id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14517v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14517v1 | Cross-Lingual Cross-Age Group Adaptation for Low-Resource Elderly Speech Emotion Recognition | 2023-06-26T08:48:08 | 2023-06-26T08:48:08 | Samuel Cahyawijaya, Holy Lovenia, Willy Chung, Rita Frieske, Zihan Liu, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech emotion recognition plays a crucial role in human-computer
interactions. However, most speech emotion recognition research is biased
toward English-speaking adults, which hinders its applicability to other
demographic groups in different languages and age groups. In this work, we
analyze the transferability of emotion recognition across three different
languages--English, Mandarin Chinese, and Cantonese; and 2 different age
groups--adults and the elderly. To conduct the experiment, we develop an
English-Mandarin speech emotion benchmark for adults and the elderly, BiMotion,
and a Cantonese speech emotion dataset, YueMotion. This study concludes that
different language and age groups require specific speech features, thus making
cross-lingual inference an unsuitable method. However, cross-group data
augmentation is still beneficial to regularize the model, with linguistic
distance being a significant influence on cross-lingual transferability. We
release publicly release our code at https://github.com/HLTCHKUST/elderly_ser. | [
0.0009329548,
0.0784326047,
0.0011462469,
0.041372899,
0.0321161672,
0.024239134,
0.0490514673,
0.0090259984,
0.0535179973,
0.0072514405,
-0.1047457308,
-0.042217128,
0.0199768916,
-0.007901486,
-0.01238201,
-0.1199083105,
0.0161452107,
0.0171419326,
0.0823275149,
-0.0201805532,
-0.0003330759,
0.0097064069,
-0.0154697178,
0.028575765,
-0.0392829105,
0.0075766509,
-0.0037793773,
0.0300285742,
0.0532053411,
-0.0210429821,
0.0356763974,
0.0217988044,
0.0289870743,
0.0006200694,
0.0000019566,
-0.0343238562,
0.0196686368,
0.0064047845,
-0.0033440357,
0.0054599559,
0.0964632928,
0.0194440968,
-0.0488398001,
-0.018233642,
-0.0315355137,
-0.0244583599,
0.071866788,
0.0320654437,
0.0494330712,
0.0612177923,
-0.0428245701,
0.0348532498,
-0.0344430059,
-0.0084621217,
0.0341344886,
-0.0624158531,
0.0172583796,
0.0252015144,
-0.0162703786,
-0.0933269933,
-0.0323366039,
-0.0000473612,
-0.018082222,
0.0341522694,
0.0056446581,
-0.0357868001,
-0.032269828,
-0.0070217727,
-0.0206122492,
0.0545097105,
-0.0049809758,
0.0475687869,
-0.0300401766,
0.0239094924,
0.0086933998,
-0.0088793319,
-0.0494507328,
-0.0333663635,
0.0282929111,
0.0152242566,
-0.0209843274,
0.0222676601,
0.0091659483,
-0.0094292453,
-0.0037430408,
0.0333999433,
-0.0216027889,
-0.0194142312,
0.0457371734,
-0.0015115112,
-0.0202190615,
0.0524483882,
0.0422674678,
-0.0083658528,
0.0021632533,
0.0016520483,
-0.031527888,
-0.02121461,
-0.0530400909,
-0.0467482582,
-0.0501113385,
0.0114731388,
-0.0970546454,
0.0399081931,
0.0034355184,
0.0007752054,
0.0086743608,
-0.0716643706,
-0.0446633361,
-0.0367992446,
-0.0219328534,
0.0269159339,
-0.0107103009,
0.006482943,
-0.0181567613,
-0.0205842163,
-0.1134064272,
-0.0303040966,
-0.0518038385,
-0.0306564309,
-0.0166886169,
0.0061611095,
-0.0034673414,
-0.0022989144,
0.0009454888,
0.0830952674,
-0.0321846232,
0.0636301786,
-0.0111839995,
-0.1174668297,
0.0231056828,
0.0364597216,
0.0134727443,
-0.0580560677,
0.0454671085,
0.0243867878,
-0.0428571813,
0.0507678092,
-0.0732240081,
0.0138649503,
-0.03903649,
-0.0438633822,
0.0423615649,
-0.0318504609,
0.0277679507,
-0.01952908,
0.0619216636,
-0.0477124751,
-0.0243029185,
-0.0444199033,
-0.0474601723,
0.0480175391,
0.0102818906,
0.0065687094,
0.0165758356,
-0.0032490799,
0.0147333834,
0.0337418728,
0.0428666174,
-0.0133221662,
0.0539115407,
-0.0357206427,
-0.0079829628,
0.0518814921,
-0.0062808963,
0.0285601988,
-0.0162818246,
-0.0302961133,
-0.0012081496,
-0.0051209289,
0.0578308366,
-0.00450418,
0.0000690193,
-0.0231852382,
0.0272580776,
0.0823108107,
-0.0210003667,
0.0474782735,
-0.0343326479,
-0.0106384838,
0.0050708964,
-0.0321532637,
-0.0143802697,
0.0433596298,
0.0023915323,
-0.040250212,
-0.0020547686,
0.0458159633,
-0.0393467657,
-0.0356087163,
-0.0056172735,
-0.0263648238,
0.0102461344,
0.0154300332,
0.0291981101,
-0.0023379026,
0.0223837011,
0.0140355201,
0.0229934081,
-0.099777475,
0.008556826,
-0.0605419651,
-0.0290664025,
0.0537568852,
-0.0431445092,
-0.0321430936,
0.012843865,
0.0306276157,
0.0031673785,
-0.0144439209,
0.0341850035,
0.0152888931,
0.0825890526,
-0.0674062446,
0.0047792951,
0.0548753515,
0.004919325,
0.0205861516,
0.0027957887,
0.0470193326,
0.0097504174,
-0.0151622472,
0.0320606455,
-0.0140908435,
-0.0628062636,
-0.021865014,
0.0231497623,
0.033381518,
0.0621145256,
0.0287928693,
-0.0079519656,
-0.0310017634,
0.003342598,
-0.0136010908,
0.0339596607,
0.0636404157,
-0.0162020735,
-0.0289329216,
0.0340647772,
-0.032073468,
0.0187015254,
0.0109726535,
-0.0322671086,
-0.040000502,
0.0822238475,
0.0370033309,
0.008184446,
-0.0404828787,
0.0243484676,
-0.0176131669,
0.0167530365,
0.0533569567,
0.0378174186,
0.0401796587,
-0.0360675566,
-0.0028734617,
-0.0187371541,
-0.001471165,
-0.0521265604,
-0.0618127994,
0.0186542086,
-0.0162373353,
0.0014378383,
-0.0101296287,
-0.0085710343,
-0.0410054885,
-0.0018212283,
-0.0723214447,
-0.0166129544,
0.009846719,
-0.0010595758,
-0.0430011488,
0.0119556906,
-0.0333993658,
-0.0375356898,
-0.054476656,
0.0416430086,
-0.0316607393,
0.0013035063,
-0.0277418215,
-0.0315937512,
0.0239352491,
-0.0350630134,
-0.0012540818,
0.0092029897,
0.0275210887,
-0.0330552049,
-0.0544335246,
0.0270074904,
-0.0120173907,
-0.0206253044,
0.041282393,
-0.0352726355,
-0.0432834476,
-0.0303290747,
0.0084780864,
0.0173915084,
0.0503792055,
-0.027500093,
0.0422500744,
0.0192074645,
-0.0301925577,
0.0225520432,
0.0566533767,
0.0135369999,
0.022969516,
-0.0182928778,
-0.0279053003,
-0.0383967571,
0.0200769324,
0.0006922162,
0.0081758527,
-0.0509266257,
-0.0463947468,
-0.0048184916,
-0.0285474267,
-0.0170400254,
0.0031661068,
-0.0146708461,
-0.0317199714,
0.0019893977,
-0.0497012734,
0.0297372043,
0.0148274666,
-0.0493212193,
-0.0466185398,
-0.0130248517,
-0.0359265506,
0.0634804443,
-0.0798708275,
0.005208415,
-0.0016918713,
-0.0189153235,
-0.0531796291,
-0.0098485062,
-0.0166317895,
-0.0710580051,
0.0549070984,
-0.0217673983,
-0.0442907587,
0.0074017104,
-0.0285720173,
0.0129268942,
-0.0010354661,
-0.060130775,
0.0265542585,
0.0079667047,
-0.0310731661,
-0.0287039969,
0.0020809565,
0.0708886012,
-0.0039901477,
-0.0051867878,
0.0277243052,
0.0267515425,
0.0099516967,
0.0164271444,
0.0594678298,
-0.0449614823,
-0.0188503433,
0.023103347,
0.0153700393,
0.0750104189,
-0.0260545351,
-0.0120801786,
0.0570190139,
0.0274225194,
0.0506551638,
-0.0282436255,
-0.0068677496,
0.0675168857,
-0.0060320687,
0.0925672427,
0.0608073883,
0.0133252647,
-0.0623551235,
0.0033675733,
-0.0702572167,
0.0272643771,
0.0212276615,
-0.0059110071,
-0.0136703895,
-0.0428081304,
0.0154076535,
0.0250467658,
0.0190464314,
0.0200340971,
-0.0143050812,
-0.0499412157,
0.0491065569,
0.0441333428,
-0.0349908061,
-0.0166914985,
0.0060305544,
0.0206870884,
-0.0268089715,
0.0504922792,
-0.0432384349,
-0.0231563468,
-0.046237763,
0.063271068,
-0.0468561463,
-0.0586360544,
0.0316464305,
-0.017078653,
0.0718929619,
0.0065136771,
0.0729343221,
-0.01381661,
-0.0241196994,
0.0184546188,
-0.0138705596,
-0.0015488777,
-0.0225291569,
0.054117322,
0.0289722662,
-0.0126115903,
0.013983679,
0.0247817729,
-0.039770633,
-0.009817984,
0.0584656708,
0.0101608811,
0.0037201254,
-0.0096607478,
0.0146788768,
0.0280354787,
0.0206175037,
0.0565699115,
-0.0060745673,
-0.0311240815,
0.0045113028,
0.0153771034,
0.0009841894,
0.0310970563,
-0.0193724912,
0.0350878499,
-0.0369122587,
-0.0620180964,
-0.0512809679,
-0.0004756983,
0.0219670571,
0.0366659611,
-0.0040432983,
-0.0356088653,
0.0002971134,
0.017150186,
-0.0082486663,
0.0533302017,
-0.0050678831,
0.0458984822,
-0.0289620925,
-0.025925478,
-0.0284989569,
-0.0360269956,
-0.0006619164,
-0.0034353589,
0.0126222176,
-0.0264738481,
0.0471252389,
-0.0043375436,
0.0108360415,
0.0438285768,
0.0063537522,
-0.0234548394,
0.0430879593,
0.0261996631,
0.0214663502,
0.0085875792,
0.0754990131,
0.0208157226,
-0.0246722493,
0.0114564551,
-0.0421221778,
0.0298789982,
0.0082913823,
-0.0110200532,
-0.0225170404,
-0.0505527481,
-0.0347251631,
0.0362899266,
-0.0077738077,
0.0037379677,
-0.0284584612,
-0.0195755344,
0.0413642526,
0.015760161,
0.0431712009,
-0.0684877783,
-0.0691184923,
0.0250858478,
0.0009162333,
0.0003000697,
-0.0255422741,
0.0100580044,
-0.0790567845,
-0.0417674482,
0.0634682178,
0.0129421204,
0.060372889,
-0.0131378341,
0.0403624438,
0.0007929616,
-0.0033018778,
0.0013646628,
-0.0023114672,
-0.0099298516,
0.0349616036,
-0.016065266,
-0.0538518988,
0.0238974839,
-0.0106283883,
-0.0142766405,
0.0308580231,
-0.0250637978,
-0.0415588319,
0.0261022467,
-0.0365828611,
0.0790911913,
-0.0403961167,
0.0431866199,
-0.0284528621,
-0.0215731934,
-0.0102305915,
-0.0311611164,
-0.0216320064,
-0.0220147055,
-0.0273211766,
0.0392339602,
0.0439364575,
-0.0092677735,
0.0294721983,
-0.0006570084,
-0.009026641,
-0.0327733196,
-0.0108922059,
0.1029687077,
-0.0433855318,
-0.0343042091,
0.0274147075,
-0.0131309619,
-0.0526065305,
-0.0048042117,
-0.0740722492,
0.0130187273,
-0.0098955436,
0.0147451814,
0.0296165794,
-0.0696951374,
-0.0028065697,
-0.0269112997,
-0.0361040272,
-0.0590661131,
0.0250419434,
0.0323091075,
-6.289316485e-33,
0.0112040499,
0.0346944965,
-0.042367585,
-0.0130474642,
-0.0299980305,
0.0071344865,
-0.0379791819,
0.0180599764,
-0.0343500711,
0.0325278565,
0.0173329916,
0.0094630271,
0.0251820609,
0.0329860263,
-0.0170525108,
-0.0257504247,
0.0590715036,
0.0136384517,
0.0427449569,
0.0016832125,
0.035677053,
0.0237455741,
0.0781994164,
-0.0849500746,
0.0334428363,
0.0434997976,
-0.0411696285,
0.0085217785,
0.0828009471,
0.0514814928,
-0.0271372627,
0.0596594103,
-0.0027923749,
0.0072765532,
0.0207230803,
0.0135737369,
-0.0685468018,
0.0041458448,
-0.0002414829,
0.0548369512,
0.0338595249,
-0.007006532,
-0.0145695098,
0.0508671477,
0.006001154,
-0.0326785818,
0.0263678879,
-0.0509895347,
0.0268367399,
-0.0380552337,
-0.0337487273,
0.0305357389,
-0.0195568986,
0.0022121218,
0.0295569431,
0.0740420297,
-0.0522862785,
-0.0027860894,
-0.0049819862,
0.0122655481,
0.0058045285,
0.0347350761,
0.0240753125,
0.0177384801,
0.0023468952,
0.0331464261,
0.0322956406,
-0.0376724228,
0.0059906845,
-0.013590984,
0.0292085819,
0.0473443232,
0.0146464603,
0.0323384516,
0.0348391868,
-0.0290977359,
-0.0054977457,
0.0151005965,
0.0663919076,
0.0233977903,
0.0322978124,
0.0386554748,
-0.0019264513,
0.0093932096,
-0.0090162354,
0.0205644872,
-0.034945596,
-0.0313094221,
-0.0089967456,
-0.0164387915,
-0.0010759538,
-0.0251488704,
0.0242037605,
-0.0152556356,
-0.0087033501,
0.0002721668,
-0.0187427271,
0.0302165058,
0.0124797747,
0.0232077874,
0.0118073244,
-0.0549651459,
0.0684548318,
0.0168259982,
0.0529039092,
-0.0140010118,
0.0079006413,
0.066504918,
-0.0747862458,
-0.0178129524,
0.0134136407,
-0.0060305325,
0.0139800506,
0.0418924615,
-0.0301385,
-0.0012771664,
-0.0124606285,
0.0166003332,
-0.0186936203,
0.0330581367,
-0.0118071921,
-0.0352855176,
-0.0136362351,
0.0185591765,
-0.0539328493,
0.0132826231,
-0.0165461712,
-0.0437729768,
0.0202609487,
-0.016500758,
-0.0204091929,
0.0017177388,
2.81e-7,
-0.0451445766,
0.0248422585,
-0.0024868401,
-0.0828643441,
0.0240345132,
0.0348894484,
-0.0615002066,
0.0112122679,
0.0260321815,
0.0107017597,
0.058407411,
-0.0020017843,
0.1267615259,
0.0476751104,
-0.0889336765,
-0.032935109,
-0.0492512025,
-0.016376134,
0.012545947,
0.0750766918,
0.0174284168,
0.070529975,
-0.0038099387,
-0.0092246989,
0.0079845851,
-0.0213884022,
0.0054010949,
-0.0777584985,
-0.0039127022,
-0.0044154557,
-0.0064931796,
-0.0261296332,
0.0118567087,
0.0292274058,
-0.0404750519,
0.0425883457,
0.0527421646,
0.0609574169,
-0.0169507544,
-0.0566450693,
-0.0138704805,
0.0836770311,
-0.0221176073,
-0.0004940543,
0.0413355939,
0.0154519314,
-0.0702693239,
-0.0390182398,
-0.0314446203,
0.0031655626,
0.036707487,
-0.0312053878,
-0.0111790234,
0.0122644529,
0.0309589542,
0.012569163,
-0.0682536215,
-0.0344200842,
0.0009432907,
0.0137307653,
-0.0610801913,
-0.0670217052,
-0.0237125531,
0.0119455094,
0.0036517226,
0.0059847538,
0.0159045774,
1.81131672e-34,
-0.0039424826,
-0.0135217169,
-0.0153165264,
0.0004962265,
0.0100156413,
-0.0230848975,
0.00863255,
0.0191979464,
0.0225437805,
-0.0210072119,
-0.0062741274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14514v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14514v2 | Data-Driven Approach for Formality-Sensitive Machine Translation: Language-Specific Handling and Synthetic Data Generation | 2023-06-26T08:45:47 | 2023-06-27T06:59:28 | Seugnjun Lee, Hyeonseok Moon, Chanjun Park, Heuiseok Lim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this paper, we introduce a data-driven approach for Formality-Sensitive
Machine Translation (FSMT) that caters to the unique linguistic properties of
four target languages. Our methodology centers on two core strategies: 1)
language-specific data handling, and 2) synthetic data generation using
large-scale language models and empirical prompt engineering. This approach
demonstrates a considerable improvement over the baseline, highlighting the
effectiveness of data-centric techniques. Our prompt engineering strategy
further improves performance by producing superior synthetic translation
examples. | [
0.0104802977,
0.0500514545,
-0.0362615287,
0.0638302863,
-0.0253617465,
-0.0211649332,
0.0019539176,
-0.0156315751,
-0.0382038988,
-0.0063737873,
0.0085629644,
-0.0378808379,
-0.0135635296,
0.0561776683,
0.0205269009,
-0.0225902684,
0.0461103581,
-0.0265659485,
-0.0087805744,
-0.0149349878,
-0.0120926974,
0.0076496154,
0.0603078604,
-0.027350368,
-0.0148965288,
0.0034897078,
-0.0258038994,
0.0542478375,
0.0157538652,
-0.017535232,
-0.0144003974,
0.0634056106,
0.0228826683,
0.0748196244,
0.0000018295,
-0.0365429707,
-0.0283668004,
0.0285353828,
0.0119929388,
0.0176814627,
0.015169438,
-0.0652013943,
-0.0152010703,
0.0199077763,
-0.0352589786,
-0.0480834693,
0.0530430079,
-0.0513798222,
0.0831545293,
0.0928236768,
-0.034251485,
-0.0093955565,
0.0291979574,
-0.0187731255,
-0.0280863903,
0.008342687,
-0.0193127785,
-0.0074625351,
-0.0313240439,
0.0498913974,
0.0009746149,
0.0522506014,
0.0060689789,
-0.0268253963,
-0.0262218006,
-0.0326050781,
-0.0009640066,
-0.0230809413,
-0.0324729495,
0.0655883625,
0.0069710603,
-0.0316841938,
-0.0144863855,
-0.0071697184,
-0.009377839,
-0.0248916466,
-0.0098867677,
-0.0023808465,
-0.0166559573,
-0.0111724157,
0.04299004,
0.0445883833,
0.0225244649,
-0.0084936889,
-0.0450535417,
0.0224785134,
0.0544214137,
-0.0261494815,
-0.0434166417,
-0.0205307174,
0.0274654813,
-0.0261140559,
0.0193812661,
-0.0116472477,
-0.0333597139,
0.0123171369,
-0.0468186252,
-0.0553399138,
0.0118371351,
-0.0472243652,
0.0390489325,
0.0579685457,
0.0001070448,
-0.0073876875,
-0.0034478013,
0.0194820724,
-0.0376135968,
0.0194277354,
-0.0590956248,
-0.0053480957,
0.0125666633,
0.02719157,
-0.0496739931,
-0.0337554626,
-0.0702859759,
0.0376364663,
0.0067332722,
0.06990356,
-0.0001529619,
0.0347106904,
0.0119375456,
-0.0622836165,
-0.0892786831,
0.0050413888,
0.018393727,
-0.0320019796,
-0.0010449638,
-0.0431205258,
-0.0067598145,
-0.0551345721,
-0.0061448873,
-0.0041560484,
-0.0020286301,
-0.0116423303,
-0.0266545638,
0.0676002428,
0.0100761801,
0.030941762,
-0.0019788111,
-0.0281250626,
0.0150572313,
-0.0189208984,
0.0130433654,
-0.0735228881,
0.0623344518,
0.0204870217,
0.0067963693,
-0.0549599677,
-0.011541903,
0.004879341,
0.0148200393,
0.0572229698,
-0.0519425049,
0.0041684406,
-0.0030106101,
-0.0176252276,
0.0227026269,
0.0656429678,
0.0372059457,
0.0265998393,
0.0690142959,
-0.0197773036,
-0.0275045596,
0.0837819055,
0.010871348,
0.0464521572,
-0.0661798641,
0.0540029965,
0.0456037372,
0.0174618531,
0.0235821251,
0.0648105741,
0.0125825163,
0.0298300087,
0.0372391567,
-0.0135163637,
0.0075375484,
0.030003773,
0.0875405818,
0.0082128029,
0.0040280554,
0.0044758706,
0.0060181189,
-0.0240054,
-0.0154121574,
0.0191983506,
0.0021578372,
0.0495399721,
0.002429971,
-0.0263053924,
-0.0054105865,
0.0232918356,
-0.0239201691,
-0.016134616,
0.0134417554,
0.0401738398,
-0.0428636447,
0.010658103,
-0.0286000296,
-0.0665560141,
0.0128746592,
0.0177193247,
-0.0375244506,
0.0820572078,
0.0480282605,
-0.0290943738,
-0.0277665444,
-0.0039832559,
0.0109744398,
0.0748772249,
0.0725151896,
-0.0207942575,
-0.004916972,
-0.0330355391,
-0.0074250954,
0.0090643475,
0.0128610712,
0.0437822528,
-0.0042233653,
0.0250777304,
0.0336309113,
-0.0089625362,
-0.1028302386,
0.0424257517,
-0.0397593044,
-0.041613806,
0.0373107195,
-0.0091476087,
0.030608369,
0.0272668973,
-0.0061414414,
0.0184646677,
0.0133066876,
-0.0360080302,
0.0235075448,
0.0241304003,
-0.0201553516,
-0.049631875,
0.0199645329,
-0.0113262516,
-0.0179374963,
-0.0109731238,
-0.0550572388,
-0.0574113205,
-0.0517799407,
-0.0322920755,
-0.023617927,
-0.0445109047,
0.0512512848,
0.019949263,
0.0294114277,
-0.0433414951,
-0.0009413541,
-0.0158204287,
-0.0197476801,
0.0465045832,
0.01739089,
0.0234025605,
-0.0132643366,
-0.0351641364,
0.0524144955,
0.029594643,
0.0401028171,
0.0214637034,
0.0243255738,
-0.002162039,
-0.0113698989,
-0.0110642416,
0.0197413731,
-0.0257306211,
0.0361228473,
0.0382568948,
0.0611537658,
-0.0087342858,
0.0040028486,
-0.0294443667,
-0.0005045384,
0.0149483662,
0.0106589058,
0.028474262,
0.019205058,
-0.0774444416,
-0.0035266713,
-0.013715147,
-0.0196228921,
0.0163741242,
-0.0051607322,
0.0139536476,
-0.0976816341,
-0.0229876973,
-0.0157667492,
0.0400177725,
-0.0050355131,
-0.0190554466,
-0.0127302194,
-0.033500988,
0.0498697571,
-0.0125329299,
-0.0123656495,
0.0023535097,
0.033267498,
-0.0277134907,
-0.0458234549,
0.0101958904,
-0.0078217853,
0.0010354986,
0.0024009331,
-0.067259863,
0.0625350475,
0.0121485144,
-0.0069570621,
-0.0239630379,
-0.0439063683,
0.0106009869,
0.0176223442,
-0.0370050408,
-0.0109679112,
0.0137997763,
0.0035237074,
0.0815768987,
-0.0046984884,
-0.057878498,
0.0551088005,
-0.0430345684,
0.0041344683,
-0.0147432256,
0.0216595754,
-0.0310616903,
0.0569184199,
-0.008042343,
0.0053930171,
-0.0261066705,
-0.0001513659,
-0.030034801,
0.0018581506,
0.0540211722,
-0.0143778129,
0.0308077428,
-0.0810025334,
-0.002591837,
-0.029222304,
-0.0041849981,
-0.0408358723,
-0.0235963501,
0.0415354744,
0.0038943656,
0.0072335475,
-0.0240416396,
0.0263763703,
-0.0195539799,
-0.045774959,
0.0746934563,
0.0224482026,
0.0124616409,
-0.0413500667,
0.0124958875,
-0.0149046965,
-0.042283088,
-0.0201720893,
-0.0239682551,
0.0463551804,
0.0152189061,
-0.0126824472,
-0.0417521335,
-0.0464715138,
-0.0250845253,
0.0862239078,
-0.0418042727,
-0.006715735,
0.0223126914,
0.0197157711,
-0.0634749904,
-0.0231138021,
0.0866527259,
0.0293675233,
-0.0152217494,
0.0153230745,
-0.0049432628,
0.0549960844,
0.0166694727,
0.0476722457,
-0.0752649829,
0.0095905717,
0.0202709604,
0.0241796337,
-0.013706048,
0.0285405777,
-0.0492771938,
-0.0996265337,
0.0184786748,
0.0382845923,
-0.0684094131,
-0.0342679098,
0.0116501302,
-0.0373994038,
0.0043751639,
0.0296249706,
0.005471597,
0.0272552278,
-0.0041977642,
-0.0195394736,
0.0041325325,
-0.0386667922,
0.001516178,
-0.0135738859,
0.0184927955,
0.0217277985,
0.0258219708,
-0.029343782,
-0.008721347,
0.0201408137,
0.0157307573,
0.0006699748,
-0.0270457305,
-0.02067196,
0.0068272739,
-0.0098132025,
0.0302477516,
0.0333087146,
-0.0140601667,
0.0145661244,
0.0434517376,
0.0575742461,
-0.0181929618,
0.0188866071,
-0.0236415062,
-0.0437184386,
0.053198617,
0.0277419705,
0.0267139338,
-0.0476768166,
-0.0118139237,
-0.0491368473,
-0.0259148888,
-0.0752470866,
-0.0018968558,
-0.033337567,
-0.0519694425,
-0.1036310047,
-0.0776733682,
-0.025574334,
0.0233931392,
0.0355167389,
0.0408458263,
-0.0085616261,
-0.0221392158,
-0.0371310301,
-0.0494342893,
0.0634925738,
-0.0387702659,
0.040821474,
-0.0273633953,
-0.0271056574,
0.0048233094,
-0.0295065567,
0.0037596966,
0.0491707698,
-0.0493854992,
-0.0859492794,
0.0048646634,
0.0720094964,
0.0181946903,
0.0557624325,
-0.0289991964,
-0.0076415334,
-0.0001357306,
0.0613057017,
-0.040936552,
-0.0593390688,
0.0765723959,
0.0092419507,
0.0035905479,
0.0501298308,
0.0096480725,
0.0011951936,
0.0219071731,
0.0632229149,
0.0287028551,
-0.0447568893,
0.0482923277,
0.0693020821,
0.0459687039,
-0.0480869487,
-0.0863493532,
-0.0249984004,
0.0037174565,
-0.0521522127,
-0.0595084354,
-0.055195462,
0.0265976526,
-0.0124130407,
-0.0094128158,
-0.0115654413,
-0.043786943,
-0.0580828525,
-0.0205793176,
-0.011924807,
-0.0024724836,
-0.0269305613,
0.0789618939,
0.0598680079,
-0.0044442783,
-0.0268524121,
0.0552855209,
-0.0027993722,
0.015755685,
-0.0308886729,
0.0212428272,
0.0269690659,
0.0546570309,
-0.0371724702,
0.0360456966,
-0.0039180168,
0.0104412083,
-0.0388894305,
0.0106763942,
0.0655064434,
0.0171890538,
0.0494040847,
-0.0112304669,
-0.0045764628,
-0.0011785245,
0.0566008836,
0.0485455208,
-0.0354845934,
-0.0008493825,
-0.0093430774,
-0.0169693436,
-0.0153325293,
0.0594596118,
-0.0194749981,
0.0002913674,
-0.0142130954,
-0.0039757513,
-0.0381960347,
-0.0090742223,
0.0277780723,
-0.0221212134,
-0.0261797067,
-0.0258565638,
-0.0582396276,
-0.070740521,
0.0065747281,
0.0413014702,
-0.0213575903,
0.0083787432,
-0.0120928185,
0.0591040924,
-0.0165103339,
0.0229453761,
-0.0427196026,
0.0117734484,
0.0240155123,
-0.0533636473,
-0.039173238,
-5.292225076e-33,
0.0014239405,
-0.0052539511,
-0.0113443602,
0.0239899326,
-0.0146996044,
-0.0165281557,
-0.0461925566,
-0.0335423648,
0.0288612787,
0.0091223065,
-0.0378673598,
-0.0097569292,
0.0293065235,
0.0004810649,
-0.0012728494,
0.0043125362,
0.0512853526,
0.0322848707,
-0.0412114225,
0.0068798172,
0.0354438908,
-0.0310100056,
0.0576709583,
-0.0213920996,
0.1068852842,
-0.0565419383,
-0.0244913939,
0.0285219681,
-0.0095659224,
-0.0050835079,
0.0126779359,
0.045763988,
0.0008175815,
0.0006062552,
-0.0471499003,
-0.0131837716,
-0.0763663277,
-0.0078991503,
0.0530367568,
0.0317390375,
0.0012560785,
-0.0714865029,
0.0104712956,
-0.0708721951,
-0.011274403,
0.0111555764,
-0.0226844512,
-0.0379788615,
-0.0267487429,
-0.0563829876,
-0.0419043414,
0.0176093001,
-0.0070152706,
0.0285196081,
0.0178800561,
0.0326286741,
0.0160061084,
-0.034347441,
-0.0260580275,
0.0225484278,
0.0117794937,
0.0169714261,
0.0919920281,
0.0123031167,
0.0181835778,
-0.0190004185,
0.0282137636,
0.0308930464,
0.0426388383,
0.0409164205,
-0.0044473871,
0.0067906203,
0.0285183676,
0.0808830559,
0.0469806157,
-0.0207217652,
-0.0139608355,
0.0437723286,
-0.009502342,
-0.0284826271,
0.0048792888,
-0.0059991903,
-0.0356460661,
-0.0222190078,
-0.0788389146,
-0.011863579,
-0.0105273891,
0.0092864186,
0.0050218059,
-0.0308680665,
-0.0581287146,
-0.0114595937,
0.0589989386,
-0.0282174721,
0.038022317,
-0.013504711,
-0.0239602346,
-0.0087543167,
-0.0029905981,
0.0480846725,
0.0515187494,
-0.0663686246,
0.0233086683,
-0.0077890949,
-0.0013556415,
0.0105121341,
0.0219867043,
0.0421962291,
-0.0343702585,
0.0271447878,
-0.049879048,
0.006397787,
-0.0426811464,
0.0127464104,
0.0475491509,
0.0057102926,
0.0026287758,
0.0034917418,
0.0294332616,
0.0055397856,
-0.0255047325,
0.0523249283,
0.0246468391,
0.0522210971,
-0.0305269044,
0.0044342177,
-0.0127036376,
-0.0381686464,
0.0683569685,
-0.0131051894,
-0.0103785777,
0.0031832801,
2.526e-7,
0.0286297742,
0.0118547967,
0.0024937422,
0.0825441554,
-0.0123542538,
-0.0205666535,
-0.0137316128,
0.0285054762,
0.014008373,
0.0396684483,
0.0201334506,
0.0142875426,
0.0652421564,
0.03000677,
-0.1028738469,
-0.0329940207,
-0.0030591935,
0.0563609079,
-0.0653773993,
0.0106359217,
0.013323348,
0.0520605035,
-0.0105816117,
0.0269398764,
-0.0271687526,
-0.0040181666,
0.003573366,
-0.0264160335,
0.016999647,
0.0696353987,
0.0328119732,
0.0001432669,
-0.0061159176,
0.0174996145,
-0.0396255441,
0.0143149449,
0.0045022191,
0.0982662961,
0.0219511706,
0.0376562104,
0.0054470142,
-0.0902325585,
-0.0250096191,
-0.0242479723,
0.0166652668,
-0.0092414971,
-0.0192889851,
0.0102272416,
-0.0312727243,
0.0052685388,
-0.0125458883,
-0.0484931469,
-0.0147484122,
0.0413696505,
0.0408764035,
-0.0025783195,
-0.0200439859,
-0.0017938653,
-0.069833681,
-0.0635074079,
-0.0054541607,
-0.060360007,
0.0223388709,
0.0155910784,
0.0091195814,
-0.0159398802,
0.0283458922,
2.715007389e-34,
0.0872124434,
-0.0081165889,
-0.0016141437,
-0.0101058651,
0.0352047198,
-0.0522878096,
0.0196627975,
0.0262661874,
0.0505283736,
-0.0340583324,
-0.0499632433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14470v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14470v1 | Knowledge Graph-Augmented Korean Generative Commonsense Reasoning | 2023-06-26T07:23:47 | 2023-06-26T07:23:47 | Dahyun Jung, Jaehyung Seo, Jaewook Lee, Chanjun Park, Heuiseok Lim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generative commonsense reasoning refers to the task of generating acceptable
and logical assumptions about everyday situations based on commonsense
understanding. By utilizing an existing dataset such as Korean CommonGen,
language generation models can learn commonsense reasoning specific to the
Korean language. However, language models often fail to consider the
relationships between concepts and the deep knowledge inherent to concepts. To
address these limitations, we propose a method to utilize the Korean knowledge
graph data for text generation. Our experimental result shows that the proposed
method can enhance the efficiency of Korean commonsense inference, thereby
underlining the significance of employing supplementary data. | [
0.0628901049,
0.0267010424,
0.0089459633,
0.0223847963,
-0.0412619077,
0.0122566894,
0.0033079281,
-0.0018953445,
0.0694155768,
-0.0386447646,
0.0383161493,
0.0009277248,
0.016236024,
0.0214191321,
0.0341667756,
-0.0393072367,
0.0001208082,
0.0179070868,
0.0195542406,
-0.0200604163,
0.0032231996,
0.032475654,
-0.0113068605,
0.0092088459,
-0.0252537951,
0.0014711618,
0.0113553125,
0.0031335279,
0.022778634,
-0.0156385358,
-0.0167500842,
0.0466496386,
0.0122718336,
0.0241513886,
0.0000016916,
-0.0089159589,
0.0280640721,
-0.0285339877,
0.0067983237,
-0.0352588184,
0.0305140093,
-0.0373439118,
0.0275642015,
0.0011366585,
-0.0461083315,
-0.0137354704,
0.0206782538,
0.0065454515,
0.0261963774,
0.0475275442,
-0.018369589,
-0.0491543896,
-0.035917379,
0.0043678856,
0.027729569,
-0.0275240503,
0.0197998155,
0.0690467209,
0.0015715651,
-0.0395551547,
-0.0379451849,
0.0028138894,
0.0276640113,
-0.0435755774,
0.012919683,
0.0386604555,
-0.0123248138,
0.0131922578,
0.0209374968,
0.1058058292,
0.0175845176,
-0.0354525782,
-0.0013691892,
-0.0071999091,
0.0101932399,
0.0276227687,
-0.0084717823,
0.0357699096,
-0.009431405,
0.0235483646,
0.0276115201,
-0.026480969,
0.0259346403,
0.0256940313,
-0.0121560823,
0.0727993175,
0.0160025824,
0.0112026567,
-0.0128718372,
0.009910984,
-0.0496194176,
-0.0443345942,
0.0006278963,
0.0377784111,
-0.0153553551,
0.0555236414,
-0.0515596308,
-0.0145382788,
0.0238768831,
-0.0248510409,
0.0008057534,
0.0456785969,
0.0085410299,
0.0149250561,
-0.0459202826,
-0.0086189844,
0.0116218459,
0.0239183456,
-0.0398658551,
-0.0058930689,
-0.0442190468,
-0.0108985323,
-0.0327946357,
0.0222522058,
-0.0301278476,
-0.0048309676,
-0.0596523061,
0.0088832146,
-0.0086333975,
0.027739998,
0.0376154035,
0.0592590719,
-0.0610471293,
-0.0341355912,
-0.0265975799,
0.0086692553,
-0.0550265871,
0.0649509877,
0.0729664415,
0.008938076,
0.0148216328,
-0.0079181343,
0.0629399419,
-0.0173987113,
-0.0054933592,
0.0056846961,
-0.0027308215,
0.0503843836,
-0.0754238963,
-0.0569601506,
-0.0310906116,
-0.030284185,
0.0097916918,
-0.0986010134,
0.0229969807,
0.0239633266,
-0.0218876712,
0.0031424318,
0.0103219412,
0.0087330788,
-0.0300979279,
0.0393660776,
-0.0371846035,
0.0002901301,
-0.0057526194,
0.0111332098,
0.0218541212,
0.040147353,
0.0141681023,
-0.0236318409,
0.0352475941,
0.0311899018,
-0.0489492863,
-0.0262995474,
0.0228209216,
0.0054946113,
0.0050040483,
-0.0202079676,
-0.0627887473,
0.0334137529,
0.021339599,
0.0033916177,
-0.0412718803,
0.0275613684,
0.0318306498,
0.0465813316,
-0.0251113102,
0.0388812609,
0.059698388,
0.0084295515,
-0.0312097911,
0.0310859382,
0.0033845953,
0.0137685696,
-0.034752246,
0.0299753901,
-0.0255759824,
0.012002755,
-0.0242668353,
0.0009705173,
-0.0012329356,
-0.0291470159,
0.0517180264,
-0.0105044525,
0.0289610773,
0.0448877513,
-0.0114421872,
0.053991925,
0.0447755493,
-0.0679691359,
0.018018255,
0.0051629818,
-0.0033992997,
0.0781548396,
0.0261364784,
0.0592957661,
-0.055830121,
0.0207727682,
0.0021068603,
0.0491073579,
0.0419296287,
-0.0427010655,
-0.0260280631,
-0.0566133372,
-0.0320067778,
0.0122097684,
-0.0016779726,
0.0090173259,
0.0235682763,
0.0225248616,
0.0580373518,
-0.0588549189,
0.0016892941,
-0.0059896437,
-0.0176687334,
0.0167829078,
-0.0036324009,
-0.0208440032,
0.0105738947,
0.0295099877,
0.0204956345,
0.0030085505,
0.0045861914,
-0.0159929208,
-0.0372615233,
0.0902739465,
-0.0473098643,
-0.1383033693,
0.0049545588,
-0.0662460029,
-0.0088740289,
-0.0000235706,
-0.0469411686,
-0.0580224246,
0.0158394389,
0.0126760174,
0.0539846607,
-0.0529340468,
-0.0408395939,
0.0097232908,
-0.0246458817,
0.0318228416,
0.1215573028,
-0.0178169012,
0.0001168713,
0.0244016666,
0.0414457023,
0.0044591734,
-0.0340108424,
0.0180230234,
-0.0104940245,
0.0028151704,
-0.0031867006,
0.0358336195,
0.0385687947,
-0.0538262129,
0.0334782936,
-0.1064561903,
0.0107670799,
0.0082588391,
-0.0031368828,
0.0170965437,
-0.0068970812,
0.0134872859,
-0.0040160483,
-0.0696136951,
0.0573619083,
0.0594962873,
0.0065779956,
0.024651723,
-0.022085622,
0.0150595699,
0.0187580548,
0.0025963522,
-0.0069787083,
0.0176589098,
0.0557615198,
0.0521165393,
0.0071437908,
0.0534548983,
-0.0620797724,
-0.0133223133,
0.006283538,
-0.0514983237,
0.0138766039,
-0.0026631653,
0.0072644814,
0.0237759072,
-0.000950092,
0.0081204474,
0.032940086,
-0.0349127613,
-0.0046366258,
-0.0174593646,
-0.0565136783,
0.0423253775,
-0.0312102307,
-0.0163579918,
-0.0573300645,
0.0262142569,
0.0454650745,
-0.0238977671,
-0.0619269051,
-0.0034965493,
-0.0053886566,
0.0031555071,
-0.0042562755,
0.0300671011,
-0.0019515968,
0.0210823175,
-0.0279930942,
-0.0053053559,
0.0774258897,
0.020356467,
0.0318772383,
-0.0250945501,
0.0431500934,
-0.0078914715,
0.0415258929,
-0.0160725079,
0.0277264658,
-0.0256786887,
-0.0040555415,
-0.0280764177,
0.0005349991,
0.0417475365,
-0.0136148715,
0.025278477,
-0.0450651832,
0.0150722964,
-0.0047176071,
-0.0179656316,
-0.0365174003,
0.0205595773,
0.0124363434,
0.0174687654,
0.05489593,
-0.0317237228,
-0.0003169519,
-0.0180259887,
0.0110595189,
0.0101991901,
0.0106024994,
-0.0150001533,
-0.0136621874,
0.0489039198,
0.0382773019,
-0.0044111907,
-0.0199945159,
0.0005212873,
-0.0017048951,
0.0557565689,
0.0211752914,
-0.0098067112,
0.003412025,
0.0454545468,
-0.0096126804,
0.0069188671,
-0.0255352072,
0.0249047931,
0.0421496741,
-0.057673391,
-0.0098910304,
0.0640172213,
0.024322791,
-0.000795196,
0.0101595912,
0.0089589059,
0.0462890603,
0.002660027,
0.0013573549,
-0.0815940872,
-0.0295923557,
0.0034584382,
0.0045541995,
-0.035945911,
-0.0896756053,
0.0152695989,
-0.1128649265,
0.0231877454,
0.0252546053,
-0.0547928885,
-0.0656987876,
-0.0351851955,
-0.0064760977,
0.0174966622,
-0.0358206294,
-0.021129068,
0.0305580832,
0.0100986529,
0.018740451,
-0.0140056275,
-0.0887264311,
0.0264972355,
-0.0186095685,
0.0225325525,
-0.0079139611,
0.0895794481,
0.035480503,
-0.0439579897,
-0.0649878457,
-0.0469814911,
-0.0148306144,
-0.0136428932,
-0.0033076508,
0.0097491806,
-0.0001049246,
-0.0302738044,
0.0748763457,
-0.0776866078,
-0.0061872769,
0.0121454261,
0.0577347912,
-0.016879255,
-0.0495771691,
0.0133641325,
0.0063899206,
0.0393743739,
0.0671618357,
0.028607687,
0.0298729558,
-0.0217550546,
-0.0424051359,
-0.0146666169,
-0.099502407,
0.0183637291,
0.0358104818,
-0.0069478666,
0.0123846503,
-0.0785802826,
-0.0342888795,
0.014159346,
0.0619363263,
-0.0028590746,
0.0000855086,
0.0061110598,
-0.0014622856,
-0.0400733165,
0.0054342309,
-0.0356592685,
-0.0277548246,
0.0386936218,
-0.0425717346,
-0.0089555103,
-0.0365123563,
-0.0107696569,
0.0328141674,
-0.0422547869,
-0.0834913999,
-0.0206524171,
0.0132484492,
0.0170294698,
0.0511005633,
-0.0091171274,
0.0245391224,
0.0636276007,
0.0292522404,
-0.0539506935,
-0.0258391518,
0.0125769395,
-0.0198169872,
0.0245437287,
0.0546548143,
-0.0327408239,
0.0061353436,
0.0054336726,
0.0788822472,
-0.0336657837,
-0.0432378575,
0.0065926742,
0.0357272774,
-0.0494320355,
-0.043510735,
0.0166225079,
-0.0703366026,
-0.0146187879,
-0.0545559451,
-0.0435285121,
-0.0207436047,
0.0149818109,
0.0107092885,
-0.0089695351,
-0.0137304636,
0.0340318978,
-0.0113249635,
0.0325401276,
0.0096753361,
-0.0248837173,
0.0456478819,
0.0469992086,
0.0493027642,
-0.0589561574,
-0.0358830318,
-0.0233020093,
-0.0462964699,
0.0048070336,
-0.008030816,
0.0668276101,
0.0319863781,
-0.0492821708,
-0.0124290502,
-0.0241937377,
-0.0376558974,
0.0063422378,
-0.022520883,
0.0408022366,
0.0735647231,
-0.0211555306,
0.0354422443,
-0.0709579214,
-0.0100896722,
0.0027874624,
0.097555466,
0.0134946993,
-0.0814659372,
0.0193402413,
-0.0078836363,
-0.0265254565,
0.0000741171,
0.077091299,
-0.004670897,
0.0378229953,
-0.0148335248,
-0.0506103672,
-0.0177220535,
-0.0430513434,
0.0469786376,
0.0345477648,
0.0095641008,
0.0147666149,
-0.0490553714,
-0.0867019743,
-0.0321234465,
0.0191640854,
0.0423409268,
0.0417140089,
0.0328750461,
0.077185154,
0.0089210467,
-0.0301163178,
-0.048332192,
0.0476506501,
-0.0853724182,
0.0336484574,
-0.0126414355,
-5.940344539e-33,
-0.0144828092,
-0.0644660816,
0.0099237422,
-0.0112073272,
-0.0249963794,
-0.0274992287,
-0.0809747204,
-0.0208890345,
-0.0024358332,
0.0400195494,
0.0001371724,
0.0121071478,
-0.0014659665,
0.0448879637,
0.0004963127,
-0.0022228325,
0.0125592574,
0.0324477479,
-0.0038065305,
0.0491525792,
0.0980331004,
0.0106512457,
0.0517027825,
0.0137566198,
0.0464833193,
-0.0461859219,
0.0295223575,
0.0013773557,
-0.0117487619,
0.0408822633,
-0.0123728011,
0.0592618324,
0.0214356594,
0.0209563076,
-0.0159031693,
0.0048508975,
-0.0569509864,
-0.0373148061,
0.0196482036,
-0.0030002326,
-0.0554945096,
-0.0219035149,
0.0226489231,
0.0026294689,
0.0503465347,
-0.0152986208,
0.0514874645,
-0.0473073795,
-0.0246485341,
-0.054097984,
-0.0571450479,
0.0251548104,
-0.0217596497,
0.0072049238,
-0.0493517295,
-0.0270678438,
-0.0226067584,
-0.0531328544,
-0.0233164001,
0.0255972613,
0.0040625874,
-0.0051702061,
0.0511247031,
-0.0074634403,
0.0286944807,
0.0242073443,
-0.0658744797,
-0.0043343063,
-0.0562194251,
0.0530022457,
0.0017592963,
0.062140502,
-0.0244988203,
0.0805436596,
0.0184725728,
-0.0376475044,
-0.0968199298,
0.0213027634,
-0.0170849189,
0.0178213678,
0.0385937765,
-0.0455236435,
-0.0189545639,
-0.0318917222,
-0.0118513322,
-0.0152789094,
-0.0130659165,
-0.0540525503,
-0.0187859535,
-0.0144660855,
-0.0559019782,
-0.0100282356,
0.0068821032,
-0.0187296774,
0.0041832505,
0.0766923428,
-0.0190574322,
-0.0209794138,
-0.0177433398,
0.036593724,
-0.0662231743,
-0.0478823222,
0.032691326,
0.0082841851,
-0.0253301635,
0.0382975191,
0.0516319871,
0.0013332362,
0.0134178428,
0.0117353285,
-0.0575993881,
-0.0213491321,
-0.0201604608,
-0.0311949588,
0.0256851148,
0.0278208386,
0.0015388125,
0.0119886911,
0.0352985971,
0.0321359187,
-0.0012906512,
0.0268649459,
0.0191829335,
0.0246098414,
-0.0288270786,
0.0143434843,
-0.0597927682,
-0.0339983478,
0.0139670679,
-0.0223569609,
0.0006142986,
0.0389707275,
2.379e-7,
0.0098823989,
-0.01088914,
0.023299491,
0.0223423392,
0.0013696314,
0.0247951895,
0.0106986146,
0.0210479274,
0.0153107373,
-0.0306656752,
0.0556096919,
0.0570273623,
0.0076840972,
0.0657563955,
-0.059944395,
0.0465451032,
-0.0360012092,
-0.0327448882,
-0.020631982,
-0.022392761,
0.0484028161,
0.0090654064,
0.0131527362,
-0.0285171084,
0.0488191769,
-0.0609516576,
0.0566657446,
0.0284321643,
-0.0063876607,
-0.0082529746,
0.0790132135,
0.0067374846,
-0.0185001921,
0.0675777271,
-0.0126697682,
-0.0132386656,
-0.0156839266,
0.0263659842,
0.0095374426,
0.0006676216,
0.0112044932,
-0.0533980951,
0.0116976537,
-0.068414636,
0.0612146929,
-0.0727316961,
0.0046312627,
0.0240025111,
0.00614001,
-0.000060804,
-0.0427430831,
-0.0362773761,
-0.0119720912,
0.0034875642,
0.0354003981,
-0.0082561979,
0.0088128131,
-0.0164153315,
0.0017054087,
0.0327347554,
-0.022374738,
-0.0502226427,
0.0046600131,
-0.0331564993,
0.0114636477,
-0.050043948,
0.0246892758,
1.933831241e-34,
-0.0062886369,
0.0250266492,
-0.0438344181,
-0.06802582,
0.0258481111,
-0.0316418111,
-0.0139517561,
-0.0000445798,
0.0165453423,
-0.0536142066,
-0.0409441628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14457v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14457v1 | Fauno: The Italian Large Language Model that will leave you senza parole! | 2023-06-26T07:00:38 | 2023-06-26T07:00:38 | Andrea Bacciu, Giovanni Trappolini, Andrea Santilli, Emanuele Rodolà, Fabrizio Silvestri | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents Fauno, the first and largest open-source Italian
conversational Large Language Model (LLM). Our goal with Fauno is to
democratize the study of LLMs in Italian, demonstrating that obtaining a
fine-tuned conversational bot with a single GPU is possible. In addition, we
release a collection of datasets for conversational AI in Italian. The datasets
on which we fine-tuned Fauno include various topics such as general question
answering, computer science, and medical questions. We release our code and
datasets on \url{https://github.com/RSTLess-research/Fauno-Italian-LLM} | [
0.020706648,
0.0948050246,
-0.0089724679,
0.0585702062,
-0.000221334,
0.035317108,
0.0152928783,
0.0169842914,
0.0504597574,
0.0041957763,
-0.0626362935,
-0.0136153381,
0.0080438452,
0.0791401044,
-0.0168628991,
-0.0461388975,
0.0329039432,
-0.0679829493,
0.0128104445,
-0.0387651175,
0.0360710472,
0.002470023,
-0.0177806094,
0.0300000682,
-0.0081807254,
-0.0219508577,
-0.0272736922,
-0.020181274,
-0.0306114163,
0.0284094643,
0.0103942854,
0.0272823721,
0.042821262,
0.0272877254,
0.0000020361,
0.0017879016,
0.0148324454,
-0.0404246971,
0.0014321953,
-0.0174072031,
-0.0001252564,
-0.0030986543,
-0.0262671132,
0.0207178723,
-0.0437813401,
0.0200444553,
0.0420175679,
0.0129316682,
0.0379016474,
0.085819222,
0.0025157044,
-0.0451014787,
0.0384693928,
-0.0547459945,
0.0037326529,
-0.0315282159,
-0.0003393011,
0.0235887729,
-0.0121759735,
0.0082157776,
-0.0234383326,
0.0419654064,
0.0215247441,
-0.0094715906,
-0.0702255741,
0.0392582975,
-0.0070758737,
-0.0245350022,
-0.0057299891,
0.0989180282,
0.020256171,
-0.0124336546,
0.0148428837,
0.034269359,
0.0189032108,
-0.0334696583,
-0.0826124027,
0.0356669389,
0.0110159842,
0.021643687,
0.0313550271,
-0.0108570913,
0.008998611,
0.0230452195,
-0.0046521449,
0.0513894781,
0.0292407107,
-0.0170846488,
-0.0054359543,
-0.0132510802,
-0.0252438392,
-0.0665290654,
-0.0009395766,
0.0457357466,
-0.029880004,
0.0139650209,
-0.052284807,
0.010262127,
0.0464137904,
-0.0214962903,
0.0063013663,
-0.0039430982,
-0.0203887839,
0.0747835413,
0.018272588,
0.0432500988,
-0.0426049754,
0.0018618049,
-0.0304263551,
-0.0345725976,
-0.0188037455,
0.0029252034,
-0.0444517508,
0.0205229428,
-0.0926315337,
-0.0384403281,
-0.0211778153,
0.040338546,
0.0113007426,
0.0241640229,
-0.0033026836,
0.0069777858,
-0.0171484537,
0.0144317886,
-0.018245602,
0.0369766504,
-0.0682918727,
0.0040145419,
0.0029263417,
-0.0815820098,
-0.026922781,
0.0350090601,
-0.0003298813,
-0.0246108342,
0.0421076789,
0.0185568705,
0.0102367708,
-0.0147144943,
0.0188245326,
-0.0054532932,
-0.0286227092,
-0.0924096629,
-0.018581586,
-0.074164845,
0.0647970885,
-0.0230434034,
0.0249750372,
-0.0403325334,
-0.0014874941,
0.0254460759,
-0.0150581114,
0.0533424653,
-0.0488485917,
-0.0091108289,
0.0381962955,
-0.0038991978,
0.008193952,
0.0542590581,
0.04963075,
0.0194590818,
0.0332500972,
0.0011237176,
0.0184163228,
0.0454724915,
0.0372584797,
0.0476879105,
-0.0009651983,
0.0445300378,
0.006281958,
0.0647772104,
0.0386272483,
0.0701342672,
-0.0093606915,
-0.0015376605,
0.0694286823,
0.0568218231,
-0.0329506136,
0.0481780022,
0.0125990249,
0.0180292409,
0.0143501516,
-0.0204471648,
-0.0170872509,
0.035741087,
-0.0127926059,
0.0010657264,
0.017706247,
0.0139495991,
-0.0512954891,
-0.0358432941,
0.0166834835,
-0.0476497076,
0.0077976277,
0.0158179328,
0.0513301194,
0.0040155295,
-0.0360830799,
-0.0226914044,
0.0422809683,
-0.0589714162,
-0.0293247942,
-0.0580505058,
0.0821155608,
0.0757602975,
0.0378232449,
-0.0132975774,
-0.0259337891,
-0.0151361283,
0.0170875434,
0.0527546778,
0.0334378704,
-0.0137067204,
0.0207821652,
-0.0593669936,
0.0199887343,
-0.0215954203,
-0.0134164132,
0.0126663633,
0.0106938612,
0.0197678227,
-0.0341110118,
0.0001728546,
-0.0103374468,
0.00711125,
-0.009567041,
-0.0018317241,
-0.0382561088,
0.0017251981,
0.0109341592,
-0.0083011743,
0.0118003516,
-0.0099553531,
0.0405085459,
-0.0498368852,
-0.0079834871,
0.0088931387,
-0.0318566412,
-0.0420267433,
0.0350709148,
-0.0079402672,
-0.0152749829,
0.0258538369,
-0.0634737164,
-0.0418430082,
0.0331721194,
-0.0360053889,
0.0159701686,
-0.0155651737,
-0.0066437116,
0.0139610888,
0.035153266,
-0.012687766,
0.0550050735,
-0.022447966,
-0.0081115495,
0.0569275171,
0.0362154618,
0.0121491458,
-0.0628007948,
-0.0286875851,
0.0413534641,
0.0049064341,
-0.0026526521,
0.0307868477,
0.009573306,
-0.0431448594,
-0.0606217049,
-0.1094492376,
0.0359620564,
0.0014090833,
-0.0035455208,
0.0267373808,
0.0242358781,
-0.0286444426,
-0.0292824972,
-0.0304430742,
0.0031940101,
0.0012053493,
-0.0125705795,
0.0593433306,
0.0138310837,
-0.0441050678,
-0.0473688878,
0.0156889688,
0.0337359495,
0.0215422306,
0.0052262335,
-0.017787857,
-0.0349051319,
0.022558026,
-0.045874659,
0.0777279735,
-0.0184804182,
-0.0531030893,
0.0125482837,
-0.0095858416,
0.0385167971,
0.0934643224,
0.0108901942,
0.0234545618,
0.0170239955,
-0.0343603604,
-0.0533299074,
0.0376896337,
0.0020156738,
-0.0748184174,
-0.0716995895,
-0.0359632596,
0.0334972553,
0.0710741282,
-0.010895079,
0.0411914289,
-0.029083427,
0.0300332773,
0.0110829128,
-0.0244727805,
0.0125450362,
0.0211453214,
-0.0179226343,
0.0312239826,
-0.0098981829,
-0.0318732522,
0.0372885577,
-0.0568999387,
0.002532078,
-0.0335669741,
-0.0223453008,
-0.032865677,
0.0538003817,
-0.0010495401,
0.0319813415,
-0.0621299148,
-0.0011042661,
-0.0072723781,
-0.0256756917,
-0.0128662745,
-0.0456839465,
0.0308100004,
-0.0615935251,
0.0202196129,
-0.0021550357,
-0.0794028565,
-0.0039845202,
0.0143543305,
-0.0725038871,
-0.0037276731,
0.0419003554,
-0.0420261994,
-0.0464734398,
0.000539561,
0.0186812896,
0.0723485723,
-0.0249728803,
0.0076186704,
-0.013253239,
0.0136803472,
0.0846621022,
0.0194777008,
-0.0274309739,
-0.0141853821,
0.0460295863,
0.0685707927,
0.0450595804,
0.0164486952,
-0.0722220019,
-0.0223391484,
0.0217823815,
0.0079958504,
-0.0416076556,
-0.0123798335,
0.0320179425,
-0.0241663326,
-0.034168914,
0.1271028072,
-0.0051644542,
-0.0679400042,
-0.0137657775,
-0.022663381,
0.0750549436,
0.0064140591,
0.0523978807,
-0.0780844763,
-0.044246383,
0.0103971874,
0.0075780563,
-0.0222265795,
-0.0092620859,
-0.0147224413,
-0.081486851,
0.0569589511,
-0.0141224032,
-0.0224351324,
-0.0799054727,
-0.0333209038,
-0.0054000183,
-0.0097855208,
0.0023873297,
-0.0061350209,
0.0002170657,
-0.0093195206,
0.0018954612,
0.0061384952,
0.0067789783,
0.0133966254,
-0.0039582974,
0.0746603236,
0.04680489,
0.0427698232,
-0.0193471164,
0.0075173797,
0.0270610452,
0.0355248377,
-0.0090524871,
-0.0376270786,
0.0543110371,
-0.0283436067,
-0.0185934156,
-0.047447335,
0.0350634232,
-0.0279928073,
-0.0158732943,
0.0534056723,
0.0275048483,
-0.0324229971,
0.0128937541,
0.0055441083,
-0.0149824517,
0.018568933,
0.0605153032,
0.0546019785,
-0.0561701506,
-0.0390156806,
-0.0151582202,
-0.013496737,
-0.0201442726,
-0.0055373381,
-0.0001181888,
0.0226743259,
0.0062885107,
-0.0496723279,
-0.0394179523,
0.0351309627,
0.0188840739,
-0.0012189164,
0.014977484,
-0.0087873004,
-0.0154860588,
-0.0064467257,
0.0586235709,
-0.0746975243,
0.0040556174,
-0.1059698537,
-0.0229574405,
0.0335295834,
-0.016160259,
-0.0410385728,
0.0620972402,
-0.0962973014,
-0.0222636759,
-0.0214888826,
0.0621101446,
0.0240689591,
0.0330802314,
-0.0117364265,
-0.0718583763,
-0.0157795697,
-0.0384254307,
-0.0146268932,
0.0238264464,
0.0327099413,
0.003529696,
0.030739313,
0.0498895533,
-0.0280350912,
0.0097824903,
0.0015879297,
0.0273650102,
-0.0414533541,
-0.0423149355,
0.0194266438,
0.0190478023,
0.0128855985,
-0.0187933911,
0.0212618914,
-0.0398872942,
0.0410421118,
0.0270347334,
0.0162892733,
-0.0499337539,
0.0262189507,
0.0644646436,
-0.0204859655,
0.0246939436,
-0.042769447,
-0.0234321486,
0.0117778275,
-0.0280974675,
-0.0065957084,
0.0282383636,
-0.0301646534,
0.0263573434,
0.0084609194,
-0.0336156972,
0.07217215,
-0.0058915229,
0.0771226883,
-0.0245028194,
0.0595833473,
0.0240459386,
-0.0549037233,
0.0081873722,
0.0650372729,
-0.0195335783,
-0.0843371376,
0.0035291312,
0.0571181439,
0.0494208634,
0.0546121486,
0.0845552459,
-0.0041814628,
0.0027174274,
-0.030439578,
0.0331477039,
-0.0144988466,
-0.0482248142,
0.0605856739,
0.0091980677,
-0.0141799059,
0.0251799244,
0.0565159172,
0.0001935559,
0.0270549189,
0.0207328126,
0.0378880724,
-0.0371762142,
-0.0317981094,
-0.039082367,
-0.0106034242,
-0.0462531149,
-0.0303169154,
-0.0103366021,
-0.0574951358,
-0.042273894,
0.0071379459,
-0.0366756022,
-0.0177274756,
0.0370047949,
0.0384325795,
-0.0052939518,
0.0093397964,
-0.0476383716,
0.0847567096,
-0.0147339106,
-0.0208891947,
-0.0102889119,
-5.873624949e-33,
-0.0530812927,
-0.0102903107,
0.0349478573,
0.0059468444,
-0.0149924103,
0.0075213299,
-0.0292156171,
-0.0199184027,
-0.037345849,
-0.0159683935,
-0.0269173067,
0.0025590092,
0.0135155674,
0.0382628292,
-0.0168385264,
-0.0367279835,
0.0299691185,
0.0006121245,
-0.0253121369,
0.0369863734,
-0.0030666124,
0.0103703579,
0.031758707,
-0.0222120732,
0.005487632,
-0.0620812736,
-0.0198431816,
0.0342353582,
-0.0042981091,
0.0708976015,
-0.0215994082,
0.019423712,
0.0066625304,
0.0010768903,
-0.0138324481,
0.0678771809,
-0.0736041069,
-0.0009196009,
0.0327164531,
0.0376593955,
-0.0166032985,
-0.0328846984,
-0.0166542884,
0.0113494731,
0.0234645642,
0.0088444687,
0.0002822403,
-0.0185779817,
-0.0161096584,
0.0404217318,
-0.0292374417,
0.0090801734,
-0.0063917288,
-0.0490931906,
0.0013822634,
0.0315475911,
0.0072406949,
0.0351063684,
-0.0183675885,
0.0282026157,
-0.0123665286,
0.0230556317,
0.0793301836,
0.0121864676,
0.0240665004,
0.0610120706,
0.046097625,
-0.0111448262,
-0.0092004836,
-0.0085275183,
0.0061278837,
0.0541804619,
0.0117424959,
0.0263652373,
-0.0140104704,
-0.0281618964,
-0.0601113327,
-0.0151212774,
0.0540846214,
0.0379379988,
-0.010488946,
-0.0207073558,
-0.0310253575,
-0.0121734822,
-0.0529425032,
-0.0179256257,
-0.0037076962,
-0.0113508673,
0.0439749286,
-0.0038337086,
0.0231146812,
-0.0524064265,
0.0290600192,
-0.0329975784,
-0.0004913491,
0.040072497,
-0.0018191308,
0.0163286738,
-0.0083732195,
0.0435619615,
-0.0549602732,
-0.0462846979,
0.0053714518,
-0.0202935115,
0.0027904767,
0.0278306827,
0.004727846,
0.0013648318,
-0.0364728346,
0.0027412775,
-0.0536868833,
0.003249127,
-0.01509606,
0.0374103375,
-0.0066020349,
0.0243450422,
-0.0173122268,
0.0753424838,
-0.0213773642,
0.0340978466,
-0.0436363742,
-0.0525288321,
-0.016631892,
0.0148444977,
-0.0608764403,
-0.0173756275,
-0.0226270668,
0.0252496619,
0.0012707121,
-0.0732564181,
-0.0210895501,
-0.0110930074,
2.651e-7,
0.0186825339,
0.0317087509,
0.0133609865,
0.0388272181,
-0.0082503343,
0.0416446775,
-0.0060226815,
0.0208863318,
-0.0020062369,
0.0088387011,
0.0016136717,
0.0531413294,
0.0238280017,
0.0043236562,
-0.0901143923,
0.0104853176,
-0.0605482832,
-0.0193040483,
-0.034794841,
-0.0242472235,
-0.0410080999,
0.0942756981,
0.032582663,
-0.0287096314,
0.0076552182,
-0.039990712,
0.0428629108,
-0.0309045948,
-0.0559464358,
0.040889781,
0.0203335602,
0.037878789,
-0.0066271527,
-0.0135823786,
0.0226343367,
0.0288553722,
-0.0205342192,
0.0812938437,
-0.0065128827,
-0.0221366324,
0.0154073909,
-0.0499496385,
-0.0378428698,
-0.0542228185,
0.0479904711,
-0.025601903,
-0.0134700052,
-0.0666120574,
-0.008661557,
-0.029709734,
0.0261354316,
-0.0452129208,
0.0211153943,
0.0027704656,
0.0121419597,
-0.0542171672,
0.0002062514,
-0.001441861,
-0.01297668,
-0.0490334071,
-0.0614280142,
-0.0614875704,
-0.0578550994,
-0.0079079298,
-0.0155014573,
0.0011348651,
0.0176128503,
1.923118745e-34,
0.0357421376,
0.0076178638,
-0.0164538603,
0.0614398196,
0.0372432135,
-0.028007891,
-0.0125114461,
-0.0058293594,
0.0138406428,
-0.0727753639,
-0.0200978089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14422v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14422v2 | The Singing Voice Conversion Challenge 2023 | 2023-06-26T05:04:58 | 2023-07-06T08:17:31 | Wen-Chin Huang, Lester Phillip Violeta, Songxiang Liu, Jiatong Shi, Tomoki Toda | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | We present the latest iteration of the voice conversion challenge (VCC)
series, a bi-annual scientific event aiming to compare and understand different
voice conversion (VC) systems based on a common dataset. This year we shifted
our focus to singing voice conversion (SVC), thus named the challenge the
Singing Voice Conversion Challenge (SVCC). A new database was constructed for
two tasks, namely in-domain and cross-domain SVC. The challenge was run for two
months, and in total we received 26 submissions, including 2 baselines. Through
a large-scale crowd-sourced listening test, we observed that for both tasks,
although human-level naturalness was achieved by the top system, no team was
able to obtain a similarity score as high as the target speakers. Also, as
expected, cross-domain SVC is harder than in-domain SVC, especially in the
similarity aspect. We also investigated whether existing objective measurements
were able to predict perceptual performance, and found that only few of them
could reach a significant correlation. | [
-0.0378689505,
0.0423615985,
0.0048833801,
-0.0158440117,
-0.0013634914,
-0.0436944887,
0.0349261165,
-0.0091364551,
-0.0804002434,
0.041830007,
-0.1230655983,
-0.0171769336,
0.029071236,
0.0380789079,
0.0327291451,
-0.0829538405,
0.0144828595,
-0.0443440229,
0.0009786499,
-0.0169224534,
-0.0018782276,
-0.0037377218,
-0.0437794216,
0.0099713346,
-0.0220102016,
-0.0047814301,
0.0217982214,
0.0281626247,
0.0182687212,
-0.0176954139,
-0.0252782758,
-0.0597711876,
0.0172444638,
0.0384395532,
0.0000016148,
-0.0312103163,
-0.0226018857,
0.0091329217,
-0.0225413237,
0.0054221628,
0.031966038,
0.0341003165,
-0.0290839467,
0.0184080414,
-0.0512712598,
-0.0413706787,
0.0235678554,
-0.0245864242,
0.0578203462,
0.0720539689,
0.0032857303,
-0.0297737624,
-0.0111021632,
-0.0173865929,
-0.0123403864,
-0.0009707981,
-0.0367424525,
0.0048203254,
0.0006940908,
-0.0343304016,
0.0000316246,
0.0554504655,
-0.0265947878,
0.0109988386,
0.0279905852,
0.0084285541,
-0.029143434,
-0.0694708452,
0.0192347094,
0.028483158,
0.0175296701,
0.0067303991,
0.0083932448,
0.0506641679,
-0.0159410629,
0.0045821834,
-0.0236382987,
-0.0134817204,
0.021071583,
0.0037321313,
-0.0852986053,
0.0770788863,
0.0073684282,
-0.0727258176,
0.0199386943,
-0.0088849114,
0.0205355603,
-0.042304527,
0.0296507385,
0.0007733375,
0.0123938071,
0.0117216129,
0.0609246045,
-0.0182872843,
-0.0221358016,
-0.0227270629,
-0.0444089808,
-0.011019866,
-0.0315223001,
-0.0217493698,
0.0762137547,
0.0351688042,
-0.0217361413,
0.0032708382,
-0.0158380046,
0.0377017595,
-0.0198612064,
-0.0001106456,
-0.0362990052,
-0.0204530172,
-0.0289458781,
0.0237997323,
-0.0349919945,
-0.0360135809,
-0.0015639334,
-0.0173956063,
-0.0181150008,
-0.0255669616,
-0.0676198602,
0.0094367703,
0.0162244141,
0.0262872633,
-0.0249332916,
-0.0391412228,
-0.000460026,
0.0473453812,
-0.0010045196,
0.0858250782,
-0.0095224772,
-0.0483055115,
0.0223806798,
0.0180634391,
0.0197499264,
0.0333459787,
0.0414334685,
0.0261059515,
0.0035971238,
0.0453635789,
0.005242656,
-0.0011123238,
0.0025134038,
-0.0315326788,
0.0089910924,
-0.0634901375,
0.0567364171,
-0.0537480637,
-0.0006208792,
-0.0146661503,
-0.0197241511,
0.0021509847,
0.0224039294,
0.0369813628,
0.0207478851,
0.0576990582,
0.0498268455,
-0.0026666443,
-0.0399612151,
-0.011348472,
0.0465700142,
-0.0011736143,
0.0173643548,
-0.0568020977,
0.0141793173,
0.0735925883,
0.055213403,
0.0234117284,
-0.0331310295,
-0.0028896441,
0.0246229377,
0.0860479772,
0.0800615251,
0.0488254242,
-0.0027099631,
-0.0597592182,
0.0874149948,
0.0518424883,
0.0449424982,
0.0084543247,
0.045333501,
0.0191736817,
0.0297644529,
-0.0211618617,
-0.050275851,
0.0114339152,
-0.0138333756,
0.0036749537,
0.0480278283,
0.0368428826,
-0.0298255645,
0.0250723436,
0.0124845821,
0.0017136283,
-0.0207283199,
-0.0394734517,
0.0050507337,
0.0434170179,
0.0060047521,
0.0185283795,
-0.0535804555,
-0.0809277222,
0.0375549383,
-0.0302462615,
-0.0013234211,
-0.0099502727,
0.0035720498,
0.0136201587,
0.0509915762,
-0.0402986296,
-0.0266438071,
0.051350072,
-0.0060765366,
-0.0389458984,
0.035450425,
-0.0047630612,
-0.0044129957,
0.0205922518,
-0.007858227,
-0.018395178,
-0.0339100175,
-0.0054672235,
0.0090469299,
-0.0297846552,
0.0758654177,
-0.0045733284,
-0.0403476693,
0.011014509,
0.0485216118,
0.0164894145,
0.0350589938,
0.0333680138,
-0.0154554201,
0.0340439677,
-0.0271502156,
-0.0362135619,
-0.0088942107,
0.0303971749,
-0.0074063051,
-0.0062281806,
0.0498599932,
-0.0787750483,
0.0684638917,
0.0778096914,
0.023730997,
-0.059762612,
0.0624734089,
-0.0181441493,
0.0266196318,
0.0170559511,
0.0151943089,
0.0267184004,
-0.0062297587,
0.0561862811,
-0.043429777,
0.0429547988,
-0.0228422657,
0.0079605607,
-0.0084496653,
0.0065308618,
-0.0798447132,
0.0101729352,
0.0394166335,
-0.0209216475,
0.042221874,
-0.0423006229,
-0.04988515,
-0.0410073437,
0.0030816665,
-0.0494203605,
0.0451344028,
0.0205635503,
0.0133826779,
0.0216401257,
-0.0072469232,
0.0036936495,
-0.0308175944,
-0.0655214116,
-0.0176629163,
-0.0055665541,
0.015223329,
-0.0444850735,
-0.0412836894,
-0.0240389034,
-0.0207871199,
-0.0061228154,
-0.0037732285,
-0.0002975575,
-0.0575799048,
0.017520858,
-0.0413777344,
0.0410654321,
-0.009542631,
0.0139393117,
0.0341394395,
0.0003301363,
-0.0001546642,
0.0117678298,
0.0158270802,
0.0148488041,
0.003207355,
-0.0721158162,
0.0206354726,
0.0204352941,
-0.0628160313,
-0.025887426,
0.0627848729,
0.0196362771,
-0.0312551036,
0.0024440731,
0.0281057637,
-0.0193844773,
0.0870684758,
0.0236100405,
-0.0302435439,
0.012712704,
-0.0367824547,
-0.0332471319,
0.000222142,
0.0191503074,
-0.0226965882,
0.0138223181,
-0.0371186323,
-0.0242255498,
-0.0025541303,
-0.0652171299,
-0.0545596667,
-0.0327678844,
-0.0421124361,
0.0034898249,
-0.0096907234,
-0.0444689877,
0.0102182031,
-0.0345099047,
0.0244405586,
-0.0376480147,
0.0279397182,
0.0338771567,
-0.0607949309,
0.025586158,
-0.0054937778,
-0.0032731097,
-0.052433759,
-0.0088754045,
-0.0044188574,
0.0074136807,
-0.0009152029,
0.0335884839,
0.014946009,
-0.0583707765,
0.0270489324,
0.038220156,
-0.0026103752,
0.0539793596,
0.0091218185,
-0.0115677165,
0.0295912791,
0.0573869832,
-0.0048748194,
0.0498501807,
-0.0243174266,
-0.0146243051,
0.0086854137,
0.0092103835,
0.0609956272,
0.0349832848,
-0.0436533242,
-0.0108717326,
0.0190663543,
0.031742841,
-0.0129523193,
0.0141724944,
0.0632863566,
-0.0191958621,
0.025831949,
0.0466406792,
-0.0361125395,
-0.0511719622,
0.0002020101,
0.0014820582,
-0.0121745486,
0.0011377713,
-0.0156888384,
-0.0316145755,
-0.0082574757,
0.0380133875,
0.070556201,
0.0353578441,
0.0281400569,
-0.0250459444,
-0.0566947199,
0.0211286135,
0.0340416171,
-0.0507306755,
-0.0338111967,
-0.027378602,
0.0106824599,
-0.0178412497,
0.0117765656,
0.001964309,
-0.0088720899,
-0.0120174149,
0.0196477361,
-0.0232012197,
-0.0231450647,
0.0027275209,
-0.0565224476,
0.1106404439,
0.0771518797,
0.0351815,
0.0138945999,
-0.068475686,
-0.0331041738,
0.0024297461,
0.0054850266,
0.0348182134,
0.0379260555,
0.0494572744,
0.0217384435,
0.0303680152,
0.0607663468,
-0.043836128,
0.0082307355,
0.0089110052,
0.0482167564,
0.0091345422,
-0.0229883716,
-0.0188968983,
0.0503457636,
0.0204835851,
0.0955803171,
0.0329810232,
-0.0569537431,
0.020775998,
0.0154522825,
0.0586814098,
-0.0380695388,
-0.0789592862,
0.0397841036,
0.0199274514,
-0.0606168471,
-0.0256330296,
0.0396597385,
-0.0022616014,
0.0654263273,
0.0004438524,
-0.0324947499,
-0.0073082764,
-0.0054752817,
-0.0111339949,
-0.0145885423,
-0.0422682799,
0.0603703223,
-0.0249711145,
-0.0324443541,
0.0138624925,
0.01700221,
0.0146745276,
-0.0239279829,
-0.0727024451,
-0.0099981576,
0.0160617437,
-0.0065694698,
0.0165007971,
0.0404405855,
-0.0014123351,
-0.0014431209,
0.0168445557,
-0.0217337795,
-0.0258028023,
0.069606483,
0.0695255324,
0.0256534442,
-0.0152783226,
0.0169566907,
0.0008134632,
0.0054120002,
-0.000685851,
0.0297160745,
0.0433036685,
-0.0642161146,
0.0120149311,
0.021057345,
0.0065120463,
-0.0118821841,
0.0319676511,
-0.0243994407,
-0.0135445893,
-0.0264542513,
0.050193768,
-0.0613167807,
-0.0775753632,
0.0735889748,
0.0773319304,
0.031434752,
0.0146864094,
-0.0243620016,
-0.0093843266,
-0.052390378,
0.0204524342,
0.0795174688,
0.0489451885,
0.0205651578,
0.0024786687,
0.0002402203,
0.0153501416,
0.0069033466,
0.0024069338,
-0.0068600941,
0.0030458381,
0.0185018908,
-0.012137725,
0.0036303799,
0.0297314543,
-0.0346781723,
-0.0226298571,
-0.0309281237,
-0.0330684818,
-0.0035642658,
0.0266559776,
0.0768161789,
0.0327718742,
0.0334109813,
-0.0009003289,
-0.0000122293,
-0.0724339634,
0.0408956446,
-0.00569851,
-0.0421322845,
0.004965717,
-0.0015266892,
0.0451074243,
-0.039120622,
0.009358516,
-0.0612615086,
0.0312101003,
0.0324987657,
-0.0218597837,
-0.0240743477,
-0.0344925895,
-0.0170622412,
-0.0596837252,
-0.032977026,
-0.0360028408,
-0.0062322761,
-0.0016726183,
-0.0036326882,
-0.0166450907,
0.0137751689,
-0.0013718317,
-0.0342380852,
0.0060968837,
0.0132457335,
-0.0525225326,
0.0257504731,
-0.0364538357,
-0.0214239396,
-4.851429388e-33,
-0.0243124291,
0.0419472121,
0.0269536395,
-0.0039541619,
-0.0560051017,
-0.0325038619,
-0.0400472842,
-0.0016885716,
0.0082743885,
-0.0058169104,
-0.0215097386,
0.0133123789,
-0.0033268512,
0.0153982639,
0.0036968468,
-0.0060849083,
0.11310675,
-0.0434700958,
-0.0492417514,
0.0054230401,
0.05869288,
0.0205451064,
-0.0024167241,
-0.1243728399,
-0.0390434712,
0.0377109796,
-0.0177730229,
-0.0082884962,
0.0263145696,
-0.0129304575,
0.007789195,
0.0362396948,
-0.0174968168,
-0.0456064939,
-0.046350766,
-0.0120448796,
-0.0469770059,
-0.0155207748,
-0.0416803248,
0.0444402657,
-0.0024691683,
0.0296701472,
0.0046719736,
0.0140540246,
-0.0523668453,
-0.044045914,
0.0065877186,
-0.0618198216,
-0.0036295541,
-0.0680162236,
-0.0254431628,
0.006198287,
0.0137989009,
-0.0361477956,
0.0596585125,
0.091335915,
-0.0629488304,
-0.0308635868,
-0.0369475074,
0.0535928793,
-0.0692469478,
0.02133899,
0.0655586123,
0.0316035263,
-0.0057825055,
0.0055583231,
0.0800422281,
-0.0854620114,
0.0131657254,
-0.0015774644,
0.0342440009,
0.0613655336,
0.0216499493,
0.037392173,
0.0314006805,
-0.0413406827,
0.0604887642,
0.0372050665,
-0.0041631726,
-0.0607662499,
-0.052782543,
0.0745550245,
-0.0098841162,
0.0150233172,
-0.0396589376,
-0.0485833772,
0.0029254276,
-0.0382891111,
0.0461574793,
-0.0341844447,
-0.0054942733,
-0.0157218277,
0.0322817266,
-0.0319487676,
0.0398368947,
-0.022967428,
-0.0009468505,
-0.0033259513,
-0.0096644303,
-0.0524456613,
-0.0095924232,
-0.046331387,
0.0660694689,
0.0343172178,
0.0376905315,
-0.0351616405,
-0.0292729475,
0.0430514067,
-0.0439426713,
-0.0224524681,
0.0206939615,
-0.0127867674,
0.0193447601,
0.0176509339,
0.0234224238,
-0.0104631046,
0.0140720922,
0.0056225308,
-0.0125811519,
0.0095974533,
0.0110599287,
0.0166329648,
0.0323178619,
0.0034418525,
-0.0391156189,
0.0135686379,
-0.0336269513,
-0.0698828548,
0.0411244556,
-0.0197255407,
-0.0192304496,
-0.0081256889,
2.425e-7,
-0.0248231813,
-0.0482209548,
0.0184432007,
-0.0510156266,
0.022680901,
0.0543648526,
-0.043972075,
0.0100537967,
-0.0137393167,
0.0070631467,
0.0171296801,
-0.0403895453,
0.1097613797,
0.0562739037,
-0.0336518362,
-0.066167213,
-0.0408696905,
0.0150851738,
-0.0147912484,
0.0019534277,
0.0284586698,
0.0299519021,
0.0102105541,
-0.0730368346,
0.0153498445,
-0.0257967077,
0.0150472783,
-0.024681773,
0.0104939453,
-0.0353135094,
0.0059934976,
-0.0603792891,
-0.0015226734,
0.0158959143,
-0.0105628567,
0.0340591483,
0.0795125961,
0.0445811413,
0.0176703148,
-0.0350075625,
-0.042406451,
0.0521285236,
-0.0123774009,
0.0305253454,
0.0267733745,
0.0006019371,
-0.0214589555,
-0.0349339731,
-0.034722928,
0.0480364151,
0.0098519288,
-0.0299993493,
0.0237326287,
-0.0204835199,
0.0204241686,
0.0432106219,
-0.0141149797,
0.0061025959,
-0.0061655412,
0.0101386001,
-0.0835585892,
-0.0491301045,
-0.0043045171,
0.0292053632,
-0.0144909825,
0.0184996761,
-0.0325405262,
1.377699927e-34,
-0.0206459742,
-0.0248456802,
0.0527624823,
-0.0247349124,
-0.0267791785,
-0.0528601743,
0.0354500562,
0.0035696106,
-0.026561603,
-0.0128858443,
-0.0236903019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14393v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14393v1 | Constraint-aware and Ranking-distilled Token Pruning for Efficient Transformer Inference | 2023-06-26T03:06:57 | 2023-06-26T03:06:57 | Junyan Li, Li Lyna Zhang, Jiahang Xu, Yujing Wang, Shaoguang Yan, Yunqing Xia, Yuqing Yang, Ting Cao, Hao Sun, Weiwei Deng, Qi Zhang, Mao Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Deploying pre-trained transformer models like BERT on downstream tasks in
resource-constrained scenarios is challenging due to their high inference cost,
which grows rapidly with input sequence length. In this work, we propose a
constraint-aware and ranking-distilled token pruning method ToP, which
selectively removes unnecessary tokens as input sequence passes through layers,
allowing the model to improve online inference speed while preserving accuracy.
ToP overcomes the limitation of inaccurate token importance ranking in the
conventional self-attention mechanism through a ranking-distilled token
distillation technique, which distills effective token rankings from the final
layer of unpruned models to early layers of pruned models. Then, ToP introduces
a coarse-to-fine pruning approach that automatically selects the optimal subset
of transformer layers and optimizes token pruning decisions within these layers
through improved $L_0$ regularization. Extensive experiments on GLUE benchmark
and SQuAD tasks demonstrate that ToP outperforms state-of-the-art token pruning
and model compression methods with improved accuracy and speedups. ToP reduces
the average FLOPs of BERT by 8.1x while achieving competitive accuracy on GLUE,
and provides a real latency speedup of up to 7.4x on an Intel CPU. | [
0.0137634175,
0.0544968396,
0.0092792297,
0.0207337942,
-0.005703731,
-0.0016106473,
0.0485191755,
-0.0133244852,
-0.0339616127,
-0.0166374333,
-0.020999603,
-0.0031042038,
-0.0081413724,
-0.0061612516,
0.0315201953,
-0.0411268882,
0.0317818038,
-0.0071976124,
0.0284951124,
-0.0109677361,
-0.0156011833,
-0.0096060662,
0.000357264,
0.0613850653,
-0.0268485136,
0.0005356604,
-0.0154659916,
0.0236898419,
0.0344721824,
0.0082218926,
0.0006260083,
0.0641783401,
0.015016403,
0.0227163509,
0.0000020434,
-0.0019891078,
-0.0352155566,
0.0040533273,
-0.0387326516,
0.0131355487,
-0.0452529117,
0.0334029719,
-0.0160871539,
0.0018898315,
0.0082254484,
0.0020988809,
0.0877093673,
0.0466689542,
0.0583878085,
0.06198157,
0.0033964252,
-0.0007786406,
0.0022945618,
-0.0426999703,
-0.0125442818,
-0.0555093363,
0.0134936273,
-0.0793921202,
-0.0395316184,
-0.0558042563,
-0.020073507,
0.0073044105,
0.0464095287,
0.0219145119,
-0.0179815888,
0.0482737124,
-0.0872600004,
-0.0294694602,
-0.0092808576,
0.0354005657,
-0.0802750438,
-0.036064554,
0.0081665507,
-0.0113883102,
-0.0089779394,
-0.0285211373,
-0.0357621834,
0.021957919,
-0.0116650499,
0.0102802496,
-0.0244644135,
0.0125684701,
0.0266066566,
0.0025044326,
-0.0759300888,
0.0487890467,
0.0186652038,
-0.0067456611,
-0.0344297141,
-0.0110467561,
-0.0439777859,
-0.0575500131,
0.0384909846,
0.0304007158,
-0.0373617709,
-0.0124299964,
-0.0433789492,
-0.0336445533,
-0.0236238148,
-0.0010699495,
0.0173120406,
0.0616177842,
-0.0121324966,
0.0362277925,
-0.0501460172,
0.0758675039,
-0.0379683934,
0.058485806,
-0.0374603122,
-0.0238074437,
0.0082187159,
-0.0239219684,
-0.0587089211,
0.0549974553,
-0.0379281603,
-0.0295928363,
-0.0384751782,
-0.0132872462,
-0.0118811298,
-0.0469919592,
0.0291677807,
0.0209782645,
-0.0576256216,
0.0005158068,
0.0013872015,
0.044076886,
-0.0260021649,
-0.0087712817,
0.0041591311,
-0.0490886122,
-0.0371461548,
0.0129721556,
-0.0016807321,
-0.0338386931,
0.0168216042,
0.0533480309,
-0.0072247623,
-0.0670917183,
-0.0029343641,
0.0262593403,
0.002551358,
-0.0454783514,
0.0207244866,
-0.0522018,
0.0292695593,
-0.0081119752,
0.0011841193,
-0.0038076921,
0.0012666909,
0.0178605728,
-0.0182687603,
0.0230672192,
0.0260094535,
-0.0180519223,
-0.0287850648,
-0.0034768966,
-0.0103228269,
0.0631473139,
0.0202149432,
0.0667039678,
-0.0095055616,
-0.0298681632,
-0.0143463193,
0.0313285552,
0.0417742729,
-0.0425983369,
-0.0383854359,
-0.0273525864,
-0.0312064309,
0.0153961871,
0.0517862402,
0.0556308813,
-0.0361512601,
-0.0391169824,
0.0410169326,
0.0512307957,
0.0372243859,
0.0294764321,
0.0259408206,
-0.0069840704,
-0.0044895667,
0.0115151163,
-0.075098224,
0.0629917756,
0.0456463881,
-0.0002915611,
0.0276812743,
0.0817551389,
-0.0256279837,
-0.0111219035,
-0.007020521,
-0.0052773673,
-0.0253399797,
0.0046951813,
0.0370995253,
0.0198389217,
-0.0576083101,
0.1525770873,
0.0100283027,
-0.0507654324,
-0.0444820933,
-0.0840326995,
-0.0130627286,
0.0316361226,
0.0383080244,
-0.0209602453,
-0.0827668533,
0.0314773135,
0.021003386,
0.0123043535,
0.0029641809,
0.014212871,
0.0407117233,
-0.0332157537,
-0.0402642451,
0.0132073844,
-0.0006814661,
0.0179966781,
0.0336021446,
-0.0242513288,
0.0167628247,
-0.0487895422,
0.006522133,
0.0402646028,
0.0231419317,
-0.0119130844,
0.0216930397,
0.0462892279,
0.0271067172,
0.0067925951,
-0.0138652371,
0.004431894,
0.0619439669,
-0.0373298079,
-0.0050984342,
0.0000487168,
-0.0661555305,
-0.0100055607,
0.0350918435,
-0.0289211422,
-0.026420081,
0.0656007528,
-0.0508958511,
-0.0350033604,
-0.0042986395,
-0.0744654611,
0.0607442036,
-0.01835154,
0.0151512017,
0.0138259009,
0.0036462331,
-0.0010377511,
0.0439343862,
-0.0339500122,
0.0132062323,
0.0357369743,
-0.0016234163,
-0.0128870877,
-0.0354186818,
-0.0180037916,
-0.0077309217,
-0.0388777703,
-0.0145863984,
0.0290961992,
-0.008938944,
0.0047354475,
-0.0230869018,
-0.06579905,
-0.0006512475,
-0.0364458747,
0.0480980277,
-0.0095360726,
0.0355885923,
0.0141488165,
-0.0261546392,
0.0157412216,
-0.0477628,
-0.0349359661,
0.0203753691,
-0.0101953615,
-0.0106676463,
-0.0267961286,
0.0049870508,
-0.0440025851,
-0.0013245414,
0.0719434246,
-0.0268851612,
-0.029223932,
-0.0178967621,
-0.0654615164,
-0.0157313868,
0.0446943678,
-0.0137515878,
-0.044886481,
0.014002027,
0.0027816985,
0.0527864657,
0.0727895796,
0.0265288725,
0.0157611538,
0.0056855627,
0.0089024585,
-0.0397559367,
0.0446970649,
-0.0216997024,
0.0383520722,
-0.0205937121,
0.0116651021,
-0.0045754341,
0.1010194346,
-0.055965405,
-0.0038604301,
-0.0764321536,
0.0032898223,
0.0337500535,
-0.0337708108,
0.0125958268,
-0.0257142782,
-0.0443343595,
-0.0089057842,
-0.0199276097,
-0.0297307428,
0.0749313161,
-0.0311506446,
-0.0137174148,
-0.026324844,
0.0237825848,
-0.0045372299,
0.0396262556,
0.0264726467,
0.0358483605,
-0.0176285915,
-0.0393221155,
-0.0512408875,
0.039830301,
-0.0127737802,
-0.0115812784,
0.0320565812,
0.0087784221,
0.0103871608,
-0.0269852914,
-0.0457647853,
-0.0375228561,
0.0006535074,
-0.023896344,
0.0318377018,
0.0463922508,
-0.0593489632,
-0.0878729075,
0.0339999534,
0.0142102716,
0.0689176172,
-0.0154889077,
0.0316157788,
-0.0244750325,
0.0295729991,
0.0173068941,
0.0365770981,
0.0667371899,
-0.0094560701,
0.0056185918,
0.0643187463,
0.0640734136,
-0.010622385,
-0.0493187495,
-0.0111280512,
0.016754644,
-0.0507695228,
0.0109114628,
0.0225326624,
0.0301056765,
-0.0568828881,
0.0045187194,
0.079490833,
-0.0022824919,
-0.0339775532,
0.0143998051,
0.0234506726,
0.0331855044,
0.01405627,
0.0316075124,
-0.0483341254,
-0.038389992,
0.0321665555,
0.0288970079,
0.016184954,
-0.0179694314,
0.0149294818,
-0.078419514,
0.0326403528,
-0.029238658,
-0.0308518913,
-0.0099712135,
-0.0537949242,
-0.0061161714,
-0.022762714,
0.0070016868,
0.0205598753,
-0.0108639393,
-0.0168533996,
0.0285840798,
-0.0028896541,
-0.0220379643,
0.0208294764,
-0.0323691107,
-0.0054757618,
0.0314140171,
0.0049066143,
0.0014217679,
-0.0797195733,
0.0686416253,
0.004917217,
0.0009324072,
-0.0102037275,
0.0338120237,
-0.0284399968,
-0.0132497055,
-0.0291782394,
0.0043393988,
0.0105229476,
-0.0246695261,
-0.0683564693,
0.0752229467,
0.0118627297,
-0.0053181285,
-0.015340006,
-0.0158306696,
-0.032776475,
0.0453023799,
0.0425840616,
-0.0139957778,
-0.060598176,
-0.0120735085,
0.0156022413,
-0.0618578531,
-0.0152669577,
0.0076072137,
0.000604175,
-0.1064487845,
-0.0290981941,
0.0368111804,
0.0034130556,
0.0698119998,
-0.028210219,
-0.0416101553,
0.0225238912,
0.0250781216,
-0.0628377348,
0.0513205715,
0.0097087575,
0.0028161632,
-0.0763607472,
0.0176768843,
0.0217472166,
-0.0013739803,
-0.0421037339,
0.0232961979,
-0.0915691108,
-0.0431210697,
0.0205300413,
0.0722966492,
0.0200462937,
0.0447590202,
-0.0114684543,
-0.0156949237,
0.0341616273,
0.0791659728,
-0.0452438295,
0.0054212776,
0.0441589467,
-0.0839483216,
-0.0225585047,
0.0307790209,
-0.0522500165,
0.0379110277,
0.0177428108,
0.0664940551,
-0.0001371466,
0.0043893158,
0.0133772343,
0.0119088823,
0.0732010603,
-0.0225450397,
0.0195047762,
0.0100527285,
0.0755365938,
0.0215934236,
0.0138657549,
-0.0338477716,
0.0091247167,
-0.0191031173,
0.0194804054,
0.0236983504,
0.0105879242,
0.0351675712,
-0.0272817109,
-0.036411088,
0.0293064173,
-0.0154544208,
-0.0061404547,
0.0287719239,
-0.0312312562,
-0.0085553247,
-0.0219066963,
0.0291622728,
0.0192117169,
-0.0413721502,
-0.0278750341,
0.0489869863,
0.0335197672,
-0.0499119721,
0.0363204665,
-0.0500376485,
-0.0587749407,
-0.0500632152,
-0.0028131297,
0.0404780768,
0.0141101358,
0.0192113388,
0.005172397,
-0.0223874338,
0.0079831937,
0.00047692,
0.0094344532,
-0.002109441,
0.0272948463,
0.030515328,
0.0231368821,
-0.0084463647,
0.0662021488,
0.0009883225,
0.0292475931,
-0.0223653503,
-0.0257271659,
-0.0336128958,
-0.0734911636,
-0.0202808566,
0.0077457475,
-0.0204269793,
-0.0256578103,
-0.0307575185,
-0.0534203053,
0.0036745602,
0.0063800248,
0.0108436793,
-0.0215561315,
0.0510603935,
0.0544039421,
0.0105945403,
-0.0612274595,
0.0317618847,
-0.0126393558,
0.0258479752,
-0.0144347465,
0.0339288637,
-6.60056241e-33,
-0.0124580534,
-0.0029957599,
0.0266479794,
0.0023653095,
-0.0485559106,
0.0558550954,
-0.0349073112,
-0.0445516109,
0.0062395143,
-0.0001248425,
-0.0172348563,
0.0034634646,
0.0230731089,
0.0278355796,
-0.0120877307,
-0.0104237376,
0.0724616647,
0.0166764166,
-0.038745001,
0.0260240287,
0.0223465879,
0.0386250243,
0.0715905875,
0.0130834132,
-0.0682566389,
0.0329883099,
0.0166177414,
0.0004535998,
-0.0045616138,
0.0428757742,
-0.0124211041,
-0.0204898175,
0.0009763843,
-0.0812771246,
-0.0143314227,
0.028588593,
-0.0889285877,
-0.0214500483,
-0.0184608661,
0.0140162762,
-0.0091701541,
-0.0103031276,
0.0558653586,
0.0464259088,
-0.0039630886,
-0.0229631104,
0.0105155092,
0.0217860676,
-0.0342876129,
-0.0506464802,
-0.0342259891,
0.0351168998,
0.0042465981,
-0.0394363292,
0.0387356728,
0.0536756739,
-0.0122579038,
0.036280673,
-0.0555416271,
0.0033593134,
0.0192958545,
0.0512797832,
0.0709488392,
0.0349135883,
-0.0092935041,
0.0362731442,
0.0208107568,
-0.0122903204,
-0.0298004132,
-0.000623287,
0.0363543816,
0.0666128993,
0.0418167002,
-0.054096505,
0.0644824132,
0.0088344924,
-0.0756092444,
0.0144897746,
0.0196019746,
0.0753062367,
0.0281277914,
0.0297619496,
0.0017678399,
0.0016282852,
0.0196304377,
-0.0010925564,
-0.0164744984,
-0.005678101,
0.0040192469,
0.0248083416,
-0.0558944345,
0.0354918614,
0.0519920811,
-0.0232814942,
0.0264863465,
0.016804073,
0.0249618236,
0.0135792894,
0.0015816512,
0.0247904416,
-0.0621985607,
-0.0234430265,
0.0291693676,
-0.0034538391,
0.0195798948,
-0.0187697969,
0.0341646746,
0.0361252949,
-0.0465998426,
-0.0117395567,
-0.0252762493,
0.0003750864,
-0.0155025544,
0.0334959663,
0.060327366,
0.0137052275,
0.0097428486,
-0.0009890056,
-0.0118552009,
-0.0245998111,
-0.0212513227,
0.0609334968,
0.0388399996,
0.0522165708,
-0.0162398797,
-0.0075410497,
-0.0653988943,
0.0418957993,
-0.0331453122,
-0.0896170959,
-0.0483656898,
0.075950481,
2.918e-7,
0.0268866066,
0.0247491263,
0.050197307,
-0.0199367777,
-0.0037177352,
0.0043208539,
0.0147256292,
0.0253771041,
0.0105623836,
0.0267163217,
0.0272963457,
0.0171152391,
0.0175474063,
0.0035545903,
-0.087058045,
-0.0232066084,
-0.0984310582,
0.0055701863,
-0.036312107,
-0.0221189763,
0.0025093153,
0.0921970606,
-0.0079891402,
-0.0333224759,
0.0256688427,
0.0024126645,
0.0075418032,
0.0231618509,
0.049958691,
0.0101007037,
0.0161804426,
-0.004997937,
-0.0145553481,
0.0224971715,
-0.0018649299,
0.0304261968,
0.0228151958,
0.0459346659,
-0.0144271683,
-0.0333446115,
0.0024229644,
0.0031469888,
0.0066862856,
-0.0625351667,
0.0478887744,
-0.0580376871,
-0.0061366051,
-0.0106629031,
-0.0385515504,
0.0005267189,
-0.0206968226,
-0.0028149311,
-0.000128257,
0.0266315844,
0.0211182293,
-0.031843584,
-0.0200290121,
-0.0964372456,
-0.0102281505,
-0.0161348842,
-0.0816134438,
-0.0267315004,
-0.0529720224,
-0.0242115092,
0.0501045473,
-0.0248439591,
-0.0528823249,
2.900182417e-34,
0.0119518489,
-0.0258389413,
-0.0164022949,
0.0622416101,
0.0149419652,
-0.0274857543,
-0.012607215,
0.0042132,
-0.0175738987,
-0.0563373007,
-0.051586099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14377v1 | Synthetic Alone: Exploring the Dark Side of Synthetic Data for Grammatical Error Correction | 2023-06-26T01:40:28 | 2023-06-26T01:40:28 | Chanjun Park, Seonmin Koo, Seolhwa Lee, Jaehyung Seo, Sugyeong Eo, Hyeonseok Moon, Heuiseok Lim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Data-centric AI approach aims to enhance the model performance without
modifying the model and has been shown to impact model performance positively.
While recent attention has been given to data-centric AI based on synthetic
data, due to its potential for performance improvement, data-centric AI has
long been exclusively validated using real-world data and publicly available
benchmark datasets. In respect of this, data-centric AI still highly depends on
real-world data, and the verification of models using synthetic data has not
yet been thoroughly carried out. Given the challenges above, we ask the
question: Does data quality control (noise injection and balanced data), a
data-centric AI methodology acclaimed to have a positive impact, exhibit the
same positive impact in models trained solely with synthetic data? To address
this question, we conducted comparative analyses between models trained on
synthetic and real-world data based on grammatical error correction (GEC) task.
Our experimental results reveal that the data quality control method has a
positive impact on models trained with real-world data, as previously reported
in existing studies, while a negative impact is observed in models trained
solely on synthetic data. | [
0.0738675073,
0.0785037279,
-0.0125099421,
0.016687749,
-0.0011873614,
0.0099681802,
-0.0103851501,
-0.0417206176,
-0.0229333472,
-0.0658529475,
-0.0197961535,
-0.0539290644,
0.0071147559,
0.0248523522,
0.0421335362,
-0.0182040352,
0.0736386478,
0.0101785446,
-0.0050778235,
0.0032053161,
-0.0147490976,
-0.0177223571,
-0.0057321549,
0.031107923,
-0.0744161457,
-0.007522257,
0.0024959196,
0.0300824642,
0.0014963303,
0.0026626259,
0.0554420725,
0.070128791,
-0.0220314488,
0.0588426366,
0.0000018202,
-0.0456014872,
0.0280859638,
0.0038149306,
-0.0603063069,
0.0185594298,
0.0363221094,
-0.0016518787,
-0.0502857342,
0.0164379887,
-0.0226216353,
-0.0064329957,
0.0484397784,
0.023858387,
0.0441856384,
0.1043764651,
-0.0142689124,
-0.0311479419,
0.0640433803,
0.0212473869,
-0.0064536752,
0.0742710829,
0.035519436,
0.0055125323,
-0.021087205,
-0.036606025,
-0.0047587878,
0.0224016644,
0.0337455571,
-0.0201017763,
0.0172794759,
0.0241896193,
-0.0620093904,
-0.024656618,
-0.036424309,
0.041664537,
-0.020289775,
-0.0409783572,
-0.0276043098,
0.0030417826,
0.0473632067,
-0.044465214,
0.0006465801,
0.0316433087,
0.0039924732,
0.0366156027,
0.045922,
-0.0706988722,
0.0236990564,
-0.0064020394,
0.0088241408,
0.0366879888,
0.0126486504,
-0.0788654983,
-0.0231612101,
0.0583219528,
-0.0161773004,
-0.0554096065,
0.0134328837,
0.0026597893,
-0.0288763419,
-0.0072013391,
-0.0809564665,
-0.0790307373,
-0.0083360076,
-0.0609848276,
0.0367190093,
0.0245694183,
-0.0175162572,
-0.0337899067,
-0.0106379362,
0.0270359982,
0.0574321449,
0.0573097803,
0.0149219874,
0.0079369452,
-0.0130687645,
0.0099797798,
-0.0139123537,
0.0442364998,
-0.0687727332,
0.0227191765,
-0.0493573919,
0.0056195268,
-0.0426604711,
0.0172235984,
0.0498449728,
0.0341724567,
-0.055606015,
0.0169668347,
-0.0317886285,
-0.0424764045,
-0.0149954157,
0.0634386912,
0.0246865954,
-0.0930337608,
-0.002049577,
-0.0001456117,
0.0278958473,
-0.0085528502,
0.0113127055,
0.0190114137,
-0.0138724716,
-0.0192568116,
-0.0611923225,
-0.0015852732,
-0.0128049934,
-0.0514005236,
-0.0184207112,
-0.0523462445,
-0.0007363003,
-0.0282749273,
0.00258871,
-0.0240777247,
-0.0097298548,
-0.0095938006,
-0.0111767342,
0.0624547116,
-0.0735775456,
0.0304050166,
-0.0031332884,
-0.0150830206,
0.0425909758,
0.0392383859,
0.040289972,
-0.0424892344,
0.024089586,
0.0005222671,
0.0533410721,
-0.007607481,
-0.0092353867,
-0.0113678388,
-0.0117140999,
-0.016388474,
-0.0421795435,
0.0209553074,
0.0466815643,
0.0734920129,
-0.0237844251,
0.0326242633,
0.091087468,
-0.0205382071,
0.0131117487,
0.011756598,
0.0350054689,
-0.052118022,
0.061140541,
0.023902256,
-0.0618599169,
-0.0128769353,
-0.0411456376,
0.0128068812,
-0.002217656,
0.0042694402,
-0.0175937023,
-0.0770954043,
-0.0023887055,
0.009455842,
-0.0154398978,
-0.0125466539,
-0.0081502981,
0.0463552028,
-0.0166679248,
0.0153677929,
0.0154813295,
-0.0668425113,
-0.0300149806,
-0.0224192571,
-0.0084308358,
0.0560013987,
0.0527166799,
0.0012202448,
-0.0554694943,
-0.0382686816,
-0.0370169282,
0.0490359329,
0.043804571,
-0.0049368548,
0.0080323825,
-0.0318626128,
0.0071791932,
-0.0026722888,
0.0349378698,
-0.0260166768,
0.0204167366,
0.0057650567,
-0.0237816833,
0.0112234773,
-0.0723791271,
0.0459571406,
-0.019260712,
-0.023750918,
-0.0148296123,
-0.0032939222,
0.0250941105,
0.0023028248,
-0.0593215264,
-0.004671257,
0.0064604692,
-0.0014150649,
-0.0188605152,
0.000178196,
-0.0433035828,
-0.0440161489,
0.0433460996,
-0.0314814337,
-0.0439375937,
0.0625276938,
-0.0172136817,
-0.0380525701,
-0.0122698126,
-0.049243141,
0.0046781395,
-0.0488313623,
0.0501908511,
-0.0080469353,
0.0438259616,
-0.0125084566,
0.0304065142,
-0.0012357746,
0.0187496673,
-0.0174299274,
0.0337751471,
-0.0092901215,
-0.0340541974,
-0.0217939094,
-0.0123888124,
-0.0155223366,
0.0381219238,
-0.0033729237,
0.0117529305,
-0.0429277681,
0.004763654,
-0.0748472661,
-0.0149751492,
-0.0275210049,
0.0142389042,
0.0479206182,
-0.0178698897,
-0.0390039161,
0.0040474599,
-0.0017254204,
0.0051366561,
0.0272534806,
0.0097054606,
0.0660453066,
-0.0255368669,
-0.0114055201,
-0.0704686493,
0.0047930111,
-0.037228778,
-0.0109259347,
0.0035068204,
-0.0048015337,
-0.0553147458,
0.0659877211,
-0.0227308571,
0.0521360412,
0.043233294,
-0.0715461522,
0.0240355339,
0.0135456603,
0.0793365687,
0.02989305,
-0.0276472233,
-0.0005983145,
0.0391451418,
-0.0073429695,
-0.0079255961,
0.0032709781,
0.0163580682,
0.0242156629,
-0.0203391202,
-0.0256614257,
-0.0011569082,
0.0580624193,
0.0174758639,
-0.0241374373,
-0.0003546997,
0.0477537848,
-0.0096207028,
-0.0587761812,
0.0003939262,
-0.0044026165,
-0.0327093415,
0.0219343249,
-0.0644489005,
-0.0035970518,
0.0675543919,
0.0266461018,
-0.0026572538,
-0.0384879187,
-0.007024311,
0.0213851333,
-0.0432155989,
-0.0089454288,
0.0115502402,
-0.0291656088,
-0.0109630153,
-0.0625563264,
-0.001171003,
0.0461683311,
-0.0098871309,
0.024012465,
-0.0573003478,
0.0214219335,
0.0141694481,
-0.0678199828,
-0.0491320305,
-0.0354222879,
0.006697352,
-0.0093053356,
0.0350753516,
-0.0386236757,
-0.0043398631,
-0.0354686007,
-0.000719152,
0.083458975,
-0.0181511324,
-0.0415365696,
-0.0130129624,
-0.0131665887,
0.0306455046,
0.0113984467,
0.0420187265,
0.0135393478,
0.025498651,
0.0390898101,
0.0099952789,
0.0292811207,
-0.0479090698,
0.0168681554,
0.0125273494,
0.0041992548,
-0.0195784159,
0.0130470302,
0.0389015712,
-0.0363091119,
-0.0520028695,
0.0895142928,
0.0193073656,
-0.0088557275,
0.0099938102,
0.0091101807,
0.0089944098,
0.0308760554,
0.014155155,
-0.0440521277,
0.0019369692,
0.0459629595,
0.0062758792,
-0.0295110457,
-0.0255279876,
0.0243868995,
-0.1434281319,
0.0798860714,
0.0017430633,
-0.0367505774,
-0.0826754645,
-0.0204443205,
0.0119681759,
0.0176278632,
0.0437136479,
0.0270081293,
-0.0057018092,
-0.0170548521,
0.0346495584,
-0.0337912031,
-0.0925596282,
-0.0341327079,
-0.0563775711,
0.0769460946,
0.0450897738,
0.0304962676,
0.0063507194,
-0.0200390946,
0.0554406159,
0.0513385385,
-0.0054826722,
0.0177557748,
0.0660782158,
0.0165249258,
-0.0255031809,
-0.0331716575,
0.0145446174,
-0.0415342636,
0.0064803734,
-0.0495310389,
0.0752629116,
-0.0196661297,
-0.0000986439,
-0.0016471432,
-0.0294121634,
0.0403770618,
0.037309289,
0.0492255017,
-0.0315209441,
-0.0578418709,
-0.0460373759,
0.0047802655,
-0.0517434254,
0.0119115794,
0.0517791174,
-0.0270989947,
-0.0614316463,
-0.0769704655,
-0.1124037579,
-0.0056482311,
0.016306961,
0.0355102867,
-0.0509372652,
-0.0309403241,
-0.0256800782,
-0.0067295381,
-0.002265689,
-0.0283860862,
0.0291097611,
-0.0406955145,
0.0039297054,
-0.0188419577,
0.0210426021,
0.0050624409,
-0.0104361968,
-0.0359847061,
-0.0516012162,
0.0735350549,
0.0686887056,
0.0143589089,
0.0395059846,
-0.0164119974,
-0.0646980181,
0.005540282,
0.0634330884,
-0.0408160277,
0.0324904025,
0.056048058,
-0.0594446212,
0.0159249231,
0.0037403621,
-0.0006389725,
0.0173196122,
0.04625744,
0.0407481566,
-0.024194479,
0.0088317851,
0.0538522415,
0.047213126,
0.068530865,
-0.0042954222,
-0.0201566741,
-0.0745453686,
0.0037202444,
-0.050595399,
-0.0309958812,
-0.0244731195,
-0.0027697561,
0.0118698524,
0.0440254807,
-0.0298137367,
0.0227001365,
-0.0448755473,
0.0195758957,
-0.0232289322,
-0.0293715429,
0.0323293209,
0.0494084917,
0.0179990325,
0.0288074911,
-0.0149425948,
0.0422629863,
0.035777159,
0.038325768,
0.0196605865,
-0.028055422,
0.0208931789,
0.017513819,
-0.023769645,
-0.002655735,
-0.0579720289,
0.0282402039,
-0.0532390773,
0.0324103236,
0.0763259009,
0.0070459289,
0.0580611937,
-0.0231347624,
-0.0141433123,
-0.0149766905,
0.0007480533,
0.0009853145,
0.007985224,
-0.0045012138,
-0.0174821503,
-0.0136730187,
-0.040459007,
0.0407861732,
-0.0001202922,
0.0946909413,
-0.0686560348,
-0.0223287772,
-0.0312679373,
-0.0021880697,
0.010831912,
-0.0489747636,
0.0001421211,
-0.0129141631,
-0.0302261338,
-0.1036735848,
-0.016873328,
0.0566470884,
0.0395397358,
-0.0109107327,
0.0021592544,
0.0203430634,
-0.0130160609,
-0.0024973499,
-0.0354027599,
-0.0087496536,
0.033222191,
-0.0150035117,
-0.0458173417,
-5.988702907e-33,
-0.0316375531,
0.0114488211,
-0.0068845865,
-0.0335671529,
-0.0198217537,
-0.030564189,
-0.0415501259,
0.0206947196,
0.0078977039,
0.0621472225,
-0.0492947325,
0.0646733642,
0.016751742,
0.0007786559,
0.0345399491,
-0.0005297181,
0.0584466867,
-0.0339956507,
-0.0204453524,
-0.056922216,
0.0434677899,
0.0415689796,
0.0754354969,
-0.0531415455,
0.0450129323,
0.01083594,
-0.0173244607,
0.0119383559,
-0.0278041158,
0.0353474095,
0.0218377318,
0.0651600286,
0.0239475518,
0.0301288161,
-0.0236832052,
-0.0194381755,
-0.056139037,
-0.0578629337,
-0.0029096266,
0.0356692336,
-0.0074447254,
-0.0374148078,
0.0704433024,
-0.0086499806,
-0.0460008942,
0.0332128555,
0.0018982812,
-0.0437749736,
0.0129049113,
-0.0249719564,
-0.0621403828,
-0.0014043489,
0.0073529342,
0.0062645259,
-0.0143208085,
0.0445694476,
-0.0026825049,
-0.0460208654,
-0.0566296913,
-0.0060307188,
0.0225375462,
0.0252588931,
0.0343496539,
0.002784251,
-0.0250539761,
0.0233280621,
0.0608542524,
0.0450290032,
-0.040930938,
0.0224375837,
0.0379538536,
0.0161633957,
0.0422303639,
0.0871053264,
0.0536101684,
-0.0578075089,
-0.029002618,
0.0210656729,
-0.0435769521,
-0.0058795782,
-0.0285226908,
-0.0022057695,
-0.0597483478,
-0.0408654474,
-0.0092594167,
0.0148460586,
-0.0130189238,
0.0259911381,
0.0562982969,
-0.0021473172,
0.0060286322,
0.0073274542,
-0.0272626467,
-0.0422343425,
-0.0080479272,
-0.024369359,
-0.0016725532,
0.0322159976,
0.0021447157,
-0.0207349434,
-0.0342619345,
-0.0326080769,
0.0360650904,
0.065279834,
0.0220156629,
0.015399823,
0.0523620769,
0.0530912802,
-0.0479020774,
0.0184863731,
-0.0096377647,
0.0484345183,
0.0449082144,
-0.0196389202,
0.0079668779,
-0.0157947727,
-0.0046503758,
0.0047830595,
0.0182047989,
0.0313997604,
-0.0202507656,
-0.0097712362,
-0.0176652074,
0.0336513966,
0.0071130511,
-0.0037220859,
-0.0555236936,
0.0006099394,
0.0348840579,
-0.0642511845,
0.0052383933,
-0.0118129486,
2.494e-7,
0.0064983633,
0.0290006194,
0.0341979377,
0.0130104776,
-0.0101857819,
-0.0050834343,
-0.0130282473,
0.0013915957,
0.0194983818,
0.028066691,
0.0311734937,
0.0247349199,
0.0451661982,
0.0160578135,
-0.0379793495,
-0.0273709223,
-0.0687418357,
0.0169136692,
-0.0401547998,
-0.007774903,
-0.0046132188,
0.0547571592,
0.02681203,
-0.0447163694,
-0.0027491697,
0.0071461867,
0.0085951462,
-0.002554076,
-0.0155353136,
0.041783087,
0.0736319348,
0.0142620159,
0.0333172902,
0.0142139783,
-0.0284212772,
-0.0150888711,
0.0161549635,
-0.0002062697,
-0.0397877917,
0.0394669399,
0.0144165754,
-0.0159556065,
-0.0153461313,
-0.0210044105,
0.0385646038,
-0.0025950486,
0.0210351143,
-0.0104854684,
-0.0286739934,
-0.0009914415,
0.0371823497,
-0.0500334539,
-0.019611869,
-0.0184912961,
0.0361369066,
0.0309534539,
-0.0112480214,
-0.0212212373,
-0.0296521671,
0.019807335,
0.0178927127,
-0.0229546465,
0.028001843,
-0.0027046092,
0.0505503602,
-0.0356931165,
0.0034924382,
2.233086159e-34,
0.0277353041,
0.01264155,
0.0712987259,
-0.0144782439,
0.0452965274,
0.0087794894,
0.0419402495,
-0.0117940251,
-0.0129457582,
-0.0054926053,
-0.0481482372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14374v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14374v1 | Transcending Traditional Boundaries: Leveraging Inter-Annotator Agreement (IAA) for Enhancing Data Management Operations (DMOps) | 2023-06-26T01:33:58 | 2023-06-26T01:33:58 | Damrin Kim, NamHyeok Kim, Chanjun Park, Harksoo Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents a novel approach of leveraging Inter-Annotator Agreement
(IAA), traditionally used for assessing labeling consistency, to optimize Data
Management Operations (DMOps). We advocate for the use of IAA in predicting the
labeling quality of individual annotators, leading to cost and time efficiency
in data production. Additionally, our work highlights the potential of IAA in
forecasting document difficulty, thereby boosting the data construction
process's overall efficiency. This research underscores IAA's broader
application potential in data-driven research optimization and holds
significant implications for large-scale data projects prioritizing efficiency,
cost reduction, and high-quality data. | [
0.0631718189,
0.0631065667,
-0.0022807594,
-0.0185263753,
-0.0181809049,
0.0177453738,
0.0451654792,
-0.019646652,
-0.001788742,
-0.0308237076,
-0.0240574405,
0.0459052324,
0.0003051585,
-0.0140176062,
-0.0307109337,
-0.0141850617,
0.0416498594,
0.0264462586,
0.02926917,
0.0042994251,
0.0418115892,
-0.0176857542,
0.0045563234,
0.0103250751,
-0.0762263909,
-0.0069391462,
0.0100346599,
-0.0281041488,
0.0104896743,
-0.0476616845,
0.04038468,
0.0550473444,
-0.0181683823,
0.0763133317,
0.0000021066,
-0.0385429896,
-0.0648562238,
0.0552880727,
-0.0256971195,
0.0621554777,
0.0311017632,
0.0006925146,
0.0110533079,
-0.0210370719,
-0.013749307,
-0.0011301414,
0.0399489626,
-0.0175432693,
0.0401162803,
-0.0146333463,
-0.0095511721,
-0.0174004212,
0.0443310514,
-0.0188085139,
0.017460376,
-0.0525280982,
-0.01643214,
0.0549892001,
-0.0069288309,
0.0126771778,
0.0113755707,
0.0676083788,
-0.004170747,
-0.0338360332,
0.0389136821,
0.0140269743,
-0.0312418435,
-0.0266964659,
0.0181843564,
0.0290572289,
0.1247578636,
0.0384980664,
0.0312271006,
-0.0360533521,
-0.0033381588,
0.0460103713,
-0.0333227292,
-0.0159261581,
-0.0128762675,
-0.0415180512,
0.0162632205,
0.0449040011,
0.0003077113,
0.0056408364,
-0.0191499274,
0.049858287,
-0.028209528,
-0.0430414341,
0.0673225597,
0.0157857612,
-0.0265783574,
-0.038111601,
-0.0018388015,
-0.0411897451,
-0.0052781925,
0.0008871278,
-0.0075834519,
-0.0752838477,
0.0540614948,
-0.0143731739,
0.0177902486,
-0.0107571119,
-0.002656304,
0.0418072939,
0.042680122,
0.0180987101,
0.0068712714,
0.015553751,
0.0219986532,
0.0323349349,
-0.0394681804,
-0.0141820619,
0.0241512917,
0.0109058283,
0.0374195017,
-0.0088603431,
-0.0448748544,
0.0191424079,
-0.0391459092,
0.0382650904,
0.0068366458,
-0.0202507842,
-0.0594590195,
0.0008163467,
-0.0472221524,
-0.0171380434,
-0.0147425188,
0.0501028635,
-0.0448706895,
-0.0002857953,
0.0518721528,
0.0244435966,
0.0149492575,
-0.0013511591,
0.0381736942,
0.0312603191,
0.0125052873,
0.0148647195,
-0.0275027584,
-0.0728962496,
-0.0003616516,
-0.0221408866,
0.0278833173,
-0.0329239294,
0.0418785438,
0.0130236456,
-0.0110401791,
-0.0343688279,
-0.0309781395,
-0.0183192957,
-0.0273398943,
0.0413436517,
-0.0813418776,
0.0158898327,
0.0382412933,
0.001349372,
-0.0072692535,
0.0013856579,
0.0433693007,
0.0118050147,
0.0368124843,
0.0071159103,
0.0362946987,
0.0183018502,
-0.0000644362,
0.0110751735,
0.0363403969,
0.0031207874,
0.0366969146,
-0.007269714,
-0.0223546699,
0.0467187911,
-0.043424096,
0.00983206,
0.0382336564,
0.0286848396,
0.0038668059,
-0.0139755281,
-0.0219957214,
0.0134084877,
0.0044642915,
-0.0241273399,
0.02373855,
0.0712038279,
0.049627699,
0.0077418345,
0.0573215373,
-0.0371853895,
-0.0146736354,
-0.0908063203,
-0.0333268158,
0.0379853994,
-0.0316992216,
-0.0100626592,
-0.0016756166,
-0.0165355969,
-0.0089058578,
-0.0126022808,
-0.0179118719,
-0.0328339711,
-0.0301853828,
0.0120630022,
0.001200397,
0.015473092,
0.0283468887,
-0.0664859563,
-0.0370678417,
-0.0257123299,
0.0221983548,
0.0196067467,
0.0305739995,
-0.0282170121,
-0.0321404561,
-0.0424386375,
-0.0572416596,
0.0270355605,
-0.0207323711,
0.0218711905,
-0.0231651478,
-0.0006351544,
-0.011602859,
-0.0484741554,
-0.0589232072,
0.0561897941,
-0.029004937,
-0.0112633239,
0.002751796,
0.0171511751,
0.0688738376,
0.0295605604,
-0.0384936742,
0.015338704,
0.040897321,
-0.0036027222,
0.0081294887,
-0.0102278208,
0.0693091974,
0.0682262257,
0.0098801283,
-0.051486928,
-0.0147409318,
-0.0644441098,
-0.0340067931,
-0.0383461043,
-0.0267294738,
-0.0342111364,
-0.0118718278,
0.0095795188,
0.0201520734,
-0.0053939396,
-0.0084182322,
-0.0412948132,
0.0198620148,
-0.0218036808,
0.0476241522,
-0.0019001797,
-0.0456769466,
0.0513675325,
0.0249667335,
0.0067949314,
0.0156612247,
0.0137948925,
0.016924575,
0.0669990852,
-0.0117574725,
-0.0400948152,
-0.0221852586,
-0.0602430776,
-0.0015917735,
0.0268489029,
0.021853758,
-0.0372125581,
-0.0334791131,
0.0013063229,
0.0105586005,
-0.0001403706,
-0.0224748608,
-0.0412600264,
0.0140246945,
0.0450486019,
0.0318039395,
-0.0227231402,
-0.0364850871,
-0.0304559674,
0.0067383815,
0.0060251774,
0.0988007709,
-0.0663358271,
-0.0195956156,
0.0007872042,
-0.0443147235,
-0.0382615589,
-0.0120792491,
0.0374900363,
0.0194404684,
0.031638667,
-0.0238871854,
0.0115195913,
-0.0420152172,
-0.0122036152,
0.0614287704,
-0.0501216948,
-0.0676078498,
0.0072230152,
0.0244907122,
-0.0053218012,
0.0484455675,
-0.0696728602,
0.0481725484,
0.0162919387,
-0.0335194394,
-0.0155558018,
-0.0243598893,
-0.0095858732,
-0.0426967256,
0.0028360137,
-0.0168960262,
-0.0078094173,
0.0099763721,
0.0986598656,
0.0013813734,
-0.0552765131,
0.0259699635,
-0.0352312773,
0.0348201506,
-0.0547552705,
0.0339788459,
-0.0404749252,
0.0146711133,
-0.0203737412,
-0.0208921675,
0.0085995104,
0.0166537911,
-0.0437939093,
0.0438659638,
0.0655419901,
-0.0323958322,
0.0137508921,
-0.0309808459,
0.0344136618,
-0.0146500738,
0.0006911184,
0.0008817356,
0.0042556725,
-0.0188337062,
-0.0079356963,
0.0705044717,
0.0048376103,
-0.0382038504,
0.0128386142,
0.0626694709,
0.0427668169,
0.0344638638,
-0.0401188843,
-0.007372098,
-0.046665296,
-0.0020225521,
-0.0367049687,
-0.0001843139,
-0.0185554121,
-0.0474122912,
0.0087917568,
-0.0184663627,
0.0400822982,
-0.0103063937,
-0.0202806722,
0.0011003138,
-0.0106436927,
-0.0535079055,
-0.0010340502,
-0.0242476724,
-0.0479316935,
0.0440915897,
0.0429571345,
0.0494528264,
-0.0612709634,
-0.0308333226,
-0.0076493793,
0.0379794836,
0.0073760222,
0.0123426886,
-0.0894731134,
0.0159128644,
-0.0023016792,
0.0593686476,
-0.0494138114,
-0.0725227296,
-0.0005858154,
-0.0325759389,
0.0608607344,
-0.0156706758,
-0.0494706519,
0.034437865,
-0.0762730166,
0.0055552041,
-0.0449019372,
-0.0194099508,
-0.0158834457,
0.0257159658,
-0.0047096442,
0.0260050353,
-0.0983895808,
-0.0160772726,
-0.0390470959,
-0.0164073054,
0.0397744253,
0.0437084772,
0.0526555181,
-0.0254848003,
-0.044826109,
0.0428920127,
0.0509507097,
-0.0236905385,
-0.0224878788,
0.1074724272,
0.0030674213,
0.0195396077,
-0.0036381593,
0.00137139,
0.0078590028,
0.0105944853,
0.0115242619,
0.0587926954,
0.0057910532,
0.0444220565,
-0.0134740183,
-0.0188795831,
-0.0097368695,
0.0381647572,
0.0056108469,
-0.0548327938,
0.0164143629,
-0.0113799982,
0.0702989623,
-0.0370382667,
0.0339016393,
0.0311938822,
-0.1468626857,
-0.0477550998,
-0.0390119553,
-0.0615110435,
0.0288042743,
-0.0018711482,
0.014712655,
-0.0082030678,
0.0000474649,
-0.0366712362,
-0.0381416529,
-0.0300534554,
0.006301526,
0.0172508452,
-0.0224793814,
-0.0196354892,
0.031597618,
0.0523752198,
-0.0302845314,
0.048143439,
0.0200177114,
-0.0407049842,
0.0326591022,
0.0289662033,
0.0197257921,
0.000869875,
0.0446031354,
-0.0480405204,
0.0013506913,
0.0543028079,
0.0303243194,
-0.0193922594,
0.0264959075,
0.0022050373,
-0.0487394445,
-0.0451718979,
-0.0458373539,
0.0231782123,
0.0171152353,
0.003305872,
-0.0268398803,
-0.0151143912,
0.0023609807,
0.0613913015,
0.0108545246,
-0.046393998,
-0.0092536444,
-0.0374333374,
-0.0076722088,
0.0084197493,
-0.035343796,
-0.0006940915,
0.032380335,
-0.0056631058,
-0.0157177616,
-0.0259728227,
0.1172844321,
-0.0012106132,
0.0199863166,
-0.0095639667,
0.0166887324,
-0.0008770541,
0.0414637439,
-0.0087634185,
-0.0131047163,
-0.0313188955,
-0.0209429581,
0.0363980569,
0.0403691754,
0.0151729723,
0.0116561549,
0.0377005227,
0.0375192016,
0.002633963,
-0.0011407719,
-0.045648925,
0.0021432745,
-0.0331101306,
-0.0107517838,
-0.010100713,
0.0289999973,
0.0526139066,
-0.0573153719,
-0.012711619,
-0.0113311708,
0.0243640132,
0.0405703373,
0.0172147024,
-0.004108842,
0.0019071402,
-0.0316042565,
-0.0127102342,
0.0659142584,
-0.001693564,
0.0018102849,
-0.1131647453,
-0.0466322079,
-0.0578483492,
0.0113557735,
0.015568655,
0.0064048725,
0.0130631234,
-0.0306119025,
-0.0784846172,
0.0111761438,
0.0423625037,
-0.0113773178,
-0.0091662593,
0.0057570101,
-0.0448332578,
0.0323680528,
0.0297752488,
-0.0121528208,
0.0067143743,
-0.0516954623,
-0.0481591485,
-0.0497063659,
0.0107488353,
-6.288714779e-33,
-0.0156454295,
-0.0221065804,
-0.0255343262,
0.0231459588,
-0.0301379226,
0.0350119136,
-0.007560635,
-0.0188037511,
0.0398177132,
0.0040081125,
-0.0431444794,
0.0052610883,
0.0073671271,
-0.0297940094,
0.1187699512,
0.0308201723,
0.054203175,
-0.0003781131,
-0.0552612096,
-0.0159274489,
0.0174459405,
-0.0235558022,
0.0125508327,
-0.083780311,
0.0699986666,
-0.0001853283,
-0.0041732546,
-0.0328144208,
0.0224703755,
0.0531268083,
-0.0096903769,
-0.0407361872,
0.0265155397,
-0.0372454934,
-0.0200187992,
-0.0018856734,
-0.0462171771,
-0.0319433957,
-0.0161615349,
0.0145687833,
0.0077339094,
-0.0298251268,
0.023869874,
0.0011337132,
-0.0356047265,
-0.0031688351,
0.0527980588,
-0.0161008127,
-0.0543400273,
-0.0628112629,
-0.0264635291,
0.029423546,
-0.0304023772,
0.0526150763,
0.0717546642,
0.0237799138,
0.0162031222,
0.0115592023,
-0.0872512683,
0.0378711224,
-0.0148644866,
-0.0015227544,
0.0397687964,
0.0172233488,
0.0152036287,
0.0321737342,
0.0044418541,
0.0488095731,
0.0865784809,
-0.0333857872,
0.0153983058,
0.0344154723,
0.0196444206,
0.0593429953,
0.0443349183,
-0.0151129458,
-0.037349049,
0.0745643526,
-0.0162043683,
-0.0129435016,
-0.0216277447,
0.0156473964,
-0.042634964,
-0.0541703589,
-0.037249472,
0.0172315612,
-0.0001083302,
0.0277910288,
-0.0028568257,
0.0065068295,
-0.0512386635,
0.0957280695,
0.0405208468,
-0.0224122237,
-0.0598817021,
0.0026175056,
-0.0145122334,
0.0783372149,
0.0024274141,
-0.0074671083,
-0.073229529,
-0.0011588337,
-0.0000163635,
0.0368941948,
0.0625537038,
-0.0120057631,
0.092826888,
0.0065756808,
-0.0683375746,
0.0088076461,
0.0152644534,
-0.0079018315,
0.0034465571,
-0.0956586227,
0.0076769311,
-0.0208606627,
0.0132929394,
0.0033812718,
0.0451303124,
0.0742663443,
-0.0319214389,
-0.0379066505,
-0.0218135603,
-0.0216292143,
0.0277394298,
-0.0011016808,
0.0331954062,
-0.0325908363,
0.0223102234,
-0.0203302074,
-0.0249450076,
-0.0270789247,
2.837e-7,
0.0515587479,
0.0768212974,
0.015198038,
-0.0200645048,
0.0122629069,
0.0170002691,
0.0036579231,
-0.0357440524,
-0.040354073,
-0.0263169613,
0.0593734048,
-0.0602360256,
0.0565019809,
0.0645132139,
-0.0073957834,
-0.0652983561,
-0.036786288,
-0.0315671712,
-0.0571279712,
-0.0083704842,
0.0253337082,
-0.0076803523,
-0.0134996511,
-0.0009416284,
-0.0173347667,
-0.0041261539,
0.0128192203,
-0.0243591201,
0.0297810808,
0.0753685981,
0.0888158083,
-0.0303631872,
-0.0131960176,
0.0516045466,
-0.0282819662,
-0.0126774702,
0.0224238988,
0.0098142177,
0.003140677,
0.0212086719,
0.0532463901,
0.0024707443,
0.0005501026,
-0.000160226,
0.0238096658,
-0.019158056,
-0.0349320099,
0.0008558338,
-0.049041938,
0.0054622213,
0.0449970067,
0.0096545462,
0.0304501299,
0.0323479511,
-0.0447597839,
0.0031285016,
-0.0268881377,
-0.0277832802,
0.0349605009,
0.0484131016,
-0.0023580652,
-0.0536842719,
0.0144556854,
-0.0052250996,
-0.0015118413,
-0.0536120869,
0.0238731857,
2.384685211e-34,
0.0588875748,
-0.045787517,
0.0155648636,
0.0278546251,
0.0134651698,
-0.0006138914,
-0.0176613759,
0.0208703782,
-0.0120637668,
-0.0396830775,
0.0199736971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14373v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14373v1 | Inter-Annotator Agreement in the Wild: Uncovering Its Emerging Roles and Considerations in Real-World Scenarios | 2023-06-26T01:28:58 | 2023-06-26T01:28:58 | NamHyeok Kim, Chanjun Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Inter-Annotator Agreement (IAA) is commonly used as a measure of label
consistency in natural language processing tasks. However, in real-world
scenarios, IAA has various roles and implications beyond its traditional usage.
In this paper, we not only consider IAA as a measure of consistency but also as
a versatile tool that can be effectively utilized in practical applications.
Moreover, we discuss various considerations and potential concerns when
applying IAA and suggest strategies for effectively navigating these
challenges. | [
0.0577274784,
0.0070991758,
-0.0059054582,
0.0077685183,
-0.0435755588,
0.0262799058,
0.0159701873,
-0.0530837737,
0.0210549626,
-0.0664620325,
-0.0328550935,
0.0090537211,
0.0305648521,
-0.0291858669,
-0.034351103,
0.0017201373,
0.0559210256,
0.0303611029,
0.0388888605,
0.0209791567,
0.072428003,
0.0228708312,
-0.0122826379,
0.0650161952,
-0.0773199871,
-0.0162563622,
0.0548474155,
-0.034289293,
0.0581796132,
-0.03202096,
0.0409764871,
0.0451720878,
-0.0336218551,
0.049976483,
0.0000018205,
-0.0391374044,
-0.0400058255,
0.0339274332,
-0.0097800978,
-0.00399051,
-0.0218395498,
0.0022481631,
-0.0126263825,
-0.009231044,
-0.0496378988,
0.0022045975,
0.0642252341,
0.0011095747,
0.0779212043,
0.0305358171,
-0.0167108998,
-0.0364082307,
0.0047043017,
0.0252205823,
-0.0260516312,
-0.0394159555,
0.0075278389,
0.0199419335,
-0.0281795766,
-0.0123382267,
0.0130285108,
0.0585056953,
-0.0048023281,
-0.027347967,
0.0144209862,
0.0107188262,
-0.0585953072,
-0.0463900641,
0.0071576131,
0.0441736951,
0.0653633699,
0.0114604868,
-0.0031644749,
-0.0123281032,
-0.0212719515,
0.0263482984,
-0.0296333078,
0.0217028689,
-0.0334945954,
0.0054608919,
0.0202952921,
0.037184678,
-0.0101926113,
-0.0057562133,
-0.0136759821,
0.095195502,
0.010622588,
-0.0330373608,
0.0278105419,
0.0310462099,
-0.0640534386,
-0.0637823641,
0.0388015397,
-0.0286079962,
-0.0344993398,
0.0184534416,
-0.0311006512,
-0.0378400572,
0.0410660766,
-0.0619582236,
0.0113911843,
0.0047818213,
-0.0417221189,
0.0334035195,
0.0316648111,
0.0331647508,
0.0351171978,
0.0359269418,
0.021041438,
0.0075136418,
-0.0375628248,
0.0101932362,
0.0022645441,
0.0061485963,
0.0433184803,
-0.0134056257,
-0.0485090539,
0.0155140869,
-0.0552841872,
0.0590670072,
0.00483739,
-0.0201814976,
0.009134504,
0.038900841,
-0.0238219295,
0.046833653,
-0.033154957,
0.0488211662,
-0.0447568744,
-0.0503576733,
0.0405492075,
0.0374341644,
-0.0230394118,
-0.0247291103,
-0.000254123,
0.0245481525,
0.0266540963,
-0.0061657103,
-0.0191292726,
-0.0394108146,
-0.0544362962,
-0.0809000209,
-0.0422121026,
-0.0652145445,
0.0344313979,
0.0134941284,
0.0261413287,
-0.0407761894,
-0.0015390656,
0.0067978906,
-0.0095333513,
0.0769367367,
-0.0412950665,
-0.0043144929,
0.0261195228,
-0.009979968,
0.0419889949,
0.0229125693,
0.0515761785,
-0.0208446588,
0.0729358494,
0.0232093111,
0.0110350884,
0.0431751758,
-0.0465679429,
-0.0151610002,
0.0405284017,
-0.0327369571,
0.0242907666,
-0.0111031793,
-0.0146808634,
0.0799068883,
0.003283927,
-0.0237119589,
0.0261986293,
0.0628104061,
-0.0190055482,
-0.0468259491,
0.0172634553,
0.0104056168,
0.0161288474,
0.0186018869,
-0.0140516795,
0.039460022,
-0.0238074083,
-0.0034618129,
0.0557753742,
0.0137537904,
-0.0030553134,
-0.054872755,
-0.0470766723,
0.0195946135,
-0.0130537692,
-0.02559443,
0.0069372007,
-0.0295428075,
-0.0024238431,
0.0039781611,
0.0140738413,
-0.0518490486,
0.0031957086,
-0.0082141832,
-0.0057794009,
0.041221723,
0.0152031723,
-0.0111168362,
0.0056430819,
-0.0174188614,
0.0080063939,
0.0294181425,
0.0192473736,
-0.0397731848,
-0.0173297394,
-0.0339366309,
-0.0378878713,
0.0534299053,
0.0204368383,
0.0011183178,
-0.0158434547,
0.0152562633,
-0.0265553501,
-0.0198980086,
-0.0461878851,
0.038242314,
0.013878556,
0.0116126668,
-0.0223951153,
0.024721276,
0.0305531491,
0.0570661388,
-0.0569086596,
0.0146249197,
0.0321153514,
0.0062150965,
0.0099704638,
0.0206645783,
0.0425840169,
0.0358425677,
0.0699592084,
-0.0515656769,
-0.0249247029,
-0.0209070202,
-0.0124544874,
-0.0525342673,
-0.022338694,
-0.0650872886,
0.0115452353,
-0.0288831852,
0.0213628076,
-0.0163298119,
0.0080388533,
-0.060522262,
0.0121546844,
0.0222714059,
0.0216451734,
-0.0206752028,
-0.0498699807,
0.0518296212,
-0.0084485179,
-0.0273954105,
0.0093790209,
0.016563613,
0.0163051486,
0.0716386512,
-0.0302380882,
-0.0549758412,
0.0064554396,
-0.0852978975,
0.0073747002,
-0.0297091734,
0.014234961,
-0.0136102792,
-0.0263603013,
0.0059939041,
-0.0029736997,
0.0007142366,
-0.002426812,
-0.0175887607,
0.0335376449,
0.0296945665,
0.0066817692,
-0.0290521104,
-0.0415392518,
0.0140891289,
-0.0280802436,
0.0244326536,
0.078621313,
-0.0887304991,
-0.023431614,
-0.024099458,
-0.0483652912,
0.0073152934,
0.0191594604,
0.0088866176,
0.0625301525,
0.0496190004,
-0.0326981694,
-0.0049164295,
0.0017972348,
-0.0090940837,
0.059721496,
-0.0487454049,
-0.0772325471,
-0.0074810432,
0.0054843612,
-0.0202602576,
0.01001768,
-0.0432431698,
0.0172834955,
0.0837059319,
-0.0030620485,
-0.0246130321,
-0.0116261896,
-0.027367359,
-0.0496346913,
0.0100515578,
-0.0249797814,
-0.0473346189,
0.000574,
0.0683001429,
0.0196408369,
-0.0482909828,
0.0747553036,
-0.0522958562,
0.0291765891,
-0.0421823412,
0.0083034523,
-0.0248678271,
0.0347481407,
-0.0357515067,
-0.011411245,
0.0641078353,
-0.0216913018,
0.0088615697,
0.0281312633,
0.0383997671,
-0.0223643575,
0.0566874593,
-0.0561793037,
0.0678259954,
0.0224078894,
-0.0244034939,
-0.0232061893,
-0.0064922343,
-0.0582883731,
0.0098903738,
0.0079835029,
-0.0127821667,
-0.0200397279,
0.0041299649,
0.0476395488,
-0.0050102621,
0.0308324248,
-0.0184785631,
-0.0068662786,
0.0151718445,
0.0383769423,
0.0023008797,
0.0126096476,
0.0107576866,
-0.0346643366,
0.0511437356,
-0.0303641614,
0.0562095046,
-0.0203580577,
-0.0343190655,
0.0281879567,
-0.0350608267,
-0.0519148596,
-0.0121690938,
0.0235637017,
-0.0485575125,
0.0043402286,
0.0844122097,
0.0555011593,
-0.0456751809,
-0.0195115395,
0.0365601927,
0.0355239771,
0.0273555908,
-0.0084408568,
-0.0999898389,
-0.0292664412,
-0.0020444633,
0.0148421424,
-0.034668237,
-0.0394448601,
-0.0290878564,
-0.0413640812,
0.0339770354,
0.0015179747,
-0.0670194551,
0.0245444104,
-0.076081641,
0.0231688842,
-0.0421346873,
0.0315910615,
-0.0379042812,
0.0204079673,
0.0093848296,
0.0293426979,
-0.0723781958,
-0.0178094041,
0.0022376194,
-0.0711217523,
0.0575800128,
0.0671306551,
0.0375792086,
-0.0083772102,
-0.0367362201,
0.0460211746,
-0.00084171,
-0.0309055429,
-0.0006787895,
0.0506519862,
-0.0531331301,
-0.0266410038,
-0.0177666023,
-0.0220653228,
-0.0097788069,
0.0104288645,
0.0038058574,
0.0719324499,
-0.0231703594,
0.0370405279,
-0.0347523876,
0.00095677,
0.0032747423,
0.0680243075,
0.0091463076,
-0.0237829816,
0.001937504,
-0.0172265451,
0.046970129,
-0.0374026373,
-0.0373787209,
0.0446149819,
-0.0676105544,
-0.0555235408,
-0.0452147797,
-0.0699946582,
0.0281801876,
-0.0371694341,
0.0102523277,
0.0154129248,
0.0329236723,
0.004295323,
-0.0199471451,
0.0227004699,
-0.0068148966,
0.0407026857,
0.0141154695,
-0.0044053253,
0.0316961221,
0.0585134029,
-0.0362601876,
0.0582589172,
-0.0235935152,
-0.0707715005,
0.0476090088,
0.0033730769,
0.017166283,
0.0111485403,
-0.0005354004,
-0.0326851569,
-0.0123603642,
0.0341239758,
0.0201858953,
-0.0058390028,
0.0093534496,
-0.0027608986,
-0.0069938698,
0.0142728016,
-0.0617863759,
0.0138119916,
-0.0231207386,
0.0402739756,
-0.0365399644,
-0.0575888231,
0.028417293,
0.0325935148,
0.0191814136,
-0.0232231952,
-0.0075727627,
-0.0374453738,
-0.0227751341,
-0.0016587109,
-0.0505230911,
-0.0018434069,
0.0035445292,
-0.0381471887,
-0.0201175623,
-0.0537980869,
0.064958103,
-0.0329823531,
0.0497881435,
-0.0056502051,
-0.0145208007,
0.0353215635,
0.0187518578,
-0.0333532169,
-0.0172311626,
-0.0269730743,
-0.0042014327,
0.033075761,
0.0390263125,
0.0160907898,
0.0089295004,
0.0248448588,
-0.0188536327,
0.0073148664,
0.0122424914,
-0.0411123075,
0.0274084862,
-0.0394765548,
0.0269766785,
0.0470324866,
-0.0069233784,
0.082376644,
-0.0018342945,
0.0095735397,
-0.0304433294,
-0.002052784,
0.0161605682,
-0.0188984405,
-0.0062069572,
-0.0019766907,
-0.0345955379,
0.030648984,
0.0328240693,
-0.0531177372,
0.0164854117,
-0.0716716573,
-0.0509869419,
-0.0183194131,
-0.0221394747,
-0.0540950783,
0.0116499625,
-0.0080755111,
-0.0412835777,
-0.0722940341,
-0.0154022276,
0.0295021683,
-0.0002997567,
-0.0001961255,
0.0453816131,
-0.0299283322,
0.0539859794,
0.0153117655,
-0.0219861902,
0.0030453496,
-0.0631706342,
-0.0406995453,
0.0000067824,
-0.0250935182,
-6.011101952e-33,
-0.0414280705,
-0.043708574,
-0.0190464705,
-0.0021015967,
-0.051873289,
0.0105758253,
-0.0086946329,
0.01291651,
0.0120102409,
0.042616643,
0.0164229553,
0.0244107172,
0.0340033993,
-0.038870167,
0.0856358558,
-0.0092671756,
0.0241785571,
0.0347348601,
-0.0445757471,
-0.0362578183,
0.0636140481,
-0.0364357717,
0.0804259032,
-0.1077668443,
0.101582244,
0.0142391035,
-0.0321274623,
-0.0078682862,
-0.0098972665,
0.0649334714,
-0.0181281287,
0.0518163703,
0.0262568407,
-0.0173648242,
0.00520095,
0.0388365351,
-0.0621301308,
-0.0408479385,
-0.0067564347,
0.0417388566,
-0.0346649736,
-0.001269843,
0.0397426262,
-0.0159001462,
-0.0149438186,
0.0211071447,
0.0677231401,
-0.0111636864,
0.0161394216,
-0.0231000241,
-0.0471635126,
0.0318792723,
-0.0307915844,
0.0156688225,
0.0586364232,
0.037051145,
0.023173118,
-0.0069488185,
-0.0770441815,
0.0364188887,
-0.0387480259,
-0.0020937014,
0.0636762157,
-0.0209542867,
-0.0297269057,
0.0812722668,
0.0061918176,
-0.0204901155,
0.0481369309,
-0.0602192506,
-0.0019172827,
0.0095539996,
0.0216770452,
0.0475928634,
0.00829749,
0.0354779139,
-0.0562618673,
0.0579898842,
0.0128736757,
0.0253250096,
-0.0428973213,
-0.0077845189,
-0.0747070909,
-0.0218664221,
-0.0306546409,
-0.0259317532,
-0.0272147842,
-0.0097860908,
0.0132944379,
-0.0161598828,
-0.0084391991,
0.1053669006,
0.0073852972,
-0.0284407455,
-0.0565650873,
-0.018392818,
0.0023750027,
0.0454858691,
0.0187158361,
0.0122263785,
-0.0463593751,
0.0214221422,
0.0010370654,
0.0102808774,
0.0598853342,
-0.0108882897,
0.07253135,
0.0033118261,
-0.065511629,
-0.0020043054,
0.0068252156,
-0.0433364734,
-0.0228577424,
-0.0729504451,
0.0387604684,
0.0270815175,
-0.0156613439,
0.0280526876,
0.0259670392,
0.0517049953,
-0.0194177832,
-0.0458548479,
-0.0339448452,
-0.0007070663,
-0.0086383242,
-0.0153369643,
0.0394727141,
-0.0090557337,
-0.0185429864,
-0.012108135,
0.0059297271,
-0.0309660286,
2.428e-7,
0.04928343,
0.0654232129,
0.0457831919,
-0.0493573993,
0.0027945868,
0.0084191933,
-0.000357863,
0.0194376558,
-0.011692008,
-0.0359947793,
0.0043639713,
-0.0380487368,
0.0327500328,
0.0695547909,
-0.0228814408,
-0.0257624723,
-0.0531997718,
0.0038661389,
-0.0660642534,
0.0127892541,
0.0607209466,
0.043798551,
0.0147192525,
0.0053053638,
-0.0262491181,
0.000773281,
0.0099574383,
0.0195453633,
0.0052807839,
0.030787468,
0.0477173142,
-0.0264058113,
0.0260703191,
0.0772429481,
-0.0197512899,
0.0219575055,
0.0348289795,
0.0179049559,
-0.0239618663,
-0.0206903666,
-0.0301751029,
0.0059488099,
0.0224045105,
-0.0044479975,
0.0628804341,
-0.0322443433,
-0.0167921316,
-0.0434498973,
-0.0543135554,
-0.0040379735,
0.0421050601,
0.039746888,
-0.0074582594,
0.0503996685,
-0.0014059588,
0.0171285886,
-0.0713485777,
-0.0670839027,
-0.0065889787,
0.0249288306,
0.0077780681,
-0.0415117703,
0.0299651753,
-0.0189868212,
0.0079006841,
-0.07399901,
0.0060458686,
1.592195963e-34,
0.0160438661,
-0.0091053909,
0.0273376107,
0.0667773411,
0.0023920988,
-0.0121194916,
-0.0427001528,
0.0387372635,
-0.029865196,
-0.0260463879,
0.014038831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14321v1 | RobuT: A Systematic Study of Table QA Robustness Against Human-Annotated Adversarial Perturbations | 2023-06-25T19:23:21 | 2023-06-25T19:23:21 | Yilun Zhao, Chen Zhao, Linyong Nan, Zhenting Qi, Wenlin Zhang, Xiangru Tang, Boyu Mi, Dragomir Radev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite significant progress having been made in question answering on
tabular data (Table QA), it's unclear whether, and to what extent existing
Table QA models are robust to task-specific perturbations, e.g., replacing key
question entities or shuffling table columns. To systematically study the
robustness of Table QA models, we propose a benchmark called RobuT, which
builds upon existing Table QA datasets (WTQ, WikiSQL-Weak, and SQA) and
includes human-annotated adversarial perturbations in terms of table header,
table content, and question. Our results indicate that both state-of-the-art
Table QA models and large language models (e.g., GPT-3) with few-shot learning
falter in these adversarial sets. We propose to address this problem by using
large language models to generate adversarial examples to enhance training,
which significantly improves the robustness of Table QA models. Our data and
code is publicly available at https://github.com/yilunzhao/RobuT. | [
0.0176366866,
0.0821937993,
-0.0128912404,
0.0144073674,
-0.0145566585,
0.031285651,
-0.0108644012,
-0.0081757894,
0.0025218623,
-0.0344543196,
-0.0275276601,
-0.0099723712,
-0.0176189356,
0.0035327701,
0.0733783171,
0.0085544875,
0.0707330108,
-0.0001639528,
-0.06681633,
0.0193406288,
0.0132446717,
-0.0375153348,
-0.0171300229,
0.0042358818,
0.0189356841,
-0.0267143119,
-0.0382546894,
-0.004949884,
-0.0196788013,
0.0156776775,
0.0312407017,
0.1056174859,
-0.0158908907,
0.0551533252,
0.0000018743,
0.0223483872,
-0.0330920964,
-0.0014155556,
-0.0210316554,
0.0280163605,
-0.0020320215,
-0.0344204456,
-0.0052797883,
-0.0173068512,
-0.0394338034,
-0.0194831286,
0.0049533532,
0.0521893352,
0.0606395006,
0.0501570813,
0.012819753,
-0.0059774704,
0.000916604,
-0.038315773,
0.0540180206,
-0.0864133313,
0.0154859032,
-0.0101311598,
-0.0034450281,
-0.0144183543,
-0.0272284504,
0.0247913711,
0.0551470034,
0.0103225065,
-0.0309782922,
0.0338221788,
-0.0474711098,
0.0526495203,
-0.0005502716,
0.1301130354,
-0.0094561726,
-0.0143277887,
-0.0031486475,
0.0180445425,
0.0563787743,
-0.03292083,
-0.0559037328,
-0.0392315239,
0.0143722007,
-0.0283435769,
-0.0271677915,
-0.0348920524,
0.0058173295,
-0.0031593803,
-0.0040895231,
0.0280297846,
0.0115121901,
-0.0383891873,
0.0028920572,
-0.020454457,
-0.033415962,
-0.0129142134,
-0.0173271447,
0.0279104784,
-0.0354983173,
0.0075255223,
-0.0079495413,
-0.0520096868,
0.029039301,
-0.0173531305,
0.0317747556,
0.0293802992,
0.0052508768,
0.0134831322,
-0.0285191536,
0.0345914029,
-0.0199408866,
0.0662795454,
-0.027402699,
-0.0054097697,
-0.0337081477,
-0.0167163312,
-0.0511961952,
0.0262903273,
-0.0375744253,
0.0202517603,
0.0071554263,
0.0018042852,
-0.0058642565,
0.0380806215,
-0.0204353463,
0.0673332661,
-0.0289488807,
0.0183516871,
-0.0046873693,
0.0007348642,
-0.0562098697,
0.0088823577,
-0.002576885,
-0.065021798,
-0.0502391383,
-0.0170485489,
-0.0180947967,
-0.0398680456,
0.0191110782,
0.0932588577,
-0.0345457345,
-0.0119707333,
0.0069072698,
-0.0054174173,
-0.0245966353,
-0.0465695299,
-0.0088881161,
-0.02141493,
0.062875025,
-0.0044913078,
-0.0044148774,
-0.0435407981,
0.0110309748,
0.0667985752,
-0.0107116662,
0.0845226273,
0.0405264832,
-0.0130580477,
0.0000562473,
0.0103003541,
-0.0383622013,
0.0737059414,
0.0259610116,
-0.0109934779,
-0.0100139938,
-0.0176635385,
-0.0068629235,
0.0417744517,
0.0485420711,
0.0125567717,
0.0247053262,
0.062597394,
0.0388138779,
0.0391455293,
-0.0059861033,
0.0151656745,
-0.0176649,
-0.0211787149,
0.0428793989,
0.0109650269,
-0.0365647785,
0.0712171644,
-0.0258318391,
-0.0176416785,
0.0326388404,
0.019290559,
-0.0493686609,
0.0275827013,
-0.0035789183,
-0.0147014791,
0.0153888045,
-0.0102674719,
-0.0447338149,
-0.0336233899,
0.0205606818,
0.0063804458,
-0.0145042064,
-0.0071510524,
0.0218207259,
0.0434191823,
-0.0523672663,
-0.0291132145,
-0.0110492166,
-0.0393986106,
-0.0165975615,
-0.0157069452,
0.0320962369,
0.0211395901,
0.0548814014,
-0.0904764459,
-0.0191668011,
-0.0243734736,
0.0339253284,
-0.0015292031,
0.0332145989,
-0.0439964831,
0.0262636002,
0.0174508765,
0.0047620181,
-0.010872826,
0.0315874889,
-0.0008817087,
0.0186313745,
-0.0113080898,
-0.0140176257,
-0.0681933612,
-0.0030210391,
0.0399725847,
0.0381071083,
-0.0587049425,
0.0011274348,
0.0070274067,
0.0170286838,
0.0122714965,
0.0045049344,
0.0218476653,
0.0469745025,
-0.0088773742,
0.0095964046,
-0.02243945,
0.003894656,
-0.0292004459,
0.0189189184,
0.0362567753,
-0.066924125,
0.0432295203,
-0.0615083911,
-0.0185984112,
0.0375688113,
-0.0340705253,
-0.0751776695,
-0.0161141418,
-0.0308966041,
0.0329074822,
0.0302969553,
-0.0224660579,
0.0772394389,
-0.0173309054,
0.019283494,
0.0139251444,
-0.0590397976,
0.0193183031,
-0.0476496592,
0.0247180052,
-0.0086395489,
-0.0296130851,
0.0337264277,
-0.0062619834,
-0.0004769104,
-0.0506905764,
-0.0027200358,
-0.0453372113,
0.0337605923,
-0.0526217148,
0.0296741091,
0.0454339311,
-0.0081182038,
-0.0080574891,
-0.0384009108,
-0.0397791006,
-0.0111170299,
-0.0073889219,
0.0257026609,
0.0528198965,
0.0114967832,
0.0085844938,
-0.0357293263,
-0.0392486379,
-0.0348361395,
0.0459259227,
-0.0353281312,
-0.0026077349,
0.0167814828,
-0.0550263971,
0.0001683692,
0.0355020277,
0.0049562701,
-0.0193153396,
0.0022555881,
0.0027902734,
0.0165363755,
0.0725401342,
-0.030109968,
0.0372520611,
0.0154182771,
0.0215620957,
-0.0129214311,
0.0342271663,
0.0029634405,
-0.0044341926,
0.0166639201,
-0.0416269116,
0.0412546694,
0.0231047273,
-0.0002533664,
-0.0080066649,
-0.0300433692,
0.0697384849,
0.0049217879,
-0.0147676133,
-0.0705019832,
0.0757759735,
-0.0224844236,
-0.0372340307,
-0.0414108858,
0.0116672767,
0.028370183,
0.0023152232,
0.0215237141,
-0.0275059137,
0.0107710976,
-0.0202093963,
0.0513279401,
0.0001590893,
-0.0093819089,
-0.0276846848,
-0.0053090844,
-0.0810507312,
-0.0353583619,
0.0101517793,
-0.0232734233,
0.0520892367,
-0.0313436836,
0.0166044626,
-0.0152361859,
-0.0441732295,
-0.0200479887,
-0.040671397,
-0.0100584468,
0.0403748974,
0.0017931355,
0.0065795039,
-0.0095016807,
-0.0363375098,
0.0236630943,
0.0368783027,
-0.040185377,
-0.0078709945,
-0.0371866673,
0.0726036355,
0.060781341,
0.0204002839,
-0.025984332,
-0.0075699631,
0.0585015565,
0.0691649765,
0.0233466383,
-0.0089923823,
0.0024522245,
0.0190610867,
-0.0016230162,
-0.0286961868,
0.0082088029,
0.0277612843,
0.0007674093,
-0.0397969894,
-0.036348369,
0.0306704473,
0.0305802859,
0.0333113335,
0.0222726204,
0.0095273303,
0.0299285334,
0.0186271612,
0.0495695285,
-0.0974423513,
-0.0491635799,
-0.0068938052,
0.0280556176,
0.0289734602,
-0.055979304,
-0.0085429633,
-0.1054787263,
0.0095847258,
-0.0401791446,
-0.0913549885,
-0.0767006353,
-0.0134823266,
0.0036849894,
-0.0370282158,
0.0701956227,
0.049359221,
-0.0021040475,
0.0298131332,
0.0235053264,
-0.0025597538,
-0.031327486,
-0.0086519495,
-0.0561989732,
0.0223885179,
0.0697511062,
0.0094874557,
-0.0406596549,
0.0066903955,
-0.0036149151,
-0.0228607096,
0.0010905251,
0.0321094133,
0.0691444874,
-0.0166338477,
-0.0188836902,
-0.0078252703,
0.0318842009,
-0.0286265537,
-0.006269773,
0.046412874,
0.054264877,
-0.0222337376,
-0.0132865151,
0.0061767399,
-0.0317229442,
-0.0130814845,
0.0719567984,
0.0459698588,
-0.0207889322,
-0.0721270889,
-0.0393655486,
-0.0652604029,
-0.0904410183,
0.0050871535,
0.033514142,
0.0226483401,
0.0166194867,
-0.0682243481,
-0.0568793677,
0.0517908297,
0.0201773793,
-0.0234865509,
0.0634305775,
-0.0603885166,
0.0041300906,
-0.0311897546,
-0.0241334457,
-0.0597483031,
0.0022552698,
-0.0104524139,
-0.0293350946,
-0.0020532839,
-0.0118152527,
-0.0179285798,
0.0179308355,
-0.0721312612,
-0.0197580494,
0.0064887307,
0.0492035002,
0.0148909567,
-0.0055653178,
-0.0207722429,
-0.0279617365,
-0.0179217141,
0.0204254426,
-0.0504322685,
-0.013465466,
0.0236665327,
-0.0448075011,
0.0097238617,
0.0589558631,
-0.0505469777,
-0.0281979181,
0.0132877678,
0.0476225801,
-0.0065669268,
0.0637847334,
0.0326519608,
-0.0148022743,
0.0018646407,
0.0383400358,
-0.0627080873,
0.010337973,
0.0291385017,
-0.0481257103,
-0.02005619,
0.0155919753,
0.0039933124,
0.0190124437,
-0.0238589179,
-0.0325081497,
0.0015187829,
0.01018833,
0.0562586077,
-0.0420754999,
-0.032158915,
0.0556462109,
-0.0275273472,
-0.0036471025,
-0.0168721862,
-0.0114908004,
-0.0142425643,
0.0140246535,
0.0408585854,
-0.0053363745,
-0.0029216988,
0.0463295691,
-0.0322318077,
-0.0149367964,
0.0444636606,
-0.0769490972,
-0.0409874134,
-0.035092406,
0.012768372,
0.0019923702,
0.0089064846,
-0.014398044,
-0.0026668075,
-0.0326607898,
0.0104835071,
-0.0307592116,
0.0367434695,
0.0208610352,
0.0492549166,
0.0198712479,
-0.005793069,
0.0127246194,
0.0919205546,
0.0716108978,
0.0476016365,
0.0139375422,
-0.0154571868,
-0.0614521317,
0.0040052678,
-0.0049504763,
-0.01442389,
-0.0223573167,
-0.0016993118,
-0.0293624066,
-0.0465466604,
0.0117327971,
0.0336064324,
-0.0285481885,
0.0082342895,
0.0157662313,
0.0398661792,
0.0422383733,
-0.0058644549,
-0.0328437015,
0.0382158197,
-0.0231584385,
-0.0468590781,
0.0070810588,
-6.11684171e-33,
-0.0268106293,
-0.0139328819,
0.0029399425,
-0.0647653192,
0.0430464223,
-0.0326206163,
-0.0507384688,
-0.0225380193,
-0.0302438941,
-0.0136384126,
-0.0281860121,
0.0408720449,
-0.003163252,
-0.0020529889,
0.0173683856,
-0.113713257,
0.0199608412,
-0.0344816409,
-0.0285000857,
0.0022489142,
-0.0175588373,
0.0356968753,
0.0298092235,
0.01188624,
0.0615445636,
-0.0209651664,
-0.0358712859,
-0.0104961731,
-0.0343821757,
0.0244610962,
-0.039882157,
0.0438542329,
0.0283092968,
-0.0381687246,
-0.0223246273,
0.0060510938,
-0.135417074,
-0.0224202275,
-0.0169576742,
0.0327972732,
-0.0246079639,
-0.0299474597,
0.0083649354,
-0.0034986071,
0.0106578162,
0.0006914071,
-0.0016651613,
-0.0263951141,
0.0067843399,
0.0149410469,
-0.0004582611,
-0.0057833875,
-0.0373134427,
-0.0097228792,
-0.0041159936,
0.0689465329,
0.0369065776,
-0.0133947749,
-0.058241792,
-0.0302823782,
0.0084027406,
0.0229602046,
0.0381434895,
-0.0483084209,
0.0190546531,
0.0109487958,
0.0404717512,
0.020138042,
-0.0272594206,
-0.0097624175,
-0.0336805806,
0.0166724194,
0.1271349639,
0.0693472102,
0.0581332855,
0.0095465118,
-0.0853072405,
0.0648618415,
-0.0084580155,
0.0333446488,
-0.0163409598,
-0.0188741665,
-0.038513381,
0.0057825097,
-0.0412620194,
-0.0196914077,
-0.0379452966,
-0.0028051904,
0.0445236079,
-0.0163884964,
0.0093290349,
-0.0036226197,
-0.0156529713,
-0.0160763953,
-0.0096903639,
0.0601343364,
-0.0210113488,
-0.0073170667,
0.0304449294,
0.0228485372,
-0.0150039,
0.0200750064,
0.0492140055,
-0.0313402005,
0.0476728678,
0.027327057,
0.0571272671,
0.0223958269,
-0.0630862042,
-0.0147249466,
-0.0190446991,
0.0732204765,
0.0125068361,
0.0175886899,
0.0037981304,
0.0075154752,
0.0129965115,
0.0361957438,
0.0351771824,
0.0207489319,
0.0006749928,
0.0155459,
-0.0087840836,
-0.0194863547,
0.0247465279,
-0.0014722884,
-0.0032770068,
0.0224349201,
-0.0125698401,
-0.0583634786,
0.0091366637,
0.0134116095,
2.372e-7,
0.0747382641,
0.0333561003,
0.0739433989,
0.0173855089,
0.0082337586,
0.0250432268,
-0.0136652095,
0.0388193838,
-0.0357332826,
-0.0259706564,
0.0296798497,
-0.0050190585,
0.0620262288,
0.0269684419,
-0.0464695022,
-0.0188708846,
-0.0789229795,
0.0242224112,
-0.0325960964,
-0.0094853994,
0.0275224298,
0.1118265465,
-0.0452885069,
0.0070883012,
-0.0092642866,
-0.046409592,
0.0373899005,
-0.0251838714,
0.0424399041,
-0.0003447339,
0.0450520106,
-0.0308168773,
0.0264338739,
0.032252904,
-0.0372842401,
-0.010618547,
0.0369604155,
0.0329323933,
-0.0032116384,
-0.0274029691,
-0.0384691469,
-0.0802133456,
0.046620369,
-0.061445158,
0.1247209013,
-0.0444720425,
0.0061571067,
0.0666068941,
-0.0159774069,
0.014991737,
0.0542033985,
0.0018913154,
-0.009469172,
-0.0058255033,
0.0255235918,
0.0243691057,
0.0387422182,
-0.0307370368,
-0.0003460571,
0.0153598981,
-0.01603573,
-0.0008816898,
-0.0135150561,
-0.0459237695,
-0.0097997868,
-0.0556152873,
-0.0181228053,
1.957822346e-34,
0.0342682153,
-0.0129634123,
0.0649297908,
0.0377056226,
0.0392171405,
-0.0257179961,
0.0302504953,
-0.0393020473,
0.0462683104,
-0.0702143833,
-0.0379496664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14310v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14310v1 | Addressing Cold Start Problem for End-to-end Automatic Speech Scoring | 2023-06-25T18:48:21 | 2023-06-25T18:48:21 | Jungbae Park, Seungtaek Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Integrating automatic speech scoring/assessment systems has become a critical
aspect of second-language speaking education. With self-supervised learning
advancements, end-to-end speech scoring approaches have exhibited promising
results. However, this study highlights the significant decrease in the
performance of speech scoring systems in new question contexts, thereby
identifying this as a cold start problem in terms of items. With the finding of
cold-start phenomena, this paper seeks to alleviate the problem by following
methods: 1) prompt embeddings, 2) question context embeddings using BERT or
CLIP models, and 3) choice of the pretrained acoustic model. Experiments are
conducted on TOEIC speaking test datasets collected from
English-as-a-second-language (ESL) learners rated by professional TOEIC
speaking evaluators. The results demonstrate that the proposed framework not
only exhibits robustness in a cold-start environment but also outperforms the
baselines for known content. | [
-0.021450514,
-0.041634012,
-0.0060562454,
0.0282377992,
-0.0187802687,
-0.0060212277,
-0.0154100638,
-0.0337649211,
0.011229611,
-0.0232814681,
-0.0412236713,
-0.0288106967,
0.0140806055,
0.03205356,
0.0132176327,
-0.0544981472,
0.0201043077,
-0.0253482349,
-0.001943039,
-0.0368687175,
0.0144616803,
-0.014043387,
-0.0420749336,
0.017510822,
-0.0049497411,
0.0044337125,
-0.0107896971,
-0.0157861523,
0.0309010837,
-0.0382473618,
-0.0120747695,
0.0497974381,
0.0221480913,
-0.01997054,
0.0000018683,
-0.0748280659,
0.0091283107,
-0.0323923603,
-0.0462164395,
-0.0083735408,
0.0082179802,
0.0740923807,
0.0222552959,
0.0530790649,
-0.0442627631,
0.0006400846,
0.0002637577,
0.0108596114,
0.0632772595,
0.0265951622,
0.002589711,
-0.0356096029,
0.0252046809,
0.0318016261,
-0.0065133376,
-0.0387944877,
-0.0005241662,
-0.0060074828,
0.0391511843,
-0.0321110822,
-0.0250994265,
0.0281215776,
0.0270125214,
-0.0054836939,
0.0113958959,
0.0108872149,
-0.0655971095,
-0.010664735,
-0.0231851786,
0.0859737694,
0.0175389834,
-0.0038717571,
0.0048699151,
-0.0090707792,
0.0133151133,
-0.0192949641,
-0.0258058254,
0.0017345131,
0.0339157879,
-0.0190659259,
0.0432358012,
0.0061485022,
-0.0020051384,
0.003396265,
0.0003518602,
0.0521096252,
0.0153627265,
-0.0686453506,
0.0051441286,
-0.0151329385,
-0.0167586058,
-0.0243742745,
0.0160779189,
0.0387543067,
-0.0384789705,
0.0254074205,
-0.0208382737,
0.0049041519,
-0.033028014,
0.0187425464,
0.0127501683,
0.0250663031,
-0.0690969974,
-0.0008464127,
-0.0066180043,
0.0551774465,
0.0888148323,
0.0081890365,
-0.0391481593,
0.0040381746,
-0.0308183562,
-0.0113351448,
-0.0681586117,
0.0367702916,
0.0031296043,
-0.0082751075,
-0.0790460631,
0.0014043889,
-0.0519948415,
0.0207544174,
0.0070305569,
-0.0090161692,
0.0112058185,
0.049962949,
0.0201235618,
0.0208193287,
-0.0696890429,
0.0280891955,
0.0081658633,
-0.0241350364,
0.0156712942,
0.0048115165,
0.0629787594,
0.0362242982,
0.0228792634,
0.0096813021,
0.0205573756,
-0.0632322729,
-0.0075254501,
-0.0118667604,
-0.0444717109,
-0.0362521932,
-0.0254529528,
-0.0420601331,
-0.0232867841,
-0.0165126603,
0.0113310814,
0.0167522971,
-0.016044734,
0.0013415561,
0.0045565017,
0.0595795661,
0.0082819406,
-0.0049100476,
0.0240554828,
0.0115808155,
0.0457428955,
0.0604263805,
0.0327528864,
-0.0478240252,
0.0571786463,
-0.0220966041,
-0.0125475433,
0.0609255582,
0.0471817143,
0.003271702,
-0.0276652351,
0.0105649801,
0.0101428693,
0.0262052063,
-0.0309334658,
-0.0282282773,
-0.0015496211,
0.0365071818,
0.0465740785,
0.0862130523,
-0.0209692586,
-0.0173772592,
0.0555648096,
0.0229083132,
0.0033488707,
0.0504153296,
0.0033231652,
-0.0500940941,
-0.0291075949,
-0.0130163189,
0.0373560153,
-0.0150957499,
-0.037839625,
-0.0478823744,
-0.0154501535,
-0.0557476506,
-0.0292112399,
0.0101627633,
0.0180961192,
0.023763461,
-0.0291850902,
-0.002792042,
-0.0167334322,
-0.0594062321,
0.0526522063,
-0.0207669027,
-0.0059335763,
0.0269488115,
0.0178906489,
-0.0385698453,
-0.0473772101,
-0.0224524029,
-0.0182306319,
0.0077919695,
0.0208905973,
-0.0458770879,
0.0178909302,
-0.0444666781,
-0.0251412373,
0.0207766164,
-0.0212664008,
0.0070233918,
-0.0607126355,
0.0232699718,
-0.0059449994,
-0.0204447024,
0.0182865765,
-0.0121621303,
-0.0027364695,
-0.0249268115,
0.0146823684,
0.0435613133,
0.0487713255,
0.0675241351,
-0.0119532691,
-0.0125271836,
0.051557485,
0.0047802981,
-0.0069107539,
0.0231027286,
-0.0785845593,
-0.0511760265,
0.030695159,
-0.0290082395,
-0.0030568296,
0.0565478392,
-0.0200169291,
-0.1013841629,
-0.0042542894,
-0.018003067,
-0.0022295341,
-0.0312958844,
0.0256546121,
-0.0254361462,
-0.024600938,
-0.031935297,
0.0188776013,
0.02302479,
0.0602735095,
0.0288123041,
0.011185783,
0.0408828594,
-0.0769941732,
-0.0825173855,
0.0005522879,
-0.0410530232,
0.028910853,
0.0176124722,
-0.0094869109,
-0.0492806509,
0.0000023493,
-0.1183184236,
0.0045443797,
-0.0035763483,
-0.0015902704,
0.0198592506,
0.0013917065,
-0.0267152749,
-0.0173102245,
-0.0682112351,
-0.0651794076,
0.0431674607,
-0.00882651,
0.0078411084,
0.0440459475,
0.0018490215,
-0.0064359237,
0.0078743408,
-0.0392119065,
0.0154326484,
0.0028856122,
0.0398058631,
-0.0316832624,
0.0373851061,
-0.0089656441,
0.0050726426,
0.0303330515,
-0.028449297,
0.0004962405,
0.027673021,
0.0627910197,
0.0694537014,
-0.001008114,
0.0272047818,
-0.0039320975,
-0.0567374937,
-0.045463223,
-0.0003282914,
-0.0095074223,
0.0478581786,
-0.025431633,
-0.0030926284,
-0.0210634638,
0.0322825871,
0.0548059233,
0.0102787921,
-0.0281259716,
0.0410186611,
-0.0526250862,
-0.017388586,
-0.064142704,
-0.0379267409,
-0.0668867901,
0.0357502513,
0.0195352174,
0.0010260456,
0.0451646857,
-0.0718726441,
-0.0064756577,
-0.0862037763,
0.007118572,
-0.0158597529,
0.0079758018,
0.0030151671,
-0.0006536563,
0.0084040184,
-0.0430011339,
-0.0563206747,
-0.0098286783,
0.0387828611,
-0.0298074745,
0.0004090077,
0.0082440143,
-0.0468711592,
0.0224628076,
-0.0281251259,
-0.0520931669,
-0.0246074591,
-0.0128203081,
0.0298362523,
-0.0055341539,
0.0005286767,
0.0109170424,
0.0193679277,
-0.0069437362,
0.0279453732,
-0.0408276543,
0.03952948,
-0.0037172597,
0.0795992464,
0.0313983038,
0.0224375129,
-0.0126354499,
0.0104830489,
0.0746163651,
-0.0388931893,
0.0982070118,
0.023165416,
-0.011259621,
0.0339267477,
0.0373855382,
-0.03906174,
-0.0412551872,
0.0557863079,
0.0610913001,
-0.0400990248,
-0.0171041749,
0.1254687607,
0.037763752,
0.0247106925,
-0.0242775008,
0.001416715,
0.0005560259,
0.025979206,
0.010094299,
-0.0775215626,
-0.0174772497,
0.0123580806,
0.0768150613,
-0.0278976187,
-0.0003532957,
0.0167972967,
-0.1296233684,
0.0398795567,
-0.0185148753,
-0.0603521913,
0.0245705452,
-0.0234880634,
-0.0041130483,
0.0158197414,
0.0092410725,
-0.0294899549,
-0.0222445615,
-0.0055495226,
0.0404471047,
-0.0934164524,
-0.0543327406,
0.0620385557,
-0.0408512242,
0.0750519261,
0.0736057088,
0.0376259275,
-0.0322205648,
-0.0075197169,
0.0052957721,
-0.0514017753,
-0.0679016784,
-0.0045689512,
0.0141134905,
-0.0252650045,
-0.0163707938,
0.0012931072,
0.0327711292,
0.0338857509,
0.0237660725,
0.0164163932,
0.0886477977,
-0.0178782269,
0.0310871098,
0.004796213,
0.0547652841,
-0.0066270814,
0.0850879699,
0.0534796268,
-0.0757376999,
0.0359822288,
0.0148390727,
0.0153160058,
-0.0320995115,
-0.0291727856,
0.0535418242,
-0.01086431,
0.0005113378,
-0.0578574166,
-0.0640712231,
0.0541616157,
0.0536053814,
0.0325673111,
0.0382655673,
-0.0443615764,
0.0281563774,
-0.0300785303,
0.0189580135,
-0.0149032362,
0.0179387107,
-0.0785050467,
0.0166831221,
0.0522329062,
-0.035794504,
-0.0520685315,
0.0156993028,
0.0038584075,
-0.0250369366,
0.0240712613,
0.0517601669,
0.0145702809,
0.037076667,
-0.0269327834,
-0.0219508726,
0.0586609766,
-0.012117493,
-0.0180543419,
-0.0070927548,
0.0437220074,
0.0059567969,
-0.0231041275,
0.0166591201,
-0.0298306439,
0.0276599824,
0.0007368433,
0.0187307727,
0.0027710381,
-0.0639190897,
-0.005036002,
0.0409993418,
0.0757308304,
-0.0036328246,
0.012484842,
-0.0366599187,
0.0383715071,
0.013516454,
-0.0140508832,
-0.0237126034,
0.0072702491,
-0.0000101885,
0.0154393576,
-0.0004962973,
0.0017105865,
-0.0657472908,
0.047515396,
-0.0746800527,
0.0798986927,
0.0517163128,
0.0522920936,
-0.0326871909,
0.0182211865,
-0.0050432389,
-0.0098115532,
0.040245343,
0.0317558385,
0.0001133713,
0.0657890886,
-0.0008226425,
0.0017240467,
0.040851254,
0.0393133461,
-0.0354912132,
0.0295372512,
-0.037746951,
0.02454767,
0.0214389246,
-0.0230353121,
-0.0026577269,
0.0408956669,
0.0269960668,
-0.0096513499,
0.0077771819,
-0.0196714997,
-0.0501013137,
0.077080071,
0.0222069994,
0.0017591437,
0.0107268104,
0.0051789368,
0.0006195857,
0.0415645689,
0.0101718409,
0.0183861721,
-0.0552911051,
-0.0097731752,
0.0254406426,
0.007694684,
-0.0251565427,
0.0010209355,
-0.042068053,
-0.0610050932,
0.050973177,
0.0341177247,
-0.010058606,
0.0119247818,
0.0510572642,
0.0159698799,
-0.0492496155,
0.00613803,
0.0114121977,
-0.0310681928,
-0.016218666,
-0.0513332635,
0.0576742999,
-5.732603463e-33,
-0.0495975539,
-0.0139822289,
0.0148906438,
0.0287998598,
-0.0023816472,
0.0251396745,
0.0003576158,
0.0053885435,
0.0011343242,
-0.019303821,
-0.0108976206,
-0.016315762,
0.0231655743,
0.0126281418,
-0.0053362022,
-0.0501133874,
0.0251276139,
-0.0043898816,
-0.0276791286,
0.0063642673,
0.0004243252,
0.0388882831,
0.0666819289,
-0.0134579521,
0.0497250222,
-0.0301604457,
-0.0036414624,
0.0073098191,
0.0446599424,
0.0437011458,
0.0174526088,
0.0391594917,
0.0044021201,
-0.0622002855,
-0.0024077897,
0.063013427,
-0.0842007324,
-0.0526334606,
0.0280145891,
0.0396833867,
-0.0147904186,
0.0166295245,
-0.0319709554,
-0.016287189,
-0.0244747531,
0.0400531143,
0.0482435971,
-0.0029315054,
0.0213173423,
-0.0178555902,
-0.0209815241,
0.0071480083,
-0.0253700875,
-0.0388280824,
0.0032466664,
0.0512972362,
0.0077892351,
-0.0601675399,
-0.0093457727,
0.0250323787,
0.0372951329,
0.0054501216,
0.0335772373,
-0.008986407,
-0.0383906811,
0.0423459299,
0.0107561098,
-0.020696057,
0.073226817,
-0.0916085392,
0.0553368889,
-0.0020996134,
0.0592404641,
0.0063444362,
-0.0023980336,
0.036798045,
-0.0547840297,
0.042678047,
0.0429716893,
0.0131711448,
-0.0142428009,
-0.0465973616,
-0.0299648754,
-0.0163701922,
-0.0942075625,
-0.0341622494,
-0.0190534778,
-0.018880941,
0.0686009601,
-0.0460486002,
-0.0043617357,
0.0085851438,
0.0317353234,
-0.0198175963,
0.0271042567,
-0.0102976449,
-0.0161163304,
-0.0013469801,
-0.0147389071,
0.0406800769,
-0.0299688168,
0.0000635844,
0.0145537471,
-0.0004938423,
0.0124769388,
0.0144836148,
0.0028941121,
0.0426023565,
-0.0307617802,
-0.0019088816,
0.0006396669,
-0.0006292832,
-0.0539182425,
0.0516379178,
0.0367761403,
0.0342129767,
-0.0046258522,
0.0729308203,
0.0194305349,
-0.002463178,
-0.0435018763,
-0.0525485203,
0.0049215467,
0.0279672258,
-0.0250480585,
-0.026771374,
0.004928167,
0.0210252423,
-0.021052165,
-0.0453080051,
0.0255251657,
-0.0135060521,
2.567e-7,
0.0093633244,
0.0386134498,
0.008910588,
-0.0211235713,
-0.0223989505,
0.0055428389,
-0.0335201733,
0.0098268958,
0.0434160754,
0.0446924269,
0.0086074024,
-0.0391657166,
0.0156253316,
0.0380308256,
-0.1410541981,
-0.0464794151,
-0.0795470923,
0.0146344239,
-0.0197190568,
0.0243354309,
0.0450319536,
0.0515617691,
0.0029654531,
-0.0142798219,
-0.0367942415,
-0.035231892,
0.0008324458,
-0.0143185286,
-0.0196654871,
-0.0205381885,
0.0068950728,
0.0015305717,
0.0038719538,
0.0691174492,
-0.0482085161,
0.0741770267,
0.0124931717,
-0.0034870484,
0.006384335,
-0.0703455582,
-0.0053808582,
0.0423803777,
-0.0308045819,
-0.0129980072,
0.0607984215,
-0.0656076074,
-0.017728582,
0.0270156804,
-0.0561468564,
-0.0506523028,
0.0379280001,
-0.0223506782,
0.0127712777,
0.0267350283,
0.0103459377,
-0.035335619,
0.0185791031,
-0.0541359708,
0.0248971544,
0.0207252037,
-0.006859567,
-0.0386736542,
-0.008848805,
-0.0645710453,
-0.0083468324,
-0.0527068935,
-0.0074484772,
2.139724127e-34,
0.0378702022,
-0.0180309694,
0.0261638872,
-0.0193612892,
-0.0118516674,
-0.0032286206,
0.0263109375,
0.0096265497,
0.0543709286,
-0.0366655886,
-0.0305238757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14308v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14308v1 | Let's Do a Thought Experiment: Using Counterfactuals to Improve Moral Reasoning | 2023-06-25T18:40:43 | 2023-06-25T18:40:43 | Xiao Ma, Swaroop Mishra, Ahmad Beirami, Alex Beutel, Jilin Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models still struggle on moral reasoning, despite their impressive
performance in many other tasks. In particular, the Moral Scenarios task in
MMLU (Multi-task Language Understanding) is among the worst performing tasks
for many language models, including GPT-3. In this work, we propose a new
prompting framework, Thought Experiments, to teach language models to do better
moral reasoning using counterfactuals. Experiment results show that our
framework elicits counterfactual questions and answers from the model, which in
turn helps improve the accuracy on Moral Scenarios task by 9-16% compared to
other zero-shot baselines. Interestingly, unlike math reasoning tasks,
zero-shot Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning doesn't work out of the box, and
even reduces accuracy by around 4% compared to direct zero-shot. We further
observed that with minimal human supervision in the form of 5 few-shot
examples, the accuracy of the task can be improved to as much as 80%. | [
0.0518611558,
0.0581774637,
-0.0249990914,
0.0424429029,
-0.0941619724,
0.0233210996,
0.0480244458,
-0.0219804235,
-0.0079563726,
-0.0416644178,
-0.0241892487,
-0.0314588882,
-0.0260884184,
-0.005611063,
-0.0010125892,
-0.0388892666,
0.0707363561,
-0.0301080737,
0.0898745731,
-0.0281895474,
-0.0228427965,
0.0364942029,
0.0091534806,
-0.0213048998,
0.0278355163,
-0.0250273868,
-0.0317304321,
-0.0032903852,
0.0204178244,
-0.0153031079,
-0.000536037,
0.0516680069,
0.0249105562,
0.0323142223,
0.0000019705,
-0.0570265539,
-0.0007048663,
-0.0141985519,
-0.0247328952,
-0.0167533066,
0.0386255719,
-0.0010707118,
0.0030377654,
0.0042589633,
-0.0471171401,
0.0814295486,
-0.0010678557,
0.0933399126,
0.0233097412,
0.057772778,
0.0035044071,
-0.0143399518,
-0.004699172,
-0.0121525573,
0.0471098907,
-0.0177839696,
-0.0119937491,
0.0700720623,
0.0202080719,
0.0158992447,
-0.0190243088,
0.02291416,
0.0723113194,
-0.0034305819,
-0.0598543845,
0.0133890491,
-0.0209669191,
-0.0225648656,
-0.0311711635,
0.0312342308,
0.0005597823,
-0.0480058976,
-0.015524921,
-0.0057262448,
0.0332212783,
-0.0273045544,
-0.0300986152,
0.0378564261,
-0.0193396732,
0.0040575848,
0.0238355361,
0.0040779826,
-0.0015199924,
0.0314785428,
0.0524603054,
0.0244732257,
-0.0237864032,
-0.0170950275,
-0.0056586303,
0.002596901,
-0.0511382855,
-0.0154545819,
-0.0167718045,
0.0208760165,
-0.0192258563,
0.0230788719,
-0.0047872127,
-0.0085319672,
0.0336623006,
-0.035181988,
0.0180797093,
0.0530679375,
-0.0047741593,
0.0479574725,
-0.0098704631,
0.0297573637,
0.0038452174,
0.0516897775,
-0.0338199288,
0.0251067858,
-0.0090520531,
-0.0185173303,
-0.0219704602,
0.0344107039,
-0.0195120275,
0.0494310409,
0.0146116158,
-0.021134574,
-0.0535122603,
-0.0162116215,
-0.0340482593,
0.0107608512,
-0.0275424328,
-0.0494949855,
-0.0318084732,
0.0283996388,
-0.0597398989,
0.01442743,
0.0163522735,
-0.0158788804,
-0.0115552749,
-0.0503160097,
-0.0147450892,
-0.0065862965,
0.0278349761,
0.1133457124,
-0.0234306958,
0.0101956818,
-0.0371573605,
-0.0204527751,
0.0064479294,
-0.0687397569,
0.0008578376,
-0.0603895448,
0.0003210315,
-0.0121641308,
-0.0273974705,
0.0043438482,
0.039859321,
0.013901908,
-0.0348566771,
0.0701787397,
0.0252016652,
-0.0258708857,
-0.0058646328,
0.0265476406,
-0.0387907773,
0.0810332224,
0.0084646679,
-0.0213183481,
0.0247742515,
0.0150692631,
-0.011310664,
-0.0369114503,
0.0216868632,
-0.0103432387,
-0.0303628799,
0.0029666922,
0.0053630145,
0.0139064528,
0.0123123843,
0.0315830298,
-0.0234521311,
-0.016881479,
0.0388854295,
0.0713265315,
-0.0202045143,
0.0096779093,
0.0250510257,
-0.0051895818,
-0.0108881555,
0.0267517548,
-0.0992515907,
0.0637481213,
-0.0257513896,
0.0068372847,
-0.0688792989,
0.0428183936,
-0.025007654,
-0.0391602553,
0.0082617579,
0.0026350711,
0.0185002387,
0.0286883824,
0.0164789129,
0.0148028694,
-0.0058891778,
-0.0784203038,
0.0328815728,
-0.0547528416,
0.0087783514,
-0.0620125644,
0.0560295358,
0.055277735,
0.0613051243,
-0.0089298338,
-0.058191292,
-0.028918976,
-0.0155922128,
0.0135339359,
0.0319666192,
-0.0117540909,
0.0022271287,
-0.0433737226,
-0.009207312,
-0.0314868502,
-0.003746588,
0.0197138526,
-0.0117859617,
-0.0215251427,
0.0259751324,
-0.0055100466,
0.0267316047,
0.036161948,
-0.0058431011,
0.0145613868,
-0.0252567865,
0.0089676259,
-0.015773505,
-0.0032497295,
0.0062657543,
-0.0209960788,
0.0212445203,
0.0072515178,
-0.003827662,
0.0172908623,
-0.0519792736,
-0.0644724444,
0.0348428749,
-0.0596215911,
-0.04521209,
0.0277256779,
-0.0271387473,
-0.0076310043,
0.0169406068,
-0.0142663606,
0.0594548732,
-0.0327109396,
-0.0019977533,
-0.0443977453,
-0.0370140076,
-0.0167534389,
0.077385135,
-0.0031630227,
0.0100701479,
-0.0096565485,
-0.0055464348,
0.0182556789,
-0.0168523286,
0.006543803,
-0.0124015491,
-0.017017791,
0.0071544764,
0.0261246227,
0.0563016571,
-0.0557644442,
-0.0083253682,
-0.0657801479,
-0.0037807098,
-0.0099412482,
0.0000225602,
0.004180687,
-0.0163087156,
-0.0112449192,
-0.0237832163,
-0.022636028,
0.011896736,
0.0077247871,
-0.0052969283,
0.012225938,
-0.0256443247,
0.0101284739,
-0.0064459252,
0.0060670529,
-0.0531525537,
-0.0014214714,
0.022594139,
0.0064555141,
0.0015503035,
0.043317508,
-0.0533083603,
0.0164540112,
-0.0054771821,
-0.0369411744,
0.0108737554,
0.033779677,
0.0438715145,
0.0944462568,
0.0275448784,
-0.0126076136,
0.0398153774,
0.0163490362,
-0.0603227392,
0.0343983471,
0.0223841984,
-0.0041953991,
-0.0171673596,
-0.0066345502,
-0.0882046446,
0.0594940819,
0.0019801687,
-0.008979043,
-0.0585196316,
0.0224434491,
-0.0169444233,
-0.0667353943,
-0.017779652,
-0.0449449308,
-0.0029233666,
0.0491665639,
-0.049902603,
-0.0351260118,
0.0936919823,
0.0570651814,
-0.0120548541,
-0.0271060579,
0.0394608118,
0.0031997126,
0.0768905059,
-0.0049741953,
0.0265585873,
0.0171917342,
0.0009342836,
-0.0442070179,
-0.0007447921,
0.0307373665,
-0.0304721016,
0.0482477546,
-0.0660857558,
0.0028911114,
-0.0072317836,
-0.0507269502,
-0.0621154942,
-0.0365176499,
-0.0269821696,
-0.0155170392,
-0.0775895417,
0.0145405708,
0.0333771296,
-0.0218851175,
0.0360607579,
0.0052038599,
-0.023328146,
-0.0178686194,
-0.0100000706,
-0.0502411276,
0.0467006937,
0.0018457596,
0.0663459301,
-0.0027086465,
0.086708717,
0.0364622921,
0.046466507,
-0.0118436562,
0.0231970958,
0.0480489731,
-0.0230541341,
0.0242935605,
0.0116775185,
0.0266580507,
0.0451282077,
-0.0243060999,
-0.0115789957,
0.1064912155,
0.0499995202,
-0.0499497242,
0.0069539375,
-0.0686832294,
0.0066383737,
0.0396621861,
-0.0052690459,
-0.0929803848,
-0.0401065499,
0.012583849,
-0.0320087224,
-0.0658406243,
-0.0599939413,
0.0074144001,
-0.1038543358,
0.0199864171,
0.0143720619,
0.0203957427,
-0.0150289023,
-0.0179719757,
-0.0125123356,
0.0069759567,
0.0130639886,
0.024205789,
0.0150528718,
-0.012271231,
-0.0129130064,
0.0600867122,
-0.0040751896,
0.0806197152,
-0.0025056435,
0.0652208477,
0.0617995225,
0.0311820805,
-0.0364678651,
-0.0126660354,
-0.0002530283,
0.0394730568,
-0.0097494181,
0.0049929488,
0.0109134987,
-0.0233158711,
0.0059779789,
-0.044850599,
0.0579467677,
0.0018159781,
-0.0622112826,
0.0210021846,
0.0986802205,
-0.0099371066,
-0.0329361707,
-0.0115348212,
0.0248853713,
-0.0071423445,
0.0669712573,
0.0185750127,
-0.0476439893,
0.0152714588,
-0.0455929786,
-0.0432682708,
-0.0386667736,
-0.0328344665,
-0.0258492455,
0.0483104996,
0.0163609851,
-0.0258757435,
-0.0758831874,
0.0206227452,
0.0183597468,
0.0204121675,
-0.0519140214,
0.0057425546,
0.0187267531,
-0.0388207324,
0.0044699688,
-0.0325752869,
-0.00427602,
0.0260960795,
0.0450213514,
-0.007856437,
-0.026769992,
-0.0186328683,
-0.0098898252,
-0.0601439625,
-0.0374591351,
0.012909133,
0.0571710616,
0.0185271185,
0.0347131379,
-0.0398219675,
0.0355012193,
-0.0270641539,
0.0370011963,
-0.0831922814,
0.0240784492,
0.0769855604,
0.0171246082,
0.0132735875,
0.0311397072,
0.0038375021,
0.0125419218,
0.0263104197,
0.0110148471,
-0.0178493448,
0.0255478546,
0.0538479015,
0.0221427232,
0.0257431064,
0.0030660869,
0.0205442756,
-0.0355708152,
0.0033161913,
-0.0428358428,
-0.0531179346,
-0.0064433813,
0.0084171742,
0.0117656048,
-0.0239258762,
-0.0032729183,
-0.0266799238,
-0.0450351276,
-0.0195370167,
0.0132215517,
0.0009251276,
0.0406155065,
0.0493813008,
-0.024504941,
-0.0172481257,
-0.0398726426,
0.0107194623,
0.0264242049,
0.0442556962,
-0.0360712111,
0.0990436524,
0.0183529872,
-0.0224136319,
-0.0051511792,
0.0030361009,
-0.1051181555,
0.0034096129,
0.0060558263,
0.0113614183,
0.0047611007,
0.0281902254,
-0.0209811088,
-0.0258177109,
0.0072213728,
0.0206304323,
0.0229942966,
0.0050861691,
-0.0433619991,
0.0014589664,
0.0183064099,
0.0011593055,
-0.0181504283,
0.0050016223,
-0.0716037154,
0.0403473489,
0.0252323803,
0.0229919795,
-0.0114217382,
-0.038312234,
0.020301206,
-0.013793542,
0.0082489401,
0.044739645,
-0.0957604349,
-0.0530569442,
-0.0531551838,
0.03779893,
0.0108363694,
-0.0290163606,
-0.0012338563,
0.0641813129,
-0.0230068564,
-0.0139657725,
-0.020511115,
0.0343086086,
0.0078977579,
0.0162393153,
-0.0787692294,
-5.551482559e-33,
-0.0429587178,
-0.0382992141,
0.0043981941,
-0.0175238457,
0.0077896649,
-0.0288273357,
-0.0081132296,
0.0215258468,
-0.0689910948,
0.0539564155,
-0.002339894,
0.0368530974,
-0.0104278224,
-0.0153084528,
0.0098094437,
-0.0486162901,
-0.0181197952,
-0.0027371955,
-0.0245942064,
0.0094484231,
-0.035839811,
-0.0077345679,
0.074919641,
-0.0471560806,
0.0496486612,
0.0008005329,
-0.0063211247,
0.0252375826,
-0.0623656102,
0.0161111224,
0.0014399581,
0.025405189,
0.0336524248,
0.0065409872,
0.0100167776,
0.0191539265,
-0.0192423966,
-0.0382087231,
0.0870767534,
-0.0352352113,
-0.0529598705,
-0.0352906771,
-0.0265854485,
-0.0083959214,
-0.0135833956,
-0.0116959354,
0.0180552304,
-0.0066591855,
0.0304733459,
0.0344807059,
-0.0912849233,
-0.0263882764,
-0.043185316,
-0.0464479811,
-0.0318635628,
0.0906413198,
-0.0183462426,
0.0070841969,
0.0075781392,
0.0327428021,
0.0162870679,
-0.0358075798,
0.0427389964,
-0.0284214243,
-0.003203429,
0.0542146787,
-0.0256309249,
0.0156891569,
-0.0400244668,
-0.0115610836,
0.0334671363,
0.0165412948,
0.0727869943,
0.0757629946,
0.0209369753,
-0.0128487172,
-0.0473775342,
-0.0376782045,
0.0440552272,
0.0075874175,
0.014735043,
-0.0163030364,
-0.0327800326,
0.0216814205,
-0.0511245355,
-0.083194308,
-0.0287438948,
-0.0258931369,
0.0236265212,
-0.0238935854,
-0.0099355886,
-0.0148313381,
-0.0056400448,
-0.0277227107,
0.0493525527,
0.0369026251,
0.0197118986,
-0.002400581,
0.0001969391,
0.0767986625,
-0.0441490971,
-0.0103940247,
0.0278753042,
0.0383165814,
0.0284045767,
-0.0143569186,
0.0868696123,
-0.0013561946,
-0.0150497258,
-0.0080893654,
-0.0593366399,
0.0324241184,
-0.0023331065,
-0.0289977007,
0.0006811952,
0.0530500486,
-0.0107868593,
-0.0031978439,
0.0266416371,
-0.0583933219,
-0.0652632415,
0.0221731197,
-0.0329226442,
0.0380289555,
-0.0230636392,
-0.0107930219,
-0.0246878974,
0.035633415,
0.0020981221,
-0.0535666086,
-0.0282625109,
0.0618816316,
2.578e-7,
0.0176835395,
0.0007379755,
0.0183665995,
0.0153994625,
-0.0097131943,
0.0784822851,
0.0021717136,
0.0315610841,
0.0554498993,
-0.0391051583,
-0.0058414252,
0.0490555167,
0.0408139229,
0.015201346,
-0.0205886513,
0.0139432456,
-0.0463849194,
-0.0472559892,
-0.0269852523,
0.0400720127,
0.0812538639,
0.0829958543,
0.0415312387,
-0.0041301404,
0.030484166,
0.0231932662,
0.0201513674,
-0.0365172215,
-0.0358801149,
-0.0324352011,
-0.0498004295,
-0.0262786429,
0.0030403575,
0.0473048128,
0.0355303511,
-0.0041890768,
-0.0345690884,
0.0245018583,
-0.0495888256,
-0.0537725687,
-0.0520033427,
-0.0253078844,
-0.0074271462,
-0.033399459,
0.0941897705,
-0.0139629524,
-0.0000548794,
-0.0069956188,
0.0238827318,
0.0117502715,
-0.0160845742,
-0.0015012531,
-0.0546223707,
-0.0061041419,
0.0243315902,
0.0044834926,
0.0165108386,
-0.0404500291,
-0.017603511,
0.0295441896,
0.0212065019,
-0.0666698739,
0.009763361,
0.018761253,
0.0470004082,
-0.0648532733,
0.0143901417,
1.89489609e-34,
0.0338190906,
-0.0334591456,
0.0487821586,
0.0308857746,
0.0322204418,
0.0328117311,
-0.028409116,
-0.0208781566,
0.0460947305,
0.0005879857,
-0.0261376295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14264v1 | Visual Question Answering in Remote Sensing with Cross-Attention and Multimodal Information Bottleneck | 2023-06-25T15:09:21 | 2023-06-25T15:09:21 | Jayesh Songara, Shivam Pande, Shabnam Choudhury, Biplab Banerjee, Rajbabu Velmurugan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this research, we deal with the problem of visual question answering (VQA)
in remote sensing. While remotely sensed images contain information significant
for the task of identification and object detection, they pose a great
challenge in their processing because of high dimensionality, volume and
redundancy. Furthermore, processing image information jointly with language
features adds additional constraints, such as mapping the corresponding image
and language features. To handle this problem, we propose a cross attention
based approach combined with information maximization. The CNN-LSTM based
cross-attention highlights the information in the image and language modalities
and establishes a connection between the two, while information maximization
learns a low dimensional bottleneck layer, that has all the relevant
information required to carry out the VQA task. We evaluate our method on two
VQA remote sensing datasets of different resolutions. For the high resolution
dataset, we achieve an overall accuracy of 79.11% and 73.87% for the two test
sets while for the low resolution dataset, we achieve an overall accuracy of
85.98%. | [
0.0466059186,
0.0168755874,
0.0133489072,
0.0877913535,
-0.0129195228,
0.0101413913,
-0.0097367885,
-0.0051841429,
0.0314332806,
-0.0554235242,
-0.033906877,
-0.0223249439,
0.0050314842,
0.0230791736,
0.0230590831,
-0.0602727011,
0.0585244969,
-0.0386972204,
0.0266251471,
-0.0158514231,
0.0094077345,
-0.0050395154,
0.0280605741,
-0.0102989031,
-0.0235067569,
-0.0171902422,
0.0073161712,
0.0087075876,
0.0625571981,
-0.0183630921,
-0.0064776326,
0.0159025714,
0.0433669835,
0.0024893209,
0.0000019243,
-0.0051757488,
-0.0099630654,
-0.0239496455,
-0.0087508634,
-0.0238426849,
0.0136306062,
-0.0613278896,
0.0243645832,
-0.0111296149,
-0.0477179661,
-0.0161178671,
0.0697826445,
0.0438114479,
0.069368422,
0.058071278,
0.0041456185,
-0.0080541549,
0.0391150936,
-0.0056508747,
0.0334802344,
-0.045729395,
0.0083301989,
0.0307065789,
-0.0182970241,
0.0060908599,
-0.0496074818,
0.065118216,
0.0374737158,
0.0076304856,
-0.0275845714,
0.0625320375,
-0.0364380665,
-0.0086086839,
-0.0299496111,
0.0758815408,
-0.0152193578,
0.0217618253,
-0.0380977057,
-0.0021328202,
-0.0149929943,
0.001075567,
-0.0354039185,
0.0243537407,
-0.0147537775,
0.0039243232,
-0.0271190293,
-0.0101429271,
-0.0329481475,
0.0536403321,
-0.046043288,
0.0353655703,
0.0051026158,
0.009143766,
-0.0255470816,
-0.0139644891,
-0.0372940637,
-0.0215703119,
-0.0063580726,
0.0741338059,
-0.0288381483,
-0.0012737999,
-0.0402000509,
-0.0371863544,
-0.0110526485,
-0.0109522538,
0.0006538279,
-0.0001049066,
-0.0524426773,
0.1034676284,
-0.0201662015,
0.0611455105,
-0.0444251299,
0.0243813768,
0.0063244761,
-0.0583834313,
-0.0020779786,
-0.0437826328,
-0.0439395308,
0.0178496838,
-0.0121066524,
-0.0239941627,
0.0175833404,
0.0088949464,
0.0171263982,
-0.0124608669,
-0.0006481056,
0.0374965928,
-0.0612001084,
-0.0430833548,
-0.0239256863,
0.0472331606,
-0.0158528425,
0.028188346,
-0.009777341,
-0.0733553544,
0.0184904616,
0.0543007925,
0.0399340242,
-0.0463426299,
-0.0245044343,
0.0593948588,
0.0026410841,
-0.0443555899,
-0.0668607429,
-0.0296093058,
-0.0142812785,
-0.0385311991,
0.0317939408,
-0.0362671502,
0.0194742847,
0.0008072566,
-0.0156208221,
0.0031549917,
0.0013213177,
-0.0048127659,
-0.0254000407,
0.0869717374,
-0.0143325543,
-0.0237686578,
0.0620350242,
-0.0205621347,
0.041528672,
0.0854079723,
0.015103925,
0.0596322902,
0.0160495713,
-0.0087908283,
0.0285421275,
0.0155880265,
-0.0181275364,
0.0445473418,
-0.0616397634,
0.0613998398,
-0.0291165262,
0.0203471612,
0.0626491383,
0.0446438231,
-0.0150387594,
-0.0197808109,
0.0479922444,
0.0301566347,
0.0023759834,
-0.0177360307,
0.0222965628,
0.0644037947,
-0.0402825959,
0.0230340958,
-0.0453933179,
0.100863263,
0.0089738239,
0.0034433589,
0.0335435569,
0.0210598204,
-0.0534303412,
-0.0358550362,
-0.0196894165,
-0.0082030222,
-0.0216608364,
0.0665999427,
0.0450769588,
-0.0155917499,
0.0227194205,
0.0337398387,
0.0100610023,
0.0323968194,
0.0133758457,
0.0034707913,
0.0433679111,
0.0230776872,
-0.0419720411,
-0.0467633307,
0.0073198965,
-0.0096743247,
0.0690905079,
0.0772539154,
0.0076113949,
0.0423374549,
-0.0077895806,
-0.0334398262,
-0.0616440475,
-0.0184432343,
-0.0456329174,
0.0247667693,
0.0040695425,
0.0519567207,
0.030285079,
-0.0393651873,
0.0009648933,
0.0189207792,
0.0586582422,
-0.0214191321,
-0.0006145183,
0.0715329796,
0.0341612846,
0.0039913622,
-0.0190859735,
-0.0113868751,
0.0047126524,
-0.0338338464,
-0.0163120776,
-0.019745402,
-0.0305110645,
-0.0572208986,
0.0090673305,
-0.0769485682,
-0.0486678854,
0.0720532462,
-0.0521459915,
-0.048240345,
0.0590737984,
-0.0537505411,
-0.0204479583,
-0.0492137894,
-0.0610657632,
0.0581863821,
0.05943048,
-0.0416140184,
0.056053184,
-0.0429286435,
0.0258202404,
-0.0058944272,
-0.014898682,
0.0620335229,
-0.0261574704,
0.0177101418,
0.002241276,
-0.0206325743,
-0.0293706954,
-0.0069472864,
0.0298485179,
-0.042739518,
-0.0150820194,
-0.0396164656,
-0.0405727476,
-0.0353921838,
0.0021727453,
0.0254644603,
0.0280830301,
0.0103906905,
-0.0435413197,
-0.0636508912,
0.0128170056,
0.0019483991,
0.0210486725,
0.0554812774,
0.0210662,
0.0329225063,
-0.0267771669,
0.001182967,
0.015381299,
0.0538662188,
-0.0014148493,
-0.0603888147,
-0.019411223,
-0.0287706424,
-0.0344884396,
0.0503655635,
0.0070043448,
-0.0396065675,
0.0298697762,
-0.0449384004,
0.0326106623,
0.0568029247,
0.0094524231,
-0.0434189849,
0.0058921189,
-0.0145771792,
-0.0601122901,
0.0501824394,
-0.0002114774,
-0.0068403021,
0.0313809663,
0.0023825222,
-0.0080905398,
0.0263937563,
-0.0250700545,
-0.0098047378,
0.005257572,
0.0186984818,
-0.0135372775,
-0.005840322,
-0.0686689392,
0.0275283866,
0.0222399328,
0.0211643036,
-0.0480719209,
-0.0588346533,
0.0682647675,
-0.0005037138,
-0.0246691387,
-0.0460588261,
0.0102284653,
-0.0624332838,
0.0582510792,
0.0088907499,
0.0157455802,
-0.0119019886,
-0.020195853,
-0.0558377393,
-0.048324205,
-0.004792308,
0.0244669057,
0.0285507701,
-0.0447596163,
0.0305429716,
-0.0500640012,
0.0167272259,
-0.0157108326,
-0.0387686193,
-0.02335703,
-0.0064484547,
-0.0387716629,
-0.0113506531,
0.0037148041,
0.0222970769,
0.0622177906,
0.0146671254,
-0.0135193169,
0.0073902938,
-0.0224610008,
0.0978978723,
0.0772309899,
0.0880928189,
-0.0022596556,
0.0092792278,
0.0112141902,
0.0112143168,
-0.0004799124,
-0.0043461854,
0.0008184151,
0.0261315685,
0.0368449055,
0.0351206996,
0.0304843169,
0.01515067,
0.0749547407,
-0.0783738717,
0.002231014,
0.0549877882,
0.0008880105,
-0.0414323285,
-0.0112121515,
-0.0066964426,
-0.0236530304,
0.0311267357,
0.0077075521,
-0.0387590528,
-0.0534217134,
-0.0802515,
-0.0509774201,
0.0248256475,
0.0163875669,
-0.0410617553,
-0.0689834878,
0.0352807418,
-0.0195424613,
-0.0762807205,
-0.0587624051,
0.0179248191,
-0.0191326663,
0.0341160372,
-0.0071206363,
-0.0488569811,
0.0147234648,
0.001925436,
-0.0173916966,
0.0103838891,
-0.0025305115,
0.0016702609,
-0.0638163909,
-0.0405170061,
0.0434933305,
-0.0002253967,
-0.0251868069,
-0.0659659132,
0.0084778592,
-0.0414314717,
0.0095253056,
0.0008714075,
0.0062720194,
-0.0139614521,
-0.0543297194,
0.0194448736,
0.0147883901,
-0.0326915048,
0.016859863,
-0.0018047731,
0.0482390709,
-0.0234232917,
0.0074424869,
-0.0302445479,
-0.0047466806,
0.0661546662,
0.0344823375,
0.0351472609,
0.0010932899,
-0.0512580574,
0.0026652149,
-0.0278801154,
-0.0726079643,
-0.0293364394,
0.0480629355,
0.0182088632,
-0.0067147962,
-0.0418197922,
-0.0499272868,
0.0553774983,
0.0032559652,
-0.0298683569,
-0.0280707665,
0.0128493067,
0.0048310617,
-0.0399140567,
0.0828412324,
-0.0381369852,
0.0171105489,
-0.0384935811,
0.0074696834,
0.0164014045,
-0.0436590873,
0.0148795266,
0.0186514594,
-0.1009132862,
0.0083309533,
-0.0323722214,
-0.0247934069,
-0.0024124626,
0.0338610485,
-0.0177307129,
-0.0409912243,
0.0261081886,
0.001329379,
-0.0205755606,
0.0079704374,
-0.0311077256,
0.0107024573,
-0.0012755261,
0.0142114041,
-0.0443111211,
0.0182162952,
0.0423142426,
-0.0358337313,
-0.0572950132,
-0.0083021782,
0.0074868668,
0.022742914,
0.0482730828,
-0.0023641586,
-0.0096286349,
-0.0103673451,
0.0239458438,
0.0325366706,
-0.0244874544,
-0.0370242074,
0.0109150019,
0.00825861,
-0.0140483705,
0.005758252,
0.0406194367,
0.0109240282,
-0.0476274528,
-0.0306960549,
0.0102519812,
0.0021962561,
-0.0000660513,
-0.0177624617,
-0.0027111717,
-0.0416816957,
0.0074696275,
0.0118719367,
0.0294639431,
0.0359345265,
0.0286700688,
0.0230789408,
-0.0431554653,
-0.0276746582,
0.0217516646,
-0.0133988131,
-0.0383893996,
-0.0339549445,
0.0012945649,
0.0314252526,
0.0079854066,
-0.0351132378,
0.0048684687,
-0.0073662736,
-0.010472957,
-0.0262152161,
0.0383067392,
-0.0408259295,
0.1010498405,
0.0324201286,
-0.0135553721,
0.007921393,
0.0593447685,
0.0307687204,
0.0275443792,
0.0020412789,
0.0396105424,
-0.0475506224,
0.0036113712,
-0.0237846468,
-0.0190423112,
0.0148046706,
0.0943543166,
-0.0083363596,
-0.0303332042,
0.0160721336,
0.0128647881,
-0.0406699441,
0.0403591432,
0.0224232767,
0.0319745019,
0.0467446931,
-0.0158925429,
-0.0048773745,
0.0144765358,
-0.0263664238,
-0.0183556285,
-0.0094395475,
-6.31363379e-33,
-0.0204122681,
-0.0527382307,
0.0322210155,
-0.0270299967,
-0.0124482252,
0.0483058356,
-0.0136474399,
-0.022344023,
-0.0636896938,
-0.0073708175,
0.0102832466,
0.0147917261,
0.0207974594,
0.0558435358,
0.019182127,
-0.0015313622,
-0.0161973108,
-0.0101402644,
0.0159239378,
-0.0107826041,
-0.0056710481,
-0.0023414642,
0.0594401322,
-0.0491408631,
-0.023836242,
0.0069330577,
-0.0214596111,
0.0435360819,
-0.0052356282,
0.0667159855,
-0.0531266369,
0.0346265174,
0.038088616,
-0.0396907814,
-0.0297767818,
0.0353651792,
-0.0350262374,
-0.0364377797,
0.0116975764,
0.0321557857,
-0.0906444937,
-0.019310046,
0.0430971608,
-0.0153915007,
0.0842678547,
-0.0370949656,
0.0346094891,
-0.0133409435,
-0.0138644055,
-0.022590654,
-0.0386662558,
0.0425144248,
-0.013128995,
-0.0129292496,
-0.0025724547,
0.0509538651,
0.0106501365,
0.0516725257,
-0.058013007,
0.0219731592,
0.0120038688,
0.0677190498,
0.0559079535,
0.0437659733,
-0.0162661951,
0.0522202216,
0.007452752,
-0.0262284167,
-0.0110484138,
-0.0295193177,
-0.0050399019,
0.0341106914,
0.0731822178,
0.0822690129,
0.0222056415,
0.0080885841,
-0.059685275,
-0.0133335004,
-0.0367719866,
0.0776895508,
-0.0202467516,
-0.0174157824,
0.0236451775,
-0.0207884312,
-0.007863123,
0.0462960415,
-0.0605447628,
0.0241690297,
0.0501301251,
0.0022406678,
-0.0170008764,
0.0492899604,
0.0412585884,
-0.0118737137,
0.0060580471,
-0.0166469272,
0.03807275,
0.057466995,
0.0529877394,
0.0242768452,
-0.0427506827,
-0.004495041,
0.0378068984,
-0.0042012534,
-0.045870401,
0.0265751928,
0.0513949655,
0.0204485953,
-0.0422487333,
-0.0282215029,
-0.0377742723,
0.0040547838,
-0.0259757824,
0.0307183098,
0.0371503308,
-0.0445665568,
-0.0413835309,
0.033426512,
-0.0218640137,
-0.0359285548,
0.0231772196,
-0.0449242927,
-0.0140368007,
0.0530131944,
-0.0216285847,
0.0245137867,
-0.0344078653,
-0.0376221836,
-0.0231381897,
-0.0138700353,
-0.0010949847,
0.0683067143,
2.589e-7,
0.0259298626,
-0.0067238472,
0.0303587727,
-0.0054348484,
0.0109432051,
0.0252802633,
-0.0122423312,
0.0264430009,
-0.0144498292,
-0.0350519717,
-0.00052565,
0.0429563634,
0.0481098667,
0.0013750055,
-0.0788169801,
0.0319427215,
-0.0001249336,
-0.0242108833,
-0.0604274794,
-0.0110871121,
0.0628344417,
0.0953430533,
-0.0384107977,
0.0027481485,
0.0198482331,
-0.0820446685,
0.0280708056,
-0.0039043406,
-0.0022323856,
-0.0262535941,
-0.023739744,
0.0014656596,
-0.0093577188,
0.0488992631,
0.0000214204,
-0.0296954643,
0.0276618954,
0.0089983903,
-0.008520253,
-0.0648882315,
-0.0166482516,
0.0093384339,
-0.0001460716,
-0.0251341444,
0.0876106098,
-0.0750966594,
-0.0354636647,
0.0087841749,
0.012431832,
0.0053589647,
0.0479601994,
-0.0221037753,
-0.0347671285,
-0.0029954317,
0.0296073239,
-0.0384976938,
-0.0291010067,
-0.0602253713,
0.0133280661,
-0.0103939548,
-0.0525451899,
-0.0022442504,
-0.0739855841,
-0.0281798132,
0.0908366889,
0.0205635019,
-0.0466368571,
1.490264991e-34,
0.0056623379,
-0.0089503778,
-0.0057989643,
-0.0081000281,
-0.0126890047,
0.0068165506,
-0.0387026221,
-0.020085685,
0.0120271416,
-0.0712482855,
-0.0048828409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14222v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14222v2 | Unveiling the Potential of Sentiment: Can Large Language Models Predict Chinese Stock Price Movements? | 2023-06-25T12:08:44 | 2024-05-04T13:02:32 | Haohan Zhang, Fengrui Hua, Chengjin Xu, Hao Kong, Ruiting Zuo, Jian Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, q-fin.ST | The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has spurred discussions
about their potential to enhance quantitative trading strategies. LLMs excel in
analyzing sentiments about listed companies from financial news, providing
critical insights for trading decisions. However, the performance of LLMs in
this task varies substantially due to their inherent characteristics. This
paper introduces a standardized experimental procedure for comprehensive
evaluations. We detail the methodology using three distinct LLMs, each
embodying a unique approach to performance enhancement, applied specifically to
the task of sentiment factor extraction from large volumes of Chinese news
summaries. Subsequently, we develop quantitative trading strategies using these
sentiment factors and conduct back-tests in realistic scenarios. Our results
will offer perspectives about the performances of Large Language Models applied
to extracting sentiments from Chinese news texts. | [
0.0345774405,
0.0941595733,
-0.0000813847,
0.0123881903,
-0.0193464141,
0.0045679854,
0.0271430723,
0.029506987,
0.0012911366,
-0.0465646349,
0.0017330237,
-0.0739769563,
-0.0482038073,
0.0363030583,
0.007477704,
-0.0069494271,
0.000372661,
-0.0158358552,
0.0447931513,
-0.0091035478,
0.0173051115,
0.0003552978,
0.08334627,
0.0062780203,
-0.008596817,
0.0086323377,
-0.0045577209,
-0.0113474941,
0.0107299779,
-0.0237009153,
-0.0021930709,
-0.0044943215,
-0.0117092934,
0.0173621476,
0.0000017372,
-0.0286481697,
-0.0125508513,
0.0038880953,
0.0610200763,
0.024690453,
0.071606122,
-0.0530004725,
0.0082402267,
0.0193722751,
-0.0692387968,
-0.041919332,
0.0302651469,
0.0816696435,
0.0640092194,
0.0878699124,
-0.0349183679,
-0.0243099853,
-0.009021041,
-0.0495684296,
-0.0042636814,
-0.0446910076,
0.0486623421,
0.0296630953,
-0.0048544607,
0.0051965136,
-0.0020880834,
0.0259229559,
-0.025943676,
0.0256684553,
-0.0394232571,
0.0007339487,
-0.0151984096,
0.0141915344,
-0.0229631644,
0.0117679723,
0.0251075774,
0.0345721729,
0.0001881341,
-0.0033810243,
-0.0122363865,
0.0247449242,
-0.0187689122,
0.0204881392,
-0.0135761704,
0.0537238643,
0.033636339,
-0.0055687875,
0.0202938858,
0.0212810021,
-0.0429116227,
0.0580334179,
-0.0277095567,
-0.0394057408,
0.0505977049,
0.0303917639,
-0.0019668203,
-0.0111035202,
0.0205622707,
-0.013125997,
0.0278483182,
0.0344363637,
0.0286028162,
0.0048591192,
-0.010761884,
-0.1561359018,
-0.0334542543,
0.0255475417,
-0.0160034392,
0.0423406996,
-0.0575308762,
0.0200836603,
0.0124647794,
-0.0593476817,
-0.0160577167,
-0.0020451536,
-0.0530426912,
0.0026718276,
0.0047340468,
0.0857285857,
-0.0168719236,
-0.0362160467,
-0.0699777082,
-0.0030162015,
-0.0071378024,
0.018423574,
0.010326759,
-0.0376952738,
0.0154840974,
-0.0124142403,
-0.0202079508,
0.0116503062,
-0.0155664328,
0.0318583436,
-0.0491695888,
-0.0037517587,
0.0356870852,
0.0161211789,
-0.0172685869,
-0.0024890047,
0.0253471714,
0.0855454803,
0.0256243031,
-0.0119698653,
-0.0360269286,
-0.0438717529,
-0.0083171334,
-0.0358976014,
-0.0237421915,
-0.0260645617,
-0.0154621331,
-0.0064859129,
0.005986671,
0.0044284617,
0.0307482574,
-0.02485439,
-0.0303337518,
0.0302078854,
0.0305363368,
-0.0217634048,
-0.0285436399,
-0.0330118835,
0.042430494,
0.0821110755,
-0.0275921021,
0.0440279916,
0.0756684914,
-0.0051605278,
-0.0033486774,
0.0452771187,
-0.020032391,
-0.0290575475,
-0.0696379319,
0.0098109925,
0.0105466954,
-0.0588085055,
0.042977605,
0.0386227742,
0.0041514658,
0.0027314967,
0.0512960777,
0.0233920682,
0.0075443583,
0.0517099537,
-0.0110699413,
-0.0245795436,
0.0100366641,
-0.0154982554,
0.0086051142,
-0.0223956145,
-0.0345238708,
0.0311743207,
0.0190602783,
0.0206120107,
-0.0283172186,
-0.047515206,
-0.0037666881,
-0.0209769942,
0.02544754,
-0.0035414624,
0.0403247625,
-0.1052626669,
-0.0209908132,
0.0156893227,
0.0536159612,
-0.0366315395,
0.0161694679,
-0.0033977602,
0.0267317928,
0.0931957215,
-0.01918035,
0.0086669819,
0.0645669624,
-0.0114688156,
-0.0568569861,
0.0385836586,
0.0186422784,
0.0112924464,
-0.0511698574,
-0.017820755,
0.0198153481,
0.0372911468,
0.0434213169,
0.0062619755,
-0.029027503,
0.0451083183,
-0.0107836844,
0.008983559,
-0.0480158292,
0.004437936,
0.0274286047,
-0.0510046594,
0.0186873358,
-0.030040022,
0.0224211756,
0.0508345068,
-0.0283648763,
-0.0186963603,
-0.0058131488,
-0.0196702369,
-0.0772691518,
0.0251566134,
-0.0115712536,
-0.0217046179,
0.0057284455,
0.0024894774,
0.0154617168,
0.0152627081,
-0.0134960832,
-0.0126731964,
-0.0043213656,
-0.0237914696,
0.0242851973,
-0.0653729439,
-0.0192962531,
-0.0301925149,
0.0279401261,
0.0053029926,
0.0348377377,
-0.0081016868,
0.0191016831,
-0.0480313003,
-0.0239563044,
0.0005911999,
0.0031161758,
-0.0275345035,
0.0451530106,
0.0296224728,
0.0592484362,
0.0269445442,
-0.0103253564,
0.0297366865,
-0.0525262579,
-0.0887828767,
-0.0270901434,
-0.0114917587,
0.0106652165,
0.0100009395,
0.008263248,
-0.0105313966,
0.0383806564,
-0.0295312814,
-0.0219715089,
-0.0072496431,
0.0066188215,
0.040849641,
0.0040638247,
0.0043831985,
-0.0575209558,
-0.0129811391,
-0.022426907,
0.0350041948,
0.0321470536,
-0.0426250994,
-0.0406993292,
0.0346120745,
-0.0317373276,
-0.0003911476,
-0.0019437742,
-0.0263512358,
-0.0293467008,
-0.0453599654,
-0.0032433718,
0.0658132061,
0.0382236987,
0.0063721687,
-0.001461001,
-0.0206045676,
-0.0373601913,
0.0037349162,
-0.0335595272,
0.0181369688,
-0.0486161485,
-0.047148563,
-0.0022563464,
0.0413065702,
-0.0104105733,
0.001275111,
-0.0720169097,
0.0084386282,
-0.0392690562,
0.035880588,
-0.0329493694,
0.0208332017,
-0.0126086576,
0.0424398147,
0.0301427301,
-0.0443580002,
0.0369380824,
0.0061585652,
0.0025582085,
-0.0488293543,
-0.0321460776,
-0.0760390386,
0.0234902557,
-0.03879489,
-0.0006603964,
-0.0380313769,
0.0132786492,
0.031594526,
-0.0193390269,
-0.0205722824,
-0.0433256626,
0.0454269238,
0.0020956553,
0.0267393626,
0.0208969191,
0.0076238723,
0.0208521802,
-0.0421941429,
-0.0823507756,
0.0359267369,
0.0892077535,
-0.0483113565,
0.006743602,
0.0780279636,
-0.0068718134,
-0.0710119307,
-0.0202775449,
-0.0221011452,
0.0422871113,
0.00082155,
0.0686167553,
-0.0472664051,
0.0459746122,
-0.0378607251,
0.0588431209,
0.0152494228,
0.0311667286,
0.0247564353,
-0.0176017284,
-0.0103462646,
0.0051350007,
0.0122698052,
-0.0171775725,
-0.0079671005,
-0.0023502614,
-0.0403758697,
0.0094897402,
0.0934027284,
-0.005347,
-0.0185991377,
0.0093732243,
0.0374347232,
-0.0206534211,
-0.0258055422,
0.0124458205,
-0.0522503927,
-0.0029700801,
-0.0253991634,
-0.0064756116,
0.0094609801,
-0.0242207088,
0.0080523556,
-0.1600631177,
0.0591756403,
0.0027064884,
-0.0168784522,
-0.0347630121,
-0.0637489632,
0.0152969984,
-0.0506141447,
0.020625446,
-0.0009825544,
-0.0257333517,
0.0092264265,
-0.0085688261,
-0.0791395232,
-0.0153281949,
0.0239449088,
0.0097319102,
-0.0247608237,
0.0094041731,
0.0143524939,
-0.0400347821,
0.0168254562,
-0.0263395179,
-0.0109815393,
0.000902486,
-0.0281828623,
0.0566016659,
-0.0181758218,
-0.0275040101,
0.001198811,
0.0268591475,
-0.0106395157,
0.075044103,
0.0167397391,
-0.0158551466,
-0.0054165684,
-0.089212589,
0.0178339016,
0.0720126033,
0.0129186343,
0.055298131,
-0.0073982198,
-0.1044294909,
-0.0260070357,
-0.0373347029,
-0.0418270826,
-0.0473953709,
-0.0568415038,
0.0012452587,
-0.0080068745,
-0.0150384409,
-0.0914016217,
-0.0632737577,
-0.0068685287,
0.0375843979,
-0.0193805136,
0.0488418452,
0.0350462198,
0.0250688978,
-0.0112837311,
0.0085962573,
0.0428647101,
-0.0077573517,
-0.014527793,
0.0343514644,
0.0696619451,
-0.0037359491,
-0.0205684118,
-0.0262801088,
-0.0507718995,
-0.0460516401,
0.0102924155,
0.0276676826,
0.0109797958,
-0.0380766578,
0.0158621352,
0.0346837677,
0.020993378,
0.0417405404,
-0.0312846377,
-0.0090579456,
0.0583964176,
0.0680061579,
0.0136445817,
0.0110843461,
-0.0041967714,
0.029683942,
-0.0107845142,
0.020398302,
-0.0540799387,
-0.0280700289,
-0.0143265026,
0.0208847579,
0.0125405043,
0.036076609,
-0.0200403761,
-0.0107463393,
-0.0136347422,
-0.0018010035,
-0.0166049376,
-0.0319620743,
-0.0375055298,
0.023238942,
0.0135544883,
-0.0656974986,
0.0359483734,
0.0131985107,
-0.0354660675,
-0.0120716775,
0.0500487015,
-0.0254071597,
0.0177920647,
0.0263572298,
0.0077916291,
-0.0055701374,
-0.0408503637,
0.0397670232,
0.0011989727,
-0.0048234141,
0.0126348231,
0.0247162897,
-0.0034700094,
0.0033416126,
-0.0414299965,
-0.033297956,
-0.0236316249,
-0.0160456859,
0.0297105666,
-0.0067409128,
-0.0313920602,
0.0286380779,
-0.0685322583,
0.0127112046,
0.0079766791,
0.0014629127,
-0.0107630538,
-0.0025167316,
0.0111283269,
-0.0003572173,
-0.0758566931,
-0.016693728,
0.0584216006,
-0.027906891,
0.023577759,
0.0292522144,
-0.0263885222,
-0.0434640981,
-0.0016944987,
0.0842168778,
-0.0267200526,
-0.0158732589,
0.0120102149,
-0.0660215616,
-0.0536481515,
0.044274874,
-0.0240121931,
0.0057481462,
-0.0011348245,
-0.0032826823,
0.0626856089,
0.0278644357,
0.0965188965,
-0.0479576252,
-0.0056045246,
-0.0492267832,
-0.0007322558,
-0.052193556,
-6.218349687e-33,
0.0123454956,
0.0069448492,
-0.0150788408,
0.0369707756,
0.0149292964,
0.0172528233,
-0.0242156796,
0.0339288712,
-0.0014372931,
0.0255927891,
0.0229508597,
0.0138614755,
0.0005027704,
0.0200828575,
0.0418887101,
0.0095474999,
0.0294320304,
-0.0079850256,
0.0242073666,
-0.0232869871,
0.046174258,
0.0512688085,
0.0310606379,
-0.0651545897,
0.026635427,
-0.0133615034,
-0.0586158037,
-0.0183951706,
0.0553286336,
0.0483752564,
0.0158920269,
0.0585784242,
0.0271272846,
-0.0558276623,
0.0104605313,
0.0171892699,
0.0454781875,
-0.0106924437,
0.0028837605,
0.020081535,
0.04812406,
0.0151982186,
0.0125945779,
0.0068816766,
-0.0028193728,
0.0187418777,
0.0327659361,
-0.0187759902,
-0.0048509026,
-0.0787292719,
-0.0562124066,
0.0363080204,
0.0265967716,
0.0774973929,
0.0541113243,
0.0858779177,
-0.012411125,
0.0314700939,
-0.0115581099,
0.0051741707,
0.0127287572,
0.0593894348,
-0.0280766729,
0.0074592913,
0.0173781868,
0.055254519,
0.0037415144,
-0.0127112782,
0.0073383795,
0.0484693088,
0.0541407131,
0.0328567065,
0.0181627143,
0.0674895793,
0.0199623276,
-0.0363598838,
-0.0476898737,
-0.0017246266,
0.0346775576,
-0.012381562,
0.0550895743,
0.0080425348,
-0.0363715142,
-0.0399885997,
0.0264210794,
0.0238007847,
-0.0220043883,
-0.0357489847,
-0.0006600703,
0.0110241855,
-0.0540282652,
-0.0195553396,
0.0323409475,
-0.0540008806,
-0.104954347,
0.0113531407,
-0.0565425418,
0.0425591022,
-0.0252846945,
-0.0300136805,
-0.0388732739,
-0.0545102209,
-0.0464198031,
0.0170536786,
-0.0313206464,
-0.0511722788,
0.0170050096,
0.0223972201,
-0.0660955235,
-0.0428594798,
0.0191266015,
0.006201765,
0.0298138782,
0.036730282,
0.0022754306,
-0.0067719161,
-0.0054040239,
0.0130877951,
0.0045841872,
0.0311161168,
0.0012821344,
-0.0235786531,
0.0003861747,
0.0024484352,
0.0080808969,
0.0094144,
0.0223527998,
0.0665374249,
0.0182455517,
-0.0239717159,
-0.0089751668,
0.0268408433,
2.5e-7,
0.0477903932,
0.0809053034,
-0.0478073433,
0.022723807,
-0.0012561725,
0.0447755158,
-0.0307809841,
0.0113066379,
0.0268662442,
-0.0049847015,
0.0508081466,
0.0369803123,
0.0469740592,
0.0456135087,
-0.0845360234,
-0.0137233613,
-0.0278917681,
0.0021969641,
-0.0519597307,
0.0373172164,
0.0165306944,
0.0798141435,
-0.0104725091,
0.0036238371,
-0.0075860554,
-0.0440151505,
0.0455778539,
-0.0678382665,
-0.0304265339,
0.0438804701,
-0.0165632088,
0.0153679084,
-0.0175975207,
-0.0182878394,
0.0097570494,
0.0272173397,
0.0196068417,
0.0435193516,
0.0384192578,
0.0175313167,
0.0194558278,
0.0150555065,
-0.0014679471,
-0.0348331518,
0.0326803811,
-0.0595073216,
-0.0395228006,
-0.0799275041,
-0.027384501,
0.0085321004,
0.0399465188,
-0.0176705383,
-0.0153465122,
0.0540270023,
-0.0150620397,
-0.0108277472,
0.0114970561,
-0.028826613,
-0.038406752,
0.0267878715,
-0.0416851528,
-0.0235991627,
0.0007197958,
0.0139343934,
-0.0206715502,
-0.0084398873,
0.055380933,
1.899348734e-34,
0.0803064257,
-0.0082827052,
-0.0546922907,
0.0603577383,
0.054213766,
0.004663853,
-0.0595648885,
0.0453932844,
-0.0148432832,
-0.0792760998,
0.0106821796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14203v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14203v2 | Stance Prediction and Analysis of Twitter data : A case study of Ghana 2020 Presidential Elections | 2023-06-25T10:54:24 | 2023-06-27T18:39:53 | Shester Gueuwou, Rose-Mary Owusuaa Mensah Gyening | cs.CL | cs.CL | On December 7, 2020, Ghanaians participated in the polls to determine their
president for the next four years. To gain insights from this presidential
election, we conducted stance analysis (which is not always equivalent to
sentiment analysis) to understand how Twitter, a popular social media platform,
reflected the opinions of its users regarding the two main presidential
candidates. We collected a total of 99,356 tweets using the Twitter API
(Tweepy) and manually annotated 3,090 tweets into three classes: Against,
Neutral, and Support. We then performed preprocessing on the tweets. The
resulting dataset was evaluated using two lexicon-based approaches, VADER and
TextBlob, as well as five supervised machine learning-based approaches: Support
Vector Machine (SVM), Logistic Regression (LR), Multinomial Na\"ive Bayes
(MNB), Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD), and Random Forest (RF), based on
metrics such as accuracy, precision, recall, and F1-score. The best performance
was achieved by Logistic Regression with an accuracy of 71.13%. We utilized
Logistic Regression to classify all the extracted tweets and subsequently
conducted an analysis and discussion of the results. For access to our data and
code, please visit:
https://github.com/ShesterG/Stance-Detection-Ghana-2020-Elections.git | [
0.0668520927,
0.0735558569,
0.0149540771,
0.0090343226,
-0.0124647282,
0.0446347147,
-0.0329348221,
-0.007480219,
0.0094283046,
-0.0497292131,
0.082315065,
-0.0727396533,
-0.0097620348,
0.0156552214,
-0.0358117223,
-0.0581770875,
0.0372599773,
0.0571796857,
0.0521668047,
-0.0214857254,
0.0353017673,
0.0457152799,
-0.0335242674,
0.0468485057,
-0.0565249361,
0.0107474485,
-0.0162789468,
-0.0355265886,
0.0261952691,
-0.0101521583,
0.0311125387,
0.0213256832,
-0.0319778509,
0.0224993117,
0.0000021971,
-0.0471471585,
-0.0401259996,
-0.0310408175,
0.0246531516,
-0.043658454,
0.0521008819,
-0.0248987172,
0.0092196725,
0.0415050685,
-0.0915319324,
0.008625458,
0.0651903003,
0.0174194649,
0.0768729597,
0.0816414878,
0.0090141147,
-0.0397052839,
-0.0209319834,
0.006471158,
-0.0386644676,
-0.0165221523,
0.0176813081,
-0.0492993668,
-0.0765168592,
0.0221935064,
0.017295491,
-0.021232143,
-0.0211661309,
0.0005751106,
-0.0075431583,
-0.0170918945,
-0.0084640663,
-0.0518205501,
-0.0127822608,
-0.0103906738,
0.0301864482,
-0.0205936003,
0.0018716726,
-0.0189771447,
-0.0141571406,
0.0415757932,
-0.0139857121,
0.0262506008,
-0.0344423875,
0.0693682209,
0.0225022677,
0.0025139062,
0.007501509,
0.0508173369,
0.0030080606,
0.0765653998,
-0.0644503757,
-0.0053387494,
0.0470755659,
0.0457132719,
-0.0107585462,
-0.0232431404,
0.0142551726,
-0.0069953534,
-0.0163219739,
0.0268499851,
0.0137256179,
-0.0070597329,
0.0368700437,
-0.1134772822,
-0.0059534432,
0.0198260639,
0.0355598852,
0.0408003926,
0.0218791738,
-0.0276071541,
-0.0010673375,
-0.0199364852,
0.0344988219,
0.0238332804,
-0.0702627078,
-0.0160471518,
0.0537064262,
0.0264260806,
-0.0065006092,
0.0050309072,
-0.0650999174,
-0.0338097326,
-0.0187988728,
-0.0000705677,
0.027871985,
0.0063055367,
0.0248766597,
0.0204368774,
-0.0543162227,
0.0513599254,
-0.0172841474,
0.0312917754,
-0.0412492231,
0.0169113707,
0.0412000343,
0.0101956697,
0.0244117305,
0.0394969545,
0.0018781258,
0.0065993653,
0.0175776295,
0.0059813275,
-0.0219675247,
-0.0138283027,
-0.0037143296,
-0.0516568311,
-0.0149745643,
-0.0652703047,
0.0195283908,
0.0297399163,
0.0542052351,
-0.0018232889,
0.0416911319,
0.0195189789,
0.035260044,
0.0651661456,
-0.0221692119,
-0.0036730804,
0.0336300917,
0.0035164836,
0.05876977,
0.0843206868,
-0.0216697212,
0.0586950332,
0.0266906712,
0.0030681647,
-0.0481925607,
0.0070117731,
-0.0065245535,
-0.0362616666,
0.0011159539,
0.0329465009,
-0.0584340058,
-0.0527823418,
-0.0396625698,
0.0155166723,
0.044017788,
-0.0034798391,
0.025481049,
0.0321553759,
0.0001477167,
-0.0008875378,
0.0231123865,
0.0211044047,
0.0197909288,
-0.0260401275,
0.0195314921,
0.0065511679,
-0.0310690086,
-0.0175479874,
0.0268216245,
0.0548170693,
-0.0042274655,
-0.046262566,
-0.013766055,
0.0158446562,
0.0049683172,
-0.0195207093,
0.0093972525,
-0.0623533726,
-0.048367247,
-0.0200419892,
0.0589364171,
-0.074562557,
-0.0353603549,
-0.0438612811,
0.0335723795,
0.0264992621,
-0.039071206,
-0.0128982803,
-0.0265012961,
-0.0460801274,
0.0115503715,
0.0325088426,
0.0326756872,
-0.0224471781,
-0.0270365532,
-0.0097383084,
-0.0074835769,
0.0211954191,
0.0162110999,
0.0441900007,
0.0244966298,
0.0902811661,
-0.0221734513,
0.046595566,
0.0239527803,
0.0326738358,
0.069260709,
0.0042850096,
0.0393071957,
0.0183401816,
0.0711303428,
0.0401869528,
0.0022602915,
-0.0494991206,
0.013544444,
0.0222558621,
-0.0472462662,
-0.020812992,
-0.0212899186,
-0.0132093141,
0.0274257828,
-0.0146633303,
-0.0345924422,
0.064946577,
-0.021542985,
0.0241861194,
0.053154882,
-0.0025912849,
-0.0274394937,
-0.0689529628,
-0.007703986,
-0.0837715641,
-0.0030564601,
0.0050571812,
0.0715048984,
-0.0158564858,
-0.006965497,
-0.0409259796,
-0.0801649913,
0.0686696097,
0.017111633,
-0.0007704597,
-0.0050176149,
-0.0259032007,
0.036515221,
0.0063890982,
-0.0043286253,
-0.0528335571,
-0.014410275,
-0.0886558816,
0.0031701194,
-0.0440048911,
0.028970506,
0.0001194366,
0.0289126355,
0.0036003552,
0.0338802338,
0.0173106529,
0.0019514782,
0.0009227674,
-0.0050928118,
-0.0122026196,
-0.0175418686,
0.0325976498,
-0.0118311495,
0.0113933478,
-0.031006407,
-0.0026698154,
0.0369555838,
-0.0565602705,
0.0157329701,
-0.0104249781,
-0.0008017336,
-0.0236616433,
0.0015025687,
-0.0291804597,
0.0266266391,
-0.0407249704,
-0.0412274003,
0.0034709016,
0.0506878346,
0.0711719245,
0.0083190231,
0.0445877463,
-0.0498448424,
0.0006492332,
-0.0442549624,
0.0210651457,
-0.0092721079,
0.0249917358,
0.0052944277,
0.054266423,
0.0238015745,
0.0135989478,
-0.0240485203,
0.0318592973,
-0.0382125191,
-0.0379468799,
-0.0068890946,
0.0101413559,
-0.0061841612,
-0.0176927447,
0.0420182981,
-0.0168675743,
0.0498497151,
0.0399189144,
0.0624854825,
-0.05312353,
-0.0437143594,
-0.0257709902,
0.0296649709,
0.0063972981,
-0.022791652,
0.0110367509,
0.0245243199,
0.0492727533,
-0.0379248485,
0.0179183483,
-0.0387924351,
0.0033203063,
-0.0011526552,
0.0446449667,
-0.0164549612,
-0.0386202782,
0.0212631281,
-0.0910782889,
-0.0562453642,
-0.0146339051,
0.0227527376,
-0.0266898368,
0.0377352796,
0.0428400487,
-0.0435895771,
-0.0588478744,
0.0100183738,
-0.0349497534,
0.0500213802,
0.000760576,
-0.022852106,
-0.0354144238,
-0.0283685718,
-0.0189505722,
-0.009910577,
0.0393576249,
-0.0357068405,
0.0175317451,
-0.0766361356,
-0.0333980545,
0.022639947,
-0.0542098433,
0.0026604729,
-0.0334201753,
0.0392037071,
-0.0022333569,
0.0326376744,
0.0814903677,
0.0623177737,
-0.0030231469,
-0.021484267,
-0.0033029059,
-0.0345182978,
0.0023623325,
-0.0014446983,
-0.0349384397,
-0.0202508289,
-0.0088880099,
-0.0090461588,
-0.0519182123,
-0.034358114,
0.0253287628,
-0.0889858678,
0.019677991,
-0.0188310891,
-0.0197728798,
-0.026076911,
-0.0757268295,
0.0007852516,
-0.0444745496,
-0.0337754786,
-0.0254148673,
0.0207803417,
0.0264185481,
0.0476507023,
-0.1107549146,
-0.0487975627,
-0.0136486022,
-0.0297212508,
-0.0013639013,
0.0066379542,
0.0498160459,
-0.0003526252,
0.0168793406,
-0.0087084947,
-0.0198945776,
0.0144153805,
-0.0547215268,
0.0468998104,
-0.0064150449,
-0.0179104395,
-0.0157915056,
0.0166824237,
-0.021038577,
0.0384631492,
-0.0277310107,
0.0348459333,
-0.0331398323,
-0.0178897865,
-0.0517208129,
0.0440859385,
0.0644506663,
0.0071230829,
0.0078594768,
-0.0548004806,
-0.0374704637,
-0.0366123393,
0.017622048,
-0.0632365718,
-0.0060827406,
-0.0152172176,
0.0017392598,
-0.02016172,
0.002366872,
-0.0201465208,
-0.0067920382,
-0.0115087815,
-0.0288175568,
0.0284058116,
0.0319179669,
0.0398126096,
-0.034258958,
-0.005198217,
0.0193145331,
0.050379701,
0.0235771034,
-0.0612648651,
0.0371974483,
0.0638231635,
-0.0094690332,
-0.0283552762,
-0.0506729372,
-0.017403543,
-0.0160880014,
0.0183819979,
0.0168092623,
-0.0257842783,
0.0220388137,
-0.021865828,
0.0053582974,
0.0929138288,
-0.000650082,
-0.0262146797,
0.0134898899,
0.0736761913,
0.0094666425,
0.019630149,
0.0333434902,
0.0016851558,
0.0296635181,
-0.0408648439,
-0.061558947,
0.036849279,
-0.0218760576,
-0.0330386721,
0.0641282126,
0.0140124112,
-0.1197112948,
-0.0233237259,
-0.0237937849,
0.0329461582,
-0.0324995071,
0.0117141167,
-0.0188546535,
0.0307981782,
-0.0067039486,
-0.0636791438,
0.0003216469,
-0.0283212792,
0.0151002714,
-0.0357701331,
0.0829130188,
0.0612538345,
0.0420302562,
0.0085943444,
-0.0161995701,
-0.0179466251,
-0.072840929,
0.0504011065,
-0.0262756441,
0.009109471,
-0.0076637468,
-0.0206393804,
0.0106124328,
0.0364854299,
-0.0029408967,
0.0043558544,
0.0158262886,
-0.0751292631,
0.0247671623,
0.0149820177,
-0.0336900763,
-0.0025549019,
-0.0047161994,
-0.0109059867,
0.0079094898,
0.0012081282,
-0.0302238911,
-0.0220682975,
0.0456996895,
-0.01622013,
-0.0285761766,
0.0338129625,
0.0363842733,
-0.0192464478,
-0.0029215971,
0.0522074439,
-0.0363366343,
-0.033290226,
-0.0120374663,
0.024291655,
0.0290996246,
0.0056935279,
0.0195950586,
-0.0294054709,
-0.0313056931,
0.0606823228,
-0.0259184521,
0.0214155652,
0.0469299853,
-0.0175067373,
0.0617571175,
0.0130557111,
0.0927589536,
-0.0750973076,
-0.0157949273,
-0.0284694247,
-0.0413214602,
-0.0316831134,
-6.595435051e-33,
0.0134802694,
-0.0502386093,
-0.0471687019,
0.0029870586,
0.00768117,
-0.0256654844,
0.0047473484,
0.0523313284,
-0.0117306896,
0.045487076,
-0.0268143415,
0.0330880694,
0.0200581644,
0.0540257692,
0.0373575985,
0.0046045021,
-0.0269485302,
-0.0178082902,
-0.0316301249,
0.0029185163,
0.0499741286,
0.0192166418,
0.0212643296,
-0.0966639891,
0.050196521,
0.0138790319,
-0.0410220213,
-0.0417823344,
-0.008656648,
0.0420867279,
-0.0223955531,
0.0614047684,
0.0610178225,
-0.0666204542,
0.0163720641,
0.0661421344,
0.0030761084,
-0.0332914516,
-0.0036923713,
0.0259171687,
0.0040173931,
0.0066880342,
0.0155911157,
0.0486009344,
-0.0873851627,
0.006615832,
0.0382141955,
0.0045334236,
0.0246460736,
-0.0586444847,
-0.0370394923,
0.0391171575,
-0.0182242729,
-0.0009455851,
-0.0203923844,
0.0281184204,
-0.0015391498,
-0.0000588,
-0.018000707,
0.0091398312,
-0.0317583866,
0.0017057862,
-0.0133888507,
-0.008364439,
-0.0448032655,
0.054208383,
0.0053921165,
-0.0180003382,
-0.0261034444,
-0.0094238408,
-0.0238007288,
-0.0210196041,
0.0451425314,
0.0600595623,
0.0555625409,
-0.076348193,
-0.0822921544,
0.0254399888,
0.0759364516,
0.0214075223,
0.0106632328,
-0.0169580802,
-0.0006991756,
-0.0122762071,
0.0088275457,
-0.0736138448,
-0.0261886921,
-0.0049492787,
-0.0248628464,
-0.0071460325,
-0.029788591,
0.0582417808,
0.0227338318,
-0.0381698087,
-0.0294073448,
0.0220857337,
-0.0017677778,
0.0600266606,
-0.0014179039,
0.0086348765,
-0.0034166442,
-0.0027257751,
-0.0529344678,
0.0305539165,
0.0156365335,
-0.0350733325,
0.011876341,
0.0136769088,
-0.072111398,
-0.0064443327,
-0.0030704918,
0.0082875481,
-0.0475305989,
0.0555545911,
-0.000980804,
-0.0103233336,
0.0215607677,
0.0280711427,
-0.0130938329,
0.0189584065,
0.0156326089,
-0.0360678211,
-0.0347418934,
-0.0321699008,
-0.0212569591,
-0.0437694043,
-0.0022924736,
0.0122185331,
-0.0647926033,
-0.0174609721,
0.0121509032,
-0.000883469,
2.866e-7,
0.0469718538,
0.0588303767,
-0.0439523011,
-0.0567908213,
0.0125991432,
0.0394988433,
0.0116936136,
0.0124955969,
-0.036829412,
-0.041837655,
-0.0025064042,
-0.0228040684,
0.0339240618,
0.0356624722,
-0.1053161696,
-0.0027018951,
-0.009711789,
0.0004714446,
-0.0595196858,
0.0299089178,
-0.0097386856,
0.0736801326,
0.0397595689,
-0.0370924883,
-0.0436982885,
0.0106361881,
0.0067787766,
-0.0212874152,
-0.0197443198,
0.0072935699,
0.0399441123,
-0.0368214063,
0.0025085513,
0.0146814296,
-0.0355524607,
0.0010180153,
0.0034559597,
0.0500538982,
-0.000491425,
0.0329207741,
0.0009396218,
0.0004591298,
0.0432344861,
-0.0039503202,
0.0624449141,
-0.0420262218,
-0.0693258643,
-0.0628270507,
-0.0014956765,
0.002940404,
0.0643754601,
0.0182921831,
-0.0163873043,
0.0146020018,
-0.01318633,
-0.0163193457,
-0.0264439546,
-0.0405910797,
0.0224208534,
-0.0096656987,
-0.0219251215,
-0.0207788739,
0.0576364696,
0.0420099683,
0.0683123916,
0.009924978,
0.0151803158,
2.170188717e-34,
0.0336150713,
-0.0217004083,
0.0162905157,
0.015770182,
0.0339316465,
0.023054501,
0.0247237012,
-0.0041669095,
0.0292919874,
-0.0237208083,
0.0318769068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14192v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14192v3 | $α$-$β$-Factorization and the Binary Case of Simon's Congruence | 2023-06-25T10:16:49 | 2023-09-11T06:47:27 | Pamela Fleischmann, Jonas Höfer, Annika Huch, Dirk Nowotka | math.CO | math.CO, cs.CL | In 1991 H\'ebrard introduced a factorization of words that turned out to be a
powerful tool for the investigation of a word's scattered factors (also known
as (scattered) subwords or subsequences). Based on this, first Karandikar and
Schnoebelen introduced the notion of $k$-richness and later on Barker et al.
