id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12672v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12672v2 | From Word Models to World Models: Translating from Natural Language to the Probabilistic Language of Thought | 2023-06-22T05:14:00 | 2023-06-23T06:05:31 | Lionel Wong, Gabriel Grand, Alexander K. Lew, Noah D. Goodman, Vikash K. Mansinghka, Jacob Andreas, Joshua B. Tenenbaum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SC | How does language inform our downstream thinking? In particular, how do
humans make meaning from language--and how can we leverage a theory of
linguistic meaning to build machines that think in more human-like ways? In
this paper, we propose rational meaning construction, a computational framework
for language-informed thinking that combines neural language models with
probabilistic models for rational inference. We frame linguistic meaning as a
context-sensitive mapping from natural language into a probabilistic language
of thought (PLoT)--a general-purpose symbolic substrate for generative world
modeling. Our architecture integrates two computational tools that have not
previously come together: we model thinking with probabilistic programs, an
expressive representation for commonsense reasoning; and we model meaning
construction with large language models (LLMs), which support broad-coverage
translation from natural language utterances to code expressions in a
probabilistic programming language. We illustrate our framework through
examples covering four core domains from cognitive science: probabilistic
reasoning, logical and relational reasoning, visual and physical reasoning, and
social reasoning. In each, we show that LLMs can generate context-sensitive
translations that capture pragmatically-appropriate linguistic meanings, while
Bayesian inference with the generated programs supports coherent and robust
commonsense reasoning. We extend our framework to integrate
cognitively-motivated symbolic modules (physics simulators, graphics engines,
and planning algorithms) to provide a unified commonsense thinking interface
from language. Finally, we explore how language can drive the construction of
world models themselves. We hope this work will provide a roadmap towards
cognitive models and AI systems that synthesize the insights of both modern and
classical computational perspectives. | [
0.0079165334,
0.0549071878,
-0.0218580682,
0.0266024452,
-0.0380154736,
0.0077882688,
-0.0116865076,
-0.0092409905,
0.0247410163,
0.0035844215,
0.0297601819,
-0.0111791268,
0.0238577947,
0.0700553209,
0.021354191,
-0.0613884293,
0.0112837804,
-0.0529736951,
0.014549355,
-0.0042512449,
-0.0636182949,
0.0203342866,
-0.0170308929,
0.033161778,
-0.0217380971,
0.0136354864,
-0.0021053955,
-0.014557098,
0.0353926457,
-0.0039550429,
-0.0759634897,
0.0031599195,
0.04171234,
-0.0011594561,
0.0000020423,
-0.0599409007,
0.0153533593,
-0.000314461,
0.0293440744,
-0.0408125184,
0.0352084972,
0.0017548167,
0.0019674529,
-0.0095881429,
-0.0475628264,
0.0727193877,
0.0738440305,
-0.0225083549,
-0.0140776625,
-0.0091853635,
-0.0081914142,
-0.0292131361,
0.006731505,
-0.0043940451,
0.0585615002,
-0.0223257467,
0.0200247709,
0.0813651904,
0.0377890915,
0.0089126276,
-0.0399359539,
0.0372951813,
0.0491597354,
-0.006443785,
-0.0122414231,
0.0534637086,
0.023127364,
-0.0176837873,
0.0056585972,
0.0471144505,
0.0068783714,
-0.0249865409,
0.0239808876,
-0.0062998189,
0.0035507134,
0.0476445891,
-0.0229974575,
0.112825118,
0.0184140019,
0.0347679146,
0.0387583189,
0.0031828585,
0.0215569902,
0.0234748889,
-0.0322661549,
0.061846219,
0.0276258644,
0.0562136434,
-0.0197871663,
0.0171149634,
-0.0195113812,
-0.0506353974,
-0.0058455314,
0.016792316,
0.0108056609,
0.0424142219,
-0.0238113869,
0.0220052022,
-0.0302291885,
-0.0609042533,
0.0280371234,
0.0622908361,
0.0335805789,
0.0566482544,
-0.0166922454,
-0.006803392,
-0.0066382792,
0.0011551743,
-0.0532398932,
-0.0113069443,
-0.0663585067,
0.0053390688,
-0.0103253396,
-0.0073448033,
-0.0413503386,
-0.0276403651,
-0.0120547768,
0.0468054637,
-0.0095468182,
-0.0035443367,
0.0075280815,
0.0304138605,
-0.051544413,
-0.0238630604,
-0.0832589194,
-0.0178850461,
-0.0420173034,
0.0170656703,
-0.0041627055,
-0.0164452959,
-0.0140100336,
0.0014360872,
0.0061464505,
-0.0191232003,
-0.0019441639,
0.0688633919,
0.0274740178,
0.0157269761,
-0.0354707465,
-0.0550491698,
-0.0008481299,
-0.0223714039,
0.0324324071,
-0.0629833788,
0.0125240227,
0.0194821414,
0.0013396889,
-0.0686754659,
0.0100328987,
-0.0172875151,
-0.0293257367,
0.072359778,
-0.031582281,
0.0116464645,
0.0250489544,
0.0294239502,
-0.0167746618,
0.0554596335,
0.0715851411,
0.0125560369,
0.0066961977,
0.0354746915,
-0.0025841321,
0.0183764417,
-0.0152678369,
-0.0209183954,
-0.0654505789,
-0.0176063739,
0.0173617136,
0.0127227651,
0.0073377467,
0.0147206429,
-0.0283972211,
-0.0047329222,
0.0401268639,
0.0595222004,
-0.0413722917,
0.032152243,
0.0581838116,
-0.0292330198,
-0.026946431,
-0.0483961217,
-0.0637994483,
0.0770149529,
-0.0257631466,
-0.0064265165,
-0.0238338728,
0.0075946478,
0.0101526147,
-0.0424389429,
-0.0009488819,
-0.031919051,
0.0469483733,
0.00181797,
0.0585213155,
-0.029815061,
-0.0046509341,
0.0180112105,
0.0122187175,
-0.0375898369,
0.0126853343,
-0.0544818118,
0.030102998,
0.0496273376,
0.0199579056,
-0.0277532004,
-0.0037974217,
0.007635545,
-0.0255810246,
0.0633621961,
0.0200644433,
-0.0033906954,
-0.0131645501,
-0.018993957,
-0.0198572204,
0.0037773889,
-0.0216911733,
0.0240307488,
0.0011769648,
0.0246251654,
0.0001572428,
-0.0192266274,
0.0009180009,
0.0221665986,
-0.0365363769,
0.023254985,
-0.0254976284,
-0.0223286245,
0.0365688317,
-0.0157993603,
-0.0007786452,
0.03019513,
0.0222702157,
-0.0213943925,
-0.0302268043,
0.059141878,
0.0048228297,
-0.0108683892,
0.0512255765,
-0.0693320632,
-0.0171467327,
-0.0319299102,
-0.0186338015,
-0.0252497289,
0.0600247718,
-0.0313214175,
0.0163712632,
-0.0164669808,
-0.0288888961,
-0.0073668347,
-0.0342270881,
0.0075223618,
0.0923542231,
0.0004649789,
-0.0333244577,
0.028262781,
0.0078940587,
0.0266974773,
-0.0396218151,
0.0081352172,
-0.0228556991,
0.0026456839,
-0.0181609336,
0.0372206271,
0.0061197234,
-0.0349413119,
-0.0073014875,
-0.0480202213,
-0.0174659621,
0.0302296299,
-0.0255815089,
-0.0042669955,
-0.0039541423,
-0.0031077589,
0.0077347187,
0.0026610845,
0.0209462438,
-0.0008329001,
0.007286482,
0.0256606787,
-0.0274007525,
-0.0134715382,
-0.0032528311,
0.0093179727,
-0.0501131006,
0.0364092849,
0.0719944313,
0.0036989963,
-0.0394277498,
0.0285822917,
-0.0717197955,
0.0275710374,
-0.0048154951,
-0.0361942947,
0.045253396,
-0.0310955364,
0.0268516783,
0.072947666,
-0.0122911371,
0.0054983911,
0.093801856,
-0.0422607288,
-0.0147118289,
0.0002735363,
-0.0297011267,
0.0121614505,
-0.011447994,
-0.0586238764,
-0.049145028,
0.0377719253,
0.0164621528,
-0.0111309728,
-0.0674007237,
0.0697228462,
-0.005797958,
-0.0462312512,
-0.0204592105,
-0.0039079338,
0.0116087161,
0.0894325152,
0.0010573822,
-0.0301938038,
0.0566705056,
0.0144539839,
0.0453282632,
-0.0255962219,
-0.0016912264,
0.0200333595,
0.0875028148,
0.0119553208,
0.0208565518,
-0.0110443067,
0.0491501912,
-0.0352673307,
-0.0089516705,
0.0022693395,
-0.020034194,
-0.0356362015,
-0.1326539814,
0.0093690343,
-0.0074170553,
-0.0132073928,
-0.0102474773,
0.0328607969,
-0.060555473,
-0.0120460698,
-0.0076571661,
-0.0366900153,
0.0025364975,
0.0185341146,
0.0144431684,
-0.0201068204,
-0.0008815868,
-0.0219757296,
-0.0115843341,
-0.0101524275,
0.057546597,
0.0233693421,
0.0450750515,
0.0114665199,
-0.0177505054,
0.0213518348,
-0.0332682543,
0.0098483488,
-0.0266356282,
0.0325589031,
-0.0025868467,
0.0141120907,
-0.0161274895,
0.0563799776,
0.0462232493,
-0.0214950182,
-0.0485843904,
0.0912759453,
0.0273939203,
0.0085915178,
-0.0012753421,
-0.0395388454,
-0.0107076569,
0.0204629935,
0.0289004147,
-0.0681274161,
-0.0375660993,
-0.0030772656,
-0.0435785539,
-0.0021726673,
-0.0810433999,
0.0223830082,
-0.0823896453,
0.0553091653,
-0.0040926859,
-0.0331848003,
-0.0363094546,
-0.0546947457,
-0.0237781908,
-0.0058282516,
-0.1056389213,
-0.0144639043,
0.03470264,
0.0428913683,
-0.0250377115,
0.0378889143,
-0.0307986923,
0.0274455212,
-0.0315431878,
0.0339711905,
0.0306553282,
0.0377787538,
0.004863542,
-0.0761004612,
-0.0399886817,
0.0219311845,
0.0101450002,
-0.012625223,
-0.0282146521,
0.0418953598,
-0.0045114211,
-0.0179632492,
0.0474425107,
-0.056023147,
-0.0803914815,
-0.0120406486,
0.1107659414,
-0.0314187445,
-0.0122772306,
-0.0691618174,
0.0349946693,
0.0283439662,
0.098916851,
0.0044375267,
-0.0274126902,
-0.0319723673,
-0.0660724044,
-0.0104535734,
-0.0027547032,
-0.027666077,
-0.0362353399,
0.0239380188,
-0.0316896364,
-0.0284152962,
0.0219658762,
0.0337295644,
0.0196477622,
0.0126987277,
-0.0491317771,
0.0476869978,
-0.0003550765,
-0.063778244,
0.035387475,
-0.0713410601,
0.0004113544,
0.0432212166,
-0.0158894937,
0.0250839386,
-0.0653293058,
-0.0319307521,
0.070638068,
-0.0411237516,
-0.0532841459,
-0.0168143976,
0.0560395718,
0.0354869142,
-0.0152812693,
-0.0131080691,
0.0072221104,
0.0060188817,
0.0103324866,
0.0024955769,
0.0263139997,
-0.0081285303,
0.0719495565,
0.0278276745,
0.0238414425,
-0.0429768041,
0.0103566619,
-0.0010685015,
0.0537616946,
-0.0201137625,
-0.0224945247,
-0.0263922792,
-0.0173296276,
0.0082302103,
-0.0299003664,
-0.0168428421,
-0.0268250983,
-0.0498680957,
-0.0554723293,
-0.0252293777,
-0.0316864476,
0.0322803631,
0.0247633923,
-0.004991041,
0.006408006,
0.0054793963,
-0.0255183931,
0.0201115683,
0.0408734791,
-0.0194690432,
0.0559279323,
0.0049085054,
0.0277542006,
-0.0220353808,
0.028366169,
-0.0274866112,
-0.0682091787,
0.0419647992,
-0.0206746124,
0.0172617454,
0.0350219235,
-0.0214241706,
-0.0187125374,
-0.0187138766,
-0.0707354322,
-0.0880394503,
0.03837201,
0.0742703304,
0.0451275185,
0.0209982861,
-0.0002585238,
-0.0969805717,
0.0018680494,
0.030429801,
0.0232124235,
0.0716033652,
-0.0376168899,
0.0607502908,
0.010361339,
-0.0031667082,
-0.0581874326,
0.0310229287,
-0.0521270707,
0.0235777572,
-0.0032209989,
-0.0448410697,
-0.0076747378,
-0.0389930606,
0.0036337625,
0.0281056985,
0.0113370661,
0.0112060755,
-0.0724212527,
-0.0558980405,
-0.0041123843,
0.1012068465,
0.0226125941,
0.00190436,
0.0505375676,
0.0240538027,
-0.0087424871,
-0.0448474847,
0.0253429711,
0.0482760295,
-0.0449336506,
-0.031105049,
-0.0645450577,
-5.930720546e-33,
-0.0096237259,
-0.0283228736,
0.0249683578,
-0.0159874801,
0.0108379582,
-0.0626313761,
-0.0524675474,
-0.0073789386,
-0.0218340438,
0.0169837512,
0.0226349607,
0.0364454538,
-0.0105605824,
0.0031419534,
0.0179949347,
-0.0128546357,
0.0104635134,
0.0020191283,
-0.0160007384,
-0.0033061437,
0.046212595,
-0.0500659943,
0.0209180582,
-0.0259212796,
0.0105134081,
0.0159360152,
0.0175618324,
0.0404272377,
-0.00445941,
0.0101484722,
-0.0296535846,
0.0233567245,
0.0224602371,
0.0081499629,
0.0330655947,
0.0337173939,
-0.0336422957,
-0.065720804,
0.037062753,
-0.0287440419,
-0.0423621088,
-0.0389458984,
0.0126622608,
0.0178801902,
-0.0545384474,
-0.0211394206,
0.058069557,
-0.0355969258,
-0.0035644381,
-0.0034793227,
-0.0310662929,
0.0006137744,
-0.0125869894,
-0.0115882922,
-0.0440370403,
-0.0328221843,
-0.0082515972,
0.0487872325,
-0.008676826,
0.0467735156,
0.0062523317,
-0.0233664308,
0.0532881804,
-0.0004602722,
0.0504679196,
0.0437613018,
0.0016134104,
-0.0287667196,
-0.0642410815,
0.0224147439,
0.0179211851,
0.0514699295,
0.0334705301,
0.0482410975,
0.0339699574,
0.0155526334,
-0.0927931145,
0.043450065,
-0.0231101848,
0.0400549881,
0.0442416482,
0.0142211355,
0.0133318929,
-0.0149866343,
-0.0510314479,
-0.0405252017,
-0.0166460183,
0.0066866805,
-0.015079746,
-0.0497803055,
-0.0346130915,
-0.0112096695,
0.0277086329,
-0.0595612898,
-0.0036174057,
0.0398014076,
0.0193151757,
0.0025017103,
0.0128715504,
0.0038962506,
0.0115674911,
-0.025805397,
0.0117901145,
0.000471505,
0.0046777092,
0.0239617359,
-0.0377977043,
0.020355409,
0.0411345288,
-0.0113618812,
-0.0402884409,
-0.0275318138,
0.0284999274,
-0.0110291429,
0.0300105009,
0.0210072976,
0.0181471109,
-0.0321978033,
-0.0049434844,
-0.0014126586,
0.0319458656,
0.0070211617,
-0.0167079605,
-0.0000573636,
-0.0524521135,
-0.0145072518,
-0.0673714206,
0.0102265319,
0.0566035099,
-0.077198416,
-0.0332091413,
0.0616975464,
2.9e-7,
0.0466337726,
0.0328752957,
0.0044714706,
0.0586739108,
0.0417090915,
0.0259077232,
0.0074504931,
0.0105519891,
0.0369197167,
-0.0315318219,
-0.0128024183,
0.0783845559,
-0.0078622187,
0.0146896113,
-0.0393350422,
0.026633326,
0.008452164,
-0.0153024597,
-0.0306647886,
0.0178745072,
0.1176446006,
0.0426672064,
0.0481725708,
-0.0018369514,
0.0310133286,
-0.0417628475,
0.0289167352,
-0.0717978552,
0.0378743261,
-0.0203369725,
-0.0421818905,
-0.0049774274,
0.0017934353,
0.0208340473,
0.0076713683,
0.0037206919,
-0.0028047853,
0.0575240925,
-0.0089611122,
0.0242942348,
-0.0112192379,
-0.0677362159,
0.0314068757,
-0.0574777685,
0.0748975649,
-0.081004709,
-0.0176096987,
-0.0049202316,
0.0068921582,
-0.0074014734,
-0.0023206482,
-0.0239420403,
-0.0246823933,
-0.0495448485,
0.0149140777,
0.0190675519,
0.0125394547,
-0.0240297355,
-0.0017862053,
0.0005750425,
-0.0283813048,
-0.0455110818,
-0.0312973671,
-0.0076938793,
0.0437568091,
-0.0685232058,
-0.0078714527,
2.639320706e-34,
0.0168115776,
-0.0027715,
-0.0200955793,
-0.0526714586,
0.0654314831,
-0.0004613893,
-0.0071355551,
0.0218667872,
0.0494502597,
-0.0699241832,
-0.053086441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12659v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12659v1 | Instruct-FinGPT: Financial Sentiment Analysis by Instruction Tuning of General-Purpose Large Language Models | 2023-06-22T03:56:38 | 2023-06-22T03:56:38 | Boyu Zhang, Hongyang Yang, Xiao-Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.ST, q-fin.TR | Sentiment analysis is a vital tool for uncovering insights from financial
articles, news, and social media, shaping our understanding of market
movements. Despite the impressive capabilities of large language models (LLMs)
in financial natural language processing (NLP), they still struggle with
accurately interpreting numerical values and grasping financial context,
limiting their effectiveness in predicting financial sentiment. In this paper,
we introduce a simple yet effective instruction tuning approach to address
these issues. By transforming a small portion of supervised financial sentiment
analysis data into instruction data and fine-tuning a general-purpose LLM with
this method, we achieve remarkable advancements in financial sentiment
analysis. In the experiment, our approach outperforms state-of-the-art
supervised sentiment analysis models, as well as widely used LLMs like ChatGPT
and LLaMAs, particularly in scenarios where numerical understanding and
contextual comprehension are vital. | [
0.0120416405,
0.0910297483,
-0.0032615855,
0.039578557,
0.000936422,
0.012603214,
-0.0003879623,
0.0122573888,
0.0095263086,
-0.0685154051,
-0.042505376,
-0.020551553,
-0.0540715903,
0.0141221285,
0.0185783058,
-0.0311322156,
0.0092095966,
-0.0040445002,
0.0402300917,
-0.0103643453,
0.0276214108,
0.0050782599,
0.0235501342,
0.0090519823,
-0.0045923456,
-0.0292878188,
0.0053318441,
0.0011422194,
-0.0145786339,
-0.0260360055,
0.0364746116,
0.00788939,
0.0317316614,
0.0118754134,
0.0000020464,
-0.0331903361,
-0.0157700833,
-0.0156769939,
0.0112332152,
0.0285664946,
0.0716479719,
-0.0549087711,
0.0367249586,
0.0235453695,
-0.0635387823,
0.009312748,
0.0461347252,
0.0820203051,
0.1049346179,
0.0960687473,
-0.0096287001,
-0.0743209943,
-0.025371315,
-0.0459194481,
0.03485604,
-0.0700901151,
0.0292549562,
0.0579501316,
-0.0134143401,
0.0222285911,
-0.030702766,
0.0180632416,
-0.0142704947,
0.0071430821,
0.0187243223,
-0.019403968,
-0.0296892021,
0.011659448,
-0.0440790877,
0.0274898447,
0.0067615611,
0.0347745866,
-0.0092531927,
-0.0171204638,
-0.0161939207,
-0.0049229199,
-0.0209482051,
0.0342128798,
-0.0042191306,
0.0325893387,
0.0327965133,
0.0113300383,
0.0064550163,
0.0119360304,
-0.0028277624,
0.0330246799,
-0.0482930876,
-0.0288960002,
0.0477640592,
0.0493463278,
-0.0191754587,
0.0007910178,
0.0066393428,
0.0103939865,
0.0147073977,
0.0158723872,
0.0038827455,
-0.005317823,
-0.0085980678,
-0.1041356996,
0.0452260748,
0.0431353226,
-0.0027970241,
0.055091612,
-0.0393099301,
0.0032893887,
0.0381107442,
-0.0266440306,
-0.0105143292,
0.0257110819,
-0.0708305687,
0.0044909348,
-0.0362449512,
0.0632920265,
-0.0502942726,
-0.0112464195,
-0.0719100684,
-0.0128419343,
-0.0084744962,
0.0096360995,
0.024432404,
-0.0305330958,
-0.0191998798,
-0.0068658926,
-0.0291282628,
0.014037515,
-0.0412579291,
0.0314656124,
-0.0602777824,
-0.0248938911,
0.0041017244,
0.021313291,
-0.0393856838,
0.0056305733,
0.0267652366,
0.098764196,
0.0395207964,
-0.0328154713,
-0.0747329667,
-0.0395270623,
0.0186571926,
-0.0430668816,
-0.0140098836,
-0.0143874865,
-0.0114433197,
-0.0123585807,
0.0005355448,
0.0308989417,
0.0166816041,
-0.015881978,
-0.025865918,
0.091052711,
0.0134560531,
-0.0313506722,
-0.0032081539,
-0.0315843225,
0.030797597,
0.0821854323,
-0.016974479,
0.0265168436,
0.0378887951,
-0.0247802064,
-0.0138687864,
0.0376516618,
0.0105070071,
-0.0624952726,
-0.0324750133,
0.020902751,
-0.0089822784,
-0.0069391867,
0.0556214154,
0.0374287963,
-0.0087622069,
-0.0011464374,
0.0374655947,
0.0074503119,
0.0220199265,
0.0318222158,
0.0043007238,
0.0280759912,
0.0262287483,
-0.0382097065,
-0.014678685,
0.0009113986,
-0.0242195092,
0.0276650991,
-0.0092295874,
0.0270795226,
-0.0237807147,
-0.0672321394,
-0.0045453995,
-0.0232398324,
-0.0008873552,
-0.0105206817,
0.0095740017,
-0.0381029323,
-0.0582549274,
0.0191606004,
0.0691649094,
-0.0237960573,
0.0044388007,
-0.0234199595,
0.0458570197,
0.1011590064,
-0.0024834429,
-0.0089631798,
0.0097434586,
-0.0221001599,
0.0120689794,
0.0455447547,
0.0223290902,
0.0038853034,
-0.0323876701,
-0.0787855238,
0.015010668,
-0.0013493346,
0.0467027016,
0.0146438209,
-0.0071648094,
-0.0104256496,
-0.0098353662,
-0.0065635219,
-0.0345154218,
0.018999584,
0.0180222988,
-0.0813019648,
0.004464074,
-0.0314967781,
0.0103823626,
0.0122469449,
-0.0124150366,
-0.0186832324,
-0.0023678932,
-0.0168281719,
-0.0497038327,
-0.0105243493,
-0.0378349535,
-0.035810139,
-0.0133942999,
-0.0195998866,
-0.0140773542,
-0.0007208652,
-0.0611802638,
0.023730509,
0.0033676771,
-0.0345688984,
0.0466888025,
-0.0296908375,
-0.0407048315,
0.0025937161,
0.01041923,
-0.005195471,
0.0603576563,
-0.0046605528,
-0.0024619331,
-0.0289199259,
0.001654288,
-0.0182546861,
-0.0005555761,
0.0122505473,
-0.0193792284,
0.0137511687,
0.0564188845,
0.0253954362,
0.0284921061,
-0.011791558,
-0.0514935255,
-0.0915533677,
-0.0165549722,
-0.0053652581,
0.0420986935,
0.0148795685,
-0.007992859,
-0.0208926741,
-0.0111126387,
-0.0173070487,
-0.0290083941,
-0.033663325,
-0.0013093223,
0.0655749589,
-0.0148114078,
-0.00389913,
-0.0541662201,
0.0086743766,
-0.0228922199,
0.0064274864,
0.059448339,
-0.0212473199,
-0.0267236289,
0.0058752229,
-0.0064244661,
0.0055755032,
-0.0020782799,
-0.0124807283,
-0.0077635162,
-0.0082003959,
-0.0003092373,
0.085836798,
0.0080136638,
0.0905025452,
-0.0315969251,
-0.0017960219,
-0.043071501,
0.0322210938,
-0.0223852042,
-0.0207185429,
-0.0311236382,
0.0084499782,
-0.0131400852,
0.0717159659,
-0.0190550108,
-0.0033423358,
-0.0877995789,
0.0339714251,
-0.0246971194,
0.038248837,
-0.0246170964,
0.0094520235,
0.0068153464,
-0.0106963571,
0.0167930312,
-0.0477976687,
0.0446247086,
0.0041808882,
-0.0204001497,
-0.0731582865,
-0.031912826,
-0.0980410278,
0.0253153201,
-0.026073806,
-0.0013015566,
-0.0161119848,
-0.008931689,
-0.0000369582,
-0.0328376591,
0.0172969624,
-0.0144027546,
0.0352844298,
-0.0365356132,
0.0204604696,
0.0178612936,
-0.0020340611,
0.0046312679,
-0.0641897246,
-0.0661175326,
0.0111743174,
0.0766784698,
-0.0501557477,
-0.040090479,
-0.0065268748,
-0.0127109652,
-0.0666799769,
-0.0151594877,
-0.0341788493,
0.0097873118,
-0.0263078287,
0.0613247789,
-0.0040030233,
0.0190798286,
-0.0484718159,
0.0358700268,
0.0158263203,
0.0071190363,
-0.0040046242,
-0.0331116728,
0.0221039373,
-0.0131060909,
-0.0142638618,
0.011736176,
0.005466165,
0.0368256569,
-0.0505415127,
0.01360818,
0.1212044433,
0.0036506504,
-0.0114904009,
0.0121912463,
0.0390561037,
0.0058703092,
-0.0042343056,
0.0374122486,
-0.0640196428,
-0.0568032824,
-0.0333559141,
0.0320247076,
0.0270797014,
-0.0294020679,
-0.0151832709,
-0.148351267,
0.0453797095,
0.0062511787,
-0.0194825213,
-0.0482239686,
-0.0508626774,
-0.0236697067,
-0.0547558144,
0.0237617586,
-0.0129045434,
-0.0544467531,
0.0496326387,
0.0154857049,
-0.0485368073,
-0.0275092665,
0.0286850929,
-0.0082138618,
0.0034880782,
0.0122576524,
0.0075715533,
-0.0173124205,
-0.0091630286,
-0.0083416272,
0.0009998741,
0.0125620896,
-0.0295648407,
0.0638967752,
-0.040600732,
-0.0497666597,
0.0077931187,
0.0415446237,
-0.0475740097,
0.0750272647,
-0.0068756002,
0.0040924004,
-0.0155778117,
-0.0466029122,
-0.0153414486,
0.0596443079,
0.0234371498,
0.0819235295,
0.005495159,
-0.070005253,
-0.0065289112,
-0.0590842851,
-0.0012607134,
-0.0565340668,
-0.0287148561,
-0.0137887746,
-0.0142289922,
0.0037022308,
-0.0815835148,
-0.0643773153,
0.0362383202,
0.0269879736,
-0.0084906304,
0.0032668631,
0.0515559614,
0.0064681456,
-0.0263138469,
0.0521382354,
-0.0192277841,
0.0109428372,
-0.0301215481,
-0.0172240883,
0.0546275452,
0.0134438481,
-0.0422147028,
0.0070820628,
-0.063130036,
-0.048453033,
0.0122074094,
0.0266073048,
0.0190791376,
-0.0043933019,
0.0087854574,
0.0215422288,
0.0251796376,
0.0806913748,
-0.0537573881,
-0.0008032586,
0.0584380813,
0.0708439425,
0.0182897002,
0.0312892534,
-0.0147296432,
0.0443867072,
-0.0137828225,
0.0287616421,
-0.0477816686,
0.0175293665,
-0.002680925,
0.0084933192,
0.028619919,
0.0450065061,
-0.017908318,
-0.0108847823,
-0.0167912524,
0.0096349595,
-0.0008455109,
-0.0424457714,
-0.0364176109,
0.0131322155,
-0.0147952167,
-0.0613228008,
0.0009861572,
-0.0034378932,
-0.0159300026,
-0.0158361085,
0.0647259355,
0.0146253407,
0.0235255342,
0.0066512944,
-0.0155086936,
0.0041442406,
-0.0233672448,
0.0475606844,
-0.0033878142,
0.0201559998,
0.0133200046,
0.0340581574,
0.0477259941,
-0.0290968642,
-0.0310668796,
-0.0042612581,
-0.0197636578,
-0.0184687432,
0.0490092449,
0.0007929627,
-0.0521116965,
0.0037698864,
-0.0460557267,
0.0351845287,
0.0241685156,
0.0309910867,
-0.0247128252,
-0.0268213749,
0.0557259619,
-0.0005644555,
-0.0554795824,
-0.0474536754,
0.0834773481,
-0.020200409,
0.0622624904,
-0.0006484139,
0.0107119661,
-0.0489122793,
-0.0274072792,
0.0823694766,
-0.0126090553,
0.014165544,
0.0442711711,
-0.0487699397,
-0.0559753925,
0.0240199957,
-0.0187041648,
0.0054654125,
-0.0161087606,
0.0481182635,
0.0548967421,
0.0039479705,
0.0503178723,
-0.0200903025,
-0.0005996744,
-0.0263499673,
-0.0398992486,
-0.0727285817,
-6.662732837e-33,
-0.0161104761,
-0.0046362579,
0.0259933416,
0.0400503799,
0.0220656414,
0.0151952235,
-0.0245953538,
0.0136422012,
-0.0106194094,
0.0479769669,
0.0269199535,
0.0372254364,
0.0005141058,
0.023600487,
0.0292207841,
-0.01119895,
0.03536034,
-0.0258780979,
0.0022618819,
-0.0145885637,
0.0166246369,
0.0677113608,
0.0665618628,
-0.0851235166,
0.0417365395,
0.008617525,
-0.0534357987,
-0.0051328866,
0.0346640907,
0.0313944556,
0.0004296013,
0.0689265653,
0.0253767166,
-0.0637535676,
-0.0041058669,
0.0135024795,
0.0317192562,
-0.0576941185,
0.0214551277,
0.0340094306,
0.0028645708,
-0.0086906115,
0.0346568003,
-0.0052782353,
-0.0324744098,
0.003688927,
0.0185921658,
-0.0019030762,
0.023082098,
-0.0391447507,
-0.085931398,
0.0372949578,
-0.0075492216,
0.0145709217,
0.0218993612,
0.0310987048,
0.0043232501,
0.0364949033,
-0.0045735748,
0.022808006,
0.0048624687,
0.0322400518,
-0.0141875586,
-0.0233675092,
-0.0095519926,
0.0630606413,
-0.0305393972,
-0.004336495,
-0.0018912647,
0.0494709425,
0.0284532532,
0.037250597,
0.03333598,
0.0337827355,
0.0327312835,
-0.0268847477,
-0.0457163528,
-0.0067732832,
0.0380885005,
0.0335160904,
0.0293765794,
0.0155342426,
-0.0521425232,
-0.0314757042,
0.0124625368,
-0.0016640753,
-0.007841141,
-0.0044698664,
-0.0021936856,
0.0081897685,
-0.0253800955,
-0.00336854,
-0.0070667849,
-0.0610634275,
-0.0776171088,
-0.001451573,
0.0026519392,
0.0192543827,
0.0039341007,
-0.02668464,
-0.0604701862,
-0.0585847907,
-0.0181177501,
-0.0000119184,
-0.003207671,
-0.0215963069,
0.0357929766,
0.0286502969,
-0.0749171674,
-0.0217800532,
0.0074600293,
0.0217680726,
0.0120042451,
0.0463188365,
-0.0078031765,
0.0276155286,
-0.0185400583,
0.0434575863,
-0.0080727674,
0.0368232429,
-0.0083483728,
-0.0236486718,
-0.0061455723,
0.0317257158,
-0.0007988403,
-0.0022119444,
0.0228762031,
0.0160181616,
-0.0013564756,
-0.0546663553,
-0.0134587074,
0.0239297934,
2.773e-7,
0.0483974591,
0.1187216863,
-0.0197708625,
0.0250392761,
0.0048364317,
0.0584918298,
-0.0224275962,
-0.0007317557,
0.0043523894,
-0.0152169764,
0.0137060834,
0.044920072,
0.0455984585,
0.0059277429,
-0.0832783356,
-0.0267962124,
-0.0360467285,
0.0290334485,
-0.0435230955,
0.0513913445,
0.0517536439,
0.1202853471,
-0.0058130254,
-0.0150221698,
-0.0194528941,
-0.0613433756,
0.0534104556,
-0.0483669713,
-0.0293144472,
0.0302099753,
-0.0013717264,
0.0229930412,
-0.0011566117,
-0.0093589444,
0.0011351018,
0.0142189348,
0.0038130041,
0.0613973364,
0.0182228703,
0.0144713456,
0.0163772441,
0.0222479645,
-0.0277969558,
-0.012245262,
0.0258464534,
-0.1020984128,
-0.0329326056,
-0.0680889711,
-0.037587557,
0.0169029534,
0.0521352105,
0.0061403774,
-0.0198786743,
0.0202728715,
0.0123981237,
-0.0324297026,
-0.025900485,
-0.0365646444,
-0.0088211503,
0.0201000888,
-0.0412774645,
0.0186082423,
-0.0159658995,
0.023724312,
0.0263467953,
-0.0325280838,
0.0315682702,
2.257231777e-34,
0.0998951271,
-0.0614133403,
-0.0056711202,
0.0459923185,
0.0841121227,
0.031824261,
-0.0473907255,
0.0495697446,
0.0083588641,
-0.0826921985,
0.0124823209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12656v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12656v1 | Identifying and Extracting Rare Disease Phenotypes with Large Language Models | 2023-06-22T03:52:12 | 2023-06-22T03:52:12 | Cathy Shyr, Yan Hu, Paul A. Harris, Hua Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Rare diseases (RDs) are collectively common and affect 300 million people
worldwide. Accurate phenotyping is critical for informing diagnosis and
treatment, but RD phenotypes are often embedded in unstructured text and
time-consuming to extract manually. While natural language processing (NLP)
models can perform named entity recognition (NER) to automate extraction, a
major bottleneck is the development of a large, annotated corpus for model
training. Recently, prompt learning emerged as an NLP paradigm that can lead to
more generalizable results without any (zero-shot) or few labeled samples
(few-shot). Despite growing interest in ChatGPT, a revolutionary large language
model capable of following complex human prompts and generating high-quality
responses, none have studied its NER performance for RDs in the zero- and
few-shot settings. To this end, we engineered novel prompts aimed at extracting
RD phenotypes and, to the best of our knowledge, are the first the establish a
benchmark for evaluating ChatGPT's performance in these settings. We compared
its performance to the traditional fine-tuning approach and conducted an
in-depth error analysis. Overall, fine-tuning BioClinicalBERT resulted in
higher performance (F1 of 0.689) than ChatGPT (F1 of 0.472 and 0.591 in the
zero- and few-shot settings, respectively). Despite this, ChatGPT achieved
similar or higher accuracy for certain entities (i.e., rare diseases and signs)
in the one-shot setting (F1 of 0.776 and 0.725). This suggests that with
appropriate prompt engineering, ChatGPT has the potential to match or
outperform fine-tuned language models for certain entity types with just one
labeled sample. While the proliferation of large language models may provide
opportunities for supporting RD diagnosis and treatment, researchers and
clinicians should critically evaluate model outputs and be well-informed of
their limitations. | [
0.0211404487,
0.0188570302,
0.0110931993,
-0.0159838926,
0.0125335995,
0.0444692373,
0.0070947953,
0.0279114787,
0.0454804786,
-0.0434667952,
-0.0078121563,
-0.0206541736,
-0.0278839953,
0.0451925918,
-0.0069769034,
-0.0449903533,
0.0523793399,
-0.0064284867,
0.054896947,
0.0140434979,
-0.0210257899,
0.0121863792,
-0.0028919294,
0.0250808224,
0.0384992287,
-0.0275537744,
0.0401651412,
-0.0144417398,
0.0519476756,
-0.0789935887,
-0.0063774344,
0.050388597,
-0.0346289165,
0.024742581,
0.0000020951,
-0.0501819886,
-0.0276861135,
0.0378844105,
-0.0425802618,
-0.016357284,
0.0190688074,
-0.0208843201,
0.0073315832,
-0.0102524627,
-0.0108961575,
-0.0632644445,
0.0342134796,
0.065539673,
0.0132971676,
0.0657191202,
0.0003833848,
0.0324684829,
0.0548453778,
-0.0249523371,
0.0480975956,
-0.0421407074,
0.0505026132,
-0.0652427748,
0.0460758433,
0.0147705656,
0.0220577586,
0.0413888954,
-0.0361206867,
0.0263846833,
0.0062313294,
0.0597387403,
-0.0280925743,
-0.0471858457,
-0.0153944418,
0.0868225321,
-0.0275182147,
0.0138038155,
0.0411847718,
-0.0302713159,
0.0004233536,
0.0017144437,
0.0080817109,
0.0067892601,
-0.0487710647,
0.0077597089,
0.0239194948,
0.0004837762,
0.0152051654,
-0.0333030783,
0.0158731546,
-0.0159751549,
0.0089755002,
-0.0143360607,
0.0015372528,
-0.0080055976,
-0.0288557932,
-0.0682894662,
0.0034451596,
0.0152180893,
-0.0411626734,
0.0073861303,
-0.0109850056,
0.0095420713,
0.0980108827,
-0.0086150654,
0.0190785397,
0.0009662358,
-0.052398324,
0.0451809578,
-0.0101881474,
0.0082181618,
-0.0029361167,
0.0398509316,
0.0137762316,
0.0223464556,
-0.0678155646,
-0.0052731894,
-0.0153251663,
0.0271730665,
-0.0150999706,
-0.001989007,
-0.067439422,
-0.0223190151,
0.0080874935,
0.0111122532,
0.0317035578,
0.023242848,
-0.0133079076,
0.0182854533,
-0.0281062871,
0.0214794017,
-0.0014414035,
-0.025178276,
0.0046206592,
-0.0894111693,
0.0204076711,
-0.0436394587,
0.015045871,
-0.0259719733,
0.0589120686,
0.0894787535,
0.0287209358,
-0.0895582363,
0.0008728929,
-0.01009,
-0.0602418184,
-0.0138797257,
-0.0459839031,
-0.0430943146,
0.0430710167,
0.0280599594,
0.0056469804,
-0.0365161709,
0.0117424047,
-0.0093649225,
-0.0611131303,
0.0524805114,
-0.0625343844,
-0.0352402441,
0.0235256795,
0.0109290732,
-0.0174370185,
0.0250438824,
0.0019581716,
-0.0380629264,
0.0333775654,
-0.0121327052,
0.0248061791,
0.0026971761,
0.0234919023,
-0.028834803,
0.0345132276,
0.0081455801,
0.033771269,
0.0214940514,
0.0061722831,
0.0410906263,
0.0316041633,
-0.0267531108,
0.0470007099,
0.0859417692,
0.0220854469,
-0.0133112036,
0.0100488551,
0.0206567589,
-0.0095549142,
-0.0399324894,
-0.0007469535,
-0.0251502357,
-0.0360518098,
0.0183646511,
-0.0030739228,
0.030357305,
-0.00924493,
-0.0154739451,
-0.0485551283,
0.020813182,
-0.0241221413,
0.0089099417,
0.0080007277,
-0.0291407332,
-0.0209698975,
0.032252606,
0.0660285205,
0.009372578,
-0.0045350781,
-0.0616873279,
0.0169839151,
0.0359959975,
0.0031284341,
-0.0548913106,
-0.0184317082,
-0.0161805768,
-0.0217640866,
0.0120750992,
0.0115191871,
-0.0084366594,
0.0212456416,
0.0075703538,
0.0158921871,
0.0273032878,
0.0198048018,
-0.0096372226,
-0.0082372315,
0.0507953279,
-0.0411822721,
-0.0159385242,
-0.0226044357,
0.0421089567,
-0.0565564744,
-0.0711214319,
0.0205882322,
0.0048438115,
0.0068700695,
0.0145349316,
-0.0070889005,
0.0205818955,
-0.0264732242,
-0.0309863128,
-0.053035032,
-0.0246816799,
-0.016581716,
-0.0578607209,
-0.0098702693,
-0.0142057184,
-0.0387177877,
-0.035417188,
-0.0395523198,
-0.0112414639,
-0.0752918646,
-0.0064044925,
0.0004112104,
-0.0055366508,
0.0244654771,
0.0369630121,
0.0117561854,
-0.0375371277,
0.0398038588,
-0.0102540627,
0.0146089736,
0.0224377774,
-0.0577686317,
-0.0101197399,
-0.070132412,
-0.0320368446,
0.0163705479,
0.012832026,
-0.0094403615,
-0.0132255964,
0.006135013,
-0.0291605704,
0.0020308415,
-0.0759804398,
0.0322650895,
0.0241680369,
0.0170968734,
0.0073066419,
0.0274063703,
-0.0302812569,
-0.0462609604,
-0.0282007046,
-0.0018921284,
0.0347908325,
0.0337389372,
0.0592851602,
0.0422531478,
-0.0261293016,
-0.0294300411,
0.0087966444,
-0.0554753728,
0.0256148744,
0.0382741354,
-0.0338245332,
-0.0189632755,
0.0261286981,
-0.0266366489,
0.0219078343,
0.0252759848,
0.0163969509,
-0.0109668151,
-0.0007417088,
-0.0277983602,
0.0396277048,
-0.0004028299,
0.0391179137,
0.0147098573,
0.0281841755,
-0.0111698341,
0.0219455305,
-0.0661288947,
-0.0245170575,
0.0374528356,
-0.0287273694,
0.0475384891,
0.0837893933,
0.0232076645,
0.0090672262,
-0.0627794191,
0.0057323589,
-0.0110396082,
0.0170320738,
-0.0653144345,
0.0305942278,
-0.0353636369,
0.0394704156,
-0.0190517921,
-0.0417901017,
0.1031744406,
-0.0076330039,
0.029546421,
-0.0490611717,
-0.0048912158,
-0.0275168158,
0.0023065268,
0.0076443143,
0.0162374601,
0.0521296151,
-0.0420780666,
0.032732904,
0.0166886281,
-0.0069220006,
-0.0434911735,
0.03048517,
-0.0226788651,
0.0210569296,
-0.0056208218,
-0.0703235418,
-0.0311970245,
-0.031570185,
-0.0441564359,
0.0075480179,
0.0050103902,
-0.0182651617,
-0.0290846303,
0.0226831641,
-0.0201108828,
0.0610080399,
0.0199391972,
-0.0198361073,
-0.0115000037,
0.0230963696,
0.0452094004,
-0.0278970376,
0.0221487172,
-0.0155730946,
0.0677854046,
0.0673343688,
-0.0313285924,
0.0482072234,
0.0249260627,
0.038782768,
0.0049640676,
-0.0636028498,
-0.0138526764,
0.047858078,
0.0485490263,
-0.0324068256,
-0.0158201754,
0.1083011553,
0.0211952142,
-0.0590673573,
0.0185403619,
0.0058608567,
-0.0068554338,
-0.0209908653,
0.0450040475,
-0.1061605737,
-0.0630377904,
0.0072260587,
0.0252652112,
-0.0440501608,
-0.095890373,
-0.0026918363,
-0.0656938925,
0.0333100706,
-0.0115661891,
-0.0577806719,
-0.0014434856,
-0.0557842106,
0.0058221035,
-0.0203909744,
-0.0019076447,
-0.0299681704,
-0.0158539061,
0.0005608295,
0.0070171584,
-0.043708954,
-0.0775879249,
0.0773908496,
-0.023900602,
0.0501024574,
0.0507521927,
-0.0033237466,
0.0076160817,
-0.0072865859,
0.0092084827,
0.0023375642,
0.0222299453,
-0.0159141347,
0.0826845095,
-0.0071163327,
-0.0243366212,
-0.0845105946,
0.0304823741,
-0.0330071971,
-0.0287421383,
0.0071072625,
0.0984039307,
-0.0011873503,
-0.0322119854,
-0.0391328894,
-0.0256736837,
0.0302056782,
0.0739389285,
0.0051830369,
-0.0234247148,
-0.0268040616,
0.0153495828,
0.0125875026,
0.0137112178,
-0.03917915,
0.0629319325,
-0.0546863303,
-0.0441359431,
-0.0384358913,
-0.0191961955,
0.0614293292,
-0.0177253541,
0.0186719969,
0.0037923839,
0.0148519147,
0.0199437998,
-0.0326087996,
0.0937375575,
0.025151236,
-0.0158300158,
-0.1143498793,
-0.0441632904,
0.0556970872,
0.0166705828,
-0.0372908935,
-0.0032878951,
-0.0414639674,
-0.0480340794,
-0.0122575844,
0.0005165656,
0.0149928825,
0.0005577541,
0.0091596181,
-0.0385333523,
0.0716595873,
0.088841632,
-0.0264208671,
-0.0318938345,
-0.037864618,
-0.0001067397,
-0.0252970401,
0.0127956225,
-0.0261667091,
0.0395732895,
0.0372613333,
0.0302463416,
-0.016873749,
-0.0247961953,
0.033008121,
0.0578270927,
0.0967483744,
-0.0316000618,
-0.0740997121,
-0.0455296487,
-0.0190887433,
0.0217372496,
0.0262613092,
-0.0067065116,
-0.0150256101,
0.0027375387,
-0.0244936235,
-0.0542408377,
0.0114526087,
-0.0397204347,
0.0165260788,
-0.1049943194,
0.0518261418,
0.037518546,
0.0018398312,
0.0618501864,
-0.034482494,
0.0118095428,
0.0556222126,
0.0034842882,
0.0269655101,
-0.0218121391,
0.0663910806,
0.0161481854,
0.0429648347,
-0.0157466512,
0.0332251377,
-0.0216739774,
-0.03261723,
-0.02735007,
0.0749002695,
0.0236366615,
-0.0029050603,
0.0047267596,
0.0058360538,
-0.0250332374,
-0.0232316479,
0.0318207778,
-0.0297952592,
-0.0018722623,
0.0685424954,
0.0166239459,
-0.0500862896,
-0.0390410237,
0.046972651,
-0.0051796599,
0.0455285124,
0.0235917792,
-0.0288945232,
-0.0470089987,
0.0222470351,
0.0439068936,
-0.0457781181,
-0.0488070659,
0.0140537294,
-0.0634778067,
-0.0442903675,
0.0516283847,
-0.0049827467,
-0.0259897895,
0.0400623046,
0.0121079218,
0.0176464096,
0.027288964,
-0.0646197721,
-0.0355092064,
0.0243099574,
-0.0348753743,
-0.0327318944,
0.0092990678,
-6.235398764e-33,
-0.009642669,
-0.0068878992,
0.0189476032,
-0.0169207938,
0.0452265814,
0.0409498252,
-0.0156307183,
-0.000198398,
0.027862018,
0.0368925408,
-0.0344072767,
-0.0362567082,
0.0119996173,
0.0164492652,
-0.0071966057,
-0.0401990004,
0.0381803364,
0.0139314532,
-0.0348989032,
0.019176824,
0.0233131628,
0.0583474673,
0.0278227478,
-0.0419502705,
0.0113622481,
0.0164601151,
0.048013892,
0.0075753112,
0.0374399051,
0.0515548401,
-0.0569798201,
0.0329830311,
0.0308700036,
-0.0488673225,
-0.0092576984,
0.0302176513,
-0.0888763145,
-0.0187628251,
-0.0381125025,
-0.0147944046,
-0.0014045766,
-0.0183643829,
0.0162971634,
-0.0124151893,
-0.0304398295,
-0.0095930155,
0.0391140692,
-0.0237378944,
-0.026169017,
-0.0304640122,
-0.0349216089,
0.0484777763,
0.006706221,
0.0120477611,
0.0025755928,
-0.0010154051,
-0.0234770142,
0.0428246297,
-0.0177650377,
-0.006436863,
0.0564703532,
-0.0044609932,
0.0135818264,
-0.0044804872,
-0.0234243292,
0.0718363598,
0.0561108887,
-0.0372915119,
-0.0191291943,
0.0288704149,
-0.029000774,
0.0296133459,
0.0028356335,
0.0243494306,
0.040340215,
-0.0119281234,
-0.0651900917,
0.0369716473,
-0.0341783985,
-0.0178600959,
0.0185755305,
-0.032044135,
-0.0443199798,
-0.0043992219,
-0.0323638879,
0.0191734917,
-0.0375649706,
0.0060016494,
0.044967819,
-0.0186455306,
-0.0288395751,
0.0018301668,
0.0310477614,
0.0006643249,
-0.0607213825,
-0.0196002554,
0.0383245647,
0.0007954311,
-0.0379743092,
0.0154548967,
-0.0301068481,
-0.0381308123,
0.0261870138,
-0.0224012733,
0.0509067513,
0.0089224959,
0.0296966583,
-0.0284169465,
-0.0809838548,
0.0120696202,
0.0129596516,
0.0586163104,
0.0113185979,
0.0716057271,
0.024066167,
0.0023548452,
0.0052851574,
0.0670339018,
0.0206355006,
-0.0145333409,
-0.0286704395,
0.047671482,
-0.0213913843,
-0.0021730333,
-0.0277834777,
0.0084244171,
-0.0183473472,
0.0382451154,
0.0095832776,
-0.0508075245,
0.0049233455,
-0.0108549753,
2.768e-7,
0.0557802916,
0.051083494,
0.0057516005,
-0.0272049922,
0.0063421642,
0.0286526028,
0.0037966375,
0.0148046743,
-0.0004803951,
0.0083018569,
0.0118162241,
0.0234702397,
0.0031587984,
0.0255936999,
-0.0840499103,
-0.0087679429,
-0.0840413421,
0.0128640579,
-0.0482671596,
0.0167883504,
0.0360207222,
0.0876838267,
-0.0343838111,
-0.0289663058,
0.0437372662,
-0.0181983188,
0.0303094964,
-0.0311741289,
0.0152904633,
0.0436411202,
0.0147223687,
0.0086996732,
0.0269020554,
0.0438442267,
-0.0097617749,
-0.018922478,
-0.0447468385,
0.0856862739,
-0.0348244272,
-0.0082727009,
0.0143354088,
0.0133166304,
0.026230529,
-0.0275904145,
0.0639069676,
-0.0671974048,
-0.0412064865,
-0.0398568772,
-0.0008345243,
-0.0394350365,
0.0354879051,
-0.0190934613,
-0.0203853212,
0.0398646556,
0.0286799334,
0.0136206821,
-0.0109179607,
-0.082664296,
0.0090047447,
0.0188785195,
-0.0495307669,
-0.0282730684,
0.0190403089,
0.0131083829,
-0.0111977393,
-0.0971660912,
0.0112095475,
2.850911526e-34,
0.006853098,
0.0276759379,
-0.0053766021,
0.005425076,
0.0031177634,
0.0017514636,
0.0247291457,
-0.0075439578,
0.0035262702,
-0.0721289739,
-0.0059962161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12619v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12619v2 | Class-Incremental Learning based on Label Generation | 2023-06-22T01:14:47 | 2023-07-20T16:04:19 | Yijia Shao, Yiduo Guo, Dongyan Zhao, Bing Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE | Despite the great success of pre-trained language models, it is still a
challenge to use these models for continual learning, especially for the
class-incremental learning (CIL) setting due to catastrophic forgetting (CF).
This paper reports our finding that if we formulate CIL as a continual label
generation problem, CF is drastically reduced and the generalizable
representations of pre-trained models can be better retained. We thus propose a
new CIL method (VAG) that also leverages the sparsity of vocabulary to focus
the generation and creates pseudo-replay samples by using label semantics.
Experimental results show that VAG outperforms baselines by a large margin. | [
-0.0226554181,
0.0874100402,
-0.0001248077,
-0.0313661695,
-0.0172323231,
0.0234294664,
-0.0169639792,
-0.0174304862,
-0.0161539465,
-0.0597880259,
0.0247968268,
-0.0264276862,
-0.0527942032,
0.0256854184,
0.0210663062,
-0.0398680605,
0.0568499453,
-0.0071230042,
0.0172627028,
-0.005441749,
0.011575928,
-0.0234930348,
-0.0181043353,
0.0047552115,
-0.0569097102,
-0.0187493078,
-0.0337343886,
-0.0272845551,
-0.0030143328,
-0.0632159337,
0.0456264056,
0.0261315592,
0.06009119,
-0.0049833059,
0.000002211,
-0.0614462383,
-0.0586200878,
-0.0357468948,
-0.0148589425,
0.0037550312,
0.0284155831,
0.0460611619,
-0.006412074,
0.0153445499,
-0.0247316472,
-0.0503308922,
0.0177357998,
0.0260279216,
0.0591830723,
0.0383935571,
0.000058965,
-0.0574620888,
0.0343881473,
-0.0101199737,
0.039656356,
-0.0349036306,
0.0133862505,
0.0344455168,
-0.0314364284,
-0.0115051884,
0.006272722,
0.0591108426,
0.0249633584,
0.003445839,
0.032461632,
0.0434622504,
0.0215324871,
-0.0203298256,
-0.0216819867,
0.0195315275,
-0.0393411592,
-0.0646347553,
0.0027128409,
0.0012025093,
-0.0139157018,
-0.0820361823,
-0.0477594808,
0.0322211273,
-0.0118619939,
0.0207712017,
0.0055660778,
0.0100092692,
0.0089588044,
-0.0019023529,
-0.0410679951,
-0.043303851,
0.0330966897,
-0.0424304828,
-0.0089135366,
-0.0382013991,
-0.0302316193,
0.0191574208,
0.0042053526,
0.0599737614,
-0.0646211505,
0.0395854414,
-0.0212371945,
-0.0169616211,
0.0376719944,
-0.0334043801,
0.0307852738,
0.0086997198,
0.0080317063,
0.0249629654,
-0.0301887337,
0.0316839889,
0.0512121581,
0.0667279959,
-0.0273454227,
0.023337137,
-0.0663360953,
-0.0276573114,
-0.0995595604,
0.0796827897,
0.0804065391,
0.0291323978,
-0.0388006233,
0.0417638943,
-0.0097987987,
0.0264963321,
-0.0410832353,
-0.0137963379,
-0.0426904447,
0.0093837753,
0.0374991745,
0.0128895203,
0.0108918427,
-0.0239711497,
0.0305662937,
-0.0489378795,
0.0025754888,
-0.0181297436,
0.0134668918,
0.0184262414,
0.0283461083,
0.0567894913,
-0.0542688407,
-0.0856915191,
-0.0575146489,
0.0165506396,
0.0078212013,
-0.0405645408,
-0.0373883396,
-0.0490969941,
0.0067864177,
-0.0150442822,
0.012917445,
-0.0586361289,
0.011168059,
0.0460423082,
-0.0090970993,
0.0508442707,
-0.0205793288,
0.006907382,
0.0495750681,
-0.0031174861,
0.0553832948,
0.0277567357,
-0.0109471763,
-0.0196876228,
0.0292373672,
-0.0155298393,
0.0420039445,
0.0134071829,
0.0362701155,
0.0169697348,
-0.0827150717,
-0.0355279334,
0.0759612396,
0.0277784597,
0.007621408,
0.0148966769,
-0.0233153589,
0.0338670388,
0.0386074036,
-0.0334716663,
0.0022006757,
0.0296144765,
0.043734137,
-0.0092567028,
-0.0015085086,
0.0129251583,
-0.0358971544,
-0.0020395759,
-0.0074786837,
0.0306552853,
0.0030606969,
-0.0264849328,
-0.0535228997,
-0.0581886433,
0.0157256201,
-0.0210429467,
-0.0202381369,
0.000846067,
0.0588734783,
0.0784128606,
-0.0556229986,
0.0748048499,
0.0457162224,
-0.052268859,
0.0048076548,
-0.0293522906,
0.0085767014,
0.0253335051,
0.0439213924,
-0.0465484262,
-0.0380873084,
-0.0138011687,
0.0059720976,
-0.0052166036,
0.0260317586,
-0.0120388316,
0.0016704937,
-0.0660043284,
-0.0034100339,
0.034535639,
0.0307917986,
0.0166796818,
0.0166656673,
0.0100564193,
0.0088594379,
-0.0316898338,
-0.0828022584,
0.0402363315,
-0.0272191204,
-0.046951469,
-0.0084605161,
-0.0138916541,
-0.0251628067,
-0.020738855,
-0.0211108364,
0.0204445962,
0.0686584041,
-0.0219171327,
-0.0279003829,
-0.0152302468,
-0.0827444494,
-0.0189374909,
0.0425209217,
0.0328505114,
0.0041326061,
-0.0392473154,
-0.0295836721,
-0.0270305313,
-0.0071726288,
0.0103196716,
0.0572440736,
-0.0542852841,
0.0549676269,
-0.0229962785,
-0.0217940658,
-0.0586451776,
0.0474334769,
-0.0070601874,
0.037413843,
-0.0081102895,
0.0300663337,
-0.0011494203,
-0.0794168338,
-0.0266048051,
0.0148007143,
-0.0379289947,
0.0261999108,
0.0124132298,
0.0355143882,
-0.056901183,
-0.0094745522,
-0.0333231427,
-0.0081466828,
-0.0303015169,
-0.0174593572,
-0.0005770469,
0.0002580445,
-0.0082747554,
-0.0517317727,
-0.0128410803,
-0.0000408926,
-0.0240545608,
0.0187636651,
-0.0001574705,
0.0103646191,
-0.001960713,
-0.0245764311,
-0.0012253204,
0.0260776337,
0.0444812514,
-0.0227489546,
-0.002930186,
-0.0537454151,
0.0504349619,
-0.0126994923,
0.0360318869,
0.0057742363,
-0.023131134,
0.0134804379,
-0.0599080399,
0.0307301413,
0.0045755808,
0.0320999324,
0.0261987876,
0.0388914384,
-0.0150236962,
-0.0422235355,
0.0024251882,
-0.0564076379,
-0.0979313776,
0.00902077,
0.0140519617,
-0.0036779586,
0.055904977,
-0.032780055,
0.0165190268,
-0.0008439476,
-0.0219510719,
-0.0302577987,
-0.0049253474,
-0.0883862674,
0.0138358539,
-0.0416791365,
-0.0252885129,
0.0233234763,
-0.0546046048,
0.0070853243,
0.0127922371,
0.0041528493,
-0.0431898125,
-0.0119555285,
0.0112737529,
0.0438752994,
0.0361815579,
0.0204397254,
0.0417496338,
-0.0500055552,
-0.0584939085,
0.0078589739,
0.0089660119,
-0.0126066823,
-0.0096625425,
-0.016652815,
0.015150778,
0.0273293946,
0.0016795164,
-0.0888100117,
-0.0539136231,
0.0107360398,
0.0128602237,
-0.0697948933,
0.0588227659,
-0.038512975,
-0.0093676643,
-0.0018845453,
0.0378865451,
0.0202250741,
-0.0151028596,
-0.010681631,
0.0493728332,
0.0008087134,
0.0063398778,
0.020980997,
0.0055502388,
0.0420646258,
0.0594595261,
0.0882090703,
0.0258219633,
-0.0071619535,
0.0016687134,
-0.0141290603,
-0.0332189202,
0.0044011651,
0.0285648908,
-0.0335696042,
-0.0583928004,
-0.0674926788,
0.0857825056,
0.0354965553,
-0.0695642307,
-0.0055255578,
0.021268962,
0.0576256402,
0.0489977375,
0.0049850573,
-0.0331716798,
0.0008083363,
0.0263700783,
0.0302301273,
-0.0058919974,
-0.0137261627,
-0.0134127755,
-0.0777894258,
-0.0056475415,
0.0316779949,
-0.0391316712,
0.0480235927,
-0.0313089676,
-0.0455837734,
0.0108360695,
0.0180200096,
0.0479798093,
-0.0120541863,
0.0105602713,
0.0378068089,
-0.0266258493,
-0.0383968987,
0.0015590813,
-0.0124782827,
0.0233012047,
0.0353973508,
0.0410245731,
0.0067068143,
-0.0354581289,
0.1356970221,
-0.0914030001,
-0.0016277332,
0.0056284107,
0.04217273,
0.0136241578,
-0.0353392176,
0.0320841931,
0.0304857343,
-0.0256474726,
-0.0359690748,
0.021729257,
0.0124284774,
0.0034095664,
0.0057441127,
0.0174665395,
-0.034327846,
0.0197311789,
0.0360399634,
0.0176371988,
-0.059711922,
-0.0288383532,
0.0114355637,
0.0500441417,
-0.019399127,
0.010219045,
0.0569984205,
-0.0511891581,
-0.0397613384,
-0.0421571396,
-0.0447504632,
0.006292454,
0.0506653413,
0.000214937,
-0.0136329196,
-0.0130652366,
0.0090037826,
-0.0585468523,
-0.0183309205,
-0.0313104279,
-0.0193254389,
-0.0731397942,
-0.0244754311,
0.0260598883,
-0.0081343558,
-0.0182180218,
-0.0166023616,
-0.046908576,
-0.0286390129,
0.0674667284,
0.0664596185,
0.0014431623,
0.0510548055,
0.0022810283,
-0.0265855417,
0.076980859,
0.0450306274,
0.0023491236,
0.0271411873,
0.0039625489,
-0.0280823596,
-0.0090555362,
0.0283962898,
-0.0272086877,
0.0182056148,
0.0236714166,
0.0601784326,
-0.0013845701,
0.0582770444,
0.060775958,
-0.0050987997,
0.0325950384,
-0.025676176,
0.0266512856,
-0.0153023694,
0.0233306009,
0.0166556314,
-0.0256805141,
-0.0049388716,
0.0325479619,
0.0046008239,
0.0092374859,
0.0084754322,
-0.0291501731,
-0.0194335282,
0.0387058631,
0.0205916371,
-0.045840282,
-0.000491,
0.0287373215,
0.0251578372,
0.0235758163,
-0.0448167212,
0.0196857825,
-0.0071637719,
0.025587013,
-0.0336915478,
0.0438389629,
0.0365382247,
0.0002379573,
-0.0650113374,
0.0083019603,
-0.0163591206,
-0.0132890642,
-0.0480725504,
0.0338561423,
0.0786887705,
0.0210899692,
0.0298627149,
-0.022474125,
-0.0046539446,
-0.0470093377,
0.0191619229,
0.0049961484,
-0.0863965899,
-0.0305404942,
0.0024876308,
-0.0085867494,
0.0150784608,
0.0691427216,
-0.0133853927,
0.0266388711,
-0.0098744361,
0.0289612859,
-0.043242719,
0.046365954,
0.0031378206,
0.0807565451,
0.031620197,
0.0131006474,
-0.0134593211,
-0.0507816039,
0.0262945648,
-0.0044734236,
0.0115861995,
0.0139598176,
0.0402536094,
0.0452321395,
-0.0254145358,
0.0421513692,
-0.0155115314,
0.0274581257,
0.0327401385,
-0.0208817776,
0.0021637776,
-6.364390167e-33,
-0.0282302629,
-0.0137280775,
0.0230607428,
0.0118521685,
-0.0419191383,
0.0066100433,
-0.0373220593,
0.0266352482,
0.0494469628,
0.0151167605,
-0.0112704951,
-0.0191321485,
-0.0055434243,
0.0571881048,
0.0381352529,
-0.022292627,
0.035478726,
-0.000699536,
0.0043474506,
0.0536080375,
0.0741490051,
0.0835381523,
0.0569799803,
-0.0522171892,
-0.0153734656,
-0.008156267,
-0.0190369282,
0.0203104783,
0.0085402448,
0.043491032,
-0.01925027,
0.0620621108,
0.0258985125,
-0.019530654,
-0.0264829863,
-0.0373013914,
-0.1043642163,
-0.0276402514,
-0.0447605513,
0.0233986787,
0.0102198338,
-0.0276086852,
0.020996118,
-0.0483704992,
-0.0112698833,
0.0110885641,
0.0339500792,
-0.0303740017,
-0.0769860819,
-0.0334170759,
-0.0535645671,
-0.0171190631,
0.0107317306,
-0.0224126112,
-0.0305221509,
-0.0198606886,
-0.0334987566,
-0.0178702157,
-0.0596785955,
0.0145405,
0.0138697643,
0.020759616,
-0.0091726054,
0.045527108,
0.0040113595,
0.0456607938,
0.0400315188,
-0.009563433,
0.0330409594,
-0.0046676556,
0.0633463785,
-0.0251746513,
0.0110678272,
-0.0088828104,
0.0431854352,
-0.0382059067,
-0.0167986881,
-0.0035190126,
-0.0060721771,
0.0464073084,
0.0439253524,
0.0205354039,
0.0033929916,
-0.0374889448,
-0.0699909851,
-0.0171757825,
-0.039487876,
-0.0071886415,
0.0592522584,
0.0614233315,
0.0103009036,
-0.0333975852,
0.0239535403,
-0.0020066493,
-0.0515440963,
-0.0092992038,
-0.0294020064,
0.0136362594,
-0.0308270622,
0.0002596121,
-0.0121731469,
-0.0298547167,
-0.0175144169,
-0.0199722666,
-0.0155858574,
0.0276531279,
0.0634800494,
0.0418118984,
-0.0529486686,
0.0099167228,
-0.017289266,
-0.0121868029,
0.0257562436,
0.0004363082,
0.0355467908,
0.019890612,
-0.0072261514,
0.0813298821,
0.0437064171,
-0.0333632194,
-0.0277601555,
0.0285568684,
0.024887884,
0.0592776909,
-0.0285202786,
0.0008562189,
-0.0430463478,
0.0132248104,
0.0246062931,
-0.0804450884,
0.0356589481,
-0.0107797422,
2.788e-7,
-0.0109041492,
0.01660675,
0.0026008054,
-0.0680670142,
0.0359989218,
0.0309430659,
-0.0315441713,
0.0116636623,
0.0090384353,
0.0617413707,
0.0062249885,
-0.0158200916,
0.0052159615,
-0.0199146718,
-0.0829494447,
0.0441751666,
-0.0677654967,
0.0030018769,
-0.0400011204,
0.025964804,
0.0458390564,
0.0642892942,
0.0188190788,
-0.0304839686,
0.0209068004,
-0.0283705499,
0.0713356659,
0.0114782648,
0.0012263461,
0.0223582499,
-0.0101030115,
0.0690076947,
0.0012977952,
-0.0066683399,
-0.0235886928,
-0.0382241122,
0.0220011026,
-0.0185841974,
-0.0032350305,
-0.0463856906,
0.0363151617,
0.0588065721,
-0.0176834986,
-0.0446999706,
0.0414069667,
-0.1072489992,
0.0070477161,
0.0234348513,
-0.0250191484,
0.0156617239,
-0.0066901958,
0.0214463249,
-0.0403105691,
0.0289314892,
-0.0112739066,
0.0812945291,
-0.0297770388,
-0.0784547925,
-0.000462485,
0.0360003859,
-0.0252276845,
-0.0363169611,
-0.0345915779,
-0.0197991654,
0.0486447178,
-0.0505447388,
0.0032780217,
2.100551008e-34,
0.0204299167,
-0.0130511494,
0.0106292535,
0.0108799767,
-0.024347201,
-0.0163253918,
0.0672922283,
0.0371613689,
0.0129004708,
-0.0355546214,
0.0074481852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12596v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12596v1 | A Hierarchical Approach to exploiting Multiple Datasets from TalkBank | 2023-06-21T22:37:51 | 2023-06-21T22:37:51 | Man Ho Wong | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL | TalkBank is an online database that facilitates the sharing of linguistics
research data. However, the existing TalkBank's API has limited data filtering
and batch processing capabilities. To overcome these limitations, this paper
introduces a pipeline framework that employs a hierarchical search approach,
enabling efficient complex data selection. This approach involves a quick
preliminary screening of relevant corpora that a researcher may need, and then
perform an in-depth search for target data based on specific criteria. The
identified files are then indexed, providing easier access for future analysis.
Furthermore, the paper demonstrates how data from different studies curated
with the framework can be integrated by standardizing and cleaning metadata,
allowing researchers to extract insights from a large, integrated dataset.
While being designed for TalkBank, the framework can also be adapted to process
data from other open-science platforms. | [
0.0715414435,
0.1038437784,
-0.0649618581,
0.0019268903,
-0.0239048228,
0.012243947,
0.0174208023,
0.0134517131,
0.0133403372,
-0.0284572653,
-0.052388873,
-0.0154616656,
0.0268590823,
0.0231192522,
0.0117614456,
-0.0554257371,
0.0703121647,
0.0195816122,
0.045685444,
0.02230932,
0.0030061856,
0.0374279805,
0.0200087167,
0.0299318675,
0.0159865245,
0.0042461162,
0.0286832619,
-0.0108013023,
-0.0048186039,
-0.0183757842,
0.030048551,
0.0553875789,
-0.0166261382,
0.042826239,
0.0000021066,
-0.0363492705,
-0.0425873324,
-0.0028269251,
-0.0109395264,
-0.0435799211,
0.091744408,
0.010994982,
-0.011524694,
-0.0096098706,
-0.0079797711,
-0.0541804954,
0.0999579355,
-0.0580704436,
0.0342137069,
0.0286871027,
-0.0259447936,
-0.0315121822,
-0.0107132737,
0.0089663742,
-0.0183047373,
0.0356949307,
0.0328597613,
-0.0092624612,
0.0714419782,
-0.0096871359,
0.0201581363,
0.0287020467,
-0.0572273768,
-0.0591794439,
-0.0073818993,
-0.00569969,
-0.0710885152,
-0.1018288732,
0.0327703692,
0.0321644135,
-0.002252213,
-0.0262387693,
0.0282360595,
-0.0122467251,
-0.0406504758,
0.012794178,
-0.0472567342,
0.0222928822,
-0.0349401534,
-0.0040918752,
0.0339989439,
0.0104803359,
0.0089967092,
0.0094713643,
-0.0323315486,
0.0829821527,
0.0141769927,
-0.0133450171,
0.0504494682,
-0.0206204224,
0.0222712364,
-0.060506016,
0.0396072082,
-0.0185530577,
-0.0306387302,
0.0419705696,
0.0252858996,
-0.0668053478,
0.0608884208,
0.0020849565,
-0.0183148794,
0.0194360912,
-0.0322768837,
0.0192129128,
0.0798314288,
-0.043255493,
0.0090550808,
-0.0566970333,
-0.0203226358,
-0.0386122093,
-0.0434074327,
-0.0161731616,
-0.041489426,
0.0022864605,
-0.0267426353,
0.0156727992,
-0.0428486951,
0.0064755953,
-0.0210226625,
-0.041875612,
0.0003980396,
-0.0130005488,
-0.0041803275,
0.0424508229,
-0.0080319019,
0.0297047105,
-0.0299568884,
-0.0089219883,
-0.0305585489,
-0.102212362,
0.026118122,
0.0091954153,
0.027387863,
-0.0237254556,
0.0255820435,
0.0112249497,
0.0480149165,
-0.0270633288,
-0.0142780039,
-0.0418674275,
-0.0063368934,
-0.0368296467,
0.0062967567,
-0.0305985902,
0.0722569749,
0.0080935387,
0.0007395268,
-0.0271739196,
-0.0078514554,
0.0368929692,
-0.0468166843,
0.0039320625,
-0.0501457788,
-0.0103710042,
0.0510906354,
-0.004917881,
-0.0060160425,
0.0519695841,
-0.0084235324,
-0.0470698476,
0.08936809,
-0.0283574834,
-0.0235692952,
0.033574082,
0.0086119315,
-0.0347192921,
0.0403795354,
0.0164287966,
0.0085603483,
0.0409811288,
0.0182477217,
0.0464582406,
-0.0372036956,
-0.0042325947,
0.0141947176,
0.1458528936,
0.0140100475,
-0.0167682953,
0.0195713043,
0.0283897594,
0.0212670434,
-0.0441421457,
0.0215741042,
-0.0006720183,
0.0655197799,
-0.0408882909,
-0.0175894834,
0.0513353869,
0.0457519889,
0.0051150369,
-0.0227779336,
0.0385104194,
-0.022021858,
-0.0070359008,
0.0043923897,
-0.0144199291,
0.0114791803,
0.0415979177,
0.0651693344,
-0.065935038,
-0.0020524999,
0.0078584738,
-0.0010702015,
0.039001517,
0.0360126272,
-0.0330181085,
0.0025392626,
-0.0118771084,
-0.0043354123,
0.0347981267,
-0.0006929733,
-0.0430204719,
0.0128329089,
-0.0472980924,
-0.0001849716,
0.0234840401,
0.0065418365,
-0.0018461467,
-0.0252378453,
0.0325639248,
-0.0178035311,
-0.0087924376,
-0.0019142036,
0.0269638374,
-0.0092899026,
0.0276518632,
0.0119885579,
-0.0072742328,
0.0650249198,
0.0250281598,
-0.0191257894,
0.008529027,
0.0101003675,
0.0147890495,
0.0449349321,
0.0409346297,
0.0251902007,
0.0566600785,
-0.0070134462,
-0.0361088067,
0.0057419133,
-0.0069340826,
0.0137360804,
-0.0252381954,
0.0099260323,
-0.0374375992,
0.0840937421,
-0.003686988,
0.0050811558,
-0.0172178224,
0.0429770984,
-0.0274914503,
0.0184654538,
0.0477524549,
0.0295667686,
-0.014985336,
-0.0391944908,
0.0639888346,
-0.0539512821,
0.0114159426,
0.0712778047,
-0.0172564015,
-0.0424339026,
0.0286813676,
-0.03464555,
-0.0660277158,
0.0186838619,
-0.1078673303,
0.0059867604,
0.0098860487,
0.0548501685,
-0.0170871615,
0.0345728919,
-0.0220351908,
0.0007543251,
0.0056526447,
0.0150823044,
0.0022804094,
0.02066819,
-0.00559778,
0.0033034254,
-0.0101333326,
-0.0435994491,
-0.0153691918,
-0.0051973234,
0.069335334,
0.0053356173,
-0.1105346605,
0.0327348299,
-0.0423872881,
-0.040939223,
-0.0097080749,
0.0001460187,
-0.0136537254,
-0.0032281107,
0.0124147115,
-0.0194054563,
0.0155505072,
-0.0315207094,
0.0126140341,
0.0287517533,
-0.0418314561,
-0.033518564,
-0.0167120751,
0.0162243135,
0.0426689535,
0.0100173978,
-0.0500614159,
0.0463215411,
0.0119398385,
0.0148612661,
-0.0047894632,
0.0145175029,
0.0073351087,
-0.0519346409,
-0.0196261462,
-0.0018466889,
-0.0364713781,
-0.0148757128,
0.0610886253,
-0.0106058372,
-0.0554059334,
0.0270756036,
-0.0050042546,
-0.0250402577,
-0.0612656251,
-0.0393136255,
-0.0298099127,
0.0750404373,
-0.0003936732,
0.0096226446,
0.0491140075,
-0.0684354901,
0.0269177537,
-0.0217249524,
0.0349038243,
-0.0107690403,
0.0134888813,
-0.066439487,
0.0080242455,
0.009940723,
-0.0222117174,
0.0117606791,
-0.0107273133,
-0.017878456,
0.001686507,
0.0558352359,
-0.0312895067,
-0.031099461,
-0.0014141848,
-0.0037734464,
0.0683352575,
0.0134016583,
-0.0020157841,
0.0059604221,
-0.0116129639,
-0.0107591478,
-0.0197894257,
-0.0020979382,
0.0544465035,
0.0007587988,
0.0108324811,
-0.0528333969,
-0.0337607488,
0.0433010198,
0.0286774598,
0.0438729823,
-0.0563238375,
-0.0239193197,
-0.0258250609,
0.0057468996,
-0.0770833716,
-0.0304034799,
0.0665413737,
0.0466119573,
-0.0266269818,
0.0187217575,
-0.0332525745,
0.0081749083,
0.0071153413,
0.0486128218,
-0.066796124,
0.0147468057,
0.0183610786,
0.0332500152,
-0.0548857525,
-0.0482324027,
-0.0238312576,
-0.0571461357,
0.0661184043,
0.0039959354,
-0.0808764696,
0.0190439783,
-0.0516265333,
0.0216195863,
-0.0168233681,
-0.0281218123,
0.0026893923,
-0.0195019394,
-0.0210493095,
0.0160591267,
-0.0493014194,
-0.0356967486,
0.0246977881,
-0.053225942,
0.0263936687,
-0.0047652861,
0.0671072975,
-0.0152319372,
0.0188747477,
0.0049882419,
-0.0128368791,
-0.0536943637,
-0.0510629304,
0.0249360651,
0.0382955521,
-0.0059937034,
-0.0376157947,
0.0173650794,
-0.0338516943,
-0.019276211,
0.0046225693,
0.0803506896,
-0.0387038887,
0.0162031278,
-0.0157343559,
0.0231351499,
0.0458120555,
0.0465282947,
0.0027775522,
-0.0037561038,
0.0248322729,
-0.0071216542,
-0.0371851325,
0.002300916,
-0.0458517149,
0.0327633247,
-0.0518323593,
-0.0529167131,
-0.0839485675,
-0.0483814999,
0.0054378314,
0.0258158594,
0.0417215638,
0.0271957498,
0.0248788018,
0.004857461,
-0.0424211435,
0.0462704413,
0.0244207717,
0.0171114933,
-0.0448972993,
-0.0689908564,
0.0493927486,
0.0061888266,
-0.0253445152,
0.0446782559,
-0.0459954068,
-0.0467741787,
0.0360557325,
-0.0241430644,
0.029230712,
0.0263178181,
0.0276983771,
-0.052589301,
0.0326386206,
0.030563714,
-0.0720183104,
-0.0166164078,
0.0210978091,
-0.0392399728,
0.0004930086,
0.0118771894,
-0.0020946492,
0.0137936026,
0.0018393818,
-0.0209224336,
-0.0047147237,
-0.0332804285,
0.0029980994,
-0.0112389727,
0.0217195675,
-0.0388632454,
-0.0273604169,
-0.074135676,
0.006000096,
-0.0116745243,
-0.0103266351,
-0.0112972744,
-0.0034889183,
0.0114696519,
-0.0104473382,
-0.040975444,
0.014233781,
-0.0664923489,
0.0093532046,
0.0074080899,
0.054252483,
0.0100384513,
0.03345019,
0.0146988416,
-0.00486852,
0.0124517037,
0.0113844704,
-0.0463510975,
0.0634640828,
-0.0440153964,
-0.0033112881,
-0.0133616831,
-0.0136629185,
0.0117986398,
0.0053781662,
-0.0474784561,
-0.0100192316,
0.0061581363,
-0.0792521909,
0.0301186368,
-0.051243607,
0.0746232048,
-0.0367615409,
-0.0163273569,
-0.0112541541,
-0.0014746021,
-0.0290954672,
-0.0472227037,
-0.0094916588,
-0.0089211958,
-0.0418296531,
-0.0144201703,
0.0376170166,
-0.0200511888,
0.0448631085,
0.0151025718,
-0.0265261307,
-0.0089761075,
-0.0494417436,
0.0476500839,
0.0135695357,
-0.0239739195,
-0.0382842161,
-0.0605496354,
-0.0287236888,
0.0033808777,
-0.017213963,
-0.0417296775,
0.0140784839,
0.0320938081,
0.0608560145,
0.0416535288,
0.0010121218,
-0.0541030727,
0.0265024733,
-0.0621363297,
-0.007332481,
-0.0079119969,
-6.631813662e-33,
-0.0168155022,
-0.0262725782,
-0.0155530358,
0.0279927403,
0.0110262753,
-0.0018676167,
-0.039593257,
-0.0471769758,
-0.020285042,
0.0200787,
-0.0214179456,
0.0043417984,
0.0284572523,
-0.0124402037,
0.0558421612,
0.0756959617,
-0.0033463235,
0.0052262531,
0.0017771285,
0.0025441956,
0.0806881115,
0.0315821394,
0.0698187947,
-0.0631757081,
0.0456862301,
0.042239029,
0.0097385915,
0.041322805,
0.0106800534,
0.050100673,
-0.008805505,
0.0510849804,
-0.0040077069,
-0.0106029548,
-0.0135811381,
0.0333562195,
-0.0688199401,
-0.0351864435,
0.0251690671,
0.0397663713,
0.0419880264,
-0.0258618202,
0.0316652246,
-0.0435744151,
0.0256149024,
0.0318901353,
-0.0049962085,
-0.0224501137,
-0.0360055901,
-0.0114362277,
-0.0406998433,
0.0139534073,
-0.0091602281,
0.0652026981,
0.0403471142,
0.0130334599,
0.006341605,
-0.0110937096,
-0.0257517733,
0.0509070717,
-0.0071232626,
0.058288604,
0.0254444405,
-0.0139678093,
0.0100099342,
0.0621993057,
0.058786951,
-0.0248003826,
0.1139678508,
0.0441056527,
0.0315776281,
0.0257643368,
-0.0006537471,
0.0508258566,
0.0516335182,
-0.0234916452,
-0.026633909,
-0.0204742774,
0.0446901545,
0.0154290777,
-0.0569050014,
0.0079372181,
0.0112311682,
-0.0263598226,
-0.0124045508,
-0.061419297,
-0.0150545789,
0.0042394977,
-0.0143833803,
-0.0563438423,
0.0295638125,
0.0500785932,
0.0398093536,
0.0065670907,
-0.0168128852,
0.0164097641,
0.0087114023,
0.0146731883,
0.0108226594,
0.0376266688,
-0.033265464,
-0.0184028391,
0.0214695595,
0.0279550981,
0.0461281613,
-0.0058213375,
-0.004616031,
0.0152279446,
-0.057888262,
-0.0103365928,
-0.0393323451,
0.0152866924,
-0.0289648995,
0.0216677636,
0.0328201726,
0.0343248248,
0.0175488871,
0.0328744613,
0.0583426841,
0.018899681,
-0.0374851376,
0.0031495027,
-0.0219716989,
0.0050166212,
-0.0068211304,
0.0141018294,
-0.018241087,
-0.0208038855,
0.0695118159,
-0.0158747006,
0.0225747451,
0.0019402092,
3.04e-7,
0.0424999669,
0.0615327619,
-0.0281368848,
0.0309660807,
0.0458496697,
-0.0333613977,
-0.0152504342,
-0.0084015755,
0.000275586,
-0.0115591465,
0.0077534583,
-0.0646024495,
0.0655953586,
0.0685200617,
-0.1281162649,
-0.0555508286,
-0.0444173925,
-0.0710853785,
-0.0745518878,
-0.0043640402,
0.0092640258,
0.1146257669,
0.0241458062,
-0.0428810231,
-0.0420190319,
0.0060829716,
-0.0004558109,
-0.0506903045,
0.0173758231,
0.0667715445,
0.0286068339,
-0.0051256213,
0.0128625752,
0.0200992562,
-0.0700158253,
0.0131798852,
-0.0168788638,
0.0044058869,
-0.0004422786,
0.0053763431,
0.0069332095,
-0.0355727486,
-0.0311470926,
-0.0463340729,
0.0380563624,
-0.0175927784,
-0.0271206032,
0.0103610046,
-0.010969202,
0.007123685,
0.0139035685,
-0.0575901791,
-0.0077655199,
0.054391291,
0.0145186326,
-0.020730624,
-0.0129679292,
-0.0552508347,
0.0141013423,
0.0136427069,
-0.0472140275,
-0.0447675362,
0.0044022258,
-0.0392170735,
0.009633976,
-0.0380673297,
0.0308259316,
2.944291925e-34,
-0.0050432803,
0.0021037508,
0.005740751,
0.0057862657,
0.0379547663,
-0.0201758053,
0.0284154899,
0.0553242378,
-0.0355945006,
-0.0220208298,
-0.008475489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12587v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12587v1 | ARIES: A Corpus of Scientific Paper Edits Made in Response to Peer Reviews | 2023-06-21T22:00:03 | 2023-06-21T22:00:03 | Mike D'Arcy, Alexis Ross, Erin Bransom, Bailey Kuehl, Jonathan Bragg, Tom Hope, Doug Downey | cs.CL | cs.CL | Revising scientific papers based on peer feedback is a challenging task that
requires not only deep scientific knowledge and reasoning, but also the ability
to recognize the implicit requests in high-level feedback and to choose the
best of many possible ways to update the manuscript in response. We introduce
this task for large language models and release ARIES, a dataset of review
comments and their corresponding paper edits, to enable training and evaluating
models. We study two versions of the task: comment-edit alignment and edit
generation, and evaluate several baselines, including GPT-4. We find that
models struggle even to identify the edits that correspond to a comment,
especially in cases where the comment is phrased in an indirect way or where
the edit addresses the spirit of a comment but not the precise request. When
tasked with generating edits, GPT-4 often succeeds in addressing comments on a
surface level, but it rigidly follows the wording of the feedback rather than
the underlying intent, and includes fewer technical details than human-written
edits. We hope that our formalization, dataset, and analysis will form a
foundation for future work in this area. | [
0.0898826942,
0.0547631532,
0.0377619229,
-0.0188474171,
-0.0389701016,
-0.0104313735,
-0.0057155909,
-0.0102396142,
-0.0431738794,
-0.0458174273,
-0.0537190214,
-0.0004340333,
-0.0079748165,
0.0017080408,
-0.0023770363,
-0.0501655787,
0.0247769188,
0.0108605092,
0.0410781503,
0.0200265013,
0.0181112196,
0.0117763644,
0.0119868787,
0.0250443146,
0.040148899,
-0.0671879351,
0.0058219968,
-0.0104145473,
0.0091163991,
0.0107511748,
0.0275142547,
0.1098475531,
0.0084987693,
0.129126966,
0.0000015544,
-0.0529013202,
-0.0206651185,
0.0407954939,
0.0239399262,
0.0697103888,
0.0395574085,
-0.0779377446,
-0.0294374526,
-0.0374086872,
-0.0219264403,
-0.0528693944,
0.051004272,
0.0550580025,
0.0677461773,
0.0847735479,
-0.0035399694,
-0.0235396568,
0.0168447904,
-0.0241195466,
0.0247122124,
-0.0151134692,
0.0474925749,
0.0053175287,
-0.0208531525,
0.0637864321,
0.0257567596,
-0.0029225599,
0.0078895316,
-0.0885906592,
0.0331309699,
0.0017205005,
-0.0272820145,
0.0151767982,
0.0048402073,
0.0231783576,
0.0313561559,
-0.0431070216,
0.0139101213,
0.0045859376,
-0.030203402,
0.0463636741,
-0.045582518,
-0.0113861244,
0.0054552816,
-0.0397242121,
0.0093158996,
-0.0538921282,
0.0376397409,
0.036112383,
0.063930504,
0.0479673147,
0.0456391908,
-0.0520913899,
-0.0377402082,
-0.0000489747,
0.002520686,
-0.0658666641,
-0.0240164679,
0.0086221267,
-0.0174696427,
-0.0232199598,
-0.0182796456,
-0.0134254238,
0.0419226289,
-0.024739787,
0.038281776,
0.0024923878,
0.0041680424,
0.0450108461,
0.003065624,
-0.0046451632,
-0.0240168851,
-0.0054132855,
0.0042450768,
0.0065113869,
-0.0581720658,
-0.0238518696,
-0.0248285886,
0.0021977006,
-0.0083194999,
0.0114328787,
-0.0644244105,
0.0126100294,
-0.0060392632,
0.0244185794,
0.052489765,
0.0106842415,
-0.0645121187,
-0.0237457119,
-0.0024148566,
0.0436351933,
0.0205582287,
0.0240484141,
0.0093576284,
0.0211469308,
-0.0191210154,
-0.0021990018,
-0.0000793206,
-0.0701838583,
-0.0142929042,
0.0311306827,
0.0266836733,
0.0093662469,
0.0047815661,
-0.0279360916,
0.0019031663,
-0.0516099744,
-0.0130969901,
-0.0603412054,
0.0269055627,
-0.0252624638,
-0.0263571255,
-0.0720715746,
-0.0214331206,
-0.0312506333,
-0.0049138521,
0.0479701236,
-0.0598359518,
-0.0157756265,
0.0405910201,
-0.0014432096,
-0.0317492299,
-0.0164624359,
0.030353602,
-0.0409803577,
0.0510435998,
-0.0413772799,
0.015798768,
0.0029305415,
-0.0042536953,
0.0132849989,
0.0104798991,
0.0069249352,
-0.0110820169,
0.0597505942,
0.018368382,
0.0302918628,
-0.0425434746,
-0.0340420865,
0.0623585172,
0.0172198415,
-0.0278964899,
0.0579020754,
0.0174894575,
-0.0166771691,
0.0183276962,
-0.0035635016,
-0.0219482351,
0.0419706777,
0.0167793371,
0.0156845208,
0.0455874987,
-0.0362261795,
-0.0020387864,
-0.0190600511,
-0.0006325681,
0.0092756134,
-0.0264445953,
-0.0430545621,
0.0535203256,
0.0078735873,
-0.0255681388,
-0.0002560357,
0.0195346512,
-0.0326307043,
0.019139288,
-0.0154274032,
0.0355287641,
0.0223192405,
0.0682851002,
-0.0333127603,
-0.0426253565,
-0.0349241346,
-0.0014312631,
0.0442306027,
0.0719699934,
-0.0415327176,
-0.025454713,
-0.0054564197,
-0.028870482,
-0.0298551302,
0.022343779,
-0.0060403924,
0.0319459252,
-0.0611645766,
0.0149124945,
0.0077766674,
-0.0791748092,
0.0265950672,
-0.0321474411,
-0.0131830471,
0.0216640756,
-0.0201303288,
0.0690553635,
0.0167521499,
-0.0454129353,
0.0266565774,
0.0128705483,
0.0054032267,
-0.0171973668,
0.0364657491,
0.0838706866,
-0.0029974671,
0.056524653,
-0.0356056653,
-0.033167813,
0.0246909652,
-0.0279706679,
-0.0345926173,
0.0460805781,
-0.0049650702,
0.0395825133,
-0.0291092787,
0.006574499,
-0.0011322615,
-0.0243624747,
-0.030495042,
-0.0010044859,
0.0083809011,
0.0193916894,
0.0022255292,
-0.0038610869,
0.0292836595,
0.0059729153,
-0.0392759778,
-0.0222641416,
0.0416856892,
-0.0260749459,
0.0449900776,
0.0132822506,
-0.0335924178,
-0.0438968427,
-0.0600083843,
0.0022151377,
-0.0012991105,
0.0244916659,
0.055276148,
0.0077806422,
0.017551342,
0.0064026555,
0.0090905251,
-0.0159427896,
-0.0133720692,
0.0123215765,
0.0664245263,
0.0207751766,
-0.0131568583,
-0.087518312,
-0.0116060199,
-0.0491569303,
0.0086482903,
0.0521651953,
0.0082973456,
-0.0458202288,
0.0177795012,
-0.0297530852,
0.0023041496,
0.012099362,
-0.0317616016,
0.0297284424,
-0.0165285971,
0.0104123801,
0.0662796646,
0.0062781633,
0.0036124496,
0.053067375,
0.0123615693,
-0.0334513187,
-0.0317393355,
-0.0275401529,
-0.0087222802,
0.0105291437,
-0.0167307612,
0.0497533344,
0.0779059455,
-0.0152977053,
-0.0350562558,
-0.0499462634,
0.0395196304,
0.0266775023,
0.0042399024,
0.0478385016,
-0.0213914402,
-0.0158188548,
0.0406777523,
-0.0250319839,
-0.0411716737,
0.0620947517,
-0.0425006151,
-0.0027373664,
-0.0604189634,
0.0355004445,
-0.0317802243,
0.028554935,
0.0040606651,
0.018186152,
-0.0199106522,
0.0299182124,
-0.0251311734,
0.0027925961,
0.05458894,
0.0309169851,
0.0075599235,
-0.0706778541,
0.0557329431,
-0.0092769871,
-0.0078907851,
0.0188267529,
-0.0414010733,
-0.0183431394,
0.034022335,
0.012060564,
-0.0797651708,
-0.0297151133,
0.0224175733,
0.0178055447,
0.0994182602,
-0.0269513559,
-0.0384474881,
-0.0309124365,
-0.0214746445,
0.0722201988,
-0.0293581411,
-0.0135776242,
-0.0315601304,
-0.0108162453,
0.0515601449,
0.0108578419,
0.0218442008,
-0.0637016818,
-0.0237761587,
-0.02225326,
-0.0845219716,
-0.0038238838,
-0.0409766994,
0.030562304,
-0.0385073051,
-0.0183599964,
0.1050836146,
0.0286640581,
-0.0915755853,
-0.01309257,
-0.030683605,
0.0070892167,
0.0182697643,
0.0458729342,
-0.0747110993,
-0.0155259324,
-0.0168532785,
0.0016590597,
-0.0046220263,
-0.0361990929,
-0.0089564081,
-0.0508296192,
0.0492642075,
0.0198693909,
-0.0216783062,
-0.024841845,
-0.040446952,
0.0386156514,
-0.0199011546,
-0.0360517949,
0.0341875516,
0.0176719129,
-0.0052496814,
-0.002540292,
0.0053317947,
-0.0432040542,
0.0266422797,
-0.0485119037,
0.0520515703,
0.0473294072,
0.0206538141,
0.0134104537,
0.0023074057,
0.0515424758,
0.0445518568,
-0.0212594252,
0.0006140786,
0.021808641,
-0.0021403907,
0.0429090112,
0.008391452,
0.0577782765,
-0.028844526,
0.0049068565,
0.0493672974,
0.0832346827,
-0.0251583755,
0.0007016705,
-0.0367829427,
0.0168635044,
-0.0164189544,
0.0346729793,
0.0170462225,
-0.0179223102,
-0.0392690338,
-0.0290869344,
0.0058287908,
-0.0137507487,
-0.0341247208,
-0.0542464368,
-0.0409890376,
-0.0071873483,
-0.0698011965,
-0.0345216393,
0.0037861336,
-0.001991024,
0.0674947277,
0.0007137542,
0.0154215023,
-0.0305429827,
0.0036374363,
0.0351943485,
0.0211480912,
-0.0132033899,
-0.01777073,
-0.050596986,
0.054756999,
0.0159750935,
-0.0318204574,
-0.0064612972,
-0.0340327173,
-0.0856568664,
-0.0255829114,
0.0570784807,
0.0295147244,
0.0539381057,
-0.0108294971,
-0.0581810474,
-0.0456151702,
-0.008708884,
0.0101720365,
-0.0185180325,
0.0114303241,
-0.01125002,
-0.021400921,
0.0137046929,
-0.0190964509,
0.007445307,
0.0178158805,
0.0190653503,
-0.0414419547,
-0.0546610132,
0.0459883437,
0.0043883682,
0.0519657917,
-0.000720629,
0.0230142921,
-0.0559809729,
0.0217507128,
-0.0411067382,
-0.0160681214,
-0.0189609453,
0.0131025733,
0.0026499804,
-0.0159722045,
-0.0184155405,
0.0630628169,
-0.0541652255,
0.0440704636,
-0.0337977633,
0.0428668521,
0.0224043,
0.0245038588,
0.0113893878,
-0.0185604133,
-0.0262027197,
-0.0169992354,
-0.0094149457,
0.0296474826,
0.0124390079,
0.0563436151,
0.0376104936,
0.032439515,
-0.0015262248,
0.0145051433,
-0.1219322011,
0.016758671,
-0.0369101278,
-0.0043834364,
-0.0012123763,
0.0015267058,
0.0757076666,
-0.0685412064,
-0.046084702,
-0.0444642641,
0.0793199688,
0.0157978758,
0.0243558642,
0.0347671695,
-0.0030738218,
-0.0017515074,
0.0109113604,
0.0565035604,
-0.0118245091,
0.0643796548,
-0.0045410786,
-0.0360924117,
-0.0465243496,
-0.0581151582,
-0.0236662701,
-0.0014049838,
-0.0218445808,
-0.0215113182,
-0.02896953,
-0.0003976774,
-0.008382502,
0.032904122,
-0.0092486665,
-0.0066885073,
-0.0254844688,
0.0779743344,
-0.0341903903,
-0.0370984115,
-0.0518799387,
0.0379455425,
-0.0395591594,
-0.0704308599,
-0.059523873,
-4.948940685e-33,
-0.0021899247,
-0.0067815413,
0.0042872727,
0.049221307,
-0.0335098431,
0.0064708362,
-0.07797236,
-0.0114261694,
0.0224386211,
0.0219565202,
-0.0479461923,
0.0297138728,
-0.0282490347,
-0.012979229,
0.0699528828,
0.0428211093,
0.0695473924,
-0.0139846513,
-0.0234619845,
0.0260128528,
0.0005457079,
-0.008413313,
0.0674336851,
-0.0471447818,
0.094716996,
0.0167997647,
-0.0199951921,
0.0131443543,
-0.0536137223,
0.0617149659,
-0.0337765999,
-0.0158554222,
-0.0033572975,
-0.0213696267,
-0.0011581491,
-0.033818122,
-0.0280094016,
0.0284490958,
0.0190961901,
0.0117814634,
-0.0230713561,
-0.0409477837,
0.0569075681,
-0.0158966146,
-0.0507006273,
-0.0287769549,
0.0494748279,
-0.012157701,
-0.0045500863,
-0.025952233,
-0.0676724389,
0.0276530236,
-0.0243547857,
0.0130634094,
-0.006942261,
0.0240546558,
0.004135624,
0.0505865812,
-0.0630923882,
0.0170748495,
0.02190556,
0.0555309244,
-0.0058836425,
-0.0350277834,
0.0367947891,
0.0309842955,
0.0148782562,
0.0197397936,
0.0020939077,
0.0084494324,
-0.0211379025,
0.0032007152,
0.0250798799,
0.089574337,
0.0411817096,
0.0143108815,
-0.0700714663,
0.0341367461,
0.0091177076,
0.049065832,
0.0437995978,
-0.0057809171,
0.0308175199,
0.0132941799,
-0.0067137601,
-0.0646844208,
-0.0085959919,
-0.0239306372,
-0.0101470491,
0.0037637514,
0.0052860873,
-0.0075273491,
-0.001295057,
-0.0358159244,
-0.0129176928,
0.0062251203,
-0.0436234102,
0.0357791297,
0.0088513708,
-0.036162708,
-0.0295321867,
0.0128086107,
-0.0149529763,
0.0157122929,
0.0313302837,
0.0075572468,
0.076969713,
-0.0054823142,
-0.0470637418,
0.0062822904,
-0.0275374483,
0.0249938387,
-0.0124001186,
0.04257809,
-0.0079202736,
0.0018904486,
0.0257124268,
0.0117942691,
0.0106419409,
0.0515513942,
-0.0105685415,
0.0766863301,
0.0206420962,
0.0164151881,
0.0073976144,
-0.0035170664,
-0.0082367603,
-0.0018114949,
0.0171943177,
-0.0159320571,
0.0010672311,
-0.0064201029,
2.322e-7,
0.0555110797,
0.0569379106,
0.0544831641,
-0.06364692,
0.0431028157,
0.0361665785,
-0.0504431017,
0.0362253711,
0.0268461145,
0.0228317734,
0.0429864787,
-0.0594498441,
0.0378504284,
0.0230949279,
-0.0864036605,
-0.0129410094,
-0.1174607426,
-0.0173129346,
-0.0422722511,
-0.0181661397,
-0.0118738962,
0.0266466551,
-0.0044416785,
-0.0020743269,
-0.0157898851,
-0.0051798532,
0.0847154036,
-0.0328200348,
-0.0055413973,
0.046978455,
0.0051552062,
-0.0460698344,
0.0027101901,
0.0125287781,
-0.0388661735,
0.006342602,
-0.0214458779,
0.0912246406,
-0.0233181939,
0.0350299366,
0.0189990569,
0.0139941024,
0.0539652556,
-0.0416287072,
0.0091548711,
-0.0354052596,
-0.030344218,
-0.0502645858,
-0.0274525695,
-0.0062239552,
0.0375910476,
-0.0355128013,
-0.0113393022,
0.0240515582,
-0.0089975251,
0.0095342593,
0.0066015827,
-0.0284632146,
-0.0239132848,
0.0149105685,
-0.0228871908,
-0.0409558192,
0.0083344486,
-0.0429274067,
0.0143009918,
-0.0460737012,
0.0101269977,
2.047563304e-34,
0.0717936158,
-0.0090097077,
0.0298502725,
0.0089982031,
0.0402672477,
-0.0121027147,
0.0039072172,
0.0123099172,
0.0223471783,
-0.0655759349,
-0.0423185751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12581v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12581v1 | Morphological Inflection with Phonological Features | 2023-06-21T21:34:39 | 2023-06-21T21:34:39 | David Guriel, Omer Goldman, Reut Tsarfaty | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent years have brought great advances into solving morphological tasks,
mostly due to powerful neural models applied to various tasks as (re)inflection
and analysis. Yet, such morphological tasks cannot be considered solved,
especially when little training data is available or when generalizing to
previously unseen lemmas. This work explores effects on performance obtained
through various ways in which morphological models get access to subcharacter
phonological features that are the targets of morphological processes. We
design two methods to achieve this goal: one that leaves models as is but
manipulates the data to include features instead of characters, and another
that manipulates models to take phonological features into account when
building representations for phonemes. We elicit phonemic data from standard
graphemic data using language-specific grammars for languages with shallow
grapheme-to-phoneme mapping, and we experiment with two reinflection models
over eight languages. Our results show that our methods yield comparable
results to the grapheme-based baseline overall, with minor improvements in some
of the languages. All in all, we conclude that patterns in character
distributions are likely to allow models to infer the underlying phonological
characteristics, even when phonemes are not explicitly represented. | [
0.0059783324,
0.0690805241,
-0.0179071222,
0.0307939574,
-0.0486171246,
-0.0054241032,
-0.0046340032,
0.0030385612,
-0.0540947914,
0.0101779131,
-0.0424403995,
-0.0832208768,
0.0545386486,
-0.001800952,
0.0843188986,
-0.0479995646,
0.0094391825,
-0.0573215261,
-0.0408663899,
-0.012462873,
0.0386454053,
0.0133210821,
-0.0039300644,
0.0227362514,
-0.1067123711,
0.0109483683,
-0.0051419078,
0.0535738766,
-0.0126377223,
-0.0014646455,
-0.0257383622,
-0.0038040748,
-0.0175890699,
0.0542645343,
0.0000016352,
-0.0334454179,
0.0336945653,
0.0044197477,
-0.0379371457,
0.0565760992,
0.0449995026,
-0.048633147,
-0.0285049807,
0.0089626927,
0.0123105058,
-0.0287941583,
0.0982063934,
-0.0641948506,
0.0041613225,
0.0621199049,
-0.026019603,
-0.0807886422,
0.0276966561,
-0.0260561686,
-0.0782330036,
0.0714417174,
0.0143030155,
-0.066308558,
0.0178215988,
-0.0608272552,
-0.0442249887,
0.029512303,
-0.0062088086,
0.0240572244,
-0.001125427,
0.0002410604,
0.0266237855,
-0.0436613671,
0.0112863295,
0.0379524156,
-0.067328155,
-0.0409229994,
0.0024562092,
-0.0011440302,
-0.0250649694,
0.0112597849,
-0.0321009532,
-0.0148203755,
-0.0064174994,
0.0427971557,
0.0334754623,
-0.0378245674,
0.0412259623,
-0.0405820496,
-0.0296453387,
0.0383671299,
0.0372877829,
-0.0094017647,
-0.0203103982,
0.0189800169,
-0.022513194,
0.014218526,
0.0275923982,
0.0525150038,
-0.0019919139,
0.0242826845,
0.0448389761,
-0.0381815247,
0.0219063777,
0.0077689709,
0.0868179426,
-0.0145403882,
-0.0323812179,
-0.0224081278,
-0.0476601124,
0.0055393423,
-0.0088886982,
0.0153311109,
-0.0247510727,
-0.038384594,
-0.0005802037,
-0.006888703,
-0.0402025655,
-0.0036905489,
0.0412168428,
0.0362698287,
-0.0076771225,
0.005084543,
0.036904458,
-0.0373380519,
0.0432144217,
0.0066956682,
-0.0791304111,
-0.0089417798,
0.0072747152,
0.0557967499,
-0.0201736353,
0.0275599975,
-0.0426509194,
-0.0701757893,
-0.0051692566,
0.0009047395,
0.0269396026,
0.0233597644,
0.0463449843,
0.0947340578,
0.0076624658,
-0.0361467265,
-0.0045281504,
0.0063153459,
-0.0744975284,
-0.0253345463,
-0.0027673393,
-0.0602001175,
0.0005016095,
0.0202240255,
-0.0338154025,
-0.0158801191,
-0.0227025691,
-0.0336691327,
-0.0195219871,
0.0477923974,
0.0078766942,
0.0288251527,
0.0273750946,
-0.047839269,
0.0027184256,
0.0168740004,
0.0382969305,
-0.0104800211,
-0.0016480075,
-0.0219806079,
-0.0012441004,
0.08728154,
0.0002139908,
-0.0019853301,
-0.0491193049,
-0.060937684,
-0.0202903599,
0.0257196333,
0.0437761955,
0.0657590255,
-0.0082146889,
-0.0487825722,
0.0405666344,
0.1291093826,
0.016347358,
0.0015940455,
0.0292943604,
-0.0285141412,
0.015446024,
0.0265293457,
0.0126420902,
-0.0208269823,
0.0027328564,
0.0526159294,
-0.0962772146,
0.0653056502,
0.0033220169,
-0.0092024151,
-0.0219937507,
-0.037512403,
-0.0293214954,
-0.0096868072,
0.053302601,
0.0292107332,
-0.0256906468,
-0.0202259459,
0.055834692,
-0.0237128101,
0.0280672871,
-0.0044477377,
0.005569174,
0.0111202709,
0.0000739696,
-0.005891365,
-0.0457711145,
0.0459248088,
-0.0574464612,
0.0357968025,
-0.0234329049,
-0.0286791977,
0.0119495858,
-0.0480790511,
0.0247869473,
0.0455886461,
0.0342307873,
0.0502121039,
-0.0471760035,
0.0115207527,
-0.0232934318,
-0.0416901708,
-0.0379387364,
-0.0015726705,
0.001297036,
0.0071399319,
0.004531661,
0.0095097702,
0.0100824647,
-0.0119130611,
-0.0176210664,
0.0353625715,
0.0198123176,
-0.043795649,
0.0526000448,
0.0227861721,
-0.0389013924,
-0.0471255928,
0.050446149,
-0.0186074208,
-0.0045919172,
-0.0474674553,
0.0527182072,
-0.0510977097,
0.066603981,
-0.0863007307,
0.0810607001,
-0.04117731,
0.0407608561,
-0.0303599797,
0.0109745553,
-0.0210958514,
0.0206944123,
0.0510616675,
-0.0037094059,
-0.0021597934,
-0.0339064002,
-0.015440587,
-0.0407377072,
-0.0100683086,
0.0252166055,
-0.0081581529,
-0.0324315615,
-0.0458763242,
-0.0173273385,
0.0135759367,
-0.0228584874,
-0.0742926896,
-0.0493959002,
-0.0260499995,
0.073869586,
0.0059548081,
0.0440939143,
-0.0040186094,
-0.0474520214,
-0.0415869094,
0.051232405,
0.0141510395,
0.0070963483,
0.0493519492,
-0.0151376231,
-0.0193972718,
-0.0537847616,
-0.0314884558,
-0.0137247164,
0.0632801726,
-0.0021444412,
-0.0342931002,
-0.0141034797,
-0.0109718461,
-0.0212594233,
0.0292193368,
0.0113393674,
-0.0779958889,
0.0316502154,
-0.0201621596,
0.0843876228,
-0.0085326014,
-0.0464471355,
-0.0154040735,
0.0093661239,
-0.0371876806,
-0.0467043035,
-0.0446171202,
-0.0398810245,
0.002021044,
-0.0835668296,
-0.0279661212,
-0.0256645754,
0.0961506143,
-0.0064039715,
-0.0061827875,
-0.0091429912,
0.0002463165,
-0.0272915941,
0.0267641097,
0.0341417044,
-0.006653362,
-0.0252322424,
0.025944097,
-0.0328178816,
-0.034438204,
0.0900234878,
-0.0743277967,
-0.0449928679,
-0.0121940309,
-0.0413653553,
-0.049723614,
0.0368655175,
0.0496043563,
-0.0126710711,
0.0784259439,
-0.0453955606,
-0.0257070251,
0.0447068214,
0.0244092867,
-0.0149381543,
0.018197434,
-0.0280418023,
-0.0044331471,
0.0009198689,
-0.0386134796,
0.0079947282,
-0.0089633884,
-0.019061517,
0.0327928588,
-0.0152439224,
-0.063655138,
0.0326992385,
0.0192603916,
-0.0307836868,
0.0329265669,
0.0025319781,
0.0291224699,
-0.0003161989,
0.0517161191,
0.0117088621,
0.0069678514,
-0.0384921618,
-0.0076341415,
0.0006041877,
-0.0297501348,
-0.0124846008,
0.0211773831,
-0.0220769271,
0.0268623065,
0.0342719108,
0.000823074,
-0.0449436419,
-0.0267538838,
0.0213581864,
-0.0100469133,
-0.0169166718,
0.0482184924,
0.0056396555,
-0.0098866839,
0.0404671952,
0.0314141549,
0.0439900942,
-0.0045851707,
-0.0060700639,
-0.0098330686,
-0.0055903238,
0.0144867944,
0.010411297,
-0.0007588448,
-0.014113565,
0.0391429216,
-0.1284880787,
0.0273933727,
0.0297324695,
0.0005636908,
0.0296399184,
-0.0245893113,
0.0538520627,
-0.0056559145,
-0.0240884684,
0.0177915934,
-0.0190213136,
0.0076118037,
0.0678177699,
-0.0250378661,
-0.0382307731,
-0.0304738116,
-0.0637348518,
-0.0331475064,
-0.0012559353,
0.020453563,
-0.0157628451,
-0.0088459346,
0.023489682,
0.0002065714,
0.0208452493,
-0.0111402478,
0.0234296024,
0.0873871297,
-0.0500136018,
-0.0286045931,
0.0154735353,
-0.0276112147,
0.010690867,
-0.0343732387,
0.0712381974,
0.0436024815,
0.0012157729,
0.0169404987,
-0.0159786604,
-0.0334520377,
-0.0077971537,
0.0536557585,
-0.0406374484,
-0.0492833368,
-0.0432505086,
0.0189844631,
-0.0130121531,
-0.0415650941,
-0.0037642075,
0.0365997776,
-0.0176536944,
-0.0771894082,
-0.0312242769,
0.0217268821,
0.0287984665,
0.0257750936,
-0.0461971909,
0.0305576548,
-0.0111883534,
-0.0378934965,
0.0137565453,
0.0211348087,
0.0325224623,
-0.0457132235,
-0.0104686311,
0.0762975663,
0.0148152644,
0.0207835287,
-0.0198584925,
-0.0240960531,
-0.0780267194,
0.0122186337,
-0.0119074099,
0.020446375,
0.0124432715,
-0.0416813679,
-0.0321757048,
0.0767304301,
0.0205723494,
0.0113656577,
0.0191996899,
0.048737973,
-0.0296330843,
-0.0032649743,
0.0308513753,
-0.003927351,
0.0263293963,
0.0286067985,
0.0111648887,
-0.0675843805,
-0.0627996549,
0.0204403345,
0.017451575,
0.051164113,
-0.0083414391,
-0.0019467716,
-0.0351144671,
-0.0184874758,
0.0200859699,
0.0274996664,
-0.0009420204,
-0.043434225,
0.0622440726,
0.0398154296,
-0.0553072393,
-0.0458243676,
0.0161879491,
0.0292265154,
-0.0045690173,
0.0236800611,
0.0560781211,
-0.0336989015,
-0.0172861796,
0.0232481062,
0.010747592,
0.0446621589,
-0.0375409499,
0.009706568,
-0.0292393081,
-0.0632998049,
-0.0221773367,
-0.0003855015,
-0.0478307493,
-0.0086738775,
-0.000135672,
0.0239612926,
-0.0431659296,
0.0031919589,
0.0508251674,
-0.0089177936,
0.0414033122,
-0.0270084366,
0.016438907,
-0.0218691621,
0.0027493825,
-0.0610370114,
0.0068909423,
0.0155437179,
0.0210724194,
-0.0141485082,
-0.0301958807,
0.0563269705,
0.0455117002,
0.0229761638,
-0.0152219916,
0.0135534443,
0.0051006097,
-0.0381217897,
-0.0119480444,
-0.0188744534,
-0.0190049056,
-0.0221601781,
-0.0469997749,
-0.1127339005,
0.0179048236,
-0.0073611895,
0.0368109792,
-0.0069572795,
0.0224742219,
-0.0311830211,
0.0184859168,
0.0451882631,
0.001079175,
0.0111763813,
0.0269167349,
-0.0057699322,
-0.0010685014,
-5.497718386e-33,
0.0042686863,
0.0107781198,
-0.0446167514,
0.0470528379,
-0.0080705108,
0.0081834476,
-0.0384357125,
0.0281530283,
-0.0368448086,
-0.0015132624,
0.0106713176,
0.0023616387,
0.0136490539,
0.0022843,
0.0351967663,
0.0099143144,
0.0320756845,
-0.0346096121,
0.0270893015,
-0.0370308533,
0.0196570922,
0.0480740741,
0.1023250297,
0.0037060641,
-0.0125697507,
0.0190512892,
-0.010361501,
0.006371025,
-0.0343301967,
0.0457079448,
-0.0076213311,
0.0815110654,
0.0168134253,
0.0103370249,
-0.0084140189,
-0.0092888139,
-0.0835326761,
-0.0197939742,
0.0253369864,
0.0556947514,
-0.0142448042,
-0.0099299923,
0.0588472895,
-0.0108156223,
-0.0197831765,
0.0057869414,
0.00655331,
-0.0369521677,
0.0245867651,
0.0184164066,
-0.0593926907,
0.0127062416,
-0.0003430683,
0.0043435101,
0.0499588586,
-0.0062140534,
-0.007668444,
-0.0186353065,
-0.0055109244,
0.0122637982,
0.0108134001,
0.0510290861,
0.0420770794,
0.0439273156,
-0.031868495,
0.0000034388,
0.0881686881,
-0.0420009978,
0.0483087227,
0.0044467347,
0.0763479695,
0.0170113333,
0.036764428,
0.0199031476,
0.0570244044,
-0.012307222,
-0.0562107749,
-0.035171371,
0.0500466637,
0.0295706801,
-0.0243978966,
0.0420035943,
-0.0073826201,
-0.030959826,
0.008825493,
-0.0793438628,
-0.0124668684,
-0.0118801594,
-0.0178982392,
-0.034089718,
0.0015417498,
0.0919404998,
0.0236400161,
0.0112645775,
-0.0285306759,
-0.0114016915,
0.034172453,
0.0584087335,
-0.0011878335,
0.0237885136,
0.0053076213,
0.0085042296,
0.0139728887,
0.0489978381,
0.0354545303,
-0.0099276975,
0.0115772365,
0.0317362025,
-0.0238609239,
-0.0225239974,
-0.0500357598,
-0.0123967845,
-0.0019764116,
0.0649404302,
0.0490633547,
0.0028119595,
-0.0084312055,
-0.0053231088,
0.0078899479,
0.015699517,
-0.0087975282,
-0.0060536712,
-0.0015503273,
0.0173404273,
-0.0354381725,
-0.0064564967,
0.0186235476,
0.0196098462,
0.0228459965,
0.0093354285,
-0.017192224,
0.0212783813,
2.569e-7,
0.0657744706,
0.0036059259,
0.0704822913,
0.0245165601,
0.0629368499,
-0.0119458456,
-0.0515396036,
-0.0026149566,
0.0277785491,
-0.0269005429,
0.0324208438,
0.0037900058,
0.0427176841,
0.0312386192,
-0.0731134862,
0.0022923534,
-0.0911292285,
-0.0196616165,
-0.0463196784,
0.0226535778,
-0.0258276407,
0.0836036131,
-0.0259709805,
-0.0827969834,
-0.0041647046,
0.0037993153,
0.0313571058,
-0.0287095811,
-0.0024562813,
-0.0049738069,
0.0265992526,
-0.025399087,
0.0129939895,
0.0264867861,
-0.0247642361,
0.0392100923,
0.0326993242,
-0.028842058,
-0.028641291,
-0.0109992288,
0.0304464474,
-0.0047970694,
-0.0267745033,
-0.0227524322,
0.0134715382,
0.0185601749,
-0.0128154643,
0.0069977348,
-0.0005140232,
0.0188401137,
0.0058994368,
-0.0529813506,
-0.0024978383,
0.0154161127,
0.0419558585,
-0.0384919196,
-0.0407037474,
0.0013883597,
-0.0216892324,
0.0732759535,
-0.0231305957,
-0.0105890315,
-0.0127540184,
0.0209928621,
0.0170070212,
-0.0077408645,
0.0029269855,
2.269011287e-34,
-0.0268783364,
-0.0089229569,
0.0348701999,
0.0511130914,
-0.0426825397,
-0.018350035,
0.0481143892,
0.0579564758,
-0.008317288,
-0.0446613543,
-0.0546484366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13114v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13114v1 | A Reference-less Quality Metric for Automatic Speech Recognition via Contrastive-Learning of a Multi-Language Model with Self-Supervision | 2023-06-21T21:33:39 | 2023-06-21T21:33:39 | Kamer Ali Yuksel, Thiago Ferreira, Ahmet Gunduz, Mohamed Al-Badrashiny, Golara Javadi | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | The common standard for quality evaluation of automatic speech recognition
(ASR) systems is reference-based metrics such as the Word Error Rate (WER),
computed using manual ground-truth transcriptions that are time-consuming and
expensive to obtain. This work proposes a multi-language referenceless quality
metric, which allows comparing the performance of different ASR models on a
speech dataset without ground truth transcriptions. To estimate the quality of
ASR hypotheses, a pre-trained language model (LM) is fine-tuned with
contrastive learning in a self-supervised learning manner. In experiments
conducted on several unseen test datasets consisting of outputs from top
commercial ASR engines in various languages, the proposed referenceless metric
obtains a much higher correlation with WER scores and their ranks than the
perplexity metric from the state-of-art multi-lingual LM in all experiments,
and also reduces WER by more than $7\%$ when used for ensembling hypotheses.
The fine-tuned model and experiments are made available for the
reproducibility: https://github.com/aixplain/NoRefER | [
-0.0210877545,
0.0738357902,
0.0324218459,
0.040770039,
-0.0444669314,
0.00387327,
0.0415187404,
-0.0188227575,
-0.0175086092,
-0.0167214703,
-0.0897277072,
-0.0374764539,
0.0483593158,
-0.0228825901,
0.0217077192,
-0.0236970577,
0.0254308339,
-0.0606627837,
0.0011323228,
-0.0177910067,
-0.0192276612,
-0.0083785383,
-0.0202076081,
0.0048884894,
-0.0135820247,
0.0187950488,
0.0155558083,
0.0078243781,
0.0071124821,
-0.0183434021,
-0.0207368508,
0.0637708977,
-0.0312016401,
0.0290103424,
0.0000019239,
-0.0547110178,
-0.018906109,
0.0242367946,
-0.0117128296,
-0.008007857,
0.0691829622,
0.0006971512,
-0.0368619598,
0.0486412644,
-0.0183695685,
-0.0521096848,
0.0596082173,
0.0382738411,
0.0384472311,
0.0545331165,
-0.0164760482,
-0.0715309754,
0.013648265,
0.0081338556,
-0.0546680167,
-0.0222251471,
-0.0238036104,
0.0405649357,
-0.050513532,
-0.0309213884,
-0.0286115985,
0.0410210863,
0.0073831729,
0.0053979075,
-0.014464953,
-0.0089327544,
-0.034781523,
-0.042501431,
0.0009424677,
0.0538188294,
-0.0443755351,
-0.021104591,
-0.0148509666,
-0.0144693973,
-0.0535642616,
-0.012592691,
0.0173651129,
0.0031606695,
0.0238187928,
0.0278784726,
0.0468238778,
0.0432622805,
0.0150782708,
-0.0170071591,
-0.0190769732,
0.0127437375,
0.021366192,
-0.0248720348,
0.0129521824,
-0.0178060401,
0.0242188107,
0.0063639451,
0.0089961328,
-0.0162605122,
-0.0154316276,
-0.0097689284,
-0.0074885907,
-0.0650717244,
0.0305741113,
-0.0445810705,
0.0411252752,
0.0448312461,
-0.0747498646,
0.0445876084,
-0.0346496701,
0.0816838592,
0.0238942131,
0.02235296,
-0.0406598374,
-0.02685358,
-0.0055219452,
0.0560241714,
-0.0059107561,
0.025514489,
-0.0133816926,
-0.0099571813,
-0.0329691954,
-0.0073327273,
0.0089088064,
0.0142413741,
0.0436697379,
-0.0542888604,
-0.0458651148,
-0.0137820626,
-0.0077410559,
0.0282907039,
0.0199952964,
-0.002681816,
-0.0365562476,
-0.0880061984,
0.0103641879,
0.028529752,
0.0344608203,
-0.0158851389,
0.0314549319,
0.0911848396,
0.0202249717,
-0.0682434291,
-0.0314900056,
0.0571536534,
-0.0255477503,
-0.0647611916,
-0.0275927335,
-0.0751884654,
0.0194943715,
0.0160423107,
0.0089976704,
-0.0411182791,
-0.0112245772,
-0.0357740521,
0.0399648063,
0.0694350824,
-0.0368589237,
0.0140399653,
0.0061776713,
-0.0110010002,
0.0111691644,
0.0631235167,
0.029923059,
-0.0616959557,
0.0280615762,
-0.035541866,
0.0184297673,
0.0325425901,
-0.0045160418,
0.0155607946,
-0.042713739,
-0.013623707,
0.0231072791,
-0.0346236266,
0.0577048063,
0.0786592141,
-0.0152901839,
-0.0105634667,
0.0505566224,
0.02245,
0.051566612,
0.0416195951,
0.0205922443,
-0.0051703569,
-0.0030777226,
0.0363916121,
0.0091236541,
0.0099867443,
-0.0051449314,
0.0416647457,
0.1137787178,
0.0387533009,
-0.0411750749,
-0.063544631,
0.0045768768,
-0.0467170626,
0.0113472342,
0.0125656147,
0.0901190266,
-0.0110652978,
-0.0614699125,
0.0062425854,
0.0435908064,
-0.0716510639,
0.0329622552,
-0.0626379997,
0.0235636029,
0.0516991392,
0.0296621695,
-0.0174697991,
0.0099246865,
-0.0264260434,
-0.0425548963,
0.0676862597,
0.0332987122,
0.0216600858,
0.1010188535,
-0.0618922785,
-0.0349650756,
0.0025641164,
-0.0086460486,
0.0510664731,
-0.0527656712,
0.027449524,
0.0308931675,
-0.0297608562,
-0.0423862375,
-0.0072206897,
-0.0051760478,
-0.033131402,
0.0356404111,
0.020093929,
0.0714143366,
0.0233109947,
-0.053295888,
0.003184248,
0.0210079923,
-0.0387157239,
0.0414818376,
0.0059294594,
-0.0649898723,
-0.0385961533,
0.0511190109,
-0.027300939,
0.0205124374,
0.0572289266,
-0.0054148813,
-0.0942235664,
0.0353550054,
-0.0026279965,
0.0400804058,
-0.0559048243,
0.0383489728,
0.0099677946,
0.0062904144,
0.0142437639,
0.0194210168,
0.0083461311,
0.0563062094,
0.0015613629,
0.0217845887,
0.0374547727,
-0.0381019488,
-0.0463841632,
0.0006925358,
-0.0210396368,
0.047579214,
0.0426400006,
0.0171734914,
-0.0227342695,
0.0002538369,
-0.0354885869,
-0.0192227419,
-0.0406566709,
0.0257009473,
0.0008861457,
0.0302369408,
0.0082525304,
-0.0346567146,
-0.0178990029,
-0.049384091,
0.0078586722,
0.0091618244,
0.0095415451,
0.0194532853,
-0.0076295701,
-0.0347154886,
-0.0184535589,
0.0580091029,
0.0118822083,
-0.0088793878,
0.0133155771,
-0.0754774585,
0.0737085715,
-0.0217908341,
0.0314142257,
0.0136678116,
-0.0430371501,
0.0001262873,
0.002387447,
0.0219321605,
0.0422408991,
-0.0188611932,
-0.0537811816,
0.048698701,
-0.0152676655,
-0.0322979055,
-0.0134828575,
-0.0156854875,
-0.0089271944,
0.038045384,
0.0000644269,
-0.0532900207,
0.032337077,
0.0320081152,
0.0085558575,
-0.0385814123,
-0.0189777985,
-0.0139504829,
0.0131839877,
0.0146136777,
0.0089442441,
-0.0018627065,
0.0433983393,
0.0016301423,
-0.0541101731,
0.0528413877,
-0.0871007815,
-0.0174261294,
-0.0389594138,
-0.0293479674,
-0.0241728015,
-0.0110784601,
-0.0298590641,
0.0211155135,
-0.005162695,
-0.0417142771,
-0.0280892029,
-0.0254251417,
0.028898444,
-0.0565454885,
0.0377047732,
-0.0229034256,
0.0182357654,
-0.0174884815,
-0.0348298699,
-0.0065136696,
0.0143230762,
-0.034368284,
0.0229367055,
0.0240203664,
-0.0012709908,
0.0121582281,
0.0655363277,
0.016727753,
0.0771972612,
0.0124342581,
0.0052555897,
0.0110547105,
0.03260478,
-0.0258564968,
0.0058832662,
0.0323053375,
-0.0068960618,
0.0304325633,
-0.0231359769,
0.0530406497,
0.0017924628,
-0.0594976135,
-0.0131448489,
0.0327105783,
0.028178161,
-0.0287628025,
-0.0086466055,
0.015489826,
-0.0188446883,
-0.0220246315,
0.1225253046,
-0.0323890336,
-0.0290454626,
-0.0309537388,
-0.0258447118,
-0.0006905763,
0.0158466958,
-0.0138231684,
-0.0203737579,
-0.0165788233,
0.0080762012,
0.0344934016,
0.0170580447,
0.0108377934,
0.0009520563,
-0.1123719439,
0.0300522223,
0.0324975774,
-0.0475052707,
-0.0446138568,
-0.0888784304,
-0.0097363209,
-0.0736737698,
0.042562075,
-0.0005856921,
0.0284337681,
-0.0289021377,
0.0170556661,
-0.0476433262,
-0.0843051225,
0.0046297968,
-0.0281008389,
0.0690736175,
0.0578545853,
0.013721074,
-0.0089093586,
-0.0528577976,
0.0187319051,
-0.0846329853,
-0.0171558112,
-0.0406539179,
0.0340640768,
0.0078804977,
-0.0378808901,
0.0244162381,
-0.0317166597,
-0.0120515535,
0.0337138921,
-0.0195138808,
0.0094660623,
0.0001309771,
0.0281698946,
0.0270542838,
-0.0066931369,
-0.0026404615,
0.0588229112,
0.0298013501,
-0.0145208137,
-0.0035493872,
0.0137553951,
0.0515934229,
-0.0317810774,
0.0048695877,
-0.010442487,
-0.0128695574,
-0.0280890092,
-0.0307238791,
-0.0213034041,
-0.0138231227,
0.014565995,
-0.0064058611,
0.01891133,
-0.0284556821,
0.0081925765,
0.0020439341,
-0.0014024586,
-0.0022560081,
-0.00796925,
-0.0990770608,
-0.0099326512,
0.0558715388,
-0.0390939862,
-0.0224475674,
-0.0009699218,
0.0285533499,
-0.0441073216,
-0.0027270047,
0.069792971,
0.0118958699,
0.0413962714,
-0.0336879939,
-0.0226630028,
0.0328011326,
0.0272662472,
-0.0305674896,
-0.0124964239,
0.0676030219,
-0.0086969137,
-0.0179482736,
0.0235395543,
-0.0637176409,
0.0233016033,
0.0059584123,
0.0321968608,
-0.0155188432,
-0.0764284953,
-0.006338018,
0.0334907696,
0.0986737236,
-0.0335626975,
0.0592080802,
-0.0262080021,
0.0077314475,
-0.0098060407,
0.0192713793,
-0.0482365899,
0.0202840082,
0.0025070198,
-0.0059840647,
-0.0204000119,
0.0102750901,
-0.0680791065,
-0.0409464166,
0.0250040665,
0.0522679612,
0.0185996126,
0.0302161463,
-0.0161754265,
0.0019609309,
-0.0275753289,
0.0019450294,
0.0576219484,
0.0115425987,
-0.0054046479,
0.0002685759,
-0.0153730987,
0.030166639,
0.0318765752,
0.0355833247,
-0.0219250564,
-0.0131642446,
-0.0397205725,
-0.0116976872,
0.0415033214,
-0.0094669079,
0.0732127577,
0.0107239345,
0.0072215423,
-0.0564273261,
0.0441707671,
0.0095426152,
0.022249816,
-0.0213107653,
0.0042783259,
-0.0045965752,
0.0674683377,
0.0630520508,
-0.0017755612,
0.0017620055,
0.0040152259,
0.0425083563,
-0.0452154689,
-0.0018832148,
-0.0339957476,
-0.0249344371,
-0.0430908017,
-0.0075415079,
-0.019947106,
-0.1098859608,
0.0431615412,
0.0430625379,
0.0256176144,
0.0048699654,
0.0087350905,
0.0334559381,
-0.027038848,
0.0251170173,
-0.0075055268,
-0.0507427827,
0.0028787325,
0.0062684175,
0.0126438476,
-6.080720605e-33,
-0.014892404,
-0.0101573328,
-0.0231380798,
-0.0296260156,
0.0179841984,
0.0143208103,
-0.025022354,
0.0028437239,
-0.0212494656,
-0.0286037233,
-0.0034761645,
-0.0091133127,
0.0341113545,
0.002025475,
-0.0232725106,
-0.0113749644,
0.0597564802,
-0.0009199223,
-0.0342908315,
-0.0024641615,
0.0121424627,
0.0402663089,
0.0552755743,
-0.10150747,
-0.0157066211,
0.0134903602,
-0.0172964539,
0.0145879099,
0.0398539603,
0.0717025995,
0.0096349576,
0.0469215475,
-0.0162830185,
-0.0375854969,
-0.0208398551,
-0.0395075418,
-0.0717706978,
-0.0404972211,
-0.00984981,
0.0218487978,
-0.024405105,
0.0013953834,
0.0225607716,
0.0010901932,
-0.0562447384,
0.000017679,
0.0217804294,
-0.0430235155,
-0.0394178033,
-0.0092892163,
0.0102316765,
0.0595881976,
-0.0091379127,
-0.0489831381,
0.0858889967,
0.0168874282,
-0.0327860788,
0.0097322203,
-0.0610884167,
0.0263560358,
-0.0049940003,
0.0309491735,
0.0661247224,
0.0333328582,
-0.0043869819,
0.013957941,
0.0453532152,
-0.0403371938,
0.0810056478,
-0.0885658264,
0.0309244692,
0.021853013,
0.0502334833,
0.0425850078,
0.0127542987,
-0.0186077319,
-0.0639998689,
0.0137182744,
-0.0167539902,
0.0337508619,
0.0140617359,
0.0303323679,
-0.0561073013,
-0.00641448,
-0.0488235168,
-0.0704422593,
-0.058955729,
-0.0175888315,
0.0268078279,
0.0101800235,
-0.028829379,
-0.0511919484,
0.0587165095,
0.000073173,
0.0081688929,
0.0295556784,
-0.0213369615,
-0.0051481728,
-0.0183982905,
0.0170705225,
-0.0553401858,
-0.0199868325,
-0.0159347765,
0.061491318,
0.0023893758,
-0.0326153636,
0.0088230846,
0.0543921031,
-0.0712872893,
0.0056276531,
0.0211147517,
0.002113279,
0.0039314064,
-0.0349087566,
0.0231422614,
-0.0464290529,
-0.0066291341,
0.0779193938,
0.019114336,
0.0032748883,
-0.005515385,
-0.0007308981,
0.0169988647,
0.0325509943,
-0.022692088,
-0.0054939049,
-0.0001510946,
0.0100667533,
0.0360808745,
0.0048765703,
-0.0252000578,
0.0070753805,
2.654e-7,
0.0066310475,
0.0124597112,
0.004320622,
-0.004362327,
-0.0271812174,
0.0419788361,
-0.0412707962,
-0.0312163774,
-0.0053023035,
0.0316301323,
0.0055730417,
0.0018889367,
0.069917284,
0.0274422895,
-0.0399409346,
0.0059519294,
-0.0653805956,
0.0305163376,
0.029175166,
0.0099440655,
0.0177531522,
0.0933450833,
-0.0150946463,
-0.0100786788,
-0.0417524651,
-0.0247916002,
0.0284895021,
-0.0097266519,
-0.0040615238,
-0.0235531777,
0.0244873241,
0.0330824666,
-0.0162093081,
0.0080753723,
-0.0205401927,
0.0373114869,
0.0417612232,
0.0370192975,
0.0057245577,
-0.0716109201,
0.0549275801,
0.0248593912,
-0.0089622047,
-0.0231288653,
0.0621349253,
0.0089615295,
-0.0132230436,
-0.0164226424,
-0.0672443807,
0.0065848725,
0.0867649615,
-0.0434475318,
-0.0542247444,
-0.0005746998,
0.0195942409,
-0.0145946695,
-0.0483408347,
-0.0252244808,
0.0085738068,
0.020880416,
0.0180861261,
-0.0336616933,
0.0193999652,
0.0161225609,
0.0448553264,
0.0016235363,
0.0441277102,
1.786659578e-34,
0.0641101152,
-0.0513980649,
0.0188320391,
-0.0033556011,
0.0024977359,
-0.0313729681,
-0.0536381379,
-0.0093450909,
0.0069456142,
-0.0395919345,
-0.0225889217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12577v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12577v1 | NoRefER: a Referenceless Quality Metric for Automatic Speech Recognition via Semi-Supervised Language Model Fine-Tuning with Contrastive Learning | 2023-06-21T21:26:19 | 2023-06-21T21:26:19 | Kamer Ali Yuksel, Thiago Ferreira, Golara Javadi, Mohamed El-Badrashiny, Ahmet Gunduz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper introduces NoRefER, a novel referenceless quality metric for
automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems. Traditional reference-based metrics
for evaluating ASR systems require costly ground-truth transcripts. NoRefER
overcomes this limitation by fine-tuning a multilingual language model for
pair-wise ranking ASR hypotheses using contrastive learning with Siamese
network architecture. The self-supervised NoRefER exploits the known quality
relationships between hypotheses from multiple compression levels of an ASR for
learning to rank intra-sample hypotheses by quality, which is essential for
model comparisons. The semi-supervised version also uses a referenced dataset
to improve its inter-sample quality ranking, which is crucial for selecting
potentially erroneous samples. The results indicate that NoRefER correlates
highly with reference-based metrics and their intra-sample ranks, indicating a
high potential for referenceless ASR evaluation or a/b testing. | [
-0.031922996,
0.1030426845,
0.0302983169,
0.0338258371,
-0.042205669,
0.003981492,
0.0432479456,
-0.0074068257,
-0.0197307542,
-0.0295608416,
-0.0749770403,
-0.0300311446,
0.0680397004,
0.0034394632,
0.034270484,
-0.0258141793,
0.0212442987,
-0.0339200534,
0.0048284205,
-0.004328988,
-0.024107771,
-0.0207323767,
-0.0168426596,
0.0239721462,
0.0240948983,
0.0222254023,
0.02115109,
0.011585393,
0.0125780031,
-0.0258432329,
-0.0267146584,
0.0403146856,
-0.0409756862,
0.0118765095,
0.000001914,
-0.0523212031,
-0.0022478574,
0.0415739715,
-0.0272741057,
-0.023749074,
0.0320150554,
0.0306132846,
-0.0305604208,
0.0515376739,
-0.0117213856,
-0.0507352985,
0.0507450476,
0.0423280485,
0.0593066029,
0.0380790681,
-0.019214984,
-0.0414938815,
0.0079200231,
-0.0156210018,
-0.0720536038,
-0.0031169225,
-0.0071581169,
0.0191138908,
-0.0275016297,
-0.0045238859,
-0.0156672262,
0.0350775905,
0.0217031352,
0.003188882,
0.0033715595,
-0.0154267568,
-0.070085533,
-0.0369994305,
0.0261328109,
0.0474201478,
-0.0320130661,
-0.0090792598,
-0.010695911,
-0.0078359703,
-0.0416960195,
-0.0261647943,
0.0090628127,
0.0044460604,
0.0207888633,
0.016022088,
0.0232667346,
0.045434162,
0.0197861493,
-0.0142952688,
-0.0408602357,
-0.0019238618,
0.0056214435,
-0.0257593226,
0.0088370601,
-0.0278166048,
0.0054476541,
-0.0015695057,
0.0218528006,
-0.0350099131,
-0.0213644058,
-0.0131751318,
0.0087040635,
-0.0484040082,
0.0370319262,
-0.0474647768,
0.0174469948,
0.0306722,
-0.0685630143,
0.0202585887,
-0.0383515023,
0.0813570619,
0.0457528345,
0.0212613922,
-0.049364429,
-0.0339227319,
-0.0022091733,
0.0515035279,
-0.0072946949,
0.0464222655,
-0.0289305076,
-0.021587586,
-0.0315249674,
-0.0146971699,
-0.0041659246,
0.0313386284,
0.0384085774,
-0.0151425265,
-0.0410404429,
0.0036723015,
-0.0162192341,
0.0300434362,
0.0215578191,
0.0019388581,
-0.006023658,
-0.0665169582,
0.0045446064,
0.0224286243,
0.0385134555,
0.0024031552,
0.0124145346,
0.0918833688,
0.0204449669,
-0.0457113571,
-0.0382076651,
0.0398158915,
-0.0274055023,
-0.0440764017,
-0.0486930646,
-0.0563885868,
-0.0067788828,
0.0164752938,
0.0218670648,
-0.0424357057,
-0.0200799704,
-0.0193088725,
0.0264892187,
0.0608297475,
-0.012364381,
-0.020250326,
-0.0187442433,
-0.0204021148,
-0.0016743343,
0.0507474132,
0.0496030673,
-0.0339362845,
0.0051895236,
-0.0140616698,
-0.037282452,
0.0105186356,
0.0014720686,
0.0178947821,
-0.0415211134,
-0.0163468905,
0.0206981935,
-0.0146092977,
0.0319863781,
0.1000535116,
-0.0226164255,
-0.0294131674,
0.0437157825,
0.0299825631,
0.0874513239,
0.0342858136,
0.018520968,
-0.013357331,
-0.0377289951,
0.0457965992,
0.0029710452,
0.0002246687,
0.0173142832,
0.0270042475,
0.1191572249,
0.0427087173,
-0.0278255101,
-0.0802973136,
-0.0168895833,
-0.0452904999,
-0.0122881886,
0.0126631791,
0.0780971497,
-0.0016115614,
-0.057878606,
-0.0144476928,
0.0124467118,
-0.0517862886,
0.0258660465,
-0.0725471973,
0.0283415299,
0.0658592433,
0.0203745198,
-0.0107698143,
0.0046327594,
-0.0297591202,
-0.0722475052,
0.0378622301,
0.0068660113,
0.0048493566,
0.0799434111,
-0.0633288249,
-0.0440912396,
0.0018968473,
-0.0043357695,
0.035806749,
-0.0779821202,
0.0283392128,
0.0416184738,
-0.0213012211,
-0.041258961,
-0.0175484959,
-0.0149299093,
-0.0337067246,
0.0601038858,
0.0162786897,
0.0782251358,
0.0067202332,
-0.0570105016,
-0.0008143648,
0.0257797576,
-0.0388960093,
0.0219931901,
-0.0090237865,
-0.0722855479,
-0.0368432291,
0.0310279448,
-0.0439790785,
0.0363393575,
0.0623083301,
-0.014765339,
-0.0838749111,
0.0329616703,
-0.0162743293,
0.00703377,
-0.0505759493,
0.0310340449,
0.0292403847,
0.0004360004,
-0.0069232159,
0.0092714066,
-0.0063942797,
0.0508914366,
0.0153018227,
0.0321026668,
0.0504938476,
-0.0402267165,
-0.0532071777,
0.0308726281,
-0.0355977677,
0.0451882742,
0.0295935962,
0.0137238372,
-0.0166930612,
-0.0157889519,
-0.0278939847,
0.0085422862,
-0.0400027335,
0.025316095,
-0.0108012585,
0.0302951075,
0.0327623636,
-0.021519145,
-0.0191474948,
-0.0602442473,
-0.003020402,
0.0014884464,
-0.0011278301,
0.0213881005,
0.0043855533,
-0.025034409,
-0.0303948522,
0.0312221479,
0.0421863422,
-0.0123954518,
0.0266734213,
-0.0795235783,
0.0708228424,
-0.0209628474,
0.0166484006,
0.0074040028,
-0.0305297785,
0.0149915935,
0.0325350463,
-0.013875938,
0.0595201366,
-0.0101873251,
-0.0565803088,
0.0502720848,
0.0049710274,
-0.0336432233,
-0.0187384821,
-0.0025399812,
0.0090809586,
0.041281838,
-0.0194503572,
-0.0491616279,
0.0359613262,
0.0319191851,
0.0105454037,
-0.0569643937,
-0.0057120877,
-0.0156448595,
0.0040108981,
-0.0032286306,
-0.0076687541,
0.0002007767,
0.0236184299,
-0.0106291948,
-0.0428516194,
0.0435449891,
-0.0691232979,
0.012528548,
-0.0469975509,
-0.0345667154,
-0.031846866,
-0.0401581973,
-0.0122031607,
0.0219054688,
0.0220151953,
-0.0233571585,
-0.016502941,
-0.0388963744,
0.0267119482,
-0.0593136065,
0.0336449966,
-0.0180259049,
0.0077025141,
-0.0367555022,
-0.0364823937,
-0.0112523157,
0.0459586531,
-0.0175773352,
0.0486559607,
0.0415835492,
-0.0046831924,
0.0095535563,
0.0564370938,
-0.0071438216,
0.0801312923,
0.0120720491,
-0.0025943676,
0.0042581954,
0.042250175,
-0.0115131186,
0.0147438738,
0.0573989302,
0.0020583102,
0.0265225135,
-0.0247687399,
0.058473371,
0.0117820874,
-0.0738811195,
-0.0286695268,
0.0190316457,
0.0235397276,
-0.033072561,
0.0009116513,
-0.0122226663,
-0.0024847644,
-0.0151639814,
0.1141633764,
-0.017724188,
-0.0074545527,
-0.0101219742,
-0.0256481469,
0.0305029489,
0.0244433302,
-0.0281720124,
-0.0248701386,
-0.0095058456,
0.0114417672,
0.0526201315,
-0.0048775864,
0.0246482715,
-0.0044837235,
-0.094486922,
0.0536863767,
0.0300241094,
-0.0349385589,
-0.0058064563,
-0.0857008025,
0.0101364665,
-0.0912035704,
0.051839117,
-0.0126358978,
0.0309957471,
-0.0239028707,
0.0284514967,
-0.0385286584,
-0.0795373172,
-0.0111836214,
-0.0272227079,
0.0642205849,
0.0271751732,
0.0131318141,
-0.001520331,
-0.0598563552,
-0.001058843,
-0.1144302115,
0.0130145382,
-0.0395346582,
0.0446824022,
0.0172326379,
-0.0262559708,
0.0119473841,
-0.0211689509,
0.008029582,
0.007549563,
-0.0371831767,
0.0149852009,
-0.0213896818,
0.0183642209,
0.0117525654,
0.0023146984,
-0.0150242746,
0.0376430452,
0.0288831498,
-0.0084746843,
0.0055772089,
0.0136761349,
0.0402469002,
-0.0343788005,
0.0169141311,
-0.0023791015,
0.0011915998,
-0.0342192426,
-0.0527585484,
-0.0045705647,
-0.0285658985,
0.0014483831,
-0.0139971189,
-0.0032600889,
0.0045655556,
-0.0030204456,
0.0002249068,
0.0035164193,
0.0226829704,
-0.0047749425,
-0.0728425309,
0.0159745123,
0.0826402828,
-0.0268869326,
-0.0355699062,
-0.0049460814,
0.0563052706,
-0.0305925161,
-0.0091046793,
0.0508106314,
0.0091158263,
0.0192448869,
-0.0189440344,
-0.0402183868,
0.0428655744,
0.0397976823,
-0.0098330695,
0.0025293918,
0.0777590051,
-0.0400955863,
-0.0243952367,
0.0190360676,
-0.0608335137,
0.0232837982,
-0.0133317234,
0.0122066932,
0.0005646468,
-0.0641453937,
-0.0079210559,
0.0375389308,
0.094107151,
-0.0164925046,
0.0235164035,
-0.0215764716,
0.0165482163,
0.0175764672,
0.0320820846,
-0.0479622521,
0.0184986554,
0.0068321996,
0.0225949883,
-0.0393471569,
0.0202679504,
-0.0568078682,
-0.0274092406,
0.0248544663,
0.071755439,
0.0117814327,
0.0155079002,
-0.0198420528,
-0.0078259418,
-0.0292175449,
-0.0142119844,
0.0432933159,
0.0321980566,
-0.0067548868,
0.0020854312,
0.0040293648,
0.0490020774,
0.0210924093,
0.0727853626,
-0.0157070402,
-0.0262511168,
-0.0504743606,
-0.0388603136,
0.0248222873,
-0.0051135221,
0.0697862506,
0.0145365922,
0.0234047975,
-0.0582023002,
0.0329532661,
0.0202600323,
0.0101651363,
-0.0304249115,
0.0180578604,
-0.0043303105,
0.0672335029,
0.0461008884,
-0.0270439107,
0.0152261341,
-0.0243471265,
0.0299225561,
-0.0446856245,
-0.0295967609,
-0.022301672,
-0.0013081286,
-0.0330389403,
-0.0401669703,
-0.0077463882,
-0.1046833917,
0.040082179,
0.0534753054,
0.0469325408,
-0.0035633356,
0.0192129035,
0.00994989,
-0.0157139339,
0.018001793,
0.00137127,
-0.0909816995,
0.0063507664,
0.0019173634,
0.001955725,
-6.281817566e-33,
-0.0124886781,
-0.0010039612,
-0.0175667424,
-0.0222405214,
0.0089609185,
0.0339589156,
-0.0138161769,
-0.0090087447,
-0.0252767038,
-0.0322634205,
0.0042097215,
-0.0110389432,
0.032233987,
0.0074896174,
-0.0284042154,
-0.0161100663,
0.073726885,
0.0232549384,
-0.0321000814,
-0.0124165891,
0.0386057347,
0.0054649198,
0.0326251648,
-0.1182587668,
-0.0378497206,
0.042822592,
-0.017881494,
-0.0070841713,
0.0144243883,
0.0719163045,
0.0077321362,
0.0693240762,
-0.0133442646,
-0.0570162237,
-0.00418521,
-0.0328043923,
-0.0543384962,
-0.0373374484,
-0.0158122554,
-0.0015993397,
-0.0204170253,
-0.0086612273,
0.0317156948,
0.0119344322,
-0.0635200962,
-0.0015288144,
0.0280192737,
-0.0457969196,
-0.0386132859,
-0.0015845298,
0.0184134841,
0.0568874665,
-0.0233279765,
-0.0510220863,
0.0474286638,
0.0374967083,
-0.040144518,
-0.0021815444,
-0.0326344892,
0.0207626875,
0.0122807687,
0.0360852666,
0.045890402,
0.0294102281,
-0.0002189869,
0.0296942145,
0.0394048914,
-0.0290814228,
0.1036800966,
-0.0967027843,
0.0241879243,
0.04847892,
0.0854198933,
0.0459579602,
0.0286429003,
-0.0300579462,
-0.0694963783,
0.0266875941,
-0.0362925231,
0.0403974876,
0.0010064665,
0.0375160761,
-0.0409894399,
-0.0236927252,
-0.0762307271,
-0.0686609671,
-0.0555402115,
-0.0079838056,
0.0233098902,
0.0111940922,
-0.0251935627,
-0.0076707862,
0.0561842434,
-0.0201438293,
0.0124300299,
0.0396144614,
-0.0201755799,
-0.0007247991,
0.0045164502,
0.0007788489,
-0.0655573532,
-0.0105606001,
0.0155605786,
0.0825143307,
0.0140214264,
-0.0329951234,
0.0177842285,
0.0338020697,
-0.0544091351,
0.0175259579,
0.0169253889,
-0.0002300545,
-0.0259275846,
-0.0521353334,
0.018871462,
-0.0310168657,
-0.0092040002,
0.0918329135,
-0.0088978056,
0.0145259686,
-0.0286117494,
0.027198907,
0.0039257156,
0.0223441143,
-0.0209408738,
0.0131425811,
0.0127592348,
0.0252947062,
0.030520251,
-0.0095136026,
-0.020927541,
0.0135193877,
2.751e-7,
-0.0163675845,
0.0222378634,
-0.0013676151,
-0.0052696206,
-0.0147337131,
0.0543243885,
-0.0233599059,
-0.0145802721,
0.0104363812,
0.0388339348,
0.0038782083,
-0.002505033,
0.0403628051,
0.048400782,
-0.0331404731,
0.0218505897,
-0.0648600087,
0.006118231,
0.0170665029,
0.0130866403,
0.0525084436,
0.0829498693,
-0.0345733054,
-0.0210839752,
-0.0010839259,
-0.0402801819,
0.0187580846,
0.0012676236,
0.014773435,
-0.0235910341,
0.0313717127,
-0.0000919527,
0.0094018402,
0.0317905322,
-0.0155533701,
0.0249905232,
0.0218292195,
0.0192443114,
-0.0023167434,
-0.0761671662,
0.0496477559,
0.0397912115,
-0.0116666127,
-0.0294076782,
0.0750495866,
-0.0053054178,
-0.0339952521,
-0.01601547,
-0.0669694468,
0.0065087047,
0.0801627934,
-0.0391064584,
-0.0291263368,
-0.000443741,
0.0024370227,
-0.0014209552,
-0.0335303843,
-0.0236817189,
0.0239210725,
0.0059365258,
0.0022760674,
-0.0436254218,
-0.0025268847,
0.0145139676,
0.0367478281,
-0.0126064382,
0.0330750532,
1.962792024e-34,
0.0633151159,
-0.0409336649,
0.0303202961,
-0.0306507573,
0.0013767815,
-0.0266007185,
-0.0483685099,
-0.0112383589,
0.004616905,
-0.0471364297,
-0.0198511593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12567v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12567v1 | Evaluating Large Language Models with NeuBAROCO: Syllogistic Reasoning Ability and Human-like Biases | 2023-06-21T21:04:11 | 2023-06-21T21:04:11 | Risako Ando, Takanobu Morishita, Hirohiko Abe, Koji Mineshima, Mitsuhiro Okada | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper investigates whether current large language models exhibit biases
in logical reasoning, similar to humans. Specifically, we focus on syllogistic
reasoning, a well-studied form of inference in the cognitive science of human
deduction. To facilitate our analysis, we introduce a dataset called NeuBAROCO,
originally designed for psychological experiments that assess human logical
abilities in syllogistic reasoning. The dataset consists of syllogistic
inferences in both English and Japanese. We examine three types of biases
observed in human syllogistic reasoning: belief biases, conversion errors, and
atmosphere effects. Our findings demonstrate that current large language models
struggle more with problems involving these three types of biases. | [
0.0422753766,
0.0993842036,
-0.0121296737,
0.037377093,
-0.0266649481,
0.050004445,
0.0407355465,
-0.0067510814,
0.0356021374,
-0.016973244,
-0.059994217,
-0.0053336998,
0.0224647559,
-0.0410200171,
0.0468000993,
-0.0498874523,
0.0493252538,
-0.0491618142,
0.0367108583,
-0.0178236645,
-0.0304893907,
0.007148359,
-0.0205799621,
-0.0192531031,
0.0314808115,
-0.0217983257,
0.0168449227,
-0.0235430766,
0.0179836433,
-0.0552712083,
-0.031842865,
0.0386580601,
-0.0152373873,
0.0584993996,
0.0000019357,
-0.0592140034,
0.035478618,
-0.0335914791,
-0.0387362838,
0.0385680646,
0.048691351,
-0.0169621892,
-0.0189599786,
0.0127573051,
-0.045288574,
-0.0187095497,
0.0374155529,
0.030464856,
0.0143111544,
0.0454689562,
-0.0084790001,
-0.0403615162,
-0.0234992672,
-0.0251630191,
0.0281187873,
0.0151083618,
0.0372923687,
0.0123797068,
-0.0256517008,
-0.0225352719,
-0.0160451215,
0.0066697504,
0.0349481627,
0.0240776427,
-0.080807969,
0.0297160689,
-0.0316519663,
-0.0164825469,
0.0163401794,
0.0159596093,
0.0238381587,
-0.0522351824,
-0.0280280858,
0.0313586481,
0.0235856175,
0.0506658927,
-0.0387450829,
0.0290058181,
-0.0350135602,
-0.0193724465,
0.1040908024,
-0.0025687818,
0.0109197348,
0.0149564389,
-0.0628325716,
0.1471087784,
0.0171564762,
-0.0397583954,
0.0296865385,
0.0236311499,
-0.0766537189,
-0.0731292069,
-0.0155822961,
-0.0242937226,
-0.0229921993,
0.0368453115,
-0.0109222215,
0.0124791386,
0.0124833537,
-0.0811131224,
-0.0054066181,
0.0035820471,
0.0118003478,
0.0402855277,
-0.0379105657,
0.0222778283,
-0.0303692333,
0.0241236594,
-0.0073843091,
-0.012975852,
-0.0206089634,
-0.0154891545,
0.0083313202,
-0.0003118018,
0.0024671773,
0.0110156722,
-0.0509278141,
-0.012063127,
-0.0386091284,
0.0051578083,
-0.0230582841,
-0.0216267966,
-0.0113218641,
-0.0333608612,
-0.0732552111,
0.0191334691,
-0.0465805158,
0.0901938304,
-0.0232535731,
-0.0749849677,
0.0116545856,
0.003482491,
-0.0005764455,
-0.0203789528,
0.0187133905,
0.0241312347,
0.0094848918,
0.0464078598,
-0.0377883054,
-0.0272328481,
-0.0239322986,
-0.0538007207,
0.0076050544,
-0.0505003557,
-0.0036299916,
0.0304023791,
0.0200711265,
-0.0675332546,
-0.0044317651,
0.0117360279,
-0.0456236415,
0.049936194,
-0.002183967,
0.0230867378,
0.0063743754,
-0.0053670434,
-0.0015115887,
0.06520354,
0.0072871796,
0.0270702261,
0.0123233106,
0.0104693491,
0.0024264201,
0.0213630833,
0.0150920162,
0.0112981685,
-0.0467716716,
0.0221516956,
-0.0477970801,
0.035754934,
0.0638837442,
0.0617049038,
-0.0536727346,
-0.0232912954,
0.0572465509,
0.0221282504,
0.0068638525,
0.0109649282,
0.0196099337,
-0.0424324758,
0.0122203389,
-0.0032536336,
-0.0759204254,
0.0184722673,
-0.0394567549,
-0.0129093127,
0.0027080723,
0.0489150621,
-0.0264610779,
-0.0380686969,
-0.0215794928,
0.0224151723,
-0.0023246787,
0.0032302837,
0.0511040911,
0.0036901708,
0.0205764305,
0.0636948571,
0.036146272,
-0.0581769943,
-0.0205536354,
-0.0349285528,
0.0361552387,
-0.015298781,
-0.0226423666,
0.0309421644,
0.0286961608,
0.0134355361,
-0.0190757196,
0.0416367128,
0.0499391556,
-0.0013048224,
-0.0187732261,
-0.0052021039,
-0.0065264199,
-0.0016825449,
0.0469653085,
0.0152092166,
-0.0291452333,
0.0486796387,
0.0044099102,
-0.0541219376,
0.0517500266,
0.0300825741,
-0.0318038873,
-0.0053106979,
-0.0843423456,
0.008363625,
0.0568422526,
-0.0118385172,
-0.0032782787,
0.0252639726,
-0.0022057102,
-0.0242171474,
-0.0172061678,
0.0857767165,
-0.0385148227,
-0.070444338,
0.0101376902,
-0.0752350986,
-0.0014463967,
0.0174750164,
-0.0246549807,
-0.0015701511,
0.0370738208,
-0.0192845687,
0.0355980583,
-0.0198043864,
0.0138896294,
-0.0280869696,
0.0092269639,
0.0082819061,
0.0843769014,
-0.0102981701,
0.0187591687,
0.0315855928,
-0.0038445732,
0.0394642651,
-0.0370397419,
-0.0163051728,
0.0107407374,
0.013854485,
-0.0221706983,
-0.003499225,
-0.0613759197,
-0.0574564412,
-0.0220541991,
-0.0881757811,
-0.0135269389,
-0.0042423061,
0.0213359427,
0.0341690741,
-0.028431043,
-0.0325363725,
0.0061927363,
0.002076121,
0.021276243,
0.0089014191,
0.0733434483,
-0.0115174288,
-0.0605789609,
0.0075663528,
-0.0016026289,
-0.0223160889,
-0.0374909379,
0.0372429825,
0.044329714,
0.0083761159,
-0.059059605,
0.0240798611,
-0.0913383365,
-0.0041118548,
0.0091058444,
-0.0295816492,
0.0322489329,
0.0143571841,
-0.0126562892,
0.0829212517,
-0.0169355124,
-0.0386415012,
0.0545153171,
0.0005070291,
-0.0266603027,
-0.0246659312,
-0.0099312067,
0.0056959116,
-0.0473430268,
-0.0980455503,
-0.0120246606,
0.0661662892,
0.0117069297,
-0.0136911217,
-0.0354660004,
0.0955892503,
-0.0515959002,
-0.0185100418,
0.02521009,
-0.0109174578,
0.0030553474,
0.0803966299,
-0.0188416652,
-0.0146693317,
0.058137197,
0.0324097387,
0.0110369893,
-0.072319515,
0.0490825996,
-0.0402460694,
0.0404138342,
0.0098984493,
0.0067909593,
0.0240693484,
-0.0044441642,
-0.0683357641,
-0.0136523694,
0.0409874767,
-0.0114613883,
0.004334297,
-0.0587335192,
-0.0005893842,
0.0128036579,
-0.0473870933,
-0.0269419514,
-0.0016658723,
-0.0779779553,
-0.0284666736,
-0.012855866,
-0.0021834667,
0.0007488926,
0.0088542616,
-0.0015296309,
-0.0097995074,
0.0025553496,
-0.0172580164,
0.0011372584,
-0.0215907767,
0.0558799282,
0.015243507,
0.0503306463,
-0.016989138,
-0.0145643512,
0.0618438572,
0.0048283907,
0.0508924089,
-0.0199435521,
0.0488709621,
0.029244775,
0.0242627095,
-0.0290203448,
-0.0016326804,
0.0448606275,
-0.0106011638,
0.0157918688,
0.0839271173,
0.0238797572,
-0.0148504423,
0.022203546,
-0.0576551557,
0.0317237899,
0.0092220828,
-0.0101161059,
-0.0666291863,
-0.031483829,
0.0132291615,
-0.0166432206,
-0.0164342411,
-0.0354781486,
0.0194907337,
-0.115229778,
0.021521816,
0.0200673807,
-0.0053566433,
-0.0260599479,
-0.0842528641,
0.04966731,
-0.0576467291,
0.011450287,
0.0310908146,
0.0059870947,
0.0075896229,
-0.0199549776,
0.0141607244,
-0.0344019234,
0.0158594903,
-0.014195729,
0.0342216119,
0.0053441077,
0.0414771102,
-0.0323341899,
-0.068519935,
0.0241654739,
-0.012595919,
-0.0361206569,
-0.0272845738,
0.0283748023,
0.0398269743,
0.017376449,
-0.053056933,
0.0448376425,
-0.0034246619,
-0.02438429,
0.0368740857,
0.0628721938,
0.0188951269,
-0.0763706043,
-0.021459097,
0.0248267483,
-0.0210211128,
0.0756562799,
0.0082280086,
-0.0361369997,
-0.0159294568,
-0.0197431464,
-0.0444483571,
0.0603266731,
-0.0238076206,
0.0400923491,
0.0162956584,
-0.057014294,
-0.0736116394,
-0.0542074293,
0.0079534212,
0.0205914266,
0.0090330299,
-0.001981284,
0.0198445693,
-0.0311318208,
0.0130717456,
0.026294386,
-0.0189674068,
0.0247742217,
-0.0028787586,
0.0678961575,
0.0042841001,
0.0044007357,
-0.0299783349,
-0.0134308739,
-0.0297255982,
-0.0491080731,
0.0315179825,
0.0231293198,
0.0326330513,
0.0097767022,
0.022295367,
-0.0314767547,
-0.0145903872,
0.0121438056,
0.0181178916,
0.0542303286,
0.0033544283,
0.0021989713,
0.0343189426,
0.0284198802,
0.0196936633,
0.0456961952,
0.0093117254,
0.0199210923,
-0.0336985998,
-0.0089229522,
0.0553112179,
0.0004039873,
0.0348865651,
0.0075328061,
-0.0165403727,
-0.0206875578,
0.008664622,
-0.0162382722,
-0.0244842097,
0.0199108981,
-0.0176080111,
0.0468577072,
0.0269474387,
-0.0005649053,
-0.0636207238,
-0.0431155637,
0.0239574704,
0.0015772807,
-0.0169390552,
0.0843614042,
0.0417167135,
0.0066416399,
-0.0045992271,
-0.0061347522,
-0.0196165685,
-0.0304711051,
0.0776745155,
-0.0089099733,
0.0740513727,
0.0309343841,
-0.0431177542,
-0.0293755177,
-0.0290523656,
-0.0520021245,
-0.0168669112,
0.03726466,
-0.0186567307,
0.0330076776,
-0.005422703,
0.0525240563,
-0.0551460721,
0.0117710354,
-0.0035646977,
-0.0067938934,
0.0093870591,
-0.0167508423,
0.0168339107,
0.0024098761,
0.0019464635,
0.0052633644,
0.0309249181,
-0.0228835903,
0.0311586633,
-0.0239006169,
-0.0168144684,
-0.008608154,
-0.0036825768,
-0.0230122842,
-0.0184660591,
-0.015244198,
-0.0070379437,
-0.0823196173,
-0.0731554851,
-0.0200714227,
0.0384839214,
-0.0007215459,
-0.0070283813,
-0.0142426724,
0.0745792389,
-0.02896473,
-0.0465433411,
-0.0166428648,
0.0172689985,
-0.017936416,
0.0213241,
-0.0324928015,
-6.214180356e-33,
-0.0280749984,
0.0022664471,
0.0160592999,
-0.0338516608,
-0.0000110651,
-0.0513042361,
-0.0076419986,
0.0262672883,
-0.0520652607,
0.0504594967,
0.0066884793,
0.0243199281,
0.0172040928,
-0.0194604695,
0.0224068314,
0.0202326737,
0.0275652222,
0.0310713667,
-0.0337262452,
-0.0477204435,
0.0316241533,
-0.0487811454,
0.0334117562,
-0.0553738624,
0.0542200319,
0.0160001665,
0.0163433533,
-0.0071783187,
-0.0622333698,
0.006708343,
0.0165082105,
0.0272084177,
0.0117279915,
-0.0069119576,
0.0143192774,
0.0274670422,
-0.0422430038,
-0.0426947139,
0.0621245801,
0.0083510168,
0.0043069785,
-0.0102409581,
0.009691936,
0.0178493205,
-0.019293597,
-0.003678289,
0.0136794699,
-0.0419443399,
0.0188995432,
0.0689230785,
-0.0677823871,
0.0070051253,
0.0060691512,
0.0209536254,
-0.0174273215,
0.0495787337,
-0.0343941599,
-0.0484577492,
-0.0336988755,
0.0578044616,
0.0325094759,
0.000367794,
0.0411419868,
0.0072464603,
0.0035951643,
0.0418139808,
0.0998384506,
0.0034947214,
-0.0228202008,
0.0083139492,
0.026619453,
0.0277521536,
0.0469427817,
0.0899377838,
0.0673317686,
-0.0030771724,
-0.0506834313,
-0.0334708169,
0.0424662605,
0.0560537949,
0.0513973199,
-0.0064291628,
-0.0261895284,
-0.0209243726,
-0.0571190901,
-0.0308037363,
-0.0357552357,
-0.0246088244,
0.0189708285,
-0.0272393338,
-0.0080423215,
-0.012853778,
0.0261347219,
-0.009699774,
-0.0439934917,
0.0238487422,
-0.0055813682,
0.0062749591,
-0.0042310902,
0.0361377858,
-0.035204187,
0.0078929514,
-0.0127554536,
0.0305203181,
0.0317167677,
0.0048374911,
-0.0018555996,
-0.0192302968,
-0.0233072992,
-0.0210568532,
-0.0352196656,
-0.0596608184,
0.0128713744,
-0.0389149785,
0.0647963956,
0.0318992175,
0.0085587408,
-0.0597449541,
0.041968707,
-0.0480224192,
-0.0322751664,
0.0231874511,
-0.0305834375,
0.0201707426,
-0.01699044,
-0.0271819718,
-0.034444727,
-0.0144006694,
0.0067832023,
-0.0671403036,
-0.0177337434,
0.0110395262,
2.726e-7,
0.0261425152,
0.0486048311,
-0.050600376,
0.0178027488,
0.0273043904,
0.025293557,
-0.0095176473,
-0.0351738557,
0.0954275802,
-0.0251256451,
-0.0260819402,
0.0128250038,
0.034041442,
0.0633824766,
-0.0490565337,
-0.0164197683,
-0.0135693625,
-0.003389155,
-0.0433669128,
0.0150951957,
0.0577319525,
0.0679057315,
0.023660861,
-0.0130155999,
-0.0103409989,
-0.0223364793,
0.0380266495,
0.0008646335,
0.0053748554,
0.0063841483,
0.0256829336,
-0.0225266647,
0.0326134562,
0.0856280476,
0.0296774302,
-0.012843824,
0.0129633239,
0.0412457921,
-0.032113295,
0.0262234267,
-0.039162904,
-0.0542499237,
-0.0263595171,
-0.1066356301,
0.0727354661,
-0.0689239055,
-0.0232661143,
0.0050968369,
-0.042908702,
-0.0067421379,
0.0384730957,
-0.0003718884,
-0.0131274192,
-0.0193068236,
0.0402156711,
0.0077303569,
-0.0207947474,
-0.0350809135,
-0.0303340517,
0.0188389383,
-0.0204264056,
-0.0831043646,
-0.005011573,
-0.0003797447,
0.0375764556,
-0.0343177877,
0.0018410389,
2.078039602e-34,
0.0232395343,
0.0123750614,
0.0225995872,
-0.0183693785,
0.0546213277,
-0.032780081,
0.0174199007,
0.0253599826,
0.0405544974,
-0.0756386593,
0.0058687683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12552v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12552v2 | SituatedGen: Incorporating Geographical and Temporal Contexts into Generative Commonsense Reasoning | 2023-06-21T20:36:55 | 2023-10-27T20:55:02 | Yunxiang Zhang, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, commonsense reasoning in text generation has attracted much
attention. Generative commonsense reasoning is the task that requires machines,
given a group of keywords, to compose a single coherent sentence with
commonsense plausibility. While existing datasets targeting generative
commonsense reasoning focus on everyday scenarios, it is unclear how well
machines reason under specific geographical and temporal contexts. We formalize
this challenging task as SituatedGen, where machines with commonsense should
generate a pair of contrastive sentences given a group of keywords including
geographical or temporal entities. We introduce a corresponding English dataset
consisting of 8,268 contrastive sentence pairs, which are built upon several
existing commonsense reasoning benchmarks with minimal manual labor.
