0392884798,
0.0185985323,
0.0718336478,
0.0141415251,
-0.0249330066,
0.0095343869,
0.0581107661,
-0.0404783487,
-0.0276138801,
0.0622455217,
-0.0239832886,
0.0273202881,
-0.023517862,
0.0616321787,
-0.0121870888,
-0.0054363096,
-0.0271030664,
0.0477861986,
-0.0351790339,
-0.0063257478,
-0.0446370579,
-0.0653162971,
0.0128690479,
-0.037749473,
0.0085361395,
0.003876881,
0.0691967532,
0.0295534413,
0.0329799838,
-0.0414605215,
0.0230551828,
-0.0698699504,
-0.0310075972,
0.0426966213,
-0.004762853,
-0.0194029845,
0.0853487775,
-0.041877117,
0.0487019829,
0.0179250874,
0.0098323785,
-0.0087468345,
0.0163572319,
0.0405604206,
0.0334234312,
-0.0298658293,
-0.0414427184,
-0.0613436326,
0.0098285973,
-0.0025172501,
0.0074577858,
0.005431599,
-0.0429556854,
-0.0535275377,
-0.0236112606,
0.0152600305,
-0.0048724031,
-0.0191369914,
-0.0436612032,
0.0425945334,
-0.0541192293,
-0.0464525297,
-0.0120699899,
-0.0340498425,
-0.035075333,
0.0318383612,
0.0316382572,
0.0185129065,
-0.0467733555,
0.0047275447,
0.0034678779,
0.0134366713,
0.0207086336,
-0.0164370947,
-0.0276141129,
0.0289450176,
-0.0078494931,
0.0562637001,
0.0131545495,
-0.0740899593,
0.0086409627,
-0.028439967,
0.0570220537,
-0.0251613557,
0.0614200905,
0.0157290418,
0.011496488,
-0.0099755218,
-0.0124876155,
0.0786447302,
-0.0015277039,
-0.0124536799,
0.0183871705,
-0.0315359496,
0.0284986384,
-0.0567189306,
-0.0551473238,
-0.0001626178,
0.037907958,
0.0843109339,
-0.0873434618,
0.016053455,
-0.0550297648,
2.633e-7,
0.0517901406,
0.0352671817,
0.013155371,
-0.0000795027,
0.0203254726,
0.0337918885,
0.014152186,
0.015192179,
0.0076524001,
-0.035360124,
-0.0447567999,
-0.0173223112,
0.0386453308,
0.0630705133,
-0.0559946038,
0.0261497498,
-0.0449502505,
-0.0336505175,
-0.0560862795,
0.0080345226,
0.0447462611,
0.0284910854,
0.0473252684,
-0.0551728457,
-0.0043180119,
-0.0561961718,
-0.0244324245,
-0.0365173891,
-0.0030871348,
-0.0135456715,
0.0070718755,
-0.0146160284,
0.0105112307,
0.0112415701,
-0.0271982457,
0.0013555158,
-0.0069311801,
0.025857918,
0.0083657587,
-0.031464953,
-0.0353696495,
-0.0599128976,
0.0224332623,
-0.0314048231,
0.060467843,
-0.0061232508,
-0.0101435957,
-0.031475842,
-0.0331732035,
-0.0320439823,
0.0091069378,
-0.0355895869,
0.0068718623,
0.0250482466,
0.0075632818,
0.0212778859,
0.0093840668,
-0.0842931047,
-0.0128612444,
0.0155975148,
-0.0174513087,
-0.0290818214,
0.0269876104,
0.0201122425,
0.0293667335,
-0.0175384451,
0.0330244862,
2.615958904e-34,
0.0032729357,
-0.0252225343,
0.0191617701,
-0.036382705,
0.027121244,
0.0265550092,
-0.0223469008,
0.0045465105,
0.0117377369,
-0.0013859575,
0.0184707977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09631v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09631v1 | AUGUST: an Automatic Generation Understudy for Synthesizing Conversational Recommendation Datasets | 2023-06-16T05:27:14 | 2023-06-16T05:27:14 | Yu Lu, Junwei Bao, Zichen Ma, Xiaoguang Han, Youzheng Wu, Shuguang Cui, Xiaodong He | cs.CL | cs.CL | High-quality data is essential for conversational recommendation systems and
serves as the cornerstone of the network architecture development and training
strategy design. Existing works contribute heavy human efforts to manually
labeling or designing and extending recommender dialogue templates. However,
they suffer from (i) the limited number of human annotators results in that
datasets can hardly capture rich and large-scale cases in the real world, (ii)
the limited experience and knowledge of annotators account for the
uninformative corpus and inappropriate recommendations. In this paper, we
propose a novel automatic dataset synthesis approach that can generate both
large-scale and high-quality recommendation dialogues through a data2text
generation process, where unstructured recommendation conversations are
generated from structured graphs based on user-item information from the real
world. In doing so, we comprehensively exploit: (i) rich personalized user
profiles from traditional recommendation datasets, (ii) rich external knowledge
from knowledge graphs, and (iii) the conversation ability contained in
human-to-human conversational recommendation datasets. Extensive experiments
validate the benefit brought by the automatically synthesized data under
low-resource scenarios and demonstrate the promising potential to facilitate
the development of a more effective conversational recommendation system. | [
0.0766428113,
0.0250454657,
-0.0100151142,
0.0249660667,
0.0031478254,
-0.0022267469,
0.0000983765,
-0.0216538291,
0.0637080073,
-0.021775946,
-0.0204014201,
0.015347736,
-0.0127341449,
0.0601797365,
0.0187347494,
-0.0364736654,
-0.0108227748,
-0.0147510655,
0.002593139,
0.0207837131,
0.0428789333,
0.042064812,
0.0116204089,
0.0216617715,
-0.008487259,
0.0232177209,
-0.0074895164,
0.0139528783,
0.0084638502,
-0.0239247773,
0.0338917151,
0.0397444516,
0.0225565676,
-0.0127468631,
0.0000018347,
-0.0067343512,
0.0201599803,
-0.0336458199,
-0.01477003,
-0.0537778363,
0.0501949154,
0.0649026036,
0.0214930587,
0.0310217254,
-0.0493265241,
-0.0036640789,
0.0244407915,
0.0586562939,
0.0393645726,
0.0484898612,
-0.0462776795,
-0.0057152025,
-0.005140774,
-0.031262774,
0.0301242042,
-0.0064905519,
-0.0075871507,
0.0118001774,
0.0146145942,
0.0318360887,
0.0315657929,
-0.0344302654,
-0.0096351728,
-0.0484812409,
0.0829375833,
0.0241454151,
-0.0580714829,
-0.031630557,
0.0045182863,
0.1386128813,
0.0299409162,
-0.009434781,
0.0102563472,
-0.0002080169,
0.0178325847,
-0.0114528937,
-0.0232904125,
-0.0327348188,
-0.0442626774,
0.0261179414,
-0.0288861226,
0.0021699157,
0.0207114462,
-0.0394492596,
0.011390578,
0.0452312455,
-0.0132110342,
-0.0099502122,
0.0222369991,
0.0030735463,
0.0037601145,
-0.0757223815,
0.005869613,
-0.0147351194,
-0.0766788125,
0.0204245429,
-0.0547197722,
0.0440708622,
-0.0142463418,
-0.0329711661,
0.0345985517,
-0.0107422201,
0.0161240529,
0.0142653836,
0.0261019152,
-0.0114354389,
-0.0007114897,
-0.0278717726,
-0.043633271,
-0.0369005054,
-0.0348694436,
0.0109644076,
-0.0304374862,
0.0244442448,
-0.073055923,
-0.0272035077,
-0.044969134,
0.0715254843,
-0.0052263895,
0.04446261,
0.0105580026,
0.0741160959,
-0.0127436342,
0.0183824487,
-0.0816265643,
-0.0135047818,
-0.0517602079,
0.0276779849,
0.035617426,
-0.022358017,
0.0460893326,
0.0411121361,
0.0494452193,
-0.0150190722,
-0.0119995596,
0.0592925623,
-0.0102074863,
-0.013661365,
-0.0176219456,
-0.0541954562,
0.0001821771,
-0.0390243828,
-0.0218085777,
-0.0478438549,
0.0837629065,
0.0270171463,
-0.0339449197,
-0.0283457171,
0.0432676449,
0.0336970799,
-0.031557247,
0.075600177,
-0.0649150908,
0.0056188656,
0.0264806654,
0.0022806535,
-0.0143234776,
0.013100531,
0.0338558108,
0.0668033957,
0.0688908622,
0.0244956892,
0.0151702091,
0.0106199859,
0.0242972914,
0.0258459169,
0.0048568025,
0.0480789505,
-0.0305657368,
0.0302911494,
0.0133177927,
0.0540475398,
-0.0677884892,
0.0166368242,
0.0510129705,
0.0102554029,
0.0129381176,
0.0786152408,
0.0565291867,
0.0642732531,
-0.0193856079,
-0.0151033178,
0.0008886571,
0.020237565,
-0.0001535992,
-0.0465214103,
0.0507032201,
-0.0174975861,
-0.0290620029,
-0.0458893403,
0.0316514671,
-0.0233224425,
0.0583095141,
0.0232648347,
-0.018049499,
0.0117649995,
-0.0585958585,
0.0308086425,
0.040888425,
-0.0577630289,
-0.0130868265,
0.014500794,
0.0631317347,
0.1141799912,
0.0477561951,
0.0250574425,
-0.0132451607,
0.0035316593,
0.0123102618,
-0.0292289965,
0.0472644344,
-0.0625030994,
0.0134494603,
-0.0670526847,
-0.0564689115,
-0.0015038721,
-0.0405700654,
0.0204751808,
0.0184210334,
0.0045937113,
0.025901556,
-0.0224555265,
-0.0489341952,
-0.0319952108,
-0.0041175871,
0.0115924207,
0.0658186078,
-0.0027570706,
0.0414478928,
0.0363034345,
0.0181133095,
-0.0324979126,
0.0235625617,
-0.0062716794,
-0.0205063038,
0.0176046416,
-0.0384205319,
-0.0255304147,
0.0021349469,
-0.0666254535,
0.0058153868,
0.0029900726,
-0.0291223451,
-0.0575207509,
-0.014343651,
-0.0343302898,
0.03299997,
-0.0012194617,
-0.0209413487,
0.0520585179,
0.0523593388,
0.0096257962,
0.0549756251,
0.0167163163,
-0.0201753583,
0.0085623637,
0.007420104,
0.0321770534,
-0.0686863512,
0.0193625055,
0.0096606743,
0.0173290446,
-0.007881782,
0.030617658,
0.0156780798,
-0.0726664662,
-0.0000993158,
-0.11232391,
0.0083625801,
0.0250441954,
-0.022807654,
0.0039506899,
0.0369483642,
0.0103792613,
-0.0388038717,
-0.0957264975,
0.0449812561,
0.0123075433,
-0.0131759373,
0.0642975122,
0.0090376204,
-0.0002654193,
-0.0196145494,
-0.000420224,
0.0117984749,
0.0543720536,
0.03052558,
-0.0026961186,
-0.0190851465,
-0.0014348101,
-0.0596293882,
-0.0003596292,
-0.0144119812,
0.0098137641,
-0.0006411636,
0.0182213765,
0.0507536866,
-0.0142289549,
0.0271843839,
0.0352811664,
-0.0022242144,
-0.0096540395,
-0.0343146138,
0.0204118714,
-0.025375396,
0.0297646821,
-0.0332378224,
-0.025044037,
0.0193704516,
-0.0200756472,
-0.0008343257,
0.021754656,
-0.0527544282,
0.016561728,
0.063751258,
0.0018653033,
-0.0177311413,
-0.0389380679,
-0.0076721362,
0.061600145,
-0.0233111214,
-0.0181473456,
0.0417935252,
-0.0088416804,
-0.0081403358,
-0.0268052612,
-0.0372287147,
-0.0297218915,
0.0097841294,
0.0122400923,
0.0147712249,
-0.0206554346,
-0.0190397054,
-0.0122129945,
-0.0138619011,
0.0316957496,
-0.0214596,
0.0026126325,
-0.0275846031,
-0.006617269,
0.0411139242,
-0.0475956649,
-0.0529771671,
-0.0244788956,
-0.0239379257,
-0.0332241021,
0.0422570817,
-0.0351112671,
-0.0289265569,
-0.0409094542,
-0.0382064469,
0.0412298888,
0.0146079753,
-0.0191136785,
-0.0043451698,
0.0504183657,
0.0601146184,
-0.011876476,
-0.0115052648,
0.0130567476,
0.0623878725,
0.0335819311,
-0.0062722121,
-0.0333066694,
-0.0134710111,
0.0008898174,
0.0219792277,
0.0327687785,
-0.0020422831,
0.0226573758,
0.032300625,
0.0396206751,
-0.0125461891,
0.0631528646,
0.0269236956,
-0.086961247,
0.0327162966,
0.0126205711,
0.0323533118,
-0.0003108626,
0.0398303643,
-0.108870022,
-0.0148358429,
-0.0212022215,
0.0565634258,
-0.0097266305,
-0.0692145154,
-0.0226198472,
-0.1078597531,
0.0428099483,
0.0026083305,
-0.0017277664,
0.0034494796,
-0.0302997734,
-0.0276490375,
-0.0092822043,
0.0068480438,
-0.0402261466,
0.0296221375,
0.0061476557,
-0.0029206914,
-0.0171650238,
-0.0419334099,
0.0444289893,
-0.0078969132,
0.0467070043,
0.0131754717,
0.0815795362,
0.0619119667,
0.0213183109,
0.0093741743,
0.0232314803,
-0.0229336936,
-0.0123426002,
0.0705727115,
-0.0083324676,
0.0018522461,
-0.0666175336,
0.0686209723,
-0.0410907492,
-0.0276450422,
0.0246105678,
0.0078307968,
-0.0378556661,
0.0061986968,
-0.0105476482,
0.0353272632,
0.0656662285,
0.033556845,
0.0323434472,
-0.0392154083,
0.0193353351,
-0.0353972577,
-0.016578678,
-0.0596204214,
0.0022437293,
-0.0129358899,
-0.0175699051,
0.0412960425,
-0.0744169578,
-0.0397169329,
0.0123734949,
0.0066436846,
-0.0144709637,
-0.0010510864,
0.0115812281,
-0.008176066,
0.0014153183,
0.0078679929,
0.0037662308,
-0.000274457,
-0.0179113988,
-0.0554720126,
0.0107257375,
-0.0773768276,
0.0030559674,
0.0468152352,
-0.052694492,
-0.0471610986,
-0.0561380163,
0.0336853229,
0.0206723083,
0.0983094424,
-0.018542476,
-0.0386542641,
0.0367796384,
0.0556374677,
-0.0494937524,
-0.0593781732,
-0.0198494773,
0.0749368817,
0.0135982428,
0.0631369725,
-0.0507009253,
0.0045542005,
-0.0259603355,
-0.0072667561,
-0.0337520614,
-0.0632621869,
0.0118851392,
0.0153838778,
-0.0018741372,
-0.0005919249,
0.0191229302,
-0.036665976,
0.0228320565,
-0.0508333072,
-0.0610976517,
-0.0633917749,
0.0106009906,
0.0223434679,
-0.0165664889,
-0.0155909667,
-0.0309348069,
-0.0389396399,
0.0453516133,
-0.0341655686,
-0.0015386688,
0.016916832,
-0.0220265891,
0.0545081533,
-0.0070166509,
-0.0015688458,
0.0154221132,
0.0329513662,
0.0317236856,
-0.0197736751,
0.0533297695,
0.0108912103,
-0.0420361497,
-0.0078557907,
0.0539367795,
-0.0359563828,
-0.0233759657,
-0.0253400225,
0.0442006439,
-0.0021942451,
-0.0235361904,
0.0338442959,
-0.0372436829,
0.0019223726,
-0.0198442936,
0.0535401329,
-0.0374213345,
-0.0415240489,
0.0034275365,
0.0034987633,
-0.0280319024,
0.0225611795,
0.0569926165,
0.0041160667,
-0.0145050669,
-0.0166064464,
-0.0545229502,
-0.0536961071,
-0.0009894918,
-0.0068754591,
0.0454468206,
-0.001551016,
-0.0289402492,
-0.0080197183,
-0.053720016,
-0.0365990549,
-0.0376790129,
0.0104787191,
-0.0053505357,
0.0574123934,
0.0495197549,
0.0152581064,
0.024446195,
-0.0513616689,
0.0018029992,
-0.0225017555,
-0.0227546878,
-0.0361878648,
-5.814467461e-33,
0.0053539337,
-0.0489509813,
0.0286573041,
0.0185394213,
-0.0265928395,
-0.0404842533,
-0.026164839,
-0.0177380051,
0.034530893,
0.0050544497,
-0.0257665068,
0.0129448213,
0.002787492,
0.0460134931,
-0.0226953197,
-0.0220909324,
0.0416225642,
0.0029043339,
-0.0238018818,
0.0902837962,
0.0597875193,
0.0338196792,
-0.0038537334,
-0.0930682048,
0.0157234296,
-0.0498687699,
0.0091031268,
0.0162716787,
0.0562869534,
0.0539067201,
0.0017196805,
0.0925978124,
0.0013418694,
0.0117516275,
0.0067619574,
0.0036312619,
-0.0796505138,
-0.0261795223,
0.0270503033,
-0.0247987974,
-0.0237875208,
-0.025022639,
0.0147432517,
-0.0231455192,
0.0250183959,
-0.0032372337,
0.0472462215,
-0.0076868436,
-0.0362052955,
-0.0314451568,
0.0063283532,
0.0116874501,
-0.0286203194,
-0.0344010554,
-0.0335484594,
0.0518971644,
0.0112363026,
-0.0064373971,
-0.0468786284,
0.0664310828,
-0.0228808746,
-0.0350912288,
-0.009193914,
-0.0175900795,
-0.0196260363,
0.0203682594,
0.0395035669,
0.0386456847,
0.000444055,
0.0193572361,
-0.0673651323,
0.0804925486,
-0.0260907225,
0.0620268732,
-0.0162188057,
-0.0297189225,
-0.0386342071,
0.0351959877,
0.0008238537,
-0.0412553735,
-0.0192805734,
-0.0000559183,
-0.0221526846,
-0.0376426764,
-0.0033463109,
-0.025275616,
-0.0316458605,
-0.0334768742,
0.0082308929,
0.0165040772,
-0.0051226509,
0.0093733715,
-0.0283798967,
-0.0644041598,
-0.004262533,
0.0167748742,
-0.0405129902,
-0.0244806428,
-0.0059211408,
-0.0389599614,
-0.0333455056,
-0.0317913853,
0.0405998342,
0.0006819025,
-0.0014826891,
0.02886834,
0.0299804695,
0.0033899823,
-0.0166213028,
0.0063244957,
-0.0105574513,
0.0155517152,
-0.0496761091,
0.013554927,
0.0221824925,
0.0518646315,
-0.0584318452,
0.0751431584,
-0.0122414073,
0.0592061691,
-0.0220743306,
-0.0780945197,
0.0216681957,
0.0166090205,
-0.0240952484,
-0.0211647786,
-0.034864936,
-0.0467809066,
0.0799466223,
-0.0453522317,
-0.0175040867,
-0.0314850733,
2.535e-7,
-0.0364432409,
0.0198405534,
-0.0034126411,
-0.0173923541,
0.0214805715,
0.037697915,
0.0453200862,
0.0598654747,
-0.0002260351,
0.0177736767,
0.0620534606,
-0.001573948,
0.0147096077,
0.0306416191,
-0.0721188411,
0.0022835413,
-0.0628526658,
-0.0524453595,
-0.0530616157,
0.0105209695,
0.0541351475,
0.0430838019,
0.0411533602,
-0.0141797047,
0.0111459829,
0.0092154527,
0.0291439705,
-0.0609714799,
-0.04403577,
0.0015523281,
0.0598884635,
0.0096365027,
-0.0388645865,
0.0328485779,
-0.0604006611,
0.0071886927,
0.0137970466,
0.026175281,
0.0070487359,
-0.038519837,
0.0199168641,
0.0009211842,
0.0117579307,
-0.0194524899,
0.0565913618,
-0.0372182615,
-0.0388031751,
0.005261865,
-0.0341821834,
-0.0223309416,
-0.0038115864,
-0.0210429039,
0.0001006552,
0.0191390645,
0.0066997311,
0.0084595559,
0.0121993143,
-0.0564012416,
0.0438756719,
0.0052961959,
-0.0473673902,
-0.0591659397,
-0.0312597305,
0.0194691624,
0.0243348498,
-0.0056474772,
0.0536757223,
1.774129887e-34,
0.0116770621,
0.0451256149,
-0.0179397203,
-0.0417477898,
0.0558237135,
-0.0373179018,
0.0085803429,
0.0035404267,
0.0601133257,
-0.0554627404,
-0.0233195219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09607v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09607v1 | Listener Model for the PhotoBook Referential Game with CLIPScores as Implicit Reference Chain | 2023-06-16T03:41:14 | 2023-06-16T03:41:14 | Shih-Lun Wu, Yi-Hui Chou, Liangze Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | PhotoBook is a collaborative dialogue game where two players receive private,
partially-overlapping sets of images and resolve which images they have in
common. It presents machines with a great challenge to learn how people build
common ground around multimodal context to communicate effectively. Methods
developed in the literature, however, cannot be deployed to real gameplay since
they only tackle some subtasks of the game, and they require additional
reference chains inputs, whose extraction process is imperfect. Therefore, we
propose a reference chain-free listener model that directly addresses the
game's predictive task, i.e., deciding whether an image is shared with partner.