the notion of $k$-universality. In 2022 Fleischmann et al. presented a
generalization of the arch factorization by intersecting the arch factorization
of a word and its reverse. While the authors merely used this factorization for
the investigation of shortest absent scattered factors, in this work we
investigate this new $\alpha$-$\beta$-factorization as such. We characterize
the famous Simon congruence of $k$-universal words in terms of $1$-universal
words. Moreover, we apply these results to binary words. In this special case,
we obtain a full characterization of the classes and calculate the index of the
congruence. Lastly, we start investigating the ternary case, present a full
list of possibilities for $\alpha\beta\alpha$-factors, and characterize their
congruence. | [
-0.0106798653,
0.0658224821,
-0.0184164699,
0.0490537882,
-0.0235192496,
-0.012915059,
-0.0175720844,
0.0522673093,
-0.1286765039,
-0.0276858304,
-0.0018770706,
-0.028643081,
0.009108752,
-0.0059623257,
0.0212585311,
-0.0269459765,
0.0446493663,
0.0078626294,
0.0143787144,
0.0230160914,
-0.0204893835,
-0.0178080704,
-0.0215222687,
-0.0023976569,
-0.0057658623,
0.0050503453,
0.0026822661,
-0.0964909345,
-0.0210643839,
-0.0151840132,
-0.0394298285,
0.0605446547,
-0.042103041,
0.0384537652,
0.000001558,
-0.0231208745,
-0.0113084055,
-0.017363552,
-0.0623449199,
0.0470426381,
0.0422051214,
0.0370573588,
-0.0188896656,
0.0080599608,
-0.0216629095,
-0.0307400506,
0.0253156926,
0.0558200963,
-0.0265293885,
-0.0335064866,
0.0056591826,
0.0035418849,
0.0227101855,
0.015755048,
0.0539028905,
-0.0351074487,
0.0220807418,
-0.064030312,
0.0199949965,
0.0338475965,
-0.0159286521,
-0.027076764,
-0.0309743155,
0.0132298199,
-0.0000952692,
-0.0424213409,
-0.0750522986,
-0.0077535119,
0.0141716851,
0.0205200408,
0.0479574986,
0.0154995238,
-0.0271892715,
0.0466659889,
-0.0171837173,
-0.0021494587,
-0.0170825496,
0.0289883837,
0.0017027428,
0.0001408281,
0.0691324174,
0.0516094342,
-0.0112781627,
-0.018745115,
-0.0567665175,
0.1162703112,
0.0854540914,
-0.0103322621,
-0.0486117452,
-0.0561567284,
-0.027294904,
-0.0310218465,
-0.0009922821,
0.054787837,
0.0061670169,
0.0027628411,
-0.0074362308,
0.0165083297,
0.0193360224,
0.0198977794,
-0.0171842221,
-0.0176298488,
0.0184148308,
-0.0123276105,
0.0419145338,
0.004705233,
0.0266822204,
0.0141793266,
-0.0042682732,
0.0437498502,
0.0178078413,
-0.0126928212,
-0.0598065034,
0.0300735924,
0.0342744142,
-0.0284738541,
-0.0253362022,
0.0122829061,
0.0617403463,
-0.0154513782,
-0.0318188667,
-0.0207904894,
0.0073695122,
0.0351056755,
0.0216856673,
-0.0059856791,
-0.0441436134,
0.0220991746,
-0.0443262309,
-0.0628074408,
0.020683717,
-0.0476570129,
0.0337783098,
-0.0196950417,
-0.0233291928,
0.0582549758,
0.0125099318,
-0.0371559337,
0.0463161916,
0.0185551103,
0.0182678066,
-0.0110503854,
-0.0100965947,
-0.0286260433,
-0.0035520471,
0.0405852422,
0.0106191831,
0.0261178687,
0.0347516239,
-0.0263277013,
0.0383909866,
-0.0060535599,
-0.0336483158,
-0.0017284501,
-0.0559958294,
0.0238250028,
0.0269931667,
-0.0302256402,
0.0057762093,
-0.0258452129,
0.0451161787,
-0.071130015,
-0.0012771656,
0.000783276,
-0.0174206179,
-0.0247644875,
0.0071856878,
-0.0671386272,
0.029817054,
-0.0371622108,
-0.0522573516,
0.0490901321,
-0.0107483482,
-0.0105410889,
0.0019314663,
0.0023265954,
0.0284522194,
0.0985833183,
-0.0556459427,
-0.0082423687,
0.0171205215,
0.040490292,
0.0180283617,
-0.0293979645,
0.0092077227,
-0.0290012453,
0.0461810715,
0.0132723022,
-0.0142779592,
-0.0173781216,
-0.0221403446,
0.0170885362,
0.0461049266,
-0.0597289205,
0.0472953171,
-0.0048927302,
-0.0414878167,
0.0413965434,
0.0152717847,
-0.062772043,
0.0212946609,
-0.0287144184,
0.0560709722,
0.0206306465,
0.0280231573,
-0.0280206185,
0.0357490256,
0.0548837632,
-0.0161237698,
-0.003173057,
-0.0479105785,
-0.0180529952,
0.0097327661,
-0.0057383683,
0.0063627497,
0.0031091778,
0.0491123758,
-0.0187692437,
-0.0278802998,
0.0494741127,
0.0015954692,
-0.0418347307,
0.023432713,
0.0294499882,
0.0511142649,
-0.0591438636,
-0.0473577529,
0.0359931923,
-0.0008603702,
0.0184573606,
0.0202908963,
0.071865201,
0.0666070804,
-0.0286741238,
-0.0201014075,
-0.027974546,
0.0294166803,
-0.026651863,
0.0302692242,
-0.0599567369,
0.0267502554,
0.0169210862,
0.0106789358,
-0.0266685635,
0.0271870345,
-0.0378652401,
0.0677122399,
0.0184759852,
0.0714939684,
-0.0001802129,
0.0022976112,
0.0111851385,
0.0378635973,
0.0114594474,
0.1077745259,
-0.0645412654,
-0.0933618322,
0.0676585957,
0.0359602422,
0.0188983288,
0.0243494548,
-0.0621821843,
0.0022135694,
-0.0006830939,
0.0010381931,
-0.0172351897,
-0.0425595678,
0.0213325135,
-0.0436158143,
-0.0173444469,
0.0341018215,
-0.0309588537,
0.024417473,
0.0270754285,
-0.0095267799,
-0.0126878303,
0.0006485777,
0.0766611099,
0.0292822197,
0.0480057448,
0.0182621703,
-0.0511006266,
-0.0026719205,
-0.0076518618,
0.017323263,
-0.0062561799,
-0.0472698547,
0.0163015127,
-0.0399743766,
0.0361559838,
-0.0520952716,
0.0360500216,
-0.0250106547,
-0.0356436335,
0.0297196768,
-0.0198554676,
-0.0002059601,
-0.0264893379,
0.0322338827,
-0.0156169822,
-0.0588473678,
-0.0185885467,
0.0919989347,
-0.0513535626,
-0.00639239,
0.033414606,
-0.0260661356,
-0.0234898329,
0.0313443393,
0.0691828206,
-0.0300083403,
-0.0569436662,
-0.0271971505,
-0.0105058011,
-0.0045451042,
0.0373065881,
0.0087426323,
-0.0411958322,
-0.0114950426,
-0.0069704764,
-0.0119219571,
-0.0469457358,
-0.0317304172,
-0.0476000682,
0.0027908213,
-0.0144847948,
-0.0257305838,
-0.0529772677,
0.0203188173,
0.0123994956,
0.0204083733,
-0.0643332899,
-0.0628392845,
0.0035567947,
0.0010448301,
-0.0024492515,
-0.0157946218,
0.0585265234,
0.0085746963,
-0.0578309596,
-0.0018268549,
-0.0316773541,
0.0141599169,
-0.0352524035,
0.013931457,
0.0092027616,
0.0666292906,
-0.0121747078,
-0.028072238,
0.0570624135,
-0.0054541905,
-0.0400946401,
0.0369384103,
0.0349427126,
0.003661355,
0.0162493605,
0.0077458927,
0.0015094484,
0.0234450493,
0.0515603684,
0.0337368771,
0.0246566832,
0.0968370289,
0.0447732359,
0.0804416835,
0.0209479164,
0.0460502803,
-0.0612977557,
-0.0180942863,
0.02289325,
0.0217623468,
0.0003293448,
0.0007665753,
0.0422147326,
0.0326192901,
-0.0016043165,
0.0817876458,
-0.0291157719,
-0.0249986611,
-0.0055075893,
-0.087372154,
-0.000234035,
0.0292475093,
0.0038554803,
-0.1090227365,
-0.0011575235,
0.0252133794,
0.040069215,
-0.0798519328,
-0.0170213338,
0.0361673608,
-0.0572452508,
-0.0468868054,
0.028878767,
-0.0107089784,
0.025707718,
-0.006793505,
0.0779972076,
-0.0442869291,
0.0372615121,
0.060703475,
0.0525475815,
-0.0323597081,
-0.0128703481,
-0.0201662071,
0.0145393955,
-0.0543614738,
0.0468906984,
-0.0212128367,
-0.1247499511,
0.0000874654,
-0.0244648755,
-0.0144303143,
0.0202877633,
-0.0265447162,
0.0026492204,
-0.011568292,
-0.0258167982,
0.0068765185,
-0.029678056,
-0.0363466032,
0.0141655775,
0.0491778292,
0.023253696,
0.0163301155,
0.0056164265,
0.0127678616,
-0.0070221508,
-0.0054081534,
0.0011727825,
0.0150306048,
0.0411476642,
0.0125253554,
0.0552425794,
0.0320088565,
-0.0394163132,
0.0378785692,
-0.0268235859,
-0.0139918625,
-0.0360436291,
-0.0247431397,
0.0291852653,
0.1022176519,
-0.0190107524,
0.0501242429,
-0.0720137432,
-0.0314790234,
-0.0191338155,
-0.0645884052,
-0.0315818973,
0.0291620176,
-0.0172348805,
0.0288284402,
-0.0557127073,
-0.0082669202,
-0.0097573968,
-0.0359240063,
-0.0227375757,
0.0107586989,
0.0497300625,
0.0410767272,
0.0355196856,
-0.0611556992,
-0.0005966984,
0.0034784582,
-0.0140132885,
-0.0210954845,
-0.0354785882,
0.0034688597,
0.0122778052,
-0.0467762351,
-0.0093454374,
0.0146094467,
-0.0159002133,
-0.0198962595,
-0.0348938778,
0.0329158567,
0.0054471069,
0.0318836123,
0.0496522635,
-0.0074515659,
-0.0067189997,
0.0265204646,
0.0512840264,
0.0336096808,
0.0081017856,
-0.0278104674,
0.0068328418,
-0.0096336156,
0.0382165574,
0.0216180645,
0.015327963,
-0.0385583304,
-0.0635973737,
-0.0288808029,
0.0300332475,
0.0530960411,
0.0726310462,
0.0463404655,
0.0570369139,
0.0102214469,
0.015550063,
0.0154725807,
0.0340163484,
-0.0395797305,
-0.0091742054,
-0.0219627284,
-0.0347080231,
-0.0229739603,
0.0370098874,
-0.0624266081,
0.0296290144,
-0.025600357,
-0.0350644365,
-0.0163339619,
0.0124907997,
-0.027853718,
0.0129701551,
-0.0223598145,
0.0039542736,
-0.0097797122,
0.0000065679,
-0.0256471615,
-0.02404912,
-0.0064626881,
-0.0405825302,
0.0128416214,
-0.0150068542,
-0.0012928118,
0.0395712033,
0.0150984256,
0.0016971912,
0.0394784585,
-0.0641380847,
-0.0278831832,
0.011561919,
0.0159622058,
0.045226723,
0.0195905752,
-0.0019757575,
-0.0568179116,
-0.0416687429,
0.004676267,
-0.0102075525,
0.0266780201,
-0.0257045254,
0.0013581509,
0.0445766449,
0.0099357851,
-0.0020942327,
-0.0128480336,
-0.0066577131,
-0.0215931889,
0.0021722068,
-0.0011936992,
-5.232818897e-33,
-0.0196114592,
-0.0197198056,
-0.000778127,
-0.0056503364,
-0.0446517915,
-0.0150889112,
0.0125967581,
0.044572819,
0.0036967776,
-0.022628475,
0.0039418256,
0.0245463718,
0.0105920369,
0.0078597162,
-0.0027167646,
0.005069627,
-0.0068102907,
0.0224646386,
-0.0299878363,
-0.0026501822,
-0.0203337725,
-0.0204822775,
0.0597948395,
0.0425577424,
0.0202116296,
-0.0654822588,
0.007555678,
-0.0099762399,
-0.0376310311,
0.02542077,
-0.023810409,
0.0108186733,
0.0413257927,
-0.0010834433,
0.0191530958,
0.0110326074,
-0.0310253091,
-0.0795703083,
0.0631589815,
-0.0207780525,
0.0133693283,
-0.0191959366,
-0.0419104919,
-0.0547288135,
-0.0371713154,
0.0727440789,
-0.0062288926,
0.0264836829,
-0.0781805217,
-0.0064327917,
-0.0338210166,
0.0190745685,
0.0064116698,
0.0239800811,
-0.0219641868,
-0.0318435431,
0.0029211151,
-0.0556557216,
0.005197451,
0.0714009926,
0.087503247,
0.0638558492,
-0.0660806298,
-0.0285580941,
-0.0359792076,
0.0057873013,
0.0584354438,
-0.0245572925,
0.0151073318,
0.0060207718,
0.0148674976,
0.114484787,
0.0517650284,
0.0077842944,
0.1077369675,
-0.0142602157,
0.0493233465,
-0.0161987245,
0.0024725543,
-0.0199710485,
-0.0010847136,
0.0047894595,
-0.0295549314,
-0.0143662319,
-0.0240541734,
-0.0432592258,
-0.019065341,
-0.0139398817,
0.0176428035,
0.0143513503,
-0.0176016707,
-0.0338753797,
-0.0036323473,
-0.0327548645,
-0.0776325017,
0.0285637043,
0.0033330945,
0.0101227826,
-0.0337528996,
-0.0222849827,
0.0137991384,
-0.0288428757,
0.0098786671,
-0.0426630527,
-0.017183844,
-0.0382470004,
-0.0517516807,
0.0085084839,
-0.0454248749,
-0.0100321677,
0.0092757391,
-0.0331215113,
0.0200093314,
-0.0146727785,
0.052827321,
-0.0287538748,
0.0143488096,
-0.0760587007,
-0.0021096403,
0.0241244882,
0.0295300242,
0.0457256697,
0.0008476595,
0.0065106722,
0.0113318153,
-0.0461904369,
-0.0610514022,
0.0104666334,
0.0582959205,
-0.0133119328,
0.0034943235,
-0.01988112,
2.395e-7,
0.0568022393,
-0.0039969189,
0.0844145864,
-0.0497834682,
0.0637729019,
-0.043087054,
-0.0076051774,
0.0333812386,
-0.0495686159,
0.0209150519,
0.030319199,
-0.017426027,
-0.028012529,
0.0200161003,
0.0523158349,
0.0112483362,
-0.0011762355,
-0.0530515313,
-0.0392926447,
0.0158555992,
0.0083809821,
0.0623758808,
-0.0238884967,
0.0041409624,
-0.0155796623,
-0.0457807668,
-0.0365204699,
-0.0179637205,
-0.0271152873,
-0.0176431481,
-0.0612223707,
-0.037192829,
0.0015657662,
-0.0202880651,
0.0070596109,
0.0508186594,
0.0833507702,
-0.012401307,
-0.0070179123,
0.0389394239,
-0.0075936695,
-0.0551584512,
0.0214356016,
0.0785991624,
0.0239343029,
0.0578522794,
-0.059691608,
0.031157434,
-0.0122712934,
0.0364843681,
-0.0066073323,
0.0205172896,
-0.0014792279,
0.0051827761,
0.0468145125,
0.0140027786,
-0.0288401898,
-0.0476557687,
0.0114582647,
-0.024028834,
-0.0356890149,
-0.0304076914,
-0.0195287932,
0.010424966,
0.0183365848,
-0.0059547597,
-0.0236445963,
2.464205568e-34,
0.0594482832,
-0.0410151407,
-0.003685646,
0.0279381294,
0.0323916152,
-0.027296491,
-0.0445163175,
0.0124987904,
0.0377606153,
-0.0641588047,
0.0035726388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14176v1 | Sentence-level Event Detection without Triggers via Prompt Learning and Machine Reading Comprehension | 2023-06-25T09:03:56 | 2023-06-25T09:03:56 | Tongtao Ling, Lei Chen, Huangxu Sheng, Zicheng Cai, Hai-Lin Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The traditional way of sentence-level event detection involves two important
subtasks: trigger identification and trigger classifications, where the
identified event trigger words are used to classify event types from sentences.
However, trigger classification highly depends on abundant annotated trigger
words and the accuracy of trigger identification. In a real scenario,
annotating trigger words is time-consuming and laborious. For this reason, we
propose a trigger-free event detection model, which transforms event detection
into a two-tower model based on machine reading comprehension and prompt
learning. Compared to existing trigger-based and trigger-free methods,
experimental studies on two event detection benchmark datasets (ACE2005 and
MAVEN) have shown that the proposed approach can achieve competitive
performance. | [
0.0218044575,
0.0008331878,
-0.0123629374,
0.0671593845,
-0.0428423285,
0.0393098965,
0.0085578617,
-0.0152073037,
0.0584036484,
-0.0581014864,
0.039103657,
0.0297711324,
-0.0307082143,
0.076465182,
-0.0422620773,
-0.0154391043,
0.103257075,
0.0187519826,
-0.0041806684,
0.0455506369,
0.0322895721,
0.0159277525,
-0.0516525842,
0.0305698831,
0.0100065917,
-0.0059931846,
-0.0487135239,
0.0052858638,
0.0353435129,
-0.0420709178,
-0.0246512815,
0.02235936,
0.0045618303,
0.0479138158,
0.0000015976,
-0.0418112725,
-0.0187883452,
-0.0353535861,
-0.0311102588,
-0.002797212,
-0.0076642889,
-0.052081503,
0.0240537152,
0.010252784,
-0.0070404583,
0.0021718072,
0.0134311076,
0.0448317118,
0.0220769346,
0.0494411364,
-0.0178992357,
-0.0213590059,
0.0280707218,
0.0059824507,
0.0082315654,
-0.0981905609,
0.0286632925,
-0.041798126,
0.0027493592,
0.0078562982,
-0.0279122572,
0.0199670829,
-0.0165958293,
0.0086974595,
0.0127641466,
0.0368776657,
-0.0217876453,
0.0064685103,
-0.0487603731,
0.0540970564,
-0.0128675113,
-0.019585222,
0.0465797335,
-0.0417774729,
-0.0055285506,
-0.0052911686,
0.0073182192,
-0.0325702131,
-0.0329864845,
0.0224874318,
0.0152752865,
0.0087174969,
0.007860898,
0.0254548676,
0.0327610187,
0.0504638776,
-0.005909529,
-0.0194718335,
-0.0555733964,
0.0197174642,
-0.0030297099,
-0.0263522565,
0.0499187894,
0.0579331107,
-0.0586771928,
0.017176738,
-0.0394482575,
-0.0204070173,
0.019021878,
-0.0615011305,
-0.0201652627,
0.0567646101,
-0.0184985064,
0.0724676624,
-0.0186038762,
0.0302782059,
0.0054543768,
0.0183521453,
-0.0368525721,
0.0266589597,
-0.0099022044,
0.0334496237,
-0.0557803027,
0.0034705608,
-0.0749477446,
-0.0494828671,
-0.0136555294,
0.0055953348,
0.0587763563,
-0.0167760942,
-0.0727526918,
-0.0225766972,
-0.0699810386,
-0.0022681355,
0.0138217751,
-0.0190938115,
-0.0430188477,
0.0461870916,
-0.0026831743,
-0.0818361118,
-0.0162709355,
0.0118143391,
0.0245144628,
0.0052800192,
-0.0281665996,
-0.0193957277,
-0.0405626111,
-0.0548566841,
-0.0885913596,
-0.0333625674,
0.0097235367,
0.0108943386,
-0.0800902843,
-0.029359892,
0.0362283699,
-0.0164175369,
0.0010004157,
0.0413945317,
0.0129834171,
0.00943367,
-0.0006081615,
0.0971651971,
-0.02412894,
-0.0032771998,
0.0043600095,
-0.000109163,
0.0072656604,
0.0693025589,
0.0424022898,
0.0443144143,
0.0558017567,
0.0590217486,
0.0148949223,
0.0095043732,
-0.0031722072,
-0.0071839392,
0.0407382771,
0.0099239713,
-0.0293075386,
0.0077597518,
0.0320867598,
-0.0164100938,
0.0054856264,
-0.0158416927,
0.0254999064,
-0.0014256669,
-0.0373362564,
-0.0287109613,
0.0445315316,
0.0250670984,
-0.0403689146,
0.0234113913,
0.0089428984,
-0.0440829508,
-0.0274418853,
-0.0191550124,
-0.0076191709,
-0.0564766489,
-0.0270511247,
-0.0128939124,
0.0048353621,
-0.0131032169,
-0.0444131419,
0.0148933614,
0.0365813114,
-0.0030181175,
-0.0379558131,
0.0157371573,
-0.0216044448,
-0.0131128933,
0.0214105342,
-0.0076116747,
0.0226488132,
0.0381906405,
0.0135050099,
-0.0568295717,
-0.0198735371,
-0.0174640398,
0.029475864,
0.0621178895,
0.0227563418,
-0.0174501911,
0.0477005839,
-0.0434612706,
0.0093938522,
0.0441219434,
0.0144849606,
0.0027909684,
-0.018509021,
0.0021146184,
-0.0055247196,
0.0326926447,
-0.0341223963,
0.074051559,
-0.0066996398,
-0.0754263401,
-0.0304612461,
0.0101158451,
0.0429326445,
-0.0122666014,
0.0044468911,
-0.0098543782,
0.0164804459,
-0.0490326807,
-0.038427487,
0.0354230627,
-0.0158866327,
-0.0666682273,
0.0069588688,
0.0268098675,
-0.0356627554,
0.0307029895,
-0.0569812283,
-0.0576236174,
-0.0700055063,
-0.0106433108,
-0.0439205691,
-0.0487027839,
0.0041733705,
-0.0041037039,
-0.0094749704,
-0.06167062,
0.0289114583,
-0.0267821196,
0.0218200274,
-0.0106550911,
0.0348103195,
0.0490943938,
-0.0251816474,
-0.0597188771,
0.0041453801,
0.0092086364,
-0.011211385,
0.0264011957,
-0.0477117263,
-0.0729191676,
0.059161406,
-0.0735493302,
0.0466782078,
-0.0152892265,
0.0444017984,
0.0357463658,
0.0137110781,
-0.0294006262,
-0.0435396507,
0.013264914,
-0.0348451622,
-0.0000404124,
0.0326049775,
0.0569692142,
0.026650805,
-0.0204603635,
-0.0509537198,
-0.0056914417,
-0.0667330697,
0.0360799469,
0.0385016985,
-0.0611406192,
-0.050695803,
0.012424726,
0.0390902758,
0.0310995523,
-0.0034124767,
-0.0213788208,
-0.0154363615,
-0.0053584841,
0.0057365145,
0.0651440695,
-0.0028734526,
0.019123802,
0.0069454596,
-0.018036142,
-0.0201872941,
0.0483249538,
-0.0329945721,
-0.0108383792,
-0.0124465544,
-0.0038673894,
0.0205809679,
0.0494499505,
0.0343870632,
0.0007152003,
-0.0342404544,
-0.0683206692,
-0.0122431666,
0.0061171441,
-0.091728285,
-0.0398063064,
-0.0684716254,
0.06307064,
-0.0486387573,
-0.0215738267,
0.072570242,
0.0088793961,
-0.0023668564,
-0.073055461,
0.0160953756,
-0.0385633409,
0.0475653782,
0.0019266745,
0.0137172416,
-0.0229020305,
-0.0683743134,
-0.015120957,
-0.0155039551,
0.0210291184,
-0.0229026526,
0.0246267375,
-0.0148739107,
0.0235733688,
-0.03620084,
0.0004422607,
-0.0671989769,
-0.0449902266,
-0.0444133319,
-0.0173820574,
-0.0083331168,
0.0354552008,
-0.0267819595,
0.0125351073,
-0.0287961923,
0.0660009086,
-0.0080325315,
-0.0189477392,
-0.0442144498,
0.1000059247,
0.0202872548,
-0.0206056014,
-0.0117824981,
-0.0139804576,
0.0457157195,
0.0556146502,
0.0205181483,
0.0082487464,
-0.019542506,
-0.0000949946,
0.0399543755,
-0.0710953623,
0.0180064272,
0.0033171782,
0.0145833055,
-0.0559664369,
0.0203448031,
0.0688067898,
0.0440510027,
-0.0052446644,
-0.009114081,
0.0219768193,
0.0055661881,
0.0119457133,
-0.006128063,
-0.0761019811,
-0.0543126501,
0.0021392622,
0.0087089092,
-0.021239901,
-0.0302527808,
0.0006193449,
-0.0629723221,
-0.0183294583,
-0.0086244969,
-0.0236634798,
-0.05047502,
-0.0266119372,
0.0313522294,
0.0028831845,
-0.0388072468,
0.053622622,
0.0214597657,
-0.0093377,
-0.0149273211,
-0.0685290918,
-0.0322611853,
0.0116363531,
-0.0350673981,
-0.0075050509,
0.0425742343,
0.02821959,
0.0168852936,
0.0038103389,
0.0583657064,
-0.0559010617,
0.0133824227,
0.0080242883,
0.0312937573,
-0.0093560014,
0.0015746716,
-0.0218633655,
0.038986396,
-0.0195294749,
-0.0255600698,
0.0133351479,
0.0576136522,
-0.0096235722,
0.0113643939,
-0.0415098891,
-0.0082213292,
0.0517004207,
0.0516704619,
0.0127562499,
-0.0043439758,
-0.0580809638,
0.0153762018,
0.0044313618,
-0.061307244,
-0.0028309294,
0.0132047441,
-0.0041047772,
-0.0465893,
-0.0475284643,
-0.0807746649,
0.0029885427,
0.0124562941,
-0.0326618589,
0.0498197004,
-0.0023805893,
0.0231771711,
-0.0427601635,
0.0366595276,
-0.0283477083,
0.0488780327,
-0.0159081612,
0.0360877067,
0.0242330916,
0.0371866375,
-0.0369350128,
0.0801013857,
-0.0630472451,
-0.0236714799,
-0.0163125526,
-0.0495024957,
0.0158676039,
0.0287511591,
-0.0425614789,
-0.0192471743,
-0.0115701566,
0.0448231176,
-0.0415645987,
-0.0051584118,
-0.0065126875,
-0.0042127385,
-0.0346381441,
0.024879491,
-0.0125946524,
0.0237668827,
-0.0199180096,
0.0613828041,
-0.0672493726,
-0.0403961949,
0.0176493488,
0.0124694444,
0.1097759828,
-0.0221915841,
-0.0386832468,
-0.0351982117,
0.0052614487,
0.0163036641,
0.0064699356,
-0.0269724932,
0.0237019286,
-0.0036157614,
-0.0218164641,
-0.0371705368,
0.01236575,
-0.02730163,
-0.0115015171,
-0.0158820022,
0.0045323265,
0.0418137647,
0.0415325053,
0.0209370386,
0.0005383705,
-0.0541192442,
0.0332176276,
0.0111297974,
-0.0118823927,
0.0278329849,
0.0583597608,
0.0514418706,
0.0148348287,
-0.0163679253,
-0.0209389552,
-0.0411420986,
0.0631705374,
0.0199242067,
0.0057597226,
0.0790502429,
-0.0222238488,
0.0051661655,
-0.0055916253,
-0.0108590201,
-0.0293550044,
0.0624917559,
0.0220144503,
-0.0293992814,
0.0294740833,
0.0194444265,
-0.0143864779,
0.022402795,
0.0682171211,
-0.0252887849,
0.0350756794,
0.0317702219,
-0.0092424313,
-0.0235135388,
0.0199710596,
0.0001122258,
0.0602818839,
-0.0291199479,
0.0329220071,
-0.0701278746,
0.0045316922,
0.067394793,
0.008589738,
0.0171444509,
-0.0212456677,
0.0353013352,
0.0258762483,
0.0235646702,
-0.0220595691,
-0.0508707836,
0.0340640396,
-0.0248110704,
-0.0054320185,
-0.0324971676,
-4.996970282e-33,
-0.0318312496,
-0.0279389806,
-0.0062528695,
0.0940417275,
-0.0011623042,
0.0330987424,
-0.0151296817,
0.0154365525,
-0.0094820438,
0.0153654683,
0.0025483915,
0.046461314,
0.0265863854,
-0.04037356,
0.0139429728,
-0.0358227529,
0.0825191587,
-0.0059914789,
-0.0164515693,
0.0162281319,
0.0551639013,
0.0636087731,
0.0112394579,
-0.0619528592,
0.0135436608,
-0.0435799807,
-0.0144160045,
0.0119976345,
0.0285768211,
0.0209083706,
-0.0207966324,
0.0473868363,
0.0528205559,
-0.0323611461,
-0.0100827748,
0.0711882412,
-0.0707236454,
-0.005497627,
0.0131367352,
0.0410266928,
-0.0218074284,
-0.0378393643,
-0.0000953214,
0.005130419,
0.0273023546,
-0.006076213,
0.0362202451,
-0.0384092852,
-0.0312540531,
-0.0633938536,
-0.0511687659,
0.0562313274,
0.0062931487,
-0.0242787562,
0.0199155156,
0.0297430325,
0.0269717611,
0.0504377671,
-0.0445503667,
-0.0141814854,
-0.0105314059,
0.0314884335,
-0.0119347796,
0.0233933832,
-0.0472972803,
0.065304406,
0.0056105787,
-0.0163551867,
-0.0244171154,
0.0682783797,
0.0127259912,
0.0189278852,
0.047433842,
0.0683501586,
0.0662672594,
0.0151379881,
-0.0968071967,
0.035365589,
0.0539720915,
0.0135228485,
0.0019997582,
-0.0055650081,
-0.0497759245,
0.0049952073,
-0.0252204388,
0.0228132531,
-0.0504966229,
0.04072861,
0.0422128029,
0.0456409641,
0.0272505824,
0.0512030795,
0.0491305962,
-0.0057436018,
0.0057407594,
0.0398051701,
0.0023759368,
0.0018095816,
-0.0102816448,
0.0357754342,
-0.0304387324,
-0.0070202458,
-0.0196221583,
-0.0007340966,
0.0275736935,
-0.024129115,
0.0155966915,
0.010088684,
-0.0371671021,
-0.0000555166,
0.011341257,
-0.0201496016,
-0.0416016355,
-0.0113015883,
0.0247344505,
-0.022216225,
-0.0039513297,
0.0742522851,
-0.0108047593,
0.0204640683,
0.0198061895,
-0.0156870428,
-0.0363409184,
0.0450877883,
-0.0022164853,
-0.0241251979,
-0.0331747718,
0.0548279099,
-0.0099901268,
-0.0392720886,
0.0162809808,
0.039180927,
2.166e-7,
0.0167395137,
-0.0005623986,
0.0553244129,
0.03063499,
-0.0049998597,
0.0347540788,
0.0005507448,
0.0525425635,
0.0052504805,
0.0212730411,
0.0110058133,
-0.0268973187,
0.0465971455,
0.0146017587,
-0.0926170126,
-0.041034773,
-0.0451093204,
0.0553311594,
-0.0812601,
-0.0100965779,
0.1135119647,
0.0425001122,
-0.0054884371,
0.0226876512,
0.0279721953,
-0.0585959069,
0.0372808762,
0.0276743751,
-0.0076562972,
0.0477384254,
0.0578312129,
0.030618526,
-0.0257364009,
0.0693209544,
-0.0249982346,
0.005851605,
-0.0019346273,
0.058882162,
0.0003665803,
0.0152569599,
0.0079813553,
-0.01416915,
-0.0189038143,
-0.0302734151,
0.0848673806,
-0.0453589372,
0.0051174294,
0.0070033767,
-0.0607057028,
0.0137760555,
-0.0429234058,
0.038867075,
-0.0473574176,
0.007380981,
0.011688197,
-0.0274269767,
0.0044306284,
-0.089161098,
-0.0343217179,
0.0060064816,
-0.0376734585,
-0.0115458397,
-0.0301127527,
-0.0180724952,
0.0004859637,
-0.0553232618,
-0.0252046231,
1.570994706e-34,
0.0056629539,
-0.0037879595,
-0.0274715964,
0.0337239429,
-0.0241713375,
-0.0311294142,
-0.0206995979,
0.0072609396,
0.0326476544,
-0.0368289016,
-0.0011017547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14152v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14152v1 | Low-Rank Prune-And-Factorize for Language Model Compression | 2023-06-25T07:38:43 | 2023-06-25T07:38:43 | Siyu Ren, Kenny Q. Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The components underpinning PLMs -- large weight matrices -- were shown to
bear considerable redundancy. Matrix factorization, a well-established
technique from matrix theory, has been utilized to reduce the number of
parameters in PLM. However, it fails to retain satisfactory performance under
moderate to high compression rate. In this paper, we identify the
\textit{full-rankness} of fine-tuned PLM as the fundamental bottleneck for the
failure of matrix factorization and explore the use of network pruning to
extract low-rank sparsity pattern desirable to matrix factorization. We find
such low-rank sparsity pattern exclusively exists in models generated by
first-order pruning, which motivates us to unite the two approaches and achieve
more effective model compression. We further propose two techniques:
sparsity-aware SVD and mixed-rank fine-tuning, which improve the initialization
and training of the compression procedure, respectively. Experiments on GLUE
and question-answering tasks show that the proposed method has superior
compression-performance trade-off compared to existing approaches. | [
-0.0070439088,
0.0398946218,
-0.0211176481,
0.0699828714,
0.0120374374,
0.0013140172,
-0.0350130647,
0.0610683896,
-0.0475582071,
-0.0005137745,
-0.0013207725,
0.0014204013,
0.0352681838,
-0.0002478264,
0.0457968377,
-0.0154243326,
0.0512422323,
-0.0146861728,
-0.0064190994,
0.0040704701,
0.0141027356,
-0.0017964286,
0.0358659476,
0.0275199376,
0.0240785833,
-0.0099215209,
-0.0127105499,
-0.0096058035,
-0.0158035066,
0.0480634719,
-0.032143563,
0.0644321963,
0.0542526729,
-0.0211309195,
0.0000019412,
0.0053541777,
0.0069278711,
-0.0118850786,
-0.0282204077,
0.0706746355,
0.0165714305,
-0.0036155418,
0.0332410038,
-0.0010909046,
-0.0241773482,
-0.0344941504,
0.0206315946,
0.0378249995,
0.0478474833,
0.0466312841,
0.0005612793,
-0.004032935,
0.0049108826,
-0.0062415395,
-0.0422114469,
-0.043458201,
0.0201107133,
-0.0193284024,
-0.0063382871,
0.0068358434,
-0.0288676936,
0.0267844219,
0.0074278354,
0.0262366626,
0.0116940355,
0.0397840403,
-0.0215546954,
-0.0151771437,
0.0290804058,
0.0744380951,
-0.0386614501,
-0.0318733566,
0.0159055497,
0.0188059583,
0.0196272787,
-0.0214554593,
-0.0654445067,
0.0233742576,
0.0333197415,
0.0355257802,
-0.0026501683,
-0.0184419248,
0.0220501199,
0.0092090489,
-0.0055630668,
0.0463258214,
0.034894757,
-0.0122903623,
-0.0268949643,
-0.0196331032,
0.0103093619,
-0.0148062259,
0.0061966386,
0.0283668507,
-0.0122114206,
0.0032437365,
-0.0595085211,
-0.0435979739,
0.0170168951,
-0.0192164965,
0.0391582809,
0.0293838941,
0.0393188484,
0.0193245728,
-0.0259879231,
0.0407450721,
0.0105087692,
0.0323111787,
-0.0550095774,
-0.011903882,
-0.008982541,
-0.0061539849,
-0.0303140618,
0.095728144,
-0.0132056447,
-0.0303830933,
-0.0292810164,
0.016790105,
0.0341947712,
-0.0220437534,
-0.0068163043,
0.0233683735,
-0.0136288768,
-0.0055202381,
0.0018217321,
0.060170427,
-0.0178726148,
0.0222182963,
-0.0612220578,
-0.0163700338,
-0.0491077863,
0.026106162,
0.0070081973,
-0.0021367406,
0.0130535513,
0.0110684922,
-0.0541609004,
-0.0481066145,
-0.014374828,
-0.0047637513,
0.0293388329,
-0.0338097475,
-0.019483922,
-0.0589217357,
0.0690036565,
0.0032561745,
0.0029805151,
-0.0563001297,
-0.00711388,
0.0335938111,
-0.0730075687,
0.0429425649,
0.0074638622,
0.024366077,
-0.010116118,
0.0224416386,
0.0374076739,
0.0224924162,
0.0154523086,
0.0289875437,
0.0185742937,
-0.0713980496,
-0.0233126488,
0.0465271808,
0.0478352606,
0.004437394,
-0.0306157395,
-0.0008471824,
0.0004516556,
-0.0376846306,
0.0446583293,
0.0873977169,
-0.0487326905,
-0.0116083184,
0.0558611341,
0.0792250559,
0.0301435757,
0.0974201635,
0.0281109326,
0.0026665139,
0.0120727727,
0.039334245,
-0.0121795433,
0.006159734,
-0.0712157488,
0.0071634105,
0.0225855913,
0.0438880362,
-0.0536246747,
-0.027351886,
-0.0077646677,
-0.0229345895,
0.0375993215,
0.0149993347,
0.0398080647,
-0.0067151263,
-0.043543864,
0.0801701397,
0.0052906345,
-0.0773786306,
0.0023804032,
-0.0246813316,
-0.0004739331,
0.0062729935,
0.0195524916,
0.0050770226,
0.011541808,
0.009629555,
0.0119607849,
-0.0244175568,
0.0249300431,
-0.0217248891,
-0.0066581671,
-0.0608033501,
0.022882117,
-0.0010983024,
-0.0042616348,
-0.0171481445,
-0.0076115779,
-0.0178432092,
0.0211653765,
-0.0176462773,
-0.0090409005,
0.0310559589,
-0.0298144668,
0.0116717201,
0.0339900032,
-0.021383781,
-0.0009300248,
0.0103234472,
0.0006192637,
0.0098845931,
0.0633207932,
-0.0524904355,
0.00888188,
-0.0812019333,
-0.0286327153,
-0.0417351238,
0.0568445958,
-0.0304389279,
-0.0004931271,
0.1071723774,
-0.0221365895,
-0.0390335955,
0.0101450142,
-0.0496404879,
-0.0035525879,
-0.0587111376,
0.0110457344,
-0.0103452336,
0.0316086337,
-0.0157860443,
0.0747914091,
-0.0390361324,
0.0226071514,
0.0725616738,
-0.0367784798,
0.0140193217,
-0.0625927672,
-0.0533758551,
0.0177910272,
-0.0524917766,
0.0282158144,
0.0046213926,
-0.0069471486,
-0.0080461344,
0.0063137123,
-0.0478551947,
0.0309269745,
-0.0149610164,
-0.0089102322,
0.0347747281,
0.0240181535,
0.0417332649,
-0.0382715128,
-0.0289911907,
0.0293858703,
0.0136066331,
0.0260428563,
-0.0035886215,
0.0082622059,
-0.0177563336,
-0.0298868883,
-0.0425123647,
0.0182477143,
0.0447827727,
-0.0709559172,
-0.0338706635,
-0.0555708669,
0.1056869254,
-0.0567876436,
0.0091264481,
-0.0169775039,
-0.0179613046,
-0.0210016426,
-0.028067911,
0.0305576548,
0.0282101016,
-0.0013429889,
0.0427935272,
0.0960168391,
0.0321209431,
-0.0235817395,
0.0027163606,
-0.0433987901,
0.0169988479,
-0.0430948287,
-0.0304953158,
0.0113630919,
0.0384325013,
0.0168958232,
0.0024520978,
-0.0522691943,
-0.0225840081,
-0.0066340724,
-0.0335109234,
-0.0456052758,
-0.0197967794,
-0.0174690355,
0.001178026,
0.0112742996,
-0.0200166311,
0.0488838665,
-0.0453867167,
-0.023635,
-0.0097646844,
-0.0709013939,
-0.0323393829,
0.0008572052,
0.0169288442,
0.014619167,
-0.0714815855,
-0.0064220899,
-0.0461172014,
-0.0120423818,
0.0073663606,
-0.0388469845,
0.0343355648,
-0.0010721937,
0.0057339743,
-0.0415685698,
-0.0452118255,
-0.0182831828,
-0.0717392042,
-0.003773019,
0.0369497389,
0.0110139009,
-0.004848782,
0.0223106239,
0.0164481532,
-0.0022055495,
0.0145440921,
-0.0111544821,
0.0323430113,
-0.0230034404,
0.0664356723,
0.0770293921,
0.0432548039,
0.0465256535,
-0.014944165,
0.0213051159,
0.0430296101,
0.0057447311,
-0.0288668144,
-0.0278826002,
-0.0043815267,
0.0350938365,
0.0148265222,
-0.0500859059,
0.0368890613,
-0.0166186076,
-0.010621381,
-0.0069124983,
0.0779488161,
0.0323315263,
-0.0608374216,
0.0075448048,
-0.0076790568,
0.0876790285,
0.0361714363,
0.0518076345,
-0.013463852,
0.0016975877,
0.0117557533,
0.0102249663,
0.061411567,
-0.0198022574,
-0.0160607863,
-0.1000233069,
0.0251153689,
0.0209734291,
0.0040998878,
-0.0254637916,
-0.0413997248,
-0.0071071647,
0.0040344358,
0.0154512469,
0.0209010169,
-0.0249032862,
0.0081941532,
0.0144488811,
-0.042912405,
-0.0705251023,
-0.0078595914,
0.0270475503,
0.0487903692,
-0.0110602239,
0.0193287991,
-0.0143773491,
-0.0763754621,
0.039394673,
0.0006089538,
-0.0237425286,
-0.0470934734,
0.0146119418,
0.0213631392,
0.0083925873,
-0.0056318254,
0.0496133119,
-0.0203575902,
-0.0140001131,
-0.0294763073,
0.1221789941,
-0.0143216895,
-0.0415192209,
0.0011271089,
-0.0197477192,
-0.0540893488,
0.0842476636,
0.0609967299,
0.0012189811,
-0.0426467136,
0.0213256646,
-0.0059009921,
-0.0136952968,
-0.0806629881,
0.0167811662,
0.0091542825,
0.0284856334,
-0.0149584599,
-0.0050846585,
0.050164219,
0.0006161932,
-0.054883033,
0.0304865781,
-0.0433334894,
0.0166083518,
-0.0311082695,
-0.0055500087,
-0.0202533975,
-0.0102508841,
-0.0048510586,
0.0231811218,
0.005548378,
-0.0011166006,
0.0057092332,
-0.0330658741,
-0.0925893486,
-0.0257209726,
-0.0566084199,
0.0344551504,
0.0194925014,
0.0440193713,
0.0179634094,
-0.0804895684,
0.0028665031,
-0.0112191541,
-0.0434493646,
0.0610720478,
0.0086157601,
-0.0894995555,
0.0016456577,
0.0505791344,
-0.049314227,
-0.0073776306,
-0.009606217,
0.0607320443,
-0.0336700343,
-0.0318940617,
0.0219204016,
0.0358026288,
0.0181141421,
0.0030633465,
-0.0289690513,
-0.0054550203,
0.0288775396,
-0.034076158,
-0.0101577966,
-0.0404089168,
-0.0048930263,
0.0120203122,
0.028780343,
0.014034017,
-0.0100380983,
0.0070885774,
0.0455032028,
-0.0046647205,
-0.0230213087,
0.0156952776,
-0.0630571395,
0.0421546698,
0.0233124588,
-0.0354721062,
-0.0000339443,
0.0048348228,
0.0123291202,
-0.0519446693,
-0.0365036801,
0.004534788,
0.0256135333,
-0.0873275697,
0.02970412,
-0.0297330897,
-0.0931010693,
-0.0233900547,
-0.0006722555,
0.017620666,
0.0017693533,
0.0529983602,
-0.0018225923,
-0.0264172684,
-0.0231253505,
-0.0006391406,
0.0262356047,
-0.0107644862,
0.0558211245,
0.0150365941,
-0.0194211435,
0.0139947496,
0.1126625016,
0.0412879214,
0.0115574813,
-0.0346952602,
-0.0328848995,
-0.0537494794,
-0.0202202424,
-0.0279031079,
0.0811672211,
-0.0130601041,
-0.0174799766,
-0.0438641496,
-0.0916347802,
-0.0335459933,
-0.0108329216,
0.009128999,
-0.0232456382,
0.0225928724,
0.0437764749,
0.0148019316,
0.0362117924,
-0.0010375486,
-0.0250232145,
-0.0049848803,
-0.0438311026,
-0.0048220898,
-5.838604033e-33,
-0.019546479,
-0.015876336,
0.019832449,
0.0284750909,
-0.0129635278,
0.0199649427,
-0.0440699048,
0.0007684556,
-0.0217339601,
0.0045476169,
-0.0369486697,
-0.0108705852,
-0.0074301744,
0.0198054425,
-0.0229635164,
0.0124319894,
0.0627701879,
-0.0340396091,
-0.0018430974,
0.0213292334,
0.011768979,
0.0386435837,
0.0158310123,
-0.006077636,
-0.0550330654,
-0.0277078599,
0.0045567178,
0.0232147817,
0.0227477998,
0.0426121205,
-0.0542414784,
0.0340004824,
0.0440798588,
-0.0468221344,
-0.032642331,
0.0462816879,
-0.0831092522,
-0.0271381494,
0.0688844398,
-0.0428249799,
-0.0645487234,
-0.0224540327,
0.0195667706,
0.0118356925,
-0.0003642622,
-0.0324996151,
0.0256746318,
-0.0324205495,
-0.0628318787,
-0.031297043,
-0.020218879,
-0.0158733092,
-0.0259853825,
-0.0191976614,
0.063352406,
0.0425936617,
-0.0631008968,
0.057653375,
-0.051021032,
0.0200721622,
0.0204773918,
0.0735178515,
0.0698915422,
0.0176075865,
-0.023746131,
0.0343173146,
-0.0194197819,
-0.0045560361,
-0.0058807959,
0.0161995236,
0.0292567704,
0.0398317687,
0.0765772834,
0.0347546339,
0.0063610408,
-0.0004681016,
-0.0910518616,
0.0100407153,
0.032162752,
0.0211294051,
0.0177763607,
0.0230045132,
0.0233489573,
-0.0514943935,
-0.040227633,
0.0191093776,
-0.0274850614,
-0.0318648964,
0.0109833907,
0.0264170021,
-0.0545962416,
-0.0152498512,
0.0477706306,
-0.0674273595,
-0.0122308545,
0.0652545542,
-0.0241691917,
0.0215609204,
0.0463760123,
-0.0038569823,
-0.0578722619,
0.0124615571,
0.0123485643,
-0.0665028617,
0.0055864966,
0.0064682332,
0.0212405063,
0.0257588401,
-0.0147536527,
-0.0115331374,
0.0090492619,
-0.0408442989,
0.0203693043,
0.0523120426,
0.0237350091,
0.0169682186,
0.0078419056,
0.0624502562,
0.0139439171,
0.023399964,
-0.0162929911,
-0.0146084577,
0.0569843985,
0.0059525948,
-0.004527838,
-0.0063895844,
-0.0505942143,
0.0722068176,
0.0682055056,
-0.0418324806,
-0.0099075269,
0.0056266128,
2.517e-7,
0.0322706774,
0.013488682,
-0.0224573929,
-0.0431078374,
0.0170574076,
0.0220446698,
0.0017617954,
0.0066272388,
0.0105454912,
-0.0223675389,
0.0352893434,
0.022047339,
0.0207844712,
0.0095870905,
-0.0803353116,
0.0226572659,
-0.0852479488,
-0.0202629417,
-0.0424093455,
-0.0370712541,
0.0179908816,
0.0915293843,
-0.012536237,
-0.0286949202,
-0.0297044571,
0.0164864939,
0.0447889119,
-0.0167881195,
-0.024278203,
-0.0107464688,
0.040632531,
-0.0326605216,
-0.0269079246,
0.0097936494,
-0.0164754968,
0.0419439487,
0.0067911572,
0.0595765822,
-0.0085313823,
-0.0058363904,
0.0148105174,
-0.0304984692,
0.0019438026,
-0.0601363219,
0.0855536088,
-0.0011485184,
-0.0194411706,
-0.0083412025,
-0.0000328202,
0.006600867,
-0.0039036663,
-0.0208531637,
0.0176377837,
0.0114710489,
0.0029857524,
-0.0070994413,
-0.0257233158,
-0.0844195336,
0.0211071242,
0.0031077822,
-0.0675735176,
-0.0497894473,
-0.0292260759,
-0.0339644328,
0.0622836351,
-0.0230406988,
0.0155617865,
2.550954755e-34,
-0.0003536521,
0.0080487737,
0.0463872291,
0.0520550087,
0.0048817946,
-0.050965827,
-0.0180382654,
0.0356570333,
0.0008427392,
-0.1323675811,
-0.026901355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14149v1 | SciMRC: Multi-perspective Scientific Machine Reading Comprehension | 2023-06-25T07:25:14 | 2023-06-25T07:25:14 | Xiao Zhang, Heqi Zheng, Yuxiang Nie, Heyan Huang, Xian-Ling Mao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scientific machine reading comprehension (SMRC) aims to understand scientific
texts through interactions with humans by given questions. As far as we know,
there is only one dataset focused on exploring full-text scientific machine
reading comprehension. However, the dataset has ignored the fact that different
readers may have different levels of understanding of the text, and only
includes single-perspective question-answer pairs, leading to a lack of
consideration of different perspectives. To tackle the above problem, we
propose a novel multi-perspective SMRC dataset, called SciMRC, which includes
perspectives from beginners, students and experts. Our proposed SciMRC is
constructed from 741 scientific papers and 6,057 question-answer pairs. Each
perspective of beginners, students and experts contains 3,306, 1,800 and 951 QA
pairs, respectively. The extensive experiments on SciMRC by utilizing
pre-trained models suggest the importance of considering perspectives of SMRC,
and demonstrate its challenging nature for machine comprehension. | [
0.0179167688,
0.0080257142,
-0.0004743725,
0.0292469412,
-0.0297678635,
0.0464206152,
0.0178792533,
-0.0409643315,
0.0157077871,
0.024840245,
-0.0471067391,
0.0018539019,
-0.0054466575,
0.0476651713,
0.0059338198,
-0.0648393333,
0.0198877193,
-0.0288643129,
0.0086031286,
0.0115244016,
-0.0000727656,
0.0202914942,
-0.0335308537,
-0.0090208463,
0.071524024,
-0.0660097227,
0.0200320575,
-0.0110746389,
0.0790464878,
-0.0520016328,
0.0111488625,
0.0257545616,
0.0295764003,
0.0137276612,
0.0000017625,
-0.0564818084,
-0.0286796466,
0.0077227764,
-0.0268214438,
0.037567459,
0.0331986137,
-0.0494737811,
0.0497402176,
-0.0092298537,
-0.0286588185,
0.0290982798,
0.0028696961,
0.0477989316,
0.0623082295,
-0.0055535012,
0.0043868218,
-0.0474507958,
0.0267697293,
0.0062188702,
0.0647021011,
-0.0519327298,
0.0465747155,
0.0412659012,
-0.0029254889,
0.0584609881,
-0.0128733274,
0.0804967135,
0.0284573883,
-0.012437054,
0.007019077,
0.0455508977,
0.0429264158,
-0.0132929496,
-0.014592398,
0.1153595522,
0.0396904312,
-0.0343960524,
-0.0140089672,
-0.0295877177,
-0.0361131653,
0.0397276655,
-0.0547333099,
-0.0180442818,
-0.0234346837,
-0.0134855825,
-0.0038496011,
0.0031725625,
0.0211962778,
0.0150543628,
-0.0072713266,
0.0542887524,
0.0133024156,
-0.0603355803,
-0.0045098634,
0.0026237515,
0.0103835966,
0.0192181077,
0.0243280102,
0.0365380347,
0.0024014045,
0.044805456,
-0.0144237541,
-0.0336869508,
0.035935767,
0.0006843589,
0.0122809773,
0.0310837701,
-0.0258709863,
0.0673465058,
0.0050880928,
-0.0016971164,
-0.0287934728,
0.0126464237,
-0.0320700146,
-0.0162818618,
0.0059478492,
-0.0290455092,
0.0017305583,
-0.0218879171,
-0.0329101905,
-0.0232001934,
-0.0080681928,
0.004842388,
0.0510315113,
-0.0194708891,
-0.0131434659,
0.0194712244,
-0.0529904105,
-0.014971992,
-0.0285435822,
0.0635810196,
-0.0662205443,
0.0323845819,
-0.024085138,
-0.0196051057,
-0.0491774753,
0.0081201922,
-0.0037550807,
-0.0348555222,
-0.013643153,
-0.0032000288,
-0.0008625721,
-0.0597793385,
-0.0013521336,
-0.0306155905,
0.0240271166,
-0.0364781991,
0.0125662908,
0.0079311151,
0.0670089424,
0.0311243348,
-0.0003701575,
-0.0024862839,
-0.0193599183,
0.032448303,
-0.0319036804,
0.0971850455,
-0.030952448,
-0.0452118628,
0.0602824911,
0.0265037715,
-0.0001575848,
0.0320587978,
-0.0066853487,
-0.0560270622,
0.0186683983,
0.0048929993,
-0.0267722718,
-0.0388718881,
0.0203859881,
-0.0026759196,
0.0318856575,
0.0412599631,
-0.0323835127,
0.0543163121,
0.000405712,
0.0167435165,
-0.0153711531,
-0.0591779202,
-0.0004231595,
0.0360633656,
-0.0128627131,
0.0180043019,
0.0242475457,
0.0086060883,
0.0353396274,
0.0384962559,
0.0182914175,
0.0416410901,
-0.0074914386,
0.0081870761,
0.0377988406,
0.0036954936,
-0.0156484898,
-0.0277766809,
0.0190364532,
0.0536439195,
-0.0257098973,
0.0193870161,
0.0689092278,
-0.0131245581,
-0.028770417,
0.0038600601,
0.0181372017,
-0.0389684364,
0.0023477376,
0.006539613,
0.0617921129,
-0.0126312161,
0.0473341607,
-0.0636820868,
-0.0718586147,
0.0172421392,
0.001724458,
0.0189273786,
0.0483155064,
-0.0189661551,
0.0121930996,
-0.0507845432,
-0.0164395142,
-0.008683987,
-0.0073789591,
0.0041888999,
-0.0149437776,
0.0043084305,
0.0126865497,
-0.0246282835,
0.0008602266,
0.043182876,
-0.0820683762,
-0.0285431799,
-0.0354745202,
-0.0358616263,
0.0296178162,
-0.0030411549,
0.0180421192,
0.0097517315,
0.0724415928,
-0.0263781101,
0.0407907963,
0.0221552495,
-0.050791692,
-0.076434195,
0.0266687218,
-0.0777080804,
-0.0339993164,
0.0425861105,
-0.01130905,
-0.0413263552,
-0.0027341088,
-0.0237915423,
-0.0600854978,
-0.0194521546,
-0.0319855846,
-0.0178377666,
0.0267516598,
-0.032026194,
0.0130984699,
-0.0120631419,
0.0541858152,
0.0377716534,
-0.0007077507,
0.0085664103,
-0.0279576816,
-0.0252592135,
-0.0440974273,
0.0254853293,
-0.0598837547,
-0.009809833,
-0.022780193,
-0.0978121981,
0.0126999281,
-0.0336187929,
0.0237229578,
0.0251057949,
-0.0103453472,
0.0296706278,
-0.0221982673,
0.0139259053,
-0.0009739364,
-0.006145482,
0.0225491337,
-0.0266088415,
-0.0326620229,
0.0572641119,
0.0194740891,
0.0357204303,
-0.0361328945,
-0.0170540027,
-0.0792502463,
0.0267627481,
0.0688063204,
0.0245903451,
-0.0631595775,
-0.0309528019,
0.0050551686,
-0.0176691301,
-0.0412040278,
0.020808164,
0.0565064885,
-0.0581522845,
-0.0067397007,
0.0888999775,
0.0136857023,
0.0345450044,
0.0356178693,
0.0059539154,
-0.0288581084,
0.0322306715,
0.0021693315,
0.0570435897,
-0.0148678096,
-0.0050672907,
0.0033977246,
0.0473869406,
-0.0167938489,
-0.009973322,
0.0015195474,
0.0438837223,
-0.0094176661,
-0.0159173701,
-0.0124199139,
0.0216717385,
-0.0201459266,
0.0466456078,
0.0072102975,
0.0057603167,
0.1112802252,
-0.0393346213,
-0.0470841564,
-0.0831811875,
0.0314175077,
-0.0445827283,
0.0038378616,
-0.0060362504,
-0.0063988212,
-0.0098075923,
-0.0109013766,
-0.0252928901,
0.0363967717,
-0.0061034667,
0.0219090711,
-0.0133250933,
-0.0506388657,
0.0037330254,
0.0118975276,
0.003488407,
-0.0005132731,
-0.0132209593,
-0.0357877985,
-0.0103328191,
0.0145539166,
-0.0460890792,
-0.057967864,
-0.0245414358,
0.042039942,
0.0142844887,
-0.03511912,
-0.0293522719,
-0.0472564548,
0.0289524272,
0.0513380095,
0.0273631979,
0.0388324,
-0.0678424761,
0.0308714081,
0.0401317216,
0.0025509542,
-0.0010043837,
0.0269878637,
0.0071978141,
0.0227010734,
-0.0201652031,
0.0630993098,
-0.0509470887,
0.0590713657,
-0.0522744358,
-0.0310964901,
0.0739230663,
0.0399731807,
-0.0512253307,
-0.0267015807,
-0.0535362773,
0.0049969559,
0.0093846805,
0.0229443293,
-0.0861305818,
-0.0274808537,
-0.0441441834,
0.0401377939,
0.0138288662,
-0.035015516,
-0.0358548164,
-0.03415066,
-0.0050419536,
-0.0031266769,
-0.0812586471,
-0.046318762,
-0.0665571615,
-0.0036560986,
-0.0006176946,
0.0056197313,
0.0451501682,
0.0078884661,
-0.0306763779,
-0.0081044529,
0.0277705975,
-0.0218321998,
0.0258265622,
0.0027480097,
-0.0009333803,
-0.0149693647,
0.0268165451,
-0.0086224135,
-0.0276078675,
0.0014348293,
-0.0552235246,
-0.0217004791,
-0.0432979949,
0.0385926813,
-0.0187317785,
-0.0101178093,
-0.0368958302,
0.0976755247,
-0.0588656142,
-0.009191093,
0.0339298137,
0.0420824699,
0.0068338811,
-0.0409664698,
-0.0900625139,
0.0402291045,
-0.013363122,
0.0904803202,
0.032352481,
-0.0199071765,
-0.0512924232,
-0.0219079442,
-0.0016437439,
-0.0311873388,
-0.0283932798,
-0.0030308166,
0.036616765,
0.0325710922,
-0.0178286675,
-0.0351332314,
0.038581185,
0.002251891,
0.0033333874,
0.0062002302,
0.028011173,
-0.0168407653,
-0.0271978099,
0.0249687098,
-0.0100842183,
-0.0084987497,
-0.043073047,
-0.0196005106,
0.0566133,
-0.0056599635,
-0.0405901447,
0.014881514,
-0.0335776992,
-0.0330392644,
-0.0342370756,
0.0280191079,
0.0178456698,
0.0271084365,
-0.0107313562,
-0.0477621593,
0.0448539704,
-0.0236691963,
-0.0098085059,
0.0025781358,
-0.0154644847,
0.0024990935,
-0.0159657132,
-0.0121298404,
0.0325559415,
0.0001378424,
-0.0427359305,
0.0236200057,
-0.0650854558,
-0.0567196794,
0.0048804083,
0.0161504801,
0.0547522604,
0.0354255587,
0.003653209,
-0.0420378596,
0.0286789015,
-0.0258611981,
0.0242458768,
-0.0214674044,
0.0222085845,
0.0348202959,
-0.0682852045,
-0.0134378169,
-0.0197902992,
-0.0574522838,
0.0165914837,
-0.0215566661,
0.0518215969,
0.0282163937,
0.0048828833,
0.0332847983,
-0.0228018239,
-0.0344409645,
-0.0221110303,
-0.0320662111,
0.0483471453,
0.0559287034,
0.0803991705,
0.053546112,
0.0135029815,
0.000325338,
0.0024077387,
-0.0931762084,
-0.0280311964,
-0.0190981142,
0.0510091372,
-0.0317025967,
0.0221736673,
0.0364312716,
-0.0195671525,
-0.0127863595,
-0.0375742391,
0.0435684696,
-0.0019501304,
0.0089803636,
0.098490335,
0.0231999438,
0.0160075631,
-0.0118299462,
0.0786936283,
0.0147913964,
0.0228329692,
0.0169057921,
-0.0072307759,
-0.0452827886,
0.0044773938,
-0.0360943191,
0.0335428827,
0.0037345763,
0.0167044792,
-0.037721172,
-0.0459110364,
0.0270046368,
0.0418123938,
-0.0004022916,
-0.0321208015,
-0.0065682074,
0.0452015921,
-0.0144723393,
-0.0436624214,
-0.0175867826,
0.0638690665,
-0.0394898914,
-0.0671383962,
-0.0146480594,
-6.04345523e-33,
-0.0030504202,
-0.0216510519,
-0.0031141669,
0.0123931589,
0.0236821081,
0.0155607173,
-0.0537192784,
-0.0234135129,
-0.029687861,
0.0136441411,
0.0110006835,
0.0527211763,
-0.0098137129,
0.012795967,
-0.0018079071,
0.0094788726,
0.031838771,
-0.0095994342,
-0.0005081663,
0.0333178788,
0.0275026783,
0.0392790139,
0.0233690925,
-0.0789016485,
0.0627743378,
-0.0482374318,
0.0229484234,
0.0325160027,
-0.0356249027,
0.0271972585,
-0.0842170119,
0.0081206774,
0.0229413919,
-0.0394441299,
0.0115816128,
0.050879851,
-0.1022665277,
-0.02764301,
-0.0092233829,
0.0086525856,
-0.097657375,
0.0108468598,
0.0151824458,
0.0204421002,
0.0547642522,
-0.0546682142,
0.0528194271,
-0.0156690758,
-0.0023695487,
-0.0159257706,
-0.0198982283,
0.0178154837,
-0.058261767,
-0.0235542934,
0.0211841743,
0.0538822599,
0.0056513203,
0.0863306895,
-0.015368538,
0.0143790105,
0.0512859635,
-0.0180666838,
-0.0158980433,
-0.0052085137,
0.0376075208,
0.0204020124,
-0.009985676,
-0.0360370576,
0.0120456917,
-0.020240562,
0.0278967544,
0.0182514936,
0.0311490223,
0.0340015143,
0.0419666618,
0.045160044,
-0.0759161785,
0.0694295093,
0.0259981882,
0.0420606025,
0.0032083739,
-0.0086986255,
0.0320889354,
0.0094103618,
-0.0454740152,
-0.0408950895,
-0.0383241959,
0.012444702,
-0.0105483243,
-0.0575795174,
-0.0703127831,
0.0240968671,
0.0373553,
-0.0225494821,
-0.0265888236,
0.0262246896,
0.021553725,
0.0144014433,
0.0155872563,
0.0506631359,
-0.0537414402,
0.0118778767,
0.000077977,
-0.0115773296,
0.0459143706,
-0.0088435588,
-0.0045844312,
-0.0459678918,
0.0151292617,
-0.0515592508,
0.0029559226,
-0.043630559,
0.0070819431,
0.0835944414,
0.0028403013,
0.0605024137,
-0.0147280311,
0.0452694558,
-0.0045052408,
0.0319073163,
-0.0260940362,
-0.0077911005,
-0.0182280447,
0.0452685468,
-0.0347200073,
-0.0535263382,
0.0026306265,
-0.0328945816,
0.0000517277,
-0.0660159588,
0.0231359657,
0.051842317,
2.44e-7,
0.0683406442,
0.0486108884,
0.0345757343,
0.0099531896,
0.0194239151,
0.0325861312,
-0.0117777213,
0.0220719259,
0.0384891778,
-0.026377311,
0.0157303195,
0.0091195265,
0.0223005507,
0.0200657789,
-0.1003822163,
-0.0544004925,
-0.0395109318,
0.0181136727,
-0.0346107893,
-0.0020440714,
0.065533936,
0.0355729498,
-0.0355577581,
-0.0259507857,
0.0279570445,
0.011719428,
0.0509600677,
-0.0107484804,
0.0387890935,
0.0405009091,
0.0326423869,
-0.0082464535,
0.0089740977,
0.0398775749,
-0.0023527225,
-0.0044819042,
-0.0061241742,
0.0408784859,
0.043331366,
-0.0629377291,
0.0428311713,
0.0534472987,
0.0540335029,
-0.0658433735,
0.0572811626,
-0.0621543005,
-0.0417527221,
0.0293250065,
-0.0441149622,
-0.0264242943,
0.0388030969,
0.0016695064,
-0.0126716858,
0.0351440236,
-0.0299961716,
-0.0460818857,
0.0348296389,
-0.0639498532,
-0.0095767351,
-0.0054069785,
-0.0352656133,
-0.0057493574,
-0.0274881199,
-0.0576418452,
0.0251665711,
-0.0196446087,
-0.0070191612,
1.478280229e-34,
0.043445155,
-0.0315681957,
0.0048273373,
0.0146430908,
0.0157634616,
-0.019390462,
-0.0163686834,
0.014313953,
0.0147781447,
-0.0947111994,
-0.0179471802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14145v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14145v1 | DSE-TTS: Dual Speaker Embedding for Cross-Lingual Text-to-Speech | 2023-06-25T06:46:36 | 2023-06-25T06:46:36 | Sen Liu, Yiwei Guo, Chenpeng Du, Xie Chen, Kai Yu | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Although high-fidelity speech can be obtained for intralingual speech
synthesis, cross-lingual text-to-speech (CTTS) is still far from satisfactory
as it is difficult to accurately retain the speaker timbres(i.e. speaker
similarity) and eliminate the accents from their first language(i.e.
nativeness). In this paper, we demonstrated that vector-quantized(VQ) acoustic
feature contains less speaker information than mel-spectrogram. Based on this
finding, we propose a novel dual speaker embedding TTS (DSE-TTS) framework for
CTTS with authentic speaking style. Here, one embedding is fed to the acoustic
model to learn the linguistic speaking style, while the other one is integrated
into the vocoder to mimic the target speaker's timbre. Experiments show that by
combining both embeddings, DSE-TTS significantly outperforms the
state-of-the-art SANE-TTS in cross-lingual synthesis, especially in terms of
nativeness. | [
-0.0567835644,
0.0224887002,
0.0134730004,
0.0151419453,
0.0045301933,
-0.0435784571,
0.0261602644,
-0.0063498076,
-0.0569710582,
0.0231564883,
-0.0839369074,
-0.0627768263,
0.0240743011,
0.0307398085,
0.0619707666,
-0.0674960464,
-0.0013237729,
-0.0307669044,
-0.0277226865,
-0.0557304285,
0.0252111591,
0.0015139985,
-0.0003006778,
0.0298851486,
0.0158389565,
0.0283417646,
-0.0173584986,
0.0013510959,
0.0439808108,
0.0395342596,
-0.0480511449,
-0.0202800129,
0.0881502777,
0.0304385833,
0.0000018366,
0.0032738389,
-0.0265878625,
-0.0091819316,
-0.0084773013,
0.0007454203,
0.0174243152,
0.0114636198,
-0.0371460617,
0.0250283293,
0.0064976872,
-0.0265417285,
0.0377766974,
0.0408977531,
0.0492269211,
0.0412868187,
-0.009395903,
-0.0440892614,
0.0122844558,
-0.0060810046,
0.003036133,
0.033131063,
-0.0712365061,
-0.0323779397,
-0.0136119807,
0.0182030629,
-0.0216967501,
0.0594458058,
0.0028932162,
-0.0010308323,
0.0016082164,
0.0003752895,
-0.0136338612,
-0.0018627014,
0.0216619093,
0.0494117327,
0.0114531731,
0.0057543758,
0.0201709252,
0.048304271,
-0.0320958421,
-0.0329200663,
0.0282361172,
-0.0179262329,
0.0098242909,
0.0025362559,
-0.0152652385,
0.0600940846,
0.0054012332,
-0.0592547916,
-0.0079936227,
-0.0433049947,
0.0239570495,
-0.0448533446,
-0.0141533185,
-0.0139893405,
0.0077147726,
0.0380126908,
0.0519392081,
-0.0111749629,
-0.0245813392,
-0.017777659,
-0.030891519,
-0.044356931,
-0.0731481016,
-0.0033355937,
0.0505112708,
0.0731412917,
-0.0574960709,
-0.0247409306,
-0.0310922619,
0.0390681587,
-0.0235646646,
0.0139698647,
-0.046252951,
-0.03299997,
-0.0131147765,
-0.0026071155,
-0.0331722647,
-0.0131885484,
-0.0043740254,
-0.0192710515,
-0.0271222144,
-0.0204597786,
-0.0344896801,
0.0396028459,
0.0103560546,
0.0116649065,
-0.0671219304,
-0.0093434472,
0.0280458666,
0.0256580897,
0.0027388714,
0.0020997254,
-0.0138516435,
-0.0219971891,
-0.0015685789,
0.0149631398,
0.0201856252,
0.0044242977,
0.0238760039,
0.0009057392,
-0.0070401053,
-0.0137076154,
0.0089500248,
-0.0110626854,
-0.0381362773,
-0.0318127908,
0.0036543522,
-0.0711212754,
0.0430759415,
-0.0403978229,
-0.0067239366,
-0.0338461325,
-0.0215389188,
-0.0118346885,
0.0352406576,
0.0247435775,
0.013873267,
0.0239477772,
0.0550202876,
-0.0030500847,
0.0298617743,
0.0302640758,
0.0450823382,
-0.0572716892,
-0.0133082345,
-0.0130602689,
-0.0231826473,
0.0757190362,
0.0481399968,
0.0286464319,
-0.0425565578,
-0.023475023,
-0.0005691211,
0.0484558716,
0.0751419812,
0.0262490511,
-0.0261289217,
0.0048730243,
0.0365488455,
0.029400168,
0.0836521983,
0.0358184986,
0.1073566973,
0.0428678021,
-0.0019313039,
0.0085431002,
0.0258158036,
0.0118206255,
0.022769263,
0.022845706,
0.048632212,
0.0313280113,
-0.0553401187,
0.0085162967,
0.0218989681,
-0.0236683134,
-0.0107557224,
-0.0102144731,
0.0088228993,
0.020442389,
-0.008371152,
0.0460236073,
-0.023096649,
-0.0708210319,
0.0409714095,
-0.0040795431,
-0.041826535,
0.0618047491,
-0.0235405602,
0.0382471494,
0.0483106747,
-0.0340893939,
-0.0577097312,
0.0441075414,
0.0347916335,
-0.0173497628,
0.0623079166,
-0.061002329,
-0.0132249128,
0.0011023639,
-0.0324683674,
0.0595454872,
-0.0342676416,
0.0800108761,
0.0332158543,
-0.0383132547,
0.0708035082,
-0.0260034483,
-0.083227165,
-0.0162831172,
0.0194316525,
0.0186209548,
0.0315986536,
0.065646559,
-0.0374428816,
0.0034356962,
-0.0038358264,
-0.0460248552,
0.0003033493,
0.0599421188,
-0.081581898,
-0.0653325692,
0.0194057338,
-0.0640627891,
0.0230419282,
0.0341502428,
0.0272517782,
-0.0975758508,
0.0486606434,
-0.005344802,
0.0044874251,
-0.0284634121,
-0.0139620602,
0.0145864319,
0.0262269843,
0.053285189,
-0.0172029454,
0.0240029544,
0.0171675663,
0.0381282493,
0.0410583951,
-0.0043273983,
-0.0674908161,
-0.007099058,
0.0123614809,
0.0399021395,
0.0356261805,
-0.0176217444,
-0.0125026442,
0.0201757904,
0.003904294,
-0.1011698395,
0.0151109174,
0.0154374093,
0.004122592,
-0.0246446375,
0.0158183519,
0.0045861825,
0.0053843241,
-0.0956787542,
-0.0728286356,
0.0130505115,
-0.0312520489,
-0.0094534289,
-0.0156590939,
-0.0149884243,
0.0118067078,
0.0239494462,
0.0208305661,
-0.0017327757,
-0.0841017663,
0.0168386828,
-0.0570759661,
-0.0093796067,
0.0002161089,
0.0158817489,
0.0090921177,
-0.0199079551,
-0.0186829064,
0.0231564343,
0.0811062604,
-0.0004793669,
-0.0093817618,
-0.0626359731,
0.0131898746,
-0.035451401,
-0.0458050817,
-0.0005264661,
0.0498798527,
0.0555642471,
-0.0107034706,
-0.0112843821,
0.0242902208,
0.0233154297,
0.0063994005,
0.0175642204,
-0.051788643,
0.0079581952,
0.0284921676,
-0.0286228135,
0.037613593,
-0.0124813616,
-0.0413667113,
-0.0167596545,
-0.0032021173,
0.0000629395,
0.0472876951,
-0.0823630616,
-0.0570819117,
-0.0382005721,
-0.0316398777,
-0.0062907841,
-0.0357998013,
-0.0137215657,
0.0634861365,
-0.0142648472,
-0.0039663999,
-0.0351480357,
0.0165615901,
0.0342941023,
-0.0601339117,
0.0155250421,
0.0371443965,
-0.0332801938,
-0.0216464438,
-0.0080616381,
0.0128785567,
0.0031673121,
-0.0186372697,
0.0329348743,
0.0479400642,
-0.0399562195,
0.0370214991,
0.0333128832,
0.0606515668,
0.0355154127,
0.0145325838,
0.0133904237,
-0.0079110907,
0.051775489,
-0.0057588355,
0.031251967,
-0.0339157954,
-0.0116373207,
0.0510842577,
-0.0427139439,
0.0386928022,
-0.0030901912,
-0.0321582407,
-0.0036946801,
0.0322611555,
0.0570639111,
-0.0474850647,
-0.0209179521,
0.0644729659,
0.0020025221,
-0.0070852838,
0.0794874951,
-0.0275026988,
-0.0306674503,
-0.0278619193,
-0.031256672,
0.0575910583,
-0.0101311095,
0.0075026862,
-0.0565863885,
-0.0265881978,
0.0613687448,
0.0381527394,
0.0114605557,
0.0243985113,
-0.0577065088,
-0.0746152475,
0.0027682779,
0.058545135,
-0.0351024866,
-0.0214061514,
0.0039401692,
-0.0612733252,
-0.0060447669,
0.0184707381,
0.0080493279,
-0.0088971946,
-0.0253787804,
0.0286044683,
-0.0630486012,
-0.0324396677,
0.011215074,
-0.0608675331,
0.078187041,
0.0334195718,
0.0578947812,
0.0111751929,
-0.0181010254,
-0.0609799549,
-0.0383787639,
-0.0078657474,
0.0139823668,
0.0027465597,
0.0090852035,
-0.004927699,
0.0174673982,
0.0444784537,
0.0047900975,
0.0445777811,
0.013162978,
0.0395448357,
-0.0119769638,
0.0105241435,
0.0212940034,
0.0351200812,
-0.0191205945,
0.0440915264,
0.008721875,
-0.0710644498,
0.0058570402,
0.0002363945,
0.0368305743,
-0.0287883952,
-0.1005888358,
0.023121018,
-0.0016896374,
-0.043624226,
-0.0410371535,
-0.0088834874,
-0.0215965882,
0.0441668443,
-0.0051092994,
-0.0044475826,
-0.0512545556,
-0.0194314774,
-0.0276199076,
-0.0242365785,
-0.0478062145,
0.0436400063,
-0.0150229456,
0.0328590833,
0.0090908622,
-0.0680742338,
0.0029181917,
0.0074191345,
-0.0176659189,
-0.061725609,
-0.0229063053,
-0.0106721176,
0.0027858366,
0.104459621,
0.0019171519,
0.0090889679,
0.1149512529,
-0.0168760922,
-0.008101861,
0.0074727386,
0.0996832922,
0.0102446405,
-0.0035420088,
0.0166193191,
-0.021470353,
0.029797757,
-0.0367491581,
0.0011166279,
0.0289135128,
-0.0546172485,
0.0071456814,
0.003573881,
0.0315968804,
-0.0420433804,
0.065763168,
-0.0326253958,
-0.0067006452,
-0.0379018709,
0.0193816833,
-0.0628367364,
-0.0266325045,
0.0466775335,
0.031024484,
0.0073773516,
0.0146855572,
0.0016894955,
-0.005699873,
0.0284549426,
0.0427138619,
0.0419624448,
0.016102856,
0.0178601537,
0.0074318242,
-0.0208562929,
0.0094038704,
0.0021495484,
0.0230436698,
-0.0369340852,
0.0002086054,
-0.006316992,
-0.0264781397,
0.0216212068,
0.0403008834,
-0.0095576271,
-0.0182591081,
-0.0294040311,
-0.0379482843,
0.0434301719,
0.0124537777,
0.0904062763,
-0.0012062894,
0.0414721854,
-0.0064475015,
0.0113169691,
-0.0422859564,
-0.0020979857,
0.0060546468,
-0.0426287316,
-0.0179648399,
0.0163307413,
0.0239406805,
-0.0058177337,
-0.0244008861,
-0.0677091628,
0.0439595319,
-0.0133867981,
-0.010386386,
-0.0252136439,
-0.0210608821,
-0.0151687171,
-0.0640732497,
-0.0009461126,
-0.0487472154,
0.0513231531,
-0.0101097804,
-0.0353405811,
-0.0278101023,
0.0181131922,
-0.0259264819,
-0.0447906069,
0.0247083753,
0.0025771663,
-0.0415774435,
0.0326200165,
-0.0159532558,
0.0587629899,
-5.02824835e-33,
-0.0209463779,
0.0748495907,
-0.0051700985,
0.0169524234,
-0.054151535,
-0.0221208893,
-0.0275766458,
-0.0180273503,
-0.0188202262,
-0.024651302,
-0.0254125427,
-0.0094893239,
0.0006616043,
0.0089362981,
-0.0276750419,
0.0505807959,
0.0829415247,
-0.0133461468,
0.0031298248,
0.0478309095,
0.0381033421,
0.0249119066,
0.0429760888,
-0.0310593583,
-0.0168833844,
-0.0259082504,
0.0070926561,
-0.0113868807,
0.0165435076,
0.0031319708,
-0.0141342003,
0.0391537175,
-0.053232763,
-0.0172640551,
-0.0360802524,
0.0139284972,
-0.0205411781,
-0.0174110625,
-0.0537063926,
0.0262191389,
-0.0041964371,
-0.0274515767,
-0.0020525393,
-0.0302103385,
-0.0542666018,
-0.0367528722,
-0.0006096498,
-0.0214947071,
0.0113389306,
-0.0531055592,
-0.0242306143,
0.0400433801,
0.0110144494,
-0.0214239024,
0.0892444253,
0.0957356915,
-0.0195015259,
-0.0620416813,
-0.0824536085,
0.0464933552,
-0.0391807668,
0.0159257092,
0.0607516505,
0.0095019974,
0.0118449917,
0.0259670783,
0.0621198788,
-0.0676265806,
0.0340790227,
0.0123659046,
0.0562835671,
0.00374447,
0.0521389544,
0.0606729314,
0.0222601052,
-0.0306934472,
0.0002748503,
0.0074537592,
0.0307532754,
-0.0173007548,
0.0044109025,
0.0332129225,
-0.0010089345,
-0.0207287036,
-0.0597361475,
-0.0472587794,
0.0109477974,
-0.0760467499,
0.0303483997,
-0.005393187,
0.0067765894,
-0.0303436518,
0.0803521052,
-0.0199882332,
0.0052187108,
-0.0123176547,
-0.0547880754,
0.0014249615,
0.0043396656,
0.0360455364,
-0.0301877167,
-0.0736466944,
0.0594588779,
0.0375641994,
0.0099102221,
0.0001749398,
0.0152579667,
0.0466250405,
-0.0620328374,
0.0006495407,
0.0124089047,
0.0066924766,
-0.0156985037,
0.0005643154,
0.0291880593,
-0.0140347201,
0.0087459357,
0.0216497332,
0.0205787066,
-0.0047056223,
0.0062122517,
-0.0180752054,
0.028851673,
0.0323000923,
-0.0061416957,
0.0454539917,
-0.0267410036,
-0.0521366671,
0.0386071727,
-0.0266176704,
-0.015301398,
-0.0378747694,
2.66e-7,
-0.0600724369,
-0.0294269398,
0.0094170859,
-0.047981374,
0.0231774785,
0.0476023816,
-0.0234764945,
0.0191666391,
-0.0076350607,
-0.0029335318,
0.0068618399,
-0.0202401076,
0.085194245,
0.0585321411,
-0.1020655781,
0.00492001,
-0.0395972654,
0.0154513437,
-0.0167059787,
0.0247626938,
0.0040655308,
0.0589811802,
-0.0390639752,
-0.0196275115,
0.0206889436,
-0.0330877416,
0.055609975,
-0.0216441415,
-0.0250385776,
-0.0397984125,
0.0193861667,
-0.0362839513,
-0.0133174816,
-0.0177411474,
-0.0540714189,
0.0822531432,
0.0235538911,
0.0289835483,
0.0304279421,
-0.0316744633,
0.0004002002,
0.0261100065,
-0.0754532143,
0.0390832797,
0.0255918931,
0.0073351683,
-0.0163482875,
-0.0419166274,
-0.0319823436,
0.0207729694,
0.0309946556,
-0.0095622959,
-0.0151038365,
0.0085932668,
0.0446009301,
0.0248829331,
0.0078656841,
-0.0124963447,
-0.0194991026,
0.0352167301,
-0.0353203081,
-0.030565504,
-0.0122247031,
0.0172339566,
0.0446189903,
0.0165194608,
-0.0045153634,
2.030647894e-34,
-0.0018393736,
-0.0051399125,
0.0559532158,
-0.0193673745,
-0.0150219295,
-0.0372063667,
0.0409303159,
0.0130446972,
0.0475275554,
-0.0130851073,
-0.0527512394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14135v1 | Interpretable Neural Embeddings with Sparse Self-Representation | 2023-06-25T05:57:01 | 2023-06-25T05:57:01 | Minxue Xia, Hao Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Interpretability benefits the theoretical understanding of representations.
Existing word embeddings are generally dense representations. Hence, the
meaning of latent dimensions is difficult to interpret. This makes word
embeddings like a black-box and prevents them from being human-readable and
further manipulation. Many methods employ sparse representation to learn
interpretable word embeddings for better interpretability. However, they also
suffer from the unstable issue of grouped selection in $\ell1$ and online
dictionary learning. Therefore, they tend to yield different results each time.
To alleviate this challenge, we propose a novel method to associate data
self-representation with a shallow neural network to learn expressive,
interpretable word embeddings. In experiments, we report that the resulting
word embeddings achieve comparable and even slightly better interpretability
than baseline embeddings. Besides, we also evaluate that our approach performs
competitively well on all downstream tasks and outperforms benchmark embeddings
on a majority of them. | [
-0.0098122982,
0.0728473663,
0.0095968954,
0.0669305548,
0.0172499102,
-0.0143449893,
0.0113628162,
-0.003408832,
-0.0085247792,
-0.0050677112,
-0.0297175031,
0.0022767903,
-0.0125934696,
0.0659988672,
0.0325437486,
-0.0278820042,
0.0395337418,
0.0104115279,
-0.020228209,
-0.0045979805,
0.0033407495,
0.0031799125,
-0.0109210666,
0.035883572,
-0.020718731,
-0.0325728133,
-0.0105719082,
-0.0182873942,
-0.0139750037,
-0.0183788836,
-0.0452768877,
0.0617343634,
0.0965627283,
0.0284865033,
0.0000018607,
0.0069878916,
-0.0267776623,
-0.012316688,
-0.0689600408,
0.0253512394,
0.0244421307,
-0.0572274923,
0.0259962957,
-0.0622497909,
-0.0379751883,
-0.0660578832,
0.0485169068,
0.0649819151,
0.0432875492,
0.0266778525,
-0.0044114552,
-0.0214845911,
-0.0253854077,
-0.0536380559,
0.0192630012,
-0.0279105213,
-0.0216435678,
-0.0238641407,
-0.0332234167,
0.0516565815,
-0.0798948109,
0.0157613773,
0.0084310146,
-0.0188183356,
0.0656084716,
0.0240816791,
-0.0026465193,
-0.015160677,
0.0341533609,
0.0959916338,
0.0045648552,
0.0068038115,
-0.0203290898,
-0.0194986239,
0.0099921022,
-0.0018444338,
-0.0035067564,
-0.0393569954,
0.0733979791,
0.0458889343,
-0.0081346529,
0.0694640651,
0.0713649616,
0.0436635278,
-0.0430070311,
0.0183946546,
-0.0295475908,
0.0066707181,
-0.0475833267,
0.0002873946,
0.0009331461,
0.0545594133,
-0.0089543583,
-0.0228958745,
0.0146093471,
0.0286197364,
-0.0272196271,
-0.0148956962,
-0.0077087739,
-0.0130514381,
0.0772027597,
0.0069907447,
-0.0248296317,
0.0537239239,
-0.0189033151,
0.0293128863,
0.0129889892,
0.0513268299,
-0.0152154015,
0.0181638617,
-0.0339132398,
-0.0104373125,
-0.011539584,
0.0482780039,
-0.029160358,
-0.0461597592,
-0.0230117999,
0.0198786221,
-0.0713337734,
-0.0006858545,
-0.0353886932,
0.042859219,
-0.0254169125,
-0.0156596787,
0.0067204917,
0.0060214419,
-0.037374638,
0.011058826,
-0.0176507998,
-0.0115580549,
-0.0428779982,
0.0044938722,
0.0418870151,
-0.0135027999,
-0.0290727448,
0.0709981024,
0.0172694083,
-0.048093047,
-0.0024888695,
-0.0233497061,
-0.0191758499,
0.003151963,
-0.0019843725,
-0.0412912443,
0.0690566003,
-0.004211538,
0.0077822059,
-0.1005072892,
-0.0155344019,
-0.0402048454,
-0.0403405018,
0.1223241612,
-0.0230833292,
-0.0405450426,
-0.0476031229,
0.0457134321,
0.0033330603,
0.0373179391,
0.020072693,
0.0485055633,
0.0181161873,
-0.0289835837,
-0.0275586192,
-0.0312458854,
0.0389590822,
0.0044459272,
-0.0396422595,
-0.0109872809,
-0.0497967266,
0.0441471189,
0.060973648,
0.0287517812,
-0.045580633,
-0.0485394225,
0.049991969,
0.0386394151,
0.0576350242,
0.0418627411,
0.0271819718,
0.0340758972,
-0.040033076,
0.0110945832,
-0.0475117378,
0.0413502008,
0.0303637497,
-0.0129129514,
0.0379055887,
-0.025002325,
-0.0257857889,
-0.0361083336,
0.0089698602,
-0.0186645966,
0.0390431397,
-0.002584893,
0.0400295332,
0.0190314036,
-0.0270675384,
0.0430685505,
0.0455948003,
-0.0162644163,
0.011903788,
-0.0348519832,
0.0533431135,
0.0392604172,
0.0460301675,
-0.0272516701,
0.005565736,
-0.0149342362,
-0.0144589869,
0.0327571891,
0.0092998855,
-0.0103670442,
0.0569812767,
-0.0569722839,
-0.0468412116,
-0.0369920284,
0.0271065217,
0.0329445936,
-0.0452521555,
-0.0257469043,
0.0457864068,
-0.0387525596,
-0.0062214099,
0.0167106111,
0.017806014,
-0.063254334,
0.0202231687,
0.0348024927,
0.0253567081,
0.043632973,
-0.0153156109,
0.0236204248,
0.0310397372,
-0.0479423441,
-0.0168252494,
-0.0550035499,
-0.0919089615,
-0.0572691336,
-0.0411224701,
-0.0369443744,
-0.0210021455,
0.0390839316,
-0.034449596,
-0.0232420005,
0.0395859368,
-0.0579612367,
0.0117133996,
-0.0288882665,
-0.0773649737,
0.0146293156,
0.0659098551,
-0.0082678748,
0.0464644134,
-0.0317309946,
0.011988461,
-0.0414418243,
0.0187268239,
0.007774475,
-0.0112962956,
-0.0656802654,
-0.0079575945,
0.0056485664,
0.0233222824,
0.0038694928,
-0.0139646167,
0.0029364221,
0.0202242676,
0.0037372122,
-0.0419519395,
-0.0107760858,
-0.0221067034,
-0.0018656766,
0.0090007177,
0.0377487876,
-0.0327416696,
-0.0417526849,
0.0310721193,
-0.0301354062,
0.0096559208,
0.0601676255,
-0.0072403024,
0.0068599461,
-0.0306816753,
-0.0235656146,
0.0003468535,
0.0707510337,
-0.0369081758,
0.0055355635,
-0.017311709,
0.0057043131,
-0.0143033843,
-0.013917583,
-0.0067296322,
-0.0339759216,
0.0119289476,
-0.0479457341,
-0.0280922577,
0.0407371037,
-0.0081134457,
0.1167777628,
0.0216235891,
0.0203041919,
-0.0581696108,
-0.0186197385,
-0.0007896448,
0.0465620123,
-0.0060429806,
-0.0301581044,
-0.0189049244,
0.0651406944,
0.0315475538,
-0.0270273108,
-0.0565319285,
0.0199449118,
-0.0137130348,
-0.0325905271,
-0.0536121987,
0.0282035433,
0.0135536734,
0.0121213859,
-0.0231963415,
-0.0702646077,
0.0589269139,
0.0132189058,
-0.0082124881,
0.0108627575,
-0.030063279,
-0.0257734042,
0.0676229671,
-0.0080672316,
0.0094930679,
-0.028049456,
-0.0394897088,
-0.0249831025,
-0.0151284263,
0.0263328701,
-0.0084264455,
0.0802711248,
-0.0008598443,
-0.0156335644,
-0.0073005673,
-0.0243255906,
-0.0046515432,
-0.0702677146,
0.0228701644,
0.0177056864,
0.0304386355,
0.002688234,
-0.0291771553,
-0.0325687118,
-0.0018171509,
0.006394512,
-0.0114111444,
-0.0040816735,
-0.0196258724,
0.0065843188,
0.0261018984,
0.065989159,
0.0392041467,
0.0173711628,
0.0376937017,
0.043234311,
0.0115519194,
-0.0314495116,
-0.0730505139,
0.0586129129,
0.0066893217,
0.0228664968,
-0.0208919141,
-0.0060981666,
0.0453083478,
-0.0482137315,
-0.0106256092,
0.0767326578,
-0.0116121322,
-0.0393705629,
0.0302118566,
0.0000085913,
-0.0033493356,
0.003298338,
-0.0013633061,
-0.0312188882,
-0.0243844762,
-0.046622429,
0.0339324474,
0.0270423945,
-0.0385501795,
0.0122228134,
-0.0346873477,
0.0207087118,
0.022144068,
0.0222736914,
-0.057175383,
-0.0363967083,
0.0023554421,
-0.0461375751,
0.0145008061,
-0.036502596,
0.0196343213,
-0.0102962274,
-0.0152049046,
0.0015779709,
-0.0335815698,
0.0241414886,
-0.0060950527,
0.0369483978,
0.0370695889,
0.0409499146,
-0.0436358601,
-0.0192106515,
-0.0543713011,
-0.0089806449,
-0.0195122678,
-0.00299939,
0.0636767447,
0.0215823241,
-0.0436803475,
0.0014098537,
0.0214358624,
-0.0380239338,
-0.0235148743,
-0.0715655237,
0.0624906309,
-0.0215347838,
-0.0125263743,
-0.0129980715,
-0.0227129888,
0.0199104119,
0.0790407434,
0.0368944407,
-0.0152959693,
-0.0252643991,
-0.0098869409,
0.0156279318,
0.0000621817,
-0.0338408686,
0.014130624,
0.0108406963,
-0.0028980512,
-0.025837427,
-0.0858792216,
0.006843315,
0.0529494993,
-0.0260925945,
0.0319206752,
-0.0218497887,
-0.0511728413,
-0.0328191929,
0.039521087,
0.0081742266,
-0.0165890716,
0.0238261446,
-0.0481271408,
0.0214493163,
-0.0087579349,
-0.0185521264,
-0.0034574042,
-0.0402011275,
0.0164212268,
0.0318490863,
0.0184288807,
0.0063173794,
0.0348270275,
-0.0187406577,
-0.0301336218,
0.0637207255,
0.0260841642,
-0.0316731893,
-0.0050295261,
0.0527875312,
0.0213715788,
-0.0155922873,
0.0844912827,
-0.0260563828,
0.0480881296,
0.0037444702,
0.0351189151,
-0.025438441,
-0.0108431978,
-0.0007965257,
-0.0236536283,
0.0354460441,
0.019578971,
0.004476144,
-0.0583369322,
-0.0462039821,
-0.0195225105,
-0.0042800247,
-0.0565226004,
-0.0150903892,
0.0486254282,
-0.0319630243,
-0.0254608169,
-0.0120145213,
-0.0059958352,
0.0184291303,
-0.0513060912,
0.0475062095,
0.0305098947,
-0.0466875918,
-0.0234694015,
0.0412667841,
-0.0476352945,
0.0399800166,
-0.0301057305,
0.0005954063,
-0.0161434524,
0.0146667464,
-0.0180073939,
0.0078773554,
-0.0891698897,
0.0425768048,
-0.0482796319,
-0.0150567535,
0.0238174684,
-0.002677605,
-0.0101324888,
-0.0500454456,
0.0194689371,
-0.0140161011,
0.0129624931,
-0.0163084399,
0.0656614602,
-0.016633505,
-0.0177289732,
0.0136169912,
0.0250654817,
-0.0128342444,
-0.0161578935,
0.0669252723,
0.0223112274,
0.0011415156,
0.0112624951,
0.014052243,
-0.0548041426,
0.0120059457,
0.0539979637,
0.079091683,
-0.0281635635,
0.041476164,
-0.0201432128,
-0.0824161842,
0.0264874361,
-0.0114127286,
-0.0050442163,
0.016997477,
0.0118547296,
0.0360954031,
0.0061307498,
0.0165379941,
-0.0513607301,
0.0332450941,
0.0037443708,
-0.024541324,
-0.0058118743,
-6.220818226e-33,
-0.0111703351,
-0.0148224663,
-0.0439901203,
-0.0681280643,
-0.010027702,
0.0474515222,
-0.0431341678,
-0.0111829918,
-0.0305118877,
0.0714077726,
-0.0033666289,
0.0112244198,
-0.0088580977,
0.0361372717,
-0.0055533606,
-0.0242771339,
0.0334045365,
0.0347011797,
0.0253939312,
0.0187240597,
0.0626195818,
0.0450997651,
0.0423334762,
-0.0787478685,
0.0370209031,
0.0168716945,
0.0159846228,
-0.003860675,
0.0390943289,
0.0567526482,
-0.0175350849,
0.038472414,
0.0357999988,
-0.0286726821,
-0.0515893102,
-0.0165996943,
-0.1084307358,
-0.0491178557,
-0.0244205464,
0.0016160278,
-0.0332385674,
-0.0069386843,
0.0411506146,
-0.0359020233,
0.0299449582,
-0.0611151718,
-0.0059914365,
0.0018309386,
-0.0645745546,
0.0404877365,
-0.0535048656,
0.0426555723,
-0.0194476321,
-0.0139440941,
0.0591325238,
-0.0315753818,
0.0129098948,
0.0041842759,
-0.0681425929,
-0.0380562656,
-0.0723082423,
0.004004688,
0.037326254,
-0.0005246421,
-0.0118002528,
0.0725682378,
0.0138026066,
-0.0293098204,
-0.0449881777,
-0.0153576024,
0.0202699564,
0.0517307669,
0.0247419327,
0.0354670286,
0.0517585389,
-0.0103694582,
-0.0562894233,
-0.0018186673,
-0.0249674842,
0.0285921674,
0.049410563,
0.0362632088,
-0.0835250169,
-0.0121503649,
-0.0246252045,
-0.0373540558,
-0.0389190353,
-0.0386901125,
0.0041951127,
-0.0160729215,
-0.048424013,
0.0236961953,
0.0276817139,
-0.0624184087,
0.0104192821,
0.029492531,
0.0131287556,
-0.0111892829,
0.0340337716,
-0.0055603106,
0.0153928725,
-0.0169532634,
0.0142266816,
-0.0030493129,
0.0282565467,
0.0145261995,
0.0442643873,
-0.0047263955,
0.0068331216,
-0.0495230891,
-0.0332476571,
-0.0709569454,
-0.0086103557,
0.0404594727,
0.0644602031,
-0.0029157503,
-0.0256404728,
0.0239651185,
0.0128322523,
0.0132819433,
0.0173427444,
0.0282494947,
-0.004546192,
0.0093125058,
-0.0162855703,
-0.0496921539,
-0.0449061878,
-0.0093756262,
0.0490247011,
-0.0578158498,
-0.0077012288,
0.0076355375,
2.403e-7,
0.0414722972,
0.0099977925,
0.0069885193,
0.0271519255,
0.0079989005,
0.0361690894,
0.0028120012,
0.0503279306,
-0.0845511034,
-0.0325169265,
0.0237118732,
0.0502511151,
0.0274644494,
0.0113210706,
-0.0259246808,
0.0415567458,
-0.0124154501,
0.0380410515,
0.0056324806,
0.0035072796,
0.0905218944,
0.1224388555,
0.0206187945,
0.0044507999,
0.0634419173,
-0.0025250688,
0.0327195749,
-0.0142378761,
0.0455302969,
-0.0069973855,
0.0237468835,
0.0102228513,
0.0302996226,
-0.0174657777,
-0.0369878523,
0.0553542003,
0.0323491767,
0.0479042754,
-0.0266795382,
-0.0183863696,
-0.0275852885,
-0.0108954916,
0.0401001498,
-0.0148431193,
0.0639551058,
-0.0586872809,
-0.0607460663,
-0.005600533,
0.0227574985,
0.0190864969,
0.0426775217,
-0.0051217321,
-0.0033866225,
0.019892443,
0.0336963274,
-0.0613534935,
-0.009252849,
-0.0794394612,
0.0151811941,
-0.0004270809,
-0.0647782832,
0.021288611,
-0.0532400124,
-0.0071142842,
0.0871073827,
0.0185134448,
-0.0120594148,
1.738455815e-34,
-0.0064341757,
0.0140091218,
-0.0080489889,
0.0275243334,
0.0201896913,
-0.0166797396,
0.0201476086,
-0.0015795004,
0.0547938421,
-0.0537243821,
-0.0181148089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14122v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14122v3 | Chain-of-Thought Prompt Distillation for Multimodal Named Entity Recognition and Multimodal Relation Extraction | 2023-06-25T04:33:56 | 2023-08-23T05:04:58 | Feng Chen, Yujian Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Multimodal Named Entity Recognition (MNER) and Multimodal Relation Extraction
(MRE) necessitate the fundamental reasoning capacity for intricate linguistic
and multimodal comprehension. In this study, we explore distilling the
reasoning ability of large language models (LLMs) into a more compact student
model by generating a \textit{chain of thought} (CoT) -- a sequence of
intermediate reasoning steps. Specifically, we commence by exemplifying the
elicitation of such reasoning ability from LLMs through CoT prompts covering
multi-grain (noun, sentence, multimodality) and data-augmentation (style,
entity, image) dimensions. Subsequently, we present a novel conditional prompt
distillation method to assimilate the commonsense reasoning ability from LLMs,
thereby enhancing the utility of the student model in addressing text-only
inputs without the requisite addition of image and CoT knowledge. Extensive
experiments reveal that our approach attains state-of-the-art accuracy and
manifests a plethora of advantages concerning interpretability, data
efficiency, and cross-domain generalization on MNER and MRE datasets. | [
0.0425538495,
0.0431128666,
0.0030102492,
0.0585863553,
-0.0272385776,
0.0448754728,
0.0445957072,
-0.0127619542,
0.0076859929,
-0.0579383932,
0.0034799799,
-0.0327179804,
-0.0118762571,
0.0008661288,
0.0264060032,
-0.075764969,
0.0239159074,
-0.0611829646,
-0.0069950186,
0.008402816,
0.0219660774,
0.0354061611,
-0.043559406,
0.0112607842,
-0.0262639076,
-0.0297189541,
-0.0253928434,
0.0227619596,
0.0325727798,
-0.059462063,
-0.0280130729,
0.0628979132,
0.0550339781,
0.0142861409,
0.0000021415,
-0.0706971362,
-0.0334768593,
-0.0060695661,
-0.0039000467,
-0.0410377085,
0.0037392338,
-0.0120294839,
0.0376478508,
-0.0275422093,
-0.0009089689,
-0.0114783831,
0.0300253239,
0.0516469106,
0.0690279901,
0.0366846062,
-0.0203313548,
-0.0637434795,
0.0221886933,
0.0109761637,
0.0180955082,
-0.0396698564,
0.0122877676,
0.0176800136,
0.0184932109,
0.0218768902,
-0.0388816334,
0.0448560007,
0.0191702694,
0.0069934707,
-0.00438909,
0.0432396792,
0.0119618196,
-0.0348416939,
-0.0249839053,
0.1266180575,
0.0095279301,
0.0241134837,
0.0143753439,
0.0120283347,
0.0053054336,
0.0561845526,
-0.0435613021,
0.038731318,
-0.0367030725,
-0.0019985908,
-0.0326665454,
-0.0018945625,
0.0025966263,
0.0081065735,
-0.0354598761,
0.0307358913,
0.0001255505,
-0.0211403016,
0.0322246104,
0.0250555892,
-0.0318825431,
-0.0322092958,
0.0046691895,
0.0365534164,
-0.0057447753,
0.0299935304,
-0.0107017308,
-0.0387728028,
-0.0178163704,
0.0116047757,
0.0170169082,
0.0153904045,
-0.0625965819,
0.0729368553,
-0.0441635512,
0.0093882205,
-0.021275552,
0.0381635688,
-0.0110608554,
-0.0099147633,
-0.07972157,
0.0055418508,
-0.0221035015,
0.0269596912,
-0.0570648387,
-0.0325733833,
0.0153075894,
0.0066357125,
0.0082757948,
0.0222471822,
0.0355866775,
0.0073542767,
0.0121881999,
-0.0063554063,
-0.069816865,
0.063770622,
-0.0419806167,
-0.001361703,
0.0222526137,
-0.0129382862,
0.008545327,
-0.0270644613,
0.0362818502,
-0.0531917177,
0.0135401236,
0.0810170099,
-0.034682855,
-0.0528144725,
-0.0422119275,
-0.0438198484,
0.0017646983,
-0.0642141104,
0.0382701308,
-0.0522654243,
0.0641000345,
0.0209793244,
0.0183767006,
-0.0128354998,
0.0136082135,
0.0119978199,
-0.0462321155,
0.0964179933,
-0.032560125,
0.0067600259,
0.0092077171,
0.0261942651,
-0.0057956534,
0.0761695504,
0.0247718282,
0.0244931467,
0.0600413345,
0.0058303918,
-0.0229727402,
0.0291391853,
0.0013164378,
-0.0221887939,
0.00098369,
-0.0118591823,
0.0086597688,
0.0072894553,
0.0494682863,
0.0321516953,
-0.0138669377,
-0.0017270381,
0.0560055859,
0.0314707346,
-0.009941767,
-0.0111828977,
0.0593644679,
-0.0133060385,
0.014698714,
0.0401399955,
-0.0523956046,
0.0432525538,
-0.0114835668,
-0.000037687,
0.0316610262,
0.0660211965,
-0.013051426,
0.0087249102,
0.0251025762,
0.0036739311,
-0.0017391646,
0.0342510939,
0.0380845815,
0.022325445,
-0.0545443855,
0.0600553676,
0.0422964096,
-0.0537954308,
-0.013788796,
0.0058580842,
0.0098572755,
0.0642827302,
0.0268245842,
-0.0102060176,
0.0035496256,
-0.0211038385,
0.034382496,
0.0296786539,
-0.0285515059,
-0.0124773839,
0.0403974503,
-0.060456764,
-0.046501454,
0.0165183023,
-0.0078113307,
0.0118805859,
-0.0189864766,
-0.0004547862,
-0.0003453218,
-0.0174961686,
0.0159929004,
0.0230013411,
0.0128694205,
-0.0124111604,
-0.0369848572,
0.0605049133,
-0.0006071388,
0.0332219638,
-0.004571286,
-0.0285713691,
-0.0238025151,
-0.0524057597,
0.0055014314,
0.0033710641,
-0.0341014899,
-0.0939988792,
-0.0023816146,
-0.0461611263,
-0.0496149212,
-0.018643856,
-0.0556928664,
-0.0491026826,
-0.0463562123,
0.0041364748,
0.0041896594,
-0.0366885848,
-0.0128196729,
0.0362765752,
0.014984875,
-0.017609084,
0.0962922722,
-0.0327556543,
0.0038976884,
0.0164931454,
-0.01191922,
-0.005467338,
-0.0095209247,
-0.0364939235,
0.0146297887,
0.0038982211,
-0.0164051615,
-0.006718907,
0.0125521924,
-0.0346624032,
0.0087865489,
-0.0752649233,
-0.0272338297,
0.0036742692,
0.0022809999,
-0.0035159274,
0.0221041832,
-0.0075703389,
-0.021062322,
-0.0182277337,
0.0180658549,
-0.0052968357,
0.0255399458,
0.0441647843,
0.0122826463,
-0.0141382357,
0.0126600014,
-0.0151430639,
-0.0325917155,
0.1062983647,
-0.0017208483,
-0.0228757598,
-0.0127276871,
0.0265885182,
-0.0640732944,
0.0168996397,
0.003403781,
-0.0028179861,
0.0284837727,
-0.026926076,
0.047041174,
0.0499176122,
-0.0034099203,
0.0185496118,
0.021561889,
-0.0342688672,
-0.0221031792,
0.0335432105,
0.0067966646,
0.0096450262,
0.0119730709,
-0.0423156954,
-0.0206918512,
0.0742369965,
0.0032982978,
0.0050727441,
-0.0518510975,
0.0072596269,
0.0625251085,
-0.0070283893,
-0.0703378692,
0.0312667303,
0.0203549527,
0.0644445121,
-0.0318375826,
0.0016284405,
0.0872214064,
-0.0544965677,
-0.0128147043,
0.0036369832,
0.0257580709,
-0.0339225382,
0.0889629424,
0.0092467349,
0.0253634024,
0.0247224998,
-0.0120005198,
-0.0602096021,
0.0080788704,
0.0363491699,
-0.0009222802,
0.0243457798,
-0.0435316674,
0.0081190607,
-0.0132991429,
-0.0113501037,
-0.0279962104,
-0.0287087224,
-0.0434012227,
-0.0213902909,
-0.0325037986,
0.017753059,
0.017392436,
0.0283991843,
0.0311683062,
0.0214415099,
0.0008028087,
-0.0112291882,
-0.0437245779,
0.0876333117,
0.0486735851,
0.0276653431,
-0.0099789314,
-0.0267830174,
0.0463243052,
0.0271129832,
0.0070749787,
-0.0290935002,
-0.0165824443,
0.0462975204,
0.0030065107,
0.0022540661,
-0.0053237728,
0.0138818976,
0.0563645251,
-0.0626022592,
0.0042529921,
0.0802815259,
0.0045919241,
-0.0254152976,
-0.0194796994,
0.0362153873,
0.0343944281,
0.0201126002,
0.0039369911,
-0.0939217284,
-0.070841603,
0.0024272467,
-0.0234943572,
0.0043570944,
-0.07727734,
-0.0141915008,
-0.1059104502,
0.0113536976,
-0.0469496027,
-0.0501155891,
-0.0026714117,
-0.0368939824,
0.0089341709,
0.0309778675,
-0.0379643105,
0.0176389888,
0.0001899653,
0.0075470591,
-0.006919493,
0.0470819212,
-0.0528509393,
0.038897384,
-0.0387305878,
0.0061360612,
0.0221964139,
0.0100491308,
0.0201508794,
-0.0706902295,
0.0192210879,
-0.0237006135,
0.0099668996,
-0.0209326409,
0.0344573632,
-0.0338076353,
-0.0242604371,
-0.034405265,
0.0368303359,
0.0008165943,
-0.0294347908,
0.0079246378,
0.0904092118,
-0.0025807791,
-0.0063899197,
-0.0377257504,
0.0018813371,
0.0116044981,
0.0794814602,
0.0357047655,
-0.0413322374,
-0.0298848711,
-0.0106618041,
-0.0071090213,
-0.0320379287,
0.0061899889,
0.0156048564,
-0.0193407107,
0.0179344025,
-0.0444143116,
-0.0112546235,
0.0271053817,
0.076056473,
0.0040633171,
0.005445268,
0.0289986953,
0.0571480729,
-0.0436633863,
0.0558277257,
-0.0083333673,
0.0083241807,
-0.0278781876,
0.0175006334,
-0.0168919191,
-0.0303152967,
-0.0450018458,
0.0162181985,
-0.0747250542,
-0.0191272423,
-0.0531001166,
0.0484579355,
0.0192344561,
0.009871725,
0.0299331807,
-0.0427192748,
0.0281211343,
0.0549181104,
-0.024736084,
-0.0165289231,
-0.0016332903,
0.0362909473,
-0.002950751,
0.0288890228,
-0.0351242684,
0.0230989177,
0.0003405635,
0.0769589841,
-0.0060536079,
-0.0240968969,
-0.012140085,
0.0254525151,
0.0537913255,
-0.0234694593,
0.0012281971,
-0.0483935401,
0.008670304,
0.0068597505,
-0.0149059901,
-0.0569903478,
0.0306430012,
0.0003472565,
-0.0067743436,
0.0041764621,
-0.0319511332,
0.0131850056,
0.0323567837,
-0.0319185667,
-0.0015429603,
0.036237631,
0.0293785818,
0.0022492355,
-0.0408554785,
0.0002400685,
0.0247835852,
0.0030341181,
0.0085553043,
-0.0213890802,
0.1262000203,
0.032958921,
-0.0276126023,
-0.0397531465,
0.030045975,
-0.0512921177,
0.0236948803,
-0.0019789569,
0.0627211258,
0.0315029174,
0.023279693,
-0.0021943757,
-0.0014874459,
-0.0140120611,
0.0337652676,
0.0562373959,
0.0214282349,
-0.0399583504,
0.0594238974,
0.0242360644,
0.0122367116,
-0.0044250418,
0.0664576441,
-0.0437126309,
0.0061774151,
0.0212471951,
-0.0070341593,
-0.0472192876,
-0.0443121828,
-0.0034043281,
0.0287507474,
0.0117015708,
0.0344070159,
-0.0650051013,
-0.078210935,
-0.0106913447,
-0.006427553,
-0.0223060977,
0.0177108552,
0.0235921293,
0.0346200876,
0.0333003178,
-0.0377482921,
-0.0153423036,
0.0137823941,
-0.0167362448,
-0.0305600744,
0.008553477,
-6.495534194e-33,
-0.0367194787,
-0.0362596624,
0.0260351561,
-0.0255483463,
-0.0151745081,
0.0277480092,
-0.0437425636,
-0.0139235891,
-0.0002132364,
0.0073929699,
-0.009219042,
-0.0397242978,
0.0026428264,
0.04727621,
-0.018393483,
-0.0105473017,
0.0195957702,
0.0131818512,
-0.0233741105,
0.0064210966,
0.0619160943,
0.0582846887,
0.0451897644,
-0.0364515707,
0.0421076156,
0.0019996781,
-0.0139579158,
0.0321603529,
0.0214932747,
0.043410901,
-0.0375427939,
0.0302506723,
0.0202912334,
-0.0685614273,
0.0091028493,
0.0481396802,
-0.1562148482,
-0.0192663539,
0.0409874097,
-0.003355219,
-0.0697051883,
-0.004841221,
0.0140965786,
-0.0302567817,
0.0498997569,
-0.044299975,
0.0405753329,
-0.0137475533,
0.0326549821,
-0.0250885319,
-0.028500719,
0.0011252026,
-0.0223278422,
-0.0345119461,
0.0235086195,
0.040940471,
0.0122609967,
0.0142376088,
-0.0479627438,
0.0096726194,
-0.002191382,
-0.0393902846,
0.0679062083,
0.0171152838,
-0.0173562653,
0.0600363873,
-0.0179154817,
-0.0282234997,
-0.0760154873,
0.0251348205,
0.0130232349,
0.0595068038,
-0.013277553,
0.0729355291,
0.0182102844,
0.0106909117,
-0.0698724613,
0.0201593116,
0.0009950437,
0.0365134999,
0.0162405632,
-0.0267256647,
-0.0055227084,
-0.019611977,
-0.0366107747,
-0.0516537428,
-0.0448039435,
-0.0103316708,
0.0300295688,
-0.0198139716,
-0.0612317696,
0.0177782793,
0.0805441663,
-0.0271571502,
-0.0614151508,
0.020355558,
0.0029347504,
0.0334152244,
0.0151576251,
0.0090993838,
-0.0137258982,
-0.0205502454,
0.0610767305,
-0.0167286713,
0.0271825567,
0.0077003841,
0.0491862781,
-0.0064625363,
-0.0223317258,
-0.0249120202,
-0.0503983311,
0.0156815872,
-0.0513103902,
0.0246108957,
0.0292633269,
0.0065108021,
-0.0564638935,
0.0175473541,
0.0072501879,
-0.0112251239,
-0.0313320421,
0.0057920036,
-0.0076168892,
0.0334582925,
-0.011343088,
0.0098842466,
-0.0017273864,
-0.0554744452,
0.0226093028,
-0.0664684474,
0.001760778,
0.061718706,
2.847e-7,
0.009938159,
0.0269517414,
-0.0121978521,
-0.0025481847,
0.0164009612,
0.0301433392,
0.0033632426,
0.0307150073,
-0.0006506242,
-0.1056294441,
-0.0171113499,
0.0354336724,
0.0289250892,
0.0169017501,
-0.0555181317,
-0.0440986641,
-0.0108500998,
-0.0313675366,
-0.0858348757,
0.0338319764,
0.0817848444,
0.0274472199,
-0.0080793696,
-0.0525812507,
0.0038904364,
-0.0033051136,
0.0480372757,
-0.0118710771,
0.0263190586,
-0.0140765291,
0.0358834416,
-0.0285272151,
0.0055047045,
0.061382968,
0.0277074352,
-0.0069264718,
0.0394672751,
0.0338528231,
0.023171166,
-0.01732127,
-0.0170912948,
-0.0262238793,
-0.0196032878,
-0.0814165026,
0.1052796841,
-0.0347835422,
-0.0288809109,
-0.0125603825,
-0.0352765918,
-0.0427986532,
-0.0140754189,
0.0060799574,
-0.0104050888,
0.0444638357,
0.0251497366,
-0.0399067551,
-0.0152053265,
-0.0934648365,
-0.0033541846,
0.0170090012,
-0.0076421495,
-0.0282724071,
-0.024577694,
-0.0696898401,
0.024302464,
-0.0842093751,
-0.0330794044,
2.499634554e-34,
-0.0102722785,
-0.0141694341,
0.0128333811,
-0.0042354269,
0.0384656116,
-0.019975137,
-0.0590214431,
-0.0189555418,
-0.0078754323,
-0.1031898409,
-0.0137217697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14115v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14115v2 | Towards Trustworthy Explanation: On Causal Rationalization | 2023-06-25T03:34:06 | 2023-09-09T03:50:04 | Wenbo Zhang, Tong Wu, Yunlong Wang, Yong Cai, Hengrui Cai | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ME, stat.ML | With recent advances in natural language processing, rationalization becomes
an essential self-explaining diagram to disentangle the black box by selecting
a subset of input texts to account for the major variation in prediction. Yet,
existing association-based approaches on rationalization cannot identify true
rationales when two or more snippets are highly inter-correlated and thus
provide a similar contribution to prediction accuracy, so-called spuriousness.
To address this limitation, we novelly leverage two causal desiderata,
non-spuriousness and efficiency, into rationalization from the causal inference
perspective. We formally define a series of probabilities of causation based on
a newly proposed structural causal model of rationalization, with its
theoretical identification established as the main component of learning
necessary and sufficient rationales. The superior performance of the proposed
causal rationalization is demonstrated on real-world review and medical
datasets with extensive experiments compared to state-of-the-art methods. | [
0.0051708468,
0.0732892677,
-0.0162298325,
-0.0047240499,
0.0017181772,
0.0197193921,
0.0256432462,
0.0173298083,
-0.0092289215,
-0.0043914518,
0.0546568446,
0.0166390911,
0.0253333338,
0.0393258408,
0.0054265447,
-0.0405201539,
0.0394316092,
-0.0021665562,
0.0461185277,
0.0027857036,
0.0001522859,
0.0266429558,
-0.0053408812,
0.0479402132,
0.0316279642,
-0.0035031107,
0.0357379094,
-0.0222351737,
-0.0124362968,
-0.0319903828,
-0.0403939635,
0.0426298678,
-0.0094097201,
0.0178147554,
0.0000021112,
-0.0446299426,
-0.0348471068,
-0.006490943,
-0.0499645472,
-0.0025647823,
-0.0530666076,
-0.013853821,
0.0361444056,
0.0107630221,
-0.0176234171,
0.0454649366,
0.030790735,
0.0765653774,
0.0005800322,
0.0608154461,
-0.0081602149,
-0.0302094482,
-0.0021879999,
-0.0091153765,
-0.0015682774,
0.0075013023,
0.0172037855,
0.0044310461,
-0.0308056492,
-0.0081556318,
-0.0007611122,
-0.0276438724,
0.0060843346,
-0.0198474731,
0.0511820801,
0.0203054436,
0.0495753922,
-0.0237274673,
0.0492721647,
0.0546275191,
0.0370923541,
-0.0533128045,
0.04756549,
-0.0259688627,
-0.0057517937,
0.0843665972,
-0.0517390445,
0.0112263747,
-0.0179177336,
0.0334985517,
0.075705938,
0.0277678724,
0.0649418458,
0.0383274257,
-0.0240393281,
0.0538095757,
-0.0231225453,
-0.0014296005,
-0.024492776,
0.0134451967,
-0.0179155115,
-0.0584106706,
-0.038342271,
0.0262439661,
-0.0334564075,
0.0292687397,
0.0188043248,
0.0108653177,
0.0331716612,
-0.00285531,
-0.0482847616,
-0.0218523834,
0.0420807451,
0.0329771638,
-0.0104465205,
0.0217798296,
-0.0222307052,
0.0585921034,
-0.0123313377,
0.0348240063,
-0.0396808907,
-0.01274407,
0.0208095741,
0.0023378574,
-0.0493357778,
0.018411912,
-0.0466262586,
-0.00200274,
-0.0387609527,
-0.0124257701,
0.0158045441,
0.0487120599,
-0.0111181056,
-0.0241772551,
-0.0580259822,
-0.0210945476,
-0.0525809266,
0.0642809644,
-0.0169308744,
0.0128249452,
-0.0146343634,
0.0165619645,
0.0216604527,
-0.015930254,
-0.0415380076,
0.0470944121,
0.008316963,
-0.013544539,
-0.0599397272,
-0.0886205286,
-0.0198282525,
-0.024261754,
-0.0220674071,
-0.0068574161,
-0.0424432121,
0.0029059285,
0.0051296651,
-0.0441573709,
-0.0167017467,
-0.0019691701,
-0.0840827376,
0.0796054974,
-0.0590717196,
-0.0153829865,
-0.0340823792,
0.025423836,
-0.0356958061,
0.0430750772,
0.0253597107,
0.0088254791,
0.0412427336,
-0.0258901231,
0.017326748,
-0.0543252937,
0.039735008,
0.0076113525,
-0.0076717562,
-0.0182813331,
-0.0546500906,
-0.01916481,
-0.002716772,
-0.0026812169,
-0.0169533323,
0.0061265924,
0.0346050672,
0.0517652929,
0.0039524692,
0.0182767808,
0.018821016,
-0.0212359764,
-0.0120287612,
0.0543077178,
-0.0477907173,
0.0196630172,
-0.0445524603,
-0.0170388818,
-0.0085976087,
-0.035498552,
-0.0042343917,
-0.0551697873,
0.000117446,
-0.0083055189,
0.0216618981,
-0.0215077326,
0.0386932753,
0.0153768025,
-0.0223454256,
-0.012101341,
0.0324351378,
-0.0291616879,
0.0163938105,
-0.0183132887,
0.0446219519,
0.0594902262,
0.0539510809,
-0.0131982928,
0.0126378667,
-0.0366653949,
-0.0008356386,
-0.0367274918,
-0.0221338794,
-0.0366119072,
-0.0072853724,
-0.0249198489,
-0.0412561595,
-0.0073321317,
0.0539300926,
-0.0163914636,
-0.0073637501,
-0.0125004984,
-0.0165408384,
-0.0363727696,
-0.0111354422,
0.0376751572,
-0.0163622405,
-0.0245936159,
-0.0094547439,
0.0181149635,
0.0579164438,
0.04278519,
0.0010232057,
0.0328202955,
0.0230492726,
-0.0210605431,
-0.0538191274,
0.0752912462,
-0.0258732047,
0.0128456876,
-0.014490867,
-0.0355306342,
-0.0072306157,
-0.0122584049,
-0.0177681763,
-0.0774701461,
0.0517965667,
-0.0161475167,
-0.0024021841,
-0.0125631103,
0.0061878781,
0.0006420517,
0.0056595095,
-0.0317361541,
0.0750281662,
0.0235916674,
0.012385672,
0.0083593549,
-0.0166971814,
0.0472903848,
-0.0057829679,
0.0491333716,
0.0100361444,
-0.0162623711,
-0.0259260722,
0.0438880697,
-0.0732019842,
-0.0346978381,
0.0326555595,
-0.0109389909,
-0.0299474336,
-0.0109881451,
-0.0060637118,
0.0193826929,
-0.0192332938,
0.0237737,
-0.0134151308,
0.0317269675,
-0.0159045346,
0.0048325448,
0.0330868438,
0.0548989326,
-0.0245855004,
0.0015574049,
-0.0315349177,
0.0059797158,
-0.0502188168,
0.0540911444,
0.0576740503,
0.0067409002,
-0.0471116751,
-0.000686121,
0.00824642,
-0.0145457191,
-0.0143803749,
-0.0286660716,
-0.0008005766,
0.0103016468,
-0.03581395,
0.0374326706,
0.0079837767,
0.0168919414,
0.0358393863,
0.0227070991,
-0.040314354,
-0.0278244745,
-0.0521175936,
0.0531409197,
-0.0314086005,
-0.0527316965,
0.0127701303,
0.0803649575,
0.0122350333,
-0.01429985,
-0.0641907379,
0.0298659243,
-0.0157493129,
-0.0082665877,
-0.0345428772,
-0.1180611327,
0.0053398232,
0.1092467532,
-0.026747752,
-0.0844883844,
0.0730495378,
-0.0101382975,
0.0532725416,
-0.0358169787,
-0.0195459742,
-0.0119290557,
0.055254586,
-0.0048010279,
-0.0011553998,
0.0730948672,
-0.0157715902,
-0.0181848798,
-0.0614540242,
0.0562597886,
0.0244619381,
0.0585148558,
-0.0841661766,
0.0229215324,
0.0369038321,
-0.0351688564,
-0.0358747467,
-0.0586299524,
-0.0310493447,
-0.025716804,
0.0130589195,
-0.0323799029,
0.002909905,
-0.0100161005,
0.0123309745,
0.0257900953,
-0.0149805965,
0.0042030783,
0.0038078593,
-0.0079432866,
0.0244181585,
-0.0363345779,
0.050455749,
-0.0183475446,
0.0473069698,
0.0277028792,
0.0096145039,
-0.0032705211,
-0.0261408295,
-0.0004690422,
-0.0387943946,
-0.0363133661,
-0.0218021702,
0.0077430662,
0.0314762592,
-0.0188728496,
0.0275548659,
0.0924280658,
0.0199381467,
-0.0112222191,
0.0191913713,
0.0205736868,
-0.0102449981,
0.013528415,
-0.0413345844,
-0.0401390456,
-0.0202381779,
0.0015084182,
0.0185254291,
-0.0175974071,
-0.0543169677,
0.0237109065,
-0.0516473167,
0.0453133024,
-0.0084483512,
0.0058983285,
-0.0129615637,
-0.0903676748,
-0.0165421534,
-0.0634990633,
-0.0414095633,
-0.0125489878,
0.0097958446,
0.0302967951,
0.0326087885,
-0.0551920719,
-0.0286097061,
-0.0115943039,
0.0038944206,
0.0346556231,
0.0118757682,
0.0417113304,
-0.0003088603,
-0.0267881956,
-0.0186338797,
-0.0145081086,
0.0212331843,
-0.0209100991,
0.1162350774,
0.0657204613,
0.0052908049,
-0.0230984483,
0.045627851,
-0.0109760892,
-0.0525574051,
-0.0246627536,
0.0838359371,
-0.0355285779,
-0.0226671211,
-0.0194091871,
0.0076528038,
-0.0288316309,
0.0628742948,
0.0167030953,
0.029042365,
-0.03889893,
-0.0008292917,
0.0055041476,
-0.0473496318,
-0.0072116968,
-0.0092517305,
0.0064886706,
-0.0484722517,
-0.0687503442,
-0.0216064733,
-0.0174305979,
0.0091338726,
0.0049989182,
0.0593880937,
0.0088104568,
-0.0414671898,
-0.014924759,
0.0433635674,
0.0082187718,
-0.0003082687,
0.0479770601,
0.0237019956,
0.0027665549,
-0.0364558585,
-0.0035520382,
-0.0170819219,
0.0314170606,
-0.0355077311,
-0.0202600993,
-0.0042019049,
0.0297120977,
0.0737703443,
-0.0359686613,
-0.0615715347,
-0.0013969054,
-0.0247837696,
-0.0054825852,
-0.0346648097,
0.0377237499,
-0.0046108188,
0.0019717794,
0.0346925743,
-0.0120774154,
0.0198786519,
-0.0230326075,
0.0110997017,
-0.0568774268,
0.0320587419,
0.0298338644,
-0.0005973532,
0.0709354356,
-0.0231357198,
0.0391941145,
-0.0529394336,
-0.0002647224,
-0.0205241684,
-0.0139316982,
0.0104768118,
0.0582793131,
0.0252727009,
-0.0111935493,
-0.0331091657,
-0.0778160542,
-0.0631172433,
-0.0054714452,
-0.0033057942,
0.0420573577,
0.0060288375,
0.0106533859,
0.0147405351,
0.0083940839,
0.0309378244,
0.0029127426,
-0.0009593047,
0.047753416,
-0.0003610276,
0.03313094,
0.0135005899,
0.0239890218,
-0.0334501714,
-0.052722577,
-0.1035169363,
-0.0325457975,
0.0394327566,
-0.0443870649,
0.0202858187,
-0.0551931597,
0.0789797455,
0.0022343879,
0.0007978149,
0.0300383177,
0.0616132915,
0.0458593145,
0.0168125629,
0.0168002658,
0.014093902,
-0.0474520661,
0.0221736543,
0.0717532784,
-0.0174019895,
0.0296007544,
-0.035009563,
-0.0531771295,
-0.0047070794,
-0.0757299364,
-0.0180497561,
0.0615895875,
-0.0257944055,
-0.015767267,
-0.0750450119,
-0.0472814366,
-0.0065884101,
-0.0182655323,
0.0264436621,
-0.010267945,
-0.0049250391,
0.0530785695,
0.0037966315,
-0.0208203513,
-0.0326846689,
0.0144236907,
-0.0071032741,
-0.0090767434,
-0.0130073698,
-6.529273086e-33,
0.028474316,
-0.063225165,
-0.0161368251,
-0.0215182155,
0.0435814671,
0.0334908366,
-0.0374575406,
-0.0276313704,
-0.0201034714,
0.0709862188,
-0.0162340067,
0.0489313789,
0.0199491419,
-0.0031974681,
0.017983567,
-0.0132466331,
0.0396534987,
0.0233250838,
-0.0040653753,
0.0192734413,
0.05975933,
0.0074251047,
0.0397088602,
-0.1093123704,
0.0856811777,
0.0383013301,
-0.0307423249,
0.0149887875,
-0.0242822617,
0.0545013137,
0.0193718001,
0.0230165347,
0.0351371244,
-0.0541597791,
0.0128516806,
0.0012745761,
-0.084420599,
-0.0337958671,
0.0603910573,
-0.0383544825,
-0.0611997619,
-0.0309600234,
0.0285355709,
0.0000539138,
-0.0092517408,
0.0031753331,
0.056768328,
-0.0194894932,
-0.0258857701,
-0.010524367,
-0.0390521958,
0.0383779928,
-0.0492805839,
0.0323418118,
-0.0082180118,
0.0189973637,
-0.0027176151,
0.0374167934,
-0.0082819862,
0.0207713023,
0.0086119715,
-0.0007178707,
0.0213464089,
-0.0182671435,
-0.0268171802,
0.0946203619,
-0.0187972542,
0.0080249468,
-0.0599736869,
0.0369677171,
-0.047025647,
0.0454805121,
0.0915701091,
0.0565545969,
0.0668955669,
-0.0048879376,
-0.1308656186,
0.0239255149,
-0.0024467206,
0.0120854676,
0.0264681429,
-0.0163752772,
-0.0576278269,
-0.0294248704,
-0.0480942391,
-0.0071343603,
-0.0247224644,
-0.0094540678,
-0.0188515317,
0.0132923536,
-0.0454968773,
0.004076174,
-0.0118740397,
-0.0550315119,
0.0063601909,
0.0405460298,
0.0092732562,
-0.0331404582,
0.0117971385,
-0.0442101248,
-0.0307077486,
0.003293168,
0.0053073722,
0.0247406587,
0.0584478825,
0.0261504874,
0.0596397892,
-0.0452029258,
-0.0280006975,
-0.004259076,
-0.0330660529,
-0.0384650379,
-0.0121921292,
-0.031503737,
0.0435275361,
0.0483138002,
-0.021418795,
0.0338055603,
0.0377993733,
0.049588725,
-0.004400393,
-0.0188473985,
-0.0349367186,
0.0023084551,
0.0029272463,
-0.0573701635,
0.0157433264,
-0.0154878693,
0.0538347252,
-0.0782325491,
-0.018011542,
-0.0179810934,
2.834e-7,
0.0677489564,
0.0379661173,
0.0097722597,
-0.0257527158,
0.0378736593,
0.0378645174,
0.024631327,
-0.026241146,
-0.0088053895,
-0.0195658579,
0.0252590273,
-0.0062138708,
0.0137710515,
0.0310707726,
-0.0298576634,
-0.0396641716,
-0.0625693947,
-0.0413061231,
-0.0117092915,
0.0020505874,
0.0651559085,
0.0322512574,
0.0315153077,
-0.020025814,
0.0153582748,
-0.0221319087,
0.0009341816,
-0.0133375833,
0.021057738,
0.0183838997,
0.0241684411,
-0.0275483578,
-0.0028827807,
0.04711622,
-0.043621745,
0.0061872713,
-0.0426470712,
0.0254813544,
-0.0346315689,
0.0038340469,
-0.0297701322,
-0.0855125487,
0.0676073506,
-0.0341869481,
0.0798297673,
-0.0113571351,
-0.0564659461,
0.0317385942,
-0.0339521617,
-0.0042776782,
0.0292461365,
0.0333021171,
-0.0087603051,
0.0265508816,
-0.0369251817,
0.0309218373,
0.0004868762,
-0.0981711149,
-0.0446366556,
-0.0003566703,
0.0144870766,
-0.0019999836,
0.0242259093,
0.0096203908,
0.0482997298,
-0.0741240606,
0.0102236755,
2.666339398e-34,
0.0267963279,
0.0288994033,
0.0109103238,
-0.0039421455,
0.0627450049,
-0.0067310613,
-0.0159375034,
0.0066499021,
0.0513743199,
-0.0511360988,
-0.0024828846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14096v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14096v5 | Chinese Fine-Grained Financial Sentiment Analysis with Large Language Models | 2023-06-25T02:24:30 | 2023-09-15T08:19:44 | Yinyu Lan, Yanru Wu, Wang Xu, Weiqiang Feng, Youhao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Entity-level fine-grained sentiment analysis in the financial domain is a
crucial subtask of sentiment analysis and currently faces numerous challenges.
The primary challenge stems from the lack of high-quality and large-scale
annotated corpora specifically designed for financial text sentiment analysis,
which in turn limits the availability of data necessary for developing
effective text processing techniques. Recent advancements in large language
models (LLMs) have yielded remarkable performance in natural language
processing tasks, primarily centered around language pattern matching. In this
paper, we propose a novel and extensive Chinese fine-grained financial
sentiment analysis dataset, FinChina SA, for enterprise early warning. We
thoroughly evaluate and experiment with well-known existing open-source LLMs
using our dataset. We firmly believe that our dataset will serve as a valuable
resource to advance the exploration of real-world financial sentiment analysis
tasks, which should be the focus of future research. The FinChina SA dataset is
publicly available at https://github.com/YerayL/FinChina-SA | [
0.0309337899,
0.097673431,
0.0011623778,
0.0486466028,
-0.0002074754,
0.0061375382,
-0.0083486727,
0.0648925081,
0.0140831554,
-0.0472334847,
-0.0439643338,
-0.0274411999,
-0.0509220921,
0.040205434,
0.0145015465,
0.0083782384,
0.0182522293,
0.0294441525,
0.0619788989,
-0.0124999331,
0.068400912,
0.0405036546,
0.0629515722,
0.0291050952,
0.0175482146,
-0.011566204,
0.0363512971,
0.0194645952,
0.0290788207,
-0.0250600316,
0.0636210963,
-0.0003375369,
0.012088093,
0.0299621429,
0.0000018274,
-0.0378873535,
-0.0367610455,
-0.0009568753,
0.0223216433,
0.047744818,
0.0529904626,
-0.0760185048,
0.0194960702,
0.0102301212,
-0.0657667145,
-0.042265635,
0.0376146771,
0.1198175475,
0.0738942176,
0.0862582251,
-0.0357272811,
-0.0594195276,
-0.0033622279,
-0.0723716989,
-0.0182810165,
-0.0823351294,
0.0514880978,
0.0003784399,
-0.0247529596,
0.0017114705,
-0.0037650587,
-0.0074336529,
-0.0631278902,
0.0182295423,
-0.0318665802,
-0.0144084068,
-0.0326294601,
0.0243201498,
-0.0408832319,
0.0374689698,
0.0082869511,
0.0241916925,
0.0068666656,
-0.0237406492,
-0.0197315235,
0.0146337748,
-0.0039368398,
0.0197511408,
-0.015724875,
0.0489812605,
0.0396038406,
-0.0112489192,
0.00328709,
0.0318437368,
-0.0242939275,
0.024609888,
-0.0268472824,
-0.0490403771,
0.0092100836,
0.0213263351,
-0.0190860033,
-0.0343871862,
0.0042107641,
-0.0245927703,
0.0313936509,
-0.009591585,
-0.0305320788,
0.0042937803,
0.0115340874,
-0.0874751359,
-0.015334907,
0.0289107654,
-0.0046955012,
0.0523497052,
-0.0375475064,
-0.0234560873,
-0.0030391759,
-0.0366759486,
-0.0182049256,
-0.0159749296,
-0.0501036495,
0.0042461962,
-0.0429466106,
0.0642875209,
-0.017265778,
-0.0284624994,
-0.077463381,
-0.0131126745,
-0.036423672,
0.0420794077,
0.0021403951,
-0.0503720716,
0.027870059,
-0.0209031831,
-0.0290119983,
0.0287124291,
-0.0443979427,
0.0655072704,
-0.0574167371,
-0.0198839288,
0.005259858,
0.0457633808,
-0.0048539271,
-0.0215984099,
0.039008718,
0.0445781313,
0.0746531636,
-0.0317130722,
-0.0591623448,
-0.0211192239,
-0.0075901891,
-0.0183306038,
-0.0324063338,
-0.0191349797,
-0.0048091877,
-0.0314755365,
0.0149009842,
0.0341350175,
0.0210594032,
-0.0061622905,
-0.0262956433,
0.0642517209,
-0.0238714516,
-0.0271782726,
-0.0437634028,
-0.0378205664,
0.0257247668,
0.0626245439,
0.0021773996,
0.0285068825,
0.0490993485,
-0.0261033028,
-0.0403804518,
0.0601489693,
-0.0100490954,
-0.0299420319,
-0.0317566432,
0.0355975442,
-0.023349043,
-0.0405372865,
0.0543600731,
-0.0007636229,
-0.008913327,
-0.0082179168,
0.0493178368,
0.012624667,
-0.0062196166,
0.0319589451,
-0.0212382581,
0.0050031468,
-0.0173930898,
-0.0082261655,
0.0234073978,
-0.034029007,
-0.0682055354,
0.0148180835,
0.0011221884,
0.0168326367,
-0.0433742516,
-0.0342959426,
-0.0349048004,
-0.0012525143,
-0.0285486821,
-0.0097739641,
0.033634197,
-0.0407672115,
-0.0432709493,
0.0147006698,
0.0537152551,
-0.0430734977,
-0.0024198676,
-0.0118862046,
0.0388794765,
0.1179999635,
0.0021184587,
-0.0131137604,
0.0221207477,
0.0078635719,
-0.0176787414,
0.0389133096,
0.0458014533,
0.023550598,
-0.0574868396,
-0.072484538,
0.0041858885,
0.0502064005,
0.0115944454,
0.0009661355,
-0.0061720526,
0.0296603087,
-0.0207269173,
-0.0045036143,
-0.0425272211,
0.0285228696,
0.0554860607,
-0.0154170273,
0.0134290596,
-0.0256136078,
0.0178248957,
0.0099112494,
-0.0335987285,
-0.0027854184,
0.0197126139,
-0.026769422,
-0.0641329959,
-0.0001980226,
0.0037427766,
-0.0399223901,
-0.0137311639,
-0.0221689586,
-0.0114551242,
0.0344212428,
-0.0710328594,
-0.0080209561,
-0.0059305774,
0.0230455752,
0.0219171997,
-0.064682059,
-0.006142999,
0.0010438329,
0.0477944203,
-0.0016478597,
0.0821509957,
-0.0045604086,
0.01803427,
-0.0682400838,
-0.0098944502,
-0.0023498829,
-0.0238307677,
-0.0541613325,
-0.0093900319,
0.0212200861,
0.0413540341,
0.041664958,
0.0015962007,
0.0117767937,
-0.0297480021,
-0.0853480026,
0.001654311,
0.0070516733,
0.0346056111,
0.0128667075,
0.0179564767,
-0.0138970045,
0.0078963693,
-0.0195064712,
0.0273772702,
-0.0167554617,
0.0134827076,
0.0336361043,
-0.0130930822,
-0.0058269068,
-0.0272642989,
-0.008816191,
-0.0139915049,
0.0031853551,
0.0320295803,
-0.0848654583,
-0.0457067043,
0.0368167311,
-0.0100525199,
0.0335613973,
-0.0033836977,
-0.0067041675,
-0.0462165289,
-0.0154146533,
0.0035876925,
0.0291859321,
0.0225056261,
0.0426026918,
-0.0276300721,
0.0052483184,
-0.0154307969,
0.0201850943,
-0.0223213471,
0.006790698,
-0.0342610925,
-0.0158280227,
0.0001661643,
0.0415305346,
-0.0037915756,
-0.0232270565,
-0.0772983432,
0.007777533,
-0.0054810629,
0.0558277033,
-0.0026068226,
-0.024470849,
-0.001918964,
0.0010613886,
-0.0032584155,
-0.0283030365,
0.0584934577,
-0.0189731624,
-0.0035355203,
-0.0253012255,
-0.0353045203,
-0.0878412351,
0.0284014102,
-0.0354141146,
-0.0050789742,
-0.0038130356,
-0.0069079632,
0.0119999982,
-0.0160597414,
0.0094252406,
-0.015454662,
0.0318449438,
0.020833116,
0.0622524321,
-0.0127009507,
-0.0056873662,
0.0331322439,
-0.0691588521,
-0.0861522704,
0.024699444,
0.0544322915,
-0.0121007748,
-0.0378690101,
0.0512593761,
-0.0555171072,
-0.0351613685,
-0.0077017611,
-0.0060442029,
0.0035517504,
0.0042035254,
0.0602021441,
-0.0114747752,
0.0472780801,
-0.0303840954,
0.0271052886,
0.0505943075,
-0.0000135683,
0.0137805995,
-0.0133898398,
-0.0219934192,
0.0238569938,
-0.0100533152,
0.000620059,
-0.0296762753,
0.0094981426,
-0.0522189662,
0.0274732951,
0.108234264,
-0.0174800549,
-0.0100213829,
0.0072895605,
0.028712064,
0.0276888683,
-0.0027961885,
0.0060740528,
-0.0895211473,
-0.0593451113,
-0.0086148446,
0.0005858676,
0.0270468388,
-0.0405139774,
0.0134234866,
-0.1375872344,
0.0628655329,
-0.0035547749,
-0.0298913103,
-0.0402520373,
-0.023508681,
-0.0114786951,
-0.0512631461,
0.0029778832,
-0.049639415,
-0.0167285167,
0.0043116235,
0.0034284887,
-0.0698043779,
-0.0280875061,
0.0333733372,
-0.0368954204,
-0.012667452,
0.0450204536,
0.0362953357,
-0.0308963805,
-0.0102727525,
-0.0234422535,
-0.0395071208,
-0.0124697695,
0.0016440341,
0.0750417337,
-0.0436423086,
-0.0644997433,
0.0306397974,
0.0226090774,
-0.0584597848,
0.0658974722,
0.020452667,
-0.0174594149,
-0.0055440059,
-0.0226672087,
-0.0149207516,
0.0772352517,
0.0082252501,
0.0909266844,
-0.0207662433,
-0.0769230947,
-0.0053109122,
-0.000090565,
-0.0081198588,
-0.0250889715,
-0.0054243817,
0.0225811321,
-0.014749513,
0.0059666415,
-0.112155959,
-0.0395921543,
0.0383237675,
0.0118303103,
-0.0179238599,
0.0294337384,
0.0220979918,
-0.0003558553,
-0.0224981271,
0.0457134843,
-0.0262273569,
0.0267029293,
-0.029362062,
0.0103826402,
0.0163981281,
0.0123537946,
-0.0481706895,
0.0200531967,
-0.0606382526,
-0.0397305973,
-0.0122575555,
-0.0213826504,
0.0028968938,
-0.0257496443,
-0.0068298117,
0.0101538878,
0.0322775654,
0.0508344658,
-0.0556795672,
-0.0058387346,
0.0456951074,
0.0157859772,
0.0080750072,
0.0311660096,
-0.0386003405,
0.0229682159,
0.0035570743,
0.0342073701,
-0.0124946572,
-0.0401082151,
-0.0148463985,
0.021483276,
0.0297420453,
0.0323608369,
-0.0135735963,
-0.035396181,
0.0172818638,
0.023282133,
-0.033665441,
-0.0493113287,
-0.0371374637,
0.0308112912,
-0.0331518315,
-0.0383689553,
0.057530418,
-0.0016022471,
-0.0129435025,
-0.0401315875,
0.0528129004,
0.0056791524,
0.0303217284,
0.0171126258,
0.0047149705,
0.0059517231,
-0.0209163837,
0.0212827791,
-0.0246139411,
-0.022978941,
0.0011630405,
0.0353537351,
0.0381405093,
0.0066126012,
-0.0204157121,
-0.0167152919,
-0.0110831149,
-0.0098349312,
0.0255920459,
0.0184963234,
-0.0550572388,
0.0388122462,
-0.0566522889,
0.0220209956,
-0.0104507888,
0.0050127101,
-0.0254784636,
-0.0234584454,
0.0430414937,
-0.0098439083,
-0.061340984,
-0.0248659458,
0.1006672308,
-0.0075440682,
0.0851827487,
0.0112270666,
-0.0086754765,
-0.0220138915,
-0.0357964337,
0.1150740087,
0.0077011888,
-0.0002369473,
0.012786204,
-0.066852726,
-0.0408665128,
0.0324854441,
-0.0268632267,
-0.0328527428,
0.0113639571,
0.0130536761,
0.0439203344,
0.0211097822,
0.0654220879,
-0.0321722813,
-0.0123406267,
-0.0291735176,
-0.0105093447,
-0.0688187927,
-6.098927543e-33,
-0.0106976656,
-0.0018875491,
0.0046646143,
0.0199594777,
0.0267858002,
0.0313721485,
0.0238823239,
-0.0203805454,
-0.0161287189,
0.0309422184,
0.0197698995,
0.0383482277,
0.0052533387,
0.0307607483,
0.0111972699,
0.0143019836,
0.0233173054,
0.0019198015,
0.0355040729,
-0.0081190579,
0.0349017158,
0.0519822128,
0.0723569021,
-0.0627291203,
0.0344367065,
-0.0139640886,
-0.062669374,
-0.0125289606,
0.0343418904,
0.0397221819,
-0.0131479139,
0.0624527894,
0.0195223782,
-0.0281926394,
0.000275179,
0.0148392767,
-0.002743657,
-0.0131473076,
0.0231682379,
0.0116306003,
0.0346578881,
0.0206618141,
0.0301054996,
-0.0191915147,
0.0181307048,
0.0288435612,
0.023845423,
-0.024867937,
0.0186726432,
-0.0800081715,
-0.0635348558,
0.0556597933,
0.0147799449,
0.0450545475,
0.0201430898,
0.0426380076,
0.0141673591,
0.0664623231,
-0.0095760487,
0.0271919016,
-0.0089341626,
0.0356444791,
-0.0399495326,
-0.0303980038,
0.0196028743,
0.0703625754,
-0.0043955576,
0.0113367056,
0.0215903036,
0.0416409411,
0.0176598951,
0.0373504162,
0.020893354,
0.060735397,
0.0144077847,
-0.024558546,
-0.0642627254,
0.042569939,
-0.0113637894,
0.0246258806,
0.053022109,
0.0184396822,
-0.0450860672,
-0.0254234094,
0.0255249534,
0.007980586,
-0.0344894938,
0.0298114456,
-0.0100437747,
0.0230833441,
-0.0165301375,
0.0268487781,
0.0014585652,
-0.0677956641,
-0.0766682029,
0.0144030191,
-0.0162204187,
-0.007176958,
-0.0013012101,
0.0086334348,
-0.0441536121,
-0.0685942024,
-0.0140182488,
-0.0130479736,
-0.0138762584,
-0.0245445259,
0.0662148446,
0.0027069144,
-0.0734811947,
0.0019904084,
0.0039195367,
0.0003771457,
-0.0023395317,
0.0360940285,
0.0145610888,
0.0136507824,
0.0219577532,
0.0391245671,
0.0193645153,
0.0326415338,
0.0101227919,
-0.0216848068,
-0.0079329452,
0.0417575538,
-0.0072136405,
-0.0002851882,
0.0275189336,
0.0197982471,
0.0304869898,
-0.019635966,
-0.017969666,
0.0143196573,
2.586e-7,
0.0476045199,
0.0506696664,
-0.0083398987,
0.0119123328,
-0.0047786734,
0.0564642102,
-0.0172463953,
0.0509588569,
-0.032264553,
0.0320445076,
0.0410381667,
0.00491978,
0.0373790786,
-0.0151598826,
-0.073300451,
-0.0076908525,
-0.055303514,
0.0131459786,
-0.0356171951,
0.0694078133,
0.0509418771,
0.1068484932,
0.0033362492,
-0.0161786582,
-0.0000074272,
-0.0734239593,
0.062544018,
-0.0490024351,
-0.0224904176,
0.040148396,
-0.0229438022,
0.0263279453,
-0.0439730361,
0.0108976522,
0.0114261927,
0.0504090823,
0.0265987962,
0.0224917419,
0.0191611126,
0.0171309114,
0.0071303565,
0.0039351098,
-0.0147236548,
-0.0215482358,
0.0448556505,
-0.0695512146,
-0.0680317655,
-0.0665379539,
-0.0042316648,
0.0077144434,
0.007170592,
0.006728786,
-0.0186267477,
0.0281652883,
0.0215690229,
-0.0218345802,
-0.0334215537,
-0.0578664765,
0.0063872379,
0.0226710718,
-0.047449965,
-0.001764439,
-0.0149735855,
0.0091383131,
0.0045220531,
-0.0403315686,
0.0231622271,
2.159702021e-34,
0.0456987247,
-0.0372779332,
-0.0518856794,
0.0395799354,
0.056918513,
-0.0117552197,
-0.0617841668,
0.0433969945,
-0.0282037426,
-0.0762890503,
0.003073948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14067v1 | UAlberta at SemEval-2023 Task 1: Context Augmentation and Translation for Multilingual Visual Word Sense Disambiguation | 2023-06-24T22:00:06 | 2023-06-24T22:00:06 | Michael Ogezi, Bradley Hauer, Talgat Omarov, Ning Shi, Grzegorz Kondrak | cs.CL | cs.CL | We describe the systems of the University of Alberta team for the
SemEval-2023 Visual Word Sense Disambiguation (V-WSD) Task. We present a novel
algorithm that leverages glosses retrieved from BabelNet, in combination with
text and image encoders. Furthermore, we compare language-specific encoders
against the application of English encoders to translated texts. As the
contexts given in the task datasets are extremely short, we also experiment
with augmenting these contexts with descriptions generated by a language model.
This yields substantial improvements in accuracy. We describe and evaluate
additional V-WSD methods which use image generation and text-conditioned image
segmentation. Overall, the results of our official submission rank us 18 out of
56 teams. Some of our unofficial results are even better than the official
ones. Our code is publicly available at https://github.com/UAlberta-NLP/v-wsd. | [
-0.022846058,
0.0025683262,
0.0086479485,
0.0802930519,
-0.0300480705,
0.0392039306,
-0.0141877839,
-0.0041593234,
0.034060251,
-0.0336312912,
0.0158976614,
-0.0020215639,
0.046627257,
0.0071735205,
0.0409638397,
-0.0857770517,
0.039542418,
-0.0308096334,
-0.0661759302,
-0.0098486794,
-0.0033286426,
0.0285139158,
-0.008909612,
-0.0229907297,
-0.0242059231,
-0.0175172202,
0.0292862654,
0.0284267943,
0.0555228144,
-0.0108295558,
-0.0193857122,
0.02534068,
0.0523383245,
0.0201291814,
0.000002323,
-0.0418118425,
-0.0116423499,
-0.009130382,
0.0477341823,
-0.0398006178,
0.0713482499,
-0.097115159,
0.0243448298,
-0.0258536078,
-0.0083231954,
-0.0121904239,
0.058545731,
-0.0333014131,
0.0486506447,
-0.0071395435,
-0.043440856,
-0.083417803,
-0.0233211275,
-0.0119496034,
0.0322105251,
-0.0615958683,
0.0041304086,
0.0358468108,
-0.0392678678,
-0.0240767449,
-0.0675477684,
0.0672196224,
0.0172047596,
0.0127716931,
0.0122710429,
0.0088966023,
-0.0119944457,
-0.0389028639,
-0.0214403905,
0.0472233891,
0.0166723877,
-0.0287910718,
-0.0440593176,
0.0102274427,
-0.0529353917,
0.0275853779,
-0.0136062549,
0.0289463103,
-0.0154463239,
0.021063732,
-0.0102508841,
0.0328655913,
0.0207589082,
0.017248081,
-0.0151619259,
0.0185914896,
0.0327838957,
0.0081236605,
-0.0146948136,
0.0493869632,
-0.0286895987,
-0.0140526118,
0.0025797645,
-0.007394766,
0.0145224463,
0.0377855338,
-0.0364545733,
-0.0550772771,
-0.0032618332,
-0.0622889511,
-0.0559922047,
0.0256428402,
-0.0261914358,
0.0836170018,
-0.0369554199,
0.036483191,
0.0091344556,
0.0201043226,
-0.0717339367,
-0.0734407529,
-0.0171614606,
0.0310778338,
-0.05637981,
-0.0325561464,
-0.0696231499,
-0.0052442434,
-0.0867981017,
-0.0020598206,
-0.00494248,
0.0158400647,
-0.0191464536,
-0.0007469457,
-0.0571520962,
-0.0011500298,
-0.045142889,
0.017053565,
-0.0123319216,
-0.0141344275,
-0.0530633889,
-0.0055048517,
-0.013478403,
0.0457631834,
0.0011444564,
-0.0487756021,
-0.013205206,
0.0531272478,
-0.0515379794,
-0.0343630835,
-0.0625876933,
-0.0327432901,
-0.0331479236,
-0.0224464964,
-0.0188528169,
-0.078692548,
0.0321355462,
0.0042997794,
0.0352889374,
-0.0624614134,
-0.0146484338,
-0.0042608944,
-0.0327192657,
0.1248660907,
-0.0615604557,
-0.0260699503,
0.0181776509,
0.0249571856,
0.0361787118,
0.1038700119,
0.0227611084,
0.0372843258,
0.0572848246,
0.0367121808,
-0.0277575813,
0.0531433634,
-0.0455321558,
0.0185991544,
-0.0457052253,
-0.0362931415,
-0.0042140917,
0.0222344119,
0.0245415904,
0.0552506112,
-0.0590266027,
0.0044405428,
0.0156367868,
0.053576082,
0.0008597777,
-0.0172124729,
0.0359557718,
-0.0219094902,
-0.0134698488,
-0.003768716,
0.0064120986,
-0.008426154,
-0.0146812629,
0.0268537626,
-0.0145219043,
0.0428064205,
-0.0033309297,
-0.0257939175,
0.0021035527,
-0.0402588956,
0.0806695297,
0.0477115847,
0.0862139463,
0.0318454765,
-0.0210902952,
-0.0006365216,
0.0221331175,
-0.0509156324,
0.0498466305,
-0.0171868112,
-0.0121713923,
0.11532107,
0.0623998381,
-0.0035850077,
-0.0154076582,
0.0263890997,
0.0157890301,
0.0422101505,
-0.0239192881,
-0.0233331714,
0.038123358,
-0.0878206491,
-0.0533647165,
-0.000394154,
-0.0256338399,
-0.0136280535,
0.0283965524,
0.0350723453,
0.0374820679,
-0.0683027431,
-0.0019287352,
0.0413669161,
-0.004412875,
0.0103413109,
-0.0288616531,
0.0245062131,
-0.0188524909,
0.0144327627,
0.0045279223,
-0.0241073631,
0.0046701054,
-0.0555694178,
0.0477450565,
0.0269224979,
-0.0052366359,
-0.0604879931,
0.0160255507,
-0.0470244437,
-0.0227783043,
-0.015341891,
-0.0341213569,
-0.0434262119,
0.0030474977,
0.0036308554,
0.0268423762,
-0.0382414386,
0.0279248953,
-0.0075508063,
0.0262351651,
-0.0408617854,
0.0520763099,
-0.0046824673,
-0.0168651398,
-0.0257930923,
0.0674359724,
-0.0173097663,
0.0186679475,
-0.0222682487,
-0.0006362217,
0.0329327136,
0.0093791354,
0.0121440841,
0.0272245631,
-0.0495129898,
-0.0062320363,
-0.078297019,
-0.0088288076,
-0.0296602789,
-0.0287296623,
0.0160953924,
0.0369363427,
0.00280726,
-0.0269481689,
0.0209651869,
0.0803410858,
0.0030791624,
-0.0030585597,
0.0304891486,
-0.036275059,
0.0217632949,
-0.0166642554,
-0.0084062181,
0.0292337816,
0.0594129041,
0.0451760255,
-0.0659447536,
-0.0278417543,
0.0160651579,
-0.0519387238,
0.0023590627,
-0.0051355474,
-0.0168577358,
-0.011115633,
-0.0058919718,
0.0314494483,
0.0197041109,
0.0157693475,
0.0467807502,
0.0173900053,
-0.0165602881,
0.0112745203,
-0.0154812643,
-0.005914656,
-0.0354964994,
-0.0242501143,
-0.018512547,
-0.0205295663,
0.0113894688,
0.0046032085,
0.0145094981,
-0.0350002125,
0.0008883002,
-0.0214398261,
-0.0422942601,
-0.0375050344,
0.0177016277,
0.0092706429,
0.0401512682,
-0.0427254289,
-0.065854609,
0.0389759652,
-0.0223740935,
-0.0050122761,
-0.0522384346,
-0.0011510992,
-0.0255213957,
0.0704631135,
0.0027019703,
0.0449381135,
-0.0038968176,
0.0159318894,
-0.0364917628,
-0.0281367283,
0.0462854207,
-0.0147985434,
0.0534129627,
-0.1023229361,
0.0237025712,
-0.010009435,
0.0287578981,
-0.0418967195,
0.031927675,
-0.0240734536,
-0.003023321,
0.0336274244,
0.0049213888,
-0.0034732311,
0.0390562676,
0.0165296197,
0.0216580052,
0.030932324,
-0.0127031747,
-0.0071828756,
0.0330383815,
0.0481282994,
-0.012515231,
-0.0129829422,
-0.0377634168,
0.0027663356,
0.0179184284,
-0.0143343098,
-0.0658787042,
-0.0386969708,
0.0360770226,
0.0504442565,
-0.0016362349,
-0.0159310587,
-0.0175425205,
0.0545638651,
-0.0539755337,
-0.0213622712,
0.0863534883,
0.0309233256,
-0.0833972991,
-0.0348893218,
0.0240592957,
0.003462248,
0.0425721779,
-0.0262238812,
-0.10452272,
-0.0440610759,
-0.0283930171,
-0.0098472787,
0.0512508787,
0.0066802357,
-0.0346318409,
-0.0571023822,
0.0449077114,
0.0296311881,
-0.035464447,
-0.0141158374,
0.0039827987,
-0.0063032722,
-0.0468752868,
-0.0015259365,
-0.0460653417,
0.008716411,
-0.0153921815,
-0.0141237685,
0.0327683799,
-0.0493822321,
-0.0087145595,
-0.0632172599,
-0.0098381452,
0.0453504063,
0.0115979891,
0.0178115387,
-0.0395291038,
0.0128721641,
-0.0704027861,
-0.0203289259,
-0.02983585,
0.0281264056,
-0.0217896402,
-0.0156754106,
0.0320134796,
-0.0020443469,
-0.0134325819,
-0.041348286,
0.0145708025,
0.0125119062,
-0.0185497999,
0.000960046,
-0.01989053,
-0.0329243578,
-0.0123947812,
0.0126197319,
-0.0307148341,
0.005856371,
-0.0194969159,
-0.0117644109,
0.0139095634,
-0.025928814,
-0.0183825847,
-0.0302840993,
-0.0624436289,
-0.0176438261,
-0.0550049581,
-0.0346024111,
0.0610842146,
0.0516541675,
-0.0054164017,
0.0255875085,
-0.0048972182,
0.0082849255,
-0.0661565438,
0.0309713669,
-0.0501432605,
0.0148217045,
-0.0020470563,
-0.0356812775,
0.0263579953,
-0.005026048,
-0.0016184436,
0.0973099321,
-0.0519273095,
-0.0067614634,
-0.0172733385,
0.0478198752,
0.0140844509,
0.054606989,
-0.0449930839,
0.0080874469,
0.0262506157,
-0.0130558359,
0.0568351261,
0.0456168465,
-0.0522369407,
0.0243375394,
-0.0180692747,
0.0166352298,
-0.0173036344,
0.0209496543,
-0.001789141,
0.0076113474,
-0.0209081732,
-0.0296568833,
-0.0112067088,
-0.006608699,
0.0516769588,
-0.069291234,
0.002088414,
-0.0347189829,
-0.0280406661,
-0.0319766328,
-0.0236003026,
-0.0155262211,
0.0061974251,
0.0135313114,
-0.0236611962,
0.0144799203,
0.0664228275,
0.0047188774,
-0.0287114214,
-0.0062545589,
-0.0086542927,
0.03666595,
-0.0112047587,
-0.0407345109,
0.0353957899,
0.043744009,
-0.0212137271,
-0.0162600596,
0.0248809326,
-0.0317617059,
0.0279878117,
0.0084076487,
0.0052713118,
-0.0507567525,
0.0477468073,
0.0096959583,
0.0169810466,
-0.040241681,
0.0484941639,
0.0937431976,
-0.0106529398,
0.0951112583,
0.0105831483,
-0.0136027811,
-0.0219149143,
0.0512921996,
0.0116595672,
-0.0147121726,
0.0200905073,
-0.0018394552,
-0.0130219059,
0.0043390915,
0.0472089984,
-0.0152600398,
0.004764705,
0.0249816347,
-0.0317619555,
-0.0171444267,
-0.0400480069,
-0.0047177719,
0.00299378,
0.0036080217,
0.0150565859,
-0.0468349829,
-0.0651190951,
0.0378414467,
0.0099737588,
-0.0002226938,
0.0729399845,
0.0821616426,
0.0385774076,
0.006463062,
0.0232788026,
-0.0081064189,
-0.0466190577,
-0.0468969271,
-0.0357120112,
-0.0053406153,
-6.186479832e-33,
-0.040949028,
-0.0449778289,
0.0298249647,
-0.0465064123,
-0.0524229705,
0.0011229647,
-0.0088181207,
-0.0266884118,
-0.0225575641,
0.0282083675,
0.0654673725,
0.001771623,
0.0328784809,
0.0363544039,
-0.0062639052,
0.0185514595,
0.051878877,
0.0251924433,
-0.0063068117,
0.0107912533,
0.031461142,
0.0066561517,
0.0821127221,
-0.0407259762,
0.0165101085,
0.0169484634,
-0.0074812658,
-0.0030302824,
0.0964695737,
0.0458826311,
-0.0270838421,
0.0770504028,
0.0155516751,
0.0296652019,
-0.0100020682,
-0.0264374651,
-0.0683977008,
-0.0234114081,
0.0276988689,
0.0276116394,
-0.0799731538,
-0.0105208531,
0.0495269932,
-0.0179416947,
-0.0120462822,
-0.0028287144,
0.0640945509,
-0.0515414514,
-0.0388059765,
-0.0067626638,
-0.0419190377,
0.0187462475,
-0.0175355077,
-0.0307702217,
0.0616638213,
-0.0195108596,
0.0216803364,
0.0273937471,
-0.0312457122,
0.0455961153,
-0.0406235754,
0.01905003,
0.0959703624,
0.061486885,
0.0105073098,
0.0295325872,
0.0145003544,
-0.0565956496,
0.0219242088,
0.0034020932,
0.019695932,
0.0206116047,
0.0403405391,
0.0887415335,
0.0072072507,
-0.0184582882,
-0.0267432779,
0.0379327238,
-0.0380304866,
0.0506629534,
-0.0183558594,
-0.0023644431,
0.0072983555,
-0.0263647176,
-0.0706750676,
-0.0141439224,
-0.0260075834,
-0.0127634685,
0.0191497561,
0.0062168306,
-0.0306926984,
0.0328607671,
0.027772421,
-0.0062309089,
0.0216519814,
0.0041774921,
0.0089005129,
0.0356877185,
0.0032139868,
0.0217239093,
0.0328803696,
-0.0345966853,
0.0337256566,
0.0525418408,
0.001420852,
-0.0029991956,
0.0004017015,
-0.016637383,
0.0167647675,
0.023013141,
-0.0382680073,
-0.0152967898,
-0.0326448344,
0.0094270781,
-0.0011590801,
0.0012821441,
-0.0264740326,
0.0250261836,
0.0324422233,
-0.0225666892,
0.0157439914,
-0.0536076725,
0.009132239,
0.0388292037,
-0.036524307,
0.0567245707,
-0.0097841378,
-0.0236162357,
0.0286597069,
-0.0242435653,
-0.0188667402,
-0.0191505756,
2.888e-7,
0.0813995078,
0.0471234098,
0.0059829839,
0.0327855311,
0.006490605,
-0.0201176126,
0.0046567791,
0.0135794422,
-0.0589132272,
-0.0457252339,
-0.003246279,
0.0483868532,
0.0320565104,
0.0122236991,
0.0148136243,
0.0381857157,
0.0280246623,
0.0251722038,
-0.0330951586,
0.018460501,
0.0908197984,
0.0769376829,
-0.0013627759,
-0.0158225689,
-0.001592838,
-0.0458592921,
0.0676814914,
-0.0312830843,
-0.0127560962,
-0.00604625,
-0.0228054505,
0.0614156909,
0.0127382064,
0.0339019001,
-0.0287948102,
-0.0378849693,
0.0384282172,
0.0212193169,
-0.0458081774,
-0.002681803,
-0.0135040767,
0.0148975709,
0.012948446,
-0.0384087153,
0.0759086013,
-0.0214259252,
0.0280203223,
0.0208664108,
-0.0142496461,
0.0482671224,
0.0384246893,
-0.0116777476,
-0.0829489529,
0.0155303227,
0.0562433302,
0.0041086371,
-0.0572522692,
-0.0641044676,
0.0240891576,
0.023812471,
-0.0035622984,
-0.0096696801,
0.0076653133,
-0.0135102179,
0.006596928,
-0.0197093971,
-0.0336866826,
2.136313587e-34,
0.0425190479,
-0.0032895363,
-0.0109639596,
0.0115507916,
0.0283458345,
-0.0454980768,
-0.0649690256,
0.0119764609,
-0.028061239,
-0.0034977589,
-0.0059801755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14060v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14060v1 | DesCo: Learning Object Recognition with Rich Language Descriptions | 2023-06-24T21:05:02 | 2023-06-24T21:05:02 | Liunian Harold Li, Zi-Yi Dou, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent development in vision-language approaches has instigated a paradigm
shift in learning visual recognition models from language supervision. These
approaches align objects with language queries (e.g. "a photo of a cat") and
improve the models' adaptability to identify novel objects and domains.