Experiments show that state-of-the-art generative language models struggle to
generate sentences with commonsense plausibility and still lag far behind human
performance. Our dataset is publicly available at
https://github.com/yunx-z/situated_gen. | [
0.0235883705,
0.0753826946,
-0.006222439,
0.0039171833,
-0.0376936682,
-0.0067392737,
0.0421636403,
-0.0299444236,
0.0217290167,
-0.042950578,
0.04065153,
0.0243875254,
0.0168316048,
0.012769537,
0.035153877,
-0.0790122226,
0.0148717053,
0.0156598315,
-0.043615099,
0.0121572427,
-0.0146649815,
0.0423103832,
-0.0247329734,
0.0437111594,
0.0074625644,
-0.0303585771,
0.0020158309,
-0.0048300507,
0.0605867803,
-0.0058760797,
0.0177459139,
0.0448288061,
0.0333537161,
-0.004292008,
0.0000016647,
0.0153901037,
0.0312555842,
-0.0110921133,
0.0536477566,
0.0034918673,
0.0167819764,
-0.0041782768,
0.0119014559,
0.0076391334,
-0.0487829894,
0.0010984468,
0.0283288322,
-0.0016085698,
0.0387972407,
0.0571687818,
-0.0189576633,
-0.0309419967,
-0.0201278944,
-0.0117686344,
0.0327895917,
0.0038381545,
-0.0234145168,
0.0201481301,
0.0282380972,
0.011973897,
-0.002083879,
0.0196056962,
0.0447621569,
-0.0140290372,
-0.0033735477,
0.0705800503,
-0.0352495611,
0.0442581773,
-0.0144794704,
0.0809875503,
0.03521543,
-0.0333456919,
0.0314523019,
-0.0097660283,
-0.0095102321,
-0.0179113224,
-0.0212500542,
0.0406402387,
-0.001451975,
0.0679489747,
0.0294425767,
0.0045229341,
0.0076362663,
0.065900743,
-0.0089716427,
0.0557271093,
0.0076595587,
0.0133128623,
-0.0730908066,
0.0258527137,
-0.0298898332,
-0.0442212299,
0.0116575593,
0.0544694588,
-0.0388793014,
0.0083872462,
-0.0370098427,
0.0184499659,
0.0271957051,
-0.0121780047,
0.0252661649,
0.0371210761,
-0.0294076689,
0.0547692887,
-0.0275385752,
0.0389138386,
-0.0249251742,
-0.0053460039,
-0.0226637144,
-0.0092753805,
-0.0386477336,
0.0060023479,
-0.004230048,
-0.0226785149,
-0.0949762389,
-0.005004243,
-0.0211102739,
0.0026901932,
-0.0037006603,
0.0154576395,
0.0060463096,
0.072187826,
-0.077407077,
-0.0473388359,
-0.0113933627,
0.0131358532,
-0.0717409402,
0.0322252326,
0.0454326458,
-0.0149198994,
-0.0122634694,
0.0205704588,
0.0518285222,
-0.0310321208,
-0.0415511616,
0.0199044868,
-0.0157276858,
0.0154502206,
-0.0852402076,
-0.0332806446,
0.0061791516,
-0.0260387957,
-0.0017570752,
-0.0609738082,
0.0036434694,
-0.0053777243,
-0.0467765741,
-0.0110292202,
0.0063098525,
0.0268839579,
0.0034649493,
0.0555639453,
0.0012949533,
0.0040262938,
0.0197555963,
0.0076230355,
0.0365311541,
0.0450751297,
0.014599612,
0.0172720104,
0.0296023525,
0.044153925,
-0.01602423,
-0.0276402347,
0.011143391,
-0.0024551111,
-0.0226390958,
-0.0047769016,
-0.0549941771,
0.0568523742,
0.0480094515,
0.0377649851,
-0.0159377977,
0.0135198198,
0.0464846715,
0.0470097549,
-0.0198602285,
0.016608255,
0.071565479,
0.0247939099,
-0.0739490315,
0.0126757761,
-0.0420991108,
0.0319292583,
-0.0156951882,
0.0224754438,
0.0290469117,
0.0504859425,
-0.0241287388,
-0.0325850025,
-0.0142055815,
-0.0110008614,
0.0200598035,
-0.0373751633,
0.0195517056,
0.0173193049,
-0.0355265476,
0.0490724891,
0.0254729446,
-0.0724801719,
0.0172025505,
0.0096252859,
0.0237846505,
0.0341824703,
0.0369248129,
0.0311531778,
-0.0382490382,
0.0022248644,
0.0207158551,
0.0548225194,
0.0499380492,
-0.0107857939,
0.0017052661,
-0.059147574,
-0.023704607,
-0.0267958008,
0.0203184262,
-0.024231527,
0.0806487575,
0.0286859199,
0.0467930511,
-0.0503238738,
0.0325631909,
0.0129050603,
-0.0084796473,
-0.0165773183,
-0.0106930714,
0.0049701123,
0.0010160287,
-0.0092152301,
0.0093102166,
-0.0028291023,
0.0035007792,
-0.0470303036,
-0.0025316055,
0.0907245204,
-0.0581853539,
-0.0988600552,
0.0198119115,
-0.0638741553,
-0.0373519063,
0.0147761498,
-0.0612309761,
-0.0345945135,
0.0058791228,
-0.0013709508,
0.0216164719,
-0.0534840636,
-0.0396391563,
0.0412504971,
0.006521896,
-0.006912285,
0.1270190626,
-0.0413088128,
-0.0022263695,
0.0181456245,
0.0456332788,
0.0020978581,
-0.0355776772,
0.0390925147,
-0.0648389757,
0.0063114148,
-0.0013983606,
-0.0044994345,
0.0355180763,
-0.0405594669,
-0.0144576132,
-0.0795102865,
0.0057232468,
-0.0164810289,
0.0061937058,
0.0396453813,
-0.0265493914,
-0.0003451931,
-0.0025982277,
-0.0611836091,
0.0025861175,
0.0240741894,
0.0134670082,
0.0830901936,
-0.0390163809,
0.0343869515,
0.0113500021,
0.020964792,
-0.0314394459,
0.031423714,
0.0305887461,
0.0606151819,
-0.0205528773,
0.0439856872,
-0.0380026177,
0.0017256194,
0.0148865758,
-0.0430972315,
0.030160265,
-0.0198306758,
0.0457043424,
0.0397453718,
0.0091431011,
0.0189514887,
0.0253178924,
-0.0356510505,
-0.0163817592,
0.0226465818,
-0.0224743988,
0.0575355515,
-0.0027997221,
-0.0437216461,
-0.0372868627,
0.0407496914,
0.0133525319,
-0.0065251631,
-0.0333748013,
0.0419686697,
0.0112852361,
0.0117335776,
-0.0183817837,
0.0494081266,
-0.000747037,
0.0664363503,
-0.0684713274,
-0.038715031,
0.0568920709,
-0.0209413953,
0.0124963652,
-0.0241226517,
0.0157529116,
-0.015116022,
0.0670670643,
-0.0270446446,
0.0152855441,
-0.0249912534,
-0.0084823482,
-0.0362615921,
-0.0443392396,
0.018238835,
-0.003983804,
0.0113699306,
-0.0611420758,
0.0071006105,
-0.0170946624,
-0.068918854,
-0.0242897943,
-0.0349042043,
-0.002936316,
-0.0069485386,
0.0091505107,
-0.0444088727,
-0.0012783422,
0.0132809784,
-0.0165935419,
0.0538626201,
-0.013281391,
-0.0085872812,
-0.009728903,
0.0756187662,
0.0709651187,
0.082087703,
-0.0082704928,
0.02949447,
-0.0452048518,
0.0399187692,
0.0196163394,
-0.002085537,
-0.0129116923,
0.0638611913,
0.0027486009,
-0.0191446543,
-0.0040664724,
0.0157343559,
0.0646023825,
-0.0511463545,
-0.0812335014,
0.0560790524,
0.0471813865,
-0.01416949,
0.013160076,
-0.0225763936,
0.0295600444,
-0.0073460094,
0.0225039478,
-0.0695833862,
-0.0288540293,
0.0073803901,
-0.0249244012,
-0.0248178765,
-0.0418578573,
-0.007094007,
-0.1182432994,
0.0702738315,
0.0125637492,
-0.0597102121,
-0.0414668843,
-0.0045149089,
-0.027476782,
-0.0033667698,
-0.0117946798,
-0.0138519593,
0.0187233128,
0.0269384161,
0.012015515,
0.0077978107,
-0.088559404,
0.0231384002,
-0.0131895803,
0.0419522151,
0.0299520902,
0.0609953851,
0.0364173092,
-0.0970647335,
-0.0276792087,
-0.0277741477,
0.0149087589,
-0.0187047757,
-0.0093305754,
0.0166069195,
-0.0268318132,
-0.0203534346,
0.0829777643,
-0.0743664354,
-0.0533295535,
0.0089694411,
0.0575072095,
-0.0106266979,
0.008460653,
-0.034247756,
0.0506486371,
0.0461367778,
0.0684120879,
0.0497565009,
0.0204562619,
-0.0566267595,
-0.0309863593,
-0.0047623082,
-0.1197401509,
0.001042477,
-0.0168851968,
0.0411703065,
0.0253778826,
-0.0812522247,
-0.0380877554,
0.011515975,
0.0691323876,
-0.018965112,
-0.0290478561,
-0.0128351096,
-0.0167413503,
-0.0630438626,
0.0541753024,
-0.0200597271,
-0.0309050046,
0.0228114258,
-0.0136553319,
0.0283726174,
-0.0413003527,
-0.0306112655,
0.0475339405,
-0.0607372522,
-0.0630529299,
-0.0186159983,
0.0280206185,
0.0169548579,
0.0423075482,
-0.0390441902,
0.0009421793,
0.0588779561,
0.049640011,
-0.0223642178,
-0.0082967384,
0.0087747378,
0.0264806412,
0.0396422707,
0.0424189903,
-0.000307958,
0.0034388888,
0.0128116645,
0.0670895353,
-0.0373005942,
0.0190314893,
-0.0126800733,
-0.0431838967,
0.0237774737,
-0.0413138084,
0.023432279,
-0.045477584,
-0.023347456,
-0.0272230208,
-0.0394658297,
-0.023951875,
0.0228338502,
0.0040650102,
0.0060842223,
-0.03295926,
0.0359923355,
-0.0134709245,
0.0272449423,
-0.0085708098,
-0.0199793335,
0.0338171944,
0.0335860588,
0.0011044398,
-0.0192017667,
-0.0441776998,
-0.0004553475,
-0.0735243931,
0.044059176,
-0.0178582389,
0.055616159,
0.0371850878,
-0.0200342666,
-0.0309314951,
-0.0028535072,
-0.0602826439,
0.0480767228,
-0.0224804822,
0.033570841,
0.0808517635,
-0.0231364947,
0.0397943854,
-0.0100576989,
-0.0251760781,
0.0151330493,
0.0735179484,
0.0396939665,
-0.0566391423,
-0.0069431602,
-0.0029284745,
-0.0229796488,
0.005211323,
0.0580043048,
-0.0420436598,
0.0214835443,
0.0489917658,
-0.0315176733,
-0.0160639789,
-0.0400241166,
-0.0067274189,
-0.0063643921,
0.0222846903,
0.0226101577,
-0.0289611444,
-0.0658288151,
0.006592717,
0.0583650172,
0.0115910945,
0.0085407766,
0.0169151854,
0.0490733534,
0.0097295204,
-0.036859449,
-0.04776223,
0.0502204224,
-0.0482885577,
-0.0079765851,
-0.0634205043,
-6.248745033e-33,
-0.0207969341,
-0.0590164289,
0.0280509312,
-0.0687149018,
-0.0052936883,
0.0078800078,
-0.077581659,
-0.0421042889,
0.0045227646,
0.0388719961,
-0.0063343034,
0.0253755152,
0.0079550408,
0.05038286,
0.0019729359,
0.0071229464,
0.0186833441,
0.0300981868,
-0.0234503895,
0.0259689372,
0.0613264814,
-0.0086554103,
0.0144675486,
0.0057239304,
-0.0085303197,
-0.0297022555,
-0.0257916972,
0.0360921398,
-0.0373993441,
0.0374556743,
-0.0186636783,
0.0465201624,
0.0209986791,
0.0053856992,
-0.0071836761,
0.0200160444,
-0.0834460184,
-0.0405826196,
0.0067343195,
-0.0298103932,
-0.0453828983,
-0.0635420904,
0.0169426333,
-0.0065905983,
0.0183490384,
-0.0101475744,
0.0389247239,
-0.0286063794,
-0.0339769274,
-0.0330165066,
-0.0318773873,
0.0140775265,
-0.0247655679,
-0.0052617341,
-0.066151306,
-0.007443931,
0.027650483,
0.0004683964,
-0.0308501869,
0.0262836087,
0.0430713668,
0.0194648579,
0.0539137833,
-0.0296411719,
0.0193341859,
0.0411353074,
-0.0497359037,
-0.021058321,
-0.0802378505,
0.0316636749,
-0.0030557315,
0.0266556814,
0.0112639107,
0.0840550289,
0.0142687438,
-0.003209535,
-0.0610349923,
0.054809723,
-0.0222309269,
0.0036323022,
0.0204178952,
-0.030531574,
0.0037411102,
-0.0072479593,
-0.0090098958,
-0.0647435859,
-0.0109647634,
-0.0108433012,
0.0025102003,
-0.0080988742,
-0.0283161569,
0.0212989096,
-0.0022781435,
0.000968816,
-0.008377458,
0.0468577929,
-0.0238842983,
-0.0345812663,
-0.0054423045,
0.0278852172,
-0.0351666324,
-0.0218078308,
0.0128243295,
0.0528550409,
-0.0152908675,
0.0249572303,
0.0194381345,
0.0107198358,
-0.0221582986,
0.0033298403,
-0.0515873432,
0.0006381613,
-0.0639354065,
-0.030343568,
0.0279431473,
-0.0151242074,
-0.0074386462,
0.0123615041,
0.0173304416,
0.0303316731,
0.0122985104,
0.0144198555,
-0.0005771879,
0.0529817604,
0.005321369,
0.0270916969,
-0.0506972335,
0.0069443649,
0.0376380086,
-0.003526018,
0.0023097284,
0.0361843184,
2.249e-7,
0.006651287,
0.0077104415,
0.0272738039,
0.009173369,
-0.01741012,
0.0111849243,
0.0128311887,
0.0024182778,
-0.0446929,
0.027505219,
0.0308097471,
0.0672488064,
0.041259855,
0.0324239843,
-0.0520709492,
0.0582373366,
-0.0831671581,
0.0043341648,
-0.0555223785,
-0.0451806597,
0.0825841501,
0.0256764255,
0.0260521602,
-0.0136139477,
0.0490685478,
-0.062807776,
0.0293422714,
-0.0345139354,
-0.0098484838,
-0.003262087,
0.0191527847,
0.002705649,
-0.0021463821,
-0.0209393948,
-0.0009957845,
-0.0137324305,
-0.0329536311,
0.0550554283,
0.0332770236,
-0.0450961627,
-0.0051189926,
-0.0507620387,
0.0072214776,
-0.0636625513,
0.0679474846,
-0.0848541334,
0.0020276355,
-0.0014270975,
-0.0186794344,
0.0240922552,
-0.0042873332,
-0.018793026,
-0.0453670174,
-0.0266845189,
0.0156974867,
-0.0079165157,
-0.0119667212,
-0.0875132754,
-0.037754178,
0.019237699,
-0.0214561149,
-0.0076047084,
-0.020190306,
0.0059156464,
0.0239240993,
-0.0434110984,
-0.0139505547,
1.888999218e-34,
-0.0127612958,
0.015417086,
-0.0334572718,
-0.0221742392,
0.0548653379,
-0.001183248,
-0.0153276492,
-0.0250544008,
0.0211532004,
-0.0278823394,
-0.009960236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12550v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12550v1 | On Evaluation of Document Classification using RVL-CDIP | 2023-06-21T20:32:22 | 2023-06-21T20:32:22 | Stefan Larson, Gordon Lim, Kevin Leach | cs.CL | cs.CL | The RVL-CDIP benchmark is widely used for measuring performance on the task
of document classification. Despite its widespread use, we reveal several
undesirable characteristics of the RVL-CDIP benchmark. These include (1)
substantial amounts of label noise, which we estimate to be 8.1% (ranging
between 1.6% to 16.9% per document category); (2) presence of many ambiguous or
multi-label documents; (3) a large overlap between test and train splits, which
can inflate model performance metrics; and (4) presence of sensitive
personally-identifiable information like US Social Security numbers (SSNs). We
argue that there is a risk in using RVL-CDIP for benchmarking document
classifiers, as its limited scope, presence of errors (state-of-the-art models
now achieve accuracy error rates that are within our estimated label error
rate), and lack of diversity make it less than ideal for benchmarking. We
further advocate for the creation of a new document classification benchmark,
and provide recommendations for what characteristics such a resource should
include. | [
-0.0152146732,
0.0580844209,
-0.0097270794,
-0.0234703254,
-0.0367443822,
0.027727969,
0.0832756311,
0.0250775628,
0.0008229254,
-0.065034844,
-0.0191909224,
0.0163238533,
-0.0044180425,
-0.0266970657,
-0.0341172293,
-0.0238083005,
0.0579545237,
-0.0094664861,
0.0208234284,
0.0103336405,
-0.0346702822,
-0.0242073126,
0.0017899066,
0.0001883757,
-0.0293926802,
-0.0377808474,
0.0057316716,
0.0051238872,
-0.010498357,
-0.0092343092,
0.0162999742,
0.0516896471,
0.0134108877,
0.0646396726,
0.0000018588,
-0.0530707836,
-0.0468367673,
0.0477818698,
-0.033770252,
-0.0176995508,
0.0602602363,
0.0347997695,
0.0112249982,
-0.0088769812,
0.0045988639,
-0.0734297037,
0.0076607694,
0.1051661298,
0.0098221758,
0.0692646727,
-0.0264829788,
-0.0146995578,
0.0251316614,
0.0020055941,
0.0291204136,
-0.052332513,
0.0340955816,
-0.0031111469,
-0.0055160099,
0.0017512224,
0.0073474078,
0.0240365248,
0.0011582557,
0.0191725492,
0.0230480097,
0.050195273,
-0.011712891,
-0.0014871673,
-0.004926973,
0.0292754695,
0.0083665028,
-0.03289425,
-0.011971849,
0.0127425026,
0.052087862,
0.0089267632,
-0.0127573246,
0.0071719075,
-0.0124435471,
-0.0445465259,
-0.024502838,
0.0575975999,
0.0256811585,
0.0142301302,
0.0430670343,
0.0280942079,
0.0000064265,
-0.0548129231,
0.0586107224,
0.0216181129,
0.041264534,
-0.001964137,
0.0125323702,
-0.0396464877,
0.0118480735,
-0.0164913721,
-0.0462881923,
-0.0733319223,
0.0227855239,
-0.0438711718,
0.0476606339,
-0.0620924532,
-0.0006226238,
0.065444991,
-0.0035783194,
0.0616234913,
0.0477757826,
0.0393377878,
-0.0073642409,
0.0303552933,
-0.0668533668,
0.0050096503,
-0.0208394248,
0.0638030842,
0.0159699265,
-0.0187159553,
-0.0790925249,
0.037548665,
-0.0249493662,
0.0216410756,
0.0025091488,
0.0057539307,
0.0145460665,
0.0442313962,
-0.0130233783,
-0.0309722479,
-0.0120222513,
0.025743315,
-0.0231333524,
-0.0124176694,
0.0400058962,
0.0112922369,
-0.0004383363,
-0.0150503991,
0.0238230992,
0.0288432054,
0.0196007974,
-0.0528073795,
-0.0281230621,
-0.0166102257,
-0.0233442634,
-0.026907187,
0.0230120439,
-0.0255666655,
0.0056200116,
-0.0055046286,
0.0133785009,
0.0014437205,
-0.0472940169,
-0.0268713683,
-0.0110293822,
0.0561003089,
0.008526044,
0.0172360744,
0.0773790404,
0.0069594034,
0.005314731,
0.0064440193,
-0.0175802875,
0.0236405376,
0.0627713948,
-0.0223893188,
0.0165808555,
0.0079741897,
0.0064193872,
-0.0295081753,
0.0078418925,
0.0158661082,
0.0255196318,
-0.0103614889,
-0.0201260727,
-0.0077958982,
-0.0216870513,
-0.0486406349,
0.0443945043,
0.0208859704,
0.0374547839,
-0.0450293124,
-0.0637879968,
0.0418481305,
-0.0026207231,
-0.0229346547,
-0.0124720782,
-0.0111640878,
-0.0349331386,
-0.0091573671,
-0.000298131,
-0.056710422,
-0.0530359931,
-0.02986544,
-0.0237966683,
-0.0288969297,
0.0105198864,
0.0359116793,
0.0538456999,
0.0012293477,
0.0152139608,
0.0080960896,
0.0147324465,
-0.0039859363,
-0.0612839013,
-0.0641618967,
0.0307003539,
0.001226148,
0.0300604701,
-0.0622828715,
0.0138799474,
-0.0397154093,
0.032588765,
-0.0106711993,
0.0658629686,
-0.0086202156,
0.0203263815,
-0.007677278,
-0.0333545022,
0.0308994297,
0.0292982552,
0.0336745903,
0.0419885032,
0.0124380188,
-0.0063862624,
-0.0823993385,
-0.0335592441,
0.0419122428,
0.018764561,
-0.046517998,
0.0494143218,
0.0415479429,
0.0471689962,
0.0257070363,
-0.033865504,
-0.0321900174,
0.0104071572,
0.0148645183,
-0.0120843686,
-0.0768951327,
0.0399389751,
0.041122891,
-0.007177277,
-0.0206345115,
-0.0481105,
0.0528784618,
-0.0107317176,
-0.0007421442,
-0.025608303,
-0.0135469539,
-0.0238573775,
-0.0428208672,
0.015245256,
-0.0485626645,
0.037103273,
-0.0578019768,
0.0557850748,
0.0217901282,
0.0528812222,
-0.0672668219,
0.018979175,
0.0335532054,
-0.0144965192,
-0.011606738,
-0.0502931848,
-0.0648839325,
0.0409358554,
0.0341474265,
0.018504044,
-0.009535566,
-0.0405784659,
-0.0219455808,
-0.0163428914,
-0.0241739936,
0.0167198069,
-0.0247844663,
-0.0264336597,
-0.0194368623,
-0.0065419106,
-0.0293324608,
-0.0471211523,
-0.0145194167,
0.0159183629,
0.0245881248,
-0.0024882618,
-0.0014440245,
0.0183455199,
-0.0171826724,
0.0251300819,
0.062846601,
0.0183272511,
-0.0253823344,
-0.0305837132,
0.0212877616,
0.0094402824,
-0.0174394827,
-0.0045497948,
-0.0002025445,
-0.0158634149,
0.0151465926,
-0.0551147796,
0.0229843017,
-0.0249155406,
0.0320687331,
0.0412632376,
0.0044421768,
-0.0434619188,
0.0097448835,
-0.0061000609,
0.0126291523,
0.0041522952,
-0.0319049284,
0.0483945981,
0.0037963423,
-0.0484759212,
0.0089472877,
-0.0224986784,
0.0028820569,
-0.0092391018,
-0.0400947034,
-0.0552739277,
-0.0069883987,
0.0193926394,
0.0367624126,
0.0181950424,
-0.0336046182,
0.0282865949,
-0.0263129026,
0.0236733761,
-0.0712458342,
-0.0170550067,
-0.0002402865,
0.023644913,
-0.0155350203,
0.0195119064,
0.0320375077,
-0.0101100896,
0.0037563466,
0.0046240976,
0.0356408842,
-0.0260174982,
-0.0070674298,
0.0226686746,
0.0122465324,
-0.0266519804,
-0.0665002093,
-0.0540756695,
-0.0376924202,
0.0526724793,
-0.0044058408,
-0.0171530079,
-0.0284928735,
-0.0505629927,
0.0206010751,
-0.0052820123,
0.004543765,
-0.0422669612,
-0.0476277322,
0.0538549647,
0.0557863489,
-0.0059149698,
-0.0681967959,
0.0284375455,
-0.0273930337,
-0.0133554619,
0.0191476233,
0.0523513146,
0.0689175352,
-0.0340704918,
-0.0003102243,
0.0084863538,
-0.0402971804,
-0.0342779532,
0.0104603469,
-0.0226077903,
-0.0299924854,
-0.0074023055,
0.0817895532,
0.0296333097,
-0.0857318118,
-0.0578501299,
-0.0050014039,
0.0096855825,
-0.0074508456,
0.0163746085,
-0.027636867,
0.0188873019,
0.0099425446,
0.045642335,
-0.0294641908,
-0.0153802317,
0.0001160021,
-0.0437900014,
0.0541444384,
-0.0163812824,
-0.0427179635,
0.0157144684,
-0.0844119713,
-0.0035166405,
0.0303686373,
0.0309107341,
-0.0659763888,
-0.0251615122,
-0.0513888337,
0.0148329306,
-0.0582158379,
-0.0573549382,
0.0133382035,
0.0220993664,
-0.0237677712,
0.0453393944,
0.0370082185,
-0.04074651,
-0.0419879109,
0.0648697466,
-0.0283951815,
-0.0182261877,
0.0035836198,
0.0903464779,
-0.0173194539,
0.041837465,
-0.0026428294,
-0.0004505356,
-0.005754089,
0.0129992981,
0.0127858855,
0.0081844162,
-0.0460744575,
-0.0441412143,
-0.0231543165,
-0.0192510933,
-0.0280498993,
0.0341399424,
0.0047778646,
-0.0602148399,
-0.0658801496,
0.0201609898,
0.0343413241,
-0.0010778389,
0.0357059278,
0.0634081364,
-0.0481414162,
-0.1109887809,
-0.0346496999,
-0.0434927158,
-0.0379050858,
0.0289416816,
-0.0026062638,
-0.0213618316,
-0.0133471824,
0.000138729,
-0.0625315383,
0.0188243426,
0.0152354119,
0.0241577998,
-0.0410242155,
-0.0079096304,
0.0305204839,
0.0121631101,
-0.0254777186,
-0.0255102124,
-0.0555489659,
-0.0339657292,
0.0412335731,
0.0087800622,
0.0177071933,
0.0131258955,
-0.0372765139,
-0.0680106357,
0.0588957928,
0.0683976635,
-0.0237402972,
-0.0021543349,
0.0451922454,
-0.0640746728,
-0.0586737394,
-0.0084643988,
-0.0705980659,
0.0378613509,
0.0425413363,
-0.0882498324,
-0.0678521395,
-0.0286694486,
-0.045460552,
0.0169018004,
0.0437147208,
0.0035034316,
0.0240003616,
0.0000552936,
0.0083340257,
0.0158904865,
-0.0262391288,
0.0436546206,
-0.0489631332,
0.0527113266,
0.0236840695,
-0.0142596429,
0.0819367468,
0.0353314504,
0.0105076106,
-0.0347797982,
-0.0255261548,
0.042356398,
0.0746382251,
-0.0443367846,
0.0112756509,
-0.0402853787,
-0.0083557693,
0.0410893112,
0.0583419539,
-0.0165302604,
0.0378553942,
-0.0025367243,
0.0612188205,
-0.0317262858,
0.0141411163,
-0.0712210685,
0.0031372013,
0.0395008959,
0.0141702509,
0.0317619517,
-0.0065038404,
-0.0248968154,
-0.0625886396,
-0.0176755656,
-0.0379591249,
-0.0006531137,
0.0418643616,
-0.0136777237,
-0.0133564621,
0.0237679817,
-0.0125660244,
0.0517268069,
0.0490203537,
0.0491818301,
-0.0288095344,
-0.0180227291,
-0.0428679362,
-0.0601506531,
-0.0059063844,
0.0165349972,
0.0453930087,
-0.0266326647,
-0.0161444582,
-0.049341552,
-0.005191938,
0.0659141168,
-0.0377217345,
0.0680333972,
0.0357751101,
0.015773546,
0.0622294694,
0.0057179406,
-0.010426322,
-0.0294302516,
-0.0472509377,
-0.0042859325,
0.0208396129,
-0.0115064373,
-5.229193966e-33,
0.0212357193,
-0.0274840333,
-0.0423017852,
0.0184604414,
-0.0020077489,
0.0300248954,
0.0310665015,
-0.0199899077,
0.0168643147,
0.0048358734,
-0.0279652439,
-0.0010842134,
0.0158043467,
0.0299000647,
0.0138122337,
0.0010652272,
0.0347571149,
0.004212507,
-0.0195317585,
0.0132854059,
0.0218096264,
0.0361104459,
-0.0038706602,
-0.1500134617,
0.0422797799,
0.0260086339,
-0.0270909518,
-0.0297183767,
0.0123398863,
0.0576946735,
-0.0193151794,
0.0326419026,
0.0471736155,
-0.0248893704,
0.0227322299,
0.0420708656,
-0.0764407739,
-0.0047295149,
-0.0567375049,
0.0686193928,
0.043148797,
0.0005781653,
0.0093343621,
0.0183562748,
-0.0444152653,
-0.0482580774,
0.0556514412,
-0.0142378816,
-0.050779704,
-0.0849048495,
0.00075613,
0.0238421839,
-0.0016207664,
0.0420514382,
0.0493921228,
0.0270509366,
-0.0294363163,
0.0162140932,
-0.0743140802,
-0.0079360968,
0.0065308912,
-0.0291411597,
-0.0057851183,
0.0132200122,
-0.025525799,
0.0364829823,
0.0521432012,
-0.0008790471,
0.0489844196,
-0.0381570123,
0.0586554445,
0.0133116385,
0.018702887,
0.0892384797,
0.053976763,
-0.0412445329,
-0.0486935601,
0.0584954731,
0.0367570147,
-0.0411016084,
0.0645236522,
0.0048723239,
-0.0947508663,
-0.0083714435,
-0.0088199489,
0.0183649007,
-0.0132510122,
-0.0049532056,
0.0273197368,
0.0149714937,
-0.0043937722,
-0.017978169,
0.0062224935,
-0.0345135182,
-0.0682436302,
0.0043417206,
0.0049334411,
0.0508779399,
-0.014127627,
-0.0602069385,
0.0071374858,
-0.0351682343,
0.0297431983,
0.0123600056,
0.0272430833,
-0.0168520119,
0.0909012705,
-0.0117883673,
-0.0517393574,
-0.0001744082,
0.0236584079,
0.0071068224,
0.0363785289,
0.0863771215,
-0.006871745,
-0.0000264276,
0.0146470983,
0.0616155863,
0.009871603,
0.0796537697,
0.0225751363,
-0.0205376763,
-0.0264441743,
-0.0211621635,
0.0065474403,
-0.0377930999,
-0.0041647423,
0.0125136077,
0.0100767836,
-0.031690184,
0.0222775694,
-0.0335334875,
2.565e-7,
0.0242346469,
0.0441416316,
0.0152156157,
-0.0059149456,
-0.0045300787,
0.0459087491,
-0.0196702257,
0.0352296047,
-0.028614182,
0.0264528971,
0.010160584,
-0.0381121896,
0.0669591501,
0.0342130587,
-0.0732680634,
-0.0625721961,
-0.0297198016,
0.0369880609,
-0.0771716163,
0.0301134791,
0.0442449003,
0.0715855509,
0.0469750538,
-0.0534076318,
0.0082616163,
0.0003339298,
0.0231728144,
-0.0334254205,
-0.0051544094,
0.0120687811,
0.0743569806,
0.0092380745,
0.0245248377,
0.0231524277,
-0.0264448598,
0.0079167737,
-0.0099107288,
0.0281289611,
-0.0134334201,
-0.0212357137,
0.0098933578,
-0.0067281579,
0.0019472443,
-0.0350120775,
0.0393603966,
0.0065625119,
0.0020665016,
-0.0104367072,
-0.0347560681,
-0.0288384426,
0.079261668,
-0.0057538985,
0.0076045603,
0.0468510315,
0.00101205,
-0.0549199097,
-0.0134809455,
-0.0681742504,
0.0323251411,
0.0220411848,
-0.0057149366,
0.0178743433,
0.0094020991,
0.0772462115,
0.0621385239,
-0.0339356512,
0.0017915614,
2.419374693e-34,
0.0040214155,
0.0231187008,
-0.0063746315,
-0.0316998474,
-0.0122712357,
-0.0112733431,
0.0509581827,
0.0085475296,
-0.0048650955,
-0.0265508257,
0.0494176224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12509v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12509v2 | Joint Prompt Optimization of Stacked LLMs using Variational Inference | 2023-06-21T18:45:56 | 2023-12-04T15:07:13 | Alessandro Sordoni, Xingdi Yuan, Marc-Alexandre Côté, Matheus Pereira, Adam Trischler, Ziang Xiao, Arian Hosseini, Friederike Niedtner, Nicolas Le Roux | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) can be seen as atomic units of computation
mapping sequences to a distribution over sequences. Thus, they can be seen as
stochastic language layers in a language network, where the learnable
parameters are the natural language prompts at each layer. By stacking two such
layers and feeding the output of one layer to the next, we obtain a Deep
Language Network (DLN). We first show how to effectively perform prompt
optimization for a 1-Layer language network (DLN-1). Then, we present an
extension that applies to 2-layer DLNs (DLN-2), where two prompts must be
learned. The key idea is to consider the output of the first layer as a latent
variable, which requires inference, and prompts to be learned as the parameters
of the generative distribution. We first test the effectiveness of DLN-1 in
multiple reasoning and natural language understanding tasks. Then, we show that
DLN-2 can reach higher performance than a single layer, showing promise that we
might reach comparable performance to GPT-4, even when each LLM in the network
is smaller and less powerful. | [
0.012452174,
0.1109498069,
-0.0040337816,
0.0409153067,
-0.0616113991,
0.0213108119,
0.0454014428,
-0.038960062,
0.0172706787,
0.0050965706,
-0.0202855114,
-0.0673405752,
-0.0016585494,
0.0102997441,
0.0395734347,
-0.0408578292,
0.0289883949,
-0.0557366312,
-0.0038999345,
-0.0340223126,
-0.0206553768,
-0.0022310736,
-0.0270056613,
0.0211097579,
0.0105703371,
-0.0139457602,
-0.0400763266,
0.002416885,
0.0178148039,
0.0057294033,
0.0056874887,
0.0401289575,
0.0354641713,
0.0329598151,
0.000002087,
-0.0208001453,
0.0129569527,
-0.0244243331,
-0.0657728016,
-0.0028002642,
0.0119252317,
0.0274239797,
-0.0087873125,
0.008239992,
-0.0161695741,
-0.043688409,
0.0316292346,
0.0199342221,
0.0497365482,
0.0740598068,
0.0217594467,
-0.0314692482,
0.0226686522,
-0.0634288937,
0.0486271083,
-0.0424249172,
0.0204529874,
-0.0292446185,
0.0274680685,
0.0255145766,
-0.0003073205,
0.0428271256,
0.0527775735,
-0.0262014847,
-0.0408084989,
0.0478518754,
0.0292447917,
-0.056869816,
-0.0184339806,
0.0851174071,
-0.0256896503,
-0.0001976796,
-0.0200331379,
-0.0502587631,
0.0257668421,
0.0081015928,
-0.0222106073,
0.052395273,
0.0126078743,
0.0155054098,
0.0153493835,
-0.0071911039,
0.0604740717,
-0.0117276665,
-0.0297048427,
0.0633382127,
0.0360921547,
-0.0060665351,
0.0234017652,
-0.0083794612,
-0.044645261,
-0.0794076994,
-0.0052081998,
0.0459750183,
-0.0500449203,
0.0239760857,
-0.005939797,
-0.0193939321,
0.0014959489,
0.0081340866,
0.0354174823,
0.0359696262,
-0.0333505347,
0.0505978055,
-0.0201397538,
0.0388369709,
-0.038117338,
-0.0132561149,
-0.0300321281,
-0.0079159057,
0.0166501906,
-0.0053410367,
-0.022247551,
0.0122535182,
-0.0489448868,
-0.0214628782,
-0.0205810573,
0.0489626117,
0.0007066563,
0.0226736758,
0.0092112944,
0.0322485492,
-0.0148065006,
-0.0124861039,
-0.0303590652,
-0.0040964321,
-0.0850673392,
0.0519545823,
0.0522632226,
-0.0661400855,
-0.0336317606,
0.0449974537,
0.0226873644,
-0.0232061502,
0.0114329094,
0.0625412539,
-0.0209828448,
0.0044308896,
-0.0461537391,
-0.0092399418,
-0.0009000299,
-0.0634812638,
0.0138208382,
-0.0627758801,
0.0449618623,
-0.0166217014,
-0.0348487981,
-0.0156162418,
-0.0101959063,
0.0222957097,
-0.0074275807,
0.0842513144,
0.033406768,
-0.0291332137,
0.035591282,
0.014060122,
-0.0294119976,
0.0397204459,
0.0321058072,
0.0553212501,
-0.0052920002,
0.0071260198,
-0.0006430778,
0.0368843302,
0.0241067838,
0.0197696984,
-0.0017917344,
-0.0128533421,
-0.0027543784,
0.055494599,
0.0313030034,
0.0414752737,
-0.0506122932,
-0.016074745,
0.0230283849,
0.033960849,
0.0420355946,
-0.012170936,
0.0841409639,
-0.0120382076,
-0.0312354807,
0.0276344121,
-0.0483392663,
0.0286147576,
-0.0085669253,
0.007097831,
0.0209932085,
-0.0099450117,
-0.0510402322,
-0.0422762707,
0.0113104954,
-0.015934322,
-0.0059454157,
0.0378565043,
0.0211345926,
-0.0127754118,
-0.0694907606,
0.0378870517,
0.0235755257,
-0.0071723498,
-0.005004447,
-0.0479464307,
0.0591650419,
0.0268400572,
0.0098190121,
-0.0175779164,
-0.0250061359,
-0.0090532871,
-0.0163845122,
0.0445201769,
0.0120650996,
-0.0244057626,
0.0194813255,
-0.0538091883,
-0.0267674029,
-0.0046634828,
0.0119534312,
0.0885495394,
-0.0228723213,
0.001787091,
0.0234424565,
0.0251681991,
0.0376291089,
0.0070663602,
-0.0476857461,
-0.0148418881,
0.0378542915,
0.0270728189,
0.0509949848,
-0.0022056906,
0.0191829987,
0.0202761386,
0.0025688857,
-0.0399999842,
-0.0418289825,
-0.0237352829,
-0.0941053182,
-0.0743666515,
0.0130498186,
-0.0059935814,
0.0259616207,
-0.0124362195,
-0.0645596758,
-0.0561415069,
0.0109926742,
-0.0164908487,
-0.0020977538,
-0.0412790477,
-0.0131835677,
0.0499369688,
0.032987766,
-0.0393586978,
0.0810049996,
-0.0382633433,
0.0103072897,
0.0515298173,
0.0741966516,
0.0154976333,
-0.0561543182,
0.012963675,
-0.0017517001,
0.0097084465,
-0.009832561,
0.0378043056,
0.0213886164,
-0.026831748,
-0.0576745346,
-0.0624185577,
0.022450937,
-0.0479942225,
0.018183196,
0.0046747136,
0.0300568752,
0.0088747507,
-0.0041954671,
-0.0646445006,
0.0338348597,
0.0171246827,
0.0048554754,
0.0363722555,
0.0351886638,
-0.0146105699,
-0.0379534923,
-0.0182884224,
-0.00807139,
0.0197495408,
-0.0004529041,
-0.0214274731,
-0.0444288291,
-0.0129035031,
-0.0170886293,
0.0470100455,
-0.0288944747,
-0.0083763227,
0.0040072426,
-0.0607732572,
0.0604184903,
0.0794479325,
0.0045900755,
0.0349613242,
0.0215196684,
-0.0111589571,
-0.0726165771,
0.0382435098,
-0.0544173121,
-0.0185319707,
-0.0188966449,
-0.0096727684,
-0.0064633493,
0.0627113879,
0.0071345414,
0.0048259692,
-0.0487252846,
0.041502744,
0.0490741581,
-0.0108278748,
-0.0226153508,
-0.0108793415,
-0.0353989229,
0.0391703248,
-0.0092998715,
-0.0207894985,
0.0715484023,
-0.0319894031,
-0.0005507057,
-0.020303173,
-0.0194133166,
-0.026078973,
0.0355175436,
0.0463021584,
-0.018749699,
-0.0135670453,
-0.0526586063,
-0.0598509088,
0.0205822363,
0.022932563,
-0.0115311062,
0.020864794,
-0.0384301506,
0.0096216593,
-0.0279012732,
-0.0465176888,
-0.0620922484,
-0.00357941,
-0.015131115,
0.0262774602,
0.0069247535,
-0.0188845135,
-0.0328857675,
-0.0345833711,
0.0029313294,
0.056883432,
-0.0173190236,
0.0282577574,
-0.051773347,
0.0499390922,
0.0297702756,
0.0171898995,
0.0187915526,
-0.0290778503,
0.0297174174,
0.0011858502,
0.0108194677,
0.011585434,
0.0032323741,
0.0306945704,
0.0635118037,
-0.0244783908,
-0.0107260225,
0.0334544331,
0.0485231392,
-0.0250523016,
0.0029276316,
0.1025872827,
-0.0011839005,
-0.0699403509,
-0.0262493733,
-0.0097054103,
0.0346664675,
-0.005576381,
0.0257963575,
-0.0859357789,
-0.0473487079,
0.0256309751,
0.0121556344,
-0.0098329158,
-0.0298985653,
-0.0169624165,
-0.0946488529,
0.0056102551,
-0.0216272362,
-0.0220689364,
-0.0041693221,
-0.0279812664,
-0.0212222394,
0.0097751394,
0.0479950905,
0.0105294455,
0.0260017738,
-0.0156483054,
0.012837477,
0.0331592709,
-0.0294694882,
0.0194174945,
-0.025074264,
0.0524827801,
0.0751741156,
-0.0120171998,
-0.0190745611,
-0.0826112255,
0.0439844802,
-0.0511311404,
-0.0104013784,
-0.0102700656,
-0.0073948223,
-0.0061118854,
-0.0149929021,
0.0067304047,
0.0684672296,
-0.0295505952,
0.0024650174,
0.009888283,
0.0445247963,
-0.0299186967,
-0.045682665,
-0.0117399655,
0.0227095317,
0.0442120545,
0.0875222683,
0.0414659418,
-0.0393785834,
-0.0189690907,
-0.0429290347,
-0.0242976379,
-0.0444078483,
0.0174785629,
0.0141372709,
0.0572601594,
-0.0268306099,
-0.0377591923,
-0.0245355759,
0.0023540307,
0.0195697416,
-0.0056660967,
0.0095067061,
-0.0140747614,
-0.0107637802,
0.0123911127,
0.0055200821,
-0.0018240461,
0.0084874723,
-0.0718141049,
0.0120313242,
0.0215312112,
-0.0578368977,
-0.0417883396,
0.005987315,
-0.1313111186,
-0.0769261047,
-0.0367029868,
0.0435241014,
0.0126880277,
0.063741982,
-0.0276516173,
-0.063623853,
0.0378906876,
0.0321014822,
0.0006910605,
-0.0261307675,
0.0214718226,
0.0100615835,
-0.0106291184,
0.0439701378,
-0.0243796036,
0.0316343755,
0.0355583727,
0.0353578813,
-0.0140594263,
-0.0563692786,
-0.0031343957,
0.0068017938,
0.0155342622,
-0.02653406,
-0.0107806092,
-0.0485422909,
0.0254821815,
0.0181558542,
-0.0079506664,
-0.0445765629,
0.0252165776,
0.0227383208,
-0.0438061766,
0.0052910508,
-0.0422009788,
0.0554358251,
0.0323289335,
-0.0060937195,
0.0249074455,
0.0438465811,
0.0001130814,
0.0427622497,
-0.0136683425,
-0.024149619,
0.0490551256,
0.0014457366,
0.045334015,
-0.0421071351,
0.0690587685,
0.0577734932,
0.0152032236,
0.0067461506,
0.0028787369,
-0.0651074126,
-0.0983921066,
0.0032373681,
0.0507798716,
0.0688748732,
0.0332227908,
-0.0298880432,
-0.0396553315,
-0.0047650225,
-0.0155334724,
0.0220438726,
0.0384357162,
-0.0418148339,
0.06958092,
0.0350719318,
0.0112821609,
-0.0056380183,
0.0551996641,
0.0092456825,
0.0409077406,
-0.0228174124,
0.0472856574,
-0.0470991358,
-0.0282603502,
0.018410977,
0.0607063733,
-0.037228968,
0.0164301358,
0.0138611933,
-0.0555415004,
-0.0314235017,
0.0616640113,
0.0115127396,
0.0116106598,
0.0474440902,
0.0598248802,
-0.019741822,
-0.0020973939,
-0.0186367556,
0.0429039523,
0.0223006494,
-0.0424550809,
-0.0041979817,
-6.612531147e-33,
-0.0200581793,
0.0014293513,
0.0252148397,
0.0038339447,
-0.0122721149,
-0.0182252694,
-0.0460629947,
0.0047979741,
-0.0467469692,
0.0043235132,
-0.0176920258,
0.0012238346,
0.0189347472,
0.0375592522,
-0.0085622314,
-0.0443049036,
0.0403228737,
0.0192873981,
-0.0094103031,
0.0529310219,
-0.0015461353,
0.02269933,
0.028187247,
0.0169339608,
0.0435721166,
-0.039629627,
-0.0015067161,
0.0600953214,
-0.0515580401,
0.0164911915,
-0.0442186818,
0.0081637781,
-0.0085287988,
-0.0574562401,
0.0046462594,
0.0237962864,
-0.0815099254,
-0.0580587536,
0.0253449511,
0.0050745606,
-0.0846933648,
-0.0453822501,
0.0208912548,
0.0091002481,
0.0070432206,
0.002767005,
0.0275173597,
0.0105419112,
-0.0268366281,
-0.0272222906,
-0.0033767058,
0.0059767752,
0.0012493401,
0.0104820374,
-0.0042834999,
-0.0044850437,
-0.0008884444,
0.0485260449,
-0.0399878696,
-0.0221130587,
0.0060551441,
0.0418583117,
0.0518517271,
0.0626743063,
-0.0104177743,
0.0243912246,
0.0006429245,
-0.0545889214,
-0.0566442423,
-0.0062446357,
0.0075070774,
0.0213586036,
0.0367628001,
0.0196530055,
0.0119755166,
0.0151802171,
-0.0866318941,
-0.0131511725,
0.0739023164,
0.0089789834,
0.0035053175,
-0.0038794561,
0.0247048736,
-0.0200946722,
-0.0854720846,
-0.0140903611,
-0.050326556,
-0.0110072847,
0.01217617,
0.0269353855,
0.0136201242,
-0.0870036334,
0.0454067774,
-0.0099535519,
-0.0194011852,
0.0481655933,
0.0114756376,
-0.0130685512,
0.012428835,
0.0569919422,
-0.058515884,
-0.0012165466,
-0.0136737674,
0.007025132,
-0.0162240546,
0.0395655036,
0.0106042493,
0.0075087338,
-0.0212180465,
-0.0149401976,
-0.0545837842,
0.0284997635,
-0.0167271215,
0.0668983012,
0.0616716743,
-0.0038001791,
-0.0114380643,
0.0324532911,
-0.0141799226,
-0.0066190828,
0.010156028,
-0.0121563254,
0.0053632767,
0.0390275344,
-0.0594890267,
0.0023477487,
-0.0164992381,
0.0144163407,
0.0089007029,
-0.0493911915,
0.0162847284,
0.0425574966,
2.749e-7,
0.0152798397,
-0.0210700538,
0.029445447,
0.0653762594,
0.0241262838,
0.0319626443,
-0.0198692307,
0.0067644878,
0.0044990648,
-0.0517744943,
0.0182188414,
0.0144334417,
0.002751305,
-0.0087029375,
-0.1070834175,
-0.0063574724,
-0.0342368819,
0.0178070217,
-0.0262189545,
-0.0129736261,
0.0605751164,
0.1078696623,
0.0081831133,
-0.0267924611,
0.0282559246,
0.001339474,
0.0358249806,
-0.0121846367,
-0.000668093,
0.011860759,
0.0560596175,
-0.0074415049,
-0.0149321724,
0.0335201584,
0.0069119772,
0.0095108757,
-0.0203768704,
0.0738680288,
0.0408727936,
-0.03765288,
-0.0280121062,
-0.0196456201,
-0.0035612076,
-0.0543713383,
0.087990351,
-0.0346425883,
-0.0204650667,
-0.0173877664,
-0.0053748209,
-0.0372834355,
0.0195508134,
-0.0291139875,
-0.0084114354,
0.0078130858,
0.0153831476,
-0.0156700984,
-0.0020424703,
-0.103723608,
0.0191201288,
-0.0153913051,
-0.0565566085,
-0.0333374627,
-0.0620694719,
-0.0178698562,
0.0334569998,
-0.0675759241,
-0.0417883247,
2.531090507e-34,
0.049416095,
0.0027072513,
0.0104270102,
0.0032337359,
-0.0062346724,
0.0022039425,
-0.0341022424,
0.0104671046,
0.0379530601,
-0.0894562826,
-0.0621494949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12424v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12424v3 | VisoGender: A dataset for benchmarking gender bias in image-text pronoun resolution | 2023-06-21T17:59:51 | 2023-12-12T16:08:18 | Siobhan Mackenzie Hall, Fernanda Gonçalves Abrantes, Hanwen Zhu, Grace Sodunke, Aleksandar Shtedritski, Hannah Rose Kirk | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We introduce VisoGender, a novel dataset for benchmarking gender bias in
vision-language models. We focus on occupation-related biases within a
hegemonic system of binary gender, inspired by Winograd and Winogender schemas,
where each image is associated with a caption containing a pronoun relationship
of subjects and objects in the scene. VisoGender is balanced by gender
representation in professional roles, supporting bias evaluation in two ways:
i) resolution bias, where we evaluate the difference between pronoun resolution
accuracies for image subjects with gender presentations perceived as masculine
versus feminine by human annotators and ii) retrieval bias, where we compare
ratios of professionals perceived to have masculine and feminine gender
presentations retrieved for a gender-neutral search query. We benchmark several
state-of-the-art vision-language models and find that they demonstrate bias in
resolving binary gender in complex scenes. While the direction and magnitude of
gender bias depends on the task and the model being evaluated, captioning
models are generally less biased than Vision-Language Encoders. Dataset and
code are available at https://github.com/oxai/visogender | [
0.0315965302,
0.0779904127,
-0.0166290272,
0.0328330658,
0.0089891218,
0.004843141,
0.0427221879,
-0.0148161175,
-0.0054699192,
-0.0664372295,
-0.0090745287,
-0.0577099733,
0.0353703275,
0.0120252604,
0.0293408446,
-0.0707968548,
0.0036136839,
0.0252738819,
0.0215554051,
-0.0267117396,
0.0273469537,
0.0301599745,
0.0081706662,
0.0613207445,
-0.0208154842,
-0.0334212705,
0.0552662089,
0.0503608696,
-0.0024770729,
0.0431278311,
0.031045625,
0.0519007742,
0.0068622152,
-0.0085908659,
0.0000018437,
-0.0580783337,
0.0184970796,
0.0254750866,
0.0155059118,
-0.0273017436,
0.0195832402,
-0.0277790762,
-0.0279488955,
0.0105470251,
0.0008283762,
-0.0278068371,
0.0640797839,
0.0366197266,
0.0293555036,
0.0001380187,
-0.0178448446,
0.0231193136,
-0.0682892054,
-0.0380395018,
-0.0367167741,
-0.0125056421,
0.0194867048,
-0.0053477972,
-0.0678486601,
-0.0067723622,
-0.0433112718,
0.0351569392,
-0.0111809149,
0.0132765826,
0.0136024365,
0.0533262752,
-0.0258059762,
-0.0600429662,
0.0070386529,
0.0556486472,
0.0376078859,
0.0275598932,
-0.0149532016,
0.0104751773,
0.0038291304,
0.0125351436,
-0.0170213301,
0.0470110849,
-0.0051427255,
-0.0201778375,
-0.0781457201,
-0.0167128425,
-0.0149824414,
0.0280782487,
-0.0111247981,
0.0520998351,
0.0175176859,
-0.0005414659,
0.0393582433,
0.015429032,
-0.0077639003,
-0.0519431233,
0.0265758522,
-0.0237476993,
0.0174851213,
-0.0039751329,
-0.0382928066,
-0.0202360954,
-0.0032122771,
-0.0519160852,
-0.0142856054,
0.0280886702,
-0.0240384191,
0.0143242748,
-0.0096403267,
0.0731831193,
0.0102231381,
0.0164303575,
-0.0436451882,
-0.0750063062,
-0.0091719376,
-0.0175824314,
-0.0373686031,
-0.035220094,
-0.051531706,
0.0021237482,
-0.0360330343,
-0.0328893252,
-0.061010953,
-0.0129719581,
-0.0050525679,
0.0560859218,
-0.0448731184,
0.0204088874,
-0.0167070813,
0.0685971156,
-0.017386036,
0.0151141211,
-0.0391665138,
-0.0680444017,
0.0086724311,
0.0118964398,
0.0154469619,
-0.0271186531,
-0.0258818567,
0.0135175949,
-0.0269335546,
-0.0230513997,
0.00538442,
-0.059822537,
-0.0464134067,
-0.0396149606,
0.0125596058,
-0.0710892528,
0.0247205012,
0.0386489183,
0.0122368801,
-0.061964646,
0.0086857518,
0.0143539216,
-0.014880307,
0.0914754644,
0.0403837264,
-0.0000299379,
0.0661831796,
0.0246236883,
-0.0068079648,
0.0961082429,
0.0343795456,
0.0442175306,
0.0346252173,
0.0203149654,
0.0078670224,
0.0471609235,
0.0131428791,
-0.0068328758,
-0.0212934893,
0.0177807584,
0.0109753134,
0.0468668379,
0.1054309234,
0.0217148773,
0.017376842,
-0.0461658016,
0.0389202237,
0.057649821,
0.0172185432,
-0.0084328773,
0.0103037432,
-0.0124742752,
0.0039957566,
0.0157735422,
-0.0515464097,
0.0344030894,
0.0113623375,
-0.0357965156,
-0.0516193099,
0.0200759657,
-0.0353839621,
-0.0307018999,
0.0100294342,
0.0313432552,
-0.0323089994,
0.002581568,
0.0210713428,
0.037538249,
-0.0062905457,
0.0562162176,
0.028609423,
-0.0749122947,
-0.0014079107,
-0.0283964593,
-0.0249477401,
0.057356935,
-0.0012151941,
-0.0122882593,
-0.0021733418,
-0.0024171534,
0.0069327825,
0.0275327582,
0.0340430327,
0.0177028738,
0.0404094085,
-0.0425375476,
-0.0332167372,
0.0331958793,
0.0086538093,
0.034727376,
0.0181289054,
0.0378463641,
0.0474348851,
-0.0214669611,
-0.0627436638,
0.0291413199,
0.038457457,
-0.0179587025,
0.0112216938,
0.0336556621,
-0.0324857719,
0.0007094032,
-0.057046432,
0.002432097,
-0.0063898787,
-0.0179640874,
0.0065780389,
0.050154727,
-0.0324805155,
-0.0164169725,
0.0122143244,
-0.1120674834,
-0.0732686296,
0.0210739765,
-0.008716885,
-0.0149962204,
0.0301453322,
-0.0256226901,
-0.0437380075,
-0.0435191207,
-0.0109067671,
0.0188404489,
0.029368965,
-0.014588045,
0.0201224647,
-0.0151988929,
-0.0325480439,
0.0016694341,
-0.0109591223,
-0.0078009237,
-0.0937922969,
-0.0455772392,
0.0205519702,
0.0069915559,
0.0483503789,
0.034219861,
-0.0291702189,
-0.0187268835,
-0.0320808627,
-0.0740869567,
-0.0447203591,
-0.0303931031,
-0.0420644395,
-0.0313744433,
-0.0133017581,
-0.0117719611,
-0.0280438997,
0.013307658,
-0.002128918,
0.0002705787,
0.0418994911,
0.0288571641,
-0.0115257269,
0.027812114,
-0.0524727851,
-0.0366120413,
-0.0320597552,
0.0637300313,
0.0428807661,
-0.0019874566,
-0.0347918905,
0.0021944733,
-0.0136558218,
0.0163644608,
-0.0147095118,
-0.0109708589,
0.0291579813,
0.0186248347,
0.0444576889,
0.0871547088,
0.0063304831,
0.039652843,
0.0314568244,
-0.0156403929,
-0.0423985384,
-0.0108070839,
0.0435172357,
-0.0341709182,
0.0245107301,
-0.0922586992,
-0.0192200169,
-0.0120509667,
-0.0126481764,
-0.0117162075,
-0.0625682697,
0.0513228923,
-0.0475486778,
-0.0681902319,
-0.0641833395,
-0.0079922536,
0.01097559,
0.055247847,
-0.0581316166,
-0.0262045395,
0.0216902476,
-0.0270325672,
-0.0322546698,
0.022828307,
0.0049862331,
-0.0377083756,
0.0726657137,
-0.0056747654,
0.0359277911,
0.0421824418,
-0.0336059481,
-0.073305048,
-0.0336691923,
0.0210351702,
-0.0389279202,
0.0559509173,
-0.0323855914,
0.0236934889,
-0.0178653579,
-0.0342869647,
-0.0317352414,
-0.0140880318,
-0.0220373683,
-0.0049197581,
-0.0316095166,
0.0065832012,
-0.0226590335,
0.0429912098,
-0.0061899936,
-0.0110663455,
-0.0210827999,
-0.0027424539,
-0.0290232226,
0.0041326135,
0.0536386184,
0.0593218617,
-0.0353372544,
-0.0174272452,
-0.0345679186,
0.0479777828,
0.0049138782,
0.0214910973,
-0.0558945313,
0.0196193345,
0.0389585458,
-0.0014718093,
0.0012945491,
-0.0301141068,
0.0421356633,
-0.0515616126,
0.034576118,
0.0963858813,
-0.0013975452,
-0.0611779355,
-0.0346321091,
0.0136568043,
0.0154059445,
0.0557231009,
0.0134275006,
-0.0605233386,
0.0007567203,
0.0205606762,
-0.0048619634,
-0.0038598825,
-0.034964297,
-0.026280256,
-0.1255924255,
0.0444762819,
0.0042636897,
-0.0340372697,
-0.0644805953,
-0.0085831536,
0.0063242209,
-0.0422630385,
0.0111508081,
0.0220170598,
-0.009607452,
0.0179903749,
0.004838598,
0.0013593307,
-0.0163107347,
0.0250893328,
-0.1142356172,
0.028918473,
0.0392522626,
0.0492639579,
-0.0111732278,
-0.0077630384,
-0.0247998443,
-0.0007017918,
0.0147308586,
-0.008023995,
0.0534672625,
-0.0695436299,
-0.0395313911,
-0.019071877,
0.0193677898,
0.0314047672,
0.016604621,
-0.0031384102,
-0.0161467399,
0.0199806094,
0.0153346937,
-0.0511889905,
0.0128249405,
0.0000764445,
0.0584777407,
0.021981474,
-0.0133618927,
-0.0587964989,
-0.0437162109,
0.0457934923,
0.0195320938,
-0.0673060268,
0.0098928567,
0.0246587619,
-0.0333759636,
-0.0294962749,
-0.0563785955,
0.0481094085,
0.0249476172,
-0.0112783611,
-0.0853472054,
0.0035684309,
0.0263165012,
-0.0977004766,
0.054972019,
-0.0377241708,
0.052404955,
0.0085992152,
0.0085908072,
0.0082293982,
-0.01122812,
-0.0252443738,
0.0529011376,
-0.0124706803,
-0.0359656736,
-0.0070250193,
0.0512451306,
0.0215196107,
0.0383529589,
-0.0018096998,
-0.0813394487,
-0.0068390346,
0.0587177016,
0.0179176182,
0.0534043722,
0.0231098048,
-0.0037551115,
-0.0216265414,
0.0472653247,
-0.0424379781,
0.0086626057,
-0.012423181,
0.0132180713,
0.003851925,
-0.0690458789,
0.0070367358,
0.0006084046,
-0.0093371589,
-0.0354797989,
0.028470166,
-0.048205439,
-0.0277795158,
-0.021820901,
-0.0090024192,
-0.0322047621,
-0.0037534891,
0.0226524863,
0.0371447094,
0.0140815936,
-0.0030040229,
-0.0110667469,
0.0089083835,
-0.013979774,
-0.0122402646,
0.0377842784,
0.0024929121,
-0.0138730211,
0.0322006345,
0.0096885944,
-0.0194019787,
-0.0080172811,
0.0458193645,
0.025496725,
-0.0200964902,
0.0399362445,
0.021140812,
-0.0432296507,
0.0031089606,
-0.0254558157,
-0.0127669768,
-0.0214094464,
0.0218072142,
0.0459490605,
-0.0269791633,
0.0516864508,
-0.0031948066,
-0.0048917574,
0.0164747741,
-0.0340948589,
0.0129629551,
0.0320193172,
0.0527464263,
0.003697196,
0.0236068685,
-0.0064655617,
0.0502984039,
0.0629978329,
0.0372817032,
-0.0215961095,
-0.0569503345,
-0.0267124157,
-0.0334108062,
-0.0138998386,
-0.059479814,
-0.0024235188,
0.0153203793,
-0.0788596049,
-0.0447056666,
0.0075279246,
-0.0280030929,
0.0073723835,
0.025666533,
0.025364304,
0.0546182021,
0.0097496854,
-0.0581903197,
0.0043643313,
-0.0196193922,
-0.0080927322,
0.0067223799,
-0.0237439759,
-5.915277856e-33,
-0.0748712271,
-0.020197181,
0.0024112505,
-0.0040141786,
-0.0265767351,
0.0293374844,
0.0034226382,
-0.0037626068,
0.0128808171,
0.0387295932,
-0.005169651,
0.038628079,
0.0307337735,
0.0280343145,
-0.0106257722,
0.0199823882,
0.072952196,
0.0331607424,
-0.0292509682,
-0.0569463298,
-0.0037164255,
0.0378256626,
0.0367347673,
-0.0783885196,
0.0362411849,
0.0288013704,
-0.0231443681,
0.0111340759,
0.0173616111,
0.020850461,
0.0104318205,
0.0784839988,
-0.0013106213,
-0.0058214203,
0.0094471844,
0.0768036097,
-0.1165762693,
-0.0224905461,
0.0222260691,
0.0867674425,
-0.0091167167,
-0.0064151143,
0.0503855385,
0.006852366,
-0.0301574655,
-0.0514426194,
0.077911973,
0.0006620727,
0.0495143421,
0.0266810041,
-0.0308845975,
-0.0015851209,
-0.0245817285,
-0.0107691484,
0.040291205,
0.0009629359,
0.0109701045,
0.0037038783,
-0.1029239893,
0.0136539042,
-0.0132621871,
0.0086299488,
0.0404458009,
0.0792810693,
0.0259599611,
0.0310102701,
0.091593042,
0.0324512683,
-0.0373840258,
-0.0690948069,
0.0339544825,
0.0174209978,
0.029567454,
0.0562776737,
0.0209627636,
0.0153733818,
-0.0339283645,
-0.0207294077,
-0.0433275402,
0.0216710567,
0.0117146969,
-0.00546668,
-0.0317540206,
-0.0334487669,
-0.0626189411,
-0.0763521716,
-0.0334848203,
-0.0029128736,
0.0153187392,
-0.0074408134,
-0.0411573648,
0.0635996684,
0.0164055582,
-0.0675543621,
-0.0337763727,
-0.0228759907,
-0.0100479117,
0.0048701027,
0.0312007759,
0.0287025701,
-0.0318289883,
0.0412521139,
0.0444264188,
0.0555314757,
0.0237423237,
0.0071673263,
0.0015102699,
0.0013912283,
-0.0543193221,
-0.0180834066,
-0.0474762656,
0.0007195859,
-0.0337447114,
0.0055541899,
0.0311702266,
0.047123313,
-0.04124441,
-0.014003465,
0.0308226924,
0.0301386379,
-0.0296806563,
-0.0310578905,
0.0087214792,
0.030655669,
-0.0073237028,
0.0079610469,
-0.0151823908,
-0.0029608759,
0.0666564554,
-0.0310125351,
-0.0143255508,
-0.0113408137,
2.467e-7,
0.013841874,
0.0379546955,
0.0626631007,
0.0342174582,
0.0216605272,
0.0315850414,
0.0191055555,
0.0596457906,
0.0586942248,
-0.0300584026,
-0.0257015303,
0.0465110838,
0.0127419448,
-0.0040246677,
-0.0150847435,
0.0284783207,
-0.0435333736,
0.0007912653,
-0.015227722,
0.0059039304,
0.0183569137,
0.0617926791,
0.0250409059,
-0.0126173645,
-0.0059331902,
-0.0440339744,
0.0681787953,
0.0043405285,
0.0329473168,
0.0194468219,
0.019558765,
0.0309935398,
0.0211056806,
0.0583432168,
0.0276186708,
-0.0116283186,
0.0709060803,
-0.0065630344,
-0.0518177114,
0.0106839985,
-0.0313441455,
0.0196176469,
-0.0472588278,
-0.0312301889,
0.075048171,
-0.0137435365,
-0.0318899415,
-0.0163659602,
-0.0345059633,
0.0205673594,
0.0707995668,
-0.0223149881,
-0.0390656441,
0.0231653135,
0.0283362102,
-0.0016273694,
-0.0366052464,
-0.0759002268,
-0.0253918059,
-0.0233432949,
-0.0125230085,
-0.0235289931,
-0.0015664794,
0.0023565711,
0.0255115535,
-0.0526157841,
-0.000266433,
1.753192771e-34,
0.0186733603,
0.0469332188,
-0.0081629874,
0.0086724367,
0.0004022557,
-0.021803692,
-0.0301121231,
-0.0126301609,
0.0147955613,
0.0113085685,
-0.0111114085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12420v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12420v2 | LMFlow: An Extensible Toolkit for Finetuning and Inference of Large Foundation Models | 2023-06-21T17:58:25 | 2024-05-05T13:13:02 | Shizhe Diao, Rui Pan, Hanze Dong, Ka Shun Shum, Jipeng Zhang, Wei Xiong, Tong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Foundation models have demonstrated a great ability to achieve general
human-level intelligence far beyond traditional approaches. As the technique
keeps attracting attention from the AI community, an increasing number of
foundation models are becoming publicly accessible. However, a significant
shortcoming of most of these models lies in their performance in
specialized-domain and task-specific applications, necessitating domain- and
task-aware fine-tuning to develop effective scientific language models. As the
number of available foundation models and specialized tasks keeps growing, the
job of training scientific language models becomes highly nontrivial. In this
paper, we initiate steps to tackle this issue. We introduce an extensible and
lightweight toolkit, LMFlow, which aims to simplify the domain- and task-aware
finetuning of general foundation models. LMFlow offers a complete finetuning
workflow for a foundation model to support specialized training with limited
computing resources. Furthermore, it supports continuous pretraining,
instruction tuning, parameter-efficient finetuning, alignment tuning, inference
acceleration, long context generalization, model customization, and even
multimodal finetuning, along with carefully designed and extensible APIs. This
toolkit has been thoroughly tested and is available at
https://github.com/OptimalScale/LMFlow. | [
0.0250189304,
0.0564257875,
-0.0035231942,
0.0238447227,
-0.0489450619,
0.0161094964,
0.0126501881,
-0.0290663168,
-0.0491602756,
-0.0244735014,
-0.0404129811,
-0.0265688673,
-0.0056365253,
0.0486706086,
0.0330917351,
-0.0387022197,
0.0584737957,
-0.0460256189,
0.0143286744,
0.0013118568,
0.0103396131,
0.0126531823,
-0.0254171696,
0.0062002479,
0.0134017523,
-0.0390807316,
-0.0003924445,
0.0008053367,
0.0226227976,
-0.030644346,
0.0263631586,
0.089776136,
0.0429408737,
0.0573214106,
0.0000020057,
-0.0621959195,
0.0051211957,
0.0195681714,
-0.0265252739,
0.0145978928,
0.0606935509,
-0.0217573401,
-0.001086954,
-0.0012405999,
-0.0396475978,
-0.0070844325,
0.0824858248,
0.0147821149,
0.032105986,
0.0640045255,
0.0060887043,
-0.0643931329,
0.0455914214,
-0.0276044924,
-0.0458787493,
-0.0310732108,
0.0435783677,
0.0059354692,
-0.0116942069,
0.0139204562,
-0.021535825,
0.0251724888,
0.0276849214,
0.011511852,
-0.0006609447,
0.0467496738,
-0.0257264655,
-0.06764815,
-0.003286571,
0.0674495548,
-0.0015935757,
-0.0671608523,
-0.0035359848,
0.0035919473,
-0.0378165618,
0.0008060204,
-0.0651179627,
0.0390824117,
0.0086824046,
0.0000249487,
0.0714884773,
-0.0202977452,
0.0402946919,
0.0645855293,
-0.0225338582,
0.0760286376,
0.0369744301,
0.0060436465,
-0.0148817077,
-0.0134840235,
-0.0283797383,
-0.0567739159,
-0.0022379688,
0.0058582774,
-0.0018325371,
0.0058607287,
-0.0609450601,
-0.0280539449,
0.0298032109,
0.015686322,
0.0289020371,
0.0291661005,
-0.001303989,
0.0562981553,
-0.0119057139,
0.01737516,
-0.0291680358,
0.0342445336,
0.004830352,
-0.0082600368,
-0.0304210689,
-0.0041681807,
-0.0234041568,
-0.0205692668,
-0.0340462215,
-0.0175714046,
-0.0251058061,
-0.0086220456,
0.0231325068,
-0.0457668677,
0.0145450616,
-0.0137525201,
-0.0606404468,
-0.0040947692,
0.0149030024,
0.03659508,
-0.0572670028,
0.0284721795,
0.0049375966,
-0.0736824721,
-0.0340592861,
0.0192549545,
-0.0284811556,
-0.0400165804,
0.0454727747,
0.0363312215,
0.052729547,
-0.0455115549,
-0.0190232042,
-0.0021655904,
0.014790439,
-0.1023511291,
0.0129370866,
-0.0681065097,
0.0318839327,
0.0281842165,
0.0025745649,
-0.039352417,
0.0011445585,
-0.0090331854,
-0.0274039842,
0.0507183373,
-0.044692114,
0.008503207,
0.0148937628,
-0.0218254253,
0.0021198967,
0.0717354491,
0.0393569246,
-0.0111572063,
0.0266383123,
-0.0310055614,
-0.0311078187,
0.034568239,
0.0021725516,
0.0126902722,
-0.0130962105,
0.0174841154,
-0.0362255834,
0.0394206792,
0.0327303447,
0.0181214064,
-0.0210229475,
-0.0039611212,
0.0414914638,
0.0392899178,
0.0374071077,
0.0298596062,
0.0616881512,
-0.0195167325,
0.0164631344,
-0.0263552684,
-0.0771353617,
0.0301344227,
-0.0312972888,
0.0295148008,
-0.0268523935,
0.0694531649,
-0.0093682529,
-0.0117073972,
-0.0086406786,
-0.0025319392,
-0.0123339398,
-0.0204953514,
0.0849131644,
0.0145490887,
-0.010061251,
0.0283465218,
0.0582770258,
-0.0508136116,
-0.0115529029,
-0.020520376,
0.0250666644,
0.0222662855,
0.0398776382,
-0.0269624013,
-0.0597951636,
0.0088108424,
0.035815943,
0.0528301895,
0.051973395,
0.0024054726,
0.0006437402,
-0.0612109825,
-0.0097289607,
-0.0048373588,
0.0364518315,
0.0037412301,
0.0387368947,
-0.0285801142,
0.025875425,
-0.0470634364,
-0.0189058315,
0.0670042485,
-0.0714216083,
-0.0117276348,
-0.0432127118,
-0.020277597,
0.0427850112,
-0.014057694,
-0.0278656818,
0.0318308882,
0.0572639331,
-0.0181378387,
0.0177647714,
0.0017862584,
-0.0103723714,
-0.0162371844,
0.0521396473,
0.0056740362,
0.01231026,
0.0348240361,
-0.0353805013,
-0.0258891024,
0.0345442593,
-0.0008142458,
0.0121591967,
-0.037796095,
0.0284858327,
-0.0424372107,
0.0168104768,
-0.0209688954,
0.0539507307,
-0.0005011358,
0.0150770927,
0.0238896273,
0.0131871942,
-0.0080273878,
-0.0576741844,
0.0081414031,
-0.0266921949,
-0.0009125656,
-0.0236821081,
0.0086981133,
0.0161673985,
-0.0311375,
0.016816169,
-0.0708428621,
0.042333331,
-0.0175028965,
0.028433701,
0.0298113506,
0.0087650102,
-0.0093193855,
0.0281903818,
0.0237131845,
-0.000067099,
-0.0091998102,
0.0092012361,
-0.0005299421,
-0.0156742427,
-0.0367582515,
-0.0661476478,
-0.0383039378,
-0.0454934016,
0.0315839723,
0.0130068092,
-0.0292963702,
-0.0418085605,
0.0163050927,
-0.0042906278,
0.0239544623,
-0.0119975191,
-0.0246131402,
0.0137569206,
-0.0443707593,
-0.0092399251,
0.0672231913,
-0.0060663754,
0.0200245325,
0.0409388468,
0.003067734,
-0.0223053973,
0.0054895761,
-0.0308266059,
0.0263905488,
-0.0273163449,
0.015808817,
-0.0006962023,
0.0897900835,
-0.0529073812,
-0.0102758342,
-0.022543693,
0.0425652415,
-0.0113822678,
-0.0034391705,
0.0505977273,
0.0100536784,
-0.0304468498,
0.0255784821,
-0.0286617521,
-0.0647670925,
0.0717201009,
-0.0492381379,
-0.0151516758,
-0.0480208658,
-0.0122020319,
-0.0460547246,
0.0441806503,
0.0092032645,
0.0102939494,
0.0403965376,
0.0138458414,
-0.0536433458,
0.0281374827,
0.0078319944,
-0.0014798869,
0.0184028465,
-0.0575097278,
0.0268750172,
-0.006868259,
-0.0077920198,
-0.0051164133,
-0.0183487423,
-0.0625278652,
0.0412180088,
0.0144647136,
-0.0462236218,
-0.045763772,
0.009305587,
0.0089934133,
0.035975717,
-0.0429442227,
0.023715958,
-0.0287350919,
0.0022991961,
0.0664009377,
0.0215171408,
0.0491993539,
-0.0509488881,
0.0091795083,
0.016581811,
0.0247350633,
0.0181573704,
-0.0386630259,
-0.0053320266,
0.0311426893,
-0.0156837814,
-0.0079037854,
0.0132769533,
0.0603116788,
-0.0642128438,
-0.0354930498,
0.1273587942,
0.0018986041,
-0.016814705,
0.0216909312,
0.0041297115,
0.0441809148,
0.0435393378,
0.0186894797,
-0.0771569163,
-0.0618583076,
0.011108391,
0.0102012688,
0.0109515302,
-0.0299365502,
-0.0074347956,
-0.0848612636,
0.0295031052,
0.0349075347,
-0.0565604828,
-0.0035696379,
-0.0762343258,
0.0079777474,
-0.0331083201,
-0.0199576337,
0.027585838,
-0.0059982645,
0.014459799,
0.0055266093,
0.0136423614,
-0.1165768355,
0.0278906263,
-0.0527700596,
0.0529329441,
0.0526977256,
-0.0004817819,
-0.0197554193,
-0.0037964259,
0.0398378484,
-0.021448873,
-0.0036442387,
-0.0245795716,
0.0306910723,
0.0023785238,
-0.0083046565,
-0.003364098,
0.0732096806,
-0.0547035374,
-0.0228387285,
-0.007529397,
0.1014746875,
-0.0147238914,
-0.0290137865,
-0.0360469446,
-0.0148291169,
-0.0074805622,
0.0777827874,
0.0233089179,
-0.0198213235,
-0.0527250953,
-0.0127139417,
-0.0148923732,
-0.0299245436,
-0.0476622917,
-0.0088614793,
-0.0086002257,
-0.0260837693,
-0.0309134293,
0.0134221222,
0.0588177331,
0.0370107591,
0.010268271,
-0.0138538582,
0.0001029634,
-0.0054289582,
-0.0485282801,
0.068076618,
-0.0259838421,
0.0464349836,
-0.0860411152,
-0.0118807992,
0.0728240684,
0.0053278552,
-0.019999655,
0.0727312639,
-0.0458357856,
-0.0856629312,
-0.0052812048,
0.0712573752,
0.0295809992,
-0.0019900622,
-0.0202893987,
-0.0392799079,
0.0057450342,
0.0040377569,
-0.0523336008,
0.0204547849,
0.0235078558,
-0.0675339177,
-0.0070094573,
0.0305221304,
-0.0264082402,
0.0415221527,
-0.0069743269,
0.0811670348,
-0.0203079041,
-0.0423783474,
0.0153202889,
0.0185783803,
0.0565828383,
-0.0178959444,
-0.0148775149,
-0.0296340194,
0.0037855697,
-0.0107348831,
-0.0123624476,
-0.0336564109,
0.0193423964,
0.010275675,
0.0171117056,
0.0116188573,
-0.0085983127,
-0.0139496895,
0.0254491679,
-0.0475501157,
0.0377873145,
0.0047316346,
0.0269716345,
0.0313610695,
-0.0190268364,
-0.0106603317,
-0.0115701882,
-0.0505842343,
0.0333733521,
-0.0426074006,
0.0466884188,
0.0244245511,
0.0235093329,
-0.0504185855,
0.0264966097,
-0.0453727394,
-0.0325210802,
-0.0537184477,
0.0122611402,
0.0419664718,
-0.0025897478,
0.0610416643,
-0.0429071262,
-0.0303225052,
-0.0444170944,
0.0362193845,
0.002913509,
-0.0097770328,
0.0484770127,
0.0380383842,
-0.0204904545,
-0.0234941561,
0.0510038026,
0.0304891914,
0.0848159119,
0.0043565594,
0.0194085278,
-0.0148066888,
-0.0422320031,
-0.0472018681,
0.0105486857,
-0.0206937362,
0.0072464105,
-0.0637793988,
-0.0635484904,
0.016968105,
-0.001032057,
-0.0020749266,
-0.033134792,
0.048662819,
0.0555096641,
-0.0471791178,
-0.0335607827,
-0.0039719236,
0.0186499208,
-0.0196208209,
-0.0385647565,
-0.0442211032,
-6.262213259e-33,
-0.0228745751,
0.0134246731,
0.0324519277,
0.0071992925,
-0.0332894325,
-0.0006400904,
-0.0420369804,
-0.0029713055,
-0.0495505407,
0.0233829189,
0.026353376,
-0.0034153752,
-0.0013709478,
0.0085922778,
-0.0075288895,
0.0343334526,
0.0357022621,
-0.0106944665,
-0.0186783895,
0.020143345,
0.0220353771,
0.0346455351,
0.0737790018,
-0.0907562971,
-0.0242829118,
-0.0027761909,
-0.0042362087,
0.0449200608,
-0.0472388975,
0.0513842441,
-0.010187218,
-0.0059784674,
0.0105634117,
-0.0577775389,
-0.0103537627,
-0.0102918269,
-0.0851746202,
-0.0007156509,
0.0336129442,
-0.0159254372,
-0.0520603098,
-0.0362680741,
0.0516535193,
-0.0015457652,
-0.0167043507,
-0.0299360827,
0.0129110897,
-0.0477837324,
-0.0152534256,
-0.027589025,
-0.085142076,
0.036002595,
0.0152511653,
-0.0254983548,
0.0172377527,
-0.0209887605,
-0.0210692268,
0.0290867705,
0.0224916935,
0.0153707657,
0.042920012,
0.0354946069,
0.0522341654,
0.0241651479,
0.0300624873,
0.0457168818,
-0.0016125838,
-0.0328461826,
0.0308951847,
0.0163375251,
0.0595531575,
0.0717150718,
0.0436420552,
0.0489173308,
0.0240389314,
0.019761879,
-0.0684963167,
-0.0173474364,
0.0313155465,
0.0678339079,
0.0095083127,
0.0214353371,
0.0087270243,
-0.0105730919,
-0.0559657961,
-0.0285540391,
-0.0178673193,
-0.0027673263,
0.0130753936,
-0.0238003712,
-0.0568506829,
0.0086801788,
0.0299218949,
-0.0520071872,
-0.0178368893,
0.0429807045,
0.0068170298,
0.0419327505,
-0.0016226408,
0.034320157,
-0.0550649613,
-0.0543642528,
0.0094692977,
-0.0220195539,
0.0401684903,
-0.0014038009,
0.0276755039,
0.0149540193,
-0.0036763072,
-0.0163741298,
-0.0209884606,
-0.0177834705,
0.0435282812,
0.0743215084,
-0.0017532562,
0.035308253,
0.0096389903,
0.0649174601,
0.0302953571,
0.0143258693,
-0.029775776,
-0.0044962708,
0.023028167,
0.0329202712,
-0.0494955108,
-0.0269864127,
-0.0326848216,
0.0021546816,
0.0163526628,
-0.0630505681,
-0.0271649808,
0.0213028118,
2.677e-7,
0.0624833703,
0.0719173551,
0.029017847,
0.0039214576,
0.0207604337,
0.017127011,
-0.0164085217,
0.0011191176,
0.0211928431,
-0.0271289404,
-0.0101177525,
0.0190466177,
0.0550081618,
0.0075829551,
-0.0725254714,
0.0059749912,
-0.0390631445,
0.0008620545,
-0.0483896099,
-0.0065676053,
-0.0310565736,
0.1039944962,
0.0295349825,
-0.0208097715,
0.0108071957,
-0.0221085679,
0.0415237844,
-0.0213344414,
0.0157305691,
0.0554090403,
-0.0457875617,
0.0141499685,
0.0010360717,
0.0000165143,
-0.0175400246,
0.0383275189,
-0.0183541663,
0.0820403993,
-0.0396299176,
0.0139711099,
0.041703552,
-0.0162421949,
0.0048995917,
-0.0464062877,
0.0601292923,
-0.0678951219,
-0.0285857879,
-0.0630153045,
-0.018681597,
0.0077904025,
-0.0234233905,
-0.0252124704,
0.0052078222,
0.0192850791,
0.0257814769,
-0.0092217634,
-0.049230922,
-0.0606321581,
-0.0305751115,
0.0300544649,
-0.0638890341,
-0.0500564016,
-0.0305371657,
-0.0367080532,
0.0147374785,
-0.0719243139,
-0.0031203481,
2.943800375e-34,
0.0549746156,
-0.0096191298,
0.0105620669,
0.0443796366,
0.0268439222,
-0.0228217468,
-0.0137075838,
0.0206236653,
0.0147863589,
-0.0965615585,
-0.0197152942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12466v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12466v1 | Misinformation as Information Pollution | 2023-06-21T17:30:02 | 2023-06-21T17:30:02 | Ashkan Kazemi, Rada Mihalcea | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL | Social media feed algorithms are designed to optimize online social
engagements for the purpose of maximizing advertising profits, and therefore
have an incentive to promote controversial posts including misinformation. By
thinking about misinformation as information pollution, we can draw parallels
with environmental policy for countering pollution such as carbon taxes.
Similar to pollution, a Pigouvian tax on misinformation provides economic
incentives for social media companies to control the spread of misinformation
more effectively to avoid or reduce their misinformation tax, while preserving
some degree of freedom in platforms' response. In this paper, we highlight a
bird's eye view of a Pigouvian misinformation tax and discuss the key questions
and next steps for implementing such a taxing scheme. | [
0.0610202365,
0.0588713251,
-0.0055693178,
0.0123826703,
-0.0376724526,
-0.0196276587,
0.0300490111,
-0.000194863,
-0.0123510296,
-0.0255138911,
0.0031214522,
0.010941417,
0.0273048989,
0.017042568,
0.0328710973,
-0.0562985502,
0.0439771526,
0.0189772546,
0.0576619506,
-0.0445110984,
0.0530326106,
-0.0123235211,
0.0145065524,
-0.0222110506,
0.0113041028,
-0.0403923728,
0.0381859988,
0.0032016132,
0.0279728938,
-0.0176632032,
0.0346877277,
0.0182497799,
-0.0024645415,
0.0776092038,
0.0000017392,
-0.0514533818,
-0.0218625497,
-0.0122950813,
-0.0072704898,
0.0348507054,
0.0904506743,
-0.0112317242,
0.022409616,
0.0187156908,
-0.0136788106,
0.0258566663,
0.0446481034,
0.0023954082,
0.0681820363,
0.0410932079,
-0.0043862211,
-0.0211932901,
-0.0104286596,
-0.0084735593,
0.0554944798,
-0.0108985715,
0.0303607825,
-0.0372086726,
-0.0536476895,
0.0171582513,
0.0267612953,
0.0683579743,
-0.0237290282,
-0.012124096,
-0.0214785729,
-0.0091907522,
0.0097992672,
-0.0447380096,
-0.0253669694,
-0.0104489028,
0.0397049747,
-0.0333340913,
0.0204754546,
0.0289601926,
0.025091134,
0.0737230629,
-0.050987564,
0.0312730446,
-0.0325011462,
0.01131701,
0.0724113286,
0.0155187901,
0.0406721272,
0.0643657073,
0.0571639463,
-0.0137511455,
-0.0278167967,
-0.0359207802,
0.0214243867,
-0.0023558449,
0.0135783525,
-0.0336110704,
-0.0055332878,
0.0310698207,
-0.0079467949,
-0.0051475717,
-0.0475371592,
-0.035972096,
0.014690496,
-0.0969819054,
-0.0660794377,
-0.0110615231,
0.0210186541,
0.0491154641,
0.0448067226,
-0.0780969858,
-0.0846474245,
0.0365271196,
0.0469747707,
0.0151699241,
0.0417951606,
-0.0008413517,
0.0044401875,
0.0115356874,
0.004668666,
0.0237516966,
-0.0089468313,
0.0100168632,
-0.0771421269,
0.0264557954,
0.0182193369,
0.0345031507,
0.016541034,
-0.0252232216,
-0.0031798945,
0.0412076525,
-0.0064572454,
0.0019574268,
0.0037746124,
0.0098511493,
0.0085752942,
0.0161060728,
0.0469464287,
0.0146044455,
0.0058045615,
0.0315766372,
0.0672056526,
0.0353355333,
-0.0271872524,
-0.0575046651,
-0.0154157113,
0.0013967722,
-0.0148843555,
-0.0204923879,
-0.0572971664,
-0.0571380854,
0.012125182,
0.0235618856,
-0.0279686339,
-0.0113132866,
-0.0564478338,
0.0348624773,
-0.0224402677,
-0.0026929223,
0.0188724063,
0.0183829721,
-0.0308339857,
0.0582715794,
0.0050126491,
0.0426940881,
0.0720062777,
0.0267173201,
-0.0012669585,
0.002068575,
0.0655599236,
0.0084779002,
0.0107848989,
-0.0127428332,
-0.0804373473,
-0.0596426427,
-0.0072588366,
0.0287222937,
0.0092340428,
0.0115330173,
0.0665525794,
-0.0317184739,
-0.0403697267,
-0.0289367121,
0.0036113427,
0.036583472,
-0.0682638884,
0.0001867781,
0.0251823869,
0.0024930718,
-0.0709055141,
-0.0311649665,
0.0558499135,
-0.0054474333,
-0.0253543109,
-0.0064893709,
0.0141618075,
-0.0154515784,
0.0746485442,
0.0406579226,
-0.0128664915,
-0.0178851895,
-0.008561817,
0.0560702384,
0.0445488133,
0.0514735915,
0.0062897541,
-0.0190834627,
0.0395229682,
0.0057302485,
-0.0003055503,
0.0167882703,
0.0322595052,
-0.0568065643,
-0.0211209971,
0.0291000493,
0.0786964297,
-0.0130223194,
-0.0568975881,
-0.0069272406,
0.011840363,
-0.0236458741,
0.0241591036,
-0.0146380002,
-0.007894218,
0.0063802614,
-0.0430635996,
0.0407281443,
0.0074242516,
-0.0296181366,
0.0527730435,
-0.0467890874,
-0.094648011,
0.0392860994,
0.049993664,
0.0081383483,
0.0037855152,
-0.0029104173,
0.0424505398,
0.0075283297,
-0.0223767906,
-0.0474902131,
0.0448423401,
0.0713153929,
0.0159083325,
-0.0215029214,
-0.0406726263,
0.0308870263,
0.0188453123,
0.0201338194,
0.0658195689,
-0.0132355168,
0.0413764492,
0.000590809,
-0.068761386,
-0.0304904468,
-0.0073627289,
0.0249751508,
0.0526971407,
-0.0375419408,
0.019766707,
-0.0260301139,
-0.0447595343,
-0.0007063783,
0.0196366273,
0.0376792327,
-0.0259982757,
-0.0224882104,
-0.0042101326,
0.0425271727,
-0.039655529,
0.0102681937,
0.0193183962,
-0.0112573979,
-0.0083177546,
-0.0328907929,
0.0237661693,
0.0187837724,
0.0329326205,
0.0110826464,
0.0152140735,
-0.0462716632,
-0.0342501327,
-0.0004051922,
0.0209289473,
-0.0176320355,
0.0030661011,
-0.0253666211,
0.0346193127,
0.0040363437,
-0.0117671434,
-0.0081418967,
0.0863000527,
-0.0648197606,
-0.0118346903,
-0.001730929,
-0.0627060384,
0.0050435541,
-0.0180149674,
0.0273712743,
-0.0034629654,
0.0155735658,
-0.054934483,
0.0140704168,
0.0451492295,
0.073259823,
-0.0222430136,
0.0713879243,
-0.0177921318,
-0.0175416004,
-0.0581692308,
0.0324535295,
-0.0603558719,
-0.0208466332,
0.0493750647,
0.0217370149,
0.011610778,
0.003823264,
-0.0347551368,
0.1418839693,
-0.0300577451,
-0.0218151044,
-0.0165392403,
-0.0377975069,
0.0093308128,
0.0411527492,
-0.037090458,
-0.0379215218,
0.0465676077,
-0.0068116798,
0.0674806088,
0.005629227,
-0.0066048559,
0.0219133645,
-0.0061381706,
-0.0144518428,
0.0139422761,
0.0153071955,
0.0337659344,
0.02671271,
0.0033073712,
0.125592649,
-0.0184730589,
-0.0239184629,
0.0161349364,
0.0287162978,
0.0211233143,
-0.030141728,
0.0261498354,
-0.1305289119,
-0.021759307,
-0.0229282267,
0.0350917317,
-0.020164391,
-0.0302832834,
-0.0381730609,
0.0600973107,
-0.0581823699,
0.0008484937,
-0.0097042006,
0.0376135074,
0.0331745706,
-0.0458136052,
-0.0228139106,
0.0300695505,
-0.0210958496,
-0.065965116,
0.037580926,
-0.0264054909,
0.0377366208,
0.0416870974,
0.0054462492,
0.0210621227,
0.0165755991,
-0.0002395157,
-0.0337037556,
0.0215056855,
-0.0083074505,
0.0182279088,
0.018970428,
0.0082578016,
0.0256677568,
0.0086140968,
0.0175645556,
0.0163526889,
-0.0117062954,
-0.0358921364,
-0.0911026374,
0.0429047197,
-0.0132419588,
-0.007946603,
-0.049944099,
-0.0205497015,
-0.0121732587,
-0.0211003758,
0.0406695791,
0.008226851,
0.0360043719,
0.0077380077,
-0.0531337075,
-0.0173127912,
-0.0484624244,
-0.0614762157,
-0.0660301372,
0.0202137139,
-0.0119855283,
0.0346719138,
-0.0006563888,
0.0281569976,
-0.034833841,
-0.0198419113,
0.0431867652,
0.0576150082,
0.0380655713,
-0.0403872915,
-0.0515172444,
0.0118535813,
0.0216020085,
-0.0736308768,
-0.0038464756,
0.056275472,
-0.0079137906,
0.0025694645,
-0.0558125563,
0.0098995017,
0.0436918847,
0.0228019748,
-0.0468501262,
-0.0155709842,
0.0158534646,
-0.0818561241,
0.0141696809,
0.0019690953,
0.0663565397,
0.0269775521,
-0.0188459735,
0.0055283224,
-0.030775547,
-0.069894731,
-0.0085515566,
-0.050613597,
0.0093454858,
-0.0054887878,
0.0210315157,
-0.0625265017,
-0.0526404493,
-0.0043792874,
-0.077236332,
-0.0005695817,
-0.0125093367,
-0.0120803667,
0.0706622079,
0.0198609587,
0.0461366624,
-0.0464375168,
-0.0220522024,
-0.0088364407,
-0.0036692959,
0.0028016898,
-0.0402345769,
0.0199706815,
-0.0370545685,
-0.0049273227,
-0.0848062113,
-0.0388554558,
0.0432154834,
-0.0164801739,
0.0293420088,
0.078260228,
-0.0444868542,
0.0176004991,
0.0574568585,
0.0407492071,
-0.0154647278,
-0.005645107,
0.0537193343,
0.0051681101,
0.0056802011,
0.0216652639,
-0.0164752025,
0.0106716799,
0.0237355474,
-0.0447396003,
-0.0597748905,
0.0146865631,
-0.0094683599,
0.0236942545,
0.0024941238,
-0.0071423152,
-0.025482744,
0.0226462688,
-0.007819769,
0.0520588756,
-0.0263018459,
0.0266232416,
-0.0337546654,
0.0338620655,
-0.0194298495,
-0.0160892364,
0.0364838503,
0.0202913675,
-0.022855591,
-0.0520326085,
-0.008128331,
-0.0159464814,
0.0129438136,
0.0072516436,
-0.0205740388,
-0.014929397,
0.0702942014,
0.0139693497,
0.0096712857,
-0.0059697707,
-0.0151461856,
0.0054658903,
-0.0119341817,
0.0389336795,
-0.0294177197,
-0.013554493,
-0.0401254259,
-0.0069890618,
0.021852864,
-0.0073760413,
0.0246380027,
0.0010793564,
-0.0040329453,
-0.0121078575,
0.0310538951,
-0.0333931446,
-0.0425309576,
-0.05025189,
-0.001232975,
-0.0177805405,
-0.0307263173,
0.040033862,
0.0266319271,
0.0021932293,
0.0309448466,
-0.0146404011,
-0.0836019441,
-0.008797721,
-0.0048419666,
-0.0296581332,
0.0249483734,
0.0293876622,
0.0390007943,
-0.0500494801,
-0.0279185642,
0.0033564826,
0.050829377,
-0.0056961221,
0.0179521926,
-0.0114171021,
-0.00483278,
-0.0088964533,
0.0287677534,
-0.0020961836,
0.0507760867,
-0.0597802661,
-0.0396059081,
-0.0197138749,
-6.06722997e-33,
0.0292034224,
-0.0369783342,
-0.032530915,
0.00319415,
-0.0058963951,
-0.0016490193,
0.0452485979,
-0.027444208,
-0.0320722461,
-0.0071313409,
0.0322884806,
0.0155434581,
0.0110994307,
0.0054287929,
-0.0503812246,
-0.0762683004,
-0.0043433211,
-0.0313687734,
0.0019375088,
0.0300710071,
0.0526062213,
0.0151452087,
0.0061698146,
-0.0422747172,
0.0969901904,
-0.0206107553,
-0.0508028343,
0.0132712619,
-0.0168095399,
0.0095354868,
0.0169885121,
0.0280124266,
0.0093073128,
-0.0409945473,
0.0138824871,
0.0751142949,
-0.0176086742,
-0.0624324642,
0.0461132377,
-0.0119748972,
0.0130109927,
-0.0003827478,
0.0405160524,
0.0137013905,
-0.0175710004,
0.0356243029,
-0.0136358188,
0.0002422566,
0.0221347306,
0.0286075566,
-0.0451360606,
-0.0146235479,
-0.0102770906,
0.0324460454,
-0.0156148225,
0.0916365758,
0.017992666,
0.0537722483,
-0.0815043077,
0.0573994368,
-0.0585960597,
-0.0228324886,
-0.022113774,
-0.0378863886,
0.0073255715,
0.0332848169,
0.0163728055,
0.0335715488,
-0.0445829779,
0.0136348577,
-0.0055563198,
-0.0337672085,
0.0199510437,
0.0453038625,
0.0501796715,
-0.0423681699,
-0.0738362968,
0.0378721803,
0.0351237953,
-0.0202320311,
0.0119260745,
-0.0614471845,
-0.0230855886,
-0.0138026793,
-0.028943114,
-0.0507146753,
-0.0154015347,
0.0069905273,
-0.0171523914,
0.0564644635,
-0.0161272213,
0.0900910646,
-0.0001576084,
-0.0104409484,
-0.0537678674,
-0.0195250791,
0.0567296483,
0.0433288291,
0.0034772507,
0.00545011,
-0.0339419208,
0.0349939913,
-0.0244773496,
0.0241229571,
0.0100521604,
-0.0164908748,
0.0315780751,
0.004263896,
-0.0189188048,
0.013278177,
-0.0045004301,
0.04567663,
0.0014117017,
-0.0031666455,
0.0361691043,
0.0356847234,
0.0191593803,
-0.0870995969,
-0.0113671795,
0.0308764651,
0.0016017415,
0.0008236334,
-0.071455285,
0.0159699731,
-0.0225641821,
-0.0018433208,
-0.0051524024,
0.0026667393,
-0.0328869782,
-0.086159423,
0.006965464,
-0.0634016767,
2.506e-7,
0.022188684,
0.0006876783,
-0.0160896499,
-0.0020342339,
0.0315781049,
0.0463262163,
0.0341469795,
0.0278753825,
-0.0232908279,
-0.0768513978,
-0.0712789893,
-0.0071307127,
-0.0179704633,
0.0372922346,
-0.0319656357,
-0.0517175086,
-0.0557008833,
-0.026568057,
0.0216801167,
0.0211043525,
-0.0516229607,
0.0198283792,
0.0346474163,
-0.021809943,
-0.0097037666,
0.0171330888,
0.0602613091,
-0.0432759263,
-0.0340973996,
-0.0106142396,
0.019149255,
0.0203218106,
0.0120566394,
-0.0388901308,
-0.0020829018,
-0.0314909518,
-0.0625617057,
-0.0116045978,
0.0256817024,
0.0186175108,
-0.0414453633,
-0.0567922667,
0.0178920943,
-0.0423746854,
-0.0082065258,
0.0356576405,
-0.0601493418,
-0.0653602332,
-0.0013377733,
0.0184779204,
0.0419156961,
0.0248285364,
-0.0461267084,
-0.0238070898,
-0.0302409288,
0.0318478048,
0.0011111157,
-0.0362748802,
0.0450742655,
0.0085771782,
-0.0415034853,
-0.0214477964,
0.0266518053,
0.021538645,
0.0043557505,
-0.0031302029,
0.0489781126,
2.152889664e-34,
0.0120802335,
-0.0596743226,
-0.005697276,
-0.1068228856,
0.0076465062,
0.0116268098,
0.0193611421,
-0.0450184941,
0.024093641,
-0.0096547939,
-0.002075657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12387v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12387v1 | Solving Dialogue Grounding Embodied Task in a Simulated Environment using Further Masked Language Modeling | 2023-06-21T17:17:09 | 2023-06-21T17:17:09 | Weijie Jack Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Enhancing AI systems with efficient communication skills that align with
human understanding is crucial for their effective assistance to human users.
Proactive initiatives from the system side are needed to discern specific
circumstances and interact aptly with users to solve these scenarios. In this
research, we opt for a collective building assignment taken from the Minecraft
dataset. Our proposed method employs language modeling to enhance task
understanding through state-of-the-art (SOTA) methods using language models.
These models focus on grounding multi-modal understandinging and task-oriented
dialogue comprehension tasks. This focus aids in gaining insights into how well
these models interpret and respond to a variety of inputs and tasks. Our
experimental results provide compelling evidence of the superiority of our
proposed method. This showcases a substantial improvement and points towards a
promising direction for future research in this domain. | [
0.0133154867,
0.0082942536,
-0.0340558514,
0.052526515,
-0.0072394707,
-0.0040985928,
0.0088815922,
-0.0192534868,
0.0004593733,
-0.0365819968,
-0.048900336,
-0.0105984472,
0.0074640312,
0.0369249098,
-0.0042616399,
-0.0219418462,
0.0342835486,
-0.0602076203,
-0.0286080558,
-0.0090170018,
-0.0300490186,
0.0139797544,
-0.0468616635,
0.0635693148,
0.0156297795,
-0.0272289813,
-0.0658774152,
-0.0086783832,
0.0065126563,
-0.0415431485,
-0.0282308254,
0.0111788558,
0.0483339429,
0.0197899081,
0.0000021685,
-0.0171271898,
-0.0098648118,
-0.0199106485,
-0.0440784506,
-0.0225834306,
-0.0102279931,
-0.0025322489,
-0.0046473048,
0.0069540478,
-0.0542528741,
-0.0107270414,
0.077878356,
0.0336175524,
0.0777181089,
0.0073025622,
0.003590503,
0.0049955253,
-0.0312528647,
0.0121039823,
-0.0202617608,
-0.0443997346,
0.020029569,
0.0706135258,
0.0388871878,
0.0001606032,
-0.0292090811,
0.0144288605,
-0.00641882,
0.0017551603,
-0.0101193907,
0.0387619548,
-0.0056206062,
0.0048108348,
-0.0249110553,
0.1094813868,
0.0057375338,
-0.021064369,
0.0281643551,
0.0058555142,
-0.014486541,
0.0158744249,
-0.0404135548,
0.0128055504,
-0.0279607419,
0.0086859884,
-0.0284293238,
0.026333807,
0.0082364753,
0.0207808204,
0.0053255656,
0.0887784138,
-0.0364212021,
-0.0246632975,
-0.0542402379,
-0.047364898,
-0.0346742906,
-0.0572452731,
0.0153378993,
0.0435325131,
-0.0711975917,
0.0340051167,
-0.0233826302,
-0.0374585874,
-0.0241901688,
-0.0252381843,
0.047592137,
0.0777506307,
-0.005522362,
0.0696576908,
0.0002662561,
0.0532360524,
0.0238685217,
0.0169468876,
-0.0274582207,
0.0222977828,
-0.0526075326,
-0.0114631085,
-0.0699014291,
0.0353175923,
-0.1073442623,
-0.0254051685,
0.0558358543,
0.035493575,
-0.0478239767,
0.0127826929,
-0.0083572771,
-0.0015471783,
-0.0567988232,
-0.0004561437,
0.0000895236,
-0.0464253128,
-0.0153492102,
0.0445835516,
-0.0215224754,
-0.0503301807,
-0.0234215725,
0.013986513,
0.0114997271,
-0.0054985783,
-0.0177370664,
0.0503809229,
0.0066941064,
0.0036064591,
0.0093300305,
-0.0212401226,
0.0146224778,
-0.0408703499,
0.0039168932,
-0.0280410592,
0.0222169068,
-0.0241738893,
-0.0046410328,
-0.0084500602,
0.0256728921,
-0.006063337,
-0.0123501942,
0.1238286942,
-0.0159126651,
0.0434368551,
0.0439335778,
0.0300427862,
-0.0271431524,
0.0571784154,
0.0450401939,
0.0027211085,
-0.0020673273,
0.0057170121,
0.0182974841,
0.0239735283,
-0.0034941474,
-0.0202093627,
0.0349311195,
-0.0119318692,
-0.0173242074,
0.0401258841,
0.0151294237,
0.0317964368,
-0.0129747307,
0.0080227396,
0.056802161,
0.055212941,
-0.0727103502,
0.0174188912,
0.0557125323,
0.0713298991,
-0.0123595474,
-0.0016961066,
-0.033225704,
0.0134752346,
0.016680412,
-0.0268717781,
-0.0217785127,
0.0152764292,
-0.0109855896,
-0.0396911912,
0.0093126539,
0.0202009808,
0.0720332488,
0.0185894296,
0.0310563222,
-0.000982023,
-0.0748562142,
0.006191663,
-0.0031679575,
-0.0391351506,
0.0027400011,
-0.059479095,
0.0146342842,
0.0399234518,
0.0215014238,
-0.0443373844,
-0.0211295281,
-0.0209075529,
0.0401914902,
0.0260980744,
-0.021011604,
-0.0180590823,
0.0439505875,
-0.0290615149,
-0.0363304727,
-0.014759169,
0.0115132509,
0.0571312159,
-0.0311429836,
-0.0516728051,
0.0027096709,
-0.0214925837,
-0.0078662075,
0.0475281328,
-0.0231206138,
0.0001461304,
-0.0456430651,
0.0053903535,
0.0206925236,
0.0120629193,
-0.0342712589,
-0.025559783,
0.0229165833,
-0.0275430065,
-0.0231653191,
0.0782533363,
-0.0462995917,
-0.0436630137,
0.0314862728,
-0.0294176582,
-0.0033739726,
0.0523021854,
-0.0169977192,
-0.0373464711,
0.0397236012,
-0.0362346768,
0.0425665565,
-0.0228885114,
0.0082975524,
-0.0145467743,
-0.0080975797,
-0.0548446067,
0.0239183772,
-0.0155491941,
0.0066303033,
0.018742051,
-0.0102169625,
0.0342905968,
-0.0489611365,
0.0036231228,
0.0460033603,
-0.0096345795,
0.0124443118,
-0.0013424079,
0.00491645,
-0.0513855442,
0.0159518979,
-0.1085463241,
-0.0593314841,
-0.0239285864,
-0.0106558399,
0.0342048071,
-0.0341457315,
-0.0239268281,
-0.0098025138,
0.0034128325,
-0.0098686209,
0.0127376104,
-0.0397155285,
0.0291041415,
0.0154388174,
-0.0443951376,
-0.0372995399,
0.0186302215,
-0.0202949382,
0.0124159334,
0.0136821,
-0.0326139368,
-0.0694862381,
0.0536380857,
0.0054250755,
0.0413093939,
-0.0367891714,
-0.0356046371,
0.0189799666,
0.0097236382,
0.0601340011,
0.0591689199,
-0.0391989797,
0.0571964346,
0.0693728328,
-0.0411412865,
-0.0571112819,
0.0399121828,
0.0145373615,
-0.0013745873,
-0.0159217957,
-0.0257343184,
0.0217664912,
0.0718089566,
0.0280760676,
0.0020201993,
-0.061497502,
0.0327636115,
-0.0247283895,
-0.052607663,
-0.0292846262,
-0.044312533,
-0.0328884795,
0.0473774411,
-0.0543648563,
-0.0088341106,
0.0714193359,
-0.0382464118,
-0.0488424748,
-0.0352300741,
0.0257882141,
0.010962313,
0.0646957904,
-0.0075834217,
0.0288589969,
0.0468473025,
-0.0172041655,
-0.0419689305,
-0.0197838489,
0.0098158205,
-0.0283171553,
0.001829593,
-0.0955054536,
0.0026253818,
0.0187640432,
-0.0287383515,
-0.0437547825,
0.0023682807,
-0.007768414,
0.0115963453,
-0.0079009682,
-0.003261911,
-0.0215527099,
0.0416073911,
0.0411149003,
0.0124354502,
0.012744939,
-0.0120054176,
-0.0562796071,
-0.0214737654,
0.053547658,
0.0889368281,
-0.0017156801,
-0.0103254011,
0.0751749948,
0.0188152641,
0.070392929,
0.0008750039,
-0.023972448,
0.020428909,
0.0350033306,
0.0038207336,
0.0025280055,
0.0350398682,
0.0614169873,
-0.0338617302,
-0.0196747221,
0.0803690478,
0.0362927802,
0.0173830055,
0.0181415621,
-0.0501693897,
0.0135715902,
0.0270253085,
-0.0059044012,
-0.0282921623,
-0.021920681,
0.0258243475,
0.0068124966,
0.0090103997,
-0.060129188,
0.0042992574,
-0.110901691,
0.0438321382,
-0.0142275169,
-0.0466175377,
-0.0498172753,
-0.0225037038,
0.0468982533,
0.0227360614,
-0.0224826876,
-0.0196645092,
0.0491854176,
0.0023910771,
0.0424557067,
0.0068161865,
-0.0144989425,
0.0341547243,
-0.0468366928,
0.1171716228,
0.0627124533,
0.0554232374,
0.011726982,
-0.0157294013,
-0.0013730597,
0.038654007,
0.0156464409,
-0.0195055977,
0.001241284,
-0.0034778717,
-0.0113642123,
0.0298939515,
0.0227557812,
-0.0491479188,
-0.0321320146,
0.0117383189,
0.055980958,
-0.0361659378,
0.0401016213,
-0.0081854109,
0.0464297868,
0.0836020485,
0.0728455484,
0.0325202048,
-0.0229799245,
-0.011985492,
-0.0357325934,
-0.0016263475,
-0.0160584878,
-0.030115094,
0.010403147,
0.0001629724,
0.035778977,
-0.0654959604,
-0.0661659613,
0.0425792523,
0.0452722199,
0.025556501,
-0.0058945888,
0.0024516734,
0.0094765779,
-0.0170302019,
0.0283525307,
-0.0206375215,
0.0573112704,
-0.0040069562,
-0.0071885963,
0.0219406299,
-0.0590101406,
-0.0078230528,
0.0594321378,
-0.03125076,
-0.0400837585,
0.0239160862,
0.0437543727,
0.0234961938,
0.0332734436,
-0.0046654753,
-0.0105310306,
-0.0307554305,
-0.0376238637,
-0.0472511463,
0.0233787298,
0.0296269748,
0.0379177891,
0.011397548,
0.0228459891,
-0.0131543716,
0.0517357104,
0.0186337717,
0.070942767,
-0.0308731645,
-0.0298143346,
0.0340734087,
0.0087315729,
0.0359656438,
-0.0063075381,
-0.0161331035,
-0.0188937634,
0.0081846388,
-0.0415308848,
-0.0195334516,
-0.0581671149,
0.0032437537,
-0.0150826667,
-0.0176521502,
0.0279547218,
0.0433013923,
-0.0362647921,
0.0569714569,
0.033153601,
0.0321169756,
-0.0200693272,
0.0143610276,
0.0002356189,
0.0327413604,
0.0128127821,
0.0120526003,
0.01141953,
0.0551692769,
0.0568389781,
0.0710667372,
0.0225666165,
-0.0547443591,
-0.0466638692,
0.0596573837,
-0.0220694765,
-0.0490557738,
0.0301077701,
0.0179235525,
0.0386035182,
0.0131215528,
0.0173121169,
-0.0136419553,
0.0331434906,
0.0114545729,
0.0314261615,
0.0431197286,
-0.048832681,
0.030249387,
0.050308615,
-0.0195136741,
-0.0119767562,
0.0250814855,
0.0113858487,
0.0358429179,
-0.0122015784,
0.0100256698,
-0.0477300175,
-0.0051526567,
0.0043835286,
0.0644831136,
-0.038133204,
0.039589908,
-0.0612722859,
-0.0511422269,
-0.0235731918,
0.05042772,
0.016327342,
-0.0389345847,
0.0300554596,
0.0397398733,
-0.0018576287,
-0.0382097252,
-0.0390551463,
-0.022754414,
-0.004485047,
0.0048852987,
-0.0656954646,
-5.410310463e-33,
-0.0722265095,
-0.0691893771,
0.0411330275,
0.0218643323,
-0.029696621,
-0.0030112257,
-0.066277869,
0.0246405862,
-0.0347997695,
-0.0102404803,
-0.0126279248,
0.0151979709,
0.0087962989,
-0.004976199,
-0.0200115517,
0.0077356859,
0.0302926712,
-0.0077895443,
-0.0375212096,
-0.0103078224,
0.0169422366,
-0.0039479472,
0.0240394175,
-0.1098580286,
0.0394909754,
0.0222491883,
-0.0336526185,
0.0132827219,
0.0021264942,
0.0173413251,
-0.0401166752,
0.0097858999,
0.0302186776,
-0.0486241691,
-0.0198217873,
0.0220718049,
-0.062210124,
0.0074841054,
0.0458314791,
0.0076489104,
-0.0191801898,
-0.0102019636,
-0.0040727505,
-0.0060170339,
-0.0054063788,
0.0025781912,
0.0353349671,
-0.0317957252,
-0.0007457362,
0.046946153,
-0.0913403928,
0.0081563611,
-0.0613422059,
-0.0755038783,
0.0411685146,
0.0567791536,
-0.0045763855,
-0.0121617122,
-0.0725669265,
0.0175952613,
-0.0191822313,
-0.0395238586,
0.0781633034,
0.0578644052,
0.0265734829,
0.0538341887,
0.0222225599,
0.0182587244,
-0.057767503,
-0.0374859422,
0.0243304502,
0.0508642718,
-0.0046234177,
0.0333844908,
-0.0019253563,
0.0258583594,
-0.0343249924,
0.0415598676,
-0.0294246729,
0.0489212088,
0.0436736606,
0.0481209196,
-0.0588064976,
-0.0070675169,
-0.0564369522,
-0.0097341212,
0.0003334463,
-0.0169107039,
0.0254989807,
-0.0139277205,
-0.0392880328,
-0.0380049348,
0.0533110127,
-0.0530400984,
0.0087245246,
-0.0150661934,
-0.0111475568,
0.0226358753,
-0.0249343254,
0.0356590077,
-0.0352243595,
-0.0346666537,
0.0406336747,
0.0419666171,
0.0358454026,
-0.0149989165,
-0.0531823337,
0.0485411771,
-0.0114285834,
-0.0191638712,
-0.0365035497,
0.0045183757,
-0.0003518476,
0.0207355414,
0.0430682041,
-0.0287452452,
-0.0335307866,
-0.0150828455,
0.0190392267,
-0.0634476915,
-0.0147013413,
0.0039417152,
-0.0584077761,
0.0127941165,
-0.0398667119,
-0.0288921501,
-0.0323021337,
-0.0523836873,
0.0645504594,
-0.0230554361,
-0.0209385529,
-0.020324979,
2.918e-7,
-0.0188213587,
0.0216645654,
0.0158499964,
0.0116159823,
-0.0056100027,
0.066316478,
-0.0279838629,
0.0327202491,
-0.0038871237,
-0.0660522059,
0.018944256,
0.0583259128,
0.051224988,
-0.0324631296,
-0.0669910684,
-0.0028459313,
0.0048932908,
-0.0140975863,
-0.0488593541,
0.0248364955,
0.0467984006,
0.0378950424,
0.0044133738,
0.0231983997,
0.0058548586,
-0.0350238718,
-0.0047761817,
-0.0606153719,
0.0188006554,
0.0123349559,
0.0176866464,
-0.027213499,
-0.0432396755,
0.016486343,
0.0064171082,
0.0240389034,
0.0465390757,
0.0459106378,
-0.0248357244,
0.0073293261,
-0.0325157419,
-0.0208061896,
0.0034844954,
-0.0230706539,
0.0248931665,
-0.0581319071,
-0.050742846,
-0.0176857244,
0.0092771063,
-0.0007878178,
-0.0630111098,
0.0165245943,
-0.0148288375,
-0.0121788243,
-0.0063683284,
-0.0267245416,
0.0101901721,
-0.062581107,
-0.0192194469,
-0.0325631835,
-0.0806308314,
-0.036035534,
-0.0173948295,
-0.0377052724,
-0.0075744712,
-0.0419148356,
-0.0030620871,
2.394271001e-34,
-0.0246225689,
0.0072824084,
0.0026112704,
0.0650819093,
0.0631166101,
-0.0056388215,
0.0011357156,
0.0310122706,
0.0402508378,
-0.0615526326,
0.0010195462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14918v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14918v1 | Utilizing Natural Language Processing for Automated Assessment of Classroom Discussion | 2023-06-21T16:45:24 | 2023-06-21T16:45:24 | Nhat Tran, Benjamin Pierce, Diane Litman, Richard Correnti, Lindsay Clare Matsumura | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Rigorous and interactive class discussions that support students to engage in
high-level thinking and reasoning are essential to learning and are a central
component of most teaching interventions. However, formally assessing
discussion quality 'at scale' is expensive and infeasible for most researchers.
In this work, we experimented with various modern natural language processing
(NLP) techniques to automatically generate rubric scores for individual
dimensions of classroom text discussion quality. Specifically, we worked on a
dataset of 90 classroom discussion transcripts consisting of over 18000 turns
annotated with fine-grained Analyzing Teaching Moves (ATM) codes and focused on
four Instructional Quality Assessment (IQA) rubrics. Despite the limited amount
of data, our work shows encouraging results in some of the rubrics while
suggesting that there is room for improvement in the others. We also found that
certain NLP approaches work better for certain rubrics. | [
0.0500541255,
-0.0045412201,
-0.0088688741,
0.0362853035,
-0.0435284488,
-0.0149957919,
-0.0055337525,
-0.0168337338,
-0.0320921503,
-0.0954656228,
0.0068743597,
0.0370629765,
0.0339044295,
0.0150679965,
0.0054440936,
-0.0662815496,
-0.0024810724,
0.0284677837,
0.0397928245,
0.0777267963,
0.0426166505,
0.0036352857,
-0.0488365926,
0.0519653484,
-0.0161785763,
-0.0063908072,
-0.0163140204,
-0.0388544276,
0.0193236042,
-0.0299353451,
0.0116985012,
0.0786383301,
-0.027685795,
-0.0031894883,
0.0000017087,
-0.0570803247,
-0.0267161243,
0.0001404396,
0.0007995802,
0.0249432251,
0.0772728696,
0.0626297593,
-0.0081696231,
0.0321524367,
-0.0665100813,
0.026965078,
-0.002730858,
0.0414316282,
0.0768131986,
0.0382451601,
-0.0014634315,
-0.030397417,
-0.0033560868,
0.0663761273,
0.0069146631,
-0.0255787,
0.0106317084,
0.0479921848,
-0.0010911956,
0.0222677998,
-0.0150255011,
-0.0120074432,
-0.0060125287,
-0.0880129263,
0.0076452824,
-0.0139338663,
-0.1172009334,
-0.003928368,
0.0001016365,
0.0636327788,
0.0295415893,
0.0299100298,
0.0286002941,
-0.0091999182,
0.0301004183,
0.0010846942,
-0.0593735315,
0.0113102831,
-0.0287130903,
0.0055474765,
0.0013902145,
0.0153205097,
-0.0355684087,
-0.0052231718,
0.0364806838,
0.0149430074,
-0.0232123323,
-0.0405216999,
-0.0025080112,
0.0266703181,
0.0178410839,
-0.0262377206,
0.0115818577,
0.0251155905,
-0.008172499,
0.064757973,
-0.0188193023,
-0.0113799721,
0.0305260364,
-0.0081877485,
0.0013359383,
0.0237340424,
0.0307843704,
0.0166875869,
0.0293937158,
0.0212510359,
0.0777332932,
0.0090263123,
-0.0221578535,
0.0013983605,
-0.0715331137,
0.0022530085,
-0.0145843728,
0.0517221056,
-0.0237378906,
-0.0184189435,
-0.0390785523,
-0.0283433739,
-0.0316102915,
0.0384356938,
-0.0063836444,
0.0116301253,
0.0226113796,
0.0467068441,
-0.0291402675,
0.0555980429,
-0.0139216166,
0.0153131038,
0.0131491357,
-0.0295899808,
0.0301375426,
0.0301708728,
0.0267462693,
0.0207274482,
-0.0046852543,
0.0273313932,
0.0039260397,
-0.0199576616,
-0.0079098372,
-0.0584985949,
-0.0183498245,
-0.0152924014,
0.0131614087,
-0.0591737218,
-0.0220389739,
0.0159433763,
-0.0175962988,
0.0052384287,
0.0309907142,
0.0611630715,
-0.0095955376,
0.0284846593,
-0.0080954228,
0.0036608002,
0.0436458364,
0.0064391247,
0.0090634692,
0.0305481721,
0.0498991609,
-0.0696176812,
0.0674818754,
-0.049759727,
0.0350148343,
0.0158428065,
-0.0152681647,
-0.0360107198,
0.0188090652,
-0.0024616302,
0.0000619966,
0.0206333026,
-0.0865944251,
0.0425551124,
-0.017693473,
0.0135300299,
-0.0236625932,
0.1176635697,
-0.0228151176,
0.0205054805,
-0.0014871509,
0.0553433262,
0.0447029434,
0.0029734843,
0.0034756018,
-0.0243487637,
-0.0068850643,
-0.0275600851,
0.0749180764,
-0.013711378,
0.0331788398,
-0.1298485845,
-0.0486231595,
0.0239066388,
0.0379242487,
-0.0338301808,
0.0174781587,
0.0118298708,
-0.0366592817,
-0.013174816,
0.0097274687,
-0.0731789023,
0.01598005,
-0.0198416449,
0.0078282217,
0.0865779892,
0.0646092296,
-0.0404802263,
-0.0376518592,
-0.0082502011,
0.032424368,
0.0560577922,
0.0483277924,
-0.0342183113,
-0.0141265765,
-0.057927005,
-0.0180417802,
0.0060036802,
-0.00727543,
-0.0118668443,
-0.0020067859,
-0.0186263863,
0.0096494863,
0.0039847959,
-0.0743583664,
0.0608253554,
0.0037212481,
-0.0302552059,
-0.0081858579,
-0.0108022187,
0.0306525454,
0.0480116457,
-0.0088859061,
0.0101957563,
-0.0085774278,
0.0211640485,
-0.0018269831,
-0.004983779,
-0.0031478847,
-0.0316725597,
0.0228989273,
-0.0626454502,
-0.027622411,
-0.0074118469,
-0.0276487488,
-0.0246886313,
0.0415399633,
-0.0293906368,
-0.000955062,
0.0265411362,
0.0032681129,
-0.0152835138,
-0.0204144269,
-0.0553797334,
0.0277495869,
0.0400425345,
0.0720149353,
0.0158506408,
-0.044350937,
0.0602071024,
-0.00150875,
-0.0156250186,
-0.0385998823,
-0.04006394,
0.019942116,
0.0554503761,
0.0150271878,
-0.078728281,
-0.0040767551,
-0.0551110059,
0.0029846025,
0.001727398,
0.030429408,
0.0227207765,
-0.0463429764,
-0.0073774909,
0.0104568144,
-0.0392588191,
-0.0363937803,
0.0316479094,
-0.0301438048,
0.0416309275,
0.0146118384,
0.0247121882,
-0.0533960722,
0.0037457591,
-0.0341870226,
0.0434007868,
0.0903960019,
0.0274786111,
-0.0350574106,
0.019193368,
-0.0174642727,
-0.0107860425,
0.0216972493,
-0.0382576399,
0.0684848204,
0.0153111583,
-0.0203505028,
0.0583823435,
0.0142434426,
0.0226531085,
-0.0161850322,
-0.0533804595,
-0.0579657257,
-0.0112307323,
-0.0015689181,
0.0383588858,
-0.0320063345,
-0.019893745,
0.0499763377,
0.0500130132,
0.0295058507,
-0.0325328223,
-0.0063327407,
0.0387877785,
-0.0578753091,
0.0143690128,
-0.0333719254,
-0.0376652256,
0.0087586045,
0.0336887725,
0.005079261,
0.0179229453,
0.0627711043,
-0.0015696448,
-0.0024637249,
-0.1197961122,
0.0277309138,
-0.0363150276,
0.0107257729,
-0.0151311904,
-0.0279554091,
-0.0018099959,
-0.0322457105,
0.0108086448,
-0.0348543525,
0.0491474122,
-0.0363625586,
0.0039838585,
-0.0786671713,
-0.023015758,
0.0118560866,
0.0295713339,
-0.0325633101,
0.0284562241,
0.0151121011,
0.0005384302,
0.0108481282,
-0.0096510574,
0.004248153,
-0.0306150597,
-0.0113474755,
-0.0032335846,
-0.0187892895,
-0.035902936,
0.0287271198,
0.0285913646,
-0.0246981438,
0.0015656393,
-0.0052473242,
0.0554869249,
0.0613373704,
0.0651401803,
0.0029712296,
0.0311475359,
-0.0208983757,
-0.0100689549,
-0.0016092621,
-0.052075468,
0.0160573423,
0.0261660814,
0.0394022092,
-0.0988036022,
-0.0244798101,
0.1019767672,
0.058579009,
0.0259224437,
-0.0338196903,
-0.0517416336,
-0.0241953265,
0.0047081509,
-0.0013549506,
-0.055205822,
-0.0278514642,
-0.0530637242,
0.0233413577,
-0.0382401273,
-0.0681676865,
0.0167479478,
-0.0968716368,
0.034040302,
-0.0211629514,
-0.0249473937,
0.0105947237,
-0.0680839643,
0.0006756148,
-0.0258023553,
0.0076042693,
-0.0417365134,
0.0009720494,
0.0287117548,
0.0502054095,
-0.0639665276,
-0.0406650528,
0.0272043999,
0.0082454169,
0.0100143868,
0.0478491597,
0.0836496279,
-0.0303538125,
-0.026335137,
0.0480788834,
-0.007836666,
-0.0322859623,
-0.0000675744,
0.0770880133,
0.0019319232,
-0.008962458,
-0.0504978448,
0.028612202,
0.0087867063,
-0.0231426805,
0.0550242551,
0.0521511398,
-0.0224878173,
0.0105096893,
-0.0379086249,
0.0339914672,
0.0010542251,
0.0678740442,
0.0431307442,
-0.0280706026,
0.0086682038,
-0.0699917674,
0.0370024852,
-0.0630105212,
-0.0724984556,
0.0010372975,
-0.003974386,
0.0445254631,
-0.067480661,
-0.0713818297,
0.0672272295,
-0.0108063854,
-0.0123221362,
0.0124591701,
0.0284064356,
0.0356083214,
-0.0430589728,
-0.005267458,
0.0146181108,
-0.0266031642,
-0.0114856623,
-0.0234085172,
-0.0159912631,
0.0526139624,
-0.039038904,
0.0041157086,
-0.0044968883,
-0.0628918782,
0.0009532716,
-0.0022727081,
0.0158358011,
0.0096701011,
0.0307191517,
0.0242065489,
0.0032393683,
-0.0216071885,
0.0166112278,
-0.0500550605,
0.0239113886,
0.0536311679,
0.0146240229,
-0.0229292829,
0.0236170199,
-0.0110249473,
-0.0327959731,
0.0121404985,
-0.0542656481,
-0.0332118906,
-0.0020463422,
0.0036237808,
0.0380180143,
0.0212120228,
-0.0306786951,
-0.0172484349,
-0.0096177179,
-0.0623150393,
-0.0480409972,
-0.0222041812,
0.0048731216,
-0.0120835658,
-0.0035944146,
-0.0225189626,
0.0374025553,
-0.0867979378,
0.0612429455,
-0.000574209,
0.0692307279,
0.0247961693,
-0.0072351727,
-0.0275074095,
-0.0253121629,
-0.0137108322,
-0.0423355475,
0.0221166648,
0.04875236,
0.0085056452,
0.0563556738,
0.0082739275,
-0.0089414576,
0.0506469868,
0.0024587691,
-0.0210151523,
0.0057359412,
-0.0156812537,
0.0089695556,
-0.0358464345,
-0.0008080708,
0.0070539899,
-0.0202165358,
0.0219051521,
0.010886752,
0.0510848053,
0.0019331689,
-0.0592592694,
0.0130590778,
0.0036749467,
0.0058267745,
-0.0198168941,
0.0312385224,
-0.050113041,
-0.0116778268,
0.0040691341,
-0.0320880599,
-0.0678245276,
0.0056696623,
0.0250491202,
0.0152690075,
0.0379732065,
0.0028244869,
-0.0464146808,
0.0097785946,
-0.0081022643,
0.0240329914,
0.0439686067,
-0.0092339646,
0.0248824731,
0.0422719158,
-0.0264288038,
0.0217764247,
-0.0427571721,
-0.0197120216,
-0.0047282027,
-0.0528647378,
-0.0534650795,
-5.316677562e-33,
-0.0233075153,
-0.0735117421,
0.0243134387,
0.0589506477,
0.0102719981,
0.0004677841,
-0.0214327984,
0.0218288172,
-0.0008123927,
0.0182544943,
0.0250138249,
0.0201823823,
-0.0113475341,
0.0385517292,
0.0390648544,
-0.0129677793,
0.0022244041,
-6.833e-7,
-0.0236770138,
-0.0055200616,
0.0121403653,
-0.03411033,
0.0742623582,
-0.0504865833,
0.0571164638,
0.0244018026,
0.012540739,
-0.0173667241,
-0.0040357625,
0.0308213066,
-0.0162811782,
0.0405602343,
0.0283882264,
-0.0467440151,
-0.0048930598,
0.0575265884,
-0.0263306331,
-0.0968291387,
0.0050045187,
-0.0126577076,
-0.0118482783,
0.0059198062,
0.0790544227,
0.01787805,
-0.0340403877,
0.0030512784,
0.0855824351,
-0.0082288459,
0.0226760786,
-0.0033326203,
-0.0883773565,
0.0580795407,
-0.078030929,
-0.0314971171,
-0.0102070021,
0.0163971428,
0.0106250159,
-0.0214406066,
-0.0567900948,
0.0479312092,
0.0315360762,
0.0215855036,
0.0165935941,
-0.0201678574,
-0.0147245964,
0.0506645814,
0.0172546636,
0.0123719396,
0.0459493548,
-0.0118064592,
0.0300448872,
0.0157321412,
0.0781261995,
0.0374095365,
0.0257429332,
0.0200324785,
-0.0388631634,
0.051344458,
0.0101712095,
0.0313316211,
-0.0186503045,
-0.0515609533,
-0.0564883016,
-0.0264041256,
-0.0480669737,
0.0022781945,
0.0129856672,
-0.0154418126,
0.0195784681,
-0.0561707728,
-0.0225315541,
0.0305083208,
0.0182736423,
-0.0019285082,
-0.0429771766,
0.0052865907,
-0.0097898133,
0.0100498628,
-0.036265377,
-0.0411495529,
-0.0387550443,
0.0018789005,
0.0210096668,
0.0052614813,
0.0410160683,
-0.0376624204,
0.0146424472,
-0.0066420399,
-0.0296108257,
-0.0063139647,
-0.0027512179,
0.026403375,
-0.0016744172,
0.016269993,
-0.0053963689,
0.0229535177,
-0.0263305251,
0.0557401404,
0.017822763,
0.0019701775,
-0.0049176509,
-0.0338474512,
0.011559316,
-0.0470525287,
-0.0397675037,
-0.0128360773,
-0.0174287055,
0.0054626628,
0.0030162144,
-0.0105976909,
0.0165667534,
-0.0433668382,
2.365e-7,
0.0755074844,
0.0843213052,
0.012072294,
-0.0553923324,
-0.0173196085,
0.0216204934,
0.0147444345,
-0.0159540195,
0.0544814765,
0.0020203914,
0.0202387441,
-0.0175836869,
0.0250853077,
0.0455127954,
-0.0897185877,
-0.0951101854,
0.0091410624,
-0.0620877184,
-0.0304331221,
0.0317774974,
0.1384501159,
0.0189654883,
0.0059091239,
0.0190894511,
-0.0593580306,
-0.0205076952,
-0.0136372503,
-0.0015672898,
-0.0010636534,
0.0325795673,
0.0283307601,
-0.0254162829,
0.0196090918,
0.0073157954,
-0.0147129307,
0.0202425737,
0.0055095451,
0.0211395398,
-0.0249594282,
-0.0152410055,
0.0263755452,
-0.0240930431,
-0.0011001648,
0.006808165,
0.0228687394,
-0.0826563239,
-0.0071098791,
0.0055727852,
-0.0599913448,
-0.0116474219,
0.0214603711,
0.0052649002,
-0.0137610482,
0.0326300673,
-0.0262109712,
-0.0297028907,
0.0163320638,
-0.0495606363,
-0.0086123394,
-0.011157264,
-0.012966359,
-0.0229244344,
0.0011067179,
-0.0406999476,
-0.0100433836,
-0.0147378333,
-0.001431489,
1.715118464e-34,
0.0168544296,
-0.0378061421,
0.0559261516,
0.0288451817,
0.0417243503,
0.0235528778,
-0.0118636834,
0.0185831189,
0.0167885646,
-0.0345401056,
0.0141923549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.15448v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.15448v2 | Understanding Social Reasoning in Language Models with Language Models | 2023-06-21T16:42:15 | 2023-12-04T22:31:26 | Kanishk Gandhi, Jan-Philipp Fränken, Tobias Gerstenberg, Noah D. Goodman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | As Large Language Models (LLMs) become increasingly integrated into our
everyday lives, understanding their ability to comprehend human mental states
becomes critical for ensuring effective interactions. However, despite the
recent attempts to assess the Theory-of-Mind (ToM) reasoning capabilities of
LLMs, the degree to which these models can align with human ToM remains a
nuanced topic of exploration. This is primarily due to two distinct challenges:
(1) the presence of inconsistent results from previous evaluations, and (2)
concerns surrounding the validity of existing evaluation methodologies. To
address these challenges, we present a novel framework for procedurally
generating evaluations with LLMs by populating causal templates. Using our
framework, we create a new social reasoning benchmark (BigToM) for LLMs which
consists of 25 controls and 5,000 model-written evaluations. We find that human
participants rate the quality of our benchmark higher than previous
crowd-sourced evaluations and comparable to expert-written evaluations. Using
BigToM, we evaluate the social reasoning capabilities of a variety of LLMs and
compare model performances with human performance. Our results suggest that
GPT4 has ToM capabilities that mirror human inference patterns, though less
reliable, while other LLMs struggle. | [
0.0487936288,
0.0717944875,
-0.0288644731,
0.0590987839,
-0.0369318612,
0.0259186365,
0.0105462186,
0.0078783287,
0.0254013166,
-0.0141518041,
-0.0436764061,
-0.0470211245,
0.0187518019,
0.0178686939,
0.0506516509,
-0.0521612316,
0.004180864,
-0.0367799886,
0.0157084353,
-0.0151820853,
-0.0141483974,
0.0262645092,
0.004218671,
0.0328527726,
0.0298038535,
0.0234731138,
-0.0117339697,
-0.0080637634,
0.0443923101,
-0.0174012482,
-0.0145381102,
0.0496271811,
-0.0020432784,
0.0386551917,
0.0000021069,
-0.0726965442,
0.0215234701,
-0.0169813447,
0.0178774502,
0.0250602905,
0.031500604,
0.0322260186,
0.0225995705,
0.0112956446,
-0.0502792075,
0.0043758648,
0.000434691,
0.0343633518,
0.0257479921,
0.0351352654,
-0.0175557323,
-0.0233025569,
-0.0048604389,
-0.0263099186,
0.0306938104,
-0.0540422536,
0.0152087929,
0.010886969,
0.0383381136,
-0.0243373122,
0.0218999535,
0.0192115605,
0.0178694092,
0.0065441746,
0.0209748708,
0.0184325688,
-0.0221708473,
-0.0313441865,
0.0038638276,
0.090905793,
0.0887366384,
-0.0126016196,
0.0027818438,
0.0059131463,
0.0148979416,
0.0704991519,
-0.0116466945,
0.0131012863,
0.0205550566,
0.0192851964,
0.0150045566,
0.0187547226,
0.0214307979,
0.0481287912,
-0.0171238147,
0.1000600532,
-0.002570359,
-0.0080899801,
0.0101439795,
0.0077368566,
-0.0303713735,
-0.0641866326,
-0.0236798245,
0.0121366857,
-0.0319312662,
0.0043953578,
-0.0027367654,
0.0300466958,
0.0192981083,
-0.0124673145,
0.072773166,
0.0495323911,
0.0106050326,
0.0527387075,
0.0050746212,
0.0516412444,
-0.0200906377,
0.0414655171,
-0.0068415888,
0.0045685484,
-0.0828431398,
-0.0067300969,
0.010119481,
0.0037110392,
0.0150375105,
-0.0043237382,
-0.0072939224,
-0.0146352751,
-0.0432993099,
-0.0260845441,
-0.0090918811,
0.0189043749,
0.0399037525,
-0.0169968046,
-0.0656554699,
0.0129783135,
-0.0791573822,
0.0277110729,
0.0097088553,
-0.0745743886,
-0.0104515413,
-0.0113779772,
0.0185295511,
-0.022753451,
-0.0077321711,
0.0267091785,
0.0141327986,
-0.039302662,
0.0043501751,
-0.0447881743,
0.0047190534,
-0.0932927728,
0.0032061536,
-0.063707687,
0.0101600261,
0.0448447391,
-0.018107526,
-0.0266943369,
0.0079845805,
-0.0039708791,
-0.0601462014,
0.0647458509,
-0.0043794559,
0.0332728475,
-0.0115594035,
0.0355841629,
-0.0104065221,
0.0264872946,
0.0211185664,
0.0140405847,
0.0062568691,
0.0152214058,
0.0439533554,
0.0217409469,
0.0065322495,
-0.017349381,
-0.0111032259,
0.0309584048,
-0.0119001949,
0.037666671,
0.0241075438,
0.0679029077,
-0.0197846685,
0.00394677,
0.0781154707,
0.0765812248,
-0.0449432619,
0.014514342,
0.0278085116,
0.0315404721,
0.0191304069,
-0.0216635484,
-0.0649551824,
0.0464375354,
-0.0510144532,
-0.0432999805,
0.025656471,
0.0117668612,
-0.0293489713,
-0.0004643624,
-0.0305723734,
0.029620314,
0.0544767231,
0.0084096519,
0.0198540371,
-0.026774276,
-0.0133408615,
0.0321697667,
0.0156377126,
-0.0430740304,
-0.0161114428,
-0.0769140571,
0.0163397118,
0.048531279,
0.04797934,
0.0199498292,
-0.0201629903,
-0.0109088533,
-0.0258892272,
0.0407410972,
0.0629003644,
-0.0033339881,
-0.0292492416,
-0.01686427,
0.0030272598,
-0.0086016962,
0.0083454046,
0.0292597339,
0.0180202555,
-0.0071211932,
0.0147627061,
-0.0490098335,
-0.0038058066,
-0.0054376838,
-0.0127680078,
0.00937426,
-0.0752144456,
0.0271971487,
0.0388314351,
0.0137979686,
0.0102041122,
0.0168394018,
-0.007391151,
0.0001848178,
-0.0158057716,
0.0589119047,
-0.0397380181,
0.0248249546,
0.0301300995,
-0.0167341027,
-0.0747660249,
0.077344507,
-0.0108120656,
-0.0310523063,
0.0598390251,
-0.0202738196,
0.0207425449,
-0.0320742205,
-0.0040337937,
-0.0381729901,
-0.0072674463,
0.0114852469,
0.0783630311,
0.002206736,
0.0020622597,
0.0333153754,
-0.0440507717,
0.0232528914,
-0.0277229417,
-0.0278056115,
0.0030614624,
0.0011714495,
-0.0275480654,
0.0114824986,
-0.0077356291,
-0.0731180012,
-0.0176928453,
-0.1035401151,
-0.0414081141,
-0.0033688757,
0.0144182611,
0.0152685037,
-0.0254356787,
-0.0128372125,
0.0201326143,
-0.0534464754,
0.0026540391,
0.0198811479,
0.0115379859,
0.0329760201,
-0.0226161052,
-0.0184209999,
-0.0370468758,
0.0273985751,
-0.0514657497,
0.0320294984,
0.0398367494,
0.0024444847,
-0.0259138383,
0.0192837641,
-0.0807497799,
0.0134117166,
-0.0169753581,
-0.0747538581,
0.0423901752,
0.0057289228,
0.0288127828,
0.0626607835,
-0.0080156913,
0.0012003684,
0.04364549,
-0.0075770868,
-0.0543088205,
-0.0022184695,
0.0047305506,
0.0054247584,
-0.0361357816,
-0.0872783735,
-0.0488705151,
0.0475678518,
0.0173053928,
0.0063092913,
-0.0808413103,
0.0325461142,
-0.0182072856,
-0.032175377,
-0.0502924062,
-0.0122220246,
-0.0148704173,
0.0739210695,
-0.0200237762,
-0.0578050837,
0.085249342,
-0.0212960355,
-0.0153411767,
0.0079973582,
0.0333069898,
-0.0317513309,
0.0867304429,
0.0055692182,
0.0034257101,
-0.0105514275,
-0.0034898254,
-0.0576866344,
-0.0290316418,
0.008003206,
-0.0168334264,
-0.0080313636,
-0.0702103078,
-0.015463735,
0.0181352347,
-0.0082594836,
-0.0008291171,
-0.0209029317,
-0.0895179138,
0.0186115447,
0.007577315,
-0.0243395697,
0.0162695404,
-0.0002468931,
0.0548466742,
-0.0179145057,
-0.0177605823,
-0.0151090445,
-0.0120500177,
-0.0009305053,
0.0350680314,
0.0056015165,
0.0355146676,
-0.0409228839,
0.0180434491,
0.036696624,
0.0356968641,
0.0117729967,
-0.0226425584,
0.0232188385,
0.024666246,
0.0635041893,
-0.0181274209,
0.0157575756,
0.0924894065,
-0.0047748545,
0.0004845901,
0.1297930181,
0.0310810804,
-0.0105544934,
-0.0100149978,
-0.0237409528,
0.0358222015,
0.0347030908,
-0.0010604404,
-0.0434027985,
-0.0215930957,
0.0264055859,
0.0146001698,
-0.0139136659,
-0.0570088699,
0.014615071,
-0.0995390266,
0.0305983238,
-0.0164470691,
-0.0044595688,
0.0022475463,
-0.0344723687,
0.0400244109,
0.0104537988,
-0.0268916115,
0.0149021801,
0.0179222114,
0.0177652892,
-0.0174981132,
-0.0269261282,
-0.0565931201,
0.1027327552,
-0.0421423391,
0.0961751267,
0.0457740799,
0.0609112829,
-0.0055740201,
-0.0949520618,
0.0254063886,
0.032892473,
0.0000712676,
-0.0096368883,
0.0168444198,
-0.0025650214,
0.0098341731,
-0.0237079188,
0.0437907614,
-0.0492650531,
-0.0122778425,
-0.0244640373,
0.0853267163,
-0.0056799408,
-0.0413952209,
0.0169707444,
0.0304031949,
-0.0304303356,
0.0937583074,
0.0586994104,
-0.0230305605,
0.0012865798,
0.0063559306,
-0.0382420793,
0.0119362678,
-0.0709659457,
0.0011576561,
0.0541486293,
-0.0434588306,
-0.0360918976,
-0.0646614954,
0.0424120948,
0.0018562973,
0.000097131,
-0.0385291465,
0.0111458506,
0.019159127,
-0.0069603445,
0.0659182742,
-0.0405762903,
0.0251150187,
-0.0299548823,
-0.0069745732,
-0.0077229063,
-0.039770823,
-0.0130753638,
0.0095987748,
-0.0355575494,
-0.0666443482,
0.0009714445,
0.0248278398,
0.0321344845,
0.0159574728,
-0.0018499743,
-0.0610408112,
-0.0084873168,
-0.0258672107,
-0.0270673558,
0.0434958935,
0.0138787776,
0.0101540675,
0.013776375,
0.0553222783,
-0.0072589465,
0.0261952225,
0.0356247723,
0.0058464729,
-0.0058443882,
-0.0117147081,
0.009217984,
0.0346196741,
0.0551517494,
-0.0102822175,
-0.0108673358,
-0.027610546,
-0.0446509086,
-0.0437136889,
-0.0223701186,
-0.0496105216,
-0.020261107,
0.0284949075,
0.0229989085,
-0.0255100969,
-0.0853641406,
-0.0529277623,
0.0328557678,
-0.0134093594,
0.0139034083,
-0.0039393427,
0.0218816008,
0.0144250514,
-0.0069808564,
-0.0010992269,
-0.0271749441,
-0.0645649135,
0.0359749421,
-0.002994553,
0.0903485343,
0.0270104036,
-0.0209870711,
0.0146592567,
0.0114898896,
-0.067686066,
-0.089156799,
0.0315367505,
0.000203986,
0.002378932,
-0.017972799,
0.0292902514,
-0.0473128855,
0.0108177988,
0.015969187,
0.0239085387,
-0.0125153074,
-0.038342312,
0.0276055429,
0.0149379177,
-0.0156634822,
0.0057963408,
0.0320815817,
-0.0172501672,
0.0011075556,
0.0039289794,
-0.0288206283,
-0.0153875798,
0.0023386704,
-0.0075511979,
0.0304452647,
-0.0138581647,
0.0043382235,
-0.0979894996,
-0.0681442842,
-0.0132739665,
0.0377870202,
-0.009918008,
-0.0171162672,
0.0411825441,
0.0682932064,
-0.0164242107,
-0.0155262332,
-0.0139072817,
-0.0005031114,
-0.0289808009,
0.0062721134,
-0.0444931835,
-7.014458379e-33,
-0.0133142369,
-0.0283018164,
-0.0015743483,
-0.0201133583,
-0.012037023,
-0.025895508,
-0.0852856413,
0.037993703,
-0.0162393898,
0.0298449956,
-0.014988048,
0.0228132457,
0.0024791842,
-0.0117425658,
0.0064860447,
-0.0175380576,
-0.009229132,
-0.0079208463,
-0.0345024541,
0.0052141882,
0.0020236359,
-0.0216980074,
0.0370982289,
-0.0794649348,
0.0759616196,
-0.0035141848,
-0.0132291084,
0.0201569628,
-0.0400406271,
-0.0048020841,
-0.0197156649,
0.009736021,
0.0426069237,
-0.0263935365,
0.0176290609,
0.0201618057,
-0.0326916128,
-0.0345555171,
0.0739254653,
-0.0430512019,
-0.0568970181,
-0.0211296417,
0.009640743,
-0.0165813304,
-0.0560104363,
0.0065402808,
0.0401577726,
0.0083140498,
0.0626011267,
0.0543905012,
-0.0444352664,
-0.0051980373,
-0.0210629012,
-0.0088646319,
0.006626796,
0.0244109947,
-0.0201773308,
0.0027080351,
-0.0407572351,
0.0228905063,
0.0149381002,
-0.0255756229,
0.0762453899,
-0.0347708091,
0.0214855112,
0.0751532689,
0.0118893925,
0.0328720622,
-0.0590665899,
-0.0343051143,
0.0416603386,
0.0601887144,
0.0725266859,
0.0387090147,
-0.0072727976,
-0.0191994403,
-0.0208684783,
0.0093751512,
0.0083198268,
0.0304900501,
0.0408391543,
0.0037183214,
-0.047349792,
-0.0228427015,
-0.0486483313,
-0.0477280542,
-0.0598184168,
-0.0176108256,
0.0315601192,
-0.0289251283,
-0.0354903415,
-0.0518572442,
0.0206451342,
-0.0337689556,
0.008799226,
0.0087604271,
-0.0345150009,
0.0334575064,
0.0164731853,
0.0166723337,
-0.0505865663,
0.0035469881,
-0.0211655423,
0.050865639,
0.0522742942,
0.0049503245,
-0.0050632986,
0.0046982211,
-0.0202799179,
-0.0075347899,
-0.0637817681,
-0.0068186196,
-0.0237165242,
-0.0514143482,
0.032102976,
0.0363836028,
-0.0188329034,
-0.0265117679,
0.0044526039,
0.0013988751,
-0.0508884676,
0.0260206908,
-0.0212312695,
-0.0140637355,
-0.0275591407,
-0.0244576558,
-0.0381123051,
-0.0058406284,
0.0448578782,
0.0160004068,
-0.0097115114,
-0.0147500811,
2.838e-7,
0.0135887573,
0.075073339,
-0.0236005168,
0.0180450007,
0.0178396776,
0.0632792488,
-0.0222651046,
0.0088733016,
0.060650412,
-0.0446431264,
0.0029901278,
0.0533446632,
0.0692983046,
0.0390433557,
-0.049713064,
0.0223707054,
-0.0314038955,
-0.0319857188,
-0.0059937784,
0.0125566274,
0.0491909198,
0.0183919203,
0.054700315,
0.0068297414,
-0.0104608005,
-0.0085814446,
0.0422910415,
-0.0715882778,
0.012907438,
-0.0137759326,
0.0198826138,
-0.0081198458,
0.0171705745,
0.0251182746,
0.0354173519,
-0.0061198235,
-0.0130218882,
0.0169562772,
-0.0159765445,
-0.0283996537,
-0.0340678468,
-0.0326508135,
0.0071955961,
-0.1059780493,
0.0634480715,
-0.064206548,
-0.0577954575,
0.0329574309,
0.0013597737,
-0.0184934977,
0.0031119627,
0.0331975631,
-0.0250340383,
0.0200667158,
0.0102596898,
-0.0293379258,
-0.0030217853,
-0.0724588782,
-0.0143416459,
-0.034952905,
-0.0167064033,
-0.0722841695,
-0.0447000824,
-0.0044621825,
-0.0036664759,
-0.055503305,
0.0018256978,
2.302892156e-34,
0.0264962371,
0.0199870281,
0.0353901014,
-0.0400063619,
0.0924651995,
0.0056371395,
-0.03486057,
0.0132891964,
0.0463319682,
-0.10614907,
-0.0022171135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.15666v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.15666v2 | Testing of Detection Tools for AI-Generated Text | 2023-06-21T16:29:44 | 2023-07-10T16:14:33 | Debora Weber-Wulff, Alla Anohina-Naumeca, Sonja Bjelobaba, Tomáš Foltýnek, Jean Guerrero-Dib, Olumide Popoola, Petr Šigut, Lorna Waddington | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, I.2.7; I.2.m | Recent advances in generative pre-trained transformer large language models
have emphasised the potential risks of unfair use of artificial intelligence
(AI) generated content in an academic environment and intensified efforts in
searching for solutions to detect such content. The paper examines the general
functionality of detection tools for artificial intelligence generated text and
evaluates them based on accuracy and error type analysis. Specifically, the
study seeks to answer research questions about whether existing detection tools
can reliably differentiate between human-written text and ChatGPT-generated
text, and whether machine translation and content obfuscation techniques affect
the detection of AI-generated text. The research covers 12 publicly available
tools and two commercial systems (Turnitin and PlagiarismCheck) that are widely
used in the academic setting. The researchers conclude that the available
detection tools are neither accurate nor reliable and have a main bias towards
classifying the output as human-written rather than detecting AI-generated
text. Furthermore, content obfuscation techniques significantly worsen the
performance of tools. The study makes several significant contributions. First,
it summarises up-to-date similar scientific and non-scientific efforts in the
field. Second, it presents the result of one of the most comprehensive tests
conducted so far, based on a rigorous research methodology, an original
document set, and a broad coverage of tools. Third, it discusses the
implications and drawbacks of using detection tools for AI-generated text in
academic settings. | [
0.0629596785,
0.0128038628,
-0.0407679863,
0.058860939,
-0.0766269267,
-0.001714747,
0.0689201429,
0.0270147324,
0.0340554714,
-0.0592131875,
0.0099272719,
0.0237556491,
-0.0109478999,
0.0366994888,
0.0299276318,
0.0439491495,
0.0263984185,
0.0237107035,
0.003387687,
0.0242804717,
0.0143714836,
0.0456050783,
0.034949366,
0.0562861189,
-0.0143222949,
-0.0409660116,
0.0089744879,
-0.0248310119,
0.0153336953,
0.0154119479,
0.0167615395,
0.050000459,
-0.0279457401,
0.1383385807,
0.0000018207,
-0.0557419695,
-0.0243745819,
0.026384199,
-0.047156617,
0.0173353553,
0.079031609,
0.009252781,
-0.0342616215,
0.0172272176,
-0.0416020304,
0.0108144358,
0.0107175112,
0.0304540545,
0.0297860876,
0.0849268436,
-0.0417441949,
-0.0024324735,
0.0642400831,
0.0302445367,
-0.0014601788,
0.0057603018,
0.0393736735,
-0.012970374,
-0.0013696513,
0.044121135,
0.0260702502,
0.0278326478,
0.0032459183,
-0.0678957403,
-0.028516531,
-0.0112773962,
-0.0433803052,
-0.0502919927,
-0.000405451,
-0.0157668013,
-0.0453459248,
-0.0808980539,
0.0315372348,
-0.0143728647,
0.02959783,
0.0446068719,
0.0230128989,
0.0496527925,
-0.0469098799,
-0.0283566453,
0.030161364,
0.0061016227,
-0.0131283067,
0.0431185067,
0.0018434132,
-0.0095179258,
0.0207748152,
-0.0649935305,
-0.0189886577,
-0.0089330925,
0.0241770316,
-0.0623178147,
0.0551844016,
0.020442795,
0.0295108184,
-0.0083363466,
-0.0544152968,
-0.1039010063,
0.0275947209,
-0.0558351763,
-0.0062803752,
0.0381650329,
-0.008973157,
0.0220065918,
-0.0557762347,
0.0960009843,
-0.0379152708,
0.0501131564,
0.0083439192,
0.0273996349,
-0.005077797,
-0.0228857584,
-0.0523685031,
0.0046691541,
-0.0059293965,
-0.0239346288,
-0.0340417773,
0.0273294058,
0.0108855236,
0.0469788723,
-0.029876817,
-0.0392972082,
-0.0384205617,
0.0147824716,
0.0423270948,
-0.0060044033,
0.0322213657,
0.0316411182,
-0.0244462434,
-0.0615090057,
0.0104738083,
0.067205593,
0.0145867011,
-0.0026319064,
-0.0031105019,
0.0567910857,
-0.0011218343,
-0.0298497751,
0.0070302896,
-0.0516754612,
-0.0261689015,
-0.0331195667,
0.0072282664,
-0.0531162545,
-0.0320209898,
0.0009410562,
-0.0168068167,
-0.0333963744,
-0.0026007164,
0.0324172303,
-0.0165285356,
0.0075547057,
-0.0227113646,
0.0206456073,
0.0643337891,
-0.0008800176,
-0.0275386479,
0.0018020066,
0.0242576953,
0.0747979134,
0.0541363098,
-0.0214270633,
0.0562600121,
0.0549592413,
0.0014335597,
-0.0054425369,
0.0354331434,
-0.0136403702,
-0.0074033779,
0.0032774664,
0.0086059785,
0.0608257651,
-0.022557117,
-0.0186784416,
0.0534469336,
0.0610371381,
0.0024120195,
0.0466760583,
0.0375116058,
0.0489086322,
0.0340542905,
0.0421598926,
0.0117771914,
-0.0360239036,
-0.0424595103,
-0.0267672893,
-0.0198167693,
0.0401763842,
0.0336906388,
-0.0341990665,
-0.0074958545,
-0.0249917451,
0.001147939,
-0.0450096428,
0.0409571156,
0.0306737497,
-0.0489343517,
-0.0660010055,
-0.0232881028,
-0.0569632277,
-0.0011971904,
-0.0986918136,
0.0497167408,
0.0595740192,
0.0754068643,
-0.0215239078,
0.0518287681,
-0.0419798084,
-0.0334464833,
0.0599375479,
0.005169211,
0.0122130066,
-0.0529512838,
-0.0221039411,
-0.0038730861,
-0.0252364259,
0.0081908312,
0.0061657331,
0.0402137376,
0.0305915773,
0.0293569136,
-0.0064416747,
-0.0746393651,
0.035644874,
-0.0302621219,
-0.0009995727,
-0.0212001968,
0.0049145594,
0.0037874691,
0.0186063703,
-0.048894275,
0.0244835764,
0.011844364,
-0.0228316095,
-0.0403519869,
0.0090595754,
0.0387782119,
0.0213937331,
0.0140715241,
-0.058865834,
-0.0180186145,
0.0094726291,
0.0081454152,
0.0253927186,
0.0136437556,
-0.0386465117,
0.0189230088,
-0.0608825311,
0.0242398269,
-0.063075684,
0.0305568799,
-0.0383079648,
0.0296443682,
0.008903943,
0.0089243557,
0.0282536894,
-0.0307229497,
0.0507389531,
0.014597307,
-0.0182807632,
0.0291722137,
-0.0231848974,
0.0017660102,
0.0236566514,
0.0099178357,
0.0104128392,
-0.0530827232,
-0.0464917459,
0.0020316844,
-0.0143229086,
0.0199581012,
0.0396910273,
-0.0305721331,
-0.0253418032,
0.0447907224,
0.0066876714,
-0.0426692702,
0.0266576614,
0.0006728118,
0.0264360942,
-0.0350288898,
0.0202073753,
-0.017397169,
0.0175700542,
-0.0271986667,
0.0372470133,
0.0862598941,
-0.0526287034,
-0.0578163341,
0.0870815441,
0.0211473145,
-0.0337329842,
-0.0144326044,
-0.0407773927,
-0.03329603,
-0.0198226236,
0.0271613654,
0.0885668695,
0.0331761762,
0.0166413356,
0.0110988123,
0.0395549498,
-0.0379343927,
-0.0286731683,
-0.0027978246,
-0.0037092834,
-0.0050794408,
-0.0593436137,
0.0470128618,
-0.0208592452,
0.0300878491,
-0.0163436029,
-0.0087366058,
0.0410573706,
-0.0582767054,
-0.0376897641,
0.0352205411,
-0.0742013976,
-0.0212693866,
0.0233924463,
0.0098767718,
-0.040507853,
0.0373485126,
-0.059140183,
0.0085062962,
-0.0502719469,
-0.0058816597,
-0.0185108837,
-0.0016946319,
0.0208221469,
0.0352517851,
0.0000033883,
-0.0026473226,
-0.0199739449,
0.0213782117,
0.0625228584,
-0.0208679829,
-0.0075477236,
0.0186633971,
-0.0082468716,
-0.0225859955,
0.0203509368,
-0.0476227328,
-0.0540171489,
0.0298739746,
-0.0092252884,
0.0823942944,
-0.029476786,
-0.0105826352,
0.0075531807,
0.0222619865,
0.0638952851,
-0.0200217366,
-0.0020434493,
-0.0236775558,
0.0532782227,
0.0004447425,
-0.0550376661,
0.0300940927,
-0.0144323939,
0.0022798902,
0.0465024523,
-0.0520599633,
0.0125784408,
-0.0106980111,
-0.0546842217,
-0.0024696053,
-0.0132547868,
-0.0099299932,
-0.0044077141,
0.0054786196,
-0.062306989,
0.0027335326,
0.0791522041,
0.0070322272,
-0.0403621197,
-0.047161229,
-0.0407056585,
-0.0330727175,
-0.0054500084,
0.013674139,
-0.073444739,
0.0334247835,
0.0146352788,
-0.003281797,
-0.057688836,
0.0085630314,
0.0070377951,
-0.0568686239,
0.0430888906,
-0.0076102433,
-0.0315233395,
-0.019328637,
-0.0214887746,
-0.0251080059,
0.0273807254,
-0.0233861543,
-0.0661008582,
0.0073944493,
0.0077118697,
0.0072852471,
-0.0477706119,
-0.020594174,
-0.0351965576,
-0.0363425761,
0.0253252499,
0.0833081603,
0.0431556441,
-0.0556083433,
-0.0274485275,
0.0189691093,
0.0124965729,
-0.0148127275,
-0.0074346815,
0.0476924032,
-0.0063883718,
0.0068714791,
-0.0033919851,
0.0327316038,
0.0197608303,
0.0060186116,
0.0487958677,
0.0671505779,
-0.0094125196,
-0.0546876229,
-0.0327813216,
-0.0124447905,
0.0260779038,
0.0546444058,
0.0132064465,
-0.0221304018,
-0.0647215396,
-0.0290463883,
0.0454217009,
-0.0409652777,
-0.0358846299,
-0.0109668421,
-0.009149109,
-0.0539894737,
-0.0772234574,
-0.0352465212,
-0.0235614423,
-0.0132125923,
0.0316718109,
-0.0018264333,
0.0192752276,
-0.0055203182,
-0.0330409221,
-0.0614348315,
-0.0115439203,
0.0405104347,
-0.0283046477,
0.0004755605,
-0.020753447,
-0.0201811306,
0.0160954278,
-0.0001011377,
-0.0365118906,
-0.0475448146,
0.0426202863,
0.0064027091,
0.0244046114,
-0.0001336761,
-0.0228921268,
-0.0135382963,
0.0741576031,
0.0357049555,
-0.0346768722,
0.0289259963,
0.0347162783,
-0.0404618792,
-0.0239460263,
-0.0070593823,
-0.0155568542,
0.0219852589,
-0.0057203053,
-0.0587920472,
-0.0396604873,
-0.0455502644,
0.0207544155,
0.0434262641,
-0.006803269,
-0.0309464689,
0.0330836885,
-0.0380660295,
-0.029746376,
-0.0433605537,
-0.0095877592,
-0.0185433421,
-0.0136096599,
0.0599287562,
0.0317141674,
0.0168561824,
0.0749627575,
-0.0492507257,
0.0049530077,
0.0127593186,
0.0343192406,
-0.0000484642,
0.0987527221,
0.0067807497,
0.0117363194,
-0.0083478615,
0.0371011309,
-0.0126281744,
0.0312416609,
0.0042464794,
0.0620320998,
0.010916017,
-0.0075676045,
0.0343295448,
0.0491787381,
-0.0661010444,
0.0068718921,
-0.0287640877,
0.0186650995,
0.0145597048,
0.0017488031,
0.0488451272,
-0.039466437,
-0.0150031429,
-0.0140083116,
0.0438500382,
0.0240313858,
-0.0315568894,
-0.0569247864,
-0.0255519692,
-0.0370786004,
-0.0053622164,
0.0616944656,
0.0116668688,
0.0211932212,
0.0036263033,
-0.0424869657,
-0.0071361098,
-0.0410185643,
0.0048128902,
-0.0285159871,
0.0156147731,
-0.010691694,
-0.0538461208,
-0.04980129,
0.0011884709,
0.0235106423,
0.0304807536,
-0.0259298775,
-0.043344304,
0.071348846,
0.0054714601,
0.0044492199,
-0.0525296181,
0.0477585532,
-0.0300836097,
-0.0339149907,
-0.0440525822,
-4.765549974e-33,
0.0053749019,
-0.1059086174,
-0.0138759986,
0.0523113571,
0.000586534,
0.02720345,
-0.0181933474,
-0.0368843265,
-0.0183179025,
0.0295411758,
-0.0302298721,
0.0154349403,
-0.0062546926,
-0.0284990259,
-0.005520639,
0.0115508353,
0.044256594,
-0.0160195641,
-0.0321641453,
0.0182300322,
0.017396342,
-0.0310282987,
0.012072647,
-0.0767925084,
0.0381092131,
-0.0655765086,
-0.0300105941,
-0.0277539063,
-0.0545759499,
0.0340531729,
-0.0118499221,
0.0146724125,
0.0276609063,
0.0086033894,
-0.0110529158,
0.055373989,
-0.0072393012,
-0.0039245021,
0.0005376777,
0.0289813336,
0.0012860451,
-0.070171997,
0.054645665,
-0.0432167761,
-0.0358990654,
0.0279919207,
0.0651145205,
-0.016801266,
-0.0041724229,
-0.0551656373,
-0.0783586055,
0.0155397728,
-0.0158128086,
0.0267345756,
0.0211695004,
0.0669696033,
0.0218236726,
0.0092289746,
-0.0648888648,
0.0109524196,
0.0036307324,
-0.0258931741,
0.022243293,
-0.0200900286,
-0.0131880799,
0.0156278536,
0.0295714065,
0.0225617383,
-0.0069557545,
-0.0264882352,
0.0224586781,
-0.0055738841,
0.0866153911,
0.0833644941,
0.0181402098,
-0.0581105165,
-0.0028911957,
0.0285794083,
0.0100331884,
0.0018567397,
0.0227168705,
-0.032054387,
-0.0774467662,
-0.022123633,
0.0186227523,
-0.064246878,
-0.0219924059,
-0.0232327096,
0.0292070955,
-0.0011799373,
-0.007165825,
-0.0111283772,
0.016646171,
-0.0650300011,
0.0523980595,
0.0083440142,
-0.0527798869,
0.0053720241,
-0.0074133296,
0.0516980179,
-0.0391706116,
-0.0073863785,
0.0386606678,
0.0092626149,
0.040538922,
-0.0103749093,
0.043758139,
0.020968765,
-0.0387871973,
0.01377609,
0.0016898668,
0.0270790812,
0.0310547575,
-0.0159024484,
0.0023724111,
-0.0044353702,
0.0233366042,
-0.0272341706,
0.0509247966,
0.0274626426,
-0.0698191449,
-0.0041723656,
0.0035917906,
-0.0122508425,
-0.0473614186,
-0.0073258071,
-0.0220660511,
0.0589450561,
0.0339767374,
-0.0746919513,
0.0150647955,
-0.0354294032,
2.497e-7,
0.0541910082,
0.0487104356,
0.0369444452,
-0.0097700329,
0.0288299508,
0.0292112399,
0.0237196684,
0.0157169886,
0.0231211409,
0.0567362793,
-0.0061602728,
-0.0180034153,
0.0483410209,
0.0198795013,
-0.0449286029,
-0.006153835,
-0.0462061539,
-0.003146871,
-0.0839558169,
0.0267901346,
0.0793581381,
0.0223011561,
0.0238139629,
-0.0134489145,
-0.0312682167,
-0.0631685555,
0.0067331987,
0.0142889759,
0.0077203335,
0.0296433698,
0.0490850322,
0.0302419644,
0.0227970369,
0.0454182327,
-0.00928267,
-0.0015733328,
0.023085691,
0.0383374169,
0.0276201367,
0.0515884385,
-0.0029308521,
-0.0624587648,
0.0008671342,
-0.0669829398,
0.049260024,
0.0009254671,
0.0135734035,
-0.0386945643,
-0.0286198203,
-0.0692676529,
0.0220664497,
-0.026029326,
-0.0074616745,
0.0226597898,
-0.005846919,
0.0186167657,
0.0204784852,
-0.0372991674,
0.0009898685,
-0.0617241897,
-0.0303513519,
-0.019384658,
-0.0278855767,
-0.0034425911,
0.0426374376,
0.0000488893,
0.0472728796,
2.577468122e-34,
0.0312613621,
-0.0256570075,
0.0050101592,
0.0088632703,
0.0367216542,
0.0115519101,
0.021235127,
0.0229324065,
-0.0236732587,
-0.018994553,
0.0096803028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12317v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12317v3 | Iterated Piecewise Affine (IPA) Approximation for Language Modeling | 2023-06-21T14:58:31 | 2023-11-01T18:04:13 | Davood Shamsi, Wen-yu Hua, Brian Williams | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we demonstrate the application of a first-order Taylor
expansion to approximate a generic function $F: R^{n \times m} \to R^{n \times
m}$ and utilize it in language modeling. To enhance the basic Taylor expansion,
we introduce iteration and piecewise modeling, leading us to name the algorithm
the Iterative Piecewise Affine (IPA) approximation. The final algorithm
exhibits interesting resemblances to the Transformers decoder architecture. By
comparing parameter arrangements in IPA and Transformers, we observe a
strikingly similar performance, with IPA outperforming Transformers by 1.5\% in
the next token prediction task with cross-entropy loss for smaller sequence
lengths. | [
-0.0184836537,
0.0822225735,
-0.0173906982,
0.0281660277,
-0.0341855437,
0.0351580493,
0.0497966707,
0.0133071942,
-0.0833712444,
-0.0388924852,
0.0001718196,
-0.0803680867,
0.0329187512,
0.0528031364,
0.0291989036,
-0.0391222835,
-0.0026124874,
-0.0703988373,
-0.0000645904,
-0.0212988965,
0.0197191387,
0.0204544943,
-0.0365013555,
0.0661047995,
-0.0449255258,
-0.0214932896,
0.0152198998,
-0.0356684029,
-0.0106565021,
0.009064584,
0.0321554206,
0.0318090469,
0.0266234465,
0.0326156542,
0.00000202,
0.022844281,
-0.0266492609,
0.0005945552,
0.0087358793,
-0.0191931985,
0.0490056723,
-0.0203544628,
-0.009291972,
0.0056720367,
-0.0094852019,
-0.0930503905,
0.0618130565,
0.0089237997,
0.0078191012,
0.0833740011,
-0.0068466556,
-0.1025469676,
0.0142629277,
-0.0293010194,
-0.0030304326,
-0.04233253,
0.0096649518,
-0.0401453823,
-0.0139130373,
-0.0234500542,
-0.0655377805,
0.0565106347,
0.0152922738,
0.0435303785,
-0.0025388261,
0.0551962666,
-0.004504486,
-0.0020895537,
0.0091286432,
0.0380406603,
-0.0216518026,
-0.032731127,
-0.0054821367,
0.032505393,
-0.0697466508,
-0.0065496722,
-0.0385838822,
0.0188323092,
0.002508047,
0.0246812534,
0.0006596136,
0.0076045427,
0.0135026183,
0.0076591317,
-0.0626292527,
0.0811072588,
-0.0049833674,
-0.037713822,
0.0005735346,
-0.0051863333,
0.0129524702,
0.0112298205,
0.0027124258,
0.0097094867,
-0.0340535454,
0.0321239345,
-0.059206523,
-0.0250970665,
-0.0439915545,
-0.0531203933,
0.0207310654,
0.038213931,
-0.0085173268,
0.005424256,
-0.0428252034,
0.0331372432,
-0.0149111198,
0.049243778,
-0.0620026588,
-0.0101246079,
-0.0253488366,
0.0132830897,
-0.0421702228,
0.0481378548,
-0.0085445018,
0.0024311987,
-0.0156417042,
0.0007630643,
-0.0009156747,
-0.0268898942,
0.0273533501,
-0.0334190875,
-0.0059890249,
-0.0629647598,
0.0096798483,
0.0583215691,
-0.0282770805,
0.0049259979,
-0.029899504,
-0.0115309749,
-0.0266956724,
0.0197863989,
0.000301918,
-0.0195961762,
0.0094304765,
0.0518416166,
-0.0145680262,
-0.0691916943,
0.0234505367,
-0.0430387594,
0.010798797,
-0.0418917835,
0.0141419927,
-0.0733632371,
0.0528948419,
0.0238289647,
-0.0049604182,
-0.0389699005,
-0.0048016682,
0.0234116074,
-0.014463068,
0.0523220375,
-0.0105702933,
-0.0002656113,
0.0089681922,
-0.0182107948,
0.040953923,
0.0499055088,
0.0218172036,
0.0224913619,
-0.0338371769,
-0.0118414089,
-0.0482587181,
0.060315866,
0.0359447598,
-0.0172451381,
-0.0296080858,
-0.0246150158,
0.0311830491,
0.0380447842,
0.0367025137,
0.0432718918,
-0.0506577156,
-0.0249234606,
0.0222656373,
0.0425824001,
0.054147087,
0.0300735813,
0.0333712697,
0.001300229,
-0.0186444316,
0.0050170971,
-0.003417589,
0.0070590163,
0.006451461,
0.005879459,
0.0451798141,
0.028237056,
-0.0492800064,
0.0002591873,
0.0293907169,
-0.0409852639,
0.0012845829,
-0.0411134958,
0.0628141388,
0.005849109,
-0.0578456037,
0.0418608747,
0.0027060853,
-0.0206030402,
0.0379761942,
-0.0049493196,
-0.0059245261,
0.0465966836,
0.0717889145,
-0.0211405344,
-0.0070362431,
0.0037693875,
0.0288909487,
-0.0024085043,
-0.0421832576,
0.0269512124,
-0.0140657974,
-0.043289654,
-0.0293795783,
0.0955595151,
-0.0173639189,
0.0325600058,
-0.0216772463,
0.0145233758,
0.0058704065,
-0.0502932295,
0.0481769554,
0.0010728529,
-0.0197856352,
-0.0284519233,
0.0365476459,
0.0227235071,
0.0280107521,
0.0004019243,
-0.0132763209,
0.0129483426,
0.0402069986,
-0.0432150625,
0.0005683714,
0.0308601037,
-0.0722713917,
-0.067108348,
0.0327556655,
-0.0062820995,
0.0386753753,
0.0127905803,
-0.0342899635,
-0.0256518163,
0.0746241212,
-0.0388879366,
0.0566600747,
-0.0488884225,
0.0390351713,
0.0258244351,
0.0329051316,
-0.0086098453,
-0.0005808304,
-0.0367426462,
0.033471711,
-0.061576128,
-0.0267003011,
-0.0508018471,
0.0220329296,
-0.040734835,
-0.0032347841,
-0.0436167307,
0.0143726915,
-0.031193329,
-0.0183993503,
0.0603754483,
0.0053762635,
-0.0426616408,
-0.063811183,
-0.0318924524,
0.0363240503,
-0.0291909371,
0.0151603855,
0.0075426036,
-0.0135862371,
-0.0129379276,
0.0374957137,
-0.0351293832,
0.0023415731,
-0.0079749264,
-0.0015378561,
-0.0573996343,
0.0062346868,
-0.0621476211,
0.0086051142,
0.1132690981,
-0.0786062628,
-0.0358664058,
-0.0587429479,
-0.0018632674,
-0.0017020893,
0.0327031463,
-0.016441755,
-0.0494887047,
-0.0217702836,
-0.0449809469,
0.0303798728,
-0.0182184987,
0.0218537953,
-0.0000635346,
-0.0130094402,
0.0123819085,
-0.0195364114,
-0.012552972,
-0.0394785218,
0.0159789808,
-0.027592238,
-0.02250834,
0.0454713888,
0.0860025436,
-0.0012373192,
0.0288671404,
-0.0670241639,
-0.0256915782,
0.0179667808,
-0.0346869864,
-0.0317400284,
-0.0156917032,
-0.0341870971,
-0.0025416161,
-0.0040458501,
-0.0390818231,
0.052887693,
-0.0619270913,
-0.0128234858,
0.0066162413,
0.0124124149,
-0.0436007977,
0.0431355797,
0.0630087554,
0.0126599651,
0.0066100657,
-0.0408166498,
-0.0121830525,
0.0483215265,
-0.0451088399,
-0.0486268103,
0.0378705971,
-0.0097052976,
0.0202134382,
-0.0011902427,
0.0082543967,
0.0119375903,
-0.054516837,
0.0000188899,
0.0079098297,
0.0329170935,
-0.0126609467,
-0.0405209027,
0.0274219979,
-0.0145748137,
0.0594155043,
-0.0105782067,
0.0205848683,
-0.015179202,
0.0430062748,
0.0483893864,
0.0160810854,
-0.0346455686,
-0.0353123955,
0.0253641941,
0.0190504361,
0.0776119009,
0.0503496751,
-0.0239089373,
-0.0229634047,
0.0572766736,
-0.0257855989,
-0.0186253395,
0.0290936176,
0.0210167635,
-0.014630992,
-0.0537672453,
0.0965814367,
0.0074667963,
-0.1036682352,
-0.0227045119,
0.0003876226,
0.0685453862,
-0.017995283,
0.006547987,
-0.0748239383,
-0.0405333899,
0.0024840848,
0.0008095321,
0.0056278082,
-0.0150449621,
0.0481832847,
-0.1077564061,
0.0035550869,
0.0105324136,
-0.0753049031,
-0.0278011244,
-0.0171950925,
-0.0199773163,
0.002874285,
0.0031033726,
0.0646183118,
-0.0301509574,
0.0003174734,
0.090124093,
-0.0565811805,
-0.0601456538,
-0.0335851014,
-0.0375075005,
0.0586077683,
0.0592133701,
-0.0283310153,
0.0108922422,
-0.0441336893,
0.0376160629,
-0.0112847518,
0.0018197562,
-0.0278487541,
0.045444075,
-0.0354369767,
-0.0067060343,
0.0432481095,
0.0027842384,
-0.0571033582,
0.0312910751,
-0.0180098601,
0.1000495106,
-0.0080251899,
0.0192135274,
-0.014265391,
-0.0042958641,
-0.0128705008,
0.0532536097,
0.0249108169,
-0.0264083184,
-0.0427735038,
-0.0221356843,
0.069156684,
-0.0398174301,
-0.0065959785,
-0.0140024135,
0.0023938392,
-0.0243432373,
-0.0059242449,
0.030454848,
0.0437313356,
0.0419076234,
-0.0357899182,
-0.0377907269,
0.0011510116,
-0.00003937,
-0.0509882458,
-0.0754094198,
0.0029297783,
0.0525938049,
-0.0816763863,
0.0152072506,
0.0212503411,
-0.029068565,
-0.0100663817,
-0.007292869,
-0.1022179276,
-0.0005167557,
0.0157121234,
0.0445456393,
0.0085290065,
0.0095156962,
0.0046257465,
-0.0637277737,
0.079713814,
0.0372693725,
-0.0280573294,
0.0253074151,
0.0170808621,
-0.0401616581,
0.0059198616,
0.0291458126,
-0.0147099681,
0.004550443,
-0.0190334786,
0.0364846587,
-0.0033222556,
-0.0071229627,
0.0070978287,
-0.0014432246,
0.0504145809,
0.001275902,
0.0163697563,
0.0181249846,
0.0571773537,
0.0027783879,
0.0594837293,
-0.0236428399,
-0.0002334605,
0.0219903439,
-0.0106382696,
-0.0105466126,
-0.0138117513,
-0.0102297319,
-0.0038804826,
0.0146840159,
0.0120203672,
-0.0119424611,
-0.0002965569,
0.0089874472,
-0.0153745553,
0.0070450734,
-0.0120422235,
0.0014363675,
0.0241140816,
-0.0494548827,
0.0221116226,
-0.0027029121,
0.028136136,
-0.0271707568,
-0.0037498141,
-0.0106203733,
-0.0056772074,
-0.0593046732,
-0.0022888654,
-0.0214744471,
-0.0050502359,
0.0256877765,
0.0044466779,
0.0237578806,
-0.0264440067,
0.0147991013,
-0.0292775556,
-0.0080240481,
0.0633537993,
0.0054012174,
-0.0054461188,
-0.063029252,
0.0386314057,
0.0218716264,
-0.0077495635,
-0.0232201908,
0.0173828192,
-0.0203618929,
-0.0367874466,
-0.0604302585,
0.001355882,
-0.0262615457,
-0.0284107067,
-0.0428350568,
-0.0380324498,
0.0010013985,
-0.0054381355,
0.0501324721,
-0.0215690117,
0.0373369716,
0.0450335033,
-0.0060753925,
0.0309154429,
-0.0289059151,
-0.0069568157,
0.0091927405,
-0.0118997209,
-0.0072298157,
-6.314328067e-33,
-0.0415245071,
0.0164642707,
-0.0003643032,
0.0145800347,
-0.023259623,
0.0107308244,
0.0088851489,
0.0111869993,
0.0216581337,
-0.0166967884,
0.0275027696,
-0.0421481319,
0.0128638428,
0.0277779102,
-0.0194925666,
-0.0092917169,
0.0507207103,
-0.0444895923,
0.0122242924,
0.0030190251,
0.0415382646,
0.0575492792,
0.0410303362,
0.0171954185,
-0.0390865132,
0.0027687079,
-0.0091642598,
0.0342192091,
0.0101582231,
0.0221023187,
-0.0235686917,
0.0355895311,
0.0384031236,
-0.0622447245,
-0.0278193243,
0.0050669354,
-0.0642330572,
0.0249204934,
0.0151095418,
0.0492100157,
-0.0007600055,
-0.0037443934,
0.0667456239,
0.013820976,
-0.0571545623,
-0.0437682755,
0.029401239,
-0.0061384905,
-0.050033547,
-0.0257613454,
-0.0421211645,
0.0312905833,
0.0209917054,
-0.0330080651,
0.0836967602,
0.0736385137,
-0.0103105586,
-0.0178738032,
-0.0327842087,
0.0124693504,
0.0026194425,
0.1045098826,
0.0395412333,
-0.0130776335,
-0.0046999273,
0.0459198765,
0.0927029029,
-0.0385221988,
-0.0640072003,
-0.0077713509,
0.0709718913,
-0.0274603739,
0.0012018154,
0.0114656063,
0.0529006086,
-0.0345322788,
-0.008304487,
0.0162034016,
-0.0104872007,
0.0749794841,
0.0433971584,
0.0104611069,
0.001229479,
-0.0065486757,
-0.0178252067,
-0.0323854387,
-0.019936379,
-0.0159744155,
-0.023463659,
-0.0042850175,
-0.0051454059,
0.0389828533,
0.0577092618,
0.009865067,
0.0352515914,
0.0002288139,
-0.0154764801,
0.0412998274,
0.0020268043,
0.029091794,
-0.0446344167,
-0.0675729364,
-0.0179717746,
0.005351047,
-0.0050641955,
-0.0423786789,
0.0302544609,
0.0427001491,
-0.0775012895,
-0.0358432196,
-0.0320127532,
0.010809713,
0.0165069178,
0.0352831483,
0.0570268184,
0.0084525589,
0.003757589,
0.045100037,
-0.0266996678,
-0.0295054018,
-0.0348154828,
0.0144943548,
-0.0071837893,
0.0331636965,
-0.0263170917,
-0.0025704817,
-0.0280666873,
0.0120629603,
0.0127182435,
-0.0598604195,
-0.0229775477,
0.0334493145,
2.723e-7,
0.0147213498,
0.037967857,
0.0345579311,
-0.0115281595,
0.0222401917,
0.0037512956,
0.0007065476,
0.0500015393,
-0.0029888425,
0.0197239239,
0.0382643417,
-0.0173758119,
0.0825360194,
0.0043435092,
-0.0838246122,
0.0093973232,
-0.0884903222,
0.065475069,
-0.0371535979,
0.0014685474,
0.0424067117,
0.0802052766,
0.0001895631,
-0.0303253625,
0.0153326811,
0.0552489981,
0.0712081194,
-0.0118116699,
-0.0124811586,
-0.0276410319,
-0.0609249994,
-0.0264137909,
0.0228699557,
-0.02523808,
0.0180715565,
0.0139016602,
0.0210516732,
0.036905285,
0.0311420299,
-0.0226401892,
0.07729581,
0.0171501506,
-0.0048785377,
-0.0288487133,
0.0491301976,
-0.0200391598,
0.0029445263,
-0.0088270539,
-0.0444492996,
0.0472464375,
-0.0096950568,
-0.0070591192,
0.0112135215,
0.0480903536,
0.0396842994,
-0.0171324462,
0.0063584573,
-0.0211863462,
-0.0147117293,
0.0272936951,
-0.0505305976,
0.029218547,
-0.0539621972,
-0.0118592978,
0.0114169605,
-0.0257170331,
-0.0469394661,
2.051018844e-34,
0.0328280255,
-0.0093996925,
0.0010402432,
0.0733280256,
-0.0284171775,
-0.0451548509,
0.0691123381,
0.063710399,
-0.0233402122,
-0.0723269507,
-0.0287991669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12310v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12310v1 | Medical ministrations through web scraping | 2023-06-21T14:43:25 | 2023-06-21T14:43:25 | Niketha Sabesan, Nivethitha, J. N Shreyah, Pranauv A J, Shyam R | cs.CL | cs.CL | Web scraping is a technique that allows us to extract data from websites
automatically. in the field of medicine, web scraping can be used to collect
information about medical procedures, treatments, and healthcare providers.
this information can be used to improve patient care, monitor the quality of
healthcare services, and identify areas for improvement. one area where web
scraping can be particularly useful is in medical ministrations. medical
ministrations are the actions taken to provide medical care to patients, and
web scraping can help healthcare providers identify the most effective
ministrations for their patients. for example, healthcare providers can use web
scraping to collect data about the symptoms and medical histories of their
patients, and then use this information to determine the most appropriate
ministrations. they can also use web scraping to gather information about the
latest medical research and clinical trials, which can help them stay
up-to-date with the latest treatments and procedures. | [
0.0439589545,
0.0084146857,
-0.0280038174,
-0.0338914059,
-0.0349679366,
0.0241631698,
0.0025693635,
0.0736420229,
-0.0004854834,
0.000822591,
0.0317768119,
-0.0645356625,
0.0334912539,
-0.0005586416,
0.007932405,
-0.0590761006,
-0.0229305029,
0.0559198409,
-0.0078525664,
-0.0078281267,
-0.0088607948,
-0.0432687216,
-0.011530037,
0.0440410376,
0.0542677417,
-0.0060612261,
0.0314616561,
0.0140674999,
-0.0208139494,
-0.0801193565,
0.0206163079,
-0.0538363606,
-0.0186034255,
-0.0432580709,
0.000002125,
-0.0220527295,
-0.0192313232,
0.0237252433,
-0.0349982455,
-0.0396065824,
0.047385104,
-0.0792662054,
0.0138520645,
-0.0060611106,
-0.0020145946,
-0.0416022204,
0.0078134136,
0.0153044108,
0.0515009239,
0.0172986817,
-0.0168680493,
0.0805492625,
-0.0799460486,
0.0057790633,
0.0437410995,
-0.0403805599,
0.053478606,
-0.0487457514,
0.0612964109,
-0.0232722238,
0.0045593525,
0.0136656146,
-0.0584858507,
0.0367224701,
-0.0253406763,
0.0075424681,
-0.0439494029,
-0.0912155062,
0.021563869,
0.004198831,
0.0525739565,
-0.014317723,
0.0290595908,
0.0142768519,
-0.0093615353,
0.0498107001,
-0.0424254201,
-0.0068947333,
-0.0384400189,
0.0112779383,
-0.0327455848,
0.0377475172,
0.015154398,
-0.0116729047,
-0.0089335339,
-0.0504528657,
-0.0178831406,
-0.0327315629,
0.0073117451,
-0.0099325348,
0.1025991365,
-0.0248442143,
0.0392166264,
0.0459674783,
0.0118912701,
-0.029743718,
0.0109308194,
-0.0612945892,
0.0919661596,
0.047315564,
0.0275652539,
0.0156720895,
0.0337772109,
0.0263306536,
0.030537568,
-0.0401166715,
-0.0383154787,
-0.0249888301,
0.0119033558,
0.0947426632,
0.0495421775,
-0.0034514749,
0.0374054573,
0.0416817889,
-0.0054753958,
0.0268579572,
0.001947583,
0.0067070629,
-0.0542693399,
0.0432344638,
-0.0468124375,
0.0138374651,
-0.0288177729,
0.0283809919,
-0.0175731219,
-0.0138521437,
0.0227169041,
0.004925828,
0.0199545678,
-0.001496995,
0.0144189605,
-0.0079796659,
0.0703623816,
0.0009790089,
0.0149022136,
0.0838238969,
0.0313260518,
0.018957762,
-0.0397729687,
-0.0320156701,
0.0014703879,
0.0214249548,
0.0073676347,
-0.0052922936,
0.0478417203,
0.0107682869,
-0.0027622832,
-0.0121343872,
-0.0069545172,
0.0087664146,
-0.1169553697,
0.016644856,
-0.0552271418,
-0.0166664775,
-0.0404084027,
0.017074395,
0.0042656134,
-0.032783594,
-0.0368648134,
0.0355503596,
-0.0037066287,
0.0033922291,
-0.0417719074,
-0.0165044609,
0.0501901284,
0.010603236,
0.0377170183,
0.0089518772,
0.0458335094,
0.0157894976,
-0.072249189,
0.0447886772,
-0.0322040245,
0.0671597496,
0.0294815451,
0.091308333,
0.0560262613,
0.0305415336,
-0.076116778,
-0.0289531741,
0.0202458873,
0.0361421555,
-0.0070273918,
-0.0047946735,
-0.0032912423,
-0.0094114104,
-0.0561692193,
0.0111081004,
0.0051170038,
-0.0147355003,
-0.0482898913,
-0.0108386055,
-0.0237578917,
0.0265363883,
0.0239846278,
-0.002957029,
0.030455593,
-0.0070181354,
0.0370758399,
-0.0039345049,
0.032646399,
-0.0530289896,
-0.0871970877,
0.063078627,
0.0227626096,
-0.0414847992,
-0.0315127224,
-0.0441595577,
-0.0197233204,
-0.0264124684,
-0.0153775727,
-0.0167750996,
-0.0830127299,
0.0395148844,
-0.0142412409,
0.0582115836,
-0.0037741521,
-0.0360007174,
-0.0089218291,
0.0390293971,
-0.0371788815,
-0.0088007255,
0.0000595192,
0.0187512133,
-0.0408850089,
0.0293589439,
0.0140063865,
0.0564383306,
-0.0154264523,
0.0117127746,
0.0038766684,
0.0001873716,
0.0442131236,
0.0048658075,
0.0091436421,
-0.0000019599,
0.0628484786,
0.0563461669,
0.0379688591,
-0.0524997227,
0.0730793998,
0.0134226745,
0.0069982004,
-0.0154250655,
0.000297253,
-0.0440427065,
-0.0030499769,
0.0150363138,
-0.0257548597,
0.0288728606,
-0.0075892182,
-0.033629261,
-0.0196466763,
0.007560906,
-0.0213638209,
0.0835509747,
-0.0639645755,
-0.0472748764,
-0.0186464433,
0.0210931916,
-0.0073213591,
-0.0370788649,
0.0221747402,
0.0418721549,
-0.0005235417,
-0.0103410417,
-0.0035956365,
-0.0023307733,
-0.0480540916,
0.013558303,
-0.0117190154,
0.0337446518,
0.0363335609,
0.0037931961,
-0.031354256,
0.0120287901,
-0.0477053113,
-0.0240111295,
-0.0240952466,
0.0483522974,
0.0598611869,
0.0149790309,
-0.0387667045,
0.0042768409,
-0.0179887209,
-0.003228165,
0.032217551,
-0.0293713789,
0.0210434776,
0.0045167888,
0.0189846456,
-0.0213318244,
-0.008748712,
-0.0631583482,
-0.0304314923,
-0.0409645401,
-0.0685915425,
0.0921444222,
0.0290683825,
0.0320739001,
0.0312957838,
0.0478168242,
-0.0001148863,
0.003616387,
-0.0418749973,
0.0289435461,
0.0142414179,
-0.0692919791,
0.0065314611,
-0.0045513688,
0.0592524819,
-0.0041871313,
-0.0148476595,
0.0531465337,
0.0028944754,
0.0293166973,
-0.0597333312,
0.0448439084,
-0.0525263622,
0.0454369932,
0.0232048891,
0.0078027979,
0.028976487,
0.0354905725,
0.0498851165,
0.0008057262,
-0.0082952324,
0.0089259474,
-0.0487846062,
-0.0040203026,
0.0227602851,
-0.0333210118,
0.0131495427,
0.0556762777,
0.0321095102,
0.0443548858,
-0.0479282588,
0.0071416455,
0.0615845993,
0.0478883013,
-0.0432559513,
-0.062252406,
-0.0050803269,
-0.0497834049,
0.0566641763,
-0.0459383838,
0.0223464034,
0.0394665673,
-0.0468874127,
-0.0312643126,
0.0447957516,
0.0510733835,
0.0126494979,
-0.0022476187,
0.0081534833,
-0.0192419775,
-0.0385341272,
-0.0464790463,
-0.0252332482,
0.0267975852,
0.0071217082,
0.057333447,
0.0304049738,
-0.0105212359,
-0.0000176898,
0.0462964028,
-0.0003218889,
-0.0302490573,
-0.0004798391,
0.0090311598,
-0.0617642477,
-0.017084254,
0.018677026,
0.0000277028,
0.001595362,
-0.0124494769,
0.0151411342,
-0.0310633704,
-0.0766322985,
-0.003416328,
-0.0061838431,
-0.0290789492,
0.0240170117,
0.0075895768,
0.0659262538,
-0.0201376863,
-0.0317530856,
0.0220505279,
0.0707400888,
-0.0042161276,
-0.0122769093,
-0.0356622972,
0.0014310395,
-0.0383723676,
0.0546465032,
0.0139646642,
-0.0744579881,
0.0266601872,
-0.0556662865,
0.007875964,
0.0253566597,
-0.1082379743,
-0.0781814307,
-0.0113649638,
0.0212821197,
-0.0220590606,
0.014563987,
0.0320954435,
-0.0382281952,
-0.0213540103,
0.0056331106,
-0.0345903337,
-0.0070491252,
-0.0326301269,
0.0957055166,
-0.0041407635,
0.0035943263,
0.0094115064,
0.0197966807,
-0.0535701141,
0.0306013189,
-0.0492875054,
0.0189710818,
-0.0521821827,
-0.0207235832,
-0.0242889635,
-0.0144317001,
0.0300941784,
0.0137855038,
0.0324123353,
0.022310283,
-0.0022108045,
0.0051824949,
0.0243875757,
-0.0138382558,
0.0136872791,
0.0306563787,
-0.0163804442,
-0.0057488168,
-0.0247656871,
0.0113625461,
-0.0124826673,
0.0104019148,
0.0442594886,
0.0160836484,
0.0135131283,
0.0467724279,
-0.0510147884,
0.0072787809,
0.0540001877,
-0.0198267903,
0.0402994789,
-0.0399207622,
0.0790247396,
-0.0131993797,
-0.0100661898,
-0.0698188171,
0.0012857969,
0.0048344922,
-0.0335647762,
0.0457368642,
0.030545719,
-0.0300374981,
0.0121939704,
0.0393314175,
-0.0286027007,
0.032180354,
-0.0298760049,
-0.0404082388,
0.0069733285,
-0.0488859974,
0.0015628259,
-0.0222870149,
-0.0291976631,
0.0004035697,
-0.0082547208,
-0.0494496003,
0.0081177577,
0.0618186221,
0.0197897498,
0.0604441166,
-0.0130280359,
-0.0288789812,
-0.0686992556,
0.0321827605,
0.0285943411,
0.0244606659,
-0.0195520651,
-0.01690186,
-0.0428287908,
-0.0099179009,
0.0032497188,
0.0351491943,
0.0237272885,
-0.0155899841,
-0.0753972009,
-0.0506046601,
0.0538731441,
-0.0093628457,
-0.0351691172,
0.0598981306,
0.011820551,
0.0051996373,
-0.0428371243,
-0.0072128307,
0.0470337011,
-0.0278823152,
-0.0274132062,
0.0182981975,
0.032801453,
0.0080628768,
0.0372999646,
-0.0416254103,
-0.004644996,
0.0343081057,
-0.0531315021,
-0.0076231635,
0.0150104593,
0.0157259982,
0.0192986839,
-0.0130453268,
-0.0245308336,
0.0112533867,
0.0002126764,
0.0736972541,
0.0079349298,
-0.0050281314,
-0.0063003311,
-0.0188653916,
0.0863682553,
-0.0373657942,
0.0015312325,
-0.0332732536,
-0.0172392409,
-0.0181215182,
0.0052421759,
0.0080367019,
0.069097653,
-0.0206182506,
-0.086330764,
0.0137754576,
-0.0380270742,
-0.0178125221,
-0.0090127653,
-0.0003471575,
-0.0216944814,
-0.0097965552,
0.012062788,
0.017526269,
0.0269761328,
-0.0215047728,
0.0720558614,
-0.0021301694,
0.0230945051,
0.0251656473,
-6.114456925e-33,
0.0311489422,
-0.060397476,
-0.0172336511,
0.0303183701,
0.0058724778,
0.0343314074,
-0.0143648582,
-0.037093889,
-0.0076486096,
-0.0118801538,
0.0032428314,
-0.0360705815,
0.0066284044,
0.0262806565,
-0.0260457825,
-0.0396648534,
0.011913755,
0.0164234005,
-0.0253832471,
-0.0087258695,
-0.045117382,
0.0134638948,
-0.0281862486,
0.007478816,
-0.0094498154,
-0.019600179,
0.0122543611,
-0.0206652433,
0.0613979734,
0.0331146754,
0.0154842557,
-0.0064458903,
0.0275021233,
0.0180876832,
-0.0109680146,
0.0618830472,
-0.0987288952,
0.0032481276,
0.0169200711,
0.0214328598,
-0.0343406424,
-0.0163765177,
0.0592149906,
-0.0234316383,
-0.035540536,
-0.0336627886,
-0.0024969287,
-0.045540452,
-0.0275651067,
-0.027112782,
0.0556279086,
0.004248892,
0.0207385737,
0.0490265861,
0.0539059937,
0.0576617382,
-0.0066772187,
0.054114487,
0.0310087781,
-0.0140937297,
0.0315225907,
0.020284066,
-0.004820446,
-0.0209177323,
-0.0117201731,
0.0153420474,
-0.0755576268,
-0.0288751554,
0.0173215307,
-0.0166883431,
-0.0232040621,
-0.0606746003,
-0.0555060618,
-0.0136634829,
-0.0242309552,
-0.0402593948,
-0.0198298115,
0.0275255609,
-0.0493946075,
0.0523876958,
0.0603809766,
-0.0495168865,
-0.0159570575,
0.003453037,
0.0258057062,
-0.0402990542,
0.0125263501,
-0.0195181891,
-0.0066583995,
0.0431205854,
-0.0346331745,
0.0459724925,
-0.0421219878,
-0.0336474031,
0.0579207353,
-0.0059832875,
0.0409820676,
-0.0163815189,
-0.0448363908,
-0.0934679136,
-0.0037517976,
0.0087973196,
-0.0487217903,
-0.0020821088,
0.037939705,
-0.0034109484,
-0.0031627433,
-0.0473434255,
-0.029233003,
-0.0019424935,
0.0304151867,
0.0344366767,
-0.0097943749,
-0.0330000073,
0.0590835847,
0.0105737206,
0.015496131,
0.0148562482,
0.029237004,
0.0196966697,
-0.0463644676,
-0.029959755,
-0.0063297581,
-0.0252070278,
-0.0305689648,
-0.0410338752,
0.0221823286,
0.0899443328,
-0.0032562222,
-0.0261042845,
0.019909624,
-0.0260690432,
2.808e-7,
0.0233529955,
0.0922233015,
0.0196123738,
-0.0095011676,
0.0522731394,
-0.0086802337,
-0.0454984307,
-0.0622534715,
-0.0444186963,
-0.0625960678,
0.0321113281,
-0.0158827566,
0.0006296751,
0.0078273118,
0.0196105223,
0.0022573771,
-0.0144656887,
-0.07207378,
0.0215075221,
0.0168661326,
0.043300312,
-0.0350516811,
-0.0330435112,
-0.0406230576,
0.0159156621,
-0.0251972247,
-0.013927564,
-0.0277871285,
0.0438616574,
-0.0015290502,
-0.006578512,
0.0662223324,
-0.0038339852,
0.0114820171,
-0.0268324669,
-0.0394729264,
-0.0484912246,
0.0511742234,
-0.0220267456,
0.0556367971,
-0.0042955196,
-0.0668825284,
0.051489424,
-0.0437419787,
0.0519240424,
0.0532342494,
0.000970407,
0.0017655828,
0.0276162457,
-0.0608858652,
0.0027094102,
-0.0232124012,
-0.0566260889,
0.008282043,
-0.0218219236,
0.0562779978,
0.0017963609,
-0.0104549108,
0.0542372018,
0.0541334897,
-0.0314499289,
-0.0579168722,
0.1026245356,
-0.0187313911,
-0.024853304,
-0.040913336,
-0.0313319378,
2.895159245e-34,
0.0000303045,
0.0036249983,
0.0041072969,
-0.0187551454,
-0.0434955284,
-0.0228276905,
0.0185239632,
-0.0185487941,
0.0003533572,
-0.008531048,
-0.0314783752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12280v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12280v1 | SIFTER: A Task-specific Alignment Strategy for Enhancing Sentence Embeddings | 2023-06-21T14:08:08 | 2023-06-21T14:08:08 | Chao Yu, Wenhao Zhu, Chaoming Liu, Xiaoyu Zhang, Qiuhong zhai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The paradigm of pre-training followed by fine-tuning on downstream tasks has
become the mainstream method in natural language processing tasks. Although
pre-trained models have the advantage of generalization, their performance may
still vary significantly across different domain tasks. This is because the
data distribution in different domains varies. For example, the different parts
of the sentence 'He married Smt. Dipali Ghosh in 1947 and led a very happy
married life' may have different impact for downstream tasks. For similarity
calculations, words such as 'led' and 'life' are more important. On the other
hand, for sentiment analysis, the word 'happy' is crucial. This indicates that
different downstream tasks have different levels of sensitivity to sentence
components. Our starting point is to scale information of the model and data
according to the specifics of downstream tasks, enhancing domain information of
relevant parts for these tasks and reducing irrelevant elements for different
domain tasks, called SIFTER. In the experimental part, we use the SIFTER to
improve SimCSE by constructing positive sample pairs based on enhancing the
sentence stem and reducing the unimportant components in the sentence, and
maximize the similarity between three sentences. Similarly, SIFTER can improve
the gate mechanism of the LSTM model by short-circuiting the input gate of
important words so that the LSTM model remembers the important parts of the
sentence. Our experiments demonstrate that SIFTER outperforms the SimCSE and
LSTM baselines. | [
0.0195765365,
0.0203513037,
0.017348256,
0.0361742377,
-0.0619639829,
0.0061267074,
-0.0029186474,
-0.0334643535,
0.0325683393,
-0.0408212095,
-0.0521639884,
-0.0305057094,
-0.015164298,
0.0255389959,
0.0055127884,
-0.026268715,
0.0740205646,
0.0545935035,
-0.0077580246,
0.0142867779,
0.0472845808,
-0.0039748186,
0.0316561572,
0.0019296912,
0.0055760331,
-0.0028162589,
0.0118500814,
0.0236017294,
0.0676452368,
-0.0083188135,
0.0366279408,
0.0273078978,
0.0197407845,
-0.005402945,
0.0000020111,
-0.0198770631,
-0.0113292942,
-0.0442990884,
0.0162485391,
-0.0111798262,
0.0649138615,
-0.0194109976,
-0.0004258952,
0.0328964479,
-0.0576854162,
0.0192998517,
0.0489204079,
0.0857213885,
0.0529860668,
0.114034608,
-0.0226197746,
-0.0377547331,
0.0226537641,
-0.0319323651,
0.001288323,
-0.0132298535,
-0.0060075135,
-0.0165278018,
-0.0174994841,
0.0059612826,
-0.0215954464,
0.0253869127,
0.0274719577,
0.0124245221,
0.0676732361,
0.0007038743,
0.0079140356,
0.0238209274,
0.0082348976,
0.07437931,
-0.0718953237,
-0.0313032418,
-0.0283901207,
-0.0256822072,
-0.0311799347,
-0.0256236028,
-0.0318994299,
-0.0146668795,
0.0190475993,
0.0558235161,
0.0495760366,
0.0331265852,
0.0254435576,
0.0008897826,
-0.0118068773,
0.0137140164,
0.0150566529,
-0.0651988536,
0.0205714032,
0.0229858756,
-0.0201575309,
-0.0043616551,
0.0283166133,
0.0002017258,
-0.0235557612,
0.0134251155,
-0.0397956632,
-0.0375870056,
-0.0198774356,
-0.0660739541,
-0.0063058166,
0.0546122156,
-0.0032035378,
0.0466159247,
-0.0276123062,
0.0235630646,
-0.0171885379,
0.0173876695,
-0.0742762536,
-0.0107538197,
-0.0338196754,
-0.0122848134,
-0.0241084825,
0.0400980115,
-0.0453426875,
-0.0607130639,
-0.0526170917,
0.0164008047,
-0.0145363659,
-0.0131582171,
0.0287512206,
0.0021173803,
-0.0166655984,
-0.0100737354,
-0.0073314807,
0.0426391102,
-0.0838171914,
0.0297135115,
-0.0183462873,
-0.0365098491,
-0.0447330996,
0.0470342524,
0.0327845328,
-0.0451474413,
-0.0005632964,
0.0022536025,
-0.0146994889,
-0.0580572635,
-0.0423009694,
-0.0146247298,
0.0019719389,
-0.0639005154,
0.028744502,
-0.0455109812,
0.0671942979,
-0.0271168444,
-0.0132581433,
-0.0432912633,
-0.0063678995,
0.0236534029,
-0.0288323686,
0.0736330524,
0.0286346059,
-0.0403729342,
-0.0478955582,
0.0156188142,
0.0771147087,
0.0604822896,
0.0074937455,
0.0513934791,
0.0138493888,
0.0114622135,
-0.0100351665,
-0.0058929762,
0.0067292182,
-0.0190852676,
0.0098179961,
0.0301320497,
-0.0407695025,
0.0461049005,
0.0407829396,
0.0140762758,
-0.0163489301,
0.0133518809,
0.043264024,
0.0335158557,
0.0061315428,
0.0208529495,
0.0207125805,
0.0126982657,
-0.0016166194,
0.0287628118,
-0.0418542959,
0.0364204273,
0.0104026059,
0.0124241309,
0.0194900017,
0.0407103226,
-0.0476713516,
-0.0171983801,
-0.0162587464,
-0.0567704961,
0.0174960196,
0.0043727574,
0.0273198225,
0.0139497947,
-0.0669985935,
0.0473507307,
0.0127365738,
-0.0577720962,
-0.0218384508,
0.0179116763,
-0.0133804288,
0.0611853898,
0.0055770064,
-0.0445451364,
-0.0536620691,
-0.013951241,
0.0069524492,
0.0484938174,
0.0535376333,
0.0252784919,
0.0019904091,
-0.0667572916,
-0.0365627967,
-0.0340744518,
0.0171020739,
0.0010354245,
0.0257250294,
0.0106650284,
0.0400168635,
-0.0093728574,
0.02517928,
0.0255904421,
-0.0173988603,
-0.0220489334,
-0.0030436537,
0.0227341037,
0.0294741746,
0.026775429,
0.0030290033,
0.021986682,
0.0399116315,
-0.0415385775,
-0.0323511809,
0.0339719281,
-0.0717382208,
-0.0764624551,
0.005970648,
-0.065476723,
-0.0087422123,
0.1113144904,
-0.083649829,
-0.0282249544,
0.0136917522,
-0.0264523178,
-0.0212803222,
-0.0371742994,
0.0364203192,
0.0082951672,
0.0161742736,
-0.0380688235,
0.0575131103,
0.0083896331,
0.0068515078,
-0.0310006104,
0.0012400592,
0.0351295434,
-0.0325414389,
-0.0260675419,
-0.0354707539,
0.0192419868,
0.0087927431,
0.0345657207,
-0.0049430872,
-0.0586637668,
-0.0276180468,
-0.0979577154,
0.0336548053,
-0.0114791831,
0.0328156576,
0.0386872105,
0.0321647711,
0.0060088709,
0.0008938793,
-0.0461419262,
-0.0101912674,
-0.001935861,
0.0116604473,
0.0744629055,
-0.0352618098,
0.0046512778,
-0.060308814,
0.0107232193,
-0.0351765193,
0.0327272415,
-0.0114574488,
-0.0253621358,
-0.0355356075,
0.043436192,
-0.0381395705,
-0.0053683557,
0.0024043396,
-0.0317410827,
-0.0453686453,
0.0110202814,
0.0685012266,
0.0540918894,
0.0065887095,
0.0070905644,
0.0067021879,
0.0221463423,
-0.006609166,
0.0187107101,
-0.0495560579,
0.0844926536,
-0.029418543,
0.003945143,
0.0110538825,
0.0663585067,
0.0043004602,
-0.0070409616,
-0.0467987582,
0.0168571696,
0.0089949034,
0.0367154106,
-0.0009911264,
0.0006997202,
-0.0203938037,
-0.0257607214,
-0.0487277731,
-0.0222664848,
0.0605354346,
0.0085714022,
0.0138562256,
-0.1028313935,
-0.0156420507,
-0.0622433387,
0.0479991175,
-0.0025166986,
0.0155992713,
0.0143398028,
0.0055347602,
-0.0567954406,
-0.0092970775,
0.003880766,
-0.0191489365,
0.018072255,
0.0194023121,
-0.0147160916,
-0.0204411913,
-0.0521117859,
-0.0175450724,
-0.067255646,
-0.0289633125,
0.009389923,
0.050107725,
0.0095799044,
-0.0147146713,
-0.0110347318,
-0.0198315289,
0.0052551869,
-0.0258488189,
0.0036168718,
-0.0207881853,
0.064546518,
0.0740894303,
-0.0061228056,
0.0284531564,
-0.0039522904,
0.0192087442,
0.0171418935,
0.0258292574,
-0.0142317656,
-0.0398713984,
-0.0256188046,
0.0158527847,
-0.0534862354,
0.0243430268,
-0.0204072539,
0.0676782131,
-0.0328179672,
-0.0057619978,
0.1397410035,
0.0278152097,
0.0041502956,
-0.0034352175,
0.0058982065,
0.0091532618,
0.020887807,
-0.001165111,
-0.0483549275,
-0.0396252647,
-0.0167130195,
-0.0403633863,
0.0366339684,
0.0047886013,
-0.0244565252,
-0.0912066847,
-0.0055371528,
0.0147682177,
-0.0287366975,
-0.0555120781,
-0.0072266851,
-0.015293017,
-0.0060657915,
0.0193169415,
-0.0239695162,
-0.0259124264,
-0.0052620228,
-0.010552112,
-0.0420154296,
-0.0468924381,
-0.0007962875,
-0.0733971298,
0.0367890745,
0.0137607567,
0.0446525626,
0.0272599924,
-0.0064075128,
0.0683021918,
-0.018671535,
0.0090246182,
-0.0171337035,
0.0434847288,
-0.0456408076,
-0.001618547,
-0.0184589047,
0.0087715844,
-0.0479786433,
-0.0043650782,
-0.0262557417,
0.066648908,
-0.0214342196,
-0.0155403167,
-0.0098483153,
0.0242336337,
-0.0015307646,
0.0849561021,
0.029984476,
-0.0323986337,
-0.0356307477,
0.0347626656,
0.0073624072,
-0.0291907936,
-0.0282788724,
-0.0075561982,
0.0056830999,
0.0095866416,
-0.0595612787,
-0.0879025534,
-0.0002397494,
0.0380127318,
-0.0229696818,
0.0255909935,
-0.0143827433,
-0.0450952835,
-0.0522823706,
0.0240120627,
-0.0538415052,
0.009343151,
0.0149842678,
0.0347384512,
0.0173770282,
-0.0131924767,
-0.0361604616,
-0.0522198863,
-0.1156085283,
-0.0510232523,
-0.0224468838,
-0.0003980194,
0.0096650552,
0.0601143464,
-0.0251176208,
-0.0056441128,
0.0330241658,
0.0208752267,
-0.0357402675,
0.0134988148,
0.054908298,
-0.0139654148,
0.0082326792,
0.030896863,
-0.0114698345,
0.0348053612,
0.0436890647,
0.022958437,
0.0172754675,
-0.037340939,
-0.0119286524,
0.002229203,
0.0870193318,
0.0186692867,
0.0183113217,
-0.0463723503,
-0.0006651665,
-0.0124266427,
-0.0047150003,
-0.0301662348,
-0.0285648964,
0.0351071991,
0.026729105,
-0.0458653159,
0.0315197818,
-0.0192469265,
0.0083577316,
-0.0450142585,
0.0073372442,
-0.0193666667,
0.0044548376,
-0.0410904437,
0.0209610257,
-0.0290982388,
-0.0019812291,
0.0027990958,
-0.0000537767,
-0.0215220153,
0.0022615991,
0.0201278385,
0.0176097695,
-0.0191941559,
0.0575343631,
-0.0533830971,
-0.0016493144,
-0.0513357073,
-0.0236176159,
0.06696596,
-0.0460164584,
0.0439993255,
-0.0189585015,
-0.0044795517,
0.0123886699,
0.0589418449,
-0.0059452062,
-0.0016969943,
0.019706713,
0.006565996,
-0.0414334759,
-0.0305479374,
0.0292993467,
-0.0236394312,
0.0268695597,
0.0435049757,
-0.0296393652,
-0.0472799391,
-0.0312543698,
0.0176508706,
0.0248822924,
-0.0034591032,
-0.0049454542,
-0.0398017801,
-0.0393767282,
0.0604911707,
-0.0012486165,
-0.0272699744,
0.0145876426,
0.0689511597,
0.0153522398,
-0.0208686981,
0.0166251361,
0.0036421244,
-0.0174768474,
0.012709396,
-0.0624695383,
0.000143967,
-6.8494704e-33,
-0.0146506177,
0.0350165181,
0.0032560879,
-0.0005404067,
-0.060044758,
0.0121047953,
-0.0400432907,
-0.0232600588,
-0.027690554,
0.0277566314,
0.0046502021,
0.0339417271,
0.0102186967,
0.0211293995,
-0.0301465672,
-0.0322634466,
0.0557508916,
0.0081877569,
-0.0171794072,
-0.0161125232,
0.0259289276,
0.0489464849,
0.0959118903,
-0.0519788228,
-0.0102486499,
-0.0053891474,
-0.0145397456,
0.028861504,
0.0581459664,
0.0328132808,
-0.0097886724,
0.0439324044,
0.0401154086,
-0.0441616923,
-0.0116870049,
0.0812149346,
-0.0604499653,
-0.067353867,
0.0249122605,
-0.0022799948,
-0.0363422632,
-0.018332433,
0.0277535878,
-0.01106741,
0.0152504202,
-0.0132451477,
0.0304233581,
-0.0108268345,
0.0281591881,
-0.0566369779,
-0.0934278816,
0.0142256301,
0.0185078271,
-0.0019854188,
-0.0087713189,
0.0410193503,
0.022088835,
0.0335614793,
-0.0208299514,
0.0145477364,
-0.0153411515,
0.0550910607,
0.0167998336,
-0.0291749146,
-0.0149902496,
0.0660597757,
0.0167720057,
-0.0237603914,
-0.0050975233,
0.0141351447,
0.0168005154,
0.0234800186,
0.0449031107,
0.0588734858,
0.0654389635,
-0.0100351088,
-0.0863484591,
0.0227054097,
0.0539566986,
0.022682948,
0.0203769784,
0.0198496561,
-0.0326511301,
-0.017544657,
0.0007896877,
0.0722599775,
-0.0216167513,
-0.0330368727,
0.0350116044,
0.0380003676,
-0.010804384,
0.0375038646,
0.0059123416,
-0.0569118187,
0.0344731398,
0.0353444964,
-0.0127952527,
0.0020998269,
0.0169815924,
0.0041793226,
-0.0560561605,
-0.0393068455,
0.0078801429,
0.0210921336,
-0.0031656821,
-0.0246100035,
0.0701267645,
0.0142204314,
-0.0895629749,
-0.0060357773,
-0.0212063622,
-0.0107480194,
-0.0291085411,
0.0184346121,
0.0146803362,
0.03866731,
-0.0253994931,
0.0849727094,
0.0495388769,
-0.0228579883,
-0.0384720415,
0.0107829813,
0.0186082888,
0.0245104451,
0.029878553,
0.0048231515,
-0.0176858865,
0.0067237159,
-0.0125933439,
-0.0720693618,
-0.0233522598,
0.0090453234,
2.882e-7,
0.0386215672,
0.023553079,
0.0389588103,
0.0183593407,
0.0067236638,
0.0225922372,
0.0145199681,
0.0513686985,
-0.0365974903,
0.0331855677,
0.0431924611,
0.0200790241,
0.0353435725,
-0.0210396182,
-0.1157620028,
0.0153159378,
-0.0547387488,
-0.0221519899,
-0.0120880893,
0.0141813317,
0.0541536435,
0.1177590713,
0.0296341218,
-0.0060910396,
-0.0145652685,
-0.004587932,
0.0573592931,
-0.0338547975,
-0.0225986559,
0.0207274556,
-0.038476225,
-0.0083857169,
-0.0212309323,
-0.0010843442,
-0.0213805791,
0.0424220525,
0.0066825105,
0.0555099584,
-0.0049555586,
-0.0250830688,
-0.0136066461,
0.0006310053,
0.000369666,
-0.0068508405,
0.0604393557,
-0.0814034492,
-0.0195878465,
-0.0492614359,
-0.050524734,
0.0029170574,
0.039948903,
0.0315189287,
-0.0302140806,
0.0099926423,
0.042365808,
0.0069423015,
-0.049097918,
-0.1019175649,
-0.0414690822,
0.0202563927,
-0.0355235375,
-0.0275541861,
-0.0115145929,
0.0120364996,
0.0762203112,
-0.0682667792,
-0.0179922227,
3.036196986e-34,
0.0568771064,
0.016151255,
0.036025919,
0.0314548872,
0.0180550758,
-0.0083662495,
-0.0449558124,
-0.0231365021,
0.050360404,
-0.0322285108,
-0.0070292735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12255v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12255v1 | Solving and Generating NPR Sunday Puzzles with Large Language Models | 2023-06-21T13:23:48 | 2023-06-21T13:23:48 | Jingmiao Zhao, Carolyn Jane Anderson | cs.CL | cs.CL | We explore the ability of large language models to solve and generate puzzles
from the NPR Sunday Puzzle game show using PUZZLEQA, a dataset comprising 15
years of on-air puzzles. We evaluate four large language models using PUZZLEQA,
in both multiple choice and free response formats, and explore two prompt
engineering techniques to improve free response performance: chain-of-thought
reasoning and prompt summarization. We find that state-of-the-art large
language models can solve many PUZZLEQA puzzles: the best model, GPT-3.5,
achieves 50.2% loose accuracy. However, in our few-shot puzzle generation
experiment, we find no evidence that models can generate puzzles: GPT-3.5
generates puzzles with answers that do not conform to the generated rules.