Our DeBERTa-based listener model reads the full dialogue, and utilizes
CLIPScore features to assess utterance-image relevance. We achieve >77%
accuracy on unseen sets of images/game themes, outperforming baseline by >17
points. | [
0.0494420342,
0.0316812769,
-0.0246297829,
0.0678573102,
-0.0343597569,
-0.0076936618,
0.0008129717,
0.0054860376,
-0.0177773349,
-0.0156611614,
-0.0789126009,
-0.0223978143,
-0.0237543993,
0.0486845821,
-0.0022464527,
-0.0580852628,
0.0326894075,
-0.0108654248,
0.0345400572,
0.0107554551,
0.0079400446,
0.0001559746,
-0.0241451021,
0.0460096039,
-0.043472413,
0.0227765311,
-0.0356138498,
0.0262066294,
0.0028564048,
-0.0083400281,
-0.0466953926,
0.0184028149,
0.0046563973,
-0.0231958814,
0.0000015149,
0.0011154406,
0.0089321416,
-0.048190292,
0.0493150316,
-0.0593987219,
-0.0109573351,
0.0214075036,
0.0061819674,
-0.0199313201,
-0.0481767617,
0.0170563497,
0.0878856629,
0.0619537868,
0.075396359,
0.0309030209,
-0.0199616607,
0.0034509981,
0.0014218903,
-0.0319124199,
0.0545452163,
-0.0826140642,
-0.0200342499,
0.0437759012,
0.0174266882,
-0.0072820974,
-0.0362729728,
0.0287909843,
-0.0138414865,
0.0061773625,
0.0089765154,
0.0359719954,
-0.046177417,
-0.0094869006,
0.0047091483,
0.1099126041,
0.0099070929,
0.0329185203,
0.0374643952,
0.0217196103,
0.0064422009,
0.0177140255,
-0.0372381918,
-0.0160799082,
-0.0171306692,
0.0202812999,
-0.0679982007,
0.0459473394,
0.0014529849,
-0.0321368612,
0.0693452507,
0.0257738158,
-0.0215044748,
-0.004284082,
-0.0260234382,
0.0206700265,
-0.0079357838,
-0.0453674458,
0.010983428,
0.0003813083,
-0.0310247373,
0.0294629969,
-0.0379441604,
0.0237991046,
-0.0119407512,
-0.0153682875,
0.0534543954,
0.0018769591,
-0.0318422206,
0.0881270766,
0.025113171,
-0.0253388137,
-0.0015206911,
-0.0079085995,
-0.0135716563,
-0.0184564684,
-0.0153919579,
-0.0033970829,
-0.0422414877,
0.0406847261,
-0.0472825468,
-0.0849960521,
-0.018567564,
0.0109382505,
-0.0402184427,
0.0203872509,
0.0147384135,
0.0311946385,
-0.0078016818,
0.0032265685,
-0.0123293418,
0.0312007666,
-0.0426204242,
0.0140200397,
-0.0193686355,
-0.0649225861,
0.0049792458,
-0.0206297282,
0.0294661038,
-0.0232700743,
-0.0158931501,
0.054049097,
-0.0387481712,
-0.0391552001,
0.0374132395,
-0.0459698439,
-0.0247495733,
-0.0737175867,
0.0195192304,
-0.0335935578,
0.0361696593,
-0.0324624106,
0.0220597479,
-0.0165604148,
0.0169434603,
0.0173999351,
-0.0179785695,
0.1209169403,
0.040929269,
0.0358909182,
0.0119742136,
0.0589889139,
-0.0441142246,
0.047913108,
0.0244186781,
0.0177286956,
0.0258653741,
0.0006729608,
0.0029094173,
0.0582418926,
-0.0016489308,
-0.0116377855,
-0.0254408289,
-0.0106611606,
-0.0155943884,
0.0101900892,
0.0050696139,
0.0185871925,
-0.0474079773,
-0.0682040155,
0.0662585348,
0.0698429272,
-0.0224317554,
0.0078515224,
0.0022686543,
0.0491054691,
-0.01929079,
0.0257522184,
-0.0167631712,
0.07715334,
0.014823514,
-0.0325000696,
0.0500613786,
-0.0395456739,
-0.0347906277,
-0.0268868282,
0.0518075749,
0.0029922572,
0.0105156172,
0.002381257,
0.011512164,
-0.0237088632,
-0.0303853601,
0.0702988431,
-0.0251706261,
-0.0314126126,
-0.0279754605,
-0.0237389915,
0.0451154448,
0.0592945106,
0.0226267129,
-0.0070026997,
-0.0263738763,
0.0162705239,
-0.0144614438,
0.0234534964,
-0.0062624584,
-0.0211710539,
0.0823959261,
-0.051140029,
-0.0515537411,
-0.0187654179,
0.00873861,
0.0696043819,
-0.0268852711,
-0.0084559461,
0.0126471529,
0.0228328258,
0.0706162602,
-0.0050868317,
0.0442385674,
-0.030721508,
-0.021790687,
0.0512432009,
0.0482586809,
0.0197311286,
-0.0072958218,
-0.005880659,
0.0151580209,
-0.0024299487,
0.0318213142,
0.066745013,
-0.0653686523,
-0.0105182026,
0.025474498,
-0.0749355257,
-0.0040126764,
0.017687412,
-0.0054151607,
-0.0321049318,
0.0601371937,
-0.0322060697,
-0.0036428303,
-0.0383913033,
-0.0132015403,
0.0182125624,
0.0411515236,
0.0362672396,
0.011179897,
-0.0155212712,
-0.0295852982,
0.0169118792,
-0.0098712537,
0.0449435897,
-0.0715444088,
0.0149036469,
0.005055076,
-0.012837314,
-0.0017884012,
0.0170291886,
0.0002072946,
-0.0844219923,
-0.0227113999,
-0.0976284891,
-0.0321525596,
-0.0014774856,
-0.0250602402,
-0.0333695412,
-0.0105524277,
-0.0087989178,
-0.0672139972,
-0.0287970416,
0.0112659689,
0.0222327933,
0.0107912328,
-0.0142926965,
0.0615507402,
0.0048593231,
-0.0384441726,
-0.0076945727,
0.039163921,
0.0357360654,
0.0055842223,
-0.018681854,
0.0091550844,
-0.0128950262,
-0.0345157161,
0.0568786487,
-0.0049144905,
-0.0136710797,
0.0297225565,
-0.0266640205,
0.0431864746,
0.0432798825,
-0.0238721669,
0.0097648473,
-0.0002170055,
-0.0739701688,
-0.0488926992,
0.0265140627,
0.0260058828,
-0.0193466544,
-0.0107581625,
-0.0223373007,
0.016724227,
0.0162613988,
-0.0330796652,
0.0296579096,
-0.0651251674,
0.028239904,
0.0606763139,
-0.0506481417,
-0.0660201982,
-0.0402583666,
-0.025063822,
-0.0110788569,
-0.0384779237,
-0.0134820789,
0.0489728115,
-0.0394529961,
-0.0264775958,
0.0113710212,
0.0044309068,
-0.0053077298,
0.0905994996,
0.0127239441,
-0.0094408579,
0.0332245156,
-0.0192436744,
-0.0290200002,
0.0056974031,
0.0557929128,
-0.0062128711,
0.0238431133,
-0.0398271531,
-0.0041560307,
0.0197238587,
-0.0167646874,
-0.0128347492,
-0.0021722631,
-0.0697099268,
-0.035320498,
-0.074064441,
0.0195793658,
-0.053047359,
0.039470721,
0.025264414,
-0.0286055021,
0.0224509668,
-0.0058286083,
-0.0095102768,
0.0754332095,
0.0714003444,
-0.0157862827,
-0.0600472167,
-0.0292039569,
-0.0254835337,
0.0436586887,
0.0393540449,
-0.0383039713,
-0.0001156551,
0.0185961276,
0.0200305097,
0.0389865339,
-0.0423589312,
0.0392221622,
0.0281174462,
-0.0372410603,
0.0058438964,
0.061250668,
-0.0016934453,
-0.0595546439,
-0.0391013287,
-0.0121554956,
-0.0132527174,
0.0138576617,
0.0080925105,
-0.0512147397,
-0.0661331266,
0.0041462402,
-0.0347395614,
0.0211973693,
-0.0342364535,
-0.0451057963,
-0.1049059182,
0.0099369688,
0.0042902031,
-0.0145754181,
-0.0000932751,
0.0324902646,
0.0267091412,
-0.0233168621,
-0.0485308431,
-0.0259738546,
0.0174688827,
0.0035060246,
-0.0149889654,
0.0282947272,
0.011040586,
0.0298774801,
-0.0644203573,
0.0518086478,
0.049753096,
0.0833172277,
0.0351694115,
-0.0276640318,
-0.0088092797,
-0.0235057101,
0.0045272619,
0.022072183,
0.067383647,
-0.0393149331,
-0.005289997,
0.0173375718,
0.0201967806,
0.035999503,
-0.0109127145,
0.0046431422,
0.0281689931,
-0.0093769729,
-0.0121325292,
-0.0252398849,
0.0645585582,
0.0681724176,
0.0373451412,
0.0233097188,
-0.0151170595,
0.0126499282,
0.0112364292,
0.032231994,
-0.0764513314,
-0.0119151678,
-0.0508733243,
0.0180889349,
0.0279854387,
-0.0684745237,
-0.0346609838,
-0.0374148004,
0.0089827087,
-0.0317957401,
0.0104908971,
-0.0102429502,
0.0472151041,
-0.0230948366,
0.0409654379,
-0.0404760838,
-0.0055445386,
-0.0343570895,
-0.014414385,
0.019398354,
-0.0244329702,
-0.0198237784,
0.0712697804,
-0.0552194305,
-0.0201686863,
-0.0522240065,
0.0762783438,
0.0162865035,
0.0204478223,
0.0132150576,
-0.0646487623,
-0.0335936025,
0.0261285417,
-0.0294841751,
0.0109004918,
0.020183716,
-0.023654243,
-0.0262569506,
0.0316478275,
-0.0292360391,
0.0318504684,
-0.0156735647,
0.0348006263,
-0.0321780629,
-0.0763145536,
-0.0382691883,
-0.0410394482,
0.0655092821,
-0.0079589523,
0.027919054,
0.0168605428,
0.0337230265,
0.0030666438,
0.0419961624,
-0.0690063313,
-0.0003276237,
-0.0309118815,
0.0135357268,
-0.0154048027,
-0.0286117997,
-0.0241336208,
0.0490324087,
0.0006231663,
-0.0145259891,
0.0684500113,
-0.0465978943,
-0.0133153638,
-0.0009960679,
0.0342425443,
0.0421303548,
0.0234414283,
0.0249336977,
0.0255095512,
0.0588287152,
0.0189417526,
-0.0644148737,
0.0192258768,
0.0390652791,
-0.0016464258,
0.0200915374,
0.0031132125,
0.0279537383,
0.0727968067,
-0.0052798339,
-0.0191484094,
-0.0064278827,
0.0045670001,
0.007226876,
0.0209449884,
-0.0136642568,
-0.0857931599,
0.0204489548,
0.0295469817,
0.0054417467,
0.0369412377,
0.0351295136,
-0.0078643123,
-0.014495017,
-0.0066045825,
-0.0214990173,
-0.0436675139,
0.0004484291,
0.0030685707,
0.0491729788,
-0.0337207243,
0.0534799211,
-0.026741948,
-0.0434357785,
0.0255459733,
0.0237940084,
0.0139253121,
0.0196397565,
0.0462833717,
0.019151194,
0.0248862039,
-0.0234328005,
-0.0027699571,
-0.0088028712,
-0.0679076537,
0.0179487057,
-0.0224680528,
-5.060867951e-33,
-0.043943353,
-0.0558829606,
0.03898485,
0.0112646986,
-0.025951229,
0.0165142659,
-0.0538409613,
-0.0051105679,
-0.0083071543,
-0.0025295389,
-0.0072535444,
0.0173370466,
0.0133898016,
0.018668443,
0.0122928703,
-0.0335148796,
0.0323978327,
-0.0042636134,
-0.0172721799,
0.0320066661,
0.0319878161,
0.0202013347,
0.034597259,
-0.0810987949,
-0.0343763232,
-0.0013253599,
-0.0390860476,
0.0342956446,
0.0453230925,
0.0430593491,
0.0029183042,
-0.015008796,
-0.0126977293,
-0.0188148599,
0.008735111,
0.0358303972,
-0.0960993543,
-0.018114252,
0.0215940382,
0.0053385478,
-0.0091565484,
-0.0026212072,
-0.0101778796,
0.0105347829,
0.0090295384,
-0.0425819233,
0.0296694208,
-0.0294365119,
-0.0261596199,
-0.0026747931,
-0.0081754206,
0.0105601735,
-0.0186215118,
-0.0378037058,
0.0560438037,
0.0856783167,
0.031901516,
-0.0373389609,
-0.0381887443,
0.0863462016,
-0.0368426666,
-0.0091914516,
0.0674476027,
0.0093907714,
0.0413970985,
0.0655904636,
0.0193786323,
-0.0588083863,
-0.0437609442,
-0.0814613029,
-0.0017955177,
0.0750777945,
0.0277526788,
0.0363267325,
0.0270975959,
0.0337711498,
0.0023580871,
0.0388697349,
0.0237559378,
0.0459236875,
0.0122934133,
0.0566174798,
-0.0204195622,
0.0332476906,
-0.023152303,
0.0177583545,
-0.0482947193,
-0.0708770975,
0.03218247,
0.0268500391,
0.0117405178,
0.0368092284,
0.101852648,
-0.0460348763,
-0.009854516,
0.0402850993,
0.0214007236,
0.0283935629,
-0.0218692254,
-0.0211295243,
-0.0335726663,
-0.0059557194,
0.0795227885,
0.0078955749,
0.0094392505,
0.0097018508,
0.0126793385,
0.0133571699,
-0.0170113165,
-0.0252948217,
-0.0017800974,
0.0508276559,
-0.0375388563,
0.0278228987,
0.0265583415,
0.0029938631,
-0.0702808648,
0.0188644435,
-0.0333445556,
0.007946874,
0.0030657793,
-0.0347683839,
-0.0151668582,
-0.0009813028,
-0.0358135812,
0.0018219897,
-0.0410805531,
-0.0256408118,
-0.0066857822,
-0.0085446425,
-0.0413757153,
0.0142575614,
2.514e-7,
-0.049800314,
-0.0018455867,
0.0118334228,
0.0210521184,
-0.0170753803,
0.057597518,
-0.0429121852,
0.0490398929,
0.0168547221,
-0.012417011,
0.0660067052,
0.0258705728,
0.0577467196,
0.0099111339,
-0.0865098611,
-0.0155055495,
-0.0546826944,
-0.0377151221,
-0.0010420553,
0.0117102321,
-0.0023792482,
0.05412855,
0.0381061882,
0.0097563239,
0.0369927995,
-0.0301846284,
0.0542874187,
-0.0667412728,
0.0072719441,
-0.0194085874,
0.0383313634,
-0.0387847535,
-0.055598814,
-0.0097614899,
-0.0229756199,
0.0304171313,
0.0593334697,
0.0342010632,
-0.006133358,
-0.0758004338,
-0.0460422747,
0.0500196703,
0.000856852,
-0.0132724987,
0.0367312245,
-0.0465869643,
-0.0586434193,
0.040372964,
-0.0440199487,
-0.0179183744,
-0.0090745697,
-0.0105956532,
-0.041095417,
0.0134177022,
0.0052591749,
-0.0193875227,
0.0058970824,
-0.0866394341,
-0.0284012165,
-0.0230815578,
-0.0132102417,
0.0175033435,
-0.0427147113,
-0.0592360795,
-0.012202098,
-0.0244086031,
-0.029158935,
1.169635131e-34,
0.004555305,
-0.015002924,
-0.0197686851,
-0.0082563879,
0.0256222431,
0.0010126467,
-0.0251962245,
0.0489981957,
0.045605015,
-0.0241901521,
0.0022621469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09597v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09597v3 | Clickbait Detection via Large Language Models | 2023-06-16T02:49:20 | 2023-12-06T09:05:32 | Han Wang, Yi Zhu, Ye Wang, Yun Li, Yunhao Yuan, Jipeng Qiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Clickbait, which aims to induce users with some surprising and even thrilling
headlines for increasing click-through rates, permeates almost all online
content publishers, such as news portals and social media. Recently, Large
Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as a powerful instrument and achieved
tremendous success in a series of NLP downstream tasks. However, it is not yet
known whether LLMs can be served as a high-quality clickbait detection system.