Recently, several studies have attempted to query these models with complex
language expressions that include specifications of fine-grained semantic
details, such as attributes, shapes, textures, and relations. However, simply
incorporating language descriptions as queries does not guarantee accurate
interpretation by the models. In fact, our experiments show that GLIP, the
state-of-the-art vision-language model for object detection, often disregards
contextual information in the language descriptions and instead relies heavily
on detecting objects solely by their names. To tackle the challenges, we
propose a new description-conditioned (DesCo) paradigm of learning object
recognition models with rich language descriptions consisting of two major
innovations: 1) we employ a large language model as a commonsense knowledge
engine to generate rich language descriptions of objects based on object names
and the raw image-text caption; 2) we design context-sensitive queries to
improve the model's ability in deciphering intricate nuances embedded within
descriptions and enforce the model to focus on context rather than object names
alone. On two novel object detection benchmarks, LVIS and OminiLabel, under the
zero-shot detection setting, our approach achieves 34.8 APr minival (+9.1) and
29.3 AP (+3.6), respectively, surpassing the prior state-of-the-art models,
GLIP and FIBER, by a large margin. | [
0.0368944556,
0.0717997178,
0.0211649407,
0.0782697648,
-0.0244719721,
0.0376578309,
-0.014879684,
0.0109625226,
0.0005244815,
-0.1007303223,
-0.00970151,
-0.0048000258,
-0.008043848,
0.0575108603,
-0.0142253861,
-0.044806622,
0.0105127133,
-0.0301923864,
-0.0297667738,
0.0338006243,
-0.0059935162,
0.0263132732,
0.0099552153,
-0.0013778069,
-0.0204545073,
0.0261593685,
-0.0044804453,
0.0198382996,
-0.0004575625,
-0.0408476666,
-0.00332389,
0.0602966845,
0.0474066585,
0.0185110588,
0.0000018899,
-0.0519873798,
0.0555104874,
0.0080522336,
0.0258627981,
-0.0449592322,
0.0643427894,
-0.0768062919,
0.0125936354,
-0.0439851023,
-0.0043903631,
-0.0345103629,
0.0917534679,
0.0415599756,
-0.0110644987,
0.0363632254,
-0.0386254862,
-0.0599357039,
0.0124379015,
-0.0131565314,
0.0518290102,
-0.0622278787,
0.0180532709,
0.0096305832,
-0.0186357256,
0.023552062,
-0.0216360502,
0.0240866691,
0.0119838305,
-0.0171134099,
0.0009436584,
0.0477734171,
-0.0492827594,
-0.053434357,
-0.0067162584,
0.0767036378,
-0.0267001223,
-0.0280110929,
-0.0057541626,
0.005877241,
0.0096895685,
-0.022466898,
-0.0190689974,
0.0454220884,
-0.0079537574,
-0.0099237505,
-0.0263156146,
0.0161623918,
0.0067798123,
0.0432115197,
0.0000743389,
-0.009148485,
-0.0008369191,
0.0437960997,
-0.0112523828,
0.0290497746,
-0.0584965236,
-0.0318340771,
-0.0264110155,
0.0200014077,
-0.0033706587,
-0.0110374363,
-0.0475100987,
-0.0074566207,
0.015793398,
-0.0589998625,
-0.0081800213,
-0.0126686487,
-0.0833875388,
0.0897878855,
-0.0509034283,
0.067943424,
-0.021449469,
0.0372533612,
-0.0668598786,
-0.0420653485,
-0.0355864652,
0.0089868726,
-0.0229100175,
-0.0159059633,
-0.0316109806,
-0.0271001868,
-0.0030867928,
0.00233297,
-0.0114617217,
0.0079351813,
-0.0518125743,
-0.0119177336,
-0.0370426215,
-0.0142466091,
-0.0227054469,
0.0061311238,
0.0134009793,
0.0042548459,
-0.0306683965,
-0.0371543393,
-0.0174039565,
0.0388752744,
0.0367687233,
-0.0289136767,
-0.0066996119,
0.0861392841,
-0.0223968346,
-0.07072559,
-0.000856664,
-0.0098685483,
-0.0043897224,
-0.0278183483,
0.041000843,
-0.0526805818,
0.0029528886,
-0.0119683156,
0.0161796492,
-0.0448041074,
-0.0004061181,
-0.0001051053,
-0.008485904,
0.0806046352,
-0.0488196462,
-0.032810051,
-0.0090676909,
0.0370784216,
0.0356164463,
0.0827922747,
-0.0265453607,
0.0399108939,
-0.0034406905,
0.0227458403,
0.0525117889,
0.0148493238,
-0.0221376829,
0.0300611928,
-0.066156365,
0.0201942641,
0.0201601852,
-0.007624127,
0.0504021347,
-0.0008145113,
0.0016558415,
-0.0262517016,
0.0552596338,
0.0302650537,
-0.0584344044,
0.0148792788,
0.0347357355,
0.0244368762,
-0.0112792756,
-0.0451731496,
-0.0705350116,
0.0494772233,
-0.0205897391,
0.0012609989,
-0.0849557519,
-0.0045436854,
-0.0474805981,
-0.0075315838,
-0.0280870143,
-0.0504891686,
0.028826151,
0.0431315713,
0.047678344,
0.0103745665,
0.0104718208,
0.0345278829,
0.0537900068,
-0.0284479354,
-0.0205850378,
-0.0818137527,
0.017804157,
0.0332736485,
0.0046181581,
-0.0154855959,
-0.0050764708,
0.0196504015,
0.0565628707,
0.0842918456,
0.032196559,
0.0036919725,
0.0508577488,
0.0015949975,
-0.0481591187,
-0.0061936341,
-0.003295358,
0.006716501,
0.028140178,
0.0012184491,
0.0622834228,
-0.0383499153,
-0.0406491682,
0.0598718077,
0.0770581439,
-0.0323045589,
-0.0110564837,
0.0252402574,
-0.0040775407,
-0.0248437785,
-0.0033677784,
-0.0243374277,
0.0108926501,
-0.0148545839,
0.0067058899,
0.019246554,
-0.0365117416,
-0.0408064798,
0.0177053735,
0.0058504455,
-0.012371134,
0.0100943716,
-0.0358985439,
-0.0075164577,
0.0121784937,
-0.014541545,
0.022507567,
-0.0295779239,
0.0003369943,
-0.0351357535,
0.0090866247,
-0.0051359711,
0.0589303114,
-0.0002299697,
-0.0270418841,
0.0033854418,
-0.0052786134,
-0.0027612089,
-0.0133335833,
-0.0452048592,
0.0155008314,
-0.0016937933,
0.0286984667,
0.0299005974,
0.055685129,
-0.021778632,
0.0158326309,
-0.0444092825,
-0.052907154,
-0.0167789459,
-0.0448847525,
-0.0077817757,
-0.0115006836,
0.0147935189,
-0.0325788409,
-0.0322860032,
0.0121015664,
-0.0459667183,
0.0277477726,
0.0248139463,
0.0478277951,
-0.032500755,
0.0053956904,
0.0034711163,
0.0337013341,
0.0605501197,
0.0433015861,
-0.0223497339,
-0.0389764644,
0.0503101982,
-0.0287347026,
0.0424724109,
-0.009195352,
-0.0170585066,
-0.0076410128,
-0.0346505716,
-0.031612318,
0.1037896946,
-0.0180254914,
0.0198688656,
0.0219073053,
-0.0018983947,
-0.0244979095,
-0.0168016423,
-0.0045594922,
-0.0625382215,
-0.0140296593,
0.0004058311,
0.0112538617,
0.0675003454,
-0.0579864867,
0.0015707425,
-0.061022982,
-0.0125162667,
-0.0315227583,
-0.0564373173,
-0.0750816241,
0.0213333666,
0.0313503817,
0.0310759451,
-0.0487876534,
-0.0622531101,
0.0560125336,
-0.031785395,
-0.0129638305,
0.0021662803,
-0.009666455,
-0.0296554305,
0.0898359641,
0.0469021536,
0.048857078,
0.0062188823,
-0.0021155281,
-0.0157376565,
-0.0254225638,
-0.0075170929,
0.0091001075,
0.017070435,
-0.0533679239,
0.0439817533,
-0.0441941209,
-0.0278164651,
-0.0046129888,
-0.0096303811,
-0.0383826047,
0.0338076279,
-0.0712294579,
-0.044035323,
-0.0353375748,
0.0436119363,
0.0004835038,
0.0549391843,
0.0072386772,
-0.0153876273,
-0.0037527832,
-0.0168770142,
0.061237298,
-0.0082269758,
-0.0463164411,
-0.0123880813,
-0.0012187584,
0.0472467728,
0.0100951483,
0.0023687058,
-0.0387268141,
0.0591273047,
0.035641402,
0.0559467971,
-0.0127413599,
0.0350309126,
0.0350249447,
-0.0519463867,
-0.0515628681,
0.0599317215,
-0.0050702458,
-0.0352130197,
-0.0414511487,
0.0257537942,
0.0229310356,
0.0463830009,
0.0163135026,
-0.0846166611,
-0.0571952574,
-0.0159766078,
-0.0173584204,
0.0171991885,
0.0010388935,
-0.035746038,
-0.0612623021,
0.0251982845,
0.000025321,
-0.0832339004,
-0.0610042214,
-0.0005632265,
0.0105856284,
-0.0440808386,
-0.0331517942,
-0.0136790872,
0.0002734147,
-0.029210465,
-0.008021865,
0.0534442514,
-0.0381812714,
0.0359382592,
-0.0382150672,
-0.0408186428,
0.056004636,
0.0269797295,
0.0142006008,
-0.0524655506,
0.0159398317,
0.0051520374,
-0.0044885003,
-0.0170074701,
0.0184798855,
-0.0181393512,
-0.0377362855,
0.0394901447,
0.0180983115,
-0.0295175444,
-0.0554393008,
-0.0431211367,
0.009591613,
0.0273698512,
-0.0004419973,
-0.0437027365,
-0.021064667,
0.0287858918,
0.0601711869,
0.0138526727,
-0.0256302636,
-0.0166424848,
-0.0064407717,
-0.0523629151,
-0.0071651144,
-0.0199479423,
-0.0134671154,
-0.0104502179,
-0.0182869285,
-0.0392943285,
0.0112594301,
0.0427102298,
0.019161839,
0.0092742592,
-0.033611577,
-0.0154617075,
0.0225056838,
-0.0801555887,
0.0796759352,
-0.0503176078,
0.0037324491,
-0.0402493961,
-0.0186350252,
0.0383361541,
-0.0410496034,
-0.0252590235,
0.0480377749,
-0.0666577816,
-0.0331431925,
-0.0221941974,
0.054016538,
0.0147643387,
0.0179737639,
-0.0150083192,
-0.0641747713,
0.0069547095,
0.0629761294,
0.0094288969,
0.0039110128,
-0.0026342766,
-0.0286202133,
0.0025043474,
0.0300488323,
-0.0341998674,
0.0444725193,
0.0386713073,
-0.029763449,
-0.0204798952,
-0.0175562538,
0.0155953206,
-0.0039736563,
0.0370558575,
-0.0251548495,
0.0517946221,
-0.0214256477,
0.0017932667,
0.0359411687,
-0.0185386874,
-0.062428914,
0.0186690968,
-0.006488136,
-0.0001209175,
0.0314490125,
0.046247039,
0.0176956821,
0.0470546186,
-0.0431390479,
-0.0238027442,
0.0194703471,
-0.0054001617,
0.032717146,
0.0205724798,
-0.0060385172,
0.0164286159,
-0.0127050392,
0.0663589984,
-0.0161283016,
0.050459519,
0.0319886096,
-0.0193608124,
-0.0398822203,
0.0185041521,
-0.0002037018,
-0.0190838091,
-0.0455567464,
0.0532976426,
0.0339473598,
-0.0610803813,
0.0127928723,
-0.0501877889,
-0.0215071011,
-0.000098487,
0.0499738492,
0.0131699359,
-0.0545581095,
0.0572986118,
0.0340064242,
0.0032838748,
-0.0265657511,
0.0358039588,
0.0782147348,
0.0296395235,
0.0206629876,
0.0131378295,
-0.0200778339,
0.0046302332,
0.0522776023,
-0.014398477,
-0.0203722324,
0.0688308999,
-0.0082096951,
-0.0377988219,
-0.0193197131,
-0.0157802608,
0.0119020157,
0.0403389186,
0.0630259141,
0.0487885401,
0.0207444672,
-0.0600610077,
-0.0082821278,
-0.0379653536,
0.0033051767,
0.0327891856,
-0.0064673685,
-5.599997047e-33,
-0.0317865163,
-0.0310875569,
0.0157584734,
0.0110848956,
0.017044099,
0.0081244111,
-0.0265405308,
0.0092206467,
-0.0436527729,
0.0101762684,
0.0155206826,
0.0096188113,
0.0115896584,
0.0460824259,
-0.0165225454,
-0.0166798644,
0.0300576054,
0.026293179,
-0.0051412224,
0.0095578376,
0.0164798908,
-0.0079126656,
0.0778692961,
-0.0635658875,
-0.0017435048,
0.0283071138,
-0.0104812253,
0.0466013402,
0.0324715525,
0.041622404,
-0.0083392253,
0.0241175853,
0.0154809104,
0.0262904018,
-0.0115495846,
0.0247038025,
-0.0857561827,
0.0223143492,
0.0045978031,
0.0601757132,
-0.0256113764,
0.0126002394,
0.0282874629,
-0.021550931,
0.0124287922,
-0.0086787306,
0.0252077784,
-0.0546964966,
-0.0214780979,
0.0015745462,
-0.0716030225,
0.0230978839,
0.0212938916,
-0.0399019197,
0.0793763548,
-0.0138574494,
0.0349631906,
0.0236300137,
-0.0183846876,
0.0315009914,
0.0186730195,
0.0360360779,
0.0705430806,
0.093248792,
-0.0092070736,
0.0679458156,
-0.0072595035,
-0.0069577224,
0.0106939413,
0.0260961652,
0.0426108874,
0.075944297,
0.0286441427,
0.0412650704,
0.0268998612,
0.0167176612,
-0.0520223901,
-0.0020030688,
-0.0917870253,
0.0704342797,
0.0083735399,
0.00896856,
-0.0400200151,
-0.0029738913,
-0.0542406961,
0.0066087744,
-0.0606989786,
0.0371503495,
0.0315812677,
0.0294865016,
-0.0435160138,
0.0253244136,
0.0385279767,
-0.0071377363,
-0.0292557869,
0.0116978278,
-0.0170047171,
0.016372839,
-0.0213238411,
-0.0064277886,
-0.0456570089,
-0.0701609999,
0.0385765061,
0.0106112994,
-0.0121703204,
0.0089757591,
0.0826039985,
0.0236265324,
-0.0291186441,
-0.0018403257,
-0.0542651191,
0.0178983696,
0.0249954034,
0.0522202589,
0.0303360727,
0.0016935662,
-0.0269425176,
0.0574216209,
-0.0108398469,
-0.0541962981,
-0.0192215294,
0.0015279963,
0.0018815773,
0.0211832635,
-0.0256032627,
-0.0035810133,
-0.0397024825,
-0.029718522,
0.0625184104,
-0.0494577661,
-0.0037393079,
0.0358250849,
2.57e-7,
0.005082285,
0.0069026044,
-0.0202195495,
0.0323966667,
-0.0162834171,
0.0664207339,
-0.0109292995,
0.043268621,
-0.0237493571,
-0.0070684701,
-0.0050265836,
0.0419422835,
0.0274386182,
-0.013004615,
-0.0558407865,
0.0617320947,
-0.0108107952,
-0.0100973221,
-0.0668213442,
-0.0224010963,
0.0228973832,
0.0828240812,
-0.028676983,
-0.0355430879,
0.0538520664,
-0.0956751183,
0.0848696157,
-0.0466557667,
0.0334219597,
-0.0012088475,
-0.0121320589,
0.0924534276,
-0.0208792742,
0.035446316,
-0.0109976968,
-0.0010715249,
0.0324683264,
0.0408868566,
-0.0320684761,
0.0257787164,
-0.0094001563,
-0.0010830164,
-0.0113711255,
-0.0509868227,
0.069779709,
-0.0663912147,
0.0111555373,
-0.0583374202,
0.0164897349,
-0.025120765,
0.005443071,
-0.0461823046,
-0.0361191146,
0.0150335291,
0.0327529982,
-0.0437865034,
-0.0290203188,
-0.0617203005,
-0.0375851095,
-0.0015758364,
0.0026380476,
-0.0025506171,
-0.0513313003,
0.0081524849,
0.02234051,
-0.0063685905,
-0.0362091139,
1.80773835e-34,
-0.006124319,
0.0162623469,
-0.0266993549,
0.0356418155,
0.0167502798,
0.0103125516,
-0.0339875668,
0.0247558132,
-0.0329775065,
-0.0146289309,
0.0125013478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14050v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14050v2 | Symbolic Chain-of-Thought Distillation: Small Models Can Also "Think" Step-by-Step | 2023-06-24T20:15:07 | 2024-04-15T21:58:27 | Liunian Harold Li, Jack Hessel, Youngjae Yu, Xiang Ren, Kai-Wei Chang, Yejin Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chain-of-thought prompting (e.g., "Let's think step-by-step") primes large
language models to verbalize rationalization for their predictions. While
chain-of-thought can lead to dramatic performance gains, benefits appear to
emerge only for sufficiently large models (beyond 50B parameters). We show that
orders-of-magnitude smaller models (125M -- 1.3B parameters) can still benefit
from chain-of-thought prompting. To achieve this, we introduce Symbolic
Chain-of-Thought Distillation (SCoTD), a method to train a smaller student
model on rationalizations sampled from a significantly larger teacher model.
Experiments across several commonsense benchmarks show that: 1) SCoTD enhances
the performance of the student model in both supervised and few-shot settings,
and especially for challenge sets; 2) sampling many reasoning chains per
instance from the teacher is paramount; and 3) after distillation, student
chain-of-thoughts are judged by humans as comparable to the teacher, despite
orders of magnitude fewer parameters. We test several hypotheses regarding what
properties of chain-of-thought samples are important, e.g., diversity vs.
teacher likelihood vs. open-endedness. We release our corpus of
chain-of-thought samples and code. | [
0.0243879668,
0.0607059859,
-0.0017615955,
0.0119747445,
-0.0169412997,
0.0194486864,
0.0334373862,
-0.0041990099,
-0.031566754,
-0.0429810286,
0.017158553,
-0.013068432,
-0.0146149071,
0.0031631785,
0.0249391533,
-0.0928711519,
0.0099169305,
-0.0655372664,
0.0310441889,
-0.0099579161,
-0.0186094102,
0.0149928685,
-0.0135912392,
0.0439756997,
0.0384010561,
-0.0447338074,
-0.0551236346,
-0.003070069,
0.0293301307,
-0.0048601297,
-0.0413518287,
0.0861779451,
0.0359428711,
0.0015818042,
0.0000022718,
-0.0475143492,
0.0193982739,
-0.0093801916,
-0.0440648794,
0.050766442,
-0.0305466596,
0.0079249265,
0.0369474292,
0.0097462414,
-0.0290935989,
0.0229927655,
0.0026954967,
0.0185628347,
0.0603474192,
0.0280192569,
0.0219180882,
-0.0375424586,
0.0279153809,
0.0030033337,
-0.0059916517,
-0.0030570505,
-0.0052586244,
0.0395413265,
0.0005059854,
0.0342005193,
-0.0359739698,
0.0108681023,
0.0468499027,
-0.007404299,
0.0159949604,
0.0385630801,
-0.0000233889,
-0.0041215336,
0.0075765504,
0.0696300715,
-0.002610906,
-0.0368718393,
0.0030964867,
-0.0150088537,
0.0298601631,
0.034227524,
-0.0535017438,
0.0335586257,
-0.0040543764,
0.0249935705,
0.0374946743,
0.0045626541,
0.0140981209,
0.029738998,
-0.0272638313,
0.0122631267,
-0.0320945829,
-0.0341994613,
0.0281016864,
0.0034982378,
-0.0413192101,
-0.0747107938,
-0.0184611455,
0.0438208096,
-0.0004063458,
0.0107221697,
-0.0113130584,
-0.006095673,
-0.0031479953,
0.003306499,
0.0310165752,
0.0454721153,
0.0277710315,
0.0203095544,
0.0062784269,
0.0449279249,
0.0058460408,
0.0754023865,
-0.0276071485,
0.0187788289,
-0.0960102826,
0.000310359,
-0.0292390194,
0.0591969714,
-0.0307494663,
0.0152629865,
-0.0116406679,
-0.0331701823,
-0.0325875506,
-0.0098660979,
0.0223996192,
0.0309277661,
0.0168728717,
-0.0102131572,
-0.0428706892,
0.0673748329,
-0.0747196823,
0.0077227531,
0.0647448078,
-0.0302006286,
-0.0377787575,
-0.0266971383,
0.0080412338,
-0.0096152797,
-0.0043766764,
-0.0088577708,
-0.0356298462,
0.0017486222,
-0.0404749177,
-0.0603373386,
-0.0006726529,
-0.0808396637,
0.0070686648,
-0.0909046829,
0.0056942324,
-0.0009819879,
0.0168319102,
-0.0317400806,
0.007329837,
0.0089115743,
-0.0158274751,
0.0548965745,
0.0019594957,
0.0030489406,
-0.0179222338,
0.0427374691,
-0.0398602672,
0.0801943243,
0.0305530988,
0.0002713319,
-0.0012615804,
-0.0176776499,
-0.01680246,
-0.0180995539,
0.031573806,
0.0185387786,
-0.01779099,
0.0169820618,
-0.0299782343,
0.0513119735,
0.0330913849,
0.0574229732,
-0.0640373826,
0.0274596345,
0.0316113755,
0.0767357275,
-0.0045905593,
0.0198665261,
0.0648193434,
0.0200810749,
0.0334334411,
0.0304868408,
-0.0715389922,
0.0193821751,
-0.012426177,
0.0157435276,
0.0153652597,
0.0205815993,
-0.027376743,
-0.0563228242,
0.0127998227,
0.0189732332,
0.0082332883,
0.008210307,
0.0321054682,
0.0170661025,
-0.0049475986,
0.072296612,
0.0304103065,
-0.0697021633,
-0.0028518392,
-0.0528527126,
0.0331096426,
0.0285343602,
0.0353108123,
0.0071799993,
0.0138928406,
-0.0349660292,
0.0320415497,
-0.0045692786,
0.0352276489,
-0.0334139504,
0.0095780324,
-0.0516381152,
-0.0354654305,
-0.0251890812,
0.0268308818,
-0.0233061519,
0.0268397704,
0.0040312377,
0.0042941482,
-0.0470507443,
-0.0136889573,
0.0132825347,
-0.0361095071,
-0.0367635898,
-0.0400267392,
0.0055414527,
0.0208664555,
0.0211516451,
0.0024634977,
0.0021081879,
-0.0086231045,
-0.031499058,
-0.0260040183,
-0.0026944217,
-0.0861432031,
-0.0666945502,
0.0309714042,
-0.0451775752,
-0.0123433601,
0.017949976,
-0.0442447849,
-0.0499631539,
0.0520949252,
-0.010949702,
0.0026838169,
0.0020600657,
0.0159851592,
-0.0052358727,
-0.0237136073,
-0.0087873209,
0.0715943351,
-0.0208382923,
0.0039617233,
0.0267481208,
-0.0044316798,
0.0067133955,
-0.0101819308,
0.019162152,
0.0038565819,
-0.0003616616,
0.0041582519,
-0.0189180151,
0.0196651816,
-0.0661205053,
-0.0003969526,
-0.0543560088,
-0.0145099256,
-0.0198479835,
0.0027205942,
0.0172873754,
-0.0019480281,
0.03228724,
0.0152921015,
-0.0251946934,
-0.0100478278,
-0.0361010432,
0.0041212346,
0.0033564623,
0.0012849513,
-0.0059510106,
-0.0095661329,
-0.0307900365,
-0.0351417027,
0.074309282,
0.0018268268,
0.0348396413,
-0.0190253668,
0.0471971296,
-0.0273737404,
0.0096709821,
0.0010128286,
-0.032938879,
0.0393261239,
-0.0254423916,
0.0375516452,
0.0643945187,
-0.0195372645,
0.0143553624,
0.0682884008,
-0.0058154087,
-0.0734772235,
0.0302390382,
0.0184489507,
0.0229282696,
-0.0165731423,
-0.0328299738,
-0.0249572508,
0.078383334,
0.0020523404,
0.0030075086,
-0.087185882,
0.0273718741,
-0.0011517162,
-0.0324572586,
-0.0594897494,
-0.037577752,
-0.0003885995,
0.0701923817,
-0.017483972,
-0.0221096333,
0.0947928801,
-0.0128475754,
0.0105343526,
-0.0429315567,
0.003992544,
-0.0136983227,
0.0710446313,
-0.0267122388,
-0.0222029965,
0.0267186891,
0.0152249755,
-0.0655462593,
-0.0104393456,
0.0332677737,
-0.0182328019,
0.0757751018,
-0.0816632435,
-0.0260066669,
-0.0171085298,
-0.0519230329,
-0.039189104,
-0.0068432535,
-0.0567997582,
0.0235329755,
0.0124091338,
-0.0261242352,
-0.002347602,
-0.0339506418,
0.0356294848,
0.0273061097,
0.0093988217,
-0.0181693248,
-0.0086103892,
0.0229830425,
0.0235963706,
0.006923716,
0.0345408805,
-0.0292813741,
0.0962373391,
0.0478757843,
0.0639318153,
-0.0362467021,
-0.0366017781,
-0.0024402644,
-0.0070419409,
-0.0103155775,
-0.0289059635,
0.0460658744,
0.0777641162,
-0.0527296886,
-0.0301158689,
0.1113498285,
0.0136500094,
-0.0195394903,
0.013549584,
-0.0288117323,
0.0794476271,
0.0078313043,
-0.0142609896,
-0.0918757394,
-0.0529088825,
0.0253656115,
-0.0024328204,
0.0036376182,
-0.0551053472,
0.0036449046,
-0.1136909947,
0.0175841376,
0.011253329,
-0.0206723008,
-0.0021991855,
-0.0379313305,
-0.0128816785,
-0.0085829813,
-0.0171655957,
0.0336566567,
-0.0143036963,
0.0426358208,
0.0329548717,
-0.0109456582,
-0.0046715443,
0.0408052281,
-0.0291034728,
0.0113134691,
-0.013553814,
0.0259577297,
0.0290809907,
-0.0838951096,
0.000319806,
-0.0341534838,
0.0184003748,
0.0033040673,
0.0326969884,
0.0216666963,
0.0148037123,
-0.0145375729,
0.072745949,
-0.0438504592,
-0.0386647545,
0.0333287306,
0.0930868536,
-0.0014748723,
-0.0317874104,
-0.0317445323,
0.0209049396,
-0.0304340031,
0.0779809132,
0.0687688366,
-0.0246320628,
-0.0442932546,
-0.0331751406,
-0.0398818292,
-0.0521128513,
-0.0378304087,
-0.0062888018,
0.0328651443,
0.0467674918,
-0.0533797555,
-0.0450771637,
0.0199720003,
0.0493895859,
-0.0209057964,
0.0038107925,
0.0049279868,
0.0252237115,
-0.0090376334,
0.0381054506,
-0.0343345776,
0.0040818024,
-0.0104483571,
0.0068392502,
-0.0226430409,
-0.0114909718,
-0.0368409455,
0.038989,
-0.1091852039,
-0.0528808013,
-0.0386195369,
0.0409803726,
0.0300130621,
0.0674891397,
0.0010709203,
-0.0489525087,
0.0271698814,
-0.0151079716,
0.0094202384,
0.0117679751,
0.0425782204,
0.0122901266,
0.0452500284,
0.0449204296,
-0.0065343762,
0.0038385314,
0.0037170833,
0.0486398526,
-0.0469838455,
0.0091751032,
0.021972917,
0.0031009149,
0.043839734,
0.0001216174,
-0.0014773979,
-0.0220555402,
0.0146600557,
-0.0116454596,
-0.013722945,
-0.0477371328,
0.0283887163,
0.0264253486,
-0.0129812825,
0.0065194769,
-0.041288808,
0.0128172338,
0.0285085961,
0.0057816342,
0.0041297153,
0.0170470066,
0.0208214596,
0.0466272347,
-0.0240893271,
-0.0301084109,
-0.0046678102,
-0.0178881083,
0.0380093083,
0.0014026337,
0.087755248,
0.0386379063,
0.0160434451,
-0.0011244754,
-0.0222243257,
-0.0997641757,
-0.0756959245,
0.0085261539,
-0.016122032,
0.0120999077,
0.0309784207,
0.035422761,
-0.0169609971,
0.004018486,
0.0200375151,
0.0475061089,
-0.0086854268,
-0.021182498,
0.0227071792,
0.0434747711,
0.0159420613,
-0.0120712603,
0.0748422295,
-0.0308381729,
0.0331536829,
0.0124711338,
0.0232988745,
-0.0168727003,
-0.0329655372,
-0.0539750867,
0.0608511232,
0.0328480937,
0.0122591658,
-0.0755223334,
-0.0634339601,
-0.0244760308,
0.0184953399,
0.0183789544,
-0.0356726646,
0.0600068085,
0.02807023,
-0.0357920378,
-0.0365519598,
-0.0029928142,
0.0073357481,
-0.0007441024,
-0.0394163691,
-0.0515080392,
-6.428697055e-33,
0.0069960672,
0.0100924354,
0.0263676737,
-0.0108133648,
-0.0019435047,
-0.0073108035,
-0.0473751202,
0.0175668094,
-0.0352445729,
0.0543326028,
-0.0295998547,
0.0341141224,
0.0021289529,
0.0229951423,
0.0360127501,
0.0056499667,
0.0470838957,
-0.0014940809,
-0.0256255195,
0.0303766634,
0.0416517593,
-0.0092187766,
0.043319162,
-0.0353294052,
0.020573739,
0.001014705,
0.0138881635,
-0.0061096214,
-0.0492937677,
0.0352528542,
-0.0030924329,
0.0405133255,
0.0093937106,
-0.0535251983,
-0.0231751837,
0.0034024464,
-0.0734746754,
-0.0488783307,
0.0430035815,
-0.0383427888,
-0.0746679828,
-0.0456998944,
0.02255252,
0.0210325718,
-0.0185480844,
-0.0605677627,
0.0235252809,
-0.0179251079,
-0.0052979845,
-0.0205777194,
-0.0250880457,
0.0032568427,
-0.0631791055,
-0.0264012422,
-0.0146128247,
0.0525504798,
-0.023878241,
-0.0011403224,
-0.0328790806,
0.0143183265,
0.0811005831,
0.0168727487,
0.0569984019,
-0.0108730551,
-0.0125811538,
0.060057696,
0.0075872666,
-0.0171550047,
-0.0429991186,
0.009004239,
0.0160119385,
0.0533369109,
0.0636015758,
0.0459409021,
0.0744160041,
0.0469903089,
-0.0855060443,
-0.0084294137,
0.0025139165,
0.0351819322,
-0.0091200089,
-0.0043563084,
-0.0317395739,
-0.0203041658,
-0.0668515339,
-0.0574592464,
-0.0255966969,
-0.0181861855,
0.024613088,
0.0050811842,
-0.0339655615,
-0.0377730392,
0.0293293074,
-0.0329414457,
-0.0104628168,
0.0498486944,
-0.0196034517,
0.0115156583,
0.0006080393,
-0.0103862556,
-0.0718652233,
0.0203440506,
0.0369271636,
0.0502822511,
0.0316032805,
0.0363819711,
0.0631821007,
-0.0000769274,
-0.0356002636,
-0.0239062421,
-0.0570481829,
0.0233242493,
-0.0025260358,
0.0000696898,
0.0392210819,
0.0286512487,
-0.0123007633,
0.026190836,
0.0004788139,
-0.0503605194,
-0.0014273068,
0.0358957127,
-0.0017250265,
-0.0087369764,
0.0000412696,
-0.0387556516,
-0.0280972756,
-0.0252643898,
0.0708131045,
-0.0469335355,
-0.0214138869,
0.0394622348,
2.823e-7,
-0.0091615133,
0.0299467314,
0.0031493451,
-0.0329377167,
0.0040063737,
0.042699609,
0.0136970226,
-0.0205319189,
0.0372664072,
-0.0888681337,
-0.0232722983,
0.0557665937,
0.0449859537,
0.0350165144,
-0.0950550437,
-0.0197361894,
-0.0821488053,
-0.030176729,
-0.0293399263,
-0.0287729017,
0.0586326942,
0.0598442554,
0.0464193635,
-0.0151971988,
0.017320605,
0.0119669251,
0.0158755165,
-0.015295743,
0.0285284948,
-0.005101176,
-0.003761959,
-0.0347085968,
0.0224658586,
0.039831765,
0.0026331374,
0.0130894138,
-0.0412142463,
0.0457528792,
0.0026568079,
0.0260755923,
-0.0273676831,
-0.0371956378,
0.0130538102,
-0.0662686229,
0.0600240231,
-0.0471391231,
-0.0135459956,
0.025556352,
-0.0382373072,
-0.0259917323,
0.0167765338,
0.0207304191,
0.0208818521,
0.0267663654,
-0.0293785408,
-0.0143297501,
0.0094371736,
-0.0602001064,
-0.0488386191,
-0.011511513,
-0.0060721082,
-0.0480706617,
-0.0199210271,
-0.0325240158,
0.0185586289,
-0.0826109871,
-0.0103388932,
2.644760122e-34,
0.0416834876,
-0.0251446161,
0.0634765327,
0.0121015571,
0.0440294854,
-0.0069023194,
-0.0524339676,
-0.0224152617,
0.0556353033,
-0.0566686578,
-0.0265936628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14040v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14040v1 | Weighted Automata Extraction and Explanation of Recurrent Neural Networks for Natural Language Tasks | 2023-06-24T19:16:56 | 2023-06-24T19:16:56 | Zeming Wei, Xiyue Zhang, Yihao Zhang, Meng Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) have achieved tremendous success in
processing sequential data, yet understanding and analyzing their behaviours
remains a significant challenge. To this end, many efforts have been made to
extract finite automata from RNNs, which are more amenable for analysis and
explanation. However, existing approaches like exact learning and compositional
approaches for model extraction have limitations in either scalability or
precision. In this paper, we propose a novel framework of Weighted Finite
Automata (WFA) extraction and explanation to tackle the limitations for natural
language tasks. First, to address the transition sparsity and context loss
problems we identified in WFA extraction for natural language tasks, we propose
an empirical method to complement missing rules in the transition diagram, and
adjust transition matrices to enhance the context-awareness of the WFA. We also
propose two data augmentation tactics to track more dynamic behaviours of RNN,
which further allows us to improve the extraction precision. Based on the
extracted model, we propose an explanation method for RNNs including a word
embedding method -- Transition Matrix Embeddings (TME) and TME-based task
oriented explanation for the target RNN. Our evaluation demonstrates the
advantage of our method in extraction precision than existing approaches, and
the effectiveness of TME-based explanation method in applications to
pretraining and adversarial example generation. | [
0.0136015108,
0.0626581162,
-0.020343177,
0.0724691749,
-0.0220377892,
-0.000746843,
0.0072709899,
-0.0392086692,
-0.0520733148,
-0.0329417065,
0.0120476391,
-0.029932661,
0.0186247956,
0.0249858648,
0.0378240682,
-0.060495317,
0.0375843234,
-0.0397589616,
-0.0295128245,
0.0383129977,
0.0073941178,
0.0023209271,
-0.0229795836,
0.0437909439,
-0.0032530092,
0.0124578541,
-0.0453709438,
-0.0390780605,
0.0281459428,
-0.0482207872,
-0.013186872,
-0.0135525987,
0.0524861813,
0.0364142843,
0.000002109,
-0.028375756,
0.0001071842,
-0.0082034431,
-0.0425866395,
-0.0005762124,
0.0013082628,
-0.0129415449,
-0.0041467245,
0.0169384256,
-0.0071916566,
-0.024785798,
0.0656049177,
0.033961039,
0.0751242489,
0.0836446881,
0.0160266012,
-0.0423379652,
0.0011141783,
-0.038213823,
-0.0179412812,
-0.0650450364,
0.0392959453,
-0.0114844898,
0.0047524744,
-0.0496872813,
-0.031187024,
-0.0080934819,
0.0336249173,
-0.0125157349,
-0.0183391683,
0.0165525675,
0.030908756,
-0.0185746402,
-0.0429103561,
0.0875163525,
-0.0259180926,
-0.0032732978,
0.0308420416,
-0.0138728749,
-0.0053100688,
-0.0403071195,
-0.0539925285,
0.0214946363,
0.0506323017,
0.0426026285,
0.0040974454,
0.0363297872,
0.0519024916,
-0.0018836332,
-0.0496003255,
0.0494734868,
-0.019578442,
-0.0018552076,
-0.053954158,
-0.0381126925,
0.044174578,
-0.0478445552,
0.0465883799,
0.1071441025,
0.0237781387,
0.0282287765,
-0.0112801641,
-0.0465288386,
-0.0035315522,
-0.0185658429,
0.1045426279,
0.0502774864,
-0.0275231507,
0.0195580646,
0.0090788575,
0.0759731457,
-0.0278607868,
-0.0270403661,
-0.0368256979,
0.0159269068,
-0.0806884617,
-0.0036528569,
-0.0162359197,
0.0172196906,
-0.0255968217,
-0.0101825269,
-0.0445944183,
0.0320308879,
-0.0405945219,
-0.0020918769,
0.003515095,
0.0404078066,
-0.0579257756,
0.0152614666,
-0.0405957699,
0.0295270868,
-0.0251660421,
0.0018858878,
0.0122762006,
-0.0135328993,
-0.0510631241,
0.0087851761,
0.0438800789,
-0.0223732237,
-0.0127255358,
0.1127133667,
0.0349413566,
-0.0467045903,
-0.0384861305,
-0.0176117532,
-0.0088645257,
-0.0629353672,
0.017279448,
-0.0004270346,
0.0325255617,
-0.0383153185,
-0.0217722822,
-0.0098878806,
0.0161210261,
-0.0038740959,
-0.0163326226,
0.0947137475,
-0.0361816958,
-0.0308351275,
0.005770274,
-0.0053739031,
0.012443454,
0.0076817726,
0.0388887562,
0.041391734,
-0.0074686976,
-0.035812825,
0.0277964659,
-0.0052972771,
0.0115931472,
-0.044501517,
-0.0362245627,
-0.0207110457,
-0.0232641622,
0.0268959925,
0.0686272532,
0.0174064506,
-0.021267822,
0.0200882312,
0.0438023359,
0.0238758959,
0.0241646711,
0.0471161716,
0.0675150007,
-0.0160409305,
0.0217739902,
0.0500426404,
-0.0482955724,
0.0159161296,
-0.0190712139,
0.0250319056,
-0.0051475614,
0.0311849788,
-0.0261791721,
-0.0740359649,
0.0107846241,
-0.0433486663,
0.0320872813,
-0.0119302208,
0.0613001995,
0.0232548621,
-0.049449034,
-0.0099099968,
0.0340029709,
-0.0202383082,
0.0048807827,
-0.0442385338,
0.0229440127,
0.0705268309,
0.0275269169,
-0.0653471425,
-0.0049706483,
0.0081376601,
0.0027532545,
-0.0010626152,
-0.0023408006,
-0.0147615755,
0.028973775,
-0.0545355715,
-0.0247968137,
-0.0431893095,
0.0354219191,
0.0425649732,
-0.0399615727,
-0.013015531,
0.0377712063,
-0.0450357348,
-0.0599595308,
0.0568252653,
0.0075950269,
-0.0607770868,
0.0345518887,
0.0147041539,
0.0539371781,
0.0177116543,
0.0142591884,
0.0225397851,
0.0205850732,
-0.0459770262,
-0.0043961853,
0.0188033003,
-0.066789709,
-0.0295990668,
0.0372108631,
-0.0028877244,
0.006236928,
0.0479405671,
-0.0609625131,
-0.0733115077,
0.0555652939,
-0.0485684387,
0.0247369651,
-0.0289607979,
-0.0241435487,
0.0430450402,
0.0440269113,
0.0016404522,
0.06672021,
-0.0112156542,
-0.0141432257,
0.0010825091,
-0.0484049916,
-0.0220810473,
-0.0045770295,
-0.0135785583,
0.0188565757,
-0.0352160782,
-0.0013028692,
-0.0205510333,
-0.0373311564,
-0.0238016117,
0.0142853409,
-0.0222019423,
0.0252529811,
-0.0236328058,
0.0445255637,
0.0201052222,
-0.0016453104,
0.0250868686,
-0.0264709741,
-0.0428649075,
0.032769274,
-0.0273628607,
-0.0049697035,
0.09246663,
0.0446017236,
-0.0880463868,
-0.0955060348,
-0.0031899526,
-0.0325409956,
0.0556472354,
-0.0080983471,
-0.0107442504,
-0.0388235524,
0.0173094086,
0.03466665,
0.0247383155,
-0.0406860337,
-0.0397011451,
0.0377434567,
0.0098686917,
0.0255011711,
0.0443783887,
0.0230880752,
0.1265241951,
0.0796087533,
-0.0212302413,
-0.015360726,
0.0142201772,
-0.046768494,
0.0303096753,
0.0048828437,
-0.0060494747,
0.0142062819,
0.1050984412,
0.0002006088,
0.0064642699,
-0.0305677038,
-0.0070926691,
0.0063587264,
0.0224783532,
0.015543269,
-0.0487854145,
-0.0406480283,
0.0205887724,
-0.0094825821,
-0.03236904,
0.0704260021,
-0.0505834147,
0.0208713915,
-0.0119761704,
-0.0551160574,
-0.0331283025,
0.0580298379,
0.0072931675,
-0.0014888156,
0.0229571313,
-0.0190532431,
0.01136587,
-0.045233205,
0.0056810379,
-0.0101256222,
-0.0197027735,
-0.014187769,
-0.0280487686,
-0.0097222524,
0.014216328,
-0.035354495,
0.0094989352,
-0.0364125371,
0.0110818595,
-0.0220998749,
-0.0206387807,
0.0005587394,
-0.0190382022,
0.0075056264,
0.0315075554,
-0.0078607863,
0.0102323359,
-0.0489791967,
0.0354340151,
0.0344430432,
0.0348874293,
0.0348865092,
-0.0352492481,
0.0197397396,
-0.0048859282,
0.0283247828,
0.001889774,
-0.0966047049,
-0.0076772277,
-0.0069003962,
-0.0528033897,
-0.0064861472,
0.0620078221,
0.0113681341,
-0.0957934782,
0.0027827837,
0.0990394652,
0.0117651103,
-0.0238183606,
0.0511618666,
0.0275556128,
-0.0522684827,
0.0258632377,
0.0234990362,
-0.0615747496,
-0.023404954,
0.0090952357,
0.039906282,
0.0132430522,
-0.0099268015,
0.0053056129,
-0.0574839301,
0.0300826356,
-0.0064059845,
-0.0398688056,
-0.051427938,
-0.0259065144,
0.0025876255,
0.0071526403,
0.0044920058,
-0.0448204055,
0.0188050792,
0.0221076366,
0.0460208058,
-0.0503998809,
-0.072441794,
0.0023919183,
-0.0046322807,
0.0492652804,
0.0600245446,
0.0641640574,
-0.0128408875,
-0.0356869325,
0.0267291162,
-0.0323547684,
0.0229708869,
0.0213136505,
0.0329687893,
0.0336575322,
-0.0414841473,
-0.0127346897,
0.0398257561,
-0.06083785,
-0.0381455198,
-0.0355906747,
0.0837815627,
-0.0197462533,
-0.0289972927,
-0.0009737177,
-0.0588537417,
0.0590756573,
0.0593609698,
0.0708984435,
-0.0172882061,
-0.0426766463,
-0.0076809009,
-0.0004400974,
-0.0586813763,
-0.0311940871,
-0.0281971842,
0.0412955843,
-0.0111889681,
-0.0686297119,
-0.048999995,
0.0020180049,
0.0197826307,
-0.0036609098,
-0.014588031,
0.0335447229,
-0.0099300807,
-0.0445702374,
0.0483082458,
-0.0135187767,
0.0174745955,
-0.0065657333,
-0.0327905007,
0.0196579881,
-0.0009718466,
-0.0203704778,
0.0088151572,
-0.056905102,
-0.0413021371,
0.0205535088,
0.0314665362,
0.0187255647,
0.0236454867,
-0.0294252336,
-0.0225817282,
0.0307906941,
-0.0039443686,
-0.011853396,
-0.0286928788,
0.0756381601,
-0.0276949387,
0.0081925634,
0.0230314638,
-0.0190690961,
0.023216065,
0.0032930465,
0.0425176211,
-0.0197421629,
-0.0084865009,
0.027956279,
-0.0143136624,
0.0357128941,
0.0077280994,
-0.0308678038,
-0.0410515182,
0.0057387361,
-0.0256321058,
-0.0133820409,
-0.052858945,
0.0142093292,
0.0165725052,
0.0034630299,
0.0003997534,
-0.0722180307,
0.0155939339,
-0.0213581417,
-0.0231787544,
0.0313636772,
0.0491056629,
0.0163382832,
-0.0533653833,
0.015961783,
0.013837277,
-0.0096533895,
-0.0208961815,
0.0357124396,
-0.0020158004,
0.0332738496,
-0.0010438787,
0.0182937812,
-0.0456993431,
0.0489105582,
-0.0471886136,
0.0183086377,
-0.0073781484,
-0.0102036847,
0.0487215966,
-0.0385781489,
0.0433616564,
0.0059926854,
0.027971603,
0.0005603652,
0.0753327757,
-0.0062285699,
-0.0088542793,
0.0311583206,
0.0336547792,
-0.0415348746,
0.0019131114,
0.0713436678,
0.0237931609,
0.065902032,
0.0167684946,
0.007819972,
-0.013301081,
-0.0387109406,
0.0113928951,
0.0281740781,
-0.0264040418,
-0.0165489875,
-0.0404269286,
-0.0864582583,
0.0213021431,
-0.0029378003,
-0.0144094303,
-0.0116663696,
0.0268661212,
0.0381417796,
0.0218936875,
0.0285823923,
-0.0278054886,
-0.0165767111,
0.0408706069,
-0.0314908139,
-0.0206922423,
-6.476869548e-33,
-0.0077504199,
-0.0254490953,
-0.0039279284,
-0.0089844605,
-0.0163518321,
0.0255900621,
-0.0931380689,
-0.0362719595,
-0.0013509772,
0.0231846441,
0.0115685919,
-0.0027953451,
0.018367663,
0.0245958623,
-0.0209847912,
-0.0361156948,
0.0273370985,
0.014818239,
-0.0065581496,
0.0191982593,
0.0647024661,
0.0511954315,
0.0439841263,
-0.0742174387,
0.022717027,
0.0178739466,
-0.0196554922,
-0.0085633378,
0.0217274874,
0.0606847815,
-0.0702663586,
0.0400797464,
0.0197804011,
-0.0326193646,
-0.0241467003,
0.0100418963,
-0.085188441,
-0.044503022,
0.0036645022,
0.0090445857,
-0.0396415815,
-0.0392470099,
0.0641075447,
-0.0080539314,
0.043147292,
0.0117657501,
0.0335432999,
-0.0220373347,
-0.0114213815,
-0.0240554176,
-0.0666687787,
0.0036711895,
-0.0386415794,
-0.0445999764,
0.0348457098,
-0.0048267846,
-0.0000797274,
-0.0231743045,
-0.0591000319,
-0.0472171307,
0.0176656842,
0.0289112497,
0.0283015259,
0.0141389668,
-0.0119572049,
0.0427693166,
-0.0179134272,
-0.0094176084,
-0.0366223827,
0.0328553244,
0.0041716285,
0.0402091928,
0.0518599935,
-0.0292720534,
0.0623565987,
-0.0083333589,
-0.080162771,
0.0007062787,
-0.0161069501,
0.0715794712,
0.0164444093,
-0.008689248,
-0.0241407342,
0.0003640193,
-0.0042795343,
-0.0217253733,
-0.005844601,
-0.0021268344,
0.0338820703,
-0.0013159076,
-0.0417753123,
0.0119243292,
-0.0219124109,
-0.0514440797,
-0.0008152675,
0.0039543007,
0.0062533952,
0.0176250376,
0.0177593809,
-0.0164987445,
-0.0151915615,
-0.0285633486,
0.0075131776,
-0.0134865735,
0.0518656708,
-0.003467706,
0.0401306003,
0.066920504,
-0.0326318666,
-0.019663034,
-0.0568899922,
0.0036666978,
-0.0103168134,
0.0552932285,
0.0367900953,
0.0126446057,
-0.0417570695,
0.0220690519,
0.0097162193,
-0.0042115916,
-0.0155467587,
0.0163101815,
-0.0187061336,
0.0381487347,
-0.0272396579,
-0.0815677494,
-0.0118509615,
0.049132999,
0.0250340682,
-0.0452573374,
-0.0142111471,
0.0032122168,
2.89e-7,
0.0321252607,
0.002355543,
0.0563666709,
0.0151571669,
0.025847353,
0.0221707448,
-0.0258943718,
0.0026318408,
-0.0183288977,
-0.0334577821,
0.025808325,
0.0453743562,
0.0402104817,
-0.0092858411,
-0.0325171016,
-0.0232937802,
-0.0520495176,
-0.0323086753,
-0.0333234519,
-0.0200839527,
0.0296750553,
0.104687959,
0.0325310864,
0.01179088,
-0.0056061298,
-0.0258827358,
0.0370632969,
0.0063392599,
0.0494068041,
-0.0129463384,
0.0451703332,
-0.0171152577,
-0.0104662292,
-0.0364770107,
-0.004460278,
0.0706427023,
-0.0521988645,
0.0468382388,
-0.0123677803,
-0.027174674,
-0.0046380865,
-0.0266186967,
0.0225990135,
-0.0123458309,
0.063119866,
-0.0474690236,
-0.0335015915,
-0.0402108394,
-0.0268392004,
0.0031341847,
0.0001683236,
0.0048758215,
0.0198608022,
0.0148812691,
-0.0189926978,
-0.0372152254,
0.0042092223,
-0.0849734321,
-0.0072145043,
-0.0086387256,
-0.0443337932,
0.0615467243,
-0.061364945,
-0.0443232171,
0.0537890196,
-0.0361475907,
0.0058259764,
2.497323743e-34,
0.0018805837,
-0.0213883445,
0.0118787196,
0.0507470816,
0.0341379046,
0.0377933048,
-0.0188561585,
0.0208601784,
0.0391093232,
-0.0618467107,
-0.0277758576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14030v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14030v2 | My Boli: Code-mixed Marathi-English Corpora, Pretrained Language Models and Evaluation Benchmarks | 2023-06-24T18:17:38 | 2023-07-20T13:54:05 | Tanmay Chavan, Omkar Gokhale, Aditya Kane, Shantanu Patankar, Raviraj Joshi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The research on code-mixed data is limited due to the unavailability of
dedicated code-mixed datasets and pre-trained language models. In this work, we
focus on the low-resource Indian language Marathi which lacks any prior work in
code-mixing. We present L3Cube-MeCorpus, a large code-mixed Marathi-English
(Mr-En) corpus with 10 million social media sentences for pretraining. We also
release L3Cube-MeBERT and MeRoBERTa, code-mixed BERT-based transformer models
pre-trained on MeCorpus. Furthermore, for benchmarking, we present three
supervised datasets MeHate, MeSent, and MeLID for downstream tasks like
code-mixed Mr-En hate speech detection, sentiment analysis, and language
identification respectively. These evaluation datasets individually consist of
manually annotated \url{~}12,000 Marathi-English code-mixed tweets. Ablations
show that the models trained on this novel corpus significantly outperform the
existing state-of-the-art BERT models. This is the first work that presents
artifacts for code-mixed Marathi research. All datasets and models are publicly
released at https://github.com/l3cube-pune/MarathiNLP . | [
0.0202765837,
0.0483128242,
-0.0059557483,
0.0557976104,
-0.0098539628,
0.04499631,
-0.040960025,
0.0282317381,
-0.0025849321,
-0.0376646854,
-0.0675253049,
-0.0142849395,
0.0227810163,
0.0417651758,
0.0245422162,
-0.019489564,
0.012012654,
-0.0035723534,
-0.0080245268,
-0.0028712112,
0.0664343387,
0.0354368091,
-0.0055189324,
0.0325394049,
-0.0705303922,
0.0227736495,
0.0422037505,
0.0079074474,
0.0180176664,
-0.0132319909,
0.0590552874,
0.0619145222,
-0.0079328474,
0.0440639555,
0.0000018293,
-0.0309334323,
-0.0546668507,
-0.0144467102,
0.0215901956,
-0.0238074549,
0.0700931326,
-0.012501535,
-0.0091155944,
0.0573462732,
-0.034756422,
-0.0010203096,
0.1024003103,
-0.0041789589,
0.0545953996,
0.1216145977,
-0.0383627191,
-0.0508684553,
0.0399203785,
0.009175403,
-0.0444684811,
0.0335855633,
0.0149624385,
-0.0238928776,
0.0202856548,
-0.020034194,
-0.0159010328,
0.003817393,
0.0084519042,
0.0008761318,
0.0153115662,
-0.0297729354,
-0.063316837,
-0.0120951319,
0.0319480486,
0.0483105369,
-0.0914028138,
-0.0675946549,
0.0209717955,
-0.0097140642,
-0.0817680657,
-0.0758572519,
-0.0016416963,
0.0034808801,
-0.0470211394,
0.083832927,
0.0051244334,
0.0113028558,
0.0230602622,
0.0166415609,
0.0115851648,
0.0032621929,
0.0176399406,
-0.0223587696,
-0.0254768357,
0.0091355387,
0.0157805067,
-0.0411643311,
0.0309481323,
0.0299188402,
-0.0049225255,
0.0128880143,
-0.0341781676,
-0.0894333273,
0.0192515478,
-0.0372038558,
-0.0146667045,
0.0551494509,
-0.0660906136,
-0.0091423597,
-0.0331272073,
0.0141551737,
-0.0461750627,
0.0401731841,
0.0039358465,
-0.0438086428,
0.0029588535,
-0.0084549049,
-0.0091190934,
0.0046931943,
-0.0170628764,
0.0601252429,
-0.0511984453,
0.0144856237,
-0.02481094,
0.0156002454,
0.0270764958,
-0.0436155647,
-0.018145116,
-0.0374618433,
0.0447879806,
0.0155699151,
-0.0191779956,
0.0127313873,
-0.0152478311,
-0.0931003019,
0.0103756329,
0.0179659091,
-0.012706141,
-0.0339932628,
0.0073220469,
0.0039214222,
-0.011213433,
-0.0482495576,
-0.061758969,
0.0344797336,
-0.0503708832,
-0.0332706943,
-0.0111987879,
-0.0830663368,
0.0157217123,
0.0259073786,
0.0359073356,
-0.0403867215,
-0.0041696425,
-0.000030722,
-0.0203731619,
0.0823307708,
-0.0339326933,
-0.0236720461,
0.024756832,
0.0303836595,
0.0200444199,
0.0751179978,
0.0248329174,
-0.0037039127,
0.0300809126,
-0.0143359108,
0.0165973101,
0.0902320221,
-0.0094130319,
0.0138019603,
-0.0065667625,
0.0319218338,
-0.0417019539,
-0.0414343998,
0.0072612339,
0.0378330052,
-0.0008879657,
0.0083026784,
-0.0043881633,
0.0235697888,
0.0199927222,
0.021219898,
0.0170277171,
0.0017866461,
0.036335256,
0.0169181153,
0.0136636235,
-0.0245249774,
-0.0580268688,
-0.0241756085,
0.0435876288,
0.0452772938,
-0.0330100469,
-0.0076705394,
-0.0316473506,
-0.0710486323,
0.0151376678,
-0.0453237928,
0.032104142,
0.0081386417,
-0.0497410707,
-0.0103895534,
0.0407400392,
-0.0652635768,
0.034920454,
-0.0467044525,
0.0174563657,
0.0205005482,
0.0211994201,
-0.0691523775,
0.0016985196,
-0.0191643406,
-0.0342451446,
0.0084445057,
-0.0000879468,
-0.004590773,
-0.0116198082,
-0.047912389,
0.0161166266,
0.0125889024,
-0.0017645059,
0.0288413186,
0.0316278487,
0.0547332093,
-0.0126397032,
0.0386335924,
-0.013195212,
0.0086869253,
0.0193113778,
0.0280841254,
-0.001251157,
0.0020367124,
0.0695521683,
-0.0046764044,
-0.0398074761,
-0.0282571837,
-0.0006657555,
-0.0010230298,
-0.0364090987,
0.0354831293,
-0.0099784322,
-0.0682299882,
-0.0119756246,
-0.0466205925,
-0.0218873471,
0.0452010036,
-0.0012070964,
-0.0255417861,
0.0356355347,
-0.0116610993,
0.0639794394,
-0.0424898192,
0.0376385897,
-0.0125605613,
-0.0108092921,
-0.0114733661,
0.0358162485,
-0.0057304366,
-0.0090597207,
-0.0092157042,
0.0020034437,
0.0711764842,
0.0086521478,
-0.0396526381,
0.0189556647,
0.0267648734,
0.0213812031,
0.0133536188,
0.0126618538,
-0.0278927311,
-0.0523011535,
-0.1045477465,
-0.0168469995,
-0.0388757363,
0.0036337969,
0.0124802263,
0.0772758126,
-0.0120336106,
0.0095007848,
0.0041419212,
-0.04027519,
0.0543792658,
0.0074719079,
0.0327502675,
-0.0226942319,
0.0334502161,
-0.0569065735,
-0.0148819229,
-0.027952604,
0.0296743903,
-0.0427121967,
-0.035495013,
-0.0100296382,
0.0115499496,
0.0082788365,
0.0272376016,
-0.0099524558,
-0.0872628465,
-0.0076924013,
-0.0185941383,
0.0719229281,
-0.0014212684,
0.0006220675,
0.0147086866,
-0.0165181886,
-0.0147794299,
-0.0172880217,
-0.005603997,
0.0297026169,
-0.0069611552,
-0.0114127453,
-0.010014317,
0.0377035551,
0.0677443519,
-0.0218076035,
0.0015898992,
-0.0728285089,
-0.0458353795,
-0.034794461,
0.0157991424,
0.0573868155,
-0.0358596519,
-0.0361979753,
0.031296514,
-0.0315119773,
-0.0561167784,
0.0480832644,
-0.0526633486,
-0.0230074264,
-0.0770553574,
0.00781962,
-0.0492921397,
-0.0067561143,
-0.0162557531,
0.0062157135,
-0.0421358123,
-0.0181684066,
-0.0299140122,
-0.016505504,
-0.0259953998,
-0.0311639775,
0.0140390703,
-0.0240635388,
0.0380237661,
-0.0193884205,
-0.0436986275,
-0.0263421871,
-0.0805444568,
-0.0358578637,
-0.0234598201,
0.0809628963,
-0.030405663,
0.0670618936,
0.0321531408,
-0.0467593893,
0.0099133924,
0.0145595847,
0.0131026842,
0.0299762562,
0.0400678515,
-0.00026614,
-0.0314002559,
-0.0026272766,
0.0174632054,
-0.0104065696,
-0.0338404961,
0.0359020941,
-0.0127544207,
-0.0475728251,
0.0068583717,
0.0245286319,
-0.0031732982,
-0.0083437925,
-0.0370727107,
0.0486452095,
0.0478392951,
-0.0031515511,
0.0776746869,
0.0363489874,
-0.0289447717,
-0.027439123,
-0.0305058435,
0.0307200756,
-0.00498458,
0.0166079737,
-0.0881179348,
-0.0125406077,
0.0010749294,
-0.0311586093,
0.0005708549,
-0.0087005375,
-0.0241764151,
-0.1109332889,
-0.0302553363,
0.0052762819,
0.0211368259,
-0.0428312309,
0.0195096452,
-0.0364768095,
-0.0089408904,
-0.0301953722,
-0.0108576706,
-0.0334750116,
-0.0142927337,
0.0477264971,
-0.0466533229,
-0.0172564313,
0.0003403068,
-0.021169398,
0.0304813422,
0.0612114184,
-0.0124371722,
-0.0464824475,
-0.0300741699,
0.0070654838,
-0.0269739274,
-0.0453106016,
-0.0435759574,
0.0382439569,
-0.0336249396,
-0.0372593291,
0.0124408361,
0.0225175507,
0.002010524,
-0.0225801729,
-0.0352979638,
0.0323995352,
0.0328280143,
-0.003075199,
-0.018451849,
-0.0049840529,
0.0034843858,
0.0151240127,
0.026722692,
-0.0504097082,
0.0037860093,
-0.0044191573,
0.0152246552,
-0.0498244986,
-0.0062088682,
-0.0012338496,
-0.0171499774,
-0.0308041777,
-0.0246993639,
-0.03558423,
0.0267049838,
0.0331903547,
0.0074801468,
-0.015095857,
0.012239839,
-0.0035033547,
-0.0361026786,
0.0164457206,
-0.0014829761,
0.0469353944,
-0.0876716673,
-0.0375938602,
0.0243983436,
-0.0034392274,
0.0042898702,
-0.0525936335,
-0.0794838965,
-0.0363180749,
0.0227069687,
0.0435072705,
0.0203946996,
0.029756628,
-0.0508262254,
-0.0661314502,
0.0139236497,
-0.0185186882,
-0.0732284263,
-0.0190006662,
0.0737147108,
0.0248189233,
-0.0042581768,
0.0222566351,
-0.0478975475,
-0.0037242617,
0.0041563986,
-0.0535963774,
-0.0460250415,
0.0183819868,
-0.0031697352,
-0.0084286677,
0.044558771,
-0.0526769906,
-0.0239925347,
-0.0298424345,
0.007445001,
0.024164129,
-0.0141321765,
-0.0441945754,
-0.037198998,
0.0424798243,
0.0076935557,
-0.0504923947,
0.0156819671,
-0.0298455823,
0.018492436,
0.027176708,
0.0984468311,
0.1004800722,
0.061430078,
0.0258460455,
0.0205393825,
-0.0087092314,
0.0179370381,
0.0188359637,
-0.0012561315,
-0.0106404787,
0.0233748499,
-0.0131253917,
0.0117730778,
0.0700790584,
0.0424275137,
0.0396051146,
0.0414542444,
-0.0088527268,
-0.015589321,
0.0337355472,
-0.0239839982,
0.0800520033,
0.0045440504,
0.0118160546,
-0.0261930693,
0.0159079954,
-0.0515496917,
0.0274162311,
0.031752713,
-0.0115734385,
-0.0326648317,
0.0173437204,
0.0699037611,
0.000872227,
0.0291234031,
0.0248494186,
0.0236418191,
-0.0181619823,
0.0363289826,
0.0622773431,
0.0027061009,
0.0277655926,
-0.0164039787,
-0.0371314436,
-0.0467160456,
0.0406890698,
-0.0328609198,
0.0344389789,
0.0154358502,
0.0150627429,
0.0397410244,
0.0017805081,
0.0555374399,
-0.0194113441,
0.0140599767,
0.0639254525,
-0.0528733917,
0.0436156616,
-6.061129155e-33,
-0.0008423033,
0.020064583,
-0.0320394449,
-0.0405657142,
0.0161837228,
0.0025975613,
-0.0003082228,
-0.0180931706,
-0.0041438639,
-0.0110509405,
-0.0222100616,
0.0218990725,
0.0053286804,
-0.0065309876,
0.0332539752,
-0.0099388873,
0.0445261076,
0.0543607883,
0.0006768898,
0.0062520942,
0.0162319019,
0.014306128,
0.0312505029,
-0.0119357156,
0.0187759642,
-0.0439564623,
-0.0445447527,
-0.0060827611,
0.0199088603,
0.0499267243,
-0.0346661918,
0.0343343206,
0.0327571668,
0.039436046,
-0.0224984773,
0.0382815078,
-0.0618252046,
0.0287866835,
0.0311498065,
0.0792799667,
0.0121679092,
-0.0261378493,
0.0410984196,
-0.0082810186,
-0.0371706523,
0.0061180098,
0.0028627098,
0.0251199491,
0.0434716642,
-0.0164187029,
-0.0837522522,
0.0735553876,
-0.0292015485,
-0.0185054652,
0.0493966527,
0.0239931345,
0.018363012,
0.0602003299,
-0.0568677187,
-0.0071189511,
-0.0054216064,
0.0266338103,
0.0194234699,
0.0151013797,
-0.0519488752,
0.0285992958,
0.0313130319,
-0.0654960349,
0.0221207663,
0.0502360277,
0.0342763849,
0.0312007125,
0.0169353224,
0.0302276202,
0.0206656363,
-0.0789754912,
-0.0364724882,
0.0358313359,
-0.0092152022,
0.0109371198,
-0.0173417367,
0.0130435126,
-0.0387838408,
-0.0415495932,
0.0613241307,
-0.0699897036,
-0.0270838793,
-0.0176887978,
0.0306412447,
-0.0211291332,
-0.0088616973,
0.0484970659,
0.0392728075,
-0.0397703834,
0.0191948432,
0.0054997201,
-0.0429262035,
0.0397645235,
0.0046310672,
0.095457986,
-0.0410586111,
-0.0319754854,
0.0404300727,
0.0300480314,
0.0165356901,
0.0021145078,
0.0721749887,
0.0299773663,
-0.0931859165,
0.0155891273,
0.0048284847,
0.0629797503,
-0.0082018869,
0.0741416961,
0.0004695359,
0.0195321366,
-0.0076475656,
-0.0003766298,
0.0051731113,
0.0267783143,
-0.0305917859,
-0.0114459563,
-0.0112707894,
0.0137321018,
-0.0032159525,
-0.0137108471,
-0.0009153815,
0.0370603651,
0.0116274888,
-0.0447387844,
0.0147833787,
-0.012086492,
2.595e-7,
0.021731589,
0.0544741042,
0.0545951128,
-0.082870245,
-0.0054352898,
0.0068637957,
-0.0670121908,
0.0078630913,
-0.0127863083,
0.0322802998,
-0.024960693,
-0.012768548,
0.0566771328,
0.0372071639,
-0.0522597842,
-0.0275498927,
-0.0646956638,
0.0159234516,
-0.0499804616,
-0.002105677,
-0.0051873871,
0.1031572148,
0.03966197,
0.0015255024,
-0.019057665,
0.0103708804,
0.0424344465,
0.0202509239,
-0.0063405475,
0.0109477742,
-0.0218799785,
0.021333877,
-0.0194648933,
-0.0509957783,
-0.0231636465,
0.0204682201,
0.0370676778,
0.0510714352,
-0.0159499831,
0.0021341052,
0.0155798439,
-0.0049431119,
-0.0511441976,
-0.047417637,
0.0644024387,
0.0445861258,
-0.0213043094,
0.0012005022,
-0.0139805879,
-0.0061137257,
0.0417280123,
-0.0118360762,
-0.0349674746,
0.0293118116,
0.0351886302,
-0.0559567921,
-0.0355649889,
-0.0725780651,
-0.009571326,
0.0165363159,
0.0030042906,
-0.0344583988,
-0.0210155137,
0.0481091775,
0.0675541386,
-0.0243658461,
0.0428343043,
2.247972463e-34,
0.0677758604,
0.0005477751,
0.0221174527,
-0.0002124988,
0.0195511077,
-0.0215471238,
0.0020515299,
0.014199703,
0.0245917179,
-0.0169881079,
-0.0142548941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14003v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14003v1 | Weakly Supervised Multi-Label Classification of Full-Text Scientific Papers | 2023-06-24T15:27:55 | 2023-06-24T15:27:55 | Yu Zhang, Bowen Jin, Xiusi Chen, Yanzhen Shen, Yunyi Zhang, Yu Meng, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.LG | Instead of relying on human-annotated training samples to build a classifier,
weakly supervised scientific paper classification aims to classify papers only
using category descriptions (e.g., category names, category-indicative
keywords). Existing studies on weakly supervised paper classification are less
concerned with two challenges: (1) Papers should be classified into not only
coarse-grained research topics but also fine-grained themes, and potentially
into multiple themes, given a large and fine-grained label space; and (2) full
text should be utilized to complement the paper title and abstract for
classification. Moreover, instead of viewing the entire paper as a long linear
sequence, one should exploit the structural information such as citation links
across papers and the hierarchy of sections and paragraphs in each paper. To
tackle these challenges, in this study, we propose FUTEX, a framework that uses
the cross-paper network structure and the in-paper hierarchy structure to
classify full-text scientific papers under weak supervision. A network-aware
contrastive fine-tuning module and a hierarchy-aware aggregation module are
designed to leverage the two types of structural signals, respectively.
Experiments on two benchmark datasets demonstrate that FUTEX significantly
outperforms competitive baselines and is on par with fully supervised
classifiers that use 1,000 to 60,000 ground-truth training samples. | [
0.0313753523,
0.0179328155,
0.0194818061,
-0.0079075238,
-0.0035111096,
0.0158948749,
0.0348761491,
-0.0020414807,
0.0549913161,
-0.0468990952,
-0.0548226647,
0.0126454262,
-0.0058779018,
0.0186114479,
0.0261826217,
-0.0316270813,
0.0305562373,
0.0087970486,
0.0594858043,
0.0165348891,
0.0013403776,
0.0033345059,
0.030242227,
-0.0079421774,
0.0521759987,
-0.029691238,
0.0019426798,
-0.0120655959,
0.0153771471,
-0.0315643847,
0.0716980621,
0.0349852033,
0.0338150263,
0.056528125,
0.0000015694,
-0.043182265,
-0.0315330625,
0.0062766457,
0.0233406276,
0.0046780067,
0.0536026359,
-0.0706807598,
0.0331066549,
0.002380217,
0.0286839455,
-0.0300232377,
0.0189096592,
0.1047722772,
0.0226386338,
0.0276141912,
-0.0257499628,
-0.0635924116,
0.0666511208,
-0.0161575153,
0.0023088658,
-0.062337622,
0.0401252881,
-0.0022761703,
0.0195137616,
0.0528730266,
0.0238689501,
0.0215161443,
0.0120253768,
-0.0549745671,
0.0504606701,
0.0614559054,
-0.0236668717,
0.0072430326,
0.0065029366,
0.0465536751,
-0.032196261,
-0.0417285413,
0.0513883233,
-0.0317668617,
0.0077207037,
0.0227743424,
-0.0165036172,
-0.0365582816,
-0.0239240136,
-0.0474735089,
0.0390472487,
0.037541572,
0.0165476184,
0.0510248169,
0.006653497,
0.0094513875,
0.0013449879,
-0.0607624725,
0.0316229835,
-0.0044944766,
0.0106309997,
-0.0056557078,
0.00467637,
0.0225383826,
-0.0022675656,
-0.0101887928,
-0.0111883599,
-0.0394182093,
0.0643223897,
-0.0642563179,
-0.0145942317,
-0.0480114147,
-0.0040310356,
0.0747950599,
0.0037287031,
-0.0351495333,
-0.043099314,
-0.0054283873,
0.0058467654,
-0.0253394544,
-0.0349491462,
-0.0268527605,
-0.0171768367,
0.0542377494,
0.0289870612,
-0.0363588892,
-0.0290702302,
-0.0104165934,
0.0023365319,
-0.0372432992,
-0.0187788047,
0.0128464131,
-0.041756656,
0.0169565901,
0.0169719569,
0.0184560716,
-0.0248909779,
0.0652630106,
-0.0034032655,
0.0528793,
0.0142652513,
0.0262724943,
0.0096631609,
-0.0341086239,
0.0420769975,
0.0209423341,
-0.0271862149,
-0.0555385873,
-0.0517143905,
-0.0495905951,
-0.0340891294,
-0.0432442352,
0.049559962,
-0.0397989452,
0.0095908437,
-0.0177796576,
0.0081556328,
-0.00556341,
-0.0163862575,
-0.0203383751,
-0.0395662412,
-0.0008917305,
-0.0378139317,
-0.0585600026,
0.0867077187,
0.0256295539,
0.0044755326,
0.0123994183,
-0.0118959201,
0.0280332137,
0.0203543343,
-0.0145631405,
-0.0035104412,
-0.0190984234,
0.0248578899,
-0.0109120505,
0.0582217649,
-0.0360728167,
-0.0343809389,
0.0091918921,
-0.0083708288,
-0.0100859515,
-0.0260113105,
-0.0030152192,
0.0003043721,
-0.0039320122,
0.0290778559,
0.0315455943,
-0.0076625147,
0.0064207539,
0.0238264073,
0.009866206,
0.0091933757,
0.025720967,
-0.0177794956,
0.0233931523,
0.0627809986,
0.0001243499,
-0.035023272,
-0.0288404673,
0.006172047,
-0.0005395239,
-0.0093437228,
-0.0302321333,
0.1101948395,
0.0390386432,
0.0210786685,
-0.0094535518,
0.0521353371,
0.0067044171,
0.0184720606,
0.0063535245,
0.0437161587,
-0.0404199325,
0.0251901485,
-0.0414458402,
-0.0136888027,
0.0039519765,
0.0551218763,
0.0226462986,
0.0357563309,
-0.0296916235,
-0.0198326334,
-0.0303926338,
-0.0301453173,
-0.0041775382,
0.0266938955,
0.0048623658,
-0.0368364975,
-0.0254190601,
0.0076169511,
-0.0104253069,
-0.0484939925,
0.022427788,
0.001795546,
0.0179949924,
0.0114742173,
-0.0324256867,
0.0354993939,
0.0187926199,
-0.0153506715,
-0.0018718672,
0.0652654767,
-0.03112657,
-0.0379991084,
-0.0510355383,
0.0005054856,
0.0405606627,
0.0273819733,
-0.0243609846,
-0.0042391689,
0.0417465605,
-0.0353926457,
-0.0475118458,
0.040829137,
-0.0035358565,
-0.0322686546,
0.0170933679,
-0.0317763835,
-0.0135921156,
0.0126550552,
-0.0291713309,
0.0658666715,
0.0373092368,
0.0860082582,
0.0118077155,
-0.0299927574,
0.0137378154,
0.0184713043,
0.0068322443,
-0.0091653503,
-0.0273493864,
0.0018450058,
0.0771040395,
0.0128834238,
-0.0297621135,
-0.0243418254,
-0.0224195067,
0.0223439932,
0.0098803332,
-0.0032117404,
0.0055653327,
-0.022860758,
0.0382460617,
-0.0141410399,
-0.0026100338,
0.0287692901,
-0.033694353,
-0.0198903065,
0.0311317928,
0.005943004,
0.0030188393,
-0.0199080799,
-0.0307554863,
-0.0585193001,
0.0465845279,
0.0413502678,
-0.0388673618,
-0.0233072434,
0.023624856,
-0.0191374775,
-0.0072048516,
-0.0384104401,
0.003417569,
0.0099441605,
-0.0057782796,
-0.0347291529,
0.0666936487,
0.0135525614,
0.0060942364,
0.0187729243,
0.0163453519,
-0.0375855416,
0.0014597303,
-0.020667024,
0.0295628496,
-0.0386953279,
0.0172197837,
0.013294328,
0.0901458636,
-0.0070192306,
-0.0017983748,
0.0035979559,
-0.0162870064,
-0.0026128339,
0.0215456318,
0.0024170126,
0.0054384461,
0.0205224697,
0.0071542063,
0.0211424828,
-0.012237573,
0.0663325638,
-0.0115351165,
-0.0138773099,
-0.0543217845,
-0.0488766916,
-0.0712186024,
0.0007369886,
-0.0061338306,
0.0129968589,
0.043591287,
0.0026385442,
-0.0208088253,
-0.0103970859,
-0.0141664883,
0.0010166547,
-0.0332696661,
-0.0141991386,
0.0222143009,
-0.0422394499,
-0.0251722708,
0.0295958892,
-0.0134086832,
0.0186673533,
0.0599284545,
0.0153894238,
-0.0364472829,
-0.0626249984,
0.0159336496,
0.0325222649,
0.0493110716,
-0.0482528433,
-0.0457879491,
-0.014012563,
0.0805361643,
0.0842939094,
-0.0477873385,
-0.0157975089,
0.0016601363,
-0.0045642918,
0.0366496779,
-0.0348240361,
0.0327225178,
-0.0217675064,
-0.022439938,
-0.0069238204,
-0.0352047235,
-0.0101958318,
-0.0281392056,
0.0043094275,
-0.0343999602,
-0.0169307478,
0.0638036132,
0.0283007938,
-0.0924279764,
-0.0415063314,
-0.0031783797,
0.0317009576,
0.0328215584,
-0.0119985547,
-0.0191900041,
0.0063256295,
-0.0239245743,
0.0390019305,
0.0115227811,
-0.0154934013,
0.0384781957,
-0.031426128,
-0.0041499836,
0.0128441378,
-0.0559892692,
0.0061871437,
-0.0995581374,
0.0081174606,
0.0030946303,
-0.0448098965,
-0.0213210043,
0.0025426806,
-0.0413232148,
0.0333540179,
-0.0110926609,
-0.0254851785,
0.0043296749,
0.0091651678,
-0.0134121394,
-0.0456585288,
0.0429341234,
-0.0573970303,
-0.0135273999,
0.0897151902,
-0.0789428875,
-0.0390613526,
-0.0269709565,
0.0454479717,
-0.0071214759,
0.026001649,
-0.0325218588,
0.0710016638,
-0.0347867683,
-0.0207901001,
0.0219313428,
0.0621506907,
-0.0051526614,
-0.045797836,
-0.0863061845,
-0.0392088965,
-0.0351889879,
0.0145543367,
0.0034400353,
-0.0620974787,
-0.0301875006,
0.0281605422,
0.0225973856,
0.0216892995,
-0.0289517492,
-0.0050988267,
-0.0384857915,
-0.0037772395,
-0.0323082879,
-0.0336921513,
-0.0222444981,
0.0126166996,
-0.0229465663,
0.0102396226,
0.0173651818,
-0.0475442261,
-0.0652733073,
0.0222858768,
0.0110530248,
0.0038830971,
-0.0031775837,
-0.0223095324,
0.1096299142,
-0.0207878109,
-0.0532468855,
0.0180926286,
0.0332950652,
-0.0532890558,
-0.0090170018,
-0.0019477636,
0.0089148581,
0.0360442996,
-0.012751108,
-0.0573944263,
0.0613298081,
0.0538336039,
-0.0343056433,
-0.0103461426,
0.018600665,
-0.0914914832,
-0.040809758,
-0.0305634197,
-0.0866098255,
0.0738152787,
0.0091834748,
-0.0198597312,
-0.0218371972,
-0.0291412212,
-0.0206092056,
-0.0336359367,
0.0664681271,
-0.0248630028,
0.0200809315,
-0.0147790015,
-0.0040713968,
0.0615984611,
-0.0300603826,
0.0214452166,
-0.0029410794,
0.0179748926,
-0.0158334877,
-0.0058663022,
0.0443121418,
0.0162264146,
0.0648139417,
-0.0185587276,
-0.0188351329,
-0.0126099382,
0.0476464964,
-0.0334511995,
-0.0095401388,
-0.0202286243,
-0.0323113985,
-0.0274664592,
0.0307038892,
0.0063454644,
0.0067380834,
0.036529731,
0.0145584596,
-0.0270596575,
-0.0025444326,
-0.1205874681,
0.0386959091,
-0.029101992,
-0.028946666,
0.0503996238,
-0.0241774209,
0.0401058495,
-0.0286562089,
-0.0436891392,
-0.0290971901,
0.0193761978,
0.0239889212,
0.0226672888,
0.0243995171,
0.0293374415,
-0.0172574297,
0.0108272471,
0.0329704694,
0.0504168905,
0.0053808843,
0.0117536839,
-0.0034446523,
-0.0060565872,
-0.0055460455,
0.0267875101,
0.0647841915,
-0.0067354878,
-0.0359875783,
-0.0070883892,
0.0133952117,
0.0885627121,
-0.0065785032,
0.0185713638,
0.0151697928,
0.0284948386,
0.047005076,
-0.0022099216,
0.0004109483,
-0.0273080412,
-0.0049296585,
-0.0182974506,
-0.0237011239,
-0.005223745,
-6.031217232e-33,
-0.0084173745,
-0.0482452437,
-0.0543801151,
0.0513664,
-0.0012505942,
0.0488894954,
-0.0623829737,
-0.0337400176,
0.0006712861,
0.0429100655,
-0.0142818969,
0.0197916776,
-0.0181891732,
0.0351433046,
0.0645080209,
0.0431206524,
0.0316409059,
0.0187665801,
-0.0132334027,
0.0840818658,
0.0115103573,
-0.0057477201,
0.0517630652,
-0.1378026754,
0.0536394715,
-0.0092792483,
0.0091989748,
-0.0169886723,
0.0045527532,
0.0639910772,
-0.0238431115,
-0.0035741737,
0.0393652394,
-0.0115719549,
0.0268723853,
0.0445744917,
-0.0821875706,
-0.0174720082,
-0.0184142571,
-0.0315370187,
-0.0387251042,
-0.0363806114,
0.0349552929,
0.0150581961,
0.0213999394,
-0.0530144759,
0.107564725,
0.0023851609,
-0.0251748823,
-0.1218451336,
-0.0218209494,
0.0232869834,
-0.028082177,
0.0401748456,
-0.0238714181,
0.0022763514,
0.0047619161,
0.0945827365,
-0.0239739195,
0.0073019983,
-0.0208802819,
0.0305614062,
-0.0324218534,
-0.0150343962,
0.0002578394,
0.0191231407,
-0.0023312483,
0.0463306308,
0.0625167713,
-0.0323486216,
0.0290905014,
0.0157936625,
0.0744252205,
0.0450205728,
0.070171833,
0.0291496869,
-0.0795882791,
0.0264273547,
0.0079676686,
0.0297771133,
0.0076364926,
0.0364577286,
0.0112761613,
0.0008771293,
-0.00864165,
-0.0348828547,
-0.0249818135,
-0.0216861721,
-0.0377900526,
0.0201684535,
-0.0256090499,
0.025479937,
0.0051447572,
-0.0248879567,
-0.0788844526,
0.0488961302,
0.0152130639,
0.0674794763,
0.0016381057,
-0.0520910323,
-0.0712639317,
-0.0782723799,
0.0263904929,
0.0073957392,
0.0375790522,
-0.0158292688,
0.071823664,
-0.0206927359,
-0.0234344769,
-0.0055398094,
0.0328987092,
-0.0558405034,
0.0007584685,
0.0265418012,
-0.0190550629,
0.0110413581,
0.0143023897,
0.0743882954,
0.0380764604,
0.0286844987,
0.0148662329,
0.0255874619,
-0.0006120267,
0.0266475547,
0.0148344338,
-0.0320980139,
-0.0068179555,
0.0141710173,
0.018641673,
-0.0519186147,
0.0230084844,
-0.0295306891,
2.531e-7,
0.0421953499,
0.0377416648,
-0.0052726222,
-0.0202306863,
0.0281644631,
0.0273969304,
-0.0074490351,
0.0412168093,
-0.0082907313,
0.0180360377,
0.0004452271,
-0.0377812423,
-0.0060605514,
0.0229310039,
-0.0932988301,
-0.0102767423,
-0.0941007137,
-0.0241142027,
-0.0602967814,
0.0076281531,
0.0256879348,
0.054939162,
-0.0092496742,
-0.0140574798,
-0.0323835649,
-0.075166814,
0.036371734,
0.0273982324,
0.0218650177,
0.0380643755,
-0.0129614007,
0.0064970506,
-0.0344476141,
-0.0115373246,
-0.029050963,
0.0298570022,
0.0027341915,
0.0105438577,
-0.0238123331,
0.0141760074,
0.0647293404,
0.0132804839,
0.0454768948,
0.0072825509,
0.0226630084,
-0.0809128806,
-0.0336504877,
-0.0545856245,
-0.0213173199,
-0.0223708712,
0.0288678482,
-0.0184873864,
0.0300109182,
0.0287079494,
-0.052393876,
-0.0051591676,
0.0037235126,
-0.0940265656,
0.0040155291,
0.0992876291,
0.0145208947,
-0.0001930671,
-0.012797175,
0.0182716828,
0.0524917655,
-0.0474461801,
0.0299829971,
1.932417433e-34,
0.0672356114,
-0.0080086133,
-0.0406411216,
0.0021565044,
-0.0059562498,
-0.0234777033,
-0.0575776249,
0.0021826336,
0.0050536972,
-0.0602050982,
0.0276244227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13986v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13986v1 | Large Language Models as Sous Chefs: Revising Recipes with GPT-3 | 2023-06-24T14:42:43 | 2023-06-24T14:42:43 | Alyssa Hwang, Bryan Li, Zhaoyi Hou, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | With their remarkably improved text generation and prompting capabilities,
large language models can adapt existing written information into forms that
are easier to use and understand. In our work, we focus on recipes as an
example of complex, diverse, and widely used instructions. We develop a prompt
grounded in the original recipe and ingredients list that breaks recipes down
into simpler steps. We apply this prompt to recipes from various world
cuisines, and experiment with several large language models (LLMs), finding
best results with GPT-3.5. We also contribute an Amazon Mechanical Turk task
that is carefully designed to reduce fatigue while collecting human judgment of
the quality of recipe revisions. We find that annotators usually prefer the
revision over the original, demonstrating a promising application of LLMs in
serving as digital sous chefs for recipes and beyond. We release our prompt,
code, and MTurk template for public use. | [
0.0445620455,
0.0637466758,
-0.0089864498,
0.0001260343,
-0.0428095311,
0.0331269912,
-0.0280394964,
0.0637626424,
-0.0139033701,
-0.04197504,
-0.0131007899,
-0.0283989999,
-0.0093687605,
0.0038667188,
0.0101600727,
-0.0649922192,
0.0062804664,
-0.0344031826,
0.019384576,
0.0134199718,
0.0151412366,
0.0139572872,
-0.007139131,
0.0286881644,
-0.015368212,
-0.0118040312,
-0.0166244414,
0.0073912404,
0.0174679831,
-0.0470214263,
-0.04261088,
0.0853919685,
-0.0101723848,
0.0397856347,
0.0000017383,
-0.0131024718,
-0.0036480441,
-0.007962103,
-0.0445522927,
0.0268397313,
0.0229356159,
-0.0044468539,
-0.0323398709,
-0.0012689477,
-0.0434234403,
0.0118422313,
0.0636902228,
0.0399080962,
0.0548538715,
0.0717271194,
0.0116475234,
-0.0593252778,
-0.0529008284,
-0.0080208192,
0.0447715446,
0.0322227478,
-0.0169570111,
-0.0134176267,
0.0192483515,
0.0102464659,
0.0093604196,
0.0372561812,
0.0267206728,
-0.0236217007,
-0.0343186557,
0.0371580832,
-0.0229816195,
-0.0340261944,
0.0142549993,
0.0550027899,
0.0344239064,
-0.0018095509,
0.0000257253,
0.0080357902,
-0.0146483649,
-0.0072996938,
-0.0519140549,
0.0010358742,
-0.0204914007,
0.0301400218,
-0.0100173047,
-0.0209880881,
0.03410016,
-0.0090421941,
0.0575180538,
0.0838562921,
0.026694946,
-0.0217089709,
-0.0259682722,
0.0412328616,
0.0037727463,
-0.1049552187,
0.0104570417,
0.0370478891,
-0.022836959,
0.0033407602,
0.0080998214,
-0.0178143959,
0.0067577334,
-0.0047336821,
0.0541114546,
0.0318034776,
-0.0348029621,
0.0255433135,
0.0086165676,
0.0437425971,
-0.0014160114,
-0.0021680994,
-0.0804237798,
0.023889102,
-0.0673521161,
-0.0157266557,
-0.0262513552,
0.0046308739,
-0.0199670475,
0.0191850793,
-0.0235608723,
-0.0126365321,
-0.0125333266,
0.0248754565,
0.0470508672,
0.0305304211,
-0.0371557176,
-0.0002816286,
-0.058334589,
0.0363445766,
-0.0344319455,
0.0066488758,
0.0045754304,
-0.004642664,
-0.0001829511,
0.0038432849,
0.0122006051,
0.0063758106,
0.0085614668,
0.0420689955,
-0.0316501297,
-0.009199447,
-0.0239065159,
-0.0263685267,
-0.013502554,
-0.0647640377,
-0.0191640761,
-0.0831058472,
0.0444030948,
-0.0220336579,
0.0235279333,
-0.0303843152,
0.0204795655,
0.0482398532,
-0.0237309728,
0.0780608505,
0.0335351899,
0.0096996278,
0.0334310643,
0.0220599789,
-0.044411011,
0.0266515985,
0.0471406691,
0.0481285527,
0.0213086698,
0.000112354,
0.0426728465,
0.0410917439,
-0.0352312699,
0.0544821955,
-0.039534796,
0.024754269,
0.0073184241,
0.0524876229,
0.0057062223,
0.0944110975,
-0.0202123486,
0.0502924025,
0.1091716066,
0.0695045963,
-0.0046811025,
0.0505005717,
0.0792750344,
0.0010274322,
0.0061436263,
0.0182711035,
-0.0196809433,
0.0292039439,
-0.0601407699,
-0.006894371,
0.0068525369,
-0.012881835,
-0.025798386,
-0.0303048026,
-0.0134768151,
-0.0164596923,
0.0448388495,
-0.0267950706,
0.0257690735,
0.0041476106,
-0.0399241261,
-0.0218693819,
-0.0092716282,
-0.0838563964,
0.0292620286,
-0.0094063627,
0.0610238835,
0.1158076674,
0.0399175398,
-0.0093483292,
0.0448068827,
-0.0153292352,
0.0388990976,
0.0378778279,
0.0360890627,
-0.0326963253,
-0.0249897577,
-0.0343690291,
-0.0446043909,
0.0020992614,
0.0290162582,
-0.0083878022,
0.0214463305,
0.0100954426,
0.0157379545,
-0.0442256518,
-0.0280694142,
0.0095362552,
0.0019988166,
-0.0462330915,
-0.0072642965,
-0.001765229,
-0.0228320491,
0.0562684946,
-0.001102637,
0.0293539912,
-0.0134143485,
-0.0553440824,
-0.0299839042,
0.0394450277,
0.0254609287,
-0.0018108228,
0.0261587799,
-0.050302621,
-0.01651836,
-0.0101004839,
-0.03051739,
-0.0467535853,
-0.0083508529,
-0.0254959259,
0.0266961996,
-0.0258325022,
-0.0106643792,
0.0347772799,
-0.032628525,
-0.0222257655,
0.0553726926,
-0.0050058994,
0.012546597,
0.0041943709,
-0.0284297969,
-0.0204671156,
-0.0527963713,
0.0086631468,
0.0055436878,
0.0624708869,
0.0510084219,
0.0191278048,
0.0589284711,
-0.0381457992,
-0.0497968048,
-0.0927169845,
-0.0077154338,
-0.042847272,
0.0163477287,
0.0300777536,
-0.0059277024,
-0.0074570714,
-0.0038782053,
-0.0609245226,
-0.0050563524,
-0.0124952896,
0.0340946466,
0.0152644245,
0.0089280456,
0.0146489004,
-0.0315093845,
-0.0060812687,
0.0262641627,
0.0302248877,
0.0313517153,
0.0091427537,
-0.0910765454,
-0.0434419625,
-0.0566133559,
-0.0172272567,
0.0363726541,
-0.0391656421,
0.00363401,
-0.0035734726,
0.0560378656,
0.0107077295,
-0.0178757664,
0.0237696655,
0.0555751659,
-0.0272457115,
-0.0324814022,
-0.0281048082,
0.0032844162,
-0.0063791424,
-0.0082965456,
-0.0793672726,
-0.0090201655,
0.0201667007,
0.0079515968,
0.0334259905,
-0.0609980635,
0.0216353517,
-0.0449591763,
-0.0154022574,
-0.0365597866,
0.0161014572,
-0.0252876095,
0.0691634491,
0.0014889343,
-0.0513571389,
0.0695666671,
-0.0474559925,
0.0344757624,
-0.0257539954,
-0.0052497238,
-0.0231674183,
0.0745595545,
0.0004643274,
0.0449333079,
-0.012281335,
0.0124957971,
-0.050045643,
0.0367780626,
0.0322389416,
-0.0633152276,
0.0757722408,
-0.0841404349,
-0.0235369541,
-0.0073966272,
-0.0343421362,
-0.0063937404,
-0.0172243062,
-0.0706600621,
-0.0052872887,
0.0450012982,
-0.0065644891,
-0.0240760036,
0.0097626215,
0.0181484427,
0.0438184924,
0.0274376683,
-0.0108457645,
-0.0106720347,
0.0296869595,
0.0412976146,
0.0180735216,
-0.0287540257,
-0.0368999019,
0.0258038957,
0.056409616,
0.0161118247,
-0.0450306125,
-0.0157053005,
0.0323170796,
0.0321798846,
-0.025891548,
-0.029697787,
0.0100009656,
0.0259783752,
-0.0286996625,
-0.0116954912,
0.110180594,
0.0243073814,
-0.0915620402,
0.0088027669,
0.0140432883,
0.0009261079,
0.0145127838,
0.0483897068,
-0.1399293542,
-0.0057251323,
0.0127102882,
0.0327287391,
-0.0401346385,
-0.0348430239,
-0.0316124931,
-0.0997957438,
0.0547091477,
0.0086570354,
-0.0592600927,
-0.0172745697,
-0.0331297703,
-0.0170198046,
-0.0280793924,
-0.0116578415,
-0.0118508143,
-0.0229903962,
0.0353705771,
-0.0005765698,
-0.0079198778,
-0.0207534954,
0.0258384217,
-0.0572625585,
0.0633354113,
0.0958215892,
0.0243122187,
-0.001273217,
-0.0373972356,
0.0151146874,
0.0202434789,
0.0187559258,
-0.0004617062,
0.029236136,
0.0212648157,
-0.0218325071,
-0.0246275552,
0.0121159405,
-0.0259981733,
-0.0302474089,
0.032629963,
0.0799014345,
0.0108719394,
0.0003489811,
0.0278053973,
-0.038597703,
0.0477981009,
0.0548698679,
0.0350870155,
-0.0433999039,
-0.020669654,
-0.0685678646,
-0.0613621846,
-0.0324374549,
-0.0233092532,
0.0518956035,
-0.0512804277,
-0.0346669927,
-0.0790018588,
-0.0252960343,
0.0267230943,
0.0528629832,
0.0433547534,
0.0063820183,
0.0075359945,
0.040423803,
-0.0045501827,
0.0155856051,
-0.0436219834,
0.015001609,
-0.0860920548,
-0.0605401583,
0.0077236728,
-0.0271235276,
0.0074831136,
0.0217674132,
-0.115126662,
-0.0413065031,
-0.0066872374,
0.0878976136,
0.0308852438,
0.03078725,
0.01407417,
-0.0583604202,
-0.0326673463,
-0.0001964225,
-0.0102171218,
0.0051383246,
-0.0269990116,
0.0268594176,
0.018321611,
0.0248312503,
-0.0353607386,
0.0233557783,
-0.0007973316,
0.0508356839,
-0.0137885194,
-0.0429085568,
0.0465125851,
0.0299497582,
0.0053277211,
-0.0317976736,
0.0086691696,
-0.0557313599,
0.0066768541,
-0.0135950074,
-0.0287548024,
-0.0504575819,
0.0135560706,
0.0450979881,
-0.0331539586,
-0.0117481574,
-0.0086778272,
-0.0181347039,
0.0204444397,
-0.0838153511,
-0.0056868875,
0.0115578901,
0.0187416412,
0.0323579647,
0.0079640076,
-0.0099784043,
0.0589564182,
-0.0297177751,
0.005639289,
-0.0136225633,
0.060405504,
0.0017403932,
0.0007915203,
-0.0227447487,
0.0546845458,
-0.0295853037,
-0.063763313,
0.0004108988,
0.0060922429,
0.0670956671,
-0.0358134285,
0.0583392419,
-0.0287781004,
-0.0134061072,
-0.0358034931,
0.0568500198,
0.0125439763,
-0.0070703574,
0.0236867592,
0.0139001114,
0.0039983033,
0.016807925,
0.0923982039,
-0.0539844409,
0.0555263199,
0.0322230645,
-0.0066590323,
-0.0276518408,
0.0004241488,
-0.0217301082,
-0.0251212679,
-0.0199256297,
-0.0532955565,
-0.0528154373,
-0.030471988,
-0.0192721188,
0.0291611627,
-0.005843902,
-0.0069523915,
0.0340828337,
0.0454794466,
-0.0378305614,
0.0311255306,
-0.030852614,
0.0240946338,
-0.0201124903,
-0.0300996602,
0.0147877391,
-6.016892731e-33,
0.0015578917,
-0.0609656684,
0.026037842,
0.0138423396,
-0.0071632494,
-0.0131038493,
-0.030809259,
0.0108269183,
0.0696386993,
0.0100485869,
0.0015432962,
-0.0177294072,
0.0237672124,
-0.0068426058,
0.0411873087,
-0.0515124425,
0.0631471425,
0.0100255618,
-0.0411673672,
0.0101980176,
-0.0120799486,
0.0030612596,
0.0290705953,
-0.0249070153,
0.0241090395,
-0.0270272959,
-0.0327229984,
0.0013112344,
-0.0047172043,
0.04554566,
-0.0384470522,
0.0476895757,
0.0244335085,
-0.030595107,
-0.0219270363,
-0.0122265387,
-0.0180455819,
-0.011695249,
-0.0160349943,
-0.011922772,
-0.032910496,
-0.0597836189,
-0.0000599613,
-0.0100563094,
-0.0265632551,
0.0610821508,
0.0314940065,
-0.0371867791,
-0.0120095219,
0.0322000161,
-0.0327435024,
0.0179995485,
-0.0030762153,
-0.0157903489,
0.0408000126,
0.0361319967,
0.027225716,
-0.0255142488,
-0.0769579336,
0.0481695309,
0.0317562968,
0.0130609293,
0.0697725192,
-0.0122454595,
-0.0292684138,
0.0280038249,
0.0001075952,
0.0155259017,
-0.0200912356,
0.0037180681,
-0.0444572754,
0.0515645407,
0.0664802715,
0.0574187003,
0.0071530477,
-0.0241913646,
0.0116601577,
0.0293653887,
-0.0131325601,
-0.0302426349,
-0.0362816416,
0.0130117284,
0.0179982446,
-0.0136066582,
-0.0317914225,
-0.0425434113,
-0.0340644754,
-0.0282563958,
0.0148028666,
0.0194142237,
-0.0198860634,
-0.0295109674,
0.0013134007,
0.0381129757,
0.0161759034,
-0.035236679,
-0.011557281,
0.023020491,
-0.016115725,
-0.0154661527,
-0.0543872491,
-0.0150264567,
-0.004659073,
0.0251053385,
0.0282757208,
0.0264418516,
0.0107396767,
0.0533796959,
-0.0578448363,
0.009872254,
-0.0378022008,
0.0105344625,
0.0157474764,
-0.0089449575,
0.0303913653,
-0.0239413287,
0.0157587864,
0.0491425842,
0.0104609029,
-0.0310591012,
-0.014606365,
0.0110750012,
0.0511318147,
-0.0469029173,
0.0028794021,
0.0277870633,
-0.0102139106,
0.0249092542,
0.046954263,
-0.0205191672,
0.000799847,
-0.0050199004,
2.506e-7,
0.0434743613,
0.0415262841,
0.0135112181,
-0.0311076045,
-0.0019873849,
0.0150512382,
-0.0008611344,
0.0323942453,
-0.0296517126,
-0.0124207875,
0.0309617631,
-0.0036932584,
0.0469692275,
0.0819985867,
-0.0536580458,
-0.0042313798,
-0.0885875523,
0.0326781012,
-0.0697641522,
-0.0178925563,
0.0429291055,
0.0399031527,
0.0244593825,
-0.0013564191,
-0.0175634082,
-0.0120432591,
0.060077928,
-0.0629583672,
0.0130655421,
-0.0216076802,
0.033099927,
0.0007308407,
0.0165684707,
-0.0313187689,
-0.0294971131,
-0.0694044828,
0.0516346432,
0.0574903525,
0.001004276,
0.0085399514,
0.0012430293,
-0.0075665736,
-0.0143519603,
-0.071765855,
0.0206567682,
-0.0211254321,
-0.0000032833,
0.0466083325,
0.0219810065,
-0.0250651222,
0.0354479067,
-0.0255926028,
0.0233981181,
0.0219308566,
0.0157854315,
0.0299313944,
-0.0130087677,
-0.0253781527,
-0.0318254866,
-0.0267416071,
-0.0272845812,
-0.0438751206,
-0.0363475829,
-0.0128845721,
-0.0710230991,
-0.0651330128,
-0.0235065967,
1.744929758e-34,
0.0277166385,
0.0106377108,
0.009663404,
0.0139923682,
0.0441759937,
0.0307206027,
-0.0095737055,
-0.0126538491,
0.0055340901,
-0.0855485871,
-0.0537933186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13971v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13971v2 | Towards Robust Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis through Non-counterfactual Augmentations | 2023-06-24T13:57:32 | 2023-07-21T01:58:13 | Xinyu Liu, Yan Ding, Kaikai An, Chunyang Xiao, Pranava Madhyastha, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | While state-of-the-art NLP models have demonstrated excellent performance for
aspect based sentiment analysis (ABSA), substantial evidence has been presented
on their lack of robustness. This is especially manifested as significant
degradation in performance when faced with out-of-distribution data. Recent
solutions that rely on counterfactually augmented datasets show promising
results, but they are inherently limited because of the lack of access to
explicit causal structure. In this paper, we present an alternative approach
that relies on non-counterfactual data augmentation. Our proposal instead
relies on using noisy, cost-efficient data augmentations that preserve
semantics associated with the target aspect. Our approach then relies on
modelling invariances between different versions of the data to improve
robustness. A comprehensive suite of experiments shows that our proposal
significantly improves upon strong pre-trained baselines on both standard and
robustness-specific datasets. Our approach further establishes a new
state-of-the-art on the ABSA robustness benchmark and transfers well across
domains. | [
0.0277835671,
0.1055397689,
0.0031067159,
0.0297113657,
-0.0201737676,
0.0022007367,
-0.0069995308,
-0.0134347975,
-0.0182579439,
-0.045361653,
-0.0444542058,
-0.0120589426,
-0.0551977642,
0.0691132545,
0.0023854382,
0.0000508541,
0.0504521206,
0.0408836231,
-0.015761029,
-0.0086175613,
0.01885687,
0.0045126081,
-0.0060874643,
-0.0218347497,
-0.0245170053,
-0.0043245684,
0.002378691,
0.0110186283,
0.0410993733,
-0.0314684436,
0.0283837356,
0.0409427695,
-0.0038789909,
0.0149140852,
0.0000019539,
-0.003351924,
-0.0228902753,
0.0177464262,
0.0095692016,
0.001942672,
0.0380502045,
-0.0784406364,
0.0095502995,
-0.0106425611,
-0.0474436805,
-0.0120878946,
0.033290457,
0.0916021541,
0.0693868101,
0.1052542552,
-0.0206487775,
-0.0079474812,
0.0273588579,
-0.0509473756,
-0.0488729812,
-0.0412009247,
0.0095345052,
-0.0274100322,
-0.0379967093,
0.0678219646,
-0.013680432,
0.0105564194,
0.0238078274,
0.0089911539,
-0.0027981994,
-0.0142041743,
0.0230096783,
0.0156671163,
-0.0098763565,
0.040857248,
0.0451676138,
-0.0318085551,
-0.019759886,
-0.0621422641,
-0.0175634529,
0.0158431083,
-0.0039058498,
-0.0089857755,
0.0344733112,
0.0379296504,
0.0180474315,
0.0400568321,
0.0386770144,
0.0252068341,
0.0293392055,
0.0243407097,
-0.0054905014,
-0.0510439388,
-0.0042977361,
0.087103717,
-0.0347209051,
-0.0083275829,
-0.0007003485,
-0.0161697399,
0.0085132662,
0.0263755322,
-0.0205076896,
0.0020537348,
0.0118773179,
-0.0853780434,
-0.0159516018,
0.0211395808,
-0.0430067964,
0.0358464383,
-0.0062922654,
-0.0279910713,
-0.0119737461,
-0.0101863993,
-0.0279077552,
0.011320509,
-0.0258982051,
0.0113187479,
0.0333837681,
0.0579857901,
-0.0660561174,
0.0356140211,
-0.0496123098,
-0.0052617001,
-0.0487978607,
-0.0108914794,
0.0187135879,
0.0101269856,
-0.0129226707,
-0.0058302847,
-0.0072887363,
0.039585229,
-0.0529670604,
0.0486775152,
-0.0263194703,
-0.0205204152,
-0.010108076,
0.0034493899,
-0.0265756566,
-0.0192193184,
0.0138777038,
0.0518891364,
0.0485074371,
-0.0471599065,
-0.0299047884,
-0.0131804347,
-0.0218387358,
-0.0562528372,
-0.010140813,
-0.0314252675,
0.01934053,
-0.0068884348,
-0.0196227785,
-0.030767953,
0.0118585555,
0.0233915709,
-0.0276933331,
0.0518314652,
-0.0309318081,
-0.0496477894,
-0.0698597804,
0.0012720934,
0.0489585251,
0.0775004178,
-0.0219750032,
-0.024682207,
0.0388999023,
0.0226794314,
-0.0103729554,
-0.0147530306,
0.035476163,
0.0173090287,
-0.0118241571,
-0.0078688171,
-0.0174881555,
-0.0523365475,
-0.006316903,
0.0053313938,
0.0033400764,
-0.0671143681,
0.0316748992,
-0.0820688382,
-0.0420456268,
0.0598759204,
-0.0179500151,
-0.0270149484,
-0.0370072797,
0.0203972552,
-0.0616529658,
0.023176115,
-0.0658308789,
-0.0056928885,
0.0083094882,
-0.0086675864,
-0.0383717604,
-0.061003644,
-0.0154494857,
-0.0085394988,
0.0369685739,
0.004033572,
0.0484718271,
0.0412851721,
-0.0056109037,
-0.0541903265,
0.0504103377,
-0.0404875278,
-0.0122212963,
0.0183312204,
-0.0005265963,
0.0409446731,
0.0303219985,
-0.0486269444,
-0.0334997922,
-0.017975308,
-0.0183942262,
0.0345241055,
0.0348240696,
0.0083903344,
0.0334653668,
-0.0378377549,
0.0100624682,
-0.0162838362,
0.0421208963,
0.0098034255,
0.0333695598,
0.0159080233,
-0.0076723411,
-0.0020684558,
0.0247190706,
0.0121751139,
-0.0273032524,
-0.0184740126,
0.0408313163,
0.0016900618,
0.0297865942,
0.0854946598,
0.0010351039,
-0.0081801517,
0.0281677414,
-0.0301392283,
-0.052396711,
0.0476000831,
-0.0349601246,
-0.0500697978,
0.0176401995,
0.0154625326,
-0.0534064248,
0.0262715369,
-0.0508607551,
-0.0218875706,
0.0400935374,
0.0045655915,
0.0329723507,
-0.0315907784,
-0.0090663573,
0.0307816006,
0.0287398156,
-0.0030190081,
0.0518445969,
-0.0254564118,
0.0179542936,
-0.0741541162,
0.0137466639,
0.0313001759,
-0.0106168073,
-0.0532964803,
-0.0239914656,
0.011450666,
-0.0107692368,
0.0156190637,
-0.0233638361,
-0.0147438608,
0.0027775583,
-0.0942051336,
-0.0055986717,
-0.0090320278,
0.027405303,
0.0289883427,
0.0146615002,
0.0233476814,
0.002138122,
-0.0326611176,
-0.0097897453,
0.000254364,
0.0413459949,
0.0170395989,
0.034585353,
0.0450318754,
-0.051422026,
-0.0323148854,
-0.0370309763,
0.0001520923,
0.0016546466,
-0.0185506623,
-0.0175000541,
0.0025974754,
-0.023364177,
0.0427286103,
-0.0293295309,
-0.0103405919,
-0.0271481182,
0.0133087793,
-0.0072620353,
0.0195688084,
-0.0130724767,
0.0163374636,
0.0139252739,
0.0299727265,
-0.0123902634,
0.0349041075,
-0.0706573948,
0.0084390985,
0.0179652628,
-0.0306231584,
-0.0081744315,
0.0629866943,
-0.0281202476,
-0.0353532434,
-0.0338626653,
0.0077331206,
-0.0186349396,
-0.0214680769,
0.0098010777,
-0.0054202275,
-0.0017521965,
0.0157805737,
-0.0136314956,
-0.0038995473,
0.0948825032,
0.0270618666,
-0.0034903542,
-0.0503866151,
-0.0053631174,
-0.0294690151,
0.0739116296,
-0.0154738929,
-0.0118500181,
0.0230228268,
0.0386337787,
0.0156744216,
-0.0451379083,
0.0122992443,
0.0031488542,
0.0508933477,
-0.0139791835,
0.019005768,
0.0264909659,
-0.0661231875,
-0.011299015,
-0.0709137172,
-0.022863606,
0.0069164857,
-0.0307367891,
-0.0111333318,
-0.0064390129,
-0.0121385818,
-0.0211826134,
0.0062822178,
-0.0352148749,
-0.0013761248,
0.0006198147,
0.0096586971,
0.0347145572,
-0.0096508572,
0.0476907566,
-0.0162895471,
-0.0092971073,
0.0371964052,
-0.0448909663,
-0.0239261463,
-0.013648863,
0.0026612026,
-0.00553662,
0.0063805734,
-0.014151956,
-0.0465325229,
0.0604249351,
-0.0377825461,
-0.0223242138,
0.0672051683,
0.0362775177,
-0.0173879806,
0.0075987433,
0.029823821,
-0.0112580471,
0.0438198373,
-0.0060198549,
-0.0462768599,
-0.0313006341,
-0.0254341047,
0.0292960051,
-0.013325843,
-0.0345207527,
0.0018795921,
-0.1102802604,
0.0100133047,
-0.0388358198,
-0.038281627,
-0.0773345828,
-0.0656903014,
0.0230704024,
-0.0630301759,
0.0172541495,
-0.0464549549,
0.0329569541,
-0.0011592832,
-0.0237997994,
0.0033065325,
-0.0324671306,
0.0008699397,
-0.0001291032,
0.0371410735,
0.0521818735,
0.0144480364,
-0.0181851517,
-0.0089806262,
0.066744335,
-0.0521859601,
-0.005889101,
-0.0190895535,
0.0901945457,
-0.0398977436,
-0.0183012988,
-0.0109067727,
0.0294993818,
-0.037195988,
-0.0116537549,
-0.0365018249,
0.0274810325,
0.021317251,
0.0183283128,
-0.0386395976,
0.0206773374,
0.0247416049,
0.0742437616,
-0.0175145958,
-0.0676891655,
0.0008549396,
-0.0173190217,
-0.0033729938,
-0.042126134,
-0.0062764441,
-0.0574215464,
0.0188742206,
-0.0260261316,
-0.087394692,
-0.0875503123,
-0.0257966053,
0.0159664676,
-0.0303448681,
-0.0059212982,
0.000594733,
-0.0419109687,
-0.0441291481,
0.0240930934,
-0.0117879659,
0.0135022793,
0.0115778456,
-0.023911152,
0.0567464605,
-0.0079277409,
-0.0202087481,
-0.0028373196,
-0.0560868196,
-0.0605071299,
0.0139764454,
0.0294838157,
0.0040801303,
0.042314522,
-0.0380134061,
-0.0069847824,
-0.0220860261,
0.0749284774,
-0.0098402584,
0.0318069011,
0.0807525963,
0.0381815955,
0.0223440584,
0.019294804,
-0.022691451,
0.0349573307,
0.0477402993,
0.0239414647,
-0.0248318948,
-0.0146022672,
0.0031960863,
-0.0099725034,
0.0726959929,
0.0253224466,
-0.0075558228,
-0.0200908612,
0.0177170206,
-0.0513029173,
-0.0222042464,
-0.019292172,
0.0267868731,
0.000565892,
0.0060255728,
-0.0490262769,
0.0712360069,
-0.0387511812,
0.0725688562,
-0.0359970964,
0.0463153571,
0.0151920151,
-0.0055927578,
-0.049859792,
0.0349424072,
-0.0081261666,
-0.0048456341,
0.0277093854,
0.0217115097,
-0.0225579422,
0.01701276,
0.021386208,
0.0260221604,
-0.0188668463,
-0.0055684713,
-0.0716763809,
0.0920046791,
-0.0616700426,
0.0015133936,
-0.0016884991,
-0.0658083037,
0.0310459994,
-0.0400435328,
0.0017791673,
0.0023048406,
-0.0062495065,
0.0177523121,
-0.00165693,
0.0322338492,
0.0324418545,
-0.0063139843,
0.0373263732,
0.0223320927,
-0.0839010179,
0.0655634329,
0.0107047539,
0.0331467912,
-0.0289653335,
-0.0365773328,
0.0232669469,
0.041148521,
-0.0166220721,
0.0409224927,
-0.0605174452,
-0.0574663468,
0.0320221633,
-0.023184469,
0.0219050311,
0.0130098769,
-0.0007748876,
-0.0043975469,
0.0260737352,
0.0547080748,
-0.0388882048,
0.0017704616,
0.0140832979,
-0.0090504708,
-0.0160398427,
-6.424684946e-33,
-0.0197591875,
0.0073593068,
-0.0273824502,
-0.0427481122,
0.0269915257,
0.0110917315,
-0.0227141473,
0.0245993175,
-0.0248208195,
0.0345277302,
0.0052065202,
0.0297572613,
0.0004737886,
0.0477424935,
-0.0093993871,
-0.0113606816,
0.0646753535,
0.0139397308,
0.0015718983,
0.0112316487,
0.0101701347,
-0.0036185998,
0.0653689355,
-0.1644219309,
0.0530745722,
-0.0166048538,
-0.0462887362,
0.0087084677,
-0.018522365,
0.0457063504,
0.0004644385,
0.047503259,
0.0383568667,
-0.0191400684,
0.0116983531,
-0.0441247709,
-0.0357544124,
-0.0202004109,
0.0154317291,
0.0095708715,
0.0124941366,
0.0018958533,
0.0035127152,
0.0084598837,
-0.0123432511,
-0.0056479401,
-0.0059630582,
-0.0454761051,
0.0319958478,
-0.0567855835,
-0.05317536,
0.0266271792,
0.0164504796,
-0.0032872283,
-0.0029113807,
0.0347094722,
0.0352057479,
0.042014394,
-0.027273681,
0.0000204871,
0.0027473187,
0.0298529901,
-0.0092295092,
-0.0299865454,
-0.0056008613,
0.0543086752,
-0.024539737,
0.0492939875,
-0.0141162798,
0.0226912424,
0.0084800553,
-0.0072212163,
0.0469562374,
0.1048625559,
0.0359886475,
-0.0090769054,
-0.0455659814,
0.0157966074,
0.0223313253,
-0.044028908,
0.0521280877,
0.0158963799,
-0.0605190545,
0.0037342599,
0.0029588426,
-0.0555890799,
-0.0317593999,
-0.0065816632,
-0.0063005658,
0.048803255,
-0.0236169659,
0.0574601255,
-0.0242895558,
-0.0442294627,
-0.0022393984,
0.0548511185,
-0.0203773566,
0.0101111671,
0.0190320145,
0.0001913903,
-0.0606926195,
-0.0188964177,
0.0187383294,
0.0271873679,
-0.0003118778,
-0.0311302505,
0.1015897542,
-0.0068822792,
-0.094586648,
-0.0112421662,
-0.0015070932,
0.0654714033,
-0.0084529528,
0.0370817892,
0.0188944936,
0.0114276996,
-0.012923033,
0.1341298819,
0.0376786776,
0.0624785349,
-0.031918034,
0.0178998727,
0.009783417,
0.020012157,
-0.0006140723,
-0.0318958461,
0.0630201548,
-0.0196075384,
-0.0350705236,
-0.0580543801,
-0.0275766049,
0.0046869237,
2.598e-7,
0.0500313416,
0.0451696925,
0.0518657453,
-0.0059425328,
0.0348278843,
0.0575292334,
-0.0096150916,
0.0031003195,
-0.0075145559,
-0.0100553213,
0.007413141,
0.016509397,
-0.0032252886,
0.0160310268,
-0.0264790747,
0.0801995769,
-0.0328280143,
-0.0253290795,
0.0084294733,
0.0126956534,
0.0842528641,
0.1270630658,
0.0354440585,
0.0249461103,
-0.0011438534,
0.0478624031,
0.060748063,
-0.0150427911,
-0.035837505,
-0.0168062896,
-0.0485570729,
0.0266741086,
-0.025503153,
-0.0129078506,
-0.0389830098,
0.0482728928,
-0.0179737676,
0.0575858131,
0.0205028635,
-0.1048816815,
-0.0048626154,
0.0122863473,
0.0167896133,
0.0072464962,
0.0580197908,
-0.0228118375,
-0.0487678014,
-0.0539226606,
-0.0779675469,
0.0758535489,
0.0061555281,
0.0166920926,
-0.0366364717,
0.0214750692,
0.0015446147,
0.0042624646,
-0.0510263741,
-0.0818685517,
-0.0432375968,
0.0291815456,
-0.017052751,
-0.0337497592,
0.0174778365,
0.0281229671,
0.0098395078,
-0.0538562611,
-0.008950497,
2.267057027e-34,
0.080636397,
0.0009988501,
0.0014495534,
0.00162466,
-0.0082815569,
0.0046491236,
-0.0134265535,
-0.0151862437,
0.0340456627,
-0.0061681201,
0.0128662866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13968v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13968v1 | Fusing Multimodal Signals on Hyper-complex Space for Extreme Abstractive Text Summarization (TL;DR) of Scientific Contents | 2023-06-24T13:51:42 | 2023-06-24T13:51:42 | Yash Kumar Atri, Vikram Goyal, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The realm of scientific text summarization has experienced remarkable
progress due to the availability of annotated brief summaries and ample data.
However, the utilization of multiple input modalities, such as videos and
audio, has yet to be thoroughly explored. At present, scientific
multimodal-input-based text summarization systems tend to employ longer target
summaries like abstracts, leading to an underwhelming performance in the task
of text summarization.
In this paper, we deal with a novel task of extreme abstractive text
summarization (aka TL;DR generation) by leveraging multiple input modalities.
To this end, we introduce mTLDR, a first-of-its-kind dataset for the
aforementioned task, comprising videos, audio, and text, along with both
author-composed summaries and expert-annotated summaries. The mTLDR dataset
accompanies a total of 4,182 instances collected from various academic
conference proceedings, such as ICLR, ACL, and CVPR. Subsequently, we present
mTLDRgen, an encoder-decoder-based model that employs a novel dual-fused
hyper-complex Transformer combined with a Wasserstein Riemannian Encoder
Transformer, to dexterously capture the intricacies between different
modalities in a hyper-complex latent geometric space. The hyper-complex
Transformer captures the intrinsic properties between the modalities, while the
Wasserstein Riemannian Encoder Transformer captures the latent structure of the
modalities in the latent space geometry, thereby enabling the model to produce
diverse sentences. mTLDRgen outperforms 20 baselines on mTLDR as well as
another non-scientific dataset (How2) across three Rouge-based evaluation
measures. Furthermore, based on the qualitative metrics, BERTScore and FEQA,
and human evaluations, we demonstrate that the summaries generated by mTLDRgen
are fluent and congruent to the original source material. | [
0.0187570378,
0.0361042246,
0.0326538719,
-0.0042592161,
0.0000853515,
0.0123531027,
0.0062450953,
-0.007284265,
-0.0450625047,
-0.0157247651,
-0.0259496644,
-0.0320135765,
0.0261355508,
0.0457927249,
0.0306744203,
-0.1109743491,
-0.0236854982,
-0.0354910716,
0.0001313365,
-0.0132912099,
0.0230411552,
-0.0098232571,
-0.0171147119,
0.0198687203,
-0.003417518,
0.0030060802,
-0.0005103335,
-0.0051855478,
0.0818882063,
-0.0342426896,
-0.0268509574,
0.0109564876,
0.0645264909,
0.000297959,
0.0000018489,
-0.0082644541,
0.0054187062,
0.015757516,
0.0755512789,
0.0261048097,
0.0544996485,
-0.0937383622,
0.0137993041,
-0.0209474992,
-0.02071351,
-0.026720088,
0.0336615257,
0.0694870874,
0.0308060404,
0.0386519879,
-0.0341847874,
-0.0533757135,
0.0806488022,
-0.0104652289,
-0.0255256258,
0.0345216952,
0.0077271061,
0.0389774852,
0.0043304497,
0.0434566773,
-0.0045508337,
0.0576031655,
0.0048188465,
-0.0312647857,
0.0289971344,
0.0437904857,
-0.0126444185,
-0.0095023988,
0.0132538071,
0.0886413231,
-0.0202523302,
0.0204632264,
0.0263279434,
0.0087479744,
-0.047587987,
0.019094158,
-0.086548537,
0.0497107059,
-0.009905587,
0.0094331466,
-0.0377121009,
0.054270938,
-0.0320850424,
-0.0098248944,
-0.0153677249,
-0.0309222005,
0.0348244011,
-0.0025747858,
-0.0413028523,
-0.0019481867,
-0.027629042,
-0.0336144939,
0.0368832126,
0.0062316526,
0.0267314054,
-0.0300627425,
-0.0328130461,
-0.10045477,
-0.003209623,
-0.0120146191,
0.0313396752,
-0.0059448527,
0.0212599561,
0.0299404617,
0.0086740013,
0.0014932926,
-0.0260027573,
0.0181215722,
-0.0336493291,
-0.0276418105,
0.0036618118,
0.0070020617,
0.0023491753,
0.0298046898,
-0.0527458079,
-0.0545515977,
-0.0292013567,
0.015802322,
0.0125358161,
-0.0111460807,
-0.0324946232,
0.032355383,
-0.0310852919,
-0.0283652749,
0.025920013,
0.0719114691,
-0.0031049161,
0.0091418205,
0.0399680361,
0.0067049544,
-0.0104743186,
0.0543603189,
0.0340263434,
0.0034261716,
-0.027910905,
0.0290856753,
-0.0527361296,
-0.0124219088,
0.0383139215,
-0.0369474813,
-0.0345570929,
0.0052852528,
0.0441112407,
-0.0386212096,
0.0527290851,
0.0060685142,
-0.0239290111,
-0.0171372872,
-0.0101941815,
0.008448855,
-0.0257983431,
0.0496769845,
-0.0136372335,
-0.0131964553,
0.0865391493,
0.0049393871,
0.0019413584,
0.0153293237,
0.0459286012,
0.0332719162,
-0.002958142,
0.028629208,
0.0500970334,
0.0288301576,
-0.0107490784,
0.0172057375,
-0.0004395368,
-0.0356997102,
-0.0662611201,
0.0307323541,
0.0335329361,
0.0835387781,
-0.0553128533,
0.0478683785,
0.067800276,
0.0606893077,
-0.0096502509,
0.0063906694,
0.0325030088,
0.0439794473,
0.0141666373,
0.0211872868,
0.0121657085,
0.0977255031,
-0.0046731145,
0.051692754,
0.0926757008,
0.040770933,
-0.0219063647,
-0.0193460025,
0.0251695532,
-0.0091064582,
-0.0073746555,
-0.043491926,
0.0524378195,
0.0140841939,
-0.0566616952,
0.027200263,
0.0159351099,
-0.0725286677,
0.0504937209,
0.0218305625,
-0.0096803317,
0.0339181237,
0.0286051016,
-0.0271779392,
-0.0053163045,
-0.0198031981,
0.0047469218,
0.0811825395,
0.0090307137,
0.006523178,
-0.0172947906,
-0.0699524954,
-0.0637665913,
-0.0025111486,
0.0089664152,
0.0013885134,
-0.0386304781,
0.0039651715,
-0.004634364,
-0.0031822918,
0.0041925088,
0.0204284377,
-0.0209879745,
0.0070533277,
-0.0516395606,
-0.00542309,
0.0070237555,
0.0163906254,
-0.0302793253,
0.0240018852,
0.0233450197,
-0.0557468422,
-0.0334990434,
0.0116763441,
-0.0385336727,
-0.041627828,
-0.0051604803,
-0.1413511634,
0.0239231344,
0.0356078036,
0.0007265781,
-0.0566330701,
0.031539619,
-0.0445145704,
-0.0017815658,
-0.0277404822,
-0.0273547992,
0.0481833369,
0.0359387398,
-0.0181531124,
0.0180175807,
-0.0229091756,
-0.022154903,
0.0497707129,
-0.0240640379,
-0.0067102332,
-0.00773738,
-0.0249861721,
0.0284809005,
0.0295753665,
-0.0082997326,
0.0498880669,
-0.022920344,
-0.0072500883,
-0.0374901481,
-0.0616859347,
-0.0442308262,
-0.0034980911,
-0.0053646476,
0.051101353,
0.0050099115,
0.0227241311,
0.0216944218,
-0.01750472,
-0.0372976288,
0.0201720949,
-0.0142351808,
0.0286499225,
0.0135670519,
0.015077048,
-0.0230355039,
-0.0212717205,
0.003619916,
0.0427583121,
0.0350094736,
-0.0324768275,
-0.0152473282,
-0.037434414,
0.0247343648,
-0.0137125785,
-0.0212945659,
0.0004691552,
-0.0131037515,
-0.0111768246,
0.0350192487,
0.0180724431,
0.0402802974,
0.0267788209,
0.0309031419,
0.0177888107,
-0.0197049528,
-0.0238076858,
-0.0432816818,
0.0320239477,
-0.0066628233,
-0.0106178243,
0.0403351784,
0.0246812049,
0.0309988763,
0.0397414975,
-0.0382049941,
-0.0224845186,
-0.0154567547,
-0.0190362427,
0.0089355102,
-0.0301412232,
-0.0250681955,
0.0257750303,
-0.00371333,
-0.0041679367,
0.032085944,
-0.0283821095,
-0.0200518295,
-0.0418369174,
0.0141790845,
-0.0342833586,
-0.0002670175,
-0.0001046737,
0.0239763819,
0.0026985835,
-0.0221955311,
-0.0437659025,
0.0135086672,
0.0192259625,
-0.0080175791,
0.0344672054,
-0.0366634987,
-0.0006139191,
-0.0364878587,
-0.0128627475,
0.0162208918,
-0.0139646167,
0.0021015019,
0.0226608794,
0.037721891,
-0.0340029299,
-0.0763304979,
0.002475014,
0.0286796968,
0.0560998246,
-0.0209793467,
-0.0189689994,
-0.0342518464,
0.1138482243,
0.0709246621,
0.0120079303,
-0.0117802741,
-0.0707601756,
-0.0034800267,
0.051983282,
-0.0361789279,
-0.0189184714,
-0.0295756049,
-0.0061071003,
0.0134190172,
0.0117354719,
0.0263878275,
-0.0214743521,
0.0554128289,
-0.0121645704,
0.018041864,
0.0720211267,
-0.0021423756,
-0.0762655288,
-0.0149953905,
0.0496950299,
0.0532635041,
-0.0166658424,
-0.0178811811,
-0.069382824,
-0.0036354272,
-0.0218673795,
0.0098080216,
0.0333753303,
-0.0045856959,
0.0055604069,
-0.0434294418,
0.0316885561,
0.0371584371,
-0.060313236,
-0.0321395099,
0.0056079584,
-0.0093020033,
-0.0029879885,
0.0074642836,
0.0003232446,
-0.023130402,
-0.0018030327,
0.0238120891,
-0.0267557111,
-0.0431976356,
-0.0482360758,
-0.0061387853,
0.0023266573,
0.0113708852,
0.0622692145,
-0.0160360094,
-0.0302847177,
0.0119706988,
0.0096921381,
0.0047219703,
0.014109225,
0.0580117404,
0.0007910743,
0.0155596109,
-0.0127142491,
0.0860304907,
0.0019031406,
-0.0322498642,
-0.0146686221,
0.047677394,
-0.0208977312,
0.011284925,
-0.0947190672,
0.032298658,
-0.039646171,
0.0430232808,
0.0225025397,
-0.0271752179,
-0.0384436175,
-0.0132631231,
0.0330427699,
-0.0581120178,
-0.0305612106,
-0.0321071334,
-0.012810736,
-0.0336146392,
-0.0738724545,
-0.0199328158,
0.0096565001,
-0.0108868135,
-0.0113618039,
-0.0332072116,
0.0181282517,
0.0093599763,
-0.0522639416,
0.0454245172,
0.0112037268,
-0.0153091317,
-0.0111354832,
-0.0054580146,
0.0603731535,
-0.0324595124,
-0.0360312797,
0.0133688683,
-0.0285593998,
-0.0634745806,
-0.0512286127,
0.0428191833,
0.0132627813,
0.0666217133,
0.0450237468,
-0.0120391371,
0.0717702284,
0.012814723,
-0.0150370216,
0.0423529521,
0.004050775,
0.0383411199,
-0.0317811742,
-0.0069843894,
-0.0483980849,
0.032844767,
-0.0416112393,
0.0278423242,
-0.0320939422,
-0.0440142341,
0.0075693401,
-0.0006464478,
0.0226779617,
-0.0397223309,
0.0003092672,
-0.0401475094,
-0.0423046798,
-0.0439304523,
0.0172118917,
-0.052351892,
0.0394026823,
-0.0067527476,
0.0111143738,
-0.0225973371,
0.1035965905,
0.0266304705,
-0.0082588429,
-0.0334282331,
0.0069694477,
-0.0139109138,
-0.0423498712,
-0.0217566621,
0.0101261772,
-0.0346477218,
-0.0146320229,
-0.0598406903,
0.0035448305,
-0.0157669429,
0.0250873249,
0.0387387909,
-0.0127497921,
-0.0172052663,
0.0493809283,
-0.0878161788,
0.0352814645,
-0.0734673068,
0.0278668497,
0.0418892242,
0.0084081972,
0.0988615602,
-0.0117828557,
-0.0031393117,
-0.0242189262,
0.0416218713,
0.0011583241,
-0.0030070534,
0.0201681256,
-0.0130822267,
0.0276406426,
-0.005007287,
0.0687135458,
-0.0746133998,
-0.0052112089,
-0.00496032,
0.0101847826,
-0.044327572,
0.0002052083,
0.0090894531,
0.0346313082,
0.0099178748,
-0.0023632636,
-0.0192180239,
-0.0027694649,
0.041156292,
0.0213617291,
-0.0246920027,
-0.0233974718,
0.0522684082,
-0.0001980861,
-0.0316797569,
-0.0226472691,
-0.0147335799,
-0.0157250706,
0.020394804,
-0.0290365499,
-0.0294379573,
-5.333832433e-33,
-0.0139994025,
-0.0029960691,
-0.0125264637,
0.0221075248,
-0.0703476593,
0.0136575513,
-0.060706187,
0.0146499788,
0.0227856543,
0.0143428035,
0.0290912036,
-0.0449504443,
-0.0041258205,
0.0739213079,
0.0048133493,
0.0531577915,
0.0290256049,
-0.0202832483,
-0.0195784215,
0.069781132,
0.0196124166,
0.0011165879,
0.0418675691,
-0.0895950198,
-0.0185794327,
-0.0169594251,
-0.0152358813,
-0.0430732481,
0.0487706922,
0.0317352004,
-0.0540871546,
-0.0002299758,
-0.0025451749,
-0.0441087298,
-0.0443765782,
0.0124594159,
-0.0628755242,
0.0221170485,
-0.0190229602,
0.0013488092,
-0.0702720061,
-0.0447351225,
0.0640714541,
-0.0343587063,
-0.0258561559,
-0.0748833418,
0.0829379261,
-0.0280637648,
-0.0152964359,
-0.1121515185,
-0.0349778347,
0.0285036359,
-0.061927896,
-0.0196782351,
0.0277121719,
0.0428146645,
0.0156206954,
0.0409785397,
-0.0286747906,
0.0653830096,
0.0126112783,
-0.0032721935,
0.0520987175,
0.0069888583,
0.0188489892,
0.0770067647,
0.0327907205,
-0.0588352159,
-0.0054895957,
0.009307066,
0.025949046,
0.0108989794,
0.0220088959,
0.0622402169,
0.0311250687,
0.0401430875,
-0.018825531,
0.0658409148,
-0.0762107,
-0.0118537853,
0.0264371317,
0.0369038023,
0.0296643972,
0.0104586212,
-0.0296390001,
0.0100164143,
0.0022478763,
-0.0057567842,
-0.007350334,
0.0323261917,
0.0030332084,
-0.0052716243,
0.0532059371,
-0.0257962011,
0.0016829023,
-0.0035668768,
-0.0091372933,
0.0720529109,
-0.0022103749,
-0.0477877297,
0.0082038939,
-0.0022195925,
0.0643787608,
-0.0168254767,
-0.0042647286,
-0.0036965841,
0.0306397919,
0.0264481213,
-0.018698791,
-0.0207924005,
0.0103653558,
-0.0283140615,
0.0179756712,
0.0454611853,
-0.0013370463,
0.0076363017,
-0.0215203129,
0.0374272428,
-0.0503968596,
0.0508567542,
-0.0084587559,
0.0086865677,
0.0089530256,
0.0375619158,
-0.0364599377,
0.0522290543,
-0.0112171629,
-0.0487934053,
0.0561288781,
-0.0606524311,
-0.0303608757,
0.0226669684,
2.476e-7,
0.0488730818,
0.0543025173,
0.0577433072,
-0.0720780417,
0.0096615395,
0.0107491435,
-0.0093590124,
0.0459466837,
-0.0007564109,
-0.0234069098,
0.0158683732,
0.0289037041,
0.0160776824,
0.0083999243,
-0.0585608892,
-0.0072205123,
-0.0654894039,
-0.0450969189,
-0.0389635041,
0.0137092723,
0.0856262743,
0.0445496216,
-0.0521260723,
-0.003596104,
0.0181136876,
-0.015216467,
0.0783397779,
0.0165426135,
-0.0088505968,
-0.0019222108,
0.0128705483,
-0.0450558364,
0.0019012426,
-0.0135013396,
-0.005174377,
-0.0476383418,
0.0713145435,
0.0451572426,
-0.0058570011,
-0.0545083471,
0.024461979,
0.0442566536,
-0.030972084,
0.0117342491,
0.0230384767,
-0.0816814899,
-0.0323010981,
-0.0317217484,
-0.0702725276,
0.0312070753,
0.0001834317,
-0.0190169662,
-0.0061055617,
0.0571848191,
0.0268682502,
0.0062800599,
0.0068791648,
-0.0417505838,
0.002659176,
0.0300894659,
-0.0533057153,
-0.0104450332,
-0.0212607216,
-0.0481561646,
0.0118001979,
-0.0310004074,
-0.0540429391,
2.425685398e-34,
0.0795513764,
-0.0235664789,
-0.0260865185,
-0.0134657659,
0.0043993038,
-0.0203897711,
-0.0187334269,
0.0064273458,
-0.0041120481,
-0.0905405656,
-0.0263800155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13959v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13959v1 | Emotion Flip Reasoning in Multiparty Conversations | 2023-06-24T13:22:02 | 2023-06-24T13:22:02 | Shivani Kumar, Shubham Dudeja, Md Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In a conversational dialogue, speakers may have different emotional states
and their dynamics play an important role in understanding dialogue's emotional
discourse. However, simply detecting emotions is not sufficient to entirely
comprehend the speaker-specific changes in emotion that occur during a
conversation. To understand the emotional dynamics of speakers in an efficient
manner, it is imperative to identify the rationale or instigator behind any
changes or flips in emotion expressed by the speaker. In this paper, we explore
the task called Instigator based Emotion Flip Reasoning (EFR), which aims to
identify the instigator behind a speaker's emotion flip within a conversation.
For example, an emotion flip from joy to anger could be caused by an instigator
like threat. To facilitate this task, we present MELD-I, a dataset that
includes ground-truth EFR instigator labels, which are in line with emotional
psychology. To evaluate the dataset, we propose a novel neural architecture
called TGIF, which leverages Transformer encoders and stacked GRUs to capture
the dialogue context, speaker dynamics, and emotion sequence in a conversation.
Our evaluation demonstrates state-of-the-art performance (+4-12% increase in
F1-score) against five baselines used for the task. Further, we establish the
generalizability of TGIF on an unseen dataset in a zero-shot setting.
Additionally, we provide a detailed analysis of the competing models,
highlighting the advantages and limitations of our neural architecture. | [
0.0127156796,
0.0630509928,
-0.0160687324,
0.042713657,
-0.0149617521,
0.0269934516,
0.0362648591,
-0.0212052204,
0.0015823557,
-0.0199832786,
-0.0484315194,
-0.0424074493,
-0.025737457,
0.0884548351,
0.011236798,
-0.0477950387,
0.0208099745,
0.0179453082,
0.0461188555,
-0.0067020222,
0.0295524765,
0.0316697918,
-0.0493666939,
0.0064621908,
-0.0388044007,
-0.0097335977,
-0.056558039,
0.0351243541,
0.0543498062,
-0.0114575466,
0.0398038141,
0.0325790308,
0.025650667,
0.0008135567,
0.0000020827,
0.0068545444,
-0.005234187,
-0.041485481,
-0.0510954708,
-0.0245584417,
0.0276427902,
-0.0037613611,
-0.0321156904,
0.010169086,
-0.0220633931,
-0.0010909084,
0.0246074945,
0.1094721854,
0.0841885954,
0.1054066494,
-0.011693581,
-0.0361372568,
-0.0150480447,
-0.0392838232,
-0.0108130937,
-0.0394344106,
-0.0001686982,
-0.0228468906,
-0.040372517,
-0.0342933387,
-0.0384691283,
-0.0253121145,
0.0392087549,
-0.0213778615,
-0.0209623296,
0.0055773575,
-0.0346264094,
-0.023701312,
-0.0114816744,
0.0775038525,
-0.0136245722,
0.0235160328,
-0.0121347317,
-0.0082488852,
-0.002504024,
-0.0285915881,
-0.0348181315,
0.006772812,
0.0036467807,
0.0220270231,
-0.0236697942,
0.0464301668,
0.008077357,
0.0087760752,
-0.057585597,
0.0772483125,
-0.0353775844,
-0.0069776364,
0.0327389836,
-0.0096730292,
0.0134090092,
-0.0242578797,
-0.0040791393,
0.0009361936,
-0.0506429523,
0.0179910865,
-0.0135512417,
-0.0272531398,
-0.0497834608,
-0.0480847992,
-0.0418580249,
0.027665332,
-0.0113621531,
0.0328169316,
0.0180092026,
0.0370793492,
-0.0206769407,
0.0132729141,
-0.002139779,
-0.0342720561,
-0.0363418348,
-0.0029095756,
0.0018161646,
-0.0048707258,
-0.0632237047,
-0.0361531302,
-0.0432719029,
0.0062700505,
-0.0670410618,
-0.0199113116,
-0.0008231461,
0.0406065695,
0.0207138415,
-0.0015254077,
-0.0001781661,
0.0713589266,
-0.0317634158,
0.0212858524,
0.0360892974,
-0.0804031864,
-0.0206589457,
0.0319997072,
0.0229144692,
-0.0108337319,
0.021358734,
0.0169370677,
-0.0192856286,
-0.0212255921,
-0.0269044135,
-0.0107743684,
-0.0506307296,
-0.0660817847,
0.0462313034,
-0.0140173156,
0.0801485255,
-0.0268011577,
-0.011002209,
-0.0254761428,
0.0364556052,
-0.022941485,
-0.0101915821,
0.091335468,
0.0327388756,
-0.0354344808,
0.0037290896,
0.012188646,
-0.0201341249,
0.0624207594,
0.0262218229,
0.047197599,
0.0126604605,
-0.0169397406,
0.0317341797,
-0.0013853759,
0.015620294,
-0.0316801295,
0.0101907905,
-0.0201354064,
-0.0271733403,
0.0585528649,
0.0350167118,
0.0034344082,
-0.0410618521,
-0.0515738688,
0.0214597452,
0.0272420496,
-0.0415526479,
0.0386431031,
-0.0141841918,
0.0314494781,
-0.0529837422,
-0.0196302589,
-0.0199078377,
0.0940496549,
-0.0258875675,
-0.0541269109,
-0.0115396623,
0.0079079363,
-0.039330788,
-0.0218789186,
0.0154712079,
-0.0083827749,
0.015994722,
0.0034294138,
0.0123077948,
0.0093166688,
-0.0275008194,
0.0509641767,
-0.007176403,
-0.0775875077,
-0.0232317504,
-0.0230749976,
-0.0183040034,
0.0564472862,
0.0113270916,
0.015077265,
-0.062030185,
-0.0380354039,
-0.0256623309,
0.0451699384,
0.0023962548,
0.006523252,
0.0546524003,
-0.0642667934,
0.0248773303,
-0.0129644815,
0.0022227343,
0.0401262492,
-0.0451108962,
-0.0095263021,
-0.0078439843,
0.0244709104,
0.0418265201,
-0.0033189538,
-0.0416071825,
-0.0025889867,
0.0231010523,
0.0350251868,
0.0429445729,
-0.0161337685,
0.0124993157,
-0.0317009389,
0.0239301082,
-0.0029813109,
-0.0472199433,
0.0729518309,
-0.0429349802,
-0.068215169,
0.0367308594,
-0.0607482418,
-0.0253448375,
0.0254182648,
-0.077493459,
-0.0451551303,
0.074023664,
-0.0018641901,
-0.0006365139,
-0.0385336243,
0.0160941966,
0.0109524792,
0.0446101613,
0.0229520034,
0.0283830501,
-0.0039582015,
-0.011902784,
-0.0171794277,
-0.0055828257,
0.0285934377,
-0.0177873056,
-0.0000929603,
0.0104162712,
0.0072150123,
-0.0280636903,
-0.0120252641,
-0.0317580551,
-0.0609147362,
-0.0627920181,
-0.0865374804,
-0.0000921335,
-0.0109019848,
-0.0010940376,
0.0231030248,
-0.0063786441,
-0.0001541968,
0.002539793,
-0.0300258044,
0.0153016038,
0.0102047715,
-0.0016967602,
0.0037628058,
-0.0258822814,
0.0066698641,
-0.0304344781,
0.0269105714,
-0.0310521089,
0.0547719374,
-0.0207123999,
-0.0112706153,
-0.0079789041,
-0.0117021743,
-0.0361635275,
0.0345480591,
-0.0382718071,
-0.0577681102,
0.0036736648,
0.0202799328,
0.0304925498,
0.0912002176,
0.0399405584,
0.0956309512,
-0.0116915163,
-0.0342198983,
-0.0459487811,
0.039454408,
-0.0190696958,
0.016884977,
-0.0267480202,
-0.0195933972,
-0.0341301262,
0.0498313159,
-0.0134324208,
0.0194099545,
-0.0554859415,
-0.0220127534,
0.0470316745,
-0.0461150073,
-0.0005606664,
-0.0543861389,
-0.0133760246,
0.0358618982,
-0.0307799336,
-0.0086004287,
0.0419493653,
-0.0151426261,
-0.0461932048,
-0.0528938286,
0.0122661367,
-0.0266081896,
0.0726715401,
-0.0081310561,
-0.0161486138,
0.0171901938,
0.0101944609,
-0.015908679,
-0.0287505351,
0.0073466068,
-0.0388992094,
0.0195260774,
-0.0460857973,
-0.0260753203,
0.016911719,
-0.0417763144,
-0.0349023826,
-0.0361279286,
-0.032716725,
0.0015908948,
-0.0037759969,
-0.0306770485,
-0.0255856793,
-0.0156234102,
0.0383915678,
-0.0217906665,
-0.0297304504,
0.0090870606,
0.013769594,
0.0064756596,
0.0475617796,
0.010538768,
0.0260937959,
-0.0135832056,
0.0270414967,
0.059430249,
0.0274961032,
-0.0124520436,
-0.0501514301,
0.0227622781,
-0.0251404643,
0.0515669361,
-0.0069856411,
-0.0383191109,
0.049439352,
-0.0267794803,
0.009886709,
0.1135976687,
0.0193285327,
-0.0509111956,
-0.0191139504,
-0.0175086632,
0.0109830555,
0.0234217141,
0.0121688675,
-0.0658868253,
-0.0371705629,
0.0113067394,
-0.0019121731,
0.00759019,
-0.0143263722,
-0.0106510893,
-0.0923364311,
0.0611579418,
-0.0035725087,
0.0041037966,
-0.0303677507,
0.0124715678,
0.0250837076,
-0.0152337467,
0.0060939267,
-0.0477722324,
0.0520468131,
-0.0087037841,
0.0252776984,
-0.0048281881,
-0.0070776376,
0.0431654602,
-0.025149934,
0.0366802141,
0.0278942026,
0.0703523979,
0.005218484,
-0.0676926672,
0.0245327447,
0.0001099491,
-0.0001815752,
0.0222349539,
0.082499668,
-0.0274705794,
-0.017190814,
-0.0216757264,
0.0569709167,
-0.0407137722,
-0.0137150632,
-0.0508657396,
0.0595425181,
-0.0686304942,
0.0156374667,
0.0000456482,
0.0393967181,
0.0314107463,
0.0440399796,
0.0437580049,
-0.0242466461,
-0.0152937006,
-0.0254532322,
0.02998247,
-0.0394694619,
-0.035551846,
0.0018194115,
0.0604243539,
-0.0303048939,
-0.0143582281,
-0.0564941727,
0.0112299267,
0.021876961,
-0.0569902435,
-0.0905520394,
0.0030902911,
-0.0277499817,
-0.0342855193,
0.026485838,
0.0144074447,
0.0219932962,
-0.0130213704,
-0.0051500555,
0.036953561,
0.0053421678,
-0.0129938973,
0.0276604481,
-0.0312944762,
-0.0255431365,
0.0164204519,
0.042243816,
0.0194499567,
0.0499959625,
0.0177957043,
0.0105737774,
-0.0215606559,
0.0215605441,
-0.0003488535,
0.0154713932,
0.0465210304,
0.0229456574,
-0.0094789295,
0.0360986516,
-0.0267434735,
0.0352605954,
0.0176389031,
-0.012115472,
-0.0497323461,
-0.0518874116,
0.0077787573,
-0.0296316948,
0.0836517215,
0.0186081082,
-0.0266657285,
-0.0239164252,
0.0260040108,
-0.0062625385,
0.0112507129,
-0.033934325,
-0.0079547595,
0.006187154,
-0.0116699757,
-0.0395696051,
-0.018006146,
0.0029116694,
0.0005557294,
0.02254197,
0.0133306235,
0.0241660532,
-0.0171421934,
-0.0613264814,
0.0472012796,
-0.0112465089,
0.0043267254,
0.0380948149,
0.0453583151,
-0.0047321459,
0.0913954824,
0.0532885045,
-0.0121628931,
0.0043769623,
0.0385019854,
-0.0618579425,
-0.0189600158,
0.0122171883,
-0.0369072147,
0.0109783439,
-0.0186615828,
0.0455178134,
0.0094068255,
0.0253492072,
0.006017813,
0.0421149246,
-0.022860622,
-0.0676417425,
0.0301042832,
0.0152728846,
-0.0108997896,
-0.0102240108,
0.0286756679,
-0.073619619,
0.0354827084,
-0.0004425689,
0.0259506889,
-0.036182899,
-0.0085231634,
0.0205119513,
-0.0320645906,
0.0454244576,
0.0435749888,
-0.0698396116,
-0.024311766,
0.01820012,
-0.0352153219,
0.0163178481,
-0.020289449,
0.0291369241,
0.0631387606,
-0.0151263056,
0.0013841419,
-0.0009709417,
0.0211719666,
-0.0362689309,
-0.0004902076,
-0.0504448153,
-6.23984801e-33,
-0.027108185,
0.0048396974,
-0.0128327664,
0.0319837593,
-0.0095920023,
-0.0025774469,
-0.0359026343,
-0.0159873329,
-0.0348675624,
0.0601627491,
-0.0144012207,
0.0655158088,
0.0070375744,
0.0263833944,
0.0005415443,
-0.0336670056,
0.0226717889,
-0.0062048496,
-0.0227230825,
0.0214906968,
0.0886414349,
0.019391574,
0.0718985051,
-0.1075371504,
-0.0389077403,
0.026434036,
-0.0362119749,
0.032223437,
-0.0000282633,
0.0051961383,
0.016787665,
-0.0011173588,
0.0166299082,
-0.0799069628,
0.0100961439,
0.0168439243,
-0.0158397965,
-0.0161396507,
-0.0290684272,
0.037060149,
-0.0296335407,
-0.0179077294,
0.004025647,
0.0260724537,
0.037369594,
-0.0372502878,
0.0038575067,
0.0027666842,
0.0464079902,
-0.0284695476,
-0.0198355857,
0.0171399098,
-0.0500557534,
-0.0538301989,
0.0177014861,
0.0702224597,
-0.0063907788,
-0.0164891221,
-0.0581904463,
0.0033678752,
-0.0398387313,
-0.0128278797,
0.0293654054,
0.0154751828,
-0.0121266851,
0.101581715,
0.0410297289,
0.0195068829,
-0.064893581,
-0.0023828808,
-0.0109651489,
0.0528608188,
0.0701527074,
0.0566007495,
0.0332607552,
-0.0317977779,
-0.0293668602,
0.0122868996,
0.0355982594,
0.0205561519,
0.0132640302,
0.0257630143,
0.0142039666,
-0.0249129739,
-0.0158685874,
-0.0455679037,
-0.0181727149,
-0.0234023463,
0.0212892722,
0.0061883358,
0.0173540283,
-0.0128922518,
0.0358083174,
-0.0199949872,
0.0461979732,
0.0401371829,
0.0069642561,
0.0372607671,
0.0242729485,
0.0184306223,
-0.0123657556,
-0.0078048357,
0.0694084689,
0.0308082011,
0.0672397166,
-0.0048559494,
0.0494979173,
0.0265617687,
-0.0302669778,
-0.0179441907,
-0.0624983199,
0.060031388,
-0.0545210354,
0.0329365432,
-0.0404202454,
0.0443408452,
-0.0239807107,
0.0175752249,
-0.0222708713,
0.0646672919,
-0.02720589,
-0.0048625148,
-0.0072716926,
0.0378793776,
-0.0344755836,
-0.0032623038,
-0.0206597056,
-0.0511394851,
-0.0045821257,
-0.0440117195,
-0.0075376737,
0.0031212298,
2.898e-7,
0.0091284281,
0.0448721796,
0.0706339255,
-0.0255332775,
0.0304490868,
0.0699511468,
-0.0104217548,
0.0018288391,
0.0531338342,
-0.0525461286,
0.0242357422,
0.0351225734,
0.0576411821,
0.0311460346,
-0.0620209388,
-0.0271064304,
-0.0597694814,
-0.0408880822,
0.013413243,
-0.0098734526,
0.0981476679,
0.0733193159,
0.0455419086,
0.0106097218,
0.0532371439,
0.0582074709,
0.0434785448,
-0.0214499291,
0.0260111485,
-0.0040388992,
-0.0218336955,
-0.060833443,
-0.0062158164,
0.0284207463,
0.0145328566,
0.0133796437,
-0.0550677925,
0.0287627801,
-0.0252783112,
-0.1077670082,
-0.0075966162,
0.0285967588,
-0.0325909294,
-0.0569362529,
0.0378329009,
-0.0630876645,
-0.0416227132,
-0.0123392018,
-0.0711992458,
0.0375560597,
0.0214076266,
0.0042428127,
-0.0115515729,
0.0260876417,
-0.0123202885,
-0.0036321611,
-0.0117327785,
-0.1175577492,
0.0063544977,
-0.0002245106,
-0.0661507845,
0.0339851342,
-0.0320760794,
-0.0055759801,
0.0648518279,
0.0123822764,
-0.0163224898,
2.059929642e-34,
0.0134228077,
0.0311744008,
-0.0179021433,
0.0198841337,
0.0718020126,
-0.0181693118,
-0.0511578359,
-0.0132658444,
0.0163585972,
-0.0353663042,
-0.0079017114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13954v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13954v1 | Characterizing the Emotion Carriers of COVID-19 Misinformation and Their Impact on Vaccination Outcomes in India and the United States | 2023-06-24T12:56:56 | 2023-06-24T12:56:56 | Ridam Pal, Sanjana S, Deepak Mahto, Kriti Agrawal, Gopal Mengi, Sargun Nagpal, Akshaya Devadiga, Tavpritesh Sethi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | The COVID-19 Infodemic had an unprecedented impact on health behaviors and
outcomes at a global scale. While many studies have focused on a qualitative
and quantitative understanding of misinformation, including sentiment analysis,
there is a gap in understanding the emotion-carriers of misinformation and
their differences across geographies. In this study, we characterized emotion
carriers and their impact on vaccination rates in India and the United States.
A manually labelled dataset was created from 2.3 million tweets and collated
with three publicly available datasets (CoAID, AntiVax, CMU) to train deep
learning models for misinformation classification. Misinformation labelled
tweets were further analyzed for behavioral aspects by leveraging Plutchik
Transformers to determine the emotion for each tweet. Time series analysis was
conducted to study the impact of misinformation on spatial and temporal
characteristics. Further, categorical classification was performed using
transformer models to assign categories for the misinformation tweets.
Word2Vec+BiLSTM was the best model for misinformation classification, with an
F1-score of 0.92. The US had the highest proportion of misinformation tweets
(58.02%), followed by the UK (10.38%) and India (7.33%). Disgust, anticipation,
and anger were associated with an increased prevalence of misinformation
tweets. Disgust was the predominant emotion associated with misinformation
tweets in the US, while anticipation was the predominant emotion in India. For
India, the misinformation rate exhibited a lead relationship with vaccination,
while in the US it lagged behind vaccination. Our study deciphered that
emotions acted as differential carriers of misinformation across geography and
time. These carriers can be monitored to develop strategic interventions for
countering misinformation, leading to improved public health. | [
0.0316784009,
0.0541043542,
-0.0221903156,
-0.0395529233,
-0.0139685692,
0.0286529921,
0.0104388855,
-0.0235044993,
0.0458746813,
0.0029380752,
0.0167341996,
-0.0174840149,
-0.0192349758,
0.046667736,
0.0095547838,
-0.0752763078,
0.0298696067,
0.0814857781,
0.0533157252,
0.0147239026,
0.0027414225,
0.0358028561,
-0.0160658304,
0.0468248054,
-0.0218534973,
-0.0157498587,
0.028826952,
0.0136072394,
0.0772093907,
-0.1000882685,
0.0633761361,
-0.0063170874,
0.0541845784,
0.0359121561,
0.0000020598,
-0.0192391369,
-0.0250201989,
-0.0029127204,
0.003173766,
-0.021888962,
0.086374715,
-0.0783923939,
0.01728555,
0.0278893504,
-0.0385799147,
-0.0338091627,
0.0677052811,
0.0704806596,
0.0434682146,
0.1021304801,
-0.031156091,
-0.0182856731,
-0.0028946484,
0.0080068549,
0.0084935306,
0.021859929,
0.0326155983,
-0.016479617,
-0.0209023673,
0.000612716,
0.0012763017,
0.0214242134,
-0.0275038425,
0.0078740418,
-0.0234978534,
0.0274920799,
-0.0068631559,
-0.05313069,
-0.0034649507,
0.0290462859,
0.007147138,
-0.0183955822,
0.0264951605,
0.0046320842,
-0.0006449042,
0.0180176888,
-0.037157841,
-0.0085211452,
-0.0135376267,
0.0481610037,
0.0008476945,
0.0480378382,
0.0284242015,
0.0351516716,
0.0287368651,
0.045531366,
-0.0495711677,
-0.0409742221,
-0.0210331436,
-0.0281966049,
-0.0003748309,
-0.0191005692,
0.026259318,
-0.0018191198,
-0.0012055067,
0.012254823,
0.0023027835,
-0.0586257055,
0.0042733368,
-0.1081861109,
-0.0664277673,
0.0029861156,
0.0022593951,
-0.0398570858,
0.0586059615,
-0.0074196458,
-0.022077715,
0.04036377,
0.0246158782,
0.0184572227,
-0.0474985652,
0.0305513684,
0.0190019757,
0.0166288279,
0.0371916331,
0.0307713263,
-0.1118131131,
-0.0490049832,
-0.0526706949,
-0.0468885638,
-0.0325187035,
0.0194224939,
0.0075124302,
0.0198556129,
0.0096592512,
0.0822498947,
-0.0119036445,
0.0235647522,
-0.0016397629,
-0.0300743785,
0.0205995366,
-0.0153375696,
0.0057992768,
0.0073726899,
-0.0134685831,
0.0091697071,
0.0328508914,
-0.009773938,
-0.0198938046,
0.0032886609,
-0.0194985885,
-0.0286572184,
-0.0254007298,
-0.0245353393,
0.0200518109,
0.0233573448,
-0.0096264398,
-0.0255334098,
-0.0125163523,
-0.0147889648,
-0.089768596,
0.0203988124,
-0.0049097105,
-0.0070925313,
0.0567533262,
0.0417507589,
0.0402234048,
0.0115122199,
0.0149741247,
0.0750246346,
0.0254024491,
-0.0135730179,
0.0365266912,
-0.0123933973,
0.0429690778,
-0.0043853545,
-0.0026838758,
-0.0345835052,
-0.0248055495,
-0.0022975162,
-0.0126219774,
0.0099943122,
-0.0140759265,
0.0222637895,
0.0298587587,
0.003869663,
-0.0350105055,
-0.0056712963,
-0.0090929,
0.0592904538,
-0.019797327,
-0.0379303321,
-0.0015068067,
-0.0017018015,
-0.0188766774,
-0.0287089143,
0.0137543771,
0.0224340279,
-0.0199553501,
-0.0099667599,
-0.0236613676,
-0.0167777371,
0.0374749377,
-0.0430395529,
0.0234702379,
-0.0407659374,
-0.0411054567,
0.0149776861,
0.0577459522,
-0.0497938655,
-0.0146893291,
-0.0447630882,
-0.0037642748,
0.036322806,
-0.0093701752,
0.0260191876,
-0.0477092676,
-0.0493529923,
0.0180470813,
-0.0119680492,
0.0233217217,
0.0147279203,
-0.0462565944,
0.00692647,
0.0115210861,
-0.0020055184,
0.02769522,
-0.0065158717,
-0.0014238301,
0.0639753044,
-0.0250154678,
0.0153746549,
-0.0064051813,
-0.0056101936,
-0.0106779505,
0.0068170344,
-0.0329929143,
0.0420912839,
0.0702645406,
0.0033774599,
0.0340199135,
-0.006422047,
0.0517964363,
-0.0087450044,
-0.0180115663,
0.0033920398,
0.0333285592,
0.0101824505,
-0.0249130577,
-0.04088578,
0.0061277538,
0.0503278412,
-0.0419306718,
0.0631404072,
0.0544586964,
0.0275148842,
0.0091571258,
0.020155143,
0.0032064593,
-0.0380778275,
0.0385206155,
0.0459468737,
0.0049056252,
-0.0542838834,
-0.0452182628,
-0.0238432288,
-0.0531472638,
-0.0153007619,
0.0219136719,
0.0168632641,
-0.0471451916,
-0.0247956011,
-0.0138154747,
-0.0134042595,
-0.041522041,
-0.0117418822,
-0.0273977034,
-0.0846517757,
-0.0218561664,
0.0149650034,
-0.0181997642,
-0.0000915301,
0.0129281897,
-0.0263680182,
0.0275121238,
-0.0078979228,
0.0008091892,
0.0343405083,
0.0344246812,
0.0208995752,
-0.0314447321,
-0.0104341032,
-0.0296985619,
0.0083999289,
-0.0774426162,
0.0009473879,
0.01957771,
-0.0784039199,
0.0085733831,
-0.0358884931,
-0.0568132997,
-0.0072994535,
-0.0342517719,
-0.058705844,
-0.0105910087,
0.0171999317,
-0.0136281829,
-0.0019700159,
0.0282794163,
0.0962808877,
0.0173162464,
0.0355241187,
-0.0173556302,
0.0356235914,
-0.0715943947,
-0.0116436752,
-0.0192209389,
-0.0577382706,
-0.0147095071,
0.0851835236,
0.0136746559,
0.0273874644,
-0.0077445949,
0.0149980932,
-0.0411832966,
-0.0344386697,
-0.0324735418,
-0.0289301462,
-0.0002693304,
0.027151715,
0.0000845684,
-0.0609142333,
0.0025988021,
0.0408246927,
0.0600070618,
-0.0692181811,
-0.0101711452,
-0.01274879,
-0.0173077844,
-0.0152661875,
-0.0122804232,
0.0410540625,
0.0239103716,
0.0234000664,
-0.0714114904,
-0.0509941392,
-0.0506542735,
-0.0432607159,
-0.0121628996,
-0.0135596842,
0.0095249191,
-0.0280272067,
-0.0274351649,
-0.0950419381,
-0.0424754471,
-0.0316088051,
0.0524757318,
-0.0223669298,
-0.0454645976,
0.0121924784,
0.0190473087,
-0.0272624791,
0.0178871937,
-0.0346492715,
0.0736664683,
-0.0155054564,
0.0614710897,
-0.0106118592,
0.0411483869,
0.0056981174,
-0.0308986995,
0.0180914607,
0.0137479519,
0.0081163952,
-0.0156875383,
0.0135171907,
-0.0070067779,
0.0208636727,
-0.0252424926,
-0.0019123029,
0.0204332527,
-0.0082659619,
0.0155969262,
0.0755843073,
0.0142309591,
-0.0191477034,
0.0083736992,
-0.0371032506,
-0.0253524669,
-0.0123907672,
0.0148857664,
-0.0300577115,
0.0068147238,
-0.0242966563,
-0.0132022081,
-0.0390338749,
-0.0196135826,
-0.0119061563,
-0.0209262576,
0.0444753133,
0.0050059678,
0.0206308514,
-0.0427130386,
-0.0362616256,
0.0009295439,
-0.0026215496,
-0.0025019231,
-0.0665446594,
0.0279591586,
-0.0182394143,
0.0150892418,
-0.0787076652,
-0.0165782217,
0.0113686724,
0.0131653221,
0.0139716323,
0.0129148951,
0.0890840292,
-0.0238328539,
-0.0666452721,
0.0036524092,
0.0445782915,
-0.0268313382,
-0.0307597201,
0.1127451584,
-0.0324891247,
0.0055048787,
-0.0530667119,
0.0245270692,
-0.0284917336,
-0.0073069003,
-0.0321621113,
0.0861764699,
0.0038789513,
-0.0782975033,
-0.0633618832,
0.0504757017,
0.0360630117,
0.0298805386,
0.0107343309,
-0.0040236269,
0.0144339381,
-0.0053773597,
0.0523176827,
-0.0030102199,
-0.0544179976,
-0.0005897945,
-0.0120513393,
-0.1090310663,
0.0127607426,
-0.0230040811,
-0.0024319193,
-0.0249259286,
-0.0172367133,
-0.0416533835,
0.0492500737,
-0.0281020701,
-0.0379953422,
-0.0105925137,
0.0318798907,
0.0180544909,
-0.003922801,
-0.0323371887,
0.0264356975,
0.0428797007,
-0.0099956291,
0.0164340809,
-0.025232818,
-0.0273349173,
0.0444521159,
0.010977719,
0.0209120475,
0.0111410208,
0.0323458463,
0.0295541044,
0.1024250314,
0.0692313388,
-0.0161044989,
-0.0385401547,
0.0104001043,
0.0410275199,
0.0005074844,
0.0032597084,
0.0091759861,
0.0220976956,
-0.0134201739,
-0.033363644,
-0.0611113459,
0.0086862035,
0.001818079,
-0.0173548497,
0.1063574031,
0.0086975563,
-0.0662253201,
-0.0249601472,
-0.0394090489,
0.0193549693,
0.0030778246,
0.0191499237,
-0.0536711812,
0.032946337,
0.0069859396,
-0.0789585561,
0.0038923901,
-0.020468628,
-0.0330287032,
-0.0393991843,
0.0493257008,
0.0184983965,
0.0703363195,
0.0103410836,
0.0018377452,
0.0264599826,
0.0078933109,
-0.0128284423,
-0.0152771724,
-0.0113302758,
-0.0061988253,
-0.0216148943,
0.0293701459,
0.0284770261,
0.0278821159,
-0.0042508543,
-0.0177106149,
-0.0428292826,
-0.026318619,
-0.0214535743,
-0.0154101634,
0.0632438511,
-0.0283665061,
-0.0143541312,
-0.0193333309,
0.0273526255,
-0.0777797326,
-0.0168636106,
0.0227116365,
-0.0482377745,
-0.0648708716,
-0.0081750555,
0.026627887,
-0.031632144,
0.0717103854,
0.047041975,
-0.069365561,
-0.0206462462,
0.014140428,
0.0336348303,
-0.0195121188,
0.0146968532,
0.0382702798,
-0.0788183063,
-0.0172108896,
0.0930309072,
-0.0913063958,
-0.0211710818,
-0.0300443303,
0.0007490384,
0.0475006551,
0.0019497996,
0.0191851594,
-0.0319538489,
0.0338780954,
-0.0394478478,
-0.0583585501,
-0.0217145588,
-6.049914939e-33,
0.0253166389,
-0.0152057549,
-0.0318008885,
-0.0064469529,
-0.0337537862,
0.0514981113,
-0.0031544026,
0.004006098,
-0.0034910876,
0.0562724881,
0.001815429,
0.0242185611,
0.0014786561,
0.0045108791,
0.0328596011,
-0.0356253646,
0.0326498635,
0.0138425343,
0.013129741,
0.0294503663,
0.0628721714,
0.0440574139,
0.0443124101,
-0.1051822752,
0.0322988182,
-0.0232688468,
0.002805006,
-0.0262185968,
0.0369586609,
0.0377846658,
-0.0114275338,
0.0579756349,
0.0382822417,
-0.0007615146,
0.0190675966,
0.0653179288,
-0.002661166,
-0.0264628045,
-0.0235147681,
-0.0328715667,
-0.0310494825,
-0.0466932058,
0.0596794859,
0.0490140244,
-0.0339982323,
0.0036834101,
0.0189530551,
0.0359396003,
0.0347257778,
-0.0437433086,
-0.0333220027,
0.0026874272,
-0.0358321704,
0.0030710311,
-0.0157698058,
0.0990851745,
-0.0086980695,
0.0944823623,
-0.061558459,
0.0242648739,
0.0226767771,
0.0179911684,
0.0150266904,
-0.0462723412,
0.0130169066,
0.0454570875,
0.0357763134,
-0.0207031798,
-0.0787244886,
0.0193127319,
0.0082959365,
0.0141301434,
-0.0004469401,
0.0643741414,
0.016903339,
-0.0758405253,
-0.0598249026,
0.0569714941,
-0.0123422081,
0.0423577912,
0.0126702758,
0.010226666,
-0.0185275227,
-0.0132961459,
0.0293535963,
-0.0245947447,
-0.0116465883,
-0.0118321097,
0.0070721437,
-0.0291916411,
0.006316727,
0.0142532047,
-0.0101468088,
0.0082237357,
-0.0325262509,
0.0079523586,
0.0144005138,
0.0378089994,
0.0081269275,
0.0246909671,
-0.0269631892,
-0.0024234694,
-0.0247866306,
0.0456345044,
0.0730867386,
0.0031258995,
0.020216126,
0.0124158552,
-0.0429564975,
-0.0245711599,
0.0157974828,
0.0416481793,
-0.0184141379,
0.0152047304,
0.0048107444,
0.0156293288,
0.0091447607,
-0.0516425334,
0.0231445674,
0.0463624224,
0.0394563377,
-0.0261132177,
-0.0546794385,
0.0369305089,
-0.0248676129,
0.0162877981,
-0.0353529938,
0.0171827041,
-0.0149637386,
-0.1022924185,
0.0006826165,
-0.0359532014,
2.883e-7,
0.0503988452,
0.0906134918,
-0.0025258707,
-0.0227048621,
-0.0003662318,
0.047401417,
-0.0096287476,
0.0049151736,
0.0001867883,
-0.0638219789,
0.0232840385,
0.000129324,
0.0021184769,
0.0436776541,
-0.0438435785,
0.0252780616,
-0.0489162505,
0.0520841777,
-0.0217316486,
0.0136665776,
0.0253472663,
0.0521136299,
0.0282455608,
-0.0199654363,
-0.0123354411,
0.0824829116,
0.0251110867,
-0.0588037558,
-0.018990526,
0.0311656222,
-0.0115227988,
-0.0136552183,
0.0017119229,
0.0067564375,
-0.0157034863,
-0.0635258555,
-0.0187915899,
0.0152203795,
0.0148956664,
0.0000877933,
0.0186289754,
-0.0170652121,
-0.0051251072,
-0.0386733823,
0.0196349844,
-0.0811303034,
-0.071189329,
-0.0184319038,
-0.0342783369,
0.0546344481,
0.0784820095,
-0.0083828848,
-0.0401352718,
0.0127303144,
-0.0003911949,
0.0018293824,
0.0018967872,
-0.0437521636,
0.0107205687,
-0.0090366537,
-0.040594656,
-0.0275998078,
-0.0145592662,
0.0135345384,
0.0397894681,
0.0140913706,
0.0722818598,
2.1356138e-34,
0.0459563881,
0.0004571147,
-0.0265405755,
-0.0344763473,
0.029883286,
0.0147200711,
-0.0097133741,
0.0112751285,
0.0118328808,
-0.0272761844,
0.0277658589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13947v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13947v1 | Comparison of Pre-trained Language Models for Turkish Address Parsing | 2023-06-24T12:09:43 | 2023-06-24T12:09:43 | Muhammed Cihat Ünal, Betül Aygün, Aydın Gerek | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Transformer based pre-trained models such as BERT and its variants, which are
trained on large corpora, have demonstrated tremendous success for natural
language processing (NLP) tasks. Most of academic works are based on the
English language; however, the number of multilingual and language specific
studies increase steadily. Furthermore, several studies claimed that language
specific models outperform multilingual models in various tasks. Therefore, the
community tends to train or fine-tune the models for the language of their case
study, specifically. In this paper, we focus on Turkish maps data and
thoroughly evaluate both multilingual and Turkish based BERT, DistilBERT,
ELECTRA and RoBERTa. Besides, we also propose a MultiLayer Perceptron (MLP) for
fine-tuning BERT in addition to the standard approach of one-layer fine-tuning.
For the dataset, a mid-sized Address Parsing corpus taken with a relatively
high quality is constructed. Conducted experiments on this dataset indicate
that Turkish language specific models with MLP fine-tuning yields slightly
better results when compared to the multilingual fine-tuned models. Moreover,
visualization of address tokens' representations further indicates the
effectiveness of BERT variants for classifying a variety of addresses. | [
0.0250560883,
0.0166576263,
0.0075337118,
0.0205955282,
-0.0203743707,
0.0358185954,
0.0512882583,
-0.0064800563,
0.0302338209,
-0.0413134396,
-0.0234697852,
-0.0438473448,
0.0151256807,
-0.0088391015,
0.0330315158,
-0.0487522781,
0.0227807239,
-0.0197092611,
0.021454066,
0.024968544,
-0.0275026895,
0.0119355172,
-0.0217198599,
0.0247310996,
-0.0126404623,
0.0295847524,
0.0096558072,
-0.0175806601,
0.0221409407,
-0.0271904226,
0.0212516636,
-0.0035735194,
-0.0325361565,
0.0041124644,
0.0000017734,
-0.0335824378,
-0.0294794161,
0.0324165784,
0.0138675729,
0.0094366688,
0.0105936388,
-0.0355360322,
-0.052021198,
0.0138700772,
0.0058346833,
-0.0675122961,
0.0357214399,
0.0705683902,
0.0447178222,
0.092695877,
-0.0171798188,
-0.1240810752,
0.0491555035,
0.004488375,
-0.0220225248,
-0.0282888301,
0.040617995,
-0.0620976053,
-0.0536057875,
0.00106377,
0.0249729119,
0.009134436,
-0.0342208892,
0.0178171322,
-0.0280987732,
0.0328480676,
-0.0479477085,
-0.0295565631,
0.0113251507,
0.0334060714,
-0.0702167079,
-0.0143404938,
0.026400093,
0.0086787231,
-0.0023712132,
0.0085864551,
0.0054918202,
0.0005010506,
-0.0182634555,
0.0312145595,
-0.0163537972,
0.008705074,
0.0292467065,
0.0111670718,
-0.0942840204,
0.0506326966,
0.0161856879,
-0.0579165071,
-0.0129493969,
0.0228934549,
-0.0027364052,
-0.0188243818,
0.0606809631,
0.0190340448,
0.0708338097,
-0.0087221824,
0.0027090402,
-0.0606478341,
0.0211511161,
-0.0694916099,
0.0520241782,
0.0357400738,
-0.0637844428,
0.0098103508,
-0.1070709676,
0.0264278091,
-0.0103210853,
0.0437614918,
0.0119380578,
-0.0277371127,
-0.0485397354,
-0.0131853018,
-0.0667135864,
0.0260679089,
-0.0218024962,
0.0437103622,
-0.0339326076,
0.0029746897,
0.0222905055,
0.0169198066,
-0.0252745114,
-0.0418011434,
0.0185893141,
0.0060342588,
-0.0251060743,
0.023896398,
-0.0530517921,
-0.0257067364,
-0.0460909829,
-0.0168590676,
0.0352393538,
0.0139876418,
0.036035724,
-0.0391723104,
0.0126955211,
0.0388748236,
0.0026531897,
-0.0540761687,
-0.0531706065,
0.0645326152,
-0.0177841131,
-0.0116492789,
0.0136765875,
-0.0197444912,
0.0301785581,
0.0146659892,
-0.00272121,
-0.0018922018,
-0.0085536418,
0.0109747397,
-0.0279834345,
0.0736602843,
-0.0000519759,
0.0237491988,
0.0709004328,
-0.0489180088,
0.0627411827,
0.0106986593,
0.0104221525,
0.0185676794,
-0.0029057129,
-0.0069114571,
0.0210555531,
0.0442799106,
0.0124065671,
-0.0477283411,
0.0250054561,
0.0131012136,
-0.0256797951,
-0.0078082308,
0.022162674,
0.0430373959,
-0.0346136093,
0.033828605,
0.0156545024,
0.0308601782,
-0.0000028513,
0.059906289,
0.0179500449,
0.0299966373,
0.0201670155,
-0.0084518399,
-0.0070289019,
-0.0698430389,
0.0336578451,
0.0343322083,
-0.0379241407,
0.0281566661,
-0.0157185551,
0.0103441263,
-0.0018605031,
-0.0210467707,
0.0029425428,
-0.0272541307,
0.1048198044,
-0.0129221864,
-0.0602564029,
0.0745280311,
-0.0129282568,
-0.0125612188,
-0.0161471795,
-0.0378658175,
-0.0252112634,
0.0243242681,
0.0128838513,
-0.0394751951,
-0.0123196542,
-0.026301397,
-0.0117042921,
0.0121938111,
0.0615350604,
0.0016466673,
0.0241702888,
-0.0482366979,
0.0155010829,
0.0340152048,
0.0036489037,
0.0257680397,
-0.0123014441,
0.0289466605,
0.0401132852,
-0.0331583358,
0.0161403529,
0.0319697671,
0.0362194069,
0.0269186888,
-0.0152597092,
0.0436363108,
-0.0291068945,
0.0335467979,
-0.0275196116,
0.001388807,
0.0176010039,
-0.0638136417,
0.0642484277,
-0.0018740653,
-0.0337088965,
0.0126778549,
0.019751057,
-0.0330207385,
-0.008801044,
0.0467494242,
-0.0322097763,
-0.0216929596,
-0.024121007,
-0.0144775268,
0.0951323658,
-0.0237099752,
0.0363566242,
-0.006218283,
0.0152636468,
-0.034405455,
0.0426186249,
-0.0160699319,
0.0028279519,
-0.0005292997,
0.0184823629,
0.0366085321,
0.0333969407,
-0.0420644954,
-0.013753497,
-0.0427593701,
-0.0311905555,
-0.0109447157,
0.0086240564,
0.0140862493,
-0.0599011071,
-0.087160401,
-0.0771944374,
-0.0295492765,
0.037075229,
0.0039660055,
0.0209510364,
-0.0261038784,
-0.0358390212,
0.0113442345,
-0.0493343733,
0.0089688208,
-0.0082760146,
0.0811833963,
-0.001981538,
-0.0203396548,
-0.0061522322,
-0.0167532004,
-0.0338792838,
0.0259372741,
-0.0017801079,
-0.1002452001,
-0.0294543412,
-0.0399697982,
0.0312115904,
0.0300216954,
0.0170308575,
-0.0481905416,
-0.0007419955,
0.0011734307,
0.0374952704,
0.0118741458,
-0.0066217287,
-0.0035704521,
-0.0327372365,
-0.0268163253,
-0.0284590833,
0.0201051924,
-0.0073698573,
0.006707889,
-0.0611250736,
-0.0174638927,
0.0179062039,
0.023044385,
-0.0645395741,
0.0053341272,
-0.0119278356,
-0.0736567974,
-0.0262585096,
0.004930187,
-0.0088023441,
0.0149138756,
-0.0205698628,
0.0548009463,
0.010427299,
0.0041731354,
0.0194027238,
-0.0659928918,
-0.0008950648,
-0.0334237665,
0.0322080106,
-0.0283383597,
0.0263706278,
0.0148440367,
0.0310551748,
-0.0213992298,
-0.0928231701,
0.0306070428,
-0.0064270012,
-0.023541268,
0.0035876569,
0.0403074548,
0.0308263693,
0.0213726591,
-0.0231276788,
-0.0462432504,
-0.0345325209,
-0.0609220415,
-0.0108969361,
0.0234050713,
0.0368741341,
-0.0051222127,
-0.0483551212,
0.0795331523,
-0.0185536761,
0.0739410445,
0.0093312217,
0.0072584162,
-0.0122440243,
0.0149173541,
-0.0001824952,
-0.0135180168,
-0.0362573601,
0.0153575083,
-0.017822668,
-0.0261541009,
0.0209553763,
-0.0044095209,
-0.0138958283,
-0.0027290492,
0.0190586373,
-0.0828775242,
-0.0245391689,
-0.0422763079,
0.0315141305,
-0.0191436447,
-0.0296558943,
0.0977635533,
0.0211986247,
0.0029493209,
-0.0227085538,
0.0085865967,
-0.0288166106,
-0.0073126061,
0.0676640496,
-0.0608048104,
0.0088667953,
0.014747696,
-0.0140760113,
0.0031342234,
-0.0261460785,
0.0636065528,
-0.1231068075,
-0.0131832696,
-0.0296759773,
-0.0455930084,
-0.0531721786,
-0.0546000116,
-0.0324220397,
-0.0229728557,
-0.0212022439,
-0.0176307578,
-0.0305910055,
-0.0300559774,
0.0419678465,
-0.0503088683,
-0.0488108732,
-0.0288920943,
-0.0561936423,
0.0152265197,
0.046895586,
0.0338629633,
-0.0751793236,
-0.008527345,
0.0194702037,
0.0060982951,
0.0121839549,
0.0227316637,
0.0133378869,
-0.0124804694,
-0.0503681898,
-0.0129872682,
-0.0496488623,
-0.0145658953,
-0.0161021762,
-0.0379780643,
-0.0026908137,
-0.0280009937,
0.0512975976,
0.0107486136,
0.0088101923,
-0.01497922,
0.0249710474,
-0.0088263722,
-0.0186319239,
-0.0567737892,
-0.0130486907,
-0.0027067789,
-0.0402371436,
0.0470280834,
0.0638402328,
-0.0224418472,
-0.0635527819,
-0.0415895917,
-0.0349465087,
0.0399885289,
0.0255613495,
0.0041492782,
-0.0339952335,
0.0447221175,
0.0184026528,
-0.0024389157,
0.0261892602,
0.0089630624,
0.0093835546,
-0.0774862766,
-0.0062210294,
0.0199962296,
-0.014243125,
-0.0322176814,
0.0150363687,
-0.0251529142,
-0.023696607,
0.0571994372,
0.0590128899,
0.0114308642,
0.003036018,
-0.0655719042,
-0.0310929399,
0.0287403967,
-0.0256702397,
-0.0127100032,
-0.0511951782,
0.0242112596,
-0.0328365006,
-0.0312892608,
-0.0282108765,
0.0071348567,
0.0467230976,
0.0270642992,
-0.0334365554,
-0.0304229669,
0.0208149012,
0.002325854,
0.0216032602,
0.0823329613,
-0.0170564633,
0.047112681,
-0.042170573,
0.0208464693,
0.0162111819,
0.0539451316,
0.0336254835,
-0.0155221242,
0.0424634591,
0.0205752067,
-0.0006891408,
-0.0094962334,
0.0005860018,
-0.0073444056,
-0.0178511124,
0.0292764157,
-0.0085208695,
0.0306225829,
0.0035279158,
-0.0118482225,
-0.0359680168,
0.0215996578,
0.0088234562,
0.0222793445,
-0.0228029471,
0.0053670211,
-0.0134885665,
0.0138310371,
-0.000257867,
0.0548539758,
-0.0255790167,
0.0003508602,
-0.0415355973,
0.0535972416,
0.0767315254,
-0.0451998413,
0.0326706134,
-0.0266159065,
0.0136269368,
-0.0066306787,
-0.0244976599,
0.0151074566,
-0.0061705201,
-0.0324336067,
-0.0187574048,
-0.0203262866,
-0.0293565914,
0.027879186,
0.0142382998,
0.0505718663,
-0.0101066465,
0.0051195612,
-0.0161682293,
0.0071297833,
0.0178268477,
0.0287926774,
-0.0517616346,
-0.0227065086,
-0.0182833802,
-0.0430717804,
0.0307925157,
-0.0172011908,
0.0163140539,
-0.0028916986,
0.0140390769,
0.0371786393,
0.0438576043,
0.0099664815,
-0.0202662833,
0.0051010218,
0.0385037921,
-0.0199546758,
-0.0294685513,
-5.294194029e-33,
-0.000144075,
0.0413844995,
-0.0015144182,
-0.0405363627,
-0.007380228,
-0.0176908951,
0.0063396189,
-0.0134496912,
-0.0510307588,
-0.003933413,
-0.0503238067,
-0.0423167385,
0.0571011789,
0.0652902499,
0.0023127778,
-0.0312732309,
0.0519703776,
0.0192262493,
0.0125853019,
-0.02055078,
0.0261001643,
0.0841567293,
0.082796216,
-0.0372138657,
-0.0155145749,
-0.0255025066,
-0.0108473832,
-0.0115519753,
0.0471018814,
0.0405621305,
-0.0135069992,
0.0050242278,
0.0207380876,
-0.036973305,
0.0138090821,
0.0198430065,
-0.1077361628,
0.0190320667,
0.003308753,
0.0762559846,
0.0512031391,
-0.0121675301,
0.0288041215,
-0.017625276,
-0.0006470009,
0.088792026,
0.0237766542,
-0.021482842,
-0.0059326505,
-0.0115026934,
-0.0728327334,
0.0601794124,
0.001697177,
0.0188141018,
0.0673121512,
0.0450955071,
0.0182450619,
0.0050663594,
-0.0483488776,
-0.0077532236,
0.0509106517,
-0.0088232383,
0.0310704466,
0.0121745542,
-0.0027711773,
0.0336047411,
0.0064225732,
0.0155917611,
-0.0120955342,
-0.0179932285,
0.0030954506,
0.014854148,
-0.0123255486,
-0.0060596168,
-0.0225549657,
-0.0859065056,
-0.0615711734,
0.0352757201,
0.044972688,
0.0195772387,
0.029279355,
-0.0330827124,
-0.0339880399,
-0.0090421773,
0.0320614055,
-0.0496963263,
0.0016912824,
-0.0059647257,
0.0196165107,
0.0005044191,
-0.0270692129,
0.1048265249,
0.0216672439,
-0.0146568678,
-0.0170020014,
-0.0630547926,
0.0161041096,
0.0438610949,
-0.0558434017,
0.031568747,
-0.0267239902,
-0.1157528087,
-0.0316332579,
0.0281945057,
0.0113644581,
0.0124489898,
0.0408026911,
-0.0071480102,
-0.0710754395,
0.0189674124,
0.010966124,
0.0316478945,
0.0079770731,
0.1032347977,
0.0177484974,
0.0018696408,
0.0024062167,
0.0154657625,
0.0306326412,
0.0132174054,
0.0415148549,
0.0068251803,
0.0475998968,
0.0325189643,
0.0312925167,
-0.0040653325,
-0.0405173264,
0.0170339439,
0.0148561336,
-0.0285802782,
-0.0091269072,
-0.0123982765,
2.51e-7,
0.0583577715,
0.0523214042,
0.0588784777,
-0.0262142532,
-0.0088497065,
-0.0042838743,
0.0442430489,
0.0332499892,
-0.0207986403,
0.0488833338,
0.0081989365,
-0.0642263219,
0.0261309799,
0.0092692198,
-0.1095416471,
-0.0161447749,
-0.0729707852,
0.0080879265,
-0.0673125014,
0.0826144144,
0.023307031,
0.0849036947,
-0.0162738282,
-0.0127816601,
-0.0183031373,
-0.0004722792,
0.0325992219,
-0.0456909761,
0.0154595114,
0.0245453157,
0.0194106065,
0.0429369099,
0.0075196014,
0.0260209125,
-0.0117721697,
0.0360446833,
0.0494711362,
0.0838529617,
-0.013015328,
0.0422673263,
0.0518220775,
-0.0344004184,
-0.0268452987,
-0.0844111145,
0.0588312,
-0.0507999361,
-0.0206739791,
0.000889878,
-0.010111602,
0.0157971177,
0.0008015915,
-0.0454585031,
-0.0040536793,
0.0521115363,
0.0564677715,
-0.0417539515,
-0.0088924179,
-0.059672378,
0.016049657,
-0.0005017087,
0.0208071396,
0.0177229736,
-0.0379884541,
-0.0549568534,
0.0724191591,
0.0056887562,
-0.0077389544,
1.853807511e-34,
-0.018243989,
-0.0030937386,
-0.0255795382,
0.044970382,
0.0179339908,
-0.003716799,
0.0273974128,
0.0319157615,
-0.0534353964,
-0.028883975,
0.0048765782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13922v1 | Unsupervised Mapping of Arguments of Deverbal Nouns to Their Corresponding Verbal Labels | 2023-06-24T10:07:01 | 2023-06-24T10:07:01 | Aviv Weinstein, Yoav Goldberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | Deverbal nouns are nominal forms of verbs commonly used in written English
texts to describe events or actions, as well as their arguments. However, many
NLP systems, and in particular pattern-based ones, neglect to handle such
nominalized constructions. The solutions that do exist for handling arguments
of nominalized constructions are based on semantic annotation and require
semantic ontologies, making their applications restricted to a small set of
nouns. We propose to adopt instead a more syntactic approach, which maps the
arguments of deverbal nouns to the universal-dependency relations of the
corresponding verbal construction. We present an unsupervised mechanism --
based on contextualized word representations -- which allows to enrich
universal-dependency trees with dependency arcs denoting arguments of deverbal
nouns, using the same labels as the corresponding verbal cases. By sharing the
same label set as in the verbal case, patterns that were developed for verbs
can be applied without modification but with high accuracy also to the nominal
constructions. | [
0.0065494203,
0.0432247184,
-0.0350101702,
0.0684450567,
-0.0567707866,
-0.0131021142,
-0.046710223,
0.009261962,
-0.021389205,
-0.0922964811,
0.0439232029,
0.030880738,
-0.0296978671,
-0.0185655616,
0.0079405233,
-0.0629291162,
0.0402879901,
0.0134713287,
-0.0550026484,
0.0168918017,
0.0294189397,
0.0104725063,
-0.0212989617,
0.0270527881,
-0.0828412995,
-0.0390568674,
-0.0101273889,
-0.033624582,
0.0151780499,
-0.0495939925,
-0.0145631498,
-0.0032029466,
0.0186001677,
-0.0266570281,
0.0000018515,
-0.0678898469,
-0.027192913,
-0.0188942943,
-0.0066451537,
-0.0225464385,
-0.0005318897,
-0.0244395416,
0.0000404029,
-0.054181397,
-0.0258595813,
-0.031573385,
0.0436194167,
0.0458276533,
0.0021810606,
0.0467174351,
-0.0219447818,
-0.0438339561,
0.0277532265,
0.032599505,
-0.0385954939,
0.040932171,
0.009551187,
0.0397019051,
-0.0080544809,
0.002103728,
-0.0185782053,
-0.0123025384,
-0.0111122457,
-0.0061461967,
0.000259653,
-0.0168156102,
0.0052579241,
-0.0038791816,
0.0260972008,
0.0302908923,
0.0145637458,
-0.0602829978,
0.0056282985,
-0.0098560546,
-0.0202291664,
0.0574950166,
-0.0108937472,
0.0207538418,
-0.0296554659,
0.0238227658,
0.1060797647,
0.0178371128,
-0.0057835835,
-0.0001968078,
0.0142437415,
0.0821399838,
0.0086635407,
-0.0130491024,
-0.020742394,
0.0140144462,
0.0042983624,
-0.0663393289,
0.0232933648,
-0.0115433708,
0.0011770325,
0.0706881806,
-0.0398251787,
-0.0214202367,
0.0066432473,
-0.075060688,
0.0015282943,
-0.0007324518,
-0.0090858582,
0.02342676,
-0.025236873,
0.0184140094,
-0.0178737957,
-0.0300467443,
-0.0258831494,
-0.0064363279,
-0.0854745209,
0.0147878928,
-0.0560877807,
0.0527743623,
-0.0382687002,
-0.0076828459,
-0.0086526936,
0.0071269544,
-0.0126429722,
-0.0348203816,
0.0091342982,
0.02956222,
-0.0293817986,
0.0189206619,
-0.054344032,
-0.0072519137,
-0.0698447451,
0.0250818525,
-0.041391544,
-0.0350230075,
0.0147674978,
0.0109824836,
0.037085034,
-0.0113028912,
-0.0452561155,
0.0861571729,
0.0291824117,
-0.0313670263,
-0.0742417127,
-0.0611963496,
-0.0225025266,
0.0224132948,
-0.0444450192,
-0.0796154216,
-0.016834056,
-0.0038313249,
0.0200496055,
-0.0377901234,
0.0271443892,
0.04429584,
-0.0111630335,
0.0818478018,
-0.0261693485,
-0.0289932378,
-0.0277435035,
-0.0259133112,
-0.0202748571,
0.0013896856,
0.0522360504,
0.013921502,
0.0321983099,
0.0114499629,
-0.0086675026,
-0.0271536391,
0.0178246479,
-0.0079922639,
-0.0207462814,
-0.0035500366,
-0.0291173551,
0.0168022886,
0.0293928757,
0.0212160107,
-0.0182561204,
-0.0212890115,
0.0246575661,
0.048753608,
0.0085432623,
-0.0068467464,
0.0809296742,
-0.036919497,
-0.0247309934,
0.025640551,
0.0084221503,
-0.042785041,
-0.0187223684,
-0.0167962611,
-0.086150229,
-0.0051763961,
0.0237218216,
-0.0461016297,
-0.0399741232,
-0.0181800034,
-0.0068655009,
-0.0297623537,
0.0519571416,
0.0762080178,
0.0296650715,
0.0220457632,
0.04951014,
-0.0353418514,
-0.0161388908,
0.0156275574,
0.0284204576,
0.0221319515,
0.0398651436,
-0.0282353703,
-0.0229889546,
-0.0002228705,
-0.0071722176,
0.0257483907,
-0.0267915614,
-0.0549681373,
-0.0227386355,
0.0162835326,
0.0222352184,
0.0136749102,
0.0132898306,
0.0273010861,
-0.0088003073,
0.0111948112,
-0.0130447289,
-0.0324215256,
-0.0361135229,
0.0479206778,
0.0257516392,
-0.0334617347,
0.0171178412,
0.0264977533,
0.0460704006,
0.032414224,
0.0133475317,
0.0050608893,
0.0336049795,
-0.0507577285,
-0.0528507382,
0.0340692624,
-0.0291540883,
-0.0275928285,
0.007095681,
-0.0573665574,
0.0120215509,
-0.0321908593,
0.021018317,
-0.0460401513,
-0.0096471375,
-0.0620794147,
0.0694440231,
-0.008026531,
0.0231341254,
0.0343187228,
-0.0074470555,
-0.0459146053,
0.1126079485,
0.0365437157,
0.0180686302,
-0.0623197556,
0.0341466777,
0.0342958011,
0.0106724333,
0.0137666222,
-0.0085315118,
0.0040684477,
-0.0226503778,
0.0527510457,
-0.0387163088,
-0.0449331515,
0.0528645404,
-0.0560913235,
0.0073096058,
0.0016572403,
0.0498704165,
0.023307126,
0.0076057394,
0.0099117449,
-0.012461476,
0.0144375945,
0.0056711677,
-0.0316133611,
-0.0035137697,
0.0485100746,
-0.0523111224,
-0.0153292632,
-0.0226893295,
0.0354167484,
-0.0498494543,
0.0202077627,
0.0047873473,
-0.0407187715,
-0.0281415209,
0.0123981033,
-0.0084146224,
0.039509628,
0.0353435799,
-0.0185366981,
0.0318349302,
0.0232437178,
0.0420172997,
0.0374738984,
-0.0158365984,
0.0352699198,
0.0329253636,
-0.0345173627,
-0.0543190353,
-0.0249475185,
-0.0058106086,
0.0619025603,
-0.0159665924,
0.0005635262,
0.0410090648,
0.0741229653,
0.0387583189,
-0.0000386616,
-0.0004323332,
0.0182302464,
-0.0582737438,
-0.0042217704,
-0.0124290064,
-0.0349937268,
-0.0427133143,
0.0314684361,
0.0193395168,
-0.0101711154,
0.0707550943,
0.0012101447,
0.0492902026,
-0.0406794697,
-0.0222356431,
-0.0230483152,
0.0946110636,
0.0279757585,
0.0205183141,
0.0677396581,
-0.0404121503,
0.0067603621,
0.0140437596,
0.0536400303,
0.0402894281,
0.0592133366,
-0.0599893108,
0.0361460149,
0.0078456709,
-0.0352624245,
-0.0326957479,
-0.0067418665,
-0.0344525687,
-0.0085287336,
0.008211947,
-0.0050821486,
0.0142244752,
-0.0006775272,
-0.0037491017,
0.0148906633,
0.0101650199,
-0.0240114499,
-0.0462209694,
0.0524539612,
-0.0162957124,
-0.0078622894,
-0.0305102691,
0.0911542401,
0.0013334866,
0.0512163863,
-0.0225523151,
-0.0058476157,
-0.0473210067,
0.0175485648,
0.0023568638,
-0.0404771827,
-0.0464908257,
-0.0247286372,
0.0010989755,
-0.0230127908,
-0.0236771442,
0.0627892464,
0.063359499,
0.0003097125,
0.044655133,
-0.0189971346,
-0.0001891805,
0.0208901856,
-0.0063035525,
-0.0764210671,
-0.0344998203,
-0.0063840342,
-0.0533205494,
-0.0396515951,
-0.0152822072,
0.0241113361,
-0.0814004987,
-0.0042139459,
-0.037416216,
-0.035556633,
0.0290173683,
-0.013114729,
0.0259096287,
-0.0354687236,
-0.0352506302,
-0.0299830809,
-0.0175781306,
-0.009593471,
0.0073182406,
-0.020486949,
-0.0061469111,
0.0152849527,
-0.0344354287,
0.0131081017,
0.0080313543,
0.0675344765,
0.0053801183,
0.0068025501,
-0.0002894086,
-0.0508674905,
0.012337531,
0.0058596395,
-0.0043782243,
0.0034184526,
-0.0050455006,
-0.0255832449,
0.0233769212,
-0.0363143124,
-0.061175663,
0.0256979633,
0.0853940845,
-0.0190161653,
0.043506965,
0.0044138953,
-0.0416540951,
-0.0215870012,
0.0335805677,
-0.002702771,
0.0190744456,
0.0038531532,
-0.0283220448,
-0.0285247844,
0.0230022147,
-0.0324100666,
0.0112739326,
-0.0830802619,
-0.0521558039,
-0.1167887077,
-0.0321899876,
0.0383324362,
0.0439047292,
0.0146351811,
-0.0077462993,
0.0725972727,
-0.001004398,
-0.0230890363,
0.0248060506,
-0.0064918608,
0.0181501452,
0.0127030928,
-0.0226341654,
0.0745194554,
0.045748163,
-0.010727576,
0.0214014146,
0.0640277117,
-0.0434131399,
0.0253344178,
-0.0024002497,
0.016507348,
0.021895824,
-0.0336230956,
-0.0186398048,
-0.0162380654,
0.0211014021,
-0.0226631463,
-0.0206846967,
0.0052626436,
0.0115173915,
0.012853899,
0.0308434442,
0.0109575307,
0.0502393283,
-0.0425344333,
0.0408763066,
-0.0844365507,
0.0259904563,
0.0802889094,
-0.0181323905,
0.0621798374,
-0.0154844029,
-0.0256040953,
-0.0407479741,
-0.0005307095,
-0.0711146295,
-0.0515218042,
-0.019008344,
0.0568711534,
-0.0036055313,
0.0451616272,
-0.0201712046,
-0.0320913792,
-0.0445503183,
-0.0223175399,
0.0243884288,
-0.0019762018,
0.1494295597,
0.0249865949,
-0.0569408908,
0.0263008699,
0.0067129848,
-0.0055540917,
-0.0219194088,
0.0218626633,
-0.0614016317,
0.0029047534,
0.0089044776,
0.0024597109,
-0.0256290771,
-0.0258186962,
-0.0184788704,
0.0399875082,
-0.0132893901,
-0.0077782641,
0.0727907866,
-0.0644301921,
0.0468193814,
-0.0550300591,
0.0111295274,
0.0568878613,
0.0112014804,
-0.0070382068,
-0.0017434987,
0.0325207412,
0.0297664441,
-0.0351320617,
-0.0069206022,
0.0281580146,
-0.0481240675,
0.0265668929,
0.0023945093,
-0.0322309993,
-0.0173133779,
-0.0218950864,
0.0191188063,
0.0329930484,
-0.0003676343,
0.0055173156,
-0.0636825636,
-0.0333266221,
-0.0125696426,
0.0124836694,
0.0183750615,
-0.031566523,
0.072293058,
0.0109059224,
0.0407075621,
-0.0148019427,
-0.0581453331,
0.0201226529,
-0.0094249882,
-0.0228635632,
-0.0285204537,
-5.849751026e-33,
-0.0359980538,
-0.0307645593,
-0.0161938872,
0.0423354246,
0.0063959453,
0.0119674457,
-0.0107461968,
0.0038897947,
0.0203772541,
0.0760967806,
0.0107808802,
0.0130089559,
0.0255289134,
-0.0069893678,
0.0465834029,
-0.0181779023,
-0.0344081484,
0.0085744504,
-0.0017496529,
-0.0192585289,
0.0955074951,
-0.005739674,
0.0831067115,
-0.0871783569,
0.0407455713,
0.0371800847,
0.000230091,
0.0098534906,
0.0280536171,
0.0681990013,
-0.0024038737,
0.0498451851,
0.0178004969,
0.0013681343,
0.0214960128,
0.0157003365,
-0.06907285,
-0.0448946357,
0.0420000739,
0.0033078713,
-0.0580819547,
-0.026681494,
0.0164399333,
-0.000967335,
-0.003449362,
0.0696755126,
0.0428321622,
-0.0041531357,
-0.0188970342,
-0.0304763,
-0.1018026844,
0.0331343003,
0.0243436825,
0.0156226698,
-0.0111469952,
-0.0098907594,
0.0129885366,
-0.0079475734,
-0.0295604263,
-0.0074705691,
-0.0457748659,
0.0274083652,
0.0098817088,
-0.0235989224,
-0.0349859148,
0.0579569116,
0.0090719303,
-0.0447483882,
0.0407799482,
0.0712996274,
-0.0389688984,
0.0738602504,
0.0248438455,
0.0574141257,
0.061828766,
0.0363557786,
-0.0344221331,
-0.0250223316,
0.0609864928,
0.0211338177,
-0.0341369137,
0.0008844119,
-0.0507301316,
-0.0099913757,
-0.0018437398,
-0.007419568,
-0.0054361285,
-0.0200504735,
0.0117677925,
-0.0455759093,
-0.0011312109,
0.0305976961,
-0.0343994088,
-0.0152526395,
-0.0154335685,
-0.0292263236,
0.0208399054,
0.0359414965,
-0.0108340047,
0.0038798035,
0.0107900184,
-0.0355032384,
-0.0129907839,
0.0077397339,
0.0591648892,
0.0261244383,
0.01878253,
-0.0082506249,
-0.0273863673,
-0.0061220191,
-0.0232007988,
-0.0628877506,
-0.067624554,
-0.0222121254,
0.0493965484,
0.0404276736,
-0.0092903078,
0.0210256055,
0.0555414706,
-0.0145309623,
-0.0042671626,
-0.0540461913,
-0.0274479836,
0.0028004318,
0.0118733998,
-0.0355288312,
-0.0135316039,
0.0060284077,
0.0413555019,
-0.053350158,
0.011114738,
0.0207005814,
2.758e-7,
0.0540338121,
0.0461290628,
0.012994023,
0.0182448346,
0.00994578,
0.0012937273,
0.0190125443,
0.0400547311,
-0.0405496955,
-0.0652130246,
-0.0086476495,
-0.0424972102,
-0.0231377482,
0.0666090325,
-0.108934246,
-0.0022020454,
0.0135544771,
-0.0480151065,
-0.0397464745,
0.0137267243,
0.0901097804,
0.0812273845,
0.0542501919,
0.0034946743,
-0.0400089212,
0.0050065345,
0.0110171903,
0.0232911445,
-0.025622163,
-0.0151448231,
0.0246056411,
-0.0100405971,
-0.0049446071,
0.0432903655,
0.002239615,
0.0373733006,
0.0202264674,
0.0034786754,
-0.0272523165,
0.029657416,
-0.0392677188,
-0.0743407756,
0.0169224031,
0.0033318913,
0.0525052249,
-0.0390623659,
-0.0121389544,
0.0423186347,
-0.0161301177,
0.0539358668,
-0.0295420382,
0.0360351689,
-0.0449200198,
0.0097234361,
0.0277547706,
0.0071625956,
-0.0379150622,
-0.0711644217,
-0.0172506496,
0.0326958299,
0.0088195624,
-0.0034594836,
0.0474154539,
-0.000578661,
0.0102280974,
-0.0343211628,
-0.0411821529,
2.224840939e-34,
-0.0325291008,
0.0390801206,
0.0166302882,
0.0070438697,
0.0334912352,
-0.0049196323,
-0.0077585736,
0.0211548619,
0.0244325679,
-0.0403364338,
-0.0145027153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13906v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13906v1 | Can GPT-4 Support Analysis of Textual Data in Tasks Requiring Highly Specialized Domain Expertise? | 2023-06-24T08:48:24 | 2023-06-24T08:48:24 | Jaromir Savelka, Kevin D. Ashley, Morgan A Gray, Hannes Westermann, Huihui Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | We evaluated the capability of generative pre-trained transformers~(GPT-4) in
analysis of textual data in tasks that require highly specialized domain
expertise. Specifically, we focused on the task of analyzing court opinions to
interpret legal concepts. We found that GPT-4, prompted with annotation
guidelines, performs on par with well-trained law student annotators. We
observed that, with a relatively minor decrease in performance, GPT-4 can
perform batch predictions leading to significant cost reductions. However,
employing chain-of-thought prompting did not lead to noticeably improved
performance on this task. Further, we demonstrated how to analyze GPT-4's
predictions to identify and mitigate deficiencies in annotation guidelines, and
subsequently improve the performance of the model. Finally, we observed that
the model is quite brittle, as small formatting related changes in the prompt
had a high impact on the predictions. These findings can be leveraged by
researchers and practitioners who engage in semantic/pragmatic annotations of
texts in the context of the tasks requiring highly specialized domain
expertise. | [
0.0547676384,
0.0310077351,
-0.0043831738,
-0.0268252734,
-0.0202472322,
0.0382184647,
0.0278867558,
-0.0131654441,
-0.020367004,
-0.1069078818,
-0.0152273476,
-0.0267592873,
-0.0693640858,
-0.0053571514,
-0.0211028084,
-0.0804205388,
0.0274439268,
0.0190332197,
0.060031645,
0.0405437835,
0.0376558788,
0.0046520033,
0.0011398551,
0.0367046297,
-0.0680217892,
-0.0467376858,
-0.0186249688,
-0.0086637046,
-0.0016447239,
-0.0101808449,
0.0245840698,
0.1151788458,
0.0167676043,
0.0500620678,
0.0000020311,
-0.0460884944,
-0.0137990853,
0.0190493166,
-0.0128318677,
0.0124007426,
0.0275029056,
-0.0219975207,
-0.0197029952,
0.0113686956,
-0.0532086752,
-0.0369938388,
0.0143257249,
0.039098274,
0.0575383082,
0.1014923528,
-0.0240080636,
-0.0417139493,
0.0439345874,
-0.0476482101,
0.0097621009,
-0.0507868193,
0.0028862129,
0.0235378146,
-0.0087212827,
0.0210909266,
0.0076752659,
0.0089708064,
0.0488615073,
-0.028190095,
-0.0239004008,
0.0080168787,
-0.0360484533,
0.0176120419,
0.003560463,
0.0246978365,
0.0511200316,
-0.0161185004,
-0.0174541846,
-0.0113796778,
0.0439860262,
0.0409983732,
-0.0161907692,
0.0639190301,
-0.0202649385,
-0.0170794483,
0.0010804951,
0.0336637981,
-0.0266641211,
-0.0029982883,
-0.0233664662,
0.0516093187,
-0.007323835,
-0.036497768,
0.0268937349,
0.0719851777,
-0.0087846648,
-0.049363438,
0.0203471985,
0.0129761361,
-0.0058429502,
0.0181943998,
-0.0395335779,
-0.0624062344,
0.0221205838,
-0.0123687023,
0.0275164265,
0.0306595173,
-0.0381233506,
0.0378913097,
-0.0196032338,
-0.0133869853,
-0.0077360845,
0.0343265347,
-0.0013879278,
-0.0208480544,
-0.0647484809,
-0.0221246667,
-0.0619239807,
0.0273699034,
-0.0730148554,
0.0205588806,
-0.01289507,
0.0225343518,
0.0134476498,
-0.0206239428,
0.0011136872,
-0.0272237528,
-0.053814467,
-0.0072513171,
-0.0699179843,
-0.0111816088,
-0.0440416522,
0.0188628342,
0.0149551472,
-0.0436901338,
0.0011376338,
0.0178722721,
-0.0083812103,
-0.0301713906,
-0.0150737194,
0.0744338036,
-0.027995605,
-0.0149335722,
-0.0409722887,
-0.054726284,
-0.0090594906,
-0.0691341981,
0.0197878014,
-0.038427256,
-0.0160473026,
0.0050380891,
-0.0043651247,
-0.0425557233,
-0.0083659515,
0.0416094065,
0.0210071784,
0.0769030005,
-0.0185330976,
-0.0321780667,
-0.0196014903,
0.020916855,
-0.0094300052,
0.0325005874,
-0.0038477436,
0.0243770815,
-0.001740685,
-0.0084211566,
0.0569083765,
0.0284015182,
-0.0128333569,
-0.0115690976,
0.0361788459,
0.0089332825,
-0.0255745947,
0.0205665976,
0.0333397947,
0.0346053503,
-0.0257338714,
0.0187469814,
0.0362286828,
0.0497123562,
0.0123528913,
0.0888602138,
0.0534740798,
0.0016045888,
0.0280631501,
0.0244103037,
-0.0723891333,
0.0387503989,
-0.0114626242,
0.0102779949,
-0.0713090077,
-0.0107969837,
-0.0191917736,
-0.054744564,
0.0286122561,
0.0056793611,
-0.0314839073,
-0.0146426605,
0.0400217623,
0.0467647463,
-0.0339862779,
0.0382929221,
0.0016183206,
-0.0860659853,
-0.0295694675,
-0.0150791658,
-0.0105960853,
0.0328867473,
0.0511271544,
-0.0419590063,
-0.0549172387,
-0.045321621,
0.0352416709,
0.0636623576,
0.0562691167,
-0.005483835,
-0.0387447849,
-0.0565441065,
-0.0490889885,
-0.0087980777,
0.0354207307,
0.0099173896,
0.0201652627,
-0.0115552861,
0.0487035997,
-0.045222424,
0.0078659896,
0.0530482605,
-0.004778496,
-0.0352476686,
0.0034341838,
-0.0139658973,
0.0322465785,
0.0425241552,
0.0037312896,
-0.0044381283,
-0.0042191246,
-0.0017705652,
0.0152499964,
0.0314241238,
-0.0346123502,
-0.0101101045,
-0.0010816348,
-0.062900275,
-0.0502122678,
0.0024466168,
-0.0576482266,
-0.0201532859,
-0.0437508784,
-0.0135564627,
0.0317381807,
-0.0885350928,
-0.0432085022,
0.0173614826,
-0.0234614946,
-0.0315665752,
0.053336259,
0.0392383225,
-0.0337081924,
-0.0027144561,
-0.0020978267,
0.0429184847,
-0.004635999,
-0.0375490785,
-0.0690199807,
-0.0077750692,
-0.0021421714,
0.0253628548,
0.0189904179,
-0.0590669997,
-0.0206031222,
-0.0682063401,
0.0236585625,
-0.0495826602,
0.0379238501,
0.0169404559,
-0.0219757874,
-0.0206835009,
-0.0240443088,
-0.0362120233,
-0.0274819061,
-0.0374549702,
-0.0017218211,
0.0225268994,
0.0113423923,
0.0376652293,
-0.0127203083,
-0.006356738,
-0.0401675403,
0.0044158418,
0.0688419864,
-0.0270801019,
-0.0105514312,
0.0567178987,
0.010410293,
0.0000354322,
-0.012827375,
0.0025326337,
0.0089946864,
0.0174042508,
0.0514529385,
0.0121880136,
0.0256216303,
0.0305290651,
-0.0072353953,
-0.0144484034,
-0.031924475,
0.0340214334,
-0.0129747046,
-0.0036998184,
-0.0371360891,
0.0232313462,
0.0194293316,
0.0226548351,
-0.0183312166,
-0.0107977344,
-0.0558752045,
-0.0027848433,
-0.0108052762,
-0.0025639979,
0.002255793,
0.0054344372,
-0.0110981232,
0.0587522238,
0.0156076858,
-0.0265383944,
0.0589434505,
0.02329427,
0.0084476853,
-0.0643104985,
0.0442371741,
-0.0318129435,
0.0923390388,
-0.003044433,
-0.0217771567,
0.002483601,
-0.0433193892,
-0.035229031,
0.0254303645,
0.051137045,
-0.0216766763,
0.1150485203,
-0.0119021451,
0.0430997647,
-0.0506399125,
-0.0387856588,
-0.0396688916,
-0.0289835762,
0.0016208754,
0.0231255423,
0.0568513833,
0.0146434335,
-0.0387385376,
-0.0031015209,
-0.0298437886,
0.0724711269,
0.0062335189,
-0.0392932482,
-0.0249733552,
0.0277234241,
-0.0067073535,
-0.0137903448,
-0.0051624649,
-0.0274480674,
-0.000312348,
0.041508399,
-0.0430197492,
-0.0291552506,
-0.0312063806,
-0.0168563109,
-0.0145089608,
-0.0931226537,
-0.0216949843,
0.0108076548,
0.0317965113,
-0.0747996122,
0.0083047263,
0.1108710095,
0.0253630355,
-0.0564899705,
-0.0317555442,
-0.0073176487,
0.0190704949,
0.0237155668,
0.04692664,
-0.130524233,
-0.0152846025,
-0.0051646968,
0.0069476101,
-0.0110888314,
-0.0414628237,
0.0030424697,
-0.0948086902,
0.0932602212,
-0.0283626951,
-0.0077202902,
0.0157321934,
-0.0058233291,
0.0154284369,
-0.0280732717,
0.0006526749,
-0.0106457612,
-0.0208656937,
0.0314925946,
0.0411164723,
-0.038717702,
-0.0106150582,
0.0251072403,
-0.0186979007,
0.0400218181,
0.050610695,
0.011579467,
-0.0236008838,
-0.0020365359,
0.0347402543,
-0.0014459587,
0.0213749968,
0.0142033966,
0.0819226354,
-0.0094172172,
0.0171880629,
-0.0478856377,
0.0297230519,
-0.0085120248,
-0.042601943,
0.0471710414,
0.0696782395,
-0.041180741,
0.0024821837,
-0.0248803049,
-0.0069238478,
-0.0097075701,
0.057970196,
0.0327702723,
-0.013697492,
-0.0519002192,
-0.038307786,
0.0404856317,
-0.079954274,
-0.0319523066,
-0.0128101297,
0.0054057119,
-0.0238485113,
-0.0400323607,
-0.0561389513,
0.0367172807,
0.0410886854,
0.0262670983,
-0.0063746036,
0.0190496463,
0.0124848615,
-0.0445110463,
0.0503025316,
-0.0432278253,
-0.0271679591,
-0.0221066326,
-0.0387526862,
0.0375834294,
-0.0021230844,
-0.0290047433,
0.0110654049,
-0.0145164812,
-0.0031760137,
0.0039047222,
0.0241706353,
0.0175009817,
0.028815737,
-0.023022335,
-0.0279676672,
0.02722455,
0.0441910587,
-0.0150149502,
-0.0206304342,
0.0560888499,
-0.0294993874,
-0.023370916,
-0.006879678,
0.0129347788,
0.0639631972,
-0.0070764069,
0.0102707464,
-0.0163024738,
-0.0199901052,
0.0469450466,
0.0176840685,
0.0595414937,
0.0012639812,
0.0099042952,
-0.0380828492,
-0.0067721782,
-0.0289749205,
-0.0066053644,
-0.0444430709,
-0.0105929943,
0.0076473621,
-0.0094354888,
-0.0397257321,
0.0655083135,
-0.0256677959,
0.030027207,
-0.05460703,
0.0251417458,
0.0307779647,
0.0085121449,
-0.0099351276,
-0.0234058406,
-0.0131807895,
-0.0126749361,
0.0106400987,
0.043680802,
-0.0090928376,
0.0827010944,
0.031526085,
0.0278554279,
0.0468720496,
0.0075526726,
-0.0477065891,
-0.0061253579,
-0.0355507284,
0.0485072806,
0.0232458059,
-0.0198425502,
0.0172546562,
-0.0604690276,
0.0032862707,
0.0151893171,
0.0363559239,
0.0280454252,
-0.0162486974,
0.0187000372,
0.0107781328,
0.0048961304,
-0.028459562,
0.0526518896,
-0.0323353224,
0.0538804233,
0.0090275593,
-0.0268858206,
-0.0472037233,
-0.0466564409,
-0.0213626958,
-0.0088005094,
0.004745191,
-0.0220481772,
-0.0769149289,
-0.0279599838,
-0.0143727371,
0.004290327,
-0.0187340882,
0.0049587251,
0.0345801786,
0.0587229989,
-0.0167324804,
-0.0389442183,
-0.0328697711,
0.0110897869,
0.0014244604,
-0.0041423938,
-0.0174489561,
-5.794757727e-33,
-0.0387883186,
-0.0356208496,
0.037166182,
0.0379102193,
-0.0218440313,
-0.0233182982,
-0.0263073444,
-0.0124521535,
0.0130539723,
0.0463100597,
-0.0230001081,
0.0184215494,
0.0223519392,
0.0266507156,
0.0352346376,
-0.0189026538,
0.048252359,
-0.0116554303,
-0.0210198648,
0.0347789638,
-0.0038670937,
0.0018877104,
0.0481952168,
-0.0873337016,
0.032329388,
0.0151182767,
-0.0236958638,
-0.0432128869,
-0.0466772504,
0.0461866632,
0.0006182302,
0.025659157,
0.0310663339,
-0.0549950525,
-0.0222025774,
0.0418089293,
-0.0729128867,
-0.0260988902,
0.0115918759,
-0.0008321816,
-0.0137120308,
-0.0321831256,
0.010820494,
-0.0178819485,
0.0089188144,
-0.0259231608,
0.0492152162,
-0.0163119175,
0.0098683964,
-0.097705245,
-0.0880828202,
0.0514192618,
-0.020613661,
-0.0095409164,
0.0420783348,
0.0438095741,
0.0252277106,
0.0163658708,
-0.0550839417,
0.0071722171,
0.0111302389,
0.0074387663,
0.0088388985,
-0.0444382876,
-0.0324532129,
0.0308322776,
-0.0309486408,
0.019710632,
-0.0449133068,
-0.0124692796,
0.025549233,
0.0446209498,
0.0216518994,
0.059183713,
0.0424708575,
-0.0003179171,
-0.0498264618,
0.0159600023,
0.006918815,
0.0038147022,
0.0118001457,
-0.0534354113,
-0.02366402,
0.0013178365,
-0.020636037,
-0.0273917988,
0.0067278682,
-0.0286642052,
0.0339421965,
-0.0123314764,
0.0362591632,
0.0316756852,
0.0083130104,
-0.0152936699,
0.0331917033,
-0.0015528928,
-0.0410151109,
0.0382194072,
-0.035706453,
0.0261264425,
-0.0418275483,
-0.0173931271,
0.039203804,
0.0061570439,
0.0042530666,
-0.0080640912,
0.1040009707,
0.0010163158,
-0.0635602474,
-0.0173106585,
0.0003614485,
0.0668598264,
0.0139945727,
0.0189049114,
0.0012602501,
0.0411374606,
0.0108544528,
0.0217041355,
0.0266576912,
0.0116611933,
-0.0342388265,
0.015405261,
0.0221450496,
-0.0406077504,
0.0080612982,
0.0059656338,
0.0381062552,
0.015774494,
0.0173715185,
-0.0245629791,
0.0085283164,
0.0524828844,
2.658e-7,
0.1283465326,
0.058118891,
0.0217210855,
-0.022177441,
-0.0185203813,
0.0056322673,
0.0245498978,
0.0172924902,
0.0343627557,
-0.0191491898,
0.0514834374,
-0.0024769534,
0.0420724116,
0.0592283495,
-0.0981353745,
-0.0423789807,
-0.0415118597,
-0.0194026884,
-0.0536539331,
0.0331033058,
0.0901206806,
0.0701714531,
-0.0157794766,
-0.0118187368,
-0.0027424945,
0.0139103904,
0.0780619457,
-0.0187171549,
0.0126708401,
0.0245923996,
0.0547592454,
-0.0133943418,
0.004509185,
0.071125187,
-0.0185817927,
0.0195321105,
-0.0196944065,
0.0628497377,
0.0169927161,
0.017838696,
0.0051462851,
0.0003979155,
0.0304951407,
-0.0260274559,
0.0380574763,
-0.0805442408,
-0.0158694219,
0.0189573821,
-0.0638522953,
-0.0124018686,
-0.0052803094,
0.0293355957,
-0.0023726313,
0.0008132731,
0.0143517731,
-0.0110268435,
-0.0191343632,
-0.0806731805,
0.0087404912,
0.0253027622,
-0.0257100165,
-0.0067259576,
-0.0225718413,
-0.0359535664,
0.0535592698,
-0.0704459175,
0.0215408169,
2.279803794e-34,
0.0455149598,
-0.0024059105,
0.0413264036,
0.0276205167,
0.022056926,
0.0470064022,
0.0321861282,
0.0038654259,
-0.0148474602,
-0.0746212825,
0.0056501571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13905v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13905v1 | Spatio-temporal Storytelling? Leveraging Generative Models for Semantic Trajectory Analysis | 2023-06-24T08:45:47 | 2023-06-24T08:45:47 | Shreya Ghosh, Saptarshi Sengupta, Prasenjit Mitra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we lay out a vision for analysing semantic trajectory traces
and generating synthetic semantic trajectory data (SSTs) using generative
language model. Leveraging the advancements in deep learning, as evident by
progress in the field of natural language processing (NLP), computer vision,
etc. we intend to create intelligent models that can study the semantic
trajectories in various contexts, predicting future trends, increasing machine
understanding of the movement of animals, humans, goods, etc. enhancing
human-computer interactions, and contributing to an array of applications
ranging from urban-planning to personalized recommendation engines and business
strategy. | [
0.0153658669,
0.0751362443,
-0.0141992774,
0.039278429,
-0.0233607274,
-0.0153604327,
0.0093306219,
-0.0071902042,
-0.0738790855,
-0.0367086567,
0.0884153247,
-0.0163205508,
-0.01641188,
0.0815394446,
0.0140351932,
-0.1204171181,
0.0079137357,
-0.0040627285,
-0.0157261714,
0.0330212042,
-0.006660053,
0.0265019927,
-0.0343297273,
0.0523435697,
-0.0794678926,
-0.0172971282,
-0.013719664,
-0.0041108415,
0.0491479486,
-0.0681560859,
-0.0293699987,
-0.0071475026,
0.1331333816,
0.0351834148,
0.0000017191,
-0.0148039144,
-0.0031305235,
-0.0100951195,
0.0298783686,
-0.0337913111,
0.019745037,
0.0465660244,
-0.0075561367,
-0.0048167775,
-0.0400705785,
-0.0280395318,
0.0245224554,
0.0257478263,
0.0510106534,
0.0599252768,
-0.0290292725,
-0.0751621947,
-0.0015681452,
-0.0030158311,
0.0397407562,
-0.0044013974,
-0.0051124748,
0.0072268778,
0.0006339119,
0.012684009,
-0.070739463,
-0.0188983772,
0.0007183885,
0.0092627751,
0.0033069337,
0.0690701008,
0.0054569542,
0.0234816037,
-0.0254012886,
0.0664670318,
-0.0200366694,
-0.0286173057,
0.0151368519,
-0.0097091859,
-0.0288803782,
0.00490053,
-0.0537209846,
0.0118469978,
0.026546333,
0.0566337593,
-0.0185971092,
0.0314525552,
0.0143585484,
-0.0164329391,
0.0234130304,
0.0343037136,
0.0435006134,
0.0063227126,
-0.0791091993,
-0.0106430203,
0.0562194772,
-0.0702648014,
0.002896216,
0.0340405814,
0.0068143592,
0.0150570124,
-0.0115012266,
0.0294047892,
-0.0359589346,
-0.0217599459,
0.0316405371,
0.0019077434,
0.0093178889,
0.0317902379,
0.0218392778,
0.0162354894,
-0.0291797034,
-0.0095839649,
-0.0001726688,
0.0056366357,
-0.0273828171,
0.0092282956,
-0.0388243534,
0.011013858,
-0.0846341327,
-0.0368177146,
-0.0113158925,
0.0384583771,
0.0111029558,
-0.0017607074,
-0.0382044129,
0.0712692142,
-0.0228503216,
0.0012981512,
-0.0439343266,
-0.0187931582,
-0.0751049295,
-0.0022481349,
-0.0034600568,
0.0006327656,
0.0308045652,
0.0073022735,
0.0794038922,
0.0157934986,
-0.0286629945,
0.0568748489,
0.0269631483,
0.0138322785,
-0.0936224833,
-0.0370699577,
0.0046979007,
-0.0370639302,
-0.0126591437,
-0.0948891938,
0.0257245004,
-0.0184801612,
-0.0053905332,
-0.0331483223,
0.0071523585,
0.013570101,
-0.011424398,
0.0250718966,
-0.0218866467,
0.0058350652,
0.0205313116,
-0.0115668764,
0.1022640541,
0.0254456159,
0.0913217217,
0.0608653501,
0.050110355,
0.0150605543,
0.0252430327,
0.0033367083,
-0.0377873033,
-0.0097751394,
-0.0511988737,
-0.0278016962,
-0.0052328864,
0.0480157211,
0.0134511963,
0.0533818342,
-0.0474308021,
-0.0125382096,
0.0235796794,
0.0630366653,
0.0152499359,
0.0167081282,
0.1373986453,
-0.0057295715,
-0.0676685572,
0.0121362563,
0.0203073211,
0.0289372038,
0.0282092094,
-0.0171030574,
0.0105383769,
0.0236175358,
-0.0272933561,
-0.0377928801,
0.0287041366,
-0.0086814659,
0.0422497056,
-0.0328361802,
0.0264191907,
-0.0389599577,
-0.059987884,
-0.0061753076,
0.0179511253,
-0.0384141393,
0.0196793061,
0.0337976292,
0.0166646298,
0.0934174806,
0.0255370717,
0.0310329981,
-0.0152770095,
-0.0306452326,
-0.0090254266,
0.015919337,
0.0095024668,
-0.0273571797,
0.0153212724,
-0.0506803729,
-0.0264729131,
0.003848617,
0.0165026747,
0.006585388,
0.0032789069,
0.0783055648,
0.0239968114,
-0.0203866102,
-0.0139077045,
0.0337418951,
-0.0004143378,
-0.008442156,
-0.0102360332,
0.0055976072,
0.0032149195,
0.0093760425,
-0.03349787,
-0.0089418292,
0.0519263484,
-0.0172092114,
0.0111861471,
0.0686787143,
-0.0157464929,
-0.0196234211,
0.0112175411,
-0.0794459432,
-0.0223175492,
-0.0045591174,
-0.0405321531,
-0.0572195873,
0.0072348188,
-0.0492713861,
0.0130312582,
-0.0140135996,
-0.0170739405,
0.0484064445,
0.0166054517,
-0.0154726375,
0.050576333,
0.0203821249,
0.0323077515,
-0.0175585058,
0.054646939,
0.0367349386,
-0.0328207575,
0.0205824915,
0.0080175493,
0.0077044261,
-0.0113974558,
0.0495904572,
-0.0452112406,
-0.044617895,
0.0205480792,
-0.0626290888,
-0.0151776178,
-0.001081907,
0.0002427738,
-0.0101618059,
-0.0104125021,
-0.0246945117,
-0.0036909333,
-0.0574057847,
0.0145855127,
-0.0091246711,
-0.0403878577,
0.0383266136,
0.00997579,
-0.0314768218,
-0.0053232429,
0.0112051861,
-0.0454441905,
0.0517139137,
0.05025113,
-0.0382488966,
-0.0293794498,
-0.0305994172,
-0.023095049,
0.0548253506,
0.0057470589,
-0.0319990665,
0.0239241589,
-0.0026128774,
0.0589252971,
-0.0192910302,
0.0357288383,
0.030988792,
0.0010124967,
-0.0983487666,
-0.0201822165,
0.0378671736,
-0.0681173429,
0.0551946312,
-0.0587012321,
-0.0393657349,
0.0144832414,
0.0381665751,
0.0309658851,
0.0174777117,
-0.0388409086,
-0.0349221751,
-0.0120530995,
0.0071766013,
0.0048038447,
0.0316588804,
-0.0257105026,
0.055713661,
0.0019271515,
-0.0122373328,
0.0414373167,
-0.0200452562,
-0.0042755506,
0.0338796303,
0.0101806661,
-0.0162642766,
0.0900529921,
0.0329559185,
0.0510398112,
-0.020374747,
-0.0083945058,
0.0113424603,
-0.0321904272,
0.0056601213,
-0.0019125425,
-0.0246267878,
-0.0752605423,
0.0079218158,
0.0397729911,
-0.0192429367,
-0.0429595821,
-0.0431095771,
0.0055791889,
-0.0324252397,
-0.0172976796,
-0.0355650559,
-0.0005679242,
0.0023938254,
-0.0456147641,
0.051763434,
0.0152963493,
-0.0269265752,
-0.0110672228,
0.0550543666,
0.0948412344,
0.0092495969,
-0.0540839285,
0.0181677733,
-0.0105487835,
0.034026783,
-0.033486478,
0.017852867,
-0.0430942066,
0.0619475432,
-0.0022570547,
-0.0343475603,
-0.0024335387,
0.0725230724,
0.0052281655,
-0.051192943,
-0.0322641283,
0.0894790515,
0.0400722474,
0.0089618601,
0.040084403,
0.0173821785,
-0.0067420602,
0.004354123,
0.0191356782,
-0.075346604,
0.0033198178,
-0.0265181083,
-0.0234660804,
-0.0076624164,
-0.0439580046,
-0.008235381,
-0.0791198835,
0.0798815414,
0.0081449281,
-0.0302818343,
-0.0113805393,
-0.0351031609,
-0.0182266608,
0.0007298116,
-0.0294707976,
-0.0460021719,
0.0076254979,
0.0073847328,
0.0200092401,
-0.0569538921,
-0.0165724549,
0.0070331763,
-0.017064603,
0.0438862182,
0.0284962058,
0.0694287568,
-0.0202176161,
-0.0360892303,
-0.0432535596,
0.0309457872,
0.0263999701,
-0.0153267933,
0.029147232,
-0.044491794,
-0.003559808,
0.0047381492,
0.0334167518,
-0.0333792865,
-0.0415435135,
-0.0020610183,
0.0666172355,
-0.0330189466,
-0.0197549444,
-0.0588470958,
0.0185651742,
0.0191242583,
0.0351425782,
-0.0068634446,
-0.0088263238,
-0.0423989743,
-0.0447950363,
0.028105475,
-0.0818686485,
-0.0559367873,
-0.0306998827,
0.007210956,
-0.0671197698,
-0.062294621,
-0.0589782447,
0.0265733972,
0.0546153188,
-0.0289368052,
0.0261292271,
0.0164483283,
-0.0309699774,
-0.0660312995,
0.0031709655,
-0.0323642455,
0.0038398232,
-0.0134245213,
-0.0219528414,
0.0256156512,
0.0269962922,
-0.0232142918,
0.0256084558,
-0.0921042562,
-0.0600016676,
-0.0041968869,
0.0115033844,
0.0111203231,
0.0556428283,
-0.0095942887,
0.0166765843,
0.0357727967,
0.0055078096,
0.0287464038,
-0.0064236159,
-0.0379511639,
0.0321213901,
-0.0032718452,
-0.012011853,
-0.017741194,
0.0442338847,
-0.0155091835,
0.0461810753,
-0.0668149367,
-0.0158969425,
-0.0015230689,
-0.0414204225,
0.0976908803,
-0.02448906,
-0.0443287678,
-0.0461780466,
-0.0330213904,
-0.0553348213,
0.0095703546,
-0.0422729403,
-0.0073750331,
0.0210509915,
0.0276981574,
-0.0380499326,
0.0005815151,
-0.049584657,
-0.0527688675,
-0.0409334525,
-0.0053540641,
0.0381382182,
-0.0144221466,
-0.0146505134,
0.0176532585,
0.0102708079,
0.0001898533,
-0.033226788,
0.0227553695,
0.0063531371,
-0.0103853298,
0.0373611748,
0.0542987548,
0.0118468842,
-0.0112168668,
-0.0231883954,
0.0371218547,
-0.0412699431,
0.0812095925,
0.0737630129,
-0.0218372289,
-0.0052178022,
-0.0103637399,
0.0298729483,
0.023427397,
0.0060040043,
0.0112885162,
-0.0479453541,
0.012280575,
0.0135396216,
-0.0243300349,
0.0097284634,
0.0837623328,
0.0131449169,
0.0512082279,
0.0421528704,
-0.0516139157,
-0.0470786691,
0.0088921124,
-0.0105714817,
-0.0077235624,
0.0357157066,
0.0268472377,
-0.0301351734,
-0.0397002622,
0.0182158817,
0.0257443562,
0.0106819412,
-0.0001136934,
0.0665401518,
0.007083945,
-0.014913491,
0.0015319374,
-0.0454044752,
0.0098894211,
0.0009212731,
-0.0539591536,
-0.0643043369,
-5.705984761e-33,
-0.0074931667,
-0.0553526357,
0.05265202,
0.0079062246,
-0.059161108,
-0.0373435691,
-0.0379649587,
-0.0208799168,
-0.0051340619,
0.0512328856,
0.0146387061,
0.0027621125,
0.0091854585,
0.045721557,
-0.0028369545,
0.0093850745,
0.0476812199,
0.0035303305,
-0.0089030508,
0.0129956668,
0.0630831346,
-0.0000847092,
0.0286568943,
-0.0501393303,
-0.0317375027,
-0.0394441411,
-0.0350978374,
0.0184170157,
0.0672489107,
0.02521584,
-0.0042541921,
0.0088346004,
0.038435448,
-0.0277802739,
-0.0165480208,
0.0021594763,
-0.040681459,
-0.0673859045,
-0.0014214122,
0.002473233,
-0.0459800102,
-0.0438097157,
0.0164022502,
-0.0270860288,
0.0042447681,
0.0389824659,
0.0617853031,
0.0077826316,
-0.0164032448,
-0.0324934088,
-0.0668795928,
0.0256861392,
-0.0554226339,
-0.0209305398,
0.0398154147,
-0.0296929572,
0.0497642867,
-0.0101634059,
-0.0052723573,
0.0527098104,
-0.0355147496,
0.0273359269,
0.0095692817,
0.0116442051,
0.0337364264,
0.0553074963,
-0.0195400305,
-0.0559930839,
-0.0455299467,
0.0590195693,
0.0105022704,
0.05940089,
-0.0127319917,
0.0272782482,
-0.0009735893,
-0.0058681555,
-0.0582878105,
0.0630582273,
-0.0036671855,
0.0130341286,
-0.0171323121,
0.026345009,
-0.0323357843,
-0.0146834077,
-0.0067656096,
-0.0262032263,
0.0261593387,
-0.0328486636,
-0.0068637175,
-0.0139433863,
0.0136427591,
0.0601368286,
0.0227669086,
-0.0120779388,
-0.0278776754,
0.0158603247,
-0.0231665149,
0.0237717982,
0.0182669498,
0.0262725558,
-0.0144097684,
-0.0268969238,
0.0196300503,
0.0218617264,
0.0221947655,
-0.0082940208,
-0.0050951936,
0.0312826745,
-0.027329931,
0.0061329785,
0.0105739161,
-0.0395333767,
-0.0137013933,
-0.0433758423,
0.0303384941,
-0.0042942436,
-0.0322618335,
0.0337758362,
0.008709792,
0.0584719628,
0.0149172358,
-0.0232558697,
-0.0246228017,
0.0441931821,
-0.0456840768,
-0.0047422894,
-0.015497148,
0.0177542157,
0.0549678989,
-0.0363312811,
-0.022872461,
0.0203975793,
2.436e-7,
0.0086290315,
0.0322827287,
0.044341743,
0.0413291566,
0.0074907788,
0.0009418093,
0.0225596949,
0.0239983257,
-0.0199937597,
-0.0079714237,
0.0394681767,
0.0326123424,
-0.0143565554,
0.0313243456,
-0.0529932082,
0.0525603332,
-0.0414284654,
-0.0085577993,
-0.0611713044,
0.0136716543,
0.0801515654,
0.0849456787,
0.0496585071,
0.0240473207,
0.024006173,
0.0161226951,
0.0311422572,
-0.0182923079,
-0.0261669215,
0.0210861582,
-0.0420692563,
0.0145882918,
-0.0306438413,
-0.0547053777,
-0.0261247475,
0.0109017901,
0.0045923754,
0.0136641711,
-0.05272175,
-0.0189939234,
-0.0022280454,
-0.0411462747,
-0.0045542167,
-0.0154701667,
0.0505950078,
-0.0041974508,
-0.0152649581,
0.0107132643,
-0.0128255216,
0.0493338369,
0.0045902701,
0.0185357947,
-0.0501406044,
-0.0216591042,
0.0291266702,
0.0086811986,
-0.0016891708,
-0.0724732429,
0.022294296,
-0.0090694102,
-0.0308455322,
0.0105840443,
0.0077448259,
-0.0004213106,
0.0328259394,
0.0092092976,
-0.0228220485,
1.790990655e-34,
0.0296781417,
0.0678787008,
-0.0487895869,
-0.0538622029,
0.0363952443,
0.0010302971,
-0.0096459175,
0.0157847945,
0.013886732,
-0.0427523255,
-0.0652427301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13899v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13899v1 | Math Word Problem Solving by Generating Linguistic Variants of Problem Statements | 2023-06-24T08:27:39 | 2023-06-24T08:27:39 | Syed Rifat Raiyan, Md. Nafis Faiyaz, Shah Md. Jawad Kabir, Mohsinul Kabir, Hasan Mahmud, Md Kamrul Hasan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The art of mathematical reasoning stands as a fundamental pillar of
intellectual progress and is a central catalyst in cultivating human ingenuity.