Puzzle generation remains a challenging task for future work. | [
0.0502977744,
0.0726090297,
-0.0085035991,
0.0080527598,
-0.0514380224,
0.0314136297,
0.0376727283,
0.0020298066,
-0.0305301603,
0.0005843468,
0.0429675393,
-0.0169542562,
-0.0365476832,
0.0503110103,
0.0087871086,
-0.0540004186,
0.0178365968,
-0.0803988203,
0.0183586944,
-0.0141106322,
-0.0247287825,
0.0194756296,
-0.0393182635,
0.0116223972,
-0.0171547625,
-0.0388929248,
-0.0696401596,
0.004739339,
-0.0061928271,
-0.0394785367,
-0.0765610784,
0.0840492174,
0.00040943,
0.0622209385,
0.0000018908,
-0.026501067,
-0.0279805679,
-0.0435660519,
-0.040826384,
-0.0021034474,
-0.0136077562,
0.0210345238,
-0.015373121,
0.0290541667,
-0.0276650935,
0.0037396352,
0.0608642884,
0.0285436586,
0.1003585011,
0.0728062615,
0.0108284988,
0.0133149242,
0.0100486465,
-0.0079381233,
0.0559076481,
-0.0352103226,
0.0040567089,
0.0231495928,
0.0206354409,
0.010055053,
-0.0184131153,
0.001598941,
0.0547515601,
-0.0292998925,
-0.0605204999,
0.0131380437,
-0.0157003365,
0.0007108744,
-0.0131163746,
0.0628375784,
0.0196142327,
0.0106030824,
-0.0086812787,
0.0047931192,
0.0188136157,
0.0387516357,
-0.0435372852,
0.0568907969,
-0.0109706838,
-0.0200724956,
-0.0029063767,
0.021654781,
0.0009084068,
-0.0032098352,
0.0101395557,
0.1013132706,
0.0116632851,
-0.0111828661,
-0.0252083838,
-0.0174718052,
-0.0284481272,
-0.0823098719,
0.0144189009,
0.0330219604,
-0.0650549755,
0.010657358,
0.0013680399,
-0.0314676166,
0.0005672178,
0.0428978205,
0.0218844712,
0.0499053188,
0.0310291369,
0.0374080427,
0.0333628356,
0.0737515762,
-0.008174682,
-0.0254973918,
-0.086860545,
0.0203891098,
-0.0258529466,
-0.0144615984,
-0.0453387573,
0.0393765047,
-0.0502323285,
-0.0185483042,
-0.0130723119,
0.0090485252,
0.0093439128,
0.02399146,
0.0251588151,
0.0321834907,
-0.0080167297,
-0.0112350145,
-0.0207332522,
0.0350038409,
-0.0753354877,
-0.014481592,
0.0411116332,
-0.0396682471,
-0.0321008824,
-0.0085513834,
0.0288194418,
-0.0371429697,
0.0022792893,
0.014368861,
-0.0224748533,
0.0086571379,
0.0194895733,
-0.0165356994,
-0.063258931,
-0.0848738924,
0.0130927581,
-0.0865544006,
0.0253682453,
-0.0128060095,
-0.0052282945,
-0.0030112136,
0.0089802807,
0.0531853326,
0.0056490819,
0.0386380479,
0.0232607871,
0.029861981,
0.0236615986,
0.0212414209,
0.0027817308,
0.0442379303,
0.0132074915,
0.049173478,
0.0289889053,
-0.0312000737,
0.0248070396,
0.036140535,
-0.0011872832,
0.0017806011,
-0.0118601071,
0.0071021267,
0.0603816584,
0.0381481312,
0.0089900037,
0.0340557061,
-0.0093831345,
0.031947013,
0.0526529588,
0.0562181436,
-0.0280021001,
-0.0035993299,
0.0798600912,
-0.0044503962,
0.0237965137,
0.0370336026,
-0.0443682894,
0.0561314188,
-0.0374916308,
0.0367233194,
-0.0035019666,
0.0440526158,
-0.0376133546,
-0.0254378188,
0.0161851514,
0.0282534342,
0.0198263247,
0.0420794152,
0.0132580353,
0.0140525186,
-0.0386313945,
0.023949543,
0.0087733138,
-0.0299788266,
-0.0287025999,
-0.0431876667,
0.0734146684,
0.0439645536,
0.0601665489,
0.0030889986,
-0.0129616093,
0.0020687818,
0.0961127877,
0.0663661212,
0.0397210233,
0.006040555,
-0.0360485017,
-0.0271698665,
-0.0278518088,
-0.0313882716,
0.0100007048,
0.0326051749,
0.0166546311,
0.011064671,
-0.0204150174,
-0.0011943979,
0.0117353313,
-0.0017318119,
-0.0279968474,
-0.0159612242,
-0.0138546759,
0.0054417271,
0.0031016858,
0.026910536,
0.0078226933,
0.02046551,
-0.0048975307,
-0.0329939984,
-0.0082953125,
-0.0159082375,
-0.0858462602,
-0.0700826719,
0.0015580337,
-0.0434958376,
-0.0051063485,
0.0576279387,
-0.0337387584,
-0.046061039,
0.0161676314,
-0.0470351204,
-0.0052453536,
-0.0228607226,
0.0019072625,
0.0264866874,
-0.0287420042,
-0.0480495654,
0.1061990187,
-0.0163520221,
0.051483877,
-0.0088849152,
-0.0054899803,
0.0210028514,
-0.0877767727,
-0.0063855606,
0.0640848577,
-0.0137889823,
-0.0237893909,
0.010571748,
0.0364718959,
-0.0581225529,
-0.0545380525,
-0.0284485966,
0.0158931296,
-0.0304194205,
-0.0025450427,
-0.0141897863,
0.0182277374,
-0.0307243243,
0.0005349637,
-0.0570303909,
-0.0240264069,
0.0356871933,
0.0123133948,
0.0012742034,
0.0173017755,
-0.0299438853,
0.020561425,
-0.0377168953,
-0.0196786039,
0.0487538613,
0.0080589745,
0.0262954887,
-0.0522915944,
0.019801477,
-0.0619438253,
-0.0262711048,
0.0225296486,
-0.011259214,
0.0168013629,
-0.0374229662,
0.0476066954,
0.0309635717,
-0.0033449749,
-0.0105900643,
0.0335864313,
-0.0654576942,
-0.0359605253,
0.0411190055,
-0.0137521308,
-0.0374700278,
0.0102740349,
-0.0774016753,
-0.0222462509,
0.0491820835,
0.0265391674,
0.0078025102,
-0.0454333611,
0.1142074838,
0.0014176193,
-0.0191610474,
-0.0701669008,
-0.0294817463,
-0.0247659329,
0.0449911505,
-0.04283325,
-0.0134797096,
0.0736620575,
-0.0200071968,
0.0156370979,
-0.0604794323,
0.0216137227,
-0.0242902543,
0.0754058957,
0.0187968165,
0.0446514711,
0.0466921479,
-0.0608010106,
-0.063889645,
0.0113350153,
0.0513004772,
-0.0396474302,
0.0200962704,
-0.0408916511,
-0.0139727527,
0.0012818893,
-0.0490342304,
-0.0499639809,
-0.0108428365,
-0.0560617223,
-0.0078694485,
0.046480298,
0.0002891585,
-0.0245273672,
0.0256667864,
0.0451478213,
-0.0339818895,
-0.0410002284,
0.0029008873,
-0.0281323306,
0.0637359545,
0.0923056677,
0.0513219461,
0.0068574403,
-0.0228747092,
0.0597491153,
0.0214718245,
0.0623178817,
0.0054224832,
0.0107237864,
0.06929674,
0.0051346226,
-0.0018672356,
-0.0203187261,
0.0599142946,
0.012278026,
-0.0127777737,
-0.027139606,
0.1040274352,
0.0640323982,
0.0010029125,
-0.0154040549,
-0.0194939822,
0.0441643372,
-0.0004449167,
0.0520364344,
-0.0882159099,
-0.0349848941,
0.04856335,
-0.0057382984,
-0.0030272868,
-0.0702303723,
-0.0155014126,
-0.1230183616,
0.0377559736,
0.0030416409,
-0.0475460216,
-0.0370794311,
-0.0242269672,
-0.0378914922,
0.0116691152,
0.0002524971,
0.0318800695,
-0.0097783823,
0.0130546894,
-0.0055094301,
0.0085446918,
0.015416842,
0.0423251465,
-0.0082550608,
0.0558221005,
0.0734353885,
-0.0156011805,
-0.0191503391,
-0.0633727908,
-0.0027564405,
-0.002325465,
0.0085083488,
0.0070307804,
0.0117370011,
0.0369385816,
-0.0196372028,
-0.0661225989,
0.0433109477,
-0.0137474928,
-0.043990165,
0.0254882928,
0.0822521374,
-0.0119584613,
-0.0402007625,
-0.0005595973,
0.0317403264,
0.0106369788,
0.0589139462,
0.0440938435,
-0.043707896,
-0.0105818203,
-0.0312332604,
-0.014797342,
-0.0529284813,
-0.0332240909,
0.0130419433,
0.0498435088,
0.006237681,
-0.0327440202,
-0.0219441932,
0.0044927122,
0.0540591069,
-0.0189662185,
-0.0016721616,
-0.0444571301,
0.0424992256,
0.0082401028,
0.0290959552,
-0.0264814626,
0.0117584001,
-0.0205440838,
-0.0020724791,
-0.0287845898,
-0.0551670566,
-0.0251630824,
0.0128599862,
-0.0767540932,
0.0049566366,
0.0101402178,
0.0480917506,
0.0344108976,
-0.0176806375,
0.0205919538,
0.0030405787,
-0.0235463642,
0.0364557058,
-0.0357407257,
-0.0062358384,
-0.0552867316,
0.0398876555,
0.0017933955,
0.0045864028,
-0.0333672576,
0.0240676571,
0.0214377549,
0.083898142,
-0.0211137868,
0.0027749205,
0.0598341636,
0.024189081,
0.0014681346,
0.0067191864,
-0.0328698754,
-0.0174763948,
0.0247713942,
-0.0384243801,
-0.0403181687,
-0.025591284,
0.0039965496,
-0.0025545915,
-0.0221329909,
0.0322039276,
0.0093829529,
0.0099301422,
0.0370731987,
-0.0371585898,
-0.0220866576,
0.0039053033,
-0.0032015189,
0.0174641311,
-0.0178099871,
0.0008410186,
0.0605774745,
0.015577131,
0.0419576652,
0.0206952151,
0.0726942345,
0.0389438346,
-0.0253438763,
-0.0055304896,
0.0211019181,
-0.0599466786,
-0.0483283401,
-0.0051351073,
-0.0033245229,
0.0602689981,
0.0058337413,
-0.050987523,
0.0223839954,
-0.0228237547,
0.0155892577,
-0.00794126,
0.0834246203,
-0.0385186262,
0.0347586945,
0.0414002426,
0.0120666111,
-0.0612152927,
0.0501481332,
0.0058764112,
0.0023677191,
0.0518555827,
-0.0125916796,
-0.0386266373,
-0.0164722856,
-0.0314147435,
0.0340545215,
-0.0159706268,
0.0131545682,
-0.0678314865,
-0.04335187,
-0.0156756602,
0.0201324001,
0.0018044345,
0.022942856,
0.0566570126,
0.0430280343,
-0.0096415197,
-0.0405090898,
-0.0000888814,
0.047977645,
-0.0331773348,
-0.0451832376,
-0.0012291941,
-5.870007365e-33,
-0.045757968,
-0.0338165835,
0.0282881204,
0.0134397829,
-0.0018584454,
-0.0337494127,
-0.053180024,
0.0233855061,
0.0079816189,
0.0162969194,
-0.017345855,
-0.0062476667,
0.0119034573,
0.0266846865,
0.0058731576,
-0.041480165,
0.0169779062,
-0.0085781859,
-0.0555801168,
0.0111327711,
-0.0075197336,
-0.0049368087,
-0.0055852807,
-0.0155437794,
-0.0092104012,
-0.0309181921,
-0.0169685129,
0.0303196479,
-0.0085766213,
0.0413087346,
-0.0155560179,
0.0108018108,
0.0110473782,
-0.0830722824,
0.0038298347,
0.0400131978,
-0.0234775878,
-0.043159429,
0.006413314,
-0.0274800807,
-0.0344899446,
-0.0517465547,
-0.0247076638,
-0.018322045,
-0.0170160048,
-0.0076754261,
0.0210520979,
-0.0444011912,
0.0298005547,
-0.0093238801,
0.0055597532,
-0.0133768423,
-0.0520932823,
-0.0384478047,
-0.0121453861,
0.0322018079,
0.0158883557,
-0.0046505323,
0.008091596,
0.0520965196,
0.0665694103,
0.0113513758,
0.0469490066,
-0.0145436637,
-0.0362525508,
0.0206457134,
0.0341302268,
-0.0487195812,
-0.0627352223,
0.0199165419,
-0.0094200484,
0.0336537547,
0.0764683932,
0.0439854264,
0.0172935594,
0.0229793489,
-0.0453626327,
0.0392549001,
-0.0079738954,
0.0361443013,
0.0349413157,
-0.0422326624,
-0.0377578847,
-0.0200524013,
-0.0523262098,
0.0291172378,
-0.062306609,
-0.0384854451,
0.023664834,
0.0054718009,
-0.0143810185,
-0.0549616404,
0.0379760452,
0.005104993,
-0.0062597552,
0.0429530889,
-0.0019442537,
0.0132015357,
-0.0184092447,
0.0099459095,
-0.0378980376,
0.0341970734,
0.0358457118,
-0.0017801936,
-0.0034886776,
-0.0018210583,
-0.0134478696,
0.0373405889,
-0.07681714,
0.0012078426,
-0.0351574607,
0.0534452796,
0.0066944305,
-0.0483976714,
0.0201425049,
-0.0206472147,
-0.008982053,
-0.0068025147,
0.0153104365,
-0.0207129959,
-0.0082416832,
-0.0068672174,
-0.0043085739,
-0.0132767279,
-0.008869404,
0.0037911625,
-0.0128087765,
0.0123716388,
0.0007600719,
0.0043537668,
-0.0153841851,
0.0099226525,
2.565e-7,
0.0159842279,
0.0408492126,
0.0003605221,
0.0668047965,
0.0205918234,
0.0080112861,
-0.0192671679,
-0.0167269148,
0.0421473533,
-0.0336241014,
-0.0107705509,
0.0432271548,
0.04373895,
0.0315806679,
-0.1201784238,
0.0294441972,
-0.0384532735,
0.0011927618,
-0.0740565062,
-0.001101308,
0.0741346776,
0.0707260445,
0.0045622629,
-0.0055292216,
0.0078329686,
-0.018680919,
-0.0065177134,
0.0085087242,
-0.0220401939,
0.0128441816,
-0.0231763907,
-0.0153838415,
-0.0092691602,
0.0420500822,
0.010497788,
-0.012814641,
0.0385160558,
0.0230952632,
0.0242192056,
-0.0302054882,
-0.0540204346,
-0.0045809848,
0.0170132089,
-0.0634176657,
0.0767995715,
-0.0400863923,
-0.0216452852,
0.0109767867,
-0.0339341909,
-0.0539508574,
-0.0006396048,
-0.0084038945,
-0.0150881773,
-0.0010637332,
0.0099708568,
0.0279352963,
0.0254619531,
-0.0328359753,
-0.029014498,
-0.0027439997,
-0.0251976065,
-0.0607207678,
-0.0581823029,
-0.0195934102,
-0.0221593566,
-0.0762467831,
0.00029866,
2.647998012e-34,
0.0526342355,
0.0369289964,
0.0015317561,
-0.0032968186,
0.0056896512,
0.0051336261,
0.007583241,
-0.0124340821,
0.0322837234,
-0.1001294553,
-0.0234667454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12245v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12245v4 | Bidirectional End-to-End Learning of Retriever-Reader Paradigm for Entity Linking | 2023-06-21T13:04:30 | 2024-03-20T03:51:23 | Yinghui Li, Yong Jiang, Yangning Li, Xingyu Lu, Pengjun Xie, Ying Shen, Hai-Tao Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Entity Linking (EL) is a fundamental task for Information Extraction and
Knowledge Graphs. The general form of EL (i.e., end-to-end EL) aims to first
find mentions in the given input document and then link the mentions to
corresponding entities in a specific knowledge base. Recently, the paradigm of
retriever-reader promotes the progress of end-to-end EL, benefiting from the
advantages of dense entity retrieval and machine reading comprehension.
However, the existing study only trains the retriever and the reader separately
in a pipeline manner, which ignores the benefit that the interaction between
the retriever and the reader can bring to the task. To advance the
retriever-reader paradigm to perform more perfectly on end-to-end EL, we
propose BEER$^2$, a Bidirectional End-to-End training framework for Retriever
and Reader. Through our designed bidirectional end-to-end training, BEER$^2$
guides the retriever and the reader to learn from each other, make progress
together, and ultimately improve EL performance. Extensive experiments on
benchmarks of multiple domains demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed
BEER$^2$. | [
0.0590340421,
-0.0127769876,
0.0044366536,
0.0358824991,
0.0130999759,
0.0302499067,
-0.0289439596,
-0.0115539758,
0.0684294105,
-0.021533696,
0.0013849837,
0.0052577183,
-0.0544092804,
0.0382698551,
0.028997058,
-0.0203024074,
0.036910329,
0.0169574451,
0.005432135,
0.0173531082,
-0.0099544758,
0.017576037,
-0.0341000035,
-0.0496047139,
0.0136227803,
0.0129719488,
-0.0097818654,
0.029134687,
0.0485894941,
-0.0638045073,
-0.0073724464,
-0.0314094014,
0.012903804,
0.0118212914,
0.0000019893,
-0.029777253,
-0.0464757904,
0.0298032127,
-0.0490238518,
-0.0198577959,
-0.000024989,
-0.0284820627,
0.029081231,
0.000828328,
-0.0144000677,
-0.0407054313,
-0.0073915687,
0.0861941278,
0.0271513574,
0.0669321939,
-0.0154504599,
-0.0710648224,
0.0593492091,
-0.0435702354,
0.0096086385,
-0.070277147,
0.0141413258,
-0.0366266891,
0.0162190516,
0.0591278858,
-0.0074821003,
0.0532986261,
0.012611635,
0.0324304029,
0.0552119277,
0.0542225353,
0.0163522884,
0.0267967526,
0.0096847359,
0.1106776595,
0.0417076051,
0.0101480577,
0.0236528218,
0.0179468039,
0.0135519225,
0.0065880883,
-0.0195244607,
-0.0271579437,
-0.035350658,
-0.0098073948,
-0.0215530917,
-0.0175805185,
0.0372878537,
-0.0078212405,
-0.0206826832,
0.0105968937,
-0.0237445869,
-0.051188644,
0.0427080765,
0.0451082997,
0.0103819519,
-0.00347291,
0.0635712966,
0.022369042,
0.001495349,
0.0367862284,
0.0036840392,
-0.0060229432,
0.0246261507,
-0.0016422538,
-0.0045079845,
0.0045508696,
-0.0400698297,
0.0476592556,
-0.0869503245,
-0.0388390981,
-0.0239511877,
-0.0295588113,
0.0028526278,
-0.0513145663,
-0.0202343836,
0.0019222414,
-0.0377556533,
0.0468109064,
-0.0692928135,
-0.0137023889,
-0.0142139271,
0.0028145954,
0.0121659404,
0.0391397737,
-0.024777621,
-0.0000135698,
-0.0217872467,
-0.0084283156,
-0.0299110319,
0.027291717,
-0.0369547382,
0.0013555069,
-0.0189906452,
0.0358471684,
-0.0271678194,
-0.0248826686,
-0.0057436619,
-0.0720734671,
0.0003013783,
0.0793318301,
-0.000382825,
-0.0378021523,
-0.075400658,
-0.0149253486,
0.0347114988,
-0.0696586147,
0.017880071,
-0.007834916,
0.0544600524,
0.0310270675,
-0.0114940573,
-0.047781717,
0.0171626378,
-0.0057460833,
-0.0464654081,
0.055665981,
-0.0285674762,
-0.053602647,
0.0070599546,
0.0196413156,
-0.014635873,
0.0567262843,
0.0234857295,
0.0172200743,
0.0249828473,
0.0444797575,
-0.0511881672,
-0.0126839448,
0.0671027303,
-0.0022668424,
0.0853114203,
0.0250907894,
-0.0273266658,
0.0243389364,
0.0584010109,
0.0565809645,
-0.0518555865,
-0.0360381231,
0.0092375036,
-0.0104760975,
0.0509987213,
-0.0016784567,
0.0599330477,
0.0158372838,
-0.0081290854,
0.0190998968,
-0.0284983329,
0.0321079344,
-0.0122882342,
0.0291179996,
0.0100572249,
-0.0011289588,
-0.0011472352,
0.0025376398,
0.0317334086,
0.0100022769,
0.0223617572,
0.0225379765,
0.0836138129,
0.0210985262,
-0.0719536468,
0.0788993388,
0.0394446664,
-0.0030834677,
0.0047317259,
0.0106949154,
-0.026191486,
0.0169864688,
0.0209011082,
0.0114298221,
-0.0218457151,
-0.0322524235,
0.0086966781,
0.0480937548,
0.024760386,
-0.0244125221,
0.0215742402,
-0.0247581452,
-0.0230545383,
0.0057719625,
-0.0110963201,
0.0091168853,
0.0206946209,
0.0478193723,
0.0283694621,
-0.0449140854,
0.0022575315,
0.0180582199,
-0.053414952,
-0.0109096169,
-0.0407037325,
0.0383460745,
-0.0376235582,
0.034789864,
0.019752821,
-0.0048461715,
0.0666932166,
-0.0193648227,
0.0038142852,
-0.0003116991,
-0.0154697644,
-0.0169171467,
0.0375475064,
-0.0170672592,
-0.0055358671,
-0.0123007176,
-0.0116990767,
-0.0371350199,
0.0174871348,
-0.0056466311,
0.0688912198,
-0.0106314979,
0.0013267952,
0.0387207568,
-0.0253414046,
-0.0275415946,
0.0445573404,
-0.0159331039,
-0.0037928978,
-0.0214778781,
0.0011607251,
-0.0068672225,
-0.0303716511,
-0.0212041661,
-0.0039919233,
0.0239476245,
-0.0183639657,
-0.0118741002,
-0.0410610139,
-0.1100547165,
-0.0170010943,
-0.0550091788,
0.0233031753,
0.009113065,
0.0389393903,
-0.0118543124,
0.0067764991,
0.0056097372,
-0.0288884509,
0.0294520352,
0.0126157301,
-0.0364281759,
0.0035500566,
0.0364925526,
0.0599190742,
-0.0095078722,
-0.0230037104,
-0.0207424425,
-0.0207406543,
0.0124517465,
0.0051999656,
-0.0270624999,
-0.0646244213,
-0.000879855,
-0.0003605214,
0.0142547982,
-0.0234445035,
0.035995461,
-0.0244410988,
-0.0069124545,
0.035832718,
0.0548652969,
-0.0301409476,
0.0402738936,
-0.0398507789,
-0.0082186526,
-0.0635698587,
0.0545632951,
0.0024175444,
0.0076036179,
-0.045379322,
-0.008582443,
-0.0133670755,
0.0225455668,
-0.0446017608,
-0.0193613954,
0.0064419322,
-0.0045166668,
0.0274912268,
-0.0031673196,
-0.0062927073,
0.0246232767,
0.0137605956,
-0.0021085851,
-0.0504696444,
0.005031941,
0.0656490251,
-0.0148268128,
-0.0119435973,
-0.0173485707,
0.004160807,
-0.0331173055,
0.0233229101,
0.0205931831,
0.0058479686,
-0.0145735247,
-0.0664045736,
-0.0188320372,
0.0529638194,
0.0150429197,
0.0046024411,
0.0532779545,
0.0103790704,
0.0412123166,
-0.0165889934,
-0.0310843997,
-0.0230665077,
0.0326408111,
-0.0216340758,
0.0060653212,
-0.0132363671,
-0.015684098,
-0.0475600399,
-0.0067783413,
0.0398484059,
0.0086526917,
0.00661177,
-0.0438887998,
0.0019348701,
0.0355815515,
0.0431044586,
-0.0304384977,
0.0219408218,
-0.0125828721,
-0.0067952774,
0.0859192163,
0.009939977,
-0.0414688624,
0.019797001,
-0.0172585919,
0.0040692841,
-0.0822171047,
-0.0332704149,
-0.0275654159,
0.035119392,
-0.0543597303,
-0.0181239098,
0.0534958467,
0.0175344981,
-0.0472458042,
-0.0373588875,
0.028197499,
0.0019359919,
0.019751437,
0.0382142998,
-0.1000392362,
-0.0367358923,
-0.0143899852,
0.0423128791,
0.0478030369,
-0.0752159432,
0.0113318171,
-0.1050625443,
-0.0029425905,
-0.013727651,
-0.0632939264,
-0.0724490955,
-0.0853829086,
0.0156650543,
-0.0124178771,
0.0068166424,
0.0533608198,
-0.042602703,
0.0044271285,
0.0080689816,
0.0622843765,
0.0219463576,
0.0022311942,
-0.0724405646,
0.0032241493,
0.0323370621,
0.0179925878,
0.0372957587,
0.050254181,
-0.0156431869,
-0.0496035889,
-0.0142375948,
-0.0148789501,
0.1019309163,
-0.0723573267,
0.020065492,
-0.0337811261,
0.0129453177,
-0.0108773904,
0.0155635327,
-0.0101242429,
0.0554295331,
0.0516393483,
-0.0007704823,
-0.0282588266,
-0.0146038765,
0.0350792967,
0.0446502119,
-0.0058021089,
0.0063145864,
-0.0207113959,
-0.0115376962,
0.0039942279,
-0.0618246347,
0.0241385158,
0.0014457023,
-0.0643578395,
0.0307521354,
-0.0616753064,
-0.1018038616,
0.0216604136,
0.0272216033,
-0.0137154432,
0.0489381328,
0.0227502175,
-0.0355555825,
-0.0813223869,
0.0303256381,
-0.0233063586,
0.0166238099,
-0.020966759,
-0.0365426987,
0.046378538,
-0.0319373757,
-0.022871824,
0.0103413258,
-0.0562917069,
-0.0371989943,
-0.0389742702,
0.0116355056,
0.0118235983,
0.0809896514,
-0.0099948468,
-0.0054151835,
-0.0044299392,
0.0182790142,
-0.0732348114,
0.0155574838,
0.014948138,
0.0346985236,
-0.0114292372,
0.0395512544,
-0.0416747145,
-0.0111640086,
0.0182676576,
0.0611041635,
-0.0335780345,
-0.025870176,
-0.0077974051,
0.027995538,
0.0318137556,
0.0332704596,
0.0040440778,
-0.0412606895,
0.0485226549,
0.0193091575,
0.0015643883,
-0.0144850956,
0.0300253015,
0.0213489812,
0.0080525801,
-0.0268167742,
0.0053843968,
0.0377866291,
0.0409481451,
-0.0471552722,
0.0095422873,
0.0071178693,
-0.0159824323,
0.0281809587,
-0.0173441656,
-0.0173522774,
0.0199977364,
0.0394615531,
0.0733882263,
0.0019222976,
0.0313201547,
0.0409792848,
-0.0024933959,
-0.0196332913,
0.0086253518,
-0.041935347,
0.0373999178,
-0.0040549613,
0.0163591728,
0.054472845,
0.0118531166,
0.0727198049,
-0.0023234985,
-0.0052990122,
0.0283886474,
0.0143244369,
-0.0516900048,
-0.0039868765,
0.0159793198,
0.0185938496,
0.0123981284,
0.0254375469,
0.0344482325,
0.0170437712,
0.0645737872,
-0.0148652997,
0.0078274487,
-0.0471201651,
-0.0338581167,
-0.0080594216,
0.0083127981,
-0.0033153372,
0.0028888367,
-0.0117508145,
-0.0699930936,
0.0392239541,
-0.0340765491,
-0.0162648559,
-0.011619539,
0.0179610569,
0.0291124899,
0.0493719056,
-0.0575747751,
-0.0456744321,
0.0182477459,
0.0172669981,
-0.0176708419,
-0.0174302384,
-6.215867925e-33,
-0.0630923435,
-0.0141189955,
0.0420635901,
0.0057216571,
-0.0608489215,
-0.0320014805,
-0.0195645969,
-0.0398302451,
-0.0610581264,
0.0127730025,
-0.0218739901,
0.0159084629,
-0.0024194634,
0.0033148967,
-0.0086478954,
-0.0152367372,
0.0385688692,
0.0166675188,
0.0057440773,
0.0207431354,
0.0897798017,
0.0918588862,
0.0469005629,
-0.0670919493,
0.0386107303,
-0.0203917772,
0.0102842664,
0.0442305766,
0.0248688664,
0.0283379741,
0.0086054988,
0.0033839622,
0.0065264176,
-0.0162449367,
0.0116394954,
-0.015053398,
-0.2155791223,
-0.0073678121,
-0.0157041997,
0.0215643831,
-0.0154446512,
-0.0200527534,
0.0293384716,
-0.0204739496,
0.0918158367,
-0.0541292578,
-0.0005994795,
-0.0024255728,
-0.0322182886,
-0.0357140712,
-0.0488347672,
0.0234982241,
0.014255302,
0.0341739245,
0.0337408893,
-0.016829839,
0.0274714231,
-0.013236003,
-0.0864796415,
-0.0410779864,
-0.0123561649,
-0.0169794727,
-0.0265026204,
-0.0155060627,
0.0113926791,
0.0311230347,
0.0343002789,
-0.0270107258,
-0.0427257679,
0.0175180547,
-0.0068847043,
-0.0126235001,
-0.03708544,
0.0166999754,
0.055971548,
-0.0275201648,
-0.0937794968,
0.0263681076,
0.0142737022,
0.0472085774,
-0.0557842292,
0.0315239206,
-0.0415742509,
-0.0085793193,
-0.0120386733,
-0.0011370296,
-0.0134370914,
-0.0527372658,
0.0079492638,
0.0225188117,
-0.0222704932,
0.0295080915,
-0.0016415826,
-0.0032668137,
-0.0214004349,
0.0449139997,
0.0118686464,
-0.0017996323,
-0.0088539282,
-0.0094671929,
-0.0984314978,
-0.0030928289,
0.0007601955,
0.01161916,
-0.0023461108,
0.0073959804,
0.0540468059,
-0.0549135543,
-0.051148206,
0.0013447218,
-0.0274120048,
0.0499144606,
-0.0140543748,
0.0351949185,
0.0119163999,
0.0221914593,
-0.0075028478,
0.04036716,
0.0387243293,
0.0061409902,
-0.0501375906,
0.0525932498,
0.0229663663,
-0.0061778766,
-0.0080203777,
-0.0054223714,
-0.0135659501,
0.0453209691,
0.0136353225,
-0.1050060093,
-0.0035592171,
0.0256743934,
2.767e-7,
0.0222798921,
-0.0085461047,
0.0406361856,
0.0452382416,
-0.0420515947,
-0.0006264912,
0.0254861433,
0.0227531493,
0.0511057116,
0.0073608547,
-0.0159391295,
0.0312079266,
-0.0006710785,
0.0261363164,
-0.120450221,
-0.0401941873,
-0.0041108369,
-0.0149219688,
0.0060496377,
-0.0229957122,
0.0356470495,
-0.0073041627,
0.0003238754,
0.018764168,
0.0181025323,
-0.0340104923,
0.07611534,
0.0053604781,
0.0290273502,
0.0030058629,
0.0178244263,
0.0317127891,
-0.0347208753,
0.0504177846,
-0.0163501054,
0.0652728081,
-0.013808432,
0.0276301727,
0.0150601137,
-0.0508628562,
0.0069574155,
-0.0389113352,
0.0122878086,
0.0358195789,
0.0439598411,
-0.066734612,
-0.0075585907,
0.0489182137,
-0.0736208409,
-0.0110311164,
-0.0420023166,
0.0009765661,
-0.00884437,
0.0409639515,
-0.0074364627,
-0.0234768894,
0.0226642117,
-0.0966777056,
0.0171344038,
0.0312709622,
0.0127118817,
-0.0262641516,
0.0126501583,
-0.0055928528,
-0.0144674424,
-0.0437824391,
-0.0190131329,
2.084464413e-34,
-0.0122546619,
-0.0032113851,
0.0056543271,
0.0394878499,
0.0440413095,
-0.0340423249,
-0.0567638949,
0.0052283648,
0.0044937069,
-0.065612033,
-0.0309067145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12213v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12213v1 | Limits for Learning with Language Models | 2023-06-21T12:11:31 | 2023-06-21T12:11:31 | Nicholas Asher, Swarnadeep Bhar, Akshay Chaturvedi, Julie Hunter, Soumya Paul | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the advent of large language models (LLMs), the trend in NLP has been to
train LLMs on vast amounts of data to solve diverse language understanding and
generation tasks. The list of LLM successes is long and varied. Nevertheless,
several recent papers provide empirical evidence that LLMs fail to capture
important aspects of linguistic meaning. Focusing on universal quantification,
we provide a theoretical foundation for these empirical findings by proving
that LLMs cannot learn certain fundamental semantic properties including
semantic entailment and consistency as they are defined in formal semantics.
More generally, we show that LLMs are unable to learn concepts beyond the first
level of the Borel Hierarchy, which imposes severe limits on the ability of
LMs, both large and small, to capture many aspects of linguistic meaning. This
means that LLMs will continue to operate without formal guarantees on tasks
that require entailments and deep linguistic understanding. | [
0.01964196,
0.0750234053,
-0.0153642176,
0.0491129458,
-0.0418394022,
0.0335941464,
-0.030966565,
-0.003525197,
-0.0427475907,
-0.0493046567,
0.0334138498,
-0.0400077216,
-0.0091646677,
0.0398418419,
0.0451432802,
-0.0210614223,
0.0516117699,
-0.022464551,
-0.004590712,
-0.0371180587,
-0.0177900232,
-0.0054189768,
0.0261533242,
0.0029965974,
-0.0330797695,
0.0135623934,
-0.0090849418,
-0.0413138717,
-0.0142733371,
-0.0106919352,
-0.0239062961,
-0.0042181001,
0.0572460629,
0.0495079421,
0.0000018374,
-0.0772979259,
-0.0415637642,
-0.008530546,
-0.042674534,
-0.0358793773,
-0.0127010774,
-0.0706858113,
0.0138283335,
-0.0159070343,
-0.0433828831,
0.0185428616,
0.0296389461,
0.0358398855,
0.0536623411,
0.0403391495,
0.0013059484,
-0.0501745082,
0.0218545739,
-0.0326733403,
0.0309762359,
-0.0497316308,
0.0415947884,
0.0590274557,
0.0113194352,
0.0087811211,
-0.0266412683,
0.0326254144,
0.0229061227,
0.0469910391,
-0.0224502087,
0.0408379138,
-0.0101780547,
-0.0604395457,
0.0260886755,
0.0397591814,
-0.0122710168,
-0.0249106009,
0.0005656806,
0.0062059327,
-0.0237037055,
-0.0134844882,
-0.041248668,
0.1015880555,
-0.0145440772,
0.0442150086,
0.0272319503,
-0.0247245263,
0.0422243774,
0.01776837,
-0.0401035026,
0.0975169539,
-0.0010380328,
-0.0410531089,
0.0113753071,
0.0261072405,
-0.0324525051,
-0.0106398985,
-0.022213392,
0.0231662411,
-0.0474826954,
0.057026118,
-0.0284379404,
0.0260576084,
0.040685337,
-0.0334500819,
0.0124920765,
0.0152253918,
0.0039490624,
0.0363455079,
-0.0321134925,
0.0602835193,
-0.0173030514,
0.0142398011,
-0.0688271597,
-0.0288937297,
-0.0479372405,
-0.0324393362,
-0.0323454104,
0.0414719582,
-0.013120153,
-0.0095931292,
-0.0297872536,
0.036471162,
-0.0096747102,
0.0745893121,
-0.0258601774,
-0.0130819324,
-0.0691265538,
-0.0115970932,
-0.0460940301,
-0.0031304359,
-0.0186171159,
0.0311111752,
0.0022386976,
-0.0422353558,
0.0075850906,
0.0090099061,
0.0148388753,
-0.003745608,
0.0210293587,
0.0735413656,
0.0348323248,
-0.0087208757,
-0.055387374,
-0.0305509511,
-0.0229508393,
-0.0950906128,
0.0084132375,
-0.0522387289,
0.020789938,
0.0193681009,
0.0200397819,
-0.0250560343,
0.0176844168,
-0.0011027033,
-0.0247415863,
0.0664313957,
-0.0109260287,
0.0049673426,
-0.021778075,
-0.0104118967,
0.0243486892,
0.0652995035,
0.0013514661,
0.0184411164,
0.0584527366,
0.0018093144,
-0.0356822871,
0.0160694309,
0.0196513049,
0.0055394815,
-0.0325822383,
0.02655093,
0.0319113396,
0.0464913025,
0.0292594545,
0.0633627921,
-0.0225323644,
-0.0292500835,
0.0520497002,
0.0005394576,
0.0019920357,
-0.0016271361,
0.0768031254,
-0.0201577414,
-0.0303257518,
0.0402930975,
-0.0454075933,
-0.0160944983,
-0.0447844975,
0.0268369094,
0.0303594265,
-0.0038862487,
-0.0375420675,
-0.0495003201,
-0.0412215553,
-0.014726148,
-0.0325315185,
0.0048476667,
0.0596246049,
0.0393006913,
0.0067031621,
0.0821033269,
0.0507622287,
-0.0387801938,
0.0561616756,
-0.0342006721,
0.0536808483,
0.0217953194,
0.0286862068,
-0.0142522138,
-0.0128835468,
-0.0221761446,
0.0007206384,
0.070328027,
0.0145932408,
-0.0087176263,
0.0098586259,
-0.0230701342,
0.0024559405,
-0.0465810671,
0.0238618869,
0.0012703369,
-0.004344116,
-0.0378409773,
0.0090905055,
-0.0654849187,
-0.0437841117,
0.0566303432,
-0.047562506,
-0.0498805679,
-0.0052786767,
0.0083149951,
0.0398792848,
-0.0247894768,
-0.0179175045,
0.0195357557,
0.0244094525,
-0.0510990061,
-0.0388533883,
-0.0105567286,
-0.0346330106,
-0.0459843315,
0.0288966242,
-0.0326827392,
0.0061149821,
0.0150659401,
-0.0591408014,
-0.0310453288,
0.0110980943,
-0.036481645,
0.0317946821,
-0.0308223423,
0.0117565701,
0.0170844309,
-0.0144113777,
-0.0565422364,
0.0926564559,
-0.0195946433,
0.0287961066,
-0.0302936472,
0.0319736004,
-0.0098630218,
-0.0411817133,
-0.0270868726,
0.0441461094,
-0.0109237721,
0.025178656,
0.0280997027,
0.015333157,
-0.0551663265,
-0.0406920537,
-0.0445104241,
0.0284979939,
-0.0121449111,
-0.0004982249,
0.0223655943,
-0.0253777262,
0.0197738875,
-0.0022170793,
-0.0515669994,
0.0038718446,
0.0505214371,
0.0226599723,
0.0663796961,
-0.002978055,
-0.0104450108,
-0.0035116405,
-0.014321343,
-0.0055639795,
0.0441069864,
-0.015806431,
0.025705412,
-0.042035412,
0.0256982818,
-0.0561303534,
0.0079109771,
-0.0038667782,
0.0386180915,
0.002526341,
-0.01521427,
0.0156355593,
0.0456395522,
0.0210350286,
0.0658663437,
0.0432596616,
0.0031526077,
-0.0294155255,
-0.0012589162,
-0.0546944141,
-0.0498792455,
-0.0327631906,
-0.0088321054,
0.0203843731,
0.0804706886,
-0.0180838816,
-0.0166386608,
-0.0366368517,
0.0616851039,
-0.0536209159,
0.0040516704,
-0.0702875555,
0.0103451917,
-0.0211220942,
0.0469044521,
-0.0248703156,
-0.0604639016,
0.0087169129,
-0.0266331676,
-0.0155153535,
-0.0676652044,
-0.0230511185,
-0.0551436357,
0.0911051035,
0.0273066461,
0.0429943651,
0.0406318828,
0.0050359671,
-0.0361595564,
0.000420894,
0.0423858128,
0.0031884562,
0.0206387471,
-0.0418064445,
0.0340172537,
-0.0148515645,
-0.0220454186,
-0.0726137087,
-0.0268408339,
-0.0197607446,
0.0267584752,
-0.0295447875,
0.0184914693,
-0.0175782386,
0.00712081,
0.0163433496,
-0.0308989193,
0.0046952558,
-0.0334029905,
-0.0655536652,
0.0351854898,
0.0746297166,
0.0111823371,
0.0249281023,
-0.0431843549,
-0.0277812909,
0.0214768611,
-0.0251778252,
0.0317819044,
-0.0148010198,
0.0392042547,
0.0026128483,
-0.0288666766,
-0.0635665879,
0.0185741112,
0.0107879089,
-0.0314054489,
-0.0325375013,
0.1007968113,
0.020032255,
0.0450445041,
0.0374877155,
-0.007845128,
0.0323061273,
0.0043222834,
-0.018958319,
-0.1059103459,
-0.0101059433,
0.018906977,
-0.0064075282,
-0.0167162251,
-0.0353831798,
-0.0419075005,
-0.1141414493,
0.006307011,
0.0213301089,
-0.0774850622,
-0.0115622357,
-0.0277808663,
-0.0142811993,
-0.0149583444,
0.0540781394,
0.0280691758,
-0.0309897196,
0.0036335592,
0.0192095637,
0.0217911974,
-0.048332423,
0.0277051982,
-0.0334570631,
-0.0054051564,
0.0388177335,
0.0469809361,
-0.0117858965,
-0.0070510809,
-0.0050195227,
0.0022144655,
-0.0199874863,
-0.0070610601,
0.0116881421,
-0.0130986329,
-0.0148964096,
-0.0114475545,
0.0517514907,
-0.0338351466,
-0.003011778,
0.0059597818,
0.0490250997,
-0.0216064397,
-0.0682745874,
-0.0071918112,
0.0210919734,
-0.0285315216,
0.0903017819,
-0.0096786637,
-0.0128611177,
-0.0255935509,
-0.0165277161,
-0.0154405804,
0.0021376372,
-0.0128917713,
0.0396280736,
-0.0263990983,
-0.030342387,
-0.0851378143,
-0.0333136208,
-0.0017401538,
0.0465124585,
-0.0073823836,
0.0092782201,
0.0310139246,
-0.0245316084,
-0.0055065532,
0.0247649942,
-0.0664676055,
-0.0233691465,
-0.0088055208,
-0.0263436288,
0.0339782722,
-0.0105064381,
-0.0349546373,
-0.0117017692,
-0.0689938888,
-0.0568421409,
-0.0181165095,
0.044157248,
0.0354452245,
0.0375212096,
0.0299862139,
-0.0263779908,
0.0374079458,
0.0138767483,
-0.0235879254,
0.0453719236,
0.0331747867,
0.0210763924,
0.0075161527,
0.0690855831,
-0.0513413288,
0.0155368829,
0.0003311886,
0.0660863593,
-0.0101677971,
-0.0097934762,
0.0800744221,
0.0291598756,
-0.0065922383,
-0.003188072,
-0.0221755374,
-0.0141935367,
-0.013465099,
-0.0210311376,
-0.0445032045,
-0.0490612723,
0.0180939026,
0.0175017267,
0.034004733,
0.0002386762,
-0.0340354592,
0.026831599,
0.0642222315,
0.014802915,
-0.0463553295,
-0.0078351647,
0.0002813377,
0.044531785,
-0.0063333167,
-0.037270952,
0.0205355287,
-0.0328402743,
0.0564267859,
0.0151565969,
0.038431704,
0.0370488763,
0.0202056672,
-0.0262422748,
-0.0247383807,
-0.0469847247,
-0.0486153588,
-0.0108012939,
0.0299130753,
0.0832776129,
-0.005639473,
0.0215812232,
-0.0717876256,
-0.0020324704,
-0.023836568,
0.0260513891,
0.0210139938,
-0.0630243644,
0.0545515493,
0.0243743174,
-0.0448084548,
0.0015008012,
0.069060795,
0.034492936,
0.0462867171,
0.0043504802,
0.0342851356,
-0.0685267225,
-0.0354318172,
0.0118426122,
0.0066596866,
-0.0111921085,
0.067439504,
-0.0489874519,
-0.0683352575,
0.0092346584,
0.0185519997,
0.016275065,
-0.0321297534,
0.0452556536,
0.0764544234,
0.0125595946,
-0.0129779475,
-0.0547552034,
0.0054420014,
-0.0216509998,
0.0192818753,
-0.0195996147,
-6.158684166e-33,
-0.0536976047,
-0.028074028,
0.0451000743,
-0.000005708,
-0.002142105,
0.0018327738,
-0.0173195079,
0.0128265787,
-0.0097178845,
-0.001119049,
0.02386209,
-0.0157271232,
-0.0022675726,
0.0361287333,
0.0112373438,
-0.01531923,
0.0338015817,
0.021722734,
-0.0065070386,
0.01262266,
0.0714242831,
0.0008148297,
0.0288508646,
0.0010846741,
0.0300306808,
-0.0228564907,
-0.0009965379,
0.0426865444,
-0.0109416535,
0.02475168,
-0.0317524746,
0.0436154231,
0.0398075022,
0.0061863433,
-0.0158573203,
-0.0099144867,
-0.0508840345,
-0.0112900138,
0.0663614199,
0.0094869426,
-0.0496891513,
-0.0198395252,
0.0702710673,
-0.0250346158,
0.004092867,
-0.0060370113,
0.0058255293,
-0.0276096929,
-0.0447075628,
-0.0487920865,
-0.0765050352,
0.0307534542,
0.0303873271,
-0.0002388263,
-0.0047511542,
0.0336992629,
-0.0202806797,
-0.0242549144,
0.0058373287,
0.0111402292,
0.0283670034,
0.0368586928,
0.0500814058,
0.00852051,
0.02254772,
0.0758714676,
-0.0082374271,
-0.019990176,
0.0003575872,
-0.0004524163,
0.0383436717,
0.0655155107,
-0.0047718449,
0.0327310674,
0.0278455131,
0.0481465906,
-0.0734691322,
0.0002315119,
0.0082134977,
0.0555245578,
0.0390508808,
0.0069538918,
-0.0032748159,
-0.0164706651,
-0.0604575239,
0.035320241,
-0.0108180502,
-0.0154887326,
0.0392512567,
0.0113238702,
0.0074083544,
-0.0345789492,
0.0207648501,
-0.0637923926,
-0.0344038978,
0.025836708,
-0.0144018997,
-0.0379802063,
-0.0013995297,
0.044353351,
-0.0450329781,
-0.0755800903,
-0.0337170213,
-0.0202548802,
-0.0123453597,
0.0272419043,
0.025744481,
-0.0083051277,
-0.0091895293,
0.0014796009,
-0.0408869684,
-0.0182270631,
-0.0191609021,
0.0098860338,
0.0626073927,
0.0035426768,
-0.015004497,
0.0314081572,
0.0065967739,
-0.0203609597,
-0.0237846132,
0.0387615897,
-0.003710492,
0.0378770903,
-0.070865266,
-0.0381054655,
-0.0503780693,
-0.0007856729,
0.0547099188,
-0.0490498319,
0.004845873,
-0.0306891538,
2.613e-7,
0.0151077313,
0.0408935919,
0.0104352767,
0.0296029225,
0.0164723527,
0.0219631176,
-0.0233577695,
0.0327602178,
0.0040560644,
0.0032311548,
0.005551503,
0.0195364729,
0.0295155849,
0.026454635,
-0.0594559759,
0.0368448533,
-0.0530386157,
0.0078844624,
-0.040101096,
0.0112967445,
0.0819879472,
0.0998501033,
0.0149542,
-0.0055334275,
0.0378611013,
-0.0850896463,
0.0834075063,
-0.0170074515,
-0.0216505919,
0.015854381,
0.0125206877,
0.0488566719,
0.0187158063,
0.0318136699,
0.0425203703,
0.038796667,
-0.0155916056,
0.0734949484,
0.0201352239,
-0.0030594137,
-0.014028023,
-0.0262238011,
-0.0195282176,
-0.0702651739,
0.0859263092,
-0.1094341651,
-0.0633463711,
-0.048054114,
-0.0072786668,
-0.0049954141,
-0.0026551443,
-0.00055308,
-0.0248303059,
-0.0055644475,
0.0113207251,
-0.0204389393,
0.0020929547,
-0.0406745709,
-0.0062987101,
0.0393628776,
-0.0434939079,
-0.0625586659,
-0.0139287664,
0.0220677312,
0.0224976186,
-0.0342937298,
-0.006986083,
2.365407334e-34,
0.0516591556,
-0.0280415323,
0.0301931743,
-0.0003271936,
0.031810604,
-0.0149317505,
-0.0314296968,
0.0469670109,
0.0158782993,
-0.0559275635,
0.0141307227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12205v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12205v1 | Investigating Pre-trained Language Models on Cross-Domain Datasets, a Step Closer to General AI | 2023-06-21T11:55:17 | 2023-06-21T11:55:17 | Mohamad Ballout, Ulf Krumnack, Gunther Heidemann, Kai-Uwe Kühnberger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained language models have recently emerged as a powerful tool for
fine-tuning a variety of language tasks. Ideally, when models are pre-trained
on large amount of data, they are expected to gain implicit knowledge. In this
paper, we investigate the ability of pre-trained language models to generalize
to different non-language tasks. In particular, we test them on tasks from
different domains such as computer vision, reasoning on hierarchical data, and
protein fold prediction. The four pre-trained models that we used, T5, BART,
BERT, and GPT-2 achieve outstanding results. They all have similar performance
and they outperform transformers that are trained from scratch by a large
margin. For instance, pre-trained language models perform better on the Listops
dataset, with an average accuracy of 58.7\%, compared to transformers trained
from scratch, which have an average accuracy of 29.0\%. The significant
improvement demonstrated across three types of datasets suggests that
pre-training on language helps the models to acquire general knowledge,
bringing us a step closer to general AI. We also showed that reducing the
number of parameters in pre-trained language models does not have a great
impact as the performance drops slightly when using T5-Small instead of
T5-Base. In fact, when using only 2\% of the parameters, we achieved a great
improvement compared to training from scratch. Finally, in contrast to prior
work, we find out that using pre-trained embeddings for the input layer is
necessary to achieve the desired results. | [
0.0249763913,
0.0403786153,
-0.0096495869,
0.0241565183,
0.0228953566,
0.0204423666,
0.0245857108,
-0.0043795402,
0.0257916804,
-0.0690392852,
-0.0843174607,
-0.0240985397,
-0.0104285441,
0.0466123521,
0.0243347976,
-0.0620372705,
0.026891984,
-0.0153977629,
-0.0017668615,
-0.017792182,
-0.0062714312,
0.0080196587,
0.0057429201,
0.0493934639,
0.0129535301,
0.0027002306,
-0.0203336719,
-0.0107025541,
0.0127696525,
0.0098967953,
0.0193736665,
0.0545949601,
0.0704732314,
0.0352567509,
0.0000021114,
-0.0185794365,
-0.0013365006,
0.0002564599,
-0.0204525832,
0.0106842192,
0.0005605172,
-0.0290553886,
0.0031822501,
0.007662558,
-0.050151635,
-0.0797923356,
0.0665448755,
0.0672718883,
0.0586109348,
0.0779851824,
-0.0195198543,
-0.0681324378,
0.041496478,
-0.0145623637,
0.0095545016,
-0.0281768031,
0.0245063361,
-0.0070331688,
0.0034645821,
-0.0155957714,
-0.0224142596,
0.0082226684,
0.0223077424,
0.0196645856,
-0.0277181324,
0.0446240604,
-0.0358023606,
-0.0335614048,
-0.0032335571,
0.0899681374,
-0.0691788271,
-0.0235668495,
-0.0329549499,
-0.0125460392,
-0.0248039272,
0.0079839481,
-0.0172106996,
0.0053284429,
0.0243739113,
0.0231370889,
-0.0039185034,
0.0010045001,
0.0363413654,
0.0008966422,
-0.0501863956,
0.0651954785,
0.017978061,
-0.0197325163,
0.0101813888,
0.0093388977,
-0.0050327452,
-0.0500311702,
-0.003215896,
0.0464398302,
0.0222105309,
0.0242317058,
-0.0456968471,
-0.0328907445,
0.0000754498,
-0.0349355452,
0.0563264415,
0.0339183137,
-0.0419003889,
0.0317735299,
-0.0470141917,
0.0750205889,
-0.0264955275,
0.0559078716,
-0.027670633,
-0.0141035393,
-0.0456672199,
-0.0057881833,
-0.0596222878,
0.0300183855,
0.0111042028,
-0.0220021978,
-0.0202405695,
0.0172330253,
0.0253171567,
-0.0191207416,
0.0274002422,
-0.0067936727,
-0.0445569865,
-0.0371532775,
-0.0321140252,
0.0094055729,
-0.0172654111,
0.0272070803,
-0.0199769568,
-0.0732446611,
-0.006046541,
-0.0121693006,
0.0173916295,
-0.017657429,
0.025853971,
0.0935333446,
-0.0009103044,
-0.0446591005,
-0.0270700213,
0.0208547302,
-0.0007107051,
-0.0756484047,
0.0276087504,
-0.0378910862,
0.026923826,
0.0194978081,
0.0035996886,
-0.0219226182,
-0.0003448103,
0.0030016454,
-0.0372707993,
0.1036199704,
-0.0239450578,
-0.0060266708,
0.0179257896,
0.0076693147,
-0.004560987,
0.0567427613,
0.0257449616,
0.0239827372,
0.0056749997,
-0.0260516852,
0.017842643,
0.0420454815,
0.0263544861,
-0.003848891,
-0.0048320661,
0.0204833262,
-0.0217455439,
0.0186177455,
0.0083984006,
0.0121135982,
-0.0220445395,
-0.0086833872,
0.0608462319,
0.0589418001,
0.0326626301,
0.0584150068,
0.0720943809,
0.005168559,
0.0407149196,
-0.0024919091,
-0.0586589612,
0.0051626833,
-0.0091385469,
0.0152239483,
-0.0205807369,
0.0129862167,
-0.0548359938,
-0.0310974829,
-0.0109065026,
-0.0236050021,
0.0159134641,
-0.0003958173,
0.0630999133,
0.023950262,
-0.0442451537,
0.0627875924,
0.0238632225,
-0.0468468964,
-0.0007220312,
-0.0417984277,
0.0112644276,
0.0287966467,
0.0228485242,
-0.045485843,
-0.0459424667,
0.0118271001,
0.0130943917,
0.0357801728,
0.0790027827,
-0.0035461094,
0.0054782615,
-0.0503140986,
-0.0389733315,
-0.00255531,
0.015594027,
0.0338925086,
0.0109211635,
0.0210625529,
0.0290201716,
-0.0534637459,
-0.004483276,
0.0524016395,
-0.045176249,
-0.0030480847,
-0.0114789391,
0.0285768118,
0.02909353,
-0.0074126632,
-0.0112360539,
0.0100663407,
0.0267398395,
-0.0234414898,
-0.0188177805,
0.0030528796,
-0.0387924686,
-0.0224620253,
0.0526771583,
-0.0339719877,
0.0020224776,
0.0524545498,
-0.0335812755,
-0.0128796566,
0.0174110066,
-0.009280785,
0.0766819865,
-0.0497717112,
0.0090832543,
-0.0260237083,
0.022237068,
-0.0081011476,
0.050717108,
0.0254344903,
-0.001871252,
-0.0129977139,
-0.0058596991,
0.0358186401,
-0.0038641521,
-0.0302348677,
-0.0088731367,
0.0086120181,
0.0180770978,
0.0166949909,
0.0049581048,
-0.0226209909,
0.0034045787,
-0.0918071792,
-0.0088375406,
-0.0258249491,
-0.0073991977,
-0.0029709295,
0.0046612998,
-0.0045883455,
-0.0285569523,
-0.0512295179,
0.0179679338,
-0.0281456485,
0.0152776306,
0.0272327513,
0.0220915023,
-0.0054024411,
-0.0323645212,
-0.0114111146,
-0.0251588039,
0.0464587547,
-0.0062026829,
-0.0074960957,
-0.0269217361,
0.0473525524,
-0.0350191779,
0.0647099018,
-0.0077788807,
-0.0810897648,
0.0032347282,
-0.0359826833,
0.0419085324,
0.0466091409,
0.0011338491,
0.0108329505,
0.0474689081,
0.0161201432,
-0.036596477,
0.0106754024,
-0.0501066223,
-0.0163478423,
-0.0650410801,
0.020954106,
-0.01817628,
0.0895320177,
-0.0218842775,
-0.0148897721,
-0.0927817225,
0.0063352464,
0.005047923,
-0.0020883419,
-0.0093295984,
0.0028821463,
-0.0050831544,
0.0445263162,
-0.0198297948,
-0.0561031774,
0.0811297521,
-0.0338848718,
-0.015255345,
-0.0275079235,
0.0102257915,
-0.0313512683,
0.057905376,
0.0388475657,
0.0349714756,
0.011710831,
-0.0225794092,
-0.071228005,
0.0367350467,
0.0005135795,
-0.0379619002,
0.0359380804,
-0.0033243785,
0.0024685129,
-0.0055302391,
-0.0380736776,
-0.0572703592,
-0.006110521,
-0.0458739474,
0.0265902877,
0.0030110222,
-0.052875828,
-0.0526516885,
0.0136315515,
0.0089624058,
0.0739814639,
0.0083829192,
0.0076114191,
-0.0121290842,
-0.0013414116,
0.0392399393,
-0.0088547776,
0.0170472097,
-0.0314249098,
0.0126973568,
-0.0110337324,
0.0291772373,
-0.040666189,
-0.0626605377,
0.0218584985,
0.0295035858,
-0.0280896891,
-0.0284728203,
0.0252138413,
0.0121853873,
-0.0415365957,
0.0030147906,
0.1216183603,
0.0117156291,
-0.0594639145,
-0.0097403824,
0.0110729123,
-0.0110845892,
0.0265160799,
0.0332794152,
-0.0755473003,
-0.0404563174,
-0.0129910745,
-0.0271789841,
0.0364865996,
-0.0271626357,
-0.0063304375,
-0.1212691888,
0.0231054183,
0.0026953118,
-0.0250217635,
-0.0487664863,
-0.0284797903,
-0.0041452092,
-0.0149749126,
0.0060770954,
-0.0271343514,
-0.0225294083,
-0.0175575335,
0.0134761194,
-0.0270260572,
-0.0764050335,
0.0549382307,
-0.0516955703,
0.0240372848,
0.0815112665,
0.0328653827,
-0.0209690575,
-0.038329713,
0.022565145,
-0.0040686135,
0.0017914795,
0.0147413397,
0.0715469122,
-0.0171656236,
-0.022178106,
0.0192010719,
0.0165116973,
-0.0335806161,
-0.0052242312,
-0.0588147528,
0.1132484302,
-0.0237041283,
-0.0539202057,
-0.003646116,
-0.0161571242,
-0.0297103208,
0.0743153393,
0.0323620476,
-0.045262564,
-0.0250682328,
-0.0153455539,
0.014347869,
-0.0207523983,
-0.0567390434,
0.0289414059,
-0.0247480683,
-0.0575825423,
-0.0587074496,
-0.0371682681,
0.0515490435,
0.0211482793,
0.0143979099,
-0.0248628948,
0.0339186788,
0.0245731156,
-0.0486501008,
0.0357085131,
-0.0056338459,
0.0032570828,
-0.049305927,
-0.0373389088,
0.0419693664,
-0.0397157632,
-0.0356932096,
-0.0100523364,
-0.0454192124,
-0.060335353,
-0.0008321,
0.0764711276,
0.0213120431,
0.0419538654,
-0.0322355777,
-0.0437927134,
0.0833058581,
0.012903532,
-0.0301012453,
-0.0453003049,
0.0571081005,
-0.0518740714,
0.0021014556,
0.0423503555,
-0.063660495,
0.0371399038,
0.0272897426,
-0.0040402221,
-0.0169222876,
-0.0217536502,
0.0379026644,
-0.0038734328,
0.071670115,
-0.0186359435,
0.0031803467,
-0.0348269939,
0.0144108385,
-0.0154198557,
-0.004467234,
-0.0557597168,
-0.0016533358,
0.0332012177,
0.0067116511,
0.0034880659,
0.0148701081,
-0.0298995338,
0.0221508574,
-0.004672592,
0.0375044197,
0.03827364,
0.0487499237,
0.0655544922,
0.0107109072,
-0.0079655917,
-0.0001760899,
-0.0040604654,
0.0088246251,
-0.0266150814,
0.0147130247,
0.0245508365,
0.0318172649,
-0.0438343994,
0.0399488918,
-0.0662318692,
-0.0704334304,
-0.0510875434,
-0.0080257738,
0.0405780151,
-0.0251185335,
0.0089460611,
-0.0365788601,
-0.0038844065,
-0.0115370862,
0.0253292192,
0.0114379609,
-0.0206092037,
0.0628676042,
0.0058876262,
-0.0313693769,
-0.0106397308,
0.0935532153,
0.0405771099,
0.0797599778,
-0.0135024833,
0.006968386,
-0.0241565518,
-0.0083666733,
0.0344771706,
-0.0022907343,
-0.0389719084,
0.0215001665,
-0.0284616146,
-0.0908443853,
0.0095465798,
-0.0260026194,
-0.0113876443,
0.0233482905,
0.041449599,
0.0596795939,
0.0051985607,
0.0049153185,
-0.0206763763,
0.0004656622,
-0.0051207705,
-0.019564392,
-0.0131273828,
-6.158273477e-33,
-0.0123007065,
0.0086687459,
0.0233053248,
0.0132253291,
0.0013570869,
0.022764843,
-0.0408896804,
-0.0061598127,
-0.0485955924,
0.0459787324,
-0.0127335871,
-0.0010068333,
0.0116324928,
0.0063930415,
-0.0234837402,
-0.0362632535,
0.0349124297,
-0.0355185941,
-0.0023613074,
-0.001669529,
-0.001753756,
0.0477910154,
0.095703423,
-0.0465680584,
-0.0247169007,
-0.0126035782,
-0.0092997355,
0.0160803311,
0.0195218399,
0.0512266085,
-0.0277875941,
0.0090057813,
0.0138264801,
-0.0269868802,
-0.0386249013,
0.0341306999,
-0.0736577287,
-0.0121360542,
-0.0115015395,
0.0374033041,
-0.0291666035,
-0.0029403872,
0.024588082,
-0.0179412588,
-0.0193588752,
-0.0146312611,
0.0532488823,
-0.0433158129,
0.0050126878,
-0.0374749862,
-0.0666565821,
0.009284311,
0.011451208,
-0.0283864196,
0.0707913414,
0.0640899763,
0.0092729786,
0.0462969206,
-0.0381858982,
0.0504381359,
0.0315088555,
0.0149649885,
0.0528274365,
-0.004012052,
0.0199385937,
0.0597619526,
0.0092232032,
-0.0233879108,
-0.0211106595,
-0.0313300788,
0.0640251711,
0.0510460287,
0.0176576544,
0.0115695456,
0.0349280313,
-0.0089787589,
-0.0739190131,
0.0249066819,
-0.0153605072,
0.0266979355,
-0.0018694344,
0.0008904164,
-0.0229720995,
0.0087673133,
-0.0372989774,
-0.0233027581,
-0.0324003845,
-0.061267633,
0.0079199169,
0.0184948053,
0.0039037359,
0.0014900083,
0.0403106026,
-0.0641425699,
-0.0013587241,
0.0180152562,
-0.0097870138,
0.0024300104,
-0.0063678171,
0.0361330882,
-0.0520463325,
-0.0557387099,
0.0246566478,
-0.0027481343,
0.0157344043,
0.015856361,
0.0460763052,
0.0653491467,
-0.0489457957,
-0.0166948047,
-0.0307715517,
-0.0422535948,
0.0404896885,
0.0809168071,
0.0240641348,
0.0211488251,
-0.0158183333,
0.0437685438,
-0.0071819085,
-0.0041591921,
-0.0186488349,
0.0172361601,
0.0348392352,
0.0394261368,
-0.0387859754,
-0.0517370328,
-0.0559371524,
-0.0012407085,
0.0315874517,
-0.057140056,
-0.0247224066,
0.0148461619,
2.77e-7,
0.0593020469,
0.0489012524,
0.0165229719,
0.0253264569,
0.0084713204,
0.0463006906,
-0.0055961548,
0.0236301236,
-0.0154576488,
0.0024771001,
0.0256808028,
0.0183236338,
0.0408502594,
0.0095424764,
-0.095609501,
-0.0329517573,
-0.0471661463,
-0.0083094593,
-0.0322817378,
-0.013769649,
-0.0015018607,
0.1569325626,
0.0110475915,
-0.0091445446,
0.0130693363,
-0.02772386,
0.0781000257,
-0.0356872678,
-0.0004478471,
0.0326147713,
-0.0360715389,
0.0475497469,
-0.023809595,
0.017139066,
-0.0464780368,
0.0267944522,
0.0436142161,
0.0488199517,
-0.0266988408,
-0.0166188218,
0.0204933994,
-0.0091754505,
-0.0151860341,
-0.0421391241,
0.05603588,
-0.0739639476,
-0.033366818,
-0.0001070288,
-0.0254670829,
-0.0052745272,
0.0003434437,
-0.0295698103,
0.0003331993,
0.0278571323,
0.0241687056,
-0.0333885886,
0.0103088282,
-0.1004390866,
-0.0197593831,
0.013945817,
-0.0323495045,
-0.0029955478,
-0.0357056037,
-0.0451282784,
0.0913123786,
-0.0416968465,
0.0232868847,
2.574827851e-34,
0.0239724498,
-0.0150413569,
0.000551336,
0.0276617538,
0.0175206084,
-0.0331455693,
0.0242344178,
-0.0043766727,
0.0243545007,
-0.0639243722,
-0.0169363376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12198v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12198v1 | Opening the Black Box: Analyzing Attention Weights and Hidden States in Pre-trained Language Models for Non-language Tasks | 2023-06-21T11:48:07 | 2023-06-21T11:48:07 | Mohamad Ballout, Ulf Krumnack, Gunther Heidemann, Kai-Uwe Kühnberger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Investigating deep learning language models has always been a significant
research area due to the ``black box" nature of most advanced models. With the
recent advancements in pre-trained language models based on transformers and
their increasing integration into daily life, addressing this issue has become
more pressing. In order to achieve an explainable AI model, it is essential to
comprehend the procedural steps involved and compare them with human thought
processes. Thus, in this paper, we use simple, well-understood non-language
tasks to explore these models' inner workings. Specifically, we apply a
pre-trained language model to constrained arithmetic problems with hierarchical
structure, to analyze their attention weight scores and hidden states. The
investigation reveals promising results, with the model addressing hierarchical
problems in a moderately structured manner, similar to human problem-solving
strategies. Additionally, by inspecting the attention weights layer by layer,
we uncover an unconventional finding that layer 10, rather than the model's
final layer, is the optimal layer to unfreeze for the least parameter-intensive
approach to fine-tune the model. We support these findings with entropy
analysis and token embeddings similarity analysis. The attention analysis
allows us to hypothesize that the model can generalize to longer sequences in
ListOps dataset, a conclusion later confirmed through testing on sequences
longer than those in the training set. Lastly, by utilizing a straightforward
task in which the model predicts the winner of a Tic Tac Toe game, we identify
limitations in attention analysis, particularly its inability to capture 2D
patterns. | [
-0.0125359567,
0.0917608291,
-0.0246348958,
0.0412732363,
-0.0123256557,
0.0187019017,
0.0066225966,
-0.0044760085,
-0.0611399971,
-0.0367963128,
-0.0417169034,
-0.0527646691,
0.0122452257,
0.0351621322,
0.0313145742,
-0.052829098,
0.0082618408,
-0.0534710027,
0.0029975406,
0.0147189749,
-0.0318277851,
-0.028790649,
-0.0163351726,
0.0499612391,
-0.0119424313,
-0.0189833287,
-0.0346530415,
-0.0348531865,
-0.0089107323,
-0.0165611263,
-0.021498343,
0.0542794652,
0.0382895917,
0.0377592482,
0.000002352,
-0.0450800657,
0.005373315,
-0.0142088216,
-0.0372515321,
-0.0018280526,
-0.000707574,
0.001174994,
0.008282464,
-0.0002212472,
-0.0358047001,
-0.0184149966,
0.0661938041,
0.0467630811,
0.0492769033,
0.0499824435,
-0.00532339,
-0.0235418398,
0.012697624,
-0.0379507765,
0.0257529989,
-0.0504678115,
0.0161122549,
-0.0337394401,
-0.0182670206,
-0.0450852327,
-0.0349406451,
-0.0047592889,
0.0576356798,
0.009125662,
-0.0162926372,
0.006532378,
-0.0070608426,
-0.0065088607,
-0.0145503981,
0.0921099335,
-0.1032705531,
-0.0302040763,
0.0305442531,
-0.0147066638,
0.0054997536,
-0.0343109667,
-0.0510362387,
0.0413029902,
0.0411459543,
0.0090399915,
0.0167276505,
0.0293062758,
0.0219332073,
-0.0085765664,
-0.0377860926,
0.0668573454,
-0.0115377726,
-0.0329722539,
-0.0136362528,
-0.0029066652,
-0.0306847412,
-0.083926715,
0.0325499475,
0.065228723,
-0.0179751776,
0.012803873,
-0.0161380097,
-0.0459548011,
-0.0426553264,
-0.023557812,
0.0612877607,
0.0644662306,
-0.0080808979,
0.0209271424,
0.0016912608,
0.0814729035,
-0.0200422052,
0.0516704507,
-0.0526986755,
0.034431044,
0.0099513913,
-0.0063651479,
-0.0493215546,
0.0318273678,
0.0021601925,
-0.0128525682,
-0.0120893847,
0.0072288048,
-0.0147390729,
0.0031425101,
0.0121433213,
0.0172148012,
0.0047403644,
-0.0226980709,
-0.0364174955,
0.0061153094,
-0.0421846919,
0.0101615088,
0.0216454286,
-0.0364087038,
-0.0339057781,
0.0180912092,
0.002139108,
-0.010784938,
0.0083189597,
0.0830177218,
0.0225080792,
-0.0186323076,
0.0159146935,
-0.0020555097,
0.0134763038,
-0.0751560777,
0.0522228293,
-0.0380797535,
0.0019995293,
-0.0144447116,
-0.00851072,
-0.0290354937,
0.0174805932,
0.0228288379,
0.0040973038,
0.0640121698,
0.0442480631,
-0.0253071133,
-0.0194723997,
0.0006202792,
0.0085350918,
0.0472385734,
0.0655626655,
0.0166395381,
-0.0157822371,
-0.0553207211,
0.0290626176,
0.0350045301,
0.0169378351,
-0.0261742212,
-0.0424209982,
-0.0043254797,
-0.0386304967,
0.0307137426,
0.0274622459,
0.0329469889,
-0.0024008013,
-0.0184001978,
0.0387481712,
0.0777590573,
0.0010351191,
0.0600364394,
0.0508925468,
-0.0266789496,
-0.001439942,
0.0430519879,
-0.0803600177,
0.0330519676,
0.0144707626,
-0.0115547907,
0.0009568857,
-0.0088026421,
-0.030032536,
-0.0807161406,
-0.0046963007,
-0.0117752505,
0.031456776,
0.0167960953,
0.0521608591,
0.0001839532,
-0.0557465516,
0.0801279396,
-0.0053105997,
-0.036324013,
-0.0075999857,
-0.0614317395,
0.007500669,
0.0380242206,
0.0278073344,
-0.0713399872,
-0.0011014134,
-0.0148509536,
-0.0097298101,
0.0045430674,
0.0069046505,
0.0292685498,
0.0105039999,
-0.0355283022,
-0.0241688155,
-0.0337397344,
0.0388621874,
0.0062305396,
-0.0410340466,
-0.0306087174,
0.0219182111,
-0.0229872391,
-0.0327743143,
0.0272088852,
0.0052935523,
-0.0456836075,
0.0210397542,
0.0234449059,
0.0228673425,
0.0091215717,
0.0225489791,
0.0583639555,
0.0394410454,
-0.0413674898,
0.0036967027,
-0.030889634,
-0.0801528171,
0.0156060122,
0.0316333696,
-0.0496321656,
0.0078258887,
0.0796598941,
-0.0257997606,
-0.0282883197,
0.0520515442,
-0.0722933784,
0.0614422709,
0.0071425294,
0.0197245851,
-0.0030362215,
0.0329088606,
-0.0272101965,
0.0781583861,
-0.0260023978,
0.033276584,
-0.0203638263,
-0.0233367272,
0.0125113344,
-0.022437444,
0.0161593314,
-0.0255108159,
-0.0383640602,
-0.0015249817,
0.0077602882,
-0.0104652094,
-0.0150565775,
0.0010710312,
-0.0294911042,
-0.0053554256,
-0.0410538539,
0.0279076565,
0.0013361935,
-0.025709141,
0.0068363911,
-0.019929532,
-0.0413283184,
0.030614445,
-0.0044346121,
-0.0001940129,
0.0581692271,
-0.0109065017,
-0.009353376,
-0.048479639,
-0.0486445315,
-0.0315642282,
0.0731411353,
0.0027778461,
0.0374576636,
-0.0304671898,
0.048053138,
-0.0106716435,
0.0405180268,
-0.0196259711,
-0.0280964747,
0.014816287,
-0.0220795628,
0.057370238,
0.0818547532,
-0.0068748859,
0.0665714219,
0.0486712903,
-0.0140868835,
-0.0147399735,
0.0263393316,
-0.0306234658,
0.0217778925,
-0.0235622469,
-0.0226909909,
0.0023637535,
0.1520024687,
-0.0374736488,
-0.0157397632,
-0.0457581989,
0.0065746163,
0.0233411416,
-0.004862091,
-0.0192290749,
-0.0042155106,
-0.0237184521,
0.0416941866,
-0.0177366734,
-0.0249605998,
0.0591292754,
-0.0087388763,
-0.0170159154,
-0.0240204446,
0.0182652902,
-0.0355245657,
0.0724804625,
0.0718898475,
-0.0142553719,
0.0027505665,
-0.0304201338,
-0.0406852253,
0.0189745314,
-0.0060934639,
-0.0223268792,
0.0648884401,
0.0052088732,
-0.0185835063,
-0.0202836655,
-0.0278978571,
-0.0462157689,
0.0235161074,
-0.0412899591,
0.034606602,
0.0472977087,
-0.0347056277,
-0.0661567599,
0.0144524453,
0.0544058606,
0.0522416458,
0.0060736197,
-0.0013649368,
-0.0277565774,
0.0354899652,
0.0664090887,
0.0398018435,
0.0446181335,
-0.044588279,
0.0098907454,
0.008576015,
0.064351283,
0.0222943984,
-0.024866458,
0.0184370279,
0.0328421108,
-0.0382372364,
-0.0166792944,
0.0710063875,
0.000911522,
-0.06359905,
-0.0186811313,
0.0993882939,
0.0391282625,
-0.0556583293,
0.0411364213,
-0.0306108501,
0.0033639399,
0.0276891813,
0.0168147795,
-0.063589707,
-0.0347430781,
0.0142898159,
-0.028624244,
0.0139715308,
-0.0612827875,
0.0101242801,
-0.1022733673,
-0.0021068896,
-0.021226611,
-0.0522676781,
-0.0322951637,
-0.0293395706,
-0.0173711609,
0.0016050299,
-0.0070812451,
-0.0097169373,
-0.0001931357,
-0.006325481,
0.0293773971,
-0.0459530205,
0.0036659793,
0.0496476814,
-0.0279204119,
0.0088957874,
0.0788865611,
0.0153949065,
-0.0449261144,
-0.0671454147,
0.0303656515,
0.0184283983,
-0.0190710369,
0.0252347272,
0.0132949799,
0.0044476287,
-0.0217758045,
-0.0019212645,
0.0238243602,
-0.0633449778,
-0.0043585813,
-0.0180659164,
0.1027449593,
-0.0120997503,
-0.0378495753,
0.0034398646,
-0.0222901311,
0.0079291677,
0.0625810698,
0.0590603687,
-0.0484968796,
-0.0621235073,
-0.0358608104,
0.0266026072,
-0.0755884349,
-0.0480718613,
0.012889863,
0.0725600943,
-0.0481310599,
-0.0365185887,
-0.0284109637,
0.0098541211,
0.0154261757,
-0.0104982797,
-0.0447199121,
0.0455152951,
-0.0139157046,
-0.0494171269,
0.0434861779,
-0.00663161,
0.0199984945,
-0.0535140745,
-0.0210368298,
-0.0053524235,
-0.0240647346,
-0.0319147483,
-0.0008206251,
-0.0991759747,
0.0041868053,
0.014383343,
0.0693021268,
0.0177724455,
-0.0275225788,
-0.000314784,
-0.0314403586,
0.0099015683,
-0.0096794767,
-0.0458473377,
-0.0188311711,
0.0228575747,
-0.0357115902,
0.0139585389,
0.0198569372,
-0.0240206327,
0.0332207978,
0.0442580171,
0.0266295746,
-0.0446251594,
-0.0358650312,
0.0350983962,
-0.0297652259,
0.0641717687,
0.0235807225,
-0.017733153,
0.0022790965,
0.0341860317,
-0.0089551043,
0.0173009969,
-0.0687502399,
-0.0373104885,
0.0082203196,
0.0094205989,
0.0386618599,
-0.0159355942,
0.0001826471,
0.0005063431,
0.0124866394,
0.0729842708,
0.0039391108,
0.0444270298,
0.0185240712,
-0.0007579289,
0.0140514094,
0.0187101346,
-0.0132322991,
0.0462458767,
0.0157462135,
0.0291089322,
0.0119156335,
0.0335133709,
-0.0188717861,
0.0164436679,
-0.0262207203,
-0.0368818752,
-0.015981596,
-0.0354870856,
0.0575001054,
-0.0331429057,
-0.036655996,
-0.0021873161,
0.0331421904,
-0.0070240628,
0.0136968903,
-0.0016575942,
-0.035306938,
-0.0053326562,
0.0374990217,
0.0140066454,
-0.0273373183,
0.0672258735,
0.0507682636,
0.0213176087,
0.0081528546,
0.0117213987,
-0.0249783248,
-0.0241948403,
0.0211231634,
0.0429472737,
-0.0326639861,
0.0175200067,
-0.0393500775,
-0.0795808136,
-0.013995396,
-0.0052607576,
0.0075419531,
-0.00715324,
0.0718070418,
0.0401746854,
-0.0481960401,
-0.0092563787,
-0.0162774902,
0.0223787148,
-0.0135422898,
-0.0390205234,
-0.0350724682,
-6.40148583e-33,
-0.0053820852,
-0.0746385753,
0.0298895817,
0.0039377371,
0.0005595206,
0.012436796,
-0.0725400746,
0.016412694,
-0.0113954209,
-0.0086782025,
-0.0145475976,
0.0005687092,
0.0002217919,
0.0427725762,
0.004713085,
-0.052892305,
0.0014061084,
-0.0166396685,
-0.0101241386,
-0.0006029376,
-0.0154937431,
0.011803031,
0.0733587444,
-0.0138230333,
-0.0026696327,
-0.0047212313,
0.0027119955,
0.0156216314,
-0.0168265812,
0.0397205912,
-0.0423101224,
0.0092082769,
0.0197585505,
-0.0668481514,
-0.0283739027,
0.0386315212,
-0.0479199775,
-0.047233168,
-0.0050667529,
0.0249684062,
-0.0439661667,
-0.0408145674,
0.0740310997,
0.0279987436,
-0.0100078704,
-0.0193059519,
0.0408811979,
-0.0125578893,
-0.0000721051,
-0.0195467435,
-0.0483857244,
0.0031500792,
-0.043003343,
-0.0337829627,
0.0308704711,
0.0469421893,
-0.0151318172,
-0.0029379625,
-0.0712824315,
0.0336094573,
0.0632783249,
0.0438695364,
0.050053753,
0.0193094648,
0.0220470726,
0.0141567644,
0.0376659781,
-0.0048038587,
-0.0795334056,
-0.0273403022,
0.0536858924,
0.0343430042,
0.0671330094,
-0.0612794831,
0.0871432945,
0.026454566,
-0.0790433884,
-0.0048202947,
-0.0074936608,
0.0537408665,
0.0064719249,
-0.0121567296,
-0.0329447836,
0.0066289213,
-0.0213458575,
0.0042155646,
-0.0518036224,
-0.0226692203,
0.0068139858,
-0.0136772618,
0.0117059937,
0.0123416325,
0.0305731669,
-0.0302098431,
0.0305484366,
-0.0005322091,
0.0450516008,
0.0355579592,
0.0108308457,
0.0014593318,
-0.0528020449,
-0.0387311876,
-0.0145835504,
0.0040788758,
0.0378588922,
0.0257962402,
0.0086023305,
0.0268804953,
-0.0304656848,
-0.0290977247,
-0.0298388675,
-0.0156306643,
0.0196648706,
0.0434584767,
0.0373860672,
-0.0137048978,
-0.0080746599,
0.0357436202,
-0.0219842866,
-0.0276639033,
-0.0123770852,
0.0683443919,
-0.0075498675,
0.0414348319,
-0.0046320888,
-0.0606820472,
-0.0765164718,
0.0261066165,
0.0237240847,
-0.0409921072,
-0.0178854689,
-0.0167608,
3.022e-7,
0.0331363045,
0.053498745,
0.0136744408,
-0.003669587,
0.0280461665,
0.0402226076,
0.0094697271,
0.0151190925,
-0.0313376822,
-0.028367769,
0.0432646386,
0.030403737,
0.0315693989,
0.0010106703,
-0.0636095181,
-0.0493216813,
-0.0578899868,
0.0111273797,
-0.015700981,
0.0225807484,
0.0082931127,
0.1154834405,
0.0149524249,
0.0095795216,
-0.0011861705,
-0.0137158604,
0.0200429894,
-0.0111990077,
0.0475496352,
0.0008661853,
0.0089918794,
-0.028979674,
-0.0459936298,
0.0040418687,
-0.0174635965,
0.0291184541,
0.0411926061,
0.0583007857,
-0.021073712,
-0.0122400504,
-0.0243137348,
-0.0155033991,
-0.007168856,
-0.0599527396,
0.0507890731,
-0.070275858,
-0.0452132784,
-0.0005219445,
0.0111061763,
-0.0000328929,
0.0004223063,
0.0237729624,
0.0153058441,
-0.0149331754,
0.0125794839,
-0.0298202969,
0.0189698227,
-0.0662074313,
-0.0277409237,
0.0062182383,
-0.0530815497,
0.0246990398,
-0.088214308,
-0.0414903499,
0.0631562024,
-0.015475844,
-0.0082649663,
2.93775163e-34,
0.0246177167,
-0.0094371829,
0.0198042355,
0.0167865772,
0.0348393321,
-0.0219889544,
-0.023710316,
0.0372634381,
0.0579127297,
-0.0690729618,
-0.0221397467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12181v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12181v1 | Feature Interactions Reveal Linguistic Structure in Language Models | 2023-06-21T11:24:41 | 2023-06-21T11:24:41 | Jaap Jumelet, Willem Zuidema | cs.CL | cs.CL | We study feature interactions in the context of feature attribution methods
for post-hoc interpretability. In interpretability research, getting to grips
with feature interactions is increasingly recognised as an important challenge,
because interacting features are key to the success of neural networks. Feature
interactions allow a model to build up hierarchical representations for its
input, and might provide an ideal starting point for the investigation into
linguistic structure in language models. However, uncovering the exact role
that these interactions play is also difficult, and a diverse range of
interaction attribution methods has been proposed. In this paper, we focus on
the question which of these methods most faithfully reflects the inner workings
of the target models. We work out a grey box methodology, in which we train
models to perfection on a formal language classification task, using PCFGs. We
show that under specific configurations, some methods are indeed able to
uncover the grammatical rules acquired by a model. Based on these findings we
extend our evaluation to a case study on language models, providing novel
insights into the linguistic structure that these models have acquired. | [
0.0355862938,
0.0458441712,
-0.0268712193,
0.0620327666,
-0.0116239181,
0.0210525598,
0.0268308893,
-0.0155484369,
-0.0288535524,
-0.030299753,
-0.0353619121,
-0.0454451069,
0.038294021,
0.0713836998,
0.016658416,
-0.0265427809,
0.0222927928,
-0.0130603975,
-0.0065318197,
0.0101040723,
-0.0091543514,
0.0127556352,
0.0242009554,
0.0682036132,
-0.0073765242,
-0.0227784943,
-0.0351914987,
0.0103559839,
-0.0370978005,
0.0288777351,
-0.0128581179,
0.0446791649,
-0.0094328932,
0.0591541417,
0.000001777,
-0.0262854211,
-0.0050718556,
0.0240847338,
-0.032592658,
0.0414871462,
0.0448092185,
-0.0280038659,
-0.001028106,
-0.0365571156,
-0.0269820727,
-0.0248629805,
0.0733792633,
0.0589311011,
0.0134910215,
0.0428557694,
-0.0119153326,
-0.0471575372,
0.0100181736,
-0.0189628676,
-0.0092209689,
-0.0188743509,
0.001446371,
-0.015092236,
-0.0557567924,
0.0150105329,
-0.0205616653,
0.0183064211,
0.0380909853,
-0.0202046689,
-0.0061227805,
-0.0081167258,
0.0206784252,
-0.0383296534,
0.023168996,
0.058044631,
-0.0070054098,
-0.0230453368,
-0.0123660937,
-0.0016941082,
-0.0027221097,
0.024831485,
-0.0192814954,
-0.0359138474,
0.0127670225,
0.022758754,
0.0399911255,
-0.0110009843,
0.0658090562,
0.0140760122,
-0.0121397721,
0.06514851,
-0.0259426516,
0.019592246,
-0.0239231214,
-0.0082339095,
-0.0075772051,
-0.027562039,
0.0280363448,
-0.0075115548,
0.0268947799,
0.0260048341,
0.0019006773,
0.0190129504,
0.0293931812,
-0.0697542578,
0.056870088,
-0.0052319337,
-0.0490471013,
0.0264499672,
-0.0091633052,
0.0286920685,
-0.030265864,
0.0215238053,
-0.0403933637,
0.0105135888,
-0.094394587,
-0.0400711931,
-0.0060685398,
0.0338972472,
-0.017971918,
-0.0118877264,
-0.0243643522,
-0.0328439958,
-0.027324874,
-0.0142555311,
0.0048209969,
0.0191921443,
-0.0472184978,
0.0138956029,
0.0148203187,
0.0383793749,
-0.0143824015,
0.0179839898,
-0.0205037892,
-0.038910538,
-0.020468818,
0.0121537801,
-0.0277162399,
-0.0154684642,
-0.0260982253,
0.0780624971,
0.030398652,
-0.014218105,
-0.0134634376,
-0.0569338873,
-0.0358396247,
-0.0304379556,
-0.0047605047,
-0.0368923545,
-0.0078463191,
0.0084887007,
-0.0104862303,
-0.0566321351,
-0.0259554591,
-0.0220927149,
-0.0279430095,
0.0711190179,
0.0146453315,
-0.00681546,
-0.012799195,
0.011883514,
0.008400877,
0.0523162782,
0.0560206287,
0.0207417142,
0.0123590371,
-0.0248417854,
0.0090646427,
0.037262965,
0.0067449128,
-0.0015642507,
-0.0387637727,
-0.0346150585,
-0.009187296,
-0.023368489,
0.0394627079,
0.0168297887,
-0.0150858415,
-0.0477288775,
0.0270593129,
0.0276406184,
0.036665339,
0.0495560206,
0.0682431236,
-0.0107395072,
0.0116917212,
0.0425394475,
-0.0622592941,
-0.0324339382,
-0.0463033952,
-0.0133469859,
-0.0747186914,
-0.0019784435,
-0.0021367709,
-0.0729063377,
-0.0050070412,
-0.000902808,
0.0242565852,
-0.0055637024,
0.0727941543,
0.0391826592,
0.0235649701,
0.0502742715,
0.0341759846,
-0.038409289,
0.0134922424,
-0.0740482584,
0.0159681104,
0.0406238586,
0.0097282473,
-0.0072796196,
0.0137411924,
0.0187614895,
0.0064326045,
0.0046407389,
0.0198067073,
-0.0143116554,
0.0563839227,
-0.0016960454,
-0.0147874523,
-0.0254797209,
0.0580362417,
0.0438390039,
-0.06135666,
-0.0646197274,
-0.0010940381,
-0.0135561191,
-0.0777237937,
0.0344747119,
0.0104754809,
0.0012227509,
0.0055332943,
-0.0002052826,
0.0187918041,
0.0370399095,
-0.0013663467,
0.019145852,
0.0127117289,
-0.0217812788,
0.0261280518,
0.0384615399,
-0.0287918914,
-0.0468498617,
0.006346005,
-0.000097348,
-0.005463548,
0.0145207047,
-0.0356095731,
-0.0239027236,
0.0481106453,
-0.0402109474,
0.0492064692,
-0.0325371511,
0.0040468643,
-0.0317189544,
0.0120413071,
-0.0480401628,
0.02591292,
-0.0377552435,
-0.0086073568,
-0.0062612249,
-0.0070825382,
0.0279343389,
-0.0104085105,
-0.005474539,
0.0505996533,
-0.0126049723,
-0.0104035828,
-0.0113143576,
-0.0138665605,
-0.0286722537,
-0.0137298089,
-0.0738328025,
-0.0212897267,
-0.0187948383,
0.0268646814,
0.0399305411,
-0.0284451526,
0.0330539979,
-0.0146674607,
-0.0168293882,
-0.0306508485,
-0.0421912931,
0.0082145454,
0.0319475755,
0.0118076289,
-0.0589598306,
-0.0476215109,
-0.0332224704,
-0.0426496081,
0.1127571836,
0.0068246103,
0.0106761511,
-0.0629455,
0.0000445112,
-0.0111009609,
0.0038664998,
-0.0171404034,
-0.0507079214,
0.0169636514,
-0.0074611539,
-0.0777348727,
0.0534395128,
-0.0301479641,
0.0974057689,
0.034529388,
0.0131354351,
-0.0612622052,
-0.0356615558,
-0.0469619408,
0.0194932818,
-0.0534480028,
-0.0531304404,
-0.0162625164,
0.1097317934,
0.0098701846,
0.0006441054,
-0.0429877415,
0.0439813882,
-0.0166274216,
-0.0477484614,
-0.0284702946,
-0.0409950428,
-0.0126251047,
0.0502722412,
-0.0448905453,
-0.0703929812,
0.0541353002,
-0.0589770861,
-0.0218458343,
-0.0129779307,
-0.0236708429,
-0.045237679,
0.108242698,
0.0212621186,
0.0033046841,
0.0513301939,
-0.0596340708,
-0.0328892171,
-0.0087616397,
0.0468173437,
-0.0148333646,
0.0482811518,
-0.0435989797,
-0.0100569781,
0.0204754155,
0.0180085637,
-0.0121260034,
-0.0442474224,
-0.0142903905,
0.0515790731,
-0.0139299612,
-0.0538544022,
0.0151214972,
0.0136895478,
-0.0064225369,
0.0058576195,
-0.0048242896,
-0.0010423536,
-0.019325193,
0.038717404,
0.0277564209,
0.0579503216,
0.033445254,
-0.0133470474,
-0.0133664506,
0.0395761542,
-0.0119085507,
0.011714506,
-0.0582154132,
0.0480962209,
0.0014477662,
-0.0258229487,
-0.0621049106,
-0.0133097973,
0.0374898352,
-0.1037141532,
0.008645854,
0.0823643804,
0.034533821,
-0.0459990911,
0.0493064523,
-0.0099967886,
0.0268931445,
0.0103632528,
-0.0080710305,
-0.0210752022,
-0.0226980373,
-0.0005033117,
0.0012460336,
-0.0143358316,
-0.0033985318,
0.0040161167,
-0.064016737,
0.0196209867,
0.0023295959,
-0.0434456207,
-0.0077042603,
-0.0248345472,
-0.0099448357,
-0.0337048136,
0.0182567779,
-0.0179163702,
0.0042655077,
0.0147318952,
0.0381355546,
0.0007657951,
-0.0346767977,
0.0442626178,
-0.0137587534,
0.045649536,
0.1050082073,
0.0050024898,
-0.028186677,
0.0058089877,
-0.0067649642,
0.0189288743,
0.0301374774,
-0.0074680652,
0.0493725911,
0.0237545781,
-0.0071868622,
0.0010329176,
0.016834734,
-0.0369974487,
-0.0054641147,
-0.0274000242,
0.0418995172,
-0.0220441595,
-0.0627883226,
0.0041949777,
-0.0085155666,
0.0083163306,
0.0690474063,
0.0731571764,
-0.02831682,
-0.0590399653,
-0.0556031242,
-0.0118890638,
0.0079285232,
-0.0919070467,
0.0339513347,
0.0408607759,
-0.0642556846,
-0.0541058145,
-0.0542501844,
0.0138271665,
0.011970249,
-0.016899474,
0.0013345911,
-0.0203526895,
-0.0315333642,
-0.0105314292,
0.1061061323,
0.0119113438,
-0.0116909286,
-0.0099601876,
-0.0294380374,
0.040294122,
-0.0210554563,
-0.0467478894,
-0.008517039,
-0.0392592177,
-0.0430205092,
0.050180994,
0.0205026343,
0.0321840346,
0.0495303348,
-0.0326424427,
-0.0630157292,
-0.0130226817,
0.0213620514,
-0.0265077855,
0.0177118424,
0.0800135285,
-0.0466404185,
-0.0108207352,
0.0591540076,
-0.004496512,
0.0267367642,
0.0244033094,
0.0199455488,
-0.0482504927,
-0.0195941757,
0.0208456144,
-0.0118130958,
0.0606582575,
-0.003208651,
-0.0481181145,
-0.0109452531,
0.0160395075,
0.0000073177,
0.0018620689,
-0.0804054365,
0.0127114952,
0.000203742,
0.0203321483,
0.0019373827,
-0.0481186919,
-0.014148606,
0.0306733493,
0.0030498942,
0.0233807433,
0.0068470673,
0.0176920593,
0.0058539459,
0.0416592993,
-0.0030618457,
0.0806380138,
-0.0363890044,
0.018233465,
-0.002284433,
0.0368424468,
0.0237259101,
0.0123900017,
-0.0552210584,
0.0228984617,
-0.0725383833,
-0.0162043255,
-0.0370808356,
-0.0333427452,
0.0296106488,
-0.0401411094,
0.0687572956,
-0.0249114726,
-0.00160181,
-0.0259392112,
0.0716070384,
0.0296372585,
-0.0267643686,
0.0188273359,
0.0179736521,
-0.0293578953,
-0.0171108656,
0.0744177401,
0.0396366268,
0.0114773279,
-0.0059855822,
-0.0008393084,
0.001675342,
-0.051673241,
0.028102247,
0.0218632799,
-0.0443398021,
0.0188799594,
-0.0799396411,
-0.0869264305,
0.0059407093,
-0.01506502,
0.0233586803,
-0.0279662404,
0.0299438573,
0.0503330156,
-0.0107205184,
-0.0029932247,
-0.0414122455,
-0.0205432903,
0.0223554838,
0.0038989293,
-0.040737275,
-5.510014424e-33,
-0.0195494033,
-0.0600474738,
-0.0338895135,
0.028911531,
-0.0020759483,
-0.008277813,
-0.0386627503,
0.0347683616,
-0.0335322879,
0.0595199876,
0.0256948583,
0.0310171284,
0.01138476,
0.008891819,
0.0104048653,
-0.0569879189,
0.050803069,
0.0213631094,
0.0189364888,
0.0248707179,
0.0452237651,
0.0107955299,
0.0765162855,
-0.0676197335,
0.0558734648,
0.0126392674,
-0.014047171,
0.02868798,
-0.0529754385,
0.0934241265,
-0.0080813859,
0.0134957526,
0.0331997387,
-0.0328195617,
-0.0041267881,
-0.0204900075,
-0.0522196628,
-0.0198265202,
0.0428997427,
0.0325418152,
-0.0489301272,
-0.0587949157,
0.0759405345,
-0.0186506789,
0.0140751014,
-0.0378418639,
0.0318727642,
-0.0207911674,
-0.0187782496,
0.0124862771,
-0.0524272621,
0.0351085477,
-0.0251211971,
0.0252265967,
0.0582286641,
-0.0164383128,
-0.0043115956,
0.0056493673,
-0.0355049334,
-0.0393109992,
0.0215413962,
0.0285343304,
0.0724844858,
0.0317918658,
0.0043966225,
0.0636812598,
0.0416503362,
0.0055324752,
-0.0727707446,
0.010024434,
0.0638078675,
0.0482084453,
0.0478997938,
0.0190800838,
0.0486482754,
0.03998648,
-0.0591314882,
-0.0289082862,
-0.0061454703,
0.0175704788,
0.0092160087,
-0.0204623938,
-0.0497968905,
-0.0217517447,
-0.0700091943,
-0.0360143706,
-0.0378044434,
-0.0719851479,
0.0086351559,
-0.0360129662,
-0.0360943824,
-0.0007708547,
0.0096490094,
-0.0661696866,
-0.010085539,
0.0365977883,
-0.0131632574,
0.039867077,
0.0339884907,
0.0102213584,
0.0010198009,
-0.0222150888,
-0.0322636142,
-0.0039983294,
0.0453864373,
0.0157373529,
0.0561131462,
-0.0016759627,
0.0076212995,
0.0002806033,
-0.0321563333,
-0.0353902131,
-0.0242298543,
0.0520922653,
0.0371700004,
0.0053160563,
-0.042193424,
0.0179460142,
0.0184453186,
0.0526614897,
-0.035660632,
0.0485043041,
-0.0143024186,
0.0383405834,
-0.0203665085,
-0.0537496507,
0.0002978473,
-0.0230466835,
0.0976622626,
-0.0028567412,
-0.0188752078,
0.0200648177,
2.376e-7,
0.0712130442,
0.0176706798,
0.0150883645,
0.0127908355,
0.0358790681,
0.043035306,
-0.0088338107,
0.0079165865,
0.0032514909,
-0.0426504649,
0.0060061263,
0.0228947215,
0.0525381565,
0.0189951528,
-0.0518451557,
0.0009101309,
-0.0439964235,
0.0059205769,
-0.0068266666,
0.035229452,
0.0343984216,
0.111937508,
0.0128783667,
-0.0068773101,
0.0230086688,
-0.007608992,
0.0422198139,
-0.0329449438,
0.0304019675,
0.0370673798,
0.00650167,
-0.0369284526,
0.0302680042,
0.0289286971,
0.0015644481,
0.0233543348,
-0.0089223422,
0.0800698698,
-0.0166837759,
-0.0009584429,
-0.0474959351,
-0.0341828875,
0.0254679918,
-0.0385766998,
0.0512378998,
-0.0655311868,
-0.0554837137,
-0.0057309391,
0.0368869156,
-0.0110890502,
0.0031551188,
-0.0019476578,
0.0385557376,
0.0410203151,
-0.0030413195,
-0.0634865016,
0.0022935176,
-0.0559761263,
-0.0581971221,
0.0131406216,
-0.0323676616,
-0.0271699335,
-0.0225725248,
-0.0286949724,
0.0355006531,
-0.0246350151,
-0.0056424499,
2.305136157e-34,
0.0299810227,
-0.0067056501,
0.0226796009,
0.0543617979,
0.0224934481,
0.0074753985,
0.0284209773,
0.0150640048,
0.0431428142,
-0.075612843,
0.0035050926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14917v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14917v1 | Towards Enriched Controllability for Educational Question Generation | 2023-06-21T11:21:08 | 2023-06-21T11:21:08 | Bernardo Leite, Henrique Lopes Cardoso | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Question Generation (QG) is a task within Natural Language Processing (NLP)
that involves automatically generating questions given an input, typically
composed of a text and a target answer. Recent work on QG aims to control the
type of generated questions so that they meet educational needs. A remarkable
example of controllability in educational QG is the generation of questions
underlying certain narrative elements, e.g., causal relationship, outcome
resolution, or prediction. This study aims to enrich controllability in QG by
introducing a new guidance attribute: question explicitness. We propose to
control the generation of explicit and implicit wh-questions from
children-friendly stories. We show preliminary evidence of controlling QG via
question explicitness alone and simultaneously with another target attribute:
the question's narrative element. The code is publicly available at
github.com/bernardoleite/question-generation-control. | [
0.0588098094,
0.0061166184,
-0.0415629372,
0.0240674056,
-0.0417490713,
0.0082593001,
0.0100363372,
-0.0117382882,
0.0346124768,
0.0008389766,
0.0439863168,
-0.0230476428,
-0.0267042294,
0.0529871769,
0.0196364019,
-0.0758646205,
0.0270223301,
-0.0041145287,
-0.0060669919,
0.0254319701,
-0.0090416865,
-0.0016973686,
-0.0261621103,
0.0318329707,
-0.0075194058,
-0.0224005505,
-0.052880045,
-0.0005745864,
-0.0124573754,
-0.034427233,
0.0406239592,
0.0417472199,
0.003781636,
-0.0098789725,
0.0000018839,
-0.0645082444,
-0.0410681032,
-0.0086128879,
-0.0064118756,
-0.04541675,
0.0036541086,
0.0328237265,
0.0219853073,
0.0218844209,
-0.0459376425,
0.0368411057,
0.0464901254,
0.054876551,
0.0504481941,
0.0597131513,
-0.0047577671,
-0.0055850111,
0.0029790089,
0.0268848594,
0.0959044993,
0.0018716771,
-0.0307459813,
0.0335316807,
0.0673381463,
-0.0153172025,
-0.0226813201,
0.0204403829,
0.0541356914,
-0.0390549712,
0.0098474752,
0.0114790546,
0.0042616278,
-0.0376166962,
-0.0323069952,
0.0894932672,
0.0340665951,
-0.0238203444,
0.031126814,
-0.0131144905,
0.0491845161,
0.043921981,
-0.0437221229,
0.0378576331,
-0.0294342488,
-0.0293348189,
0.0048852228,
0.0125995288,
-0.0220579803,
0.0178795513,
0.0303147919,
0.0467493758,
0.007392698,
-0.0217596814,
-0.0423300341,
0.026493961,
0.0035751052,
-0.0955277085,
0.0351241939,
0.0511985719,
-0.0235770158,
0.0142841144,
-0.0584712513,
0.0071173199,
0.0006246149,
-0.0249737371,
0.0006631697,
0.0389416777,
-0.0011836562,
0.0125466716,
-0.0018932163,
0.0525542609,
-0.0163843911,
0.0134090809,
-0.0438520238,
0.0420547575,
-0.0181558132,
-0.0085024619,
-0.0441933498,
0.023008965,
-0.0294273607,
0.0007134132,
-0.017415341,
0.0501813143,
0.019366676,
0.010047188,
-0.0365462005,
0.0410575308,
-0.0440002456,
0.0044993623,
-0.0345870703,
0.0128442151,
-0.0795857608,
-0.0250273347,
0.0239855126,
-0.009522046,
-0.004069481,
0.0223358981,
0.063993983,
0.0014573975,
-0.0076455744,
0.0484740511,
-0.0297915675,
0.0021912153,
-0.0065614451,
-0.0969567969,
0.0172729567,
-0.0334809087,
0.0191825423,
-0.0378478095,
0.0138444658,
0.0058033145,
-0.0171390362,
-0.0190525111,
0.0219230317,
0.0426051319,
0.0030904543,
0.0259861201,
0.0114863049,
-0.0052581471,
0.0319023654,
0.0224084314,
0.0112809753,
0.0303875059,
0.0664995462,
0.0174377393,
0.0542315245,
-0.0054095369,
0.0203738995,
-0.0266918335,
0.011478113,
-0.019240154,
0.0043733711,
0.0148587013,
0.000492912,
0.0387764052,
-0.0628800914,
0.0449179709,
-0.0083668455,
0.0262195151,
0.0390823074,
0.023169525,
-0.0207591821,
0.0055721859,
0.085312441,
0.0024413052,
0.0200364944,
0.0847129673,
-0.0405560806,
0.0432343334,
-0.0255446769,
0.0067837248,
0.002377952,
0.0098105362,
0.0083326874,
-0.0688705891,
-0.0028746109,
0.0388472117,
0.0111621032,
0.018215403,
-0.0010523954,
0.0532638133,
-0.034380585,
-0.0202612486,
0.0066897883,
-0.0741929784,
0.0384115539,
-0.0415989086,
0.0922162607,
0.0149390297,
0.0749573261,
-0.0391220786,
-0.0463765375,
-0.0135689462,
-0.0036711947,
0.0341223627,
0.0319900848,
-0.0338689648,
0.0022959861,
-0.0002946512,
-0.0164226145,
-0.0270215105,
-0.007783649,
-0.0065179891,
-0.0008429913,
-0.00765735,
0.0033754043,
-0.0038899197,
-0.0392078012,
0.0667410195,
-0.0299311616,
-0.0411351472,
-0.0017294785,
0.0304267667,
-0.0313415006,
0.0097037936,
0.0154341338,
0.0214700531,
0.0348413363,
-0.0214306936,
-0.058728382,
0.020090336,
-0.0644625649,
-0.0776786283,
-0.0037606531,
-0.0782057717,
0.0076387967,
-0.0237073675,
-0.0076128412,
-0.0331120007,
0.0541031286,
-0.0411425158,
0.0207237657,
-0.0240432974,
0.0139334938,
-0.0030071631,
-0.0680783391,
-0.0497553311,
0.0542678647,
0.0285342913,
0.0108771808,
-0.0015979155,
0.0182294119,
-0.0042212973,
0.0096708136,
-0.0015209317,
0.0446472019,
-0.0314999931,
-0.0119318804,
0.0493187569,
0.0107862595,
-0.0822850689,
-0.0087245079,
-0.0150731988,
0.0158775821,
-0.0236027185,
0.0107404292,
0.0379745997,
0.0106498608,
-0.00620047,
-0.0180320404,
-0.0779748112,
0.0018132487,
0.0252176318,
-0.0087544937,
0.0572047904,
0.030638352,
0.0122044459,
-0.021149436,
0.011010984,
-0.0301836487,
0.0245170854,
0.0731590688,
0.030341953,
-0.0482749119,
0.006877475,
-0.0521337762,
-0.0148388017,
0.0228680819,
-0.0048287134,
0.0269428864,
-0.034332145,
0.0330645479,
0.0630589277,
-0.0202596728,
0.0148239322,
0.0360355787,
-0.0216975715,
-0.0167731885,
0.0394541286,
-0.0391634144,
-0.010817444,
0.0261462908,
-0.0341891423,
0.0171509273,
0.0834644511,
0.0436987579,
-0.0195879638,
-0.0534375012,
0.0790584683,
-0.0152540989,
0.0287483856,
-0.0512323305,
-0.0378100164,
-0.0186447669,
0.0516052842,
-0.0240107253,
-0.0646508783,
0.0802140161,
0.0127531085,
-0.0044827242,
-0.0622666329,
0.0216644369,
-0.0214306023,
0.0913069695,
0.0190928765,
0.021381028,
0.0824436024,
-0.0326583236,
-0.082504943,
0.0235648006,
0.0484139957,
-0.0231308602,
-0.002661217,
-0.0660283864,
-0.0354609825,
0.0236648992,
-0.0233833082,
-0.0764589161,
-0.0190151706,
0.0553008281,
-0.0338052027,
0.0251192283,
-0.0187422819,
0.0005065216,
-0.0358895324,
0.0348601118,
0.0631092116,
-0.0516773723,
-0.02201383,
-0.0348307081,
0.0805922747,
0.0926081166,
-0.0031673252,
0.0167537034,
-0.0238459203,
0.0393354408,
0.0552111343,
0.0033949725,
0.0065693874,
0.0631182864,
0.0434258543,
0.007478829,
-0.0211584084,
-0.0034786654,
0.0434264876,
0.0659899861,
-0.0865986571,
-0.0567853488,
0.0547063053,
0.0831958503,
0.0178354848,
0.00886703,
-0.0227689482,
0.0236483812,
0.0182595234,
0.0210060533,
-0.0418321155,
0.0040272046,
-0.0105140926,
0.0202476941,
-0.0599290282,
-0.0572840087,
-0.0283004884,
-0.0783440173,
0.0165199656,
-0.03386214,
-0.0267087314,
0.0067796991,
-0.0109085524,
-0.028082652,
0.0534098335,
-0.0129310796,
0.0195477102,
-0.0054051196,
0.0262562092,
0.0117015997,
-0.0055472744,
0.0008015773,
-0.035775464,
-0.0025732683,
0.0004936028,
0.077322267,
0.0182186253,
0.0101336539,
0.0165513307,
-0.0332038067,
-0.0262883287,
-0.0295753758,
-0.0079488559,
0.025467338,
0.008069667,
-0.0204608627,
-0.0581343099,
0.1090010777,
0.0345842615,
0.0068210359,
0.0400114357,
0.0713691264,
-0.018496003,
-0.0566638149,
-0.0245115515,
0.0246710591,
0.0180148855,
0.0751523077,
0.0507418141,
-0.051773876,
-0.0005502249,
-0.0372719504,
-0.018785188,
-0.0811280981,
-0.0298090819,
-0.0172085259,
0.0029265198,
0.0525575727,
-0.135921061,
-0.0307589397,
0.0584117509,
0.0217360612,
0.0107532144,
-0.0378005542,
0.0319466554,
-0.0142334336,
-0.0539381579,
-0.003841311,
0.0040668081,
-0.0288893282,
-0.0461386405,
-0.0135113224,
-0.0218519103,
-0.0555490814,
-0.009445346,
0.0416133292,
-0.0468939543,
-0.0625376701,
-0.0212324262,
0.0303974729,
0.0215676893,
-0.0184638985,
0.0094369575,
-0.0381171815,
-0.0081745656,
-0.0194162354,
-0.0144875124,
-0.0223827101,
-0.038757287,
0.0268841311,
0.0036282309,
0.0246259496,
-0.0281183757,
0.0084664831,
-0.0045553599,
0.0408427119,
0.0077339169,
-0.0064872778,
0.0446202457,
0.0152899958,
-0.018761389,
-0.028756097,
-0.0128008341,
-0.0513401963,
-0.0080932304,
-0.0545886643,
-0.027733935,
-0.0377916805,
0.0460369289,
-0.0208552647,
-0.0013828569,
0.0021229719,
-0.0430707633,
-0.0836838111,
0.0403278135,
-0.0346299671,
0.0326578654,
-0.0123594664,
0.0066265957,
0.0191024765,
0.0111224493,
-0.008874434,
0.009339178,
-0.0016616395,
0.0714865848,
0.0135420421,
0.0827607065,
0.0213309303,
-0.0005313933,
-0.014200381,
-0.008212571,
-0.0509000495,
-0.012789675,
-0.0020140838,
0.0106213065,
-0.006288541,
-0.0015666367,
-0.0109441532,
-0.0188621469,
-0.0027224016,
0.0263131317,
0.0299006514,
0.0543071441,
-0.0601304434,
0.0216822885,
-0.0037762814,
0.0088429172,
-0.0058089551,
0.0217123125,
-0.0053589926,
0.0426476374,
-0.0060173068,
0.0165159162,
-0.046702981,
-0.0235756114,
0.0209686775,
0.0128937168,
-0.0035970265,
0.0530183949,
-0.060520485,
-0.0355813839,
0.0022024245,
0.0055347658,
0.0106064389,
-0.0427288748,
0.0276055876,
0.002056438,
-0.0090751071,
-0.0315542631,
-0.0235482547,
0.048783727,
-0.0460250303,
-0.0262861196,
-0.0195303988,
-6.173365723e-33,
-0.0332260169,
-0.0584151596,
-0.0009850658,
-0.0251865778,
-0.0184421502,
0.0129297571,
-0.0782378986,
0.0423737094,
-0.0053921314,
0.0126391165,
-0.0016453946,
-0.0099211792,
-0.0122338813,
0.0206851475,
-0.0016822893,
-0.0413489752,
0.0183914434,
-0.0190029517,
-0.0464125872,
0.0477278382,
0.0465831645,
-0.0085274661,
0.015670741,
-0.0123696104,
0.0512102358,
-0.0641135946,
-0.0079663498,
0.0290103052,
-0.0068194671,
0.035205625,
-0.0121217221,
0.0049794419,
0.032418929,
-0.0168354064,
-0.0034451277,
0.0700399578,
0.0012269939,
-0.069026351,
0.0265952162,
-0.0524306446,
-0.0855504796,
-0.0239539724,
0.0247412398,
-0.0230095759,
0.0462859422,
-0.0072184196,
0.0284666903,
0.019019356,
0.0243777521,
-0.0343950987,
-0.0823540241,
-0.0079333251,
-0.0395630784,
-0.0422158316,
-0.0337996408,
0.1123060435,
0.0242793951,
-0.0349893868,
0.0291463789,
0.0239567664,
0.0286135934,
0.027360389,
-0.0015399946,
0.0056779147,
-0.0189570282,
0.0481544994,
0.0000593261,
0.022748718,
-0.0330286995,
0.0512166955,
-0.0205670334,
0.0344279967,
0.0862377882,
0.0312194079,
0.0245154165,
0.0318584479,
-0.0439977571,
0.0401887149,
0.019972939,
-0.0046479786,
-0.0325421467,
-0.0482081436,
-0.0404683277,
-0.0004755979,
-0.0359982699,
0.0025489691,
-0.0222306363,
-0.0196246877,
0.0465414003,
-0.0246339887,
-0.0522846133,
-0.0147499749,
-0.0294140857,
0.0071487166,
0.041237779,
0.0033295492,
-0.0316606164,
0.0296593327,
-0.0171816144,
0.0272452999,
-0.0193723049,
0.0175029635,
0.0255054981,
-0.0247561466,
0.0224475842,
0.0321815759,
0.0090886233,
-0.0074424073,
-0.0405134708,
0.0066773901,
-0.0325683467,
0.0392588899,
-0.009144498,
-0.0069501637,
0.0022164274,
0.0192202982,
-0.0217618719,
0.0142276352,
0.0147622451,
-0.0183796603,
-0.0657568723,
-0.0360491984,
0.0097682318,
0.0264206119,
-0.019639153,
-0.0129470192,
-0.0426372737,
0.0545598269,
0.0116824238,
-0.0736046359,
-0.0141676776,
-0.0199475121,
2.6e-7,
-0.01338467,
0.0306168217,
0.0373562723,
0.0477981716,
0.0023258284,
0.0133133791,
0.0389270075,
-0.0081849843,
0.0181862805,
-0.0433597639,
-0.0100344354,
-0.0240151901,
0.0271443762,
0.0088339215,
-0.0890935361,
-0.0113483798,
-0.0067356988,
0.0114417803,
-0.0270893928,
-0.0106669189,
0.1343038529,
-0.0199723709,
0.008142272,
0.0058216969,
-0.0016144555,
0.0008730436,
0.0029368422,
0.0184117872,
0.0186336581,
0.0527288727,
-0.0316924565,
0.0097178482,
0.0038556152,
-0.0204730239,
-0.033237949,
0.0124167763,
0.0022420164,
0.0316558443,
0.0318471603,
-0.0167015418,
-0.0076831775,
-0.0218311548,
0.014398356,
-0.0561634079,
0.0806608647,
-0.0443310067,
0.0016036289,
0.0587434098,
0.0238972269,
-0.0101410626,
-0.0289560799,
-0.0389661118,
-0.023106074,
0.021103194,
0.0028158571,
0.002210028,
0.0397023894,
-0.0192785934,
-0.0228694808,
-0.0080314223,
0.0000252104,
-0.0282663815,
-0.0634888485,
-0.0039054826,
-0.0590583608,
-0.0497732833,
-0.0080534564,
2.385016738e-34,
0.0092136459,
-0.0070338231,
0.0319595933,
-0.0318687819,
0.0364479497,
0.0031314336,
0.0357332006,
0.0081593646,
0.0594817884,
-0.0659651607,
-0.0409799106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12173v1 | Mixture Encoder for Joint Speech Separation and Recognition | 2023-06-21T11:01:31 | 2023-06-21T11:01:31 | Simon Berger, Peter Vieting, Christoph Boeddeker, Ralf Schlüter, Reinhold Haeb-Umbach | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Multi-speaker automatic speech recognition (ASR) is crucial for many
real-world applications, but it requires dedicated modeling techniques.
Existing approaches can be divided into modular and end-to-end methods. Modular
approaches separate speakers and recognize each of them with a single-speaker
ASR system. End-to-end models process overlapped speech directly in a single,
powerful neural network. This work proposes a middle-ground approach that
leverages explicit speech separation similarly to the modular approach but also
incorporates mixture speech information directly into the ASR module in order
to mitigate the propagation of errors made by the speech separator. We also
explore a way to exchange cross-speaker context information through a layer
that combines information of the individual speakers. Our system is optimized
through separate and joint training stages and achieves a relative improvement
of 7% in word error rate over a purely modular setup on the SMS-WSJ task. | [
-0.0138787553,
0.0206024833,
0.0313495323,
0.0378344655,
0.0003033265,
-0.002246245,
0.0509711616,
-0.0111514712,
-0.007186444,
0.0080353273,
-0.0494875498,
-0.0042880736,
0.0048852023,
-0.0051863315,
-0.0096220896,
-0.0451520756,
0.0078520821,
-0.0219720006,
-0.0095623797,
-0.0255432352,
0.0038898871,
-0.0071783555,
-0.0257532783,
-0.0129720997,
-0.035301771,
0.0258589238,
-0.0149676111,
-0.0010196503,
0.040801771,
0.0410763435,
0.0024975778,
-0.0006554598,
0.0476008654,
0.041905228,
0.0000019038,
0.0121976044,
-0.0374963507,
0.0046767215,
-0.0493330769,
-0.0342842713,
-0.0496590175,
0.0255571436,
0.0024424791,
0.0328110978,
0.0115560079,
-0.0282661524,
0.0181526821,
0.0410879962,
0.0705962479,
0.0286619645,
-0.0034493371,
-0.0257669855,
0.0189931765,
0.004515436,
0.0094261998,
-0.0265120883,
0.0014805177,
-0.0240498651,
-0.0245683677,
-0.0521485284,
0.0067327754,
0.0597822666,
0.032798104,
0.0382081568,
0.0369798504,
0.0079832971,
0.0127524175,
-0.058434777,
-0.0616125427,
0.0564559214,
-0.0077529158,
0.040093936,
0.0415188596,
-0.0228306539,
-0.0414967537,
-0.0287625082,
-0.0076443139,
0.0126778223,
-0.0295638479,
-0.0153350076,
-0.0353325568,
0.0333649702,
0.0123971263,
-0.0331599824,
-0.0805639178,
0.0293329656,
-0.007371278,
-0.0309305862,
-0.0091195805,
0.0119901104,
0.0310776792,
-0.0127851749,
0.0871178508,
0.0024753788,
-0.0146068744,
-0.0157506354,
-0.0144291455,
-0.0909467712,
-0.0658222139,
-0.0338632502,
-0.0443046205,
0.0396405868,
-0.0322431438,
-0.0040181326,
0.0202475097,
0.0216401964,
-0.0039564464,
0.0065266737,
0.0341405869,
-0.0298817437,
-0.0319706723,
0.0011056358,
-0.0008606885,
0.0308999605,
-0.0533299074,
-0.0115289232,
-0.0278387517,
0.0077279555,
-0.0600673333,
0.002355437,
0.0493989661,
0.0152447633,
-0.030170979,
-0.0296954289,
0.0525815524,
0.0356971473,
-0.0065285992,
0.0286838785,
0.0309705418,
-0.0652799085,
-0.0246623028,
0.0390983038,
0.0557305627,
0.0145319728,
-0.0324011967,
0.03927771,
-0.0305298306,
-0.007533004,
-0.0262403022,
-0.0309463758,
-0.0131627796,
-0.0349903554,
0.0347725376,
-0.0505761504,
0.0788342953,
0.0181821324,
0.0171405263,
-0.0209010784,
0.0060257791,
-0.0550482757,
0.0095718857,
0.0635419711,
-0.026935989,
-0.0057059363,
0.1109961644,
0.0179752819,
-0.0206544511,
0.0435962602,
0.049322959,
-0.0135048823,
0.0065723597,
-0.0144506088,
0.0077047986,
0.0453355685,
-0.0353726335,
-0.0495473854,
0.003683079,
-0.0359494314,
0.0076444456,
-0.005772437,
0.0035744535,
0.0288562458,
-0.0590136871,
0.0520605966,
-0.0092950622,
0.0090958402,
0.0421261266,
0.0467850529,
0.0386333801,
0.0178118441,
-0.0187766962,
0.0205937251,
0.0385833569,
-0.0269256476,
-0.0329961516,
-0.0297227707,
0.0726727024,
0.0489489026,
-0.036640007,
0.0030051479,
0.0529265404,
-0.0734429136,
0.0082336506,
0.0329975672,
0.0698207989,
-0.0490825139,
-0.0265571456,
0.0381014012,
0.0238288157,
-0.097082749,
0.0311493743,
0.009183757,
-0.0136934547,
0.0482757092,
-0.0209578518,
-0.0287259519,
0.0047156583,
-0.0203185882,
-0.0701277256,
0.0181635059,
-0.04019906,
0.0182504766,
0.1046371907,
-0.0733657181,
-0.0192358643,
0.0349770412,
-0.019190494,
0.0482203141,
-0.0127728665,
0.0082541648,
0.0471047461,
0.07306014,
0.0911982283,
-0.012036779,
-0.0531163886,
-0.0017199672,
0.0003457105,
0.0178911127,
0.0725666806,
0.052778285,
-0.0309496876,
-0.0112805348,
0.0197539683,
-0.0328669809,
-0.0143111236,
0.0186663866,
-0.0803593323,
-0.0690130591,
0.0438316613,
-0.0172578059,
0.018581396,
-0.0095888507,
0.0162579231,
-0.090647012,
0.0233846512,
0.0079507018,
0.0180629268,
-0.0483168475,
0.0191031601,
0.0590159595,
0.0214292947,
0.0250017475,
0.0132013736,
0.0162927713,
-0.0173565559,
0.0024831605,
-0.0407719575,
-0.0272869132,
-0.0451777875,
-0.0032968083,
0.0158205908,
0.0085436199,
0.0699551851,
-0.041206304,
0.01554929,
-0.0178340711,
-0.0407293811,
-0.0844256133,
0.0189835373,
-0.0493569449,
-0.0117385667,
-0.0331014805,
0.0557623431,
0.0087042395,
-0.0275697391,
-0.0112182004,
-0.0114687849,
0.0210802928,
-0.0424573459,
-0.0610668845,
0.0180348493,
0.0026464113,
0.0018180546,
-0.0258212574,
0.0218748525,
0.0044000237,
-0.0349315777,
-0.086653322,
-0.0226702373,
-0.0321330503,
0.0077090166,
0.0567937456,
0.0119567625,
0.0097043626,
-0.0083252043,
-0.0045131766,
0.0491780117,
0.0095396778,
0.0047612372,
0.0165692698,
-0.0066665793,
-0.0491935164,
-0.0517577231,
0.0332874693,
0.0299134944,
0.0666103438,
0.037174508,
0.0283879396,
-0.0212938637,
0.024815429,
0.0064029591,
0.0234717708,
-0.0542632863,
-0.0323785245,
0.0061252653,
-0.0800433382,
-0.0199107435,
-0.0641617402,
-0.0289194398,
-0.0096243965,
-0.0192597397,
0.0344474763,
0.0216658972,
-0.0734606236,
-0.0309583563,
-0.029661091,
-0.0689992383,
-0.0093632573,
-0.0495793782,
-0.0421103574,
-0.0099155772,
-0.0324236043,
-0.0515266061,
-0.0045681559,
0.0225279015,
-0.0137976203,
-0.054635074,
0.0472065359,
-0.0157970563,
0.0001111704,
-0.0126664303,
-0.0257919915,
-0.0315312929,
0.0135373613,
-0.0189493522,
0.0247140266,
0.0078368438,
-0.0023041884,
-0.0194488913,
0.0292334799,
0.0482252315,
0.0395467281,
-0.0037412844,
0.0506618656,
-0.0555400401,
0.1029191986,
-0.0338004827,
0.0312456507,
-0.0222533513,
-0.091107972,
0.0120412791,
-0.0278129596,
0.0701803118,
-0.0038037167,
-0.0116462857,
-0.0154800154,
0.0144727128,
0.0091700293,
0.0032185435,
-0.003661199,
0.0773971453,
-0.0412409827,
0.0128820855,
0.1080870479,
0.0172023866,
-0.0795852244,
-0.0820402801,
-0.0080994591,
-0.0213290434,
-0.0281237364,
-0.0060129282,
-0.0085109267,
-0.0113495803,
0.0548240878,
0.0012600455,
0.0282800086,
0.0372039862,
-0.0134871881,
-0.0530802794,
-0.0058268756,
0.0416898876,
-0.0454734713,
-0.0547994114,
-0.0237120651,
-0.0361826792,
0.0017477706,
0.0614522509,
0.0010162774,
0.0208760686,
-0.064161256,
0.0381392799,
-0.0326102003,
-0.0381166302,
-0.040787898,
-0.0507375412,
0.0466830432,
0.008575283,
0.0069595133,
-0.0174551811,
-0.0207005274,
0.0368252397,
-0.0625510216,
-0.0078344159,
-0.014368142,
0.0229937509,
-0.0304180905,
-0.001216162,
0.0158405099,
-0.0111650601,
-0.0065610618,
-0.0164620671,
0.047252588,
0.0443130881,
-0.0210912172,
0.0024040823,
0.0234543104,
0.0466458574,
0.0253787134,
0.0425059013,
0.0265824888,
-0.0250832736,
0.0011528342,
0.0087854434,
0.0582193732,
0.0293137915,
0.0641268715,
0.0136951273,
-0.024234511,
-0.0598399937,
0.0114572542,
-0.0480290838,
0.0197770596,
0.0164483655,
0.0031933472,
-0.0054798168,
-0.0126540037,
0.034683302,
0.0045570675,
-0.0146328881,
-0.0106423469,
-0.0073680542,
-0.0294091925,
0.0340016484,
0.0020939182,
-0.0190757755,
-0.0011913988,
-0.0022653381,
-0.0630249009,
-0.0631813481,
0.0203621853,
-0.0276474636,
0.0146637186,
0.0584087744,
-0.034456782,
-0.0614900626,
0.0649344847,
0.0004039458,
-0.0455964245,
0.0283339471,
0.063238509,
-0.0039743092,
-0.035689868,
-0.0038362467,
-0.0280432459,
0.0205395073,
-0.0286994707,
-0.0202894732,
-0.0726288781,
-0.031772431,
-0.0427465178,
-0.0048465622,
0.0294259023,
0.0242036842,
0.0337459892,
-0.0414656773,
0.0316053033,
-0.0295158513,
0.0441309214,
-0.0337124839,
-0.0152215725,
-0.0223889779,
-0.0136451861,
0.006182265,
0.0421788543,
0.0335592441,
-0.0043953741,
0.020096112,
0.060746409,
0.037163768,
-0.0105797099,
-0.0235900935,
0.0024774261,
-0.0268443301,
-0.0017322761,
0.0823486596,
-0.0221982319,
-0.0338221863,
0.0523085371,
-0.0145968031,
-0.0166375376,
0.0044178599,
0.0368855856,
-0.0354027897,
-0.0215391926,
-0.0050424682,
0.0714113787,
0.0076439357,
0.0322104767,
0.0528591536,
0.04486553,
0.0269202758,
-0.0284126252,
0.0192168206,
-0.0275968201,
0.0333943181,
-0.0107500972,
0.0020213271,
-0.028738182,
-0.0112368995,
0.0502804965,
0.0055671786,
-0.0041964971,
-0.0347581245,
0.0438775904,
-0.0652655885,
0.0044702687,
0.0269940086,
-0.0137840658,
-0.0245893225,
-0.0195447747,
0.0260542408,
-0.0048778523,
0.0539226681,
-0.0050604604,
0.0371637493,
0.0122390725,
-0.0063838186,
0.0094651654,
-0.0488433465,
0.004360558,
0.036210373,
-0.0199009012,
0.0476603843,
-0.0081545059,
0.0541984588,
-6.666750089e-33,
-0.060323026,
0.0422215723,
-0.0136016198,
-0.0409783944,
-0.0411823243,
-0.0138512207,
0.0105031217,
0.0046628066,
0.0109192887,
-0.034824986,
-0.0297285896,
0.0554085821,
0.044447314,
0.0154578481,
0.0050941133,
-0.0018422961,
0.086731866,
-0.0059746508,
0.0231581982,
0.0185471158,
0.0182007626,
0.0659759939,
0.0130138192,
-0.0168106649,
-0.0322384201,
0.0196546949,
-0.011958289,
-0.027025694,
0.00205355,
-0.0009004843,
-0.0224115103,
0.0136902481,
0.0079557206,
-0.0099105556,
-0.0088222055,
0.0752342492,
-0.0676099956,
-0.0216926727,
-0.0712230653,
0.014934917,
-0.0467399359,
-0.0482340232,
0.0946203843,
0.0401080921,
0.01376592,
-0.046705544,
0.042899847,
0.0260201693,
-0.0145052094,
-0.0426714532,
0.0447786637,
0.0408978313,
-0.0139030274,
0.0038974779,
0.110217683,
0.0138511267,
-0.0113725625,
-0.0229845066,
-0.0885170251,
0.0262723751,
0.0166331362,
-0.0061600222,
0.0032528422,
0.0842321888,
-0.0085818078,
0.0291657522,
0.0687132478,
-0.0438761711,
0.0112062953,
-0.069675833,
0.017664358,
0.0498819016,
0.025282884,
0.0040075262,
0.0188683309,
-0.0345855169,
-0.0537385978,
-0.0152754933,
0.0246339086,
-0.0274225064,
0.0207431894,
0.0278842356,
-0.0035675454,
0.0097252382,
-0.0161507539,
-0.0498049445,
-0.0167100746,
-0.0054028514,
0.0142870583,
0.0291236117,
-0.0044520493,
-0.0443731323,
0.0602644011,
-0.0356440395,
0.0367381722,
-0.0069306968,
-0.0078894682,
0.0026818269,
-0.0036734254,
0.0202831719,
-0.0448050722,
-0.0380242467,
0.0239733588,
0.0437502787,
-0.0112742288,
-0.0294489227,
0.0094881728,
0.0424660034,
-0.0385062471,
-0.0107213324,
-0.002056676,
0.0615034699,
-0.0042614657,
0.0723941252,
0.0412539952,
-0.0206687003,
-0.0048184763,
-0.0001329386,
0.008870719,
0.0262135994,
0.0189511925,
-0.0036317168,
0.0330054052,
0.0243480001,
-0.0113923075,
0.0185530428,
-0.0009604882,
-0.0499797985,
0.0641132295,
-0.0186806377,
0.0088443672,
-0.0291473586,
2.745e-7,
-0.0878534466,
0.0143730314,
0.0513473228,
-0.0664774701,
0.0540786684,
0.012329964,
-0.0167241246,
-0.0268868431,
0.001150574,
-0.0243798681,
0.0237090215,
0.0226803683,
0.0758503005,
0.0057236506,
-0.0646727309,
-0.0195830744,
-0.0582988672,
-0.0129015036,
-0.0121110985,
0.0125031099,
0.033633057,
0.0454292782,
0.0120098926,
-0.0031999017,
-0.0086596608,
0.037957374,
0.0359643772,
-0.0154902833,
-0.0161234625,
0.0036077902,
0.0167482123,
-0.0269309655,
-0.0081651025,
0.0049691135,
-0.0049655605,
0.0452101827,
0.0443157777,
0.0467607081,
-0.0244319048,
-0.0387738943,
0.0294307861,
0.0706900135,
-0.0378433354,
0.0283741392,
0.052903641,
-0.0050246255,
-0.0021806257,
-0.0248313863,
-0.0613508932,
0.0133779496,
0.007250262,
0.0293267351,
0.0015215822,
0.0266844425,
-0.0154726738,
0.0012558318,
-0.0170747265,
-0.0374516807,
0.007963635,
0.0094960378,
-0.1001454219,
0.009147726,
0.00469349,
-0.0386474691,
0.0308941249,
-0.0052489466,
0.0127666146,
1.78828828e-34,
0.0029527827,
0.0063847643,
0.0101287114,
0.0205371473,
-0.0039464398,
-0.0761118084,
-0.0903275833,
0.0167502966,
-0.0123445187,
-0.0009643296,
-0.0145816738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12146v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12146v1 | Which Spurious Correlations Impact Reasoning in NLI Models? A Visual Interactive Diagnosis through Data-Constrained Counterfactuals | 2023-06-21T09:50:48 | 2023-06-21T09:50:48 | Robin Chan, Afra Amini, Mennatallah El-Assady | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | We present a human-in-the-loop dashboard tailored to diagnosing potential
spurious features that NLI models rely on for predictions. The dashboard
enables users to generate diverse and challenging examples by drawing
inspiration from GPT-3 suggestions. Additionally, users can receive feedback
from a trained NLI model on how challenging the newly created example is and
make refinements based on the feedback. Through our investigation, we discover
several categories of spurious correlations that impact the reasoning of NLI
models, which we group into three categories: Semantic Relevance, Logical
Fallacies, and Bias. Based on our findings, we identify and describe various
research opportunities, including diversifying training data and assessing NLI
models' robustness by creating adversarial test suites. | [
0.0520403832,
0.0766738355,
-0.0383251384,
0.0213971883,
-0.0472007692,
0.0147302067,
0.0152744818,
0.0173451714,
0.0312428549,
-0.033195626,
-0.0073651145,
0.0051546558,
0.0224166419,
0.0294040404,
0.0222550891,
-0.0562164113,
0.0750046819,
-0.0164355505,
0.01235558,
-0.0135963401,
-0.0223057698,
0.0142269861,
-0.0124595296,
0.0234203674,
-0.0299067181,
-0.0313561037,
0.0133303851,
0.0171868522,
-0.0112936506,
-0.0411954932,
0.0055624139,
0.0590678081,
-0.0129770041,
0.0378207155,
0.0000020631,
-0.0522136576,
0.020997094,
-0.0018348211,
-0.0576607659,
-0.0030453962,
0.013559903,
-0.0084592653,
0.0169596653,
0.0087674158,
-0.0256223343,
0.0334335044,
0.0455620512,
0.1068012938,
0.0307974499,
0.0428276286,
-0.0094891256,
0.0087078754,
0.0159634072,
-0.029443251,
0.0101765431,
-0.031947922,
0.0097365538,
0.0173941236,
-0.0304035917,
-0.0288866963,
0.0009281068,
0.0056465007,
0.0450788699,
0.0469474941,
-0.0271824319,
0.0056645563,
-0.0411889292,
-0.0343519934,
0.0085156281,
0.0467206165,
0.0071134735,
-0.0314055048,
-0.0238947812,
-0.0225276444,
0.0256554037,
0.0715235621,
-0.0374952592,
-0.0148297939,
-0.0140925292,
-0.0258693043,
0.0356560759,
0.0369813517,
0.0709205419,
0.0379163958,
0.0250766538,
0.0604650006,
0.0075719077,
-0.0650538728,
0.0199151523,
0.0203856807,
-0.0272344984,
-0.0283092018,
0.0035517621,
-0.0095716538,
-0.0376446508,
0.0205958765,
-0.0159869678,
-0.042084612,
0.0439444259,
-0.0449341461,
0.0269194972,
0.0022230519,
0.0090614678,
0.0381684229,
-0.0068744426,
0.0226365384,
-0.0247408915,
0.0125320125,
0.0010620301,
-0.0222914089,
-0.0317263976,
-0.0588267222,
-0.0046865949,
0.0379129797,
-0.0232039262,
0.0065823537,
-0.0157068335,
-0.0162435733,
-0.095232144,
0.004564215,
-0.0187342837,
0.0497968718,
-0.0125898374,
-0.0174249876,
-0.0627239123,
-0.0071551222,
-0.0381917059,
0.0206853859,
-0.0326592028,
-0.0722857192,
-0.0198681429,
0.006865697,
-0.0347787552,
-0.0567293242,
-0.0045731757,
0.0911507457,
0.0442776531,
-0.0210576784,
-0.0440135635,
-0.0480161756,
-0.0401737578,
-0.0256973673,
0.0120209409,
-0.0293049812,
0.0159939975,
0.011302066,
-0.0126905758,
-0.0686894208,
-0.0056386022,
0.0178511292,
-0.0664955899,
0.057675276,
-0.0118271885,
-0.0195494164,
0.002501898,
0.0397910811,
-0.0271311998,
0.0809620917,
0.0071726479,
0.0011704635,
0.0204862393,
0.0188979413,
0.0155902402,
-0.0083521679,
0.0387856178,
0.0046016248,
-0.0304406267,
0.0196359325,
-0.0305052307,
0.0252652429,
-0.0032895072,
0.0375459604,
-0.0097170146,
-0.0270661004,
0.0802626088,
0.0230100639,
0.0008520866,
0.0313750021,
0.0271521676,
-0.04224848,
-0.0303024668,
0.0352651589,
-0.0757913217,
0.0422108583,
-0.0633028299,
-0.0201819912,
-0.017032925,
0.0320967548,
-0.005109604,
-0.050864514,
-0.0178820193,
0.0183785427,
0.0247949921,
-0.0041560205,
0.0285457298,
0.047069557,
-0.039804969,
0.0168145951,
0.023737764,
-0.0585069545,
0.0063943667,
-0.0171210971,
-0.0180747267,
0.0677162632,
0.0794367269,
-0.0262169242,
-0.0101791676,
0.0195261277,
-0.0142545588,
0.0328322649,
0.0810110793,
-0.000767982,
-0.0282029808,
-0.0195311904,
-0.0027637684,
-0.028167082,
0.0509568974,
-0.0029402429,
0.0221368186,
0.0228169616,
0.0005880901,
-0.0374807492,
-0.0383756869,
0.0416610315,
-0.0346191116,
0.0043805209,
-0.0399260372,
0.0404791459,
0.0148941046,
-0.003808063,
0.0032079876,
0.0308699589,
0.0198853277,
0.0031968972,
-0.0272867456,
0.0255313758,
-0.0267044865,
-0.0242729653,
-0.0028222445,
-0.0422950573,
-0.0433867052,
0.0261618607,
-0.0401356928,
-0.0150589244,
0.0466824509,
-0.0251558945,
0.0247444827,
-0.02384522,
-0.0017374291,
0.0029183701,
0.0352389403,
-0.0250783935,
0.0752760395,
-0.0145230945,
0.0104815587,
-0.0036252222,
0.0173196811,
0.0196154807,
-0.0388616845,
-0.0239758492,
0.0410183631,
-0.0050404794,
-0.022727035,
0.0015836689,
-0.0538906083,
-0.0397565216,
0.0058561969,
-0.0555537567,
-0.0188931674,
-0.0256737024,
-0.0156071456,
0.0149364043,
-0.0230082497,
-0.0109892944,
-0.0012018085,
0.0167100411,
-0.0551216453,
0.0117952749,
0.0516061299,
0.0409384184,
0.0036573857,
0.0120112449,
-0.0202504322,
-0.0174180232,
-0.0497954264,
0.0749279112,
0.0297502279,
-0.010962951,
-0.0062824427,
0.0098102745,
-0.0430696122,
0.0141952904,
-0.0013210333,
0.0128017841,
0.0303522442,
0.0592017099,
0.0110324807,
0.0729122162,
0.000148644,
0.0734648332,
0.029356014,
-0.0178577602,
-0.029067846,
0.0157279223,
-0.0121588251,
0.0195741151,
0.018420022,
-0.0403813161,
0.021595275,
0.0353345051,
0.0272003934,
-0.0213561449,
-0.0813477859,
0.0859731436,
-0.056194067,
-0.0414928645,
-0.0266911574,
-0.0495163947,
-0.00167705,
0.0429158844,
-0.0389820114,
-0.0310205221,
0.0893281624,
-0.0027929549,
0.048281841,
-0.0310710706,
-0.0157950651,
-0.0222636256,
0.0554893427,
0.0053518354,
0.0108682038,
0.0523759015,
0.0070604268,
-0.0701442286,
-0.0063340613,
0.0046697441,
-0.0112795718,
0.0212183241,
-0.0621023774,
-0.0168906748,
0.0296708904,
-0.0574061722,
-0.0504936352,
-0.0438169241,
-0.0164528787,
-0.0060816822,
-0.0034362194,
-0.0097769424,
-0.0293069705,
-0.0294641443,
-0.0175224692,
0.0025813589,
-0.0249574017,
-0.0181708094,
-0.0047316137,
-0.0130680669,
0.0639839321,
0.0206207726,
0.0508563779,
-0.0161714312,
0.0011443062,
0.0431917645,
-0.0174038764,
0.0038104439,
-0.0357246473,
0.0283735748,
-0.0278953668,
-0.0287283286,
0.0004334434,
0.0026248281,
0.0126337633,
-0.0491272882,
-0.0139327385,
0.0796245635,
0.0275780223,
-0.0008121328,
0.0345656276,
-0.0190672893,
0.0584516264,
0.0040583736,
-0.0409175009,
-0.0417365581,
-0.0336760432,
0.0056946436,
0.0204415135,
-0.0603314415,
-0.025648661,
-0.0169057734,
-0.1303053051,
0.019381715,
-0.0167857166,
-0.0101598734,
-0.0145060606,
-0.0521540269,
-0.00486283,
-0.0278420262,
0.0532151647,
0.0086765802,
0.0130059561,
0.0327299871,
-0.00878614,
-0.0450868532,
-0.0571918152,
0.0121439248,
0.0016780789,
0.0296455715,
0.0622503646,
0.0315487497,
-0.0218490828,
-0.0004520534,
0.0337440297,
-0.024236884,
0.0448151641,
-0.0222359505,
0.1165475771,
0.0011497182,
0.0152817667,
-0.0906311721,
-0.0013717476,
-0.0105928322,
-0.0565406643,
-0.0107336128,
0.0620183982,
-0.0216604974,
-0.0276742224,
-0.0450954996,
0.0252298173,
0.0011405232,
0.0934460685,
0.0205510482,
-0.0368079804,
-0.033419054,
-0.0373696573,
0.0064712111,
-0.024445368,
-0.0412388928,
0.0293461196,
0.0868834928,
-0.0205828846,
-0.0471944287,
-0.0963625684,
0.0083821192,
-0.0024760193,
0.0257253349,
0.0063184854,
-0.0611143932,
-0.0187866371,
-0.0157771651,
0.059167549,
0.0079782642,
0.0097280499,
0.0086714961,
0.0387832001,
0.0080825631,
-0.0134316906,
-0.0136354184,
0.0265504774,
-0.0618149005,
-0.0523035191,
0.0040862351,
0.0502568595,
0.0368627459,
0.0445556454,
-0.0252713542,
-0.0061869407,
-0.0258695576,
0.0768741369,
-0.0130627882,
0.0120306592,
0.0261699967,
-0.0158429146,
0.0228629075,
0.0357940271,
-0.0277065448,
-0.0303826593,
0.0232156552,
0.0362033509,
-0.0310588591,
0.0069393353,
0.0525729507,
-0.0141846519,
0.0785246715,
0.0102512455,
-0.0175271891,
-0.0190484095,
0.0129494993,
-0.0194213986,
-0.0331269093,
0.0066081542,
0.0215769913,
0.0196225364,
0.0354329422,
-0.0364658795,
-0.0099268127,
-0.0286728404,
0.0235767681,
-0.0213130005,
-0.0040197973,
0.0252994504,
0.0392397046,
-0.0118206199,
-0.0000429094,
-0.0318631902,
0.0094460398,
-0.0171876084,
0.0433836542,
0.0086687636,
0.0336041227,
0.0282751862,
0.0024028295,
0.0048484863,
-0.0109018674,
-0.0676928237,
-0.0360293016,
0.0063771298,
0.0032773763,
0.0106416577,
-0.0526356474,
0.0089599118,
-0.0401143581,
0.0034713417,
0.0263857059,
-0.0151204206,
0.0298296325,
-0.0305961799,
0.0490116514,
0.0154778585,
-0.0233276356,
-0.0137513848,
0.0527705401,
-0.0171424393,
0.0580382496,
-0.0071192374,
0.009311921,
-0.0019630396,
-0.0545877665,
0.0144936563,
0.0184321217,
-0.0232253578,
0.0092706913,
-0.1300165653,
-0.068223916,
0.0076860799,
0.0124230757,
0.0194862913,
-0.012016274,
0.0160670001,
0.0644543618,
-0.0001590437,
-0.018225044,
0.0140164774,
-0.005583656,
-0.0427817255,
-0.0039247293,
-0.0730543211,
-6.598097546e-33,
-0.014556231,
-0.0932739675,
-0.0053992644,
-0.0430297293,
0.0329549089,
-0.0325466581,
-0.0355998874,
0.0127915544,
-0.0632342026,
0.0152979679,
0.0105059631,
0.0404726565,
0.0009821205,
0.0065799244,
-0.0153508577,
-0.0547329076,
0.0312646739,
0.0361592621,
-0.0264561269,
-0.022770524,
0.0227535218,
0.0064390097,
0.0268796626,
-0.1183277071,
0.0718611851,
-0.0041075833,
-0.0081682596,
-0.0022767875,
-0.067201443,
0.034020938,
0.0120176068,
0.0705393851,
0.038400162,
-0.0172326118,
0.0159426052,
-0.0116581265,
-0.0160280466,
-0.067802228,
0.0425832607,
0.0197035931,
-0.0203761104,
-0.0344040357,
0.0509311557,
-0.000865068,
-0.0239234082,
0.0040206029,
0.0469903499,
-0.0304767601,
0.0004388682,
0.0412208736,
-0.070599854,
0.0008006288,
-0.0158151127,
0.0417084768,
-0.0414630137,
0.0718328282,
0.0290320199,
0.0096791508,
-0.0696415305,
0.0163342413,
0.0117428852,
-0.01975259,
0.0518224686,
-0.00575455,
0.0120216189,
0.0825966448,
0.0305014495,
0.0467569716,
-0.0695711374,
0.00795912,
0.002875563,
0.038694635,
0.1025288701,
0.0694495887,
0.0749180242,
-0.0115353605,
-0.0482336283,
-0.007003427,
-0.0347473808,
0.023972705,
0.0398590155,
-0.0083444081,
-0.0805607587,
-0.0087408843,
-0.0505459346,
-0.0406015776,
-0.0408167206,
-0.0311443936,
0.0413958058,
-0.0212346129,
0.0147485072,
0.005921972,
-0.029377589,
-0.008888281,
-0.010707262,
0.0351248085,
0.0153825963,
-0.0478289761,
0.011139336,
0.0075790007,
-0.0088788522,
0.0023858394,
-0.0155330626,
0.0326609761,
0.0587632395,
0.0092537943,
0.0535401851,
-0.011703073,
-0.0284081679,
-0.0216842443,
-0.0363301635,
0.0230208077,
0.0144529575,
-0.0392525941,
0.0575360283,
0.0187927671,
-0.0149761522,
0.0243953988,
0.0474548452,
0.0195436515,
-0.0651411414,
0.0227596909,
-0.0472912975,
0.0051745004,
-0.015062226,
-0.0478782393,
-0.0029133353,
-0.0129456818,
0.0288436562,
-0.0930344611,
-0.0167167932,
0.0067254486,
2.708e-7,
0.0684740022,
0.0598851554,
0.0033227128,
0.0284370445,
0.0156401452,
0.0439198948,
-0.0343901925,
-0.0206470713,
0.0081504164,
-0.0167308878,
0.0050860504,
0.0394281633,
0.0430908054,
0.0308894403,
-0.028153263,
0.0047947895,
-0.0646721199,
-0.0057188338,
-0.05655469,
0.035017658,
0.0838122219,
0.0588184334,
0.0365383886,
0.003040347,
-0.0135353804,
-0.0263908338,
0.053521011,
-0.03066702,
0.0398469195,
-0.0098288711,
0.0361622088,
-0.0145355184,
0.015586867,
0.0622921176,
-0.0098377727,
-0.0254290272,
0.0041923975,
-0.0022580612,
-0.0244452413,
-0.0520353392,
-0.0484872684,
-0.0373147838,
-0.0116144828,
-0.0545411482,
0.0789326057,
-0.0332287066,
-0.056823384,
0.0033558332,
-0.0198211651,
0.0281383265,
0.0471217781,
0.030238349,
-0.0212436523,
-0.020368427,
-0.0022573364,
0.0268087164,
0.0070610298,
-0.0400026515,
-0.0283684265,
0.0197672918,
-0.0279020369,
-0.0076599382,
-0.0273084771,
0.0308841728,
0.0521514341,
-0.0114538474,
-0.0168265216,
2.711076141e-34,
0.0291737113,
0.0052621928,
0.0381469876,
-0.0382470787,
0.063859351,
0.0046463758,
-0.0161565803,
0.0229513124,
0.0212283619,
-0.0206932314,
-0.015248796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12105v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12105v2 | Mass-Producing Failures of Multimodal Systems with Language Models | 2023-06-21T08:43:29 | 2024-03-01T21:28:00 | Shengbang Tong, Erik Jones, Jacob Steinhardt | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SE | Deployed multimodal systems can fail in ways that evaluators did not
anticipate. In order to find these failures before deployment, we introduce
MultiMon, a system that automatically identifies systematic failures --
generalizable, natural-language descriptions of patterns of model failures. To
uncover systematic failures, MultiMon scrapes a corpus for examples of
erroneous agreement: inputs that produce the same output, but should not. It
then prompts a language model (e.g., GPT-4) to find systematic patterns of
failure and describe them in natural language. We use MultiMon to find 14
systematic failures (e.g., "ignores quantifiers") of the CLIP text-encoder,
each comprising hundreds of distinct inputs (e.g., "a shelf with a few/many
books"). Because CLIP is the backbone for most state-of-the-art multimodal
systems, these inputs produce failures in Midjourney 5.1, DALL-E, VideoFusion,
and others. MultiMon can also steer towards failures relevant to specific use
cases, such as self-driving cars. We see MultiMon as a step towards evaluation
that autonomously explores the long tail of potential system failures. Code for
MULTIMON is available at https://github.com/tsb0601/MultiMon. | [
0.0167609137,
0.0727487877,
0.0014057888,
0.0389628112,
-0.011794311,
-0.005114689,
0.0172974672,
0.0130139701,
-0.0316143073,
-0.0872741565,
0.0239297878,
0.0319924429,
0.0034574613,
0.0691386983,
0.0503679924,
-0.0516190827,
0.051679153,
-0.0468955413,
-0.0476737879,
0.0047896197,
0.0168241709,
0.0170423966,
-0.0381330289,
0.0481167771,
-0.050242316,
-0.0280495044,
-0.041048646,
0.0234156996,
0.018701395,
-0.0182550997,
-0.0418849774,
0.0186694004,
0.0165817868,
0.0489425361,
0.0000019906,
-0.0443899222,
-0.0192092098,
0.0118980296,
0.011669877,
-0.0076897833,
0.0357438028,
-0.0144906091,
-0.0115526263,
0.0000805983,
-0.0025058158,
-0.0172906518,
0.0635423213,
-0.0065758964,
0.08907637,
0.0461040251,
-0.0147017501,
0.0242672563,
0.0095483288,
0.0415007174,
0.0118050398,
-0.0243955795,
-0.0147085991,
0.0364985205,
0.0643239245,
-0.0108946171,
-0.0111419903,
0.0248339865,
0.0258020591,
-0.0197923761,
-0.0310869887,
0.0299345106,
-0.0235632844,
-0.0792449489,
-0.0224347394,
0.0444658026,
-0.0271156058,
0.0063045276,
0.0070954612,
0.0037332184,
-0.0134003339,
0.0198437702,
-0.0209596902,
0.0276022535,
-0.0346354619,
-0.0189816877,
-0.0839959234,
0.0122817578,
0.013010934,
-0.0435061269,
-0.0108991684,
0.0442683958,
0.0241759922,
-0.0025535105,
-0.0139523996,
0.0037523706,
-0.0034945237,
-0.0430811942,
0.0169077199,
-0.0083542578,
-0.036120303,
-0.0097992951,
-0.0618283525,
-0.0291648302,
0.0258224197,
-0.0563853346,
0.0350459367,
0.0116973128,
-0.0517902933,
0.0544582382,
0.0090970257,
0.0553828888,
0.0046522683,
0.0183641184,
0.0009932531,
-0.0000030034,
-0.0412838161,
-0.0117880125,
-0.0221097078,
0.0128063615,
-0.00220773,
-0.0239849277,
-0.0017304319,
0.05452618,
-0.0441044234,
0.0805292279,
-0.0703497231,
-0.0002678849,
-0.0153335594,
-0.0047769211,
-0.0000406452,
0.0121744061,
-0.0122526661,
-0.0005319915,
0.0148004917,
-0.0618865602,
0.0153058283,
0.0407642722,
-0.0186875779,
-0.022728622,
0.0021010148,
0.1093009338,
0.0179598443,
-0.011125342,
-0.0178607535,
-0.0520378686,
-0.0528530739,
-0.0291181263,
-0.0042902422,
-0.0696648061,
-0.0056366553,
0.0256026778,
0.0199886113,
-0.0100850249,
0.0220166072,
-0.0055206432,
-0.0055968021,
0.1038449556,
-0.0235869884,
0.011411597,
0.0171436723,
0.0146489078,
0.0034307784,
0.0802286044,
0.0263485536,
0.0217739306,
0.0624078736,
-0.00523774,
0.0716367215,
0.0636756048,
-0.0347350389,
0.0119696613,
-0.0295356158,
-0.0206585005,
0.0068768635,
0.0325880609,
0.0216807518,
0.051061675,
-0.0142925307,
-0.0310657565,
0.0467899218,
0.0234996006,
-0.059417367,
-0.0156090232,
0.0445242226,
-0.0123939142,
-0.0111315083,
-0.0069051622,
-0.0253001153,
0.03801075,
-0.0364964716,
-0.0104646254,
0.0399914086,
0.0464528687,
-0.025451459,
-0.0401482582,
-0.0609434508,
-0.0224160589,
-0.0039849211,
-0.0112414984,
0.0647594854,
-0.0102598853,
-0.0268571377,
-0.0022194237,
-0.0383246019,
-0.0584263392,
-0.0110771349,
-0.0362751782,
-0.0108452588,
0.0476914719,
0.0822688043,
-0.032602381,
-0.0569262728,
0.0065361261,
-0.0274276603,
-0.004324507,
0.0487481616,
-0.0297516361,
0.0009250579,
-0.0297493916,
-0.054729268,
-0.0048699481,
0.0145597197,
0.0122774569,
-0.0399238728,
0.0333028696,
-0.0155436108,
-0.0409191176,
-0.0114774602,
0.0315565653,
0.0486889742,
-0.0052964096,
-0.0461379066,
-0.0061368607,
0.0364887603,
0.0067596235,
-0.0455360338,
-0.0032088608,
0.0450868122,
0.0230434164,
-0.0247539505,
0.0421502367,
-0.0087279491,
-0.0110151842,
0.0324743539,
-0.0932913199,
-0.0258646235,
0.0892864466,
-0.076223366,
-0.0433013737,
0.011236893,
-0.0631973445,
-0.0303831119,
0.007637579,
0.0280823074,
0.0168036073,
-0.008541232,
-0.0046627815,
0.004947715,
-0.0093846023,
-0.002950917,
-0.0481635258,
0.0212005451,
0.0412454717,
-0.0157254767,
-0.0653537586,
0.0422898121,
-0.0248614978,
0.0095354849,
0.0280153342,
-0.0079920655,
-0.0144215655,
-0.0048356997,
-0.0943207815,
-0.0331614576,
-0.01359763,
0.0126891434,
0.0035431169,
0.0096006105,
0.0080757802,
-0.0340287909,
0.0366074741,
0.0244844761,
0.0387759544,
0.0131661929,
0.0427886024,
-0.0050298595,
-0.0273015685,
-0.0262950584,
-0.0309671275,
-0.0328352451,
0.062458802,
-0.0007604518,
-0.0147992503,
-0.0818961263,
-0.0061674812,
-0.0120642465,
0.0255086441,
-0.0037000324,
-0.024107689,
0.0465121306,
0.0189633742,
0.0047041536,
0.0293581057,
-0.0132251121,
0.0672149062,
0.0297212042,
0.0066248351,
-0.0432102866,
0.001233918,
0.0401202887,
-0.0382924788,
0.00324554,
0.0074990229,
-0.0058002658,
0.0113282818,
-0.0053172107,
0.0089840107,
-0.0422040075,
0.0390134379,
-0.0205602497,
-0.0329556242,
-0.0247700196,
-0.0492524095,
-0.018962888,
0.0590426661,
0.0076281959,
-0.0205405671,
0.0481552333,
-0.0574205033,
-0.0270664282,
-0.0019247484,
-0.0114815217,
-0.0010015311,
0.0749613568,
0.0204280037,
0.0071798833,
0.0474847294,
-0.0064329472,
-0.0303271227,
0.0096753836,
0.0205602683,
-0.0017540969,
0.0501116253,
-0.0831539854,
0.0062039103,
-0.0126045169,
-0.0542057008,
-0.013053054,
-0.0060508801,
-0.0232248344,
-0.0340692587,
-0.013136344,
-0.0016039539,
-0.0551763587,
0.0313329697,
0.0064689904,
0.0496228151,
0.0352499746,
-0.0388086475,
-0.0406231843,
0.0197117999,
0.025443377,
0.0252857618,
0.0097677615,
-0.0640916452,
-0.0317956693,
0.0659336373,
0.0507589094,
0.0193136334,
-0.106198065,
0.0114058694,
0.0342880115,
0.0207229238,
0.006165402,
0.0204704814,
0.0702122003,
-0.0714937672,
-0.0124425553,
0.0284515135,
0.0114614004,
-0.0505046621,
0.0244168229,
0.0031926117,
0.0411621444,
0.0319143087,
0.0007077636,
-0.0998509377,
-0.0424858332,
0.0086058481,
0.0388637558,
0.0079467371,
0.0389755033,
0.0339502655,
-0.0987843052,
0.0437526666,
0.003911837,
-0.0440312624,
-0.0283938311,
-0.0126343155,
-0.0038334511,
-0.0482391864,
0.0287923571,
0.018122172,
-0.0002480129,
0.0097002303,
0.0088915471,
-0.0409848168,
-0.0727993622,
0.0203191917,
-0.0293191373,
0.060444776,
0.0685019568,
-0.0056266813,
-0.0346780792,
-0.0436232649,
0.053639967,
0.020820111,
0.0166693777,
0.0146728214,
0.0713686496,
-0.0101731364,
-0.0086346343,
0.0021984791,
-0.0060360902,
-0.0341409147,
-0.0272924583,
-0.0206228551,
0.080235213,
-0.0441942886,
-0.0056979125,
-0.0699815601,
0.0066193533,
0.0100732455,
0.0431021862,
0.0014468092,
-0.0282482319,
-0.0659752488,
-0.0183793828,
0.0007221396,
-0.0407193266,
-0.0297860429,
-0.0089431703,
0.0145071261,
-0.0182722174,
-0.0557846241,
-0.0427068733,
0.0161698088,
0.051598087,
-0.0218304638,
-0.0785001442,
0.0021813198,
0.0524422303,
-0.0298345797,
0.0320727304,
0.0497640818,
-0.0025544351,
-0.0256494824,
0.0586132333,
-0.0023852643,
0.0202734768,
-0.0118440203,
0.05594844,
-0.0500564016,
-0.0597897992,
0.0014681738,
0.0944526792,
0.0345255956,
0.0121076331,
-0.0313673019,
-0.047619611,
0.0152186444,
0.0408340879,
-0.0076070232,
0.0096807303,
0.0497031286,
-0.0378308482,
-0.0217526853,
0.0016931025,
-0.0588549599,
0.0045659789,
-0.0488428473,
-0.0063891839,
-0.0206405241,
-0.0020597761,
0.0014674254,
-0.0135858888,
0.0362218507,
-0.050406836,
0.0183193348,
0.0115797929,
-0.008568828,
-0.0033035381,
-0.0173375718,
-0.0682377964,
0.0701497123,
-0.0392087996,
-0.0342639387,
0.0290334597,
0.007079625,
-0.0052591562,
0.0365927927,
0.0073321466,
0.0188180059,
0.0595508516,
-0.0196698364,
0.0211664084,
-0.0138548128,
0.0044541224,
0.0320949703,
-0.014874436,
0.0391663909,
-0.0197730102,
0.0675493255,
0.0342126936,
0.0039671552,
0.0466631763,
0.0555341765,
-0.0118383253,
-0.0182658639,
-0.0485843085,
0.0361350141,
0.0774992853,
0.0237951726,
0.0660098344,
-0.037851166,
0.0121765006,
-0.0404700004,
0.0386876166,
0.0112279737,
0.0031228219,
0.0087419497,
0.0245937761,
-0.009217211,
-0.0286581479,
0.0550577603,
-0.0398974679,
0.0230653565,
0.0056572626,
-0.0081317239,
-0.0397551209,
-0.0037760569,
0.0038810885,
-0.0022084878,
-0.0378702097,
-0.0447171256,
-0.0600461476,
-0.065037854,
-0.0153168831,
0.0792566165,
0.0219257995,
0.0134365121,
0.0245252587,
0.0692343712,
0.0458562411,
0.0192011185,
0.0093052248,
-0.0361317135,
-0.0165517814,
-0.0012390679,
0.0080630574,
-6.076561559e-33,
-0.0367771015,
-0.0517782308,
0.0165375955,
-0.0091685345,
-0.0069973045,
-0.0296800621,
-0.0229782835,
0.0336205289,
0.0421485379,
0.0201128162,
0.0267479401,
-0.0052516018,
0.0027358099,
-0.00789655,
0.0647830665,
0.0228368472,
0.0467688516,
-0.0008776507,
-0.0674279481,
0.0022872754,
0.0684139952,
-0.0001417524,
0.0266248845,
-0.0572705679,
0.0294515267,
0.0246056076,
-0.0521753877,
-0.0027307793,
-0.0249791797,
0.0632320419,
-0.0042137294,
0.0354788378,
-0.0028474459,
-0.0196023434,
-0.0305981524,
0.0047970344,
-0.0295672528,
-0.0302189775,
-0.0050630979,
0.0512421019,
-0.0632034689,
-0.002287558,
0.0528179891,
-0.0317907445,
-0.0120368395,
0.0095534492,
0.046570465,
0.001580134,
0.0183776729,
-0.0092463866,
-0.0488966815,
0.0385400802,
-0.0237458479,
-0.0129974913,
0.0249339975,
0.0854142383,
0.0360425487,
-0.0227277074,
-0.0266150236,
-0.0025152317,
-0.030918071,
-0.0116542615,
0.1136102527,
-0.0445903279,
-0.0436605699,
0.0750737041,
-0.0181184653,
-0.031913247,
0.001506274,
-0.0030360471,
0.0146932583,
0.0680871829,
0.0541070141,
0.0767856538,
0.0255144984,
0.0084311459,
0.0001151221,
0.0409112088,
-0.0527179688,
0.0281418934,
0.01538995,
0.0246012192,
-0.0414566398,
0.0281741042,
0.0032334956,
-0.001226511,
-0.0295597427,
-0.0456115082,
0.0306680053,
-0.0007831774,
-0.0003350241,
0.0313154794,
0.0675782412,
-0.0407161675,
-0.0174858496,
-0.0203824472,
-0.0421804823,
0.0282462966,
-0.0047061839,
0.0255942494,
0.0219565425,
-0.0236209128,
0.0128608588,
0.0314764678,
0.0651885048,
-0.0046087494,
0.001858842,
0.0643277615,
-0.0414248593,
0.022078082,
-0.0118265804,
-0.0030072846,
-0.0154690584,
0.009219721,
0.0528328866,
-0.0228963643,
-0.0357960127,
0.0105659077,
-0.0188838821,
-0.0082559837,
-0.0610034615,
-0.0060197087,
-0.0408188291,
-0.0095763169,
-0.0394662321,
-0.0196310766,
-0.0682532489,
-0.0279244259,
0.0326860957,
-0.0237201117,
-0.0242702328,
0.0373031162,
2.74e-7,
0.0141945044,
0.0561189763,
0.0334699675,
-0.0237207133,
0.0326267369,
0.0689587668,
-0.0266259294,
0.0377208777,
-0.0242420621,
-0.0124463188,
-0.0101144314,
-0.0168604385,
0.0689393505,
0.0585792176,
-0.0093497587,
-0.0188837573,
-0.032724753,
0.0018226426,
-0.0589727908,
0.0075193532,
0.0813927203,
0.0638238192,
0.0264884196,
-0.0188499708,
0.0265643913,
-0.0338498764,
0.0105438028,
0.0165013224,
-0.0146739492,
-0.0122895213,
0.0167230107,
-0.0031701662,
-0.0123422984,
0.0299725365,
-0.0054242909,
-0.0636363253,
0.0296537373,
0.0337970443,
-0.026746016,
-0.0592050552,
-0.0269812029,
0.0037959733,
-0.0218946319,
-0.0454198644,
0.042620331,
-0.0151126012,
-0.0098783495,
-0.0358031727,
-0.0340684317,
-0.0306638665,
0.0149085568,
0.0063747554,
0.0025178853,
0.0396323949,
-0.0074711321,
-0.0038222512,
-0.03059588,
-0.0801549852,
0.0161953606,
0.030652998,
-0.037187513,
-0.0450395718,
0.0010262766,
-0.0266607553,
0.0382942446,
-0.0509336255,
-0.0740499794,
2.459930166e-34,
0.0455138572,
-0.0083029252,
0.0078749508,
-0.0415230431,
0.0197605807,
0.0008961524,
-0.0524187833,
0.0016863201,
-0.0076840627,
0.0165962577,
-0.0328708179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12089v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12089v1 | Towards Accurate Translation via Semantically Appropriate Application of Lexical Constraints | 2023-06-21T08:08:15 | 2023-06-21T08:08:15 | Yujin Baek, Koanho Lee, Dayeon Ki, Hyoung-Gyu Lee, Cheonbok Park, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Lexically-constrained NMT (LNMT) aims to incorporate user-provided
terminology into translations. Despite its practical advantages, existing work
has not evaluated LNMT models under challenging real-world conditions. In this
paper, we focus on two important but under-studied issues that lie in the
current evaluation process of LNMT studies. The model needs to cope with
challenging lexical constraints that are "homographs" or "unseen" during
training. To this end, we first design a homograph disambiguation module to
differentiate the meanings of homographs. Moreover, we propose PLUMCOT, which
integrates contextually rich information about unseen lexical constraints from
pre-trained language models and strengthens a copy mechanism of the pointer
network via direct supervision of a copying score. We also release HOLLY, an
evaluation benchmark for assessing the ability of a model to cope with
"homographic" and "unseen" lexical constraints. Experiments on HOLLY and the
previous test setup show the effectiveness of our method. The effects of
PLUMCOT are shown to be remarkable in "unseen" constraints. Our dataset is
available at https://github.com/papago-lab/HOLLY-benchmark | [
0.0544489324,
0.0232186317,
0.0076571591,
0.0495573916,
-0.0307488684,
0.0060534137,
0.0036589897,
0.0020255083,
0.0046324902,
-0.0345113352,
-0.0753561631,
-0.0414917655,
-0.0040028566,
-0.0532081462,
0.0236411914,
-0.0454436205,
0.032631468,
-0.0058796559,
-0.063445881,
-0.0153322192,
-0.0056878547,
0.0412173346,
0.0137355337,
0.0138785113,
-0.0381004587,
0.0191006213,
0.0211119503,
0.0601389073,
0.0163611528,
-0.0016387703,
0.0285427105,
0.0654177442,
0.0056397216,
0.0560405925,
0.0000021396,
-0.0478701517,
-0.0398874357,
-0.0033908288,
0.0235228073,
-0.0035413178,
0.060412433,
-0.0666955262,
0.0297398511,
-0.0025755183,
-0.0041238847,
-0.0146561824,
0.038840279,
0.0136152571,
0.0806255415,
0.03592325,
-0.0284254067,
-0.0225871317,
-0.033602275,
-0.0388695598,
0.0128216557,
-0.0431426391,
-0.0095719695,
0.0313607007,
-0.0326464102,
0.0019849413,
-0.0061890925,
0.0712585002,
0.0251939669,
0.0492434427,
0.015176232,
0.0205362365,
-0.0211646054,
-0.0155755254,
-0.0137606822,
0.1081839949,
-0.034960214,
-0.037213143,
0.0160136297,
-0.016628772,
-0.0285263304,
0.028578952,
-0.0160957631,
0.0063087489,
-0.0091477893,
0.0073543075,
0.0046268469,
0.0173274018,
0.06396088,
0.0292244833,
-0.00271389,
-0.0001079152,
0.0443622135,
-0.0162907932,
0.0214196332,
0.012769416,
-0.0179294068,
-0.0085892286,
0.0446189642,
-0.0151936105,
0.0072890241,
0.0299449824,
-0.0378813557,
0.0015446503,
0.0139422044,
-0.0907875299,
-0.0168852881,
0.0518701188,
-0.0044256863,
0.033821743,
-0.0266381055,
0.0288511757,
-0.0313531309,
0.0315295272,
-0.0657747686,
-0.0338003561,
-0.0700739622,
0.0062079732,
-0.0802180544,
0.0026309879,
-0.0222355407,
-0.0006021052,
-0.0411733314,
-0.0176455434,
-0.0023976851,
0.0228636321,
-0.0026038499,
-0.0403380617,
-0.0768403634,
-0.0087846583,
-0.0209353063,
0.0247618202,
-0.0236557964,
-0.0431106053,
-0.0304727927,
-0.0418810174,
-0.0159046594,
0.0259019565,
-0.0307345428,
-0.0652481318,
0.0120739397,
0.0788014233,
-0.0011609893,
-0.0435569473,
0.014266476,
-0.0234015435,
-0.0544226281,
-0.0467469506,
0.020740265,
-0.0762405917,
0.0305650141,
-0.0231545474,
0.0160788316,
-0.0684874579,
0.0076545435,
-0.0120103098,
-0.0542781614,
0.1123023555,
-0.0001898364,
-0.0387494862,
-0.0002822771,
0.0382829159,
0.0050389376,
0.0382723026,
0.0316088572,
0.0448140465,
0.0289278142,
0.0202899501,
-0.0224404354,
0.0458826125,
0.0102156391,
0.0480312668,
-0.0269382447,
-0.017843483,
-0.0007355173,
0.0337357149,
-0.0037303858,
0.0904803872,
-0.0303796548,
0.0041691097,
0.0606988668,
0.0440172479,
0.0381758213,
0.0349322855,
0.0705702454,
-0.0010600414,
-0.0101846643,
-0.0023390383,
-0.086000599,
-0.0246903133,
-0.0300295576,
0.0191666298,
-0.0090924324,
0.0239146855,
-0.0255954359,
-0.0339480154,
-0.0088656172,
-0.0221908651,
0.0231136959,
-0.0215863865,
0.0587589815,
0.0233335104,
-0.0227449983,
0.0920644924,
0.003317087,
-0.0385429077,
0.0473253839,
-0.0115658576,
-0.0682761073,
0.0639113113,
0.0629386082,
-0.004791338,
-0.0664873421,
0.0016514289,
-0.0603905059,
0.0732663348,
0.0490430668,
0.00756212,
0.0336781517,
-0.0639852062,
-0.0241105873,
0.0143412473,
0.0213702954,
0.0057167597,
0.0267957337,
0.0322146788,
0.0789240822,
-0.0517340042,
-0.0513369143,
0.0236562323,
0.0088921431,
-0.0331130065,
-0.0147847608,
0.0136945508,
-0.0303580463,
0.0431517027,
-0.0248809122,
-0.0110438429,
0.0115268361,
-0.0237621758,
-0.0130945938,
0.0217298716,
-0.0827028379,
-0.0372109488,
0.0374009907,
-0.0787053779,
0.0007282724,
0.0330569856,
-0.0346146449,
-0.0574055389,
-0.006976991,
0.008905137,
0.0311940853,
-0.0454952978,
0.0267470554,
0.0132074039,
-0.033643011,
-0.037654724,
0.0691118464,
0.0085037006,
0.0156351849,
0.0107145775,
-0.0113990689,
0.004733636,
-0.0032124182,
-0.0501711853,
0.0360401943,
0.0451599509,
0.0358551592,
0.0466999374,
0.0629529506,
-0.0375577509,
-0.0231235325,
-0.0527815968,
0.0178253315,
-0.0390981063,
0.0190131459,
0.0523230024,
0.0360302627,
-0.0046645235,
-0.0285369847,
-0.0012704781,
0.0226040632,
-0.0049883318,
-0.001008841,
0.0173006095,
0.0100368774,
-0.0097656753,
-0.0204759557,
-0.0229101591,
-0.0069982028,
-0.0070651458,
0.0187933575,
-0.0482484251,
-0.0209233314,
0.0207531247,
-0.0729519054,
0.0127777802,
0.0071825497,
-0.0254196487,
-0.0004934819,
-0.0263541751,
0.0118180932,
-0.0246423893,
-0.0620753132,
0.0183850359,
0.0739563629,
0.0212062132,
-0.0240311082,
-0.0047809798,
-0.0272749793,
-0.0161800701,
-0.0074673118,
-0.035905838,
0.0123273041,
0.0581752025,
0.0175002757,
-0.0043197609,
-0.0742868632,
0.0024457681,
-0.0433258899,
-0.0254463349,
-0.035797976,
0.0407372005,
-0.0078389309,
0.0171262305,
-0.0273041893,
-0.0609044246,
0.0618485883,
-0.0480993949,
0.0105258562,
-0.0404937789,
0.0043405574,
-0.0365428217,
0.055250451,
0.0111440569,
0.0394226164,
0.0300016347,
-0.0463602096,
-0.0480160117,
-0.0092899203,
0.0295138676,
-0.0253227931,
0.0766431689,
-0.0689257234,
0.0118296649,
-0.0085380543,
0.0185713265,
-0.025336856,
-0.0059329537,
-0.0225433838,
0.0150224213,
0.0334547721,
-0.0010848877,
0.0477213487,
0.0213120431,
-0.0102451527,
0.0970194265,
0.0005422449,
-0.0169040635,
-0.0445939153,
0.0288516935,
0.037823379,
-0.0202935673,
0.0125553887,
-0.0328404121,
-0.0145151801,
0.0039775502,
0.0010167157,
-0.0481619984,
-0.031736955,
0.0251481477,
0.0224057604,
-0.0340336002,
-0.0301266629,
-0.0132357897,
0.0448827408,
-0.0344322287,
-0.0237404183,
0.127574876,
0.0524762869,
-0.054790888,
0.0005577881,
0.019282097,
0.0523767844,
-0.0094116135,
-0.0039563766,
-0.0968661681,
-0.0469518118,
0.0124014951,
0.030268373,
0.073371768,
-0.0146478033,
-0.0187312346,
-0.0588652194,
-0.0069374125,
0.0416341648,
-0.0503620133,
-0.0436496325,
0.0185724441,
-0.0117718764,
-0.0502161272,
0.035403844,
-0.0382476859,
0.0029899597,
0.0006014539,
-0.0103860442,
0.0104159424,
-0.0234719086,
0.0152266119,
-0.0551451147,
0.0108350953,
-0.0001223774,
0.0211295802,
0.0134300003,
-0.0010640071,
0.0258644801,
-0.0298386868,
4.204e-7,
-0.0517441705,
0.0089507652,
-0.0038903879,
-0.0245264657,
-0.0019036614,
-0.0015825635,
-0.0577087365,
0.0034104574,
-0.015683258,
0.0525945164,
0.0057432121,
0.0015869034,
0.0200955011,
-0.0013580669,
0.0173633974,
0.0806177109,
0.0171961114,
-0.0129551236,
-0.0315854177,
-0.0108663319,
0.0040404624,
-0.0193399321,
-0.0173388422,
0.001664885,
-0.0928527936,
-0.0009590819,
-0.0781890675,
-0.0730670691,
0.0018171637,
0.0272113401,
0.0200453717,
-0.0064564925,
0.0140438285,
0.0070813163,
-0.0092608882,
0.0460917391,
-0.060994491,
-0.0230240803,
-0.0333808251,
0.0065117539,
0.0268872902,
-0.0010158541,
0.0077276463,
0.0704056472,
-0.0578564368,
-0.0352030918,
-0.0202728733,
0.0311192609,
0.0294605512,
0.0709550306,
-0.0712830573,
-0.0172487851,
-0.0321407393,
-0.005673111,
-0.0011973412,
-0.0144197196,
0.0334222205,
0.0017248825,
-0.0228032954,
0.0375257023,
-0.0483624376,
0.0230858959,
0.0190566927,
0.062381316,
-0.0146310562,
-0.096892409,
0.0306026042,
0.0087848436,
0.0352974832,
-0.0584692061,
0.0181671232,
-0.0179640874,
-0.0000257922,
-0.0025978014,
0.0023730821,
-0.0313668512,
-0.0068898862,
0.0521432981,
0.0080193477,
-0.011485884,
-0.0041999598,
-0.0193720162,
0.0189733822,
-0.0199672543,
-0.038957864,
-0.0036140007,
-0.012276426,
-0.024822969,
0.0134458747,
-0.0156245539,
0.0466212519,
-0.0089095263,
0.0291621946,
-0.0514805578,
0.0265959743,
0.0064486573,
-0.011634279,
-0.0230990499,
0.0246820953,
-0.0134391934,
0.0260717943,
-0.0416572541,
0.0156171136,
0.0908508971,
-0.0232642032,
0.0970975086,
-0.0621341914,
0.003275271,
-0.0050754454,
0.0433815196,
0.0115122451,
0.0045703365,
0.0053341254,
0.0022646284,
0.0271751117,
0.0112371361,
0.0517629273,
0.0545302965,
0.0325508863,
0.0402237326,
-0.0169801805,
-0.0168973599,
-0.0277912803,
-0.0095349057,
-0.0167334285,
-0.0167426839,
-0.0057883505,
-0.0562116094,
-0.0849575102,
0.0219602175,
0.0149371829,
-0.0085336743,
0.0195475146,
0.0317872576,
0.0318656303,
-0.0268360134,
-0.0466145761,
-0.0317082256,
0.0061179595,
0.0148737729,
0.0139344893,
-0.0100147594,
-6.592684394e-33,
-0.0467882939,
-0.028105244,
0.0109730782,
-0.0318123028,
-0.044097703,
-0.0121604595,
-0.0170792155,
-0.0342979319,
0.0132519267,
0.0006888106,
0.0185259543,
0.0002291656,
0.0202015322,
0.0010071378,
-0.0112221111,
-0.0203797463,
0.0424176045,
0.0210616831,
-0.0236735921,
0.0344012044,
0.0425178297,
0.0115038147,
0.0861643553,
-0.0118421772,
0.0431371853,
-0.0418768972,
-0.0005904198,
0.0139205055,
0.0215660427,
0.0206496231,
-0.0059427815,
0.0346232131,
0.0331663601,
-0.0252943765,
-0.0288469624,
0.0023890294,
-0.1203148291,
-0.0446249396,
0.0450174585,
0.0052753403,
-0.020117972,
-0.0458548591,
0.0761263892,
-0.0339301825,
-0.0170338433,
0.0002680108,
0.0037104229,
0.0068161995,
-0.0497565158,
-0.0063358238,
-0.0592066795,
0.02351062,
-0.0030200682,
0.0005292594,
0.038084466,
0.0236872789,
-0.0175000001,
-0.0437359437,
-0.0791737065,
0.0196205433,
0.0191183072,
0.0361317471,
0.0761936903,
0.0461761467,
-0.0167101827,
-0.0018001122,
-0.0090620248,
-0.0499173403,
0.0367032401,
-0.0144591834,
0.0460822918,
-0.0040843813,
0.0511976853,
0.0312058702,
0.0375454016,
0.0009727016,
-0.0260129236,
0.0110311024,
-0.0201401524,
0.0507417433,
-0.0250838865,
0.0065618609,
-0.0383102782,
-0.0280204471,
-0.0615763515,
0.0171112977,
-0.0230777357,
-0.0491627865,
0.0346963592,
0.00458227,
-0.035299141,
0.0730384737,
0.0500762574,
-0.0057698064,
0.026683677,
0.0149810314,
0.0156453829,
0.0196455643,
-0.0192664769,
0.0478193648,
-0.0435056314,
-0.0236457214,
0.0030140625,
0.0407827049,
0.0205439255,
-0.0149930017,
0.0103909709,
0.0105245728,
-0.0267647095,
0.0270415973,
-0.0323985405,
-0.0069259712,
-0.0326339565,
-0.018670164,
0.0335178711,
-0.0011395247,
-0.0015841089,
0.0377706848,
0.0598323569,
0.0030287821,
-0.0177536421,
0.047457695,
0.00939856,
0.0330949128,
-0.0269682351,
0.0495876484,
-0.0076754061,
0.0373989642,
0.0575373434,
-0.0527927764,
-0.0109242341,
-0.002395259,
2.847e-7,
0.0426081978,
0.0475249253,
0.012053906,
0.0035958355,
0.0000694311,
-0.0050357548,
-0.0140902093,
0.0311740357,
-0.0297734216,
-0.013643804,
0.0468431227,
0.0304380003,
0.0268517993,
0.0399443433,
-0.056513276,
0.0121905692,
-0.0292197801,
0.0366846099,
-0.0383046567,
0.0306325275,
0.0698998794,
0.0682995096,
-0.0134752225,
0.0133204516,
-0.0477172136,
-0.0675953329,
0.0565973856,
-0.0371012017,
-0.0352762155,
0.0221643597,
0.0624293648,
0.0481128618,
-0.0378343239,
0.0025951418,
-0.0261272397,
-0.005579913,
0.079391934,
0.0815642998,
-0.0008375897,
-0.0247931015,
-0.0142486561,
-0.0426074862,
0.0095320847,
-0.0420691818,
0.0585391782,
-0.0417862386,
0.0253949687,
0.0259226598,
0.0051432801,
0.0432566665,
-0.0032129879,
-0.0105846897,
-0.0659129024,
0.003701542,
0.0378506631,
0.0139497416,
-0.0308105256,
-0.063850008,
0.0010792249,
0.0321457237,
0.0206760187,
-0.0280350018,
-0.0255304351,
-0.042020373,
-0.0286319107,
-0.0508410968,
-0.0184778161,
2.551089064e-34,
0.0184547827,
-0.0142971063,
0.034295816,
-0.0149456467,
0.0211362429,
0.00003822,
-0.027032204,
0.0173067991,
0.0109361354,
-0.0509921685,
-0.0028353119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12069v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12069v1 | Modeling Hierarchical Reasoning Chains by Linking Discourse Units and Key Phrases for Reading Comprehension | 2023-06-21T07:34:27 | 2023-06-21T07:34:27 | Jialin Chen, Zhuosheng Zhang, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Machine reading comprehension (MRC) poses new challenges over logical
reasoning, which aims to understand the implicit logical relations entailed in
the given contexts and perform inference over them. Due to the complexity of
logic, logical relations exist at different granularity levels. However, most
existing methods of logical reasoning individually focus on either entity-aware
or discourse-based information but ignore the hierarchical relations that may
even have mutual effects. In this paper, we propose a holistic graph network
(HGN) which deals with context at both discourse level and word level, as the
basis for logical reasoning, to provide a more fine-grained relation
extraction. Specifically, node-level and type-level relations, which can be
interpreted as bridges in the reasoning process, are modeled by a hierarchical
interaction mechanism to improve the interpretation of MRC systems.
Experimental results on logical reasoning QA datasets (ReClor and LogiQA) and
natural language inference datasets (SNLI and ANLI) show the effectiveness and
generalization of our method, and in-depth analysis verifies its capability to
understand complex logical relations. | [
0.0231832322,
-0.0094645349,
-0.0048984499,
0.0781246126,
-0.0538179353,
0.0366151482,
0.0158571415,
-0.0266432595,
0.0798715726,
-0.0091918483,
0.018270256,
0.0360591933,
0.0089044366,
0.0420560427,
-0.0114015639,
-0.0489990674,
0.0279713273,
-0.0063103973,
0.0121960659,
0.0041444018,
-0.0145725599,
0.0454570018,
-0.0223270282,
-0.0080932435,
0.0178619679,
-0.0452344082,
-0.0367621332,
0.009448437,
0.0500162728,
-0.0323662758,
-0.0232347976,
0.0039314716,
0.0294694621,
0.042322211,
0.0000018449,
-0.0374397486,
-0.0447334088,
-0.009839274,
-0.0451075211,
-0.0099348584,
0.004610247,
-0.032333497,
0.0253240466,
-0.0298338979,
-0.0275845751,
-0.0294957962,
-0.0059109307,
0.0456328057,
0.0330201201,
0.0254467633,
-0.0068156351,
-0.0545495152,
0.0128772091,
0.0003345119,
-0.0098869717,
-0.0851863101,
0.0276751593,
0.079362303,
0.0145702111,
0.01617047,
-0.0330463238,
0.0282980911,
0.0409222133,
-0.0191552732,
-0.0067337104,
0.0163313467,
0.0184386764,
0.0177762806,
0.0125809992,
0.1049353033,
0.0554747768,
-0.0204619728,
-0.0156034771,
0.0055314754,
-0.0144768907,
0.0532094724,
0.0073312009,
0.0126264654,
-0.0921353102,
0.0106738759,
0.0345053785,
-0.0393765569,
0.0334767848,
0.0178473555,
-0.0326684378,
0.0860659704,
-0.011279962,
-0.0127688209,
0.0326818675,
0.0160912406,
-0.0161198545,
-0.004864784,
0.045081038,
0.0427154265,
-0.0324305296,
0.0410171114,
-0.014190794,
0.0107232444,
0.0036240804,
-0.0408435501,
-0.0341665819,
0.0117131071,
0.0079841865,
0.0511617213,
-0.0210887752,
0.0261120703,
-0.0469710454,
0.0088920407,
-0.0443927944,
-0.0333361775,
-0.0218568817,
-0.0106304921,
-0.0218459982,
0.0442524403,
-0.0484290719,
-0.0174385365,
-0.0478479005,
0.0270939171,
0.0316204317,
-0.0001321423,
0.0023393326,
0.0186905563,
-0.031263195,
-0.0205088593,
-0.0222085007,
0.0161449052,
-0.0618806444,
0.0411996134,
-0.0386394598,
0.0193840321,
-0.0143119358,
0.0021413651,
0.0277545732,
-0.0289285351,
-0.0188979413,
0.0971787721,
0.0066175992,
-0.0093592023,
-0.0373612642,
-0.0424903966,
0.0305731744,
-0.0345137119,
0.0038160793,
-0.0407288149,
-0.0074802195,
0.0244188197,
-0.0010550126,
0.011114656,
0.0033395065,
0.0065218061,
-0.0592526346,
0.0563292243,
-0.0395682268,
-0.0255549066,
0.0339962728,
0.0205471646,
-0.0224121753,
0.0169078913,
0.0558097102,
0.0026953022,
0.0469314381,
0.0147712966,
-0.0694446713,
0.0000782519,
0.0007028754,
-0.0274627376,
0.0136855245,
-0.0038931491,
-0.1057282165,
-0.0018220921,
0.0001242485,
0.0405303016,
-0.0259407852,
-0.0588598959,
0.0096800905,
0.0382179543,
-0.0002684385,
0.0098792454,
0.0422294773,
0.0060113589,
0.0105413217,
0.0657511055,
-0.0230002645,
-0.0062596635,
-0.0168676246,
0.0050920141,
-0.0223487578,
-0.035499543,
0.0189907569,
-0.0324827954,
0.0044486639,
0.0386812687,
0.0416156165,
-0.0066587874,
0.0818623528,
0.0372423567,
-0.0451858789,
-0.0035764042,
0.0399009399,
-0.0137026059,
0.0092293909,
-0.0134674516,
0.0230377503,
0.0355980769,
0.0651874244,
-0.00770027,
-0.0158330072,
0.033038117,
-0.0243156385,
0.0090558389,
-0.0375047922,
-0.0383702368,
0.0115493564,
-0.038830366,
-0.0228754804,
0.0267233495,
-0.0061353929,
0.024132099,
-0.0090854401,
-0.0344878584,
0.0049261106,
-0.0318824537,
0.0005735121,
0.0130466903,
-0.0197070986,
0.0188196804,
-0.0136249503,
0.0215190407,
0.0315524973,
0.0363487005,
0.0097953519,
-0.0063023204,
0.0273115002,
-0.0229022019,
-0.0056215534,
0.0213982444,
-0.0520472564,
-0.0550531708,
0.0190695319,
-0.0802167729,
-0.0170321222,
-0.0107904561,
-0.0467209965,
-0.0423862748,
0.0326833948,
-0.0327397995,
0.0074300505,
-0.0094661945,
-0.0330489911,
0.0201293658,
-0.0449344665,
-0.0207052976,
0.0988850594,
0.0087242778,
-0.0001650093,
0.0130911171,
0.0279483385,
-0.0081888866,
-0.0036779197,
0.0344192758,
0.0046943403,
0.0028003727,
-0.0265181139,
-0.0078585958,
-0.015843533,
-0.0774478465,
0.0457300991,
-0.0655267835,
0.0207438339,
0.0257693585,
0.0196405891,
0.0338559933,
-0.0043465476,
0.0029198234,
-0.0261473469,
0.018982362,
0.0285245962,
-0.0323304795,
-0.0036268402,
0.044108998,
-0.0198439509,
0.0166195873,
-0.0223080516,
-0.0585176125,
-0.0595357567,
0.0768695176,
0.0624269359,
-0.017489709,
-0.0007815021,
0.014804149,
-0.0211205203,
0.0237366594,
-0.0208852105,
0.0059884861,
0.0154296244,
0.0139483288,
0.0298472773,
0.0831546709,
-0.0107124066,
0.0357417502,
0.0156433508,
-0.0578379855,
-0.0205212962,
0.0314952768,
-0.0261024646,
0.02858264,
-0.0429269932,
-0.0137180742,
-0.0562687404,
0.0324275903,
0.0313426331,
0.0006981742,
-0.0124164922,
0.0201206971,
-0.0088893361,
0.0102061974,
-0.0384164676,
-0.0207277015,
0.0311417617,
0.024435088,
-0.0447016582,
0.0150266699,
0.1042096317,
0.0020115022,
0.0224357583,
-0.0291310921,
-0.0011267137,
-0.0543325059,
0.0780415833,
0.0151507249,
0.0032453507,
-0.0072449734,
-0.0529459156,
-0.0410034359,
-0.008968439,
0.0497476831,
0.0080258194,
0.040496543,
-0.0666909516,
0.0143030994,
-0.0109211784,
0.0029948982,
-0.028516192,
0.0626165196,
-0.0493695214,
-0.027508907,
-0.0140368072,
-0.0142266974,
0.0027360786,
-0.0011502948,
0.0033497007,
0.0071499902,
-0.016960552,
-0.026260294,
-0.0334264189,
0.0775222704,
0.0311474428,
-0.0019442237,
0.0325821713,
-0.0203572884,
0.0349875838,
0.0510795414,
-0.0209317952,
-0.0527562946,
-0.0115995398,
0.0338452607,
-0.0197533853,
-0.020315161,
0.0231091864,
-0.0323624201,
0.0261599962,
-0.1021554619,
-0.0229850467,
0.0562030077,
0.0119133508,
-0.0251361802,
-0.0238205157,
-0.0070083551,
0.0241758265,
0.0052924864,
-0.0007202181,
-0.0583101027,
-0.0349372774,
0.0042766049,
0.0283395052,
0.0017519603,
-0.0808440968,
0.0109422533,
-0.0551379248,
0.0110180276,
0.0043274476,
-0.0235796515,
-0.0593924634,
-0.0522319861,
0.0178972855,
0.0008643612,
-0.0127573134,
0.0247985534,
-0.0033621842,
-0.0111297797,
-0.0133778388,
0.0323229097,
0.0275395028,
0.0393118933,
-0.0069236686,
-0.0164396539,
-0.0055141416,
0.0317484625,
0.0262933336,
0.0183005258,
0.0036649818,
-0.0447731912,
-0.023053389,
-0.0317202695,
0.0414743684,
-0.0123735694,
0.0219224561,
-0.0833733603,
0.0621874854,
-0.0430699922,
-0.0137710739,
0.0190491732,
0.038505774,
0.0220541582,
-0.0505427867,
-0.0359350443,
0.0391789638,
-0.03581772,
0.0442185886,
0.0121973604,
0.009817793,
-0.0588654019,
-0.0310515873,
-0.0014788931,
-0.051776506,
0.0178619865,
0.0275768861,
-0.0109657915,
0.0126561401,
-0.0295334496,
-0.0545765795,
0.0023202565,
0.0169615578,
0.0070205461,
0.0435494184,
0.1094553322,
-0.0215181615,
-0.0595917962,
0.0153356986,
-0.0151762525,
-0.0027662488,
0.020415267,
0.0285204742,
0.0027755105,
-0.0184469633,
-0.0343028978,
0.034087915,
-0.0154875508,
-0.038925685,
-0.0305005144,
-0.0078201555,
0.0164450426,
0.0647286624,
-0.0099246362,
-0.0086582592,
0.0025962458,
-0.0201879982,
-0.0388871841,
0.0007206547,
0.0072706249,
0.0119212074,
-0.0143015506,
0.0375322364,
-0.0069825142,
0.0251270253,
-0.0050807879,
0.0629073381,
-0.0500755385,
-0.0312251449,
0.0189603139,
-0.0047949371,
-0.002976161,
0.0366590954,
0.0012697192,
-0.0617195666,
0.0392233431,
-0.0520417131,
-0.0328503959,
-0.0008919802,
0.0365526415,
-0.005705805,
-0.0498525053,
-0.0299685393,
-0.0718016475,
0.0199295301,
0.0539146774,
0.0330089852,
0.0084769148,
0.0491923913,
0.027880637,
0.0118955299,
-0.0568428673,
-0.0170901585,
-0.0025278924,
-0.0049782041,
0.0540707707,
0.0042629465,
0.0857001022,
0.0576224811,
-0.0362081267,
-0.0210638978,
-0.0157541148,
-0.0379913263,
0.0423596948,
0.0197020527,
0.0109795239,
0.0209574848,
0.0161517411,
0.0056444416,
-0.0180331785,
0.0041390983,
0.004512589,
0.0752589777,
0.0098592173,
-0.0368305817,
0.0321969092,
0.0179568343,
0.0034534817,
0.0309322961,
0.0250334702,
0.0134203667,
0.019132169,
0.036733266,
-0.0387481786,
-0.0331553742,
-0.0548309758,
-0.0352157354,
0.0390633382,
-0.0150753362,
0.035356231,
-0.066238828,
-0.0843401551,
0.0151975527,
0.0187509488,
0.0429164693,
0.0027608662,
-0.0125790415,
0.0416525528,
0.039466057,
-0.0686091557,
-0.0432668589,
0.0528014526,
-0.0658264011,
-0.0231661629,
-0.0183032714,
-5.588525692e-33,
-0.0588678569,
-0.0874395072,
0.011990943,
0.0034470982,
-0.0074648932,
0.0314678848,
-0.0581335947,
-0.0238429643,
-0.0391115248,
0.0553954095,
0.0123171378,
0.0386420265,
-0.0108605269,
0.0179125387,
-0.04219063,
0.0069870963,
-0.0094101457,
0.032351695,
0.0046019601,
0.0286402721,
0.0720656663,
0.0153774656,
0.0260515921,
-0.0477225929,
0.0084844893,
-0.0434209183,
0.0211055167,
0.068219386,
-0.0152405025,
0.0207612514,
-0.0160680525,
0.0266424697,
0.0560603216,
0.0439518467,
0.0371792391,
0.0729553103,
-0.1826042831,
-0.0454294868,
0.0468566827,
0.0033307262,
-0.0928862244,
-0.0010128671,
0.0258650631,
0.0162815116,
0.078318648,
-0.0801284611,
0.0547723845,
-0.0120415296,
-0.0164048243,
-0.0152617721,
-0.0638056844,
0.0530287474,
-0.0254950374,
0.0008935381,
-0.0065826857,
0.0208166968,
0.0041382043,
0.003132472,
-0.0618713535,
-0.0240093991,
-0.0083618937,
-0.0363397524,
0.0110292053,
0.051657673,
0.0039221393,
0.0431467332,
-0.0428540967,
-0.0390854366,
-0.0508132279,
0.0318564475,
0.0105842752,
0.0318146199,
-0.0081197228,
-0.0038397815,
0.0028845759,
0.0357797183,
-0.1280743331,
-0.0019697968,
0.0035916569,
0.061784666,
-0.0151069462,
-0.0139108114,
-0.0218269341,
0.0068791909,
-0.0366931073,
-0.0149665093,
-0.0272431206,
-0.0204749182,
-0.0117759276,
-0.0589778423,
-0.0370062292,
-0.0070185065,
0.0004926726,
-0.0265226159,
-0.0033546251,
0.0539451353,
0.0126167489,
-0.0031930534,
-0.0035191127,
0.084558554,
-0.0112239355,
-0.0171990022,
-0.0184799004,
-0.0055919783,
0.0187026579,
-0.0035891598,
0.0148682082,
-0.0512485541,
0.0231910665,
-0.0180872362,
-0.0162097719,
-0.0275594275,
-0.0393852331,
0.0424145907,
0.0523864254,
0.0782300159,
-0.0089465873,
0.0528174452,
0.0057202228,
0.0356963761,
-0.0256229546,
0.054311797,
-0.0087715704,
0.0258346796,
-0.007365407,
-0.0421969481,
-0.0072494536,
0.0217835363,
0.0181334652,
-0.0739954785,
0.0088089006,
0.0392844416,
2.534e-7,
0.0310296323,
0.0473449044,
0.0659162998,
0.0433208458,
0.0178162809,
0.0297429226,
0.0146318171,
0.0244891252,
0.0353321433,
-0.053431619,
0.0210322477,
0.0472302064,
-0.0114966286,
0.0436991267,
-0.0534585267,
-0.0522499196,
-0.0357880108,
-0.0294347443,
-0.0405250005,
0.0177396275,
0.0928487405,
0.0092894873,
0.0387721546,
-0.0178682748,
-0.0131896548,
-0.0356141441,
0.0186340827,
0.0357108302,
0.0228775665,
0.029705856,
-0.0044794907,
-0.0274805892,
-0.0156586152,
0.0678993315,
0.0131349359,
0.0262221768,
0.0029129582,
0.0307774264,
0.0012022525,
-0.0238901079,
-0.0234565791,
-0.0358270928,
0.0247733966,
-0.0381378569,
0.0576792099,
-0.0719595104,
-0.0488463268,
0.0280810781,
-0.0329632275,
-0.0133726513,
-0.0342788361,
0.0179840103,
-0.0037499296,
0.023302814,
0.0008588301,
-0.039885316,
0.0246422961,
-0.0844948143,
0.035827741,
0.0169497188,
-0.0079216501,
-0.0024364472,
-0.0052323788,
-0.032416828,
0.0244552754,
-0.0344438143,
0.0106123798,
1.94073176e-34,
0.007495922,
-0.0249040779,
-0.0214666147,
0.0102224294,
0.0502963886,
-0.0401403904,
-0.0417725891,
0.0337576307,
0.0386058874,
-0.0954237729,
0.0086192368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12043v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12043v1 | Sample Attackability in Natural Language Adversarial Attacks | 2023-06-21T06:20:51 | 2023-06-21T06:20:51 | Vyas Raina, Mark Gales | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Adversarial attack research in natural language processing (NLP) has made
significant progress in designing powerful attack methods and defence
approaches. However, few efforts have sought to identify which source samples
are the most attackable or robust, i.e. can we determine for an unseen target
model, which samples are the most vulnerable to an adversarial attack. This
work formally extends the definition of sample attackability/robustness for NLP
attacks. Experiments on two popular NLP datasets, four state of the art models
and four different NLP adversarial attack methods, demonstrate that sample
uncertainty is insufficient for describing characteristics of attackable/robust
samples and hence a deep learning based detector can perform much better at
identifying the most attackable and robust samples for an unseen target model.