In this paper, we analyze the performance of LLMs in the few-shot and zero-shot
scenarios on several English and Chinese benchmark datasets. Experimental
results show that LLMs cannot achieve the best results compared to the
state-of-the-art deep and fine-tuning PLMs methods. Different from human
intuition, the experiments demonstrated that LLMs cannot make satisfied
clickbait detection just by the headlines. | [
0.0758522004,
0.0143854227,
-0.0221357904,
0.0467401855,
-0.0501407459,
0.0106329601,
-0.0205680467,
0.0462559201,
0.0239955354,
-0.0197763126,
-0.0354082994,
-0.0434385389,
-0.0023722057,
0.0403836183,
0.011614793,
-0.0190523211,
0.0295033604,
-0.0147988321,
-0.0009011699,
0.0153543297,
0.0298280045,
0.0152322352,
0.0616738908,
0.0187502168,
0.036007721,
-0.019776253,
0.0163737778,
0.0370885544,
0.0145550119,
-0.0291465949,
0.0300047956,
0.0436790027,
0.0255407933,
0.07872352,
0.000001593,
-0.0126726329,
0.01607012,
-0.0035632106,
0.0075744623,
0.062009085,
0.0545271114,
-0.0584478341,
-0.0101476153,
0.0112744328,
-0.0061500343,
0.0301856492,
0.0262801833,
0.0775990561,
0.0541082025,
0.0705861524,
-0.0173894782,
0.0031366951,
0.0063841548,
-0.0434478782,
0.0150666116,
-0.0339649506,
0.0442722328,
-0.0285917204,
0.009567108,
0.0552305728,
-0.0069025028,
0.0241567381,
-0.0069148857,
-0.0279082637,
-0.0625313893,
0.0159459226,
-0.0310553946,
-0.0059927264,
0.006922144,
0.0451361127,
-0.1178757027,
-0.0444687977,
0.0025982815,
0.0008748969,
-0.0089281471,
-0.020465482,
-0.0748275295,
0.0495980047,
0.0297758114,
0.034295667,
0.0116700316,
-0.0255964305,
0.0349955074,
0.0651272014,
0.0184203237,
-0.0133251632,
0.020543728,
-0.0457017869,
0.0210842807,
0.0026095451,
0.0138260797,
-0.0338303745,
0.0297692604,
0.0076554269,
-0.0205925312,
0.0060962192,
-0.047825776,
-0.0131377587,
0.0333728828,
-0.0934086069,
-0.0268804003,
0.0051168171,
-0.0185133368,
0.0691069886,
-0.0380706564,
0.0117568029,
-0.0310026705,
0.0152805895,
-0.0089522786,
0.0233825315,
0.0101181017,
-0.030287724,
-0.0108902194,
0.021484334,
-0.0238087419,
-0.0428339988,
-0.0457683206,
0.02937801,
0.025881717,
0.0252490193,
-0.0415859818,
0.0068831732,
-0.0190551206,
-0.0081613632,
0.0276951101,
0.0207400247,
0.0261488091,
0.015364591,
0.0061596492,
-0.043828547,
-0.0427244902,
0.0342453346,
0.001585343,
-0.0296935979,
0.035055723,
0.0002289718,
0.0058044307,
-0.0471462831,
-0.0794009715,
-0.0411451831,
-0.0325632542,
-0.0195484571,
-0.0251695514,
-0.0777913183,
0.0078983745,
-0.0135808056,
0.0244283937,
-0.0061733359,
0.0056167571,
0.0742193758,
-0.0470507555,
0.0473340526,
0.0448617823,
0.0002466626,
-0.0075444472,
0.0393964648,
0.0406323224,
0.1067256257,
-0.027178172,
0.1539037675,
0.0669556111,
0.0176571701,
0.0393321626,
0.0633797571,
0.0152901467,
0.0310224537,
0.0071437191,
-0.0381335951,
-0.0275492277,
0.0037849497,
0.0185864754,
0.0271525644,
-0.0024988297,
-0.0236253235,
0.1081731543,
0.0261021759,
-0.0375189818,
0.0186695363,
0.0740354657,
0.021582311,
-0.0339473747,
-0.0156939328,
-0.0420500375,
-0.0103179961,
-0.0276748687,
-0.0084536653,
0.0387852453,
0.0266245473,
-0.0126521373,
0.0151843335,
-0.003003201,
-0.0052992781,
-0.0182758365,
-0.0156033495,
0.0485503674,
0.0028086407,
-0.0506995767,
0.0453694724,
0.0268117674,
0.0372379795,
0.0317546837,
-0.0230256002,
0.009920096,
0.0187240634,
0.0526504256,
0.0267719217,
0.0280912481,
-0.036781352,
0.0218171813,
0.0569478236,
0.0295212287,
0.0026969765,
-0.0373623855,
-0.0055433311,
-0.0304303765,
-0.0219121128,
0.0269560684,
0.0140196476,
0.0361215696,
0.0351204239,
0.0478305966,
-0.0155705092,
-0.0389536582,
0.0117197083,
-0.0005448833,
-0.0123344464,
-0.006078742,
0.0098476373,
0.033960931,
0.0236966014,
-0.0117436079,
-0.0064750467,
0.0271475967,
-0.0136288228,
-0.0419757329,
-0.0136329858,
0.0446607769,
-0.0517260581,
0.0224829447,
-0.0641672984,
-0.006357905,
0.0629831851,
-0.0269935485,
0.0100079346,
0.0154306116,
-0.0327393226,
0.014706593,
-0.0380015187,
0.0103779789,
-0.027731007,
0.0474689789,
0.0106134433,
0.0533980951,
-0.0073514674,
0.0415039137,
0.0462534539,
0.0071348576,
0.0009549082,
-0.033873193,
-0.0599668361,
0.0022872891,
-0.0095612882,
0.0032527258,
0.0101620248,
-0.0052518137,
-0.0105900969,
-0.0126386052,
-0.0762029886,
-0.004033356,
-0.0192757007,
-0.0015438335,
0.0333800875,
-0.0039892211,
-0.0099715525,
0.0044836593,
-0.0582559519,
-0.0677840933,
0.0059009171,
0.0515142679,
-0.0206485912,
-0.0284537207,
0.0082309227,
0.0007701908,
0.0226730015,
0.0014727137,
0.0501594096,
0.0205425285,
-0.0236693602,
-0.0102073448,
0.0162477084,
0.0107380385,
-0.018634202,
-0.0373983197,
-0.0233893264,
-0.0495939478,
-0.003550201,
0.0004193911,
0.0403125137,
0.0184666645,
0.0299345367,
0.0138450805,
0.0189955812,
-0.0414756387,
-0.0363559909,
-0.0597186089,
-0.0220746361,
-0.0350770205,
-0.0453374125,
0.0493216962,
0.0086189406,
0.0043234183,
0.0503086522,
-0.0099942572,
0.0386051834,
-0.0062139523,
0.0337335989,
-0.0281792041,
-0.0118724275,
0.0032257303,
0.0061117401,
-0.0361936279,
-0.0239461288,
0.0553612858,
-0.0269139893,
0.0195131153,
0.0036482268,
-0.0225227568,
-0.038951721,
0.0204693507,
-0.003010585,
0.0457572453,
-0.0205391385,
-0.0535122864,
0.0094822627,
0.0411921851,
0.0146861542,
-0.0243650079,
0.0394237712,
0.0214990973,
0.0046413424,
-0.0019073286,
-0.0552830696,
-0.050424546,
-0.1111694202,
-0.0285654031,
-0.0143421367,
0.0135225877,
0.0036491323,
-0.0391915999,
0.0481837317,
0.0134946229,
-0.011795016,
-0.0300387144,
-0.0082033956,
0.0154957231,
0.0759828538,
0.0580064729,
-0.0465983711,
-0.0057807285,
-0.0190719813,
0.0024452049,
0.0488858372,
-0.0147454413,
0.0352679826,
-0.0069108796,
-0.0093230912,
0.0355559513,
-0.0292317737,
-0.0158271771,
-0.047440365,
-0.0413844772,
-0.0537362881,
-0.0136323841,
0.0784520507,
0.0088526439,
-0.0387250409,
-0.0070705661,
0.0172781292,
-0.0080456231,
-0.0040320065,
-0.0045606955,
-0.0590117425,
-0.0260457508,
-0.0165709537,
-0.0146562541,
-0.01099448,
0.0075455937,
-0.0212034062,
-0.1418984681,
0.0089524854,
0.0179365892,
-0.0368618146,
-0.046298407,
-0.0693397895,
-0.0040912773,
-0.0116284285,
-0.0092323469,
0.0047632232,
-0.0116652334,
-0.0229721256,
-0.0352971256,
0.0136556886,
-0.0871688202,
0.0198903009,
-0.0400917754,
0.0238553118,
0.042747505,
0.0505348332,
-0.0493358113,
-0.0004852353,
0.0133456299,
-0.0328525603,
-0.0468254052,
-0.0196186751,
0.0554954261,
-0.0376482494,
-0.0011197466,
0.0012531753,
0.0328610353,
0.0137305949,
0.0212515872,
-0.0065893009,
0.0336044766,
0.0279711112,
-0.0767807662,
-0.0384721719,
0.0090249162,
-0.0172463916,
0.0838803202,
0.0242314581,
-0.0478563383,
-0.0140311578,
-0.0168585721,
-0.0499919578,
-0.0551263541,
-0.0481081828,
-0.0049519353,
-0.0490979664,
-0.0351624303,
-0.0552504957,
-0.0168043599,
0.0009201599,
-0.0093384041,
0.0227297824,
0.0259341542,
-0.0385448299,
-0.0166536551,
-0.0316851549,
-0.0095005212,
-0.0405434221,
0.0150677487,
-0.0283743851,
0.0536235906,
0.0880426019,
-0.0458560735,
-0.0155207412,
0.0029990701,
-0.1091046631,
-0.0423455387,
-0.061183352,
0.0129209859,
0.0129011422,
0.0413364433,
-0.0291122571,
-0.052041728,
0.0772244632,
0.0583862998,
0.0194260404,
-0.0011524613,
-0.0110633709,
0.0257917717,
0.0291609168,
0.0330754891,
-0.041892238,
0.0254890807,
0.0425079614,
-0.0170496218,
-0.0393490344,
0.0330378823,
0.0214637499,
0.0352087505,
0.0426285639,
-0.0227872655,
0.0172430947,
-0.0166553985,
-0.0207267571,
-0.0059923055,
-0.024778448,
-0.0325602032,
0.0172734819,
0.0451129824,
0.0188230481,
-0.0361021273,
0.0109322667,
-0.0168742593,
-0.000294754,
-0.0743409023,
-0.0418005548,
-0.001258546,
-0.0075381603,
0.042282857,
0.0127078192,
-0.0264588296,
0.0206539482,
0.0196106955,
0.0182617567,
-0.0164344292,
0.0153873535,
0.0430811942,
-0.0424238145,
0.0311285313,
0.016486736,
-0.0139494743,
0.0185558163,
-0.0604183674,
-0.0015464168,
0.073907949,
-0.0487939417,
0.0089179222,
-0.0545596257,
-0.0239004828,
0.0096375924,
-0.0048057865,
-0.0241678488,
-0.0614557862,
0.007263429,
0.0162776373,
-0.0058090463,
0.017416209,
0.0590319633,
-0.0120478682,
0.0015310921,
0.0693616122,
-0.0729327053,
-0.0114284661,
0.0079843784,
0.0534917861,
0.0423184335,
-0.0160787646,
0.0089279907,
-0.0381184407,
-0.0406671502,
0.0019214542,
0.0005798457,
0.0257389098,
0.0277614873,
-0.0069173202,
0.09091831,
0.0195255354,
0.0324064381,
-0.046169918,
-0.0075013535,
-0.0243014991,
-0.0526365601,
-0.0046236776,
-5.675897248e-33,
0.0258722827,
-0.0470877476,
-0.0329397582,
0.0350644253,
-0.0331777036,
0.0166336466,
-0.0346942879,
-0.0117893303,
-0.0130132223,
0.0005839763,
0.014224546,
0.0264876727,
-0.0065384805,
0.0328916758,
-0.0323025323,
-0.0190939642,
0.0532560907,
0.0080779269,
-0.0399530903,
0.0140137514,
0.0131846592,
0.0120012322,
0.0054966821,
0.0118689258,
0.0186880715,
-0.0396386869,
-0.0618406497,
0.0295911562,
0.0221582558,
0.0632634535,
-0.0003891115,
0.056801036,
0.0426078551,
-0.0192093458,
0.0216338616,
0.0311535336,
-0.013279709,
-0.0028473246,
0.0433558896,
0.0074162232,
0.0333355814,
0.0012471845,
0.0748626292,
-0.0328767411,
0.024621997,
0.008928082,
0.021535283,
-0.0481338277,
-0.0060546873,
-0.0348405465,
-0.027413873,
0.0224732701,
-0.003657646,
0.0030114143,
0.0358417556,
0.0391278453,
0.0082245544,
0.0910622776,
-0.0593419187,
0.0384735353,
0.0379749835,
0.0330830999,
0.0527811907,
0.0038527921,
0.0090273423,
0.0619697534,
0.004409242,
0.0295120161,
-0.0336611308,
0.0573762096,
0.0243985523,
0.0270346273,
0.0569904707,
0.0700202882,
0.0361011177,
-0.0130324513,
-0.058681339,
0.0260690115,
0.0524037182,
-0.0224842802,
0.0518939495,
-0.011450965,
-0.0383836366,
-0.0077145621,
-0.0311495326,
-0.0115727177,
-0.0637567416,
-0.0506439768,
0.0343186036,
0.0403410532,
-0.0471581034,
0.0216011908,
0.013979747,
-0.0511574745,
-0.0313032493,
0.0292022638,
-0.0077772718,
-0.004164374,
-0.0001577415,
0.0118288612,
-0.0208094604,
-0.0147644272,
-0.0190014821,
-0.0226385072,
-0.0164394528,
-0.0262092035,
0.0324602462,
0.0153578864,
-0.0622130483,
0.0157324057,
-0.0257636085,
-0.0138416179,
-0.0113390628,
0.0255682282,
0.0185504127,
-0.0413569398,
-0.0250452198,
-0.0096011637,
0.0522550605,
0.0031483807,
0.012405985,
0.0038329042,
-0.0219171327,
0.0330514722,
-0.0183466859,
-0.0167649519,
0.0150223393,
-0.0054821461,
0.0139759211,
-0.102548331,
-0.0180432107,
-0.0326326638,
2.346e-7,
-0.0254135579,
0.0493293181,
-0.0353272967,
0.0364939608,
0.0113933664,
0.0393624194,
-0.009431689,
0.0337902494,
0.0087353168,
0.004168855,
-0.0087379329,
-0.0066242134,
0.0066733314,
-0.021642739,
-0.1143366247,
0.0810491815,
-0.0625414401,
-0.0168326572,
-0.0454188362,
-0.0389604904,
-0.0090303468,
0.0851191506,
0.0301127192,
-0.0345299207,
0.0237846039,
-0.0590942204,
0.0545428023,
0.0060511832,
-0.050958693,
0.0451229513,
0.0269731972,
0.0374583751,
-0.015035606,
-0.0061068623,
-0.0305237677,
0.0154133774,
0.0626017228,
0.0531020574,
0.0344186313,
-0.0002453075,
-0.0202313121,
-0.0507635623,
0.0048838286,
-0.0896054506,
0.0719938949,
-0.030479515,
-0.020357186,
-0.0487089306,
-0.031415306,
-0.0584174469,
0.0427497886,
-0.0814260095,
-0.0226261355,
-0.0226235148,
0.0064927596,
0.0261758324,
-0.0059349849,
-0.0707779378,
0.0239097532,
-0.0028937634,
-0.0460303761,
-0.0249922648,
-0.0250090156,
-0.0101222564,
0.0031171534,
-0.0369841605,
0.0254204907,
1.985733219e-34,
0.0487917848,
-0.04800855,
-0.0116144018,
-0.0034528908,
-0.0199535489,
0.0519389361,
0.0046074567,
-0.0011720922,
0.0038480156,
-0.0306441057,
0.0110418517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09594v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09594v1 | CMLM-CSE: Based on Conditional MLM Contrastive Learning for Sentence Embeddings | 2023-06-16T02:39:45 | 2023-06-16T02:39:45 | Wei Zhang, Xu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Traditional comparative learning sentence embedding directly uses the encoder
to extract sentence features, and then passes in the comparative loss function
for learning. However, this method pays too much attention to the sentence body
and ignores the influence of some words in the sentence on the sentence
semantics. To this end, we propose CMLM-CSE, an unsupervised contrastive
learning framework based on conditional MLM. On the basis of traditional
contrastive learning, an additional auxiliary network is added to integrate
sentence embedding to perform MLM tasks, forcing sentence embedding to learn
more masked word information. Finally, when Bertbase was used as the
pretraining language model, we exceeded SimCSE by 0.55 percentage points on
average in textual similarity tasks, and when Robertabase was used as the
pretraining language model, we exceeded SimCSE by 0.3 percentage points on
average in textual similarity tasks. | [
-0.0045201913,
0.0518170223,
0.0029102236,
0.0598416254,
-0.0754823759,
0.0350712873,
0.0133193582,
-0.0225665905,
0.0057610502,
-0.0362399109,
-0.0084029408,
0.0010368694,
-0.064295128,
-0.0250170212,
0.0351577513,
-0.0599009804,
0.0044277124,
0.0376824439,
-0.0079496801,
-0.0131443217,
0.0466616154,
0.0037705617,
0.0252348855,
-0.0002018057,
0.0094108833,
-0.0148606198,
0.014162411,
0.0039349468,
0.0649084449,
-0.0157778803,
0.0560478345,
0.0204126388,
0.0576397777,
-0.0187059175,
0.0000018636,
-0.0358977169,
-0.0035044048,
-0.0377834812,
0.0157514159,
-0.0162510984,
0.0632368028,
-0.0183251128,
0.0242597256,
0.0413007624,
-0.0290865283,
0.0043794471,
0.0148292026,
0.0646611229,
0.0304930881,
0.0820704028,
-0.0300080609,
-0.0618824624,
0.0114913676,
-0.0115431938,
-0.0333909169,
0.0173031241,
0.0086901719,
0.021562105,
-0.0192907993,
0.0170192551,
0.0001395975,
0.0509954616,
0.0541211367,
0.0156835262,
-0.0005845727,
0.0479380414,
0.01674187,
0.0330655277,
-0.0169287063,
0.0598228276,
-0.0213299096,
-0.0416703187,
-0.0092477212,
-0.0239195917,
-0.0096827364,
-0.0329291411,
-0.006813583,
0.0295007359,
0.0114629967,
0.057151217,
0.0581335872,
0.0501672402,
0.0087560825,
0.0043087099,
-0.0209212713,
-0.0149350679,
0.0558662079,
-0.0492185056,
-0.0058720279,
-0.0142930066,
-0.0182351433,
0.0309054609,
0.0325006209,
-0.0112219499,
-0.0314137116,
-0.0108380793,
-0.077405706,
-0.0640692189,
-0.0020946634,
-0.0607579648,
0.0670367032,
0.0186065305,
-0.0156244766,
0.0336208381,
-0.0317753591,
0.0315819196,
-0.0030478949,
0.0013827403,
-0.0575708896,
-0.032094039,
-0.0245904066,
-0.0076753548,
-0.0316575058,
0.0361110084,
-0.0571393967,
-0.0375338271,
-0.021119602,
0.0282197408,
0.006601986,
0.03432668,
0.0300579108,
0.0082358075,
-0.0183671396,
-0.0128344679,
0.0137410928,
-0.022930108,
-0.0431349315,
0.0146593945,
0.0029370524,
-0.0219970606,
-0.0030311414,
0.035547249,
0.0326589867,
-0.0513049886,
0.0224568658,
0.0476197377,
-0.0008102885,
-0.051038757,
-0.0400747657,
0.033832144,
0.0023275418,
-0.0286404565,
-0.0046981731,
-0.0731158853,
0.0263482351,
-0.0198950227,
0.0025510541,
0.0086137429,
-0.0117676957,
0.0205862541,
0.0040395572,
0.0886337757,
0.0085298084,
-0.0664069131,
-0.0149472654,
0.0027183867,
0.0291545615,
0.0410793573,
0.0110406401,
-0.0229999553,
0.0301592071,
0.02848012,
0.0027693561,
0.0055311471,
-0.0186826251,
-0.0162236597,
-0.0648901761,
0.0272768214,
0.0034435096,
0.0367334411,
0.0371620208,
0.0607400872,
-0.0290929303,
-0.0502545498,
0.0432871915,
0.0080153272,
0.0373280384,
0.0309995376,
0.0547159947,
0.0516242646,
-0.0226147324,
0.0622770824,
-0.0063959938,
0.0137945469,
-0.0186420213,
0.0223833583,
0.0139017059,
0.0263522398,
-0.0530157238,
0.0031932364,
0.0067679673,
-0.0539245009,
0.0021572965,
-0.0194846112,
0.0223951172,
0.0078787087,
-0.0612778068,
0.0198157746,
0.0419810489,
-0.0438270681,
-0.0445578061,
-0.0103286365,
-0.0140678417,
0.0578615069,
0.0325431414,
-0.0298634786,
-0.0305228885,
-0.005629695,
-0.0377540775,
0.0766946301,
0.0203800667,
0.0066238516,
0.0309829488,
-0.0545469448,
-0.0022388978,
-0.0568732843,
0.0134402756,
0.0062980079,
0.0011942586,
0.0201518852,
0.0226071402,
0.0010650832,
-0.0087197814,
0.0372539721,
-0.0150086917,
-0.0231875535,
0.0202892125,
0.0108795734,
-0.0028079336,
0.0028778983,
-0.0298824962,
0.0147499852,
0.0339327976,
-0.0787175074,
-0.044237528,
0.0154938549,
-0.0939405039,
-0.1581073403,
0.0194264688,
-0.0851173401,
-0.0089931889,
0.1149708778,
-0.035428375,
-0.0214518383,
-0.0126643721,
-0.0158854704,
0.072795108,
-0.0630043745,
0.011296466,
0.0125050582,
-0.0183970463,
-0.0145147331,
0.0720270276,
-0.0365827754,
0.0282390937,
-0.0066835219,
0.026508756,
-0.0059219296,
-0.021907961,
-0.0280585606,
-0.0529664047,
0.0486211739,
0.0153103136,
0.0107824672,
0.0189616792,
-0.0473264158,
-0.0200378299,
-0.0796862915,
-0.0092425141,
-0.0061274199,
0.0046559568,
0.0584327318,
0.0260409545,
-0.0149319591,
0.0024724694,
-0.0345342904,
-0.0289574843,
-0.0238253195,
0.0094738975,
0.0784383118,
-0.0236283001,
0.0041423198,
-0.0490396135,
-0.0033296174,
0.0065520625,
0.0739097968,
-0.0410141274,
-0.0077924812,
-0.0229314752,
0.0596650615,
0.0053826161,
0.01991098,
-0.0261030644,
-0.0353540108,
-0.0186031777,
-0.0290607307,
0.049307093,
0.0450981371,
0.0292515177,
-0.002161439,
0.0379492193,
0.012959525,
-0.0200583376,
0.0137003716,
-0.0262581911,
0.0439057127,
-0.0347744599,
-0.028189607,
-0.0095744021,
0.0586624257,
0.0099469936,
0.0023586098,
-0.0151541261,
0.0039989557,
0.0434814356,
0.005580307,
-0.0067098201,
0.011199032,
-0.0311597493,
-0.0224261601,
-0.024718849,
-0.003334312,
0.061819993,
-0.0239335075,
-0.0057124156,
-0.0655108318,
-0.0420657508,
-0.0372277349,
0.0038575388,
0.0200270377,
0.0294689704,
0.0035786356,
0.003661342,
-0.0309685618,
-0.0279990528,
0.0088860905,
0.0090930667,
-0.0090191551,
0.0158244595,
-0.0253696386,
-0.0011008014,
-0.0553636178,
-0.041445531,
-0.0490292385,
-0.0353049673,
0.0415836386,
0.0506054796,
-0.0134570627,
-0.0153134922,
-0.0373363048,
-0.0209030677,
0.0538704321,
0.0088582402,
0.002017135,
-0.0262638777,
0.1069742888,
0.0608428866,
0.0112457713,
0.0083763665,
-0.0326829478,
0.0607444718,
0.0256845914,
0.0460852385,
-0.0027458626,
-0.0677003413,
0.0026151638,
-0.0075727571,
-0.0379420668,
0.0039136526,
0.0015565336,
0.011543531,
-0.0253356434,
-0.0193210468,
0.1415251642,
0.0157064479,
-0.0263163708,
-0.027922228,
0.0103629148,
0.0207956061,
0.0217683073,
0.0201667044,
-0.0705189481,
-0.0497929715,
-0.0159288682,
-0.0040332079,
-0.0030891183,
-0.0027175285,
-0.0220513046,
-0.0767801702,
-0.0091634318,
-0.0109500596,
-0.0231540687,
-0.0315103345,
-0.0085913725,
-0.021366369,
0.0018593468,
-0.0020721722,
0.0098903785,
-0.0266203396,
-0.0218689498,
-0.0198982544,
-0.034295354,
-0.0407938324,