Researchers have recently published a plethora of works centered around the
task of solving Math Word Problems (MWP) $-$ a crucial stride towards general
AI. These existing models are susceptible to dependency on shallow heuristics
and spurious correlations to derive the solution expressions. In order to
ameliorate this issue, in this paper, we propose a framework for MWP solvers
based on the generation of linguistic variants of the problem text. The
approach involves solving each of the variant problems and electing the
predicted expression with the majority of the votes. We use DeBERTa
(Decoding-enhanced BERT with disentangled attention) as the encoder to leverage
its rich textual representations and enhanced mask decoder to construct the
solution expressions. Furthermore, we introduce a challenging dataset,
$\mathrm{P\small{ARA}\normalsize{MAWPS}}$, consisting of paraphrased,
adversarial, and inverse variants of selectively sampled MWPs from the
benchmark $\mathrm{M\small{AWPS}}$ dataset. We extensively experiment on this
dataset along with other benchmark datasets using some baseline MWP solver
models. We show that training on linguistic variants of problem statements and
voting on candidate predictions improve the mathematical reasoning and
robustness of the model. We make our code and data publicly available. | [
0.0076435809,
0.1120345816,
-0.0016648488,
0.0389627814,
-0.0668173656,
0.0018169318,
0.000004576,
-0.0015068348,
-0.0398026519,
-0.0206204541,
0.0361714549,
0.0261184592,
-0.006336696,
0.0047919378,
0.037558198,
-0.0525240712,
0.0135378847,
-0.0206691995,
0.0108801788,
-0.0454889387,
-0.0159414355,
-0.0103446711,
-0.0337970443,
0.0192411877,
-0.0525889248,
-0.0380160213,
-0.0128501477,
-0.0574621446,
0.0125218378,
-0.0209193733,
0.0382072255,
0.04101713,
0.0299721062,
0.0504384898,
0.0000022781,
-0.0344183035,
-0.0174386613,
0.0032334342,
-0.0427525081,
-0.0423271693,
-0.0280927774,
-0.0076327277,
0.0359316245,
0.025249647,
-0.0650525838,
0.0350794867,
0.0178535152,
0.0224942993,
0.0866903737,
0.0412297249,
-0.0056622308,
-0.0324451216,
0.0002660976,
-0.0215083212,
0.0469762348,
-0.0757390782,
0.0009774691,
0.0185605772,
-0.0051135817,
-0.009074159,
-0.057005398,
0.0427455492,
0.0649286658,
0.0259584878,
0.0053519532,
-0.0157889742,
-0.0357148722,
-0.0009775676,
-0.0090361675,
0.0890335292,
-0.0235493649,
-0.0218483489,
-0.0253831707,
-0.0036419604,
-0.0131538687,
0.0499078557,
-0.0285986383,
0.0098608676,
-0.0126085822,
0.0012416644,
-0.0032200257,
0.0291012246,
-0.0066813934,
0.0188885201,
-0.0492819846,
0.0782023892,
0.0176165886,
-0.0443092212,
-0.0016583408,
0.0029548395,
-0.06639947,
-0.0555552691,
0.076676406,
0.03673134,
0.0166022964,
0.0300573856,
-0.0530067272,
-0.1202049404,
-0.0219116118,
-0.0293115992,
0.03498758,
0.0584896021,
0.0340526253,
0.0305590779,
-0.0295724329,
0.0629658774,
-0.0263762176,
0.0398301817,
-0.0371312797,
0.0071321791,
-0.0441583432,
-0.0189579781,
-0.0684467107,
0.0463381074,
-0.0053548208,
0.0003893017,
-0.0042200563,
-0.0150439814,
-0.0139043182,
0.0233048666,
-0.0101519087,
0.0305764452,
-0.0391983353,
-0.0446458161,
-0.0338895731,
0.0045620776,
-0.0766276419,
0.0110021336,
-0.0204134975,
-0.0201978907,
-0.041612871,
0.0062901396,
-0.0048856759,
-0.0513025112,
0.045371525,
0.0858042836,
-0.0173747614,
-0.0062223808,
0.0141032701,
-0.0089919167,
0.0009497633,
-0.0707842559,
0.0206600539,
-0.0860458016,
0.0838014781,
0.0258660782,
-0.0433288366,
-0.0573471449,
0.0183445998,
0.0336574167,
0.0260808747,
0.0647125021,
0.0210406464,
-0.0165924374,
0.0546908416,
-0.0169124566,
-0.0429159962,
0.060453698,
0.093836911,
0.0190496091,
0.0176022388,
0.0143620474,
0.0114973383,
0.0213600751,
0.0559854433,
0.0230964851,
-0.0188664794,
0.0220795535,
-0.0049892743,
0.0331534557,
-0.0123208575,
0.0648085922,
-0.0356957205,
-0.042768579,
0.0323742032,
0.0572780743,
-0.0263342839,
0.0371925645,
-0.0176311173,
-0.0054406985,
0.0293394141,
0.0156303924,
-0.0097669391,
0.0536444411,
-0.0131067038,
-0.0119089875,
0.0026589364,
-0.0045233727,
-0.0204728041,
-0.0642482787,
-0.0140556218,
0.0240698121,
0.0053490447,
0.0335231982,
0.0496055335,
0.0162127037,
-0.0133080473,
0.0456245877,
-0.0141450111,
-0.0319435857,
-0.0040610298,
-0.0378245935,
0.0131186945,
-0.0189449284,
0.0855164528,
-0.0395653471,
-0.0249490906,
-0.0242372137,
-0.0171596818,
0.0252263173,
0.0246653054,
0.0008455327,
-0.0147452634,
-0.0450958908,
-0.0106289098,
-0.053833589,
-0.0140796509,
-0.0050936304,
0.0518388599,
-0.0064481157,
0.0097233513,
-0.044550471,
-0.0031275018,
0.0373224616,
-0.0426534824,
-0.043948967,
0.0164847262,
0.0068005528,
0.0301231127,
-0.01314741,
0.0219985526,
0.0481025949,
-0.0124725932,
-0.0648297966,
-0.034844622,
-0.0030738811,
-0.0465731993,
-0.0522214472,
0.0675123185,
-0.114176847,
-0.0334846191,
0.0366494693,
-0.0406376123,
-0.0226817504,
0.0620290339,
-0.0991804749,
0.0109899566,
-0.0046754326,
-0.0050834105,
0.003906705,
-0.0025445358,
-0.0343169048,
0.0906245112,
-0.0040570633,
0.0263151247,
-0.017848637,
0.008011126,
0.0299804732,
-0.0050899638,
0.0014164605,
-0.0185643788,
0.0105880992,
-0.0117171081,
0.0209759437,
0.0096232835,
-0.0342799202,
-0.0463688634,
-0.0168203339,
0.0078333076,
-0.0027030706,
0.0473674536,
0.0309678111,
-0.039356675,
0.0155278239,
-0.0120032122,
-0.055599317,
-0.0353360064,
-0.0282113031,
-0.0253794789,
0.0595638603,
0.003638983,
0.0176464524,
-0.0468442775,
-0.032259427,
-0.0406724922,
0.0365107134,
0.0372154303,
0.0043116212,
-0.0104672806,
0.0238716863,
-0.0432571061,
0.0279296376,
-0.0067191888,
-0.0006846449,
0.0186668858,
-0.0049438551,
0.055484809,
0.0783462897,
0.0104847122,
0.0695727095,
0.0195154753,
-0.018604029,
-0.0770607367,
0.0308309179,
-0.0330665559,
0.0257001389,
0.0170998815,
-0.0450130068,
0.0040126061,
0.0606333241,
0.0176214874,
-0.0172126628,
-0.0558385327,
0.0627301857,
0.0125874104,
-0.0129130855,
-0.0383108072,
0.0141528659,
-0.0078721875,
0.0387013629,
-0.0139902802,
-0.0205980912,
0.1019856781,
0.0132888425,
-0.0101999296,
-0.1207052842,
0.0373226963,
-0.0618821047,
0.0304168314,
-0.0142325619,
-0.0078254854,
-0.0711832643,
-0.0008769673,
-0.0617774129,
-0.0068925661,
0.0440111458,
-0.0408213846,
0.0345988236,
-0.0286087021,
0.0199012011,
-0.0168576874,
-0.0640479401,
-0.0435539633,
-0.0159110259,
0.0029902579,
0.0114351511,
0.0278995913,
-0.0208467357,
-0.0541033186,
-0.0208917651,
0.043496266,
0.0138370683,
-0.019333696,
-0.0298971832,
-0.0338536575,
0.007533574,
0.0456099957,
0.0378485434,
0.0406248607,
-0.0618005656,
-0.0072326972,
0.006148736,
0.0753137693,
0.0225219317,
0.0017805113,
0.0237299651,
0.0135644712,
-0.0269897748,
0.0350392163,
-0.0027241264,
0.0111080511,
-0.0565220825,
-0.007548131,
0.0530449152,
0.0727920309,
0.017651733,
0.001263638,
-0.057272803,
0.0098349582,
0.0019169957,
0.0335551798,
-0.0874693766,
-0.0325606689,
0.0211718306,
0.0029349646,
0.0177037474,
-0.0435023904,
0.0041232128,
-0.1119939908,
-0.0029283792,
0.0144431349,
0.0300134085,
-0.0284853112,
-0.0131118027,
-0.0141970059,
-0.0027273106,
-0.0047812238,
-0.0159391742,
0.0266100876,
0.0493331961,
0.0067272177,
0.0136722652,
-0.0100697111,
0.0100345965,
-0.0025512455,
-0.032950148,
0.0575625561,
0.0121237254,
-0.037521068,
-0.08888565,
-0.0165268555,
0.0309175886,
-0.0634579211,
0.0221803449,
0.0288222469,
-0.0297157913,
-0.0239770822,
-0.0330032222,
0.0673505962,
-0.0358236246,
-0.0410244763,
0.0441373885,
0.0642722324,
-0.020992361,
0.010753707,
-0.0223774742,
0.0042860801,
-0.0284881853,
0.0633604005,
0.0353368074,
-0.0324112177,
-0.0490116812,
-0.0370432138,
0.0091767358,
-0.0810449198,
0.0148175387,
0.0215496216,
0.0473883078,
0.0122270016,
-0.0708450526,
-0.026785519,
0.083263576,
0.048239328,
0.0205863211,
-0.0575127415,
0.0362817794,
-0.0169257801,
-0.0439268537,
0.0235133003,
-0.0020662649,
0.0234793816,
-0.0311861243,
-0.0261602048,
-0.0152586475,
-0.005495734,
-0.0365382433,
0.0517338887,
-0.1024710238,
-0.0636693984,
0.012801717,
0.0405090787,
0.0172318853,
-0.0104405088,
-0.0190301873,
-0.0111765284,
0.0137079293,
0.0335059389,
-0.028713258,
0.011547287,
0.0225391313,
0.0205809548,
0.0245510284,
0.0097469194,
0.0011551275,
-0.0072212876,
0.0399600305,
0.0676073879,
-0.0340898819,
0.0225739907,
0.0383712985,
0.0403340012,
-0.0262518469,
-0.0022950452,
0.007041079,
-0.0021535528,
0.0388611555,
-0.0241362788,
-0.0054239598,
-0.0654941425,
0.0126273688,
-0.0060180998,
-0.0319706872,
0.0287008118,
0.0222776309,
0.0105734169,
0.0125109041,
0.0257329084,
0.0820677206,
-0.0149643384,
0.0191167928,
0.0335875936,
-0.0177717656,
0.0093107866,
0.0073373029,
-0.0252268929,
0.0320514664,
0.0063450434,
0.0428733714,
0.0430754125,
0.0012061159,
-0.0559801459,
-0.0161065441,
-0.0466233902,
-0.0757629499,
-0.0043790098,
0.0392429754,
0.0146202762,
0.0122122923,
-0.0424822457,
-0.0287361033,
-0.008724248,
0.0266624317,
-0.0003911444,
0.0031327957,
0.0042609926,
0.0240109544,
0.0412177816,
0.0287751704,
-0.0563001446,
0.0631679818,
-0.0350831002,
0.0365958661,
0.0133690415,
0.0275537707,
-0.0484588817,
-0.0433777161,
0.02553913,
0.0074552018,
0.021103153,
0.0274762698,
-0.0635637715,
-0.0509733818,
0.0209803954,
0.0015172169,
-0.0098281801,
0.0348117165,
0.0485623777,
0.0397394225,
-0.032957118,
-0.0184728317,
-0.0033957278,
0.0720538497,
-0.0105566094,
-0.0623568632,
-0.0389984474,
-6.073567354e-33,
-0.0194720365,
-0.0464188904,
0.0123116644,
-0.0302638412,
0.0386890322,
-0.0228698421,
-0.0351183414,
-0.0016718495,
-0.012279951,
0.0047414806,
-0.0291016623,
0.0181412455,
-0.0021195468,
0.0460770689,
-0.0119973011,
-0.0263955146,
0.0067009777,
-0.0217989255,
-0.0393719785,
-0.0547444597,
0.0252519343,
0.01269913,
0.0530580506,
-0.045152247,
-0.0111040678,
-0.0030699205,
0.0055322777,
0.009247547,
-0.0236170869,
0.0268682297,
-0.0158014353,
0.0173067208,
0.0004229264,
-0.011037766,
-0.0302253831,
0.0141154025,
-0.0329702571,
-0.0485430658,
0.0014646159,
0.0174776223,
-0.0799974948,
-0.0306718946,
0.0201157052,
0.0103445426,
-0.0153116249,
-0.0169291664,
0.0192124434,
-0.0212021563,
0.0043433709,
0.0146437297,
0.0047183181,
0.0066369879,
-0.0325510539,
-0.0172928181,
0.0225882493,
0.0148026841,
-0.0011820379,
-0.0023660918,
-0.0445923954,
-0.0026068531,
0.0295059662,
0.0050263773,
0.0161611475,
-0.0301237721,
0.0201430339,
0.0315322243,
0.0025128054,
-0.0406550951,
-0.0024246448,
-0.0056436514,
0.0339188576,
0.0503943861,
0.1153274924,
0.0116274366,
0.0688925013,
0.0188584775,
-0.0325321481,
-0.0183784366,
-0.006948424,
0.0376681052,
0.0219128039,
0.0095024398,
-0.041959092,
-0.0016377656,
-0.0526668653,
0.0059260153,
-0.0505679026,
-0.0021960486,
0.0207158867,
-0.0049823448,
-0.010973406,
-0.0051559089,
0.0195101276,
-0.0228272788,
0.0089459904,
0.0133574046,
0.0116288802,
0.0194040686,
0.0210357085,
0.0361550339,
-0.0206966382,
0.0166304857,
0.0146903796,
0.0386366658,
0.0374779813,
0.0090620648,
0.0094716828,
0.0100054173,
-0.0321146175,
-0.0131878201,
-0.0634794459,
0.0167938415,
0.0605058968,
0.0296451375,
0.010200127,
0.0333955325,
-0.0160276722,
-0.00980921,
-0.0277960412,
-0.0102965068,
-0.0140666971,
0.040531747,
-0.0036269105,
0.0419475697,
-0.0035035764,
-0.0094460128,
-0.0167422108,
0.0065099224,
0.0228696074,
-0.0527331866,
0.0086437594,
0.0117807658,
2.939e-7,
0.051032465,
0.0652222261,
0.0529871397,
0.0144871846,
0.0056212852,
0.0312941372,
-0.0140762478,
0.000103563,
-0.026191568,
-0.040860083,
0.0000857336,
0.0654324219,
0.0336350538,
0.0477246977,
-0.0466244072,
0.0137382168,
-0.0402562097,
-0.0110886572,
-0.0459702872,
0.0183263421,
0.0834651366,
0.0704741776,
0.0385873914,
0.0096719917,
-0.0129004978,
-0.0300529562,
0.0456434079,
0.0194331817,
0.0028051967,
0.0071188849,
-0.0058147269,
-0.0422748141,
0.0165302828,
0.0305330288,
-0.0196897294,
0.0343193859,
0.0421541445,
0.0625617728,
0.0202081073,
-0.0150644621,
-0.0506529137,
-0.0159930699,
-0.026949821,
-0.0329004265,
0.0537572019,
-0.0756581426,
-0.0548506528,
0.0167327803,
-0.002244001,
-0.003994388,
0.0355419368,
-0.012987406,
0.0232679322,
0.0052636368,
0.0318946876,
0.0006537899,
0.0065468294,
-0.0687391385,
-0.0054115239,
-0.0056147831,
-0.0588339306,
-0.0065154694,
-0.0521669053,
0.0011747201,
0.0633454919,
-0.0114178387,
-0.0168720819,
2.893612047e-34,
0.0372617878,
0.0030990245,
0.0055795321,
0.0423244946,
0.0398125425,
-0.0313055217,
-0.0098630507,
0.0236861091,
0.0236571245,
-0.064102456,
-0.0302007496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13891v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13891v2 | Estimating the Causal Effect of Early ArXiving on Paper Acceptance | 2023-06-24T07:45:38 | 2024-02-20T06:37:12 | Yanai Elazar, Jiayao Zhang, David Wadden, Bo Zhang, Noah A. Smith | cs.CL | cs.CL | What is the effect of releasing a preprint of a paper before it is submitted
for peer review? No randomized controlled trial has been conducted, so we turn
to observational data to answer this question. We use data from the ICLR
conference (2018--2022) and apply methods from causal inference to estimate the
effect of arXiving a paper before the reviewing period (early arXiving) on its
acceptance to the conference. Adjusting for confounders such as topic, authors,
and quality, we may estimate the causal effect. However, since quality is a
challenging construct to estimate, we use the negative outcome control method,
using paper citation count as a control variable to debias the quality
confounding effect. Our results suggest that early arXiving may have a small
effect on a paper's chances of acceptance. However, this effect (when existing)
does not differ significantly across different groups of authors, as grouped by
author citation count and institute rank. This suggests that early arXiving
does not provide an advantage to any particular group. | [
-0.005353149,
0.0508771054,
-0.0172966346,
-0.0657958239,
-0.0371318646,
-0.0225390606,
0.0830591917,
0.0328935832,
-0.0138996979,
0.0271477159,
-0.0122494502,
0.050107412,
-0.016028434,
0.0282155015,
0.021467654,
0.027892258,
0.0346162803,
0.0280170273,
0.0386779718,
-0.0332806483,
-0.0147805549,
-0.0559136532,
-0.0020698928,
0.0022504549,
0.0794252008,
0.0002104877,
0.0373658389,
0.0095480494,
-0.0334962569,
-0.0391436517,
-0.0164817218,
0.0424947143,
0.0258335192,
0.039420791,
0.000002149,
-0.0410713218,
-0.0327758826,
0.0425186791,
0.0107417479,
0.0557749383,
0.0068005547,
-0.005369049,
-0.0052349623,
0.0116699841,
-0.0431457646,
-0.0316919014,
-0.0288307369,
0.0383656621,
-0.0594679005,
-0.0065874276,
-0.004901771,
0.0499235243,
0.0322936773,
-0.0404917113,
-0.0218718927,
-0.04893554,
-0.0123658665,
-0.0240189172,
-0.0225906465,
0.0210639853,
-0.0014602267,
0.0518533029,
0.0062113423,
-0.02404912,
0.027975522,
0.0770601779,
0.0015612427,
-0.0305559449,
-0.0079045175,
-0.004409499,
0.0479374938,
-0.027130181,
0.0383040197,
-0.0182559136,
0.0190264806,
0.0541237816,
-0.052378878,
-0.0232168585,
0.0391643234,
-0.0085955244,
0.0399262421,
0.0341279469,
0.0139359897,
0.0411348864,
0.0537360124,
-0.0084664393,
0.0052311574,
-0.0896255299,
0.0051237186,
0.0437134653,
-0.0011773135,
-0.0416185111,
-0.0452817269,
-0.059004046,
0.0508929417,
-0.0203165226,
0.0902066976,
0.004662802,
0.01845254,
0.0123822223,
-0.0177704692,
0.0003005907,
0.0133976424,
0.0511577576,
-0.0222609621,
-0.0609643608,
-0.0429804102,
0.0366363823,
0.0556791313,
0.0816820338,
0.0301885214,
0.013676581,
0.0199636035,
-0.0117733181,
0.0381315984,
0.0005767505,
-0.0352001451,
-0.0160041824,
0.0040652645,
-0.0205827821,
0.0208805092,
0.03492558,
-0.0297023673,
-0.0010553848,
0.0019794242,
0.0322539173,
-0.0392662473,
0.0447336659,
-0.03699366,
0.0361373387,
-0.0133495862,
0.0106681874,
0.0683885291,
-0.0305005088,
0.0262008905,
0.0223723482,
0.005480587,
-0.027409263,
0.0509342551,
-0.0210864488,
0.0320254788,
-0.0114039285,
0.0168930702,
-0.0277971756,
-0.0048721777,
0.0167357661,
0.0361684225,
-0.031972941,
-0.0675077438,
-0.0648330823,
-0.004140866,
-0.0603022799,
-0.0378894284,
0.0131564913,
-0.0153662013,
0.0050038956,
-0.0124539994,
-0.0414671414,
0.0002379414,
0.0223951172,
0.0029724527,
-0.0388545357,
0.0118190693,
0.0189506393,
0.0656242669,
0.051522173,
0.0773092508,
0.013703485,
-0.0429161713,
-0.0392631888,
-0.0414334945,
-0.0135406796,
-0.0583684221,
0.0616991967,
0.0427751243,
-0.021920396,
-0.020761624,
-0.0201938264,
-0.0623345152,
-0.0349015035,
-0.0562162474,
-0.0579940751,
-0.0125441998,
0.0414942168,
-0.0150790652,
0.0113566509,
0.0868635029,
-0.0468091294,
-0.0297675095,
-0.0414037071,
0.0324576423,
0.0190900322,
0.0202937648,
0.0207421724,
0.0448482335,
0.0120676234,
-0.0189899821,
-0.0550380722,
0.0141453994,
0.0406220593,
-0.0065891151,
-0.0298361685,
0.0447208285,
-0.0700931549,
0.0535370559,
0.0000104947,
0.0677085593,
-0.0389409065,
0.0225209519,
0.030094929,
-0.0060616001,
0.0439163893,
-0.0510771275,
0.0285879206,
-0.0060135536,
0.0280174781,
-0.0019016862,
0.0006096881,
0.046334926,
0.0431019403,
-0.0569442734,
0.0064607128,
-0.0647386312,
0.0126146032,
-0.0286535509,
-0.0425898843,
-0.0474408939,
-0.0030149762,
0.0663748085,
-0.0197690055,
-0.0492738821,
0.0090341559,
0.0306022931,
0.0129052754,
-0.0263669901,
0.0511955805,
0.0770874992,
0.0456136912,
-0.0295672342,
-0.0761923566,
0.0053901463,
-0.0343486294,
-0.0117002623,
0.0229776688,
0.1342769861,
0.0883079991,
0.0324072875,
0.046008382,
-0.032438565,
-0.047567606,
-0.0271056034,
0.0123049291,
-0.0050609969,
-0.0009015145,
0.0380367152,
0.0125801638,
-0.0758018792,
0.0127137797,
0.0123938136,
-0.0313943774,
-0.0493480004,
-0.048876062,
-0.0079619465,
0.0816786662,
-0.0332189836,
0.0028503381,
-0.0314899608,
-0.0123967659,
0.0034226133,
0.0027749317,
-0.0254978277,
0.0288374946,
-0.03679391,
-0.0038791206,
0.0166627839,
0.0428014025,
-0.0768769607,
0.0385364294,
0.0338746645,
-0.0048800437,
0.0133162681,
0.0006151497,
-0.0505395122,
-0.0432176478,
-0.00159862,
-0.0042240131,
0.0835527182,
-0.002161368,
0.0302056056,
0.0370174497,
-0.0173519794,
-0.0203239769,
-0.0200498626,
0.0003958139,
-0.0226042848,
0.0009023438,
-0.0576927662,
0.0265642591,
-0.0257105455,
0.011925824,
0.0287046749,
0.0132442238,
-0.0417033471,
-0.0166727453,
-0.0641086474,
-0.0048649297,
-0.0183643233,
-0.017672576,
0.0334589072,
0.0083357776,
0.0105310827,
0.0082204035,
-0.0386785381,
-0.0063057225,
-0.0443659574,
-0.0235487856,
0.0204271153,
0.0048743589,
-0.0058445875,
0.0769179612,
-0.0073028062,
-0.0657790527,
-0.0105906352,
-0.0140802506,
0.0199383646,
-0.0390985049,
0.0165560432,
-0.0258565005,
-0.0183371417,
0.0086379554,
-0.0081940731,
-0.0000363342,
0.0625967905,
-0.0281018466,
-0.008922331,
0.0260040332,
0.0187350251,
-0.0432871729,
0.0136424368,
0.0191614535,
-0.0173610374,
-0.0007076198,
0.0328130722,
-0.0764917135,
0.0312455855,
-0.0193744525,
0.0417390727,
-0.0114381807,
-0.0071765133,
-0.0044709682,
0.026071528,
0.0122217517,
-0.0312332846,
-0.0163236856,
0.0044065188,
-0.0327613614,
0.0002824712,
-0.0399934836,
0.0458993502,
-0.0443898998,
-0.0169311576,
-0.0097992467,
0.0519547276,
-0.0013849656,
-0.0166786239,
-0.0144991474,
0.0031576531,
-0.0242112614,
-0.0116571737,
0.0091627827,
0.0338115208,
0.0189652201,
0.0576604493,
0.0259919893,
0.0068245512,
-0.0296653435,
-0.0164558478,
0.0193590391,
0.0571704209,
-0.0124675268,
-0.0279234778,
-0.0500985794,
0.0471428223,
-0.0030115235,
-0.0071690604,
-0.0558364131,
-0.0012293651,
-0.0011330334,
0.0111941285,
0.0400410518,
-0.0084502371,
-0.000017181,
0.0368438698,
-0.0182500426,
0.0246841013,
-0.0063018179,
-0.0396452062,
0.0097354166,
0.0225198269,
0.002073199,
-0.008972697,
-0.0692141876,
-0.04954236,
0.0207118411,
-0.0204103533,
0.0377502777,
-0.0004825788,
0.0105930129,
-0.0395871811,
0.0091602253,
-0.0006149327,
0.0154130533,
-0.0480034687,
-0.022046065,
0.0706754923,
0.0181378648,
0.0351057351,
-0.0284939855,
0.0039554858,
-0.0023594247,
-0.0013441092,
-0.0225814581,
0.0047805621,
0.0271865483,
-0.094237715,
0.0109936129,
-0.0151369888,
-0.0335826762,
0.0114013264,
-0.0259642676,
-0.0191731006,
-0.0073205219,
0.0074626259,
0.0202528611,
0.0094891051,
-0.0204772018,
-0.0986833647,
0.0243673641,
-0.0424286462,
-0.0335674956,
-0.0090162912,
-0.0518596955,
0.0195171367,
0.0239966828,
0.0164117962,
0.0418935753,
-0.0189432539,
-0.0014833905,
0.0517410748,
0.0027733196,
-0.02202335,
-0.0560934171,
0.0156004559,
-0.0293068159,
0.0223149825,
-0.0666461959,
0.01557812,
-0.0008828565,
-0.0034680034,
-0.0031848515,
0.0303562079,
0.0306998808,
-0.007692772,
-0.0152056376,
-0.0029214558,
0.0148634557,
-0.0216863099,
0.0327699706,
-0.0093426397,
0.034641318,
-0.0938321352,
-0.0192498565,
-0.0438984036,
-0.0202038791,
-0.0065715797,
0.0361597873,
-0.0404767133,
-0.0061438121,
-0.0330004655,
-0.0104444074,
0.0057090144,
0.0570641607,
-0.0564270243,
0.0173315201,
-0.0031239197,
-0.0054792184,
0.0402000882,
0.0334486701,
0.0036581014,
-0.0588340014,
0.0210121684,
0.0169570018,
-0.0297774374,
0.1029138565,
-0.0149363168,
0.004804207,
-0.0368152149,
0.0781002194,
-0.0230692849,
0.0427666306,
0.0283578988,
0.0438009687,
-0.0024345296,
-0.0042224787,
-0.0516416654,
0.0537538901,
-0.0138366185,
0.0000391322,
-0.0457882397,
-0.017814314,
0.026392037,
0.0096164318,
-0.1025439873,
-0.0301345102,
0.0103694331,
0.0181851108,
0.0158674177,
0.0183605719,
0.0902853459,
-0.0150926923,
0.0142126307,
-0.0411452316,
0.0417977162,
0.0370286666,
-0.0031042316,
0.0140926708,
-0.0370774232,
-0.0557162948,
-0.0157051589,
0.0346428081,
0.0436138213,
-0.0406452492,
-0.0534686111,
0.0538056456,
0.0219830498,
-0.0555329993,
-0.034444131,
0.0107428692,
0.0049038352,
0.0355867408,
-0.0387000851,
-0.0154249063,
-0.0158428885,
-0.027023105,
0.0037438311,
-0.0078863008,
-0.0529006906,
-0.020844439,
-0.0207201224,
-0.0288041253,
0.0226445235,
-0.0064805876,
-0.0096639274,
-0.0596888959,
-0.0255353283,
-6.928456274e-33,
0.0230769031,
0.0194300022,
-0.0150719779,
0.0021732729,
0.0169154443,
-0.0018975181,
-0.0355998501,
0.0048796148,
-0.0132343005,
-0.0256275721,
-0.0791098475,
-0.0051235626,
0.0171852391,
0.0086826915,
0.0523001328,
0.0068159737,
0.0107759396,
-0.0195262842,
0.0003688933,
0.0278666243,
-0.0705306605,
-0.0096502481,
-0.0100982022,
-0.0173822567,
0.0503958352,
0.0080662714,
0.022899745,
-0.0494762659,
0.0387170054,
0.0075739301,
-0.0065184804,
-0.0592315421,
0.0118278833,
-0.0983444303,
0.0091558946,
-0.0002768532,
-0.0495099761,
0.0210371148,
0.035261523,
-0.0146829383,
0.028655408,
-0.0056205895,
-0.0093613937,
0.0261327568,
-0.0447652824,
-0.0204407237,
0.0220627841,
0.0433241427,
-0.0140727134,
-0.0162859038,
-0.0171293803,
0.0174044911,
-0.0282839723,
0.0434960388,
0.015004389,
0.0399216712,
0.0172589123,
0.0543931797,
-0.0706624538,
0.0241536144,
-0.0585269518,
0.0032207665,
-0.0057021985,
-0.0318879224,
0.0240847692,
0.0089652138,
-0.0639719516,
0.0612124652,
0.0327775627,
-0.0087578334,
0.0514093563,
-0.0016606349,
0.0262996722,
0.0650148392,
0.086217016,
-0.0419587269,
-0.0500560962,
-0.0152073605,
0.0072597284,
0.0189997125,
0.0890145898,
-0.0243739374,
-0.0157300103,
-0.0349196792,
-0.0070170518,
-0.0243267156,
0.0293270536,
-0.0201543495,
0.0055480436,
0.0520983264,
-0.0047515314,
-0.0174848083,
0.0896650776,
-0.0228007622,
-0.1166659668,
0.0454033129,
0.0099793728,
0.0605557151,
0.0059201494,
-0.0133391684,
-0.0866550431,
0.0115684923,
0.0014920424,
0.0750680193,
0.0604790561,
-0.0247548651,
0.0361794718,
0.0254104789,
-0.0555411987,
0.0297219697,
-0.0251649674,
0.0140963132,
0.0574108809,
-0.0295702834,
0.0047034365,
0.0680441409,
0.0130211143,
-0.036003802,
0.0278985314,
0.0606941916,
-0.00523797,
0.0237420965,
-0.0345078707,
0.042857673,
0.0038420863,
-0.0155541627,
-0.0141458614,
0.0798379853,
-0.0027797737,
-0.0584348738,
0.0094666407,
-0.0771668479,
3.01e-7,
0.0145162893,
0.0089725778,
-0.0396068618,
0.0481402613,
0.0356478766,
-0.0105093895,
-0.0485930257,
0.0416757949,
0.0605200343,
0.0591221154,
0.0194406398,
0.0134976702,
-0.0106874835,
0.0157722868,
-0.0354104452,
-0.0823139325,
-0.1024492756,
0.0121872639,
0.0122163445,
-0.0243211389,
-0.0348568298,
-0.0150389597,
-0.0032345045,
0.0440885313,
-0.0326320007,
-0.0088745039,
0.0374756306,
-0.0271920282,
0.015404406,
0.0133694205,
-0.0055176117,
0.0177108198,
-0.0184145812,
-0.0028919347,
-0.036493063,
-0.0081909848,
-0.0372407362,
-0.0293258708,
0.035924729,
0.0436838828,
0.0226180796,
-0.0316745713,
0.0140317455,
-0.0110286716,
0.0515934937,
-0.0127185406,
-0.0226118099,
-0.0083724381,
-0.0497243255,
0.0002249365,
0.0669861585,
0.0323941037,
-0.0013509222,
0.0021477833,
-0.0134289386,
0.0026001849,
0.0262643937,
-0.0548250228,
-0.0258185714,
0.0471946374,
0.027261097,
-0.0796984583,
-0.0080395769,
-0.0313760675,
-0.0167186745,
-0.0002961591,
0.0148488516,
2.709161601e-34,
0.0778043494,
-0.0132603394,
0.0155588724,
0.0161661524,
0.0348730758,
-0.0357221365,
0.0231876783,
-0.0302549489,
0.0194556136,
-0.0038773355,
0.0252507459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13888v1 | L3Cube-MahaSent-MD: A Multi-domain Marathi Sentiment Analysis Dataset and Transformer Models | 2023-06-24T07:27:53 | 2023-06-24T07:27:53 | Aabha Pingle, Aditya Vyawahare, Isha Joshi, Rahul Tangsali, Raviraj Joshi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The exploration of sentiment analysis in low-resource languages, such as
Marathi, has been limited due to the availability of suitable datasets. In this
work, we present L3Cube-MahaSent-MD, a multi-domain Marathi sentiment analysis
dataset, with four different domains - movie reviews, general tweets, TV show
subtitles, and political tweets. The dataset consists of around 60,000 manually
tagged samples covering 3 distinct sentiments - positive, negative, and
neutral. We create a sub-dataset for each domain comprising 15k samples. The
MahaSent-MD is the first comprehensive multi-domain sentiment analysis dataset
within the Indic sentiment landscape. We fine-tune different monolingual and
multilingual BERT models on these datasets and report the best accuracy with
the MahaBERT model. We also present an extensive in-domain and cross-domain
analysis thus highlighting the need for low-resource multi-domain datasets. The
data and models are available at https://github.com/l3cube-pune/MarathiNLP . | [
0.0476554483,
0.0268222652,
0.0003094062,
0.0621424317,
-0.0381462425,
0.0118120871,
-0.0405710116,
0.0213431306,
-0.0115422029,
-0.0290606413,
-0.0516901985,
-0.0333820358,
-0.0234331712,
0.0366510786,
-0.0386477299,
-0.0449096411,
-0.001924468,
0.0430266224,
0.0383296646,
-0.0197193082,
0.0410294756,
0.0276534725,
-0.0102946358,
0.0205451287,
-0.0605600737,
-0.0050817141,
0.0367771909,
0.0278891176,
0.0202688929,
-0.0310673211,
0.0445948206,
0.0326528102,
0.0160444584,
-0.0156163881,
0.000002018,
-0.0173660424,
-0.035768833,
-0.0282501578,
0.0693003312,
-0.0409409776,
0.0791251138,
-0.0394562073,
0.0112450514,
0.0343096927,
-0.0475292616,
0.014409502,
0.0526349321,
0.0354843996,
0.0664241612,
0.0981096402,
-0.0455023386,
-0.0404008701,
-0.0337702036,
0.0016246097,
-0.0417101607,
0.002303371,
0.0065569184,
-0.0132788075,
-0.0278588291,
-0.0141395926,
-0.0190834925,
-0.0226514358,
-0.0251022726,
-0.0154675376,
0.0075011915,
-0.0306246504,
-0.0199583042,
-0.0173977166,
0.0423542708,
0.0276855435,
0.004568263,
-0.0188982766,
-0.0042086602,
0.0099957138,
-0.037852481,
0.0068114162,
-0.0083400477,
-0.0017800767,
-0.0186143033,
0.0745089576,
0.0136483852,
0.0395383425,
0.0034957256,
0.0114338789,
0.0413434729,
0.0276436061,
-0.0028256027,
-0.0227185879,
-0.0140362987,
0.0401101559,
-0.0322286263,
0.0081039649,
0.0219287276,
-0.0335635468,
0.008405027,
0.0293934774,
-0.0192824882,
-0.0464459211,
0.0158569012,
-0.0624097995,
-0.0139267333,
0.0180074908,
-0.0222619697,
-0.0015485267,
0.0074065863,
-0.0076034586,
-0.0082918983,
-0.002518974,
0.0049009509,
-0.0599661246,
-0.0164335929,
-0.0183208287,
0.0345350988,
0.0366942249,
-0.0318713076,
0.0653265789,
-0.0845016763,
-0.0028237116,
-0.0343222953,
-0.0264389105,
0.0489105657,
-0.0218520537,
0.0079014944,
-0.0292134918,
-0.0217693578,
0.074878104,
-0.0849507824,
0.0437329076,
-0.0337075479,
-0.0373075455,
0.0179429762,
0.0214313772,
0.0021513738,
-0.0268046595,
-0.0167512707,
0.068047151,
0.0361285731,
-0.0432648063,
-0.055505462,
0.0078081,
-0.0331711322,
-0.0608138852,
-0.0004724799,
-0.0625763014,
0.0433858037,
0.0382190533,
0.0090256603,
-0.0206476152,
0.0000609481,
0.0003559166,
-0.0142210992,
0.0517917462,
-0.0054832865,
-0.0081193764,
0.0089785671,
0.01834324,
0.0163593777,
0.0452283733,
-0.0010908009,
0.0242061839,
0.0466871038,
-0.0017989629,
0.0159185845,
0.0230717286,
0.0037215913,
-0.0003477988,
-0.0367018692,
0.0302118808,
-0.0653041229,
-0.0279430356,
-0.0044999439,
0.0072512729,
0.0182305332,
0.007688914,
0.0206025094,
0.022478899,
-0.0068031978,
0.0352668092,
-0.0384502374,
0.005888945,
0.0126899891,
-0.0003418828,
0.0126169901,
0.0351965725,
-0.006839795,
-0.031679064,
0.0310823321,
0.0153735578,
-0.0213291571,
-0.0172382556,
-0.0246281698,
-0.0556834452,
-0.0006586828,
-0.05144573,
0.0653594658,
-0.0116801867,
-0.0746334046,
-0.0132113853,
0.0619433187,
-0.1006155461,
0.0020672239,
-0.0355961919,
0.0540546924,
0.0516071916,
-0.0040796651,
-0.0194723047,
-0.0092928885,
-0.0247541834,
0.0023992467,
0.01937069,
0.0147403767,
-0.001600908,
-0.0402298681,
-0.0446660966,
0.0190902017,
0.0324624851,
0.0227410067,
0.0256230496,
-0.028025249,
0.0661136657,
-0.0352364108,
-0.0095374249,
0.0295077916,
-0.0150347957,
0.0227877833,
0.0192272142,
0.0137754101,
0.0130600203,
0.056560386,
0.0395774953,
-0.0331703462,
-0.0490039736,
0.0352936648,
-0.0017094526,
-0.0482275896,
0.0278052296,
0.0199053362,
-0.0544643924,
-0.0332907252,
-0.0659988746,
0.0165908486,
0.0588897988,
-0.0102990232,
-0.0299709626,
0.0372298323,
0.0176535137,
0.0273458604,
-0.0097594541,
0.0186316278,
-0.0268208645,
0.0000695271,
0.0072997306,
0.0345513821,
-0.0025666931,
-0.0004790546,
-0.0284429695,
-0.0061873873,
0.0488231815,
0.0150619615,
-0.0260346439,
-0.0004265659,
0.0336538292,
0.0291765314,
0.0437526703,
-0.0069969348,
-0.015848564,
-0.0557855517,
-0.0859222412,
-0.02116476,
0.0031894757,
0.0261889286,
0.0024749762,
0.0553729385,
-0.0032551966,
0.0207386408,
-0.0010937713,
-0.0075108823,
0.0315405913,
0.0143247033,
0.0470452309,
-0.017726725,
0.0562172942,
-0.0455753133,
-0.0154840108,
-0.03657493,
0.0228089131,
-0.017942572,
-0.0523258448,
0.0171533599,
0.0053739343,
-0.0103378203,
0.0038025663,
-0.0174087007,
-0.0803283527,
-0.0403043404,
-0.014370149,
0.0329460427,
-0.0183060393,
0.0042317878,
0.0070984014,
-0.0384589881,
-0.0059922533,
-0.0296748299,
0.0163600165,
-0.0214673076,
0.0160526019,
0.0037625837,
-0.0082398783,
0.0092048999,
0.0581996962,
0.0108365109,
-0.0164999124,
-0.0500829816,
-0.0358564556,
-0.0370266959,
0.01257955,
0.0374282636,
0.0169938896,
-0.0139335245,
0.0281325951,
0.0289264061,
-0.0258690566,
0.0556304045,
0.0066755181,
0.0156506114,
-0.0996577442,
0.0235040039,
-0.0329481661,
0.0267196931,
-0.045214586,
-0.0039922926,
-0.002384854,
0.0163955856,
-0.0169701222,
-0.0419234298,
-0.024224367,
-0.023752857,
0.0477345437,
0.0023160011,
0.021913005,
-0.0050268825,
-0.0425305255,
0.0211001914,
-0.0526094139,
-0.0324242972,
-0.042379383,
0.0411384441,
-0.052937109,
0.0144625343,
0.0167300571,
-0.0517622754,
-0.0641884357,
0.0010597158,
-0.0117886802,
0.0557106659,
0.0426502824,
0.0581459738,
-0.0354731642,
-0.0024762817,
0.017187763,
-0.0037390476,
0.0041521061,
-0.0097600436,
0.0070445803,
-0.0089070387,
-0.0264432505,
0.0082931425,
0.0135985352,
0.0070306631,
-0.0853366479,
0.0460960753,
0.0219840109,
0.0337728634,
0.0983970538,
0.0264235605,
-0.0328099206,
-0.0223723091,
-0.020359816,
-0.0138722081,
0.0059318752,
0.0133632878,
-0.0671580583,
-0.0545853339,
-0.0112555809,
-0.010336536,
0.0115183936,
-0.0144515987,
0.0142062465,
-0.1129949465,
-0.0063464036,
-0.0271712076,
0.0410710014,
-0.050782077,
-0.018714916,
-0.0401658192,
-0.0221732855,
-0.0310897604,
-0.0566708595,
-0.012901607,
0.0057550333,
0.0331676118,
-0.0115975896,
-0.0383066833,
0.0508904606,
-0.0166108124,
0.0079151746,
0.0480658337,
0.0556081422,
-0.0466646403,
-0.0454611219,
-0.0065670721,
-0.0226089209,
-0.0361803807,
-0.023565378,
0.0708277002,
-0.0311764665,
-0.0370945148,
-0.019713724,
-0.0016227699,
-0.0568952821,
0.0162011385,
-0.0103336275,
0.0389614105,
0.0127102388,
-0.0385508835,
-0.0436036699,
0.0172050521,
0.0157621745,
0.0289865248,
-0.0178044718,
-0.0677267313,
0.0063131247,
-0.0001788748,
-0.0078127943,
-0.0548745543,
-0.0056983926,
-0.018249575,
-0.0405740477,
-0.0414190553,
-0.0383586064,
-0.0438021868,
0.0287256148,
0.0309571009,
0.0025668913,
0.0008478364,
0.0064987713,
0.0166850016,
-0.032988511,
0.0081238896,
0.0092027737,
0.0323171131,
-0.0371435992,
-0.0312324129,
0.1096692905,
0.0249598678,
-0.0086078113,
-0.0597127602,
-0.0023976227,
-0.0158564355,
-0.0203128885,
0.0406677201,
0.0174459759,
-0.0129065681,
-0.0278883297,
-0.0286957882,
0.0555284508,
0.0388534106,
-0.052419778,
-0.01186819,
0.0512203462,
0.0527338199,
-0.012516059,
0.042658098,
-0.0326927118,
0.0377933681,
-0.0347682685,
-0.0248473641,
0.0120973978,
0.0138011305,
-0.0014352797,
-0.014850867,
0.0700256228,
-0.0163458642,
-0.0162251275,
-0.0274536107,
-0.0090844333,
0.0146061024,
-0.0222889986,
-0.029291397,
-0.0267566983,
0.0448202007,
0.0097645717,
-0.077794753,
-0.0007687796,
-0.0246859379,
-0.0071208626,
-0.0050306506,
0.1049074382,
0.0735833049,
0.0759364218,
0.0013509007,
0.0084767966,
0.0043760766,
-0.043604847,
0.0090145916,
-0.0327831097,
-0.0124120107,
0.0467187092,
0.0003158316,
0.0263972022,
0.0643251911,
0.0416653864,
0.0639123619,
0.0715993717,
-0.0305934139,
0.0082484586,
0.0055498397,
-0.0054448731,
0.0656675622,
-0.0160721857,
0.0187857561,
-0.0188790858,
0.0215619709,
-0.0474464446,
0.0313814804,
0.0835506469,
-0.0154398065,
-0.0367858894,
-0.0218692515,
0.0504420176,
-0.0543309636,
0.0302978028,
0.0505425557,
-0.0015122328,
-0.0464642085,
-0.0004447387,
0.0503577702,
-0.020920001,
0.0492627546,
0.0236689653,
-0.0645946264,
-0.0272125807,
0.0595307648,
-0.0779132396,
0.0517990477,
-0.0004122355,
0.0077785463,
0.0366428457,
0.0276942607,
0.0612517819,
-0.062338423,
0.0085275164,
-0.0433977246,
-0.0339483805,
0.0134447124,
-6.147500806e-33,
-0.0091859009,
0.0076737595,
-0.0640034974,
0.0095908158,
-0.0006477644,
-0.0195307229,
0.016021885,
0.0147905871,
-0.0051824762,
0.0508947261,
-0.0127025368,
0.0431944318,
0.0059929737,
0.0256930608,
0.0684870183,
-0.0418950543,
0.0356210023,
0.016690379,
-0.0055555571,
0.0253883116,
0.0514236726,
0.0416707359,
0.0721915066,
-0.0744173825,
0.0297751371,
-0.0481964983,
-0.0626647994,
-0.0118761864,
0.0283093695,
0.0434385091,
-0.0311783683,
0.0484991595,
0.0412026048,
-0.004826847,
0.0117370086,
0.0418362953,
-0.0381633081,
0.0065864315,
0.0185608529,
0.0534172207,
-0.0067495499,
-0.0264542066,
-0.0015462191,
0.0218017697,
-0.040647693,
0.0277815405,
0.0256357733,
0.0039826627,
0.0350129232,
-0.0666279122,
-0.0457927734,
0.0469659194,
0.002272354,
-0.0291954745,
0.0191334952,
0.0679355785,
0.0399145111,
0.0470488966,
-0.0543909222,
0.0178718772,
-0.0285724476,
0.0179953612,
0.0000141127,
-0.0273328982,
-0.023741398,
0.0497362316,
-0.0007032489,
-0.0364311747,
0.0408996344,
0.0515745506,
-0.0104774227,
0.0263177082,
-0.0087070344,
0.08195737,
0.0132606123,
-0.0768493563,
-0.0314896554,
0.0410384424,
0.0170699488,
0.0114880381,
0.044244308,
-0.003020575,
-0.0288550016,
-0.0194444302,
0.0860930681,
-0.0349630415,
-0.0211975947,
-0.0293816272,
0.0063117407,
-0.0430748239,
-0.0136045162,
0.0319502838,
0.0177712161,
-0.0656021014,
-0.0127830356,
0.0338296853,
-0.0674435347,
0.0361391753,
0.0049362537,
0.010762074,
-0.0059966613,
-0.0432998911,
-0.0449752323,
0.0664572492,
0.003645709,
0.0004839915,
0.0558994673,
0.0253694449,
-0.1073040515,
-0.0252701752,
-0.0059152674,
0.0424397066,
-0.0021467418,
0.1036990657,
-0.0366529189,
0.0057902085,
-0.0162644833,
0.0295994263,
0.0148588093,
0.0359129757,
0.0066003869,
0.0228903778,
0.0119859716,
-0.004806241,
-0.0185669027,
-0.0358895548,
-0.0251944698,
-0.0336479284,
-0.0156458803,
-0.0552456528,
-0.0086503783,
-0.0253524613,
2.802e-7,
0.0030798984,
0.0796246976,
0.0082403338,
-0.0516598001,
-0.012574655,
0.0707496107,
-0.0425476432,
0.0261111651,
-0.0245955177,
0.0291098561,
-0.0029755123,
-0.0399527103,
0.0149728991,
0.0315390304,
-0.1252249926,
0.0314980708,
-0.0419611819,
-0.0153206168,
-0.0163526312,
0.0344478004,
0.0264800545,
0.0986505002,
0.0616361946,
-0.0059434944,
-0.0376208425,
0.0113211665,
0.0667437389,
-0.0285784677,
-0.016506277,
0.0382741876,
-0.0372712612,
-0.009916937,
-0.0328652486,
-0.036396116,
-0.0073860958,
0.0153038269,
0.0282817204,
0.0692156032,
0.0158601571,
-0.0225944743,
0.0241530407,
0.0167610478,
0.0101442039,
0.0113690551,
0.0305189751,
0.0009456362,
-0.0677212477,
-0.026572492,
0.0010822034,
0.0183578525,
0.0483222939,
-0.0209530741,
-0.0248439107,
-0.0130669028,
-0.0043503144,
-0.0513292737,
-0.0552634336,
-0.0411749482,
0.0195096619,
0.0100974888,
-0.0075482763,
-0.045653794,
0.0156513453,
0.0397580117,
0.0527649634,
-0.0393391363,
0.0311385654,
2.024123901e-34,
0.0843292624,
-0.0289673731,
-0.0075710239,
0.0016780414,
0.0126562966,
-0.0335014649,
-0.0344275534,
-0.0219635107,
0.0300878566,
-0.025393337,
0.0111730667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13865v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13865v1 | IERL: Interpretable Ensemble Representation Learning -- Combining CrowdSourced Knowledge and Distributed Semantic Representations | 2023-06-24T05:02:34 | 2023-06-24T05:02:34 | Yuxin Zi, Kaushik Roy, Vignesh Narayanan, Manas Gaur, Amit Sheth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) encode meanings of words in the form of
distributed semantics. Distributed semantics capture common statistical
patterns among language tokens (words, phrases, and sentences) from large
amounts of data. LLMs perform exceedingly well across General Language
Understanding Evaluation (GLUE) tasks designed to test a model's understanding
of the meanings of the input tokens. However, recent studies have shown that
LLMs tend to generate unintended, inconsistent, or wrong texts as outputs when
processing inputs that were seen rarely during training, or inputs that are
associated with diverse contexts (e.g., well-known hallucination phenomenon in
language generation tasks). Crowdsourced and expert-curated knowledge graphs
such as ConceptNet are designed to capture the meaning of words from a compact
set of well-defined contexts. Thus LLMs may benefit from leveraging such
knowledge contexts to reduce inconsistencies in outputs. We propose a novel
ensemble learning method, Interpretable Ensemble Representation Learning
(IERL), that systematically combines LLM and crowdsourced knowledge
representations of input tokens. IERL has the distinct advantage of being
interpretable by design (when was the LLM context used vs. when was the
knowledge context used?) over state-of-the-art (SOTA) methods, allowing
scrutiny of the inputs in conjunction with the parameters of the model,
facilitating the analysis of models' inconsistent or irrelevant outputs.
Although IERL is agnostic to the choice of LLM and crowdsourced knowledge, we
demonstrate our approach using BERT and ConceptNet. We report improved or
competitive results with IERL across GLUE tasks over current SOTA methods and
significantly enhanced model interpretability. | [
0.0305793677,
0.048069749,
-0.0032669208,
0.0820024759,
-0.0182301514,
0.0134358564,
-0.0053920583,
-0.0249176286,
-0.0319480449,
-0.0407395475,
-0.0591374747,
-0.0316377468,
0.0202379376,
0.0089937123,
0.0230529662,
-0.0013505685,
0.0349690169,
-0.0065294765,
-0.0194685664,
-0.0066291653,
-0.0093306508,
0.0430848487,
-0.0046795052,
0.0816308111,
-0.003434913,
-0.0046106288,
-4.359e-7,
0.0153130908,
0.0123990634,
-0.0018314674,
-0.017310692,
0.0807352737,
0.062053971,
0.0761275515,
0.0000020049,
-0.0512904748,
-0.0398825891,
0.0040371348,
-0.0624664426,
0.0146593396,
-0.0140355742,
0.0299837776,
0.0346961915,
-0.0066612712,
-0.0221112724,
0.0031845998,
0.0393560566,
0.0342919938,
0.0304843727,
0.0308884941,
0.0231197625,
0.0085557522,
-0.0074083824,
-0.0092911795,
0.0246478934,
-0.0138686271,
0.0267400462,
0.0090800794,
-0.0276593417,
-0.0263352543,
-0.0174265429,
0.0159635898,
0.0175767802,
0.0120423902,
0.0505479053,
0.0275841691,
-0.1005465686,
-0.0394484289,
0.0040824711,
0.1019012332,
0.0016056088,
-0.0360919461,
-0.0134025579,
-0.0017084784,
-0.0047520865,
0.0493279733,
-0.0061312956,
0.0065063443,
-0.007950671,
0.0497190394,
-0.0135500291,
0.0160689037,
0.0612726584,
0.0369344465,
-0.0482927896,
0.1026166975,
-0.0071389852,
0.0187175237,
-0.0286373775,
0.0226567946,
-0.0902493075,
-0.0010337366,
0.0283182282,
-0.0303175077,
-0.0519102216,
0.0389339551,
-0.0124041447,
-0.0794442371,
0.0242361389,
-0.0086642737,
0.0484769344,
0.0083392132,
-0.014912935,
0.0606722273,
-0.0578817278,
0.0252006147,
0.0092654116,
0.0354930684,
-0.0368688963,
-0.0136927646,
-0.0807624012,
-0.0268200263,
-0.0351753794,
0.0249078926,
-0.0381271988,
-0.0338219628,
-0.0050000353,
0.002973052,
-0.0576198623,
0.0174791422,
0.027877653,
0.0471118614,
-0.0186188091,
-0.0309222918,
-0.0046964251,
0.0164142065,
-0.0192501228,
0.0182425305,
0.0283921547,
-0.0509893298,
-0.0217265189,
0.0086988956,
0.0133074652,
0.0068851728,
-0.0039645219,
0.0225701928,
0.0211561993,
-0.0064463629,
-0.0254158732,
-0.064962022,
-0.0147182979,
-0.0323112011,
-0.0084522814,
-0.0652606487,
0.0514308028,
0.0183946621,
-0.0109650269,
-0.0588218905,
0.0196015853,
-0.0122340359,
-0.0097755371,
0.0672880709,
-0.02474357,
-0.001197247,
0.0136220595,
0.0248177964,
-0.0273747519,
0.0699241906,
0.0241903253,
0.0566461347,
0.0108778542,
-0.0014594706,
-0.0038459883,
0.0080042137,
0.0623629019,
-0.0241342988,
-0.0300743412,
0.0165475961,
0.0005246195,
0.0522988252,
0.008136997,
0.0492355302,
-0.0354083516,
-0.0052160984,
0.0482448898,
0.037082132,
-0.0413162783,
-0.0062915264,
0.0459237956,
0.027281573,
-0.0169368256,
-0.0295569617,
-0.0514542051,
0.0216971505,
-0.0272530485,
-0.0256156158,
0.0106406817,
0.0231697988,
0.0040320172,
-0.0243609641,
-0.0188307539,
0.0093192216,
-0.0389196984,
0.0275841244,
0.0517480001,
0.0111327665,
-0.0409352817,
0.0944417939,
0.0288721863,
-0.0377852954,
0.0456131846,
-0.0667199045,
0.0565679111,
0.0948701203,
0.0538124032,
-0.0285861753,
-0.0066850418,
-0.0194623377,
-0.0178423561,
0.0429651402,
-0.0191176608,
-0.0210610703,
-0.0140694091,
-0.0581463315,
-0.0451193936,
0.0158575028,
0.0233468898,
0.0462364778,
-0.0076206634,
-0.0275044031,
0.0284010526,
-0.0780850127,
-0.0445916429,
0.0323388092,
0.0019859117,
-0.0122588398,
-0.0106688086,
-0.0007240318,
0.0388082676,
0.0123485681,
-0.0273252316,
0.0173644125,
0.0082755126,
-0.0286572594,
-0.0723511502,
0.0247060172,
-0.0938111693,
-0.0586149991,
-0.018145809,
-0.0349017046,
-0.0229895655,
0.0109998202,
-0.0497652628,
-0.0147906058,
0.0219539236,
-0.0424238741,
0.0317547135,
-0.0465721227,
-0.0048646322,
-0.003925351,
0.0159649383,
-0.0157274082,
0.0769537836,
-0.037964385,
-0.0141991451,
-0.0185128339,
-0.0096397763,
0.0401268676,
0.0017858873,
-0.0223431215,
0.0150313163,
0.0140195927,
0.0166198425,
0.0138306553,
-0.0361367539,
-0.0653164387,
0.0048881262,
-0.0746516809,
0.0021977127,
-0.0247097369,
0.0164387245,
0.034733057,
-0.0198418405,
0.0185063053,
0.0045513115,
-0.0236589797,
0.0143481297,
-0.0022841531,
-0.0009714073,
-0.0089088148,
0.0091503849,
-0.0216302946,
-0.0065770266,
-0.0036296051,
-0.0066359639,
0.076326929,
0.0042977068,
-0.0065499772,
-0.0524265058,
0.0080379825,
-0.0448038317,
-0.0245406236,
-0.011247783,
-0.02086813,
0.0153288292,
-0.0231734458,
-0.0088562118,
0.0262945164,
-0.0034298422,
0.0700362399,
0.0304286368,
0.0128161274,
-0.0677028447,
-0.0459102057,
-0.0004409575,
0.0361799076,
-0.0039255586,
-0.008241781,
0.0011386028,
0.0472022481,
0.051838547,
-0.0245754197,
-0.0706192628,
0.017419301,
-0.0544998832,
-0.0897245258,
-0.1075960547,
-0.0284580197,
0.0106330095,
0.0020403245,
-0.0451132394,
-0.0484486483,
0.0704464018,
-0.0190792065,
-0.0021976656,
-0.0174350608,
0.0012870085,
-0.0221857224,
0.0743388981,
0.0188200716,
0.0395698547,
-0.0197574068,
-0.0156418979,
-0.0423160158,
-0.0093526263,
0.0177237447,
-0.0589896962,
0.007237406,
-0.0506917424,
0.0001512439,
0.0191960521,
-0.0019749294,
-0.0528817512,
-0.0447136313,
-0.0207543913,
0.0159966517,
0.0417431034,
-0.0092765344,
-0.0210284237,
-0.0074709966,
0.0144138122,
-0.0319203436,
0.003248136,
-0.0179760829,
-0.0148169603,
0.0270228926,
0.0305098332,
0.0095502781,
0.0334581025,
-0.0361690745,
-0.0135103567,
0.061951369,
-0.0023482253,
-0.007182104,
-0.0625246689,
0.0245423894,
-0.0026663523,
-0.0071734516,
-0.0005039061,
-0.0151168872,
0.0612642504,
-0.0784678906,
0.012232746,
0.0918057188,
0.0415519103,
-0.0084887091,
0.015364089,
-0.0287501458,
0.059599068,
0.0176488347,
0.0055800574,
-0.0550117791,
-0.032553073,
-0.0053563486,
0.0303950664,
0.0076391413,
-0.0567055121,
-0.0117818369,
-0.0847548544,
0.0347600617,
0.0216274522,
-0.0569396727,
-0.0048689214,
-0.0298211817,
-0.002940262,
-0.0248564519,
0.0004401459,
0.0072738077,
0.0432369411,
0.0414812751,
0.0334518626,
-0.0034185513,
-0.0629696548,
0.0548125133,
-0.0282537192,
0.0925811678,
0.0912025943,
0.0121668661,
-0.0218083877,
-0.0552157164,
-0.0153851099,
-0.0083533404,
0.0074894046,
-0.0151705602,
0.0532122403,
0.0075021898,
-0.0093110343,
-0.0134646259,
0.039175313,
-0.0866403505,
-0.0292855371,
-0.0144180302,
0.0790995061,
-0.0058493381,
-0.0406962186,
0.0093926238,
-0.014315404,
0.0501391217,
0.120156683,
0.0451064371,
-0.0061113499,
-0.0076335622,
-0.0141721889,
-0.0020595251,
-0.0436962247,
-0.0212800018,
0.0744249746,
0.0504283905,
-0.0249693915,
-0.0508235134,
-0.0185792409,
0.049676232,
0.0118446918,
0.0026684613,
0.0230043065,
-0.022157995,
0.0111785084,
-0.0402253978,
0.0648847073,
-0.0284142978,
0.0123650981,
-0.0068167872,
-0.0491235554,
0.0143632749,
-0.0369873792,
-0.0652658194,
0.0264652856,
-0.0602770336,
-0.0371244028,
0.0192292538,
0.0194784999,
0.0196745954,
0.0415108688,
0.0112580098,
-0.0144362543,
0.0941992104,
0.0792379305,
0.0016587795,
0.0101699661,
-0.0021092077,
-0.0053183003,
-0.016467344,
0.0466082543,
-0.0529857352,
0.0401423685,
-0.001956386,
0.0391357541,
-0.0017013776,
-0.0076360158,
0.0342474952,
0.0351791754,
0.0114683108,
-0.0424298495,
-0.0101418914,
-0.0523250028,
-0.0362234078,
0.0046150894,
-0.0128780026,
-0.053170912,
-0.0199767426,
0.0077434019,
-0.0698112473,
-0.0067179292,
0.0104689226,
0.0270932838,
0.0128825316,
0.0115326457,
0.0142483944,
0.0247682258,
0.0215355027,
0.0538485125,
0.0186758712,
-0.0326859653,
0.0065674977,
-0.0311669987,
0.025503967,
-0.008473496,
0.0479842462,
0.0157210175,
-0.0160118807,
-0.0201714151,
0.0428484082,
-0.0456840098,
-0.0719793737,
-0.006514654,
0.0546184741,
0.0267913919,
0.0081536612,
0.0391160883,
-0.0303315558,
0.0161862373,
-0.0255044643,
0.0365575589,
0.0193648133,
-0.0185484309,
0.0290921144,
0.0124080246,
-0.0187540613,
-0.0117797237,
0.0763797015,
-0.0514940694,
0.0661416203,
-0.0353192426,
-0.0191857181,
-0.0652217939,
-0.0049745953,
0.000516204,
-0.0215238836,
-0.0295751356,
0.0191363469,
-0.0428558886,
-0.0604612827,
-0.0056385654,
0.0554759018,
0.0111006526,
0.0037693074,
0.0409792401,
0.0442858897,
-0.0313522741,
-0.0018563345,
-0.017542595,
0.0096260337,
-0.0335328318,
0.0114511633,
-0.0110685984,
-6.570852525e-33,
-0.0230485257,
-0.0529467799,
0.0021046379,
-0.0502281636,
-0.0143688247,
-0.0011403512,
-0.0506239869,
-0.0145755308,
0.0260328855,
0.0414394699,
0.0426523127,
0.0163874906,
-0.0033116054,
0.0289644431,
-0.0073557589,
-0.0385077931,
0.0457102507,
0.0064805676,
0.0058588088,
0.0534905791,
0.1051626503,
0.0236485898,
0.033351101,
-0.073975943,
0.0389105454,
-0.0098676728,
-0.0158347022,
-0.0033336605,
-0.0053649424,
0.01637334,
-0.0174157526,
0.0438757762,
0.0293854121,
-0.0407989919,
-0.0344015881,
-0.0315808207,
-0.0472456925,
-0.009356753,
-0.0036990438,
0.0273828693,
-0.0674020499,
-0.0004348099,
0.065703541,
-0.0174947716,
0.0196081232,
-0.0040904526,
0.035310749,
0.0044636671,
-0.0221666675,
-0.0071547003,
-0.0469956324,
0.0230662003,
-0.025257973,
-0.0160472859,
-0.0157189779,
0.027962245,
-0.0015540022,
0.0296958797,
-0.0512303859,
-0.0221971851,
-0.0352465212,
-0.0196615737,
0.0807470754,
0.0507546663,
0.0040684752,
0.0813839138,
0.01223398,
-0.0388413519,
-0.0341727287,
-0.0409260504,
0.0134332618,
0.0719328225,
0.0316583663,
0.0578319095,
0.0121862926,
0.0087141497,
-0.0400598496,
0.0224409513,
-0.0283050165,
-0.0170428231,
0.0399618894,
0.0069402424,
-0.0469422638,
0.0053100297,
-0.0329900831,
-0.0339591689,
-0.0393275134,
-0.007524055,
0.0404623151,
-0.0401218161,
-0.051177904,
-0.0099058105,
0.03597489,
-0.0482652187,
0.0015673507,
0.0388192199,
-0.0004925345,
-0.0263961293,
0.0120895552,
0.0343395956,
-0.0189751517,
-0.0214081854,
0.0173390061,
0.0306572765,
0.0290721171,
0.0315482765,
0.0582127906,
-0.0022448956,
0.0035916304,
0.0222431663,
-0.0635628849,
-0.0165897384,
-0.0186311007,
-0.0263496172,
0.0589917116,
0.0319858678,
-0.0385534391,
-0.0378953628,
0.0113076782,
0.0089483978,
0.0441338345,
0.0162968077,
-0.0281839669,
0.0148922736,
-0.0417101048,
-0.0121134259,
-0.0286499951,
-0.0350668691,
0.0660328642,
-0.0247744117,
-0.0013091267,
-0.0011042765,
2.799e-7,
0.0560580939,
0.0323570818,
-0.0033799666,
0.0064788172,
0.0230577663,
0.0311516616,
-0.0207268279,
0.0360875577,
-0.0071178898,
-0.0485152602,
0.0217001457,
0.0584290847,
0.0287341811,
0.0221537556,
-0.0500929914,
-0.0077619087,
-0.0538395457,
0.0501254573,
-0.0294187199,
0.0242676213,
0.0977783129,
0.0711579695,
0.0280470736,
-0.0172034856,
0.0375540294,
-0.0456650481,
0.0660396367,
-0.0389711745,
0.0187947638,
-0.0021918502,
0.0274081342,
0.0090488167,
0.0169577803,
0.0309363101,
-0.0115331654,
-0.0175684374,
0.0110158548,
0.006112379,
-0.0242540352,
0.0068095992,
-0.0385212973,
-0.0298774727,
0.0281735975,
-0.0738453567,
0.0563913435,
-0.0569371805,
-0.0380019061,
-0.0116679594,
-0.0054387543,
-0.0305057894,
0.0223728232,
0.0173632037,
0.0161835086,
0.0140312249,
-0.0063015693,
-0.0351571217,
-0.0186876822,
-0.0623025,
-0.0004687562,
-0.0347707793,
-0.0708509311,
-0.0297186263,
-0.0204192381,
0.0255751386,
0.0120541286,
-0.0497737639,
-0.0082534971,
2.4186896e-34,
0.0191269517,
0.0095787961,
0.0071051735,
-0.0043710466,
0.0416142195,
-0.016457431,
-0.0114682624,
0.008694943,
0.0002839946,
-0.0515136346,
-0.008475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13841v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13841v1 | Is Pre-training Truly Better Than Meta-Learning? | 2023-06-24T02:26:45 | 2023-06-24T02:26:45 | Brando Miranda, Patrick Yu, Saumya Goyal, Yu-Xiong Wang, Sanmi Koyejo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | In the context of few-shot learning, it is currently believed that a fixed
pre-trained (PT) model, along with fine-tuning the final layer during
evaluation, outperforms standard meta-learning algorithms. We re-evaluate these
claims under an in-depth empirical examination of an extensive set of formally
diverse datasets and compare PT to Model Agnostic Meta-Learning (MAML). Unlike
previous work, we emphasize a fair comparison by using: the same architecture,
the same optimizer, and all models trained to convergence. Crucially, we use a
more rigorous statistical tool -- the effect size (Cohen's d) -- to determine
the practical significance of the difference between a model trained with PT
vs. a MAML. We then use a previously proposed metric -- the diversity
coefficient -- to compute the average formal diversity of a dataset. Using this
analysis, we demonstrate the following: 1. when the formal diversity of a data
set is low, PT beats MAML on average and 2. when the formal diversity is high,
MAML beats PT on average. The caveat is that the magnitude of the average
difference between a PT vs. MAML using the effect size is low (according to
classical statistical thresholds) -- less than 0.2. Nevertheless, this
observation is contrary to the currently held belief that a pre-trained model
is always better than a meta-learning model. Our extensive experiments consider
21 few-shot learning benchmarks, including the large-scale few-shot learning
dataset Meta-Data set. We also show no significant difference between a MAML
model vs. a PT model with GPT-2 on Openwebtext. We, therefore, conclude that a
pre-trained model does not always beat a meta-learned model and that the formal
diversity of a dataset is a driving factor. | [
-0.0281731728,
0.0221343543,
-0.017122563,
-0.0281850789,
0.0023286531,
0.0068297195,
0.0509478711,
-0.0187211949,
-0.1005822122,
-0.0299124662,
-0.0260175951,
0.0344432853,
0.0151295727,
0.008053638,
-0.0048352284,
-0.0580189228,
0.0321331806,
0.0284299403,
-0.0006376608,
-0.0282813795,
-0.0353341289,
-0.0495766252,
0.0216574669,
0.026479682,
0.0481824987,
-0.00188074,
-0.0172271207,
0.0245065,
0.0534586161,
-0.0196881071,
-0.003590642,
0.0353667624,
0.0064765099,
0.0756887421,
0.0000023208,
-0.0403769389,
-0.0096844863,
0.0332524925,
-0.0421984531,
0.0006895033,
0.00223857,
0.0134117454,
-0.0008911235,
-0.0124051468,
-0.0026668971,
-0.0899125412,
0.06353347,
-0.0013766335,
0.0175375845,
0.0489039309,
-0.0142330658,
-0.0369977355,
-0.0060073286,
-0.0309385937,
0.0285019595,
-0.0068052858,
-0.0008027725,
-0.0311095417,
-0.0527169742,
-0.0165300351,
-0.0122174732,
0.0181116369,
0.0301025677,
0.0803083181,
0.0135739446,
0.0460002534,
-0.0505955704,
0.007221268,
-0.003464327,
0.0701058805,
-0.0460372232,
-0.0119231427,
-0.0217166059,
-0.0391692258,
0.0185796972,
0.0257512312,
-0.0414872989,
0.0075351102,
0.0004629716,
-0.0023927968,
-0.1073475331,
0.0491736345,
0.0500172786,
-0.0152429538,
-0.0444527455,
0.0041068634,
0.0099824155,
-0.0098597882,
0.0206258297,
0.0050249966,
-0.0179979037,
-0.0058544534,
-0.0433882922,
-0.0181909967,
0.0124235051,
-0.0179848652,
-0.0336651653,
-0.0296238568,
0.0167985391,
-0.0191745143,
0.1320844889,
-0.010364485,
-0.032305561,
0.0377709158,
-0.0092207501,
-0.0347799957,
0.0151381446,
0.0471612625,
-0.0089448523,
0.0298537817,
-0.0776761025,
0.0163125806,
0.0105170514,
0.054533191,
0.0230829604,
0.0214600638,
-0.0658103749,
0.0103738895,
0.0118527478,
-0.0153105883,
-0.0150613142,
-0.0212503821,
0.0093182744,
-0.0071165757,
0.0192975756,
0.0149138048,
-0.0490320362,
0.0312126782,
0.0236763023,
-0.0471247472,
-0.0089113005,
-0.0328145176,
0.0036169318,
-0.0286090225,
0.0415689722,
0.0357492119,
0.0247894935,
-0.0599645004,
-0.0099558979,
0.01235021,
-0.0110897617,
-0.0565587804,
0.0315556787,
-0.0496739186,
0.0281251818,
-0.0256634429,
0.0297378991,
0.0062960149,
-0.0414274856,
-0.0244109612,
-0.0233526155,
0.0582521744,
-0.0587568618,
0.0092966398,
0.019570332,
0.0001999603,
-0.0377092361,
0.0886761397,
0.0135692237,
0.0129009234,
0.0250432175,
-0.0303107072,
0.0126134893,
-0.0088206371,
0.0271159075,
-0.0072844271,
0.0199079644,
-0.0135770021,
-0.0016048829,
-0.0091708414,
-0.0302007683,
-0.0371877626,
-0.0816149414,
-0.0223583411,
0.0421052836,
0.0321161784,
0.0262697134,
0.0054826131,
0.0093937507,
0.005467406,
0.0489152782,
-0.0129391588,
-0.0569554977,
0.0556753315,
-0.0650032535,
-0.0197074451,
-0.0040902738,
0.0259835217,
-0.0690404773,
-0.0309804734,
0.0288379043,
-0.0147418566,
-0.0712896436,
-0.0011795105,
0.0648471341,
-0.0252668615,
0.0123322019,
0.0037791147,
0.042648986,
-0.0136325359,
-0.0602884069,
-0.0537243001,
-0.0226319749,
0.0108423121,
0.0067438344,
-0.0318616889,
-0.0370291211,
-0.032175649,
0.0331188627,
0.0223956592,
0.0285613667,
0.0283248667,
0.070850797,
-0.018844055,
-0.041649323,
-0.0373727009,
0.0252215415,
0.0566633865,
-0.0027851439,
0.0192036703,
0.0103093535,
-0.0407760218,
-0.0057262131,
0.0236801766,
-0.0420079194,
-0.0066048722,
0.0478000045,
0.017262781,
0.0125001352,
-0.0153225446,
-0.0598950051,
-0.0240091272,
-0.0020910245,
-0.0100269588,
0.0083081713,
0.0332161561,
-0.021044096,
-0.0288081281,
0.0245268922,
-0.0642524734,
0.0059302314,
0.0059561436,
-0.0728172809,
-0.0329246111,
0.0176623575,
0.0548858494,
0.0155426729,
-0.0301743113,
0.0086088283,
-0.0631014854,
0.0251011029,
-0.0342947617,
0.0174302179,
0.0157748163,
-0.0342381038,
0.0044595334,
-0.0556341819,
0.0668392405,
0.0257499702,
-0.0528211817,
0.0149171064,
-0.0189006235,
0.0193502083,
0.0223397743,
-0.0131863179,
-0.0247090627,
0.0278763585,
-0.0561157204,
0.0113142245,
-0.0306647662,
0.0002825689,
-0.0012858624,
0.0029919769,
-0.0182356704,
0.0036818979,
0.0195683762,
0.049334079,
-0.0266894568,
0.0290349405,
0.0115584238,
0.0145957526,
0.0206464157,
-0.0339187644,
-0.0431364477,
0.0433978848,
0.06407433,
0.0032179062,
0.0265819728,
0.0488658026,
-0.0143766142,
-0.0003285414,
-0.0297855157,
-0.0134916594,
-0.0345873199,
-0.0083261933,
-0.026700085,
-0.0462225303,
0.043380972,
-0.0058877422,
-0.0201798696,
0.0304432083,
0.0510760732,
-0.0542280935,
0.0170688052,
0.0047696028,
-0.0056163375,
-0.0164463334,
-0.0082017286,
-0.0020337238,
0.0418964215,
-0.0324443169,
0.0146079501,
-0.0545412935,
0.0501136966,
0.0180778522,
-0.065838553,
-0.048266951,
0.054879982,
-0.0120509425,
0.0100919129,
-0.0323754176,
-0.0386227928,
0.0344186649,
0.0590829141,
0.0042408607,
0.0016788784,
0.0199958645,
0.0120907947,
0.0027817702,
-0.0131442277,
0.0173814129,
0.024582468,
0.0315235257,
-0.0693394318,
-0.0475501679,
0.0637813732,
-0.0056588808,
0.0063278857,
0.0083669834,
-0.0007726259,
-0.0421842448,
-0.0399238616,
-0.0258074217,
-0.0152280498,
0.0012460324,
-0.0032626423,
-0.0508474112,
0.0013723003,
-0.036768809,
-0.0233200602,
-0.008094403,
0.0582257509,
-0.0281595476,
-0.035560403,
0.0286544561,
0.0068896525,
-0.0018786239,
-0.0432761386,
0.0336453877,
-0.0304463804,
0.0985657349,
0.0022467053,
0.0177603289,
0.0009841145,
-0.0542674512,
0.0078936229,
-0.0143763395,
-0.0279188566,
-0.0260151923,
0.0200920217,
-0.000066893,
-0.0175201017,
0.0109318113,
0.0745743886,
0.011922027,
-0.0415537432,
-0.0232405458,
-0.0054330807,
0.0139963366,
0.0061847554,
0.0043794266,
-0.0245926306,
-0.0350209996,
-0.010975942,
0.0203821752,
-0.0078282375,
-0.0045839548,
0.0065989071,
-0.0594205074,
0.0140796173,
0.0041189911,
-0.0551695339,
0.0364220515,
-0.0148141412,
-0.0040216548,
-0.0474085994,
-0.0011190268,
0.0079119978,
-0.0263521187,
-0.0008820889,
0.0197991244,
-0.0188121535,
-0.0906763747,
0.0234242864,
-0.0386889167,
0.0005553663,
0.0914432257,
-0.0146940146,
-0.0501424782,
0.0075138183,
0.0989008695,
0.0236753635,
0.0275333244,
0.0190444104,
0.1163805723,
-0.0221748389,
0.0124225765,
0.0003648985,
-0.016645385,
-0.0061699026,
-0.0179353151,
0.0475006476,
0.0225307439,
0.0095272912,
-0.0210129842,
-0.013935714,
-0.0275518112,
-0.0293011535,
0.0197295249,
0.0216725171,
-0.0491391383,
-0.0349878483,
-0.0119183017,
-0.00713157,
-0.0576570965,
0.0101913735,
0.0468854345,
0.0348702408,
-0.0704417229,
-0.0214212015,
-0.0216420069,
-0.000129717,
0.0599995926,
-0.0278878026,
-0.0113134505,
-0.0278898329,
0.0592621677,
-0.0537161119,
-0.0051193628,
-0.0078954287,
-0.0143185174,
-0.0497406162,
-0.0209773891,
0.0378691182,
-0.0393881053,
-0.0111197131,
-0.0568718985,
-0.0596358068,
-0.0349080414,
0.0004917518,
0.0959505588,
0.0134964325,
0.0358694904,
0.0173744801,
-0.0242534615,
0.1100207791,
0.0882840902,
0.0187494699,
0.0069809514,
0.1194850877,
-0.0685605481,
-0.0246592481,
-0.0044788686,
-0.0253543947,
0.052335415,
0.0767885298,
-0.053460516,
-0.0015847783,
0.0567742363,
0.0221350752,
0.0165698081,
0.0968141481,
-0.0294023864,
-0.0306924116,
0.007823132,
0.0036946603,
0.0309733488,
0.0144132916,
-0.0335215591,
-0.0556025915,
0.0255495608,
0.0002895194,
-0.0168993399,
0.040566884,
-0.0005716366,
0.0214819107,
-0.0201616362,
0.0488583073,
-0.0119607411,
0.0605994053,
0.0127664562,
0.025290722,
-0.0191894528,
0.018958956,
0.0366837047,
-0.0097283637,
-0.0198651403,
0.0182259269,
0.0115710469,
0.026750721,
-0.0320054479,
0.0555239394,
-0.0965469703,
-0.0135735823,
-0.0119899632,
0.033294186,
0.0479036421,
0.016091913,
0.0141170751,
0.0120585319,
0.0022413887,
-0.0519278161,
0.0014681211,
-0.0105880052,
0.0322529338,
-0.0247309692,
-0.0035102542,
-0.0053142691,
-0.0105165802,
0.0760322362,
-0.0078389095,
0.0215791594,
-0.0020371345,
0.045480404,
-0.0282697398,
0.0123352585,
-0.0010908862,
0.0409036316,
-0.0010736122,
0.0012541311,
-0.077006124,
-0.0102300094,
0.0186506975,
-0.0278954376,
0.0629255772,
0.0234539341,
0.0098767253,
0.0132773053,
-0.0017699368,
0.0122669172,
0.0072676917,
-0.0267661363,
0.0119098369,
0.0283252411,
0.0365427062,
-6.22678239e-33,
-0.0093631214,
0.0513636172,
-0.0051870537,
-0.0548184104,
0.0149882892,
-0.0217608567,
-0.0208996721,
0.0044677164,
-0.0447146147,
0.0006149153,
-0.0338892452,
0.0095874509,
0.0134928143,
0.0043168282,
0.0261957422,
-0.0156492293,
0.0540046245,
-0.0132995639,
-0.0218699612,
-0.0018435115,
-0.0141781159,
0.0310711544,
0.0166375507,
0.0375924148,
-0.0809920505,
0.0454206578,
-0.0189381018,
-0.0750064403,
-0.0204460192,
0.0220823176,
0.0235259421,
0.0346452333,
0.0037774227,
0.0043096403,
-0.0512581393,
-0.0408916213,
-0.0283344425,
-0.0525549427,
-0.0110214008,
0.001967821,
0.0085331555,
-0.0156831685,
-0.0008456489,
-0.0085120397,
-0.0308556352,
-0.055695489,
0.0337931365,
-0.0440804884,
-0.0352196954,
-0.0380487628,
-0.0065843305,
0.0374310613,
-0.0289939307,
-0.0000025104,
0.0463054031,
0.0403195657,
-0.0204607509,
0.0460007787,
-0.0188566074,
0.0337268338,
0.0357558243,
-0.0345147997,
0.0166221652,
0.0600531995,
0.0405682437,
0.0639979243,
0.0849615633,
0.0423842594,
0.0468846411,
0.0074903183,
0.0330348015,
0.025891535,
0.0029945495,
0.103945151,
0.1067746133,
-0.0111170523,
-0.076148659,
0.0169738699,
-0.0519433804,
0.0010385042,
0.0260377787,
-0.0044811959,
0.004487942,
-0.0152409486,
-0.0381647274,
-0.0497711562,
-0.0272597093,
-0.0214328337,
0.0360443033,
0.0321867131,
-0.031914264,
-0.0029562742,
0.0647427887,
-0.0412283875,
0.0302708708,
0.0288358405,
-0.0410367213,
0.0217259564,
0.0320895575,
-0.0013927546,
-0.0672588125,
-0.0465625785,
0.0303922333,
0.0462284312,
0.0262744799,
-0.0073416522,
0.0468007512,
0.0257805102,
-0.0294782314,
-0.012500071,
-0.0134812584,
-0.016325213,
0.0379654877,
-0.0324907638,
0.0121003045,
0.0138816619,
-0.0070542637,
0.0349087752,
-0.0063700718,
-0.0543389283,
-0.0040915469,
0.0003282312,
-0.0150462352,
0.0325990133,
0.0178136732,
0.0212645065,
-0.0040129232,
-0.0657400563,
0.0542910993,
-0.0479285568,
-0.0247768126,
-0.0224580429,
2.884e-7,
0.0019219622,
0.01547099,
-0.0032891559,
-0.0451512486,
0.0211558696,
0.0267782733,
-0.0410965011,
0.0069576879,
0.0079986397,
0.0225519072,
0.068854399,
0.0413604528,
0.0505344719,
0.0143775903,
0.0019750795,
0.0279427897,
-0.025351828,
0.0482320562,
-0.0273835175,
-0.0117511088,
0.010803625,
0.0657534003,
0.0307164863,
-0.0086912252,
0.0255615674,
0.0119931148,
0.0711704269,
-0.059300065,
0.0448202081,
0.0213050898,
-0.0540381484,
0.0055433731,
-0.0222785529,
0.014524377,
-0.0116718411,
0.010821891,
-0.0020950197,
0.0353999026,
-0.0227765068,
0.0168090798,
0.0110448143,
0.0148902088,
0.0211893767,
-0.0028767525,
0.094697386,
-0.0943789929,
-0.0397351161,
-0.0477428809,
-0.1005743667,
-0.0221709907,
0.0928666145,
-0.0301630516,
-0.004359948,
-0.0028153313,
-0.0289782956,
0.0056274156,
-0.0163366944,
-0.0512348413,
-0.0208032783,
0.0291610919,
-0.0056554074,
-0.0442815199,
-0.0296534244,
-0.0396717265,
0.0663687885,
-0.0199198462,
-0.0016761293,
2.212381158e-34,
0.0495884493,
-0.0170309506,
0.0456673615,
-0.0431803204,
-0.0691252351,
-0.0215594713,
-0.0211576708,
-0.0321319364,
0.0412823372,
-0.0067198332,
0.010662823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13840v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13840v2 | Beyond Scale: the Diversity Coefficient as a Data Quality Metric Demonstrates LLMs are Pre-trained on Formally Diverse Data | 2023-06-24T02:25:56 | 2023-09-26T23:29:05 | Alycia Lee, Brando Miranda, Sudharsan Sundar, Sanmi Koyejo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE | Current trends to pre-train capable Large Language Models (LLMs) mostly focus
on scaling of model and dataset size. However, the quality of pre-training data
is an important factor for training powerful LLMs, yet it is a nebulous concept
that has not been fully characterized. Therefore, we use the recently proposed
Task2Vec diversity coefficient to ground and understand formal aspects of data
quality, to go beyond scale alone. Specifically, we measure the diversity
coefficient of publicly available pre-training datasets to demonstrate that
their formal diversity is high when compared to theoretical lower and upper
bounds. In addition, to build confidence in the diversity coefficient, we
conduct interpretability experiments and find that the coefficient aligns with
intuitive properties of diversity, e.g., it increases as the number of latent
concepts increases. We conclude the diversity coefficient is reliable, show
it's high for publicly available LLM datasets, and conjecture it can be used to
build useful diverse datasets for LLMs. | [
0.0075359801,
0.0493564643,
-0.0063228481,
0.046269577,
-0.000182251,
0.0278609004,
-0.0135643203,
0.0325205736,
-0.0323187783,
-0.0293038078,
-0.0324141271,
-0.1071164608,
0.030937966,
0.0611608773,
0.0271651372,
-0.0317591429,
0.0295808055,
-0.0420097262,
-0.0056782593,
-0.0263217054,
-0.0358891301,
-0.0281901788,
0.0265873373,
0.0184009913,
0.004647274,
-0.0137320114,
-0.0035863405,
-0.0022674566,
0.0099385465,
-0.0175791699,
-0.00892225,
0.0561437197,
0.0259919334,
0.0378864929,
0.0000017695,
-0.0694778115,
-0.0048501701,
0.0108025689,
-0.0391645916,
0.0386555679,
-0.0097529693,
-0.0166501924,
0.0035426754,
-0.0026213818,
-0.0154983606,
-0.0474942178,
0.0464016236,
0.0524587892,
0.0297958851,
0.0833367184,
-0.0048837475,
-0.0416199006,
0.0362831131,
-0.030564066,
-0.0033827757,
0.0304662548,
0.0168263167,
0.0165416375,
-0.0319772102,
0.0592365786,
-0.0461106338,
0.0082319994,
0.016737178,
0.026530521,
0.0126100546,
0.0440989695,
-0.0118850674,
-0.0317448229,
0.0369873829,
0.0626362786,
0.0096328054,
-0.0087402547,
-0.0181217268,
-0.0255562104,
-0.0069269519,
0.0272904616,
-0.031249404,
0.0218745358,
0.0237182491,
0.0329894088,
0.024609983,
0.0058579934,
0.0474784635,
-0.0191160738,
-0.0353882536,
0.0417075641,
0.0102677196,
-0.0246864203,
0.0017988506,
0.0272701215,
-0.0272338334,
-0.0044268975,
-0.0464277714,
-0.0194244534,
-0.016273465,
0.0136479978,
-0.0078900931,
-0.0501157455,
0.0290764738,
-0.053621158,
0.0662379265,
-0.0053585465,
-0.0617524683,
0.028670365,
0.0287156627,
0.0189895127,
-0.0169535223,
0.0158743784,
-0.0489956662,
-0.0124347042,
-0.0151555287,
0.0159421023,
0.0124470079,
0.0160898287,
0.0056001521,
0.0260967668,
-0.0198925752,
0.0147769526,
-0.0269685443,
-0.020672068,
0.0252359193,
-0.0316491872,
-0.0228450391,
-0.0042232331,
-0.0198039562,
-0.0132559184,
-0.0356159545,
0.0410501808,
-0.0159401968,
-0.0831231773,
-0.0035046777,
0.0055763423,
0.000536309,
-0.0393493511,
0.0083639501,
0.0262742024,
0.0197681412,
-0.0494686775,
-0.0378200114,
0.0020599659,
-0.0350761823,
-0.0808627009,
0.0218339339,
-0.0645106882,
0.0278774127,
0.0252525713,
0.0251490697,
-0.0388050079,
-0.026845865,
-0.0488820374,
-0.0450346209,
0.0415231399,
-0.0372366756,
0.0347682983,
0.017182786,
-0.0018810338,
-0.0186824314,
0.0919520706,
0.003297152,
-0.031501241,
0.0623063073,
-0.018387517,
-0.0327018946,
0.0009762928,
0.0135769071,
0.0407964028,
0.0041545327,
0.0266073626,
0.0372761153,
-0.0022131982,
0.0249768607,
0.067973718,
-0.0510987416,
-0.0150666442,
0.0680994317,
0.0402020141,
0.0581445806,
0.0111565534,
0.0217640363,
0.0078617604,
0.0224290211,
0.038631659,
-0.0422108918,
-0.0011720549,
-0.0185002815,
0.0091630518,
0.0601558872,
0.0239499677,
-0.0369782858,
-0.0508784093,
-0.0460758917,
0.0011190795,
0.0090875439,
-0.0259085596,
0.0660865903,
-0.022422893,
0.0063650631,
0.0733827949,
0.0350892395,
-0.0622705221,
-0.0081763556,
-0.0186996814,
0.0539716892,
0.0244974773,
0.006486258,
-0.0059199962,
0.0042069191,
-0.0058854879,
0.0274660457,
0.0092140269,
0.0573872179,
0.0045174211,
0.0618977211,
-0.0504321158,
-0.0440750085,
-0.0342861526,
0.0352929793,
0.0258821808,
0.016301211,
-0.0000675441,
0.0029746292,
-0.0677292198,
-0.0519571342,
0.050307557,
-0.0486032479,
0.0009078989,
0.02254037,
-0.004385022,
0.0624057651,
0.0372664779,
-0.0424424,
-0.0023093496,
0.0247588847,
-0.0404681787,
0.0228365175,
-0.012564511,
-0.0556622557,
-0.0314191282,
0.0368014313,
-0.0678977594,
0.0160864238,
0.0778172389,
-0.0285501257,
-0.0446410775,
0.0090349177,
-0.0146063948,
-0.0160557069,
-0.0489684604,
0.0230170842,
-0.0574520603,
0.0595632754,
0.010403567,
0.0688179135,
-0.0227225721,
0.0409287028,
-0.0135844117,
-0.0040258537,
0.0232427958,
-0.0284235664,
-0.0702727735,
0.0176995974,
0.00741811,
0.0287263244,
0.0232058242,
0.0093963267,
-0.023483865,
-0.0013047487,
-0.0672585964,
-0.0066469372,
-0.0681124181,
-0.001672025,
-0.0000857912,
-0.0190526377,
0.005854324,
0.0227324385,
-0.0309177488,
-0.0239855945,
0.0025915927,
0.0433996134,
0.0101479013,
0.009186469,
-0.0264147166,
-0.0008483533,
-0.0365569443,
0.0283552185,
0.0665370598,
-0.0247296859,
0.0175303835,
-0.0528865159,
0.0734302625,
-0.0119393729,
0.007104727,
-0.0171403829,
-0.0067569292,
0.0203811713,
-0.0095245661,
0.0310147628,
-0.0032974877,
0.0094701117,
0.0160671137,
0.0632890612,
0.0209613573,
-0.038970992,
-0.0187651161,
-0.0096289739,
0.043543186,
-0.0443873592,
-0.0540395305,
0.0094735371,
0.0808769614,
-0.0169148445,
-0.033460822,
-0.0720968693,
-0.0358780548,
-0.045707386,
-0.0401541889,
-0.0066514965,
0.0089916149,
-0.0376704261,
0.0524819866,
-0.0188285634,
-0.0619240217,
0.0294569265,
-0.0132537289,
-0.0105064521,
-0.009863249,
-0.0223962478,
-0.0647291094,
0.0787434429,
0.0044042347,
-0.0246211495,
0.0395268463,
0.0074304072,
-0.0477691106,
0.0112109939,
0.0399367288,
-0.0295148809,
0.1072250828,
-0.042114716,
0.0206430014,
-0.0432515778,
-0.019370636,
-0.032301452,
-0.0173319988,
0.0246472899,
-0.0040081255,
0.0794559345,
0.0007087566,
-0.0141595751,
-0.0096040452,
-0.0174175557,
0.0353640094,
-0.003891089,
0.0023078732,
0.0283992514,
0.0262408927,
0.0365903564,
0.0554323457,
0.0560562909,
-0.0634066015,
-0.0031279682,
0.0080911238,
0.0073808478,
-0.0238176342,
-0.0253756363,
0.007838469,
0.0441875868,
0.0017381106,
-0.0544277541,
0.0225120615,
0.0770284906,
0.0049818153,
-0.0254486278,
0.0991072282,
-0.0273946095,
-0.0373662747,
0.0300545003,
-0.0264094081,
0.0362702943,
0.0150806326,
-0.0357125215,
-0.0508539751,
0.0078415638,
-0.0149236443,
0.0054964996,
-0.0006755926,
-0.0357910022,
-0.0337000489,
-0.103095755,
0.0137671567,
0.009530019,
-0.0607032627,
-0.0205536783,
-0.0412485339,
-0.0078337863,
-0.0544855781,
0.0562847331,
-0.0095204776,
-0.0128156459,
-0.0003631498,
0.0398496054,
-0.0323626772,
-0.1054402739,
0.0249681473,
-0.0414002948,
0.0708361417,
0.0336511098,
0.0084337518,
-0.0453638881,
-0.0209958777,
0.0252096057,
-0.0058995066,
-0.0179010052,
0.0214669388,
0.0708365589,
0.0129721882,
-0.0043258886,
0.0074462178,
0.0198497828,
-0.0209328961,
-0.0146296853,
0.0042114831,
0.0535616912,
-0.0237828456,
-0.0338044763,
-0.0083447695,
-0.0259611923,
0.0073033297,
0.0896117985,
0.048958201,
-0.0345793143,
0.0190481097,
-0.0202554427,
0.0280167367,
-0.0239263326,
-0.0184954032,
0.0465125293,
0.0018259705,
-0.0314944237,
-0.0284984391,
-0.0299901478,
0.002098745,
0.0270653591,
-0.0116140777,
0.033669699,
-0.0194625016,
-0.0120387096,
-0.0080285789,
0.0485294424,
-0.0170165226,
0.0062474264,
-0.0643837228,
-0.0501996316,
-0.0349663906,
-0.0112766866,
-0.0006243515,
-0.0236052275,
-0.105557397,
-0.0701692402,
0.0329623818,
0.0273990054,
0.0235468484,
0.0426152907,
0.0377061516,
-0.0756264776,
0.0619923584,
0.0322010517,
-0.0610015169,
0.049286209,
0.0578639656,
-0.0195410214,
0.0075119892,
0.0536093749,
-0.0668282807,
-0.0056965305,
0.0231220573,
0.0408511385,
-0.0012061961,
-0.0114997793,
-0.0086335931,
0.0079157511,
0.052224014,
-0.0325926729,
-0.0170238819,
-0.0697117597,
-0.0162411295,
-0.0241591446,
0.014930414,
-0.0585676357,
0.0233212505,
0.0269748941,
-0.0122485999,
-0.0370487832,
0.0430195779,
-0.0161974132,
0.0519193895,
-0.0572442003,
0.0424905494,
-0.0138841067,
-0.0046900143,
0.0548995361,
0.0117757143,
-0.0250725672,
0.0255135149,
-0.0257103201,
0.0009164131,
0.0433879346,
0.035679847,
0.019235488,
0.039427422,
0.0029903136,
0.022754129,
-0.0937189758,
-0.041377075,
0.0168834142,
0.0270017069,
0.0527387857,
-0.0191007834,
0.0817409307,
-0.0093321325,
0.0177124217,
-0.061904721,
0.0063984687,
0.0105916774,
-0.0165498424,
0.0238446873,
0.0163405295,
-0.0313889571,
0.0229252893,
0.113167204,
-0.0001427884,
0.0004697503,
-0.0018445413,
0.0536552146,
-0.0360742025,
-0.0143251168,
0.0103713861,
0.0250636935,
-0.0447327681,
0.0067388262,
-0.066554904,
-0.0718430057,
0.0258009806,
-0.003963694,
0.0083636902,
-0.0079520643,
-0.001324478,
0.0575844571,
-0.0145158814,
0.0130213946,
-0.0282024872,
-0.0481202938,
0.017873574,
0.0156930815,
-0.0178786796,
-6.159460727e-33,
0.0040213726,
0.0139954938,
-0.0306389853,
-0.0506556891,
0.0174827948,
0.0280486234,
0.0009541918,
0.0137344981,
-0.056439966,
0.0150372973,
-0.0118397735,
0.0281667393,
0.0086001856,
0.0390235186,
0.0019642969,
-0.0130182263,
0.0479693376,
0.0155879026,
-0.0192037933,
-0.0058920081,
0.0313146524,
0.0034267823,
0.0534544811,
-0.0198631417,
0.0675782636,
-0.0110698808,
0.02801794,
-0.0029795528,
0.023733642,
0.0523982048,
-0.0193244871,
0.0659578666,
0.0375324413,
-0.0716027245,
-0.0504446849,
-0.0298805796,
-0.0467200391,
-0.0593132377,
0.031963177,
0.0069151856,
-0.0346225277,
-0.0205981713,
0.0239650737,
0.0133783538,
-0.0237000827,
-0.0511095189,
0.0302994903,
-0.0196322501,
-0.0323028378,
-0.0429923013,
-0.0090153655,
0.0454421155,
-0.0124948882,
0.0218419023,
-0.0008756547,
-0.0030370264,
0.0074232174,
0.0083123427,
-0.0469386168,
0.0293089859,
0.0451174639,
0.0015816338,
0.0398410484,
0.0306883957,
0.0107626999,
0.0601768531,
0.0250184294,
0.0262790266,
-0.0069769514,
-0.0436498486,
0.0221258905,
0.0167474914,
0.0093332846,
0.054616835,
0.0320205204,
-0.0019963442,
-0.0777992532,
0.0128701013,
-0.0081793657,
-0.0003935952,
0.0205621459,
0.0259755515,
-0.0368617512,
-0.0284107048,
-0.0272632316,
0.0056593758,
-0.0035450538,
-0.025869295,
0.0239574332,
-0.0129720531,
-0.0088494336,
-0.0379345119,
0.0576535501,
-0.060806673,
-0.0349057056,
0.0510875061,
-0.0090269754,
-0.0208566524,
-0.001863025,
0.017591903,
-0.0531985238,
-0.0484879278,
0.0218287036,
-0.0104620075,
0.0040284316,
-0.019894518,
0.0228277128,
0.0203036144,
-0.0463156402,
-0.0210851207,
-0.0222345497,
-0.0198775958,
0.0297508705,
0.0449171402,
0.0398989543,
-0.0153091438,
-0.0062608118,
0.0647912771,
0.018930722,
0.0009927818,
-0.0240733232,
-0.0053433897,
-0.0137515897,
0.0242202766,
-0.0238555763,
-0.0097232703,
-0.0286515281,
-0.0318098813,
0.0943727717,
-0.0032870669,
-0.0270056799,
-0.0038901342,
2.361e-7,
0.0477210619,
0.0175230317,
-0.0058603743,
0.0299459435,
-0.0031417103,
0.0354106538,
-0.0375454277,
0.0289886519,
-0.0503882393,
-0.0217302311,
0.0062686568,
0.052439969,
0.0589341037,
0.0292070154,
-0.0400810242,
0.0105053168,
-0.0668248907,
0.0206073727,
-0.0200890563,
0.0267634802,
0.0268489383,
0.1301810294,
0.0330130979,
0.0048171971,
-0.0017426267,
-0.0149515877,
0.0461340584,
-0.0877394378,
-0.0045570871,
0.0257544741,
0.0285666566,
-0.0246138722,
0.0151773747,
0.0088698408,
-0.0012185675,
0.0455545634,
0.0026960028,
0.0422160774,
0.0090052476,
0.0159710962,
0.0077294349,
-0.0308646224,
-0.0462606549,
-0.0578833446,
0.0843930766,
-0.0125493277,
-0.0776267871,
-0.0401290916,
-0.009304652,
-0.0096698524,
0.0605245754,
-0.0026065581,
0.007003386,
0.0047776205,
0.0012102561,
-0.037803404,
0.0006609833,
-0.0470298715,
-0.0054943855,
-0.0131175797,
-0.0382846408,
-0.0697492659,
-0.0123994285,
-0.0085491929,
0.0699960366,
-0.0132236844,
0.0169370919,
2.167890074e-34,
0.0824339911,
-0.0178290308,
0.0161663704,
-0.0056651207,
0.0097809583,
-0.0636035055,
-0.0196142886,
-0.0024571286,
-0.0250031743,
-0.0717247725,
-0.0083385278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13817v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13817v1 | The Double Helix inside the NLP Transformer | 2023-06-23T23:53:49 | 2023-06-23T23:53:49 | Jason H. J. Lu, Qingzhen Guo | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2 | We introduce a framework for analyzing various types of information in an NLP
Transformer. In this approach, we distinguish four layers of information:
positional, syntactic, semantic, and contextual. We also argue that the common
practice of adding positional information to semantic embedding is sub-optimal
and propose instead a Linear-and-Add approach. Our analysis reveals an
autogenetic separation of positional information through the deep layers. We
show that the distilled positional components of the embedding vectors follow
the path of a helix, both on the encoder side and on the decoder side. We
additionally show that on the encoder side, the conceptual dimensions generate
Part-of-Speech (PoS) clusters. On the decoder side, we show that a di-gram
approach helps to reveal the PoS clusters of the next token. Our approach paves
a way to elucidate the processing of information through the deep layers of an
NLP Transformer. | [
0.0080286693,
0.0161001347,
-0.0247751661,
0.0465879701,
0.0108209606,
0.0256265178,
-0.0588176809,
0.0145786125,
-0.0789397433,
-0.0507062934,
0.0271802153,
0.0151542677,
0.0105431294,
0.017357422,
0.0543325283,
-0.0778887793,
-0.0010024522,
0.0133600365,
-0.0330779515,
0.0139873959,
0.0067078364,
-0.001235427,
-0.0090212664,
0.0775999278,
-0.0132974852,
-0.0191258341,
-0.0177745838,
-0.0265475903,
0.0165101551,
-0.0103048682,
-0.0296527334,
-0.0131758833,
0.0242050141,
0.0268696733,
0.0000019332,
-0.0166350119,
-0.0151051413,
0.0164552107,
-0.051856067,
-0.0166510865,
-0.0218185373,
-0.0461400598,
-0.029856598,
-0.023616001,
-0.0080276802,
-0.0467999652,
0.0546168089,
0.0675094947,
0.0511582345,
0.069770582,
-0.0236525536,
-0.0510985069,
0.0651322156,
0.0056699752,
0.0065127918,
0.0111219445,
0.0005198861,
-0.0230155103,
-0.0267030429,
0.0365421586,
-0.0498668067,
0.0221207906,
0.016342625,
0.0198542941,
0.003514776,
0.0400709584,
0.0071138069,
-0.0421669185,
-0.0230081826,
0.0526727326,
-0.0426055863,
-0.0068978146,
-0.0036144587,
0.0139793782,
0.0093325665,
0.00047034,
-0.0591147244,
0.0400312953,
0.0281220656,
0.0224687774,
0.0292749442,
0.039163392,
0.0035345647,
-0.0484587364,
-0.0384648517,
0.0779224783,
0.0174872894,
-0.0381943509,
-0.0582898371,
0.0213564448,
0.0054698531,
-0.0126893036,
0.0306978878,
0.0115688182,
0.0773063228,
0.0206296369,
0.008995235,
0.0106809828,
-0.0041968869,
-0.0308050234,
0.048536133,
0.0283329822,
-0.0219474658,
0.0260532182,
-0.0430679359,
0.0542776473,
-0.0799880475,
0.034126319,
-0.0272474959,
0.0003059101,
-0.0314647965,
-0.0340162292,
-0.0442032628,
0.0560345463,
-0.0465801097,
-0.0579159521,
-0.0022129959,
0.0355396084,
-0.00005025,
-0.0176623538,
-0.0180411171,
0.0447850898,
0.0033590144,
0.0476524904,
-0.0129769407,
0.06293834,
-0.0439475849,
-0.0174824204,
0.0173012726,
-0.0416854918,
-0.024779018,
0.0345171951,
0.022019092,
-0.0171343777,
-0.0281291753,
0.0414897539,
0.0076537733,
-0.0180295967,
0.0036439421,
-0.0322593674,
-0.0435316451,
0.0093061216,
0.0156144779,
-0.0418396145,
0.0191262662,
0.0128803216,
-0.0009159854,
-0.0568986125,
-0.0078868736,
0.0219702665,
-0.0206477679,
0.0810081139,
-0.0005312216,
-0.0208073147,
0.018176673,
0.0151429642,
-0.0100597218,
0.0432291143,
0.0542101823,
0.0119784912,
0.0491543077,
-0.0358100124,
0.0117376251,
0.0124267908,
-0.0087066209,
-0.019197328,
0.0038996809,
-0.0717701837,
0.01297158,
0.0275440719,
0.0367492996,
0.0274637826,
-0.0420449562,
0.0016988716,
0.0206325855,
0.0778336599,
0.0668844804,
0.0129520716,
0.0563645624,
0.039534606,
-0.0313448049,
0.0501750447,
-0.0064002993,
0.0101289349,
0.0052031898,
0.012608937,
-0.0032967136,
0.0210683998,
-0.0282738246,
-0.0212396029,
-0.0090509728,
0.0041616447,
0.0368158296,
-0.0746997744,
0.0065875286,
0.0556517765,
-0.0199444201,
0.1316202879,
0.02557767,
-0.0229898617,
0.0212821886,
-0.0076258122,
-0.0168501791,
0.003083203,
0.0110860597,
0.0049672271,
-0.0130400136,
-0.0163482893,
-0.0751845986,
0.0332020558,
-0.0215952992,
-0.0006744203,
-0.0145938117,
-0.023918435,
-0.0145244757,
-0.0204429459,
0.0202545263,
0.0048148432,
-0.0155848078,
-0.0096342992,
0.0026952834,
0.003363264,
0.0454628244,
0.038298469,
0.0108523006,
-0.0239505712,
-0.0130298566,
0.0336872078,
0.0231257305,
0.0335875973,
0.0126920445,
0.0153040029,
0.0517383926,
-0.0423139371,
-0.0394953676,
0.0201373734,
-0.0302847233,
-0.0538027398,
0.0242830105,
-0.061476469,
-0.0003767484,
0.0048683537,
-0.0015019998,
-0.0327176005,
0.0334124416,
-0.0585188307,
0.078714557,
-0.0088264262,
0.0184477307,
0.0339962505,
0.070750542,
-0.0284244716,
0.0424453467,
0.0084193051,
0.0119045172,
-0.0182447843,
0.0333275311,
0.006911824,
0.002077589,
-0.000916546,
0.0140658049,
-0.0403602235,
-0.0045092176,
0.0333103836,
-0.0430533215,
-0.0211209655,
-0.0447523035,
-0.036945492,
-0.0085587902,
0.0027255255,
0.023587754,
0.0390239544,
0.0167403724,
0.0236981306,
0.0004075963,
-0.0277357195,
-0.015387387,
-0.0237880424,
0.0140804006,
0.0480664,
0.0056328378,
-0.0549912266,
-0.0138675841,
-0.009771836,
-0.0434915088,
0.0750073791,
-0.0289777387,
-0.0402458087,
-0.0691016689,
-0.0143482648,
0.0037987637,
-0.006284846,
0.0135510536,
-0.0415017121,
0.0267954282,
0.0093874633,
0.0278115552,
0.0285878703,
-0.0007579831,
0.1116221324,
0.0235215183,
-0.0111636808,
-0.0564073026,
0.0129265152,
-0.0593517572,
0.0620834753,
-0.0518810414,
0.0313338228,
0.0255515687,
0.0968531966,
0.0082460977,
0.0157569032,
-0.0587290861,
-0.0057070134,
-0.043778915,
-0.0233055595,
0.0342935361,
-0.0405008048,
-0.0522602238,
0.034197446,
-0.0049352762,
0.013568786,
0.0323807076,
-0.0426679365,
-0.0281925891,
-0.0363262109,
-0.0118946759,
-0.0473235659,
0.0669710115,
0.028520219,
0.0330720171,
-0.0057127727,
-0.067578882,
-0.0250900313,
0.0338242613,
-0.0326324925,
-0.0255789068,
0.0413152687,
-0.0032024067,
-0.0344658978,
-0.0113269696,
-0.0284328628,
-0.0437721238,
0.0145101389,
-0.013767533,
0.0269819442,
0.0532357879,
-0.0317532122,
-0.0413698889,
0.0094747311,
0.0158003028,
0.0195226595,
0.0136549631,
-0.0137375025,
-0.0566937923,
0.0663494542,
0.0345926248,
0.0259027686,
0.0165381022,
0.0144964363,
0.0070449049,
0.0509275198,
-0.0428165495,
0.0485427789,
-0.020564625,
-0.0022232337,
0.0479187854,
-0.0412050635,
-0.0325249955,
0.0044830563,
0.0088411113,
-0.0147170313,
-0.0361961052,
0.1054742858,
0.0358400978,
-0.07159096,
0.028788995,
0.0256242342,
0.007398447,
0.0126645137,
0.0002304177,
-0.0864217952,
-0.0449003689,
0.0118346428,
-0.0516845137,
0.014224655,
0.0169900395,
-0.0004270684,
-0.0855020881,
0.0220106356,
-0.0215788223,
-0.0176217705,
-0.0578045547,
-0.0537385233,
-0.0120217819,
0.0038312825,
0.0298816338,
-0.0190912392,
-0.0079169665,
-0.014649624,
0.0200902727,
-0.0816339925,
-0.0132988142,
-0.0160531327,
-0.0397847518,
0.0101361489,
0.0544641316,
0.0669655576,
-0.010364959,
-0.0640371591,
-0.0280200504,
-0.0316686556,
0.0206107236,
0.0214735474,
0.0424133092,
-0.0210535545,
-0.004479324,
-0.0070229541,
0.026846014,
-0.0651626214,
-0.0093231415,
-0.0551785119,
0.0857811645,
-0.0159020517,
-0.0218904205,
-0.0200452004,
0.0145540293,
-0.0622173361,
0.0677760467,
0.0378579907,
-0.0335502662,
-0.0111651262,
-0.0476702489,
0.0669937208,
0.0025724769,
-0.054260686,
0.0050927117,
0.0469211414,
-0.0189895593,
-0.0895867273,
-0.0031403662,
0.0147332568,
0.041743543,
-0.0054930062,
-0.0311115347,
0.0314754508,
-0.0331716724,
-0.0668055862,
-0.0246090442,
0.0098800948,
-0.0061321231,
-0.0265744515,
-0.0131777674,
0.0489712283,
0.0169904735,
-0.0424678251,
0.0001560713,
-0.0558369495,
-0.0660379976,
0.0435179062,
0.0004435643,
0.021821551,
0.0289892666,
-0.0226556119,
-0.0379328877,
0.0619126186,
0.0173735842,
-0.0684011504,
-0.0016032844,
0.0173366163,
-0.0086967871,
-0.0061436486,
0.0234410651,
-0.0325284153,
-0.0051190411,
-0.0509258248,
0.0144933835,
-0.0669023544,
-0.0397903249,
0.0556862839,
-0.0201037433,
0.0989412516,
-0.0062545636,
0.0124775628,
-0.0067625423,
-0.0136797568,
-0.0056548375,
0.014196367,
-0.0364937931,
-0.0268224515,
0.0463077277,
-0.0034861518,
0.0118814567,
0.0544730015,
0.0337066203,
-0.0171882063,
0.028821921,
0.0043222215,
0.0260671452,
-0.0239372812,
-0.0097294282,
0.0457859561,
0.0175994746,
0.0192864593,
-0.0374725685,
0.0089260917,
-0.0231502149,
0.0048399526,
0.0221955553,
0.036930114,
-0.0464470424,
0.0386662073,
-0.0554875284,
0.0071323337,
0.0291330107,
-0.0538033172,
0.0167282969,
-0.0155336503,
0.0619659312,
-0.003116311,
-0.023529537,
0.0366999209,
0.0087905247,
-0.0487703979,
-0.0333849043,
0.059080068,
0.0268304572,
-0.0174380504,
-0.0404407382,
0.0506242812,
-0.0395992063,
0.0101813292,
-0.0317758322,
0.0178999677,
-0.025885934,
-0.0068476787,
-0.0044514961,
0.0299844854,
0.0042911652,
0.020640241,
-0.0484383926,
-0.053048607,
0.000007454,
-0.0212540012,
0.0245500561,
-0.0308339633,
0.054528188,
0.0237247776,
0.0198271349,
-0.0386137962,
-0.0145977298,
-0.0238833223,
0.0170748848,
-0.0250178892,
-0.0028780026,
-6.489946923e-33,
-0.0192719139,
-0.013570074,
-0.0225542411,
0.076397486,
-0.0347107314,
0.019361224,
-0.0185957216,
0.0096582072,
-0.0052989116,
0.0329593047,
-0.0194192808,
-0.0057003824,
-0.0008666421,
0.0372751318,
-0.001875406,
-0.0153988609,
0.0516122654,
0.0180435888,
0.0000766614,
0.0011020857,
0.0551548563,
0.021756364,
0.0562904999,
-0.0089070946,
0.0005279305,
0.0228259508,
0.0163499676,
0.0222141277,
0.0368911214,
0.077465862,
-0.0390539691,
0.0220719539,
0.018496789,
-0.1135811657,
-0.0025816213,
0.0347359926,
-0.0736444592,
-0.0391302258,
-0.0234899707,
0.0434405878,
-0.0322778299,
-0.0591272004,
0.0625458807,
-0.0107899252,
-0.0238293558,
-0.030804025,
0.0330017693,
0.0295146629,
-0.0101372031,
-0.0277531408,
-0.073810555,
0.0081827277,
-0.023404371,
-0.0110250581,
0.0606866926,
-0.029881373,
0.012845072,
-0.0172229614,
-0.0956200734,
0.0193092693,
-0.0328500047,
0.0600296259,
0.0114003709,
-0.0197830442,
-0.0061738631,
0.0623949096,
0.0358429216,
-0.0283416416,
-0.0691421032,
0.0229315553,
0.0269028675,
0.0437389389,
0.0471310057,
-0.0376064107,
0.0539661609,
0.0113750473,
-0.0277955979,
0.011742373,
-0.0008198424,
0.0421479605,
-0.0149749182,
0.0323510207,
-0.0389214605,
-0.0040319059,
-0.0267952569,
-0.036560189,
-0.0092801042,
-0.0379054695,
-0.0022490623,
0.0059350841,
-0.0146929799,
0.0268618725,
0.0248754211,
-0.0653661415,
0.0221565068,
0.0003774919,
-0.0075566289,
0.0545491464,
0.0004878647,
0.0108456016,
-0.0110231675,
-0.0547187403,
0.0176015608,
-0.0017869842,
0.0302112736,
-0.0032335292,
0.0423120335,
0.0320234001,
-0.054433208,
-0.0036352633,
-0.0177203082,
-0.0136593254,
-0.0245023947,
0.002599888,
0.0237347391,
0.0210445561,
-0.0362729877,
0.0152487485,
0.0286494419,
0.0511255935,
0.0087235132,
0.0358527899,
-0.0035635186,
0.0177038833,
-0.0652000681,
-0.021872282,
-0.0514361635,
0.0436508134,
0.0509986728,
-0.0657001212,
-0.0339353867,
0.0161484797,
2.806e-7,
0.046770405,
0.0617956817,
0.0991513804,
-0.0098717213,
0.0475950465,
0.0199147779,
0.0353921875,
0.0563334785,
-0.0238988008,
-0.031654764,
-0.0305663999,
0.0189932659,
-0.027169982,
0.0140022496,
-0.1005616263,
0.0111017954,
-0.0286666732,
0.0128379585,
-0.0059113409,
0.0256861262,
0.050609488,
0.1138627231,
-0.0081873713,
0.0039917906,
0.0033670177,
0.034265466,
0.0306889229,
0.0203402359,
0.0443659462,
0.0181587264,
-0.0068218871,
-0.0039213346,
0.0159581974,
-0.0067050532,
-0.0187149756,
0.0396395735,
0.0067391586,
0.000875732,
-0.0180334933,
-0.042273812,
0.0109061198,
-0.0197800398,
-0.0140930256,
-0.0491978601,
0.0247778371,
-0.0743062273,
-0.0697471648,
-0.019877404,
-0.0564320162,
0.0365801603,
-0.0299468599,
0.0098243374,
-0.0345008746,
0.0100862216,
0.0285255536,
0.0016298138,
-0.0074805706,
-0.10047362,
-0.0189842712,
-0.0007469855,
-0.03835354,
0.0292570852,
-0.0193591435,
-0.0449337959,
0.0666051656,
-0.0080541736,
-0.0345079713,
2.605390704e-34,
-0.0179461557,
0.0333551392,
0.0389762297,
0.0057508522,
0.0110816797,
-0.042222362,
0.0302990358,
0.0025656589,
0.0221123677,
-0.056624528,
-0.0292318035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13804v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13804v3 | Cross-Language Speech Emotion Recognition Using Multimodal Dual Attention Transformers | 2023-06-23T22:38:32 | 2023-07-14T13:36:35 | Syed Aun Muhammad Zaidi, Siddique Latif, Junaid Qadir | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Despite the recent progress in speech emotion recognition (SER),
state-of-the-art systems are unable to achieve improved performance in
cross-language settings. In this paper, we propose a Multimodal Dual Attention
Transformer (MDAT) model to improve cross-language SER. Our model utilises
pre-trained models for multimodal feature extraction and is equipped with a
dual attention mechanism including graph attention and co-attention to capture
complex dependencies across different modalities and achieve improved
cross-language SER results using minimal target language data. In addition, our
model also exploits a transformer encoder layer for high-level feature
representation to improve emotion classification accuracy. In this way, MDAT
performs refinement of feature representation at various stages and provides
emotional salient features to the classification layer. This novel approach
also ensures the preservation of modality-specific emotional information while
enhancing cross-modality and cross-language interactions. We assess our model's
performance on four publicly available SER datasets and establish its superior
effectiveness compared to recent approaches and baseline models. | [
-0.0302761775,
0.0432519168,
-0.0047719195,
0.048088342,
0.0260837115,
-0.0240206104,
0.0155711332,
-0.0472517945,
0.0239073299,
-0.0428202972,
-0.1041689217,
-0.0379806347,
-0.0202729125,
0.0414121114,
0.019310575,
-0.0854576975,
0.0131041957,
0.024051439,
0.0246899221,
-0.0098260706,
0.0221345723,
0.0236325003,
0.0175895058,
0.0330921337,
-0.0604179017,
-0.0084499447,
-0.0247109924,
0.0302562322,
0.0183982812,
-0.0260199364,
0.0101382416,
0.0270610359,
0.0389138237,
-0.0025592542,
0.0000021494,
0.0145416204,
0.0081410799,
-0.0151725635,
0.0245383717,
-0.0158263892,
0.0476523265,
-0.0297886971,
-0.0128900418,
-0.023321813,
0.0134303831,
-0.0298187509,
0.0604906455,
0.0655984133,
0.0785825625,
0.0542540178,
-0.0328299552,
-0.0193422418,
-0.0074713971,
-0.008796148,
-0.0296163298,
-0.0192484614,
-0.0234914608,
0.0019942643,
0.0061276918,
-0.0576298162,
-0.0940603912,
0.0193571188,
-0.0040133027,
0.0089718169,
0.014811975,
-0.0194989257,
-0.0143676624,
-0.0350305438,
-0.0307162572,
0.1071554422,
-0.0502626412,
0.0202351399,
-0.0276819803,
-0.0008649111,
0.0046220268,
-0.0111930538,
-0.0247174222,
0.0217044316,
0.0076949373,
0.0088981166,
-0.0167664904,
0.0239249021,
0.0098114405,
-0.0511359349,
-0.0254052356,
0.0375298895,
-0.0227516107,
-0.0140962759,
0.0490404032,
-0.0017145859,
-0.0380982384,
0.0263758227,
0.0232540593,
-0.0248212796,
0.0026957393,
-0.0067109903,
-0.059732873,
-0.0652571544,
-0.0450729467,
-0.0238203704,
0.0167900175,
0.0212947391,
-0.1164925992,
0.0418548398,
0.0127313845,
0.0434745662,
-0.0343255661,
0.0170083866,
-0.0250913221,
-0.050621707,
-0.0096275881,
0.0397838093,
-0.0038600543,
0.0150864711,
-0.0173197314,
-0.0571610332,
-0.0528923497,
-0.0070248703,
-0.0442177206,
-0.0106202941,
0.0264802426,
0.0072234119,
-0.0095091555,
-0.0092243189,
0.0372604653,
0.0940912664,
-0.000447952,
0.024066072,
-0.0131554147,
-0.0580110513,
-0.0018110754,
0.0576611832,
0.0338652954,
-0.0121336449,
0.0269663669,
0.0892774835,
0.0084660314,
-0.0220177453,
-0.017433662,
-0.0094875051,
-0.045090422,
-0.0477576107,
0.0539836176,
0.0065646768,
0.0691231042,
-0.0223497599,
0.0228665732,
-0.0371421464,
0.0092771687,
-0.0654551759,
-0.0125142485,
0.0491662212,
0.0381388143,
-0.0016434253,
-0.0155075211,
-0.0254846662,
-0.0206636172,
0.0223818645,
0.0256458763,
0.036151778,
0.0352165811,
-0.0627201051,
0.0183442552,
0.0297333524,
0.0054119588,
-0.0412267409,
0.0185233653,
-0.0404693261,
-0.00631268,
-0.0037579294,
0.09718059,
0.027085036,
-0.0045022569,
-0.0309173092,
0.0520237163,
0.0133029483,
0.0104463454,
0.0549277551,
0.0092047146,
0.0346767567,
-0.0201281719,
-0.0175182167,
-0.0281662252,
0.0673714802,
-0.0020924232,
0.0068280706,
0.0435206369,
0.0350375585,
-0.0261601657,
-0.0077846497,
0.0158007573,
-0.0469591618,
0.0269074738,
0.0406888202,
0.0377145596,
-0.021672111,
-0.0528590493,
0.0496215485,
0.0169066936,
-0.0790330842,
0.0062946123,
0.0120777264,
-0.0423411019,
0.0283309203,
-0.0484500416,
-0.0348900855,
-0.0201254133,
-0.0379378721,
-0.0048543271,
-0.0072089839,
0.0073850211,
0.0442915857,
0.0640247688,
-0.0670654327,
-0.0212499946,
-0.0393183082,
-0.01887176,
0.0563981608,
-0.0610246658,
0.0276291929,
-0.0073104892,
0.0070094918,
0.0493578799,
-0.0283856876,
0.0178663563,
-0.0047091763,
-0.0070590358,
0.0330457278,
0.0571554191,
0.0311257578,
-0.004453429,
-0.02431456,
0.0298396423,
-0.0270594042,
0.0430930592,
0.0402800031,
-0.0325653441,
-0.0302492753,
0.0257135313,
-0.0531421714,
0.0019670301,
0.0508201495,
-0.0205170363,
-0.040894378,
0.0826880932,
-0.0199948251,
0.0277474876,
-0.0236545391,
0.0044132257,
0.0036120713,
0.0876250118,
0.0393464193,
0.0019224706,
-0.0073223482,
-0.0138365813,
0.0010051916,
-0.0129769621,
0.0028306916,
-0.0338500626,
-0.0509102568,
0.0487870313,
0.0050366847,
0.0073761321,
-0.0134383859,
-0.021309277,
-0.0200087689,
-0.0176161807,
-0.0838335976,
-0.006918008,
-0.0187270772,
-0.0171706975,
-0.0157339144,
0.0280311629,
-0.0174034853,
-0.0258794129,
-0.0489315577,
0.0260309298,
0.0131952949,
-0.0119799701,
-0.0329229385,
-0.0302410722,
0.0401337184,
-0.0437573195,
0.0039643799,
-0.0002361969,
0.0368733443,
-0.0504690632,
-0.0333123654,
-0.0102065457,
0.0034014194,
-0.0253588855,
0.0372889489,
-0.0113939168,
-0.0567401536,
-0.0218737293,
0.0021718261,
0.0241337381,
0.0505572557,
-0.0145848179,
0.0565570593,
0.045808576,
-0.043312382,
-0.022538431,
0.0679009929,
0.0151877357,
0.0422823913,
-0.0107697118,
-0.0005444085,
-0.0101611437,
0.0559571944,
0.0230206959,
0.0071546901,
-0.0425016582,
-0.0680212304,
0.0421302915,
-0.0250863526,
0.0346227288,
-0.0026788202,
-0.0161988977,
-0.0383870788,
0.0049232994,
-0.0159246214,
0.0467256345,
-0.0057801008,
-0.0740979761,
-0.0344400033,
-0.0040562442,
-0.0299951043,
0.0579413623,
-0.0207192618,
0.0298287272,
-0.0073012956,
-0.0287559219,
-0.0031336714,
-0.0177975986,
-0.0056934003,
-0.0423720479,
0.0277470369,
0.0219279509,
-0.0593933724,
0.0125930114,
-0.0157671589,
0.0082632042,
-0.0128497826,
-0.0486044548,
-0.0150454119,
0.0028750771,
-0.0069188043,
-0.03392075,
-0.0109305708,
0.0640472099,
-0.0371551961,
0.0158714224,
0.0341532715,
0.0179619063,
0.0347114578,
0.0072928322,
0.0520352349,
-0.0137625914,
-0.0268835276,
-0.0091052344,
0.0323948041,
0.032164935,
-0.0293576568,
-0.0089007774,
0.0267031118,
0.039315585,
0.0523742139,
-0.0314105526,
-0.0282025877,
0.0389172286,
-0.0512914658,
0.0845318735,
0.0650569424,
-0.0184665546,
-0.0706410334,
0.0013526945,
-0.0328115188,
-0.0146503504,
0.0256285854,
0.0249130279,
-0.0519388765,
-0.0793443993,
-0.0164789576,
0.0043731714,
0.0622996874,
0.000388421,
-0.002160388,
-0.0565285124,
0.031895861,
0.0107711032,
-0.0183817353,
-0.0523722991,
-0.0103157917,
0.0289356913,
-0.0175887458,
-0.0009120391,
-0.0700585097,
0.0026060822,
-0.0427924916,
0.0228975974,
-0.0092778709,
-0.0533909462,
0.022189904,
-0.0134924613,
-0.0095157055,
-0.0247064121,
0.0750460997,
-0.0213886444,
-0.0453651547,
0.0339614749,
0.028356865,
0.0011178866,
0.0062654992,
0.0084148087,
-0.0181151144,
-0.030169649,
0.0105878217,
0.0132623706,
-0.0139518762,
0.0134163573,
-0.0204276554,
0.0967403725,
-0.0234701801,
-0.0367179103,
-0.0071175052,
0.0197051615,
0.0266390648,
0.0039762971,
0.04769402,
-0.0557147078,
-0.0292150173,
-0.0121645592,
0.0363527201,
-0.019797653,
-0.0519656725,
0.0449757166,
0.0064208559,
-0.0576214455,
-0.0014066343,
-0.0689946935,
0.0074980785,
-0.02045561,
-0.0170332529,
-0.0676608086,
0.0184111372,
-0.0004918713,
-0.0187109616,
0.0926501602,
0.0133377258,
0.025981633,
-0.0445419177,
0.0024067813,
0.0134278759,
-0.0310497265,
0.0093027977,
0.0212650727,
-0.0078916065,
-0.0524992608,
0.0081449347,
0.0220179651,
-0.0072372369,
0.0470405407,
0.0156950355,
-0.0180406868,
0.0177410729,
-0.0259091593,
-0.0346475765,
-0.0226905122,
0.0951975137,
-0.0224033725,
-0.0300946459,
0.000366729,
-0.0397058092,
0.0575191155,
-0.0036015692,
0.0231483169,
0.0086725177,
-0.0625301152,
-0.0263562314,
0.0326616466,
0.0848298296,
0.0146809611,
0.0103087863,
-0.0349876098,
-0.0128540071,
0.0272605326,
0.0226406604,
-0.0726234242,
-0.0458977185,
-0.0076985867,
-0.0145779094,
-0.0241941046,
-0.017806327,
0.0148355542,
-0.0705297366,
-0.0194080137,
0.1184551343,
0.0178970024,
-0.0091446834,
-0.015645856,
0.0382275842,
0.0041865171,
0.0027171783,
0.050826367,
0.0092714764,
-0.0053418418,
0.0248449426,
-0.0291506313,
-0.0528888069,
-0.0102210166,
0.0417586379,
0.0070910044,
0.0328750312,
-0.0076979706,
-0.032481879,
0.0548326783,
-0.0360008068,
0.0644628257,
-0.0056704031,
0.0241488591,
-0.0089677349,
0.0546458475,
-0.0280635562,
-0.0448880121,
0.0323053487,
-0.0404885113,
-0.0117684333,
0.0237097517,
0.0316054262,
-0.0482009165,
0.013247231,
-0.01059647,
0.0067019355,
-0.0629969835,
0.0041878847,
0.0758517534,
-0.0315751582,
-0.0061969399,
0.0211983155,
-0.0109465299,
-0.063166745,
0.0353793763,
-0.0655090287,
-0.0469748676,
-0.0267781429,
0.02041029,
0.0378218479,
-0.018462427,
0.0226527378,
-0.0306106173,
0.0132657718,
-0.0261515286,
-0.0062407916,
0.0380642228,
-5.875124806e-33,
-0.0073315855,
0.008455392,
-0.0609431975,
0.0106874835,
-0.079781644,
0.0268275533,
-0.0393416211,
0.0236039087,
-0.042289488,
0.0317181647,
0.0059746085,
-0.0015197913,
-0.0021061655,
0.0307087041,
0.0115659898,
-0.0238400921,
0.0172446296,
0.0231750123,
0.0036818485,
0.0436816998,
0.035000775,
0.0595640093,
0.1243321747,
-0.0878019854,
0.0073694387,
0.0218476374,
0.0044157654,
-0.0363310054,
0.0744138286,
0.0540348068,
0.008023805,
0.0907518268,
-0.008704395,
-0.0252404381,
-0.0088300584,
0.033221785,
-0.0343268625,
0.0028017983,
-0.0109291878,
0.037289124,
-0.0171580631,
-0.0532199629,
0.0422625281,
0.0307376906,
0.0339464918,
-0.0616863929,
0.0378431194,
-0.0095501542,
0.0105430093,
-0.0415877551,
-0.0304112006,
0.0135577293,
-0.0341184661,
-0.0185168125,
0.0664975047,
0.10605786,
0.0055733472,
0.0287939906,
-0.0318370946,
0.0259184055,
-0.0523345321,
-0.0206985492,
0.0470421873,
0.0027105554,
-0.0031628651,
0.0437669791,
-0.0060015554,
-0.0360326953,
-0.0027588466,
0.0214172322,
0.0279601403,
0.046387352,
0.0033324102,
0.0392615534,
-0.0312093943,
0.0030976431,
-0.0276423711,
0.0148521876,
0.0158091541,
0.049708169,
0.028657997,
0.0221345332,
0.0198358241,
0.0116706807,
0.021429373,
-0.0121613722,
-0.0170938317,
-0.0345764793,
0.0097904326,
-0.0326142497,
0.0253030788,
0.0376351178,
0.0645389184,
-0.0035942991,
0.013143477,
0.0338927098,
0.004757693,
0.055327706,
-0.0003751036,
0.0302209351,
0.0059852209,
-0.0041598524,
0.028123619,
-0.0201117862,
0.0581763387,
0.0123563427,
-0.016344374,
0.069616206,
-0.0271212738,
-0.0249828454,
-0.0043300041,
0.0062257913,
-0.0379580595,
0.052536808,
0.0018580465,
0.0157397781,
-0.0223222729,
0.0191318225,
0.0008654912,
0.0721844137,
-0.0203184895,
-0.0305769108,
0.0114353532,
0.0530175231,
-0.0421191044,
0.0159601644,
-0.0488012917,
-0.0341630429,
0.0031959051,
-0.0258155931,
-0.0179804396,
0.0082042497,
2.922e-7,
-0.0075007002,
0.019850295,
-0.0111013139,
-0.0476001762,
0.0061715497,
0.0529647917,
-0.0330573916,
0.0378001966,
0.0302412957,
-0.0249348618,
0.0310309082,
0.0067835199,
0.0524376705,
0.0262237042,
-0.0809756741,
-0.0276933536,
-0.0090022348,
0.0016329555,
0.0041471198,
0.0435367338,
0.0652032271,
0.0995373428,
-0.0060618203,
0.0206525326,
-0.0040746443,
0.0208619311,
0.0315559991,
-0.0389295109,
-0.037843436,
-0.0354715213,
-0.0135159055,
-0.0455842055,
-0.0456468873,
-0.0123390863,
-0.0201704279,
0.0278837439,
0.0638250113,
0.0187777318,
-0.00296576,
-0.0908967704,
0.0092436932,
0.0542086624,
-0.0481274761,
-0.011544277,
0.0163800716,
-0.0478170365,
-0.0591993704,
-0.0285673533,
-0.0523458086,
0.0290042497,
0.0452720672,
-0.0231115129,
-0.0267217886,
0.0069648623,
0.0150455739,
-0.0495403484,
-0.0391738005,
-0.0618127212,
-0.0097761042,
0.0226868447,
-0.0401529782,
0.0147786206,
-0.0188760459,
-0.0382963941,
0.0501305014,
0.0053707655,
-0.002572366,
1.957452938e-34,
0.0250765942,
-0.0105083268,
0.022481624,
-0.0173514485,
0.0039560092,
-0.0357179418,
-0.0428575575,
-0.0210103877,
0.0339600518,
-0.0364605598,
-0.0230590273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13797v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13797v1 | An analysis of vaccine-related sentiments from development to deployment of COVID-19 vaccines | 2023-06-23T22:10:05 | 2023-06-23T22:10:05 | Rohitash Chandra, Jayesh Sonawane, Janhavi Lande, Cathy Yu | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL | Anti-vaccine sentiments have been well-known and reported throughout the
history of viral outbreaks and vaccination programmes. The COVID-19 pandemic
had fear and uncertainty about vaccines which has been well expressed on social
media platforms such as Twitter. We analyse Twitter sentiments from the
beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic and study the public behaviour during the
planning, development and deployment of vaccines expressed in tweets worldwide
using a sentiment analysis framework via deep learning models. In this way, we
provide visualisation and analysis of anti-vaccine sentiments over the course
of the COVID-19 pandemic. Our results show a link between the number of tweets,
the number of cases, and the change in sentiment polarity scores during major
waves of COVID-19 cases. We also found that the first half of the pandemic had
drastic changes in the sentiment polarity scores that later stabilised which
implies that the vaccine rollout had an impact on the nature of discussions on
social media. | [
0.0148338256,
0.0614849553,
-0.0144320568,
-0.0339342877,
-0.0076394225,
-0.0009790346,
-0.0053500826,
-0.0371038467,
0.0019601574,
0.0095552504,
0.0402418636,
-0.0057939352,
-0.0133759351,
0.0407577939,
0.001479703,
-0.0561870113,
0.0118384799,
0.0633271635,
0.0673515573,
0.000621277,
0.0136377951,
0.004297025,
-0.0176225342,
0.0508659147,
0.0123832626,
-0.0054266336,
0.0166475512,
0.0014464499,
0.0678000376,
-0.1211494207,
0.0232825503,
-0.0345242247,
0.0548427626,
0.0319360048,
0.000001907,
-0.0130016357,
-0.00436207,
-0.0184814129,
0.0221407656,
-0.0138423648,
0.0850572363,
-0.0492521524,
0.0161410868,
0.0276223309,
-0.0792800337,
-0.034822192,
0.0507014617,
0.0406336039,
0.0241022073,
0.0533103719,
-0.002452156,
-0.0257620662,
0.0238310769,
-0.0049331803,
-0.0286845732,
-0.0014404088,
0.0069059753,
-0.0544541255,
-0.0159056988,
0.026089415,
0.0248774886,
0.0323221721,
-0.0174507517,
-0.0065444652,
0.0009406959,
0.0436010472,
0.0146721322,
-0.0397362076,
-0.0255445093,
0.0547831394,
0.0284136999,
-0.0068463562,
0.0219908133,
-0.024008669,
-0.0107079213,
-0.0025364789,
-0.0482407995,
-0.0218916051,
0.0074793017,
0.0452757999,
-0.0029757137,
0.0320105106,
0.0608983859,
0.0089343134,
0.001441267,
0.0275219884,
-0.0426167622,
-0.0286162943,
-0.0224522259,
-0.0032645927,
0.0205793809,
-0.0054503223,
0.0353969932,
0.0174603295,
0.0126242824,
0.0186920296,
0.0504629202,
-0.0513305813,
0.024356313,
-0.1085249633,
-0.0384269729,
-0.0388112888,
0.0098161427,
0.0076592392,
0.0350676253,
-0.0311570615,
-0.0340720154,
-0.0079942849,
0.0611427501,
0.0320859589,
-0.0622305125,
0.0127958693,
0.0053875712,
0.0069072437,
0.0359865353,
0.0256664529,
-0.0729797035,
-0.0366512984,
-0.0640837774,
-0.0226992778,
-0.0351515375,
0.0380803533,
0.0259139147,
0.0087445052,
-0.0222707316,
0.0841032267,
-0.0573501363,
0.0332952328,
-0.0172715783,
0.009610882,
0.0191081185,
-0.0111208558,
0.0589188673,
-0.0047109267,
-0.0175097547,
0.0444333032,
0.050757084,
0.0164179076,
0.0058271531,
-0.015424666,
-0.0219744295,
-0.0292158574,
-0.012186042,
-0.0530429073,
0.0101347044,
-0.0023090709,
-0.012492788,
0.0076908739,
-0.019835718,
0.0142868822,
-0.0860469788,
0.0242061745,
-0.0423594415,
-0.00677909,
0.0192446131,
0.007234375,
0.0581147559,
-0.0005717576,
-0.0047517545,
0.0464638099,
0.0043568825,
-0.0304286089,
0.0224062577,
-0.0066285371,
0.0509116277,
-0.0052880724,
-0.0254796892,
-0.0263855048,
-0.0183445085,
0.0063948571,
-0.0508459024,
0.0228575133,
-0.0027845593,
-0.0197166633,
0.0342882015,
0.0425849669,
-0.0438263118,
-0.050863117,
0.0003418525,
0.0532420278,
-0.0234293342,
-0.0164407827,
0.0142665328,
0.02480058,
-0.0035585605,
-0.0301476959,
0.0025831491,
0.023660088,
-0.0159843378,
-0.0128905578,
0.0039108759,
-0.000469968,
0.0282145627,
-0.0491049513,
0.0270678531,
-0.0574779138,
-0.0324926712,
-0.0147219272,
0.0458656177,
-0.0579868294,
0.0081236456,
-0.0478293002,
0.0108678639,
0.0455218703,
-0.0251000356,
0.0264594145,
-0.065878585,
-0.0318136252,
0.0061935978,
0.0164110903,
0.04715655,
0.0194935035,
-0.0361589789,
-0.0123430667,
0.0064902073,
-0.0096353851,
0.0468298793,
0.0104488209,
-0.0189163834,
0.0498163775,
-0.0208897833,
0.0104874065,
0.0129266409,
0.0023426111,
0.0169853289,
0.0198992249,
0.0014977892,
0.0436494686,
0.0576907396,
0.0600661337,
0.0204177909,
0.011356106,
0.0828942582,
-0.0419048332,
-0.0274784081,
0.0230741072,
0.0230820924,
0.0479622744,
-0.0059541073,
-0.0783077627,
-0.0132259317,
0.0108790118,
-0.0401512869,
0.0337488279,
0.0923693702,
0.0152884275,
0.0132017517,
0.0124282707,
-0.0191582963,
-0.0476660356,
0.0032800129,
0.0135304267,
0.0173485577,
-0.0304611754,
-0.0160205923,
-0.0035025803,
-0.0706930086,
-0.0029860549,
-0.005871444,
0.0138698826,
-0.0222389381,
-0.0008593854,
-0.0160425678,
0.0162939057,
-0.0438137166,
0.0045407331,
0.0129951369,
-0.0852481052,
-0.019773053,
0.0165724903,
0.009680626,
0.0243471507,
0.0108081177,
0.0010409312,
-0.002687084,
-0.0231606532,
0.0112331556,
0.0170589667,
0.0190611277,
0.0516372286,
-0.0057541355,
0.0048500253,
-0.0635053292,
-0.0135435564,
-0.0669259876,
-0.0147271156,
0.0519877896,
-0.037911851,
0.0417036563,
-0.0403264128,
-0.0554399565,
0.0083804438,
-0.0237964578,
-0.0426692031,
0.020308027,
-0.0103487726,
-0.0215589441,
0.015391035,
0.0223075822,
0.0694365948,
0.0601327047,
0.0522475839,
-0.021134777,
0.0246281046,
-0.0689674541,
0.0096971132,
-0.0248121433,
-0.0065790885,
0.0005067288,
0.0928847939,
0.0240076408,
0.0313291177,
-0.0414829291,
0.020661829,
-0.0515952781,
-0.0164789166,
-0.0305382777,
-0.0033481782,
0.003846196,
0.0166868735,
0.0064881723,
-0.0292947479,
0.0241597742,
0.0401951224,
0.0580035411,
-0.0530245155,
-0.0324728936,
-0.0343349725,
0.0125751579,
0.0013207014,
-0.0136990249,
0.0039277649,
0.0144179929,
0.0139792431,
-0.0709729716,
-0.0441263095,
-0.0308033656,
-0.0506481417,
-0.0333292745,
-0.012059384,
-0.0154543556,
-0.0011954326,
-0.004654937,
-0.05371131,
-0.0789285898,
-0.0313090906,
0.0603053868,
-0.0329317674,
0.0059058862,
0.0048177624,
0.0157111604,
-0.0204129703,
0.0291716382,
-0.0178943016,
0.0493068174,
0.0114986794,
0.0113298018,
-0.0317556262,
0.0166097432,
-0.0153825944,
-0.0236501358,
0.0009129946,
0.000365073,
0.0174457226,
-0.0616372563,
-0.0058346661,
-0.0226697102,
0.0161672682,
-0.0125773288,
0.0022534986,
0.0510179512,
-0.038001433,
0.0543532856,
0.0404952131,
0.0188637115,
-0.02158181,
0.0167202447,
0.0023530093,
-0.0171268117,
-0.0116439778,
0.0073143826,
-0.0634529293,
0.0074413926,
-0.0330387391,
-0.0376102775,
-0.0436810963,
-0.0398949943,
-0.0027499599,
-0.0595270209,
0.0344913974,
-0.0134344744,
-0.0015783433,
-0.0047442107,
-0.0621090606,
0.0248629488,
-0.0195880719,
0.0006572835,
-0.0637222454,
0.0368930697,
0.0064250799,
-0.0231007822,
-0.0722858906,
0.0122244172,
0.0074024969,
-0.0213189926,
0.0248203259,
0.022740839,
0.0993056595,
-0.0376936458,
-0.055852592,
-0.0088187158,
0.0473189764,
-0.0210245531,
-0.0186447725,
0.1155262291,
0.0063903374,
-0.0136236018,
-0.0433985293,
0.0133951381,
-0.051588688,
0.0181336738,
-0.005207336,
0.0629436523,
-0.0007885986,
-0.0979219973,
-0.0717317387,
0.0748862475,
-0.0035338018,
0.0293859094,
0.017690137,
-0.0250229109,
-0.0287578218,
-0.0059081549,
0.062564902,
-0.0771586522,
-0.0263356864,
-0.0415448286,
-0.012487323,
-0.0492246374,
-0.017786894,
0.0035580345,
-0.0059272512,
-0.0164210629,
-0.0089838728,
-0.0344504751,
0.063383393,
-0.0274635237,
-0.0392759107,
0.0075948103,
0.0317320488,
0.0206948575,
0.0040252539,
-0.0177420992,
0.0366075486,
0.0646176562,
-0.003465116,
0.024488356,
-0.0057755015,
-0.040707048,
-0.0028739783,
0.0001907043,
0.0209904518,
0.0022418767,
0.0319870114,
0.0284298491,
0.0718598142,
0.0878034681,
-0.0154332416,
-0.0555331558,
-0.0015821086,
0.0514551289,
0.0045988839,
0.0088805063,
0.0332693681,
-0.0066290251,
-0.0025485188,
-0.027000308,
-0.0662898496,
0.0078687221,
-0.0036119523,
-0.0560029969,
0.0824800357,
0.0427279957,
-0.056432493,
-0.0421640798,
-0.0299448669,
0.0226290729,
0.0008209501,
0.024989035,
-0.0500178039,
-0.010684954,
-0.0179667156,
-0.0773296505,
0.0344033949,
-0.014097671,
0.0243127216,
-0.0474285893,
0.0510802381,
0.033946313,
0.0546533316,
0.029831402,
-0.008354798,
0.0180532318,
0.0228371769,
-0.031755615,
-0.0142001174,
0.0223860648,
-0.0354232714,
-0.0350660197,
0.023855878,
0.0266256686,
0.0105201174,
-0.0353092216,
-0.0697039589,
-0.0213012025,
0.0120631102,
-0.0057598851,
0.0066423048,
0.0419341736,
0.0225482844,
-0.0152584547,
-0.0171924811,
0.0367097184,
-0.0519928783,
0.0088512003,
0.0280140992,
-0.0298194829,
-0.0506475121,
-0.0221326444,
0.0267406311,
-0.0179427899,
0.1008280292,
0.0385687537,
-0.0101764128,
-0.0045455354,
-0.0072719264,
0.0588466376,
0.0102294097,
-0.0051876046,
0.0418919884,
-0.0531856343,
-0.0279089697,
0.0568371974,
-0.0650595576,
0.0038453096,
-0.0046434798,
-0.0115095861,
0.0167937912,
0.0095825996,
0.060315799,
-0.0079064928,
0.0528685302,
-0.0462619551,
-0.0549634881,
-0.0476531126,
-6.114666678e-33,
0.0176795274,
-0.0213972703,
-0.0292576514,
-0.0294050295,
-0.0117312763,
0.0341360867,
-0.022486601,
0.0258663129,
-0.0294828117,
0.0351351909,
0.0177590381,
0.0292410627,
0.0065219891,
0.0086648073,
0.0230668485,
-0.0140205203,
0.0424463488,
-0.0217722543,
0.0360445045,
0.0437620841,
0.0175108165,
0.0168788936,
0.026744619,
-0.0987085402,
0.0402378514,
0.00246942,
0.0175175648,
-0.0220355149,
0.0298338048,
0.0352098048,
-0.007566466,
0.0164693836,
0.0517134368,
-0.0128940903,
0.013092705,
0.0753073469,
0.0150802666,
-0.0512193106,
-0.0194916502,
-0.0435266681,
-0.0642235503,
-0.0536301658,
0.0587360226,
0.0427473187,
-0.0356856361,
0.0308446828,
0.0393638574,
0.0329395793,
0.0364807285,
-0.050353203,
-0.0560560934,
0.0178926624,
-0.0498458706,
0.0093731564,
-0.0233276226,
0.0524941124,
-0.0120257325,
0.1220155805,
-0.0262860022,
0.0558867157,
-0.0188267641,
-0.0179037433,
0.0077963374,
-0.0513683707,
0.0118619474,
0.0408432484,
0.0203856919,
-0.0120955762,
-0.0581321083,
0.0279284678,
0.0105920788,
0.0269153938,
0.0198475327,
0.054120522,
0.0262710527,
-0.0382758193,
-0.0893087387,
0.0247006714,
-0.030547658,
0.0500186719,
0.0129411453,
0.0246250145,
0.0147143193,
0.0098281568,
-0.0040901657,
-0.0793460608,
-0.0122712674,
0.0001340883,
-0.0243350659,
-0.0224219151,
-0.0417048521,
-0.0128601268,
-0.0028901116,
-0.0151703553,
-0.0470663272,
0.0192920361,
0.009752145,
0.0143151395,
0.0234217197,
0.0210503675,
-0.0421962142,
0.0101969913,
-0.0500214733,
0.0382821001,
0.0414068885,
0.0141013144,
0.0009512931,
-0.0282101538,
-0.0498543903,
-0.0251576882,
-0.0064422716,
0.0232076477,
-0.0266169626,
0.0651784018,
0.0314204842,
0.0207247939,
0.0211302955,
0.0092310132,
0.0070667835,
0.0283080526,
0.0321056508,
-0.0172197111,
-0.0656558871,
0.0106805647,
-0.0320189185,
-0.0237408485,
-0.0348596424,
0.0277074501,
-0.019377958,
-0.0967047662,
-0.0077898842,
-0.0451531,
2.617e-7,
0.0664545372,
0.0727906376,
0.0269702245,
-0.0117847621,
0.0281637404,
0.0450063534,
-0.0112667605,
0.0209238082,
-0.0287468508,
-0.0659155697,
0.0050967834,
0.0211624373,
-0.0197577141,
0.0222710315,
-0.0419390909,
0.0221823528,
-0.0580901429,
0.0443737656,
-0.0223606154,
0.0252870973,
0.0403637812,
0.0474639311,
0.0282550715,
0.0030437745,
-0.023101097,
0.0369306207,
0.0523113869,
-0.0416237637,
-0.0156048471,
-0.0031829963,
-0.0263692848,
-0.0008655839,
-0.0230707303,
0.0028289894,
-0.0149717685,
-0.0369559787,
-0.0321545824,
0.0328283869,
0.0212551076,
-0.020238854,
0.0192333236,
-0.0364389382,
0.0066922209,
-0.0125390338,
0.0267783683,
-0.0990986302,
-0.0714828447,
-0.0566932373,
-0.0331353322,
0.0534111261,
0.0843269154,
0.0025380075,
-0.0287878271,
0.0150090875,
-0.0098168878,
0.0001799434,
-0.0172113106,
-0.0481947176,
0.0210601911,
-0.0195816625,
-0.0381013714,
-0.0431743935,
0.0080207335,
0.0238808151,
0.0302645639,
0.0133789759,
0.0968654454,
1.393595733e-34,
0.0774331391,
-0.0080970507,
-0.0260563791,
-0.0491603948,
0.0177883711,
0.0084641296,
-0.0313843302,
0.0042485744,
0.035003338,
-0.0071895951,
0.0219162498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13789v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13789v1 | Deconstructing Classifiers: Towards A Data Reconstruction Attack Against Text Classification Models | 2023-06-23T21:25:38 | 2023-06-23T21:25:38 | Adel Elmahdy, Ahmed Salem | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Natural language processing (NLP) models have become increasingly popular in
real-world applications, such as text classification. However, they are
vulnerable to privacy attacks, including data reconstruction attacks that aim
to extract the data used to train the model. Most previous studies on data
reconstruction attacks have focused on LLM, while classification models were
assumed to be more secure. In this work, we propose a new targeted data
reconstruction attack called the Mix And Match attack, which takes advantage of
the fact that most classification models are based on LLM. The Mix And Match
attack uses the base model of the target model to generate candidate tokens and
then prunes them using the classification head. We extensively demonstrate the
effectiveness of the attack using both random and organic canaries. This work
highlights the importance of considering the privacy risks associated with data
reconstruction attacks in classification models and offers insights into
possible leakages. | [
0.0162381865,
0.1167577356,
-0.0022220949,
0.0701901242,
-0.0660832748,
-0.0174851734,
0.0258906297,
0.0153080001,
0.0010637956,
-0.0568433255,
-0.0023094581,
-0.0058059422,
0.0160113741,
0.014339217,
0.0449001975,
0.0008781914,
0.0117788184,
-0.0131587312,
-0.0558573678,
-0.041435279,
-0.0353649296,
-0.0146101294,
0.0226852335,
0.0428732075,
0.0091481265,
-0.0079107573,
-0.01788041,
0.003630287,
-0.010983374,
0.0065382477,
0.008076028,
0.0384749137,
0.0221558753,
0.0688794255,
0.0000017462,
-0.017657591,
-0.0558220483,
0.0766715631,
-0.0552376471,
-0.0096015856,
0.0205084719,
0.0118989693,
0.0005931161,
0.0253105033,
-0.0115907295,
0.0195719339,
0.0204393324,
0.0860709399,
0.038348604,
0.111112088,
-0.0040179882,
-0.045770634,
0.0257493351,
-0.007144778,
0.009668122,
-0.0187492073,
0.0415395349,
-0.0525567383,
-0.0309009068,
0.035607256,
0.0193488486,
-0.0075457003,
-0.0165135488,
0.0368383937,
-0.0247608144,
0.0312632099,
-0.0245708395,
0.0030695833,
0.0027980458,
0.0019528217,
-0.0251661073,
-0.0327853225,
0.0274452344,
0.0442360975,
0.0317789093,
0.0019624685,
0.0057525313,
0.0558832064,
-0.024596937,
0.025011275,
0.0325610042,
-0.0390221514,
0.0564460494,
-0.0180221144,
0.0224082414,
0.0338533148,
0.0221172515,
0.0017469351,
-0.0068258466,
-0.0334698744,
0.0239054132,
-0.0609918609,
0.0119129336,
-0.0148798814,
0.0611117408,
0.0138772363,
-0.0851539895,
-0.0347352847,
0.0303492248,
-0.0330729038,
-0.0007949052,
0.0114136683,
0.0083235949,
0.0254475959,
0.0111781713,
-0.0199935324,
-0.0197723955,
0.0746339485,
0.004061156,
0.0041196686,
-0.0502257049,
-0.0297280587,
0.0309980325,
0.0834167376,
-0.021019429,
0.0276323315,
-0.0499085151,
0.0234438758,
-0.0232370012,
0.0273284502,
-0.0195791349,
0.033501897,
-0.0124847088,
0.0262889676,
-0.0110537298,
-0.0538443774,
0.0481535122,
0.0186685082,
-0.0061399806,
-0.0757568628,
-0.0269522499,
-0.005427408,
-0.0313649178,
-0.0179431271,
-0.0070388373,
0.108310692,
0.0174527299,
-0.0757307857,
-0.0428379923,
-0.0758332238,
-0.0016644734,
-0.0018851914,
-0.0266504921,
-0.0390331224,
-0.0064254305,
-0.0215257928,
-0.0067616436,
-0.0613255911,
0.0025447984,
0.001396306,
-0.0591173023,
0.067337051,
-0.0242659971,
-0.0271940697,
-0.0009588202,
0.023235172,
-0.0463533662,
0.0128657678,
0.0006141898,
0.0429356731,
0.0404690951,
-0.0070839892,
0.0406090431,
0.0147267375,
0.0345815942,
-0.0163433682,
-0.0340697728,
0.0172940306,
0.0165988225,
-0.0546777733,
-0.0339667164,
0.0666831583,
-0.0265872125,
-0.0545288883,
0.0689074323,
0.0787202939,
-0.0090235276,
0.0593537502,
-0.0354182087,
-0.0133104846,
-0.0057619479,
0.0082250861,
-0.0541892424,
-0.0279344898,
-0.124360472,
-0.0484078638,
0.003001156,
0.010782511,
-0.0125249224,
-0.029031327,
-0.0092568379,
-0.0346668512,
0.0055430057,
0.0096634673,
0.034290731,
0.0328461453,
0.0280811675,
0.053078156,
0.0021224818,
-0.0564978011,
-0.0125708133,
-0.0605326705,
-0.0131524075,
0.0120608006,
0.0608170107,
-0.0364932381,
0.0305981003,
-0.0363017432,
-0.0606323779,
-0.0092940582,
-0.0050611263,
0.0092947781,
0.0393339247,
-0.0053700949,
-0.0074974434,
-0.0174916927,
0.0463255569,
-0.0050190557,
0.0189981181,
-0.0107585676,
0.0016534755,
-0.0491697565,
-0.0408225022,
0.0226802472,
0.013898096,
-0.0255410653,
0.0460321754,
0.0246652756,
0.0243572574,
0.0291032679,
-0.0196020491,
0.0263587609,
0.0707452446,
0.0176527482,
-0.0192364436,
-0.0240765177,
0.0569735952,
-0.007178037,
-0.0108438646,
-0.033299014,
0.0109351361,
0.0541492291,
-0.0281702802,
-0.015672937,
0.0096829301,
-0.0258649699,
0.0371314511,
-0.010813633,
0.0153137688,
0.0045126104,
0.0474887639,
-0.0414458998,
0.0298292898,
-0.0295574646,
0.0186572522,
-0.0593836978,
-0.057772506,
0.0064044585,
-0.0358039252,
-0.0371163972,
0.0115602603,
-0.0312961638,
0.0330811739,
0.0006925181,
-0.0505127981,
0.013292646,
-0.0696419179,
-0.0136882942,
0.0024326479,
0.0046833679,
0.0457429886,
-0.000732235,
-0.0009298128,
-0.0194451232,
-0.0245228838,
-0.0106689008,
-0.048058968,
-0.0233902819,
0.0227765013,
0.0308801197,
-0.0068315077,
-0.0342286974,
0.0323066711,
-0.0095945802,
0.0048064711,
0.0760598406,
-0.058770638,
-0.0335494615,
-0.0342013985,
0.0294555072,
0.0119785918,
0.0461210348,
-0.0176307671,
0.0174573138,
0.0141626121,
0.0223597493,
-0.0632645264,
0.0466828123,
0.0374591127,
0.0911482424,
0.0272616707,
0.0166847948,
-0.0191302784,
-0.0281103067,
0.0266657155,
-0.0037874077,
-0.0583962649,
-0.0404473208,
0.0400761701,
0.0232299659,
0.0242443979,
-0.0516516715,
0.0013248118,
0.0373962857,
0.0399502702,
-0.0455361903,
-0.0362624153,
-0.0069783293,
-0.023776887,
-0.0173950028,
0.0141004175,
-0.0699532181,
0.0278394409,
-0.0628971308,
0.0447010361,
-0.0248077977,
-0.0618111379,
0.0183724221,
0.0347787887,
0.0213809758,
0.0193034988,
0.0643280894,
-0.0284764767,
-0.0091228411,
-0.0036732636,
0.0374325886,
-0.063256748,
0.0255514011,
-0.0040531266,
-0.0181040838,
-0.0200947896,
-0.0288589802,
-0.0672722682,
-0.0670749545,
-0.0070972154,
0.0022992843,
0.0000217577,
-0.0241899081,
-0.0630338639,
-0.0635898486,
0.0306046717,
-0.0172755979,
-0.0115416124,
-0.0081019429,
-0.0182350259,
0.0368116647,
0.0099598523,
-0.0510017015,
-0.0207095258,
-0.0147603946,
-0.0063187252,
0.109023653,
0.0600175261,
0.0284500811,
-0.0122622997,
-0.0318637788,
0.0393737294,
-0.0138624497,
-0.0061493339,
0.0106218839,
0.0144054592,
-0.0090440419,
-0.0002456786,
0.0374475606,
-0.0039460426,
-0.0423158407,
0.0109267104,
0.044480931,
-0.0172569472,
0.0083075678,
0.0033405877,
-0.0781983659,
-0.0100547904,
0.0665889606,
0.0475915372,
-0.0492863134,
-0.0277389679,
-0.0091745686,
-0.0842356235,
0.0133934058,
0.0071072392,
-0.0395080969,
-0.0155593902,
-0.0356436297,
-0.0281300973,
0.0085040508,
0.0067341761,
-0.0405458212,
0.0232254788,
0.0119519653,
0.0127722844,
0.022519663,
-0.0227036327,
-0.0020809108,
-0.0027868948,
0.0467678644,
0.0595560335,
0.0097161941,
-0.0389418006,
-0.0131704481,
0.0483978167,
0.0138503183,
-0.0104058692,
0.0227519497,
0.0680140033,
-0.0089686112,
-0.0138367638,
0.0239492971,
0.0610786825,
0.0087575186,
-0.0144867124,
0.0207503624,
0.0042746603,
-0.0001156216,
-0.0133459093,
-0.0114334049,
-0.05599574,
0.0216015466,
0.0574218556,
-0.029257508,
-0.020001689,
-0.0085674115,
-0.0689310879,
0.0169802625,
0.0030158989,
-0.0067046606,
0.0486013331,
-0.0011038753,
-0.0522482693,
-0.0186829213,
0.0575024672,
-0.0212158673,
0.0174062978,
0.0233775787,
0.0334071815,
-0.0018411508,
0.0119459536,
-0.0319772623,
0.0265620574,
-0.0478891619,
0.0378905609,
-0.0632568598,
0.0098697571,
0.0020454961,
-0.0192348454,
-0.0219856407,
-0.021205049,
-0.0700463653,
-0.0704361349,
0.0072266851,
0.0292279087,
0.0211159997,
0.036805138,
0.011821392,
-0.0834765211,
0.0537605956,
0.0993786305,
-0.0006064976,
0.0287353601,
0.046601437,
-0.0357191376,
-0.0121658817,
0.0088576525,
-0.033662457,
-0.0067239455,
0.0730695426,
-0.0436961539,
-0.0232745148,
-0.0043269447,
-0.0078836977,
0.0381299555,
0.0657009482,
0.0251918472,
0.0344801731,
0.0136119537,
0.071772553,
-0.0050004986,
-0.0037624314,
-0.0142702078,
-0.0026566661,
0.0124253612,
-0.0021647238,
0.026876498,
-0.044765044,
0.0281383321,
0.0442264229,
-0.0009959382,
-0.0175113715,
0.040993575,
0.0045624538,
0.0413030721,
-0.0003909475,
-0.0150503861,
0.0271562189,
0.0305427406,
0.0676897094,
-0.0156964939,
-0.0097033372,
0.0024046698,
0.0318481363,
-0.0221452005,
0.0251220409,
-0.0546420515,
-0.0224733893,
-0.0164529625,
0.0482498147,
-0.0114257624,
-0.0049646678,
-0.0574817322,
-0.0015054238,
-0.0041303188,
-0.0450340956,
-0.0207235664,
-0.0187746268,
-0.0309278704,
0.0197942425,
-0.0247366913,
-0.0181351472,
0.0343497135,
0.0822240189,
0.054752361,
0.0471508726,
-0.0150968283,
-0.0488317236,
-0.0304416157,
-0.0299172886,
0.0361277349,
0.0162729677,
-0.0076591675,
-0.0444791242,
-0.0226466227,
-0.0651814342,
0.0510812923,
-0.0311845317,
0.0471447073,
0.0092320917,
-0.0565779507,
0.0389596857,
0.0101272613,
0.0161787029,
-0.0897065252,
0.035064809,
0.0331000946,
-0.049009148,
0.0398670137,
-5.05751669e-33,
0.0352261104,
-0.0296860412,
-0.0583725534,
0.0090727666,
0.0523592718,
0.0213511884,
0.0332841799,
-0.0158427637,
0.0024832373,
-0.0438177623,
-0.0478728972,
0.0089249285,
0.0072957622,
0.0524493493,
-0.0334695168,
-0.033928059,
0.0058788559,
-0.0037168823,
-0.0163231585,
-0.0107857278,
0.0958631635,
0.0041689584,
0.0461695753,
-0.0307356566,
0.0370021537,
-0.000377089,
-0.0253710654,
0.0091094812,
-0.051535558,
0.0461873263,
-0.0001893348,
0.0093554603,
0.0116457064,
0.0358982868,
0.0106232818,
0.0230462607,
-0.0236447789,
0.0017504201,
-0.0148215089,
0.0115785878,
0.0241639353,
-0.0674410909,
0.0393401906,
-0.0148300165,
0.0080787744,
0.0082274936,
-0.0071248915,
-0.0194708519,
-0.0420404635,
-0.0302545596,
0.0272944327,
0.0051887273,
-0.0259781461,
0.0199861955,
0.0426021256,
-0.0022174926,
0.0448730402,
-0.0204911605,
-0.0426911674,
0.0281772334,
0.0387707576,
0.016785033,
0.0171770882,
0.0144524937,
0.0216384139,
0.0599824078,
0.0419721529,
-0.0054714866,
-0.0208923295,
0.0057706037,
-0.0210552067,
0.0522791892,
0.0063782954,
0.0516198948,
0.0691825077,
-0.0451502576,
-0.0306530669,
0.0315048806,
0.005583595,
-0.029670747,
0.0618268363,
0.0056236386,
-0.0671799108,
-0.0160307679,
-0.0482339971,
-0.0470866859,
-0.0387166664,
0.0145760877,
-0.024801163,
0.0367738493,
-0.0422683246,
-0.0307060182,
-0.0130849537,
-0.0640256181,
-0.0302397087,
0.0086005582,
0.0333513282,
-0.0397803336,
-0.020552028,
-0.037088763,
0.0108352434,
-0.0178401712,
0.014021948,
-0.039726194,
0.0328779705,
0.0150466608,
0.0522350632,
-0.0079884166,
-0.0663009807,
-0.0247389674,
-0.0228535887,
0.0526255742,
0.0424580909,
0.0196843743,
0.0526684746,
-0.0037876472,
0.0002452979,
-0.0188586488,
0.0278347582,
0.071800746,
-0.0475036912,
0.0279284827,
-0.0217261296,
-0.0080203414,
0.0371820368,
-0.0182196759,
0.0241168123,
0.0162747074,
0.0698053837,
-0.0172738954,
0.0124520333,
-0.0395640582,
2.695e-7,
0.0082569281,
-0.0345144682,
0.0062622521,
-0.0366944894,
0.0353396423,
0.0709541738,
-0.0022826276,
0.0696358681,
-0.0003301527,
-0.0458719805,
-0.0644422919,
-0.0337124169,
0.0479468592,
0.0135550573,
-0.0860064924,
0.0241185278,
-0.0122156683,
0.0016361454,
-0.0322452001,
0.0164252464,
0.0151180346,
0.0710003749,
0.0431653932,
-0.053941004,
-0.0601503663,
-0.0347434059,
0.0200325102,
-0.0197636336,
-0.0208473541,
-0.0244030301,
0.0501838997,
0.0434774049,
0.0423892848,
0.020978855,
-0.0488107651,
0.0255494658,
-0.0496806428,
0.0282070674,
0.0180671047,
-0.0168134235,
-0.041019097,
-0.0513832867,
-0.006208064,
0.0167898368,
0.0502222739,
0.0014702008,
-0.036100693,
-0.0628592148,
-0.0170832444,
-0.0367979705,
0.0265507605,
-0.0173144955,
0.0296328031,
0.0414700173,
-0.0106803617,
-0.0040914346,
0.0259685572,
-0.0843044743,
-0.0171968378,
-0.0581049249,
-0.0411598794,
-0.01280824,
0.0198058169,
0.0445779935,
0.0131719979,
-0.0084064463,
-0.0042948765,
2.504398291e-34,
-0.0305022299,
-0.0030619106,
-0.0163048264,
0.0429688059,
0.020091828,
-0.0289086197,
0.055263944,
0.0163447149,
-0.0147953359,
-0.0608137287,
-0.0294528808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14924v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14924v1 | LLM-Assisted Content Analysis: Using Large Language Models to Support Deductive Coding | 2023-06-23T20:57:32 | 2023-06-23T20:57:32 | Robert Chew, John Bollenbacher, Michael Wenger, Jessica Speer, Annice Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.AP | Deductive coding is a widely used qualitative research method for determining
the prevalence of themes across documents. While useful, deductive coding is
often burdensome and time consuming since it requires researchers to read,
interpret, and reliably categorize a large body of unstructured text documents.