Nevertheless, further analysis finds that there is little agreement in which
samples are considered the most attackable/robust across different NLP attack
methods, explaining a lack of portability of attackability detection methods
across attack methods. | [
0.0382957719,
0.054814741,
-0.0178010799,
0.0361605063,
-0.0384900942,
-0.013020657,
-0.0016004555,
0.0085587781,
-0.001321424,
-0.0683996305,
0.0203909818,
-0.0035327165,
0.0155278658,
0.0154358577,
0.0538441613,
-0.0197663177,
0.040290717,
0.0065275244,
-0.0315517783,
0.0011746514,
0.002791343,
-0.0230941195,
-0.0097533865,
0.0431504436,
0.0111457687,
-0.0138139622,
0.0176947676,
-0.0149375722,
0.0271893349,
-0.0142927077,
0.0252324026,
0.0265228543,
-0.0041121212,
0.0791499019,
0.0000015701,
-0.0258325059,
-0.0306260549,
0.0145984655,
-0.028170459,
-0.0027325905,
0.0500546396,
-0.0247809514,
-0.0122296605,
0.0186416358,
0.0034742155,
-0.0107182702,
0.0227623321,
0.0861191675,
0.0417322032,
0.1250703782,
-0.0001061157,
-0.0378184058,
0.057602562,
-0.0314475931,
-0.0571486093,
-0.0463779606,
0.0286769439,
-0.0302791689,
-0.0294964276,
0.0134134572,
0.0093011679,
0.0143820271,
0.0127913104,
0.0181325451,
-0.0578926243,
-0.0178315919,
-0.0363374278,
0.0059242859,
0.0047895364,
0.068431437,
-0.0481144413,
0.017760694,
-0.0215162206,
-0.0270466357,
0.0064400667,
0.0173825845,
-0.0199312847,
-0.0046978761,
0.0409263335,
0.0149384188,
-0.0238808896,
0.0091297729,
0.0711089969,
0.0273466408,
0.0009280191,
0.0173923317,
0.0057602255,
-0.0113205519,
0.0108844498,
-0.0322476178,
-0.0365793779,
-0.0007661276,
0.000054355,
-0.0107891168,
0.0060399664,
0.0098973932,
-0.0960755944,
-0.0665056854,
0.0475638695,
-0.016830232,
0.0571778342,
-0.0077845925,
-0.0384331681,
0.0287162159,
0.0225156862,
0.0271212216,
-0.039385397,
0.0197225269,
0.0090099107,
-0.007951973,
-0.0309921,
-0.0101086171,
0.0253160018,
0.0073145791,
-0.0174557343,
0.019600682,
-0.0452863425,
0.0232624188,
-0.058877632,
0.0013979018,
-0.0365119912,
0.0207834672,
-0.0133036226,
0.0357817598,
0.0087144896,
-0.0175802466,
0.0080940006,
0.0213697795,
-0.004858986,
-0.1353975683,
-0.0115758767,
0.0253304094,
-0.0363092758,
-0.0509737842,
-0.0149124209,
0.1156112477,
0.052570913,
-0.0438183621,
-0.041831214,
-0.0692202076,
-0.0308119822,
-0.0083912872,
0.037620794,
-0.0342015512,
-0.0238845404,
-0.0448981002,
-0.0001178832,
-0.0687149093,
-0.0056565278,
0.0154795181,
-0.0299487077,
0.0850583464,
0.0212631337,
-0.0428316779,
0.0136605538,
0.0183553267,
-0.0152626717,
0.0767933726,
0.0125702638,
0.0110657746,
0.0696415231,
0.048387412,
0.0349173434,
-0.0013519262,
0.0278851483,
0.0233891997,
-0.0047935462,
0.0038491213,
-0.0357608572,
-0.0248182788,
-0.0307504889,
0.0442064293,
-0.0101752244,
-0.1123420969,
0.0949756876,
0.0277701598,
-0.0265071578,
0.0338193551,
0.023255704,
-0.0028650579,
0.0062252022,
-0.0115069272,
-0.0497826897,
-0.0273112897,
-0.0708375722,
-0.0339867547,
-0.0088332975,
0.0249642394,
-0.0117572574,
-0.0479912385,
-0.0547974184,
-0.0188001562,
0.013874121,
-0.034149494,
0.0340703912,
0.032898739,
-0.0019566924,
0.0112802973,
-0.0258784071,
0.0148284007,
-0.0182910841,
-0.0451230519,
-0.0241409037,
-0.0349976383,
0.0310613606,
-0.045259349,
0.04037055,
-0.0683534965,
-0.0216337685,
-0.0112329507,
0.0287890863,
0.0231694281,
0.0549122207,
0.0074054231,
-0.0019654804,
-0.0509695187,
0.024456339,
0.0253756177,
0.0289530624,
0.0348977856,
0.005540167,
-0.0146084949,
-0.0367864482,
0.0469818749,
0.0486431122,
-0.0454667248,
0.0162821319,
0.0128287422,
0.0628235042,
0.0158558134,
-0.0378285833,
0.0317741595,
0.0424710885,
0.0146091441,
-0.0277748592,
-0.0078290971,
0.0496274009,
-0.0341689847,
-0.0042633242,
-0.0524888933,
-0.0027028897,
0.0767206773,
-0.0532222353,
0.0229215585,
0.0625614747,
-0.0344097055,
-0.037162412,
0.0127837425,
-0.0165265258,
-0.00643567,
0.0644328743,
-0.0412322581,
0.0582308434,
-0.0265644789,
0.001212633,
-0.0235989466,
0.0394052267,
0.0386343934,
-0.0421369672,
-0.0580539666,
0.0326058008,
-0.0509492531,
-0.0102108689,
0.0109412372,
-0.0329619609,
-0.0196719691,
0.0190871172,
0.0115265585,
-0.0273049064,
-0.0172512792,
0.0019404026,
0.003338686,
-0.0353772715,
-0.0091493661,
-0.0074800723,
0.0195691008,
-0.0016298137,
-0.0075491541,
0.0451114513,
0.0262087863,
-0.0200739484,
0.0050769933,
-0.0275262073,
-0.0347462781,
-0.0058126491,
0.0973090902,
-0.0132881477,
-0.035440769,
-0.0076927752,
0.0314602554,
0.0076385248,
0.0546182506,
-0.019064337,
-0.0418459773,
0.024921786,
0.0299951527,
-0.0502518453,
0.070530951,
0.0113275209,
0.0699968487,
0.0310343187,
0.0383738056,
0.0248368159,
-0.0083721913,
-0.0124800261,
-0.0017125657,
-0.0291613489,
-0.0157137252,
0.0457794927,
0.0564090833,
0.0451114587,
-0.0383756608,
0.0171344765,
0.0436068736,
-0.0088420743,
-0.0301322509,
0.0031489055,
-0.0006949768,
-0.0114988312,
-0.0092756813,
-0.0111015309,
-0.0437249877,
0.0740162656,
-0.0160620119,
0.0265838131,
-0.0343331844,
-0.0561405644,
0.0258045997,
0.0346459784,
0.0199027397,
0.0041253828,
0.02453853,
-0.0102392789,
-0.0259993225,
-0.0344235227,
0.0464178137,
-0.0064274902,
0.0359625258,
-0.0007441525,
0.0019917439,
-0.0142693287,
-0.0219473932,
-0.065072678,
-0.0203271508,
-0.022222532,
0.033291135,
0.0214234162,
-0.0336378105,
-0.0578894503,
-0.0341079645,
-0.0083001368,
-0.0199708864,
-0.0012162512,
-0.0089975679,
-0.0187486224,
0.0675541535,
0.0351936743,
-0.0333481282,
0.041074641,
0.0242018886,
0.0147230476,
0.0699887723,
0.0199947748,
0.0374585614,
-0.0624059439,
0.0095892726,
0.0143031403,
-0.0218347739,
0.0114492914,
0.0035177879,
0.0299347341,
-0.0444110557,
-0.0049246154,
0.0187503323,
-0.0171635617,
0.039782092,
0.02780631,
0.0332670622,
-0.0039013829,
0.0147595285,
-0.0184014309,
-0.0331580974,
-0.0319811217,
0.0049019991,
0.0275593437,
-0.0518051796,
-0.0124784196,
-0.0124577694,
-0.080972679,
0.0159379486,
-0.0249017272,
-0.0569581389,
-0.0450318977,
-0.0398742743,
-0.0233584307,
-0.0454946607,
0.0567317568,
-0.0316929072,
0.0447191037,
-0.0038594124,
-0.0063634906,
-0.0357146375,
-0.085765861,
-0.004396772,
-0.0474670902,
0.0440775976,
0.0827500895,
0.0541633777,
-0.0396633036,
0.0273046345,
0.0234709214,
-0.0389430337,
-0.0044978894,
0.0289604384,
0.0818573162,
0.002302055,
-0.0366146937,
0.0181463379,
0.0400187373,
-0.0196427777,
-0.0002252926,
-0.0306450073,
0.0146218333,
-0.0001406568,
-0.0025426836,
-0.0356755704,
-0.0066965143,
0.0266986992,
0.0756790563,
0.0107958531,
-0.0133087328,
-0.0324222371,
-0.0642874688,
0.0268728063,
-0.0554469638,
-0.0522359386,
0.0486004688,
0.0220314749,
-0.0285671987,
-0.0785499513,
-0.0330246203,
-0.0478632338,
0.0151707726,
-0.0004456865,
0.0189071037,
-0.0257307347,
0.0130381389,
-0.0376686193,
-0.0037404983,
0.0291983318,
0.0414592139,
-0.0269669108,
0.0035782782,
0.0281277075,
0.0113081001,
-0.046651151,
0.0229140408,
-0.088363491,
-0.0907144919,
0.0052074068,
0.0169874597,
0.0176507682,
-0.0013758988,
-0.0499736778,
-0.0967728868,
0.0702994391,
0.0453799926,
0.0175039377,
-0.0026877855,
0.0909445807,
-0.0243038666,
0.0147846686,
0.044215057,
-0.0403891429,
-0.0143176187,
0.0328230336,
-0.0195566881,
-0.0125283366,
-0.0008661592,
-0.0074344305,
0.0119578997,
0.0573557317,
0.0140942456,
-0.0070440415,
0.0302271917,
0.0029481703,
0.0243829079,
-0.0082070213,
-0.0062746275,
0.0272914432,
-0.0009715754,
0.0003187929,
-0.0130983712,
0.0071457769,
0.002897931,
0.0300892089,
-0.0214097518,
0.0162671153,
0.0345399752,
0.0462484024,
-0.0061928346,
0.0239908397,
-0.0200134199,
0.044523567,
-0.0298035536,
0.0225043036,
0.0296216588,
0.024227418,
-0.0063115889,
-0.0128300348,
-0.0013842772,
-0.0116476715,
-0.0832037255,
-0.0083847269,
-0.0197336227,
0.0065152636,
0.0192992724,
-0.0259231757,
0.0058470019,
-0.0200769734,
-0.0092624081,
-0.0257114787,
-0.0043567694,
0.0004336243,
-0.0171435047,
0.048892621,
0.0162443984,
0.0139458003,
0.0472481251,
0.0566750877,
0.0449597724,
0.0481310673,
0.007051866,
-0.0396653749,
-0.0170415323,
-0.0133714546,
0.0246764515,
-0.0107938591,
-0.0186461359,
0.0056324876,
-0.0240636654,
-0.0919344872,
0.0314308517,
-0.011895217,
0.0422074124,
0.0299568865,
-0.0364673659,
0.0603286661,
0.0204307791,
0.0598043986,
-0.0710064769,
0.0286577214,
0.0050080568,
-0.0360445604,
-0.0092064906,
-5.168313277e-33,
0.0470517837,
-0.0209803693,
-0.0616924316,
-0.0537358336,
0.0362830907,
0.0144228879,
-0.0105023719,
-0.0161547195,
-0.0536853224,
0.0012546759,
0.0133527648,
-0.0026343369,
-0.0187093057,
0.0438195057,
-0.0444064029,
-0.0672389269,
-0.0020085797,
-0.0243215784,
-0.0085576698,
-0.0293811224,
0.081592463,
0.0185474418,
0.0565167516,
-0.079362765,
0.0501726195,
0.0175692178,
-0.0009749753,
-0.0148011362,
-0.0236011278,
0.0749139264,
0.0045123314,
0.0357369296,
-0.0027013361,
-0.0298402421,
0.0099205719,
-0.025266014,
0.0181203857,
-0.021958854,
-0.0380469859,
0.0358770788,
-0.0260097496,
-0.0240922868,
0.0325796939,
-0.0268539675,
0.0018309439,
-0.0149753587,
0.008001334,
-0.0387635157,
0.0086992001,
-0.0412590206,
0.004029341,
0.0226405896,
-0.0473547764,
0.0292153135,
-0.0214264356,
0.0334941745,
0.0398958661,
0.0272338372,
-0.063304089,
-0.0120510105,
0.0400407985,
0.029716989,
0.0337087624,
-0.0274292473,
0.0108267991,
0.0719981194,
0.0195620432,
-0.0110969543,
0.0273497663,
-0.0084855752,
-0.0027699098,
0.052617278,
0.0823428556,
0.1122550741,
0.055504214,
0.0061421175,
-0.0978369564,
-0.0045172032,
0.0377717279,
0.0016647304,
0.0440229401,
0.0172287002,
-0.0713701844,
0.0031563872,
-0.0197017714,
-0.0953806043,
-0.0416368134,
-0.0150217162,
0.0187114272,
0.0082106488,
-0.0293045584,
0.0256694015,
0.001930336,
-0.0461199768,
-0.0089389095,
0.0391871333,
-0.0364015177,
-0.0263134725,
0.0126091102,
0.0015924212,
0.0120897982,
-0.0025666405,
0.0245268103,
-0.0416693911,
0.0428797565,
-0.0289449841,
0.0397394113,
0.0208936036,
-0.0266555846,
-0.0186929796,
-0.0083266562,
0.0231929217,
0.017417673,
0.0397693664,
0.0323397741,
-0.0287137646,
-0.0344972126,
0.0132313194,
0.0371300876,
-0.0001522509,
-0.0189488493,
0.0246274844,
-0.0515650138,
-0.0172889512,
-0.0009720662,
-0.0592442043,
0.0047186799,
0.0311324354,
0.0337911546,
-0.0849944428,
0.014772255,
-0.0512279794,
2.432e-7,
0.0120017454,
0.0166694988,
0.017474724,
0.003246167,
0.0344811492,
0.058456365,
-0.0048895017,
0.0780673772,
-0.0167727303,
-0.0400069021,
-0.0502448305,
-0.0275361724,
0.0265299585,
0.0196675975,
-0.0283580478,
0.018165648,
-0.0549417138,
0.0174076967,
-0.0164686441,
-0.0208992269,
0.032190837,
0.1254981607,
0.0398322493,
-0.0135447895,
-0.0201185364,
-0.066087991,
0.0204499941,
-0.0309398063,
0.0264520906,
-0.004341207,
0.0738707781,
0.0247615334,
0.0301584154,
0.0098582925,
-0.0451855846,
0.0129616652,
0.0164723974,
-0.0042919368,
0.025700815,
-0.0128270108,
-0.0292654578,
-0.0370805524,
0.0121883145,
-0.0087760389,
0.0681407526,
-0.0210547596,
-0.0338043533,
-0.0103524309,
-0.0199919157,
-0.0303978585,
0.061775621,
-0.0663215667,
0.0055237664,
-0.0051572784,
-0.0293333381,
-0.0071090437,
0.0155996345,
-0.0557356067,
-0.011272938,
-0.0227623209,
-0.0050402051,
-0.0008148407,
-0.0164502356,
-0.0024628672,
0.0718838871,
-0.003070672,
-0.0375542641,
2.16237099e-34,
0.0126207629,
-0.0189140029,
-0.0198722966,
0.0050755511,
0.032299377,
0.013286585,
0.0325769261,
-0.0256257113,
-0.0121428529,
-0.0097413845,
-0.0446412936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12040v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12040v1 | Strategies in Transfer Learning for Low-Resource Speech Synthesis: Phone Mapping, Features Input, and Source Language Selection | 2023-06-21T06:12:14 | 2023-06-21T06:12:14 | Phat Do, Matt Coler, Jelske Dijkstra, Esther Klabbers | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | We compare using a PHOIBLE-based phone mapping method and using phonological
features input in transfer learning for TTS in low-resource languages. We use
diverse source languages (English, Finnish, Hindi, Japanese, and Russian) and
target languages (Bulgarian, Georgian, Kazakh, Swahili, Urdu, and Uzbek) to
test the language-independence of the methods and enhance the findings'
applicability. We use Character Error Rates from automatic speech recognition
and predicted Mean Opinion Scores for evaluation. Results show that both phone
mapping and features input improve the output quality and the latter performs
better, but these effects also depend on the specific language combination. We
also compare the recently-proposed Angular Similarity of Phone Frequencies
(ASPF) with a family tree-based distance measure as a criterion to select
source languages in transfer learning. ASPF proves effective if label-based
phone input is used, while the language distance does not have expected
effects. | [
-0.0116616217,
0.0360163189,
-0.0100450357,
-0.0475472324,
-0.0364438742,
-0.0213799253,
0.0654207319,
-0.0090310313,
-0.0125526665,
0.0111520831,
-0.0904419646,
-0.0674344674,
0.0667725503,
0.0031541756,
0.0269777328,
-0.0859416723,
-0.011503702,
-0.0382083766,
-0.0080425944,
-0.0061847526,
0.0035554515,
0.0353772491,
-0.017215969,
0.0178174749,
-0.0531343445,
0.0313077569,
0.0026245762,
0.0070271045,
0.019758435,
-0.0187291056,
-0.0602538995,
-0.0076028788,
-0.0103503419,
0.0151260151,
0.0000019642,
-0.0541562103,
-0.0414282158,
0.002885811,
-0.0074056843,
-0.0012844979,
0.0904541314,
0.0333120525,
-0.0439645015,
0.051828295,
0.0230822973,
-0.036852438,
0.0832184032,
0.0150991334,
-0.0048914254,
0.0460282043,
-0.0247097202,
-0.0014997363,
-0.0086387517,
0.017617533,
-0.0170348845,
0.0237170327,
-0.0198877994,
-0.0019927332,
0.0026279588,
-0.0787882283,
0.0088872071,
0.035666462,
-0.0414604284,
-0.0348999947,
0.0112087866,
-0.0184392016,
-0.041421596,
-0.0518222973,
0.0182577372,
0.0572023094,
-0.0217182264,
-0.0184688028,
0.0211618021,
0.0231140722,
-0.0017661629,
0.0173959788,
-0.0323981903,
-0.0254148059,
0.0222752485,
0.0063509759,
0.0061691613,
0.0062439148,
-0.0132563151,
-0.0843326822,
-0.0179477483,
-0.0246109776,
0.056783326,
-0.0494093932,
0.030780863,
-0.0069592451,
0.0032067283,
0.0168722756,
0.056218788,
-0.0061676204,
0.0288903713,
0.0135325398,
-0.0212837607,
-0.0279616658,
-0.0286533646,
-0.0145863965,
0.0235822313,
0.0395601839,
-0.0251823124,
-0.0647344142,
-0.040958818,
0.0140972883,
0.0334051289,
-0.0338593572,
-0.0626711473,
-0.0142327193,
-0.0413683243,
0.0156530607,
-0.0305077899,
0.0248659849,
-0.0059679891,
0.0161543023,
-0.0426667444,
0.0014378752,
-0.0217248723,
-0.0048783859,
0.021216942,
-0.0266434178,
-0.033726465,
0.0016689595,
0.0107455952,
0.0714480802,
0.0039618211,
0.055686634,
-0.0280169994,
-0.100585632,
0.042359706,
0.0293389428,
0.0400751382,
0.0320113488,
0.0039743274,
0.0473643839,
-0.026776012,
0.0061440035,
-0.0468695909,
0.0088653062,
-0.0386076719,
-0.0171489716,
0.0195359737,
-0.0434197858,
0.0044821003,
-0.0103922421,
0.0091957664,
-0.0072211814,
-0.0203945097,
0.0070714401,
-0.000164456,
-0.000473013,
0.0072674938,
0.0409245305,
0.0448249839,
-0.0297957566,
-0.0095735108,
0.0259841867,
0.0619065836,
-0.0086359112,
-0.0049017072,
-0.0829725042,
-0.0376815461,
0.0449583568,
0.0102271745,
0.0289886389,
-0.0049990239,
-0.0422406197,
-0.0141427005,
0.0097590471,
0.0473879538,
0.0436655656,
-0.0037431102,
0.0503173172,
0.0721434876,
0.0584473871,
0.0618924946,
0.0617370494,
0.0108562242,
0.0084181018,
-0.0304431822,
-0.0036221107,
0.0140613429,
0.0045524267,
-0.0144695453,
0.0152533902,
0.0420558527,
0.0335732438,
-0.0123549215,
0.0074966359,
0.0226658359,
-0.0252378527,
-0.0353015475,
-0.0389977582,
0.0395191945,
0.0420936197,
-0.0307386108,
0.037921764,
0.0254269745,
-0.0678876638,
0.0286857802,
-0.0085506309,
0.0075620092,
0.0669303685,
-0.0160838515,
0.0234634131,
0.0171345249,
0.0012643778,
-0.027453687,
0.0272601657,
0.0008201829,
-0.0189306736,
0.0369708575,
-0.0647352338,
0.0138575612,
0.0748824403,
-0.0156627651,
0.0677043945,
-0.0795184225,
0.063563168,
0.0266457051,
-0.0440432243,
0.0146547975,
-0.0336519964,
-0.0247523524,
0.0139755448,
0.0304984618,
0.0314154923,
0.0287733823,
0.0312928818,
-0.0064956825,
0.0365424231,
-0.0159178209,
-0.0452409275,
0.0620708391,
0.0029732431,
-0.0416429304,
-0.0083652288,
0.0153381741,
-0.0558312461,
0.0459741838,
0.0176602546,
0.0512727201,
-0.0808590949,
0.0953012779,
-0.0091163926,
0.0230085831,
-0.0088040633,
0.0683199614,
0.0203982722,
0.0052102297,
0.0200510826,
-0.0232185945,
0.0509183183,
-0.0276405104,
0.0265052617,
0.0020289004,
0.0165988654,
-0.0581738874,
0.0277926363,
0.0575382337,
-0.0428012758,
-0.0105631799,
-0.0147007685,
0.0056348848,
-0.0093244137,
0.0043202648,
-0.067401506,
-0.0018477793,
0.0395428576,
0.0313473158,
-0.0091732237,
0.0262143854,
0.0188956857,
-0.0080889473,
-0.0448411331,
-0.0160945728,
0.0069368929,
-0.0045273742,
-0.0272156969,
-0.0310918894,
-0.0408611856,
-0.0214235261,
-0.0135812676,
0.0414700136,
0.005751512,
-0.0362606272,
-0.0410726964,
-0.0246153343,
0.0051525855,
0.0164559893,
-0.0029054922,
0.0344528817,
-0.0155572426,
0.0000697364,
0.0097200843,
0.0279986821,
-0.0068971175,
-0.0307388678,
-0.0640075803,
0.0397299863,
-0.0399444439,
-0.0288455021,
-0.0187299903,
0.0200978499,
0.0300014671,
0.0002270082,
-0.0405677706,
-0.0270406548,
-0.006999664,
0.0196261015,
0.0102587463,
-0.0414333604,
-0.0473872013,
-0.0097834505,
-0.0118464185,
0.0349449478,
0.0307110883,
-0.0200150311,
0.0130694145,
-0.0068167592,
-0.0252465177,
0.0002801808,
-0.0653729215,
-0.0335715637,
-0.0346636809,
-0.0211014822,
0.0069567333,
-0.046079427,
-0.0331111364,
0.0038826677,
-0.0406924412,
-0.0173142925,
-0.0433961414,
0.0089150844,
0.0282504894,
-0.0353535526,
0.0275237542,
-0.0424815305,
-0.0209552031,
-0.0185908545,
-0.0339126475,
-0.0082138134,
0.0508911684,
0.011725924,
0.025211459,
0.0444995798,
-0.0270884261,
0.0342161097,
0.0400012806,
0.0314185992,
0.0166943837,
0.0301378295,
0.0207842439,
0.0088389935,
0.0556437671,
0.0218140371,
0.0123482011,
-0.0240077991,
0.025261743,
0.038229689,
-0.0461674184,
0.044533778,
0.0217442643,
-0.0102530112,
0.0122133028,
0.0544727519,
0.0412727222,
-0.0513743833,
0.0310254134,
0.0352341011,
0.0188247766,
0.0130143426,
0.0618164949,
-0.036940828,
0.021161532,
0.0142870909,
-0.0133573776,
0.0521433875,
-0.0282686949,
0.011274443,
0.0043767286,
0.0078086117,
0.0570702516,
0.0582280681,
-0.01630513,
0.0439381562,
-0.0315736346,
-0.1368436217,
0.0058652037,
0.0357966572,
-0.0498415418,
-0.0781399012,
-0.0520009585,
0.0074544773,
0.0116146505,
0.0013647062,
-0.0067424099,
-0.0508402251,
-0.0341174677,
0.0626457408,
-0.1150686741,
-0.039610412,
-0.0305972844,
-0.016828388,
0.0683567449,
0.0336453468,
0.0330053084,
-0.0074537257,
-0.0429366603,
-0.0160175245,
-0.0049222521,
-0.0115740793,
-0.0102264695,
-0.0164500754,
0.0697657987,
0.0087726209,
0.0195801966,
0.0216158666,
-0.00101688,
-0.0024363343,
0.026865121,
0.0619875342,
0.0080296388,
-0.0291870367,
0.0396850929,
0.045337297,
0.0215842649,
0.0166417994,
0.0498821735,
-0.057815738,
-0.0010716241,
0.0332453623,
0.0065144114,
-0.0423017256,
-0.0062975176,
0.067869395,
-0.0441783145,
-0.090082109,
-0.0790862069,
0.0038747448,
-0.0027975799,
0.0803989843,
0.0405581035,
0.0026314894,
0.0161307231,
0.0349830724,
0.040569894,
-0.0487670191,
-0.0073993402,
0.0124772266,
-0.0247171633,
-0.0227871891,
-0.0241980422,
-0.060603343,
0.0124134682,
-0.0519156419,
0.0215210579,
-0.0368243046,
0.022243537,
-0.0306971818,
0.0131908199,
0.0345555358,
0.0194718726,
-0.0330261849,
0.0375547931,
0.0131070707,
0.0181930065,
0.0092047397,
0.0589305088,
-0.0035112614,
0.018644629,
0.022907991,
-0.0344237797,
0.0445909016,
0.0031303242,
-0.0018770195,
-0.0235078521,
-0.0416617058,
-0.0089050569,
0.026084302,
0.0373583548,
-0.0294580162,
-0.0041715172,
-0.0409195386,
0.0171826053,
0.0022971539,
0.0628637746,
-0.0494189709,
-0.0627189726,
0.047223296,
0.0782472044,
0.0047361045,
-0.0490223467,
-0.0110491831,
0.0092415037,
0.0622965544,
0.0502072014,
0.0129272426,
0.1022326723,
0.0041494337,
0.004042292,
-0.0404435173,
-0.0045322543,
0.0191169195,
0.0037069914,
-0.0151952673,
-0.0220328029,
-0.0105694756,
0.0030382141,
0.0408222079,
-0.0029937371,
0.0353310853,
-0.0274449978,
-0.0419005938,
-0.0379597656,
0.0072297244,
-0.010454149,
0.0904777721,
-0.023265224,
0.0443384908,
-0.0379525684,
0.0127175562,
-0.033079274,
0.0088558104,
-0.0275814999,
-0.0272597373,
-0.0147839077,
-0.0022415174,
0.0285215788,
0.0210700836,
0.0078407591,
-0.0643685758,
0.0356897451,
-0.0027958513,
-0.0413040705,
0.0144080315,
-0.0376463979,
-0.0131962672,
-0.0078767445,
-0.0520474799,
-0.0431601442,
0.0191820785,
-0.0514723919,
-0.0065975823,
-0.0272950623,
0.0493803397,
-0.0227361936,
-0.0295388345,
0.0501723662,
0.0052192667,
-0.0448634923,
0.0089610787,
-0.0006688084,
0.0145500489,
-6.023327828e-33,
-0.0274126641,
0.0313777365,
0.0062226621,
-0.0181565136,
-0.0299516264,
-0.0390177034,
-0.0152910007,
0.0023516826,
-0.0207192469,
-0.0044828961,
-0.005410328,
-0.0618212186,
0.0179125816,
0.027579762,
-0.0116313109,
0.0437716991,
0.0570843816,
0.0164244305,
0.0054930616,
0.0329240263,
0.0506724864,
0.048198007,
0.0551270843,
-0.0708185509,
-0.0708661154,
0.0033814688,
0.0067113163,
-0.0430477038,
0.059627451,
0.0131993406,
0.0075523742,
0.0591212101,
-0.0268568806,
-0.0627975464,
-0.0172192641,
0.0431257747,
-0.0564701632,
-0.0428000204,
0.0052003064,
0.0626569539,
0.0378368124,
-0.0134777064,
0.0084599033,
-0.0143413329,
-0.0291754473,
-0.007337539,
-0.0015321097,
-0.0609367788,
-0.0507901534,
-0.0306947324,
-0.0546584874,
0.0254634228,
0.0069347643,
0.007446541,
0.0429153107,
0.0950203463,
-0.067570962,
-0.0601683743,
-0.0171749182,
0.0522734933,
-0.0218911394,
0.0792803392,
0.0258741919,
0.0333897546,
-0.0159193929,
0.0030346299,
0.0720177218,
-0.0751202106,
0.0524391755,
-0.0362471193,
0.0433302894,
0.0354630388,
0.0117275771,
0.0464283414,
0.0270186588,
-0.079275392,
-0.021574324,
-0.0178378653,
-0.0312720686,
-0.0120431883,
0.003206338,
0.0266838614,
-0.0193679649,
-0.0160479601,
-0.0258841645,
-0.0177515112,
0.0022291816,
-0.0414928682,
0.0350064412,
-0.0383231677,
0.0116138989,
0.0064449045,
0.0823729485,
0.0147556514,
-0.0179320648,
-0.0280296486,
-0.0455963239,
0.0045606769,
-0.015146411,
-0.026689481,
-0.0638927296,
-0.0746106207,
0.0525708571,
0.0042458652,
0.0465452857,
-0.0260544755,
-0.0197680872,
0.0486893505,
-0.0640537366,
-0.0122933658,
-0.0118917432,
0.0154518578,
0.0258158613,
0.0118553508,
0.0145130921,
-0.0220226571,
0.0177723411,
-0.0090091107,
-0.0142969778,
-0.0084991073,
0.0508858636,
0.0119796582,
0.0015088015,
0.0001709369,
-0.0693648309,
0.0248269979,
-0.0290964972,
-0.0170013085,
0.0152008431,
-0.002859296,
-0.0281518251,
0.0004337811,
2.972e-7,
-0.0194869936,
-0.0050806371,
-0.0015852967,
-0.0362589434,
0.0000330253,
0.0047525167,
-0.0236755554,
0.0226915404,
0.0122911446,
0.0599479154,
0.0305101201,
-0.0478765406,
0.1313589811,
0.038579721,
-0.0812101141,
-0.0411668979,
-0.0478458293,
-0.0163951386,
-0.0307546221,
0.0435725898,
-0.0036740401,
0.0400176384,
-0.031006746,
-0.0590558015,
0.0032363932,
0.0014361587,
0.0063454797,
-0.0458050072,
0.0277960114,
-0.0303427503,
0.0420770235,
-0.0317836814,
-0.0165481456,
0.0079382677,
-0.0644150749,
0.0050982679,
0.0506297089,
0.0275068488,
0.0126505243,
-0.0382337272,
0.0489448532,
0.027045114,
-0.0545495339,
0.0026540372,
0.0192441568,
0.0200648624,
-0.0109344414,
-0.011708078,
-0.0222415682,
0.0316072591,
-0.024318086,
0.000791789,
-0.0003564284,
0.0069078738,
0.029836541,
0.0152536565,
-0.0256393366,
0.0501209497,
0.0266413726,
0.0384892598,
-0.0287130121,
-0.0833042338,
-0.0326886922,
0.0119238989,
0.0498163588,
0.0368376188,
0.0281315539,
2.266340251e-34,
-0.01030106,
-0.0443972461,
0.0342137404,
-0.011018944,
-0.0088167749,
-0.0303619374,
0.0375785939,
0.0427782051,
0.0312596485,
-0.0207767449,
-0.0282970723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12020v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12020v1 | Visual-Aware Text-to-Speech | 2023-06-21T05:11:39 | 2023-06-21T05:11:39 | Mohan Zhou, Yalong Bai, Wei Zhang, Ting Yao, Tiejun Zhao, Tao Mei | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Dynamically synthesizing talking speech that actively responds to a listening
head is critical during the face-to-face interaction. For example, the speaker
could take advantage of the listener's facial expression to adjust the tones,
stressed syllables, or pauses. In this work, we present a new visual-aware
text-to-speech (VA-TTS) task to synthesize speech conditioned on both textual
inputs and sequential visual feedback (e.g., nod, smile) of the listener in
face-to-face communication. Different from traditional text-to-speech, VA-TTS
highlights the impact of visual modality. On this newly-minted task, we devise
a baseline model to fuse phoneme linguistic information and listener visual
signals for speech synthesis. Extensive experiments on multimodal conversation
dataset ViCo-X verify our proposal for generating more natural audio with
scenario-appropriate rhythm and prosody. | [
0.0243597068,
0.032325279,
-0.0057309433,
-0.0175553579,
-0.0111377174,
-0.0250354446,
0.0096508926,
0.0254224017,
-0.0091277827,
-0.0266359001,
-0.0476005897,
-0.0361294858,
0.0552484021,
0.0786322951,
0.0667210594,
-0.1087664887,
-0.012577069,
-0.0481854118,
-0.0103784641,
0.0111514358,
0.0566474125,
0.0173945688,
-0.0497156158,
0.0121742319,
-0.0681463629,
-0.0022463105,
-0.0449241102,
0.0342033952,
-0.0065799481,
0.019699892,
-0.0695007369,
0.0201797169,
0.0305466224,
-0.032544855,
0.0000013602,
-0.0192254912,
0.0171923209,
0.0057969131,
0.012161728,
-0.0158827323,
0.0510501862,
-0.0431619436,
-0.0298643149,
0.0286456402,
-0.0237048492,
-0.0062660812,
0.0525787957,
0.0235371832,
0.0642479807,
0.0527226813,
-0.0322818235,
0.0343024768,
0.0315137319,
-0.0537267476,
0.0108305262,
0.0099647027,
-0.0269862488,
-0.0101738609,
0.0095987525,
-0.0491293482,
-0.058288794,
0.0548108742,
0.0032509288,
-0.0130079463,
0.0323044807,
0.0410522111,
-0.0217660144,
-0.0562318675,
-0.0267843101,
0.0998144001,
0.0085897222,
0.0186500512,
0.0252593476,
0.0128072426,
0.0121938623,
-0.0027424337,
0.002802752,
0.001254507,
-0.0130285257,
0.0122257341,
-0.0432512872,
0.0211054496,
-0.0198766943,
-0.0470178723,
0.0321763046,
-0.0615555532,
0.0196988788,
-0.0023755964,
-0.0129888318,
0.0201018546,
0.0009976566,
-0.044478856,
0.0333096236,
0.0174058247,
0.0010272448,
-0.0100163613,
-0.0443032756,
-0.0320467241,
-0.0541814715,
-0.0084783528,
0.0236228332,
0.002910838,
-0.0513264351,
-0.0306571182,
0.0262704194,
0.0162071083,
-0.0178963039,
-0.0320693515,
-0.0100405058,
0.0043179616,
0.0041836174,
-0.0226473939,
-0.0292955134,
-0.0225746278,
-0.064697437,
-0.0616402067,
0.0028491057,
0.0098742936,
-0.0446573943,
-0.0029720748,
0.0205463637,
0.0367421135,
-0.0466633439,
0.0087045655,
-0.0000052675,
0.0117780492,
0.0410362743,
0.0489371195,
-0.0024575104,
-0.069695197,
-0.0034939735,
0.0123606184,
0.045013912,
0.0320942588,
0.0032257005,
0.0687135011,
-0.0439776033,
-0.0133365691,
0.0126232756,
-0.0034185974,
-0.054422982,
-0.0408593602,
0.0178089738,
-0.0225532595,
0.00940191,
-0.0434443168,
-0.0166999213,
0.0237146262,
-0.0150631592,
-0.0134051153,
0.0250013955,
0.0342000462,
0.0139227333,
0.0431619287,
0.0378555767,
0.0007825611,
0.0266260412,
0.0179290827,
0.0563964322,
0.0043877587,
-0.0063747,
0.0033144131,
0.0421244837,
0.0790745094,
0.0222175717,
0.0131825395,
-0.0392925702,
-0.0143814441,
-0.0281997118,
0.0235882327,
0.0488052815,
0.0653530061,
-0.0231325533,
0.0058526164,
0.1043891609,
0.0154418573,
0.0612978116,
0.0182509236,
0.0410311483,
0.0318624191,
-0.0042734202,
0.0018184036,
-0.0304700006,
0.0336045586,
-0.0368611477,
0.0372796729,
0.0072829574,
0.0180132408,
-0.0536127761,
-0.0177357867,
0.0191192701,
0.0005668692,
-0.0048106429,
0.0036318365,
0.0031917214,
0.0429222845,
-0.0439477637,
-0.0016147514,
-0.043332953,
-0.0764880106,
0.036371395,
0.0255263969,
0.0376901887,
0.0545035079,
-0.0042990502,
0.0166234914,
-0.0079158405,
0.0199302752,
0.0022261301,
0.0797871128,
-0.0046279612,
-0.0301395021,
0.0923250914,
-0.0274964478,
0.0134343849,
0.0300577059,
-0.0124945305,
0.0097707668,
-0.0461241417,
0.0382640697,
-0.0127170766,
0.0225909818,
0.0693608597,
0.0192820076,
0.0037123156,
0.0128226224,
-0.0127238147,
0.0213943403,
-0.0010707539,
0.0010201125,
-0.0529370233,
0.0255058818,
-0.0080357743,
-0.0235033203,
0.0379119627,
0.0564270653,
-0.0246893186,
-0.0331889279,
0.028372556,
-0.0518713854,
0.0258321911,
0.0051940274,
0.0197523106,
-0.0780136138,
0.0680146366,
-0.0478831306,
-0.0042357431,
-0.034627609,
-0.0122532938,
0.0403811447,
0.0250326563,
0.0478771888,
-0.0371880792,
0.0051854299,
-0.0236522704,
0.0284260772,
0.0127866855,
-0.0099897673,
-0.0676069781,
0.0114582926,
0.0297632739,
-0.0120787472,
0.0201564748,
-0.0242008995,
0.0266528949,
-0.0407960378,
-0.0638659969,
-0.111740917,
-0.0222807396,
0.0204718672,
-0.0354036503,
0.0157474093,
0.0037038659,
-0.0119279781,
-0.0394030437,
-0.0946266949,
0.039342057,
0.0536432564,
-0.0313986503,
-0.0163754988,
-0.0054765698,
-0.0265772436,
-0.0627801567,
0.0037727717,
0.0490449108,
0.0074351835,
0.017040059,
-0.0170240197,
-0.0247157868,
0.0048428373,
-0.0232809894,
0.0550204702,
0.0028776266,
-0.0134089207,
0.0032765775,
-0.0022710036,
0.0890349075,
0.0402111895,
0.0341319256,
-0.012211537,
-0.0070502488,
-0.054137893,
0.0012588222,
-0.0008377444,
0.0033917385,
0.0443697609,
-0.0179143846,
-0.0170533545,
-0.0170929898,
-0.01143103,
0.0389308594,
0.0551056266,
-0.0830771178,
-0.0008469813,
0.0476533473,
-0.0650154427,
0.0019880075,
0.0105838543,
-0.0180847272,
-0.006213903,
-0.0322706737,
-0.0797744617,
0.022203695,
-0.0681138933,
-0.0644405559,
0.0248491447,
0.004132505,
0.0035318392,
0.0368864797,
-0.0034589812,
-0.0040004705,
-0.0011223101,
-0.017582709,
-0.083264783,
0.0045130188,
0.0049299179,
-0.0435268916,
0.0326964855,
-0.0467610806,
-0.027534632,
-0.0241352767,
-0.0058694188,
0.0005256035,
0.0023750039,
-0.0350912213,
-0.0062845252,
-0.0125057483,
-0.012499406,
0.0300038774,
0.019531114,
0.0113013973,
0.0158492513,
0.0064824908,
0.0054720151,
-0.0155842332,
0.0460817367,
0.0667084754,
0.0468557067,
-0.0616012886,
-0.0160156246,
0.0261102077,
0.0364681296,
0.0618723147,
0.0244380906,
-0.0386267528,
0.0412494056,
0.0276221372,
0.1017187908,
-0.0366544165,
0.0350315757,
-0.0037936859,
0.0006281092,
0.0135347405,
0.0455987938,
-0.0386765413,
-0.0216167066,
-0.0074287076,
0.0299723949,
0.0554213151,
0.0116568571,
0.0156300925,
-0.0424352027,
-0.0267729182,
0.0501179174,
0.00509841,
0.0163490567,
0.0429818779,
-0.0594456121,
-0.037950024,
0.0450923033,
0.0142776016,
0.0106832273,
0.028949881,
0.0408490896,
0.0144142378,
-0.0117383767,
-0.0155796511,
0.0177131761,
-0.0169592556,
-0.0008356076,
0.0332599171,
-0.0081211356,
-0.0270858146,
-0.0098589873,
-0.0330873169,
0.0462458134,
0.0363067761,
0.0439360254,
0.0176282786,
-0.0350629911,
-0.0009254128,
0.0142333619,
0.0098208301,
0.0015532594,
0.068790324,
-0.0239281226,
-0.0279140137,
-0.0254434962,
0.0770072713,
0.0036535421,
0.0053620329,
0.0200498644,
-0.029685434,
-0.015886778,
-0.0029740289,
-0.0097074723,
0.0656670108,
0.0120276632,
-0.0090533998,
0.0005860837,
-0.0897084847,
-0.0248933937,
0.0070594326,
0.0532191545,
-0.0553452335,
-0.049960833,
-0.0186612643,
0.0163245294,
-0.0613656603,
-0.0807981715,
0.0271680132,
0.0032303447,
0.0725468695,
0.0095573636,
-0.0403647199,
0.0260925815,
0.0187272076,
-0.0418559574,
0.0184940286,
0.0139487069,
0.0696147233,
-0.0537508465,
-0.0166106019,
-0.0230461191,
-0.0920566916,
0.0046144291,
0.025491327,
-0.0818390176,
-0.0568201989,
-0.0467320383,
0.0204340629,
0.0176589396,
0.0680575445,
0.0302854702,
-0.028614223,
0.0278643444,
0.0019459137,
-0.0067670257,
0.0829179883,
0.0457315668,
-0.0137638757,
0.0015888569,
-0.0085796677,
-0.0210286006,
0.0198013447,
0.0027774645,
0.0152470507,
0.0168587454,
-0.0462219678,
-0.0169091057,
-0.0076968553,
0.0223789848,
-0.0233443845,
0.0393876247,
-0.0558674224,
-0.0230591819,
0.0035132586,
0.0427040495,
-0.1110466272,
0.0207592752,
0.0160805844,
0.0719993785,
0.0162962116,
-0.0160381366,
-0.025250813,
0.0128312707,
0.0048447163,
-0.0194642153,
0.0069535873,
-0.000786781,
-0.0023475231,
0.034150213,
0.0169939976,
0.0117520439,
-0.0423980728,
-0.0027098334,
-0.0013872453,
0.0358552039,
0.0202675741,
-0.0644491911,
-0.0025175756,
0.0489893481,
-0.0311730951,
0.0275217369,
-0.0162543915,
0.0362877138,
0.0135250995,
0.0262096021,
0.0584322214,
-0.0022427421,
0.0355006978,
-0.0161056109,
0.0721360967,
-0.0649205446,
-0.0598791465,
0.0315175839,
-0.0203598849,
-0.0326407626,
-0.0064977626,
0.023602562,
0.0080685085,
-0.02512688,
-0.0462141261,
0.0558741614,
-0.0366463102,
-0.025174275,
0.019172933,
-0.0243112277,
-0.011365748,
0.0074094306,
-0.0385520011,
-0.0445411727,
0.0443949439,
0.0279732812,
0.0158468708,
-0.0593635887,
0.0310793426,
-0.0379496329,
0.000564973,
0.0234723389,
-0.0007787562,
-0.0341450684,
0.0045360462,
0.0079802666,
0.0076909596,
-4.559506386e-33,
-0.0437570252,
-0.0075396332,
0.0108969742,
0.0424523912,
-0.0556803495,
0.006132172,
-0.0393440053,
0.014978691,
0.0012794668,
-0.005381145,
0.0094980607,
0.0191308297,
-0.0039670016,
0.0540384799,
-0.037552245,
0.0295865964,
0.0401757695,
-0.0242305491,
0.0018068709,
0.0527192689,
0.0133236069,
0.0100217452,
-0.0118793743,
-0.0519025251,
-0.0213365704,
-0.0044773864,
-0.0402827673,
-0.0330674425,
0.0169264674,
0.0319890343,
-0.0288786832,
0.0146268867,
-0.0084866621,
0.0181954801,
-0.0144169554,
0.0527812056,
-0.0347610153,
0.020020742,
0.0041619763,
0.0373245813,
-0.085076876,
0.0452351756,
-0.0158660337,
-0.0008292985,
-0.0240121111,
-0.0385801047,
0.0333373882,
-0.0470133089,
-0.003006405,
-0.0084871585,
-0.0237325411,
-0.0128132915,
-0.0083571635,
-0.0702133477,
0.0300325193,
0.0757239982,
0.004543961,
-0.0354344621,
0.008285339,
0.1004912481,
-0.0142236175,
0.0097720614,
0.0770027041,
0.0443879217,
0.0259089153,
0.0317818597,
0.0614085868,
-0.0622965619,
-0.0016312303,
0.0232610665,
0.0278069507,
0.0628585368,
0.0178524628,
0.0633898973,
-0.0242009703,
-0.0226247255,
0.0223350339,
-0.0121348845,
-0.007726064,
-0.0317372307,
-0.0050180345,
0.0108299628,
0.0078705223,
0.0105956858,
-0.0582763068,
-0.0096827075,
-0.0306921676,
0.0061675487,
0.0632554889,
0.054917179,
0.0114495177,
-0.0018655321,
0.0684128255,
-0.0061143814,
0.0121130254,
0.0097574331,
-0.0886512473,
0.049988009,
0.0114958528,
-0.0204400606,
-0.0206683744,
-0.0108977379,
0.1374936849,
0.0313055962,
0.0200624298,
-0.0102641499,
-0.059649501,
0.0519962609,
-0.0345646329,
-0.0068107061,
-0.0058586546,
0.0759886652,
0.0021184587,
0.0261593536,
0.0155650061,
-0.0398979224,
-0.0569786169,
0.0107090967,
-0.0242129695,
0.0060707894,
-0.0182329677,
-0.0331258476,
0.0082194339,
0.0458906256,
-0.0317057781,
0.0437334403,
-0.0027401668,
-0.0740692168,
0.03850336,
-0.0189227443,
-0.0047300556,
0.0413352773,
2.317e-7,
-0.0546900518,
-0.0330194235,
0.0222506244,
-0.0126912082,
0.0464757532,
0.0478204899,
-0.034607593,
0.0352781452,
0.0108971884,
0.0003235168,
-0.010918662,
-0.0247194711,
0.0883108377,
-0.042103596,
-0.0071124993,
-0.0134019684,
-0.0267138183,
0.0073604812,
0.0101880515,
0.0113058882,
0.0260038376,
0.0320900194,
-0.0177375041,
-0.049138885,
0.044048015,
-0.0340155698,
0.0710585639,
-0.0283242147,
0.0005317166,
-0.0410772488,
0.0288005006,
-0.0560521036,
-0.0297388621,
-0.0054183067,
-0.0372741111,
-0.0088898679,
0.01927072,
0.0509744808,
-0.0257653855,
-0.0572497323,
-0.0225922633,
0.0526634902,
-0.0722575933,
0.0295375343,
0.0188997742,
-0.0047488855,
-0.0132714212,
0.0034445208,
-0.0236314423,
0.0011270611,
-0.0247618761,
-0.0389653109,
-0.0416351259,
0.0383334383,
0.0450082421,
-0.0104487929,
-0.0084250448,
-0.0123919137,
-0.0294045433,
-0.0329031721,
-0.0625021234,
-0.0353361182,
-0.0308144037,
0.0148425121,
0.0045972578,
0.0015266119,
-0.0648894385,
1.140840226e-34,
0.0085965823,
-0.0330635272,
0.0330369398,
-0.0192496479,
-0.0327559263,
-0.0225843303,
0.0015398124,
0.0131146396,
0.0370493643,
-0.0405129008,
-0.062591888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12018v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12018v1 | A Semi-Autoregressive Graph Generative Model for Dependency Graph Parsing | 2023-06-21T05:07:40 | 2023-06-21T05:07:40 | Ye Ma, Mingming Sun, Ping Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent years have witnessed the impressive progress in Neural Dependency
Parsing. According to the different factorization approaches to the graph joint
probabilities, existing parsers can be roughly divided into autoregressive and
non-autoregressive patterns. The former means that the graph should be
factorized into multiple sequentially dependent components, then it can be
built up component by component. And the latter assumes these components to be
independent so that they can be outputted in a one-shot manner. However, when
treating the directed edge as an explicit dependency relationship, we discover
that there is a mixture of independent and interdependent components in the
dependency graph, signifying that both aforementioned models fail to precisely
capture the explicit dependencies among nodes and edges. Based on this
property, we design a Semi-Autoregressive Dependency Parser to generate
dependency graphs via adding node groups and edge groups autoregressively while
pouring out all group elements in parallel. The model gains a trade-off between
non-autoregression and autoregression, which respectively suffer from the lack
of target inter-dependencies and the uncertainty of graph generation orders.
The experiments show the proposed parser outperforms strong baselines on
Enhanced Universal Dependencies of multiple languages, especially achieving
$4\%$ average promotion at graph-level accuracy. Also, the performances of
model variations show the importance of specific parts. | [
0.0237317961,
0.0790901408,
0.0071756793,
0.0337718911,
-0.0364567041,
0.0125303175,
-0.0033427617,
-0.0437335372,
0.0046939491,
-0.0139660491,
0.0134313181,
-0.0085678604,
-0.0162856746,
0.0642870963,
0.0186562203,
-0.048720099,
0.0254446846,
-0.0060468824,
-0.0011209333,
-0.008980074,
-0.0125502497,
0.0240221731,
-0.0081531983,
0.0311799459,
-0.0880522802,
-0.0245116949,
0.0117232138,
0.032621,
-0.0254855212,
-0.060510572,
-0.0283222403,
0.0262248646,
-0.0008079893,
-0.0185526926,
0.0000019097,
-0.0156448241,
-0.0297156032,
-0.002744586,
-0.0082782721,
-0.0219994299,
-0.0166980419,
-0.0791521221,
0.0046877707,
-0.0311373211,
-0.0313239284,
-0.0644736141,
0.0159250926,
0.0137227513,
0.0378916115,
0.0873747021,
-0.0388996303,
-0.0374578722,
0.034106236,
-0.0254933257,
-0.0345844813,
-0.0202732794,
0.0009820738,
0.0202106331,
-0.0178460926,
-0.0377939828,
-0.0806012005,
-0.0043068882,
0.0423947871,
-0.0216774773,
0.0621105321,
0.0238695703,
0.008579025,
0.0276750661,
0.0029694356,
0.0931584165,
-0.0197005589,
-0.0192421023,
0.0015998059,
-0.0430378132,
-0.0070779645,
0.049289111,
-0.0438597389,
0.0104036871,
-0.0154990815,
0.0738725662,
0.0294905528,
-0.0056165238,
0.0357104018,
-0.0267155711,
0.0173052158,
0.1179086044,
-0.012527178,
-0.0187295545,
0.0053875279,
0.0498578176,
-0.0285427012,
0.0140012503,
0.0426799469,
-0.027639119,
0.0048864456,
-0.0012956087,
-0.0286686532,
-0.0077443593,
-0.0230407007,
-0.0064932159,
0.0033521699,
-0.0034783571,
-0.0454349183,
0.0047780266,
-0.0164692085,
0.0123497797,
-0.0218257662,
-0.020172216,
-0.0324492604,
0.0370810628,
-0.0166972596,
0.0306481905,
-0.0585599951,
0.04226375,
-0.0231498405,
-0.049374871,
-0.0367258675,
0.0144856665,
-0.0248416215,
-0.0142146423,
0.0701671615,
0.0403368138,
-0.0291649271,
-0.0129535841,
0.0297920126,
0.0335889384,
-0.0138064595,
-0.0190509241,
-0.0275312029,
-0.0178662725,
-0.0034247539,
0.0228780992,
0.0543887019,
-0.0432061069,
-0.0268858057,
0.0626042485,
0.0408488065,
-0.0066203643,
-0.0221531857,
-0.0229959972,
-0.0115773492,
-0.0077818506,
0.0585913584,
-0.0585343838,
0.0243440755,
0.0368325002,
0.028341502,
-0.0114922673,
0.0024561128,
-0.0179794393,
-0.0120038753,
0.0127306879,
0.0061320071,
-0.0132785225,
-0.0291669294,
-0.0499266088,
-0.0183178596,
0.0362598039,
0.0257968847,
0.0144304661,
-0.0106411949,
0.0153936772,
-0.024749577,
-0.001690387,
-0.0003283459,
-0.0203355737,
-0.003162357,
-0.0481309146,
-0.0584734306,
-0.0291456617,
0.0784442052,
0.0725920498,
-0.0319606848,
-0.0219338555,
-0.0014419821,
0.0127262883,
-0.0051283846,
0.0131391305,
0.0950470343,
0.0114407875,
-0.0130188921,
0.0613776371,
-0.0635172054,
0.0018721222,
0.0533686057,
0.030738866,
-0.0460495353,
-0.019099772,
0.009524297,
-0.0069274986,
0.0329375789,
-0.0430776365,
0.0508642644,
-0.0466429815,
0.0661193207,
0.0261048842,
-0.0511688218,
0.0013929753,
0.0231822319,
-0.0098963641,
0.0031560212,
0.0301146861,
-0.0192503612,
0.0750303864,
0.0283327047,
0.0405058227,
-0.0007795066,
0.0174759366,
-0.0274795704,
0.0120615074,
-0.0093805166,
-0.007141693,
0.0187253226,
-0.0207780916,
-0.0392705649,
-0.0190447103,
-0.0053605819,
0.0339400135,
-0.0334716216,
-0.017892383,
0.0058386358,
0.0286449958,
-0.0072329692,
0.0036579871,
0.0343733281,
0.0481130891,
0.00862105,
-0.0019428469,
0.0090393834,
0.0382722802,
-0.0155425677,
0.0418413058,
0.0056561693,
-0.0532121994,
-0.0182042792,
0.0374321081,
-0.0913805366,
-0.0614252277,
0.027525112,
-0.0544636771,
-0.0283873249,
-0.0085733272,
-0.0263213012,
-0.0676778331,
0.0550491586,
-0.0420744829,
0.061618533,
0.0115201855,
-0.0118164979,
0.0618858375,
0.0374630243,
0.0137655716,
0.0851005539,
-0.0194597058,
0.0048692767,
-0.0263365433,
0.0432975218,
0.0040932805,
-0.0451467112,
0.0065282024,
0.0063004,
0.0055700932,
-0.0412272401,
0.0119291777,
-0.009105037,
-0.0271673761,
0.0384315141,
-0.037671458,
-0.0338456705,
-0.0226729326,
0.0470443629,
0.0059181699,
0.0090432111,
0.0257830154,
-0.043003913,
-0.0045335735,
0.0259411912,
0.0147827407,
0.0143565647,
-0.0170637723,
-0.0088932263,
0.012776454,
-0.0243091118,
-0.0769989565,
-0.0294726919,
0.0680804923,
0.0379153267,
-0.0583345294,
-0.0061632688,
0.0237046611,
-0.0203345902,
0.0364196636,
0.0116147744,
-0.0245457981,
0.0273253117,
-0.0386860855,
0.0525501445,
0.0026879024,
-0.0517332181,
-0.0064333035,
0.0141975656,
-0.0430274755,
-0.006899477,
0.0075322436,
-0.0162476674,
0.0781447068,
-0.0340346843,
-0.0294849277,
-0.0522007011,
0.0471792556,
0.0457354821,
0.0038042841,
-0.0437071919,
-0.0528857596,
-0.0428144448,
-0.0028589705,
0.0462666675,
-0.05395009,
-0.0028732948,
-0.0331526883,
-0.0633430406,
-0.0330368914,
0.0883317739,
-0.0056537613,
-0.0145583237,
0.0297509804,
0.0039801025,
-0.0490352064,
0.0558121726,
0.0738234222,
-0.0127683077,
-0.0029170224,
-0.0876618922,
0.0066095875,
0.0516084433,
0.0445756242,
0.0223946199,
0.0277875569,
-0.0175685436,
0.0483885407,
0.0129186399,
-0.0269248988,
-0.0117100021,
-0.0067549152,
-0.0202312041,
0.0154996961,
0.0229770057,
-0.0064135543,
0.0733595639,
0.001683886,
-0.0343516134,
0.0227609146,
-0.0366349518,
0.0088292519,
-0.0166898035,
0.042590715,
0.0492992699,
-0.0369233489,
-0.0204974581,
0.0054915803,
0.0171785448,
0.0259201434,
0.0480130948,
-0.0004346285,
-0.0751079395,
0.0340384208,
-0.0316392407,
0.0258440766,
-0.0419577807,
-0.0559813865,
0.02809247,
-0.0372768342,
0.0098357815,
0.0500795022,
0.0225733873,
-0.0444902591,
0.0247012377,
0.0199716762,
0.0455728173,
0.0159957558,
-0.0092839226,
-0.0817900673,
-0.0003751772,
-0.0093804123,
0.0001418941,
0.0278441459,
-0.0453618057,
0.0138204638,
-0.0992388576,
0.020460438,
0.038039349,
0.033291135,
-0.0015552696,
-0.0408423841,
-0.0459374413,
-0.0326353908,
0.0043347194,
-0.0004489572,
-0.0341957584,
0.0143582961,
0.0447411165,
-0.0414615721,
-0.0306546204,
-0.0058653634,
0.0032135625,
-0.0001944752,
0.0256992187,
-0.0078784348,
0.0085009309,
0.0287599768,
0.069957532,
-0.0254690945,
0.0198684577,
-0.0216451455,
0.0255241487,
0.012860938,
-0.0226510558,
-0.0225477032,
-0.0071316906,
-0.0337157473,
-0.0065522497,
-0.0666555986,
0.0758452266,
-0.0240163673,
-0.0203756634,
0.0103034992,
-0.035507936,
-0.0084049273,
0.0039270432,
0.0539014861,
-0.0025264428,
-0.0697479323,
-0.0499440581,
0.0413400941,
-0.1060271934,
-0.0081156669,
0.0295162201,
-0.0144718895,
-0.0355640091,
-0.0549704619,
-0.0661635995,
0.0096674263,
0.0066389288,
-0.0568915606,
-0.0083175087,
0.0397138596,
-0.0506827049,
-0.0028715271,
0.0488082804,
0.0196043402,
0.0102987289,
-0.0183881558,
-0.036075227,
0.0224924535,
0.0150625538,
0.0045407871,
0.0217374489,
-0.0438933372,
-0.0665104017,
0.0203213505,
0.0478281081,
0.008909869,
0.0359724239,
-0.0359222069,
-0.0204894971,
-0.0317553915,
0.016493341,
-0.0264911465,
-0.0005511416,
0.0171054397,
0.000767569,
-0.0117606325,
0.025929397,
-0.0318722613,
0.0442069843,
-0.0220449977,
0.0863212645,
-0.0357261449,
-0.0215131324,
0.0413838923,
0.0218072701,
0.0577119552,
-0.0071636708,
0.0643397346,
-0.058177989,
-0.0233799461,
-0.0620373935,
-0.0119861858,
-0.063564457,
0.0125219552,
0.0412817076,
-0.0041180984,
0.0082499655,
-0.0612707622,
-0.0110614654,
0.0289983582,
-0.0207000617,
0.0013904066,
0.0430733748,
0.002276235,
0.0287949741,
0.0180009976,
-0.0227824394,
-0.0095518697,
0.0383573137,
-0.0400697291,
-0.0089806281,
-0.002682342,
-0.0017489285,
-0.0253141243,
-0.0575816482,
-0.0461994819,
-0.0313428566,
0.0391221046,
-0.0030279141,
-0.0400988348,
0.0881543383,
-0.0005245205,
0.1288575977,
-0.0005754106,
0.0355359875,
-0.0060835537,
0.0591776222,
0.0081746383,
-0.0598688759,
0.0428576879,
0.007735081,
-0.001905187,
0.0166120958,
0.0934648439,
0.0534664504,
0.022978602,
-0.0086843912,
-0.01133647,
-0.0323835388,
-0.0332902409,
-0.0568986684,
0.0226913001,
-0.0316800177,
0.0349148586,
-0.0149928387,
-0.079059191,
-0.0359788835,
0.0129007688,
0.0279926509,
-0.0026545865,
0.0388381928,
-0.0059693572,
0.0089945579,
-0.0330339856,
-0.0266235918,
0.0612444729,
-0.0002037209,
-0.0271159336,
-0.0268401112,
-6.047503339e-33,
0.0015135929,
-0.0462410524,
-0.0032504522,
0.0284091923,
-0.0384510122,
0.0203614868,
-0.0591077395,
0.0225793775,
-0.011260299,
0.0207529906,
-0.0088127982,
0.0112231653,
0.0230779257,
0.048365768,
0.0546391495,
0.0028878301,
0.0468011424,
-0.043822974,
0.042334877,
0.0255860183,
0.0545013957,
0.0591106713,
0.058802966,
-0.0426216312,
0.0301933102,
-0.0296255667,
0.0006024839,
0.0051406724,
0.0262534991,
0.0272989776,
-0.00127073,
0.0263546892,
0.0584619679,
0.0133016007,
-0.0215187594,
-0.0369527973,
-0.1006646901,
-0.0351320915,
0.00802767,
0.0214432292,
-0.0754878968,
-0.0124467369,
0.0480837859,
0.0003862434,
0.041145917,
-0.0038910965,
0.0213884879,
0.0006119615,
-0.021508595,
-0.001485344,
-0.0439430736,
0.0351370052,
0.0037682084,
0.0287219007,
0.0478644557,
0.0506912917,
-0.0055191261,
-0.0240205675,
-0.0177646466,
0.0263111982,
-0.0824662074,
0.0278756507,
0.0346510559,
0.0137922037,
0.0124747548,
0.0335636586,
0.0166706145,
-0.0347527824,
0.0066177296,
0.0268063433,
-0.0168156307,
0.0653505847,
-0.0457215011,
-0.0400581993,
0.0271472428,
0.0236039981,
-0.063546136,
-0.0204020329,
0.0688360408,
0.0459385216,
-0.0548909642,
0.0387090668,
-0.006203129,
-0.034712404,
0.0333695784,
-0.0506610498,
-0.0092119938,
-0.0601506047,
-0.0188444536,
0.0084241107,
0.0056857783,
0.0418625288,
0.0270992238,
-0.0176112726,
-0.0503382757,
0.063753061,
-0.0189078189,
0.0610631593,
-0.0178436115,
-0.0013851019,
-0.0482129157,
-0.0189322717,
-0.01474912,
-0.0110731982,
0.0216536522,
0.0099029401,
0.0470426194,
0.0263826847,
-0.0054939818,
0.0007580415,
-0.0578179993,
-0.0112278229,
-0.0284411777,
0.0154140955,
0.0552136898,
0.0253929961,
-0.0380379632,
0.0423959643,
0.0000253679,
0.067813091,
0.0042030662,
0.0292256791,
0.0025258146,
0.0690247118,
-0.0349502712,
-0.0339687355,
-0.0186383463,
0.0545153022,
0.030188188,
-0.0518673472,
-0.0345069766,
0.0408349447,
2.606e-7,
0.0576934144,
0.0114002135,
0.0771895498,
0.0026456283,
0.0426164381,
-0.0210364722,
-0.0468664244,
0.0190410297,
0.0005646028,
0.0012289693,
-0.0101043927,
0.0199329145,
-0.0042599309,
0.0277722962,
-0.0685562417,
0.0536551178,
-0.056354586,
-0.03283941,
-0.0163467899,
-0.0069774934,
0.0184614174,
0.0321636759,
-0.0128082652,
0.0077480194,
-0.0349890701,
0.0128951082,
0.0371263884,
0.0330097117,
-0.0291597117,
-0.0203245003,
-0.0202584267,
-0.0454027504,
-0.0327426828,
0.0199946575,
-0.0138395699,
0.0224830192,
0.0358411819,
0.0047149737,
-0.0181434155,
-0.0048817084,
0.0533059277,
-0.006907329,
0.0021258933,
0.0234042034,
0.0443520509,
-0.0323020257,
-0.0177987814,
0.0147560621,
-0.0711895153,
0.0301227663,
-0.0324496366,
0.0099576395,
-0.0191649441,
0.0067356145,
0.0410853475,
-0.0275208354,
-0.041402217,
-0.0090436516,
-0.0424154997,
0.0215256643,
-0.0109760175,
-0.0057682698,
0.0093865879,
0.0157835148,
0.0136362063,
0.0321714543,
-0.0223041773,
2.08005034e-34,
0.0266808718,
0.0108542116,
0.027451029,
-0.0030142057,
0.0108468151,
-0.0361457169,
-0.0909574106,
0.0620608889,
-0.0157911386,
-0.0781098604,
-0.0506206341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12014v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12014v1 | 3HAN: A Deep Neural Network for Fake News Detection | 2023-06-21T04:34:27 | 2023-06-21T04:34:27 | Sneha Singhania, Nigel Fernandez, Shrisha Rao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SI | The rapid spread of fake news is a serious problem calling for AI solutions.
We employ a deep learning based automated detector through a three level
hierarchical attention network (3HAN) for fast, accurate detection of fake
news. 3HAN has three levels, one each for words, sentences, and the headline,
and constructs a news vector: an effective representation of an input news
article, by processing an article in an hierarchical bottom-up manner. The
headline is known to be a distinguishing feature of fake news, and furthermore,
relatively few words and sentences in an article are more important than the
rest. 3HAN gives a differential importance to parts of an article, on account
of its three layers of attention. By experiments on a large real-world data
set, we observe the effectiveness of 3HAN with an accuracy of 96.77%. Unlike
some other deep learning models, 3HAN provides an understandable output through
the attention weights given to different parts of an article, which can be
visualized through a heatmap to enable further manual fact checking. | [
0.0492730029,
0.0135608343,
0.0032078107,
0.0602633581,
-0.0439648218,
0.0291440021,
-0.0003097718,
-0.0160103925,
0.0162793081,
-0.0315988697,
0.0036349627,
-0.0273972787,
0.0086329421,
0.073941797,
-0.0140600055,
-0.0289411433,
0.0834739357,
0.0297336727,
0.0801828727,
0.0021688566,
0.03825403,
0.0340357162,
0.0067882156,
0.0209592972,
-0.0325140283,
-0.0230165143,
0.0238425452,
0.016732201,
0.0312162042,
-0.0150915775,
0.0150693515,
0.0313678421,
0.019691661,
0.0787013844,
0.0000020485,
-0.0045883749,
-0.0041134353,
-0.0284385476,
-0.0289759655,
0.0071680117,
0.0373784862,
-0.0638397336,
-0.0386242382,
-0.0005061171,
-0.028509466,
-0.0043931822,
0.0105343591,
0.0942454487,
0.0820030943,
0.1064901799,
-0.014657598,
-0.0235027131,
0.0156190814,
-0.0006954595,
0.000610769,
-0.0320529081,
0.0451314524,
-0.0014614586,
-0.0433093719,
0.0337580927,
0.0181839988,
0.0029861343,
0.059616901,
-0.0217196103,
-0.0274959449,
0.0300427228,
-0.0320619531,
-0.0070371465,
0.0011414643,
0.0474974029,
-0.1146381944,
-0.0494810306,
0.0073772594,
-0.0218276232,
0.0285888538,
-0.0082539506,
0.0101750921,
0.020280337,
-0.0252220072,
0.0085387994,
0.050077863,
-0.0183907282,
0.0137376506,
0.0378111005,
-0.0048596426,
0.0338301845,
-0.0251009166,
-0.0077152303,
-0.0069777477,
-0.0121670133,
0.0111497194,
-0.0427061096,
0.058734864,
0.0042931479,
-0.0020263579,
-0.0242834669,
-0.0750985891,
-0.0448853448,
0.0024890602,
-0.1250380427,
-0.0407229178,
0.002276889,
-0.0149779059,
0.0528680868,
0.0001478526,
-0.0125099542,
-0.0315213166,
0.0099827992,
0.0027855665,
-0.0094809495,
0.0389133058,
0.0170194209,
-0.0000163579,
0.0208956208,
-0.0154589154,
-0.0293696187,
-0.0331809036,
-0.0337140895,
-0.0136337066,
0.0168199539,
-0.0295352358,
0.0317910686,
-0.0357921384,
-0.0256974436,
0.007736655,
0.0381240025,
-0.0336072072,
0.029658664,
-0.0009614062,
-0.031731084,
-0.0137957353,
0.0342889018,
0.0072738202,
0.0293437932,
0.0116198407,
-0.0144677134,
-0.0302498545,
0.0004430921,
-0.0456851199,
0.0034115163,
0.0057230531,
-0.0424977168,
0.0158443786,
-0.0682829544,
-0.0357436948,
-0.0730509236,
-0.0036531803,
0.0157705955,
-0.0235547964,
0.0325809903,
-0.0137922345,
0.007456494,
-0.0134502538,
-0.032348752,
0.0444948785,
0.0234050062,
0.0226112437,
0.0636449084,
0.0131555544,
0.1284515262,
0.0291982461,
0.0214529112,
0.0026271797,
-0.0217670687,
0.0309598465,
0.0095229615,
0.0370932817,
-0.016683273,
-0.095026195,
0.0252886564,
0.0237012617,
-0.0140159847,
0.0155148245,
-0.0376774333,
0.0802976117,
-0.0234882925,
-0.0123216771,
0.0137787256,
0.0460378416,
0.0473235436,
0.004365813,
0.0269759446,
-0.0344639756,
0.0538170896,
-0.0309178885,
-0.0207869876,
-0.0417891331,
0.0562824123,
-0.0285622589,
-0.031762626,
0.028916942,
0.0199148469,
-0.0409708619,
-0.0152892936,
0.0012106105,
0.0231445152,
-0.0202137437,
-0.0053885533,
0.0142148621,
0.016891988,
0.0013228871,
-0.0320513844,
0.0358296074,
0.0337101892,
0.0025594831,
0.0155972289,
0.0255620331,
-0.0084608709,
0.0136359064,
0.0528059453,
0.0182528459,
0.0052148998,
-0.0470124222,
-0.0045970571,
0.0042751543,
-0.0259488616,
0.0157630518,
0.0377254784,
-0.0104975747,
0.0477271602,
-0.0004511673,
0.0259538218,
-0.0120633608,
0.0096038952,
0.0056538768,
0.0003567249,
0.0124678435,
0.0396299064,
0.0143397152,
0.0280177686,
-0.0010052219,
-0.0135479243,
0.0379978754,
-0.0124896653,
-0.0315562338,
-0.0486489944,
-0.0119417282,
-0.0248801708,
-0.0294162668,
-0.0791979134,
-0.0517820232,
0.1080320552,
-0.021366166,
0.0088738669,
0.0262664519,
-0.0430229194,
-0.0158871766,
-0.0415509827,
-0.0412217975,
-0.0213843621,
0.0467946939,
0.0395823643,
0.1160107926,
-0.0594473928,
-0.0333594754,
0.0070020147,
0.0128673604,
-0.0311243087,
-0.003376557,
0.0200786199,
-0.0138297416,
-0.0061332844,
-0.0013894866,
-0.0043270029,
0.0001820078,
0.00661788,
0.010938297,
-0.0131442109,
0.0097200619,
-0.0474353693,
-0.0037400092,
0.0392281115,
0.0041482635,
-0.0066663856,
0.0101001561,
-0.0579378791,
0.0071675093,
-0.0030336252,
-0.0188342519,
-0.0021423388,
-0.0414430499,
0.0381769128,
-0.0159107707,
0.0080597429,
-0.0361704193,
0.0274902713,
0.0286640096,
-0.0549907237,
-0.0233354513,
-0.0552166514,
-0.0163101647,
0.0168720577,
-0.0078917574,
-0.0299352724,
-0.0067617442,
0.0029502115,
-0.0088632302,
0.0849617794,
0.062372651,
0.0352662615,
0.0249652825,
0.0546724014,
-0.0115896035,
-0.0039585796,
-0.0216529071,
0.0841699317,
-0.0203097761,
-0.0438925326,
0.0267081186,
0.0308543649,
0.0409961715,
0.034037631,
0.01422277,
0.0460799076,
0.0247182027,
-0.02514413,
0.043478936,
-0.0201686192,
0.0011620537,
0.0005800572,
-0.0483245477,
-0.003897924,
0.0827877745,
-0.0031947452,
0.0445151106,
-0.0422266312,
-0.0212393757,
-0.0289413091,
-0.0368324779,
-0.0314721353,
0.0287034754,
-0.0238631722,
-0.0315513387,
0.0283154957,
-0.0140323881,
0.0238440372,
-0.0118337683,
0.0098339505,
-0.001879223,
0.0107758939,
0.0200110339,
0.006639034,
-0.0528299399,
-0.0691682696,
-0.0224032868,
-0.0244707167,
-0.0084328642,
-0.0201441776,
-0.1027273089,
-0.0310502443,
0.0595514365,
0.0773105919,
-0.0226807799,
0.0133559126,
-0.0146340374,
0.0670088828,
0.0107353479,
0.0204418357,
0.0773889497,
0.0184324589,
0.0100549534,
0.0691287443,
-0.0177945327,
0.0697110966,
-0.0321451649,
-0.0131559968,
-0.0015017317,
-0.0240799896,
0.0081869233,
-0.0437169783,
-0.0402475595,
-0.0648346841,
0.0162963532,
0.0649247617,
-0.0159461647,
-0.0345614217,
0.0189311244,
0.0371008664,
-0.0376308784,
0.0019238667,
-0.0003118433,
-0.0790096,
-0.0189369936,
-0.0002461332,
-0.0154767074,
-0.029943509,
-0.0228629373,
-0.0052604144,
-0.0588398948,
0.0146751329,
-0.0173181854,
-0.0316684917,
-0.0754769444,
-0.0702426881,
0.0161374453,
0.0235368852,
0.0057605668,
-0.0130126011,
0.0290982127,
-0.0578382313,
-0.0305446051,
0.0044433456,
-0.0500532687,
0.0312592983,
-0.0092465617,
0.0132358456,
0.0279896744,
0.0631132424,
-0.038435556,
-0.0587820001,
-0.0133866528,
0.021525925,
-0.0514906645,
-0.0118825855,
0.0404261649,
-0.0687567815,
-0.003112545,
-0.0372489467,
0.0508637242,
0.0110814692,
0.0279534701,
-0.0210770685,
0.0511882007,
0.0064699454,
-0.088069886,
-0.0552160516,
0.0330991708,
0.0309117474,
0.0262997597,
0.0363176949,
-0.0414800867,
0.0109502133,
-0.0066236821,
-0.0155909443,
-0.0294990856,
-0.0537416376,
0.0795186758,
0.0032965611,
-0.0620683581,
-0.0440870449,
-0.0189960636,
-0.0356474146,
0.021381557,
-0.0269113779,
-0.0432016887,
0.0293657575,
-0.0076992586,
-0.0190046206,
-0.0038088751,
0.0102408445,
0.0284687243,
-0.0036914435,
0.0279718451,
0.0059336377,
-0.0042134351,
-0.0270789694,
0.034580715,
-0.0543700196,
0.0172275659,
0.0006717124,
0.0263531785,
0.0050775367,
0.0178652387,
-0.0230839159,
-0.0430062599,
0.0125098508,
-0.0115266014,
-0.0136069246,
0.0007760884,
0.0006794611,
-0.0438147895,
0.0371781252,
0.0156809203,
0.0013747909,
0.0737986192,
0.0019903954,
-0.0510921665,
-0.050290864,
0.0267566051,
-0.0017683016,
-0.016990792,
0.0222539455,
0.0264150407,
0.022176899,
-0.0344647393,
-0.0072684553,
-0.0012381504,
-0.0154300602,
-0.000558414,
0.0396026522,
0.0302035846,
-0.0111589096,
-0.0045880643,
0.0007788125,
-0.0102045126,
-0.0315030664,
-0.0307817347,
-0.0031277186,
-0.0145579549,
0.0670495331,
-0.0430146903,
-0.0099965688,
-0.0757539496,
0.0223152172,
-0.0129143875,
0.0298814233,
-0.0152434101,
-0.0144467689,
0.024510894,
-0.0476365909,
0.01336997,
-0.0189109016,
-0.0617862269,
0.0250140969,
-0.0411229171,
0.0144435903,
0.0585610531,
-0.0112409443,
-0.0086420383,
-0.000373116,
-0.0068330886,
0.0045060897,
-0.0231679175,
-0.0079891216,
-0.0520976037,
-0.0326350853,
0.019557884,
-0.0124923363,
0.0287463684,
0.0261689276,
0.0327478759,
0.0000304743,
0.0592581481,
-0.0364057608,
-0.03988811,
0.009821997,
-0.000544973,
0.0681595728,
-0.0142873004,
-0.0001658617,
-0.041177351,
-0.025246799,
-0.0026339493,
0.0286133122,
0.0310810972,
0.0293489303,
-0.015054455,
0.071484454,
0.0221685823,
-0.038117826,
-0.0078143561,
0.0298261549,
-0.034112785,
-0.0407064371,
0.0236385092,
-6.463341812e-33,
0.0138875013,
-0.0723932013,
-0.0606056601,
-0.0175242033,
-0.0059466711,
0.0701315776,
-0.0257377699,
-0.0397662856,
-0.068874307,
0.0448555574,
0.0083727688,
0.0586394891,
-0.0006507051,
0.0101230778,
-0.062488053,
-0.0084173363,
0.0371012613,
-0.0033669989,
-0.0064540068,
0.0410126634,
0.0551944934,
0.0051011676,
0.0694417506,
-0.0254728179,
0.0112060336,
-0.0281852558,
-0.0469758138,
0.0100304363,
-0.0412452817,
0.0245417804,
-0.0052458029,
0.0138521641,
0.0528246723,
-0.0397601612,
0.0034093168,
0.0612974316,
-0.0455122329,
-0.0341317058,
0.0109013179,
0.0048816791,
-0.0735576749,
0.0079280538,
0.0701480508,
0.0256351028,
0.0117035564,
-0.0024281901,
0.0417886823,
-0.0199686456,
-0.0186592843,
-0.0369045064,
-0.0459763706,
0.0168296769,
-0.0140093016,
0.0255229287,
-0.035399504,
0.0472562313,
0.0252888687,
0.0126976846,
-0.0987863913,
-0.0001372737,
-0.0338143036,
0.0244566165,
0.0027406316,
-0.0404992141,
-0.0449959897,
0.0523186252,
0.0222048759,
0.0565034039,
-0.056794811,
0.0207921024,
0.051609952,
0.0191886388,
0.0735536069,
0.0534387417,
0.0350001827,
-0.0584692582,
-0.0904220268,
0.031842228,
0.0476930253,
0.0197046138,
-0.0089504588,
-0.0357159935,
-0.0334823467,
0.0439264216,
0.0177021101,
-0.0194077678,
-0.0344652981,
-0.0152888848,
-0.0126450052,
0.0239065662,
-0.0569595508,
0.0500037782,
0.0067444025,
-0.0304741636,
0.0411900803,
0.0377591886,
0.0109250182,
0.0032137225,
0.0199725218,
0.0498378016,
-0.0811548904,
0.0149108004,
-0.0090806503,
0.0129389288,
0.0064997487,
-0.0062731137,
0.0361051485,
0.0004964827,
-0.0251244716,
0.0042749443,
0.0105178002,
0.0167298578,
0.0007654931,
0.0310913678,
0.0223216731,
-0.0441249721,
0.0000099459,
0.0100194886,
-0.0373521037,
0.0079808934,
-0.0021494355,
0.0295015872,
-0.0396627076,
0.0386055224,
-0.0405156836,
-0.0040024659,
-0.0915083289,
0.022653589,
0.0111237895,
-0.1381648183,
0.0175323561,
0.0357540064,
2.831e-7,
-0.0364789143,
0.0449580736,
0.0032557589,
0.0052775852,
0.0133422939,
0.0392771214,
0.0506043248,
0.0608731769,
-0.0419584773,
-0.0716965124,
-0.0165336784,
0.0143951746,
0.0019609174,
0.0239868537,
-0.0872990787,
0.0090471795,
-0.0652832016,
0.0032206783,
-0.045425348,
-0.023612747,
-0.0046196217,
0.0739872828,
0.0303062331,
-0.0296436809,
0.0296356678,
0.0224291496,
0.0110441046,
0.0978051648,
-0.0284308419,
-0.0044046002,
0.0751513541,
0.0030960757,
-0.0133485505,
0.0017659819,
-0.0155101046,
0.0080775609,
0.0014813781,
0.0379955992,
0.0112722311,
-0.0151772872,
-0.0046131741,
-0.0621360764,
0.0227665007,
-0.0575252473,
0.057441894,
-0.0293993745,
-0.0302380659,
-0.0605795979,
-0.0190269426,
0.0167961977,
0.026261013,
-0.0018247808,
0.005414064,
0.0276297592,
-0.00916385,
-0.0321289636,
0.0178777501,
-0.0257570073,
0.0044671916,
0.0100392513,
-0.0453099869,
0.0189629234,
-0.0192768704,
-0.0556665696,
0.0823589116,
-0.0201405007,
0.0271457005,
2.078611508e-34,
0.042268198,
-0.0182623919,
-0.0023397168,
-0.007181034,
-0.0045430302,
0.0353477746,
-0.012670123,
-0.0432247519,
0.0385115109,
0.0008356326,
-0.0025361422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11976v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11976v1 | Interactive Molecular Discovery with Natural Language | 2023-06-21T02:05:48 | 2023-06-21T02:05:48 | Zheni Zeng, Bangchen Yin, Shipeng Wang, Jiarui Liu, Cheng Yang, Haishen Yao, Xingzhi Sun, Maosong Sun, Guotong Xie, Zhiyuan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, physics.chem-ph, q-bio.BM | Natural language is expected to be a key medium for various human-machine
interactions in the era of large language models. When it comes to the
biochemistry field, a series of tasks around molecules (e.g., property
prediction, molecule mining, etc.) are of great significance while having a
high technical threshold. Bridging the molecule expressions in natural language
and chemical language can not only hugely improve the interpretability and
reduce the operation difficulty of these tasks, but also fuse the chemical
knowledge scattered in complementary materials for a deeper comprehension of
molecules. Based on these benefits, we propose the conversational molecular
design, a novel task adopting natural language for describing and editing
target molecules. To better accomplish this task, we design ChatMol, a
knowledgeable and versatile generative pre-trained model, enhanced by injecting
experimental property information, molecular spatial knowledge, and the
associations between natural and chemical languages into it. Several typical
solutions including large language models (e.g., ChatGPT) are evaluated,
proving the challenge of conversational molecular design and the effectiveness
of our knowledge enhancement method. Case observations and analysis are
conducted to provide directions for further exploration of natural-language
interaction in molecular discovery. | [
0.0487860925,
0.0593907759,
-0.0024150501,
0.0088897366,
-0.0084077017,
-0.01917959,
0.0195412617,
0.0062226374,
0.0589483157,
-0.0156258289,
-0.0261000004,
0.0019858568,
-0.0180192385,
0.0811848417,
0.0420983322,
-0.022482723,
-0.0057907263,
-0.0208391473,
0.0037425549,
-0.0147916451,
0.0278631449,
0.0135688698,
-0.0034691149,
0.0125029944,
-0.0114431223,
-0.0330953188,
-0.0653718933,
-0.0202198625,
0.0158936344,
-0.0172646679,
-0.0300786663,
0.0771726221,
0.0362296849,
0.0312435646,
0.0000019312,
-0.0661858991,
-0.0058290209,
0.0418161601,
-0.047021836,
-0.0191502515,
0.05333497,
-0.0111472197,
-0.0107373055,
-0.0066217957,
-0.0415866747,
0.0080967853,
0.1029113457,
0.0115914084,
0.0112863341,
0.0520960055,
-0.0098215463,
-0.0181738269,
0.0279949997,
0.0014996791,
0.0884901434,
0.0027476314,
0.0236936715,
0.0475848615,
0.0540254936,
0.0174255967,
-0.0072249635,
0.0398649983,
-0.0136247184,
-0.0773765892,
0.0379485041,
0.011542188,
-0.0098682651,
-0.0361043587,
-0.0196033604,
0.0830103308,
0.0066701067,
-0.0180405192,
-0.0518265069,
0.0127792666,
-0.0083911922,
0.0178428069,
-0.0502264202,
-0.0021605953,
0.0209818594,
0.0105926516,
-0.002193287,
-0.0244295429,
0.0266576037,
0.0018669877,
0.0267462153,
0.014906765,
0.0011608331,
0.0005387989,
-0.0181999002,
0.0013643521,
-0.0415370986,
-0.0369146019,
0.0098632509,
0.0065263221,
-0.0039082193,
0.0180799961,
0.0353358351,
-0.0042321966,
0.0452901572,
-0.0576316305,
0.0202450138,
0.019970296,
0.0029441633,
0.0341732539,
0.0064384779,
0.0001877397,
-0.005692095,
0.0003441518,
-0.0329860933,
-0.0013784434,
-0.0836143419,
-0.0174735002,
-0.0456257984,
0.0246427804,
-0.0283087473,
-0.0150448019,
-0.0431868583,
0.0514078513,
0.0178068224,
-0.0094485357,
0.0108111342,
0.0330575705,
-0.0413945541,
0.0206260383,
-0.0466656275,
0.0111804279,
-0.0200347062,
-0.0147427954,
0.0036345869,
-0.085441649,
-0.042114418,
0.0038279521,
-0.0122839259,
-0.0262810197,
-0.0102115218,
0.1295015067,
-0.0236327332,
-0.0294283889,
0.0506536327,
-0.0624189116,
0.0024664118,
-0.025979029,
0.0368072391,
-0.0332916342,
0.0590113625,
0.0279129222,
-0.0130232098,
-0.0590551198,
0.0217866115,
-0.0119147869,
-0.0165906902,
0.1191479042,
-0.047589086,
-0.0531735756,
0.0226817261,
0.0047058268,
-0.0101157743,
0.0017059827,
0.0138978185,
-0.0065919105,
0.0066801189,
0.0034485685,
0.0229579937,
-0.0024959792,
-0.0179023389,
-0.0780947581,
0.0245214608,
-0.0067840614,
0.0051020621,
0.0711180568,
-0.0261440147,
-0.007820637,
0.0007090521,
0.0041809012,
0.0338511094,
0.054875318,
0.0160873886,
0.0756362826,
0.0163110718,
0.0663557574,
0.0038751883,
-0.0213457271,
-0.0042243819,
0.0555783883,
-0.0511461422,
0.0059613422,
0.0375414155,
0.0311038774,
0.0034284247,
-0.041491434,
-0.0163548384,
0.0105425436,
0.05382232,
-0.0461666062,
0.0265677534,
-0.008091243,
-0.0685896426,
0.0050623007,
0.0556781366,
-0.0451919697,
-0.0060733259,
-0.0217643026,
0.0221884716,
0.0847195089,
0.0576649792,
-0.0697169825,
-0.0066000796,
0.0223229863,
-0.0274232421,
0.057818532,
0.0392229855,
-0.0276442785,
0.0002431722,
0.0165707078,
-0.0176441502,
-0.046909146,
0.0035693448,
-0.0048049334,
-0.0081202332,
-0.0002980327,
-0.0017158521,
-0.0268945768,
-0.0146986246,
0.0168682616,
0.0389880687,
-0.0437215641,
-0.008775997,
-0.00378423,
0.015736144,
0.0082823951,
0.0030624017,
0.0481244624,
0.0501975045,
-0.0345075764,
-0.022364419,
-0.0082740225,
0.0244117565,
-0.0773401931,
0.0296909399,
-0.0622129329,
0.0003882875,
-0.0346112102,
-0.048611287,
-0.0342255309,
0.0685848445,
-0.0415487327,
0.0223984122,
-0.0324880704,
-0.0327191018,
0.0302110184,
0.0523730479,
-0.0367013291,
0.0424139239,
0.0500916429,
-0.0177328605,
-0.0190929286,
-0.0008017492,
0.0257556271,
-0.0439445004,
0.0208995249,
0.0074179396,
0.0482783727,
0.0107805291,
0.0487470254,
-0.0132896816,
-0.0174810309,
-0.0017867963,
-0.0566731952,
-0.0315706506,
0.0012131435,
0.0051543983,
-0.0120716896,
-0.0024602781,
-0.0002012139,
-0.0233675763,
-0.0248077214,
-0.0139237707,
-0.0366999544,
-0.0219254643,
0.0659245402,
0.0138499429,
-0.0585894473,
-0.04957987,
-0.0232817139,
-0.0316932164,
0.0580792092,
0.054916352,
-0.0707983598,
0.003294664,
-0.0076206746,
-0.0126182809,
0.0293401964,
0.0260757823,
-0.0156987105,
0.0268251877,
-0.0196959805,
0.0131695084,
0.0269603934,
-0.0270309485,
0.0442465432,
0.0701173022,
0.015273395,
0.0014586825,
0.0197475348,
-0.0425879471,
-0.0044817468,
0.0564377755,
-0.0071104942,
0.0216927808,
0.067658253,
-0.0289632678,
0.0033115717,
-0.0393255502,
0.0538700037,
0.0442020148,
-0.0339450128,
-0.0384705551,
-0.0016569153,
0.0077052847,
0.032051228,
0.0258530863,
-0.0606137142,
0.0959455967,
-0.0246190224,
-0.0042786882,
-0.0621719845,
-0.0097355815,
0.0407955386,
0.0425123237,
0.0102930991,
0.0246426649,
0.0441072322,
0.0043013287,
-0.0020285719,
-0.0211844817,
0.0406820923,
-0.0043995795,
-0.0208713375,
-0.0614469796,
-0.002491632,
0.0306008141,
-0.0441246778,
-0.0188186616,
0.0276362263,
-0.0375360101,
0.0322113931,
0.0764589235,
-0.0508243255,
-0.0159250051,
0.0133562302,
0.0314931571,
-0.0026676443,
-0.0015601955,
-0.0092179803,
-0.0415195562,
0.0016022917,
0.0086977975,
-0.0290807914,
-0.0076451506,
-0.0101285074,
0.0458117761,
0.038593892,
-0.0357509144,
-0.010783039,
-0.0014590411,
0.0144815864,
-0.0042144116,
0.0037444448,
-0.0067405575,
0.0202158112,
0.0027768193,
-0.0304355901,
-0.0271297917,
0.0924903452,
0.0329982713,
-0.0018882323,
0.0443006493,
-0.0042518959,
-0.0239923261,
-0.042893026,
0.0872766078,
-0.1084099337,
-0.0278395172,
-0.0571749359,
-0.0093995957,
-0.0298444815,
-0.0286178477,
-0.036453858,
-0.0671818107,
0.0496524535,
0.0083421199,
-0.0441954471,
-0.0247490443,
-0.0840964839,
-0.0530012026,
-0.0214875024,
-0.00533331,
0.0196126495,
0.0086559681,
0.0010126329,
0.007978214,
-0.0423311144,
-0.0500419699,
0.009528975,
0.0047992775,
-0.0187267978,
0.0667600036,
0.0504021831,
0.0167895798,
-0.0045270626,
-0.0101685943,
0.0934252366,
0.0534198768,
-0.024076106,
0.0648845583,
0.0280539393,
-0.0353127271,
-0.0551404282,
0.0222682692,
-0.0219730604,
-0.0579798371,
-0.0531855412,
0.0973520875,
-0.0320265517,
0.0041902773,
-0.0278504509,
0.0309747197,
0.0012434365,
0.0638433397,
0.0018533147,
-0.0276061557,
-0.0596069731,
-0.0157566182,
0.0371700153,
-0.0295966808,
-0.0166645292,
-0.0441946387,
-0.0109913927,
-0.0165879298,
-0.0493621379,
-0.0278499462,
0.0519105084,
-0.0102533614,
0.0003813715,
0.0089532798,
0.0217022877,
-0.0118148997,
-0.0246615391,
0.0507786311,
0.00911415,
-0.0206855852,
-0.0137236947,
-0.0856624618,
0.0104074972,
-0.0308846068,
-0.0059039001,
0.0657943189,
-0.0227188673,
-0.0748955086,
-0.0507749729,
0.0496669635,
0.0231785662,
0.0203131065,
-0.0139616672,
-0.0784431249,
0.0204120707,
0.0506195948,
-0.0018214791,
-0.0466330014,
-0.0038186717,
0.0106351264,
-0.0180075224,
-0.0028772531,
0.0053099967,
-0.0110773938,
-0.0201363377,
0.0058443076,
-0.0090373456,
-0.0449156426,
0.0559756868,
0.0226901174,
0.0709046796,
0.0046883109,
0.0204719882,
-0.0262350868,
-0.0224691443,
-0.0115790563,
-0.0009867431,
-0.0582150631,
-0.0110970195,
0.0150383273,
-0.0058913012,
0.0034055333,
-0.004350442,
-0.0777388737,
0.0010174377,
0.0145981843,
0.0251322091,
0.0109985527,
-0.0147744212,
0.0687863678,
0.0006658534,
0.0073191151,
0.0188264288,
-0.0291338805,
0.0381065644,
-0.0134587698,
0.0207286254,
0.0127610099,
0.0400953479,
-0.0218070541,
0.0194127448,
-0.0109986458,
-0.0469102152,
-0.0663362965,
0.0731544942,
0.0433692448,
-0.0021051776,
0.0142540829,
-0.0412561484,
-0.0113694929,
-0.0061676973,
0.0611714721,
0.0120063368,
-0.0481197946,
0.0642847195,
0.0190908089,
-0.0396114737,
-0.0671719238,
0.0537752733,
0.0095258234,
0.0221341457,
-0.0274168663,
-0.0528168194,
-0.0308437254,
-0.0102105942,
-0.0118981013,
-0.0100859301,
-0.0283060633,
0.0227271356,
-0.0453271158,
-0.0538994446,
0.0010099697,
0.0373820439,
-0.0389359035,
0.0134554906,
0.0788606927,
0.0312117655,
0.0113970488,
-0.0801029429,
0.0140060773,
0.0375540778,
0.0006132185,
-0.0285766833,
-0.0266599115,
-5.721356186e-33,
-0.0154746585,
-0.0263869949,
0.0067170835,
0.0353786238,
0.030752359,
-0.0358966403,
-0.1067717001,
0.0168653689,
0.0229465533,
0.1019700766,
0.01161284,
-0.0200791173,
0.0144444071,
-0.0415806808,
-0.0121358139,
-0.0044052438,
0.0334861539,
0.0241276473,
-0.0050485772,
0.0231408644,
0.0528910346,
0.0527945049,
0.070334956,
-0.0524978191,
0.0201928355,
0.0293051694,
-0.0054803742,
0.0122144707,
-0.0250202622,
0.023767747,
-0.0353174098,
0.0602904819,
-0.0492638163,
-0.0158580225,
-0.0510357469,
0.0096454378,
-0.0264363475,
-0.0284133554,
0.033227399,
0.0240032859,
-0.0105373468,
-0.0190410223,
-0.0091509679,
-0.0208767708,
-0.0426527634,
0.0213548038,
0.0471093059,
0.0071810628,
0.005807634,
-0.0020287468,
-0.0859584734,
-0.0030468102,
-0.017743703,
-0.0235697031,
0.0251688641,
-0.0265897773,
0.0247029513,
-0.0575889945,
0.0108942222,
0.0535846688,
0.045793131,
0.0140357362,
0.0625403896,
0.0011667092,
0.0185607243,
0.041200228,
0.0169006176,
0.0206455886,
0.0071833539,
0.0384431183,
0.0021990817,
0.0529997833,
0.0328974985,
0.0292869527,
0.0216022395,
0.0357449055,
-0.1111030504,
0.0105820121,
-0.0239315834,
0.0218312833,
-0.0377224721,
0.0496391729,
0.0042744912,
-0.0572452582,
-0.0139426123,
0.0292655043,
-0.0062076515,
-0.0504754744,
-0.0404550731,
-0.0544382259,
-0.013029675,
-0.0142915035,
-0.0011637353,
-0.0308605209,
-0.0422497988,
0.0171858687,
-0.0146834133,
0.0036971483,
-0.0371680781,
-0.0392333046,
-0.0420712754,
-0.0395686999,
0.040174026,
-0.0256721452,
0.015307948,
-0.0073150625,
-0.0111017637,
0.0410847999,
-0.0128405346,
0.0103284894,
-0.0732019544,
0.0081479205,
0.0388855264,
0.0024202093,
0.00771775,
0.0236746464,
-0.0291266479,
0.0329394639,
0.0148240868,
-0.0010796769,
0.008130433,
0.0232744813,
0.0013542043,
0.0083909426,
-0.0850751474,
-0.0108566387,
-0.024323741,
-0.0212631561,
0.0542169958,
-0.0706959441,
-0.0330190919,
-0.0276470464,
2.74e-7,
0.0852586776,
0.0500347503,
0.064853251,
0.0075861975,
-0.0065570809,
0.016095547,
0.0097665275,
0.0281694401,
-0.0456291325,
-0.0301375203,
0.0068677654,
0.0146134924,
0.0153555544,
-0.0017637361,
-0.0474516079,
0.0001614637,
-0.024834659,
-0.0235514436,
-0.0692460835,
0.009458934,
0.0315818228,
0.0678990334,
-0.0022476229,
0.0014985446,
0.0008515232,
-0.0251676813,
0.030973427,
-0.0436140895,
0.006755135,
0.0520615689,
0.002859104,
-0.0304563437,
-0.0037619439,
0.0568300746,
-0.0389010832,
-0.0342099816,
0.0037379921,
0.0338822156,
-0.0384850726,
-0.0037467207,
0.0234081894,
-0.0175936371,
0.0116117587,
0.0012284375,
-0.0085122082,
-0.0643059462,
-0.0293570738,
0.0193771794,
0.0139580769,
-0.0066274144,
0.0154444017,
-0.0155034754,
-0.0006579967,
0.0387589745,
-0.0007521986,
0.0178978276,
0.0258866325,
-0.0284343325,
-0.0487576537,
0.0045225113,
-0.0260136873,
0.0206397679,
-0.0312102884,
-0.0192339625,
0.0202683024,
0.0135595771,
0.0038230731,
2.199898647e-34,
0.0545390882,
0.0051635895,
0.0066024507,
0.014022626,
0.07757999,
0.00605678,
0.0265757851,
0.0208062846,
0.0346336849,
-0.0763911679,
-0.0304093305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11943v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11943v2 | Towards Understanding What Code Language Models Learned | 2023-06-20T23:42:14 | 2024-02-27T21:24:14 | Toufique Ahmed, Dian Yu, Chengxuan Huang, Cathy Wang, Prem Devanbu, Kenji Sagae | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG | Pre-trained language models are effective in a variety of natural language
tasks, but it has been argued their capabilities fall short of fully learning
meaning or understanding language. To understand the extent to which language
models can learn some form of meaning, we investigate their ability to capture
semantics of code beyond superficial frequency and co-occurrence. In contrast
to previous research on probing models for linguistic features, we study
pre-trained models in a setting that allows for objective and straightforward
evaluation of a model's ability to learn semantics. In this paper, we examine
whether such models capture the semantics of code, which is precisely and
formally defined. Through experiments involving the manipulation of code
fragments, we show that code pre-trained models of code learn a robust
representation of the computational semantics of code that goes beyond
superficial features of form alone | [
0.0169749465,
0.0622135662,
-0.0537802465,
0.0404331833,
-0.0134288464,
0.0291420482,
-0.045784574,
0.0125366533,
-0.0232575871,
-0.0486379638,
-0.0362463668,
0.0190484934,
0.0149541115,
0.0720854625,
0.0404237062,
-0.0015046209,
0.0646956861,
-0.0351167619,
-0.0255410653,
0.0357810594,
0.0141845215,
0.010140039,
0.0361977443,
0.0549191087,
-0.00691619,
-0.0115463967,
-0.0373679958,
-0.0052831555,
-0.0592545643,
-0.0134295952,
0.0046428493,
0.0319748446,
0.0189818777,
0.0071214889,
0.0000019053,
-0.0244218055,
-0.0280541144,
-0.0191957075,
-0.0075888038,
0.0403199643,
0.0301872026,
-0.0254980717,
-0.0098921442,
-0.01329403,
-0.0642342716,
-0.0358289666,
0.0801447853,
-0.0361489132,
0.0502111316,
0.0505656376,
-0.0014867996,
-0.0032644048,
0.0117401807,
0.0069573205,
0.0451180488,
-0.0332702883,
0.0047597769,
0.0484355688,
0.0151371984,
0.0109010637,
-0.0143257128,
0.0046510403,
0.0125647783,
0.0296733957,
-0.0237165336,
0.0356725678,
-0.0436818749,
-0.0154561317,
-0.0013026223,
0.0129370624,
-0.0640357286,
-0.0625866875,
0.0119750546,
-0.0267699733,
-0.013395926,
-0.0180518143,
-0.0107746348,
0.0137334419,
0.02839485,
0.0211613812,
0.0164163746,
0.0021988729,
0.037938904,
0.0032956051,
-0.0373770706,
0.0569956414,
-0.0027642217,
-0.0059956387,
-0.0063445582,
-0.0132879959,
0.0158027224,
-0.0643672198,
-0.0242895707,
0.0441456698,
0.0302290022,
0.035979446,
-0.0314371176,
-0.01856062,
0.032829389,
-0.0389689058,
0.0356626622,
0.0290447883,
-0.0485812835,
0.036086075,
-0.0690065324,
0.0450821705,
-0.0075601293,
0.0269531235,
-0.0305999294,
0.017218994,
-0.0482634455,
-0.0356958807,
-0.0490300581,
0.0629101694,
0.0300369412,
0.0049160495,
0.0082530221,
0.0518381037,
0.0146755036,
0.031756293,
-0.0756280199,
-0.0257324949,
-0.0578899793,
0.0257533975,
0.0059531336,
-0.0397353992,
0.00008109,
-0.0165780578,
-0.0287248548,
-0.0620559454,
-0.0179344527,
0.009012172,
-0.017961042,
-0.0165192317,
0.0048045968,
0.0454820693,
0.0437111259,
0.003549041,
-0.0306617636,
-0.0415986106,
0.0046394155,
0.006320918,
0.0051778569,
-0.0735319331,
-0.0454943143,
0.0225673597,
0.0135532347,
-0.0942991227,
-0.0027732588,
-0.0297039989,
-0.0112440567,
0.0989159271,
-0.073471047,
-0.0191481672,
-0.0125886323,
0.0161960833,
0.0262461957,
0.0379954055,
0.0242601372,
0.0197201744,
0.0177704915,
-0.0596874878,
0.0399624407,
0.0182309393,
0.0036615515,
-0.0218675919,
-0.0251400508,
0.014050453,
0.0562117584,
-0.0193779301,
0.0273295827,
0.0103510721,
-0.0106651094,
-0.0110736145,
-0.0085439468,
0.0459172241,
0.0095455823,
0.0404139869,
0.0966345295,
-0.0035134945,
0.0175992697,
0.0237773079,
-0.0638495609,
-0.0108555313,
-0.0250144787,
0.0125947511,
-0.0229518842,
-0.0191226695,
-0.0140521163,
-0.0693466142,
-0.0062059266,
-0.0403615572,
0.0167260114,
-0.0238032192,
0.0328230895,
0.0341559574,
-0.0134955021,
0.0214247685,
0.0460503772,
-0.0367032066,
-0.0047631343,
-0.0804544613,
0.0160340983,
0.0131808994,
0.0333199166,
-0.0880601779,
-0.0029156161,
0.0041000922,
-0.0286073033,
-0.0520536676,
0.0429048166,
-0.0139568215,
0.0255602282,
0.0028201062,
-0.0128267193,
-0.0692702755,
0.0343536586,
0.0483234972,
-0.0001854608,
-0.0397379659,
0.0329087302,
0.0019311206,
-0.0531333834,
0.0640468076,
-0.0091581158,
-0.0066193575,
-0.0228132512,
-0.0006236848,
0.008639046,
-0.040451657,
-0.0404953398,
0.0407974012,
0.0344403684,
0.00818324,
0.014473794,
-0.0077513671,
-0.0268010143,
-0.0370903984,
0.026063839,
-0.0118464483,
-0.0073743374,
0.0372690856,
0.000049399,
0.0006261651,
0.0608992539,
-0.0473332927,
0.0755283311,
-0.0167872682,
0.0158471558,
-0.0221171342,
-0.018844584,
-0.0185361896,
0.0442056283,
0.0221225582,
0.0270389933,
-0.0340974145,
0.0567330681,
0.0409702249,
0.0179687701,
-0.029925894,
0.0156943649,
-0.0370910466,
0.0301121324,
0.0127129089,
0.0087690074,
-0.03416875,
-0.0333532579,
-0.0751597136,
-0.0021159188,
-0.0170955211,
-0.0036053397,
0.0200191252,
-0.0112023354,
0.0128279598,
-0.0373261981,
-0.0208609719,
-0.0267378874,
-0.0290803537,
0.0082880771,
0.0438103303,
0.0146388048,
-0.0412483439,
-0.078395471,
-0.0071847169,
-0.0575374365,
0.076497294,
-0.0036026493,
0.0064443629,
-0.0464135446,
0.0518497713,
-0.0207971167,
0.0102077555,
-0.0141241699,
-0.0603217147,
0.0385108814,
-0.0409227759,
0.0013674869,
0.0671584755,
-0.007521335,
0.0271600727,
0.0639296994,
0.0069733486,
-0.0563162118,
-0.0171812251,
0.0014412986,
-0.0429536663,
-0.0286681894,
-0.0121192634,
0.0207882579,
0.1102722511,
0.0076677548,
0.0008827655,
-0.0246501826,
0.0402120501,
-0.0194848105,
-0.0281344764,
-0.0046777381,
-0.0433971472,
-0.0214596987,
0.0711895004,
-0.022601597,
-0.1080695242,
0.0490525886,
-0.0407805741,
-0.0282345694,
-0.0216161404,
-0.0294693224,
-0.0279592667,
0.1026007012,
0.0216348227,
0.0195958391,
0.046472121,
-0.0367170982,
-0.0394434147,
0.0018958442,
-0.0080081709,
-0.0167839378,
0.027571395,
-0.0557539277,
0.0106390873,
0.0224192087,
-0.0119269947,
-0.0517252386,
-0.0415416323,
-0.0287100021,
0.0206604004,
0.0044005988,
0.0255133715,
0.0359296426,
0.0156120183,
0.0030340971,
0.0380365886,
0.0345767774,
-0.0353161171,
-0.0442349724,
-0.035193488,
0.0042294026,
-0.0427134521,
-0.0012572412,
0.0019619172,
-0.0329023711,
-0.004986532,
0.0172044449,
0.0573101528,
-0.0890227556,
0.0350074843,
0.0106246304,
-0.0433691181,
-0.0680104718,
0.0563670397,
0.037789613,
-0.0374637917,
-0.0267184023,
0.0919013023,
0.0582032874,
-0.0207755193,
0.0316668898,
-0.0035558399,
0.0089044943,
0.0625900328,
0.0096023344,
-0.0688266084,
-0.0287661031,
-0.0151012875,
-0.0293022078,
0.0036074615,
0.00323483,
-0.0271071177,
-0.0738512427,
-0.0145751182,
0.013218279,
-0.0322537087,
-0.0127479965,
-0.008470214,
-0.0099531505,
0.0013119871,
-0.0385167226,
-0.013532605,
-0.019917896,
0.0307857115,
0.0092120543,
-0.0284116529,
0.0280655846,
0.0416638441,
-0.0367843285,
0.0323908366,
0.1282620877,
0.0141479252,
-0.0251706392,
0.0084297117,
0.0327315442,
-0.037224263,
0.0344867744,
0.0004204783,
0.0267603062,
-0.006313256,
-0.0166640822,
0.0644995719,
0.0066753873,
-0.0545010827,
-0.031490203,
0.0153871449,
0.0336276181,
-0.019147424,
-0.0296563245,
-0.0034625262,
-0.018590102,
-0.0077919313,
0.0249348283,
0.0838398561,
-0.0158700403,
-0.0317499302,
-0.0687493086,
0.0260170046,
-0.0047414326,
-0.0894005969,
-0.0087006856,
0.0433874205,
-0.0053065093,
-0.0548567735,
-0.044738628,
0.0121379802,
0.0162312035,
0.0195150133,
-0.0217749197,
0.019299306,
-0.0119989589,
-0.0430456884,
0.0506208204,
-0.028775258,
0.0105657401,
-0.0465899594,
-0.0520273596,
0.0267009381,
-0.0212759133,
-0.0378905311,
-0.0272438098,
-0.0588722862,
-0.017834384,
0.0072322963,
0.0804001391,
0.0247879662,
0.0184944943,
-0.0466273092,
-0.0450961255,
-0.0465073101,
-0.0073953816,
-0.0660966486,
0.0028129988,
0.0739410147,
-0.0289067999,
0.0079982867,
0.0161535498,
-0.0388666354,
0.023066435,
0.0353933945,
-0.0301913433,
-0.0469179787,
-0.0138846096,
0.064841032,
0.0013247355,
0.0656509921,
0.037652187,
0.0005088435,
0.0076361261,
-0.0318794027,
0.0338116325,
-0.0246824808,
-0.0448825136,
-0.002036839,
0.0218139272,
0.0208132528,
0.0182305891,
-0.017157428,
-0.0515111238,
0.0701858774,
-0.0114677781,
0.0191691574,
0.0295402613,
0.0539432652,
0.0307567474,
0.0177621674,
-0.0086024394,
0.041463349,
-0.0373533405,
0.0315943286,
-0.0100741554,
0.019142285,
0.0129138036,
0.0493499897,
0.0172175374,
0.0125768529,
-0.0567890927,
-0.0598439798,
0.0053951032,
-0.023382498,
0.0367005058,
-0.0147910686,
-0.0000494028,
-0.0001060604,
0.021155104,
-0.0266646799,
0.0735675618,
0.018993767,
-0.0365327634,
0.0286275577,
0.0397924893,
-0.0348553956,
-0.0469392166,
0.0719483197,
-0.0180556476,
0.0474127457,
0.0016400074,
-0.006817502,
-0.0220304336,
0.008336762,
0.0732522756,
0.0042305221,
-0.0219967496,
0.035566058,
-0.0451594032,
-0.0633834749,
0.0077791791,
0.0270654988,
0.0313178226,
-0.0085774567,
0.033329308,
0.105452098,
-0.007838157,
0.0020126586,
-0.0180896241,
0.0048576454,
0.036565017,
-0.0119235115,
-0.0343771875,
-5.118591336e-33,
-0.0493145883,
-0.0232043136,
-0.0148995128,
0.0381368473,
0.0332141034,
0.0211325251,
-0.0670460612,
0.0102822324,
-0.0305963457,
-0.0395307317,
0.0289012939,
0.0172333606,
-0.0141156996,
-0.0639118105,
0.0351765901,
-0.007717818,
0.0128499679,
0.0166089237,
-0.0534138419,
0.0107458197,
-0.0499707349,
0.0114244837,
0.037709076,
-0.0589533672,
0.0202898216,
-0.0011279576,
0.0242543276,
-0.0260842573,
0.0137800593,
0.0650739297,
-0.0157693755,
-0.0196952075,
-0.000026224,
-0.0236887187,
-0.0552345775,
-0.0181683861,
-0.015301588,
-0.0418997146,
0.0476631597,
0.0131801786,
-0.0023139417,
-0.0475170873,
0.0566080585,
-0.0274798926,
0.0094396109,
0.0049699186,
0.047236409,
0.0155785549,
-0.0033601862,
-0.0250486471,
-0.0793365091,
0.0427698232,
-0.053441789,
-0.0123049421,
0.036508821,
-0.0068591675,
0.0093431994,
0.044741895,
0.0182575993,
0.0050261975,
0.0321248919,
0.0524269007,
0.01143941,
0.0038157748,
0.0073174234,
0.0528499149,
0.0222780537,
0.0193357747,
-0.0072213877,
0.0415931158,
0.0908026695,
0.0337960348,
0.0194845833,
-0.0026544968,
0.0500201881,
0.0275129005,
-0.0126431007,
-0.0054886742,
-0.0241777431,
0.015613026,
-0.0074639996,
0.0321939141,
-0.0267917607,
0.0065787584,
-0.0633805171,
-0.0001402473,
-0.0089469524,
-0.0574067235,
0.0346196331,
-0.0214489922,
-0.0190618951,
0.034589801,
-0.000272145,
-0.0680390522,
-0.0048100883,
-0.0007546199,
-0.0394063219,
0.0194264185,
-0.0120756617,
0.0496475659,
-0.0334175453,
-0.0358448811,
0.0232357103,
-0.0276533607,
0.0902430564,
0.0189847555,
0.0518275276,
0.0427840091,
-0.0460150689,
-0.0111213345,
-0.024143789,
-0.0581607893,
-0.001248355,
-0.0001498349,
0.0287730787,
0.0365960561,
-0.0009052659,
-0.0102661094,
-0.0091663627,
-0.0418506823,
-0.0833689123,
0.0077651129,
-0.0141321961,
0.0414945707,
-0.0622155406,
-0.0783576071,
-0.0448685996,
0.041485846,
0.044344712,
-0.0053253639,
-0.0347320363,
0.017137818,
2.521e-7,
0.0429220721,
0.0088240113,
0.0157788228,
0.0354201198,
0.0147290044,
0.0406836793,
-0.0544188917,
0.0157575142,
0.014814822,
-0.0368918665,
-0.0146531267,
0.0229216926,
0.0171644352,
0.0084305694,
-0.0436831526,
0.0335701667,
0.0108651752,
0.0132213896,
-0.0438302495,
0.0153698009,
0.0411551185,
0.1145324931,
0.0031494345,
0.0269290302,
0.0027224759,
-0.0343444496,
0.0255351551,
-0.0334266499,
0.0210139062,
0.0323348269,
-0.0623570047,
0.0381908044,
-0.0141501641,
-0.0073214672,
-0.0141266435,
0.0107097151,
0.0189743713,
0.057554841,
-0.0327698179,
0.0453516729,
-0.0122392457,
-0.0206083786,
0.0014386211,
-0.0545839742,
0.0649902225,
-0.0381638557,
0.0059279455,
-0.0108135557,
-0.0120548299,
0.0066829952,
-0.0033606095,
0.0312350802,
0.0075819092,
0.0294257104,
0.0050647939,
-0.0269862227,
-0.0118512167,
-0.0641584545,
-0.0452880822,
0.0255215708,
0.0060971496,
-0.0349454768,
-0.0479076654,
-0.012670462,
0.0304899421,
-0.0420448668,
0.0362413637,
2.222856603e-34,
0.0270105284,
-0.0132272746,
0.0297927503,
0.0366073363,
0.0661970228,
-0.0108273281,
0.0157710556,
0.0470798388,
0.0296633765,
-0.0018565899,
0.0013660651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11932v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11932v1 | Opportunities and Risks of LLMs for Scalable Deliberation with Polis | 2023-06-20T22:52:51 | 2023-06-20T22:52:51 | Christopher T. Small, Ivan Vendrov, Esin Durmus, Hadjar Homaei, Elizabeth Barry, Julien Cornebise, Ted Suzman, Deep Ganguli, Colin Megill | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | Polis is a platform that leverages machine intelligence to scale up
deliberative processes. In this paper, we explore the opportunities and risks
associated with applying Large Language Models (LLMs) towards challenges with
facilitating, moderating and summarizing the results of Polis engagements. In
particular, we demonstrate with pilot experiments using Anthropic's Claude that
LLMs can indeed augment human intelligence to help more efficiently run Polis
conversations. In particular, we find that summarization capabilities enable
categorically new methods with immense promise to empower the public in
collective meaning-making exercises. And notably, LLM context limitations have
a significant impact on insight and quality of these results.
However, these opportunities come with risks. We discuss some of these risks,
as well as principles and techniques for characterizing and mitigating them,
and the implications for other deliberative or political systems that may
employ LLMs. Finally, we conclude with several open future research directions
for augmenting tools like Polis with LLMs. | [
0.051280193,
0.0920073465,
-0.0148062725,
0.006802259,
-0.0241293721,
-0.011829963,
0.0088302093,
-0.0080587566,
-0.0062405113,
-0.006188713,
0.0082756765,
-0.0056073815,
0.0074629933,
0.0250091441,
-0.0139812557,
-0.0719045922,
0.0189106371,
-0.026409626,
0.0561964698,
-0.007271389,
0.0297635403,
0.0021292074,
-0.0013441257,
0.061709214,
-0.0191953368,
0.0284845904,
-0.0510456152,
-0.0201094821,
0.0176414214,
-0.004398027,
-0.0576342456,
0.0585725456,
0.0123083554,
0.0459564179,
0.0000020364,
-0.043302469,
0.0186076444,
0.0139964717,
0.0087289521,
-0.0132334437,
0.0744954869,
0.0191171374,
0.0069515221,
0.0144407162,
-0.0450583287,
0.0234633349,
0.026832588,
-0.0166484136,
0.06518621,
0.0263445806,
0.0093350261,
0.0018300228,
0.0082932049,
-0.0305266585,
-0.0399479568,
-0.033730492,
0.0018989639,
-0.0263469722,
0.0084085362,
0.0188137908,
0.0350798927,
0.0316305719,
0.0105169145,
-0.0450928956,
-0.0568733551,
0.0009486321,
-0.0068443879,
-0.0377572775,
-0.0082619525,
0.0392706916,
0.1011530906,
0.0071883928,
-0.0037071581,
0.0048738555,
0.0384613946,
0.0368477851,
-0.0698652714,
0.0712237284,
-0.0018766399,
0.0141579323,
0.0234578401,
0.023916414,
0.0034676371,
0.04470874,
-0.0231793094,
0.0561970547,
-0.0150504122,
-0.0151662333,
-0.0043288884,
-0.0003643691,
0.0099000363,
-0.0474675372,
-0.0134635754,
0.0307750106,
-0.0787975937,
0.0114224348,
0.0353367403,
-0.0004468615,
0.0500304028,
-0.0454803742,
0.0197219644,
-0.0075284056,
0.0523407832,
0.0671810582,
0.0898327231,
-0.022719387,
0.0237984788,
0.0489145443,
-0.0052777478,
-0.0577562004,
-0.0693396106,
-0.029618362,
-0.0116013568,
0.0398463346,
-0.0701457188,
-0.0014345258,
0.0146914516,
0.0216475204,
-0.0487425439,
0.0159966853,
-0.0272355173,
0.006825034,
-0.0032312365,
-0.0300584417,
-0.0809077024,
0.049504254,
-0.0357195772,
0.0419451073,
0.0153398896,
-0.0175607651,
0.0101278676,
0.0139257014,
-0.0200282671,
0.0251864716,
-0.0124138547,
0.0628292412,
-0.0129088331,
0.0187648758,
0.0215218198,
-0.0406922884,
-0.0295373537,
-0.0481632911,
-0.0121327844,
-0.0606208891,
0.0416275375,
0.0043498082,
-0.0252399463,
-0.0537222475,
0.0040285401,
0.0184857156,
-0.0292246509,
0.0433389992,
-0.023065744,
0.0445455015,
0.0404913351,
0.0339156389,
-0.0099406224,
0.0610141121,
0.0345855579,
0.0346092507,
0.0305088479,
0.000540306,
0.0172266718,
0.0256178901,
-0.0162709057,
0.0599578805,
-0.0182673242,
0.0283183437,
-0.0485623144,
-0.0063704234,
-0.008619789,
0.0969333425,
0.0020186072,
0.03121005,
0.0848232582,
0.0807004794,
-0.036853537,
0.0266016889,
-0.0083079124,
0.0453475118,
0.0158570856,
-0.0188776106,
-0.0278113466,
0.0151618896,
-0.0324106775,
-0.0227942392,
0.0797644407,
0.002362093,
-0.0369567312,
-0.0420416407,
0.0291252267,
-0.0092813782,
0.0506799296,
0.04523471,
0.0075233178,
-0.0221647359,
0.0189793855,
0.0657899156,
0.0231212191,
-0.0627548993,
-0.0097549325,
-0.0559275821,
0.0327530913,
0.0294946879,
0.0362236649,
-0.0514301173,
0.0054587228,
-0.035455171,
0.0276704375,
0.0727757961,
0.0898474157,
-0.036132995,
-0.0643983558,
-0.023812294,
-0.0354087837,
0.0168471765,
0.0054031699,
0.0112259686,
-0.0162524264,
-0.0072970232,
-0.0093422942,
0.0031993981,
-0.0253871195,
0.0069367578,
-0.0048258496,
0.022504922,
-0.0382891819,
0.0042897868,
0.02830524,
0.0478822663,
-0.0165684316,
0.0374240912,
0.0369218513,
-0.0091339704,
-0.0240179021,
-0.0128070153,
-0.0190687217,
0.0738598257,
0.0501524322,
-0.0287337508,
-0.0083101792,
-0.0090109874,
-0.0191941969,
-0.0229077041,
0.0566868186,
-0.0463392101,
-0.0167872999,
-0.002504556,
0.0177143328,
-0.0477905422,
-0.0449708253,
-0.0562424324,
0.032362666,
-0.0038565965,
-0.0187488161,
0.0364858955,
-0.036295671,
0.0432532504,
-0.0207759757,
-0.0120562445,
0.0339397751,
0.0431073047,
0.0231650043,
0.0706587583,
-0.0207721032,
-0.0156955197,
-0.077278547,
-0.1102447286,
-0.0216158703,
-0.0150418878,
0.0219198465,
-0.0069385022,
-0.0069321119,
0.0304707922,
0.0299598239,
-0.0415161438,
-0.0184197761,
0.0097406106,
0.0224985275,
0.021678498,
0.0211810526,
-0.0047125625,
-0.005665753,
-0.0044133514,
-0.008790778,
0.0271182619,
0.0180025697,
-0.0383215584,
-0.013408239,
0.0081426324,
-0.0597283877,
-0.0286745094,
-0.0220236592,
0.001809691,
0.0584961176,
0.0080550686,
0.0077503356,
0.0065932292,
0.0568278618,
0.032412637,
0.0366657302,
0.0212169159,
-0.0606348403,
-0.0176598318,
-0.0238729566,
0.015664231,
-0.0443576202,
-0.0116625624,
0.0348055027,
0.028796535,
-0.0175753292,
0.0180718396,
-0.0128926281,
0.1173323914,
-0.0276118107,
-0.0326587632,
-0.0357441604,
-0.0370416939,
-0.0157075245,
0.0239359941,
-0.0171607733,
-0.0178574771,
0.041363962,
0.0068260916,
0.040617384,
-0.0475701094,
-0.0195264276,
-0.062724486,
0.081075646,
-0.020426074,
0.0142621184,
-0.0555306599,
-0.0018040162,
-0.0521838553,
-0.0426525846,
0.0296207964,
-0.059125945,
0.0775527805,
-0.0871009231,
0.0020309673,
-0.0296515618,
-0.0565971173,
-0.0108685195,
-0.0245294571,
-0.0720900968,
0.0503245369,
0.0588096417,
-0.0065389704,
-0.0369703583,
0.0073314416,
0.0692590624,
-0.0152788395,
0.0498234592,
-0.0126963006,
-0.0000782313,
-0.0263339225,
0.0026088397,
0.0692456439,
0.050317578,
-0.0096661439,
0.0145447822,
0.0625792667,
0.0017013372,
-0.0400772952,
-0.0108599644,
-0.0611502007,
0.0050648968,
-0.0395153612,
-0.0012914102,
-0.0131396782,
0.0354041904,
-0.0394028537,
0.0194781292,
0.064625971,
0.0360073447,
-0.0659493506,
-0.0007075907,
-0.0354813561,
0.0069199502,
0.0164536238,
-0.0103057325,
-0.1028358936,
-0.0092882337,
0.0083926683,
-0.0312084872,
-0.0402868427,
-0.0384660549,
-0.0197488796,
-0.1195656583,
0.0386209488,
0.0202512071,
-0.0216798112,
-0.0021512045,
-0.0206907969,
0.0125046726,
0.0006610642,
-0.0017943446,
-0.0073357369,
0.0099897766,
-0.0064141625,
0.01898624,
-0.0608064495,
0.0121750217,
-0.0248616096,
-0.027454054,
0.0462575816,
0.0310152043,
0.0620953776,
-0.009352847,
-0.0151934344,
0.0628027916,
-0.0017210307,
-0.0235249382,
0.0218640342,
0.0141418809,
0.0225164033,
0.028635351,
-0.0365131758,
0.0153620159,
0.0449524969,
-0.0475635789,
0.0407717265,
0.0647049397,
-0.0541172251,
-0.0105456794,
-0.0285485592,
0.0185417216,
0.0278130975,
0.0607965291,
0.0452179797,
-0.0337785482,
-0.0503458492,
-0.052820053,
-0.0262260307,
-0.0297636017,
-0.0487583391,
-0.0088847531,
0.0203011967,
0.0213496089,
-0.0071508051,
-0.0412706994,
0.031298995,
-0.0021827293,
0.0241392162,
0.0018440963,
0.034087684,
0.0237081703,
0.0087215109,
0.0092139663,
-0.0257643498,
-0.0119006876,
-0.0376213975,
-0.0442418605,
-0.0090205586,
0.0308523718,
-0.0124099031,
0.0097193606,
-0.0069000688,
-0.0764984488,
0.0095839836,
0.0149709638,
0.0337173715,
-0.0031910227,
0.0112164905,
-0.067396149,
0.0713816509,
0.0446390398,
-0.0209009014,
-0.0177622307,
0.0169519056,
0.0667738095,
0.0012045947,
0.0372792408,
-0.0041011283,
0.0308955964,
0.0061765132,
0.0246493649,
-0.0550139025,
-0.0567812361,
0.0018902653,
0.0213984195,
-0.001971507,
-0.0130128013,
-0.0554986522,
-0.0285306033,
-0.0189893134,
-0.0412867628,
-0.0150987701,
-0.0081196716,
-0.0006099863,
-0.0325955562,
-0.0232865419,
0.0299711488,
0.0580375642,
-0.0038227625,
0.0218643602,
0.0091275042,
0.0489074476,
0.0007692603,
-0.0114549175,
0.0006111845,
0.0020436523,
-0.0119146779,
0.0333457664,
-0.0313087888,
0.0275682081,
0.0073223007,
0.0553902797,
0.014348031,
-0.0259768758,
0.0024701196,
0.020310333,
-0.0548040383,
-0.0897818208,
0.013064188,
0.0741602108,
0.0130992197,
0.0483350046,
-0.0129093966,
-0.0186076779,
-0.0234781224,
-0.0211001132,
0.0005937191,
0.0203731619,
-0.0283053834,
0.0049537946,
0.0285246223,
-0.054138463,
-0.0033305516,
0.0394309759,
-0.0560611635,
-0.00237981,
0.0029641255,
-0.0072728093,
-0.0260071736,
-0.0855858549,
-0.0410477258,
0.0061043217,
-0.0270020515,
-0.0199095681,
-0.0892129689,
-0.0052347607,
-0.0114181098,
0.0100028571,
0.0047595585,
-0.0205622781,
0.0114092641,
-0.0004568363,
-0.0039913598,
0.0155155752,
-0.0445927046,
0.0231456496,
-0.0768240169,
0.0140157063,
-0.0062502841,
-5.940246091e-33,
-0.0240843464,
-0.0495294891,
0.0467581116,
0.0250170045,
-0.0216780435,
-0.0289984643,
-0.0311232843,
0.0458961651,
0.0119457748,
0.0320262611,
-0.0082512219,
-0.0026715477,
0.0113100549,
0.0110439351,
0.0088302344,
-0.0027837069,
0.0366111957,
0.0040988671,
-0.0277777053,
0.0302127264,
0.0482041538,
-0.0511157103,
-0.0460308567,
-0.0882107019,
0.0236639008,
0.0320445634,
-0.0101848477,
0.0174395256,
-0.0129191531,
0.03089476,
-0.0060460768,
0.0362526439,
0.0192503575,
-0.0395200886,
-0.0233184621,
0.0707028061,
-0.0244806521,
0.0060569332,
0.0214696191,
-0.0443824977,
-0.0194529667,
-0.0397013873,
0.0017983597,
0.0026170672,
-0.0370222405,
0.0013956131,
0.0058887983,
-0.0461728089,
-0.0301045794,
-0.0166074838,
-0.0546983853,
0.0371673815,
-0.0181506202,
0.0263944045,
0.0054627638,
-0.0107026352,
0.0108962758,
0.0083149932,
-0.051238291,
0.0657915249,
0.0126704872,
-0.0157593191,
0.0344178639,
0.0079990998,
0.0177896991,
0.0790664405,
0.034953732,
0.022898905,
-0.0691533312,
-0.0120253908,
-0.0129841138,
0.0458243005,
0.0668004155,
0.0665642843,
-0.0147825731,
-0.0193093643,
-0.0608794168,
0.0198782571,
-0.0041089389,
0.0206688792,
0.0611354746,
-0.0150003666,
-0.0271913111,
-0.0225657299,
-0.0689392686,
-0.0098415241,
-0.0010003649,
-0.0042007989,
-0.012568933,
0.0163112506,
-0.0245887153,
0.0165529046,
0.0392510556,
-0.058180213,
0.0045841597,
0.0177644175,
0.0041872831,
0.0133198537,
-0.0005961446,
-0.0255674459,
-0.0573359504,
-0.0039496473,
-0.0174820106,
0.0169600807,
0.0483121984,
0.006927303,
-0.0081800297,
-0.0223193336,
-0.0323634706,
-0.0084713697,
-0.0262833275,
0.0516385771,
0.0039865817,
0.0034327977,
0.0200737175,
-0.0021448527,
0.0292326044,
-0.0144756259,
-0.01895307,
0.0304552969,
0.0068495353,
0.0227176566,
-0.0279628783,
-0.0131785888,
-0.0440355949,
-0.0049551073,
-0.0165485386,
-0.0023579022,
0.0472163297,
0.0025953008,
-0.0140337208,
-0.0192929506,
2.65e-7,
0.0463849418,
0.0452444479,
0.0029445305,
-0.0230375268,
0.0158292782,
0.0414015353,
0.0010485466,
0.0138716139,
-0.0204791389,
-0.0222880226,
0.0295053869,
0.051534377,
0.0645666271,
0.0598436259,
-0.0934791639,
-0.0496704318,
-0.0453542024,
-0.004227153,
-0.0669879913,
0.0475077927,
0.0045221299,
0.0407559872,
0.0058798976,
-0.0045796852,
-0.0353858434,
-0.0379736759,
0.0469190255,
-0.0518280901,
-0.0502891503,
0.0421661027,
0.0350155979,
-0.0260960143,
0.0147187263,
0.0289795827,
0.0168089978,
-0.0090406332,
-0.0329995751,
0.0625363216,
0.0159062091,
-0.0525664687,
-0.0144518884,
-0.0324449427,
0.0347470567,
0.0222392697,
0.0284993853,
-0.0829066113,
-0.0551347509,
-0.0648570806,
0.0123176677,
-0.0415315852,
0.01766962,
0.0172388051,
-0.0143315038,
-0.0028995865,
-0.0144540137,
-0.0156966988,
0.0500751361,
-0.0708846673,
-0.0124380123,
-0.0127028078,
-0.0454519205,
-0.0943201929,
-0.0055756615,
0.0078168139,
-0.0010750529,
-0.0518067032,
0.0251853988,
2.294157682e-34,
0.0532431342,
-0.0117213679,
-0.0269043185,
-0.0039370977,
0.0682574585,
0.0213907361,
-0.015217769,
-0.0290416367,
0.043608278,
-0.0749796778,
0.0181540139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11900v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11900v1 | Evaluation of Chinese-English Machine Translation of Emotion-Loaded Microblog Texts: A Human Annotated Dataset for the Quality Assessment of Emotion Translation | 2023-06-20T21:22:45 | 2023-06-20T21:22:45 | Shenbin Qian, Constantin Orasan, Felix do Carmo, Qiuliang Li, Diptesh Kanojia | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we focus on how current Machine Translation (MT) tools perform
on the translation of emotion-loaded texts by evaluating outputs from Google
Translate according to a framework proposed in this paper. We propose this
evaluation framework based on the Multidimensional Quality Metrics (MQM) and
perform a detailed error analysis of the MT outputs. From our analysis, we
observe that about 50% of the MT outputs fail to preserve the original emotion.
After further analysis of the errors, we find that emotion carrying words and
linguistic phenomena such as polysemous words, negation, abbreviation etc., are
common causes for these translation errors. | [
0.0409580506,
0.0059232423,
-0.0253055803,
0.0285636261,
-0.0178240519,
0.0283136871,
0.016768733,
0.0069886046,
0.0260159187,
-0.0053892178,
-0.0099054156,
-0.0569026954,
0.0206867997,
0.0104617318,
-0.0210288633,
-0.0576523729,
0.0117820315,
0.0643229261,
0.0056736968,
-0.003256354,
0.0496544577,
0.0263106823,
0.0159034617,
0.0025986896,
-0.0323279053,
-0.0022400788,
0.0060500316,
0.0820320025,
0.0653365031,
-0.0322964862,
-0.0059790993,
0.0047449227,
-0.0435669422,
0.0598119982,
0.0000020942,
-0.0311043859,
-0.0469367169,
0.0112438779,
0.0484927334,
-0.0100579867,
0.1109477207,
-0.0575039499,
-0.0233564116,
0.0322088897,
-0.0098648379,
-0.0191894304,
0.06265641,
0.0539132617,
0.0906948969,
0.0876525789,
-0.0344687663,
0.013317965,
-0.0197259728,
-0.0252943281,
-0.0085403472,
-0.0066709276,
-0.0217810143,
0.0079189055,
-0.052536305,
-0.0254131947,
-0.0033014365,
0.0470322706,
-0.0184419006,
0.0113531109,
-0.0317521207,
-0.0219949782,
-0.0158070344,
-0.0421982259,
0.0155140404,
0.043533273,
-0.0187708959,
0.0252037942,
-0.0059855236,
-0.0052956813,
-0.0021442594,
0.007009042,
-0.0032501118,
-0.0085571771,
0.0013671961,
-0.008804786,
-0.0383867063,
0.0286548492,
-0.0018489852,
0.0258688144,
-0.0000569445,
-0.0239233933,
-0.0222118292,
-0.0344381705,
-0.0063848295,
-0.0060783275,
-0.0292435605,
0.0177667513,
0.0546908975,
-0.0303162728,
0.0167869478,
0.0216456428,
-0.0540510155,
-0.0420725979,
-0.0172039773,
-0.0908141956,
-0.0135456249,
0.0437568091,
0.0325762928,
0.007828271,
0.0029407274,
0.0270582847,
0.0212247334,
-0.0126134874,
-0.0558291748,
-0.022452157,
-0.0339473337,
0.0399725288,
-0.0083449781,
0.0137197906,
-0.0329755545,
-0.0052906154,
-0.080776155,
0.0078927195,
-0.0119660543,
-0.0231095627,
-0.0351087078,
-0.0165406894,
-0.0272731036,
-0.0313729495,
-0.0215365812,
0.0559041128,
-0.0164006334,
0.0170767885,
-0.0126955053,
-0.00789076,
0.0210297666,
0.0345175788,
0.0196770132,
-0.0007975884,
0.0034450265,
0.0538561493,
0.0127595356,
-0.0130778896,
0.0045008678,
-0.0194874927,
-0.0367131308,
-0.018863868,
-0.01921851,
-0.0229260474,
0.0591019578,
-0.0066700545,
0.0006647951,
-0.0032002276,
0.0167010874,
-0.0171906985,
-0.0013319703,
0.0265057683,
-0.0326246135,
0.0109070754,
-0.0078264894,
0.009765815,
-0.0188321266,
0.0357081443,
0.0520984791,
0.0984708071,
0.0573094599,
0.0124358255,
0.006864795,
-0.0063423365,
-0.01612252,
0.0213764142,
-0.0388111472,
-0.0356918983,
-0.0605542101,
0.0224971231,
0.0189728346,
0.0770404488,
-0.0307744481,
0.0440067537,
0.0546436049,
0.0126736276,
-0.0058586621,
0.0511230938,
-0.006540101,
0.02195777,
0.0115164584,
-0.0139325028,
-0.0103381062,
0.0167557746,
-0.0158180371,
-0.013615422,
0.0417724214,
0.0524383858,
0.013770584,
-0.0813030601,
-0.0181301907,
-0.016936671,
0.0100405402,
-0.0321927704,
0.0072424356,
-0.0287223067,
-0.0392401554,
0.0051040119,
-0.0307099298,
-0.0619393438,
0.0096879872,
-0.0063169207,
-0.0294757448,
0.1166517809,
0.0307530314,
-0.0046155346,
-0.0191159286,
-0.0276240148,
-0.0344730094,
0.0507796817,
0.0373469889,
0.0169296153,
-0.0069088177,
-0.0375778042,
0.0147661744,
0.0599885583,
0.0133971768,
-0.0040485417,
-0.0260228068,
0.094630003,
0.0454683527,
-0.009234353,
-0.0656332597,
0.0004368696,
0.024917962,
0.0004369239,
0.0221419185,
0.009812505,
0.0278893039,
0.0640922114,
-0.0475736558,
-0.0189912133,
0.0105295843,
0.0098771667,
-0.0563028045,
0.0405373275,
0.000329586,
-0.0427367017,
0.0144211855,
-0.0469719097,
-0.0184492599,
0.0353050418,
-0.0683744699,
-0.0233517755,
-0.008406478,
-0.0061089965,
-0.0079902308,
-0.0271787494,
0.038772475,
-0.0486076325,
0.0356174111,
-0.000956197,
0.0051514162,
-0.0261671729,
-0.0047659604,
-0.0200865641,
-0.0334871896,
0.0130253285,
0.0116249463,
-0.0653015524,
0.0253258366,
-0.0009651539,
0.0667601973,
0.0185708981,
-0.0167007707,
-0.0641913339,
-0.0686173365,
-0.0611224957,
0.0287711509,
0.005694082,
0.041016113,
0.0366583951,
0.0306109209,
-0.0218389723,
0.0368242227,
0.0145974169,
0.0227001663,
0.0034907307,
0.0013863348,
0.0174180679,
-0.0268965121,
0.0678573623,
-0.0465609655,
0.0056967139,
-0.0184560735,
-0.0113704596,
0.0100037707,
-0.0074566375,
-0.0170216598,
0.0359796099,
-0.0452776626,
-0.0350946561,
0.0236195736,
-0.1088868454,
-0.0052767633,
0.0033359358,
0.0124858273,
0.0397701934,
0.0109195672,
0.0505336076,
-0.0232707411,
-0.0076045338,
-0.0088727931,
0.0022654061,
-0.0213899147,
-0.0214585699,
-0.0008508799,
-0.066305086,
-0.0014937784,
-0.0208161492,
0.0046776598,
0.0119850356,
-0.0659995899,
0.0042802445,
-0.0213117879,
-0.0323033966,
0.0193847753,
0.0213855263,
-0.0027139618,
0.0217047818,
0.0000385724,
-0.0541138425,
0.0195949972,
0.034124583,
0.0092171226,
-0.0546612181,
0.0178877618,
0.0037603346,
0.051462058,
-0.0717582107,
0.0230839644,
-0.0339257158,
0.0185993444,
0.0047199377,
-0.0029832199,
-0.014729823,
-0.0666065291,
0.0011803651,
0.0052624238,
-0.0518591888,
0.0202503651,
0.0480657518,
0.0292430855,
-0.0158338994,
-0.020432869,
-0.0519450009,
0.0476303883,
-0.0210151896,
0.016306363,
0.0125653073,
0.0367752947,
-0.0510361232,
-0.040829055,
-0.0332872123,
0.0334496945,
0.0015584357,
-0.0038897903,
-0.0152794458,
0.0345463529,
-0.0140466094,
0.0533729419,
0.0424490348,
0.0125648007,
-0.0017891605,
0.021190444,
-0.0318070315,
-0.0099932188,
0.03345263,
-0.0422755927,
-0.0474291071,
0.060725525,
-0.0394474044,
0.0528583974,
0.1048212126,
0.0326833166,
-0.0139700556,
-0.0010860664,
-0.0014545671,
0.0358598232,
-0.0162617397,
0.0177870188,
-0.0773252323,
-0.0077263061,
-0.0013579458,
0.0591366775,
0.0052667735,
-0.00046518,
0.009897274,
-0.0795390308,
-0.0054260655,
0.0465828329,
-0.0000638785,
-0.0536859818,
-0.0063876407,
0.0059341807,
-0.0268109143,
-0.0113026323,
-0.0384323895,
0.0220267922,
0.0072653131,
0.0147779752,
0.0027041305,
-0.074101612,
0.0024383848,
-0.0369548984,
0.0433682352,
0.0158368386,
0.1027866229,
-0.0217743944,
-0.0172361825,
-0.0018995078,
0.0159128904,
-0.0182473864,
-0.0247749463,
0.0616955124,
-0.0287890211,
-0.0118594067,
-0.0378959402,
-0.023477193,
0.0003382697,
0.0117018092,
-0.0117505621,
0.038746316,
-0.0035829926,
-0.0178490635,
-0.0137432506,
-0.0215511527,
-0.0035305677,
0.0520305596,
-0.002765842,
-0.0490144454,
-0.0175954103,
-0.0286806524,
0.0132717341,
-0.045924779,
-0.0222272966,
0.0077261575,
-0.0857285634,
-0.0604756624,
-0.10676907,
-0.0904199854,
0.0019617598,
0.0400428437,
-0.0289540067,
-0.046415858,
0.0182213522,
0.0105868764,
-0.0101090232,
0.00052259,
0.0444323085,
0.0236284528,
-0.0046923966,
0.0355665199,
0.0044342759,
-0.0016738218,
0.0407435335,
0.0103883781,
0.003438412,
-0.0331514515,
0.0101791443,
0.0244303141,
0.0102922041,
-0.0087516457,
-0.034982942,
-0.0110350857,
0.0053443471,
0.0468617752,
-0.0018438403,
-0.024722103,
0.0623009354,
0.075905852,
-0.0236918442,
0.0179004669,
-0.0066747037,
0.0145891076,
-0.0448939577,
0.0348997787,
-0.0034955388,
-0.0835737139,
-0.0079816198,
0.0394860879,
0.0061789602,
-0.0135458922,
-0.0734066665,
-0.0334890448,
-0.0219276492,
-0.0271830019,
-0.0259775929,
-0.0474211946,
-0.0315829627,
0.0469546281,
0.0090629114,
-0.0501320511,
-0.0333777331,
-0.0188951455,
-0.0781872571,
0.0134762954,
0.0311242342,
-0.0351301804,
0.0361826494,
-0.0258826111,
0.043804884,
-0.0146607477,
-0.0394796208,
0.0114355423,
-0.0138719473,
-0.0469746888,
0.022460673,
-0.0026039414,
-0.0114629623,
0.063612856,
0.0415220223,
0.0030991698,
0.0325416662,
-0.0403864533,
-0.045539964,
0.0664140955,
-0.0207466669,
0.1397469789,
-0.0367399193,
0.0110684177,
-0.0252422206,
0.0055902679,
-0.0038636301,
-0.0078099589,
-0.0518797599,
-0.0267532393,
-0.0257728118,
0.0160659496,
0.0260124579,
-0.0928951874,
0.0279269144,
0.0202270579,
-0.044429481,
-0.0168913621,
0.0324598402,
0.0375576466,
-0.0317806751,
0.007950522,
-0.0214823801,
-0.0759718418,
-0.0516764075,
0.0629266575,
-0.0117691047,
0.0204373989,
-0.0306284502,
-0.0161883794,
0.0627387315,
-0.0294830911,
0.05953734,
-0.0795733333,
-0.0121726207,
-0.0345878452,
0.0036259845,
0.0103711523,
-6.389179873e-33,
0.0056568305,
-0.031300623,
-0.0694649145,
-0.0041428478,
-0.0503869243,
0.0082246065,
-0.0236648899,
0.0167617444,
0.0067156842,
0.0452346876,
0.0077071982,
0.0171832815,
0.0108174784,
-0.0327482112,
0.0045655314,
0.0194698833,
0.0198510215,
-0.003539457,
-0.0132608004,
0.0221787989,
0.0365124196,
0.0221944731,
0.0599965379,
-0.1195172518,
0.0694633052,
0.0009255202,
-0.0605883822,
0.0099485368,
0.0935272351,
0.0226585884,
0.0240374785,
0.0374309719,
0.0124903331,
0.016903732,
-0.0159045886,
-0.0173129775,
-0.0230058059,
-0.0144630698,
0.001156498,
0.0147287017,
-0.0299272779,
-0.0157441739,
0.0155672533,
-0.0095759677,
-0.0024109671,
0.0002326752,
-0.0003841689,
-0.044949647,
0.028669212,
-0.0950656906,
-0.0226751734,
0.0558495782,
-0.019999478,
-0.0142394342,
0.0365282372,
0.0527615957,
-0.0010471547,
0.0196882188,
-0.038439855,
0.0087281317,
-0.0226236191,
0.0151510993,
0.0183699951,
-0.0362012833,
0.0088725258,
0.0031346835,
0.0382422842,
0.0194197092,
0.0241341833,
0.0395670608,
0.0501987152,
0.0096590752,
0.0524101667,
0.0971412212,
0.0290338714,
-0.052627869,
0.0063092811,
0.0599833801,
-0.0040556779,
0.0275456998,
0.0163312946,
0.0326719619,
-0.0153631195,
0.0119987857,
-0.0165522266,
-0.0167104285,
-0.0357688814,
-0.0578225777,
-0.0152807282,
-0.0128625967,
-0.0475133993,
-0.0152920131,
0.0399790145,
-0.0196415167,
0.0057478771,
0.0104327407,
-0.0580125302,
0.0627457649,
-0.0175177921,
0.0322111212,
0.0089388965,
-0.0269486997,
0.0196487587,
0.0447442867,
0.0407143757,
-0.0362395644,
0.0243514851,
0.0381439663,
-0.0530439131,
0.0120125832,
0.0023742963,
-0.0147614423,
-0.0014267741,
-0.0379128978,
-0.0568915643,
-0.0315865241,
-0.0158477351,
-0.006745121,
0.064186506,
0.0736197382,
-0.0156014813,
0.0011486585,
0.0046121436,
-0.0067130947,
-0.0448632427,
0.0289756097,
-0.0018190945,
0.0027546133,
0.0144006023,
-0.0572429001,
-0.0413763858,
-0.023153279,
2.935e-7,
0.031493362,
0.0969283581,
-0.0003049072,
-0.0092027355,
-0.0023416188,
0.0494740978,
-0.014691907,
0.0353102759,
0.0087525202,
0.0557114333,
0.0577767938,
0.0120229693,
0.0759485662,
0.0334246382,
-0.0399216674,
0.0049978113,
0.0027836296,
0.0267629065,
-0.0120158708,
0.0880692229,
0.1037813649,
0.0563399419,
0.0268330052,
0.0342320427,
-0.0075740335,
0.0027041375,
0.0308772679,
-0.021749448,
-0.0208335258,
0.0318050645,
0.0579425916,
-0.0090987468,
-0.0279582962,
-0.0409954078,
-0.0168437492,
-0.0444105044,
0.0659482926,
0.0612311289,
0.0129372105,
-0.0413151085,
0.0293666571,
-0.0220008809,
0.0055121435,
-0.0224947855,
0.0283092558,
-0.0336139202,
-0.0402790271,
-0.0106595652,
-0.0154251996,
0.0028960374,
0.0719708353,
-0.0523424856,
-0.098809801,
0.0324961096,
0.0195039641,
0.0207375884,
-0.0381202437,
-0.0158308204,
-0.0182755068,
-0.0162194613,
0.0344654657,
-0.0418953858,
0.0182941686,
0.0285828859,
0.0206560157,
-0.0060265949,
0.027554078,
1.943392694e-34,
0.0457676277,
-0.0347834043,
-0.0183286406,
-0.0166050419,
0.0417483486,
0.0141051598,
-0.0525336191,
-0.0001520241,
0.0044194423,
-0.0201612823,
-0.0005775664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11892v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11892v1 | Exploring New Frontiers in Agricultural NLP: Investigating the Potential of Large Language Models for Food Applications | 2023-06-20T21:12:16 | 2023-06-20T21:12:16 | Saed Rezayi, Zhengliang Liu, Zihao Wu, Chandra Dhakal, Bao Ge, Haixing Dai, Gengchen Mai, Ninghao Liu, Chen Zhen, Tianming Liu, Sheng Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper explores new frontiers in agricultural natural language processing
by investigating the effectiveness of using food-related text corpora for
pretraining transformer-based language models. In particular, we focus on the
task of semantic matching, which involves establishing mappings between food
descriptions and nutrition data. To accomplish this, we fine-tune a pre-trained
transformer-based language model, AgriBERT, on this task, utilizing an external
source of knowledge, such as the FoodOn ontology. To advance the field of
agricultural NLP, we propose two new avenues of exploration: (1) utilizing
GPT-based models as a baseline and (2) leveraging ChatGPT as an external source
of knowledge. ChatGPT has shown to be a strong baseline in many NLP tasks, and
we believe it has the potential to improve our model in the task of semantic
matching and enhance our model's understanding of food-related concepts and
relationships. Additionally, we experiment with other applications, such as
cuisine prediction based on food ingredients, and expand the scope of our
research to include other NLP tasks beyond semantic matching. Overall, this
paper provides promising avenues for future research in this field, with
potential implications for improving the performance of agricultural NLP
applications. | [
0.073840864,
0.1024905741,
-0.0009411791,
0.0118248686,
-0.0254704505,
0.0121972831,
-0.0816059932,
0.0457582586,
0.0067018964,
-0.0736074001,
0.005056615,
-0.0085580079,
-0.0308795832,
0.023426313,
-0.0365494452,
-0.0246675629,
0.0436513275,
0.0476630777,
-0.0400984809,
0.0429006889,
0.0149987629,
0.0459321104,
0.007747415,
0.0454613864,
-0.0633457601,
0.0184814949,
0.0132488273,
0.0046563912,
0.0109399492,
-0.0162077118,
-0.0100274654,
0.0189695358,
-0.0218966566,
0.0029495468,
0.0000016723,
-0.0153334942,
-0.0440803804,
0.0330754705,
-0.0128159681,
0.0214111786,
0.015524514,
-0.0073020868,
-0.0051648407,
0.027690284,
-0.0284736566,
-0.0110106142,
0.0820792988,
0.0509898663,
0.004383008,
0.0407983847,
-0.0224157441,
-0.103711769,
0.0231934898,
0.0220946614,
0.0165822245,
0.0118327374,
0.0226270482,
-0.0081669297,
0.0010002432,
0.0376460068,
0.00036577,
0.0178681333,
-0.0041591115,
0.0220357496,
-0.03871952,
0.0435391739,
-0.0328256302,
-0.0401554592,
-0.0066733435,
0.0497811772,
-0.0452984013,
-0.0508787595,
-0.009520595,
0.0143473204,
-0.0549940653,
0.0132505186,
0.0062842052,
-0.0092222048,
-0.0241846703,
0.065214999,
0.0312625021,
-0.0093447752,
0.0161433704,
0.0199554283,
-0.0179431438,
0.0990007296,
0.022609001,
-0.0167791806,
-0.0055497149,
0.0267429575,
-0.0290829651,
-0.0664291009,
0.0347739793,
0.0394322872,
0.011434163,
0.0262098853,
0.0020365748,
0.0075555928,
0.0153145622,
-0.0248668063,
-0.0100788353,
0.059775997,
-0.0541832075,
-0.0177518092,
-0.0100207664,
0.0387077779,
-0.0094703324,
0.0283027925,
-0.0615504384,
-0.0422464684,
-0.1095905155,
-0.0091907065,
-0.0566236563,
0.0103334701,
-0.0003761801,
-0.0307507664,
-0.0155498181,
0.0081585953,
0.0197985023,
-0.0366208516,
0.0328862891,
0.0351698473,
-0.030512616,
-0.0071934536,
-0.0716392472,
0.0641075,
0.0003054945,
0.0092059067,
-0.0349221304,
-0.0671973079,
-0.0039614672,
-0.0246493649,
0.0160325021,
-0.0030585092,
0.0301016383,
0.0715727955,
-0.0100904629,
-0.0379439555,
-0.0279749501,
-0.0048205918,
-0.0380080193,
-0.0360190868,
-0.0272291675,
-0.0345538892,
0.0418285169,
0.0141760558,
0.0634562373,
-0.0288531613,
0.0396526456,
0.0777688175,
-0.059405379,
0.1252023429,
0.0674916506,
-0.0079157352,
-0.0080479067,
-0.0025560013,
0.0383203477,
0.0252363365,
0.0015656961,
0.0317367315,
0.0103700738,
0.0076257628,
-0.0008949101,
0.0156039428,
-0.0373715535,
0.0077713686,
-0.0223026127,
0.0301200654,
0.0380770005,
0.0267300792,
-0.0037158821,
0.0797412172,
0.0047384142,
0.0096120266,
0.1049404293,
0.0890331492,
0.0311983153,
0.0561328419,
0.0601376146,
0.062609233,
-0.0096154725,
-0.0061014127,
-0.0070049372,
0.0113462713,
-0.0808298737,
0.0147383241,
-0.0292702429,
0.0311546735,
-0.013155967,
-0.0380553789,
-0.0436037257,
-0.0186613873,
0.042209629,
-0.0090085957,
0.0339310318,
0.0286255311,
-0.0296780728,
0.0392089225,
0.0206308533,
-0.0487081334,
0.0086942548,
-0.0274511296,
-0.0136674568,
0.0252040159,
0.0310647599,
-0.0194445942,
-0.0126574459,
0.0143404957,
-0.0257931668,
0.0422764458,
0.0297150183,
-0.0288472679,
-0.0293235499,
-0.0071518933,
-0.0204534139,
0.0231448431,
0.0224245675,
-0.0274798013,
0.0293076653,
0.048556719,
0.0134044113,
-0.0084077409,
0.0012975389,
0.0453103483,
0.0051322915,
-0.0141793322,
0.0116562173,
-0.0177477784,
-0.0041979412,
0.0206635371,
0.0179797076,
0.0481611937,
0.0177148022,
-0.0245738514,
-0.0258523244,
0.057938803,
0.0249918867,
-0.0075657726,
0.0283307061,
-0.0368562974,
-0.0006588244,
0.0239666905,
-0.0242008865,
-0.0308695771,
-0.0243155453,
-0.0224157777,
0.0636028945,
-0.0426641516,
0.0418896787,
0.0143554537,
0.0178551078,
-0.0216036644,
0.0219762158,
0.0315309167,
0.0081713377,
-0.0604316071,
-0.060291484,
0.0332475007,
-0.0190301239,
0.011764776,
-0.0041715046,
0.008654288,
0.0222939961,
0.0208632126,
0.044147484,
-0.0434237719,
-0.0319144353,
-0.0664767846,
0.0284652244,
-0.0236942843,
0.0230672304,
0.0403105132,
0.0311922021,
-0.0033407614,
0.0061434391,
-0.0389381871,
0.049032297,
-0.0260480121,
0.012899993,
0.0067468467,
-0.0227260683,
0.0219434928,
0.0009826196,
0.0302137714,
-0.0168833099,
0.0444019064,
-0.0030068147,
-0.0532076955,
-0.0293937884,
-0.0531881452,
-0.0407539718,
0.028900167,
0.0170733985,
-0.0143634947,
-0.0378813148,
0.024333762,
0.0051920908,
-0.0023217457,
0.0185406338,
0.0056901127,
0.0401164033,
-0.0058299126,
-0.0289923027,
-0.0030432821,
-0.0449514613,
-0.0157457534,
-0.0226068608,
-0.0197925381,
0.0213737525,
0.0519668572,
-0.0066998829,
0.0011677216,
-0.0400189087,
0.0195686426,
-0.0333779603,
0.019315375,
-0.0419695303,
0.0376335084,
0.0215291698,
0.0332706198,
-0.0181809627,
-0.0274435915,
0.0554263778,
-0.0486065187,
0.0301558711,
-0.0589337945,
-0.0003292912,
-0.0416134261,
0.0546764024,
0.0202785544,
0.0406698547,
0.0549011528,
0.0126564065,
-0.0220855195,
0.0304796472,
-0.0085138967,
-0.0485575609,
0.0616817884,
-0.0428050533,
0.0212048534,
-0.0019014372,
-0.0269906893,
-0.0403185971,
-0.0145439068,
-0.0341977589,
0.0575360358,
0.0543897934,
0.0123739382,
-0.0697455406,
0.0522036888,
-0.0491543747,
0.0282688271,
0.0312465075,
-0.0476492904,
0.0082243308,
0.0337856635,
0.0512739569,
-0.0028351182,
-0.0365555324,
0.0467619598,
-0.0084512951,
0.0259966534,
-0.0296592228,
-0.0399971455,
0.009815841,
0.0245124288,
0.0349833146,
-0.0807362497,
0.0017054304,
0.0077970303,
-0.0201148428,
-0.0236809868,
-0.0517493747,
0.1120537445,
0.0740679801,
-0.0203753281,
0.0357411094,
0.0435789488,
-0.0364403538,
0.0184073038,
0.060483966,
-0.0781527907,
-0.0212990008,
-0.0288112815,
-0.0520927757,
-0.0371669382,
0.0044595753,
-0.0624026544,
-0.108026877,
0.003640936,
-0.0255954899,
-0.0454291999,
-0.0280904733,
-0.0285633169,
-0.029475037,
-0.0723469332,
0.0263774283,
-0.0447189845,
-0.0392338112,
0.0133120371,
0.0179238152,
-0.0087425616,
-0.0259653404,
0.0343914852,
-0.0555660389,
0.0312763117,
0.0756444559,
0.0384992734,
-0.0202016514,
-0.043738734,
0.0074461047,
0.0084243985,
0.0133220805,
-0.0123490719,
0.0435948111,
-0.0394858718,
-0.0130973412,
0.00866827,
-0.0449764654,
-0.01513064,
-0.0352451652,
-0.0105453217,
0.0670654029,
0.0052566919,
-0.0001814693,
0.0107604619,
-0.0254909657,
0.0265452843,
0.0477956533,
-0.0216454472,
-0.0265803579,
-0.0513794199,
-0.0156361852,
-0.0718531013,
0.0065322835,
-0.0612145253,
0.0434933677,
-0.0256803669,
-0.0374416932,
-0.0473383106,
-0.010422606,
0.0266347174,
0.0059207389,
0.0225848276,
0.0252379067,
0.0403986126,
0.0024493504,
-0.0646870211,
0.0438831188,
-0.0321224481,
-0.0133966422,
-0.0278049894,
-0.0441401787,
0.1008027643,
-0.0541232154,
-0.0207982436,
-0.0186334923,
-0.0903821588,
-0.0292120576,
-0.0131734898,
0.0049619707,
0.0208172649,
0.0450917929,
-0.015829742,
-0.0144454241,
0.0230364464,
0.0488859601,
-0.0322290845,
-0.0446921214,
-0.0273287967,
-0.0132335434,
0.0261784177,
0.0101270229,
-0.0015165003,
0.0569300763,
0.0049494454,
0.0493874848,
0.0029598067,
-0.0644898415,
0.0884761512,
-0.0043794392,
0.0543074273,
0.0039563412,
-0.0046296739,
-0.0383347012,
-0.0062156641,
-0.0167818032,
-0.0169167835,
-0.0145735741,
-0.0176028498,
0.0597321428,
0.0252967235,
-0.039138943,
-0.0135561936,
-0.0558107458,
0.0113914255,
-0.0114851007,
-0.035318993,
0.0086248722,
-0.0228281301,
-0.0088335639,
-0.003364631,
0.0018213214,
-0.0278852675,
0.03141886,
0.0128569407,
-0.059471637,
0.0447436869,
-0.0099914325,
0.0238204356,
-0.0494468659,
0.0508783013,
-0.0125852525,
-0.0124929808,
-0.0572516248,
0.0140470956,
0.0429711938,
-0.0814230815,
0.0340580717,
-0.055395361,
-0.0166310314,
-0.0161831789,
0.0402601175,
0.0105336271,
-0.0301397182,
0.045844011,
-0.0255855359,
-0.0292002596,
-0.0091749141,
0.0750536397,
0.0025422263,
0.0557462089,
0.0337223373,
-0.0510514863,
0.0018767851,
-0.0001061962,
0.0018890708,
-0.0296006668,
-0.0206889044,
-0.0065316563,
-0.0292638671,
-0.0571371913,
0.0129148411,
-0.0267075244,
0.0110253943,
0.0221399385,
0.0292069316,
0.0372244492,
0.0254232809,
-0.0061134156,
-0.0191956479,
-0.0171872377,
-0.0354939662,
-0.0167541541,
-0.0294794738,
-5.92425496e-33,
-0.0215688236,
-0.0427537486,
0.0322262011,
0.0172749739,
0.017163327,
-0.005094578,
0.0088411709,
-0.0451820679,
0.0063718394,
0.0081447223,
0.0005334416,
0.0035473683,
0.0179975275,
0.0085152052,
0.0143317496,
-0.0435701311,
0.013822386,
0.0262709055,
-0.0038302871,
-0.0307120644,
-0.0167311989,
0.0265007541,
0.0707692653,
-0.0309958234,
-0.0027476628,
0.0078422418,
-0.0174565278,
-0.0127597777,
-0.002516235,
0.0677522719,
-0.0705627725,
0.0726772994,
0.043113485,
-0.0413151234,
-0.0064597074,
-0.0015074988,
-0.0723569989,
-0.0481123067,
-0.0365832821,
-0.0041249259,
-0.0159544479,
-0.0018640965,
0.0215070825,
-0.0180750508,
-0.022604553,
0.0278066918,
0.0405765176,
-0.0361624844,
0.0117118526,
-0.0289713666,
-0.0772380233,
-0.0040289592,
0.0300405603,
-0.0019476373,
0.0479373187,
0.0069984975,
0.0059350673,
0.0197890177,
-0.0006571776,
0.0239508357,
0.0096045295,
0.020588804,
0.0587925948,
0.0117493188,
-0.0173853692,
0.0318292491,
-0.0296238456,
-0.0389044508,
-0.0122714648,
-0.0203045961,
-0.0146036614,
0.0172885861,
0.0496249758,
0.014359273,
0.0724205598,
-0.0436529629,
-0.0233967938,
0.0763040036,
-0.0180958156,
-0.0066905217,
-0.0349225141,
0.0210544635,
0.0300738029,
-0.011860474,
-0.0348874666,
0.0300738104,
-0.0368137024,
-0.0194443967,
0.0291759986,
0.0082270037,
0.0020753259,
0.0688025355,
-0.0227177776,
-0.0056484905,
-0.0125545738,
-0.0459625274,
0.0048600044,
-0.0411095247,
-0.0471238196,
0.0344000421,
-0.0806099027,
-0.0696918741,
0.0200268608,
-0.0012295508,
-0.000788268,
-0.0035413809,
0.0190029144,
0.0428044908,
-0.0738875344,
-0.0021506413,
-0.0309655573,
-0.0339988582,
0.000949892,
0.0149452621,
0.0367599204,
0.014274599,
0.0066950214,
0.0313808545,
0.0515085682,
-0.0222368948,
-0.0194494538,
-0.000856678,
0.0465953127,
-0.0208904911,
0.0041873478,
0.021992337,
0.0031357557,
-0.0186228566,
-0.0019419162,
-0.0333474092,
-0.0028914032,
0.0025174408,
2.456e-7,
0.0883290246,
0.048547145,
0.0091688959,
-0.0245121792,
-0.0391204804,
-0.0209037047,
0.0310615655,
0.0551159568,
-0.0323151201,
0.0266043004,
0.0277772006,
-0.0334162414,
0.0113029899,
0.0573556051,
-0.0471842401,
-0.0116945971,
-0.0683664531,
-0.0167116523,
-0.0673042312,
-0.0040169354,
0.0589605272,
0.0728503168,
0.0106801009,
0.0078202132,
-0.018382566,
-0.0077492893,
0.0698004663,
-0.0674104318,
0.0154789658,
0.0116831427,
0.0271465015,
0.0264051873,
0.0187886674,
0.0232284609,
-0.0205234792,
-0.0216856934,
0.0436576344,
0.0155147789,
-0.0567046814,
-0.0169224422,
-0.0248472858,
-0.0356556848,
-0.0073919077,
-0.0686676279,
0.0574497543,
-0.0886109993,
-0.02009397,
0.0427361988,
0.0077791158,
0.0429611579,
-0.0176040828,
0.0016644574,
0.0152350403,
0.012237357,
0.042359598,
0.055621881,
-0.0260349549,
-0.0722254887,
-0.0049899323,
-0.0033978382,
0.0057441089,
-0.0076275789,
0.0054699774,
-0.0222495664,
-0.0156301036,
-0.0397806875,
-0.0244866926,
2.229566105e-34,
-0.0016685332,
0.0473852232,
0.0159216747,
-0.0136311529,
0.0123540666,
0.032705117,
0.0547576919,
0.0204450861,
-0.0391531661,
-0.0698963329,
-0.0127083957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11879v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11879v4 | Open-Domain Text Evaluation via Contrastive Distribution Methods | 2023-06-20T20:37:54 | 2024-06-10T00:44:32 | Sidi Lu, Hongyi Liu, Asli Celikyilmaz, Tianlu Wang, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in open-domain text generation, driven by the power of
large pre-trained language models (LLMs), have demonstrated remarkable
performance. However, assessing these models' generation quality remains a
challenge. In this paper, we introduce a novel method for evaluating
open-domain text generation called Contrastive Distribution Methods (CDM).
Leveraging the connection between increasing model parameters and enhanced LLM
performance, CDM creates a mapping from the _contrast_ of two probabilistic
distributions -- one known to be superior to the other -- to quality measures.
We investigate CDM for open-domain text generation evaluation under two
paradigms: 1) _Generative_ CDM, which harnesses the contrast of two language
models' distributions to generate synthetic examples for training
discriminator-based metrics; 2) _Discriminative_ CDM, which directly uses
distribution disparities between two language models for evaluation. Our
experiments on coherence evaluation for multi-turn dialogue and commonsense
evaluation for controllable generation demonstrate CDM's superior correlate
with human judgment than existing automatic evaluation metrics, highlighting
the strong performance and generalizability of our approach. | [
-0.0018093527,
0.0675344691,
0.0344299078,
0.0068840724,
-0.0395046435,
-0.0173404552,
0.0036486457,
-0.0037070864,
-0.0134856105,
-0.069034718,
-0.0535279103,
-0.0867257863,
0.0146570653,
0.0214494728,
0.0180382933,
-0.0474844575,
-0.0134615237,
-0.0103738178,
0.0067918343,
0.0116496179,
-0.005524456,
0.0013592847,
-0.0173277073,
0.0335570872,
0.0156542938,
-0.0199889075,
0.0105160698,
0.0148638804,
0.0460174754,
-0.0285213143,
0.0017506659,
0.0828534886,
-0.0026125167,
0.0004787699,
0.0000019211,
-0.0118170343,
0.0020726395,
0.0052043353,
0.0380469225,
0.0299065188,
0.0731128827,
0.006104745,
-0.0102752782,
0.0275555067,
-0.0274289381,
-0.0013496542,
0.026064463,
0.0345996208,
0.0436325483,
0.0604732297,
-0.0044280584,
-0.0337221883,
0.023712635,
-0.0258654673,
-0.0276390705,
0.0008962388,
-0.0092070466,
0.031408444,
-0.0003793967,
-0.0101785744,
-0.0118112117,
0.0191447064,
0.0260105077,
-0.033325769,
-0.0015570738,
0.0548233688,
-0.0246216077,
0.0043573272,
-0.0072840289,
0.091999203,
-0.0017876517,
-0.0127499113,
0.0084328502,
-0.0350566842,
0.0029978487,
0.0119761443,
-0.0046013664,
0.0488923639,
0.0033501221,
0.0470168553,
0.0273058843,
0.0243561827,
0.005392856,
0.029699631,
-0.0124007016,
0.0328189954,
0.0401746631,
-0.0186598487,
-0.0014132243,
0.0249554235,
-0.0511303023,
-0.053265661,
0.009880323,
0.02065151,
-0.0347724296,
-0.0021629331,
-0.0651286691,
-0.0651048943,
0.0199847221,
-0.0165143181,
0.0725164115,
0.0262859073,
-0.0408687703,
0.0050886073,
-0.0088156024,
0.0729124025,
0.0104724159,
0.027212603,
-0.0321256481,
0.0403058529,
-0.0191970989,
0.0201362725,
0.000559134,
0.0138756558,
-0.0732444152,
-0.0347490609,
-0.0464995094,
0.0121086994,
0.0165182352,
-0.0259044897,
0.0651248172,
0.0251717735,
-0.0174613986,
0.0078435196,
-0.0199709442,
0.0010490702,
-0.0223455485,
-0.0031941775,
0.0540997721,
-0.0192620289,
-0.0110727251,
0.0676544681,
-0.010737624,
-0.0258251186,
-0.0202455223,
0.0661577359,
-0.0437545516,
-0.0358858109,
-0.0381230302,
-0.0193972681,
-0.0599922501,
-0.0661083609,
-0.0232126899,
-0.0833560079,
-0.0302000232,
0.0074769193,
-0.0260532852,
-0.0381175317,
0.0149873244,
0.0044315672,
-0.0012999362,
-0.0098926211,
0.0000885017,
0.0056996075,
0.0261202808,
-0.000384495,
0.0108647319,
0.0314657278,
0.0449337028,
-0.0029714999,
-0.0014522666,
0.0258552302,
0.0244657304,
0.0072989347,
0.0124158571,
0.0151576726,
0.0037523105,
-0.0090875849,
-0.0187054984,
0.0388349146,
0.0847354382,
0.0737327784,
-0.0495415218,
0.0123177916,
0.0744490698,
-0.0035277118,
0.0438057259,
-0.0049191481,
0.0927463546,
0.0240696128,
-0.0038075973,
0.0558828674,
0.0180771332,
0.0039882702,
0.0106668519,
0.0493130535,
0.0706515312,
0.0349964984,
-0.0274268575,
-0.0496990196,
0.006799642,
-0.0127039459,
0.0022228388,
-0.0302338619,
0.0370605029,
0.0339528695,
-0.078887783,
0.0219813008,
0.0213329215,
-0.0804204419,
0.0436611101,
-0.0414154306,
0.0361131169,
0.0522665754,
0.0469483212,
0.0145011004,
0.0156480856,
0.0095219053,
-0.013050897,
0.0864132717,
0.0217837859,
0.0085940808,
0.0031129105,
-0.045415014,
-0.0204847697,
-0.0581438653,
0.0273997337,
0.0381892398,
-0.015047065,
0.0279756114,
0.0549312159,
-0.0490781628,
-0.0341034196,
0.0279343203,
-0.0155399907,
-0.02249391,
0.0411605909,
-0.013224462,
-0.0000877227,
0.0168849938,
-0.0481019877,
0.0377748087,
-0.005994468,
-0.0303916223,
-0.0122509506,
0.0137927951,
-0.0594847016,
-0.0582373515,
-0.0040719346,
-0.025983477,
0.0195471235,
0.0207922049,
-0.0113635948,
-0.0497593544,
0.0376841724,
-0.0124479719,
0.0142941969,
-0.0708474442,
0.0249356311,
0.0347573832,
-0.0000336898,
-0.0344688743,
0.0993175432,
-0.0220821723,
0.0131868441,
0.0280961525,
0.0435423851,
0.0228021704,
-0.0514424071,
0.0096852686,
-0.0301173106,
-0.004620458,
0.0448735356,
0.0189469494,
0.0529045053,
-0.0372718871,
-0.0531187803,
-0.0544152558,
0.0451330878,
-0.0524570718,
0.0320389383,
0.044470042,
-0.0289904922,
0.0090021342,
0.0381993093,
-0.0365162119,
-0.0299065281,
0.0537804849,
-0.0146822548,
0.0387202874,
0.0197572354,
0.0168968122,
-0.0233707856,
0.019977184,
0.0398215577,
0.0577560104,
0.0202400852,
0.0731451288,
-0.0554545298,
0.1081149429,
-0.0383376107,
-0.0216968339,
0.0142410081,
-0.0498601198,
0.0277625471,
0.0320771895,
0.0753956735,
0.0293634366,
0.0522766449,
0.0267269798,
0.026439501,
-0.013436378,
-0.0056225266,
-0.0285817608,
-0.037357457,
0.0056623062,
0.0014431049,
-0.0128475791,
0.0223348923,
0.0620368421,
0.0443080664,
0.0042847018,
-0.050866399,
-0.0093274312,
-0.0279501062,
-0.0310257841,
-0.0008182079,
-0.0008182469,
-0.0212450288,
0.0277694091,
-0.0194970574,
-0.0577995442,
0.0452465154,
-0.0619240925,
0.0291967727,
-0.0301163606,
-0.0056586498,
-0.019167643,
0.0005064525,
-0.0199225005,
0.0272927769,
-0.0008298695,
-0.022473976,
-0.0498681478,
0.0049342797,
0.0155774122,
-0.0311089158,
0.0401390158,
-0.0682623461,
-0.0069510704,
-0.0106496736,
-0.0410795212,
-0.0439840592,
-0.0627707317,
0.0284402445,
0.0462020412,
0.065599978,
-0.0263239276,
-0.0039387909,
0.0452980958,
-0.0002203291,
0.036344599,
-0.0212916173,
-0.0061957599,
-0.0043024789,
0.0566247329,
0.0206191186,
0.0005400966,
0.0209573116,
-0.0509265438,
-0.0064106365,
0.0211058427,
-0.0113521144,
0.0140678575,
-0.0156890154,
-0.0031534107,
-0.0096309697,
-0.0100258496,
-0.0336440578,
0.0307361484,
0.0669608265,
-0.0133279068,
-0.0441911444,
0.1106567159,
0.0098352125,
-0.0051603271,
-0.0024359273,
-0.000796756,
0.0491390079,
-0.0275424346,
-0.0026015702,
-0.0772363618,
-0.0224771593,
-0.0359830707,
0.0353463963,
-0.0125674922,
-0.0335355587,
-0.0192135368,
-0.1164156571,
0.022598926,
0.0258792043,
-0.0643525198,
-0.0278810672,
0.0001539596,
-0.0182684436,
-0.0112067694,
-0.0010369135,
0.0127397105,
0.0034157659,
0.0388237871,
0.0222626366,
0.0137905749,
-0.0900402293,
-0.0199925937,
-0.0381290875,
0.0086378604,
0.0688297153,
0.0439851247,
0.0277468339,
-0.0631366894,
-0.0223162211,
-0.0728574172,
0.0176245365,
0.0057608155,
0.0337208137,
-0.009830771,
0.0001842466,
-0.026612049,
0.0287690777,
-0.0151614584,
-0.0181319453,
-0.022697011,
0.0055767605,
-0.015903648,
-0.0339340046,
0.0088845538,
0.0266707111,
0.0705849752,
0.0746870413,
0.0509146973,
-0.0339661948,
-0.0478812531,
-0.0117544178,
0.0040558581,
-0.0713265315,
0.0026893879,
0.0001627862,
0.0231021792,
-0.0155401593,
-0.1146780774,
-0.0231626853,
-0.0193515196,
0.0275464915,
-0.0170245152,
-0.011751011,
-0.0490843616,
-0.0305423159,
-0.0103587126,
0.0197396167,
-0.0202132519,
-0.0013684245,
-0.1096922234,
-0.045801755,
-0.0050433078,
-0.0471454337,
-0.0534618907,
0.0359110795,
-0.050988432,
-0.0678448677,
-0.0359744281,
0.0345775448,
0.0118645886,
-0.0094974283,
-0.0064151781,
-0.0452450961,
0.0587448329,
0.048401244,
-0.0170702804,
0.0328927152,
0.0232694112,
-0.0177987013,
-0.0069646998,
0.0057091475,
-0.0060929372,
0.0230956879,
0.0181421991,
0.0628532469,
0.012255609,
-0.0761393756,
-0.0102646369,
0.0025183628,
0.0336177051,
-0.0574806891,
0.0171093848,
-0.0375636779,
-0.0238404181,
-0.0355577506,
-0.0144190267,
-0.0710140169,
0.0128189903,
0.030968003,
-0.0076281191,
-0.014499533,
0.0548011474,
-0.0439056344,
0.0620399565,
-0.0180811416,
-0.0008251359,
0.027109541,
0.0175864771,
0.0131370118,
-0.0148950676,
-0.0246503297,
-0.0263112076,
-0.0346694104,
0.0416778289,
0.0179797616,
0.085109368,
-0.0069822292,
0.0056680101,
0.06224503,
0.0344017744,
-0.0455755591,
-0.0044238009,
-0.042561423,
0.0322660245,
0.049790483,
0.0171097275,
0.0807744861,
-0.0249993205,
0.0058801896,
-0.0421181992,
0.0819500014,
0.0230878796,
-0.0149803162,
0.0132090747,
0.0012039897,
-0.0035041047,
0.002489256,
0.1033562943,
-0.0144268787,
-0.0172106232,
-0.0133945057,
0.0015969833,
-0.03821804,
-0.0365187377,
-0.0017565595,
-0.0137902703,
0.0094113098,
-0.0122497752,
-0.068304725,
-0.0344950035,
0.0209189821,
0.046271611,
0.0166897103,
0.0108684525,
0.0442928746,
0.0395278744,
-0.0520950779,
0.0309204198,
-0.0657102093,
-0.0136924917,
-0.0361313671,
0.0097643984,
-0.0571366251,
-5.990913938e-33,
-0.0423387624,
-0.0535822362,
0.0226640757,
-0.0563547798,
-0.0391414873,
0.0009844108,
-0.0467473865,
0.0154175414,
0.0304743759,
0.0118667325,
0.0230532084,
0.00493075,
0.0087829251,
0.0496175736,
-0.0537174828,
-0.0123248436,
0.0386572629,
0.0123225888,
-0.0799047425,
0.0444867797,
0.0367658474,
0.0068114456,
0.0239592399,
-0.0304053221,
0.010678079,
-0.018926844,
-0.0134285558,
-0.0173770133,
0.018363364,
0.032295242,
-0.0236029942,
0.0317884982,
0.0112281414,
-0.0235468261,
-0.0272892527,
0.0171718821,
0.0100744935,
-0.0027222186,
0.0154180592,
-0.0435751602,
-0.0482856706,
-0.028043855,
0.0064496817,
0.0149197979,
-0.0193889197,
-0.0116087003,
0.0243974067,
-0.0203262419,
-0.0060573639,
-0.0421070047,
-0.0555119328,
0.065722324,
-0.0027650816,
-0.0527261682,
-0.0346619263,
0.0158779249,
-0.0158333648,
0.0059083137,
-0.0012348379,
0.0256638769,
0.0366608612,
0.0247560963,
0.0647913367,
0.0316122547,
-0.0086281598,
0.0503376313,
-0.0647805482,
-0.0045219087,
-0.0150049971,
-0.0251394641,
-0.0110246865,
0.0327655599,
0.0228235032,
0.0971100479,
0.0086058769,
0.0076165549,
-0.0644188672,
0.0714106336,
-0.0591353551,
-0.0433746614,
0.0274838917,
-0.0147285797,
0.0042662136,
-0.0041644541,
-0.0412143581,
-0.0427514799,
-0.0189051088,
-0.0354786031,
0.0348213427,
0.0117009906,
-0.0338576324,
-0.0578058772,
0.036419645,
0.0032002807,
-0.0041090823,
0.0395725481,
-0.0706443861,
0.0194220617,
-0.039697662,
-0.0105709424,
-0.0550270788,
-0.0343938805,
0.0507030971,
0.0570712723,
-0.0181085262,
0.0091801053,
-0.0015527384,
0.0102965832,
-0.0369886421,
0.0375004299,
-0.0213365015,
0.0420615114,
-0.0021464154,
0.0209448356,
0.0147223733,
-0.0377689935,
-0.0293836147,
0.0596246235,
-0.0179186705,
-0.0142403431,
-0.0114755435,
-0.0102757215,
0.0122052683,
0.0197656211,
-0.0470447689,
0.0387630798,
-0.0053415201,
0.0012891513,
0.0315213911,
-0.0317192897,
-0.0214972999,
0.0149147063,
2.479e-7,
0.052778136,
-0.0171312913,
-0.009829469,
0.0262281094,
-0.0236209873,
0.0223163776,
0.017878484,
0.027738031,
-0.005194963,
-0.0146826003,
-0.0040267683,
0.0162160601,
0.0610733703,
-0.0038921239,
-0.0589840002,
0.0246753599,
-0.0799243152,
0.0154867815,
-0.022724051,
-0.0438511893,
0.067069307,
0.0273931734,
-0.0268747099,
-0.0070767244,
0.0295688901,
-0.029259691,
0.0935407132,
0.0035423925,
-0.0105524333,
0.0027157012,
0.024536835,
-0.0168788545,
-0.0106956149,
0.0220301803,
-0.0234262422,
-0.0099827684,
0.02582426,
0.0692901239,
0.0575340651,
-0.036453981,
0.036303021,
-0.007196134,
0.0057337112,
-0.0317306332,
0.0504655354,
-0.0617460981,
-0.0140164299,
-0.0033162502,
-0.0380369686,
-0.0171810891,
0.0386193618,
-0.0644322708,
-0.025994027,
0.0174330361,
0.0076127783,
0.0069917948,
0.0139579438,
-0.0164482668,
-0.0449209772,
0.0178497527,
-0.0254257619,
-0.0491673239,
-0.0301788449,
-0.0219081845,
0.0088332668,
-0.0580802411,
0.0114044026,
2.200609913e-34,
0.0468500108,
0.0028536196,
-0.0056073074,
-0.0322753005,
0.0245793946,
0.0168489236,
-0.0002763613,
-0.029989155,
0.0147627834,
-0.0650654435,
0.0044817436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11843v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11843v1 | Retrieval-Based Transformer for Table Augmentation | 2023-06-20T18:51:21 | 2023-06-20T18:51:21 | Michael Glass, Xueqing Wu, Ankita Rajaram Naik, Gaetano Rossiello, Alfio Gliozzo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR | Data preparation, also called data wrangling, is considered one of the most
expensive and time-consuming steps when performing analytics or building
machine learning models. Preparing data typically involves collecting and
merging data from complex heterogeneous, and often large-scale data sources,
such as data lakes. In this paper, we introduce a novel approach toward
automatic data wrangling in an attempt to alleviate the effort of end-users,
e.g. data analysts, in structuring dynamic views from data lakes in the form of
tabular data. We aim to address table augmentation tasks, including row/column
population and data imputation. Given a corpus of tables, we propose a
retrieval augmented self-trained transformer model. Our self-learning strategy
consists in randomly ablating tables from the corpus and training the
retrieval-based model to reconstruct the original values or headers given the
partial tables as input. We adopt this strategy to first train the dense neural
retrieval model encoding table-parts to vectors, and then the end-to-end model
trained to perform table augmentation tasks. We test on EntiTables, the
standard benchmark for table augmentation, as well as introduce a new benchmark
to advance further research: WebTables. Our model consistently and
substantially outperforms both supervised statistical methods and the current
state-of-the-art transformer-based models. | [
0.0005605359,
0.0780166015,
-0.0131794177,
-0.0101474011,
-0.0000298757,
0.029834656,
-0.0328439362,
0.0356194042,
0.0139870765,
0.0044645746,
-0.0339237787,
0.0110527258,
-0.0208958127,
0.0413990468,
0.0193542689,
-0.0016822673,
0.0165602528,
0.047077395,
-0.0785385966,
0.0302439518,
-0.0208329931,
-0.0366986953,
0.0153267374,
-0.004899241,
-0.0339579061,
0.043445617,
-0.0580126345,
0.0244053546,
-0.0352916606,
0.0229485817,
0.0272560194,
0.0639367104,
0.0339373462,
0.0078280391,
0.0000021151,
0.0228342898,
-0.0517464615,
-0.0139426515,
-0.0108431345,
-0.0055216635,
0.0468120426,
-0.0674626753,
0.0000127148,
-0.0088955564,
-0.0264175255,
-0.0180118531,
0.0237394962,
0.0712915435,
0.0488930941,
0.0159278642,
-0.0113891792,
-0.0401599333,
0.0220035259,
-0.0105350809,
0.079832904,
-0.0034127599,
0.0095671685,
0.0022071321,
-0.0394345969,
-0.0196297299,
0.0005327354,
0.0701343045,
0.0321567282,
-0.0054646111,
0.0415543802,
0.0115235262,
-0.0423826352,
0.0100324694,
0.009433846,
0.0555890016,
-0.0310607608,
-0.0365735069,
0.002969051,
0.0052274512,
0.0521890819,
-0.0057815602,
-0.056843102,
-0.0369299352,
0.0200929232,
-0.009680857,
-0.0586283356,
0.0043036076,
0.011150253,
0.0015097981,
-0.0599135719,
0.004138777,
-0.034597218,
-0.0241989046,
-0.0463474877,
-0.0035546627,
0.0430684052,
-0.0003816229,
0.0060358667,
0.035689041,
-0.0153869791,
0.0064956518,
0.0182675887,
-0.0717910752,
0.0011270113,
-0.0118056927,
0.0482266843,
0.0306131113,
-0.0240504127,
0.0074589988,
-0.0364830717,
-0.0092641674,
-0.0604729317,
0.0273400825,
-0.0268082563,
-0.0228539985,
-0.0371619575,
0.0005536792,
-0.0256720241,
0.0326393284,
-0.0792247355,
0.0118524255,
-0.0064755687,
0.0175221041,
-0.0198850483,
0.0267425273,
-0.0012906403,
0.0431655347,
-0.0480944999,
-0.0023613751,
-0.0203922838,
0.0287458524,
0.0065952619,
-0.0093333665,
0.0146504603,
-0.0875386,
-0.0340663791,
-0.0315801129,
0.0489898473,
-0.0207087751,
0.040364176,
0.0570334233,
-0.0483447425,
-0.0145715214,
-0.0710594654,
-0.0465048291,
-0.0176038202,
0.0063904449,
0.0188781787,
-0.0224897526,
0.0644929558,
-0.0359115116,
-0.0162861682,
-0.0667347535,
-0.0042382525,
0.0293630846,
-0.0272581242,
0.0598084107,
-0.0016503276,
0.0216193143,
0.0445007198,
-0.0351831838,
-0.0310980119,
0.0508085415,
0.017976746,
0.0558216684,
-0.0265303217,
-0.0452651531,
0.0370932296,
0.0364606008,
0.0481086299,
-0.0190667044,
-0.0250478778,
0.0233648233,
-0.0162254069,
0.0067923786,
-0.0010256805,
-0.0105985878,
-0.0459840447,
0.0240188651,
0.0438665077,
0.0084448131,
0.0507460609,
0.0896151438,
-0.0131500755,
0.0003273802,
0.0172306448,
0.01048763,
-0.0097130677,
0.0571490563,
0.0310885012,
-0.0025619203,
0.0133635234,
0.0111745764,
-0.0343108103,
-0.0714847967,
0.0618071854,
-0.007484145,
0.0024378141,
-0.0042138272,
0.0591344535,
0.0753207281,
-0.0406566337,
-0.0282022133,
-0.0070501016,
-0.0760249868,
-0.0163252428,
-0.0073195957,
-0.019184282,
0.051371824,
0.0622779839,
-0.0610312335,
-0.0340013131,
-0.0333176143,
-0.0013162002,
-0.0053597139,
0.019311605,
-0.0250496976,
0.0167588349,
-0.0189415757,
-0.0256501324,
0.0457072966,
0.0209074654,
0.0039321952,
0.0215726644,
-0.0275785271,
0.0450865887,
-0.0809843242,
-0.0501238108,
0.0120455697,
0.0095288632,
0.0056256563,
0.0469245389,
0.0087964898,
-0.0050036898,
0.0251979083,
-0.0050811986,
0.0066711847,
0.0624516644,
-0.005475319,
-0.0194329247,
-0.0101828398,
-0.008252563,
0.0283407383,
-0.0070932307,
0.0110931983,
-0.0450553484,
-0.013975489,
-0.0378648043,
-0.0336664729,
0.0260068402,
-0.0165073872,
-0.0484662913,
-0.0153465411,
0.0149459699,
-0.0032757069,
0.0387949049,
0.0010158712,
0.0714148134,
0.007428674,
0.0221776683,
-0.0082338341,
-0.1035701409,
0.0085772518,
-0.0513837561,
0.0399679802,
-0.0665893406,
-0.0483009182,
0.0259971377,
0.0281991027,
-0.0459166169,
-0.0501661412,
-0.0074983123,
-0.0544944517,
0.0349682607,
-0.0019440032,
0.0156594552,
0.0116594108,
0.0492021441,
-0.0149988262,
-0.0683126822,
-0.0218186267,
-0.0350242332,
-0.0153555376,
-0.005554188,
0.0569140762,
-0.0078090252,
0.0197171532,
-0.0334640332,
-0.0398165882,
-0.0325679593,
0.0081819789,
-0.0198231842,
-0.048939161,
0.0228377115,
-0.0507840291,
0.0104058553,
0.026855709,
0.0144848749,
-0.0107465154,
-0.0246359929,
-0.0338738374,
0.0265476704,
0.0682037398,
0.0019131934,
0.0196320787,
-0.0022706657,
-0.0204248019,
-0.054419592,
0.0356224626,
-0.0186985079,
0.0276352055,
0.0108503755,
-0.0438935459,
0.0612513945,
-0.002428856,
-0.04178432,
0.0054055834,
-0.0184026174,
0.0015437092,
0.0556042939,
0.0011135865,
-0.0698456615,
0.0552793629,
-0.0064201718,
0.0038987885,
-0.0164222531,
0.0016986264,
-0.005547991,
-0.0216392875,
0.0135054262,
0.0000074074,
0.0034088425,
-0.0304226708,
0.0516304746,
0.0352298096,
-0.0060312641,
-0.0412299484,
-0.0141842859,
-0.0426790938,
0.0401600376,
0.023296304,
-0.0665647089,
0.0866436213,
-0.0120040681,
0.0055483999,
-0.0013598836,
-0.0334596038,
-0.0378165506,
-0.0334383212,
0.045389656,
-0.0238067023,
0.040999338,
-0.0094167972,
-0.0863567144,
-0.0533071458,
0.0323674828,
0.0992506221,
0.023406215,
-0.0499629602,
-0.0356217809,
0.0610671304,
0.0028753362,
0.0420377068,
-0.0510971099,
0.0176799633,
0.0128563447,
0.047053691,
0.0122707579,
-0.0446309559,
-0.0216542799,
0.0241987891,
0.0008960787,
-0.0161264576,
0.0237186085,
0.0170819499,
-0.0476579964,
-0.0518327393,
-0.0008598547,
0.0394698195,
0.0233280081,
-0.0259137936,
-0.0506669208,
0.0187708642,
0.017674176,
0.0224110112,
0.0596459247,
-0.0830885842,
0.0049535106,
0.0123111401,
0.0236685481,
0.022432683,
-0.0396611691,
-0.0078469114,
-0.0811589733,
0.0706451088,
-0.0270597655,
-0.0188440569,
-0.0715114027,
-0.0379194766,
0.0093756318,
-0.0479943603,
0.011223061,
0.0498790592,
-0.0277267452,
-0.0000651137,
0.0224173069,
-0.0362044089,
-0.0504285544,
-0.0878322199,
-0.0413233638,
0.0225776415,
0.0368721858,
0.0338149518,
-0.0411584787,
-0.0098934239,
0.0160509609,
0.0065966756,
0.00926877,
0.0108327568,
0.1217782348,
0.0175925475,
-0.0073382067,
0.0002983618,
-0.0012059921,
-0.0049647703,
-0.0045033549,
0.0070964331,
0.0588154607,
-0.0178703573,
0.0401914828,
0.0069820257,
-0.0564743429,
-0.0118778786,
0.039602235,
0.0179474745,
0.0169395301,
-0.0054506427,
-0.0305267777,
-0.0140598593,
-0.0296311863,
0.0270729344,
0.0619618818,
-0.0359378308,
-0.0475563705,
-0.0588570982,
-0.0045905276,
0.0366864018,
0.0385778323,
0.0090978174,
0.0255675875,
-0.0325545631,
-0.0304497778,
-0.0684051812,
0.0023041174,
-0.0472416505,
-0.0103236465,
-0.0077511775,
-0.0158718191,
0.0029377427,
-0.041869197,
-0.0058284909,
0.017495716,
-0.0338670351,
-0.0146239521,
0.0069762613,
0.020456491,
0.0197932404,
0.0515390858,
0.0047162632,
-0.0039368519,
-0.0083082952,
0.077933602,
-0.0860860348,
-0.0620139539,
-0.0121954232,
-0.0552929342,
-0.0193149876,
0.001132099,
-0.0185028892,
0.0279696602,
-0.0278283954,
0.0142221507,
0.0027678693,
0.0451130234,
0.0715015456,
-0.0010301329,
0.0420392193,
0.0579569452,
-0.012480218,
-0.019820815,
0.0223694276,
-0.0278851204,
-0.0318152867,
0.0042646518,
0.0001376601,
0.0433027335,
0.0150437551,
-0.0098219477,
0.0585436933,
0.0268369783,
0.014660351,
-0.0801201388,
-0.0511339456,
0.0043380051,
-0.055616118,
0.0058246134,
-0.0160071608,
0.0104190484,
-0.0077209701,
0.05005043,
0.0482437648,
-0.002733723,
-0.013097195,
0.0363508835,
-0.0075429073,
-0.0657638982,
0.0395413749,
-0.0754982904,
-0.0216895118,
-0.0248125475,
-0.0100529185,
-0.0238604471,
-0.0096904207,
0.0170586277,
-0.0013636998,
-0.026328709,
0.0097821206,
0.0054395124,
0.027741693,
0.0325622968,
0.0126216626,
-0.0105264857,
-0.0165638532,
-0.0244990084,
0.0525167398,
0.0053981096,
0.0102078244,
-0.0171875823,
-0.0160154421,
-0.0551333278,
0.009109322,
0.0031475422,
-0.0162860584,
-0.0146029014,
-0.059825711,
0.01376196,
-0.0342460275,
0.0428409018,
0.0207969174,
-0.0192120746,
-0.0178428944,
-0.0016414642,
0.031952288,
0.0399862267,
0.0185424909,
-0.0259445719,
0.0317537747,
-0.0001314648,
-0.0415030271,
-0.0051753572,
-6.317454147e-33,
-0.0127596129,
0.0048977123,
0.0016870032,
-0.0402697176,
0.0028071913,
-0.0248480607,
-0.0214465465,
-0.0137037793,
-0.0018802383,
0.0121397767,
-0.0513181277,
0.0668313131,
0.0228412095,
-0.0027660662,
0.0356850624,
-0.0369991362,
0.0579138622,
-0.004692852,
-0.0175906811,
0.0153997466,
-0.0192011073,
0.0485659838,
0.00241997,
-0.0432248041,
0.0128889978,
0.0154508892,
0.0011819019,
-0.005965177,
0.0430131182,
0.0034803313,
-0.0126362797,
0.0268071927,
0.0244283825,
-0.0667423159,
-0.0422576554,
0.0108056683,
-0.1752054691,
-0.0042991918,
-0.0720075965,
0.0276197381,
-0.0226459224,
0.0047591422,
0.0600345619,
-0.0296804216,
-0.0120320246,
-0.027062811,
0.0373280831,
-0.0320877545,
-0.0117862755,
-0.0000817137,
0.0197803304,
0.0190988202,
-0.0261861812,
-0.0042919414,
0.0830895677,
0.0506300479,
0.0509479344,
-0.0197087601,
-0.0898400992,
0.032498531,
-0.0131303128,
0.0209311359,
0.0417198092,
-0.0249911416,
0.0242731106,
0.0094119329,
0.0371877477,
0.0393200219,
-0.0590669401,
-0.0172057841,
-0.0097955186,
0.0475160144,
0.0383101478,
-0.0011504416,
0.0683962628,
-0.0222802963,
-0.0172920674,
0.0980714187,
-0.0164740253,
0.010337959,
-0.0372586884,
-0.0044795992,
0.0030741561,
-0.0004186598,
0.0102395685,
-0.0008458847,
-0.0213371161,
-0.0053094667,
0.0139509654,
0.0281745307,
-0.0060786819,
-0.0031413834,
0.0010841768,
-0.0188777223,
-0.003826736,
0.0447381847,
-0.0049861572,
0.0226719696,
0.028711684,
-0.04046271,
0.0501095578,
-0.0301562361,
0.0275678374,
0.008058982,
0.0120706614,
0.0271861926,
0.078245528,
0.0368335694,
-0.0570878536,
-0.0109725203,
-0.0187097527,
0.0387411267,
0.0215408467,
0.001662037,
0.0033462693,
0.0397723503,
-0.0040192427,
0.0004921554,
0.0577997454,
0.0606060252,
-0.0086555183,
0.0295237694,
0.0035079347,
-0.0212098267,
0.0378552713,
-0.0055477531,
-0.0569520034,
0.0026065509,
0.0290508773,
-0.050712239,
-0.0016364631,
0.0065576606,
2.705e-7,
0.0757348612,
0.0208984911,
0.078990154,
-0.0121245319,
0.0218539368,
-0.0033612028,
-0.011796087,
-0.0093309451,
-0.0095945252,
-0.0246087592,
0.0632968694,
-0.0219742619,
0.0719624236,
0.0221665595,
-0.0471761599,
-0.068838574,
-0.0479492061,
-0.0214920267,
-0.0329957753,
0.0050174883,
-0.0011021808,
0.0750655383,
-0.0353382826,
-0.0037021134,
0.0193260703,
0.0070627425,
0.0142694339,
-0.0562601611,
0.0539152361,
0.0352127999,
0.0724562556,
0.0351175629,
-0.0067201816,
0.047433313,
-0.0532949194,
0.0440538786,
-0.00691876,
-0.0183601659,
-0.0027216543,
0.056831833,
0.0188249275,
-0.0431875885,
0.0382525511,
-0.0512355827,
0.0629649535,
-0.0754753351,
0.0165500063,
0.08425574,
-0.0573941618,
0.0759008452,
0.0183222145,
0.0158361625,
-0.0186906289,
0.0222918596,
0.0339695215,
0.0285046306,
-0.0095726056,
-0.0312222727,
-0.0126629621,
0.0148203131,
-0.0190742277,
0.0242957119,
-0.0316784121,
-0.021949375,
-0.0059583783,
-0.0303639565,
-0.0176402275,
2.475235699e-34,
0.0412605815,
0.0267584492,
0.0405757166,
0.0139829554,
0.0438070819,
-0.0408654176,
0.0223408788,
0.0360271521,
-0.0200869385,
-0.0751369074,
-0.0101472186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11838v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11838v1 | Efficient Machine Translation Corpus Generation | 2023-06-20T18:46:47 | 2023-06-20T18:46:47 | Kamer Ali Yuksel, Ahmet Gunduz, Shreyas Sharma, Hassan Sawaf | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper proposes an efficient and semi-automated method for
human-in-the-loop post-editing for machine translation (MT) corpus generation.