-0.0104309553,
-0.0840754583,
0.016206868,
0.0103431102,
0.0307375509,
-0.007786979,
-0.0197002888,
0.0366447344,
-0.0647588894,
-0.0282599013,
-0.012858958,
0.0351115316,
-0.0488755479,
0.0012591828,
-0.03917557,
0.0127507187,
0.0002859582,
-0.0047233454,
0.0099946996,
0.0478863679,
0.0031056297,
-0.0212335009,
-0.0264317617,
0.0245414078,
-0.0242207237,
0.0752740651,
0.0585454181,
-0.0526220798,
-0.0247020423,
0.0052619292,
-0.0106796548,
-0.0420575738,
0.0251290742,
-0.0142066507,
0.0263748299,
0.0378413945,
-0.0603152327,
-0.0693706647,
-0.0233918969,
0.0132509721,
-0.0243771654,
0.0008401309,
-0.0355503224,
-0.0402218066,
-0.0708137602,
0.012522094,
-0.0226343926,
-0.006973831,
-0.0021114219,
-0.0055989539,
0.0610682182,
-0.0292904563,
-0.0394279361,
-0.075777553,
-0.0673954338,
-0.0426530391,
-0.051903639,
0.0401058085,
-0.0055233459,
0.0642564446,
-0.0029229051,
0.0076115844,
0.0635894611,
0.0586335361,
-0.0285468157,
0.0053170742,
0.0770436525,
0.0102227107,
0.0250060223,
0.033075057,
-0.0050169718,
0.0085741561,
0.0235714912,
0.0628465787,
-0.0051842844,
-0.0185870435,
0.0191175491,
-0.045105733,
0.0555636175,
-0.0018603328,
0.0051343958,
-0.0586777888,
0.0228182692,
-0.0216696616,
-0.0316629298,
-0.0498523973,
0.0102716535,
-0.0078242058,
0.0576445758,
-0.031199608,
0.0234309211,
-0.0498598143,
0.0108960494,
-0.0338739641,
0.0564123429,
0.0503174663,
0.0316964798,
-0.0194246955,
-0.0082739135,
-0.0409156717,
-0.0140808988,
-0.0066374326,
0.0062806364,
-0.0205319636,
0.0277442429,
0.016987741,
-0.0190616008,
-0.033567179,
0.0555484183,
-0.058381483,
0.0299779605,
-0.0482303016,
0.0043444149,
0.0779491439,
-0.0492948219,
0.0234438553,
-0.0212168228,
-0.0061600348,
-0.0046859221,
0.0430130027,
-0.0108785816,
-0.0173318516,
0.049296692,
-0.004901832,
-0.0192422401,
0.0252428409,
0.0450483635,
-0.0093550673,
0.0366286412,
0.0179238543,
-0.0161689613,
-0.0508267768,
-0.0126729617,
0.0674661994,
0.0424562469,
0.0131654013,
0.0138100823,
0.0116118705,
-0.0555504486,
0.0649125725,
0.0239228886,
-0.0077211228,
0.0301004108,
0.0503861383,
0.0097682551,
-0.0008346297,
-0.0259893499,
-0.0135919368,
0.0454730839,
0.0552874282,
-0.0565638617,
-0.0479730107,
-6.437221593e-33,
-0.0086294543,
0.0155461021,
-0.0031623445,
-0.0055376156,
0.0052281991,
0.0225867983,
-0.0349710733,
-0.0340056196,
-0.0087897517,
0.0256579332,
0.0158315431,
0.0075838091,
-0.0078609353,
0.0589003451,
-0.02902494,
-0.0155226737,
0.0330308788,
0.0047585731,
0.0162536483,
-0.0172499586,
-0.0199147668,
0.0836226493,
0.0572177805,
-0.0420294739,
-0.016857069,
-0.0298779756,
0.0199693944,
0.0447080918,
0.0244205706,
0.059129294,
-0.027873436,
0.0392305478,
0.0182354767,
-0.0047178264,
-0.0074679484,
0.0230312087,
-0.079735592,
-0.0207219757,
-0.0002851271,
-0.0393227898,
-0.0218400415,
-0.0203676727,
0.0000633447,
-0.0203327443,
0.0077608349,
0.0044080382,
0.0568594895,
-0.0115326894,
0.0251766331,
-0.0234310981,
-0.0427585617,
0.0220735967,
0.012914625,
0.0290454999,
0.010686093,
0.0610794723,
0.0058650039,
0.0616431758,
-0.0212858301,
0.0061264848,
0.0139384801,
0.0006614119,
-0.0031362211,
0.0140147675,
0.0013362502,
0.0682290196,
0.0090873437,
-0.0816861615,
0.0161568299,
0.005819256,
0.0130054867,
0.0231510345,
0.0644388124,
0.0550565831,
0.0067509785,
0.0191808026,
-0.0711428672,
0.017980095,
-0.0139707671,
-0.0150275156,
0.0372370034,
0.0299160704,
-0.0341831595,
-0.0342415273,
-0.0043145558,
-0.027723005,
-0.0333255529,
0.0142587181,
0.0329378322,
0.0074835569,
-0.0131873619,
-0.0107278852,
-0.0028262469,
-0.0437129326,
-0.0017499352,
0.0040425025,
-0.0095213214,
-0.0113286562,
0.0096960999,
0.039004907,
-0.0641920194,
-0.0145740276,
0.0136288116,
-0.0016467597,
-0.0197383724,
-0.0025694435,
0.0849557742,
0.0026249536,
-0.0628386214,
0.0020012727,
-0.0184282474,
-0.0679003969,
-0.0300698448,
0.0134836016,
0.0097749466,
0.0227574296,
-0.0203372966,
0.0587537438,
0.0374724939,
-0.0188640188,
-0.0453353636,
-0.0281975903,
0.0096655237,
0.0544021614,
0.0059522833,
0.0121057779,
-0.0409893282,
0.0722084269,
-0.0025799472,
-0.0606330447,
-0.0069561256,
-0.0092528742,
2.557e-7,
0.0348803625,
-0.0098223584,
0.0167588033,
0.0039063762,
0.0188201908,
0.0459602475,
-0.0175832678,
0.0658650622,
-0.0225209389,
0.046626661,
0.0387182608,
0.0169717018,
0.0603327192,
0.0033040871,
-0.0902617723,
0.0385633223,
-0.0701479688,
-0.0703214258,
-0.0237311814,
0.0033744525,
0.0878220871,
0.0748349428,
0.0519489236,
-0.0113816187,
0.0175129287,
-0.0360647812,
0.0455609933,
-0.0581511669,
-0.0177296735,
-0.0451352559,
-0.0323841348,
0.0552845672,
-0.0047029234,
0.0133175915,
-0.0101881437,
0.0673739985,
0.0005517568,
0.0366976224,
0.0248401035,
-0.0577852093,
0.0443438478,
0.0199520383,
-0.0208353363,
-0.0163207445,
0.0705204606,
-0.0532367527,
0.0074029472,
-0.0299415831,
-0.0370465219,
0.006374978,
0.0330370739,
-0.0179365668,
-0.0694224015,
-0.0181955192,
0.0314027444,
-0.00580286,
-0.0228781365,
-0.0773127005,
-0.0087258266,
0.0281411335,
-0.0632275045,
-0.0147730969,
-0.0312558375,
0.0202527028,
0.0468249135,
-0.0356418639,
0.0352179073,
2.473463963e-34,
0.0364560597,
0.0107427565,
-0.0156915057,
0.0229668766,
0.0058039464,
0.004138344,
-0.0118856626,
-0.0511541702,
0.0540764555,
-0.0568919182,
-0.0128991436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14907v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14907v1 | Clickbait Classification and Spoiling Using Natural Language Processing | 2023-06-16T01:45:57 | 2023-06-16T01:45:57 | Adhitya Thirumala, Elisa Ferracane | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Clickbait is the practice of engineering titles to incentivize readers to
click through to articles. Such titles with sensationalized language reveal as
little information as possible. Occasionally, clickbait will be intentionally
misleading, so natural language processing (NLP) can scan the article and
answer the question posed by the clickbait title, or spoil it. We tackle two
tasks: classifying the clickbait into one of 3 types (Task 1), and spoiling the
clickbait (Task 2). For Task 1, we propose two binary classifiers to determine
the final spoiler type. For Task 2, we experiment with two approaches: using a
question-answering model to identify the span of text of the spoiler, and using
a large language model (LLM) to generate the spoiler. Because the spoiler is
contained in the article, we frame the second task as a question-answering
approach for identifying the starting and ending positions of the spoiler. We
created models for Task 1 that were better than the baselines proposed by the
dataset authors and engineered prompts for Task 2 that did not perform as well
as the baselines proposed by the dataset authors due to the evaluation metric
performing worse when the output text is from a generative model as opposed to
an extractive model. | [
0.0934685469,
0.0202444308,
-0.0349059813,
0.0418545194,
-0.0603552051,
0.0151456408,
-0.0053297598,
0.0305952765,
0.0395296402,
-0.0238777827,
0.0083495658,
-0.0103718117,
-0.0116423005,
0.0696936846,
0.0201474167,
-0.0621241182,
0.0249307062,
-0.0229973663,
0.0329686441,
0.0195835605,
0.0278158467,
0.0350963324,
0.0549022555,
0.017282607,
0.0135419965,
-0.0082645966,
0.0116665047,
0.0059812274,
0.0005221695,
-0.0181870684,
0.0410979539,
0.0615526959,
0.0338164829,
0.0427177474,
0.000001369,
-0.0415944457,
0.0122250328,
0.0044744518,
-0.0121481074,
0.0199400429,
0.0628075898,
-0.0499901026,
0.0159087721,
0.0128309866,
-0.0360963382,
0.0188462101,
0.0179974437,
0.0723012909,
0.0582481474,
0.0669996217,
-0.0190038849,
0.003590517,
0.0334161408,
-0.0140175018,
0.0681855381,
-0.0279650521,
0.0329907462,
-0.0266312659,
0.0142253283,
0.0788412988,
0.0035451311,
0.0249850173,
0.0124617871,
-0.0258778166,
-0.0269204229,
0.037115749,
0.0032728887,
-0.0116221989,
-0.0253019668,
0.0118904999,
-0.0649476424,
-0.0451380797,
0.0116330702,
0.01864269,
0.0184547864,
0.0026796395,
-0.0699305683,
0.0364094153,
0.0178811569,
0.0014947488,
0.0299644154,
-0.0194849428,
-0.0012089133,
0.0380150713,
0.049732767,
0.0124714617,
0.0177065656,
-0.0399009921,
-0.0003226322,
-0.0018307762,
0.0237859674,
-0.071211569,
0.0196628552,
0.0300769415,
-0.0043055853,
0.0062867091,
-0.0693301484,
-0.0319839008,
0.0187280159,
-0.081687361,
-0.0511007197,
-0.0238299482,
-0.0039244113,
0.0527109504,
-0.0452366248,
-0.0091470983,
0.0058669844,
0.031438835,
-0.0184389856,
0.0350352153,
0.0452963561,
-0.0493771024,
-0.0338383466,
0.0481351651,
-0.0436915532,
-0.0334256999,
-0.0299066417,
0.0291150101,
0.0183264446,
0.0373327322,
-0.0337262116,
0.0349492244,
-0.0143692521,
0.0044017355,
-0.0064465697,
-0.0174562056,
-0.0153403534,
0.0146364029,
0.0260214694,
-0.0222889986,
-0.035691753,
0.0196152292,
0.0106835458,
-0.0097248731,
0.0432556495,
0.0264206082,
-0.017624585,
-0.0366587117,
-0.0768543929,
-0.0414948091,
-0.0516349003,
-0.0348554365,
-0.0377085358,
-0.0600832328,
0.0197791848,
0.0163369477,
-0.0197785031,
-0.0114408163,
0.0114400508,
0.0654551536,
-0.0425104201,
0.0450280495,
0.0128650097,
-0.0176525023,
0.0171149708,
0.0413187519,
0.0205467585,
0.0589096807,
-0.0097290687,
0.1315744221,
0.0733209774,
0.0102354102,
0.0296383537,
0.0341497585,
0.0132215973,
-0.0115301749,
0.024316445,
0.0183901433,
-0.0121436995,
-0.011670744,
-0.0181789119,
0.024340339,
0.0091016479,
-0.0128866863,
0.0716354474,
0.0418623537,
-0.0655564666,
0.0078758821,
0.0464683399,
0.0192861501,
-0.0166201945,
0.0294380728,
-0.0394221917,
0.0006898943,
-0.039923843,
-0.0090575498,
0.0091237053,
0.021238938,
-0.00364676,
-0.0444587022,
-0.0025519649,
-0.0058974647,
-0.0006850859,
-0.0070260596,
0.0363782197,
0.0570280254,
-0.0856234655,
0.00584612,
0.0264711976,
0.0318373628,
0.0511982217,
-0.035694059,
0.0350603163,
0.0163624138,
0.0441160388,
-0.0011371596,
-0.0062329578,
-0.0391425453,
0.0070111663,
0.0301856808,
0.0009748995,
-0.0118322121,
-0.0563870892,
0.0117934495,
-0.0285267364,
-0.0568447933,
0.0245101973,
0.0168510824,
-0.0032597729,
-0.001493772,
0.0372751802,
-0.0114963306,
-0.0460935161,
0.0273910277,
0.0332336724,
-0.0338994078,
-0.0089751538,
0.0088218208,
0.0362345092,
0.0031960285,
0.007901758,
-0.0112807099,
0.0287760217,
-0.0054306942,
-0.0384508148,
-0.0151846241,
0.0423950627,
-0.0505286865,
-0.0159186088,
-0.0662185028,
-0.0155333467,
0.070786953,
-0.0077597634,
-0.0083699757,
0.0140443295,
-0.0369405486,
0.0067450479,
-0.0526503064,
-0.0034106858,
-0.0141563602,
0.0029434725,
-0.0195274986,
0.0710670948,
0.0032067911,
0.0573937036,
0.0111370645,
-0.0391316712,
-0.0105617074,
-0.0278284252,
-0.0331620984,
-0.0042797402,
-0.0311246663,
-0.0136030149,
0.0329588093,
-0.0259865243,
-0.0040766909,
-0.0397701971,
-0.0635082945,
-0.0059111137,
-0.02639121,
0.0156682599,
0.0419453867,
0.0079010623,
-0.0248562358,
-0.0091065066,
-0.0661853626,
-0.0743846819,
0.0312860459,
0.0242134444,
-0.0025566653,
0.0026177007,
0.0177825112,
0.0020029449,
0.0105375871,
-0.0239870865,
0.0628741086,
0.0646159649,
0.0080602886,
-0.0378710777,
-0.0090090251,
0.0110782301,
-0.0156114195,
-0.0302840117,
0.0010591303,
-0.0367206447,
0.0149094826,
0.0112554552,
0.042791795,
0.0537375398,
0.0579352565,
0.0229188632,
0.022238465,
-0.03483814,
-0.0233512167,
-0.0785579458,
-0.0196422953,
-0.052866552,
-0.0625492781,
0.0780906081,
0.015887294,
0.0308145955,
0.0265716016,
0.002240496,
0.0750770494,
-0.0203273762,
0.0144103477,
-0.0302462913,
-0.0301357824,
0.0002555031,
0.043782182,
-0.0238833576,
-0.0361434296,
0.063490741,
-0.0235131588,
0.0114506539,
-0.0099037085,
-0.0293866862,
-0.04406856,
0.0345026143,
-0.0099677118,
0.0487634167,
0.0111588454,
-0.0610374734,
-0.0080074947,
0.0216535348,
0.0252176709,
-0.0271173194,
-0.0094002532,
0.0082890214,
-0.0068319025,
0.0161137227,
-0.0531660728,
-0.0584810115,
-0.105028972,
-0.0072529158,
-0.0270022508,
0.0425539836,
0.0155899078,
-0.0330025293,
0.0337310806,
0.0099186515,
-0.0201194715,
-0.0620233975,
-0.0141536342,
0.0198000614,
0.103961736,
0.0851476938,
-0.0273912307,
-0.006578506,
-0.0108140679,
-0.0032797644,
0.0443248451,
-0.0233785231,
0.0295659956,
0.0161317624,
-0.0013673624,
0.0568259247,
-0.0661038682,
-0.0041449,
-0.0292369388,
-0.040382266,
-0.0521296933,
-0.0089244097,
0.0787014663,
0.0570089407,
-0.0173088666,
-0.0058619669,
0.0231175311,
-0.0109752594,
-0.0028045774,
0.013381727,
-0.0623265356,
0.0019432132,
-0.0223356299,
0.010553251,
-0.0292971972,
0.0040215948,
-0.0194704924,
-0.102992557,
0.0235467646,
-0.0037056603,
-0.0489634275,
-0.0189286936,
-0.06949839,
-0.0140668591,
-0.0026485559,
-0.0313165747,
-0.0005171027,
-0.0153009659,
-0.0004222519,
-0.0239128266,
0.0185489114,
-0.027509585,
0.0055614454,
-0.0017212937,
0.0090818936,
0.0543960892,
0.0373078696,
-0.0450311489,
0.0193286724,
0.0010122739,
-0.0443067141,
-0.0242350493,
-0.0343900099,
0.0869061202,
-0.0383739695,
0.0129778339,
-0.041514229,
0.0617561042,
0.0576121956,
0.003127702,
0.0110070314,
0.0332982205,
0.0309958849,
-0.0856264755,
-0.0522665158,
-0.000713697,
0.0026519662,
0.0882244632,
0.0214971174,
-0.0431555212,
-0.0352135487,
-0.0227115266,
-0.0030733906,
-0.0622988455,
-0.0325850621,
-0.040946655,
-0.0091967639,
0.003170426,
-0.0604888387,
-0.0384623967,
0.0092423931,
-0.0056551364,
0.0347215608,
0.0041323057,
-0.0210962705,
0.0034693857,
-0.0591009781,
-0.0197863784,
0.0006514561,
-0.0073530194,
-0.0197094176,
0.0074736425,
0.0524675697,
-0.0528031029,
-0.0487004519,
0.0020121778,
-0.0639501289,
-0.0232357252,
-0.0327074677,
0.0438942388,
0.0188283157,
0.0307238884,
-0.0207133815,
-0.0422703363,
0.0736074522,
0.0592627339,
-0.020156553,
-0.0155752562,
-0.0202843919,
0.0352017395,
0.0192154888,
0.0099213067,
-0.0407395363,
0.0209980309,
0.0255048499,
-0.0236045849,
-0.0565054491,
0.0392495729,
0.028891407,
0.0288310517,
0.0352488831,
-0.0232551731,
0.0116711566,
-0.0339523517,
-0.0241243988,
-0.0100092338,
-0.0294687375,
-0.0293202288,
0.0358885489,
0.0344873145,
0.0152691063,
-0.0311680138,
0.0234469101,
-0.0405118875,
0.0020208661,
-0.0893097147,
-0.0234273467,
0.0364424996,
-0.011631324,
0.01138392,
0.0383633897,
-0.0135589419,
0.0196923707,
0.0393930562,
0.0276601184,
0.0111321583,
0.0148710618,
0.0380125307,
-0.0350600891,
0.0373680703,
0.0342606343,
-0.0644579232,
0.0398923717,
-0.0507795997,
0.0479000807,
0.0054439181,
-0.0538310446,
-0.0245786905,
-0.0258521792,
-0.0261002462,
0.0148158232,
0.0044994191,
-0.01447058,
-0.0772777647,
0.0261763074,
0.0187299438,
-0.0284056962,
-0.0040533012,
0.0554897636,
-0.0017872966,
-0.0141895525,
0.0832706913,
-0.0737379193,
-0.0184278563,
-0.0013908092,
0.0477317758,
0.0485969819,
0.0155498814,
-0.0017946599,
-0.0524729416,
-0.041001562,
0.0005313818,
0.0099634863,
0.0505154394,
0.0303197689,
-0.0194656625,
0.074332796,
0.0284095332,
-0.0060192798,
-0.0417633094,
0.0230348706,
-0.0234606601,
-0.0605364181,
-0.0202208236,
-5.213086388e-33,
0.0175914038,
-0.0654103458,
-0.0388623029,
0.079601109,
-0.0221955888,
0.0372828878,
-0.0137177743,
-0.0097451257,
0.0003687442,
0.0023553923,
-0.0010327713,
0.0089605963,
-0.0032355615,
0.0335518532,
-0.0185214095,
-0.0318669155,
0.0405169614,
-0.0029242788,
-0.0549190976,
0.0324632637,
0.0249692556,
0.0323443897,
0.0006719372,
-0.002334313,
0.0646117032,
-0.0607240535,
-0.0535254218,
0.019389201,
0.0331384987,
0.04063778,
0.0100377956,
0.0568804517,
0.0396588258,
-0.0506145097,
0.02751901,
0.075773187,
-0.057980828,
-0.0371144973,
0.0698010549,
0.0015862543,
-0.001601783,
-0.012216676,
0.0599981435,
-0.0331366062,
0.0040901676,
-0.0084201815,
0.0677883923,
-0.0261315107,
0.0085322652,
-0.0566674396,
-0.044069346,
-0.0059644971,
-0.0264112409,
-0.0142698372,
0.0219729822,
0.0509577319,
0.0273644272,
0.051289916,
-0.0423459113,
0.0319519229,
0.033915747,
0.0378733873,
0.0375331156,
-0.0060031773,
-0.0097037507,
0.0453920923,
0.0222882554,
0.0121244816,
-0.0551511161,
0.0612867549,
0.0002577258,
0.0246794596,
0.0846110657,
0.0345903598,
0.0609138049,
-0.0331445523,
-0.0479292721,
0.0306720491,
0.0202806033,
-0.0263225529,
0.0301701613,
-0.0529565811,
-0.0337639563,
-0.0085580964,
-0.0307561662,
-0.010313333,
-0.0383859947,
-0.0444951802,
0.0241179951,
0.0153703634,
-0.0549939759,
0.0211907513,
-0.0237296857,
-0.0529747307,
0.002036324,
0.0127245225,
0.0160612073,
0.0042641554,
0.0090355398,
0.0227585137,
0.0016266423,
0.0493164137,
0.0074591078,
-0.0216290932,
-0.0114295306,
-0.0333274193,
0.0282225329,
0.0134488018,
-0.0626929924,
0.0270644426,
-0.0073308283,
0.013439157,
-0.0206039026,
-0.0200481433,
0.031477388,
-0.0028533146,
-0.0228621811,
-0.0448231474,
0.0353238918,
0.0353606604,
-0.0063398276,
0.0074290512,
-0.0373437405,
0.0288133863,
-0.010420192,
-0.0082689729,
0.0359963253,
-0.0029521738,
-0.0242310055,
-0.0841295198,
0.0056140306,
-0.0064635877,
2.188e-7,
-0.0022912037,
0.0459910333,
-0.0147805577,
0.043107409,
0.0010280379,
0.033784911,
0.0329204462,
0.035794057,
0.0507834628,
-0.0142682698,
-0.0052174861,
-0.0025815377,
0.0051761889,
0.0092148921,
-0.1110986248,
0.0401131809,
-0.0528538264,
-0.0153288841,
-0.0477097109,
-0.0260742549,
0.0475742891,
0.0331310593,
0.023774324,
-0.0285156146,
-0.0094297612,
-0.0499552637,
0.0364161246,
-0.0048599136,
-0.0380489416,
0.0523078851,
0.0642722175,
0.0196304005,
-0.0040058279,
0.0004882474,
-0.0310364887,
0.0010928983,
0.0472554564,
0.02593874,
0.0340474136,
-0.007646149,
-0.0200385358,
-0.0325743593,
0.0029310612,
-0.0915624797,
0.0768038556,
-0.0282049607,
-0.0245020855,
-0.0457334816,
-0.0496549085,
-0.0481422991,
0.0340204686,
-0.0518816262,
-0.0205671601,
0.0056084399,
0.0024836143,
0.0134276217,
0.0190564655,
-0.0570274554,
0.0079848869,
0.0465845466,
-0.0276078191,
-0.0135764619,
-0.0284301862,
0.015517625,
0.0025269161,
-0.0721774697,
0.0147777488,
1.87015974e-34,
0.0358384363,
-0.0334189013,
-0.0288787466,
-0.0004351799,
-0.0259406008,
0.0497077703,
0.03101689,
-0.0011365163,
0.0121971387,
-0.0390473269,
0.0026328256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09572v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09572v1 | How do different tokenizers perform on downstream tasks in scriptio continua languages?: A case study in Japanese | 2023-06-16T01:22:32 | 2023-06-16T01:22:32 | Takuro Fujii, Koki Shibata, Atsuki Yamaguchi, Terufumi Morishita, Yasuhiro Sogawa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper investigates the effect of tokenizers on the downstream
performance of pretrained language models (PLMs) in scriptio continua languages
where no explicit spaces exist between words, using Japanese as a case study.