Large language models (LLMs), like ChatGPT, are a class of quickly evolving AI
tools that can perform a range of natural language processing and reasoning
tasks. In this study, we explore the use of LLMs to reduce the time it takes
for deductive coding while retaining the flexibility of a traditional content
analysis. We outline the proposed approach, called LLM-assisted content
analysis (LACA), along with an in-depth case study using GPT-3.5 for LACA on a
publicly available deductive coding data set. Additionally, we conduct an
empirical benchmark using LACA on 4 publicly available data sets to assess the
broader question of how well GPT-3.5 performs across a range of deductive
coding tasks. Overall, we find that GPT-3.5 can often perform deductive coding
at levels of agreement comparable to human coders. Additionally, we demonstrate
that LACA can help refine prompts for deductive coding, identify codes for
which an LLM is randomly guessing, and help assess when to use LLMs vs. human
coders for deductive coding. We conclude with several implications for future
practice of deductive coding and related research methods. | [
0.0457399189,
0.0378086679,
-0.0304297395,
-0.0049560419,
-0.0560700633,
0.0461350717,
0.0009781304,
0.0036337024,
0.0424059108,
-0.0130691063,
0.0567725264,
0.0565417856,
0.0325438604,
0.0499147959,
-0.0446559116,
0.0175369419,
-0.0061800298,
-0.0059164241,
0.0555672273,
0.0160838012,
0.0142084034,
0.0567546338,
0.0200797413,
0.0192137994,
-0.0114881229,
-0.0421862602,
-0.0209766794,
-0.0247497745,
-0.0184352696,
-0.0459575169,
0.0208918024,
0.057027515,
0.0259883627,
0.0245279651,
0.0000023587,
-0.0498291887,
-0.0312660187,
-0.0099358279,
-0.0195589494,
-0.0130892098,
0.0257700421,
0.0156399403,
0.0072375694,
0.0318990871,
-0.0522479378,
0.0063636657,
0.0586421378,
0.0231048577,
0.0165580623,
0.0520812385,
-0.028636232,
-0.0720524564,
0.0248383339,
0.0116777364,
0.0088788262,
-0.0140502881,
0.0410763361,
0.0717170537,
0.0335639119,
0.0358540826,
0.0210740622,
0.032154575,
0.0402109511,
-0.0143223852,
-0.00598071,
0.0241826009,
-0.0396272577,
-0.040354833,
0.0188749172,
0.0422515981,
0.0139974151,
-0.0360640585,
0.0358254276,
-0.011042146,
0.011501167,
0.029284792,
-0.0399479419,
0.0545191653,
-0.0571858846,
0.0089171724,
0.071972549,
0.0220120791,
0.0191688314,
0.0101238247,
-0.0186266359,
0.0355974473,
-0.0197104197,
-0.0191356279,
0.0123437876,
0.0194551237,
-0.0162237268,
-0.0842786133,
0.0315890498,
0.0150509682,
0.0127972579,
0.0388336033,
-0.0255899355,
0.0224185232,
0.053738337,
-0.0489134975,
0.0096330596,
0.0212186556,
0.0010025795,
0.0319977105,
-0.0248073377,
0.0197125357,
-0.0100217927,
-0.0256959163,
-0.0101784403,
0.0028573913,
-0.0886602104,
-0.0457175113,
-0.0186006781,
0.0639188737,
0.0297605842,
-0.0016234813,
-0.0046150172,
0.0201511197,
-0.0040364722,
0.0277800057,
-0.0206290949,
-0.0023403028,
-0.0023932413,
0.0029771309,
-0.023951102,
0.0112539055,
-0.0438620374,
0.0448905751,
-0.0188544616,
-0.0410488807,
0.0483185388,
0.0031610867,
0.0022054447,
-0.0081887208,
-0.0014790057,
0.023140423,
-0.0037754828,
0.004434396,
-0.087416254,
-0.0499917269,
-0.0030833788,
-0.0338829942,
0.0351936631,
-0.0991432369,
-0.0213696845,
0.036440704,
-0.001277189,
-0.0836322233,
-0.0082643386,
0.03188245,
-0.0553695261,
0.0379412808,
-0.050900273,
0.0164348781,
0.0683861151,
0.0406595245,
0.0113183167,
0.0781424567,
0.0374684148,
0.0372307077,
0.044224035,
0.0031032055,
0.0591879785,
0.0024626919,
-0.0198762976,
0.0391925387,
-0.0220493954,
0.0305942781,
-0.0099116201,
-0.0147755798,
-0.0071888478,
0.0230160709,
-0.0324455127,
-0.0169332586,
0.0446579196,
0.0798961669,
0.0248910747,
0.0296688881,
0.0140727218,
0.02042838,
0.0074046841,
0.0117764715,
0.0232104342,
0.0133508854,
-0.0237456746,
-0.023251567,
0.0233006943,
-0.0052611842,
-0.0229022335,
-0.0697122365,
-0.0289762393,
0.0137878014,
0.0548850484,
-0.0011773093,
0.0025172257,
0.008074671,
0.0042019701,
-0.0174035653,
-0.0078446381,
-0.0696372166,
-0.0321595185,
-0.0450515971,
0.0666357428,
0.0619713925,
0.0772024095,
-0.0097201802,
-0.0181256384,
-0.0385935605,
0.0196403563,
0.0401448347,
0.0084111514,
-0.0210261531,
-0.0437892005,
-0.057777904,
-0.0238624346,
-0.0401597507,
0.0113521097,
0.0249512438,
-0.0018521608,
0.0211120117,
-0.0067787422,
-0.0188933872,
-0.0346153714,
0.0290125161,
-0.053084176,
-0.0197350942,
0.0138482256,
-0.0114431856,
0.0486497395,
0.037861906,
0.0005352591,
0.0119078243,
0.0134675382,
-0.0205348562,
-0.0412109829,
-0.0094725396,
0.009145353,
0.0058510993,
0.0081547005,
-0.0555817075,
-0.0484530106,
0.0017728053,
-0.0139688225,
-0.0051545813,
0.0186542757,
-0.0439467803,
0.029688986,
-0.0387327112,
-0.0118129123,
-0.0364760384,
-0.0287666451,
-0.0059083202,
0.0716648176,
0.01951674,
0.0037978049,
0.0092143333,
-0.0325696059,
0.0305418279,
-0.0246958472,
0.0246191639,
0.0433159173,
0.0260733869,
-0.0025597278,
0.052294381,
0.0187586732,
-0.0088796085,
-0.0286440663,
-0.0998637304,
-0.0031327319,
0.000046322,
-0.0019301963,
0.0273993593,
-0.0360033177,
-0.0227577854,
0.045576591,
-0.0538653545,
-0.0785482973,
-0.0061600828,
0.0371046662,
0.0241271816,
-0.004020093,
-0.0131927216,
0.0070742276,
0.0055613089,
-0.0280921571,
0.0426643007,
0.0500260182,
-0.0190267134,
-0.0251676459,
0.0803606138,
-0.0245086588,
-0.0237030294,
0.0008719019,
-0.029649483,
0.0407473706,
-0.002561863,
0.0090248156,
0.0355261751,
-0.0220827628,
0.0323477574,
0.0434225313,
-0.0453412607,
-0.0286822412,
-0.0121519202,
-0.0055062133,
0.0279064011,
-0.0135099497,
-0.0886687934,
0.0286737531,
0.0425311178,
0.0223967303,
-0.0018615955,
-0.0834934488,
0.0368243754,
-0.0153731257,
0.0079871807,
-0.0339528285,
-0.0667790622,
0.0251184162,
0.1070977077,
0.0124262962,
-0.042569112,
0.0422297828,
0.0009639689,
0.0321574025,
-0.0933812708,
-0.0078551034,
-0.0560131371,
0.0608323626,
-0.0569872409,
0.0059483796,
0.0141803222,
-0.0139336167,
0.0035248434,
-0.0407415293,
0.006012213,
-0.0365431532,
0.0441539958,
-0.0730641484,
0.0136214243,
0.000450929,
-0.0128164049,
-0.0227247607,
-0.0167829301,
-0.0375712998,
0.0022466928,
0.0042609107,
-0.0153869903,
-0.0058165267,
0.0141020091,
0.0137803266,
0.042027358,
-0.0210103635,
-0.0149849178,
0.0112413988,
0.0228743739,
-0.0079995021,
-0.0536830761,
0.0159992836,
-0.0078559229,
0.0188829452,
0.0486216657,
-0.0474259108,
0.0172743965,
-0.0463552698,
0.0197879504,
-0.0224861596,
-0.0352933705,
-0.0252259728,
0.0033515131,
0.0107783331,
-0.0785342827,
0.0170936827,
0.122857295,
0.0604345091,
-0.0741772577,
-0.0192585345,
-0.0409379341,
0.0036784001,
0.0131681077,
0.0196891483,
-0.0967412293,
-0.0385038294,
0.030222781,
0.0048957109,
-0.0573629886,
-0.0381753221,
-0.0169969201,
-0.1029967964,
0.0428165346,
0.0030790698,
0.0428515002,
0.0009082097,
-0.04803266,
0.0089073023,
0.0049218917,
-0.0764599219,
-0.0212332979,
0.0063511534,
0.0114535885,
-0.009759672,
-0.0679971948,
-0.0188570041,
0.0106230108,
0.0178523157,
0.0516419969,
0.0609533228,
0.040330492,
-0.0346621163,
-0.0098848911,
0.0340893827,
-0.006615242,
-0.0091415485,
-0.0126581928,
0.0184332021,
-0.0096795531,
0.0361649133,
-0.0089323213,
0.0587155521,
-0.0379301868,
-0.026186645,
0.0750310794,
0.070387356,
-0.0327092223,
-0.0377414115,
-0.0599161051,
0.016390169,
-0.0126419719,
0.0806140155,
0.0363728069,
-0.0227197725,
-0.0183657687,
-0.0516176634,
0.0031481197,
0.0327036381,
-0.0145595213,
-0.0031731538,
0.0041662999,
0.0117857875,
-0.0579994433,
-0.0381260552,
0.0404167473,
-0.036970716,
0.019966159,
0.0292241685,
0.0257944502,
0.0012221604,
-0.0598134734,
-0.007686839,
-0.0208461676,
0.0132258264,
-0.0140185431,
-0.0033101488,
0.0033861231,
-0.0343773887,
-0.0034063614,
-0.0111780092,
-0.0283684563,
-0.0503053889,
0.007294232,
-0.0354203396,
0.0286369938,
0.0053461189,
-0.0092611583,
-0.0461567752,
0.0234685652,
0.0669794828,
-0.0709287673,
0.013506202,
0.0069609117,
0.051101815,
0.0247801766,
0.0007741037,
-0.0159618501,
0.032374423,
-0.0425169058,
0.0122722695,
-0.082866922,
-0.025855314,
0.0129615981,
0.0017091762,
-0.0335439406,
0.0297165178,
-0.0078706443,
-0.0427555293,
-0.0184493326,
-0.0189633053,
-0.0330352038,
-0.0186131932,
0.0113701234,
0.0094719334,
-0.0158579182,
-0.0390974097,
0.0188104101,
-0.0757486597,
0.0211153068,
-0.0217318814,
0.0472353213,
0.0035516773,
0.014225075,
-0.0359547324,
-0.0327784084,
-0.0302680321,
0.0251079965,
-0.0537951961,
0.0306112804,
0.001235949,
0.0659203976,
0.0090262024,
-0.0040345513,
0.0030735838,
0.0268134736,
-0.0400181636,
-0.0322789885,
0.0253688525,
0.0064796093,
0.0209768005,
0.0024231656,
0.0034267001,
-0.0602427796,
0.005316556,
0.009628484,
-0.0145073337,
0.0079982532,
-0.0242430363,
0.0149679733,
0.0249968898,
-0.0638016015,
-0.0196341649,
0.0750332475,
-0.0134077147,
0.0180976074,
0.0069855335,
-0.0390761867,
-0.0301202368,
-0.0339475423,
0.0874032006,
0.0238233805,
0.0156938229,
-0.0112183969,
-0.045504611,
-0.0409897156,
0.0198087282,
-0.0245745629,
0.0244254339,
-0.008214457,
0.0073239314,
0.0481751263,
-0.0123273171,
-0.0205905531,
-0.0479821153,
-0.0177502055,
-0.0658714473,
-0.0296391957,
0.0092668543,
-7.068860258e-33,
0.0112279532,
-0.0695081055,
0.0371221937,
0.0462813713,
-0.0103170881,
0.0142425336,
-0.0336601138,
-0.0184449088,
0.0067396932,
0.0437341966,
-0.0155991791,
0.0372236595,
-0.0056734555,
-0.0260924548,
0.0304086581,
0.0315349251,
0.0408327244,
0.0157792401,
-0.0147084026,
0.0290744044,
0.0273303222,
-0.025011044,
0.0131236063,
-0.1011548638,
0.041317381,
-0.0124138873,
-0.0280096419,
0.0063815201,
0.0040230099,
0.0300048627,
-0.0344469398,
-0.0317682922,
0.045177523,
-0.0339424722,
0.0258797836,
0.0620709881,
-0.0160151236,
-0.0564148352,
0.0278720539,
-0.0507533737,
0.0047820518,
-0.095515348,
0.0008146086,
0.0126951095,
-0.009578269,
0.0083475858,
0.0426462144,
-0.0346134044,
0.0268118363,
-0.0454126,
-0.0112798586,
0.055616878,
-0.0604043566,
0.0166347995,
0.012165023,
0.0179609321,
-0.0392767489,
0.0363356806,
-0.0353699364,
0.0414373949,
0.020721823,
-0.0139704933,
0.0246099737,
-0.0843717158,
0.0123262787,
0.054002542,
-0.0094859824,
-0.001773674,
-0.0301273279,
0.0281679146,
-0.0043699271,
0.0261837915,
0.0472089164,
0.0300722346,
0.04439006,
-0.0210989527,
-0.0550235175,
0.0298425984,
-0.024559617,
0.0432477482,
0.082007125,
-0.0007074425,
-0.0643706918,
-0.0399725959,
-0.033004377,
0.0134480326,
-0.0123058446,
-0.0227337796,
0.0143831354,
-0.0181300975,
-0.0442575701,
0.0044859475,
0.016368527,
-0.0429413281,
0.0329163596,
0.0363677032,
-0.0401417203,
0.060084343,
0.0348204076,
0.0248412509,
-0.0946989879,
0.0217539426,
0.0350041054,
0.0168352723,
0.0495302379,
0.018316621,
0.0093380697,
0.0074202861,
-0.0598528869,
-0.0242330879,
0.0208924823,
0.0153194973,
-0.0184577536,
0.009383589,
0.012747555,
0.0299604069,
0.013804704,
0.0096541503,
0.0275934841,
0.0301977601,
-0.0631825924,
-0.0158365518,
-0.0155396741,
0.0063285623,
-0.021667283,
-0.028126739,
-0.0172565077,
0.0201073047,
0.0601921752,
-0.0395643823,
0.0001612904,
0.0437833332,
3.15e-7,
0.0357618406,
0.0874995664,
-0.0060140719,
0.0342541933,
0.0396817699,
0.0305395555,
0.0077111404,
-0.012564864,
0.0171670672,
-0.0414572731,
0.0384560302,
0.0429584831,
0.0451395586,
0.0990934595,
-0.0491398312,
-0.0206104778,
-0.015988661,
-0.0289778132,
-0.0853927284,
0.0190029945,
0.0478208177,
0.0227980278,
0.0046396451,
-0.0094930138,
-0.0029277427,
-0.0321164057,
0.0489375032,
-0.0066755088,
0.021513883,
-0.0022206521,
0.0198663846,
0.0326070599,
0.0082210945,
0.0282782987,
0.0045895632,
0.0216814037,
-0.0264990795,
0.0785327032,
0.0070199622,
-0.0007608606,
0.0115688406,
-0.0131835593,
0.0026350394,
-0.0752011463,
0.0879182443,
-0.0504732914,
-0.0611679778,
-0.03249567,
-0.003915038,
-0.0624314137,
0.0270024855,
-0.0161719676,
-0.0185073763,
0.0223373715,
-0.0138780521,
-0.0259765815,
-0.0165420491,
-0.0693426132,
0.0118220663,
-0.0131573817,
-0.0340344831,
-0.0180236287,
-0.0198586527,
0.0160260405,
0.0233613364,
-0.0603272729,
0.0571255125,
3.01106207e-34,
0.0491152629,
-0.0488017611,
-0.0157004241,
0.0090861293,
0.0422042049,
0.0273174718,
-0.0126506072,
0.0260059088,
0.0069813076,
-0.0920018107,
0.0082322583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13775v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13775v1 | Resume Information Extraction via Post-OCR Text Processing | 2023-06-23T20:14:07 | 2023-06-23T20:14:07 | Selahattin Serdar Helli, Senem Tanberk, Sena Nur Cavsak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Information extraction (IE), one of the main tasks of natural language
processing (NLP), has recently increased importance in the use of resumes. In
studies on the text to extract information from the CV, sentence classification
was generally made using NLP models. In this study, it is aimed to extract
information by classifying all of the text groups after pre-processing such as
Optical Character Recognition (OCT) and object recognition with the YOLOv8
model of the resumes. The text dataset consists of 286 resumes collected for 5
different (education, experience, talent, personal and language) job
descriptions in the IT industry. The dataset created for object recognition
consists of 1198 resumes, which were collected from the open-source internet
and labeled as sets of text. BERT, BERT-t, DistilBERT, RoBERTa and XLNet were
used as models. F1 score variances were used to compare the model results. In
addition, the YOLOv8 model has also been reported comparatively in itself. As a
result of the comparison, DistilBERT was showed better results despite having a
lower number of parameters than other models. | [
0.0564358123,
0.0004896137,
0.0105221067,
0.0145268114,
-0.0494169891,
-0.0105434153,
0.0003374831,
0.0558488145,
0.021619251,
-0.0861164555,
0.0255170092,
0.0237712637,
0.0315304697,
-0.0582891069,
-0.0154630812,
-0.0172061548,
-0.0084090643,
0.0125120832,
-0.0172220673,
0.0305696223,
-0.0188798904,
0.0337801985,
-0.0113911312,
0.0308826305,
0.021371631,
-0.0130482735,
0.0223771911,
0.0125287231,
0.0176615454,
0.0275855921,
0.0066792821,
0.0215577316,
-0.0044859028,
0.0089976741,
0.0000018918,
-0.0555925332,
-0.0474330261,
0.0386688076,
-0.0016954191,
-0.0563462712,
0.0625282079,
0.0270835776,
-0.0157371871,
0.0024415192,
0.0272975992,
0.0458834358,
0.0128166908,
0.0551108606,
0.0153313577,
0.052453123,
-0.0168200918,
-0.0343802869,
0.0229838677,
0.047073245,
-0.0056568682,
0.0029295543,
0.0458006635,
-0.0424617939,
0.0143160941,
-0.0172955878,
0.0169475209,
0.0109747611,
-0.0517314114,
-0.0169811565,
0.0167928711,
0.0350864716,
-0.0257068593,
-0.0024635135,
-0.0131361149,
0.0227960572,
-0.0214311816,
-0.0118673658,
-0.0067525604,
-0.0267956369,
0.0141797382,
0.0002172414,
-0.0247645713,
0.0291175265,
-0.0587457381,
-0.0138180451,
-0.0108579965,
0.0370955393,
-0.054778371,
-0.0160150528,
0.0040880623,
0.0269420166,
-0.0201501511,
-0.0507524051,
0.0595874041,
-0.0049967156,
0.0447221771,
-0.0064281323,
0.0389380269,
0.0291429777,
0.0644334927,
-0.0003567552,
-0.0435372218,
-0.0583613589,
0.0454550274,
-0.0673866272,
0.0244757533,
-0.0145430211,
-0.0746549144,
0.0349749587,
-0.0609910227,
0.066474773,
0.0028887165,
0.01269871,
-0.0067472607,
0.0175602958,
-0.1219431534,
-0.0345069207,
-0.0513653122,
0.0285363011,
0.0006522933,
0.0153285172,
-0.0137146376,
-0.0233935062,
0.0045104292,
-0.0065032318,
0.0575775765,
-0.0090860613,
0.0282919537,
0.0365420878,
-0.0299105272,
-0.0214286242,
0.0461468361,
-0.0093280822,
-0.0212580469,
-0.0580536388,
0.0549223945,
0.0198058374,
0.0640955865,
-0.0297724418,
0.0237931591,
0.0139414193,
0.0054287384,
-0.0347758308,
-0.0292194784,
-0.0213231426,
-0.0275903456,
-0.035731405,
0.0012730596,
-0.0171051007,
-0.0096904663,
0.0259013399,
-0.0225413088,
-0.0245965123,
0.0248905383,
0.0310145225,
-0.0396999344,
-0.0052941842,
-0.0373839885,
0.0075595966,
0.0737663656,
-0.0606686138,
0.0554494224,
-0.0204642005,
0.000309625,
0.0882237777,
0.045789279,
-0.0368362516,
0.0579164699,
0.0519780554,
-0.0482670963,
-0.1036960483,
-0.0187258981,
0.0480479412,
0.0043787831,
-0.0011596571,
0.0164393,
0.0249269567,
-0.0308117773,
0.064484857,
0.0482627302,
0.0346450582,
0.0278870296,
0.0096359663,
0.0117418114,
0.0510412641,
0.0639977902,
-0.0225293897,
0.0103158234,
0.0076436908,
-0.0020407308,
0.0193345379,
-0.083058022,
0.0293633956,
-0.0098662768,
-0.0077300183,
-0.0525813438,
-0.0091712391,
-0.0429752506,
-0.0250431933,
0.0783798248,
0.0055515147,
-0.0947128162,
-0.0381642729,
0.0186118484,
-0.0223484803,
-0.0186991654,
-0.0352982394,
-0.0229586717,
0.0492608398,
0.0589638315,
-0.0658120811,
0.0104156779,
-0.0258047897,
-0.0357703492,
0.0023301339,
0.0591255352,
-0.0249252208,
-0.0268926583,
-0.04653899,
-0.0421385095,
0.0195991285,
-0.0253926627,
0.0118393824,
0.0042050164,
0.0226483736,
0.0220045019,
-0.0219620951,
-0.070184879,
0.0467654951,
0.0382766388,
-0.0414792076,
-0.0127805751,
0.0362957306,
0.0000393883,
0.0272236448,
-0.0198317654,
0.0041945302,
0.01827031,
-0.0007059688,
-0.0073799137,
-0.0097930497,
0.0327315666,
-0.0089921132,
-0.0106813172,
0.0373489708,
-0.005944835,
0.0285010003,
0.0000462297,
0.0154327638,
-0.0321672335,
0.014565778,
0.0067746285,
-0.0493313521,
0.0485685654,
-0.0337170959,
0.0055857101,
-0.0664056912,
0.0565734059,
0.0609402843,
-0.0037204223,
-0.014010109,
-0.0724143013,
0.0426372662,
-0.1223188788,
-0.0203866493,
0.007049134,
-0.0355772525,
0.0281745382,
0.0147114517,
0.0138550363,
-0.0223012939,
-0.0521702506,
-0.0724705681,
-0.0329414867,
0.0205570795,
0.0248705521,
0.0081388913,
-0.0371839404,
-0.0152468579,
-0.0189418606,
-0.0061497046,
0.0205540471,
-0.0251531154,
-0.0598520152,
0.0729057789,
-0.0224423856,
-0.0283817481,
-0.0069044353,
-0.0360407159,
-0.0159380492,
0.0364430062,
0.0427530147,
-0.0611480549,
-0.0291477125,
-0.0104488973,
0.0059850058,
0.0258567575,
0.0267442893,
0.0001154732,
-0.0426364429,
-0.0086129671,
0.0048978231,
0.0982897729,
-0.0045056269,
0.0227039345,
-0.0004718341,
0.020880146,
0.0311478041,
-0.0134300273,
-0.0215022732,
0.0567617007,
0.013552242,
-0.0192754939,
0.0304518975,
-0.0451162606,
0.0158312675,
0.0031589188,
0.0215706695,
-0.0405940749,
-0.043910142,
-0.0022076657,
-0.0535888188,
0.0048027816,
-0.0331006534,
-0.0051180217,
0.0176356416,
-0.0066291983,
-0.0120992521,
-0.0354873426,
0.007240755,
-0.0476281568,
-0.0154331075,
-0.0379119702,
0.0468307734,
0.0140549541,
0.0167547092,
0.0281317607,
-0.0725214556,
-0.0072423089,
-0.0640038401,
-0.0091187619,
-0.0361375175,
-0.086910069,
0.0358168744,
0.0297119897,
-0.0381368101,
0.0080685131,
-0.0270131808,
-0.0346833766,
-0.0081825778,
0.0378987342,
-0.0170617308,
0.0143676111,
-0.0558600053,
0.0312035363,
-0.0073475577,
0.0645852089,
-0.048229821,
0.0151824085,
-0.0378365889,
0.0679994673,
0.0342781097,
-0.0361150168,
-0.0257247835,
-0.0388031974,
-0.0141258566,
-0.017833,
0.0002481277,
-0.0033252952,
-0.0083288001,
-0.0281775966,
0.016810745,
-0.0879114866,
-0.0187205393,
-0.0024335121,
-0.0145407207,
-0.0444034152,
0.0159957521,
0.0488537475,
0.0186502934,
0.0052816626,
-0.0244255271,
0.0524903983,
-0.0952013955,
-0.003826532,
0.0438925065,
0.0232933164,
0.012102956,
-0.0044328975,
0.0248421151,
-0.0243366249,
0.0007794568,
-0.0163959134,
-0.027758114,
0.0520396605,
-0.0309437197,
-0.0285239518,
-0.0426784717,
-0.011707603,
-0.0114838649,
-0.0202431809,
-0.0408836082,
0.0114335762,
-0.0559499189,
-0.0178569555,
0.0526396334,
-0.0180309117,
0.0021026735,
0.0192663744,
0.0070584076,
-0.0467665568,
0.0483852141,
0.0443564616,
-0.0614146404,
-0.0322677083,
0.0096523166,
-0.0255372673,
0.0196912792,
0.0017751041,
0.0694648996,
-0.0053193388,
0.0133785382,
-0.0213699434,
-0.0298635848,
-0.0133658042,
-0.0060696402,
0.0220789593,
0.0118192853,
-0.011595441,
-0.0319850035,
-0.0323814973,
-0.0105685871,
-0.0118090902,
0.0348918214,
-0.0305771716,
-0.0583937801,
-0.0414032713,
0.0273609161,
-0.013294871,
-0.0365648158,
0.0227726083,
0.0255086515,
-0.0556979813,
-0.0517257564,
-0.0369049571,
-0.0044869781,
0.0400018096,
0.0474577472,
0.0129346633,
0.0132397683,
0.0021137169,
0.0486829355,
-0.0387188084,
-0.0063102976,
0.0142363971,
0.0306972191,
-0.0966783315,
0.0196973998,
-0.0323041119,
-0.0605795085,
-0.0617330782,
-0.0509500429,
-0.0099433297,
0.0257657394,
0.0156534258,
-0.0164359342,
0.0180477798,
-0.0488324575,
0.0097501799,
-0.0648627952,
0.095056355,
0.0365518853,
0.0383655205,
-0.0346579552,
-0.0374939293,
-0.0358643383,
-0.0376782641,
-0.0222114976,
0.0026186022,
0.0187152848,
0.0358281545,
-0.0887885168,
0.0770314783,
-0.0322884023,
-0.0028444447,
0.0284959618,
0.0196885914,
0.0172651205,
-0.0179798938,
-0.0602136813,
-0.0003057846,
0.0288807675,
0.0021235389,
-0.0039626718,
0.027745327,
0.0292737857,
0.0357432179,
-0.0053843269,
0.0003615592,
-0.0001604204,
0.010060017,
-0.0437946357,
0.033242058,
-0.0507839397,
0.0837928355,
-0.0308115669,
-0.0264148284,
-0.0163291134,
-0.0350461192,
-0.0011916111,
0.0164400935,
0.016064303,
0.0126088038,
-0.0298977736,
0.0210344754,
0.0157748107,
0.0412429869,
-0.0208136421,
0.0464800447,
-0.0539341941,
0.0368179791,
0.0268185809,
-0.0394447856,
0.0071754828,
-0.0117672356,
-0.0075852131,
-0.0265225898,
0.0001793167,
0.0598116554,
0.0230986327,
-0.0028707453,
-0.0109848147,
-0.0353309922,
-0.0425504036,
-0.0044474816,
0.0546313338,
-0.0437052995,
-0.0004127825,
-0.0220520403,
-0.0480763763,
0.0561176538,
0.0706700385,
0.0232372973,
-0.0471853651,
0.0192290787,
-0.0364665426,
0.0305667073,
0.0592156202,
0.0078658145,
-0.0002825853,
0.0193750169,
0.0099518541,
0.0352781676,
0.0080785081,
-0.0304304007,
-0.0516038164,
0.0228252653,
0.0110508315,
0.0172775369,
-0.0111378888,
-5.263687011e-33,
0.0078610806,
-0.027452305,
-0.001660384,
0.0563884266,
0.0067745512,
0.0194798745,
0.0525336713,
-0.0473740213,
-0.0305091999,
-0.0060898666,
-0.0164416172,
-0.0099107865,
0.0563306473,
0.0170656443,
-0.004127318,
0.0412977636,
0.0195918903,
-0.0042538526,
-0.0238352716,
-0.0328209177,
0.0222774968,
0.0490617901,
0.099934116,
-0.0735767111,
0.018188633,
-0.0149285197,
-0.0108631691,
-0.0287629385,
0.0860068426,
0.0131499944,
-0.0073950104,
0.0117663629,
0.0268704221,
-0.0126482723,
0.0391709208,
0.0363884717,
-0.0553101674,
0.0425878763,
0.0147793656,
0.0839841217,
0.035597831,
-0.0155437421,
-0.0064118141,
-0.0255128127,
-0.0253987554,
-0.0049723941,
0.0759020597,
0.0137976082,
0.01323683,
-0.0090084299,
-0.0694200993,
0.0292111095,
0.027905805,
0.0011603393,
0.0814787,
0.0204515178,
-0.0057578511,
0.0652391389,
-0.0668506101,
-0.0056554251,
-0.016584944,
0.0108452039,
-0.0057244771,
0.0110369995,
-0.004538422,
0.0040728389,
0.0386137031,
0.0086097727,
0.0142428325,
-0.0051859757,
0.006210037,
0.0611423887,
-0.0113516729,
-0.0223372411,
0.0535633788,
-0.0447214171,
-0.0199469142,
0.0248780996,
0.0096726855,
-0.0109342895,
0.0250536837,
-0.0238317568,
-0.01816958,
0.0350765288,
0.0578040853,
-0.0597825013,
-0.010176165,
0.0455524996,
0.0409871899,
0.0124331061,
0.0013774603,
0.0254240893,
-0.0142803658,
-0.0191099774,
-0.0025018794,
0.0002433278,
-0.0269005559,
0.0423558764,
-0.0584890507,
-0.0096488353,
-0.046374809,
-0.0582779497,
0.0037536907,
0.0190700032,
0.0121353092,
0.0343633033,
0.0259698723,
0.0171110854,
-0.0586219132,
-0.0129234213,
0.0183060337,
0.010622954,
0.0093966527,
0.0798391178,
0.0092190485,
0.0021617822,
0.0187029056,
0.0198620874,
0.0481414981,
0.007531154,
-0.0037175561,
-0.0666505843,
0.0727018714,
0.0072589745,
0.0053165499,
-0.0029852835,
-0.011230045,
0.0341593288,
-0.0233445652,
0.0194453597,
0.0248234794,
0.0379066095,
2.46e-7,
0.0608839132,
0.0358691327,
0.0037044196,
-0.0131353708,
0.00782008,
-0.0181927625,
0.0008990755,
0.0256069489,
0.0041202256,
0.0596968234,
0.0128955059,
-0.0472700074,
0.0393702053,
-0.0293902811,
-0.076055795,
-0.0446030535,
0.0172546748,
-0.0534167401,
-0.0612334348,
0.0584193468,
0.1007767692,
0.0244191419,
0.0341476314,
-0.0323952436,
-0.0486869738,
-0.0068029892,
0.0082888622,
0.0370742083,
0.0472170562,
0.0249898396,
0.0857440829,
-0.0161698479,
-0.0064010886,
0.0665404201,
0.0067000478,
0.0398870558,
0.0678324997,
0.0151893348,
-0.0615101829,
0.0553055853,
0.027503144,
-0.0185478367,
-0.0199352279,
-0.0481352583,
0.0442915224,
-0.0080810925,
-0.0095845629,
-0.0074530346,
-0.0506930687,
0.0287029184,
0.0070479866,
0.0230381917,
-0.0329607315,
0.0267245527,
0.0243235007,
-0.0414879248,
-0.0592168309,
-0.0311734714,
0.0324053764,
-0.012889564,
0.0088676224,
-0.0399311148,
0.0288556907,
0.0068245684,
0.0581376441,
-0.0509179682,
-0.0018053274,
2.241110056e-34,
0.0168670435,
0.0111095663,
-0.0254775975,
-0.0115377903,
-0.016746914,
0.0034747291,
0.0607114509,
0.0160143934,
-0.0757548064,
-0.0296699386,
0.0100969253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13734v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13734v2 | The CHiME-7 DASR Challenge: Distant Meeting Transcription with Multiple Devices in Diverse Scenarios | 2023-06-23T18:49:20 | 2023-07-14T09:45:21 | Samuele Cornell, Matthew Wiesner, Shinji Watanabe, Desh Raj, Xuankai Chang, Paola Garcia, Matthew Maciejewski, Yoshiki Masuyama, Zhong-Qiu Wang, Stefano Squartini, Sanjeev Khudanpur | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | The CHiME challenges have played a significant role in the development and
evaluation of robust automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems. We introduce
the CHiME-7 distant ASR (DASR) task, within the 7th CHiME challenge. This task
comprises joint ASR and diarization in far-field settings with multiple, and
possibly heterogeneous, recording devices. Different from previous challenges,
we evaluate systems on 3 diverse scenarios: CHiME-6, DiPCo, and Mixer 6. The
goal is for participants to devise a single system that can generalize across
different array geometries and use cases with no a-priori information. Another
departure from earlier CHiME iterations is that participants are allowed to use
open-source pre-trained models and datasets. In this paper, we describe the
challenge design, motivation, and fundamental research questions in detail. We
also present the baseline system, which is fully array-topology agnostic and
features multi-channel diarization, channel selection, guided source separation
and a robust ASR model that leverages self-supervised speech representations
(SSLR). | [
-0.0160272773,
0.0086347181,
0.035035979,
-0.0065104575,
-0.0054985927,
-0.0101668863,
0.0981198102,
-0.0108676022,
0.0322862864,
0.0197177865,
-0.07619486,
0.0224180687,
0.0264452491,
0.0279987622,
0.006328559,
0.0016434691,
-0.0148515506,
-0.094866313,
-0.0778296366,
-0.0501753837,
-0.024866607,
-0.0122967325,
-0.0565089844,
0.0186884776,
-0.0449651107,
0.0227311496,
-0.0083619924,
0.0198155921,
-0.0134796919,
-0.0336676762,
0.0159303918,
0.0405596532,
0.049420394,
0.0295850039,
0.0000019742,
-0.0044753738,
-0.0451276824,
-0.0043694116,
-0.0693445653,
-0.0111149196,
-0.010742534,
0.0271576177,
-0.0203937273,
0.0213383324,
0.0014864578,
-0.0569641218,
0.0323371701,
-0.0191862714,
0.0377198644,
0.0043767211,
0.0105674742,
-0.0736255646,
-0.0122160492,
-0.0333648473,
-0.0157928355,
-0.0103693437,
-0.0315985978,
-0.0144137647,
0.0011893433,
-0.0543002859,
0.0326682702,
0.0432892442,
0.0117001962,
-0.010524598,
0.0884973556,
0.002741023,
-0.0475132801,
-0.027660843,
-0.0190087911,
0.0589056127,
0.0472998805,
-0.0316655561,
0.0616970658,
0.0087623978,
-0.0263692867,
-0.0375815071,
-0.0185092967,
-0.0422072262,
-0.0058943047,
-0.0190988481,
-0.0670730993,
0.0498209484,
0.0187007673,
-0.0260987375,
-0.0147724031,
0.0086069982,
0.0044469889,
-0.0408505462,
-0.0350357704,
-0.0124692619,
0.0479332134,
0.0051107691,
0.0498555936,
-0.0231400747,
-0.0222730488,
-0.023593694,
0.0292688664,
-0.0397456065,
-0.0132991355,
-0.0431290604,
0.0439821929,
0.0330356695,
-0.043895077,
0.0132006034,
0.0217290707,
-0.0101639656,
0.0307834446,
-0.022636747,
-0.0253370088,
0.0485072471,
-0.0051959641,
0.0118427882,
-0.0166712701,
0.0256820563,
-0.0120765204,
-0.0485858209,
-0.0256139506,
-0.0009338075,
-0.0164839774,
0.0063968287,
0.0423755199,
0.0196718108,
-0.0377953649,
-0.0382204354,
0.0738942325,
0.0135430861,
-0.0279012788,
0.0648536906,
-0.004737847,
-0.0640467405,
-0.0606986508,
0.029407125,
0.0467396602,
0.0059316992,
-0.0354088768,
0.0689699203,
-0.0016744455,
-0.044552695,
0.0015184631,
0.0094294278,
-0.0367200263,
-0.0343824774,
0.029741032,
-0.055634167,
0.0244054198,
0.0024487104,
-0.0185617264,
-0.0260513127,
0.0162289608,
-0.0419218764,
0.061530333,
0.0611450002,
-0.0062604868,
-0.004904577,
0.0902176797,
-0.0094434815,
-0.0477857515,
0.0157558229,
0.0405509397,
-0.0066434899,
0.0053186039,
-0.0664726049,
-0.0151494574,
0.0561932139,
-0.0007637183,
-0.011783286,
-0.0065250788,
0.0442405678,
0.045843441,
0.0349136181,
-0.008114133,
-0.0101700267,
-0.0246254839,
0.0060863011,
0.0264416467,
0.0779243186,
0.0517369695,
-0.0224990398,
0.014040024,
-0.0130440528,
0.0074243522,
-0.0347468406,
-0.0170845576,
-0.0106162308,
-0.0081827445,
-0.0130530978,
0.0695808455,
0.0429324135,
-0.0196939986,
0.002867792,
0.0111880694,
-0.0393633917,
-0.0424997471,
0.0420645699,
0.0521574356,
-0.0480697714,
-0.0089512663,
0.0054475013,
-0.0096309809,
-0.0925268978,
-0.0085178316,
0.0324024223,
0.0417404585,
0.0097795893,
-0.0043521994,
-0.0719242096,
-0.0371445417,
-0.024302261,
-0.016318433,
0.0218447093,
0.0304418597,
-0.0104896417,
0.0861900151,
-0.0044466397,
-0.0492084175,
0.0521752536,
-0.0042588152,
0.0400502793,
-0.0051058172,
-0.0061752098,
-0.0006435061,
-0.0130205173,
0.0486770421,
0.001091542,
-0.0267131235,
-0.0566477217,
0.0070836577,
0.008964967,
0.0783111304,
0.0333566666,
-0.0281567425,
0.0072007985,
0.0301182065,
-0.0580011457,
0.0144993002,
0.0112330541,
-0.0702487454,
-0.0319993608,
0.0279223882,
-0.0194333643,
-0.0239409339,
0.0334917754,
0.0163457394,
-0.040523719,
0.0806952268,
-0.0274361242,
-0.0172931254,
-0.0402796902,
0.0505449958,
0.029582724,
0.0148492903,
0.0160091296,
-0.0165660437,
0.0222728606,
-0.0115746493,
-0.0469681136,
-0.0128778908,
0.0277811643,
-0.0373796597,
0.0468560569,
-0.0062555545,
0.0053655282,
0.0103183901,
-0.0027035293,
0.0132064624,
-0.0401922576,
-0.0300096124,
-0.040931087,
-0.0140485577,
-0.029261373,
0.026840467,
-0.0457727462,
0.0001739389,
0.0110830246,
-0.0376609862,
-0.0224085394,
-0.0122176213,
-0.0197182931,
-0.0170123503,
-0.0755677149,
0.0055569941,
-0.046666082,
-0.0285286568,
-0.0295672491,
0.0429641344,
0.0226252601,
0.0119903367,
-0.021570893,
-0.015959572,
-0.0275417771,
-0.0000933172,
0.0336299278,
-0.0071844151,
0.0318602733,
0.0292520858,
0.0035903754,
0.0023447338,
0.0233633835,
0.0169962849,
0.001326832,
0.0257259198,
-0.0039075315,
-0.0381122455,
-0.0021161032,
0.0370571353,
0.0588072054,
-0.0065590991,
0.0588710606,
-0.0106109343,
-0.0378246568,
0.031875737,
0.033049576,
-0.0238384828,
0.0115538463,
0.0047487891,
-0.0954206511,
-0.010249286,
-0.011189553,
-0.0156959612,
-0.0113890897,
0.0079282718,
-0.0068575102,
0.0044256374,
-0.059476357,
-0.0419861339,
-0.0236427244,
-0.0711912066,
-0.014411659,
0.0156541709,
-0.0404752418,
-0.0236111376,
-0.0311778486,
-0.0244947225,
0.0258151069,
-0.0405169651,
-0.0041728527,
-0.0521974191,
0.020411171,
-0.0182290561,
0.0401008241,
0.0046433057,
-0.0636842102,
-0.0127688665,
0.0189661607,
0.0143755944,
-0.0021982456,
-0.0417129993,
-0.0205436759,
-0.0112641808,
0.0566628352,
0.0083671622,
0.0687933266,
0.0178363416,
0.0234504193,
-0.0442762822,
0.0639160126,
0.0028308637,
0.0227251276,
0.0377943181,
-0.0235877503,
0.0228016861,
-0.0193789899,
0.0751168057,
0.014014869,
-0.0316827036,
0.0326564535,
0.0547906049,
0.0175450947,
-0.0349872783,
0.0187927596,
0.0681908205,
0.0044169854,
-0.0217059162,
0.0913996696,
-0.0099111944,
-0.0880617127,
0.0116254678,
0.0057846606,
0.0127993636,
-0.0048712608,
-0.0164184514,
0.0016913062,
0.0156777836,
0.0604694076,
0.0436394438,
0.0447486006,
0.0335702524,
-0.0346239693,
-0.0764824748,
0.021715248,
0.0393521935,
-0.0014361831,
-0.082762748,
-0.0330770575,
-0.0376544818,
-0.027549576,
0.0923700258,
0.0070157773,
-0.0287319869,
-0.0411406346,
0.0297106411,
-0.0834341049,
-0.0457529202,
0.0024635962,
-0.0207199827,
0.0888457596,
0.0490910187,
-0.0425267331,
0.0254071932,
-0.0122302137,
0.0015576239,
-0.0156919938,
0.0226083621,
-0.0250154119,
0.0271385182,
0.0193005204,
0.0222996641,
0.0646316186,
0.0108378669,
-0.0543829054,
0.010948292,
0.0471281596,
0.0333274081,
-0.0281498563,
0.009589632,
0.0612842627,
0.0544352643,
0.0105595998,
0.0552925467,
0.026303295,
0.0032169293,
-0.0049429946,
0.0358980149,
0.0557665005,
-0.0149512002,
0.0370090939,
-0.030523371,
0.0063991342,
-0.0741273388,
-0.0045584105,
-0.0040474245,
0.0294617489,
0.0156989768,
0.0120959012,
-0.0044800681,
-0.0226431862,
0.0543840751,
0.0167050567,
0.0092718247,
0.001300074,
-0.016495619,
-0.0222686753,
-0.0118516106,
0.0316679999,
-0.0493308268,
0.0130004436,
0.0503236465,
-0.0801361427,
-0.0380812362,
0.0520758852,
-0.0128464932,
0.0241588987,
0.0370641612,
-0.0131146628,
-0.0006279391,
-0.0019062243,
-0.0078212954,
-0.0252741184,
0.0876048207,
0.0538643785,
-0.0297637247,
-0.011299205,
0.0294053331,
-0.0669519529,
0.0717093796,
-0.0268884897,
0.0160105135,
-0.0377141796,
-0.0410590731,
0.0057913526,
-0.0144483307,
0.0541349202,
0.0057873363,
-0.0003572834,
-0.0209202003,
0.032649532,
-0.0647057295,
0.0518950671,
-0.0258615501,
0.0082735708,
-0.0329582319,
0.045001097,
-0.0121919038,
0.0520773605,
-0.0514720045,
0.0313134305,
-0.0350056067,
0.0622682013,
0.0394071117,
-0.0406059474,
-0.0171003472,
0.0077481656,
-0.0140693281,
0.0479434803,
0.0006568976,
-0.0268808864,
-0.0352238119,
-0.0009667774,
-0.0109255351,
0.0487272367,
0.0048046624,
0.0323736966,
-0.0585712977,
-0.0259104706,
0.0216022059,
0.03177277,
0.0110424645,
0.0360331982,
0.0382303633,
0.0207525976,
0.0225834046,
-0.0159435272,
0.0164627489,
-0.0146666467,
0.0517981462,
-0.0063155582,
0.0168596394,
-0.0224343017,
0.0252627973,
0.0135095753,
-0.0440729409,
0.0371192284,
-0.0090957126,
0.0667848364,
-0.0671624318,
-0.061770536,
0.0145999528,
-0.0014343632,
-0.0332898721,
-0.0306131952,
-0.0011880301,
-0.0564730279,
0.0378246121,
-0.0280266553,
-0.0101377713,
-0.022489978,
0.0048912219,
0.0127957538,
-0.0135921137,
0.0089196619,
0.0683041215,
-0.0395554975,
-0.0211713817,
-0.0468252413,
0.0128140869,
-6.786954672e-33,
-0.0189152118,
0.0411348008,
-0.0176101141,
-0.0356186405,
-0.0262972098,
0.0092297141,
-0.0252873022,
0.0137420297,
0.0078239897,
-0.0372150168,
-0.0216270778,
0.0352891162,
0.0430360809,
-0.0135724908,
0.0223945044,
0.007650895,
0.0993691832,
-0.051446639,
-0.0004998129,
-0.0241024084,
0.0355051644,
0.0690199658,
-0.0325712748,
-0.0924859494,
-0.0350076929,
0.0366237424,
-0.0334565267,
-0.02679497,
0.000196523,
-0.0096041365,
-0.0027977712,
0.0126218377,
-0.0512426607,
-0.01834343,
-0.0049406313,
0.0073858327,
-0.1081973016,
-0.0286628306,
-0.044212278,
0.0225679167,
0.0407091007,
-0.0448828787,
-0.0099101532,
0.0075828903,
-0.0989364386,
-0.010621733,
0.021325212,
0.0166713335,
-0.026730828,
-0.0026128674,
0.0602916069,
0.0216614865,
-0.0348321311,
-0.0401252918,
0.0565640517,
0.0221369267,
-0.0143546201,
-0.0215377901,
-0.048696246,
0.0700713173,
-0.0191976838,
0.0210873503,
0.0148923546,
0.0142113101,
0.0352308601,
0.0647746101,
0.1020977646,
-0.0548899658,
0.0179783516,
-0.0885178149,
-0.0228870492,
0.0265435372,
-0.0162780173,
0.0095804334,
0.0165437013,
-0.0155021604,
-0.0261909049,
-0.0172028691,
0.0399382785,
-0.0526573807,
0.0041875946,
0.0369318686,
-0.0209923349,
0.019732777,
-0.0204352494,
-0.0164842103,
-0.009582323,
-0.0076388759,
0.0227473378,
0.0143094957,
-0.0038526936,
-0.0156046068,
0.0451836064,
0.0030297078,
0.0698454753,
0.0694746971,
0.0349648558,
-0.0017267484,
0.0112362113,
0.0105255032,
-0.0116095077,
-0.0287836641,
0.069027774,
0.0354060605,
0.0379718728,
-0.0626458824,
-0.0377124809,
0.077478908,
-0.0233752001,
-0.0233773477,
0.0309508145,
0.0321625359,
-0.0019167017,
-0.0050397646,
0.033524286,
-0.0199585147,
-0.0011259575,
0.0138289966,
0.0002519764,
0.0374540724,
0.0269817859,
0.0171297677,
0.0017727175,
0.0298393629,
-0.0116009424,
0.0260617528,
-0.0145430285,
-0.0305935889,
0.0928153545,
0.0002051124,
-0.0045460551,
-0.0283739213,
2.991e-7,
-0.0338829197,
0.0193279069,
0.0563232638,
-0.0343904942,
0.0041114553,
0.0068214866,
-0.001000146,
0.0331085213,
-0.0505364574,
0.0346617848,
0.0158803202,
0.027776625,
0.0854818076,
0.0036236467,
-0.0561144277,
-0.0016544992,
-0.0680649281,
0.0407029651,
0.0068832254,
0.017815819,
-0.0176414978,
0.0382875279,
-0.0047189719,
-0.0438493714,
-0.002191935,
0.0016496681,
0.0063730478,
0.002447865,
0.0149194812,
-0.0374733843,
-0.0355552658,
-0.1136405915,
-0.036075443,
0.006530175,
0.0009179807,
0.0030033558,
0.0251293406,
0.0302003622,
-0.0001982491,
-0.077158317,
0.0027806938,
0.074508816,
-0.0128672197,
0.0148440003,
0.0421478897,
0.013655819,
-0.0341569372,
-0.014685493,
-0.0598892234,
0.007755002,
-0.0069380165,
0.000558764,
0.0358336382,
0.0039350749,
-0.0328315757,
0.0075344583,
0.0257134493,
-0.0298185907,
-0.0037851804,
0.0365277715,
-0.0624750964,
-0.0171508454,
0.0073365364,
0.0074881995,
0.0366421305,
-0.0285178553,
0.0256064702,
2.060583741e-34,
0.0416207574,
-0.0096774669,
-0.0054478124,
-0.0315028429,
-0.0147938216,
-0.0876767859,
-0.0093586417,
0.0032771165,
0.0304408856,
-0.0438042469,
-0.0151026389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13651v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13651v2 | Bring Your Own Data! Self-Supervised Evaluation for Large Language Models | 2023-06-23T17:59:09 | 2023-06-29T17:30:45 | Neel Jain, Khalid Saifullah, Yuxin Wen, John Kirchenbauer, Manli Shu, Aniruddha Saha, Micah Goldblum, Jonas Geiping, Tom Goldstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | With the rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) and their ubiquitous deployment
in diverse domains, measuring language model behavior on realistic data is
imperative. For example, a company deploying a client-facing chatbot must
ensure that the model will not respond to client requests with profanity.
Current evaluations approach this problem using small, domain-specific datasets
with human-curated labels. These evaluation sets are often sampled from a
narrow and simplified distribution, and data sources can unknowingly be leaked
into the training set which can lead to misleading evaluations. To bypass these
drawbacks, we propose a framework for self-supervised evaluation of LLMs by
analyzing their sensitivity or invariance to transformations on the input text.
Self-supervised evaluation can directly monitor LLM behavior on datasets
collected in the wild or streamed during live model deployment. We demonstrate
self-supervised evaluation strategies for measuring closed-book knowledge,
toxicity, and long-range context dependence, in addition to sensitivity to
grammatical structure and tokenization errors. When comparisons to similar
human-labeled benchmarks are available, we find strong correlations between
self-supervised and human-supervised evaluations. The self-supervised paradigm
complements current evaluation strategies that rely on labeled data. | [
0.0482070595,
0.0705047473,
-0.0193845276,
0.0406696387,
-0.0304461084,
0.0127055189,
0.0480594225,
0.010768122,
0.0368211567,
-0.0753499717,
-0.0746427849,
-0.0023785378,
-0.0312010087,
0.0458943248,
0.0267281123,
-0.0107487673,
0.0280168243,
-0.0223963484,
-0.0226601828,
0.0107399719,
0.0102638826,
-0.0012496482,
0.0114600947,
0.055983562,
-0.0310309976,
-0.0265439246,
0.0169113241,
0.0306726638,
-0.0234840531,
-0.0024235458,
0.0224935729,
0.0710283965,
-0.0092147402,
0.0485619009,
0.0000019062,
-0.0670719072,
-0.0296770632,
0.0021343278,
-0.023473734,
0.0427410938,
0.0953328758,
-0.0217186399,
-0.0295145717,
0.0301614441,
-0.0416928269,
-0.0037365186,
0.0394785218,
0.0114925355,
0.0862097591,
0.077290915,
0.0007808086,
0.0024604776,
-0.0131245013,
-0.0124235377,
-0.0312968604,
-0.0342850685,
0.0278730467,
0.00694932,
-0.0163273234,
-0.0002165624,
-0.0151645085,
0.0274149776,
0.0192265175,
-0.0214211028,
0.0253727641,
0.0112273758,
-0.0684952959,
-0.0174902566,
-0.0062917466,
0.0781844333,
-0.0041875066,
-0.0378003903,
0.0051600304,
-0.0007112796,
0.0029554509,
-0.0063364976,
-0.0131103313,
0.0082556186,
0.0359002501,
0.0054033068,
-0.0329586528,
0.0075462898,
0.021226313,
0.0137358615,
-0.0084555792,
0.0713258684,
0.0120642968,
-0.0192536749,
-0.00540845,
-0.0036898216,
0.0045085656,
-0.0398923308,
-0.0082170973,
-0.0095362393,
-0.0170742534,
0.0276524983,
-0.0546703488,
-0.0271852165,
0.025136739,
-0.0588256046,
0.0301631689,
-0.0009762187,
-0.0417965055,
0.0535145961,
-0.0224245638,
0.0476477183,
0.0254439637,
0.0536458902,
-0.0236743055,
0.0107112713,
-0.0419507436,
0.0151536791,
-0.0279497877,
0.0215015989,
0.0135665862,
0.0068599116,
-0.0524184406,
0.0270470828,
-0.020216288,
0.0059723528,
0.0329990014,
0.0038618122,
-0.0408150591,
-0.0271239951,
-0.0144536812,
-0.0243640672,
-0.0111291343,
0.0099730305,
-0.0030827087,
-0.0851817057,
0.0060605584,
0.0172102246,
-0.0407191999,
-0.0209653359,
0.0008738693,
0.1189747304,
0.015060476,
-0.0306671355,
-0.0342749245,
-0.0219462328,
-0.0630735904,
-0.0435736813,
-0.0307730604,
-0.0638066828,
-0.0228233393,
0.0053592855,
0.0007883377,
-0.0681888685,
-0.0012420558,
-0.0121827135,
-0.0039891214,
0.0858798549,
0.0001968237,
0.0104356166,
0.0164681971,
0.0205681883,
-0.0218989458,
0.1082937568,
0.03849902,
0.0246291477,
0.0497676693,
-0.0084387707,
0.0240508206,
0.0597768351,
0.0143049508,
0.0348013341,
-0.0731581524,
0.0130286533,
0.0087107057,
0.0225649215,
0.0122894254,
0.0638169423,
0.0087996516,
-0.0296383351,
0.0750310495,
0.0441993326,
-0.0014613939,
-0.0007725874,
0.0507322773,
0.0128646595,
0.0044597932,
0.0185505264,
-0.0550921671,
-0.023109518,
-0.0280650258,
-0.0237727053,
0.0342536792,
0.0041135876,
-0.0144082103,
-0.0655947253,
-0.0172134824,
-0.0220886096,
0.0102495449,
-0.0158797633,
0.0526470356,
0.0377306379,
0.007125041,
0.0311044063,
0.0377643183,
-0.0597381629,
-0.0146310795,
-0.0449412018,
-0.0026428467,
0.0728897527,
0.0528093688,
-0.040984083,
-0.0150076114,
-0.0170424748,
0.0306437612,
0.0444258712,
0.031618081,
0.0000480534,
0.0059679803,
-0.0224695783,
-0.0199355278,
0.0035670642,
0.0381021723,
-0.0053225248,
0.0265006311,
0.0250769705,
0.0115542663,
-0.0896696076,
-0.0612369068,
0.0592148826,
-0.0148015246,
-0.04990438,
0.0248149242,
0.0027989848,
0.044093404,
-0.0145803848,
-0.0247064792,
-0.0039723525,
0.0261800811,
-0.0128691914,
-0.015110787,
-0.0116165187,
-0.0391338356,
-0.0148906121,
0.048908174,
-0.0283229481,
-0.0352862403,
0.0599552169,
-0.0416899361,
-0.0199387595,
0.017246088,
-0.0390816629,
0.0219819508,
-0.0297468118,
0.0132817794,
-0.020390816,
0.0255141053,
-0.0352840684,
0.0262170471,
0.00599143,
-0.0079117492,
-0.0259578153,
-0.0083470596,
0.0114738001,
0.0071294615,
-0.0520377606,
-0.0122830374,
-0.0259025954,
0.03406021,
0.0246721115,
0.0302612297,
-0.0576867387,
-0.0136046959,
-0.0721275061,
-0.0122179398,
-0.0355671383,
0.0104985656,
0.0453264639,
0.0018311439,
-0.0186106525,
-0.0262653511,
-0.0269641895,
-0.0337531306,
-0.0005972573,
0.0330346078,
0.0305315834,
-0.0128818769,
-0.0276995245,
-0.0534794256,
-0.0021574174,
-0.0175775681,
0.0572556704,
-0.00218845,
0.003937027,
-0.0366043448,
0.0354609489,
-0.0131811127,
0.0252484642,
0.0144577371,
-0.0826739147,
0.0268684886,
0.0111898752,
0.014630219,
0.0694525316,
0.0245656818,
0.0259468611,
0.0643137917,
0.0234979577,
-0.0720424876,
-0.0313590206,
0.0001154181,
-0.0518559553,
-0.0362138301,
-0.0183009971,
-0.0073927119,
0.056134861,
-0.0026750118,
-0.0160433874,
-0.0440928377,
0.0176676326,
-0.0544928536,
-0.059207201,
-0.0455719121,
-0.0090014506,
-0.02743119,
0.0338501371,
0.0094186943,
-0.0741328895,
0.0815767497,
-0.0392719954,
0.0119222226,
-0.0204906464,
-0.0388095155,
-0.0209917817,
0.0711848959,
-0.0014656987,
0.0160634965,
0.0303318389,
-0.022969177,
-0.0536787808,
0.013940732,
0.0400810279,
-0.0304062068,
0.0426032692,
-0.0629918128,
0.0167561695,
0.0331410542,
-0.0348558687,
-0.0713938475,
-0.0673026592,
-0.0373595469,
-0.0209347811,
0.0370820239,
-0.0073738103,
-0.0152946794,
0.0320317708,
0.0005536944,
0.025203852,
-0.0005443809,
-0.0177590102,
0.0144909956,
-0.0086271958,
0.0327822082,
0.0019021152,
0.0046135504,
-0.0070832279,
0.029318884,
0.0588241257,
0.025385363,
-0.0013421671,
-0.0507871471,
0.0127574718,
0.002992118,
-0.0193838123,
0.0183895025,
0.0169587359,
0.0398065485,
-0.0404556915,
-0.0227808636,
0.1210593581,
0.0215368401,
-0.0529801287,
0.024958415,
-0.0067717494,
0.0368731208,
0.0243141707,
0.012281293,
-0.0834189728,
-0.0246946905,
0.0092884609,
0.0399364121,
-0.0090975221,
-0.0412809253,
0.01388238,
-0.1370195001,
0.022032598,
0.0011264115,
-0.0315733328,
-0.0050260038,
-0.0425619148,
0.0057077743,
-0.0619822666,
0.0173027664,
-0.0229281224,
-0.0126784071,
-0.0178521797,
0.0209242851,
-0.0650155693,
-0.0777098909,
0.0514564998,
-0.039206557,
0.0783692598,
0.0332379043,
0.0032334619,
-0.0189417191,
-0.0001865619,
0.0591775514,
0.0199652538,
-0.0121611804,
0.0152994879,
0.072487995,
-0.0270079337,
-0.0099114738,
0.0235103145,
0.0178624708,
-0.0380675234,
0.0207432639,
0.0113663077,
0.0509122573,
0.0071010003,
-0.0034173252,
-0.0216653422,
-0.0023000466,
0.0313741043,
0.0842751861,
0.0454403609,
-0.0668669716,
-0.0246089306,
-0.031797871,
-0.0102400631,
-0.0012060899,
-0.0747317225,
0.01978199,
-0.0215434767,
-0.0515050553,
-0.0934834182,
-0.0320270956,
0.0279795714,
0.017786013,
0.0143178105,
-0.0181584023,
-0.0018519269,
0.0073220059,
-0.0043504043,
0.0323351622,
-0.0463199653,
0.0061407043,
-0.0860418007,
-0.0081869233,
0.03808631,
0.0021942358,
-0.0145769082,
0.0422493406,
-0.0585001074,
-0.073639676,
0.0522338971,
0.0525445193,
0.0206625145,
0.0458468609,
-0.0480125099,
-0.0499371029,
0.0555319265,
0.0598997064,
-0.0837754607,
-0.0033707609,
0.0511050001,
-0.0145482225,
0.0038910913,
0.0438237563,
-0.0616645217,
0.0565529838,
0.0189370085,
0.0001118255,
-0.0330439471,
-0.0725415051,
0.0291587003,
0.0255836491,
0.06278532,
-0.032440979,
-0.0274454616,
-0.0070859175,
0.0024705385,
-0.032123737,
-0.0347339064,
-0.043962799,
0.0126489904,
0.01759197,
0.0033937362,
-0.0088080531,
0.0044417977,
-0.0564148203,
0.0270013046,
-0.0168536957,
-0.0035492168,
0.0372027904,
0.0059569483,
0.0133889923,
0.020327935,
-0.0054608118,
0.0020086605,
0.0153751122,
0.0225323234,
0.0051527396,
-0.0041681048,
0.0186251346,
0.0304543711,
0.0228790659,
0.0526124686,
-0.0451399349,
0.0075425808,
-0.0410476774,
0.0109661287,
0.026177384,
-0.0147779277,
0.0674922243,
-0.0324734226,
0.0017920877,
-0.0379713587,
0.023328647,
-0.0242004897,
-0.0085554346,
-0.0034411729,
0.0119708851,
-0.0462158844,
0.0374277234,
0.084351711,
0.066110827,
0.0339810736,
0.0103445966,
0.0003902719,
-0.0418750532,
0.0080170995,
-0.0083523579,
-0.0105832824,
-0.0203689076,
-0.0093648583,
-0.0559795499,
-0.1030154675,
-0.0182762071,
0.0251349621,
-0.0015767049,
0.0011172396,
0.0389664248,
0.0662405789,
-0.0050386204,
0.0270814653,
-0.0570653267,
0.0045961798,
0.038841024,
-0.034657456,
-0.0161239542,
-6.388256376e-33,
-0.018649241,
-0.0331441648,
-0.0069715618,
-0.0087264348,
0.0172623433,
-0.0106643941,
-0.0036277759,
0.0376022905,
0.0132197421,
0.0219809934,
-0.0076796105,
0.0209016502,
0.0115352124,
0.0025053164,
0.0326613449,
-0.0160933938,
0.0353820287,
-0.0434520133,
-0.0382792428,
0.0147701567,
0.0091304351,
0.0372122563,
0.0365779847,
-0.1063762829,
0.0202271622,
0.0064801485,
-0.0293729473,
-0.0065817637,
0.0024782256,
0.0776800141,
-0.0031958346,
0.0592892505,
0.0070796395,
-0.0346052162,
-0.0118787652,
-0.0206248537,
-0.04752611,
-0.0088779815,
-0.0015176517,
0.0268526096,
-0.0296441428,
-0.005108967,
0.068245858,
-0.0053510489,
-0.0361110196,
0.008109333,
0.0468660519,
-0.0245110039,
0.0026944166,
0.0096913874,
-0.0526109971,
0.0267554205,
-0.0253502931,
-0.0378901921,
0.0321191587,
0.0266378205,
-0.0026404958,
0.0160415173,
-0.0333425403,
0.0123554589,
-0.0097511113,
0.0324894898,
0.0823511332,
0.0003465805,
0.0123701859,
0.0650671571,
-0.0005894665,
0.0409620106,
0.0063557429,
-0.0461731181,
0.0533061549,
0.048655007,
0.0182842594,
0.0667045563,
-0.0044076839,
-0.0203308724,
-0.0561492853,
0.027683476,
-0.0042485609,
0.0037813853,
-0.0059358333,
0.0084947869,
-0.0507805645,
-0.013902301,
-0.0131552946,
0.0053527891,
-0.0270849317,
-0.0385939851,
0.0476316288,
-0.0188761931,
-0.0430357903,
-0.0373642817,
0.0043253712,
-0.0603807904,
-0.0344461799,
-0.0061824205,
-0.0152355414,
0.0084479423,
0.0188481733,
0.0486339554,
-0.0298192557,
0.0097008925,
0.0123787299,
0.0119065745,
0.0423110835,
-0.016075151,
0.0516002811,
0.0275141075,
-0.068170324,
0.0081659267,
-0.0272994321,
0.0167615861,
-0.0089694615,
0.0241266657,
0.0079689063,
-0.0136098312,
-0.0203484129,
0.0503808521,
0.0149500286,
-0.0069028814,
-0.02301443,
0.0049900478,
-0.0020428279,
-0.004113046,
-0.0495793559,
-0.0335247666,
-0.0131300688,
0.0263211261,
0.0667967722,
-0.0230495278,
-0.0053756405,
-0.0121004852,
2.731e-7,
0.057234101,
0.0596680455,
-0.0115289968,
0.0163220782,
0.0174654815,
0.0542284027,
-0.0260924175,
0.0367848612,
0.0033914994,
-0.0514831059,
0.0072120586,
0.0062318025,
0.0817948058,
0.0408959351,
-0.0701026842,
-0.0055663404,
-0.084744595,
0.0234498437,
-0.0382717475,
-0.0217331816,
0.0314478725,
0.118131645,
0.0399936363,
-0.0080208182,
-0.0245090425,
-0.0494402349,
0.0188711509,
-0.0483281054,
-0.0133443493,
0.0235728491,
0.0513395853,
0.0477456748,
0.0159776006,
0.0131001398,
-0.0222061258,
-0.0221100524,
0.0187855773,
0.0601107292,
0.0098719317,
-0.0105305407,
-0.0096238367,
-0.0173755419,
-0.0108302897,
-0.043386329,
0.0766277462,
-0.0360414237,
-0.0073566702,
-0.0137771964,
-0.0012313384,
-0.0441388711,
0.0546654798,
-0.0277917013,
-0.0272080284,
0.0337866321,
0.0378776304,
-0.0158508848,
-0.0197140872,
-0.0603162758,
-0.0291222259,
-0.0101849083,
-0.0312114824,
-0.0373726487,
-0.0046386993,
-0.0015442735,
-0.0056459275,
-0.0418915413,
0.0425884053,
2.3909888e-34,
0.0283517875,
-0.0119982129,
0.0177126676,
-0.0035912714,
0.0272509325,
0.0064898515,
0.0042948681,
-0.0009984286,
-0.0136850979,
-0.0530314296,
0.0115784332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13649v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13649v3 | On-Policy Distillation of Language Models: Learning from Self-Generated Mistakes | 2023-06-23T17:56:26 | 2024-01-17T03:23:23 | Rishabh Agarwal, Nino Vieillard, Yongchao Zhou, Piotr Stanczyk, Sabela Ramos, Matthieu Geist, Olivier Bachem | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Knowledge distillation (KD) is widely used for compressing a teacher model to
reduce its inference cost and memory footprint, by training a smaller student
model. However, current KD methods for auto-regressive sequence models suffer
from distribution mismatch between output sequences seen during training and
those generated by the student during inference. To address this issue, we
introduce Generalized Knowledge Distillation (GKD). Instead of solely relying
on a fixed set of output sequences, GKD trains the student on its
self-generated output sequences by leveraging feedback from the teacher on such
sequences. Unlike supervised KD approaches, GKD also offers the flexibility to
employ alternative loss functions between the student and teacher, which can be
useful when the student lacks the expressivity to mimic the teacher's
distribution. Furthermore, GKD facilitates the seamless integration of
distillation with RL fine-tuning (RLHF). We demonstrate the efficacy of GKD for
distilling auto-regressive language models on summarization, translation, and
arithmetic reasoning tasks, and task-agnostic distillation for
instruction-tuning. | [
0.0152772414,
0.0713275746,
0.0045300596,
-0.003558543,
-0.028396843,
0.0212662034,
-0.0106431637,
-0.0488375314,
-0.0518124327,
-0.0265978817,
0.0244317092,
0.0035046919,
0.0104929479,
0.0066199065,
0.0296232626,
-0.0585819967,
0.0238433108,
-0.0530374944,
0.0148137016,
-0.0017889218,
-0.0023001148,
0.0072107692,
-0.0064490438,
0.0372384898,
0.0293616634,
-0.0216120724,
-0.0197204035,
-0.0209507123,
0.0074650533,
0.0090769539,
0.0103614843,
0.0759993643,
0.0362732038,
0.0051325327,
0.0000022762,
-0.026408866,
-0.0077670431,
-0.0239252876,
-0.0355920419,
0.0366287269,
-0.0015790781,
0.0040276507,
0.0380668305,
0.0111816991,
-0.0296745803,
-0.0060331807,
0.0095989127,
-0.0043278588,
0.0748794824,
0.0680616498,
0.03038349,
-0.0522931255,
0.0209672861,
-0.0523971543,
0.0193330441,
-0.0146367112,
0.0135050016,
0.0351498909,
-0.0141804684,
-0.0171812866,
-0.0608540624,
0.0361445434,
0.0266591292,
0.0000069843,
-0.0220374204,
0.0014591892,
-0.0314433873,
-0.0525338389,
0.0169576276,
0.063385725,
-0.0370444469,
-0.0338509306,
0.0363700539,
-0.0035106901,
0.0194956996,
0.0064458326,
-0.0417883471,
0.0446195528,
0.0042943014,
0.0379038751,
-0.0083217807,
-0.0125891706,
0.0136166532,
0.0014974659,
-0.0435495786,
0.0118753426,
-0.0135534955,
-0.0129720531,
-0.0241270866,
0.0078848712,
-0.0418788493,
-0.0497899055,
-0.0071859849,
0.0452570543,
0.0094754519,
0.0077012382,
-0.0585354455,
-0.0443028919,
-0.0030948303,
0.0316319615,
0.043881055,
0.0475917943,
0.0096105346,
-0.0064736386,
-0.0068201306,
0.0980494916,
0.0548414029,
0.0616328344,
-0.0337786786,
0.0351924151,
-0.0562696494,
0.0108558778,
-0.0458980873,
0.0463601686,
-0.0325923823,
0.0029993276,
-0.0533173904,
0.0043978198,
-0.0494084507,
0.0124757858,
0.0333060808,
0.0087466799,
-0.0531474203,
0.0079930276,
-0.0270958673,
0.0802246928,
-0.0267519541,
-0.0152255129,
0.046187114,
-0.0271283127,
-0.0471238568,
-0.0097039491,
0.0159833804,
0.0171097871,
-0.0055855038,
0.029888548,
-0.029487377,
-0.0358554944,
-0.0361847281,
-0.0529188327,
-0.0247898828,
-0.0934253186,
0.0162727535,
-0.0895589441,
0.0123987552,
-0.0091743609,
0.0006594863,
-0.0714708939,
0.0170556195,
-0.0044048131,
0.0157916229,
0.0376732536,
0.0375023708,
-0.0020737196,
-0.0086650839,
0.0356006958,
0.0067376797,
0.0729906633,
0.0169566367,
0.0006635151,
-0.0143642472,
-0.0115031758,
-0.0094683925,
-0.0103804609,
0.0745129511,
0.0220346432,
-0.0527328514,
-0.016926432,
-0.0228349268,
0.0119918529,
0.0645774677,
0.028546473,
-0.0406576395,
0.0444054045,
0.0580810122,
0.0329461321,
0.0167314801,
0.0079254713,
0.0273604225,
0.0320239626,
-0.0047674999,
0.0771339312,
-0.0526781529,
0.0140403248,
0.0139759248,
0.0462105088,
0.0750919655,
0.0481409729,
-0.0369158946,
-0.0885403156,
0.0277788565,
-0.0035088747,
0.0188459698,
0.034559872,
0.05531618,
0.0521240383,
-0.0231573842,
0.0615297854,
0.0321656205,
-0.0468815416,
0.0223432947,
-0.0658927038,
0.0418119021,
0.0204663798,
0.0520068482,
-0.0267813616,
-0.022211751,
-0.0241068639,
0.0107001131,
0.0044603865,
0.015472604,
-0.0114590507,
-0.0120670302,
-0.0443866476,
-0.0517580733,
-0.0168067683,
0.0439162068,
-0.0137727279,
0.0180565361,
0.0064836591,
0.0524259694,
-0.0570704602,
-0.047861129,
0.0089898026,
-0.0564567223,
-0.0906649008,
-0.0263086054,
0.0069745774,
-0.0061881966,
0.0030998962,
-0.004941667,
0.0149950115,
0.0342183746,
-0.0213540513,
-0.0092841247,
-0.0453684926,
-0.0918722078,
-0.0930798203,
0.0421593077,
-0.0286621246,
0.0080761118,
0.0283988863,
-0.0624090359,
-0.0755450875,
0.0373824425,
-0.0087733679,
0.024852097,
-0.0228307359,
0.0282012951,
0.0332604721,
0.0039071366,
-0.0156892557,
0.037697155,
-0.0505446903,
0.0050069615,
-0.0251655318,
-0.0231261589,
-0.0392584391,
-0.0094740279,
-0.0108496835,
-0.0223288592,
-0.0120339049,
0.048970677,
0.0363169052,
0.0110150091,
-0.0274357144,
-0.0008362669,
0.0043949019,
-0.0033691588,
-0.0456987433,
0.0156168565,
0.008531739,
0.0289367586,
0.0048735808,
-0.0234965663,
-0.0265222732,
-0.029907275,
0.0227822606,
-0.0180098303,
0.0040029925,
0.0283188913,
0.0138686169,
-0.0346879065,
-0.0319972336,
0.0150558008,
0.0252358709,
-0.0592228994,
0.0389907807,
-0.0313276723,
0.0152020762,
-0.0377653055,
0.0287845638,
-0.0101840077,
-0.0340864025,
-0.0014114566,
-0.0365983471,
0.0340984538,
0.0779639035,
-0.016103318,
0.0435027182,
0.055055216,
-0.0110208178,
-0.0757591799,
0.0282957405,
-0.0385516547,
-0.0110111311,
0.0010680378,
-0.0207107235,
-0.0328623503,
0.0876907036,
-0.0067031174,
-0.0154100917,
-0.055716712,
0.0079343962,
0.0098395394,
-0.0248965044,
-0.0450835489,
0.0102370149,
-0.0048449892,
0.0198350549,
-0.0197999012,
-0.0451179035,
0.067836903,
-0.0054122666,
0.0155065805,
-0.0495586954,
-0.0102886502,
0.0004826768,
0.022109136,
0.0285489783,
0.005213635,
0.0071536107,
0.0268233102,
-0.0576821975,
-0.0113004893,
0.0640559718,
-0.0192041304,
0.0957011878,
-0.0718284324,
-0.0152100381,
-0.0044166921,
-0.0317088738,
-0.0394776985,
-0.0133493841,
0.0062440643,
0.0149986828,
0.0024214811,
-0.038276609,
-0.0457665995,
0.0104645193,
0.0203144848,
0.0542944372,
-0.0252297074,
0.002346816,
-0.028575968,
0.0147831999,
0.0578447878,
-0.0094927503,
-0.0119940285,
-0.024479799,
0.0186008308,
0.0355045348,
0.059521623,
-0.0197197217,
0.0026484667,
0.0068109147,
0.0152718248,
-0.0384007059,
-0.0025500578,
0.0529718958,
0.0633952469,
-0.0873553902,
-0.0362546407,
0.107082963,
0.0054457793,
-0.0114543904,
-0.0017320594,
0.0376854427,
0.0829132199,
0.0169157665,
0.007842741,
-0.0609260201,
-0.0375580415,
0.0019579912,
0.0446337983,
0.0290968474,
-0.0208509825,
-0.0085215485,
-0.0990994647,
-0.0013970159,
0.0373491868,
-0.0480277762,
-0.067939274,
-0.0324631557,
-0.0259035695,
-0.0235202853,
0.0140400231,
0.0152630555,
-0.037470635,
0.0404444225,
0.0587516204,
-0.0191224236,
-0.0533315949,
-0.0188488197,
0.0021857196,
0.0201440118,
0.0639467239,
0.0045658126,
0.0190104581,
-0.0511734188,
0.010762196,
0.0103889946,
-0.0022904749,
0.0163269509,
0.0323145203,
0.0042067487,
0.0048584407,
0.0012577476,
0.0653777421,
-0.0283006001,
0.0008596434,
-0.007993185,
0.0582271926,
-0.0024752223,
-0.0397724211,
-0.0198056623,
0.0005019993,
0.044808805,
0.0727256909,
0.0563415959,
-0.0070123896,
-0.0697767809,
-0.0376466662,
-0.0128825381,
-0.0392482094,
-0.0018230785,
-0.0083359247,
-0.0151950745,
-0.0209864415,
-0.0529517978,
-0.0598513894,
0.0086438172,
0.0321824215,
-0.019128859,
-0.013422831,
0.0225049797,
0.0068044965,
-0.0392905213,
-0.0123951389,
-0.0199210029,
-0.0231223758,
-0.009031116,
-0.0161380395,
-0.0212970581,
0.0067359363,
-0.0357830301,
0.0208067186,
-0.1411040872,
-0.0893180966,
0.0002331163,
0.0969199985,
0.0222861338,
0.0869660676,
0.0265722666,
-0.0123476684,
0.0840963721,
0.0219439026,
-0.0198373161,
0.0149595942,
0.0509674586,
-0.0111665083,
0.0121015208,
0.0463129804,
-0.0217458103,
0.0237391647,
-0.0086033978,
0.0685433596,
-0.0354316197,
-0.0297040213,
0.017281333,
-0.0057262955,
0.0456941836,
-0.0028668705,
0.0159945115,
-0.0158648435,
0.0068360055,
0.0258561708,
0.0028126934,
-0.0365562178,
0.0095823556,
0.0192507319,
-0.0086835939,
0.0228616931,
0.0281411894,
0.0182468835,
0.0098637687,
-0.0318606533,
0.0102132112,
0.0069819828,
0.0018740708,
0.0310159698,
-0.0026564938,
-0.0157445613,
0.0529662631,
0.004224367,
0.0362704471,
-0.013639925,
0.0448504314,
0.0359054878,
0.0699600056,
0.0102683827,
-0.0105001666,
-0.0527471974,
-0.0470858142,
-0.0390608795,
0.0280539542,
0.0436052717,
-0.0051359092,
0.0361234024,
-0.0223605838,
-0.0083988588,
-0.0127930585,
0.0392990783,
-0.0252280664,
0.0213789437,
-0.0023687964,
0.0217152964,
0.0184431411,
-0.032859914,
0.1109391749,
0.0239101741,
0.0551711321,
-0.0044760667,
0.0217285734,
-0.045880843,
-0.0705819651,
0.0062576374,
0.0260951743,
0.0175948814,
-0.0021494515,
-0.0193271842,
-0.0931940228,
-0.0373545922,
0.0309287738,
0.0086570382,
-0.0265501197,
0.0590956323,
0.0143457409,
-0.0490576252,
-0.0132733751,
-0.0403420478,
0.0123345498,
-0.0147318421,
-0.0276431367,
0.0217613969,
-6.720410672e-33,
-0.0118190767,
0.0020884133,
0.0238254759,
0.013816434,
-0.0118525736,
-0.0308093224,
-0.0306361001,
-0.0016168709,
0.0177064091,
0.0296828318,
-0.0002280901,
0.0392575674,
0.0059996494,
0.0564796925,
0.0113752941,
0.0151089979,
0.0853770226,
0.015914619,
-0.0394471027,
0.0571049042,
0.0312373918,
0.0324011818,
0.0459532887,
-0.0171300322,
0.0085408371,
-0.0215297192,
0.0222960152,
-0.0092992857,
-0.0175388325,
0.0279393252,
0.0010672134,
0.0493484363,
-0.0099015199,
-0.0570826121,
-0.0718284324,
0.0007194358,
-0.1076670066,
-0.0785109028,
0.014809614,
-0.0371306539,
-0.0404792391,
-0.024417134,
0.0575011186,
0.0077019534,
0.0045601153,
-0.0364260152,
0.0151954284,
0.0015892495,
-0.0408982448,
-0.0228569601,
-0.0302609541,
0.0011758216,
-0.0216484088,
-0.0673814192,
0.0277638715,
0.0145925572,
-0.0111575136,
-0.0276490152,
-0.0492276773,
0.018232163,
0.0637456775,
0.0886819214,
0.078809917,
0.0309967529,
-0.0145543925,
0.0171480533,
-0.0515570305,
-0.0104806842,
-0.0346133411,
-0.0152737591,
0.0426917374,
0.0522992164,
-0.0200960357,
0.0075665922,
0.0699322149,
-0.0142444214,
-0.0351779126,
0.0290426165,
-0.0146303959,
0.0577411875,
-0.0055932738,
-0.0105509926,
-0.0112062674,
-0.0429751836,
-0.0862587169,
-0.0046678549,
-0.0086354064,
-0.0054765106,
0.0401692577,
0.0480604582,
-0.0289449971,
-0.0127343833,
0.0061100321,
-0.0416390412,
0.0017738617,
0.0374239534,
-0.0256097261,
-0.0410578214,
0.003791336,
-0.0035156703,
-0.0798709616,
-0.0043937764,
0.0089283781,
0.0039682966,
-0.012017915,
0.0298263784,
0.0595783852,
0.0109707676,
-0.0381953083,
-0.0070953253,
-0.0417602658,
0.0484523214,
0.0150961988,
0.0363011472,
0.0491994545,
0.017570693,
-0.0107237985,
0.0123295346,
-0.0016254417,
-0.0314377658,
-0.0026443892,
0.0348184593,
0.0153432228,
0.025156321,
-0.0212922674,
-0.0218049325,
-0.0449552983,
0.0092440257,
0.0049657151,
-0.0511748493,
-0.0080577191,
0.0200590175,
2.862e-7,
0.0221006144,
0.0153517835,
0.0358215123,
-0.0032496729,
-0.0015478748,
0.0252055749,
-0.0050562778,
0.0122291138,
0.0126673905,
-0.0501136184,
0.0123571623,
0.0616776496,
0.0502599403,
0.0222632345,
-0.0678270459,
-0.0167806037,
-0.0508078746,
0.003596189,
-0.0229309574,
-0.0503973663,
0.0158132408,
0.0655581057,
0.0234708115,
-0.0125229349,
0.0195596144,
0.0144913988,
0.0176668223,
0.0373175964,
0.0211831573,
0.0055484469,
0.0257208105,
-0.0006977819,
-0.0031326897,
0.0163345765,
-0.0234280601,
-0.0009345993,
-0.0370420329,
0.0678832978,
0.0001307425,
-0.0290857051,
-0.0271538645,
0.0067107412,
-0.0085587958,
-0.0470927171,
0.0387267172,
-0.0638940558,
0.0276380964,
0.0123171872,
-0.0127410125,
-0.0158747509,
0.0335674994,
0.0017795456,
0.0106892716,
0.0392809063,
0.0037888428,
0.0050828396,
-0.0004431633,
-0.0599401407,
-0.0149872899,
0.0324558839,
-0.0075991568,
-0.0384640209,
-0.0601532981,
-0.0255687088,
-0.0110680936,
-0.0385132097,
-0.0080559626,
2.666408504e-34,
0.0356826372,
-0.0060674604,
0.0049016848,
-0.0294163339,
-0.0048338012,
-0.0212387852,
-0.0760962889,
0.0316955708,
0.0269635729,
-0.0608715042,
-0.047219526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13596v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13596v4 | Max-Margin Token Selection in Attention Mechanism | 2023-06-23T16:35:46 | 2023-12-08T18:56:20 | Davoud Ataee Tarzanagh, Yingcong Li, Xuechen Zhang, Samet Oymak | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.OC | Attention mechanism is a central component of the transformer architecture
which led to the phenomenal success of large language models. However, the
theoretical principles underlying the attention mechanism are poorly
understood, especially its nonconvex optimization dynamics. In this work, we
explore the seminal softmax-attention model $f(\boldsymbol{X})=\langle
\boldsymbol{Xv}, \texttt{softmax}(\boldsymbol{XWp})\rangle$, where
$\boldsymbol{X}$ is the token sequence and
$(\boldsymbol{v},\boldsymbol{W},\boldsymbol{p})$ are trainable parameters. We
prove that running gradient descent on $\boldsymbol{p}$, or equivalently
$\boldsymbol{W}$, converges in direction to a max-margin solution that
separates $\textit{locally-optimal}$ tokens from non-optimal ones. This clearly
formalizes attention as an optimal token selection mechanism. Remarkably, our
results are applicable to general data and precisely characterize
$\textit{optimality}$ of tokens in terms of the value embeddings
$\boldsymbol{Xv}$ and problem geometry. We also provide a broader
regularization path analysis that establishes the margin maximizing nature of
attention even for nonlinear prediction heads. When optimizing $\boldsymbol{v}$
and $\boldsymbol{p}$ simultaneously with logistic loss, we identify conditions
under which the regularization paths directionally converge to their respective
hard-margin SVM solutions where $\boldsymbol{v}$ separates the input features
based on their labels. Interestingly, the SVM formulation of $\boldsymbol{p}$
is influenced by the support vector geometry of $\boldsymbol{v}$. Finally, we
verify our theoretical findings via numerical experiments and provide insights. | [
0.0209744982,
0.0205453448,
-0.010659704,
0.051060494,
-0.0037886265,
0.0223617479,
-0.0028138822,
-0.0106006581,
-0.0781960562,
-0.021144785,
-0.0480639562,
-0.0146452785,
0.0075161709,
0.0115596261,
0.084576346,
-0.0391779989,
0.0373948887,
-0.0345267728,
0.0014906984,
-0.0160774533,
0.0194894616,
-0.0580107979,
0.0237778202,
0.0566652678,
-0.0272622127,
0.0152557045,
-0.0111599788,
-0.009464344,
0.0023530968,
0.0033702785,
0.0204403829,
0.0336111858,
-0.0000098531,
0.0146916872,
0.0000020267,
-0.0309153516,
-0.0206081439,
-0.0134620676,
0.0028826543,
-0.0178672578,
-0.0467247553,
-0.0457238257,
0.0014279487,
-0.0173581392,
0.0207796544,
-0.0272356048,
0.0943346024,
0.0739397407,
0.0409719236,
0.0947765037,
-0.0102832643,
-0.0409149714,
0.0200086869,
-0.0570458695,
-0.0011570139,
-0.0611984171,
0.0337442718,
-0.0932469368,
-0.0688080341,
-0.0263901744,
-0.0580694787,
0.0136240199,
-0.0026936799,
0.0351519883,
0.0600614473,
0.0525631085,
-0.0615703017,
-0.0253275838,
-0.0001152469,
0.0598860309,
-0.0632106289,
-0.0260396097,
0.0317811631,
0.0019607143,
-0.0012901508,
-0.0325749628,
-0.0405386426,
0.0194180179,
0.0210207291,
0.048024971,
0.0468967073,
-0.0077471137,
0.0081007136,
-0.0191639327,
-0.0331739075,
0.0320671126,
0.0128431926,
-0.0333208852,
0.0091817463,
0.0217418186,
-0.0613894351,
-0.0124309044,
0.0196594633,
0.0350138955,
-0.0103872837,
0.0110297166,
-0.0237435624,
-0.0637780353,
-0.0100208623,
-0.038378343,
0.0383983105,
-0.0024120358,
0.0062520062,
0.0349630527,
-0.0387054384,
0.0713882744,
-0.0360612124,
0.0675300807,
-0.0258332118,
0.0122313742,
0.011872571,
0.0071867425,
-0.0417666063,
0.0331424028,
0.0088904668,
-0.0055639013,
-0.0006193875,
0.0018175162,
-0.0174770653,
-0.0080919433,
0.0069214767,
0.0146025792,
-0.0583681241,
0.0206550024,
0.0225586127,
0.0462442189,
-0.0595701076,
0.0124580534,
-0.0163371451,
-0.001960241,
-0.0396410748,
0.0471531563,
0.0261029229,
-0.0193439405,
-0.0349619985,
0.0815410465,
-0.0274116769,
-0.016536545,
-0.0443136506,
0.0030849359,
-0.0445782728,
-0.0225770194,
0.0526587181,
-0.0157649554,
0.0205615088,
0.0229834355,
0.0075640175,
0.0110356156,
0.0004625809,
0.0032846872,
-0.0057476959,
0.021891281,
0.039839182,
-0.0059801713,
0.0092083141,
-0.0397157446,
-0.0322951674,
0.0681241155,
-0.0016477581,
0.0526606105,
0.0276141502,
-0.0050318735,
0.0027627638,
0.0419291556,
0.036702916,
0.0111638801,
-0.0400012322,
-0.018606618,
0.0543175787,
-0.0002106965,
0.0614786074,
0.0531591177,
-0.0346269049,
-0.0530371256,
0.0311332904,
0.0764493421,
0.0463927798,
0.0574634001,
0.0279263966,
-0.025046166,
-0.0228694957,
0.0529034697,
-0.0331651643,
0.0182911605,
0.0151365418,
-0.0078576664,
0.0260706078,
-0.0198407415,
-0.0484083965,
-0.0236285497,
0.0006917277,
-0.012916822,
-0.0052397,
-0.0527762994,
0.0668435097,
-0.0127361184,
-0.0482581109,
0.062051598,
0.0169337392,
-0.0073167575,
-0.0061745867,
-0.0390854254,
0.0333473049,
-0.0384874493,
-0.0259639379,
-0.0515613966,
-0.0078389198,
-0.0051740361,
-0.0222444199,
0.0106919967,
0.026881041,
0.0080249058,
-0.011971062,
-0.0096381642,
-0.0045666466,
-0.0053536235,
0.0157783013,
-0.002393791,
-0.0365773514,
-0.0061284425,
0.0164222755,
-0.0056807087,
-0.0268606748,
0.0396258794,
0.0162380897,
-0.0490450114,
-0.0070543005,
0.0442946851,
0.0544367768,
-0.0033929478,
0.0156201702,
0.0255689509,
0.0255411509,
-0.047319036,
0.0131810019,
0.0138510652,
-0.0350196399,
-0.013213072,
0.0446425341,
-0.0702702627,
0.0158416051,
0.0408047475,
-0.0138545837,
-0.0665904731,
0.0513592064,
-0.0793025568,
0.050013911,
-0.0282141585,
0.0151289329,
0.000406145,
0.0458740555,
-0.0415154696,
0.0362029485,
-0.0079774223,
0.0472953878,
-0.0022489487,
0.0020388726,
0.0007402084,
-0.0265061371,
-0.0306970663,
0.0304721743,
-0.0305212084,
0.0381402224,
0.0096182404,
-0.0295944959,
-0.0248888079,
-0.0328603983,
-0.0466392003,
-0.0109850066,
-0.0477402546,
0.0230391584,
0.0133238593,
-0.0193531364,
0.0308350809,
-0.0025304409,
-0.010337797,
0.028789917,
-0.0208565369,
0.0147472639,
0.0391840488,
-0.0017760789,
0.0221208762,
-0.0345795155,
-0.0493602343,
0.0088780783,
0.0510325916,
-0.0182544515,
-0.009802945,
-0.0684079006,
-0.0093354117,
0.0084884167,
0.032672029,
-0.018520195,
-0.0343993641,
0.0020802971,
-0.0262597576,
0.0252879523,
0.1197811961,
0.0257695392,
0.0419910327,
0.0160179548,
0.0400481373,
-0.0208654497,
0.0154340565,
-0.0481293015,
-0.0140422862,
-0.0335391127,
0.0026802849,
0.0617385842,
0.1226042062,
-0.0352279842,
-0.0377051048,
-0.0551812984,
-0.0032824771,
-0.012170244,
-0.0073417085,
0.0226956587,
0.0277684219,
-0.060910888,
0.0179624446,
-0.0251857061,
-0.0449072234,
0.0588420704,
-0.0180234425,
-0.0170964655,
-0.0464019962,
0.0002732299,
-0.0544291548,
0.0166176986,
0.0361366309,
-0.0027977957,
-0.002401677,
-0.0586868934,
-0.0368829332,
0.0018145861,
-0.0087813651,
0.0014265187,
0.0740032122,
0.0394914895,
-0.0073758918,
-0.0410703011,
-0.0046374802,
-0.0148227392,
-0.0208463501,
-0.0076009044,
0.0106633855,
0.054525923,
-0.0094795814,
-0.0442531928,
0.0303885639,
0.0370192677,
0.0540491305,
-0.0529280938,
0.0331028625,
-0.0253883339,
0.0202157963,
0.0527498275,
0.0446488596,
0.0161613189,
-0.0528578572,
-0.0114722829,
0.0541359074,
0.0491187349,
-0.0001794313,
0.0013022235,
-0.0068908134,
0.0408357717,
-0.0353686698,
-0.0462917387,
-0.0149946772,
0.0577787682,
-0.0298406743,
-0.0243986696,
0.065446943,
-0.0119084381,
-0.1018136293,
0.0227633715,
-0.0258758422,
0.0162786376,
0.0415604375,
0.0146092139,
-0.0154339662,
-0.0408233739,
-0.006088092,
0.040662732,
0.0354493596,
-0.0269453917,
0.0222589262,
-0.0673696995,
0.011905509,
0.0018339155,
-0.0551467426,
-0.0341863558,
-0.0394186117,
0.0405403376,
-0.0256132539,
0.0184735358,
0.0068713268,
-0.0104318224,
-0.0019271674,
0.0331629962,
0.017232785,
0.0202407222,
-0.0052446327,
-0.0599970333,
0.0070600165,
0.0479096472,
0.0261964556,
-0.0177524462,
-0.0799279138,
0.0344577245,
-0.0252137743,
-0.0051708403,
-0.0035260662,
0.020092167,
-0.0128505034,
-0.0375971235,
0.0337827392,
0.0463273004,
-0.0078946091,
0.0186318811,
-0.0124657694,
0.0920303464,
0.018997509,
-0.0408765934,
-0.0098809749,
-0.0214942228,
-0.0403789468,
0.0504114181,
0.0477938242,
-0.0819260329,
-0.0501015373,
-0.0220576897,
0.0250026211,
0.0052173911,
-0.026440993,
-0.0063072536,
0.0007459536,
-0.0947063193,
-0.0682314038,
-0.0100108553,
0.036996305,
0.0745570213,
-0.0163999218,
-0.0483225025,
-0.0036586428,
-0.024729345,
-0.016581187,
0.0478073545,
-0.005681688,
-0.0161950514,
-0.066714175,
0.0055288658,
0.0347058401,
-0.039294254,
-0.024900943,
-0.0003079948,
-0.0420722105,
-0.0522878021,
-0.0032698589,
0.0233155694,
0.0111960396,
0.0395416357,
-0.0121073555,
-0.0644333884,
0.0039134682,
-0.0099028321,
0.0025829962,
0.0349136442,
0.0448458567,
-0.0264822729,
-0.0096770879,
0.047140263,
-0.0476790965,
-0.0194840189,
0.0430654883,
0.0468990877,
0.0004903183,
0.0223108642,
0.0098678153,
-0.025651915,
0.0625033826,
-0.0055268751,
-0.032348197,
-0.0117691979,
0.014045151,
0.0741139874,
-0.0062900805,
-0.0583398119,
-0.0021804341,
0.0024801884,
0.0184264556,
0.0185556766,
-0.0342588909,
0.0015941444,
0.0107787289,
-0.0092895003,
0.0230532195,
0.0013690317,
0.0133396089,
0.0183657408,
0.0320711583,
-0.0255189408,
-0.0197649039,
-0.0075434051,
0.0181217249,
-0.0101232147,
0.0072623859,
0.0384030007,
0.0444884859,
-0.0412131548,
-0.0211505201,
-0.0596871674,
-0.020112196,
-0.0288603175,
0.0122431917,
0.0351102985,
-0.0574698783,
0.0189167,
0.0175617263,
-0.0302545149,
-0.0065502054,
-0.0150945242,
-0.039141573,
-0.0293232594,
0.0218877457,
0.0274013095,
0.0096022803,
-0.026565006,
0.0702090412,
0.008708653,
-0.0137419701,
-0.0122781079,
0.0131363161,
-0.0506791659,
0.009977092,
0.0351052508,
0.0321974307,
-0.0184078719,
0.0188913252,
0.0056190444,
-0.0708642229,
0.0271172747,
-0.0292577073,
-0.0112617575,
0.0018932453,
0.0310040154,
0.05270423,
-0.0108768344,
-0.0248696394,
-0.036218971,
0.0364466906,
0.0561167076,
-0.0134331062,
0.0116194431,
-6.39295321e-33,
-0.0084431497,
-0.0077607776,
-0.0430913679,
0.0167857595,
-0.0219537336,
0.0364634693,
-0.016612675,
0.0157514494,
-0.0137352692,
-0.0174976997,
-0.029951781,
-0.0196110327,
-0.0010005041,
0.0529750697,
-0.0102614649,
-0.0501400754,
0.0090398202,
-0.0287806857,
-0.006817346,
0.0330985039,
0.0129275518,
0.0208386928,
0.102642104,
-0.0004815215,
0.0096193673,
0.001526985,
-0.0009239065,
0.0442063697,
0.0292136539,
0.0685991794,
-0.0166481733,
0.0076507619,
0.0286356453,
-0.1030238494,
-0.0173089411,
0.0113111399,
-0.0614754669,
-0.0250365976,
0.0275219865,
0.0222679358,
-0.033929795,
-0.0404369049,
0.0979520157,
0.0005652294,
0.0067764879,
-0.0379541367,
0.0479415469,
-0.0049242266,
-0.0743673295,
-0.0188940186,
-0.0739351735,
0.0006058893,
-0.0052082781,
0.0173886325,
0.0151664307,
0.0318351574,
-0.0173510369,
0.0418092795,
-0.046253413,
0.0041848077,
0.0085689118,
0.0747414082,
0.0308711529,
0.0504291691,
0.0212752335,
0.0330816172,
0.0634185374,
-0.0051347869,
-0.0264562331,
-0.0615110658,
0.0500123911,
0.0179133415,
0.0370743386,
-0.0592319183,
0.0292715766,
0.0028374644,
-0.0634823889,
-0.0455735959,
-0.0178181753,
0.056403406,
0.0478353724,
0.0311535951,
0.008897908,
-0.0220634378,
-0.0332473442,
-0.0541705936,
-0.0302967671,
0.0294628181,
-0.0112030627,
0.0316684917,
-0.020017432,
0.0139000909,
0.0431395285,
-0.0324875973,
0.0027534531,
0.0303776152,
0.0150489369,
0.0363871641,
0.0050276066,
0.0006587746,
-0.0606450774,
-0.0100219203,
-0.0329557471,
-0.0199535489,
0.014268511,
0.0159592573,
0.037480101,
0.0123380385,
-0.0369779803,
-0.051851023,
-0.0437175408,
-0.0254726019,
-0.005109943,
0.068132095,
0.0693224519,
-0.0150328493,
0.00230395,
0.0891273543,
0.0446012206,
0.0172759686,
-0.0129033308,
0.0007124473,
0.0157245249,
0.0472090878,
-0.0420829691,
0.0001848653,
-0.0173406005,
0.0558614992,
0.0479145832,
-0.070477508,
-0.0079764202,
0.0229848754,
2.815e-7,
0.0360682756,
0.0153455995,
-0.0035268855,
-0.0433165394,
0.0327715538,
0.0520934202,
0.0081373993,
0.0433352664,
0.019691335,
-0.021148853,
0.0195225589,
0.0164329484,
0.0254724361,
-0.017674394,
-0.1137168035,
0.0185320899,
-0.0480818599,
0.0289877299,
-0.0123307975,
0.0336143002,
0.0027618478,
0.1210695803,
-0.018024385,
-0.0049901344,
-0.0250443108,
0.0056343316,
0.0165388361,
-0.017235918,
0.0346038043,
0.0001182808,
0.0512289964,
-0.0509893075,
-0.028522158,
-0.0137726618,
-0.0080440147,
0.0584391691,
0.0175512005,
0.0547023751,
-0.0206117276,
-0.0634021163,
0.0161229037,
-0.0151458615,
0.007193862,
-0.0571318269,
0.0532484204,
-0.0723131597,
-0.038728144,
-0.0291181877,
0.0012075171,
0.0461834483,
-0.0156674255,
-0.0359593332,
0.0055154241,
0.0310027674,
0.0158260856,
-0.0120339468,
-0.016981354,
-0.0797406808,
-0.0127755487,
0.0303263459,
-0.0872223973,
-0.0270235259,
-0.0564332642,
0.00883142,
0.047228124,
-0.0156548619,
-0.0234035365,
2.559953715e-34,
0.0287466906,
-0.0302894786,
0.0272589438,
0.0344055519,
0.0034947486,
-0.0537848622,
-0.0045567341,
0.0115285814,
0.0141728912,
-0.0601627976,
-0.0314421766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.15687v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.15687v2 | Voicebox: Text-Guided Multilingual Universal Speech Generation at Scale | 2023-06-23T16:23:24 | 2023-10-19T13:23:28 | Matthew Le, Apoorv Vyas, Bowen Shi, Brian Karrer, Leda Sari, Rashel Moritz, Mary Williamson, Vimal Manohar, Yossi Adi, Jay Mahadeokar, Wei-Ning Hsu | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Large-scale generative models such as GPT and DALL-E have revolutionized the
research community. These models not only generate high fidelity outputs, but
are also generalists which can solve tasks not explicitly taught. In contrast,
speech generative models are still primitive in terms of scale and task
generalization. In this paper, we present Voicebox, the most versatile
text-guided generative model for speech at scale. Voicebox is a
non-autoregressive flow-matching model trained to infill speech, given audio
context and text, trained on over 50K hours of speech that are not filtered or
enhanced. Similar to GPT, Voicebox can perform many different tasks through
in-context learning, but is more flexible as it can also condition on future
context. Voicebox can be used for mono or cross-lingual zero-shot
text-to-speech synthesis, noise removal, content editing, style conversion, and
diverse sample generation. In particular, Voicebox outperforms the
state-of-the-art zero-shot TTS model VALL-E on both intelligibility (5.9% vs
1.9% word error rates) and audio similarity (0.580 vs 0.681) while being up to
20 times faster. Audio samples can be found in
\url{https://voicebox.metademolab.com}. | [
-0.0270940531,
0.0429234356,
0.0239553247,
-0.0054222592,
-0.0112153441,
-0.018175656,
0.0652735159,
0.0041734199,
-0.0594664291,
0.0107205193,
-0.0794224143,
-0.0475842431,
-0.0065761129,
0.054836873,
0.0508463383,
-0.0758378431,
-0.0067286538,
-0.0227155443,
-0.0329478644,
-0.0208311323,
0.0362293087,
0.0423415639,
-0.0289292857,
0.02781507,
-0.0173984598,
-0.0271019042,
-0.0270670261,
0.0532229804,
0.0192193072,
-0.0035858182,
-0.0156723168,
0.040493276,
0.0545824766,
0.0443722829,
0.0000021811,
-0.0126323206,
-0.0143077988,
-0.0037178991,
-0.0122006796,
0.0017936775,
0.0187271927,
-0.0006567698,
-0.057643529,
0.0198567566,
0.0059232041,
-0.023737343,
0.0614143014,
0.0323201232,
0.0428527743,
0.088008754,
-0.0213842802,
-0.0505849048,
0.0121164983,
-0.0437105633,
0.0310880654,
-0.0048541026,
-0.0352203958,
-0.0091183055,
0.0065007536,
-0.0165368449,
-0.0192396771,
0.0329027064,
0.0211896468,
-0.0270586591,
0.0034382867,
0.0213746671,
-0.0465493649,
-0.0412085727,
0.0073872027,
0.11319682,
-0.0138943279,
-0.0151720885,
0.0149956029,
-0.0110022575,
-0.0301959999,
-0.0457960479,
-0.009133243,
0.000931135,
0.0232626144,
-0.0034364706,
-0.0326332934,
0.0203804709,
0.0199456587,
-0.0394163281,
0.018996384,
-0.017910026,
0.0369171277,
-0.0145209264,
-0.0253377296,
-0.013133144,
-0.0154903037,
-0.0579392202,
0.0430144742,
0.0209191609,
-0.0163597651,
-0.0221822634,
-0.0715221837,
-0.0394707322,
-0.0469268598,
0.0017105039,
0.0415267237,
0.0534888767,
-0.0185912438,
0.0253751297,
-0.0006272602,
0.0460071117,
-0.032019563,
-0.0221658982,
-0.035330385,
-0.0178331267,
-0.0110389572,
0.0110472022,
-0.0450746976,
0.0065121534,
-0.0443802327,
-0.0268253777,
-0.0523693636,
-0.0150399795,
-0.043975208,
0.0095669124,
0.0186248496,
0.0234018192,
-0.0559270196,
-0.0761982277,
0.0309228636,
0.0332987085,
-0.0233887285,
0.0387127697,
0.010014005,
-0.0535608195,
-0.014074889,
0.036061462,
0.0392166041,
-0.0034609486,
0.0403901301,
0.0523718148,
-0.0121701565,
0.007973535,
-0.0385812558,
-0.0370358601,
-0.025380522,
-0.062219739,
-0.0246849097,
-0.0737479776,
0.0153352497,
-0.0429114103,
-0.0050990935,
-0.0196788926,
0.004919346,
-0.0165974144,
0.0377489738,
0.0129162129,
0.0201388374,
0.0100695807,
0.0287113562,
-0.0013544766,
0.0345802419,
0.0407565087,
0.0571668409,
-0.0117495712,
-0.0240765736,
-0.0297001768,
-0.000150282,
0.0789109617,
0.029596081,
0.0436440594,
-0.0428377874,
-0.039266225,
-0.0011191067,
0.0498994961,
0.0910465121,
0.0311965309,
-0.0493971966,
0.0070079863,
0.0960048363,
-0.0039893626,
0.0302999709,
0.0170194171,
0.07215143,
0.0197092369,
-0.0321901403,
-0.020789355,
0.024262622,
0.0420529395,
0.023358956,
0.036916282,
0.0796053708,
0.0451784842,
-0.0474362187,
-0.0042973375,
0.039259661,
-0.0152280452,
-0.0351241976,
0.0023237702,
0.0217293315,
0.0386412032,
-0.0616780259,
-0.0075464998,
-0.0024773772,
-0.0763560459,
0.0236700252,
0.0010049614,
0.0108318944,
0.0678676441,
0.0314865895,
0.0574647412,
-0.0093723172,
-0.0609580912,
-0.003702542,
0.0813406855,
-0.0083855456,
-0.0002157677,
0.0555809475,
-0.0814689547,
-0.0260424688,
0.0173168704,
-0.0146335717,
0.0519578196,
-0.028862033,
0.03977862,
0.0120200822,
-0.0146402046,
0.035643097,
-0.0167894345,
-0.0452410989,
-0.0464527383,
0.0427123085,
0.0162213258,
0.0549314991,
0.031768471,
-0.0605713353,
0.0136257801,
-0.0170661397,
-0.0470616631,
-0.0021282821,
0.0473299995,
-0.1035736725,
-0.0297292732,
0.0214720611,
-0.0528741702,
0.0133184157,
0.0106075238,
0.0112013342,
-0.0836497992,
0.0403042436,
0.0195550919,
0.0234941691,
-0.0164328311,
0.0395768583,
0.0200060233,
-0.0007916242,
0.0079899207,
-0.0018719301,
0.0349692665,
0.0017887987,
0.0256983414,
0.0783686414,
0.0182049815,
-0.0668995604,
-0.0048582852,
0.0261709411,
0.0115715498,
-0.003699922,
0.0179634821,
0.0033867802,
-0.0208018739,
0.0034956315,
-0.0677131936,
0.034749575,
0.0061400924,
0.0122756958,
0.0421092324,
0.0473860577,
-0.0113612292,
-0.0120119136,
-0.0557389893,
-0.0002747031,
0.035808526,
-0.0430756174,
-0.021574039,
-0.0473176166,
0.0022115337,
-0.0223430805,
0.0186008941,
0.03324572,
-0.0147664277,
-0.0092363786,
-0.0252205692,
0.0003636688,
0.0520489775,
0.0022592389,
0.042802237,
0.0081471279,
-0.0331706703,
-0.0121040419,
0.0353067853,
0.0662363023,
0.029863745,
0.0092244195,
-0.0720553994,
0.0097121326,
-0.0101467194,
-0.0596883893,
0.022993328,
0.0268421602,
-0.0072579542,
-0.0309246313,
0.016135741,
0.0036375073,
0.0342307724,
0.0634858608,
0.005613178,
-0.0615028143,
-0.0116000818,
0.0126225585,
-0.0237192828,
0.0181028415,
-0.0157775283,
-0.0348752365,
-0.0012430843,
-0.0241044238,
-0.0463223718,
0.0174415894,
-0.0510446392,
-0.0518517904,
-0.0185062904,
-0.0199145451,
-0.0114224274,
0.0160206128,
-0.008822443,
0.051748693,
0.0017874334,
-0.010987075,
-0.0430247299,
0.0219566785,
0.0505446643,
-0.0314695574,
0.0161443166,
-0.01304611,
-0.0067003672,
-0.0382882319,
-0.0484918393,
-0.0196302105,
0.0330009647,
-0.0097210081,
0.0156212095,
0.016616188,
-0.0491411872,
-0.0295459013,
0.0019347318,
0.0520381927,
0.0722846389,
-0.0144484648,
0.0041344631,
-0.0264796428,
0.0362398401,
0.0356678665,
-0.007915006,
-0.0271280147,
-0.0122522265,
0.0427742451,
0.0163144674,
0.0360422805,
0.0091632493,
-0.0284771696,
0.0222869236,
0.0340784267,
0.0304734353,
-0.045803573,
0.0261639915,
0.0746072978,
-0.027539162,
0.0003554584,
0.1106104851,
-0.0285986755,
-0.0357818939,
-0.0082207713,
0.0113117611,
0.0661924779,
-0.0064899907,
-0.0025663036,
-0.0882256627,
-0.0435111076,
0.0338614844,
0.0305146761,
0.0049161725,
0.0248147808,
-0.0260609053,
-0.1107126325,
0.0537188463,
0.0763488933,
-0.0540960915,
-0.0285865925,
0.001264574,
-0.0249674395,
-0.020360386,
0.0242647324,
0.0208319034,
-0.0167749003,
-0.0042349789,
0.0516203642,
0.0037363325,
-0.0455566049,
-0.0069095474,
-0.0599228665,
0.0864245445,
0.0709527358,
0.0388097316,
0.0202431977,
-0.0136534795,
0.0126841674,
0.0156528596,
-0.0220408887,
0.0403486416,
0.0348722339,
0.0106931068,
-0.0099571319,
0.0081476355,
0.0615756661,
-0.0340238214,
0.0262060873,
0.0350068249,
0.015692791,
-0.0013686501,
0.0173111223,
0.0008482884,
0.0323222913,
-0.0026641958,
0.0550430343,
-0.0090336185,
-0.0441003628,
-0.0476249307,
-0.0061902236,
0.0348552689,
-0.0970107839,
-0.0465439558,
0.0029086496,
-0.0155891683,
-0.0526947007,
-0.0685823113,
0.0041114581,
-0.0167039242,
0.053390298,
0.003235949,
-0.0178439301,
-0.0181316193,
-0.0251463279,
-0.0241514686,
-0.0323670469,
-0.004653377,
0.0286897309,
-0.0778367296,
-0.0231718831,
0.0116300248,
-0.0491714403,
-0.0115407566,
0.0615195706,
-0.0687327906,
-0.0679355264,
-0.0303223226,
-0.0257415976,
0.0104089975,
0.0820180178,
0.0220979415,
-0.0064313891,
0.0727392659,
0.0209541135,
-0.0036141886,
0.0275849495,
0.0332049355,
0.0261645243,
-0.0062648449,
0.0171123929,
-0.0398666374,
0.0475159995,
0.0055317474,
0.0224374048,
-0.0010612631,
-0.035182897,
0.0049615339,
-0.0200026948,
-0.032600835,
-0.0185866635,
0.0827554464,
-0.0575542897,
-0.0056135263,
-0.0004854462,
0.0114683509,
-0.0618745945,
-0.0097415512,
0.0585003607,
0.0154338246,
0.0052105351,
0.0017840371,
-0.0300367288,
0.0054110475,
-0.0313986018,
-0.0141679831,
0.0155655127,
0.0034335766,
0.0153135555,
-0.0148854936,
0.0221667234,
0.0327951573,
-0.0023763038,
0.0179339834,
-0.0338555463,
0.0150968535,
-0.0068205786,
0.0137387346,
0.0283956099,
-0.0081356037,
-0.0292431992,
-0.0164546017,
-0.0579984076,
0.0065368549,
0.0490833074,
-0.0023303439,
0.0885201171,
-0.0204280037,
0.013575485,
-0.0221245494,
0.0238606129,
-0.0316958576,
-0.0228186101,
-0.006500578,
-0.0065962328,
-0.0029560071,
0.002688077,
0.0547607988,
0.0173530113,
0.0481733195,
-0.0125195859,
0.0497601666,
-0.0252121575,
-0.0219946802,
-0.0235341471,
-0.0056075882,
0.0052033411,
-0.0051920563,
-0.0160276927,
-0.0443719514,
-0.0152128153,
-0.0074962764,
-0.0030480898,
-0.0432307422,
0.0612329058,
-0.019827839,
-0.0489927754,
0.0189079065,
-0.0134282252,
-0.0339116417,
-0.0439840481,
-0.0111296289,
-0.0323505476,
-5.942141943e-33,
-0.0441438369,
0.0141769527,
0.0150945894,
-0.0405967161,
-0.0416381471,
-0.0286912434,
-0.032936696,
-0.0044109714,
0.0050408584,
0.0125982361,
0.0040475442,
-0.0029423879,
0.0061363275,
0.0638251454,
-0.0023448684,
0.0525863394,
0.0890710875,
-0.0254842024,
-0.006088268,
0.0756146386,
0.0560388751,
0.0226016566,
0.0131849488,
-0.063060388,
-0.0275433585,
-0.0451924764,
-0.0297674164,
-0.0245260671,
0.0352648385,
0.00788463,
0.0208082628,
0.0075494288,
-0.0376027226,
-0.0252617188,
-0.0314051621,
-0.0160034262,
-0.037275482,
0.0051991763,
-0.0137205813,
0.0128289778,
-0.0133630661,
-0.0275193024,
0.0380440094,
-0.0283520613,
-0.0188434031,
-0.0261354614,
0.0248507485,
-0.0154752294,
-0.0172451884,
-0.0816289186,
-0.0610339753,
0.0300546587,
-0.0549614504,
-0.045761019,
0.0093436753,
0.0715393126,
-0.0305993333,
-0.0196879171,
-0.052117452,
0.0709354803,
0.001721904,
0.0467005223,
0.0599756315,
0.0316639133,
0.0219320748,
0.0487137251,
0.0261209123,
-0.045451764,
0.0163039975,
0.004393707,
0.0170403328,
0.0233990457,
0.0093377857,
0.0708770752,
0.0355170853,
-0.0021575098,
-0.0357333906,
0.0349331051,
0.0029513221,
0.0008336878,
0.0198636688,
0.0389342196,
-0.0068568708,
0.0046087587,
-0.0429577343,
-0.0829492584,
-0.0092389677,
-0.0452442281,
0.0406825729,
0.0169820599,
0.0345003158,
-0.0409513935,
0.0532164499,
0.0225514397,
-0.0015191738,
0.0222518239,
-0.0763933808,
-0.0206995532,
0.0200552773,
0.036042165,
-0.0421810746,
-0.0389326997,
0.0674891621,
0.0529782809,
0.0073566562,
0.0140314521,
-0.0235658027,
0.0431613103,
-0.0619864687,
-0.0076954854,
-0.0559808724,
0.0293461531,
-0.0132888062,
0.0079633994,
0.0234676059,
-0.038956441,
-0.0198618118,
0.0525078289,
-0.0057318565,
-0.0249635149,
0.0369251333,
-0.0136356009,
-0.0072287195,
0.0223009493,
-0.0474641062,
0.0423047803,
-0.0108178388,
-0.0064444137,
0.0824476928,
-0.0141731557,
-0.0282817315,
-0.01159357,
2.862e-7,
-0.036268305,
-0.0388188101,
0.0172086637,
0.0000646261,
0.0399972945,
0.0537188984,
-0.0194053613,
0.0147615429,
-0.0040829522,
0.0341481864,
0.0117862523,
-0.0177913364,
0.1006000564,
-0.0060819071,
-0.08254271,
0.0035209437,
-0.0717801452,
0.001253897,
-0.0224106293,
-0.0171148609,
-0.0093739675,
0.0523765236,
-0.0258662496,
-0.0330051109,
0.0635730177,
0.0036793514,
0.066708453,
-0.0060285251,
0.0096752923,
-0.0181312691,
-0.035331104,
-0.0104799327,
-0.0448606648,
-0.0311039351,
-0.0482912995,
0.0222240202,
0.0424931943,
0.0828896835,
0.0145409647,
-0.0333712548,
0.0168383159,
0.0450277328,
-0.0161903705,
-0.0311096944,
0.0460875779,
0.0259016957,
-0.0170862861,
-0.0229521673,
-0.0607852675,
0.0312777683,
0.0294289514,
-0.0270445757,
-0.0173866581,
-0.0017065712,
0.0399836414,
0.010606085,
-0.0179225188,
0.0006476821,
-0.0223856084,
-0.0065432559,
-0.059625756,
-0.0245863758,
-0.055622004,
0.0285576843,
0.0104826149,
0.012655356,
-0.0189070515,
2.316335725e-34,
-0.0050436258,
-0.0327944905,
0.042420242,
-0.0288907662,
-0.0073201451,
0.0016331641,
0.0006889885,
-0.0042421878,
0.0108785341,
-0.0172110628,
-0.0423772819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.15686v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.15686v1 | Master-ASR: Achieving Multilingual Scalability and Low-Resource Adaptation in ASR with Modular Learning | 2023-06-23T16:23:00 | 2023-06-23T16:23:00 | Zhongzhi Yu, Yang Zhang, Kaizhi Qian, Yonggan Fu, Yingyan Lin | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Despite the impressive performance recently achieved by automatic speech
recognition (ASR), we observe two primary challenges that hinder its broader
applications: (1) The difficulty of introducing scalability into the model to
support more languages with limited training, inference, and storage overhead;
(2) The low-resource adaptation ability that enables effective low-resource
adaptation while avoiding over-fitting and catastrophic forgetting issues.
Inspired by recent findings, we hypothesize that we can address the above
challenges with modules widely shared across languages. To this end, we propose
an ASR framework, dubbed \METHODNS, that, \textit{for the first time},
simultaneously achieves strong multilingual scalability and low-resource
adaptation ability thanks to its modularize-then-assemble strategy.
Specifically, \METHOD learns a small set of generalizable sub-modules and
adaptively assembles them for different languages to reduce the multilingual
overhead and enable effective knowledge transfer for low-resource adaptation.
Extensive experiments and visualizations demonstrate that \METHOD can
effectively discover language similarity and improve multilingual and
low-resource ASR performance over state-of-the-art (SOTA) methods, e.g., under
multilingual-ASR, our framework achieves a 0.13$\sim$2.41 lower character error
rate (CER) with 30\% smaller inference overhead over SOTA solutions on
multilingual ASR and a comparable CER, with nearly 50 times fewer trainable
parameters over SOTA solutions on low-resource tuning, respectively. | [
-0.0104169548,
0.1085672826,
-0.0019060652,
0.0208094101,
-0.0031277339,
0.0349479131,
0.0670175105,
-0.021131983,
0.0092205862,
0.0346684866,
-0.0847152174,
-0.0197119396,
0.0122459233,
-0.0439190082,
0.0337449051,
-0.02126614,
0.0462267473,
-0.0619304776,
-0.0409340635,
-0.0219648574,
0.0263256896,
0.0210089423,
0.0033743216,
0.0272449683,
0.0045862738,
0.0493609011,
-0.0163233355,
0.0035701967,
0.0298196636,
0.007293087,
-0.0170764793,
0.0091178911,
0.0279286895,
0.0818998814,
0.0000020374,
-0.0211582482,
-0.0372713841,
0.0079645356,
-0.0084424624,
0.016390577,
0.0441016033,
-0.0246521626,
0.0075228484,
0.0444813669,
0.0012285894,
-0.0398671888,
0.0819314048,
0.0045700204,
-0.0062120152,
0.0424765013,
-0.0190037712,
-0.0350317061,
-0.0084884586,
-0.0287138894,
-0.040629968,
-0.0384119935,
-0.0242194775,
-0.0156642068,
0.0272718649,
-0.0313662328,
-0.0277900361,
0.0437235571,
0.0176159609,
0.016475467,
-0.0447689891,
0.0159341134,
-0.0261485726,
-0.0379043482,
-0.024167655,
0.0396005213,
-0.0211536977,
-0.0443311036,
0.0244017523,
-0.0069921771,
-0.0472879522,
-0.0086549604,
-0.0364677757,
0.0399292745,
-0.0038740898,
0.0076181814,
0.0562777705,
0.0054125283,
0.0401667468,
-0.0117397597,
-0.0133080725,
0.0128045389,
0.0251300316,
-0.0026254081,
-0.0118692499,
0.0053782729,
0.0098615959,
0.0076037543,
0.0254088379,
-0.0097587407,
-0.0060113855,
0.0021720617,
-0.0333569944,
-0.0458182581,
0.009476332,
-0.0508224368,
0.0238703303,
0.0632043332,
-0.0370548852,
0.0432639942,
-0.0350941792,
0.0456715263,
-0.0135287978,
0.0137900794,
-0.0508636422,
-0.0407983996,
-0.0640111268,
0.0158606786,
-0.0432987995,
0.0262069833,
-0.0118797738,
-0.0234249234,
-0.016689118,
0.0258933082,
0.0191947501,
0.0095599294,
0.0195297971,
-0.0387354903,
-0.0333385095,
-0.0088908309,
0.0443929285,
0.081989713,
-0.0203527156,
-0.0033912398,
-0.009909071,
-0.0449149273,
-0.0186623354,
0.0389367752,
0.0158434287,
-0.0037706445,
0.0501731522,
0.0505062304,
-0.0249269791,
-0.0133490777,
-0.0249566007,
0.040425539,
-0.0258107707,
-0.0653086677,
0.0096023595,
-0.0606209822,
0.0952670872,
0.0117569081,
0.0162577387,
-0.0146592772,
-0.0121925157,
-0.029569732,
0.001669676,
0.0625975579,
0.0008238946,
-0.0008735859,
0.0222510453,
0.0086854724,
0.0314015336,
0.0818625912,
0.0150638884,
-0.0098134642,
0.0111511443,
-0.0276840795,
-0.0345858745,
0.0532896668,
-0.0260362215,
0.0215025824,
0.0166706871,
-0.0272217244,
0.0328935497,
-0.0296847373,
0.0212573502,
0.0448213108,
-0.0255602729,
-0.0223555453,
0.0195016284,
0.0265491791,
0.0166110303,
0.0473223552,
0.0262677372,
-0.0042064609,
-0.0009229691,
-0.0057320297,
-0.0314287134,
0.0177624226,
-0.0157547072,
0.0023871439,
0.0180182457,
0.051348988,
-0.0634604618,
-0.0015244853,
-0.0283707306,
-0.037180718,
0.0066465209,
0.0654162914,
0.0604036376,
-0.0057472619,
-0.0330973789,
0.0692994744,
0.0571933165,
-0.0583403446,
0.0025750727,
-0.0345052183,
0.0053221788,
0.0348554924,
0.0095311226,
-0.056032192,
-0.0452285297,
0.0296151061,
0.0022002703,
0.0513187796,
0.0211088751,
0.013584529,
0.0969092771,
-0.1085988879,
0.0191148743,
0.0369379446,
-0.0005727719,
0.1018747613,
0.0032431979,
0.0204442665,
-0.0112180989,
-0.0295827743,
0.0069368114,
-0.0054390999,
-0.0470234454,
0.0027539679,
0.0425033644,
0.0258446392,
0.0655217022,
0.0201474726,
-0.0219691861,
-0.0308170393,
0.0175459497,
-0.0471921526,
0.0037239166,
0.0580567084,
-0.0643219724,
-0.0367861427,
0.0238240995,
0.0090283277,
0.0164628103,
0.0282585006,
-0.0031130658,
-0.0546491891,
0.0596172921,
-0.0247352645,
0.041913189,
-0.0508965366,
0.0386390649,
0.0005095004,
0.040283151,
0.0139444014,
0.006134843,
0.0173426736,
-0.0161961913,
-0.0012852736,
-0.0102942567,
0.0425804667,
-0.0306692831,
-0.0755933598,
0.0307554584,
-0.0013938535,
0.0297773369,
0.024695985,
0.0012326272,
0.0246468913,
-0.0167415421,
-0.1288220435,
-0.0085569844,
-0.0259741917,
0.0362524278,
-0.0213849936,
0.0604732335,
0.0192872863,
-0.0329980776,
0.0024583174,
-0.0036552791,
0.0038106106,
0.0299747493,
-0.0320294239,
-0.0114430087,
-0.0316699818,
-0.0231852531,
-0.0226272717,
0.0184717104,
0.0404397137,
-0.0454810634,
-0.0175568629,
-0.0684699342,
-0.0339333229,
-0.0503390692,
0.0331842229,
-0.0306163896,
-0.0436135121,
-0.0267021712,
-0.0286994781,
0.0186612532,
0.0099583045,
-0.0607240312,
-0.0357411318,
0.0624427423,
0.0173909273,
-0.0372648798,
0.0290668365,
0.0082921945,
0.0085936366,
-0.0130820693,
-0.0149441985,
-0.0309667848,
0.0578171685,
0.0004589424,
0.0076953229,
-0.0514668003,
-0.0639089048,
0.0144540211,
-0.0226697382,
0.0378775373,
-0.009510559,
0.0120949587,
-0.0116427317,
0.0134646324,
-0.0410871096,
0.0506095737,
-0.05942728,
-0.0641104057,
-0.0605347678,
-0.0610160492,
-0.0513121895,
0.051277522,
0.0012203128,
0.0211314633,
-0.0139563642,
-0.0597769767,
-0.0205216669,
0.0016954066,
0.0500189401,
-0.0001653585,
0.0779494271,
-0.0295049027,
0.0246651936,
-0.0315864347,
-0.0669086874,
-0.0039235251,
0.0591048747,
-0.0501657762,
0.0540758409,
-0.0082227746,
-0.0515967496,
-0.0778522417,
0.0207341667,
0.0511210859,
0.0678424612,
0.0361364409,
0.0531989187,
-0.0069555617,
0.0380893424,
-0.0315399654,
0.0238138977,
0.0203518756,
-0.0477557518,
0.0574929789,
0.0102441385,
0.0639714971,
-0.0187627021,
-0.0378347002,
-0.0178999528,
0.0467534885,
0.007589018,
0.0052332906,
-0.0097863879,
0.0619916022,
-0.0371144488,
-0.0083656237,
0.0733229369,
-0.0113101257,
-0.0344480984,
-0.0225687027,
-0.0135508217,
0.0703703687,
0.0057157651,
0.0151731251,
-0.04642573,
-0.026348412,
0.0448257551,
0.0131072681,
0.039064981,
0.0108770728,
0.0055769566,
-0.0922662169,
0.0307998341,
0.0244192109,
-0.0929168239,
-0.0193984639,
-0.062319845,
-0.0357882529,
-0.0182536971,
0.0379084945,
-0.0018148026,
-0.013905758,
-0.0489463881,
0.0332213938,
-0.0867775977,
-0.0334200896,
-0.0182960387,
-0.0302383881,
0.04680999,
-0.0030230451,
0.0024304974,
-0.0051951637,
-0.0110864267,
0.0050364765,
-0.0349134021,
-0.0018773825,
-0.0493413992,
-0.0097728381,
0.0343841612,
-0.0273272991,
0.0357305035,
-0.0163846426,
-0.0164618026,
-0.0040528919,
0.0286253504,
0.065124765,
-0.0140299052,
-0.0014110921,
0.0125332428,
0.0054798066,
-0.0163689032,
0.0594055913,
0.0320103094,
0.0033983206,
-0.0235937443,
0.0236984175,
-0.0203596614,
-0.0227291267,
0.011122888,
0.0130129997,
-0.0427391976,
-0.0402997509,
-0.0285654645,
-0.0028574006,
0.0117078498,
0.0294130333,
0.0149924168,
0.0127053941,
-0.032121785,
0.020769909,
-0.0574597791,
-0.0205146763,
-0.0238981768,
-0.0149871325,
-0.0540592708,
-0.0263486598,
0.0421417654,
-0.0388086066,
-0.0087872939,
0.0144810397,
-0.1036825627,
-0.0925102979,
-0.0369734094,
0.0273114592,
0.0055279299,
0.0558943003,
-0.0070081637,
-0.0296359137,
0.0131677371,
0.0183637328,
0.0039578932,
0.0197962597,
0.0666424558,
0.0083861677,
-0.0051238989,
0.0411875956,
-0.0278509837,
0.0269959699,
-0.0108251851,
0.0314289778,
-0.0294523891,
0.0144090503,
-0.0336428843,
0.0321195945,
-0.0138838608,
-0.0314403884,
-0.0316197015,
-0.0388143994,
0.028349502,
-0.0001462398,
0.0268305019,
-0.0539835654,
-0.009110068,
0.0085473433,
0.0240321569,
0.0123486929,
0.0484116934,
0.0333599858,
0.0026967172,
0.0167257246,
0.0845952928,
0.0038451129,
0.0128609929,
0.0040218434,
0.0145417945,
-0.0229295697,
0.0105930623,
0.0368716605,
0.0057408288,
-0.0444667041,
0.0052158823,
-0.0063839881,
-0.0015222764,
-0.0269413386,
0.0087478757,
-0.0313423201,
-0.0927481949,
-0.0019182062,
0.070362933,
0.0332810208,
-0.0185240991,
0.0856296495,
-0.0118579539,
0.007536991,
-0.0398536138,
0.0246695969,
-0.0460947044,
0.0037707146,
0.0180300642,
0.0138594443,
-0.0042608851,
0.030057501,
0.0450936891,
-0.0076226946,
0.0254841428,
-0.0098731825,
0.0108520687,
-0.0290843975,
-0.055390913,
0.0247954689,
-0.0145974625,
-0.063493371,
-0.017246889,
-0.0009521151,
-0.0475005507,
0.0182213914,
-0.0037207473,
0.0108978767,
0.0190260001,
0.0065828604,
0.0296035707,
-0.0035176545,
-0.0035258608,
0.0027963421,
-0.0328717679,
-0.0026968203,
-0.0390366986,
0.0583305396,
-6.16931541e-33,
0.0021065488,
0.0350638479,
-0.0093612177,
-0.0279731266,
-0.0161661711,
0.0139799071,
-0.0277635101,
0.0147246514,
-0.0142035754,
-0.0417677835,
-0.0005833533,
-0.0416794494,
0.0340153016,
0.0191849433,
0.027883634,
-0.0027164966,
0.0674124584,
0.0302006528,
0.0038211436,
0.0192440171,
0.0146555109,
0.0423718952,
0.0912873968,
-0.0361348763,
-0.0812608004,
0.0184986088,
0.0115280142,
-0.0280306023,
0.0104828151,
0.0701191276,
0.0082134297,
0.0425337106,
-0.0016230016,
0.0119345831,
-0.0161917284,
-0.0050335424,
-0.0900713727,
-0.0254892875,
0.016753342,
0.0486203097,
0.0066797235,
-0.0133099407,
0.0279337466,
-0.0339488573,
0.0163389724,
-0.0145218391,
0.02623244,
-0.0140196532,
-0.040641848,
0.0102143316,
-0.0511231534,
0.025994638,
0.0054547638,
0.0239701197,
0.0592876077,
0.0559131019,
-0.0131802689,
-0.0218733754,
-0.0524987765,
0.0239853319,
-0.0148948906,
0.0493269674,
0.0377673283,
0.0201328173,
-0.0149641037,
0.0120279798,
0.1015565991,
-0.0438122526,
0.0247386936,
-0.0286148097,
0.0539407209,
0.0156246694,
0.0485014059,
0.0472124889,
0.021123562,
-0.0141572999,
-0.0658887252,
-0.041517131,
0.0588261224,
0.0260223504,
0.0309111327,
0.0352129824,
-0.0481749065,
-0.01265983,
-0.0270446613,
-0.0008318393,
-0.0436161011,
-0.0209977888,
0.0410243273,
0.0401901528,
-0.0217369068,
0.0188698079,
0.083557725,
-0.024374947,
0.0014035429,
0.0213565379,
0.0295739938,
0.0072073983,
0.0057872985,
0.0178058874,
-0.0831533596,
-0.0691038445,
-0.0170869529,
-0.0229544565,
-0.0149986176,
-0.0273954049,
0.052493684,
0.0584455244,
-0.0656211376,
0.0072141318,
-0.0320042409,
0.0112726483,
-0.0014165347,
0.0504265688,
0.0251118299,
-0.021265965,
0.008828911,
0.0011002548,
0.0010808781,
-0.0136880679,
-0.0208124183,
0.0128906574,
0.0256398469,
0.024413269,
-0.0340134352,
0.0095164655,
-0.0411204584,
-0.0781632364,
0.0172444135,
-0.0461236723,
-0.0052880938,
0.0310843904,
2.791e-7,
-0.0289782621,
-0.0002012279,
0.0148356147,
-0.0588117838,
0.0116722872,
0.0015726602,
-0.046568878,
0.006299302,
-0.0116377166,
0.0585693195,
0.0186074432,
0.0595011897,
0.0868056715,
0.042325858,
-0.0897537917,
0.0008547141,
-0.0233217701,
-0.0025258285,
-0.0158195049,
-0.0158743281,
-0.0379999094,
0.1045082733,
0.012333096,
-0.020732604,
-0.0158343725,
-0.0273255911,
0.0440320633,
-0.0050400468,
-0.0096151289,
-0.0107937045,
-0.0248483773,
0.0368974842,
-0.0409673154,
-0.0207540151,
-0.0227141734,
0.0073776636,
0.0185385533,
0.0275461897,
-0.0118434373,
-0.0646197125,
0.0348546766,
0.0238988493,
-0.026292339,
-0.0361084379,
0.0391964354,
0.0317355692,
0.0017173574,
-0.0342397206,
0.0023635414,
0.0115764914,
0.0406958051,
-0.0056305216,
-0.0368215255,
0.050220523,
0.0398243479,
-0.046184849,
-0.0327969193,
-0.0453045219,
0.0263999421,
0.0153483953,
-0.0565035269,
-0.0138265565,
-0.0367033519,
-0.0253769979,
0.0053626988,
-0.0380213223,
-0.0027925565,
2.31929191e-34,
0.0308261868,
-0.0175182316,
0.0082415277,
0.0370473526,
0.0099217519,
-0.0597024448,
-0.0583354607,
0.0217021387,
-0.0008075137,
-0.0661177188,
-0.0426115468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13588v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13588v3 | System-Level Natural Language Feedback | 2023-06-23T16:21:40 | 2024-02-03T00:24:11 | Weizhe Yuan, Kyunghyun Cho, Jason Weston | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Natural language (NL) feedback offers rich insights into user experience.
While existing studies focus on an instance-level approach, where feedback is
used to refine specific examples, we introduce a framework for system-level use
of NL feedback. We show how to use feedback to formalize system-level design
decisions in a human-in-the-loop-process -- in order to produce better models.
In particular this is done through: (i) metric design for tasks; and (ii)
language model prompt design for refining model responses. We conduct two case
studies of this approach for improving search query and dialog response
generation, demonstrating the effectiveness of system-level feedback. We show
the combination of system-level and instance-level feedback brings further
gains, and that human written instance-level feedback results in more grounded
refinements than GPT-3.5 written ones, underlying the importance of human
feedback for building systems. We release our code and data at
https://github.com/yyy-Apple/Sys-NL-Feedback. | [
0.0909340158,
0.0187497996,
-0.031499505,
0.0204540193,
-0.0164603759,
-0.0276680011,
-0.0225242991,
-0.0153956329,
0.0263641067,
-0.0400856808,
-0.0331663117,
-0.0065298714,
0.0263180714,
0.0307359584,
-0.0043894835,
-0.0825610235,
0.0544793941,
-0.0440671109,
-0.0068278816,
0.0466364138,
0.0124695627,
0.0315060727,
-0.0033760334,
0.066728957,
0.0144453449,
-0.0346868485,
-0.0354623757,
0.0401995704,
-0.0339873172,
-0.0375153869,
0.0062457649,
0.0480660722,
-0.0354081765,
0.027561266,
0.0000021197,
-0.0562057607,
0.0513292365,
0.0099867014,
-0.0240746196,
0.0393103734,
0.0449457131,
0.0514892824,
-0.0032957904,
0.0120619051,
-0.0210100655,
-0.0054327953,
0.0413120799,
0.0238145739,
0.0745393708,
0.0218996145,
-0.0220286548,
0.0110457456,
-0.0425504968,
0.0254169665,
0.0274379011,
-0.0046397718,
-0.0455244333,
-0.0232145227,
0.1016827375,
0.032128118,
0.0194491595,
0.0154881347,
0.0075061177,
-0.0413418449,
0.0103447139,
0.039140135,
-0.0197603554,
-0.0241848584,
-0.0037373293,
0.0238604099,
0.0348506495,
0.0025560916,
-0.0284385234,
0.0069485446,
0.0168550499,
-0.0247799437,
-0.0034314541,
-0.0540354326,
-0.0359983109,
-0.0377216116,
-0.0451570563,
-0.0272264294,
0.0011589152,
-0.0029252595,
0.0058379858,
0.0570755713,
0.0249685012,
-0.0086370613,
0.014273501,
0.0022708043,
0.0306651443,
-0.0443163179,
0.0122750234,
0.0247255508,
-0.1169292703,
-0.0159309469,
0.0032636875,
0.0189120546,
-0.0077643022,
-0.0517763048,
0.0237117354,
0.0318209082,
-0.041348286,
0.0116622299,
0.0273129176,
0.0455496088,
0.0077028167,
-0.0032158555,
-0.0315724984,
0.0064958343,
-0.0617441908,
-0.025530681,
-0.0568283312,
0.0441260934,
-0.0370608568,
0.0262493566,
-0.0100168344,
0.0674820095,
0.019187063,
0.021106286,
-0.0228551235,
0.0234534722,
-0.0569131635,
0.0067180293,
-0.0488042012,
0.0119379982,
-0.0543097109,
-0.0337221771,
0.0056215301,
-0.0625128001,
-0.0108971018,
-0.0031979373,
-0.0342608802,
0.0025190434,
-0.0356336609,
0.0619977899,
-0.0080345422,
0.0173520446,
-0.0431417562,
-0.0449741706,
-0.0008957742,
-0.0092065651,
-0.0453797467,
-0.0140141416,
-0.0461724102,
0.0234544352,
0.0026979472,
0.0080633415,
-0.0216016527,
0.0470311381,
-0.0088516129,
0.06067238,
-0.0586235225,
0.0121071627,
0.0381792076,
0.010354002,
0.0258801542,
0.0460679419,
0.0303276833,
0.0459312312,
0.0563357584,
-0.0025149377,
0.0424400941,
0.0123258559,
-0.0306732114,
-0.0139384912,
0.0101105357,
0.0219486281,
-0.0645699054,
0.0164998174,
0.0084851515,
0.0465348735,
0.0195693914,
0.0337322503,
0.0404028147,
0.0583801717,
0.0409958921,
0.0149525376,
0.0122465147,
0.0115645863,
-0.0329654925,
0.0043172999,
-0.0280357618,
0.020804463,
-0.0423678383,
0.0448561385,
-0.000781063,
-0.0061693592,
-0.0151981227,
-0.0728115663,
-0.0000754333,
0.04237587,
0.0105153713,
0.0093177604,
0.0189745184,
0.0330754109,
-0.0184268672,
-0.0052862214,
0.007781981,
-0.0583141185,
0.0036133092,
-0.0456913747,
0.0437297262,
0.1346170753,
0.0513682626,
-0.0119311959,
-0.0105537437,
0.0174199473,
-0.0197975691,
0.0315037966,
0.0576507971,
-0.0167916026,
-0.0048039197,
-0.0001310203,
-0.0195366237,
-0.0000807969,
-0.0036082275,
0.0405798815,
-0.0351724476,
-0.0137157207,
0.0125655429,
-0.0070036971,
-0.0660243556,
-0.0100833997,
0.0476404056,
-0.0210284553,
0.0234596897,
-0.0056115892,
0.0011249071,
0.0416321866,
-0.0138403354,
0.0105154514,
-0.006464297,
0.028038146,
0.0028033028,
0.0360105112,
-0.0194141548,
-0.0079839649,
-0.0014580775,
-0.0007903916,
0.017288344,
0.0253234413,
-0.0253057573,
-0.0291565172,
0.0200274233,
-0.0666306391,
0.0259329081,
-0.0051357262,
0.0004653487,
-0.0221706536,
-0.079496704,
-0.0630450621,
0.0172706805,
0.0327077322,
-0.0220912416,
0.0099754501,
0.0379624069,
0.0376468822,
-0.0160762966,
-0.0263778549,
0.0592051744,
0.0164228603,
0.0089621805,
0.0705055147,
0.0592486933,
-0.0335970484,
0.0127376243,
-0.1170390248,
-0.0254018679,
-0.0382540263,
0.0114356931,
0.0041353814,
0.0821262896,
-0.005089161,
-0.0512435101,
0.0035096814,
-0.029360326,
0.0193477441,
0.018655749,
0.0412875675,
0.0362772383,
-0.0148915788,
-0.0525162928,
0.0000176585,
-0.030708814,
-0.0079159457,
0.0159725398,
-0.0191810075,
-0.0873121247,
0.0109643629,
-0.0097293546,
0.0046422952,
0.0025656864,
0.0096716275,
0.0565216765,
0.0104375556,
0.0475151837,
0.0335585661,
0.0056939619,
0.0437609367,
-0.0044094957,
-0.0052671926,
-0.0672138333,
0.0367956161,
0.0219579395,
-0.0475865453,
0.004521844,
0.008366257,
0.0789530203,
0.0505263172,
-0.0141562345,
-0.0063488791,
-0.0510947555,
0.0323696993,
-0.042043943,
-0.0136141321,
-0.0269689579,
-0.0238798223,
-0.0147860432,
0.0323770829,
-0.0100413924,
-0.0809924379,
0.0838378221,
-0.0169060454,
-0.0318013132,
-0.06491974,
-0.0233744979,
-0.0230076518,
0.0853840709,
-0.0653838664,
-0.004203069,
0.0420230106,
-0.0419815369,
-0.0144902337,
-0.0055440911,
0.0213865358,
-0.0230773203,
0.0465419516,
-0.0724811926,
-0.0156492181,
0.0068356576,
-0.0450155735,
-0.0208975319,
0.0190492216,
-0.0618663654,
-0.0270774402,
0.0325716697,
-0.0077022621,
0.0088943923,
0.0117054163,
0.0306742135,
0.0419687741,
-0.0025953164,
-0.0606715307,
0.000599431,
-0.0454694852,
0.0243609473,
0.0264479853,
-0.0278088972,
0.008436989,
-0.0145296212,
0.0094452109,
0.0641767904,
-0.0170467533,
-0.0221064165,
-0.0156560335,
0.0410576612,
-0.0164180808,
-0.0250306223,
0.0357120521,
0.0336040966,
-0.0197262578,
-0.0466362834,
0.1091664135,
0.0431554168,
-0.0432357378,
0.0262730345,
-0.0427047797,
0.0635007098,
0.055740349,
0.0537720397,
-0.0315702967,
-0.0412512831,
-0.0037789254,
0.0352942087,
0.0240738932,
0.0265548378,
-0.0090301745,
-0.0817476735,
-0.0016811807,
-0.0142991263,
-0.0302849188,
-0.0202612802,
-0.0244933199,
-0.0231201649,
0.0167255439,
-0.0050979373,
0.0252372567,
-0.0076326132,
0.0248482898,
0.0074378359,
-0.0466358587,
-0.0196222607,
0.0063629942,
-0.0235531852,
0.0232386366,
0.0997309685,
0.012082641,
0.0386507437,
-0.0145649444,
0.0182874855,
0.0281581394,
0.0564808771,
-0.0478397794,
0.0044161207,
-0.0156701971,
-0.0060033812,
-0.072902374,
-0.0140810469,
-0.0264956187,
0.0105030993,
0.018103471,
0.0187057573,
-0.0442303866,
0.0343889259,
-0.0488863997,
-0.0086862994,
0.0217938032,
0.0199540611,
0.0165089574,
-0.0501914397,
-0.0311303679,
-0.0605968647,
-0.0049873516,
-0.0337626077,
-0.0641922504,
-0.0241109654,
-0.0014973661,
0.0379280224,
-0.0470065139,
-0.0418059081,
-0.0025537354,
0.0380001813,
0.0188428555,
-0.0140156541,
0.0059792274,
0.0252764188,
0.0286129229,
0.0422442108,
-0.0152532272,
0.0101327999,
-0.017166296,
-0.0109012397,
0.0244053844,
0.0094566541,
-0.0054394095,
0.0635594279,
0.0326913558,
-0.0578333139,
-0.0475204252,
0.0686668828,
0.0236087684,
0.0403243676,
-0.0455559604,
-0.0777051002,
-0.0163182262,
0.0276103541,
-0.055840902,
-0.0193037465,
0.0210804529,
0.0241511445,
-0.0136357537,
-0.0009139081,
-0.0634218231,
-0.024385808,
-0.0180699229,
0.0114966547,
0.0322584473,
-0.0503760614,
0.0281568822,
0.0448805764,
0.0525839068,
-0.0104726059,
-0.0099413441,
0.0130187729,
0.0377640612,
-0.0354870111,
-0.0206658058,
-0.027701132,
0.0091655133,
-0.0492051952,
-0.0440093242,
0.0087024095,
-0.0076126633,
-0.0862014741,
0.0793175772,
-0.0340409093,
-0.0331283882,
0.0090823248,
0.0229736324,
0.0115656732,
0.019469671,
-0.0052671474,
0.008128427,
0.0344302244,
0.058548037,
-0.0244709793,
0.050530266,
0.0270367526,
0.0002785865,
0.0168118235,
0.0480390079,
-0.0458386019,
-0.0498033129,
-0.0251855087,
-0.0235576779,
-0.0046054688,
0.0071689687,
0.0055581401,
-0.0094552403,
0.0294148419,
-0.0083886152,
0.0389817841,
-0.0021748545,
-0.0097206021,
-0.0303431936,
0.03834261,
-0.0076326099,
-0.0668088719,
0.0337688327,
-0.0175660867,
-0.0075781527,
-0.0167054534,
-0.036531873,
-0.0400560796,
0.0084420033,
0.0061768787,
0.0180732515,
-0.0276081096,
-0.044513341,
-0.0830297247,
-0.0066466313,
-0.0125835687,
0.0255221333,
0.0362345763,
-0.0296473224,
0.0838922113,
0.0829840526,
-0.001628249,
-0.0632097051,
0.0104476176,
-0.0290296003,
-0.068226099,
-0.0064375633,
-0.0777454078,
-5.055455901e-33,
-0.0499374978,
-0.0295393206,
0.0307573229,
0.0360323265,
-0.0250312127,
-0.0525438264,
-0.0430646762,
0.0396179259,
0.0353922509,
0.0139660584,
-0.0257672854,
-0.009544367,
-0.002847275,
-0.0121537624,
0.026394235,
-0.0072431848,
0.0988766104,
0.0209668297,
-0.0760544762,
0.0510641374,
0.000674719,
-0.0038460793,
0.0463655107,
-0.0849898234,
0.0402860902,
0.0171732698,
0.0088267904,
0.0147048347,
0.0049978038,
0.0144836335,
-0.0057225837,
0.0803018212,
0.0018808732,
-0.0503575131,
-0.0033624028,
0.0226454139,
-0.0051777526,
-0.0644884259,
0.0441358872,
0.0143843526,
-0.029827239,
-0.0062135593,
0.0140611371,
0.0237241238,
-0.0292468332,
0.0693923086,
0.0240366999,
0.0309846699,
-0.0077607553,
-0.0000406843,
-0.0480776988,
-0.0134747187,
-0.0178906824,
-0.0221282039,
-0.0417561643,
0.0693500191,
-0.014547783,
-0.0299226139,
0.0130657488,
0.008375112,
0.0254851449,
0.0369542986,
0.0659300238,
0.0400260538,
-0.0222749729,
-0.0059552584,
0.0014352485,
0.0592318624,
-0.0343291797,
-0.0167334247,
0.0329975411,
0.0180869363,
0.0573538058,
0.0398710705,
-0.0108071854,
-0.0096770776,
0.032129705,
0.0439178757,
-0.053366404,
0.0760911405,
-0.0024164417,
0.050779108,
-0.0661094785,
-0.007497781,
-0.0298686605,
0.0028352635,
-0.0263365768,
-0.0503960364,
0.0325315706,
0.0025494667,
-0.0053671789,
-0.0340833515,
-0.0142555721,
0.0165934134,
-0.0080105131,
-0.0636532009,
-0.0247891061,
0.0081285434,
-0.014904541,
-0.0273939762,
0.0201674402,
0.0173721369,
0.0183963217,
0.0525439344,
0.0454622246,
-0.0025464352,
-0.0420872606,
0.0341903344,
-0.0509427786,
0.0180410519,
-0.0124954181,
0.0340345949,
-0.0488153845,
-0.0226037875,
-0.0034264834,
-0.0306615848,
-0.0333285928,
0.0757863,
-0.0295823123,
-0.0347563997,
-0.0584191233,
-0.0226545092,
0.0235419031,
-0.0179212689,
-0.0092218798,
-0.0139213577,
0.0025534241,
-0.0061623114,
0.0399757139,
-0.0039815516,
-0.0412756912,
-0.007388413,
2.823e-7,
-0.0310011264,
0.0554304533,
0.0403050147,
0.0085029369,
-0.0038004213,
0.0525380857,
0.0407754332,
0.0329830609,
0.0292349197,
-0.0347816795,
-0.0114859808,
-0.0202785078,
0.0179836024,
0.0146653755,
-0.0769891813,
0.0034208077,
-0.0235500168,
0.0429804921,
-0.0572599396,
-0.0009548601,
0.0652022436,
0.0062073865,
0.0140059423,
0.0171513036,
0.0031182587,
-0.0466461591,
-0.0310291816,
-0.052259054,
-0.0060176766,
-0.012938913,
0.0830277354,
0.0169094186,
0.0253454708,
-0.0023943554,
-0.0158514008,
-0.0544468947,
-0.0042352127,
0.0015102365,
-0.0504688472,
-0.0121040065,
-0.0468544886,
-0.0011455249,
0.0228453428,
-0.0655902177,
0.0048161279,
-0.0125568034,
0.0086820899,
-0.0337868445,
0.0511643067,
-0.0399194993,
-0.0125374375,
-0.0272078328,
-0.0313744135,
-0.0172010995,
0.0110111954,
0.0466268398,
-0.0200965945,
-0.0310811792,
-0.0143506629,
0.0129473507,
-0.0010731146,
-0.0297460034,
-0.0892989039,
0.016916398,
0.0080977436,
-0.0364609957,
-0.0026675484,
2.402550889e-34,
0.0345221423,
-0.0090619214,
0.049170468,
0.0506096296,
0.0556030348,
0.0383182727,
0.0017681454,
0.0126063609,
0.0814758986,
-0.0282191243,
-0.0349595398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13549v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13549v2 | A Survey on Multimodal Large Language Models | 2023-06-23T15:21:52 | 2024-04-01T17:51:54 | Shukang Yin, Chaoyou Fu, Sirui Zhao, Ke Li, Xing Sun, Tong Xu, Enhong Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, Multimodal Large Language Model (MLLM) represented by GPT-4V has
been a new rising research hotspot, which uses powerful Large Language Models
(LLMs) as a brain to perform multimodal tasks. The surprising emergent
capabilities of MLLM, such as writing stories based on images and OCR-free math
reasoning, are rare in traditional multimodal methods, suggesting a potential
path to artificial general intelligence. To this end, both academia and
industry have endeavored to develop MLLMs that can compete with or even better
than GPT-4V, pushing the limit of research at a surprising speed. In this
paper, we aim to trace and summarize the recent progress of MLLMs. First of
all, we present the basic formulation of MLLM and delineate its related
concepts, including architecture, training strategy and data, as well as
evaluation. Then, we introduce research topics about how MLLMs can be extended
to support more granularity, modalities, languages, and scenarios. We continue
with multimodal hallucination and extended techniques, including Multimodal ICL
(M-ICL), Multimodal CoT (M-CoT), and LLM-Aided Visual Reasoning (LAVR). To
conclude the paper, we discuss existing challenges and point out promising
research directions. In light of the fact that the era of MLLM has only just
begun, we will keep updating this survey and hope it can inspire more research.
An associated GitHub link collecting the latest papers is available at
https://github.com/BradyFU/Awesome-Multimodal-Large-Language-Models. | [
0.0097418865,
0.0699598864,
-0.0120435311,
0.0588447899,
-0.065232195,
0.011436386,
0.0392961912,
-0.0054812222,
-0.0119705265,
-0.0824464709,
-0.0347730592,
-0.0500161946,
0.0109170582,
0.0186102092,
0.0556149893,
-0.0860342905,
0.0005018444,
-0.0847513452,
-0.0324359424,
-0.0263512358,
-0.0057145394,
0.0134605151,
-0.0327435434,
0.0357638523,
-0.0476544201,
-0.0296233837,
-0.0179786514,
-0.0000550673,
0.0054353019,
0.0068778871,
-0.0454401933,
0.031796582,
0.0854199156,
0.011302704,
0.0000021354,
-0.0614420138,
0.0029426734,
-0.0085977949,
0.0577273518,
-0.0303005893,
0.0120315021,
-0.0408550203,
0.0107086925,
-0.0376177803,
-0.0333409384,
-0.0258881748,
0.058783371,
0.0631666332,
0.0727887675,
0.0460982881,
-0.0206716713,
-0.0817849115,
0.0393564664,
0.0111012561,
0.0413462818,
-0.0248055235,
0.0113421809,
0.0566977859,
0.0176654328,
-0.0175373964,
-0.062282078,
0.0443795808,
0.0496484675,
0.0026163412,
-0.0346368253,
0.0702489465,
-0.0112585044,
-0.0273686592,
-0.020230772,
0.0565099008,
-0.0320168696,
-0.0127748745,
-0.0081148911,
0.0324958079,
-0.0094050784,
0.0072078868,
-0.0698939487,
0.0858314037,
-0.0189558659,
0.0203194954,
-0.0209101848,
-0.0336534493,
0.0072751809,
-0.0033050207,
-0.0271377396,
0.030883465,
0.0258462243,
-0.0023657961,
-0.0050632856,
-0.0091012157,
-0.0575226806,
-0.0288245175,
0.0115113836,
0.0530254766,
0.016408138,
-0.0033236244,
-0.0369435512,
-0.0036156387,
-0.019758625,
-0.038845405,
0.0356465243,
0.0129465451,
-0.0442707799,
0.0499488413,
-0.0319029167,
0.0432847328,
-0.0325288586,
0.0444353633,
0.0028808212,
-0.0156959612,
-0.0587297007,
-0.0178017896,
-0.0447441973,
-0.0046646483,
-0.0134037733,
-0.0459822081,
-0.0043702219,
0.0180632938,
-0.0132286707,
0.0076238243,
-0.030484356,
0.0092500448,
0.0113904122,
-0.0490970574,
-0.009748972,
0.0192516595,
-0.0060583013,
0.0051425258,
-0.015503237,
-0.0413380116,
0.0195095446,
0.0432466008,
0.0031033512,
-0.0453650951,
0.0028141055,
0.0946777761,
-0.0164428968,
-0.0281532072,
-0.0177359674,
-0.0244225077,
-0.0147948051,
-0.1045743898,
0.0474202,
-0.0801944733,
0.0303228982,
-0.0042880275,
0.018760154,
-0.021978423,
-0.0026186998,
0.0183036476,
0.0015969629,
0.1062673852,
0.0229327846,
0.0084882015,
0.0424528569,
0.0138865607,
0.0001225735,
0.0509135649,
0.0582889915,
0.0323088132,
-0.0049832226,
-0.0261020381,
0.0396361649,
0.0507627167,
-0.0373240374,
-0.0101997647,
-0.0412973054,
-0.0324979983,
0.0286823064,
0.0458624512,
0.0184645671,
0.0723105147,
-0.0347140245,
-0.021099627,
0.1017914861,
0.0360386334,
0.0154544767,
-0.0096504157,
0.0568929911,
-0.0176673345,
0.0095361443,
0.0025316931,
-0.0712547377,
0.0710939094,
-0.0004705739,
0.0038545062,
0.013222469,
0.0357152149,
-0.0157097913,
-0.0086293407,
-0.0125121996,
-0.0151095577,
0.0027813951,
0.0150333634,
0.0716081783,
-0.017583156,
-0.042360872,
-0.0014923138,
0.0043603564,
-0.0158756375,
0.0107545927,
-0.0361814909,
0.0074114222,
0.0249921717,
0.0453264304,
-0.0169953145,
-0.0200364534,
-0.0233821776,
0.023204539,
0.0440178849,
0.0024762559,
0.0121582989,
-0.005104139,
-0.0594850257,
0.0044518271,
-0.0205895267,
-0.0013426599,
0.0117737772,
-0.0168372877,
0.0130742565,
-0.0304188821,
-0.0112246629,
0.0132841086,
0.0172028746,
0.0094522126,
0.0212371815,
-0.0625047758,
0.0091383969,
-0.0024526191,
-0.0077415523,
-0.0157354474,
-0.0103750108,
0.0186008345,
-0.0496985093,
-0.0065989741,
0.0343311727,
-0.0432669595,
-0.0267231707,
0.0323308371,
-0.0692855418,
-0.0080893422,
0.0072684311,
-0.0221135169,
-0.0150145059,
0.0279978588,
-0.0168045349,
0.0143425334,
-0.0651852787,
-0.0018957304,
0.0387565829,
0.004841269,
-0.0301225595,
0.067569077,
-0.024124207,
-0.0181566235,
0.0148631493,
0.021290876,
0.0103386324,
-0.0293503348,
-0.0219508912,
0.048923336,
0.0080253333,
0.0174978897,
-0.0293755755,
0.0075760642,
-0.0235374682,
-0.0063383719,
-0.1164562181,
-0.0240673833,
-0.0082503082,
-0.0326818675,
-0.002625729,
-0.0154347792,
0.0072807251,
-0.0113142496,
-0.0237718485,
0.0200458933,
0.0257082004,
0.0161973182,
-0.0017182075,
0.0039086351,
0.004386052,
0.0369161814,
-0.006654894,
-0.0285715926,
0.0618232824,
-0.0059891725,
-0.0305463616,
-0.0551011041,
-0.0089474795,
-0.0414681286,
0.0450757109,
-0.0424767397,
-0.0025650298,
0.0362946726,
-0.0461235903,
0.0637448654,
0.071131736,
0.0067347325,
0.0215231162,
0.0642433092,
-0.0296382904,
0.0008850763,
0.0158245526,
0.0226367842,
0.009194782,
-0.0040540639,
-0.0160427187,
-0.0407902375,
0.047704652,
0.0027999233,
0.0169670824,
-0.0531159863,
0.0244440194,
-0.0013358208,
-0.0575137846,
-0.0287630968,
0.0059599304,
-0.0192085635,
0.0350684412,
-0.0312492047,
-0.0564976893,
0.0347753428,
-0.0508867316,
-0.0321915187,
0.0324051194,
0.0243131872,
-0.0263220463,
0.1011990607,
0.0400371477,
0.0401428044,
-0.033064235,
-0.0005463331,
-0.043391414,
-0.0020141152,
-0.0018635676,
0.006976096,
0.0643891841,
-0.0732763633,
0.011475293,
-0.0123192305,
-0.0226851292,
0.011689066,
-0.0044320691,
-0.0280214362,
0.0008756376,
-0.0676379129,
0.0044396608,
-0.012611785,
0.05658371,
0.0439817086,
0.0178390909,
-0.0155571448,
-0.0002774126,
-0.0366026983,
0.0473578721,
0.0556416288,
0.0323086306,
-0.0297260582,
-0.0641953796,
-0.0151345674,
0.0431386195,
0.0214895327,
0.0064556412,
-0.0590675361,
0.0616888143,
0.0127732521,
0.0501670763,
-0.0164613109,
-0.0004285632,
0.0633827671,
-0.0591627136,
0.0092624249,
0.0685031861,
-0.0056605889,
-0.0631787032,
-0.0087009836,
-0.016087018,
0.03415104,
0.0086688772,
0.0047520646,
-0.0802930817,
-0.0571791865,
0.002662672,
-0.0404394642,
0.0259449892,
-0.0283767674,
-0.0208046474,
-0.0741744563,
0.0788179338,
0.0033307225,
-0.0185067952,
-0.0438878834,
0.0014006345,
-0.0137139196,
0.0362298749,
-0.0107436823,
0.0018677925,
0.0067256317,
-0.0123454919,
-0.0042728232,
0.0096299462,
-0.0294111371,
0.0345306247,
-0.0347938351,
-0.0005198137,
0.042374339,
0.0333172418,
-0.0212880895,
-0.0468609035,
0.0420801304,
0.0308514424,
0.0110422913,
-0.0067150868,
0.0248653796,
-0.0164023694,
-0.0242078509,
0.0035020376,
0.0364900082,
0.0027279332,
-0.0391326249,
-0.0208279863,
0.0861336663,
-0.0527989417,
-0.0354392603,
-0.0145745836,
0.0184276048,
-0.0299259964,
0.0540679991,
0.0206186026,
-0.0520738475,
-0.0612083785,
-0.0087601971,
0.0115605881,
-0.0163495727,
-0.0343520157,
0.0042760759,
0.0282134563,
0.0027925048,
-0.0360700153,
-0.0175541211,
0.0447666086,
0.0762557834,
-0.0001294636,
-0.0001648393,
-0.0131548392,
0.0020055422,
-0.0256697685,
0.0478072539,
-0.0414940119,
0.021578351,
-0.0265401565,
0.0034273942,
0.0209714044,
-0.0839151666,
0.0043111406,
0.0514070094,
-0.1003346667,
-0.0467924252,
-0.0298132747,
0.0555860363,
0.0206177235,
0.0505053885,
0.0142411478,
-0.0769709274,
0.027379375,
0.0176973529,
0.0197895579,
0.0439897738,
-0.0085813031,
-0.0000277607,
0.0037554908,
0.0183337629,
-0.0102336761,
0.0126927784,
-0.0018937319,
0.0194643643,
-0.0130743105,
0.0258083344,
0.007836747,
-0.0216423217,
0.0149681829,
-0.0302887037,
-0.0038937994,
-0.04192416,
-0.0156945512,
-0.0153405331,
-0.0209575202,
-0.0785132572,
0.0155229075,
0.0143421572,
0.0188912582,
0.0166398734,
-0.0191491265,
0.0314149745,
0.0021175316,
-0.0246652719,
0.0143161304,
0.0271133129,
-0.0358503871,
0.0164406337,
0.0201771129,
0.0034392925,
0.0199221428,
-0.0640319511,
0.0339485072,
-0.0175331496,
0.098192744,
0.0235627089,
-0.0528912582,
-0.0258960351,
0.0315322131,
-0.0295304582,
-0.0673746616,
0.0146162994,
0.0486255102,
0.0865630656,
0.0421783924,
0.0449804142,
-0.0627160966,
-0.0027591863,
-0.0107788872,
0.0428250842,
0.052295398,
-0.042437315,
0.0341510847,
0.0270920806,
0.010201646,
-0.0113118812,
0.0460334048,
-0.0206669588,
0.0364332683,
0.0046314574,
0.011887745,
-0.0359242037,
-0.0381852537,
0.0325312428,
0.0200557318,
0.0003854205,
0.0012028971,
-0.0293584801,
-0.0595617592,
-0.0151436999,
0.02075723,
-0.026719898,
-0.0105973436,
0.0314292759,
0.0654814616,
0.0055521247,
-0.0272754822,
-0.0156399254,
-0.0122061083,
0.036624331,
-0.0040277727,
0.0056622322,
-5.952206379e-33,
-0.0075986129,
-0.0276170503,
0.0722556189,
-0.01202338,
-0.0362528712,
-0.0171836577,
-0.0169737991,
0.015487385,
0.0091877766,
0.0012215561,
0.0297067314,
-0.0421713218,
-0.0000455369,
0.037470933,
0.0041563148,
0.0150141213,
-0.0182501376,
0.0034171354,
-0.0105513493,
0.013046843,
0.0184479207,
0.0088314498,
0.0701014772,
-0.0233303122,
-0.0065917345,
-0.0078416457,
-0.0396994837,
0.0345081724,
-0.0410100631,
0.0532173216,
-0.0618532673,
0.011815941,
0.0550796427,
0.0086148931,
-0.0311145522,
0.014891319,
-0.0403033122,
0.0149445208,
0.0219979174,
0.0329595655,
-0.0875185207,
-0.0117405951,
0.0618053898,
-0.03845945,
-0.0095116012,
-0.0290065371,
0.0476681851,
-0.0085010016,
0.0088288616,
0.0332856774,
-0.0570723563,
0.000337261,
-0.0011272317,
-0.0296082459,
0.0447592065,
0.0439973995,
0.0065259514,
0.0407994054,
-0.0364455394,
0.0374529101,
-0.0368469059,
-0.0177193917,
0.0819739699,
0.0232296437,
0.0241949446,
0.0523141474,
0.04521171,
-0.0331935212,
-0.0497173294,
-0.0053558564,
0.0465430059,
0.0620100908,
0.0207044743,
0.0468857624,
0.0033760574,
0.0567433313,
0.0029385777,
-0.0188901406,
-0.0298586097,
0.0580493808,
0.0706177205,
0.0085275061,
0.0155297434,
-0.0127993003,
-0.0306355357,
-0.0028542525,
-0.0335603803,
-0.0106352745,
0.0442430303,
-0.0035531742,
0.0244271643,
0.0281884484,
0.1054310203,
-0.034003552,
-0.02121659,
0.0042097699,
-0.0236692764,
0.0841393173,
-0.0037973714,
0.0299605597,
-0.0042628995,
-0.0282997228,
0.0278454758,
-0.0067426758,
0.0173484497,
0.0130007416,
-0.0028100177,
0.0387487598,
0.0001258665,
-0.0042682439,
-0.0586983822,
-0.0139007894,
0.0288408119,
0.026609499,
0.0571023934,
-0.0001265266,
-0.0392092206,
0.0044399113,
-0.0063622873,
-0.0147310253,
-0.0081876591,
-0.0356534533,
-0.0592344217,
0.0256178938,
-0.0112775741,
0.026254179,
-0.0464161597,
-0.0634833202,
0.0131082917,
-0.0601688288,
-0.0007889298,
0.0445483327,
2.761e-7,
0.0052308324,
0.0322028026,
0.0045713591,
0.0119317845,
0.0353168249,
0.0352120958,
-0.0309288576,
0.0289020427,
0.0086941645,
-0.0362128243,
-0.0255552493,
0.0746209472,
0.0292841699,
-0.0017992151,
-0.0321709551,
0.0065806792,
0.0070385551,
-0.0217028502,
-0.0741426274,
0.0114220046,
0.0529642105,
0.0348700471,
-0.0161739346,
-0.0605481677,
0.0387194902,
-0.0473785959,
0.08642371,
-0.0313689001,
-0.0310342964,
-0.0116019985,
-0.0156062096,
0.0004100159,
-0.0082642073,
0.0251087137,
0.0444479287,
-0.051425904,
0.0411190651,
0.0215994809,
-0.0146487644,
-0.0174478199,
0.001460753,
0.0137293376,
-0.0592991933,
-0.0789788663,
0.0948690772,
-0.0217963569,
-0.0316567384,
-0.0025376142,
-0.0024831051,
-0.0539638735,
-0.0012535952,
-0.0167992227,
-0.0292140711,
0.0254738219,
0.014384673,
-0.0022926428,
-0.019680107,
-0.0714623258,
0.0041050049,
0.013579906,
-0.0724478588,
-0.0054550734,
-0.0354430862,
-0.0224192273,
0.0457978472,
-0.0717354119,
-0.0563599989,
2.479296895e-34,
0.0139306523,
0.0018009306,
0.0248497706,
0.0131124267,
0.0245642569,
0.0046907212,
-0.0151569294,
0.0074090185,
-0.0306875221,
-0.0791723728,
-0.0363672934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.16282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.16282v1 | ChatGPT may excel in States Medical Licensing Examination but falters in basic Linear Algebra | 2023-06-23T15:19:29 | 2023-06-23T15:19:29 | Eli Bagno, Thierry Dana-Picard, Shulamit Reches | cs.CL | cs.CL | The emergence of ChatGPT has been rapid, and although it has demonstrated
positive impacts in certain domains, its influence is not universally
advantageous. Our analysis focuses on ChatGPT's capabilities in Mathematics
Education, particularly in teaching basic Linear Algebra. While there are
instances where ChatGPT delivers accurate and well-motivated answers, it is
crucial to recognize numerous cases where it makes significant mathematical
errors and fails in logical inference. These occurrences raise concerns
regarding the system's genuine understanding of mathematics, as it appears to
rely more on visual patterns rather than true comprehension. Additionally, the
suitability of ChatGPT as a teacher for students also warrants consideration. | [
-0.0198358819,
0.0187476687,
-0.0392722376,
0.0166007914,
-0.0459787473,
0.0387209356,
0.0345448628,
0.0331189148,
0.0397744365,
-0.0124841351,
0.0442257449,
0.0293621738,
-0.0095243696,
-0.0266258288,
0.0418925434,
-0.0647173375,
-0.0217674021,
0.0436871424,
-0.0060981321,
0.0010684112,
0.0027917942,
0.0066158585,
-0.0870854482,
0.0174235348,
-0.0429443903,
-0.078700833,
0.0486406609,
-0.0419282243,
0.0065870648,
-0.0122156153,
-0.0069191847,
0.020853499,
0.0260657538,
0.0181060079,
0.0000024407,
-0.0209730286,
-0.0225797463,
0.0181700066,
-0.0248699468,
0.0657553151,
-0.0113964016,
0.0775770545,
-0.0078830458,
-0.0186985303,
-0.0576586612,
-0.0065263854,
0.0093949884,
0.0179401077,
0.0011626408,
0.0191268418,
0.0095907263,
0.0190915205,
0.0159906466,
0.013717521,
0.0666853935,
-0.0438537747,
0.0050718873,
0.0551576652,
0.059084069,
0.0047057886,
-0.047433719,
0.0310329534,
0.0251987167,
-0.0085347956,
0.0351615436,
0.0194254182,
-0.0409572609,
0.0620118864,
-0.0285779592,
0.0176585764,
0.0275436044,
-0.0320677534,
0.0441630445,
0.0438798666,
0.03076341,
0.016307652,
-0.089719519,
0.0175889414,
-0.0486099385,
-0.0208881218,
-0.0503604561,
-0.0353932679,
-0.0319178402,
0.0303414296,
0.0633656904,
-0.0270868968,
0.028040139,
-0.0033185568,
-0.0406984128,
0.0454703234,
-0.0101572676,
0.0202400405,
0.019269241,
0.0569632128,
0.0334895365,
-0.0081227673,
0.0203644875,
-0.0094285198,
-0.0034166407,
-0.0612278096,
0.0413837247,
0.0684822127,
0.0043418272,
0.0073955567,
-0.0300910063,
0.0899557769,
-0.0173516311,
0.0993387848,
-0.047071632,
0.116630584,
-0.0457762368,
0.0347721875,
-0.0436377935,
0.006034256,
0.0558272563,
0.0539438501,
-0.0736073405,
-0.0177172478,
-0.0443903841,
0.0539548546,
-0.1015320197,
-0.020901598,
0.0184116624,
-0.017029155,
-0.0080965078,
0.0219493471,
0.0309388805,
-0.0058221091,
-0.036028903,
-0.0382355861,
-0.0373964868,
0.0348990932,
-0.0225509498,
-0.0027020245,
0.0023757562,
0.0452485606,
-0.0173360333,
-0.0034512219,
0.0178985018,
-0.005304466,
-0.023856489,
-0.0313356407,
0.018620545,
-0.0338863246,
0.0080034174,
-0.0071098111,
0.0043896777,
0.0443955548,
0.0081569366,
0.0140425777,
0.0050775446,
0.0364285633,
0.0245301723,
-0.0025293846,
0.0254535824,
0.0425057784,
-0.0396296903,
-0.0277172662,
0.0128054973,
-0.036339283,
-0.011198217,
-0.0452998951,
0.0716759562,
-0.0284195524,
0.0255561639,
-0.0231471732,
0.01799074,
0.0283274557,
0.0343097225,
0.0331166871,
-0.0713316649,
0.0164138079,
-0.0747115836,
0.0705048218,
-0.0154257417,
0.0810330883,
0.0226504914,
0.0590865612,
0.0015217635,
-0.0047006663,
0.0587681904,
0.0079740779,
-0.0601460449,
0.0152742816,
-0.0458369814,
-0.0076623773,
-0.0539996698,
0.0219764113,
-0.0070248898,
-0.0338287354,
-0.0284725334,
0.0077722445,
-0.0241640154,
0.0088409903,
0.0402878411,
-0.0644539818,
0.0259822048,
0.0303390231,
0.0214365814,
-0.0310350973,
0.0161845572,
-0.0542779006,
0.0116783287,
0.020472059,
0.0267897751,
0.0025559247,
-0.0221808814,
-0.0475136414,
0.0657195076,
-0.0111382827,
0.0550209396,
0.0144424215,
-0.0631701499,
-0.0113513609,
0.0186275765,
-0.0065492052,
0.0487694517,
0.0058870101,
-0.0148743372,
0.0199194085,
-0.0126541518,
-0.000871077,
0.026710188,
-0.0090242261,
-0.0588571355,
-0.0414930321,
0.0001900203,
-0.0017270579,
-0.0023246717,
0.0048325257,
0.0042333449,
-0.0187166054,
-0.0357706286,
0.0097569432,
0.0001208647,
-0.0621349961,
-0.0415921211,
-0.0026967528,
0.0114245145,
-0.0990755633,
-0.0214329865,
-0.057592947,
0.0127115203,
-0.0227450859,
0.0450961329,
-0.0408931337,
0.0108478516,
-0.0024628162,
-0.0032156918,
-0.0021242835,
-0.0537701584,
-0.0052896189,
-0.0094844038,
0.0467163362,
0.0510486998,
0.0478793606,
-0.027032271,
0.0459719449,
0.0131719662,
-0.0094432048,
-0.0162919257,
-0.028914351,
0.0254215878,
-0.0278973877,
0.0529593527,
0.0103401523,
0.0262701679,
0.0285420269,
-0.0239788536,
-0.0027535907,
0.0036262833,
0.0289575979,
-0.0808268636,
-0.0453530513,
0.0005089117,
-0.0030819268,
-0.0095111756,
-0.0087681748,
-0.0588895828,
-0.0150102451,
-0.0078815585,
-0.0143441707,
-0.0259577036,
-0.0056808433,
-0.0542309582,
0.0086081661,
0.0440800563,
0.043550279,
0.026955083,
0.0263120551,
-0.0141792689,
-0.0291926619,
-0.0149569483,
-0.001501332,
0.0330101997,
-0.0262517612,
-0.0395045355,
-0.0001313071,
-0.007591167,
0.0617138334,
0.0129230311,
-0.0405644812,
-0.0073484778,
0.0079980902,
-0.0227044187,
0.025706606,
0.0269085895,
-0.0217772257,
-0.0532647856,
-0.0244508144,
0.0116914129,
-0.0226591248,
-0.0454440713,
0.0217487644,
-0.0623525605,
0.0602464266,
-0.076397799,
-0.0187354796,
-0.0025233224,
-0.0040920009,
0.0284057315,
0.016715169,
0.0178905297,
0.0161664858,
-0.0307297837,
-0.0711188912,
0.0038240852,
-0.0488378368,
-0.0246872567,
-0.0160590149,
0.0162841976,
-0.0639687926,
-0.0082711885,
-0.0170125682,
-0.0049644127,
0.0415355861,
-0.0553528927,
0.0473590083,
-0.0175102577,
-0.0160075668,
-0.0402293056,
-0.0341254957,
-0.0507540256,
0.0606810451,
0.0396385156,
-0.0502230003,
0.0038814067,
-0.0194260571,
0.0138231097,
-0.0302833151,
0.0196232442,
0.0067160078,
-0.0487405285,
-0.0248152427,
0.0235880744,
-0.0119122844,
-0.0084244944,
0.0046950737,
0.0416360758,
-0.0536252707,
0.0078340312,
0.0611633882,
0.0250971392,
0.0005586222,
0.0225892719,
0.0497011542,
0.0285344031,
0.0348126367,
-0.0178851299,
0.0298468824,
-0.0378884785,
-0.0069373678,
-0.0202070195,
0.0335939378,
-0.0140521452,
-0.0129781161,
-0.0094493413,
-0.0139735052,
-0.0446584374,
-0.0340730436,
0.0301576983,
-0.1196117476,
0.0568824001,
-0.0324564427,
0.0205586217,
0.0001698206,
0.0104079004,
-0.0243430659,
-0.0206145924,
0.0278228149,
0.0251356643,
-0.0461916476,
-0.0164034124,
0.037147291,
-0.0142500298,
0.0246591941,
0.0358301513,
0.0231056903,
-0.0457261615,
0.0688592121,
0.052072674,
-0.0566617139,
-0.0041059698,
-0.0093939006,
0.0628307462,
-0.0079782074,
-0.0366546288,
-0.0003518349,
-0.0813072845,
-0.0896468759,
0.015624783,
0.048427403,
-0.0286389105,
-0.0012270203,
0.0227043312,
-0.0025209158,
0.0209810603,
-0.0809392557,
0.0412178226,
-0.0058918651,
-0.0291234404,
0.0338743143,
0.0714240521,
-0.0066162506,
-0.0190702397,
-0.0142365983,
0.016633261,
-0.0420832932,
0.0060764728,
-0.0039403117,
0.0338949002,
-0.0199833494,
-0.0034768821,
0.0226070974,
0.0083432915,
-0.0847777948,
-0.0089676091,
0.0054146731,
0.0280487947,
0.0426027104,
-0.0258953497,
0.046697896,
0.0509929024,
-0.029224297,
-0.0189480204,
0.0053014653,
0.0209965426,
-0.0075036301,
0.0452959314,
0.0380022898,
-0.0099614719,
0.034671355,
0.0363575406,
-0.0709856674,
-0.019069979,
-0.05192855,
-0.0012392384,
-0.0431840569,
0.0027021237,
0.0104359072,
0.0272810366,
0.0289588198,
-0.0671901181,
0.0235238839,
0.0767697394,
-0.0075674797,
0.0166996643,
0.0281504784,
0.0252202693,
-0.033795625,
0.000032072,
0.020311486,
-0.0351508632,
0.0247104652,
-0.0141884219,
0.0209066831,
0.0068523041,
-0.0101647284,
-0.0012805482,
-0.0119282305,
0.0408695117,
0.0391318649,
0.0467093885,
0.0292206034,
0.0109444102,
0.0131351715,
-0.0335083641,
0.0342616849,
-0.0122147026,
-0.0482474342,
0.0088091753,
-0.0101271681,
-0.0451667383,
-0.0120918052,
0.0024663331,
0.0284286421,
-0.0229249932,
0.0495184474,
-0.0361067057,
-0.0600651801,
0.0354261734,
-0.0426747836,
0.0023377952,
-0.0134427035,
0.0051873247,
0.0380749553,
0.0031999983,
0.0861503184,
0.0344512351,
0.0263938867,
0.0447562486,
-0.0170887951,
-0.0324865431,
-0.0818016976,
-0.0081515871,
0.1040032357,
0.0045305961,
0.0307637975,
0.0380239747,
-0.0407103635,
0.0151790855,
0.0087420773,
0.0205759928,
-0.0357100666,
-0.0248704199,
0.0543556921,
0.0168657582,
0.0434934087,
-0.0573046468,
0.0015279725,
-0.0593767725,
0.0215393733,
-0.0118171461,
0.0071571721,
-0.0234077144,
-0.0244031567,
0.0125771621,
0.005118357,
0.0469034389,
0.007036393,
-0.1024536192,
-0.0301655643,
-0.0201442,
0.0057682227,
0.0068761213,
-0.0152098406,
0.0248015486,
0.0159216058,
0.0080104806,
-0.0272193588,
0.0481072851,
0.0475311093,
-0.0350570418,
-0.0417993143,
-0.0041244007,
-5.851763325e-33,
0.016294118,
-0.0356135219,
0.0730725527,
0.0797214583,
-0.0420656949,
-0.0301149804,
0.0204349067,
0.0706473142,
-0.0224851929,
-0.0010686879,
-0.0014460771,
0.0195389427,
0.003285089,
0.0488755219,
0.0089024976,
-0.0093147876,
-0.0247596595,
0.0180648789,
-0.0051648663,
-0.0088234413,
-0.0747439563,
0.0153621007,
0.0878541917,
-0.0613147095,
0.0069840811,
-0.0004071644,
0.0189793818,
-0.0478306673,
-0.0651232228,
0.0113222161,
-0.0183689017,
0.0211553499,
-0.0118751638,
-0.0116635999,
-0.0033050338,
-0.0199748557,
0.0122815035,
-0.0218846444,
-0.0020073885,
0.0330419727,
-0.0140992505,
-0.0004714557,
0.0006102882,
-0.0082059596,
-0.0766718462,
-0.0233276915,
0.0302682836,
-0.0137785841,
0.0343947969,
0.026412122,
0.0093621537,
0.0078012277,
-0.060462743,
-0.0137294065,
-0.01385534,
-0.0089790421,
-0.0289927255,
-0.0740259364,
-0.0092694955,
0.0313855633,
0.042015437,
-0.0173318088,
-0.0022362489,
-0.0771637857,
-0.0336983837,
0.0055694534,
0.0336189419,
-0.0187555198,
-0.0402185433,
-0.0653860271,
0.0065545756,
0.0294969026,
0.055163756,
0.032770697,
0.0221813675,
-0.0001171325,
-0.0771946684,
0.0124631897,
0.020046996,
0.0389569476,
-0.0280712526,
-0.0365318432,
-0.0922982842,
-0.0523290224,
0.0317774266,
0.016534159,
-0.0190899353,
-0.0156372748,
0.0244882219,
-0.0565793104,
0.0321871825,
0.0251254365,
-0.0069741011,
-0.0163422395,
-0.0606195554,
-0.0450819619,
0.007011401,
0.0101308543,
0.0137608116,
-0.003728691,
-0.0848276466,
0.0245354883,
-0.0143939881,
-0.0060524405,
0.0219293572,
-0.0003226585,
0.034576185,
-0.0072419727,
-0.014497418,
0.0019797767,
0.0009560794,
-0.0190849397,
0.0700246394,
-0.040916089,
0.0255117975,
0.0162047669,
0.0025807465,
0.0350673534,
-0.0084494893,
0.0084992656,
-0.0230151508,
-0.017830411,
-0.0505669042,
-0.0416653082,
-0.0166496132,
0.0050047906,
-0.0042017121,
0.0251463428,
0.0029899057,
-0.0970422253,
0.0200445801,
-0.0580361076,
3.069e-7,
0.0276332404,
0.0561728328,
0.0065456666,
-0.0335984714,
0.0124658234,
-0.008139628,
-0.0759435594,
0.0132680899,
0.0416027904,
0.0325201079,
0.0289825778,
0.0034513439,
0.0363455787,
0.0411369354,
0.026821211,
-0.00335271,
-0.0221152585,
-0.0197525527,
-0.0129548823,
0.0442970134,
0.1197020337,
-0.0798869208,
0.0503800251,
-0.0121814664,
-0.0087799653,
-0.0172724277,
0.0677920356,
0.0137937712,
0.0181930643,
-0.0049242759,
0.0353493094,
-0.0276466385,
0.0054250062,
0.0270748511,
0.0168609787,
-0.0297848955,
-0.0059765615,
0.0589856952,
0.0359268188,
0.0621595085,
-0.0010102381,
-0.0069277529,
0.0006461156,
-0.0211769193,
0.0582638085,
-0.0241584983,
0.010143484,
-0.0099168681,
-0.0443838201,
-0.0222963691,
0.0381609164,
0.0290549062,
-0.0110985171,
-0.020220397,
0.0121841505,
-0.0171177816,
0.0363956615,
-0.0029231866,
0.0410079435,
0.0078035998,
-0.0380303301,
-0.0389862061,
-0.0037953432,
0.0351174138,
0.050720159,
0.0181235317,
-0.0629429966,
2.860469994e-34,
-0.0230267122,
-0.0037618703,
0.0894359499,
-0.0433730111,
-0.0234018341,
0.0247117653,
0.038931895,
-0.0074037388,
0.0170593299,
0.0170959849,
-0.0371284895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13501v1 | Knowledge-Infused Self Attention Transformers | 2023-06-23T13:55:01 | 2023-06-23T13:55:01 | Kaushik Roy, Yuxin Zi, Vignesh Narayanan, Manas Gaur, Amit Sheth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based language models have achieved impressive success in various
natural language processing tasks due to their ability to capture complex
dependencies and contextual information using self-attention mechanisms.
However, they are not without limitations. These limitations include
hallucinations, where they produce incorrect outputs with high confidence, and
alignment issues, where they generate unhelpful and unsafe outputs for human
users. These limitations stem from the absence of implicit and missing context
in the data alone. To address this, researchers have explored augmenting these
models with external knowledge from knowledge graphs to provide the necessary
additional context. However, the ad-hoc nature of existing methods makes it
difficult to properly analyze the effects of knowledge infusion on the many
moving parts or components of a transformer. This paper introduces a systematic
method for infusing knowledge into different components of a transformer-based
model. A modular framework is proposed to identify specific components within
the transformer architecture, such as the self-attention mechanism, encoder
layers, or the input embedding layer, where knowledge infusion can be applied.
Additionally, extensive experiments are conducted on the General Language
Understanding Evaluation (GLUE) benchmark tasks, and the findings are reported.
This systematic approach aims to facilitate more principled approaches to
incorporating knowledge into language model architectures. | [
0.0451525636,
-0.0001353039,
-0.0189174395,
0.0707088336,
-0.0146856178,
0.0033642279,
-0.0240032934,
-0.0393688045,
0.0298779942,
-0.054555662,
-0.0556097291,
0.0020902581,
0.0001406597,
0.0413276404,
0.0413693003,
-0.0360251181,
0.0561658628,
-0.0242521185,
-0.0216315314,
0.0218094699,
-0.0104304869,
-0.0002154667,
0.0114568686,
0.02717405,
-0.026973391,
-0.026982436,
-0.0056065018,
0.0019869166,
0.0000407607,
-0.0103691006,
0.0024791029,
0.0470534042,
0.0092909299,
0.0402663015,
0.000002286,
-0.0398207754,
0.0014825274,
-0.0159324184,
-0.0432706699,
-0.0307290107,
-0.0068814983,
-0.0366335437,
-0.0018766684,
-0.0009327699,
-0.036537692,
-0.0023130605,
0.0383108035,
0.0569451526,
0.069434613,
0.0492334925,
-0.0166672207,
-0.0243619736,
0.0241402853,
-0.0046678297,
0.0058889338,
-0.0152766369,
0.032084696,
0.0222138818,
-0.0080677485,
-0.0206824932,
-0.0432687923,
0.0649403706,
0.0353762433,
-0.0154300602,
0.0615899451,
0.0437730663,
-0.0484098904,
-0.046117615,
-0.0273360517,
0.0671787858,
-0.0391726047,
-0.040147122,
-0.0278361849,
0.0099862088,
0.0047510052,
0.0400586016,
-0.0312962346,
-0.0035914539,
-0.0043152389,
0.010101771,
0.0145422984,
0.0360085778,
0.025956247,
-0.0134054534,
-0.0485244505,
0.1150587127,
0.0043651955,
-0.047451701,
0.0060426532,
-0.0012727779,
0.0015540507,
-0.0385545008,
0.0330747254,
0.0465737171,
0.0367669091,
0.0449026041,
-0.0225053187,
-0.0232269559,
0.0039520347,
-0.078610152,
-0.0160597898,
0.0330405347,
-0.0274692979,
0.0719082803,
-0.0344994068,
0.0653984547,
-0.0282766186,
0.0521057919,
-0.0268282946,
-0.0246491376,
-0.0291111693,
-0.0414649732,
-0.061961282,
0.0208155941,
-0.0179672409,
-0.0511744842,
-0.0026803103,
0.0637349412,
-0.0180604942,
-0.0105043231,
0.0250830315,
0.0282057058,
-0.0148717267,
-0.0320726596,
-0.0200259835,
0.0514097773,
0.0055857315,
-0.0354212746,
-0.005548975,
-0.0527193211,
-0.0352448709,
0.0299092904,
-0.0080551831,
-0.0188293438,
-0.0351512991,
0.0612402149,
0.0183737483,
-0.0408384204,
-0.0027087734,
-0.0157749988,
-0.039104104,
-0.0450931899,
0.0068776798,
-0.0376858152,
0.0269935671,
0.0183528904,
-0.0107648717,
-0.0570300594,
0.0121916272,
0.0131276585,
-0.0246896595,
0.0696786344,
-0.0296345446,
0.0227419697,
0.0236332249,
0.0229256358,
-0.0022782197,
0.0604189746,
0.0287943427,
0.0049637896,
-0.0078292601,
-0.04504361,
0.042985592,
0.0233180542,
0.0147373667,
-0.0257695764,
-0.0174698196,
0.0160628874,
-0.0367359966,
0.0167320743,
0.0405426845,
0.0372615978,
-0.0044059921,
0.0094965389,
0.0724891201,
0.0337087139,
0.0541867949,
0.0436061956,
0.0170601215,
0.0177814122,
-0.0052231452,
0.0046891491,
-0.0691080689,
0.0648882762,
-0.0081697479,
0.0269050375,
-0.0032988389,
0.0307228696,
-0.0244034678,
-0.0458273962,
-0.0158710517,
0.0050990377,
0.0228804667,
0.0238399189,
0.0614521168,
0.052671764,
-0.0509451516,
0.0639147237,
0.0234578159,
-0.0301450342,
0.0384626128,
-0.0418709144,
-0.0039578858,
0.0874286965,
0.0497156605,
-0.0169872846,
-0.0357506536,
0.0025155982,
-0.0220153537,
0.0569715574,
0.0143681206,
0.0078532016,
-0.0298401676,
-0.0343062952,
-0.0319323279,
-0.0222832393,
-0.0010508551,
0.0155989537,
-0.0140062971,
-0.0191439092,
0.0155680878,
-0.0383600555,
0.008045706,
0.0383291394,
-0.0296073426,
-0.017328484,
-0.0321651809,
0.0071954085,
0.0122182928,
0.0063543296,
0.0110378945,
0.0249700379,
0.0401349775,
-0.0237173345,
-0.050268691,
0.0409476198,
-0.0850027502,
-0.0320171788,
0.0143966926,
-0.0428463779,
-0.0190527719,
0.0062721809,
0.0087437583,
-0.0527819693,
0.0442357771,
-0.0595576391,
0.0717820376,
-0.0545351133,
0.0354627296,
0.0093725659,
0.0463785902,
-0.0063361591,
0.0621768758,
-0.0042771501,
0.0006117829,
-0.0132694347,
-0.0038062995,
0.0052565108,
0.024048917,
-0.0320608318,
-0.0289123841,
-0.0318202339,
0.0127526829,
0.0030635281,
-0.0493512116,
-0.0636258498,
-0.0151925506,
-0.0625867397,
-0.0062297434,
-0.0294783898,
0.0155144362,
0.0361017734,
0.0226193294,
-0.0050633964,
-0.0371944048,
-0.0108272014,
-0.0029496823,
-0.0173379611,
0.0047774445,
0.0167716071,
-0.016018616,
0.0099042477,
-0.0046578548,
-0.0018790995,
-0.0276483577,
0.0536609888,
0.0187155623,
-0.0200464912,
-0.0619228147,
-0.0021235214,
-0.0231095292,
0.0148587422,
-0.0198580083,
-0.0526802279,
0.0139989546,
0.0259874873,
0.0752745569,
0.0439603701,
0.019346321,
0.0233579669,
0.0769443065,
-0.0425320417,
-0.0448138863,
0.014605335,
-0.0305831023,
0.0286125243,
-0.0207143165,
0.0109263388,
0.0148212127,
0.0990810022,
0.0239986479,
0.0019538312,
-0.0778122172,
-0.0070210602,
-0.0076597496,
-0.0497006178,
-0.0009254926,
-0.0323908255,
-0.038750995,
0.0087653762,
-0.0431490391,
-0.019350864,
0.101070568,
-0.0382279828,
-0.043586418,
-0.0126951877,
0.0090470696,
-0.0232006498,
0.0457828268,
0.0170619413,
0.0064633652,
-0.000117944,
-0.0291195698,
-0.0197649542,
0.0266011134,
-0.0155990925,
-0.0451242514,
0.0665438548,
-0.0192277767,
0.0039184671,
0.0363372862,
-0.0040871552,
-0.0767771825,
-0.0021443183,
-0.0239657778,
-0.0027072364,
0.0072061806,
0.0081691211,
-0.039460104,
0.0458886735,
0.0338569507,
0.0631965697,
0.0038044832,
-0.0381428301,
-0.0208904315,
0.0286857132,
0.0419064574,
0.0251196362,
0.0343415067,
0.019852601,
0.0425525829,
0.0446151346,
0.0030435219,
-0.0190524664,
-0.0220160577,
-0.0131022707,
0.0121129146,
-0.0458265804,
0.0025333238,
0.0133549999,
0.0335703865,
-0.0966807827,
-0.0364381969,
0.12833336,
0.0293442588,
-0.0389114544,
0.0035645317,
-0.0334374234,
-0.000960599,
0.0584117062,
0.0287519265,
-0.0528064407,
-0.0172474496,
-0.0098233838,
0.0084662912,
0.0292014927,
-0.0166911297,
-0.0037037614,
-0.0877559632,
0.0266371723,
-0.0071984893,
-0.0241456218,
-0.0605548136,
-0.0363179967,
0.0258731302,
-0.0018921146,
0.0209296197,
-0.010001353,
-0.0125178583,
-0.029967159,
0.0062063029,
-0.0481868871,
-0.0430888124,
0.0146876238,
-0.0184428561,
0.0611160584,
0.0380447395,
0.0150170214,
0.0070372252,
-0.0388698392,
0.003362332,
-0.0321057737,
0.0218203254,
0.0135670826,
0.046940323,
-0.0073385052,
0.0005438427,
-0.0286868345,
-0.0066177542,
-0.0679142252,
-0.0236669723,
-0.0209507458,
0.1212442666,
-0.0366987772,
-0.0374332853,
-0.0102003561,
-0.0019227498,
0.0005841001,
0.0924217626,
0.0513028987,
-0.0202884302,
-0.0174733475,
-0.0187080577,
0.0406377502,
-0.0190703701,
-0.0702209845,
0.0680587068,
0.0410249196,
-0.0532255359,
-0.044961527,
-0.0457395352,
0.022546595,
0.00750056,
0.0328176543,
-0.0004792688,
0.0491229594,
-0.0325535797,
-0.0343565345,
0.0361893848,
-0.0310067758,
-0.0242816564,
-0.0216703322,
0.0133432755,
0.0115431463,
-0.0328080989,
-0.0098935422,
0.036528375,
-0.0452910215,
-0.0473331586,
0.0483479574,
0.0419058166,
0.017332416,
0.078998968,
-0.0595740788,
-0.0150497779,
0.0498502329,
0.0164313242,
-0.0692763776,
-0.022543516,
0.0107079959,
-0.0342626572,
0.0053150696,
0.0298059098,
-0.0380684771,
0.0195987597,
-0.0080292206,
0.0292794425,
-0.0410901494,
-0.0402743593,
0.0561288446,
-0.0215994343,
0.0553299598,
-0.0137682594,
0.0404792801,
-0.0280333869,
0.0101069808,
-0.0202942379,
-0.0016337058,
-0.0413284078,
-0.0360613205,
0.0248620585,
-0.0213421769,
0.0251239855,
0.0035360926,
-0.0351024829,
-0.0249505024,
-0.0089635467,
0.0118247448,
0.0170728434,
0.0030036524,
0.0157415532,
0.0026293588,
-0.0076473276,
0.0044339993,
0.0064468477,
0.0314361565,
-0.0123730712,
0.0655078292,
0.0019337873,
-0.0352251641,
-0.0074341847,
0.0162195563,
-0.0584917367,
-0.007705519,
-0.0036974344,
-0.0134483501,
0.0181791037,
-0.0322399288,
0.0494128503,
-0.0179104917,
0.0057705035,
0.0109702311,
0.0229243785,
-0.0223495495,
-0.0250567365,
0.0131308744,
0.0261438955,
-0.0062262411,
-0.0093146283,
0.0465966016,
-0.0304367617,
0.0304471664,
0.0048299031,
-0.015265529,
-0.0493372716,
-0.0168543402,
-0.0214152113,
0.0061138147,
-0.0538965836,
0.0169700775,
-0.0648786351,
-0.0938197672,
0.0019097072,
-0.000397286,
-0.0067092315,
-0.0217500422,
0.0441091023,
0.0517920777,
-0.0145354597,
-0.0241809152,
-0.005546045,
0.0223739706,
-0.0188056361,
0.0062104021,
0.0073345695,
-7.143323417e-33,
-0.0289614145,
-0.065548338,
0.0053260787,
-0.0042771571,
-0.0286541302,
0.001817947,
-0.0544001833,
-0.011384083,
-0.0051425598,
0.0125624761,
-0.0117022581,
0.0206084102,
-0.0028697902,
0.0326259807,
0.015631685,
-0.016986521,
0.0351478979,
0.0183939245,
-0.0199139118,
0.0039032148,
0.0193470493,
0.0358917192,
0.0840760097,
-0.064519532,
0.0306439996,
-0.0042303568,
0.0209972169,
0.0174257159,
0.0031136491,
0.0636610314,
-0.0299094468,
0.0716458634,
0.0367114022,
-0.0654346496,
-0.0216109715,
0.0445693471,
-0.1165116355,
-0.0431957021,
0.021216562,
0.0406982861,
-0.0379112214,
-0.0123296641,
0.1011843532,
-0.0133611895,
0.0490552746,
-0.0445709713,
0.0486546122,
-0.0050197504,
-0.0197396614,
0.0048029828,
-0.0718371347,
0.0102116615,
-0.0383755825,
-0.0431438871,
0.0481876545,
0.0485513248,
0.004094094,
-0.0048720622,
-0.1010104418,
0.0062344838,
-0.0376120359,
0.0225971881,
0.1066273898,
0.0223695822,
-0.0047893655,
0.0432280339,
-0.0345333777,
-0.0083407983,
-0.0606630519,
-0.0387865268,
0.040405415,
0.0360571891,
0.0436155014,
-0.0136249028,
0.004012208,
0.0016479417,
-0.015492646,
-0.0164603908,
-0.0325207226,
0.0455532335,
0.0278312806,
-0.0007824315,
-0.0437501222,
-0.0062404866,
-0.0228234455,
-0.0082001109,
-0.0314624831,
-0.0498391539,
0.0203105826,
-0.0092384089,
-0.0067386301,
0.0281710532,
0.0107040694,
-0.0536424145,
0.045956526,
0.028905198,
0.0147648975,
0.0353272296,
0.0104153519,
0.0675646886,
-0.0354568325,
0.0037230074,
0.0270532425,
0.0402393788,
0.0063313423,
0.0141846994,
0.0194637962,
0.0351379067,
-0.0452607423,
-0.0187353659,
-0.0644028112,
0.0090025105,
-0.0165106431,
-0.0080943909,
0.0391937979,
0.0566693693,
-0.0471205488,
0.0093107102,
0.0200041309,
0.0110803051,
-0.0179247968,
0.0484014191,
-0.0035825789,
0.0191861745,
-0.0390661508,
-0.0138287265,
-0.0452167913,
0.0073748394,
0.03647957,
-0.0451405309,
-0.0164810419,
0.0405034684,
3.093e-7,
0.0767522007,
0.0568712391,
0.021853691,
-0.0028206713,
0.0304731485,
0.0108197592,
-0.0019585467,
0.0179132055,
0.0219528116,
-0.0396133214,
0.0024589493,
0.0497863889,
0.0147049651,
0.0108634839,
-0.0971970633,
-0.0268603619,
-0.0483945943,
0.00774041,
-0.0127864406,
-0.0041587488,
0.0473393388,
0.0861272663,
0.0102306828,
0.0052270871,
-0.037231613,
-0.0327932276,
0.0321272947,
-0.0023337649,
0.0073957234,
0.0248362906,
0.0548781939,
0.0412835926,
-0.0113104666,
0.059294261,
-0.0109892171,
0.0110161025,
-0.0068529835,
0.0213946942,
-0.023398906,
-0.0381333306,
-0.0119685037,
-0.003694457,
0.0150898825,
-0.1039933786,
0.0566348732,
-0.123900041,
-0.0388735458,
0.0145617248,
-0.0391631238,
0.0072442968,
0.0082960632,
0.0076166843,
-0.0082366234,
0.004198486,
0.0339537971,
-0.0023230135,
-0.0179132558,
-0.067605488,
-0.0304428469,
0.009956954,
-0.0330722369,
0.0232190471,
-0.0522620678,
-0.0545682088,
0.0551790074,
-0.0286573414,
0.0131024541,
2.517966526e-34,
-0.0067092986,
0.0267744642,
0.0174172912,
0.0091779493,
0.011816713,
-0.0397201739,
0.003115468,
0.0173283517,
0.0192305297,
-0.0852900743,
-0.0105576152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13467v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13467v1 | Incorporating Graph Information in Transformer-based AMR Parsing | 2023-06-23T12:12:08 | 2023-06-23T12:12:08 | Pavlo Vasylenko, Pere-Lluís Huguet Cabot, Abelardo Carlos Martínez Lorenzo, Roberto Navigli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR) is a Semantic Parsing formalism that
aims at providing a semantic graph abstraction representing a given text.
Current approaches are based on autoregressive language models such as BART or
T5, fine-tuned through Teacher Forcing to obtain a linearized version of the
AMR graph from a sentence. In this paper, we present LeakDistill, a model and
method that explores a modification to the Transformer architecture, using
structural adapters to explicitly incorporate graph information into the
learned representations and improve AMR parsing performance. Our experiments
show how, by employing word-to-node alignment to embed graph structural
information into the encoder at training time, we can obtain state-of-the-art
AMR parsing through self-knowledge distillation, even without the use of
additional data. We release the code at
\url{http://www.github.com/sapienzanlp/LeakDistill}. | [
-0.0077224602,
0.0358662382,
-0.0171496011,
0.0451783575,
-0.0274650268,
-0.0028699657,
-0.0336521789,
-0.0558151491,
0.0346567594,
-0.0248410739,
0.0010856055,
0.0387686789,
-0.0111330664,
0.066793941,
-0.0064656846,
-0.0268386304,
0.0405062214,
0.0115005774,
-0.010713229,
0.0200514756,
0.0115818018,
0.0410951115,
0.0389671586,
0.0124220196,
-0.02307133,
-0.0293554999,
-0.0223234203,
0.0202126671,
-0.0022213832,
-0.0462226346,
-0.0248003155,
0.0005695104,
0.0255714096,
0.0233348347,
0.000002046,
-0.0001459534,
-0.0936466679,
0.0277449545,
-0.0486972705,
-0.0404021181,
0.0404985882,
-0.078584969,
0.0224458352,
0.0079946239,
-0.0413924232,
-0.0506556705,
0.0383867398,
0.0157181863,
0.0802674666,
0.083903864,
-0.0383486897,
-0.0501177572,
0.0432656668,
0.000835539,
-0.0187516082,
-0.0255708303,
0.0060672224,
0.047713533,
-0.0200610179,
-0.0133321332,
-0.1141809598,
0.0279346798,
0.020736184,
-0.0052044922,
0.0758617371,
0.0180831365,
-0.0052573942,
-0.001228791,
0.0039518122,
0.076245293,
0.0104446448,
-0.0367087908,
0.0136264022,
-0.0145323239,
-0.0170784146,
0.0315574221,
-0.026179919,
0.0051724156,
-0.0202420969,
0.0479358062,
0.0084554022,
-0.0114580197,
0.0160594042,
-0.0166426506,
-0.0300846901,
0.0532387309,
-0.01001269,
-0.0278783496,
0.0329947248,
0.0290705133,
-0.0178866405,
-0.0049403594,
0.0396335199,
-0.0001136682,
0.0061542182,
0.014689914,
-0.0575734563,
-0.0529824533,
-0.0522244573,
0.0204061177,
0.0348040201,
0.0543316901,
0.0153166158,
-0.0077731819,
-0.0111858584,
0.0692744255,
-0.0254037101,
0.0744377002,
-0.0776013359,
-0.0021887084,
-0.0610571951,
-0.0056148409,
-0.0957848579,
0.0341494493,
-0.0368330851,
-0.0594288036,
-0.0195484087,
0.066788502,
-0.0044157971,
-0.0076720994,
0.052271869,
0.0157899559,
-0.0311447419,
0.0111735649,
0.0258805919,
0.0807839558,
0.0280117542,
-0.0410547368,
-0.0025247382,
-0.005390042,
-0.0373876542,
0.0101753371,
0.0755207017,
-0.0293018837,
-0.0262327269,
0.0583619289,
0.0003146087,
-0.0152709465,
0.0042462358,
-0.039467033,
-0.0017841217,
0.0154552544,
0.0433154702,
-0.0479185171,
0.0484517291,
0.0330717303,
0.0198255423,
-0.0357437618,
0.0045753885,
-0.0051137838,
0.0098895673,
0.0330026634,
-0.0247229263,
-0.0058969744,
-0.0195774958,
-0.0287555438,
-0.0003792925,
0.0238987952,
0.0503849089,
0.0198055096,
0.007312214,
0.0082003772,
-0.0495234467,
-0.0081649423,
0.0197082851,
-0.0229738858,
0.0125607885,
0.0086158318,
-0.0614460744,
0.0106963459,
0.029971214,
0.062993899,
-0.0340461545,
-0.0033183738,
0.0081831021,
0.0143171251,
0.0088272458,
0.0142877977,
0.0419668518,
0.0481188335,
-0.0324682556,
0.0079167048,
-0.0596354567,
0.0059033711,
0.0089175943,
0.0515361987,
-0.0626564473,
-0.0111268777,
0.0263490919,
-0.0122076971,
-0.0090740509,
-0.0240603685,
0.0674938336,
-0.0171911139,
0.0327313766,
0.057978943,
-0.0295870807,
0.0706876591,
-0.0190047156,
-0.0137209781,
0.0195524767,
0.008525488,
-0.0432766788,
0.0455558188,
0.0397100933,
0.0056179622,
-0.0272455029,
-0.0288279243,
-0.0079619903,
0.0187405907,
-0.0044841403,
-0.0190075282,
-0.0234213993,
-0.0540676117,
-0.0498706959,
-0.0523726828,
-0.0049277344,
0.0010875659,
-0.0338975377,
-0.0120812338,
0.0135230049,
-0.0774103478,
-0.0325057209,
0.0210571382,
-0.0019325159,
0.0018364788,
-0.0279143751,
0.0178653672,
-0.022516476,
0.0102223661,
0.009631848,
0.0222537927,
0.0274136346,
-0.0160146467,
-0.001285166,
0.0426935144,
-0.0919833854,
-0.0640081018,
0.0198799428,
-0.0849754736,
-0.0209683739,
0.0363961086,
-0.0584184714,
-0.068127811,
0.0142319286,
-0.0668751597,
0.0826417431,
0.0134722963,
0.018129576,
0.0045708492,
-0.0004895569,
0.0196602084,
0.0464343056,
-0.0148222381,
-0.0292545222,
-0.0431884304,
0.0241903905,
-0.00285668,
0.0050489688,
-0.0252806209,
0.0013014413,
0.0136380959,
-0.0098888315,
0.0228860341,
-0.0009413021,
-0.0483399816,
0.0041825869,
-0.0326633677,
-0.0059009846,
-0.0209744256,
0.0257784966,
0.0596552603,
0.0436398163,
0.049798131,
-0.0129527859,
-0.0046745525,
0.0298697241,
-0.0079791741,
-0.0068458328,
0.0500441715,
-0.0254490338,
-0.0236415658,
-0.0068813036,
-0.0342962928,
-0.039349068,
0.049227152,
0.0183828697,
-0.0477321558,
-0.0012775821,
0.0182568952,
0.0030272973,
0.015853785,
-0.0052874251,
-0.0237627942,
0.0004725596,
-0.013105453,
0.034425728,
0.0533388928,
-0.0310401507,
0.0700677633,
0.0319896005,
0.0018839212,
-0.0332135484,
0.0020266161,
-0.0217838865,
0.0208823942,
-0.0598603226,
-0.0366946496,
-0.023333,
0.0439419895,
0.0242012236,
0.0301123653,
-0.0403951034,
-0.0361535922,
-0.0315332077,
0.0001373462,
0.0137666967,
-0.0383930579,
-0.0196717568,
-0.0359229408,
-0.063581802,
-0.0107986033,
0.1054757088,
0.0057734414,
-0.0484825037,
-0.0069297585,
0.0056790663,
-0.0726567954,
0.0562106818,
0.0532650724,
0.0157925431,
0.0122532332,
-0.0699156597,
-0.0188016836,
0.0231342595,
0.0386017077,
-0.022686651,
0.0543980338,
0.004107092,
0.0250916518,
-0.0027077373,
-0.0230203327,
-0.0089450981,
-0.0120664919,
-0.0243903175,
0.0400277041,
-0.0019655731,
-0.0061593149,
-0.0188331548,
-0.0076006143,
-0.0135581605,
0.0114157256,
-0.0110044703,
-0.005246859,
-0.0395141244,
0.0352349505,
0.0738424137,
-0.0020665098,
-0.0038940916,
-0.0030436586,
0.0392279103,
0.0360875875,
0.0131199071,
-0.0229244065,
-0.0639673918,
0.0253805183,
-0.0123832216,
-0.0151003785,
-0.0029623259,
-0.0409766808,
0.0499678925,
-0.0609373823,
-0.0429371633,
0.0777615756,
0.0224807058,
-0.0124300271,
0.0115142381,
0.00389293,
0.0466922373,
0.0293013528,
-0.0050012255,
-0.1207486093,
-0.0298394896,
-0.0171054304,
0.0155645646,
0.0371086746,
-0.0552983209,
0.0219850466,
-0.116424419,
-0.0111328121,
0.0311702546,
0.0015765431,
-0.0000030203,
-0.0316231512,
-0.0288764052,
-0.0494903177,
0.0166387632,
-0.0261989199,
-0.0417947248,
0.0102600567,
0.0010244071,
-0.0167002119,
-0.0201491024,
-0.015498573,
0.0084518678,
-0.0051399763,
-0.0117781321,
0.0307789538,
-0.0206857454,
-0.0407931544,
0.0384786241,
-0.0053365082,
0.0180101525,
-0.0145884901,
0.0282975845,
-0.0244228877,
0.0090001142,
-0.0207873918,
0.0083556231,
-0.0395705588,
-0.0167614855,
-0.0755678341,
0.1183877215,
-0.0114653995,
-0.0054267668,
0.0094097508,
-0.0542702638,
-0.0108608464,
0.0331474133,
0.0407032967,
0.0312628597,
-0.0620692037,
-0.048938673,
0.0572043546,
-0.0401887074,
-0.0136931045,
0.0378524661,
-0.0288650412,
0.0104568386,
-0.0290604532,
-0.0290358439,
0.0363354944,
-0.0074019991,
-0.0155963097,
-0.0404984877,
0.0389308743,
-0.0457309037,
-0.0720078275,
0.0166667085,
-0.0143554378,
0.0164967254,
0.0020474223,
-0.0214544963,
0.0066183712,
0.0109312981,
-0.0298212077,
0.0013429698,
-0.0379398875,
-0.0602768883,
0.0176366828,
0.0164398719,
0.0107900612,
0.0782343298,
-0.0339928605,
0.0349920765,
0.0458690263,
-0.005567736,
-0.0303539205,
-0.0123417061,
0.0431774668,
0.0071324641,
0.0063804109,
0.0317238234,
-0.041806493,
0.0276654754,
0.0032862693,
0.0506687574,
0.0062094,
-0.0132218981,
0.0583121926,
0.0713127106,
0.0337156914,
0.0261221193,
0.0267784055,
-0.0252668913,
-0.0161546487,
-0.045597434,
-0.0255638566,
-0.0389744975,
0.0113602597,
0.044335302,
-0.0092242025,
-0.0069601689,
0.0154130273,
0.0203542393,
0.033383105,
-0.0091446554,
0.0464169234,
0.0494349822,
-0.031344045,
0.0175193436,
0.0486698151,
-0.0207870249,
-0.0058259978,
0.0552541204,
0.0151880719,
-0.027309522,
0.0048932871,
0.0253079794,
0.0032443244,
-0.0579365157,
0.014921681,
-0.0653932095,
0.0129708396,
-0.0027369806,
-0.0108561702,
0.0256196931,
0.0029688287,
0.1034698859,
0.0097951861,
0.0176197663,
-0.0070948419,
0.0803343505,
-0.0130514177,
-0.0592358485,
0.0358000472,
0.0119829644,
0.0078159701,
-0.0164631903,
0.004664944,
-0.027937565,
0.0379787162,
-0.0010533008,
-0.0083292313,
-0.0459324718,
-0.0078953188,
-0.024961751,
-0.0033505696,
0.0089033069,
-0.0202450473,
-0.0200962201,
-0.0824349299,
0.028491307,
0.0100501627,
0.0129041635,
-0.0100946454,
0.0085253883,
0.0029636228,
0.0257014334,
-0.0680887476,
-0.0019013595,
0.008054168,
-0.0258283168,
-0.0097324289,
-0.041555468,
-6.083448854e-33,
-0.0449255593,
-0.0154448431,
0.0119417468,
0.0328401849,
-0.0737991855,
0.0239007864,
-0.0619834624,
-0.0281435456,
-0.0216723066,
0.0138334017,
0.0048742075,
0.017458437,
0.0066887769,
0.030262772,
0.0034776069,
-0.0046969592,
0.08453428,
-0.0168711394,
-0.0080797644,
0.0096909236,
0.0401051864,
0.0342464112,
0.0607274175,
-0.018482279,
-0.0056934031,
-0.0165030956,
0.009487154,
0.0025490548,
0.0421658866,
0.0457312986,
0.0147198904,
0.0577841587,
0.0258872416,
0.0491175726,
-0.0458738357,
0.0036109339,
-0.1376764178,
-0.041809082,
0.0164067391,
0.0369491763,
-0.0431203842,
-0.0162606202,
0.0602605343,
-0.0292976499,
-0.0035346656,
-0.0546704829,
0.0370442681,
0.0280184522,
-0.0007559428,
0.0023711082,
-0.0281378832,
0.0132817281,
-0.0128883999,
0.0100626471,
0.0547635332,
0.0111817904,
0.0196277723,
-0.0446956679,
-0.0512042791,
0.0021099744,
-0.0475271195,
-0.0052814009,
0.0128214331,
0.042097047,
0.0332215615,
0.0384700559,
0.0018245603,
-0.0325939059,
0.0115879867,
0.0404205136,
0.0159669444,
0.0614864863,
-0.0281319786,
-0.0158946458,
0.0072607836,
-0.0123928227,
-0.0072682025,
-0.0228479244,
-0.0222501159,
0.0847636983,
-0.0442678817,
0.059843488,
-0.0193619728,
-0.0355575234,
-0.0081115011,
-0.0421051979,
-0.0035497663,
-0.027799163,
0.014541612,
-0.0054563591,
-0.021253448,
0.0772204474,
0.0118408082,
-0.0566073358,
0.0116893267,
0.038803298,
0.0092914654,
0.0470551141,
-0.011827182,
0.0327999331,
-0.0295484718,
-0.035854429,
0.0190275032,
0.0126980115,
0.0344209895,
0.0121963397,
0.0556973517,
0.0379332528,
-0.0259617902,
0.0084547149,
-0.0543983392,
-0.0376462415,
-0.0469209254,
-0.0167751927,
0.0481661484,
0.0511338413,
-0.0403773598,
0.0232144929,
0.0171289239,
0.0714405552,
-0.0382731408,
0.0577903017,
0.0189510416,
0.0349026732,
-0.0370528735,
-0.0138259819,
0.0046242815,
0.0227783788,
0.0593959987,
-0.07090009,
-0.020013148,
-0.0042003957,
2.753e-7,
0.0761334002,
0.0479121394,
0.0937337801,
0.0075918781,
-0.0003988605,
-0.0191063732,
-0.0288076885,
0.0452030487,
0.0049396656,
-0.0164329112,
0.0132620558,
0.0132741835,
-0.0041010892,
0.0353117138,
-0.0639187619,
0.0867353231,
-0.0655382797,
-0.0207255781,
-0.0105917463,
0.0489273183,
0.0718134195,
0.0322411284,
0.0037585387,
0.0199878011,
-0.0622914247,
-0.0351070128,
0.0283613075,
0.0225796402,
0.0291639641,
-0.0133510754,
-0.046568349,
-0.0058930609,
-0.0103360042,
-0.0157584995,
-0.0102387527,
0.0317858085,
0.0089820744,
0.0267191101,
-0.0477914214,
0.0108051524,
-0.01373458,
-0.0308168083,
-0.0094643934,
-0.0005843678,
0.0417566635,
-0.0727637857,
-0.0325222798,
-0.0193769634,
-0.0796741247,
0.0235479698,
-0.0246284045,
0.0241425969,
-0.0104432255,
0.0113497525,
0.0475394763,
-0.0221196562,
-0.0146631654,
-0.0389153585,
-0.026268797,
0.0079282075,
0.0081560649,
-0.0276528951,
0.0074137752,
0.0111829871,
0.0246456414,
-0.0315071866,
-0.0252126306,
2.502938566e-34,
0.0280558113,
0.0038309358,
0.0224421155,
0.0321667232,
0.0370185822,
-0.0410514437,
0.0060363142,
0.0420374908,
0.0048943209,
-0.1102268323,
-0.0474599712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13460v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13460v3 | Learning Descriptive Image Captioning via Semipermeable Maximum Likelihood Estimation | 2023-06-23T12:03:07 | 2023-10-28T11:44:48 | Zihao Yue, Anwen Hu, Liang Zhang, Qin Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Image captioning aims to describe visual content in natural language. As 'a
picture is worth a thousand words', there could be various correct descriptions
for an image. However, with maximum likelihood estimation as the training
objective, the captioning model is penalized whenever its prediction mismatches
with the label. For instance, when the model predicts a word expressing richer
semantics than the label, it will be penalized and optimized to prefer more
concise expressions, referred to as conciseness optimization. In contrast,
predictions that are more concise than labels lead to richness optimization.