The method is based on online training of a custom MT quality estimation metric
on-the-fly as linguists perform post-edits. The online estimator is used to
prioritize worse hypotheses for post-editing, and auto-close best hypotheses
without post-editing. This way, significant improvements can be achieved in the
resulting quality of post-edits at a lower cost due to reduced human
involvement. The trained estimator can also provide an online sanity check
mechanism for post-edits and remove the need for additional linguists to review
them or work on the same hypotheses. In this paper, the effect of prioritizing
with the proposed method on the resulting MT corpus quality is presented versus
scheduling hypotheses randomly. As demonstrated by experiments, the proposed
method improves the lifecycle of MT models by focusing the linguist effort on
production samples and hypotheses, which matter most for expanding MT corpora
to be used for re-training them. | [
0.0702157617,
0.0250407439,
-0.0222769137,
0.000566389,
-0.0268228576,
0.004683231,
-0.0289391596,
0.0021467367,
-0.0258767623,
-0.0538207516,
-0.0151805822,
-0.0309685934,
0.0216115043,
-0.0096305115,
0.0364850536,
-0.0662454292,
0.0256850757,
0.0091134161,
-0.0246143825,
-0.0039244005,
0.0117647611,
0.0053833406,
0.0186562259,
0.0269183423,
-0.0069538425,
0.0080421958,
0.0246560834,
-0.0019239525,
0.0312355198,
0.0039376104,
-0.0218152069,
0.0550087132,
-0.0311018303,
0.0657087117,
0.0000024056,
-0.0588423461,
-0.0614123456,
0.0331868976,
-0.0044012079,
-0.0242534373,
0.0548213273,
-0.0288112611,
-0.0526415184,
0.02611918,
-0.0212818272,
0.0475706123,
0.062364798,
-0.0567786545,
0.071328871,
0.0502184518,
-0.019599108,
-0.0076145004,
-0.0230551828,
0.0021380167,
-0.0418738052,
-0.0377383418,
-0.0221424848,
-0.0091241971,
-0.0365169942,
-0.003030411,
0.0244473871,
0.0306628607,
-0.0066373795,
-0.0586750284,
-0.0085755885,
-0.0458806045,
-0.0572815761,
-0.05006193,
0.0056578526,
0.0317509025,
-0.0055324384,
-0.0241823494,
-0.0003584346,
-0.0085538626,
0.0088753812,
0.0092712902,
0.003828659,
0.0389509872,
-0.0217117127,
-0.0269707032,
0.0227027349,
0.008362473,
-0.0184876267,
0.012708893,
-0.0327726714,
0.0056252517,
0.0277744737,
-0.0193975251,
-0.0096848346,
0.0563302748,
-0.0414447337,
-0.0305822473,
0.0367212892,
-0.0122129032,
-0.0324725099,
0.0141128683,
-0.0372486748,
-0.0798266456,
-0.0050758291,
-0.0548400134,
-0.006166135,
0.0315353684,
0.0035457921,
0.0156205827,
0.0095024966,
0.0181874949,
-0.0025265175,
-0.0493414067,
-0.0391259603,
-0.0096422676,
-0.0439934991,
0.032109905,
-0.0726225749,
0.0231798645,
-0.0112264529,
0.0440476947,
-0.0580602624,
0.0374084376,
0.0022313511,
-0.0037193829,
0.024759477,
-0.034172114,
-0.0722517595,
-0.0348846912,
-0.0296648778,
0.0016876569,
0.0086559886,
-0.0166893303,
-0.0407541767,
-0.0572821908,
0.0134301158,
0.0080149909,
0.0021760075,
-0.0202112868,
-0.0040311287,
0.0350011736,
-0.0128039774,
-0.0159431975,
-0.0156236449,
-0.0477711372,
-0.0172076207,
-0.0278401598,
-0.0507947914,
-0.0434020087,
0.037227422,
-0.0011118033,
0.0010710085,
-0.0034525541,
-0.012354821,
-0.0087493984,
-0.0006022881,
0.0083495956,
-0.051451277,
0.0423850194,
0.0430245772,
-0.0361000039,
-0.0312193204,
0.0627578124,
0.0775298476,
0.010092265,
0.0671046525,
-0.0012840446,
-0.0151395937,
0.0549393594,
-0.0331496522,
0.0170874838,
0.0021833908,
-0.0025360072,
-0.0222421326,
0.039067775,
0.024002118,
0.0655053407,
-0.0275628865,
0.0699901432,
0.0617784634,
-0.0066282819,
0.0242069196,
0.0252991654,
0.0716812015,
0.0188786648,
0.003275574,
0.0142107839,
0.0211123824,
0.021203246,
0.0012322339,
0.0065616355,
0.0344072655,
0.0167160109,
0.0117656235,
-0.0650844723,
-0.0123383095,
-0.0040805731,
-0.0062758131,
-0.0346235111,
0.0366581492,
-0.0011658868,
-0.0398411304,
0.0288472921,
-0.0070361788,
-0.032531511,
0.0098471977,
-0.049500566,
-0.0296578798,
0.0807966664,
0.0765488148,
0.0067074592,
-0.0193900205,
-0.0307368375,
0.0067269374,
0.0728750452,
0.0543745905,
-0.033974234,
-0.0002959844,
-0.0328461491,
-0.028077092,
0.0567752011,
0.0191066805,
0.0245433562,
0.0115293097,
0.0106465807,
0.0350525342,
-0.0118274046,
-0.0779160634,
0.0222742669,
0.0191260725,
-0.0038237753,
0.0231219456,
0.0136473421,
0.0591167547,
0.0245600212,
-0.0550558046,
-0.0043659671,
-0.0017323794,
-0.0147363693,
-0.0022783156,
0.065361619,
0.0178557374,
0.0051389015,
0.0314544626,
-0.0125820944,
-0.0342605673,
-0.0111860372,
-0.0113949236,
-0.0313696153,
-0.0445075706,
-0.0666540563,
0.0366524085,
-0.0601843297,
0.0652097687,
-0.0182141867,
-0.0455164686,
-0.0312576108,
0.0102926129,
0.00359306,
-0.0013813676,
0.0201147571,
-0.0328290723,
0.0364598371,
-0.0413759761,
-0.0005768093,
0.0251253601,
0.0150264977,
0.0246699303,
0.0495155305,
0.0244249515,
-0.0209502038,
-0.0370531119,
-0.0691846982,
-0.0235787462,
-0.0098287994,
0.0246465728,
0.0256219022,
0.0079708211,
-0.0119408211,
0.0050921878,
0.028726209,
-0.0135737611,
-0.0167621393,
0.0421134233,
0.0287397187,
-0.020201046,
0.0270410478,
-0.0250364766,
0.0333974734,
0.0301576946,
0.0045787776,
0.0732086003,
-0.0751292855,
-0.0760311112,
0.034379553,
-0.037991669,
-0.014275156,
0.0496768914,
-0.0808820426,
-0.0010921541,
-0.0153001649,
0.0308381226,
0.0245814864,
0.030214997,
-0.0291290991,
0.0473839231,
0.0198779814,
-0.0254437923,
-0.0255706031,
0.0045227073,
-0.0489836931,
0.0128805935,
-0.036805518,
0.0631626099,
0.0523556471,
0.0080233999,
-0.0355005153,
-0.0529027432,
0.009670116,
-0.0560330078,
-0.0056315698,
0.0057935626,
-0.0226979218,
-0.0474463701,
0.0664916858,
-0.0017775035,
-0.0543574877,
0.0786980391,
-0.0056751412,
0.0069945785,
-0.0901797786,
0.0302253645,
0.0151410671,
0.0107157696,
-0.0058103865,
0.0403206237,
0.0100808013,
-0.0178206153,
-0.0694108754,
0.0293066036,
0.076708816,
-0.0284672249,
-0.0341433361,
-0.0825993121,
0.0082187168,
-0.0077092955,
-0.0036873629,
-0.0091097457,
-0.0049429233,
-0.0298749954,
-0.0276688077,
0.0471498333,
-0.0075104879,
0.0240743943,
0.0174117424,
0.0154796029,
0.068841897,
0.0041568275,
-0.0088019399,
0.0127480114,
0.0123882582,
0.0033610121,
0.022585012,
-0.0159214269,
-0.0360781588,
0.0422373451,
0.0336511657,
-0.0038608145,
-0.0368678644,
0.0125685856,
-0.0402538963,
0.029352067,
-0.0327389762,
-0.0396912768,
0.0250177532,
0.0193549786,
-0.0367723815,
0.0049146423,
0.1119792014,
0.0465252884,
-0.0301837679,
0.0063340412,
-0.0048994245,
0.0165574513,
-0.0002796599,
0.0511878319,
-0.0803534165,
-0.0128153618,
0.0267477725,
0.0617142431,
-0.0413171239,
-0.0104283746,
-0.015126016,
-0.100326553,
0.0488758609,
0.0165615287,
-0.011807655,
0.0013338596,
-0.0080276979,
-0.018740423,
-0.0297357962,
-0.0295648146,
0.0216844883,
0.038308531,
0.0282544643,
0.0194769129,
-0.0456296876,
-0.0510316789,
-0.0119908154,
-0.0599976517,
-0.0213936251,
0.0891777426,
0.045473408,
-0.0034084562,
0.004251793,
0.0151763419,
0.0017395574,
0.0104994019,
-0.0146598602,
0.0369316265,
-0.0041711032,
0.0042337468,
0.0108840698,
-0.0150058605,
0.0528707132,
0.0237892605,
0.0388289765,
0.0508679301,
-0.0273617227,
0.0491745137,
0.0236519426,
-0.0038134246,
0.0049019447,
0.0276455488,
0.011987308,
-0.0703017637,
0.0515513606,
-0.0196342319,
0.0056650252,
-0.0888322368,
0.0021341476,
-0.035258498,
-0.0984682068,
-0.0373156928,
-0.1438981295,
-0.0585518293,
0.0008736314,
0.056875404,
0.0397652909,
-0.0085440101,
0.02698889,
0.0202283859,
-0.02878768,
0.0011327771,
0.007140839,
-0.0194001589,
-0.0755503625,
-0.0377454907,
0.0289972331,
-0.0180421527,
-0.0060874363,
0.0337951109,
-0.0515763164,
-0.0740710646,
0.0083645806,
0.0485322289,
0.0247499608,
0.0431147516,
-0.010845514,
-0.0629366785,
0.0035046996,
0.0014368145,
-0.0344974585,
0.005666547,
0.0339600444,
0.0016087634,
-0.037694931,
0.0148836141,
-0.0376016386,
0.0073376787,
-0.0243035294,
0.033405222,
-0.0087332744,
-0.085003756,
0.0308733936,
0.0496479794,
0.0294161662,
-0.064448528,
-0.0216094255,
-0.0412150584,
0.013879722,
-0.0047158776,
-0.0382019393,
-0.0419673361,
0.0455243029,
0.0232055914,
-0.0187761821,
-0.0257725473,
0.0450402871,
-0.0777459815,
-0.0375798903,
0.0394971818,
-0.0075509897,
-0.0587811358,
0.054706417,
0.0256200153,
0.027040001,
-0.0050430708,
-0.0019850903,
0.0109211178,
-0.0006408424,
-0.0297160931,
0.0230022185,
-0.0167645216,
0.0217792001,
0.0148607679,
0.0453077517,
-0.0089308852,
0.012262661,
-0.0624089949,
-0.001274024,
0.0694448575,
-0.0012494893,
0.1096151695,
-0.0340159684,
-0.0183549393,
-0.0190549735,
0.065605782,
0.0165027883,
0.0109766228,
-0.0333463326,
-0.0141885607,
-0.0181609839,
0.008466051,
0.0531549901,
-0.0473640226,
-0.0025137868,
-0.0358170271,
-0.0223940704,
-0.0247543268,
0.0016772504,
-0.0765389577,
-0.0443276986,
-0.0139308404,
-0.0350317135,
-0.0364761911,
-0.0288622621,
0.0115747526,
0.0089110145,
0.0183965024,
-0.0099053634,
0.0097498801,
0.0694113448,
-0.0425358526,
0.0353409052,
-0.0679560229,
0.0017235097,
0.0297637898,
0.0125386361,
-0.0095934821,
-6.233335036e-33,
-0.0194492806,
-0.0452927463,
-0.0118911872,
-0.0309518315,
-0.0023079768,
-0.0263918359,
-0.0336302668,
-0.0113968328,
0.0475378521,
-0.0054683043,
-0.0150037734,
-0.0079245353,
0.0317782201,
-0.0575071536,
0.0412197933,
0.0976226032,
0.0591211282,
-0.0129871117,
-0.0251358133,
-0.0194433536,
0.0227640271,
0.0104797743,
0.0585522018,
-0.0096948864,
0.0557165146,
0.0157269891,
-0.02829968,
0.0125735179,
0.0235326625,
0.0328613408,
0.0398885868,
0.0192663968,
0.0111880535,
-0.0196779203,
-0.0364132673,
-0.0398739763,
-0.0150440196,
-0.0031717361,
-0.0083072074,
0.0503405109,
0.0254749395,
-0.0361234508,
0.0266988631,
-0.0589449443,
-0.0545156524,
0.0329337157,
0.0064188093,
-0.047014147,
-0.000467503,
-0.0288748834,
-0.0570103563,
0.065654099,
0.0101940027,
-0.0292861592,
0.0303257164,
0.0391880274,
0.0009606856,
-0.033314202,
-0.0694994256,
0.0555817075,
0.0004174641,
0.0263148583,
0.0436721705,
-0.0317591876,
-0.0130105717,
0.0082949307,
0.012605641,
0.0161652565,
0.0412594862,
0.0765987486,
0.0266248919,
-0.0198913235,
0.0562395006,
0.1025026888,
0.0564418286,
-0.0304837152,
-0.0146604963,
0.0695077628,
-0.0536302514,
0.0334545784,
-0.0262683965,
0.0153524699,
-0.0102959853,
-0.016504107,
-0.0283217989,
-0.0371131152,
0.00765219,
-0.0342034549,
0.0034474302,
0.0068582278,
-0.0468949266,
-0.0223399866,
0.0642116368,
-0.0133504877,
0.041298233,
-0.0244600028,
-0.0587993115,
0.0286729168,
-0.0219826382,
0.009859479,
0.0105082057,
0.0085444218,
0.0197342485,
0.0293831974,
0.0213746354,
-0.026582092,
0.0262840055,
0.0319379121,
-0.0459640771,
0.0457945392,
-0.0108619304,
0.0109994113,
0.0072021028,
0.0094745336,
0.0235885419,
-0.0205847863,
0.0033770655,
0.0451713502,
0.0412058048,
-0.0169329047,
-0.0532855242,
0.0456532016,
0.0519580208,
0.0248040613,
-0.0337864794,
0.0309223086,
0.0164194405,
0.0187180918,
0.0396422409,
-0.0185253676,
-0.0449762531,
-0.0411718115,
3.041e-7,
0.0513876528,
0.0805030465,
0.0141153578,
-0.0356765427,
0.0185687225,
0.0071725883,
-0.0078611746,
-0.015034548,
0.0018716162,
0.0510299504,
0.0284190103,
-0.0357536338,
0.0846627876,
0.0580970757,
-0.0673270822,
-0.0433671102,
-0.0263237543,
0.0363324173,
-0.0242689103,
0.0008602657,
0.0180128887,
0.0349351801,
-0.009053994,
-0.0123729473,
-0.0243547019,
-0.0378497951,
0.0580878183,
0.0113487588,
-0.0465673171,
0.0373854637,
0.0596476831,
0.0298342798,
-0.0136772366,
-0.0174731314,
-0.079536207,
-0.0080695515,
0.0143957967,
0.0625532642,
-0.008642911,
0.0320650265,
0.0427327119,
-0.0077797961,
0.0044809077,
-0.0014653897,
0.0250004306,
-0.0259944275,
0.0105148004,
-0.0081449933,
-0.016592579,
-0.008089642,
0.0017195754,
-0.0675003454,
-0.0129028689,
0.0297116712,
0.0211008694,
0.0202773791,
-0.0175573137,
-0.0069669457,
-0.0332245305,
-0.0106276255,
0.0044253455,
-0.0756967589,
0.027204318,
-0.0402602516,
0.0090422761,
-0.0217171349,
0.0202009548,
2.591484285e-34,
0.0258277468,
-0.0043216799,
0.0436005667,
0.0124094151,
0.0391424187,
0.005252386,
-0.0133430958,
-0.0146582145,
-0.0070440117,
-0.0073207482,
-0.0376579724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11832v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11832v1 | QuOTeS: Query-Oriented Technical Summarization | 2023-06-20T18:43:24 | 2023-06-20T18:43:24 | Juan Ramirez-Orta, Eduardo Xamena, Ana Maguitman, Axel J. Soto, Flavia P. Zanoto, Evangelos Milios | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Abstract. When writing an academic paper, researchers often spend
considerable time reviewing and summarizing papers to extract relevant
citations and data to compose the Introduction and Related Work sections. To
address this problem, we propose QuOTeS, an interactive system designed to
retrieve sentences related to a summary of the research from a collection of
potential references and hence assist in the composition of new papers. QuOTeS
integrates techniques from Query-Focused Extractive Summarization and
High-Recall Information Retrieval to provide Interactive Query-Focused
Summarization of scientific documents. To measure the performance of our
system, we carried out a comprehensive user study where participants uploaded
papers related to their research and evaluated the system in terms of its
usability and the quality of the summaries it produces. The results show that
QuOTeS provides a positive user experience and consistently provides
query-focused summaries that are relevant, concise, and complete. We share the
code of our system and the novel Query-Focused Summarization dataset collected
during our experiments at https://github.com/jarobyte91/quotes. | [
0.0470295697,
-0.010621612,
0.00769012,
-0.0466121063,
-0.0007233424,
-0.0001696087,
-0.0037119999,
0.0003556951,
-0.0011916689,
-0.0349374898,
-0.0142670516,
0.0538637117,
0.0028561871,
0.0222695898,
-0.0032410775,
-0.090021193,
0.033229012,
0.011393982,
0.0389663875,
0.018960366,
0.0180520974,
-0.0067148907,
-0.0052763163,
0.0158062223,
0.0718941167,
-0.0033278093,
0.0099098617,
-0.0230479967,
0.0362726748,
-0.0356261842,
0.0144512169,
0.0046772053,
-0.0113745257,
0.0163458623,
0.0000019776,
-0.0633568987,
-0.0291122738,
0.022790255,
0.011946761,
0.0576096028,
0.0731804147,
-0.0008688037,
0.022907339,
-0.0093310364,
-0.0041291188,
0.0177150946,
-0.0069337916,
0.039897874,
0.0545863137,
0.003772045,
0.0078747589,
-0.0490135476,
0.0304445922,
0.0258987993,
0.0368922427,
0.0087080784,
0.0057205334,
0.0191473514,
0.0863599628,
0.0347984843,
0.0650412589,
0.0537771918,
-0.0313740373,
-0.0511754639,
0.0606796816,
0.0465226173,
-0.0485043824,
-0.019474078,
0.0156451091,
0.0468810946,
0.0561814085,
0.0043778354,
0.0608411245,
0.0066037285,
-0.0034805483,
0.0542011075,
-0.1136291698,
0.0067728832,
-0.010440371,
-0.0458164811,
-0.0152728138,
0.0170805696,
-0.0205551907,
0.0115648471,
-0.0058577158,
-0.0000130434,
-0.0057998081,
-0.0194808692,
0.0007291583,
-0.0247686114,
0.0517292693,
-0.0222122353,
0.0159168895,
0.0522684976,
0.0078526866,
-0.0413052179,
0.0235213377,
-0.0769506842,
0.0792888403,
-0.0248401146,
-0.0059491964,
-0.036889594,
0.0389349237,
0.0284505151,
-0.0035552739,
-0.0384796597,
0.001452793,
-0.0163589809,
-0.002342114,
0.0045875912,
-0.0478434041,
-0.0325481072,
-0.0288057327,
0.0464975722,
-0.0115444222,
-0.0018821699,
-0.0177857596,
0.0205315687,
0.0227138586,
0.0137469387,
-0.0146087361,
0.0207020249,
-0.0385040194,
0.0109972591,
-0.0235020872,
-0.0188645814,
-0.0182265341,
-0.0422937162,
0.0240005199,
-0.0160520859,
-0.0199766997,
0.0065972079,
0.0419465043,
-0.0013777184,
-0.0136859706,
-0.0265984666,
-0.0092564858,
-0.0449702069,
-0.0005741193,
-0.0591661744,
0.028430175,
0.0056881667,
0.0081278393,
-0.043810904,
0.0210075974,
0.0499327928,
-0.0221816711,
-0.0452252626,
-0.0062183528,
0.0465439186,
-0.0701532587,
-0.0132762762,
-0.0750358105,
-0.0182625689,
0.0661538318,
0.0114383213,
0.0202187542,
-0.0007484377,
0.0235424954,
0.014959475,
0.0350765102,
0.002271818,
0.0388766415,
-0.0223846901,
0.00652252,
-0.0045711906,
0.0187967476,
0.025609944,
-0.0159920473,
0.001032476,
-0.0251029655,
0.0224221703,
-0.0379974432,
0.0667123571,
0.003973105,
0.0599263012,
0.0092396764,
0.0019968892,
-0.0192110427,
0.0573955104,
0.0547843501,
0.0011960143,
0.010841365,
0.0718998387,
0.0051464466,
0.0646515191,
0.0526743345,
0.0257252473,
0.0005220395,
-0.0441727042,
-0.004926973,
0.0321057625,
-0.019818265,
0.0055809245,
0.0379994474,
0.0117539736,
-0.0070044631,
0.032637503,
0.0117323697,
-0.0575440004,
0.0073781055,
0.0236992184,
0.0265237931,
0.0092946906,
0.0399865992,
-0.0770096928,
0.0056829671,
-0.0158887021,
-0.0153856166,
0.0099383034,
0.0477870852,
-0.0101071009,
-0.0289731137,
-0.0382072106,
-0.0339447409,
-0.0274003763,
-0.0191961322,
-0.0262540989,
-0.0205839332,
-0.0188729484,
0.040673811,
-0.0132381087,
-0.073497124,
0.0346389674,
-0.0173689425,
0.0037927923,
-0.0141350646,
-0.0431633517,
0.0054367133,
0.0305131841,
-0.0177855175,
0.0540688112,
0.0698346868,
-0.0010977094,
0.011466031,
0.0120211905,
0.0328951776,
0.0327010788,
-0.0084647937,
-0.0599103719,
0.0263064764,
-0.0355658494,
-0.0061266008,
-0.0287217386,
0.0203927122,
-0.0492014438,
-0.0370253399,
-0.0039932178,
-0.0186674967,
-0.0166255683,
-0.0073506706,
-0.0357269533,
0.0454798713,
0.054858461,
0.0148145882,
0.060144905,
-0.0743718147,
0.0070429747,
-0.027573036,
-0.0139121665,
0.0146223186,
0.0052103535,
-0.0263596438,
0.0745853707,
-0.0308657326,
-0.0288466904,
0.0006476858,
-0.0787937269,
0.0052863001,
0.0162407141,
-0.0058944328,
0.0121991653,
0.0278952476,
-0.0148145901,
-0.027018968,
0.0117845479,
-0.0478957146,
0.0032236616,
-0.0224298891,
0.0726856813,
0.0534118637,
0.0360729285,
-0.0708776042,
-0.0137991263,
-0.0268435217,
0.0390301868,
0.0762663484,
-0.0469711125,
-0.0258353334,
0.0357899889,
0.012053458,
-0.0439723991,
0.0067129037,
0.0402554199,
-0.0000400295,
-0.0043975627,
0.019874448,
0.0901859999,
0.0241308436,
0.0033595099,
0.0808811486,
-0.0014956573,
-0.0483530201,
-0.0074854791,
-0.028552724,
0.0401558913,
0.0514919721,
-0.0322639234,
0.085066855,
0.0041071195,
-0.0019093372,
0.0158522129,
0.0045668026,
0.0334608108,
-0.0020300052,
0.0306141637,
-0.0317733735,
0.0044311821,
0.0135396468,
0.0390402712,
0.0235051587,
0.0215013046,
0.0336076692,
-0.003413575,
-0.0127459764,
-0.0674277991,
0.0150094274,
-0.0546608269,
0.0012036202,
-0.0052252663,
0.0008184732,
0.0338437855,
0.0148517275,
-0.0087666428,
-0.0326946415,
0.0241697319,
-0.0298382156,
-0.0002689785,
-0.0336339436,
0.0099017667,
-0.0377858654,
0.0027842156,
0.0158847794,
-0.0230231658,
-0.0293748751,
0.0196453854,
0.0305038244,
-0.0147834793,
-0.0463743284,
0.0081385607,
0.1227932945,
0.037462119,
-0.0376444049,
-0.0464292951,
-0.0061430596,
0.0025026565,
0.0665008947,
-0.0287064388,
0.0154751465,
0.0047176955,
0.011856257,
0.0658624694,
0.0015403937,
0.0058176732,
0.0012609902,
-0.0556620024,
-0.0212950017,
-0.1023806855,
-0.009252876,
-0.0172681101,
0.0059708259,
-0.0211840533,
0.0027489571,
0.0656846911,
0.0468925126,
-0.0504278578,
-0.0479322188,
-0.0122222165,
0.0132628335,
0.0261318423,
0.0438938737,
-0.0316095576,
0.0191287789,
-0.0143015916,
0.0688350499,
-0.003120919,
-0.0349764526,
0.0042752638,
-0.0439294949,
0.0335922986,
-0.0078221429,
-0.0350869,
-0.0180859342,
-0.0789118633,
0.0192252435,
0.0019737948,
-0.065469116,
0.0602124669,
-0.0542242005,
0.0128950952,
0.0211937297,
-0.0544692837,
0.0248900447,
-0.0519070141,
0.0001763091,
-0.0450535975,
0.0262168255,
0.0554882623,
-0.0024055103,
0.0241591148,
-0.0117187323,
-0.0408675224,
-0.0130120385,
-0.0152120925,
0.0739556104,
0.021754818,
0.0280300286,
-0.0285045523,
0.0207510926,
0.0213818867,
-0.0171408542,
0.0691967383,
0.0178806931,
-0.0226492509,
0.0173803195,
-0.1042300984,
0.0343385674,
-0.0601521134,
0.0343993194,
0.0449850187,
0.0027837823,
-0.0383111052,
-0.0249538403,
0.0208409764,
-0.0671042129,
-0.0326314569,
-0.0346980393,
-0.0813707188,
0.0101419771,
-0.06160447,
-0.0249613244,
0.0051166117,
-0.0185691472,
0.0241182484,
0.0116498275,
0.0312496796,
0.013321355,
-0.0509505868,
-0.0085135857,
0.0093353642,
-0.0125578763,
-0.0032032903,
-0.022430256,
0.0918331742,
-0.0192767549,
-0.0197029877,
-0.0164952148,
0.0462938584,
-0.0355537422,
-0.0135941086,
0.0208919663,
0.021129366,
0.0073214965,
-0.0002333195,
-0.0142580969,
0.0358941108,
0.0551091097,
0.0002504931,
-0.0207626447,
-0.0209054351,
-0.0129404655,
-0.0479561239,
-0.0562270768,
-0.0724907741,
-0.0021394717,
-0.0698019937,
-0.0111663025,
-0.0617995039,
-0.0453100838,
0.0125597063,
0.0448313542,
0.0357053764,
0.0030508777,
0.0217256751,
0.0032871226,
-0.0043121404,
-0.0136442306,
-0.0036545817,
-0.0067936415,
0.0746024102,
-0.057967715,
-0.0133695211,
0.0351626612,
0.0656238496,
-0.0211425368,
0.0263864268,
-0.0357004926,
0.0233771931,
-0.0239827633,
0.0092399912,
-0.0017956827,
-0.0238847844,
-0.0496964492,
-0.0283193979,
-0.0381092727,
0.0358462222,
0.0006493878,
-0.0019433139,
0.0277149901,
-0.0179035086,
0.0023516256,
0.0166584905,
-0.136565879,
-0.0146312658,
-0.0096629234,
-0.0081966426,
-0.0122035332,
-0.0028682528,
0.0450794771,
-0.010175243,
-0.0279659778,
-0.0140340962,
0.0532390326,
0.0185577646,
0.055533912,
-0.0201947,
0.0197857153,
-0.0062989593,
-0.0413751975,
0.0534688495,
-0.0339121632,
-0.0369303562,
-0.0004410947,
-0.0438179784,
-0.026366381,
-0.014336803,
-0.0253731981,
0.0242384542,
0.003710692,
-0.0757002905,
-0.0362037793,
0.0335727148,
0.0604936033,
0.0143876662,
-0.0020278499,
-0.0229164287,
0.0542932972,
0.0357442386,
0.021849582,
-0.0408779867,
-0.0378952622,
0.0636039153,
-0.0609948263,
-0.0387121327,
-0.0122942189,
-6.153496929e-33,
-0.0197028816,
-0.015413302,
-0.0379726216,
0.0540762059,
-0.0206674859,
-0.0260118712,
-0.0671596155,
-0.0325934142,
-0.0071541863,
-0.0071544331,
-0.0562393218,
0.0043407115,
-0.0031759283,
-0.006822193,
0.0408735871,
0.0441049673,
0.0251578577,
0.0171917807,
-0.0412640646,
0.0792857632,
0.0449561998,
0.013280415,
0.0066023483,
-0.0652063638,
0.0426195227,
-0.0182263441,
0.0263444297,
-0.0313280113,
0.0567097329,
0.0291803125,
-0.0050323866,
-0.012352325,
-0.0032227249,
-0.0224927068,
-0.0149947414,
0.0212439857,
-0.0837539583,
0.0076288111,
0.0083327005,
-0.0456046686,
-0.01837142,
-0.0487013981,
0.0402968153,
-0.0339158401,
-0.0184401702,
-0.0241969991,
0.0955756083,
-0.0152028324,
-0.0752650946,
-0.094176285,
-0.0127336485,
0.0164079051,
-0.0537446812,
0.0533192866,
0.0180609319,
0.0646902248,
0.0109501816,
0.0610467643,
-0.0092090378,
0.0372035019,
-0.0000997972,
0.0385011062,
0.0107491724,
-0.0131640937,
0.0389426351,
0.0250206497,
-0.0114333807,
-0.0146213965,
0.0351318903,
0.001530449,
-0.0124389436,
0.0079374071,
0.023104962,
0.0245849453,
0.0378548056,
0.0093981242,
-0.0230724234,
0.07619977,
-0.0100468667,
0.0483556539,
0.0240884498,
0.0062013213,
0.0117028104,
-0.006267583,
0.02404093,
0.0014869093,
0.0022187878,
-0.0198717695,
-0.0331160501,
-0.0128563158,
-0.0647845566,
-0.0148653826,
-0.0192424897,
0.0046546133,
-0.0041180369,
0.002859941,
0.0027830198,
0.050217554,
-0.022720959,
-0.0671000257,
-0.0167000331,
0.0137663996,
-0.0242818575,
0.0107655115,
0.0128386775,
-0.011457636,
0.0180028956,
-0.0240799766,
-0.0216483176,
-0.0218105707,
0.0440081134,
0.0029147235,
-0.0397073179,
-0.0023252664,
-0.0505009852,
0.0592837445,
0.0315097012,
0.0265160352,
0.0083405422,
0.0308585186,
-0.0380543023,
-0.0334473811,
0.0265065301,
0.0411114544,
0.0327051617,
0.0030151871,
-0.0051661418,
0.076368317,
0.0170621462,
-0.0271829572,
-0.0145291137,
0.008203608,
2.758e-7,
0.0614387318,
0.0525656305,
0.0355569161,
0.001372539,
-0.0061575612,
0.0205088221,
0.0068348153,
0.002366025,
0.032326173,
0.0410272852,
0.020747982,
-0.0021043499,
0.0049875313,
0.0331440642,
-0.1210616827,
-0.1285376847,
-0.0861020982,
-0.0902177766,
-0.0513927191,
-0.0007231749,
0.0475022495,
-0.0231400449,
-0.0389830507,
0.0278349575,
-0.0393009074,
-0.0456089266,
0.0085046431,
-0.0216762573,
-0.0012104678,
0.0768615678,
0.0444249175,
-0.0147746103,
-0.0080692274,
-0.0293219462,
-0.0208190326,
-0.0221939627,
0.0233251676,
-0.0033385255,
0.0369124785,
-0.0031970779,
0.0414960906,
0.0039028698,
0.0697827488,
-0.0304579735,
0.0196186099,
-0.0387581661,
0.0086941086,
-0.0292745754,
-0.0496015921,
-0.0231041014,
0.0075318054,
-0.0004030474,
-0.0234250352,
0.0459595174,
-0.0587327369,
-0.0204926394,
-0.0028660833,
-0.0293283239,
-0.0312525444,
0.0538078435,
0.0137419663,
-0.0297341757,
-0.0061044502,
-0.0245842487,
-0.0121730166,
-0.0191012695,
0.0021832676,
2.546185278e-34,
0.0753399283,
-0.011620922,
-0.0187926721,
0.0242132712,
0.0335220136,
-0.0215246174,
-0.024324365,
0.0185517613,
0.0165555608,
-0.0442392118,
0.0050491872
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11825v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11825v2 | DiNADO: Norm-Disentangled Neurally-Decomposed Oracles for Controlling Language Models | 2023-06-20T18:36:52 | 2024-06-06T21:01:09 | Sidi Lu, Wenbo Zhao, Chenyang Tao, Arpit Gupta, Shanchan Wu, Tagyoung Chung, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL | NeurAlly-Decomposed Oracle (NADO) is a powerful approach for controllable
generation with large language models. It is designed to avoid catastrophic
forgetting while achieving guaranteed convergence to an entropy-maximized
closed-form optimal solution with reasonable modeling capacity. Despite the
success, several challenges arise when apply NADO to a wide range of scenarios.
Vanilla NADO suffers from gradient vanishing for low-probability control
signals and is highly reliant on a regularization to satisfy the stochastic
version of Bellman equation. In addition, the vanilla implementation of NADO
introduces a few additional transformer layers, suffering from a limited
capacity especially compared to other finetune-based model adaptation methods
like LoRA. In this paper, we propose a improved version of the NADO algorithm,
namely DiNADO (norm-Disentangled NeurAlly-Decomposed Oracles), which improves
the performance of the NADO algorithm through disentangling the step-wise
global norm over the approximated oracle $R$-value for all potential
next-tokens, allowing DiNADO to be combined with finetuning methods like LoRA.
We discuss in depth how DiNADO achieves better capacity, stability and
flexibility with both empirical and theoretical results. Experiments on
formality control in machine translation and the lexically constrained
generation task CommonGen demonstrates the significance of the improvements. | [
-0.0006076607,
0.0973999873,
-0.0059629041,
0.0175115224,
-0.021277478,
0.0343368612,
-0.0004486905,
-0.0131228324,
-0.0042655934,
0.0046990388,
-0.0076391096,
-0.0265109409,
0.0126569932,
0.0452221781,
0.0453700982,
-0.0424213894,
0.0311305914,
-0.0495661423,
-0.0095874863,
-0.0418888591,
-0.0107101668,
-0.0289357807,
0.0098772887,
0.0368435159,
0.0374778919,
-0.0170962419,
-0.0227509253,
0.0044756578,
-0.0055741761,
0.0188946724,
0.008980439,
0.0389714502,
0.0182366949,
0.0454790965,
0.0000021192,
-0.009851425,
-0.0303715542,
-0.0149050066,
0.0420888029,
0.0023461455,
-0.0188909248,
-0.0484007969,
-0.02984,
0.0217298903,
-0.0157854389,
-0.0240225736,
0.0476218946,
0.0139994733,
0.0552094802,
0.0837520137,
-0.0018389844,
-0.0327881239,
0.0632008165,
-0.0546521321,
-0.0547651164,
-0.0271704663,
0.0105451364,
-0.0226500574,
-0.0370363593,
-0.0228886604,
-0.034457393,
0.0197337139,
0.0448008142,
-0.0012135148,
-0.0168112349,
0.0126894284,
0.0335755609,
-0.0475093685,
-0.0303150043,
0.0697329342,
-0.0570945218,
-0.0180623382,
0.0399698466,
0.0080772853,
-0.0160300639,
-0.0484311469,
-0.0315959193,
0.0289692916,
0.0311568901,
0.0538992025,
0.0423470885,
-0.0363456234,
0.0282608848,
0.0210514218,
-0.0603916161,
0.036156714,
0.0414759815,
-0.017574802,
-0.0428426154,
0.0150719481,
-0.0068646972,
-0.0203555841,
0.0383978263,
0.0206696726,
-0.057843063,
-0.0012823164,
-0.0583934002,
-0.0542663038,
-0.0274589565,
-0.0360255204,
0.0537749827,
0.0384349041,
0.0415400751,
-0.0020769641,
-0.018862417,
0.0630023926,
-0.038628161,
0.0512717292,
-0.0132082896,
0.0161685422,
-0.0067793098,
0.003350337,
-0.0365913361,
0.0647844374,
-0.0809742436,
-0.0075308331,
-0.0115358382,
0.0050357496,
-0.0333900303,
-0.0005156538,
-0.0350570604,
0.0102578104,
-0.0428190008,
0.0020309691,
0.0003895339,
0.0248905234,
-0.0207840148,
0.0063743778,
0.0531100444,
-0.0311759934,
-0.0251175407,
0.0084098428,
0.0064323377,
0.0020850569,
-0.0090485858,
0.0756659806,
-0.0479883999,
-0.0056028236,
-0.0331107527,
-0.0329500958,
-0.0173885971,
-0.077623345,
0.0277399179,
-0.0566170998,
0.0653437823,
-0.0010657525,
-0.0133495461,
-0.0952868611,
0.0154319778,
0.0089368271,
-0.0251492877,
0.0231081955,
-0.0171943326,
-0.0506077781,
0.0195441078,
0.0236874539,
0.0417955592,
0.071231328,
0.0422136225,
0.0671169981,
-0.0359926075,
0.0080125919,
-0.0025800078,
0.0514489301,
0.0570180193,
0.0092315869,
-0.1070640311,
-0.0394853428,
0.0172046311,
0.0452932306,
0.0557290129,
0.1321824193,
-0.0586769618,
0.0221161135,
0.0657093972,
-0.0158653464,
0.0526012033,
0.044706922,
0.0309133884,
-0.0434377789,
-0.0132228024,
0.041519668,
-0.0240901951,
0.0362257585,
-0.0154656246,
0.01911732,
0.0303909443,
0.0482701547,
-0.0326124914,
-0.0464651845,
0.0253799204,
0.0107503599,
-0.0084497239,
-0.0342203565,
0.0432492234,
0.042533163,
-0.0515210256,
0.0147734163,
0.024343906,
-0.0425555557,
0.0578962825,
-0.0172719043,
0.0030232195,
0.0278363861,
0.0648874342,
0.0331976525,
-0.028831983,
-0.0296774432,
-0.0607824326,
0.0685715005,
-0.0120695271,
0.0338838175,
0.0107478173,
-0.0626296848,
-0.0128644081,
0.0165446997,
0.0093487408,
0.0165265538,
-0.017611865,
0.0174262822,
0.0204544961,
0.0339013673,
-0.0254573021,
0.0416038595,
-0.0503145717,
-0.0417400822,
0.0118528735,
0.0009415049,
0.0608017668,
0.0019840917,
-0.004777031,
0.0201504808,
0.0246557016,
-0.0574883372,
-0.0300849993,
-0.0362900235,
-0.0913237929,
-0.0867791697,
0.0267902464,
-0.0194544587,
0.0395767987,
0.0207622889,
-0.024370715,
-0.0751212612,
0.0658744872,
-0.0389464311,
0.0375604182,
-0.038868662,
0.0048888074,
0.0282559246,
0.0430918075,
-0.0110603953,
0.0326450318,
-0.0413393676,
-0.003092119,
0.0603708029,
0.0291780345,
-0.0387195423,
-0.0199776012,
-0.0256568436,
0.0146961519,
-0.0029561722,
0.030588977,
0.0394699574,
0.0315531343,
0.0184125938,
-0.0624897219,
0.0159622468,
-0.0008975929,
-0.0407971665,
0.0130076921,
0.0223721564,
0.0370863676,
0.0227057114,
-0.0051423791,
-0.045133356,
0.0366759971,
-0.0112494538,
-0.0051794443,
0.0034179667,
-0.0011431359,
-0.0396306068,
-0.0431616679,
-0.01756474,
0.0301319081,
0.0224738251,
-0.0089418655,
-0.0153730884,
-0.0497157983,
0.0585931391,
-0.0530598573,
0.0516126677,
-0.0257551074,
-0.0491729006,
0.0068556881,
-0.035485331,
0.0573086888,
0.0121645583,
-0.0182347409,
0.0295277461,
0.0601556078,
0.0237964839,
-0.0357717536,
0.0045843511,
-0.052867122,
-0.001135314,
-0.0087010795,
0.0133235818,
0.0441843756,
0.069902122,
0.0085739046,
-0.0165786482,
-0.0528903082,
-0.0191140622,
0.003407805,
-0.0542775877,
-0.0442692637,
0.0277214404,
-0.0171593521,
0.0386144333,
-0.0335131697,
-0.0357676409,
0.0508781709,
-0.0030308422,
0.0202960316,
-0.0178977028,
-0.0118108001,
-0.0319291428,
0.0512993373,
0.0199330747,
0.0360905305,
0.005422228,
-0.0369558819,
-0.067620188,
-0.0236719754,
-0.0172745418,
-0.0081863655,
0.0264610536,
-0.0418121256,
0.0040972419,
-0.0029244584,
-0.0473749898,
-0.0255611707,
0.0115654571,
0.0131975263,
0.035490226,
0.0854975358,
-0.0274060499,
0.008542452,
-0.0129171116,
0.0212243926,
0.0410700813,
0.0011349174,
-0.0033247587,
-0.0467703603,
0.0506499596,
0.081901215,
0.004466115,
0.0228906628,
-0.0492401123,
0.0111942152,
0.0486063734,
0.0047291513,
-0.0103732469,
-0.0591619648,
0.0225042943,
0.051606074,
0.0205950327,
0.0012166882,
0.0157135744,
0.0140217179,
-0.0226653218,
-0.0540566556,
0.0810106471,
-0.0084661013,
-0.0607856363,
0.0255932752,
0.0214512013,
0.0771781653,
-0.0029502665,
0.0225733258,
-0.0705765113,
-0.006975336,
0.0156157734,
0.022514388,
0.0278947335,
-0.0103286766,
-0.0273437351,
-0.0957879722,
-0.0139230369,
0.0378113464,
-0.0287499465,
-0.0548416711,
-0.0023595581,
-0.0147644505,
-0.019074345,
0.0623399615,
0.0456057452,
0.0049649631,
0.0068101161,
0.0090924725,
0.0411610082,
-0.0206848588,
-0.0360509641,
-0.0314204991,
0.0607370213,
0.0666087195,
0.0221725944,
0.0128304921,
-0.0411064364,
-0.0021590251,
-0.0275544263,
-0.0083026113,
0.0087950556,
-0.0096495776,
0.0543430969,
-0.0419845171,
-0.0161486603,
0.0606738292,
-0.0154334148,
0.0010992397,
-0.0191394761,
0.0445620716,
-0.0109108128,
-0.0414456204,
0.002785878,
-0.0123388413,
-0.0124166245,
0.0476472192,
0.0410815366,
-0.0316162556,
-0.0727740973,
-0.0243838187,
0.003070842,
-0.0527490228,
0.0289920457,
-0.0470494516,
-0.0161806103,
-0.0667030141,
-0.1045575067,
0.0149140358,
0.0110606495,
0.0646415427,
0.0081509547,
-0.002607218,
0.0616078116,
-0.0586654432,
-0.0029032526,
-0.0174297877,
-0.0294130128,
-0.0043837652,
-0.0582837984,
-0.0082329921,
-0.0032157113,
-0.0041043316,
-0.0064255097,
0.0255300067,
-0.0721072629,
-0.100486055,
0.0222665071,
0.0486805029,
0.0189658552,
0.0203640629,
0.0134987291,
-0.0471817926,
0.0486008674,
0.0632387251,
-0.0480665155,
0.0281903464,
0.0093646524,
0.0083811982,
0.0034423047,
0.0698427632,
-0.0276674628,
0.0022158574,
0.0296934228,
0.0775061324,
0.0231238063,
-0.0225163177,
0.0188010745,
-0.0030548109,
0.0291100405,
-0.0335919373,
-0.0003556889,
-0.0253069848,
-0.0364286639,
-0.0079112565,
0.0069910167,
-0.0589259602,
0.0064019151,
0.013197531,
-0.0022596547,
-0.0026647181,
0.0029925266,
0.0464948937,
0.0066013825,
-0.0304375552,
-0.0694092438,
-0.0072912634,
0.0205922592,
0.0410073027,
0.0053534415,
0.0039083147,
0.0446712449,
-0.0026063749,
0.019424621,
-0.045489192,
0.0271564368,
0.02477034,
0.0250986591,
-0.0268469434,
0.0207337812,
-0.0321366787,
-0.044825606,
-0.0064944709,
0.0217518751,
0.0683120415,
0.0604814999,
0.0531996898,
-0.0114696901,
0.0111258505,
-0.0043656356,
0.0454052724,
-0.0105228471,
-0.0201834794,
0.0169157013,
-0.0056114816,
0.0088091446,
0.0153480927,
0.0866429135,
-0.0058840923,
0.0129947197,
-0.0144703817,
0.0602675006,
-0.0294310953,
-0.0250738189,
-0.0149123827,
-0.00281879,
-0.0205277428,
-0.0046316097,
-0.0236210022,
-0.0588325523,
-0.0357153416,
-0.0027280822,
0.0152686322,
-0.0072659678,
0.0602382123,
-0.0186731555,
-0.0249947924,
0.0161806513,
-0.0298748147,
0.0134956017,
0.0351720788,
-0.0474491455,
-0.0224320833,
-7.103992845e-33,
-0.0476360433,
-0.000192828,
0.0299763065,
-0.0178173427,
-0.0298296977,
-0.0378072374,
-0.0476367585,
-0.0008628799,
0.0242294278,
0.0088881096,
-0.0049893833,
0.0012420299,
-0.0090373922,
0.0558318123,
-0.0134116821,
0.0139102517,
0.0550378412,
-0.0129907234,
-0.0198491439,
0.0393253565,
0.0653766543,
0.0318280347,
0.006490746,
-0.0062263198,
0.0059170639,
0.0119831925,
-0.0190097094,
-0.0082042608,
0.0079218708,
-0.0163347889,
-0.0261971802,
0.004608768,
-0.0089538051,
-0.0288758669,
-0.0529338568,
-0.0170108285,
-0.0579589978,
-0.0385363698,
-0.0032497845,
-0.0161793754,
-0.0380763449,
-0.0520578027,
0.0532043725,
-0.0167696085,
-0.0284588318,
-0.0031539048,
-0.0244171415,
0.0022162027,
-0.0435184464,
-0.0636562631,
-0.0623905733,
-0.012384193,
-0.0036681155,
-0.0403328687,
-0.002735225,
0.0102069434,
-0.0590112954,
-0.0652738363,
-0.0494449101,
-0.0010668285,
0.063296251,
0.0677316561,
0.064409256,
0.0435510874,
0.0061660777,
0.0234345086,
0.0687625632,
-0.0248855334,
-0.0175668672,
0.0282944683,
0.0155782355,
0.040404547,
0.0443503484,
0.0108339814,
0.0382907093,
-0.0229059886,
-0.0602425821,
-0.0010877764,
-0.0087363571,
0.0444774181,
0.0169229154,
0.0287254471,
0.003477982,
-0.0437456034,
-0.0410360694,
-0.0184791554,
-0.0256747082,
-0.0051127141,
0.0113694901,
0.0437047035,
-0.0158432554,
-0.0819520876,
0.0342564806,
-0.0283988621,
0.043524079,
0.0376919843,
-0.0253375527,
0.0127607593,
0.0251146033,
0.0329551175,
-0.0468565673,
-0.0434824601,
0.0087876627,
0.0185778327,
-0.0224279631,
0.0161676146,
0.0073533794,
0.0413436107,
-0.028367158,
-0.0093610641,
-0.0884739459,
0.0333971009,
0.0360323675,
-0.0137991318,
0.0415454879,
-0.0284753647,
-0.013410232,
0.0285691712,
-0.0039433534,
0.0331734568,
0.0384395458,
0.0362613872,
0.0523279421,
0.0587601513,
-0.0272651985,
-0.0058841729,
-0.0478874184,
0.0119309975,
0.0429467,
-0.0303537287,
-0.0110599482,
-0.0034317567,
2.961e-7,
-0.0261801295,
0.0151573429,
0.0371363573,
0.017130129,
0.0378546678,
0.0109515227,
-0.0022476201,
0.0352841988,
-0.0253701117,
0.0300865714,
-0.0126931146,
-0.0041968846,
0.0527788103,
-0.0287936572,
-0.0586250648,
-0.0033358715,
-0.0647625551,
0.0228598937,
-0.0293152388,
-0.0687487796,
0.0082085282,
0.0757736936,
-0.006445264,
-0.0096143009,
0.0115663428,
-0.0018430753,
0.0638872012,
0.009897938,
0.0013988359,
-0.016445145,
0.0624100715,
0.0213684421,
-0.0160085279,
-0.0507552363,
-0.0106023792,
0.0283969585,
-0.0236903485,
0.0621752925,
0.0328805484,
-0.0250602979,
0.0414537266,
-0.018216962,
0.0074993046,
-0.0467425324,
0.0570141524,
-0.0678861737,
-0.0042851064,
-0.0068295482,
-0.0184822343,
0.028094599,
-0.003297017,
-0.0472956188,
-0.0255146343,
0.0026232183,
0.018841967,
0.0193255432,
-0.0058085648,
-0.0287079941,
-0.014214009,
0.0252419803,
-0.0268263295,
-0.0173086207,
-0.0456072465,
-0.0089202905,
0.0004165968,
-0.0453156009,
-0.00677107,
2.871483595e-34,
0.0229098257,
-0.0369819589,
-0.0058839167,
-0.0124811158,
0.0214342456,
-0.0384061001,
-0.0127925873,
0.0238903426,
0.0156039679,
-0.0550537929,
-0.0257879067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11823v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11823v1 | EvolveMT: an Ensemble MT Engine Improving Itself with Usage Only | 2023-06-20T18:32:30 | 2023-06-20T18:32:30 | Kamer Ali Yuksel, Ahmet Gunduz, Mohamed Al-Badrashiny, Shreyas Sharma, Hassan Sawaf | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents EvolveMT for efficiently combining multiple machine
translation (MT) engines. The proposed system selects the output from a single
engine for each segment by utilizing online learning techniques to predict the
most suitable system for every translation request. A neural quality estimation
metric supervises the method without requiring reference translations. The
online learning capability of this system allows for dynamic adaptation to
alterations in the domain or machine translation engines, thereby obviating the
necessity for additional training. EvolveMT selects a subset of translation
engines to be called based on the source sentence features. The degree of
exploration is configurable according to the desired quality-cost trade-off.
Results from custom datasets demonstrate that EvolveMT achieves similar
translation accuracy at a lower cost than selecting the best translation of
each segment from all translations using an MT quality estimator. To our
knowledge, EvolveMT is the first meta MT system that adapts itself after
deployment to incoming translation requests from the production environment
without needing costly retraining on human feedback. | [
0.0150483809,
0.0371286646,
-0.0019400555,
0.0139884865,
-0.0164469946,
0.0285012331,
0.0276248828,
0.0048929779,
-0.0616950989,
-0.0222227685,
-0.0123232445,
-0.0082815075,
0.0183697641,
0.021226868,
0.0317347199,
-0.0574654117,
0.0030668788,
0.0140234903,
-0.0750882328,
0.0125192553,
0.0004309184,
0.0285705402,
0.0202566292,
0.0617356487,
0.0251075663,
0.0079037445,
-0.0083237868,
0.0321731903,
0.0508811846,
0.0117740901,
-0.0136052379,
0.0315784179,
0.0089455405,
0.080838196,
0.0000019771,
-0.028168302,
-0.0747985318,
0.018369928,
0.0057015796,
-0.0216188319,
0.0341856033,
-0.003530147,
-0.0282790009,
0.0473409705,
-0.0060172351,
0.0028922593,
0.0856825858,
-0.0421176963,
0.0825043321,
0.0699841306,
-0.0052654548,
-0.0038508042,
-0.0349396691,
-0.0377853774,
-0.0556218736,
-0.0377116352,
-0.023510471,
-0.0444166325,
-0.044410076,
-0.0143550178,
0.0121764289,
0.0514281914,
0.020633731,
-0.0189076662,
0.0398542807,
-0.0151896263,
-0.0499585234,
-0.0467806645,
-0.0307376366,
0.0459071435,
-0.0153032094,
-0.024599107,
-0.0264237802,
-0.011555749,
-0.0128322951,
-0.0362880453,
-0.0236527659,
-0.0028822226,
-0.0254797973,
-0.0009947903,
-0.0401229411,
0.0307247825,
0.0039856653,
0.018547209,
-0.0684900433,
-0.0046411338,
0.0146327475,
-0.0130134504,
0.0029338729,
0.0334203094,
-0.0297740083,
0.0036514499,
0.0518054962,
-0.0215697438,
-0.0445450693,
0.0224670079,
-0.0404946506,
-0.0868784562,
-0.0140408352,
-0.0344184339,
0.039575696,
0.0396532193,
-0.0016674699,
0.0463558435,
-0.0248550568,
0.0413339548,
-0.0120187402,
-0.0449871533,
-0.0879027694,
-0.0208083186,
-0.0694875941,
0.034909416,
-0.0325401835,
0.0209860466,
-0.0602902621,
-0.0033443235,
-0.0576682873,
0.0405846089,
0.0209663175,
0.004661995,
0.0550829247,
-0.011366453,
-0.0764118657,
-0.0289741587,
-0.0087306816,
0.0578734837,
0.010784056,
-0.0323469676,
0.010549563,
-0.0519705862,
0.0043279333,
0.0126906224,
-0.0090529518,
0.0007187095,
-0.0106746908,
0.0722337738,
-0.0225621536,
-0.0196543001,
0.0108059328,
-0.0129526071,
-0.0095603205,
-0.0337279327,
-0.0197965316,
-0.0330079086,
0.0748116896,
0.0061406293,
0.0082311342,
0.0292440448,
-0.0119252,
-0.0193916485,
0.0161349867,
0.0110720294,
0.0014981177,
0.0280591324,
0.0246312506,
-0.0084052728,
-0.0008395141,
0.094728753,
0.0306108575,
0.0402422324,
0.0310898069,
0.0120234406,
-0.0299123432,
0.03799605,
-0.0210368652,
0.0494465828,
-0.0072256899,
-0.0039217016,
-0.0247373525,
0.0381920747,
-0.0237039011,
0.0314783454,
-0.029410312,
0.0613164157,
0.0775338858,
-0.0224862937,
0.0765070468,
0.0482146144,
0.0593034476,
0.0158400629,
-0.0063561085,
-0.0132602649,
-0.0066210823,
0.0195348114,
-0.007858471,
0.0005617135,
0.0401745476,
0.0645143688,
-0.0037931963,
-0.0568474829,
-0.0070662457,
-0.0279649757,
-0.0391321927,
-0.0236051306,
0.0621808842,
-0.0223839954,
-0.0539238974,
0.0154552665,
-0.0305723343,
-0.0414628424,
0.0039446312,
-0.0148513066,
-0.0310695395,
0.0909122825,
0.0621255636,
-0.0021659355,
-0.0367973,
-0.0281829871,
-0.0000238071,
0.0748231709,
0.0183836631,
0.0071440991,
0.0375866517,
-0.0514058284,
-0.0568464994,
0.0525835529,
0.0062251328,
0.0472558998,
0.0027668681,
0.0455883741,
0.0202403106,
-0.0371851139,
-0.0618352443,
0.0358923189,
0.0122850621,
-0.0016553386,
0.0399029106,
0.0146279773,
0.048494827,
0.0142454673,
-0.0417737775,
-0.0205397699,
0.0025111963,
-0.0321473069,
-0.0731693581,
0.0670814887,
-0.0542696714,
-0.0065847007,
-0.0000149904,
-0.0210091565,
0.010804534,
-0.0583068207,
-0.0620594881,
-0.0620775782,
-0.0415807925,
-0.055411268,
-0.003510877,
-0.0514920801,
0.0460343994,
-0.0253938325,
-0.0187129062,
-0.0446950719,
0.0354407281,
-0.0075134314,
-0.0225103572,
0.0006157022,
-0.0440380014,
0.0322849117,
0.0012013445,
-0.0129529983,
0.0389131643,
0.0201982092,
0.0395617597,
0.0405410044,
0.0159109794,
-0.0413134657,
-0.0328905471,
-0.0705305636,
0.0231974311,
0.0004940023,
0.0320039727,
0.0400480703,
0.0294775367,
0.010340577,
0.004981033,
0.0157296564,
0.0201431792,
-0.0070953406,
0.0213023443,
0.001696958,
-0.000008222,
0.0126055842,
0.0062325727,
0.0026397784,
0.0189586822,
0.0563503318,
0.0003450018,
-0.0461792238,
-0.1009275615,
-0.03237243,
-0.0548625253,
0.0037882978,
0.0298435297,
-0.072152704,
-0.0173373986,
-0.0306376535,
-0.0062166355,
0.0433593392,
0.0079613132,
-0.0268931184,
0.0557223931,
0.0165802091,
-0.048236493,
0.009749189,
0.0091595892,
-0.0249921549,
-0.0045654853,
-0.0253011063,
0.0109393708,
-0.0021137008,
0.011158159,
0.0064406884,
-0.0645816177,
0.012850102,
0.0012744208,
-0.0134439589,
-0.0012950791,
0.0011954207,
0.0061773034,
0.0243432093,
-0.000443481,
-0.0629117563,
0.092752859,
-0.0015541968,
-0.0314109698,
-0.0823156014,
-0.0010544563,
-0.0077943956,
0.0160859339,
-0.0271974951,
0.0409946144,
0.0238881148,
-0.007203985,
-0.0378079563,
0.0125057902,
0.0616750941,
-0.0266585164,
0.0185889322,
-0.0729796365,
-0.0063961344,
-0.0167808142,
-0.0164844058,
-0.008484005,
0.02617619,
-0.0033317409,
-0.0001130867,
0.0096251229,
-0.041674044,
-0.0581245683,
0.0131085226,
0.0211144108,
0.0528817028,
-0.0127400383,
-0.0124435592,
0.0105666928,
0.0042635337,
-0.0300120059,
0.0535432585,
-0.0039852629,
-0.0271254051,
0.0713050365,
0.0066194129,
-0.0051919846,
-0.0412073731,
-0.0482088253,
-0.0536796711,
0.0201879237,
-0.026936464,
-0.0135412524,
-0.0174060091,
0.0382562689,
-0.0685052797,
0.0269433334,
0.0800236762,
0.0039514168,
-0.0237323344,
-0.029097518,
0.004045249,
0.0386653729,
0.0061721196,
0.0321923234,
-0.08117982,
-0.0198593419,
0.0116556212,
0.0622262843,
-0.0019028819,
0.0200239401,
-0.0274709594,
-0.0859018788,
0.0102475761,
0.0392297879,
-0.043752566,
-0.0035214,
-0.0248412266,
-0.0233843923,
-0.052846577,
0.0191701911,
0.0043679113,
0.0483527593,
-0.0035100717,
0.0114802253,
0.0122672915,
-0.0712948218,
-0.0339329615,
-0.0467703976,
-0.0059243282,
0.1088538468,
0.0257846005,
-0.0005244906,
-0.0248312391,
0.0424550995,
-0.0364202522,
0.0317542106,
-0.0224966016,
0.0201397259,
0.0058019795,
-0.0151677392,
0.0083022928,
-0.0273975115,
0.0266092494,
0.0619669929,
0.0464454368,
0.0607299656,
-0.0165882893,
0.0257581044,
0.0008049468,
-0.0482768118,
0.0044156304,
0.0162482485,
-0.0041529858,
-0.0669761226,
-0.0007722707,
-0.0021412515,
-0.0341675431,
-0.0587154217,
0.0283961687,
0.0176170543,
-0.0901497155,
-0.0379824415,
-0.1179799139,
-0.0251116585,
0.0054510217,
0.0887379423,
0.0111366184,
0.0294401664,
0.0130518824,
0.0317006223,
-0.0130477939,
-0.0071993954,
0.0047900751,
-0.0087705897,
-0.0373965725,
0.0087920269,
0.0180713106,
-0.0136771016,
0.0117865074,
0.0117410077,
-0.0344559029,
-0.0700641423,
-0.0355139636,
0.0347197168,
0.0236509778,
0.0286314599,
-0.029138051,
-0.0485369042,
0.068148084,
0.051931005,
0.0166592635,
-0.0143855214,
0.0537959374,
-0.0217767302,
-0.0445116274,
0.0258044191,
-0.0297085289,
-0.0055644484,
-0.0122480178,
0.0283253733,
0.0260378849,
-0.0262658447,
0.0099038696,
0.0136179486,
0.0224952959,
-0.0586317442,
-0.0532486066,
-0.0192377884,
0.0386655107,
0.0303537752,
-0.0282707196,
-0.0512742363,
0.0374307074,
0.0271714106,
-0.0335346125,
0.0131080467,
0.0446238294,
0.0045598508,
-0.069465816,
0.0113733569,
0.0292990953,
-0.0631934777,
0.0206202883,
0.0066715251,
0.0350425467,
-0.0275692903,
0.0125328628,
0.0141719263,
0.0055917543,
-0.0512849502,
0.0445069373,
0.0059696976,
0.0150422249,
0.0388551541,
0.0746226981,
-0.0328292511,
0.0024201297,
-0.062822111,
0.0396944135,
0.0974560007,
0.019122323,
0.1219486445,
0.0045274859,
-0.0106046563,
-0.0415846966,
0.0348529406,
0.0142691694,
0.0203209706,
-0.0081352023,
-0.0248148013,
-0.0100697186,
0.016580753,
0.0313917398,
-0.0572740398,
-0.0063614785,
-0.0028994959,
-0.0134284794,
-0.0393182561,
0.0176952556,
-0.0291257184,
-0.031849958,
-0.0119860843,
-0.0292420685,
0.0185987726,
-0.0064215842,
0.0301521141,
0.0145794591,
0.0048910021,
-0.0174487196,
-0.000725909,
0.0731640384,
-0.0100734076,
0.0349323414,
-0.0221465174,
-0.0024963436,
0.0024881037,
0.01848826,
0.000255457,
-6.026885902e-33,
-0.0004796397,
-0.0154858083,
-0.0138378218,
-0.0622517578,
-0.0395120345,
0.0004217293,
0.0041915397,
-0.0296171196,
0.0106108347,
-0.0235049017,
-0.0011561123,
0.0150204888,
0.0414055735,
-0.0295658596,
0.0159310568,
0.0434795991,
0.0574636646,
0.0072241202,
-0.0400272422,
0.0261326488,
0.0402385294,
0.0345059149,
0.0792475194,
-0.0473602675,
0.0126440506,
0.0073181833,
-0.0411497764,
0.0179837216,
-0.0042404006,
0.0486460216,
0.0507606901,
0.0334665589,
0.0058525903,
-0.0429733843,
-0.0380330794,
-0.0549355559,
-0.0153881628,
-0.0029788648,
0.0089848302,
0.027124064,
0.0115731256,
-0.0194720943,
0.0604787692,
-0.0442193188,
0.0003068463,
-0.0049080113,
0.0212910492,
-0.0807619244,
-0.0256923102,
-0.0545729324,
-0.0248937793,
0.0380189568,
0.0132615268,
-0.0035655368,
0.0117959939,
0.056560643,
-0.0048604175,
-0.008253729,
-0.0471975878,
0.0195980575,
-0.0320264399,
0.038865108,
0.0786961168,
0.0064317342,
-0.0274299141,
-0.0012488717,
0.0081519224,
-0.0305074472,
0.0378451385,
0.0065865116,
0.0286176708,
0.0231069066,
0.1036164463,
0.0526467897,
0.0067965905,
-0.0037421056,
-0.0214844849,
0.0683650747,
0.0250223558,
0.0148432935,
0.0190416519,
0.0482584983,
-0.0062525733,
0.0046763783,
-0.0362743735,
-0.0607671402,
-0.035061758,
-0.0474767089,
0.0081796329,
0.030119624,
-0.0435745791,
-0.0171607453,
0.0773673505,
-0.0150550576,
0.0365265794,
-0.0123246908,
-0.0499451868,
-0.0049489741,
0.0011418494,
0.029378945,
0.010148284,
-0.049342569,
0.0068196137,
0.0311457887,
-0.0132554974,
-0.0551387295,
0.029821109,
0.0206779707,
-0.0554909892,
0.0570937246,
-0.0180227589,
-0.012397211,
-0.0284307525,
0.0183041506,
0.0165573154,
-0.0451107956,
-0.0195772573,
0.0177452266,
0.0283065066,
0.0021484119,
-0.0577916056,
0.0325358734,
0.033381626,
0.037339285,
-0.0412811562,
0.0420257598,
-0.0062493375,
0.0150212552,
0.0267515089,
-0.0178937949,
-0.0517611206,
0.0064357221,
2.685e-7,
0.0395916738,
0.056952443,
-0.0173498765,
-0.0289694071,
0.0114044966,
0.0206216183,
-0.0363858715,
0.0165040642,
-0.0023268682,
0.038834326,
0.0335240066,
-0.0077699544,
0.0955998152,
0.0447080247,
-0.0639947578,
-0.0362269618,
-0.0363280252,
0.0468959995,
-0.0602909438,
0.0208080802,
0.0485003889,
0.0882600024,
0.011163176,
0.0126204481,
0.0021322665,
-0.0295966417,
0.046050556,
0.01880854,
-0.0142958751,
0.0221607499,
0.0344414674,
0.0341521427,
-0.0454329662,
-0.020679025,
-0.0445154384,
0.0050300006,
0.0221009646,
0.0750890523,
0.0035303796,
0.0030229031,
0.0513883047,
-0.0088335415,
0.0139426431,
-0.0130616482,
0.0308826454,
-0.0304174032,
0.0071384246,
-0.0090281786,
-0.0028030605,
-0.0044674478,
0.0606774502,
-0.0344445594,
-0.0395518765,
0.0346215218,
0.0161491055,
-0.0179693922,
-0.0227242038,
-0.0523929037,
-0.021991536,
-0.0147161502,
-0.0088117281,
-0.0765419081,
-0.0208585765,
0.0218934063,
0.0202083699,
-0.0261919554,
-0.0107058799,
2.331577433e-34,
0.023307398,
-0.006990945,
0.0266626868,
0.0133111877,
0.0116312848,
-0.0238427389,
-0.0186814088,
-0.0140258661,
-0.0169123728,
-0.0374777578,
-0.0231194887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11816v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11816v2 | Learning to Generate Better Than Your LLM | 2023-06-20T18:19:17 | 2023-11-13T18:51:42 | Jonathan D. Chang, Kiante Brantley, Rajkumar Ramamurthy, Dipendra Misra, Wen Sun | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Reinforcement learning (RL) has emerged as a powerful paradigm for
fine-tuning Large Language Models (LLMs) for text generation. In particular,
recent LLMs such as ChatGPT and GPT-4 can engage in fluent conversations with
users after finetuning with RL. Capitalizing on key properties of text
generation, we seek to investigate RL algorithms beyond general purpose
algorithms like Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO). In particular, we extend RL
algorithms to allow them to interact with a dynamic black-box guide LLM and
propose RL with guided feedback (RLGF), a suite of RL algorithms for LLM
fine-tuning. We provide two ways for the guide LLM to interact with the LLM to
be optimized for maximizing rewards. The guide LLM can generate text which
serves as additional starting states for the RL optimization procedure. The
guide LLM can also be used to complete the partial sentences generated by the
LLM that is being optimized, treating the guide LLM as an expert to imitate and
surpass eventually. We experiment on the IMDB positive sentiment, CommonGen,
and TL;DR summarization tasks. We show that our RL algorithms achieve higher
performance than supervised learning (SL) and the RL baseline PPO,
demonstrating the benefit of interaction with the guide LLM. On both CommonGen
and TL;DR, we not only outperform our SL baselines but also improve upon PPO
across a variety of metrics beyond the one we optimized for. Our code can be
found at https://github.com/Cornell-RL/tril. | [
0.0636525527,
0.0303259641,
0.0171308126,
-0.0046120435,
-0.030642394,
0.0045119924,
-0.0350648984,
0.0214094464,
0.0106889987,
-0.0226614177,
-0.0258908924,
-0.0115982862,
0.0008876229,
0.0282847583,
0.0354154147,
-0.065113768,
0.0153012201,
-0.0102892658,
0.0320768841,
-0.0163433589,
0.0335056633,
0.0194185618,
0.0097786514,
0.0352804177,
0.0050601782,
0.0298915245,
0.0012364627,
0.0195935387,
0.0490068272,
-0.0135229677,
0.0165664088,
0.0161201861,
0.0249212831,
0.0028642546,
0.0000019541,
-0.0207122415,
-0.0202362314,
-0.040161442,
0.0544641502,
-0.0238973014,
0.054906413,
0.0061732777,
0.0075582196,
0.0254510064,
-0.0488107353,
0.0313011371,
0.0211378336,
0.0552194826,
0.0772774667,
0.1136344075,
0.0269372985,
0.0024518874,
0.0186422113,
-0.0512287542,
0.0400354713,
-0.0109056365,
-0.0108893607,
0.0329102427,
0.0189548023,
-0.0127566317,
-0.017659463,
0.0080081057,
0.0282692201,
-0.0256854221,
0.0115729617,
0.0635914057,
0.003735628,
-0.031511426,
0.0112764956,
0.0759255365,
-0.0095844073,
-0.0024133895,
0.0432614349,
-0.0039488659,
0.0074397665,
-0.0402209163,
-0.0440489165,
0.0430531427,
-0.0085643446,
0.0360871106,
-0.005493518,
-0.0116015738,
0.0273586698,
0.0090546636,
0.0109033985,
0.0141663868,
-0.0001877532,
-0.0393825881,
-0.0040381658,
0.0098389592,
-0.0153087117,
-0.0511271618,
0.0021270495,
0.0442211218,
-0.063177377,
0.0037534644,
-0.0625985414,
0.0218986869,
0.0094998777,
0.0148371644,
0.0351574458,
0.0282394271,
0.0299151205,
0.0055959746,
-0.0130155068,
0.0411454402,
-0.0014100019,
0.0244894624,
-0.0223920662,
0.0340382196,
-0.0569436997,
-0.0114188567,
-0.0166537855,
0.0631434768,
-0.023186449,
-0.037370991,
-0.0898841769,
0.0274346042,
-0.0096121896,
0.0300195776,
0.0071405577,
0.0303100366,
-0.0336687826,
-0.014056541,
-0.0338770449,
0.0076255519,
-0.0661913678,
-0.0087890318,
0.0383018963,
0.0033305925,
-0.0053778072,
0.0446987599,
0.0078365533,
0.0080238869,
0.0030301802,
0.0875992253,
-0.0346000344,
-0.0294610187,
-0.0185954496,
-0.0664950833,
-0.0395914465,
-0.0791703984,
0.0026287495,
-0.0802493244,
0.0092670871,
-0.0259286109,
-0.0130514028,
-0.031141853,
0.0212792382,
0.011503987,
-0.0295008887,
0.0217840783,
-0.0177615006,
-0.0182766691,
0.0158180855,
0.010782415,
-0.0028245468,
0.0342917591,
0.0499864481,
0.0614164881,
-0.0016604707,
0.0233957302,
-0.0019657528,
0.0122906128,
0.0480291843,
0.0227818154,
-0.0250382014,
-0.025519561,
-0.0351941772,
0.0469569527,
0.0438867509,
0.0630261004,
-0.0381897092,
0.0398860611,
0.0727639198,
0.0266890712,
-0.0379190557,
0.0069941888,
0.0345912986,
0.0463403687,
-0.0165369362,
0.0448971391,
-0.0302712061,
0.045408424,
-0.0214594249,
0.0416090749,
0.0687324256,
0.0171349738,
-0.009779132,
-0.0482847132,
0.0275344942,
-0.0295465682,
0.0035730058,
0.0114553049,
-0.0043980135,
0.0283510257,
-0.0790643543,
0.003927344,
0.0283022169,
-0.0410245061,
0.0255383886,
-0.0452654921,
0.0471655689,
0.0740889683,
0.0441814326,
-0.0042822487,
-0.0171820018,
-0.0362917222,
-0.0025236853,
0.0758573785,
0.0281735938,
-0.0037974955,
-0.012031747,
-0.0420844033,
-0.0085255308,
-0.0270430949,
0.0072561274,
0.0342273675,
0.0369421095,
-0.0025958263,
0.0223267805,
0.0196605083,
-0.0362093709,
0.0106810816,
-0.0310125053,
-0.0440835096,
0.0290876981,
-0.0260416288,
0.0180671997,
0.0007738734,
-0.0204064623,
0.0197383743,
0.0030349293,
-0.032000456,
-0.052788917,
-0.0023156586,
-0.0594424158,
-0.0420543626,
0.0229767151,
-0.0446856171,
0.026203597,
0.0268492177,
-0.0532876253,
-0.0390682817,
0.0095014852,
-0.0398312546,
0.0200326573,
-0.0208917167,
0.0012843198,
0.0406919792,
-0.0006670647,
-0.0426852293,
0.0424684919,
-0.0361330956,
-0.0004011422,
0.0248684101,
0.0040646796,
-0.0269073881,
-0.0557432845,
0.0038016506,
0.0033647621,
0.013877756,
0.0344037227,
0.0824938491,
0.0839708298,
-0.0601567738,
-0.0619827025,
-0.0629415661,
0.0157871973,
-0.0267203581,
0.0133329071,
0.0413156152,
0.0088102473,
-0.02103661,
-0.0120187486,
-0.0498638153,
-0.0094889719,
0.0463040471,
-0.0170826837,
0.061930798,
0.0168332811,
0.0148644727,
-0.0557794981,
-0.0024900099,
0.0248837788,
-0.0091443546,
0.0029835682,
0.0161647517,
-0.0251912456,
0.023903029,
-0.0382143632,
-0.0265811626,
-0.0076561174,
-0.0350678302,
0.0058726724,
-0.0217582211,
0.0332304575,
0.0484116413,
0.0312345363,
0.0482201353,
-0.0043390542,
0.0184246488,
-0.0630863383,
0.0277204625,
-0.0501517206,
-0.0445118062,
-0.0355432369,
-0.0337240063,
0.0532896146,
0.0486943051,
0.0155804781,
0.0324914679,
-0.0759757906,
0.0485978872,
0.0063551082,
-0.0399121232,
-0.0088695278,
0.0374434739,
-0.0464516021,
-0.0016659627,
-0.0392856076,
-0.0643457323,
0.0688793808,
-0.018934615,
0.004422172,
-0.0312500224,
-0.0228838939,
-0.0368441008,
0.0053314664,
0.0224024206,
0.0303801559,
-0.0292353667,
-0.0025765286,
-0.0459098928,
-0.0270061996,
0.0204620864,
-0.0052565285,
0.0352318548,
-0.0078847148,
-0.0037699777,
0.0097787706,
-0.050611224,
-0.0393763743,
-0.0344090909,
-0.0143298917,
-0.0059714871,
0.0172705762,
-0.0558184125,
-0.0142651377,
-0.0190156028,
0.0176519863,
0.0089457687,
-0.0441943184,
-0.0370690785,
-0.0254770294,
0.0194526389,
0.0565787181,
-0.0154503016,
-0.0054259426,
-0.0465573855,
0.0139074596,
0.045076035,
0.0299531873,
-0.0097851902,
-0.0051374608,
0.0069877133,
-0.0008892662,
-0.0395251028,
0.0021340773,
0.0437492803,
0.0575541072,
-0.0466745198,
-0.024901526,
0.1181454509,
0.0116774524,
-0.0536213964,
0.0036844544,
0.0335602425,
0.0807802901,
0.0172711238,
0.0355006009,
-0.0467802286,
-0.0286948271,
-0.0175891276,
0.0741337612,
-0.0083047273,
-0.0332158878,
-0.0374854691,
-0.1189885885,
0.0155280372,
0.0111895697,
-0.0221467149,
-0.0223610234,
0.007460787,
-0.0316899978,
0.0173845291,
0.0093712546,
0.0127507905,
-0.0365888253,
0.0217708796,
0.0196633041,
-0.014540026,
-0.0276733078,
-0.02531242,
-0.0185107999,
0.0298517868,
0.086198464,
0.0490865,
0.0085414099,
0.0255220328,
0.0453684703,
0.0268456582,
0.0078505734,
-0.0362906456,
0.0360763855,
-0.0145226978,
0.0046227076,
-0.0235832501,
0.0628028065,
-0.0125401504,
-0.004003318,
0.0070294258,
0.0239408724,
-0.0091741513,
-0.0312381499,
0.0001519189,
0.0783847049,
0.0163708106,
0.0572431013,
0.0316311494,
-0.0368343592,
-0.0553428382,
-0.030074764,
-0.003046823,
-0.0880868062,
-0.0175736155,
-0.036740154,
0.0059345108,
0.0351578407,
-0.1084107012,
-0.0583122112,
0.0092861531,
0.0152184553,
-0.0350585505,
-0.0076822331,
-0.0451085605,
-0.0040837703,
-0.0120516876,
-0.0207303837,
-0.0345504023,
-0.0199594796,
-0.0515419468,
-0.0359408483,
0.0167408176,
-0.0446657129,
-0.0139466338,
-0.0090567674,
-0.102529794,
-0.0706290454,
-0.0379134193,
0.0961398929,
0.0180726368,
0.0719509944,
0.0251560658,
-0.0496342294,
0.0700306892,
0.0809085891,
-0.0279255696,
0.0333978683,
0.0130906506,
0.05682211,
-0.0050717248,
0.0453150682,
-0.0488590822,
-0.0054388116,
-0.0049180179,
0.042525325,
0.0020242338,
-0.0216178596,
0.0043330044,
0.0154970074,
-0.0122638568,
-0.0504202321,
-0.0033699395,
-0.0188800413,
-0.0225283932,
0.0113777267,
-0.0096127549,
-0.0418945067,
-0.0034465804,
0.0050161122,
0.0000680009,
-0.0033586898,
0.0183040705,
-0.0015312927,
0.0644657165,
-0.0298271626,
-0.0148338871,
-0.0053152135,
-0.0279609635,
0.0263544824,
0.0064852312,
-0.0149562676,
0.0314165391,
0.0051471721,
0.0260914322,
-0.0170107856,
0.0565685257,
0.0424836092,
0.0170153659,
-0.0092216078,
0.018109398,
-0.0615699254,
-0.0543090478,
-0.0124241002,
0.0760019347,
0.0766720921,
0.0341614485,
0.0564071685,
-0.0523585789,
-0.0040586973,
-0.0165019184,
0.0371636823,
-0.0324335583,
-0.0281859189,
0.0183724016,
0.0015785869,
-0.0092421547,
-0.0060627917,
0.0897563025,
0.0142888976,
0.0245425049,
0.0055139861,
0.0123708686,
-0.0529137552,
-0.0409037247,
0.0046477849,
0.018086832,
0.0232277978,
0.0027670618,
-0.0323732011,
-0.0439889617,
-0.0083859432,
0.0256684553,
0.0014779978,
-0.0407609269,
0.0637796596,
0.0252235774,
-0.0103788665,
0.0156546794,
-0.05061993,
-0.0081063882,
-0.0103712287,
-0.0327282026,
-0.0106033441,
-6.346754813e-33,
-0.045235645,
-0.0526010729,
0.0268384144,
0.0288336482,
-0.04933789,
-0.0282834955,
-0.037445128,
-0.0008628647,
0.0715968013,
0.0086251628,
-0.0164292548,
-0.0083678616,
-0.0070516015,
0.0478039756,
-0.0126032121,
-0.0151972277,
0.0561064854,
-0.0096560726,
-0.0712186545,
0.0631234124,
0.0208023433,
0.0447733365,
0.0110534318,
-0.0226014331,
0.0192202609,
-0.0197617225,
-0.0447420515,
0.0257201307,
0.0021686279,
0.0441015251,
-0.0045624315,
0.0210712831,
0.0120040737,
-0.0111744553,
-0.0425328165,
0.0185116343,
-0.0477228016,
-0.0426475666,
0.0122012878,
-0.0397145115,
-0.0777493492,
-0.0434160456,
0.0348600857,
-0.0183129851,
-0.0130775832,
-0.0110793235,
0.0164888687,
-0.0088543445,
-0.0277673453,
-0.0626812279,
-0.0538114868,
0.0058386922,
0.0030610047,
-0.0176198147,
-0.0058431085,
0.023597043,
-0.0128113795,
0.0221519805,
0.0169470664,
0.0185494181,
0.0072538806,
0.0374239944,
0.0544230007,
0.0450151004,
-0.0097922459,
0.0582727976,
-0.0105965696,
0.0085962042,
-0.0106973192,
-0.0080862641,
0.0040846309,
0.0172442589,
-0.015227966,
0.0563957058,
-0.014445466,
0.0132030062,
-0.0229617916,
0.0408057533,
0.0268256813,
0.0211067777,
0.0479771011,
-0.010424911,
-0.0090644397,
-0.0232785828,
-0.0578466989,
0.0086410875,
0.0019872542,
-0.0392474011,
0.0227788668,
0.0694837272,
-0.0218173079,
-0.0747528449,
0.0055894051,
-0.0209914669,
-0.0038974457,
0.0293496847,
-0.0735417306,
-0.0104668783,
0.0053689084,
-0.0117487404,
-0.0730809271,
-0.0126603562,
-0.0052725454,
-0.0233927574,
-0.016378643,
0.0214636531,
0.0369996093,
0.025758015,
-0.0606715232,
0.0409210399,
-0.0311403461,
0.0858232006,
-0.02327062,
0.0109789008,
0.0137773613,
-0.005643548,
-0.0273459014,
0.0623035915,
0.0142662218,
-0.0004985132,
-0.0190921072,
-0.0073447581,
-0.0085509941,
0.0024942749,
-0.0550312661,
0.0335158631,
-0.0193425193,
0.0176067483,
0.0007680369,
-0.0648962483,
-0.0139931003,
-0.0103409421,
2.617e-7,
-0.0086543355,
0.0540491082,
0.0558778495,
0.0537894666,
0.0191473495,
0.0496766493,
-0.013657609,
0.036297068,
0.014614691,
0.0020556154,
0.027075896,
0.0388713181,
0.0417777598,
-0.0129857874,
-0.087755844,
0.0181775913,
-0.0885178596,
0.0056904256,
-0.0367927328,
-0.0536253154,
0.0415901691,
0.0457424223,
0.0190465413,
-0.0307071637,
0.0259242281,
-0.0238306765,
0.1042464226,
-0.0371793732,
-0.0461166836,
0.0108274277,
0.0521057174,
0.0104151396,
-0.0267089065,
-0.0373023711,
0.0043003331,
-0.0251012594,
-0.039865993,
0.0909403935,
0.0555775054,
-0.0417073779,
0.0206139162,
0.0201116465,
0.02494023,
-0.0118645504,
0.0406647585,
-0.0656790361,
0.001893412,
-0.0191593375,
0.018079577,
-0.0510981902,
0.0076142019,
-0.0727732629,
-0.0491980426,
0.0415505171,
-0.0071217129,
0.027874276,
-0.0074143396,
-0.0569688678,
-0.0443262458,
0.0062589934,
-0.038153369,
-0.0414254032,
-0.0588027276,
0.0636252984,
-0.0176445525,
-0.0533076003,
-0.0226285551,
2.661850479e-34,
0.0546711348,
-0.0201854594,
-0.0114922533,
-0.0175119601,
0.0181291644,
0.0308122989,
-0.0000614863,
0.0111308908,
0.0498402417,
-0.0364116393,
-0.0272300523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11702v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11702v2 | Lingua Manga: A Generic Large Language Model Centric System for Data Curation | 2023-06-20T17:30:02 | 2023-09-01T15:40:40 | Zui Chen, Lei Cao, Sam Madden | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL | Data curation is a wide-ranging area which contains many critical but
time-consuming data processing tasks. However, the diversity of such tasks
makes it challenging to develop a general-purpose data curation system. To
address this issue, we present Lingua Manga, a user-friendly and versatile
system that utilizes pre-trained large language models. Lingua Manga offers
automatic optimization for achieving high performance and label efficiency
while facilitating flexible and rapid development. Through three example
applications with distinct objectives and users of varying levels of technical
proficiency, we demonstrate that Lingua Manga can effectively assist both
skilled programmers and low-code or even no-code users in addressing data
curation challenges. | [
0.0274830777,
0.090374358,
-0.0152628794,
0.0032988563,
0.014855409,
0.0265688561,
0.0078837955,
-0.0158153586,
0.0175122228,
-0.0081537841,
-0.0203958862,
0.0027998944,
-0.0232620593,
0.0479278155,
-0.0228431281,
-0.0212538112,
0.040453665,
-0.024346441,
0.0090280036,
0.0159655102,
0.0074528749,
0.0269265994,
0.0386858135,
0.028443642,
-0.0075807949,
-0.0108576734,
-0.0009038458,
-0.0166625679,
-0.0260939393,
0.01314345,
0.0176867265,
0.0418445282,
-0.0200473629,
0.0569390394,
0.0000021061,
-0.0437759161,
-0.038909357,
0.0061095352,
-0.0274487566,
0.032845594,
0.0502649955,
-0.0322870314,
-0.0491414107,
0.005376786,
-0.0096657667,
-0.0168815143,
0.0502836928,
-0.002279229,
0.0882759616,
-0.0039359434,
-0.0134039614,
-0.0574593171,
-0.0166976657,
-0.0068069869,
0.0203259811,
-0.0213466585,
0.0412106998,
0.0360635892,
0.0418891571,
0.0122477254,
0.0289503001,
0.0393358991,
-0.0071936711,
-0.041271884,
-0.0088764066,
0.0166006386,
-0.0205746349,
-0.0380589217,
-0.0151692098,
0.0739058554,
-0.0315551572,
-0.0313499421,
0.0195877124,
-0.0047996407,
-0.0013558459,
0.0084271831,
-0.0336217619,
0.015896244,
-0.0064558769,
-0.0011649299,
-0.0165699236,
-0.0448444635,
-0.0073346454,
-0.0152303912,
-0.0536335893,
0.0361057185,
0.0018638684,
-0.0220920369,
0.0100286053,
-0.0099738883,
0.0255413819,
-0.0940150172,
0.0299700312,
0.0682947189,
-0.0178007279,
0.0096208286,
-0.0226665083,
-0.0709479824,
0.0471449383,
-0.0687981918,
-0.005537637,
-0.0107017821,
-0.0354750678,
0.0700189024,
0.0380365588,
-0.0005674979,
0.0018707828,
-0.0223536585,
-0.015868485,
-0.0486595854,
-0.0577194877,
-0.0405396186,
-0.0397585742,
0.0285644121,
-0.0285396483,
0.0126545317,
-0.0474130362,
0.0654281676,
-0.0184504185,
0.0470684022,
0.0558667295,
-0.0404316261,
-0.011207819,
0.013147247,
-0.0143801821,
0.0141768139,
-0.0291716605,
-0.0032469169,
-0.0331078433,
-0.0394830257,
0.0269403551,
-0.0179352239,
0.0508924574,
-0.0305611715,
0.0422640257,
0.0579479374,
0.0129413577,
0.04404594,
-0.0462279841,
-0.0405533947,
0.0024075776,
-0.0255152062,
-0.0514787212,
-0.0646083429,
0.0415529013,
0.0307843518,
-0.012807589,
-0.0775343403,
-0.012052564,
0.0190507397,
-0.0653275177,
0.0549549088,
-0.0787702128,
0.0342204198,
0.063823007,
-0.0014383317,
0.0459058136,
0.0553275123,
-0.0019199998,
0.0443589985,
0.0276957937,
-0.0307114311,
0.0346353166,
0.0679599643,
-0.0162644219,
-0.0029630344,
-0.0451944843,
0.0310112964,
0.0248508118,
-0.0106746564,
-0.0024248047,
0.0435671844,
-0.0209598169,
0.038861949,
0.0506453551,
0.0341682509,
0.0233341213,
0.0506735295,
0.0266921651,
0.0349678621,
0.0047197449,
-0.0718850419,
-0.0144104511,
0.0436998345,
-0.0050313333,
0.0064783152,
-0.026780881,
0.0557842627,
-0.0198590308,
-0.0437403545,
-0.0070230379,
-0.0223163161,
-0.0173756797,
0.011147731,
0.0429507419,
0.0248412434,
-0.009485323,
0.0113920057,
0.0087215062,
-0.0557913333,
-0.0015488965,
0.0207011662,
0.001177922,
0.0669278204,
0.0236445386,
-0.0694323555,
-0.0306849945,
-0.0075151576,
0.0495842323,
-0.0113825332,
0.0536605231,
-0.0591113083,
-0.0322649889,
-0.0404801443,
-0.0300715026,
0.0339224041,
-0.0130709792,
0.0381346047,
-0.0088970726,
0.0055342023,
0.0125524988,
-0.0113318348,
-0.0966602191,
0.0315987207,
-0.0105298059,
-0.0462468117,
-0.0122503573,
0.0051644691,
-0.0003174626,
0.0172283817,
-0.032904353,
0.0036140883,
0.060757257,
-0.0042097401,
-0.0026871825,
0.0131858671,
0.0254013576,
-0.0130231734,
0.0698675439,
0.0099926498,
-0.0399353877,
-0.05552366,
-0.0534523055,
-0.0211420227,
-0.0175505914,
-0.0041094138,
-0.046165131,
-0.0188069139,
0.0374744758,
-0.0164470039,
-0.0084074009,
-0.0417258106,
0.0623767152,
0.0426259451,
0.0086662518,
0.0183041245,
0.0021661259,
0.0094698202,
-0.0219225753,
-0.0045440779,
0.0388315618,
-0.0027107559,
0.0272700414,
0.0076253824,
0.0148383696,
-0.0247019138,
-0.0026615083,
-0.0866403207,
-0.0018267435,
0.010649737,
0.0017946678,
0.0047148969,
0.0313103385,
-0.0230096523,
-0.035786178,
-0.0182541609,
-0.0097394651,
0.0088182921,
0.0329387747,
0.021208223,
0.0190949813,
-0.0024579638,
-0.0076619782,
-0.010141477,
-0.001520089,
0.0177322756,
0.0419938527,
-0.0421056077,
-0.0358241834,
0.0030998189,
-0.0695814863,
0.0040448452,
0.0415789299,
-0.0073315524,
-0.0329000354,
-0.0255061388,
0.033389546,
0.0219726842,
-0.0365690961,
0.0006371344,
0.0456037112,
-0.0388162993,
-0.0328202285,
0.0067631169,
0.0032723646,
-0.0124113234,
0.0109262774,
-0.0175887905,
0.0407210477,
0.0634082854,
-0.0145256575,
-0.0019926224,
0.0020591684,
0.0438235477,
-0.0046106381,
0.0194026474,
-0.0616875924,
-0.0096727675,
-0.012065717,
0.0449313112,
-0.0297722984,
-0.0367501937,
0.0774371624,
-0.0221424494,
-0.0191756971,
-0.0247998182,
-0.0373386741,
-0.0431715026,
0.0054364554,
0.0094936835,
0.0321311131,
-0.0365365669,
-0.0237024464,
-0.0132494345,
0.0635719374,
0.0247237179,
-0.0464188233,
0.0357430801,
-0.0321761146,
0.0111711789,
-0.0076847002,
-0.0328158773,
-0.0176818892,
0.0352565236,
-0.0314786695,
-0.0178890619,
0.0419805907,
0.0279520918,
-0.0071436074,
0.0289190765,
0.0225750487,
0.083792299,
0.0459153689,
-0.0258173216,
0.007061772,
-0.0473269932,
-0.005289027,
-0.0329136103,
-0.0416201018,
0.0060960688,
-0.0014623184,
0.0300313961,
0.0353691652,
-0.050742507,
-0.0075235479,
0.0220844001,
0.0454254411,
-0.0409786068,
-0.0041446099,
0.0112322988,
0.0017866185,
-0.0470774844,
-0.0008927135,
0.0980564356,
0.0596708171,
-0.0622138679,
-0.0200759396,
0.003681333,
-0.0067278813,
0.0524343178,
0.0309353285,
-0.0786608011,
-0.0122842789,
0.0101735648,
0.0064413734,
0.0086714104,
-0.0488211438,
-0.0116723347,
-0.0769205689,
0.0764615163,
0.0015398397,
-0.0666161478,
-0.0141710127,
-0.0600603409,
0.0040621846,
-0.0350097939,
-0.0291121844,
0.0192624852,
-0.03037454,
-0.0052650883,
0.0017607824,
-0.0445029922,
-0.0499105789,
-0.0119761322,
-0.0350207239,
0.0121968584,
0.0559076257,
0.0444789007,
-0.0225622971,
0.0242538303,
0.0727440938,
0.0301220026,
-0.0316755101,
-0.0648105219,
0.0238299966,
0.0143473903,
-0.0217364263,
0.0071844971,
-0.002046695,
-0.0170474146,
-0.007615841,
0.0221359357,
0.1068218276,
-0.0029118357,
0.0508002788,
-0.0077755493,
-0.0483096279,
0.0405884832,
0.0490990281,
0.0263532456,
-0.0605891049,
0.0004955819,
-0.0565738939,
-0.046523653,
-0.003754575,
-0.0312251057,
0.0260134544,
-0.0804573968,
-0.0623042509,
-0.0507613644,
-0.0309766922,
0.0751822665,
0.0186845809,
0.0521684103,
0.0222393181,
0.044266317,
-0.0253690314,
-0.0556611568,
-0.0051906807,
-0.0426068567,
0.0103952661,
-0.0784597099,
-0.0281434692,
-0.0022464832,
-0.0033535834,
-0.0479859821,
0.0059949798,
-0.0518572703,
-0.054470133,
0.0111086657,
0.0428586602,
0.0217946451,
-0.0017423825,
-0.0002854818,
-0.0649013817,
0.0056613199,
0.0411459468,
-0.0331437849,
-0.0391997918,
-0.0221919119,
-0.0014780357,
-0.0032991534,
-0.0149023915,
-0.0532550663,
0.0514679812,
0.0202281345,
-0.042659007,
-0.0367564596,
-0.0043446301,
0.0314032212,
0.0606553368,
0.0179985538,
0.0288063716,
-0.0529611185,
-0.0559488311,
0.0150761046,
-0.023405578,
-0.0566400513,
-0.0349767543,
0.0318388417,
0.0500374287,
-0.0116144633,
0.0337705612,
0.0558618791,
0.006054203,
0.0237969421,
-0.0689497367,
0.0282903239,
-0.029967377,
0.0345306247,
0.0702033639,
-0.0060723387,
-0.0043079369,
-0.0002280164,
0.0231464487,
0.0373635963,
-0.0342965983,
-0.0027701007,
0.0053317612,
0.0322737694,
-0.0079217292,
0.010728105,
-0.0130285155,
-0.0621058643,
-0.0255688801,
0.0261209179,
0.0586098544,
-0.004714522,
0.0236410443,
-0.0326824784,
-0.0363502316,
-0.0438791029,
0.0307004377,
0.0356894061,
-0.0148071265,
-0.0110066002,
-0.006824302,
-0.0425021872,
-0.0426063128,
0.0882007852,
0.0176002793,
-0.0160405319,
-0.0150637059,
-0.0469170958,
-0.0408969074,
0.0263288561,
0.0119394325,
-0.0336757302,
-0.0505555347,
-0.036513377,
-0.0285756923,
-0.0556834526,
0.0303890072,
0.0008312152,
-0.0329057537,
0.0194976572,
0.0280387048,
0.0844277143,
0.0072648418,
0.0343014263,
-0.0261441898,
0.0233901422,
-0.0249013789,
-0.0407105535,
0.0153044481,
-5.925557187e-33,
-0.0201440752,
-0.0520884506,
0.0131447501,
-0.0190509427,
0.0495381244,
-0.0311141573,
-0.0100295153,
-0.0195606239,
0.0349294059,
-0.0205464605,
-0.0201363433,
0.0152401207,
0.025753662,
-0.0181217715,
0.0368303135,
0.0268617272,
0.0687814057,
0.0197157748,
-0.0195983909,
0.0038637053,
0.0038031028,
0.0520955138,
0.0209765695,
-0.0970989391,
0.0130340252,
0.0184039138,
0.026174359,
0.0071217641,
0.0678610876,
0.0502765104,
-0.0007392856,
0.0269253366,
0.0041376879,
-0.0381795801,
-0.0435359813,
0.0008309424,
-0.073153913,
-0.0286781583,
0.0033857166,
0.0294172466,
0.0561206155,
-0.0279526617,
0.0341112167,
-0.0233690012,
-0.0005261721,
0.0394668765,
0.0340187736,
-0.041604653,
-0.0452069826,
-0.0413185917,
-0.0575037934,
0.0240482185,
-0.0103748105,
0.0545079485,
0.0862459689,
-0.010872473,
0.0292358827,
0.0429136679,
-0.0583696067,
0.0359405465,
0.0230247341,
0.0178473238,
0.0813573748,
0.0155034028,
0.0330374576,
0.0136347124,
0.0227022469,
0.0222842693,
0.019753933,
0.0456787795,
-0.0241097007,
0.053328298,
-0.0000553009,
0.0198572986,
0.0267179385,
-0.0581716299,
-0.0399847925,
0.0484874733,
-0.0340956412,
-0.0112417331,
-0.0328358151,
0.045670297,
0.0017103703,
-0.0243263971,
-0.0025583841,
0.0455581918,
-0.0474886447,
0.010256161,
0.0137983477,
0.024031451,
-0.0416872986,
0.0636879727,
0.0203811154,
-0.0108072767,
-0.0921761468,
0.0307161361,
-0.0040190332,
-0.0087270234,
-0.0123662744,
0.0136690354,
-0.048724886,
-0.0222483389,
-0.0201680511,
-0.0181937013,
0.0408361852,
0.0293294396,
0.0509967431,
0.0210257061,
-0.0721826106,
0.0375994109,
-0.0102294888,
0.0059496141,
0.0160735566,
0.0588505715,
0.029179614,
-0.0065433923,
0.0361787863,
0.0273768101,
0.0671334267,
-0.0165394135,
-0.0485816486,
-0.0329579897,
-0.0031728998,
-0.0075087678,
-0.0125631858,
-0.0314973481,
-0.038285803,
0.0153252259,
0.0650221631,
-0.0262916815,
-0.0059945984,
0.0096355844,
2.676e-7,
0.0595368482,
0.0590712354,
0.0116883023,
0.0238584112,
0.0030935295,
-0.0137811787,
-0.0179535095,
-0.0282847472,
0.0129772387,
0.0288450532,
0.0117483614,
0.0019613251,
0.0523901582,
0.0807761177,
-0.1007217243,
-0.0329285823,
-0.0203106143,
-0.0090721482,
-0.113515079,
0.0086828023,
0.0170053169,
0.0753557086,
-0.0300757997,
0.0039205654,
0.0086648231,
-0.0449512079,
-0.0014900942,
-0.0295990426,
0.0246254448,
0.0807186961,
0.0405278578,
0.0156416018,
-0.0225558374,
-0.0108062867,
-0.0223319791,
-0.0071507753,
0.0307359435,
0.0601342022,
-0.0333278887,
0.0675070956,
0.0339380279,
-0.063759394,
-0.0267463941,
-0.0226169694,
0.045135539,
-0.0301300623,
0.0190577954,
0.0324541926,
0.0096876686,
-0.0249815099,
-0.0039700572,
-0.0402804352,
0.007885485,
-0.0028634781,
0.021556763,
-0.0065177418,
-0.0433866791,
-0.0388477594,
-0.0320114903,
0.0263776686,
-0.0122562181,
-0.0491974354,
-0.0396565907,
-0.0209885035,
0.0233404469,
-0.0114015127,
0.0402239412,
2.936464096e-34,
0.0354893468,
0.0080194417,
0.0122783091,
0.0436330214,
0.0472174622,
-0.0224532671,
0.024319794,
0.029776141,
-0.0464236289,
-0.0434449501,
0.0039968318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11698v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11698v5 | DecodingTrust: A Comprehensive Assessment of Trustworthiness in GPT Models | 2023-06-20T17:24:23 | 2024-02-26T20:41:01 | Boxin Wang, Weixin Chen, Hengzhi Pei, Chulin Xie, Mintong Kang, Chenhui Zhang, Chejian Xu, Zidi Xiong, Ritik Dutta, Rylan Schaeffer, Sang T. Truong, Simran Arora, Mantas Mazeika, Dan Hendrycks, Zinan Lin, Yu Cheng, Sanmi Koyejo, Dawn Song, Bo Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR | Generative Pre-trained Transformer (GPT) models have exhibited exciting
progress in their capabilities, capturing the interest of practitioners and the
public alike. Yet, while the literature on the trustworthiness of GPT models
remains limited, practitioners have proposed employing capable GPT models for
sensitive applications such as healthcare and finance -- where mistakes can be
costly. To this end, this work proposes a comprehensive trustworthiness
evaluation for large language models with a focus on GPT-4 and GPT-3.5,
considering diverse perspectives -- including toxicity, stereotype bias,
adversarial robustness, out-of-distribution robustness, robustness on
adversarial demonstrations, privacy, machine ethics, and fairness. Based on our
evaluations, we discover previously unpublished vulnerabilities to
trustworthiness threats. For instance, we find that GPT models can be easily
misled to generate toxic and biased outputs and leak private information in
both training data and conversation history. We also find that although GPT-4
is usually more trustworthy than GPT-3.5 on standard benchmarks, GPT-4 is more
vulnerable given jailbreaking system or user prompts, potentially because GPT-4
follows (misleading) instructions more precisely. Our work illustrates a
comprehensive trustworthiness evaluation of GPT models and sheds light on the
trustworthiness gaps. Our benchmark is publicly available at
https://decodingtrust.github.io/ ; our dataset can be previewed at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/AI-Secure/DecodingTrust ; a concise version of
this work is at https://openreview.net/pdf?id=kaHpo8OZw2 . | [
0.0249609109,
0.1158047095,
-0.014464247,
0.0439590327,
-0.0166733395,
-0.0003156105,
0.030791983,
-0.0049914783,
0.0359688848,
-0.0043526278,
-0.0609517135,
-0.0216993969,
0.0162342321,
0.0288249254,
0.0206523743,
-0.0446984395,
0.0477918461,
0.0112827113,
-0.0133941518,
-0.0225170702,
-0.0006540298,
-0.0068373405,
0.0114112124,
0.0579074584,
-0.0168809332,
-0.0169261061,
0.0253801253,
-0.0050529172,
0.0508497804,
0.0018074124,
0.0035496401,
0.0588281564,
-0.0179733466,
0.0812437385,
0.0000021928,
-0.0212857779,
-0.0230840668,
0.0287035238,
-0.0215682741,
0.0084884744,
0.0136121828,
-0.0472012609,
-0.0134273656,
0.0284596179,
-0.0662607402,
-0.0267444998,
0.0426621921,
0.047202073,
0.0795223936,
0.0840751827,
-0.0201524962,
0.0116176866,
0.0594508722,
-0.048654452,
-0.0015894307,
-0.0728215054,
0.0165745392,
-0.0609114058,
-0.094532378,
0.0229634102,
-0.017611498,
0.0126734367,
0.0472746342,
0.0077386484,
-0.0201042816,
0.0223220382,
-0.0285123587,
-0.0446394607,
-0.0373607539,
0.0602904037,
-0.0384895205,
-0.0033355793,
-0.0083031543,
-0.0037206695,
0.0171850361,
0.0194849726,
0.0072967103,
0.0320680663,
-0.0218688902,
-0.0010520235,
-0.0303825624,
0.0399921201,
0.057065662,
0.0109883025,
-0.0111071225,
0.0349264853,
0.0148693435,
-0.007011259,
0.0135291079,
0.0052591534,
-0.0194814801,
-0.0385765135,
0.0207434352,
-0.0155173307,
0.0117054107,
0.0195751693,
-0.065241918,
-0.0022218558,
0.0220510252,
0.0018381255,
-0.0248578116,
0.0145924361,
-0.0187796205,
0.0085812919,
0.0093529178,
0.0418762304,
-0.0301249512,
0.0467971638,
-0.0022111817,
0.0010282897,
0.0029689868,
-0.0094832499,
-0.0115783308,
0.0092271697,
-0.0254113544,
0.0187898837,
-0.0651592612,
-0.0160009805,
-0.0488745384,
0.0323299542,
0.0321505889,
0.0062929443,
-0.0502281263,
-0.0162502434,
0.0001776889,
-0.0147383763,
-0.0085215345,
0.0130475489,
0.0124190049,
-0.1099152043,
-0.033056099,
-0.001792718,
-0.0614821017,
-0.0406471603,
-0.0247187763,
0.1004520729,
0.0083363559,
-0.0621217974,
-0.0150657343,
-0.0367083214,
-0.0464913175,
-0.04429131,
0.0154829631,
-0.0159456823,
0.017437933,
-0.0251843464,
0.0106700044,
-0.0804723725,
0.0081378398,
0.0012454919,
-0.0431594588,
0.0733280703,
0.0253803115,
-0.0204793345,
-0.0232804548,
0.0658995062,
-0.0467124097,
0.0113809109,
0.0293121915,
0.0642175972,
0.0514470004,
-0.0362533294,
0.0488066152,
0.0245598853,
0.0636316836,
-0.0001752778,
0.0452285148,
0.00706835,
-0.0106937792,
-0.0115220519,
-0.0123372264,
0.0834686086,
-0.0343617685,
-0.0796391144,
0.1108636037,
0.0420679301,
-0.0202139765,
0.0274808742,
0.0058903005,
-0.0067515438,
-0.0018661717,
0.0104115317,
-0.1019587964,
0.0018319299,
-0.0568552688,
-0.0406864285,
-0.045950219,
0.0600204542,
-0.0224499274,
-0.0191693846,
0.0343895592,
-0.0403890312,
0.0435489491,
-0.0044323467,
0.0136357499,
0.0403901637,
-0.0586837232,
0.0242485907,
0.0017343172,
-0.0548410118,
-0.0345263816,
-0.0891069025,
0.025437247,
0.0259314682,
0.0552170761,
0.0228765607,
0.0230120905,
-0.0620111823,
-0.0428159982,
0.0059660017,
0.0198837314,
0.013245835,
0.0387981124,
-0.0423688926,
-0.0063100439,
0.0121801691,
0.0249088444,
0.0403865837,
0.0487919562,
0.0479578525,
0.0124069098,
-0.0341017023,
-0.0034271416,
0.0194058213,
0.0106028644,
-0.0241087768,
0.0299059171,
0.0108212894,
0.0478958897,
0.0212884154,
-0.025395643,
0.0024384037,
0.0269079357,
0.0203561578,
-0.0128033673,
0.0330296569,
-0.0745320842,
0.0042851982,
-0.0181615911,
-0.0691048279,
-0.0233695973,
0.07910157,
-0.045902472,
0.0107310805,
0.0066634859,
0.0016451585,
-0.0014749903,
-0.0349667557,
0.0183542818,
-0.0094067808,
0.0326474532,
-0.0085907215,
0.0213855933,
-0.04997316,
-0.0389587432,
-0.0552353188,
0.0132498872,
0.0107718203,
-0.0038967656,
-0.0250379741,
0.037258029,
-0.026471559,
0.0355750248,
0.0134208836,
0.0142865852,
-0.0097086336,
-0.011125464,
-0.0363887511,
-0.0172274038,
-0.0332262553,
0.0171745829,
0.0271225274,
-0.0030310568,
0.0006167591,
-0.0113112582,
-0.0256811045,
0.0236686338,
0.0009755719,
0.0023372108,
-0.0059531615,
-0.0240891688,
0.0249098893,
-0.0141687477,
-0.0108257253,
-0.0001817632,
0.0577922277,
-0.0050411182,
-0.0053436537,
-0.0033620098,
0.0052643563,
0.0285391118,
0.0147297168,
-0.0264778733,
-0.0607751645,
0.0282084439,
0.0450084843,
-0.0046240781,
0.0594137609,
0.0433333367,
0.0759822875,
0.0147547415,
0.0374497138,
-0.0192766264,
-0.0172949806,
-0.0048400108,
-0.0595724247,
-0.0106106997,
-0.0303155314,
0.0275388248,
0.0597992092,
0.0429316424,
-0.0362608731,
-0.0725114271,
0.0296345651,
-0.0071778777,
-0.0509097949,
0.0297180954,
-0.0254727136,
-0.0175115764,
0.01520692,
-0.0201802012,
-0.076113984,
0.075602904,
-0.0396529324,
0.0170833692,
0.0004040738,
-0.0246707201,
0.0209886897,
0.0502865873,
0.0105556343,
0.0191166848,
0.0450715795,
-0.0080714012,
-0.0319641046,
-0.0183773786,
0.0225481894,
-0.0321804136,
0.0352245606,
-0.0107310517,
-0.026704276,
-0.0123091629,
-0.0724588037,
-0.0444537625,
-0.0585222878,
-0.0034136069,
-0.0179276336,
0.0363836549,
-0.0622057691,
-0.0089310678,
-0.0231306665,
-0.002176225,
0.0369705036,
-0.0189864244,
-0.0072010346,
-0.0042500356,
0.0149251511,
0.0201171115,
-0.0376614109,
0.0527850799,
-0.0157411098,
0.0159306489,
0.0906637385,
0.0156603437,
0.0177962296,
-0.019430913,
-0.0195756387,
-0.0094835442,
0.0035219702,
0.002656898,
0.016483454,
0.0589079484,
-0.0270709228,
0.0081446134,
0.0735364109,
-0.0173446294,
-0.0337470472,
0.0288026351,
0.058015164,
-0.0037890607,
-0.0121254688,
-0.0378180556,
-0.1080508381,
-0.0092731696,
0.0061205397,
0.0505172089,
-0.0239900909,
-0.052274175,
0.017340526,
-0.0971144065,
0.0439643003,
0.0009373449,
-0.0164052546,
-0.049734436,
-0.028693486,
-0.0312625766,
-0.0429919288,
0.0308202859,
-0.0300372094,
0.024663588,
-0.015082363,
-0.0204030685,
-0.01758793,
-0.0362734534,
0.0561267659,
-0.0245473087,
0.035472136,
0.0680995062,
0.0184669234,
-0.0239048749,
-0.0490813926,
-0.0227874815,
-0.0037333656,
-0.0330458246,
0.0218378827,
0.0815316737,
-0.0278493781,
-0.010974681,
0.0083756251,
0.0625106618,
-0.0005250803,
-0.0092667965,
0.0110513447,
0.0322492756,
0.0026496602,
-0.0795783922,
-0.0201024581,
-0.0061623277,
0.0337549672,
0.0723266006,
0.0099481251,
-0.0050524981,
-0.0189617313,
-0.0446603596,
0.0325957201,
-0.0108728558,
-0.0407571085,
0.0448715314,
0.0551728904,
-0.0558118932,
-0.0576615371,
-0.0251599029,
-0.0232940279,
0.0181653276,
-0.0039409664,
-0.0627037361,
0.0350644626,
0.0161483232,
-0.0257893465,
0.0272574276,
-0.0133965034,
0.0359911397,
-0.0325538404,
0.0343746617,
0.0193396471,
-0.0299166087,
-0.0050891894,
0.0525555573,
-0.0344956592,
-0.0486914031,
0.0240925904,
0.0784061477,
0.0247594435,
0.0350978449,
-0.0457705595,
-0.003606515,
0.0568675213,
0.0458826311,
-0.0529117286,
-0.0154445441,
0.0917814672,
-0.0304188859,
-0.0007149532,
0.0213696212,
-0.0034350641,
0.0134378634,
0.0310076047,
-0.0306636821,
-0.0421160609,
-0.0086270953,
0.0194843933,
0.0013657406,
0.0678898469,
-0.0139418375,
0.0563365892,
-0.0182338879,
0.0095286053,
-0.0113655301,
0.0106486436,
-0.0399721451,
-0.0025269277,
0.0816567391,
0.0028905028,
-0.0024986188,
-0.0335375778,
-0.0168533158,
0.0205903444,
-0.0308341905,
0.0197502747,
0.0251155496,
0.0469083972,
0.0227919016,
-0.0072781239,
-0.0055904547,
0.0245050192,
-0.0216830615,
0.0274968501,
0.0106326034,
0.0402826481,
0.0062249377,
-0.0088859741,
0.0433182083,
0.0548214465,
-0.0741692856,
-0.0377366729,
-0.0418490358,
0.0334786028,
-0.0037073216,
0.0091153197,
0.019275438,
-0.0326125249,
0.0033877287,
-0.0086278031,
0.0001042635,
-0.0074413973,
-0.0271369033,
0.0321750343,
-0.0039098742,
-0.0060292524,
0.0229475535,
0.0743237063,
-0.0124803195,
0.0653225705,
-0.0078405859,
-0.0322563909,
-0.0396130383,
-0.0502020232,
0.0172806419,
-0.0116198957,
-0.0202901736,
-0.0468290076,
-0.0600577518,
-0.0916191787,
-0.0133947311,
0.0015516831,
0.0387671478,
0.0028144708,
0.0024924271,
0.0560725033,
-0.0011295072,
0.0266519673,
-0.0244405381,
-0.0135820443,
0.016815193,
-0.0244613774,
-0.005877391,
-6.432360924e-33,
0.0235205442,
-0.0350420251,
-0.0345944315,
-0.0021666302,
0.0107154865,
0.0068350495,
-0.0176253822,
-0.0196902119,
-0.048532404,
0.0161200017,
-0.0286346544,
0.035249088,
0.0001454349,
0.0304565951,
-0.0428104475,
-0.0272851307,
0.0470067859,
-0.0253000539,
-0.0329540819,
0.0414508767,
0.0142479371,
0.0151427602,
0.0663510785,
-0.0911112875,
0.0550626367,
0.0018973695,
-0.0661710426,
-0.0123499958,
-0.0553123578,
0.0422668755,
0.0021405327,
0.0304381363,
-0.0056647519,
-0.0488037392,
0.0126046175,
0.0193813257,
-0.0471580848,
0.0025985339,
-0.01789934,
0.0073813149,
-0.0269039515,
-0.0322349668,
0.0228662733,
-0.0340838209,
-0.0366670825,
-0.0439974517,
-0.0305156503,
0.0040919017,
0.0156883597,
-0.0518323928,
-0.018794572,
0.0152617022,
-0.0242549479,
-0.0152381537,
-0.0055326708,
0.0352703258,
0.0021732755,
0.0213786215,
-0.0550512113,
0.0163092967,
0.0326587819,
-0.0432703681,
0.0489728786,
-0.0575468056,
-0.0111100068,
0.031769909,
0.0147409951,
-0.0082938774,
-0.0199218411,
-0.0116194105,
-0.0030278962,
0.0552345775,
0.0803969726,
0.0952838212,
0.0406662971,
-0.0584567562,
-0.0586696379,
0.0191470832,
0.0086545376,
0.0193769541,
0.0204292741,
-0.0071419119,
-0.0542201288,
0.0047735968,
-0.031682346,
-0.0696657002,
-0.0142470393,
-0.0319273621,
0.013211715,
0.0169746932,
-0.0252276361,
0.022641914,
0.0087987753,
-0.0751534626,
0.0249980949,
0.0333261974,
-0.0114865489,
-0.0123180496,
-0.0159506295,
0.047826454,
-0.0173311401,
0.0041606901,
0.0539385118,
0.0111388704,
0.0395955369,
0.0110456841,
0.0608097985,
0.0239088405,
-0.039897386,
-0.0014642108,
-0.0090737492,
0.0688155144,
0.0300624594,
0.0212279502,
0.0334716477,
-0.0008126791,
-0.0299503952,
-0.0082283653,
0.0035978407,
0.0436529219,
-0.0616370067,
0.0484969281,
-0.0105229802,
0.0197253078,
0.0054919585,
-0.0278909765,
0.0032566255,
-0.0136093935,
0.0593493097,
-0.0610562265,
-0.0091761481,
-0.0207568929,
2.952e-7,
-0.0133855417,
0.0216800552,
0.010421766,
-0.0049229404,
0.020775998,
0.0583722405,
0.0193518288,
0.0751149356,
-0.0274189655,
-0.0391109623,
-0.0194895267,
0.0204756968,
0.0618420057,
0.0519488342,
-0.0274825078,
-0.0207305104,
-0.0913413092,
-0.0273690782,
-0.029579591,
-0.0011750638,
0.0205530208,
0.1117305681,
0.0068479469,
-0.0259551201,
0.0368777625,
-0.0030783599,
0.0315954387,
-0.0315959714,
0.0071399068,
-0.0145830344,
0.0460740775,
0.0322400592,
0.0066435128,
0.0210776497,
-0.0127041303,
-0.0033653977,
-0.0077590002,
0.0641307682,
-0.0025598863,
-0.0244919155,
-0.0349077582,
-0.0218993407,
0.011697676,
-0.0783282891,
0.0529488809,
-0.0380796827,
-0.0335308053,
-0.0210874267,
-0.0303630847,
-0.0381002277,
0.0713367164,
-0.0337962136,
0.0129036726,
0.0098855505,
0.0027147136,
0.04019887,
0.0149913477,
-0.0433139019,
-0.0074836588,
-0.0375223197,
-0.0212389287,
-0.0491396487,
0.0031123539,
0.0023851309,
0.0067580347,
-0.0223562866,
0.0193956587,
2.703716215e-34,
0.0191321839,
-0.033435069,
0.0263997335,
-0.019844152,
0.0514859334,
0.0141987251,
0.0344217159,
-0.0054710563,
-0.0014187123,
-0.0260553602,
-0.0335716233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11695v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11695v3 | A Simple and Effective Pruning Approach for Large Language Models | 2023-06-20T17:18:20 | 2024-05-06T17:47:01 | Mingjie Sun, Zhuang Liu, Anna Bair, J. Zico Kolter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | As their size increases, Large Languages Models (LLMs) are natural candidates
for network pruning methods: approaches that drop a subset of network weights
while striving to preserve performance. Existing methods, however, require
either retraining, which is rarely affordable for billion-scale LLMs, or
solving a weight reconstruction problem reliant on second-order information,
which may also be computationally expensive. In this paper, we introduce a
novel, straightforward yet effective pruning method, termed Wanda (Pruning by
Weights and activations), designed to induce sparsity in pretrained LLMs.
Motivated by the recent observation of emergent large magnitude features in
LLMs, our approach prunes weights with the smallest magnitudes multiplied by
the corresponding input activations, on a per-output basis. Notably, Wanda
requires no retraining or weight update, and the pruned LLM can be used as is.
We conduct a thorough evaluation of our method Wanda on LLaMA and LLaMA-2
across various language benchmarks. Wanda significantly outperforms the
established baseline of magnitude pruning and performs competitively against
recent method involving intensive weight update. Code is available at
https://github.com/locuslab/wanda. | [
-0.015427283,
0.0875444859,
0.0002721263,
0.0668348968,
0.011367511,
0.001620413,
0.0044732238,
0.0409921929,
0.0124918791,
0.0383832939,
-0.0665827096,
-0.0627888218,
-0.0056972606,
0.0199511815,
0.018762067,
-0.0040289289,
0.0154798813,
-0.0380855501,
-0.0305006206,
-0.0289966762,
0.0061909123,
0.012283776,
0.0292951167,
0.0394732542,
0.0233517457,
-0.0017929093,
0.000194541,
0.0039806841,
0.0011888735,
-0.0069825882,
0.0116930511,
0.0341503918,
0.0198573396,
0.0437416621,
0.0000020926,
-0.0246729311,
0.0371136516,
-0.0169133432,
-0.0374161825,
0.0912688076,
0.0370641984,
-0.0047906707,
-0.0160944965,
0.0132263573,
-0.0152898729,
-0.0481738895,
0.0271732006,
0.0403870419,
0.0269583594,
0.080779925,
0.0129547138,
-0.0471793301,
0.0061774598,
-0.0567507185,
-0.0111983065,
-0.0410578698,
0.0247300006,
-0.0241631232,
-0.0468618795,
-0.0113803074,
-0.0038744756,
0.018659614,
0.0444491729,
0.0174583253,
-0.0290270392,
0.0458946712,
-0.0062599448,
-0.0057323035,
0.0278738737,
0.0793653429,
-0.0415998548,
-0.0222169328,
0.0016960265,
-0.0104555832,
-0.0104348008,
-0.0645216033,
-0.0405758731,
-0.0015507743,
0.0536911562,
0.0574146137,
-0.019229874,
-0.0384663828,
0.0734971017,
0.0279022176,
-0.0489008762,
0.0250588134,
0.0292128436,
0.020811962,
-0.0078042368,
-0.0128678791,
-0.026602814,
-0.0356577188,
0.0193207059,
0.0284933411,
-0.0035026509,
-0.0063208975,
-0.0144811487,
-0.0119419917,
0.0006852833,
-0.0390357673,
0.0334770307,
0.0287818313,
-0.0122814681,
0.0308326073,
-0.0313645676,
0.0406379253,
-0.0141824279,
-0.0153503325,
-0.0356578305,
0.0017950602,
-0.0068731257,
0.0039655296,
-0.0100923982,
0.0491863899,
-0.0250552911,
-0.0132884085,
-0.04433918,
-0.0079556033,
-0.0135906059,
-0.0301686749,
0.0080375401,
0.0171421077,
-0.0160131436,
-0.0223931726,
0.0039621019,
0.0722593293,
-0.0017778409,
0.0403946228,
-0.0182277616,
-0.0419394039,
-0.0270518772,
0.0466626808,
0.0037606258,
-0.0014894983,
0.0565083921,
0.0496290252,
-0.0220331047,
-0.0465526208,
-0.0556221344,
0.003158005,
-0.0043692663,
-0.0596797802,
-0.0052488311,
-0.0735362023,
0.0159130991,
-0.0428153239,
0.016306961,
-0.0726563558,
0.0164206941,
0.0139606912,
-0.028906811,
0.0285543371,
0.0014164409,
0.0188303236,
-0.0002299552,
-0.0060426244,
0.0353335626,
0.0490069538,
0.0295803808,
0.0452582687,
-0.0101708304,
-0.0136029776,
-0.0276749656,
0.0507642068,
0.0437567458,
0.0247341041,
-0.0557505786,
-0.0166906044,
-0.0119747203,
0.0145344548,
0.0675753504,
0.0735253692,
-0.0624126643,
-0.0248921681,
0.0800024271,
0.0408012085,
0.0197220594,
0.0587490201,
0.0535956584,
-0.0180609468,
0.0094762677,
-0.0018321477,
-0.0528983474,
0.0127795776,
-0.0375556983,
-0.016513845,
0.0085498551,
0.0666220933,
-0.0697569847,
-0.0357026197,
0.0032029103,
-0.0357425697,
-0.0048870388,
0.0326381363,
0.04390819,
0.0196025632,
-0.0149334213,
0.0655382127,
0.0481347702,
-0.0427312516,
0.0221809186,
-0.0662229881,
-0.0099759074,
0.0511909202,
0.0113795549,
-0.0053577586,
-0.0035835563,
0.0352086388,
0.0146980789,
-0.0056274128,
0.0136956656,
-0.0035547288,
0.031967666,
-0.0816014633,
0.0245492943,
0.0121931825,
0.006594636,
0.0142450314,
-0.0068307878,
0.0143395141,
0.0206418578,
-0.0191816408,
-0.0441799276,
0.0327908285,
-0.0429580882,
-0.0391435288,
0.0500392541,
-0.0102803186,
0.0224562343,
0.0040106447,
-0.0125466101,
-0.0062597943,
0.050079111,
-0.0426113456,
-0.0045032897,
-0.0148829464,
-0.0320296027,
-0.0370762609,
0.0693185627,
0.0385134928,
0.0306871794,
0.068356432,
-0.042012129,
-0.0455937982,
0.0293086022,
-0.0105393063,
0.0233571138,
-0.0743670762,
0.0180196781,
-0.0081369514,
0.0674195364,
0.0023476719,
0.0246446785,
-0.0258921664,
-0.0003080597,
0.0305036921,
-0.0249575712,
-0.0107623236,
-0.0704532936,
-0.0562278964,
0.0235171616,
-0.011272056,
0.0327833295,
-0.0203361232,
0.020440964,
0.0333852321,
-0.0295928344,
-0.0828029886,
0.0205686726,
-0.0517449491,
0.0236972254,
0.0201689862,
0.0329246372,
0.0096627306,
-0.0243486743,
0.0001466649,
0.0421553813,
0.0113475118,
0.0209805965,
-0.0054250159,
-0.0125441188,
-0.0145906415,
-0.0220407788,
-0.0420100316,
0.0281618722,
0.0546346828,
-0.0269628819,
-0.0180548001,
-0.040937379,
0.050568305,
-0.0237367842,
0.0407362245,
-0.0199820269,
-0.0610248744,
-0.0327280462,
-0.0071460484,
0.0036624067,
0.0484632738,
-0.0155110164,
0.0354200229,
0.0863323733,
0.0365527831,
-0.0254303534,
0.0066230684,
-0.0388126038,
-0.0148402685,
-0.0751400813,
-0.0355464406,
-0.0066127023,
0.0823099464,
-0.0084509663,
-0.015012363,
-0.0447804667,
-0.0619089231,
0.0089692194,
-0.0188269801,
-0.0199076068,
-0.003295965,
-0.0392153077,
-0.0036331899,
-0.0024967543,
-0.0361903906,
0.0226141121,
-0.0550851189,
-0.0174520649,
-0.0129140597,
-0.0570866764,
-0.0493600331,
0.0446922481,
0.0565068536,
0.018851513,
-0.0157262217,
-0.0030783925,
-0.0523979515,
0.0019794875,
-0.0181300472,
-0.0154426405,
0.0164053645,
-0.0263282973,
0.0245112162,
-0.0132455425,
-0.046478644,
-0.007464156,
-0.0118697444,
-0.0223158412,
0.0328484029,
0.0042387522,
-0.0236205794,
0.000917025,
0.0098801916,
0.0189724993,
0.0550162718,
0.0139707364,
0.0344701447,
-0.022462219,
0.034915112,
0.0542314276,
0.031251803,
0.0444119163,
-0.0500565507,
0.0198146328,
0.0382785723,
0.0270641986,
0.0032520352,
-0.0730321556,
-0.0028452135,
0.0183826163,
0.0009120624,
-0.0140532879,
0.005032171,
0.0602515936,
-0.037843585,
0.0214517992,
0.0717141479,
-0.0070379339,
-0.0688676313,
0.0268489514,
0.0532859229,
0.03823952,
0.0256409086,
0.0354048163,
-0.0597441904,
-0.0212562233,
0.0137285199,
-0.0166874155,
0.0304676816,
-0.0216777753,
0.0074045327,
-0.1099297106,
0.027010031,
0.0111490404,
-0.0161968805,
-0.0018142222,
-0.0274855979,
0.0023488079,
-0.0355854966,
0.0232548527,
0.02517776,
-0.0168494079,
-0.0068846461,
0.0163382404,
0.0091907959,
-0.0442716517,
0.0295219719,
-0.0138502466,
0.0407713652,
0.0226653889,
0.0094959494,
-0.0142774759,
-0.0327116661,
0.0847437307,
-0.031844724,
-0.0248064548,
0.0015990275,
0.0251180623,
0.0535833649,
-0.0308419671,
0.0215216298,
0.0436829776,
-0.029935468,
-0.0114855561,
-0.0117233973,
0.0548187345,
-0.0062547121,
-0.0522428975,
0.0106682749,
-0.033006791,
-0.0224430114,
0.0451192707,
0.0546372682,
-0.0444001667,
-0.009893816,
-0.0114979325,
-0.0203420762,
-0.031333115,
-0.0699956939,
0.0167743657,
0.0193400551,
-0.0501755439,
-0.0419395566,
-0.0059806705,
0.0033582661,
0.0108754011,
-0.0274192281,
-0.0097998148,
-0.0065432265,
-0.0087289661,
-0.0232888982,
0.0387464352,
-0.045470342,
0.00880644,
-0.0546980686,
0.0220543165,
0.0445765108,
-0.0106691318,
-0.021561509,
-0.0186733007,
-0.117221579,
-0.0592519082,
-0.0338466428,
0.0346404351,
0.0158688203,
0.0194369126,
-0.0045742593,
-0.0731437132,
0.0667989403,
0.0415228866,
-0.0134731522,
0.062935032,
0.0084686102,
-0.0537610576,
-0.0048329248,
0.0882389247,
-0.021233229,
0.0226209499,
0.0324936844,
0.0449634716,
-0.0308206417,
-0.0052655302,
-0.0285005663,
0.0300310366,
0.0049788319,
-0.005945649,
-0.0108708432,
-0.057463523,
0.0318866633,
0.0286389869,
0.0146779595,
-0.06058833,
0.001827606,
0.0288288947,
0.0410684794,
-0.0057787756,
0.0121369231,
0.0504235998,
0.0069804695,
-0.0103134923,
-0.0004969474,
0.0089316117,
0.0263822228,
0.064829357,
0.0122635914,
-0.0185614005,
0.0192219093,
0.0079606762,
0.0033750993,
-0.0294492636,
-0.0294216685,
0.0091819363,
0.006075731,
-0.0973405316,
0.0175586622,
-0.0294656809,
-0.0702417642,
-0.0369612277,
0.0383004174,
0.0658595115,
0.002179127,
0.0313379839,
-0.0056054122,
-0.0169410985,
-0.0675900578,
0.0089001115,
0.0015392352,
-0.0046201278,
0.0331509262,
0.0058403062,
-0.0326220542,
0.0232326873,
0.0824031606,
0.0136594186,
0.0639708266,
0.0236806832,
0.0230180286,
-0.0098129846,
-0.0610348508,
-0.0175938513,
0.0201061275,
-0.0457393751,
-0.0044295397,
-0.0094504301,
-0.0801592618,
0.0266791526,
-0.0214039721,
-0.0283513218,
-0.0292070862,
0.0479769185,
0.0251936354,
0.0120231332,
0.0465310402,
0.0018449376,
-0.0449131206,
-0.0175478663,
-0.0418987125,
0.0044124592,
-6.54897731e-33,
0.0048296112,
0.0052153459,
0.0346981697,
0.0149988784,
-0.0303194597,
0.0205278061,
-0.0453045629,
-0.018173473,
-0.0473241098,
0.0167184714,
-0.0222149212,
0.0121924486,
0.0054995567,
0.0284403693,
-0.0312861986,
0.0194999799,
0.0783469379,
-0.0244710557,
-0.0097161103,
0.0489656702,
0.0268357489,
0.0264063571,
0.062013492,
-0.0267640948,
-0.0562398285,
0.0184244849,
-0.0141373649,
0.0402759537,
-0.0155349942,
0.0291808899,
-0.0607460141,
0.0623467714,
0.0081729759,
-0.023683032,
-0.0156873204,
-0.0279367678,
-0.049966637,
-0.0195243061,
0.0083604213,
0.0023463783,
-0.0017248121,
-0.0340718031,
0.0852424875,
0.0092513803,
-0.0286581442,
-0.0127047943,
0.0240461417,
-0.013399261,
-0.0383131243,
-0.0202619098,
-0.0357418619,
0.0259245224,
-0.0013357855,
-0.0117117297,
0.0202432051,
-0.0314375162,
-0.0354473963,
0.0121793635,
-0.0627084598,
-0.0081195859,
0.0270769373,
0.0700291991,
0.0411356725,
0.0252724905,
0.038215097,
0.0499297082,
0.0488244109,
0.0003109114,
-0.0222173668,
0.0167580433,
0.0727509409,
0.0327983834,
0.0414785556,
0.0203164313,
0.0013316501,
-0.0405614525,
-0.1249732301,
-0.0194506068,
0.018294815,
0.0501462184,
-0.0038711072,
0.0368960351,
0.021987373,
-0.0135323871,
-0.0231502466,
-0.0462809876,
-0.0361119621,
-0.0153524233,
-0.0030241893,
0.0381680802,
-0.0369662829,
-0.0198720731,
0.018716976,
-0.0518533662,
-0.0373482518,
0.0371532552,
-0.0156360194,
0.0152144413,
0.0325986072,
0.024081761,
-0.0570804141,
-0.0117442142,
-0.0229036193,
-0.0276448503,
0.0144341327,
-0.0029019949,
0.0376947001,
0.0477205105,
-0.0491980612,
-0.02502154,
-0.0430312492,
-0.0125095118,
0.0277120024,
0.0981349796,
0.0355168134,
0.0025916169,
0.0144911269,
0.0588003583,
0.0096213184,
-0.0046000355,
-0.0301207509,
0.0110517936,
0.0549981333,
0.0394092351,
-0.0498818383,
0.0031770256,
-0.0381693244,
0.0481813289,
0.0356989615,
-0.0517759435,
-0.0330549106,
0.0181057286,
2.673e-7,
0.0049161562,
-0.0254541039,
-0.0165071562,
0.0085463338,
0.0228210445,
0.0276380107,
-0.0244434997,
-0.0002708219,
-0.0048291148,
0.0060346555,
0.0162395258,
0.0591075048,
0.0526752248,
0.0034988774,
-0.1016241461,
0.0581535809,
-0.0689827874,
-0.0264147073,
-0.0294605102,
-0.0634617135,
-0.0565290675,
0.1083827838,
0.0136324363,
-0.0406900756,
0.0410069935,
-0.0469259843,
0.056296479,
-0.0120438775,
0.0038707345,
0.0109823737,
0.00847957,
0.0103061078,
-0.0340135917,
-0.0594533496,
-0.004841466,
0.030541569,
-0.0229491163,
0.0875294432,
-0.0121546015,
-0.0136984773,
0.0206372831,
0.0126491487,
-0.0145732546,
-0.0164707452,
0.0594544075,
-0.0036980184,
-0.0060243951,
-0.045961462,
0.0086445063,
-0.0543848723,
0.0000992184,
-0.0346176475,
0.0229332987,
0.0442979299,
0.0082222009,
-0.0404795781,
-0.0494979694,
-0.0813939273,
-0.0174569134,
-0.0170591269,
-0.0673012584,
-0.0356579162,
-0.058292646,
0.0005732017,
0.0324502103,
-0.0326208994,
0.031849362,
2.511194806e-34,
0.0196187999,
-0.0238085464,
0.012988477,
0.0475585796,
0.0181471519,
-0.0177006293,
-0.0256703161,
0.0189155862,
-0.0262148455,
-0.0966615751,
-0.0337458402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11648v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11648v1 | Harnessing the Power of Adversarial Prompting and Large Language Models for Robust Hypothesis Generation in Astronomy | 2023-06-20T16:16:56 | 2023-06-20T16:16:56 | Ioana Ciucă, Yuan-Sen Ting, Sandor Kruk, Kartheik Iyer | astro-ph.IM | astro-ph.IM, astro-ph.GA, cs.AI, cs.CL | This study investigates the application of Large Language Models (LLMs),
specifically GPT-4, within Astronomy. We employ in-context prompting, supplying
the model with up to 1000 papers from the NASA Astrophysics Data System, to
explore the extent to which performance can be improved by immersing the model
in domain-specific literature. Our findings point towards a substantial boost
in hypothesis generation when using in-context prompting, a benefit that is
further accentuated by adversarial prompting. We illustrate how adversarial
prompting empowers GPT-4 to extract essential details from a vast knowledge
base to produce meaningful hypotheses, signaling an innovative step towards
employing LLMs for scientific research in Astronomy. | [
0.0320162103,
0.0747471005,
0.0147959404,
0.0242438056,
-0.0403185524,
0.000411096,
0.0382771902,
0.0106530096,
0.038995374,
-0.0195826199,
-0.0040941141,
-0.0544807315,
-0.0081599671,
0.0207741279,
0.0133481575,
-0.0569160841,
0.0189783294,
-0.0439241566,
0.0544423945,
-0.0285919886,
-0.0516924933,
-0.0309984554,
0.007958211,
-0.0166076533,
0.014539401,
-0.0175369866,
0.0009555884,
-0.008482635,
0.0148337306,
-0.0554209985,
-0.0117848571,
0.0878775939,
0.0039076498,
0.1028617173,
0.0000016132,
-0.0654964298,
-0.0131528378,
0.0351623334,
-0.0084420778,
0.0675799698,
0.0471686721,
-0.0368193015,
0.0069681783,
-0.0077484357,
-0.0207522977,
-0.0151429931,
0.0329994448,
0.0202424023,
0.0076362016,
0.0305354949,
0.0046564057,
-0.0296255425,
0.012795371,
-0.0608313531,
0.0083254026,
-0.0206655078,
0.0527999476,
0.0164357554,
0.0268575791,
0.0756051168,
0.0022301665,
0.0578113645,
0.0412234217,
-0.0073707425,
-0.0054304106,
0.0410776138,
-0.0304664858,
0.0038295155,
0.0224217642,
0.0233241469,
0.0282944161,
-0.0473919474,
0.0197216477,
-0.0106135225,
-0.0326524936,
0.0863955468,
-0.0752195492,
0.0159466639,
0.003659524,
-0.0402404703,
0.0067391139,
-0.0154946102,
0.0381271802,
0.0408879705,
-0.024848355,
0.0742582455,
0.0491157845,
-0.063870199,
0.0005900105,
0.0244507063,
-0.0295748543,
-0.085845083,
-0.0110424375,
0.0061794594,
-0.0244677681,
0.0053263358,
-0.0106178094,
-0.0240263212,
0.0533753522,
-0.0181873161,
0.0210053287,
-0.0024679643,
0.0011247117,
0.0711794198,
0.0166795701,
0.0048892396,
-0.0297264159,
-0.0234997645,
0.0202932823,
-0.0143752359,
-0.0185894836,
-0.0505296066,
0.004449897,
-0.0191021971,
0.0149694253,
0.005887134,
-0.001443891,
0.0072426582,
0.0187780056,
0.0169202294,
-0.0438972935,
0.0071028508,
-0.0937464088,
-0.0323610455,
-0.0308465287,
-0.0048086862,
-0.0098141693,
0.0403108522,
0.0158313978,
-0.0456255376,
-0.031295456,
0.035705816,
-0.0149087412,
-0.0161879472,
0.0233893916,
0.0874297246,
0.0558277294,
-0.0214850605,
-0.0093705906,
-0.0404942557,
0.0026891879,
-0.0801984072,
0.029433066,
-0.0527133606,
-0.0063336687,
0.0328401327,
-0.0285742395,
-0.0282198824,
-0.0187945068,
0.0023471152,
-0.010969203,
0.0442904644,
-0.0403332971,
-0.0279751793,
0.037921194,
0.0284854677,
-0.0114998864,
0.0612300895,
0.0062882812,
0.0559759252,
0.0289327092,
-0.0096106306,
0.0325420499,
0.0102985781,
0.0205102321,
0.0349301435,
-0.0229518656,
0.0292434134,
-0.047625374,
0.0493637919,
-0.0166822597,
0.0534256995,
-0.0385788716,
0.0195239838,
0.0248548053,
0.0483519249,
0.0083368002,
0.0586195029,
0.0331524611,
-0.0328583121,
0.0038059137,
0.0253079254,
-0.0292888246,
0.0722297356,
-0.0500299633,
-0.0112475669,
0.0225179754,
0.0082688378,
-0.0293766856,
-0.0297515877,
-0.0051251934,
0.0316242054,
-0.0572814606,
-0.0252908468,
0.0523766056,
0.0088089062,
0.0197210386,
-0.0301854424,
0.0390515141,
-0.008392687,
0.0059782048,
-0.0249785222,
0.0450437106,
0.0102184489,
0.0551156513,
-0.0684809238,
-0.0067430055,
-0.0008706542,
0.0487283804,
0.0829888806,
0.0752202943,
-0.010840619,
-0.0275965333,
-0.0208221935,
-0.036585696,
-0.050141722,
0.0230573658,
0.0236065108,
0.0072558345,
-0.0036022249,
0.018296469,
-0.0177365504,
-0.0277648661,
0.0250560716,
-0.0549329109,
-0.0672411919,
0.0253701322,
-0.0412303843,
0.0320277549,
-0.0435119309,
-0.0437096842,
0.032245107,
0.0412740968,
-0.0131463856,
-0.0293786377,
0.0189447701,
0.0232835989,
-0.0156276915,
0.0306623764,
-0.0736609101,
-0.0347100161,
-0.0089750662,
-0.0313744657,
-0.0261228383,
0.0529542118,
-0.0153437108,
-0.0091770506,
-0.0232821982,
-0.0220697429,
-0.0310232993,
0.0094966386,
-0.0411186218,
0.0552896857,
-0.0038304322,
0.0306615625,
0.0437056795,
0.0165298544,
0.0260739885,
-0.0278058629,
-0.022151703,
0.0262235645,
0.0246984549,
-0.0184129123,
0.0468618348,
-0.0038585581,
0.0002597458,
-0.0210526027,
-0.0245065596,
-0.0047178604,
-0.0157753006,
-0.0250538755,
0.0499886386,
-0.0167953502,
-0.0317573063,
-0.007231392,
0.0204645526,
-0.0099321613,
0.0230231974,
0.023666814,
0.050066907,
0.0248841792,
0.0073639723,
-0.0605605394,
-0.0218641814,
-0.0284550879,
0.037306428,
0.0671032667,
-0.0043536895,
-0.0694529489,
0.0318909213,
0.0095857214,
0.0048042578,
-0.0414013118,
-0.0071283793,
0.0558705479,
-0.0604367927,
0.0154407742,
0.0705937147,
0.0061043799,
0.0205730777,
0.0555525124,
0.0021046496,
-0.0167182591,
-0.0208189879,
-0.0244649351,
-0.0036451693,
0.0103878696,
-0.0082671372,
0.0467964858,
0.0092515498,
-0.0083489744,
-0.0304733273,
-0.0158835836,
0.0371987708,
-0.018143747,
-0.007886095,
-0.0074249511,
0.011324198,
-0.0259800926,
0.0279495437,
0.0353209339,
-0.0536017492,
0.068975389,
-0.0422389433,
-0.0051932465,
-0.0610531941,
-0.0015778948,
-0.0080018826,
0.014557464,
-0.0104065184,
0.008619803,
0.0391369909,
0.0168251917,
-0.0667324141,
0.0163488947,
0.0053084223,
0.0244493559,
0.0160233751,
-0.066790767,
0.0056249634,
0.0187389385,
-0.0151928887,
-0.0187902432,
-0.0425430983,
-0.0162387118,
0.0257682968,
0.0171275046,
-0.0438974537,
-0.0472390912,
-0.0300929714,
0.0441052765,
0.0211083349,
-0.0373186246,
-0.02430043,
-0.0223037526,
0.0151865808,
0.0982864127,
-0.0043431297,
0.0372367352,
-0.0648125038,
0.0193088725,
0.0316729955,
-0.0185213648,
0.0384683423,
-0.0185360573,
-0.0431711711,
-0.0196316615,
-0.0210443307,
-0.0038291339,
-0.00827586,
0.0322562419,
-0.0192340221,
-0.0061892001,
0.099102743,
0.0109995632,
-0.0331707783,
-0.0126397619,
0.0032714233,
0.0428765155,
0.0075943843,
-0.0024886837,
-0.0820200741,
0.0031693815,
-0.0242601056,
0.0091712084,
0.0093016438,
-0.0372952893,
-0.0223428831,
-0.0695757195,
0.0330919586,
0.000462301,
-0.0124868928,
-0.0176550001,
-0.0910669342,
-0.0126486421,
-0.0261473805,
-0.0321952477,
0.008688136,
0.0063361241,
0.0067957528,
0.0053797993,
0.0442615189,
-0.0762134716,
0.0146130817,
-0.0602305941,
0.0046335161,
0.0201794691,
0.0378854759,
-0.0471967049,
0.0032081332,
-0.0254608933,
-0.0069976039,
-0.0116040502,
0.0168480929,
0.0319247432,
0.0295504183,
0.0203049202,
-0.0244947486,
0.0727806911,
-0.051732827,
0.0150157306,
0.0275625736,
0.0765379965,
-0.0452134795,
-0.0497737974,
-0.0417292751,
0.0049214419,
0.0355386026,
0.0963353366,
0.0069306591,
-0.0236329231,
-0.0240558553,
-0.048804529,
-0.0194616709,
-0.0019809257,
-0.0175807551,
-0.009707747,
0.0690689236,
0.0033430064,
-0.0183996651,
-0.0259861108,
0.0093565118,
0.0194829777,
0.0269535277,
0.0316807181,
-0.0231133364,
-0.0243270639,
-0.0076712742,
0.0361563265,
-0.0255611632,
0.0003203004,
-0.0431494229,
-0.0468815155,
0.043794319,
-0.0080828071,
-0.0344047062,
0.0289062168,
-0.0616759025,
-0.0847689882,
-0.0220879018,
0.0230995733,
0.0323489979,
0.0101908557,
-0.0247914642,
-0.0722035244,
0.0390197672,
0.0490057357,
0.0056755021,
0.0030535548,
0.0003712256,
-0.0367618389,
0.0198040325,
-0.0165060982,
-0.0159332864,
0.0195790567,
0.0308645368,
-0.038894482,
-0.0448541529,
-0.037851166,
0.0085131731,
0.0531103276,
0.0652929321,
-0.0689808428,
-0.0344339237,
0.0012481738,
-0.0299875271,
-0.0211560968,
-0.009918048,
0.0007049584,
0.0471126363,
0.0290277526,
0.0268053468,
-0.0029424524,
0.0191419758,
-0.0048397486,
0.0100344662,
-0.0569371656,
0.0151521564,
0.0097400155,
0.0306200534,
0.0809898451,
-0.0038558394,
-0.0088239266,
-0.0271627959,
-0.0284321532,
0.0390240662,
0.0055692913,
0.0307124294,
0.0717289224,
0.0155287124,
-0.0009959074,
0.0203908719,
-0.1355274767,
-0.0742856786,
-0.0381836407,
0.0268851221,
0.0388090499,
0.025133919,
-0.0163623597,
-0.1107423306,
-0.0183442887,
-0.0260755904,
0.0245481655,
0.0393164121,
0.00623922,
0.0802039132,
0.0065841451,
-0.0460222922,
0.0158292353,
0.077537857,
0.0273951255,
0.0450316146,
0.0089738565,
0.0280770604,
-0.0382174961,
-0.0380729213,
-0.0228914022,
-0.0220187102,
-0.015833782,
0.0115385009,
-0.0572388731,
-0.0284608379,
-0.0138336429,
0.0282295179,
-0.000911073,
-0.0330182463,
0.0093856454,
0.0521218851,
-0.0540258028,
0.0117124673,
0.0030484067,
0.0434072129,
-0.0449133776,
-0.0631071776,
-0.0216226093,
-5.795872977e-33,
-0.0110329948,
-0.013971664,
0.0161715355,
-0.0308181755,
0.0359256566,
-0.0133214099,
-0.0656078756,
-0.0288042389,
0.0145983417,
0.0327157453,
0.0056672688,
0.0152432034,
-0.0181132834,
0.012170529,
0.0397935249,
0.002075054,
0.0732028559,
0.0040521375,
-0.0345084928,
0.0497890189,
0.04154687,
0.0082525006,
0.0117842015,
-0.0670719817,
0.0029176306,
0.0006649824,
-0.0185773354,
0.0171452034,
-0.0813559666,
0.0296192225,
-0.0459591933,
0.011909591,
-0.0351738147,
-0.0051152213,
-0.0017159143,
0.0060088583,
0.0045986548,
-0.0283223186,
0.0129958792,
-0.0145467566,
-0.015295418,
-0.0299670193,
-0.015738342,
0.0014886857,
-0.0032971655,
-0.0190828051,
0.018640345,
0.0021690696,
-0.0305453707,
-0.034869615,
-0.0232382305,
0.0281970147,
-0.0041497257,
0.0263127293,
0.0154889161,
-0.0018141267,
-0.0004306251,
0.086417079,
0.0065618348,
0.0573883243,
0.0608888641,
-0.0089724762,
0.0199208446,
-0.0053060572,
0.0378472209,
0.0747523084,
-0.020431919,
0.0009509306,
0.0145913083,
0.0033729449,
0.0086716544,
0.0195321795,
0.0649738684,
0.0575092174,
0.0552148409,
0.0054665837,
-0.0769141167,
0.0187062994,
0.0049564722,
-0.0122014321,
0.0240319762,
0.0299378131,
0.0090511404,
-0.0169572905,
-0.0046887947,
-0.0715526268,
-0.0026500199,
-0.0327499099,
-0.0145200612,
-0.0291599557,
-0.0515398122,
0.0164462645,
0.0140552865,
-0.0436334088,
-0.0280994959,
0.06398388,
-0.0599401668,
-0.0014989789,
0.0120538166,
0.0281321965,
-0.0917395204,
-0.0120825013,
0.0396318361,
0.0375017859,
0.0067901905,
0.0221712962,
0.0051171742,
0.0398736186,
-0.0259233229,
0.0101945475,
-0.0220691115,
-0.005430859,
0.0478696562,
-0.0289362352,
-0.0065369136,
0.0175399035,
0.0263334643,
0.0322206244,
0.0133719267,
-0.0006703366,
-0.0036091248,
0.0471054651,
-0.0337143689,
0.0066749197,
-0.0030927542,
-0.039537292,
-0.0136990994,
-0.0542399548,
0.0649239942,
-0.0794666484,
0.0046139043,
0.0172957014,
2.394e-7,
0.0291739069,
0.0736585855,
0.0166428667,
-0.0142998388,
0.0507201627,
0.0240569357,
-0.0379768647,
0.0160093121,
0.0352838188,
0.0243004505,
-0.0050367615,
-0.0442735329,
0.0349881351,
0.0523452647,
-0.0799309537,
-0.0191399604,
-0.0465741903,
-0.0457550697,
-0.0719381049,
-0.0299707446,
0.0229864065,
0.0611510351,
-0.0083705764,
0.0042617293,
0.04959286,
-0.0745906979,
0.062976256,
-0.0131624583,
0.0503146984,
0.063843742,
0.0082699424,
0.012697571,
0.0119186258,
0.0369791873,
-0.0242638625,
0.012709925,
0.0083587952,
0.0469044074,
0.0459227972,
-0.0006378397,
0.0169100352,
-0.0119617255,
0.0174173918,
-0.0504771322,
0.0568253137,
-0.0496176742,
-0.049100209,
0.0127419662,
0.0102900648,
-0.0481366515,
0.0177271999,
-0.0428508334,
0.0067047132,
-0.0134775657,
-0.0474704951,
0.0194120128,
-0.0063547925,
-0.0398054644,
0.0048516947,
0.0532303974,
-0.0770647302,
-0.0441372022,
-0.0120675014,
-0.0396780819,
0.0232826471,
0.0098319687,
0.0126445889,
2.216490796e-34,
0.0650414675,
-0.0006681922,
-0.0211730674,
-0.0383628681,
0.0392090455,
-0.0039390726,
0.0342593156,
0.0181217659,
0.0419379808,
-0.0877563059,
-0.008736359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11646v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11646v1 | Recent Advances in Direct Speech-to-text Translation | 2023-06-20T16:14:27 | 2023-06-20T16:14:27 | Chen Xu, Rong Ye, Qianqian Dong, Chengqi Zhao, Tom Ko, Mingxuan Wang, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Recently, speech-to-text translation has attracted more and more attention
and many studies have emerged rapidly. In this paper, we present a
comprehensive survey on direct speech translation aiming to summarize the
current state-of-the-art techniques. First, we categorize the existing research
work into three directions based on the main challenges -- modeling burden,
data scarcity, and application issues. To tackle the problem of modeling
burden, two main structures have been proposed, encoder-decoder framework
(Transformer and the variants) and multitask frameworks. For the challenge of
data scarcity, recent work resorts to many sophisticated techniques, such as
data augmentation, pre-training, knowledge distillation, and multilingual
modeling. We analyze and summarize the application issues, which include
real-time, segmentation, named entity, gender bias, and code-switching.
Finally, we discuss some promising directions for future work. | [
0.0083243828,
0.0347945169,
-0.0189867076,
0.0138260117,
-0.0103390673,
0.0186057426,
0.0202052407,
-0.0143506676,
-0.0366690047,
-0.0405501686,
-0.0330173634,
-0.0095778098,
0.0438538566,
0.0163138695,
0.0307689924,
-0.0812588409,
0.0179957841,
-0.0314576998,
-0.0020859395,
-0.0060631391,
0.0150446575,
0.0222901255,
-0.0203985535,
0.0321683586,
-0.0203829333,
0.0309265479,
-0.0111981388,
0.0493317097,
0.0283848997,
0.0077488828,
-0.0091782669,
-0.0046720658,
0.0514871888,
0.0461762361,
0.0000021338,
-0.0321055241,
-0.037939366,
0.0208531898,
-0.0412117541,
-0.0411139689,
0.0420821048,
-0.0946922004,
-0.004881795,
0.0402079001,
0.002443668,
-0.0211835969,
0.0593625568,
0.0062280311,
0.0551527217,
0.0609043911,
-0.0338460095,
-0.0205456614,
0.0369057916,
-0.0344294943,
-0.0429826491,
0.0030563131,
-0.0189532973,
-0.0120887635,
-0.0632239506,
-0.0104554379,
-0.0305276383,
0.0987657234,
0.0087579871,
0.0095920293,
-0.0051122913,
-0.0016282605,
-0.0315075405,
-0.0365039743,
-0.02855164,
0.0747386739,
-0.0470542908,
0.0153062213,
0.0226259753,
0.0072761821,
-0.0180198047,
-0.0168516729,
-0.0187649522,
0.0176391955,
0.0239780787,
-0.0147519084,
0.0106286258,
0.0531529337,
0.0081771547,
-0.0490057692,
-0.0592777915,
-0.0046729944,
0.0329927988,
-0.0405909196,
0.0132383723,
0.0201897807,
0.0011684751,
-0.023080945,
0.094768852,
-0.0004448979,
0.0125452857,
0.0107487943,
-0.0514751263,
-0.0742057636,
-0.0566574223,
-0.0664790645,
0.0055625192,
0.0816026628,
-0.0191305876,
-0.0160823017,
-0.0063797794,
0.0285802018,
-0.0099928975,
0.0211203583,
-0.0318545364,
-0.0501269698,
0.0017730921,
0.0248716734,
-0.0813270956,
0.0011516837,
-0.0469279401,
0.0027674907,
-0.0250303149,
0.0067816866,
-0.0013017482,
0.0043734582,
0.0377649777,
-0.024070397,
-0.0884767547,
-0.0108518768,
0.0220556203,
0.0655774772,
-0.0019284789,
0.0104234423,
-0.019107135,
-0.0563975051,
-0.0121614886,
0.0294226464,
0.0155382808,
-0.0234919619,
-0.0213488005,
0.0614157133,
-0.0341849588,
-0.0455541797,
-0.0285154022,
-0.0169688277,
-0.041078724,
-0.0375529341,
-0.040028397,
-0.0520059727,
0.0610264875,
0.0140669029,
0.0446489602,
-0.0307166185,
-0.0146777621,
-0.0273893308,
0.0120241037,
0.059985429,
0.0168305617,
0.0436505675,
0.0770911351,
-0.0030160113,
-0.0155000798,
0.0787622854,
0.0915400162,
-0.0049842978,
0.0058267065,
-0.0106211109,
-0.0258239731,
0.0801475346,
0.0202356223,
0.034641359,
-0.0068057352,
0.0154893994,
-0.0250064805,
0.0075249337,
0.043426536,
0.0324282311,
-0.0313245319,
0.0331997909,
0.0588920005,
0.0145543525,
0.01913823,
0.0232554525,
0.0490903743,
0.0265549086,
-0.0197851881,
-0.0094403019,
0.0203307737,
-0.0070664519,
0.0135694006,
-0.0137401186,
0.0359874852,
0.039087005,
-0.0327987932,
-0.0280385856,
0.0440505743,
-0.050980892,
0.0317856781,
0.016122777,
0.0371697657,
0.0222598892,
-0.0540319346,
0.0500018932,
-0.011680102,
-0.0721357316,
0.0408881903,
-0.0247599054,
-0.085623771,
0.0612440258,
0.0280957334,
-0.00650999,
-0.0064382507,
-0.0460360199,
-0.0163779743,
0.0431224592,
0.0078747673,
0.0032752152,
0.0461000092,
-0.0712891221,
-0.0061471527,
0.0422375537,
0.0044782497,
0.0390087627,
-0.0174403116,
0.081760183,
0.048703406,
0.0169467852,
-0.0093383994,
0.0079774028,
-0.0153659238,
0.0134438137,
0.0268839691,
0.0287484694,
0.0213508774,
0.0407524072,
-0.0147287296,
-0.0190550741,
0.0102286031,
-0.0395589881,
0.0059701526,
0.0569704659,
-0.0479840934,
-0.0461935177,
-0.0221499801,
-0.06580697,
-0.0079930713,
0.0535415076,
0.0109565789,
-0.0936101899,
-0.0187268704,
-0.0154364826,
0.0453056917,
-0.0136811603,
0.0663988441,
0.0185414348,
0.0104829948,
0.0143955508,
-0.0040299878,
0.0085903835,
-0.0465526991,
0.0492761657,
-0.0218888782,
-0.0137415389,
-0.0703682825,
-0.0335094035,
0.0213837232,
-0.0062085525,
0.0096906228,
0.0031495409,
-0.0310096722,
-0.0028711397,
-0.0212848559,
-0.0676931664,
-0.0054092901,
-0.0258189831,
0.0229964461,
0.0208142437,
0.0599684305,
0.0072801309,
-0.0132219521,
-0.0285540801,
-0.0221476369,
0.0196647421,
-0.0240875296,
-0.0220276974,
-0.019889513,
-0.0020948099,
0.0037238172,
0.0113409031,
0.0231574122,
-0.0026589315,
0.007231887,
-0.0469677225,
-0.0592163801,
0.0320052542,
0.0198655576,
0.0130401617,
0.0022055558,
-0.0018318371,
-0.0110470401,
0.0165134221,
0.0604560226,
0.020853864,
-0.006849329,
0.0010157777,
-0.0077817072,
-0.0374354869,
-0.0844251812,
-0.0020050029,
-0.0088091642,
-0.002427103,
-0.0385882035,
-0.0219649747,
0.0202126689,
0.0391605236,
0.0335534588,
0.0081132902,
-0.0858135149,
-0.0687667206,
-0.0362157784,
-0.0503608733,
0.0047424315,
-0.0320145264,
0.0024569654,
0.0062099444,
0.0028261265,
-0.0266579315,
0.0423476398,
-0.0795942023,
-0.040236149,
-0.0205021389,
-0.0165925808,
-0.028988516,
0.0132036414,
-0.0314163789,
0.0165074077,
-0.0197222866,
-0.036570251,
-0.0285163298,
0.0353620425,
-0.024084067,
-0.0357849821,
0.0543587953,
-0.041340664,
0.0057714293,
-0.0193077866,
-0.0275045261,
-0.0250750687,
0.0277378242,
-0.0075622108,
0.0015211551,
0.0343225114,
-0.0292918924,
-0.0335174911,
0.0382200368,
-0.0217316635,
0.0773779601,
0.0150998877,
-0.0065550758,
-0.040925011,
0.043677941,
0.0004815046,
0.0086883018,
-0.0413489826,
-0.0482365191,
0.0076642949,
-0.0042324075,
0.0273490231,
-0.0169291534,
-0.016770808,
-0.0198061615,
0.0476372093,
0.0067041009,
-0.0097803595,
-0.0180581957,
0.0354833044,
-0.0466287471,
-0.0063050236,
0.120064564,
0.0028520497,
-0.0485170223,
-0.0171644911,
0.0052275565,
0.0233264025,
-0.0112738246,
0.0131050339,
-0.0576677993,
-0.0376578495,
0.0328745283,
0.0719782263,
0.0240033157,
0.0148005625,
-0.0190176107,
-0.0787337869,
0.0091318311,
0.0310376026,
-0.0355777033,
-0.0504617319,
0.027058525,
-0.0420272276,
-0.0456180014,
0.0214749798,
-0.0245781392,
0.0172999818,
-0.0109512452,
0.0096190246,
-0.0004855218,
-0.0297870077,
0.0067926338,
-0.019132955,
0.0590112768,
0.0618316345,
0.0393438675,
0.0112152612,
0.0205448288,
0.0048505804,
-0.0092088738,
-0.0134138903,
0.0180155747,
0.0191752035,
-0.0673400387,
-0.0075538303,
0.0117226439,
0.0376854837,
0.0071634809,
0.0530340932,
0.0362330005,
0.0294325594,
-0.025982216,
0.0422337689,
0.0286355317,
-0.0383135527,
0.0352021195,
0.0736458227,
-0.01794702,
-0.0420759693,
0.0050931559,
-0.0103275971,
0.023484014,
-0.0398751423,
-0.0311221424,
0.004198614,
-0.0168796182,
-0.0386039875,
-0.0638303235,
-0.0145526398,
0.0387952216,
0.0422533154,
0.0365640633,
0.0084755654,
0.0686745644,
0.0017881171,
-0.0224407855,
-0.0006929038,
-0.0407723822,
0.0468998812,
-0.050987374,
-0.0480095074,
-0.0052928673,
-0.0420166217,
0.021790009,
0.0363496281,
-0.0868775323,
-0.0566491559,
-0.0024559484,
0.0218770672,
0.0257483143,
0.0843022689,
-0.0391313098,
-0.0146181798,
0.0393798314,
-0.0042948802,
-0.071209535,
0.000704934,
0.0470480286,
0.0278705433,
-0.0187909771,
0.0291444082,
-0.0142384563,
0.0219641309,
-0.0254919883,
0.0403025821,
-0.0352640375,
-0.0672843084,
-0.0047109132,
0.0377216153,
0.0268223975,
-0.0226215981,
-0.0053766728,
-0.029635651,
0.0480000973,
-0.0198246501,
0.0255634692,
-0.0674266294,
-0.0030913285,
0.0505901016,
0.0352529325,
0.0235906858,
0.0201109685,
0.0008753244,
-0.0676901937,
-0.0279648285,
0.0239632372,
0.0027382874,
0.0351800956,
0.0395437144,
0.0220991205,
-0.011718723,
0.0414974503,
0.0226107314,
0.0059812479,
-0.0367143825,
0.0378173627,
-0.0054371874,
0.0188769009,
0.0157031864,
0.0162813682,
-0.0199938621,
-0.0069915452,
-0.0326638967,
0.0066630119,
-0.0058251815,
0.0108206617,
0.1203058213,
-0.0068607177,
0.0318497382,
-0.0041927248,
0.0445511416,
-0.0288192667,
-0.0055847769,
-0.0123233749,
-0.0248121917,
0.0038049468,
0.0368023515,
0.0355454311,
0.0040269922,
0.0313605815,
-0.0447394699,
-0.009232413,
-0.0108073205,
-0.0568477921,
0.026903009,
-0.0376888923,
-0.0273637976,
-0.0423315279,
-0.0222780369,
-0.0483155847,
0.0030400944,
-0.0265989751,
0.0119432323,
-0.0296735037,
0.0239873007,
-0.0035581216,
-0.0427350141,
-0.000374305,
-0.0228024796,
-0.0194355641,
0.0101756314,
-0.0228599384,
0.005225915,
-6.138284196e-33,
-0.0474992208,
0.0061691762,
0.0008389128,
-0.0452133678,
-0.0549689606,
-0.0047257273,
-0.0331184529,
-0.0286747515,
0.0024637347,
-0.04184407,
0.0016251036,
0.0154196341,
0.0298902206,
0.0289280303,
-0.0047611091,
0.0286509153,
0.0876861885,
-0.0072302185,
-0.027933063,
0.0390544869,
0.049180977,
0.0287238155,
0.028989654,
-0.061234314,
0.0330178216,
-0.0221322551,
-0.0185060836,
-0.0137362489,
0.0161645394,
0.0021599345,
0.0093097063,
0.0338760689,
-0.0194536597,
-0.0577149354,
-0.0256112907,
0.045813866,
-0.1366814375,
0.0498825759,
-0.0225502662,
0.0802380741,
0.0001928879,
-0.0120561449,
0.04187629,
-0.0007798495,
0.0294197407,
0.0046467264,
0.017067885,
-0.0421059914,
0.0237355754,
-0.0271330215,
-0.0701721534,
0.0112227146,
-0.0714437068,
-0.0213816222,
0.0926706493,
0.0963154882,
-0.0131017193,
-0.0279934648,
-0.0942683667,
0.0446251482,
0.02194467,
-0.0081592137,
0.0738849193,
0.0179971009,
-0.0060284091,
-0.0144734178,
0.0222400725,
-0.0400348678,
0.0170452762,
0.0328709856,
0.0351865813,
0.0142735383,
0.0039779157,
0.0205965247,
0.0299415644,
-0.0275130905,
-0.0169120152,
0.0220847428,
-0.0145765776,
-0.0174185652,
0.0291412082,
0.017692171,
-0.0467177145,
-0.0079576503,
-0.0360185951,
-0.0251516309,
0.0146049866,
-0.02745899,
0.0402111188,
0.0339895673,
-0.0414893664,
0.0155942878,
0.0869215652,
-0.0214188378,
0.0218034536,
-0.0332714505,
-0.0155814216,
0.0154591314,
-0.0334982425,
0.0456880443,
-0.0353688151,
-0.048923213,
0.0857072324,
0.0105262687,
0.0126606179,
-0.0170853175,
0.0116480794,
0.0497352183,
-0.0460202508,
0.0167994872,
-0.0040693469,
0.0207855068,
-0.0040137833,
0.0606639646,
0.016324861,
-0.012298218,
-0.0186253712,
0.0328690074,
0.0197816752,
-0.0194825511,
-0.0194059592,
0.0254251193,
0.0383228064,
0.0157372952,
-0.0532101318,
0.0252386238,
0.0058045364,
-0.05056623,
0.0542917848,
-0.039106939,
-0.0208106507,
-0.0105515271,
2.771e-7,
0.0086435257,
0.0174246095,
0.0383020006,
-0.0250399057,
0.0121217417,
0.0264099576,
-0.0052249315,
0.0398715734,
0.020430902,
0.0439825803,
0.0186509043,
0.0172603615,
0.1046967953,
0.0183167234,
-0.0736122206,
-0.0709770545,
-0.0082645379,
0.0391483717,
-0.033346653,
0.0151472995,
0.0345465429,
0.0749953762,
-0.0322018564,
-0.0009481874,
-0.0053767664,
0.0213879254,
0.0432164073,
0.0102533437,
0.0223974511,
-0.0096494183,
-0.0123662548,
0.0180568527,
-0.0802149102,
0.0282158218,
-0.021270059,
0.0124837104,
0.0584533215,
0.0871225968,
-0.0075754272,
-0.0179758612,
-0.0012022535,
0.0121162748,
-0.0557455122,
-0.0074804686,
0.0523034446,
-0.0482267179,
-0.0093132369,
0.0367487855,
-0.007016446,
0.0481682271,
-0.0288443714,
-0.0095501766,
-0.0002091889,
0.0187527165,
0.056867227,
0.0148358699,
-0.027954381,
-0.0410273932,
0.0047699139,
-0.0427144952,
-0.0041692434,
-0.0538248084,
-0.0345195048,
0.0010389205,
0.0012510363,
-0.0320700631,
-0.0089590056,
2.349545736e-34,
0.0206217617,
0.0014351306,
0.0151075134,
-0.019662397,
0.011641304,
-0.0482492931,
-0.0055401484,
0.0102019012,
-0.010254126,
-0.0721309558,
-0.0678092465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11644v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11644v2 | Textbooks Are All You Need | 2023-06-20T16:14:25 | 2023-10-02T06:12:30 | Suriya Gunasekar, Yi Zhang, Jyoti Aneja, Caio César Teodoro Mendes, Allie Del Giorno, Sivakanth Gopi, Mojan Javaheripi, Piero Kauffmann, Gustavo de Rosa, Olli Saarikivi, Adil Salim, Shital Shah, Harkirat Singh Behl, Xin Wang, Sébastien Bubeck, Ronen Eldan, Adam Tauman Kalai, Yin Tat Lee, Yuanzhi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce phi-1, a new large language model for code, with significantly
smaller size than competing models: phi-1 is a Transformer-based model with
1.3B parameters, trained for 4 days on 8 A100s, using a selection of ``textbook
quality" data from the web (6B tokens) and synthetically generated textbooks
and exercises with GPT-3.5 (1B tokens). Despite this small scale, phi-1 attains
pass@1 accuracy 50.6% on HumanEval and 55.5% on MBPP. It also displays
surprising emergent properties compared to phi-1-base, our model before our
finetuning stage on a dataset of coding exercises, and phi-1-small, a smaller
model with 350M parameters trained with the same pipeline as phi-1 that still
achieves 45% on HumanEval. | [
0.0104438877,
0.0590448678,
-0.0189031232,
0.0129442904,
0.0189458076,
0.0114612132,
-0.0234807767,
0.0097546522,
-0.0213867929,
-0.0185213387,
-0.0198571961,
0.0140972203,
-0.0098237107,
0.0635683388,
0.0674844012,
-0.0101266773,
0.0363931544,
-0.0457971022,
-0.0356069878,
0.0017964361,
0.0188866835,
-0.0048886007,
0.0305062141,
0.0680675507,
0.0388971865,
-0.0298024118,
-0.013609766,
-0.0124928607,
-0.0230158456,
-0.0224732235,
0.02104613,
0.0400361903,
0.0184291508,
0.0434484333,
0.0000021585,
-0.0178980287,
-0.021091247,
0.0140414704,
-0.0093961479,
0.0384311117,
0.0085726529,
-0.0271222442,
-0.0165957771,
0.0349547639,
-0.0359667689,
-0.0325237848,
0.0683005452,
0.0112347314,
0.0703433231,
0.0567151643,
0.0052039158,
-0.0436672755,
0.0450272597,
0.0063357484,
0.0165602453,
-0.0128569901,
0.0128643299,
0.0268785376,
0.0303292945,
0.0537100397,
-0.0477275439,
0.0139361341,
0.0491488241,
-0.0147997001,
0.0039313207,
0.0495070294,
-0.0434244499,
-0.0033088704,
0.0114583848,
0.0369644985,
-0.0811127722,
-0.0607417226,
-0.0024770738,
-0.0147519726,
-0.0193666536,
-0.0505259074,
-0.0486991704,
0.0562013388,
-0.0040549445,
0.0150159895,
0.0123740695,
-0.0411584079,
0.0181055889,
-0.0178642161,
-0.0157411639,
0.0248347372,
0.0160221942,
-0.0164635703,
-0.0206192061,
-0.0107682999,
-0.0174633265,
-0.0367705226,
0.0014253121,
0.0517310016,
0.0193121769,
-0.0102642383,
-0.0313178375,
-0.0139577538,
0.0077277487,
-0.0439322963,
0.0274938922,
0.0314343758,
-0.0043912437,
0.0159318931,
-0.0549869277,
0.0737815127,
-0.0179019906,
0.018422503,
-0.0111617595,
0.0236435048,
-0.0538514741,
0.0101038888,
-0.0588764176,
0.0467932895,
0.0215600133,
0.0236896388,
-0.0424575061,
0.0172780119,
0.0107747968,
0.0418862291,
0.005175469,
-0.0148592005,
-0.0338091552,
0.0042671892,
0.0452867933,
0.0023518302,
0.0008127503,
-0.0403354578,
-0.0138546107,
-0.0686839148,
-0.0071053584,
0.008355299,
-0.0204920676,
-0.0301038269,
0.0045300387,
0.0570142716,
0.0023627458,
-0.002300184,
-0.0482378379,
0.0121409493,
-0.0040015853,
-0.0087199342,
-0.0194622297,
-0.0912358537,
-0.0315462276,
0.0355787352,
0.0282166712,
-0.0564268269,
-0.0030800512,
0.0236263294,
0.0073337918,
0.0310825631,
-0.0416693576,
0.0137258098,
-0.0063957935,
0.0010095134,
-0.020281028,
0.0462178998,
0.0527943186,
0.0128026595,
0.0036642354,
-0.0802850053,
0.0491622426,
0.064316161,
-0.0091561414,
-0.00046163,
0.0344729237,
0.0024227302,
0.0708406791,
-0.0104258955,
0.0414312705,
0.0565774366,
-0.0341116823,
0.0020763555,
0.0234942455,
0.0158867426,
0.0157840662,
0.065826267,
0.0703798681,
0.0476573594,
0.0373002067,
-0.0304129068,
-0.0457569174,
0.0311600734,
-0.0243969504,
0.0171338152,
-0.0096713975,
0.0289518815,
-0.0072631836,
-0.0506223999,
-0.0009889076,
-0.0171071067,
-0.0103302179,
-0.0200097486,
0.0478553995,
0.0134858433,
-0.0565982051,
0.0230274647,
0.0098098498,
-0.0671335086,
-0.0087371273,
-0.0532179736,
0.0209058672,
0.0092495196,
0.0533778295,
-0.0298271757,
-0.0061024535,
-0.0351949446,
0.0107057923,
-0.0109140016,
0.029865494,
-0.0200740378,
-0.0018665912,
-0.0845697597,
-0.0023465022,
-0.0269890819,
-0.0060181618,
0.0016947102,
0.0188371204,
-0.0251561087,
0.025562888,
0.0087950407,
-0.0678133219,
0.0298423581,
-0.0519748479,
-0.0101863844,
-0.0203335937,
-0.0262904856,
0.025071973,
-0.0407865047,
-0.0343011729,
0.023429824,
0.0170035865,
-0.0147326794,
0.01362509,
-0.0404043794,
-0.0257979259,
-0.0117685497,
0.0472744778,
-0.0287394337,
-0.0126618743,
0.0533421263,
-0.0169858579,
-0.0230522193,
0.0146759534,
-0.0398668945,
0.0545941778,
-0.0013487814,
0.035048224,
-0.04510694,
0.0094448272,
-0.0222130567,
-0.0033340522,
0.0183416978,
0.0571720302,
-0.0345846005,
0.061059311,
0.0189210325,
0.008268618,
-0.0555625148,
0.018809218,
-0.0445103198,
0.0477606505,
0.0038107855,
0.0483472496,
-0.0283755511,
-0.0522604883,
-0.074586913,
0.0074000731,
-0.0106511908,
0.0025736149,
0.0022683332,
0.003043442,
0.0049179317,
0.0055208923,
-0.0349197723,
-0.0064241602,
-0.0362291709,
0.01366009,
0.0103334729,
-0.0191596225,
-0.0582364276,
-0.057489939,
-0.0252437629,
-0.0536026657,
0.0496595241,
-0.0057730419,
0.0279281214,
-0.0675851628,
0.0907996669,
0.039835345,
0.0279830489,
-0.0205664951,
-0.0977852345,
0.0222797189,
-0.051853016,
0.0847616866,
0.0418150052,
-0.0141611174,
0.0062399367,
0.0344107226,
0.0050145686,
-0.0559144653,
0.0035624621,
0.011132854,
-0.0877066106,
-0.0458574332,
-0.0318067633,
0.0143372305,
0.096728839,
-0.0256777294,
-0.026785031,
-0.0686792135,
0.0165536571,
-0.0042571323,
0.0102315182,
0.0111546982,
-0.0069452762,
-0.0133435307,
0.0200960599,
-0.0242457762,
-0.0715581924,
0.052483093,
-0.0551802441,
-0.0322839357,
-0.0394799337,
-0.0120998994,
-0.0521739013,
0.0324410908,
0.0173224118,
0.0041072755,
0.0272932574,
-0.0310116448,
-0.0571891405,
0.0189623199,
-0.0219525117,
-0.0475373343,
0.0614818148,
-0.0297108646,
0.0029006978,
-0.0142402304,
-0.0465566106,
-0.034258578,
0.0076661529,
-0.0089471014,
0.0158128832,
0.0440618806,
-0.0296274442,
0.0004277135,
0.0183968861,
0.0068170405,
0.0629872233,
0.0001308018,
-0.044555869,
-0.0127385538,
-0.0303056706,
0.006225002,
-0.0413670465,
-0.0014221892,
-0.0464198478,
0.0226273648,
0.026626423,
0.0492893271,
0.0612285286,
-0.0787382051,
0.0170740839,
0.0399470218,
-0.0217198543,
-0.0208373349,
0.0542497374,
0.0199702177,
-0.0512824953,
-0.0427217521,
0.1178324372,
0.0177831631,
-0.0770579576,
0.0049922545,
-0.0022621518,
0.0396305881,
0.0394877978,
0.0314074717,
-0.0471469536,
-0.0075450512,
-0.0081110857,
0.0132232411,
0.0005204282,
-0.0328724906,
-0.0049142078,
-0.1108308211,
0.0038050236,
0.0418755226,
0.0068164617,
-0.0584920757,
-0.0503580086,
-0.0395777933,
-0.0452797785,
-0.036994122,
0.0475464314,
-0.0316446759,
0.0394710153,
0.016103752,
-0.013937098,
0.0075958534,
0.0478854999,
-0.0370693132,
0.0218529012,
0.0625136271,
0.0051763118,
-0.0335119478,
-0.0041677915,
0.0299855471,
-0.0188410655,
-0.0108496463,
-0.0067359698,
0.0280615706,
0.0030851203,
-0.0201697927,
0.0274606925,
0.0343532003,
-0.0676576868,
-0.0022394457,
0.0411795489,
0.0754436255,
0.009520811,
-0.0247913953,
-0.0258184914,
-0.0143443793,
-0.0333060734,
0.0295388512,
0.042582538,
-0.0606743731,
-0.0239131302,
-0.0616051443,
-0.005393751,
-0.0441545546,
-0.0352259912,
0.0199988,
0.0180473588,
-0.0258430205,
-0.0405957885,
0.0032536918,
0.0339537673,
0.0513835624,
0.0278424025,
-0.0262403283,
0.0322708003,
-0.0030469394,
-0.0573120601,
0.0285291206,
-0.0212504007,
0.0000877771,
-0.0869385153,
-0.0086078318,
0.0509246625,
-0.0154087469,
-0.0294302758,
0.0149250375,
-0.1039914489,
-0.0507012643,
0.0161384977,
0.0779270753,
0.0242734123,
-0.0126831643,
-0.02561884,
-0.0404583998,
-0.0492010377,
-0.0179213341,
-0.045653563,
0.0108549334,
0.0357733965,
-0.0156628452,
0.0142545383,
0.0022671905,
-0.0354143195,
-0.0122991353,
0.0195020493,
0.0096463412,
-0.0173944626,
0.0179895367,
0.0487922952,
0.0044001746,
0.0427751988,
0.0257418137,
-0.0244864896,
0.0001821184,
-0.0010888526,
0.0142342364,
-0.001185187,
-0.0585777834,
0.015955694,
0.0549705066,
0.0144475186,
0.0038686004,
0.0235054698,
0.0103025781,
0.0502373241,
0.0150696607,
0.0554872714,
0.0199727658,
0.0328632072,
0.0915668458,
-0.010147173,
-0.019068487,
0.0028611091,
0.0100049488,
0.0188254379,
-0.0170073528,
0.0420817733,
0.0162406135,
0.0415571965,
0.0150608644,
0.0220422987,
-0.0444810912,
-0.0464042276,
-0.0259715598,
-0.013979828,
0.0280054435,
0.0378495045,
0.026395943,
-0.0109164268,
0.0206866544,
-0.0275996532,
0.0642429292,
-0.043428354,
-0.0373925604,
0.0270326305,
0.0364756472,
-0.0113403611,
-0.0266120341,
0.0900158137,
0.0307895299,
0.0195205696,
0.0031422637,
0.0116535882,
-0.0215524416,
0.021314349,
0.0242135972,
-0.0036748603,
0.0128250616,
-0.0041895066,
-0.0223464184,
-0.0597810596,
-0.0030171399,
0.0299520399,
0.0239159483,
-0.0105303638,
0.0577821285,
0.09133064,
-0.0269565415,
-0.014942999,
-0.0384383239,
0.0213207547,
0.0315767452,
-0.0635659397,
-0.039729666,
-5.847593626e-33,
-0.0149804559,
-0.0050337953,
0.0310629532,
0.0026977316,
-0.0103586819,
-0.0013940386,
-0.0328505933,
-0.0081096534,
-0.036857076,
-0.0309829451,
0.0012615757,
0.0439914577,
-0.0083499793,
0.0035425678,
0.0529998355,
0.0337343514,
0.0671508089,
0.0053032446,
-0.0408576429,
0.0357728787,
-0.0246535074,
0.028980637,
0.0302862022,
-0.0144588863,
-0.0423836224,
-0.0037202116,
0.0042870245,
-0.0328425243,
-0.0053320113,
0.0633969605,
0.0038960159,
0.0340348855,
0.0035314139,
-0.0153254699,
-0.0273617581,
-0.0317721814,
-0.0324849747,
-0.0079642544,
0.0001372864,
0.0188424587,
0.0218294822,
-0.0728820115,
0.0620628111,
-0.0217267089,
-0.0317151621,
-0.0245538224,
0.0319410972,
-0.0049141608,
-0.0168003812,
-0.0188578349,
-0.0629830658,
0.0325483494,
-0.030912783,
0.0120588783,
0.015790727,
0.0080050481,
-0.0119503113,
0.0415851586,
0.0184990987,
0.019436501,
0.0505689383,
0.0866423771,
0.0289691724,
0.0008726338,
0.0123473834,
0.0293360297,
0.0716934726,
0.0312011167,
0.0157594141,
0.0074334955,
0.0628236234,
0.03431293,
0.0505899824,
0.0357187614,
0.0137030995,
-0.0042853048,
-0.0348129645,
0.0062709814,
0.006647937,
0.0311065279,
-0.0082112523,
0.0191973019,
-0.0376106501,
-0.0257430356,
-0.0394503213,
-0.0259137768,
-0.0007287628,
-0.0415460765,
0.0345811807,
-0.0166188721,
-0.012921581,
0.0063976576,
0.0403833427,
-0.0544865243,
-0.0051848753,
0.020507101,
-0.0295651332,
0.0778900534,
-0.0153054148,
0.0573107973,
-0.0556494631,
-0.0500124991,
0.0088227978,
-0.0154249873,
0.0706778988,
0.0129798651,
0.0263850056,
0.0509417951,
-0.0643364862,
-0.0330675095,
-0.0493212081,
-0.023886295,
0.0202186294,
0.0658026263,
0.0087566338,
-0.00801019,
0.0156951509,
0.0415867567,
-0.0179056432,
-0.0387773253,
-0.0547648482,
-0.0052578696,
0.0116864257,
0.0292529631,
-0.0249027591,
-0.050758291,
-0.0648774356,
0.0486548021,
0.041899804,
-0.0670111924,
-0.0509667955,
0.0479203239,
2.838e-7,
0.0199265834,
0.0399286114,
0.0015354508,
0.0095430994,
0.0126017369,
0.0310652852,
-0.0283348244,
-0.0009692473,
0.0060323691,
0.0171418563,
-0.0274935979,
0.008538696,
0.0355223082,
0.0120403022,
-0.0902972147,
-0.0029832053,
-0.0395486876,
-0.0014643427,
-0.0510669723,
-0.013352612,
0.0189220738,
0.1170668826,
-0.0012107512,
0.018271612,
0.0235734098,
-0.0317678526,
0.0117160659,
0.0108488044,
0.0008820584,
0.0682913288,
-0.0856099203,
0.015629366,
-0.017310055,
-0.0271494668,
-0.0053928937,
-0.0060207383,
0.024458494,
0.0734196901,
-0.0044837408,
0.0598870143,
0.0496459007,
-0.0245339088,
-0.0266985986,
-0.0903823897,
0.042022258,
-0.0221536737,
-0.0085707959,
0.0028672405,
-0.0390754007,
-0.013081138,
-0.0273495913,
-0.0405678824,
0.014323323,
0.0202781353,
0.0030049689,
-0.0317519456,
0.0010270959,
-0.0377960168,
-0.0236525722,
0.0158647858,
-0.0163303073,
-0.0640709251,
-0.0746955797,
-0.0094953263,
0.0422648191,
-0.0412531495,
0.0359647162,
2.957405345e-34,
0.0475506298,
-0.0694059357,
0.0644750744,
0.0359986387,
0.0304465443,
-0.0087992745,
0.0271009523,
0.0161849614,
0.0009746896,
-0.0272320136,
-0.0496800654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07513v1 | An empirical study of using radiology reports and images to improve ICU mortality prediction | 2023-06-20T15:43:28 | 2023-06-20T15:43:28 | Mingquan Lin, Song Wang, Ying Ding, Lihui Zhao, Fei Wang, Yifan Peng | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, eess.IV | Background: The predictive Intensive Care Unit (ICU) scoring system plays an
important role in ICU management because it predicts important outcomes,
especially mortality. Many scoring systems have been developed and used in the
ICU. These scoring systems are primarily based on the structured clinical data
in the electronic health record (EHR), which may suffer the loss of important
clinical information in the narratives and images. Methods: In this work, we
build a deep learning based survival prediction model with multi-modality data
to predict ICU mortality. Four sets of features are investigated: (1)
physiological measurements of Simplified Acute Physiology Score (SAPS) II, (2)
common thorax diseases pre-defined by radiologists, (3) BERT-based text
representations, and (4) chest X-ray image features. We use the Medical
Information Mart for Intensive Care IV (MIMIC-IV) dataset to evaluate the
proposed model. Results: Our model achieves the average C-index of 0.7829 (95%
confidence interval, 0.7620-0.8038), which substantially exceeds that of the
baseline with SAPS-II features (0.7470 (0.7263-0.7676)). Ablation studies
further demonstrate the contributions of pre-defined labels (2.00%), text
features (2.44%), and image features (2.82%). | [
-0.0093203969,
0.0282097142,
-0.0089197699,
-0.0520192534,
-0.0064014262,
0.0236006659,
0.0119158924,
0.0110696666,
-0.0339198522,
0.0136795798,
-0.01147635,
-0.0698098391,
0.0138438875,
0.0949313566,
-0.0204661265,
-0.039100714,
0.0354660042,
0.0003358334,
0.0454086736,
0.0098434426,
-0.0072413748,
0.0328049995,
0.0152962627,
0.048283197,
-0.0345349349,
0.0374794602,
0.0082093747,
0.013971176,
0.0091191074,
-0.06602218,
0.0013334383,
0.0068949223,
0.0242847018,
-0.0244669002,
0.0000022476,
-0.0470835045,
-0.0387195088,
-0.0107363351,
-0.0629138499,
-0.0593730472,
0.0303368457,
-0.0638942569,
0.0123309726,
0.0048273322,
-0.0565484539,
-0.023502918,
0.0259065516,
0.0796520934,
0.0326557346,
0.0204260703,
-0.0254937913,
0.0147032952,
0.0425470918,
-0.0370393991,
0.0210243035,
-0.0491031706,
0.0180110428,
0.0032520618,
0.01650282,
-0.0298206862,
-0.0221656989,
0.0717168748,
0.0645584315,
0.0474103428,
0.0130674196,
0.0749255419,
-0.00418542,
-0.0171126667,
-0.0089214789,
0.0472510457,
-0.0539493002,
0.004963065,
-0.0038446698,
-0.0136123858,
-0.0045545893,
-0.0517045073,
-0.030307496,
-0.0379173942,
0.0210251156,
0.0106321005,
-0.039053496,
0.0632196143,
0.010241949,
-0.0214840993,
0.0027211471,
-0.0614458546,
-0.0067544649,
-0.0016548663,
0.0055147326,
0.0010058378,
-0.0395568162,
-0.0108106667,
0.0024923279,
0.0030275662,
-0.0462015569,
0.0059630428,
-0.0230408832,
-0.0090807769,
0.0296649504,
-0.0803724825,
-0.0184260998,
-0.0134732053,
-0.0312578455,
0.0401538685,
-0.0249605477,
-0.0034943514,
-0.0294679999,
0.0249493252,
-0.005966865,
0.0188057665,
-0.0528062284,
0.0001234609,
0.0099560097,
0.044995904,
0.1056956947,
0.0268009827,
-0.0732967928,
-0.0414662175,
-0.0100051835,
0.0211324468,
0.0738214254,
0.0936373994,
-0.0398765318,
0.0273028389,
-0.0343163796,
-0.0013076391,
0.0208637211,
0.0062374668,
-0.0295169465,
-0.0062672822,
0.0580093116,
0.0295219831,
0.018494552,
-0.0118702007,
0.027216481,
-0.0025945224,
0.0277442336,
-0.0069511938,
0.008055889,
-0.0244678501,
-0.0546145998,
-0.0051363283,
0.0103634745,
-0.0315366238,
0.0196859278,
-0.0231169779,
0.0058478946,
-0.0476267748,
0.0172930378,
-0.0417450145,
-0.0129978629,
0.0176591221,
-0.0462011509,
-0.014764877,
0.0261373948,
0.0102289924,
0.0209625568,
0.0093745925,
0.0429217704,
-0.0026397454,
0.0017240008,
-0.0272543542,
0.0132148517,
0.0029155132,
-0.0060132011,
-0.0449781567,
-0.036669258,
-0.0174567979,
-0.0432124585,
0.0550102144,
-0.0304869823,
0.0042248853,
0.0425594673,
-0.0734099671,
0.0211116225,
0.0030958822,
0.0563295521,
0.0459441021,
0.0171587151,
-0.0261399318,
-0.0351232961,
-0.0485560223,
0.0025163773,
0.0485220701,
0.0683004037,
-0.0018646215,
-0.003318296,
-0.0198482145,
-0.0471129902,
-0.097602956,
-0.0168107376,
-0.0130364904,
-0.0220489968,
-0.0165083949,
0.0643749908,
-0.0372338369,
-0.0280245785,
0.0209076647,
0.0242934376,
0.0055799899,
-0.0066647115,
-0.0460975356,
-0.0448986776,
0.0748256445,
0.0320753716,
-0.0396294035,
-0.0249812789,
-0.0424659625,
0.0304719321,
-0.0329570137,
0.0324329585,
0.0266656931,
0.0259322748,
-0.0170645658,
-0.0423849262,
0.0044866242,
-0.0032257144,
-0.0247971993,
-0.0469867773,
0.0049437466,
-0.019889608,
-0.0420578457,
-0.0574430227,
0.0250947308,
-0.0198181216,
-0.0148814721,
0.0099141309,
0.0138931414,
0.0233496092,
0.0086524384,
-0.0024518848,
-0.0040168711,
0.0559998751,
-0.0067321286,
-0.0737278014,
0.0095775975,
-0.0735267922,
0.0062752762,
-0.0026254056,
-0.0277529974,
0.0001685251,
0.0109729245,
-0.0366737358,
-0.0199897941,
-0.017498536,
-0.0386990458,
0.0052726567,
0.0208574962,
-0.0087283319,
0.0469734557,
-0.0023309535,
-0.0153382896,
0.0344681665,
-0.0472161919,
0.0086789951,
-0.0290211532,
-0.0396841504,
0.0302438959,
0.0124922544,
-0.0255538896,
-0.0145144183,
-0.0535649359,
0.0105013819,
0.0159250665,
0.0199977234,
-0.000748547,
0.0314432234,
-0.1312284321,
0.0062040556,
0.0007313006,
-0.0216829795,
0.0264200121,
0.0153294392,
-0.0101372236,
-0.0283726398,
-0.0459389873,
-0.0226611011,
0.0074065216,
-0.0197312701,
0.0450900719,
0.0682899505,
-0.0017814083,
-0.0243481006,
-0.0016108713,
-0.0486376435,
0.0335125178,
0.0151011702,
-0.0327565484,
0.0478084795,
0.0179605465,
-0.0241499431,
0.0109629668,
-0.0192800201,
-0.0310304351,
0.0027270217,
-0.0469774567,
-0.0320968777,
0.0247209165,
0.0112628732,
0.0143362666,
0.0029935525,
0.0281791147,
-0.0349719003,
0.0349625088,
-0.0817491561,
-0.0308649726,
0.0181301348,
-0.0580101758,
-0.0527617261,
0.0361079536,
0.0247040335,
0.0200266726,
-0.0354635157,
-0.0208489392,
-0.0130422544,
-0.0041707586,
-0.0585252009,
0.0326069668,
-0.0223041009,
0.0148824714,
0.0216570795,
-0.0474312045,
0.060065385,
0.0033038878,
0.0477435403,
-0.0547691472,
-0.018434383,
-0.0443521254,
0.0020132381,
-0.0212090909,
0.0129373437,
0.0139558241,
0.0180491712,
-0.0301678833,
0.0456102751,
-0.0274335928,
-0.0457019024,
-0.0140082538,
-0.0007234853,
0.0157554504,
0.0394906327,
-0.0185143538,
-0.0449873693,
-0.0004571079,
-0.0009695509,
0.0124980379,
-0.0343196951,
0.031041557,
-0.0587329641,
0.0270296689,
-0.0121422075,
0.0276900344,
0.0018905137,
-0.0177706201,
-0.0031704747,
0.0480945632,
0.031616386,
0.0036745146,
0.0040801889,
-0.0257633869,
0.0322694704,
0.0429322794,
-0.0188181791,
0.068413794,
-0.0350101069,
0.0104690455,
-0.0336288661,
0.0155400494,
0.0110557918,
0.0189402662,
-0.0038731731,
-0.0454457775,
0.0101128565,
0.0979938656,
0.0322333649,
-0.0536724031,
0.0039314423,
-0.0131260287,
-0.0071513136,
-0.0221451744,
-0.0287684966,
-0.012407749,
-0.0233510472,
-0.0275999643,
-0.0041739717,
0.0067453007,
-0.0434549637,
0.0598684587,
0.035374023,
0.016155351,
-0.0328538567,
-0.0427364148,
-0.034777794,
-0.0520989224,
0.0316322893,
-0.0343363285,
-0.0173494164,
-0.0655239671,
0.0060943915,
-0.0159300771,
0.0160265975,
-0.0761757568,
-0.0524794608,
0.0389524251,
-0.0435677506,
0.001683951,
0.0979415104,
0.049888432,
-0.0632230118,
-0.0165120102,
-0.0050436701,
0.0395402871,
0.0403639115,
-0.0076966151,
0.0792413279,
0.0001000948,
-0.0065366994,
-0.0532070324,
0.0246140286,
-0.0220186114,
0.0087940032,
-0.0305852592,
0.0720152631,
-0.0366208181,
-0.0633283854,
-0.0873720273,
0.0085240537,
0.0067900964,
0.0282902271,
-0.0106726149,
-0.0343844742,
-0.0291330889,
0.0113656586,
0.0705453902,
-0.0219499581,
-0.0323442928,
0.0128083788,
-0.0443720445,
-0.04379135,
-0.0343605429,
-0.0263386369,
0.0231947321,
-0.0263961311,
0.0020250254,
0.0043392773,
0.0136471549,
0.0033290307,
-0.0786666423,
0.0542426184,
0.0227496568,
0.0256670825,
-0.027466977,
0.0003567036,
0.0561429821,
0.0178515986,
-0.0382323265,
-0.0080684237,
0.007773221,
0.0571554862,
-0.0053901263,
0.0901787058,
0.0138744283,
-0.0249090847,
0.0162753928,
-0.0057527148,
0.0901985839,
0.0278903674,
-0.0049120253,
-0.0574314781,
0.0018685615,
-0.0518902428,
-0.0234196763,
0.0098531721,
-0.0093709584,
0.0557285808,
-0.0137811657,
-0.0008712694,
0.0085242968,
-0.0227422062,
-0.0168283917,
0.0078176148,
0.0288522802,
-0.0142154209,
-0.0676871017,
-0.015400392,
0.0145917879,
0.0409355983,
0.045752991,
0.0116849123,
0.0482065193,
0.0630500466,
0.0267251544,
-0.0049323323,
0.0419770144,
-0.0039328309,
-0.0771028101,
-0.0721025318,
0.0442312546,
0.0366960093,
0.0418004468,
0.0213017501,
0.0221681688,
-0.0032058638,
0.0045296238,
0.0213847999,
0.0153040336,
-0.0008813986,
0.0055162194,
-0.0198032595,
0.03925265,
0.0059474171,
0.0684687495,
-0.0099123036,
-0.0136745842,
-0.0750261247,
-0.018261414,
0.0274041221,
0.0106340377,
-0.0019283239,
-0.0252289865,
0.0462350361,
-0.0354767889,
0.0328609459,
-0.0146445977,
0.0536389202,
0.055637762,
-0.002864596,
-0.0006763351,
0.0210746471,
0.0955477953,
0.0337369516,
0.0444839224,
-0.0059698224,
-0.0246399082,
-0.0498551093,
0.0290268511,
0.0671172068,
0.0479793735,
-0.0335094631,
0.0014757745,
-0.0380317308,
-0.0032352479,
0.09600766,
-0.0108810542,
-0.0235229004,
-0.0271291286,
0.0690135583,
0.0211718939,
-0.0165072009,
0.0217982009,
-0.0076167448,
-0.0081672492,
-0.0018924751,
-0.025210619,
-0.0150536336,
-5.546909151e-33,
0.0241514128,
-0.0149790253,
0.0069596465,
-0.0157737285,
0.0125636533,
0.0584254526,
-0.0184815023,
-0.0353174545,
-0.0008537132,
-0.0068204198,
-0.0050356761,
-0.0095623489,
0.0051858746,
0.0100592086,
0.0308307018,
-0.0736336485,
0.004487047,
0.0066283094,
-0.0014985671,
0.0580906793,
-0.0162484664,
0.0485475957,
0.0449860357,
-0.0937346071,
-0.0115491161,
0.0194886066,
-0.0035789404,
-0.0290179439,
0.0161408037,
0.0340624452,
-0.0560044423,
0.0450722985,
0.0381581001,
-0.038585823,
-0.0078628678,
0.0027000254,
-0.0103771109,
-0.0162414983,
-0.0083845286,
-0.0382814445,
-0.019532945,
-0.0032767314,
0.0466417484,
0.0277097691,
-0.0038576964,
-0.0045098821,
0.0506007746,
-0.0015357792,
0.0183417834,
-0.0563176461,
0.0035999981,
0.0483129285,
-0.0289785098,
-0.0184474662,
0.0008212762,
0.0131888194,
-0.0054368274,
0.0711485073,
-0.0678038374,
-0.0278911795,
-0.0317764394,
0.0421697423,
0.0238933675,
-0.0616289042,
-0.0422316007,
0.0711537674,
0.0386369899,
0.0163925644,
-0.031961605,
0.0040873825,
-0.0090293279,
0.0826177746,
0.0888078809,
0.0609085672,
0.0182210971,
-0.0504332632,
-0.0860069767,
0.0825379342,
-0.0507586375,
0.0468972996,
0.0267452877,
-0.0118826209,
-0.0372469239,
0.0107835149,
-0.004554451,
0.0027006406,
0.0034363023,
-0.0137293795,
0.0310895629,
0.0019195378,
0.0157742612,
0.0703317299,
0.0059736338,
-0.0312894806,
0.0399549119,
-0.0154798096,
0.0737168267,
0.0473791212,
-0.0005328843,
-0.0087017203,
0.0000239036,
0.0079912748,
0.0529674739,
-0.0308846124,
0.0558834709,
-0.0174707621,
0.0312547944,
0.0095747942,
0.0017790885,
-0.0271448195,
0.0235198177,
-0.0487165451,
-0.0277789179,
0.0171112083,
0.0060927197,
0.0288934968,
0.0016723181,
0.0147801116,
0.0005692588,
0.0050422661,
-0.0353090167,
-0.0547143035,
0.0077275112,
-0.0189893134,
-0.0217500106,
-0.0471068248,
-0.0526919067,
-0.007394833,
0.0160932727,
-0.0687950552,
-0.0223057624,
0.0540919341,
2.966e-7,
0.090048261,
0.0288861245,
0.0210677721,
-0.0889721438,
0.007899303,
0.0404471941,
-0.0041769473,
0.0218989328,
0.0145546701,
-0.0279973336,
0.0685263574,
-0.0097124642,
0.0301826932,
0.0424556248,
-0.0606202111,
-0.05920019,
-0.0404753983,
0.0172289982,
-0.0202260911,
-0.042527914,
0.0783258453,
0.0890654027,
-0.0193426218,
-0.0326142907,
0.0315808952,
0.0109634018,
0.0025038482,
-0.0681853294,
0.0071002049,
-0.010400936,
0.001482025,
0.049843289,
-0.0038431908,
0.0135381529,
-0.007238463,
-0.0078343051,
0.0351568051,
0.060272295,
-0.0385443866,
-0.0257805828,
0.0158396009,
0.022492405,
0.0376760513,
-0.0468860418,
0.0779290423,
-0.0211831313,
-0.0044564395,
-0.0289280601,
-0.0260251686,
0.0660973787,
0.0701653436,
-0.0136622461,
-0.0485687815,
0.0395668298,
0.0116457781,
-0.0057979641,
-0.0522529706,
-0.0469949618,
-0.0066181594,
0.0662684739,
-0.0377091207,
-0.034676332,
0.0062629413,
0.0009847535,
0.0201716032,
-0.0407374576,
0.0094981343,
2.348476771e-34,
0.0295022279,
-0.0055483137,
-0.0155454651,
0.0039670737,
0.0121778259,
-0.0015542011,
0.0149004012,
0.0021448594,
-0.0180903971,
-0.0454913713,
-0.0182907283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11593v1 | Improving Image Captioning Descriptiveness by Ranking and LLM-based Fusion | 2023-06-20T15:13:02 | 2023-06-20T15:13:02 | Simone Bianco, Luigi Celona, Marco Donzella, Paolo Napoletano | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.LG | State-of-The-Art (SoTA) image captioning models often rely on the Microsoft
COCO (MS-COCO) dataset for training. This dataset contains annotations provided
by human annotators, who typically produce captions averaging around ten
tokens. However, this constraint presents a challenge in effectively capturing
complex scenes and conveying detailed information. Furthermore, captioning
models tend to exhibit bias towards the ``average'' caption, which captures
only the more general aspects. What would happen if we were able to
automatically generate longer captions, thereby making them more detailed?