The tokenizer for such languages often consists of a morphological analyzer and
a subword tokenizer, requiring us to conduct a comprehensive study of all
possible pairs. However, previous studies lack this comprehensiveness. We
therefore train extensive sets of tokenizers, build a PLM using each, and
measure the downstream performance on a wide range of tasks. Our results
demonstrate that each downstream task has a different optimal morphological
analyzer, and that it is better to use Byte-Pair-Encoding or Unigram rather
than WordPiece as a subword tokenizer, regardless of the type of task. | [
0.0121339997,
0.0591549911,
-0.0175232477,
0.0209323447,
-0.0319741517,
0.0145901153,
0.0324958265,
0.0532513931,
-0.0712032542,
0.006701584,
-0.0353616327,
-0.056900762,
0.0303883962,
0.0326031446,
0.0736474097,
-0.0356310941,
0.0969290659,
-0.0458490476,
0.0018534272,
0.0261478908,
0.0335092209,
-0.0115094343,
-0.0001463018,
0.0347022973,
-0.0582135655,
0.0050474312,
0.001806529,
-0.0101652667,
-0.0227539148,
-0.0005923019,
-0.0371639878,
0.0173483212,
-0.0530292615,
0.0058222632,
0.0000016576,
-0.0520494506,
-0.0104939444,
-0.0188041162,
0.0071215802,
0.0528716482,
0.0682822615,
-0.026676245,
-0.0284651741,
0.0592605136,
0.0002028755,
-0.0262092557,
0.0701961368,
0.0038254289,
0.0268541202,
0.0603433885,
-0.0287712179,
-0.0359041877,
0.0253776256,
-0.0243074857,
-0.0727966949,
0.0342172086,
-0.0055603078,
-0.062950328,
-0.0267351959,
-0.0315560214,
-0.032072328,
-0.00011154,
-0.0329867788,
-0.0124060996,
-0.0214531478,
0.0130200787,
-0.046354223,
-0.0585198514,
0.0055480185,
0.0073293415,
-0.0562832877,
-0.0185283795,
-0.0134710902,
-0.0059726271,
-0.0064466558,
-0.0120998602,
-0.0264381543,
0.0221720934,
-0.0101414714,
0.0391037352,
0.0528149754,
0.0083757136,
0.0261678174,
-0.0193076357,
-0.0654276162,
0.0774949715,
0.057252571,
-0.064357385,
-0.0141726909,
-0.0094275428,
-0.029858781,
-0.0721047074,
0.0312034991,
0.0098004546,
-0.0186602622,
0.0337072872,
-0.0160119124,
-0.0575976968,
0.0192452352,
0.0074539441,
0.0437246338,
0.0409844369,
-0.0357906222,
-0.0121621443,
-0.0407100096,
0.0340266563,
0.0332799032,
0.022281982,
-0.0379386805,
0.0018324468,
0.0096315378,
-0.0339751057,
-0.0856606513,
0.0491534397,
-0.0110888183,
-0.0091112517,
0.0001885595,
0.0132303424,
0.0274643693,
-0.0290591326,
0.0118420105,
-0.0565744974,
-0.0377418846,
0.0021024086,
-0.0175258908,
0.0263000652,
-0.0360556841,
0.0113399215,
-0.0207242239,
-0.0574849695,
0.0058243792,
0.043120034,
0.0096994899,
-0.0104097072,
0.0347653963,
0.0759334564,
-0.0205553416,
-0.0454066545,
-0.0065035541,
-0.0080471952,
-0.0205981284,
-0.0241163317,
-0.0349797532,
-0.0388512276,
0.0439446308,
-0.0013830928,
-0.008325832,
0.0086198011,
-0.0004316726,
0.0050970484,
0.0060325959,
0.0716846287,
0.020840561,
-0.0068229856,
-0.0175195672,
-0.0411226377,
0.0094329007,
0.0481436402,
0.035528969,
0.0035173264,
0.0485303812,
-0.0289577022,
0.0075837411,
0.089173764,
-0.0273397081,
-0.0261779297,
-0.0602267534,
-0.0278614424,
0.0530338213,
0.030659182,
0.06444823,
0.1001619175,
-0.0264560375,
0.0447837971,
-0.0236597378,
0.0938844234,
0.0235313624,
0.0158386566,
0.062054418,
-0.0359919034,
-0.007404766,
0.0213479623,
0.0092970757,
-0.037939582,
0.0444586165,
0.0259128008,
0.0024981413,
0.039130494,
-0.0164897032,
-0.0489658378,
-0.0142762056,
-0.0257617217,
-0.0225058533,
-0.0672519952,
0.0649604201,
0.0225476827,
-0.0891940743,
0.0339633226,
0.0283194911,
-0.0774598122,
0.03395091,
-0.0447408818,
0.0133044543,
0.0571888611,
0.0574652739,
-0.0062235543,
-0.0130861113,
0.0287483782,
0.0030329577,
0.0216825753,
0.0158250183,
-0.0116736125,
0.0265567228,
-0.0458849259,
0.0324275121,
0.0333601721,
0.0112551134,
0.0549958833,
-0.0340033062,
0.031262219,
-0.0128320735,
-0.0303166453,
0.0048006359,
0.0665922686,
0.0014257025,
0.0303753503,
-0.0246986691,
0.0175400004,
0.02617836,
0.0067370837,
-0.051139906,
0.0375507921,
0.0131771397,
-0.068928197,
0.0363339148,
0.0412765704,
-0.022018576,
-0.0104911514,
0.0628474057,
0.018549813,
0.0143555235,
-0.0071033742,
0.0290465672,
-0.0395146236,
0.0062824585,
-0.0090759667,
0.0958899036,
-0.0652117431,
0.0916981474,
-0.0291204862,
0.0132926311,
-0.0457923338,
0.0084329685,
0.0122817764,
0.0206059143,
-0.0050131106,
-0.0033949567,
0.0545869432,
-0.0394585654,
-0.0263632387,
0.0376462601,
-0.0270472225,
-0.0304514691,
-0.0022793796,
-0.0142996609,
0.0063928994,
-0.0544874705,
-0.1015419811,
-0.0105002066,
-0.028751839,
0.0293224212,
-0.0320652351,
0.0323687382,
-0.0341032557,
-0.0048142457,
0.0015752434,
0.0114556998,
0.0224659536,
-0.0029680452,
0.0575839393,
0.0082846303,
-0.0218561739,
-0.0551833399,
-0.0326061994,
-0.0021554134,
0.0452541038,
0.0162270181,
-0.047945451,
-0.0515564308,
0.0240930431,
0.0170072317,
0.0359420627,
0.0008547166,
-0.0828658342,
0.0393443257,
-0.0540112294,
0.0700601637,
0.0397482924,
-0.0029071604,
-0.0040712892,
0.0286468137,
-0.0179359298,
-0.0321067944,
-0.0218093395,
0.0349994302,
-0.0185226221,
-0.0422439836,
-0.0108454246,
0.0428039953,
0.0920570716,
-0.0074063069,
0.0022169526,
-0.0426733717,
-0.0161269717,
-0.0436911099,
-0.0000924867,
0.0375609659,
-0.0282374714,
-0.0450649224,
0.0309260581,
-0.0171016864,
-0.0429292172,
0.0432438627,
-0.0910262913,
-0.0395827405,
-0.0574015006,
0.034750741,
-0.0398781598,
0.0308746938,
0.0101533923,
0.0017365745,
0.0035634993,
-0.0975035354,
-0.0251760595,
0.0497964099,
-0.0015456966,
-0.018370565,
0.0064353012,
-0.0299512707,
-0.008000561,
-0.0127576347,
-0.0295931343,
-0.0235436857,
-0.0259616897,
-0.0232426059,
0.0134703992,
0.0751797408,
-0.0011526307,
0.0078380499,
0.0666791871,
-0.0473513864,
0.0305033773,
0.0011991807,
0.0260285083,
-0.0083275801,
0.021348441,
0.0009877888,
-0.0294310823,
-0.0417148508,
-0.0016638776,
0.0284321588,
0.003216885,
0.0122772092,
-0.0372683592,
-0.0314947404,
-0.0043626372,
0.0333771855,
-0.0568990633,
-0.0291978437,
-0.0374323614,
0.0453936867,
-0.0135143287,
-0.0175614972,
0.1148795858,
0.0331596732,
-0.0109464256,
0.0071073296,
0.0038726344,
0.0127034895,
0.0045104022,
-0.0057135746,
-0.0498884395,
-0.0171610564,
0.0297947079,
0.0258026645,
0.0315098837,
0.0056674667,
0.003256561,
-0.1365353167,
0.0102018937,
0.0102637298,
-0.0447819456,
0.0069788354,
-0.0247240998,
-0.006740958,
-0.0140948165,
0.0508935191,
0.0546308607,
-0.0247658063,
0.0363526903,
0.0415238738,
-0.0549828522,
-0.0186266545,
-0.0416704006,
-0.0666189194,
0.0152146593,
0.0332334265,
-0.0177645013,
-0.0439064279,
0.0055278386,
0.0984077528,
0.0002561893,
0.0222255755,
-0.0445075631,
0.0199087597,
-0.0016969638,
-0.0530347675,
0.014999629,
-0.0197193362,
-0.0012587993,
-0.006484299,
-0.0057347883,
-0.0048894542,
0.0279381722,
0.0090105869,
0.0013172609,
-0.0062232888,
-0.0473340116,
0.0293863919,
0.031190034,
-0.0613340624,
-0.0392008498,
0.0064182109,
0.0160079412,
-0.0458714142,
0.0471193604,
-0.0555877574,
-0.0080788573,
0.0007189173,
-0.0830135047,
-0.0499294549,
0.0358499661,
0.0740603358,
0.0003743032,
-0.0103880474,
-0.0304764435,
0.0046644015,
-0.0381226055,
-0.0049991384,
0.0331592895,
0.0091457684,
-0.0939389616,
-0.0116143934,
0.0183143504,
0.029348202,
0.0007133427,
-0.0298760124,
-0.0353404172,
-0.050725814,
0.0117828008,
0.0383190215,
0.024849169,
0.0160887241,
-0.0234900862,
-0.0468462631,
-0.0115486607,
0.0162523929,
-0.0337002613,
0.0381743945,
0.0484658629,
-0.0037788532,
-0.0059995749,
-0.0006148146,
-0.0013442156,
-0.020161584,
-0.0046279184,
0.0119445296,
-0.0193434078,
0.0030548703,
-0.0019175496,
0.0338144824,
0.0475850254,
-0.0447431765,
0.0628493801,
-0.0400568359,
0.0130114621,
-0.0384653322,
0.012199454,
-0.0349657312,
-0.0167163368,
0.0432458557,
0.0130488668,
-0.0268868264,
-0.0349494964,
-0.0799069032,
0.0122417463,
0.0428843945,
0.0188628361,
0.0353951268,
0.0231967252,
0.0294097438,
0.0235440545,
0.0100467736,
-0.0356496349,
-0.0079463078,
0.0016620745,
-0.0625924096,
-0.0090138605,
-0.0242952947,
0.035906177,
-0.0331867151,
0.0333397724,
0.0249893386,
-0.0093672639,
-0.0154782645,
0.0159909278,
0.0317529701,
-0.0248326678,
0.0201175846,
-0.0204000976,
-0.0027056746,
0.0117953261,
-0.0023467755,
-0.0124658719,
-0.0026960878,
0.000324047,
0.0048794602,
-0.0381916016,
-0.0492646545,
0.0874593705,
0.0308649186,
0.0130901486,
-0.0118076662,
0.007914939,
-0.0188126005,
0.0295048412,
0.0187944304,
0.0315111764,
-0.0353371091,
-0.0228237193,
-0.0369565375,
-0.0548086613,
-0.0142007964,
0.0395951308,
0.0080556283,
0.0412493534,
-0.0064124833,
0.0389417075,
-0.0021370077,
0.019422859,
-0.0050719469,
0.0036563617,
0.0447784588,
-0.003932741,
-0.0141698271,
-5.351881781e-33,
-0.0376406983,
0.0230588298,
-0.0030862328,
-0.0017023025,
-0.0265343804,
-0.002226108,
-0.0211497452,
0.0182396304,
0.0137922298,
-0.0338999033,
-0.0242370758,
0.0188889708,
0.0252339765,
0.0034412218,
0.0359992832,
0.0215000771,
0.0522999242,
-0.009431215,
-0.0301934592,
-0.0459655523,
0.0086028464,
0.0441910364,
0.0239698086,
0.0319027156,
-0.0136334281,
-0.0162960645,
-0.0104585141,
0.0174802858,
0.0138346469,
0.0617065877,
0.0065677455,
0.0247001536,
0.0061503528,
0.0190226082,
-0.0357127525,
0.0594239011,
-0.0995675698,
-0.0323457532,
0.0477534272,
0.0648542717,
-0.0001551819,
-0.0489484072,
0.0110150017,
-0.0244361404,
-0.0039344216,
0.0277360231,
-0.011971496,
-0.008701467,
-0.0168736242,
0.0027827362,
-0.0471712165,
0.0053370493,
-0.0036665858,
0.0222265758,
0.0665558949,
-0.0396627486,
0.0078120506,
-0.006471395,
0.0082263257,
0.0299603269,
0.0171828941,
0.0561188571,
0.0509387739,
0.0239260364,
-0.0313639231,
0.0124897501,
0.0931540951,
-0.027565727,
0.0414436869,
0.017854793,
0.0708237216,
-0.0133398222,
0.0369996913,
-0.0261253342,
0.0676811039,
-0.0353947207,
-0.0373409949,
-0.0213087536,
0.0451531522,
0.0320981406,
-0.0216966476,
0.0402840897,
-0.0209328011,
-0.0464019924,
-0.0123238079,
-0.075250566,
-0.0245985165,
-0.0278924685,
0.0331104808,
0.006616645,
0.0021171414,
0.0000886142,
0.0340392031,
-0.0055258684,
0.0029008556,
0.0057349233,
-0.0016781017,
0.0457131267,
-0.0279004388,
0.0279737785,
-0.0329414681,
-0.070949249,
0.0005873968,
0.0194128491,
0.0175908934,
-0.0290473476,
0.018653458,
-0.0025982698,
-0.0894701555,
0.0308879334,
0.0022166613,
0.0227622408,
-0.001643871,
0.0169624519,
0.0398735106,
0.0094925417,
0.0171592664,
-0.0091115776,
0.0431439504,
-0.0377286226,
-0.0484388582,
-0.0026204099,
-0.0136458026,
0.0004032904,
-0.0094487118,
0.0163317509,
0.0023493725,
0.0504174083,
0.0335118584,
-0.0177170578,
-0.0192067046,
0.0209490154,
2.406e-7,
0.0771479234,
0.0418007523,
0.0854003131,
-0.0302393511,
0.0193190239,
-0.0369470045,
-0.0302798674,
-0.0149237122,
0.0113254227,
0.0540094636,
0.0011638124,
-0.022443885,
0.0203772131,
-0.0142331123,
-0.0607632995,
0.0265355557,
-0.03629243,
0.0095394943,
-0.0837794542,
0.0057673603,
0.0274539907,
0.0885132104,
-0.0245283619,
-0.0136281801,
-0.0509051308,
-0.0647292882,
0.0285598189,
0.00121122,
0.0008535634,
0.0270110518,
0.0026900531,
0.0241115559,
0.0094817579,
0.0148145026,
-0.0284318104,
0.0355208442,
0.053344667,
0.0262662526,
-0.0108111445,
0.0050903587,
0.0514583215,
0.0009467994,
-0.0418668091,
-0.0418135524,
0.0778437331,
-0.0166116394,
0.0165181179,
-0.0303562898,
-0.0230916739,
0.0103762066,
-0.0230631437,
-0.0067559476,
-0.0308132637,
0.0600574911,
0.0559962876,
-0.0097291898,
-0.0358977504,
-0.0448054224,
-0.0430974253,
0.033626385,
-0.0303162485,
-0.0450896509,
-0.0098708002,
0.0261717811,
0.0435740054,
-0.0070529561,
-0.0320212096,
2.372282828e-34,
0.0577395633,
-0.0379782356,
0.0382945985,
0.0412589535,
-0.0060773459,
-0.0265630856,
0.0117566865,
0.0635138825,
-0.0265121795,
-0.0337598138,
-0.0051063937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09562v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09562v1 | Reproducibility in NLP: What Have We Learned from the Checklist? | 2023-06-16T00:39:25 | 2023-06-16T00:39:25 | Ian Magnusson, Noah A. Smith, Jesse Dodge | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scientific progress in NLP rests on the reproducibility of researchers'
claims. The *CL conferences created the NLP Reproducibility Checklist in 2020
to be completed by authors at submission to remind them of key information to
include. We provide the first analysis of the Checklist by examining 10,405
anonymous responses to it. First, we find evidence of an increase in reporting
of information on efficiency, validation performance, summary statistics, and
hyperparameters after the Checklist's introduction. Further, we show acceptance
rate grows for submissions with more Yes responses. We find that the 44% of
submissions that gather new data are 5% less likely to be accepted than those
that did not; the average reviewer-rated reproducibility of these submissions
is also 2% lower relative to the rest. We find that only 46% of submissions
claim to open-source their code, though submissions that do have 8% higher
reproducibility score relative to those that do not, the most for any item. We
discuss what can be inferred about the state of reproducibility in NLP, and
provide a set of recommendations for future conferences, including: a) allowing
submitting code and appendices one week after the deadline, and b) measuring
dataset reproducibility by a checklist of data collection practices. | [
0.0466118567,
0.0733040124,
-0.0236521568,
0.0012002339,
-0.0518111698,
0.0036333029,
-0.0096845934,
-0.0070325518,
-0.0249379277,
-0.0468135104,
0.0216671489,
0.0408870019,
0.0622494221,
0.0260455366,
0.0054979832,
-0.021999862,
0.0193463694,
0.0405328944,
-0.0137755051,
0.0114351539,
0.0020934159,
0.0131104412,
-0.0193860233,
0.0617570281,
0.0103510618,
-0.0225362014,
0.0036912942,
-0.0293757748,
-0.0023283598,
-0.012977059,
-0.0251104422,
0.0661088675,
-0.0066727074,
0.0727315843,
0.0000020081,
-0.064158529,
-0.0280662142,
0.0771533772,
-0.0436538383,
0.0021278497,
0.0396076255,
-0.0383713022,
0.0011425189,
-0.0119353365,
-0.0117377508,
-0.0341826715,
0.0913658068,
0.03934367,
0.0548690557,
0.0399628282,
-0.0000278052,
-0.0100972215,
0.0420027822,
0.0017993811,
0.0346281528,
0.0223010611,
0.0030939279,
0.0337413885,
-0.0055766022,
0.0147931008,
0.0163605381,
0.0423131771,
0.0145951007,
0.0081170984,
-0.0023471769,
0.0172996204,
-0.0933984965,
-0.0489900634,
0.0100302771,
0.0744412839,
0.040376436,
-0.0505676419,
0.0209423043,
-0.021619197,
-0.0149883274,
0.0193684865,
-0.0455400199,
0.0484207235,
0.0248512514,
0.0154813314,
-0.0466603972,
-0.0254545845,
0.0242913458,
-0.0080983425,
0.0489687286,
0.0478180498,
-0.0185906086,
-0.0303831343,
0.0158448163,
0.0438100956,
-0.0001000584,
-0.076342918,
-0.020019656,
-0.0384534523,
0.0448793024,
0.0064104688,
-0.0210524052,
-0.0183149427,
0.0754471868,
-0.0037921483,
0.0525027253,
-0.0030732492,
-0.0257050078,
-0.0038419242,
-0.008479055,
0.0389913395,
-0.0064638914,
0.0447336808,
0.0068552368,
0.0173374582,
-0.0935642123,
0.0269638654,
0.0037013022,
0.0241346285,
0.0272739697,
0.0090243826,
-0.0505199842,
0.0080309035,
-0.0265115537,
0.0551030114,
0.0009296354,
-0.0020901815,
-0.0060750437,
0.0530237183,
-0.0100071132,
-0.0037425496,
-0.0031067857,
0.0180861745,
0.0012621671,
-0.0640435219,
0.0049059778,
0.0015434247,
-0.0003755359,
-0.0241831504,
0.0132860234,
0.0322176181,
0.0550854243,
-0.0219020881,
0.0119237537,
-0.0477179959,
-0.0273737144,
-0.0321653709,
0.0129279261,
-0.0984108672,
0.0617319494,
0.0211895667,
0.0017122057,
-0.0563033298,
-0.0150252199,
0.016654864,
-0.0284938086,
0.0783764794,
-0.0585635751,
0.0061913803,