Such conflicting optimization directions could eventually result in the model
generating general descriptions. In this work, we introduce Semipermeable
MaxImum Likelihood Estimation (SMILE), which allows richness optimization while
blocking conciseness optimization, thus encouraging the model to generate
longer captions with more details. Extensive experiments on two mainstream
image captioning datasets MSCOCO and Flickr30K demonstrate that SMILE
significantly enhances the descriptiveness of generated captions. We further
provide in-depth investigations to facilitate a better understanding of how
SMILE works. | [
0.0321903713,
0.0721373931,
0.017560428,
0.0509442613,
0.0045134942,
0.018637415,
-0.0128418235,
-0.0007442795,
0.0041742269,
-0.0648156777,
-0.0206439868,
-0.0332592353,
0.009936451,
0.054268565,
0.028027175,
-0.0904808119,
0.0060289199,
-0.0297647342,
-0.0180041641,
-0.0080002127,
0.023473179,
0.0033751563,
0.0106139043,
0.0197508484,
-0.0310214702,
0.0069558299,
0.0102566388,
0.0278172046,
-0.0111649688,
-0.0049085226,
0.0016323898,
0.0736943707,
0.0510368757,
-0.0245771743,
0.0000018079,
-0.0113177625,
0.0039701508,
-0.0011375309,
0.0241719279,
-0.0161477551,
0.0728048906,
-0.0800871626,
0.0267779883,
-0.0217344761,
0.017261304,
-0.0113393683,
0.0904482976,
0.044390671,
0.0380439907,
0.0525036156,
-0.0214046538,
-0.0538067669,
-0.0306436308,
-0.0473876111,
0.0259781331,
-0.0397300981,
-0.0078579001,
0.0242623109,
-0.0389937274,
-0.0144476704,
-0.0443658307,
0.0436179526,
0.0071521741,
-0.0063422043,
0.0523991399,
0.0575201809,
-0.0100873681,
-0.0508622602,
0.003545814,
0.0746782124,
0.0471997038,
0.0026762763,
-0.0198801383,
-0.0126291746,
-0.0195758194,
-0.0294509511,
-0.0245899316,
0.0441884287,
0.0187531784,
0.0093985945,
-0.0548082218,
0.0535445958,
0.0208665002,
0.0142521644,
-0.0040702764,
-0.0017994256,
0.0091949636,
-0.0119896131,
-0.0513669886,
0.0085492339,
-0.043868918,
-0.0355130024,
-0.009417004,
-0.0057988111,
-0.0046685138,
0.006915017,
-0.0344559811,
-0.0112728439,
-0.0044100825,
-0.0228738692,
-0.0181482174,
-0.0178274792,
-0.0129019534,
0.0733025819,
0.0012776151,
0.0100388108,
0.0328090824,
0.0217424426,
-0.0684861243,
0.0050496045,
-0.0359837934,
-0.0012221751,
0.0047788243,
0.0340173766,
0.0054004118,
-0.0489267372,
-0.0479085036,
-0.0133906137,
-0.0281242263,
0.024096489,
-0.0403873511,
0.0357285477,
-0.052099552,
-0.0083941417,
-0.0467186011,
-0.0007009241,
-0.0042642234,
-0.0086391037,
-0.0084563307,
0.0287595149,
-0.0125682503,
0.0603219569,
0.0427144505,
-0.010818894,
-0.0149166305,
0.0700056106,
-0.0270468779,
-0.0412412919,
0.009032459,
-0.0537352525,
-0.021740308,
-0.0397384316,
-0.0123355286,
-0.0288395789,
0.0475677997,
-0.0045419568,
0.0202703979,
-0.0707587078,
-0.0038621021,
-0.0011018289,
-0.0068616956,
0.1227332577,
-0.0427312031,
0.0078976331,
-0.0009512787,
0.0228204541,
0.010456752,
0.0751234069,
0.0181303769,
0.0540860854,
0.0374904647,
-0.0102459062,
0.0192836262,
0.0133606363,
0.0202325601,
-0.0010688263,
-0.0133910226,
-0.0208225735,
0.0054604658,
0.0207835026,
0.0657190308,
0.0590666495,
-0.0026647248,
0.0311456509,
0.0920711607,
0.0191546138,
0.0028853773,
-0.0013832556,
0.0540253893,
0.031565778,
-0.0213789456,
0.0587171987,
-0.0670765266,
0.0391388088,
0.0033052696,
0.0338553004,
0.0555882528,
0.0258074068,
-0.0368596427,
-0.0386824198,
-0.0143326335,
-0.0629373267,
0.0386134684,
0.0081430133,
0.0242613088,
0.0222452432,
-0.0330577157,
0.0740909874,
0.0323704295,
-0.0123994639,
-0.0061922111,
-0.0352849737,
0.0178470891,
0.0513162501,
0.0370234214,
-0.0048483447,
-0.0232576542,
-0.0234951768,
0.0303835142,
0.0556302443,
0.0178495683,
0.0249684136,
0.0456968807,
-0.0268278457,
-0.0510567911,
-0.0279018246,
0.045589678,
-0.0114096897,
0.0113808466,
-0.0219812002,
0.065982312,
-0.003857522,
-0.062363632,
0.0202512816,
0.0377140343,
-0.0629414469,
0.0014653121,
0.0310349967,
-0.0156096462,
-0.001731865,
-0.0285247117,
-0.0006067245,
-0.0009154993,
-0.0077556707,
-0.0543746203,
0.0541843101,
-0.0537687615,
-0.0565127656,
-0.0036374254,
-0.0667272657,
0.003505341,
-0.0059655206,
-0.0440074839,
-0.0400089845,
0.0169161446,
-0.0542684086,
0.007066065,
-0.0551202819,
0.0063413861,
0.016858574,
0.0190318543,
0.009170291,
0.0593287125,
-0.0023579502,
0.0094079105,
0.0094330451,
-0.0245291274,
-0.0216522384,
-0.0223429482,
-0.0417152196,
-0.0127272084,
0.0067980164,
0.0208041891,
0.0293602739,
0.0392469279,
-0.0293768328,
0.0003672901,
-0.0684819818,
-0.0364243053,
-0.0096816905,
-0.0336818211,
0.0101045808,
0.0161755029,
0.0301094446,
-0.0088261152,
-0.0167363696,
-0.0055431062,
-0.0362422504,
0.0211980399,
0.0481320098,
0.0436266214,
-0.0285500549,
-0.0240014698,
0.0146073187,
0.0181140583,
0.069167465,
0.0169748217,
-0.0230677426,
-0.0324364007,
0.0185076054,
-0.0362663865,
-0.0168570075,
-0.0021305133,
-0.0251681283,
-0.0406259112,
0.012244015,
-0.0092964154,
0.0205448512,
0.0224516597,
0.034240596,
0.0127158761,
0.033435639,
-0.0214593839,
0.0041131591,
-0.0171886142,
-0.0674813613,
0.0565736033,
-0.0822863877,
0.0048214407,
0.0640749112,
-0.0279225782,
0.0323672779,
-0.0555663966,
0.0141591504,
-0.027881166,
-0.0462534688,
-0.0439892709,
0.0313328579,
0.0172488689,
0.0169174969,
-0.0436337106,
-0.0864852443,
0.0637207776,
-0.0141573185,
-0.0288292412,
0.0092862304,
-0.019711921,
-0.0204900578,
0.0635453537,
0.0303722005,
0.0612634681,
0.039481245,
-0.0067268568,
0.0078975735,
-0.0393555313,
0.0516437814,
0.0274144206,
0.0455884375,
-0.0405833572,
-0.0148757426,
-0.026438484,
-0.0378571711,
0.0103404922,
-0.0608444437,
0.0000891133,
-0.002376508,
-0.0155343162,
-0.0005422328,
0.0081299106,
0.0333162621,
0.0060888478,
0.021738423,
0.0001643637,
-0.0098832296,
-0.005851204,
0.0038897202,
0.0748752281,
-0.0027280427,
-0.0670878142,
-0.0442862846,
0.0297036506,
0.0155796055,
-0.0235910174,
0.0196176935,
-0.0246306527,
-0.0168373864,
0.0100736851,
0.008485755,
-0.0191087108,
0.029441651,
0.0823213384,
-0.0391034856,
-0.0083021307,
0.1010080278,
-0.0039140317,
-0.0428809114,
-0.0124804936,
0.0360472985,
0.0298242196,
0.0355437063,
-0.0050740154,
-0.0373938717,
-0.0464182496,
-0.0452649966,
0.0150771812,
0.0216923952,
0.0356397331,
-0.0533904657,
-0.0417049453,
0.0191369932,
0.0209273547,
-0.037728332,
-0.046916578,
-0.0008436752,
-0.0413829237,
-0.0207077693,
-0.0056940741,
-0.0290480517,
-0.0188148413,
0.0236161686,
-0.0013146973,
-0.0308032297,
-0.0516595431,
-0.0121755712,
-0.06685514,
0.0196021702,
0.051097665,
0.0284987632,
-0.0346392579,
-0.0133401109,
0.0064013428,
0.005282192,
0.0005513644,
-0.0126734888,
0.0696898848,
-0.0157582387,
-0.0266534183,
0.0171188433,
0.0195708591,
0.0018458647,
-0.0289770104,
-0.0151849575,
-0.012169797,
0.0192202646,
0.0047810213,
-0.0042988877,
0.0502843037,
0.0043792576,
0.085288614,
0.0443212464,
-0.0166287888,
-0.0086762579,
-0.0255236793,
-0.0242941193,
-0.0422824994,
-0.0022353346,
-0.0137780374,
-0.0281211771,
-0.0261608455,
-0.0523456708,
-0.0172746629,
0.0276027005,
0.0177323744,
0.0098722428,
0.0153862871,
-0.0336791463,
-0.0147178136,
-0.0736925155,
0.0306053888,
-0.059167698,
0.0073694075,
-0.0059309364,
-0.0384729356,
0.0753195733,
-0.0215565357,
-0.003214448,
0.0148097137,
-0.0702243075,
-0.0176681746,
-0.0878410414,
0.074552305,
0.0134619465,
0.0375679843,
0.0092098359,
-0.0486364365,
-0.006122902,
0.0659234002,
0.0193226673,
0.0135947205,
0.0254733674,
0.0047158492,
-0.0094826594,
0.0340320393,
-0.0338930562,
0.0064738914,
-0.0174652226,
-0.0012501987,
0.0253181607,
-0.0372952223,
0.0099263526,
0.0236203466,
0.0241024029,
-0.0812946633,
-0.0253962073,
-0.0158214979,
-0.0205300767,
-0.0075516668,
-0.0401743837,
-0.0197118651,
0.0367041454,
0.0204572752,
0.0690577701,
-0.0117914276,
0.0026173482,
-0.0363701843,
0.0415346958,
-0.0489418171,
-0.009871589,
0.0108767403,
-0.1084734872,
-0.0187550187,
-0.0038402439,
-0.0203181319,
0.001544651,
-0.0005371145,
0.007882121,
-0.0153187383,
0.0259507988,
-0.0120854946,
0.0243951194,
-0.0346285887,
0.0376541503,
0.0068514585,
-0.0089109493,
-0.0757324621,
0.0398217104,
0.0646173954,
-0.0197088663,
0.0276695117,
-0.0065434035,
-0.0190306995,
-0.0113533363,
0.0645846054,
-0.0002873559,
-0.063423045,
0.0668227524,
0.0183721837,
-0.0044900677,
0.0104370387,
0.0718043223,
0.0263716988,
0.0437835604,
0.0080518229,
-0.0176957119,
-0.0470584929,
0.0022194169,
0.0237796567,
0.0330617987,
-0.0139070246,
0.0387036912,
-0.0255919453,
-0.0719114915,
0.0256454237,
-0.0084336866,
0.0100067304,
0.0371902399,
0.0577851199,
0.0096523669,
0.0009929539,
-0.0067138923,
-0.0584582314,
-0.030617578,
0.034106873,
0.0565205179,
0.0150346979,
-6.103865721e-33,
-0.0417767726,
-0.0416359827,
-0.0224963073,
-0.0087685548,
-0.0362201408,
0.0230573285,
-0.0315975025,
0.0186901577,
0.0213829484,
0.0155395605,
0.0319400206,
-0.0186489224,
0.0104568871,
0.0427542962,
0.0104313549,
-0.0264399927,
0.0403503142,
0.0172174778,
-0.0366433263,
0.0002243782,
-0.012749603,
0.0025073867,
0.0301799774,
-0.0649443567,
0.0203978997,
0.0126823122,
-0.0605281517,
0.0103969201,
0.0678046122,
0.0570893921,
-0.0229403414,
0.0370163471,
0.0156360678,
-0.0247992054,
-0.0300359763,
-0.0244499333,
-0.0255876202,
0.0207326114,
0.0489176884,
0.0036996314,
-0.0466138013,
-0.0386948064,
0.0158233996,
-0.0464667082,
-0.0131480694,
-0.0412013009,
0.062297821,
-0.0212977994,
-0.0076207281,
-0.0345254503,
-0.0573686175,
0.0026593402,
-0.0143401828,
-0.0395032875,
0.0340546928,
0.0231904984,
0.0123968674,
0.044252038,
0.0084653301,
0.0113852546,
0.0096355751,
0.050250195,
0.0854263306,
0.0447933488,
-0.0068983878,
0.0385694541,
0.0178087652,
0.0058727008,
-0.0209052823,
0.0209048353,
-0.0062509868,
0.0511199571,
0.0170255061,
0.0806127563,
0.0422933362,
0.0046605929,
0.0122841885,
0.0214633811,
-0.0824103802,
0.0032119344,
0.0122360317,
0.0296007693,
-0.0135673862,
-0.0185590871,
-0.0765715539,
-0.0108448453,
-0.0404826738,
-0.0173191018,
-0.0032212948,
0.0311678611,
-0.0487749167,
0.0679910704,
0.0066680536,
-0.0319670029,
0.0063289828,
-0.0388714559,
-0.0264441967,
0.0364926904,
-0.0097751003,
-0.0287907403,
-0.0132260369,
-0.0742122382,
0.0325289369,
0.0281085409,
0.0199593585,
0.0215545539,
0.0840057582,
0.0329664089,
-0.0188860968,
-0.0010274816,
-0.0397966728,
-0.0161964167,
-0.0545727611,
-0.0204427075,
0.0302320756,
0.017632056,
-0.0888489261,
0.0333008282,
0.0023223714,
0.0210542735,
-0.0128999446,
-0.0482758172,
0.0075300205,
0.0505138189,
-0.009416393,
0.0335067324,
-0.0037777689,
-0.0632237867,
0.0067334436,
-0.0552981608,
-0.0519201197,
0.0030654559,
2.428e-7,
0.0179507472,
0.0336098112,
0.0139441509,
0.0413366221,
0.0347295143,
0.0579321422,
-0.0243507754,
0.0369504839,
-0.0226100031,
-0.0607460067,
0.0314847417,
0.0260166153,
0.0443855412,
-0.0516898893,
-0.0570394695,
-0.0069477949,
-0.0194740966,
-0.0046508354,
-0.0260205697,
-0.030613564,
0.0904358998,
0.0884272233,
-0.0159365479,
-0.0079666115,
0.0349291936,
-0.0850337669,
0.1044604555,
-0.0656749159,
-0.0128048854,
-0.0008903904,
0.0335288383,
0.0346597023,
-0.0148726534,
0.0083130002,
-0.047888048,
-0.0332123674,
0.0587085076,
0.079562977,
-0.0047728075,
0.0044382606,
-0.0204200651,
0.0347038694,
0.0021422449,
-0.026496144,
0.0717961639,
-0.0458547212,
-0.0171915591,
-0.029777199,
0.0046692663,
0.0325881764,
0.0380146354,
-0.0605598614,
-0.0456436127,
0.038544938,
0.0542037562,
0.0086067095,
-0.0488267876,
-0.0563115515,
-0.0497577414,
0.0005468411,
-0.0428997166,
-0.0161738954,
-0.0415307023,
-0.004469478,
0.0454661958,
-0.0669118986,
-0.0288970191,
1.940991884e-34,
0.0712457374,
-0.0139887454,
-0.0072862939,
0.008431429,
0.021869164,
-0.0050384505,
0.0058751646,
-0.0150073161,
-0.0142791737,
-0.0447870828,
0.0071258605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13421v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13421v1 | Long-range Language Modeling with Self-retrieval | 2023-06-23T10:18:02 | 2023-06-23T10:18:02 | Ohad Rubin, Jonathan Berant | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented language models (LMs) have received much attention
recently. However, typically the retriever is not trained jointly as a native
component of the LM, but added to an already-pretrained LM, which limits the
ability of the LM and the retriever to adapt to one another. In this work, we
propose the Retrieval-Pretrained Transformer (RPT), an architecture and
training procedure for jointly training a retrieval-augmented LM from scratch
for the task of modeling long texts. Given a recently generated text chunk in a
long document, the LM computes query representations, which are then used to
retrieve earlier chunks in the document, located potentially tens of thousands
of tokens before. Information from retrieved chunks is fused into the LM
representations to predict the next target chunk. We train the retriever
component with a semantic objective, where the goal is to retrieve chunks that
increase the probability of the next chunk, according to a reference LM. We
evaluate RPT on four long-range language modeling tasks, spanning books, code,
and mathematical writing, and demonstrate that RPT improves retrieval quality
and subsequently perplexity across the board compared to strong baselines. | [
0.0280254092,
0.0545392819,
0.000503099,
0.0253495313,
-0.0280058067,
-0.0197129659,
-0.0162658356,
-0.0137492875,
0.0040244781,
-0.0597971827,
-0.0351009108,
-0.0217714813,
-0.0395824984,
0.0353642926,
0.015239819,
-0.0305207614,
0.0342111997,
-0.0195552986,
-0.0120504843,
0.0190475788,
0.0181498975,
0.0131957596,
0.0253834296,
0.0209547561,
-0.0106111495,
-0.0323324166,
-0.0237785205,
0.0142255854,
-0.0333462767,
-0.0246012025,
0.0431976691,
0.0242822673,
0.0617973246,
0.0327566527,
0.0000019472,
-0.0364890099,
-0.0658864528,
0.001965961,
-0.0237699095,
-0.0067803166,
0.0570838936,
-0.0157778338,
0.0126095498,
0.01373812,
-0.0611141585,
-0.0192845687,
0.004819985,
0.0696027279,
0.0621181577,
0.078366898,
-0.0090601919,
-0.0369571187,
0.0622755587,
-0.0317336246,
0.0610155463,
-0.0460084341,
0.013876928,
-0.0185497198,
0.009264295,
0.0586696267,
-0.018562464,
0.0433749557,
0.0345528424,
-0.0120996041,
0.0321013816,
0.0260665324,
-0.0449984521,
0.0225871913,
-0.0140820956,
0.0320440419,
-0.0012103256,
-0.0410096906,
-0.0016412174,
0.0081473347,
-0.0197432339,
0.0106999557,
-0.0413854159,
-0.0071134027,
0.0227076169,
0.0194596834,
-0.0157720596,
-0.0007652893,
0.028693866,
0.0312512703,
-0.0913432389,
0.0464415178,
0.0210507084,
-0.0392257906,
-0.0393103883,
-0.0156333987,
-0.0033027208,
-0.0018813398,
0.0354162715,
0.0507730022,
0.0216955692,
0.0172142405,
-0.0302047227,
-0.0580179617,
0.0093152802,
-0.0028927624,
0.032689672,
0.0311805382,
-0.0447081923,
0.0556378178,
-0.0503335632,
0.0283196978,
-0.0269139446,
0.0046783104,
-0.0452454612,
-0.0014242867,
-0.0418565869,
-0.0472252779,
-0.0787420198,
0.0267614964,
-0.0139983259,
-0.0261022374,
-0.0177386943,
0.0218598377,
0.0129358573,
-0.0337560326,
0.0118434196,
0.0280324873,
-0.0483861305,
-0.0429923981,
-0.0188940167,
0.0424897447,
-0.0105099836,
-0.0076209903,
0.0189169347,
-0.0422186404,
-0.0355662368,
0.018929271,
0.0243039988,
-0.0505548045,
-0.0012736836,
0.037726257,
-0.0245285947,
-0.0497154295,
-0.0198225416,
-0.0261830445,
-0.0130867036,
-0.0425528511,
0.0191634204,
-0.0689091086,
0.0177063253,
-0.0018522985,
-0.0152635807,
-0.029278487,
0.0052363775,
0.0406329855,
0.0050427923,
0.0744382963,
0.0113697993,
0.0067555248,
0.0436232053,
0.0087999422,
0.02540881,
0.032527633,
0.0365000553,
0.0219723023,
0.0525315851,
0.0018598209,
0.0321179628,
0.0270580929,
0.0225628708,
-0.0189718939,
-0.0237544868,
0.0320908949,
-0.0014771513,
0.0134156244,
0.0144795841,
0.0418516845,
-0.0395612754,
-0.0035887398,
0.0218889657,
0.0522856489,
0.0600516833,
0.0409116484,
0.0340261497,
0.0252351016,
-0.027960632,
0.0100740539,
-0.041314695,
0.0289115813,
-0.0088713784,
0.0198721793,
0.0302668195,
0.0066854274,
-0.0244046487,
-0.0479765013,
0.0120199658,
-0.0250851419,
0.0080349008,
0.0046073818,
0.0738288835,
0.0466705486,
-0.0517050885,
0.065661177,
-0.0148732197,
-0.0823902041,
0.0382938609,
-0.0482449271,
0.0082535679,
0.0552590415,
0.0660793334,
-0.0612748712,
-0.003371747,
0.0093669547,
-0.011405223,
0.0156444497,
0.0156545471,
0.0078849876,
0.0009760363,
-0.0475855395,
-0.019361224,
-0.023830818,
0.0069289142,
-0.0046509532,
0.0379613489,
0.003532633,
0.0616151169,
-0.0520639829,
-0.0086083803,
0.0506328717,
-0.044321809,
-0.0344165452,
0.0035724139,
-0.0040850583,
-0.0278756469,
-0.0103153214,
-0.0136182038,
0.0453966483,
0.0504792593,
-0.0441489778,
-0.0377135389,
-0.0168781523,
-0.0797841474,
-0.0350392163,
0.0428851545,
0.0097979791,
0.0235020015,
0.0296699777,
-0.0165317468,
-0.0332555734,
0.0521682426,
-0.0336705372,
0.0265420787,
-0.0641454458,
0.0273969639,
0.0206107963,
0.018197326,
-0.0616035238,
0.0308846328,
0.0412408784,
0.0123830931,
-0.044233162,
-0.0021379339,
0.024056647,
-0.0156637263,
-0.0267970227,
-0.0245285314,
-0.0312716663,
0.026522072,
0.0454447269,
-0.0159592219,
-0.0321231373,
-0.0668504089,
-0.0835002959,
0.0033315977,
-0.026770303,
0.008940422,
-0.0127647175,
0.0401054844,
-0.0037751249,
-0.0335178971,
-0.028969489,
-0.0386869088,
0.0263473615,
0.0175108444,
0.0339231938,
0.0205727164,
0.0062552579,
-0.0484028198,
-0.0368029736,
-0.0173007026,
0.0562036447,
-0.0198170692,
0.0075724539,
-0.04205231,
0.0153630143,
-0.0289982408,
0.0271631833,
-0.032370735,
-0.0172525719,
-0.0137800435,
-0.0810401067,
0.0718632415,
0.0731349736,
0.0388058536,
-0.0038958159,
0.0227258708,
-0.0328370593,
-0.0629400909,
0.0389778726,
-0.0433373563,
-0.0232622828,
0.0009187978,
0.0199114513,
0.0116263786,
0.0367303081,
-0.0218989644,
-0.0265065022,
-0.0134316301,
0.011033305,
0.0015260337,
-0.023568321,
-0.018161986,
0.0000567099,
-0.0143363914,
0.0452902764,
-0.0176074859,
-0.0577947721,
0.066117987,
-0.0402399674,
-0.0195634775,
-0.0275956225,
0.0054141735,
-0.0827619806,
0.0836735964,
0.0105329566,
-0.0238762163,
-0.0274819043,
-0.0272480976,
-0.0454990864,
0.0034633616,
-0.0007100275,
-0.0496035069,
0.0787418112,
-0.0008128306,
0.0369105525,
-0.0106364377,
-0.0495727956,
-0.0390859731,
-0.0382834561,
0.0052159228,
-0.0206115171,
0.0148747778,
0.0062381416,
-0.0477365218,
0.0008227775,
0.0398966521,
0.0763114989,
-0.053814549,
-0.0253887139,
-0.0164375212,
0.0256172232,
0.0677796155,
0.0086455354,
-0.0132240755,
-0.0394292548,
0.0071313237,
0.0467333123,
0.0428916551,
-0.0148790302,
-0.0377269611,
-0.002945137,
0.0349228568,
-0.0484832078,
-0.0086392835,
0.0068672253,
0.0189133342,
-0.0882455036,
-0.0562234074,
0.1057585999,
0.0221231189,
-0.0529714748,
-0.0414736755,
-0.0536742136,
0.0344265737,
0.0157752652,
0.0577188469,
-0.0664839596,
-0.0210139938,
0.001569459,
0.0267627835,
0.0352499187,
-0.0039238092,
-0.0053557889,
-0.106284678,
0.0267204084,
0.009733432,
0.0062648589,
-0.0087986318,
-0.0333468206,
-0.0290180463,
0.0126699051,
0.0019733552,
0.0389368869,
-0.0501290336,
0.0065559745,
-0.0011488082,
-0.0277691092,
0.01325511,
-0.013602796,
-0.0373793468,
-0.0316728055,
0.0756262392,
0.0081375483,
0.0120936641,
-0.0102439662,
0.0257484429,
-0.0148245404,
0.0206908267,
0.0167949591,
0.0573167242,
-0.0413172655,
0.0149479713,
-0.0150640691,
0.0032564143,
-0.0468486771,
-0.0172546357,
0.0083963908,
0.0663491189,
-0.0233382918,
0.0125108939,
-0.0407696925,
-0.0132340575,
-0.0337887295,
0.0510629863,
0.012264749,
-0.0102324588,
-0.0627513751,
-0.0100854021,
0.0402628556,
-0.0463376567,
-0.0211733375,
-0.0088581201,
0.014380835,
0.0193252154,
-0.0521001406,
-0.0438667499,
-0.0084154997,
0.0312197581,
-0.0002163478,
0.0335865282,
-0.0097188782,
-0.0065892441,
-0.0800150558,
0.0238169599,
-0.0479070768,
-0.0006180574,
-0.0602327287,
0.0358149596,
0.0462826677,
-0.0391323157,
0.0026781084,
-0.0057135313,
-0.0707148984,
-0.0449541397,
-0.0010877977,
0.0280702412,
0.0132630467,
0.055646684,
-0.0072943131,
-0.0326519869,
0.0272925142,
0.0552351624,
-0.0813607275,
0.0131366141,
0.0212548226,
-0.000457661,
-0.0201224908,
0.0310240071,
-0.0409079008,
0.0270954166,
-0.0142557211,
0.0293941181,
0.0087189181,
-0.056608744,
0.016268298,
-0.0026261129,
0.0702179819,
0.0322429612,
0.0587851517,
-0.0271492954,
0.0297183879,
-0.048934564,
-0.0134197846,
-0.0301889181,
0.034260951,
0.0412064195,
-0.0074849376,
-0.0100363595,
0.0453963839,
0.0058989967,
0.0796927363,
-0.0476463288,
0.0247397646,
-0.0341748893,
-0.0123327533,
0.0029424501,
-0.0020423424,
0.0055072214,
-0.0127679845,
-0.0012601077,
0.0487223789,
-0.0294148494,
0.0362659357,
0.0207442008,
0.0064405878,
-0.0364423431,
0.0083380649,
-0.0948370099,
-0.0271192417,
-0.0110628316,
-0.0420464613,
0.0274823774,
-0.0119805979,
0.0443592295,
0.00674765,
-0.0136106275,
-0.0282785688,
0.0366316475,
0.0216864478,
-0.0246682912,
-0.011173157,
0.0308301356,
-0.0188983977,
-0.0004761641,
0.0551892594,
0.011367497,
0.0126240971,
0.0236193836,
-0.0124484655,
-0.0211452302,
-0.0179725755,
0.0163839236,
0.0164229255,
-0.0062355627,
-0.0198692419,
-0.0044809799,
-0.0475142226,
0.0620507151,
0.0063566137,
-0.0348188803,
-0.0283300579,
0.0283935163,
0.096808821,
-0.0133755654,
-0.0289795101,
-0.0345893316,
0.0467367209,
0.0045453245,
-0.0284689944,
-0.0184570812,
-6.201784768e-33,
-0.0065884902,
-0.007693293,
0.0326582566,
-0.0140578272,
-0.066699557,
-0.0050373785,
-0.0236308929,
-0.0050033904,
0.0051380345,
-0.0056365263,
-0.0473578125,
0.028589651,
0.0070779934,
0.0565317012,
0.0001866769,
-0.002625264,
0.0593028814,
-0.0100463927,
-0.0110596465,
0.0127126435,
0.0246300101,
0.0848468319,
0.0338696577,
-0.0362186804,
-0.0271390919,
-0.0228376668,
0.0303174891,
0.0183303356,
0.0204855334,
0.058888685,
-0.0219141934,
0.0142456256,
0.0377833396,
-0.0279928949,
-0.0308911055,
0.0335669145,
-0.1058016196,
-0.0167799164,
-0.032696493,
-0.0061113425,
-0.0311938822,
-0.0134414891,
0.0498418026,
-0.0344292261,
-0.0001356019,
-0.0286255088,
0.0415277667,
-0.0075588427,
-0.0297018159,
-0.0077272928,
-0.0337631963,
0.033791814,
0.0185918417,
-0.0242551584,
0.0462690182,
0.037204098,
0.0167130567,
0.0512591973,
-0.0349169374,
-0.011658527,
-0.0162700471,
0.0912644714,
0.0127788372,
0.0301749706,
0.0070354436,
0.0529764183,
0.0419457816,
-0.0177550353,
-0.0474658497,
-0.0312786736,
0.0659066364,
0.0220918246,
0.0190085284,
0.0302120261,
0.0502591655,
0.0085083898,
-0.0376034714,
0.0191781186,
-0.0242804866,
0.0534216464,
0.0279949307,
0.0389396288,
-0.0179347824,
-0.0155972112,
-0.0338971429,
0.0170399379,
-0.0324347354,
-0.0317406952,
0.0330506489,
0.0527024157,
-0.0008803721,
0.0176299475,
0.0514317416,
-0.0334185548,
-0.0155937839,
0.0370205045,
-0.0231854282,
0.0094436444,
-0.0158385299,
0.0384415165,
-0.0340263247,
-0.0200607628,
0.0179949664,
-0.0081701772,
-0.0315648466,
-0.0066148154,
0.0169999097,
0.0284636207,
-0.0834454149,
-0.0091958586,
-0.0121641997,
0.0007244861,
-0.0031965256,
0.043054726,
0.0294990055,
0.0580476634,
0.0096812807,
0.0623453781,
0.0224220119,
-0.0060108546,
-0.061575152,
-0.0198740009,
0.0154214706,
0.0147022754,
-0.0060178307,
0.0059855501,
-0.0456339531,
0.0170151591,
0.019468436,
-0.0819033906,
0.0066994876,
0.054942444,
2.699e-7,
0.0626465231,
0.0437703989,
0.0780418366,
0.0117471926,
0.0066000847,
0.0071143331,
-0.0033220772,
0.0305654146,
0.0362807959,
0.0069246772,
0.0020050111,
0.0249845181,
0.0494381934,
0.0017885771,
-0.0902907699,
0.0181172602,
-0.0738981888,
-0.0079735145,
-0.0373895131,
-0.0425433367,
0.0659353808,
0.0985775962,
-0.0020754414,
0.0117472038,
-0.0166624747,
-0.0615485609,
0.0967708752,
-0.0124380207,
-0.0157193821,
0.03763403,
0.0064942087,
0.039829351,
0.002488116,
-0.0313950889,
-0.0154894004,
0.0587773658,
0.014327311,
0.0498844422,
0.003625727,
-0.0407017991,
0.0145646678,
0.0120850196,
-0.0210845228,
-0.0387300402,
0.0677584559,
-0.0725405067,
0.0131720724,
0.0127814999,
-0.055233527,
0.0009659136,
0.0016163047,
-0.0025205824,
-0.0259289071,
0.049953904,
0.0429007895,
0.0079751322,
-0.0011998331,
-0.1223503202,
-0.0181492083,
-0.0020061904,
-0.0474340878,
0.0185664594,
-0.0711726844,
-0.010572657,
0.0121528646,
-0.0563017875,
0.0030943302,
2.613846917e-34,
0.0431358591,
-0.0084944954,
-0.009546061,
0.0072400584,
0.0451803282,
-0.0107465442,
0.0157175027,
0.0348130651,
0.0110854441,
-0.113003552,
-0.0269780904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14921v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14921v1 | Product Information Extraction using ChatGPT | 2023-06-23T09:30:01 | 2023-06-23T09:30:01 | Alexander Brinkmann, Roee Shraga, Reng Chiz Der, Christian Bizer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Structured product data in the form of attribute/value pairs is the
foundation of many e-commerce applications such as faceted product search,
product comparison, and product recommendation. Product offers often only
contain textual descriptions of the product attributes in the form of titles or
free text. Hence, extracting attribute/value pairs from textual product
descriptions is an essential enabler for e-commerce applications. In order to
excel, state-of-the-art product information extraction methods require large
quantities of task-specific training data. The methods also struggle with
generalizing to out-of-distribution attributes and attribute values that were
not a part of the training data. Due to being pre-trained on huge amounts of
text as well as due to emergent effects resulting from the model size, Large
Language Models like ChatGPT have the potential to address both of these
shortcomings. This paper explores the potential of ChatGPT for extracting
attribute/value pairs from product descriptions. We experiment with different
zero-shot and few-shot prompt designs. Our results show that ChatGPT achieves a
performance similar to a pre-trained language model but requires much smaller
amounts of training data and computation for fine-tuning. | [
0.0329252444,
0.0174453165,
0.0130169662,
0.0407279842,
-0.049067352,
0.0012183568,
0.020594852,
0.0070260726,
-0.0070072734,
-0.0858913139,
-0.0500552282,
-0.0333649777,
-0.0163296293,
0.0750687569,
-0.0190473236,
-0.0297598243,
0.003110853,
-0.0049740663,
0.0108923232,
0.0273324661,
0.0303814728,
0.0211791806,
-0.0034538384,
-0.0042477674,
0.023167368,
-0.0396613516,
-0.0329622477,
-0.010186729,
0.027092455,
-0.0240357127,
0.0327528641,
0.0128272995,
-0.0087926313,
-0.0291241426,
0.0000019452,
-0.0347542726,
-0.0041650641,
0.0070333737,
-0.0672111139,
0.0171822477,
0.0817352012,
0.0475395322,
0.0248499177,
0.0014482044,
-0.0267298184,
-0.0625923201,
0.0391059108,
0.0955479071,
0.0047130543,
0.077476263,
-0.0393194072,
-0.0278717428,
0.0158307292,
-0.0259977225,
0.0586332828,
-0.0372083411,
0.035283789,
-0.0463532358,
0.0456843637,
0.076189436,
0.0407008529,
0.0373395123,
-0.0152790612,
0.0265543908,
0.0182727184,
0.0657806024,
-0.0470987484,
0.0096213846,
-0.0360046253,
0.1136331409,
-0.0217388626,
0.023823468,
-0.002387705,
-0.0224897955,
0.0077248779,
-0.0481465012,
-0.0100747384,
0.000626549,
-0.0184756331,
-0.0214873943,
-0.0392341129,
0.0308430642,
-0.0070010964,
-0.0196101945,
0.0066826693,
0.0097070755,
0.0063457051,
-0.0441259183,
-0.0017096116,
0.0017698958,
-0.0551258884,
-0.0468534343,
-0.0223997235,
-0.0007650607,
0.0351722501,
0.0088633634,
-0.0135881044,
0.0003298178,
-0.021363562,
-0.0359890498,
0.0121751446,
-0.0045911372,
-0.0713215917,
0.0728154182,
-0.0417666361,
0.0384898447,
0.0559536107,
-0.0061788904,
-0.0681531206,
0.0291043632,
-0.0647231936,
-0.020368902,
-0.0522573441,
0.0400266573,
-0.0189913381,
-0.0406712592,
0.0049294191,
-0.017837191,
0.0076132761,
0.0145078488,
-0.0092961406,
0.0005974534,
0.0021143463,
-0.0277121067,
-0.0149088781,
0.0037239627,
-0.0174745452,
-0.0073566684,
0.0055495556,
-0.0601169392,
0.012243689,
0.0022176746,
0.0653656796,
-0.0438657962,
0.0259210858,
0.0435635932,
-0.0008763035,
-0.0699273646,
-0.0336188339,
-0.0299332421,
-0.0099118743,
-0.0356290676,
-0.0237281453,
-0.0268276054,
0.0607023053,
0.0092476793,
-0.0068265437,
-0.0010650436,
0.0066413037,
0.004718964,
-0.0380819105,
0.1139013171,
-0.0179497618,
-0.0251031946,
-0.0278389584,
-0.0140107013,
-0.0007262172,
0.0089068282,
-0.0181456916,
0.0768849999,
0.0373391956,
0.0012364797,
0.0098389136,
0.0253824368,
-0.0222866237,
-0.0564905852,
0.0144795682,
0.0526620969,
0.0314191841,
-0.0053576371,
0.0091440361,
0.0352455191,
-0.0439397208,
0.0194944832,
0.0969084129,
0.0524550714,
0.0270946473,
0.0227223225,
0.02483394,
0.0695622042,
0.0214541778,
-0.0417289175,
-0.0049682418,
-0.0189213399,
-0.0249868352,
0.0310648624,
-0.0229329858,
0.0065513877,
-0.0256358478,
-0.0341494344,
-0.006998912,
-0.0468275137,
0.029345043,
0.0383548811,
0.026337374,
-0.0163386613,
-0.0240249038,
0.0038937146,
0.0431426913,
-0.0338729471,
-0.0095645981,
-0.0209032707,
0.0215223413,
0.0959276482,
0.0311128069,
-0.0277493782,
-0.0143193407,
-0.0023211346,
0.012732571,
0.0181493685,
0.0362912342,
-0.0376914367,
0.0213819034,
-0.0440448299,
-0.0321754776,
-0.0606248975,
0.0024524513,
0.0254816301,
-0.0182451513,
0.0151164653,
0.03173922,
0.0292815771,
-0.0079123657,
0.003170938,
0.0088215787,
-0.0677745491,
0.0429168828,
0.0063971961,
-0.0307535715,
-0.0010629144,
-0.008970635,
-0.0002528634,
-0.0092724487,
-0.0344875306,
-0.0314905792,
0.0264780894,
-0.0189541839,
-0.0495718718,
0.0131755657,
-0.0121462559,
0.0139927175,
-0.033315029,
-0.0247543659,
-0.0254442822,
-0.0522662997,
-0.0173587669,
0.0274832696,
-0.0086389892,
0.0029963432,
0.0022858684,
0.0222692601,
-0.032176327,
0.0586448461,
0.0710303932,
-0.021767525,
-0.0284080878,
-0.0070699006,
0.005817988,
-0.0277250446,
-0.0171701945,
0.0309209246,
-0.0022648054,
0.0137318065,
0.0097536836,
0.0168003272,
-0.0149480328,
0.0093584312,
-0.0838610008,
-0.0017274155,
0.0179588851,
0.0448555686,
-0.0079594208,
0.0369659401,
-0.020862665,
-0.0148142334,
-0.0654925779,
0.0199368149,
-0.0620912313,
-0.0018940083,
0.0522824451,
0.0413624533,
0.0061686416,
-0.0139799668,
0.0138289733,
0.0228689536,
0.0251627043,
0.02673495,
-0.0014162214,
-0.068233259,
0.0244347081,
-0.0124862604,
0.0228734259,
0.0177900847,
0.0259740297,
-0.0615435131,
-0.0338664763,
0.0213180333,
0.0596192516,
0.0071030739,
-0.0121337613,
0.015887592,
-0.0041566831,
-0.0535728969,
0.0204330422,
-0.0341679007,
0.0262724906,
0.0190933999,
0.0210203398,
0.0347610563,
0.0632552132,
-0.0404951684,
0.0099027026,
-0.0393162854,
0.0037988664,
0.0041403868,
0.0084663257,
-0.0601044334,
0.0365302637,
-0.0068702241,
0.0422707796,
-0.0259113107,
-0.0145701207,
0.0567723289,
-0.0361729003,
-0.019038748,
-0.0466510504,
-0.0121474303,
-0.0592784993,
0.0627186075,
-0.0042588874,
0.0093736714,
0.0334108025,
-0.0432374068,
0.0033729931,
0.0176217146,
0.0426928177,
-0.0127762901,
0.0319208689,
-0.0094064269,
0.0451342091,
-0.0610383712,
-0.0712632462,
-0.0264148675,
-0.0836688578,
0.0159172509,
-0.0147523563,
0.0033201426,
-0.0062034498,
-0.0390821472,
0.0323495381,
-0.0231728088,
0.0528792068,
-0.0141530717,
-0.028663516,
0.0090848077,
0.0424572602,
0.1030213237,
-0.0539529435,
-0.0544984341,
-0.0061779995,
0.0196886733,
0.0417949967,
-0.0183140617,
0.0107865715,
0.0000187523,
-0.0188743472,
0.0321049429,
-0.0539974272,
0.0035016946,
0.0151241031,
0.0009011318,
-0.0120070176,
-0.0018974897,
0.1140250489,
0.0078526521,
-0.0517389141,
0.0030072331,
0.0539968014,
-0.0200941749,
-0.0192444976,
0.0251622871,
-0.0893241987,
-0.0297091659,
-0.0191182029,
0.0206949525,
0.0273700636,
0.0083044851,
-0.035877414,
-0.1190734878,
0.005125219,
-0.0129005602,
-0.0079551376,
-0.0418394394,
-0.005846981,
-0.0078017679,
-0.0599018782,
0.0693391562,
0.0039537218,
-0.0756156668,
-0.0005137281,
0.0042058551,
0.0138721764,
-0.044986885,
0.0779550895,
-0.0022334356,
-0.0031585253,
0.0503701493,
-0.0044260109,
-0.0141750481,
-0.0049682809,
0.0172633044,
0.0250457488,
-0.0192259401,
0.0097166765,
0.0582553968,
-0.039074719,
-0.0152752968,
0.029430734,
0.0091416053,
0.0075521516,
0.0106579503,
0.0314351432,
0.0004032083,
0.0335974917,
-0.018150121,
0.0188785791,
-0.0447252356,
-0.0201345161,
0.0837971717,
-0.0081963213,
-0.0726724342,
-0.0394483283,
-0.0246224366,
-0.0581005663,
-0.0200176798,
-0.0495753475,
0.0061798352,
-0.0042051612,
-0.0354496613,
-0.0787291899,
-0.0657963827,
0.0349410027,
0.0089153927,
0.0159995928,
-0.025058927,
-0.0029038631,
0.0733270571,
-0.0414805785,
0.0217414089,
-0.0296360031,
0.0186185222,
-0.0226783846,
0.0349921659,
0.0410243645,
-0.0852211267,
-0.0276732761,
-0.0225509237,
-0.0476550683,
-0.0488800108,
-0.0340834409,
0.0110758878,
0.0111360699,
0.0635472611,
-0.0474053323,
-0.0413001329,
-0.0083236294,
0.0689828172,
-0.0462875031,
-0.0481187887,
0.0341421701,
0.0610892251,
0.0130079091,
0.0264190976,
-0.0243698843,
0.0485174544,
0.0251064375,
0.0276863948,
0.0286222938,
-0.0209630243,
0.0453357175,
0.0451031365,
0.0532460921,
0.0299071018,
0.0477084294,
-0.0400302522,
0.0323367827,
-0.0112260729,
-0.0337728597,
-0.0584869385,
0.0248558037,
0.0209230427,
-0.0188043751,
-0.0187174603,
-0.0038196745,
0.0082394583,
0.0496833175,
-0.0672919825,
-0.006910691,
-0.0314628221,
-0.0032332551,
0.0240590442,
-0.036755424,
-0.0185739044,
0.016045779,
0.0259621851,
0.0215008818,
-0.0588653795,
0.0304506179,
0.0276804771,
-0.0277055074,
-0.0301778726,
0.0621088855,
0.0061428342,
-0.005373836,
-0.0636774376,
0.0307657346,
-0.0112474961,
-0.0239627268,
0.0196039453,
-0.0372621007,
-0.0269728173,
-0.0366274528,
0.0525661781,
-0.002403253,
-0.0042988579,
0.0146039641,
0.0412846804,
-0.0540931411,
-0.0502263345,
0.0739061683,
0.0160242487,
0.0403475836,
0.0141056394,
-0.0323302448,
-0.0647343695,
0.0150735304,
0.0010742898,
0.0004787098,
-0.0283902604,
0.0099857701,
-0.0296830162,
-0.0254301112,
-0.033616215,
-0.0226941984,
0.0382471122,
0.0437614769,
0.0534935109,
0.0707399473,
0.0221228451,
0.0138931461,
-0.0140812062,
-0.002446281,
0.0058475127,
0.0097121662,
-0.0310663283,
-5.907932119e-33,
0.0104119023,
0.0080545433,
0.0105945738,
0.0540249795,
-0.0032465155,
0.0212666448,
0.0034121072,
-0.0001332262,
-0.0045607877,
0.0204176344,
0.0083745681,
-0.0295266546,
0.0239225738,
0.0356633849,
0.0045719463,
-0.0405498035,
0.0341765434,
0.0255359411,
-0.0161598157,
0.0516407117,
0.0107478974,
0.0495839268,
0.0708003864,
-0.0322536454,
0.0189286657,
-0.0348706692,
-0.0020938215,
0.0146854836,
0.0580834188,
0.0500961356,
-0.0271125436,
0.0433171168,
0.0155377714,
-0.0480227098,
0.0144359348,
0.0047208304,
-0.1095186919,
0.0115650902,
-0.0027434309,
0.0061061024,
-0.0067569241,
0.0120791011,
-0.0234447494,
-0.0325193927,
0.0205642357,
0.0018697438,
0.0516159981,
-0.0381487533,
-0.0246460978,
-0.0348986909,
-0.0605283305,
0.0219561663,
0.012723946,
-0.0186645165,
0.0895792842,
0.0507890545,
0.0165682118,
0.005440434,
0.0130833266,
0.0172286686,
0.0018432083,
0.0270090047,
0.02230018,
0.0197318215,
0.0097569171,
0.0399423465,
0.0288879573,
0.00477897,
-0.0050948681,
0.0719313249,
-0.0186271071,
0.0631000474,
-0.0054519521,
0.0235945545,
0.0581962094,
0.0110457102,
-0.0173804946,
0.0045768199,
0.0550149381,
-0.0071141319,
-0.0336993001,
0.008925736,
-0.0600629486,
-0.0135244112,
0.0185812339,
0.022775704,
-0.0701197684,
-0.0301770233,
0.0333011821,
0.0479409471,
-0.0519484282,
0.0504952036,
0.0075947978,
-0.0127286054,
-0.0367020145,
-0.0175983533,
-0.0168159399,
0.0042036241,
-0.0182292257,
-0.0544102974,
-0.0454817452,
-0.0447899364,
-0.0051802094,
0.0074875597,
-0.0110554472,
-0.0098077878,
0.0612001643,
0.0095986594,
-0.0403668024,
-0.0018322314,
-0.010856702,
-0.0015115341,
-0.0225844849,
0.0505989641,
0.041964639,
0.0300225485,
-0.0561200902,
0.0749374032,
0.0161319934,
-0.0136990612,
-0.045029331,
-0.048018612,
0.0293144081,
-0.0079516852,
0.0004503796,
0.0155851627,
-0.0140861878,
-0.0335653089,
0.0286457408,
-0.0457723849,
-0.0042989114,
0.0217171963,
2.661e-7,
0.00412506,
0.0469782278,
0.0065998533,
0.0247347802,
0.0213981401,
0.052602414,
0.0191424768,
0.0466374047,
-0.0214333497,
-0.0042624632,
0.0370770469,
0.0071205576,
0.0394142643,
-0.0009361869,
-0.0862879381,
-0.0140990671,
-0.0555255376,
-0.0446309224,
-0.0569937602,
-0.0211835746,
0.0900284871,
0.0757751912,
0.0014472583,
0.0079787802,
0.0173276849,
-0.0361247174,
0.0581546947,
-0.0193397887,
0.0066409176,
0.0344904214,
0.0287467726,
0.0223585628,
-0.0544980876,
-0.0215277448,
-0.0047681034,
0.0152163859,
0.044065278,
0.0715379938,
0.0070152758,
-0.0019476875,
-0.0316532366,
-0.0409587137,
-0.0092035187,
-0.0212064739,
0.0994750708,
-0.0574702807,
-0.0083316518,
-0.0516946837,
-0.0435998589,
-0.0096816346,
-0.0178064387,
-0.0229047127,
-0.0114213442,
0.0323034935,
0.0212883949,
-0.0455330983,
-0.0314200446,
-0.0621139444,
-0.0083446447,
-0.003471073,
0.0008979092,
-0.0218502339,
-0.0170701444,
0.0547501259,
0.020056339,
-0.072791405,
-0.0084445477,
2.197714111e-34,
0.0429714173,
0.001420112,
-0.0074377684,
0.034091223,
0.0050211484,
0.0073628314,
0.0399574265,
-0.0338861644,
-0.0026578694,
-0.0810407251,
-0.0185000952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13379v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13379v1 | Stress Testing BERT Anaphora Resolution Models for Reaction Extraction in Chemical Patents | 2023-06-23T09:01:56 | 2023-06-23T09:01:56 | Chieling Yueh, Evangelos Kanoulas, Bruno Martins, Camilo Thorne, Saber Akhondi | cs.CL | cs.CL | The high volume of published chemical patents and the importance of a timely
acquisition of their information gives rise to automating information
extraction from chemical patents. Anaphora resolution is an important component
of comprehensive information extraction, and is critical for extracting
reactions. In chemical patents, there are five anaphoric relations of interest:
co-reference, transformed, reaction associated, work up, and contained. Our
goal is to investigate how the performance of anaphora resolution models for
reaction texts in chemical patents differs in a noise-free and noisy
environment and to what extent we can improve the robustness against noise of
the model. | [
0.0478605703,
0.0419723541,
-0.016984392,
0.0200708229,
-0.0606448092,
-0.01325808,
-0.0081184441,
0.0475563966,
0.0157518387,
-0.0748250037,
-0.0052031218,
-0.0101116765,
-0.028400071,
-0.0350027122,
0.0166661106,
-0.0118580423,
0.0208917502,
-0.0471052602,
0.0115421889,
0.0090150461,
0.0114942901,
0.0152794877,
-0.0076787448,
0.0388823524,
0.0104099978,
0.0191725697,
0.0272262879,
0.0181851145,
0.0442681424,
-0.0228869542,
0.0081335781,
0.0454262197,
-0.0189431049,
0.0341001861,
0.0000012889,
-0.1024526432,
-0.006599891,
0.0565850846,
0.0196822248,
0.0303788614,
0.0184226632,
0.0014423834,
-0.0154308872,
0.0143719083,
0.0280764941,
0.0100329742,
0.0153350364,
0.0165437032,
0.0028620143,
0.0104991067,
-0.0368207581,
-0.0373346843,
0.0601041205,
-0.0013244669,
0.007263646,
-0.0288756229,
0.0673489571,
-0.0274790004,
0.0582798794,
-0.0655781105,
0.0206602234,
0.0261679851,
-0.0355331115,
-0.0103871152,
-0.022997709,
0.005691004,
-0.0018054857,
0.00150477,
0.0013215755,
0.048343543,
0.0081810681,
0.0170247536,
-0.0003982748,
0.0244662948,
0.0097711552,
0.0521236435,
-0.0364045985,
-0.0079004848,
-0.0334286615,
0.0187379122,
0.0234586503,
-0.0101368781,
-0.0457485951,
-0.0052601043,
-0.0239566844,
0.0326174833,
0.0173425116,
-0.050530225,
0.0462203324,
-0.020379724,
-0.0162024852,
-0.0068456228,
0.0597037375,
0.00140306,
0.037082538,
0.0388550498,
-0.0295398682,
-0.0614237897,
0.0379973352,
-0.1280450374,
-0.0093819853,
-0.0160898697,
-0.0070021995,
0.0352845155,
-0.0465856716,
0.0550053045,
0.0141521739,
0.0169108175,
-0.0258959383,
-0.0077046263,
-0.0571429692,
-0.0010005401,
-0.0841689855,
0.0679437593,
-0.0406727791,
-0.0162164383,
-0.0204583108,
-0.0058764294,
-0.0216436759,
0.0115657225,
-0.0125452364,
-0.0043606833,
-0.045286078,
0.0036920644,
0.0059408275,
-0.0074204188,
0.0042453809,
-0.0138741266,
-0.041583214,
-0.0416522324,
-0.0088572102,
-0.0118173063,
-0.0010840979,
-0.0514273867,
0.0010496782,
0.0826429352,
0.0180311948,
-0.0254379567,
-0.0214179214,
-0.0358340554,
0.0050782459,
-0.0302568413,
0.0019882172,
-0.0395650454,
0.0554383062,
0.0191813763,
0.0031575682,
-0.0608083457,
0.0232492872,
-0.008990936,
-0.0587925427,
0.0440072641,
-0.0055159344,
-0.0269073471,
-0.0458124951,
0.0011326899,
0.0198411606,
0.0083972244,
0.0271878429,
-0.0095116887,
0.0076935692,
-0.0129028875,
-0.0126285208,
0.0230008122,
-0.0067705428,
-0.0319517925,
0.01570802,
-0.0051157069,
0.0164968353,
0.0180078223,
0.0187162887,
0.0498575941,
0.0138771916,
-0.0130066257,
0.0480499938,
0.0523997881,
0.0237350017,
0.0193163548,
-0.0365565866,
0.0017620295,
0.0627004951,
0.0337378792,
0.0065813479,
-0.0272553749,
-0.0427011363,
0.0022522751,
0.019845847,
0.0394671336,
-0.0021093818,
-0.0385237895,
-0.0504815727,
0.0115844673,
-0.0398055539,
-0.075716503,
0.0756095126,
-0.0079869395,
-0.0899191722,
0.0528941751,
0.0045727054,
-0.0325901434,
0.0133894635,
-0.0306714978,
-0.0173749905,
0.0541672483,
0.0780223161,
-0.0420741811,
-0.0398270786,
-0.0008842605,
-0.0622136183,
0.042892877,
0.0017972902,
-0.0075850631,
0.0214201976,
-0.0114762569,
-0.0317357816,
0.0084977355,
0.019930413,
-0.0100063821,
-0.0261153523,
-0.0073000439,
-0.0109066367,
-0.0291340742,
-0.0176307913,
0.0249067023,
-0.0152436178,
-0.0769722685,
-0.0184217021,
-0.0208247434,
0.0146104759,
0.0408178084,
-0.060821943,
0.0414871685,
0.0576259419,
-0.0680359602,
-0.0061377832,
0.06668327,
0.0705082789,
-0.0119173443,
0.0356176868,
-0.0077403709,
0.0037360569,
-0.0067231245,
0.0028173348,
-0.0108905248,
-0.008266151,
-0.0289341193,
0.0472616404,
0.0072173984,
0.0170861315,
0.0064015938,
0.0248255506,
-0.033344809,
0.0386146866,
0.0112522701,
0.0328979716,
0.0013383918,
-0.0297368467,
0.010966829,
-0.0064278971,
0.0000392896,
0.0168127511,
0.0099582737,
-0.019635018,
0.0093579013,
-0.0427651256,
0.0110189449,
-0.0285067465,
-0.0213550217,
0.0012227282,
0.011926488,
0.0828571692,
0.0179318171,
-0.0170621164,
-0.0073650707,
0.0105523085,
0.0241546649,
-0.0278065465,
-0.0497814678,
-0.0073244441,
0.0407875776,
0.0191127434,
-0.0741762593,
-0.0329100005,
-0.0237916037,
-0.022976771,
0.0677657351,
0.0493788943,
-0.0602218807,
-0.0461505651,
0.0291772354,
0.0206754785,
0.0460577011,
0.0324220173,
0.0017857467,
0.0004098399,
-0.0085048834,
0.0052174656,
-0.0113817388,
0.0040951893,
0.0335766412,
0.0151537377,
-0.0104371961,
-0.0343067087,
-0.0141888857,
0.0111372955,
0.0301978271,
0.0199036561,
-0.0595841594,
0.0403617807,
0.0555480719,
-0.027364891,
-0.0023226894,
-0.0198712163,
-0.0282837171,
-0.0152503652,
-0.0118368519,
-0.0196484774,
-0.0393134803,
-0.0231794249,
0.003429733,
-0.002080529,
-0.0235475022,
0.0662583485,
-0.0349535979,
0.0305729285,
-0.1080690771,
0.040378876,
0.0275597014,
0.0255127922,
-0.0160745345,
0.0286852065,
0.0533352196,
-0.0382137634,
-0.0084656943,
-0.0489583686,
0.0356903784,
-0.0309159216,
0.035979636,
-0.0291158482,
0.0538000651,
0.0018346508,
-0.0004272865,
-0.0145291779,
-0.0153849721,
0.0692339391,
0.0394711792,
0.0327444337,
-0.0210250616,
0.0069985674,
0.0698856488,
0.020890452,
-0.023037849,
0.013797313,
-0.0249885451,
-0.0329842567,
0.0984244868,
0.0423877239,
-0.0362485535,
0.0005472057,
-0.027119197,
-0.0020977487,
0.0375395715,
0.0728350133,
0.0190872755,
-0.0262531564,
-0.0397633426,
-0.0055665541,
-0.0478323922,
0.0048763533,
-0.0060965912,
-0.069197014,
-0.0024452503,
-0.0034507143,
0.0841819197,
0.0226599704,
0.0511864461,
0.0419798233,
0.0196420997,
-0.0062417304,
-0.0206076298,
0.0422130078,
-0.0482343249,
0.0529191755,
-0.0064126411,
0.0198152494,
-0.0094652921,
-0.0222965796,
0.0277641714,
-0.1071820706,
0.0641900972,
-0.004376749,
-0.0619081706,
-0.0826245993,
-0.0736467466,
0.0323661081,
0.0015425335,
-0.0023644201,
0.0117052644,
-0.0200559739,
-0.0305572879,
0.0414454415,
-0.0477556847,
-0.0545614287,
-0.0098400433,
-0.0514429212,
-0.0249259658,
0.0151484814,
0.0190049075,
-0.0305203032,
0.0092264311,
0.040686477,
-0.030995138,
-0.0045236889,
-0.0053427322,
0.0222667046,
0.0459196605,
-0.0003801311,
-0.0183339957,
-0.0031434495,
-0.0346906222,
-0.0279302076,
-0.0514661446,
0.0302419253,
0.0087411273,
-0.0066103488,
-0.050503321,
0.0209999178,
0.0085268002,
0.053370785,
0.0385700278,
-0.0251747128,
-0.0726999119,
-0.0027563628,
0.0107167866,
-0.0866046622,
0.0268484876,
-0.0087091858,
-0.0720097795,
-0.0599385202,
-0.0899543241,
-0.0368419513,
-0.0031579179,
0.0744225532,
-0.0161066297,
0.0110361204,
0.0216767043,
0.0077345571,
-0.0135959536,
0.0322784446,
0.0457120575,
0.0073071076,
-0.007156678,
-0.0108117294,
0.0551589318,
0.0429707579,
-0.0483696163,
0.0546582267,
-0.012956731,
-0.0767413378,
0.024863027,
0.0065291962,
0.0390406251,
-0.0128200678,
-0.0349464715,
-0.0216605421,
0.037156105,
0.0668475777,
0.0365861095,
-0.0008229098,
0.0178025886,
-0.0391554497,
-0.0338305607,
-0.0171888247,
-0.0140016824,
0.0261739418,
-0.0165225547,
0.0587848872,
0.0016303271,
-0.0737415105,
0.0466870405,
0.0676948503,
0.0206684731,
0.0188253615,
-0.0097209737,
-0.03050326,
0.0237645693,
0.0252094474,
0.0355006084,
-0.0420801528,
-0.0089450348,
0.0066336808,
-0.0267675836,
-0.0206786674,
0.0203254148,
-0.0085052093,
-0.0003723931,
-0.0184477288,
-0.0185066331,
-0.0294823684,
0.0263197459,
0.0380455442,
-0.0333527774,
0.0124978423,
0.0144270696,
0.0045320396,
0.0081388615,
-0.0329151042,
-0.0255913306,
-0.0190613922,
0.0459281057,
0.0063551911,
0.0180417746,
-0.0277987458,
-0.0043977676,
-0.1189886332,
0.0129522914,
0.0737602264,
-0.0106019443,
0.0789990351,
-0.0689330772,
0.0158791821,
0.0029548183,
-0.0238675736,
0.0003305415,
0.0767360479,
0.0377366319,
0.0243716799,
0.031739451,
-0.0060053398,
0.0829318538,
0.0357448645,
0.0677700639,
-0.0406383798,
-0.0553367548,
-0.0214911345,
-0.0631198063,
-0.0006681116,
-0.0485545844,
-0.0242323708,
-0.0222637095,
-0.0638606325,
-0.0222906452,
0.0378773101,
0.0212257933,
0.031287536,
-0.0133180786,
0.0332920291,
0.06659206,
0.0424479358,
-0.0233313646,
-0.0141774733,
0.0525699183,
0.0138738742,
-0.0439631939,
0.0036805882,
-5.088183868e-33,
-0.0208667554,
-0.013898205,
-0.0410709269,
0.0248341225,
0.0132084535,
-0.0327478349,
-0.0695960373,
-0.0394628979,
0.0286653452,
0.034386076,
0.0149385985,
-0.0065749339,
0.0264626779,
-0.0607925169,
-0.0159579366,
-0.0302093998,
0.0224876497,
0.0042563216,
0.0057200626,
-0.0203060172,
0.062560834,
0.0481020361,
0.0285064392,
-0.0881261304,
0.0317153931,
0.0366901755,
0.0104617104,
-0.0559829958,
-0.0121038901,
0.0509853698,
-0.0142794093,
0.0508280061,
-0.0010714747,
-0.0341633298,
-0.0120363329,
-0.0443782695,
-0.099538669,
0.0121520981,
0.0228427649,
-0.0030699593,
-0.0047388398,
-0.0109283328,
0.0567848831,
0.0106001617,
-0.068429403,
0.038592495,
0.0405032299,
-0.013216937,
-0.033858452,
-0.0609375462,
-0.0914576501,
-0.0024671282,
0.02649666,
0.017156858,
0.0267721508,
0.0315304734,
0.00538916,
0.0025002081,
0.006532785,
-0.0076667196,
0.0609826706,
0.0448316149,
0.0247848239,
-0.0230489206,
0.0000691828,
0.0093325814,
-0.0316026025,
0.0432799719,
0.0535048395,
0.0111161815,
0.0082326522,
0.0620606281,
0.0524171069,
-0.0129176723,
0.0660594106,
0.0380493216,
-0.0722905174,
0.0494186208,
0.0220658649,
0.007811137,
0.0346205086,
0.0186140332,
-0.0126265762,
0.0024272089,
-0.0022436213,
0.0467721671,
-0.0054925177,
0.0121391285,
0.0006533624,
-0.0248499289,
-0.0299538933,
0.0474577509,
0.0044449777,
-0.0272125434,
-0.0350244828,
-0.0177654363,
0.0100113042,
0.080648765,
-0.021922823,
-0.0331443995,
-0.0086745815,
-0.0482193977,
0.002081332,
0.0348100588,
0.0258318409,
-0.0001873311,
-0.0339364745,
-0.021758683,
-0.0421488918,
-0.0003031929,
-0.0435633771,
0.0107006924,
0.0296384301,
-0.0234298371,
0.0040365243,
-0.0071913339,
0.0588443093,
0.000881327,
0.023005927,
-0.0125846649,
0.0513544939,
0.0472377203,
0.0349737592,
0.0109743141,
0.0239565317,
-0.0019109844,
0.0038047554,
0.0651066899,
0.012793012,
-0.0274373516,
-0.0132924356,
0.0274405535,
2.239e-7,
0.0704929456,
0.0298435446,
0.0596858412,
0.0157419369,
0.0031366246,
-0.0227188226,
-0.0090236235,
0.0492533371,
-0.0313684233,
-0.0315008834,
0.0075824116,
-0.0469654202,
0.027164368,
0.0444486178,
-0.0391951874,
-0.0938581675,
-0.0564252138,
-0.0010427368,
-0.0706786364,
0.0299506895,
0.0630733147,
0.013621713,
-0.0338370167,
-0.0152205685,
-0.0279458575,
-0.0656737462,
0.0256902073,
-0.0099226665,
-0.0030729591,
0.0616110191,
0.0749130026,
-0.0397358388,
-0.0073784492,
0.0524168424,
-0.0323200747,
0.0201711562,
0.027938107,
0.0283549037,
-0.0180756319,
0.0037133042,
0.0276425537,
-0.0604429506,
0.03044484,
0.005790229,
0.0091527039,
0.0094257789,
0.0099472646,
0.0371045657,
-0.0395916477,
-0.0024285652,
-0.0243154485,
-0.0221597925,
-0.0144364275,
0.0032298001,
-0.0093523031,
0.0086156866,
-0.0224081371,
-0.0588402152,
0.0044525946,
0.0030763084,
-0.0395488031,
-0.0111441426,
0.0136786336,
-0.0140784327,
0.0000857396,
-0.0663092807,
-0.0138518782,
2.3280622e-34,
0.050591208,
-0.0207059644,
-0.0013284775,
0.0462367758,
0.0140515454,
0.0089672273,
0.000774091,
0.011641264,
-0.0292879287,
-0.0975475162,
-0.0081201121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.15685v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.15685v1 | Implementing contextual biasing in GPU decoder for online ASR | 2023-06-23T08:59:50 | 2023-06-23T08:59:50 | Iuliia Nigmatulina, Srikanth Madikeri, Esaú Villatoro-Tello, Petr Motliček, Juan Zuluaga-Gomez, Karthik Pandia, Aravind Ganapathiraju | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | GPU decoding significantly accelerates the output of ASR predictions. While
GPUs are already being used for online ASR decoding, post-processing and
rescoring on GPUs have not been properly investigated yet. Rescoring with
available contextual information can considerably improve ASR predictions.
Previous studies have proven the viability of lattice rescoring in decoding and
biasing language model (LM) weights in offline and online CPU scenarios. In
real-time GPU decoding, partial recognition hypotheses are produced without
lattice generation, which makes the implementation of biasing more complex. The
paper proposes and describes an approach to integrate contextual biasing in
real-time GPU decoding while exploiting the standard Kaldi GPU decoder. Besides
the biasing of partial ASR predictions, our approach also permits dynamic
context switching allowing a flexible rescoring per each speech segment
directly on GPU. The code is publicly released and tested with open-sourced
test sets. | [
-0.0411821045,
0.0387709811,
-0.0141121093,
0.044382222,
-0.0090715187,
0.0321562737,
0.0449569449,
0.0017472791,
-0.0455597863,
-0.0150248855,
-0.0182445832,
-0.0165879484,
0.0703906268,
0.0175229777,
-0.016980527,
-0.0597366132,
-0.0103416303,
-0.0688202083,
0.0417250991,
-0.0417217761,
0.0063485722,
0.0394198969,
-0.0431972072,
0.0236805025,
0.0075356597,
-0.0152198942,
0.0012161866,
0.0160755552,
0.0175793562,
-0.0192057602,
-0.0366252959,
-0.0001243661,
0.0456144512,
0.01337945,
0.0000020667,
-0.0186655037,
-0.0297624655,
0.0059082713,
-0.0535989292,
-0.028975809,
0.0636365935,
-0.0792289898,
-0.0424806587,
-0.0015457114,
-0.0514230132,
-0.0119887227,
0.0584865287,
-0.0073109204,
-0.0471469201,
-0.0226220619,
-0.0061295768,
-0.030517213,
0.004610097,
-0.0069076992,
-0.018071156,
-0.0313402042,
-0.0141179524,
0.0068902257,
-0.0606297441,
-0.0407359153,
-0.0398178995,
0.0353145078,
0.0155181913,
-0.0155922649,
-0.0256523304,
0.0093424637,
0.0080869999,
-0.0172485467,
-0.028291963,
0.0118131721,
-0.0343994908,
-0.048982352,
0.0004309579,
-0.0166412126,
-0.0372899473,
-0.0243788976,
-0.0201784074,
0.068077825,
-0.0575872511,
-0.0015089497,
0.0543722361,
0.0253674574,
0.025280036,
-0.0303202476,
0.0038823592,
0.0605426878,
0.0388973467,
-0.032320559,
-0.0152224964,
0.0393121205,
0.0376190357,
-0.0292774793,
0.0488829575,
-0.0185845047,
-0.0282540061,
0.029389007,
-0.0464899689,
-0.0327985846,
-0.0188105088,
-0.0422829837,
0.0284802653,
0.0613130443,
0.0163312592,
-0.0137084518,
-0.0056330543,
0.0298768859,
0.0269545391,
-0.0275673978,
-0.0316251442,
0.0234129708,
0.0263972543,
-0.0183140561,
-0.0434876643,
0.0032350698,
-0.065721415,
-0.0189342014,
-0.0357232615,
0.0222994313,
-0.0126222325,
-0.0286795273,
0.0377687216,
0.0076254434,
-0.0434386171,
0.0028963173,
0.0304148067,
0.0263333656,
-0.0075068641,
0.0243425053,
-0.0097922347,
-0.10885939,
0.0136195542,
0.0145445978,
0.0348616205,
-0.0183926858,
0.0003691738,
-0.0082129845,
0.0023258356,
-0.0042023142,
0.0103911059,
0.0212705974,
-0.0097999088,
-0.0040163933,
0.012886242,
-0.0262415651,
0.0368275605,
0.0359349623,
0.0259263683,
0.0077645886,
0.0078628361,
0.0198525991,
0.0556814671,
0.0488579795,
-0.0054517253,
-0.0173573606,
0.0418096557,
-0.0029139502,
0.0584720783,
0.0792055503,
0.0291887,
0.0090085659,
-0.0107438341,
-0.0327648707,
0.0105865374,
-0.0028701387,
0.0066026924,
-0.0087163886,
-0.0524406023,
-0.0009434027,
0.0298090372,
0.0467699617,
0.0875630826,
0.0355680063,
-0.040826384,
-0.009029978,
0.0258241519,
0.0370730869,
0.0234972704,
0.030335756,
-0.0034412788,
-0.0037038692,
0.0015563831,
-0.0150026195,
0.0208523087,
0.0148120187,
0.0129191102,
0.0420032106,
0.0478458591,
0.0662004575,
0.0250048917,
-0.0091128116,
0.0094605144,
-0.0276126117,
-0.0121335322,
0.0258924961,
0.0356079973,
0.0275538992,
-0.0478028543,
0.0019534808,
0.0017488542,
-0.0486444496,
-0.0223403908,
-0.0671112835,
0.0056079845,
0.0686668083,
0.0607945696,
0.0157185495,
-0.0337866843,
-0.0064119282,
-0.0577943847,
0.0220763925,
-0.0499892458,
-0.0048202076,
0.0499123409,
-0.0804101005,
-0.0051924274,
0.0624293983,
0.0034736958,
0.0671969876,
-0.0061575626,
0.0159886461,
-0.0203597881,
-0.039045319,
-0.0010381162,
0.0002907628,
0.036690291,
-0.0226262696,
0.0212270822,
0.0001222405,
-0.000055779,
0.0073020002,
-0.0149225099,
-0.0317729972,
0.04151842,
-0.0413093343,
0.0232972018,
0.0266939607,
-0.1029925123,
-0.0579783507,
0.0178182535,
0.008088273,
0.0342540853,
-0.012636493,
0.0112551106,
-0.0276203398,
0.0265823994,
0.0108260075,
0.0815063789,
-0.0319355689,
0.0255317297,
0.0292740986,
0.0330239721,
-0.0041394844,
0.0328439698,
-0.020404011,
0.0039980509,
0.0459122881,
-0.0044259909,
-0.033209607,
-0.0954392701,
0.0569156371,
0.0221467409,
-0.0068141143,
0.0173717048,
0.0035583675,
-0.0352009758,
0.0254519656,
0.0146050584,
-0.0678617284,
-0.0373410396,
-0.0236003269,
0.0132252602,
0.0364419073,
0.0159083754,
-0.0095783537,
-0.0394623466,
0.0468241312,
-0.0356722549,
-0.0032094992,
-0.0049779359,
-0.0361821614,
-0.0187761169,
-0.0143832937,
0.0310052056,
-0.0161245801,
0.0094168996,
0.0518075414,
0.0122878496,
-0.0602278784,
-0.0617339909,
-0.0069922763,
0.0480720401,
0.0163088143,
0.0052366266,
0.0086109703,
0.0205546506,
0.0118470108,
0.0228319317,
0.0807963759,
-0.0151114613,
0.0053893118,
0.0236306321,
-0.0258925203,
-0.0176794045,
-0.0062306803,
0.0327302255,
0.0012363442,
-0.0161490254,
-0.0099570714,
-0.0307641309,
0.0685217828,
0.0297391638,
0.0315463617,
-0.0195315685,
-0.0344290696,
-0.0088141691,
-0.0437208116,
-0.0351701677,
-0.0201146007,
-0.0210540723,
0.0181793198,
-0.001300469,
-0.0769587085,
0.0006723066,
-0.0711606741,
-0.0270376299,
-0.0303866733,
0.0037241916,
-0.0111556416,
0.0140576698,
-0.0002402712,
0.0059378506,
-0.0845264122,
-0.0170570407,
0.0612001792,
0.0452840775,
-0.0198167246,
-0.0594073869,
-0.0009444474,
-0.0575970002,
0.0022816916,
-0.0414659902,
-0.0007862663,
0.003584282,
0.1025900766,
-0.0451573022,
-0.0080077611,
0.0384416804,
-0.0210878793,
0.0505918898,
0.0415448062,
-0.0299725123,
0.0672269762,
-0.0037450206,
-0.0040810169,
-0.0032551957,
0.0182981566,
0.0474522263,
0.0206148624,
-0.0309704095,
0.0149660585,
0.0028381415,
0.0154880742,
0.0875151381,
-0.0040087034,
-0.0746951476,
0.0027660131,
0.0742776617,
0.0074601858,
0.0197342336,
0.055694174,
-0.0379149914,
-0.0798491463,
0.0079793101,
0.0586672798,
0.0075067636,
-0.0763420016,
-0.0335992277,
0.015147306,
0.0193148497,
0.0148887048,
0.0053569642,
-0.0916188732,
-0.0283997804,
0.0401084088,
0.0287467819,
-0.0030884393,
0.0030152097,
-0.0083304029,
-0.0839561448,
0.0639208183,
0.0069480613,
-0.0012556509,
-0.0300337803,
-0.0324779153,
-0.0219075251,
0.010111982,
0.0268296078,
0.0179985911,
-0.0097287688,
0.0172998793,
0.0320632346,
-0.0565070473,
-0.0121441763,
-0.0243668165,
-0.0069585699,
0.078248769,
0.1025862172,
0.0264992118,
0.0058300756,
-0.0244463645,
-0.0034699638,
-0.0402522348,
0.0240923092,
-0.0509746149,
0.0001492698,
-0.0249682199,
0.0238944534,
-0.0189239085,
0.0048122033,
-0.0547601618,
-0.012071277,
0.0113988128,
0.0326016918,
-0.0519979931,
-0.0204504188,
0.0288374051,
-0.0268675368,
0.0382209532,
0.0231392346,
-0.0171389244,
0.0048778118,
-0.0528990775,
-0.0596294515,
0.0589495525,
-0.0333154276,
-0.0026649688,
-0.0120375967,
0.0418409966,
-0.041467227,
0.0048996233,
0.0102014951,
0.004811265,
0.0588122234,
0.0173308961,
0.0313840769,
-0.0164798461,
0.0025208157,
-0.0846972689,
-0.0557310581,
-0.0420362428,
0.0466498286,
-0.0393590815,
-0.0219036378,
0.0073214071,
-0.0813505352,
-0.0047528539,
0.0426100865,
-0.0461544581,
-0.0060442346,
0.0816200152,
0.0097399866,
0.0198158398,
0.0499349162,
-0.0235607997,
-0.0400207862,
0.0808234215,
0.0526202656,
-0.0304533336,
0.0428743325,
0.0152172428,
0.0192142222,
-0.0090937205,
-0.0043320972,
-0.0107155992,
0.0187554918,
-0.0188316498,
0.0109321363,
-0.0108072488,
-0.0591739193,
0.0069187037,
0.0278775562,
0.0289239604,
-0.0454961956,
-0.0091765821,
-0.0056520831,
0.057714574,
0.0085682739,
0.0678354502,
0.0025479195,
-0.0319495201,
0.0320310555,
0.0126920603,
-0.0045742327,
0.0304402541,
0.0156001272,
-0.0683411509,
-0.0370251127,
0.0520608164,
0.0167546757,
0.0420373827,
0.0074145836,
-0.0022577562,
0.0177511647,
0.0424084812,
0.0135847544,
0.0720916241,
-0.0168641023,
0.011583372,
-0.0040890081,
-0.0152827799,
0.0221775752,
0.0555001721,
-0.0125376331,
-0.0050996128,
-0.0573267378,
-0.0015865935,
-0.0019098978,
0.0223951507,
0.0378626622,
-0.0018816878,
0.0250311028,
-0.0454316437,
0.030328447,
-0.0102032423,
-0.0329342782,
0.0550320223,
0.0001037792,
-0.0305841845,
0.0424624458,
0.019623572,
-0.0454674847,
0.0116363065,
0.0058101988,
0.0032837768,
-0.0329991691,
-0.0614565834,
-0.0977894366,
-0.0335638896,
-0.0370288715,
-0.0387456715,
0.030658707,
-0.0429171324,
0.0169344526,
-0.0179976933,
0.0225031953,
-0.0712054595,
-0.0139548602,
0.0122540016,
-0.056144096,
-0.0242374912,
0.0089378152,
0.0220630653,
-0.038392704,
0.0079402709,
-0.0142917763,
-6.182376622e-33,
-0.04448599,
0.0112947663,
0.0491435118,
-0.0310341511,
0.0085307835,
0.0165982172,
-0.007956191,
-0.0220945645,
0.0212513078,
-0.0186472237,
-0.0129659008,
-0.0112912841,
0.0463825315,
0.0091691557,
-0.0234815404,
-0.0122474171,
0.0717730448,
-0.0167268682,
0.0064839195,
0.015065439,
-0.0160623845,
0.0368315428,
0.0168021172,
-0.044245176,
-0.0293477122,
0.0049842787,
0.0102469623,
-0.0374026783,
-0.0024715138,
0.0215023085,
-0.0386000499,
0.0190891773,
0.0149469413,
-0.0360758081,
-0.006937861,
0.0403631106,
-0.0927788764,
0.0131210973,
0.0079042669,
0.0866950005,
-0.0340118855,
-0.04892461,
-0.0227637123,
0.0552606173,
-0.0647869259,
-0.0097668925,
-0.0165779311,
-0.0266036317,
-0.0686555803,
-0.040983364,
-0.0076592909,
0.0337197967,
0.0093518291,
0.0420469344,
0.1008836329,
-0.0308436938,
-0.0353549905,
0.0110917464,
-0.0719723403,
0.0430631712,
0.0182673335,
0.0308325477,
0.07692267,
0.0262573119,
0.0153280944,
0.0135379415,
0.074724637,
-0.0445945822,
-0.0121242125,
0.0179910604,
0.0107238302,
-0.0146197947,
-0.0626056269,
0.0389927588,
0.0752535239,
-0.0274068508,
0.020753352,
-0.0296625681,
0.018299479,
0.0008894922,
0.0631287172,
0.0548641942,
-0.0322156288,
-0.0297778416,
-0.0310582202,
-0.052439779,
-0.0123232948,
-0.0002815396,
0.0693501234,
0.0455178879,
-0.0197335873,
0.0169609953,
0.0199798103,
-0.0133256819,
0.0495622791,
-0.0172510277,
0.0285815839,
0.0168602224,
0.00669144,
-0.0021265296,
-0.0122795096,
-0.0082437824,
0.0533146858,
-0.0011485385,
0.038985651,
-0.04289601,
-0.0417797938,
0.0551670007,
-0.0868671685,
0.0070650801,
-0.0145651465,
0.0158008635,
0.0409223363,
0.0325525999,
0.0407678112,
-0.006662928,
0.0088650733,
0.0240547545,
-0.0241112001,
0.0237300918,
-0.0260793734,
-0.0273063816,
-0.0146674244,
0.0004675323,
-0.0493677557,
-0.0046093939,
0.0157894753,
-0.069893688,
0.0243152548,
-0.0362391211,
-0.035909757,
0.0127312047,
2.798e-7,
-0.0173859745,
0.0561659448,
0.0541162528,
-0.0150734782,
0.0029502416,
-0.0211041514,
0.039115414,
-0.0023097144,
0.0566527545,
0.0003789554,
-0.022552643,
0.0157940593,
0.0562076196,
0.0148942657,
-0.0669021755,
0.0277121756,
-0.0205057599,
0.0597690567,
0.022216538,
0.021163201,
-0.0604889579,
0.0734103471,
-0.0591900907,
-0.0313989781,
0.0879867002,
-0.0120005691,
-0.0166995265,
-0.0013709913,
0.0433990546,
-0.020488644,
-0.0333384201,
-0.0117393862,
-0.0436238348,
0.0405771434,
0.0123940147,
-0.0218619388,
-0.0230862126,
0.0469051227,
-0.0541752726,
-0.0073440913,
-0.0003718376,
0.0027932643,
-0.0046873465,
-0.0182868727,
0.0285625085,
0.0826201513,
0.0303443037,
-0.0635520592,
-0.0366268717,
-0.0036082487,
-0.0265313834,
0.012052631,
0.0714180991,
-0.000258552,
0.0327191465,
0.0219766274,
-0.04315418,
-0.0104804635,
-0.0226956196,
-0.0180140622,
-0.0328189433,
-0.0435127765,
-0.0674339831,
-0.0026631753,
0.0294175576,
-0.0464027151,
-0.0036891589,
2.416417819e-34,
0.0252271071,
0.0213087928,
0.0029417884,
0.033648435,
0.0317808241,
-0.0616328828,
-0.014354744,
0.0402869284,
-0.0149105964,
-0.0759843662,
-0.0285195597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13315v1 | Abstractive Text Summarization for Resumes With Cutting Edge NLP Transformers and LSTM | 2023-06-23T06:33:20 | 2023-06-23T06:33:20 | Öykü Berfin Mercan, Sena Nur Cavsak, Aysu Deliahmetoglu, Senem Tanberk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text summarization is a fundamental task in natural language processing that
aims to condense large amounts of textual information into concise and coherent
summaries. With the exponential growth of content and the need to extract key
information efficiently, text summarization has gained significant attention in
recent years. In this study, LSTM and pre-trained T5, Pegasus, BART and
BART-Large model performances were evaluated on the open source dataset (Xsum,
CNN/Daily Mail, Amazon Fine Food Review and News Summary) and the prepared
resume dataset. This resume dataset consists of many information such as
language, education, experience, personal information, skills, and this data
includes 75 resumes. The primary objective of this research was to classify
resume text. Various techniques such as LSTM, pre-trained models, and
fine-tuned models were assessed using a dataset of resumes. The BART-Large
model fine-tuned with the resume dataset gave the best performance. | [
0.0548372082,
0.0163471736,
0.0149676977,
-0.0136444559,
-0.0097924722,
-0.0018754249,
-0.0219819304,
0.0075928024,
-0.011958166,
-0.0823836178,
0.0025072948,
-0.0182593893,
0.0172505993,
-0.0358480029,
-0.012785377,
-0.0576946512,
0.0241233949,
0.0226048436,
-0.0336459652,
0.0131745189,
-0.0051905033,
0.0475325733,
0.0364593677,
0.0474563427,
0.0449384749,
0.0037659565,
0.0429534838,
0.0130002405,
0.0498486608,
0.0146134198,
0.0483118482,
0.019804826,
0.0155601474,
0.0047160015,
0.0000021686,
-0.0218865722,
-0.0259186067,
0.0095728273,
-0.023378402,
-0.0213337,
0.0894207209,
-0.0036270032,
0.0193025395,
0.0386081263,
-0.0099773621,
0.0205551535,
-0.027229825,
0.0716014132,
0.081928432,
0.0602168255,
0.0066940091,
-0.0803668275,
0.0250143465,
-0.0214627106,
-0.0078168437,
-0.001160549,
0.0201781001,
-0.0553256832,
0.0093153976,
-0.0229473542,
-0.0021622167,
0.0109452521,
-0.0152067831,
0.0012337452,
0.0177876391,
0.0274395533,
-0.0180024132,
0.0200181939,
0.0218783338,
0.0337495171,
-0.018199794,
-0.002938583,
-0.0098401783,
-0.0212639179,
0.0047024474,
-0.0167051796,
-0.0476914681,
0.0530032776,
-0.0340957083,
0.0320638716,
-0.013990893,
0.0325760134,
-0.0261010602,
0.0304786246,
-0.0215455778,
0.0375766344,
-0.0208047312,
-0.0254521128,
0.0041207294,
-0.0078105633,
0.0585856177,
-0.0635703877,
0.0418809317,
0.0463034324,
0.0036867566,
-0.0284602996,
-0.0387566835,
-0.0526203923,
0.0398691371,
-0.0242764279,
-0.0216297787,
-0.0368863903,
-0.0264144465,
0.0389518254,
-0.046715524,
0.0266759675,
0.0027597907,
0.0015004516,
-0.0398438051,
-0.017924428,
-0.0979333743,
-0.020763861,
-0.0319974236,
0.0390042067,
-0.0289318264,
0.015011631,
-0.0588852316,
-0.0086056497,
0.0271206293,
-0.0279940888,
0.0529976115,
0.0313515738,
-0.0279401802,
0.0254022703,
-0.0493774936,
0.0027685028,
0.0289681796,
-0.0210039709,
-0.0021096386,
-0.0305527784,
0.0346265398,
0.0033051185,
0.047757674,
-0.0265415218,
0.0207408164,
0.0061301254,
0.0126045421,
-0.0653967857,
-0.0577302761,
-0.0257592667,
-0.0156543385,
-0.0406434238,
-0.0079539884,
-0.0406806953,
-0.0017351015,
0.0043828599,
-0.0269363523,
-0.0110040214,
0.0093730139,
0.0485034734,
-0.0353570953,
0.0081826588,
-0.0252447166,
0.0088698585,
0.0776849091,
-0.0182367451,
0.036619436,
-0.0081274435,
0.0569326133,
0.1160483584,
0.0240309071,
-0.0279061217,
0.0556857176,
0.0237547942,
-0.0157118961,
-0.0568278059,
-0.0105332686,
0.0261312835,
-0.0504282676,
0.0137024047,
0.0247778017,
0.0216804054,
-0.0170806441,
0.0646005794,
0.0649707466,
0.034406703,
0.0339755379,
0.0391283892,
0.0248526111,
0.0727799162,
0.0529064536,
-0.0007007211,
-0.0149806496,
0.0471574776,
-0.029187927,
0.0373454168,
-0.0087863319,
0.0587606058,
-0.0274033342,
-0.0273341406,
-0.0088176392,
-0.0343796797,
-0.0089303264,
-0.0005971264,
0.0150171928,
0.0052741966,
-0.0700109452,
0.0366666466,
-0.0059033958,
-0.0635698885,
0.010798865,
-0.034727525,
-0.0203471873,
0.0645444393,
0.0257014595,
-0.0443770997,
-0.0371827483,
-0.0672823638,
-0.0024508177,
0.0309381951,
0.0605928041,
0.0116490833,
-0.0113766585,
-0.0631268099,
-0.0494515561,
-0.0163060427,
-0.0152198737,
0.0078596352,
-0.0029494418,
0.020038886,
0.0483733565,
-0.0267947298,
-0.0642745942,
0.0426337272,
0.009060936,
-0.0333861299,
0.037919119,
0.0000541938,
-0.0054458529,
0.0248653069,
0.0111982021,
-0.0004282689,
0.0074196984,
-0.0084184604,
-0.0437374189,
-0.0013147899,
-0.0139614018,
-0.0102851419,
-0.0332967155,
-0.0039069178,
-0.0272182785,
0.0685948879,
-0.0617009252,
-0.0374354869,
-0.005229752,
-0.012604841,
-0.0146067729,
-0.0577804632,
0.0209533386,
0.022454828,
0.0194061361,
-0.0530097112,
0.0729139373,
0.0604719967,
0.0180006791,
-0.0028040425,
-0.0594209917,
0.0260633659,
-0.0814154595,
-0.0324064866,
-0.0192864891,
-0.0142176701,
0.0016960446,
0.0291618407,
0.0153944781,
-0.0383656695,
-0.0410749428,
-0.0937322527,
0.0091818701,
-0.0074746651,
0.0364548564,
-0.0006168528,
0.012865833,
-0.0228500441,
-0.0175754949,
-0.0395208821,
-0.0388755351,
0.033663936,
-0.0256703589,
0.0865349174,
0.0030744383,
0.0035423434,
-0.0498447083,
-0.0239961203,
0.0115754027,
0.0316376798,
0.0144918784,
-0.0275671277,
-0.0157625936,
-0.0311148819,
0.0084000994,
-0.0099560535,
0.04360383,
-0.002912045,
-0.0449301787,
0.0171824377,
0.0468035154,
0.0444117896,
0.0461494662,
0.0078291437,
0.0019248396,
0.0473239906,
0.0223001651,
0.0182246268,
-0.0239522867,
0.0408148617,
-0.0198881552,
-0.028122073,
0.0107902633,
-0.0040749861,
0.0370716602,
-0.01946868,
0.0089045055,
-0.0043107788,
-0.0331192277,
0.033933863,
-0.0437849127,
0.0108161531,
-0.0223644804,
-0.0024002485,
-0.0045649209,
0.0277327951,
-0.000532262,
-0.0166381858,
0.021357907,
-0.0499645174,
-0.0499504767,
-0.0817909688,
0.0525060631,
0.0136651862,
0.0052076839,
-0.0075502703,
-0.0445682742,
-0.0141058182,
-0.055738952,
-0.0129675567,
-0.0213932749,
0.0108843464,
0.0025395581,
0.0039583184,
-0.0458869077,
-0.0085024042,
-0.0311969072,
-0.0614866354,
-0.0343056768,
0.0065014446,
0.0489561446,
0.0268417113,
-0.0725834072,
-0.0162733439,
0.0105322348,
0.0691891983,
-0.0410613008,
-0.0223287772,
-0.0180441495,
0.0631069914,
0.0659601614,
0.023581801,
0.0193423964,
-0.0255648103,
-0.0023326778,
0.0010131911,
-0.0019365231,
0.0149363363,
-0.030881593,
-0.0441803858,
-0.0149056697,
-0.137437731,
-0.0052552344,
0.0066002235,
0.0000151555,
-0.059341222,
0.0326486565,
0.1003618538,
-0.002928894,
0.0050660754,
-0.0015679684,
0.0610213727,
-0.0658882484,
0.008428121,
0.0268694647,
-0.0031952723,
-0.0142564904,
-0.0144632747,
0.000919378,
0.0185232256,
-0.0093772691,
-0.0202758219,
-0.039767582,
0.0314286575,
-0.0272619054,
-0.0555697121,
-0.008754937,
-0.0257945415,
-0.0280055478,
-0.0274579991,
0.0035549481,
-0.0203838143,
-0.0890310258,
0.0174831096,
0.0273892712,
-0.084469974,
-0.0108151175,
0.0100392159,
0.0105185928,
-0.0159858521,
0.0287996531,
0.0560197793,
-0.0467057079,
0.0183414463,
0.0384562947,
-0.039122995,
0.0323712751,
0.0349724963,
0.0734580755,
-0.0298828613,
0.0142438048,
-0.0407874696,
0.0029873466,
-0.0228851493,
0.008133702,
0.0145731941,
0.0208285507,
-0.0017426286,
-0.0433414504,
-0.0501133874,
0.0016809807,
-0.0445614867,
0.0679646134,
0.0096768448,
-0.0619910732,
-0.0279417131,
0.0140426233,
-0.0386403538,
-0.0808548704,
-0.0235227365,
0.0239394289,
-0.0314812623,
0.023065133,
-0.0405115411,
-0.0505944937,
0.0457243919,
-0.0477899536,
-0.0040997039,
0.0184989795,
-0.0221998058,
0.0257891193,
-0.041576542,
0.0168740395,
-0.0152232284,
0.0333181135,
-0.0517167188,
0.0089494726,
0.0177213084,
-0.065222472,
-0.0656919181,
-0.0560729839,
-0.0824842229,
0.0227055475,
-0.0011982119,
-0.0091030309,
0.0187009517,
0.0013894994,
0.0273699425,
-0.0268318634,
0.1206506863,
0.0502037108,
0.0003255881,
0.0018493097,
-0.0127166985,
0.0016392147,
-0.0412585028,
-0.0092298808,
-0.0726705417,
0.0528464615,
0.0146934427,
-0.0371832773,
0.0552183576,
-0.0430634432,
-0.0312866606,
0.035160806,
0.012515435,
-0.0014914381,
-0.0316483378,
-0.0616093278,
-0.0302785784,
0.0172335375,
0.0137852691,
-0.0122161396,
0.026974516,
0.0320420563,
0.0251625385,
-0.0199998822,
0.0097816531,
0.016893113,
0.019249551,
-0.0775699839,
0.0261805169,
-0.0788033605,
0.0160250254,
-0.0467095263,
0.0017766948,
-0.0568438582,
-0.031497024,
0.0121339997,
-0.0054348144,
0.0137756476,
-0.0172404759,
0.0083401296,
0.0436108708,
-0.0015689209,
0.0624891855,
-0.0702781454,
0.0068643475,
-0.0684397817,
0.0314019769,
0.0454322249,
-0.0636197105,
0.0331197679,
-0.004728585,
-0.0016108621,
-0.0166463573,
0.0258939806,
0.0540770814,
0.0058352957,
-0.0226440709,
-0.0219339915,
-0.0196257718,
-0.0041126786,
0.0501663871,
0.0158227012,
-0.0124766426,
0.0389143564,
0.0048996946,
-0.0356878228,
0.0142579284,
0.0035495199,
0.0285376441,
-0.0080405725,
0.0016809399,
-0.0353858061,
-0.000463233,
0.0905456468,
-0.0063078348,
-0.0021401185,
-0.0359587111,
0.0334799998,
0.0078322375,
0.0325070694,
-0.0043637231,
-0.0390573889,
0.0019837047,
0.0222071931,
0.0265665464,
-0.0305805691,
-6.326865448e-33,
-0.0145473545,
-0.00947739,
-0.0001471703,
0.0480845384,
-0.0241535287,
0.0305603202,
0.0198966097,
-0.0742691904,
-0.0125166569,
-0.0190232173,
-0.0407115184,
0.0259742215,
0.0183369592,
0.0586084016,
0.0271243323,
0.0308139138,
0.0431126021,
0.0126075288,
-0.0227253176,
0.0292828437,
-0.0117053092,
0.0476872772,
0.105248481,
-0.0518252179,
0.0017913118,
-0.0168392621,
-0.0154885966,
-0.0164459944,
0.0230199434,
0.0265606754,
-0.0125051066,
0.0404560864,
0.0602391288,
-0.0671890453,
-0.0116083696,
0.0158177502,
-0.0314810798,
-0.02317518,
0.022740325,
-0.0070704324,
-0.0059943362,
-0.0264553335,
0.027395701,
-0.0024436119,
0.0003898612,
-0.0321869552,
0.0962365419,
-0.0208394937,
0.0192258526,
-0.0511261299,
-0.0175521281,
0.0235406663,
-0.0157154743,
0.0006253743,
0.0256574191,
0.042731721,
-0.0147297997,
0.0759611502,
-0.0735946372,
0.0030146558,
0.0066092792,
0.0252119359,
0.0066953814,
-0.035564959,
-0.0368510149,
0.0519096255,
0.0259219576,
0.0429139435,
-0.0174685102,
-0.0191130694,
-0.0128466738,
0.0392940715,
0.0128491754,
0.009611751,
0.0520332344,
-0.0142807253,
-0.0207914244,
0.0759671032,
0.0129119307,
0.015931502,
0.0128629757,
-0.0021904656,
0.0242852755,
0.0242409799,
0.0203291047,
0.0156332571,
0.0082246987,
0.0313200541,
0.0089310091,
0.0324196927,
-0.0094795581,
0.008391995,
-0.0284567084,
-0.031809397,
0.0241306368,
0.0086962795,
-0.0127874427,
0.0168003161,
-0.0160317719,
-0.0346030705,
-0.0162454713,
-0.0190443825,
0.0148409884,
-0.0168156549,
-0.0059125083,
0.0308085233,
0.052367039,
0.0505036116,
-0.0400327295,
-0.0047976268,
0.04679735,
0.0297808461,
-0.0354801081,
0.0388910808,
-0.0246322323,
0.017323114,
0.0225137882,
0.059041284,
-0.0030014277,
-0.0010112738,
-0.0198117346,
-0.0737205744,
0.0898919031,
0.0257287119,
0.0048054899,
-0.0014802552,
-0.003699491,
0.0298903584,
0.0156723801,
-0.0220482983,
-0.0078530153,
-0.004701111,
2.758e-7,
0.0721874684,
0.0377672985,
0.0301692858,
-0.0006187619,
-0.000998317,
-0.0078331744,
0.0308222249,
0.0457427576,
0.0162203684,
0.0857413039,
0.0267878678,
0.0019767068,
0.0373925231,
-0.0337016806,
-0.1139600128,
-0.0476725511,
-0.0702848509,
-0.0329775773,
-0.0401259474,
0.007779547,
0.1127937883,
0.06987717,
0.0214449838,
-0.0302583072,
-0.0323026031,
0.006942993,
0.0145360501,
-0.0128958253,
-0.0035477343,
0.0305469148,
0.058490891,
-0.0081186816,
-0.0030544202,
0.0158265177,
-0.0123198014,
0.0106337667,
0.0488266721,
0.0402358249,
-0.027174497,
0.0175652616,
0.0402482264,
0.0169141032,
-0.0044669532,
0.0028221984,
0.0401118137,
-0.0624897368,
0.0102368807,
-0.0004643619,
-0.0690940917,
-0.0063528861,
0.0000244257,
0.0442990437,
-0.0151126487,
0.0223417785,
0.0182427391,
-0.0178230498,
-0.0530141592,
-0.1012716442,
-0.0110183768,
0.0147175761,
-0.0156957172,
-0.0008738057,
0.0063718772,
-0.0148054324,
0.0497053787,
-0.0591976158,
-0.0277431235,
2.71827283e-34,
0.0690201446,
0.0269622914,
-0.0149970194,
-0.0139591377,
0.017056128,
0.0113238376,
0.032786306,
-0.0004223523,
-0.0375500657,
-0.0683183745,
-0.0238341484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13310v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13310v1 | Mutually Guided Few-shot Learning for Relational Triple Extraction | 2023-06-23T06:15:54 | 2023-06-23T06:15:54 | Chengmei Yang, Shuai Jiang, Bowei He, Chen Ma, Lianghua He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge graphs (KGs), containing many entity-relation-entity triples,
provide rich information for downstream applications. Although extracting
triples from unstructured texts has been widely explored, most of them require
a large number of labeled instances. The performance will drop dramatically
when only few labeled data are available. To tackle this problem, we propose
the Mutually Guided Few-shot learning framework for Relational Triple
Extraction (MG-FTE). Specifically, our method consists of an entity-guided
relation proto-decoder to classify the relations firstly and a relation-guided
entity proto-decoder to extract entities based on the classified relations. To
draw the connection between entity and relation, we design a proto-level fusion
module to boost the performance of both entity extraction and relation
classification. Moreover, a new cross-domain few-shot triple extraction task is
introduced. Extensive experiments show that our method outperforms many
state-of-the-art methods by 12.6 F1 score on FewRel 1.0 (single-domain) and
20.5 F1 score on FewRel 2.0 (cross-domain). | [
0.0411262885,
0.0099774376,
0.0262577198,
0.0647366717,
-0.0098115662,
0.0469785668,
0.0004270843,
0.0044724834,
0.0095059965,
-0.0501733012,
-0.0363849103,
0.0283107478,
-0.0277860109,
-0.0105456458,
0.0039610006,
-0.0304475613,
0.0258408003,
0.0317158177,
0.0310590584,
0.0425272137,
-0.0186797958,
0.0350806303,
-0.0413463376,
-0.0292409007,
-0.0042375159,
-0.000211053,
0.0175009742,
0.0066169947,
0.0410516225,
-0.0521179438,
-0.0045348029,
0.0169362482,
0.0038143587,
-0.0028084742,
0.000001909,
-0.0455998108,
-0.0512378365,
0.0348475762,
-0.0370448604,
-0.0288535524,
-0.0234965272,
-0.0440128557,
0.0269071106,
-0.0074895206,
-0.0525575168,
-0.068983078,
-0.0063779592,
0.0690254122,
-0.0004146911,
0.0529702194,
-0.0361739136,
-0.068214193,
0.0241748057,
-0.0142824454,
0.0203885175,
-0.0282630622,
0.0302208494,
0.0156188337,
-0.0117802043,
0.006769883,
0.0026799198,
0.0099988664,
0.0053690374,
0.0265563894,
0.0429413617,
0.0343122892,
-0.0502843931,
-0.0008794398,
-0.0128830755,
0.0825462937,
0.0275193844,
0.055197686,
0.0156640541,
0.0034108129,
-0.0029188166,
-0.0268654451,
0.0230139103,
-0.0367065258,
-0.061289575,
-0.0067662844,
-0.0304617658,
-0.0046029221,
0.01290977,
-0.0148584498,
-0.0299397539,
0.028237056,
-0.003652697,
-0.0255591925,
0.047075972,
0.0396346264,
0.0135548646,
0.0053892178,
0.0065407478,
0.00721703,
0.0394672379,
0.0373973064,
-0.0156097747,
0.0017686369,
-0.0205486175,
-0.0155809997,
-0.0138185266,
0.0207968634,
0.0132143358,
0.0730818808,
-0.0713040531,
-0.0213811547,
0.0197352786,
0.0111166043,
-0.0035754242,
0.003340123,
-0.0715262368,
0.0354323164,
-0.0124322716,
0.0784790292,
0.0019480515,
-0.0086252037,
-0.061803557,
-0.0038419494,
0.015888311,
0.0272430256,
0.0220851116,
0.016712904,
0.0144234523,
-0.0079018325,
0.0064832545,
0.0467332415,
-0.0348566808,
0.02136744,
-0.0213565174,
-0.0281885285,
-0.0097495774,
-0.0282331221,
0.0528544746,
-0.047416281,
-0.006107437,
0.0833380744,
-0.0135424212,
-0.0718448684,
-0.0544232763,
-0.0493526012,
0.0069473688,
-0.0486913733,
-0.0041930382,
-0.0044059926,
0.100267902,
0.0274017341,
-0.0155183328,
-0.0350193083,
0.0335796438,
-0.053854987,
-0.0572395213,
0.0620152093,
-0.0357290059,
-0.0252990313,
-0.02138355,
0.0196512863,
-0.0185948741,
0.0607237406,
0.032128986,
0.0026452779,
0.0239484832,
0.016009286,
-0.0313605033,
0.0114583494,
0.0202696286,
-0.0269026123,
0.0109676206,
0.0085987831,
-0.0051646447,
-0.0166094676,
0.0294723138,
0.0113496883,
-0.0412114002,
0.0029738655,
-0.0070454902,
-0.0122555438,
0.0275775492,
0.0298482738,
0.0513894781,
-0.0025922484,
0.0230105463,
0.0249955729,
-0.0515429303,
0.0064525828,
-0.0387828685,
0.0166557878,
-0.0215985272,
0.0378228873,
0.0081131672,
-0.0011743545,
0.0359373689,
-0.020932734,
-0.0222969651,
0.0055278935,
0.111026518,
0.0138566606,
-0.0464661345,
0.0310034454,
0.0550134741,
-0.0309750196,
0.0107750576,
0.0284164157,
-0.0325961262,
0.0455748476,
0.0305936895,
-0.0362810455,
-0.056261979,
0.0060808514,
-0.0343041085,
0.0008707631,
0.0167587921,
-0.0271006525,
0.0748476237,
-0.0261129327,
-0.07997372,
0.0113082919,
0.000442891,
0.0105860149,
0.0309515838,
0.0231084488,
0.0046799458,
-0.0243406724,
0.0760718212,
0.0194026437,
-0.0407253355,
-0.037358705,
0.0160887148,
0.0442208201,
-0.0093382969,
0.0613122247,
-0.0185505133,
-0.0241619498,
0.024707621,
-0.0340395942,
0.005147723,
-0.0144838803,
-0.0135629792,
-0.0848277509,
0.0161268208,
0.029469626,
-0.041277796,
-0.0751050636,
-0.0449275151,
0.0079380181,
0.0037767519,
0.0406014808,
0.0560446568,
0.0233655684,
-0.0062888525,
0.043370571,
0.0021405162,
-0.0252645705,
0.069210954,
0.0048912591,
-0.0297220517,
-0.0067100567,
-0.0845134929,
-0.0115376031,
0.0353293568,
0.0215214286,
-0.0186859816,
-0.018939307,
-0.0018980982,
-0.0049450593,
0.003522251,
-0.0703838915,
-0.0144764865,
-0.0215086062,
0.0359906517,
0.0336264297,
0.0663588122,
-0.0324137919,
0.0156607013,
-0.0054369508,
-0.0207021348,
0.0095060971,
0.0425284021,
-0.0756726637,
-0.0131808557,
0.0222417843,
0.0359603539,
-0.0162482765,
0.0054294094,
-0.0117400791,
-0.0544385538,
0.0479431972,
0.0024870103,
-0.0336475037,
0.0214593038,
0.0570945665,
-0.0378799364,
0.0261703208,
0.0154859908,
0.0112542147,
-0.0270732623,
-0.0092670983,
0.0064955908,
0.0262039658,
-0.0502602868,
0.0527531132,
-0.0167058744,
-0.0282384064,
-0.0400501266,
0.0295252297,
-0.0331239775,
0.0163317863,
-0.0158479623,
0.0305082947,
-0.0238119103,
0.0034689514,
0.0298605375,
0.0284226984,
-0.035959851,
0.0154486177,
0.0288192332,
-0.0333507843,
-0.0134520428,
0.0556070134,
0.0391150452,
-0.0056613567,
-0.0457439311,
0.0508052334,
0.0878553018,
0.0010763078,
0.0001887782,
0.0202577431,
0.0052850088,
-0.0436697043,
0.0413714387,
-0.0271018855,
0.0189890079,
0.0326947644,
-0.0304729976,
-0.0153820831,
-0.0345221981,
0.0495011881,
-0.0153105278,
0.01468312,
-0.0220407378,
-0.0000821695,
-0.0243790876,
-0.0281346664,
-0.0099566821,
0.0179640576,
-0.0375149287,
0.0133973034,
-0.0396542288,
0.0115179177,
-0.0103352014,
-0.0038526405,
0.0232164208,
0.0181952212,
-0.007090196,
-0.0456281826,
-0.0107977288,
0.0822679251,
0.0328140073,
-0.0123652136,
-0.0212399866,
0.0140175335,
0.0522735491,
0.0639816895,
-0.0016703375,
-0.0224769562,
-0.0140254339,
0.0238956753,
-0.0058471845,
-0.0429721661,
0.0216552839,
-0.0132863037,
-0.006944729,
-0.0832505301,
0.0147866439,
0.0834400579,
0.0296775531,
-0.0369220302,
-0.034952879,
0.0484534279,
-0.0194407608,
0.0245472509,
0.0247768816,
-0.1164692417,
-0.0452129394,
-0.0366866812,
0.006315256,
0.0314797014,
-0.0747349784,
-0.004918254,
-0.119550027,
-0.0138055459,
0.0031258585,
-0.0303089265,
-0.0340823866,
-0.0677312315,
0.0090848915,
-0.0062648444,
-0.0502730422,
-0.0146983434,
-0.0313960835,
-0.004954664,
-0.0092219962,
0.0402077809,
-0.0664260387,
0.0208029691,
-0.047192052,
-0.0025922959,
0.0132222902,
0.0125666149,
-0.0136989579,
0.0287761837,
-0.0176214986,
-0.0079365922,
-0.0305285454,
-0.0344725512,
0.0678296164,
-0.0643552318,
-0.0062516122,
-0.0256128348,
-0.0136028649,
-0.0556473881,
-0.0031980504,
0.0106156068,
0.0836120322,
0.0131478552,
-0.0279709771,
-0.0089076497,
-0.0304782875,
-0.0160227846,
0.0463068858,
0.002557813,
-0.0097677987,
-0.0058774007,
0.0125590358,
0.007289697,
-0.0690141097,
0.0068929018,
0.0186073612,
-0.0660257638,
-0.0134864664,
-0.0329977609,
-0.0488416068,
0.0772756711,
0.0062690517,
-0.009302767,
0.0104451571,
0.0487819463,
0.0368997194,
-0.0775227249,
-0.025865525,
-0.003000082,
-0.0160988234,
0.0039183889,
0.0214647148,
0.0256274641,
-0.0081160339,
-0.0214538425,
-0.0514358357,
-0.0140315192,
-0.0294397995,
-0.021372566,
0.0399291888,
-0.0025108226,
0.0353937484,
0.003258633,
0.0125536127,
0.0014690075,
0.1207434088,
-0.064897351,
-0.0193265174,
0.0129727675,
-0.0145644937,
-0.0215597488,
0.0226615574,
-0.0441858284,
0.0080062579,
0.01261786,
0.0429637544,
-0.0636111274,
-0.020261718,
0.0350851715,
0.0008480322,
0.0887000784,
-0.0030895164,
0.0095231039,
-0.0317883268,
0.023927547,
-0.0390528962,
-0.0082993796,
-0.0462622866,
0.0028222916,
0.0103523452,
-0.0085315956,
-0.0083547086,
-0.0079005612,
0.0332662873,
0.0451670885,
0.0062578218,
-0.0067972071,
0.0345258377,
-0.0266882051,
0.0221030898,
-0.0485834107,
-0.0244316235,
0.048437614,
0.0203012023,
-0.033982072,
-0.0537341125,
0.0455270596,
0.0051925648,
-0.0324391164,
-0.0067430027,
0.0203064717,
0.019118581,
0.067254357,
-0.012218154,
-0.0109401476,
0.0607546568,
0.0223002993,
0.0294376388,
0.0042707999,
-0.0128779309,
0.0211366862,
0.0379107334,
-0.0375137776,
0.0246212594,
0.0264454558,
0.0152662275,
-0.00330397,
0.0015793466,
0.0487915464,
0.0001311892,
0.0663408563,
0.0524571873,
-0.0303789862,
-0.0592275821,
-0.0361985788,
0.0081183081,
-0.0027453043,
-0.0160102006,
0.0182137042,
-0.0710409954,
-0.0286638048,
-0.0171265677,
-0.0371117443,
-0.058160875,
0.0154081807,
0.0177771654,
0.0222051255,
0.0224719197,
-0.0732364357,
-0.0359875634,
0.0044274004,
-0.0465868376,
-0.0007456701,
0.0438375995,
-6.141909127e-33,
-0.0620821603,
-0.0106704431,
0.0408641361,
-0.006221774,
-0.0272628181,
0.0174732599,
-0.0136526767,
-0.0136665767,
-0.0231226739,
0.0159567744,
-0.0086668199,
-0.007411357,
0.0109963147,
-0.0072577759,
-0.0115676215,
-0.0052943886,
0.0247430764,
0.0009729671,
0.0282393675,
0.0078089689,
0.0312401354,
0.0790560767,
0.0682684779,
-0.0748234019,
-0.0235904083,
0.0325890407,
-0.0055399458,
0.0116743017,
0.0550323203,
0.0431016944,
-0.0277072396,
0.0135505283,
0.0186431631,
-0.0127955843,
0.0301280525,
-0.0144515224,
-0.1707055122,
-0.0271663945,
-0.0501476489,
0.0176466629,
-0.0210084878,
-0.0132480683,
0.0095033161,
0.0066213431,
0.077886723,
-0.0826348066,
0.0305438507,
-0.0325373039,
-0.0355757326,
-0.1126742959,
-0.0485241003,
0.0422244743,
0.029732883,
0.0095782429,
0.0800196677,
-0.0072768009,
0.0232459027,
-0.0106918579,
-0.0600039996,
-0.0466975346,
-0.0325982459,
-0.0122255469,
0.01768771,
0.0185504779,
-0.0017125589,
0.0324551463,
-0.0025305559,
-0.0091937026,
-0.0220128223,
0.0055770809,
0.0062917476,
0.0830514356,
-0.0451197177,
0.044289548,
0.0236211363,
-0.0065129111,
-0.0786863118,
0.0044477261,
0.0322708003,
0.0323661081,
-0.0459360182,
-0.0063425116,
-0.0387443043,
0.0178355854,
0.0208877213,
-0.0001795415,
-0.0329794362,
-0.0548199527,
0.0101695163,
0.0096630258,
-0.034950614,
0.052295927,
0.0117091155,
-0.0309662633,
-0.0308077149,
0.0484911725,
0.0182662904,
0.0206395481,
-0.0181453638,
0.0004842546,
-0.0654823855,
-0.050244838,
-0.0044297269,
-0.0089507233,
0.0343809649,
0.0214724485,
0.0349362195,
-0.0253865998,
-0.0549403094,
-0.0212897211,
-0.0365259983,
-0.0065539819,
0.0035127469,
0.0170977376,
-0.0091997311,
0.0520825498,
-0.0091659864,
0.0210601743,
0.0444661416,
0.0175080635,
0.0044948724,
0.0866428167,
0.02845666,
0.0246122051,
0.0421899408,
-0.0237533189,
-0.0175894927,
-0.0030026948,
0.0142270913,
-0.0470837541,
-0.0165153947,
0.0206542406,
2.705e-7,
0.030389905,
0.037735112,
0.0282140989,
0.0230405461,
-0.0149694039,
0.058515422,
0.021797169,
0.0337750129,
-0.013545203,
0.0134139415,
0.0301286504,
0.0021340179,
-0.0206726138,
0.0589663386,
-0.0564348921,
-0.0005461265,
-0.0037858689,
-0.0657168478,
-0.0510512441,
0.0032686207,
0.0963721201,
0.0349877104,
0.0515416823,
0.0091121346,
-0.0361994989,
-0.0165858548,
0.0488682948,
0.0217533465,
-0.0050731148,
0.0449439771,
-0.0027312979,
0.0214096457,
-0.036186073,
0.0752657503,
-0.0269855242,
0.0275473818,
0.0055349506,
0.0666937456,
-0.0194824338,
-0.0063590198,
0.0301848799,
-0.0274015777,
0.0125484336,
0.0206646249,
0.0781516731,
-0.0916220322,
-0.0103030792,
0.0568922013,
-0.0528686792,
0.0064847623,
-0.0241410658,
0.0096936263,
0.005947507,
0.0162771344,
0.0347043164,
-0.0046393634,
-0.0534411483,
-0.06179405,
0.0320798531,
0.0603193007,
0.0428849943,
-0.0069150827,
0.0256133676,
-0.0220456272,
-0.0055954121,
-0.0406589657,
0.0032292097,
2.442628359e-34,
-0.0258810036,
-0.0047678188,
0.0084533449,
0.0140430499,
0.0310583282,
-0.0447006859,
-0.0462997556,
-0.007777486,
0.0029375597,
-0.0445086993,
0.047119461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13307v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13307v2 | Towards Effective and Compact Contextual Representation for Conformer Transducer Speech Recognition Systems | 2023-06-23T05:55:19 | 2023-06-26T02:48:53 | Mingyu Cui, Jiawen Kang, Jiajun Deng, Xi Yin, Yutao Xie, Xie Chen, Xunying Liu | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Current ASR systems are mainly trained and evaluated at the utterance level.
Long range cross utterance context can be incorporated. A key task is to derive
a suitable compact representation of the most relevant history contexts. In
contrast to previous researches based on either LSTM-RNN encoded histories that
attenuate the information from longer range contexts, or frame level
concatenation of transformer context embeddings, in this paper compact
low-dimensional cross utterance contextual features are learned in the
Conformer-Transducer Encoder using specially designed attention pooling layers
that are applied over efficiently cached preceding utterances history vectors.
Experiments on the 1000-hr Gigaspeech corpus demonstrate that the proposed
contextualized streaming Conformer-Transducers outperform the baseline using
utterance internal context only with statistically significant WER reductions
of 0.7% to 0.5% absolute (4.3% to 3.1% relative) on the dev and test data. | [
-0.0485659726,
0.0047724033,
0.0221704282,
0.0190671068,
-0.0035067415,
-0.0330959,
0.0316527449,
-0.0124341911,
-0.0490989648,
-0.0203070976,
-0.0352626704,
-0.0555278175,
0.0518213548,
0.005112492,
-0.0174263585,
-0.0160547923,
-0.0091845179,
-0.017889766,
-0.0177743882,
-0.0028464806,
-0.0014056979,
-0.0200737994,
-0.0015115761,
0.0480462611,
0.0047683818,
0.0203826502,
-0.0099624414,
-0.0342329517,
0.0511439778,
-0.0189122129,
-0.0380334519,
-0.006306855,
0.0896683782,
0.0407315418,
0.0000021698,
-0.0025804979,
-0.0581811517,
0.0014886305,
-0.0802561045,
-0.005409081,
-0.0222232677,
-0.0309189893,
-0.0291649289,
0.0324833132,
0.0051842076,
-0.0133538488,
0.0275722165,
0.0418394953,
0.0162320342,
0.0096526844,
0.0081713656,
-0.0540818162,
0.0272312146,
-0.0030618636,
-0.0064440658,
-0.0788114592,
-0.0319618545,
-0.0344435871,
0.0001098847,
-0.0149645116,
-0.0547135733,
0.0495630912,
0.0515141003,
-0.01365548,
0.0205284227,
0.0043234974,
0.0007593535,
0.0122223264,
-0.0233706944,
0.032961525,
0.0373906642,
-0.0395436808,
-0.0097879991,
0.0132234851,
-0.0481405072,
-0.0592109375,
-0.0363982245,
0.0138175478,
-0.0295511018,
0.0074604191,
-0.0246009566,
0.0453475304,
-0.0086244438,
-0.0229193904,
-0.0577736571,
-0.0234181751,
-0.0147712911,
-0.0200153608,
-0.0228312984,
-0.0383388586,
0.0355969183,
-0.007423291,
0.0629788488,
0.0210260581,
-0.0119170509,
-0.0327104442,
-0.0095203118,
-0.0410558693,
-0.007261185,
-0.0263454765,
0.0169816632,
0.0434103422,
-0.0511763841,
-0.000990093,
-0.0320148617,
0.1344946027,
-0.0250228941,
-0.0262140632,
-0.0231727809,
-0.0203077476,
-0.011204266,
-0.0034026974,
-0.0265436731,
0.0075406372,
-0.0350475758,
-0.0301168393,
-0.0549199022,
0.0302237198,
0.0106584094,
-0.0171738062,
0.0291451085,
-0.0014111026,
-0.0388523154,
-0.0185770355,
0.027033275,
0.0655000508,
0.0021498571,
0.0236714594,
-0.0040256763,
-0.0625714883,
-0.0536886342,
0.0163209345,
0.0629749894,
-0.0209632721,
-0.019140793,
0.0372838713,
0.0165006407,
-0.0265842713,
-0.0248064026,
0.0004386265,
-0.058523234,
-0.0094766589,
-0.0074951956,
-0.0273450315,
0.0350579694,
-0.0113887032,
0.0026577991,
-0.0379783288,
-0.0028284285,
-0.0100689009,
0.0438702293,
0.0533062816,
0.0423959792,
-0.0327514522,
0.0026283804,
-0.0233282782,
0.0544817559,
0.0049134544,
0.0758840889,
-0.0049014115,
-0.020275915,
-0.0572629049,
-0.0064266487,
-0.0002873812,
0.0204283092,
-0.0286584143,
-0.0401767753,
-0.0134962406,
0.0503182374,
0.0452821888,
0.0381236859,
0.0326152518,
-0.0201379396,
-0.0396917202,
0.0352063477,
0.0188359898,
0.0780999959,
-0.0066131852,
0.0434688739,
0.0079718996,
-0.0529991724,
0.0218641739,
0.0057336204,
0.0192447752,
0.0187548306,
0.0160950571,
0.0447694659,
0.0103631038,
-0.0221643671,
0.0055184215,
0.0107069723,
-0.0359802954,
0.0003743297,
0.027792614,
0.0472943634,
-0.0028053529,
-0.0675653815,
0.0660684705,
-0.0111531429,
-0.0547856502,
0.0099727549,
-0.0216426905,
0.0102127194,
0.0244852919,
0.0001882437,
-0.0024002867,
-0.0368193276,
-0.0623535588,
0.0231482498,
-0.0095370738,
0.0159207694,
0.0132292127,
0.0617656261,
-0.0624366663,
-0.0285427272,
0.0307226181,
-0.0140981907,
0.0673930198,
-0.0260634106,
0.0427046046,
0.0190885533,
0.005359666,
0.0393817946,
-0.0123246377,
-0.0176907051,
-0.0547432713,
0.0231962334,
0.0375437476,
0.0593803152,
0.0567596518,
0.0124883205,
-0.001971439,
0.0913821533,
-0.0669154599,
-0.0101666227,
0.0467671566,
-0.1090680137,
0.0001090121,
0.0214966498,
-0.0273156222,
0.0317442566,
-0.0061532143,
0.0277093519,
-0.0794426054,
0.0252007917,
-0.0439055897,
0.1206242144,
-0.0234776512,
0.0502630249,
0.0504599847,
0.0232154466,
0.0083541628,
-0.0002251329,
0.0293415282,
-0.0034043631,
0.0178169049,
-0.0070669418,
0.004305732,
-0.0533544831,
0.0325820409,
-0.0087876236,
-0.0356861651,
-0.011986996,
0.0414274223,
-0.0335910991,
0.0102489553,
-0.0080142515,
-0.0383565053,
-0.0348705649,
-0.0189982653,
0.0087037375,
-0.0440349206,
0.0494232774,
0.0363380574,
-0.012420889,
0.0098711923,
-0.040596202,
-0.0111157885,
-0.0071004839,
-0.039109081,
0.0458698496,
-0.0538904518,
-0.0022994573,
0.0094682975,
0.006868015,
0.014803214,
-0.0024177604,
-0.0191295017,
-0.0383762009,
-0.0087441439,
0.074564904,
0.0176697914,
-0.0393674374,
-0.0034300159,
-0.0038295626,
0.0188233797,
0.0124456706,
0.0460820869,
0.0194279496,
0.0495155156,
0.0083166603,
-0.0195080638,
-0.0541956201,
0.0294784196,
0.0071937004,
0.0052543213,
0.0053613125,
0.0475348532,
-0.0060475278,
0.0079274019,
0.0109482026,
0.0546362065,
-0.0400578231,
-0.063469477,
0.0125349415,
-0.0179804489,
-0.0130059952,
-0.0439160541,
-0.0685818642,
-0.016758142,
0.0048385891,
0.0025507207,
0.023873426,
-0.0505274646,
-0.0240878575,
-0.0079902839,
-0.0374428667,
-0.0297877323,
0.0324066915,
-0.0222059861,
0.0006112233,
0.0142825777,
-0.0754672363,
0.0096076662,
0.0205938239,
-0.001781767,
-0.0068561132,
0.0598171726,
-0.0001354515,
-0.0057759881,
-0.0227135569,
-0.0266742408,
-0.0385847799,
-0.018275734,
-0.0224279445,
0.0305707995,
0.0251092259,
-0.0133525413,
-0.0346101038,
0.0544133224,
0.0379918627,
0.0465198345,
0.0192503296,
0.0275887568,
-0.0100921197,
0.0550772101,
0.0050232983,
0.0568217896,
0.0128530161,
0.019384224,
0.0271224212,
0.0174848065,
0.0909645408,
-0.0074786237,
-0.0463414416,
-0.0298972912,
0.0211055223,
-0.005932638,
0.0266435686,
0.013894096,
0.0610774495,
-0.0674639121,
0.0085778721,
0.0747835934,
0.0198998228,
-0.0221278053,
-0.0082571609,
0.0250900108,
-0.0051555876,
-0.0079900753,
-0.0284356438,
-0.0685270354,
-0.0345597826,
0.0306079779,
0.0019365515,
0.0178340077,
0.023805948,
-0.0193267334,
-0.0703043044,
-0.0081765596,
0.0333941467,
-0.0628257245,
-0.060063187,
-0.0579019263,
-0.0362990163,
-0.0271305386,
0.0468120836,
0.0096538933,
-0.0307633877,
-0.0612082109,
0.0261956714,
-0.0606655516,
-0.0662439093,
0.0135783087,
-0.0183022153,
0.0589834601,
0.0358352847,
0.0112234652,
-0.0048919655,
-0.0643537268,
0.0511868186,
-0.0413723029,
0.0276623853,
-0.0149856489,
-0.0302587133,
0.0031875707,
0.0059406036,
0.0521897711,
0.0272808988,
-0.0419543013,
-0.0021800438,
-0.0115713002,
0.0776447728,
-0.0422865264,
0.0063791829,
0.0369968191,
0.0089110034,
0.0127095124,
0.0743004903,
0.0244705994,
-0.0016532821,
-0.0148412501,
0.0221457239,
0.043100737,
-0.0088418331,
0.0040638428,
-0.0355517827,
0.0306815449,
-0.0567905419,
-0.0153264692,
-0.005046478,
0.004982179,
0.0130838314,
-0.0029067316,
-0.0062452569,
0.0045295232,
0.0230885129,
-0.0362779014,
-0.0056185587,
-0.0306473821,
0.0492325984,
-0.0753691196,
0.024205165,
0.0276219193,
-0.0323126465,
-0.0043262383,
0.0628851503,
-0.0652951598,
-0.0415749997,
0.0574749671,
-0.0410470739,
0.0099535221,
0.0751402676,
-0.0094204918,
0.027451843,
0.0586890317,
-0.0377093963,
-0.0610540435,
-0.0045295842,
0.0511007085,
-0.008904174,
-0.0090184398,
0.0085769538,
-0.0477427319,
0.0112464614,
-0.0420816354,
0.0019639956,
-0.0254020449,
-0.0515251458,
0.0357355215,
-0.0222072303,
0.0360844359,
-0.0056864638,
0.0057271309,
0.0114997476,
0.0594473034,
-0.0232039653,
0.078483969,
0.0039761956,
-0.0245289598,
-0.0299665518,
0.0142091205,
0.0067394874,
0.0717885643,
-0.0251613315,
-0.0183445998,
-0.0337240212,
0.1093564034,
0.0465459451,
0.0195525959,
-0.0058828937,
0.0089382492,
-0.0289155804,
0.0033840467,
0.0620371178,
0.0569080524,
-0.028594302,
0.0121554229,
-0.0146125685,
-0.0047881017,
-0.0083492808,
0.0304010008,
-0.0868635252,
0.0452540219,
-0.00894746,
-0.0062596765,
0.0282057431,
-0.0245759189,
-0.002677761,
0.0305476803,
0.0151206534,
-0.0283316169,
0.0440693535,
-0.0268050563,
0.0079376958,
0.0430673659,
0.0166702028,
-0.0169174522,
0.0725524798,
0.0287614856,
-0.0569079593,
0.0409002006,
-0.0050796843,
0.0288542565,
-0.0370262153,
-0.0208734591,
-0.048573982,
0.0048262714,
-0.0222466737,
-0.0355163515,
-0.0137411142,
-0.0163088068,
0.1079200506,
-0.0445456132,
0.0296154562,
-0.0271650497,
0.0004416307,
-0.0327914059,
0.0033835627,
0.0097392639,
0.0561685711,
-0.0092728948,
0.0059062219,
-0.0053069917,
-0.0447398499,
-6.592908473e-33,
-0.0143232113,
0.0125291916,
0.0110948067,
-0.0349343754,
-0.0713237822,
0.034671329,
-0.0347083472,
-0.0175164416,
0.003228938,
-0.0338939093,
-0.0275344886,
-0.0086984457,
0.0285278931,
0.0116052488,
-0.0089424122,
-0.0222585667,
0.1064199507,
0.0256976988,
0.0174596496,
0.0105376933,
0.036812529,
0.032468766,
0.0272254609,
-0.0670767054,
-0.0539263152,
0.0541807748,
0.0187193584,
0.0002889077,
0.0342990756,
0.0722425655,
0.0096240314,
0.038522169,
-0.0162591599,
-0.0604748204,
-0.0078884894,
0.0352623612,
-0.0845157281,
0.0240091886,
-0.024616627,
0.0357793905,
0.0412658229,
-0.0531625152,
0.021424802,
-0.0077426122,
-0.0327208638,
-0.031362243,
-0.0017586227,
-0.014746896,
-0.0403302796,
-0.0235515069,
-0.0118417563,
0.026975248,
-0.0247655138,
-0.0054918434,
0.0272992142,
0.0661847517,
-0.0051511605,
-0.0263246652,
-0.0919980109,
0.0361341313,
0.0133471582,
0.0089322245,
0.026477972,
-0.0052622138,
-0.0093719931,
0.0011105638,
0.0053339773,
-0.0611658879,
-0.0118077388,
-0.0550029092,
-0.0052250763,
-0.0144431517,
0.0038221218,
0.0105026616,
0.0142988442,
-0.0451952256,
-0.0235609002,
-0.0100451624,
-0.0122941518,
0.0707594529,
0.0172236245,
0.0423074737,
-0.028682977,
0.0137948096,
-0.0044408413,
0.0065762382,
-0.0085930843,
0.0226895232,
0.0325711742,
0.0142515013,
0.015554077,
0.0101330634,
0.0791302696,
-0.0281290393,
0.0579993613,
0.0107543776,
0.030929286,
-0.0159623977,
0.0129681416,
0.0066712215,
-0.0382059477,
0.0129567096,
0.0670280457,
0.0298971478,
-0.0013557309,
-0.0126350001,
0.0323450156,
0.0702354461,
-0.0699880645,
-0.0218004249,
-0.0054086847,
-0.00356607,
-0.018578412,
-0.016264962,
0.0651315972,
0.0083298674,
0.0315514468,
0.0500699133,
-0.0395119004,
0.0416209549,
0.0244547799,
0.0066283206,
0.0554823205,
0.0406194665,
-0.0130042899,
0.012149266,
0.02900552,
0.0535374358,
0.0483700559,
-0.0069018719,
-0.0164915994,
-0.0153556988,
2.886e-7,
-0.0581988059,
-0.0135693932,
0.0796134844,
-0.066981107,
0.0108762579,
-0.0238232668,
0.0156441815,
-0.0104257129,
-0.0234440248,
0.0241828039,
0.0262562577,
-0.0336801745,
0.0555516556,
0.0024713671,
-0.0734402314,
-0.0154728685,
-0.0551517382,
-0.0099937273,
0.0019852088,
0.0131286345,
0.0584428981,
0.085045062,
-0.0308544692,
-0.0164646246,
0.0226044059,
0.0109314434,
0.022115279,
-0.021318106,
0.0328025371,
-0.0452492647,
-0.0436078496,
-0.0388850532,
-0.0424739197,
-0.013138039,
-0.038777288,
0.0404913612,
-0.0339258388,
0.0165652819,
-0.0262761135,
-0.1221820116,
-0.0147925112,
0.059718173,
-0.0279176272,
0.0156802554,
0.0553690903,
-0.0143101998,
-0.0165229142,
-0.0485434048,
-0.0688007027,
0.0137683656,
-0.0247091111,
0.0289986413,
0.0297356192,
-0.0161252152,
-0.0091920877,
0.0144505221,
-0.0306489896,
-0.060433805,
0.0224272162,
-0.0162093937,
-0.0601708628,
0.036484018,
-0.020514518,
-0.0452314951,
0.0529098697,
0.0002583672,
0.0003383222,
2.632756534e-34,
0.020378245,
-0.0115435468,
0.0341373198,
-0.0027268806,
0.0031592404,
-0.0286225006,
0.0373938084,
0.005968804,
0.0345545039,
-0.075923726,
-0.0454249233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13304v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13304v1 | ToolQA: A Dataset for LLM Question Answering with External Tools | 2023-06-23T05:43:28 | 2023-06-23T05:43:28 | Yuchen Zhuang, Yue Yu, Kuan Wang, Haotian Sun, Chao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance in
various NLP tasks, but they still suffer from challenges such as hallucination
and weak numerical reasoning. To overcome these challenges, external tools can
be used to enhance LLMs' question-answering abilities. However, current
evaluation methods do not distinguish between questions that can be answered
using LLMs' internal knowledge and those that require external information
through tool use. To address this issue, we introduce a new dataset called
ToolQA, which is designed to faithfully evaluate LLMs' ability to use external
tools for question answering. Our development of ToolQA involved a scalable,
automated process for dataset curation, along with 13 specialized tools
designed for interaction with external knowledge in order to answer questions.
Importantly, we strive to minimize the overlap between our benchmark data and
LLMs' pre-training data, enabling a more precise evaluation of LLMs' tool-use
reasoning abilities. We conducted an in-depth diagnosis of existing tool-use
LLMs to highlight their strengths, weaknesses, and potential improvements. Our
findings set a new benchmark for evaluating LLMs and suggest new directions for
future advancements. Our data and code are freely available to the broader
scientific community on GitHub. | [
0.0154095143,
0.0272196885,
-0.0041644312,
0.0629219189,
-0.0268503167,
0.0166575518,
-0.0205632318,
-0.0108784623,
0.0206140876,
-0.0336876214,
-0.0412435345,
0.0119050601,
-0.051171191,
-0.023613805,
0.0417825505,
0.0107161887,
0.0350749046,
-0.046261359,
-0.0454931669,
-0.0063154632,
0.0003225379,
0.0424886644,
0.0042822482,
0.0318496414,
0.0179691035,
-0.04190173,
0.0089478418,
0.0097123524,
-0.0001508354,
-0.0077842074,
0.0248522237,
0.0459073931,
0.024554573,
0.0479569882,
0.0000019008,
-0.0687175393,
0.0043798997,
-0.0048061139,
-0.0414518118,
-0.0049417778,
-0.0108221574,
0.0037627285,
0.0511170365,
0.0251993537,
-0.050935708,
0.0040808492,
0.0212192237,
0.022715643,
0.0722055882,
0.0418855362,
0.0262909029,
-0.0172151774,
0.0141880382,
-0.006768479,
0.0179848708,
-0.0058071129,
0.0196925029,
0.0584273934,
0.0167570412,
-0.01337271,
0.0245472752,
0.0343695395,
0.0518963151,
0.013478444,
-0.0052186167,
0.0124302171,
-0.0636976585,
0.0059399237,
0.0055356282,
0.096864216,
0.0068496522,
-0.0467400178,
-0.016283758,
0.0033807326,
-0.0095109856,
0.038106095,
-0.0739151016,
0.0281137358,
-0.0097699473,
-0.0070989309,
0.0020225521,
-0.0015396723,
0.0343779735,
0.025739003,
-0.0075439005,
0.0783987567,
0.0096457638,
-0.01045777,
0.0226092581,
-0.0002537102,
-0.0306337792,
-0.0527787767,
-0.0092396513,
0.081941098,
-0.0096360045,
0.0370262191,
-0.0217004605,
0.0100376392,
0.0551736057,
-0.0700902492,
0.0208609886,
0.0239414908,
-0.0307311397,
0.067936942,
-0.0504147857,
0.0104683684,
-0.0119730383,
0.073371768,
-0.0367064886,
-0.0184763707,
-0.0354577191,
-0.0486811399,
-0.0083058355,
0.0178903993,
0.0112535506,
-0.0179074835,
0.0120312311,
0.0236823279,
-0.0017754795,
0.0150479311,
0.0331804343,
0.0086259395,
0.0040215608,
-0.0219994634,
-0.071109049,
-0.0019974201,
-0.0651911721,
0.0303572956,
0.0087027783,
-0.089711763,
-0.0503082685,
0.0160358083,
-0.0181863345,
-0.0436953157,
0.0284346789,
0.0796577483,
0.0175699536,
0.0101947151,
-0.0365845636,
-0.0583143272,
0.038388133,
-0.0624640398,
0.0018839396,
-0.0941417441,
0.0344414636,
0.0413920842,
-0.0370225944,
-0.0402259007,
0.0258729719,
0.0396036915,
0.0059766327,
0.0538012348,
-0.0309276972,
0.0118315881,
0.0363990106,
0.0153610557,
-0.0110100694,
0.0775649324,
-0.0032455984,
0.002984171,
0.0400753804,
-0.0001909654,
0.0035627044,
0.0616517887,
0.018384425,
0.002744281,
-0.0528807901,
0.0879250616,
0.0169545431,
0.0237587038,
0.0076124519,
0.0298292059,
-0.0142194992,
-0.0579777807,
0.0273291003,
0.0430704467,
0.01901564,
-0.0119812507,
0.0319981016,
-0.0092711411,
0.0334401056,
-0.0180152524,
-0.027821498,
0.0396723598,
-0.0358955115,
0.0006567975,
0.0312542841,
0.0260249488,
-0.0242068693,
-0.0489100441,
-0.0352551267,
0.0160870142,
-0.0447125621,
0.0626061261,
0.0411422588,
0.0274431668,
-0.017252041,
0.0748736411,
0.0137660345,
-0.0131276771,
-0.021688994,
-0.0408266746,
0.0471141003,
0.0524259619,
0.0652531385,
-0.0410081744,
-0.0483369641,
-0.0125183342,
0.021209145,
0.0257628653,
0.0232064631,
-0.0197967626,
-0.0005547414,
-0.0440803804,
0.0062898523,
-0.05774967,
-0.0073326207,
-0.0127416234,
0.0675094798,
-0.0029339972,
0.0122342352,
-0.087302275,
0.0027542433,
0.0477855355,
-0.0489873998,
-0.038316641,
-0.0249504969,
-0.0376938172,
0.0064979014,
-0.0127554219,
-0.0100378767,
0.0422395356,
0.0358461328,
-0.02267229,
-0.0331180133,
0.001551331,
-0.0076819803,
-0.0260285195,
0.0754772499,
-0.0140187601,
-0.0314246267,
0.0289958417,
-0.047946617,
-0.0346238688,
0.0025620332,
-0.0167626478,
0.029125141,
-0.0611785538,
-0.0291632451,
0.0355150141,
0.0370538644,
-0.0279203113,
0.0584670752,
-0.02096029,
0.0510267131,
0.0007488332,
0.0022348883,
0.015954094,
-0.0179161001,
0.0037660687,
-0.0066028913,
-0.0070006503,
0.0012547453,
-0.0187586024,
0.0039652432,
-0.0795289651,
-0.0108625228,
-0.0655961707,
0.0250091348,
-0.0088587934,
0.0188567005,
0.0381855033,
-0.0130157135,
-0.0096707176,
-0.0162528437,
-0.0503233708,
-0.0116244787,
0.0224506017,
0.0170854386,
0.0381317474,
-0.001544963,
0.0082195615,
-0.0242879242,
-0.0158463102,
-0.0119352881,
0.0562142879,
-0.0165978391,
-0.0004704919,
-0.0362589061,
0.0367467664,
-0.0580749996,
-0.0004746801,
-0.0122243091,
-0.0144598931,
-0.0095486334,
-0.0238951687,
-0.0067782551,
0.0422528945,
-0.0308944583,
-0.0159980599,
0.0630246475,
0.0007383302,
-0.0695518479,
0.0011072826,
0.0214978587,
-0.0194243658,
-0.0095220767,
-0.0282527152,
-0.0097871516,
0.0347768031,
-0.0017950226,
-0.0039406959,
0.0141195441,
0.051640179,
0.0019638669,
-0.0392750055,
-0.0349313281,
0.0040183319,
0.0037737775,
0.0639349371,
-0.0293642282,
-0.0535831079,
0.0680787116,
-0.0389635302,
-0.0193374772,
0.0001385509,
-0.0113562243,
-0.0796914399,
0.0530958436,
0.0000563771,
-0.0086620422,
-0.0362861119,
0.0145617016,
-0.0431151502,
-0.0323221795,
0.0045872978,
-0.0506953336,
0.0480358899,
-0.050274644,
0.0353152826,
-0.0043004882,
0.0114846574,
-0.0157367848,
-0.029894717,
-0.0465509295,
0.0144710345,
-0.0376507826,
0.009743046,
0.0067467368,
-0.0032172797,
0.0254641939,
0.012377494,
-0.0159617867,
0.0006831274,
-0.0077644424,
0.0544625521,
0.0602957904,
0.053062316,
0.0474326536,
-0.0229354817,
0.0302618518,
0.0456613638,
0.0211201888,
-0.0109200524,
-0.0247294791,
-0.0027777092,
0.0130167659,
-0.0323771946,
0.0313656144,
-0.0093803434,
0.0740318149,
-0.0803287104,
-0.0008890521,
0.1038685292,
0.0386790037,
-0.0048339395,
0.0017314199,
-0.0516786203,
0.0229294505,
0.0439196005,
0.0399321914,
-0.0921695381,
-0.0466500185,
-0.0128464969,
0.006631074,
-0.0064070416,
-0.0345522761,
-0.0129197147,
-0.1324984878,
0.0268703215,
-0.0111170523,
-0.0007704073,
0.0123909777,
-0.04969633,
0.0085020354,
0.0031538578,
0.0009504341,
-0.00123667,
-0.0056772404,
0.010094258,
0.0079330904,
-0.0266899876,
-0.0194164664,
0.0658216774,
-0.0024828739,
0.0164694209,
0.0389815718,
-0.0095841363,
-0.0184081215,
-0.0127615063,
0.0736358017,
-0.0238767099,
-0.0149225295,
-0.0202612821,
0.032354299,
0.0244349483,
-0.0146600613,
-0.0163707398,
0.0342157334,
-0.0631972849,
-0.0089020962,
0.0325263366,
0.0883747935,
-0.0188390855,
-0.0085389717,
-0.0134542156,
0.0226938818,
-0.0423726887,
0.0772818774,
0.0303226467,
0.0177734382,
-0.0409042537,
-0.0339655057,
-0.0376798026,
-0.0228039287,
-0.0687942058,
0.0322628506,
0.050799951,
0.0241235234,
-0.0559255406,
-0.0473320223,
0.0876008198,
0.0159854311,
-0.0110101951,
0.0269176476,
-0.0503954403,
0.0259587001,
-0.0475151353,
0.0631225258,
-0.051427532,
0.0202893894,
-0.0054145507,
-0.0094483364,
0.0176915769,
-0.0070278673,
-0.0290815327,
0.0407536589,
-0.0802017152,
-0.0483592488,
-0.0528172366,
0.0468970649,
0.0297750104,
0.0131858559,
-0.0284105185,
-0.0435884334,
-0.0004897484,
0.029903328,
-0.0526438393,
-0.0083254687,
-0.0043496196,
0.0208301414,
0.0022506348,
0.0437261425,
-0.0560406558,
-0.0255596545,
-0.0055311723,
0.0466439165,
-0.0200980902,
-0.0376425162,
0.0356702134,
0.0202797502,
-0.0487724394,
0.0409144051,
0.0245607682,
-0.0128608188,
0.0313074961,
-0.0193263572,
-0.0289123617,
-0.0290504843,
0.0286791567,
0.0106476871,
-0.0461903736,
0.0116852932,
-0.0143821351,
-0.0123547437,
0.0134337712,
-0.0219007265,
0.0293827895,
0.0434823968,
0.003342781,
0.0068133408,
-0.0142114731,
-0.0335863791,
-0.0025997576,
-0.0203339458,
0.0579019822,
-0.0029689518,
0.0398180448,
0.0037670077,
0.0195443388,
-0.0088551044,
-0.004628703,
-0.0561809167,
-0.1260086,
-0.0161936842,
0.0138669405,
0.0281684846,
-0.0144820157,
0.0273843557,
-0.0018894235,
-0.0259188935,
-0.0114691425,
-0.0128411464,
0.0061805402,
-0.0092618838,
0.0756123811,
0.0471680127,
-0.0261301156,
-0.0056831436,
0.0843447521,
-0.010996731,
0.0551729351,
0.0219791606,
0.0278155413,
-0.03030416,
-0.051697351,
-0.0172204133,
-0.0150699886,
0.0181568917,
0.0178607292,
-0.045111455,
-0.0935729593,
-0.0242104232,
0.0165993366,
-0.0258227438,
-0.0009296096,
0.0145689687,
0.0626300946,
0.0331007876,
-0.0203465614,
-0.0203603264,
0.0146734938,
-0.0251258686,
-0.0250016768,
-0.0213806592,
-5.982026834e-33,
-0.0228141602,
-0.0399534889,
0.0454581715,
-0.0399070755,
0.0195413884,
-0.001141804,
-0.0401149765,
-0.0262337383,
-0.0561975129,
-0.0174127445,
-0.0107334107,
0.0302691031,
0.0013070101,
0.0205820613,
0.0063805291,
-0.0445343629,
-0.0134421038,
-0.013673652,
0.0018839694,
0.0037799487,
0.0127794258,
0.0091269184,
0.0556686111,
-0.0073293946,
0.0154184652,
-0.007984492,
-0.008957685,
0.0522203892,
-0.0285883155,
0.0740938857,
-0.0283276476,
0.0225510895,
0.0236963332,
-0.0569946207,
-0.0084325802,
-0.0168191381,
-0.0564293377,
-0.0256818682,
0.032473553,
-0.0087222941,
-0.0246961974,
-0.0269873478,
0.0377092846,
-0.0066624358,
0.0224406179,
-0.0337237678,
0.0261945631,
-0.035440553,
-0.0050598499,
-0.0198437516,
-0.0119146658,
0.0383562744,
-0.0432594754,
-0.0317784399,
-0.0161662344,
0.0363713503,
-0.0137708969,
0.045593705,
-0.0377076231,
-0.0075865453,
0.013622649,
0.0155205904,
0.0771522522,
-0.0099261608,
0.0223716963,
0.0373865068,
0.0079377033,
-0.0297653042,
-0.0386392996,
-0.0093218591,
-0.0239388384,
0.0602514632,
0.0412840322,
0.016588809,
0.0179591477,
0.0462455116,
-0.0597314797,
0.0427962467,
0.0245007183,
0.0486539677,
0.026712779,
-0.0033186988,
0.0025947478,
-0.0022218027,
-0.0521893837,
0.0178773273,
-0.028071411,
-0.0195620414,
0.0468940549,
-0.0304514505,
0.0242119413,
-0.0171047524,
0.0077212048,
-0.0577076226,
-0.0002250557,
0.046395909,
0.0047557065,
0.0212292485,
0.0122755403,
0.0521391779,
-0.0427550562,
0.0429779068,
0.0120288432,
-0.0216268785,
0.023099402,
0.0058608376,
0.002530158,
-0.0355926566,
-0.0735851973,
-0.0022557306,
-0.0779403076,
0.0368203968,
-0.0301259141,
0.0219101906,
0.0238701794,
0.0158869177,
-0.0107006114,
0.0296268985,
-0.0193230733,
-0.0093933567,
-0.0167058725,
0.0204222165,
-0.0109704435,
-0.0022628359,
-0.0278597753,
0.0159365237,
-0.0327652395,
0.0058314791,
-0.0095401164,
-0.0242347177,
0.0074886302,
0.0204334166,
2.526e-7,
0.0760762915,
0.0149675729,
0.0116546247,
0.0806497708,
0.0015037792,
-0.0134939216,
-0.0350887962,
0.0029332435,
0.0285696182,
-0.0667974651,
-0.0295990538,
0.0695242137,
0.0607708842,
0.0566531532,
-0.0741764978,
0.014962744,
-0.0570046939,
-0.0169858355,
-0.0672586039,
-0.0261113029,
0.0342939012,
0.1024954468,
-0.0133431731,
-0.006317541,
-0.0325472094,
-0.0860047862,
0.0496638045,
-0.0471526645,
-0.0165610835,
0.0207913406,
0.0351865962,
0.033045359,
0.0304014571,
0.0181208178,
0.0076698135,
0.0117295347,
0.0068698158,
0.0590818301,
0.0172247924,
-0.0716211721,
-0.0353382751,
-0.041527763,
0.0277609434,
-0.0668054,
0.0957243219,
-0.0372096412,
-0.046771463,
-0.0030303169,
0.0024850662,
-0.0265076682,
0.0241523311,
-0.0141123487,
0.0161766056,
0.0327362008,
0.015022805,
-0.0367396139,
-0.0080327978,
-0.0690520555,
-0.0292863268,
0.0435349643,
-0.0514454544,
-0.0512605384,
-0.0148289222,
0.0028939857,
-0.018913636,
-0.0233522244,
-0.0076663322,
2.525027987e-34,
0.0421129577,
0.0112034548,
0.009919188,
0.0826477036,
0.0622932687,
-0.0330614857,
0.0281215142,
-0.00521826,
-0.0026422422,
-0.1034414321,
0.0099590868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13230v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13230v2 | DiversiGATE: A Comprehensive Framework for Reliable Large Language Models | 2023-06-22T22:29:40 | 2023-06-26T20:55:56 | Shima Imani, Ali Beyram, Harsh Shrivastava | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this paper, we introduce DiversiGATE, a unified framework that
consolidates diverse methodologies for LLM verification. The proposed framework
comprises two main components: Diversification and Aggregation which provide a
holistic perspective on existing verification approaches, such as
Self-Consistency, Math Prompter and WebGPT. Furthermore, we propose a novel
`SelfLearner' model that conforms to the DiversiGATE framework which can learn
from its own outputs and refine its performance over time, leading to improved
accuracy. To evaluate the effectiveness of SelfLearner, we conducted a rigorous
series of experiments, including tests on synthetic data as well as on popular
arithmetic reasoning benchmarks such as GSM8K. Our results demonstrate that our
approach outperforms traditional LLMs, achieving a considerable 54.8% -> 61.8%
improvement on the GSM8K benchmark. | [
-0.0359372273,
0.0727390647,
0.0157614928,
0.0544138029,
-0.0372902006,
-0.0116895474,
0.0090621756,
0.0154599752,
0.0280020386,
-0.025120439,
-0.0313004181,
-0.0271093994,
0.0058848029,
-0.0122963535,
0.0548062883,
0.0194981415,
0.0477238409,
-0.0798285902,
-0.033101961,
-0.0311149471,
-0.0078492751,
-0.0154195195,
-0.0187790468,
-0.0043798224,
-0.003420982,
-0.0625345781,
0.0034391258,
-0.0185007378,
0.0049905232,
-0.0202259738,
0.014885677,
0.0384860411,
0.0016011586,
0.0692744479,
0.000002425,
-0.065361701,
-0.0230428036,
0.038340494,
-0.0655933693,
0.0416221544,
-0.0301532149,
0.0137162479,
-0.0238219667,
0.052675534,
-0.0363411084,
0.0176146012,
-0.0058962521,
-0.0002079641,
0.09932708,
0.0841463432,
0.0055547138,
-0.0139418757,
0.0492202006,
-0.0003378306,
0.0012725712,
-0.0286532994,
0.0196869224,
0.0293092225,
0.0086175147,
0.0037612994,
-0.0144842099,
0.0205200836,
0.0633369982,
-0.0061985101,
-0.0588277765,
-0.0079905903,
-0.0269782022,
0.0240652729,
-0.0205795243,
0.0305673983,
-0.0012661883,
-0.0356242545,
-0.0046193646,
-0.0227947347,
-0.0310313273,
0.0038948238,
-0.0586220287,
0.0555361137,
-0.0050536618,
0.0044918568,
0.0063057286,
-0.030077884,
0.0437781401,
0.0082026897,
-0.0318971723,
0.1164376438,
0.0532544143,
-0.0452075265,
-0.0034895528,
0.0000526962,
-0.0075843628,
-0.0638459921,
0.0001164134,
0.0542789809,
-0.0201851204,
0.0092437789,
-0.0127182733,
0.0055348249,
0.0352391526,
-0.0128203537,
0.0322249755,
0.0468295142,
-0.0377475657,
0.0328861699,
-0.0229451694,
0.0754717439,
-0.0262347795,
0.0082128532,
0.0146904457,
0.0455996431,
-0.001309584,
0.0087135257,
-0.0087414095,
0.0476981588,
0.0203884877,
0.0301787909,
-0.0621791668,
0.0183134936,
-0.0463410281,
0.0720130652,
0.0415174924,
-0.0659912527,
0.0230712388,
-0.0423012786,
-0.0184523184,
0.011643541,
-0.0150293093,
-0.0005070326,
-0.0074482155,
-0.1058341637,
-0.0103552444,
0.0328427441,
-0.0442795046,
-0.0146751879,
0.0299240928,
0.0695046112,
0.0079256324,
0.0021198622,
-0.0409843847,
-0.0052391049,
-0.0051029455,
-0.0980376527,
-0.0207701661,
-0.108489193,
0.0179563183,
-0.0003946779,
-0.0028073995,
-0.0222121552,
-0.0002032298,
0.0114470161,
0.071703881,
0.0602365993,
0.0114500131,
0.0129909245,
0.013849196,
0.0069155009,
0.0068962257,
0.0478292033,
0.0203287881,
-0.0164968763,
0.0334261507,
-0.0063585998,
0.0262383036,
0.0761896744,
0.0051030568,
-0.0158370845,
-0.0148467729,
0.0263647288,
0.0097158356,
0.0064824019,
-0.0326887183,
0.0839567333,
-0.0301826373,
-0.0150768887,
0.0251412652,
0.0435566679,
0.0297763739,
0.0157041848,
0.0288165584,
-0.015671717,
0.0537569001,
-0.0072700926,
-0.0813131779,
0.0035305407,
-0.0398398936,
0.0346618481,
0.0328976847,
0.0445333682,
-0.0185281262,
-0.0549910329,
-0.0586501621,
0.0063863136,
-0.0529574417,
0.0104707805,
0.0678993836,
-0.0390578248,
-0.017592594,
0.0906350091,
-0.0004233181,
-0.081595093,
-0.0184423178,
-0.0460525863,
0.0636726394,
0.0262558274,
0.0661255196,
-0.0392468832,
-0.0334056169,
-0.0273510646,
0.0053239204,
0.0276091602,
0.0311434455,
0.0091578318,
0.0016779661,
-0.048374299,
-0.0058395681,
0.0112132207,
0.0206892118,
-0.0014463713,
0.0536706746,
0.0137705356,
0.0013138317,
-0.065467298,
0.0184329804,
0.0266650431,
-0.0609197132,
-0.0352061838,
-0.004411377,
-0.0072290138,
-0.0078148283,
0.0119863115,
-0.009787038,
0.0368512571,
0.0204395261,
-0.0044592037,
-0.0084177135,
-0.0489223115,
-0.045799084,
-0.0273096077,
0.09685684,
-0.0084535824,
-0.0263622329,
0.0227012169,
-0.0443345569,
-0.0329392329,
0.0140992934,
-0.0313466117,
-0.0453122333,
-0.048122935,
0.0455908813,
-0.0047661117,
0.0012561341,
-0.0040746913,
0.0577954538,
-0.0118577192,
0.0017856697,
-0.004220596,
0.027776096,
0.0336350575,
-0.0504845902,
-0.0246710274,
0.0025185803,
-0.0183868632,
0.0448551513,
-0.0127885146,
0.0248203091,
-0.0530883558,
-0.0448041223,
-0.0565455854,
0.0141594345,
-0.0317259394,
0.0563539341,
-0.0121172434,
-0.0095803393,
-0.0060358243,
-0.0002328889,
-0.0398443118,
-0.0172283314,
0.0358510651,
0.004983766,
0.018662896,
-0.0329699889,
-0.0230457056,
-0.0327908956,
-0.0226662867,
-0.0332746953,
0.0243374165,
-0.0306182336,
0.0308396202,
-0.0582326874,
-0.0003496423,
-0.0223771445,
0.0140314922,
-0.0058068577,
0.0248944629,
0.0317510292,
-0.0234401058,
0.0324408039,
0.0103046503,
-0.0004339245,
-0.0172880553,
0.0202455055,
-0.0267249793,
-0.0700836703,
0.0084344875,
0.0127858743,
-0.020454593,
0.0101699522,
0.0084530162,
-0.0124403434,
0.0570999384,
-0.0200971309,
-0.0096280174,
-0.0054772273,
-0.0034932194,
0.0007048874,
0.0111170979,
-0.0175345801,
0.0184182134,
-0.0283309519,
0.0028960083,
0.0103529347,
-0.0606675707,
0.0378497168,
-0.0571919717,
-0.0008667426,
-0.011438963,
-0.0174241941,
-0.061910294,
0.0261875242,
-0.0277339518,
-0.0363748968,
0.006044114,
0.0088840118,
-0.0064301291,
-0.0068553975,
0.0646158308,
-0.0545550585,
0.1095986515,
-0.0340055861,
0.0483216941,
-0.0100031886,
-0.0558296703,
-0.051323913,
-0.0014198329,
-0.0408342704,
0.0210341271,
-0.0508755185,
-0.0179451592,
0.003801883,
0.0029055534,
0.0017999485,
0.0488513224,
-0.0443135612,
-0.0036890951,
-0.0093081631,
0.0181254502,
-0.0033261343,
0.0294671115,
0.0554660596,
-0.0497968011,
0.0458420925,
0.0215292331,
0.0476977713,
-0.0119257383,
-0.0362353735,
-0.0053750067,
0.0224110335,
-0.0518130772,
0.0036245794,
0.0486432612,
0.0231601708,
-0.0733499303,
-0.0196617264,
0.1159515753,
0.006041225,
-0.0268311836,
-0.0124529749,
-0.0708286241,
0.0122693088,
0.0230152775,
0.0338799171,
-0.0886321217,
-0.0293958467,
0.0003681915,
0.0181980114,
0.0381381363,
-0.019347297,
-0.0014297602,
-0.1039431766,
0.045941636,
0.0347371288,
-0.0311281011,
0.0279375613,
-0.0208066218,
-0.0080045667,
-0.0286008324,
0.0309475549,
0.0685717463,
-0.0136887748,
-0.0183047913,
0.0050135674,
-0.066883713,
-0.0314580314,
0.0478491448,
-0.0323342867,
0.0165928006,
0.0183079056,
-0.0206610076,
-0.0272030663,
-0.0999111757,
0.0811164975,
-0.0046933056,
-0.0435780287,
-0.0089944713,
-0.0060885292,
-0.0029117481,
0.0121971043,
0.0022020072,
0.0136813819,
-0.0472039245,
-0.0271398108,
0.0444859937,
0.1070680916,
-0.0107997935,
-0.0253205933,
0.0097779185,
-0.019902613,
-0.0166112557,
0.0547281466,
-0.0166392513,
0.0037415121,
-0.0558217131,
-0.0363111459,
-0.0267784689,
-0.0042369026,
-0.0277029723,
0.0177578256,
0.0238725245,
-0.013564351,
-0.0161196291,
0.0305133853,
0.0096670985,
0.0465078391,
-0.0341251269,
0.0004628901,
0.0050896131,
0.0048176297,
-0.0368249044,
0.022536017,
-0.0859335214,
0.0376932099,
-0.078986004,
0.054010924,
0.0030195401,
-0.0284836795,
0.0194499996,
0.0277060997,
-0.1234790236,
-0.0654022247,
-0.0240392145,
0.0579371862,
0.0239698719,
0.0331413448,
-0.0147329457,
-0.005440651,
0.0336765088,
0.0380082615,
-0.0428398363,
0.0306562707,
0.0179107338,
0.0052185124,
0.002595165,
0.0048609464,
-0.03811232,
-0.0076828599,
0.0038378665,
0.0685220063,
0.0134670381,
-0.0158710442,
0.032466501,
0.0721811205,
-0.0007442333,
-0.021363752,
0.0456675552,
-0.0120619126,
0.0304574613,
-0.0249717012,
-0.004672559,
-0.0145924715,
0.04821942,
-0.0051262393,
-0.0365240946,
0.0076682181,
-0.0159818064,
-0.0047132601,
0.0339728631,
-0.0020366309,
0.0277079586,
-0.0134250345,
0.0347073078,
0.0254782829,
-0.050103873,
0.0131103089,
0.0105573153,
-0.0068624923,
0.0256139319,
0.0038214843,
0.0332784839,
0.0060426383,
0.0321225822,
-0.0153254056,
-0.0072882459,
-0.0033999104,
-0.0836830884,
-0.0277555175,
0.0436628833,
0.0718957633,
0.0483641773,
0.0077628572,
-0.0415733159,
0.0047485349,
-0.0419264659,
0.0089131985,
0.0209650919,
0.0110188313,
0.0227991156,
0.04607388,
-0.0036914218,
-0.0160213783,
0.0233256351,
-0.0160454605,
0.0099002412,
0.0302918199,
0.0202439055,
-0.056846153,
-0.0574067123,
-0.0456845425,
-0.0039466172,
-0.0311502814,
-0.0512442552,
-0.0600767173,
-0.0838793218,
0.0315369405,
0.0680841878,
-0.0149090067,
0.0171387438,
0.0060722688,
0.0697351992,
0.0056698909,
0.0230562221,
0.0040306346,
0.0291074421,
-0.0026259262,
-0.0256617945,
0.0066997958,
-6.237761507e-33,
-0.0189221557,
-0.0312737599,
0.0669281706,
-0.0314779505,
0.0008542961,
-0.0137325553,
-0.0265964884,
0.0017539704,
0.0168284569,
0.003097238,
-0.0174876209,
0.0378847234,
0.0180323832,
-0.0023730567,
0.0181719959,
-0.0164967068,
0.0223689675,
0.0061713536,
-0.064520441,
-0.0372412503,
-0.0143717285,
-0.0142406691,
0.0683272853,
-0.0331271999,
0.0166384168,
-0.0204083081,
-0.0372550935,
0.0227815472,
-0.0634679496,
0.0921710879,
-0.0081371227,
0.046009995,
-0.0038653049,
-0.0315179564,
-0.0173839089,
-0.0083046071,
-0.0589029938,
-0.0386651494,
0.0169206746,
-0.000101224,
-0.0666996241,
-0.016891446,
0.0325419046,
-0.012785418,
-0.089003861,
-0.009162751,
-0.0140518444,
-0.0171823613,
0.0094469115,
-0.005604248,
-0.0136030475,
0.056265872,
0.0034885618,
0.0138917807,
0.0114015704,
-0.0216579419,
-0.0226333663,
-0.0027190186,
-0.0322522819,
0.0176026449,
0.0317469798,
0.0148807717,
0.1024349183,
-0.0158183593,
-0.0189526081,
0.0372374281,
0.0065615103,
-0.0289345589,
-0.016984133,
-0.0295104366,
0.0148161827,
0.0398647711,
0.0784975439,
0.0297380742,
0.0272918325,
0.0204986725,
-0.0425992981,
0.0277274549,
0.0481503271,
0.0230613351,
-0.0095914258,
-0.0092307469,
-0.0343485177,
-0.009874288,
-0.0071171294,
0.0297543183,
-0.0461510122,
-0.0274843983,
0.0426473655,
-0.0100533655,
0.0110514006,
-0.0071450993,
0.0150171192,
-0.0438369811,
-0.045372203,
0.0378130563,
0.0092972443,
0.0010854108,
-0.0017356583,
0.0449211076,
0.0094278762,
-0.0021516529,
-0.0350097567,
-0.0103746029,
0.0209246036,
0.0118771829,
-0.0072736414,
0.0443891548,
-0.0643335134,
-0.007552457,
-0.0175695252,
-0.0000114941,
0.0416337028,
-0.009054359,
0.0229925625,
-0.016994562,
0.0220204741,
0.0697871894,
-0.0113421632,
-0.0436237715,
-0.0171688087,
0.0468096212,
0.0213191882,
0.0454830043,
0.0183616187,
-0.0021107085,
-0.0084290635,
0.0302336831,
0.0174034331,
-0.0363204107,
0.0239121262,
0.0150877126,
3.043e-7,
0.0302151404,
0.0385863669,
0.0446746312,
0.0022233985,
0.0075101885,
0.0143613592,
-0.0550165586,
-0.0275563058,
-0.0493204035,
-0.0437274538,
-0.0050538289,
0.0537540354,
0.0447462499,
0.0294232816,
-0.0180137195,
0.0368369073,
-0.0374297537,
0.0058991066,
-0.0475937426,
0.0166511741,
0.0019711917,
0.0451645479,
0.0123375412,
-0.0230363999,
-0.0286203548,
-0.0250540357,
0.0297534801,
-0.0028061988,
-0.029249372,
0.0368183739,
0.0467307307,
-0.0142711857,
0.0263836067,
-0.0222727526,
0.0006849018,
0.047404699,
-0.0074621346,
0.0776560903,
0.0161069576,
0.0322836563,
-0.0097769769,
-0.0454204716,
0.0071175285,
-0.0456557907,
0.0535248928,
0.0238313209,
-0.0084596574,
-0.0647388548,
-0.0309349634,
-0.0632717386,
0.0412681215,
0.0017427437,
0.0094517656,
0.0149161443,
0.0222147088,
-0.0095897298,
-0.0208199918,
-0.0428497382,
-0.070036076,
0.0162459891,
-0.0613913611,
-0.055816818,
-0.025061518,
0.0367769301,
0.0133235445,
-0.0679337829,
-0.0053421771,
3.090659338e-34,
0.0513147563,
-0.0156516638,
0.0142177716,
0.0563867018,
0.0232838355,
0.0055652126,
-0.0572139435,
0.04353844,
0.0065201116,
-0.0416429266,
-0.0195825845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13213v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13213v2 | Visual Adversarial Examples Jailbreak Aligned Large Language Models | 2023-06-22T22:13:03 | 2023-08-16T22:38:55 | Xiangyu Qi, Kaixuan Huang, Ashwinee Panda, Peter Henderson, Mengdi Wang, Prateek Mittal | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, there has been a surge of interest in integrating vision into Large
Language Models (LLMs), exemplified by Visual Language Models (VLMs) such as
Flamingo and GPT-4. This paper sheds light on the security and safety
implications of this trend. First, we underscore that the continuous and
high-dimensional nature of the visual input makes it a weak link against
adversarial attacks, representing an expanded attack surface of
vision-integrated LLMs. Second, we highlight that the versatility of LLMs also
presents visual attackers with a wider array of achievable adversarial
objectives, extending the implications of security failures beyond mere
misclassification. As an illustration, we present a case study in which we
exploit visual adversarial examples to circumvent the safety guardrail of
aligned LLMs with integrated vision. Intriguingly, we discover that a single
visual adversarial example can universally jailbreak an aligned LLM, compelling
it to heed a wide range of harmful instructions that it otherwise would not)
and generate harmful content that transcends the narrow scope of a `few-shot'
derogatory corpus initially employed to optimize the adversarial example. Our
study underscores the escalating adversarial risks associated with the pursuit
of multimodality. Our findings also connect the long-studied adversarial
vulnerabilities of neural networks to the nascent field of AI alignment. The
presented attack suggests a fundamental adversarial challenge for AI alignment,
especially in light of the emerging trend toward multimodality in frontier
foundation models. | [
0.0136498371,
0.0785840601,
-0.0237441361,
0.0548171699,
-0.0253842697,
-0.0011190708,
0.0183937829,
-0.005322495,
0.0228573065,
-0.0513090789,
-0.0248759836,
-0.0226720478,
0.0446781591,
0.0266482942,
0.0912521333,
-0.0448478758,
0.0434244983,
-0.0235460345,
-0.0408101641,
0.0053312941,
0.035918735,
-0.006659775,
0.011110669,
0.0330753438,
-0.0415531062,
-0.0697251633,
-0.0229739621,
0.0298894588,
0.029937923,
-0.0012139365,
-0.0228782371,
0.0193246137,
-0.0013930657,
0.0900603682,
0.0000018266,
-0.0218625292,
-0.0105529567,
0.0393431708,
0.0190566014,
0.0343044028,
0.0071205143,
-0.08009772,
-0.0220208913,
-0.0021376589,
-0.0370070413,
-0.0128879463,
0.0624501593,
0.0490330979,
0.0889205858,
0.0792782456,
0.0011505721,
-0.024177568,
0.0576892532,
-0.0197266396,
-0.0214513782,
-0.0519183353,
0.0268111378,
-0.0301043689,
-0.0575078689,
0.0122990916,
-0.0226868447,
0.0328862146,
0.0115795014,
-0.0079587707,
-0.0230907649,
0.0197171662,
-0.0447586291,
-0.0464540012,
-0.0141206868,
0.0637398362,
-0.0627872944,
0.0181666352,
-0.0191263221,
0.0138924839,
0.0144965863,
-0.0068728887,
-0.014589034,
0.026718691,
-0.004020053,
0.0132463891,
-0.0230618399,
-0.0530348718,
0.056237027,
0.0164927468,
0.0250807703,
-0.0149032576,
0.0366947204,
-0.0051092189,
-0.017778758,
-0.0006045201,
-0.0251663048,
-0.0383115299,
-0.0308380108,
0.0053742137,
0.0181271452,
0.021637626,
-0.109374553,
-0.022536872,
0.0194227491,
-0.0460391007,
0.0741170347,
0.0096338559,
-0.0228614453,
0.0334950015,
0.0049714162,
0.0496102646,
-0.0715437531,
0.072552368,
0.0090397317,
0.0197301749,
0.0175084416,
-0.041213654,
0.0177924894,
-0.0225154478,
-0.0075118411,
-0.0198936332,
-0.0231223535,
0.0431732684,
-0.0332729816,
0.0616749153,
-0.0547865741,
0.0178051591,
-0.0122854104,
-0.0037401067,
0.0032422806,
-0.0028766906,
0.0163410883,
-0.0106753828,
-0.0176086761,
-0.0820724294,
-0.0330756456,
0.0461011007,
-0.0811754838,
-0.0323386975,
-0.0265929252,
0.1296679974,
0.0187632926,
-0.0322940201,
-0.0150604239,
-0.0334835164,
-0.0525752343,
-0.0282788891,
0.0463205501,
-0.0373344049,
-0.0025966174,
-0.028748244,
-0.0196829122,
-0.070616439,
0.0180497169,
0.0179453306,
-0.028020354,
0.1041012928,
-0.0027907121,
-0.0430801921,
0.010009787,
0.012648155,
0.01703058,
0.0600175187,
0.0218886174,
0.0399963111,
0.0354494825,
-0.0156831406,
0.0102990353,
0.0665927604,
0.0069905613,
0.0412044339,
-0.0547708571,
-0.0044353148,
0.0297998004,
0.0402218401,
-0.0079221092,
0.0748929605,
-0.0011740375,
-0.0622262619,
0.1210209504,
0.0313033201,
-0.0259951074,
0.0263934135,
-0.0263248403,
-0.0288851522,
0.0085897492,
0.02843084,
-0.0851413906,
0.0172149055,
-0.0596358515,
-0.0233012997,
-0.0008377607,
0.0889262185,
-0.0343566239,
-0.0098849786,
-0.0130535234,
-0.0005653056,
0.0154129192,
-0.0150331678,
0.0105861938,
0.027770102,
-0.0310660768,
-0.0287856404,
0.0012991652,
-0.0318442471,
-0.0062588905,
-0.0433887839,
-0.0285123289,
0.027140554,
0.0675782636,
-0.0144277858,
-0.0049566478,
-0.0265467018,
0.0090990122,
0.026559379,
0.0396613069,
0.0163685437,
0.0093483413,
-0.038712658,
-0.0123026436,
-0.0458917618,
0.0016779822,
0.0103805792,
-0.0118106594,
-0.0148285786,
-0.0425705947,
0.0043941499,
-0.012863717,
0.0475867018,
0.029269699,
-0.0398697443,
-0.0403198935,
0.0470335372,
0.0027741129,
0.0086381594,
-0.045883026,
0.0147938002,
0.0501039773,
-0.0069725094,
0.0267700143,
-0.0167838,
0.0041254642,
0.0061828126,
0.0494058505,
-0.0604075529,
-0.0409124978,
0.0615476221,
-0.0500949286,
0.0285554342,
0.0451670252,
-0.0273203421,
-0.00706361,
0.0129295532,
0.0062587215,
-0.0023879441,
0.0546693951,
-0.044375442,
0.0368246771,
-0.0286102705,
-0.032622315,
-0.0248715021,
-0.0061250729,
0.0072235814,
-0.0204810202,
-0.0344395861,
0.0244001877,
0.0108459499,
0.0275768135,
-0.0268828385,
-0.0318516269,
-0.0060318215,
-0.0022747919,
-0.0282743573,
-0.0077884044,
-0.0175853577,
-0.0161622167,
0.0182145424,
-0.0225339998,
0.0019344781,
-0.0125336461,
-0.0108677177,
0.025223447,
-0.0303349588,
0.0187474173,
0.0448675528,
-0.0170401018,
-0.0186957121,
-0.0106112408,
-0.0296842307,
-0.0224924888,
0.0678663328,
0.0043349913,
-0.0335845053,
-0.0269317981,
-0.0016597308,
-0.0246121585,
0.0544780605,
-0.0266807005,
-0.0225038677,
0.0433476605,
0.0220742933,
-0.0249830298,
0.0810426772,
0.0223439671,
0.0810855329,
0.0579206683,
0.0506774411,
0.0086156661,
-0.0118669728,
0.0459314398,
-0.0194882229,
-0.0090412339,
0.0172711145,
0.0026581243,
0.0185452942,
0.0186808947,
0.0015896386,
-0.039269302,
0.0813891813,
0.0030590885,
-0.0496082157,
-0.016960552,
-0.0310151111,
-0.031611938,
-0.0162398238,
-0.0403683186,
-0.0937876925,
0.0447944328,
-0.0462901108,
0.0181224942,
0.0525980368,
-0.0280346423,
0.0183643326,
0.0717086643,
0.0248033702,
0.0255331565,
0.0170222595,
-0.0032803952,
-0.080225274,
-0.0114715528,
0.0192826726,
-0.0185661204,
0.0921841562,
-0.0332020223,
-0.005372881,
-0.0277598798,
-0.0298505314,
-0.0618168227,
-0.0495252945,
-0.0032126503,
0.0005093613,
-0.0077876514,
-0.0226339363,
-0.0445774384,
-0.0370591953,
0.0397397503,
-0.0546992496,
-0.0032493109,
0.0056766309,
-0.024058409,
0.0375017673,
0.0466943346,
-0.0341986567,
-0.0034850582,
-0.0316205733,
0.0054746089,
0.0796130672,
0.0014192455,
0.0334211662,
-0.0372205675,
-0.015014112,
0.007238565,
0.0497054979,
-0.025243815,
-0.0042503136,
0.0560576394,
-0.038115114,
0.0286019128,
0.0141306249,
-0.0100578768,
-0.009631318,
0.0226153042,
0.0534805246,
0.0201412812,
0.0074230717,
-0.0016068042,
-0.0800698474,
-0.0154304076,
0.0084005361,
0.0178209897,
0.0032402903,
-0.011636572,
-0.023265427,
-0.0949599072,
-0.0003593003,
0.0317104831,
-0.002077573,
-0.0374402776,
0.0352521241,
-0.0119236391,
-0.0131734144,
0.0392044,
-0.0183067769,
0.0091289049,
-0.0086826365,
0.0045907921,
0.0433743037,
-0.0029357341,
-0.0211839713,
-0.02542747,
0.0147219207,
0.0761914253,
0.005467603,
-0.0439874493,
-0.0512518398,
0.0262115952,
0.0142981419,
0.0099518457,
0.0478737466,
0.0705537796,
-0.0303743575,
-0.0446948968,
0.0167622045,
0.0017227301,
0.0315906331,
-0.003979878,
0.0026412357,
0.024801733,
-0.0063825576,
-0.0112587009,
-0.0406474657,
-0.0070565743,
-0.0135210901,
0.0250675716,
0.0138995871,
-0.0504411645,
-0.0300702825,
-0.0686053112,
0.0276839472,
-0.0337424912,
-0.073278144,
0.0465045273,
0.0296318345,
-0.0262494963,
-0.0423026904,
-0.0243209135,
-0.0126086371,
0.0591573454,
0.0260685552,
-0.0292189624,
-0.0429492593,
0.0112022841,
-0.0116922455,
0.0245511103,
0.0185457561,
0.0496017113,
-0.0253448058,
0.0270141661,
-0.0021594111,
-0.0302757099,
-0.0022626866,
0.0278119631,
-0.0711449981,
-0.0983713716,
0.0108555155,
0.0571063384,
0.0169683136,
0.0273690056,
-0.003258111,
-0.0430310071,
0.045376353,
0.0649617165,
0.0439606272,
0.0313960426,
0.0387592427,
-0.0476323329,
0.0125672473,
0.0366353989,
-0.0288071819,
-0.0396910086,
0.0419330448,
-0.0206667632,
-0.0547576249,
0.0189717896,
0.0111634517,
0.0010684279,
0.0737901181,
-0.0398267843,
0.0103465253,
0.0208517332,
0.0058809812,
-0.0002113993,
-0.0232741069,
-0.0167782865,
-0.0252114367,
0.024247678,
0.0084375292,
0.034468133,
0.0297189597,
0.0341539457,
0.0063580223,
-0.0187025387,
0.0086994227,
0.0127764549,
-0.0085670557,
0.0225788355,
0.0512632281,
-0.0156819262,
0.0908686519,
-0.043489866,
0.0129629439,
0.0014514033,
0.0535909794,
0.0156932268,
0.0191016607,
-0.007799685,
0.0322429128,
-0.0500892624,
-0.057341788,
-0.0027843304,
0.0392049365,
0.0373917259,
-0.0042826622,
-0.0052793575,
-0.0145761278,
-0.0277914759,
-0.0318528861,
-0.0048220856,
-0.0093833879,
-0.0505883209,
0.0661906973,
0.0258733667,
-0.01042917,
-0.0033049372,
0.0514658727,
-0.0010128482,
0.0492904708,
0.0010545832,
-0.0029824311,
-0.0195394102,
-0.0330147967,
0.0812127665,
-0.0169919524,
0.0007688172,
-0.0303026624,
-0.055801712,
-0.095137015,
-0.0023835045,
0.0202036202,
0.0149826473,
-0.005459758,
0.0001012734,
0.0361770988,
0.0171501283,
0.0478930324,
-0.0234443881,
-0.005389696,
-0.0060305358,
-0.0468282886,
0.02436422,
-5.790408765e-33,
0.006761394,
-0.0159774497,
-0.0232458115,
-0.0193656161,
0.0014628136,
0.0103561776,
0.0207691994,
-0.0013432265,
-0.0391107313,
-0.0163691826,
0.0052884226,
0.0025711702,
-0.0254917946,
0.0248582624,
-0.0249021593,
-0.0461474843,
-0.0076688416,
-0.0207506996,
-0.0078241201,
-0.0166072994,
0.022517154,
-0.0039014372,
0.0119581092,
-0.0611798391,
0.0275880583,
0.0081587443,
-0.0726454109,
-0.0068471339,
-0.0303858556,
0.0653625354,
-0.0088754296,
0.0188792925,
-0.0012440226,
0.0325681642,
-0.010199314,
0.0513223186,
0.0121078426,
0.0022806448,
0.0002085895,
0.0459520407,
-0.0614222623,
-0.0297328737,
0.0512276068,
-0.0323039927,
-0.0158346407,
-0.0338862725,
0.0111355409,
-0.0095302146,
-0.0229432061,
0.0209067576,
-0.0427302793,
0.0059579434,
-0.0264830124,
-0.0144574512,
0.019418288,
-0.0140669048,
0.0653035939,
0.0227221418,
-0.0596699156,
0.0197820514,
-0.0028861125,
-0.010960429,
0.0832154751,
0.0295107849,
0.0139488252,
0.1033291221,
0.0383957028,
-0.0236368626,
-0.0207099114,
-0.0156754162,
-0.002859158,
0.039855279,
0.0615130849,
0.0900823995,
0.0176553335,
-0.0151047204,
-0.0470860563,
-0.0014615986,
-0.0377356,
0.0236778874,
0.0075455736,
0.0111901024,
-0.0457260907,
0.0186478011,
-0.0124696894,
-0.0660704821,
-0.0374010839,
-0.010651161,
0.0199743509,
-0.0055838707,
-0.001433503,
0.0312531292,
-0.0016703232,
-0.0407647751,
0.0000109359,
0.0258070696,
-0.0191150252,
-0.0018560132,
-0.0033151926,
0.0097490204,
0.0032756834,
-0.0032703078,
0.0009809167,
-0.0221615694,
0.0481517054,
0.0167414881,
0.0781495497,
0.0346643738,
-0.0503268465,
-0.0023977396,
-0.0234649088,
0.0187886171,
0.045284003,
0.0046590702,
0.0774420127,
-0.0327342153,
-0.0238139704,
-0.0064580739,
0.0370727256,
0.0167104416,
-0.0299645327,
-0.0112273442,
-0.0734491646,
0.0021213242,
-0.001815379,
-0.0163802132,
-0.0104581919,
0.0055122566,
0.0643148795,
-0.1067836508,
-0.0176805668,
-0.0257672668,
2.569e-7,
0.0131452968,
0.0318164825,
0.0366771705,
0.0031882701,
0.0306759104,
0.078227222,
-0.0455786474,
0.0910805017,
-0.0686333627,
-0.0404603109,
-0.0370869562,
0.009782806,
0.0515870787,
0.0192805361,
0.015491615,
0.0323821492,
-0.0421344377,
0.0216439143,
-0.0612178631,
0.0154184569,
0.0403827876,
0.1034631878,
0.0188855957,
-0.0341211893,
0.0162207056,
-0.0782359689,
0.0391885228,
0.0000592942,
-0.012654013,
-0.0491811037,
0.0134656951,
0.0328482538,
-0.0320055671,
0.0018764846,
-0.010050945,
-0.021537127,
0.0029037064,
0.0356728993,
-0.0251521748,
-0.0174626429,
-0.0444859006,
-0.0156109827,
-0.0300684199,
-0.025707785,
0.0603110865,
-0.0004712697,
-0.0437751636,
-0.0151894996,
-0.0026504407,
-0.0046518128,
0.0661272034,
-0.0048150965,
-0.0126368869,
-0.008848506,
0.0005455536,
-0.0087962924,
-0.0043452736,
-0.0610430725,
-0.0032913557,
-0.0048833536,
-0.0285425149,
-0.0087247072,
-0.0229608715,
0.0171228219,
0.0440562703,
-0.0055149463,
-0.0389587022,
2.318779238e-34,
0.0062990743,
-0.0644339547,
0.0275622215,
-0.0393499956,
0.0037891495,
-0.0189632215,
0.0006576876,
-0.0215075519,
0.0079742437,
-0.0354911052,
-0.0215275101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13195v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13195v1 | Prompt to GPT-3: Step-by-Step Thinking Instructions for Humor Generation | 2023-06-22T20:38:52 | 2023-06-22T20:38:52 | Yuetian Chen, Bowen Shi, Mei Si | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Artificial intelligence has made significant progress in natural language
processing, with models like GPT-3 demonstrating impressive capabilities.
However, these models still have limitations when it comes to complex tasks
that require an understanding of the user, such as mastering human comedy
writing strategies. This paper explores humor generation using GPT-3 by
modeling human comedy writing theory and leveraging step-by-step thinking
instructions. In addition, we explore the role of cognitive distance in
creating humor. | [
0.0875199437,
0.0102283163,
-0.010084697,
-0.0132164117,
-0.0346837379,
0.0097354352,
0.0205184929,
0.0255798139,
0.073779583,
-0.0422923379,
0.0160642043,
-0.0515989475,
0.005484344,
0.0640068129,
0.0140825054,
-0.0944287255,
-0.0277283099,
0.0070467712,
0.0335613005,
-0.0133070285,
0.0059061712,
0.0204839259,
-0.0488671847,
0.0361975171,
0.0060399296,
-0.0009116684,
-0.020097509,
0.0369893536,
0.0094486605,
-0.0247961078,
0.0099353138,
0.0061739553,
0.0028760768,
-0.0126662692,
0.0000015903,
-0.0432358421,
0.012744382,
-0.0400886908,
0.0430876836,
-0.0017955479,
0.0071275313,
-0.0195610393,
-0.057183519,
0.0477139167,
-0.0233147684,
0.0545581169,
0.0430043824,
0.0571103767,
0.0798974782,
0.0856290907,
0.0028484059,
-0.000423219,
0.0006102425,
-0.03021143,
0.0593553521,
-0.042627845,
-0.0015234185,
0.0291733071,
0.0310297236,
-0.0239725914,
-0.0453370214,
-0.0176182333,
0.0086259712,
0.0246968959,
-0.0352190696,
0.0494253226,
-0.0095525542,
0.0085390676,
-0.0425301641,
-0.0064518545,
-0.011718275,
0.0164116882,
0.0003509655,
0.0180514418,
0.0093222475,
-0.0133506432,
-0.0381747894,
0.0332333893,
-0.0059390529,
-0.0188128855,
0.0015471972,
0.0305420775,
-0.0486234725,
0.034551464,
0.0736280009,
0.0175391752,
0.0140792234,
-0.0338034779,
-0.0391569622,
0.0016049618,
-0.0494474694,
-0.0391130671,
0.084990941,
0.0638850927,
0.0341801345,
0.0077527603,
-0.0210587718,
-0.0089189718,
0.0359139666,
-0.0112408977,
0.0488433912,
0.0627515167,
0.0286492426,
0.0289627463,
-0.0087754214,
0.0317151546,
-0.0005763348,
-0.0302505419,
-0.020716073,
0.0285700466,
-0.048815947,
-0.0231329948,
-0.0677341148,
0.0263662878,
0.0050827088,
-0.0378175713,
-0.0792584643,
0.0322349854,
0.0422316678,
-0.0318005309,
0.036068406,
0.045015607,
-0.0532894656,
-0.0418476537,
-0.0070178988,
0.0173760112,
-0.0709386319,
-0.001862311,
-0.0045963535,
0.0109904045,
-0.0496601388,
0.0286743063,
0.0467995368,
-0.0402941406,
0.0129634337,
0.0628458709,
-0.0440834872,
-0.0360586345,
-0.0277783237,
-0.0127503937,
-0.0355818346,
-0.0547453053,
0.0294819903,
-0.0477772281,
0.0195987392,
0.0135494154,
-0.0110246278,
-0.025909286,
-0.0122236405,
0.0137605611,
-0.0038697512,
0.0197634902,
-0.0237013754,
0.0187358148,
0.0692496151,
0.0292262938,
-0.045907028,
-0.0028142817,
0.0372801125,
0.0083851255,
-0.0048095281,
0.006158975,
0.012558192,
-0.0031559211,
-0.0129074464,
-0.0239153896,
0.0038154742,
-0.005875058,
-0.0147930756,
0.0517429709,
0.0031672623,
0.0239530914,
-0.0306262709,
0.0715924054,
0.0254453737,
0.0653487518,
0.0437791273,
0.0577045791,
0.1004404575,
-0.0087269237,
-0.0176452603,
0.0630542412,
0.0084168231,
0.0282107498,
-0.0491999537,
0.0234670136,
-0.0008215925,
0.0524805263,
-0.0220865551,
-0.0189108402,
-0.0119881835,
-0.0217546355,
0.0442644618,
-0.0837929472,
-0.0258991122,
0.0276542567,
-0.0387552977,
0.0251910966,
-0.03206053,
-0.0829066858,
-0.0229517668,
0.0233111847,
-0.0174579583,
0.0846232027,
0.0156677831,
0.0018267919,
0.0083855391,
0.0067331651,
0.0354685299,
0.0410700552,
0.0046188207,
0.0312241372,
0.0001129472,
-0.0278221667,
0.0469144806,
-0.0252175946,
0.012981887,
-0.0072325421,
0.0635961965,
0.0376607403,
0.0051209237,
0.041272711,
0.0792483911,
0.0244357605,
-0.1054457799,
-0.0055187452,
-0.0436852239,
0.0217384528,
0.0117059397,
-0.0181474742,
-0.013224558,
0.000489752,
-0.0232116971,
-0.041343201,
-0.0417072847,
0.048043035,
-0.0374349169,
-0.0399120003,
0.0220087785,
-0.0613637082,
0.0273857601,
0.0146188354,
-0.0003297218,
-0.0291442964,
0.0590510629,
-0.0738060176,
0.002665895,
-0.0588175133,
0.006587815,
0.0137262754,
-0.0421698615,
0.0091157015,
0.0831239298,
-0.0209141448,
0.0225297771,
-0.0067351195,
0.0021340472,
0.0389167108,
0.0102388132,
0.0252032466,
0.0054571815,
-0.0102897082,
0.0242908224,
0.0097399447,
0.064425312,
-0.0292392317,
-0.071491085,
-0.0580410473,
0.0131220883,
0.0100671751,
-0.0161285289,
0.0398953035,
0.0058608758,
-0.0407994986,
-0.0235780794,
-0.0194302257,
0.0169575419,
0.0005841744,
-0.0269789528,
0.0519293956,
-0.0085304966,
-0.0252337139,
-0.0180714689,
-0.0250613689,
-0.0392667726,
-0.0115891462,
0.0383214839,
0.007299033,
-0.0328607373,
0.0265487935,
-0.0755796209,
-0.000826088,
0.0090133762,
-0.0668089166,
0.0259745028,
-0.0128098978,
0.0454025604,
0.0630482808,
0.0694144964,
0.013793922,
0.0135459667,
-0.0250932276,
0.0203395989,
0.0180530921,
-0.0062765041,
0.0590561628,
0.0143322907,
-0.0306380764,
-0.0192869715,
0.0172566585,
0.0409742668,
0.036901582,
-0.108031325,
0.0804343969,
0.04229635,
0.022109028,
0.0326465853,
-0.0259911455,
-0.0343315862,
-0.0086114099,
-0.0244487505,
-0.0083297938,
0.0870523974,
-0.0211260132,
-0.0029359111,
-0.0514263995,
0.0042592166,
-0.0187169742,
0.0866055712,
-0.0169499349,
0.0742951185,
-0.0199017692,
-0.0259034932,
-0.0490384698,
0.0102757681,
0.0373783298,
-0.010648476,
0.0271628667,
-0.016571302,
-0.0135187646,
0.0015065534,
-0.0507832542,
-0.0086723538,
0.0052473294,
-0.0088624796,
0.0113998335,
-0.0138099324,
-0.0353413224,
-0.0231832322,
-0.0120419189,
0.0022130825,
0.0218415111,
-0.0304275453,
-0.0259406492,
-0.0247820225,
-0.00315459,
0.009670564,
0.0015247165,
-0.0354550444,
0.0193084739,
-0.0145128323,
0.0065971538,
-0.0317286812,
0.017888369,
0.0285741668,
0.0333717354,
-0.0084739439,
-0.0404982641,
-0.015759008,
0.0144662978,
0.057290107,
-0.0086056283,
-0.0587805435,
0.0809794217,
0.0323203504,
0.0265088342,
0.0319386572,
-0.0075590876,
-0.0056715594,
0.0114879282,
0.0331849903,
-0.0329495557,
-0.0265072975,
0.0002928519,
0.0041915285,
-0.026325563,
-0.0191068277,
-0.0454456881,
-0.0947144479,
0.0114651807,
0.0264108386,
-0.0142303118,
-0.0252572335,
0.0342480019,
-0.0230326448,
0.0399131365,
-0.0501414649,
-0.0088189607,
-0.0149988923,
0.0363922752,
-0.0174193811,
0.0160442479,
-0.0404790267,
0.013504358,
0.0092479307,
0.0735901967,
0.0103953667,
0.0458689481,
0.0177471284,
-0.051293835,
-0.0367851146,
-0.0578418709,
0.043255467,
-0.0123890396,
0.0490154475,
-0.0019890214,
0.0250399597,
-0.0455096513,
0.0243818481,
0.0010908622,
-0.019178886,
0.0083650351,
0.0404323488,
-0.0529469028,
-0.0429214276,
-0.0419189371,
0.0768916681,
0.0049421005,
0.0670818165,
0.0198995713,
-0.0702679306,
-0.0441132896,
-0.0523035564,
0.0108016124,
-0.0674419403,
-0.0110632954,
-0.0245632362,
0.0234254617,
0.0013163353,
-0.0846773833,
-0.0276366007,
-0.0006443458,
0.0791952685,
-0.0090766884,
-0.025547348,
-0.0769697875,
0.0326302163,
-0.0143807894,
-0.0448329747,
0.0371245258,
-0.0185345635,
-0.0048151966,
0.0194768701,
-0.0094510084,
-0.0887230113,
-0.0219729859,
0.0300480556,
-0.0527919196,
-0.0440558344,
0.0112849837,
0.0414413996,
0.0332073048,
-0.0334014073,
-0.007374424,
-0.0617249422,
-0.0191604905,
0.0563203096,
-0.0065887761,
0.060874667,
-0.0134432819,
0.0490606949,
0.0194638688,
0.0129560921,
0.0049317586,
0.0359771885,
0.0039833859,
0.0587556064,
-0.0369816013,
-0.0116562145,
0.0124374321,
-0.0046096435,
-0.0322400779,
-0.0298402514,
-0.032927122,
-0.0014088387,
-0.0230989493,
-0.0220719744,
-0.0083568478,
-0.037720263,
-0.0153664686,
0.0201813392,
-0.0130109051,
-0.0198094547,
-0.0740695223,
-0.0280087292,
0.0045065228,
-0.0383679271,
-0.0115895672,
0.034211766,
0.0098355124,
-0.0092743468,
-0.0010810151,
-0.0356632136,
0.0011980145,
-0.0355807282,
-0.0129669961,
-0.0009059993,
0.0831683949,
0.0203919392,
-0.0264195558,
0.0162708275,
0.0528706685,
-0.0126763079,
-0.0117490133,
0.0048118695,
0.0068284348,
0.052353017,
0.0075109238,
0.0526325293,
-0.0413052738,
0.0254226699,
0.0299550798,
0.0080139088,
-0.0115677258,
-0.0546531267,
-0.0186127722,
0.0086068986,
0.035246063,
-0.0642929152,
0.0744601414,
-0.0603986718,
0.0123797078,
0.0177921411,
-0.0345131084,
-0.0398336276,
-0.0392692462,
-0.0076873098,
0.0307519138,
0.0432881676,
0.031514179,
-0.0349353291,
-0.0366268568,
-0.0062829182,
-0.0162132867,
0.0032383262,
-0.0238304976,
0.0574526675,
0.0509096272,
-0.0244349949,
-0.0218576062,
-0.0138642071,
0.0388498716,
-0.0645584464,
-0.0074639744,
-0.0242692642,
-5.315251173e-33,
-0.0380690135,
-0.0537528135,
-0.0060451422,
0.0458775274,
-0.0131805046,
-0.0238128863,
-0.0653178766,
0.042967815,
0.0157353543,
-0.0017492552,
0.0032262695,
0.0114192767,
-0.0183485448,
-0.0116807809,
0.0213618614,
0.0165496301,
0.0127527351,
-0.0175261572,
-0.0494927168,
0.0034539504,
0.0463922508,
0.0259323902,
0.0168039724,
-0.0378927439,
-0.0240294393,
-0.0298703983,
-0.0509800091,
-0.002260481,
0.0718361437,
0.0404234789,
-0.0012036328,
0.0476812571,
0.0395296998,
0.0223152526,
0.0271481127,
0.0214630738,
0.0054547414,
-0.0517603308,
0.0164955966,
-0.0570926294,
-0.0335532576,
-0.047009591,
0.0234608818,
-0.0428890362,
-0.0224158112,
-0.0072461301,
0.0322194062,
-0.0109843053,
0.069115825,
-0.018230468,
-0.0582279526,
-0.0150386225,
-0.028615104,
-0.0444649123,
-0.0232509375,
0.0296253599,
0.0244914629,
-0.0300497413,
-0.0226061083,
0.039011687,
-0.0484817959,
0.0096453065,
-0.0393291637,
-0.0805895254,
-0.0221969392,
0.0517512374,
-0.0454399511,
0.0337691344,
-0.0307018459,
-0.014029419,
-0.0036471274,
0.0305312295,
0.0586586297,
0.020552747,
0.0383905396,
-0.0389131159,
-0.0223953146,
0.0214839019,
0.0335153639,
-0.0237971786,
0.0344478339,
-0.0161531158,
-0.0410450622,
0.0102521097,
0.05263111,
0.0052399617,
0.0254241861,
-0.0994121581,
0.0004441859,
0.0667116418,
0.0144921429,
-0.0302908774,
0.0003684258,
0.013854865,
0.0113180177,
0.0073852409,
-0.0541538261,
0.0417291448,
-0.0015815765,
0.0183402654,
-0.0437226407,
-0.0247786585,
0.0212085173,
0.1013648957,
0.0244926456,
0.0237790737,
0.041988939,
0.0217887592,
-0.0431024618,
0.0156976171,
-0.0366441458,
0.0566661507,
-0.020587042,
-0.0130161084,
-0.0294814836,
0.0429560617,
-0.0213912893,
-0.063769117,
0.0299154446,
-0.0249962639,
-0.0310994834,
0.0210872758,
0.0046840594,
0.0083547663,
-0.0525857136,
-0.0095132003,
-0.0023874154,
-0.0547716767,
0.0000529929,
-0.0460870303,
0.002329635,
0.0000764705,
2.545e-7,
0.0282286741,
0.0608909354,
0.062524043,
0.0539569929,
0.0534801669,
0.0161020979,
0.013488098,
0.0464864746,
0.0225577764,
0.0242094994,
0.0033221808,
0.0373058133,
-0.0165021066,
-0.0175479241,
-0.065082185,
0.036005307,
-0.0558319166,
0.0225986503,
-0.0490549505,
-0.0096044689,
0.0559492558,
-0.0605700314,
-0.001141612,
-0.0177787095,
0.0013660989,
-0.0477129184,
0.0336746834,
0.0090327831,
0.0518326871,
-0.0112721762,
0.0222270992,
-0.0116081815,
0.0031271961,
0.031875208,
0.0104923062,
-0.0520062335,
0.0281884186,
0.0386074372,
-0.0483947434,
0.0055343495,
0.0367841683,
0.0170872044,
-0.0048497133,
-0.0648098513,
0.0397045873,
0.0035808764,
-0.021590855,
0.0143265752,
0.0076078959,
-0.0125650484,
0.0274730697,
-0.0039393669,
-0.012870051,
-0.003600572,
0.0243517403,
0.023082193,
0.0400516354,
-0.0212714933,
-0.0618946627,
0.0367855765,
-0.037906751,
-0.0026236267,
-0.0344931483,
-0.0249804109,
0.0128906406,
-0.0923487321,
-0.013723623,
1.990004948e-34,
0.0169162173,
-0.0083832024,
0.0502188131,
-0.0514594279,
0.0264020395,
0.0381983556,
0.0285526998,
-0.0001227136,
0.0299393497,
-0.0013112243,
-0.0431890003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13075v1 | Semi-automated extraction of research topics and trends from NCI funding in radiological sciences from 2000-2020 | 2023-06-22T17:47:42 | 2023-06-22T17:47:42 | Mark Nguyen, Peter Beidler, Joseph Tsai, August Anderson, Daniel Chen, Paul Kinahan, John Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, 68T50 (Primary), 68T10 (Secondary), I.2.7; I.5.3; J.3 | Investigators, funders, and the public desire knowledge on topics and trends
in publicly funded research but current efforts in manual categorization are
limited in scale and understanding. We developed a semi-automated approach to
extract and name research topics, and applied this to \$1.9B of NCI funding
over 21 years in the radiological sciences to determine micro- and macro-scale
research topics and funding trends. Our method relies on sequential clustering
of existing biomedical-based word embeddings, naming using subject matter
experts, and visualization to discover trends at a macroscopic scale above
individual topics. We present results using 15 and 60 cluster topics, where we
found that 2D projection of grant embeddings reveals two dominant axes:
physics-biology and therapeutic-diagnostic. For our dataset, we found that
funding for therapeutics- and physics-based research have outpaced diagnostics-
and biology-based research, respectively. We hope these results may (1) give
insight to funders on the appropriateness of their funding allocation, (2)
assist investigators in contextualizing their work and explore neighboring
research domains, and (3) allow the public to review where their tax dollars
are being allocated. | [
0.0272393748,
0.0924485624,
-0.0088492557,
-0.0029084927,
0.0193347111,
-0.0017328721,
0.0139214788,
0.0745536909,
-0.0245999116,
0.0284283329,
-0.0000263002,
0.0095894504,
0.0195746571,
0.064231284,
0.0239834059,
-0.0943674743,
0.0306282323,
-0.0026934352,
0.0317460485,
0.0163872596,
-0.0087316381,
-0.0040022344,
-0.0233724713,
0.0295811519,
0.0116040809,
-0.0105697727,
0.0521231182,
-0.0400463864,
0.0159050748,
-0.0703217238,
-0.0086099943,
0.034123946,
0.0069318577,
0.0251425281,
0.0000019135,
-0.0601972453,
-0.0786625296,
0.013611218,
0.017585475,
0.0533375219,
0.0983348191,
-0.0852940679,
0.0127800982,
-0.0166984312,
-0.0039425311,
-0.0243563484,
0.0271925982,
0.0072767539,
-0.0304233395,
-0.0389645249,
-0.0124711646,
0.0197454672,
0.0268145911,
-0.0375631861,
0.0011317492,
0.0160846896,
0.0199579895,
0.0058617778,
0.0093301516,
0.0556528941,
-0.0093921563,
0.0536670648,
-0.0454698801,
-0.023015162,
0.0745960549,
0.0974920169,
0.0046781385,
-0.0057465904,
-0.0240909476,
0.0455168858,
0.0284544602,
0.0165837239,
0.0635657534,
0.0072751003,
-0.0272095148,
0.0418394208,
-0.059983626,
0.001392982,
0.0249498505,
-0.0435720459,
0.0104042385,
0.013786328,
0.0209858511,
0.0329104811,
-0.014344071,
-0.0079212151,
-0.0019667903,
-0.0365776308,
-0.0177037213,
-0.0027328841,
0.0240302831,
-0.0383246988,
0.0246687867,
-0.01088126,
0.0175952222,
0.0482419729,
0.0397809371,
0.0229627099,
0.0661193728,
0.0312999785,
-0.0576623753,
-0.0260023121,
-0.0342788063,
0.0935180485,
0.03927752,
-0.0262993444,
-0.0712549537,
0.0065515679,
-0.0163558293,
0.0206680484,
-0.0441700816,
-0.0102947196,
-0.0056320522,
-0.0144773098,
-0.005511628,
-0.0266888682,
-0.0265698601,
-0.0032706999,
-0.032626912,
-0.0029393367,
-0.0148762632,
0.0483305231,
-0.039780423,
0.0216051228,
-0.0086772479,
0.063201271,
-0.0393903963,
0.0279758777,
-0.0254010595,
0.0650881603,
-0.031582661,
0.0119082974,
0.0290918611,
0.0042853346,
-0.0240031872,
0.0073358505,
0.046776861,
-0.0337362885,
0.05788913,
-0.0683516413,
-0.0409310386,
0.0094749453,
0.0414836593,
-0.0345258079,
0.0208986923,
0.0107607041,
0.0341020711,
0.0259652697,
-0.0221567564,
-0.0280527677,
-0.0527294129,
0.0618957393,
-0.068091847,
-0.0493981019,
0.0388926789,
0.0297648516,
-0.0072340183,
-0.0520053729,
-0.0186954327,
-0.0079195369,
0.0507780612,
-0.0334600657,
-0.0357555971,
-0.0432889573,
0.0211251881,
0.0092386762,
-0.0008475744,
-0.0111319451,
-0.012345612,
0.0449239537,
0.0024804103,
-0.0153359948,
-0.0412621386,
-0.0000727624,
-0.0293219686,
0.1388337165,
0.0441726111,
0.0129999779,
-0.0625539795,
-0.0165377837,
-0.0057565398,
-0.0723895505,
0.0435807295,
0.0344602913,
-0.0078633204,
-0.0132491058,
0.0350964665,
-0.0106419483,
-0.0132089248,
-0.007185427,
-0.0024897344,
0.0460323431,
-0.0074753198,
-0.0579854101,
0.0528594553,
-0.019693207,
0.0426930226,
-0.0263443179,
0.0701500401,
0.0194785316,
0.0076915063,
0.0312201809,
-0.0005103233,
0.031044811,
0.0322155766,
-0.0662712455,
-0.0499860048,
0.002699591,
0.0425328016,
0.0324588791,
-0.0170068648,
-0.0180039741,
-0.0239766333,
0.0117951091,
-0.0276252553,
0.0074392632,
0.0057579833,
0.007857725,
0.0170533136,
0.024801882,
-0.0665018484,
-0.0618997291,
0.0480446629,
0.0273390934,
-0.0082462654,
0.0397972278,
0.0212991498,
-0.0139959957,
0.0050815712,
-0.0027217213,
-0.0016117721,
0.0053573442,
0.0604770705,
0.006582058,
-0.0074716588,
-0.0206420366,
0.0424655005,
0.0317123905,
-0.0165339112,
-0.044246193,
0.0157704223,
-0.0641577691,
-0.0414554514,
0.0129842907,
0.0534802452,
-0.0118201459,
0.0140339192,
0.0230883192,
0.0051161423,
-0.0091944681,
0.000045667,
-0.0248631928,
0.0096762665,
-0.0340397172,
0.0263264887,
0.0497950651,
-0.0316113085,
0.0129075972,
-0.0184341744,
-0.0218357611,
0.0117174145,
0.0324758179,
-0.0110017918,
0.0121871904,
-0.0619450323,
0.0022336864,
0.027987523,
0.0128886774,
-0.0381753482,
0.0343665071,
-0.0379971825,
0.0380245037,
-0.0205564611,
0.0144634331,
0.0012328804,
0.0551221631,
-0.027493,
0.0101157837,
-0.037986163,
0.0914701,
0.011071505,
0.0017911209,
-0.0763814598,
-0.0239825305,
-0.0438111164,
0.0059450562,
0.0400453545,
-0.0277852342,
-0.0030820349,
-0.0118515398,
-0.0027598434,
0.0000862915,
-0.0329219289,
-0.0180788096,
0.052847825,
-0.0206524972,
-0.0556601249,
-0.0056579104,
0.0126145724,
0.1055088267,
0.0282586515,
-0.0232968386,
0.0031495104,
-0.0026043942,
-0.0395234823,
0.0306380093,
0.0657215267,
0.003003381,
0.0583698675,
0.0218210611,
0.0231379271,
0.0325633138,
-0.0338885374,
-0.0148909967,
-0.0713351369,
0.0106976992,
-0.0624527149,
0.0507998541,
-0.0107419146,
0.0436421484,
0.0043089753,
-0.0082302177,
0.0702397078,
0.0156342294,
0.0253312644,
-0.0565764308,
-0.0379522443,
-0.0340030603,
0.0145972492,
-0.0304080453,
0.0321912728,
-0.0084944973,
-0.0040066126,
0.0161306728,
-0.0004923522,
0.0083146794,
-0.0126442444,
0.0197847057,
-0.038375169,
-0.0190988798,
-0.0012869039,
-0.001569059,
-0.0177246891,
-0.0193966571,
0.0337290987,
-0.012057906,
0.0828156099,
-0.0655307695,
-0.0363070183,
0.0387364402,
0.0408641919,
-0.003310767,
-0.0123620918,
-0.0216517076,
-0.0085849892,
0.0437994935,
0.0063798707,
-0.044768393,
-0.0344085582,
0.0088960975,
0.0080136852,
0.0269240141,
-0.0196285378,
0.0245846845,
-0.0403634571,
0.0344412774,
0.0018705252,
-0.0264475737,
0.0001206563,
-0.0348063149,
0.0308580436,
0.0289516971,
-0.0092333518,
0.0450337939,
0.0320922211,
-0.0311702937,
0.0052833096,
0.0009417514,
-0.0225721542,
-0.0101991808,
-0.0087411348,
-0.0520462953,
0.0440011658,
-0.0672370791,
0.0173036363,
0.0158862807,
-0.0455067977,
-0.024775371,
-0.0023392562,
0.0661998615,
-0.0196591374,
-0.0418831185,
0.0094739888,
-0.0857672989,
0.0133609287,
0.0101763755,
-0.0768075883,
-0.012037646,
0.0056412788,
-0.0325278118,
0.0013927552,
-0.0604018159,
-0.0294596329,
-0.0012650562,
-0.033868894,
0.0137009732,
-0.0285416432,
0.0409790911,
-0.044435259,
0.0015598696,
-0.0622856431,
0.0163938534,
-0.0187655818,
0.0050953557,
0.0864629298,
0.0265788529,
0.0067137405,
-0.0730286688,
0.0231707375,
-0.008177273,
-0.0046321019,
0.0079989666,
0.0734521449,
-0.0327122249,
0.0145469289,
-0.0553575195,
0.0195714552,
-0.0063669588,
0.0150138242,
-0.0132190827,
0.0177039746,
0.0365184844,
0.0068461574,
0.0942183584,
0.0442964621,
0.0211553909,
-0.0172510818,
-0.0623057857,
-0.0268702134,
-0.0568266064,
0.009380742,
0.0471633002,
0.0003340949,
-0.0003536923,
0.0154725481,
0.0391741768,
-0.0700599775,
-0.0382383168,
0.0385886468,
0.0157948192,
-0.0175042767,
0.000132985,
-0.0748237148,
0.0329814032,
0.0607998893,
-0.024825938,
0.010035594,
0.0201665983,
-0.0049529392,
-0.0556136556,
-0.0292924233,
0.0191754624,
-0.0286971144,
-0.0214868039,
-0.0047215438,
0.0757186413,
0.0599067435,
-0.0217103697,
-0.0552488938,
-0.0537187532,
-0.0142687177,
-0.0423886143,
-0.0485293828,
-0.0172163378,
0.0319343396,
-0.0454951003,
-0.0178776029,
-0.1014788523,
-0.0331410393,
0.004680471,
-0.0015994287,
0.1239156649,
-0.0510216914,
-0.0179124549,
-0.0146290734,
-0.0791438892,
-0.0294471756,
0.0284909215,
0.0375640467,
-0.0249621347,
0.0503527373,
-0.0073560784,
-0.0171147194,
0.0436306186,
-0.0414778292,
-0.0161546394,
-0.0542414151,
0.0350367278,
0.0158976149,
0.0212777052,
0.0536750145,
0.0124944523,
-0.0023978364,
-0.0262900945,
-0.057584662,
0.0062039434,
0.0072069382,
0.0011754323,
0.0212982744,
0.0376266427,
-0.0317463987,
0.0385677181,
-0.0702976435,
-0.0607801303,
0.0239451956,
0.0023023908,
0.0113676433,
0.0419336073,
0.0030139543,
-0.0230711419,
-0.0284714699,
-0.0054656491,
0.0284511242,
-0.024497224,
0.0298387613,
0.0647614896,
0.0122736199,
-0.0067944606,
-0.030505592,
0.0582410544,
0.030108152,
-0.002161283,
-0.0157165043,
-0.0268148743,
-0.0134223774,
-0.0162771456,
0.0122202821,
0.0217346307,
-0.0124770738,
0.0177999958,
-0.0559815764,
0.0168401729,
0.0377197377,
-0.0272989254,
-0.062854901,
-0.005341745,
0.0221976805,
-0.0117326919,
0.0142122945,
-0.0227701869,
-0.0081317853,
0.0419258773,
-0.0619342439,
-0.1045700163,
0.0071434262,
-6.48450218e-33,
0.0236508921,
-0.0185841974,
-0.0005045157,
-0.025930237,
-0.0009803596,
0.0996085554,
-0.0264430121,
-0.0188083313,
0.0073636333,
-0.0127473986,
-0.038448479,
0.0028086347,
-0.0084441807,
-0.0242823176,
0.0649081096,
0.0372651629,
0.010787569,
-0.0060435375,
-0.0176747665,
0.0330844447,
0.007847175,
0.0153100388,
0.0159821045,
-0.0569373183,
0.0127302352,
0.0812171027,
0.0339430794,
0.001079532,
0.0716964006,
0.0212717112,
-0.0476443879,
0.0314943753,
-0.0165327992,
-0.0690688938,
0.0100226002,
-0.0026873401,
-0.0357208885,
-0.0147955585,
-0.0063837892,
-0.0611083545,
-0.0378793776,
0.0131299468,
0.0103160068,
0.0334093459,
-0.0056943111,
-0.0121336095,
0.0485488884,
0.0247162245,
-0.0234806482,
0.0417474099,
-0.0058203922,
0.045028083,
-0.0394739248,
0.061382141,
0.0094288299,
-0.0420311019,
-0.0153527297,
0.1199470609,
-0.0130212978,
0.0597662739,
0.0258805472,
0.02308443,
0.0299263299,
-0.0196372792,
0.0142691303,
0.0510925613,
-0.0165472608,
-0.0006736582,
0.0147917569,
-0.0145112146,
0.0201789197,
0.0375982486,
0.0276756268,
0.0286377296,
0.0246472862,
-0.0336594582,
-0.0567033887,
0.0164507311,
0.0206348896,
0.0552188046,
-0.0014235997,
0.0297758356,
-0.004737739,
-0.0288796648,
0.0370762162,
-0.0821746737,
-0.0020467541,
-0.0271079447,
0.0120808808,
-0.0149227167,
-0.0388423279,
0.0675471649,
0.0261416137,
0.0079469681,
-0.0003073839,
0.005284287,
0.0080709681,
0.0600510724,
-0.0364182442,
0.021406129,
-0.0894612968,
-0.0385480262,
0.0326928385,
0.0099596474,
0.0334414095,
-0.0073177586,
-0.0011222375,
-0.0500380099,
-0.0015413512,
0.0308600925,
0.0075490782,
-0.0644415542,
-0.0233942028,
0.0014901407,
0.0116789332,
0.0257820878,
0.0136802532,
0.0117941266,
0.0410214067,
0.0620516241,
-0.0031561903,
-0.0220339503,
-0.064148508,
0.0104885707,
-0.0287690833,
-0.044546295,
-0.025557816,
-0.0083076125,
0.0453350395,
-0.058832258,
-0.0186151285,
-0.0242299791,
2.831e-7,
0.073447682,
0.0644550696,
0.0241704267,
0.0179796498,
0.0003569817,
-0.0255319942,
-0.0498627312,
0.0142820077,
-0.0309456661,
-0.0171505101,
0.0374623984,
-0.018843051,
-0.0162273403,
0.036445193,
-0.0152822835,
-0.0813601539,
-0.0560253672,
-0.0097649945,
-0.0591145307,
-0.019086862,
0.0159849841,
-0.0124870604,
0.0256133173,
0.0060197762,
-0.0190669876,
-0.0386669822,
-0.0001342071,
-0.0525827557,
0.0372512899,
0.0113356626,
-0.0166097786,
0.0387441926,
-0.0113634476,
0.034984868,
-0.0126502141,
-0.04821603,
-0.0092790369,
-0.0013494738,
-0.0265664421,
0.0190177727,
0.0120262168,
0.0148276221,
0.0184455551,
-0.0336881727,
-0.0098465607,
-0.045346655,
-0.0109554417,
-0.0038670918,
0.0126943495,
0.0190255679,
0.0481793471,
-0.0339908898,
-0.0219722297,
0.0003828533,
-0.0171670299,
0.0285543073,
-0.0165137742,
-0.0452860259,
0.0377576314,
0.0629122779,
-0.0079397168,
-0.021493163,
0.0212502629,
-0.0219551567,
0.0328133367,
0.0010588727,
0.0180184748,
2.363920976e-34,
0.0413692072,
-0.006485342,
0.00720882,
-0.0504723005,
0.0117361927,
-0.0290374998,
-0.0508006811,
0.0011836942,
-0.0091960058,
-0.0600871705,
0.0056693284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13063v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13063v2 | Can LLMs Express Their Uncertainty? An Empirical Evaluation of Confidence Elicitation in LLMs | 2023-06-22T17:31:44 | 2024-03-17T04:38:48 | Miao Xiong, Zhiyuan Hu, Xinyang Lu, Yifei Li, Jie Fu, Junxian He, Bryan Hooi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Empowering large language models to accurately express confidence in their
answers is essential for trustworthy decision-making. Previous confidence
elicitation methods, which primarily rely on white-box access to internal model
information or model fine-tuning, have become less suitable for LLMs,
especially closed-source commercial APIs. This leads to a growing need to
explore the untapped area of black-box approaches for LLM uncertainty
estimation. To better break down the problem, we define a systematic framework
with three components: prompting strategies for eliciting verbalized
confidence, sampling methods for generating multiple responses, and aggregation
techniques for computing consistency. We then benchmark these methods on two
key tasks-confidence calibration and failure prediction-across five types of
datasets (e.g., commonsense and arithmetic reasoning) and five widely-used LLMs
including GPT-4 and LLaMA 2 Chat. Our analysis uncovers several key insights:
1) LLMs, when verbalizing their confidence, tend to be overconfident,
potentially imitating human patterns of expressing confidence. 2) As model
capability scales up, both calibration and failure prediction performance
improve. 3) Employing our proposed strategies, such as human-inspired prompts,
consistency among multiple responses, and better aggregation strategies can
help mitigate this overconfidence from various perspectives. 4) Comparisons
with white-box methods indicate that while white-box methods perform better,
the gap is narrow, e.g., 0.522 to 0.605 in AUROC. Despite these advancements,
none of these techniques consistently outperform others, and all investigated
methods struggle in challenging tasks, such as those requiring professional
knowledge, indicating significant scope for improvement. We believe this study
can serve as a strong baseline and provide insights for eliciting confidence in
black-box LLMs. | [
0.0369626097,
0.0993032604,
-0.0118569927,
0.0268350076,
-0.0393235944,
-0.0145165417,
-0.032695327,
-0.010813171,
0.0110602099,
-0.0257286429,
-0.0244884938,
-0.0375363529,
0.0290166903,
0.0019206243,
0.0267993901,
-0.0184463877,
0.0057803905,
-0.0528954901,
0.0578588806,
-0.033289846,
-0.0149282543,
-0.0133942934,
-0.0284137689,
0.0353652537,
0.0190930869,
-0.0135088358,
-0.0189834721,
-0.0047071893,
0.0079883141,
-0.058629714,
0.0124575626,
0.0691138431,
0.0046912162,
0.0148769254,
0.0000020907,
-0.0583181791,
0.0054292534,
-0.0095355641,
-0.0624123588,
0.0167654883,
0.0030939875,
0.0460664444,
0.0040106438,
0.0357554816,
-0.0580100231,
0.0280703958,
0.0412562042,
-0.0169966053,
0.0363322049,
0.0266979486,
0.0151612964,
0.0329884179,
0.0258205645,
0.0099720191,
0.019812556,
-0.0474645831,
-0.0013833818,
0.0192484502,
0.0169714019,
0.0057745888,
-0.0094723525,
0.0309315398,
0.03741052,
-0.0197105035,
-0.041215919,
0.0191900674,
-0.0278378483,
-0.0461384766,
-0.050105229,
0.0337037519,
0.071948573,
0.0034753596,
-0.0369130671,
-0.0157379918,
0.0555585809,
0.0417336561,
-0.0514522865,
0.0305166934,
-0.0181122869,
0.0070432215,
-0.0460417345,
0.0169343315,
0.0209843852,
0.0047496357,
0.0249643847,
0.091410622,
-0.0110431639,
-0.0201894902,
0.0281837769,
0.0136815421,
-0.0020613966,
-0.0605155639,
-0.009742137,
0.0632207245,
-0.0458920859,
0.0291458741,
-0.0080619352,
0.0157261584,
0.0424588248,
0.0051042745,
0.031038532,
0.0536670499,
-0.023749724,
0.0001343206,
0.01410475,
0.0316629671,
0.0220714211,
0.024304213,
0.000735706,
0.0205374435,
-0.0095902458,
-0.0185726695,
0.0013525864,
0.0166928601,
0.0103878146,
0.0262823943,
-0.0886634067,
0.0136469919,
-0.0360925533,
0.0613038056,
-0.0115531804,
0.0271468479,
0.0133935623,
-0.0410805233,
-0.0697818398,
0.0094499756,
-0.0030873474,
0.0374396853,
0.0437173918,
-0.1098373309,
0.0048751063,
0.0099511426,
-0.0307868198,
0.0217859019,
0.0134531399,
0.0841028243,
-0.0133961858,
-0.001213755,
-0.025710769,
-0.0454159826,
-0.0250627771,
-0.0653447881,
-0.0070153847,
-0.076635547,
-0.0006520685,
0.0205600113,
-0.0042312467,
-0.0192453321,
0.0233548023,
0.016072534,
0.0215036478,
0.0750275776,
-0.0137549452,
0.014502652,
0.0172547698,
0.0279839914,
-0.0509643629,
0.0570855439,
0.0636881217,
0.0132366186,
0.0455638468,
-0.0029475177,
0.0526567809,
0.0233887788,
0.00873168,
0.0075310119,
-0.0074661104,
0.0255939905,
-0.036106769,
0.0187957175,
-0.0047147772,
0.0516229197,
-0.0291006304,
0.0121656423,
0.105685018,
0.0576063171,
-0.0170976352,
-0.035044834,
-0.0060084448,
-0.018769037,
0.0602901056,
-0.0056482316,
-0.0688744038,
0.0430107415,
-0.0502808951,
0.0209880341,
0.0317628905,
0.0175541602,
-0.0097616715,
-0.0699939802,
-0.0324691683,
-0.0039283987,
-0.0203871448,
0.0617432222,
0.0144950086,
-0.0500236079,
-0.0173812285,
0.0344213806,
0.0002460142,
-0.0477761962,
-0.039384868,
-0.0796540901,
0.0554295704,
0.0236713514,
0.0365713611,
0.0035487351,
-0.0403301045,
-0.0185887329,
-0.01030913,
0.0176315587,
0.0448856242,
-0.0018652719,
-0.0065698503,
-0.0345860347,
-0.0452044234,
0.0122596808,
-0.004538225,
0.0120305205,
0.0446566977,
0.0056908317,
-0.0050640209,
-0.0419130661,
-0.0003255305,
0.0022931285,
-0.02015098,
-0.0241383463,
-0.0266908426,
-0.0251934882,
0.0339820981,
0.0185049139,
0.0194982402,
0.039575506,
0.0294560865,
0.0397615694,
-0.0425976068,
-0.002733324,
-0.028338531,
0.0251550004,
0.0622137263,
-0.003025292,
-0.0281839576,
-0.0183687136,
-0.0328303613,
-0.0231923107,
-0.0115853595,
-0.0296602156,
0.0099578295,
-0.0268895514,
0.016485313,
-0.0163358431,
-0.0216484759,
-0.0388716422,
0.0248192549,
-0.0201835986,
0.0011624332,
0.019259112,
0.0119898943,
0.0040095071,
-0.0392442904,
-0.0145295244,
0.0146653699,
0.0082786772,
0.0274224151,
0.020975776,
0.0198807493,
-0.0635789335,
-0.021270657,
-0.0765093565,
-0.0222754236,
0.0004543376,
0.0371126793,
-0.017943332,
-0.0310328845,
-0.0170881785,
-0.0135252234,
-0.0578278154,
0.0147670507,
0.0184855573,
0.0249006636,
0.0315630957,
-0.0077956091,
-0.0164360702,
-0.0286283474,
-0.0016302461,
-0.0114421267,
0.0035944215,
0.0266716424,
0.0075078839,
-0.0707746595,
0.0390954167,
-0.0490670763,
-0.0120962169,
-0.0072300043,
-0.0324645415,
0.0337669067,
0.0014416036,
-0.0225172546,
0.0272406284,
-0.0086599318,
-0.0127026057,
0.052745875,
-0.0150991827,
-0.0658162907,
0.011277589,
-0.0126540111,
-0.069137536,
-0.0095311329,
-0.04698167,
-0.0066808932,
0.0372285545,
0.012023164,
0.0129896747,
-0.0211620145,
0.0193147864,
0.0072055091,
-0.0238328055,
-0.0096033821,
-0.017093461,
-0.0159967244,
0.0849547163,
0.00383811,
-0.0978593677,
0.0982274041,
-0.0277649667,
-0.0150216836,
0.0198161379,
-0.0154829994,
-0.0151006933,
0.0526261032,
-0.0344810747,
-0.030217791,
0.0214699116,
-0.0105745094,
-0.0638798252,
-0.0554020777,
0.0248119906,
-0.0763395056,
0.0471697897,
-0.0665711313,
-0.0191033594,
-0.0100246528,
-0.0470159426,
-0.0413536951,
-0.0071683321,
-0.0812680796,
-0.0067859907,
-0.0008366015,
-0.0603558011,
0.0053296266,
-0.0420524105,
0.0346683264,
-0.0211142395,
-0.0341959856,
-0.0394908078,
-0.0034800847,
-0.0241793413,
0.0265093539,
0.0401535258,
0.0840035453,
-0.0501121841,
0.017416833,
0.0791560262,
0.0453358106,
0.0152370278,
-0.0222690254,
-0.0169290379,
0.0566570349,
0.0176559649,
0.0029180327,
0.0858813748,
0.0791909173,
-0.0164811257,
0.0191924218,
0.1069044247,
0.0082571013,
-0.0085692806,
-0.0122908587,
-0.0730501339,
0.0479850881,
0.0194260459,
0.0079257153,
-0.0704331473,
-0.0307366513,
0.0164886825,
0.0640274435,
-0.0364770927,
-0.032568939,
0.0055254856,
-0.1213424206,
0.048863925,
0.0066285017,
-0.0157214347,
-0.0074827452,
-0.0272003505,
0.0235106777,
0.0005010586,
0.0607390851,
0.0327928588,
0.0100166481,
-0.0014301871,
0.0231193807,
-0.0717052296,
-0.0357458703,
0.0197266415,
-0.0269648526,
0.0680663437,
0.0234123841,
-0.0042708665,
-0.0174886435,
-0.0566968657,
0.0290243812,
0.0149291167,
-0.0115295928,
-0.0117936535,
0.0220896862,
0.0116015347,
0.0192591455,
-0.0236851443,
0.0304956716,
-0.0317118876,
-0.0126141151,
0.025132088,
0.0647842959,
-0.035686817,
-0.0142839402,
-0.0320203006,
0.0174455866,
0.0256055221,
0.0527320132,
0.0131999999,
-0.0273491796,
-0.0113256844,
-0.0457294807,
-0.0068651927,
-0.0111897523,
0.0010299883,
0.0257711783,
0.0233934056,
0.037896771,
-0.0240559261,
-0.0296529979,
0.0270088278,
-0.0009320468,
-0.0059374184,
-0.0091868807,
0.0306169167,
0.0117354076,
-0.0117521528,
0.011635852,
-0.0378073417,
0.0426303856,
-0.0437819734,
0.0553017706,
0.0020541623,
-0.0146407811,
0.0280709565,
0.0313089304,
-0.0605859682,
-0.0841553584,
-0.022062419,
0.08654695,
0.0357132256,
-0.0233097374,
0.012716026,
-0.0529874489,
0.0521137714,
0.028865587,
-0.0202245321,
0.007528259,
0.0323239639,
0.0725395828,
-0.0050636716,
0.0404391438,
-0.0276448429,
-0.0208381843,
0.0162186809,
0.0267935153,
-0.0302949063,
-0.0882731602,
0.0189091787,
0.0328402482,
0.017457176,
-0.032352414,
0.0298237801,
0.0087196585,
0.0303710736,
-0.0242102761,
-0.0158715993,
-0.021778129,
-0.0095574884,
-0.0033261988,
-0.0617851578,
0.0238131713,
-0.0469654612,
-0.0293202661,
0.0300125778,
-0.0138131306,
0.0342410617,
0.0252746586,
0.0096067712,
0.0418151394,
-0.0263923462,
-0.008698808,
0.0052001257,
-0.0155028775,
0.0385329835,
0.06856516,
0.0539737269,
0.004610057,
-0.0249863192,
0.0112725692,
-0.0100438586,
-0.0611763261,
-0.1011900529,
0.0105476528,
0.0328757465,
0.0193839911,
0.0409245864,
-0.0006664081,
-0.0371774584,
0.0043101739,
-0.005014088,
-0.0137990434,
0.0021501197,
0.0280516464,
0.0782598555,
0.0162819959,
-0.0270910673,
-0.0249726363,
0.0412606634,
-0.0427116491,
0.0454260372,
-0.0486933514,
-0.0290135033,
-0.0282583125,
-0.0398868136,
0.0209649038,
0.0194645729,
-0.0218445193,
-0.0282102618,
-0.0772972926,
-0.0637960657,
0.0229151677,
0.0420501977,
-0.0086315162,
-0.0526883192,
-0.0021506164,
0.054767672,
0.0129678482,
-0.0035173257,
-0.0071373563,
-0.0035961044,
-0.0302503388,
0.0207372103,
-0.0574726835,
-6.208025174e-33,
-0.0302499812,
-0.0867938846,
0.0155753037,
-0.0074743535,
0.0193210803,
-0.0081020938,
-0.0113616735,
0.0559899025,
-0.0049648411,
0.028081378,
-0.0297360644,
0.0075473194,
0.0222526584,
0.0042845639,
0.060364455,
-0.0315172635,
-0.012642202,
0.0014367332,
-0.0459499769,
-0.0390704796,
0.0022031702,
-0.0182350948,
0.0614678822,
-0.0915730074,
0.1093623415,
0.0114499601,
-0.0260400586,
0.0295430217,
-0.0568341389,
0.0461997613,
0.0209969413,
0.0484838635,
-0.015739616,
-0.0224156156,
-0.014792406,
0.0177128576,
0.0133670187,
-0.0572151579,
0.0333460793,
-0.009388838,
-0.0336003229,
-0.0073613278,
0.0132726263,
-0.002670523,
-0.0583501793,
-0.0071200696,
0.0010671696,
-0.0364765823,
-0.0049449084,
-0.0165404528,
0.0120503223,
0.0210783947,
-0.0009395686,
-0.0052406518,
-0.0295056775,
0.0781053528,
-0.0102310134,
-0.0208450817,
-0.0405598916,
0.0245522428,
0.0358843543,
0.0007519113,
0.0814106464,
0.0178543106,
-0.014005024,
0.0533740744,
0.0009577478,
-0.0023609789,
-0.0324329995,
-0.0372575633,
-0.0244212374,
0.0428562723,
0.0668147653,
0.0691098124,
0.0003626595,
0.0252247788,
-0.0492248088,
0.0399558209,
0.0200637281,
0.0414064117,
0.0298991296,
0.0128544914,
-0.0709591061,
-0.0218942892,
-0.037985187,
-0.0134636145,
-0.0264962874,
-0.0145100998,
-0.0011522023,
-0.006961057,
0.0006291236,
-0.0222718734,
-0.005360031,
-0.0059169265,
-0.0374300964,
-0.0336650386,
0.013450888,
0.0257957634,
0.0011551796,
0.0360003375,
-0.0239697229,
0.0198083557,
-0.0115398215,
-0.0007183405,
0.0179481059,
0.0345846564,
-0.0072028334,
0.0239925347,
-0.0686898232,
0.0037501084,
-0.0247309692,
0.0259395149,
0.0255144276,
-0.0452895425,
0.0302536096,
-0.0172486436,
-0.0144134657,
0.018356476,
-0.0444089435,
-0.0069193719,
-0.0123913065,
0.0208511744,
-0.0054911049,
-0.0142020164,
-0.0076166554,
-0.0221992675,
-0.0037187908,
-0.0256275758,
0.019269444,
0.0136411479,
-0.0080548124,
-0.0182197355,
2.782e-7,
0.0375580527,
0.0065118177,
0.0002164268,
0.0547288284,
0.0020596019,
0.0561528392,
-0.02086992,
-0.0118407374,
0.0603420772,
-0.0723604858,
-0.0010953045,
0.0280669574,
0.0671441704,
0.0662418529,
-0.0331651643,
-0.065400131,
-0.0326045416,
0.0110123204,
0.0033952747,
0.0345592909,
0.0846221447,
0.0303341392,
0.0056734979,
-0.0252510719,
-0.0295378957,
-0.0142866485,
0.0403483137,
-0.0643126741,
-0.0232136752,
0.0335381366,
0.0679727942,
0.0028208534,
0.0158609562,
0.0461316891,
0.0068920213,
-0.0293802079,
-0.0461094044,
0.0606980026,
0.0212590806,
-0.0287181959,
-0.0109594492,
-0.0270152222,
0.0302767102,
-0.0303826258,
0.0351822563,
-0.0551651455,
-0.0434299484,
-0.0275552012,
0.0338050425,
-0.0748192146,
0.0672094226,
-0.0292781666,
0.0037207897,
0.0046732659,
-0.0080220355,
0.0204701405,
-0.0159558654,
-0.0215520281,
-0.0390043296,
-0.000944576,
-0.0095623881,
-0.0916381478,
-0.0217019469,
-0.0130213704,
-0.0132598309,
-0.1010095477,
0.0193208978,
2.553752753e-34,
0.0334659331,
-0.0001417863,
0.0212607663,
0.056883581,
0.0449717119,
0.0110692205,
0.0193456803,
0.0197122786,
0.0484074727,
-0.040102385,
-0.018385442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13062v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13062v1 | Named entity recognition in resumes | 2023-06-22T17:30:37 | 2023-06-22T17:30:37 | Ege Kesim, Aysu Deliahmetoglu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named entity recognition (NER) is used to extract information from various
documents and texts such as names and dates. It is important to extract
education and work experience information from resumes in order to filter them.