Would these captions, evaluated by humans, be more or less representative of
the image content compared to the original MS-COCO captions? In this paper, we
present a novel approach to address previous challenges by showcasing how
captions generated from different SoTA models can be effectively fused,
resulting in richer captions. Our proposed method leverages existing models
from the literature, eliminating the need for additional training. Instead, it
utilizes an image-text based metric to rank the captions generated by SoTA
models for a given image. Subsequently, the top two captions are fused using a
Large Language Model (LLM). Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness
of our approach, as the captions generated by our model exhibit higher
consistency with human judgment when evaluated on the MS-COCO test set. By
combining the strengths of various SoTA models, our method enhances the quality
and appeal of image captions, bridging the gap between automated systems and
the rich, informative nature of human-generated descriptions. This advance
opens up new possibilities for generating captions that are more suitable for
the training of both vision-language and captioning models. | [
0.0418715365,
0.0652486607,
0.0169917643,
0.0406229906,
0.0133594023,
0.0359686054,
-0.0307800677,
-0.0098051308,
0.0192701723,
-0.1000508144,
-0.0281666126,
-0.0076846438,
0.0164414011,
0.0298041832,
0.0067412723,
-0.0852604955,
-0.0146401785,
-0.0504929125,
-0.0125233158,
0.0030335828,
0.0213681646,
0.0011131832,
0.0252500027,
0.0299893953,
-0.0120712519,
-0.0028760664,
0.020783579,
0.0081865061,
0.0203529168,
-0.0320072547,
-0.0168860592,
0.0646501705,
0.0770492181,
-0.0100361872,
0.000001681,
-0.0113764796,
0.0398563556,
0.0007914111,
0.0371772684,
0.0326480605,
0.0525829643,
-0.0233926736,
0.0059405868,
-0.0201523826,
-0.0249810684,
0.0213334449,
0.0515972376,
0.0367337428,
0.0768280774,
0.0186514072,
-0.016649412,
-0.0588424057,
-0.0137716895,
-0.0501494631,
-0.0219151098,
-0.0215655565,
-0.0013536398,
0.08400736,
0.0000475813,
0.0103751021,
-0.0119795734,
0.0271734241,
-0.0285414178,
-0.0356681868,
0.0324210003,
0.0681812912,
-0.0547402911,
-0.0422953479,
-0.0227873623,
0.0791813955,
0.0086991908,
0.0251249298,
-0.0314899348,
0.0133574829,
-0.0078752171,
-0.0267374609,
-0.0529527217,
0.0462173037,
0.0187197886,
0.014596872,
-0.0382599048,
0.0499390364,
-0.0049127191,
0.0188108813,
-0.0008065234,
-0.0144002,
0.0153530659,
0.0169004705,
-0.0290095434,
0.0084138885,
-0.055139102,
-0.0550272651,
-0.0188012272,
-0.0069306223,
0.0338306725,
0.0064220941,
-0.0199350677,
0.0103312917,
0.0176873039,
-0.0616202801,
-0.0045569814,
-0.0083546331,
-0.0573217534,
0.1069527641,
-0.0256374311,
0.0577959754,
0.0184359793,
0.0331870206,
-0.0610269345,
0.0226907376,
-0.0468130521,
-0.0081988079,
0.0055587366,
0.0312664956,
-0.0415984914,
-0.0466645695,
-0.0565846972,
-0.0096287476,
-0.0219701417,
0.0209769383,
0.0098004472,
0.0386869386,
0.0023228498,
0.0172129311,
-0.0593685582,
0.0000244305,
0.0143416161,
-0.0006166945,
-0.0185348652,
-0.0123411315,
0.0105995908,
0.0545494221,
-0.0025011941,
-0.0025752841,
0.0079029305,
0.0542512648,
-0.045391392,
-0.0327132121,
0.0149013521,
-0.021784775,
-0.0587369613,
-0.0209232438,
0.0048238309,
-0.0329200253,
0.023016043,
-0.0063889059,
0.0208989251,
-0.0369456448,
0.0290205907,
0.0162804369,
-0.0058507374,
0.1070194989,
-0.0146682076,
0.0022337828,
0.0249688514,
0.0307761058,
-0.0118911676,
0.0491424948,
0.0254019219,
0.0743189156,
0.0419597924,
-0.0003753705,
0.0429129489,
0.0214305725,
-0.0368997082,
0.0120147727,
-0.031056663,
0.0020634972,
0.0019035307,
0.0013595364,
0.0544520952,
0.0558722429,
-0.0034758055,
0.0467978641,
0.1022201777,
0.0383126736,
-0.0239158105,
0.0261405837,
0.0327803083,
0.0210694745,
0.0027311877,
0.0306579936,
-0.0414293185,
0.0618850738,
0.0344044194,
0.0211983435,
0.0350053161,
0.0298370738,
-0.0219497122,
-0.0422810726,
-0.0208610874,
-0.0325981677,
0.0121610444,
-0.0322977863,
0.0093006855,
-0.0021010912,
-0.0310820416,
0.0541878194,
0.0113969278,
-0.0508465096,
-0.000541653,
-0.048095867,
-0.0059146918,
0.0843105912,
0.0317777283,
-0.0023841599,
-0.0099996012,
0.0048717326,
0.0457451791,
0.0521875545,
0.0128559899,
0.0154947797,
-0.0087378072,
-0.0446975417,
-0.0402363725,
-0.0255942233,
0.0103156194,
0.0144707644,
-0.0219597723,
-0.011047706,
0.0516210869,
0.0097149201,
-0.1109854579,
0.0319070481,
0.0634824559,
-0.0404994115,
-0.0084194131,
0.0076893102,
-0.0036477356,
-0.0038351112,
-0.0350853801,
0.0220296048,
0.0053351936,
-0.0121756215,
-0.0351171046,
0.0783866122,
-0.0620534644,
-0.0296521448,
0.0150314672,
-0.0687108934,
-0.0060476311,
-0.0173822399,
-0.044131726,
-0.0266690254,
-0.0220903493,
-0.0482103042,
-0.0154467886,
-0.0769130364,
0.0312197153,
0.0195670594,
0.0135568986,
-0.0190321282,
0.0875770152,
-0.0115082562,
-0.0305202994,
0.0328136384,
-0.0334486775,
-0.0111003369,
-0.0296211634,
-0.0440038256,
-0.0069773197,
0.0192319192,
0.0284093842,
0.0253979769,
0.0532985888,
-0.0374880023,
-0.0209582038,
-0.098590821,
-0.0488417,
-0.0048882328,
-0.0343335681,
-0.0116321379,
-0.0315222479,
0.0163644068,
-0.0103708617,
-0.0334560461,
-0.0213354807,
-0.0130517436,
0.021757571,
0.0462154411,
0.0290867034,
-0.0218558051,
-0.0363729447,
0.0143297473,
0.0203477163,
0.0698890537,
0.0418847091,
-0.0271973275,
-0.0432973281,
0.0129837813,
-0.0177246463,
-0.0039948071,
-0.0154633494,
-0.0413710773,
-0.0019450706,
0.0125723416,
-0.0174001195,
0.0503732339,
0.0367195569,
0.0102170613,
0.0399272032,
0.0041498696,
0.0030924901,
-0.0006874587,
0.0197796244,
-0.0736015439,
0.0398336835,
-0.046817895,
-0.003919675,
0.0257903188,
-0.0432471223,
0.0447045527,
-0.0692223608,
0.010964198,
-0.0285294913,
-0.0507035144,
-0.0529833511,
-0.0102165714,
-0.0019141498,
0.0169459712,
-0.0447285734,
-0.0517075993,
0.0295651555,
-0.0638739318,
-0.036154896,
-0.0105404174,
0.0014293673,
-0.0519032106,
0.0867990926,
0.0226810575,
0.0448576733,
-0.008727341,
0.004668131,
-0.0005924396,
-0.0258872826,
0.0332954526,
-0.0224050451,
0.0612437874,
-0.0677697882,
-0.0015993319,
-0.0169716273,
-0.0459742658,
-0.0150495898,
-0.0203297455,
-0.0404573493,
-0.0001774688,
-0.0296191629,
-0.0035986679,
0.0043110466,
0.0544070266,
0.009031794,
0.0315913297,
0.0071720895,
-0.0023685761,
-0.000872189,
0.0319310315,
0.0580275506,
0.0275488887,
-0.0723542124,
-0.0202168673,
0.0392987505,
0.0130191939,
-0.0228760596,
0.0187596232,
-0.0432100445,
0.0141826151,
0.0114279538,
0.0201721694,
-0.0069531193,
0.0179887563,
0.0564221032,
-0.0374896452,
0.0054269182,
0.0937223583,
0.0165393054,
-0.0431817099,
-0.0307103209,
0.028318001,
0.0206395611,
0.0378111638,
-0.0176983476,
-0.041388832,
-0.0391313098,
-0.0381146371,
-0.0103787947,
0.0136783235,
0.0376261882,
-0.0595498756,
-0.0740823746,
0.0539153628,
0.0368157066,
-0.03647919,
-0.0399830416,
-0.0059423698,
-0.0272792354,
-0.0176100768,
-0.0267169364,
-0.0221814718,
-0.01015714,
0.0105654979,
0.0048125354,
-0.0130066304,
-0.0323973745,
0.0250628162,
-0.0525287874,
0.0060038026,
0.0736647397,
0.0508807786,
-0.0400047898,
-0.036955107,
0.0045479699,
-0.0018202696,
0.0287999418,
0.0105912061,
0.0538503528,
-0.0358347669,
-0.0338598788,
0.0189375747,
0.0120211076,
0.013662043,
-0.015035077,
0.0032709681,
-0.0096010566,
0.0119032804,
0.017003661,
-0.0455256775,
0.0402851477,
-0.0044057285,
0.0624621399,
0.0276679844,
-0.029962942,
0.0193778835,
-0.0160969961,
-0.0078816591,
-0.0491421185,
-0.0272027496,
0.0226479936,
-0.0235719271,
-0.0248634201,
-0.0889624059,
-0.0038379519,
0.0337286182,
-0.0030852042,
0.0431968458,
0.0233042426,
-0.0236337539,
0.0429063663,
-0.0473991632,
0.0579614788,
-0.0378818251,
-0.0068648919,
-0.040316049,
-0.0016096856,
0.0968480483,
-0.0212376919,
-0.0346589051,
0.0247854553,
-0.050753504,
-0.0095182825,
-0.0425448231,
0.0694881603,
0.0105668679,
0.0044845198,
0.0320588686,
-0.0507795401,
0.0067211632,
0.0513337888,
0.027458204,
0.0011660454,
-0.0019855949,
0.007547651,
-0.0350996628,
0.0000224124,
-0.0471577384,
0.0155638894,
-0.0241465662,
0.0149137024,
-0.0169879328,
-0.051627066,
0.0102216499,
0.0100253103,
0.0183124598,
-0.0786802098,
0.0131171998,
-0.00437199,
0.0138838971,
-0.0129630258,
-0.0126293292,
-0.0337602012,
0.0236735921,
0.0048307567,
0.0465081781,
-0.0095227286,
0.0101886606,
-0.0251072627,
0.0106440047,
-0.0205776785,
-0.0075985086,
0.0305184703,
-0.0604653917,
-0.0171928722,
-0.003515274,
-0.0238965917,
0.0036753675,
-0.0183369722,
0.0208366197,
-0.0201881193,
0.029662678,
-0.0082663354,
-0.0192730073,
-0.0107763121,
0.0883322284,
0.0035495213,
-0.0099153379,
-0.0825589001,
0.0396534763,
0.085902445,
-0.0215073992,
0.0339607224,
-0.0198907517,
-0.0152530009,
0.0005378427,
0.0203397945,
-0.0015614998,
-0.0411070958,
0.0392851047,
0.0283523537,
0.0057682903,
0.0112171285,
0.0503978767,
0.0170572046,
0.0055741221,
0.00161139,
-0.0347145684,
-0.0404271521,
0.0081328489,
-0.0098564243,
-0.0190082956,
-0.0101617295,
0.0372387841,
-0.0380839743,
-0.0502587631,
0.0248677097,
-0.0038622823,
0.0182177685,
0.0342809856,
0.0630100369,
0.0255417954,
-0.0014147596,
-0.00339061,
-0.0320650972,
-0.0432076119,
-0.0166428871,
0.0432245098,
-0.0149051901,
-5.375484606e-33,
-0.0522774346,
-0.0663079992,
0.0006595374,
-0.003477792,
-0.036848709,
0.0151121151,
-0.0203331877,
0.0151983956,
0.0217850357,
0.012097314,
0.0157747883,
-0.0280323792,
0.0216235425,
0.0348244943,
-0.0012858154,
0.0139674768,
0.0440285727,
0.0178291239,
-0.0271546599,
-0.0038045072,
-0.0016346113,
-0.0307227615,
-0.0046051522,
-0.0661751032,
0.0111788763,
0.0008059801,
-0.0522144064,
0.0089850165,
0.0459987447,
0.0620762818,
-0.0123134935,
0.0208123941,
0.0249434374,
-0.0094896462,
-0.0137939844,
0.0091333278,
-0.0213173255,
0.0169640854,
0.0574301928,
0.0039017848,
0.0019858154,
-0.0293363165,
0.015243385,
-0.0426763222,
-0.0083224559,
-0.0179961193,
0.0745911002,
-0.0417683721,
0.0098486152,
-0.0401682481,
-0.0331373177,
0.0150318081,
-0.0217747614,
-0.0344438776,
0.047539521,
0.0052253725,
0.0192285124,
0.0662637576,
-0.0304216295,
0.0625505522,
0.0281643588,
0.0458040126,
0.0914625823,
0.0653549805,
-0.002269594,
0.0653677359,
-0.0123945987,
0.0012352007,
-0.0384481363,
-0.0106096966,
-0.0069697401,
0.078269124,
0.0595543534,
0.0530720875,
0.0113868667,
0.01790509,
-0.0005199412,
0.0529791713,
-0.0954743326,
0.0246237218,
0.0196675453,
0.0285801161,
-0.0274639763,
0.0243181363,
-0.0683510378,
-0.0023678599,
-0.051585447,
-0.0115885055,
0.0200628508,
0.0209540352,
-0.0511337556,
0.0337504521,
0.032449685,
-0.0279278085,
0.0139953448,
-0.0362385996,
-0.0129423905,
0.0539126471,
-0.0213952512,
-0.0125270234,
0.0103464536,
-0.0461022295,
0.0412581675,
0.0286095105,
0.0369636938,
0.0051157651,
0.0625368431,
0.0240468346,
-0.0138720162,
-0.0002335884,
-0.0082056187,
-0.0202661902,
-0.0504133962,
-0.0016434012,
0.0119554652,
0.0264682788,
-0.0846119672,
0.0022289867,
-0.0262395851,
0.0296891481,
-0.0166830234,
-0.0407395214,
0.0298946016,
0.0372303464,
-0.0208973512,
0.0505476855,
0.0014040926,
-0.0268061478,
0.0113843381,
-0.0421426892,
-0.0505256057,
0.0229770746,
2.249e-7,
0.0031148396,
0.0377819501,
0.0200824812,
0.0085509755,
0.0163042136,
0.04102448,
-0.024918627,
0.0064376551,
0.0051274202,
-0.0553076565,
0.0461314768,
0.0267377645,
0.0339494981,
-0.0281426162,
-0.0523063801,
0.0090905968,
-0.0505556948,
-0.0343882293,
-0.0384735949,
-0.0468995087,
0.0807187706,
0.0853061825,
-0.0429759547,
-0.0260001328,
0.0031373142,
-0.0994370952,
0.0922194868,
-0.0443040133,
-0.0267059784,
-0.0059303665,
0.0186141506,
0.0665367916,
-0.063042663,
0.0281689931,
-0.0332469121,
-0.0161919817,
0.0860332698,
0.0424263999,
-0.0403799042,
-0.0085598519,
-0.030805869,
0.0578875914,
0.0006406845,
-0.0400852188,
0.0580139607,
-0.0507575572,
0.0001924622,
-0.0444350652,
-0.0050296239,
0.0114361327,
0.0409389921,
-0.0580754466,
-0.0397452377,
0.0377092324,
0.0335478149,
0.006555581,
-0.037913505,
-0.0809390396,
-0.0281736869,
-0.0100848181,
-0.0277525391,
-0.0332418866,
-0.0562068596,
-0.0119228708,
0.0167603251,
-0.0290070623,
-0.0077949553,
1.669360854e-34,
0.0557049289,
-0.0136337504,
0.0141754216,
-0.0022477687,
0.0344908759,
0.0119427927,
-0.0277289059,
-0.0077904202,
-0.0055170651,
-0.0708636492,
0.0092456266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11585v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11585v2 | FAIR: A Causal Framework for Accurately Inferring Judgments Reversals | 2023-06-20T15:02:25 | 2023-07-20T14:31:10 | Minghua He, Nanfei Gu, Yuntao Shi, Qionghui Zhang, Yaying Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Artificial intelligence researchers have made significant advances in legal
intelligence in recent years. However, the existing studies have not focused on
the important value embedded in judgments reversals, which limits the
improvement of the efficiency of legal intelligence. In this paper, we propose
a causal Framework for Accurately Inferring case Reversals (FAIR), which models
the problem of judgments reversals based on real Chinese judgments. We mine the
causes of judgments reversals by causal inference methods and inject the
obtained causal relationships into the neural network as a priori knowledge.
And then, our framework is validated on a challenging dataset as a legal
judgment prediction task. The experimental results show that our framework can
tap the most critical factors in judgments reversal, and the obtained causal
relationships can effectively improve the neural network's performance. In
addition, we discuss the generalization ability of large language models for
legal intelligence tasks using ChatGPT as an example. Our experiment has found
that the generalization ability of large language models still has defects, and
mining causal relationships can effectively improve the accuracy and explain
ability of model predictions. | [
0.042721767,
0.0724167526,
-0.0493887886,
0.0055968352,
-0.0654106811,
0.0181690138,
-0.0006908071,
0.0222795866,
0.0321648344,
-0.0341258347,
-0.011365233,
-0.0001459062,
-0.0212718938,
0.0030546063,
0.0020165222,
-0.0186966993,
0.0463089421,
0.0274788141,
0.0869791731,
-0.0095799975,
0.0253519956,
-0.0051977546,
0.0072957682,
0.0190805718,
-0.0388218313,
0.0042759175,
0.0052471077,
-0.013845236,
-0.0089219939,
-0.000067197,
-0.0025775291,
0.0631603375,
-0.0050415494,
0.0292886104,
0.0000019332,
-0.0395665355,
-0.0101057049,
-0.0281162076,
-0.0008578132,
0.0239977203,
-0.0075215953,
-0.0019356041,
-0.0154245496,
0.018926179,
-0.0674017221,
0.0297350343,
0.0114169391,
0.0603112131,
0.0305583663,
0.0861685276,
0.0039938395,
-0.0447686054,
0.0234568454,
-0.0526992492,
0.0080452496,
-0.0617279671,
0.0185382701,
0.0172744989,
-0.0307642054,
-0.058519654,
-0.0131543772,
-0.0147620924,
0.0440724865,
0.0049317083,
-0.0588302724,
-0.0081257196,
-0.0182700157,
0.024330819,
0.0060217399,
0.059989769,
0.0617779233,
-0.0441053435,
-0.015416258,
-0.0052793943,
0.0660692677,
0.0569427125,
-0.0356213748,
0.0658756495,
-0.0124936551,
0.0407087393,
0.0436701849,
0.0287002791,
0.0358099118,
0.0312386081,
-0.0236527808,
0.0909563303,
-0.0096625369,
-0.0458525531,
-0.0025660882,
0.0417678729,
0.0189883243,
-0.0015564094,
0.0093870284,
0.0041744052,
-0.0320386887,
0.0375435278,
0.0458020084,
0.0037909942,
0.0120263845,
-0.071782805,
0.0021734498,
0.0174413528,
-0.0213387255,
0.0512724705,
-0.0539320372,
0.0325249396,
-0.0065388028,
0.0498293489,
-0.0180292539,
-0.0424334705,
-0.0339362733,
-0.0202081483,
-0.0075902394,
0.0235250462,
-0.0408489741,
0.0352876633,
-0.0531474017,
-0.0212876778,
-0.0617695786,
-0.0143594872,
-0.0031691778,
0.0294577125,
0.0002818703,
-0.0207966454,
-0.07903447,
-0.0266889688,
-0.0406855345,
0.0699579343,
-0.0120733967,
0.0235841814,
0.0056186346,
-0.0056675747,
-0.0013901381,
0.0222385079,
-0.0017210273,
0.1390511841,
0.00216268,
-0.0025417414,
-0.0670391843,
-0.0565335155,
-0.0175357386,
-0.0577608794,
0.0082995361,
-0.0383841582,
-0.0026689915,
-0.0104012601,
-0.0277109835,
-0.0604725778,
0.0155559331,
0.0133045185,
-0.0464537591,
0.0720144212,
0.0528902411,
-0.0256682262,
-0.0518303886,
0.0088155353,
-0.0023974043,
0.0059054312,
-0.0011245757,
0.044100225,
0.0275594518,
-0.0125519335,
0.0398963429,
0.0172044132,
0.0360353999,
0.0051806802,
-0.0360625833,
-0.0279373322,
-0.0122989891,
-0.014915525,
-0.003135643,
0.0185023379,
-0.0032907759,
-0.0036926735,
0.048746556,
0.0113216136,
-0.017511623,
0.0489627384,
0.0088227903,
-0.0584170111,
-0.0235652663,
0.0312526338,
-0.080863066,
0.0346137956,
-0.0572274141,
-0.0107044615,
-0.0557398461,
-0.0206435136,
-0.0465926491,
-0.0627832562,
0.0208572559,
0.0225786325,
0.0592831522,
0.0115202377,
0.045697026,
0.0219846163,
-0.0184948742,
-0.0026793687,
0.0574755818,
-0.0577512681,
-0.0342273936,
-0.0549620986,
0.0156295486,
0.0533944108,
0.0380254313,
-0.0038926371,
0.0075459871,
0.0031219164,
-0.0493104197,
0.0111571159,
0.0398742072,
-0.0249111783,
-0.0518124811,
-0.0175713897,
-0.0165246949,
0.0588431507,
0.0499337688,
0.0343921371,
-0.0196555778,
-0.0021820997,
0.0369571708,
-0.0365983658,
0.0172029529,
0.0307269916,
-0.0328771584,
-0.0282912701,
0.0222950894,
0.0189588554,
0.054226324,
0.0102309436,
0.0040150741,
-0.0001061279,
0.0318005979,
0.002108963,
-0.0592140369,
0.0857192576,
-0.0034263576,
-0.0333865546,
0.0208487418,
-0.0763654113,
0.00323369,
0.0256122015,
-0.0498547517,
-0.040432021,
0.0442475602,
0.0037387377,
0.0097591374,
-0.0445614979,
0.0126729198,
-0.0042900755,
-0.0349551141,
-0.0190100744,
0.0529184751,
-0.0097861802,
-0.0021184648,
-0.0385161676,
-0.02506621,
0.0215529725,
-0.0106474925,
-0.0216386113,
-0.0607001819,
-0.0166010745,
0.0031831129,
0.0403144322,
-0.0026980273,
-0.0066126827,
-0.0238108076,
-0.0555697829,
0.0020700668,
-0.0227043666,
-0.0245460682,
0.0064126942,
-0.0320873298,
0.0094440822,
-0.0321825966,
-0.0121586397,
0.0127515811,
0.0014424918,
0.0087157283,
0.0159331411,
-0.0415049754,
-0.018923277,
-0.0238664765,
-0.0255125277,
-0.0780627429,
0.0153584676,
0.0168245677,
-0.0159715377,
-0.0178189408,
0.0346046016,
0.0053899381,
0.0082766628,
-0.0606093407,
-0.0377011076,
-0.0055387034,
0.0154126873,
-0.0279831868,
0.0419056378,
0.0412896909,
0.0099191675,
0.0266620927,
-0.0086114649,
-0.0396098346,
0.0010309534,
-0.0320163555,
0.0150149642,
-0.0137915332,
-0.0552006699,
-0.0185162891,
0.0556554124,
0.0368641429,
-0.024790816,
-0.0339933746,
0.0001594171,
-0.0005645241,
-0.0205026995,
-0.0189650673,
-0.0158647727,
-0.0070960741,
0.0498541147,
-0.0004842655,
-0.0675738901,
0.0578183308,
0.0304094888,
0.0737894103,
-0.0219762381,
0.0139682954,
-0.0331324935,
0.0859720409,
0.0273914486,
-0.0079278238,
-0.0048909993,
-0.0199787859,
-0.0306358151,
-0.013905948,
0.0480744503,
0.0065805982,
0.0446208529,
-0.0631788298,
0.025801437,
-0.0210921913,
-0.0555605628,
-0.0485058613,
-0.0534160361,
-0.0027699149,
0.0235382132,
0.0301467404,
0.0072441748,
-0.0166787282,
-0.0014428741,
-0.027299067,
-0.0066811573,
-0.0075593768,
0.0018207118,
-0.040370658,
-0.0383327007,
-0.0016361062,
-0.0411093496,
0.029840501,
-0.0210705139,
-0.0116638234,
0.0109138424,
-0.0168263093,
0.0172624364,
0.0269275643,
0.0041359928,
-0.0195288882,
-0.0283419508,
0.0069427458,
0.0422547795,
-0.01446121,
-0.0416781902,
0.0345911831,
0.0566521659,
0.0243732166,
-0.0246852022,
-0.0038020229,
0.0385311171,
-0.047458712,
0.0376421288,
-0.0211330596,
-0.0828714445,
-0.0224614125,
0.0063374871,
-0.0351118967,
-0.0375674479,
-0.0552429296,
0.0260669962,
-0.1058570817,
0.0838507116,
0.0209005009,
-0.0113108028,
-0.0573754497,
-0.0061310325,
-0.0188501459,
-0.0459178314,
-0.0009731441,
-0.0010033032,
0.0143170618,
-0.0112255746,
0.0012652116,
-0.016736038,
0.0466652028,
0.0290741436,
-0.0354871377,
0.0484602302,
0.0444614142,
0.0637124404,
-0.0354150534,
-0.013872629,
-0.0143087097,
0.0191016402,
0.0169730261,
0.0160135776,
0.0715689361,
0.0099604288,
0.0140825072,
-0.047232952,
0.0472985618,
-0.0060122903,
-0.0058727884,
0.0407752544,
0.0470772386,
-0.0514175259,
-0.0389845259,
-0.0166362561,
-0.0040818187,
-0.0135149891,
0.0883186534,
-0.0116034457,
-0.018463986,
-0.0470147282,
-0.0445696525,
-0.0521831289,
-0.0506115295,
-0.0379650109,
-0.0046083876,
0.0390482806,
-0.0010311216,
-0.0505392179,
-0.0166043043,
-0.0304879565,
0.0020283868,
0.0143410498,
-0.0073473337,
0.0565582514,
-0.0138871707,
-0.0621026158,
0.0088236285,
-0.020855004,
-0.0142964395,
-0.0234421529,
0.0100823874,
0.0065671895,
-0.0390425846,
-0.0092534581,
0.0122922668,
0.0004580144,
-0.0039882315,
0.0191420577,
0.0310923774,
0.0105803777,
0.0200899318,
-0.0501571558,
0.0004465807,
0.0061382758,
0.0317790173,
-0.0243454706,
-0.0068242857,
0.0768066719,
-0.0130584994,
-0.0053831213,
0.0161765348,
-0.0095362989,
0.0416075327,
0.0678400621,
-0.0071298159,
-0.023542447,
0.0015475563,
0.0519760959,
0.0292752907,
0.0655680969,
0.0116068022,
-0.0078453124,
-0.0560779423,
0.00736626,
-0.022293089,
-0.0268395767,
-0.0178430118,
-0.01834042,
0.0329468399,
0.0129539641,
-0.0610074624,
0.0098457979,
-0.0196132287,
-0.0438837148,
-0.0460444652,
0.0262553468,
0.0436891131,
0.0279240496,
-0.0208983049,
-0.0215095282,
0.0169380493,
0.0063300328,
0.0064960644,
0.0443643406,
-0.0029076883,
0.0733046532,
0.0262497403,
0.0194108058,
-0.0519353598,
-0.0266679768,
-0.0717670023,
-0.0042676022,
0.0127720321,
0.0436924659,
0.0662486777,
-0.0258795209,
-0.0350786746,
-0.048550427,
0.0119628655,
0.0148065919,
0.0597655848,
0.010061508,
-0.0111921243,
0.032331612,
0.0017278033,
-0.033675354,
-0.0178203266,
0.0501051396,
-0.011844784,
0.0349236764,
-0.0323056616,
-0.0493848883,
0.0036994778,
-0.0439479351,
0.0256317314,
-0.0086528612,
-0.0231210273,
-0.0170233194,
-0.0939002335,
-0.0372635052,
-0.0610680319,
0.0110431332,
0.0285045151,
0.0135490336,
-0.0060675913,
0.0770551413,
0.0041520102,
-0.0174700413,
-0.0291856714,
0.0224217996,
-0.039550256,
0.0077924011,
-0.0359795615,
-5.777381716e-33,
-0.0292827487,
-0.040284615,
0.0085520623,
0.0279190019,
0.0460851714,
-0.0533061363,
-0.0127645917,
0.0010564578,
-0.0391106829,
0.0490309,
-0.0191166587,
0.0516629294,
0.0193788894,
-0.0093646618,
0.04315947,
-0.013375462,
0.01526256,
0.0143599994,
0.0237447638,
0.0025030449,
0.0291214511,
0.0231245328,
0.0596087724,
-0.1110478938,
0.0234693959,
0.0330538303,
-0.0196301453,
-0.0024544275,
-0.0999023095,
0.0291417539,
0.0267378725,
0.0313045345,
0.0457103662,
-0.0697721243,
0.0174729079,
0.0339403488,
-0.0547068641,
0.00072657,
0.0223100893,
-0.0068229875,
0.0120027466,
-0.035012152,
0.0254753772,
0.002101806,
-0.009538861,
0.0299834032,
0.0460305922,
-0.021468835,
0.01454347,
-0.0062937238,
-0.0770807043,
0.0269309822,
-0.01959089,
0.0010712903,
-0.0107092233,
0.0026211096,
-0.0123401536,
0.013296864,
-0.0492875502,
0.0384585634,
-0.0097750043,
-0.0197140425,
0.0040221978,
-0.0104321828,
-0.0102371164,
0.0606672354,
0.0214296915,
0.0307170916,
-0.0568377376,
-0.0202974603,
0.0244188104,
0.0944135636,
0.0665990859,
0.0629785731,
0.0626681969,
-0.0712184459,
-0.1159176007,
-0.0282998085,
0.0485129021,
-0.0020368937,
0.0440614186,
-0.0191179458,
-0.070917666,
-0.0276122969,
-0.0310540386,
-0.0619971789,
-0.0250663385,
0.0108007314,
0.0213986728,
0.0161290206,
0.0449439399,
-0.078111656,
0.0108203022,
-0.071616061,
0.0550780222,
0.0508789346,
-0.033830706,
-0.016403228,
-0.0204179753,
0.0138446866,
-0.0673386082,
-0.0284233335,
-0.0096070021,
0.0098080337,
0.01505474,
0.0083889933,
0.087986581,
-0.0230825245,
-0.0123790968,
-0.003162594,
0.0028938944,
-0.0033775829,
0.03053567,
-0.0118634412,
0.0192393307,
0.0433118865,
0.010219506,
-0.0235317852,
0.0209196974,
0.0477478169,
-0.0466803908,
-0.0428690091,
-0.0088758115,
-0.0114046978,
-0.0019067517,
-0.0197774917,
0.0062317499,
0.026032187,
0.0048133619,
-0.0299403854,
-0.0076094368,
0.0621537678,
2.645e-7,
0.0628052577,
0.0177397337,
-0.0173342638,
0.046603892,
0.0137759577,
0.051367607,
-0.0035299626,
0.0119821187,
0.0535009727,
0.0215397272,
0.0641954169,
0.0259062275,
0.0522722155,
0.0535223223,
-0.0704184473,
-0.031400919,
-0.0275538824,
-0.054518573,
0.0154754436,
0.0394527502,
0.0348582044,
0.0773518011,
0.0300532728,
0.0068666544,
0.0217594486,
-0.0078562582,
0.0338562243,
-0.0114896121,
0.0004232562,
-0.0070280456,
0.0376187824,
-0.0535690039,
-0.0275462847,
0.0714606941,
0.0088664657,
0.0520461649,
-0.03572331,
0.0267931651,
-0.0188823044,
0.0090544615,
-0.0438705981,
-0.0296369735,
0.0346252844,
0.000406855,
0.0567522608,
-0.0248719137,
-0.0336769596,
0.006489791,
0.007735054,
-0.0029729081,
0.0181509629,
0.0374314748,
-0.0047225389,
-0.001879778,
0.0295681544,
0.0102573484,
0.0149950879,
-0.1055925786,
-0.0205736458,
0.043782305,
-0.0111754443,
-0.0223317873,
0.0220044032,
-0.0153803825,
0.0528703332,
-0.0823599473,
0.0318920687,
2.060353004e-34,
0.0284111388,
0.0181367956,
0.0002464326,
-0.0036474725,
0.0610893182,
0.008734473,
-0.0275963917,
0.0173710007,
0.0085584195,
-0.0528617203,
0.0010255484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11559v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11559v1 | The Ecological Fallacy in Annotation: Modelling Human Label Variation goes beyond Sociodemographics | 2023-06-20T14:23:32 | 2023-06-20T14:23:32 | Matthias Orlikowski, Paul Röttger, Philipp Cimiano, Dirk Hovy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many NLP tasks exhibit human label variation, where different annotators give
different labels to the same texts. This variation is known to depend, at least
in part, on the sociodemographics of annotators. Recent research aims to model
individual annotator behaviour rather than predicting aggregated labels, and we
would expect that sociodemographic information is useful for these models. On
the other hand, the ecological fallacy states that aggregate group behaviour,
such as the behaviour of the average female annotator, does not necessarily
explain individual behaviour. To account for sociodemographics in models of
individual annotator behaviour, we introduce group-specific layers to
multi-annotator models. In a series of experiments for toxic content detection,
we find that explicitly accounting for sociodemographic attributes in this way
does not significantly improve model performance. This result shows that
individual annotation behaviour depends on much more than just
sociodemographics. | [
0.0748534277,
0.0108263604,
-0.0420779064,
-0.0004058917,
-0.0064935167,
0.0466162637,
0.0455913059,
-0.0079102674,
0.0172855482,
-0.0949107111,
-0.0068275598,
0.0321449302,
-0.0361493081,
-0.0286768153,
0.042741783,
-0.0446825549,
0.0160215814,
0.0032677189,
0.0286812596,
0.0034785187,
0.0538030192,
-0.0019621411,
0.0403917432,
0.0382531919,
-0.0296012349,
-0.0171397831,
0.0496756583,
0.0052979537,
0.0449411124,
-0.0093498277,
0.0530000329,
0.0733877048,
-0.0076174168,
0.0479007587,
0.0000016953,
-0.0024675904,
-0.0178166274,
0.0234859604,
-0.0059174821,
0.0031072276,
0.046835646,
-0.0030434572,
-0.020312041,
0.014043171,
-0.0346981175,
-0.0135196066,
0.045295909,
0.0295333695,
0.0518548898,
0.0323044062,
-0.0208090581,
-0.0092859026,
-0.0145017225,
0.0120852925,
0.0061780992,
-0.0063059274,
0.0431782976,
0.0024294243,
-0.0026188919,
0.0678344741,
-0.0077323411,
0.0449738242,
0.0015311484,
0.0071215322,
0.0331422761,
0.0131768472,
0.0171549842,
-0.0365224257,
0.0134373214,
0.0414169356,
0.0186297856,
0.0032507968,
0.0226895977,
-0.0172024164,
0.033806514,
0.0353561975,
-0.0166193508,
0.0357665345,
-0.0186821166,
-0.0107357176,
0.0187710449,
0.0565007143,
0.0080087567,
0.0299006011,
0.052674558,
0.0791843832,
-0.0262874886,
-0.0248104576,
0.0087400228,
0.0151324309,
-0.0212911237,
-0.0264543388,
0.0253498945,
-0.0266500991,
0.0073108436,
0.0095001161,
-0.026184842,
-0.0615319051,
0.0486674011,
-0.1020880789,
0.027706936,
-0.0003782921,
-0.0480306186,
0.0279910378,
0.0304861479,
-0.0005326407,
-0.0032358808,
0.044382181,
-0.006567569,
-0.0087076332,
-0.0629192516,
-0.0289414041,
-0.0063982364,
0.0286769178,
-0.0067917113,
0.0080802515,
-0.0356734954,
0.0129986228,
-0.045832105,
-0.0516296402,
-0.026875589,
0.0134331444,
-0.021287987,
0.0441097356,
0.0273263156,
-0.0132528823,
-0.051221393,
0.0321064219,
-0.0034355458,
-0.0271011703,
0.028766552,
0.0221660361,
-0.0191225279,
-0.0342837237,
-0.0276905335,
0.049328275,
0.0140073262,
-0.0055515422,
-0.0508935712,
-0.0373644643,
-0.0301732924,
-0.0180548336,
0.0054738307,
-0.0312911794,
0.0161839016,
0.0151528744,
0.0161101073,
-0.0551372692,
-0.0297858305,
0.0248572975,
-0.0359172411,
0.0779511929,
0.037497852,
-0.0281392541,
0.0785268098,
0.0240560044,
-0.0187803041,
0.0814613476,
0.0377702489,
0.0030621013,
0.0347253345,
-0.0109304097,
0.002555483,
0.0330486968,
0.0016313011,
0.009354203,
0.0376214087,
-0.0454319827,
-0.0071484367,
-0.0196017101,
0.0508856401,
0.0510662794,
-0.0288741663,
-0.0518702827,
0.0653423816,
0.0525142141,
0.005585534,
-0.0014959604,
0.0345724896,
0.0256248284,
-0.0277470183,
0.0381272025,
-0.038868621,
0.0335770398,
-0.0412662737,
-0.0447195061,
-0.0022055933,
-0.0134178866,
-0.0229227468,
-0.0421975888,
-0.0622987412,
0.0318682492,
0.0700313747,
-0.0377242565,
-0.0052848542,
0.0093754828,
0.0270335171,
0.0050653573,
0.0435882322,
-0.0391294397,
-0.0136082508,
-0.0317872986,
0.0204523597,
0.0382629149,
-0.0149125038,
-0.014602188,
0.0234182179,
-0.0318773203,
0.0122758141,
0.0251934789,
0.0248068441,
-0.0358713828,
-0.049423907,
-0.0218002591,
-0.0342585295,
0.0048701959,
0.0260782838,
-0.001318577,
0.0285596717,
-0.0313208699,
0.0096556898,
-0.0147914775,
-0.0583175756,
0.0662254915,
-0.0002886669,
-0.0107022952,
-0.0557741933,
0.0135722337,
0.0474969409,
0.0050379843,
-0.0053088274,
0.0081643695,
-0.0017635197,
-0.0120833488,
-0.0372989066,
-0.0338368267,
0.0241972972,
-0.0088347634,
-0.0144131007,
-0.0479090586,
-0.0214393549,
0.0003329858,
0.0039267829,
-0.0090377778,
-0.0355140455,
-0.0677761659,
0.0300592259,
-0.0254137125,
-0.0537333451,
-0.001840618,
0.0002360008,
-0.056114044,
0.046842698,
-0.0065779374,
-0.021612037,
-0.0220316313,
-0.022229908,
-0.0168100856,
-0.0378722958,
-0.0280211587,
-0.0648380369,
0.0214664415,
0.0215636976,
0.0411586165,
-0.025870584,
-0.0393452458,
-0.0196075197,
-0.0643960834,
-0.0188134182,
-0.0145968553,
-0.0049904152,
0.0047581876,
-0.0228634551,
0.001966727,
-0.0175209325,
-0.0237467512,
-0.0280112289,
-0.0487812422,
0.0933425054,
0.0143134482,
-0.0261163712,
0.0230970941,
-0.0371351764,
-0.0241709165,
-0.0522086546,
0.0522522032,
0.031629879,
-0.1049530283,
-0.0197885279,
-0.0107579986,
-0.0342749134,
-0.015308233,
-0.0010357829,
-0.0139334127,
0.0226204097,
0.0602590889,
0.0079171909,
0.0749848634,
0.0138584459,
0.0784670338,
0.0300230607,
0.0367284454,
-0.061667081,
-0.0144281499,
-0.0204854645,
0.0182165932,
0.0126181245,
-0.0820168033,
0.0038077636,
0.0843715519,
-0.0220327098,
-0.0187632907,
-0.0423511788,
0.0480161197,
-0.0861224085,
-0.044000078,
-0.0265092663,
-0.0550255217,
0.0003585266,
0.0230602659,
-0.0201520398,
-0.0456619561,
0.0690007657,
0.0466492884,
0.0000064005,
-0.0118775554,
0.0026512572,
-0.0087180901,
0.0425740778,
0.0211623143,
0.0205808412,
0.0691733733,
-0.0238366798,
-0.0211492721,
0.0167879313,
0.0766128525,
-0.0143320719,
0.007014818,
-0.0287532806,
0.0169371106,
0.0172287915,
-0.0546863638,
-0.0150227975,
-0.0686277822,
-0.0233297441,
0.0270143021,
0.0272986367,
-0.0006270289,
-0.037270356,
0.0252126474,
0.0174240638,
-0.0180717018,
-0.0082276864,
-0.0135830361,
0.0152027057,
0.0170789119,
0.0298945718,
-0.0098780133,
-0.0018185915,
-0.037945386,
-0.0226474963,
0.0765873045,
-0.0222738497,
0.0014169289,
-0.0056658681,
0.0307338927,
0.0284136962,
-0.0012764768,
-0.0538068116,
-0.0025755099,
0.0133404844,
-0.0417159013,
0.0311022997,
0.0600906163,
0.0261296742,
-0.0180610269,
0.0230654832,
0.0164712463,
0.0504282787,
0.0146571351,
0.0124619314,
-0.0477454364,
-0.0049561071,
-0.0062037469,
0.0001857531,
-0.0672623664,
-0.038297765,
0.0194456391,
-0.0578580201,
0.0227036066,
0.0161175486,
-0.0843946263,
0.0576495677,
-0.0493630357,
0.0071354192,
-0.0617193803,
0.0066000684,
-0.0211355221,
0.0178905074,
-0.0074127805,
0.0659661293,
-0.0799431875,
-0.0300474279,
0.0260963719,
-0.0301791355,
0.0681223944,
0.0417570807,
0.0131582208,
-0.0296110474,
-0.0344536863,
0.0527139455,
0.0129075916,
0.0055945106,
-0.0154730575,
0.0885896459,
-0.0478591733,
0.0128289629,
-0.0519971438,
0.0375528261,
0.0033719675,
-0.0149426945,
-0.0517818555,
0.0439596698,
0.0475821979,
-0.0362415835,
-0.0533777699,
0.0072454237,
-0.0073978854,
0.065210849,
0.008214755,
-0.0573803633,
-0.0173824318,
-0.0392325036,
-0.0130853858,
-0.0159444734,
-0.0603711344,
0.0388468094,
-0.0501607396,
-0.0954980999,
-0.0454085693,
-0.0684279725,
0.0230295602,
-0.0038030951,
0.0078938399,
-0.0215280876,
0.0338472873,
-0.0206988994,
-0.0242647268,
0.0409674011,
0.0144870374,
-0.0027623416,
0.0230542608,
-0.0443414152,
0.0502875298,
0.0180462562,
-0.0415529422,
0.0320175327,
-0.0522731282,
-0.0663271695,
0.0628653318,
0.0238740351,
0.0197110791,
0.0291161146,
0.001517438,
-0.1152796745,
0.050330963,
0.016482003,
0.0121619683,
0.0361582153,
0.0179464426,
-0.032658577,
-0.0001298022,
0.0214530863,
-0.0200469662,
0.0473717339,
0.0493698567,
-0.0017055876,
-0.0956056863,
-0.0023505404,
0.0229533762,
-0.0259610992,
0.0263924766,
-0.0248838905,
0.0029543843,
-0.022257762,
-0.0509761721,
0.0150100235,
-0.0377793051,
-0.0010255907,
-0.0205637366,
0.0062495316,
-0.0144112604,
-0.0526618809,
0.03166629,
-0.0174053889,
0.0596021116,
-0.0632194355,
-0.00187505,
0.0557548404,
-0.0179351624,
-0.0183087084,
0.033395879,
-0.0174700636,
0.0197074898,
0.0120569458,
0.0275672823,
0.0271541271,
0.0147593301,
0.0174110886,
0.0271317307,
-0.0082871439,
0.0190732293,
-0.0642434359,
0.0459589772,
-0.0226845052,
-0.0118458103,
-0.014438143,
-0.0324504897,
0.0399367549,
-0.01093842,
-0.0325948521,
-0.0072523528,
-0.0006261388,
-0.0080361087,
-0.0198143888,
0.0222166814,
0.0103043765,
-0.015884202,
-0.014574185,
0.0669046044,
0.0597567745,
0.007829749,
-0.0413473621,
-0.051564198,
-0.0260036662,
0.0345218144,
0.0247482415,
0.0351953506,
-0.0152711421,
0.0057968311,
-0.08137732,
-0.0550667532,
0.0184063762,
-0.0233651455,
0.0575372092,
0.0234755483,
0.0194482356,
0.0739938468,
-0.0075693266,
-0.0887216702,
-0.0435128398,
-0.0258430038,
-0.00046511,
0.0156971235,
-0.0102941366,
-6.006417607e-33,
-0.0377713069,
-0.0697606206,
-0.0137071647,
0.0493587852,
0.0277486462,
0.0181235112,
0.0175648499,
0.0282726679,
0.012472719,
0.0426923148,
0.0143670021,
0.0265294313,
0.015866993,
-0.0120774135,
0.0650566593,
-0.0215828158,
0.0358788744,
-0.0074022235,
-0.0197400078,
-0.0223048031,
0.0187779181,
0.0102110207,
0.001913077,
-0.1040963978,
0.0873841047,
0.0191074107,
-0.0145367058,
-0.0245363601,
-0.0180701688,
0.0770351663,
-0.0192711763,
0.0638854206,
0.0430310108,
-0.0064255768,
-0.0051815589,
0.0703242496,
-0.0822677836,
-0.0311019886,
0.0191286467,
0.0040669856,
-0.0338623337,
-0.0375807472,
0.061046686,
-0.0175700299,
-0.0255139228,
-0.0214417502,
0.0744079724,
-0.0050108624,
-0.0015200129,
-0.03094377,
-0.052767586,
0.0333077982,
0.0014557529,
0.0144098783,
0.03049336,
0.0215931721,
-0.0000866588,
0.0199330281,
-0.0904432237,
0.0402194522,
-0.0593269765,
-0.0278011914,
0.0172833018,
0.0487670824,
0.0040373672,
0.041420646,
0.0265443642,
0.0861663744,
-0.0365952887,
-0.0289668553,
0.009761232,
-0.0060306136,
0.0451538414,
0.0177508481,
0.0043275072,
0.0131893903,
-0.0401996821,
0.0018968667,
0.0116496999,
-0.0341319852,
0.021357026,
0.0303012971,
-0.08192195,
-0.052053906,
-0.0291857328,
-0.0265089162,
-0.0158372372,
0.0048882449,
0.0062173973,
-0.0040993742,
-0.0506481193,
0.0309168175,
-0.0126890913,
-0.0392589644,
-0.0315601453,
-0.0531326607,
0.0087209968,
0.0401778892,
-0.0021454764,
0.0072787697,
-0.0498874448,
0.0073122508,
-0.0113301203,
0.0139535153,
0.0344596319,
-0.0072930893,
0.1087398157,
0.0092437053,
-0.0611187816,
-0.047512114,
0.0080507025,
-0.0113397986,
0.0182934385,
-0.0192091689,
0.0467874967,
0.0188357681,
-0.0034410947,
-0.0010912063,
0.0618315749,
0.0536615998,
-0.0001248499,
-0.0069823093,
-0.0498587713,
-0.0150287589,
0.0001813312,
-0.0245703142,
0.011185701,
0.0407112837,
0.0282805823,
-0.0367451124,
0.0074114017,
-0.0282746926,
2.422e-7,
0.0620928332,
0.0535961315,
0.006353315,
-0.0382229835,
0.0403143279,
0.0430131592,
0.039470382,
0.0480538011,
0.0129172076,
-0.0662774742,
-0.0210565161,
0.0127397459,
0.0199889317,
0.0404105112,
-0.0393371433,
-0.0274578333,
-0.0503456295,
0.015410319,
-0.0227846876,
0.0191547312,
0.0178506356,
0.0401267335,
0.042056147,
-0.0021991422,
-0.0221568719,
-0.0063633407,
0.0571159236,
-0.009958812,
0.0007133561,
0.0189635567,
0.0275851395,
0.0113225272,
0.023497453,
0.0995401293,
-0.0229596682,
-0.0311015844,
0.05711383,
0.0285477098,
-0.0387649685,
-0.0076472727,
-0.0048493939,
-0.0249253567,
0.005961664,
-0.0249606688,
0.0516392514,
-0.0217411462,
-0.0273871031,
-0.0271250382,
-0.0150436033,
0.0062359311,
0.0333750658,
-0.0185445324,
-0.0018235162,
-0.0112815574,
0.0107119381,
-0.0246241353,
-0.0158458054,
-0.0769265369,
-0.0327569023,
-0.0098915845,
-0.0360363014,
-0.0729243904,
-0.0102832923,
0.0391779654,
0.0251089018,
-0.0413812213,
-0.0253265854,
1.782922447e-34,
0.0034973568,
0.0146822371,
0.0212356839,
-0.0029931443,
-0.0001555999,
0.0349361189,
-0.023159368,
-0.0005567722,
0.031685885,
-0.040337678,
0.0087059513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11520v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11520v1 | Hallucination is the last thing you need | 2023-06-20T13:14:15 | 2023-06-20T13:14:15 | Shawn Curran, Sam Lansley, Oliver Bethell | cs.CL | cs.CL | The legal profession necessitates a multidimensional approach that involves
synthesizing an in-depth comprehension of a legal issue with insightful
commentary based on personal experience, combined with a comprehensive
understanding of pertinent legislation, regulation, and case law, in order to
deliver an informed legal solution. The present offering with generative AI
presents major obstacles in replicating this, as current models struggle to
integrate and navigate such a complex interplay of understanding, experience,
and fact-checking procedures. It is noteworthy that where generative AI outputs
understanding and experience, which reflect the aggregate of various subjective
views on similar topics, this often deflects the model's attention from the
crucial legal facts, thereby resulting in hallucination. Hence, this paper
delves into the feasibility of three independent LLMs, each focused on
understanding, experience, and facts, synthesising as one single ensemble model
to effectively counteract the current challenges posed by the existing
monolithic generative AI models. We introduce an idea of mutli-length
tokenisation to protect key information assets like common law judgements, and
finally we interrogate the most advanced publicly available models for legal
hallucination, with some interesting results. | [
0.0161524713,
0.0587695129,
-0.0107164802,
-0.0072740978,
-0.0617219135,
0.0225011371,
0.022402849,
-0.0114396838,
0.0015492258,
-0.0309449416,
0.0081497431,
-0.0359699614,
-0.0532121435,
-0.0055391048,
0.0143605983,
-0.0589688495,
0.0283378214,
-0.0034816831,
0.02711723,
-0.0199595671,
0.0086493511,
0.0025806124,
-0.0119419685,
0.0200895984,
-0.0567028187,
-0.0289900713,
-0.0310529899,
-0.0130452532,
0.0122696813,
0.0262991395,
-0.0511984639,
0.0627774745,
0.0222539492,
0.0365916975,
0.0000019911,
-0.050163582,
-0.0038134062,
-0.0147700319,
0.0312849134,
-0.0236556195,
0.0095630614,
0.017989751,
-0.0102299834,
-0.0010744933,
-0.0478946976,
0.035949152,
0.0061906078,
0.0369570218,
0.0462476052,
0.0785023123,
0.0111601958,
-0.0568708554,
0.0517116524,
-0.027908897,
0.0470467247,
-0.0176339746,
0.0300674159,
0.0176497828,
0.0083989594,
-0.0636608154,
0.0077908514,
-0.0021697164,
0.046078153,
-0.0380298793,
-0.0012866255,
0.0189646538,
-0.0303096324,
0.0023723659,
0.0006402942,
0.0103974165,
0.0348485596,
-0.0187640321,
0.0299500208,
0.0083650835,
0.089994669,
-0.0104720769,
-0.020187268,
0.1034926921,
-0.0408449583,
0.0226721149,
0.0238855146,
0.0394389704,
0.0143938009,
0.0050242473,
-0.0391809009,
0.026251914,
-0.003784084,
-0.024022406,
-0.003861431,
0.0172638204,
0.0417329557,
-0.0678549707,
0.0208487418,
0.0514851473,
-0.0129612135,
0.0223158654,
-0.0269115511,
-0.0030882892,
0.0447501503,
-0.0412863716,
0.0057194787,
-0.0016909473,
-0.0413345471,
0.0655636117,
-0.0375797786,
-0.005818563,
-0.0247697011,
0.0627683923,
-0.0127571337,
-0.0252863597,
-0.0632253587,
-0.0173383933,
-0.0292248484,
0.0918173864,
-0.0792281479,
0.0033421195,
-0.0150052179,
0.0035696218,
-0.0665587783,
0.0466088019,
-0.0132756103,
0.0433656946,
0.0175154414,
-0.0388498418,
-0.0626071319,
-0.0630063564,
-0.0704493746,
0.0294987094,
0.0343099348,
-0.0286128893,
0.01299523,
0.0105650444,
-0.0152975079,
0.0480359457,
-0.0124301873,
0.0962607414,
0.0180747416,
0.0080341529,
-0.0315200128,
-0.0696021691,
-0.0112485941,
-0.0861527026,
-0.0031309766,
-0.0647537187,
0.0332725048,
-0.0554507896,
-0.0144400969,
-0.0797649771,
-0.0002625283,
0.0111233545,
0.0316482522,
0.0687835515,
-0.0237175636,
-0.0227270536,
-0.0147022819,
0.0588064939,
0.0171133652,
0.0141156679,
-0.0060376152,
0.0581251085,
-0.0048941239,
0.0147594586,
0.0977652371,
-0.020210566,
-0.0187360011,
0.0044250032,
-0.0058367662,
-0.016149953,
-0.0393948294,
0.0161098223,
0.0129281161,
0.0595858879,
-0.0310069229,
-0.0117270974,
0.0261843428,
0.038540706,
0.0032581212,
0.0963215381,
0.0646552369,
-0.0394532084,
0.0315784365,
0.049661506,
-0.0503866971,
0.0567658879,
-0.0018282335,
0.0143315783,
-0.0180988219,
0.0240370203,
-0.031777706,
-0.0841411427,
0.0364732146,
0.0006945981,
-0.0427770764,
-0.0028270786,
-0.0069854925,
0.0244814046,
0.0010330238,
0.0235329252,
0.0213004127,
-0.0473515391,
-0.0043989099,
-0.0581697598,
0.025478499,
0.0821996331,
0.0372914821,
-0.0472394973,
-0.0005602338,
-0.0322955251,
-0.0050652167,
0.0612251796,
0.0429170989,
-0.0129423533,
-0.0204375535,
-0.0339255221,
-0.020071758,
-0.0219872259,
0.0495615304,
0.0422935858,
-0.0380020402,
-0.0154654114,
0.0164826382,
-0.0454643518,
0.0162820332,
0.0301427431,
-0.0235593263,
-0.0126602938,
-0.0024985964,
-0.0207793005,
0.0297753364,
0.0375432447,
0.0021997683,
0.0282924902,
0.0171764269,
-0.0016263947,
-0.0357180424,
0.0331352763,
-0.0123335412,
0.0229561795,
0.0226617604,
-0.0565068647,
-0.002898874,
-0.0589903742,
-0.0296681374,
-0.0169881303,
-0.0522658788,
-0.0120822843,
0.0329865701,
-0.0710435212,
-0.0087061748,
0.0160081647,
-0.0128179844,
0.0095133642,
0.0754908398,
-0.043835979,
-0.0581183359,
-0.0053364653,
-0.0062136902,
0.0253988113,
-0.0175893176,
0.0024394654,
-0.0239605233,
0.0040955185,
0.0299970731,
-0.013555008,
-0.0351796411,
-0.0437783338,
-0.0452895276,
-0.0672090054,
0.0136861159,
-0.0202299114,
-0.0175101086,
0.0003803324,
-0.0571870543,
-0.0147034731,
0.0012260237,
-0.0422080047,
-0.0170665495,
-0.0069647538,
-0.0185523853,
0.0107453465,
-0.0061230278,
-0.0259382799,
0.01199836,
0.0058316216,
-0.0308131799,
0.0238690339,
0.0179614946,
-0.0273226574,
-0.0512686931,
0.0123578105,
-0.0571845584,
0.0021940526,
-0.0208966825,
0.023600487,
-0.0063246028,
0.0018219276,
0.0094903745,
0.0210530497,
0.0510266721,
0.0319400951,
0.0538780056,
0.0268360786,
-0.0301832054,
-0.0000763177,
-0.0068017319,
0.045863647,
-0.0078931162,
-0.0066038314,
0.0121067418,
-0.0051085288,
0.0128070358,
0.0142783877,
-0.0498944297,
0.0735917836,
0.0096859764,
-0.0639822334,
0.0110960156,
-0.0397628807,
-0.0360802971,
0.039715115,
0.0027848165,
-0.0453555696,
0.051841706,
0.03110696,
0.0764439628,
-0.0156713072,
0.026034493,
-0.0099512795,
0.086779274,
0.0040674312,
0.0236024838,
-0.0215965584,
-0.0146725802,
-0.0105974302,
-0.0018163369,
0.0339685827,
-0.051747717,
0.0397858433,
-0.0189730935,
0.0110329399,
0.0143924812,
-0.0403623283,
-0.049094867,
-0.0239876956,
0.004754337,
0.0361303724,
-0.005397446,
0.0157930125,
-0.0459333509,
-0.0268126465,
0.0012827229,
0.0106567703,
0.0199609213,
-0.0346247517,
-0.0347752199,
0.0075925328,
-0.0018574336,
-0.0244659688,
0.0380380042,
-0.0239950567,
0.0001651107,
0.0494817197,
0.0156018212,
0.0223023146,
-0.0007588189,
-0.0214893762,
-0.0173017625,
-0.0564538464,
-0.0106284395,
0.0442525037,
-0.011907775,
-0.0233240351,
0.0025843983,
0.0760626197,
0.0101400148,
-0.0343399383,
0.0049163746,
-0.0398811698,
-0.0010099077,
0.0186502039,
0.0068278238,
-0.1029216051,
0.0450570248,
-0.0031519623,
-0.0021181027,
-0.0534294695,
-0.0575929061,
-0.002605607,
-0.0718670487,
0.1013864726,
0.0253174771,
0.0064988597,
-0.0268962309,
0.0222122222,
-0.0116783697,
0.0099198725,
-0.0312753916,
-0.0021391301,
0.0117813526,
-0.017190991,
0.0318106301,
-0.0071605858,
0.0438938215,
0.0227515344,
-0.0366560668,
0.0602554977,
0.0546966642,
0.0427619405,
-0.007947051,
-0.0863033608,
-0.0163901579,
0.0320790485,
0.0261249356,
0.0427158289,
0.0425041467,
0.0095145293,
0.0231391564,
-0.0308878087,
0.043334879,
0.0053896406,
-0.0386651978,
0.0443183482,
0.06905628,
-0.0518971533,
-0.0579114407,
-0.0316449851,
-0.0021334419,
0.0120904613,
0.0670907572,
0.0284916218,
0.0026800577,
-0.0438365787,
-0.0246699415,
0.0145839965,
-0.0704709962,
-0.0252871476,
0.0049224733,
0.0409300216,
-0.0116549069,
-0.0384316966,
-0.0234173015,
-0.030538395,
0.085876286,
0.0039567468,
0.031409733,
-0.0097021284,
-0.0247545335,
0.0016667867,
-0.022699289,
-0.0548866354,
-0.0320471413,
0.0293020606,
-0.0174945369,
0.0106388768,
-0.008672257,
-0.0092626549,
-0.0021631278,
-0.002337341,
-0.0085311821,
0.0338566341,
0.0550273992,
0.0363569707,
0.0245046262,
-0.0332117081,
-0.0197994821,
0.0744798258,
0.0701431856,
0.0233498383,
0.0096267937,
0.0420911796,
-0.0145144099,
-0.0110123334,
0.0041418276,
0.0012990647,
0.0283406172,
0.0158349201,
-0.0000027431,
-0.0392474085,
0.0228191763,
0.0438189134,
0.0044421325,
-0.048111219,
-0.0254921578,
0.0076934686,
-0.018208934,
-0.0104466239,
-0.041096922,
-0.0110774031,
-0.0067542442,
-0.0283369515,
0.0401516072,
-0.0131797213,
-0.00786178,
0.0466916412,
-0.0149785383,
0.0202807002,
-0.0570360161,
0.0030737682,
0.0359124839,
-0.0023228251,
0.0096641341,
-0.056828022,
-0.0179381613,
0.031295225,
-0.0260902233,
0.0443862565,
-0.0133208223,
0.0424227156,
0.0114584146,
-0.0150742047,
-0.0110971853,
0.0195258912,
-0.0531064644,
-0.0717221871,
-0.0258806553,
0.1045859605,
0.044242207,
0.0444765054,
-0.0334197581,
-0.0226923674,
0.0036122377,
0.0282728951,
0.0080460599,
0.0311535299,
-0.0513052903,
-0.0178614501,
0.0190353487,
-0.0102314632,
-0.0455611311,
0.0354335532,
-0.0627737492,
0.048128508,
-0.0363350585,
-0.0170525648,
-0.0439313501,
-0.0722357109,
-0.0703696162,
0.0151439533,
0.0036172692,
-0.0586169884,
-0.1105493233,
-0.0138619319,
-0.0213447995,
0.0428602397,
0.0158825722,
0.0177566092,
0.0020735052,
0.0688632503,
0.0204422288,
-0.0232306477,
-0.0248907469,
0.043976102,
0.0278350972,
0.0050264439,
0.018073624,
-5.657468068e-33,
-0.0245149676,
-0.0440921076,
0.0333659723,
-0.0159998853,
-0.0260020457,
-0.0465720519,
-0.0070409612,
-0.0053666038,
0.0020988723,
0.0404746793,
-0.0130626932,
0.019115435,
0.0172734857,
-0.0272501614,
0.0126112159,
-0.0137490444,
0.0289846286,
-0.0012978001,
-0.0182154402,
0.032774359,
0.0003547322,
-0.0022547292,
-0.0212694667,
-0.0830046386,
0.0379005484,
0.0099016055,
-0.0529819466,
-0.0301252119,
-0.0922518596,
0.0406958871,
-0.0076632923,
0.022276856,
0.0163692404,
-0.0618559867,
-0.0172249973,
0.0188197494,
-0.0490744077,
-0.0110136159,
0.0173534136,
-0.0507133752,
-0.0268583857,
-0.0443160087,
0.0369280055,
0.0026999686,
-0.0069378172,
0.00306713,
0.0358260162,
-0.0381862633,
-0.0184889827,
-0.0963517055,
-0.0845960155,
0.0139318835,
-0.0071811015,
0.0286300723,
-0.0026304633,
-0.0242522769,
0.0158179644,
0.0064541246,
-0.0754447803,
0.0181228649,
-0.0255097989,
-0.0589394867,
0.0477494895,
-0.0753052533,
0.0051802723,
0.0656163692,
0.0394846499,
0.0253841598,
-0.1108827293,
-0.0031983822,
-0.0188783724,
0.096037291,
0.0430208966,
0.0466331542,
0.0060445839,
-0.0372615643,
-0.0421403088,
0.0122426059,
-0.0047416412,
0.0036761123,
0.0393864103,
-0.0196222793,
-0.024775045,
0.0184973367,
-0.0183105897,
-0.0676976517,
-0.0051838537,
-0.0020481874,
0.0016014689,
0.0121608358,
-0.0036965036,
-0.03240766,
-0.032715112,
-0.0434247479,
0.0386375561,
0.0271045547,
-0.0025738755,
0.0166079402,
-0.0206864476,
0.0021341117,
-0.0140633341,
-0.0452837795,
0.0129861031,
-0.0131824529,
0.0375587158,
-0.001938598,
0.0625013411,
-0.0315106325,
-0.0327789932,
-0.0080241114,
-0.0016429545,
0.0614694543,
0.0727555603,
-0.0270820726,
0.0242960025,
0.0244725328,
-0.0005609339,
-0.0375047475,
0.0222770162,
0.020784229,
-0.0104167927,
0.0300838426,
-0.018367257,
-0.004131835,
-0.0026697461,
0.0094014974,
0.0084809707,
0.0126832696,
0.0635829121,
-0.0120016076,
-0.0151600596,
0.0672533289,
2.705e-7,
0.0378988944,
-0.0119115189,
0.0139362654,
-0.0310706832,
0.0106286313,
0.0161891431,
0.0262779593,
0.0478370413,
0.0070547769,
-0.0651478767,
0.0024465208,
0.0310357586,
0.0112131657,
0.0617082827,
-0.0701648816,
-0.025395751,
-0.0051313289,
-0.004329884,
-0.0636373162,
0.0267838798,
0.0472646207,
0.0428006202,
0.0406223126,
-0.0254714228,
0.0233678501,
-0.0076052812,
0.0480977222,
0.0232874416,
0.0110856593,
0.0133433565,
0.105737783,
-0.0220908169,
0.0073208194,
0.0404225327,
0.0052157291,
0.0064874976,
-0.0237599853,
0.044555366,
0.0131509872,
0.0144824935,
0.0007201181,
-0.0263171215,
0.0550272912,
-0.0272790454,
0.0554126054,
0.0076893931,
-0.0036388247,
-0.0242016334,
-0.049376674,
-0.0018711354,
0.0175083578,
0.0365268327,
0.0088301059,
-0.0208225027,
0.0074221827,
0.0101222768,
0.0346372239,
-0.0918832198,
-0.0024362204,
-0.0042324327,
-0.0354337543,
0.003227127,
0.0200676583,
-0.0057819169,
0.0495123528,
-0.1025311723,
0.006746727,
2.088599536e-34,
0.0285406094,
0.0133722331,
0.0184610002,
0.03023009,
0.0195822231,
0.0448813587,
0.0146058416,
-0.0033301988,
0.0133983279,
-0.0134845804,
0.0073190238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11518v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11518v2 | One model to rule them all: ranking Slovene summarizers | 2023-06-20T13:12:58 | 2023-08-07T09:17:43 | Aleš Žagar, Marko Robnik-Šikonja | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text summarization is an essential task in natural language processing, and
researchers have developed various approaches over the years, ranging from
rule-based systems to neural networks. However, there is no single model or
approach that performs well on every type of text. We propose a system that
recommends the most suitable summarization model for a given text. The proposed
system employs a fully connected neural network that analyzes the input content
and predicts which summarizer should score the best in terms of ROUGE score for
a given input. The meta-model selects among four different summarization
models, developed for the Slovene language, using different properties of the
input, in particular its Doc2Vec document representation. The four Slovene
summarization models deal with different challenges associated with text
summarization in a less-resourced language. We evaluate the proposed SloMetaSum
model performance automatically and parts of it manually. The results show that
the system successfully automates the step of manually selecting the best
model. | [
0.0451272205,
-0.0137769552,
0.0197847653,
0.001628614,
-0.0139271021,
0.0027192726,
-0.0270048343,
-0.0358216539,
-0.005070237,
-0.0417869203,
0.0230011344,
0.0427208617,
0.0229225364,
-0.0077028694,
-0.0137814013,
-0.068099834,
0.054700885,
-0.0137512106,
0.0056788712,
0.0201086942,
0.0295228157,
0.0010574122,
0.0148249073,
0.035674952,
0.0269831996,
0.0141994301,
0.0371935703,
-0.0097689452,
0.0066350065,
-0.0167471357,
-0.0067416276,
-0.0140704475,
0.0033369786,
0.0223642346,
0.0000019628,
-0.0578131676,
-0.0425453968,
-0.0081844293,
0.0427448787,
0.0072820173,
0.0714136586,
-0.0357036255,
-0.0032674936,
0.0089791529,
-0.0095261391,
0.0076989075,
0.0055144774,
0.0106029473,
0.0623929873,
0.0377391726,
-0.0090158153,
-0.0578182898,
0.0305653028,
0.0006193146,
-0.0405871235,
-0.0004023306,
-0.0001933669,
0.0532915518,
-0.0105314599,
-0.03573763,
-0.0046503167,
0.0388814919,
-0.0163434632,
-0.0451968163,
0.0056882231,
-0.0016248648,
-0.0638181046,
-0.0150573319,
0.0271121357,
0.0429300927,
0.0045168204,
0.0121107884,
0.0257155951,
0.0494061932,
0.0300694872,
0.0295526404,
-0.0914083496,
0.0277279373,
0.0106647816,
0.0032114577,
0.0221109521,
0.0802126825,
-0.0185381956,
0.0331418812,
-0.0181571878,
0.0753951818,
-0.0030086865,
0.0177645013,
0.0054964023,
-0.0225120299,
-0.0236101933,
-0.0177541748,
0.0396638475,
0.042589996,
-0.0001114364,
-0.0325355753,
-0.0087121176,
-0.0544305593,
0.035665106,
-0.0711527318,
0.036495585,
0.0108218128,
0.0608848855,
0.0337676145,
-0.0580321327,
-0.0032142887,
0.0463192873,
-0.0043120128,
-0.0617908463,
-0.0304006618,
-0.0402248353,
0.0108318022,
-0.0476154685,
0.0632724091,
-0.0265908521,
-0.0210351031,
-0.0469042175,
0.0153661594,
0.0135661168,
-0.0122900251,
0.0092674578,
0.0213700086,
0.0398557521,
0.0121134045,
-0.0238946658,
0.0202649739,
-0.03334032,
-0.0244501326,
-0.0121814394,
0.038649749,
0.0145372832,
0.0093385912,
0.0007133741,
0.0250658859,
0.0247991979,
0.0311635118,
-0.0060169478,
-0.0152041055,
-0.0096046971,
-0.0145676946,
0.0044788611,
-0.0666865408,
-0.0235795584,
-0.0776282102,
-0.0283825956,
0.0072947782,
-0.0132119106,
0.0019624496,
0.0065648151,
0.010647309,
-0.0475950688,
0.0168148801,
-0.0375862941,
-0.0089652706,
0.0662318543,
-0.0174637213,
0.019728858,
0.0190828145,
0.0407018997,
0.0468485095,
0.0616625957,
0.003602522,
0.0086722542,
0.0274500623,
-0.0228517801,
-0.0497676954,
-0.0082956031,
-0.0056795822,
-0.0410900488,
-0.0177527443,
0.0412882008,
0.0489850529,
-0.0414605662,
0.0099378806,
0.0621668063,
0.0620995648,
0.0335949101,
0.0206787866,
0.0531729385,
0.0027093352,
0.0493921526,
0.0275614224,
-0.0015289537,
0.0301071908,
-0.0542176776,
0.0608202368,
0.0499029346,
0.014616413,
-0.0228493977,
-0.0866487101,
0.0053546103,
-0.0199346785,
0.0573577844,
-0.0355693325,
0.0214421581,
-0.0141701289,
-0.0257989839,
0.0013454612,
-0.0057523474,
-0.0388468318,
0.0137843993,
-0.0093625989,
0.019444475,
0.0406140909,
0.0567615442,
-0.0679778904,
0.0105587402,
-0.0369067341,
-0.0140831834,
0.0059563564,
0.0351693444,
-0.0430686437,
-0.0216847975,
-0.06734512,
0.0029673146,
0.0047113323,
0.0195312239,
0.0109547293,
-0.0744663179,
-0.0049784235,
0.0370610952,
-0.0138040036,
-0.0794108361,
0.0222527757,
0.0136000803,
0.0019354038,
-0.0122492705,
-0.0482463613,
-0.0097215576,
0.0280406661,
0.0023465517,
0.0475687385,
0.0465466715,
-0.040261697,
0.0054541742,
0.0176596735,
-0.0232066922,
-0.0565277375,
0.0343287066,
-0.0816861987,
0.0427744985,
0.0399408713,
-0.0165946037,
-0.045489084,
0.0317960344,
-0.0579415634,
-0.0333289951,
-0.0405143946,
0.027308004,
0.0026854121,
0.0131498594,
-0.0348682627,
0.0577641614,
-0.0150485178,
0.0161597244,
0.0944156721,
-0.0500968546,
-0.0008086209,
-0.0235122275,
-0.0192417521,
0.0385654084,
-0.0195882544,
-0.0032086656,
0.0480377972,
-0.0035977538,
-0.0012457824,
-0.0099112187,
-0.111220032,
0.0140600884,
-0.0036669085,
0.0264736861,
0.0371133462,
0.0047434368,
0.0080425628,
-0.0105717871,
-0.0467714593,
-0.0220292062,
0.0390555859,
-0.0076639187,
0.0398650803,
-0.0005857372,
0.0339016989,
-0.0789989457,
-0.0457453988,
0.0147739043,
0.0609170049,
0.0171453729,
-0.0326547287,
-0.0218532737,
0.0164746586,
-0.0266207531,
-0.006575549,
0.0083721215,
-0.0127798272,
-0.0444580056,
-0.0038372988,
0.0086153755,
0.0547129735,
0.0337640829,
-0.0374813899,
0.05284198,
0.0054030172,
-0.0186945703,
-0.0424118228,
-0.0347542465,
0.0755861253,
0.0096080294,
-0.0183589943,
0.0311603453,
0.0384878591,
0.0093356166,
0.0079878448,
0.0154072447,
0.0312385578,
-0.0615445375,
0.0176045597,
-0.0263573211,
-0.0178796593,
0.0112041039,
0.0371842496,
0.0031791369,
0.0221141782,
0.0384071283,
-0.0075928424,
0.0295179114,
-0.0716628581,
-0.0113803716,
-0.0789552703,
-0.0067196544,
0.0446563251,
0.0234245025,
-0.0453254171,
-0.0324188396,
-0.0408207625,
-0.0480149575,
0.0788886547,
-0.0307324249,
0.0462358184,
-0.0430155806,
0.0029261354,
-0.0347829051,
0.0108601684,
0.0053597186,
-0.0287953354,
0.0035089406,
0.0500165969,
0.0470680669,
0.0521406978,
-0.0365553908,
0.0415916257,
0.0232442077,
0.1034923866,
-0.0590865761,
-0.0111021409,
0.0002850966,
0.068824254,
0.0226415768,
-0.0210184809,
0.0530713499,
-0.0066185165,
0.0671796426,
0.0302810818,
0.0005628782,
-0.0269297343,
0.0079765245,
-0.0062161712,
-0.0072683189,
-0.1005926505,
-0.0217638519,
-0.0356496274,
0.0049042162,
-0.0546663851,
0.0352539457,
0.1225824431,
0.0258131307,
-0.0304124411,
-0.0198702347,
-0.0315854624,
-0.0099897292,
0.0305141658,
0.0009032704,
-0.0160049051,
-0.0017424627,
-0.009319745,
0.0223551448,
-0.0054546054,
-0.033373747,
0.020572111,
-0.0611642115,
-0.0005552467,
0.008615802,
-0.0691621229,
-0.0140897566,
-0.022025574,
-0.0137046548,
-0.041283574,
-0.013522651,
0.0419221781,
-0.0578408018,
0.0194934662,
0.0045558847,
-0.0846060365,
0.0151608083,
-0.0463855714,
-0.0157553479,
-0.0011065871,
0.0679326281,
0.0456874557,
-0.0347929448,
0.073732011,
0.0560781918,
-0.017732203,
-0.0038531013,
-0.0256311391,
0.0819329172,
0.0166066159,
0.0340164565,
-0.036979869,
0.0179295093,
0.038877748,
0.0270066429,
0.0175182037,
-0.0006487158,
0.0477715172,
-0.0089085,
-0.042701833,
0.0393712521,
-0.068272911,
0.0246215705,
0.0316933915,
0.0142611619,
-0.0324883945,
-0.0233990755,
-0.0356121212,
-0.0532882027,
-0.0532488935,
0.0128232744,
-0.0129094459,
-0.0585837848,
-0.0972876176,
-0.0645450503,
0.0288332421,
-0.0124382721,
0.0119326646,
0.0281014554,
-0.0139965769,
0.0008524186,
-0.0393436737,
0.0125436326,
0.0312433802,
-0.0193178765,
-0.0439316817,
0.0395198762,
0.0828699321,
-0.0359272249,
-0.0196053907,
0.015277084,
-0.0144430362,
-0.0358111635,
-0.0238359012,
0.0865638331,
0.0322686285,
0.0468856767,
-0.0012247759,
-0.0350836329,
0.0521240644,
0.0211511236,
-0.0301839169,
-0.0009271997,
0.0132425213,
0.0133177219,
-0.024633687,
0.0017165272,
-0.0401702635,
0.0536628291,
-0.049825944,
0.0092417412,
-0.0252515003,
-0.0440704264,
0.0123315267,
0.0335925743,
0.0012375807,
-0.023323603,
0.0150362151,
-0.0382460319,
-0.0326285847,
-0.0333181843,
-0.019145038,
-0.0091515677,
0.079820931,
-0.005123768,
0.0106971972,
-0.0213576071,
0.037086308,
-0.0266468562,
-0.0376587398,
-0.0372844078,
-0.0027549032,
-0.0170273185,
0.0222905166,
-0.0530893691,
-0.0077699167,
-0.0569269843,
-0.0145997023,
-0.0373706706,
-0.0159847979,
-0.0444313064,
-0.0048421347,
0.0065123122,
-0.0036092224,
-0.0267824382,
0.0758268163,
-0.0748393759,
0.024485603,
-0.0488061756,
0.0240882225,
0.080829978,
-0.0355127119,
0.0757471547,
0.0189864952,
-0.0159150194,
-0.0269066412,
0.032762114,
0.0505689606,
0.0182838477,
-0.0525582694,
0.0152840884,
-0.0020366965,
-0.019887805,
0.0588773489,
-0.0159822032,
-0.040146742,
0.0114986794,
-0.0402117111,
-0.0469788983,
-0.0115274489,
-0.0421169847,
0.0534296408,
-0.0319779217,
-0.0496131331,
-0.0867400169,
-0.0024547088,
0.0152637921,
0.0285504088,
0.0002472232,
-0.0171006396,
0.0332295001,
-0.0146764265,
0.0237590633,
0.0223748498,
-0.050040517,
0.0167932734,
-0.0463865995,
-0.0033472795,
-0.0183750391,
-5.470877442e-33,
-0.0363635942,
-0.0047206888,
-0.0260783937,
0.0281327479,
-0.0390244275,
-0.0216602087,
-0.0423216335,
-0.0088007655,
-0.018759178,
0.0101499222,
-0.0251219869,
-0.0125295836,
0.0180066098,
-0.0008326228,
0.0139479041,
0.0302229486,
0.0273289606,
-0.0006746617,
-0.033528816,
0.0022454769,
0.0343685523,
0.0227862652,
0.0525531843,
-0.0418274775,
0.0141207492,
-0.0132256169,
-0.0237956569,
-0.0302893966,
0.0486498177,
0.044706028,
0.0372572094,
0.0127084255,
0.0289362054,
-0.0392693728,
-0.0365800112,
-0.0122042038,
-0.0593593493,
-0.0444961675,
0.0388412997,
-0.0201843865,
-0.0464696512,
-0.0590667166,
0.0570030734,
-0.0249788538,
-0.0019009252,
0.0187461637,
0.0883588865,
-0.070424132,
-0.0505803414,
-0.0617529117,
-0.0301284771,
0.036725238,
-0.0466788672,
-0.0274921414,
0.0492121503,
0.0561124831,
0.0030194467,
-0.0049857534,
-0.0206904206,
0.0341208912,
-0.0211209059,
0.0612847954,
0.0501046106,
-0.0041302941,
0.0041140569,
0.0435122102,
-0.0054304944,
-0.034101855,
0.0009103344,
0.0384031609,
0.0008884235,
0.0414292738,
0.0682048872,
0.021070959,
0.0383243747,
-0.0014072249,
-0.0592204891,
0.0873075575,
0.0263097603,
0.0147397825,
0.0062718308,
-0.0192293637,
0.009309792,
-0.0155813349,
-0.0229450893,
-0.0559100024,
-0.0172788072,
-0.0123866508,
-0.0003480344,
-0.0267557595,
-0.0412137732,
-0.0387897231,
0.004785595,
-0.0426044799,
0.0243661068,
0.0349359363,
-0.028959753,
0.0509632677,
-0.015809292,
0.0024891708,
-0.0082938634,
0.0142362099,
-0.0103843296,
-0.0002440661,
-0.0004435811,
0.008148198,
0.011239049,
-0.0190730803,
-0.005079933,
0.0099852867,
0.0197397061,
-0.0029586358,
-0.018041607,
0.0619964153,
-0.0362437703,
-0.0065956702,
-0.0071278904,
0.042354878,
0.0135286599,
-0.021241067,
-0.0124981701,
-0.0279829036,
0.0604209676,
0.0340653248,
-0.0226892587,
0.050276842,
0.0008204464,
0.0593059957,
0.0346969701,
0.0228263997,
-0.0105754603,
0.0116480859,
2.544e-7,
0.083508417,
0.0415093713,
0.0208223835,
-0.0319901295,
0.0005787488,
0.0156104509,
-0.0079853898,
0.0211622119,
0.0257436745,
0.0411648639,
0.0245200396,
-0.0029492241,
0.0239566341,
0.0370632857,
-0.1024427414,
-0.0254656971,
-0.0422210693,
-0.0476365797,
-0.0168713201,
-0.0273898169,
0.0449716635,
0.0405593999,
-0.0209257714,
-0.0067209126,
-0.0707362592,
-0.0396095663,
0.0189563986,
-0.0140302004,
-0.0523377322,
0.0345216617,
0.0567324087,
0.0094804941,
-0.0378930345,
-0.0135620749,
0.0161755588,
0.0392577127,
0.0643026978,
0.0522403307,
-0.0340282284,
0.0233990494,
0.0526581593,
-0.0390001573,
0.0206870269,
0.0218479205,
0.0629119277,
-0.0318163633,
-0.0139265005,
-0.0062350882,
-0.0284302253,
0.0190686975,
0.0259721167,
-0.0124256127,
-0.0511914231,
0.0743821859,
-0.0086394465,
-0.0261826124,
0.0043887151,
-0.0561805554,
-0.0484564528,
-0.0209333617,
0.0208447818,
-0.0403284691,
-0.0010242632,
0.020910101,
0.0238762219,
-0.0259469748,
-0.0096297665,
2.180722707e-34,
0.0732696727,
-0.0009591243,
-0.0325974338,
-0.0035251488,
0.0031179951,
-0.031142693,
-0.0303829126,
0.0171713326,
0.0026373535,
-0.0551165119,
-0.0165463444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11507v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11507v1 | TrustGPT: A Benchmark for Trustworthy and Responsible Large Language Models | 2023-06-20T12:53:39 | 2023-06-20T12:53:39 | Yue Huang, Qihui Zhang, Philip S. Y, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT, have gained significant
attention due to their impressive natural language processing capabilities. It
is crucial to prioritize human-centered principles when utilizing these models.
Safeguarding the ethical and moral compliance of LLMs is of utmost importance.
However, individual ethical issues have not been well studied on the latest
LLMs. Therefore, this study aims to address these gaps by introducing a new
benchmark -- TrustGPT. TrustGPT provides a comprehensive evaluation of LLMs in
three crucial areas: toxicity, bias, and value-alignment. Initially, TrustGPT
examines toxicity in language models by employing toxic prompt templates
derived from social norms. It then quantifies the extent of bias in models by
measuring quantifiable toxicity values across different groups. Lastly,
TrustGPT assesses the value of conversation generation models from both active
value-alignment and passive value-alignment tasks. Through the implementation
of TrustGPT, this research aims to enhance our understanding of the performance
of conversation generation models and promote the development of language
models that are more ethical and socially responsible. | [
0.0535804965,
0.0493313596,
-0.0189406071,
0.0420250148,
-0.0764881819,
-0.0039834538,
0.0208368301,
-0.0143257584,
0.0588774011,
-0.0319542214,
-0.0475309603,
-0.0308902729,
0.0029161382,
0.0281175543,
0.0113046542,
-0.0297205057,
0.071352236,
0.0191811007,
0.0388240404,
-0.0063169422,
0.0276450869,
0.0302387848,
0.03107916,
0.0445853695,
-0.0200702809,
0.0041648904,
0.0152990883,
0.0208214894,
0.0558419265,
-0.0166992936,
0.0225294158,
0.0519580133,
-0.0251884088,
0.0625680014,
0.0000019326,
-0.0762607828,
0.0049903695,
0.0005643828,
0.0090748975,
0.0293309055,
0.0735633001,
0.0210745689,
-0.0329100266,
0.0297929123,
-0.0439011678,
0.034851253,
0.0494655743,
0.0231054649,
0.0608874522,
0.0622871108,
-0.0061922953,
0.040186163,
0.0324411765,
-0.0163529404,
-0.0000636559,
-0.0400036462,
0.0262258388,
0.013949641,
-0.029223308,
0.0301035978,
0.0140999863,
0.0199760292,
0.0002128364,
-0.0409507081,
-0.0018458451,
-0.0165937487,
-0.0287682377,
-0.0754811093,
-0.0194124933,
0.0551031455,
0.007205755,
-0.0020488771,
0.006677682,
-0.0043324181,
0.0297254566,
-0.0206322987,
-0.0003869168,
0.0451430231,
-0.0213396568,
-0.0102600958,
0.0052903071,
0.0274060983,
0.0022118161,
0.0464782603,
0.0801129714,
0.013918546,
0.0086961333,
-0.0237979144,
-0.0090925908,
0.0129933367,
-0.0371116772,
-0.0538212433,
0.0064501562,
0.0051081055,
-0.0498502962,
0.0457464047,
-0.034686774,
0.0273307618,
0.0761216953,
-0.0463661365,
-0.0154705122,
0.0517420359,
0.0233436115,
0.006656636,
0.0300144423,
0.0309445355,
-0.0161452852,
0.0228653979,
-0.0266359989,
0.0254140198,
0.020839544,
-0.0355212912,
-0.0293368436,
-0.0025901566,
-0.0216692165,
0.0125091849,
-0.0420514457,
0.0201190561,
-0.0338935181,
0.0118605392,
0.0299557373,
0.0242789518,
-0.018573083,
-0.0006343768,
-0.0100442106,
0.0058751516,
-0.0334136337,
-0.003616133,
0.0373343453,
-0.1031506732,
0.0221340954,
-0.0126470458,
-0.0417555533,
-0.0227957889,
-0.0129567441,
0.0960460231,
-0.0034847921,
-0.0014311924,
-0.016847102,
-0.0388534218,
-0.0432096198,
-0.0652154237,
-0.0386949815,
-0.0413026996,
0.0328662805,
-0.0098316781,
-0.0391872451,
-0.0321818292,
0.0301409569,
0.056326557,
-0.047718782,
0.0093550235,
-0.0042401422,
0.0126180649,
0.0385697037,
0.0484163389,
-0.0349979363,
0.0479007736,
0.0268033072,
0.0307252873,
0.0358575135,
-0.0425694883,
-0.0324777402,
0.0295207594,
0.0075450363,
-0.0028595007,
-0.01789755,
0.0073786266,
-0.0063648866,
0.0394351967,
0.0097768931,
0.1099040136,
-0.0357234888,
-0.0339486897,
0.0949379578,
0.0572895035,
-0.0543923639,
0.0178531855,
0.0149886757,
0.0223694202,
-0.0035229444,
-0.0027751015,
-0.0649916828,
0.0039674076,
-0.0238704961,
-0.0201793332,
-0.0186682045,
0.0541087613,
-0.0014417274,
-0.0299115386,
-0.0091001028,
-0.0022741668,
0.0513448901,
-0.0036694717,
-0.033769574,
-0.0068296716,
-0.052521456,
-0.0124958223,
0.0252830628,
-0.0772762746,
-0.0041919593,
-0.0278448015,
0.0593340881,
0.070310913,
0.0507415906,
0.0248034205,
-0.0256646406,
-0.0369210206,
-0.0257027745,
0.0414300412,
0.0449781083,
-0.0075337309,
-0.0158208292,
-0.0469938293,
-0.011876096,
0.0247713551,
-0.0169354435,
0.0027806875,
0.0247112419,
0.0165978763,
0.026629122,
-0.0151629746,
-0.0497148819,
0.0225911476,
-0.0192355793,
0.0085450057,
-0.0432796739,
-0.0040718778,
0.0369692445,
0.0090148719,
-0.0105151879,
0.0123879453,
-0.0058282819,
0.0275330339,
0.0085327318,
0.0211059153,
-0.0938632786,
0.0010675748,
0.0178098213,
-0.0482678488,
-0.0207611471,
0.0571510717,
0.0031343494,
0.0186785832,
-0.0147068063,
-0.041055128,
0.0035586418,
-0.0500433221,
0.009584371,
-0.0344936065,
0.0063439235,
-0.053755559,
0.0418957993,
-0.0192315821,
-0.0040081516,
-0.0203716587,
0.0124996845,
0.0074340566,
-0.0307555106,
-0.0353402458,
0.0197782833,
-0.0293657351,
0.0378102027,
0.0671997443,
0.0307132844,
-0.0578156412,
-0.0353574678,
-0.0823833942,
0.0072817947,
-0.0007149323,
0.0169684142,
0.0252912808,
0.0009320223,
-0.02680506,
0.0230636485,
-0.0693300664,
-0.0129054645,
0.0396406166,
0.0326077864,
0.0271916837,
-0.048029393,
-0.0223471336,
-0.0347691402,
0.0020643568,
-0.0095674414,
0.0055870595,
0.0186368432,
-0.0240090135,
-0.0235334672,
0.0429586098,
-0.0382498279,
-0.010727399,
0.0195422713,
-0.0719992965,
0.0304406695,
0.0839661434,
0.0359132029,
0.0772646815,
0.0883850381,
0.035855405,
-0.0133606447,
0.0320045725,
-0.0583677851,
-0.0197686646,
-0.0089615658,
-0.0287981071,
-0.0151181687,
-0.0722943172,
0.0084798094,
0.048766613,
0.0145614445,
0.0056502772,
-0.0557694957,
0.044396989,
-0.0319508724,
-0.0498783067,
0.0013977577,
-0.0910065919,
-0.0427341871,
0.0047592083,
-0.0390115231,
-0.0749312788,
0.0422364883,
-0.0175195448,
0.0208781064,
-0.015299418,
0.021836035,
-0.0108510032,
0.030460503,
-0.0002809435,
0.0569662638,
0.0318606235,
-0.0450030603,
-0.0417757519,
-0.0142471679,
0.0778989866,
-0.0521314777,
0.0038494791,
-0.0174560621,
-0.0009344266,
-0.0082395207,
-0.0380401239,
-0.0620793775,
-0.0369523987,
-0.0016807946,
0.0010026586,
0.0510638095,
-0.0003470323,
0.0049800612,
0.0038330068,
0.0212857649,
-0.0131297549,
-0.0215058606,
0.0065969131,
-0.0104559716,
0.0044100615,
0.0543627962,
-0.0431708768,
0.0602599606,
0.0149683934,
0.05488557,
0.0806819424,
-0.0204924252,
0.0110417223,
0.0094717508,
0.0121667376,
0.0409863032,
0.0126266368,
-0.003922544,
0.0278728642,
0.0696987733,
-0.01933017,
0.0002120497,
0.0859311372,
0.008471394,
-0.0336887576,
0.0154946717,
-0.0237646233,
0.0412801541,
0.0084699076,
-0.0192042608,
-0.0844477192,
0.0141985361,
0.0051414613,
0.0151580852,
-0.074953869,
-0.0587220825,
0.0012490307,
-0.1133344844,
0.0276161879,
0.022339223,
-0.0375741981,
0.0197755359,
-0.0118460702,
-0.002676202,
-0.0221260171,
0.0889782012,
0.0030707933,
-0.0006762345,
-0.0561181828,
0.0332889073,
-0.0366873555,
-0.0236215945,
0.0305287279,
-0.0433532596,
0.1020628959,
0.0799409449,
0.0304915588,
-0.0098411329,
-0.0374456495,
0.0424187295,
0.0173229985,
-0.016066866,
0.0083147185,
0.01911797,
-0.0387158021,
-0.0019256223,
-0.0744639635,
0.0344773456,
0.0082172053,
-0.0196247436,
0.0035714826,
0.0525367521,
0.0088779796,
-0.0335215814,
-0.032916747,
0.0232123509,
0.0232458375,
0.0977009907,
0.0128955394,
-0.0297320709,
-0.0020070651,
-0.0047750161,
-0.0182461292,
0.0005292176,
-0.0314178541,
0.005564054,
-0.0023562412,
-0.0301151164,
-0.0850367323,
-0.0598032549,
-0.0186900571,
-0.000908623,
0.0074956138,
-0.034039475,
0.0170651097,
-0.005108593,
-0.0088044545,
0.0199525878,
-0.0146494387,
0.0188075323,
-0.0423896126,
0.0574258976,
-0.0281902254,
-0.0228673574,
0.0092234556,
0.0304677151,
-0.0319985896,
-0.0728341192,
0.0366826355,
0.055705674,
0.0241079014,
0.0261845198,
0.0052488567,
-0.0242954809,
-0.0211534109,
0.0282631349,
-0.0426349007,
0.0214332324,
0.0160926189,
0.0094281398,
0.0002642403,
0.0129752886,
0.0018857244,
0.0134053594,
0.0219224039,
0.0254178438,
-0.0201452635,
-0.0470302626,
0.0394132324,
0.0414664783,
0.0041109519,
-0.0428198799,
0.0420121923,
-0.0377556086,
-0.0507056527,
-0.06259799,
-0.0361912288,
-0.0368210599,
0.0063666082,
0.0339889452,
0.0080062561,
-0.0034761135,
-0.0432246327,
-0.0810201392,
0.0447840318,
-0.0123082343,
0.0104396502,
-0.031312976,
0.0320004076,
0.0192380976,
0.0031570003,
-0.0555623099,
0.0090086525,
-0.0325666256,
0.0342585482,
0.0041114013,
0.0772448778,
0.0190672092,
0.001100879,
0.0472967252,
0.0478882529,
-0.0230285246,
-0.0231356919,
-0.0307667349,
0.0151322186,
-0.0065242411,
0.0106897634,
0.0538063385,
-0.0334463827,
0.0086474353,
-0.0171912592,
0.013446752,
0.0001917564,
-0.0678308234,
0.0186360925,
0.0097881677,
-0.0466634594,
0.0048425989,
0.0495687611,
-0.0079603447,
0.0096029937,
-0.0156186679,
-0.0102447188,
-0.0135290269,
-0.0240969993,
0.0359778218,
-0.0304931272,
-0.0281945281,
-0.0420384258,
-0.0786123425,
-0.056967251,
-0.0400429964,
0.0077663399,
0.0206557792,
-0.0123356376,
0.022150429,
0.0570863299,
-0.0248003397,
0.0036464478,
-0.0216841195,
-0.0016409573,
-0.0429378375,
-0.0032385529,
-0.0169730913,
-6.129164564e-33,
0.0006356412,
-0.0395475104,
0.0055964673,
-0.0091869701,
-0.0600393116,
-0.0175706297,
-0.0206954405,
0.0280980319,
-0.0302252229,
0.01276985,
-0.0084142284,
-0.0164760798,
0.0138229998,
0.0063638375,
-0.0026660988,
-0.0302413944,
0.0179298222,
-0.0098349731,
-0.0339309312,
0.0223392714,
-0.0012559997,
-0.0056628608,
0.0356987678,
-0.0520772822,
0.0664820895,
-0.0134768402,
-0.0376010574,
0.0138086053,
-0.0132465605,
0.0233307742,
0.0031131143,
0.0484698303,
0.0083708223,
-0.0226539131,
0.0196068976,
0.0750519857,
-0.0013023894,
-0.0103799878,
0.0710808635,
-0.0101323342,
-0.0245155804,
-0.0354970358,
0.0169115141,
-0.0433628075,
-0.0513173938,
0.0081212893,
-0.0059590987,
-0.0101280389,
-0.0242325254,
-0.0065161446,
-0.070135206,
0.0201715529,
-0.0387535244,
-0.0063066008,
-0.0481840707,
0.0715067014,
-0.0150483018,
0.0009549846,
-0.0053875023,
0.0117065832,
-0.0302943494,
-0.02728297,
0.0768379569,
-0.015047932,
0.0126053914,
0.0944812521,
0.0114962645,
0.0481671356,
-0.0220947247,
-0.0039826455,
0.004394833,
0.0356074274,
0.040263366,
0.0769492909,
-0.0506200939,
-0.0495129637,
-0.0273649711,
0.0083852028,
0.0553902537,
0.0281386115,
0.0164992884,
-0.0241947584,
-0.0685541034,
-0.0353625081,
-0.0268195625,
-0.0261158254,
-0.0119376192,
-0.0497819111,
0.0517521538,
-0.0192279406,
-0.0181072261,
-0.0216890387,
0.0350009575,
-0.0209200345,
0.030501971,
0.0246905815,
-0.0089566112,
-0.0104685482,
-0.0181394555,
0.0514076911,
-0.0509702191,
-0.0152384918,
0.0160567742,
0.0078926096,
0.0189585183,
0.0149741927,
0.0180436689,
-0.0197009034,
-0.0222268049,
0.024970958,
-0.0302938521,
0.0688162297,
-0.0130857117,
-0.0103702452,
0.0350320078,
-0.0159411766,
-0.026145054,
0.0174462777,
0.0446843915,
0.0049585658,
-0.0505426005,
0.0290115997,
-0.0277136136,
0.0141489264,
-0.0196936335,
0.0208821688,
-0.0185500719,
0.0283843428,
0.053245414,
-0.0097344927,
-0.0090542473,
-0.0210943408,
2.704e-7,
-0.0022476674,
0.0181943886,
0.0385924354,
0.0140510472,
-0.0133409481,
0.040468704,
0.0415912792,
0.0828057677,
0.0386695005,
-0.0380094089,
0.0150950253,
-0.0230080299,
0.0532603972,
0.0415570848,
-0.043384131,
-0.0245022271,
-0.1302743852,
-0.0342492983,
-0.0335856155,
0.0167369563,
0.0361381359,
0.0318405479,
-0.0249877851,
-0.0280022789,
-0.0028871726,
-0.0016442228,
0.0465202816,
-0.071120508,
-0.0255046338,
0.0176769681,
0.0526462086,
-0.0169671252,
0.0378683545,
0.0218321476,
0.0371280946,
-0.0059418748,
0.0187714603,
0.0612873361,
-0.0093006818,
-0.0335736386,
-0.0048461989,
-0.0482609868,
0.0006423027,
-0.0999802276,
0.0342188254,
-0.0193660688,
-0.0139783723,
-0.0428909659,
-0.031101726,
-0.0368811414,
0.0379349254,
-0.0395868421,
-0.0142314536,
0.0213028826,
0.0120056439,
0.0140538011,
0.0141344294,
-0.0241232589,
-0.0170613863,
-0.0595413037,
-0.0166129321,
-0.1005604938,
-0.0047783996,
0.0466398485,
-0.0166162644,
-0.0276834387,
0.0171796996,
2.245563159e-34,
0.0021791626,
-0.0555350482,
0.063639231,
-0.0092552444,
0.0549404658,
0.0567371026,
0.0147921871,
0.0231277384,
0.0074769841,
-0.0173236821,
-0.0164982863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11489v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11489v2 | Give Us the Facts: Enhancing Large Language Models with Knowledge Graphs for Fact-aware Language Modeling | 2023-06-20T12:21:06 | 2024-01-30T12:11:45 | Linyao Yang, Hongyang Chen, Zhao Li, Xiao Ding, Xindong Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, ChatGPT, a representative large language model (LLM), has gained
considerable attention due to its powerful emergent abilities. Some researchers
suggest that LLMs could potentially replace structured knowledge bases like
knowledge graphs (KGs) and function as parameterized knowledge bases. However,
while LLMs are proficient at learning probabilistic language patterns based on
large corpus and engaging in conversations with humans, they, like previous
smaller pre-trained language models (PLMs), still have difficulty in recalling
facts while generating knowledge-grounded contents. To overcome these
limitations, researchers have proposed enhancing data-driven PLMs with
knowledge-based KGs to incorporate explicit factual knowledge into PLMs, thus
improving their performance to generate texts requiring factual knowledge and
providing more informed responses to user queries. This paper reviews the
studies on enhancing PLMs with KGs, detailing existing knowledge graph enhanced
pre-trained language models (KGPLMs) as well as their applications. Inspired by
existing studies on KGPLM, this paper proposes to enhance LLMs with KGs by
developing knowledge graph-enhanced large language models (KGLLMs). KGLLM
provides a solution to enhance LLMs' factual reasoning ability, opening up new
avenues for LLM research. | [
0.068825841,
-0.0245399419,
-0.0002610529,
0.0605331808,
-0.0378528275,
-0.0062875664,
-0.0156233683,
-0.0130152944,
0.0535851009,
-0.0726650581,
0.0116832722,
-0.0075900778,
-0.0269653238,
0.0491384938,
0.0190391336,
-0.0057248906,
0.0456491411,
-0.0209954642,
0.058363717,
-0.0277098361,
0.0330724716,
0.044878915,
-0.0132226506,
-0.0071373414,
-0.0323842913,
0.0009807143,
0.0027896655,
-0.0167365242,
-0.0182153974,
-0.011373735,
0.0019612287,
0.0233779717,
0.0294125881,
0.0120687503,
0.0000019615,
-0.0433870926,
0.0186785255,
-0.0144311385,
-0.0676725656,
0.0171135645,
0.0197750628,
0.0378740169,
0.0167165268,
-0.0051743067,
-0.0578664504,
-0.0305982474,
0.0048707272,
0.062725313,
0.0362342596,
0.0805424154,
-0.0119755128,
-0.0265234001,
0.0124961799,
0.0051007443,
0.0206116587,
-0.0135614118,
0.0437305942,
0.0764015093,
0.0131126586,
0.0218909383,
0.0074888268,
0.0235039722,
0.0053665759,
-0.0245799962,
0.0387956612,
0.044370167,
-0.0166140106,
-0.0053858268,
0.0193946548,
0.1066162214,
-0.0005355434,
-0.0411952063,
-0.0033698778,
-0.0097285295,
-0.0161559079,
0.0237648487,
-0.0401485711,
0.0055927336,
-0.0280204006,
0.0288461689,
0.0066839638,
-0.0208238158,
0.0580781251,
0.023172196,
-0.0208582096,
0.0903471634,
0.001139037,
-0.0106730871,
0.0061067953,
-0.009207651,
-0.0281802081,
-0.0356564522,
0.0063423663,
0.0524602123,
0.0028280471,
0.0590025522,
-0.0215815268,
0.0287086163,
0.0230830796,
-0.0943344906,
-0.0270141773,
0.0032395008,
-0.0173856057,
0.0783519,
-0.039365191,
0.0185221191,
0.0128865242,
0.0271910131,
-0.0206101593,
-0.0162513945,
-0.0372390337,
-0.0022600177,
-0.0162910894,
0.0243111718,
-0.0043036588,
-0.0201729592,
-0.0013665463,
0.0488084257,
0.0169881489,
0.0363380201,
0.0274353046,
0.0146597885,
0.00944955,
-0.0459506921,
-0.05593336,
0.0397156589,
-0.0026510209,
0.0162079465,
-0.0148076862,
-0.0403871313,
0.0144856395,
0.0008987111,
0.0195375737,
-0.0048644422,
0.0023768055,
0.0125659462,
0.0116662122,
-0.0130850933,
-0.0589148812,
-0.0341711789,
0.0031256319,
-0.0701610968,
-0.0010702095,
-0.083261922,
0.0362051018,
0.024478009,
-0.0368680134,
-0.0262617599,
0.0413223617,
0.0162478052,
-0.062948443,
0.057565812,
-0.0487772301,
0.0096996147,
0.0151989851,
0.0118956314,
-0.0179491099,
0.0370866545,
0.0280316826,
-0.0009291446,
0.0589076243,
-0.0047595492,
-0.0242900457,
-0.0055201147,
0.0320092961,
0.0035673368,
0.0382795297,
0.0169676244,
-0.0159988999,
0.0175251439,
0.0163558219,
0.0359024182,
-0.0247147493,
0.0051651774,
0.0850055441,
0.0095743565,
-0.0048015392,
0.0410482511,
0.048640877,
0.0282622948,
0.0388980955,
-0.0067570196,
-0.0333717726,
-0.0099039143,
-0.0404803529,
0.0414201766,
-0.0164469332,
0.0239051059,
-0.0262207072,
-0.0278949533,
-0.0182533395,
-0.0147436652,
0.0296595264,
0.0412428118,
0.0677414685,
-0.0016679257,
-0.0296048224,
0.053976588,
0.0518052243,
-0.039467711,
0.027297318,
-0.0331962369,
0.0371179245,
0.0613238327,
0.0436190106,
-0.0451562703,
-0.0629865453,
0.0183662791,
-0.0025524925,
0.0244072564,
0.0463053696,
-0.0125410529,
-0.0355057754,
-0.0466691591,
-0.011395758,
-0.0226009823,
-0.0052189645,
-0.000478048,
0.0347555503,
-0.001610102,
0.0341979004,
-0.0543035455,
-0.0334346853,
0.0128400978,
-0.0311766546,
0.011725991,
-0.0060820999,
-0.0271837395,
-0.0008496877,
0.0316833742,
0.0055553596,
0.0124805942,
0.0357425883,
0.0120360097,
-0.0287300963,
0.0152603388,
-0.0384746529,
-0.0948348939,
0.0616715588,
0.0262168441,
-0.0172061957,
-0.0304183103,
-0.0526765138,
-0.0385123044,
0.0050204224,
-0.0097165508,
0.0986382961,
-0.0624547414,
0.0005866823,
0.0270054974,
-0.0078537567,
-0.0135834282,
0.0758836418,
0.0034408034,
0.0067999889,
-0.0060827592,
0.0113407038,
0.0161590874,
-0.0207030773,
-0.0144126555,
0.004777337,
0.019834917,
0.0271344744,
0.0331149027,
-0.0006577359,
-0.0621123537,
0.0284898262,
-0.1164499819,
0.0152653018,
0.0050007603,
-0.0121354125,
0.0055858693,
-0.0097259562,
-0.0116157997,
-0.0177791603,
-0.0551430285,
0.0122655779,
0.0268073864,
-0.0045782453,
0.0203344766,
-0.0030944706,
0.0064749871,
-0.0093713095,
0.011956335,
0.0012830219,
0.0374432877,
0.0268615596,
-0.0137663754,
-0.0167851038,
0.073062256,
-0.0764006227,
0.021009203,
-0.0267959535,
-0.0025224504,
-0.0201968607,
-0.0168572068,
0.0558996052,
0.0441749394,
-0.0020415087,
0.0250097569,
0.0314507894,
-0.0265250932,
-0.0360365547,
0.00369328,
-0.0599063598,
0.0029247233,
-0.0323640779,
0.0072001335,
-0.0156518742,
-0.0047393963,
0.0208430775,
-0.0362538807,
-0.0420168787,
-0.0073161921,
0.0005915901,
0.0051859263,
-0.038240198,
-0.0041081579,
-0.0052776085,
0.0056667174,
-0.050557036,
-0.0206608921,
0.0575763658,
-0.0515199974,
0.0206830762,
-0.0156126162,
-0.0131502338,
-0.0166398883,
0.0324015692,
0.0318134092,
0.0124356821,
-0.0461352803,
0.0061671971,
-0.0326964334,
0.0069365478,
0.034713164,
-0.0643632188,
0.0279736184,
-0.0524279922,
0.0326622054,
0.0424544513,
-0.0131319659,
-0.0520148389,
-0.0335359499,
-0.0397163853,
0.0078950357,
-0.0091415066,
-0.0280233044,
0.0033669642,
0.0069949781,
0.0354116112,
0.0102225253,
0.003549804,
-0.0007511036,
-0.0092665004,
0.0048865681,
0.058989659,
0.0163408406,
0.0320345685,
-0.0079254936,
0.0245854892,
0.0616780519,
-0.0152406786,
-0.056574624,
-0.0091090556,
-0.0069954158,
-0.0129101416,
-0.0284313112,
-0.034630131,
-0.0086264322,
0.0185219757,
-0.0389168784,
0.0006892589,
0.1268438101,
0.0133189047,
0.0004362104,
-0.0224663261,
-0.0050815064,
0.0192557164,
0.0086994618,
0.0316650197,
-0.078824833,
-0.0040145968,
-0.0169933718,
-0.003112226,
0.0017279988,
-0.0370413102,
-0.0348126553,
-0.1224489436,
0.0006478664,
0.0058481623,
0.0215503424,
-0.0603083074,
-0.0292407293,
-0.0005128392,
0.0116483411,
-0.0064825937,
0.0069777747,
-0.0026841068,
0.0084741777,
0.0256608911,
-0.0459640883,
-0.0560607091,
0.0308330003,
-0.030460069,
0.0607120618,
0.003279893,
0.0427137017,
0.0127778547,
0.0043938714,
-0.0111758765,
0.0373161994,
-0.0059880763,
-0.0017763007,
0.0108449897,
-0.0202833731,
0.0093193529,
-0.0405738987,
0.0160190724,
-0.0397962481,
-0.0350088961,
-0.0129959341,
0.0811937377,
-0.037922442,
-0.0270280465,
0.014781801,
0.0265270192,
-0.0106268264,
0.0870704949,
0.0293957964,
0.0237829108,
0.0015184457,
-0.0335149206,
-0.0165459793,
0.0052025509,
-0.0329149365,
0.0338257588,
-0.0480627157,
0.0230816957,
-0.0767772198,
-0.0130054457,
0.0375913903,
0.0189114921,
-0.0025107742,
0.0182604957,
0.0553428233,
-0.0186016671,
-0.0263503399,
0.0230976734,
-0.0576188266,
-0.0186437238,
-0.0227620285,
-0.0202590898,
0.04068584,
-0.0614564866,
-0.0044104368,
-0.0056640175,
-0.0658821762,
-0.0866839364,
0.009223138,
0.0319136456,
0.015275863,
0.0710355565,
-0.0339259394,
-0.0375517346,
0.0976274386,
0.0268911552,
-0.0719843209,
-0.0025568637,
0.0221350137,
-0.007669392,
0.0036789293,
0.0241442043,
-0.0512576737,
0.0052988613,
0.0061475593,
0.0502366424,
-0.0457622148,
-0.0708198622,
0.0058102435,
0.0453815125,
0.0438909158,
0.0134355761,
-0.0215467382,
-0.0732314363,
0.0020247344,
-0.0482591428,
-0.0285438169,
-0.0272363294,
0.0104491664,
-0.0074546598,
0.0036593762,
-0.0145643726,
-0.0391995646,
-0.0171269495,
0.034965042,
0.0189316031,
-0.0433410145,
0.0104572456,
-0.0198115557,
0.0504839271,
-0.0242535006,
-0.0247280635,
0.0492908731,
-0.003339943,
0.0017940758,
-0.0214203354,
0.0675248951,
0.0163660757,
-0.0487947576,
-0.0258728918,
-0.0158542357,
-0.0561794862,
-0.0504171215,
-0.0109078102,
0.0473390967,
0.0804086626,
-0.0200861134,
0.0268542208,
-0.0739092529,
-0.0201348569,
-0.0190512799,
0.0575130358,
0.0273830518,
-0.0239089672,
0.0436997712,
0.0033413142,
-0.0445807353,
0.0309839938,
0.06608174,
0.0432887711,
0.0396004282,
0.0057163839,
-0.0520198718,
-0.0154814851,
-0.0471929871,
-0.0023426821,
0.0306324326,
-0.0168508552,
0.034737803,
-0.0663625151,
-0.0950467885,
-0.007589838,
-0.0064764367,
-0.0294412635,
-0.0222918279,
0.0302283131,
0.0645221844,
0.0050216517,
-0.0102097858,
-0.0598266348,
0.0485739931,
-0.026397964,
0.0086383894,
0.0132241761,
-6.728844109e-33,
-0.0228453744,
-0.0409411229,
0.0269793142,
0.0339473784,
-0.0356663056,
-0.0015525018,
-0.0319287963,
-0.002332486,
-0.0281285737,
0.0473669171,
-0.0073999227,
0.0261233989,
-0.0052790632,
0.0193803068,
-0.0498367995,
-0.0282486565,
0.0159182027,
0.0023808822,
0.016597081,
0.0435793139,
0.0665863231,
0.0396820568,
0.0770757869,
-0.0483355857,
0.030783359,
-0.0351075195,
0.0119643807,
0.0474916101,
-0.0050530271,
0.0419939235,
-0.0235137679,
0.0788078308,
0.0346890837,
-0.0194464065,
-0.0152709186,
0.0053270995,
-0.0804285556,
-0.0415388495,
0.0813393369,
0.0020715983,
0.0210124999,
0.0160754416,
0.0195919722,
-0.017733993,
0.0528042726,
-0.0045459634,
0.0421199091,
-0.0126767093,
-0.050763227,
-0.0169601943,
-0.0259840079,
0.0365061462,
0.0158835333,
0.0084463907,
-0.0260016769,
-0.0395990089,
-0.0007482137,
-0.009711002,
-0.0660843179,
0.0296836086,
0.0092735365,
-0.0016854363,
0.050943844,
0.0205671377,
0.02463153,
0.0545728318,
-0.0639669299,
0.016390983,
-0.0728829354,
0.0381255038,
0.0185020175,
0.0545538515,
-0.0031382523,
0.0600759797,
-0.0144516127,
-0.0150305703,
-0.0806090608,
-0.0019375831,
0.0287735257,
0.0180603806,
0.0167198312,
-0.0144989174,
-0.0314196236,
-0.0515263341,
-0.0341905169,
0.0415521115,
-0.0117770154,
-0.0418739393,
-0.022467941,
-0.0160294883,
-0.0120120402,
-0.0137531739,
0.00202735,
-0.0425027274,
-0.009154968,
0.0385729149,
-0.0270261019,
-0.0038595547,
-0.0380390659,
0.0439493693,
-0.0829207599,
-0.0174051393,
0.012108244,
-0.0422945581,
-0.0382667184,
0.0336176082,
0.0306584053,
-0.0008472622,
-0.0059296959,
0.008583853,
-0.0332742184,
-0.0020246662,
0.0024903077,
-0.0043637441,
0.0282953773,
0.0649939179,
-0.0141938468,
0.0494939759,
0.0477230474,
0.0270811524,
-0.0203125831,
-0.0350826457,
0.001075952,
0.0207206719,
-0.0388634242,
-0.0005652775,
-0.0456188023,
-0.0158976074,
0.0130198542,
-0.0529516526,
0.0039998535,
0.0098284669,
2.775e-7,
0.0583107732,
0.0334063135,
-0.0083597926,
0.0240134131,
0.0088090068,
0.0328978412,
0.0044262335,
-0.0073528946,
0.0305879693,
-0.0642924234,
0.037416283,
0.0742382407,
0.0119312489,
0.0235738512,
-0.0908024237,
-0.0174573977,
-0.0561492182,
-0.0567648895,
-0.0459692478,
-0.0166982338,
0.0529692844,
0.0665046871,
0.0540095791,
-0.0153365862,
0.0008711552,
-0.0563909076,
0.0668813884,
-0.0050779879,
-0.0589802489,
0.0319087617,
0.0874956623,
0.0261899494,
-0.0240129326,
0.0532724187,
-0.020791823,
0.0141906273,
-0.0065646381,
0.0554955229,
0.0146362083,
-0.0004554238,
0.0057439841,
-0.0357675217,
0.0176806971,
-0.0565691069,
0.0995731205,
-0.049834799,
-0.0061927689,
0.0024405818,
-0.0123101817,
-0.0452152938,
-0.0260048416,
-0.0364042372,
-0.0381582342,
0.0073425677,
0.0067192209,
-0.0272104833,
0.0070844442,
-0.069057934,
-0.0193902161,
0.0157434512,
-0.0414975211,
-0.075492166,
0.0202129744,
-0.029236123,
0.0327442549,
-0.0234502908,
0.0454086885,
2.656145428e-34,
0.0489911214,
0.0127121415,
-0.0223106742,
-0.0262776837,
0.0650808662,
0.00977505,
0.0006845429,
-0.0003095219,
0.0406889059,
-0.1027702242,
0.0040916489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.12443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.12443v1 | DEPAC: a Corpus for Depression and Anxiety Detection from Speech | 2023-06-20T12:21:06 | 2023-06-20T12:21:06 | Mashrura Tasnim, Malikeh Ehghaghi, Brian Diep, Jekaterina Novikova | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Mental distress like depression and anxiety contribute to the largest
proportion of the global burden of diseases. Automated diagnosis systems of
such disorders, empowered by recent innovations in Artificial Intelligence, can
pave the way to reduce the sufferings of the affected individuals. Development
of such systems requires information-rich and balanced corpora. In this work,
we introduce a novel mental distress analysis audio dataset DEPAC, labeled
based on established thresholds on depression and anxiety standard screening
tools. This large dataset comprises multiple speech tasks per individual, as
well as relevant demographic information. Alongside, we present a feature set
consisting of hand-curated acoustic and linguistic features, which were found
effective in identifying signs of mental illnesses in human speech. Finally, we
justify the quality and effectiveness of our proposed audio corpus and feature
set in predicting depression severity by comparing the performance of baseline
machine learning models built on this dataset with baseline models trained on
other well-known depression corpora. | [
-0.0046953647,
0.0467008799,
-0.0376870781,
-0.0256243814,
0.0117105981,
0.0284468811,
0.041309163,
-0.0038495504,
0.019316433,
-0.0027506768,
-0.0026341132,
0.0149130393,
-0.0025439712,
0.0034642266,
-0.0283526368,
-0.070741713,
-0.0224639475,
0.039987918,
0.0536881909,
0.0029787,
0.0100721912,
0.0285450257,
-0.0524428636,
0.0514419377,
-0.0460211337,
-0.0010970772,
0.035555169,
0.0179875102,
0.0345158018,
-0.0873938054,
-0.0014574976,
0.0346931592,
-0.0061949524,
-0.0249467157,
0.0000018016,
-0.0215693116,
0.0131108854,
-0.0162650645,
-0.0170773715,
-0.0698358789,
0.0302321594,
-0.0293822736,
0.0128941927,
0.0204377528,
-0.0316711962,
-0.0479795076,
0.0295979697,
0.063378714,
0.0543314926,
0.0501173995,
-0.0454144031,
0.0083970316,
-0.0058475723,
-0.0220326148,
-0.030097628,
-0.003340133,
0.0527765974,
-0.0130830975,
0.0318561606,
-0.073958233,
-0.0021142943,
-0.0147487009,
-0.0502159335,
0.0649414137,
-0.0163546279,
-0.0104233949,
-0.0481854565,
-0.0703264549,
-0.0085589122,
0.0787974745,
0.0160585139,
0.0167390369,
0.0172085483,
-0.0086974129,
0.0052727503,
0.0017861397,
-0.0070789768,
-0.0254640039,
0.0076699369,
0.0433204696,
0.0334936976,
0.0489341728,
-0.003405195,
-0.0216671545,
0.0317032747,
0.047736343,
-0.0323610976,
-0.0418866798,
0.0472116731,
-0.0072476058,
-0.0457833149,
-0.0362970978,
0.01208519,
-0.0184432287,
-0.0352037363,
-0.0043429742,
-0.0399755314,
-0.0797057524,
-0.0043516727,
0.031739641,
-0.0360089317,
0.0013531796,
-0.0934841782,
-0.0094413245,
0.0324996747,
-0.0055080708,
0.036397621,
-0.0458410606,
-0.0125415316,
-0.0178757161,
-0.0511629209,
0.0488467179,
-0.0438916646,
-0.0063419566,
0.0269927159,
-0.0180921908,
-0.072257176,
-0.0352967493,
-0.0365033224,
-0.0039012351,
0.0263536032,
0.0041540642,
0.0343753733,
0.0461270623,
0.0575741529,
0.0253742542,
-0.0534694381,
0.0569340102,
0.0043203365,
-0.0666500479,
0.0367975235,
-0.0169057101,
-0.0030461526,
-0.0363205783,
0.0496976785,
0.0215028003,
0.0806831568,
-0.0183335636,
-0.0454585403,
-0.0003314756,
-0.0314744338,
-0.0237346478,
-0.0267310143,
-0.0260443743,
0.0107991053,
-0.003090251,
0.016655542,
-0.0557467565,
0.0098409541,
-0.0337321274,
-0.0051303399,
0.0534017086,
-0.0402477905,
0.0066077029,
0.0296065826,
-0.0027687233,
-0.0051734536,
0.0493656434,
0.056251768,
-0.0135799395,
0.0574691445,
-0.051161997,
-0.0057640439,
0.0155508174,
-0.0150870103,
-0.0448730364,
0.0135017959,
-0.0645511299,
-0.0615262426,
0.0322012417,
-0.007253869,
-0.0060472758,
0.0109782564,
-0.0252608955,
0.0295773428,
0.1096958891,
0.0156940464,
0.0188274812,
-0.0379151031,
0.0305656344,
-0.0155759957,
-0.0282433107,
0.0025845452,
-0.0154605089,
-0.0140188178,
-0.0454062931,
0.0085837785,
0.0164927058,
-0.0212684926,
-0.0356384329,
-0.0603062324,
-0.0081902044,
-0.0120264376,
0.0201487541,
-0.0128280213,
-0.009976537,
0.0269935932,
0.0554861724,
0.0280626509,
-0.0120723126,
-0.0597120225,
-0.0187833961,
0.0077686966,
0.0212135967,
-0.0180453919,
-0.0694883913,
0.0090073925,
-0.0135950707,
0.0190324951,
0.007933951,
-0.0046754992,
0.0283262264,
0.0537674874,
-0.0287199561,
0.0117660649,
0.0645214096,
0.0285203066,
-0.0110733695,
-0.0401009992,
0.0306229722,
-0.0294851884,
-0.0496408716,
0.0006772811,
0.0449204631,
0.0161311124,
-0.0319894888,
0.0564847514,
0.0190446861,
0.0657080635,
0.0197901838,
-0.0401361659,
-0.0177610349,
0.0186870582,
-0.0341154896,
-0.0094811535,
0.0186456628,
0.0196321066,
-0.016869124,
0.0067968853,
-0.0411567017,
0.0415693261,
0.0920704827,
-0.0366684571,
-0.04404632,
0.036605835,
-0.037109483,
0.012226034,
0.0074627898,
-0.0245021973,
-0.0118916454,
0.0917050764,
0.010838666,
-0.0154879903,
0.0058897454,
0.005085595,
-0.0138256839,
-0.049152039,
-0.0132400449,
-0.0362367406,
-0.0481939949,
-0.0095070992,
-0.0056962268,
-0.0049923463,
-0.0387807526,
-0.0110189533,
-0.0088022221,
0.0123946471,
-0.1330562532,
-0.0090438277,
-0.0068277847,
-0.0325475968,
0.000101264,
-0.0143093988,
-0.0468688905,
-0.0331719182,
-0.0118871108,
0.0206825417,
0.0291490424,
0.0264197774,
-0.0022726997,
-0.011290106,
-0.0217395294,
-0.040446613,
-0.0203987062,
-0.0220528897,
-0.0106081646,
-0.0117298514,
-0.0634897426,
0.0035206084,
0.024286069,
-0.0213290732,
0.005493551,
0.0041652862,
-0.0145110749,
-0.0277354009,
0.0000040837,
-0.0090189744,
0.0350815021,
-0.0070386874,
0.0840116069,
0.0312352572,
0.0216360278,
0.0113909552,
0.0147093786,
0.0132859023,
0.0457634367,
-0.0429580957,
-0.0304860715,
-0.0207318962,
0.0492837764,
0.045609735,
0.0147296088,
-0.0077529415,
-0.0285964683,
-0.0086930813,
0.0128028635,
-0.0083463863,
-0.0150432261,
-0.0136858569,
0.0341630317,
0.0037397293,
-0.0276897103,
0.015252497,
-0.0001409518,
-0.0255332924,
-0.0429629423,
-0.0724495202,
-0.0287695844,
0.0129840607,
-0.0266778935,
-0.0119762179,
0.0605490394,
-0.0153307999,
0.0236526281,
-0.0168989003,
-0.0061835372,
-0.0438717976,
-0.0118182991,
-0.0336257294,
-0.0163951758,
0.0433316529,
-0.0518069752,
-0.0320391767,
-0.0442328602,
-0.065628536,
-0.0013829342,
-0.0203564223,
-0.0158590823,
-0.025112059,
-0.0255517587,
0.0011739474,
0.0440895706,
0.0065545077,
-0.0024025594,
0.0452511385,
0.0528602339,
0.0438294224,
0.0375633687,
0.0283789411,
0.0091435313,
0.0125305681,
0.0222419295,
0.0023917509,
0.0682448819,
-0.0001558956,
0.0622367449,
-0.0113393031,
0.0106636258,
-0.0203879364,
0.0164772701,
-0.0138132777,
-0.0122192027,
0.0136421919,
0.1127953753,
0.0137609961,
-0.0335808992,
0.0374909565,
-0.0013100805,
-0.0040838341,
0.0121716913,
-0.027449172,
-0.035876669,
-0.0425409228,
-0.0015108413,
0.0717498958,
-0.0281617772,
-0.0113203442,
0.0181624666,
-0.0120439678,
0.064033404,
-0.0337488912,
0.0148732662,
0.0299407952,
-0.0384309515,
0.0424819961,
-0.0621215962,
-0.0199333243,
-0.084276855,
0.0085829413,
-0.0271729641,
0.0265544374,
-0.102782324,
-0.0722182021,
0.0713849962,
-0.0062249037,
0.0828654766,
0.0188738648,
0.0789306313,
-0.0241988078,
-0.0287882257,
-0.0222330838,
-0.0022025099,
-0.0142331645,
0.0041169515,
0.0828820542,
0.0125507927,
-0.0292140394,
-0.0106359022,
0.0683189705,
-0.0867685974,
0.0164234061,
0.0148533657,
0.07005319,
-0.0022339397,
-0.0083931917,
-0.0223011989,
0.0434452444,
0.04166843,
0.0457139798,
0.0360332727,
-0.0514058098,
0.0017146959,
0.0319184437,
0.0010669685,
-0.0000015365,
-0.0183787607,
0.03078283,
0.0098051745,
-0.0598747656,
-0.0569316931,
-0.0438680239,
0.0492052548,
-0.0142557789,
0.0043983203,
-0.0399944335,
0.0091192024,
0.0299965758,
-0.0830337033,
0.0720806047,
0.0777414292,
0.0406287275,
-0.0198130757,
-0.0183481947,
0.026167348,
0.0167080779,
-0.0398570821,
0.0228474028,
-0.0675822645,
-0.021560749,
0.0763356462,
-0.0224636905,
0.0158655904,
-0.0397614427,
-0.0104054427,
-0.0393247753,
0.0613727123,
-0.0057702619,
-0.0318745635,
0.0079722786,
0.0545600057,
-0.0096500637,
-0.0126497326,
0.0528551154,
-0.012235106,
0.0835640579,
0.004198913,
-0.0414773561,
-0.0155325979,
-0.0088490704,
-0.0175625868,
0.0224915016,
0.0459480435,
-0.0009096554,
-0.0486195162,
-0.02907563,
-0.0243709721,
0.0266683176,
0.0229276288,
-0.0279833842,
-0.0228485074,
0.0125585748,
-0.0029140729,
-0.0439366922,
-0.0314697251,
-0.028567424,
-0.0599051081,
-0.0326108187,
0.0508915968,
-0.0027486724,
0.0203068852,
0.0009193704,
0.0248907562,
0.0150856609,
0.041106455,
-0.0195321124,
0.0092305308,
0.0126501061,
0.041356571,
-0.009050143,
0.007931645,
0.0377799533,
0.0593711846,
-0.0159951765,
-0.0460275859,
-0.0256243031,
-0.0378399938,
0.0425808914,
-0.0245811306,
0.0847889483,
-0.0092285462,
0.0191841312,
-0.0151350396,
0.0044558756,
-0.0571065061,
0.0104262996,
-0.0014603689,
-0.0055578733,
-0.0182981789,
0.0049094353,
0.0551262423,
-0.0285886917,
0.0096341884,
0.0186543055,
0.0148644941,
-0.02662999,
0.0180328246,
0.0053582112,
0.0056031863,
-0.002031072,
0.0107289599,
-0.0229247343,
-0.0623091869,
0.0594481789,
-0.061994113,
0.0018260963,
-0.0113700293,
0.0262440983,
0.0154059194,
-0.0062514856,
0.0374030098,
-0.0219742619,
-0.0255958997,
-0.0377831459,
-0.0315523483,
-0.0490853488,
-5.066534201e-33,
-0.0003963567,
0.0100541459,
-0.0505890399,
0.0068753436,
0.0114108752,
0.0296716597,
0.0050773546,
0.0178024955,
-0.0053970115,
0.0371721052,
0.0210780092,
0.0768118948,
0.0066732136,
0.0415415317,
0.0211531054,
-0.0246677622,
0.0313955806,
-0.0394010879,
-0.0139019666,
-0.0203076527,
0.0235932469,
0.074979499,
0.0575747639,
-0.0827091411,
-0.0418705009,
0.0436657369,
-0.0140698897,
-0.0219498519,
0.0538657196,
0.03989508,
-0.0244645011,
0.090597041,
0.0342599154,
-0.0025496494,
0.0117644174,
0.004451639,
-0.0431142002,
-0.0241552778,
-0.0203126539,
0.021529004,
0.0048245396,
0.0377165154,
0.0083310837,
0.0116831483,
0.006948743,
-0.0371768959,
0.0626357645,
-0.0487343781,
0.0467360094,
-0.0468567014,
0.0098835547,
0.0097974474,
-0.0244748648,
-0.0147129735,
0.0186480116,
0.0661352053,
-0.0587267429,
-0.0028885987,
-0.0060838778,
0.0123414509,
-0.0119185206,
0.0067687593,
0.0016134847,
-0.0712836832,
-0.0139307007,
0.0603298396,
0.0393898487,
-0.0567308441,
0.0152780013,
0.0163067468,
-0.0132385036,
0.0712593123,
0.0388823524,
-0.001317859,
0.0483144224,
-0.0186652951,
-0.0229346342,
0.021059664,
-0.0008724246,
0.0008966538,
-0.0010493171,
-0.0080205705,
-0.0408869386,
0.0009357827,
-0.0066620302,
-0.0051047006,
-0.0189935695,
0.003150638,
0.0281534437,
-0.0041016326,
0.0136422152,
0.0140124802,
-0.0199549068,
-0.0271601304,
-0.012732558,
-0.0160364825,
0.0025220583,
0.0319864526,
0.033970654,
-0.0138833215,
0.0166492108,
-0.0004343372,
0.0698036999,
0.0398031287,
0.1090525761,
-0.0330910124,
0.0199613925,
0.0096422834,
-0.0402522497,
-0.0074352659,
0.0311582051,
0.0313989967,
-0.0127971303,
0.0981607661,
-0.0253714472,
0.0192462988,
-0.018436024,
0.0036656342,
-0.0278138164,
0.0282515045,
-0.0733860135,
-0.0396090783,
-0.0088494485,
0.0209419634,
-0.0057637594,
-0.0389766879,
-0.0135905342,
-0.0426597446,
0.0636453703,
-0.0292419642,
0.0118668415,
-0.0515850857,
2.589e-7,
-0.0057815155,
0.0483992547,
0.0052333358,
-0.0128265228,
0.0229495913,
0.0077834423,
-0.006131188,
0.0497619398,
0.0106243584,
-0.0239065904,
0.0195853654,
-0.0065023787,
0.0848086774,
0.0800134912,
-0.0378591977,
-0.0456637517,
-0.0100986054,
0.0018441757,
-0.0554455668,
-0.0040664314,
0.0752495229,
0.1145178303,
0.0257338155,
-0.0444828495,
0.0429420918,
0.0103322593,
-0.0108126104,
-0.0427503772,
0.0426288582,
-0.016670702,
0.038992539,
-0.0061948178,
0.0122341597,
0.0165929254,
-0.0223689564,
0.0329391249,
-0.0038969426,
0.0163752194,
-0.011396626,
-0.0550609119,
-0.0056990962,
0.0723700747,
-0.0422130935,
0.041330725,
0.0532849059,
-0.0349128917,
-0.0397619829,
-0.0397749767,
-0.0286347866,
-0.0445263796,
0.0646822006,
-0.0321217068,
0.0128549039,
0.0229188856,
0.0354091935,
-0.0153369019,
-0.0030963342,
-0.0596405715,
-0.0204435308,
0.0512848832,
-0.0733040348,
0.010036137,
-0.0010244495,
-0.043768473,
-0.0111459848,
-0.0654294491,
0.0116947386,
1.930842225e-34,
0.0026447109,
0.0286617186,
0.0101698758,
0.0105320364,
-0.0038482624,
0.0021718114,
-0.0327459611,
-0.0121633541,
-0.0276417416,
-0.0727361441,
-0.003966196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11485v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11485v2 | Explicit Syntactic Guidance for Neural Text Generation | 2023-06-20T12:16:31 | 2023-06-25T13:32:14 | Yafu Li, Leyang Cui, Jianhao Yan, Yongjing Yin, Wei Bi, Shuming Shi, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most existing text generation models follow the sequence-to-sequence
paradigm. Generative Grammar suggests that humans generate natural language
texts by learning language grammar. We propose a syntax-guided generation
schema, which generates the sequence guided by a constituency parse tree in a
top-down direction. The decoding process can be decomposed into two parts: (1)
predicting the infilling texts for each constituent in the lexicalized syntax
context given the source sentence; (2) mapping and expanding each constituent
to construct the next-level syntax context. Accordingly, we propose a
structural beam search method to find possible syntax structures
hierarchically. Experiments on paraphrase generation and machine translation
show that the proposed method outperforms autoregressive baselines, while also
demonstrating effectiveness in terms of interpretability, controllability, and
diversity. | [
0.0475394502,
0.0565341711,
-0.0170690697,
0.0011757424,
-0.0324509479,
-0.001954806,
-0.0030271169,
-0.0038585395,
-0.0047580837,
-0.0250872113,
0.0204928927,
-0.0343958065,
-0.0096905259,
0.0544803329,
0.0380761065,
-0.0664246976,
0.019930236,
-0.0097240768,
0.0089106895,
0.0198764,
-0.019460449,
0.0322998874,
0.0156505071,
0.0522491969,
-0.0263170451,
-0.0175570995,
-0.0231217947,
0.0351980403,
0.0011308282,
-0.03358078,
0.0361121409,
0.0033332189,
0.0156936664,
0.0116555439,
0.0000017573,
0.0068607009,
-0.0155488923,
-0.0108021107,
-0.0013082719,
-0.0089647789,
0.0613973215,
-0.0324945226,
0.0079049747,
0.0223763529,
-0.05177797,
-0.00055349,
0.0296321716,
-0.0131676709,
0.0949319825,
0.0721615925,
-0.0046761017,
-0.056336198,
0.0077372845,
-0.0177767891,
0.0276124775,
0.002477752,
-0.0321244411,
-0.0072898725,
-0.0105761429,
0.0464513861,
0.0057801735,
0.0226609018,
0.0403567031,
-0.0240691379,
0.0515609086,
0.0324998945,
-0.0061739692,
-0.0307416469,
0.0027105191,
0.0370097645,
-0.0097144796,
-0.0586277582,
0.0302043408,
-0.0161188189,
0.0040880726,
-0.027034685,
-0.0240733139,
0.0756097361,
-0.0248554703,
0.0207412038,
0.0783914253,
0.0046029445,
-0.0041504102,
0.0005474736,
0.0170960166,
0.0199911818,
0.0374647602,
-0.0042663445,
-0.0405821726,
0.0297329128,
-0.0105324248,
-0.0632081926,
0.0207430143,
0.0001313627,
-0.0619626679,
0.0308181494,
-0.1003658921,
-0.0645503104,
0.0038032092,
-0.0573543198,
0.0433725938,
0.0446351133,
0.0468561016,
-0.0152315618,
-0.0355545543,
0.0310265832,
-0.0428931862,
-0.0239618532,
-0.0822345614,
0.0053185006,
-0.0741667226,
-0.0165436864,
-0.064250052,
0.0100841671,
-0.0579459853,
-0.036716871,
-0.0325275622,
0.026354773,
0.0501055717,
-0.0234457459,
-0.0119720781,
0.0394310504,
-0.0664503351,
0.022285264,
0.0081245154,
-0.0206165332,
-0.0317819715,
-0.0345119163,
0.0209103227,
-0.0388332382,
-0.0357080288,
0.0849737823,
-0.0048939707,
-0.0371220969,
-0.0241606515,
0.0423113406,
-0.0482540838,
-0.0019256286,
-0.0360578597,
-0.0820339248,
-0.0206116922,
-0.0224527847,
0.0658749416,
-0.049559392,
0.0344663784,
0.0052536712,
-0.0536789298,
-0.0336593762,
0.0213796981,
0.0467810333,
-0.0088531962,
-0.0078403661,
-0.0150374714,
-0.0304598175,
0.0214565583,
-0.0217813142,
0.0012148792,
0.0175864231,
0.0325821415,
0.0685675591,
-0.0126126623,
0.0234097019,
-0.0276931655,
-0.0060135084,
0.0239620712,
-0.0134151056,
-0.0592079163,
0.013558493,
-0.002003812,
0.0371346064,
0.0235822927,
0.0348750502,
-0.032781031,
0.0126149151,
0.0206329953,
0.0100672105,
0.0247294866,
0.0529579371,
0.1184737682,
0.0205996837,
-0.028792873,
0.0205023326,
-0.003057282,
0.0394646451,
-0.0079442998,
0.0374305733,
-0.023728339,
0.0235987753,
-0.0119807366,
-0.0227849185,
0.0045411023,
0.0048294435,
-0.0033059742,
-0.0343361162,
-0.0020490251,
0.0688607171,
-0.0751153603,
0.0812483206,
-0.0032213,
-0.0782441646,
0.0248838589,
-0.0159086175,
-0.0094460072,
0.0486487634,
0.0403882563,
0.0477720387,
-0.0201201942,
0.0143740755,
0.003815044,
0.0939251706,
-0.0076466454,
0.0100884037,
0.0077099651,
-0.0421097726,
-0.0172223393,
-0.037827611,
0.0090390099,
0.0074058096,
-0.0065892721,
-0.0397532843,
0.0462914109,
-0.0217388496,
-0.0523967296,
0.0712316409,
-0.0207753647,
-0.0036470937,
0.0467054024,
-0.0137515329,
0.036012657,
0.0112376837,
-0.014586227,
0.0381354056,
0.0188557934,
-0.0287891869,
-0.0247884057,
0.029222874,
-0.0945577249,
-0.0721633807,
-0.039231807,
-0.0626909509,
0.0055917823,
-0.0302587152,
-0.0230695605,
-0.0517414622,
0.0238712411,
-0.0933079571,
0.0043675709,
-0.0558212958,
0.0054836888,
0.0262502674,
-0.0032842928,
-0.0222582426,
0.1055147275,
0.0120742377,
-0.0207779463,
0.0156454407,
0.0150935231,
0.0264544934,
-0.0137898093,
0.0269233268,
-0.0138049861,
0.0002475413,
-0.0302773714,
0.0278469957,
0.056917984,
-0.0342121087,
-0.0316840112,
-0.0444759689,
0.000080744,
-0.0332561657,
-0.0031377093,
0.067881681,
0.0140404133,
0.0310335886,
-0.0297934022,
-0.0326938555,
0.0557090044,
0.0355297178,
-0.0061719911,
0.0574890822,
0.0098121893,
-0.0250229388,
-0.037677221,
-0.0098703494,
-0.0291418247,
0.0480627082,
0.0642995462,
-0.0205509625,
-0.0572495051,
0.0547848195,
-0.007637281,
-0.0129910344,
0.0189154577,
-0.0586075075,
0.0183861926,
-0.0484023318,
0.0308512896,
0.0644050837,
0.0307406057,
0.0119232964,
0.0214638524,
0.000425242,
-0.0342190936,
0.0012012714,
-0.0331678167,
0.0305542797,
-0.0093615809,
-0.048478175,
0.0499964282,
0.0792311355,
0.057511881,
0.0143343098,
-0.0675745979,
0.0281566549,
0.0130654881,
-0.0177578665,
0.0055429498,
-0.0166167356,
-0.0138333617,
0.02122752,
-0.0211713277,
-0.0279215369,
0.0601812229,
-0.0080921091,
-0.0104932981,
-0.0516706966,
-0.0048984243,
-0.0239524171,
0.0343674049,
0.0405087546,
0.0401045829,
0.0283086486,
-0.0357426889,
-0.0295517426,
0.0196522325,
0.0156380478,
0.0257245228,
0.0084971599,
-0.0771760941,
-0.0053460887,
0.0045791655,
-0.0275008511,
-0.0488338433,
-0.0159967002,
0.0327543542,
0.0027360718,
0.0308531988,
-0.0023206451,
-0.0174533445,
-0.047023885,
-0.0071303663,
0.0493867286,
-0.0150088221,
-0.0176267698,
-0.0452345945,
0.0343266129,
0.0126457587,
0.0000841038,
0.0029932451,
-0.0270009991,
-0.0139363026,
0.0161114186,
-0.0007467965,
0.0448875763,
-0.0395226702,
0.016682392,
0.0061503942,
0.0021709313,
-0.0530248545,
0.024401376,
0.0159032866,
-0.0513362363,
-0.0556287505,
0.0889763013,
0.0367914103,
-0.009693413,
0.0118107768,
-0.0111537948,
0.063570708,
0.0082416972,
0.026689155,
-0.0511863008,
-0.0099174157,
0.0020320294,
0.012837166,
-0.0088073984,
-0.0124689303,
-0.0226576086,
-0.0776495337,
0.0433888994,
0.0118722813,
-0.0106610311,
0.0037854861,
0.0288128816,
-0.0485310666,
0.0189893264,
-0.0283512753,
0.0394234173,
-0.0295652542,
0.0499845967,
-0.0050910893,
-0.0212543886,
-0.0272561964,
-0.0290760994,
-0.0424629785,
0.0108269639,
0.096946381,
0.0277330261,
0.0400447436,
0.0105273752,
-0.0134527758,
-0.0453922376,
0.04961491,
-0.0182288364,
0.0176566727,
0.0186366644,
-0.0021032714,
-0.0316007771,
0.0529834777,
-0.0407797769,
0.0180620849,
0.0182144381,
0.0335742049,
-0.0380009264,
-0.0026579942,
-0.0067078639,
0.0402934551,
0.0238294117,
0.0653836578,
0.0426007099,
-0.0411951691,
-0.0556966364,
-0.0583663583,
0.0258139838,
-0.1150882989,
-0.0005725755,
0.0253953151,
0.0079562208,
0.0262961369,
-0.1179751754,
-0.0467550866,
-0.0058706328,
0.0211664699,
-0.0034417366,
-0.0141400769,
-0.0149266012,
-0.0619945601,
0.0004717247,
-0.0269315187,
0.0116972029,
-0.0165056065,
-0.0176441241,
-0.0221551005,
0.0158854164,
-0.0524468012,
-0.0176312681,
0.0335482508,
-0.0641418323,
-0.0402348191,
0.0245943051,
0.0763998628,
0.0087308157,
0.0082303165,
0.0047659646,
-0.0024068037,
0.0225700904,
0.046022661,
-0.0461958311,
0.0100267688,
-0.0013914997,
0.0110239806,
-0.01237146,
0.0381577983,
-0.0082093952,
-0.0005088777,
0.009912,
0.0537597239,
0.0119853448,
0.0060372814,
0.0565950312,
-0.0032404384,
0.0033755363,
-0.0405157954,
0.0006220945,
-0.0197015442,
-0.0035509081,
-0.0502924286,
-0.0062862523,
-0.0545443706,
0.0360520072,
0.0322796255,
0.0098079639,
0.0205587093,
0.0114458529,
-0.0291357562,
0.0745488778,
-0.0040910305,
0.0053877071,
0.0046581374,
0.0351684242,
0.0107677849,
-0.0010545474,
-0.0002846097,
0.0237002596,
-0.0373431519,
0.0217422582,
-0.0458266288,
0.0385243297,
0.0350519083,
-0.0077084987,
-0.0092638526,
0.0158808548,
-0.0558788776,
-0.0159153752,
-0.0317722224,
-0.014328233,
0.0524592623,
0.016712103,
0.0724351332,
-0.0583297312,
0.0167644471,
0.0299019832,
0.0797166303,
-0.0031526308,
-0.0688341185,
0.0048222058,
-0.0077179042,
-0.0064884922,
-0.0785036609,
0.0770285055,
0.0428731777,
0.0144019211,
0.016415365,
0.0254251119,
-0.055756975,
-0.0440619327,
0.000842403,
-0.0012470271,
-0.0066068536,
0.0137895225,
0.0024729893,
0.0005383777,
0.0287257619,
0.0260074679,
0.0172051042,
-0.0191407781,
0.0848784074,
0.0465232059,
-0.0234078262,
-0.0421984345,
-0.0533403158,
0.0275558345,
-0.0158862509,
-0.0341602378,
-0.0798303336,
-5.774052128e-33,
-0.0517635234,
-0.050714016,
0.0057685794,
0.021029219,
-0.0213871486,
-0.0369805545,
-0.068027474,
-0.0068872194,
0.0298157874,
-0.016383186,
0.0095260963,
0.0205010157,
0.0056033754,
0.0614230409,
0.0335625485,
0.0137230251,
0.0599547997,
-0.0475087501,
0.0066610849,
0.046061255,
0.0313843302,
0.0311491136,
0.0256810449,
-0.0279092826,
-0.0169425532,
-0.0199385658,
-0.005143363,
-0.0008717495,
-0.0080091758,
0.0263247062,
-0.0026702618,
0.008299022,
0.0120200356,
-0.0000699173,
-0.0352033451,
0.0139810145,
-0.0286832135,
-0.015159036,
-0.0005765358,
-0.0186939221,
-0.0735433623,
-0.0792230666,
0.01259379,
-0.0536684021,
-0.005910988,
0.0079140542,
0.0242881328,
-0.0155466348,
0.00095083,
-0.0217638165,
-0.0676063225,
-0.0199252404,
0.0086665973,
0.0162524767,
-0.0376053825,
0.09409675,
0.0008246634,
0.0176360682,
-0.0473179743,
0.0232862644,
-0.0291329566,
0.0490718633,
0.0127907153,
0.0157426465,
0.0176470894,
0.0346992575,
0.0231290627,
-0.013902545,
-0.0131268604,
0.0429534428,
-0.0051537566,
0.030095933,
0.0366728567,
0.0489430577,
0.0162970759,
0.0403915159,
-0.0413041674,
0.0016955192,
0.0121553605,
0.0420895405,
0.0098891417,
-0.0010304572,
0.021892745,
-0.0151541037,
-0.0309764296,
-0.0492536277,
-0.0065565468,
-0.0426773839,
0.0385943912,
0.0270694643,
-0.0085605197,
-0.0476587452,
0.0461746007,
0.0266134683,
0.0395195708,
0.049254436,
-0.0474000648,
0.0094374241,
0.0132735474,
0.0290300716,
-0.0393371992,
-0.0542788319,
0.0430778824,
0.0191628672,
0.0260535926,
0.0136125302,
0.0028859493,
0.0155701553,
-0.0077686966,
0.0242764857,
-0.0548946857,
0.0277985744,
-0.0249696411,
0.0108063444,
0.0318918042,
0.0030447645,
-0.0156817921,
0.0506061986,
-0.0132389022,
0.0032049813,
-0.0328077152,
-0.0141404076,
0.0156535916,
0.0413096063,
-0.026922835,
0.0254452173,
-0.0456048436,
0.004794728,
0.0442807525,
-0.0516835861,
-0.0145530049,
0.0419878624,
2.507e-7,
0.0240365434,
0.053388644,
0.0553161316,
0.0772888958,
0.0175949149,
0.0336728059,
0.0308175739,
0.0356323496,
-0.0312347487,
-0.0171265434,
-0.0163977463,
-0.0258157309,
0.0383187383,
-0.0012081014,
-0.1048896387,
0.0606251396,
-0.0747020245,
-0.0089966292,
-0.0352151431,
-0.0229311679,
0.0828554407,
0.0435523316,
-0.0527183041,
-0.009564694,
0.0219216142,
-0.0197154786,
0.0784129351,
0.015539417,
-0.038172558,
-0.0072311712,
-0.0269281175,
-0.0125358431,
-0.0489415638,
0.0118926177,
-0.0270239376,
-0.0258040167,
-0.0202744473,
0.0364229009,
0.0262479298,
-0.0012114109,
0.0172005221,
-0.0050308458,
0.0109128682,
-0.0390878171,
0.0024741688,
-0.0757488459,
-0.0106276069,
0.0205402374,
-0.0158451442,
0.0440094993,
-0.0201697201,
-0.0463028625,
-0.0107581168,
-0.0147800287,
0.0195572339,
0.0028248292,
0.0096621923,
0.0019968413,
-0.0240461845,
-0.0119602457,
-0.0666998625,
0.0328722112,
-0.062688984,
0.0425188914,
0.0238443762,
-0.0151766594,
-0.0267391168,
2.37640716e-34,
0.0171202272,
-0.019352695,
0.0144125149,
-0.0107794972,
0.0373832621,
0.0183074139,
-0.0573513843,
0.0377315134,
0.0123404423,
-0.0631337836,
-0.0591682941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11477v1 | CATS: A Pragmatic Chinese Answer-to-Sequence Dataset with Large Scale and High Quality | 2023-06-20T12:02:26 | 2023-06-20T12:02:26 | Liang Li, Ruiying Geng, Chengyang Fang, Bing Li, Can Ma, Rongyu Cao, Binhua Li, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | There are three problems existing in the popular data-to-text datasets.
First, the large-scale datasets either contain noise or lack real application
scenarios. Second, the datasets close to real applications are relatively small
in size. Last, current datasets bias in the English language while leaving
other languages underexplored. To alleviate these limitations, in this paper,
we present CATS, a pragmatic Chinese answer-to-sequence dataset with large
scale and high quality. The dataset aims to generate textual descriptions for
the answer in the practical TableQA system. Further, to bridge the structural
gap between the input SQL and table and establish better semantic alignments,
we propose a Unified Graph Transformation approach to establish a joint
encoding space for the two hybrid knowledge resources and convert this task to
a graph-to-text problem. The experiment results demonstrate the effectiveness
of our proposed method. Further analysis on CATS attests to both the high
quality and challenges of the dataset. | [
0.0358242244,
0.0604558475,
-0.0112102777,
0.0221940316,
-0.0301169306,
0.0030160346,
-0.0438749678,
0.0150271263,
0.0196844712,
-0.0160857104,
0.0012035273,
-0.0075735422,
0.0253356285,
0.0356229581,
0.0212789793,
-0.0241411049,
0.0329503678,
0.0411837474,
0.000578541,
0.0167191569,
0.0290516857,
0.0178631619,
-0.0003901662,
0.0248683244,
-0.019279154,
-0.0146908266,
-0.042463731,
0.004742153,
-0.006529761,
-0.0072161024,
-0.0339192785,
0.0704029575,
-0.0030892573,
-0.0098710693,
0.0000015962,
-0.0275999699,
-0.0578508228,
0.0007642426,
-0.0219490509,
0.0140354857,
0.0089615537,
0.0012248103,
0.024562642,
0.0418487862,
-0.0548186563,
-0.0430511795,
0.0689593256,
0.0390970968,
0.0812510327,
0.1024806947,
-0.011789469,
-0.0508280694,
-0.0043894388,
0.0066416394,
0.0306648593,
-0.0340067595,
0.0059734993,
0.0529098772,
0.0508609936,
-0.0227268394,
-0.0196790844,
0.0212727152,
0.0054490943,
-0.0290123858,
-0.0195866171,
0.0032874246,
-0.0278379116,
0.023541946,
0.0114179282,
0.1043997109,
0.0182595849,
-0.0326719731,
0.0075972476,
0.0034308787,
0.0442214571,
0.0105313398,
-0.0138790943,
-0.0113892453,
-0.0204245672,
0.0125259627,
-0.0143018309,
-0.0248275939,
0.0064037433,
-0.0345400982,
-0.0725916326,
0.0147437947,
-0.0010436781,
-0.0338966064,
-0.0172775462,
-0.0349429362,
-0.0072350055,
-0.027049087,
0.009399442,
0.0581316911,
-0.06424243,
0.0453433059,
-0.0497567505,
-0.0037627609,
0.00279389,
-0.0496345647,
0.0352020487,
0.0339445248,
0.0156685542,
-0.0007159655,
-0.0339842401,
0.0384744108,
0.0163419712,
0.0201509725,
-0.0815845802,
-0.0362518616,
-0.0714838654,
0.0068989997,
-0.0665845871,
0.0556007437,
-0.0505594201,
-0.0266050063,
-0.0279395413,
0.0363923907,
0.0094648628,
0.03432348,
0.04356388,
0.0359868631,
-0.0151417553,
0.0163809806,
-0.0315972082,
0.0324412994,
-0.0121590849,
0.0017321949,
-0.008939079,
-0.0403679945,
0.0031624443,
0.0179329384,
0.0595810972,
-0.024294965,
-0.008766925,
0.0900515169,
-0.0144583806,
0.017362928,
-0.0308757368,
-0.0414940827,
-0.0275206752,
-0.0209162384,
-0.0150434235,
-0.0543007813,
0.0399368145,
0.0186688639,
-0.0020546436,
-0.0582705475,
0.0351295583,
0.0443277247,
-0.0052504651,
0.0573294163,
-0.0502818525,
0.0204981659,
-0.0145256557,
-0.0258879308,
0.0273230039,
0.0454453714,
0.0533567816,
0.0000656412,
0.0497287735,
-0.0513009578,
-0.0340564027,
0.0281082802,
0.0523485094,
-0.0039353231,
-0.021236388,
0.0803138986,
0.000572766,
0.0303136166,
-0.031878531,
0.0596509166,
0.0077461293,
0.0091847619,
0.0256976783,
0.0070438092,
0.0174792949,
0.0238867868,
-0.018847527,
0.0337142758,
0.0092981625,
0.0109904967,
-0.010642183,
0.0246631801,
0.017404981,
0.0691636652,
0.058788307,
-0.03927432,
-0.0300698355,
-0.0529972836,
-0.0192870069,
0.0166800655,
0.0295536797,
0.0227782428,
0.0057615712,
0.0328073055,
-0.0464229658,
0.0153798778,
-0.0184071921,
-0.0543722399,
-0.0004690228,
0.0022933357,
0.0001366811,
0.0491278432,
0.0146087985,
-0.0254744906,
-0.0031113941,
0.0203653872,
0.000129717,
0.0140401721,
0.0160618238,
-0.0591197237,
-0.0618832707,
-0.0370119512,
-0.024504086,
0.0518763512,
-0.0258008558,
-0.048501458,
0.0142150708,
0.0244706385,
0.0180748645,
-0.0404817536,
-0.078754954,
0.0203991719,
0.005374481,
-0.0090704793,
0.00993005,
-0.0004566228,
0.0181677341,
0.070601806,
-0.0299819037,
0.0616975799,
0.0443668216,
-0.0030669707,
-0.0179321673,
-0.0087563628,
-0.0116022155,
-0.0451998524,
0.0632262826,
-0.0379237384,
-0.0340914316,
-0.0108484253,
-0.0737405494,
-0.0794869959,
-0.0197003055,
-0.0570913367,
-0.0206600539,
-0.0425521098,
0.0152970962,
0.0136881629,
0.0026315984,
-0.0162303988,
0.0568549111,
0.0200201198,
0.0378772393,
0.0147438487,
-0.0235478524,
0.0265208241,
-0.0603698939,
0.0287698749,
0.0224338863,
0.0032508047,
0.0272795744,
0.0204206426,
0.0331266262,
-0.0511300042,
0.0180729553,
-0.0680833384,
0.0183914341,
-0.0260860454,
0.0405956618,
0.0533719473,
0.0100205271,
0.0068516335,
-0.0332979932,
-0.0985515267,
0.008075932,
0.0065462962,
-0.009504973,
0.0679684058,
-0.0156352744,
0.0005995214,
-0.020556327,
-0.0274782404,
-0.0093299979,
0.0191988237,
-0.017255852,
-0.0392095707,
-0.0256457515,
0.0108646443,
-0.0101501681,
0.0201079883,
0.0353859328,
-0.0236403961,
-0.0087842895,
0.0016781905,
0.009094297,
0.0000023988,
0.0205828864,
-0.0268848035,
-0.0106004244,
-0.0083712926,
0.0034357505,
-0.0026936429,
-0.0259178877,
-0.0025021106,
-0.008424704,
-0.0867574736,
0.0042070234,
-0.007762148,
0.0192786753,
-0.0041972534,
-0.0683682635,
-0.0232443605,
0.0261415429,
0.0296801738,
-0.0721642449,
0.0450754724,
-0.0070996713,
-0.0029819901,
-0.0088914698,
0.0312265567,
0.0587102845,
-0.0377426259,
0.0116417967,
-0.0557850897,
-0.0031647047,
-0.0484121777,
0.0728468448,
-0.0010061063,
0.0325742103,
-0.0162550118,
-0.0320494361,
-0.0821314827,
-0.0239436291,
-0.0081802402,
-0.042129986,
0.0535592958,
-0.0284310319,
0.031427376,
-0.0463657454,
0.0194432326,
-0.0239893161,
0.0005411059,
-0.0079003572,
0.0362409167,
0.0558839738,
-0.038077794,
0.031348709,
0.0224343631,
-0.0079430677,
0.0254172385,
-0.011079194,
0.0109295258,
-0.0165761672,
0.0490295514,
0.0795854703,
0.0641796589,
-0.028592715,
0.0176521987,
0.0339789502,
0.0664822087,
0.0218803678,
-0.0164422747,
0.032344345,
-0.0245756805,
-0.0090188868,
-0.053734459,
0.0018695462,
0.0509689264,
-0.0178545844,
-0.018364653,
-0.0061657038,
0.0815643221,
0.0232671928,
0.0269932002,
0.0113737406,
0.0358632207,
0.0126059065,
0.0213626157,
0.0279612187,
-0.1670913845,
-0.0288430434,
-0.039009776,
0.0120344087,
0.025477346,
-0.019221345,
-0.0194969345,
-0.1287240982,
0.0078035081,
-0.0133411204,
-0.0728500113,
-0.0707334131,
-0.0061461767,
-0.0258847997,
0.0069685369,
0.009739493,
0.0498135798,
-0.0186581463,
0.017906595,
0.0252211876,
-0.0032835607,
-0.0044382056,
-0.0038423568,
-0.0154340761,
0.0200576894,
0.0286541861,
0.0391816646,
0.0230604988,
0.0087888986,
-0.0026068762,
-0.0256148875,
-0.0267654955,
-0.0003676844,
0.0283171404,
-0.0061462969,
-0.010987821,
0.0130817033,
0.014511684,
-0.0709297583,
0.0185334813,
0.0800716504,
0.058087226,
-0.0218543727,
0.0007964309,
-0.0126763992,
0.0042984211,
0.0087709762,
0.0472939499,
0.0317791477,
0.0011524911,
-0.0548096746,
-0.0149531281,
-0.0356795229,
-0.0549128912,
-0.0306912232,
0.0704190359,
-0.0473494492,
0.0012123422,
-0.098405838,
-0.0284437854,
0.0361552946,
0.0275129601,
0.0038025833,
0.0248384662,
0.0302268676,
-0.0130537115,
-0.0814567804,
-0.0431853421,
-0.0165766347,
0.0109725855,
-0.0548293516,
-0.0121214492,
-0.0126017826,
-0.0040336284,
0.0035829425,
-0.0059810495,
-0.012958752,
-0.0404658616,
-0.0198651925,
-0.0127718234,
0.0078529567,
0.0091176797,
0.0079861917,
0.0152447,
0.0276766792,
0.0010113681,
-0.0412819982,
-0.038509205,
0.0027384502,
-0.0298894867,
-0.0251527298,
0.0289216377,
-0.035960976,
-0.0163715873,
-0.0234642662,
0.0628178418,
0.0062051187,
-0.0059025898,
0.0567167699,
0.0688534752,
-0.0385180302,
0.0352552868,
-0.0266741421,
0.0124155963,
0.0774827674,
-0.082099542,
-0.0765523985,
-0.0174299628,
-0.0098462906,
0.0065390631,
-0.0236021355,
0.0207609106,
-0.0384323038,
-0.0164616331,
0.0279459525,
0.0139559405,
0.0054564751,
0.049819015,
-0.0040647346,
0.0140419407,
-0.0357695036,
-0.0058331992,
-0.0136125032,
0.0224441513,
0.045345556,
-0.005797863,
0.0279766116,
0.0226084907,
-0.0033393968,
0.0135804936,
0.0318531059,
-0.0256304555,
-0.0208362043,
-0.0178041719,
-0.0054188692,
0.0439943299,
0.0333474502,
0.0224857181,
-0.0166363344,
-0.0130238738,
-0.0212351084,
0.0582828,
0.0323302299,
-0.0256998986,
0.0150814867,
0.0077081406,
-0.0394533724,
-0.0321379229,
0.0782435015,
0.0251765326,
-0.0135369012,
0.0013265155,
-0.0418668017,
-0.0319148935,
-0.0413812995,
0.0025956277,
-0.0006122024,
-0.0218494255,
-0.0420403443,
-0.034516409,
-0.0775391459,
-0.0180595759,
0.0369660817,
0.004126023,
0.022000432,
0.0402491055,
0.0092515284,
0.071593903,
-0.0153028676,
-0.0540202223,
0.0693755969,
-0.0408462025,
-0.0295697711,
-0.0084186615,
-5.226543227e-33,
-0.0372564197,
-0.0627422705,
0.0072092311,
-0.0275984854,
0.016050728,
-0.0195410587,
-0.0100019146,
-0.0208280478,
-0.0329807997,
-0.0010001875,
-0.0429586619,
0.0404297523,
0.0312542729,
0.054838866,
-0.0128843747,
-0.0417237803,
0.0180902537,
-0.0137300594,
0.0170697737,
0.0214410163,
0.0621234402,
-0.0041699819,
0.0516923815,
-0.0351535752,
0.0464495756,
-0.0211231746,
0.0102559794,
0.0110993497,
0.018091023,
0.0373453163,
-0.0001749096,
0.0836337134,
0.0117082624,
-0.0041501462,
-0.0248667058,
0.0141508318,
-0.121340625,
-0.0397023968,
0.0288212467,
0.0280588251,
-0.0189181957,
-0.0228401609,
0.0220404584,
-0.0433816426,
0.0154404659,
0.0020078188,
0.025099922,
-0.0354189985,
-0.017645143,
-0.0340574756,
-0.0181635357,
0.0286623929,
0.0054424652,
0.0336118117,
-0.0102980863,
0.0649631321,
-0.0113333045,
-0.05512546,
-0.0461954959,
0.0270973649,
0.0196898207,
0.0592001081,
0.0336416177,
0.0074626785,
0.0306830965,
-0.0269964095,
0.0114168674,
-0.0211298913,
0.0179991666,
0.0606668964,
-0.0640018731,
0.0505180396,
0.0421454124,
0.0312912539,
-0.0040075183,
-0.0067864,
-0.0782526359,
0.0412439071,
-0.0308164209,
0.0105753439,
-0.0330261849,
-0.0229551252,
-0.0163936093,
-0.0382917114,
-0.000402254,
0.0460621491,
-0.0252542607,
-0.0564571656,
0.0244095903,
-0.0389110856,
-0.0158582181,
-0.0057528089,
0.005825839,
-0.0494601429,
-0.0508605689,
0.0559845939,
-0.0255823452,
-0.0051636747,
-0.0146473767,
0.0281523373,
-0.0478518829,
-0.0349685661,
0.0468918793,
-0.0227688625,
0.0127383126,
0.0244626794,
0.0274704546,
0.0241802372,
-0.0690454915,
0.0219081063,
-0.0051084952,
0.0172375366,
-0.0338454172,
-0.0143008363,
-0.0010154928,
0.0076782429,
0.0112039689,
0.0257326141,
0.0036286619,
0.0084330132,
-0.0064370665,
-0.0030348364,
0.0110267904,
0.0177421737,
0.0027627298,
0.0392734036,
-0.0343987271,
0.0291642752,
0.0115815941,
-0.0158505943,
0.0067874906,
0.0233650077,
2.324e-7,
0.0810564831,
-0.0200455692,
0.097941719,
0.0735070035,
-0.021506235,
-0.0057237409,
0.0003020242,
0.0575714633,
-0.0056868941,
-0.0016930421,
0.0750017017,
-0.0300713535,
0.0307612438,
0.0261137541,
-0.0725394487,
-0.0185543057,
-0.0566634275,
-0.0010189802,
-0.0485988669,
0.0656878725,
0.0996431336,
0.0882241875,
-0.0615924485,
0.0297292713,
-0.0185165498,
-0.0248487387,
-0.0064997356,
0.0043534655,
0.0081944605,
0.0317678489,
0.0138730612,
-0.0467080735,
-0.0116083603,
0.0297239553,
-0.0244530886,
0.0106617631,
0.013064906,
0.041246064,
0.0038499085,
-0.014778208,
-0.0162766259,
-0.0676701665,
0.0445227697,
-0.0272666551,
0.0870843157,
-0.0335644633,
-0.0436927862,
0.0485870764,
-0.0258142147,
-0.0173026863,
-0.0040016039,
0.0141143976,
0.0126949558,
0.0091002658,
0.0521580577,
0.0123092299,
0.0169292334,
-0.0453306474,
-0.0517968386,
0.0119998492,
0.0155151412,
-0.0209940858,
0.0133830411,
-0.0063647013,
-0.0256550033,
-0.0156892035,
-0.0164823104,
2.153272159e-34,
0.0161173008,
0.0096002789,
0.0109848594,
0.0137276268,
0.0382496342,
-0.0654413849,
0.0172849018,
0.013818616,
0.0324411318,
-0.0920666382,
-0.0596560203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11473v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11473v1 | Timestamped Embedding-Matching Acoustic-to-Word CTC ASR | 2023-06-20T11:53:43 | 2023-06-20T11:53:43 | Woojay Jeon | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | In this work, we describe a novel method of training an embedding-matching
word-level connectionist temporal classification (CTC) automatic speech
recognizer (ASR) such that it directly produces word start times and durations,
required by many real-world applications, in addition to the transcription. The
word timestamps enable the ASR to output word segmentations and word confusion
networks without relying on a secondary model or forced alignment process when
testing. Our proposed system has similar word segmentation accuracy as a hybrid
DNN-HMM (Deep Neural Network-Hidden Markov Model) system, with less than 3ms
difference in mean absolute error in word start times on TIMIT data. At the
same time, we observed less than 5% relative increase in the word error rate
compared to the non-timestamped system when using the same audio training data
and nearly identical model size. We also contribute more rigorous analysis of
multiple-hypothesis embedding-matching ASR in general. | [
-0.0424465239,
0.067919597,
0.0438991077,
0.0236182641,
-0.0239954535,
-0.0090658814,
0.0637726486,
-0.0316182934,
-0.0608290583,
0.0103293136,
0.01903891,
-0.0481786653,
0.0672536492,
0.0070401966,
-0.0200572722,
-0.0020911144,
0.040950194,
0.0150563754,
-0.0215441845,
-0.0101668956,
0.0123147555,
0.0043743625,
-0.0732679814,
0.0292453449,
-0.0256450884,
-0.0016961612,
-0.0253897924,
-0.0190495607,
0.045739945,
-0.0692583248,
-0.0404219478,
-0.0072556855,
0.0408227704,
0.060042467,
0.0000016624,
-0.0170743018,
-0.0403616317,
-0.0023954182,
-0.0448239893,
-0.0172060058,
0.0220924541,
0.0256478619,
-0.0166187081,
0.0501704961,
0.0103729079,
-0.0231646821,
0.0150213996,
0.0269095432,
-0.015360523,
0.0577215217,
-0.0056863367,
-0.0303556733,
0.0523803942,
-0.0136226239,
0.0120187849,
0.0018777525,
-0.031170303,
0.011536492,
0.0126014827,
-0.0653559789,
0.0040337788,
0.0495027713,
0.0120806526,
0.0061178273,
0.0202591587,
0.0425688736,
-0.0376337916,
0.0078160018,
-0.0227863509,
0.0480080433,
-0.0049116621,
-0.0350753553,
0.0108868619,
-0.0088555617,
-0.0358689614,
-0.0042900541,
0.0190391522,
-0.0146562103,
0.0516950339,
0.0214936733,
0.0328543223,
0.0465154573,
0.0522008911,
-0.0026090029,
-0.0147066657,
0.0161253419,
0.0112531697,
-0.0616010092,
-0.017162174,
-0.036557503,
0.0471504554,
-0.0090744924,
0.0462087132,
0.0002710468,
0.0079839267,
0.0035131017,
-0.0292061586,
-0.0376377702,
-0.0261613522,
-0.047733739,
-0.0112021146,
0.0654097423,
-0.02394283,
0.0340974294,
-0.0359609164,
0.0302900374,
-0.014139262,
-0.007890434,
-0.0028535137,
0.004499875,
-0.0336730853,
-0.0136607904,
-0.0139660835,
-0.0109768836,
0.0305925347,
-0.0238615479,
-0.0453025736,
0.0374338739,
0.0060844258,
-0.0015635723,
-0.0120112151,
-0.0013798772,
-0.0652900189,
-0.0108803771,
0.0118698571,
-0.012648616,
0.016577933,
0.0350750946,
-0.0188014805,
-0.0404944308,
-0.0187527146,
0.0185156297,
0.0493803062,
-0.0181973502,
0.0205513053,
-0.0017745224,
-0.0459451079,
-0.0319364741,
-0.0317746475,
0.0026645472,
-0.0341711938,
0.0140895899,
-0.0046351822,
-0.045071695,
0.0456280261,
-0.0365896113,
0.0061357603,
0.0025574486,
-0.0151089905,
-0.0320051387,
0.0336862281,
0.0931005999,
0.0356890559,
0.0057681049,
0.0638060421,
-0.0098183975,
0.0436804667,
0.0272081234,
0.095400475,
-0.0349157117,
-0.0061110458,
-0.0162118208,
-0.0388905816,
0.031819094,
-0.0053151445,
-0.0402541161,
-0.0810799971,
-0.0224597845,
0.008906452,
0.0578854457,
0.0336081609,
0.0098053133,
0.0037192686,
-0.0024137076,
0.0309026521,
0.0491874292,
0.0264988448,
0.02092609,
0.0353218392,
0.0116367945,
-0.022132881,
-0.0369070619,
-0.0079322206,
-0.0107296892,
-0.0009425935,
0.0467898361,
0.0092269238,
0.0057714912,
-0.0005556698,
0.0164045617,
-0.0163810514,
-0.0242525898,
0.0062360154,
0.004844801,
0.0483129323,
-0.0246428177,
-0.066756703,
0.0416997634,
-0.0452671424,
-0.0167215038,
0.0061241011,
-0.020300271,
0.0094822934,
0.0337124467,
0.0296664443,
-0.0472156927,
-0.0170098711,
-0.0500409678,
-0.0346743315,
0.0815724432,
0.0275148805,
0.0038067347,
0.0042950218,
-0.0669021383,
0.0039304853,
0.0459670462,
-0.0138780214,
0.0443369299,
-0.0083094016,
0.0721385628,
0.0346488953,
-0.0238286741,
0.0376190171,
0.0107685002,
-0.0047764881,
-0.022546161,
-0.0034081792,
0.0336134136,
0.0883112848,
0.0374914259,
-0.0129534444,
-0.0115918061,
0.0276901349,
-0.0449429303,
-0.007029443,
0.0389514938,
-0.1014702544,
-0.064287439,
0.048355747,
0.0016435413,
0.0188062694,
0.0578571111,
0.0245557949,
-0.0877432749,
0.039854385,
0.0188847054,
0.0518750027,
-0.0390525982,
0.0488283262,
0.0262086354,
0.0394505002,
0.0539827533,
-0.0134907234,
-0.0347256102,
-0.0152239315,
0.0140284533,
0.001613158,
-0.0237227883,
-0.0589353591,
-0.0573432893,
0.0309616793,
-0.0184157249,
-0.0188691448,
-0.0376789831,
-0.0234006159,
-0.0211650431,
-0.0141792661,
-0.0822064877,
0.0099177985,
-0.0073141288,
0.0145370029,
-0.0389907435,
-0.0058579934,
0.0218143333,
-0.0039401148,
-0.0444204621,
-0.0064813136,
0.0013754531,
-0.0178636685,
-0.0259960163,
-0.0101137301,
-0.0704932287,
-0.0377443992,
0.0072648907,
-0.0295053944,
0.0288970582,
-0.0160099119,
-0.0394390672,
-0.0308646336,
0.0161280483,
0.0280956067,
0.055523403,
-0.0159986876,
-0.0094462577,
0.0030365332,
0.0000659949,
0.0256415028,
0.0430780686,
0.0290037803,
0.0031153024,
0.020725878,
0.0042504887,
-0.0315604582,
0.0154766943,
0.0203742888,
0.0878668725,
0.0014942847,
-0.0079354057,
-0.0810261667,
0.0762596801,
0.0089123752,
0.0636546686,
-0.0401373766,
-0.0183214284,
-0.030942969,
-0.0399932638,
0.0039855386,
-0.0090121208,
-0.0685771033,
-0.0244166236,
-0.0215002503,
-0.0110554611,
0.0345615409,
-0.0716193095,
-0.0424464792,
-0.0078300796,
-0.0769650266,
-0.0004812732,
0.0314857773,
0.0057236138,
-0.0293898713,
-0.0245716609,
-0.0319756977,
-0.0383646898,
-0.0028827605,
0.0095909601,
-0.0642168894,
0.0232144538,
0.0027060229,
0.0069501903,
-0.0208882522,
-0.0268690195,
-0.0459891222,
-0.061671894,
-0.0298539661,
0.0133368326,
-0.009036459,
-0.0223971475,
-0.0292575508,
0.0343793221,
-0.0275060013,
0.063255541,
0.0256014019,
0.0190733653,
-0.0378471725,
0.0699755475,
0.0214010514,
0.0304587819,
-0.0051804143,
0.0202282406,
0.0436803065,
-0.0337879695,
0.1127830297,
-0.0143422168,
-0.091086857,
-0.026410874,
0.0134116793,
-0.012273402,
0.0013749946,
0.0004060844,
-0.0071363915,
-0.0461424254,
-0.0000462263,
0.125524655,
0.0190621018,
-0.0170003697,
-0.0324870497,
0.0311018638,
-0.0195066687,
-0.0168033615,
-0.0371624753,
-0.0524365045,
-0.0163593274,
0.0413080044,
0.0323693492,
0.0187301636,
0.0276308879,
-0.0405533276,
-0.0522237085,
-0.0039031031,
0.0200405437,
-0.06112995,
0.017533524,
-0.021215992,
-0.0443567149,
-0.023088716,
0.053658966,
-0.0006893758,
-0.0159185193,
-0.0258498397,
0.0345835648,
-0.089800097,
-0.0470171012,
0.0289806277,
-0.0035418551,
0.0887069777,
0.0371164642,
0.0257665496,
-0.039576035,
-0.0352555774,
0.0437327921,
0.0291109011,
-0.0281084925,
0.0200343952,
-0.0061445176,
-0.041816432,
0.0004179673,
0.0572027974,
0.0405385345,
-0.0135638826,
-0.0020579668,
-0.0159410518,
0.0754236579,
-0.0064442889,
0.0174769275,
0.0072883228,
0.0100863008,
-0.0055546733,
0.0704572722,
-0.0123860678,
-0.0432579108,
-0.0184698943,
0.0603387244,
0.0435313098,
-0.044724524,
0.0240610894,
-0.0050045787,
-0.0008640223,
-0.019367082,
-0.020496117,
-0.0472680889,
-0.013057095,
0.0026759768,
0.0311751496,
-0.0094036236,
-0.0278814044,
0.0112751583,
-0.0767189786,
0.0292777326,
0.0045929872,
0.038788829,
-0.0731118992,
0.0359064154,
0.0272288956,
-0.0360257775,
-0.0156990886,
0.0344551355,
-0.0894508958,
-0.0374328494,
0.0307957269,
-0.0881026238,
0.0032204902,
0.0821262151,
-0.0218004566,
-0.0249976218,
0.0719687939,
-0.0251507144,
0.0042977454,
-0.0016056512,
0.0531835631,
0.011612921,
-0.0173401013,
-0.0045858496,
-0.0787130147,
0.0146228625,
-0.0388835147,
-0.0110860225,
-0.0243027247,
0.0132155018,
-0.0102443863,
0.0032374854,
0.0778449029,
-0.0131614339,
0.052983202,
-0.0489976145,
0.0172547344,
0.0133452602,
0.0678783655,
-0.0112719191,
0.0073287175,
0.0193935428,
0.0136778848,
-0.0188671555,
0.0002674386,
0.0022010901,
-0.021729555,
-0.0026940224,
0.0747461393,
0.0363033079,
0.0098319063,
0.0241060648,
-0.0046330541,
-0.0089066736,
0.0332834013,
-0.0045167808,
0.0138703063,
0.0070438064,
0.0338643864,
-0.0078762295,
0.0190894939,
-0.0161217805,
-0.0013236431,
-0.025978623,
0.0305809863,
-0.0113021377,
0.0313864499,
0.0538666807,
-0.0292804539,
0.0316126794,
0.0055823927,
0.0212830175,
-0.0046598758,
0.0125766695,
-0.0130241169,
-0.0125830257,
0.0433358699,
0.0133135598,
-0.0257155858,
0.0488026589,
0.0205301996,
-0.0067434292,
0.0274315793,
-0.0135003189,
0.01294953,
-0.0343526565,
0.0257798862,
-0.0368113406,
0.0238461848,
-0.0410220213,
-0.029656373,
-0.0183738247,
-0.0428160727,
0.069835864,
0.0062245601,
0.0201571044,
0.0333328061,
-0.0194472708,
0.0201987009,
-0.030938806,
-0.0208899342,
0.0443464331,
-0.0102919145,
0.0367810018,
-0.0507888831,
-0.0311785936,
-5.993383211e-33,
0.0009044804,
0.0124358749,
-0.0066123926,
-0.0282048229,
-0.0302247927,
0.0467792302,
0.0119540682,
0.0033091286,
0.0055818832,
-0.0103285396,
-0.0502801277,
0.0362109728,
0.0407999083,
0.0271855742,
-0.0000180863,
0.0107438806,
0.0933864489,
-0.0587307848,
0.0076808142,
-0.0271870326,
0.0620122328,
0.0320950598,
0.0271804463,
0.0067445077,
-0.0191633888,
0.0172164403,
0.0204530302,
-0.0060565672,
0.0608353093,
0.0371435545,
-0.0380690508,
0.0105778165,
0.009518276,
-0.020361321,
-0.010156218,
0.0448711179,
-0.1278378218,
-0.0022662471,
-0.0281271674,
0.0438384674,
-0.0067099743,
-0.0161447506,
0.0038754209,
0.0109613631,
-0.0193910114,
-0.0286025871,
0.0176657233,
-0.0284108557,
-0.0291792694,
-0.0668274462,
0.0186033063,
0.0523225069,
-0.0350063033,
-0.0092213349,
0.0837113708,
-0.0021191081,
0.0269598644,
-0.0306676067,
-0.101798743,
0.0327666663,
0.0010403614,
-0.0150274932,
0.0591351427,
0.0512609296,
-0.005867898,
0.0338994227,
0.0117135383,
-0.0488681085,
0.0446866937,
-0.0099553512,
0.024332663,
-0.0262930058,
0.0159558095,
-0.0431093387,
0.0629402399,
-0.0251935739,
-0.0092027662,
-0.0192687288,
0.0801590607,
-0.0244698562,
0.0480204001,
0.0570390075,
-0.1019932553,
0.0288958941,
-0.037417911,
-0.0194405969,
-0.0257348157,
-0.0061616618,
0.0720561072,
0.0165666025,
0.0180008095,
0.007662659,
0.0704579949,
-0.0215902682,
0.0346767567,
-0.0057041519,
-0.0153207872,
-0.0341972597,
-0.0056679188,
0.0290435906,
-0.0528546721,
-0.0116303051,
0.0381909646,
0.0225458741,
0.022754686,
-0.0301889479,
-0.0434356332,
0.0399159268,
-0.0541973934,
0.0143738184,
0.0140011618,
-0.0113539491,
-0.0015097603,
-0.0296608452,
0.0817999169,
-0.0203424618,
0.0062924391,
0.029537661,
0.0056122025,
0.0178063586,
0.0141714038,
0.0027015072,
-0.0343336985,
0.0434236266,
-0.0261943247,
0.0264556222,
0.0399144553,
0.0225027185,
0.0574965626,
-0.0132271349,
0.0225977581,
0.0133534754,
2.588e-7,
-0.0535577238,
-0.002842071,
0.0310483146,
-0.0210030209,
0.0293689556,
-0.0154122422,
0.0061526508,
-0.010864649,
-0.0646042824,
0.0279580597,
0.0552902706,
-0.0404387861,
0.0892444849,
0.035678912,
-0.0508093126,
-0.0473759398,
-0.086288549,
0.057312578,
-0.0278462116,
-0.023648046,
-0.0034106071,
0.0998295248,
0.0236609671,
-0.0264888331,
-0.0221942365,
-0.0739916563,
-0.0003531549,
-0.0054320553,
-0.0049925311,
-0.0321563669,
0.0259135719,
-0.0025156424,
-0.0301059056,
0.0147956731,
-0.0364203677,
0.0722229481,
0.0016186606,
-0.0038260845,
-0.0183328334,
-0.0470577404,
-0.0183465276,
0.0165455509,
-0.0591036156,
0.0012498873,
0.0566540435,
-0.0291233994,
-0.0148156807,
-0.0347984098,
-0.0461205281,
-0.0035829903,
0.0504571237,
0.0147213284,
0.0245372914,
-0.0093425559,
-0.0038560925,
-0.0230743252,
-0.0359954834,
-0.0801553577,
0.0208386723,
0.0299245268,
-0.0597527511,
0.0069737686,
-0.0084809372,
-0.0370666683,
0.0442189649,
0.0026787776,
-0.019036321,
1.91520287e-34,
0.0131210461,
-0.0102457507,
-0.0167697892,
0.0172979645,
-0.0029071535,
-0.024754364,
0.037700545,
-0.009924558,
0.0153356697,
-0.0516851619,
-0.0370677561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11444v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11444v1 | Blackbird language matrices (BLM), a new task for rule-like generalization in neural networks: Motivations and Formal Specifications | 2023-06-20T10:45:56 | 2023-06-20T10:45:56 | Paola Merlo | cs.CL | cs.CL | We motivate and formally define a new task for fine-tuning rule-like
generalization in large language models. It is conjectured that the
shortcomings of current LLMs are due to a lack of ability to generalize. It has
been argued that, instead, humans are better at generalization because they
have a tendency at extracting rules from complex data. We try to recreate this
tendency to rule-based generalization. When exposed to tests of analytic
intelligence, for example, the visual RAVEN IQ test, human problem-solvers
identify the relevant objects in the picture and their relevant attributes and
reason based on rules applied to these objects and attributes. Based on the
induced rules, they are able to provide a solution to the test. We propose a
task that translates this IQ task into language. In this paper, we provide the
formal specification for the task and the generative process of its datasets. | [
0.0059164343,
0.0562374741,
-0.0486001223,
0.028337324,
-0.051518172,
0.0443530753,
0.0156711321,
0.0294269845,
-0.0343817025,
-0.0075910697,
-0.0057520056,
-0.0028393548,
0.0179203562,
0.0417850353,
0.0721461847,
-0.0469988361,
0.0121766273,
-0.0374982916,
0.040886905,
-0.0111471936,
-0.0425939113,
-0.0119470526,
-0.0139846643,
0.0235230606,
-0.0401021652,
-0.0136310328,
0.0101286974,
-0.0359001979,
-0.0059852921,
0.0076098246,
-0.0317791663,
0.0278730411,
0.0047432519,
-0.0001902295,
0.0000019568,
-0.0539203584,
0.055955708,
-0.0295894742,
0.007877592,
-0.0199860986,
-0.0040702056,
-0.0083360532,
0.0249035656,
-0.0102555873,
-0.074766852,
-0.0473476127,
0.0299088731,
0.0556319617,
0.0353366248,
0.0976495668,
-0.0053521846,
-0.0634901375,
0.0609456301,
-0.0007330697,
0.0458110198,
-0.0381366946,
0.0383751281,
0.0184169114,
0.0058361734,
-0.0401476249,
-0.0034972162,
0.0179233812,
0.0652100071,
0.0092654889,
0.0163800828,
0.0228559077,
0.0052497955,
-0.0091710743,
0.0042345407,
0.0465707183,
-0.004897574,
-0.0098878955,
-0.0011016288,
0.0326626264,
0.0473826192,
0.0082165971,
-0.0704085976,
0.0568573847,
0.0077547822,
0.0093226442,
0.0195076764,
-0.0206110235,
0.0402546711,
-0.0006069324,
-0.0408422984,
0.1055785939,
0.0069648093,
-0.0187915638,
0.0096133444,
0.0074420087,
-0.0150203165,
-0.0342990868,
-0.0053841961,
0.0496777296,
-0.0116130766,
-0.0268616322,
0.0266887378,
-0.0021207528,
-0.0217058603,
-0.0410023816,
0.102284424,
0.0344361849,
0.003164852,
0.0090281582,
-0.0786553398,
0.0678276941,
-0.0090383925,
0.0567657351,
-0.051403895,
0.0014303206,
-0.0585818179,
-0.0167464502,
-0.0184205677,
0.0467557311,
0.0052035232,
0.0038121319,
-0.0471344329,
0.0096013406,
-0.0658442006,
0.03144392,
-0.0411187671,
-0.0031694574,
0.0136774099,
-0.0106487665,
-0.0291816089,
-0.0679541454,
-0.0486175455,
0.0138289882,
-0.0045897183,
0.0039531495,
0.0119556664,
0.0123452256,
-0.0014339554,
-0.0021874837,
0.0032888197,
0.1106486842,
0.0233522207,
-0.0057276399,
-0.0613412,
-0.0153158261,
0.0159311015,
-0.047208298,
0.065267168,
-0.0398387797,
0.0210759863,
-0.0112623572,
-0.0248089153,
-0.0488223732,
-0.0392806269,
0.0215070546,
-0.0175728686,
0.0395276845,
-0.0209970083,
0.0026204563,
0.0239089821,
-0.0092453137,
0.0084546525,
0.0526473336,
0.0512762144,
-0.004084989,
0.0118359439,
-0.0293763652,
0.0459680706,
0.0299692936,
0.0069898828,
-0.0275583956,
-0.0840481669,
-0.0275713764,
-0.0152811399,
0.0336515605,
0.0158082582,
0.0698595345,
-0.0415289216,
0.0020273554,
0.0415567197,
0.0727190375,
0.0415243432,
0.0477940552,
0.076682426,
-0.0571051724,
0.0160545539,
0.0323292464,
-0.0537248328,
0.0398517661,
-0.0603892691,
-0.0021556024,
-0.0771228895,
0.0311604943,
-0.0263508148,
-0.0805161446,
-0.0076189688,
0.0280676465,
0.043732997,
-0.007046876,
0.0439604558,
-0.0007717434,
0.0142626725,
-0.0271527953,
0.0123405606,
-0.0252468176,
-0.0149414111,
-0.0758794174,
0.0616203249,
0.0469993986,
0.0182478204,
-0.0133797089,
0.0195364766,
-0.0051615527,
0.0211272575,
0.0276241433,
0.0338193625,
-0.0171180721,
-0.0169172697,
-0.047554791,
-0.0084091239,
-0.0079221148,
0.0348193645,
-0.0145661253,
-0.0169058032,
-0.0426262394,
-0.0079289712,
0.0017449842,
-0.0768648162,
0.0663041398,
0.0081906347,
-0.0201642904,
0.0141167035,
0.0074456176,
0.0365599692,
-0.0041733454,
0.0114729507,
0.0227306634,
0.0093053756,
-0.033534091,
-0.0192267001,
-0.0104376283,
-0.0112490673,
0.0114009082,
0.0344404429,
-0.0789551362,
-0.014115056,
0.0409957655,
-0.010279539,
-0.024182843,
0.0526937991,
-0.0610328242,
0.0347859226,
-0.0025345739,
0.01358552,
-0.0146295447,
-0.0041837059,
-0.046002984,
0.0510901138,
-0.0092588449,
-0.0053059445,
-0.0117717115,
-0.080871217,
0.0085206302,
-0.0332916155,
-0.0012086097,
0.0155253904,
-0.0044644848,
0.0326474495,
0.0073714172,
0.0368409567,
-0.0196151752,
0.013746189,
-0.0265439656,
0.0095753809,
-0.0080971671,
-0.0068798433,
-0.0106474105,
-0.0349577479,
-0.0023055524,
-0.0062502776,
-0.0360593498,
0.0492430069,
-0.0140241738,
-0.0028933543,
0.0640482903,
-0.0221797377,
-0.0760480836,
-0.009639238,
-0.0517583154,
-0.0386594906,
0.066312395,
0.0209071338,
0.0280878711,
-0.0534103438,
0.0193300452,
-0.0379129127,
0.0038750872,
-0.0223496743,
-0.0039702253,
0.0509821884,
-0.0312785618,
0.0092953397,
0.0977055207,
-0.0063036038,
0.0147422459,
0.0290062297,
0.0158270709,
-0.0456987619,
0.0129567878,
-0.0258276407,
0.0306097101,
-0.0073225154,
-0.0693699941,
0.0326241218,
0.0451839082,
-0.0294051729,
-0.0232572183,
-0.0540833287,
0.0833520591,
-0.0131054325,
-0.0435175933,
-0.0496779568,
-0.0410203226,
-0.001275889,
0.030573396,
-0.0282847155,
-0.0543161444,
0.0450939573,
0.0179713182,
0.0092543922,
-0.0072915331,
-0.0141804293,
-0.0598668382,
0.0799938887,
0.0127345407,
-0.0177474953,
-0.0471180566,
-0.0025853573,
-0.0540851206,
-0.0323633775,
-0.0022037092,
0.0020771809,
0.0532610901,
-0.0736940429,
-0.0080971541,
0.0134368865,
-0.0023107415,
-0.0357776172,
0.0622682311,
-0.0262964889,
0.016952144,
0.0003623517,
-0.0147185335,
-0.0230572242,
-0.0058016409,
0.0457441583,
-0.0080560725,
0.0000670165,
-0.0188362971,
-0.0155393602,
-0.0456569269,
0.0243600123,
0.025851056,
0.0386458635,
-0.0423985906,
0.0047851685,
0.0154580176,
-0.026053017,
0.040979173,
-0.0420995206,
0.0532722995,
0.0191245731,
-0.0208611377,
-0.0043303324,
0.0380395837,
-0.000447247,
-0.0348124653,
0.0171814114,
0.0728082433,
0.0181373917,
-0.0096137589,
0.0320269503,
-0.0273368098,
-0.0179118682,
0.0103154769,
0.0602027029,
-0.0642115846,
0.0076762731,
0.0045334492,
-0.0243608821,
-0.019665163,
-0.0577838533,
0.013437287,
-0.0813131705,
0.0327799618,
0.0263452958,
-0.0126521215,
-0.0683848932,
0.0194561128,
-0.0128927771,
-0.0247469321,
-0.0044999602,
0.0101344567,
0.0129260309,
0.0084652426,
0.0110131791,
-0.0068406081,
-0.0102116559,
-0.0038513285,
-0.0271614231,
0.0204244908,
0.0459357277,
0.0120384386,
-0.0422778688,
-0.0789804533,
0.007645939,
0.0430000015,
0.0057668011,
-0.0121249612,
0.0301179271,
0.0193786807,
-0.0182215683,
-0.0385244675,
0.0284251682,
-0.0244885199,
-0.0350795649,
0.0055406159,
0.0767387971,
-0.0168958846,
-0.0899622887,
-0.0090773432,
-0.0068285866,
-0.0568476021,
0.0633004606,
0.0598057508,
-0.0410843194,
-0.0175152067,
-0.0413008668,
-0.0321238451,
-0.1170332953,
-0.0836942419,
0.0249352623,
0.0285765901,
-0.0153488107,
-0.0927951261,
-0.0033577129,
0.0650980175,
0.0537860505,
0.0212474465,
-0.0876425728,
0.0097823916,
-0.021110544,
-0.0076910034,
0.0349081568,
-0.006159327,
-0.0069477311,
-0.0263166223,
-0.0320367068,
0.0056497771,
-0.0272423364,
-0.0092895795,
0.0275150724,
-0.0046890117,
-0.0413035862,
0.0408726148,
0.0706915036,
0.0304149929,
-0.0059977509,
0.0105417538,
-0.0569309555,
0.0353903137,
0.004754243,
-0.0087321661,
0.0341854729,
0.0163103789,
-0.0309598166,
0.0179794375,
0.0384140089,
-0.0238159969,
0.0629872903,
0.0420550816,
0.0177817382,
-0.0291670281,
0.0322127379,
0.025741417,
0.0331969857,
-0.0091575664,
0.01313016,
-0.0677097738,
-0.035224773,
-0.0113519104,
-0.0213790964,
-0.0046732202,
-0.0477737859,
-0.0088174148,
0.0057648909,
0.0512904637,
-0.0149512477,
-0.0502930023,
0.0195729397,
-0.0237972252,
-0.0295839254,
-0.004953776,
-0.0132384589,
-0.0014077555,
-0.0084188664,
0.020011887,
-0.0198846385,
0.0536425225,
-0.0459026657,
0.0371367782,
0.0169477761,
0.03869389,
0.0324022509,
0.0193161815,
-0.071740374,
-0.00508868,
-0.0491248481,
-0.0500670671,
0.0277467538,
0.0421143658,
0.0343017802,
0.0197991822,
-0.0054538269,
-0.0268853866,
-0.000294084,
0.0272942688,
0.0132114841,
-0.0093562957,
0.010704888,
0.0315228328,
0.050083138,
-0.0147824055,
-0.0695097968,
0.0286096092,
-0.0135577228,
0.0301323365,
-0.053151466,
0.025523508,
-0.0420734249,
-0.0087584294,
0.0301548038,
0.023310421,
0.0047997427,
0.0181616023,
-0.0735610723,
-0.0859360844,
0.00803346,
0.0753473788,
0.0344982073,
-0.0141920093,
0.0127564659,
0.0541513376,
0.0082954559,
-0.0364901051,
0.0185109712,
-0.0170280486,
-0.0047725593,
-0.0226635933,
-0.0530597083,
-6.03476098e-33,
-0.0248028152,
-0.0340403728,
0.06181629,
0.0343304127,
0.0175530892,
-0.0306066386,
0.0068284073,
0.0024095818,
-0.0344348624,
0.0251579564,
0.0170812365,
-0.0077055399,
-0.0104641747,
-0.0005175527,
0.0305517223,
0.0002100635,
-0.0061640451,
-0.0279861204,
-0.010532096,
-0.0196635835,
-0.0014798708,
0.0038026127,
0.0595063977,
-0.0463490076,
-0.0121601149,
0.0165981762,
-0.0034774449,
0.0381695852,
-0.0465597138,
0.0236398187,
-0.0299543086,
0.0011409608,
0.0534173436,
-0.0032578467,
-0.0014662725,
0.0097963847,
-0.0274509545,
-0.0521926098,
0.0544264503,
0.0126037169,
-0.0548187941,
-0.0663777292,
0.1098705009,
-0.017249018,
-0.0516072214,
0.0040646303,
0.0411671847,
-0.0322234891,
-0.0108024646,
0.0245114602,
-0.0750560835,
-0.0060598818,
-0.0161495022,
-0.0032285471,
-0.0164754521,
0.0007881654,
-0.0630616322,
-0.023913743,
-0.02902559,
0.0394656286,
0.0248848516,
-0.0170611516,
0.0291261673,
0.0291868038,
0.0168427434,
0.0588281751,
0.1041213349,
0.015878886,
-0.0511426665,
-0.0211455431,
0.0426887237,
0.062855415,
0.0681463331,
-0.0148431258,
0.0250393692,
-0.0269190911,
-0.0844786018,
-0.0034622722,
0.0234597102,
0.0432860628,
0.0043063094,
0.0041086529,
-0.0314070582,
-0.018451022,
0.0065229479,
-0.0038393147,
-0.0383305363,
-0.0025822429,
0.0311728902,
-0.0064831884,
0.0115373405,
0.0210106596,
0.0086528277,
-0.0256653242,
0.0421518832,
-0.0295376442,
-0.0184114873,
0.0519032218,
0.0326312408,
-0.0281076767,
-0.0448312908,
-0.0399001762,
-0.0128001813,
0.0052555511,
0.0651479438,
0.010325199,
0.0708206668,
0.0179761685,
-0.0211520344,
-0.0367197245,
-0.0266464036,
-0.0031776002,
0.0670056343,
-0.002515544,
0.0177531969,
0.0415315852,
-0.006435378,
-0.0226823036,
-0.0065279887,
-0.0398789905,
-0.0307503454,
0.0280082356,
-0.0183035731,
0.0289177839,
-0.0157654192,
-0.0350147486,
0.014224234,
0.0108367885,
0.0259696338,
-0.0549935363,
-0.0126832267,
0.0244248714,
2.786e-7,
0.0106431367,
0.0486532152,
0.0012575638,
0.0330650993,
0.0164890084,
0.0008031999,
-0.0297978632,
-0.0344808735,
0.0286214799,
-0.0031514307,
0.0010991517,
0.0526818819,
0.0082914578,
0.0227933694,
-0.0602004454,
-0.0039531561,
-0.0164877642,
0.0015875555,
-0.0164089501,
0.029246863,
0.0325143486,
0.0465768166,
0.0230111107,
0.0061278162,
0.0097663561,
-0.0774182826,
0.0474023893,
-0.0595569424,
-0.0048095207,
0.0120529365,
0.0589939542,
-0.0047146087,
0.0041964492,
0.0698101744,
0.0456818454,
0.0384165198,
0.016401425,
0.0514766499,
0.0008177174,
0.0346373245,
-0.0209810678,
-0.0253395308,
0.012347714,
-0.0135708321,
0.059242066,
-0.065979436,
-0.0696967244,
0.0139570488,
0.0180113185,
0.0086498214,
0.0069673373,
-0.0000621903,
0.025769813,
0.0012630839,
0.0274462141,
-0.0189286433,
0.0243524238,
-0.0575575791,
0.0054300507,
0.058706183,
-0.0330822356,
-0.0372498147,
-0.0454480909,
-0.0161571559,
0.0203714091,
-0.0073003527,
0.0031511434,
2.439924722e-34,
0.0073191756,
0.0050528087,
0.0325642116,
0.0268278401,
0.0356251709,
-0.0134958876,
-0.0629544705,
0.0161290504,
0.0286965072,
-0.0922102407,
-0.0119496295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.17184v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.17184v1 | Why can neural language models solve next-word prediction? A mathematical perspective | 2023-06-20T10:41:23 | 2023-06-20T10:41:23 | Vinoth Nandakumar, Peng Mi, Tongliang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | Recently, deep learning has revolutionized the field of natural language
processing, with neural language models proving to be very effective for
next-word prediction. However, a rigorous theoretical explanation for their
success in the context of formal language theory has not yet been developed, as
it is unclear why neural language models can learn the combinatorial rules that
govern the next-word prediction task. In this paper, we study a class of formal
languages that can be used to model real-world examples of English sentences.