-0.0298753083,
-0.0222264919,
-0.0047523272,
0.0510343425,
0.047618825,
-0.0189995561,
0.0699511841,
-0.0197737459,
0.0284990519,
-0.0200603902,
0.0199539084,
-0.0214100815,
0.0297122356,
0.0125537384,
0.0293122679,
-0.0024949701,
-0.0237004086,
0.0624285042,
-0.0336252302,
-0.0229301527,
0.0349479839,
0.0444385558,
0.0345131271,
-0.0357602574,
-0.0089854104,
0.0138214985,
0.0235934481,
-0.0352907106,
-0.0415661111,
0.0125517435,
0.010670498,
0.0268583801,
0.0006017456,
0.0162142292,
0.0059524253,
-0.0497707799,
-0.0631804317,
-0.0197789129,
0.0097905826,
-0.0108658196,
0.0053053987,
0.0267042592,
0.0191995446,
0.0268314388,
0.0202568863,
-0.0737225637,
-0.0330213904,
-0.0260892063,
0.0285373535,
0.0054734568,
0.0558312871,
0.0172399487,
0.0375094898,
-0.0477549098,
0.0103255427,
0.0128804706,
0.0285054743,
-0.0043078139,
0.0300665405,
-0.0181499068,
-0.0377656631,
-0.0133492304,
0.0106179863,
-0.0162645169,
0.0590531379,
0.0034966469,
0.0014984685,
-0.0280121285,
-0.0786137506,
0.0698782131,
-0.0098434994,
0.0027948353,
-0.0381031968,
-0.0182093196,
0.0802276507,
0.0335474536,
-0.0185252503,
0.0306142177,
0.0314854607,
0.013526476,
-0.0260188133,
0.0304463245,
0.0708362535,
-0.0283804778,
0.0252117794,
-0.0778940469,
-0.0458133258,
0.044853013,
-0.0458878316,
0.0120019987,
0.0120591028,
-0.0401288085,
0.0216949508,
-0.029979907,
-0.0016700753,
-0.0115895281,
0.0194950737,
0.00277668,
0.007377882,
0.0121108517,
0.0440440923,
0.0042554126,
-0.0488094054,
0.0303712487,
-0.0164278541,
-0.0477159061,
0.0451265126,
-0.02337531,
0.0207635239,
0.0220003072,
0.0253712162,
-0.0510125943,
-0.0147209698,
-0.0370278247,
0.0063776094,
0.0324844755,
0.0140318647,
0.0300698821,
-0.0337655134,
0.0074300002,
0.0174992979,
0.0201480594,
-0.0170997642,
0.0002998361,
0.0145511972,
0.0622234084,
-0.0121854311,
-0.0033715428,
-0.0439055152,
-0.0244553909,
-0.0079010846,
0.0875089392,
0.0065527777,
-0.0125705851,
-0.048281908,
0.0301880445,
-0.0475405045,
0.0031301957,
0.0349413902,
-0.0027631379,
0.0310894977,
0.0307095647,
-0.0260036066,
0.0177564062,
-0.0383978076,
-0.0164004955,
0.0462455861,
-0.0010427244,
-0.071465455,
-0.0072112787,
-0.0320321023,
-0.0659196824,
0.0337092876,
-0.0639178753,
0.0607452169,
0.0240589678,
-0.0040910221,
-0.0172713008,
-0.0387486666,
-0.0141622405,
-0.0247304738,
-0.0508666784,
-0.0136287035,
-0.0257741064,
-0.0183977969,
0.0446281433,
-0.0216318741,
-0.062565662,
0.0582882352,
-0.048276864,
-0.0038823758,
-0.0453304909,
0.0339081734,
-0.0261130724,
0.0838177428,
-0.0088867089,
0.0056978245,
0.0406641439,
0.0172270983,
0.0148212602,
0.010558527,
0.0216047894,
-0.0250077471,
0.0371079482,
-0.0413725153,
0.0363511443,
-0.0132005131,
-0.0108076306,
-0.0081851799,
-0.01570669,
-0.0066269534,
0.0204088259,
0.0152758956,
-0.0147041138,
-0.0544805378,
-0.0168528482,
0.078411065,
0.0059650205,
0.0169575792,
-0.0382224545,
-0.0066186972,
-0.0283181723,
0.0098978076,
0.0211179443,
0.0292221084,
0.0113801248,
-0.0553429872,
0.0844360441,
0.0151600763,
0.0729939193,
-0.033800941,
0.0092893783,
0.0140437484,
-0.0561015345,
-0.0176301319,
0.0179481469,
0.0216577891,
-0.0413985364,
0.0248240419,
0.0748254433,
0.0370231085,
-0.0243895259,
-0.0099934731,
-0.0114933802,
0.0000633848,
0.0130246691,
-0.0102510434,
-0.0998283252,
-0.025098443,
-0.0014945201,
0.0410991348,
-0.0346547328,
-0.045919165,
-0.0128704468,
-0.0788569674,
0.0453963019,
-0.0113873538,
-0.0434610322,
-0.034114629,
-0.0838628337,
0.0024229167,
-0.0540404245,
0.0092253461,
0.0058064233,
-0.003185641,
0.0358888432,
0.0229063779,
-0.0888226181,
-0.0711692125,
0.0417535305,
-0.0468194596,
0.0849491879,
0.0827390105,
0.0494235754,
-0.0194439944,
-0.0448284782,
-0.0174433012,
-0.0334404521,
-0.0099590207,
0.0009934367,
0.0808444694,
-0.0071635232,
0.0032196231,
-0.0136115933,
0.0034749971,
-0.0630978569,
-0.027411351,
-0.0025425951,
0.0616462156,
-0.0054427795,
-0.0513353199,
-0.0326300636,
0.0152783105,
-0.0281854551,
0.08361312,
0.0247963052,
0.0199120734,
-0.021111533,
-0.0295272227,
-0.0016695526,
-0.038052842,
-0.0494223423,
0.0194831695,
-0.0057584085,
-0.0154935261,
-0.0789414048,
-0.0623648278,
0.0439367555,
0.0044474192,
0.0064329444,
-0.0078310017,
0.0024322248,
-0.0234503374,
-0.0686202049,
0.0375311598,
-0.0002989045,
-0.0103405965,
-0.0273683798,
-0.0282334723,
-0.0057383515,
0.030603094,
-0.0224557482,
0.063246794,
-0.0670838729,
-0.0458417758,
-0.0013397931,
0.0410743579,
0.0275563728,
-0.0079223225,
-0.0111334026,
-0.0085693756,
-0.0578188375,
0.0348643363,
-0.0064089885,
-0.0047277771,
0.0145374956,
-0.0244828686,
0.0155170392,
-0.0115693025,
-0.0374611691,
-0.0103119174,
0.0144803468,
0.0325593352,
0.023714656,
-0.0178168751,
0.033635579,
0.0754501298,
0.0467709862,
-0.0352797247,
-0.0243435074,
-0.0032887263,
-0.0390832499,
-0.0029706687,
-0.0139603904,
-0.0601415299,
0.0206600763,
-0.0090570971,
0.017423125,
-0.0157994796,
0.0830959082,
-0.0544401892,
0.0509717762,
-0.0525728986,
0.0538843274,
0.0227081794,
0.0189916138,
-0.019456232,
-0.0025360319,
-0.0517797545,
0.0058335778,
-0.0619851574,
0.0272624902,
-0.0181479547,
-0.0100930361,
0.0135528017,
-0.0188413318,
0.0267941859,
0.049646847,
-0.0702985004,
-0.0307356548,
-0.0094000902,
-0.0067405906,
0.0084460033,
0.0366472714,
0.0746052861,
-0.057464499,
-0.0020691559,
-0.0255119391,
0.0571828187,
0.0095371632,
-0.0110070268,
0.0083234143,
0.0091412729,
-0.0541658029,
-0.0612193421,
0.0659256652,
-0.0267602187,
0.0112192184,
-0.0413852595,
-0.0142176282,
-0.0173987411,
-0.0433650948,
-0.0216511022,
-0.014804339,
-0.0272756293,
-0.061523255,
-0.0359330252,
-0.0661336929,
0.0244545769,
0.0287267081,
0.0327483788,
0.0210989695,
0.0087328488,
0.0627828464,
0.0261388961,
-0.0590262711,
-0.0233481787,
-0.015352549,
0.0107777892,
-0.0391718298,
-0.0187018141,
-5.813551677e-33,
0.0150676109,
0.0124991974,
-0.0134525411,
-0.0242107939,
0.0051903161,
0.0271486416,
-0.0367969461,
0.0062346295,
-0.0410204083,
-0.0013827943,
-0.0104513885,
0.0078538144,
0.0175494291,
-0.0235146079,
0.0606973357,
0.004923034,
0.023485275,
-0.0123551618,
-0.0498112366,
-0.0192816034,
0.0251699574,
-0.020069398,
0.1012853011,
-0.0646250024,
0.0821794048,
0.0230496433,
0.0050753024,
-0.0302722938,
0.0102959825,
0.0704570115,
0.0048191459,
0.0238580145,
0.0321369581,
-0.0439177267,
-0.0231507793,
-0.0504195876,
-0.0609078296,
-0.0180459637,
0.0274418872,
-0.0036029636,
-0.0420716144,
0.0259096511,
0.0557806678,
-0.0362689123,
-0.0399311781,
-0.0164355766,
0.031126231,
-0.0324426442,
-0.0387310311,
-0.0208721478,
-0.0252324324,
0.0032296765,
-0.0170667302,
0.0341742113,
0.0226986781,
0.0644454062,
-0.0123887248,
-0.0053772423,
-0.0801881477,
0.0284380503,
0.0049069012,
-0.0023689314,
0.0574351177,
-0.0665619373,
0.0317744538,
0.0543777943,
0.0181616582,
-0.0005526563,
-0.0175854266,
-0.0011069664,
0.0417616293,
0.0592069365,
0.0394944213,
0.0855690688,
0.0268499739,
0.0045807147,
-0.0062629529,
0.0406577438,
-0.0259626675,
0.0192028768,
0.0279040895,
-0.0229476187,
-0.0789229423,
-0.036023777,
-0.0464008488,
0.016170036,
-0.0121781705,
-0.0339130424,
0.0292296298,
-0.0045522829,
-0.0011460111,
0.0601449683,
0.0151816364,
-0.0275386143,
-0.0560254157,
0.0015808935,
0.004582515,
0.0483017415,
-0.0069255615,
-0.01258949,
-0.0819918141,
0.0249530189,
0.0102279931,
0.0460058823,
0.0687701404,
-0.0026925423,
0.0649034977,
0.0262666084,
-0.0487488247,
0.0098367091,
-0.0160251576,
0.0317180119,
0.0152981263,
-0.0183577463,
0.0270789806,
0.0292883925,
0.002364787,
-0.0125560667,
0.0180539936,
-0.0072082439,
-0.0502785519,
0.0511602014,
0.0122704422,
-0.0033102918,
0.0053294268,
-0.0080294311,
-0.0246280096,
0.0452973023,
0.0518339388,
0.0069460263,
-0.0168379638,
-0.0109943058,
2.706e-7,
0.0694857463,
0.0209615994,
0.0168039165,
0.0073361397,
-0.0021406724,
0.0038426775,
-0.0259086583,
0.0265510697,
-0.0130495001,
-0.0052365111,
-0.0092839953,
-0.0023587141,
0.0495381355,
0.0551396497,
-0.0518738739,
-0.0615691952,
-0.0448837169,
-0.0198637005,
-0.0485800952,
-0.0019449531,
0.0379891992,
0.0337821096,
0.0293162689,
0.0238267053,
-0.0244665202,
-0.0168801453,
0.0135102775,
-0.0682064667,
0.049791228,
0.0434256159,
0.0162359588,
-0.0010140117,
0.035038285,
0.0096831704,
-0.0321297348,
-0.0507870391,
0.0022291087,
0.0260469466,
0.0187671501,
-0.0317424946,
-0.0041602808,
-0.0512386374,
-0.0015664692,
-0.0717521086,
0.0339465961,
-0.0252896547,
-0.0544064566,
-0.0122256801,
-0.0251829363,
-0.0100440513,
0.0483672135,
0.0111636249,
0.0204072725,
0.0113836899,
0.0025950035,
0.0136343427,
-0.0602383129,
-0.0567745864,
-0.0365646258,
-0.0136041222,
0.0026909411,
-0.0728060976,
0.0160206091,
-0.0329031721,
0.0119162975,
-0.0728404522,
0.0073005147,
2.448674578e-34,
0.0098323626,
0.0100002866,
0.0461599305,
0.0094015012,
0.0317158625,
0.000920523,
0.0639969707,
-0.0321337953,
-0.0508616455,
-0.0002249541,
-0.0129496204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.01201v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.01201v1 | Schema-learning and rebinding as mechanisms of in-context learning and emergence | 2023-06-16T00:29:19 | 2023-06-16T00:29:19 | Sivaramakrishnan Swaminathan, Antoine Dedieu, Rajkumar Vasudeva Raju, Murray Shanahan, Miguel Lazaro-Gredilla, Dileep George | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In-context learning (ICL) is one of the most powerful and most unexpected
capabilities to emerge in recent transformer-based large language models
(LLMs). Yet the mechanisms that underlie it are poorly understood. In this
paper, we demonstrate that comparable ICL capabilities can be acquired by an
alternative sequence prediction learning method using clone-structured causal
graphs (CSCGs). Moreover, a key property of CSCGs is that, unlike
transformer-based LLMs, they are {\em interpretable}, which considerably
simplifies the task of explaining how ICL works. Specifically, we show that it
uses a combination of (a) learning template (schema) circuits for pattern
completion, (b) retrieving relevant templates in a context-sensitive manner,
and (c) rebinding of novel tokens to appropriate slots in the templates. We go
on to marshall evidence for the hypothesis that similar mechanisms underlie ICL
in LLMs. For example, we find that, with CSCGs as with LLMs, different
capabilities emerge at different levels of overparameterization, suggesting
that overparameterization helps in learning more complex template (schema)
circuits. By showing how ICL can be achieved with small models and datasets, we
open up a path to novel architectures, and take a vital step towards a more
general understanding of the mechanics behind this important capability. | [
0.0248321537,
0.0487037972,
-0.0342848971,
0.0213662274,
-0.0424281657,
-0.0010408873,
-0.0171789136,
-0.0122463042,
-0.0151427723,
-0.0150788156,
-0.0254955254,
-0.0252476539,
0.0086613363,
0.0262549389,
0.0209879987,
0.0116003202,
0.0457259975,
-0.0358388722,
-0.0314470157,
-0.0136535699,
-0.0411948599,
-0.0239748675,
0.0518866219,
0.0342614762,
0.0057991897,
0.0080357371,
-0.0145729659,
-0.0088629397,
-0.0484487899,
-0.0152316447,
-0.0208394788,
0.0253490452,
0.02322492,
0.0531142354,
0.00000205,
-0.0519453175,
-0.0413028635,
-0.0085527981,
-0.0134697286,
0.0086251786,
-0.00374989,
-0.0238069389,
-0.0097006699,
-0.0007208592,
-0.0437894538,
-0.0365724191,
0.0761827976,
0.0404652767,
-0.0004177798,
0.0895726383,
-0.0092983739,
-0.080965288,
0.044474259,
-0.0392761528,
0.0189465489,
-0.018117046,
0.0355527103,
-0.0116698164,
0.0378258377,
-0.0186783504,
-0.0541945249,
0.0115343332,
0.0163368247,
0.0110036386,
-0.0090607321,
0.0191751756,
0.0231013242,
-0.0525004715,
0.0069809044,
0.0394575596,
-0.0295126811,
-0.0661420673,
0.0067894128,
0.0063760555,
0.0213201791,
0.056883648,
-0.0415377207,
0.0394558199,
0.012310856,
0.0402636901,
0.0648026466,
-0.0266859233,
0.0684618056,
-0.023228975,
-0.0657837167,
0.0615610294,
0.0070263352,
-0.0073568337,
-0.0798254311,
-0.0191320423,
-0.0185363404,
-0.0388913639,
-0.0358565561,
0.017733207,
-0.0421397351,
0.035293106,
-0.0163587984,
0.0065942225,
-0.0016080588,
0.0232182313,
0.0410766266,
0.0408919938,
0.0160048101,
0.0108841769,
-0.0541682988,
0.0585293174,
-0.0597517975,
0.0302912053,
-0.0443502739,
0.0139338626,
-0.0417048633,
-0.026551988,
-0.0245628469,
0.0486707203,
-0.0024753003,
-0.0284192469,
-0.0246143006,
0.0564307421,
0.014607612,
0.0028574569,
-0.0078770854,
-0.0285948571,
-0.0112336176,
0.016488703,
0.0043589831,
0.0164398104,
0.0270810556,
0.0017192281,
-0.0324495547,
-0.0447481833,
-0.0213213731,
0.0015599316,
0.0183710661,
-0.0236141589,
0.0080648288,
0.0865962282,
0.0191777367,
-0.0707915947,
-0.0361268222,
-0.0156985912,
-0.0235718638,
-0.0246650092,
0.0228005573,
-0.0728775188,
-0.0134894047,
0.0473790765,
0.0110783987,
-0.0431974791,
0.0209434647,
0.0013458804,
-0.0357355848,
0.0587101914,
0.0273326412,
0.0116085764,
-0.0424919575,
-0.0203908831,
-0.0014528481,
0.0277490839,
0.0067004594,
0.0163680892,
0.0166946668,
-0.0224767998,
0.0191993713,
0.0544211902,
0.0330098346,
-0.0000254174,
-0.0396430939,
-0.0291673597,
0.0576947294,
-0.0143000456,
0.0241817534,
0.0133581497,
-0.0115252696,
0.0129601369,
0.0652360469,
0.0251595583,
0.0193119664,
0.0543834902,
0.0460309573,
-0.0282350816,
-0.0363461003,
0.0385096073,
-0.0665098205,
-0.0068137008,
-0.0218401514,
0.0438595004,
-0.0224410985,
-0.0050840192,
-0.0034186502,
-0.020659728,
-0.0141950073,
-0.0046012332,
-0.0211186279,
-0.0145927742,
0.0556253009,
0.0510459915,
-0.0657211989,
0.0396272987,
0.0219641924,
-0.0431411192,
-0.017419368,
-0.0443701781,
0.0400758274,
0.0303267855,
0.0689729527,
-0.0257615447,
-0.0012816982,
0.0357101113,
-0.0345887728,
0.0233444367,
-0.0151653755,
-0.0165326316,
-0.0265253149,
-0.0291319676,
-0.0289652329,
0.0029620186,
0.017098302,
0.0367510319,
0.0216674972,
-0.0477469899,
0.0062679276,
-0.0231554024,
-0.0273849647,
0.0214807317,
-0.0420766175,
-0.0132289808,
0.0055819321,
0.0052399212,
0.0495447293,
-0.0036817966,
-0.0292686969,
0.0548473224,
0.0529813841,
-0.0301929768,
-0.0319530405,
0.0308690742,
-0.0971899554,
-0.0204216894,
0.0265304968,
0.002399008,
0.040596731,
-0.0017194699,
0.0116202496,
-0.0526692718,
0.0607154518,
-0.054253839,
0.115555428,
-0.0064881174,
0.0573472269,
-0.0153670646,
0.0225230157,
-0.0390363745,
0.0750824586,
-0.0178011246,
0.008279168,
0.0300595257,
0.009390776,
-0.0381782576,
0.0196867939,
-0.0090214778,
0.0039536185,
-0.0050646397,
-0.0049031312,
0.0313794129,
-0.0395326726,
-0.0082181264,
-0.0281038284,
-0.0417516492,
-0.0075282608,
-0.0139952293,
0.025046777,
0.010205443,
0.0237977915,
0.0101647712,
-0.0115200998,
-0.0034618089,
-0.0140069658,
0.0012015509,
0.0294496398,
0.0179543179,
0.0010117987,
-0.0693849623,
-0.010416449,
-0.03440037,
-0.0309924334,
0.0890808105,
-0.0187613871,
-0.0270564929,
-0.0630430877,
0.0187347066,
0.0243977513,
0.0373520553,
-0.0457699932,
-0.0066713342,
0.0192245711,
-0.0353016369,
0.0575385727,
0.014008509,
-0.0255925674,
0.0164808556,
0.0317543037,
-0.0070550363,
-0.0209344327,
-0.034007024,
-0.0756838173,
-0.0239170641,
-0.0572984628,
0.0150956521,
-0.0207029339,
0.0934288949,
0.0011540699,
-0.0313408114,
-0.0578670576,
0.0007147134,
0.0230688769,
-0.0079908175,
-0.0037406264,
-0.0375547744,
-0.0396391042,
0.0211978052,
-0.0205266736,
-0.0767212138,
0.0382407382,
-0.0401539393,
0.0112804323,
-0.0121394899,
0.0022543576,
-0.0647202283,
0.0849682167,
0.0567012206,
0.0091927089,
0.0420521274,
-0.0502889194,
-0.0379957743,
0.028851578,
0.0110611068,
-0.0074197017,
0.0377545431,