Considering the fact that all information in a resume has to be entered to the
companys system manually, automatizing this process will save time of the
companies. In this study, a deep learning-based semi-automatic named entity
recognition system has been implemented with a focus on resumes in the field of
IT. Firstly, resumes of employees from five different IT related fields has
been annotated. Six transformer based pre-trained models have been adapted to
named entity recognition problem using the annotated data. These models have
been selected among popular models in the natural language processing field.
The obtained system can recognize eight different entity types which are city,
date, degree, diploma major, job title, language, country and skill. Models
used in the experiments are compared using micro, macro and weighted F1 scores
and the performance of the methods was evaluated. Taking these scores into
account for test set the best micro and weighted F1 score is obtained by
RoBERTa and the best macro F1 score is obtained by Electra model. | [
0.0287438463,
-0.0096444655,
0.0168839768,
0.0061321817,
-0.0116845826,
0.0384275429,
0.0195717942,
0.0099463649,
0.0132572213,
-0.0522068441,
-0.0046973247,
-0.0073252781,
0.0014523534,
0.0009475329,
-0.0024505756,
-0.0208562445,
-0.0038076243,
0.0248592105,
-0.0207270533,
0.0317979753,
-0.0455762222,
0.01354477,
-0.0159180872,
0.0391557477,
-0.0024409934,
0.0032930837,
0.0021311569,
0.022542024,
0.0389291234,
-0.0087372931,
0.022534715,
0.0191028807,
-0.0183036271,
0.027562568,
0.0000020507,
-0.0483848602,
-0.0740222409,
0.0142723657,
-0.0482299253,
-0.0497546569,
0.0438683331,
0.0193487573,
-0.0258665103,
0.0033054641,
-0.0072996449,
-0.0171706211,
0.0049148099,
0.0857125521,
0.0191222243,
0.067340441,
-0.0177364685,
-0.0553132482,
0.043885354,
0.0128739988,
-0.0391200557,
-0.0328862295,
0.0552208275,
-0.0361933485,
-0.0240097381,
0.006094622,
0.0205581561,
0.0014295608,
-0.0231971219,
-0.0088303043,
0.0119039016,
0.0196938012,
-0.0146454545,
0.0024381874,
-0.0108806742,
0.0490374938,
-0.0554660335,
0.0050812447,
0.0114880139,
-0.0597963259,
-0.0125308177,
-0.0144264307,
-0.0043165409,
0.0005334646,
-0.0384332389,
-0.0231189467,
-0.0101432996,
0.0328958035,
0.0009133229,
-0.0072185942,
-0.0150523353,
0.02995467,
-0.0082963007,
-0.0391459242,
0.050906267,
-0.0249846578,
0.0635250583,
-0.0400365293,
0.0615329295,
0.0350444056,
0.0481873229,
-0.0063043083,
-0.0127302101,
-0.0522186011,
0.021002965,
-0.0386969559,
-0.0270578749,
-0.0219736136,
-0.0199212804,
0.0625301376,
-0.0740474388,
0.0524127893,
-0.0116775734,
0.0010061768,
0.0325013883,
-0.0409496427,
-0.0610067435,
-0.0224546194,
-0.0451076105,
0.0469874144,
-0.0160769895,
0.0168090817,
-0.0537651889,
-0.0275368504,
0.0106933014,
0.0077828439,
0.054529909,
0.0110304356,
0.0047286679,
0.0064534652,
-0.0460357107,
0.0108662918,
0.0201451126,
-0.0077355597,
-0.0113632344,
-0.0487741642,
0.0612068847,
-0.0231834706,
0.08374957,
-0.0349388681,
0.0371386856,
0.0188353695,
0.0632498935,
-0.0765439421,
-0.072666429,
0.0005888014,
0.0169535205,
-0.0260085184,
0.0052028294,
-0.0291305259,
0.0113527253,
-0.0027516023,
-0.0191259775,
-0.0414875671,
0.0105770128,
-0.0026366527,
-0.0129990913,
0.0579453446,
-0.0334179513,
-0.0100269523,
0.0819198266,
-0.0365759768,
0.0378476009,
-0.0222054757,
0.0430263244,
0.0734693557,
0.0156277567,
-0.0442945473,
0.0367426053,
0.0521011688,
-0.0349051617,
-0.0924266726,
0.0334922001,
0.0073598903,
-0.0327146314,
-0.0017555859,
-0.0057105334,
0.0263394844,
-0.004829634,
0.0420263894,
0.019225752,
0.0238979999,
0.0651360899,
0.0348291248,
0.0443829224,
0.0332569964,
0.0186183788,
-0.0377356037,
0.0031415625,
0.0088199321,
-0.0090705464,
0.0004728489,
-0.0501415133,
0.0479420498,
-0.0450250767,
-0.0096347332,
0.0064266259,
-0.0366356783,
-0.0374581255,
-0.0019511122,
0.0693594217,
0.0149170859,
-0.108987622,
0.0175738018,
0.00747826,
-0.0189281013,
0.0168097652,
-0.0174937341,
-0.0051826159,
0.0726075992,
0.0286366306,
-0.033737544,
-0.0306440871,
-0.0529614203,
-0.0225575622,
0.016121719,
0.0388390496,
-0.0041211308,
0.006959287,
-0.0515371077,
-0.0354332291,
0.0244955663,
-0.0196629521,
0.0378433466,
-0.0043078782,
0.0563151576,
0.0441985503,
-0.0215425696,
-0.0481596962,
0.0384381339,
-0.0062173265,
-0.0512173809,
0.0285726599,
0.0587788746,
-0.0359296091,
0.0447848849,
-0.0091051133,
-0.0221860558,
0.0262171589,
-0.0091118105,
-0.030680595,
-0.0160703547,
-0.0065107555,
-0.0005086268,
-0.0392868444,
-0.013353847,
-0.016414538,
0.0354771353,
-0.0247747116,
-0.0424973555,
-0.0693842992,
0.0379354693,
-0.0017423811,
-0.0373911411,
0.0503608994,
-0.0199964084,
0.0387773588,
-0.0588383153,
0.0479805917,
0.02643691,
0.0269391406,
-0.0072131311,
-0.0273400899,
0.0281518269,
-0.0767679513,
-0.0570990853,
0.0047520907,
-0.0343704596,
0.0029168148,
0.0073610265,
-0.0118076904,
-0.0384289362,
-0.0399361402,
-0.0598572567,
0.005990488,
0.0037226202,
0.0294368044,
-0.0046564681,
0.0240775254,
-0.026321603,
-0.0267646052,
-0.0066213165,
0.0247793179,
-0.0198220015,
-0.0492873825,
0.0649237782,
-0.0050711506,
0.0026071912,
-0.0129168192,
-0.0172559898,
-0.05008737,
0.0436012,
0.0701287463,
-0.0317263976,
-0.0261111706,
0.0255538728,
0.0140741048,
0.0261262655,
0.0270825867,
0.0210884418,
-0.0206242595,
0.0400181524,
0.0391684957,
0.0773059353,
-0.0014193676,
0.0091511458,
-0.0429746248,
0.0177652277,
-0.0200866871,
0.0134704988,
-0.0288541857,
0.0620123856,
-0.0061386349,
-0.0273788515,
0.0182925239,
0.0137197739,
-0.0146343401,
0.0186061375,
0.0094541069,
-0.0063009043,
-0.0196763873,
0.0001127632,
-0.0026894566,
0.0446299575,
-0.0253722761,
-0.0197957829,
0.0138367955,
0.0341329314,
0.0262670424,
-0.0472771563,
-0.0031901519,
-0.0077023166,
-0.025425138,
-0.0425763056,
0.0241823401,
0.0085974745,
0.0068650525,
-0.0022712171,
-0.1096157655,
0.0055159889,
0.0111506172,
-0.011236582,
-0.031525556,
-0.0317455083,
0.0657181144,
0.0002951926,
-0.0436830521,
0.0246472992,
-0.0634281337,
-0.0298271514,
-0.0284326728,
0.0536426343,
0.0194697082,
0.0125274062,
-0.0353828147,
0.0606160313,
0.0059604556,
0.0670935661,
0.0059583741,
-0.0051167575,
-0.032991685,
0.061707966,
0.0579683706,
0.0183960181,
0.0194210839,
0.0238148402,
0.0056067565,
-0.0355001055,
-0.0323701315,
0.0223786496,
-0.0495880879,
-0.0347942375,
-0.0105382856,
-0.1095786244,
0.016102368,
-0.0204835963,
-0.0120546492,
-0.0418601148,
0.0296284072,
0.0835481808,
-0.0033014617,
-0.015618857,
-0.0390000902,
0.0236676298,
-0.0843632072,
0.0112484731,
0.0332790315,
-0.0272634178,
-0.0042626159,
-0.0022412341,
-0.0249845162,
0.0177096054,
-0.0466615036,
0.0316546299,
-0.0730782822,
0.0052138576,
-0.0662661269,
-0.0344377719,
-0.0144928917,
-0.0443082079,
-0.0044068978,
-0.0242797993,
0.0044358671,
-0.0433592163,
-0.0426069163,
-0.032463979,
0.0573835447,
-0.0170585848,
-0.0494685546,
0.0088603916,
-0.0517813154,
0.0008682729,
0.0313578993,
0.0566853881,
-0.0609519705,
-0.0250583384,
-0.0293580275,
-0.0058680405,
-0.0048505552,
0.0058393795,
0.035224326,
-0.0525703095,
-0.0150679965,
-0.0121669341,
-0.0326521173,
-0.0245907139,
0.0247524623,
0.0089753997,
0.0383178443,
-0.0052643744,
-0.0036198362,
-0.0203946847,
-0.043966759,
0.0202935189,
0.063906908,
-0.0124318115,
-0.0726876184,
-0.0153859928,
0.0364224911,
0.0117608067,
-0.0320712291,
-0.0099160112,
0.043034099,
-0.0405329429,
-0.0304663237,
-0.0245150141,
-0.0301459152,
0.0378779992,
0.0230512768,
0.0209665988,
0.0045589837,
0.0425119512,
0.0159483738,
-0.0759435222,
0.010577918,
-0.0232172608,
0.0290802456,
-0.0784312487,
0.0228089616,
0.0132603375,
-0.011292642,
-0.0650394484,
-0.03407906,
-0.0298390128,
0.0101751043,
-0.0028080456,
-0.0023158425,
0.0045946497,
-0.0179626308,
-0.0107595809,
-0.0551080331,
0.0823042765,
0.0443957895,
0.0030568861,
-0.0633748323,
-0.0026844805,
-0.0260267816,
-0.0486270525,
-0.0039585838,
-0.0211510062,
0.0265194252,
0.0392207168,
-0.0220486242,
0.0423460342,
-0.0447318442,
-0.0103400182,
0.0216792282,
0.0448777862,
0.0160315894,
-0.0393775553,
-0.0692044795,
0.0257802587,
0.0393468291,
0.0326541848,
0.0169671364,
-0.0197847895,
0.0560149327,
0.0286772251,
0.0020767474,
0.0130499946,
0.0138906455,
-0.003959239,
-0.0499716066,
0.0602459088,
-0.0361287817,
0.0969644785,
-0.0250188857,
-0.0225910805,
0.0068277088,
0.0036812876,
0.0703980401,
0.0435662456,
-0.0054077483,
-0.0219307318,
-0.0336563066,
0.0389536694,
-0.0078421971,
0.044557184,
0.0109801525,
0.0132793048,
-0.0421579257,
0.0392014645,
0.0576825812,
-0.0329919793,
0.0040828828,
0.0134116365,
0.007522353,
-0.0111619988,
-0.0046028611,
0.0176263582,
0.0106115676,
0.0107656308,
-0.0093039544,
-0.0200720914,
0.0112192966,
0.0121393697,
0.0355558991,
-0.0074968347,
0.0163787771,
-0.0063284785,
-0.0555497259,
0.0236175098,
0.0455267839,
0.0017493868,
-0.0519668497,
0.0098534664,
-0.0129348421,
-0.0208457876,
0.0611135438,
-0.0206392184,
-0.0109861987,
0.0145812454,
0.0305622071,
-0.0003717313,
0.0065685897,
-0.0077226195,
-0.0293769073,
0.0292921811,
0.0015779771,
-0.0027183723,
-0.0310385432,
-5.811327789e-33,
-0.0171084628,
-0.0424119495,
0.0267182812,
0.0426909663,
0.0086547583,
0.0381170586,
0.0093064075,
-0.0306676906,
-0.0193295591,
-0.035987962,
-0.0295129269,
-0.0041011353,
0.0545642823,
0.0177983325,
-0.0355233178,
-0.0021172119,
0.0378186777,
0.0316114649,
-0.0141560361,
-0.0000846222,
-0.00600371,
0.0925460532,
0.1173574179,
-0.0776483044,
-0.0024843591,
-0.0112269595,
0.0173855778,
-0.0241573974,
0.0601137578,
0.0601432584,
-0.0280840173,
-0.0082993424,
0.0166859105,
-0.0869770125,
0.0372111611,
0.033023499,
-0.1108490154,
0.0202039648,
-0.0430650897,
0.0916205421,
0.0358940437,
-0.0211076383,
0.0680296645,
-0.0214655548,
-0.0169737898,
0.0333893113,
0.0764003396,
0.0258047283,
0.0057614101,
-0.052060131,
-0.0562293679,
0.0291766003,
0.0140502108,
0.0270306449,
0.0447943024,
-0.006874633,
0.0245966557,
0.0383420996,
-0.1196191758,
-0.0219218656,
0.0241400506,
-0.0067634452,
0.0223879479,
0.0115105668,
-0.0130395526,
0.0181193221,
0.0546918586,
0.0333741084,
-0.0157047622,
-0.0111174816,
0.0435363986,
0.039682135,
-0.0136044584,
0.0132466014,
0.0407927334,
-0.0641152635,
-0.0562439598,
0.0522177927,
-0.0148612065,
0.0099983476,
0.0060825213,
-0.0332707576,
-0.0556555912,
0.0498086028,
0.0117697008,
-0.0284651369,
-0.0258154385,
0.0066287732,
0.0325708613,
0.0136646451,
-0.043979276,
0.0604663119,
0.001657292,
-0.0507454164,
-0.0350557938,
0.0074337106,
0.0162601005,
0.036684569,
-0.0348546579,
-0.002605055,
-0.0417111814,
-0.0707508996,
0.000530071,
-0.0084199617,
0.0238470808,
0.0219707973,
0.0334518775,
-0.0014330896,
-0.0624112561,
-0.0061358078,
0.0275632404,
0.0034654725,
-0.0124219973,
0.0619995482,
-0.0056683086,
-0.0169379227,
0.0032628765,
-0.0031626814,
0.0510894768,
0.0192085151,
0.0033453896,
-0.0445715562,
0.0870985761,
0.0495083183,
-0.0227357745,
-0.0308420565,
-0.0258871298,
0.0178602263,
0.008113049,
-0.0270030368,
0.0156434104,
0.0098626763,
2.619e-7,
0.024513809,
0.0238683838,
0.0122394226,
-0.0424539894,
-0.0151531296,
-0.0042799492,
0.0551170744,
0.0256850272,
-0.0082340343,
0.0684313178,
0.017442748,
-0.0406284146,
0.0123409675,
-0.0253494289,
-0.1265422851,
-0.0590301938,
-0.0020787332,
-0.0048444849,
-0.0650235265,
0.0438398011,
0.0415396467,
0.0579174459,
0.0288778637,
-0.0349376909,
-0.0247990955,
0.0049365708,
0.0160520785,
0.015640635,
0.0595485158,
0.0420909449,
0.0749190673,
0.0722434595,
-0.0232981704,
0.0445767418,
0.0138424905,
0.0490819588,
0.0423977077,
0.0370904356,
-0.042994231,
0.0279755555,
0.0304431953,
-0.0429609492,
-0.0116427196,
-0.024056809,
0.0525150336,
-0.0483773686,
-0.0250720549,
0.0158991348,
-0.0437512845,
0.0061104884,
0.010817267,
0.0221900959,
0.0009715536,
-0.0082589053,
0.050182689,
-0.0505474508,
-0.03707394,
-0.0386418104,
0.0592932068,
0.0119020492,
0.0057140682,
0.0094445301,
0.0010488839,
-0.0543739349,
0.0458124354,
-0.0024256266,
0.0123052923,
2.168451878e-34,
-0.0094073182,
0.0298802461,
-0.0094820503,
0.015390154,
-0.0048675085,
0.0056408914,
0.021697823,
-0.0060092215,
-0.0591254383,
-0.0396617204,
-0.0058549703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13047v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13047v4 | Analysis of the Cambridge Multiple-Choice Questions Reading Dataset with a Focus on Candidate Response Distribution | 2023-06-22T17:13:08 | 2023-10-15T20:58:26 | Adian Liusie, Vatsal Raina, Andrew Mullooly, Kate Knill, Mark J. F. Gales | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multiple choice exams are widely used to assess candidates across a diverse
range of domains and tasks. To moderate question quality, newly proposed
questions often pass through pre-test evaluation stages before being deployed
into real-world exams. Currently, this evaluation process is manually
intensive, which can lead to time lags in the question development cycle.
Streamlining this process via automation can significantly enhance efficiency,
however, there's a current lack of datasets with adequate pre-test analysis
information. In this paper we analyse a subset of the public Cambridge
Multiple-Choice Questions Reading Database released by Cambridge University
Press & Assessment; a multiple-choice comprehension dataset of questions at
different target levels, with corresponding candidate selection distributions.
We introduce the task of candidate distribution matching, propose several
evaluation metrics for the task, and demonstrate that automatic systems trained
on RACE++ can be leveraged as baselines for our task. We further demonstrate
that these automatic systems can be used for practical pre-test evaluation
tasks such as detecting underperforming distractors, where our detection
systems can automatically identify poor distractors that few candidates select. | [
-0.0129685421,
0.008151127,
-0.0436486304,
0.0160422325,
-0.0254511833,
0.0320662148,
0.0180750899,
0.0128963962,
0.0364079103,
-0.0505599901,
0.0168136396,
-0.0110211223,
-0.0458362103,
-0.0230827704,
0.0196438059,
-0.0585124753,
0.0053135827,
0.0115518188,
-0.0282214396,
0.0063418383,
-0.0155691626,
-0.0104390373,
-0.0112017421,
0.0060774083,
0.0278658997,
-0.020165965,
0.0050472426,
-0.0070108124,
0.0493616201,
-0.0172899012,
0.0163877793,
0.077335462,
-0.0230348893,
0.0004375933,
0.0000020439,
-0.0609727092,
-0.0168366283,
-0.0279061496,
-0.0256723948,
-0.0059835459,
0.0340246297,
0.064758338,
0.0179070327,
0.0164025072,
-0.0489151515,
0.0168307833,
0.0247763004,
-0.0532121584,
0.0645933673,
0.0320254341,
0.0248045307,
0.0365826674,
0.0262248274,
0.0042464933,
0.0219342522,
-0.062898308,
0.0134790419,
-0.0039136168,
0.0059579927,
0.0344489142,
-0.0563455112,
0.0104015227,
0.0025984934,
0.0247725472,
0.0286940895,
-0.0125369513,
-0.0221823063,
0.0038547399,
-0.0162587427,
0.0586847365,
-0.0269487575,
0.0008241834,
-0.0191807915,
-0.034396857,
-0.0014094067,
0.0341524519,
-0.0058546695,
-0.0058893035,
-0.0503296182,
-0.0254911073,
0.010358531,
-0.0293729436,
-0.0294261612,
0.012481343,
0.005131443,
0.0489877164,
0.0278952513,
-0.0423722155,
0.0386796743,
0.0389904827,
0.0452275984,
-0.0359153301,
0.0660357475,
-0.004989991,
-0.027098557,
0.011656723,
0.0046964446,
-0.0671514645,
0.0298929047,
0.0082518766,
0.0134698302,
0.0442879759,
-0.0371998437,
0.0432209931,
0.0163698085,
0.0579784624,
0.019071376,
0.0531735905,
-0.0633679628,
-0.0019809289,
-0.0148946149,
0.0133306915,
0.008309627,
-0.0081083523,
-0.0171514601,
0.0224313028,
-0.061023131,
0.0120530939,
-0.0252695139,
-0.0126738381,
0.0033789789,
-0.0043584928,
-0.0278075635,
0.0465299115,
-0.0655680969,
0.0223722067,
-0.0366578773,
-0.0170475505,
-0.006208729,
-0.0011329188,
0.0150278332,
0.0393128209,
0.0053521842,
-0.052698575,
0.0053859414,
0.0498877689,
-0.0021572476,
-0.0275918338,
-0.0145366956,
0.0107533904,
0.0239195041,
-0.0031055843,
-0.0004513378,
-0.0263183601,
0.0160838049,
0.0101752197,
-0.0128489546,
-0.0033154781,
-0.0160219595,
0.0604093149,
0.0399390981,
0.037674576,
0.0361979939,
-0.0088800089,
0.0333694592,
0.0203345045,
-0.0289040487,
0.0484713241,
0.0059092916,
0.0067779664,
0.0590706542,
-0.0755401626,
0.0310992859,
0.0351739638,
-0.021139821,
-0.0060596969,
0.0436526164,
0.0665216222,
0.0222729128,
0.0072640367,
0.0381265543,
-0.0143177686,
0.0169344898,
-0.0525189489,
0.0263913907,
0.0548953414,
0.0520512015,
-0.0173534788,
0.0340617076,
0.0147574395,
-0.0025142832,
0.0636521354,
-0.035289336,
-0.010535147,
-0.0263468716,
-0.0058705709,
0.0110824751,
0.0422175974,
-0.0093964841,
-0.0368121341,
0.0277513079,
0.0386977233,
0.0076730498,
0.0631466657,
0.0693791881,
-0.0320094414,
-0.0565519072,
-0.0171408132,
0.0036678328,
-0.0314804204,
0.040731132,
-0.0587664843,
0.0323768705,
0.0220920965,
0.0196386706,
-0.0784645379,
-0.047873348,
0.0047083404,
-0.0074553397,
0.0146035198,
0.0491720475,
-0.0539993718,
0.0311604552,
-0.0480765067,
-0.0436467528,
0.0648074001,
0.0068891407,
0.0140548982,
0.0136904102,
0.0360279344,
-0.0014356863,
-0.0391577221,
-0.0362781957,
0.0606755689,
-0.0074056918,
-0.0445242636,
0.00522677,
0.0110949147,
0.0353808142,
0.000851745,
0.0041068462,
-0.0302107241,
-0.005033948,
0.005285874,
0.0542540699,
-0.0489914194,
-0.0467379391,
0.0190529693,
0.0471325964,
-0.0399903208,
-0.0349422656,
0.1094771922,
-0.0295756087,
-0.0166736525,
0.0192149878,
-0.0078937653,
-0.0672569126,
-0.0154475868,
0.0195136443,
-0.0252568871,
-0.0142432619,
-0.072943382,
0.0756299496,
0.0461835936,
0.0607231036,
0.0087740626,
0.0150064565,
0.0230373126,
-0.0646709874,
-0.002024729,
-0.0441705324,
-0.0066192155,
0.0406305194,
0.0215103365,
0.0168651659,
-0.101074025,
0.0071512144,
-0.0360537134,
0.0702353641,
-0.0069601047,
0.0256838519,
0.0266072266,
-0.0306071285,
-0.0155239301,
-0.0123088704,
-0.0157593414,
0.0050226934,
0.0135145774,
-0.0088636316,
0.0092152813,
-0.0049408842,
0.0188928749,
-0.0131868487,
-0.0370535441,
-0.0578588955,
0.0151863014,
0.0512762964,
0.0559451282,
-0.0299262963,
0.0410733409,
0.0136168227,
-0.0144379213,
0.0107585834,
0.0048470353,
0.0229103193,
-0.0017521544,
0.0281860512,
0.0901309326,
0.0107070357,
0.0061030891,
0.0029187892,
-0.0101540266,
-0.0480702966,
0.0316080153,
-0.0057060183,
0.0191782173,
-0.0235875566,
-0.0346645974,
0.0128867989,
0.0371740349,
0.0416727774,
-0.0578114167,
-0.0184928514,
0.0293914564,
-0.0490645207,
-0.0047965404,
-0.0918627679,
0.0075130686,
-0.0138422996,
0.0541370995,
-0.0274481662,
-0.0232943948,
0.0845994726,
-0.0246249903,
0.0171478242,
-0.0892897099,
0.0268660281,
-0.0157835148,
0.0263457093,
0.0158005431,
-0.0139784785,
-0.0274430029,
-0.0155419866,
-0.067303732,
0.0037445826,
0.0058657574,
-0.0504884012,
0.0592776015,
-0.0403442979,
-0.0504821613,
-0.0207170602,
-0.0215708259,
-0.02731614,
-0.0336875468,
0.0235561077,
-0.0302517619,
-0.0027173667,
-0.0109049631,
-0.0367091373,
-0.0226791725,
-0.0095382603,
0.0293040778,
-0.0209983066,
-0.0056905537,
0.0012319467,
0.0743481815,
0.0147530194,
0.0392397828,
0.0349923074,
-0.0538578145,
-0.0054945596,
0.060594622,
0.0332559831,
0.0027285207,
0.0235046037,
0.0153698241,
0.0341000147,
-0.09773013,
0.0253164954,
0.0098028919,
0.060290426,
-0.0494596623,
0.0187739525,
0.0550410673,
0.0271658767,
-0.0219131336,
-0.0158907343,
-0.016341811,
-0.0208435003,
0.0221890341,
0.0237142108,
-0.066067189,
-0.0034272771,
-0.0034749024,
0.0659799874,
-0.0259067658,
-0.0316523202,
0.0149131259,
-0.091704689,
0.0309658758,
-0.0139045073,
-0.0783331171,
0.0188929997,
-0.0382209867,
0.0276731048,
-0.0369124338,
0.0040195822,
-0.0000425203,
0.0440002084,
0.0191633273,
0.0118418429,
-0.0136540588,
-0.034540005,
0.0353817679,
-0.0356826968,
-0.0034863451,
0.030336516,
0.0266972706,
-0.0072920872,
-0.0085247345,
0.0146369617,
-0.1392463297,
-0.0376739018,
0.001012837,
0.0530851297,
-0.0190397557,
0.0141823934,
-0.0701349378,
0.0467973277,
-0.0224719308,
0.0307732131,
0.0830892771,
0.0697204992,
0.0283231176,
-0.0455680341,
-0.0643049255,
0.0020446442,
0.0466193035,
0.0406082273,
0.0309686437,
-0.0938976407,
0.025504116,
-0.0461203344,
0.044624012,
-0.0791218355,
-0.021532096,
0.0478538796,
-0.0147347543,
-0.0002679431,
-0.0173923876,
-0.0808903277,
0.050255511,
-0.0073091458,
0.0152404765,
-0.0059014382,
0.0078690313,
-0.0240615383,
-0.0381192863,
0.070214808,
-0.0049072984,
0.0124694435,
-0.0221886672,
-0.0642398894,
-0.015400717,
-0.003579939,
-0.05381139,
0.0324816257,
-0.0658442527,
-0.0002627619,
0.0174347367,
0.0351489298,
0.0170440841,
-0.026388675,
-0.0251585115,
-0.0237674005,
-0.0215700064,
-0.0350428484,
-0.021470964,
-0.0010667157,
-0.0457033105,
-0.063259311,
-0.0470200889,
-0.0236848798,
0.0047515524,
0.0387844481,
0.0624932237,
-0.0141619388,
-0.0267635714,
-0.0301059149,
0.0067820214,
0.0202116631,
0.0188784115,
0.0120144514,
-0.0327517875,
-0.0626773909,
0.0010919468,
0.0107739931,
-0.0233982243,
0.0192224383,
-0.0400178507,
0.0271553881,
-0.0369102694,
-0.0389438346,
-0.0419075638,
-0.0420551561,
0.0188693851,
-0.07985764,
0.0667479187,
0.0715754181,
0.0415751711,
0.0149269365,
-0.014179687,
-0.0208300315,
-0.0055366796,
-0.0015360547,
0.0939352587,
0.0407068692,
0.0522115491,
-0.0007377348,
-0.0136663951,
0.0765164122,
-0.0203735698,
-0.0408855192,
0.0215910133,
-0.0006062189,
0.0264536962,
-0.0012815284,
-0.0108552678,
-0.0271496698,
0.0273070503,
-0.0058677341,
-0.0295843594,
-0.0009281193,
0.0305586588,
0.0168689266,
0.0262472797,
0.0245715659,
0.036034923,
-0.0052395812,
0.0466649868,
-0.0111564994,
-0.0131494282,
0.0368689708,
-0.0204473715,
-0.0527912602,
0.0056807594,
-0.0016872279,
0.064159967,
0.0089808078,
0.0152026201,
-0.0565918498,
-0.0470831767,
0.0418187752,
0.0355067179,
0.0333597064,
0.0196962804,
-0.0016170283,
0.0621636733,
-0.0524218865,
-0.0264847651,
-0.0183199905,
0.0398435108,
-0.0889101475,
-0.036077369,
-0.0122185005,
-5.720292364e-33,
-0.0389760248,
-0.0425147004,
0.0107891196,
-0.076308988,
0.009568085,
-0.0105180722,
0.0018558897,
-0.0265680216,
-0.0108312424,
-0.0366914943,
-0.0317829475,
0.0129102925,
-0.0052241576,
0.0461094342,
0.0006994788,
-0.024865713,
0.0004435019,
0.0128475716,
-0.039677307,
0.0338894427,
0.0072801178,
0.0112909982,
0.0380146168,
-0.0303199645,
0.012788075,
-0.0268244799,
0.0189254526,
0.0072311377,
-0.0065561202,
0.0392782986,
-0.0167153925,
0.0747371614,
0.0433500633,
-0.0505223311,
0.025478391,
0.0522789396,
-0.0448086597,
-0.0306026582,
-0.0229668953,
0.0407778732,
-0.0025628055,
-0.0210217219,
0.0241521187,
0.014746788,
-0.0032709467,
-0.0683562756,
0.0782995149,
-0.0348769315,
0.0178554785,
0.002470769,
-0.03552204,
0.0299012698,
-0.0599480495,
0.0151961893,
-0.0274347365,
0.0628757253,
0.0258442312,
0.0269362405,
-0.0463984683,
0.0086919675,
0.017000936,
0.0189456884,
0.0291806739,
0.0306785926,
-0.0139361145,
0.0495084487,
-0.0049518514,
-0.0081283087,
0.0234347694,
-0.0552480072,
0.0338052139,
-0.0334275514,
0.052535478,
0.0474164151,
0.0473125577,
0.0067841802,
-0.0848615393,
0.0853377581,
0.0230135676,
-0.0348568372,
-0.0212848913,
-0.0282245632,
-0.058597181,
-0.0024653319,
-0.0296260975,
-0.0134640988,
-0.0316952504,
-0.0279281121,
0.0792886093,
-0.0573887937,
-0.0381736346,
0.0374846384,
0.0197626166,
-0.0232054889,
0.017806353,
-0.0135235665,
-0.0061454261,
0.0330966674,
-0.027585756,
0.0260471068,
-0.017768506,
0.0162688624,
-0.0064017912,
-0.0059125358,
0.044070065,
-0.0035156908,
-0.0506875217,
-0.008429422,
-0.0434113741,
0.0114571992,
-0.0104788896,
0.0062491936,
0.0114180716,
0.09343604,
0.0293925907,
0.0459732749,
0.0180648528,
0.0264110155,
0.0206971448,
-0.0172849651,
-0.0293347593,
-0.0262566134,
-0.0022164397,
-0.0048086941,
0.0098746689,
-0.038451273,
-0.0059815906,
-0.0090570459,
-0.0092249047,
-0.0620419234,
0.0145730618,
-0.0049532359,
2.509e-7,
0.0375117995,
0.0304652285,
-0.0289298743,
-0.0076885973,
-0.0276021957,
0.0025924051,
0.0110239806,
0.0259851534,
0.0670885518,
-0.0097777927,
-0.0035911608,
0.0139898909,
-0.0078761401,
0.0291693788,
-0.0856512859,
-0.0504403412,
0.0139182406,
0.0342761353,
-0.0472432077,
0.0505483374,
0.0532736592,
0.0788217038,
0.0147930812,
-0.0303290896,
-0.0137127163,
-0.019309815,
-0.0315518081,
-0.0153015954,
0.0017221356,
0.0495702662,
0.0370763317,
-0.0400964133,
-0.0042384262,
0.1039248854,
-0.0257279705,
-0.0096500851,
0.0212144889,
0.0102019636,
0.0165188015,
0.0010958601,
-0.0258450788,
0.0261073131,
0.0140376743,
-0.0593171529,
0.0374933146,
0.0071476889,
-0.0107434597,
-0.0058878013,
-0.0763639808,
-0.0503679737,
-0.0014550225,
0.0075381002,
0.0208623447,
-0.0099623753,
0.0087969508,
-0.0385723971,
0.042649921,
-0.0372752808,
0.0067415782,
0.0058306335,
-0.0081365844,
-0.0736126527,
-0.0153451758,
-0.0319199078,
0.0295386333,
-0.0750601441,
0.0018106619,
1.844729687e-34,
0.009671675,
0.0260931887,
0.0480837971,
-0.0442444757,
0.0220986623,
-0.0227680635,
0.0107038403,
-0.0184532534,
0.0301737189,
-0.0545319952,
-0.0036841426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13041v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13041v1 | Towards Explainable Evaluation Metrics for Machine Translation | 2023-06-22T17:07:57 | 2023-06-22T17:07:57 | Christoph Leiter, Piyawat Lertvittayakumjorn, Marina Fomicheva, Wei Zhao, Yang Gao, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Unlike classical lexical overlap metrics such as BLEU, most current
evaluation metrics for machine translation (for example, COMET or BERTScore)
are based on black-box large language models. They often achieve strong
correlations with human judgments, but recent research indicates that the
lower-quality classical metrics remain dominant, one of the potential reasons
being that their decision processes are more transparent. To foster more
widespread acceptance of novel high-quality metrics, explainability thus
becomes crucial. In this concept paper, we identify key properties as well as
key goals of explainable machine translation metrics and provide a
comprehensive synthesis of recent techniques, relating them to our established
goals and properties. In this context, we also discuss the latest
state-of-the-art approaches to explainable metrics based on generative models
such as ChatGPT and GPT4. Finally, we contribute a vision of next-generation
approaches, including natural language explanations. We hope that our work can
help catalyze and guide future research on explainable evaluation metrics and,
mediately, also contribute to better and more transparent machine translation
systems. | [
0.0139222778,
0.0476601198,
-0.0189503375,
0.0382826701,
-0.032821916,
0.0235445313,
0.0105051314,
0.0029083139,
-0.0440395549,
0.0044771405,
-0.0182694327,
-0.0253929552,
0.0392912254,
0.018768942,
0.01905993,
-0.077990666,
0.0096919602,
0.0197603032,
-0.0054777879,
0.0281718522,
0.0139315911,
0.0184495002,
-0.0003497724,
0.0783588588,
0.0364671052,
-0.0062553314,
0.0118315089,
0.0307256225,
0.0497243479,
0.0188583266,
-0.0463183299,
0.0075850249,
0.0187294576,
0.0705551654,
0.0000019394,
-0.036514122,
-0.0345589295,
0.0199486185,
-0.0092291953,
0.0201228634,
0.0117841335,
-0.0351609923,
0.0138067435,
0.0080460105,
-0.0215790644,
0.0048834179,
0.0667386353,
0.0133316424,
0.0562477186,
0.0619473234,
-0.0104416441,
-0.034511026,
-0.0314441659,
-0.029083617,
0.0114770923,
-0.043594487,
-0.057226602,
0.0316082425,
-0.037588276,
0.0091515528,
-0.0249498263,
0.0124175642,
0.0341387838,
-0.0359883755,
0.0131610073,
0.0067292186,
-0.0246560965,
-0.040689636,
0.0170279369,
0.0396279059,
-0.01939057,
-0.0253931098,
-0.011151324,
-0.0154137462,
0.0008678578,
-0.0086503401,
-0.0480014682,
-0.0249060504,
0.0157296639,
0.0239906218,
-0.0073569436,
0.0576025136,
0.0570891276,
0.0080003105,
-0.0241231509,
0.0429997668,
0.0228057057,
0.0012774694,
-0.0536786988,
0.0154708382,
-0.0429035462,
-0.0301388633,
0.0184947606,
0.0169035587,
-0.0258630626,
0.0157777984,
0.0260353051,
0.0043883407,
-0.0087761208,
-0.0229262058,
0.01404237,
0.0487643406,
-0.0145514309,
0.048421625,
0.0021084393,
0.1020281017,
-0.0258538462,
-0.0028100684,
-0.0587841868,
-0.0238569845,
-0.0608701184,
0.0054834555,
-0.0222774576,
-0.0574574955,
-0.0282068942,
-0.0129028363,
-0.0379374586,
0.0261467323,
-0.0408328772,
-0.0102263186,
0.0452097245,
-0.0255781449,
-0.0517830141,
-0.0365975164,
-0.0291054156,
0.0153185846,
-0.0491194427,
-0.018033348,
0.0159319546,
-0.0535589866,
-0.0309553985,
0.0359878168,
-0.0171783864,
-0.0140178232,
-0.0331075639,
0.0857464373,
0.0143304579,
-0.0090430882,
0.0294854417,
-0.0322678313,
-0.0505940244,
-0.065721266,
-0.0570268892,
-0.012772182,
0.0013986049,
0.0091650784,
0.0025298414,
-0.0169624053,
-0.0020193658,
-0.0226161033,
0.0127261104,
0.0704010651,
0.0022227496,
0.0107037602,
-0.0121984491,
0.0058470191,
-0.0382229462,
0.0253419876,
0.0555352792,
0.0217417926,
0.0481712781,
-0.0453945026,
0.0236755162,
0.0038218682,
0.0105726691,
-0.004362586,
-0.021451395,
-0.0210131686,
-0.0348254479,
0.0674126223,
0.0273461118,
0.0234555677,
-0.0376014896,
0.0223993473,
0.0669954196,
0.0177236535,
0.037137758,
0.049069833,
0.0656748489,
0.0024663059,
-0.0297474973,
0.0467979684,
0.0011681111,
0.0451557338,
-0.0063843732,
0.0114593916,
0.0539397746,
0.0185215045,
0.023742985,
-0.0869331062,
-0.0089883953,
0.0037471456,
-0.0113422377,
-0.0144668594,
0.0424146689,
0.010113379,
-0.0326665007,
0.0134584913,
-0.0190095659,
-0.0702564642,
0.0209656637,
-0.0671923608,
0.0148919942,
0.0705021992,
0.0702208057,
-0.0045134039,
-0.0162470248,
-0.0082128579,
-0.0320775025,
0.0310488883,
0.010442473,
0.0151464334,
0.0272928979,
-0.0398266278,
-0.0368298665,
-0.0234557819,
0.0293146744,
0.0071251593,
0.0143347792,
-0.0189658087,
0.041606456,
-0.1037792712,
-0.0662935451,
0.0200980473,
0.0226524975,
-0.0179960597,
0.011267609,
0.0110670961,
0.0656811595,
0.0431789942,
0.0025662358,
0.0289052743,
0.001863842,
-0.0280697811,
-0.0303970631,
0.0707679912,
0.0020974153,
-0.0262900535,
-0.0139257135,
-0.0603967234,
0.0157051943,
0.0233880766,
-0.0431190021,
-0.0584533252,
-0.000841716,
-0.0571984127,
0.0465802327,
-0.0460023358,
0.0329056568,
-0.0218804143,
0.005880916,
-0.0494744144,
0.0475477353,
0.0070572034,
0.0222313181,
-0.007384826,
0.0071652676,
0.0420023277,
0.0026995519,
0.004169724,
0.0225108936,
0.0035811586,
0.0147372978,
0.0669027343,
-0.0062044803,
-0.0292621553,
-0.046428185,
-0.0610551201,
0.0116217937,
-0.0299021639,
0.02716708,
0.0397159867,
0.0256839152,
0.016366588,
0.007315692,
-0.0364979282,
-0.0048468066,
0.0038385156,
0.0010617397,
0.0399636254,
-0.0097846566,
-0.0409863219,
-0.0184598938,
0.0073662736,
0.0131143248,
0.064118214,
0.0209671669,
0.0264105611,
-0.0810026526,
0.0184297524,
-0.0420252234,
-0.0471585914,
-0.0106527256,
-0.0802642703,
0.0435964465,
0.0108458707,
0.011385167,
0.0241020638,
0.0207154956,
0.0544015169,
0.0171915069,
0.0245027523,
-0.0328497924,
-0.0340951569,
-0.0729518384,
-0.0522040017,
0.0094872434,
-0.0593434609,
0.0209064297,
0.0589572638,
0.0032936076,
-0.0231791474,
-0.0744811147,
0.0210751966,
-0.0234874412,
-0.0264060274,
-0.0214531049,
-0.0131462729,
-0.0187609904,
0.0657011941,
-0.0294271074,
-0.0987225994,
0.0573453046,
-0.0690576509,
0.0039485623,
-0.028101936,
-0.0009674082,
-0.0515821688,
0.0830297768,
-0.0046720314,
0.0195518695,
-0.0352827385,
-0.0095099611,
-0.0006401166,
0.0181180593,
0.0578657798,
-0.0181195866,
0.0027814505,
-0.0534505025,
-0.0267148931,
0.0148088243,
0.0129691986,
0.0019813124,
-0.0022462113,
0.0160943083,
-0.0056075486,
0.0693086609,
-0.0532945395,
-0.0087480377,
0.0354053266,
0.020416148,
0.0245890897,
-0.0148896398,
-0.0025349509,
-0.0121856192,
0.0163985528,
-0.0080258735,
0.0090816393,
0.0526789576,
-0.032267347,
-0.0050167404,
0.0069174627,
0.0187313035,
-0.0123624336,
-0.0400437973,
-0.0176806021,
0.01637391,
-0.0107364589,
-0.0295338836,
0.0038399072,
0.0729254633,
-0.0572411492,
0.005261559,
0.1311697662,
0.0103417421,
-0.0130260941,
0.017333962,
-0.0152352313,
0.0269004349,
0.0090010585,
-0.0225087814,
-0.0090012299,
-0.0183018427,
-0.002388353,
0.020806307,
0.0160910599,
0.024522081,
-0.0232194327,
-0.0476362631,
0.0347118452,
0.0315769389,
-0.0450815186,
-0.0580290928,
-0.0276776422,
-0.0217737872,
-0.0366128311,
0.0052695652,
-0.0213908199,
0.0537853688,
0.036358539,
0.0399830863,
-0.0199707672,
-0.0429492593,
-0.0068311621,
-0.0366084725,
0.0268458035,
0.0936162099,
0.0722706541,
0.0178175885,
-0.0424378105,
-0.018585816,
-0.0285317004,
0.013173556,
0.0224850122,
0.0381532162,
0.028659502,
-0.0228684582,
-0.0180911738,
0.0200431384,
0.0050279684,
0.0070913564,
-0.0449158363,
0.0438460149,
-0.0241998658,
0.0018757108,
0.0104975412,
0.0039450703,
0.0226146802,
0.0878686607,
0.0569670796,
-0.0155548519,
-0.0182925425,
-0.0163693056,
0.0191855952,
-0.0542817526,
-0.0167913549,
-0.0139291035,
-0.0070815166,
-0.0791632608,
-0.0594680496,
-0.0409302823,
-0.0260413382,
0.0511490144,
0.0091903005,
0.0223719683,
-0.0319682322,
-0.0198801551,
-0.0142960092,
0.0527387485,
0.0083431974,
0.0031549132,
-0.0335107669,
-0.0205249134,
-0.0060211518,
-0.0250125043,
-0.0350795537,
0.0509040467,
-0.0344199203,
-0.0303348377,
-0.0205925032,
0.0241733212,
0.0355756208,
0.0205382984,
-0.0296056047,
-0.0365846679,
-0.0052872719,
-0.0046921177,
-0.00739684,
-0.0134888478,
0.0335416906,
0.0129228104,
-0.0024243819,
0.0617869757,
-0.0076685352,
-0.0146265924,
-0.0122440439,
0.0486064628,
-0.0044408664,
-0.0437688492,
0.0327794924,
-0.0088307504,
0.0588847734,
-0.0685654432,
-0.0318433084,
-0.0281637069,
-0.0313984901,
-0.0187723581,
-0.0162056237,
-0.0686487779,
-0.0154901668,
0.0656397268,
-0.0106539764,
-0.0215799026,
0.0041142129,
-0.0342334844,
-0.0297349673,
-0.0184819754,
-0.003266749,
-0.016359305,
0.0152177904,
-0.0319521539,
0.0319577046,
-0.0206817612,
0.0140451938,
-0.0382599458,
0.0215835348,
0.0024913514,
0.0788142681,
0.0247695222,
0.0420318805,
0.0375565216,
0.041183427,
-0.0609171018,
-0.0004578049,
-0.0140755381,
0.0216979999,
0.0561850555,
-0.0025306316,
0.12756522,
0.0125656426,
-0.0188567843,
0.0065307328,
0.100914523,
0.0476626717,
-0.0408045053,
-0.0305034705,
-0.012948853,
-0.0181977712,
0.0119331069,
0.0738590509,
-0.0209234003,
-0.0078568775,
-0.0135720521,
-0.043195311,
-0.0078434907,
-0.02543124,
-0.012389848,
-0.0233985111,
0.0177039783,
0.0149946148,
-0.0634753257,
-0.0467884988,
-0.0432222039,
0.0197766535,
-0.0032831961,
-0.0212769434,
0.0169186573,
0.1075131148,
-0.0672803149,
-0.0309441686,
-0.0463915467,
0.0144585697,
-0.0292596035,
0.0340010449,
-0.0438751616,
-6.035645907e-33,
-0.0341482423,
-0.0509150326,
-0.0262694601,
-0.0420652814,
-0.0247405637,
0.0024189085,
-0.0319863968,
-0.041808635,
-0.0051206872,
0.0628366023,
0.0411294922,
0.02978101,
0.0083680088,
-0.0134425955,
-0.0088047404,
-0.0120739397,
0.052001819,
0.0555825941,
-0.0718568861,
0.0506169572,
0.0492280573,
-0.0228153113,
0.0620806031,
-0.0385768712,
0.0795015544,
0.0141517352,
-0.0494641289,
0.020934958,
-0.0054361024,
0.0363846719,
-0.0019094128,
0.0234094635,
0.0196606927,
-0.0480304845,
-0.0042491127,
-0.0019833662,
-0.0330134667,
0.0045865267,
0.0599404834,
0.030671481,
-0.0401094556,
-0.0483380482,
0.0433031805,
-0.0311940257,
-0.0345265679,
-0.0141765028,
0.0195797291,
-0.0410361439,
-0.0345287994,
-0.0132857393,
-0.0351440683,
0.0391663872,
-0.0649532005,
-0.0390534364,
0.0225340221,
0.0232804529,
-0.0153409494,
0.0040692487,
-0.0219177902,
-0.0018285669,
0.0197967403,
0.0589747429,
0.0867142752,
0.0002977894,
-0.0085539604,
0.0271691829,
0.0186006799,
-0.0213054512,
-0.0263271648,
-0.0277515855,
-0.027436588,
0.0227407552,
0.1009193212,
0.0330481641,
0.0153918955,
0.0259327479,
-0.0231495649,
0.0643965006,
-0.021738762,
0.0201173946,
0.0424450859,
0.0198964104,
-0.0580277741,
-0.0025071709,
-0.0409256518,
-0.0668136403,
-0.0334911421,
-0.0238410719,
0.005066752,
-0.0264298804,
-0.0401947275,
-0.0345504619,
0.0236376971,
-0.0237403866,
0.0597491413,
0.0202710479,
-0.0298549738,
-0.0003945604,
0.0046307901,
0.0291539058,
0.02524326,
-0.0026155321,
0.0216901675,
0.0660631135,
0.0469011776,
-0.0383826457,
0.0217307713,
0.0001468586,
-0.0035221761,
0.0111895222,
-0.0835185274,
-0.0266083013,
-0.0727938712,
-0.0370322876,
0.0198926907,
0.0030386741,
-0.0520469397,
0.0170094073,
0.0313884616,
0.0334311351,
-0.001277216,
-0.0021203198,
-0.0201612692,
0.0085354224,
-0.0489707142,
0.0053407447,
0.0014079025,
-0.0229252521,
0.0526068471,
-0.0203537364,
-0.0439730547,
0.0054725125,
2.53e-7,
0.059416201,
0.0319726244,
0.0170452483,
0.0117708119,
0.0158209242,
0.0260093566,
0.012151001,
-0.0095381029,
-0.0168113317,
0.0171337705,
0.0249234997,
0.011688727,
0.089301452,
-0.0123653887,
-0.010989462,
-0.0456135534,
-0.0630926117,
0.0077656386,
-0.028559668,
0.0149471881,
0.0845654905,
0.0589496382,
0.0158210024,
0.0245949849,
0.0194696113,
-0.0204179082,
0.0538788699,
-0.0566962957,
-0.0162424706,
0.0362703092,
0.0905239657,
0.0243871007,
0.0071147522,
-0.0200899076,
-0.0086214878,
0.0141868982,
0.0404932126,
0.0577345788,
-0.0032941422,
-0.0038480493,
-0.0337493718,
-0.0267141573,
0.0232872143,
-0.0914082304,
0.0634994805,
-0.0042587002,
-0.0349259675,
0.0101882732,
-0.0170615911,
-0.0210597552,
0.0281836335,
-0.0198769979,
-0.0503065065,
0.0282698628,
0.0093264505,
-0.0104107372,
-0.0097934008,
-0.0660774484,
-0.06641379,
-0.0229991991,
-0.0040269471,
-0.0193123203,
-0.0278004743,
0.0066055418,
0.0378741547,
-0.0376818739,
-0.0192613117,
2.38971045e-34,
0.0384649821,
-0.0022912312,
0.0289968345,
-0.0416554734,
0.0783803314,
0.0141321709,
0.0085210083,
-0.0208977386,
0.0276615564,
-0.0450914465,
-0.0047347108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09630v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09630v1 | Noor-Ghateh: A Benchmark Dataset for Evaluating Arabic Word Segmenters in Hadith Domain | 2023-06-22T16:50:40 | 2023-06-22T16:50:40 | Huda AlShuhayeb, Behrouz Minaei-Bidgoli, Mohammad E. Shenassa, Sayyed-Ali Hossayni | cs.CL | cs.CL | There are many complex and rich morphological subtleties in the Arabic
language, which are very useful when analyzing traditional Arabic texts,
especially in the historical and religious contexts, and help in understanding
the meaning of the texts. Vocabulary separation means separating the word into
different parts such as root and affix. In the morphological datasets, the
variety of labels and the number of data samples helps to evaluate the
morphological methods. In this paper, we present a benchmark data set for
evaluating the methods of separating Arabic words which include about 223,690
words from the book of Sharia alIslam, which have been labeled by experts. In
terms of the volume and variety of words, this dataset is superior to other
existing data sets, and as far as we know, there are no Arabic Hadith Domain
texts. To evaluate the dataset, we applied different methods such as Farasa,
Camel, Madamira, and ALP to the dataset and we reported the annotation quality
through four evaluation methods. | [
-0.0032435867,
0.0268933121,
-0.0066485628,
0.0397753455,
-0.0818904638,
0.0168719944,
0.0312653892,
0.0354027785,
-0.0602908358,
-0.0512339659,
0.008011301,
-0.0929248855,
0.0639849827,
-0.0687652901,
0.0193557329,
-0.036261104,
0.0351428837,
-0.0637213513,
0.0081911152,
0.0418983549,
0.0738551393,
-0.0043979078,
-0.0384309925,
-0.0072121471,
-0.0466686822,
-0.0045175804,
-0.0242356583,
-0.0499477163,
0.0322585069,
0.0236770343,
-0.0351780988,
0.055840563,
-0.0838952214,
0.0587389544,
0.000001715,
-0.0853790417,
-0.060924273,
-0.0151365437,
0.0088473456,
0.0135522224,
0.0348699205,
-0.0225811489,
-0.0463479608,
-0.0477788709,
0.0204162057,
0.0340276025,
0.0414201915,
0.0291254092,
0.0373699889,
0.0470914952,
0.0054068184,
-0.1076343134,
0.0326026902,
0.0330826454,
-0.0077585899,
0.0502164811,
-0.0167739969,
0.0194513015,
-0.0087728994,
-0.0146888169,
-0.0248236675,
0.0038462821,
-0.0385825224,
-0.0192915723,
-0.0285578985,
0.0061175772,
-0.0783543289,
-0.0483953878,
0.0397974141,
0.0025474722,
-0.0293193739,
-0.0011154929,
0.0236857869,
-0.001255547,
-0.0102165537,
0.0250098314,
0.0036775786,
0.0492484942,
-0.1042051613,
-0.0092436373,
0.0712652653,
0.0276832152,
-0.0130126113,
-0.0217974316,
-0.0598841272,
0.0641974136,
0.0259372443,
-0.0289630815,
0.0398832932,
0.0119141266,
-0.0558002293,
0.0099838097,
0.0018408252,
-0.0158986393,
0.03596095,
0.0003166398,
-0.0264420956,
-0.065303877,
0.0145303998,
-0.0508242771,
0.0212645382,
0.0156275351,
0.004587837,
0.007599981,
-0.0148467915,
-0.0342308544,
0.0703028068,
0.0358647741,
-0.0111988308,
0.0269543231,
-0.0168261677,
0.0234855339,
-0.0098887887,
0.0373983718,
-0.0565534309,
0.0200528875,
-0.0543576032,
-0.0224847253,
0.0141720157,
-0.023771733,
0.0110660903,
-0.0903011113,
0.0095689595,
-0.0126672927,
0.020973878,
-0.0690763593,
-0.0578779988,
0.0047625029,
-0.0701080784,
-0.0729560331,
0.0531013757,
0.0207908712,
0.0269774552,
0.0065380805,
-0.0006150375,
0.0420016833,
-0.0024313671,
-0.0812848061,
-0.0417571589,
0.0194280241,
-0.0315495133,
-0.0129516609,
-0.0151837105,
-0.0464007035,
0.0335310139,
-0.0166345052,
-0.0202340484,
0.0300417859,
-0.0257562157,
0.0019969586,
0.033552438,
0.0710281357,
-0.0389101431,
0.0021399036,
0.0578218699,
0.0062977416,
0.0449568219,
0.0171351191,
0.0240434296,
0.0242624618,
0.0407375731,
0.0017008957,
-0.0006906805,
0.0307316631,
-0.0340783969,
-0.0297014583,
-0.0683946535,
-0.0547007173,
0.0081007676,
0.0182739347,
-0.0452856869,
0.0556625426,
-0.0289965533,
-0.009060327,
0.020130882,
0.0751318708,
0.0122502958,
0.0265125204,
-0.0323157273,
0.0374464057,
0.0873560533,
0.0376787297,
0.0385452174,
-0.0776591226,
0.0070279376,
0.0261178929,
0.0134935314,
0.0385558493,
0.0301810335,
-0.0503881425,
-0.0408030301,
-0.0148115158,
-0.013951472,
-0.0584136844,
0.1059536189,
-0.0088333767,
-0.0468288511,
-0.0236107316,
0.0482930504,
-0.0240796879,
-0.0114235906,
-0.0201974772,
0.032710012,
-0.0282960441,
0.0218791701,
-0.0553026944,
-0.0008230353,
0.015523226,
-0.0065257116,
0.0235247668,
-0.0453453511,
-0.0163640454,
-0.0184470452,
-0.0469297655,
0.0205122959,
0.0461991541,
0.0107758101,
-0.0486482233,
0.0009214409,
0.0405988321,
0.0001357566,
-0.0389121212,
-0.020311214,
0.0782200471,
0.038722083,
0.0194021184,
-0.0710440204,
0.0006790645,
0.0300355721,
0.0162481386,
-0.0323303342,
-0.0192895811,
-0.0138741992,
-0.0330902189,
0.0252636988,
-0.0079335505,
0.0083249602,
0.0315402821,
0.0535515621,
-0.0443662368,
0.0077183642,
-0.0227505881,
0.0188719705,
-0.0182744358,
-0.0076756864,
-0.0238445234,
0.0130876061,
-0.0345292576,
0.0626339614,
0.0054751844,
0.0344903171,
-0.0359101184,
0.0590856709,
-0.0035064924,
-0.0000457653,
-0.0680314749,
-0.0483379848,
0.0176908299,
0.038409099,
-0.0046636327,
0.0141283534,
-0.0084273918,
-0.0174095389,
-0.0089644417,
-0.0204602052,
-0.0312135853,
-0.0507748947,
-0.0397911929,
-0.0266075823,
-0.0238035694,
0.051580321,
-0.0113966446,
0.0147612365,
0.0066081872,
0.0187812001,
0.0169922616,
0.0028315163,
0.002441376,
0.002934556,
0.0513903648,
-0.0264464691,
-0.0062141381,
-0.0456492715,
-0.0155394496,
0.020597972,
0.0357490592,
0.0719454065,
-0.0796739757,
0.0384816527,
-0.0490233675,
-0.0120443245,
0.0044624922,
0.0168261733,
-0.008176418,
0.031862136,
-0.0215034597,
-0.0048328931,
-0.0009479341,
0.0303067174,
-0.0205360707,
0.00162687,
-0.026606651,
0.013113833,
-0.02830665,
0.0450199097,
0.0348853692,
-0.0480959788,
-0.0162000284,
0.001644109,
0.035311792,
-0.0261852574,
0.0175007991,
0.018615365,
0.0156080481,
-0.0868218765,
0.0234352406,
0.0224524029,
0.0064663361,
-0.0543804877,
0.088790372,
0.0164863244,
-0.0459015891,
-0.0196280759,
-0.0426793247,
0.0229459982,
-0.0190631337,
0.0071281889,
-0.0522502288,
-0.0315466411,
-0.0010855548,
0.0046370504,
0.0103808949,
-0.0254637096,
0.0285041966,
0.0278256107,
0.0300895683,
-0.0086421203,
0.0336465761,
0.0014529212,
0.0170158781,
-0.0463654362,
0.0279122759,
0.0069658128,
0.0321215726,
-0.0351340808,
-0.0202119593,
0.0905545577,
0.0181123167,
0.0177884102,
0.081180051,
-0.0379998647,
0.0389469713,
0.0106540602,
0.0214774143,
-0.0023977542,
0.0408742316,
-0.0048451708,
-0.0475113951,
-0.004764765,
-0.0089108497,
-0.0086827762,
-0.0025472078,
-0.0656705797,
-0.0241271742,
-0.0234332439,
-0.0449618213,
0.0111090476,
-0.0708339885,
-0.0408870131,
-0.046717193,
-0.0231254157,
-0.0240391269,
0.0119145801,
0.0705878288,
0.0324970409,
-0.0097709242,
0.0084333709,
-0.0083270362,
-0.0518782586,
-0.0408505052,
-0.0448397696,
-0.09832187,
0.0080076,
0.034735553,
0.0150359403,
0.0221477859,
-0.0192702282,
0.0806977227,
-0.0524883457,
-0.0219647828,
-0.0128416596,
-0.0699625984,
0.0061463816,
-0.0309519526,
0.0186049491,
-0.0169628114,
-0.0543515868,
-0.0224406682,
-0.0245884079,
0.0360518023,
0.0561735407,
-0.0262694862,
0.0111410832,
-0.0290319137,
-0.0260343812,
-0.036740344,
-0.00527969,
0.0434383638,
-0.0640619248,
-0.0329819247,
0.057519041,
-0.0224071927,
-0.0435980186,
-0.0055347327,
0.0489027835,
0.0069671832,
0.0090312129,
-0.0372793935,
-0.0416192971,
0.0105280085,
0.0126461778,
0.0079345712,
0.004846096,
0.0025266679,
0.0428652354,
0.0227011498,
0.0157695971,
-0.0654133111,
-0.0008092626,
-0.0124821644,
-0.0288278051,
-0.0694841892,
0.012929298,
0.0069137807,
-0.0199339483,
-0.0620299578,
-0.0043218783,
-0.0018420691,
-0.0129215643,
-0.0909216106,
-0.0699070841,
0.0083002765,
0.063520506,
0.0422460437,
0.0235176571,
-0.0128824171,
0.0553523079,
-0.014519278,
-0.0583129898,
0.0199069362,
-0.0119414488,
-0.0598911755,
-0.0137244528,
0.0158647262,
0.0167090911,
0.0270058531,
0.022701228,
0.0039196098,
-0.0270679295,
0.0816567019,
-0.032347139,
0.0130556859,
-0.0330959,
-0.0177811701,
-0.0023878033,
0.0105071226,
-0.010322188,
0.0149777243,
0.0265227295,
0.0370317362,
0.0030786758,
-0.0572662577,
0.008778031,
0.0418716185,
0.0295340698,
-0.0148230949,
-0.0328706987,
-0.0455774181,
-0.012968679,
-0.022374019,
0.0185625535,
0.0116175897,
-0.0447838716,
-0.0234691482,
-0.0184085332,
-0.0124674132,
-0.0137689589,
0.0118895322,
-0.0013923328,
0.0105156405,
0.0199290793,
0.0254115742,
-0.0149133094,
0.0169493817,
0.0211111903,
-0.0036877852,
-0.0022153626,
0.0443958789,
0.0678814948,
0.0238815583,
-0.0456672013,
0.0160507336,
0.042401012,
-0.0531034581,
-0.0134519096,
0.0333638154,
-0.0297025219,
0.0114656137,
-0.0134652192,
0.0044512339,
0.0113829477,
0.0601016842,
0.0365945175,
0.0216875318,
-0.0430156328,
0.0940648392,
0.009613378,
-0.0131569877,
0.0354100652,
0.0200390872,
-0.0109854192,
0.0068901107,
0.0412027873,
-0.0026771277,
0.0190872904,
-0.0542518385,
0.0170518495,
-0.0289233122,
-0.0027433089,
0.025110146,
-0.003723541,
-0.0174884889,
0.0502981171,
-0.0116859181,
-0.0330617465,
0.0151981432,
-0.0345890559,
-0.0038907516,
-0.0096952291,
-0.0183800347,
-0.0869635493,
-0.0135412635,
0.0170397833,
0.0224472955,
0.0373694263,
0.0480733067,
-0.0106549207,
0.0462614261,
0.0299188718,
-0.0104352962,
-0.0452767238,
0.0178392883,
-0.005834565,
-0.0102919424,
0.0381746367,
-5.164918303e-33,
-0.0159665216,
-0.0236855503,
-0.0247824918,
-0.0064441869,
0.0099721709,
0.0087640649,
0.0119651873,
0.0119915549,
0.0115370285,
0.0028022905,
-0.0244585741,
0.0013576417,
0.0483042598,
-0.0335916393,
0.029315196,
0.0043053343,
0.0402020961,
-0.0106440689,
-0.0389362164,
-0.0273039434,
0.03288652,
0.0358068757,
0.0948488638,
-0.0237737503,
0.0270667784,
-0.0107575022,
-0.0132166883,
-0.0000387884,
0.0012146831,
0.050500121,
-0.014411509,
0.0274996553,
0.0129190264,
-0.0261950586,
0.0271602347,
-0.0203903522,
-0.0493489839,
0.0026974101,
0.0196151622,
0.0506078117,
-0.0210498441,
0.0053747087,
-0.062682189,
-0.0035090356,
-0.0193468444,
0.0373608395,
0.029518716,
-0.0268354919,
-0.0282331016,
0.003473524,
-0.092845723,
0.0838087276,
0.0152951526,
0.0342714563,
0.0947057307,
-0.0189658385,
0.0226087216,
-0.0204907674,
-0.026145475,
-0.0126724131,
0.0675986335,
0.024756996,
0.0047818641,
0.0381037556,
-0.0777738988,
0.0239214469,
0.0481035486,
-0.0489554256,
0.1082027555,
0.0328459665,
0.024989916,
-0.0263788011,
0.012471715,
0.0244802143,
0.0468377843,
-0.0246602222,
-0.0147530343,
-0.0009289652,
0.0104437172,
0.0044982773,
-0.0099323606,
0.0095702298,
-0.0787539035,
0.023910325,
0.0433578975,
-0.0741464272,
0.0268100947,
0.0349650532,
-0.0038006122,
0.0072266478,
-0.0354213193,
0.0733463466,
-0.0300605595,
0.0412252583,
0.0481469482,
-0.0138123324,
-0.0167866275,
0.0495208651,
-0.0486889146,
-0.0241915695,
-0.0137059996,
-0.0386131033,
0.0020599884,
0.0327741764,
0.025564678,
-0.038875211,
0.0410146005,
-0.0320124738,
-0.0485079139,
0.0158810895,
-0.0153494664,
0.0239916984,
-0.0020181129,
0.0648826286,
0.0266252011,
-0.015512214,
0.0237852279,
0.0302316509,
0.0668376014,
-0.0084096259,
0.0011020481,
-0.009702214,
-0.0396030284,
-0.0637827963,
-0.0096309297,
0.0276610907,
0.0356001183,
0.0012873719,
0.0057847276,
-0.0149922632,
0.0098570762,
-0.0091402167,
2.462e-7,
0.0630061477,
0.0147019327,
0.0379517153,
-0.0549251661,
-0.0070694522,
-0.0196291264,
0.0180098768,
0.0046844915,
-0.0317871496,
0.0067381896,
0.005118676,
-0.0465486757,
0.0513668768,
0.0061078845,
-0.0306090917,
-0.0574138202,
-0.0159108862,
-0.0109530557,
-0.0565072149,
0.0282590576,
-0.0011614293,
0.0890209228,
-0.0485822968,
-0.0219678283,
-0.0343826488,
-0.0160291325,
-0.0116606345,
-0.0157128554,
-0.0211787168,
0.046582181,
0.0977777913,
-0.0531434305,
0.0121675059,
0.0068682204,
0.0074419053,
0.0070914235,
0.0694600493,
0.059046343,
0.0023802561,
0.0428304113,
0.0067777066,
-0.0137732755,
0.0041355537,
-0.006015447,
0.0460399687,
0.073776722,
-0.0212134495,
0.0113069238,
-0.0067075798,
0.0481588878,
0.0048725065,
0.0180164333,
0.0078021237,
0.028249545,
0.0369447693,
-0.0099551771,
-0.0295639969,
0.011755107,
0.0382421501,
0.0060519236,
0.0144490255,
0.0065313373,
0.0212094132,
-0.0067826174,
-0.0259386487,
0.0197779704,
-0.0381439812,
1.997251687e-34,
0.0034027263,
0.0132897953,
0.0053710714,
0.0460776538,
0.0025160096,
0.0140930573,
0.004251434,
0.0174000822,
-0.0399831496,
0.0044696284,
0.0290312078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13000v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13000v1 | Apolitical Intelligence? Auditing Delphi's responses on controversial political issues in the US | 2023-06-22T15:56:50 | 2023-06-22T15:56:50 | Jonathan H. Rystrøm | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | As generative language models are deployed in ever-wider contexts, concerns
about their political values have come to the forefront with critique from all
parts of the political spectrum that the models are biased and lack neutrality.
However, the question of what neutrality is and whether it is desirable remains
underexplored. In this paper, I examine neutrality through an audit of Delphi
[arXiv:2110.07574], a large language model designed for crowdsourced ethics. I
analyse how Delphi responds to politically controversial questions compared to
different US political subgroups. I find that Delphi is poorly calibrated with
respect to confidence and exhibits a significant political skew. Based on these
results, I examine the question of neutrality from a data-feminist lens, in
terms of how notions of neutrality shift power and further marginalise unheard
voices. These findings can hopefully contribute to a more reflexive debate
about the normative questions of alignment and what role we want generative
models to play in society. | [
0.0368606821,
0.1278703809,
-0.015495141,
0.0139509449,
-0.0601612441,
-0.0082859537,
0.039640516,
-0.0147634037,
-0.0007328558,
-0.0452685468,
0.0046368986,
-0.006448023,
-0.0239513516,
0.0043730517,
-0.023558585,
0.0070915814,
0.0136272088,
0.0190360509,
0.0907077193,
-0.0504845455,
0.0097584287,
0.0159683917,
-0.0031802063,
0.051758185,
0.0066841766,
0.036552202,
0.0194942132,
0.0069720782,
0.0300416332,
0.0158740971,
0.0095080202,
0.0571722873,
-0.0346239917,
0.0402108394,
0.000001743,
-0.0543191507,
0.0046954365,
0.0112240119,
0.0385040678,
-0.0588527471,
0.0652055144,
0.0175974108,
-0.0111742085,
0.0106226373,
-0.084202759,
0.0223321337,
0.0402891934,
-0.0235461984,
-0.003629226,
0.0367343873,
0.0163580682,
0.0008889185,
0.031498868,
-0.0201606415,
-0.0283175185,
0.0189817529,
0.028322326,
-0.0674581602,
-0.0629568174,
0.0362239853,
-0.0273427628,
0.0246061813,
0.0258127246,
-0.0173384324,
-0.0291690119,
-0.0083848173,
-0.0045276773,
-0.0445467569,
0.0048483498,
0.0406639762,
0.0670975968,
0.0191200245,
0.0649662316,
0.0216719043,
0.0266398061,
0.024237927,
-0.0148361074,
0.0537381284,
-0.0228482652,
-0.0053464761,
0.0676569194,
0.0052231085,
0.0071184542,
0.0649991632,
0.0169093292,
0.0372265428,
-0.0138869435,
0.0012545475,
-0.0017725597,
-0.0142848426,
-0.0026077563,
-0.0164112598,
0.015043796,
-0.0154539198,
-0.0001832371,
0.0219200831,
-0.0028334218,
0.0061221598,
0.0613533445,
-0.0344661437,
0.015900204,
0.0256809033,
0.0157152377,
0.0359336138,
0.0694777369,
-0.0174971763,
-0.0076409411,
0.0763282925,
-0.0134113338,
-0.0231215265,
-0.0048713679,
-0.0027131182,
0.0205774829,
0.0056379596,
-0.0395261757,
0.0178427435,
0.0245799571,
-0.0328725278,
-0.059522789,
0.0146703701,
-0.0207166355,
0.0351478383,
0.0049488004,
-0.0113856876,
-0.0454842634,
0.0383382402,
-0.0613075495,
0.0453204028,
0.0009378496,
-0.0656549335,
0.0254680235,
0.0054438389,
-0.0210154038,
-0.00753611,
0.0133740818,
0.0683532581,
0.0285103358,
-0.0006727776,
0.0063898722,
0.0113896523,
-0.0251178928,
-0.061214868,
0.029658515,
-0.0504535101,
0.0538384877,
0.0192239936,
-0.0082816081,
-0.0801985264,
0.0231628623,
0.016212631,
-0.0104650166,
0.0513162836,
0.0180660505,
0.0274695866,
0.0382364355,
0.0303176939,
-0.0251969695,
0.0799887106,
0.038391415,
-0.0036298914,
0.0284846891,
-0.011414066,
0.0191018917,
-0.0074005546,
-0.0155885536,
0.0401041508,
-0.0510171317,
0.0475199297,
-0.0727719218,
-0.0186446086,
0.0550042652,
0.1015547663,
0.0225840453,
-0.0530861579,
0.0709335208,
0.0963508934,
-0.0458406806,
0.036420092,
0.0135208489,
0.0023407114,
-0.0129555883,
0.0085468479,
-0.0348561257,
0.0029892733,
-0.0436866544,
-0.042607259,
-0.0188157726,
0.039106451,
-0.02345917,
-0.0520099178,
0.0048325215,
0.0210905075,
0.0452435277,
0.0144871036,
0.0042736623,
-0.0362005271,
-0.0278998595,
-0.0364957303,
0.0111552458,
-0.0535765365,
-0.0221270993,
-0.0715633854,
0.0505489521,
0.0199445523,
0.0200827941,
0.0081963362,
-0.0169805381,
-0.0454657115,
-0.0131617552,
0.0694577396,
0.0513867736,
-0.0115868766,
-0.0585156009,
-0.0424021482,
-0.0249266345,
0.0127048139,
0.0191187914,
0.0498655625,
-0.0219394173,
0.0123531185,
-0.0108646806,
0.0054535414,
-0.0541488454,
0.0116551481,
-0.0221872255,
0.0084148562,
-0.0444699451,
0.0017644586,
0.0370173194,
0.004078412,
-0.0240426939,
0.0138656963,
0.0241039004,
-0.0066894102,
-0.0120923929,
-0.0267576519,
-0.0250875782,
0.0649276748,
0.01764399,
-0.077811636,
0.0099738082,
0.0702488199,
0.0192807447,
0.0140250521,
0.0520533174,
-0.0177651253,
-0.0393882021,
-0.0465834215,
-0.0156496763,
-0.0561118871,
0.004628222,
-0.0517318659,
0.0584492311,
-0.0484062396,
0.0278847441,
0.0109056132,
-0.0076550245,
0.0471947752,
0.0228992626,
-0.0322369598,
0.0273640286,
0.0152574135,
0.05764376,
0.043110311,
-0.0501652658,
-0.0242323726,
-0.0662992373,
-0.0335000195,
0.0067108269,
-0.0137835667,
0.014783808,
-0.0023394683,
-0.0333415903,
-0.0109871468,
0.0285902042,
-0.0226632375,
-0.0490112863,
0.0085015949,
0.0081330007,
0.0307920035,
-0.0206096675,
-0.0267124549,
-0.0239383169,
-0.0069376715,
-0.0301987194,
-0.0181813128,
0.0285210237,
0.0291443337,
0.0363243185,
0.0016900436,
-0.0651931912,
-0.0085222805,
-0.0231583007,
-0.0346249416,
0.0124219609,
0.0436341539,
-0.0017900701,
0.0595748499,
0.0500041582,
0.0631964207,
0.0100637181,
0.0508884676,
-0.0507940017,
-0.0322489254,
-0.0133379512,
-0.0004915295,
-0.0230500661,
-0.0495268218,
0.0072418167,
0.0642170981,
0.0008225297,
-0.0126818819,
-0.0337786004,
0.0853774771,
-0.0637429431,
-0.0637446269,
0.0099803247,
-0.0317887664,
-0.0159279369,
0.037002217,
-0.0439078249,
-0.0514830537,
0.030896835,
0.0209026299,
0.0396727361,
-0.0358277448,
-0.0241190642,
-0.018608246,
0.0781556517,
-0.0019469196,
0.023118984,
-0.0158587825,
-0.0129925348,
-0.0780203193,
-0.0233986843,
0.0281277709,
-0.0728666857,
0.055224292,
-0.0270264745,
0.0211544018,
-0.0240678117,
-0.0330080241,
-0.0385474227,
-0.0450358242,
-0.023142634,
0.0362051241,
0.0702733546,
-0.0043066423,
-0.0038354993,
-0.0012290479,
0.0423138253,
-0.0244198367,
0.024622092,
0.0127298115,
0.0036298074,
-0.0261194687,
0.0194659121,
-0.0085931029,
0.0412949435,
0.0054039666,
-0.0298791137,
0.0476262905,
-0.0268175751,
0.0488675833,
0.0051244427,
-0.0098144123,
0.0526614934,
-0.012889416,
-0.0146810487,
-0.0114055034,
0.0061337226,
-0.0213938486,
0.0325853415,
0.0559150241,
0.004685421,
-0.0621036366,
-0.0165583659,
-0.0081033558,
-0.0292328242,
0.0257486068,
-0.0259491,
-0.0850184783,
0.0404784605,
0.0017669469,
0.0180967338,
-0.1048037112,
-0.0797147229,
-0.0116852522,
-0.1355122924,
0.0173378307,
-0.0081898589,
-0.0141682792,
0.0074173864,
-0.0147373807,
0.0274974927,
-0.0252476539,
0.0082393382,
-0.0018595472,
0.0462910496,
0.0013310007,
0.0122143524,
-0.0124882888,
-0.015872106,
-0.0014575253,
-0.0326968916,
0.0652294457,
0.0526290461,
0.0706935376,
-0.0428359024,
-0.0781634748,
0.0073959189,
0.0059718643,
-0.0516202375,
0.009060639,
0.003297318,
-0.0122475196,
-0.0100867823,
-0.039832633,
0.0461602211,
0.0159769673,
0.0144458693,
0.0012851681,
0.0085770488,
-0.0148525955,
-0.0387964658,
-0.0520921201,
0.0238392316,
0.0402803868,
0.0570854098,
0.0229289234,
-0.0421909094,
-0.0053770295,
-0.0474852771,
0.0099911289,
-0.0095622493,
-0.0490487628,
0.0061106575,
0.0465059914,
-0.0350223929,
-0.0215154774,
-0.0605222061,
-0.0178665705,
0.0288000721,
0.0270698704,
-0.0355455838,
-0.006682232,
-0.0148973521,
-0.0094632357,
0.0305463895,
-0.0031718165,
-0.0201742891,
-0.0258330423,
-0.0641932711,
-0.0174817033,
0.021418184,
-0.0340996385,
0.0477786623,
0.0172427129,
-0.0334723704,
0.0981852412,
0.0219832603,
0.0284740198,
-0.0158610251,
-0.0268437322,
0.0241382383,
-0.0062869173,
0.0920110717,
-0.0630424991,
0.0232769214,
0.0116445189,
0.0260729175,
0.0015936176,
0.0189977009,
0.0005335982,
0.0471347496,
0.0430547483,
-0.0059002661,
-0.0546370745,
-0.0339142382,
0.0096327569,
-0.0032105395,
0.0336612202,
-0.003526337,
-0.008643508,
-0.0347292386,
-0.0677513778,
-0.0227534994,
-0.0344949141,
-0.0097918827,
-0.0221947804,
0.0495502315,
-0.0121577932,
-0.0183703061,
0.0417274237,
-0.0429845862,
0.0453576073,
-0.0287421066,
0.0454906486,
0.0337742157,
0.0380962975,
-0.0173907708,
-0.0120071983,
-0.0030500463,
0.0401341021,
0.0144871837,
0.0297790207,
0.034656357,
0.0217300374,
0.0085875019,
-0.0144294249,
0.0147870574,
-0.0007628642,
-0.0575884767,
-0.0716299862,
0.0262822211,
0.0418329649,
-0.0214928407,
0.0249916688,
-0.0203049965,
0.0289792884,
-0.0095629143,
-0.0188072845,
-0.0178261604,
0.0324754976,
-0.0298665855,
0.0469256938,
0.0080534471,
-0.0263899751,
-0.0014059593,
0.0231995489,
-0.035609819,
0.039029561,
0.0049210228,
-0.0042028176,
0.0016390187,
-0.07223773,
0.0164887607,
-0.0281668585,
0.0075335051,
-0.0199765153,
-0.0909292772,
-0.0066360584,
-0.0021306826,
0.0095165772,
0.0280875918,
-0.0411738083,
-0.0097539369,
0.0538955294,
-0.0287017804,
0.0000161697,
-0.048287563,
0.0423906818,
-0.0783820599,
-0.0059415847,
0.0207352005,
-5.778281704e-33,
-0.0015664222,
-0.0335178934,
0.0208504666,
-0.0222493242,
-0.0330412164,
0.0002834337,
0.0033470374,
0.0384349637,
-0.0472347401,
0.0231375378,
0.0094651617,
0.0273324102,
0.0017667629,
0.0069840485,
0.009444911,
-0.0473376475,
0.0061210152,
-0.0050890865,
-0.0211525653,
-0.0196925234,
0.0080225095,
-0.0242331307,
0.0001108806,
-0.071758233,
0.0840915665,
-0.0113821868,
-0.0280482341,
-0.0047793314,
-0.0086127007,
0.0126047209,
-0.0031950881,
0.0410577506,
0.004074784,
-0.0442984439,
0.0078391526,
0.0692659691,
-0.0120656174,
-0.0108792409,
0.0467010885,
-0.0406508259,
-0.0246703867,
-0.0353993624,
0.031076258,
0.024218468,
-0.0731440932,
0.0130166793,
0.0450279787,
-0.0224108603,
0.0123032946,
-0.0137849236,
-0.0533794239,
0.0063252896,
-0.0269821417,
0.0132760378,
-0.0453177243,
0.0021507489,
0.0224409085,
0.0245710723,
-0.0254288409,
0.017966751,
-0.0080330139,
-0.0181690566,
0.0422468632,
-0.020841714,
0.0456518456,
0.0820914283,
0.0679267347,
0.0512080155,
-0.0405050889,
-0.0312719606,
0.0286418106,
0.0042628529,
0.0473408215,
0.0735772327,
-0.0228246506,
-0.0444028005,
-0.0385051891,
-0.0298774969,
0.003604654,
0.0022021718,
0.028227618,
-0.0604970865,
-0.0555169657,
-0.0223528743,
-0.0444902182,
-0.1115845293,
-0.0209569521,
-0.0129770609,
-0.0047545736,
0.005073464,
-0.0470711179,
0.0304297227,
0.0309181642,
-0.0435373895,
0.0184574071,
0.0526241995,
-0.0116702961,
-0.0171971265,
0.0195750725,
0.0327870436,
-0.0529553704,
0.0070561613,
-0.0331303477,
0.0271416921,
0.0427446216,
0.0166742839,
0.0012264986,
0.0094030332,
-0.0542900711,
-0.0190700013,
-0.0265225563,
0.0440356769,
-0.0094928043,
-0.000091548,
0.0396556631,
0.0361125432,
0.0228877235,
-0.0171560757,
0.0442193225,
0.0508297868,
-0.0061773257,
0.0213520117,
-0.0679700896,
0.0137501145,
-0.041544728,
-0.0180340149,
-0.0112227006,
0.065984726,
0.0207246747,
-0.0182819888,
-0.0247282442,
-0.0488374904,
2.421e-7,
0.0331248119,
0.0019531518,
-0.0065349247,
-0.0333646387,
-0.0275366493,
0.0216821395,
0.0400819257,
0.0597457327,
-0.0034365975,
-0.0449219644,
-0.0303120501,
0.0238615349,
0.0042889589,
0.0459678806,
-0.0672739074,
-0.0096266568,
-0.0495969616,
0.0443946198,
-0.0390314534,
0.083600238,
-0.0299153887,
0.0272864718,
0.0336831324,
-0.0021795398,
-0.0236333609,
-0.0339595154,
0.0390503667,
-0.0558269136,
-0.0351866037,
0.0171787459,
0.06623137,
-0.0094294567,
0.0366306528,
0.0220136289,
0.0405825339,
0.0159431826,
0.0127042225,
0.0778595284,
-0.0006445264,
-0.0144494632,
-0.0143468548,
-0.0435879342,
-0.0039289864,
-0.0244540367,
0.0697839484,
0.003118213,
-0.0241180696,
-0.0837098435,
-0.0294314381,
-0.0152963521,
0.035199739,
-0.0074850698,
-0.0244708993,
-0.0173431821,
0.0062875045,
-0.000040621,
0.0204204749,
-0.0285146609,
-0.0074333358,
-0.0446469486,
-0.0179915782,
-0.1042141318,
0.0270610768,
0.0283707082,
0.0164233316,
-0.0232669152,
0.0325281173,
1.947108128e-34,
0.023705883,
-0.003022016,
-0.0245263129,
-0.0143088391,
0.0301428977,
0.0315260962,
0.017255364,
-0.0227761045,
0.0300899241,
-0.0133337155,
0.0018762241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12991v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12991v2 | Speech Emotion Diarization: Which Emotion Appears When? | 2023-06-22T15:47:36 | 2023-10-20T11:31:26 | Yingzhi Wang, Mirco Ravanelli, Alya Yacoubi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Speech Emotion Recognition (SER) typically relies on utterance-level
solutions. However, emotions conveyed through speech should be considered as
discrete speech events with definite temporal boundaries, rather than
attributes of the entire utterance. To reflect the fine-grained nature of
speech emotions, we propose a new task: Speech Emotion Diarization (SED). Just
as Speaker Diarization answers the question of "Who speaks when?", Speech
Emotion Diarization answers the question of "Which emotion appears when?". To
facilitate the evaluation of the performance and establish a common benchmark
for researchers, we introduce the Zaion Emotion Dataset (ZED), an openly
accessible speech emotion dataset that includes non-acted emotions recorded in
real-life conditions, along with manually-annotated boundaries of emotion
segments within the utterance. We provide competitive baselines and open-source
the code and the pre-trained models. | [
-0.0306718443,
0.0737333,
0.0082224095,
0.0421274863,
0.0266522896,
0.0240652058,
0.0331923813,
-0.0457772687,
0.0003702906,
-0.0202489961,
-0.0565363914,
0.0037590079,
-0.0403143279,
0.010903039,
-0.064544186,
-0.093483068,
0.0441578664,
0.0556645542,
0.0359585732,
-0.0006532419,
0.0485999398,
0.0406398028,
-0.039287921,
0.0386736169,
-0.0340489484,
0.0068223211,
-0.0356864817,
0.0323260613,
0.0608242378,
-0.0346566886,
0.0516670533,
0.059954688,
0.0391141474,
0.008798968,
0.0000018821,
0.0015836628,
0.0091937305,
-0.0196256489,
-0.027840117,
0.0143134547,
0.0765072703,
-0.007157045,
-0.0065423935,
0.0105590923,
-0.0255600121,
-0.0270577651,
0.0357646532,
0.0555566773,
0.0792887956,
0.0459928066,
-0.0172851812,
0.0157056004,
-0.0270060487,
-0.0031839604,
-0.0194728989,
-0.0277293604,
0.0070685642,
-0.01834701,
-0.0279776081,
-0.0973421186,
-0.0408285409,
0.0017700288,
0.0042184009,
0.016364092,
0.0240173601,
-0.0141724395,
-0.0600998141,
-0.0171959382,
-0.0102997469,
0.0643729046,
0.0243428499,
0.0186237488,
0.0232581552,
-0.0010701801,
-0.0205452945,
-0.0573567115,
0.0012190944,
-0.0161181483,
0.0146468151,
0.0180798564,
-0.0212218575,
0.0744425356,
0.0004262625,
0.0214223545,
-0.0258924887,
0.0396415442,
-0.0509280525,
0.0017057983,
0.0086642979,
-0.0582612455,
-0.0244019609,
0.0219186116,
0.0070044287,
-0.0361376591,
0.0028213887,
-0.0168459322,
-0.0239613745,
-0.0049583488,
-0.0357440859,
-0.0055762897,
-0.0069490676,
-0.0028877386,
-0.0398496576,
0.0391223878,
0.0499608666,
-0.0117163192,
0.0271602459,
-0.0218758136,
-0.0194134843,
0.0284106247,
-0.0427914821,
0.0551499873,
-0.0097914413,
0.01830801,
-0.0002066788,
-0.0411700048,
-0.0898008421,
-0.0554420948,
-0.0581704751,
-0.0050179404,
-0.0290139001,
0.0201992802,
-0.0043179221,
-0.0028213614,
0.0396974459,
0.0291843731,
-0.0355289951,
0.0661229044,
0.0109109394,
-0.0509444401,
0.0141645577,
0.0199202597,
0.0272846222,
-0.006703733,
0.0218346138,
-0.0243314411,
-0.0166642834,
-0.0271678045,
-0.0350625701,
-0.0491286218,
-0.0200054571,
-0.0459384657,
-0.0297738984,
-0.0317648873,
0.059967272,
-0.0463018455,
0.0084751155,
-0.0134660583,
0.0060127671,
-0.0608075522,
0.0136252567,
0.0743181407,
0.0251809284,
-0.0126549415,
-0.0091609238,
0.0411059521,
0.0691541508,
0.0133303385,
0.0279744565,
0.0370867476,
0.0592417903,
-0.0300642811,
0.0203192327,
0.0330839902,
-0.0122351805,
-0.004105398,
0.0050814841,
-0.0464008637,
-0.0067186942,
0.0513388664,
0.0528683625,
-0.0298624597,
-0.0305423904,
-0.0256492905,
0.0058871903,
0.0603069961,
-0.0141446861,
-0.0163764004,
-0.0186260268,
0.0291598327,
0.0422507003,
-0.0253453515,
-0.0169612281,
-0.008020577,
-0.0258444883,
-0.0394611023,
0.0146762468,
0.0052484605,
-0.0245729908,
-0.0663032979,
-0.0024907331,
-0.0080815814,
-0.0209226031,
0.0427441113,
0.0321872644,
-0.010578285,
-0.0004437921,
0.0497027077,
-0.0009079685,
-0.1090552956,
0.0163676161,
-0.0155249452,
0.0129218679,
0.0488946438,
0.0020105066,
-0.0920715854,
-0.031321235,
-0.0426716059,
0.0201276746,
-0.0005448824,
0.022900695,
-0.0269731879,
0.0768124834,
-0.086677894,
0.0120575484,
0.0434092171,
0.0233641546,
0.0170782525,
-0.011240528,
0.0195479486,
-0.0039979769,
-0.0189770181,
0.0373737849,
0.0061894739,
-0.0276237577,
-0.045941785,
0.0067692203,
0.0182796344,
0.0555564053,
0.0418088585,
-0.0199160185,
-0.046820581,
0.0415916443,
-0.0080061937,
0.0317863673,
0.0261122659,
-0.0103648184,
-0.0362762138,
0.0416223072,
-0.0173831619,
0.0090513472,
0.0649640188,
-0.0757825077,
-0.0400807932,
0.0555316359,
0.0584161878,
-0.004936154,
-0.0250319298,
0.0110208625,
-0.0183190927,
0.0510424264,
0.0111556286,
-0.0074222605,
-0.0116637349,
-0.0081823617,
-0.0032699071,
0.0173998754,
0.0169324297,
-0.0278557483,
-0.0591535084,
-0.0155003443,
-0.019708775,
0.0229943339,
0.0007447317,
-0.0543142818,
-0.0440491475,
-0.0273981914,
-0.0707584471,
-0.0021354454,
-0.011985912,
0.002656189,
-0.0231249239,
-0.0000745215,
-0.0245957673,
0.0008877939,
-0.0160047542,
0.0308049005,
-0.0152749829,
-0.0189027227,
-0.0224211048,
-0.0223378595,
-0.0160395578,
-0.0737904534,
0.0201551374,
-0.0219540298,
-0.0357915312,
-0.0177326426,
-0.0123954592,
-0.0103360629,
0.0160594173,
0.0053092605,
0.0257339869,
-0.0238514859,
-0.0344299302,
-0.0146485707,
-0.0072820634,
-0.0187937766,
0.0849656612,
0.0021353806,
0.1058849245,
-0.0143814245,
0.0048663523,
-0.0258625317,
0.0478172489,
-0.0137328608,
0.0425753668,
-0.0402790755,
-0.0469075739,
-0.0119685493,
0.0554137789,
0.0241521262,
0.0344287492,
-0.0220568571,
-0.0270605516,
-0.0137068126,
-0.0513596833,
0.004739135,
-0.0146392072,
-0.0233958922,
-0.0041485373,
-0.0058786194,
-0.02510841,
-0.0273827072,
0.0114861615,
-0.0434919558,
-0.0140702361,
-0.0324903615,
-0.0498113111,
0.0884405822,
-0.0614695251,
-0.00715581,
0.0279665422,
-0.0094628893,
-0.0019393137,
-0.0639988035,
0.0046124491,
-0.0623076148,
0.0207719374,
-0.0022568298,
-0.0502216816,
0.0098198708,
-0.0322655737,
-0.0103066871,
-0.025637975,
-0.0407405756,
0.0006796317,
0.0023932809,
-0.0319960304,
-0.0125973634,
-0.0278551579,
-0.0051933751,
-0.008043997,
0.0077287098,
0.0120824473,
0.0015568055,
0.0733089969,
0.0008638744,
0.0258979052,
0.0262725074,
0.0037034925,
0.0194428451,
0.0467637405,
0.0737068132,
0.0165578388,
-0.029232502,
0.0327887461,
0.0298303459,
0.0241390616,
0.0096814986,
-0.0262242202,
0.0070087472,
-0.0340357609,
0.0553819835,
0.1372146606,
0.0593909733,
-0.0550949723,
0.0004104947,
-0.0115526924,
0.0052161543,
0.0256910305,
0.0062928651,
-0.0460425951,
-0.0428466499,
0.0147676822,
0.029279571,
0.0214327965,
-0.0130714206,
0.0138702057,
-0.0534408912,
0.0619942769,
0.0173795763,
0.0419003367,
-0.0173697304,
-0.0181519054,
0.0173103213,
-0.0509817228,
-0.0189308859,
-0.052345641,
0.0235184524,
-0.0281097014,
0.0556688458,
-0.0471364707,
-0.0439896807,
0.0564741194,
0.0013247755,
0.0703919008,
-0.0061596176,
0.0690596476,
-0.0218407363,
-0.0074059214,
0.0428777821,
-0.0066283033,
-0.0543865152,
-0.004778774,
0.0595081151,
-0.0009482669,
-0.006053084,
0.0003786087,
0.0491424538,
-0.0413885824,
0.0015242522,
0.0043408233,
0.0527728051,
-0.0070753004,
-0.0181386936,
-0.0202085897,
0.0603997447,
0.0423007198,
0.0399961732,
0.0139248893,
-0.0173550025,
-0.0139202187,
0.0222231802,
0.035125643,
-0.0148351118,
-0.0415561013,
-0.0250986163,
0.0121781714,
-0.0619750805,
-0.0464626215,
-0.0501082242,
0.007459308,
0.0212741271,
-0.0320654288,
-0.0556327328,
-0.00285869,
0.0027304774,
-0.0370036587,
0.0607765652,
0.0290531553,
0.0353359058,
-0.0548443273,
-0.0099444436,
0.0252256915,
-0.0214440059,
-0.0175254475,
0.0371972881,
-0.0176079236,
-0.0394499712,
0.04453668,
-0.0200196914,
0.015016255,
0.0276616029,
-0.001066582,
-0.0268178023,
0.0544407144,
0.0206515417,
0.0112593509,
0.01402291,
0.1077153832,
0.0087831328,
-0.0534050651,
0.0204323921,
-0.025541544,
0.0899046212,
-0.0115519417,
-0.04052094,
-0.05281993,
-0.0741023868,
-0.058193069,
0.0043730973,
0.0773954391,
0.0232077669,
-0.0259032622,
-0.0464206524,
-0.0031204061,
0.0176636875,
0.0186449606,
-0.0606427006,
-0.0412028618,
0.0079783937,
0.0031806498,
-0.070823811,
-0.0133369751,
0.007950454,
-0.0650802255,
-0.0046574534,
0.0472128391,
0.0445737839,
0.0298160296,
-0.0155981919,
0.0275272802,
-0.0002706308,
0.0295780543,
-0.0297024399,
-0.0229422823,
0.0064101191,
0.024778923,
-0.0030387023,
0.0050711553,
-0.0357475206,
0.0173976868,
0.0142827565,
0.0359909572,
-0.0459015705,
-0.0255206935,
0.0130205406,
-0.0509166829,
0.0588467903,
-0.0135563379,
0.0189963039,
-0.011992652,
0.0015214642,
-0.0347391628,
-0.048512198,
0.0107514337,
0.0073673157,
-0.0136707211,
0.0183701459,
0.02690617,
-0.0267870855,
0.0642447919,
0.0022559969,
0.0141364569,
-0.0470668823,
-0.0115699247,
0.0751180351,
-0.0330559574,
0.0016957324,
0.0206405334,
-0.0487774871,
-0.0347430333,
0.0561206527,
-0.0387133546,
-0.0097766723,
-0.0117239375,
-0.0047108182,
0.0216254666,
-0.0631356686,
0.0222181249,
-0.0097748321,
-0.0180557724,
-0.0774941817,
-0.0167940799,
-0.0045888578,
-5.692049643e-33,
0.0167117193,
0.0498869792,
-0.056085702,
-0.0101713752,
-0.0384228304,
0.0383878201,
-0.0108860638,
0.0273747612,
-0.0023401978,
0.055272337,
-0.0068413927,
0.0350068435,
0.0197937936,
0.0258919485,
0.0270359349,
-0.0369650461,
0.056575004,
-0.051290527,
0.003425065,
0.043727465,
0.0309087988,
0.003135934,
0.0426422283,
-0.0993472636,
-0.0151380803,
0.0024260872,
-0.0638886839,
0.0194580071,
0.0474522598,
0.0392947495,
0.0018268001,
0.0418157205,
-0.0130350031,
-0.0214055125,
0.0155019825,
0.0019317982,
-0.0586981215,
0.0273029059,
-0.0531594865,
0.0339591578,
-0.0424778238,
-0.0417149812,
-0.0184138548,
0.0334580056,
-0.0221579261,
-0.0551957116,
0.052335836,
-0.0169424228,
0.0112846466,
-0.0751647353,
-0.0103769545,
0.0420330428,
-0.0332893692,
-0.0440029725,
0.0475023873,
0.0569406636,
-0.0002908011,
-0.0148574375,
-0.0372320823,
0.0136013636,
-0.0068797627,
-0.0086367009,
0.0034296946,
-0.0043329336,
-0.0179478619,
0.0677689314,
0.0612232052,
-0.0257020853,
0.0298158079,
0.0354364142,
0.0186929889,
0.0599022098,
0.0269768685,
0.0209302511,
-0.010407513,
-0.0160231814,
0.0216985885,
0.0221370943,
0.0690804422,
-0.0301919151,
0.0422164612,
0.0064357803,
-0.0420829691,
0.0089759538,
-0.006788847,
-0.0153756784,
-0.0124230776,
0.0300918724,
0.0498163216,
0.0051855156,
0.0087411264,
-0.0103146378,
0.0195533372,
-0.0058020642,
0.0235553887,
0.0216624532,
0.0081534274,
0.0530344285,
0.0011585481,
0.0266231522,
-0.024791969,
-0.0271467846,
0.0775087848,
0.0117324162,
0.0788647905,
-0.0320914946,
-0.0097334264,
0.0321076401,
-0.0450512916,
0.0094820159,
0.0099501573,
0.0692220852,
-0.0121612968,
0.0284527801,
-0.0402618386,
-0.01565657,
-0.0017338673,
-0.0074992529,
-0.004859224,
0.0473573655,
-0.0077407751,
0.0008407947,
-0.0464458913,
0.0426593684,
-0.0362385921,
0.016321199,
0.0054043243,
-0.0565833375,
-0.0035242038,
0.0160802621,
0.003906752,
-0.0185402017,
2.607e-7,
-0.0550579764,
0.0050743902,
0.0378920846,
-0.0555177927,
0.0189416204,
0.0435250513,
-0.0135180764,
0.0374341421,
0.0083871959,
0.0235724822,
0.0813391507,
-0.0017565344,
0.065871805,
0.0057768733,
-0.0877745524,
-0.0280090272,
0.0269618183,
0.050040029,
0.0081753228,
-0.0150523074,
0.0579759441,
0.0875463188,
0.0505184606,
0.0126512889,
0.0280989427,
-0.0040532979,
-0.0062109777,
-0.0282984339,
0.0155763943,
0.046969071,
-0.021893559,
-0.0355054662,
-0.0244235303,
-0.0346504524,
-0.0100486167,
0.0041181464,
0.0263246652,
0.0667262301,
0.035021849,
-0.0651999041,
0.0057588797,
0.0399098769,
-0.0071307989,
0.0193394702,
0.0393447988,
-0.0574239902,
-0.0414061919,
-0.0102304313,
-0.0421242639,
0.0193848573,
-0.00414907,
-0.0166471973,
-0.0175697282,
0.0329671539,
-0.0017174302,
-0.0334331729,
-0.0424972773,
-0.1082623303,
-0.0144389328,
0.0361665636,
-0.0674670935,
-0.0012460775,
-0.0073077851,
0.0518048145,
0.0354598798,
-0.0397760794,
-0.0015632651,
2.046094625e-34,
0.0070445226,
-0.0163420569,
-0.0361342169,
0.0182039123,
0.0201794561,
0.0012112346,
-0.0512715876,
-0.0379309356,
0.0647515357,
-0.0185001437,
0.0308525544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12982v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12982v1 | Conversation Derailment Forecasting with Graph Convolutional Networks | 2023-06-22T15:40:59 | 2023-06-22T15:40:59 | Enas Altarawneh, Ammeta Agrawal, Michael Jenkin, Manos Papagelis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Online conversations are particularly susceptible to derailment, which can
manifest itself in the form of toxic communication patterns like disrespectful
comments or verbal abuse. Forecasting conversation derailment predicts signs of
derailment in advance enabling proactive moderation of conversations. Current
state-of-the-art approaches to address this problem rely on sequence models
that treat dialogues as text streams. We propose a novel model based on a graph
convolutional neural network that considers dialogue user dynamics and the
influence of public perception on conversation utterances. Through empirical
evaluation, we show that our model effectively captures conversation dynamics
and outperforms the state-of-the-art models on the CGA and CMV benchmark
datasets by 1.5\% and 1.7\%, respectively. | [
0.0480679087,
0.0891358331,
-0.0155414231,
0.0088345427,
-0.037680354,
-0.0043823775,
0.0042091808,
-0.0005868494,
0.0350750051,
-0.0373692513,
0.0132971108,
-0.0493454747,
-0.0288575925,
0.0819863454,
-0.0030602976,
-0.0323928483,
0.0235445183,
0.0150870243,
0.0334957279,
0.0161460973,
0.0759288892,
0.001809126,
0.0018273686,
0.0393048525,
-0.0365056805,
-0.0191404,
-0.0115683191,
0.0441182591,
0.0128730945,
-0.0272153132,
0.0443853401,
0.0542511344,
0.0471057408,
0.0626137033,
0.0000018389,
-0.0167570394,
-0.0147671402,
-0.0219390839,
-0.010902537,
-0.0059882822,
0.0154907228,
-0.0233540349,
0.0103458837,
0.0413651876,
-0.0314106196,
0.0137685295,
0.0124978982,
0.0445940979,
0.0777658746,
0.1190543026,
-0.0180861745,
-0.0399814248,
0.0334119312,
-0.0355486572,
-0.021584712,
-0.0816228986,
0.0168355461,
-0.0184909701,
-0.060336072,
-0.0456215441,
-0.0205686465,
-0.0291081425,
-0.0015719157,
-0.03331111,
0.0055587403,
0.0007483886,
-0.0212748554,
-0.0405790173,
-0.0187224876,
0.1119045243,
-0.0148273511,
-0.0188220982,
0.0265214927,
-0.012499705,
0.0279376414,
-0.0225647129,
-0.0822914094,
-0.0502887145,
-0.0037949467,
0.0139510613,
-0.0613480285,
0.008351298,
0.0481810533,
0.0249291752,
0.0405668095,
0.0165568516,
-0.0306139253,
-0.0171199366,
-0.0254699457,
-0.0174233243,
0.0148332305,
-0.0542638116,
0.0104640108,
-0.0013309352,
-0.0702816173,
-0.0118029304,
-0.0412970632,
-0.026009405,
-0.0271681193,
-0.0284372289,
0.0061222469,
-0.0102530671,
0.0423875041,
0.0052252454,
0.0325533822,
0.0276426356,
-0.0125442501,
0.0015698158,
0.0147236148,
0.0124711609,
-0.0575616136,
0.0140801575,
-0.0216018297,
-0.0167939924,
0.0038521264,
-0.045375064,
-0.0477269888,
0.0204677302,
-0.0462798141,
-0.0079932846,
-0.0142535018,
0.0485031903,
-0.0131541304,
-0.0080044689,
0.0060301302,
0.0440875217,
-0.0030436111,
0.0251793824,
0.0221152492,
-0.044288151,
-0.0042195069,
0.0080709187,
0.0366023183,
0.0296786241,
-0.0087135704,
0.0751583576,
0.0106650265,
-0.0355188884,
-0.0242642723,
-0.0216926429,
-0.0358778648,
-0.0619265549,
0.0204068869,
-0.0349820442,
0.0271718875,
-0.0317599848,
-0.031298805,
-0.0193974543,
0.0373869166,
-0.0146668078,
-0.0246867854,
0.0370367914,
0.0200775452,
-0.0007834668,
0.0340843908,
0.030240193,
-0.0113357175,
0.0455522053,
0.0322623774,
0.0317996703,
0.0515796617,
-0.0099012218,
0.0085761566,
0.0229991917,
0.0688569546,
-0.0077428026,
-0.014218499,
-0.0037992811,
-0.0603015982,
0.0044287648,
0.0020962888,
0.0164838042,
-0.0376582369,
-0.060056828,
0.0633316934,
0.0543151721,
-0.0766059831,
0.0360230617,
0.0257549938,
0.0680955648,
-0.0623780154,
-0.0094742086,
-0.0392059535,
-0.0002451314,
0.0086816875,
-0.0161288939,
0.0311659984,
0.0104858493,
-0.0312248506,
-0.0328512713,
0.0245772041,
-0.0268395506,
0.0863820761,
-0.0043525239,
-0.0135088358,
0.0066945399,
-0.0538039915,
0.0172753781,
0.0151361935,
-0.0121875647,
-0.0540453233,
-0.0258780438,
-0.0081250453,
0.0803161561,
0.0343686379,
0.0180540569,
-0.0861478522,
-0.0853495449,
0.0396475792,
-0.0037019036,
0.0274690464,
-0.0050019627,
0.0160440821,
-0.0547536612,
-0.0006703325,
0.0011435969,
-0.0068319142,
0.0237166099,
0.0147880623,
-0.0039106212,
-0.0055024698,
0.0249407329,
-0.041116178,
0.0026818356,
0.0312638767,
0.0041527469,
0.0287509821,
-0.0044223601,
0.0711442456,
0.0155454613,
0.000987464,
-0.0172697362,
0.0276456121,
0.0220302008,
-0.0501946956,
-0.0078511126,
-0.0620383359,
-0.0182561371,
0.0437236764,
0.0114717018,
-0.0187972467,
-0.0078248065,
-0.0596046969,
-0.0116321146,
0.0843379125,
-0.0454645343,
0.0075604897,
0.0116470139,
-0.0171868112,
-0.0023884305,
0.0389812365,
0.0340328962,
-0.0045191287,
-0.0507337302,
-0.0229457971,
-0.0152846379,
-0.0199486185,
-0.0117886569,
-0.0060959784,
-0.0162371174,
-0.0136394808,
-0.0082354899,
0.0235628076,
0.0223939698,
-0.0037221203,
-0.0443643779,
0.0061222329,
-0.1012507156,
-0.0215793289,
-0.029175058,
-0.0010012834,
0.0112653133,
0.0045352308,
-0.0050223768,
-0.0388669446,
-0.0350318849,
0.0297499578,
0.0364153758,
0.0066027329,
0.0050435732,
-0.0191388708,
-0.0307828616,
-0.0548729077,
-0.0117605077,
-0.0132648507,
0.0546654463,
-0.0073832707,
-0.075211212,
0.028836688,
-0.0118961297,
-0.0370707549,
0.0450792611,
-0.0509673916,
-0.0363913812,
-0.0142954066,
0.0369856469,
0.0192835238,
0.0481521599,
0.0462462232,
0.0933940858,
-0.0294216312,
-0.0212722849,
-0.0106304558,
0.0088714594,
-0.0455267131,
-0.0164242554,
-0.0606590584,
-0.0122200102,
-0.0328725427,
0.0337243676,
-0.0029539249,
0.0258970913,
-0.0292236768,
-0.0084474292,
-0.0081638079,
-0.0202690754,
-0.0112804985,
-0.0687878057,
-0.0176672265,
-0.0198654924,
-0.0326263383,
-0.0576979741,
0.0631652474,
0.0140564945,
0.0172911473,
0.0265406724,
-0.0519247018,
-0.0282190815,
0.0548756011,
0.0240605976,
-0.001364609,
0.0447241254,
-0.0154952249,
-0.030175237,
-0.052324295,
0.0443741307,
-0.0508418344,
-0.0055877082,
-0.0167771969,
0.0165010635,
0.0366676301,
-0.0161483418,
-0.022545876,
-0.0440953411,
-0.0129582817,
-0.0247203428,
-0.0043302835,
-0.0323073678,
-0.0370750241,
0.0117076552,
-0.0335201435,
-0.0014328144,
-0.0321390778,
0.0296767987,
0.0199199151,
0.0644259974,
0.0604412593,
0.0107348859,
-0.0029881226,
-0.051876504,
0.0341374502,
0.08556813,
-0.0106613655,
-0.0099663744,
0.0090838326,
-0.0252512638,
-0.0386904515,
0.0421639979,
-0.0229673591,
0.0051994622,
0.0311844721,
-0.0448264927,
-0.0244934186,
0.0843468979,
0.0024086004,
-0.0578685366,
-0.0037918845,
0.0517914444,
0.0414523259,
0.0222610552,
-0.022165386,
-0.0873061642,
-0.0209452379,
-0.0250803344,
0.0203002878,
0.0075041531,
-0.0499855727,
-0.016614899,
-0.0459300317,
0.0144138299,
0.0075776572,
-0.0044150329,
-0.0163544118,
0.0016013414,
0.0016340181,
0.0083380137,
0.0403245315,
-0.0547483787,
0.0349212363,
-0.0135392239,
0.0244250968,
-0.0778018162,
-0.0242286827,
0.0129783899,
-0.0163188186,
0.0386907049,
0.0014901218,
0.0858988315,
-0.0121444715,
0.0152962347,
0.0658836216,
0.0321242288,
-0.0318716876,
0.0278058425,
0.0921681747,
-0.0170234907,
0.0119156791,
-0.0225520898,
0.0564402975,
-0.0022239224,
-0.0198239759,
-0.0155930929,
0.0242771693,
0.0020672656,
-0.0429978259,
-0.0120832119,
0.0425413027,
0.0405458137,
-0.0080364887,
0.0501355678,
-0.0269900933,
-0.051884044,
-0.0266266279,
0.0275405496,
-0.0144800972,
-0.001267745,
-0.0398831554,
0.0144336997,
-0.0209125206,
-0.0354491211,
-0.0306812674,
-0.0329778232,
-0.013807022,
-0.032773152,
-0.0222580358,
0.0494216494,
-0.0166213382,
-0.0341224745,
-0.0015726674,
0.02887398,
0.0449399427,
-0.0483242571,
0.0218061619,
0.0044950359,
0.0519566871,
-0.0232293196,
0.0598504394,
-0.1254571378,
-0.07650242,
-0.0001066146,
0.0331055783,
0.0121333022,
0.0517108627,
-0.0016519353,
-0.0253023896,
-0.0092695877,
0.0411583707,
-0.013981482,
-0.0089662485,
0.0248514842,
0.0365867391,
-0.0049040304,
0.0251284502,
-0.0036192241,
0.0401530415,
-0.009574919,
-0.0107253836,
-0.0718195885,
-0.0622530058,
-0.0257139392,
-0.0297519434,
0.028188616,
0.0197923295,
-0.0116959633,
-0.0342498533,
-0.0059365113,
0.0019086909,
-0.0117997378,
-0.005315478,
0.0048102541,
0.0041973842,
-0.025922399,
-0.039736677,
-0.0263750106,
-0.0081309676,
0.0203769784,
-0.0635849461,
-0.0172656421,
0.0519700907,
-0.036941193,
0.0303867422,
-0.0116849253,
0.0067548552,
0.0385755971,
0.0247655045,
0.0044455719,
-0.0050763274,
0.0518369414,
0.0114054633,
0.0326351039,
0.0005381524,
0.0116835004,
-0.0526178144,
-0.0258814804,
-0.0370677039,
0.0108079156,
0.0284385066,
0.0178026389,
0.0590461642,
0.0305745825,
0.0015532293,
-0.0165025331,
0.0879418328,
-0.0572024919,
-0.0632046461,
0.0177118685,
0.0278633256,
-0.0461050197,
0.0646042377,
0.0411114655,
0.0407629013,
0.0152958119,
0.0530723296,
-0.0657584071,
-0.0341314115,
-0.0032907485,
0.0227002539,
0.0657248124,
0.0449176468,
0.0206713732,
-0.0468192063,
-0.0434068069,
0.037097577,
-0.029272614,
0.0362549797,
-0.0056747114,
0.0066921972,
0.0121043967,
-0.0000370372,
0.0335879624,
-0.0507338978,
0.0162824839,
-0.0000770997,
-0.0571159758,
-0.0089993076,
-5.438105027e-33,
0.005289149,
-0.05734431,
-0.0243360791,
0.0692881197,
-0.0483363904,
0.0258364696,
-0.0276647136,
-0.0151471728,
-0.0097340047,
0.0294763856,
0.0150165018,
0.0684505776,
-0.0012688044,
0.0199421514,
-0.0224719606,
-0.0348468237,
0.0372792929,
-0.0477374569,
0.0138968192,
0.0737499893,
0.0662034228,
0.030931592,
0.0142419096,
-0.066576764,
-0.0018121884,
-0.0220768489,
0.0018789192,
-0.0287955441,
0.0317702778,
0.033093255,
0.021068709,
0.0408784337,
0.0251718555,
0.0343805701,
0.0136134932,
0.0466374122,
-0.0243843868,
-0.0041593476,
-0.0643798932,
-0.0105510093,
-0.0047398303,
0.0246457197,
0.0215910934,
0.0333314799,
0.0419858135,
-0.0291900598,
0.0322304517,
0.0520016663,
-0.0180331077,
-0.0405863188,
-0.023577651,
0.0376041122,
-0.0593427569,
-0.0380390361,
-0.0198641662,
0.0417810641,
0.03226633,
-0.0332251303,
-0.0608309619,
0.0123023661,
-0.0449157506,
-0.0032420892,
-0.0190618522,
-0.002652508,
0.0058864304,
0.0442408025,
0.0278120358,
0.0499062315,
-0.0156801455,
0.0116954967,
-0.0091549829,
0.0632033795,
0.0034845371,
0.0168780349,
0.0016631788,
-0.0984295085,
-0.1009446904,
-0.0314023793,
0.031205507,
0.0343794078,
0.0152703645,
0.0245120656,
-0.0314474404,
-0.0448156223,
0.0205472689,
-0.0489302352,
0.0176944919,
-0.0012028236,
0.0034898033,
0.0211634804,
0.0172045063,
-0.0275412016,
0.0316784158,
-0.0573696233,
-0.0108471978,
0.0847427547,
-0.030498201,
0.0003266876,
0.0247929841,
0.0285127535,
-0.0675539151,
-0.007095241,
0.0107046915,
-0.0166759994,
0.0164842345,
-0.0403714254,
0.0555075034,
0.0241119675,
-0.0213678479,
-0.0120856445,
-0.0299364533,
0.0522982664,
-0.0504606552,
0.0646361709,
0.0214217193,
0.0265058558,
-0.037830025,
0.0657220036,
0.0213128384,
0.0540590659,
-0.0027879009,
-0.0024202953,
0.0041339267,
0.0070586321,
-0.0389296897,
-0.0074003213,
0.004950875,
0.0130914859,
0.012357302,
-0.0530139208,
0.0020416719,
-0.0252095349,
2.554e-7,
-0.0148510635,
0.0635960847,
0.0493380912,
0.0247939806,
0.0355443209,
0.046905309,
0.0161776543,
0.0420624614,
-0.0002348538,
-0.0276514404,
0.0690267831,
0.0307750516,
0.0065240241,
0.0656398833,
-0.0531636626,
-0.0044184355,
-0.1297432035,
0.0004384699,
-0.0036386345,
-0.0274116229,
0.0322417989,
0.0579916202,
0.0639408603,
-0.023458153,
0.0283627231,
0.0067129326,
0.0536310337,
-0.0149351116,
-0.0352158658,
0.0130965644,
0.0318830647,
-0.0068886317,
-0.0328708924,
0.0137676802,
-0.0315008871,
0.0424959846,
0.0117979413,
0.0312755778,
0.0011276569,
-0.0302226618,
-0.0202202797,
0.0107481163,
0.0082838144,
-0.0216196999,
0.0231474284,
-0.042927593,
-0.0363127403,
-0.053354267,
-0.0619391687,
-0.0017217693,
0.0642532855,
-0.0135438712,
0.0109650474,
0.0448078252,
0.0229294542,
-0.0120893521,
0.0181972496,
-0.0826187879,
0.0153179644,
0.008194983,
-0.0414266586,
-0.0245394222,
-0.0235332567,
0.0022621758,
0.0226381887,
0.0519393235,
0.0333964266,
1.879244337e-34,
0.0436091572,
-0.0125909876,
-0.0148157263,
-0.0189636312,
0.0259919371,
0.0050889207,
0.0075210799,
-0.0168375187,
0.0316461623,
-0.0415096134,
-0.0219913702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12951v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12951v2 | Public Attitudes Toward ChatGPT on Twitter: Sentiments, Topics, and Occupations | 2023-06-22T15:10:18 | 2024-02-13T20:53:00 | Ratanond Koonchanok, Yanling Pan, Hyeju Jang | cs.CL | cs.CL | ChatGPT sets a new record with the fastest-growing user base, as a chatbot
powered by a large language model (LLM). While it demonstrates state-of-the-art
capabilities in a variety of language-generation tasks, it also raises
widespread public concerns regarding its societal impact. In this paper, we
investigated public attitudes towards ChatGPT by applying natural language
processing techniques such as sentiment analysis and topic modeling to Twitter
data from December 5, 2022 to June 10, 2023. Our sentiment analysis result
indicates that the overall sentiment was largely neutral to positive, and
negative sentiments were decreasing over time. Our topic model reveals that the
most popular topics discussed were Education, Bard, Search Engines, OpenAI,
Marketing, and Cybersecurity, but the ranking varies by month. We also analyzed
the occupations of Twitter users and found that those with occupations in arts
and entertainment tweeted aboutChatGPT most frequently. Additionally, people
tended to tweet about topics relevant to their occupation. For instance,
Cybersecurity is the most discussed topic among those with occupations related
to computer and math, and Education is the most discussed topic among those in
academic and research. Overall, our exploratory study provides insights into
the public perception of ChatGPT, which could be valuable to both the general
public and developers of this technology. | [
0.0739425272,
0.0391580351,
-0.011471766,
-0.0299051069,
-0.0520551726,
-0.0042700986,
0.0244248137,
0.0035392083,
0.0635290816,
-0.054478202,
0.0290638618,
-0.0112057002,
-0.0250250809,
0.0478889532,
0.0179325752,
-0.0189729165,
0.0091291331,
0.0356164128,
0.0522230342,
0.0124719441,
0.0370452777,
0.0414216481,
-0.0155365774,
0.0684437156,
-0.0040898076,
-0.0317658857,
0.022650877,
-0.015169017,
0.0183319263,
-0.017869344,
0.0359419473,
0.0315499939,
0.0034578389,
0.0578001216,
0.0000018205,
-0.0284592248,
-0.0378086343,
-0.0019662429,
0.0240720436,
-0.0202645306,
0.119598344,
0.0324511155,
-0.041119013,
0.063645713,
-0.0676194131,
0.042197641,
0.0541739054,
0.0170915686,
0.0514499508,
0.0578671135,
-0.0354514979,
-0.0007681897,
-0.0384725891,
0.0037353749,
-0.0053285141,
-0.0037935404,
0.0054484201,
-0.0202678666,
0.0042506917,
0.0387927406,
0.0291560367,
0.0333370976,
-0.0282915495,
-0.0255357195,
0.0195871219,
0.0349046774,
-0.0439646579,
-0.0418740213,
0.0226949118,
0.0235602278,
0.0503002815,
-0.029181974,
0.035154622,
0.0205810051,
0.0267430525,
0.0056201061,
-0.0394390374,
0.0267454032,
-0.0030753305,
0.006485716,
-0.003222923,
-0.0214604344,
-0.004250057,
0.0450909734,
0.0317886584,
0.0402130671,
0.0006650237,
-0.0370535664,
-0.0298239682,
0.0186031479,
0.0286932457,
-0.039609652,
0.0477492549,
-0.0019994592,
-0.0073081283,
0.0196001548,
0.0001323571,
-0.0132418089,
0.0044623027,
-0.0683508441,
-0.0855338424,
0.0453695394,
0.0116542494,
0.0391483791,
0.0585655048,
-0.0135713788,
0.0002925757,
0.0023151161,
0.0357951447,
-0.0072909151,
-0.0717335567,
-0.0123954862,
-0.0010781561,
0.0161272679,
0.0377361253,
-0.0126494933,
-0.0379185751,
0.0292049292,
-0.0026428134,
-0.0129009597,
-0.0101391915,
-0.0099159786,
-0.0123391449,
0.0126707451,
-0.020518668,
0.0575808324,
-0.0367060378,
0.0167568102,
-0.0076698712,
-0.0291705858,
0.0346317068,
0.0091863023,
0.0230710059,
-0.0107680429,
-0.0084676547,
0.0554080755,
0.029113356,
-0.034902323,
0.0016767407,
-0.0420270115,
-0.0091517679,
-0.0128513426,
-0.0013544826,
-0.0572273917,
-0.0070150397,
0.046711009,
0.0021161097,
0.0209697485,
0.0172418449,
0.0415525436,
-0.0528593808,
0.0034011307,
-0.0560022406,
0.0212514009,
0.0396540649,
0.0285278521,
0.0043932088,
0.0462695956,
0.0288126096,
0.0626590028,
0.0478283241,
-0.0029701665,
0.0056670508,
0.0254341718,
-0.0388891622,
-0.0287876949,
0.0210827682,
-0.0170711279,
-0.0322791338,
-0.0229775552,
-0.0463223979,
0.0535180643,
0.0005090708,
0.0328137092,
0.0433597341,
0.0694567338,
-0.0200893208,
0.0449925326,
-0.032156568,
0.0743220001,
0.0137817506,
-0.0463459529,
0.0095654447,
0.0149243688,
-0.0540716201,
-0.036347881,
0.0279141627,
0.0270503815,
-0.0163073037,
-0.0195028391,
0.000288461,
-0.0184422452,
0.0779623836,
-0.0134766474,
0.0384646021,
-0.0581085831,
-0.0303896181,
0.011679681,
0.0219608769,
-0.0642842948,
-0.0229659416,
-0.0625230595,
-0.006780684,
0.1088676155,
0.016074311,
0.0186591502,
-0.0254184306,
-0.0274570957,
0.0068138307,
0.0543033928,
0.0047765998,
0.0188663378,
-0.0663841665,
-0.0075607416,
0.0088438932,
0.027822908,
0.0086499816,
0.0025921501,
0.0291874222,
0.0533982031,
-0.0152057577,
-0.004736362,
-0.0028699874,
-0.0292890947,
0.0062319827,
0.0080127362,
-0.0480912253,
0.0080540348,
0.0116333552,
0.0701941773,
-0.0078382166,
-0.0045002848,
0.0056332024,
0.0054085762,
-0.0480533056,
0.0171773881,
0.0098257512,
0.0473804101,
0.0436099172,
-0.0527236909,
-0.0386797152,
0.0553641655,
-0.0098882699,
0.0116638048,
0.091531381,
-0.031449616,
0.052404549,
0.0004422595,
-0.0197920166,
-0.0531549007,
-0.0103761926,
-0.0004691935,
0.0233975314,
0.0072450992,
-0.0303299204,
-0.0006521267,
-0.0502232276,
0.0032474978,
-0.0263720322,
-0.0388042256,
0.0258361548,
-0.0040903213,
0.0425881371,
0.0630481765,
0.0046353987,
-0.0723584741,
-0.0117857605,
-0.1119067818,
-0.0001523407,
-0.0261951499,
0.0028331287,
0.0407510325,
0.010786362,
-0.0023974574,
0.0058601005,
-0.0472009815,
0.0002110905,
0.0073299184,
0.0241810158,
0.0360404998,
-0.0331791006,
-0.0145723522,
-0.0375504866,
-0.0119178565,
-0.0484079532,
-0.0151616717,
0.0629527494,
-0.0661978722,
0.0083552795,
0.0322001725,
-0.0430738479,
-0.0266710836,
-0.0277364608,
-0.0411500372,
0.0480063222,
-0.026371805,
0.0034706367,
-0.0117056519,
0.050377503,
0.0362916626,
0.0138938436,
0.0110548185,
-0.0274340324,
-0.0140207391,
-0.0106873903,
-0.0287921559,
0.0078670932,
-0.0525419861,
-0.0019429193,
0.0192194488,
-0.0002024924,
0.0124868779,
-0.0535168909,
0.0244910102,
-0.051976081,
0.0096621206,
-0.0521425717,
0.02165135,
-0.0139394468,
0.0114135239,
0.0303498358,
-0.0112754703,
0.013201125,
0.0363252833,
0.0180467758,
-0.0537394211,
-0.0563414618,
-0.0124238022,
0.0308572259,
-0.0162779335,
0.0250982437,
0.0349737965,
-0.021028582,
-0.003365021,
-0.0168690626,
-0.0087739574,
-0.0682069138,
-0.0360378101,
0.010515633,
0.0012322671,
0.0159060527,
0.0192617029,
0.0033405167,
-0.0734544992,
-0.0679635108,
-0.0178369749,
0.0442895144,
-0.0591766462,
-0.0044274372,
0.0020721287,
0.0203874335,
-0.0497216508,
0.0154321408,
-0.028312251,
0.009430849,
-0.0016746637,
0.0264599863,
0.0042487066,
-0.0265513547,
0.0423921086,
-0.006614862,
0.0602278896,
0.0277594682,
-0.0180367753,
-0.0328840986,
-0.0662273914,
0.0136171319,
-0.0099465474,
-0.0237284414,
0.0061729886,
0.0577516258,
-0.00294494,
0.0222611614,
0.1068262756,
0.0228368696,
-0.0182953775,
-0.025937451,
-0.0013169438,
-0.0015933329,
-0.004591865,
0.0145270936,
-0.100318253,
0.0073834429,
-0.0100522749,
0.0299620479,
-0.0293737501,
-0.0323309302,
-0.0177071616,
-0.0813704431,
0.0202918928,
0.0005809238,
-0.0154021233,
0.0165896341,
-0.0566956624,
-0.0067599164,
-0.0127576329,
0.0181698818,
-0.0472578295,
-0.0103677856,
0.0136679718,
0.0083339168,
-0.0972332582,
-0.0339526273,
0.0504341833,
-0.0211803019,
0.0683392584,
0.0323953778,
0.0833233446,
-0.0239314754,
0.0157263353,
0.0068645515,
0.0702142417,
-0.0065940646,
0.0069399229,
0.0431028642,
-0.0218630861,
0.0137443906,
-0.0566570871,
-0.0122907078,
-0.0599412732,
0.0104238335,
-0.0107155778,
0.033503864,
-0.0181545876,
-0.0081487373,
-0.0369319506,
0.0397500508,
0.0359062888,
0.0639893711,
-0.0107643371,
-0.0598356128,
-0.0086535448,
-0.0455818623,
0.012582914,
0.0381061025,
-0.0579128936,
-0.0579070672,
-0.0120084258,
-0.088786684,
-0.0459371619,
-0.0384402536,
0.0058970307,
-0.0085159522,
-0.0168206915,
-0.0038122099,
0.076368466,
0.0196020678,
-0.0191572532,
-0.0002120822,
-0.0240315758,
0.0258719996,
-0.0322323926,
-0.0437167808,
0.0189493168,
-0.000748441,
0.0017680676,
0.0069524986,
-0.0643277094,
-0.0471719652,
0.0154222669,
-0.0276279319,
0.0307669565,
-0.0139398826,
-0.0345221162,
-0.000527581,
0.002254532,
0.0858328938,
-0.0472107977,
0.0035196221,
0.0331587046,
0.0813795626,
0.0182380844,
-0.0008757388,
-0.0288568176,
-0.0135740396,
-0.0324618965,
-0.023513861,
-0.0478544012,
-0.0059927683,
0.0192797873,
0.0548070818,
0.0455679931,
0.0205343403,
0.0062136604,
-0.0082723824,
-0.0743052885,
-0.0456869677,
0.0030740553,
-0.0152821541,
-0.0282711834,
0.008446455,
0.0025001119,
-0.01717842,
0.0111507745,
-0.0469855405,
0.0090877954,
-0.0442065261,
0.0293291546,
-0.0429751538,
0.0242841095,
0.0045548445,
-0.022529209,
-0.0023087072,
0.0016425772,
0.0074495701,
-0.0028879426,
-0.0057939156,
0.0245560128,
-0.0288798176,
-0.0109994411,
0.0493899919,
0.0501787812,
-0.06680163,
-0.0941740125,
0.0159282293,
0.0724104121,
0.0150907459,
0.0186587442,
0.0557668582,
-0.0537217744,
0.0021430699,
-0.0074286233,
0.0307183489,
-0.0065617641,
-0.0188901853,
-0.0092224432,
-0.0225120392,
-0.045472119,
-0.0127480123,
0.0451591201,
-0.0185448062,
-0.0029661944,
0.0451346859,
-0.0417270511,
-0.0164216775,
-0.0033732224,
-0.0162951611,
0.018414909,
0.019616304,
0.0183683969,
-0.0382913761,
-0.0306084491,
0.0012625366,
-0.046409592,
0.0197691601,
-0.0173154119,
0.0334608294,
0.0629179031,
-0.0352425389,
0.0295908526,
-0.0577189066,
-0.006758546,
-0.0252170116,
-0.0410303697,
-0.014626204,
-6.553541902e-33,
0.0305732004,
-0.0433663428,
-0.0025184022,
0.0194092076,
-0.0194322243,
-0.0143751735,
-0.0193121433,
0.0642082468,
-0.0303230844,
-0.0139261577,
-0.0344923846,
0.0590202287,
0.0198945086,
-0.0047562593,
0.0298905335,
-0.0318495929,
0.0631601214,
-0.0173468702,
0.0032605838,
0.0597680286,
0.0482125543,
0.0025711427,
0.0340382792,
-0.1271420866,
0.0708178133,
-0.0228388291,
-0.035666123,
-0.0321082696,
0.07220532,
-0.0006098439,
-0.0262713768,
0.0678259432,
0.0229392573,
-0.023391882,
0.0070529617,
0.056194216,
-0.011544643,
-0.0154352039,
-0.0180943049,
0.0031886643,
0.0203226916,
-0.0400447138,
0.0199356265,
-0.0037818053,
-0.0646596253,
0.0380297489,
0.0467881002,
0.0204509087,
0.0584421046,
0.0088639371,
-0.036830578,
0.0133418534,
-0.0446714535,
-0.0031567998,
-0.0210796334,
0.0376228616,
0.0171819683,
0.0376807451,
-0.050096374,
0.0613156706,
-0.0072291554,
-0.0243428741,
0.0237919446,
-0.0571685284,
-0.0097765457,
0.0525562763,
0.0203385968,
0.0344453603,
-0.0112714879,
-0.0307077821,
-0.0107047614,
-0.0082636112,
0.0112867635,
0.0368259475,
0.0154662225,
-0.0604845174,
-0.0462008975,
0.0134748891,
0.0771835521,
0.0105040325,
0.0418969393,
-0.0052588484,
-0.0602187328,
-0.0211517271,
0.0488591231,
-0.0226515997,
-0.0316664167,
-0.0471239462,
-0.021795949,
-0.0258783679,
-0.028359836,
-0.0383504219,
0.0076167784,
-0.0522131398,
-0.0290445853,
0.0398969725,
-0.0545997545,
0.0140186409,
0.0019015607,
0.0310661085,
-0.0659674332,
0.0041095549,
-0.0125290584,
0.0406420752,
0.0062981653,
0.0110810008,
-0.0348157808,
0.0468634553,
-0.0494779609,
-0.0222583972,
0.0106502613,
0.0288128462,
0.0011087701,
-0.0247815121,
0.0186517723,
0.0118385181,
0.0192745514,
0.0245740842,
0.055648312,
0.0439672023,
-0.0114167081,
-0.0091563454,
-0.0449144356,
-0.0370571353,
-0.0144551909,
-0.0015137829,
-0.0326201022,
0.0193821229,
0.0161462538,
-0.0468226559,
-0.0360242762,
-0.0918156281,
2.704e-7,
0.0280201156,
0.0682709739,
-0.050608892,
0.0316434428,
0.0386414714,
0.0395534709,
0.0243238695,
0.0540837683,
0.0262504872,
-0.0100640748,
-0.0123978248,
0.0093300892,
0.0257592946,
0.0256047472,
-0.0734977797,
-0.015182035,
-0.0614614971,
-0.0142409597,
-0.0462322533,
0.0726224482,
0.0916278586,
0.0573398359,
0.0363630913,
-0.0038592552,
-0.0578008853,
-0.0465934426,
0.0416969135,
-0.0486060642,
-0.0338100716,
0.0160526279,
0.0498354472,
0.0492674485,
0.0124106091,
-0.0106737055,
-0.0040208749,
-0.0006749248,
0.0267116446,
0.0187285468,
0.0232363194,
0.0220475271,
0.0323268138,
-0.0152149126,
0.0053388099,
-0.0225321706,
0.0424637906,
-0.0450359657,
-0.0803999677,
-0.0591895133,
-0.0028776852,
-0.0206468441,
0.0450952649,
-0.0192403719,
-0.0640230477,
-0.0058872495,
-0.0280241556,
-0.019192338,
-0.0351142362,
-0.0290099978,
0.0461084247,
-0.0395895019,
-0.0391971171,
-0.0948256105,
-0.0012260207,
0.0318321548,
0.0503255762,
0.0201569013,
0.0494090505,
1.798620462e-34,
0.0403190143,
0.0023806402,
-0.0070223217,
0.0202406049,
0.0510018617,
0.0387932435,
0.0113983499,
-0.0059563774,
0.0100608105,
-0.0251718592,
-0.0048274868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12929v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12929v2 | Quantizable Transformers: Removing Outliers by Helping Attention Heads Do Nothing | 2023-06-22T14:39:04 | 2023-11-09T14:05:51 | Yelysei Bondarenko, Markus Nagel, Tijmen Blankevoort | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Transformer models have been widely adopted in various domains over the last
years, and especially large language models have advanced the field of AI
significantly. Due to their size, the capability of these networks has
increased tremendously, but this has come at the cost of a significant increase
in necessary compute. Quantization is one of the most effective ways to reduce
the computational time and memory consumption of neural networks. Many studies
have shown, however, that modern transformer models tend to learn strong
outliers in their activations, making them difficult to quantize. To retain
acceptable performance, the existence of these outliers requires activations to
be in higher bitwidth or the use of different numeric formats, extra
fine-tuning, or other workarounds. We show that strong outliers are related to
very specific behavior of attention heads that try to learn a "no-op" or just a
partial update of the residual. To achieve the exact zeros needed in the
attention matrix for a no-update, the input to the softmax is pushed to be
larger and larger during training, causing outliers in other parts of the
network. Based on these observations, we propose two simple (independent)
modifications to the attention mechanism - clipped softmax and gated attention.
We empirically show that models pre-trained using our methods learn
significantly smaller outliers while maintaining and sometimes even improving
the floating-point task performance. This enables us to quantize transformers
to full INT8 quantization of the activations without any additional effort. We
demonstrate the effectiveness of our methods on both language models (BERT,
OPT) and vision transformers. | [
-0.0284131635,
0.0159829948,
0.0122010633,
0.0301139634,
0.017200781,
-0.0092544258,
0.0106506236,
-0.000704215,
-0.0470134169,
-0.0035814389,
-0.0352239646,
-0.0235905796,
-0.0314753056,
0.0231255405,
0.0364620462,
-0.0096104192,
0.0567355528,
-0.0286465436,
-0.0056856233,
-0.0032897652,
-0.0147459982,
-0.0327744856,
0.0214456022,
0.0340711586,
-0.0299973451,
-0.0134649221,
0.0024529095,
0.0094095701,
0.024817029,
0.0306611434,
0.0187656023,
0.0408974215,
0.0156835932,
0.0234973077,
0.0000021218,
-0.0178369209,
0.006808477,
-0.0033279369,
-0.028010793,
0.0437092185,
-0.0397022106,
-0.0171042942,
-0.0176659487,
0.0096755819,
-0.0101020504,
0.0029839899,
0.0727760494,
0.0325663537,
0.066924274,
0.0732728392,
-0.014443446,
0.0021134019,
0.0519742481,
-0.0439186208,
0.0146609182,
-0.007484755,
-0.0098992847,
-0.0279108081,
-0.0396564528,
-0.0115783084,
-0.0490496755,
0.017120339,
0.0314966962,
0.01913484,
0.0372430943,
0.0610283725,
-0.059316244,
-0.0275764298,
-0.0095203621,
0.0654903874,
-0.1274267882,
-0.0090635065,
-0.0070344703,
-0.0112611391,
-0.016808752,
-0.0716679469,
-0.0358802378,
0.0308482591,
0.0399839617,
0.0417887084,
-0.0292269569,
-0.0035839875,
0.0420487188,
-0.0075103398,
-0.0646658391,
0.0211141109,
-0.0042896471,
-0.0065457285,
-0.0081114573,
-0.0110931052,
-0.0771220252,
-0.0193215255,
-0.0024231102,
0.0526965074,
0.0106331967,
-0.0205593519,
-0.0659829378,
-0.0197054837,
-0.0225726496,
-0.0232871976,
0.0530290045,
0.0582583211,
-0.0539703034,
0.0438499413,
-0.0483006649,
0.0788505375,
-0.0297186617,
0.0701212063,
-0.0082145818,
0.0103392247,
0.0309482757,
0.025321532,
-0.059132725,
0.0373763144,
-0.0095693264,
-0.009595599,
-0.0116153769,
0.0149507727,
-0.0217043757,
-0.0109425085,
0.034104459,
0.0150435604,
-0.0712788031,
-0.0366770029,
0.0153010236,
0.0505081788,
-0.0425459445,
-0.0185144749,
-0.0003654516,
-0.0739566907,
-0.0487461984,
0.0263079274,
0.0225923546,
-0.0217269938,
0.0353377536,
0.0443432257,
-0.0114701791,
-0.0500572585,
0.0086362772,
0.0077508134,
-0.0051905443,
-0.0250245593,
0.0262463726,
-0.0453408249,
-0.0134197604,
-0.0040314752,
0.0087479688,
-0.032656759,
0.0416525006,
0.0236490555,
-0.0075292806,
0.0238345973,
-0.0118860491,
-0.013296742,
-0.0176591203,
-0.0187021829,
0.0166996773,
0.0413294397,
0.0304600392,
0.0045146029,
-0.0089726588,
-0.0037123379,
0.0598461777,
0.0452017076,
0.0350888856,
-0.0116704609,
-0.0111115351,
-0.0148083046,
-0.025491057,
0.0153596168,
0.069534041,
0.0748450905,
-0.0305009894,
-0.0411499478,
0.0768782422,
-0.0084105264,
-0.0132494606,
0.0449325778,
-0.0194748081,
-0.0316086225,
-0.0007567321,
-0.0234147552,
-0.0720538273,
0.0850542858,
0.0513569005,
-0.0237012468,
-0.0161989313,
0.023524195,
-0.0681254938,
-0.0432863496,
0.0026278484,
-0.0061117513,
-0.0049527143,
-0.0068436717,
0.0593319796,
0.0305862762,
-0.0650936663,
0.0888605341,
-0.0031287123,
-0.0209048763,
0.011812672,
-0.0902091637,
-0.0258195363,
-0.0063985372,
0.0255003665,
-0.0352236852,
-0.0360941663,
-0.0151454816,
-0.0262492504,
0.0128169693,
0.0114048757,
0.0250543803,
0.0030936287,
-0.0609212369,
0.0153595954,
-0.0285745505,
0.0041396911,
-0.0097502712,
0.0160011537,
0.0020149329,
-0.0026549255,
-0.0569735989,
0.0047207354,
0.0365900211,
0.0338679403,
-0.0733700842,
0.0279922914,
0.0131714763,
0.0078974701,
-0.0157854706,
-0.001437642,
0.0049298755,
0.0425603017,
-0.0440494828,
0.0132572241,
-0.0114873042,
-0.0324972197,
0.0264012031,
0.035021551,
-0.0437057652,
0.0074867862,
0.0905801132,
-0.0164917689,
-0.0257784761,
0.0113758817,
-0.0554074906,
0.0164046027,
-0.035756778,
0.0260450393,
0.0071756472,
0.0385464132,
-0.022997288,
0.0295534693,
-0.0295118038,
0.002558589,
0.0027272487,
-0.0364550836,
0.0014749881,
-0.0236634016,
-0.0475965329,
-0.0142808603,
-0.0307934619,
0.0255226847,
-0.0110659013,
-0.0461194627,
-0.0144561063,
-0.0151599646,
-0.0487804115,
-0.010869598,
-0.0520018153,
0.0218476746,
0.035871312,
0.013657541,
0.0356862321,
-0.0233548898,
-0.0095623415,
0.0094531318,
-0.0193057805,
0.0022916079,
0.0363679789,
-0.0110411486,
-0.0032375306,
-0.0159469415,
-0.0600095652,
0.0042020138,
0.0345224626,
-0.0234597679,
-0.0246643443,
-0.0541248843,
-0.0270565189,
0.0048213643,
0.0500029325,
-0.0182685629,
-0.0455011055,
0.0074503925,
-0.021491766,
0.0426042192,
0.1295897514,
0.0245008841,
0.0056984755,
0.0560868159,
0.0124315005,
-0.0183816794,
0.055142846,
-0.0471866652,
-0.0393493734,
-0.0214219429,
0.0028977618,
0.0096513238,
0.0666004643,
-0.0593176559,
-0.0246010181,
-0.0463129692,
0.0204056744,
0.0179598723,
-0.0181848127,
0.010640244,
0.0317289233,
-0.0325132236,
0.0445722453,
-0.0194525737,
-0.0174920578,
0.0150930397,
0.0138065983,
-0.0202104803,
0.0178507771,
0.0305809155,
-0.0029073956,
-0.0031999785,
0.0529895276,
0.0258061271,
-0.017800916,
-0.0390402675,
-0.0619233362,
-0.0226917919,
-0.0021618234,
-0.0121127218,
0.0802368596,
0.0262223519,
0.0060330452,
-0.0308309402,
-0.0218620729,
-0.0323637202,
0.0122688198,
0.0040837238,
0.0505049564,
0.0137021393,
-0.04498858,
-0.044348184,
0.0266959276,
0.022142468,
0.0981510207,
-0.0282334033,
-0.0069574984,
-0.0143375248,
0.0330418497,
0.0017758143,
0.0286204275,
0.0461886153,
-0.0405173078,
-0.0326005593,
0.0406280272,
0.0087183919,
0.0107736224,
-0.0487449318,
-0.0258162543,
0.0303622335,
-0.0247032028,
-0.0000028867,
0.019575322,
0.072168082,
-0.0392676517,
-0.0500733033,
0.0446642488,
0.0109296422,
-0.0236568544,
0.0265268292,
0.0016185313,
0.0141271614,
0.0326078795,
0.0233727042,
-0.0426599979,
-0.0287765488,
0.0251148604,
0.0310334247,
0.0226301029,
-0.0307198595,
0.0159837753,
-0.0913278461,
0.0333018303,
0.001181935,
0.0023966024,
-0.0601560622,
-0.0003850601,
0.0141171375,
-0.0358823538,
0.0232096314,
0.0244721547,
0.0127913188,
-0.0273506362,
0.009366638,
0.0338782631,
-0.0099059986,
0.0361184403,
-0.0254376438,
0.0117053529,
0.0583704673,
0.0026214176,
-0.0217626132,
-0.0182898231,
0.0482414402,
0.0095804911,
0.0104603749,
0.036143709,
0.0459446572,
0.0029260481,
-0.0470651388,
0.0123298299,
0.007128418,
-0.0296801627,
0.0077188686,
-0.0552090667,
0.0675410777,
-0.0012445484,
-0.0380344987,
-0.016949784,
-0.036947336,
-0.0249087084,
0.0241378993,
0.0054965178,
-0.0407732949,
-0.0496544652,
-0.005117421,
0.0248692203,
-0.0210083555,
-0.0444125012,
0.0167400893,
0.0343412086,
-0.1125192046,
-0.0608679876,
-0.0334619731,
-0.0080415579,
0.0246547591,
0.0099231647,
-0.1191003993,
0.03676828,
0.0439803526,
-0.0546621755,
0.0331472494,
-0.0162218846,
0.0030809594,
-0.0528183356,
0.0205342937,
0.0371801592,
-0.0165187605,
-0.0196481626,
-0.0141575634,
-0.1012587622,
-0.0270856135,
0.0322870575,
0.0508703329,
0.0196543187,
0.0329057164,
-0.0236243475,
-0.0429888517,
0.0422579125,
0.0766786262,
-0.01271539,
0.0504602492,
0.0475359745,
-0.0704735443,
-0.0096117575,
0.0332959406,
-0.0180347171,
0.0537932664,
0.0241826437,
0.0375751443,
-0.0776618049,
-0.0086268084,
0.013146854,
-0.0208699089,
0.0810051784,
0.0358689204,
0.0412110053,
-0.0071632452,
0.0302455556,
0.0368068106,
0.0258181617,
-0.0538803153,
-0.0221985672,
0.0166719202,
0.0235253908,
-0.0091032609,
0.0647200793,
0.0326462686,
-0.0419263132,
0.0316135883,
0.0038429124,
-0.0369676128,
0.0091563463,
-0.0057122028,
0.0130878016,
-0.034433946,
-0.0222539268,
0.0156371519,
0.0356100611,
0.0078520635,
0.0088231266,
0.0140844956,
0.0320814848,
-0.0387059115,
0.0098949503,
-0.0391138494,
-0.0323674344,
-0.0578450523,
-0.0090874117,
0.0267584603,
0.0171026662,
0.0111763934,
-0.0091174468,
-0.0181240495,
-0.009225985,
-0.0092342459,
0.0208479855,
0.0094159609,
0.0246575791,
0.0253159963,
0.0369007178,
-0.0503348149,
0.0224285014,
-0.0586798191,
0.0165203996,
0.0045765094,
0.0200645253,
-0.0282423813,
-0.0210994687,
-0.060360454,
-0.0160433762,
0.0331300758,
-0.0033170672,
0.0133540584,
-0.0432408638,
0.0108557995,
0.0125372345,
0.0080896402,
-0.0291168001,
0.0338818282,
0.0154749267,
0.0076046488,
-0.0579010211,
-0.0006734164,
-0.0202059373,
0.0073813954,
0.0083384328,
-0.0180402659,
-6.244419948e-33,
-0.0056337067,
-0.0040190918,
0.0048198551,
-0.0228283405,
-0.021162523,
0.0170168169,
-0.0180005878,
-0.0011738969,
-0.0798900872,
-0.0106947413,
-0.050604444,
0.0333968475,
0.0074377144,
0.0110105239,
-0.0228568781,
-0.03015811,
0.0719560981,
-0.0241308734,
-0.0343798846,
0.0302798804,
-0.0078746453,
0.0073370538,
0.0945908874,
-0.0007577168,
-0.0485958457,
0.0052856351,
-0.0413489938,
0.0237130169,
0.0121408682,
0.0141351037,
-0.0096343905,
0.0417499095,
0.0076648379,
-0.0363082215,
-0.0214299206,
-0.0195362214,
-0.0922686681,
-0.010895378,
-0.0403462872,
0.0393742025,
0.0108409189,
-0.0487358011,
0.0966392383,
0.0150692649,
-0.0097585991,
-0.0709767416,
0.0225437786,
0.0076868189,
-0.0274284352,
-0.039677836,
-0.0392859392,
0.0122019984,
0.0029361458,
-0.0257495549,
0.016267525,
0.0462556928,
-0.020191459,
0.0221552923,
-0.0880557373,
0.0140481368,
0.0539846011,
0.0589389801,
0.0350481085,
0.0460619368,
0.0082427552,
0.0152489292,
0.06213383,
0.0046246825,
-0.0243503731,
-0.0218268931,
0.0808969289,
0.0369457379,
0.0708666891,
-0.0156829152,
0.10467536,
0.0088413022,
-0.0816138983,
-0.0282752384,
-0.0159238074,
0.0369008854,
0.0639933348,
-0.0111145657,
-0.0139873065,
-0.0104262205,
-0.0059926021,
0.001085498,
-0.0510687567,
0.0019947586,
-0.0017480088,
0.0352793261,
0.0015371344,
0.0369229354,
0.0320243724,
-0.0369755328,
0.0553269088,
-0.0114952493,
0.0095248362,
0.0572039634,
0.00223537,
-0.0036023706,
-0.0489986911,
-0.0134176537,
0.0010762964,
0.0281677395,
0.0134368232,
0.0127651114,
0.0491919927,
0.063097991,
-0.0764989108,
-0.0472006835,
-0.0352785178,
0.0294598099,
0.0156095764,
0.0850445554,
0.0341880545,
-0.0061425162,
0.0036675134,
0.0424494743,
-0.0235628877,
0.0257433336,
-0.0189312194,
0.042592749,
0.0241736602,
0.0244428683,
-0.0244337022,
-0.0141423699,
-0.0501941368,
0.0670027658,
0.0061162813,
-0.082468085,
-0.0394073948,
0.0194098279,
2.871e-7,
0.0182954036,
0.0198618267,
-0.0127863949,
0.0235159099,
0.0144036654,
0.0204868224,
0.04255227,
0.0284365267,
0.0285313707,
-0.010458678,
0.0421584062,
0.0341281444,
-0.022612026,
0.0010357895,
-0.0551298447,
-0.0225600284,
-0.0102772666,
0.0192516968,
-0.0154411821,
-0.0252461042,
-0.0016260784,
0.1105807722,
-0.0161863342,
0.0056491252,
0.0456178598,
-0.0143323196,
0.0479943641,
-0.0146180782,
0.0394968092,
0.0213167034,
0.0494643189,
0.0260383952,
-0.016033031,
-0.0060732821,
0.0070430571,
0.0062251203,
-0.0142495381,
0.0703692436,
-0.049237594,
-0.0843941197,
-0.0072552953,
0.0419608727,
-0.0050191828,
-0.0382526815,
0.0526842959,
-0.0918129459,
-0.042357631,
-0.0288481973,
-0.0380077399,
0.0113538681,
-0.0023115091,
-0.0208921228,
0.0181993004,
0.0086499071,
0.0201526545,
-0.0115394881,
-0.0043684272,
-0.09218885,
-0.0239191912,
0.0084638447,
-0.0445175916,
-0.067728579,
-0.0533437505,
-0.0303415861,
0.0268500783,
0.0073171672,
-0.0141365109,
2.449043068e-34,
0.0318862982,
-0.0080242027,
0.0375578068,
-0.0023837397,
-0.0268869661,
-0.0171480514,
-0.0010715864,
-0.0300905742,
0.0324863717,
-0.035467498,
-0.0539999679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12925v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12925v1 | AudioPaLM: A Large Language Model That Can Speak and Listen | 2023-06-22T14:37:54 | 2023-06-22T14:37:54 | Paul K. Rubenstein, Chulayuth Asawaroengchai, Duc Dung Nguyen, Ankur Bapna, Zalán Borsos, Félix de Chaumont Quitry, Peter Chen, Dalia El Badawy, Wei Han, Eugene Kharitonov, Hannah Muckenhirn, Dirk Padfield, James Qin, Danny Rozenberg, Tara Sainath, Johan Schalkwyk, Matt Sharifi, Michelle Tadmor Ramanovich, Marco Tagliasacchi, Alexandru Tudor, Mihajlo Velimirović, Damien Vincent, Jiahui Yu, Yongqiang Wang, Vicky Zayats, Neil Zeghidour, Yu Zhang, Zhishuai Zhang, Lukas Zilka, Christian Frank | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS, stat.ML | We introduce AudioPaLM, a large language model for speech understanding and
generation. AudioPaLM fuses text-based and speech-based language models, PaLM-2
[Anil et al., 2023] and AudioLM [Borsos et al., 2022], into a unified
multimodal architecture that can process and generate text and speech with
applications including speech recognition and speech-to-speech translation.
AudioPaLM inherits the capability to preserve paralinguistic information such
as speaker identity and intonation from AudioLM and the linguistic knowledge
present only in text large language models such as PaLM-2. We demonstrate that
initializing AudioPaLM with the weights of a text-only large language model
improves speech processing, successfully leveraging the larger quantity of text
training data used in pretraining to assist with the speech tasks. The
resulting model significantly outperforms existing systems for speech
translation tasks and has the ability to perform zero-shot speech-to-text
translation for many languages for which input/target language combinations
were not seen in training. AudioPaLM also demonstrates features of audio
language models, such as transferring a voice across languages based on a short
spoken prompt. We release examples of our method at
https://google-research.github.io/seanet/audiopalm/examples | [
-0.0102526518,
0.0727694184,
-0.0038308881,
0.0539890602,
-0.0095139006,
-0.0106277112,
0.0691025928,
-0.0429457352,
-0.0543172732,
-0.02934172,
-0.094976753,
-0.0390318818,
0.0386693403,
0.0398046784,
0.070115529,
-0.0679344088,
0.0349349715,
-0.0734731182,
0.000540292,
-0.0096646594,
0.0240731034,
0.0112395873,
-0.048623465,
0.0277993958,
0.0001564447,
0.0038318462,
-0.0410902835,
0.0465307981,
0.0117786061,
-0.0191778112,
-0.0387322642,
-0.0217352994,
0.0550927147,
0.0559087992,
0.0000016967,
-0.0205897782,
0.0188419633,
-0.0125875436,
0.0017152557,
-0.0113054365,
0.048137363,
-0.0063959109,
-0.0255101528,
0.0349753164,
0.0108510926,
-0.051186014,
0.045319818,
0.046155259,
0.0559166782,
0.0586563721,
-0.023075521,
-0.0394461155,
0.012570492,
-0.0403954946,
0.0078471098,
-0.0178057048,
-0.0362903588,
-0.0398114771,
0.0150194727,
0.0076129036,
-0.0227042045,
0.0549012385,
-0.00587042,
0.0016143498,
0.014624007,
0.027693456,
-0.0129281413,
-0.0586656742,
-0.0207141396,
0.095461823,
-0.0009283973,
0.0007248842,
0.0267718676,
0.0395871811,
-0.0016405678,
-0.0220259111,
-0.0245440193,
0.0468018539,
0.0254545398,
0.0027492151,
-0.0277236812,
0.0383105204,
0.0288296286,
-0.0376668386,
-0.0206710938,
0.0076785018,
0.0317343548,
0.0078146197,
0.0245687589,
-0.0201561283,
0.0131098544,
-0.04602677,
0.0547833219,
0.0676746368,
-0.0263913758,
0.0215802025,
-0.0474799015,
-0.0164073836,
-0.0240448359,
-0.0227954667,
0.0195812508,
0.0443588756,
-0.0558376536,
0.039248012,
-0.0302253701,
0.0360044613,
0.0007269967,
-0.0123785837,
-0.0295195915,
-0.0170815997,
-0.0039535267,
-0.0115594156,
-0.028604107,
-0.0091367038,
-0.0582779422,
-0.075993754,
0.0081919562,
0.0175654087,
0.0087785991,
0.0052734534,
-0.0165045839,
0.0069365283,
-0.046940349,
-0.0032710533,
0.0183299463,
0.079221867,
0.0129332403,
0.0614624433,
0.0010490185,
-0.0438458733,
-0.0047982507,
0.0353857316,
0.0304703582,
-0.0149081787,
0.0180293284,
0.1021047011,
-0.0310543552,
-0.0356119573,
0.0128955087,
-0.0039110444,
-0.0161124337,
-0.0691444054,
0.0078928713,
-0.0571477115,
0.0454086773,
-0.0196915194,
0.0162675641,
-0.0010873723,
0.0168960076,
0.0150983091,
0.0126486644,
0.0659413412,
-0.0080270041,
0.0492821373,
0.0661725327,
0.0062264288,
0.0179010574,
0.0317891389,
0.0699313283,
-0.0089210384,
-0.0126208151,
-0.0384792946,
-0.0103529636,
0.0912303701,
-0.0026718311,
0.0014244022,
-0.0318535008,
-0.0380385965,
0.0111046238,
0.0467920005,
0.0433576629,
0.0352877006,
-0.0334121287,
-0.0111088175,
0.0886215195,
0.045393832,
-0.0002385623,
-0.0134564573,
0.0397303253,
-0.0198737253,
0.0073237102,
-0.0502269492,
-0.0407829247,
0.0325648971,
0.0028226678,
0.0028296856,
0.0263462178,
0.0348464362,
-0.0354433805,
0.0224033482,
0.0305092949,
-0.0202453379,
-0.0057376311,
0.0290902313,
0.0292941555,
0.0343945026,
-0.01880995,
0.0339004993,
0.0127844354,
-0.0515476689,
0.033874318,
0.0078535536,
0.0098826261,
0.0555842593,
-0.0023957808,
0.0010755245,
0.0068083801,
-0.0205246583,
0.0130662592,
0.0689532086,
0.0190146416,
-0.0111981258,
0.0804151669,
-0.0462217182,
0.0054894006,
0.0268291924,
-0.019302072,
0.0498857945,
-0.0360876769,
0.0235796925,
0.0141270496,
0.0093064206,
0.025245145,
-0.0007589767,
-0.0524131283,
-0.0167660285,
0.0128962155,
-0.0042612124,
0.0390849039,
0.0131906876,
-0.0385681316,
-0.0064283782,
0.0206836425,
-0.0461327732,
0.0281891488,
0.0507815816,
-0.0781008378,
-0.0362936743,
0.0473329835,
-0.0334790908,
0.0408238582,
0.016218923,
0.0142466901,
-0.094289273,
0.0516804494,
-0.0344481841,
0.0628530681,
-0.0371227451,
0.0349384435,
0.0236905497,
-0.0029807179,
0.0050603035,
-0.0176494736,
0.0448514856,
-0.0202035364,
0.0163822658,
0.0544491671,
-0.0149415573,
-0.0662453324,
-0.0462690704,
0.0410485715,
-0.0014238192,
0.0233190674,
-0.0071928869,
-0.0077739195,
-0.0340698846,
-0.0157354958,
-0.1268071681,
0.0170398764,
0.0055097817,
0.0016710429,
0.0166692846,
0.0182694364,
0.001529216,
-0.0315676928,
-0.064220801,
-0.0004610121,
0.0321002714,
-0.0217294395,
-0.0312168244,
-0.0041735461,
-0.0090762684,
-0.0212337058,
0.0084574763,
0.0365704596,
0.0213524979,
-0.0092963176,
-0.0080594346,
-0.0373556428,
0.0081525454,
-0.0072994218,
0.0404855348,
-0.0109563032,
-0.0209687166,
-0.0068620406,
-0.0205137637,
0.0550870039,
0.0213441271,
-0.002635122,
-0.0123351729,
0.0130632287,
-0.0357350409,
-0.0566042438,
0.009967735,
0.0208731648,
0.0291986819,
-0.0492996722,
0.0063608191,
-0.0243089329,
0.0580338128,
0.0172648672,
0.0222628862,
-0.0361403748,
-0.0196308028,
-0.00987955,
-0.042044837,
-0.0210786387,
-0.0136553813,
-0.0407790169,
0.0155213661,
-0.0324982703,
-0.0260661077,
0.0056269881,
-0.1206550077,
-0.0488607995,
-0.0267544985,
-0.0279511046,
-0.0053288275,
0.0521320403,
0.0098864706,
0.0410051234,
-0.02466866,
-0.0062344619,
-0.0183663722,
0.0321681462,
-0.0183328018,
-0.0392897986,
0.0137123913,
-0.0474497788,
0.0010530599,
-0.0109799476,
-0.0146796843,
-0.0225142222,
-0.0123302741,
-0.0656073987,
0.0034687826,
-0.0304504503,
-0.0277385935,
-0.0354294218,
0.0130853979,
0.0574909635,
0.0694008097,
-0.0125043793,
0.0157351233,
-0.0455451049,
0.022274334,
0.0260576848,
0.0343207233,
-0.016411582,
-0.0712512508,
0.0431532785,
-0.0040492322,
0.0504129827,
-0.001758034,
-0.0543610305,
0.0195195898,
0.0308736823,
0.0533562526,
-0.0516101718,
0.0370043404,
0.056903109,
-0.0586998649,
0.0044411197,
0.1063835993,
-0.0189701039,
-0.0392471701,
-0.0187679883,
0.0265401844,
0.0220854208,
0.0292139128,
0.0014830501,
-0.040264111,
-0.0505296923,
0.0604585446,
0.0213090386,
0.0328316689,
0.0190339517,
-0.0315338783,
-0.0825074539,
0.0081502805,
0.0478831045,
-0.0635094345,
-0.0107715633,
0.0031030942,
-0.0035895812,
0.0004396564,
0.0207355879,
0.0414002873,
-0.027894564,
-0.0109003745,
0.0237168018,
-0.0047482532,
-0.0331680439,
0.024155302,
-0.0252312962,
0.095586367,
0.0573901907,
0.0349001698,
-0.0163765736,
-0.0300556496,
0.0416536592,
0.0085829357,
0.0010805909,
0.001351767,
0.0333495773,
0.0097252224,
-0.0264447518,
0.0111438334,
0.0668252409,
-0.0291150603,
0.0110179782,
0.0356774107,
0.0428761318,
-0.0120556187,
0.0056297872,
0.0200871956,
0.0391015075,
-0.0056965165,
0.0481357649,
0.0147981793,
-0.0582670942,
-0.0232308116,
0.001317173,
-0.0048363046,
-0.0419031978,
-0.0235648174,
0.0167230442,
-0.0021570928,
-0.058890745,
-0.042697046,
0.0005504277,
-0.0009456971,
0.0716563836,
0.0454481356,
-0.0050280998,
0.0239850935,
0.0188659206,
-0.0127902022,
0.0219450649,
-0.0257401038,
0.0525655337,
-0.0622382872,
-0.0032633285,
0.0407965854,
-0.0878023356,
0.0078081288,
0.0364350751,
-0.0730833858,
-0.0631722212,
-0.0143602965,
0.0210612845,
0.025054248,
0.0695641115,
-0.0266525503,
-0.058370322,
0.0300768483,
-0.0203886237,
-0.0702982172,
0.0489091016,
0.0378286242,
0.0027962944,
-0.0163546484,
0.0150619866,
-0.0421273001,
0.0352442302,
0.0076056696,
0.0049340581,
-0.0137523906,
-0.0521704294,
-0.0212210119,
0.0024130917,
0.0212072693,
-0.0169252325,
0.0671588704,
-0.0552963167,
0.0088660941,
-0.0131242378,
0.043552231,
-0.073710002,
-0.0108019691,
0.0378008261,
0.0444853492,
0.0189254265,
-0.0374250673,
0.0206431933,
0.0246218443,
0.0158357788,
0.0175874867,
0.016305767,
0.0142682558,
0.022827642,
0.0016890677,
0.0062157931,
0.0418060124,
-0.0311253034,
0.0213841572,
-0.0161598623,
0.0360399708,
-0.000317513,
-0.0316503942,
0.0107158627,
0.0103590069,
-0.036825534,
-0.0358710103,
0.0043925755,
0.0243616421,
0.0424372852,
0.0134879779,
0.0670278668,
0.0004673528,
0.0081460867,
-0.0399743132,
0.0539111905,
-0.0347107425,
-0.0495960973,
0.0145706404,
-0.0083858408,
-0.0030162381,
-0.0089649884,
0.0268754549,
0.0307654124,
0.0178563278,
-0.0037869427,
0.047859218,
-0.0444533974,
-0.0240859985,
0.0001643799,
0.010588157,
-0.03596076,
0.0063112299,
-0.0037484788,
-0.0695195869,
-0.0112636611,
0.001198418,
0.0042295987,
-0.0447828323,
0.0133274654,
0.0072591887,
-0.0212879498,
0.0228525661,
-0.0311145708,
-0.0169969797,
-0.0023658411,
-0.0160347428,
0.0259144716,
-5.373399573e-33,
-0.0490990207,
0.0166680571,
0.0215150937,
-0.0332541801,
-0.0516674705,
-0.0103566106,
-0.0653514192,
0.0084233517,
0.0074098478,
-0.0168852992,
0.008110472,
-0.0037035982,
0.0063211587,
0.0482421517,
-0.0112687182,
0.0184114762,
0.0693360642,
-0.0208358336,
0.0163979921,
0.0531208888,
0.0457834415,
0.0525030568,
0.016813362,
-0.0425483026,
-0.040663261,
0.0008325008,
-0.0224589854,
0.006155327,
-0.0004579588,
0.0225185603,
-0.0207845923,
-0.0083333524,
-0.014433247,
-0.0167508498,
-0.037470255,
0.0522014797,
-0.0860001743,
0.0162807982,
0.0127898427,
0.0600229017,
-0.0423187315,
-0.0205147844,
0.0430049933,
-0.0336141586,
-0.0005666991,
-0.0214714743,
0.0216812417,
-0.0377300158,
-0.0157701485,
-0.0309542529,
-0.0454689935,
0.0134465722,
-0.0237076525,
-0.0524586923,
0.0455606766,
0.0707193911,
-0.0251772013,
-0.017621221,
-0.0435004085,
0.0465876795,
-0.0262254272,
-0.0008164526,
0.0426538587,
0.074211292,
-0.0006625558,
0.0671423003,
0.034510497,
-0.0771249905,
0.014278342,
0.0171584561,
0.0505071245,
0.0213711541,
0.0014001201,
0.035588108,
-0.0119114136,
-0.0219119992,
-0.0314831585,
-0.0053841323,
0.0119330809,
-0.0291183554,
0.0198665876,
0.0136550637,
0.0118973712,
0.0194110237,
-0.0628373176,
-0.0308626164,
-0.0206728708,
-0.0116914641,
0.0486713275,
0.0229749084,
-0.003192262,
-0.0301710982,
0.1058427989,
-0.0250665825,
-0.013082061,
0.0027173162,
-0.0308763459,
0.0080886595,
-0.018889118,
0.0490778312,
-0.0449244827,
-0.034545783,
0.0803062394,
0.0232914686,
0.0137222372,
-0.011135418,
-0.0109906672,
0.0671054646,
-0.0463534743,
-0.0213125721,
-0.039165318,
0.0478913784,
0.0139420917,
0.0604792535,
0.02709594,
-0.0276329257,
-0.0371879749,
0.0378059186,
-0.0424394086,
-0.0251422375,
-0.0405084193,
-0.0448612161,
-0.0328214876,
0.0111444974,
-0.0739763975,
0.0359857827,
-0.0179309659,
-0.0307651516,
0.048858013,
-0.0443237312,
-0.0134312892,
0.0332801975,
2.555e-7,
-0.0178283043,
-0.026999753,
0.003636176,
-0.0231909323,
0.0730625093,
0.0326345712,
-0.0533933677,
0.0514331944,
0.0027055934,
-0.0168046821,
-0.0182379093,
0.0341139324,
0.0854149014,
-0.0104680341,
-0.0947223902,
-0.010846463,
-0.0597290434,
0.0261548962,
-0.035730768,
0.0096309725,
0.0258734822,
0.0917238593,
-0.017565554,
-0.0479055904,
0.0333244316,
-0.0235220883,
0.0705348253,
-0.0123859914,
-0.0001575846,
-0.038065277,
-0.004391585,
-0.0127981631,
-0.0464824326,
-0.0136370156,
-0.0156781934,
0.0308997314,
0.0188166481,
0.0756887719,
0.0098813539,
-0.0351102017,
0.0095641147,
0.0444415733,
-0.0366793014,
-0.0234994236,
0.0542566441,
-0.0068209656,
-0.0284185112,
-0.034132503,
-0.0314602964,
-0.0251880884,
-0.0222495869,
-0.0239053462,
-0.0224298034,
0.0176538266,
0.0175322108,
-0.0425382629,
-0.0108809583,
-0.0565644242,
-0.0354288965,
0.018805733,
-0.0886516348,
-0.0237371307,
-0.0697810426,
-0.0206872206,
0.0049650967,
-0.0459634513,
-0.0182929635,
1.670901738e-34,
-0.0026083596,
-0.036637295,
0.0067135142,
-0.0166675355,
0.0052169682,
-0.0328767486,
0.0091961445,
0.0217338577,
0.0227739159,
-0.0567725077,
-0.0347076021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12916v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12916v3 | Cross-lingual Cross-temporal Summarization: Dataset, Models, Evaluation | 2023-06-22T14:31:18 | 2024-06-02T20:38:10 | Ran Zhang, Jihed Ouni, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | While summarization has been extensively researched in natural language
processing (NLP), cross-lingual cross-temporal summarization (CLCTS) is a
largely unexplored area that has the potential to improve cross-cultural
accessibility and understanding. This paper comprehensively addresses the CLCTS
task, including dataset creation, modeling, and evaluation. We (1) build the
first CLCTS corpus with 328 instances for hDe-En (extended version with 455
instances) and 289 for hEn-De (extended version with 501 instances), leveraging
historical fiction texts and Wikipedia summaries in English and German; (2)
examine the effectiveness of popular transformer end-to-end models with
different intermediate finetuning tasks; (3) explore the potential of GPT-3.5
as a summarizer; (4) report evaluations from humans, GPT-4, and several recent
automatic evaluation metrics. Our results indicate that intermediate task
finetuned end-to-end models generate bad to moderate quality summaries while
GPT-3.5, as a zero-shot summarizer, provides moderate to good quality outputs.