We construct neural language models can solve the next-word prediction task in
this context with zero error. Our proof highlights the different roles of the
embedding layer and the fully connected component within the neural language
model. | [
0.0433801003,
0.0347124599,
-0.0298106074,
0.0521434881,
-0.0482161269,
0.0182582494,
-0.0141335931,
-0.0252553821,
0.0001581891,
-0.0138776852,
0.0413916558,
-0.0784899145,
0.0200443808,
0.0528483689,
0.0527881235,
-0.032183025,
0.0210123099,
-0.0603191517,
0.0253883097,
-0.0423151888,
-0.001925295,
-0.0230886284,
-0.0232047196,
0.0393954478,
-0.01227987,
-0.0088696061,
-0.0358748399,
-0.0493473485,
-0.0567388199,
-0.0311499927,
0.0293883272,
0.0325470716,
0.0032407127,
0.0568766408,
0.0000014728,
-0.0226770286,
0.0264746007,
-0.0395096801,
-0.0277132578,
-0.0219151266,
-0.0135962749,
-0.0002551476,
-0.0016760759,
0.0176768396,
-0.0400276929,
-0.047407072,
0.0626799092,
0.0408690386,
0.0268742889,
0.0673121661,
-0.0049468214,
-0.0519234389,
0.0430413149,
-0.0451107062,
-0.0114407055,
-0.0414646082,
0.0426058359,
-0.0255263578,
-0.0176945124,
-0.0108191222,
-0.0412244387,
0.0241464078,
0.031325344,
0.0176162496,
0.0013858295,
0.0693798885,
0.0154566336,
-0.0369844809,
-0.0369425341,
0.0670384914,
-0.0536952391,
-0.0269964822,
0.0063977093,
0.0080875056,
-0.0143775074,
0.0075107096,
-0.0407218188,
0.0175299831,
0.0413622819,
0.0505826809,
0.0378394425,
0.0083916616,
0.0335397869,
0.017068183,
0.0037013693,
0.1269707382,
0.0323839672,
-0.0343650728,
0.0099376803,
0.002341914,
0.0556191243,
-0.0522591025,
0.0471414328,
0.0418679453,
0.013913299,
0.0180891287,
-0.0096672401,
-0.0168926883,
-0.0020809616,
-0.0835869759,
0.0198732279,
0.0221482925,
0.0270064157,
0.0191423874,
-0.0250098296,
0.0214238539,
-0.0032717139,
0.0082312999,
-0.0321222804,
0.0050009158,
-0.0139248827,
-0.0370649807,
-0.0432161614,
0.0420330204,
-0.0432955325,
-0.067784071,
-0.0225684494,
0.0129630184,
0.0126356082,
-0.0040903329,
0.0032825957,
0.0302044135,
-0.0405188315,
0.0069581028,
-0.0545340031,
-0.0370014012,
-0.0416375212,
0.0046451357,
-0.0326284915,
-0.0106381793,
-0.0121335099,
0.0138551025,
0.0285235643,
-0.0217417218,
-0.0448309146,
0.0453149155,
-0.0010566422,
0.0007563892,
0.015612362,
0.0164607521,
-0.007328995,
-0.0269905478,
0.0398915224,
-0.0602234975,
0.0007714091,
-0.0034886675,
-0.0053988523,
-0.0626901835,
0.0252831634,
0.0213464685,
-0.0496256985,
0.0801330283,
-0.0230094586,
0.0211941674,
0.0091151884,
-0.0079533551,
0.0626585633,
0.0302579515,
0.0215427671,
-0.0000652035,
0.0377085544,
-0.0054384791,
-0.0070833149,
0.0475107767,
-0.0058168392,
-0.0358293317,
-0.0646748543,
-0.0225720629,
0.0146482065,
0.0624781996,
0.0027790607,
0.0572172515,
-0.0085117621,
-0.0344897211,
0.0194993634,
0.0411671698,
0.0508137383,
0.0269038118,
0.0502011105,
-0.0144333597,
-0.0032453502,
0.0569215715,
-0.0358349681,
0.0101108793,
-0.0161980912,
0.0129607338,
0.0220783409,
-0.0157149695,
-0.0325920023,
-0.0247468464,
-0.0109642604,
-0.0307329949,
0.0294826869,
-0.0773794129,
0.0223043077,
0.0044049011,
-0.0426023342,
0.0527846403,
0.0179214962,
0.0004043342,
0.031631913,
-0.007764576,
0.0296119768,
0.0462119095,
0.0130917272,
-0.0000867636,
-0.0559072234,
0.0237860791,
-0.0114357313,
0.0833855867,
0.0382488631,
-0.0324277282,
0.0175466966,
-0.0284953676,
0.0064830012,
0.0200997256,
-0.0065558958,
0.0061835186,
-0.0392970517,
0.0223017,
0.0231514331,
-0.0013020979,
-0.0622677505,
0.0549980924,
-0.0151094673,
-0.0675644949,
0.0085235136,
0.0355201922,
0.0277613513,
-0.0104462476,
0.0110186422,
0.0366536118,
0.0645509288,
-0.0440730415,
-0.0180176422,
-0.0126975719,
-0.0626677647,
-0.0486702509,
0.0596435107,
-0.0342986025,
0.0478465557,
0.0618650541,
-0.0048990138,
-0.0638342425,
0.0218543038,
-0.0284030102,
0.0573012382,
-0.0364121087,
0.01320122,
0.031417083,
0.0254807658,
-0.0067641563,
0.0342462473,
-0.0109860068,
0.0448759533,
-0.0210161619,
0.0051350221,
-0.0077595031,
-0.0091882898,
-0.0397480726,
0.0574441142,
0.0118001597,
0.0074891159,
0.0416216217,
-0.0051631727,
-0.0317163467,
-0.0135539975,
-0.0207483619,
-0.0464858525,
-0.007532279,
0.0166456085,
-0.015612497,
-0.0262611546,
0.0278329905,
-0.0465935431,
-0.0524021871,
0.0356345885,
0.0220745932,
-0.0101640848,
0.0750405937,
0.0179138407,
-0.0607325882,
-0.0569278896,
-0.0371768586,
-0.021867469,
0.0376710929,
-0.0189240389,
-0.0087440824,
-0.0383037366,
-0.0313283801,
-0.025087975,
0.0687234029,
-0.022829229,
-0.0232712924,
-0.0093501098,
-0.0564756915,
-0.0115988059,
0.0128069567,
0.03796703,
0.0159648769,
0.0196157843,
-0.0190174151,
-0.0230527762,
-0.0042629414,
-0.0647723526,
0.0267618801,
-0.0387598686,
0.0145931561,
-0.0384808853,
0.0819876269,
-0.0080804406,
-0.0268826261,
-0.0332654528,
0.0515918694,
0.0037781266,
0.0140824504,
0.0017791167,
-0.0249541048,
-0.0624327287,
0.040092811,
-0.0297928527,
-0.0522090681,
0.0638078451,
-0.0366048515,
-0.0096677188,
-0.0310353823,
-0.0099496376,
-0.0416308641,
0.0446538553,
0.0533697233,
0.0135091189,
0.0080152797,
-0.0136832539,
-0.0257913098,
-0.0097323526,
0.0016012162,
0.0040556616,
0.0177928936,
-0.0071557122,
0.0088092433,
0.0131611265,
-0.0053235688,
-0.0573872104,
-0.0447323099,
-0.0424476676,
0.0041322783,
-0.0199426282,
-0.0230305213,
-0.0030320662,
0.0054109613,
-0.0373446792,
0.050610289,
-0.0215072297,
0.0202867724,
-0.0330434553,
0.0381028317,
0.0616489872,
-0.023486428,
0.0168813057,
0.0066969651,
0.0463562123,
0.0053946986,
0.0290019158,
0.086593613,
-0.0394378342,
0.0292468201,
0.0376331508,
-0.0592917874,
-0.0782326311,
0.0578114167,
-0.036743369,
-0.0230728909,
-0.0104099074,
0.1263685524,
0.0305277295,
-0.0317998417,
0.047154516,
0.0002427907,
0.0363326631,
0.0283948723,
0.019196257,
-0.0330822207,
-0.0134496735,
0.0167199709,
-0.0400015414,
0.005018427,
-0.0352864154,
-0.0166076887,
-0.1131206527,
-0.0450385585,
0.034208253,
-0.0321221761,
-0.0057707978,
0.0055474429,
0.0020641889,
0.0326324329,
0.0250829495,
0.0172100514,
0.0033149573,
0.0138599249,
0.0347943269,
-0.022623321,
0.0028523612,
0.0124705955,
-0.0423924178,
0.0615494102,
0.0550606027,
0.0623380244,
-0.0593160167,
-0.0263364334,
0.0443317108,
-0.0015124341,
-0.0269955397,
0.0175877903,
0.0646025166,
-0.010893113,
0.0008162137,
0.0100480299,
0.0063811229,
-0.0477107577,
-0.0056468612,
-0.0027269502,
0.0883493349,
0.0030254186,
-0.0771271214,
-0.0239529274,
0.0240766946,
-0.0012793464,
0.0472001061,
0.0105146971,
-0.0426935777,
-0.0282697175,
-0.0220084004,
0.0506690219,
-0.0180195272,
-0.021192411,
-0.0201918967,
0.0352129489,
-0.0358189009,
-0.081520021,
-0.0529472679,
0.0178231914,
0.0429623872,
0.0261852648,
0.0316165872,
0.0301031657,
-0.0302340798,
0.0096211005,
-0.0032737427,
-0.0102014011,
0.0129190832,
-0.0162048694,
0.0016867488,
0.0168172121,
-0.0010939888,
-0.022632556,
-0.028657835,
-0.0549345501,
-0.0701801032,
0.0077237035,
0.0536368564,
0.0232171956,
-0.0023893788,
-0.0126731498,
-0.0832903013,
0.0129577452,
0.0056239679,
-0.0176738407,
-0.0238237754,
0.0586563386,
-0.0239517037,
0.0197131354,
0.07801608,
-0.0221048985,
0.0024515069,
-0.0152556328,
0.048604399,
0.0382901132,
-0.0688261166,
0.0342224129,
0.0008243927,
0.0477054231,
-0.0035228108,
0.031149691,
-0.0191888139,
0.009217768,
0.0064080805,
-0.0236506313,
-0.0191596001,
0.0526862182,
0.0081599383,
0.0376823619,
-0.0326999798,
-0.1036119536,
-0.00640349,
0.0172460005,
-0.0167403929,
-0.0130126942,
0.0728037506,
-0.0060827346,
0.0492034033,
0.0064992448,
-0.010494058,
0.0268086102,
-0.0323952511,
0.0275048409,
-0.0058916891,
-0.0031734328,
0.0245615728,
0.029629508,
-0.0733328462,
-0.0398688242,
-0.0735659674,
-0.0520293638,
0.0015878892,
0.0507362112,
0.0669821426,
-0.0303694475,
-0.0297323037,
-0.0166417826,
0.0172959007,
-0.009227477,
-0.0092196278,
-0.0097523546,
-0.0454258285,
0.0406397395,
0.019197749,
-0.0080908975,
0.0178243555,
0.0929250568,
0.0200727321,
0.02098988,
0.0277754646,
0.0080757765,
-0.0221557394,
0.0134605551,
0.022357624,
0.0881065801,
-0.0182275344,
0.0480732694,
-0.0251761843,
-0.0862557963,
0.0757741481,
0.0119489292,
0.0306528732,
-0.0408193544,
0.0186489671,
0.0436898172,
0.0045766891,
0.0004909378,
-0.0380740464,
0.019787075,
0.0263911095,
-0.0263987817,
-0.0342462063,
-5.726209876e-33,
-0.0131572848,
-0.0209209826,
-0.0001953834,
0.0279129278,
0.000962873,
-0.018231716,
-0.0304582287,
-0.0018908841,
-0.0117630186,
0.0145477625,
-0.0472390465,
0.0080368146,
0.0082853967,
0.0317561403,
0.0259670373,
-0.0369134545,
-0.001673135,
-0.0202293713,
0.0175162163,
-0.017830275,
-0.0129951611,
0.0455096513,
0.0589371063,
0.0240573734,
0.0563108139,
-0.0371633135,
0.002955751,
0.0459897406,
-0.0048451885,
0.040105287,
-0.0465008654,
0.023789987,
0.0248447862,
-0.0184012018,
-0.0255430732,
0.0517127626,
-0.0488232598,
-0.0842568949,
0.0428226888,
-0.007043412,
-0.0394140594,
0.0058824704,
0.0465417989,
-0.0517025888,
-0.027213024,
0.0564563647,
0.0434912145,
-0.0003125671,
-0.0560375676,
-0.0062125628,
-0.033530172,
-0.0044211377,
0.0045509925,
0.0014283846,
0.0316894725,
0.0056250845,
-0.0091937836,
-0.0419656932,
-0.0771306828,
0.0145787979,
-0.0221175998,
0.0338204615,
-0.0268020742,
0.0117466701,
0.0097383196,
0.0718142167,
0.0599010028,
-0.0333668962,
-0.0264496021,
0.0029474578,
0.0409705304,
0.0099944789,
0.0051485905,
-0.0079108002,
0.0677982494,
-0.0086811315,
-0.0290418547,
-0.0400707833,
0.0327631608,
0.0474086925,
0.0448709913,
0.0052158269,
-0.0412827097,
-0.0612157993,
-0.0716613531,
-0.0684050098,
-0.003576149,
-0.0202641711,
0.0079275277,
0.0176238753,
-0.0074807946,
-0.0355823301,
0.0082212556,
-0.0639303997,
-0.0282877926,
0.0342513584,
-0.0192843024,
-0.0302750487,
0.011725653,
0.0548653714,
-0.060041938,
-0.0268690567,
-0.0785017088,
-0.0061886474,
-0.0003125267,
0.0267992578,
0.000150101,
0.0197894387,
-0.0499023572,
-0.0228895117,
-0.0419154465,
-0.0648189634,
0.0083122719,
0.0292210355,
0.0512588844,
0.0079383347,
-0.0127843674,
0.0072550513,
0.0274976026,
0.0064279106,
-0.005331804,
0.0110638132,
0.0163919535,
0.0277029499,
-0.0449221171,
-0.0417548418,
-0.054528486,
-0.0078374194,
0.0619654879,
-0.0657700822,
0.0141536426,
0.0188445281,
2.259e-7,
0.01614861,
0.0344101712,
0.0414091796,
0.0244130958,
0.0153376479,
0.0027881244,
-0.0017626918,
0.0110923061,
0.0008575975,
-0.0028234425,
0.0163582992,
0.0370052271,
-0.0071988557,
-0.0270222127,
-0.0735454634,
-0.0062612463,
-0.0860875696,
0.0438560992,
0.0117362263,
-0.0198684502,
0.0101750465,
0.0966401622,
0.0475046523,
-0.0144444155,
-0.0484607071,
-0.0673517957,
0.0175739657,
0.0008060026,
0.0352157503,
-0.0065600881,
0.0108965002,
-0.0055940012,
0.0024349936,
0.037209779,
0.019218808,
0.0715472773,
0.0098313922,
0.0442396775,
-0.0273021609,
0.0217079911,
0.0000651669,
-0.042299971,
-0.0061175129,
-0.0077353101,
0.0658195987,
-0.0463040061,
-0.0156416837,
-0.0129223419,
0.0140777091,
0.0334519967,
0.0046719904,
-0.0014287088,
-0.0372207761,
-0.0122362785,
0.0220594313,
-0.0314002112,
0.0356071964,
-0.0598075911,
-0.0428606793,
0.0090712011,
-0.0237826016,
0.0141371386,
-0.0093764383,
-0.0099273296,
0.046284955,
-0.0178050473,
0.0125414031,
1.883937016e-34,
0.0459662043,
-0.0058979448,
0.0128191318,
0.0179524906,
0.0340106972,
-0.0393875018,
0.0313879028,
0.0282451287,
0.0514836982,
-0.0796173513,
-0.0551070757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11432v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11432v1 | Towards Theory-based Moral AI: Moral AI with Aggregating Models Based on Normative Ethical Theory | 2023-06-20T10:22:24 | 2023-06-20T10:22:24 | Masashi Takeshita, Rzepka Rafal, Kenji Araki | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Moral AI has been studied in the fields of philosophy and artificial
intelligence. Although most existing studies are only theoretical, recent
developments in AI have made it increasingly necessary to implement AI with
morality. On the other hand, humans are under the moral uncertainty of not
knowing what is morally right. In this paper, we implement the Maximizing
Expected Choiceworthiness (MEC) algorithm, which aggregates outputs of models
based on three normative theories of normative ethics to generate the most
appropriate output. MEC is a method for making appropriate moral judgments
under moral uncertainty. Our experimental results suggest that the output of
MEC correlates to some extent with commonsense morality and that MEC can
produce equally or more appropriate output than existing methods. | [
0.039857313,
0.088943541,
-0.0095161898,
-0.0150845675,
-0.0634452477,
0.0203654394,
0.0053856536,
-0.020411307,
0.0120377354,
0.0045528542,
0.0122380024,
-0.0184396673,
-0.018470699,
-0.0127546424,
-0.0366542414,
-0.0140907085,
0.0328376219,
-0.0053032739,
0.0585458949,
-0.0221428238,
-0.0200502034,
0.0116968611,
0.0107490867,
-0.034125153,
-0.0160652511,
0.0381307751,
0.0040935492,
-0.0296209492,
0.0529066548,
-0.0121161034,
0.0103937788,
0.014418941,
-0.0216405764,
-0.017956987,
0.0000018684,
-0.0553642623,
-0.0110775074,
-0.0167405922,
0.0560162403,
-0.0199623685,
0.0580632314,
0.0381565616,
-0.0001069054,
0.0073687569,
-0.0207586214,
0.0574686155,
0.0204087105,
0.0304648187,
-0.047363501,
0.0391292945,
-0.0046909791,
-0.0219262466,
0.0334914923,
-0.0088170702,
-0.0160501003,
-0.0425942838,
0.0314027406,
0.0169899277,
-0.0117152696,
-0.016715711,
0.0348811187,
-0.0137002291,
0.0157938879,
-0.0016538776,
-0.0210783165,
0.003515912,
0.0128159588,
-0.0489569679,
-0.0247032885,
0.0223841406,
0.0551976077,
0.0097370874,
0.0512669235,
0.0106792618,
0.0525121838,
-0.0033631669,
0.0431865416,
0.0435884409,
-0.0235482343,
0.008285569,
0.0388851576,
0.0359046459,
-0.005266306,
0.0717975199,
0.0126483673,
-0.0066642161,
-0.0188843887,
0.0071812794,
0.0384683982,
0.0311139319,
-0.0726360679,
0.0087431138,
0.0037002594,
0.0114605213,
-0.0299668163,
0.013683917,
0.0263185482,
0.0402819999,
0.0245406479,
0.0040356289,
0.017648017,
0.0293822717,
0.0330391861,
0.0173036363,
0.0329196006,
0.0206641164,
-0.0074521191,
0.0221593343,
-0.0494567268,
0.0206217337,
0.0014165645,
0.0311678573,
0.0364618562,
0.0703374892,
0.0009106761,
0.0467069037,
-0.0521840788,
-0.0199971665,
-0.1017077714,
0.0286766496,
-0.0054769572,
0.0290462542,
-0.0169130359,
0.0007616363,
-0.0724889562,
-0.0497896299,
-0.0511444435,
0.0132137164,
0.0038180696,
0.0365334265,
0.0291640908,
-0.0352928378,
-0.0034265989,
-0.0041342597,
0.0227777194,
0.1280240715,
0.0273105726,
0.0048394608,
-0.0266865119,
-0.0026572368,
-0.0159541797,
-0.0353384204,
-0.0164871402,
-0.0349362418,
0.0119629679,
-0.0453443676,
-0.0147313019,
-0.0406222604,
0.014612386,
-0.0234604981,
-0.0213105269,
0.0302003976,
0.037725877,
-0.0067332131,
0.0176883545,
0.0175506175,
-0.0327064432,
0.0156912077,
-0.0106236245,
0.0220959652,
0.0320075005,
0.0206519663,
0.0300777666,
-0.0128001068,
-0.0047987029,
0.0222254079,
-0.0155136893,
-0.0025775828,
-0.0441019386,
0.0007625009,
-0.0039920965,
0.0459214076,
-0.0193954334,
-0.0014157455,
-0.0053176349,
0.0679084212,
-0.0465529524,
0.0025185274,
0.0168326758,
-0.0388020501,
0.0302465111,
0.0194731206,
-0.0553604029,
0.053422492,
-0.0200865008,
-0.0160212852,
-0.070988588,
0.0301952846,
-0.0378343202,
-0.0636070669,
0.0345711149,
-0.0512961969,
0.0252304226,
0.022722289,
0.0234963037,
-0.0430250131,
0.0025583929,
-0.1319589019,
0.0447007492,
-0.0454656444,
-0.017796455,
-0.0525538474,
0.1056647822,
0.0478409231,
0.0540436432,
-0.0260736309,
-0.0374309383,
0.0020319177,
-0.0842665136,
-0.0238010343,
0.0074772965,
-0.0324730761,
-0.0029301902,
-0.0434880778,
-0.0386706591,
0.0240078233,
0.0028505141,
0.0499902293,
-0.0240719616,
-0.0257744715,
-0.0047788019,
0.0221974626,
0.0032984652,
0.0280811824,
-0.0024550112,
0.0672180206,
-0.0182637442,
0.0114558144,
0.0591235273,
-0.0222515836,
-0.0046380009,
-0.016936535,
-0.0068056481,
0.0502859056,
-0.0231436454,
0.005499403,
-0.0389331505,
0.0113852965,
0.0133948503,
-0.1017048657,
-0.0262043029,
0.032811746,
-0.0213416722,
0.0348352715,
-0.0741675943,
-0.0103709083,
-0.0120853977,
-0.0352141,
0.017264571,
-0.0507892594,
-0.0599812679,
0.0018484258,
0.0872965455,
-0.0541707426,
-0.0113126105,
-0.0135458512,
-0.0353125446,
0.0423926003,
-0.0114212148,
-0.0202269349,
-0.0298831128,
-0.0183015727,
0.0366534479,
0.0515780337,
0.0634323433,
-0.030691592,
-0.0664685592,
-0.0508220382,
-0.0084362244,
0.0341251828,
-0.0125186862,
-0.0320426561,
-0.0352228247,
0.013298016,
0.014752334,
-0.0525770374,
0.0311619174,
-0.0063404115,
-0.0020693582,
0.0170891713,
-0.0113947662,
-0.0079066427,
-0.0216248557,
0.0021554644,
-0.0093608508,
-0.0312381163,
0.0059195985,
0.0333459079,
0.006722135,
0.0559649393,
-0.0932731554,
0.0029145719,
0.0164461192,
-0.0525090881,
-0.0392286144,
0.0322900303,
0.0077887238,
0.0702527463,
0.0603396259,
0.0103032561,
0.0338709429,
0.0701478571,
-0.0126107959,
-0.0186737217,
0.002967024,
0.008750475,
0.0181641784,
-0.0528020822,
-0.0318106115,
0.0212779678,
-0.0054215086,
0.0175359715,
-0.0171897784,
0.0361635536,
0.0068914811,
-0.069411926,
0.0113313571,
-0.0593144819,
0.0067454218,
0.0731979311,
-0.0283067543,
-0.0373924337,
0.0745975524,
0.0885164514,
0.0400680304,
0.0151750073,
0.0377150178,
0.0213519018,
-0.0192176495,
0.0523291565,
0.0229327697,
-0.034988746,
-0.0143866455,
-0.0121452799,
-0.0259411782,
0.04181787,
-0.0512468331,
0.0460187607,
-0.0264051389,
0.0144071169,
0.0013925319,
-0.0864722878,
-0.051045958,
-0.0196374208,
-0.0012615555,
-0.0363819599,
0.0116550671,
0.0068446104,
0.0346418284,
-0.0301666688,
0.0331535265,
-0.0378705189,
-0.011626997,
-0.0084102461,
-0.0215517487,
-0.04575992,
0.0164403114,
-0.0357003771,
0.0582310632,
0.0193887502,
0.0050940625,
0.0554294847,
-0.0076396423,
0.0230642166,
-0.0070550377,
0.0274949465,
0.020238325,
0.0116075184,
0.0119215278,
0.0367988124,
0.0216292553,
0.0578587726,
0.0404683761,
0.0618334189,
0.0070731374,
-0.0298716985,
0.0043676095,
-0.0115761552,
-0.0383604281,
-0.0080293277,
0.0185596962,
-0.0335528851,
0.0144541804,
-0.007837492,
0.0254675858,
-0.0948517546,
-0.073460266,
0.0732956752,
-0.0676019117,
0.014176107,
0.0358068086,
0.0356471092,
-0.0314230062,
0.0046215723,
0.0131083177,
-0.0659831166,
-0.0186708812,
0.0133242086,
0.0402637348,
-0.0303029492,
-0.0013622944,
0.0847098157,
0.0447871201,
0.0535835437,
-0.0358918048,
0.0474288911,
0.0925794467,
0.0474223718,
-0.0712528154,
-0.0500463136,
-0.0415466204,
0.0297183525,
-0.0133881355,
0.0446529388,
-0.0192373637,
-0.0025663895,
0.0109389713,
-0.0682754517,
0.0456198826,
0.0516689904,
-0.0445557311,
0.0364896283,
0.0434088819,
-0.0048790304,
-0.0547810756,
-0.0207245015,
-0.0108990455,
0.001112366,
0.0513908044,
-0.0271726213,
-0.0279181506,
0.0123252906,
-0.0171714611,
-0.0357832946,
-0.0144490404,
-0.0049493024,
-0.0250839107,
0.005918486,
-0.0529411361,
-0.0411979668,
-0.0146547016,
-0.0721803233,
0.0144459866,
0.0444713011,
-0.1009336859,
0.0606280863,
0.0194719601,
0.0217447728,
-0.0161388852,
-0.030371327,
-0.019841196,
-0.0218191613,
0.0500248522,
0.031925153,
-0.0339878872,
-0.0012417312,
-0.0280862078,
0.0813259408,
-0.0160336774,
0.0125058582,
0.0934772044,
0.016883336,
-0.0047938139,
-0.0608302392,
0.0165418778,
0.0415440165,
0.0478695519,
-0.0471568964,
0.0535835065,
0.069808431,
0.0418640301,
-0.0201767832,
-0.0018943725,
-0.0150497593,
0.0415201224,
-0.0077980272,
-0.0225292277,
-0.0288133714,
-0.0063447617,
0.0254191123,
0.0126495594,
-0.0292683765,
-0.004139306,
0.028631134,
-0.0136288283,
-0.0433134027,
-0.0022798548,
-0.0277675837,
-0.0092136245,
0.0129400603,
0.0383456759,
-0.0007768613,
-0.0043468042,
0.0148200952,
-0.0104650967,
-0.0485280976,
-0.0058989017,
-0.0205962397,
0.0386248752,
0.0852428824,
-0.0227696002,
-0.0212077405,
-0.045774702,
0.0046687615,
-0.0105436491,
0.0207042545,
-0.0178462248,
0.0664404035,
0.0471811704,
-0.0186155792,
0.0190138724,
0.0333366543,
-0.0741407946,
0.0103231436,
-0.0019464659,
0.0038147923,
-0.0183123089,
0.0415815897,
-0.0203941632,
-0.021526875,
0.0084800264,
-0.0337164812,
0.0333634354,
0.0134391813,
0.0205814391,
-0.0065024486,
0.0160708614,
0.0146821085,
-0.0329857394,
0.0226300266,
-0.0987485647,
0.0001363331,
-0.0301562008,
-0.0164221711,
-0.0037665265,
-0.0302907713,
0.0053817369,
-0.0231081583,
-0.0135208098,
-0.0189105235,
-0.049252253,
-0.0156567264,
-0.0431231111,
0.0588172078,
0.0273215771,
-0.0210175794,
-0.0556940772,
0.0332648121,
-0.0318872854,
0.0412478112,
-0.0273350179,
-0.0027942413,
-0.0569169521,
0.03662223,
-0.0607031435,
-4.926960777e-33,
-0.0036245543,
-0.0298891831,
-0.0516152121,
-0.0133931423,
0.0084674638,
-0.0459805317,
0.0429060981,
0.0138195939,
-0.0583235249,
0.0250144843,
-0.0159133244,
-0.0001105026,
-0.006453203,
-0.0298994612,
0.0267237425,
-0.0365131237,
-0.0206240006,
0.0201271195,
-0.0357625373,
0.0024417017,
-0.0408514589,
-0.0374730863,
-0.0174159296,
-0.0684581026,
0.0141778346,
0.0334093943,
-0.0131903961,
0.0300066248,
-0.0587898605,
0.0285817683,
0.0229124445,
0.0350709595,
0.0094532482,
0.0076515335,
-0.002410142,
0.0105330963,
-0.0137860402,
-0.006998641,
0.0343996882,
-0.0383794457,
-0.0420484617,
-0.0676729828,
-0.0229011737,
0.0264880322,
-0.036681857,
0.007737719,
0.0274809171,
-0.0193404239,
0.023305716,
0.0032478482,
-0.0007292474,
-0.0194689557,
-0.0371314213,
-0.0195480287,
-0.0464135148,
0.0303886142,
-0.0107969251,
0.0196544416,
0.0358523391,
0.0505873598,
0.0095569007,
-0.0553203933,
-0.0027599484,
-0.059702564,
0.0155394776,
0.0435789414,
-0.0017325027,
0.0013465219,
-0.0437259674,
-0.0656200945,
-0.037187621,
0.0608849637,
0.013847026,
0.0574757382,
-0.037527632,
-0.062432915,
-0.0384477675,
0.0421652459,
0.0415106378,
-0.0110848024,
-0.0057101478,
-0.0065515558,
-0.0662357882,
0.0260876492,
-0.0189093426,
-0.0787657276,
-0.0428303815,
-0.004827356,
-0.0150732677,
-0.0285505634,
-0.0431555547,
-0.033030808,
-0.0281713754,
-0.0434196033,
0.0588622913,
0.0589860268,
0.0072185895,
0.0190599058,
-0.0160932355,
0.0213153269,
0.0012455517,
-0.0580959916,
0.0236580875,
-0.0144172497,
0.0097993203,
0.0124636339,
0.0379563756,
0.0062517263,
0.0324935727,
-0.0154144317,
-0.0197553001,
0.0031367622,
0.0365629308,
-0.0704220012,
-0.0097170444,
0.0371778756,
0.0155359888,
-0.0262562614,
-0.0080992617,
0.002792628,
-0.040957544,
-0.013685707,
-0.0094417231,
0.0480794273,
0.0013210366,
-0.0015551043,
-0.0294937957,
0.0123795234,
-0.0216039587,
0.01956187,
-0.0306058824,
0.0339139886,
2.501e-7,
-0.0393960774,
-0.0726791322,
0.0180470645,
0.0302662849,
-0.0330634415,
0.0776159912,
0.0230024811,
0.0410571955,
0.0430960357,
-0.0632868186,
0.0313633084,
-0.001604932,
0.0302017592,
-0.0222173389,
0.038024012,
-0.0495521538,
0.0434103124,
-0.0269965827,
-0.0134059051,
0.0507374927,
0.042671524,
0.0254038777,
0.070590876,
-0.0127931368,
0.0277699232,
0.0564767532,
0.0037721226,
-0.047926221,
-0.0235428475,
-0.0135436589,
-0.0274775773,
-0.0240013208,
0.0406285673,
0.0388378203,
0.031132808,
-0.0002528592,
0.0180811249,
0.0621648245,
-0.0070191929,
-0.02221133,
0.0036817731,
-0.0185538456,
0.0044731605,
0.0123935668,
0.0744244605,
-0.0062592654,
-0.0156481378,
-0.0097033707,
-0.0011321957,
0.0014283925,
-0.0066060442,
-0.0121541694,
-0.0082492465,
-0.0068035652,
0.000443032,
0.0172233675,
0.0143885305,
-0.0042745224,
0.0416410863,
-0.0116122523,
0.0382318869,
-0.110350281,
0.0622428544,
0.0460492298,
0.0374270417,
-0.0894972607,
0.0063229534,
1.64690409e-34,
0.0023813855,
-0.0175883044,
0.0133200092,
-0.0114876311,
0.0571132153,
0.0386750773,
-0.0097497748,
-0.0042073387,
0.0282931663,
0.0141210761,
-0.02122101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11426v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11426v1 | Exploring the Performance and Efficiency of Transformer Models for NLP on Mobile Devices | 2023-06-20T10:15:01 | 2023-06-20T10:15:01 | Ioannis Panopoulos, Sokratis Nikolaidis, Stylianos I. Venieris, Iakovos S. Venieris | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Deep learning (DL) is characterised by its dynamic nature, with new deep
neural network (DNN) architectures and approaches emerging every few years,
driving the field's advancement. At the same time, the ever-increasing use of
mobile devices (MDs) has resulted in a surge of DNN-based mobile applications.
Although traditional architectures, like CNNs and RNNs, have been successfully
integrated into MDs, this is not the case for Transformers, a relatively new
model family that has achieved new levels of accuracy across AI tasks, but
poses significant computational challenges. In this work, we aim to make steps
towards bridging this gap by examining the current state of Transformers'
on-device execution. To this end, we construct a benchmark of representative
models and thoroughly evaluate their performance across MDs with different
computational capabilities. Our experimental results show that Transformers are
not accelerator-friendly and indicate the need for software and hardware
optimisations to achieve efficient deployment. | [
0.0149357263,
0.029073691,
0.0129431402,
0.0145205604,
-0.0031723783,
-0.0313733481,
0.0581877492,
-0.0078013302,
-0.0423127078,
-0.0565242469,
-0.0055315951,
-0.032596115,
0.0041647824,
-0.0256828591,
-0.0348290689,
-0.0136241075,
0.0423059389,
0.0264376998,
-0.0713763908,
0.0195027739,
-0.011908778,
-0.0053994423,
-0.0091748573,
0.0671299547,
-0.0372609496,
-0.0224834066,
-0.0010684204,
0.0333824158,
0.0037453945,
-0.0431535505,
0.0151962657,
0.0408624597,
-0.0141033921,
0.0169697758,
0.0000019721,
0.0390781164,
0.0003179932,
0.019115271,
-0.0209925249,
-0.0052803783,
0.0403041206,
-0.0144404452,
-0.0194395967,
0.0298290569,
-0.0342781879,
-0.0534054749,
0.0220748428,
0.0346351713,
0.0355103984,
0.0573070683,
0.0006332482,
-0.0131210135,
0.0515586361,
-0.0266557969,
-0.0410572924,
-0.0262981374,
-0.0360848121,
-0.0530346446,
-0.0323880166,
-0.0051201605,
0.0204085689,
0.0345670395,
0.0657106489,
0.0630584434,
-0.0247179028,
0.0024075992,
-0.0400674231,
-0.0144131724,
-0.04686407,
0.0470742844,
-0.0547460094,
-0.0090096835,
-0.0047844928,
-0.0003671662,
-0.0484745763,
-0.0192247853,
-0.0260611773,
0.0326668695,
0.0068296953,
-0.0111330776,
-0.0338275842,
0.0084741125,
0.0870757997,
-0.0044596097,
-0.038889911,
0.04165297,
0.0116844196,
0.0041307746,
-0.0195519812,
0.0281414129,
-0.0176123567,
-0.0327301994,
0.0404984318,
0.0104002608,
-0.0508947335,
-0.0022725922,
-0.0480049402,
-0.066955395,
-0.0293216538,
-0.0393147692,
0.0434210412,
0.012812838,
0.0125289569,
0.0035961785,
-0.029275978,
0.0447061881,
-0.0413269214,
0.009623955,
-0.0060392758,
0.0106667541,
-0.0306179412,
0.0039721872,
0.0041582575,
0.0289177243,
-0.0416733325,
-0.0594496205,
-0.0282910671,
-0.0162130725,
0.0030211378,
-0.0106755095,
0.0128631545,
0.0490912385,
-0.0333687291,
0.0063217985,
0.0231669899,
0.0509464704,
-0.0238282122,
0.0379848108,
0.0442436598,
-0.1229582652,
0.0149200559,
-0.0323578343,
-0.014015777,
-0.0036717823,
0.0062785633,
0.0691145584,
0.0153689971,
-0.0450605303,
-0.0142240794,
0.014713658,
-0.0049332511,
-0.0283697601,
0.0217367746,
-0.0611346625,
0.0475335829,
-0.0079762535,
0.0421042182,
-0.0316004641,
0.0641633123,
0.0502973646,
-0.0081862351,
0.0235098843,
0.0099352421,
0.0099027539,
0.0099059008,
0.0097053908,
-0.0008548273,
0.0353084318,
0.0588405691,
0.0526668616,
0.0338648558,
-0.0149462288,
0.0144490087,
0.0318285637,
0.0228215139,
-0.0251072384,
0.0091477688,
-0.0445408151,
-0.056249138,
0.0498247519,
-0.0244553667,
0.0750631392,
-0.0176562108,
0.0107915243,
0.0783098191,
0.0536623187,
0.0374827497,
0.054339949,
-0.0114194406,
0.0026274759,
-0.0069994931,
-0.0491167121,
-0.0689461678,
0.0141933439,
0.023454804,
-0.0068658078,
0.0029031977,
0.0611208417,
-0.0162434913,
-0.0408202894,
-0.0264543034,
-0.0474863872,
0.0090434253,
0.0468319394,
-0.0072083832,
0.0514937602,
-0.0127212582,
0.0857042149,
0.0090702921,
-0.0368050709,
-0.037929818,
-0.0413614921,
0.0010772684,
0.0265772119,
0.0558878072,
0.0181528814,
-0.0503846072,
-0.0160666592,
-0.0362289511,
0.0243399255,
0.0185592975,
0.0024906469,
0.0478642955,
-0.0489786379,
-0.015496931,
-0.0047170473,
0.0332166441,
-0.0064570857,
0.0701921508,
0.0371024646,
0.0120694432,
-0.0250472147,
-0.0114976307,
0.0373741016,
0.0141253229,
-0.028839279,
0.0887403041,
0.027300315,
0.0016011983,
0.0068587339,
-0.006124232,
-0.0350522771,
0.044186309,
-0.060189195,
0.0050078882,
0.0095295347,
-0.0409352519,
0.0063406257,
0.0004072287,
-0.045112092,
0.0252359547,
0.0919858441,
0.0067765815,
-0.005530721,
-0.0049369545,
-0.022322597,
0.0380210131,
0.0163521562,
0.0456066616,
0.00563573,
0.0350598507,
0.0086900527,
0.0318511799,
0.0009626612,
0.0225622226,
0.0186663177,
-0.0182298683,
-0.026480997,
0.0256148428,
-0.0212336909,
0.0083192969,
-0.0360293388,
-0.0033169205,
0.0079036439,
-0.0081980852,
-0.0020903468,
-0.0275268294,
-0.0609333813,
0.0407974124,
-0.036739707,
0.0126326187,
0.0311466046,
0.0689344183,
0.0447970517,
-0.0237627309,
0.0028220871,
0.0016425727,
-0.0207169093,
0.0606458001,
-0.0026487552,
-0.0244061295,
0.0092271678,
-0.0277840365,
-0.0394845866,
0.0206243247,
0.0588268787,
-0.0407455824,
0.0209102314,
-0.003609339,
-0.045460131,
0.0016596648,
0.0103583625,
-0.0003384972,
-0.0427103415,
0.0356926434,
0.0068901437,
0.0235033091,
0.056159474,
0.0155800981,
0.030501103,
-0.0017872965,
0.0020305193,
-0.0731559619,
0.0250896737,
-0.0082948226,
-0.0071575469,
-0.046314545,
-0.0192536972,
-0.0230797045,
0.1073107421,
-0.0441668481,
0.0190060288,
-0.0025453579,
-0.0508690923,
-0.0268037096,
-0.0432776213,
0.0199238472,
0.0561995395,
-0.0223612338,
0.0190660302,
-0.025055822,
-0.0163381081,
0.0211033337,
-0.0207328405,
0.0102458363,
-0.0409832858,
0.0036656572,
0.0021012758,
0.0687044039,
0.010220875,
0.0275147539,
-0.036928758,
-0.0231819451,
0.0056756446,
0.0249513015,
-0.0160249081,
-0.0490348488,
0.0778655931,
-0.0097557707,
-0.02470842,
-0.0380276702,
-0.0598884411,
-0.0176146384,
-0.0201212801,
-0.035182476,
-0.0039284294,
0.0632728711,
-0.0365012176,
-0.0732373819,
0.0384682305,
0.0017678951,
0.0505344719,
-0.002724471,
-0.0190698802,
-0.0229060519,
0.0627167225,
0.014567594,
0.0439798124,
0.0132658258,
0.0139244124,
0.0287889205,
0.0678588822,
0.0504080318,
0.0249997042,
-0.0833558887,
0.0018667028,
0.0480265245,
-0.0032705092,
-0.0422973298,
0.0524477065,
0.0490527339,
-0.1023377925,
-0.0105779469,
0.0568934754,
0.0177209172,
-0.0303881448,
0.017250577,
0.0651660264,
-0.0064200792,
-0.004843344,
0.0159921255,
-0.0854371116,
-0.0593501888,
0.0225941502,
-0.0083171222,
0.0277620796,
0.0163676944,
0.0023486679,
-0.0737409666,
-0.0008037681,
-0.0344445445,
0.0208448321,
0.012820526,
-0.0400015898,
-0.0041624908,
-0.0237111337,
0.0409284346,
-0.0404125452,
0.0026290056,
-0.0250508245,
0.0006453188,
-0.0693983287,
-0.0449913852,
0.0389378592,
-0.0451831482,
-0.0335087627,
0.087261878,
-0.0099332705,
0.0142158726,
-0.0525026582,
0.016813891,
0.0152623896,
0.0345298946,
0.0074715745,
-0.0033443242,
-0.0109786279,
-0.0158343427,
-0.0003378573,
0.0060344543,
-0.0581276827,
-0.0046123387,
-0.0217501167,
0.0696823001,
0.0260207411,
-0.0148044154,
-0.0559034012,
-0.0226711836,
0.0047780871,
0.0133209871,
0.009182238,
-0.038246844,
-0.0616814643,
-0.0064869076,
0.0128861414,
-0.0364228711,
-0.0426341631,
0.0104592927,
0.0337498449,
-0.0704533681,
-0.0548846275,
-0.0044095591,
-0.0124060102,
0.0018014575,
0.0201678798,
-0.0568215363,
0.0581801385,
0.0415944047,
-0.0551420562,
0.0266859997,
0.0178260673,
0.0556401312,
-0.0578078628,
0.0419818237,
0.0594128296,
-0.021506073,
0.0164802112,
0.0096387239,
-0.1454667747,
-0.0372532308,
0.024753755,
0.0036180548,
0.0135136591,
0.0089968741,
-0.0431377105,
-0.0163924322,
0.0008119751,
0.0797624439,
-0.0555578247,
0.0093984297,
0.0093686581,
-0.0382854007,
0.0043542599,
0.0225405972,
-0.0154648125,
0.031995263,
-0.0090818265,
0.0445821658,
-0.0411615074,
-0.0372358039,
0.0232396312,
-0.0539663769,
0.0488066114,
0.0255538505,
-0.0227357596,
0.021818202,
0.0327670351,
0.0485494062,
0.0150513723,
-0.0304039456,
-0.0166726764,
-0.0059796218,
0.0303438138,
-0.0123963896,
0.0388022065,
0.070802398,
-0.0232091714,
-0.0207496807,
0.0066869189,
0.0135422256,
-0.0039829728,
-0.0302824546,
0.0251309071,
-0.016372947,
0.0160486195,
-0.0107436525,
0.0340978727,
-0.0450662524,
-0.0065885396,
-0.0138424104,
-0.0083608441,
-0.0414303169,
0.0337599777,
-0.0482440032,
-0.0097128833,
-0.0233161561,
0.0118997833,
0.0440624915,
-0.0158722699,
0.0104833171,
-0.0012094623,
-0.0065044994,
-0.0086490633,
-0.0068829372,
-0.0207066983,
-0.0031022944,
0.0123852659,
0.0137692299,
0.0086769098,
0.0020860175,
0.0384078175,
-0.0370697528,
0.0200372059,
0.0202849209,
0.0099244574,
-0.0355609655,
-0.0402344242,
-0.0206563771,
0.0142805725,
0.0133098485,
-0.0008876116,
0.0042097522,
-0.0243390314,
0.0360473357,
-0.0216072462,
0.0380998068,
-0.0454421565,
0.0038801327,
0.0677785426,
0.026388824,
-0.0373606607,
-0.0303437449,
0.000623347,
-0.0271648429,
0.0153941456,
-0.0315708742,
-5.726516974e-33,
0.0062848143,
0.0244119745,
-0.008990325,
-0.0247261282,
-0.0408220887,
0.0182707496,
0.0039972425,
-0.0023552724,
-0.063012898,
-0.0017119606,
-0.0798622295,
0.0223048814,
0.0319457687,
0.0533542335,
-0.0179922748,
-0.0245960224,
0.0743579119,
-0.0303117353,
-0.0342870988,
-0.0066867643,
0.007708794,
0.0219289344,
0.0159368664,
-0.0180121455,
-0.0612834617,
-0.0109417355,
-0.0018147916,
-0.0589578412,
-0.0093080876,
0.0457670502,
-0.0131599717,
-0.011478439,
0.0317552425,
-0.0514998175,
-0.0044650799,
0.0005624396,
-0.095689103,
0.0086541446,
-0.0734043419,
0.0773679987,
-0.067144677,
-0.036493957,
0.0831413046,
0.0368428566,
-0.0340810008,
-0.0227183849,
0.0157591458,
-0.0098195812,
-0.0465359166,
-0.0659182444,
-0.0124769444,
0.0053475173,
0.024085857,
-0.0326446109,
0.0102921361,
0.0153271453,
-0.0593939498,
0.0145493094,
-0.1038576663,
0.0048816525,
-0.0350647084,
0.0674951449,
0.0662935823,
-0.0058104116,
-0.0151670212,
0.0330453329,
0.0371132679,
-0.0114991013,
-0.0346453413,
0.0143486131,
0.0111999502,
0.0737620294,
0.0246363319,
0.0050410782,
0.0805963725,
-0.0260582902,
-0.0235185921,
-0.0073033376,
0.0157603733,
0.0425181799,
0.0474315509,
0.0039965585,
-0.015810404,
0.0049454281,
-0.0486056283,
0.0160023756,
-0.0216631684,
-0.0425835475,
0.0426456966,
0.0405149534,
-0.0251685847,
0.0310598724,
0.026411036,
-0.051739797,
0.0270199478,
-0.0079544205,
0.0304573402,
0.045369789,
-0.0272507202,
0.0027519155,
-0.0393778943,
-0.0026051297,
-0.0355412401,
0.029872844,
0.0370909274,
0.0035974935,
0.0139156152,
0.025189016,
-0.0542377234,
-0.0369054973,
-0.0336324126,
0.05978778,
-0.0159129053,
0.0585770682,
0.0742895752,
-0.0257086847,
-0.0261288621,
0.0486823581,
-0.0541334674,
0.0214371551,
-0.0050370935,
0.0099486699,
0.0502527356,
0.0052157594,
-0.0304644816,
0.0031220387,
-0.1149918512,
0.0052718534,
-0.0023888142,
-0.0561925769,
-0.0487160832,
0.0180728734,
2.61e-7,
-0.0274481513,
-0.0007840747,
-0.0008483522,
0.0319647752,
0.029489018,
0.0104149431,
0.0527454428,
0.0068394197,
-0.0199891366,
0.0183580257,
-0.0363617837,
0.0382986553,
0.0795698315,
0.0432879329,
-0.0142949037,
-0.011685987,
-0.0804779157,
0.0761984363,
-0.0172454696,
-0.0167147405,
-0.0369369797,
0.110107258,
0.0003352449,
-0.0284776352,
0.0262128431,
0.0198644511,
0.0246489998,
0.0030209234,
0.030409243,
0.006674502,
0.0189727359,
0.0604642704,
-0.0409420878,
-0.0286757667,
-0.0144433724,
-0.0086423084,
0.0080011385,
0.0399775319,
0.0163210984,
-0.0302057415,
0.0050576641,
-0.0289960708,
-0.026906848,
0.0012241978,
0.0536421798,
-0.0272810739,
-0.0166352615,
-0.0333489217,
-0.0247548483,
-0.0142275989,
-0.0200905539,
0.0030946268,
0.0255989488,
0.0007026912,
-0.0018986986,
-0.004501367,
-0.052461151,
-0.0693337098,
-0.0244564544,
-0.0051293382,
-0.0119884359,
-0.0166251399,
-0.0859652758,
-0.0137647204,
0.030514257,
-0.0213505682,
-0.032494247,
2.257497182e-34,
0.0000164994,
0.0012013424,
0.0216048695,
0.051830899,
-0.003799146,
-0.0087873219,
0.0708902702,
-0.0251989532,
-0.0041418415,
-0.0668806359,
-0.0197394695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11420v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11420v1 | On Evaluating Multilingual Compositional Generalization with Translated Datasets | 2023-06-20T10:03:57 | 2023-06-20T10:03:57 | Zi Wang, Daniel Hershcovich | cs.CL | cs.CL | Compositional generalization allows efficient learning and human-like
inductive biases. Since most research investigating compositional
generalization in NLP is done on English, important questions remain
underexplored. Do the necessary compositional generalization abilities differ
across languages? Can models compositionally generalize cross-lingually? As a
first step to answering these questions, recent work used neural machine
translation to translate datasets for evaluating compositional generalization
in semantic parsing. However, we show that this entails critical semantic
distortion. To address this limitation, we craft a faithful rule-based
translation of the MCWQ dataset from English to Chinese and Japanese. Even with
the resulting robust benchmark, which we call MCWQ-R, we show that the
distribution of compositions still suffers due to linguistic divergences, and
that multilingual models still struggle with cross-lingual compositional
generalization. Our dataset and methodology will be useful resources for the
study of cross-lingual compositional generalization in other tasks. | [
0.0337120071,
0.0603752919,
-0.0012056815,
0.022397466,
-0.0171184037,
0.054885935,
0.0012829378,
-0.0211901143,
-0.075472258,
0.0001614821,
-0.0109201241,
-0.0637109354,
0.0056309081,
-0.0270269588,
0.0130619202,
-0.0256588496,
0.0314052477,
0.0250972658,
-0.0303361118,
0.0030673963,
0.0069926055,
0.0083930902,
0.0284753777,
0.0393682718,
-0.0551542155,
-0.0115204081,
0.0104526235,
-0.0163451955,
-0.0014201308,
0.006083766,
0.0113077397,
0.0327787176,
-0.0071382835,
0.0384278968,
0.0000015829,
-0.0497723892,
0.0003196488,
-0.0104006026,
0.0342788659,
-0.0188888647,
0.0370113999,
-0.0918609947,
0.0141537152,
-0.0136263883,
-0.0225921702,
-0.0454134941,
0.0532160662,
0.0591432899,
0.0610899031,
0.0946384221,
-0.0105061783,
-0.0822956115,
-0.0179767814,
-0.0219159704,
0.0330849253,
-0.0180567354,
0.0028527491,
0.0222140178,
-0.0510158949,
-0.0578766502,
-0.045146618,
0.0091636404,
0.047370974,
0.0241566952,
-0.0340085886,
0.0272758696,
-0.0512075275,
-0.0292133577,
0.0219178498,
0.0878776908,
-0.0148607884,
-0.0189151037,
-0.0077580381,
-0.0038013465,
0.0082658529,
-0.0235942509,
-0.025416201,
0.0621447563,
-0.0413063765,
0.0321992487,
0.0394820347,
0.0045568533,
0.0398576483,
-0.0113332672,
-0.028649725,
0.0706387833,
0.0180909596,
-0.0571686439,
0.038826596,
0.0298371483,
0.0015260512,
-0.0067893267,
0.0108262496,
-0.0078897839,
-0.0461829714,
-0.0015363503,
-0.0305360593,
-0.0313896947,
0.0017514731,
-0.0719472095,
0.0376007259,
0.0605995469,
-0.0083282404,
0.0520356297,
-0.0210488252,
0.041070085,
-0.0242797267,
0.0395491272,
-0.0756225884,
-0.0340957083,
-0.0818428919,
-0.0085590212,
-0.0318878293,
0.0556541644,
0.0008033398,
-0.0191243552,
-0.0507563502,
-0.0106813852,
-0.0347806588,
0.039075803,
0.0443550795,
-0.0076566264,
-0.0937731937,
0.0247266721,
0.0083035631,
0.0143852802,
-0.0431003906,
0.0095106252,
-0.0009410859,
-0.0108637735,
-0.0195301622,
-0.0136371385,
-0.0122782961,
-0.0276527032,
0.0037465584,
0.0763850659,
0.0210115388,
0.0011148159,
-0.0023804379,
-0.0241004191,
-0.0130470227,
-0.0425016768,
0.0454683267,
-0.0536228605,
0.0857750475,
-0.0074651758,
0.0237532519,
-0.0408407599,
0.0108670508,
0.0179278962,
0.0028030709,
0.0492958762,
0.0335714035,
-0.0210154261,
-0.0303224176,
-0.0179364849,
-0.0292901192,
0.0978212059,
0.0097266911,
-0.0281692687,
0.0367196016,
0.0036383118,
-0.0360496528,
0.0047586705,
-0.0008159801,
-0.029525876,
0.009600997,
0.0116651235,
0.0057915826,
0.0343085229,
0.0188611988,
0.0272666272,
-0.0372512117,
-0.0195766836,
-0.0085938573,
-0.0041656378,
0.0092657786,
0.0336907469,
0.0832008496,
-0.0264515821,
-0.0140971122,
0.0464108437,
-0.0526821911,
-0.0068048346,
-0.0213264469,
0.0185710024,
-0.0436830148,
0.017248841,
-0.0307449345,
-0.0438915566,
-0.004947782,
-0.0194386896,
0.036477495,
-0.0463002846,
0.0353296772,
0.0503474586,
0.0082918471,
0.0592497997,
0.0518246852,
-0.0643199831,
0.0213226173,
0.0370089561,
0.0246431027,
0.0309686363,
-0.0112531483,
-0.0341163203,
-0.0053440714,
0.0117785623,
0.0516732112,
0.0219730139,
0.0520262346,
-0.0223608427,
0.0661099181,
-0.0303891376,
0.0034794861,
-0.0610140301,
0.032038115,
0.0017748536,
0.0018539369,
-0.021811543,
0.025612995,
-0.0458675288,
-0.0295091458,
0.0546582229,
0.0087892413,
-0.0120938653,
0.0248996373,
0.0226258095,
0.0332772844,
0.0236518811,
0.0095731756,
0.0285801589,
-0.0068596243,
-0.0405814461,
-0.0562677495,
0.0616247877,
-0.0421383269,
-0.0787001178,
0.0423102938,
-0.0862259269,
-0.0291984733,
-0.0186960977,
-0.0915687382,
-0.0215986315,
0.0233164858,
-0.0055935676,
0.0283611789,
-0.0307389721,
-0.0111920089,
0.0022518057,
-0.009198878,
0.0099107418,
0.0625451952,
-0.0039899093,
0.0279026181,
0.0111907553,
-0.0381086729,
0.0212839562,
-0.0236940309,
-0.0431118682,
0.0386524349,
-0.0038605316,
-0.0156634841,
0.007521899,
0.01505154,
-0.0523288175,
0.0036888872,
-0.0313744545,
0.0127691729,
-0.0487894937,
0.0195318107,
0.0597131252,
0.0267512668,
0.0371445268,
0.0122451717,
-0.0304417443,
-0.0172730982,
-0.0068954849,
0.0276982952,
0.0478883609,
0.0035111278,
0.0103864986,
0.001714092,
-0.0454183482,
-0.0403830707,
0.0543463975,
-0.0304848179,
0.0027225944,
-0.0447545238,
-0.0385581776,
-0.0346242413,
-0.0126360636,
-0.0099884849,
-0.0381658264,
-0.0065892278,
-0.0066805435,
0.0202584956,
0.0491872244,
-0.0585975125,
-0.0017601368,
0.0531871691,
0.0070233559,
-0.023291178,
0.0252812617,
-0.0140399272,
0.0066518006,
-0.0336795412,
-0.0329089947,
0.0126080671,
0.0695398152,
-0.0109796971,
-0.0201372784,
-0.0503299795,
0.0149677172,
-0.0666090548,
-0.0267290231,
-0.0160042308,
0.0088651599,
-0.0167127624,
0.0125482567,
-0.046539396,
0.0081885019,
0.0857029632,
0.0106047587,
-0.0084613515,
-0.0533183515,
0.0256629884,
-0.0507520512,
0.0527967103,
-0.0091835484,
0.008756849,
-0.0132841123,
-0.05053946,
-0.0297803972,
0.0028099567,
0.0291451626,
0.0256288201,
0.0084790867,
-0.0258838926,
-0.0264830198,
-0.0240227357,
-0.0196383335,
0.0089844083,
0.0067112185,
0.0031924886,
0.0147580272,
0.0259209983,
0.0380152203,
-0.0117251975,
-0.0243299883,
-0.0109373881,
-0.0192315783,
0.008313572,
0.014394721,
-0.0136868218,
-0.0195104945,
-0.0082926704,
0.0194763336,
-0.0106989928,
-0.0250197295,
0.033005923,
0.0128366249,
-0.0120460261,
0.0154569959,
-0.0160514656,
0.019320596,
-0.0037534065,
-0.0113653922,
-0.0273753963,
-0.0049156621,
0.054015968,
-0.0463719554,
0.0062420964,
0.0813502222,
0.039182879,
-0.0109571004,
0.0175345913,
0.014286506,
-0.0130893467,
0.036473792,
0.0083230883,
-0.1088238358,
-0.0096625341,
0.0424639359,
-0.0399528518,
0.014399956,
-0.0275509525,
0.003707363,
-0.1126800105,
-0.0121667422,
0.0188116971,
-0.0686989874,
-0.0485317931,
-0.0215944517,
-0.0236743912,
-0.0648623332,
0.0255697854,
-0.0050244904,
-0.0198138617,
-0.0000456074,
-0.0073579913,
-0.0204712469,
-0.0554118082,
-0.0044981465,
-0.070790939,
-0.0193613805,
0.044132106,
0.0296028554,
-0.0234643687,
-0.0121941529,
0.0490878299,
0.0011827049,
-0.0186139252,
0.0142122405,
0.0228962488,
-0.0053814012,
-0.0263833646,
0.036356017,
0.0294544641,
-0.0372365341,
0.012445312,
-0.0110071395,
0.0627025515,
0.0221983083,
-0.031953074,
0.0053526745,
0.0189699456,
-0.031523224,
0.0924137458,
0.042696394,
-0.0203392319,
-0.0166805275,
-0.0585211888,
-0.0155106224,
-0.0803190544,
0.0212743953,
0.0639388263,
0.0098998658,
0.0047004814,
-0.0810371712,
-0.0920749232,
0.0365731791,
-0.0017367085,
-0.0100945029,
-0.0216488503,
0.026778033,
-0.016742073,
-0.0006238769,
0.0209578685,
-0.0075366986,
0.0281812958,
0.0080147721,
0.0105371559,
-0.0286187343,
-0.0082842186,
-0.0142983599,
-0.0391173437,
-0.0749275535,
-0.0603384972,
-0.0096930694,
0.0666297078,
0.0061354619,
0.0207922533,
-0.0325819254,
-0.0230560619,
-0.0215270519,
0.0097862156,
0.0062045353,
-0.0028897042,
0.0744102448,
-0.003070133,
0.0483470149,
0.0565751046,
-0.0559326485,
-0.0043981923,
0.0113097802,
0.0679277331,
0.044998996,
0.0437586792,
0.0747026652,
-0.0129869906,
-0.0135995243,
-0.0107691009,
0.0460268632,
-0.0181560051,
0.0245184787,
-0.0536656827,
-0.0653117374,
-0.0466900319,
-0.004669507,
0.0670947805,
0.0062403367,
-0.0153324381,
-0.0053623109,
-0.0222815089,
0.033227548,
-0.0403115414,
0.0014017038,
0.0618191622,
-0.0549069121,
-0.0118036401,
0.0300357938,
-0.0195992086,
0.0113080479,
-0.0241910163,
-0.0264994334,
-0.0323256999,
-0.0265101157,
0.0413218699,
0.0340874195,
-0.0537843555,
-0.0288440138,
-0.0425102264,
0.0243955012,
0.0186368655,
-0.0148343537,
0.0861273631,
-0.0558667444,
0.0349702351,
0.0208389778,
-0.0296926834,
0.0024328977,
0.040151298,
0.0010450587,
-0.0281380657,
0.0469211265,
0.0000423791,
-0.0158802923,
-0.05117587,
0.1211328432,
-0.0164930932,
0.066440247,
0.0078025982,
0.0113833826,
-0.0212971475,
-0.0211404786,
0.0267753266,
0.0454145931,
-0.0352736935,
-0.0342762247,
-0.0262461193,
-0.0404441319,
-0.0135216499,
0.0080769844,
-0.0019785115,
0.0253799558,
0.0198444612,
0.086020954,
0.0065303431,
-0.0343784615,
-0.001103026,
-0.0619155578,
0.0107106678,
0.0104511781,
-0.0457775742,
-5.310239894e-33,
-0.0060206088,
0.0307019409,
-0.0045665684,
0.0234158225,
-0.0083618453,
-0.0157134514,
-0.0131626548,
-0.0110475253,
-0.0267642103,
0.0392900631,
-0.0011877706,
0.0083982656,
0.0184416063,
0.0222119931,
0.0364252739,
-0.0117479693,
0.0628378317,
0.0040824367,
-0.0153383417,
-0.0178191718,
0.0176151153,
0.0409286991,
0.0949997529,
0.005077803,
0.0400324464,
0.0440192483,
-0.0118908715,
0.0344471671,
-0.0157989804,
0.0629323497,
0.0141801583,
0.0414628685,
0.0528826639,
0.0160597693,
-0.0285393819,
-0.0285455938,
-0.0916459188,
-0.037274722,
0.05025189,
0.0118704112,
-0.0264447145,
-0.0464125946,
0.0397174656,
-0.0370211676,
0.0271437895,
-0.0410652421,
0.0239581205,
-0.0133922594,
-0.0154680042,
-0.0692557469,
-0.0693751648,
0.0116325002,
-0.0027377177,
0.0424255133,
-0.0035306492,
0.0341374613,
-0.0188508593,
0.0407328419,
-0.0621766895,
0.0080939513,
-0.0696677864,
0.0279771537,
-0.0013996771,
-0.0178316906,
0.0230424162,
0.0099003362,
0.0278656241,
0.0183116086,
-0.0194633491,
0.0406105071,
-0.0064215828,
0.0359244347,
0.0115761673,
0.0548608117,
0.0531653948,
0.0012153692,
-0.0538573749,
-0.013180472,
-0.0168743562,
0.0619551726,
0.0101812165,
-0.0008731564,
-0.0035837549,
-0.0114331609,
-0.0480596647,
-0.0259036273,
-0.0132947816,
-0.0379021913,
0.0074391151,
0.0265112873,
-0.018076323,
-0.0099992212,
0.0140784858,
-0.0497041792,
0.0051793773,
0.0388731286,
-0.0226259027,
-0.0178331118,
0.0099130878,
0.013196446,
-0.0394666865,
-0.0544830821,
-0.0045221141,
0.0084812287,
0.0276585277,
-0.0208452344,
0.1061866209,
0.0103314575,
-0.0217622146,
0.0062493267,
-0.0651312321,
-0.0325604491,
-0.0103485864,
0.0504427478,
0.0465001166,
0.0439519845,
-0.0271975622,
0.0169128459,
0.0239110459,
0.0351445638,
-0.0337916501,
-0.0264938474,
0.0073145023,
0.0424246229,
-0.0161488112,
-0.0098116361,
-0.0115733463,
0.0180114079,
0.078491874,
-0.0400937609,
-0.0355439782,
0.0034041395,
2.34e-7,
0.064306058,
0.0230787918,
0.0122504393,
0.0604411364,
0.0111290142,
-0.0222933609,
-0.0572107993,
0.0270100422,
-0.0261411313,
0.0016024023,
-0.0109218219,
-0.0019567285,
0.0516139008,
0.0442645773,
-0.0921464264,
0.0096777314,
-0.0849231854,
-0.0144614801,
-0.0378075875,
0.0019228616,
0.0179392546,
0.1010095254,
0.0021900171,
0.0236156415,
-0.005057584,
-0.0313056074,
0.0745396391,
-0.0270095319,
-0.0209126212,
0.0042510447,
0.0331783183,
0.0210063141,
0.0251197144,
-0.022706775,
-0.032021787,
0.052229017,
0.0386967659,
0.0416359715,
0.024686005,
0.0101310965,
0.0056451033,
-0.0348623917,
-0.0143380556,
-0.0362162478,
0.0560724922,
-0.0690832734,
-0.0024487644,
0.0003679341,
-0.0166282803,
0.0153052695,
0.0578101166,
-0.0122428425,
0.0177701004,
0.0283532534,
0.0482387133,
0.0109046958,
-0.013738363,
-0.0184709858,
-0.0571845584,
0.019131856,
-0.0010741614,
-0.0141313393,
0.0305544976,
-0.0093444865,
0.0144516937,
-0.0329415873,
-0.018078424,
1.747072739e-34,
0.0651093721,
-0.0120552089,
0.0530703403,
-0.0051917438,
0.0539296791,
-0.0498558581,
-0.0283345357,
0.010906483,
-0.0379253887,
-0.0415142141,
-0.0145184537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11400v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11400v1 | MuDPT: Multi-modal Deep-symphysis Prompt Tuning for Large Pre-trained Vision-Language Models | 2023-06-20T09:15:52 | 2023-06-20T09:15:52 | Yongzhu Miao, Shasha Li, Jintao Tang, Ting Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Prompt tuning, like CoOp, has recently shown promising vision recognizing and
transfer learning ability on various downstream tasks with the emergence of
large pre-trained vision-language models like CLIP. However, we identify that
existing uni-modal prompt tuning approaches may result in sub-optimal
performance since this uni-modal design breaks the original alignment of
textual and visual representations in the pre-trained model. Inspired by the
nature of pre-trained vision-language models, we aim to achieve completeness in
prompt tuning and propose a novel approach called Multi-modal Deep-symphysis
Prompt Tuning, dubbed as MuDPT, which extends independent multi-modal prompt
tuning by additionally learning a model-agnostic transformative network to
allow deep hierarchical bi-directional prompt fusion. We evaluate the
effectiveness of MuDPT on few-shot vision recognition and out-of-domain
generalization tasks. Compared with the state-of-the-art methods, MuDPT
achieves better recognition and generalization ability with an apparent margin
thanks to synergistic alignment of textual and visual representations. Our code
is available at: https://github.com/Mechrev0/MuDPT. | [
0.0040514087,
0.0480926558,
0.0268857479,
0.0396239311,
-0.0186868571,
0.0121938149,
0.0392546691,
-0.0328754,
-0.0188161973,
-0.0564395897,
-0.0808875039,
-0.022557456,
0.0207072999,
0.0563283451,
-0.001787092,
-0.0580079369,
0.0606734343,
-0.0249741431,
-0.0298476908,
0.0139492415,
-0.0009864048,
0.0055900072,
-0.0234597679,
0.035833057,
-0.008095582,
-0.0254090987,
-0.0165678877,
0.0570229106,
0.0294352807,
-0.002179526,
0.0055889124,
0.0582115836,
0.038449496,
0.0282464884,
0.0000020351,
-0.0620809756,
0.0059150616,
-0.0101286974,
-0.0052723549,
-0.0093868263,
0.0330461413,
-0.0421946272,
-0.0070304605,
0.009418183,
-0.011927804,
-0.0123038087,
0.0622936413,
0.0176159032,
0.0709528476,
0.0638464615,
-0.0236831121,
-0.014715312,
0.0099031879,
-0.0494922809,
-0.002186771,
-0.0154698184,
0.008387818,
-0.0594786406,
-0.0004957521,
-0.0112811737,
-0.0311304592,
0.0142060034,
0.0127410702,
-0.0106859682,
-0.0057942695,
0.0148841962,
-0.0132389702,
-0.0378633849,
-0.0468033291,
0.0833864659,
-0.0347723588,
-0.0071663051,
-0.0317063481,
-0.032368768,
0.0294575319,
0.0132678784,
-0.0061280341,
0.0146982325,
0.011895353,
0.0154816527,
-0.0541103892,
0.0100058261,
0.0104421992,
0.0031520894,
-0.0210720915,
-0.0030765904,
0.0257024448,
0.0446811058,
0.0031394067,
0.0132519463,
-0.0388026685,
-0.0635205805,
0.0153367622,
0.0349367335,
-0.0605708137,
-0.027227208,
-0.0756683052,
-0.0095047513,
-0.0172710121,
0.0389647968,
0.0594619028,
0.0513572432,
-0.0927416235,
0.0817133188,
-0.0523766801,
0.0502979234,
-0.0122212144,
0.099311851,
-0.0366735719,
0.0011071515,
-0.0190005209,
0.0095859887,
-0.025950253,
-0.0303277355,
-0.0456185266,
-0.0464119911,
-0.0113896653,
0.0324112475,
-0.0159068275,
-0.0139135951,
0.0143867712,
0.0135901487,
-0.0516545549,
-0.0432485789,
-0.0141183408,
0.0388288051,
-0.0238994434,
0.043832425,
0.0240309481,
-0.0686955377,
-0.0321599245,
0.0445892029,
0.0276022144,
-0.0169619489,
0.0138445692,
0.0560825169,
-0.0643089861,
-0.0518429726,
0.0020154654,
0.0110877231,
-0.0189546291,
-0.024600774,
0.0307517275,
-0.0344860181,
0.0345739536,
-0.0049420726,
0.0098801712,
-0.0193226952,
-0.0110514918,
-0.0193248317,
0.0109571209,
0.0881736353,
-0.0205494445,
-0.0042585088,
0.0137272933,
-0.0021102163,
-0.0106718428,
0.0539373271,
0.0020652593,
0.054864984,
0.0178928971,
0.0224400293,
0.0304613505,
0.0517809913,
-0.0060866293,
0.0266604554,
-0.0411728881,
-0.0217810497,
0.0561317988,
0.0108167855,
0.062100742,
0.0232077297,
-0.0033743177,
-0.0238088593,
0.0351488627,
0.0064025102,
0.0138207227,
-0.0495786108,
0.0707498863,
0.0018243906,
-0.0020724984,
-0.021413913,
-0.0513244048,
0.0325322524,
-0.0034411605,
-0.019744277,
-0.0273458194,
0.0603444539,
-0.0446599871,
-0.0061480738,
0.0327550396,
-0.0018486264,
-0.0386128314,
0.0450938903,
0.0307679381,
-0.0020982581,
-0.0306244064,
0.0437391587,
0.0274043903,
0.0019319704,
0.0163212102,
-0.0397613458,
-0.0139450328,
0.0099493312,
-0.0317803249,
-0.0542944297,
-0.0182333775,
-0.0023816833,
0.0289353523,
0.0421532504,
0.0191109404,
0.0012605306,
0.0662127659,
-0.0474449433,
-0.063387692,
-0.0105569782,
0.0089397402,
0.0288792048,
-0.0306525808,
-0.0138963033,
0.031688273,
0.0346217379,
0.0530638024,
0.0610970594,
0.0135822538,
-0.0115187699,
-0.0047008344,
0.0555859618,
0.0027602643,
-0.0082801944,
-0.0205129497,
0.000459599,
0.0118481396,
-0.0333132446,
0.0391219407,
-0.003561636,
-0.0689770132,
-0.041327104,
0.0377245024,
-0.0200973712,
-0.0029806984,
0.0325554349,
-0.0402978286,
-0.0614317954,
-0.024122756,
-0.0154394014,
-0.0024632951,
-0.0563713051,
0.0289124902,
-0.0032671078,
0.0411117859,
-0.0300184339,
0.0224097781,
0.0039667464,
-0.0211550016,
0.069104977,
0.0494451113,
-0.0000932705,
-0.0185412988,
-0.0128862793,
-0.0151205622,
-0.0307636391,
0.0014697518,
0.0172286332,
0.0085214199,
-0.0305842552,
-0.0299948994,
-0.0857031345,
-0.0091833072,
-0.0399500243,
-0.0284621846,
0.0273536351,
0.0048723845,
-0.0128970155,
-0.0556276776,
-0.0335210674,
0.0314650014,
0.0128850155,
0.0164299551,
0.0169550534,
0.0306775793,
0.0008695747,
-0.0283426102,
0.0030202873,
0.0212641321,
0.046919886,
-0.0146629019,
-0.0343989916,
-0.0422888696,
0.0277411789,
0.0089025702,
0.0286987349,
-0.0194934662,
-0.0016300761,
0.0025878097,
-0.0366157629,
0.0562572367,
0.0681473687,
-0.0030764211,
-0.0197432768,
0.0173895713,
-0.0130076427,
-0.0251142867,
0.0035159765,
-0.0221391004,
-0.0486698262,
-0.0143339699,
0.0498716496,
0.0094665205,
0.0296532307,
-0.0525168069,
-0.0079302583,
-0.0689911321,
0.0218793433,
0.009883537,
-0.0268704724,
-0.0901698098,
0.0016859089,
-0.0218568351,
0.0254503414,
-0.0383072719,
-0.0576324612,
0.0213928446,
-0.0552720539,
-0.0132462354,
-0.005314705,
0.0014827076,
-0.0240069758,
0.0569004975,
0.0252679046,
0.0185378939,
0.0183246844,
-0.0425899662,
-0.1180486158,
-0.0073425756,
0.0143046295,
0.0050576841,
0.0450228453,
-0.0186955314,
0.0138476482,
-0.0533372499,
-0.0333634056,
-0.0262264628,
-0.0702099502,
-0.0235782806,
0.0229678806,
-0.0126087647,
-0.0109534319,
-0.017331874,
-0.0190688781,
0.0182905756,
0.0806560367,
-0.0085332878,
0.0135214627,
-0.0392315909,
0.0446781777,
0.0538120829,
0.0570470989,
-0.006240644,
-0.0290009379,
0.0170004629,
0.0230867062,
0.0216752924,
-0.0104716998,
-0.0352905579,
0.0410059951,
0.0610653199,
0.0084813805,
0.0074424068,
0.0335958526,
0.0720862448,
-0.0300310869,
0.0074775163,
0.0475760326,
0.0122049395,
-0.0847828686,
-0.0422083735,
0.0387490354,
0.0149554387,
0.0285896901,
0.0061357711,
-0.0644657016,
-0.064174965,
0.0118937409,
-0.0306490939,
0.0354612209,
0.0141218752,
-0.0435126685,
-0.0754825175,
-0.0048500751,
0.0162656158,
-0.0446912348,
-0.0337084979,
0.025208693,
0.016458042,
-0.0083603999,
-0.0076173982,
0.009064639,
-0.0433268994,
-0.0138808871,
-0.0153213758,
0.0517562851,
-0.0444495641,
0.0162000004,
-0.0593398996,
-0.0019542479,
0.0652189702,
-0.0180445462,
-0.0032940353,
-0.0720542073,
0.0638054162,
-0.0311491806,
-0.0020635275,
0.0287174173,
0.0258336272,
-0.0416906439,
-0.020323066,
0.0294446945,
0.0486625917,
-0.0347562134,
-0.0472158007,
-0.0399571322,
0.0088554621,
0.0111582726,
0.0255696289,
-0.0453724451,
0.0013734527,
0.020938959,
0.0198221784,
0.0095010381,
-0.0471828617,
-0.0162962433,
0.0019300925,
-0.0172862709,
-0.0232622176,
-0.0015882843,
-0.0011982657,
0.0274267234,
-0.0288136005,
-0.0289618298,
-0.006875535,
0.0210141186,
0.0546000041,
-0.0067043141,
-0.0668336824,
-0.0366085581,
0.0500082634,
-0.031830702,
0.0813538879,
-0.0294908565,
0.0495549478,
-0.0898454711,
0.0363860317,
0.0448145941,
-0.0383140557,
-0.0242379885,
-0.0021449465,
-0.0876384526,
-0.0345417112,
-0.0186195672,
0.0436798148,
0.0155691933,
0.0345309637,
-0.0287719816,
-0.0451395772,
0.0425092056,
0.060192842,
-0.0200623982,
0.0106014758,
0.0115744714,
-0.0497188829,
-0.0431930833,
0.0166474655,
-0.0426073223,
0.0318073668,
0.061431352,
-0.0067420295,
0.0221174583,
-0.0251194816,
0.0168711692,
-0.025983464,
0.0997088552,
0.0029153866,
0.0205715913,
-0.0663337409,
-0.0029163072,
0.0301482081,
-0.0123556349,
-0.0659047514,
0.0237096846,
0.0079949573,
-0.0170033146,
0.0149956215,
-0.0130562801,
0.0380802527,
0.0278155897,
-0.0186101366,
-0.0141398804,
0.0304891579,
0.0044137863,
0.0126369325,
0.019993227,
0.0023827739,
0.0614765882,
-0.0060685291,
0.0172311831,
-0.0208187103,
0.0643049106,
0.038200777,
0.0115397666,
-0.0311277807,
0.0693356246,
-0.0282251928,
-0.0445647687,
-0.0713793412,
0.0301654022,
0.0485039689,
0.0033141486,
-0.0137101971,
0.0232591014,
-0.0277837738,
-0.0329288468,
0.0427890792,
0.042309165,
-0.0276000239,
0.0363649875,
0.0147588328,
-0.0208792202,
-0.0042610429,
0.0526488908,
-0.0301552806,
0.0269024558,
0.0213511884,
0.0356107987,
-0.0485093668,
-0.007180851,
0.0181336217,
0.0068819951,
-0.0372888967,
0.0577876344,
-0.0093745776,
-0.0387508981,
-0.0137156984,
0.0131110465,
-0.0195873491,
0.0649894252,
0.0333959945,
0.0438665375,
-0.0091022048,
-0.0200486742,
-0.0093431938,
-0.020572044,
0.0430079959,
0.0092928754,
0.0217674989,
-6.132641823e-33,
-0.0418432765,
0.0250558108,
0.0172057841,
-0.0322210081,
-0.0181436613,
0.0032161875,
-0.0126395039,
0.0465124398,
-0.0303185936,
0.0096737668,
-0.0248962305,
-0.007350341,
0.0434067361,
0.0469681658,
-0.0232276786,
0.0095455274,
0.0605650954,
0.0075246696,
-0.0200214926,
-0.0048006522,
0.0326029509,
0.0475385524,
0.0355047248,
-0.0051776939,
-0.0329506062,
0.022672385,
-0.0483103804,
0.0248789266,
0.0288509149,
0.0175777003,
0.0063201999,
-0.0261201821,
-0.001184899,
-0.0340108164,
-0.0153353335,
0.0618230067,
-0.0540426373,
-0.0204405077,
-0.0178166144,
0.0254989136,
-0.0741297305,
-0.0309932511,
0.0158165898,
-0.0173225384,
0.0114947278,
-0.0404175781,
0.0355926715,
-0.0278989263,
-0.0124003096,
-0.0264494196,
-0.0501821637,
0.0110453572,
0.0298749376,
-0.0612318888,
0.013744019,
0.071385406,
0.0212546047,
0.0216433555,
-0.0380239338,
0.0065414128,
0.0045736479,
0.0448946059,
0.0324749015,
0.0811025128,
-0.0208393466,
0.0460749306,
0.0004885935,
-0.0575391091,
0.0006902613,
-0.0236787256,
0.0426480472,
0.0499793552,
0.0412135087,
0.0682538599,
0.0193210915,
-0.0122208111,
-0.0611115322,
0.0270857085,
0.0102455243,
0.0243178289,
-0.008708478,
0.0205153041,
0.039550662,
0.0005218258,
-0.0462846234,
-0.0334123448,
-0.0512457043,
0.0088607287,
0.0243204497,
0.0596755147,
-0.02742186,
0.0538299195,
0.1022264436,
-0.0306893382,
0.0052273194,
0.0181989148,
-0.00699906,
0.0123657398,
0.00003622,
0.0222615823,
-0.0456784815,
-0.0439479239,
0.0629329756,
-0.0077700973,
-0.0091005964,
0.0084930444,
0.0381511711,
0.0450184792,
-0.0452485532,
-0.0005209465,
-0.0123860203,
0.0244507045,
0.0037443617,
0.0838332474,
0.0260548946,
-0.0110911233,
-0.0440973826,
0.0464423671,
-0.0400557816,
-0.0436619818,
-0.0114829345,
0.0048092739,
0.0091212932,
0.0449575745,
-0.0019958362,
0.0047934577,
-0.0419744216,
-0.0058951746,
0.0340538882,
-0.0208042171,
0.0000308734,
0.0014893543,
2.736e-7,
0.0168542508,
-0.018430274,
-0.0143993292,
-0.0289830267,
0.0065012439,
0.044364471,
-0.0215451065,
0.0476787463,
-0.0065623233,
-0.0639815927,
0.0250780601,
0.0165837463,
0.0260217227,
-0.0109416274,
-0.0503294803,
0.0125677772,
-0.0451730639,
0.0275309402,
-0.0290642511,
-0.0197381023,
0.0185670126,
0.1392004043,
-0.0225194339,
-0.0109969657,
0.0494744927,
-0.0391236134,
0.0758848414,
-0.0424564183,
0.0092341956,
0.0217791125,
-0.0061480612,
0.0016419798,
-0.0331999883,
0.0308682453,
-0.0132604865,
0.0239016656,
0.0525855981,
0.0254575256,
-0.003142877,
-0.0178041607,
-0.0246314239,
0.052865766,
0.0033672878,
-0.0712880269,
0.0717856884,
-0.1019685268,
0.0010980148,
-0.0663884059,
-0.0415878296,
-0.0104576778,
0.0337068662,
-0.0110146813,
-0.0238597821,
0.0455067232,
0.0535134226,
0.0121937031,
-0.0420273542,
-0.1192676201,
-0.0141179264,
-0.0313890651,
-0.0393091403,
-0.0055741263,
-0.0504064783,
-0.0329929329,
0.0656069145,
-0.0554692671,
-0.0179038998,
2.269645181e-34,
0.0110055003,
-0.0237240382,
0.0333843604,
-0.0345318057,
0.0043834108,
-0.0000494309,
0.0034825737,
-0.0014813984,
0.0074405666,
-0.0522771031,
-0.0227188617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11386v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11386v1 | Did the Models Understand Documents? Benchmarking Models for Language Understanding in Document-Level Relation Extraction | 2023-06-20T08:52:05 | 2023-06-20T08:52:05 | Haotian Chen, Bingsheng Chen, Xiangdong Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level relation extraction (DocRE) attracts more research interest
recently. While models achieve consistent performance gains in DocRE, their
underlying decision rules are still understudied: Do they make the right
predictions according to rationales? In this paper, we take the first step
toward answering this question and then introduce a new perspective on
comprehensively evaluating a model. Specifically, we first conduct annotations
to provide the rationales considered by humans in DocRE. Then, we conduct
investigations and reveal the fact that: In contrast to humans, the
representative state-of-the-art (SOTA) models in DocRE exhibit different
decision rules. Through our proposed RE-specific attacks, we next demonstrate
that the significant discrepancy in decision rules between models and humans
severely damages the robustness of models and renders them inapplicable to
real-world RE scenarios. After that, we introduce mean average precision (MAP)
to evaluate the understanding and reasoning capabilities of models. According
to the extensive experimental results, we finally appeal to future work to
consider evaluating both performance and the understanding ability of models
for the development of their applications. We make our annotations and code
publicly available. | [
0.0743780136,
0.0459659621,
0.0151572302,
0.095274657,
-0.0389950648,
0.0450091735,
-0.0132561754,
-0.0388602652,
-0.0115942527,
-0.0440470167,
-0.0115374215,
-0.0168863311,
0.0075436193,
0.0105121471,
-0.0253847707,
-0.0378919095,
0.0393602848,
-0.0233193561,
0.0280151851,
0.014591462,
-0.0078597786,
0.0009863621,
0.0016167833,
-0.0157126263,
-0.0079471273,
-0.018887056,
0.0173452199,
0.009015928,
0.0055758273,
-0.0524250641,
-0.0009158429,
0.0467616767,
0.0177642684,
0.061397288,
0.0000019031,
-0.0471079685,
-0.0525844395,
0.0340297408,
-0.0470619947,
-0.0031148097,
0.0067155855,
-0.0575442798,
0.0062463311,
-0.0198677517,
-0.04597966,
-0.0345942527,
0.0051133344,
0.0582094416,
0.0214018524,
0.0937457457,
-0.0321990252,
-0.0386083201,
0.0590226017,
-0.0328792669,
-0.0002816728,
-0.0769591779,
0.034745317,
0.0255255383,
0.0072374097,
-0.0086853942,
-0.0040890784,
0.009467802,
0.0025858532,
-0.0025128485,
-0.0018635296,
0.032058496,
-0.0222720541,
-0.033333309,
0.0021321352,
0.0839077979,
-0.0030162246,
0.0236466583,
0.0324871503,
0.0317227133,
-0.0100535061,
0.0465272479,
-0.0087121101,
0.0032075723,
-0.0592919029,
0.0234283116,
0.0177064091,
0.0166136306,
0.0599768348,
0.0243655965,
-0.0147106089,
0.0831283331,
-0.0167925972,
-0.0697624907,
0.0563919768,
0.0345987901,
-0.0018203532,
-0.0296806972,
0.0250439998,
0.0181569867,
0.0113992272,
0.0523756593,
-0.0347779021,
-0.0287471041,
0.0114233959,
-0.0577241629,
-0.0046083392,
0.0057263817,
-0.005591487,
0.0793632343,
-0.0427465439,
0.0308505204,
-0.02804281,
0.0025812921,
0.0050835949,
-0.0107908221,
-0.0299338419,
0.0125770355,
-0.00048016,
0.0490433909,
-0.0652559698,
-0.0372597091,
-0.0374824256,
0.0202138368,
-0.0082445052,
0.0581044294,
-0.006636621,
-0.0207764376,
-0.037115477,
-0.0197277945,
-0.0091384687,
-0.032279823,
-0.0069427509,
-0.0063841273,
-0.0193079226,
-0.0241129994,
-0.0060826493,
-0.0382820703,
-0.0013655374,
-0.0466479249,
-0.0044945679,
0.0982074291,
0.0101316907,
-0.0573294014,
0.0031674758,
-0.0579348616,
0.0133737894,
-0.0540166199,
0.0206806716,
-0.0078164814,
0.0215468053,
0.0411489904,
-0.0168814585,
-0.049961403,
0.0204952117,
-0.0101233795,
-0.0747483075,
0.0956467465,
-0.0047507621,
-0.0122626219,
0.0097847758,
0.0351098105,
-0.0087777236,
0.070650205,
0.039311558,
0.0231727362,
0.0801385939,
0.020603789,
0.0362061262,
0.0013326836,
-0.0139890499,
-0.038327571,
0.0272018574,
0.0131352497,
-0.0005740699,
0.0141916983,
0.0591744743,
0.0273769218,
-0.0180932023,
-0.0744510293,
0.0426386446,
0.0354838148,
0.0236177109,
0.034768898,
0.0283130892,
-0.0195475724,
0.0444050543,
0.0397738591,
-0.0806077942,
-0.0188098513,
-0.0230092146,
0.0400418937,
-0.0705284923,
0.0230494961,
0.0101284804,
0.0033850248,
-0.0472701602,
-0.0195693057,
-0.0205364656,
-0.0086874878,
0.0841996148,
-0.0083275102,
-0.0279112011,
0.0308386236,
0.0383422934,
-0.0292884596,
-0.0035927976,
-0.0252621882,
0.0159937218,
-0.0009715527,
0.0907605588,
-0.0669400841,
-0.008717726,
-0.0002212301,
-0.023177458,
0.0305536259,
0.0681978241,
-0.0082190465,
0.0172270276,
-0.0272511225,
-0.0579297394,
-0.0066121658,
0.0192195531,
-0.0058753653,
0.0399990454,
-0.030012615,
0.0153345773,
-0.0771789625,
-0.0232808124,
0.0627720803,
-0.0144097237,
-0.0255787093,
-0.0223152284,
0.0166665222,
0.0346875228,
0.0119545562,
-0.0213406775,
-0.0018543168,
0.0622077435,
0.0009702363,
0.0380174182,
0.0149560329,
-0.0457924157,
-0.0135523118,
0.012057038,
-0.0199062098,
-0.0380928516,
0.024824407,
-0.0383558162,
-0.0239473768,
-0.0213159248,
-0.0101606483,
0.0507882088,
-0.0244372748,
0.0018258508,
0.0355176181,
0.0059577813,
-0.0238924827,
0.0786679015,
-0.0124610439,
-0.0276330616,
0.032363195,
-0.0445495285,
0.0078953505,
-0.0253567174,
-0.0275400113,
0.0448231585,
-0.0075265113,
-0.0336003862,
0.0047275512,
-0.0060701258,
-0.0393473916,
-0.0382235423,
-0.0434115231,
-0.0235143416,
0.0034804691,
0.080648303,
0.007484166,
0.0002269241,
-0.0242326614,
-0.0197548606,
-0.0054681553,
-0.0054410826,
-0.0478834584,
0.0177202392,
0.0714200586,
0.0000777311,
-0.0054253577,
-0.0552490577,
-0.0163472593,
-0.0184938796,
0.0777907819,
0.0367561318,
0.0084456485,
-0.0241199024,
0.0140283415,
-0.0254499707,
0.0501343086,
-0.0225185715,
-0.0009037191,
-0.0152186705,
0.0009466426,
-0.0053814128,
0.0707781315,
-0.0063173492,
0.099364534,
0.0168122966,
0.0239153318,
-0.0233219378,
0.0142272431,
-0.0205854662,
0.0290535875,
-0.0402713455,
-0.023889415,
-0.0004139216,
0.0679262653,
-0.0256922282,
0.0260431394,
0.0286052655,
0.0288468432,
-0.0021733071,
-0.0161393043,
-0.0365884267,
0.006149672,
0.0137531627,
0.032000415,
-0.0610026494,
-0.0232721101,
0.0928781629,
-0.0277221743,
-0.0193024278,
-0.0587980375,
0.0148773352,
-0.0397920795,
0.070844017,
-0.0134854261,
0.0161291417,
-0.0213349368,
-0.0298834611,
-0.0083249705,
-0.0398305394,
0.0412333645,
-0.0213127472,
0.0214838125,
-0.0912033021,
0.0409358777,
-0.0102902856,
-0.01273988,
-0.0472574122,
-0.0373713598,
-0.0396933109,
0.0148963397,
-0.0051564695,
-0.0158879496,
-0.0155072249,
0.0385541804,
0.0317303129,
0.0437888317,
-0.0304737911,
-0.0457705446,
-0.0177310035,
0.0735248551,
0.0644974411,
-0.0334257297,
0.0359017365,
-0.0157573447,
0.0403840356,
0.0584100708,
0.0146191288,
-0.0110991271,
-0.0448764749,
0.0251685251,
-0.005722472,
-0.044161018,
0.0030670164,
-0.0243754052,
0.0152378762,
-0.0950123817,
-0.0374541208,
0.095654808,
0.0275478587,
-0.0221729428,
0.0073516532,
0.0006422273,
-0.0040478981,
0.0022397391,
0.0025872269,
-0.0220290814,
-0.0343378633,
0.0185742602,
0.0208487902,
-0.0069238376,
-0.0773435533,
-0.0007866031,
-0.0642622635,
0.0368571468,
-0.0359787829,
-0.0483466983,
-0.0237818453,
-0.0472084172,
0.0122333122,
-0.0407602265,
0.0251967926,
0.0182941724,
-0.0364284739,
0.0060635325,
0.0045589469,
-0.0106033441,
-0.0571816005,
0.0227429979,
-0.0105788549,
0.037305519,
0.0710909814,
0.0302891079,
0.005042376,
-0.0019194898,
0.0419533923,
-0.008492738,
0.0127817439,
-0.0351601429,
0.0676349476,
-0.0242545921,
0.0018207969,
-0.0206738096,
0.0087706642,
-0.0763141438,
0.0176621526,
-0.0017907097,
0.0571467355,
-0.0096058724,
-0.0405517034,
-0.0330761485,
-0.0293237455,
-0.0012715944,
0.0871286839,
0.0152637875,
0.0143918395,
-0.0711825341,
-0.0134158973,
0.0264329221,
-0.0188883264,
0.0242939889,
-0.0332462303,
-0.0433408953,
-0.0088673588,
-0.05336551,
-0.0950481519,
-0.0075324033,
0.0019856174,
-0.0180474687,
-0.0166164208,
0.0346499979,
0.0219199993,
-0.037364088,
0.0025819147,
-0.0126697002,
-0.0094509786,
-0.020038357,
0.0462831147,
0.0089304401,
-0.0212984774,
-0.0461045951,
-0.023244692,
-0.0490516536,
-0.0325837657,
0.0172900725,
0.0103618475,
0.0399781317,
0.040290419,
-0.0066086524,
-0.0192349404,
-0.0007215692,
0.0085307602,
-0.0354489163,
-0.0145860706,
0.0830531344,
-0.0319923647,
0.0003472621,
0.0456311107,
-0.0422972366,
0.0312979259,
0.0334012359,
0.0109260892,
-0.0385250337,
-0.0136669567,
0.0155841839,
0.0085673323,
0.057654392,
0.0209940653,
-0.0206421632,
-0.027001746,
0.0319909193,
-0.0640189797,
0.0081942864,
-0.0418648534,
0.0170342401,
0.0005908926,
0.0165571067,
-0.0280269999,
-0.0235733297,
-0.0099360254,
0.0372780971,
-0.0047669313,
-0.0268176291,
0.0414870791,
0.0177505855,
0.0014180802,
-0.0288021863,
-0.024429258,
0.028534973,
-0.0029868637,
0.0469585098,
-0.0043920232,
0.0305650719,
0.0115060741,
-0.0399892367,
0.0077141011,
-0.005238119,
-0.092768915,
0.0127235353,
0.0015593184,
0.0512380414,
0.0424572527,
-0.0383141786,
0.0464148,
-0.0406854153,
0.0067241397,
0.0145406919,
0.0176489539,
0.0102743609,
0.0421318933,
0.0157135874,
0.0213012509,
-0.015025422,
0.0343098305,
0.0801849961,
-0.0081333416,
0.032702405,
-0.0041565811,
-0.0781140402,
-0.0437091738,
-0.0189183075,
0.0061372407,
-0.0002928549,
-0.0490217023,
-0.005429606,
-0.0811368152,
-0.0482183546,
0.0161879733,
0.0117309019,
0.0096285101,
-0.000921696,
-0.0300885085,
0.0951675698,
0.027858967,
-0.0214122124,
-0.05274719,
0.0315102823,
-0.0658336505,
-0.0192770362,
-0.024268236,
-6.419683952e-33,
-0.0183598138,
-0.0233552847,
-0.0162234008,
0.0001333449,
0.0064761979,
0.0521828085,
-0.0628940687,
-0.0367147587,
-0.0340763442,
0.0352377892,
-0.0278468262,
0.0067880754,
0.020186428,
-0.0021092126,
-0.0303909462,
-0.0267727263,
0.0130994003,
-0.0009875385,
-0.0146130221,
-0.012766052,
0.0321069472,
0.0595826842,
0.0453053452,
-0.0969367698,
0.0499026999,
-0.015735656,
-0.0112421485,
0.01657358,
-0.0088010319,
0.0576582886,
-0.0282927044,
-0.0008518968,
0.0347975828,
-0.0073336586,
0.0017439777,
0.0006192133,
-0.1354159564,
-0.0026898419,
-0.0093611507,
-0.0080076093,
-0.0325836167,
0.0133533562,
0.047461763,
0.0111796772,
0.0437681414,
-0.0474049821,
0.025904974,
-0.0366203003,
-0.0477540903,
-0.0352587923,
-0.0428805314,
0.0397391208,
0.0247568041,
0.0095769446,
0.063121967,
0.0123221595,
0.0248861015,
0.0232597049,
-0.0592339821,
-0.0509487838,
0.0122401249,
0.0065259156,
0.0709273443,
-0.0287760757,
-0.0196818039,
0.0564195924,
0.0062498138,
-0.0215002894,
0.0128354151,
-0.0148936361,
-0.0001003372,
0.0403716676,
-0.010128268,
0.0248402879,
0.0500205643,
0.042047713,
-0.0979202464,
0.0128432158,
0.0331829451,
0.0847966,
0.0130491899,
0.0027637265,
-0.0994188562,
0.0242107492,
0.0100413049,
-0.0184735674,
-0.0220290534,
-0.0198497791,
0.0059388499,
0.0047250167,
-0.0159699395,
0.0401372835,
-0.0177753177,
-0.0289833173,
-0.0073792082,
0.0165842343,
0.0075596864,
-0.0167645626,
-0.0115786446,
-0.0064699021,
-0.025876699,
-0.0326527767,
-0.0107122492,
0.0033503345,
0.0107478248,
0.0065456908,
0.0409202091,
-0.01805369,
-0.0335188657,
-0.0325541347,
-0.0435377397,
0.0200854372,
0.0029503307,
0.044292625,
0.0229914337,
0.0026821033,
-0.0136432517,
0.0270927101,
0.024102509,
0.0392971709,
-0.051217474,
0.037906941,
0.0149641447,
0.0248191077,
0.0248649977,
-0.0167040192,
0.0134192724,
0.0144928508,
0.0364144035,
-0.0283802357,
0.0219020341,
0.0183391366,
2.759e-7,
0.0523557328,
0.041496139,
0.0619400926,
-0.0040587778,
0.0211764183,
0.0529068895,
-0.0142233614,
0.0326382034,
0.0158815533,
-0.0255399719,
0.0220622327,
-0.0178637635,
0.0558259413,
0.0452289768,
-0.0307094064,
-0.0311578158,
-0.0845368356,
-0.062802434,
-0.0299980752,
-0.0181709696,
0.0479640663,
0.045923043,
0.01017919,
-0.0153667964,
-0.0607826784,
-0.0255394988,
0.0554866269,
-0.0518604517,
0.0191675443,
0.014360588,
0.0975321904,
-0.0144231357,
0.006630362,
0.0508001745,
-0.0090319645,
0.0321076997,
0.0298595931,
0.0680320486,
-0.0158437211,
0.0140457368,
-0.021500608,
-0.0579239279,
0.0368783735,
-0.0571776778,
0.0482810587,
-0.0417316854,
-0.0010571111,
-0.0148996264,
-0.0255452543,
-0.0136390617,
-0.0118572842,
0.0000716765,
0.0043424624,
0.0203008465,
-0.0057619908,
-0.0268901028,
-0.0071165832,
-0.0684924722,
0.0065518222,
0.0218666289,
0.0013084494,
-0.0169501174,
-0.0100355679,
-0.0207229946,
0.0200114492,
-0.0338772498,
-0.0263862312,
2.437012618e-34,
0.0205723755,
0.0133242365,
-0.0235411841,
0.0487962142,
0.0222625993,
-0.0065201889,
0.0017631702,
0.0207267329,
-0.0416206904,
-0.0820515528,
0.0159556102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11372v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11372v1 | Democratizing LLMs for Low-Resource Languages by Leveraging their English Dominant Abilities with Linguistically-Diverse Prompts | 2023-06-20T08:27:47 | 2023-06-20T08:27:47 | Xuan-Phi Nguyen, Sharifah Mahani Aljunied, Shafiq Joty, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are known to effectively perform tasks by simply
observing few exemplars. However, in low-resource languages, obtaining such
hand-picked exemplars can still be challenging, where unsupervised techniques
may be necessary. Moreover, competent generative capabilities of LLMs are
observed only in high-resource languages, while their performances among
under-represented languages fall behind due to pre-training data imbalance. To
elicit LLMs' ability onto low-resource languages without any supervised data,
we propose to assemble synthetic exemplars from a diverse set of high-resource
languages to prompt the LLMs to translate from any language into English. These
prompts are then used to create intra-lingual exemplars to perform tasks in the
target languages. Our unsupervised prompting method performs on par with
supervised few-shot learning in LLMs of different sizes for translations
between English and 13 Indic and 21 African low-resource languages. We also
show that fine-tuning a 7B model on data generated from our method helps it
perform competitively with a 175B model. In non-English translation tasks, our
method even outperforms supervised prompting by up to 3 chrF++ in many
low-resource languages. When evaluated on zero-shot multilingual summarization,
our method surpasses other English-pivoting baselines by up to 4 ROUGE-L and is
also favored by GPT-4. | [
0.0403995626,
0.0440154336,
0.0205102433,
0.0206689443,
-0.0335402042,
0.0304564759,
0.0345027223,
-0.0296236333,
-0.0082557555,
-0.0367286988,
-0.0431883521,
-0.0474039353,
0.0186489746,
-0.0527360179,
0.0522792004,
-0.0545389429,
0.0147584295,
-0.0465085693,
-0.0254823994,
-0.0351443216,
-0.0284699667,
0.043014653,
0.0020924278,
0.0358683765,
0.0153897628,
-0.0120267943,
0.0143937338,
0.0341241919,
0.0289070457,
0.004828678,
-0.036296811,
0.0407044254,
0.0215812717,
0.0230799261,
0.0000022108,
-0.0636661127,
0.0054915939,
-0.0056821057,
-0.035051465,
0.0184338428,
0.0588508286,
-0.0554179363,
-0.0034386504,
0.0121937133,
-0.0173427369,
-0.0102310712,
0.0339802019,
-0.0087993415,
0.037325304,
0.0886875764,
0.0088521037,
-0.0135228401,
-0.0007458098,
-0.065329954,
0.0170479845,
-0.0214011464,
-0.0025511908,
-0.0138492342,
-0.0161754563,
0.0006113177,
-0.0215584189,
0.0389160216,
0.0286657028,
-0.0205363464,
-0.0122140571,
0.0215420555,
-0.0298824105,
-0.0400512554,
0.0051889685,
0.0701725408,
-0.0524435416,
0.0038119252,
-0.0034850365,
-0.0112012969,
0.0032348502,
-0.0008643571,
-0.0740507394,
0.0726514384,
0.0246686377,
0.0180321168,
0.0407260433,
0.0451539941,
0.0208971798,
0.0015380741,
-0.0393716693,
-0.0206717234,
0.0441653691,
0.00493277,
-0.0063948501,
0.0246799421,
-0.004399912,
-0.0370594822,
-0.0373431295,
0.0040524499,
-0.0356687196,
0.014965212,
-0.0155026261,
-0.0245626066,
0.0237457603,
0.0003213193,
0.0431996994,
0.0417731665,
-0.0241285414,
0.058579389,
-0.0153093887,
0.0435806215,
-0.0120303659,
0.0675687566,
-0.0696305931,
-0.0335443169,
-0.0136081073,
0.0162705947,
-0.0132588958,
0.0039067836,
-0.0842721313,
0.0159703195,
-0.0557842143,
0.0063816798,
0.0154348789,
0.0038075442,
0.0414286107,
-0.0209627394,
-0.049182497,
-0.0345704481,
0.0039862962,
0.0504894108,
-0.0058373497,
-0.0148541415,
0.0217694007,
-0.0870913714,
-0.0181161575,
0.0151397446,
-0.005478899,
-0.0452619568,
0.0077300384,
0.0810656473,
-0.0388842002,
-0.0438997336,
-0.0456685163,
0.0133194942,
0.0011994867,
-0.0885246694,
-0.0178320892,
-0.090417929,
0.0609358884,
0.0040569324,
0.0352388769,
-0.0290414132,
0.000944093,
-0.0031362853,
-0.0048418771,
0.0510696918,
0.027161682,
0.0185992997,
0.0267568827,
-0.0137481438,
0.0128176352,
0.0849105418,
0.0226433892,
0.0170073248,
0.0308770724,
0.028152125,
-0.0027925228,
0.0756003261,
-0.0045745648,
0.0401780978,
-0.0093226768,
0.0034319223,
0.0015975132,
0.005058819,
0.0609053522,
0.0369320661,
0.0004903309,
0.039142549,
0.0707076415,
0.0533253402,
-0.0226738881,
0.0063139834,
0.0634612888,
0.0195085742,
-0.017499458,
0.0293861739,
-0.0378642492,
0.0536239147,
-0.0102997897,
0.0087140817,
0.0693616048,
0.0854598731,
-0.047294829,
-0.0326910242,
0.0184836723,
-0.0251560453,
-0.0197312515,
0.0320141464,
0.0486771129,
0.0195169393,
-0.0410102904,
0.0337320901,
0.0469709374,
-0.0483415239,
0.0316900872,
-0.0330566242,
0.0123289144,
0.0642806962,
0.020741431,
0.0119290743,
0.0034321698,
-0.0358490534,
0.0356452093,
0.0735214502,
0.0323333926,
-0.0089646392,
0.0375608541,
-0.0508312881,
-0.0096928468,
-0.0079643521,
0.0080606071,
0.049331367,
-0.0257065538,
0.0044495724,
0.023877291,
-0.0577481315,
-0.0574823767,
0.020975804,
-0.0750964805,
-0.0452748537,
0.030503761,
0.0215138532,
0.0064253542,
0.0207416862,
-0.0014726523,
-0.0034571979,
-0.0082546044,
-0.0678128228,
0.0103145652,
0.0095398538,
-0.0555060096,
-0.072412014,
0.026259752,
-0.0180180874,
-0.0252053123,
0.0001990959,
-0.0383985601,
-0.0740610063,
0.0214555506,
-0.0103293033,
-0.0147422198,
-0.0655498803,
0.0177852828,
0.0148960259,
-0.0095129143,
-0.0366411172,
0.0497847833,
0.0047016069,
0.0019083758,
0.0443541557,
-0.0159647353,
0.0053223385,
-0.0457804911,
-0.0080387238,
0.0231266916,
0.0108519094,
0.0237694103,
0.0427724607,
0.0662848428,
-0.0120426435,
-0.0231359825,
-0.0759400725,
0.0037950024,
-0.0243165866,
0.0108986078,
0.0260599088,
0.0516539663,
0.0066408361,
0.0125851277,
-0.0360333212,
-0.0397969931,
0.0389398523,
0.0129452841,
-0.003083067,
0.011730535,
0.0248928983,
-0.0319568105,
0.009586337,
0.0444400981,
0.0391171239,
-0.0004102735,
-0.0173160601,
-0.0180142913,
0.0171976984,
-0.0142572578,
-0.0308382679,
-0.0100083752,
-0.0483719483,
-0.0147238411,
-0.0286959335,
0.0652135462,
0.0155925164,
-0.0099416114,
-0.0174554698,
0.0461874492,
0.0051721921,
-0.0826366097,
-0.0129905995,
-0.010817958,
-0.0365555771,
-0.0277629271,
-0.0323531479,
0.0066998671,
0.0452727899,
0.025584165,
-0.0122818099,
-0.0673020855,
0.008771752,
-0.0029342975,
-0.0209380928,
-0.0378545299,
0.0432339907,
-0.0140259117,
0.0632713512,
-0.0419795103,
-0.0316299684,
0.0598144978,
-0.0322816633,
-0.0427813977,
-0.012983554,
-0.0026483191,
-0.0450816229,
0.0181593094,
-0.0171725564,
0.0365257747,
-0.0252257343,
-0.0158571303,
-0.0727600008,
0.009323081,
0.0231475104,
-0.01600595,
0.0645368025,
-0.0574212596,
0.0146881975,
-0.0344071202,
-0.0399363227,
-0.0325826369,
-0.0414506085,
0.0037604128,
0.0042866012,
0.0077569983,
-0.0027691124,
-0.0317356884,
-0.0060346033,
0.0588500053,
0.0787648708,
-0.0079799388,
-0.009649965,
-0.0025339993,
0.0231119134,
0.0164780337,
0.010214786,
0.0000016325,
-0.0610607639,
0.0643264204,
0.0039762203,
0.0243146755,
-0.024747679,
0.0141641898,
-0.015684016,
0.024768237,
0.0004275476,
0.0035406456,
-0.0003928615,
0.0711702555,
-0.0009135091,
-0.0020045878,
0.1105955988,
0.0077489964,
-0.0598561913,
-0.0026143969,
-0.0215522032,
0.020349877,
0.0333979391,
0.0322610773,
-0.0893206149,
-0.0206567198,
-0.0046891947,
0.0224835686,
0.0141388811,
-0.009422468,
-0.0318617262,
-0.1836557984,
0.044502575,
0.0402366519,
-0.031745214,
-0.011179043,
-0.0106879976,
-0.0131495586,
-0.0411743037,
0.0315424018,
0.0003402866,
-0.0020399175,
-0.0158171821,
0.0114318468,
0.0056415964,
-0.0827249885,
-0.0039261184,
-0.0357931517,
0.0275400188,
0.0393005982,
0.0105084172,
-0.0108479131,
0.0261223316,
0.035998933,
-0.0102242334,
-0.0113034928,
-0.0018483062,
0.0198282227,
0.025092328,
-0.0234052893,
0.0082006659,
0.0397275798,
-0.025484411,
-0.0002795184,
0.0100796269,
0.0619271621,
-0.0113365697,
0.0028923205,
0.0161238126,
-0.0264116097,
0.007449151,
0.064742662,
0.0533309057,
-0.0524510704,
0.0169179309,
-0.0150533738,
-0.0283734128,
-0.0643713251,
-0.0362865515,
0.0263921563,
-0.0148991318,
-0.0386034697,
-0.0772432759,
-0.066002965,
0.0423017517,
0.027004296,
0.025286464,
0.0113312919,
-0.0426720642,
-0.0059519894,
0.011873791,
0.0247404911,
-0.0673823804,
-0.0036741591,
-0.0620816462,
-0.0412224308,
0.0336187445,
-0.0502046533,
-0.0029892162,
0.0008215375,
-0.0506273918,
-0.081510976,
-0.0455349833,
0.078152217,
0.0188945122,
0.0449502356,
0.002343491,
-0.0344632007,
0.064991869,
0.0462274402,
-0.0109037263,
0.0130916527,
0.0132994391,
0.0277558025,
-0.0075801383,
0.0637281537,
-0.0417106152,
0.0409294888,
0.030637959,
0.0586029664,
-0.0481550097,
-0.0396025516,
0.0143402331,
0.038016364,
0.0263956357,
-0.083376348,
-0.0091143921,
-0.0523609892,
-0.0183680449,
-0.0126238205,
-0.0148003856,
-0.0453015193,
-0.0122254528,
0.0343174562,
-0.0050499118,
0.0166646205,
0.0342063904,
-0.021127915,
0.0172939282,
-0.0265307464,
0.0135839749,
-0.0204898529,
-0.0184171721,
0.0099596586,
0.0429102033,
-0.0259639323,
0.0230264869,
-0.023993995,
0.0117657697,
-0.0081332056,
0.024868859,
-0.0016081261,
0.0087276651,
0.0036955762,
0.0156277511,
-0.0289781187,
-0.017147392,
-0.0172716137,
0.0555811711,
0.095178619,
-0.0120683657,
0.0801646635,
0.0174902063,
-0.006371588,
-0.0322732627,
0.0230345149,
0.0140493298,
-0.0271553062,
0.0047377674,
0.0116619989,
0.0048326561,
0.0108358879,
0.083227329,
-0.0226373132,
0.0139441723,
0.0110439342,
0.0503593907,
-0.0437779091,
-0.0448979586,
-0.0082647288,
-0.0416320823,
-0.0093288068,
0.016173495,
-0.0497832559,
-0.0395179875,
-0.0164364818,
-0.0006643492,
-0.0363845974,
-0.014223339,
0.0304965228,
0.0266924165,
-0.0321839228,
0.0357167125,
-0.0445390195,
-0.0302638113,
0.0002687121,
-0.02895022,
0.0108175874,
-6.582304779e-33,
-0.0375603363,
-0.0110789221,
0.0081361812,
-0.0573293343,
0.0176776722,
-0.0242044292,
-0.0493962467,
-0.0013334351,
0.0029448376,
-0.0065584835,
-0.0384148322,
-0.0318949595,
0.0196548682,
0.0525349081,
0.0378167033,
0.0389395505,
0.0610179789,
0.0046497462,
-0.041153159,
0.0429555066,
0.0320106745,
0.0329106972,
0.0732748955,
-0.0199579746,
0.0315456204,
-0.0525877625,
-0.0295404233,
0.0259632245,
0.021423623,
0.0187288951,
-0.0080889575,
0.0268860199,
0.0104699517,
-0.0449040756,
-0.0432145707,
-0.0080732564,
-0.0615496449,
-0.0140157035,
0.0617461838,
-0.0002467881,
-0.0221357476,
-0.0693499967,
0.008320814,
-0.0375397466,
0.0012701764,
-0.0240324698,
0.0214360468,
-0.0476838127,
-0.0213046744,
-0.0256169681,
-0.0564308167,
0.0144322002,
-0.0044919606,
-0.0352595225,
0.0148802819,
0.0746688247,
-0.0285911243,
0.009703638,
-0.0246644225,
0.0251051299,
0.0075406209,
0.0373234674,
0.0875159577,
0.0277106483,
-0.015660258,
0.0424106419,
-0.0054781991,
-0.0186357982,
0.0220265109,
-0.0065170312,
0.0057618325,
0.0071735531,
0.0147966603,
0.0903405398,
0.0357544869,
0.0216814708,
-0.0494266711,
0.0682888702,
0.0234523006,
-0.0140707437,
0.0330706574,
-0.0095648011,
0.0025235899,
-0.0359529182,
-0.0320459791,
-0.0214306582,
-0.0316421948,
-0.0247430746,
0.0310406424,
0.0136764804,
-0.0261774324,
-0.0352046341,
0.0909776464,
-0.0108873751,
-0.0142192077,
0.029969817,
0.0031923433,
0.0097120376,
-0.0028017517,
0.0088501628,
-0.0502881594,
-0.0139967939,
0.0145472325,
0.0161010846,
-0.0111649856,
0.0142257726,
0.0495928936,
0.0218461566,
-0.0629429072,
0.0150814941,
-0.032569468,
0.0501774102,
-0.0319572836,
0.0503501408,
0.0157121103,
-0.0219000615,
-0.0173729043,
0.0380632281,
-0.0096813943,
-0.0541974381,
0.0232536159,
0.0263259578,
-0.0188053418,
0.0376682244,
-0.0528468899,
0.0249798391,
-0.0262359958,
0.0035044921,
0.0420109965,
-0.0111979479,
-0.0085436068,
0.00402505,
2.884e-7,
0.0150758596,
0.0235174038,
0.0064820526,
0.0095872376,
-0.0188675467,
0.0130418781,
-0.0476567298,
-0.0086527495,
-0.0020455967,
-0.0111613981,
0.0272446983,
0.040717911,
0.0968146324,
0.0130293276,
-0.1112956479,
0.0321149677,
-0.0412345827,
0.0335645974,
-0.0408641994,
-0.0367434546,
0.0011065002,
0.113453187,
-0.0173375383,
-0.0283177122,
-0.0267979316,
-0.0461042523,
0.0801791549,
-0.0502876602,
-0.0622506924,
-0.0136872474,
0.0271377023,
0.0423041359,
-0.0106003005,
-0.0210379139,
-0.0115050357,
-0.0081626959,
0.0186099205,
0.0823861584,
0.0174340624,
-0.0108978134,
0.0346317291,
0.0054601436,
-0.0163017605,
-0.0094758021,
0.039414037,
-0.0608887188,
-0.0086818244,
0.0062624393,
-0.0101814205,
0.0109490035,
0.0127846915,
-0.0555949844,
-0.0372737721,
0.0354775265,
0.0453549288,
-0.0339339301,
-0.0042048185,
-0.0345633067,
-0.0380025059,
0.0038883677,
-0.0098757483,
-0.0453006066,
0.0045699319,
0.0279681887,
-0.0170421675,
-0.0351695567,
0.0002974757,
2.737350047e-34,
0.0682082474,
0.0097138537,
0.0130784139,
-0.0025901599,
-0.0043465439,
-0.0231729876,
-0.015372525,
-0.0065360162,
0.0075866855,
-0.0502382964,
-0.020861255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11371v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11371v3 | Visually grounded few-shot word learning in low-resource settings | 2023-06-20T08:27:42 | 2024-04-18T17:36:53 | Leanne Nortje, Dan Oneata, Herman Kamper | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | We propose a visually grounded speech model that learns new words and their
visual depictions from just a few word-image example pairs. Given a set of test
images and a spoken query, we ask the model which image depicts the query word.
Previous work has simplified this few-shot learning problem by either using an
artificial setting with digit word-image pairs or by using a large number of
examples per class. Moreover, all previous studies were performed using English
speech-image data. We propose an approach that can work on natural word-image
pairs but with less examples, i.e. fewer shots, and then illustrate how this
approach can be applied for multimodal few-shot learning in a real low-resource
language, Yor\`ub\'a. Our approach involves using the given word-image example
pairs to mine new unsupervised word-image training pairs from large collections
of unlabelled speech and images. Additionally, we use a word-to-image attention
mechanism to determine word-image similarity. With this new model, we achieve
better performance with fewer shots than previous approaches on an existing
English benchmark. Many of the model's mistakes are due to confusion between
visual concepts co-occurring in similar contexts. The experiments on Yor\`ub\'a
show the benefit of transferring knowledge from a multimodal model trained on a
larger set of English speech-image data. | [
-0.009698255,
0.0653542429,
0.0021911433,
0.0423379242,
-0.0455237143,
-0.0258626956,
0.028710274,
0.0038696358,
-0.042827677,
-0.0788384452,
-0.0670474172,
-0.0252906475,
0.0186656546,
-0.0269049332,
0.0812417865,
-0.0817840174,
0.0474497676,
-0.0077308645,
-0.0136446776,
0.0076225302,
0.0339041986,
0.0065443357,
-0.0321670137,
0.0035864485,
-0.0612121895,
-0.043611642,
-0.0126464041,
0.0082329195,
0.0044772946,
-0.0270676631,
-0.0480013974,
0.016783407,
0.040535178,
0.0096359691,
0.0000018283,
-0.0205916818,
0.0181489233,
-0.0029136317,
0.0045775753,
-0.0267514754,
0.0189971011,
-0.0211286396,
0.0048059854,
-0.0032635652,
-0.0357034653,
-0.0257795081,
0.0473505333,
0.0293554701,
0.0481182933,
0.0281681251,
-0.0363874733,
-0.0389011838,
-0.0292893909,
-0.0232116543,
0.045211859,
-0.0176509582,
-0.0254239328,
0.008386855,
0.0152293108,
-0.0239513535,
-0.0874250755,
0.0266288798,
-0.0211141668,
0.0113850916,
0.0332311578,
0.0735410377,
-0.0451176688,
-0.0531316549,
-0.0193976853,
0.1192974225,
-0.0512510575,
-0.0157922395,
-0.0186345484,
-0.0046503884,
-0.0136130126,
0.0050867689,
-0.0509420447,
0.0225744769,
-0.0029934864,
0.0404039882,
-0.070651561,
-0.0144565813,
-0.0067061619,
-0.0183932856,
-0.0106072538,
-0.0405623503,
0.0280940253,
-0.0034224764,
-0.0123988586,
-0.0107360147,
-0.0651210323,
0.0036888763,
-0.0335718282,
0.0270148255,
0.0238183755,
0.0313698389,
-0.0428451486,
-0.0366031975,
-0.0063028908,
-0.0545876026,
0.0551515445,
0.003473355,
-0.0616536513,
0.0930284783,
-0.0298049804,
0.0090845665,
0.0140445894,
0.0220631994,
0.0005411143,
-0.0090430714,
-0.029780332,
0.0115477508,
-0.0711504966,
0.007881375,
-0.0313244499,
-0.0569421127,
0.0030263448,
-0.013169623,
-0.0117515307,
0.003148119,
0.0172640085,
-0.0040321425,
-0.0231749397,
-0.0231090896,
-0.005635479,
0.0298552085,
-0.0189149566,
0.0414632484,
-0.0289926212,
-0.0662296861,
-0.0114052761,
0.0340976119,
0.0703062788,
-0.0179472566,
-0.0069694975,
0.0553583279,
-0.0289826468,
-0.0858265683,
-0.043276839,
-0.0086501623,
-0.0178585779,
-0.0351778194,
0.0148701007,
-0.0307038222,
0.0172978938,
-0.0434397534,
0.012810328,
-0.0375877731,
0.0156430583,
0.0504610613,
-0.0260741357,
0.1078507677,
0.013095784,
0.0217829887,
-0.0033645204,
0.0015015519,
0.0282242447,
0.0867663473,
0.0233259071,
-0.0022019697,
0.0301021598,
-0.0261003785,
0.0112534799,
0.0353162289,
0.0273645986,
0.0109189888,
-0.038453199,
-0.0294277743,
-0.0020803493,
0.0259457808,
0.0584052131,
0.040734414,
-0.0347968936,
0.0026248381,
0.0856448486,
0.0522963256,
0.0214739218,
-0.019801151,
0.023693189,
0.0095836259,
-0.0229592845,
-0.0097998604,
-0.0277887452,
0.0651000366,
-0.0034764919,
0.0254812762,
0.0497439094,
0.024545081,
-0.0562458485,
0.0136141554,
0.0016511909,
0.004730409,
-0.0145877656,
-0.0050664833,
0.0569688603,
0.0703444555,
-0.084467575,
0.0439251512,
0.0374081135,
-0.0174670108,
-0.0005654747,
0.0158194695,
0.0235380922,
0.0363012068,
0.0362118743,
0.0025076892,
0.0267423596,
-0.0094256811,
0.0494843125,
0.0618596897,
-0.0256627686,
0.0081360508,
0.0267395433,
-0.0452296846,
-0.0168487169,
-0.0113885505,
-0.0151165714,
0.0247463044,
-0.0256093666,
0.0150848934,
-0.0237700604,
-0.0426307619,
0.036245279,
0.0336206257,
0.038235072,
-0.0247744527,
-0.038444981,
0.0616794564,
0.011691344,
-0.0020067219,
-0.0081064226,
0.031712655,
-0.0017434469,
-0.0232905094,
0.0340362042,
0.01806123,
-0.0492141917,
-0.0662101507,
0.0124189174,
-0.0608533509,
0.0464313291,
-0.0037305767,
0.0022282,
-0.02500402,
0.057366766,
-0.0358900614,
0.0326372385,
-0.0564482808,
0.0246170163,
0.0231680144,
0.0524102263,
-0.003623479,
0.0341949202,
-0.0196603723,
-0.0056979437,
-0.0027621267,
0.01157765,
0.0020405583,
-0.0420063846,
-0.0180750433,
-0.0059174453,
-0.008261363,
0.0227074474,
-0.0046297801,
-0.0035971946,
-0.0463254787,
0.0273294263,
-0.0537746847,
-0.0283376798,
-0.0030035744,
-0.0336428657,
-0.0120624797,
-0.0202586707,
0.0216797385,
-0.0671837628,
-0.0021487863,
0.0508282334,
-0.0221854802,
0.0291836094,
0.0240089353,
0.0070150634,
0.0072388281,
-0.0533162467,
0.0088401763,
0.0403465368,
0.086867556,
-0.0244951453,
-0.0099207237,
-0.0130181313,
0.0219814144,
-0.0162345637,
0.0440545715,
0.0109780002,
-0.0229276177,
0.0129242083,
-0.0218649358,
0.0367609486,
0.0508821495,
0.0048911567,
0.0050485469,
0.0185863394,
-0.0191108026,
-0.0449906364,
-0.0031759508,
0.0225162655,
-0.0010199047,
0.0378445238,
0.0217960421,
-0.0137774069,
0.0229105912,
0.0088066952,
0.0384957008,
-0.0757841989,
0.0515383594,
0.0447650626,
-0.0182113033,
-0.0627739802,
0.0434469916,
-0.0116487537,
0.002139559,
-0.0615745224,
-0.0581576079,
0.0364463627,
-0.0457607172,
-0.0348550454,
-0.0095207263,
0.007459092,
0.0162762292,
0.0315078236,
0.0034775797,
0.0144510325,
0.0011951646,
-0.005997248,
-0.0641807541,
-0.0108351931,
0.048135668,
0.0069037792,
0.0677983239,
0.0076024826,
0.0065269493,
-0.0214359965,
-0.0222833604,
-0.0474962853,
-0.0197865795,
-0.0538661517,
-0.0205583759,
-0.0773873255,
0.0310658794,
0.0037295499,
0.0246389061,
0.0406398363,
0.0205022208,
0.0505994074,
-0.0121137882,
-0.0225561727,
0.0597113594,
0.0647942722,
-0.0011409244,
-0.069592528,
-0.002146564,
0.0678416565,
0.0061860331,
0.0493324921,
-0.0046327021,
-0.0414095894,
0.0076882974,
0.0041592983,
0.0386154577,
-0.0097137922,
0.0280191749,
0.0220964346,
-0.0128476257,
-0.0328117535,
0.0443919525,
-0.0115103722,
-0.0300139096,
0.0012887291,
0.012066735,
0.0073745986,
0.0511244796,
0.0228965357,
-0.0487816371,
-0.0650859624,
-0.0063741072,
-0.0230201129,
0.0412779897,
-0.0029156192,
-0.0652708113,
-0.1376640201,
0.019148957,
0.0235695727,
-0.0283289049,
-0.0267871823,
-0.0420448929,
0.0059025874,
0.0054975478,
-0.0017399321,
0.0165513679,
-0.0134186279,
-0.013333573,
-0.0102789057,
0.0591899082,
-0.034854576,
0.0263222288,
-0.0419008955,
0.0000659188,
0.0185220428,
0.0423162505,
-0.0066004419,
-0.0493107028,
-0.005276612,
0.0019341497,
0.0152360499,
0.0136874141,
0.0639582053,
-0.027965758,
-0.0542108715,
0.0116979964,
0.0333867185,
0.01131221,
-0.0320086591,
-0.0250062961,
0.0756676421,
-0.0075275544,
-0.0011900981,
-0.0288769007,
0.0261557214,
-0.0017400488,
0.0216634143,
0.0731219649,
-0.0405993313,
-0.0166956987,
0.0471573286,
0.0384433605,
-0.0510885417,
-0.0389146581,
0.00533988,
-0.0143907061,
0.0178350769,
-0.0715369508,
0.002858324,
0.0357315652,
0.1040242463,
0.001724791,
0.008325032,
-0.0031728258,
0.0360634029,
-0.0281466916,
0.0179524198,
-0.0304523371,
0.0420185253,
-0.0573474653,
-0.0172223542,
0.0653259754,
-0.0283573251,
-0.0030838279,
-0.0135347424,
-0.047721494,
-0.0169816334,
-0.0508292168,
0.0438928977,
0.0092040943,
0.0391769186,
0.0035056737,
-0.0226264186,
0.0516224131,
0.0277673658,
0.0166932195,
0.0308846515,
0.0113103492,
-0.0192305837,
-0.0107694184,
0.0176627245,
-0.0377684608,
0.0402005948,
0.0147667406,
0.0161420889,
-0.020451244,
0.0367919058,
0.0085658133,
-0.0055346391,
0.0910419449,
-0.0411555618,
0.0256863479,
-0.0249048173,
0.0038654893,
0.0157177132,
0.0221000519,
-0.062550813,
-0.0174173638,
-0.0257990938,
0.0076949494,
0.0009632451,
-0.0302436352,
0.0001179222,
0.0468505621,
-0.0100462558,
0.0308036059,
0.0295121521,
0.0060329195,
-0.047692962,
0.0196660236,
0.0311060045,
0.0241136178,
-0.0298630111,
0.0340946205,
-0.0083905645,
0.0922788978,
0.0004669004,
-0.0557561591,
-0.0216272511,
0.0055446764,
0.0162270591,
0.0356020704,
-0.0300597269,
0.0426112078,
0.0487213358,
-0.0213065669,
-0.0128564704,
0.0202802308,
-0.0188602228,
-0.0036601047,
0.0284520779,
-0.0488988534,
-0.0592358746,
0.0531915762,
0.0214393921,
0.0088200038,
0.0018355454,
0.0780963674,
0.0182840377,
0.0221342221,
-0.0106563689,
0.0213284381,
-0.0491923355,
0.00255529,
0.0442219377,
0.0113610355,
0.0077414131,
0.0627910197,
-0.0400874242,
-0.0725239366,
0.0015302618,
-0.0048382161,
-0.0286275856,
0.0187064167,
0.062329486,
0.0036170667,
0.0097442335,
0.0312357135,
0.0031207411,
-0.0046607228,
-0.0152845597,
0.0012282886,
0.0311837327,
-5.641455264e-33,
-0.0312443022,
-0.0354445279,
0.0288347602,
-0.0367816724,
-0.0076162885,
0.0020111506,
-0.0350622982,
0.0025669967,
-0.0456650592,
0.0122046126,
0.0070827575,
-0.0071820435,
-0.0053179753,
0.0382216163,
0.0173885748,
0.001865096,
0.0429952964,
-0.0025926789,
-0.0071726069,
-0.0037706885,
0.0024634465,
0.0401591361,
0.0455184281,
0.0163063817,
-0.0706798136,
0.0240675155,
-0.0185766108,
0.0092051625,
0.0588767193,
0.0699593723,
-0.0306072067,
0.03846303,
-0.0210391432,
-0.0239202119,
-0.0530679114,
0.0366525799,
-0.0906618983,
-0.0232481137,
0.0207704008,
0.0415485948,
-0.0339768231,
0.0188131742,
0.0259697139,
-0.0310753901,
0.0199259315,
-0.0191473179,
0.0356722921,
-0.0311381835,
-0.0491144508,
0.0243545547,
-0.0454375744,
0.0012821218,
0.0005547356,
-0.044541385,
0.0387908109,
0.0254280195,
0.014939094,
0.0398180373,
-0.0499024764,
0.0261755344,
-0.0263266973,
0.0108890589,
0.077628389,
0.0396106541,
0.0118935676,
0.0837490559,
0.024395518,
-0.0407772213,
0.0131359054,
-0.0101487152,
0.0465571545,
0.0537361279,
0.0280688424,
0.0656929761,
0.0215728767,
-0.014272131,
-0.0294458587,
-0.0448138937,
-0.0220297575,
0.0778414831,
0.0305093601,
0.0245324001,
-0.0141341295,
-0.0024148442,
-0.0312017687,
-0.0417065546,
-0.0673362687,
-0.0064198254,
0.0433212817,
0.0364535488,
-0.003427959,
0.0206605271,
0.0881947577,
-0.0400856733,
-0.0289654359,
0.0252684131,
0.0098255044,
0.0282239523,
-0.0206052121,
0.0087442668,
-0.0522259586,
-0.0273697134,
0.0610674508,
0.0427828878,
0.0045361342,
0.020132307,
0.033064913,
0.0287830327,
-0.0674909651,
-0.0210936349,
-0.0198283195,
-0.029867474,
-0.0304494463,
-0.0312942341,
0.0188230649,
0.0180280823,
-0.053197667,
0.0357084759,
-0.0008313743,
-0.0642388538,
0.015503318,
-0.044611197,
-0.0364650339,
0.0411358364,
-0.0196770635,
0.0091681974,
-0.0401197374,
-0.0395318493,
0.0668619871,
-0.0491202883,
-0.0163244158,
0.0439164303,
2.712e-7,
-0.010872311,
0.0021240159,
-0.0209329817,
-0.004959458,
0.0172419474,
0.0236006062,
-0.0477592871,
0.0442424752,
-0.0407320671,
-0.0516034141,
-0.0065826122,
0.0048520658,
0.0434579365,
-0.0329601094,
-0.0550159514,
0.0214837044,
-0.0525474846,
-0.0210453197,
-0.0437201187,
-0.0537712872,
0.0249372907,
0.1125960052,
-0.0011950025,
-0.0078631062,
-0.001511064,
-0.0499221534,
0.0672679916,
-0.0131659498,
-0.01009358,
-0.0667532608,
-0.019084461,
0.0121105891,
-0.0218163021,
-0.0108138705,
-0.0194875784,
0.0054249936,
0.0745972395,
0.0102228634,
-0.0392928608,
-0.0379265584,
-0.0471593477,
0.0128427073,
-0.0537902564,
-0.0058892607,
0.0499051847,
-0.0728462189,
-0.0301377177,
-0.018595282,
-0.0418044329,
0.0144329723,
0.0356713869,
-0.0025765956,
-0.0671783686,
0.0009655832,
0.0576681457,
-0.0064094947,
-0.0353229344,
-0.073924683,
-0.0034479073,
0.0252130851,
-0.0021780212,
0.0054560141,
-0.0453430861,
-0.0611297898,
0.0403511152,
-0.0034403848,
-0.0439008102,
1.415828074e-34,
0.0413586237,
-0.0216146223,
0.0051659993,
0.0182744358,
-0.0132604055,
-0.0396338217,
-0.0133090429,
-0.0211863704,
0.0649780333,
-0.0464446805,
-0.0121241361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11345v1 | KiUT: Knowledge-injected U-Transformer for Radiology Report Generation | 2023-06-20T07:27:28 | 2023-06-20T07:27:28 | Zhongzhen Huang, Xiaofan Zhang, Shaoting Zhang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Radiology report generation aims to automatically generate a clinically
accurate and coherent paragraph from the X-ray image, which could relieve
radiologists from the heavy burden of report writing. Although various image
caption methods have shown remarkable performance in the natural image field,
generating accurate reports for medical images requires knowledge of multiple
modalities, including vision, language, and medical terminology. We propose a
Knowledge-injected U-Transformer (KiUT) to learn multi-level visual
representation and adaptively distill the information with contextual and
clinical knowledge for word prediction. In detail, a U-connection schema
between the encoder and decoder is designed to model interactions between
different modalities. And a symptom graph and an injected knowledge distiller
are developed to assist the report generation. Experimentally, we outperform
state-of-the-art methods on two widely used benchmark datasets: IU-Xray and
MIMIC-CXR. Further experimental results prove the advantages of our
architecture and the complementary benefits of the injected knowledge. | [
0.0184815675,
0.0412562229,
0.0295198876,
-0.002072324,
0.0094584925,
0.010034821,
-0.0115934145,
0.0074960105,
0.0174868461,
-0.021795094,
-0.0025966323,
-0.0039726743,
0.0210459903,
0.0882684737,
0.0090571241,
-0.0918773338,
0.019953154,
0.0176064372,
-0.0147942184,
-0.0174456835,
-0.0047376282,
-0.0059200581,
-0.0059402711,
0.0377362184,
-0.0401219092,
0.0098291244,
0.0101028578,
0.0361636579,
0.0217023473,
-0.0487608016,
-0.008878584,
0.0440965407,
0.0377548151,
-0.0223913062,
0.0000021389,
-0.0023197054,
-0.0307164229,
0.010855115,
-0.0036119556,
-0.0585742518,
0.0559889898,
-0.1328591406,
0.0045797341,
-0.0012776629,
-0.0221347027,
-0.0254617296,
0.0506022424,
0.058293663,
0.0673315525,
0.0476164035,
-0.0452331454,
-0.0190339424,
0.0335085131,
-0.0392698087,
0.0036170925,
-0.021960672,
0.0078964196,
0.0413619541,
-0.0023850258,
-0.0173454508,
-0.0675286874,
0.043737933,
0.0229341853,
-0.017094925,
0.0442917496,
0.0582441017,
0.009245296,
-0.0339826606,
-0.0362512805,
0.0627010763,
-0.0303841662,
0.0341964439,
-0.0174888745,
-0.0086185774,
-0.0229237825,
0.0195815153,
-0.0238301568,
-0.0213186853,
-0.0368266329,
-0.0032484976,
-0.0420506746,
0.0269201864,
-0.0111242654,
-0.0092562307,
-0.0361044668,
-0.0241217446,
0.0062768748,
0.0165671743,
0.0015900419,
0.0150474533,
-0.0022558689,
-0.0477262698,
0.0354592986,
0.0516958125,
-0.0213880185,
0.0158255026,
-0.047310099,
-0.0293582398,
0.0364455432,
-0.0508621968,
-0.0016720031,
-0.00372248,
-0.0297028087,
0.0695785135,
-0.0071984828,
0.0476942509,
-0.0136260362,
0.0531348437,
-0.0321510285,
0.0044997712,
-0.0458447188,
-0.0294878632,
-0.0284573697,
0.0093705663,
-0.0154892793,
-0.0429763384,
-0.0473865382,
0.0093054054,
0.0008107915,
0.0320320278,
0.0463950485,
0.0792452469,
-0.0810177624,
0.0321514755,
-0.0387262218,
0.0705190375,
0.0161444191,
-0.0411529467,
-0.0173460599,
-0.0072129467,
0.0125904186,
0.0311085992,
0.0210739113,
0.0127913365,
-0.0023155943,
0.0382785648,
-0.0454036705,
-0.0227862597,
0.0327137597,
-0.0615889467,
-0.0536693558,
-0.0149788549,
0.0496179312,
-0.0537523888,
0.043091204,
0.0108538521,
-0.0002483606,
-0.0647505671,
0.0102496287,
-0.0011086512,
-0.0336629115,
0.0767812952,
-0.0612076297,
-0.0314751565,
0.0169573296,
0.0366944596,
0.0223953929,
0.00466112,
0.0180578046,
0.0394676588,
-0.0197531674,
0.0003286816,
0.0250148848,
-0.0138867665,
-0.0001340787,
-0.0527930818,
-0.0299667642,
-0.0205102451,
-0.0204985533,
0.0471341982,
0.0309615303,
0.0467098877,
-0.0144597525,
-0.0007659182,
0.0290516708,
0.0120743252,
0.0521791913,
0.0419366583,
0.0242134221,
0.0093190223,
-0.0398485214,
0.0034741941,
-0.0257669128,
0.0770610869,
0.0555725023,
0.0167429782,
-0.0285391863,
0.0236614067,
-0.0395340212,
-0.0577423237,
-0.0049266419,
-0.0183089823,
-0.0112714069,
-0.0308886636,
0.0449025333,
0.0322695076,
-0.0576605424,
0.0489488468,
0.0427065305,
-0.0136293424,
-0.0090151317,
-0.0199001618,
-0.0120393913,
0.0924451798,
0.076602757,
-0.0088214111,
-0.0448557697,
0.0024987464,
0.0183946695,
0.0646456629,
0.0015721507,
-0.0099403653,
0.0236136559,
-0.0447843038,
-0.0673833266,
-0.0008944423,
-0.0117772063,
0.0063072806,
-0.0185399819,
0.0109125692,
-0.0139307855,
-0.0251320433,
-0.0290327463,
0.0406028219,
-0.0162936933,
-0.024325382,
-0.0254482161,
0.0185949672,
-0.0151536288,
-0.0036338964,
-0.0383017212,
0.0060499543,
0.0160183255,
-0.0199746769,
-0.049986545,
0.0382286087,
-0.0789398104,
-0.0803806037,
0.0146938721,
-0.0825222656,
0.0140676415,
-0.0199748892,
-0.022761764,
-0.0335266329,
-0.0218173787,
-0.0343652032,
0.0402130149,
-0.0387179889,
-0.0142723667,
0.0557419173,
0.0142906904,
0.0104800519,
0.0674934909,
-0.0392203517,
-0.0248217918,
0.019923389,
-0.0163776446,
-0.0256793424,
0.0176244248,
-0.0277829245,
0.0006617329,
0.0185275078,
0.0033515035,
0.0004073813,
0.0248204451,
0.003580757,
-0.0076240124,
-0.0780054256,
-0.0200855471,
0.014268971,
-0.0440282077,
0.0281815492,
0.0163554233,
0.0263783652,
-0.0495076403,
-0.0450694673,
0.0129596107,
0.0329340436,
-0.005403854,
0.061618302,
0.0121394983,
0.0256507322,
-0.0220559053,
-0.0109844459,
-0.0124095725,
0.0395712554,
0.034182243,
-0.0320269838,
-0.0014836759,
0.0296670236,
-0.0254252478,
0.0237606205,
-0.0032749246,
-0.0334494226,
0.0111203091,
0.0224287622,
-0.0035660637,
0.0512363128,
0.0100350976,
0.0567098632,
0.0119014345,
-0.0166605003,
0.0033174972,
0.0125519084,
-0.0497588813,
-0.0316819958,
0.0018467053,
-0.0230891649,
-0.0286963452,
0.0665856525,
0.0188234281,
0.0252168104,
-0.0376402922,
-0.0294706617,
-0.0010524411,
-0.0208104867,
-0.0340887979,
0.0119632091,
-0.0023104127,
-0.0040490539,
-0.0459487438,
-0.0430073403,
0.0591206066,
-0.0151818311,
0.0176043026,
-0.0201142244,
0.018457735,
-0.019812528,
0.0316911265,
0.0149205588,
0.0444843657,
0.002552954,
-0.0003273255,
-0.0169091728,
0.0101003321,
0.0077617751,
-0.048432678,
0.0157743748,
-0.0139732352,
-0.0029867457,
-0.0180781838,
-0.0413389914,
-0.0419278741,
0.0137599269,
0.0220424458,
0.0075478395,
0.0053059636,
-0.0141458586,
-0.0495505333,
0.0474621467,
-0.0006827184,
0.0419303924,
-0.0058545447,
-0.0275770482,
-0.0245801155,
0.0693979487,
0.0406060405,
0.0386179276,
-0.0342776515,
-0.0239488874,
0.0280297827,
0.071788691,
-0.05502332,
0.0221134722,
-0.0152155682,
0.0209368039,
-0.0409758687,
0.0304331109,
0.0111284452,
0.0064550298,
0.0269079413,
-0.0566982888,
-0.0279940702,
0.0611246079,
0.0333683118,
-0.0380896702,
-0.0155808199,
0.0291862749,
0.0114240022,
0.0269727204,
-0.0006936318,
-0.059750706,
-0.0423075743,
-0.0377975665,
0.0232945886,
0.0293357894,
-0.0148910573,
-0.0009992418,
-0.0231750365,
0.0414569192,
0.0108156446,
-0.0297292341,
-0.0667496771,
-0.0070592486,
-0.0048314203,
0.0019772472,
-0.0256661195,
-0.0073038256,
-0.004888766,
-0.0132682463,
0.0187594406,
-0.0218403097,
-0.0557753779,
-0.0169437788,
-0.0402111188,
-0.0382227637,
0.053479515,
0.0451846197,
-0.0010769113,
-0.0300955661,
-0.0737224519,
0.0441388898,
0.0399432369,
0.0045410832,
0.113381654,
-0.0323359333,
-0.0153897246,
-0.0313857645,
0.0346556604,
-0.0318769701,
-0.0165109392,
-0.0481263213,
0.0404715575,
-0.0355536565,
-0.0249105543,
-0.0606260262,
0.0080433413,
0.0172647517,
0.0297288112,
-0.0131714195,
0.0033256118,
-0.0595409498,
0.0096488623,
0.0754302666,
-0.0644357353,
-0.00502613,
0.0498482771,
-0.0467872322,
-0.0741571784,
-0.0834326744,
-0.026934864,
0.0458808653,
0.0103241745,
0.0081391856,
-0.0153751383,
0.0192656144,
-0.0020489236,
-0.11044842,
0.0126591073,
0.0154515672,
-0.0093065929,
0.0035706565,
-0.0392757431,
0.0473252721,
-0.0079379687,
-0.0210076421,
0.0471541174,
-0.0561058745,
0.0082662972,
-0.0119111175,
0.0734698251,
0.0185566992,
0.0367307849,
0.0137605928,
0.027257055,
0.1160625294,
0.0534522086,
-0.0074425051,
-0.0000726747,
0.0146317156,
-0.0363123529,
-0.0319086164,
0.0065643401,
-0.018507814,
0.0141918892,
-0.0384622663,
0.0074568177,
-0.0189296957,
-0.0311667304,
0.0235863402,
-0.0296246242,
0.0059243268,
-0.0438850485,
0.0006159053,
-0.0151778692,
0.0035364244,
-0.0178422574,
0.0141833201,
-0.0570387132,
0.0171611626,
0.0209370796,
0.0252981335,
0.0171456207,
0.0157451816,
-0.0000679087,
-0.0129861487,
-0.0144663388,
0.0194642227,
0.0482744388,
-0.0414740145,
0.0234935489,
0.0100193443,
0.0001577219,
-0.0108939167,
0.0007294689,
0.0184273869,
-0.0179816578,
0.0535309911,
0.0269467793,
0.0393334776,
0.0003275817,
0.0562457219,
-0.0122752152,
-0.0126327956,
-0.0662283748,
0.0135623217,
0.0188655108,
0.0127036357,
0.0021218436,
-0.0406023264,
0.008808515,
0.0046039023,
0.0547564588,
-0.0175875239,
-0.0210399367,
0.0826894194,
-0.0107494853,
0.0293386634,
-0.0294461865,
0.1014394835,
-0.0040852088,
0.0248638224,
-0.0280633681,
-0.0503333919,
-0.0638792217,
-0.0090716053,
0.0363586359,
-0.0157683417,
-0.0196907446,
0.0216117091,
-0.0461677872,
-0.047917854,
0.021274766,
-0.007789209,
-0.0104009937,
0.0029218772,
0.0800544322,
0.0226824209,
0.0193434916,
-0.0322146714,
-0.0011360064,
0.0197694805,
-0.0372642428,
0.0125443703,
0.0511432104,
-6.292338241e-33,
-0.0282518491,
-0.0520060919,
0.0336973369,
-0.0142671177,
0.0020432707,
0.0314809382,
-0.047085762,
-0.0092550647,
0.01337153,
0.0129412711,
-0.00161453,
-0.0142524289,
0.0136708049,
0.0748732165,
-0.0153581481,
-0.0003014398,
0.0572249405,
-0.0090105347,
-0.0110482574,
0.0337497033,
0.0133274561,
0.0394630879,
0.0608974025,
-0.0463075005,
-0.0345929675,
0.0103371274,
0.0246287771,
-0.0224537253,
0.0506964475,
0.0131239081,
-0.0595151298,
0.0181565415,
0.0308188088,
-0.0203488804,
-0.0120863635,
0.0236201454,
-0.1018020734,
-0.0043266183,
-0.0123026585,
0.0194694605,
-0.0926237106,
0.0115623958,
0.0390824899,
-0.0359385535,
0.0481160022,
-0.0610179342,
0.0448470116,
-0.0009505893,
-0.0236269888,
-0.0374419466,
-0.0451021232,
0.0377841257,
0.0029019432,
-0.0536614172,
0.0144708771,
0.0007535992,
0.0210321359,
0.0154270614,
-0.0480994619,
-0.0122247962,
0.0218869131,
0.0476283431,
0.060741052,
-0.0131987156,
-0.0245435126,
0.0639279932,
0.0229766183,
-0.0378333703,
-0.027330175,
0.0541610681,
-0.0205894802,
0.0786848888,
0.025282165,
0.0399804786,
0.0677291304,
-0.0509727113,
-0.0366755091,
0.043374978,
-0.0733477101,
0.0814513937,
0.008054547,
-0.0012681971,
-0.0075506889,
-0.010856567,
0.022401765,
-0.0239564534,
-0.0009842732,
-0.054685656,
0.0460882857,
0.0464342572,
-0.0152785042,
0.0416371524,
0.022676101,
-0.0040891571,
0.041098617,
-0.0050257007,
0.0186125711,
0.0563047938,
-0.0446984507,
-0.0159866437,
-0.0310999732,
-0.0175356269,
0.0699894279,
0.0097438628,
0.0335891023,
0.0455071442,
0.0513420813,
0.0349928439,
-0.0400372446,
-0.00503923,
-0.0267460551,
-0.0153621919,
-0.0143662943,
0.0306856912,
0.0267608576,
0.039707467,
-0.0519998446,
-0.006959375,
-0.0255052503,
0.0214759689,
-0.0424441248,
-0.0652215257,
0.0173309073,
0.0107635213,
-0.03841893,
-0.0191873498,
-0.0580236167,
-0.0316212773,
0.0317665786,
-0.0699647218,
-0.0203745496,
0.0428389795,
2.836e-7,
0.059637066,
0.0436870009,
0.0475891456,
-0.0041458318,
0.0253957044,
-0.0028677566,
-0.0122886989,
0.045583006,
-0.0167436823,
-0.067194283,
0.0557163581,
0.0137124397,
0.0121140461,
0.0353425369,
-0.0792011917,
-0.0031778209,
-0.0238666683,
-0.0286675654,
-0.0050159562,
-0.0446902253,
0.1077789962,
0.0538700148,
-0.0599274673,
-0.0450382233,
0.0427421443,
-0.0413279906,
0.0713462383,
0.013514366,
0.0443150364,
-0.012246659,
0.0043542669,
0.047274027,
-0.0205958504,
0.0765843168,
-0.0122345565,
-0.0204950236,
0.0266545843,
0.0232072733,
-0.0547450669,
-0.0308609568,
0.0116528729,
0.0206230599,
0.0004175874,
-0.0408212952,
0.0546194389,
-0.0782101601,
-0.0146566043,
-0.0108806388,
-0.0183596946,
0.0424907319,
0.0310225841,
-0.0299303811,
-0.0506975166,
0.0326799862,
0.0366857164,
0.0212086365,
-0.0402332395,
-0.0772080198,
-0.022016054,
0.0410641693,
-0.006721003,
-0.0225292798,
-0.0117305582,
-0.0479354821,
0.0109547637,
-0.0367539413,
-0.0313945226,
2.676973489e-34,
0.0190662537,
0.0170112923,
0.0037823021,
0.0108427294,
0.0255581811,
-0.0228530169,
-0.0149433827,
-0.0002579185,
0.0089502539,
-0.0487493351,
-0.0315073654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11341v1 | MSVD-Indonesian: A Benchmark for Multimodal Video-Text Tasks in Indonesian | 2023-06-20T07:19:36 | 2023-06-20T07:19:36 | Willy Fitra Hendria | cs.MM | cs.MM, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, eess.IV | Multimodal learning on video and text data has been receiving growing
attention from many researchers in various research tasks, including
text-to-video retrieval, video-to-text retrieval, and video captioning.
Although many algorithms have been proposed for those challenging tasks, most
of them are developed on English language datasets. Despite Indonesian being
one of the most spoken languages in the world, the research progress on the
multimodal video-text with Indonesian sentences is still under-explored, likely
due to the absence of the public benchmark dataset. To address this issue, we
construct the first public Indonesian video-text dataset by translating English
sentences from the MSVD dataset to Indonesian sentences. Using our dataset, we
then train neural network models which were developed for the English
video-text dataset on three tasks, i.e., text-to-video retrieval, video-to-text
retrieval, and video captioning. The recent neural network-based approaches to
video-text tasks often utilized a feature extractor that is primarily
pretrained on an English vision-language dataset. Since the availability of the
pretraining resources with Indonesian sentences is relatively limited, the
applicability of those approaches to our dataset is still questionable. To
overcome the lack of pretraining resources, we apply cross-lingual transfer
learning by utilizing the feature extractors pretrained on the English dataset,
and we then fine-tune the models on our Indonesian dataset. Our experimental
results show that this approach can help to improve the performance for the
three tasks on all metrics. Finally, we discuss potential future works using
our dataset, inspiring further research in the Indonesian multimodal video-text
tasks. We believe that our dataset and our experimental results could provide
valuable contributions to the community. Our dataset is available on GitHub. | [
0.0369552337,
0.0438824482,
-0.0025512166,
0.0578401275,
-0.0200033672,
0.0080285519,
0.0235172398,
0.0136990584,
-0.004917773,
-0.0596823767,
-0.0634081662,
-0.0560261421,
0.0130959144,
0.0172651708,
0.0208831243,
-0.1091770604,
0.0347878449,
-0.0109407455,
0.0150271375,
0.03365805,
0.0172109101,
0.0160915963,
-0.0183389205,
-0.0146716265,
-0.0704042092,
0.0067250626,
0.0031218168,
0.0045431447,
0.0516350567,
-0.0302859545,
-0.0187324677,
0.0210946389,
0.0307190325,
-0.0321013667,
0.0000017627,
-0.0083684837,
0.0175074674,
-0.0311453324,
0.0549107902,
0.0204670765,
0.0661515296,
-0.0864890292,
-0.0050392011,
-0.0002815997,
-0.0276707243,
-0.0387516133,
0.0527774952,
0.0412264355,
0.0509814136,
0.0643764511,
-0.0522170775,
-0.0587633848,
0.0291787554,
-0.0125163607,
0.0331720561,
-0.006151679,
-0.0218254868,
0.0080057541,
-0.0008944109,
0.0047293282,
-0.0552249737,
0.0805977732,
-0.0074458569,
-0.0096413065,
-0.0195165537,
-0.0360697992,
-0.037618041,
-0.0428456068,
-0.0070898593,
0.0953337848,
0.0013335766,
0.0367204435,
-0.0312521718,
0.0138975251,
0.0030499217,
0.0212670527,
-0.0649907738,
0.043522723,
-0.0009766666,
0.0098494915,
-0.0302536152,
0.0439459011,
0.009806701,
-0.028025059,
0.0388978459,
-0.067186892,
0.0264103878,
0.038492851,
0.0003796472,
-0.0145870782,
-0.0181755498,
0.0082515683,
0.0264095236,
-0.0142629594,
0.0462947786,
-0.0013059092,
-0.0361967869,
-0.0395771265,
-0.0323266312,
-0.070862785,
0.0418063067,
0.0373285562,
-0.05256043,
0.0496896356,
-0.0528837703,
0.066024743,
-0.0323547386,
0.0488586612,
-0.0249710493,
-0.0436381027,
-0.0550861992,
-0.0078973584,
-0.0336177237,
0.013125754,
-0.0231573693,
-0.0395620652,
-0.0211155005,
-0.0254824273,
0.0070975749,
-0.0450104885,
0.0197652839,
0.0256664902,
-0.0110906456,
-0.0329910368,
-0.0124613941,
0.0637195408,
-0.0127384206,
0.0569240563,
0.0117809875,
-0.0591836125,
0.0042226668,
0.0405998006,
0.0398879498,
-0.0404375196,
0.0428989641,
0.0542819612,
-0.0833711997,
-0.0464395396,
-0.0404084325,
0.0320464298,
-0.0629589707,
-0.009462825,
0.0587392934,
-0.0293917134,
0.0714218169,
0.0054034023,
0.0036250341,
-0.0209737755,
-0.0084917778,
0.0273780413,
-0.0105800787,
0.1012914181,
0.0089534018,
0.0070990124,
0.0416048504,
-0.00022853,
-0.0009434731,
0.0450607277,
0.0318783112,
0.0636245534,
0.0520783886,
0.0251555629,
0.0088234842,
0.0487010665,
-0.0184787121,
0.0333139487,
-0.0545871034,
-0.0142191844,
0.0205681361,
0.0164199583,
0.0175949074,
0.0447198935,
-0.0047321515,
0.0132549861,
0.0549058914,
0.0232038237,
-0.0072259023,
0.0108686127,
0.045435559,
-0.0018823387,
0.0079061622,
-0.000579119,
0.0295360833,
0.0722605512,
0.0322186835,
0.0099947425,
0.0248465836,
0.02969441,
-0.0579143614,
-0.0287837498,
0.0311698765,
-0.0107458653,
0.0109136486,
0.0090371761,
0.0798840597,
0.01962406,
-0.0630841181,
0.0113200666,
0.0166528337,
-0.0154732289,
0.026815135,
-0.0146781243,
-0.0322668515,
0.0416782871,
-0.0064076022,
-0.019734662,
0.0119062476,
0.0223454777,
0.072185196,
-0.0107495431,
0.0319888219,
-0.0161423776,
0.0518905483,
-0.0747645423,
-0.0174056403,
0.0034272529,
0.0164812114,
0.066594027,
-0.033372771,
0.0481191725,
0.0256608557,
-0.0053039663,
-0.0210632849,
0.0533512086,
0.0323991142,
-0.0091901487,
-0.0020455329,
0.0369126946,
0.014519508,
0.0300917756,
-0.0079887044,
-0.0331460983,
-0.0003603349,
-0.0576934814,
0.0280088503,
0.0223019887,
-0.0250552855,
-0.0497121252,
0.0142741995,
-0.0620109141,
0.0370004326,
0.061964456,
0.014221278,
-0.0394383781,
0.0151579799,
0.0387010127,
-0.0320302509,
-0.0721143112,
-0.0107807089,
0.0009751261,
0.0307650268,
-0.0145093892,
-0.0078673316,
0.0102376072,
-0.042554263,
-0.0215458572,
-0.020340519,
0.0390328951,
-0.0350047424,
-0.038615983,
-0.0011248502,
-0.0294988174,
0.030309977,
-0.0190936867,
0.0060656378,
-0.026589863,
-0.038368877,
-0.097930029,
0.0044438695,
-0.0127281779,
0.0127656376,
-0.0202223975,
0.0004548189,
-0.0183924995,
-0.0524171889,
0.0053691096,
0.0058071199,
0.0354173295,
0.0127383498,
0.0152764246,
0.0527968667,
0.0368254073,
-0.007790281,
-0.024760792,
0.0295295678,
0.0438361391,
-0.0330720916,
-0.1289780736,
0.0180023499,
0.0147586083,
0.0046718097,
-0.0137189515,
-0.0241229553,
-0.04346117,
0.0060969042,
-0.0123940939,
-0.0344007984,
0.0321018212,
-0.0014508452,
0.0069745397,
-0.0139770303,
-0.0336925946,
-0.0019983007,
-0.0021129309,
0.0156941544,
-0.0256293528,
-0.0121687958,
0.0078209052,
-0.0004067537,
-0.0070308126,
-0.0132142762,
0.0161460359,
-0.0597153902,
-0.0234538466,
-0.0134651801,
-0.0069296076,
-0.0401974954,
0.049445726,
-0.007514555,
0.0235312153,
-0.00886783,
-0.0278866719,
-0.0099310232,
-0.0611705258,
-0.0301320516,
-0.0069044861,
0.0116301067,
-0.0394616611,
0.0610459447,
-0.0198755376,
0.0250635389,
-0.027383877,
-0.0296800211,
-0.0426823832,
-0.000980469,
0.0187410284,
0.0171140656,
0.0375458673,
-0.0193475503,
0.0100799939,
-0.0388185158,
-0.0078145936,
-0.0049994644,
-0.0494555607,
-0.0296673477,
-0.018851513,
-0.0309591126,
0.0342969187,
-0.0374375843,
0.0199228637,
0.0389965437,
0.0225604512,
-0.0192593541,
0.0188582297,
-0.0049538407,
0.0436654277,
0.0181566104,
-0.0078322496,
-0.0844717398,
-0.0566304773,
0.0120936641,
0.0213784836,
-0.0130631272,
-0.0345876925,
-0.0342275724,
0.0288520269,
0.0257664956,
0.0485691354,
-0.0047129355,
-0.0027560219,
0.055074729,
-0.0302585922,
0.0232835971,
0.0289091282,
-0.0231512226,
-0.0469677038,
-0.0525914915,
0.0098319333,
-0.0054575456,
0.0127794119,
0.0475892648,
-0.0604302697,
-0.0599888787,
-0.0195019357,
-0.0135626877,
0.0538530014,
0.0325149745,
-0.0573332272,
-0.0714862347,
0.0192553792,
0.0195112452,
-0.0766320378,
-0.056002561,
0.0005422783,
-0.0170932636,
-0.0025739558,
-0.0058660349,
-0.027932955,
0.0112413811,
-0.00418148,
0.0336680822,
0.0453249477,
-0.0827694908,
0.0035368055,
-0.0306657366,
0.0008025881,
0.0165418908,
-0.0069773849,
-0.0309138689,
-0.0114090443,
0.0233740583,
-0.0036045909,
0.0102805616,
0.0250492338,
0.0782005042,
-0.0255673937,
-0.0589859486,
0.0140604926,
0.0145986797,
0.0010526223,
-0.0137928594,
0.0235331263,
0.0316543318,
0.0229748636,
0.0096440632,
0.0021372202,
0.0002149549,
0.0244106743,
0.0054734526,
-0.0177905317,
-0.0672307462,
0.0279748905,
0.0034899137,
-0.0324231237,
-0.0396278389,
-0.038703341,
-0.0059067956,
-0.0395725034,
0.0342766605,
-0.0656962767,
-0.0185501035,
0.0359230489,
0.0714982003,
0.0148421032,
0.0027318341,
0.0165242981,
0.0310383923,
-0.052423045,
0.0420281552,
-0.0155037353,
0.0122146262,
-0.0420055613,
-0.0155914444,
0.027930744,
-0.0376879983,
0.0154304644,
-0.0294805411,
-0.0090095876,
-0.0055112783,
-0.0469144024,
0.0499474928,
0.0091292895,
0.0447928682,
0.0163452085,
-0.0305409972,
-0.0015367866,
0.0310614277,
-0.0109975748,
-0.0192732234,
0.0056817653,
-0.0482647792,
-0.0321618393,
0.0157448761,
-0.0021572884,
0.0423139669,
-0.0025660302,
0.0079841735,
0.0121341022,
-0.0170690157,
-0.0132099213,
-0.0049023409,
0.0627909899,
-0.0375042371,
-0.0091111148,
-0.0811481476,
-0.0113529526,
0.0100641968,
0.0025521505,
-0.0736024976,
0.0175409261,
0.0571529642,
0.0170736033,
-0.0000430598,
0.0057205246,
0.0309226457,
-0.0225467272,
-0.0033518795,
-0.0034187264,
0.0150265861,
0.0124834236,
-0.0194849987,
0.0479717925,
0.0139498562,
0.0245883428,
0.0019586363,
0.024917569,
-0.0288234446,
0.0659984499,
0.0120338527,
-0.0335456207,
-0.003348347,
0.0576635264,
0.0414160453,
0.0342605039,
-0.0562855229,
0.021141056,
0.0367872044,
-0.0452015847,
0.0251420345,
0.0056768372,
-0.017840201,
-0.050995566,
0.0504478179,
-0.0061768563,
-0.018377196,
0.0202658195,
-0.0267127361,
-0.0169421155,
0.0314654,
0.0534428954,
-0.0065872334,
-0.0076657282,
0.0228447095,
-0.0153362835,
-0.0217951536,
-0.0150554208,
0.0349145383,
0.0015935716,
-0.0212179199,
0.0000688331,
0.0007765387,
-0.050012745,
-0.0181759633,
-0.0367478505,
-0.0428384952,
0.0427135788,
0.0285742991,
0.0314010903,
0.0474307165,
0.0156042334,
-0.0363163874,
-0.0482271314,
-0.0255692732,
0.0242110025,
0.0081035169,
-5.004941236e-33,
-0.036741443,
0.029988423,
0.0051561506,
0.0042341431,
-0.0164112989,
-0.0159246698,
-0.0164692402,
0.0579805262,
-0.0400399715,
0.0337444581,
0.0056365877,
-0.0032597096,
0.0401583537,
0.0400328264,
0.0314262174,
-0.0285966042,
0.0028840066,
-0.0415138863,
0.0187172182,
-0.0147703206,
0.0430167653,
0.0512264147,
0.0808768943,
-0.0671125203,
-0.0177276395,
0.0392179564,
-0.0308432691,
-0.0149252005,
0.0474719703,
0.0341807939,
-0.0213804971,
0.0121475877,
0.0007942455,
-0.0314754806,
-0.0248757396,
0.0290773902,
-0.0410722159,
0.031473197,
-0.0076214601,
0.0643248037,
-0.0299406387,
-0.021703817,
0.0245224889,
-0.0310935937,
0.0079771029,
-0.019032279,
0.0390632153,
-0.0460459143,
0.0056515983,
0.0148298629,
-0.0386239626,
0.0242458526,
0.0049077724,
-0.0449142829,
0.0521795861,
0.0558593422,
0.0263312478,
-0.0322686248,
-0.0418230183,
0.0291544031,
-0.0686972588,
0.0316008925,
0.0708142519,
0.022065362,
-0.0230384134,
0.0578618683,
0.0332372338,
-0.0569340363,
0.011410444,
0.016167121,
0.0322333649,
0.0629599318,
0.0263594594,
0.0768376663,
0.0155328875,
-0.0560649186,
-0.0616627261,
0.0105817337,
-0.0772967711,
0.0081414375,
0.0060782698,
-0.0056062755,
-0.0149470633,
-0.0124605717,
-0.003464394,
-0.0349846482,
-0.0232345648,
-0.0285074599,
0.0415784009,
0.0039110458,
0.0008884826,
-0.0020913125,
0.1020990685,
-0.057942003,
0.0294017177,
0.0110320542,
-0.0603175834,
0.0772105679,
-0.0058073439,
-0.0026071179,
-0.0560520999,
-0.0434469581,
0.0155222649,
0.0441976823,
0.0108110849,
-0.0047794739,
0.0526709035,
0.0462371521,
-0.0480266251,
0.0070733717,
-0.00887099,
-0.0119051393,
-0.0171971284,
0.0953914523,
-0.0021891559,
0.0092983777,
-0.0514157079,
0.0536397174,
-0.0202803034,
0.0051994682,
0.005307104,
-0.0582054257,
0.0267555751,
-0.0166236237,
-0.0262450278,
0.0580370612,
-0.0604583882,
-0.0258597862,
0.0116261849,
-0.0252828281,
-0.0085489228,
0.0561335422,
2.438e-7,
0.0510837585,
0.0052253371,
0.0390298516,
-0.0334991775,
-0.003831266,
0.0684352294,
-0.0570477732,
0.0317089744,
0.0232100822,
0.0063255555,
0.0442782156,
0.0203528665,
0.0519362949,
-0.0134009942,
-0.0622636937,
-0.016788993,
-0.0241774619,
0.0074205273,
-0.0383705311,
-0.018100515,
0.0303623192,
0.0857030898,
-0.0274659973,
-0.0055856965,
-0.0208007172,
-0.0661982447,
0.1148874983,
0.0063444306,
-0.0440962911,
-0.0191733502,
0.0171660651,
0.0312998407,
-0.0452480279,
-0.0137858093,
-0.0098399213,
0.0111110806,
0.0883847401,
0.0596541427,
-0.0054973443,
-0.0395274088,
-0.000328789,
0.0766297877,
-0.0533203408,
0.0066032698,
0.098395668,
-0.0356319509,
-0.0331765525,
-0.0015002767,
0.0008289817,
0.0287875645,
0.0001929421,
-0.0066894735,
-0.0293364301,
0.0360344537,
0.0806822255,
-0.0026983018,
-0.0696571395,
-0.0705588832,
-0.0215280857,
0.0052173915,
-0.031634897,
0.0308208428,
-0.0545614548,
0.0330386236,
0.0232290085,
0.0079965964,
-0.0285637248,
1.213548455e-34,
0.0032800892,
-0.0116367098,
-0.0034089012,
-0.077095814,
-0.0275722761,
-0.0213256441,
-0.0457374789,
0.0021786285,
-0.0178194921,
-0.0568751693,
-0.0152561981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11309v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11309v1 | Multi-pass Training and Cross-information Fusion for Low-resource End-to-end Accented Speech Recognition | 2023-06-20T06:08:09 | 2023-06-20T06:08:09 | Xuefei Wang, Yanhua Long, Yijie Li, Haoran Wei | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS, eess.SP | Low-resource accented speech recognition is one of the important challenges
faced by current ASR technology in practical applications. In this study, we
propose a Conformer-based architecture, called Aformer, to leverage both the
acoustic information from large non-accented and limited accented training
data. Specifically, a general encoder and an accent encoder are designed in the
Aformer to extract complementary acoustic information. Moreover, we propose to
train the Aformer in a multi-pass manner, and investigate three
cross-information fusion methods to effectively combine the information from
both general and accent encoders. All experiments are conducted on both the
accented English and Mandarin ASR tasks. Results show that our proposed methods
outperform the strong Conformer baseline by relative 10.2% to 24.5%
word/character error rate reduction on six in-domain and out-of-domain accented
test sets. | [
-0.037702363,
0.0308972672,
0.0300305728,
0.0103882747,
-0.008046167,
-0.0122940112,
0.0288639963,
-0.0123570645,
-0.0210863445,
0.0051694727,
-0.0723095834,
-0.05833368,
0.087285243,
-0.0236712582,
0.0265091583,
-0.0199681465,
-0.0238381941,
-0.0364923961,
-0.0244241562,
-0.0475894883,
0.0177804064,
0.0107420748,
-0.0215206966,
0.0484362505,
-0.0023319859,
0.0560239963,
-0.0079400409,
0.0072400142,
0.0477759689,
-0.0086407848,
-0.0196169987,
-0.0367122702,
0.022017695,
0.0063470025,
0.0000018663,
0.0140544306,
-0.0322117768,
0.001720432,
-0.0491549708,
0.0113171004,
0.0242447592,
0.0012219208,
-0.04808544,
0.0740622878,
0.0236339979,
-0.0269366223,
0.0807888955,
0.0599300675,
0.0011283446,
0.052127447,
-0.0040145358,
-0.078901194,
0.0395753086,
-0.0104734423,
-0.0294919945,
-0.0097970907,
-0.0004789977,
-0.0666285008,
-0.0235053301,
-0.0201320387,
-0.0198597722,
0.0354642719,
0.0101153553,
0.0268941652,
-0.0124446871,
0.0177415069,
0.0061509232,
-0.0073796008,
-0.0288866721,
0.0184812453,
-0.0409127995,
-0.0203283466,
-0.0207386091,
0.0014901678,
-0.0271010436,
-0.0270191468,
-0.0026047509,
-0.0025923159,
-0.0197169781,
0.0230285227,
0.0026491629,
0.030644495,
0.0096029779,
-0.0142169269,
-0.0666243359,
-0.0149272159,
0.0011346409,
-0.0431869403,
0.0412598699,
-0.0197899882,
-0.0022011821,
0.0150965154,
0.0216883793,
0.0075073484,
0.0248296689,
-0.0198313948,
-0.0121825589,
-0.0297470745,
0.0039251493,
-0.0247754622,
0.0022059686,
0.0631189272,
-0.0345127881,
-0.0227085911,
-0.0224145781,
0.0837093815,
-0.0199429896,
-0.002912736,
-0.0338324867,
-0.0456172861,
-0.0141095696,
0.0102421641,
-0.0341187567,
0.0237292703,
-0.0086924247,
-0.0217991825,
-0.0284460615,
-0.0334346481,
-0.0044610873,
0.0017460036,
0.0575117134,
-0.0093332324,
-0.0290528852,
-0.0202470142,
0.0105056921,
0.0733576491,
0.0286885351,
0.0239634383,
-0.0022123782,
-0.074450545,
-0.012400873,
0.0125581222,
0.0309750009,
-0.0180593748,
0.0361738056,
-0.0035895302,
-0.0138194524,
-0.0144928321,
-0.0390298218,
0.018058924,
-0.0299762096,
-0.0119520677,
0.0067832004,
-0.0447139964,
0.0498484783,
-0.0084149232,
0.0201760121,
-0.0502231382,
0.0019489672,
-0.0055383407,
0.0401543789,
0.0517295413,
-0.0143647436,
-0.0137758553,
0.0409582593,
-0.0447771214,
0.0194504093,
0.0572532564,
0.0250442512,
-0.0313132256,
-0.0380218066,
-0.0282079894,
-0.0425849669,
0.035661459,
0.0067394068,
0.0021089173,
-0.0171384942,
-0.042426534,
0.0313013606,
-0.0125676384,
0.0349583663,
0.0474127941,
-0.0211596601,
-0.0033555299,
0.0120344842,
-0.019543577,
0.0363644212,
-0.0071963654,
0.0275606327,
0.0060483408,
-0.0210760403,
-0.0096825436,
0.0197163038,
-0.0061804033,
-0.0168303046,
0.0295198839,
0.0453886688,
0.0842180923,
-0.0360293798,
-0.0198555905,
-0.0000242069,
-0.0475292355,
-0.0192065947,
0.0474661887,
0.0536850207,
-0.0040864726,
-0.0464034453,
0.0145474561,
-0.0118391998,
-0.0454453118,
0.0434079506,
-0.0267461967,
-0.0431965068,
0.0293840822,
0.0148590198,
-0.0150383329,
-0.0080788508,
-0.0248480663,
-0.0041767252,
-0.0072404202,
0.0149610173,
0.0263398774,
0.0684259161,
-0.0907615796,
-0.0269560441,
0.0348436013,
-0.0364338383,
0.0723841041,
-0.0463923812,
0.0409715399,
0.0016698092,
0.0195853952,
0.0262394883,
-0.0430607386,
0.0021486008,
-0.0113759246,
0.0485144444,
0.0185104311,
0.0302004348,
0.0392750576,
-0.044242844,
0.0056465529,
0.0528439432,
-0.0790955946,
-0.011136258,
0.0319512486,
-0.0677709654,
0.0022095693,
0.0547762103,
-0.0345657691,
0.0389016755,
0.0040903469,
0.0267869439,
-0.104961291,
-0.0132798692,
-0.0396724753,
0.1116703004,
-0.0409765393,
0.0825470909,
0.0553773232,
0.0321746357,
0.047249157,
0.0103104431,
-0.0019055941,
-0.009491303,
-0.0006659094,
0.0283677429,
-0.0131431501,
-0.0589091927,
-0.0119341388,
0.0359653085,
-0.0071769278,
0.0052570798,
0.0191714559,
-0.0254077595,
0.0562373698,
-0.0332505815,
-0.0391772613,
-0.0169650801,
-0.0205191188,
0.0208892301,
-0.0348690897,
0.0483709127,
0.0243639685,
-0.0050033196,
-0.0446749218,
-0.012129141,
-0.0358568802,
-0.0169845186,
-0.0436612181,
0.0123221176,
-0.0289434269,
0.029879244,
-0.0025194923,
0.0165755749,
-0.014540093,
-0.0311065018,
-0.0224540699,
-0.0455704108,
-0.0318447016,
0.0437719859,
0.0448700674,
0.0039668949,
-0.0469480716,
-0.0122383274,
0.0067063007,
0.0206282083,
-0.0075359368,
-0.0032792538,
-0.0411503986,
0.0189989638,
-0.019999506,
-0.0462341681,
0.009744403,
0.0534935035,
0.0497413911,
0.0028795225,
0.0249044504,
-0.0590738989,
0.0066350535,
-0.0024207029,
0.045013275,
-0.0499910265,
-0.0605817474,
0.0282583423,
-0.0417488031,
-0.0211440381,
-0.0572678298,
-0.0286372602,
-0.0385554247,
-0.0372778699,
0.0100705475,
0.0099278968,
-0.0920937657,
-0.0373619348,
-0.0308168717,
-0.0465975255,
-0.0137759289,
-0.0344845578,
-0.0128886141,
0.0129733831,
0.0227946378,
-0.0524322167,
0.0361803509,
0.0352652855,
-0.0032435274,
-0.0478601605,
0.0633769035,
0.023067696,
-0.0169706568,
-0.0156934038,
-0.0233791918,
0.0103300195,
0.0008569038,
-0.0350532755,
0.058263991,
0.04883641,
-0.0471596122,
-0.0137465326,
0.0346500762,
0.0367082916,
0.0592199787,
0.0175893791,
0.012781458,
-0.0285857171,
0.0215341561,
0.0068509942,
0.0531552285,
-0.0515585095,
-0.0163671784,
0.0364481397,
-0.0135451276,
0.0766888261,
-0.024521295,
-0.0432027206,
-0.0254525654,
0.0554325655,
0.0226169918,
0.0084989024,
-0.0028750896,
0.0352375284,
-0.0160436537,
0.0153415455,
0.0662522092,
0.0012571249,
-0.0286137629,
-0.044546809,
0.0075185541,
0.0332120247,
0.0072370716,
-0.0293813832,
-0.0350683779,
-0.038940616,
0.0536493547,
0.0224193297,
-0.0073676282,
0.0524585024,
-0.0114401812,
-0.1173965335,
0.0018128714,
0.0297398437,
-0.056812387,
-0.0660770461,
-0.0548533946,
-0.0447263494,
-0.0421387888,
0.0566336662,
-0.0247403029,
-0.0129995914,
-0.0695041791,
0.0347544476,
-0.0612269938,
-0.0539358705,
-0.0306028314,
-0.0343577377,
0.0356098451,
0.0320887193,
0.01032006,
-0.0219210051,
-0.0827303231,
0.0375294574,
-0.0550725758,
0.0434142128,
-0.0396724492,
0.035432253,
0.0221562963,
-0.015361079,
0.044660449,
0.0034400616,
-0.0295375418,
-0.0013567318,
0.013875776,
0.0519659705,
-0.0532490462,
0.0741568059,
0.0414148532,
-0.0093085803,
-0.0066353246,
0.0543498211,
-0.0102600642,
-0.0363545306,
0.006399279,
0.0160500742,
0.0402148217,
-0.0118469838,
0.0315682925,
0.0094990572,
0.0102558192,
-0.0609779544,
-0.0159897134,
-0.0168176051,
0.00537189,
0.0436270051,
0.0202069003,
-0.0189776495,
-0.0372681245,
0.0266624782,
0.0101350462,
-0.0365358852,
-0.0191028286,
0.0632809624,
-0.0486205705,
0.040893957,
0.0052286424,
-0.0542288795,
0.021723887,
0.0235060006,
0.0332622901,
-0.060239099,
0.0305259358,
-0.01416035,
0.0095814047,
0.0707375631,
-0.0292359591,
0.0004470384,
0.061618302,
-0.019473413,
0.003987636,
0.0009209648,
0.0781192556,
-0.0501486324,
-0.0039259596,
-0.008438128,
-0.0327832028,
0.0136373276,
-0.0449759029,
-0.0239736158,
-0.0466027483,
-0.0551742911,
0.0341688693,
0.0603601485,
0.0309492704,
-0.0257576499,
0.0273520835,
-0.0194110926,
0.0654832125,
-0.0078045484,
0.0841117501,
-0.0064361184,
-0.0410942324,
0.0364624523,
0.017177226,
0.0222158041,
0.079383038,
0.0226102043,
-0.0550977588,
0.0111902459,
0.0659570694,
0.0071941228,
0.0566723086,
-0.0265644733,
0.0060183434,
-0.0140551236,
0.0221559256,
0.0659515783,
0.0187513772,
-0.0295733009,
0.0254348982,
-0.0075447373,
-0.0110317972,
0.0221223254,
0.0340285078,
-0.0252534971,
0.0423277356,
-0.0325143598,
-0.0205434691,
0.031930685,
-0.0090066353,
0.0448790044,
0.0169520993,
0.0282245539,
-0.026927501,
-0.0084346067,
-0.0422686599,
0.0204066467,
0.0164879877,
0.0035818224,
0.0084624188,
0.0111590018,
0.0219822153,
-0.0820564553,
0.0525681973,
-0.0607009046,
0.0443483666,
-0.0175041929,
-0.0289327446,
-0.0007273806,
-0.0082495166,
-0.0350113846,
-0.045891162,
0.0173685066,
-0.0317175649,
0.0636224225,
-0.001487273,
0.028649997,
-0.0227405578,
-0.0065356684,
-0.0403435342,
-0.030556526,
0.0085826777,
0.0430685878,
-0.0670694113,
0.0047469689,
0.0252500791,
0.0325130373,
-5.982727355e-33,
-0.0159685779,
0.0754267201,
0.0057049249,
0.0136825312,
-0.040684469,
0.0356253833,
0.0204349365,
-0.0078406809,
-0.0380105935,
-0.0478119738,
-0.0058774953,
-0.0060023591,
0.0415611155,
0.0006453939,
0.006249385,
0.0424939618,
0.0971956179,
0.0117198909,
0.0179786328,
-0.01826635,
0.0625252649,
0.0170835424,
0.0275349617,
-0.047839582,
-0.073970601,
0.0407344028,
-0.0197561774,
-0.0039624139,
-0.0097602634,
0.0415410697,
0.0207867566,
0.0583495386,
-0.0019933311,
-0.0526259206,
0.0029077905,
0.0071650478,
-0.1001388654,
0.001477871,
-0.0299300198,
0.0428714529,
0.0476452336,
-0.0621833019,
0.0452949591,
0.0186485723,
-0.0160088148,
-0.0291108247,
0.0074578626,
-0.0347281769,
-0.0023696071,
0.0052604442,
0.0229984876,
0.0423873886,
0.0099400934,
0.0189279281,
0.0729916021,
0.0586641878,
-0.0073099062,
-0.0518880114,
-0.0822766274,
0.0141191958,
0.0268224515,
0.0165730845,
0.0088683031,
0.0240191557,
0.0091070058,
0.00209367,
0.0507601611,
-0.0747237727,
0.0255138967,
-0.0197253544,
0.0214276426,
0.0217587575,
0.0329805911,
0.0376646891,
0.0402035974,
-0.0659630895,
-0.0267551504,
0.0312265251,
0.0492815301,
0.0373665653,
-0.0135163721,
0.0322365686,
-0.0246779826,
0.0110165663,
-0.0203775838,
-0.0083218813,
-0.0306886714,
-0.0109753655,
0.0127573507,
0.0371093825,
-0.0061557489,
0.0806194991,
0.0585809797,
-0.0007514736,
0.0527718551,
0.0123369507,
0.0328658745,
-0.0009543471,
-0.0097101787,
0.0047082244,
-0.062157359,
-0.0484972894,
0.040856339,
0.0274674166,
-0.0047353231,
-0.0274507478,
0.0481286831,
0.0870379731,
-0.0844722465,
-0.0208075829,
-0.0047532334,
0.020534493,
0.0166140031,
-0.021523498,
0.0284866579,
0.0034881183,
0.0125120431,
0.0047123306,
-0.0196490083,
0.0167935248,
0.0001535978,
-0.040917512,
0.0638586879,
0.019354729,
0.0058245505,
0.0189925395,
0.0348120034,
-0.0577115305,
0.0107050389,
0.0023365507,
-0.0301627126,
0.0179135632,
2.645e-7,
-0.0322120301,
-0.0497337058,
0.0550974086,
-0.0144758122,
-0.014535279,
-0.0200450923,
-0.0195508264,
-0.0170909148,
-0.0074379649,
0.0183128882,
0.0132806646,
-0.0036556325,
0.064178437,
0.0153167732,
-0.0723272189,
-0.0103249038,
-0.0145082278,
-0.0041516651,
0.021929007,
0.0450149365,
0.0322028436,
0.0685920566,
-0.0463623069,
-0.0569782555,
0.0132767921,
0.011199167,
0.0236675236,
-0.0043921052,
0.0269915089,
-0.0457899235,
0.0223952774,
-0.0134133007,
-0.0265590958,
0.0608506501,
-0.0380417369,
0.0606554784,
-0.013761281,
-0.0132955443,
-0.0360687003,
-0.0797193423,
0.0403217562,
0.055268608,
-0.0607501268,
0.0106242308,
0.0777726397,
0.0238679517,
-0.0120704649,
-0.0391099975,
-0.081925936,
0.0152405649,
0.0002398045,
0.0092716655,
0.0186318867,
-0.0238357987,
0.0094057703,
-0.0061380276,
-0.0395513214,
-0.0040875082,
0.0284624025,
0.0410182551,
-0.0401528366,
0.0174010042,
-0.0127084795,
-0.0072836853,
-0.0151417488,
-0.020314211,
-0.0219704639,
1.80352597e-34,
-0.0008394643,
-0.0636348799,
0.0257890951,
0.0166810397,
-0.0131666493,
-0.0583778322,
-0.0158243123,
0.0004863009,
-0.0341501161,
-0.0500300527,
-0.056965556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11300v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11300v5 | RS5M and GeoRSCLIP: A Large Scale Vision-Language Dataset and A Large Vision-Language Model for Remote Sensing | 2023-06-20T05:30:59 | 2024-01-02T14:18:02 | Zilun Zhang, Tiancheng Zhao, Yulong Guo, Jianwei Yin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM | Pre-trained Vision-Language Models (VLMs) utilizing extensive image-text
paired data have demonstrated unprecedented image-text association
capabilities, achieving remarkable results across various downstream tasks. A
critical challenge is how to make use of existing large-scale pre-trained VLMs,
which are trained on common objects, to perform the domain-specific transfer
for accomplishing domain-related downstream tasks. A critical challenge is how
to make use of existing large-scale pre-trained VLMs, which are trained on
common objects, to perform the domain-specific transfer for accomplishing
domain-related downstream tasks. In this paper, we propose a new framework that
includes the Domain pre-trained Vision-Language Model (DVLM), bridging the gap
between the General Vision-Language Model (GVLM) and domain-specific downstream
tasks. Moreover, we present an image-text paired dataset in the field of remote
sensing (RS), RS5M, which has 5 million RS images with English descriptions.