-0.0417441428,
0.01508075,
0.013068689,
-0.0189195015,
-0.0375920609,
0.0179114603,
-0.0106261037,
0.0228897985,
0.0565262921,
-0.0300227311,
-0.0339400731,
0.0071535269,
0.0081432089,
0.0763675794,
-0.0001689709,
0.0057416596,
-0.0370302424,
0.0314618237,
-0.0071446924,
-0.0463059582,
0.0512123443,
-0.0155981267,
0.0303516649,
0.0319193713,
0.0441606045,
-0.0242183693,
-0.0204809085,
0.0185445081,
0.0439757332,
-0.0189259779,
-0.0624818243,
0.0288684443,
0.0186965335,
-0.0442254357,
-0.0196798034,
0.1015793011,
0.0144306626,
-0.0601596646,
0.0489615686,
0.0027663836,
0.0220781136,
0.0695714056,
0.0073459246,
-0.097317718,
-0.0219931751,
0.0284609739,
-0.0126366457,
-0.025807919,
-0.0438621826,
-0.0062182439,
-0.1063383818,
0.017850738,
0.014407441,
-0.0624487624,
-0.0132668288,
-0.055572167,
-0.0065973727,
0.0051674703,
-0.0043734019,
0.034118209,
-0.0289290324,
0.0034927404,
0.0212936606,
-0.0024681021,
-0.0407739095,
0.0056975586,
0.0077918875,
0.0251793023,
0.0530004911,
-0.0132562742,
-0.0014577856,
-0.0133614773,
0.0319322199,
-0.0196607597,
0.0422045328,
-0.0336397775,
-0.0040915287,
0.0269527528,
-0.0283347331,
-0.0061238175,
0.0556873903,
-0.0360562988,
-0.0325978212,
-0.02977903,
0.1077456996,
-0.0038562147,
-0.0229487475,
0.0201235954,
-0.0609901398,
-0.0163632017,
0.0499485731,
0.0371074229,
-0.0356933065,
-0.028393453,
0.0115264868,
-0.0041665211,
0.0092997449,
-0.0420141593,
-0.0132359639,
-0.0138400653,
-0.037311051,
-0.0627355427,
0.040584296,
0.0083668493,
0.0208890438,
0.0239932481,
0.0157535598,
0.031949129,
-0.0367398523,
-0.0735654086,
0.0013664765,
-0.0472731702,
0.0071146647,
-0.0931305587,
-0.0170998443,
0.0324763954,
-0.0572376363,
-0.0296208654,
-0.0027123303,
-0.0536864139,
-0.07390064,
0.0060615838,
0.0386268087,
0.0198947042,
0.0599352419,
0.0210894197,
-0.019420499,
0.0650140196,
0.0542232059,
-0.0176615044,
0.0007990033,
0.0355310142,
-0.0480656438,
-0.0065983497,
0.0427803695,
-0.010419447,
0.0268535744,
0.0321877152,
0.0358194895,
0.0009868686,
0.0427699909,
0.0652126521,
-0.0031136987,
0.0486200564,
-0.0139608011,
0.02614302,
0.0031037754,
0.0357293747,
-0.0109162051,
-0.0085529014,
-0.0295819938,
0.0029186741,
0.0277541298,
0.0264925677,
0.0119088395,
-0.0410615653,
0.0092111472,
0.0470953435,
-0.0293560252,
0.0305819456,
-0.0209303256,
-0.010583696,
0.0457679927,
0.0063080182,
0.0244081765,
0.0422692746,
0.0060587334,
0.032547202,
-0.0189381652,
0.0400668494,
0.0025333471,
0.0316126049,
-0.0543930866,
0.0131007703,
-0.086509347,
-0.031489104,
-0.0146577824,
0.0194067918,
0.0719483346,
-0.0321064666,
0.0329859927,
-0.0331186317,
0.0011397767,
-0.0071626576,
0.0239724331,
-0.0091316355,
-0.039592851,
0.0098628644,
0.0235031545,
-0.0278962776,
0.0168396104,
0.107974343,
0.0255950503,
0.0706693977,
-0.0057745478,
-0.0147400983,
-0.009445169,
-0.0579618923,
0.0564018674,
0.0284438673,
-0.0457910001,
-0.0084520448,
-0.0615544096,
-0.0435599312,
-0.009551771,
-0.0165874865,
0.0138174891,
-0.0346398205,
-0.0001234242,
0.0578260869,
0.015998926,
-0.0205618031,
-0.0378162414,
0.019925585,
0.0404104143,
-0.0095250886,
0.0088107092,
-6.278500468e-33,
0.0037411682,
-0.0327362865,
0.0076854061,
0.0320244357,
0.015931651,
0.0278346203,
-0.0480425805,
0.0194415394,
0.0210098773,
-0.0177965555,
-0.0138804363,
-0.0066748932,
-0.0005288793,
0.028038539,
0.0090238126,
0.0008248065,
0.0314750001,
0.0297153331,
0.0006461255,
0.0324234627,
0.0358435661,
0.0107493429,
0.0718195587,
-0.0137000903,
-0.0065362053,
-0.018067427,
0.0321034603,
0.0140107311,
-0.0370556712,
0.0573075823,
0.0129663208,
0.0222628098,
0.0262951013,
-0.0700679645,
-0.0263807755,
0.0133909648,
-0.0752272829,
0.0066283094,
0.0701141655,
0.0143943252,
-0.008917734,
-0.0598333441,
0.0599549152,
-0.0156142479,
-0.0301460456,
0.0189639796,
-0.0081564393,
-0.0152877169,
-0.0657981336,
-0.0281048287,
-0.0629616976,
0.0186473913,
0.0227624103,
-0.013724179,
-0.0001993513,
-0.0048450171,
0.0005815323,
0.0306145754,
-0.0196950193,
0.0615958683,
-0.0000224346,
0.0704146922,
0.0331172235,
0.0457167886,
0.0374252908,
0.0338123217,
0.0037123647,
0.0120559409,
0.0188606996,
-0.0211856905,
0.0007869403,
0.0517983511,
0.0016400489,
-0.0019679202,
0.0313072354,
-0.0195962712,
-0.0415419899,
-0.040688891,
0.0342675857,
0.0350395292,
0.0583374538,
0.020047361,
-0.0169856716,
-0.0342910551,
-0.0554099791,
-0.0188888945,
-0.0358084589,
0.0024417401,
-0.0015883351,
0.0243364424,
-0.0297834631,
-0.0038185921,
0.0186770316,
-0.0603816845,
-0.0352001265,
0.0616940111,
-0.0140309855,
0.014670819,
-0.0250053462,
-0.0066528586,
-0.0589286648,
-0.0659585893,
0.0113223679,
-0.0304437838,
0.0034325167,
0.0139111159,
0.0493862331,
0.0447388403,
-0.0548920035,
-0.0221761074,
-0.0565052107,
0.0053209974,
-0.0032164762,
-0.0183638241,
0.0619454645,
0.0197642408,
-0.0098986011,
0.0028724053,
0.0585044399,
0.0216538701,
-0.0104629816,
0.0182536021,
-0.0166792441,
0.0182609223,
-0.0179039631,
-0.0355751887,
-0.0628949478,
0.0564823486,
0.0602658913,
-0.0521814115,
-0.0399955325,
0.0031528715,
2.911e-7,
0.0355779231,
0.0509461053,
0.0385407843,
0.0178748798,
0.0644808188,
0.0192009825,
0.0018882273,
0.007400671,
0.0043185293,
0.0200143587,
0.0380842015,
-0.0221620388,
0.000101713,
-0.0176234096,
-0.0710477531,
0.0194897298,
-0.0792076439,
0.0411001816,
-0.0256062597,
0.0182097014,
-0.0037262943,
0.1157600731,
-0.0007550904,
-0.0206921622,
-0.008245605,
-0.0206099022,
0.0416458845,
-0.0228904821,
0.018510256,
-0.0007404029,
-0.078044869,
0.0002381517,
0.0052861599,
0.0090038413,
0.0031699387,
0.0588424355,
-0.030869741,
0.0195335485,
0.0105011491,
0.0163917355,
0.0259369854,
-0.0148219205,
-0.0187482536,
-0.0699445903,
0.0562948585,
-0.0788753852,
-0.0583116412,
-0.0181923285,
-0.0285558812,
-0.0076579498,
-0.0723351687,
0.0299394839,
-0.0063685398,
0.0371934064,
0.0118376622,
0.0195423961,
0.0008789748,
-0.0503593236,
-0.0288167968,
0.0055705351,
-0.0280383565,
-0.0450734906,
-0.0628073364,
-0.0337718949,
-0.0064042285,
-0.0282310341,
-0.0150436191,
3.160667833e-34,
0.026505325,
-0.0113338381,
0.0136650344,
0.0294138659,
0.0397618227,
-0.0643619895,
-0.0257269144,
0.0605026037,
0.04217669,
-0.0968198925,
-0.0408150479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09544v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09544v1 | Building blocks for complex tasks: Robust generative event extraction for radiology reports under domain shifts | 2023-06-15T23:16:58 | 2023-06-15T23:16:58 | Sitong Zhou, Meliha Yetisgen, Mari Ostendorf | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper explores methods for extracting information from radiology reports
that generalize across exam modalities to reduce requirements for annotated
data. We demonstrate that multi-pass T5-based text-to-text generative models
exhibit better generalization across exam modalities compared to approaches
that employ BERT-based task-specific classification layers. We then develop
methods that reduce the inference cost of the model, making large-scale corpus
processing more feasible for clinical applications. Specifically, we introduce
a generative technique that decomposes complex tasks into smaller subtask
blocks, which improves a single-pass model when combined with multitask
training. In addition, we leverage target-domain contexts during inference to
enhance domain adaptation, enabling use of smaller models. Analyses offer
insights into the benefits of different cost reduction strategies. | [
0.0250176862,
0.0336544774,
0.0190714169,
-0.015371345,
-0.0054534045,
0.0246050265,
0.0389803052,
0.0371720828,
0.0027213183,
-0.0254012346,
-0.0086070541,
-0.0560254864,
-0.0181697551,
0.0300367419,
0.0413014442,
-0.0959871411,
0.0116178831,
-0.0036449998,
-0.0254841819,
0.0309425984,
-0.0157026164,
0.0205578879,
-0.0138199255,
0.0209916513,
-0.0061775842,
0.0095263049,
0.0160855409,
0.0054054786,
0.0510053486,
-0.0315001681,
-0.0208607838,
0.050612431,
0.0408239849,
0.0183376055,
0.0000019176,
-0.024954861,
-0.0529352538,
0.0439784341,
-0.0091663413,
-0.0164316185,
0.0608594902,
-0.0455283411,
-0.0071116979,
0.0016716413,
-0.0076780231,
-0.0645687804,
0.0309961606,
0.0595956892,
0.0243384968,
0.0912701413,
-0.0343651697,
0.0287034102,
0.0037364818,
-0.0559951626,
-0.0031560455,
-0.0733985007,
0.0350014009,
-0.0254395418,
0.0182173159,
-0.0179758817,
0.0125303026,
0.0084842332,
0.0093222708,
0.0203785561,
0.0004644204,
0.0656950399,
0.0168302525,
0.0071224663,
0.0240054578,
0.0222470518,
-0.0170820411,
-0.0075868587,
0.045192562,
-0.012212065,
0.0000487865,
0.0208350085,
-0.049294468,
0.0003303882,
-0.0361346714,
-0.0172203537,
0.0028188205,
-0.0149278846,
-0.0056469557,
0.0028962877,
-0.0037206474,
-0.0517580733,
0.0186936632,
-0.0122579448,
0.010892801,
0.0622101426,
-0.0357775129,
-0.045990333,
0.0383404866,
0.004330426,
-0.0296723694,
0.0064257444,
-0.0670892075,
-0.0492471755,
0.0222882051,
-0.0475501828,
-0.026915729,
-0.0067394986,
-0.0411580056,
0.0314362384,
0.0049541122,
-0.0145904217,
-0.0456160419,
0.0241415426,
-0.0648148432,
-0.0078747282,
-0.0412736498,
0.010109121,
-0.0315706134,
0.0109697012,
-0.0141814761,
0.0243516415,
-0.0512227863,
-0.0027059258,
0.0200852249,
-0.014204504,
0.0224939492,
0.0443198569,
-0.1375732571,
0.0176298618,
0.0292637572,
0.0444157906,
-0.0027704481,
0.0061506112,
0.0087573845,
-0.0131635452,
-0.0313040465,
0.0307167489,
0.0242685806,
-0.0152131598,
-0.013671319,
0.0046642851,
-0.0254630968,
-0.0045907865,
-0.0384169556,
-0.0461182334,
-0.0336144529,
-0.0162430983,
0.0640398264,
-0.0362520553,
0.0341526121,
-0.0013214842,
0.0009302491,
-0.0388480797,
0.0059450064,
-0.0101747783,
0.0070979199,
0.0319415443,
-0.0044570011,
-0.0165801477,
0.0435851552,
0.0209717713,
0.0019269501,
0.0345520191,
0.0432551019,
0.0103766732,
-0.0154152783,
0.0046810037,
0.0001291452,
0.0334278978,
0.0176756214,
-0.0641933903,
0.0335977226,
-0.01157354,
0.0206284784,
0.0359757394,
0.037180569,
0.0009262996,
-0.0121727157,
0.0114543652,
0.0288990717,
0.0470250547,
0.0324174166,
-0.002224576,
0.0322515219,
-0.0444873273,
-0.035484463,
0.0184064917,
-0.0157821923,
0.0187061727,
0.0276447237,
0.0010251375,
-0.0443517976,
-0.0006297024,
-0.0264624804,
-0.0256573465,
-0.0268695503,
0.0223115887,
-0.0477571934,
0.0046467474,
0.0744668245,
-0.0100610899,
-0.0350817367,
0.0389923751,
0.0344770402,
-0.0376413539,
0.0405655243,
-0.0693552122,
-0.0166705046,
0.0456212498,
0.0441566668,
-0.0530729666,
-0.0417830572,
-0.0195889212,
0.0859395489,
0.0456883162,
0.0309899785,
-0.020401461,
0.0407346301,
-0.0410576612,
-0.0433267355,
0.0248026233,
0.0016030725,
-0.0116100358,
0.0132638644,
-0.0139200082,
-0.0231235623,
-0.0412820838,
-0.0107864067,
0.0508517213,
-0.0627620071,
-0.0558936149,
0.0048380806,
0.0188885555,
0.0093491236,
-0.0061519076,
-0.0398127958,
-0.0086173667,
0.0268158074,
-0.0313045904,
-0.0153429955,
0.0154617345,
-0.0535948016,
-0.0355328582,
0.0080788657,
-0.0377898067,
-0.0028187898,
0.0006803673,
-0.059868563,
-0.0136603555,
-0.0378102288,
-0.0123512736,
-0.0020216855,
-0.0095523009,
0.0111550689,
0.0747061819,
-0.0174124297,
-0.0251113698,
0.0547005944,
0.0108845243,
-0.0252002906,
0.0103129344,
-0.0102558751,
-0.0029435304,
-0.0501558483,
0.0011020853,
0.0216622297,
0.0031638991,
-0.0226223487,
-0.0017869069,
0.0249371324,
-0.0393546782,
-0.0342162251,
-0.0784255043,
0.012622714,
0.0121476986,
0.0330585726,
0.0353059582,
0.0364002883,
0.0039711809,
-0.0273526032,
-0.0500300713,
-0.0772983208,
0.0197416786,
0.0023962408,
0.0423065871,
0.03717421,
0.0288971476,
-0.0363031961,
-0.0125611192,
-0.0334354527,
0.0216071364,
0.0439352691,
-0.038302578,
-0.0142900366,
0.0534161888,
0.0279349536,
0.0288547948,
0.010510454,
-0.0003277067,
-0.0048979251,
-0.0459657125,
0.0221773628,
0.0692030787,
0.0107123163,
0.0413257219,
0.0063496567,
-0.0263864212,
-0.0203622635,
0.0338423066,
-0.0413277075,
-0.011699317,
0.0174523946,
-0.0522990711,
0.0051279771,
0.0491152182,
0.003281852,
-0.0046565309,
-0.0415663607,
-0.059262488,
-0.0298391301,
-0.0157108922,
0.0009497062,
0.0117791658,
-0.0287574995,
-0.000094749,
-0.0240168124,
-0.0102391783,
0.0956793949,
0.0100558,
0.004787609,
-0.093681924,
-0.0081034126,
-0.0149064669,
0.0600583069,
-0.0158712994,
0.0155427428,
0.0765386373,
-0.03075945,
-0.0396293066,
0.0277221799,
0.0300891493,
-0.0523399189,
0.0351631455,
-0.037958283,
0.0168909188,
-0.0506448485,
-0.0498396456,
-0.0342951901,
0.006650826,
0.0493641533,
0.0027607584,
-0.0129086161,
-0.0014356632,
-0.0677907541,
0.0207380187,
-0.01628487,
0.0722767636,
-0.0025228271,
-0.0146624483,
0.0034719978,
0.1089587957,
0.0530452654,
0.0190642998,
-0.0835084766,
-0.0516159832,
-0.0248993151,
0.0757130459,
0.0436853096,
0.0392869264,
-0.0022672268,
-0.0114364112,
-0.0003457542,
-0.0362492651,
-0.0144983837,
0.01863035,
0.0230742935,
-0.0669418499,
-0.0271620899,
0.0783082619,
0.0190726239,
-0.0126406644,
-0.0280985981,
0.0190489162,
-0.0131262839,
-0.0268216506,
0.0236703921,
-0.0423277505,
-0.0181904249,
-0.0018108073,
0.060756743,
0.0038701387,
-0.0249806363,
0.0236034673,
-0.0653380752,
0.0699992254,
-0.0005294238,
-0.0487127565,
-0.0405953079,
-0.0418902412,
0.0257712416,
-0.0151114175,
-0.0345357433,
-0.0188275073,
-0.0039805761,
-0.0005988517,
0.0653773546,
-0.030716829,
-0.1040521041,
0.0010680683,
-0.0415495373,
-0.0039833803,
0.0506955907,
0.0118431263,
-0.0163764078,
0.0055029411,
-0.0131629296,
0.0124849472,
-0.01527608,
0.0023222687,
0.0973407403,
0.0001450602,
0.0085088033,
-0.0341760144,
0.0542901158,
0.007484518,
-0.0117422603,
-0.0121557182,
0.0796033144,
0.0076794866,
-0.0200499035,
-0.0411040075,
0.0138062825,
0.0284547135,
0.0461176261,
-0.009914251,
-0.0290650744,
-0.0141271502,
-0.0018391263,
0.0663452819,
-0.0925084725,
-0.0134051563,
0.0177798849,
-0.0639400184,
-0.1105380282,
-0.0633615106,
-0.0222718418,
0.047885485,
0.0331635885,
-0.0086474195,
-0.009555744,
0.0103976047,
-0.0075165392,
-0.0564209595,
0.0655864328,
0.0092532253,
-0.0141921612,
-0.0284663364,
-0.0617186353,
0.0501159318,
-0.003028726,
-0.0255787075,
0.0910684913,
-0.0812761039,
-0.0053398274,
-0.0099578714,
0.0080902502,
0.0156123601,
0.0059040971,
0.0070421067,
0.0138352262,
0.0428553857,
0.0617020577,
-0.0106177432,
-0.0056623039,
0.0174951144,
-0.068666786,
-0.0252507702,
-0.002619525,
-0.048580572,
0.0324875526,
0.0240091849,
0.0310748592,
-0.0155691868,
-0.0242438838,
0.0244554877,
0.0087960828,
0.0416455902,
-0.0322228745,
-0.0293733478,
-0.0635445863,
-0.0060988618,
-0.0141888196,
0.0192172099,
-0.0348489396,
0.0257569011,
0.0269581638,
0.0158988815,
-0.0156124663,
0.076957114,
-0.0168042872,
0.009766398,
-0.0857637823,
0.0095490012,
0.043259576,
0.0016591462,
0.0250470228,
-0.0040376992,
-0.0360059142,
-0.0613715947,
0.0382323787,
0.0076946579,
-0.0323458724,
0.046205502,
0.0286355503,
0.0477327406,
0.0174469613,
0.0197632499,
-0.0520114675,
0.0383055583,
-0.0837315619,
0.0046657673,
0.0496885851,
0.010809266,
0.0416324399,
-0.0388807915,
-0.0033066191,
-0.0034482395,
0.0537963621,
0.0117356312,
0.029312497,
0.0283575114,
0.0024571235,
0.0367584676,
-0.0372130498,
0.1023809463,
-0.009170007,
0.0748366266,
-0.0211974643,
-0.0422188193,
-0.0545679629,
-0.0433929563,
0.0207004994,
-0.0224762857,
-0.0164614357,
-0.0095510473,
-0.0276594087,
-0.0306984559,
0.0497940183,
-0.0183793176,
-0.018102577,
-0.0373782255,
0.0494800285,
0.0477423333,
-0.0084296204,
-0.0464676097,
0.008607951,
0.0551683828,
0.0398224406,
-0.0172493774,
0.0024264615,
-5.967490009e-33,
-0.0420042239,
-0.0102901561,
0.0311658382,