GPT-3.5 also seems very adept at normalizing historical text. To assess data
contamination in GPT-3.5, we design an adversarial attack scheme in which we
find that GPT-3.5 performs slightly worse for unseen source documents compared
to seen documents. Moreover, it sometimes hallucinates when the source
sentences are inverted against its prior knowledge with a summarization
accuracy of 0.67 for plot omission, 0.71 for entity swap, and 0.53 for plot
negation. Overall, our regression results of model performances suggest that
longer, older, and more complex source texts (all of which are more
characteristic for historical language variants) are harder to summarize for
all models, indicating the difficulty of the CLCTS task. | [
0.0367657654,
0.0192272626,
0.0106046069,
0.0204919837,
-0.0400960855,
0.017063614,
-0.0243994612,
-0.0181714892,
0.0012454225,
-0.0250287317,
-0.0000540088,
-0.0151823461,
0.0653427839,
-0.0094235921,
0.0225448441,
-0.0972183049,
0.0332686007,
0.0034721179,
-0.0282142777,
-0.0042746416,
0.0173732005,
0.0098946458,
0.017015662,
0.0312758461,
0.0315819904,
0.0069211596,
0.0041169235,
-0.0369792096,
0.0730506629,
-0.0145966923,
-0.0066548395,
0.0087170629,
0.0266032852,
0.0408391207,
0.0000020303,
-0.0396842435,
-0.0106181055,
-0.0059806923,
0.0247124694,
0.0505587272,
0.0209144391,
-0.0544517264,
-0.0110466741,
-0.0174217764,
-0.0120847942,
-0.0168032441,
-0.0058241524,
0.0955285653,
0.0814393684,
0.0841254964,
-0.0060947868,
-0.0464615114,
0.0472193845,
-0.0422423109,
-0.0221346114,
-0.0286257733,
-0.0113800243,
0.0189146604,
-0.0180016179,
-0.0125505375,
-0.0207962971,
0.051193472,
0.0167495385,
0.0048232926,
-0.0288780797,
0.0270477664,
-0.0424988866,
0.0187361389,
0.022148909,
0.0633830428,
0.0041374094,
-0.0052531371,
0.0133472439,
0.0243917424,
-0.0043765907,
-0.0002950859,
-0.0708717406,
0.0319128074,
0.0086859316,
0.0186903123,
0.0343114398,
0.0121394088,
-0.0040197149,
0.0202562939,
-0.0163033716,
0.0239445176,
0.0173272304,
-0.0005368439,
-0.0354106314,
-0.0023703189,
-0.0307820328,
-0.0536925457,
0.0064374511,
0.0263328254,
0.025902966,
-0.0292450469,
-0.0363109522,
-0.059499342,
0.0118980175,
-0.0220404491,
-0.0295757633,
0.0129751358,
-0.0144077837,
0.0530242845,
-0.0060043484,
0.036141973,
0.0072388132,
0.0007946471,
-0.0227284096,
-0.037713591,
-0.0223805793,
0.0236431975,
-0.0237455219,
0.0109865321,
-0.0460274965,
0.0115055041,
-0.067591235,
-0.0215037465,
0.014454538,
-0.0084399423,
0.0069486024,
0.0050105811,
-0.023366414,
-0.0082533583,
-0.0310825612,
0.0667423531,
-0.0560792014,
-0.0278648976,
-0.0057845591,
-0.0209440682,
-0.0416808501,
0.0207101386,
-0.0106386328,
-0.0326704085,
0.0036861973,
0.0480048656,
-0.0314932466,
0.0023883663,
-0.0418614745,
-0.0280644596,
-0.0320079327,
-0.0544682518,
0.0024179879,
-0.0627746359,
0.0143901929,
-0.0133025367,
0.0056530498,
-0.0314489193,
-0.005592898,
0.0177397076,
-0.0667776167,
0.0318058729,
0.002197877,
-0.0119341752,
0.0441576168,
0.0124902902,
0.0002614589,
0.0595829114,
0.0626589581,
0.0277329013,
0.0562298745,
0.0237112958,
-0.0253646206,
0.0458519943,
0.0130127789,
0.0233976711,
-0.0021021415,
-0.0234976783,
-0.0460183099,
-0.0157740954,
0.0379888825,
0.0628034025,
-0.0418682694,
-0.0250797402,
0.0595302358,
0.0167099647,
-0.0094326716,
0.0149058262,
0.0527219325,
0.0234989859,
0.0236752462,
0.0701436773,
-0.0396314114,
0.033159133,
-0.0411425605,
0.0378877819,
0.0354052261,
0.0438160263,
-0.0170997065,
-0.0220384933,
0.045145534,
-0.0107149873,
0.0420886464,
-0.0244346689,
0.0345943272,
0.0287256613,
-0.0510384701,
0.031594608,
0.0137631269,
-0.0762787685,
0.0451770909,
0.0060429173,
-0.0005746403,
0.0463564098,
0.0519965515,
-0.0147083038,
0.0028680866,
-0.0219642799,
-0.0000344838,
0.0153571265,
0.0549796075,
-0.0268549118,
0.0140233738,
-0.056717664,
-0.0351253003,
-0.0366786905,
0.0109807737,
0.03796608,
-0.0036614586,
0.0262619425,
0.0460173525,
-0.0377759337,
-0.0206755735,
0.0252859928,
-0.0334072001,
-0.0155230463,
-0.0322814137,
0.0141604636,
0.0023142775,
0.0424083173,
-0.0107254488,
0.0080821766,
0.0197245833,
-0.0296253003,
0.003427228,
0.0312164016,
-0.013497401,
-0.0393441878,
0.020599544,
-0.0966177136,
-0.027979983,
0.0629569069,
-0.0376737863,
-0.0529641472,
0.0269606747,
-0.0396631472,
0.0141706429,
-0.0402791575,
-0.0092085274,
0.0162574295,
0.0247264635,
-0.031390667,
0.0840940326,
-0.0022280402,
-0.0031533812,
0.0580623932,
-0.0662793368,
0.0260918979,
-0.0412235931,
-0.0383640379,
0.0282196142,
0.0300420057,
-0.0071721082,
0.07159587,
-0.015222935,
-0.0243693553,
-0.0110566411,
-0.0752736852,
0.0081095686,
-0.0442804284,
0.0361675993,
0.0679975301,
0.0175226685,
-0.0116140209,
0.00488981,
-0.0312200766,
0.0010144688,
0.0257740915,
0.0166729763,
0.0376140736,
0.0238876697,
0.0504233763,
-0.021900272,
-0.0094451103,
0.0041706013,
0.0509532578,
-0.0135650188,
-0.0540011488,
-0.0135768671,
0.0399715789,
-0.0188335162,
0.0004868054,
-0.0263169315,
-0.0120421052,
-0.0260496605,
0.0278345104,
0.0548566319,
0.0217884462,
0.0389474407,
-0.0099563245,
0.0344534591,
-0.0316548049,
-0.0268688872,
-0.015447,
-0.0077705532,
0.0035524194,
-0.0169892851,
-0.0271144714,
0.0203069765,
0.0445291735,
0.0097464826,
0.0071943691,
-0.0423412882,
0.0197039507,
-0.0361904539,
-0.0090124905,
0.0075101499,
-0.0164339188,
-0.0117763756,
0.0314808376,
-0.0332884826,
0.0289890859,
0.0631012172,
-0.0146749672,
0.0184909664,
-0.0204382818,
-0.0064841663,
-0.0434911773,
0.0479765348,
0.013457966,
0.0210872609,
0.0242731255,
-0.0382167064,
-0.0690938011,
-0.0227502547,
0.0676755831,
-0.0153734917,
0.0670709684,
-0.0113340961,
-0.0224987566,
-0.0364732891,
-0.0016565223,
-0.0118726566,
-0.0571133532,
-0.0208208151,
0.0148841366,
0.0064826561,
0.0020642581,
-0.05920076,
0.0223297775,
0.0304557495,
0.0367432162,
-0.0405366607,
-0.001958109,
0.0078989798,
0.0618970245,
0.047695525,
0.0048240456,
0.0260982458,
-0.025363002,
0.0354556255,
0.0486359857,
0.0061214212,
-0.0243190676,
0.0245912634,
-0.007308349,
-0.0254260357,
-0.0597227849,
-0.0328603797,
-0.0379477702,
0.056135606,
-0.0562261268,
0.0369669646,
0.105608739,
0.0018759638,
-0.0320104994,
-0.0200895928,
0.0382562391,
0.0082083121,
-0.0030355188,
-0.0118222209,
-0.0846114829,
0.0016492974,
-0.0158652365,
0.0234376602,
0.0075966809,
-0.0654367879,
-0.0018473078,
-0.1314111054,
0.0175499581,
0.0274502207,
-0.0564334355,
-0.0356554538,
-0.0310089942,
-0.0065646516,
-0.0509209745,
0.0311286002,
-0.0071160961,
0.0072700423,
0.0152442204,
-0.0314696357,
-0.0500457361,
-0.024938209,
0.004648468,
-0.0271098912,
0.0045709522,
0.0276638456,
0.0782181993,
-0.0239738543,
0.0233272836,
0.0415086001,
-0.044103153,
-0.01542712,
0.0135269761,
0.1218225211,
0.0074455873,
-0.0075869048,
-0.0123027051,
0.0287018828,
0.050210122,
-0.0239601359,
0.0062857689,
0.0402740873,
0.0299349148,
-0.0084818872,
-0.0249013081,
0.0529077835,
-0.0130309118,
0.0728929192,
0.016011104,
0.0064196554,
-0.022173604,
-0.030183943,
0.0061001219,
-0.0978386998,
-0.0641642585,
0.0061633028,
-0.0332662165,
-0.0486140624,
-0.086970754,
-0.1029158533,
0.0003361679,
-0.0299067125,
0.0227784067,
0.0004896056,
-0.0052096415,
0.0252017528,
-0.0396617539,
0.0115898913,
-0.0192336775,
0.0036674554,
-0.0158027261,
0.0071558696,
0.0267542079,
-0.0165775754,
0.0010224077,
0.0384578258,
-0.051846683,
-0.0743256137,
0.0088943467,
0.0338510126,
0.019700421,
0.0751007274,
-0.0022996792,
0.0079489015,
0.0612201765,
0.0311461203,
-0.0253510606,
0.0223389883,
0.0092647439,
0.0307153966,
-0.0299875494,
0.0281665437,
-0.0594122708,
0.0021703311,
-0.0152021116,
0.0142491246,
-0.0300953705,
-0.0222772099,
0.0065704663,
0.0487326346,
0.0143368104,
-0.0447481871,
0.0345858485,
-0.0186070129,
-0.043317318,
-0.0532631278,
-0.0097132726,
-0.0004380444,
0.0208401978,
0.0072771451,
-0.0218412559,
-0.0182811022,
0.0754441246,
-0.0216650106,
-0.0139986621,
-0.0976197049,
0.0156775899,
0.0042465613,
0.0103002992,
-0.0400516279,
0.0240349919,
-0.032084804,
-0.0276868511,
-0.0098850541,
0.0232496336,
-0.0273321122,
0.0082569588,
0.0121946717,
0.0045993812,
0.0116898557,
0.0304189604,
-0.1019158885,
0.0422432162,
-0.0323694572,
-0.0002203858,
0.0694105253,
-0.059319824,
0.1269737929,
0.0099014286,
-0.0294071492,
0.0026834267,
0.0080159251,
0.0302901696,
0.0142736742,
-0.046892222,
0.0089352354,
0.003015697,
0.0243220218,
0.0803336054,
-0.0428711958,
0.0334411785,
0.0609603375,
-0.0463278666,
-0.032907933,
-0.0429092869,
-0.041562371,
-0.0223176237,
0.001421126,
-0.0480278507,
-0.0743740052,
-0.0359058864,
0.0030691149,
0.019370025,
0.0136680119,
-0.0031473625,
0.0081637586,
0.0004721346,
0.0042424807,
0.0199481361,
-0.0436554626,
0.0328511931,
0.0249382854,
-0.0132882297,
-0.0282781068,
-5.955487477e-33,
-0.0411044806,
0.0176675525,
-0.0202971175,
0.0271645356,
-0.0639003962,
-0.0169399492,
-0.0578708462,
-0.0105781974,
-0.0100567183,
0.0253802668,
0.0017106767,
-0.0006770373,
0.0101296483,
0.0055908482,
-0.0089675076,
-0.0002682272,
0.0578119457,
0.0200645011,
-0.0695037544,
0.0507853851,
0.0643623173,
0.0241558105,
0.097763747,
-0.0461254232,
0.035884466,
0.0022619916,
-0.0288183689,
-0.0278172139,
0.0676970705,
0.020062279,
0.027010059,
0.0224053152,
0.0139304549,
-0.0599412322,
-0.0436841287,
-0.0256518926,
-0.1139540672,
-0.0423028171,
0.0423687585,
-0.0011341581,
0.0069645741,
-0.0434220433,
0.0206224304,
-0.039550893,
0.0073020919,
-0.0403412059,
0.0604689643,
-0.0395749956,
0.0005127953,
-0.0465067439,
-0.0194467399,
0.0324930102,
-0.0420726798,
-0.0234691873,
0.0189207569,
0.0770938396,
0.0393106639,
0.0143709499,
-0.0611663796,
0.05473895,
0.0104524959,
0.0066039157,
0.016793061,
-0.0310187675,
0.0015539168,
0.0660184771,
-0.0051124557,
0.0183994267,
-0.0417861156,
0.0233659782,
-0.0090674208,
-0.0216955394,
0.0175671596,
0.0616129413,
0.0547129959,
-0.0053480533,
-0.0534645729,
0.0925619826,
-0.0227300934,
0.0593053885,
-0.0073224343,
-0.0253654737,
0.0249411631,
-0.0058118496,
-0.0201132428,
-0.0397699997,
0.0067543001,
-0.0051993877,
-0.020463245,
0.0048603597,
-0.0418126881,
-0.0177199673,
0.02176526,
-0.0393052772,
0.0265599247,
0.0306463297,
-0.033483956,
0.0060121054,
0.0289024897,
-0.0097760269,
-0.0188358575,
0.0550165474,
0.0230675954,
0.0150701804,
0.020340113,
-0.0239506532,
0.051696524,
0.0228854939,
-0.0477978885,
-0.0051269298,
0.0010423794,
0.0172305442,
-0.0396138057,
0.0139759677,
-0.0028684989,
0.0057496815,
-0.0040528309,
-0.0177677572,
0.0215565916,
-0.0003835466,
-0.0125178462,
0.0116352206,
0.0561861433,
0.0254628081,
0.0005850827,
0.0190362278,
0.0206688903,
0.0397262424,
0.0545465499,
-0.053379178,
-0.0253401697,
-0.0206084084,
2.721e-7,
0.0470181555,
0.0022743694,
0.0861044452,
0.0205874816,
-0.0255372338,
0.019798344,
-0.0314652994,
0.0342938937,
0.0134673314,
0.0083258385,
0.0294956118,
-0.0032988472,
0.0451765545,
0.0572369248,
-0.0828489289,
-0.0311786886,
-0.0427353308,
-0.054874707,
-0.0293527804,
0.00100625,
0.0340596139,
0.054989282,
-0.0024007999,
-0.0090749357,
-0.0214283746,
-0.0197843015,
0.0528220832,
-0.0326234512,
-0.0878634378,
0.0005447348,
0.0546382628,
0.006177526,
-0.0064561442,
0.0041543893,
-0.0293113496,
0.0080878902,
0.0607923605,
0.0203532092,
0.0094473269,
-0.0406189524,
-0.0096584884,
-0.0188446157,
0.0004323256,
-0.006153123,
0.0592085794,
-0.0373599567,
-0.0175794829,
0.0112001756,
-0.0702366456,
0.0371554457,
0.0377524011,
-0.0061490596,
-0.0502292924,
0.0461224802,
0.017953407,
0.0288007986,
0.0041443449,
-0.0523501188,
-0.0414358862,
0.0409669802,
0.0002276483,
-0.0406936407,
0.0146067254,
-0.0259475224,
-0.0261718202,
-0.0249898154,
-0.0060014571,
2.550149817e-34,
0.0822928697,
-0.0239052735,
-0.0364915319,
-0.0672873408,
0.0322971083,
-0.0317209288,
0.0208459515,
-0.0270992164,
-0.0001503702,
-0.0372040346,
-0.035697706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12913v1 | Implicit spoken language diarization | 2023-06-22T14:29:53 | 2023-06-22T14:29:53 | Jagabandhu Mishra, Amartya Chowdhury, S. R. Mahadeva Prasanna | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Spoken language diarization (LD) and related tasks are mostly explored using
the phonotactic approach. Phonotactic approaches mostly use explicit way of
language modeling, hence requiring intermediate phoneme modeling and
transcribed data. Alternatively, the ability of deep learning approaches to
model temporal dynamics may help for the implicit modeling of language
information through deep embedding vectors. Hence this work initially explores
the available speaker diarization frameworks that capture speaker information
implicitly to perform LD tasks. The performance of the LD system on synthetic
code-switch data using the end-to-end x-vector approach is 6.78% and 7.06%, and
for practical data is 22.50% and 60.38%, in terms of diarization error rate and
Jaccard error rate (JER), respectively. The performance degradation is due to
the data imbalance and resolved to some extent by using pre-trained wave2vec
embeddings that provide a relative improvement of 30.74% in terms of JER. | [
-0.0357214622,
0.0634306222,
0.0079558119,
0.0045615104,
0.0039475835,
0.0237766318,
0.0588003583,
-0.019929029,
0.028247606,
-0.0058096116,
-0.0117009655,
-0.0336712562,
0.0392668508,
0.0263328459,
0.0122896219,
-0.0141612124,
0.0463699736,
-0.042577967,
0.0106981564,
-0.0213924963,
-0.0283679366,
-0.021987237,
-0.0353235714,
0.0049866401,
-0.0177209266,
0.0084297368,
0.002162976,
0.0007799927,
0.0427523032,
-0.0033598987,
0.0402385071,
0.0426264815,
0.0142213563,
0.0579449311,
0.0000020977,
0.0239145085,
-0.0013158903,
-0.040106561,
-0.0481137894,
0.0285089761,
-0.0368653461,
0.0091948314,
-0.0123889735,
0.0162375886,
-0.0200583544,
-0.0601343773,
0.0384427495,
0.0086066471,
0.0363178439,
0.0092790239,
0.0005287583,
-0.0459708236,
0.0125293788,
-0.0021760331,
-0.0122220144,
0.0199746285,
0.0215393584,
-0.0482166447,
-0.0696673915,
-0.051520966,
0.0106304316,
0.0802532211,
0.0218437556,
-0.0356356017,
0.0380541272,
0.0254129451,
-0.0385138579,
0.0109042805,
0.005071098,
0.0583912544,
-0.0454009548,
-0.0012125461,
0.0173571147,
0.0023621756,
-0.03665068,
-0.015617908,
0.0172620006,
-0.0450550616,
0.0086296732,
-0.0201676898,
-0.0066424003,
0.0683467239,
0.0445243269,
-0.0346533395,
-0.0271991435,
0.0114686918,
-0.0086451015,
-0.0250041578,
-0.0142288553,
-0.0292524789,
0.0278540328,
0.0003462114,
0.0463116132,
0.0116286529,
-0.0150300413,
0.0005149927,
0.019437151,
-0.0238084514,
-0.0238241255,
-0.0788647085,
0.0212087724,
0.0282071475,
-0.0435875729,
-0.0023400809,
-0.0327759869,
0.0325738154,
-0.0072444035,
-0.0263694283,
-0.004564858,
0.0058845221,
-0.0305226315,
0.0155976629,
-0.0388518237,
0.0207985658,
0.0861003697,
-0.0041305255,
-0.0620151795,
-0.0029513168,
-0.0210663434,
-0.0189353693,
0.0033339611,
0.0079818452,
-0.0319467708,
0.0326869786,
0.0063478379,
0.0148209734,
-0.0201265253,
0.02431353,
-0.0588463917,
-0.0439687558,
0.0223829448,
0.0430721529,
0.0014401688,
-0.0018201037,
-0.0291085113,
-0.0125724562,
-0.0130321477,
-0.0282903444,
-0.026057912,
-0.0002508449,
-0.0240212101,
-0.0191560406,
-0.0084570684,
-0.0834521055,
0.0260555726,
-0.0205873214,
0.0006216039,
-0.0338403024,
-0.0258656237,
-0.0285316166,
0.0468712412,
0.0739583671,
0.0038855176,
0.0180993602,
0.1005270109,
-0.0034867299,
0.0427140333,
0.0316096619,
0.0329483412,
-0.0317637809,
-0.0074207191,
-0.0538232587,
0.0175046977,
0.0553902462,
0.0006287319,
-0.0059797987,
-0.0428342037,
-0.0186713431,
0.0219565555,
0.0308253281,
0.0459791087,
0.0187202152,
-0.0268403217,
-0.0170001816,
0.0270316098,
0.0596291348,
0.0365957916,
0.0314096026,
0.074574925,
-0.003566074,
0.0281898584,
0.0129773961,
0.0126036284,
-0.0111817401,
0.0138997789,
-0.0523525439,
0.0397063643,
0.0014226692,
-0.051067479,
-0.0243753884,
0.0683578774,
-0.0604484677,
0.0071897353,
0.0316282101,
0.0153997755,
-0.0359570235,
0.0219093636,
0.1278550625,
0.0018863446,
-0.0143994568,
0.0105514424,
0.0061551766,
-0.0285691936,
0.0417670533,
-0.0248411205,
-0.0297755152,
0.0259582121,
-0.0696066469,
-0.0061637266,
0.0141863814,
0.0623940788,
-0.0277594589,
0.031395372,
-0.0501982681,
-0.0409226567,
0.0487978198,
-0.0274533238,
0.0357545093,
-0.0091546401,
0.0373347588,
0.038410224,
-0.025310915,
0.008887589,
-0.0085991193,
-0.0737981424,
-0.039169725,
0.0330853648,
0.0307059232,
0.032673303,
0.0599702708,
-0.012234441,
-0.0214123968,
0.0062102801,
-0.060100846,
0.0139298942,
-0.0190623347,
-0.0982006267,
-0.0325695574,
0.0461973585,
-0.031311661,
-0.0022459405,
0.0468742065,
-0.0140995523,
-0.0781538785,
0.0318364426,
-0.02596635,
-0.0093565388,
-0.0412206985,
0.0220344197,
-0.0242697746,
0.0549240336,
-0.0021477798,
0.019135138,
-0.0025881708,
0.0199869405,
0.0535398312,
0.0102647478,
0.0128333382,
-0.073643811,
-0.0360367969,
-0.0033218367,
-0.0059591262,
0.0317594782,
-0.0069132657,
-0.0339485295,
0.0014499691,
-0.0165683702,
-0.071928151,
-0.0247954484,
-0.0210680924,
-0.0009943937,
-0.0355509371,
0.0355064012,
0.0111242244,
-0.0233431123,
-0.0297797602,
-0.0036176855,
-0.0220955983,
-0.0238074455,
-0.0352261141,
0.0232580192,
-0.0735421628,
-0.0197657272,
-0.0069587552,
-0.0108217662,
0.029485587,
-0.0084923944,
-0.0246291794,
-0.0503622033,
-0.0176084433,
0.0287901554,
0.0315027609,
0.0033176348,
-0.0333568491,
-0.0175105203,
0.0079886876,
0.0707217753,
-0.0073265382,
0.0244923066,
-0.0152766695,
0.0087713124,
-0.0059713791,
-0.0556020141,
-0.0027237148,
0.0016558347,
0.0354443304,
-0.050613936,
-0.0147199426,
-0.0438647494,
0.061474923,
0.0011996531,
0.0361521244,
-0.0141508151,
-0.0343105905,
-0.0149290413,
-0.0268071722,
0.0105073527,
-0.0181220621,
-0.0339154601,
-0.0080676479,
-0.0065158214,
-0.0181043483,
0.0524423011,
-0.0473482572,
-0.0046984334,
-0.0293679256,
-0.0776399001,
-0.0010750246,
-0.0443790443,
-0.0038319842,
-0.0017379898,
-0.0038320844,
-0.0521164387,
-0.006244286,
-0.0290811062,
0.0041962448,
-0.0502977371,
0.0329234935,
0.0175276678,
0.033510454,
0.0012463209,
-0.0162501968,
-0.0522864424,
-0.0326492861,
-0.0065624882,
0.0280532762,
0.0244801156,
-0.0315780379,
0.0035301149,
0.0668817535,
0.0072281337,
0.022091398,
0.0158197731,
0.0116068292,
-0.0285550095,
0.0838405043,
0.0023424772,
0.0094986316,
-0.027793847,
0.0216130186,
0.0431569517,
-0.0644803122,
-0.0027832952,
0.0587937534,
-0.060027428,
0.0038814056,
0.0158307385,
0.001391154,
-0.0509222038,
0.0087210061,
0.0086736968,
0.0069735739,
0.0075730127,
0.1319749802,
0.0000668331,
-0.1293101609,
-0.0154150026,
0.0001371239,
-0.0273420792,
0.0108048087,
0.0063886968,
-0.0347086079,
0.0073285475,
0.0231863838,
0.0268604811,
0.041941382,
-0.0264639352,
0.0167460535,
-0.0594925359,
-0.0014561616,
0.0069028172,
0.0307695586,
-0.0449862555,
-0.0547363237,
-0.0000720125,
0.014977756,
0.0359704345,
-0.0157170705,
0.0213746149,
-0.0575820655,
0.0594393015,
-0.0923764706,
-0.0476475395,
0.0349394567,
-0.0275876112,
0.0806802064,
0.0002794321,
0.0476195551,
-0.0145319831,
-0.0022536246,
0.0231884662,
-0.0407449789,
-0.0479577295,
-0.0087192962,
0.0532970391,
0.0186425112,
0.0144642713,
0.0185815841,
0.0041459543,
0.0227323882,
0.0170474909,
-0.0207133312,
0.0541961975,
-0.0179091021,
-0.0062226811,
0.0044488041,
0.025741417,
0.0628606826,
0.0354760215,
0.0540238507,
-0.034048222,
0.0155966189,
0.0371776409,
0.0643222257,
-0.0165279917,
-0.0378617197,
0.0133965891,
0.0206394885,
-0.0761985183,
0.0180158895,
-0.0269151237,
-0.0126471911,
0.0035245176,
0.022726886,
0.03889516,
0.0031954837,
-0.0030380327,
-0.0463652574,
0.0144908335,
-0.015222962,
0.0752242133,
-0.0412925445,
-0.0369445495,
0.0260161813,
-0.0284128562,
0.0304415189,
-0.0000895332,
-0.0198958814,
-0.0116251446,
0.0303120352,
-0.0190486964,
0.0061727292,
0.0615976974,
-0.0645846948,
-0.0703673512,
0.0855695233,
0.0122547904,
-0.0564683005,
-0.0113544567,
0.0187477283,
0.0439948924,
-0.0332049653,
0.0265412703,
-0.051156994,
0.0281590931,
-0.0131880846,
-0.037973281,
-0.0959974676,
-0.096692048,
-0.0231967028,
-0.0234785303,
0.052284345,
-0.0176133085,
-0.0190672651,
-0.0289480686,
0.0064856545,
0.0181736182,
0.0329647288,
0.0023188365,
-0.0026043789,
0.0288170353,
-0.0099326884,
-0.0042963438,
0.0382669419,
-0.0073187239,
-0.0462665223,
0.009360767,
0.0944922194,
0.0496620275,
0.064437598,
0.0088283923,
0.0292727314,
-0.0224453267,
0.0265846327,
0.0052693165,
0.009498152,
-0.007528455,
-0.009043226,
-0.0055568474,
0.0387691073,
-0.0167715698,
0.0043996698,
-0.0110805994,
-0.0169533379,
0.0035289999,
-0.0305843502,
0.0476187579,
0.0021945902,
0.0450852886,
0.0345432237,
0.016416816,
-0.0230463669,
0.0040075229,
-0.0366998352,
0.0090624774,
0.0534083992,
0.0047881058,
-0.0213888139,
0.0460418649,
0.0335448459,
0.0365097038,
0.0338500738,
-0.0405085944,
0.0291927475,
-0.0514721759,
0.0292952731,
0.0560089536,
0.0041907551,
-0.0540031157,
-0.0178072266,
0.0111500006,
-0.0723592639,
0.037522126,
-0.0395171046,
-0.0014595755,
0.0195023026,
-0.0157843474,
0.0156960022,
-0.0303515624,
0.0264687464,
-0.0006624096,
-0.0091159474,
0.0383899212,
-0.0468619615,
-0.0222850833,
-6.253200156e-33,
-0.0342498235,
0.009071691,
-0.0220576581,
-0.0196205098,
-0.016260393,
0.0244262367,
-0.038348332,
-0.0055068061,
0.0000664775,
-0.0398066901,
-0.0072312709,
0.0191213656,
0.0329331942,
-0.0032590555,
-0.017118413,
-0.0159428734,
0.0877700001,
-0.0402814522,
0.0076078796,
0.0343100317,
0.0283671245,
0.0194016509,
0.0294676609,
-0.0721741691,
-0.0359499417,
-0.0128764007,
0.023477288,
0.0126252286,
0.0130950129,
0.0239331946,
-0.0544589125,
0.0428530946,
-0.0110634612,
0.0193599686,
-0.0049664672,
0.0727760047,
-0.1078779176,
-0.0137105742,
-0.0656075478,
0.0772289634,
0.0231848471,
-0.0500388891,
0.0394937284,
0.0434602611,
-0.0153294438,
-0.0242637768,
0.0677454546,
0.0044798716,
-0.015971072,
-0.0646096319,
0.0340828411,
0.0435567722,
-0.030422762,
-0.0300519019,
0.0926828012,
0.0252494738,
-0.0075050057,
-0.0417127423,
-0.1361224353,
0.0171722043,
0.0253475159,
0.0145765888,
0.0327347033,
0.0423495211,
-0.0177454669,
0.0111926803,
0.0971378312,
-0.0414779671,
0.0371070243,
-0.0412373766,
0.0497019365,
-0.0170696955,
-0.0140176434,
-0.0140638789,
0.02577205,
-0.0479109138,
-0.0283373296,
-0.0014278967,
0.0788908899,
-0.0339240208,
0.0408918969,
0.0000661403,
-0.0500893667,
-0.0265864246,
-0.0270952825,
-0.0272977874,
-0.0141961444,
-0.0288613252,
0.026598122,
-0.0132583734,
0.0084176604,
-0.0585089363,
0.0689991191,
-0.0495395884,
-0.0133616114,
0.0381367244,
0.0345844887,
0.0226560459,
0.0130750304,
0.0165776704,
-0.0191156305,
-0.0541838594,
0.0432890356,
0.0367147401,
0.0517280586,
-0.0355154835,
-0.0369583815,
0.0644013882,
-0.0225917101,
-0.0143041462,
0.0245802607,
-0.0021291785,
0.0013290835,
0.0652610436,
0.0153341088,
-0.02203824,
0.0204733685,
0.0070062787,
0.0197468996,
0.0023406611,
0.0254192203,
-0.034867879,
0.0129016899,
0.0815881193,
-0.0408574603,
0.0023269395,
-0.0205978286,
0.0264503248,
0.0221581776,
-0.0363936499,
0.0140109574,
0.0056072394,
2.793e-7,
-0.0323889963,
0.0032882395,
0.0298837461,
-0.0319694653,
0.0217125472,
-0.0039534667,
0.0220951848,
-0.0152403573,
-0.0097489376,
0.0000811646,
0.019531982,
0.0099001396,
0.068494603,
0.0342997424,
-0.0831269994,
-0.0079428926,
-0.0403001346,
0.0758564994,
-0.0241073389,
-0.0082366345,
0.032319624,
0.0815874711,
0.0005117728,
-0.032221783,
0.0016971062,
0.0153767252,
-0.0138881207,
0.0125674689,
0.000867688,
0.0129453419,
0.0545535386,
-0.0187607221,
-0.0157697573,
0.0512691364,
-0.0070680091,
0.0506930538,
0.0055953818,
0.0092667872,
-0.0072429175,
-0.0219765957,
-0.0397894681,
-0.0154919745,
-0.0273973644,
0.0008625756,
0.04259241,
-0.0306463074,
-0.0350164659,
0.0336450152,
-0.0560800433,
0.0063430709,
0.0221183449,
0.0063196439,
-0.0175395012,
0.0273877401,
-0.0022527487,
-0.0485263653,
-0.0164978933,
-0.0795089826,
-0.0040434445,
0.0473165587,
-0.0659228638,
0.0063583204,
-0.0084047671,
-0.0175047591,
0.0712570623,
0.0129952766,
0.0773468837,
1.954685016e-34,
0.0137937423,
0.0231177174,
-0.0055299816,
-0.0168019775,
-0.0190400779,
-0.0525404103,
-0.0208786651,
0.0408299267,
0.0461460389,
-0.0490357354,
-0.0180335585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12907v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12907v1 | xSIM++: An Improved Proxy to Bitext Mining Performance for Low-Resource Languages | 2023-06-22T14:20:15 | 2023-06-22T14:20:15 | Mingda Chen, Kevin Heffernan, Onur Çelebi, Alex Mourachko, Holger Schwenk | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce a new proxy score for evaluating bitext mining based on
similarity in a multilingual embedding space: xSIM++. In comparison to xSIM,
this improved proxy leverages rule-based approaches to extend English sentences
in any evaluation set with synthetic, hard-to-distinguish examples which more
closely mirror the scenarios we encounter during large-scale mining. We
validate this proxy by running a significant number of bitext mining
experiments for a set of low-resource languages, and subsequently train NMT
systems on the mined data. In comparison to xSIM, we show that xSIM++ is better
correlated with the downstream BLEU scores of translation systems trained on
mined bitexts, providing a reliable proxy of bitext mining performance without
needing to run expensive bitext mining pipelines. xSIM++ also reports
performance for different error types, offering more fine-grained feedback for
model development. | [
-0.0125935664,
0.032485202,
-0.0286954995,
0.0559941046,
-0.0284991488,
0.0204611607,
-0.0124969557,
0.0280633345,
-0.0607880354,
-0.01686644,
-0.0321327932,
-0.0031407611,
-0.0066779321,
0.0317847431,
0.0365459993,
-0.0038387449,
0.0447311625,
0.0047264677,
-0.0099841142,
0.0228965655,
0.0145456465,
-0.0186338183,
0.0174495745,
0.0434138775,
-0.0154617904,
0.0084649837,
0.0302391853,
0.0021498455,
0.0830712542,
-0.0163176209,
0.0281933825,
0.0361122116,
-0.0131165218,
0.0721265748,
0.000002088,
-0.0471463427,
-0.0470676608,
0.0148856258,
0.0102800867,
0.0150874946,
0.0193295833,
-0.0624073744,
-0.040835306,
0.0352866724,
-0.0342981555,
-0.0363502391,
0.058100421,
0.0190682374,
0.066870071,
0.0604792908,
-0.0209151972,
0.0161868576,
-0.0303276181,
-0.0380233191,
-0.0291931815,
-0.0078859525,
-0.0155160995,
0.0290661044,
0.0019915844,
0.0209565368,
0.0258698929,
0.0388043188,
0.0313219428,
-0.0122864619,
0.0002377448,
0.0406165756,
-0.0356364548,
0.0395587161,
0.0134228664,
0.0512725301,
-0.0753207207,
-0.0114923595,
-0.0148107652,
-0.0271102246,
-0.0328517817,
-0.0580432937,
-0.0547232032,
0.0545604117,
-0.0075519881,
0.023661064,
0.0100932196,
0.0295089725,
0.047029268,
-0.0117007233,
-0.0240508877,
0.0438446142,
0.0338767506,
-0.0507444553,
-0.0154031571,
0.0539543442,
-0.0042618513,
0.0185782555,
0.0309571829,
-0.0323375799,
-0.0398218483,
0.0141048776,
-0.0153572969,
-0.0213981774,
0.0454027206,
-0.0470535271,
0.0254312791,
0.0716335922,
-0.0530451946,
0.0241032131,
-0.0431330949,
-0.0182452835,
0.011954451,
-0.0166300777,
-0.0574274957,
-0.0062380671,
-0.0346675031,
0.0142080076,
-0.0296001229,
-0.0247276854,
-0.0742131099,
0.0004330002,
-0.0182424765,
-0.0068565281,
0.0142767141,
0.0077913105,
-0.0053093233,
-0.0265377406,
-0.0316955857,
0.0346223973,
0.0085076448,
0.0449728295,
-0.031613186,
-0.0048381188,
0.0126934387,
-0.0205190424,
-0.0462647676,
0.0189788267,
-0.0032972209,
-0.0436139591,
-0.0258009396,
0.082384944,
-0.0087031117,
-0.0516041331,
-0.0411003828,
-0.0195366144,
-0.0089828214,
-0.0466302335,
0.0069549894,
-0.0453042425,
0.0613097288,
-0.0045842412,
0.0275447723,
0.0164593291,
0.0087933978,
0.0096992301,
0.0182539746,
0.0502876639,
-0.0045216749,
-0.0493097119,
-0.0667344108,
-0.0067181019,
0.0240032244,
0.0727793947,
0.0360318571,
0.0184646398,
0.0400995091,
-0.0139188571,
-0.051863052,
0.073979333,
-0.0028430179,
0.019353047,
0.0030758493,
-0.0085259099,
0.0356633179,
0.0407940596,
0.0374358408,
0.0226897076,
-0.0554835349,
0.0040230718,
0.04461243,
0.0194443185,
0.0520981029,
0.0521960482,
0.0490765572,
-0.0160030313,
-0.0237982851,
-0.0159091875,
-0.0275709927,
0.0039930767,
-0.0289300177,
0.0167005565,
0.0263965875,
0.0621973574,
0.0116935512,
-0.0356418677,
-0.0353554562,
-0.0117728766,
0.0100110797,
-0.0529323891,
0.037106242,
-0.0087860711,
-0.0241335258,
0.0682309791,
0.0425000116,
-0.0725696906,
0.0020251833,
-0.0385836512,
0.0081248721,
0.0454085469,
0.0643118024,
-0.016402483,
0.0077309785,
-0.0080191949,
-0.0723912716,
0.0509251133,
-0.0189419966,
-0.004844822,
0.0288691241,
-0.0585150495,
-0.0364681073,
-0.0091782873,
0.007471506,
0.0364733338,
0.0054097343,
0.025268143,
0.0251120646,
-0.0368585959,
-0.0426594019,
0.0262135174,
0.002288653,
-0.0017466593,
0.0153474277,
0.0128775807,
0.0350894257,
0.0513986163,
-0.037083704,
-0.0065130861,
0.0290531181,
-0.0549148954,
-0.0735800639,
0.0248822663,
-0.0251107085,
-0.115358606,
0.0600157939,
-0.0543199442,
0.0188082512,
-0.0282278601,
-0.0420727096,
-0.0447744876,
0.0000276284,
-0.0770425871,
0.0549436286,
-0.0587084442,
0.0235943813,
0.0036841501,
0.0311672762,
-0.0492028557,
0.0625685453,
-0.0155781237,
0.0059611029,
-0.0222458243,
-0.0507290363,
0.0552061163,
-0.0246734321,
-0.0082473308,
0.0332410932,
-0.0275843423,
0.0579973161,
0.0344634205,
0.0412089676,
-0.0494678244,
-0.0468326285,
-0.0431971401,
0.0328301974,
-0.0414038189,
0.0480444133,
0.0414403379,
0.0460418575,
-0.010063597,
-0.0037643453,
-0.0107086655,
-0.0646122694,
0.0155212712,
-0.0018126533,
0.0109108854,
0.0001359254,
0.0189874787,
-0.0355986804,
-0.0127549097,
-0.0074062692,
0.0328272767,
-0.0365110971,
-0.0145229418,
-0.0869825333,
0.0259611178,
-0.0127574392,
-0.0441696607,
-0.0013923612,
-0.0598138943,
0.0076791486,
0.0003463628,
0.043238882,
-0.0069473581,
-0.0183194391,
0.0222482122,
0.0408394076,
-0.0093144225,
-0.0330497213,
0.0034491238,
-0.0069838846,
0.0318546481,
-0.0162497591,
-0.0099618202,
0.0217508953,
0.0609236099,
-0.0134468377,
-0.0128093977,
-0.049095694,
0.0024531046,
-0.0089685693,
-0.0031809425,
0.0087039936,
0.0151411891,
0.0150066912,
0.0031069103,
-0.0249494184,
-0.0631159618,
0.0783836618,
-0.0649746507,
-0.041378092,
-0.1073578969,
-0.043507833,
-0.0607416369,
-0.0081050107,
0.0085661523,
0.0164084416,
0.0162887666,
-0.0059724501,
0.0189432334,
0.013043765,
0.0012595814,
-0.0112561043,
0.0174401794,
-0.0268582385,
0.0112302518,
-0.0272793993,
-0.0163234472,
-0.0255764108,
-0.005915537,
-0.0052927374,
0.0014002536,
0.0452339612,
-0.0300306734,
-0.0258729216,
0.0429904945,
0.0183843784,
0.0285033304,
-0.0204178225,
-0.0069126631,
-0.0246263165,
0.0351729244,
0.0245151427,
0.0225149859,
0.049312599,
-0.0031426377,
0.030233223,
0.0601338036,
0.0179858394,
-0.0143529885,
-0.0580915585,
0.0101176882,
0.028996015,
-0.0053486377,
-0.0038327356,
-0.0214549489,
0.0469257645,
-0.0394395068,
-0.000210431,
0.0852154568,
0.043758098,
0.0010420447,
0.0145292208,
-0.0238937195,
0.0601220801,
-0.0001697656,
-0.0026937057,
-0.076960288,
-0.0285063349,
0.0140971942,
0.0351146385,
0.0240491871,
0.0280985925,
-0.0055585257,
-0.109058328,
0.0472021699,
0.0294906721,
-0.0687443018,
0.0145932185,
-0.0222457685,
-0.040565405,
-0.0402315482,
0.023309296,
-0.0205269028,
-0.0012387827,
-0.0075523588,
0.0209776554,
0.0293651782,
-0.0757577047,
-0.002588657,
-0.0700879395,
0.0292887706,
0.0779419467,
0.0352687426,
0.0233176537,
-0.0203001555,
-0.0146022644,
-0.0644000322,
-0.0045170346,
-0.0331742987,
0.0626864284,
0.0163464397,
-0.0368207544,
0.0120924395,
0.0350813977,
-0.0272890385,
-0.0061626579,
0.0043986267,
0.0809760392,
-0.0276969615,
-0.0267075691,
-0.0083924951,
-0.0252097603,
0.0038616911,
0.045758903,
0.0219632871,
-0.0256131068,
0.0087554669,
-0.0241233613,
-0.0015053359,
-0.0692331269,
-0.0418376885,
0.0044268169,
-0.01383253,
-0.0258858688,
-0.0624166355,
-0.0970535725,
0.0164795425,
0.0495614484,
-0.020986015,
0.0052191252,
0.0162197668,
-0.004419493,
-0.0147462776,
0.0710076392,
-0.0301655512,
0.0477170981,
-0.0278382413,
0.000544994,
0.0049928371,
-0.0070265597,
-0.0197191164,
-0.0331959985,
-0.070302099,
-0.0623752736,
-0.0708293244,
0.0418219306,
0.0174707863,
0.0340630487,
-0.0382069238,
-0.0207279399,
0.0613737442,
0.0052444246,
-0.0343704261,
-0.0068853106,
0.0685172379,
-0.0515454225,
-0.01381501,
0.0082313893,
-0.0163614843,
0.0013925662,
-0.0094812149,
0.0793722421,
0.016974844,
-0.0503236763,
0.0191911627,
-0.0025316796,
0.0259004086,
-0.0305115618,
-0.0030517045,
-0.025139967,
0.0279027559,
-0.0079957359,
0.0119580254,
-0.0608548224,
-0.0045479173,
0.0435740836,
0.0071578729,
-0.0171881393,
0.0225738473,
-0.0196564607,
-0.0055458718,
0.0037121668,
0.0425696485,
0.0011566854,
0.0176526103,
0.0101704895,
0.0198053773,
-0.016585201,
-0.0349600762,
0.0100828838,
0.041609101,
-0.0371253081,
0.0501937419,
0.0288972631,
0.0004681548,
0.0314033218,
0.0708068311,
-0.0056970008,
0.0256682448,
-0.0381548218,
-0.0273123886,
0.0708040968,
-0.0259918291,
0.115861088,
-0.0241096672,
0.0066929576,
-0.0085352426,
0.0356877483,
-0.0206590779,
-0.0280610994,
0.029958887,
-0.0026033509,
-0.0436893515,
-0.0083647249,
0.0410614274,
-0.0279213078,
0.0202794708,
-0.0166915599,
-0.0220114104,
-0.0310796052,
-0.0342856571,
-0.019462293,
0.010822936,
-0.0371057168,
-0.000116993,
-0.0354111418,
-0.0609474741,
-0.0270410888,
0.0492780097,
-0.0201264676,
-0.0117066307,
0.0078083915,
0.0417708047,
-0.0165610388,
-0.0198844522,
0.0082343724,
-0.0389305241,
0.0082281372,
-0.0071696769,
-0.0168367922,
-6.342974864e-33,
-0.0079835858,
0.0188541971,
0.0259882137,
-0.0527895801,
-0.021721825,
-0.0141056878,
-0.0382935032,
-0.0044314265,
0.0086627444,
0.0260349475,
0.0058311583,
-0.0250494406,
0.029013887,
0.0304810256,
0.0044921967,
0.0458680391,
0.0585829392,
0.0299424231,
-0.0181051809,
0.0158771239,
0.0069560246,
0.0334234163,
0.0964401513,
-0.0472248718,
-0.0055658454,
0.0158590116,
0.0176469162,
0.0062510748,
0.0010117949,
0.0543273427,
-0.0455798656,
0.013945641,
-0.0013654979,
-0.0447275527,
-0.0378013961,
-0.0239698812,
-0.0872836113,
-0.0258915629,
0.022915775,
0.0291294046,
0.0498029813,
-0.0037682292,
0.0158299655,
-0.0239702705,
0.0051346864,
-0.0105615938,
0.0190164503,
-0.0467698909,
0.0021629177,
0.0013536498,
-0.0899675488,
0.0378538221,
0.0046111513,
0.0130286943,
0.0322974101,
0.0467068702,
-0.0000223256,
-0.00241001,
-0.0678416342,
0.0208052974,
-0.0059755174,
0.04351414,
0.0776865408,
-0.0219669379,
-0.0424181037,
0.045829758,
0.0333864093,
-0.0403179303,
0.0775059983,
0.0334729403,
0.0398041271,
0.0161882676,
0.0639709979,
0.055627957,
0.0384346247,
0.007821925,
-0.0645859241,
0.0555564426,
0.034387365,
0.0011620581,
0.0174084771,
0.0254136696,
-0.0168902427,
0.0011193897,
0.002752577,
-0.0097669233,
-0.0087538743,
-0.0554809682,
0.0423221365,
0.0120926229,
-0.01622824,
-0.0197835527,
0.0499910675,
-0.0347294696,
0.00254572,
0.0222989861,
-0.0410490334,
0.0157119501,
-0.0090273507,
0.0071587143,
-0.0204029921,
-0.0314313322,
0.020525394,
-0.0124857621,
0.0191297159,
-0.0354466848,
0.0497860722,
0.0138357822,
-0.0484693088,
0.0499581546,
-0.0370899513,
0.0032431344,
-0.0349452794,
0.0189016368,
-0.0019830028,
-0.0025504092,
-0.0201363079,
-0.0082822293,
0.0425156727,
0.0280408468,
-0.050674174,
-0.0335484259,
0.0239733253,
0.0359433293,
-0.0084345704,
0.0136331981,
-0.0236627273,
0.0278219059,
0.0418623649,
-0.0535664931,
0.0030803278,
0.0109393522,
2.863e-7,
0.0396306291,
0.0335783586,
0.0100241648,
-0.0204945486,
0.0108813765,
0.053085804,
-0.0925976485,
0.0145875476,
0.014164946,
0.0549141727,
0.0084863016,
-0.0106718326,
0.0800906345,
0.0416947082,
-0.097760193,
-0.0080437465,
-0.0293388963,
-0.0426882319,
-0.0603558905,
-0.0172775574,
0.0253753476,
0.1247226968,
-0.0039601838,
-0.0108927907,
0.0226232167,
-0.1086355373,
0.0475464351,
-0.0108387694,
-0.0347003713,
0.0035823649,
0.0200700834,
0.0161761381,
-0.0306681916,
-0.0242621563,
-0.0040473416,
0.0565515272,
0.0173180215,
0.0350265168,
0.005852032,
0.0178762265,
0.0111216158,
-0.032184992,
0.0143494653,
-0.0293252375,
0.0260901544,
-0.0024227742,
-0.0022944314,
-0.0284196753,
0.0111478548,
-0.0049514249,
0.0277350266,
-0.0115904612,
-0.0167470369,
0.009626775,
0.0288766511,
-0.0000935089,
-0.0383532904,
-0.0752633736,
-0.0533732399,
0.0778504983,
-0.0278545599,
-0.0781855658,
-0.0412363186,
-0.0028988388,
0.0223945472,
-0.0363271572,
-0.0050305012,
3.027725391e-34,
0.0438340269,
-0.0232656207,
0.0382523984,
0.0397140272,
0.0393715054,
-0.0045473049,
0.0443608463,
-0.0005620585,
-0.030537257,
-0.0409614109,
0.001917582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12886v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12886v2 | Unveiling Global Narratives: A Multilingual Twitter Dataset of News Media on the Russo-Ukrainian Conflict | 2023-06-22T13:52:31 | 2024-04-07T16:01:11 | Sherzod Hakimov, Gullal S. Cheema | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL | The ongoing Russo-Ukrainian conflict has been a subject of intense media
coverage worldwide. Understanding the global narrative surrounding this topic
is crucial for researchers that aim to gain insights into its multifaceted
dimensions. In this paper, we present a novel multimedia dataset that focuses
on this topic by collecting and processing tweets posted by news or media
companies on social media across the globe. We collected tweets from February
2022 to May 2023 to acquire approximately 1.5 million tweets in 60 different
languages along with their images. Each entry in the dataset is accompanied by
processed tags, allowing for the identification of entities, stances, textual
or visual concepts, and sentiment. The availability of this multimedia dataset
serves as a valuable resource for researchers aiming to investigate the global
narrative surrounding the ongoing conflict from various aspects such as who are
the prominent entities involved, what stances are taken, where do these stances
originate from, how are the different textual and visual concepts related to
the event portrayed. | [
0.0304022469,
0.0389488861,
-0.0010459578,
-0.0008965387,
-0.0319232233,
0.0177515391,
0.0187070351,
-0.0232779309,
0.0018297887,
-0.017509345,
0.0518333502,
-0.038462285,
-0.017567791,
0.0457947329,
0.0240412708,
-0.0610541441,
0.0020034667,
0.0025959201,
0.0532797463,
-0.0164411552,
0.025741037,
0.058800865,
-0.0223288722,
-0.0127009628,
-0.0481216833,
0.0227189418,
0.0063808239,
0.002113505,
0.0412478223,
-0.0150294062,
-0.0310943183,
-0.0072847055,
0.0308499727,
0.0491985306,
0.0000018302,
-0.0017194059,
-0.0154120279,
-0.0472096577,
0.0460339636,
-0.0401454531,
0.0708646923,
-0.0629639328,
-0.0005171137,
-0.0117909601,
-0.0538488068,
-0.0112118488,
0.041950915,
0.0598222539,
0.0625341684,
0.0862236917,
-0.0336917974,
-0.0315884314,
-0.0262872949,
-0.0104897972,
-0.0236548912,
0.0257265214,
0.0067777545,
-0.0176563077,
-0.062565431,
0.0181528162,
0.0409305021,
0.0572814867,
-0.0154941725,
0.0117176287,
-0.0653770119,
0.0134146512,
-0.0510674603,
-0.0060939817,
0.0217070598,
0.0114735207,
0.0507606007,
-0.0255713724,
0.0409716889,
0.0040204022,
-0.0176707841,
-0.0185195468,
-0.0132938474,
0.0550344661,
-0.0249440782,
0.0536751114,
-0.01998684,
-0.0070163407,
-0.0124387508,
0.0220129862,
-0.0231933054,
0.0253664013,
-0.028532248,
0.0044165496,
-0.019096544,
0.0283201467,
-0.0269064121,
-0.0255272705,
0.0212673433,
0.0058045853,
-0.0163083188,
0.0147970542,
-0.0308007635,
-0.0032280872,
-0.0094350725,
-0.1128101721,
-0.0608105324,
0.0044501969,
0.0234882813,
0.0824729428,
-0.0216368474,
-0.0403922014,
-0.0137504684,
-0.0079143671,
0.0111143524,
-0.0310799647,
-0.074528724,
0.0258487016,
0.0243856739,
-0.0252029262,
0.0103079146,
-0.0062502464,
-0.0148466974,
-0.0084367795,
-0.0163264535,
0.0572713017,
-0.0351909325,
-0.0065022944,
-0.0141733447,
-0.0017271028,
-0.0179362129,
0.077646248,
-0.0524563156,
0.000370743,
-0.0561993495,
-0.0243137926,
0.0216042381,
-0.0083703622,
0.039364595,
-0.0073594437,
-0.0085196299,
0.0262390431,
-0.0189484581,
0.0146321002,
-0.0202989075,
-0.0366886668,
0.0293165911,
-0.0433663279,
0.0459980443,
-0.042552907,
0.052835241,
0.0214481875,
0.0146731567,
-0.0209467579,
-0.0142133748,
0.0015947514,
-0.0358239561,
0.037403442,
0.0138499336,
0.0388483144,
0.0439631902,
-0.0039507556,
0.0540124737,
0.1044227332,
0.0012745254,
0.0476927385,
0.0766056105,
-0.0069249519,
-0.0311087277,
0.0259148851,
-0.0062740468,
0.0413301997,
-0.039289888,
-0.0072941063,
-0.0243310407,
-0.0033087058,
0.0009327548,
-0.0055152108,
-0.0087978011,
-0.0179929566,
0.0719456002,
0.0430188999,
-0.0471032858,
0.000327018,
0.0094165429,
0.0403686576,
0.0148256775,
-0.0007462869,
0.0209038444,
0.0209785346,
0.0341955498,
0.0038411336,
0.042106647,
0.038453795,
-0.0385283828,
0.0143995164,
0.0257184636,
0.0210588481,
0.0142761339,
-0.015846597,
0.0240714941,
-0.0567430407,
-0.0248706117,
0.0155783696,
0.0373566672,
-0.0761389583,
0.0026513457,
-0.0161805172,
-0.0089490414,
0.0399661995,
0.0185584892,
-0.045055043,
-0.0311254803,
-0.044359833,
0.0820350349,
0.0300768223,
-0.0248638485,
0.0166096222,
-0.0096365921,
-0.0183890276,
-0.0404801928,
-0.0198442005,
-0.0242857337,
0.0119016152,
-0.0121604437,
0.0667311475,
-0.0202650651,
0.0078235669,
-0.0129459957,
0.0152450791,
0.0433141328,
0.0080684489,
-0.0046490659,
0.0414725207,
-0.0080581326,
0.0674199909,
-0.0214478467,
-0.0349061526,
0.0488458425,
0.0101989945,
0.0169757884,
0.048071228,
0.0261982419,
0.0386327244,
0.0194757357,
-0.0895598233,
-0.068508409,
-0.0332028009,
-0.0457869433,
-0.0004050615,
0.0865518227,
0.0130650802,
-0.0347236805,
0.0131259589,
-0.0393425636,
-0.0346601158,
-0.0002175287,
0.0299019217,
0.0292438678,
0.0099501582,
0.013773879,
-0.0318178274,
-0.0423584245,
0.031493213,
0.0108324988,
0.0043753386,
0.060579095,
-0.0001091831,
0.0088691609,
0.0325674303,
-0.0432215594,
-0.02920858,
0.0240971483,
-0.0765592754,
-0.0246671513,
-0.0221634265,
-0.019772809,
0.0446401983,
-0.0149006648,
-0.0260696001,
0.0214078147,
-0.0245480351,
-0.0288979951,
-0.0026065672,
-0.0015745445,
0.0000482105,
-0.0028312413,
0.0690684021,
-0.0330773555,
-0.0200155117,
-0.0337254032,
0.0538356714,
0.0131750815,
-0.0433933623,
-0.0046002669,
-0.0007585179,
-0.0539702028,
0.012854835,
-0.0466811135,
-0.0718071535,
0.0369341597,
-0.0204446428,
0.0203129034,
0.0483205542,
0.012289308,
0.0543402508,
0.0479187332,
0.003569318,
0.0074336454,
-0.0117209628,
-0.0528902411,
-0.0186758954,
-0.0004382733,
-0.0368075408,
-0.0086122202,
0.0227241721,
-0.0009203994,
0.0293402839,
-0.027771879,
-0.0303728823,
-0.0423775762,
0.0021764783,
-0.0274092425,
0.0074785412,
0.0296690911,
0.0458234698,
0.0099523012,
0.0177197289,
0.0215467438,
0.0175892301,
0.0620421544,
-0.0050544795,
-0.0458588004,
-0.0365110897,
0.0916446,
0.015024743,
-0.0137097053,
-0.0185908694,
0.0205094647,
-0.0095051182,
-0.0848145932,
0.0430053361,
-0.0123567162,
0.0109803071,
-0.0152988033,
0.0028301249,
-0.0220709648,
0.0389366932,
0.0275675766,
-0.0551022291,
-0.0150644807,
-0.0330560058,
-0.0009426306,
-0.0271970946,
-0.0329034403,
-0.0251779202,
0.0732272714,
-0.0034147594,
0.0002299209,
0.0052179378,
-0.0082999822,
0.0441269539,
0.0207494702,
-0.0577085055,
-0.0175599474,
-0.0074151112,
-0.0139258988,
0.0370401777,
0.0225418769,
-0.0242928825,
0.0036599841,
-0.0301409215,
0.0115581397,
0.0125423949,
-0.0085590687,
-0.0639004335,
0.0315178297,
-0.0313645229,
0.0597411618,
0.0558310896,
0.0266214646,
-0.0079930415,
-0.0119295334,
0.0346219391,
-0.0390023366,
0.0078583807,
0.0135296257,
-0.0961143225,
0.0602446944,
0.0100158891,
-0.0464501977,
-0.0494609363,
-0.0577619597,
-0.028747458,
-0.0671830028,
-0.0107001606,
-0.0100190379,
0.0027526908,
-0.0253107939,
-0.0351031646,
-0.0071070804,
-0.0206025336,
-0.0452815741,
-0.0265461262,
-0.0038003523,
0.0159957428,
-0.008799688,
-0.030669637,
-0.0317915753,
-0.0120961284,
-0.0307547618,
-0.0140667884,
-0.0095431935,
0.0560172573,
-0.0053797015,
0.0008819249,
-0.0371768735,
0.0114221461,
-0.0562603027,
-0.0050648246,
0.065712817,
-0.0282327551,
-0.0422246605,
0.0028296588,
0.028009031,
0.0106177721,
-0.0218012352,
-0.0010325997,
0.0244757049,
-0.0164794382,
0.0055924822,
0.0174352378,
0.0335549526,
0.049050685,
0.0054005883,
-0.0047492753,
0.0051207962,
-0.0341251604,
-0.0279223081,
0.0384170972,
-0.0789110288,
-0.0233754814,
0.0403800234,
-0.0283514354,
-0.0793628246,
-0.0172323696,
-0.0464117639,
0.0445685089,
0.0375856645,
-0.0375664718,
0.0101371957,
0.0073598716,
-0.0069315848,
-0.0738361329,
0.035218358,
0.0272160936,
0.0391862653,
0.0297763646,
-0.0338509008,
0.0050852862,
0.0224745926,
0.0045356117,
0.0423473753,
-0.0364068635,
-0.0331202038,
-0.0111615499,
-0.032819543,
0.0179009195,
0.0022590228,
0.0468360335,
-0.029952528,
0.032857921,
0.0487538725,
-0.0192686599,
-0.0023433077,
0.0096187256,
0.0518686809,
0.01587612,
0.0286836084,
0.02362106,
-0.0147720361,
0.0437429808,
-0.0541820824,
-0.0341622233,
0.0296833944,
-0.0119574498,
-0.0626762137,
0.0709849894,
-0.0127873244,
-0.0730117187,
-0.0605077595,
-0.0305473618,
-0.0481471755,
-0.0102653103,
0.0044968133,
0.0084816236,
-0.0061323792,
0.0008727198,
-0.0432889611,
0.0563759394,
-0.0280133504,
0.0058260234,
-0.0492141843,
0.032504037,
-0.00386732,
-0.0155131631,
-0.0040501039,
-0.0089685777,
0.0138221905,
0.0034779035,
-0.0253201313,
-0.045176588,
-0.0241879486,
-0.0227597896,
0.025790805,
0.0209958367,
0.0450530574,
0.0215054657,
-0.0293294229,
-0.0246530548,
0.0125600379,
0.0080487961,
0.0879066586,
-0.0300269742,
0.0525894128,
-0.0049770311,
-0.0054778461,
0.0260195732,
-0.0001994791,
-0.0376558118,
-0.032419879,
-0.0186123159,
0.0088081779,
-0.0195387658,
0.069956921,
0.041465003,
-0.0473054834,
0.0160473846,
0.0727559179,
-0.0225844197,
0.0210218802,
-0.0131235095,
0.0217800811,
-0.0107682832,
0.0053059086,
0.0006100233,
-0.0303437635,
-0.0484217666,
0.017563941,
-0.0129208108,
-0.0477973558,
0.0161461253,
0.0001988213,
0.0424677879,
0.0477258749,
0.0610633455,
-0.0723855868,
0.0368372388,
-0.0219558086,
-0.0497144498,
0.0481380932,
-6.351158509e-33,
0.0252983794,
-0.0015413783,
-0.01536927,
-0.0151077993,
-0.0443685576,
0.004096881,
-0.0321530588,
-0.0199502688,
-0.0341085456,
0.0285076667,
-0.0075753205,
0.0309798587,
0.0195289012,
-0.0124679208,
0.0356893875,
-0.0051910472,
0.0043553789,
-0.0257499907,
-0.017637752,
0.0392148606,
0.0879014954,
-0.0162572153,
0.0474644154,
-0.104996413,
0.0379836075,
0.0132379215,
-0.0248988178,
-0.0210476071,
0.1102562547,
0.0273652337,
-0.0552124046,
0.0452060215,
0.0335851684,
-0.0526895449,
0.0155846691,
0.0322962478,
-0.0169958249,
-0.0083306571,
0.0235219821,
0.0103919003,
-0.0223983396,
0.0063913087,
-0.0130361412,
-0.0016018857,
-0.0106468545,
0.0095586954,
0.0327490158,
-0.0034018469,
0.0403704196,
-0.0473837331,
-0.0601897761,
0.0393151119,
-0.0595709234,
0.0313514359,
0.024974633,
0.0261048283,
0.0599549487,
0.0520244911,
-0.0990957096,
0.055294767,
-0.0548275597,
0.0212408546,
0.0417559445,
-0.0422123559,
0.0240164381,
0.0593607835,
0.0071827024,
0.0352024361,
-0.0164819174,
0.0427508466,
-0.0280219056,
0.0291483849,
0.0087588429,
0.0982773006,
-0.0305617675,
-0.0793544799,
-0.0831475928,
0.0093726749,
-0.003117328,
0.0585685819,
-0.0226309095,
0.0052730916,
0.0546215847,
-0.0095666191,
0.0063785156,
-0.0894026905,
-0.0241820682,
-0.0218155608,
-0.0688914359,
-0.0316558108,
-0.0144006852,
0.0473449863,
0.0581351817,
-0.0089485552,
-0.0230065212,
0.0272379946,
-0.0274837278,
0.090823926,
0.0339576416,
0.0563578755,
-0.01928645,
-0.0137216393,
0.0188861638,
0.0323461443,
0.0232403483,
-0.0164985787,
0.0190975089,
0.0276247878,
-0.0218272116,
0.0116666183,
-0.0134018436,
0.0412664786,
-0.0470085703,
-0.0075751483,
0.0115557881,
0.0423429273,
0.0005282604,
0.0129743377,
0.0358045436,
-0.0465782657,
0.0653361753,
-0.0409484394,
-0.0583710521,
0.015015509,
0.0041810037,
0.0089186532,
-0.0344676003,
0.0234764814,
0.0312689841,
-0.0104558514,
-0.0246330798,
-0.0290723592,
2.668e-7,
0.0186055563,
0.0395403206,
0.0023925779,
0.0224989299,
0.0251251217,
0.0401811972,
-0.0199548677,
0.0453497693,
-0.0505374335,
-0.0814628154,
0.0264370106,
0.0164201837,
0.0696455091,
0.0231498629,
-0.0468959063,
0.0291132256,
-0.0152012315,
-0.0159042086,
-0.0824808106,
0.0627239048,
0.0757197738,
0.0368370265,
0.0265916642,
0.0052575385,
-0.0347755067,
-0.0259020161,
0.0351367146,
-0.047381606,
-0.0466117859,
-0.017421782,
-0.0043063085,
-0.0396880731,
-0.0230163392,
-0.0018013238,
-0.0205452554,
-0.0088710366,
-0.0043571144,
-0.013516522,
0.0473194756,
0.0003912002,
-0.0252849385,
-0.0481321104,
-0.0027674239,
-0.0872748718,
0.0880704746,
-0.0409280434,
-0.0754261762,
-0.0253009293,
0.0100100022,
-0.0023326864,
0.0712342039,
-0.0031711208,
-0.0801932365,
0.031216491,
0.0090419138,
-0.0288976356,
-0.0020273852,
-0.0476686843,
0.0354052149,
0.0077222995,
-0.0425102003,
0.0161063913,
0.0158614498,
0.0493904203,
0.0595174879,
0.0452792905,
0.036769364,
1.902591101e-34,
0.0134134702,
-0.0095048808,
-0.0182388015,
-0.0221524797,
0.029427534,
0.0020398747,
-0.072262764,
-0.0114338147,
-0.0104760239,
-0.0089037372,
-0.000899207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.01202v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.01202v1 | Predictive Patentomics: Forecasting Innovation Success and Valuation with ChatGPT | 2023-06-22T13:21:20 | 2023-06-22T13:21:20 | Stephen Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DL | Analysis of innovation has been fundamentally limited by conventional
approaches to broad, structural variables. This paper pushes the boundaries,
taking an LLM approach to patent analysis with the groundbreaking ChatGPT
technology. OpenAI's state-of-the-art textual embedding accesses complex
information about the quality and impact of each invention to power deep
learning predictive models. The nuanced embedding drives a 24% incremental
improvement in R-squared predicting patent value and clearly isolates the worst
and best applications. These models enable a revision of the contemporary
Kogan, Papanikolaou, Seru, and Stoffman (2017) valuation of patents by a median
deviation of 1.5 times, accounting for potential institutional predictions.
Furthermore, the market fails to incorporate timely information about
applications; a long-short portfolio based on predicted acceptance rates
achieves significant abnormal returns of 3.3% annually. The models provide an
opportunity to revolutionize startup and small-firm corporate policy vis-a-vis
patenting. | [
0.0113246869,
0.053922791,
-0.0201123133,
-0.0129812425,
-0.0209116004,
-0.0549085662,
0.0376260206,
0.0313200392,
0.0468583144,
-0.031662412,
0.0137674687,
0.0285249911,
-0.0071025728,
0.0883481354,
0.0123227276,
0.0294556711,
0.0195070878,
0.0248674657,
0.0106088538,
-0.0100145051,
0.0132661881,
0.0084066102,
0.004575015,
0.0610917099,
0.0128721604,
-0.0016033762,
0.0252932664,
-0.031209182,
-0.0040799463,
-0.0881209821,
-0.0214657895,
-0.0065384451,
0.0241882969,
0.0483480804,
0.0000019867,
-0.0692672804,
-0.0249199942,
0.0218592286,
0.0307745971,
0.0666386411,
0.0542432852,
0.0165211335,
0.0090156924,
0.0306467041,
-0.0360904001,
0.0198368188,
0.0114977183,
0.0683244541,
-0.03944299,
0.0219110083,
-0.0087835211,
-0.0203930456,
0.0935683399,
-0.0722134113,
0.0020225625,
-0.0795727819,
-0.0033027802,
0.0094972197,
-0.0060945582,
-0.0358269922,
-0.0099690827,
0.0468413942,
0.0102032861,
-0.0069898381,
0.0636313632,
0.05520574,
0.0231251847,
0.0269142892,
-0.0303904004,
0.055263456,
0.0414652117,
0.0137117142,
0.0021116175,
-0.0187647007,
0.0264246892,
0.0092784716,
-0.0298555624,
0.001088025,
0.0211056415,
0.0555191301,
0.0347036757,
-0.0091295894,
0.0206013657,
0.0202660579,
0.0316665284,
0.0480402298,
-0.0237545166,
-0.0207329504,
0.0161979292,
0.001216357,
0.003625806,
-0.0278571881,
-0.0048923185,
-0.0148440981,
0.0514546335,
0.0127763869,
-0.0137384208,
-0.0397063568,
-0.0039950726,
-0.0594939888,
0.0032639413,
-0.0066783568,
-0.0253252853,
0.0775994062,
-0.0986112952,
-0.0009923226,
-0.0414375365,
-0.0323589109,
-0.0003595967,
0.0012700099,
-0.0469861627,
0.0137580978,
-0.0015749694,
0.0772736222,
-0.004693917,
-0.0294526834,
-0.0684563443,
0.0084592551,
-0.0301403087,
0.0114636188,
0.0044059805,
0.0622914433,
0.0242360085,
-0.0188677441,
-0.0794557482,
-0.0080366526,
-0.0181723032,
0.0362356342,
-0.0318464749,
-0.0268089566,
0.0219153445,
0.0102742594,
0.0032343806,
0.0196678136,
0.0160363205,
0.0333504453,
0.0364466459,
-0.0360092297,
-0.00881116,
-0.0564171895,
0.0186340269,
0.0115151508,
0.0096205957,
-0.0198269803,
-0.0277589895,
-0.0435520895,
0.0141042536,
-0.0616654716,
-0.0061603589,
-0.0247279387,
-0.0210276507,
0.019020712,
0.0238756966,
-0.0449949913,
-0.0272146501,
0.0027795529,
-0.0184227787,
0.0021760697,
0.0234173462,
0.0130105484,
0.0583795384,
-0.0215283614,
0.0027357067,
0.0415374748,
0.0273918211,
-0.0468826443,
0.0219950415,
0.0079567647,
-0.0046564662,
0.0069362209,
-0.0223066919,
-0.0104270894,
-0.0018334199,
0.0240716264,
0.0593554229,
0.0781809092,
0.0441170894,
0.0457931571,
-0.0139896944,
0.000740148,
-0.0376777872,
-0.0858066007,
0.0338770747,
0.0149171157,
-0.0597801767,
-0.0080827801,
0.0138418917,
0.0179177411,
-0.0246870127,
-0.0431668051,
0.0281584822,
0.0006901143,
0.0004152052,
-0.045214016,
0.0420597754,
-0.0575503223,
-0.0296677258,
0.0303285457,
0.0163029786,
0.0232258812,
-0.0184845831,
-0.0673277006,
0.0389891043,
0.0139990086,
0.0259575285,
-0.0269732904,
0.0237864945,
-0.0043680319,
-0.0403613336,
0.0047214511,
0.0545610823,
0.0276446864,
-0.0497298762,
-0.0133326082,
0.0098067308,
-0.0260504391,
0.0146241011,
0.0163227562,
-0.0292603914,
0.0339981355,
-0.0140091097,
-0.0433136858,
0.0634180605,
0.0070793657,
-0.0445813537,
-0.0365811959,
0.0455532931,
-0.0243958626,
0.0100688525,
0.0406845175,
-0.007180965,
0.0189592168,
0.0326556675,
-0.0137471566,
-0.0499161482,
0.0057468629,
0.0434472114,
0.0097727338,
-0.032500945,
-0.0383456945,
0.0266689025,
-0.002857954,
-0.0160500128,
0.033272624,
0.0198570825,
0.0210142508,
0.0380941071,
-0.0286873076,
-0.0745390728,
-0.0006681453,
0.0499240011,
0.0125225056,
0.0250931475,
0.0008588662,
0.0239898581,
-0.0032522241,
-0.0457048863,
0.0214755163,
-0.009617337,
-0.0239811763,
-0.0234978758,
-0.0131205674,
0.0244263802,
0.0118876528,
-0.0558009669,
0.0157456156,
-0.0008629994,
-0.0978214443,
-0.0090657305,
0.0066576782,
-0.0045390837,
-0.0118999081,
-0.0116886571,
0.0177545659,
0.0224547554,
-0.0299207177,
-0.026770914,
0.0091507621,
-0.0285829976,
0.0468481407,
-0.0098160431,
-0.0506097525,
-0.0225720797,
-0.0359679013,
-0.0362339243,
0.0037886919,
0.0502837002,
0.0020298285,
-0.0219517443,
0.0154423853,
-0.0375408009,
0.0213683136,
-0.0264753792,
0.0370117836,
0.003576848,
-0.0002380122,
-0.0623190328,
0.0160235129,
-0.0330294818,
0.0864343718,
-0.004451918,
0.0138229206,
-0.0301721189,
0.0231003258,
0.0111775687,
0.0490106046,
0.0145894084,
0.0447145104,
-0.0096938126,
-0.002684609,
-0.0001311669,
-0.0185541268,
-0.0317900218,
-0.0053973729,
-0.0093553131,
0.0017503708,
-0.0177108366,
0.02290879,
0.015857039,
0.0727239251,
0.0082942666,
-0.0469274446,
0.0715996549,
-0.0188252218,
0.0031416407,
-0.0501967743,
-0.0267825499,
-0.0580714047,
0.0545479544,
-0.0494202822,
-0.0468495563,
-0.0023362127,
0.0071136705,
-0.0173239522,
0.0230714642,
-0.0362502597,
-0.0314589106,
0.0266080797,
-0.0131299412,
0.0212214682,
0.0022263429,
0.0092533911,
-0.0093883909,
-0.1007230282,
-0.0029722881,
0.0273397788,
0.0690167695,
-0.0083649484,
-0.0044226041,
-0.0373599194,
-0.0473878346,
-0.0102147125,
0.0146373464,
-0.0132257976,
0.000385879,
0.0448882766,
0.028547788,
-0.0456350669,
0.032675866,
0.0070180767,
0.0322657749,
0.0009682699,
-0.0261253975,
0.0127682546,
-0.0545366816,
0.0252215266,
-0.0322079584,
-0.0038979549,
-0.0145637402,
0.0289101768,
0.02407635,
-0.0210514888,
0.0325941592,
0.0562323071,
-0.0044749277,
0.052533742,
0.0319588631,
0.0666895956,
0.0233255383,
0.0118265739,
0.0001471621,
-0.1328433752,
0.0044048042,
-0.0525312014,
-0.0029429796,
-0.0070025986,
-0.0552217029,
-0.0201823413,
-0.1172368154,
0.0656991974,
-0.0140263811,
-0.0134233693,
-0.008780268,
-0.017335901,
-0.0039750594,
-0.0282028373,
-0.0194286574,
-0.0216572415,
0.0156484246,
-0.0105729671,
-0.0204739869,
-0.128009975,
0.0193926878,
0.0592511296,
-0.0288766772,
-0.0253649522,
0.064051494,
0.0134196868,
-0.0262042992,
-0.002804019,
0.006122468,
0.0216437522,
0.0219129957,
0.0277988929,
0.0449452847,
0.0100002335,
-0.0217358489,
-0.022890415,
0.0460141711,
-0.0445195548,
0.0231832881,
-0.006981669,
0.0590180829,
-0.0264191665,
-0.0315633528,
-0.0358668901,
-0.0102740033,
-0.0229725633,
0.0569514446,
-0.0123927137,
-0.0524676442,
-0.0364669561,
-0.0483363606,
-0.0017726282,
-0.04500762,
0.0169962365,
-0.048045937,
0.0082623186,
0.0048952582,
-0.0807635263,
-0.0342196152,
-0.0054798173,
-0.0112955663,
0.0173848346,
0.0178319216,
0.0184472799,
0.0145626338,
-0.0307536218,
0.0207051951,
0.0186367854,
-0.0088438317,
0.0007027433,
0.0530683771,
0.0324361436,
-0.0076177446,
-0.0503234006,
0.0171672013,
-0.0737370327,
-0.0581562743,
-0.0550088249,
0.0095079737,
0.0223964639,
-0.0185328815,
-0.0432712287,
0.0102162901,
0.0995936468,
0.0474325754,
0.0208009593,
-0.0345092565,
0.0385861397,
-0.0035294304,
-0.0079068309,
-0.0320122503,
0.0017832294,
0.01200129,
-0.0128646018,
-0.0259373356,
0.0395090282,
-0.0519323163,
-0.021659309,
-0.0032347746,
0.0950020999,
0.0328847505,
0.0289013628,
-0.0265003033,
-0.0119234324,
0.0468722656,
0.0280827433,
-0.045613233,
-0.021174321,
0.023269657,
-0.0363290943,
-0.0554076657,
0.0357488059,
0.0352372564,
0.0100285104,
-0.0843747556,
0.0316598304,
-0.0333168171,
0.0286890063,
0.0154643878,
0.0072667063,
-0.0054116542,
0.0138787609,
-0.0520258099,
0.0057657701,
-0.0140336007,
0.0230565798,
-0.0409181006,
0.0734693334,
0.0199104678,
0.0024474564,
-0.015412543,
-0.1025470421,
-0.0275373459,
0.0797387287,
0.0068323542,
0.0163304862,
0.0140243927,
-0.0478888266,
0.0021937436,
-0.0051259436,
0.0724218562,
-0.0487038605,
-0.0253593288,
0.0390915014,
-0.0018729648,
-0.0428468063,
-0.0152462674,
0.056400232,
0.0310081821,
0.0377310663,
-0.0498611964,
0.0041756318,
-0.03408603,
-0.0176937338,
0.0539782122,
0.0357266851,
-0.0008698681,
-0.0055688121,
-0.0427398197,
-0.0175427254,
0.0275675561,
-0.0292925481,
0.015312531,
0.0187508892,
-0.0235017855,
0.0484119244,
-0.0202703495,
-0.0078617809,
0.0178375393,
-0.0363063514,
-0.035311792,
-0.0762287378,
-0.0401495136,
-5.923730396e-33,
0.0163076892,
-0.0114869196,
0.0108235944,
0.011677566,
0.0092531079,
0.0100743314,
-0.0403510146,
0.0317902565,
-0.0175322443,
0.0117776301,
-0.0050303368,
0.0163290799,
0.0006069653,
0.0293755103,
0.0479363091,
-0.032351017,
0.017413931,
-0.0208108388,
0.015588644,
0.0096426327,
0.0012795149,
0.0372050256,
0.0325066559,
-0.0151832961,
0.0305302907,
0.0415996872,
-0.0163263921,
-0.0586357526,
-0.0039414954,
0.0631793588,
-0.0229757093,
0.0389083438,
0.0277773477,
-0.0881395191,
0.009827151,
-0.0215340909,
0.0015183681,
0.0228144713,
-0.0387068652,
-0.0437551662,
-0.0238803737,
0.021704644,
0.0450231098,
0.0414642543,
-0.0323264375,
-0.0067619001,
0.059657529,
0.0057774181,
-0.0132139241,
-0.0333631709,
-0.0272634942,
-0.002230159,
-0.0248028766,
0.0120913861,
0.0383515731,
-0.0099043613,
-0.0047366642,
0.0706316382,
-0.0557409562,
0.0058819032,
-0.0683969334,
0.0023237644,
-0.0004759485,
-0.0464070812,
0.0083193136,
0.0660726205,
-0.0040569571,
0.0228525586,
-0.0206282325,
-0.0232550967,
0.0404164903,
0.0942105129,
0.0415591784,
-0.025107637,
0.0547135472,
-0.0133362496,
-0.0762002394,
0.0248160623,
0.0307239536,
-0.0215350408,
0.0224460196,
0.0174977537,
-0.0094169676,
-0.0276776534,
0.0494465791,
-0.0593602546,
0.0073328372,
0.0191352628,
0.0099564297,
-0.0062251333,
0.0158753041,
0.0742703006,
0.0579157919,
-0.081577599,
-0.0362610444,
-0.0138463592,
-0.014995601,
0.0936775878,
-0.0117697446,
-0.0327554159,
-0.0892167613,
-0.0304684043,
-0.0324154533,
0.0090197232,
0.0287679881,
-0.0170976911,
0.0025705602,
-0.0381250903,
-0.0243383143,
-0.0147072393,
-0.0223112982,
-0.0155182211,
0.0654024258,
0.0081814462,
0.0242584907,
0.0125621418,
0.0272182152,
0.0408843458,
0.0027127324,
0.0188046284,
-0.038104184,
-0.0369031243,
0.0111541692,
-0.0612339303,
-0.0281889327,
-0.012259841,
0.0232064314,
0.0379146449,
0.0236552432,
-0.0553623028,
-0.0286980066,
0.0082210479,
2.668e-7,
0.0518670157,
0.04719669,
-0.0083948355,
0.0328835323,
0.0159483589,
0.0526152849,
0.0085120844,
0.0597209223,
0.0016539375,
-0.0377762765,
0.0503263883,
-0.028110018,
0.0324707478,
-0.0066765952,
-0.0648626909,
-0.0876945183,
-0.0715858415,
0.0448935591,
-0.0661884919,
-0.0109790834,
0.075069882,
0.0596140139,
0.0342754684,
-0.0129140206,
0.017586017,
-0.0051529924,
0.0713966489,
-0.0344474055,
0.0351310857,
0.0130182495,
0.0508355349,
0.0031543074,
-0.0688885599,
0.0275306776,
-0.0369802415,
0.0458026528,
0.0107548246,
-0.0177829806,
0.040719483,
0.0134557821,
0.0112472149,
-0.0234266613,
-0.012280032,
-0.0387419164,
0.0392246507,
0.0117327794,
-0.0401179343,
-0.0370539799,
-0.0008941459,
0.024930425,
0.0346546657,
0.0285639782,
0.0416124314,
-0.0086957142,
-0.0163662992,
-0.0235741977,
-0.0220531765,
-0.0569832921,
-0.0060828095,
0.0049437867,
-0.058144372,
0.0207101908,
-0.0041781878,
0.0141909728,
0.0566303506,
-0.0241594017,
0.0482050516,
2.452612025e-34,
0.0585410185,
-0.0532760546,
0.0213111099,
0.0220990628,
0.0472052284,
-0.0051103435,
0.0718557164,
0.0014279423,
-0.0181667488,
-0.0717256069,
-0.0228854921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12834v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12834v1 | Natural Language Processing in Electronic Health Records in Relation to Healthcare Decision-making: A Systematic Review | 2023-06-22T12:10:41 | 2023-06-22T12:10:41 | Elias Hossain, Rajib Rana, Niall Higgins, Jeffrey Soar, Prabal Datta Barua, Anthony R. Pisani, Ph. D, Kathryn Turner} | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Background: Natural Language Processing (NLP) is widely used to extract
clinical insights from Electronic Health Records (EHRs). However, the lack of
annotated data, automated tools, and other challenges hinder the full
utilisation of NLP for EHRs. Various Machine Learning (ML), Deep Learning (DL)
and NLP techniques are studied and compared to understand the limitations and
opportunities in this space comprehensively.
Methodology: After screening 261 articles from 11 databases, we included 127
papers for full-text review covering seven categories of articles: 1) medical
note classification, 2) clinical entity recognition, 3) text summarisation, 4)
deep learning (DL) and transfer learning architecture, 5) information
extraction, 6) Medical language translation and 7) other NLP applications. This
study follows the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and
Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines.
Result and Discussion: EHR was the most commonly used data type among the
selected articles, and the datasets were primarily unstructured. Various ML and
DL methods were used, with prediction or classification being the most common
application of ML or DL. The most common use cases were: the International
Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision (ICD-9) classification, clinical
note analysis, and named entity recognition (NER) for clinical descriptions and
research on psychiatric disorders.
Conclusion: We find that the adopted ML models were not adequately assessed.
In addition, the data imbalance problem is quite important, yet we must find
techniques to address this underlining problem. Future studies should address
key limitations in studies, primarily identifying Lupus Nephritis, Suicide
Attempts, perinatal self-harmed and ICD-9 classification. | [
0.0456698872,
0.0238366779,
0.0130279865,
-0.0280890707,
-0.0042498717,
0.0505958609,
0.020824939,
-0.0037501287,
0.0457841493,
-0.0332906134,
0.016430933,
-0.0309108198,
0.0123740565,
0.0570988506,
-0.0220940039,
-0.0442840718,
0.0042634476,
0.0274294037,
0.0452168621,
0.0465304777,
-0.0503108241,
0.0020390013,
-0.0133218542,
0.0512677506,
0.0386750363,
0.0261680484,
0.0202717632,
-0.0177992415,
0.0190453455,
-0.0946924537,
-0.0214664824,
0.0174713768,
-0.0234605893,
0.0001161633,
0.0000021171,
-0.0562556721,
-0.0332224071,
0.0280375406,
-0.0373607837,
-0.0767455027,
0.0300065279,
-0.0894805491,
-0.0040635234,
0.0166723114,
-0.018151423,
-0.060248822,
0.042853266,
0.0844428316,
0.0027079356,
0.0642397553,
-0.0398385562,
-0.0055766366,
0.0476278923,
0.0101306429,
0.0083236294,
-0.0082491273,
0.0666523352,
0.0025010202,
0.0025086072,
-0.0495588407,
0.0318638794,
0.0346491151,
-0.0299567562,
0.0386719704,
-0.0049137664,
0.0443111248,
-0.0421619937,
-0.0304410588,
-0.0070214858,
0.0561819561,
0.0029433751,
0.0435648896,
0.0343619511,
-0.0333479904,
-0.0283149611,
-0.0390658528,
-0.011448388,
0.019008508,
-0.0277941972,
0.0047607063,
0.0264287684,
0.0138001414,
0.0139724119,
-0.0186411329,
-0.0273426455,
-0.0125246532,
-0.0045241849,
-0.0214105397,
0.0653028116,
-0.0044588218,
0.0286529996,
-0.0465878844,
0.0314269029,
0.0165360477,
-0.013985076,
0.0157020129,
-0.0253932588,
-0.045022428,
0.0898898244,
-0.0626010299,
0.0212487262,
-0.0073475507,
0.0120584099,
0.0163190924,
-0.0149676315,
-0.0100405524,
0.0143887065,
0.0318256654,
-0.0217120517,
0.011211101,
-0.042551294,
-0.0078111291,
-0.0001774804,
0.027039675,
0.0031583994,
-0.00045951,
-0.0976077318,
-0.0164816696,
0.0009218806,
-0.0024693043,
0.0103325807,
0.0413629301,
-0.0141358674,
0.029806355,
-0.0244084168,
0.0285203848,
0.0323748291,
0.0052440977,
-0.0124184182,
-0.0414072648,
0.0613119416,
-0.0011191856,
0.0389045253,
0.0019761894,
0.0501477234,
0.0528903902,
0.0415817723,
-0.0583422109,
-0.0508737192,
-0.0032993658,
-0.018719146,
0.0097206552,
0.0225102417,
-0.0473114699,
0.0073797596,
-0.0187997818,
-0.0133079169,
-0.0548560508,
0.0149358204,
0.0046197805,
-0.0651400089,
0.0452627055,
-0.0988751799,
-0.0115763051,
0.0560201108,
-0.0092202956,
0.0114553962,
-0.0026277774,
0.0305510312,
-0.0124028735,
0.0057922057,
-0.0302907974,
0.0078591751,
-0.010430865,
-0.0096305739,
-0.0850655213,
0.0181629993,
-0.0104993805,
-0.0703593045,
0.0365616605,
-0.0384248644,
0.0545553491,
0.0219025798,
0.015374505,
0.0108905556,
0.078261286,
0.0390617698,
0.0293198042,
-0.0122268116,
-0.0027794016,
-0.0201437883,
-0.0314392298,
0.0055545396,
0.0024731723,
0.0302717537,
0.0071047358,
0.0005419333,
-0.0071052215,
-0.0135232052,
-0.0546250306,
-0.0435902178,
-0.0216226503,
-0.0042943596,
-0.017688347,
0.0389652178,
-0.0148078026,
-0.0264018793,
0.0352887958,
0.0347493142,
0.0310274269,
-0.031706024,
-0.0319869407,
-0.042487368,
0.0667735189,
-0.0116700707,
-0.0408966914,
-0.039122656,
-0.0541721396,
-0.0275262091,
0.0115866745,
0.002224494,
0.013237834,
0.0276597627,
-0.0274182726,
-0.0128295394,
0.0238869153,
0.0024840117,
-0.0305135753,
-0.0515082441,
0.0316036753,
-0.0196389463,
0.0022971837,
-0.0611725785,
0.0603339411,
-0.037921492,
-0.0562746562,
0.0365655161,
0.0036529438,
0.0464895368,
0.0191345606,
-0.002920859,
0.0283088442,
0.0135066183,
-0.0247925092,
-0.0685435981,
-0.0111409025,
-0.0040085963,
-0.0139113627,
-0.011715401,
-0.0555753261,
0.0027843723,
-0.0245014001,
-0.0311328731,
-0.0378064215,
-0.0198265072,
-0.0304049402,
-0.0068538953,
-0.0034309814,
0.003483667,
0.0338576995,
0.0059694219,
-0.0430503748,
0.017869819,
-0.0173252188,
-0.0006182239,
0.0085575506,
-0.0981284082,
0.0158079751,
0.0082113324,
-0.0199304577,
0.0159857832,
-0.0408816002,
0.0123575618,
-0.0070669916,
0.0207127593,
-0.0086609833,
-0.0007149664,
-0.1092787459,
0.0358946361,
0.0077836276,
0.0356653556,
0.0161837414,
0.031898316,
-0.0133661143,
-0.0352191366,
-0.0291293096,
-0.0310528148,
0.0349861905,
0.0224562008,
0.0451047979,
0.0692081675,
0.0377258584,
-0.0237121899,
-0.0217356887,
-0.0552232973,
0.038240727,
0.0210025311,
-0.0543470047,
0.0021737416,
0.0096423216,
-0.0219400749,
0.0092984019,
0.0084310845,
0.0330505297,
-0.0081627676,
0.0067063719,
-0.0089950003,
0.0434115008,
-0.0110789444,
0.0339933559,
0.0336419418,
0.009623412,
-0.0011275723,
0.0289242361,
-0.044486355,
0.0255518928,
-0.0108328536,
-0.040453434,
0.0509978831,
0.0494036935,
0.0295324605,
-0.0053212731,
-0.0050437287,
-0.0230393726,
-0.0226038229,
0.0251855012,
-0.0511528924,
0.008363096,
-0.0278011691,
0.0272568204,
0.004202405,
-0.0361094065,
0.0670515746,
0.0113545302,
0.0481192768,
-0.0898912027,
-0.0380030163,
-0.0558806136,
0.0030359672,
0.0033366946,
0.0122067174,
0.0047504911,
-0.0530754589,
0.0526087731,
-0.007288835,
-0.0152195618,
-0.0236088447,
0.0452461429,
-0.0063523487,
0.0259069651,
-0.0165454969,
-0.0031378001,
-0.0307835154,
-0.0022593422,
-0.042631872,
0.0261881482,
-0.0170309898,
0.0195788722,
-0.0328107215,
0.0189546403,
-0.0175366551,
0.0899978131,
0.0120571619,
-0.0253832676,
-0.0039046679,
0.0002089933,
0.0628101155,
-0.0299231298,
0.0481321514,
0.0208436623,
0.0203267168,
0.0366936587,
-0.0355079919,
0.0478747599,
-0.0055365236,
0.0069182445,
-0.0267272107,
-0.0869908407,
-0.0144362459,
0.0335488468,
-0.0114660757,
-0.0626781434,
0.0341274068,
0.093075119,
0.0129334005,
-0.0665545762,
0.0035720058,
-0.0061340383,
-0.0708663911,
-0.0217238124,
-0.0111069018,
-0.030591635,
-0.0425745063,
-0.0324552581,
0.0309895296,
-0.0368458889,
-0.0571002997,
0.0225551687,
-0.0024830974,
0.0054633263,
-0.0427516848,
-0.0543387644,
-0.0395634584,
-0.0583626293,
-0.0021896386,
-0.0148005905,
0.0060479576,
-0.0782156289,
-0.0443353541,
-0.017779408,
0.0270377342,
-0.1203913316,
-0.0703406781,
0.0221763272,
-0.0294268131,
0.0426258445,
0.0299878772,
0.0531992614,
-0.0338593721,
-0.0019627342,
0.0108502358,
0.0002493635,
-0.000095259,
0.004682479,
0.1035897359,
0.0069641815,
0.0118242949,
-0.0522446632,
0.0316158272,
-0.0557999276,
-0.0050034015,
-0.0022981463,
0.0787458196,
-0.0444242954,
-0.0471013747,
-0.0437494107,
-0.0021552132,
0.0225375053,
0.036831338,
-0.028661862,
0.0054973853,
-0.0401651673,
0.0312673226,
0.0360444076,
-0.0034824088,
-0.0105091445,
0.0558753535,
-0.0497233458,
-0.0504751801,
-0.0447590873,
-0.0532848164,
0.0550292395,
-0.0385796167,
0.0342983976,
0.0391509868,
0.0889492705,
0.0020168128,
-0.0605220646,
0.0426176675,
0.0424004123,
0.0017193808,
-0.0238049384,
0.0004769923,
0.0369508713,
0.0326284692,
-0.0081304368,
-0.0216221772,
-0.0127312141,
0.0096924296,
0.0039257566,
0.0218142234,
0.0052257422,
-0.0155663267,
0.0138593866,
-0.0220169164,
0.0225936789,
0.0213993676,
0.0143978167,
-0.0841298848,
-0.0147837969,
0.0129853301,
-0.0178444777,
-0.0003906521,
-0.0045443447,
0.0200809967,
0.0084455404,
-0.0196097698,
0.0135828964,
-0.0167123768,
0.005573784,
0.0400745869,
0.0338350646,
-0.0144252358,
-0.0515618101,
-0.0328351893,
0.0152548822,
0.0281248614,
0.0357232504,
-0.0308148041,
-0.014494257,
0.0082693491,
0.0084059816,
-0.0313240588,
0.0279729869,
-0.0430334657,
-0.0629956648,
-0.048078198,
0.0831364021,
0.0295458548,
0.0632201731,
0.0056329682,
-0.0205453876,
-0.0049728556,
0.0349587128,
0.0105483569,
0.0153059084,
-0.0111809392,
-0.0003504257,
-0.0183024276,
0.0300501492,
-0.0030896266,
0.0539930575,
-0.0395676419,
-0.0288574006,
-0.0231561884,
-0.0229357965,
0.0466461591,
-0.0210497007,
0.022219073,
-0.0153373219,
0.0136700952,
-0.0274273474,
0.0244012829,
-0.0228015073,
0.016534023,
0.0154944509,
-0.0069597419,
-0.0433244519,
-0.0230820198,
0.0572634116,
0.03045859,
0.0262411237,
0.0275204983,
-0.0471263938,
-0.0286333375,
-0.0075229043,
0.0362918675,
-0.0027496009,
-0.0577383526,
-0.0336290263,
-0.0231678169,
-0.0271953698,
0.0578678474,
-0.0310929678,
-0.0027507723,
-0.0098381154,
0.0285737384,
0.0219550021,
0.0248689856,
-0.0049516642,
-0.0259745922,
0.024870608,
-0.0214316025,
-0.0046764528,
-0.0135288956,
-5.518203212e-33,
0.025131451,
-0.0245646741,
0.0275379512,
-0.0127847735,
0.0122075053,
0.0298204105,
-0.0300471969,
0.0004913234,
0.0291262064,
0.0093337661,
-0.0149974739,
-0.0062364941,
0.0263575483,
0.0585241392,
0.0394478738,
-0.0348043852,
0.0268491469,
0.0165949669,
0.0074242032,
0.019010948,
-0.0194876567,
0.0698164925,
0.09271238,
-0.0705513209,
0.0470523238,
0.0597232543,
0.0322338454,
-0.025705345,
0.0352919288,
0.0400268659,
-0.0540645644,
0.0280323587,
0.0556419007,
-0.0307311974,
-0.0229189396,
0.0179323032,
-0.0777200013,
-0.0319237709,
-0.03375962,
-0.0167088937,
-0.0060828277,
-0.0090342285,
0.0806297809,
-0.0052320338,
-0.0034269483,
0.007839391,
0.0503304042,
-0.036165785,
-0.0089844158,
-0.0992844105,
-0.0315366238,
0.0562771,
-0.0178854521,
0.0513404272,
0.0008662723,
0.0161589105,
-0.0588940233,
0.0238403492,
-0.0812275708,
-0.0254745949,
0.0193084925,
-0.01373035,
-0.0019473566,
-0.0497748964,
-0.0300446041,
0.0634641573,
-0.0172794741,
-0.0046496685,
-0.0429166146,
0.0193323195,
-0.0102357147,
0.0529299565,
0.0262508597,
-0.0008899636,
0.0565665402,
-0.0257886723,
-0.0924891755,
0.0637654811,
-0.0675307214,
0.0319251418,
0.031771414,
-0.0335179456,
-0.0430391021,
0.0089006294,
-0.0136366179,
0.0039771846,
0.0015587814,
-0.0087941866,
0.0201486442,
-0.0001905826,
-0.0040078438,
0.0210955795,
0.0027590678,
-0.0436022282,
-0.0160606652,
-0.0346610993,
0.0602908395,
0.0164297111,
-0.0190182496,
-0.0239035189,
-0.0529436134,
-0.0340836197,
0.0018146983,
-0.0047625401,
0.0685490593,
-0.0075905668,
0.0384644531,
-0.040497072,
-0.044075802,
-0.0019230586,
0.0560097769,
0.017722493,
-0.0002991919,
0.1052850783,
-0.0108572589,
-0.0021544024,
0.0159976576,
0.0568629168,
0.0012437361,
0.0089461133,
-0.0352666602,
-0.0267303027,
0.0173720717,
-0.0044349697,
-0.0247577727,
-0.0148754846,
-0.0513816699,
0.0610993877,
0.0380198397,
-0.047872629,
0.0201310366,
-0.0076897298,
2.814e-7,
0.0861361995,
0.0479148962,
0.0218553692,
-0.0567724966,
0.0103563396,
0.0236932635,
0.037017528,
0.034587577,
0.0270306803,
0.0334281437,
0.0498091765,
0.0055073225,
0.0107011413,
0.0508907773,
-0.0633531883,
-0.0362968482,
-0.0504316129,
-0.0066194539,
-0.0469984114,
-0.0072307978,
0.061050877,
0.0868408009,
-0.0484382585,
-0.0453531519,
0.0086273272,
0.0324740298,
-0.0160880052,
-0.0386253148,
0.0334990099,
0.0370104462,
0.0471274741,
0.0205326881,
0.0156039316,
0.0352970473,
-0.0136113437,
-0.0020982362,
-0.0226716269,
0.063548997,
-0.0558826961,
0.016463425,
0.0331936441,
-0.0035389308,
0.0456664637,
0.0105110938,
0.0696737021,
-0.0538220443,
-0.0569863804,
-0.0265105795,
-0.0111109093,
-0.0022012026,
0.0943845958,
-0.0025918782,
0.0028116743,
0.0293148514,
0.0314250626,
-0.0103746839,
-0.0192948729,
-0.058849372,
0.0194091424,
0.0396031626,
0.0039247852,
0.0338280201,
0.028728297,
-0.0178929288,
0.0283898357,
-0.056843143,
0.0358994864,
2.517136563e-34,
-0.0068006427,
0.0226503313,
-0.0041058306,
-0.0086321756,
0.0031735292,
0.0099970037,
0.0012344166,
0.0134750269,
-0.0395247974,
-0.0722731948,
0.0033031041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12794v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12794v3 | Overview of Robust and Multilingual Automatic Evaluation Metrics for Open-Domain Dialogue Systems at DSTC 11 Track 4 | 2023-06-22T10:50:23 | 2023-09-14T01:33:36 | Mario Rodríguez-Cantelar, Chen Zhang, Chengguang Tang, Ke Shi, Sarik Ghazarian, João Sedoc, Luis Fernando D'Haro, Alexander Rudnicky | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advent and fast development of neural networks have revolutionized the
research on dialogue systems and subsequently have triggered various challenges
regarding their automatic evaluation. Automatic evaluation of open-domain
dialogue systems as an open challenge has been the center of the attention of
many researchers. Despite the consistent efforts to improve automatic metrics'
correlations with human evaluation, there have been very few attempts to assess
their robustness over multiple domains and dimensions. Also, their focus is
mainly on the English language. All of these challenges prompt the development
of automatic evaluation metrics that are reliable in various domains,
dimensions, and languages. This track in the 11th Dialogue System Technology
Challenge (DSTC11) is part of the ongoing effort to promote robust and
multilingual automatic evaluation metrics. This article describes the datasets
and baselines provided to participants and discusses the submission and result
details of the two proposed subtasks. | [
0.0045045963,
0.0308716558,
-0.0075834123,
0.0531682037,
-0.0255019367,
-0.0001981832,
0.0127240699,
-0.0130662154,
0.00415084,
-0.0250489209,
-0.086839661,
-0.0688764825,
0.0198201556,
0.0587805547,
-0.0021815964,
-0.0628219098,
0.0438910685,
-0.0283900425,
-0.009867602,
0.010042455,
-0.0090697538,
-0.0099280775,
-0.0621720031,
0.0651857182,
0.0070629711,
-0.0258358121,
-0.0072929868,
-0.0156816319,
0.02614462,
-0.0188194979,
-0.0073800716,
0.0479746349,
-0.0325847231,
0.0649963468,
0.0000015569,
-0.0618436895,
0.0360245928,
-0.0133712059,
-0.0351495408,
-0.0052545583,
0.0288093574,
0.0236064084,
-0.0203011949,
0.0257835612,
-0.0587844066,
-0.0308456328,
0.0466941856,
0.0111864405,
0.0779847503,
0.0498927943,
0.0119363209,
-0.0180518478,
0.0221221894,
-0.0017363579,
-0.0696898624,
-0.0754730478,
-0.0278856196,
0.0173796769,
-0.0089562535,
-0.0236181952,
0.0128854914,
0.0076234275,
0.0339773558,
-0.0716605186,
-0.0340516269,
-0.0092147421,
-0.0493060574,
-0.0214513522,
-0.0312613398,
0.0991642997,
0.057353653,
0.0616728328,
-0.0341909602,
-0.0092473635,
0.0010181293,
-0.044591289,
-0.0341872387,
-0.0159046855,
0.0156636424,
-0.0223892238,
-0.0484207496,
0.0569813699,
-0.0073188357,
0.0204638299,
0.0280442387,
0.0849141702,
0.0056786663,
-0.0198008306,
0.0161345713,
-0.0117953131,
-0.0083188331,
-0.0272059143,
0.0170710348,
0.0322311781,
-0.0653647035,
0.0131832873,
-0.0200200137,
-0.0330775231,
0.0228179507,
-0.0751071572,
0.0515064485,
0.0242539216,
-0.0412121527,
0.0437269807,
0.0156631749,
0.1144481227,
-0.0006533276,
0.0000959948,
-0.010801984,
0.0046965894,
-0.0511891693,
0.0192297567,
-0.0293122008,
0.014679525,
-0.0594118387,
-0.004611088,
-0.0545471087,
0.0267937295,
-0.0303054843,
0.0048592123,
0.0327172577,
0.0200227704,
-0.0059796437,
0.0034413887,
-0.0647167638,
0.0456323363,
-0.052442722,
-0.0027599467,
0.0204769205,
-0.0569307208,
0.0057850322,
0.0361041315,
-0.0183934998,
-0.0145141985,
-0.0277676061,
0.101748392,
0.003939773,
-0.0238387454,
-0.0168772582,
-0.0138117811,
-0.0508695804,
-0.072248593,
-0.03034674,
-0.0248854682,
0.0314298309,
-0.0098923855,
-0.0123154512,
-0.0272461101,
-0.0017719009,
0.0097264778,
0.0368225314,
0.0322314315,
-0.0033549976,
-0.0095371036,
0.0397807285,
0.0010022535,
-0.0047428007,
0.0573385321,
0.0347463191,
0.012252368,
0.0727570355,
-0.0057003647,
0.010791407,
0.0365678594,
-0.0183711145,
-0.0115336347,
0.0156738162,
0.0361753441,
-0.0154659292,
0.0515226312,
-0.0092946915,
0.0735773072,
-0.0321411118,
-0.0202745106,
0.0605186522,
0.0438395366,
0.0057136281,
-0.0004020831,
0.0670941472,
-0.0186817218,
0.0318132862,
0.0103508374,
-0.0022312226,
0.0276566055,
0.0003780955,
-0.0105456542,
0.032793954,
0.017410282,
-0.0288344994,
-0.0954656526,
-0.0049989587,
0.0007302133,
0.0231126249,
-0.0081537152,
0.0383061618,
0.0010700815,
-0.0373520628,
0.0103721814,
-0.0280108247,
-0.0602468774,
0.0101429895,
-0.0506758019,
-0.0237465166,
0.0343688205,
0.044796817,
-0.010275905,
-0.0436206982,
-0.0282207504,
0.0025606432,
0.0528196767,
0.0699411854,
-0.045266293,
0.0649554804,
-0.0455467962,
-0.0104497196,
0.0016031133,
-0.0082154004,
0.0346981063,
-0.0115286168,
0.0165392458,
0.0021149565,
-0.0063791298,
-0.0065341531,
-0.0017010394,
0.0016946837,
-0.0281712301,
0.0373441204,
0.0089264251,
0.0574100167,
0.0687890202,
-0.0227382965,
0.0043714345,
0.0202981178,
0.0066068126,
-0.0137349442,
0.0254908893,
-0.0393981934,
-0.0102669122,
0.039034903,
0.0010087003,
-0.0137999225,
0.0441018417,
-0.0185452234,
-0.0521902107,
0.0485746637,
-0.0541146845,
-0.0111725833,
-0.0690970868,
0.0292667989,
-0.0110601978,
0.0078227324,
-0.0257586576,
0.0282885283,
0.0014473238,
0.0401980989,
0.0397131741,
0.0049879821,
0.0801048577,
-0.0621104613,
-0.0411479548,
0.0222009532,
-0.0387648866,
0.0315865129,
0.0119618541,
0.0109022018,
-0.0557693429,
-0.0163355824,
-0.0818884373,
0.0050446251,
-0.0332118347,
0.0394278392,
0.0171086751,
-0.0045757866,
0.0065007671,
-0.0162725896,
-0.0430226102,
-0.0170899034,
0.0662379861,
0.005586498,
0.0388497896,
0.0379516184,
-0.0122705195,
-0.0154138925,
-0.0114679076,
0.0058585522,
0.0395659246,
-0.0171212144,
0.0267470349,
-0.0329356752,
0.0120734144,
-0.0527414642,
0.0187867135,
0.0078273192,
-0.0767146349,
0.0378959216,
0.046482753,
-0.0069211181,
0.0570022389,
0.018786246,
0.0225160141,
0.008798725,
-0.0262707733,
-0.0202451628,
0.0236987844,
-0.0216109771,
-0.0096435472,
-0.0182383377,
0.0286758449,
0.0070234062,
0.0066369125,
0.0215181224,
0.0153278187,
-0.0334679484,
0.0010765125,
-0.0353213362,
-0.0606520623,
-0.0411718227,
-0.0104083316,
-0.0423650965,
0.0551119745,
-0.0057825493,
-0.029188145,
0.0929728374,
-0.0414953902,
-0.0301555544,
-0.0622196235,
-0.0092343353,
-0.0467649773,
0.0502009206,
-0.0535259247,
0.0150850648,
0.0093948329,
-0.0459740795,
-0.0374299362,
-0.0205227844,
0.0296819843,
-0.0483041406,
0.0449902788,
-0.0399547219,
-0.0302779656,
0.0039769006,
-0.0498924665,
-0.046843186,
0.0083188694,
-0.0110932346,
0.0339132622,
0.0153174596,
-0.026046576,
-0.009757679,
0.0335780457,
0.0100731133,
0.0170989893,
-0.0211238191,
0.0147150178,
0.0063697109,
0.0610977411,
0.0114637762,
0.0498520881,
0.012175058,
0.0149508417,
0.0755280182,
0.0127500603,
0.0105908085,
0.0020706744,
-0.0217870288,
0.003271173,
0.0182573069,
-0.0252444297,
0.0038073992,
0.018031301,
0.0563954301,
-0.030485725,
-0.0141570568,
0.1063006744,
0.0234653,
-0.0129624577,
-0.0246049184,
-0.0317321345,
0.0043198927,
0.0255066156,
0.0093287071,
-0.0630692318,
-0.0126619255,
-0.0139169227,
0.0468163528,
-0.0118875457,
-0.0279908609,
0.0101328343,
-0.1092478633,
0.0017050849,
-0.0167531781,
-0.0760345384,
-0.0337693095,
-0.0181947649,
-0.0024525549,
-0.0429293662,
0.0607078634,
-0.0025151884,
0.0497548655,
-0.0256368481,
0.0052991002,
-0.0180461723,
-0.0387632251,
0.0538285933,
-0.0138512263,
0.0614539348,
0.0974955186,
0.0439098999,
0.0169472899,
-0.0490102507,
0.0185203776,
-0.0374322981,
0.0003189339,
0.0211193245,
0.035621848,
0.002986046,
-0.0161711946,
-0.0336314887,
-0.0230728835,
-0.004737081,
-0.0000720621,
0.008085439,
0.0434429199,
-0.0255748071,
0.0466240123,
-0.0172342621,
0.0402155034,
0.0225874968,
0.0540517233,
0.0325936824,
-0.0442503318,
-0.0141276848,
-0.0098125972,
-0.0109938793,
-0.0709552392,
-0.0077757039,
0.0102515053,
0.0143168801,
-0.0070602796,
-0.0891949162,
-0.0705594867,
0.0006429174,
0.031036891,
-0.0094338339,
-0.0280907266,
-0.0346786976,
0.0583283827,
-0.0011934231,
0.0228661876,
0.0193736516,
0.0294065513,
-0.0903001353,
0.0353448614,
0.0501387864,
0.0029622153,
-0.0139140449,
0.0681429431,
-0.0312489215,
-0.0477711186,
-0.0067810449,
0.059283074,
0.0242443848,
-0.0137998546,
-0.0312360078,
-0.0573526807,
-0.0100115221,
-0.0125933597,
-0.0138441911,
-0.0193911027,
0.0600479282,
0.0312099494,
-0.0427061245,
0.0332918502,
-0.0230108202,
0.0154070556,
-0.0157203823,
0.0278684311,
-0.0034225839,
-0.084256798,
-0.0094693452,
0.0124478554,
0.0503015332,
0.0016439599,
-0.0541363694,
0.0069089006,
0.0256346036,
-0.0242127888,
-0.0223186724,
-0.052343782,
0.0051246979,
-0.0014862671,
0.0083971741,
-0.0137269469,
0.0023044522,
-0.0440407805,
0.031753879,
-0.0160988495,
0.0148489736,
0.0674743056,
0.0224338975,
-0.0465812795,
0.0204744786,
-0.0358894281,
0.0129043721,
0.0052437671,
0.0251808465,
0.0104603404,
0.1026660725,
-0.0035576397,
0.0026170057,
0.0652581751,
0.0685428083,
-0.0609613732,
0.0288366675,
-0.0285963509,
0.0159326904,
0.0381965674,
0.055710502,
0.0476574153,
0.0071903374,
0.0089712115,
-0.0236164369,
0.0366472825,
-0.0093468539,
-0.0132053401,
0.024566723,
0.035596434,
0.0002236786,
0.0114981728,
0.0365294218,
-0.0381746627,
-0.0090795681,
0.0079160035,
-0.0003939956,
-0.0387202688,
-0.0377079695,
-0.0228649452,
0.0152250174,
-0.0138266748,
-0.0219383575,
-0.056803409,
-0.0594825745,
0.0226138514,
0.0629171282,
0.0273617655,
0.0108542936,
0.0471335016,
0.0546541028,
-0.0216457937,
0.001545569,
-0.0324655809,
-0.0205513183,
-0.0327258408,
-0.002470274,
-0.0268607475,
-4.927696931e-33,
-0.0320309587,
-0.0330692679,
-0.0049762791,
-0.0062624868,
-0.0445343517,
-0.0267867092,
-0.0227640625,
0.0366831049,
-0.0377285518,
0.0175783355,
-0.0101859039,
0.0009380672,
0.0180180725,
0.0051262886,
-0.0152406022,
-0.047513023,
0.0056987056,
-0.0171665326,
-0.0314542465,
0.0130541548,
0.0228392109,
-0.0151197249,
0.0543320887,
-0.081315957,
0.0791730806,
0.0363708101,
-0.0175550357,
0.0339792334,
0.0335768238,
0.0743026063,
-0.0040819682,
0.0822811276,
0.0200379062,
-0.0641828626,
0.0025292083,
0.0019261546,
-0.0341059603,
-0.0274061766,
0.015699964,
0.0277314838,
-0.0111684874,
0.0044925157,
-0.0126501769,
-0.0180153456,
-0.055342041,
0.0087770112,
-0.0097746076,
-0.0171980225,
0.0049677482,
-0.0143493637,
-0.0299320072,
0.0405975766,
-0.0275410339,
-0.0573103763,
-0.0196366459,
0.070259206,
-0.0076856227,
-0.0453105755,
-0.0214084778,
0.0333971344,
-0.0285450704,
-0.0035792175,
0.0540199019,
0.0083786612,
-0.0236635357,
0.0399933681,
0.0327190496,
0.0250860658,
0.0101580694,
-0.0421576649,
0.0101935361,
0.0149753867,
0.0952623785,
0.0817106888,
-0.0256383438,
0.0351688974,
-0.0449968465,
0.0437810645,
0.0190530661,
0.0299701337,
-0.0242187195,
-0.0170524921,
-0.0227768682,
0.0055873566,
-0.0404000096,
-0.020241553,
-0.0467662327,
-0.0473075248,
0.0467047133,
-0.0450320356,
0.0023568608,
-0.026228765,
0.0391004868,
-0.0309240539,
0.0248617586,
0.034025114,
0.0256516114,
0.0376710817,
-0.0051788604,
0.0056749526,
-0.0017722478,
-0.0024052165,
0.0124371555,
0.073550269,
0.0351056941,
-0.0417596921,
-0.0040136343,
0.0246018618,
-0.0250400268,
0.0116658788,
-0.0089671863,
0.0478292368,
-0.0228209775,
0.0611775666,
-0.0038088521,
-0.0469040275,
-0.0269849822,
0.0642124414,
-0.0054470212,
-0.0092141405,
-0.0438569933,
-0.0308912992,
0.058272738,
0.0068836478,
-0.0499801114,
-0.0003168326,
0.0059647057,
-0.0183740277,
-0.01095259,
-0.0116544329,
0.0006225276,
-0.010895391,
2.23e-7,
0.0115861986,
0.0123134973,
0.0329531394,
0.0184463821,
0.0067825383,
0.0205982868,
-0.0162205286,
0.0127310818,
0.0135825984,
0.0107255876,
-0.0034925074,
-0.0432636403,
0.0616720915,
0.0246035457,
-0.1073774099,
-0.0649472401,
-0.0661058202,
-0.0087748095,
0.0075378609,
0.0137873301,
0.0660965368,
0.0559719466,
-0.0058611338,
0.0251493361,
-0.0402771533,
-0.0548388287,
0.0178425256,
-0.0012155324,
-0.0071155829,
0.0021299822,
0.0555653572,
-0.0098362174,
-0.0041080527,
0.0117292786,
-0.0202996209,
0.0375963151,
0.0410162322,
0.0525177345,
0.0019858135,
-0.0921248645,
-0.0063147126,
-0.0214005988,
0.0050209984,
-0.0285454355,
0.0381188691,
-0.023864042,
-0.0232289955,
0.0049067219,
-0.0112164263,
-0.027148895,
0.0756105036,
-0.0590531416,
-0.019270679,
0.0226014145,
0.0252386052,
-0.0140226483,
0.0196283255,
-0.0719522163,
-0.0116644381,
-0.0051103346,
-0.0147453509,
-0.080417119,
-0.0040876344,
-0.0366332754,
0.0040630773,
-0.0325989202,
0.001833493,
1.464852617e-34,
0.0528067313,
-0.0222407915,
0.0453097299,
0.0222607665,
0.0343751311,
0.0060809143,
0.009471667,
-0.0258763265,
0.0520455278,
-0.0678408816,
0.0019695482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12766v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12766v1 | Mapping and Cleaning Open Commonsense Knowledge Bases with Generative Translation | 2023-06-22T09:42:54 | 2023-06-22T09:42:54 | Julien Romero, Simon Razniewski | cs.CL | cs.CL | Structured knowledge bases (KBs) are the backbone of many
know\-ledge-intensive applications, and their automated construction has
received considerable attention. In particular, open information extraction
(OpenIE) is often used to induce structure from a text. However, although it
allows high recall, the extracted knowledge tends to inherit noise from the
sources and the OpenIE algorithm. Besides, OpenIE tuples contain an open-ended,
non-canonicalized set of relations, making the extracted knowledge's downstream
exploitation harder. In this paper, we study the problem of mapping an open KB
into the fixed schema of an existing KB, specifically for the case of
commonsense knowledge. We propose approaching the problem by generative
translation, i.e., by training a language model to generate fixed-schema
assertions from open ones. Experiments show that this approach occupies a sweet
spot between traditional manual, rule-based, or classification-based
canonicalization and purely generative KB construction like COMET. Moreover, it
produces higher mapping accuracy than the former while avoiding the
association-based noise of the latter. | [
0.0205363333,
0.0651332736,
0.0032801395,
0.0319951139,
-0.0445499606,
-0.0001549994,
-0.0399520956,
0.0198930446,
0.0565345697,
-0.0667116567,
0.0110061318,
0.0192422755,
-0.0018686197,
0.0199491363,
-0.0191017725,
-0.0398170613,
0.0401865207,
-0.0141348513,
-0.0045881532,
0.0032284481,
-0.05107655,
0.0095334919,
-0.0181198604,
-0.0319666527,
0.0059723267,
-0.030357169,
0.0131474212,
-0.0302326232,
0.0395534821,
0.0145415878,
-0.0426356681,
0.0515113957,
-0.0054202816,
0.0087470543,
0.0000019619,
-0.0391135663,
-0.016866887,
0.0233445931,
-0.0007623495,
-0.0141606247,
0.005040511,
-0.0258789472,
-0.029685,
-0.0053368616,
-0.0466381609,
-0.0403192565,
0.0348052308,
0.00448108,
0.0379870459,
0.0548311174,
-0.018332487,
-0.0948441401,
0.0465545617,
0.0238973778,
0.0493859053,
-0.0487978272,
0.0347916298,
0.0421058461,
-0.0180009454,
-0.0178769734,
0.0170700252,
0.0329124629,
-0.0117499381,
-0.0395524837,
0.0363605134,
0.0496340916,
-0.0379095376,
0.011026727,
0.0052545592,
0.103833288,
0.004377075,
-0.0024282706,
0.0258551612,
-0.0008219603,
0.0111642517,
0.046029035,
-0.0013827271,
0.0454893894,
-0.0373156257,
0.0163834412,
0.0557797514,
-0.0261482783,
0.0252308063,
-0.0062456746,
-0.0414297655,
0.0530103408,
0.0065018171,
-0.0163857732,
0.0332310684,
0.0060826624,
-0.0086616222,
-0.0573784672,
-0.0175806005,
0.0367356241,
0.018927766,
0.0627765954,
-0.0095949844,
-0.0118300905,
-0.0203780513,
-0.0580838174,
0.0055447691,
0.031302657,
-0.0331698619,
0.0467558168,
-0.0448511951,
-0.0096133789,
-0.0245915782,
0.0342275165,
-0.0085057514,
0.0144360764,
-0.0819899812,
0.03027777,
-0.0062858202,
0.0381891541,
-0.018861413,
0.0152159296,
0.0071065784,
0.0192994624,
-0.0019755987,
0.0404087529,
0.0251630265,
0.0011344027,
-0.0076997508,
-0.0020101841,
-0.0602587052,
0.0104480842,
-0.0180888027,
-0.018847391,
-0.0103991348,
-0.0038374078,
0.0063551739,
0.0117537277,
0.0295344237,
0.0102941068,
-0.0385019109,
0.0358957611,
-0.0056736148,
0.0298993513,
-0.0840680152,
-0.0345680118,
0.0016372785,
-0.0280641932,
-0.0245061088,
-0.0595552661,
0.0159170479,
0.0198884122,
-0.0263556559,
-0.0542746112,
0.0092858309,
0.0247197188,
-0.0849756673,
0.0570759177,
-0.0427566133,
-0.0270223785,
-0.0231751595,
0.0080873966,
-0.0138891414,
0.0306571834,
0.0110586574,
-0.0195447337,
0.0193245653,
0.0046534543,
-0.0158746056,
-0.0116919419,
0.0387433097,
-0.0132509796,
0.0227007493,
0.0427765138,
0.04557693,
0.0503287576,
0.0416793562,
0.0405998044,
-0.0235348009,
0.0116016613,
0.0054639457,
-0.006453373,
0.009117689,
0.0422942415,
0.0140346475,
-0.0004353244,
0.0019195097,
0.0345502123,
-0.05488047,
-0.0233621113,
-0.0601028651,
0.0223826747,
-0.0446634702,
0.0173257608,
0.0180888902,
-0.0159186367,
-0.0289339088,
0.01384544,
-0.002955836,
-0.032636296,
0.0449780114,
0.0544643551,
-0.0186124127,
0.0819192827,
0.0504349545,
-0.050144136,
0.0363868624,
0.0001578823,
0.032014221,
0.026820302,
0.0371236317,
-0.0337437131,
-0.0117073143,
-0.0203290638,
-0.0487143546,
0.0629366785,
-0.0160238016,
-0.065484874,
-0.0191706568,
-0.0385826565,
-0.0284796841,
0.0346442014,
0.0064398684,
0.0048209336,
0.0204608552,
-0.0087749222,
0.011075642,
-0.0586689673,
-0.0273647755,
0.0221544299,
0.0334277079,
-0.0287666172,
0.0035982905,
0.0146909859,
0.0256321337,
0.0213258527,
0.0128266606,
-0.0031513528,
0.0209678002,
-0.0252143107,
-0.0216882303,
0.0465961881,
-0.0142186768,
-0.0623559803,
0.0458867066,
-0.0187954605,
-0.0362420119,
-0.0381788798,
-0.0474460907,
-0.0361275971,
-0.019226484,
0.0286696143,
0.0518384166,
-0.0334461182,
-0.0198935885,
0.0377124734,
-0.0695108846,
-0.0177618507,
0.1548618525,
-0.0241025165,
-0.0218683537,
0.0183929317,
-0.0690080002,
0.0272149891,
0.0089463079,
0.0165565517,
0.0198712796,
-0.0030931828,
0.0065603289,
0.0257328674,
0.0176483579,
-0.0622418858,
-0.00765451,
-0.0394933559,
0.0124237789,
0.0013716531,
0.0408179313,
0.0359563157,
0.0136623839,
0.0201938003,
-0.0000347348,
-0.067102164,
0.0278894287,
-0.0237279944,
-0.0020964681,
0.0375429317,
0.022077173,
-0.0054216995,
0.051497288,
0.0415270999,
-0.0115099223,
0.0333355106,
0.0150450654,
0.0279284287,
-0.0518762991,
0.0832034424,
-0.0213079713,
0.0206680615,
0.0194512717,
0.0206813496,
0.0105350437,
-0.0060157874,
0.0505795926,
0.0323114879,
-0.0111371633,
-0.0084765833,
0.0444341116,
-0.0386697911,
-0.0061571188,
0.0149857728,
-0.0195296798,
-0.0163878761,
-0.007518502,
-0.0091215232,
-0.0135735627,
0.0167531911,
0.01061818,
-0.0238111652,
-0.0669129565,
-0.0081046838,
-0.0046296483,
-0.0061628008,
-0.0860367492,
0.0456425585,
0.0114735644,
0.0512637123,
-0.0061338451,
-0.0094915796,
0.0407344662,
-0.0061070952,
0.076905176,
-0.0380349495,
0.0739942566,
-0.0174552649,
0.069255732,
-0.0255087316,
0.0338486098,
0.035303466,
-0.0280066729,
-0.0345658548,
-0.0112403976,
0.0286455546,
-0.0118794041,
0.0110684391,
-0.0667898655,
0.0476631001,
-0.0115375975,
-0.0102817947,
-0.0610269159,
0.0219533611,
0.024432417,
0.0112370402,
0.010379971,
-0.0177200753,
-0.0035524296,
-0.0015406935,
-0.0050577926,
0.0277800951,
0.0436287075,
-0.0030886759,
-0.0008136083,
0.0534144565,
0.0115799606,
0.0145044615,
-0.0156243267,
0.0572931767,
-0.0352412499,
0.0623196512,
0.0061063897,
-0.0113991937,
0.0345297642,
0.0072803516,
0.0047419048,
-0.060563609,
-0.016549401,
0.0001104584,
-0.013006282,
-0.035852164,
-0.0377952605,
0.0632766858,
0.0402427427,
-0.0066131828,
-0.0244907215,
-0.0176502895,
-0.0018914372,
-0.0241654236,
0.0030110243,
-0.1082333624,
-0.0069890702,
0.0006214578,
0.00148801,
0.0058542881,
-0.0854339302,
0.0125607392,
-0.1278633028,
0.0039893365,
0.0191881303,
-0.0960656032,
-0.0181641374,
-0.0030478814,
0.0205166303,
-0.0490108393,
-0.0388501175,
0.0107954005,
0.0162931439,
0.0226093642,
-0.0212627314,
0.0104610976,
-0.0877423808,
-0.0001688974,
-0.0671218708,
0.0694965124,
0.0433895737,
0.0539718643,
0.0232061613,
-0.0561950505,
-0.0429539829,
-0.0295825526,
0.0075096698,
-0.0153284622,
0.0069599152,
-0.0005657641,
-0.0027679394,
-0.013866541,
0.0560013056,
-0.0766785517,
-0.0137839261,
0.0301520657,
0.0906086043,
0.0009571349,
0.0142574981,
0.0194803067,
-0.035199102,
0.0579730086,
0.0961443856,
-0.0117982849,
0.0503933206,
0.0139158526,
-0.0340625569,
-0.0144444508,
-0.0419456959,
-0.0184579771,
0.0439536609,
-0.0235016085,
-0.0379932038,
-0.1261451393,
-0.0131984819,
0.0447695218,
0.0383054502,
0.0217717905,
0.0016051112,
0.0256437287,
0.0029404352,
-0.0489502102,
0.0157380719,
-0.0673058853,
-0.0347177759,
-0.0351934992,
-0.0511085205,
0.008360072,
-0.0156427845,
-0.0424524695,
0.0057320553,
-0.0083110472,
-0.0465845987,
0.0190712791,
0.0394418053,
0.017481057,
0.0363341831,
-0.0484680608,
0.0451823771,
0.0711720511,
0.0591947585,
-0.0737566724,
-0.0117854914,
0.0132445721,
-0.0200635195,
0.0131391333,
0.0500374027,
-0.022712715,
-0.0089143496,
-0.017231483,
0.0655352473,
-0.0184030514,
-0.0309752021,
0.0333054923,
0.0293793846,
0.0049034641,
-0.0224912874,
0.0038011766,
-0.0353634134,
0.0100940512,
-0.0447337329,
-0.0419263057,
0.0003722727,
0.0438283607,
0.0291510783,
-0.0307658762,
-0.0058726794,
0.0226349682,
-0.0488763787,
0.0314673632,
0.0034613963,
-0.0569108166,
0.0743041709,
0.0491929017,
0.0444816686,
-0.0267698467,
-0.0458806157,
0.0222132243,
-0.0043176035,
0.039207764,
-0.0162030905,
0.0136947678,
0.024789298,
-0.0098410267,
0.0181213245,
-0.006744375,
-0.0005656295,
0.0001915633,
-0.0165833607,
0.0478418171,
0.0371333063,
0.0369514115,
0.0455083437,
-0.0340407342,
-0.0277809966,
0.0265124086,
0.0341425054,
0.0450392924,
-0.0335857198,
0.0365865603,
0.0028283494,
-0.0078279171,
-0.0206508953,
0.0715249181,
-0.0670126677,
0.0536387041,
-0.0289258454,
-0.0225076377,
-0.0581055172,
-0.0195780899,
-0.0502030551,
0.02706871,
0.0046645636,
0.011569499,
-0.0751583576,
-0.032822784,
-0.0113854278,
0.0421903767,
0.0228353068,
0.0178050548,
0.0128981192,
0.0489163995,
0.045399785,
-0.0616562031,
-0.0283369087,
0.0284145605,
-0.0808682442,
-0.0331689976,
-0.0074291006,
-6.030327529e-33,
-0.0614623092,
-0.014354581,
0.0032450054,
0.0101456884,
-0.0063261888,
-0.0281077046,
-0.0319742598,
-0.022873085,
-0.0317446329,
0.0147282751,
-0.0068445038,
0.0071991119,
0.0120358439,
0.0063006585,
-0.017821826,
-0.0057077529,
0.0227332506,
0.0264437143,
-0.0298503432,
0.0076822452,
0.0976530388,
-0.0011436535,
0.0477170795,
-0.0508120954,
0.0586081594,
-0.0224849563,
-0.0094029261,
0.028789971,
0.0142325079,
0.0154961832,
-0.0294797365,
0.0498262942,
0.0060079116,
0.0227613002,
0.0157035664,
-0.0078267092,
-0.1327763796,
-0.0168449674,
0.0449483879,
-0.0108123673,
-0.0191722102,
-0.0523850434,
0.0205081366,
-0.0100040408,
0.0344533883,
-0.0214724261,
0.0101251137,
-0.054467693,
-0.0162780024,
-0.0252498612,
-0.0678506494,
0.0253265519,
0.0601514578,
-0.0052076885,
-0.0553211048,
-0.0434934311,
-0.0108246999,
-0.0323800519,
-0.0654676408,
0.0111036738,
0.0299072899,
0.028163977,
0.0380149819,
-0.0204115566,
0.0014681952,
0.0233050827,
-0.0635150671,
-0.0349473394,
-0.0335017443,
0.0184024684,
-0.0126312571,
0.0581694134,
-0.0147226024,
0.046915032,
0.0564545579,
-0.0035656379,
-0.0774858519,
0.056124974,
-0.0003505728,
0.0360963158,
-0.0345445648,
0.008346607,
-0.022267282,
-0.0112449015,
-0.0280190334,
-0.015550389,
-0.0196296014,
-0.0432133526,
0.0033606854,
-0.0295310244,
-0.0558797643,
0.0133320056,
0.0197465159,
0.011500665,
0.0160669349,
0.0384897105,
0.0153060211,
0.0032824005,
-0.0295382664,
0.0000589249,
-0.0570082627,
-0.0409238413,
0.0328860842,
-0.0060604159,
0.0033976161,
0.06505467,
0.0166498087,
0.030575173,
-0.026781721,
-0.0041399207,
-0.028641006,
0.0191656556,
-0.0189999118,
-0.0011606716,
0.026686212,
0.0141808214,
0.0194640998,
0.0318960547,
0.0361769423,
0.0427378304,
-0.0124426559,
0.0312478747,
0.0308329072,
0.0261907447,
0.0002855875,
0.0084323017,
0.0133376475,
-0.0333706215,
0.0231351946,
-0.0203520264,
0.0136268521,
0.0266908519,
2.727e-7,
0.0411100537,
-0.0140956808,
0.010508352,
0.0439081229,
-0.0205099303,
0.0276255738,
0.0253705569,
0.0228404459,
-0.0270244181,
-0.0796153322,
-0.0003913169,
-0.0211746786,
-0.0218895115,
0.0585450605,
-0.0828957707,
-0.0248193275,
0.0321825333,
-0.0589483604,
-0.0097120823,
0.0038917232,
0.0777528435,
0.0056803972,
0.0061186422,
0.0035467127,
0.0075478787,
-0.0246250052,
0.0440863855,
0.0120552685,
-0.0231888574,
-0.0060113729,
0.0426053852,
0.0223192926,
-0.0233584102,
0.0591257028,
0.0018722425,
0.0112002045,
-0.0076823584,
0.006236474,
0.0036749595,
0.0375431404,
-0.0205180924,
-0.1096626222,
0.0235373322,
-0.0268527009,
0.0529187471,
-0.0793470889,
-0.0045076143,
0.0227271188,
-0.0405789651,
-0.0073800371,
-0.0333695561,
0.0091300327,
-0.0140923858,
-0.0081497328,
0.0136895003,
0.0156602059,
-0.0057483912,
-0.0627558753,
0.0104531655,
0.0211220495,
0.0286519397,
-0.0528326668,
0.0453179143,
-0.0334080458,
-0.00944407,
-0.10348095,
-0.0009118224,
2.240354709e-34,
0.0038262389,
0.0250829291,
-0.0415582806,
-0.0187575463,
0.0331307575,
-0.0116277635,
0.0018192651,
-0.0367827043,
0.0134270424,
-0.0757376328,
0.0115064615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12756v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12756v1 | On the Robustness of Generative Retrieval Models: An Out-of-Distribution Perspective | 2023-06-22T09:18:52 | 2023-06-22T09:18:52 | Yu-An Liu, Ruqing Zhang, Jiafeng Guo, Wei Chen, Xueqi Cheng | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, we have witnessed generative retrieval increasingly gaining
attention in the information retrieval (IR) field, which retrieves documents by
directly generating their identifiers. So far, much effort has been devoted to
developing effective generative retrieval models. There has been less attention
paid to the robustness perspective. When a new retrieval paradigm enters into
the real-world application, it is also critical to measure the
out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization, i.e., how would generative retrieval
models generalize to new distributions. To answer this question, firstly, we
define OOD robustness from three perspectives in retrieval problems: 1) The
query variations; 2) The unforeseen query types; and 3) The unforeseen tasks.
Based on this taxonomy, we conduct empirical studies to analyze the OOD
robustness of several representative generative retrieval models against dense
retrieval models. The empirical results indicate that the OOD robustness of
generative retrieval models requires enhancement. We hope studying the OOD
robustness of generative retrieval models would be advantageous to the IR
community. | [
0.0542729758,
0.0448910259,
0.0033912149,
-0.0212046839,
-0.0230228733,
-0.0011639702,
-0.0212702006,
0.0525686108,
0.0054089781,
-0.0144670717,
-0.0063085048,
-0.0401108079,
-0.0423704311,
-0.0001019809,
0.0031709985,
-0.0511270761,
0.0082710274,
0.0064233257,
0.0103059225,
-0.0008838456,
-0.0378243104,
0.0047291382,
0.0232047476,
0.0249011945,
0.0100841699,
0.0111560728,
0.0055064694,
0.0546540916,
-0.0336496457,
-0.0012326998,
-0.005593135,
0.0376785062,
0.0224403776,
0.0324188285,
0.0000018147,
-0.0496869832,
-0.0611028671,
0.0263642296,
0.0009987908,
-0.0142557649,
0.0551676862,
0.0272435676,
-0.019136291,
0.0107625434,
-0.0037480192,
-0.0296129212,
0.0249076039,
0.0191075522,
-0.0231641326,
0.060376931,
-0.0115341041,
-0.0167606734,
0.0591295101,
-0.0490649231,
0.0440002196,
-0.0286422148,
0.0191376451,
-0.0293669757,
0.0245955065,
0.0441098809,
0.0007338914,
0.0231659357,
-0.0379976071,
0.0027907384,
0.0369770788,
0.0081637073,
-0.0401488803,
0.017117491,
0.0155623294,
0.011178459,
-0.0006258979,
-0.0064434558,
0.0052268528,
0.0060166861,
0.0041650585,
0.0807705596,
-0.0628483519,
0.0006863053,
-0.020819284,
0.0010705922,
-0.0341937952,
0.0402493961,
0.0105821146,
-0.020254897,
-0.0165500212,
0.010916234,
0.0275367498,
-0.0301762968,
-0.0410534926,
-0.0273789521,
-0.049976334,
0.0010813645,
-0.0210594647,
-0.0099230213,
0.0257729404,
-0.0026584528,
0.0128268227,
-0.0372474566,
0.0697137415,
-0.031328395,
0.0204987563,
-0.0149324145,
-0.0256709177,
0.0387029201,
0.0144626647,
0.0551955365,
-0.0281398706,
0.0044049555,
-0.0285420641,
0.0045627565,
-0.0751575455,
-0.0488734506,
-0.0333340541,
0.0530969687,
-0.025525894,
-0.0308416355,
-0.0211922713,
0.0701415762,
0.0094846878,
-0.0399904363,
-0.015764419,
0.0417015888,
-0.0702218264,
-0.0154057024,
-0.0567620769,
-0.0165934935,
-0.0075537702,
-0.0285723675,
0.0115974052,
-0.067010127,
0.0122689921,
0.0063549322,
0.0250839014,
-0.0306909475,
0.0028635755,
0.0144211045,
0.0252753012,
-0.0477226749,
-0.0330562294,
-0.0436085649,
0.0159413014,
-0.007154434,
0.0240300205,
-0.0368714258,
-0.022674188,
0.0119209718,
-0.0313296057,
-0.0660875291,
-0.0104083447,
0.0310458466,
-0.0188451745,
0.0009425172,
0.0322430246,
0.0147568434,
0.0436423533,
-0.0170283746,
0.0441828407,
0.0093362173,
-0.0273282956,
-0.001975833,
0.0750859231,
0.0124125388,
0.0727544054,
-0.0037022778,
-0.00176691,
0.0196101181,
-0.0024796606,
0.0396126024,
0.0029796464,
-0.0246898644,
0.0013457106,
0.0535484515,
-0.0296553299,
-0.0214592237,
0.022953691,
0.0537111498,
0.0440553837,
-0.0093918974,
0.015328845,
-0.0010159789,
-0.0373873971,
0.0318962969,
0.0113466363,
0.008660187,
-0.0385886058,
0.0157662239,
0.0314593948,
-0.001827803,
-0.0501121841,
-0.0490483679,
-0.0273851082,
0.0468995571,
-0.0501087233,
0.0030702676,
0.0722053498,
0.0211339798,
-0.0085136918,
-0.0280706417,
-0.0316156335,
-0.0550329648,
-0.0136768129,
-0.0610065721,
0.0072761434,
0.0368089266,
0.1113723591,
-0.0535009168,
0.0190312956,
0.0333672017,
-0.0453115441,
-0.0369901918,
0.0059491671,
-0.0130862724,
-0.0178273972,
-0.014096329,
-0.0434650816,
0.0239330903,
0.0082263155,
0.0136254858,
0.0273830593,
-0.0098239211,
0.032537967,
-0.0922193155,
-0.0128542287,
0.0173228905,
-0.0046960311,
-0.0625483617,
0.0312852673,
-0.0041037807,
-0.0030441748,
0.0194180626,
-0.0207753275,
0.0372971185,
0.0542586967,
0.0155992638,
-0.031229781,
-0.0035165625,
0.0213739946,
0.0310739502,
-0.0386621393,
-0.0130884247,
0.0343946107,
-0.0376528539,
0.0168823265,
-0.0174053218,
0.0200030655,
-0.0028132631,
0.0246540476,
-0.0812606066,
0.0351879708,
0.0068148682,
0.0031556347,
-0.0650158152,
0.1055289209,
-0.0061005834,
0.0357294567,
-0.0265644286,
0.0435245745,
0.0388402492,
-0.0921930298,
-0.0194419101,
0.0424893238,
-0.0266787801,
0.0173103884,
0.0465340167,
-0.0205860715,
0.0036924717,
-0.0350391939,
-0.0355398133,
0.0160998031,
-0.0217840429,
-0.003786386,
-0.0181135107,
0.0305366274,
-0.0242260024,
-0.0088385725,
-0.0156026976,
-0.0200708881,
0.0395806618,
0.0117856469,
0.0072232359,
0.0054759919,
-0.0072543086,
0.0048750909,
-0.0522247329,
0.0210729986,
0.0685934424,
-0.0165344216,
-0.0016766127,
-0.0362404995,
0.0483221188,
-0.057697285,
0.0290768277,
-0.0220041052,
0.0301921815,
0.0150255356,
-0.0555158257,
0.081273295,
0.05436958,
0.0369031206,
-0.0163082387,
-0.0011687798,
-0.0219508484,
-0.0639986247,
0.0151090976,
-0.0594513565,
-0.0715751499,
0.0503036305,
-0.0151898768,
0.0477682352,
-0.0271373633,
-0.0035657969,
-0.0399403796,
-0.0383431166,
0.0046706488,
0.0109611861,
0.0001897953,
-0.0531240813,
0.0128963105,
0.0261925422,
0.0453548767,
-0.0010863023,
-0.067270577,
0.0188597813,
0.0051551419,
0.0314772241,
-0.0041731982,
0.0032547486,
-0.0276461281,
0.0855267718,
-0.0185050555,
0.0246018432,
0.0393052846,
-0.0187771842,
-0.0117516816,
0.0193659104,
0.0397141576,
-0.0600637868,
0.0201749187,
0.0085633509,
0.0345673449,
0.0186270438,
-0.0506205931,
-0.0318828709,
0.000760839,
0.0740200728,
0.0278798994,
0.026770914,
-0.003809145,
-0.0393596217,
0.0401650965,
0.0011751305,
0.0139338067,
-0.021953918,
-0.0404231139,
0.0245188195,
0.0382914394,
0.0157585014,
-0.0819470957,
-0.049593199,
0.0114065241,
-0.0478267036,
0.0031103231,
0.0423131846,
-0.0325331986,
0.0174231101,
0.0189424716,
0.046010606,
-0.0118292328,
-0.0497105718,
0.0473376736,
-0.033301346,
0.0236634947,
-0.0532045066,
0.0182289835,
0.0319290943,
-0.0422391929,
-0.030489549,
-0.0334382281,
0.039886333,
0.0378135219,
0.0370671377,
-0.0095482748,
0.0508799404,
0.0214093775,
0.08238215,
-0.0363345221,
-0.0040453495,
0.0171296913,
-0.1243971214,
0.0951372162,
-0.02452912,
0.0149554498,
-0.0475663655,
-0.0418739021,
0.0118498607,
0.0019655118,
-0.0509874411,
0.0489299335,
-0.0324252024,
-0.0230551194,
0.0223624613,
0.0441216119,
-0.0591902845,
-0.0377894193,
-0.0158794075,
-0.0387015156,
0.0805914029,
-0.0118282456,
0.0465240143,
-0.0427514762,
-0.0161542334,
-0.0441662334,
0.0154407816,
-0.0110744759,
0.0504315756,
0.0072575994,
0.0306328982,
-0.0190878846,
0.0049468242,
0.0095145004,
0.0049190321,
-0.054163307,
0.0182988532,
-0.0294437241,
0.0120165888,
-0.0641984344,
-0.0604787394,
-0.0167077053,
0.054544542,
-0.0176548529,
0.0206299163,
-0.0439041704,
-0.0329087414,
0.069236286,
-0.0076802545,
0.0250832364,
-0.0003612408,
-0.0044980296,
-0.0420315675,
-0.0723908693,
-0.003529812,
-0.0734356567,
0.0762207732,
-0.0211165436,
0.0241591185,
-0.0520586893,
-0.0150407702,
-0.019633539,
-0.0111830877,
-0.0212108698,
-0.042325642,
-0.0554488674,
-0.010129259,
0.0738169625,
-0.0426298045,
-0.0466180407,
-0.0008957257,
-0.0167274773,
-0.0396762341,
-0.0041719428,
0.0203766041,
0.0311870445,
-0.0004884173,
-0.0227933712,
-0.0557978712,
0.064140901,
0.0870543867,
0.018910246,
-0.0065291175,
0.0044403048,
-0.0062872246,
-0.0228428598,
0.0113996603,
-0.0666574761,
0.0498827212,
0.0033099649,
0.0283981133,
-0.0029361036,
-0.047361888,
0.0164488424,
0.0258442461,
0.0435877256,
0.0138593167,
-0.018027138,
-0.0477087796,
0.023634145,
-0.0176504049,
-0.019209275,
-0.0165981352,
0.0230602957,
0.0552606136,
-0.0005129935,
-0.0131207863,
0.0556037538,
-0.0156941675,
0.1278014779,
-0.0569987074,
-0.0584085435,
0.0026512537,
-0.0017914085,
-0.0211777184,
-0.0071333186,
-0.0054178522,
0.0196149927,
-0.0114938244,
0.0581360161,
-0.0227348879,
0.0335314386,
0.0019506604,
0.0176296923,
-0.0200443007,
-0.0319682695,
-0.091219373,
0.0096777631,
-0.0317303911,
0.0418661274,
0.0141550945,
-0.0020412274,
-0.0363508984,
-0.0237371586,
-0.0089054871,
-0.0378621332,
-0.0325400867,
0.0643838346,
-0.0186471269,
-0.0085786879,
0.0256484877,
0.0153685398,
0.0195178706,
0.0765527859,
0.0243755225,
0.0143004553,
-0.0956594497,
-0.033869952,
-0.0253393762,
-0.0013080264,
0.0522059463,
0.0022548519,
-0.0007590823,
-0.0186992008,
-0.0295933615,
-0.0218711495,
0.0505581833,
-0.0095446464,
0.0487580299,
-0.0158064533,
0.0272747092,
0.1248037815,
0.0048380396,
-0.0208180342,
-0.0457710922,
-0.0083836997,
-0.0672134161,
0.0197830144,
-0.0227013249,
-6.340399797e-33,
-0.0084214071,
-0.0051850434,
-0.0214784183,
-0.0539732948,
0.0098003251,
-0.0363343395,
-0.0049145301,
-0.0380163565,
0.0142056998,
-0.0649366751,
-0.0395946167,
-0.0033958992,
0.0037057595,
0.0139868828,
0.0067916024,
0.0198093448,
0.0166072696,
0.0031033915,
-0.0466779694,
0.0258614141,
0.0728615448,
0.0211909283,
-0.0179084856,
-0.0481685326,
0.0136507181,
-0.0627082065,
0.0240363553,
0.0093633542,
0.0440324098,
0.071979478,
-0.0062055746,
0.0309232827,
0.0067781745,
-0.0152923474,
0.0081166467,
-0.0402659141,
-0.0688672736,
-0.0051218383,
-0.0276346486,
-0.0487350784,
0.0279904716,
-0.0241583269,
0.0228677783,
-0.0236524157,
-0.0454519019,
0.0012816776,
0.043812234,
-0.0028881833,
-0.060944356,
-0.0883394629,
-0.0132044135,
0.0196635239,
0.0191346053,
0.0340124369,
-0.008764036,
0.0273907762,
0.0458437093,
0.0508596078,
0.0141094383,
0.0320629328,
-0.0044038612,
0.0613014735,
0.0173078626,
0.032902915,
0.0391175635,
0.0106640719,
-0.0131824678,
0.0167642441,
-0.0212201867,
-0.0361661091,
0.0198683962,
0.0273180492,
-0.0083833486,
0.0748494193,
0.0484041013,
-0.0226015635,
-0.042306494,
0.0757328197,
-0.0400396027,
-0.0003694788,
0.0595567785,
0.0526163913,
-0.0732700974,
-0.0176099427,
-0.0080852648,
-0.042633906,
-0.0153059214,
-0.0060424898,
0.0476325452,
0.0478462391,
-0.023204999,
-0.0043974658,
0.0497265346,
0.0076876832,
-0.0144452658,
0.0577716641,
-0.0201651268,
0.0202749092,
-0.0341831073,
0.0097643146,
0.0202341918,
-0.0477423891,
0.0492668264,
0.033254113,
-0.0477892384,
-0.0102489293,
0.0006366041,
0.0116176317,
-0.0623969696,
-0.0025411623,
0.0102082724,
0.0271298401,
-0.0303994957,
-0.0044704108,
0.0258901417,
0.0247967672,
0.021537561,
-0.0011216543,
0.0484824218,
0.0470012203,
-0.0083231609,
-0.0105042038,
-0.0148755321,
-0.0255992766,
0.0356056057,
0.0592317581,
0.0012795067,
0.0157292895,
0.0162925497,
-0.0186619386,
0.0028535638,
0.0606208034,
2.652e-7,
0.0439235009,
0.0048287534,
0.0382418819,
0.0373939574,
-0.0086470637,
-0.0123252803,
0.0148511892,
0.0077922274,
0.0230030455,
-0.0213992447,
0.0319589488,
-0.0004314084,
-0.0028347345,
0.0048329909,
-0.077391915,
-0.0023872021,
-0.0197124016,
0.0253444426,
-0.026119018,
-0.0223611072,
0.045942571,
0.0468840562,
-0.0402213931,
0.0066520916,
-0.0014439785,
-0.0936703831,
0.0561407767,
0.0089941639,
0.0331037864,
-0.0009131749,
0.0648755431,
0.0607400946,
0.0423196629,
-0.0092218574,
-0.0034177531,
0.0345704593,
0.0444425829,
0.000080249,
0.0042193588,
-0.0391415469,
0.0228020102,
-0.0040900568,
0.018527478,
-0.0516791418,
0.0576337613,
-0.0120528713,
0.0358817726,
0.0670047477,
-0.0578312129,
0.0203744583,
0.0002800013,
-0.0265387837,
-0.0301909819,
0.0120153204,
-0.0145601956,
0.0312398318,
0.036541786,
-0.0531402193,
0.0231431313,
-0.0174244437,
-0.0306908116,
-0.0234467983,
-0.0294122845,
0.0675799102,
-0.0377660058,
-0.0008405434,
-0.0062613762,
2.358896197e-34,
0.0333029106,
0.0523087382,
-0.0401383042,
-0.043133758,
0.021628214,
-0.0204190891,
-0.0199434869,
0.0263546016,
0.0061781839,
-0.0748134106,
-0.0196453612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12725v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12725v4 | Generative Multimodal Entity Linking | 2023-06-22T07:57:19 | 2024-03-20T01:30:41 | Senbao Shi, Zhenran Xu, Baotian Hu, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multimodal Entity Linking (MEL) is the task of mapping mentions with
multimodal contexts to the referent entities from a knowledge base. Existing
MEL methods mainly focus on designing complex multimodal interaction mechanisms
and require fine-tuning all model parameters, which can be prohibitively costly
and difficult to scale in the era of Large Language Models (LLMs). In this
work, we propose GEMEL, a Generative Multimodal Entity Linking framework based
on LLMs, which directly generates target entity names. We keep the vision and
language model frozen and only train a feature mapper to enable cross-modality
interactions. To adapt LLMs to the MEL task, we leverage the in-context
learning capability of LLMs by retrieving multimodal instances as
demonstrations. Extensive experiments show that, with only ~0.3% of the model
parameters fine-tuned, GEMEL achieves state-of-the-art results on two
well-established MEL datasets (7.7% accuracy gains on WikiDiverse and 8.8%
accuracy gains on WikiMEL). The performance gain stems from mitigating the
popularity bias of LLM predictions and disambiguating less common entities
effectively. Further analysis verifies the generality and scalability of GEMEL.
Our framework is compatible with any off-the-shelf language model, paving the
way towards an efficient and general solution for utilizing LLMs in the MEL
task. Our code is available at https://github.com/HITsz-TMG/GEMEL. | [
0.0332325324,
0.0418494977,
0.0072695366,
0.0109281605,
0.0052377083,
0.0050623002,
0.0151144275,
-0.023682734,
0.0132789435,
-0.0720227137,
-0.0170914102,
0.013262528,
0.0020945121,
0.0081899324,
0.0816331282,
-0.0695559382,
0.0264048465,
-0.0048593045,
-0.0363419689,
0.0154991848,
0.0045911525,
0.0425228029,
-0.0315770991,
0.035460595,
-0.0839834511,
-0.0074675009,
0.0006163111,
0.0379557014,
0.0207145754,
-0.0554542318,
-0.0224244241,
0.0239603724,
0.0236984231,
0.0318734422,
0.0000019615,
-0.0529070646,
0.0004441986,
0.0047939061,
0.0425451174,
-0.0236428194,
0.0371262692,
-0.0405273326,
0.0062034675,
-0.0069563673,
-0.0117213447,
-0.0305751227,
0.0418506302,
0.0441256687,
0.0570394173,
0.0237328615,
-0.0342162959,
-0.0317045227,
0.0381701887,
-0.0196538102,
0.0181286167,
-0.0532503128,
-0.0096097486,
0.0071403743,
-0.0089243446,
0.0155003648,
-0.0456893593,
0.0830086991,
0.0048325439,
0.0066036806,
0.0344998166,
0.033288639,
0.0032407793,
-0.0070854537,
-0.0124658681,
0.1340562552,
0.0051698531,
0.0015567162,
0.006181688,
0.0237091705,
-0.0025440627,
0.0386733077,
-0.0328991413,
0.0003882257,
-0.0086563621,
-0.0010753438,
-0.0616074726,
-0.0133841354,
0.0505505688,
-0.0173872355,
0.0332112275,
-0.0284019765,
0.0156719945,
0.0120245665,
-0.0018925163,
0.0128904106,
-0.0198731869,
-0.0541626252,
-0.0210190658,
0.0076098875,
-0.0256887004,
0.0362350196,
-0.0695833787,
-0.0269700438,
0.0083344188,
-0.0124850729,
0.0063007432,
-0.0056501715,
-0.0180187169,
0.0377834626,
-0.0532945767,
-0.0172686558,
-0.058780361,
-0.0115305157,
0.0089485999,
-0.0709262863,
-0.0524281338,
0.0158995148,
-0.0117876586,
-0.0162085891,
-0.0314905234,
-0.0491757616,
-0.0464357361,
0.0071159038,
-0.0009091624,
0.0466462299,
-0.0140073476,
0.0077862721,
-0.0388371348,
0.0017289035,
-0.046091035,
0.040684972,
-0.0403207652,
0.0031653747,
-0.0360325463,
-0.0140323807,
0.0187857375,
0.0085059544,
0.0052045677,
-0.0500482917,
0.0110107912,
0.1217994988,
-0.0121388342,
-0.0425935946,
-0.039060656,
-0.0658032298,
0.0049851597,
-0.0368188061,
0.0224526729,
-0.0600484535,
0.0498747006,
0.0064517609,
0.0056542852,
-0.067651853,
0.0275441259,
0.0029743281,
-0.0545637645,
0.1208572611,
-0.0105665484,
-0.0026196078,
0.0402448066,
0.0080133313,
0.0031046267,
0.0527316183,
0.0727391317,
0.0036700929,
0.039193444,
0.0249954406,
-0.0074084448,
0.0571141802,
0.0513005294,
-0.0031646604,
0.0165220685,
-0.0172773711,
-0.0170286112,
0.0540729277,
0.0684361905,
0.0534109958,
-0.0196504928,
-0.0361708924,
0.0446453728,
0.0117618293,
-0.0000669952,
0.0200867597,
0.0528806262,
-0.0147316633,
-0.0333559327,
-0.0439803004,
-0.0468539894,
0.0666027591,
-0.0019283177,
-0.0123124579,
0.0591374077,
0.0658839419,
-0.016165005,
0.0307338089,
0.0292320326,
-0.0115202172,
0.0130153764,
0.0097514046,
0.0374536105,
0.0299999882,
-0.0591756664,
0.0770544782,
0.043032337,
-0.028645752,
-0.0116497194,
0.0066741551,
-0.0409787558,
0.0467846543,
0.0410293974,
0.0384887978,
-0.0188437011,
-0.0482426248,
0.0331073068,
0.0536812283,
-0.0064621312,
-0.0294078272,
0.0239115469,
-0.0342491753,
-0.0305733383,
0.0090225441,
-0.0134726893,
0.0343431123,
0.0299459342,
0.042555891,
0.0319190249,
-0.0669986308,
0.0535470918,
0.0308811944,
-0.0022803552,
0.0183208436,
-0.0356846191,
0.026922727,
-0.0241077207,
0.0216290336,
-0.0075293966,
-0.0348076299,
0.0092970943,
-0.0421511307,
0.0395792462,
0.0431097113,
0.0078679426,
-0.0372429751,
0.0281131696,
-0.0745291635,
-0.0093425922,
-0.0162815396,
-0.016231712,
-0.0466339849,
0.028874496,
0.0021929278,
0.0431587324,
-0.0153129147,
-0.0101061193,
0.0423540771,
0.0293304771,
-0.0152766583,
0.04861857,
-0.0228774939,
-0.0163112357,
0.0296471585,
0.0314185508,
-0.0117107807,
0.0010738403,
-0.0472137146,
0.0133509301,
0.0204515085,
0.0157053098,
-0.005816895,
-0.0156823266,
-0.0474700108,
-0.0196126159,
-0.1074939296,
-0.0043762447,
0.0201197043,
-0.018883219,
-0.0237384643,
0.0264164526,
-0.0059660343,
-0.0465697758,
0.004037295,
0.0210059676,
-0.0040825577,
0.0181924701,
0.0287024938,
0.025763439,
0.0115941586,
-0.0327204876,
0.0042734062,
-0.0142526962,
0.0798190013,
0.0078942282,
-0.0091289645,
-0.0335755348,
-0.0105659822,
-0.0431059077,
0.0089703891,
-0.0266124532,
0.0145915002,
0.0141698429,
0.0116346925,
0.0756270885,
-0.000158635,
-0.0205493476,
0.0299111791,
-0.0108974501,
-0.0497627556,
-0.0773826092,
0.0453893356,
0.0305964909,
0.0038843702,
-0.0388370082,
-0.0201629493,
0.0055552479,
0.0410113409,
-0.0151445027,
0.0116085857,
-0.0435614772,
0.0415600315,
0.0740833804,
-0.0439774245,
-0.0114251357,
0.0421052724,
0.0097282538,
-0.001449678,
-0.0104547068,
-0.0208147056,
0.0186719056,
-0.0469087102,
0.0030570806,
0.0219529886,
0.0302002598,
0.0001279175,
0.0779261589,
0.0198172946,
0.0282261539,
0.0024674621,
-0.0087605286,
-0.0381843038,
0.0438403673,
0.0126104169,
0.0176984016,
0.0388224833,
-0.0250664968,
0.0323720202,
-0.001601151,
-0.0019697573,
0.0018406042,
-0.0292937532,
-0.0391463302,
-0.0250738226,
-0.0188172031,
-0.0222670138,
-0.0174929909,
0.0240683593,
0.0368859395,
-0.0091730058,
0.0486428402,
-0.0519232526,
-0.0052374904,
0.0213595219,
0.0705280975,
0.0274088401,
-0.0260234177,
-0.0035958416,
-0.0412368849,
0.0334844179,
0.0440841317,
-0.0177530758,
-0.0249793436,
-0.0166742634,
0.0129894176,
-0.000718132,
-0.0339636356,
0.0018658458,
0.0544133559,
-0.0270770453,
0.0345488191,
0.0890348703,
0.0159480963,
-0.0536341667,
-0.0053858701,
0.0300777499,
0.0249961875,
-0.0044128862,
0.0235093459,
-0.0826029181,
-0.0704748556,
-0.0053826701,
-0.0213150252,
0.0339104161,
-0.0610369295,
-0.0136781204,
-0.1267448366,
-0.0017513692,
-0.0331032425,
-0.0321953818,
-0.0185714662,
-0.0184019618,
0.0259287376,
-0.0123298159,
-0.0146587901,
-0.0130208377,
-0.0148633048,
0.0086188093,
-0.0052730823,
0.0474740602,
-0.0560377054,
0.0272423234,
-0.0953158736,
0.0797257721,
0.0375224836,
0.0475267991,
0.0282278247,
-0.0184319187,
-0.0185842942,
0.0119052641,
-0.0097761787,
-0.0249637254,
0.0569423065,
-0.060144078,
-0.0186298769,
-0.0109149786,
0.0196350776,
0.012254986,
-0.0169787779,
-0.027022412,
0.0518646687,
0.012802735,
0.0260536689,
-0.0277644489,
-0.0082156043,
0.0299838204,
0.053011708,
-0.008994774,
-0.0537935421,
-0.0049312138,
-0.0251402166,
0.0323715508,
-0.0122158378,
-0.0223155934,
-0.0093229357,
-0.0378080979,
0.0131335547,
-0.0832184628,
-0.0330306441,
0.0292870607,
0.0703498945,
0.0131014576,
0.0126701063,
-0.0246195327,
0.033045765,
-0.0498739369,
0.0536060818,
-0.0237763394,
0.0414112844,
-0.0170926079,
-0.0170581769,
0.0679353476,
-0.0401335508,
-0.0105827898,
0.0433710702,
-0.0635317042,
-0.042503953,
-0.0595262572,
0.0309623573,
0.0118600298,
0.048891589,
0.0005298224,
-0.048742719,
0.0140014095,
0.0384060591,
-0.0321821272,
0.0303165987,
-0.0140032619,
0.0345289707,
0.0108041633,
0.0395445973,
-0.0712776408,
-0.0129865641,
-0.0323433615,
0.0623652227,
-0.0593241565,
-0.0447048992,
-0.0341113918,
-0.019407995,
0.0264564715,
-0.0559237003,
-0.0071645691,
-0.022025425,
-0.0120426379,
0.0145075414,
-0.0137421293,
-0.0586199649,
0.0214006752,
0.0255909171,
0.0391369537,
-0.0120455595,
0.0043605301,
0.0369384214,
0.0449659079,
-0.0277854614,
0.010296585,
0.0260873418,
-0.0308103878,
-0.0134243509,
0.0095823137,
0.0203675721,
0.0132334633,
0.0142056057,
0.0322953723,
-0.0324904583,
0.0612445474,
-0.0006945835,
-0.0481224954,
-0.0151876267,
0.0210592598,
0.0070125642,
0.0405469127,
-0.0349058844,
0.0691096261,
0.0665378794,
0.0382907428,
0.0905842036,
-0.0212501362,
-0.0125582889,
0.038847208,
0.0467763543,
-0.0387538411,
-0.0164285954,
0.0603211112,
0.0023455597,
-0.0076579931,
0.0268909372,
0.0523050055,
0.0062517864,
0.0473201722,
0.0105770575,
-0.0091458308,
-0.064120695,
-0.0242153909,
0.0204205438,
0.0049389596,
0.0103135481,
0.0148331961,
-0.0233845226,
-0.0679987445,
0.0361549221,
-0.0094499756,
-0.0446782634,
0.0137099186,
0.0402923301,
0.0373313762,
0.0537617244,
-0.0115176514,
-0.0280304626,
-0.0239575896,
0.0098833917,
-0.0502665564,
-0.0130908536,
-5.59458059e-33,
-0.0672589913,
-0.0345695056,
0.0248543099,
-0.0395007282,
-0.0375093296,
-0.02372263,
-0.0085483706,
0.0035743096,
-0.0444311909,
-0.0291692242,
0.0175413154,
-0.0288907923,
-0.0041330191,
0.0282607637,
-0.0087165032,
-0.0083916048,
0.0343196057,
0.0164032038,
-0.0282800067,
0.0268634632,
0.0163942296,
0.0422792472,
0.058836747,
-0.0760146156,
0.0250400566,
0.0209016763,
-0.0417792052,
0.0089745997,
0.0595644154,
0.0641963482,
-0.0374371558,
0.0348728746,
-0.0148735298,
-0.0166303422,
0.003425451,
0.0156397596,
-0.1366619617,
0.0229284503,
0.0045318068,
0.0341688655,
-0.0264313407,
-0.0194091443,
0.0558373556,
-0.0170371979,
0.0305346604,
-0.0119378408,
0.0482817851,
-0.0114176637,
-0.0074381628,
-0.0310743991,
-0.0540549941,
0.0404415764,
-0.0056064874,
-0.0199098252,
0.0231476165,
-0.0037539182,
0.0395232476,
-0.0047783386,
-0.0778876841,
-0.0003531982,
-0.0342844315,
-0.0270050075,
0.0588549711,
0.0091799377,
0.0174113978,
0.0874761418,
0.0140876723,
-0.0410600156,
-0.0294368844,
0.0230016988,
0.03903782,
0.0303758662,
-0.0098954067,
0.1256361604,
-0.0056058937,
-0.0068481495,
-0.038294781,
0.0260562841,
0.0010049876,
0.0162203182,
-0.0030577586,
0.0075192782,
-0.0077983905,
-0.0054495968,
-0.0419515595,
-0.0052601644,
-0.0248624571,
-0.0545523204,
0.0266692918,
-0.0071902513,
-0.0238160938,
0.0637832284,
0.0647101626,
-0.0096451882,
-0.0678188577,
0.0244788826,
0.012601519,
0.0475604795,
0.004838773,
-0.0235990304,
-0.0281765163,
0.0001060161,
0.0571459681,
-0.0413743183,
0.0243366249,
0.0052487548,
0.0202525817,
0.0136660589,
-0.0718385056,
-0.0092026498,
-0.0108823953,
0.0032260921,
-0.0475323498,
-0.0109442445,
0.0307018906,
-0.0114051793,
-0.0613938756,
-0.0281475987,
0.0417660549,
0.0049265656,
-0.0121245701,
-0.0246239044,
0.0004918998,
-0.002489757,
-0.0224181414,
0.0145217283,
-0.0289360192,
-0.0367996208,
0.025013905,
-0.0864063129,
-0.025301652,
0.0199258681,
2.64e-7,
0.0310918465,
0.0221232716,
-0.0259258691,
0.0197306275,
0.0092508644,
0.0375790335,
0.0364496,
0.0752275735,
0.0066676992,
-0.0605081096,
-0.0311814025,
0.0139679248,
0.0240784548,
0.0433515236,
-0.0590920784,
-0.0178081822,
-0.0085382368,
0.0018699681,
-0.0434180945,
0.0062342668,
0.0040260688,
0.055680681,
0.0017172326,
-0.0079484042,
-0.0022233056,
-0.0424721241,
0.0878186896,
-0.0456715189,
-0.0263053384,
-0.0238855015,
0.0030875164,
0.0146757578,
-0.0284375288,
0.0164054502,
-0.0013305305,
0.0000035179,
0.0508278869,
0.0270402785,
0.0010111424,
-0.0453889519,
-0.0295569245,
-0.0310143624,
-0.0136708897,
0.0005110261,
0.0593940578,
-0.0311995316,
-0.0176393334,
0.0067283004,
-0.0098781055,
0.0159409847,
-0.0011980587,
-0.0423914753,
-0.0459269434,
0.0379018188,
0.025288865,
-0.0144520067,
-0.0367165506,
-0.0822005272,
-0.0475407802,
0.006665932,
-0.0268747024,
-0.0250012875,
-0.0076135285,
-0.0745799616,
-0.0030352881,
-0.0579851456,
-0.0201109592,
1.999049137e-34,
-0.0115926126,
0.0031599074,
-0.01892557,
0.0027387883,
0.0367804617,
-0.0264763143,
-0.0270360094,
-0.0117902951,
0.0057661589,
-0.0670564696,
-0.0166719165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12719v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12719v1 | Natural Language Generation for Advertising: A Survey | 2023-06-22T07:52:34 | 2023-06-22T07:52:34 | Soichiro Murakami, Sho Hoshino, Peinan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural language generation methods have emerged as effective tools to help
advertisers increase the number of online advertisements they produce. This
survey entails a review of the research trends on this topic over the past
decade, from template-based to extractive and abstractive approaches using
neural networks. Additionally, key challenges and directions revealed through
the survey, including metric optimization, faithfulness, diversity,
multimodality, and the development of benchmark datasets, are discussed. | [
0.079315871,
0.058951553,
-0.0082792416,
0.0158673692,
-0.0220409688,
-0.0132706892,
-0.0089861788,
-0.0206842441,
0.0215574168,
-0.0722665712,
-0.0031389829,
-0.082205072,
-0.0034604634,
0.0606450066,
0.015018017,
-0.0809728578,
-0.0291408505,
-0.0074185585,
0.0055764746,
0.0061873333,
-0.0065546934,
0.0390150361,
-0.0163944345,
0.045105435,
-0.0239872634,
-0.0398870893,
-0.0115669975,
-0.0101987142,
-0.0023333819,
-0.0269537959,
0.0124681294,
0.0036848921,
0.0133252423,
-0.0013575093,
0.0000016097,
-0.0666050091,
0.0092401328,
0.01783197,
0.026105063,
0.0025833773,
0.05007625,
-0.0115281362,
0.0104315691,
0.0144106438,
-0.0383802541,
0.0697614029,
0.0737287179,
0.0589272305,
0.038131088,
0.0837280601,
-0.0311914757,
-0.0384218842,
-0.0235028975,
-0.0221168362,
-0.0213229787,
0.0215009581,
-0.040255826,
-0.0284271725,
-0.0085355882,
-0.0219452046,
0.0097192749,
0.0314707793,
-0.0034901162,
-0.0102948835,
0.0150256259,
0.032514073,
-0.0227530152,
-0.0358307734,
-0.0445393845,
0.0387735963,
-0.0478856638,
0.021807367,
0.0147764338,
-0.0334232524,
0.0189677142,
-0.0397587754,
-0.0226081852,
0.0705031604,
-0.0211481377,
0.0441810079,
-0.0017840607,
0.0232998151,
-0.0047777332,
0.0031668164,
0.0094004637,
0.021838624,
0.0349560976,
-0.0225125924,
0.0113422992,
0.0212319959,
-0.0079571446,
-0.0173323583,
0.0279144477,
-0.0433669053,
0.0015003993,
0.0260545891,
-0.021117622,
-0.0183014646,
0.0259426888,
-0.0764359683,
0.0805625096,
-0.0159151871,
0.0018710654,
-0.0133763254,
-0.0417393297,
0.0640765056,
-0.0200043414,
-0.0125991926,
-0.0335145704,
0.0488680191,
-0.0544259213,
-0.0371582508,
-0.0392185152,
0.0460612401,
-0.0131015601,
-0.0306454189,
-0.092142649,
0.0216088612,
0.0200177487,
-0.0115231713,
0.0338047594,
0.0542303622,
-0.0108585414,
-0.0035396144,
-0.0176602751,
-0.0093019316,
-0.0103031611,
-0.0328298509,
0.0146500235,
-0.0312279407,
0.0544751585,
0.0849134028,
-0.0119517613,
-0.0185114816,
-0.0375274718,
0.067442067,
-0.0312458165,
0.0072577712,
-0.0540544316,
-0.0359369963,
-0.056996882,
-0.0351115391,
-0.0086185746,
-0.0252196789,
0.0383482203,
0.0046499469,
-0.02836743,
-0.0612277128,
0.0121679092,
-0.0040210849,
-0.042123761,
0.0165846683,
-0.0119339284,
0.0128186308,
0.0074064075,
-0.0461684316,
0.064366214,
0.0626821071,
0.0514819361,
0.0733166561,
0.0315905139,
0.0044552949,
-0.0231287964,
0.0206143223,
0.013639085,
-0.0456351042,
-0.0212586746,
0.0056541013,
-0.0412892625,
0.0106400149,
0.0050708796,
0.0634864792,
-0.0028664432,
0.0346725918,
0.086279422,
0.0010102136,
0.0450367704,
0.0243721809,
0.1050482169,
0.0527212918,
-0.0285908207,
0.0109194312,
0.000674452,
-0.0003847493,
0.0085931215,
0.0260601267,
0.0595712028,
0.0619770996,
-0.0135009205,
-0.0247430913,
-0.0160490461,
0.0021369469,
0.0515750796,
-0.0216300525,
0.0228820648,
0.0147281429,
-0.0573110133,
0.0482541882,
-0.0005862932,
-0.0082899667,
0.0219579823,
0.0119696092,
0.027087735,
0.057561554,
0.015812099,
0.0342302769,
-0.0210841764,
0.0049709179,
-0.0355187356,
0.0837281495,
0.0436669253,
0.0019256588,
0.0407907218,
-0.0386579148,
-0.037570864,
-0.0615756288,
0.0151241496,
0.0504973009,
-0.0205075908,
0.0425854698,
0.0661696196,
0.0317522623,
-0.0371725932,
0.0240585338,
0.0423964821,
-0.0345734023,
0.0514709167,
0.003838842,
0.020234758,
0.0198744778,
-0.0322008692,
0.0289683975,
-0.0290503036,
-0.0450263806,
-0.0383074656,
0.0226897094,
0.006684843,
-0.0319378413,
0.0167602021,
-0.0685227439,
0.0116459355,
-0.0031484053,
-0.0250738021,
-0.032089863,
0.0454264581,
-0.069765605,
0.0183849763,
-0.044768475,
-0.0154755302,
0.0435256474,
0.0404408537,
0.0117013939,
0.0437185466,
0.0342688859,
-0.0126116257,
0.0260116272,
-0.0188832451,
-0.0038227059,
-0.0619721934,
0.0375661403,
-0.0079958998,
-0.0154028721,
0.007823267,
0.0278375596,
0.08221481,
-0.0210438911,
-0.0166652557,
-0.055951912,
0.001675621,
0.0156296566,
0.0436056219,
-0.0093367407,
0.0262703486,
-0.0168454479,
-0.0209475961,
-0.0775847211,
-0.0331872851,
0.0077498551,
0.0215680897,
0.0329585746,
0.0170145743,
-0.0178528763,
0.0324527845,
0.0095727239,
0.0405153036,
0.0390651673,
0.0869479626,
-0.0515674017,
-0.0907587036,
-0.000276611,
-0.0482135005,
-0.0243857261,
0.0586670488,
-0.0023177548,
-0.0124167316,
0.0189069174,
0.0185291674,
-0.0075027002,
0.0715889558,
0.013080243,
0.018697843,
0.0130255967,
-0.0406173244,
0.0049827076,
-0.0570132472,
0.0457343124,
0.0331305563,
-0.0413556062,
0.1175959632,
0.0336667411,
0.0287537575,
-0.0009159159,
-0.0407384187,
0.0460849069,
-0.0071901828,
-0.0469514914,
-0.0615964793,
0.0090566352,
-0.016872026,
0.0430247933,
0.015207205,
-0.0624777563,
0.0432180054,
0.0022923627,
-0.0018331611,
-0.036514584,
-0.0118152043,
-0.0214907806,
-0.028735958,
-0.0159138646,
0.0621708594,
0.0306331795,
-0.0544515774,
-0.0151582221,
-0.0155453905,
0.0173199065,
-0.014902832,
0.0280388687,
-0.0197736807,
0.0056522381,
-0.0129715465,
-0.032083571,
-0.0776265115,
-0.0839199722,
0.0573727787,
-0.0013896817,
0.0581750534,
0.020619249,
-0.0335902981,
0.0516437516,
-0.0355415978,
0.0163043607,
-0.0279293824,
0.0057083247,
0.0176670495,
0.0866246074,
0.0696478859,
-0.0192481037,
-0.024051208,
-0.019658953,
-0.016436033,
-0.0021235924,
-0.0202263203,
0.0425385535,
-0.0416254103,
-0.008263913,
0.0091732433,
-0.0449407548,
-0.0084249377,
0.0468386598,
-0.0108661922,
0.0053940769,
0.0050946991,
0.069480285,
0.0117212897,
0.0157427061,
0.0143925855,
0.0094962288,
0.0116816005,
-0.0167941898,
0.0177609902,
-0.0492742136,
-0.0079654297,
-0.0536469072,
0.0369337611,
-0.0010187214,
0.0180544984,
-0.0396824032,
-0.083497256,
0.0557749756,
0.0233870111,
-0.0376807526,
-0.0168497525,
-0.0078992201,
-0.0618481375,
-0.0160800777,
0.0342738554,
-0.0122902021,
-0.03298999,
0.0200318787,
0.0292120688,
-0.0165774971,
-0.0624254644,
-0.0708127394,
-0.0064248475,
0.0133270118,
0.0382189937,
0.0422392227,
-0.0132639306,
-0.002963688,
-0.0178937912,
0.0044631478,
0.0299502648,
-0.0148939155,
0.0216963887,
-0.0059017618,
-0.020980332,
-0.0029110152,
0.0168597549,
-0.0048015411,
0.0386668555,
0.0182904489,
0.0020009845,
0.0037061758,
-0.039428778,
-0.0262161512,
0.0308236405,
0.0495216101,
0.0758831799,
0.0138651673,
-0.073157385,
-0.0068242806,
-0.025209751,
-0.0031252757,
-0.081743449,
-0.0005257688,
-0.0171135608,
-0.0432246849,
0.002331953,
-0.098345682,
-0.0167125016,
-0.0023024345,
0.0182974506,
0.0266022459,
-0.0187645778,
0.0146220941,
-0.0260380562,
-0.0326445475,
-0.0050722677,
-0.0169214383,
-0.025923416,
-0.0314434431,
-0.006862801,
0.0050918763,
-0.0927070528,
-0.0118706683,
0.0317203104,
-0.0610689521,
-0.0575089343,
-0.0366076194,
0.0525827967,
0.0084180608,
0.0618170612,
0.0214208923,
-0.0169401839,
0.0284976698,
0.0742437243,
0.0243036058,
-0.0470136926,
-0.0192174651,
0.0577679947,
-0.0076178377,
0.0171286855,
-0.0397747941,
0.0127441129,
0.0093234312,
0.0537816025,
0.0448943302,
-0.0057393364,
0.0406295098,
0.0493758209,
-0.0247252416,
-0.0985704809,
0.0392182991,
-0.0416317321,
0.0157904662,
-0.0068488731,
-0.0364868715,
-0.0883148983,
0.0393320061,
-0.0035212205,
0.0323390588,
-0.0021020144,
-0.0148554174,
-0.0397475921,
0.0306664146,
-0.0045798896,
-0.0277942978,
-0.0059819319,
0.0364708453,
0.0181430224,
-0.0094997035,
-0.0160718672,
0.0501654185,
0.0047106068,
0.0239158031,
-0.0057954849,
0.0342035629,
0.0189718716,
0.0264692586,
-0.0362101942,
0.0327777155,
0.0296615455,
-0.0005420969,
-0.0896303728,
-0.0137271173,
0.0442444347,
-0.0227555837,
0.0661276504,
-0.0647448525,
0.0172448307,
0.0132260686,
0.0635592788,
-0.0049541625,
-0.0381600596,
-0.0199363735,
-0.0164664052,
-0.0205968078,
-0.0543916523,
0.0792689025,
-0.0012079134,
-0.0231789164,
-0.0018808751,
-0.0442699715,
-0.0687022507,
-0.0091022914,
0.0459936708,
0.0113163693,
-0.0053358283,
-0.0165144075,
-0.0317337401,
-0.0376875177,
0.0104844822,
-0.0286137927,
0.0514611788,
0.0354247093,
0.0787173733,
0.0233498365,
-0.0088405767,
0.0262135584,
-0.0386887565,
0.0043649813,
-0.0446556024,
0.0159058478,
-0.0559085347,
-5.853822277e-33,
-0.0199630894,
-0.0265051797,
-0.0100049907,
-0.0406216718,
-0.0330037437,
-0.008523399,
0.0118696271,
-0.0183779299,
0.0695640892,
-0.0138556445,
0.014477035,
-0.0433345363,
0.0306049027,
0.0594824366,
0.0374013521,
-0.0113711068,
0.0335534662,
-0.0190315787,
-0.0374835171,
0.032167498,
0.03953363,
0.0082868626,
0.0363097191,
-0.0512851775,
0.0115030343,
-0.0025686035,
-0.0425239205,
-0.0167394988,
0.0439771414,
0.0372790359,
-0.0012345195,
0.0323746391,
0.0480744839,
-0.0147224525,
0.0030267949,
0.0060783629,
0.0195477102,
-0.0337633751,
0.0529488251,
0.0037514847,
-0.026211068,
-0.0084121572,
0.0461101867,
-0.0426210761,
-0.0161642302,
0.0558297597,
0.0395702608,
-0.044901941,
-0.0018988821,
-0.0666468665,
-0.0578538179,
0.0032282351,
-0.0354785696,
-0.0005806533,
0.0147283403,
0.0506545417,
-0.0318648778,
-0.0061809337,
0.0067693223,
0.0705814809,
0.009146234,
-0.0068179695,
0.0708848238,
0.0245153308,
0.0012738435,
0.0258021448,
0.0338367485,
-0.0224102437,
-0.0159829538,
0.0094745457,
-0.0448869467,
0.039476607,
-0.0087830545,
0.0406658202,
0.0408873856,
0.0138520682,
-0.0140717635,
0.0578777716,
0.0347769856,
-0.0676049367,
-0.0019756535,
-0.0462360419,
-0.0197746716,
-0.0131775402,
0.0006282548,
-0.0462183617,
-0.02263817,
-0.0575357713,
0.0334195308,
0.0037661297,
-0.0480738655,
0.0290978886,
0.0053942106,
-0.0159539618,
0.0077136531,
-0.0093996776,
-0.0045479485,
-0.0189128406,
-0.0346075296,
-0.0445306152,
-0.0054752924,
-0.0853465647,
0.0163497049,
0.0212497022,
-0.0296923723,
-0.0001161205,
0.0111552114,
0.0183565728,
-0.0292769372,
0.0341629945,
0.0189506449,
0.0054796762,
-0.0001767526,
0.0483528897,
0.0086230077,
-0.0322506577,
-0.052200418,
0.0097884713,
0.0183649249,
-0.0152645009,
0.0281030405,
-0.0247448143,
0.0474604294,
0.0738151297,
-0.0256801154,
0.0222516879,
-0.0302248634,
-0.056583073,
0.0394751653,
-0.0367023684,
-0.0387228429,
-0.001853563,
2.409e-7,
-0.0089400858,
0.0457136594,
0.0062214681,
-0.0103608556,
0.0302776787,
0.0121369092,
0.0191699564,
0.0381147638,
0.0047200802,
0.0207906514,
-0.006926971,
-0.0471091047,
0.0340666883,
-0.0160923153,
-0.0879785866,
0.0723687708,
-0.0503659509,
-0.0116844308,
-0.0505574159,
0.0187553465,
0.0323277526,
0.0266170483,
-0.0032977073,
-0.0266099107,
-0.0260166898,
-0.0361320078,
0.0433785394,
0.005361788,
-0.0120750489,
0.0195328165,
0.0068840594,
0.0188543592,
-0.0393376984,
-0.0120085748,
-0.0053528836,
0.011131851,
0.0521324873,
0.0148003874,
0.0352578051,
-0.0026244391,
-0.0149576096,
-0.0175690465,
-0.0209531728,
-0.0112589169,
-0.0069449544,
-0.0657595098,
-0.041968476,
-0.0643017441,
0.0019137543,
-0.0048693405,
0.0080102812,
-0.0910047516,
0.00566296,
0.0167614799,
0.0124250669,
-0.0104004527,
-0.0073768348,
0.0124270665,
-0.0040517491,
-0.0334337205,
-0.0182124004,
0.0163395666,
-0.0251937862,
0.067296043,
0.0475571975,
-0.0685336962,
-0.0028476836,
1.689406361e-34,
0.0433102474,
-0.0073184012,
0.0006625485,
-0.0045633721,
0.0037139468,
0.0046945415,
-0.0223994162,
0.0002084409,
0.0115973009,
-0.0397373624,
-0.0331370085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12693v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12693v1 | Multilingual Neural Machine Translation System for Indic to Indic Languages | 2023-06-22T06:44:09 | 2023-06-22T06:44:09 | Sudhansu Bala Das, Divyajyoti Panda, Tapas Kumar Mishra, Bidyut Kr. Patra, Asif Ekbal | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper gives an Indic-to-Indic (IL-IL) MNMT baseline model for 11 ILs
implemented on the Samanantar corpus and analyzed on the Flores-200 corpus. All
the models are evaluated using the BLEU score. In addition, the languages are
classified under three groups namely East Indo- Aryan (EI), Dravidian (DR), and
West Indo-Aryan (WI). The effect of language relatedness on MNMT model
efficiency is studied. Owing to the presence of large corpora from English (EN)
to ILs, MNMT IL-IL models using EN as a pivot are also built and examined. To
achieve this, English- Indic (EN-IL) models are also developed, with and
without the usage of related languages. Results reveal that using related
languages is beneficial for the WI group only, while it is detrimental for the
EI group and shows an inconclusive effect on the DR group, but it is useful for
EN-IL models. Thus, related language groups are used to develop pivot MNMT
models. Furthermore, the IL corpora are transliterated from the corresponding
scripts to a modified ITRANS script, and the best MNMT models from the previous
approaches are built on the transliterated corpus. It is observed that the
usage of pivot models greatly improves MNMT baselines with AS-TA achieving the
minimum BLEU score and PA-HI achieving the maximum score. Among languages, AS,
ML, and TA achieve the lowest BLEU score, whereas HI, PA, and GU perform the
best. Transliteration also helps the models with few exceptions. The best
increment of scores is observed in ML, TA, and BN and the worst average
increment is observed in KN, HI, and PA, across all languages. The best model
obtained is the PA-HI language pair trained on PAWI transliterated corpus which
gives 24.29 BLEU. | [
0.0113833304,
-0.0250535142,
-0.0101371603,
0.0370745324,
-0.057482373,
0.0083946064,
0.0114231883,
0.0182845984,
-0.0387018435,
-0.0244231373,
-0.0556709208,
-0.0566612147,
0.0602121316,
-0.029985033,
0.0507732816,
0.0018929567,
-0.0005509132,
-0.0312063806,
-0.0460105725,
0.0223159771,
-0.0003793271,
0.0215885174,
0.0057179308,
0.0136617953,
-0.0370725729,
0.0161113217,
0.0309394225,
0.0455366895,
0.0130709996,
-0.0409340262,
-0.0517041609,
0.0299876686,
0.0013124795,
0.0265175775,
0.0000021099,
-0.0326947235,
-0.0337784849,
-0.0037554319,
0.0369236618,
-0.0311302692,
0.0656297505,
-0.0361493118,
-0.0016478653,
0.0359323546,
0.005690536,
0.0169726815,
0.0718474165,
0.0222213492,
0.0477894098,
0.0942864195,
-0.0228579286,
-0.058558438,
0.0330459811,
-0.0014995886,
-0.0384873785,
-0.0256809201,
-0.0200340394,
0.0122062489,
-0.0590914935,
-0.019010352,
-0.0226829238,
0.0251194183,
-0.0158945657,
-0.0012273083,
-0.0102829365,
-0.0124658104,
0.0124607282,
-0.024295168,
0.0244997106,
0.0326304138,
-0.0694661885,
-0.0108594541,
-0.0284168627,
0.0258272905,
-0.0201955736,
-0.0137452325,
-0.0543148331,
-0.0008716518,
-0.0384137146,
0.04275674,
0.0612118877,
0.0332316682,
0.0206411574,
-0.0135045117,
-0.0274534486,
-0.0064212466,
0.0246571358,
-0.0421906896,
0.005037677,
-0.0213625152,
0.0369312279,
0.0278208219,
0.0340053961,
0.0263143033,
-0.0099491011,
0.0323144794,
0.0059077772,
-0.0574966334,
-0.0132136419,
-0.0753179118,
0.0244317222,
0.0718254149,
-0.0005449249,
-0.0019805233,
-0.0078560747,
0.0658520237,
-0.005077187,
0.0081016738,
-0.045626346,
-0.0433885939,
-0.0075301798,
0.0001928653,
-0.0353024676,
0.0218598638,
-0.0118073104,
0.0361103527,
-0.0385540165,
-0.0102156205,
0.0488258526,
-0.0475388356,
0.0327878967,
-0.0763302743,
-0.0633439124,
-0.0284681898,
-0.0039413143,
0.0507072657,
0.0019203862,
-0.0225113463,
-0.0293993037,
-0.0778645799,
-0.0033942049,
0.0139399329,
-0.060726732,
-0.0456508473,
-0.0113720773,
0.0645019189,
-0.0386319943,
-0.0375919975,
-0.0579727665,
0.0500030257,
-0.0012770826,
-0.0547387935,
0.0083660139,
-0.0557890274,
0.0915500969,
0.0232639164,
0.0231414791,
-0.0260961819,
-0.0043646158,
-0.0000187477,
-0.0177516155,
0.0350240543,
0.0229554046,
0.0180487335,
0.055943232,
-0.0099676987,
0.0348930508,
0.0403004512,
0.0593758859,
-0.0065009524,
0.0140237408,
-0.051853057,
-0.0064050602,
0.0616045818,
-0.0156870428,
0.0154898865,
-0.051839795,
0.0035077506,
-0.020802673,
0.056740962,
-0.014890179,
0.0692670345,
-0.0082049472,
0.0347428732,
0.0198404081,
0.0437702313,
0.0443068221,
0.0590565242,
0.0157439876,
-0.0027927854,
0.002829209,
-0.0015205997,
0.0109330984,
0.0256122425,
-0.0508266054,
-0.0137718385,
0.052047614,
0.0627415925,
-0.0161331855,
0.0028208247,
-0.0070248083,
-0.0473283231,
-0.0005718633,
-0.0724724233,
0.0587417074,
-0.0274536759,
-0.0452188738,
0.0340935662,
0.0157457143,
-0.0410544425,
0.0368629768,
-0.0293662231,
-0.0274735,
0.0266302861,
0.0171321109,
0.0004155817,
-0.0268955734,
-0.0121503025,
-0.0556195639,
0.0567211099,
0.023498144,
0.0061501889,
0.0020625074,
-0.0787662193,
0.0214868449,
0.0656000748,
-0.0239263326,
0.0608362071,
-0.0679708719,
0.0427872688,
0.0199699886,
-0.0049993461,
-0.0237330887,
0.0249860771,
-0.0606219172,
0.0241933446,
-0.0028893971,
0.0041209534,
0.0601325259,
0.0235107467,
0.0045320629,
-0.0052532689,
0.0094468007,
-0.0245574899,
-0.0117534623,
0.0261158179,
-0.0396946259,
-0.005652694,
0.0410529934,
-0.0436460376,
0.0399235673,
0.007528787,
0.0069095073,
-0.0873580351,
-0.0102503775,
-0.0128510147,
-0.0470747091,
-0.0184635557,
0.0747587532,
-0.0151578281,
-0.0470923893,
-0.0496939644,
0.0358518437,
-0.0162465274,
0.0075863893,
0.0240522493,
-0.0527121127,
0.0746519938,
-0.0578436144,
-0.006022336,
0.0796828493,
0.0454108529,
0.0288273562,
0.0208085328,
-0.002438002,
0.0025988217,
-0.0626663938,
-0.0511279181,
-0.0067029637,
-0.0082433308,
0.02810736,
-0.0020626138,
0.0486543439,
0.0073450198,
-0.0041150041,
-0.0187101308,
0.0099782301,
0.0163732152,
-0.0126747508,
0.0257013403,
-0.0044417223,
0.0457229279,
-0.0276418868,
-0.0301312394,
0.0038063242,
0.0383856855,
0.0063865138,
-0.0714131221,
-0.0654455423,
-0.0038894056,
-0.0334173441,
0.0056322464,
-0.0282602124,
-0.0550409034,
0.0271654557,
-0.0428473055,
0.0316635743,
-0.0255617704,
0.0144056687,
-0.0240324102,
-0.0119481217,
-0.0180223398,
-0.040307384,
-0.0082723405,
0.0170890857,
0.0222829226,
-0.044441808,
-0.0680105835,
0.000906668,
0.0554112904,
0.002169237,
-0.0036252358,
-0.0620934553,
-0.0137379244,
-0.0394572839,
0.0278575253,
0.0061849593,
0.0584399067,
-0.0036276791,
0.0383457765,
-0.0000598321,
-0.0306433402,
0.0395102911,
-0.0636096299,
-0.0077038379,
-0.0968283564,
0.0253910888,
-0.0532619134,
0.0091079185,
-0.0254766308,
-0.0174404047,
-0.0089632068,
-0.0442859046,
-0.0381239876,
0.0386634991,
-0.0301137529,
-0.0304378942,
0.0363368616,
-0.0312795714,
0.0090333261,
-0.0450850017,
0.0203430019,
0.0048286272,
-0.0186502896,
0.018810669,
-0.0013267747,
0.0383974984,
-0.0002305893,
0.0215169266,
0.1079026163,
0.0018835058,
0.0085484786,
-0.0163998771,
0.0419344231,
0.0027662853,
-0.0047748163,
-0.0037557948,
-0.0087853614,
-0.0153937368,
0.0127317449,
0.0395466797,
-0.0532411635,
-0.0129382312,
-0.0225496087,
-0.0246218648,
-0.0196328983,
0.0423581786,
0.0072340458,
-0.056521412,
-0.0168948006,
0.0010912204,
0.003389173,
0.0130491117,
0.103535682,
0.0326047912,
-0.0420965105,
-0.0230440255,
-0.0236009341,
-0.0101615433,
-0.0084833009,
0.0192352403,
-0.0141115757,
0.0031152049,
-0.0006707879,
0.0161169767,
0.0290114228,
-0.0097206142,
-0.0295482278,
-0.1019236073,
-0.0461106338,
0.0493587181,
-0.0631047785,
-0.0804066509,
-0.0057608085,
-0.0519560464,
-0.0251673982,
0.0339204185,
0.0530564971,
0.0128000909,
-0.0202637631,
0.0221378747,
0.0074236151,
-0.0620895773,
-0.0353609063,
-0.0243060477,
0.0071353321,
0.0400568843,
0.0309026111,
-0.0705273896,
-0.0073075844,
0.0366144367,
-0.0171365738,
0.0101736514,
-0.0357987583,
0.0164910983,
-0.0115201855,
0.0006460022,
0.0046775797,
-0.0170152243,
-0.0056760754,
0.0369206667,
-0.0054098489,
0.0205410793,
-0.0177940279,
0.0030588517,
0.0229630861,
-0.034464255,
-0.0069868285,
0.0053485534,
-0.0087720063,
-0.0557315014,
0.0316821747,
-0.0138157327,
0.0016572175,
-0.035417337,
0.0367783457,
0.0156753901,
-0.0600603372,
-0.0401223116,
-0.076778993,
-0.0767126828,
-0.0075186621,
0.0389886685,
0.0490026362,
0.0318778269,
0.0368808918,
0.0060250578,
0.0371409096,
0.0001905752,
-0.0047731278,
-0.0014396488,
-0.0777939409,
0.0181071367,
0.0555309616,
-0.031488087,
0.0248732846,
-0.0211995766,
-0.0042544161,
-0.0602283478,
-0.0463730022,
0.0454187691,
0.0200407021,
0.0021647678,
-0.0256663635,
-0.0423294604,
0.0231822617,
-0.0301634166,
0.014231435,
-0.0273757372,
-0.0006908931,
-0.0029113938,
-0.0192046482,
0.0162406005,
-0.0114724236,
0.0273695234,
-0.0179043431,
0.04595441,
-0.0086564217,
-0.0300857686,
0.033714246,
0.0358336531,
0.0024215267,
-0.0690016523,
0.0186203085,
-0.026252389,
0.0074339849,
-0.0196131747,
-0.0079745399,
-0.0330987424,
-0.0025313813,
0.0983498469,
0.0253225118,
-0.015079271,
-0.067333065,
-0.0142575596,
-0.0245170798,
0.0107263001,
0.0017807151,
-0.0236369073,
0.0937918052,
0.0198617727,
0.0168695301,
-0.038720943,
-0.0173666514,
-0.0367404595,
-0.0097569255,
-0.0146392649,
0.0885288417,
-0.0109299468,
0.0271303318,
0.0565005876,
0.0631873086,
0.0688683763,
0.0467240848,
-0.0106190899,
0.0055197976,
0.067277737,
0.0440274067,
0.1030754969,
-0.0111412257,
0.024078276,
-0.0180925466,
0.0353825167,
0.0348809101,
0.0363324694,
0.0256205872,
0.0008780838,
0.005971083,
-0.0018999948,
0.050119251,
-0.0139375804,
-0.0598095842,
0.0009097393,
-0.0056504183,
-0.0259799268,
0.0357119888,
-0.0279470775,
-0.0222553238,
0.0033040547,
-0.0012743355,
-0.0355882458,
-0.0186681189,
0.0306767114,
-0.0131765129,
0.0290778242,
-0.0321812257,
0.0122713018,
0.0661155879,
-0.0054536052,
0.0391145274,
-0.0161570404,
0.0080942828,
-0.0443430431,
-0.0103189088,
-0.0458188057,
-5.937102746e-33,
-0.0724040493,
0.0300087128,
0.0348799229,
-0.0076964367,
-0.015373488,
-0.0651842654,
-0.0070826407,
-0.0215833988,
0.0014783619,
-0.022741599,
-0.0061337906,
0.0050363699,
0.0121518839,
-0.0074505419,
0.0121937785,
0.0167929698,
0.0131067308,
0.0028892099,
-0.0352853239,
0.0067914617,
0.046841383,
0.0359572545,
0.1261066347,
-0.0380446389,
0.0075889677,
-0.0712827444,
0.0238164403,
0.0474866033,
-0.0293248836,
-0.0211409405,
0.0209059883,
-0.0044505042,
0.0411538668,
-0.0161138959,
-0.0021573941,
-0.0235351007,
-0.037024606,
0.0199064724,
0.0280054398,
0.0890675411,
0.0423371345,
-0.0372512825,
0.0610403903,
-0.0399899073,
-0.0197574571,
0.0097591504,
0.0016970468,
-0.0287280381,
-0.0227577332,
0.0019455461,
-0.0608789697,
0.0463957153,
0.0267828647,
-0.0386983752,
0.0140333036,
0.0678414702,
-0.020851111,
-0.0101222657,
-0.0779919326,
-0.0128464382,
-0.0018653932,
0.0368229449,
0.0424646959,
0.0307708662,
-0.0330628976,
-0.032914985,
0.0271953586,
-0.0228902902,
0.0733418018,
0.0312679671,
0.0274954494,
-0.0094247675,
0.0608296767,
0.0051613706,
0.0447961465,
-0.0348676592,
-0.0204520747,
0.0294583347,
0.0311299153,
0.0310519971,
0.0211592764,
-0.0019938052,
-0.0210985541,
-0.0284593496,
0.0186009072,
-0.083138302,
-0.003045684,
-0.0401126407,
0.0262037404,
-0.040184252,
0.0092233811,
0.0080501186,
0.0920843929,
-0.0023736681,
0.0229059812,
0.0087998239,
-0.0365653001,
0.0423880108,
-0.0340599008,
0.0458059683,
-0.0258036144,
-0.0727735385,
0.0001186428,
0.0250711087,
0.0017545394,
0.0011322857,
0.0042750603,
0.0184987392,
-0.0082522426,
-0.0290110782,
-0.0189259443,
-0.0065422296,
0.0060166446,
0.0365779363,
-0.01300372,
-0.0082394714,
0.0021058926,
0.0068674996,
0.0637026876,
-0.0305639785,
0.0003176714,
-0.012715376,
0.0586990155,
-0.0068068178,
-0.0084178066,
0.0454795621,
-0.0137710376,
0.0089034848,
0.0460865386,
-0.0118048796,
-0.016497435,
0.0281832274,
2.972e-7,
0.0320995487,
0.0408053733,
0.0232873838,
-0.0373093076,
-0.0092699071,
0.0061001261,
-0.080826439,
0.0102391746,
0.0406563096,
0.0753624961,
0.011230872,
-0.0242299363,
0.0579685681,
0.0605524704,
-0.0645015985,
-0.050238952,
-0.0227027498,
0.0521173105,
-0.0381429605,
0.0386239216,
-0.0006131219,
0.0619170964,
-0.0101617109,
-0.0284189731,
-0.0250543635,
-0.0493870378,
0.0425090678,
-0.0014801476,
-0.0220953878,
0.0286131203,
0.0546381138,
0.0021507395,
-0.044964049,
0.0144713214,
0.0073558427,
0.0511967838,
0.091580756,
0.0402513705,
-0.0128029902,
0.0039307559,
0.0519280471,
-0.0127114588,
-0.026854232,
-0.0300416518,
0.017610766,
0.013264562,
-0.0372963585,
0.0180994496,
-0.0103974901,
0.0196364764,
0.0189034138,
-0.0238508992,
-0.0046542929,
0.010878847,
0.0517746098,
-0.038349703,
-0.0122526409,
0.0049393293,
-0.0494144224,
0.0099564223,
-0.0035252061,
-0.0748283416,
0.0101080704,
-0.0482073128,
0.0301788729,
0.0068347314,
-0.0177760571,
2.294608365e-34,
0.0407267213,
-0.0443598032,
0.0421500131,
-0.0072970516,
0.0246434882,
-0.0257546715,
-0.041804757,
0.0301314611,
-0.0329849049,
-0.0532456785,
-0.0313523263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12689v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12689v1 | Vec2Vec: A Compact Neural Network Approach for Transforming Text Embeddings with High Fidelity | 2023-06-22T06:23:31 | 2023-06-22T06:23:31 | Andrew Kean Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG, I.2.7; D.2.12 | Vector embeddings have become ubiquitous tools for many language-related
tasks. A leading embedding model is OpenAI's text-ada-002 which can embed
approximately 6,000 words into a 1,536-dimensional vector. While powerful,
text-ada-002 is not open source and is only available via API. We trained a
simple neural network to convert open-source 768-dimensional MPNet embeddings
into text-ada-002 embeddings. We compiled a subset of 50,000 online food
reviews. We calculated MPNet and text-ada-002 embeddings for each review and
trained a simple neural network to for 75 epochs. The neural network was
designed to predict the corresponding text-ada-002 embedding for a given MPNET
embedding. Our model achieved an average cosine similarity of 0.932 on 10,000
unseen reviews in our held-out test dataset. We manually assessed the quality
of our predicted embeddings for vector search over text-ada-002-embedded
reviews. While not as good as real text-ada-002 embeddings, predicted
embeddings were able to retrieve highly relevant reviews. Our final model,
Vec2Vec, is lightweight (<80 MB) and fast. Future steps include training a
neural network with a more sophisticated architecture and a larger dataset of
paired embeddings to achieve greater performance. The ability to convert
between and align embedding spaces may be helpful for interoperability,
limiting dependence on proprietary models, protecting data privacy, reducing
costs, and offline operations. | [
0.0394961461,
0.0607048459,
0.0009105995,
0.0287929159,
0.0113921249,
-0.0012252684,
-0.0171230938,
0.0281501617,
-0.0028458354,
-0.0423956215,
0.00484691,
-0.0121556455,
-0.026100425,
0.0538353063,
-0.007452094,
0.0126625635,
0.0404325128,
0.0420235731,
0.0079223849,
0.043413803,
0.0160745457,
0.0237362441,
0.0218715016,
0.068504937,
-0.008643114,
0.0033063435,
0.0258509163,
-0.0097119017,
0.0326179788,
-0.0340338238,
0.0149825132,
0.0113995159,
0.0203944873,
0.0189939737,
0.0000020575,
0.0515486784,
0.0231587328,
0.0049240845,
0.0019853672,
0.0295399856,
0.0520595126,
-0.0397619829,
0.0167930499,
0.0045112283,
-0.0345904417,
-0.0615790486,
0.0478256196,
0.0768042281,
0.0098815914,
0.0542642586,
-0.0104761505,
-0.0547069088,
-0.0060506123,
-0.0235610362,
-0.0296616685,
0.009413206,
0.0173393283,
-0.0225984212,
-0.0002217915,
0.0733591989,
0.014780215,
0.0385165252,
0.0023373971,
-0.0222249012,
0.0207388718,
0.0477358736,
0.0018809895,
-0.0094244126,
0.0232075788,
0.0844700933,
-0.0411977731,
-0.0301025305,
-0.0232403353,
-0.0017645938,
-0.0407481343,
0.0054242378,
-0.0402890183,
-0.0397132337,
0.0382087901,
0.0638359711,
-0.0135763139,
0.0232688859,
0.0453564115,
-0.0061359657,
0.0385831892,
0.029957734,
0.0012698183,
-0.0219578482,
0.0154810427,
0.0161781255,
0.003556411,
-0.0084804473,
0.0307567604,
-0.0270838886,
0.0378254019,
0.0076134587,
0.012342032,
-0.0525758602,
0.0338257365,
-0.1094713956,
0.0708783641,
-0.006768798,
-0.0393656641,
0.0169589017,
-0.0708111599,
0.0065264204,
-0.0321005024,
0.0300436653,
-0.08564841,
0.047170572,
-0.0636787042,
-0.0258710589,
-0.0132581778,
0.0244053435,
-0.0201895498,
-0.0697717071,
-0.0336350612,
-0.0010967911,
-0.0263230894,
0.0021984831,
0.0106060151,
0.0744428188,
0.0265024155,
0.0259674434,
-0.0244973227,
0.036961548,
-0.0362734906,
0.0224067084,
-0.0486170687,
0.0213422664,
-0.025756795,
0.015472319,
0.0318380147,
0.0074957251,
0.0124132624,
0.0271288957,
-0.0013266699,
-0.0679777712,
0.0063959956,
-0.0169760473,
-0.0554644465,
-0.0305631738,
-0.0162495729,
-0.0456947088,
0.0555520244,
-0.0242432151,
-0.0035728002,
-0.0223826803,
0.0136520304,
0.058794301,
-0.0548651181,
0.0934025571,
0.0352930836,
-0.0264088623,
-0.0107263727,
0.0227786675,
0.0425487086,
0.0310553294,
-0.0038940338,
0.0370144136,
0.0378385112,
0.0118898768,
-0.0077274819,
-0.0162744857,
0.0150493719,
-0.0188286807,
-0.0430983268,
0.0355144329,
-0.0300873686,
0.0529175214,
0.0126406699,
0.0554122739,
-0.0182497706,
-0.0188113488,
0.0983838215,
0.0500350483,
0.0129771167,
0.0482477918,
0.0299255606,
0.0197982602,
-0.0210230984,
-0.0310596731,
-0.0112107797,
0.054486271,
-0.0415086187,
-0.0090255821,
0.0040790839,
-0.0128368987,
-0.0357827507,
-0.0173368845,
-0.0009856381,
-0.0420889221,
0.0428524204,
-0.0372010022,
0.0303156748,
-0.0036040253,
-0.0504754707,
0.000640567,
-0.0006313251,
-0.0516571328,
-0.0042039012,
-0.0039106035,
0.0459142178,
0.071049422,
0.0741264597,
0.0043312437,
0.0178420898,
-0.0209342595,
-0.0148420716,
0.0127758775,
0.0517848395,
-0.0345570073,
-0.0349644125,
-0.056893453,
-0.0214098617,
-0.0268512182,
0.0191131178,
0.0011519226,
0.0014962497,
0.0619781837,
0.0349279195,
-0.0172282401,
-0.0183651913,
0.0309358742,
0.0227555092,
-0.0254444927,
0.0100577604,
0.0043334393,
0.0118017234,
0.0529896431,
0.0104070725,
0.0446686968,
0.0504047573,
-0.0595116764,
-0.0817310214,
-0.0011224706,
-0.0015934828,
-0.0119544743,
0.0077240919,
-0.0751921758,
0.0438987315,
0.0599135198,
-0.0141140157,
-0.0241414905,
-0.0162085071,
0.0069205486,
0.0501377918,
-0.0259654429,
-0.0178775936,
-0.0088891024,
0.0456743613,
0.0044657635,
0.0198521558,
-0.0072580297,
0.0242801476,
-0.0356105119,
-0.0542249531,
-0.0124025382,
0.0079617416,
-0.0556790009,
-0.0042272545,
0.0350111611,
0.0076109064,
0.0020391385,
0.042670913,
-0.0013450674,
-0.0165573955,
-0.0990673453,
0.0091004586,
0.0161284283,
-0.0061405525,
0.0218660757,
-0.0339505933,
0.0356879793,
-0.0025686079,
-0.0426960066,
0.0240873136,
-0.0534492992,
0.0431976393,
0.0038027025,
0.0214180965,
0.0023638394,
-0.0618810728,
-0.024243135,
-0.0125412038,
0.0593470372,
-0.0323585682,
-0.0414917432,
-0.043989446,
-0.0214526933,
-0.0394925401,
0.0061685704,
0.0096162679,
-0.0393744968,
-0.0296415519,
-0.0093813622,
-0.0116686337,
0.0046945303,
0.0002002746,
0.0203240439,
0.0675982907,
0.0087819342,
-0.0414007418,
-0.0116220564,
-0.0467523597,
0.0374455452,
0.0071168565,
0.0127414642,
0.0200207885,
0.0220439602,
0.0221406743,
-0.0097878249,
-0.0431440249,
-0.0113011831,
-0.0371562392,
0.0012655979,
-0.0473055691,
-0.0350569524,
0.0046939752,
-0.0001644721,
0.0004127825,
-0.0007667365,
0.0598634183,
-0.0196497738,
0.0246217288,
-0.0464262627,
-0.0221103616,
0.0019798328,
0.0432018898,
0.0154756419,
0.040535327,
-0.0373765081,
0.0299865045,
-0.0040352806,
0.0271411315,
-0.0160083491,
-0.0506900996,
0.0894358754,
0.0071292766,
0.0101124039,
-0.0042838133,
-0.0507395901,
0.0035319219,
-0.0493488573,
-0.039467182,
-0.0026668541,
0.0529095419,
-0.0201164465,
-0.0446681306,
0.0551247522,
-0.0415046774,
0.0453023762,
0.0006222288,
-0.0263534375,
0.0001062857,
0.0479928702,
0.0730824396,
-0.0292671137,
-0.0055210222,
0.0201951955,
0.0420466922,
0.0551552027,
-0.0114420382,
-0.0040736892,
-0.0492206365,
-0.0517105237,
0.0025252437,
-0.0229549054,
-0.0021207463,
-0.0231000725,
-0.0263754111,
-0.0079417061,
-0.0234482419,
0.077532351,
0.0382296965,
-0.1158085689,
-0.0020299214,
0.0289321318,
-0.0386778675,
0.0059974743,
0.027476918,
-0.07868471,
-0.0153462784,
-0.0058581866,
-0.0084135504,
0.0040241191,
0.004518413,
-0.0201979298,
-0.0806161091,
-0.0050109909,
-0.0032599517,
-0.0005176159,
-0.1058698818,
-0.0409077704,
-0.0005400048,
-0.0166232679,
0.0218220036,
-0.0170653816,
-0.005414627,
-0.0118794804,
-0.023075616,
-0.0027959892,
-0.040214926,
0.0353601798,
-0.0250018723,
0.063248992,
0.0603052899,
0.0608123988,
-0.0073700137,
-0.0282245018,
0.0135087138,
-0.04858201,
-0.0125421872,
-0.0177085251,
0.0929578096,
-0.0267070439,
0.0115546472,
-0.0143083455,
-0.0134542994,
-0.0399794541,
0.0075410926,
-0.0050979033,
0.0758494139,
0.0015188003,
-0.0403407291,
-0.0559304804,
0.0238536168,
-0.0188959092,
0.0564897768,
0.0130988546,
-0.0425692759,
-0.0048337439,
0.0189960729,
-0.0285009854,
-0.0075857132,
-0.021462867,
0.0138688236,
-0.0049611279,
-0.0091868062,
-0.0766273439,
0.0071533564,
0.0140555305,
0.0233632922,
0.0456571653,
0.0122740129,
0.0192326196,
-0.0211238153,
-0.0333856158,
0.0148322275,
-0.0019424453,
0.0139574287,
-0.0015886599,
0.0269436296,
0.0974735096,
-0.0010352269,
-0.0195254944,
-0.0266432408,
-0.0536791496,
-0.0293431506,
-0.0466037467,
0.0496232882,
0.0066643604,
0.0286905952,
-0.0258179475,
-0.0467007905,
0.036757417,
0.0214035399,
-0.031888634,
-0.0449931733,
-0.0016760476,
0.0099021122,
0.0182122774,
0.027725663,
-0.0447143279,
0.0169873144,
-0.0207589027,
0.0155410683,
0.0115294456,
-0.0426181629,
0.0281615406,
-0.0440830365,
0.0322652459,
0.0155415209,
0.0411301181,
-0.0799163431,
0.0329439528,
-0.0490572564,
0.012350183,
-0.0434725098,
0.0076377122,
0.0414022058,
0.0238222517,
-0.0597454086,
0.0039088875,
0.0034282992,
0.0546456128,
-0.0535907,
0.0184870157,
0.0165714789,
0.0115450975,
-0.0022774078,
0.0072487779,
-0.034561526,
0.0045978362,
-0.0286929011,
-0.0133100357,
-0.0631372482,
0.0171207711,
0.0195188597,
-0.0100933407,
-0.0618078113,
0.0828009173,
-0.0217630826,
-0.0032245251,
-0.0472629592,
-0.0058309021,
0.0120197395,
-0.0685795322,
0.0541866757,
-0.0473454967,
-0.0175925326,
0.0042268406,
0.0175840445,
-0.0289467759,
0.010966205,
0.0747270063,
0.0240576677,
-0.0066415318,
0.0049034441,
0.0718086883,
-0.0298668873,
0.0320810117,
-0.0010798896,
-0.0608638376,
-0.0291512571,
0.0109570269,
0.021837635,
0.0650489777,
-0.0555211492,
-0.042774979,
-0.0151051898,
-0.0398517996,
0.0035812596,
-0.0011240726,
-0.0265369266,
0.0017075748,
0.0289791748,
0.0426401496,
0.0505299084,
-0.0004907947,
-0.0278175697,
0.0098564029,
-0.0171466339,
-0.0480030514,
-0.0259965491,
-6.293211045e-33,
0.0167818423,
-0.0311826523,
-0.0385361724,
-0.0037466115,
-0.0327448174,
0.0257381797,
-0.0241709724,
-0.0097034359,
-0.0144015532,
0.0405980423,
0.0170381013,
0.0181994699,
0.001265047,
-0.0013748867,
0.0282211713,
-0.0346709341,
0.0473899804,
-0.014257635,
0.0502284765,
0.0274061803,
0.0175871514,
0.0352046676,
-0.0020841458,
-0.0768053234,
0.034668617,
0.017500937,
-0.0084988987,
-0.0068717944,
0.0157696232,
0.0684335306,
-0.0539594963,
0.0827371851,
0.0399223603,
0.0162217114,
0.0060789003,
0.0290174149,
-0.0571807399,
0.0158061478,
-0.0364471637,
-0.0235219505,
-0.0370842852,
0.001354487,
0.0288128499,
0.008971978,
-0.0307036955,
0.0534516014,
0.0495249964,
-0.0257636942,
-0.043464236,
-0.0261481293,
-0.0543538257,
-0.0017964237,
-0.0002672775,
0.0088375276,
0.0608999506,
0.0477527678,
0.0312508121,
0.0470391363,
-0.0889565125,
0.0043026735,
-0.0546392463,
0.0431949496,
0.0067949952,
-0.0115310233,
-0.0202098936,
0.0843835622,
-0.0282014646,
-0.0362418257,
-0.022859551,
0.0083313342,
0.0116018457,
0.0077608945,
0.0633165687,
0.0171284843,
0.039972946,
-0.0889359564,
-0.0227903072,
0.02151368,
0.013225208,
-0.0133907665,
0.0601772517,
0.0120212054,
-0.0275619738,
0.0055023194,
0.0126517117,
-0.0481136739,
-0.0588533357,
-0.0656573176,
0.017547572,
0.0331168249,
-0.0256725624,
-0.030111488,
-0.0144407004,
-0.0478999577,
0.0060877763,
0.025824165,
-0.0075278231,
0.0017620138,
-0.0129720112,
-0.0186828133,
-0.0554469898,
-0.0322831683,
-0.0362604782,
-0.0071544368,
0.00183013,
-0.0264711492,
0.0644308105,
0.0212455299,
-0.0809144378,
-0.0188038312,
-0.0040455735,
-0.0348108113,
0.034231063,
0.0632658452,
0.0081726648,
-0.0079845982,
0.0015698025,
0.0567835495,
0.0358951688,
0.0418015979,
0.0119131049,
-0.0280028731,
0.041350387,
-0.0194519795,
-0.018520752,
-0.012896697,
-0.031323988,
0.0108279791,
0.0105819702,
-0.0994235128,
-0.0080799842,
0.037228696,
2.757e-7,
0.0582765602,
0.0541284084,
-0.0002143413,
-0.0674102753,
0.0335592479,
0.0145722479,
0.0447843783,
0.0324309692,
-0.0422573984,
0.0103615588,
0.0401950441,
-0.0090394476,
0.0045523341,
0.0410354137,
-0.0751963109,
0.0429036953,
-0.104357712,
-0.0155707467,
-0.0347946063,
-0.0365025848,
0.0487749763,
0.0969769508,
0.0278601144,
0.0205502268,
-0.0184855983,
-0.0207411833,
0.0490988791,
-0.0377817675,
-0.0047190227,
-0.0363492593,
0.0219537579,
0.0192163158,
-0.0289404634,
-0.0449484475,
-0.0425906964,
0.0164810885,
0.0449841172,
0.0483183637,
0.0095565422,
-0.0311648995,
0.0023395068,
-0.0170786195,
0.0134834656,
-0.046758946,
0.0703405887,
-0.0554368831,
-0.022879174,
-0.0671831146,
0.0269160569,
0.0139355399,
0.0573086739,
-0.0196659248,
-0.0009199909,
0.0291404128,
0.0263186451,
-0.0118224425,
0.0022739025,
-0.0903068706,
-0.0058189677,
0.0190731846,
-0.011382143,
0.0057614064,
-0.0138519993,
-0.0014463501,
0.0170080215,
-0.0165458545,
0.0084068533,
2.631875832e-34,
0.0579292923,
-0.0029365034,
0.0107189016,
-0.0167302564,
-0.0030997926,
0.0179459173,
-0.0212714188,
-0.0045723608,
0.0085155051,
-0.0842486024,
-0.0340396725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12679v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12679v2 | Constructing Colloquial Dataset for Persian Sentiment Analysis of Social Microblogs | 2023-06-22T05:51:22 | 2024-03-07T04:25:50 | Mojtaba Mazoochi, Leila Rabiei, Farzaneh Rahmani, Zeinab Rajabi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Introduction: Microblogging websites have massed rich data sources for
sentiment analysis and opinion mining. In this regard, sentiment classification
has frequently proven inefficient because microblog posts typically lack
syntactically consistent terms and representatives since users on these social
networks do not like to write lengthy statements. Also, there are some
limitations to low-resource languages. The Persian language has exceptional
characteristics and demands unique annotated data and models for the sentiment
analysis task, which are distinctive from text features within the English
dialect. Method: This paper first constructs a user opinion dataset called
ITRC-Opinion in a collaborative environment and insource way. Our dataset
contains 60,000 informal and colloquial Persian texts from social microblogs
such as Twitter and Instagram. Second, this study proposes a new architecture
based on the convolutional neural network (CNN) model for more effective
sentiment analysis of colloquial text in social microblog posts. The
constructed datasets are used to evaluate the presented architecture.
Furthermore, some models, such as LSTM, CNN-RNN, BiLSTM, and BiGRU with
different word embeddings, including Fasttext, Glove, and Word2vec,
investigated our dataset and evaluated the results. Results: The results
demonstrate the benefit of our dataset and the proposed model (72% accuracy),
displaying meaningful improvement in sentiment classification performance. | [
0.058941599,
0.0370903015,
0.0152801042,
0.0413681194,
-0.0492936224,
0.0163541622,
0.0131267142,
-0.003235097,
0.0314790197,
-0.033946164,
-0.024110822,
-0.0658526495,
0.005560542,
0.0428465754,
-0.0129689854,
0.0084244935,
0.0214996226,
0.0359419361,
0.0422815494,
-0.0299199615,
0.0593108051,
0.0397710465,
-0.0086050918,
-0.001434402,
-0.0361438692,
-0.0129625741,
0.0167751908,
-0.0043167961,
-0.0088439714,
-0.0030893232,
0.0553431213,
0.028292058,
-0.0014963089,
0.0392487906,
0.0000017096,
0.0258007981,
0.007816989,
-0.0402154438,
0.0511089936,
-0.0153211569,
0.0849139094,
-0.0142250229,
-0.0204939693,
0.0432739817,
-0.0562915429,
-0.048614163,
0.0509885848,
0.0687789172,
0.0477614179,
0.0710696429,
-0.0304116476,
-0.0238897987,
-0.0329190418,
-0.0338643603,
-0.0361577459,
-0.0066756071,
0.0147007229,
-0.0621624924,
-0.0529063158,
0.0123661049,
0.0087344078,
0.0409949236,
0.00700401,
-0.0238273144,
0.0072986195,
-0.0285301544,
-0.0433674939,
-0.0149200754,
0.035219606,
0.0573879853,
-0.0113644945,
-0.0270783193,
-0.0007610805,
0.0164050236,
-0.0144499252,
0.0036474492,
-0.0121492865,
-0.0126341851,
0.0044813724,
0.0526093952,
-0.0050617266,
0.0302667897,
0.029774148,
0.0653064251,
-0.0093414076,
0.0273375828,
-0.0171000138,
-0.0250522327,
0.0019423179,
0.0319815502,
-0.0072385245,
0.0079727303,
0.0394171476,
-0.0199383311,
-0.0238559712,
0.0062738433,
-0.0034060299,
-0.0138020096,
0.0289465841,
-0.1061461419,
-0.0034991633,
0.002695035,
0.0221363679,
0.0254425872,
-0.0378844067,
-0.0442271568,
-0.0014405247,
0.007832964,
0.0044759922,
-0.0253796279,
-0.057351362,
0.0096444283,
0.0014194511,
0.0208326187,
-0.0113043953,
-0.0055391435,
-0.0786545053,
0.0165196117,
-0.0108302981,
0.0398099348,
-0.0138049843,
0.0333414748,
0.0202811714,
0.0343467779,
-0.0122623648,
0.0275614746,
-0.0368034616,
0.0331679247,
-0.0382424258,
-0.0691651255,
0.0276221894,
0.0262135044,
0.0484842062,
-0.0115641626,
-0.0046410901,
0.0013782377,
0.0241577569,
-0.0528528988,
-0.0473451354,
0.0039911345,
-0.0130634503,
-0.0490705334,
0.0213560127,
-0.0807581246,
0.0454321951,
-0.0039882576,
-0.0126127107,
0.0117808711,
-0.0001571245,
0.0365347303,
-0.0206542909,
0.0731151924,
-0.0371367857,
-0.0116860773,
0.0333096385,
0.0044463458,
0.074204132,
0.0606771074,
0.0143677192,
0.0726031438,
0.0523992628,
-0.0175025836,
-0.0039502061,
-0.0177193675,
0.0195527487,
-0.0075389761,
-0.0290725455,
0.0073695709,
-0.0695949048,
0.0365851074,
-0.0338973925,
0.0443853289,
0.0244768132,
0.0262044184,
0.0483321697,
0.0095931441,
0.0234676152,
0.0797709152,
-0.0085858256,
0.0589485131,
0.0133332098,
-0.0398319438,
0.0039456673,
0.015884351,
0.0233994275,
-0.0028054074,
0.0259466544,
0.0207125638,
-0.0681305155,
-0.0522898212,
-0.0078414399,
-0.0274339262,
0.0328739434,
-0.0247516483,
0.062395025,
-0.0259351656,
-0.0254710149,
0.0348223671,
0.032653708,
-0.0650559515,
-0.025302358,
-0.0329574831,
0.034463156,
0.0631628782,
0.0000196794,
0.0096883047,
0.0156209413,
-0.0430306308,
0.0098271165,
0.0458021984,
0.0551913865,
-0.0098525379,
-0.0217063595,
-0.0688121542,
0.0094289826,
0.021824766,
-0.0092636952,
-0.0123126311,
0.0054331142,
0.0623680577,
0.0142664528,
0.0317049287,
-0.0481323972,
-0.0212485362,
0.024069922,
0.0030705517,
0.0249671992,
0.0417973697,
0.0384857468,
0.0590793751,
-0.0144883925,
-0.0285690799,
0.0452988409,
-0.0150125958,
-0.0430591181,
0.0149440141,
-0.0377917662,
-0.054136496,
0.0297600124,
-0.0372439735,
-0.0108008683,
0.0536611453,
-0.0590363145,
-0.0624945834,
0.079640843,
-0.0175352413,
0.01252345,
-0.0542945862,
-0.003022013,
-0.0366034657,
0.0304383747,
0.0159398951,
0.0026141226,
-0.0354200304,
-0.0048550055,
-0.042155087,
-0.0253527537,
0.039131958,
0.0268041901,
-0.0623948239,
0.0472223386,
0.0396390744,
0.0063385698,
0.0395134017,
0.0031571467,
-0.0186947193,
-0.0335062072,
-0.0818826035,
-0.0112124681,
-0.0206040479,
0.0333826654,
-0.0068354891,
0.0315874852,
0.02436487,
0.006539457,
-0.0478498489,
0.0203682389,
-0.0070173624,
0.0211802889,
0.0527999364,
-0.0076021659,
0.036982052,
-0.0375213847,
-0.0366922021,
-0.0012772933,
-0.0094399126,
-0.0035488312,
-0.0330740213,
0.0368395634,
-0.007690839,
-0.0099372976,
0.0254754312,
0.0013035994,
-0.0814069062,
-0.0101324245,
-0.0272491686,
0.0075715953,
-0.0066556437,
0.0073028165,
0.0015222133,
0.0000163451,
0.0336136594,
0.0084528876,
0.012630811,
-0.0254963879,
-0.0062608812,
-0.0176219828,
-0.036953222,
-0.0632673055,
0.0169595685,
-0.0098050861,
-0.003275841,
-0.0575804077,
-0.026819462,
0.0081844842,
0.0218853895,
0.0186594073,
0.0200476702,
0.0002372454,
-0.0001839297,
-0.0138508435,
-0.0294817146,
0.009991413,
0.0027253602,
0.0237810668,
-0.0505529344,
-0.0390192047,
-0.050580278,
0.0184844192,
-0.0076358756,
-0.0105118947,
-0.0426867306,
0.0265089404,
0.0003046818,
-0.0356402956,
-0.0423742272,
-0.0340119451,
0.0086866627,
0.0379031785,
-0.0048375572,
-0.0086397696,
-0.0161560159,
0.019341629,
-0.054708045,
-0.0539047234,
0.0064692702,
0.0490352809,
-0.0478562936,
0.0379351638,
-0.012119581,
-0.0288540833,
-0.0191300139,
-0.022977028,
0.0182023905,
0.0013282495,
0.0152126458,
0.063749969,
0.0034831888,
0.0187242255,
0.0458237752,
0.0154200671,
0.0447085388,
0.0198934861,
0.0009481978,
-0.0593980514,
-0.0508536734,
0.0226966254,
-0.0121206772,
0.0063376827,
-0.0628212914,
0.019590158,
-0.047479216,
0.0057452563,
0.1098792702,
0.0112153236,
-0.0687489286,
-0.022211574,
0.0468964726,
-0.0143304747,
0.0164103191,
-0.0087745115,
-0.0665573329,
-0.0202606097,
-0.0351359285,
0.0060719554,
-0.0298183654,
-0.001294514,
0.0200491045,
-0.0902167708,
-0.0443432368,
-0.0206181947,
0.0019297319,
-0.0495317392,
-0.0090263961,
-0.0149524864,
-0.0153229097,
0.0054947212,
-0.0622333772,
-0.0072153229,
0.0166557413,
0.0335111618,
-0.042759981,
-0.0552957803,
0.0281960201,
-0.0201938059,
0.0297366362,
0.0178211536,
0.0791152641,
-0.0479668304,
-0.0364179164,
0.021164611,
-0.0033691733,
-0.0264972821,
-0.0376073122,
0.0739779696,
-0.035735283,
-0.0206710435,
-0.0234817266,
-0.0245078336,
-0.0940462053,
0.0412395261,
-0.0372012481,
0.0111060496,
-0.0186944734,
-0.0148528293,
-0.0288324468,
0.0224338192,
0.0284472406,
0.0454290956,
0.0078207217,
-0.0589460805,
-0.0199479312,
0.0171772223,
-0.0420027487,
-0.0677032098,
0.0133643113,
-0.035627231,
0.0217885617,
-0.0360985585,
-0.0438151769,
-0.0653702691,
0.0182807073,
0.0112134544,
-0.0264515709,
0.0167848449,
0.0393288583,
-0.009705022,
-0.0505796596,
-0.0023424344,
0.0456190743,
0.0356461518,
-0.0105831102,
-0.0098888706,
0.0618251786,
-0.027676411,
0.0253334865,
-0.0065109748,
-0.0690570772,
-0.0299242418,
0.0102822399,
0.0026585013,
0.0028047115,
-0.0106644304,
-0.0425411761,
-0.0884155631,
0.0138421636,
0.0386020094,
-0.0340047516,
-0.0247224774,
0.0508133136,
0.0634417385,
0.0055556702,
0.0701127499,
0.0127798365,
0.0056522568,
-0.0038251132,
-0.0386980176,
-0.0492311753,
-0.0233683512,
-0.0240942799,
-0.0298848804,
0.0448645428,
0.0141550777,
-0.020241959,
-0.0587366186,
0.0046358206,
0.0180334728,
0.0013789398,
-0.0296320468,
-0.0002416164,
0.028404586,
-0.0030595437,
-0.0851787403,
-0.0068283663,
-0.0165904816,
-0.015748268,
-0.0244845394,
0.0559858829,
0.016974913,
0.0421406552,
-0.0276436079,
0.0388587303,
-0.0237662848,
-0.0016106738,
-0.0000580377,
-0.0345919691,
-0.009849106,
-0.002858086,
0.0008342288,
-0.0047570025,
0.0211981647,
0.0498214141,
-0.0103367884,
0.0022875725,
0.0023198738,
0.0355602764,
0.0510944799,
-0.0703811049,
0.0639234856,
-0.0255136061,
0.02000417,
0.0017419574,
0.0258457679,
-0.0448321998,
-0.0125779416,
0.0297757797,
-0.0221168082,
-0.0533751771,
0.0009993025,
0.024751151,
-0.0173024125,
-0.0114704473,
0.0531884767,
-0.0266832691,
-0.0123267742,
0.0273785666,
0.0271680318,
0.0388393626,
-0.0065921913,
0.0373072177,
-0.0180636272,
-0.080527477,
0.0571384393,
-0.0511809327,
0.0170404594,
0.0063946312,
0.0381558202,
0.0446636863,
0.0198780764,
0.048573263,
-0.0922365934,
0.0154666593,
0.0150682693,
-0.0455103405,
-0.0311783645,
-6.296556796e-33,
0.0419861525,
-0.0143991746,
-0.0427236073,
0.0114409812,
-0.0000355472,
-0.0276794024,
-0.0296760239,
0.0110560609,
-0.0477300324,
0.044276379,
-0.0163937043,
0.0519480668,
0.0058255061,
0.0493108146,
0.0634501353,
-0.0257097818,
0.0396409631,
-0.0167110022,
0.0298799388,
0.0539593771,
0.0715863407,
0.0377063155,
0.0970759168,
-0.1334429532,
0.0212446488,
-0.053720437,
-0.018692188,
0.0430842862,
0.0313045718,
0.0420144871,
-0.0017275182,
0.0990032405,
0.035000965,
-0.0053770896,
0.0289571267,
0.0440368913,
-0.0434405133,
-0.012506065,
-0.0237501636,
0.0403687358,
-0.0410890207,
-0.0126608312,
0.0071519758,
0.0038648543,
-0.0248153284,
0.0533295348,
0.0313595198,
0.0096472064,
0.0215200912,
-0.0594038442,
-0.0130345132,
0.0407650955,
0.0113246953,
-0.0079838475,
0.035872072,
0.0150720933,
0.0251463018,
0.0276555214,
-0.0723606125,
0.01034158,
-0.0590411462,
0.0164741017,
0.0153169064,
-0.0293415282,
-0.0157388672,
0.0335287973,
0.0019948578,
0.0178192127,
0.036458753,
0.0313404985,
-0.0107104266,
0.0055072051,
0.0151418271,
0.0800205693,
0.0535765998,
-0.0657623932,
-0.0515355021,
-0.0236139707,
0.0608863458,
0.0670912564,
0.0378364772,
-0.0253245085,
-0.0591503009,
0.0039276797,
0.0427168384,
-0.0244580694,
-0.0340003744,
-0.0258104578,
-0.0319344066,
-0.0052984767,
0.0140053891,
0.0411338098,
-0.0149805676,
-0.0608623736,
-0.0143004162,
0.0319948122,
-0.0407597236,
0.0235543121,
0.0083707459,
0.0263181087,
-0.0635939464,
-0.0229833871,
-0.0394463614,
0.0361996368,
-0.0209453646,
0.0094288867,
0.0544102266,
0.0487984866,
-0.0594442748,
-0.0086803399,
-0.0284295138,
0.0095411958,
-0.0189417005,
0.0405145474,
-0.0303228255,
0.0269683134,
-0.0264388006,
0.0536677875,
0.0111973742,
0.0165190157,
0.0126051167,
-0.0535442308,
0.0039436561,
-0.0397297926,
-0.0086880131,
-0.0251781959,
-0.0280483067,
0.0067127487,
-0.0104552414,
-0.0653646961,
0.011093121,
-0.0065054279,
2.638e-7,
0.033649005,
0.0403458253,
-0.0310240295,
-0.004704305,
0.0024263191,
0.0327912457,
0.0176040344,
0.0465525277,
-0.0521734394,
0.0349106789,
0.0400566533,
0.0230487362,
0.0667591169,
0.0094087832,
-0.0975844488,
0.0040139738,
-0.0640032366,
0.0210146289,
0.0142985415,
0.0352870524,
0.0545180924,
0.120203279,
0.0496356525,
-0.0366337486,
-0.007266074,
-0.0414962545,
0.015835952,
-0.024228625,
-0.0095347371,
0.0425574109,
0.0079830568,
0.0280162487,
-0.0214776117,
-0.0326653384,
-0.0361551344,
0.0238149762,
0.0246059615,
0.0346438587,
0.0114288805,
-0.0432390086,
0.0283241738,
-0.0350686498,
0.0224695764,
-0.0051888321,
0.0421326011,
-0.0133272763,
-0.0541227162,
-0.0416818969,
0.0406197459,
0.0149004981,
0.0890094563,
-0.0034916846,
-0.0144155761,
0.0009194136,
-0.0043908278,
-0.0637099594,
-0.0300872512,
-0.0750681385,
0.0400687717,
0.0078935074,
-0.0214455631,
-0.0009457208,
0.0171861295,
0.0141371367,
0.053616032,
0.0378517881,
0.0297846906,
1.837349787e-34,
0.0436772667,
-0.0204450376,
-0.0070628352,
0.0077002891,
0.0027002443,
0.0093066478,
-0.0338101983,
-0.0176049992,
0.0398333073,
-0.0306165107,
-0.003086041
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.