-0.0048217741,
-0.0038464465,
0.0250635128,
-0.0304084439,
-0.0312882401,
0.031679526,
0.0009726454,
-0.0246848427,
0.0085149286,
0.0307862852,
0.0357506424,
0.020909708,
0.0063499548,
0.066521436,
-0.0288579632,
-0.0225475729,
0.0427541062,
0.0145482896,
0.0306239091,
0.0775404423,
-0.0800090358,
-0.0061942409,
0.0118525932,
0.0075394656,
-0.0435852334,
0.0318897441,
0.0307618957,
-0.0233006496,
0.0108010005,
0.031260848,
-0.0647404939,
-0.0009081023,
0.0287415702,
-0.1178614646,
0.0007086261,
-0.0049716276,
-0.0134195788,
-0.0260581151,
-0.0357263871,
0.026655443,
-0.0007140345,
0.0283933375,
-0.0698689073,
0.0470045097,
-0.0167559404,
-0.0007625311,
-0.0611498244,
-0.0524237007,
0.0555213317,
-0.0047498727,
-0.0347519182,
-0.0049178805,
0.0283579752,
-0.0123433182,
0.0122346329,
-0.0217316858,
-0.0043550609,
0.0392487086,
0.040024478,
0.0305691157,
-0.0091897789,
-0.046947021,
0.0242104325,
0.0142459739,
-0.0071511217,
-0.0090029491,
0.0022560908,
-0.0284154415,
0.038228333,
0.0148636606,
0.0373655409,
0.0363684967,
-0.0110474564,
-0.1192884371,
0.0743588209,
-0.0135394726,
0.0193653926,
0.0096746488,
-0.0095490813,
-0.0321698152,
0.0179637633,
0.0443613529,
-0.0161169712,
0.0183512997,
-0.0132126035,
0.0326528847,
0.0294539556,
0.0057739159,
0.0881558955,
0.0410030521,
0.0241717882,
0.0311890952,
-0.0279949829,
0.011837068,
0.0126589956,
-0.0412049927,
-0.001413317,
-0.0128722191,
-0.0119741596,
0.0658502355,
0.0259174872,
0.0220823381,
0.0073786695,
0.0306538101,
0.0232780557,
-0.0443589985,
-0.0016674494,
-0.0106885321,
0.0176757649,
-0.018732341,
0.081537202,
0.0362336263,
-0.0011155296,
0.0074325404,
0.0311330948,
-0.0222618785,
0.0140666189,
-0.0184672065,
-0.0216219239,
0.029007677,
0.0032588805,
-0.009889368,
-0.0091506084,
-0.0195327979,
0.0084535349,
0.0500910133,
-0.0159208011,
-0.0245665926,
0.0077668363,
2.653e-7,
0.0854663327,
0.0210026968,
0.0301145967,
0.0161842685,
0.008715773,
0.0009293222,
-0.0092756245,
0.0403726399,
0.0220927969,
0.0419222303,
0.0013383434,
-0.0258967988,
0.0345722027,
0.0604762323,
-0.0810792744,
-0.0597796068,
-0.0203584991,
0.0174870845,
-0.0153015936,
-0.0327119529,
0.0804242641,
0.0783889145,
-0.0306248255,
-0.0235892348,
0.0076102056,
-0.0329894125,
0.0473807305,
-0.0137083502,
0.0000387548,
0.0241671428,
0.0022217024,
0.0073205708,
-0.017389575,
0.061254967,
-0.0360549316,
-0.0139201721,
0.0399003625,
0.0973669514,
-0.0342750773,
0.0111549329,
0.0065227216,
-0.0069990098,
0.0188308302,
0.0080082603,
0.0432029963,
-0.0664210618,
-0.0032228183,
0.0238890145,
-0.030808486,
0.0025282847,
-0.0222312305,
-0.0204937682,
-0.0308839362,
0.0253679957,
0.0259910375,
0.0130457589,
-0.0643572658,
-0.0770088732,
0.002751149,
0.0279217288,
-0.0340952799,
-0.0408769511,
0.0381291471,
-0.0380592011,
-0.0044273166,
-0.0796834007,
-0.0059980904,
2.581007691e-34,
0.0175317079,
0.0241443478,
-0.0338388346,
0.0158121828,
0.015791934,
-0.0224544164,
0.0017773332,
-0.0093221404,
0.0047991849,
-0.0418070555,
-0.0403266065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09539v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09539v4 | Block-State Transformers | 2023-06-15T22:48:08 | 2023-10-30T15:44:04 | Mahan Fathi, Jonathan Pilault, Orhan Firat, Christopher Pal, Pierre-Luc Bacon, Ross Goroshin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | State space models (SSMs) have shown impressive results on tasks that require
modeling long-range dependencies and efficiently scale to long sequences owing
to their subquadratic runtime complexity. Originally designed for continuous
signals, SSMs have shown superior performance on a plethora of tasks, in vision
and audio; however, SSMs still lag Transformer performance in Language Modeling
tasks. In this work, we propose a hybrid layer named Block-State Transformer
(BST), that internally combines an SSM sublayer for long-range
contextualization, and a Block Transformer sublayer for short-term
representation of sequences. We study three different, and completely
parallelizable, variants that integrate SSMs and block-wise attention. We show
that our model outperforms similar Transformer-based architectures on language
modeling perplexity and generalizes to longer sequences. In addition, the
Block-State Transformer demonstrates more than tenfold increase in speed at the
layer level compared to the Block-Recurrent Transformer when model
parallelization is employed. | [
-0.0140334507,
0.0334016234,
-0.0019955563,
0.0337746888,
-0.0244661048,
0.0147552807,
0.0639675632,
-0.0284959693,
-0.0145837683,
-0.0256469008,
-0.0031938897,
-0.0897726938,
0.0243595168,
0.0302892849,
-0.0013991175,
-0.0939457566,
0.0310171116,
-0.0071068686,
-0.0276718009,
0.0143037476,
0.0141949058,
-0.026396323,
-0.0069576493,
0.0533802956,
0.0092619704,
-0.0352249444,
-0.0328896306,
-0.0351498872,
0.0314158425,
-0.0569436625,
-0.022963196,
0.0328967944,
0.0463190973,
0.0259363037,
0.0000019982,
-0.0036542043,
0.0137295155,
-0.0102820843,
0.011385669,
-0.0114991535,
-0.0139383059,
-0.0280170199,
-0.0079993447,
0.0025868369,
-0.0355826095,
-0.0389827862,
0.0648476928,
0.0478448831,
0.0564230382,
0.0581979789,
-0.011767094,
-0.0551393814,
0.012504749,
-0.0541576184,
-0.0200022589,
-0.0471095927,
0.0017852162,
-0.029114794,
0.0342458151,
0.0105301868,
-0.0708585382,
0.0597950779,
0.0534575135,
0.0227763914,
0.0199233815,
0.0174872465,
0.0326129608,
0.0003400828,
-0.0018146926,
0.0586848035,
-0.062538825,
-0.0152846025,
0.0013464477,
0.0043406938,
0.0003423606,
-0.006288623,
-0.0337138623,
0.0352321602,
-0.0047207186,
0.0101928012,
-0.019253999,
0.024148399,
0.0488274209,
-0.0146253342,
-0.0645343438,
0.0171506982,
-0.0051616635,
-0.0233792141,
-0.0630025342,
-0.0409372076,
-0.002042402,
-0.0705772415,
0.049286887,
0.0570582598,
-0.0004878151,
-0.0047138883,
-0.0231723431,
-0.0573568828,
-0.0332712941,
-0.0187277142,
0.0143618491,
0.0357318893,
-0.0282040928,
0.0558116622,
-0.021200221,
0.0501338579,
-0.0406963415,
0.0024735865,
-0.0175578594,
0.0107167345,
-0.0446561314,
0.0056840451,
-0.0392375588,
0.0043471153,
-0.0386632346,
-0.0612923428,
-0.0218885653,
0.0269244388,
-0.0306624472,
-0.0138839353,
-0.0246482491,
0.0254639145,
-0.0272706989,
-0.0118446741,
0.0181369409,
0.048974663,
0.0072622993,
0.012802748,
0.0145480614,
-0.0019576815,
-0.0553500541,
0.0400151908,
0.0211270358,
-0.0003735193,
-0.0270647854,
0.0327917971,
0.0039019813,
-0.0562926941,
-0.0305192675,
0.0273392051,
-0.0278797969,
-0.0360180438,
0.0261969566,
-0.0292742345,
0.0076347287,
0.0071475934,
0.010050443,
-0.0178915504,
0.012434761,
0.0305606704,
0.0174367018,
0.0708553493,
0.0187895782,
-0.0573311187,
-0.0245807935,
0.0423055403,
0.0410113111,
0.0174458381,
0.0551130101,
0.0218972247,
-0.0189172737,
-0.0637619719,
0.0282929279,
0.0347093791,
-0.0053902515,
-0.0129448436,
-0.0770236775,
-0.0175022501,
0.0170315765,
0.0318222903,
0.0370021723,
0.0464401431,
-0.0184243117,
-0.028035678,
0.0418473966,
0.0184646044,
0.0536654554,
0.0736311376,
0.0441506691,
0.0117898975,
-0.0335034654,
0.0074549653,
-0.0259160865,
0.0997269079,
0.0213747174,
0.0202802718,
0.0007906868,
0.0567734204,
-0.0346714593,
-0.0052842051,
-0.0193635002,
-0.0059996131,
0.0191370919,
0.034207847,
0.052197963,
0.0125154313,
-0.0731405392,
0.0680540353,
-0.0384601653,
-0.0451161973,
-0.0150993261,
-0.0290919431,
0.0122938342,
0.0627988949,
0.0184985958,
-0.0367367715,
0.0099442089,
-0.0368556008,
0.0102167409,
0.0548172221,
-0.037085671,
0.0216023885,
0.0343330875,
-0.0461697094,
-0.0380419232,
0.0418568254,
-0.0023231509,
0.0206743032,
-0.0000871659,
0.0062811961,
0.0284607206,
-0.0135314288,
0.0355357565,
0.0181545224,
-0.0237209331,
0.0052248389,
0.0066857026,
-0.005635472,
0.0292535666,
0.022376636,
-0.0029383034,
0.019882679,
0.0303707607,
-0.0620163903,
-0.011843075,
0.0221633371,
-0.1170668229,
-0.0551154055,
0.0095048323,
0.0039287149,
0.0331997797,
0.0877107456,
-0.0271966085,
-0.0649211556,
0.0575669743,
-0.0674920455,
0.0416957736,
-0.0347302333,
0.0113735078,
0.0279543698,
0.0767833889,
-0.0197969731,
0.0185928829,
-0.0316717885,
-0.0059889182,
0.0121554248,
0.0264215413,
-0.0200179182,
0.0006691812,
-0.0150919259,
0.0159348324,
-0.0233455878,
-0.0091864085,
-0.0208465066,
-0.046046637,
-0.0031145748,
0.0089030564,
-0.0474279448,
-0.0301552005,
-0.0330097042,
0.005770274,
-0.0003659291,
0.058269158,
0.0351893455,
-0.0034727808,
-0.0226337053,
-0.0052175429,
0.0091853896,
-0.0022233783,
-0.0028599664,
0.0095245922,
-0.0732359886,
-0.038325876,
-0.012962536,
0.0288996939,
0.0461134687,
-0.0529738702,
-0.0222766306,
-0.0435719825,
-0.0051179421,
0.0259462502,
0.0483895168,
-0.0305837691,
-0.0168829449,
-0.0075923242,
-0.0213800464,
0.0313499458,
0.0387134664,
0.0334833674,
0.0289849713,
0.0334536284,
-0.0367668867,
0.0196625385,
0.0430943742,
-0.0210038386,
0.0804337338,
-0.04065191,
0.0183854382,
-0.0141172418,
0.0833872333,
0.0044974321,
0.0009475526,
-0.0444500968,
-0.0349101163,
0.0236992519,
0.0159561932,
0.0179540794,
-0.026865622,
-0.0419830419,
0.0188085344,
-0.0218544956,
-0.0302352197,
0.0514967032,
-0.0645233318,
-0.0173218939,
-0.0026157217,
-0.0224289168,
-0.0412730277,
0.0640875474,
0.0046564783,
-0.01871855,
-0.0461929664,
-0.0030373684,
-0.0027832827,
0.0134523148,
-0.034870252,
-0.013611868,
0.0657744929,
-0.0317310281,
0.0114466129,
-0.009846543,
-0.003366173,
-0.0432064757,
0.0107049169,
-0.0367990658,
0.0170798805,
0.0531314313,
-0.0289338306,
-0.0514632724,
0.0605944619,
0.0342781134,
0.0737101212,
0.0037521762,
0.0212824419,
-0.0101332627,
0.0618900806,
0.0326316021,
0.0319419801,
0.05550294,
0.0070428853,
0.0733633786,
0.0519050732,
0.0406857654,
0.0054508192,
-0.0740719661,
-0.0087109106,
0.0328613445,
-0.0027626655,
-0.0056612431,
0.0369549952,
0.0245233513,
-0.095440805,
-0.0537877865,
0.0911600143,
0.0178134367,
-0.0567038842,
0.0100848088,
0.0070678019,
-0.0046258103,
0.0162847284,
-0.0074112178,
-0.0524208881,
-0.0445591286,
-0.0086051989,
-0.0213771183,
0.0288248342,
0.0000958963,
-0.0040269722,
-0.041944962,
0.021854477,
0.0263343696,
-0.0502922088,
-0.044807706,
-0.0316552967,
-0.0014695773,
0.0338703096,
0.0021748899,
0.0142353987,
-0.0262166075,
-0.0226339567,
0.0167682972,
-0.0293346476,
-0.0201783217,
0.040150255,
-0.0027602708,
0.0335252695,
0.0896118954,
-0.0065739816,
-0.0088010877,
-0.0686919242,
0.0226302706,
-0.0288074277,
0.0075652013,
-0.0080616875,
-0.0206847005,
0.0025237575,
-0.0161070805,
-0.0033159943,
-0.0022712278,
-0.0477806143,
-0.0253681485,
-0.0173265263,
0.0634734184,
-0.0341047645,
0.004876839,
-0.0415887758,
0.0414071791,
-0.0013801377,
0.0493796468,
0.0671050027,
-0.0194075145,
-0.0511034131,
0.0017727372,
-0.0149197457,
-0.1052101627,
0.0183481891,
-0.0135752494,
0.0470475964,
-0.0144873494,
-0.0182117894,
-0.0074732928,
0.0027688262,
0.0236202758,
-0.0032921617,
-0.010082379,
0.0393198468,
0.0120959766,
-0.056227725,
0.0184249729,
-0.0024103208,
0.0497105457,
-0.015286088,
0.0084268739,
0.0113191409,
-0.0228329897,
-0.0263661705,
0.0419060662,
-0.1309124827,
-0.0277420506,
0.0391949601,
0.0128749972,
0.0113045424,
0.0326475538,
0.0117075993,
-0.0024348043,
0.0210395064,
0.0253686421,
-0.0073669115,
0.0229114946,
0.0176159758,
-0.0285986755,
0.0055526197,
0.0243892875,
-0.0157389976,
0.0433914475,
0.0135706058,
0.0183246024,
-0.0262441747,
-0.0143915862,
-0.0359255113,
-0.0819241926,
0.0402533747,
0.0347171873,
0.0164381173,
0.0294719897,
0.0228013583,
-0.0073468806,
0.0327019133,
-0.050439477,
-0.0213061757,
0.0196678471,
-0.0042198454,
0.0205076989,
0.016098151,
0.016770184,
-0.029221924,
-0.012169159,
0.0486182161,
-0.0534334555,
-0.0441994816,
0.0004851169,
0.0028606211,
-0.0002770182,
-0.0103066107,
0.0209477637,
0.0186324138,
-0.0021313822,
0.0886411667,
0.0050395518,
0.0193256699,
-0.0282989312,
0.0307781175,
-0.0796620846,
-0.0128998216,
-0.0158267096,
-0.0469075851,
0.0540570877,
-0.0454620942,
0.0141163617,
0.0203862172,
0.0280439723,
-0.0199879706,
0.0486276895,
-0.025334239,
-0.0688399747,
0.0452477075,
0.0283517446,
0.00290502,
-0.0147586558,
0.0716009662,
0.0235972758,
0.0229170024,
0.0114304991,
-0.0091577312,
-0.0275630001,
-0.0478248335,
-0.0165292267,
0.0587458313,
-0.0167400502,
-0.0005259789,
-0.0479587875,
-0.0745073184,
0.0472027436,
-0.0372090861,
0.0377186388,
-0.0473692343,
0.028102193,
0.0156260226,
0.0090940855,
-0.024584949,
-0.0057722428,
0.0087612476,
0.0229722727,
-0.0517434329,
-0.022258291,
-6.126898431e-33,
-0.0187212527,
-0.0223035123,
0.0238915514,
-0.055554077,
-0.065772146,
-0.0064728851,
-0.0608011633,
0.0037721861,
-0.0076086298,
-0.0151816634,
-0.0053080958,
0.0330061801,
0.0039279363,
0.0771068633,
0.0135008926,
-0.0417454019,
0.0570030659,
0.0146565707,
0.0297484174,
0.0421249308,
0.0330459438,
0.0499666035,
0.0464864671,
-0.0137212267,
-0.0340985395,
-0.0075705997,
0.0147892768,
-0.0211889762,
-0.0058349501,
0.0170986112,
-0.0464794487,
0.0043548672,
0.0308023803,
-0.1024165079,
-0.0243891831,
0.0442950763,
-0.0445524454,
0.0326016545,
0.0010559692,
0.0107136657,
-0.0524720401,
-0.0255205408,
0.0582683422,
0.0251569897,
0.0210749563,
-0.030865727,
0.029730523,
-0.0388265625,
-0.0470788777,
-0.0146949738,
-0.0387693793,
0.0096309455,
-0.0357227325,
-0.0202573743,
0.0472637266,
0.0230506174,
-0.0469502285,
0.0450307727,
-0.0788169131,
-0.0332510285,
0.0084626665,
0.0736498237,
0.0580625683,
0.0541096143,
0.0296625663,
0.0209753234,
-0.0026577942,
-0.0612058192,
-0.0549581423,
0.0199883264,
0.0329248346,
0.0238317344,
0.0550841801,
-0.0228231158,
0.0168584976,
0.0034320557,
-0.0510293171,
-0.0360293575,
-0.0353206396,
0.0615503155,
0.0363539904,
0.0187957883,
-0.0118185803,
-0.0155584728,
0.0094249193,
-0.0029569108,
-0.0265102554,
0.0064616101,
0.0275195111,
0.019991219,
0.028676495,
0.025134448,
0.062994428,
-0.0106745902,
0.0268012621,
-0.003905437,
0.023504924,
0.0201778673,
0.0314842686,
-0.0127028776,
-0.0363606364,
0.0008805127,
0.0296330173,
0.016099168,
-0.0025606197,
-0.0225185156,
0.0159394927,
0.0308601782,
-0.0683429837,
-0.0408768058,
-0.055910144,
0.033646699,
-0.0078189643,
0.059893392,
0.0327376463,
0.0085958028,
-0.0142563684,
0.0683594942,
-0.043587748,
-0.0364161581,
-0.0144361826,
-0.0050711888,
-0.0157539491,
0.030156495,
-0.0389685109,
-0.0244019236,
-0.0519398376,
0.0108329291,
0.0264572948,
-0.0792890266,
-0.0181099493,
0.0401432887,
2.656e-7,
0.0048538935,
0.0141830994,
0.0338682346,
0.0021639236,
0.0456956625,
0.0239883792,
0.003452485,
0.0227064993,
-0.0056676441,
0.0232154299,
0.0037485189,
0.0118066603,
0.0468920767,
-0.0250243228,
-0.0966675878,
0.0099667599,
-0.0639436319,
0.0314030908,
-0.0214665979,
-0.0024738498,
0.0305336788,
0.0984716043,
-0.0021461351,
0.0065077832,
0.0287294798,
-0.0057362681,
0.0414317958,
0.0119260699,
0.050231982,
-0.0255991984,
-0.010649411,
0.0128341457,
-0.0328200087,
0.0137461154,
-0.0118619865,
0.0251592118,
-0.0168390423,
0.0555968806,
0.0231984556,
-0.0389552303,
0.0076729259,
0.040984381,
-0.014648363,
-0.0710673332,
0.0455951393,
-0.0462758951,
-0.0086940192,
-0.0191130694,
-0.0385750569,
0.0168935955,
-0.0343516171,
0.0377688557,
0.0180718433,
-0.0051407772,
0.0057681133,
-0.0285545606,
0.0236481354,
-0.0927525088,
-0.0277027786,
-0.0245042313,
-0.0999787077,
0.0155091491,
-0.0774137005,
-0.0250715297,
0.0677279681,
-0.0016552081,
-0.0458444655,
2.625236814e-34,
0.0199824087,
-0.0234857593,
-0.0154548921,
0.0258563757,
-0.0130836051,
-0.020449331,
0.0125008868,
0.0135042071,
0.0102917161,
-0.096099183,
-0.0390910804
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.