The dataset is obtained from filtering publicly available image-text paired
datasets and captioning label-only RS datasets with pre-trained VLM. These
constitute the first large-scale RS image-text paired dataset. Additionally, we
fine-tuned the CLIP model and tried several Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning
methods on RS5M to implement the DVLM. Experimental results show that our
proposed dataset is highly effective for various tasks, and our model GeoRSCLIP
improves upon the baseline or previous state-of-the-art model by $3\%\sim20\%$
in Zero-shot Classification (ZSC), $3\%\sim6\%$ in Remote Sensing Cross-Modal
Text-Image Retrieval (RSCTIR) and $4\%\sim5\%$ in Semantic Localization (SeLo)
tasks. Dataset and models have been released in:
\url{https://github.com/om-ai-lab/RS5M}. | [
0.0371793881,
0.0507249609,
0.0311103351,
0.0474115275,
-0.0328876041,
0.0388433151,
0.0104392022,
-0.0338260904,
0.0062510674,
-0.0873797685,
-0.0261371695,
0.0077188984,
0.0257431734,
0.0512275547,
0.001718835,
-0.0564047061,
0.0472913086,
-0.0576089062,
-0.0075684604,
0.0069560721,
0.0054651042,
0.0129034035,
0.014807744,
-0.0069615911,
0.0191988945,
0.003708371,
0.0243345052,
0.0178376064,
0.0538183115,
-0.0177130532,
-0.0348209441,
0.0425969362,
0.0425170995,
0.005317077,
0.0000018618,
-0.0381156653,
-0.0057465257,
0.0347421467,
-0.0035924239,
-0.0279733092,
0.067497313,
-0.0404602699,
0.0133179855,
-0.0134928795,
-0.0068676714,
-0.0492665246,
0.1050648615,
0.0256497879,
0.0357284136,
0.064967297,
-0.0268821828,
-0.0536008626,
-0.0090251835,
-0.0070080976,
-0.0014538084,
-0.0417541713,
0.0583807118,
0.0166527107,
-0.0176987816,
0.0544263273,
-0.0215564407,
0.0241184402,
-0.0105967745,
0.0014685357,
-0.0143612996,
0.0462983847,
-0.0707621202,
-0.023528615,
-0.0076200459,
0.0419655293,
-0.02547515,
-0.0174265988,
0.0006737477,
-0.0018874073,
-0.0561743192,
-0.0076656281,
-0.0151465563,
0.0238995068,
0.0185801368,
0.0329837091,
-0.043799594,
0.0114368182,
0.0002357703,
0.066411823,
-0.0163165703,
0.0044785328,
0.002102135,
0.0330996998,
-0.0115071153,
0.0339328498,
0.0019095297,
-0.0390039496,
-0.0100631872,
0.0155218169,
0.0054646819,
-0.0059459307,
-0.0781240091,
0.0037769738,
0.0137777729,
-0.0106822681,
0.0038873861,
-0.0129669318,
-0.0361546166,
0.1091701537,
-0.030122105,
0.0235095751,
0.0324535929,
0.0520833395,
-0.0023277609,
-0.0564910285,
-0.0388247296,
-0.0183813013,
-0.0243178476,
0.0211484078,
-0.0060832999,
-0.0312265642,
-0.0163915027,
-0.0080606248,
0.027048789,
-0.005451763,
-0.02094239,
-0.0157485362,
-0.0394049585,
-0.0511248969,
-0.0152562708,
0.0208782014,
0.041545134,
0.0423298925,
-0.00836989,
-0.016972037,
0.0213748366,
0.0400250182,
0.0340868123,
-0.0245741811,
-0.0157926157,
0.0484568737,
-0.0054150028,
-0.079930827,
-0.0224557091,
-0.00416617,
-0.0233783722,
-0.026633136,
0.0082011344,
-0.0573528521,
0.0073124785,
0.0165953003,
-0.0132024977,
-0.0321068913,
0.0017108191,
0.0177381989,
-0.0731947422,
0.1232057735,
-0.0251033604,
-0.0147344377,
0.007766244,
-0.0071492158,
0.031640783,
0.1201594546,
-0.0093354313,
0.0625392422,
0.0043904535,
0.0134263299,
0.0103876283,
0.0343680717,
-0.024034543,
0.0418946818,
-0.0723446086,
0.0195446666,
0.0021044295,
-0.0291944891,
0.0396480933,
-0.0066428105,
-0.0017563117,
0.0026804989,
0.0615213886,
0.0290060062,
-0.0033915984,
-0.0051620374,
0.0238986835,
0.0348399468,
-0.0249094237,
-0.0509064943,
-0.0540187322,
0.035898298,
-0.04623501,
0.0001236335,
-0.0193478111,
0.0419327095,
-0.0519554131,
-0.003067699,
-0.0205238629,
-0.0232665762,
-0.009958026,
0.0124907531,
0.089045234,
-0.0203528199,
0.0321222767,
0.0176976286,
0.040049307,
0.0004715985,
0.0209286828,
-0.0365470015,
-0.006875963,
0.0012426991,
-0.0226671342,
-0.0283677969,
0.0172573216,
-0.0148877772,
0.0800631642,
0.085758999,
0.0090505043,
0.033480268,
0.0179686379,
-0.0374556556,
-0.0856316388,
0.0033898491,
-0.0236929022,
-0.0105995601,
-0.01467863,
0.0422593355,
0.0520804077,
-0.0297014304,
-0.0284617264,
0.0405015126,
0.0287099387,
-0.0121159656,
-0.0031187178,
0.0478677824,
-0.014127397,
-0.0193008129,
-0.0342600271,
-0.0060337088,
-0.0020098782,
0.0094313044,
-0.0101542361,
0.0016151401,
-0.007400936,
-0.0431683362,
0.0038465026,
-0.0326817222,
-0.0207301751,
0.0523035191,
-0.0507863201,
-0.0208202004,
-0.0079916352,
0.0012922897,
-0.0022905718,
-0.0379882306,
0.0115771545,
0.0017789688,
0.038484253,
-0.0337671489,
0.0243241061,
-0.0041867825,
-0.0149524622,
-0.0154076461,
-0.0170573611,
0.0370818302,
-0.0059361635,
-0.0119137708,
-0.0426599048,
-0.0261335,
0.004163486,
0.0202717055,
0.0535213426,
-0.0278549455,
-0.0109283328,
-0.0244146511,
-0.0387568325,
-0.020059498,
-0.0105796009,
0.0075506186,
-0.0172965676,
0.007244797,
-0.0201236699,
-0.0054147514,
0.0138598261,
-0.0081327539,
0.0339532085,
0.0181246381,
0.0113279345,
0.0284697562,
-0.000966939,
0.002843691,
0.0270821005,
0.0487957336,
0.0271439962,
-0.0661431625,
-0.0537434369,
0.0502640568,
-0.0375973806,
0.0166337471,
-0.0156915672,
-0.0367719196,
-0.0141971922,
-0.0382710733,
-0.0072885407,
0.0096673211,
-0.0101142433,
-0.0268766545,
0.0147697087,
-0.009284717,
-0.0391305313,
-0.0113405399,
-0.0301315151,
-0.0559603609,
0.0188224539,
0.0126959682,
0.0037767706,
0.0068301819,
-0.0527311079,
-0.007383598,
-0.0201081671,
0.0423722044,
-0.0120494748,
0.0018854962,
-0.0549683943,
0.0106679378,
0.0300629847,
0.0202285964,
-0.0442148037,
-0.0844413638,
0.0095110936,
-0.0375882648,
-0.0117936237,
-0.0599749349,
-0.0170147084,
-0.027901696,
0.0611227974,
0.0333671793,
0.0224808492,
0.0160944629,
0.0151373129,
-0.0261275582,
-0.0581911542,
-0.031474907,
0.0218877289,
0.029422516,
-0.0654738396,
0.0727811903,
-0.032269001,
-0.0023042315,
-0.0106674824,
-0.0274590272,
-0.0400555432,
0.0124775413,
-0.0540698692,
-0.0252560582,
-0.019318752,
0.0533489585,
0.037889868,
0.026902372,
0.0170481037,
-0.0029068918,
-0.0056254109,
0.0045873038,
0.0894177556,
-0.0094342157,
-0.0296419002,
0.0091520427,
-0.0199829359,
-0.0061373943,
0.003353752,
0.01332324,
-0.0260555651,
0.0052212086,
0.0206602756,
0.0351724625,
0.0249745194,
0.0030344848,
0.0520038977,
-0.036544349,
-0.0106042605,
0.0428914465,
-0.0005063942,
-0.063706547,
-0.0571769215,
-0.0152953286,
0.0011281502,
0.0440294147,
0.0093611414,
-0.0527173318,
-0.0549631827,
-0.0338945091,
-0.060670279,
0.0273335315,
-0.0126424516,
-0.0845487192,
-0.0986840948,
0.02452893,
0.0243003052,
-0.0878629908,
-0.0263657272,
-0.030222483,
0.0000977633,
-0.0299000125,
-0.059414193,
-0.0698576868,
-0.0180284288,
-0.0113029331,
-0.0002951681,
-0.0185874887,
-0.0474101752,
-0.0002466107,
-0.067828238,
-0.0110595422,
0.0511316098,
-0.0036796778,
-0.0277207289,
-0.0328859873,
0.0103957066,
-0.018891912,
0.0003487232,
-0.0031740176,
0.0650948435,
-0.038330894,
-0.0409266166,
0.0336796567,
0.0013557699,
-0.0195982084,
-0.0170795731,
-0.021005936,
0.0458458066,
-0.003727546,
0.015619006,
-0.0529611558,
0.0079142125,
0.0515876934,
0.0470563993,
-0.0212194379,
0.0063806237,
-0.0375932194,
0.0088893631,
-0.0352020599,
-0.0439840704,
-0.0426619835,
0.0194564909,
-0.0426451936,
-0.0362477973,
-0.0407543816,
-0.004374275,
0.0626549497,
0.0185733903,
-0.0193967354,
0.0277528968,
0.0165454708,
-0.009966637,
-0.0663153231,
0.0752176642,
-0.0796872675,
0.0351168886,
-0.0614957474,
-0.0224605873,
0.0788635761,
-0.041361697,
-0.0036754992,
0.0247405581,
-0.0933806598,
-0.0244859289,
-0.0157945249,
0.0606654845,
0.0099421889,
0.0161563996,
-0.0039608441,
-0.0449254625,
0.0434009247,
0.0575625226,
-0.0022937884,
0.0174292773,
0.0023263046,
-0.0299218539,
-0.0238064751,
-0.0004364159,
-0.0572433732,
0.0584178418,
0.0449388549,
-0.0302246548,
-0.0122576803,
-0.0079242913,
-0.0171498135,
-0.0045595965,
0.1085385904,
-0.0053056781,
0.0019167189,
-0.0161569901,
0.0099748727,
-0.0128316004,
-0.0022994878,
-0.0315934829,
0.0165982991,
0.0096794069,
0.0372814909,
0.0139679387,
0.0278143119,
-0.0289813522,
0.0043799737,
-0.0054352954,
-0.0272393432,
0.0052241585,
0.0082207806,
0.0412868261,
0.0217703581,
-0.0063639148,
-0.0094937542,
0.0077361981,
0.0022061381,
-0.0087188967,
0.0242686849,
0.0391876213,
0.0323431566,
-0.0245818235,
0.0223014932,
0.0167707,
-0.0469592474,
-0.0408563167,
-0.0122594405,
0.0246554427,
-0.024200663,
0.0038126311,
-0.004136479,
-0.0254560784,
-0.0408717133,
0.0218701828,
0.0171643049,
-0.0296101645,
0.0648874491,
0.009253392,
-0.0365766808,
0.0442345031,
0.0464209616,
0.0470879599,
0.0099682221,
0.0102510704,
-0.001087056,
-0.0122349439,
-0.0083223581,
0.0381565355,
-0.0200576633,
-0.0010178259,
0.0494701676,
-0.0156312287,
-0.0482595675,
0.0187007934,
-0.044111535,
-0.0368802175,
0.0570390224,
0.029778026,
0.0282363743,
-0.0100589236,
0.0007092569,
-0.0308316126,
-0.0311581604,
-0.0177336652,
0.0033545792,
0.0291254688,
-5.61493207e-33,
-0.0118705416,
-0.0385892503,
0.0500511974,
0.0335953385,
0.0021224853,
0.0196060874,
0.0086925412,
-0.0174521394,
-0.0242690518,
0.0080882544,
0.0331616923,
-0.0183507372,
0.0277100131,
0.066959627,
0.0030069887,
0.0282237418,
0.0325650759,
0.0055531971,
0.0320920423,
-0.0241408665,
0.0163355861,
0.010530564,
0.0521873124,
-0.0767334327,
-0.0501847081,
0.0222529713,
-0.0291280039,
0.0099656414,
0.0453991704,
0.0663232505,
-0.0274636634,
0.0232999902,
0.0199560188,
-0.0155021343,
-0.0507130213,
0.0331493989,
-0.0401800424,
-0.0212573744,
-0.0032550944,
0.0404561907,
-0.0312309656,
0.0113311782,
0.0148439379,
-0.016175881,
0.0443757512,
-0.0641501024,
0.0653119907,
-0.0322410427,
-0.0134751173,
-0.0321430638,
-0.0389590375,
0.0439812765,
0.028028721,
-0.0241080727,
0.0500145853,
-0.0120487027,
0.0171569549,
0.0921043232,
-0.0706769377,
0.0224033911,
0.0433607958,
0.0368393213,
0.0658361241,
0.058284644,
0.0099627944,
0.0736034513,
-0.0036890947,
-0.0308249965,
0.0188074708,
-0.0165863745,
0.0349335223,
0.0431828499,
0.0250481907,
0.0819202662,
0.024946956,
-0.00246628,
-0.0578771494,
0.0275842268,
-0.0788411722,
0.0616794527,
0.003002967,
0.010939314,
0.0107382685,
-0.0097253043,
-0.0313554518,
0.0073289983,
-0.0645433962,
-0.0071300743,
0.0579641648,
0.0398842879,
-0.0320564993,
0.0824745744,
0.058472991,
-0.0241562687,
-0.0505564623,
0.0145683093,
0.0044725295,
0.0261844732,
0.0036405216,
-0.0012609293,
-0.0814169571,
-0.0627734065,
0.0353177227,
0.0276144408,
-0.0064859814,
0.0187297482,
0.0601828806,
0.049317155,
-0.0464279279,
-0.0046599018,
-0.0116343088,
-0.0209986474,
-0.0072915307,
0.0530826636,
0.0038975705,
0.0085543115,
-0.0195701942,
0.0836077332,
0.0045231632,
-0.0520030931,
0.0434668697,
-0.013205843,
-0.0144983092,
0.0355543494,
-0.0040890067,
0.0053723785,
-0.0149349002,
-0.0223279521,
0.0417412855,
0.0066731106,
0.0018241069,
0.0087443646,
2.57e-7,
0.0532242842,
0.028834179,
0.0045363628,
-0.0232014656,
-0.0447312556,
0.0522627123,
-0.0141000906,
0.0343385041,
-0.0151276933,
0.0334292799,
-0.0029220809,
0.003441378,
0.0444723293,
-0.0110572781,
-0.0575639382,
0.0773233026,
-0.0413325094,
-0.0292944461,
-0.0646744892,
-0.031225631,
0.0587586537,
0.0990678519,
-0.0009191481,
-0.014252739,
0.0216067266,
-0.0733619928,
0.0849960297,
-0.0564526692,
-0.0060165576,
-0.0056478018,
-0.0588684902,
0.0178762153,
-0.0447734706,
0.0585005023,
-0.012725641,
-0.0036196476,
0.0615830533,
0.0463519879,
-0.0528483652,
0.0141260233,
-0.0169687048,
0.0189098548,
-0.0037495529,
-0.0330502652,
0.0785210729,
-0.111874193,
0.0022060759,
0.0027051794,
-0.0047038891,
0.0060550533,
0.04659741,
-0.0187440794,
-0.0246699434,
0.0023623158,
0.0337680206,
0.0040029543,
-0.0561845899,
-0.0935832113,
0.0188579559,
0.0170920826,
0.0027426942,
0.0270542894,
-0.0478380099,
-0.0093927365,
0.0756362379,
-0.0143257966,
-0.0100517329,
1.800233782e-34,
-0.01400158,
-0.0184762646,
-0.0332976468,
-0.0395902917,
-0.0199064482,
0.0130953509,
-0.0187584944,
0.0480221473,
-0.0398066267,
-0.0423055813,
0.0202589333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11296v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11296v2 | ChatGPT Chemistry Assistant for Text Mining and Prediction of MOF Synthesis | 2023-06-20T05:20:29 | 2023-07-20T02:20:35 | Zhiling Zheng, Oufan Zhang, Christian Borgs, Jennifer T. Chayes, Omar M. Yaghi | cs.IR | cs.IR, cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.CL, physics.chem-ph | We use prompt engineering to guide ChatGPT in the automation of text mining
of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) synthesis conditions from diverse formats
and styles of the scientific literature. This effectively mitigates ChatGPT's
tendency to hallucinate information -- an issue that previously made the use of
Large Language Models (LLMs) in scientific fields challenging. Our approach
involves the development of a workflow implementing three different processes
for text mining, programmed by ChatGPT itself. All of them enable parsing,
searching, filtering, classification, summarization, and data unification with
different tradeoffs between labor, speed, and accuracy. We deploy this system
to extract 26,257 distinct synthesis parameters pertaining to approximately 800
MOFs sourced from peer-reviewed research articles. This process incorporates
our ChemPrompt Engineering strategy to instruct ChatGPT in text mining,
resulting in impressive precision, recall, and F1 scores of 90-99%.
Furthermore, with the dataset built by text mining, we constructed a
machine-learning model with over 86% accuracy in predicting MOF experimental
crystallization outcomes and preliminarily identifying important factors in MOF
crystallization. We also developed a reliable data-grounded MOF chatbot to
answer questions on chemical reactions and synthesis procedures. Given that the
process of using ChatGPT reliably mines and tabulates diverse MOF synthesis
information in a unified format, while using only narrative language requiring
no coding expertise, we anticipate that our ChatGPT Chemistry Assistant will be
very useful across various other chemistry sub-disciplines. | [
0.0418271199,
0.0519712195,
-0.0085075954,
-0.0072894651,
-0.0071289279,
-0.0087834224,
-0.0170866381,
0.0523890182,
0.0622531995,
-0.0344063751,
-0.0117158154,
0.0485850014,
-0.0496143401,
0.0556254238,
-0.0106320251,
-0.0156359728,
0.0062434133,
-0.0489110723,
0.0120383641,
0.0062798886,
0.0244564041,
0.0506946519,
-0.0264168289,
0.0178081635,
0.0173393097,
-0.0074798712,
-0.0245349277,
-0.0112379743,
0.0278867893,
-0.0200117491,
-0.0180121455,
0.0547175966,
-0.0076451791,
0.0266888943,
0.0000024428,
-0.0589546002,
-0.0401400775,
0.0412384681,
0.0034216053,
-0.0324963927,
0.0920074806,
-0.0188688505,
-0.0316100791,
0.0358547308,
-0.0218283497,
0.001801711,
0.0435259268,
0.0041915304,
0.0283245184,
0.023448199,
-0.0158439763,
0.0116985282,
0.0294693653,
0.0427643284,
0.0324573889,
-0.0116942534,
0.0197657347,
0.0480956137,
0.0422265455,
0.0127366139,
0.0214130227,
0.030784931,
-0.0393488221,
-0.031657692,
0.023826763,
0.026600413,
-0.0504812971,
-0.0839380547,
-0.02035111,
0.0778606236,
0.0267495308,
-0.0434696972,
-0.019816082,
0.0149926962,
-0.052179344,
0.0550718904,
-0.0632175431,
0.0296974033,
-0.0335072055,
0.0092588728,
0.0081888856,
-0.0267304927,
-0.0169149246,
0.0294028651,
0.0010442724,
0.0249069575,
-0.0166784581,
-0.0136486199,
0.0113014933,
0.0034851381,
-0.0310850106,
-0.0385734104,
0.0248757657,
0.0234757885,
-0.0033974312,
0.0178285837,
0.0290124696,
0.0152326021,
0.0584739633,
-0.0534011237,
-0.0125988983,
0.0451629646,
-0.0038809187,
-0.0000825738,
-0.0283272602,
-0.0168907493,
0.0198787376,
0.0093316641,
-0.0532913432,
-0.0270940978,
-0.0881107077,
-0.0231257845,
-0.0429349281,
-0.0002416801,
-0.0027243057,
-0.0016021586,
-0.00481115,
0.0390827842,
0.0124607263,
0.0117512448,
0.0155135775,
0.0321324803,
-0.0246945936,
0.03471037,
-0.0178401768,
0.0227215197,
-0.0073357048,
-0.0046832124,
0.0008482682,
-0.0536200404,
-0.0123301409,
0.0109436465,
0.0126563562,
0.0101548946,
0.01897908,
0.0970851406,
-0.014095352,
-0.0159957875,
0.0260042343,
-0.0806960985,
0.0278662797,
-0.0187820401,
0.0098404437,
-0.0386061817,
0.0942855999,
0.0575022437,
0.0116905961,
-0.0099047367,
0.0103009818,
0.0100909583,
0.0186757632,
0.0583749451,
-0.0373944864,
-0.0511748902,
0.0512182005,
0.0102490801,
0.0154779702,
0.0080821663,
-0.0080918344,
0.0518316999,
0.0093325935,
0.0349925123,
-0.0065179956,
-0.015847085,
-0.0184369814,
-0.0236968361,
0.034028057,
0.0119884796,
-0.028981531,
0.0437698252,
-0.019837644,
-0.0283069126,
0.0121324295,
0.0111463359,
0.0183216445,
0.0481314361,
0.0472393446,
0.0377395563,
0.0193667002,
0.0136833871,
0.0579801872,
-0.0357673131,
-0.0015699858,
0.0489630252,
-0.0554417372,
-0.0431786031,
0.0360752195,
0.044356484,
0.0063449624,
-0.0248592123,
-0.0129831908,
-0.0075508477,
0.0131988302,
-0.0113595044,
0.0306010786,
-0.0022685903,
-0.0622816086,
0.0239106864,
0.0421821922,
-0.0502558947,
-0.0297671072,
-0.0113649638,
0.0149623314,
0.0889734477,
0.0716176033,
-0.0702853203,
-0.0292232744,
0.0274993274,
0.0054124328,
0.0101484284,
-0.0082046129,
-0.0141638527,
-0.0136028659,
-0.0050708982,
-0.0251405817,
-0.0145238191,
0.0204661079,
-0.0256929677,
0.0006646111,
-0.0157642625,
-0.0102133173,
-0.0026998566,
-0.0740147755,
0.0474741794,
0.031773109,
-0.0415015891,
-0.0159543734,
-0.0199727975,
0.0079691522,
0.0348902233,
-0.0029274037,
0.0339221582,
0.0691640675,
-0.0316508114,
-0.0516362414,
-0.0041411542,
0.0086570913,
-0.0405639932,
0.0059515508,
-0.0215395745,
0.0405197702,
-0.0536054671,
-0.024562262,
-0.0082365749,
0.0297940969,
-0.0098815951,
0.0265709199,
-0.0045150588,
-0.0056749857,
0.0213402472,
0.021071326,
-0.0441311412,
0.0318761654,
0.0234159008,
-0.005750644,
0.000828045,
0.0173286982,
0.0224875733,
-0.0221633259,
0.0724146068,
0.016348334,
0.0259176157,
0.0414837562,
0.0253800135,
-0.0148032308,
-0.0405295044,
-0.0373951606,
-0.0558489561,
0.000358918,
-0.0238003433,
-0.0081202323,
0.0608969368,
-0.0260132216,
0.0009242727,
0.0062259561,
0.0167226102,
-0.0405665338,
-0.0233227275,
-0.040232081,
0.0484075285,
0.0164864566,
-0.043671485,
-0.0337199271,
-0.0278794765,
-0.0461668745,
0.060223449,
0.0510539599,
-0.0157034528,
-0.0344009325,
0.0037072529,
0.0341096893,
0.0156849232,
-0.0066806618,
0.0368597209,
0.0217437614,
-0.0242677946,
-0.0008617007,
0.027784206,
0.0344657078,
0.0735574141,
0.0738982633,
0.0133565534,
-0.010890618,
-0.0040135519,
-0.0059526307,
0.0106992256,
0.0997833237,
-0.0701450929,
0.0374358855,
0.0228936113,
-0.0215594191,
0.0514443964,
-0.0270648673,
0.0166277215,
0.0197927188,
-0.0407900847,
-0.0043119499,
0.0150775267,
0.0162198804,
0.0088247294,
0.0357351638,
-0.0686251447,
0.0633763522,
-0.0406645387,
0.003432527,
-0.1008110866,
-0.0129862912,
0.0003789008,
-0.0151143437,
-0.0088647129,
0.05203861,
0.0450744703,
0.022558203,
-0.0259882454,
-0.0390741192,
0.0500659384,
-0.0086157853,
-0.0004975781,
-0.0446156859,
-0.0053542061,
0.0016016685,
-6.205e-7,
-0.0111884791,
-0.0147927972,
-0.0157694295,
0.0310463347,
0.0380978622,
-0.0395658016,
-0.0331860073,
0.0409190468,
0.0638128221,
0.0041817483,
-0.0105103469,
-0.0170663316,
-0.03237262,
0.0073981769,
0.0124039436,
-0.0267011113,
-0.0190510787,
-0.0444995165,
0.0578486025,
0.0783051848,
0.0114137242,
-0.020413328,
-0.0375473537,
-0.0107330373,
-0.0008206728,
0.0117564229,
0.0106983865,
-0.0190882646,
-0.0306732543,
-0.024534747,
-0.0064169266,
0.0608696043,
0.0573263094,
-0.0236904733,
0.0277926885,
0.0309508815,
0.0014934613,
-0.0355693735,
0.0462188497,
-0.0750466734,
-0.0057009985,
-0.0100737847,
0.0469614528,
-0.043553587,
-0.0194436945,
-0.014972169,
-0.0516825542,
0.0317993648,
-0.0234226063,
-0.0460808985,
-0.0290611349,
-0.1034223661,
-0.0451190174,
-0.0109609645,
-0.0233892892,
0.05083156,
-0.049855873,
-0.0282012187,
0.0084457407,
-0.0806080252,
-0.0634632111,
0.0235558134,
0.0093947006,
-0.0061791535,
0.0558832623,
0.0635552257,
0.0100532202,
0.0346033312,
0.0034788735,
0.0132250283,
0.0262346994,
-0.0643504933,
0.0673707575,
0.0195946824,
-0.0056507043,
-0.0243142415,
0.0389843658,
-0.0029966016,
-0.0636439472,
-0.0058643576,
0.0823584497,
-0.0465057008,
0.0193494242,
-0.0290796682,
0.0270552356,
-0.0021665574,
0.0311038941,
-0.0301194675,
-0.0087313736,
-0.0685326383,
0.0045878519,
0.026971506,
-0.0322974399,
-0.0212817844,
-0.0205078125,
-0.0468988828,
-0.0022620831,
-0.0185396802,
-0.0179106221,
0.0390504859,
-0.004650949,
-0.0373560004,
-0.0132780029,
0.0027645165,
0.0173994843,
-0.0532420091,
0.0204545707,
0.0066878935,
0.0021829593,
-0.0264725927,
-0.0786174238,
0.0373174325,
-0.0481145382,
-0.0154319443,
0.0600990355,
-0.0309689138,
-0.0145685254,
-0.0291748494,
0.0106857102,
0.0167164225,
0.0285859015,
-0.0057264934,
-0.0156977624,
0.0585984178,
0.0578067526,
-0.0456747822,
-0.0246520471,
0.0017836272,
0.0010523306,
-0.0326965936,
-0.0386753045,
-0.0463871174,
0.0390347131,
-0.0627643168,
0.0098355291,
0.002878635,
-0.0177034121,
0.0674554408,
0.0618996769,
0.0019928191,
0.0101753622,
0.0040436597,
-0.0253308732,
-0.0289593302,
0.0333066881,
0.0203081127,
-0.0387315415,
0.0486480705,
0.0194376353,
-0.0405823328,
0.0283286348,
0.0166278873,
-0.0498644412,
0.0106042856,
0.0282443408,
0.0720387399,
-0.0440735444,
0.0508175492,
0.0755235776,
-0.0177411903,
-0.0289441515,
-0.0168421473,
-0.0306440704,
0.0229740366,
-0.0312558636,
0.0239283815,
0.0000434074,
0.0616444573,
-0.0347421467,
0.0587966107,
-0.0517254807,
-0.0791840628,
-0.0774056688,
0.0247909166,
0.0421978682,
-0.0047581526,
0.0776268244,
-0.0378839634,
-0.0242799427,
-0.0272226539,
0.0512594879,
0.0184966903,
0.0043420545,
0.002998451,
0.0383361876,
-0.0113031212,
-0.0794836134,
0.0674574226,
-0.0013759731,
0.0104462309,
-0.0106291212,
-0.0756081417,
-0.0366859026,
-0.0769805461,
-0.045022577,
-0.0169469956,
-0.0197510961,
-0.037123777,
-0.0297708455,
-0.0027626471,
-0.0069283769,
0.0206228942,
-0.0521216132,
-0.0000987402,
0.0534790233,
0.0685230866,
0.0168531816,
-0.0611167885,
-0.0372233205,
-0.0321621746,
-0.0077467784,
-0.0328679048,
0.0095981667,
-6.794210411e-33,
0.0049897898,
-0.011793592,
-0.0284239948,
0.0405673422,
0.0016451814,
-0.0455031842,
-0.097367309,
-0.0300755072,
0.0290223379,
0.0568734631,
-0.0052577886,
-0.038857609,
0.0169321187,
-0.0547235273,
0.0146824708,
0.0450349376,
0.024727514,
0.0324354507,
-0.0004010763,
0.0390444882,
0.0986298174,
0.0670272261,
0.0178898089,
-0.0426602662,
-0.0077555859,
0.0342870355,
0.0000174299,
-0.0150269223,
-0.0398002379,
0.0726554915,
-0.0261866339,
0.0806495622,
-0.0029496611,
0.0174424071,
-0.0510936826,
-0.0125820721,
-0.0652406365,
-0.0100082681,
0.0073622698,
-0.0019404956,
-0.0182170253,
0.0399401411,
0.0066937627,
-0.0287276004,
-0.0220830236,
0.0168598685,
0.0656526834,
-0.0205764417,
0.0157546662,
0.0057396474,
-0.092867136,
0.0077547105,
0.0184444748,
-0.0010478756,
0.0060777678,
0.0970716402,
0.0221330542,
-0.0274569597,
0.0206220299,
0.0547120012,
-0.0115687968,
0.0256358981,
0.0507200658,
0.0526551418,
-0.0045368127,
0.0285259224,
-0.0052798926,
0.0401189588,
0.0200260505,
0.0280484632,
-0.0031744766,
0.0723466501,
0.0558846965,
0.0258435439,
0.0112166135,
0.0138566578,
-0.0885892957,
0.0042622914,
-0.015609473,
0.0099825822,
0.027064519,
0.0188484434,
0.002428167,
-0.0513842292,
-0.0079009412,
0.0811334997,
-0.0120427916,
-0.0162538569,
-0.0231795684,
0.0009536165,
-0.0807079002,
-0.0523998588,
-0.012331008,
-0.0240919795,
-0.0014841992,
0.0386024192,
-0.058345139,
0.0150613142,
-0.0354505852,
-0.0161229186,
-0.0765881911,
-0.0463448577,
0.0106111607,
-0.0470451787,
0.0316397212,
-0.0000269656,
-0.0235057287,
0.048212152,
-0.027520325,
0.0043750573,
-0.0674373433,
0.0029805715,
0.0147892954,
-0.0171760842,
-0.0216372591,
-0.0145801492,
-0.0071564359,
-0.0122093717,
0.0021848157,
0.0242541134,
-0.0027647729,
0.0208773278,
-0.0136462804,
0.0116311591,
-0.0508352704,
0.0028210927,
-0.0485484414,
-0.001975501,
0.058228638,
-0.0741263777,
-0.0181947872,
-0.0374268033,
3.255e-7,
0.0847867355,
0.0520326644,
0.0187661592,
-0.0232411753,
-0.0261090342,
0.0131716188,
0.0015386281,
0.0217544232,
-0.0149539392,
-0.0028001678,
0.017320076,
0.0162582528,
0.0471654162,
0.0650448129,
-0.0570837371,
0.0214882903,
-0.0475212783,
-0.0659351647,
-0.0673640445,
-0.0187378749,
0.0117333382,
0.0192432776,
-0.0050167507,
-0.0296918899,
0.0056841401,
-0.0321215838,
0.0066192597,
-0.0454735607,
0.0352066755,
0.0725443214,
-0.0046549155,
-0.0381946154,
-0.020527605,
0.0473043323,
-0.0337369107,
-0.0498690456,
0.0037427568,
0.025758896,
-0.0275325831,
-0.0180624984,
0.0522865206,
-0.0364365578,
0.0221537165,
-0.0295060948,
0.0099903215,
-0.0332352109,
0.0008896856,
-0.0079305163,
-0.0008896855,
-0.0160145611,
-0.0039928048,
-0.0045011388,
0.0110634416,
0.0321047753,
-0.0367894582,
0.0240425318,
0.0043854709,
-0.04384299,
-0.022036789,
-0.0046584583,
-0.0614933893,
-0.0398939997,
-0.0398295149,
-0.0378160179,
-0.0058203959,
-0.0140060298,
0.0221695621,
3.502889366e-34,
0.0533271693,
0.0151028223,
-0.0002208378,
0.0044051348,
0.038831532,
0.0106899664,
0.0279923901,
0.0253203958,
0.0176243987,
-0.0647911504,
-0.0102683445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11270v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11270v2 | Evaluating the Zero-shot Robustness of Instruction-tuned Language Models | 2023-06-20T03:48:51 | 2023-07-09T00:39:30 | Jiuding Sun, Chantal Shaib, Byron C. Wallace | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Instruction fine-tuning has recently emerged as a promising approach for
improving the zero-shot capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) on new
tasks. This technique has shown particular strength in improving the
performance of modestly sized LLMs, sometimes inducing performance competitive
with much larger model variants. In this paper we ask two questions: (1) How
sensitive are instruction-tuned models to the particular phrasings of
instructions, and, (2) How can we make them more robust to such natural
language variation? To answer the former, we collect a set of 319 instructions
manually written by NLP practitioners for over 80 unique tasks included in
widely used benchmarks, and we evaluate the variance and average performance of
these instructions as compared to instruction phrasings observed during
instruction fine-tuning. We find that using novel (unobserved) but appropriate
instruction phrasings consistently degrades model performance, sometimes
substantially so. Further, such natural instructions yield a wide variance in
downstream performance, despite their semantic equivalence. Put another way,
instruction-tuned models are not especially robust to instruction re-phrasings.
We propose a simple method to mitigate this issue by introducing ``soft
prompt'' embedding parameters and optimizing these to maximize the similarity
between representations of semantically equivalent instructions. We show that
this method consistently improves the robustness of instruction-tuned models. | [
0.0396132283,
0.0317327194,
-0.0181716774,
0.0303832479,
-0.0278232396,
0.0010466145,
0.012257304,
0.0034094367,
-0.0171208624,
-0.0880149305,
-0.0488303155,
-0.0107402382,
-0.0140414899,
-0.0171641726,
0.0371984318,
-0.0417488553,
0.0530518852,
-0.0308335163,
-0.0216886736,
0.0090414658,
0.0103790257,
0.0036563857,
0.0100051388,
0.060111247,
0.0210306868,
-0.0202691909,
-0.0046130316,
0.0408490263,
-0.0229401272,
-0.0175109897,
-0.0018275218,
0.0671843439,
0.0090833716,
0.0151301417,
0.0000020398,
-0.0292115808,
-0.0016177871,
0.0031344821,
-0.0575212575,
0.043464262,
0.0567230247,
-0.0338586308,
-0.0147897815,
0.0207169149,
-0.0086100297,
-0.0209391713,
0.0416137762,
0.0208363794,
0.0407801978,
0.0972358659,
0.0071375244,
-0.0088817859,
0.0089920033,
-0.0230129026,
0.0023364471,
-0.0548025668,
-0.0061772512,
-0.0224024672,
0.0239400901,
0.0745875835,
-0.0331498161,
0.0190383494,
0.0098763388,
0.0094184941,
-0.006287999,
0.0236059334,
-0.0292125419,
-0.0007941005,
-0.0488345847,
0.0605722815,
-0.0476290919,
-0.0095202839,
-0.004799867,
-0.0332178399,
0.0005099858,
0.0037051707,
-0.0438993312,
0.0446541309,
0.0295646526,
-0.0035468426,
0.0134182936,
0.0022294847,
0.0167627148,
0.0066892593,
0.0209116191,
0.0634105355,
0.0288445223,
-0.0356399342,
-0.0214497373,
-0.008988467,
-0.0530608334,
-0.0666530207,
-0.0347038023,
0.0268568322,
-0.0443384238,
0.0170496125,
-0.0924599245,
0.0100430772,
0.033956822,
-0.0217895713,
0.141042456,
0.0631811991,
-0.0012779423,
0.0420024544,
-0.0387236029,
0.0799681395,
0.0025301531,
0.0215442348,
-0.0363138951,
0.037768852,
-0.0920718685,
-0.0095666153,
-0.0322991274,
0.0384198204,
-0.0473157652,
-0.0311648566,
-0.0099715171,
0.0360088274,
-0.0080304714,
0.0005630131,
0.0027999431,
-0.0161260031,
-0.0490690805,
-0.003432889,
-0.0210637897,
0.0113182664,
-0.048501011,
0.0092269955,
0.0041340818,
-0.0920387879,
-0.0275552478,
0.0088029206,
-0.0042434032,
-0.0205245521,
-0.001649386,
0.075411506,
0.0073174988,
-0.0382352136,
-0.0083106672,
-0.0457473397,
-0.0237273034,
-0.0490484126,
0.0008309804,
-0.0430965126,
0.0273846034,
0.0106029697,
0.0131876208,
-0.0354277045,
0.0068437937,
0.0461184569,
-0.0536821336,
0.0775925666,
0.0197438598,
0.0167615432,
-0.0362574421,
0.0032480452,
-0.0023263667,
0.073328495,
0.0078060208,
-0.0011637796,
0.0463650599,
-0.0101618357,
0.0064249956,
0.0195445679,
-0.0035755427,
0.0260268487,
0.007358002,
0.0075872443,
0.0410151444,
0.016642075,
0.0184746347,
0.0535121709,
-0.0277279057,
-0.0138099492,
0.0519812107,
0.0363276564,
-0.0021009543,
-0.0221884605,
0.0838593096,
0.0266102385,
-0.0171630774,
0.0255347155,
-0.0642710701,
-0.0019242048,
-0.0294267368,
0.0085342759,
0.0215906799,
0.0112923691,
-0.0379336439,
-0.0202214122,
-0.0440812409,
-0.0028527724,
0.0056517744,
-0.0117079988,
-0.0102053089,
0.0180907398,
-0.0593713,
0.0313511305,
0.0441302434,
-0.0090149064,
-0.012332961,
-0.0377729274,
-0.0224544872,
0.0708593577,
0.0529337637,
0.0046080551,
-0.0248945672,
-0.0052486076,
0.060405843,
0.0465842485,
0.0646534786,
0.0019611577,
0.009469023,
-0.0481099747,
-0.0305134133,
-0.0616212711,
0.0509189069,
0.0099278986,
0.0326151848,
-0.0247811396,
0.0308606196,
0.0152207445,
-0.0441933051,
0.0399690345,
-0.0398463681,
-0.0647591725,
-0.0005859052,
-0.0024344954,
0.000534803,
0.0013830831,
-0.015089225,
0.0286123473,
0.0047326218,
-0.0200268626,
0.0110839522,
-0.0419818871,
-0.052759517,
-0.0353443995,
0.0160382837,
-0.0063399547,
0.0107258195,
-0.0115535092,
-0.0442212,
-0.0290912017,
0.0058139111,
-0.0083798738,
0.0264989231,
0.0028886299,
0.0520797595,
0.0000433388,
0.0001959586,
-0.0538303927,
0.0157528222,
0.0108469483,
0.0299109686,
0.0299028642,
0.0403326787,
0.0050022812,
-0.0548570529,
-0.0205942318,
0.0065907203,
-0.0061561284,
0.0117109325,
0.0113883689,
0.0307395998,
-0.0229054503,
-0.0428346582,
-0.0797395706,
0.0366999693,
-0.0216287356,
0.0020844925,
0.0474100821,
-0.0020783425,
-0.0124710593,
0.0021921315,
0.0019226287,
-0.0139161702,
-0.0174631085,
0.0435892455,
0.0254873522,
0.0030672669,
-0.024962306,
-0.0307247955,
-0.0173224863,
-0.0167155303,
0.0222417433,
-0.0063949698,
0.0282629412,
-0.0607922114,
0.0487572774,
-0.009105511,
-0.0029429842,
0.0111004515,
-0.0515631475,
0.0085687321,
0.0192723088,
0.0395203792,
0.0899288505,
-0.030656375,
0.0104102371,
0.0310576633,
-0.0123421801,
-0.0534850545,
0.0087846639,
-0.0251721293,
-0.0747686401,
-0.0195160639,
-0.0157390237,
0.0006845819,
0.0774673298,
0.0170568991,
-0.0018432888,
-0.0909447819,
0.0261517633,
-0.052785553,
-0.0099396287,
-0.0070637004,
0.0061162785,
-0.0047980524,
0.0061460147,
-0.0483465865,
-0.0525388755,
0.0548527129,
-0.0290876441,
0.0146567347,
-0.0354982018,
-0.0052407347,
-0.0333273485,
0.0242750496,
-0.0019332241,
0.0131122004,
0.0260064136,
-0.0035710181,
-0.054375805,
-0.000900323,
0.0339622311,
-0.0077876933,
0.0262973718,
-0.0396097489,
-0.0056490339,
-0.0166514851,
-0.0479868986,
-0.0291753765,
-0.0704533979,
-0.0067732926,
0.0395864397,
0.0580567829,
0.0084479377,
-0.0239878651,
0.0180666484,
0.0102251209,
0.0319581516,
-0.0348138735,
-0.01057244,
-0.0684093833,
-0.0265020765,
0.0487212241,
-0.0233393162,
-0.0163628366,
-0.0240454078,
0.0477831513,
0.0190255977,
0.0320351124,
0.0215293635,
-0.0252187494,
0.0282354392,
0.0187464338,
-0.0450048447,
-0.0370790176,
0.0577816218,
0.0928253531,
-0.0656791925,
-0.0293743443,
0.1237990111,
0.0374157913,
-0.0037663102,
0.0277700201,
0.0177250113,
0.0329842195,
0.0321107581,
0.0329721719,
-0.068587102,
-0.0538597703,
0.0293531008,
0.0226665623,
-0.0058818152,
-0.0064367084,
-0.0198725555,
-0.1526165307,
0.0225350391,
0.0116767306,
0.0067354217,
-0.0190273467,
-0.0384111181,
0.0101978211,
0.0059271641,
0.0398436598,
-0.0020710884,
-0.0437392518,
0.0099627133,
0.0262201838,
0.0039716051,
-0.0861727372,
0.0417749546,
-0.0512763113,
0.0768493637,
0.0848114267,
-0.0104366681,
0.0342059471,
0.0026152271,
0.033700116,
-0.025768809,
0.0298484378,
-0.0290452447,
0.0353865139,
-0.0289107971,
-0.0088589629,
0.0168824568,
0.0308047254,
-0.0239614639,
0.001562846,
-0.0047951303,
0.042436827,
0.0010754674,
-0.0066039362,
-0.0266762953,
-0.0057685953,
0.0033274335,
0.1088225991,
0.041903127,
-0.0376194194,
-0.0407371894,
-0.0453869626,
-0.0237169433,
-0.0665248185,
-0.0482031368,
0.0115992567,
-0.0377613157,
-0.005329832,
-0.0549329519,
-0.041810181,
0.0266685225,
0.0315141715,
0.0288169719,
-0.0072587696,
0.0104396744,
-0.0305511486,
-0.0092813773,
0.0134158535,
-0.060685046,
0.0246318672,
-0.0983012095,
-0.0305015389,
0.0394311212,
0.0251772068,
-0.012367106,
-0.0199778508,
-0.0775667727,
-0.077341266,
-0.0067995274,
0.0746075809,
0.0176335219,
0.0302656721,
-0.0283316392,
-0.0637023076,
0.021099817,
0.0294158179,
-0.039330326,
0.0285689104,
0.0354405753,
0.0054526017,
0.0117178811,
0.0508010723,
-0.0319589227,
0.0348970816,
0.0525791608,
0.0698048398,
-0.0155592728,
-0.0216941964,
0.0319538526,
0.0138512207,
0.0259767119,
0.0026257399,
-0.0122295236,
0.0026220544,
-0.00170951,
-0.0467527919,
-0.0211852081,
-0.0345615335,
-0.004314133,
0.0122791119,
-0.0117865782,
-0.0067006629,
0.0118871061,
-0.0412573256,
0.0614926219,
-0.057442192,
0.0065156408,
0.0023526684,
-0.008635466,
-0.0049896515,
0.027068153,
-0.0257581398,
0.0418759063,
-0.0059260218,
0.0284958053,
-0.0187806692,
0.0416151024,
0.0154733434,
0.0327969603,
-0.0471707694,
0.0352633968,
-0.056711033,
-0.0245294012,
-0.009857161,
0.0208488014,
0.0478004068,
-0.0328759886,
0.0201763064,
-0.0089443577,
-0.019770775,
-0.0290517174,
0.0133094843,
0.0269983206,
-0.0251209736,
0.0409499072,
0.0412290208,
-0.020135114,
-0.0131548475,
0.0903559253,
0.011418974,
0.0579002053,
0.0170445871,
0.0119609013,
-0.0296597239,
-0.0024855693,
0.0329642035,
0.0216705538,
0.0029246714,
0.0327863209,
-0.0552303568,
-0.0439284779,
-0.0148764551,
-0.0019765224,
0.0220024753,
-0.0163883958,
0.0298556834,
0.034480866,
-0.0000937212,
-0.025223691,
-0.0534332283,
-0.0178813562,
-0.0014677327,
-0.0156345218,
-0.0433833934,
-6.72893521e-33,
-0.0537504181,
0.0142414393,
-0.0000893753,
-0.0426154621,
0.0143271955,
0.0253989771,
-0.0269550513,
0.0081024682,
-0.0289023481,
-0.0002012957,
-0.0208665878,
-0.0092434362,
0.0147099141,
0.0160378087,
0.0086703151,
-0.0293603726,
0.0520815738,
-0.0069688484,
-0.0580623932,
-0.0024436563,
0.0119251981,
-0.0018307391,
0.0163797308,
0.0076519591,
0.0239667948,
-0.003123387,
-0.0087437807,
-0.0054432559,
0.0172767453,
0.0833167806,
-0.0085345814,
0.0408716053,
0.0219386648,
-0.0479204468,
-0.0412481911,
-0.0012563547,
-0.0367498361,
-0.038034603,
0.0430508591,
-0.0128334453,
-0.0132365422,
-0.0517086238,
0.0256593302,
-0.0261827279,
-0.0585656948,
-0.0160008222,
0.0078000464,
-0.0056041931,
-0.0259585343,
0.0196749959,
-0.0678594559,
0.0125039117,
0.0163791012,
-0.0589594916,
0.0064234491,
0.0170418657,
0.0066665104,
0.0272769816,
-0.0424197912,
0.0138542093,
0.0383437835,
0.0914190561,
0.0498168245,
0.01788559,
-0.0028530979,
0.0332659781,
-0.000490209,
0.0301012769,
0.0127335321,
0.0103891119,
0.0345063657,
0.032189697,
0.0275769308,
0.0170937292,
0.0651832595,
0.0297468174,
-0.02630811,
-0.0037424075,
0.0181780905,
0.0381661914,
0.0420957729,
0.0193961319,
-0.0804302692,
-0.0329792388,
-0.0586203374,
-0.0147622023,
-0.0351314247,
-0.0281076469,
0.0671076104,
0.0262515824,
-0.0393806323,
0.0087483469,
0.0382320099,
-0.0344570018,
-0.0112400772,
-0.0222708136,
-0.0266274307,
0.0187022928,
-0.0110099064,
0.0300779156,
-0.0651752651,
-0.0525972918,
0.0434195921,
-0.0120262168,
0.0275598299,
0.0119591681,
0.0281053614,
0.0238965079,
-0.0721648932,
-0.0164797306,
-0.0263068359,
0.002252934,
-0.017929893,
0.0107314996,
0.0397644937,
0.0322550461,
-0.0073586456,
0.0631882995,
0.0274010487,
-0.0450427271,
-0.0056515774,
-0.0135408668,
0.001698507,
0.0183592532,
-0.01346754,
0.0317256674,
-0.0328609049,
0.005517893,
-0.0107951555,
-0.0363236181,
-0.0390652716,
0.0063070161,
2.765e-7,
0.0263496712,
0.0758661032,
0.0145267863,
0.0448232703,
0.006106148,
0.0262206644,
-0.0138344951,
0.0194632169,
-0.0097270757,
-0.0193594564,
-0.0280197989,
0.0442483649,
0.0386659838,
-0.0243452601,
-0.0679452345,
0.0271941591,
-0.0413890071,
0.0578774922,
-0.0788595229,
-0.0146923829,
0.0433996283,
0.1120680273,
0.0058777798,
0.0343920365,
0.0008790694,
-0.0180025212,
0.0436642654,
-0.0167959835,
-0.017440401,
0.0315729193,
0.0108471224,
0.0467998236,
0.002109834,
0.0284203198,
-0.0306199845,
0.0158119127,
-0.0175324045,
0.0992696732,
-0.0144648235,
-0.0196601525,
-0.0068860902,
-0.0389556773,
-0.0193500295,
-0.0234359298,
0.0861208066,
-0.0708170682,
-0.0250549931,
-0.0124632558,
-0.0306034982,
0.0130244931,
0.0116996504,
-0.0140327783,
-0.050713785,
0.0111993123,
0.0409787558,
0.0166977476,
-0.0451912694,
-0.0741802901,
-0.0093957689,
0.0082190456,
-0.0108066257,
-0.0533223674,
-0.0359594338,
-0.0140651204,
0.0147679411,
-0.0802696571,
-0.0093284929,
3.165920594e-34,
0.0420597643,
0.0010987889,
0.0604453236,
0.0093948301,
0.0336886011,
0.0225621872,
-0.0290624965,
0.0065435534,
0.0474157445,
-0.0829034895,
-0.0310824607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11260v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11260v3 | A Novel Counterfactual Data Augmentation Method for Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis | 2023-06-20T03:25:51 | 2023-10-07T02:23:14 | Dongming Wu, Lulu Wen, Chao Chen, Zhaoshu Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect-based-sentiment-analysis (ABSA) is a fine-grained sentiment evaluation
task, which analyzes the emotional polarity of the evaluation aspects.
Generally, the emotional polarity of an aspect exists in the corresponding
opinion expression, whose diversity has great impact on model's performance. To
mitigate this problem, we propose a novel and simple counterfactual data
augmentation method to generate opinion expressions with reversed sentiment
polarity. In particular, the integrated gradients are calculated to locate and
mask the opinion expression. Then, a prompt combined with the reverse
expression polarity is added to the original text, and a Pre-trained language
model (PLM), T5, is finally was employed to predict the masks. The experimental
results shows the proposed counterfactual data augmentation method performs
better than current augmentation methods on three ABSA datasets, i.e. Laptop,
Restaurant, and MAMS. | [
0.0413725413,
0.049370382,
-0.0038693203,
0.0455372073,
-0.040665146,
0.0143909706,
0.0071877586,
-0.0185982939,
-0.0041167173,
-0.0469562262,
-0.0627051145,
-0.0367686525,
-0.0429221578,
0.0690873861,
-0.0147747118,
-0.0041475329,
0.0352720246,
0.0660185888,
0.0415192619,
-0.0224948116,
0.0202067867,
0.0137889851,
0.0141005358,
-0.0204956252,
-0.0061710496,
0.0022753167,
0.0065690256,
0.0286001861,
0.0509776808,
-0.0324680395,
0.052450642,
0.0031997489,
-0.0172888786,
-0.0085054738,
0.000002102,
0.0022250295,
-0.0278846826,
0.0007884561,
0.0201192256,
-0.015684234,
0.0907994956,
-0.0249575004,
-0.0015578597,
0.0150212366,
-0.0516900271,
-0.0153562706,
0.049774643,
0.1102181822,
0.0827317908,
0.0945720971,
-0.0264283456,
-0.0190193821,
-0.0235032365,
-0.0138535714,
-0.0280672312,
-0.0053832964,
0.0044231452,
-0.0281168781,
-0.0547374748,
0.023845112,
-0.0063341474,
0.0243820101,
0.0205424018,
0.0202029981,
0.0020365687,
0.0167587586,
0.0372000188,
0.0180874802,
-0.0216056444,
0.0372534208,
0.0040553329,
-0.0186131876,
-0.03694015,
-0.0649543032,
-0.0086069722,
-0.0187231768,
-0.0034343686,
-0.0100661302,
0.0444780514,
0.0586467981,
0.029931929,
0.050604634,
0.013765322,
0.0319736861,
-0.0001186096,
0.073499389,
-0.0132797426,
-0.0735224411,
-0.0115157245,
0.0463913903,
0.0050861533,
0.010236714,
0.0324976072,
-0.0119386734,
0.0225585345,
0.0119283916,
-0.0038364737,
-0.0348996408,
0.010279173,
-0.0772377402,
0.0213720519,
0.0092204949,
-0.0530675016,
0.0279293135,
-0.0106434748,
-0.0133582251,
0.0006869809,
-0.0233854111,
-0.0385254733,
0.0044555329,
0.0105994446,
-0.0078172814,
0.0078845741,
0.0393548943,
-0.0672191158,
-0.0035599861,
-0.0430239439,
-0.0334764607,
-0.0734606609,
-0.0232196804,
0.0207551252,
0.0056893616,
0.0063617053,
-0.0303879883,
-0.0120535474,
0.043479111,
-0.0477320068,
0.0520854592,
-0.0464210883,
0.0152352238,
0.008205615,
0.0363339186,
-0.0058924966,
-0.0228884015,
0.0282975715,
0.0308603067,
0.0130699333,
-0.005777908,
-0.0274601039,
-0.014006393,
-0.0065904264,
-0.0540397167,
0.0010503595,
-0.0377764553,
0.0132621378,
-0.0209430289,
-0.0123518175,
-0.015166821,
0.0268093497,
-0.0025579673,
0.0143050076,
0.0586995035,
-0.033157289,
-0.048587583,
0.0020470088,
-0.0030643889,
0.0391281582,
0.0541484728,
-0.0103031043,
0.0418825112,
0.0225329995,
0.0059192241,
0.0175670143,
-0.0023322492,
0.0470268205,
-0.0131598264,
-0.0392670184,
-0.0063140891,
-0.0646190867,
-0.0412311554,
0.0118281087,
0.0360871628,
0.0177459959,
-0.0490815639,
0.0293635838,
-0.0545737706,
-0.0550873987,
0.0331754349,
-0.0249663703,
0.0275980663,
-0.0428181775,
0.0194817185,
-0.0166683104,
0.0500301421,
-0.0714208335,
0.0025167519,
0.0013432477,
0.0022478821,
-0.0246071238,
-0.0744639933,
-0.004661167,
-0.0144643197,
0.070452489,
-0.0034597041,
0.0354984477,
0.020112507,
-0.0490956381,
-0.0725089982,
0.028161481,
-0.0669297725,
-0.0115280934,
-0.0269901026,
0.0049053449,
0.0654422194,
-0.0076803518,
-0.0391277261,
-0.0342236236,
-0.0225186609,
-0.0407310314,
0.0308256429,
0.0467933603,
0.0242959708,
-0.0168578755,
-0.0454800539,
0.012233858,
-0.0164163653,
0.0187751725,
0.030706564,
-0.0083287014,
0.0378872901,
0.0262171384,
0.0199038871,
0.0018562832,
0.0078418739,
-0.0069252946,
-0.0343080349,
0.044423271,
0.0250003859,
0.0327237658,
0.058935184,
-0.0014882552,
-0.0008319177,
0.0448200367,
-0.0359530114,
-0.0731448606,
0.0199132897,
-0.0270650871,
-0.0771400183,
0.0134865325,
-0.0340512879,
-0.0244087707,
0.0282033589,
-0.041402366,
-0.0436789989,
0.0523893423,
0.0050864434,
0.0511909984,
-0.0503836945,
-0.0009704232,
-0.0001538847,
0.0233609341,
-0.0107544865,
0.0474101081,
-0.0330201536,
0.0050100675,
-0.0477405973,
-0.0093210628,
0.0136078252,
0.008958281,
-0.0517604686,
-0.0403606854,
0.0331814736,
-0.0060665817,
0.0110026086,
-0.0071540833,
-0.0167035535,
-0.0166021306,
-0.0965544581,
0.0001769332,
-0.0041619213,
0.0250859763,
0.0343333781,
-0.0040951115,
-0.0056697861,
0.0012380334,
-0.0490851365,
-0.0314549394,
-0.009874641,
0.0261801034,
0.0093614962,
0.0390171185,
0.0345456861,
-0.0642281771,
0.0018326832,
-0.0217888746,
-0.0032097173,
-0.0006319768,
-0.0383068956,
-0.0076712873,
0.0169029478,
-0.0087246066,
0.0235614423,
-0.0191540457,
-0.0637774467,
-0.0139723606,
0.0130181424,
0.0272985715,
0.018114211,
0.0129172765,
0.0201769862,
0.0346674807,
0.0007111963,
-0.0213526376,
0.0310193133,
-0.0500936359,
0.0511020571,
0.016361434,
-0.0551653989,
-0.0062191174,
0.0440615751,
0.0107674468,
-0.0029453842,
-0.0382631533,
-0.0033313872,
-0.0225049406,
-0.0339483321,
0.0195595324,
-0.0163689554,
-0.0258220378,
0.0027790212,
0.0015111971,
-0.0126998546,
0.0653757602,
0.0042410791,
-0.0151362773,
-0.0598830543,
-0.012615256,
-0.0052662753,
0.0759951025,
-0.025501851,
0.0138911819,
-0.0103195608,
0.0277352128,
0.0094650658,
-0.027793346,
-0.0177501887,
-0.0402221829,
-0.0058144326,
0.0008762043,
-0.0247478765,
0.0236465223,
-0.0361787751,
-0.0155412648,
-0.0854771584,
-0.0150957722,
-0.0208642613,
0.0329521671,
-0.0045391731,
0.0157882757,
0.0123630259,
-0.0199897848,
-0.0165167749,
-0.0378048569,
0.0148869678,
0.0131312981,
-0.0003043871,
0.0442785583,
-0.0162265059,
0.0320728905,
0.0081364326,
-0.0105475318,
0.0113174934,
-0.0299016163,
-0.0162539631,
0.004391734,
-0.0249453224,
0.0165297333,
0.0247184131,
-0.0385739617,
-0.0710773095,
0.0339665413,
-0.0386950262,
0.0121063339,
0.0946289822,
0.0413613878,
-0.0459647514,
-0.011362372,
0.0054408191,
-0.0232874099,
0.0343779996,
0.0086742435,
-0.0406191349,
-0.0065872101,
-0.0201545563,
0.0257443432,
-0.0389738865,
0.0144500816,
-0.0184202921,
-0.1315236688,
0.0107303299,
-0.0123437829,
-0.0020670455,
-0.0755989626,
-0.0235431064,
0.013653948,
-0.0110193845,
-0.0028464017,
-0.0228022225,
0.0246579871,
0.007012716,
-0.0024744305,
-0.0210435893,
-0.0330092013,
-0.0037922228,
0.0102393841,
0.0446139388,
0.0624409281,
0.0502773449,
-0.0237295777,
-0.0415544696,
0.0437875427,
-0.0365741216,
0.0090297954,
-0.0247914586,
0.0781474411,
-0.0438166857,
-0.0212391615,
-0.0116130393,
0.0223902725,
-0.0141901355,
0.0090889707,
-0.0060310345,
0.0422821157,
-0.0125416322,
0.0109786903,
-0.0223377347,
0.0408013873,
0.0591928661,
0.0778875947,
-0.0000957636,
-0.096664995,
0.0100982562,
-0.0004239262,
0.0229844078,
-0.0537824519,
0.0064947242,
-0.0439413078,
0.0079482682,
-0.0165182482,
-0.0751074851,
-0.0700607598,
-0.0033067036,
0.0319030322,
-0.0200368334,
-0.0020991468,
-0.0116023747,
-0.035945043,
-0.0318924859,
-0.0146995084,
0.0104562528,
0.0381273441,
0.0159525778,
-0.0560183302,
0.0465933308,
-0.0353386216,
-0.0255167205,
-0.0054942151,
-0.0073112454,
-0.0540367551,
0.0291267689,
0.0528623536,
0.0043865866,
0.0184437055,
-0.0076605771,
-0.0192127749,
0.0034704602,
0.0999675095,
-0.0274604224,
0.0221660733,
0.0839780569,
0.0329551771,
0.0205375981,
0.0134183038,
-0.0045276158,
0.0465997756,
0.0594215132,
0.0075742998,
-0.0275669973,
-0.0217440091,
-0.0030329304,
-0.0088548483,
0.0782275349,
-0.0134162605,
-0.0065319412,
-0.0386156589,
0.0120868301,
-0.0661283359,
-0.0478585958,
-0.0323499478,
-0.0077010472,
0.0011074881,
-0.0161463637,
-0.0509392247,
0.0545188971,
-0.0338712335,
0.0231743492,
-0.0318810791,
0.0669329166,
0.0436644144,
0.0463417396,
-0.034777388,
0.0375425518,
-0.014661042,
-0.025202848,
0.025367666,
-0.0263207834,
0.0048054494,
0.0209109075,
0.002084245,
-0.0094513427,
-0.0533113144,
0.037495967,
-0.0228127502,
0.0690211356,
-0.0504202917,
0.0174263716,
-0.0231065731,
-0.045549266,
0.048323743,
-0.0267179944,
-0.0067369947,
0.0099547375,
0.0009425555,
0.0010125462,
-0.0258879587,
0.0471539684,
-0.0025343145,
-0.0276434254,
0.0080407429,
0.026332004,
-0.0871881396,
0.0568857528,
0.0078592366,
0.0074023143,
-0.0269303843,
-0.0077145491,
0.0607596301,
0.0343710259,
0.0073131588,
0.0386593379,
-0.0649725497,
-0.0574285351,
0.0125220967,
-0.0009048907,
0.0149340993,
0.0099293161,
0.0125421677,
0.0201192424,
0.0155386599,
0.0370519161,
-0.054943312,
0.0447592549,
-0.0151116094,
-0.0002473562,
-0.0333381817,
-6.64410419e-33,
-0.0264951624,
-0.0175761618,
-0.031842079,
-0.0177042782,
-0.0010806342,
0.0223272759,
-0.0120419329,
0.0391144045,
0.0106546953,
0.0525063947,
0.0053471685,
0.0121910935,
0.0120250247,
0.0431994349,
-0.0287094899,
0.0251670759,
0.073310174,
0.004598937,
0.0026327106,
0.027312506,
0.017513657,
0.027365366,
0.0675289631,
-0.1519283503,
0.0560466796,
-0.0399533212,
-0.0749160573,
-0.0139503665,
0.000976309,
0.0326422527,
-0.021390697,
0.059863396,
0.0202321652,
-0.0139174992,
-0.0080496017,
0.0036464846,
0.0162279215,
-0.0188469235,
0.0237486083,
0.0137617672,
-0.0182576459,
-0.0160395652,
0.0107905157,
0.003380466,
-0.0260673631,
0.0442860052,
0.0021641918,
-0.0379016623,
0.0609449446,
-0.0576041825,
-0.0586913042,
0.0213236101,
0.0276387352,
-0.0237005036,
0.0324526019,
0.0523006804,
0.027178051,
0.0212389119,
-0.0610993728,
0.0211612433,
-0.0114399781,
-0.0072538843,
0.0101829981,
0.0035524943,
0.0165863782,
0.0494665131,
0.0166020971,
0.0353095047,
-0.0063678278,
0.0374926887,
0.0107958596,
-0.0052561276,
0.0381330363,
0.089765504,
0.0486160964,
-0.0465641022,
0.0040868283,
0.0212230459,
0.0056236619,
-0.0542535149,
0.0724138618,
0.0206962898,
-0.044984363,
0.010110491,
0.004868472,
-0.0903607458,
-0.0295609795,
-0.020089291,
-0.0011211298,
0.0320541076,
-0.0584533736,
0.0205369238,
-0.0031722628,
-0.0514058769,
-0.0035575824,
0.0429232083,
-0.0413429774,
0.0180530548,
0.0238766968,
0.0110021085,
-0.0493092351,
-0.0098310281,
0.0154559584,
0.030119611,
-0.0151272314,
-0.0278858561,
0.0772817582,
0.0240098424,
-0.1130405292,
0.0054949089,
0.0005749753,
0.0490326583,
0.0077007823,
0.0370255299,
-0.0191205777,
0.0080972621,
-0.0153702665,
0.0896202177,
0.0189794656,
0.0498029813,
-0.0416732244,
-0.0261596274,
-0.0100396425,
0.031799309,
-0.0343793631,
-0.0126338275,
0.0493959747,
-0.0188996792,
-0.021579558,
-0.0423987955,
-0.022216266,
0.0108623262,
2.864e-7,
0.0456965677,
0.0372802317,
0.0122535937,
-0.0113473888,
0.0142724589,
0.0641261414,
0.0005288734,
0.004814351,
0.0212254059,
0.0098864892,
0.0357069448,
0.0092918519,
-0.0158267487,
0.0071346853,
-0.0284941103,
0.0701185763,
-0.0293886401,
-0.0020004886,
0.0046921144,
0.0244444329,
0.1050719246,
0.0998134688,
0.0559820496,
0.0121287769,
-0.016307639,
0.0579401366,
0.0461819097,
-0.0462815724,
-0.0203326754,
-0.0131183285,
-0.0425827242,
0.002355909,
-0.0272473581,
-0.0228549968,
-0.0273986198,
0.0320164599,
-0.0036912574,
0.0444448814,
0.0204517897,
-0.0788525864,
0.0076105162,
0.0434497967,
0.0054448219,
-0.0248739943,
0.0619066842,
-0.0245276559,
-0.0265019685,
-0.1299179941,
-0.0669685006,
0.0546351448,
0.0365294851,
-0.0303613748,
-0.0565681383,
0.018373359,
0.0021598991,
-0.0098525947,
-0.0676209778,
-0.071697861,
-0.0403905809,
0.0201163832,
-0.0084754694,
-0.0171953868,
-0.0165155977,
0.0586268306,
-0.0027107599,
-0.0278932434,
0.0378572084,
2.370441526e-34,
0.0720933154,
-0.0300363339,
-0.0265241154,
-0.0024559374,
0.0042263372,
0.0354400128,
-0.0489332788,
0.0091538923,
0.0347615331,
-0.0106353527,
-0.0053463466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11256v1 | GUMSum: Multi-Genre Data and Evaluation for English Abstractive Summarization | 2023-06-20T03:21:10 | 2023-06-20T03:21:10 | Yang Janet Liu, Amir Zeldes | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic summarization with pre-trained language models has led to
impressively fluent results, but is prone to 'hallucinations', low performance
on non-news genres, and outputs which are not exactly summaries. Targeting ACL
2023's 'Reality Check' theme, we present GUMSum, a small but carefully crafted
dataset of English summaries in 12 written and spoken genres for evaluation of
abstractive summarization. Summaries are highly constrained, focusing on
substitutive potential, factuality, and faithfulness. We present guidelines and
evaluate human agreement as well as subjective judgments on recent system
outputs, comparing general-domain untuned approaches, a fine-tuned one, and a
prompt-based approach, to human performance. Results show that while GPT3
achieves impressive scores, it still underperforms humans, with varying quality
across genres. Human judgments reveal different types of errors in supervised,
prompted, and human-generated summaries, shedding light on the challenges of
producing a good summary. | [
0.0258624069,
0.034242671,
0.0218042247,
-0.007846674,
-0.0199495871,
-0.0022701682,
-0.030977916,
-0.0550193153,
-0.0341713652,
-0.0414873622,
-0.0114643322,
-0.0333636105,
0.0561284274,
0.0307651721,
0.0249510724,
-0.0883318931,
0.0155112594,
-0.0240525194,
0.0239275675,
-0.0046449197,
0.0560013168,
0.0252130311,
-0.0003817504,
0.0455448143,
-0.0023278908,
-0.0117797032,
0.0009112855,
-0.0056870696,
0.050022725,
0.0143221375,
0.0385483913,
0.0214125719,
0.0195559971,
0.0204426311,
0.000001691,
-0.0657520071,
0.0017612544,
-0.0178356189,
0.0484236665,
0.0523392372,
0.0318355113,
-0.0209258962,
0.0173376556,
0.017680807,
-0.0057645729,
-0.0212402642,
-0.0091760913,
0.04958608,
0.1005046517,
0.06246645,
-0.0115530426,
-0.0418957248,
0.0320825763,
-0.0104121417,
-0.0725425929,
0.0139205465,
-0.0255964398,
0.0203759242,
0.005707867,
-0.0280587524,
0.0083828298,
0.0440032482,
0.0070402385,
-0.0104512572,
-0.0108891241,
0.0194061212,
-0.1068003178,
0.0129649034,
0.0192177258,
0.0616400056,
0.0255356822,
-0.0307192728,
0.0051566088,
0.0067277509,
-0.001960987,
-0.0317949541,
-0.0587396994,
0.0669796765,
-0.0243876949,
0.0014409864,
-0.0036918914,
0.0639530867,
-0.0163101163,
0.0485857651,
-0.0037868142,
0.0357034355,
-0.0012360527,
-0.0138334474,
-0.007603243,
0.027032325,
-0.0159707274,
-0.06555444,
0.0197266042,
0.0018355771,
-0.0252344627,
-0.0285942163,
-0.0679678246,
-0.0469595753,
0.0037155317,
-0.022377817,
0.0202120878,
-0.0008732158,
0.0016162599,
0.0224175714,
0.02741272,
0.0038992015,
0.0377626047,
0.0261380877,
-0.0500704497,
-0.0064729205,
-0.0013750502,
0.0206631906,
-0.0575731248,
0.0396403521,
-0.0242136866,
-0.0233787689,
-0.0359364115,
-0.0301610939,
-0.0055916389,
0.0165480711,
-0.0134674199,
0.0198283717,
0.0035165045,
-0.0109815076,
-0.0069360053,
0.0123463254,
-0.038888216,
-0.0063016373,
0.0486360416,
0.0138306702,
-0.0178220887,
0.0189981405,
0.0104695465,
0.0123787792,
0.0217044689,
-0.0062701451,
-0.0273734722,
-0.024329789,
-0.0003367046,
-0.0312049706,
-0.0137474751,
-0.0526676998,
-0.0369254053,
-0.0564674661,
0.0127517944,
-0.0109866802,
-0.0053680306,
0.0064809876,
-0.0175412986,
0.0238180179,
-0.0159354694,
0.0132706994,
-0.0342817307,
0.0103519922,
0.0122252041,
0.0190364681,
0.0051651653,
0.0213781931,
0.0622183233,
0.0619702749,
0.0510959364,
0.0275802929,
0.0379274972,
0.0141547136,
-0.0078003984,
0.0007464393,
0.0409025401,
-0.0211592671,
-0.0714985207,
0.0169073567,
0.042482581,
0.0868979916,
-0.0212155357,
0.0185979921,
0.0769135207,
0.0552388951,
-0.0156057319,
0.0397493877,
0.0456223376,
0.0291730464,
0.0734305531,
0.0669314936,
-0.0115733864,
0.0040846458,
-0.0246296488,
0.0886291713,
0.0817988366,
0.0375592001,
-0.0209119674,
-0.038096711,
0.0037328606,
-0.000080585,
0.0068918052,
0.0157537237,
-0.0158203188,
0.0131893679,
-0.0422726572,
0.0212876853,
0.0015452098,
-0.0651775151,
0.033557158,
-0.0079929028,
0.0231674258,
0.0504860096,
0.0384630635,
-0.0207682345,
-0.0225512944,
-0.0271696784,
0.0192238018,
0.049638059,
0.0436826833,
-0.0270521492,
0.0280711204,
-0.0281784199,
0.0020906506,
-0.0154741164,
0.0135914749,
-0.0049695862,
-0.0097161848,
-0.0079866061,
0.0212091394,
-0.0288546234,
-0.071503669,
0.0152341919,
-0.0129112629,
-0.0275510438,
-0.0369436666,
-0.0132024949,
0.0055075604,
0.0562419929,
-0.0278340615,
0.0151008023,
-0.0016095154,
-0.0129057057,
-0.0076469379,
0.0470006689,
-0.0660733059,
-0.0152566861,
0.0301036164,
-0.0760515779,
-0.0143701676,
0.0360025726,
-0.0201348066,
-0.0685036853,
0.0188346002,
-0.0645407811,
0.0306634456,
-0.055807393,
0.0111696953,
0.0226021428,
-0.015964115,
-0.0082691293,
0.0272300709,
0.0137762222,
-0.0198409613,
0.0203979835,
-0.0630359426,
0.0116747692,
-0.0133167282,
-0.0122156311,
-0.0001062704,
0.0382073522,
0.0436683781,
0.0725141391,
-0.0010549556,
-0.0393227786,
0.0090831835,
-0.0771262571,
0.0098060714,
-0.0399223119,
0.0024948807,
0.0663949475,
0.0093429796,
-0.0238280632,
0.0270213354,
-0.0429815836,
-0.0439591072,
0.0157133322,
-0.0094862785,
0.0213192217,
0.0286099948,
0.0622242615,
-0.066115886,
-0.0133695621,
-0.0076853302,
0.0308217313,
0.0048079868,
-0.0028941657,
-0.0236051995,
0.0168817099,
-0.0184732694,
-0.0232784301,
0.0079279561,
0.0037536353,
-0.0243793428,
0.0082999216,
0.0441932082,
0.0099568833,
0.0365153402,
-0.0130261853,
0.0480599403,
0.0143451858,
-0.0074396115,
-0.007197543,
-0.0133558623,
0.0025594565,
0.0254978593,
-0.0046737297,
0.0455283448,
0.0367411859,
0.0302744471,
-0.0010636378,
-0.026836887,
0.0005148929,
-0.0155070014,
-0.0009287847,
-0.0542299449,
-0.0512565374,
-0.0215378217,
0.029781526,
-0.0421308614,
0.0133150248,
0.0725181997,
-0.0535287783,
-0.0025022789,
-0.0853207856,
-0.0132254753,
-0.0470868386,
0.0282875337,
0.0071161534,
0.0312880315,
0.0091323182,
-0.0373871848,
-0.0311877895,
-0.0384698138,
0.0354208648,
-0.0028990193,
0.1158210188,
-0.0457771793,
0.0107226502,
-0.0176712647,
-0.0179182775,
-0.0074527641,
-0.0485987514,
-0.0378978737,
0.0315005518,
0.0152236708,
-0.0214540306,
-0.0392222591,
0.0036884351,
0.034929622,
0.0826420486,
-0.0380075872,
-0.0271706693,
0.0034240342,
0.0500494801,
0.0887968466,
0.0062608793,
0.0277541298,
-0.0399035364,
0.0402024724,
0.0248974208,
0.0042962702,
-0.0103606312,
-0.0244360771,
0.0002843408,
0.0053280406,
-0.0783609748,
0.016521398,
-0.0168863274,
0.0710018054,
-0.0370056443,
-0.0041741203,
0.1218019351,
0.0091693196,
-0.0430018418,
-0.0135836853,
0.043117635,
0.0389230661,
-0.0021415176,
-0.0167163648,
-0.0537187792,
-0.000912614,
0.0027590739,
0.0382276103,
0.044324182,
-0.0270778555,
-0.0141967814,
-0.0933956653,
0.0172654875,
0.0238010846,
-0.0951503515,
-0.0224808212,
0.0078612221,
0.005439145,
-0.0197882485,
0.03133481,
0.0155776637,
-0.0514122583,
0.017965354,
0.001037477,
-0.0611326545,
0.0194184463,
0.018090222,
-0.0567821078,
-0.0010980184,
0.0320221707,
0.0475159846,
-0.0211347491,
0.0057277805,
0.0420567729,
-0.0604106598,
-0.0324875675,
0.0475648046,
0.0595089979,
-0.0224885829,
0.0329161547,
-0.0429602191,
0.0463814139,
0.0260535832,
-0.0333713628,
0.0174440425,
0.001558687,
0.0064356774,
-0.0370651074,
-0.0535034835,
0.0712615326,
-0.0395675041,
0.0780864805,
0.0515280813,
0.0029027578,
-0.0139333215,
-0.0245923866,
0.0077587552,
-0.0852273256,
-0.038832847,
-0.0010863449,
-0.0440523662,
-0.0067588785,
-0.0696545318,
-0.0926574171,
0.0207925998,
-0.0169808548,
0.0092195831,
-0.0203778874,
0.0077894442,
0.008626218,
-0.03552185,
0.0258713774,
0.0039006809,
0.0019251521,
-0.0295084659,
-0.0402901992,
0.0414059646,
-0.0294013321,
-0.0210947357,
0.0284549519,
-0.0303061754,
-0.0376900844,
0.0052892799,
0.0254620817,
0.0229765438,
0.061379157,
0.0100166854,
-0.0094452649,
0.0712850615,
-0.0139728151,
0.0223952997,
0.0470411219,
0.0008685615,
0.0544904657,
-0.0223069843,
0.0166244768,
-0.0477052182,
0.0361507162,
-0.0385027863,
0.0335131064,
0.0052856449,
-0.0437469557,
0.0192575771,
0.0259438641,
0.0126821855,
-0.0543859936,
0.0173686612,
-0.0403743871,
-0.0524115488,
-0.0124292979,
-0.0194943268,
-0.0261672325,
0.0346688144,
-0.0086693866,
0.0065115122,
-0.041176606,
0.0521850027,
-0.0146440854,
0.0148624377,
-0.041550938,
-0.0106484266,
-0.0076606288,
-0.0196109451,
-0.051775042,
-0.0042277169,
-0.0692924932,
-0.034800712,
-0.0334319212,
0.0435177051,
0.0046162941,
-0.015686281,
0.0257076845,
-0.0068114572,
0.004451144,
0.0589058772,
-0.0907236636,
0.0306800213,
-0.0550244153,
0.0206760503,
0.0396018997,
-0.0723231062,
0.0947209671,
-0.0098457094,
0.0022672038,
-0.0257402044,
0.0254706349,
0.0232881941,
0.0041471231,
-0.0586305074,
0.0210219994,
0.0050858236,
0.020614095,
0.0636686087,
-0.0487641059,
0.0020319144,
0.0538189374,
-0.0256265104,
-0.0231958255,
-0.0412087366,
-0.0437734909,
0.0321158692,
0.00718304,
-0.0362296104,
-0.069653444,
-0.0203222185,
0.0219798088,
0.0366771147,
0.0302592516,
-0.0044516982,
0.033623863,
0.02699502,
0.0027063796,
0.0052694157,
-0.0373946019,
-0.0303914361,
-0.0167630017,
0.0097937249,
-0.0200720895,
-5.60555236e-33,
-0.0509219468,
0.0330185443,
-0.0360621549,
0.0275950879,
-0.0658226833,
0.0256285388,
-0.0742712468,
0.0111153563,
0.0158217568,
0.028374169,
-0.02130365,
0.0244926438,
0.0101355296,
0.0418793224,
0.0146660274,
0.0127999568,
0.0402273498,
0.0128247291,
-0.0629500896,
0.0400757939,
0.0078520505,
0.0060326052,
0.0418143272,
-0.0455559567,
0.0366151705,
-0.033793252,
-0.0438277684,
-0.0360738337,
0.0225872379,
0.0131253535,
0.0127891963,
0.0380029082,
0.0203002803,
-0.0033848109,
-0.0531920977,
-0.0119117117,
-0.0689588413,
-0.0317574441,
0.0558454692,
-0.0303473175,
-0.0343413055,
-0.0241531637,
0.0276676863,
-0.0309726819,
-0.0018506572,
-0.0545914285,
0.0661722571,
-0.0400735438,
0.0110021392,
-0.1107293591,
-0.0381780379,
0.0063344687,
-0.0312339868,
-0.0249317437,
0.014462091,
0.0574829169,
0.0084205512,
-0.0024985133,
-0.0425040424,
0.0578942262,
0.0293560214,
0.0191638079,
0.028784724,
-0.0148862842,
-0.031135112,
0.059025988,
-0.0180878341,
-0.0207311995,
-0.0296194926,
0.0417907126,
0.002846299,
-0.006066944,
-0.0042286464,
0.0386578217,
0.0342373922,
0.0391174741,
0.004799407,
0.1068616062,
-0.0121490601,
0.0092821168,
0.0131029282,
-0.032967031,
-0.0270751268,
-0.0204643123,
-0.0082056895,
0.0019542635,
0.0033586505,
-0.0029951308,
-0.0184520967,
-0.0055476227,
-0.0176119115,
-0.0067752246,
-0.0069653094,
-0.0384667255,
0.0278786048,
-0.0076610735,
-0.0500896312,
0.0178349614,
0.0005351045,
0.0157911517,
-0.0224925373,
0.0447912961,
0.0141479792,
0.0550508983,
0.0165763795,
0.0094328774,
0.0666956753,
0.051872652,
-0.0488416888,
0.0179222953,
0.0037074548,
0.0156302005,
-0.046356678,
0.0006478995,
-0.0122238332,
0.0284002256,
0.0027607218,
0.0345670022,
-0.0172720142,
0.004147632,
-0.0144010363,
0.0173777752,
0.032196153,
0.0354628339,
-0.0094959056,
0.0347225107,
-0.006407768,
-0.0320667364,
0.0337505937,
-0.0413429588,
-0.0148477256,
-0.0314517654,
2.272e-7,
0.0404344089,
0.0248094965,
0.0715587363,
0.0081443526,
-0.0402177311,
0.0141438609,
-0.015631225,
0.0472978204,
0.0243617967,
0.0090866052,
0.0480144806,
0.0234612841,
0.0496713668,
0.0312985182,
-0.115438804,
-0.0139928684,
-0.0892349258,
-0.0348505713,
-0.0456729718,
-0.0257549342,
0.079613097,
0.0472310372,
-0.0075192563,
-0.0190351345,
0.0054213889,
-0.0231168866,
0.0223268494,
-0.0113718994,
-0.0407898203,
0.0085601341,
0.0480777808,
0.0244642068,
-0.0199625939,
-0.0311598256,
-0.0129683241,
-0.0174417216,
0.0603313521,
0.0274935849,
0.0164493378,
-0.037567392,
-0.0104658697,
-0.0130295306,
0.0357403494,
-0.0101121934,
0.0420689434,
-0.00794507,
0.0038462204,
-0.0351635143,
-0.057856869,
0.0148796672,
0.0005569007,
-0.0098117059,
-0.0567818396,
0.0460752696,
-0.0010552355,
-0.0023511152,
0.0036182341,
-0.0760256648,
-0.0658151358,
0.0559974276,
0.0052446527,
-0.0200443957,
0.0194838252,
0.0000820289,
-0.0122655509,
-0.1138872281,
-0.0034259527,
2.161715055e-34,
0.108993277,
-0.0095400885,
-0.0086208554,
-0.0196667705,
0.0156165203,
-0.0179492533,
0.0347524434,
-0.0296353325,
0.010027864,
-0.0299946032,
-0.0191114768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11252v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11252v1 | HK-LegiCoST: Leveraging Non-Verbatim Transcripts for Speech Translation | 2023-06-20T03:09:32 | 2023-06-20T03:09:32 | Cihan Xiao, Henry Li Xinyuan, Jinyi Yang, Dongji Gao, Matthew Wiesner, Kevin Duh, Sanjeev Khudanpur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We introduce HK-LegiCoST, a new three-way parallel corpus of
Cantonese-English translations, containing 600+ hours of Cantonese audio, its
standard traditional Chinese transcript, and English translation, segmented and
aligned at the sentence level. We describe the notable challenges in corpus
preparation: segmentation, alignment of long audio recordings, and
sentence-level alignment with non-verbatim transcripts. Such transcripts make
the corpus suitable for speech translation research when there are significant
differences between the spoken and written forms of the source language. Due to
its large size, we are able to demonstrate competitive speech translation
baselines on HK-LegiCoST and extend them to promising cross-corpus results on
the FLEURS Cantonese subset. These results deliver insights into speech
recognition and translation research in languages for which non-verbatim or
``noisy'' transcription is common due to various factors, including vernacular
and dialectal speech. | [
0.0017292232,
0.0376956537,
-0.0064693619,
0.0412115864,
-0.0316262022,
0.001584789,
0.0350531377,
-0.000283791,
-0.0513304137,
0.0118902158,
-0.0906131119,
-0.0403207056,
0.0584435686,
-0.0703162402,
0.0069148052,
-0.0487848744,
0.0402311273,
-0.0005089261,
0.0169666503,
0.0152764861,
0.0231731385,
0.011174663,
-0.0059013707,
0.0154818036,
0.0282612648,
-0.0284815133,
-0.0007845493,
0.083921887,
0.0523580089,
-0.0092636067,
-0.0314700566,
-0.0037783091,
0.007354944,
0.0728457421,
0.0000015775,
-0.0358939022,
-0.0403887555,
0.0062290458,
-0.0274325907,
0.0384202711,
0.0227688439,
-0.0154288188,
-0.0129190134,
0.0464105718,
-0.0048384778,
-0.0299846046,
0.0566450916,
0.0269861687,
0.020483546,
0.0771089196,
-0.0254354738,
-0.0332611725,
-0.0330110341,
-0.0405824222,
-0.0284804497,
-0.0142998043,
-0.0385341048,
0.0035814822,
-0.0205627549,
-0.0409689844,
-0.021824535,
0.0432709977,
-0.0454089083,
-0.020524079,
-0.0296598934,
-0.0404037461,
-0.0863306299,
-0.0231955107,
0.003168243,
0.0638216957,
-0.0179114733,
-0.0129491361,
0.0061374074,
0.0048298836,
-0.0014856603,
-0.0044431482,
-0.0193370003,
-0.0005884469,
0.0234835874,
-0.0143731367,
-0.0029147223,
0.0224842727,
0.0245173667,
-0.0539526828,
-0.0321779437,
-0.0361519307,
0.0382867083,
-0.0383543819,
-0.0145835923,
-0.0070926715,
0.0074808993,
0.0069153016,
0.034804333,
-0.0373841822,
0.0188313499,
0.0095915487,
0.0174791105,
-0.014641094,
-0.0300659854,
-0.0447383597,
-0.0358433239,
0.0682928264,
-0.0308826864,
0.019540932,
0.0292309988,
0.0261450652,
-0.0402019583,
0.0199652053,
-0.1040950865,
-0.0183586515,
0.0045330129,
0.0289370734,
-0.0396506824,
-0.0187373143,
-0.0384252556,
-0.0158476233,
-0.0119491937,
-0.0054366724,
0.0214838479,
0.0245919637,
0.0218171719,
-0.0509867035,
-0.0676448122,
-0.0091837924,
0.0327844024,
0.0321612507,
0.0139845079,
0.0375276394,
-0.0335220918,
-0.0341267399,
-0.0545098186,
0.0613003969,
0.0149214389,
-0.0271440335,
-0.0169208162,
0.0339347906,
-0.0138987321,
-0.0217472035,
0.0059117679,
0.009699191,
-0.0649039596,
-0.0412783027,
-0.0056455471,
-0.0378828235,
0.056368582,
-0.0225180089,
0.0382440649,
0.0217890162,
-0.0176109821,
-0.0192851219,
0.0447959788,
0.0529229529,
0.0172802936,
0.0223869886,
0.0028621594,
-0.0079395929,
0.0098293973,
0.0523878559,
0.0591294952,
-0.03463009,
0.0323693529,
-0.0355058312,
-0.0441047549,
0.0729395375,
-0.0065056453,
0.031632442,
-0.0797148943,
0.0160679817,
0.0471128672,
0.0339184068,
0.0089541022,
0.0396305583,
-0.0039821421,
-0.0089169387,
0.0164953507,
0.0389167368,
0.0180929024,
-0.0033728511,
0.0170098674,
0.006836053,
-0.0143072167,
0.0308019482,
0.0037887476,
-0.0041177166,
0.0428025201,
0.0180857833,
0.0257426798,
0.0225352738,
-0.0309434161,
-0.0004867819,
-0.0506698228,
-0.0243186988,
-0.0025513999,
0.0005133309,
-0.0080771623,
-0.0153888259,
-0.0008325278,
0.0349473804,
-0.0310294181,
-0.0596660599,
0.0398235433,
-0.0129318768,
-0.0384231247,
0.0624316372,
0.02034254,
-0.0189595595,
-0.0188039988,
-0.0389545709,
-0.0314300433,
0.0662930235,
0.0501581356,
-0.0128359618,
0.0486788601,
-0.0717192516,
0.007928458,
0.0612533577,
0.0008356229,
-0.0149897644,
-0.0141474586,
0.0473876558,
0.0177511442,
-0.063280873,
-0.0007206944,
-0.0067200102,
-0.037271332,
-0.0218895525,
0.0335949808,
0.0090557989,
0.0702633783,
0.0521907248,
-0.0454924554,
0.0197627414,
0.0256648399,
-0.0186873078,
0.0125930654,
0.1234799474,
0.0028484385,
-0.077498965,
0.0294175837,
-0.0144931246,
0.0061021303,
0.0132563813,
-0.0000710164,
-0.0929768384,
-0.023205515,
0.0147539293,
0.0935815722,
-0.0570355617,
0.0695143715,
0.0132925147,
0.0214254707,
-0.0073852441,
-0.0157959051,
0.0266389884,
-0.0124534508,
0.0255320333,
-0.0067727407,
0.026897585,
-0.0544975176,
-0.0374605134,
0.0313543752,
0.0190856438,
0.0382249989,
0.0032344684,
-0.041027382,
-0.0007016886,
-0.0243664309,
-0.0798441023,
0.0347133242,
-0.0445412844,
0.0385382362,
0.025447635,
0.0317230187,
-0.0067863911,
0.0000375889,
-0.0260055102,
0.0181515254,
-0.0163996331,
0.0034355468,
-0.0426252857,
-0.0225710087,
-0.0031820647,
-0.020665545,
0.005078807,
0.0368023999,
-0.0107050808,
-0.0217288155,
-0.0012841807,
-0.0330906659,
-0.0082164118,
0.0128891831,
-0.0112980362,
0.0110267801,
-0.0312337484,
-0.037796434,
-0.0040591173,
0.0322876237,
0.0123038441,
-0.00637348,
-0.0146650812,
-0.0212454256,
-0.0172779895,
-0.0349053107,
-0.0011722938,
0.0217764936,
-0.0334405191,
-0.0259344131,
0.0184698086,
-0.0100914733,
0.0359634608,
0.0591504537,
0.000134303,
-0.0732655004,
-0.094768852,
-0.0119364364,
0.0034911088,
0.0138558252,
0.010880582,
-0.0402199253,
0.0053152167,
-0.0155667756,
-0.0336411558,
0.0344874561,
-0.0834633633,
-0.038981732,
-0.0533614904,
-0.0154619906,
-0.0212195069,
0.0337932743,
-0.0539969578,
-0.0035352558,
-0.0410149693,
-0.0604104921,
-0.0209843274,
0.0192637146,
-0.0049394406,
-0.0289316904,
0.0358342603,
-0.0246469174,
0.0040167789,
-0.0288638696,
-0.0245809257,
-0.0029207722,
-0.0427945778,
-0.0065725064,
-0.0022279536,
0.0126800621,
-0.0412981957,
-0.0133920694,
0.0529597588,
-0.011395066,
0.051143501,
-0.0021770082,
0.0584830455,
-0.0104418229,
0.0497527383,
-0.0079532871,
0.0326900408,
0.0120819071,
-0.0303042699,
0.0865962803,
-0.0208322443,
0.0625999123,
0.0260836631,
0.0124907345,
-0.0536856353,
0.0266449023,
0.003264742,
-0.0475300327,
-0.0101109836,
0.0606308505,
-0.0056750365,
0.0032225302,
0.119551748,
-0.0053257784,
-0.0338794366,
-0.0135301528,
0.0020763075,
0.0335504264,
0.0110647818,
-0.0323042981,
-0.0893775076,
-0.0150255384,
0.0530918241,
0.0501666181,
0.06188526,
0.0447237305,
-0.0259699523,
-0.0931908414,
0.0568035915,
0.0730052441,
-0.0442087464,
-0.0193381645,
0.0021794317,
-0.0335182995,
-0.0379721671,
0.0453632399,
0.017091712,
0.0022064524,
-0.0188616514,
0.0214562826,
0.0126345018,
-0.01729949,
-0.0029213149,
-0.0465083085,
0.0774751976,
-0.0005302919,
0.0305742882,
-0.0017074097,
-0.0212073289,
0.0435885265,
-0.0595758371,
-0.022095602,
0.0127560571,
-0.0152619733,
0.0092807543,
-0.0041170283,
0.0399932973,
0.0264175646,
-0.0249058139,
0.024150867,
0.0563869104,
0.0227283817,
-0.0247783177,
0.0486339144,
0.0459860414,
0.052867122,
-0.0092896419,
0.0696644485,
-0.0033434159,
-0.0203877445,
0.0428964011,
0.030747097,
-0.0195291415,
-0.0226287246,
0.023441758,
0.0263597555,
-0.0395070463,
-0.0157703962,
-0.0793442354,
-0.0192929097,
-0.0371762663,
0.0469308458,
0.0518702529,
0.0089293187,
0.0220902618,
0.0300036967,
-0.0225779619,
0.0073178248,
-0.0133110201,
0.0157176368,
-0.0463604517,
0.0030050988,
0.0223327372,
-0.0484659262,
0.0252069291,
0.0115463715,
-0.0614978597,
-0.0664838105,
0.0025561189,
-0.0313172638,
0.0125325462,
0.0538197793,
-0.0281081926,
0.0512081236,
-0.0410402827,
-0.0356462859,
-0.0172684025,
0.0207456648,
0.0273682233,
-0.0050981166,
-0.0361863934,
0.0271076001,
-0.0203265827,
-0.0050013387,
-0.0210177656,
0.0213281717,
-0.0165712647,
-0.0526650734,
-0.0203431733,
0.0280055329,
0.0582313873,
-0.0248227585,
0.0065957513,
-0.0204480011,
0.0373353474,
0.0015626884,
0.0157085322,
-0.0224299841,
-0.0498072878,
0.0689359605,
-0.0031811674,
-0.0195901413,
0.0170427784,
-0.0464348271,
-0.0309758969,
-0.025434006,
0.0117779663,
-0.0338044614,
0.0195031278,
0.002105935,
0.0109503241,
-0.0062955725,
0.0618979447,
-0.0071468535,
0.0350360274,
-0.0065650707,
0.0406950228,
-0.0215810724,
0.0582934581,
0.0483086705,
0.0047153202,
-0.0370587297,
-0.0024052227,
-0.0083669797,
-0.0317718051,
0.0496783778,
-0.0247966386,
0.0964770913,
-0.0014155768,
0.0207662452,
-0.0309042335,
0.024402583,
-0.0193489548,
0.0024868425,
-0.0185020249,
-0.0142984502,
-0.035273958,
0.0470946953,
0.0367603451,
0.0016662115,
0.0152319446,
0.0161149278,
0.0224149674,
-0.0077066789,
-0.0623448603,
0.0299492292,
-0.0165824555,
-0.038603358,
-0.0446363427,
-0.0230221413,
-0.025236845,
0.0001034764,
0.0212702602,
0.0234378651,
0.0068511502,
-0.0249198712,
0.0315388814,
-0.0661506578,
-0.0002980146,
-0.0161365252,
-0.0222300012,
0.0073253014,
0.0148491384,
0.0179786459,
-5.387352323e-33,
-0.0221713297,
0.0267445091,
-0.0028519994,
-0.0025378473,
-0.0654171631,
-0.0116128242,
-0.0070816134,
0.0015733893,
0.0130364951,
-0.0453163311,
-0.0055530411,
0.0423872024,
0.0262638908,
0.0142231351,
0.0290555973,
-0.0042967629,
0.0744385496,
-0.0191763192,
-0.0254964791,
0.0106399944,
0.0580350682,
-0.0003426061,
0.0275034662,
-0.0562030002,
0.0102486704,
-0.0125005553,
-0.0280179475,
0.017505236,
-0.0051597576,
0.0212298706,
0.0200605299,
-0.0149530014,
-0.0022831203,
0.0023284645,
-0.0309443548,
-0.0181833021,
-0.1021767855,
0.0707863495,
0.0538315587,
0.0843847319,
0.0728130192,
-0.0010471428,
0.0096688177,
-0.029698547,
-0.0061245901,
-0.01675478,
-0.0256436486,
-0.0566968657,
0.0042145234,
-0.0028572984,
-0.0410655104,
0.0394888446,
-0.0342777669,
-0.0031417273,
0.0545810014,
0.0717956424,
-0.0124789206,
-0.0091954516,
-0.0949866399,
0.0134143978,
-0.0358749591,
0.0399631262,
0.034901347,
0.0366861261,
-0.0108049987,
-0.0110538378,
0.0481114015,
-0.0628633127,
0.067215234,
-0.0009468279,
0.0270483252,
0.0050025396,
-0.0067880768,
0.0149858231,
0.0429072976,
-0.0339593254,
-0.0273169465,
0.0012263386,
-0.0133612696,
-0.0498379022,
0.0095582996,
0.0625253394,
-0.0141149843,
-0.0052520465,
-0.0197124612,
-0.0256383363,
0.0194304697,
0.0164710172,
0.0084329369,
0.0155388769,
-0.0047692079,
-0.026488414,
0.1136467233,
0.0011033906,
0.0395947844,
-0.0229738615,
-0.0165044609,
-0.0115355644,
-0.0631687641,
0.055811312,
-0.0414362662,
-0.0576894023,
0.0523959398,
0.008460681,
0.0022339688,
-0.0219114553,
0.0368582904,
0.0300583635,
-0.0715188384,
0.0035748112,
0.0140085202,
-0.0262892954,
-0.0427633375,
0.0332868733,
0.0205204766,
0.0029612118,
0.0460583828,
0.0500707217,
0.0205491669,
-0.0039303149,
-0.0102038439,
0.0214553531,
-0.0109428558,
-0.0218808595,
-0.0502505824,
0.0440449603,
0.0329029076,
0.0012691577,
0.0376979299,
-0.0308098383,
0.0112730386,
0.0081611332,
2.345e-7,
0.0121808024,
-0.0365838148,
0.0660949126,
-0.032397747,
0.0129869888,
-0.0103031378,
-0.0411414132,
0.0285792165,
-0.0240717269,
0.0555570088,
0.0589040071,
-0.011701473,
0.1490849257,
0.0229041465,
-0.0936997086,
-0.0053768526,
-0.0611899681,
0.0060056932,
-0.0255772173,
0.0168378055,
0.0035675378,
0.0964023769,
-0.0545613654,
0.0365099497,
0.0219853595,
-0.0250942986,
0.0364723802,
-0.0072461958,
-0.0226553828,
-0.0180652197,
0.0042123441,
0.0003900731,
-0.0642920509,
-0.004409221,
-0.0489033982,
0.0810079575,
0.0354775861,
0.0931852683,
0.0105061326,
-0.0539482832,
-0.0147779472,
0.0114900032,
-0.0317299366,
0.0018434057,
0.0276400801,
0.0538923815,
-0.0125493351,
-0.0013231554,
0.0111284386,
0.0113601889,
0.0269806422,
-0.0032236739,
0.0153984251,
0.0173282586,
0.0542373732,
0.0032084258,
-0.0306867026,
-0.0197464488,
-0.0614508316,
0.0051071383,
-0.0562981665,
-0.0563968159,
0.0290720388,
0.0072436137,
0.0027931037,
-0.0238653533,
-0.0206027478,
1.761387482e-34,
0.0227398016,
-0.0270908717,
-0.0067697628,
0.0046129562,
0.0108112656,
-0.0731329769,
0.0009356679,
0.0078579746,
-0.0226468835,
-0.0463118218,
-0.0293257684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11232v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11232v2 | Eight challenges in developing theory of intelligence | 2023-06-20T01:45:42 | 2024-06-21T08:26:30 | Haiping Huang | q-bio.NC | q-bio.NC, cond-mat.stat-mech, cs.AI, cs.CL | A good theory of mathematical beauty is more practical than any current
observation, as new predictions of physical reality can be verified
self-consistently. This belief applies to the current status of understanding
deep neural networks including large language models and even the biological
intelligence. Toy models provide a metaphor of physical reality, allowing
mathematically formulating that reality (i.e., the so-called theory), which can
be updated as more conjectures are justified or refuted. One does not need to
pack all details into a model, but rather, more abstract models are
constructed, as complex systems like brains or deep networks have many sloppy
dimensions but much less stiff dimensions that strongly impact macroscopic
observables. This kind of bottom-up mechanistic modeling is still promising in
the modern era of understanding the natural or artificial intelligence. Here,
we shed light on eight challenges in developing theory of intelligence
following this theoretical paradigm. Theses challenges are representation
learning, generalization, adversarial robustness, continual learning, causal
learning, internal model of the brain, next-token prediction, and finally the
mechanics of subjective experience. | [
-0.0159183163,
0.0773463622,
-0.0473783389,
0.005707989,
-0.0333622135,
0.0046815486,
0.0058246967,
-0.0083813583,
-0.0103467135,
-0.0023340022,
-0.0000015644,
-0.0564129464,
-0.0127193667,
0.0086783897,
0.0692454651,
-0.0681606904,
0.0211654287,
-0.0278082043,
-0.0013787864,
-0.0454122201,
-0.0732013434,
-0.0913293809,
-0.0045173662,
-0.0209067725,
-0.0330706798,
-0.01278817,
-0.0007849339,
-0.0650118515,
-0.0358635075,
-0.0142353335,
-0.0397738032,
-0.0177511834,
0.0221580956,
0.0862272978,
0.0000021197,
-0.0314139985,
0.0246388279,
0.0258924644,
-0.0459325649,
-0.0234944951,
-0.0106571196,
0.0099169072,
-0.0270359721,
-0.0329891108,
-0.0118885869,
0.0215096194,
0.0336875804,
0.0419018231,
-0.0229034908,
0.0378664322,
-0.0071520321,
-0.0673336461,
0.0835256055,
-0.0312567428,
0.0476857536,
0.0161968805,
0.0091588162,
-0.0265652779,
0.0022148376,
-0.0362667404,
-0.026830988,
-0.0098240515,
0.072436519,
0.033462286,
0.0190812051,
0.0113282781,
0.0493765287,
0.0237950012,
0.015131685,
0.0366942436,
-0.0201855712,
0.0233873464,
-0.0500118434,
0.0286091566,
0.0020465755,
-0.0257328879,
-0.0717374757,
-0.0071168612,
0.0433847681,
0.0002845275,
-0.0359247811,
0.0304911789,
0.0466078073,
0.0205909647,
-0.0369235091,
0.0427275449,
0.0197370686,
-0.0232718252,
-0.0062384666,
0.0002976273,
-0.0333341733,
0.0200337097,
-0.0445086285,
0.0164461304,
0.0075962939,
-0.0418354385,
0.0073773945,
0.0048400457,
-0.0260141697,
-0.0376109779,
0.0562283993,
0.025941845,
0.0044054748,
0.0200638752,
0.0077789896,
0.0804461092,
-0.056855537,
0.0541112237,
-0.045119565,
0.0477880128,
-0.0578354076,
-0.0026281613,
0.023640167,
0.0714965388,
0.0466967188,
-0.0029582574,
-0.0147539936,
0.0159973092,
-0.0401307419,
-0.0232217461,
-0.0847083032,
0.0123908101,
-0.0015936183,
0.0158659872,
-0.0398624949,
-0.0376775563,
-0.0382024832,
0.0275719408,
0.0040780045,
0.0021139376,
-0.0205507837,
0.00246587,
-0.013273512,
0.0085634599,
0.0210195649,
0.116522409,
0.0249516293,
0.0000931183,
0.0010586799,
-0.0058492837,
-0.0131687988,
-0.0305372123,
0.058404576,
-0.0274940822,
-0.0160800833,
-0.0196519047,
-0.0068249698,
-0.081914857,
-0.0345928855,
-0.0396508351,
-0.0302441008,
0.0502699539,
-0.0096782641,
-0.0156114195,
0.0188919902,
0.0279558077,
0.0268291943,
0.0113272304,
0.0270413086,
-0.0043007326,
0.0174274817,
0.0045687594,
0.0262803994,
0.0134387398,
0.0210737903,
-0.0195851624,
-0.0268804375,
-0.0486720502,
-0.0088326009,
0.0448295213,
-0.0223161504,
0.0413737223,
-0.013490404,
-0.0083128763,
0.0349765457,
0.0468290932,
-0.0270650852,
0.0808580741,
0.0547002666,
-0.0585144423,
0.0687467307,
0.0797365382,
-0.0812960193,
0.0488703437,
-0.0408609919,
-0.0117910495,
0.0012377432,
-0.0178692341,
-0.0524139181,
-0.0513745435,
0.0339334942,
-0.0183455013,
0.0456218421,
-0.0227099266,
0.0681114867,
-0.0199095849,
0.0124706114,
-0.0479849167,
0.0002857561,
0.0230450556,
-0.0072556669,
-0.0423129424,
0.0253132898,
0.0002177462,
0.0209578872,
-0.039197132,
-0.0059957183,
0.008772973,
0.0150965629,
0.0006990509,
0.0488957055,
-0.0062505789,
-0.0087563088,
0.0158658233,
-0.0063509275,
-0.0453003794,
0.0198946893,
-0.0138391815,
-0.0629412383,
-0.0211017821,
-0.0177155435,
0.0516115054,
-0.0495961159,
0.0130160879,
-0.029112773,
-0.0352661833,
-0.0052346531,
-0.0173886437,
0.0672117993,
0.0164976045,
-0.0088672331,
0.0396333337,
0.0454758853,
-0.0447502956,
0.0125333918,
0.0197289325,
-0.0125797475,
0.0650780573,
0.0198569596,
-0.0486131348,
0.0453820303,
0.0305834953,
0.0179716032,
-0.025473455,
0.0844894052,
-0.060881339,
0.0358317867,
0.0177364256,
0.0326656327,
-0.0474089496,
0.0447888784,
-0.0152178621,
0.038259577,
0.0020451185,
0.0131368889,
-0.0063912743,
-0.0147647895,
0.0482053161,
-0.0543892384,
-0.0101531399,
-0.0039404277,
-0.0150803262,
-0.0015463808,
0.0367519632,
-0.0112809716,
0.0262525789,
0.0206490718,
-0.0237788428,
-0.0589311682,
0.0007309149,
0.0067796954,
-0.03874778,
-0.0183239561,
0.0196165536,
0.0202882383,
0.0149557153,
0.019718647,
0.0222658124,
0.0055793817,
0.0255447589,
0.0124287028,
-0.0258567836,
-0.0341754481,
-0.024235595,
-0.0519414172,
0.0423598215,
0.0153577104,
0.0332404189,
0.01555207,
-0.0153635126,
-0.0205562171,
0.0433404855,
-0.0230043642,
-0.0366465524,
0.0432849005,
-0.0117629105,
0.0178925712,
0.0845997781,
-0.0195579231,
0.0542909466,
0.0114210062,
0.0414464995,
-0.0013426492,
0.0067961952,
-0.0389660001,
0.0145722879,
-0.0130940657,
-0.0158656426,
-0.0172926281,
0.0917356312,
0.0015882486,
-0.0264651347,
-0.0208960678,
0.1112655848,
-0.0288528204,
-0.0437421277,
-0.0057148677,
-0.0193050541,
0.0089576226,
0.0156650804,
-0.0449354611,
-0.0324202962,
0.0586486012,
0.0149301896,
0.0070961858,
-0.0023514768,
-0.0002103341,
0.019330522,
0.0721125677,
0.0497631021,
-0.0112135634,
-0.0104911197,
0.0367567837,
-0.0768289417,
-0.0036089302,
-0.0086789858,
0.0091610318,
-0.0369331092,
-0.0460598432,
-0.0163340475,
0.0146743013,
-0.0190564021,
-0.0299834777,
0.0230883136,
-0.0103603257,
0.0521516539,
0.0208606254,
-0.0097025568,
-0.0208422355,
-0.0032754391,
0.064561151,
-0.0094460053,
-0.0185269509,
-0.0140691241,
-0.0091439458,
-0.0210676529,
0.0240432937,
-0.0195887107,
0.0752340257,
-0.0400218479,
0.054196924,
-0.0003583665,
-0.0017765913,
0.0677987337,
-0.0091805421,
0.0566246696,
0.0016054332,
0.0091149108,
-0.0302485563,
0.0208399966,
-0.0048978846,
-0.0056187534,
-0.0238259751,
0.041260235,
-0.0032622335,
0.0086982818,
0.0565284491,
0.0065119294,
-0.0795394406,
0.0381444283,
0.0264521204,
-0.0085172513,
0.0259724222,
0.0034468547,
-0.0352986641,
-0.0319556482,
-0.0579290949,
0.0393737815,
-0.0516734906,
-0.02722992,
0.0244869255,
-0.040094763,
-0.0499645211,
0.0170277264,
-0.0269768052,
0.0240045562,
-0.0019002699,
0.0056210374,
0.0206207167,
0.0073629203,
0.0088877659,
-0.0046246536,
-0.0149337621,
0.0172036551,
-0.0213627778,
-0.0056905337,
0.0602062419,
0.0040087043,
-0.0662621707,
-0.0277297962,
0.0204594787,
0.0368559398,
0.0233881399,
0.0272212029,
0.0266290233,
0.0401374064,
-0.014800298,
-0.0339350291,
0.0303756278,
0.0007519516,
0.0068070022,
-0.0159544479,
0.0601967499,
-0.0280815195,
-0.0362973623,
-0.0248487219,
-0.0318433419,
-0.0487640649,
0.051129166,
0.0042178291,
-0.062586762,
-0.0445774458,
-0.036827568,
0.0109887011,
-0.0262313802,
-0.1015541703,
0.0104700783,
0.0667724386,
0.0043092309,
-0.0296502803,
-0.0130644171,
-0.0158206876,
0.043239817,
0.0311704315,
-0.0704259202,
-0.0371692926,
-0.0296743605,
-0.0218901038,
-0.0055332528,
0.0271056518,
-0.0335144214,
-0.031864401,
-0.0211225301,
0.0322435983,
-0.1034561098,
-0.0022361085,
-0.007648549,
0.0264638271,
-0.0368016809,
0.0321504325,
0.0481541865,
0.0242837276,
0.0296879709,
-0.0084694317,
-0.0689241514,
0.0718889982,
-0.0079412051,
-0.0366451703,
0.0056908247,
0.0393021405,
0.0165232606,
0.0143882697,
0.0212959722,
-0.0263260901,
0.0350336954,
0.0201707557,
-0.0330431722,
0.0051090065,
-0.000257663,
0.0470618345,
0.0200589579,
0.0451380424,
0.0330625921,
-0.0227480028,
0.025430847,
-0.0128033869,
0.0029737914,
-0.016525222,
-0.0408332422,
-0.0352454856,
0.0241865758,
0.0750652552,
-0.0348259546,
-0.0578498691,
0.0661565885,
0.0080915494,
-0.0024421758,
-0.0063957213,
-0.0305738673,
0.0493775159,
-0.0166175272,
0.0452102497,
0.0084178895,
0.0221534725,
-0.1083009467,
-0.0097741289,
0.0077084689,
-0.0099855876,
0.0249343738,
0.0250643082,
-0.0660161749,
-0.0148989558,
-0.1024302468,
-0.0694478005,
-0.0182349794,
0.0688479319,
0.0267363787,
0.0088556074,
-0.0655489266,
-0.0531467535,
0.0080771055,
-0.0035653834,
-0.028158417,
0.0352712274,
0.0055771288,
0.0043110154,
0.0540454052,
-0.0045889728,
-0.0346422233,
0.0473051667,
-0.0034856531,
0.0368203036,
-0.0378017798,
0.0317803696,
-0.0151295047,
0.0149771497,
0.0178515092,
0.0567587949,
0.0331276841,
-0.0027859858,
-0.0319888256,
-0.0424261726,
0.0418507867,
0.0243191086,
0.0259565711,
0.0076062805,
-0.0021309278,
0.0631781667,
-0.0132510308,
-0.0006431358,
0.0474540927,
0.0025707043,
-0.0093654897,
-0.0276236553,
0.0191355571,
-6.061037687e-33,
0.0164474491,
0.0013328355,
-0.0162842795,
0.0132894013,
-0.0178997722,
-0.0254760105,
-0.0228108969,
-0.0105361715,
-0.0457926318,
0.0137865078,
-0.0200413279,
-0.0044865217,
-0.0138990209,
0.0298128091,
0.0490526631,
-0.0102190422,
0.0095622558,
-0.0453453436,
0.0018157889,
0.0077657495,
-0.0045791906,
-0.008280104,
0.024449423,
-0.0578823723,
0.024382364,
-0.0057365298,
0.0300354082,
0.0431971252,
-0.0256787613,
0.0088195018,
-0.0572238117,
0.0225250982,
0.0196254626,
-0.036026787,
0.000340279,
-0.0682066903,
-0.0016269479,
-0.0252656527,
-0.0240313001,
-0.0029282158,
-0.0228969269,
-0.0797205269,
0.0562585369,
-0.0400190651,
-0.0143737979,
0.0108006829,
0.0334916972,
-0.0340008698,
0.0172158889,
-0.0102311354,
-0.05433999,
-0.0478242673,
-0.0352593064,
-0.008200963,
0.0310811289,
-0.0193746258,
-0.0182461441,
-0.0006657004,
-0.041678369,
0.0429565348,
-0.0269941483,
0.0114610959,
0.0004919,
-0.0151072117,
0.0736999586,
0.0294803753,
0.1097154319,
0.0054191356,
-0.0377021767,
-0.024032332,
0.0283673592,
0.0590763278,
0.074875176,
0.0311034601,
0.049028486,
-0.034390185,
-0.0931026265,
-0.0159698706,
0.048956383,
-0.0005202546,
0.0247195177,
0.0104081351,
-0.0512124933,
-0.029432131,
0.038090758,
-0.0620259941,
-0.0342587046,
-0.0004898137,
-0.0062374412,
-0.0239376165,
0.0240449049,
-0.0074962149,
0.0184147339,
-0.0787291154,
0.0626724511,
-0.0094911698,
0.0042594713,
0.0576919317,
0.0322321244,
-0.0301683433,
-0.0225153677,
-0.0561099946,
-0.0547258779,
0.043872267,
0.0294277482,
0.0144703612,
-0.0064868373,
0.0653573126,
0.0684513003,
-0.0260929782,
-0.0102435406,
-0.0579017811,
0.1142864078,
-0.0190017279,
0.0109637398,
-0.0043248939,
-0.0106198229,
-0.0268149897,
0.0024987571,
0.0306688733,
-0.0033188171,
0.0542307012,
-0.0299165379,
0.0345103852,
-0.0077896169,
-0.0493094102,
-0.0238859802,
-0.0344245881,
0.0032951897,
-0.0945401415,
-0.0161691364,
-0.0222405009,
2.975e-7,
-0.0389304906,
0.0073737008,
0.0380410142,
-0.0363187753,
0.0519116446,
0.0030006445,
-0.0133656748,
-0.001261377,
-0.015479451,
0.008707271,
0.0322194174,
0.0226637665,
-0.0013165056,
0.0000776345,
-0.0187341031,
0.0013631578,
-0.0049754274,
0.0259872321,
0.0295120403,
0.0167830437,
-0.0091700284,
0.0563551001,
0.0296629108,
0.0154986735,
0.0165317021,
-0.048029311,
0.0307449698,
-0.0144979423,
0.0781351998,
0.006456994,
0.0223159902,
0.0046379687,
-0.0164520275,
0.0236230586,
0.024401607,
0.0305580348,
0.0102559738,
-0.0282699279,
0.0166245531,
0.005977036,
-0.0188274048,
-0.0162891299,
0.0032334751,
-0.0004802404,
0.0766861439,
-0.0812607259,
-0.0836455002,
0.032218162,
-0.0102820359,
0.0101647433,
-0.0011210985,
0.0273255184,
0.0092453426,
-0.0354012251,
-0.0234780386,
0.007571599,
0.0295358729,
-0.0305180829,
0.0136480769,
0.0524227954,
-0.0542963594,
-0.0342747197,
-0.039325837,
-0.0094907386,
0.0767062306,
-0.0510649718,
-0.0170185119,
2.760765114e-34,
0.0313259624,
0.0152169773,
0.0367226936,
-0.0607678629,
0.0130852005,
-0.0384899974,
0.019909516,
-0.0253744461,
0.071838595,
-0.0401742384,
-0.0495213754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11222v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11222v2 | LoSparse: Structured Compression of Large Language Models based on Low-Rank and Sparse Approximation | 2023-06-20T01:16:11 | 2023-06-26T15:34:57 | Yixiao Li, Yifan Yu, Qingru Zhang, Chen Liang, Pengcheng He, Weizhu Chen, Tuo Zhao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Transformer models have achieved remarkable results in various natural
language tasks, but they are often prohibitively large, requiring massive
memories and computational resources. To reduce the size and complexity of
these models, we propose LoSparse (Low-Rank and Sparse approximation), a novel
model compression technique that approximates a weight matrix by the sum of a
low-rank matrix and a sparse matrix. Our method combines the advantages of both
low-rank approximations and pruning, while avoiding their limitations. Low-rank
approximation compresses the coherent and expressive parts in neurons, while
pruning removes the incoherent and non-expressive parts in neurons. Pruning
enhances the diversity of low-rank approximations, and low-rank approximation
prevents pruning from losing too many expressive neurons. We evaluate our
method on natural language understanding, question answering, and natural
language generation tasks. We show that it significantly outperforms existing
compression methods. | [
0.0104369083,
0.0868959576,
-0.0074184239,
0.0545157753,
-0.0098607391,
0.0061956877,
-0.0105499737,
0.0235541221,
-0.0228672586,
-0.0080783078,
-0.0304172095,
-0.037732318,
0.0219064578,
0.0195937473,
0.0229021292,
-0.0316125341,
0.0300691966,
-0.0311875232,
-0.0227394123,
-0.0020856643,
-0.0088531673,
0.0058831493,
0.02212031,
0.0478882343,
0.014653028,
-0.0101563344,
-0.0311405119,
-0.0076065636,
-0.0260936581,
0.025446441,
-0.0024662188,
0.0621700548,
0.0710483864,
0.0139437523,
0.000001945,
0.008317749,
-0.0145886531,
0.0042349943,
-0.0300234258,
0.0172826257,
0.0419086739,
-0.0322506651,
0.0192231573,
0.0005870456,
-0.0313898586,
-0.0610175617,
0.047230877,
0.0585075691,
0.0780960247,
0.0518667549,
0.00101361,
-0.0419138521,
0.0344033949,
-0.019903997,
-0.0031884939,
-0.0266596861,
0.0001805559,
0.0049808174,
-0.0143151907,
0.0349630676,
-0.02131222,
0.0380741097,
0.0381696634,
0.0114384387,
0.0083281612,
0.0537781268,
-0.0348972529,
-0.0224050544,
0.0069405129,
0.0692257881,
-0.0434275568,
-0.0531756096,
0.003784003,
0.0252676252,
-0.0023059982,
-0.0544185117,
-0.0576981269,
0.0636045784,
0.0447485782,
0.0276786275,
0.0018012095,
0.0064444109,
0.0232344102,
0.0048804563,
-0.032766629,
0.031865634,
0.0316267349,
-0.0196258295,
-0.0487156324,
-0.0116706053,
-0.055689849,
-0.040259786,
0.0015304817,
0.0323776715,
-0.013166857,
-0.006319222,
-0.0716240257,
-0.0302399378,
-0.0222153254,
-0.0280357767,
0.057504911,
0.0561147481,
0.0286976099,
0.0404241569,
-0.0504959114,
0.0576664396,
-0.0222772788,
-0.0244474635,
-0.0407864749,
-0.0142477443,
-0.0229460225,
-0.0190231204,
-0.0641371161,
0.0777672529,
-0.0677021816,
-0.0445950031,
-0.0099034114,
0.015557047,
0.0170042086,
-0.0212522782,
0.0221836865,
0.0533260852,
-0.0126266591,
-0.0129072806,
-0.0069330675,
0.0314714871,
-0.0225924663,
0.0013551661,
0.014162438,
-0.040368747,
-0.0358259045,
0.0514489748,
0.0219654534,
-0.0358658992,
0.017007973,
0.0221787915,
-0.0427501835,
-0.0337799937,
-0.0248352494,
-0.0148804933,
0.0016167248,
-0.0546435378,
-0.0060078274,
-0.0903146341,
0.0643424243,
-0.0112130111,
-0.0079598147,
-0.0463284217,
0.0123669747,
0.0436817817,
-0.0583483651,
0.0372143276,
0.0169356186,
0.0083000036,
0.0037075954,
0.0279488843,
0.0205952507,
0.0159771387,
0.0259387158,
0.0346976779,
-0.0157891307,
-0.0362962894,
-0.0426636599,
0.0145447617,
0.0416473709,
-0.0169227701,
-0.0333150625,
0.0128336893,
-0.0308923814,
0.0066895583,
0.0417817943,
0.1105151325,
-0.0531200282,
-0.0268618651,
0.0629597604,
0.0581257865,
0.0229834206,
0.0702871159,
0.05654357,
0.0052621374,
-0.0063477047,
0.0029843405,
-0.0333700702,
0.0511202626,
-0.0484344028,
0.018122049,
0.0319048017,
0.0318538509,
-0.0522257723,
-0.0231036004,
-0.001010761,
-0.0374272168,
0.0299810767,
-0.0129282847,
-0.0056878594,
0.0300155841,
-0.0545861572,
0.1079170033,
0.0150564034,
-0.0659002811,
-0.0093314433,
-0.044422593,
0.0165075213,
0.0035299086,
0.0234786011,
0.0220986735,
-0.017125193,
-0.0046285922,
0.0071320999,
0.0269419141,
0.0151388254,
0.0010016559,
0.0098044639,
-0.0650947914,
0.0083684931,
-0.0152666764,
0.0000639193,
-0.0256796498,
0.0188961718,
-0.0249762032,
0.0371534564,
-0.0454448909,
-0.0084858872,
0.0249495935,
-0.0340386741,
-0.0160949118,
0.0331627615,
-0.0172900278,
0.019591203,
-0.0169541929,
-0.0093488144,
0.0291580409,
0.0588658266,
-0.0536844023,
-0.0204424132,
-0.0415901244,
-0.0553610697,
-0.0558902174,
0.0225385781,
-0.0004542455,
0.0133865876,
0.0763760731,
-0.0162441619,
-0.0453476124,
0.0087056672,
-0.0787092969,
0.0165316276,
-0.0575068556,
0.003715229,
0.0189964343,
0.0649217442,
-0.0245016888,
0.0762147084,
-0.0443223938,
0.0231283493,
0.0486815162,
-0.0236643013,
-0.0092810262,
-0.0469208583,
-0.064226456,
-0.0075894366,
-0.0355788022,
0.0116930315,
0.0198591612,
0.0150806941,
0.0116065312,
-0.0214668363,
-0.0686126053,
0.0241296347,
-0.0007639831,
-0.0017440597,
0.0316014253,
0.0504378937,
0.0323561355,
0.0012596489,
-0.0532816015,
0.0363838561,
0.0462622121,
0.0017708149,
0.0099277133,
-0.0063118776,
-0.0232844371,
-0.0397192761,
-0.0454836451,
-0.0050112247,
0.0805563852,
-0.0573937446,
-0.009524269,
-0.0440495536,
0.0563378856,
-0.0402334444,
0.0352341048,
0.0058327448,
-0.0410260595,
-0.0194885898,
-0.0268751439,
0.0547641329,
0.0374673344,
0.0173724797,
0.0421615206,
0.0778642073,
0.0168949068,
-0.0306419637,
0.0178342909,
-0.051366251,
0.0168151911,
-0.0181199368,
-0.061256703,
0.0110744564,
0.0856891423,
0.0397127755,
-0.0047086016,
-0.0666830987,
-0.0189040769,
0.0258479454,
-0.0159228165,
-0.02322069,
0.0143809058,
0.00721779,
0.0125435563,
-0.0374013782,
-0.0029465235,
0.0503957309,
-0.0472059287,
0.0006361176,
-0.0116606951,
-0.0310587827,
-0.034342546,
0.0354998671,
0.0399497785,
0.0498234034,
-0.0112285828,
0.0205884762,
-0.0525231324,
0.0088656154,
-0.0279810447,
-0.0270610861,
0.0414573029,
-0.0034114432,
0.0126704713,
-0.0162703432,
-0.0301143564,
-0.0276597589,
-0.0540008955,
0.0196064636,
0.0513412096,
0.0531627052,
-0.0064167343,
-0.0227448642,
0.0104375985,
0.0149629544,
0.035733901,
-0.0020041305,
-0.0046688393,
-0.0220058467,
0.0734370351,
0.0597195514,
0.0523729064,
0.0490712635,
-0.0384390876,
0.0348216668,
0.0582018569,
0.0172690451,
0.0147702172,
-0.0668767318,
0.0128047001,
0.0323581658,
0.0185436103,
-0.0327744894,
0.0373104401,
0.0266956799,
-0.0322983116,
-0.0418399163,
0.1212210059,
0.0261086207,
-0.0400117896,
0.019692352,
-0.0121958433,
0.0983706936,
0.0131622897,
0.0517669171,
-0.057077989,
-0.0085547371,
-0.005428575,
-0.0044785244,
0.031003613,
-0.028714532,
-0.0026255152,
-0.1150606498,
0.02552584,
0.0077186977,
0.0196767747,
-0.0309066176,
-0.0063906517,
-0.0126001518,
0.0062876167,
-0.0174683277,
0.0215073712,
-0.0157023016,
0.0052492269,
0.0165506043,
-0.0175325964,
-0.030230524,
0.0117399618,
0.0138387168,
0.0398488343,
0.0124821644,
0.027120851,
-0.0067321807,
-0.0508096628,
0.009425546,
0.0084123099,
-0.0164424218,
-0.0196990725,
0.0052809133,
0.0372659713,
-0.0190643761,
-0.0075421999,
0.0424790941,
-0.0480734408,
-0.0264267512,
-0.0319646634,
0.1015618294,
-0.0161198676,
-0.0300751925,
0.0041477629,
0.0088177733,
-0.0295996312,
0.093898721,
0.0496907309,
-0.0190613475,
-0.0364006758,
0.0106509561,
0.0051566241,
-0.0264976341,
-0.0569952764,
0.0227350704,
0.0447555073,
0.0018396116,
-0.0644537136,
0.0173890106,
0.0094394051,
0.0129529499,
-0.0541103929,
-0.0247634742,
-0.0045013786,
-0.0321541652,
-0.0458472893,
0.0085327644,
-0.025466824,
-0.0242963787,
-0.0349373557,
0.0048185019,
0.005191376,
-0.0166215748,
-0.0220986139,
-0.0203707814,
-0.1193887368,
-0.031004766,
-0.0288510304,
0.0712593719,
0.0194379613,
0.0144089116,
0.0145938285,
-0.0259023886,
0.0062043923,
0.0283171106,
-0.0476766489,
0.0489748791,
0.0017910769,
-0.0523955859,
0.0077571864,
0.05435168,
-0.0136231603,
0.0212979652,
-0.0055403607,
0.0723208934,
-0.0131586753,
-0.0390011109,
0.046437785,
0.01000115,
0.0104067791,
0.0160668828,
0.0260286517,
-0.0007385974,
0.0066010072,
-0.0072049038,
-0.0137930047,
-0.0566662587,
0.0001631692,
0.0337081291,
0.0402555577,
0.0024178193,
0.0232047029,
0.0283000246,
0.043280296,
-0.0237605199,
-0.0343075395,
0.0109799905,
-0.0652098954,
0.0170126539,
-0.0059418175,
-0.0290506482,
-0.0169667788,
-0.0093556643,
0.0242637582,
-0.0390715078,
0.0205972288,
-0.0067485203,
0.0068424507,
-0.0438806601,
0.0294416044,
-0.041199822,
-0.0623200685,
-0.0158607531,
-0.0046125175,
0.0172500759,
-0.0012950093,
0.0244416818,
-0.0056047598,
-0.0069028093,
-0.0208511539,
0.029956799,
0.0104220128,
-0.0301404689,
0.0527787395,
0.0218529366,
0.0011674968,
-0.0222200733,
0.0904586241,
0.0349001586,
0.035908103,
-0.0060318979,
0.0061340211,
-0.0516041853,
-0.0421288088,
-0.0236597359,
0.0267687868,
-0.0225213189,
0.0185309146,
-0.0073428862,
-0.0652931407,
0.0080689164,
0.0073424764,
0.0141872363,
-0.035303209,
0.0517915972,
0.0337932073,
0.018090656,
0.000834192,
-0.0151634561,
0.0056285989,
0.0000520621,
-0.0220151674,
-0.0410513803,
-6.441953692e-33,
-0.0416164733,
-0.0072891903,
0.030104354,
-0.001685914,
-0.0258626733,
-0.001683876,
-0.0587196127,
0.0014622913,
-0.0189299434,
0.0125303296,
-0.0102864103,
0.0086311139,
-0.0211346298,
0.058526922,
-0.0227233041,
0.0009478858,
0.0520935841,
-0.01155583,
-0.0109981634,
0.0236691535,
0.0199280176,
0.034230452,
0.0019202916,
-0.0147567037,
-0.0417526849,
0.0001075366,
0.004532868,
0.0260633938,
-0.0022139356,
0.0572039522,
-0.0548017286,
0.0340637825,
0.0367937982,
-0.0434301645,
-0.0058712736,
0.0275196861,
-0.0716976598,
-0.0009268884,
0.0368833505,
-0.029383203,
-0.0381934941,
-0.0377716571,
0.0352796502,
-0.0130543848,
0.0099560078,
-0.0436113104,
-0.0028789644,
-0.0388968177,
-0.0337371156,
-0.0427088886,
-0.0562612377,
-0.013207037,
-0.0123935705,
-0.0404026359,
0.0013164056,
0.069612667,
-0.0455708317,
0.0286550503,
-0.0301666036,
-0.0296414811,
-0.0111661898,
0.0947605669,
0.0357120335,
-0.0112801595,
-0.0069635124,
0.0275357608,
-0.0049644988,
-0.0250806939,
-0.070834592,
0.0395983756,
0.0145958234,
0.0533553846,
0.0485945269,
0.0227478929,
0.0176880378,
0.024319306,
-0.0699424669,
0.0054163854,
-0.0080998186,
0.0617639609,
0.0280082952,
0.003513634,
0.0297107212,
-0.0224478599,
-0.0316942111,
0.0020881677,
-0.0361365452,
-0.0152168246,
0.0090536252,
0.0211736728,
-0.0519481711,
-0.0259554088,
0.0444147661,
-0.0650765076,
0.0264074504,
0.041078914,
-0.0164883975,
0.0073483069,
0.0206171554,
0.0447616391,
-0.0594199747,
-0.0256452728,
0.022711128,
-0.0145279085,
-0.0026886878,
0.0313612148,
0.0331440829,
0.0403456278,
-0.0405449122,
-0.0287127234,
-0.0439124517,
0.0101396088,
-0.0325222388,
0.0672313645,
0.0311277229,
0.0375827402,
-0.0154314497,
0.0617263205,
-0.02232912,
0.0136681385,
-0.0168987028,
-0.0031189409,
0.0415113643,
0.0373235121,
-0.016741531,
0.0057632383,
-0.0819159821,
0.0507066026,
0.0286680665,
-0.0538298301,
-0.0252690036,
0.0318277292,
2.658e-7,
0.0245298296,
0.0035356293,
0.0047614472,
0.0138152,
0.0164396241,
0.0110374764,
0.0157060213,
0.0334241278,
-0.0172811132,
-0.051231239,
0.0075334292,
0.0304639097,
0.0372651294,
-0.0078867963,
-0.0581449978,
0.0061045489,
-0.1133882329,
-0.0312370956,
-0.0308430549,
-0.0331591368,
0.0597449131,
0.1122899726,
-0.0189284366,
-0.0220776219,
0.0131370258,
0.0299140755,
0.0830828398,
0.0063300063,
-0.0188475531,
-0.0090733124,
0.0403262563,
-0.0080868239,
-0.0189841036,
-0.0198915694,
-0.0087207342,
0.0342848599,
0.0029191871,
0.076034084,
0.0058928924,
0.0088231824,
0.0269918572,
-0.0307482127,
-0.027518509,
-0.0367549323,
0.0723405033,
-0.051847823,
-0.0237421077,
-0.0375764631,
-0.0181777962,
0.018067535,
-0.038366124,
-0.0368327685,
-0.0002715262,
-0.0079032835,
0.0322773904,
-0.0216145683,
0.0035750978,
-0.0589107797,
-0.0206969231,
0.0052598515,
-0.0663646311,
-0.0023304832,
-0.0445911959,
-0.0266725831,
0.0465039536,
-0.0428525135,
-0.0195119884,
2.664543325e-34,
0.0198253077,
0.0185376387,
0.007931524,
0.0349496752,
0.0256246366,
-0.0353492685,
-0.0029755945,
-0.0059730937,
-0.0056384252,
-0.1213379726,
-0.0494830981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11207v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11207v3 | Quilt-1M: One Million Image-Text Pairs for Histopathology | 2023-06-20T00:14:47 | 2023-10-27T23:56:33 | Wisdom Oluchi Ikezogwo, Mehmet Saygin Seyfioglu, Fatemeh Ghezloo, Dylan Stefan Chan Geva, Fatwir Sheikh Mohammed, Pavan Kumar Anand, Ranjay Krishna, Linda Shapiro | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent accelerations in multi-modal applications have been made possible with
the plethora of image and text data available online. However, the scarcity of
analogous data in the medical field, specifically in histopathology, has slowed
comparable progress. To enable similar representation learning for
histopathology, we turn to YouTube, an untapped resource of videos, offering
$1,087$ hours of valuable educational histopathology videos from expert
clinicians. From YouTube, we curate QUILT: a large-scale vision-language
dataset consisting of $802, 144$ image and text pairs. QUILT was automatically
curated using a mixture of models, including large language models, handcrafted
algorithms, human knowledge databases, and automatic speech recognition. In
comparison, the most comprehensive datasets curated for histopathology amass
only around $200$K samples. We combine QUILT with datasets from other sources,
including Twitter, research papers, and the internet in general, to create an
even larger dataset: QUILT-1M, with $1$M paired image-text samples, marking it
as the largest vision-language histopathology dataset to date. We demonstrate
the value of QUILT-1M by fine-tuning a pre-trained CLIP model. Our model
outperforms state-of-the-art models on both zero-shot and linear probing tasks
for classifying new histopathology images across $13$ diverse patch-level
datasets of $8$ different sub-pathologies and cross-modal retrieval tasks. | [
0.0114251925,
0.0859336406,
0.0170735177,
-0.0053864038,
-0.021777384,
-0.0000749935,
-0.0004354757,
0.0279415399,
-0.0160082318,
0.0284338556,
-0.0030020478,
-0.0282698218,
-0.0318929069,
0.0383032598,
-0.008396781,
-0.0590666458,
0.0044813366,
0.0258468725,
0.0029215915,
0.0041833813,
0.0167223047,
0.0126559548,
0.0351607166,
0.0577591546,
-0.0380950049,
0.0301934592,
0.0331006013,
-0.0095538134,
0.028593611,
-0.0191505291,
-0.0102576455,
0.0468448065,
0.0398484394,
0.0308772493,
0.0000018865,
-0.0236358307,
0.0007461939,
0.011906039,
-0.0330715105,
0.0323554985,
0.0213401467,
-0.0427624956,
0.0046721371,
-0.0181270968,
-0.0058465977,
-0.0203177165,
0.0112425163,
0.0528774895,
0.0478584245,
0.0590596609,
-0.0218915679,
0.0084097255,
0.0282711443,
-0.04581853,
0.0483433306,
-0.0125497142,
0.0383535475,
0.0215927828,
-0.0133261522,
0.0102261566,
-0.00548058,
0.0657617003,
0.0136673301,
0.020451609,
0.0216484629,
0.0674408451,
-0.0190355666,
-0.0479182899,
0.0182978921,
0.0762124211,
-0.0420823768,
-0.0298908129,
0.0214850828,
-0.0066938079,
-0.0012488385,
0.0246480051,
-0.0311787482,
0.0341502242,
-0.00022823,
0.0093161184,
-0.0692815855,
-0.010300152,
0.0292102955,
0.0102346977,
0.0278494935,
-0.0393285118,
-0.0072779097,
0.0279762894,
0.0192162618,
0.0125628402,
0.0028548655,
0.009426686,
0.0130354874,
0.0100524658,
0.0128377518,
-0.027519891,
-0.0370400101,
-0.0191014018,
0.0469632857,
-0.0194892492,
0.0605553538,
-0.0000547416,
-0.0857596397,
0.088500239,
-0.0422083177,
-0.041380614,
-0.0393089391,
0.0409185626,
-0.0194607005,
0.0023383051,
-0.0077789892,
-0.0006065361,
-0.0293793436,
-0.019826347,
-0.0092232898,
-0.0445712991,
-0.0265034009,
-0.0149777709,
-0.0130925709,
0.011953868,
0.0166574512,
0.0388376452,
-0.048436489,
-0.0198078305,
0.0250247531,
0.0214428008,
-0.0067932452,
0.019712735,
-0.0327079669,
-0.0099784415,
-0.0047339802,
0.0314171165,
0.0247703176,
-0.0017740182,
0.0338591561,
0.0406754054,
-0.0252280869,
-0.010276882,
0.0521606468,
-0.0063175969,
-0.0634002015,
-0.0122118844,
0.0318162292,
-0.0848656669,
0.0317356102,
0.0056520919,
-0.0079142544,
0.0049391584,
0.0039107339,
-0.0114734108,
-0.0535609014,
0.0888151824,
-0.0191662349,
-0.0111979004,
0.0219388232,
0.0327262841,
0.0054452769,
0.036518041,
-0.0363083631,
0.0346775949,
-0.0007754195,
0.0199865717,
0.0293221679,
0.0118514327,
0.0420688353,
0.0157460682,
-0.0567244887,
-0.0003907315,
-0.003119057,
0.049544964,
0.0309306271,
0.0237302296,
-0.0091259126,
-0.0949353874,
0.0168563128,
0.0506305285,
0.0339097343,
0.0412802137,
0.0069154492,
0.0490636975,
0.0015910125,
-0.0360891894,
-0.0112140272,
0.0037860062,
-0.0080293221,
-0.0021335955,
0.0149699505,
-0.0157309622,
-0.0456051379,
-0.0299756266,
0.0064222286,
0.0299290344,
-0.0058040731,
-0.0142576536,
0.0622720011,
-0.0466510057,
0.0204578005,
-0.0093250629,
0.0218363255,
0.0002521673,
-0.0199250858,
-0.0635556579,
-0.0052838512,
0.016076386,
0.0151390089,
-0.0443684384,
-0.0136946384,
0.0023648522,
0.0418894254,
-0.0075036762,
-0.0398892909,
0.017631337,
0.0501847193,
-0.0252697878,
-0.0290275645,
0.0214274339,
0.0201571267,
-0.0331695825,
-0.0143168969,
0.0388710052,
0.0100589488,
-0.048890397,
0.0230411943,
0.0393442884,
-0.0053196172,
-0.0267443657,
-0.0278115496,
0.0360278152,
-0.0135429809,
-0.0373174436,
-0.0575835221,
-0.0299156327,
0.0149339642,
-0.0224054307,
-0.0632800609,
-0.0073519782,
-0.0044286093,
-0.0005746499,
0.0566114075,
-0.1041042954,
-0.0485653765,
0.0122121954,
-0.0403038114,
0.0100858733,
-0.0180125926,
-0.031441506,
-0.0795035511,
-0.0054944702,
-0.0336262472,
0.027424993,
0.0024468158,
0.0086546233,
0.0174009819,
-0.0300418641,
-0.0108306659,
0.0157362949,
-0.0407940932,
0.044827912,
-0.0231086556,
-0.0543391854,
-0.0202472173,
-0.0266176015,
0.0465735272,
0.012826845,
0.0222214255,
-0.0365770087,
0.0134574817,
-0.0670183674,
0.0189989861,
-0.0255448334,
-0.0466970615,
0.0040548085,
0.0124605475,
-0.0120258629,
-0.0921570361,
-0.0422712117,
-0.0088897254,
0.0544344336,
0.0140067935,
0.0361719839,
0.0333567895,
0.0558313765,
-0.0288310852,
-0.043781817,
0.0128078964,
0.020593429,
0.0052221245,
-0.0694384351,
0.0466995835,
-0.0036036414,
-0.018825382,
0.0415128917,
0.0041803215,
-0.0609511994,
-0.0112934485,
-0.0684582889,
-0.0373718776,
0.089079231,
-0.0112693906,
0.045129925,
-0.0116368197,
-0.0085382285,
-0.0071897036,
-0.0017881532,
-0.0624806881,
-0.0153009091,
0.0080592297,
-0.0109133953,
-0.0562889986,
0.0095690303,
0.0038169997,
0.0206246767,
-0.0702372417,
-0.0170664228,
0.0107267918,
0.0029923783,
-0.1081608534,
-0.0114153288,
0.0083830031,
0.0073333113,
-0.0322153345,
-0.0395775884,
0.0467402339,
0.0372953191,
0.037487343,
0.0597457364,
-0.0105336672,
-0.0203884635,
0.0502422862,
-0.0114613557,
0.0164745115,
-0.0419798642,
0.0019230348,
-0.0340902843,
0.0453096963,
-0.0114772413,
-0.0497201197,
0.0286066197,
-0.0141287213,
0.0075245895,
-0.0015224509,
-0.056784302,
-0.0248158704,
-0.023955578,
-0.0313651077,
0.0210793149,
-0.0590295568,
-0.0110060787,
-0.0453573018,
0.0004663399,
0.0170844961,
0.0600349009,
0.0033032743,
0.0037766928,
-0.0136050982,
0.0619774684,
0.0157470591,
0.0168487094,
-0.0407900438,
-0.0135344844,
0.0042387047,
0.0476648621,
0.0247999802,
0.0458530933,
0.0092825564,
0.0101626599,
-0.0153034274,
0.0253314432,
0.0121772774,
0.0009518123,
0.0528724976,
-0.0404770039,
-0.0038224126,
0.0426696837,
-0.0248147007,
-0.0588012785,
-0.042018149,
-0.0022497003,
-0.0189388879,
-0.0481041856,
0.0281422213,
-0.1019678116,
-0.0391152203,
-0.0229786467,
-0.0367792547,
0.0471834503,
0.0045918766,
0.0270298924,
-0.0050816922,
0.0767687708,
0.0336474665,
-0.0279221274,
-0.0544835441,
-0.0497058332,
-0.0084279906,
-0.0724978149,
-0.0605360903,
-0.0382271111,
0.0075017479,
-0.0246970505,
-0.0098752566,
-0.0055640284,
-0.0897230729,
0.0204099324,
-0.0495406277,
-0.0426019095,
0.011653441,
0.0337539688,
-0.0427772142,
-0.0415261015,
-0.0089498553,
0.0080550266,
-0.0334957615,
0.0226014368,
0.1443844736,
-0.0134540563,
-0.0208858252,
-0.0438072123,
0.0743410736,
0.0056139808,
0.0095354933,
-0.0536358096,
0.0683732033,
0.0038666942,
-0.0272248778,
-0.0779862553,
0.0288299639,
0.008260184,
0.0216761511,
0.0089430492,
-0.0293048713,
-0.0228103269,
-0.0285533313,
0.0606071874,
0.0251999833,
-0.072050795,
0.0369317159,
0.0030215422,
-0.0364142545,
-0.0081680138,
-0.0209628642,
0.0218070485,
0.0026338412,
0.019127544,
-0.0010849332,
-0.0244016685,
-0.0214675032,
-0.1085719839,
0.1256866157,
-0.0044501345,
0.004168361,
-0.0329483561,
-0.0196503866,
0.0650888979,
-0.0520372353,
0.0053768945,
0.0416867696,
-0.0570640154,
0.0131091503,
-0.0179384649,
0.047834225,
0.0179595035,
0.0525631011,
-0.022852391,
-0.0816536024,
0.0808136687,
0.076045379,
0.0078213876,
-0.0156907421,
0.0128823817,
-0.0549457446,
0.0124985948,
0.0370389298,
-0.0262935627,
0.0112828547,
0.0123827048,
-0.0445466153,
-0.0074345269,
-0.0094528226,
-0.0032575864,
0.00161692,
0.0962494835,
-0.0175982527,
-0.0071043237,
-0.0002024739,
-0.0290171206,
0.0173830353,
-0.0218572915,
-0.0170539021,
0.0151478257,
0.0292316563,
0.0070442646,
-0.022297034,
0.0240596719,
0.0149779404,
-0.011500001,
-0.079102397,
-0.0023678353,
0.0196901709,
-0.031335596,
0.0565917268,
0.0105793253,
0.0044813962,
-0.0118738161,
-0.0083878841,
-0.0105519937,
-0.0017505962,
-0.0120573156,
0.0300109126,
0.0343104154,
-0.0223780349,
0.0413546003,
-0.0650661662,
-0.0358812846,
-0.049314037,
-0.0093520405,
0.0562237203,
-0.0745351762,
-0.0097237546,
-0.0302434266,
-0.0439377576,
-0.032727316,
0.0609213077,
-0.0464298911,
0.0068983911,
0.0117981387,
0.0188639779,
0.0001884065,
0.0039529447,
0.0522536784,
0.0296799578,
0.0025654682,
0.0104151834,
-0.0505872779,
-0.062917456,
0.0098043466,
0.0411310159,
0.0109886341,
-0.0153651265,
0.0330301151,
-0.0337938033,
-0.0462581068,
0.0257887524,
0.0172710791,
-0.0520437434,
0.0343629867,
0.0487166084,
0.045537591,
0.0271333661,
-0.0189710557,
-0.0126057779,
0.0548568405,
-0.0078667421,
-0.0380074494,
0.044011455,
-5.979201239e-33,
0.026897911,
0.0464681163,
0.0301399846,
-0.048750449,
-0.0018701789,
0.0532363579,
-0.0061877016,
0.0302421749,
-0.0112840505,
0.075661689,
-0.034067858,
-0.0211657174,
0.0082070306,
0.0384732187,
0.0014757048,
-0.0021151311,
0.0407127291,
-0.0216481555,
-0.0444553904,
0.0310402717,
-0.0267113429,
0.0393219031,
0.0385413282,
-0.0681348369,
-0.0353702977,
0.0530463457,
-0.0231621712,
0.0277396403,
0.012246361,
0.0192145836,
-0.0437400602,
0.0060366616,
0.0135138035,
0.0060454789,
-0.0316668227,
-0.0002878746,
-0.0787405744,
-0.0014616515,
-0.0419691838,
0.013290735,
-0.0929888636,
0.0191081949,
0.0669357702,
-0.0243797228,
0.0152506093,
-0.0260251407,
0.0573491976,
-0.0134620341,
-0.0327313989,
0.0117637264,
0.0212101899,
0.04599059,
-0.007462047,
-0.0507842936,
0.064021118,
-0.0270705279,
-0.0113160396,
0.0346151888,
-0.0920620188,
0.0156704653,
0.0232600812,
0.0213578548,
0.0372990891,
-0.0079182573,
-0.0120377336,
0.0749169663,
0.0267833751,
-0.0649754182,
-0.0533393696,
-0.0119641311,
0.0036114587,
0.061685428,
0.0471182875,
0.0047537214,
0.0567259789,
-0.0055455747,
-0.0482703783,
0.0436279587,
-0.0192900542,
0.0108287521,
0.0054447455,
-0.0008071925,
0.0118570914,
0.0407068022,
-0.0112558594,
-0.0508495532,
-0.0010074268,
0.0018063388,
0.0059471573,
0.0285199471,
-0.0010838032,
0.0642833561,
0.0231046304,
-0.0010647114,
-0.0244277511,
0.0400875174,
0.0118020047,
0.0110423416,
-0.000573721,
-0.0134321889,
-0.0516592488,
0.0116041116,
0.0112922275,
0.0001179942,
0.0001107465,
0.0028896448,
0.0743678585,
0.0052354829,
-0.0574688874,
0.004720381,
-0.0161340758,
-0.0097503364,
0.0196017828,
0.0470454767,
0.0404081382,
0.0339157656,
-0.0133325085,
0.0351682082,
-0.0267135147,
0.0078156088,
0.0117791742,
-0.0341220237,
-0.0155990906,
0.0015261383,
-0.0122037502,
-0.033494629,
-0.0528035238,
-0.0036056209,
0.0231755842,
-0.0540277362,
-0.0239433423,
0.0086640958,
2.655e-7,
0.0756021142,
0.0217406768,
0.024325192,
-0.0346240215,
-0.0103084175,
0.028821554,
-0.0467349589,
0.0280533582,
-0.0366909467,
-0.0278284885,
0.0321644619,
0.080607824,
0.0238044783,
-0.0080474941,
-0.021302687,
0.0134559115,
-0.0438683815,
0.0119987866,
0.0000171501,
-0.0083167823,
0.0220793225,
0.1054282263,
-0.0010273749,
-0.0217311941,
0.067831248,
0.0129783582,
0.0552357957,
-0.039028164,
0.018810967,
-0.010095967,
-0.0540473238,
0.0604610853,
0.0013714028,
0.006288873,
0.0115044061,
0.0056344252,
0.0460707322,
0.0631839335,
0.0130457748,
0.0006327436,
0.024630595,
0.0732987225,
0.0270256232,
0.0147934444,
0.0449196734,
-0.0388935059,
-0.0435594246,
-0.0341444723,
0.0501855202,
0.015654305,
0.0836485401,
-0.0511868224,
-0.0352407955,
0.050852038,
0.0149871847,
0.012189215,
-0.0286896266,
-0.0945591405,
-0.0325430855,
-0.0070585799,
-0.0143750748,
0.0145896431,
-0.0205345657,
0.0037443666,
0.020913817,
-0.0145651037,
-0.0042734663,
1.915723921e-34,
0.0101641705,
0.0316720605,
-0.0239073355,
-0.0090589141,
-0.0288466308,
-0.0085273422,
0.0385887139,
-0.0263814423,
-0.0202616975,
-0.0031147278,
-0.0120091159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11197v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11197v4 | Sparse Modular Activation for Efficient Sequence Modeling | 2023-06-19T23:10:02 | 2023-11-04T21:26:03 | Liliang Ren, Yang Liu, Shuohang Wang, Yichong Xu, Chenguang Zhu, ChengXiang Zhai | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Recent hybrid models combining Linear State Space Models (SSMs) with
self-attention mechanisms have demonstrated impressive results across a range
of sequence modeling tasks. However, current approaches apply attention modules
statically and uniformly to all elements in the input sequences, leading to
sub-optimal quality-efficiency trade-offs. To address this limitation, we
introduce Sparse Modular Activation (SMA), a general mechanism enabling neural
networks to sparsely and dynamically activate sub-modules for sequence elements
in a differentiable manner. Through allowing each element to skip non-activated
sub-modules, SMA reduces computation and memory consumption of neural networks
at both training and inference stages. To validate the effectiveness of SMA on
sequence modeling, we design a novel neural architecture, SeqBoat, which
employs SMA to sparsely activate a Gated Attention Unit (GAU) based on the
state representations learned from an SSM. By constraining the GAU to only
conduct local attention on the activated inputs, SeqBoat can achieve linear
inference complexity with theoretically infinite attention span, and provide
substantially better quality-efficiency trade-off than the chunking-based
models. With experiments on a wide range of tasks, including long sequence
modeling, speech classification and language modeling, SeqBoat brings new
state-of-the-art results among hybrid models with linear complexity, and
reveals the amount of attention needed for each task through the learned sparse
activation patterns. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/renll/SeqBoat. | [
0.0020616769,
0.0728690624,
-0.001218845,
-0.0065873768,
-0.0071815224,
-0.0093351128,
0.036652457,
-0.0189111978,
0.0085207541,
-0.027755307,
-0.0200618319,
-0.0630035475,
0.0125060594,
0.0487640463,
0.0520775132,
-0.0100394944,
0.0744134039,
-0.0113429716,
-0.0008970978,
0.0041221143,
0.010341811,
-0.0363249332,
0.0035413865,
0.0522758923,
0.0137355309,
0.0192997698,
-0.0522938073,
-0.0210520625,
-0.0264626164,
-0.0527819842,
0.0018327993,
0.102224119,
0.0313934386,
0.0381943993,
0.0000021369,
0.0223216135,
0.0204501338,
-0.0201294608,
-0.0430613831,
0.0541941933,
-0.015106177,
0.0380271338,
0.0367664471,
0.0002926282,
-0.0183965415,
-0.0395129025,
0.0872259066,
0.0071783951,
0.0242857113,
0.0859332383,
0.0023351968,
0.0003850785,
0.0155915534,
-0.0566925891,
0.0524563752,
-0.0206673089,
0.0145782316,
-0.0081544071,
0.0328760371,
0.0082192384,
-0.0411426723,
0.0418094322,
0.0277532898,
0.0301518682,
0.0203442518,
0.0465283841,
0.0079045044,
-0.032112103,
-0.0000260398,
0.0417141095,
-0.0341759473,
-0.0478387475,
0.0144789377,
-0.0092440061,
-0.0009236846,
-0.0251000579,
-0.0402758382,
0.0105777476,
0.0249007083,
0.0075766374,
0.0218484793,
0.003332552,
0.0670049936,
-0.0003356473,
-0.0460667908,
0.0152844498,
-0.0054868078,
-0.0283922479,
-0.0665801167,
-0.0336116478,
-0.0363459997,
-0.0300371852,
-0.0024565693,
0.0536483154,
0.0014780074,
0.0046356423,
-0.0370441638,
-0.0641349703,
0.0242338572,
-0.0269858725,
0.0219731536,
0.0654415786,
0.0080041699,
0.0239370745,
-0.0181336887,
0.0191538781,
-0.0070937029,
0.0099035287,
-0.0132848471,
0.0512911119,
-0.0528105237,
0.0190399047,
-0.0053647119,
0.0494005866,
-0.0146217765,
-0.0207046289,
-0.0401339345,
0.0070720012,
-0.0153894443,
-0.025537027,
-0.0156434029,
0.0301745981,
-0.0433172658,
0.0178288948,
0.0150817549,
0.0540093705,
-0.000468481,
0.0067054336,
0.0279242285,
-0.0272912476,
-0.0617156364,
0.022318624,
0.0162242092,
-0.0169943944,
-0.0097083673,
0.025842635,
-0.0042578056,
-0.0851624236,
-0.0416142493,
0.0006769291,
-0.026859222,
-0.0457683243,
0.0109376777,
-0.0636441037,
0.0376688316,
-0.0183248259,
-0.0113604851,
-0.0252005812,
0.0316695608,
0.0098718014,
-0.0145669933,
0.0560587049,
0.0240591951,
-0.0348489806,
-0.0170447025,
0.0239588153,
0.0166450832,
0.0281930938,
0.0378247723,
0.0192115437,
-0.0241404455,
-0.0311730728,
0.0093036043,
0.0210393891,
0.0344249867,
-0.0119428989,
-0.0301365927,
-0.034096282,
-0.0157926884,
0.0021464068,
0.0306465551,
0.0302489381,
-0.0375428833,
-0.0188639536,
0.0593812168,
0.0282259043,
-0.0117191849,
0.0386957005,
0.0480351038,
0.0222541578,
-0.0139796445,
0.0189259294,
-0.0570464842,
0.0713685825,
-0.0065939897,
0.0266032852,
0.0645864308,
0.0076971552,
-0.0280524977,
-0.0115558729,
-0.0156871621,
-0.027662551,
0.0385319777,
0.0244455431,
0.0365782604,
-0.0482234955,
-0.0766943321,
0.0718346611,
0.0113541698,
-0.0487662442,
-0.0231016688,
-0.031324923,
0.0546996035,
0.0312755294,
0.0245127641,
-0.0500736237,
-0.0547691137,
-0.0260602105,
-0.0315903202,
0.0058447425,
-0.0004278685,
0.0146768186,
0.0036002714,
-0.0549787767,
-0.0216788631,
0.0192512646,
0.0289997254,
0.0223087315,
0.0138912527,
-0.021977732,
0.0372531824,
-0.0136352079,
-0.016316019,
0.018702291,
-0.0260693207,
-0.0389937535,
-0.0070452495,
-0.0009481502,
0.0733324587,
0.0004987368,
-0.0121311322,
0.0448982827,
0.067658782,
-0.0247204266,
0.0034840514,
-0.0228773504,
-0.0957416072,
-0.0549199954,
0.0432775058,
0.0250371564,
0.0375136361,
0.0534227639,
-0.007883871,
-0.0779102594,
0.0394492,
-0.0801597461,
0.0010424528,
-0.0629482567,
0.0106705511,
0.0361361429,
0.0696857646,
-0.0154202031,
0.025624454,
-0.0474917591,
0.0212655533,
0.0043549561,
0.0128688766,
-0.0155457705,
-0.0346943289,
-0.0425942168,
-0.0215324387,
-0.0177088585,
-0.0058812583,
0.0071089901,
-0.0378384106,
0.0041401642,
0.0174884684,
-0.0935849622,
-0.0027975114,
-0.0354397409,
0.0137822609,
-0.0180132892,
0.0384793878,
0.0251865033,
0.0101884007,
-0.0324347764,
0.0073067625,
0.0001173742,
0.0142768696,
-0.0041277646,
0.004600218,
-0.0481185615,
-0.0629002675,
-0.0498618782,
0.0169241745,
0.0521755666,
-0.0497629158,
-0.0209188256,
-0.019536918,
-0.0533835813,
-0.0120268753,
0.027362261,
-0.0252943393,
-0.0372735672,
-0.0324844494,
-0.0270430408,
0.0256550703,
0.0270833299,
0.0237285551,
-0.0020586839,
0.0534915961,
0.0313255824,
-0.002674093,
0.0410040282,
-0.0408180058,
0.0907237232,
-0.0126782041,
-0.0184795074,
-0.015888337,
0.110766381,
-0.0365409628,
-0.0118781207,
-0.0479579903,
-0.0286615752,
0.0519108847,
-0.0399503559,
0.0351469778,
0.0022454208,
-0.0438457988,
0.0155464886,
-0.0310917925,
-0.0562759079,
0.0360999145,
-0.0450908989,
-0.0306639578,
-0.0118970433,
-0.0090465341,
-0.0366211683,
0.063596487,
0.0526669137,
-0.0089045456,
0.014962161,
-0.0128099872,
-0.0139585435,
0.0035665745,
-0.02816879,
-0.0141689265,
0.079176724,
-0.0081089986,
0.0322928689,
-0.0375512168,
0.0204031207,
-0.0159658752,
0.0085336156,
-0.0149051053,
0.0523465015,
0.0365890451,
-0.0201648045,
-0.0649673864,
0.0346786305,
0.006151116,
0.0649000332,
-0.0238384213,
0.0595403239,
-0.022926949,
0.0424479432,
0.0285827406,
0.045344878,
0.0311533082,
-0.0197662115,
0.0119465217,
0.0264307875,
0.0231194627,
0.010481542,
-0.0272146035,
-0.0289184563,
0.0295845829,
-0.02655253,
-0.0078359796,
0.0616417266,
0.0387734398,
-0.1028493866,
-0.0333326198,
0.0962646008,
0.0068041258,
-0.0508016571,
0.0169058517,
0.027335681,
0.0433137305,
0.0262208674,
0.0105568953,
-0.0530334115,
-0.0378149003,
0.0082689226,
-0.0064005442,
-0.0008999598,
-0.0097032413,
0.0096811503,
-0.0296242125,
0.01424501,
0.0359642357,
-0.0556027666,
-0.0359544419,
-0.0289516095,
-0.0080383029,
-0.0010193193,
-0.0180470347,
0.0442829691,
-0.0166859906,
0.0069070384,
0.036747653,
-0.0203579944,
-0.017614508,
0.0086028166,
-0.0000119734,
0.0536987484,
0.0304767918,
-0.0111154784,
-0.0045868279,
-0.0601938181,
0.0400022864,
-0.0104041379,
-0.004792823,
-0.0080210725,
0.0025381111,
0.0105335843,
-0.0304348022,
-0.0025581107,
-0.00197312,
0.0043979371,
-0.0085700722,
-0.0447842181,
0.0863136202,
-0.0245956574,
-0.0113440398,
-0.032391347,
0.0093328785,
-0.0188252553,
0.0541183986,
0.0738610625,
-0.0046446868,
-0.0677516535,
0.0001053905,
-0.0286293402,
-0.0588063747,
-0.0084843263,
0.0197744798,
0.0166312549,
-0.0723710284,
-0.03931785,
-0.0203701798,
0.0135587035,
0.0209115725,
-0.0223568156,
0.0263530444,
0.0178382788,
-0.0287961215,
-0.0448388234,
0.0237009358,
-0.024431454,
0.0068955021,
-0.0322879404,
-0.0273607206,
0.0090848086,
-0.0293546133,
-0.009275184,
-0.002588161,
-0.1327293813,
-0.0398813747,
-0.0184815079,
0.0649942681,
0.0019075049,
0.0071893507,
0.0169269182,
-0.0250276234,
0.0484426394,
0.032406427,
-0.0294639226,
0.0162780024,
0.0393040515,
-0.0373645611,
-0.0248051491,
0.0322215892,
0.0085516153,
0.013123313,
0.0121797118,
0.0624965839,
-0.0174841229,
0.0123296296,
-0.0181740355,
-0.0370445065,
0.0338054188,
0.0163632296,
0.0148058655,
-0.0004959852,
0.0243604984,
0.0387284681,
0.033658158,
-0.0438005067,
-0.0182686597,
0.0245707259,
0.0215181652,
0.0010407893,
-0.009643727,
0.0126064615,
0.030581668,
-0.0055655213,
0.067737788,
-0.0243812595,
-0.0540099367,
-0.0009815639,
-0.0263696909,
-0.039398782,
-0.0017301957,
-0.0137643199,
-0.0084603149,
-0.015736986,
0.0210980549,
-0.0115794558,
0.0653959587,
-0.0362758897,
0.0061873817,
-0.0487109497,
-0.0033749342,
-0.0165888015,
0.0366652235,
0.0831042752,
-0.035083618,
0.0230909418,
0.0200444702,
0.0084975008,
-0.0590389073,
0.0312838294,
-0.0239023976,
-0.0197526123,
0.018093735,
0.0554383285,
-0.0110216271,
-0.0086990846,
0.086342901,
0.0688186213,
0.0431351215,
0.0298349746,
-0.0059961719,
-0.0171372127,
-0.0443545505,
0.0210066158,
0.0626132786,
-0.0507260524,
0.0083384402,
-0.0199214052,
-0.0671257228,
0.0408254452,
-0.0208846573,
0.0236151628,
-0.0201800279,
0.0392077453,
0.0000421787,
-0.0234203953,
0.007887247,
-0.0243273601,
-0.0066518504,
0.0308946427,
-0.0335848369,
-0.0012130984,
-6.846568399e-33,
-0.0086025121,
-0.0164643005,
0.0257814955,
0.0154214576,
-0.042439308,
-0.0095459232,
-0.0602681525,
0.0231810976,
0.0183202941,
-0.0192585196,
-0.0140582379,
-0.0050957329,
-0.0148827359,
0.0464435779,
0.0421897471,
-0.0164389461,
0.0681919232,
0.0120719401,
0.0085348068,
0.0271176323,
-0.0002434526,
0.0367960557,
0.0552243963,
-0.0049240971,
-0.0232586246,
0.0213310029,
0.0311301611,
-0.0530596301,
-0.0371859632,
0.0356139354,
-0.0188091937,
0.0101353349,
0.0371299498,
-0.0434190147,
-0.0368855745,
-0.0040375474,
-0.0529885218,
0.0045694252,
0.0037868982,
-0.043174766,
0.009012552,
-0.0335701518,
0.0623273253,
0.0089384988,
0.0094550811,
-0.0272421315,
0.0028824441,
-0.0187806208,
-0.0790055543,
-0.039907746,
-0.0471065305,
0.040146593,
-0.0110914418,
-0.0020887156,
0.034826424,
0.0401832275,
-0.0363660157,
0.0041911397,
-0.0099408925,
-0.0148980664,
0.03003411,
0.1050127596,
0.0281568095,
0.0513427854,
0.0170194916,
0.0110921441,
0.0447134636,
-0.0262856018,
-0.0655527487,
0.032140255,
0.0454839878,
-0.0003952445,
0.0565429032,
-0.044235792,
0.0709486976,
-0.0061453059,
-0.0772926658,
-0.0115824807,
0.0267995391,
0.0720431879,
0.0611016452,
0.0391834527,
0.0118011702,
-0.0099384245,
-0.018218495,
0.014485877,
-0.0368925668,
-0.0069609098,
0.0072080232,
0.0527817681,
-0.0123383235,
0.0319747627,
0.0598507971,
-0.0154602109,
0.0231275652,
0.0108191585,
0.0384671502,
-0.0077781565,
0.0231989138,
-0.0017920779,
-0.0658641979,
-0.0183344614,
0.0325951241,
-0.0285430327,
-0.02554138,
-0.0233510956,
0.029860694,
0.0176842343,
-0.0451510027,
-0.0314544886,
-0.0523818694,
0.0102985827,
0.0007645739,
0.0791780502,
0.0641388819,
-0.0045411526,
-0.0060424916,
0.0459377579,
-0.0442513898,
-0.0084728394,
-0.0268025491,
-0.0108557837,
-0.005821818,
0.0535139702,
-0.025526531,
-0.0113721369,
-0.0956049711,
-0.0103605399,
-0.03378148,
-0.0684575662,
-0.0184949599,
0.0550570637,
2.902e-7,
-0.004533567,
-0.0027900632,
-0.0093554091,
-0.0319425315,
0.0526794456,
0.0156335328,
-0.0189779941,
0.0186929423,
-0.0220800731,
-0.0193678942,
0.0409665778,
0.016872786,
0.0319216102,
-0.0206516311,
-0.0999040306,
-0.0317980684,
-0.0466713645,
0.0305578075,
-0.0409398153,
-0.01078266,
0.0001664718,
0.1198251471,
-0.0136361569,
0.000329168,
0.0475542396,
-0.020573508,
0.0370331816,
0.0410790816,
-0.0018660896,
-0.0120836422,
0.0207632519,
0.0140938954,
-0.0148335854,
-0.012177933,
-0.0298758578,
0.0276642963,
-0.0230175164,
0.0775855035,
0.0048775678,
-0.049075231,
0.0106899012,
0.0264448188,
-0.008950511,
-0.0126882428,
0.0524621233,
-0.0261986144,
-0.0181850679,
-0.0306626707,
-0.0358571857,
0.0384854451,
-0.0126626929,
0.0168754961,
0.0127223674,
0.0265489854,
0.0141758947,
-0.052274134,
-0.0059037432,
-0.0683038011,
-0.0004897752,
-0.0209890325,
-0.0929797366,
0.0181966592,
-0.098728694,
-0.006040615,
0.0326277167,
-0.0142334849,
-0.0476921014,
3.154195267e-34,
0.0497731343,
-0.0482162051,
-0.0011601041,
0.0517625995,
0.0129483333,
-0.0568611883,
-0.054744985,
0.0144457938,
0.0148176597,
-0.0796517879,
-0.0539092124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11189v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11189v1 | BioREx: Improving Biomedical Relation Extraction by Leveraging Heterogeneous Datasets | 2023-06-19T22:48:18 | 2023-06-19T22:48:18 | Po-Ting Lai, Chih-Hsuan Wei, Ling Luo, Qingyu Chen, Zhiyong Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Biomedical relation extraction (RE) is the task of automatically identifying
and characterizing relations between biomedical concepts from free text. RE is
a central task in biomedical natural language processing (NLP) research and
plays a critical role in many downstream applications, such as literature-based
discovery and knowledge graph construction. State-of-the-art methods were used
primarily to train machine learning models on individual RE datasets, such as
protein-protein interaction and chemical-induced disease relation. Manual
dataset annotation, however, is highly expensive and time-consuming, as it
requires domain knowledge. Existing RE datasets are usually domain-specific or
small, which limits the development of generalized and high-performing RE
models. In this work, we present a novel framework for systematically
addressing the data heterogeneity of individual datasets and combining them
into a large dataset. Based on the framework and dataset, we report on BioREx,
a data-centric approach for extracting relations. Our evaluation shows that
BioREx achieves significantly higher performance than the benchmark system
trained on the individual dataset, setting a new SOTA from 74.4% to 79.6% in
F-1 measure on the recently released BioRED corpus. We further demonstrate that
the combined dataset can improve performance for five different RE tasks. In
addition, we show that on average BioREx compares favorably to current
best-performing methods such as transfer learning and multi-task learning.
Finally, we demonstrate BioREx's robustness and generalizability in two
independent RE tasks not previously seen in training data: drug-drug N-ary
combination and document-level gene-disease RE. The integrated dataset and
optimized method have been packaged as a stand-alone tool available at
https://github.com/ncbi/BioREx. | [
0.0279647019,
0.0456528217,
0.0104597546,
0.0270159207,
-0.0007606795,
0.0231669657,
-0.0178352986,
0.0158261042,
0.0312665626,
-0.0243884828,
-0.0655702129,
-0.0066110766,
-0.0108157992,
0.0565508492,
-0.0005114866,
-0.0076234909,
0.0234542489,
0.0554484203,
0.0498680472,
0.0238633342,
-0.0117229922,
0.021798227,
-0.0130661381,
0.0168237742,
0.0071476758,
-0.0115761748,
0.0575906597,
-0.0169027708,
0.0669416711,
-0.0554161035,
0.0240860078,
0.0216420088,
0.0061237225,
-0.0132159432,
0.0000016172,
-0.0646294504,
-0.0352035761,
0.0450201295,
-0.0128899738,
-0.0473568216,
0.0055442187,
-0.0440406688,
0.0394206233,
-0.0140530765,
-0.063391,
-0.0550916083,
0.0359705202,
0.0602571778,
-0.0053059435,
0.044554323,
-0.0355733484,
-0.0209321789,
0.0387416892,
-0.0323884189,
0.0030525066,
0.0057735778,
0.0796116889,
0.009191446,
0.0207172073,
-0.0341722853,
0.0108723892,
0.0014359086,
-0.028772844,
-0.0029170723,
0.0582424961,
0.0315713622,
-0.0256137438,
-0.0209558289,
-0.0135407578,
0.1189024374,
-0.0226111636,
0.0112764109,
0.0438068733,
0.0077830721,
-0.044737529,
0.0425429344,
-0.0126388762,
-0.0211655758,
-0.0528301261,
0.0426140949,
-0.0088386638,
-0.0187995341,
0.0472329296,
-0.0206046198,
0.0077573159,
0.0409278423,
-0.0054277414,
-0.0087808929,
0.0310143288,
-0.0061849831,
-0.0155341038,
-0.0052087726,
0.0378665999,
0.0082009472,
0.0038187352,
0.0367785059,
-0.0127627682,
-0.0419959985,
0.057493791,
-0.0508257449,
-0.0170713756,
-0.0311874412,
-0.0325197168,
0.0486137047,
-0.0369807258,
-0.0452640839,
-0.0242755301,
0.0004852451,
0.0071664001,
-0.0062448685,
-0.0739752278,
0.0077655036,
0.0217745099,
0.0694314614,
-0.0294694211,
-0.0108058127,
-0.0622152537,
-0.013794153,
-0.0212664958,
-0.0011822459,
0.0388922542,
0.0378471091,
-0.038532272,
0.0069397585,
0.0022334433,
0.0015673698,
0.0141977435,
0.0231636949,
-0.0553237461,
-0.0478215516,
-0.0213954505,
-0.0370084345,
0.0593022965,
-0.0549272299,
0.0113167791,
0.0971611366,
0.0011813956,
-0.052789215,
0.0317619517,
-0.0433760732,
0.015231207,
-0.040448349,
0.019849956,
-0.0277345218,
0.0767564252,
-0.0077550798,
-0.0224182568,
-0.0243125781,
0.0389360748,
-0.0193288196,
-0.0928261653,
0.0724754557,
-0.0498963818,
-0.0310981572,
-0.0079163862,
0.0136320209,
-0.0155336838,
0.016063543,
0.0436458699,
-0.0498147532,
0.0261472724,
0.0106813731,
-0.0159710534,
-0.0042767348,
0.0100283967,
-0.0639026091,
0.029678518,
0.0214525219,
0.0253668241,
0.0196329318,
0.0012831059,
0.0220998451,
-0.011609951,
-0.0228468031,
-0.0128550455,
0.0428678505,
0.0152139673,
0.0047452496,
0.020144552,
0.0119817015,
0.0285365209,
-0.0373078622,
-0.0258801635,
-0.0084971031,
0.008660472,
0.027197469,
-0.0281939171,
0.0349448994,
0.0260474924,
0.0033248111,
-0.0132746287,
-0.0078824926,
-0.0116697671,
-0.0184287764,
0.0824901164,
0.0097437175,
-0.0301641468,
0.0451789573,
0.0931340754,
-0.0160303488,
-0.0092412876,
0.0091314977,
-0.0177402496,
-0.0077292216,
0.0351408124,
-0.0838558152,
-0.0418323763,
-0.0362354144,
-0.0203482062,
0.0103860404,
-0.0019943961,
-0.028864678,
0.0505281761,
-0.0284910314,
-0.0106895454,
0.0220143739,
0.0165937264,
-0.0121686738,
-0.0052155075,
0.0152567001,
-0.0182578117,
-0.0155532723,
0.003338272,
0.047227297,
-0.0401421078,
-0.0339126512,
0.012342656,
-0.0039021298,
0.0378866717,
0.0202474371,
-0.0281733666,
0.0055040256,
0.0604204237,
-0.0724367723,
-0.0224336088,
0.005771297,
-0.0017839333,
-0.0525728539,
0.0261494741,
-0.0285411049,
-0.0099374866,
-0.0138416085,
-0.0603557676,
-0.0109402901,
0.0061755967,
0.0140305376,
0.0404626727,
0.0201930813,
-0.0148872379,
0.0280745327,
0.026550103,
-0.0337009169,
0.0271268822,
0.024862567,
-0.0224273317,
-0.0054455716,
-0.1008040607,
0.0046962374,
0.0122958981,
0.0187225658,
0.0032387783,
-0.0231284574,
-0.0244302806,
-0.005595034,
-0.0080475751,
-0.0306811277,
0.0230493341,
-0.0368748307,
0.0287182108,
0.0505529083,
0.0549853407,
0.0199755467,
0.0021809833,
0.01841419,
-0.0241487045,
-0.021538619,
0.0018992301,
-0.0270495992,
-0.0082996963,
0.0608108155,
0.0201878008,
-0.0035707785,
-0.0434471257,
-0.0243609883,
-0.0607025288,
0.0605817214,
0.0182313044,
-0.0551338345,
0.0475982465,
0.0051688128,
-0.0346910395,
0.0357180052,
-0.0214025062,
0.0165637676,
-0.0280202795,
0.0336609557,
-0.0208420418,
0.0002794364,
-0.0209775176,
0.0239773598,
0.052012153,
0.0191478431,
0.0127231907,
0.0210841447,
-0.0488092564,
0.0349019431,
0.0038154656,
-0.0173432305,
-0.0113221919,
0.0419049039,
0.0223621503,
-0.0238869991,
0.004878608,
0.0124967471,
0.0138131548,
0.0226179194,
-0.0425835028,
0.0300248209,
0.0041036522,
-0.0146872401,
-0.0378402509,
-0.0240443945,
0.0814190656,
0.0184089113,
0.0222875252,
-0.0519980825,
-0.0079511097,
-0.0407480225,
0.0331395939,
-0.000218664,
0.0161459837,
0.0450414903,
0.0062699816,
0.0165048819,
-0.0105173197,
0.0196566768,
-0.0395579189,
0.049369067,
-0.0427838489,
0.0513465554,
-0.0072167553,
-0.0290367901,
-0.0364403799,
0.0335170999,
-0.0338808969,
0.0261060577,
0.0102306381,
-0.0333964564,
-0.0023378255,
-0.000940606,
-0.0139667792,
0.0155558409,
0.0032473586,
-0.0172069166,
-0.0031990437,
0.040744476,
0.0822325051,
-0.0311049689,
-0.0174553934,
0.0214816928,
0.0150157986,
0.059936516,
-0.0359044187,
-0.0054297517,
0.0086681545,
0.0218253359,
-0.0101593453,
-0.0255376231,
0.0480444245,
-0.0165692698,
0.0241636187,
-0.0420784988,
-0.0117308991,
0.0538635142,
0.0248098634,
-0.0332575813,
0.0217391048,
0.0118877962,
-0.0440922342,
0.0124159539,
0.0381616764,
-0.0890941247,
-0.0410073549,
-0.0364736542,
-0.0198564623,
-0.0055379928,
-0.0649734288,
-0.0134703852,
-0.0389171168,
0.0023552624,
-0.0156175243,
-0.0633921549,
-0.0244098473,
-0.075680919,
-0.002676165,
-0.0455605201,
-0.0204273947,
-0.0433699042,
-0.0269712079,
-0.0125320153,
0.0182747077,
-0.0326935239,
-0.0956808403,
0.0135353068,
-0.0209320281,
0.0305113643,
0.0065421434,
0.0429340489,
0.000539994,
0.0340309441,
0.0201259106,
-0.0099583063,
-0.0388531052,
-0.0106115127,
0.0963980183,
-0.0111004822,
-0.0236527696,
-0.0489671938,
0.0392853916,
-0.0796618983,
-0.0181791168,
-0.0007876993,
0.0882414281,
0.0096928095,
-0.0218036566,
-0.0526407771,
-0.0445459373,
0.010712035,
0.0454083309,
-0.0169338286,
0.0207661353,
-0.0579965338,
0.0263407435,
0.029992545,
-0.0364972688,
0.0134080509,
-0.0176171791,
-0.0922645256,
0.0260785185,
-0.0484417714,
-0.0080733886,
0.0388803296,
-0.0365703888,
0.0231612884,
0.0254872851,
0.0522718988,
-0.007385741,
-0.0906653777,
0.052334629,
0.0481964275,
0.0007950549,
0.0001169252,
-0.0481021926,
0.0385513417,
-0.0020096309,
-0.0182383042,
0.0054167132,
-0.014029447,
-0.0381372757,
-0.0394863039,
0.0164141506,
0.0156968366,
0.0247244686,
0.0128745642,
0.0242201537,
0.0554777794,
0.0634969026,
-0.062788792,
-0.0475644693,
0.0042807199,
-0.0176212005,
-0.0107430192,
0.0281398669,
-0.0209507849,
0.0303543862,
0.0095573915,
0.0341825709,
-0.0124429502,
0.0042150663,
0.0412073955,
0.0199894197,
0.053914018,
0.0143631138,
-0.0104534086,
-0.0790210292,
0.0092474185,
-0.039702151,
0.0263430029,
-0.0430596955,
0.0255666245,
0.0146207036,
-0.003549987,
-0.0171522852,
-0.005445282,
-0.0391026475,
-0.006206024,
-0.004518046,
0.003742171,
0.0172430184,
-0.0176337902,
0.0619378276,
-0.0365015119,
0.0091885468,
-0.0099535864,
-0.0066130809,
-0.0185379833,
-0.0275496449,
-0.0057982639,
0.0026362541,
0.0093415091,
-0.0232444815,
0.0198897477,
-0.0247722249,
0.0433993302,
-0.0152109107,
-0.0116097499,
0.0494419597,
-0.0239380915,
0.056073565,
-0.0034569977,
-0.0092429239,
0.0018666952,
0.0587009564,
-0.0652024895,
0.0542786196,
0.0424932241,
0.0191287007,
-0.0442638844,
-0.0141054476,
0.0878636092,
0.0039985483,
0.0669046417,
0.01222659,
-0.0560315512,
-0.0291102454,
-0.0153097799,
0.0194498878,
0.0118599543,
-0.0527824014,
0.0009515311,
-0.039930813,
-0.0371135101,
0.0399529673,
-0.03962069,
-0.0228087138,
0.0241746437,
0.0075602825,
-0.0027076739,
0.0531902984,
-0.0818787366,
-0.023396723,
0.0430279225,
-0.0340139046,
-0.0304845385,
-0.0107656075,
-5.626230408e-33,
0.028119579,
-0.0439589545,
-0.0126959141,
-0.0072258441,
0.0105397217,
0.0557980277,
-0.0402839296,
-0.0443672352,
-0.0044804784,
0.0720643252,
0.0150937168,
0.0081098359,
-0.0029451801,
0.0073408424,
0.0016232226,
-0.0119439401,
0.0076898006,
0.0039367075,
0.0349910967,
-0.0067227716,
0.0366151966,
0.1078836247,
0.0611315891,
-0.081961289,
-0.0152989412,
0.0160210058,
0.0444894508,
0.0128677757,
-0.0016793564,
0.0429431722,
-0.0740809143,
0.0532747284,
0.0285798386,
-0.025527833,
0.0232087765,
0.0069536106,
-0.1133163869,
-0.0163120609,
-0.0159290452,
-0.0384720303,
-0.0192469433,
0.009577889,
0.0420456491,
0.0203807428,
0.0252409242,
-0.0520563833,
0.0655393526,
-0.0375936106,
-0.0448814146,
-0.060146872,
-0.0660309866,
0.0273688529,
0.0295053441,
0.0021095502,
0.0333728194,
-0.0031426183,
-0.0064193746,
0.0219546854,
-0.0285128262,
-0.0378555842,
-0.0141700134,
0.0220942087,
0.0027144665,
-0.0093028545,
0.0068612886,
0.0552718341,
-0.0051537678,
0.0012489171,
0.014616007,
0.0214637034,
-0.0575445928,
0.0796249434,
-0.0509703159,
0.0127531253,
0.0528426655,
0.0214822106,
-0.1352656633,
0.0078031495,
0.0005824357,
0.035416089,
-0.0520544611,
-0.0264060721,
0.023756152,
0.0135920718,
0.0110963862,
0.0414110608,
-0.0106729288,
-0.0160774756,
-0.0190863963,
-0.0319393016,
-0.0047072591,
0.0528388098,
-0.0339539573,
-0.0368591771,
-0.0518043227,
0.0211528167,
0.0335740112,
-0.0096750883,
0.0086168358,
-0.0184644572,
-0.0579707548,
-0.0502040721,
-0.000640637,
-0.0309786145,
0.0555217601,
0.001825085,
0.0533627607,
-0.0397045948,
-0.0183135271,
-0.0245906916,
-0.0318023451,
0.002698886,
0.0138001591,
0.0751041993,
-0.012574858,
0.0761881694,
-0.0002843552,
0.0652669147,
0.0526245013,
0.0228499174,
-0.0106608169,
0.0534434691,
0.01287561,
0.0152750732,
0.000027772,
-0.0318685807,
-0.0209776834,
0.042388767,
0.0172919948,
-0.0559170172,
-0.0147910845,
-0.0157342665,
2.555e-7,
0.0883385465,
0.0298451353,
0.0311000235,
-0.0139464522,
0.0193271451,
0.0105181281,
-0.0173193589,
0.0588536263,
-0.0436454304,
-0.0115441829,
0.0036100999,
-0.0069770319,
0.0029412117,
0.0391084626,
-0.0397201627,
-0.0604948364,
-0.0563943796,
-0.0871031657,
-0.0361127816,
-0.023124665,
0.0389482416,
0.0515788496,
0.0191318933,
-0.0277237315,
-0.002702012,
0.0277141798,
0.0267447177,
-0.027987659,
0.0010951301,
0.0624170974,
-0.0141943041,
-0.0103857806,
-0.028471062,
0.0781781375,
-0.0485966168,
-0.0010949997,
-0.0093590301,
0.0663939565,
-0.0526231863,
0.0058499617,
0.0488436297,
0.0087805893,
0.0544910729,
0.0201243907,
0.0395098701,
-0.055245515,
-0.0460869297,
-0.0097858589,
0.0080022747,
0.0340618901,
0.0184940435,
-0.0046874112,
0.0330926031,
0.0413101278,
0.0272383224,
0.0188076347,
-0.0514093675,
-0.0914652869,
-0.0005549351,
0.1015500426,
-0.0155268712,
0.0039809826,
0.0306845978,
-0.0187207162,
0.0182636064,
-0.0505879112,
0.0245604273,
2.059717961e-34,
-0.0153341796,
-0.003040554,
-0.0005605823,
0.0436481386,
0.0236473903,
-0.0530591048,
-0.0344442353,
-0.000073738,
-0.0357272141,
-0.0532889999,
0.0299491677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11174v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11174v1 | Evaluating Privacy Questions From Stack Overflow: Can ChatGPT Compete? | 2023-06-19T21:33:04 | 2023-06-19T21:33:04 | Zack Delile, Sean Radel, Joe Godinez, Garrett Engstrom, Theo Brucker, Kenzie Young, Sepideh Ghanavati | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Stack Overflow and other similar forums are used commonly by developers to
seek answers for their software development as well as privacy-related
concerns. Recently, ChatGPT has been used as an alternative to generate code or
produce responses to developers' questions. In this paper, we aim to understand
developers' privacy challenges by evaluating the types of privacy-related
questions asked on Stack Overflow. We then conduct a comparative analysis
between the accepted responses given by Stack Overflow users and the responses
produced by ChatGPT for those extracted questions to identify if ChatGPT could
serve as a viable alternative. Our results show that most privacy-related
questions are related to choice/consent, aggregation, and identification.
Furthermore, our findings illustrate that ChatGPT generates similarly correct
responses for about 56% of questions, while for the rest of the responses, the
answers from Stack Overflow are slightly more accurate than ChatGPT. | [
0.0420311317,
0.0630617365,
-0.0438457094,
-0.0312811397,
-0.0693131238,
-0.0202051606,
0.0874217376,
-0.019890083,
0.0701130852,
-0.0386124626,
0.0017134553,
-0.0297672953,
0.0306782573,
0.0190873593,
-0.0379710421,
-0.0054832986,
-0.011106031,
-0.0096125081,
0.0041094683,
0.015981257,
0.0150479982,
0.0100611141,
-0.0282847807,
0.044733081,
0.0393858477,
-0.0492010415,
0.0199977811,
-0.002672042,
-0.0074364818,
-0.0462070368,
0.0330530182,
0.0260999743,
-0.0325277336,
-0.0017881341,
0.0000021075,
-0.0676963627,
0.0078770099,
0.06463857,
-0.0328148566,
0.0470196903,
0.0193316173,
0.0599765591,
0.013654951,
0.0458544865,
-0.0202443656,
-0.0118993018,
0.0575080626,
-0.0218446106,
0.0166241359,
0.0143518755,
-0.0326723233,
-0.0209945496,
0.0026436537,
0.0072339512,
0.0586978681,
-0.0080299554,
-0.0190250874,
-0.0333230086,
0.0168048386,
-0.0025527824,
0.0547756813,
-0.0108401654,
0.002679111,
0.0036526902,
0.0145879965,
0.0300455596,
-0.0193021856,
-0.0619826093,
-0.0048693283,
0.0250706244,
0.0878588334,
0.0186433606,
0.027681157,
0.0242917072,
0.0130413808,
0.0638104379,
-0.0303836502,
0.0088532716,
-0.0477291048,
-0.0385898538,
-0.0607363321,
0.0033177901,
0.0046226862,
-0.0274045598,
0.0195734594,
-0.0170707963,
0.0036517405,
0.0020997785,
-0.0179009512,
-0.0234618541,
0.0605920814,
-0.0510062724,
0.0409690775,
-0.0030389193,
0.0465698875,
-0.0141451117,
0.0211173259,
0.0151115851,
0.066691421,
-0.0186752733,
-0.0834548548,
0.0185561888,
-0.007261374,
0.0015125787,
0.023613859,
0.0049474309,
-0.0049248342,
0.0177188385,
0.0130634336,
0.031746909,
-0.0342527628,
0.0162778478,
-0.0060875551,
0.0646191984,
-0.0142821679,
0.0473085083,
0.0014002323,
0.0269463193,
0.0031262168,
0.0441984273,
-0.0358122103,
0.004705511,
0.0122356247,
-0.0027992278,
-0.0221407358,
-0.0960790291,
-0.0446981713,
0.026912719,
-0.0166759174,
-0.0496884212,
0.0218847822,
-0.0394163914,
0.0292592458,
0.0115081565,
-0.0078487778,
0.0867670998,
0.0085621886,
0.0275108144,
-0.0065293908,
-0.0571578331,
0.0135912662,
0.0395498388,
-0.0282933768,
-0.0543699525,
0.01745666,
-0.0017792992,
-0.0435814932,
-0.005892898,
-0.0048912149,
0.0311111603,
-0.0257349201,
0.0234269649,
-0.0018397514,
0.0094605815,
0.0241141766,
0.0729747117,
0.0030973139,
-0.0266041234,
-0.0196747929,
0.0605365336,
0.0291112252,
-0.0339097753,
0.0573626459,
-0.0112269446,
-0.0492573641,
0.0318214484,
0.0770984516,
0.0625633523,
-0.0121185025,
-0.084157519,
-0.0603904277,
0.0471229367,
-0.0250653271,
-0.0036574397,
0.0448209308,
0.0898981467,
0.010783595,
0.017024409,
-0.0674478635,
0.0444398709,
0.002634004,
-0.0079431366,
-0.0375244245,
0.0375101417,
-0.0696934983,
-0.020708967,
-0.0703573823,
0.0474271141,
-0.0196828078,
-0.0040793945,
-0.0027578063,
-0.0282234717,
0.0509274118,
0.0906917304,
-0.036097493,
-0.0097802728,
0.0136324745,
-0.0299895275,
-0.0330680758,
-0.0281463899,
-0.0811957791,
-0.0543418825,
0.0603664219,
0.0117172506,
0.0142247118,
-0.0015234039,
-0.0375562944,
-0.0260287989,
-0.0503994487,
-0.0191228483,
0.0702271834,
0.0160166137,
0.0123534501,
-0.0007320153,
-0.0085719684,
0.0088427393,
-0.0001751592,
0.0339718498,
-0.0012539403,
-0.0061639771,
0.0069856117,
0.0127294334,
0.0188647937,
-0.0057276157,
0.0143341413,
-0.0061426098,
0.0126179187,
0.0374334864,
-0.0038711012,
0.0317156129,
0.0242835768,
0.0402161554,
0.0145550398,
0.0383190475,
0.0059330063,
-0.0022849217,
0.0203470942,
0.0177974999,
-0.0242746007,
-0.0620277114,
0.0039842934,
-0.0030715994,
-0.029827347,
0.0428564325,
0.0029295643,
0.0026498286,
0.0351528525,
0.0026279967,
-0.0382804833,
-0.0016479647,
-0.0579221174,
-0.039732337,
0.0124377888,
-0.0062649325,
0.0074540195,
-0.0479152426,
0.0026195853,
0.0294737052,
0.0142485788,
0.0056165596,
0.0105435085,
-0.069728978,
0.0352301337,
0.0376958475,
0.0131020164,
-0.0564318597,
-0.0101869907,
-0.044493679,
0.0096542006,
-0.0056143547,
0.0216623228,
0.0498334058,
0.0301363878,
0.0096429214,
-0.0186160747,
-0.0773643479,
-0.0543486401,
-0.0573743582,
0.0168322362,
0.0265696049,
-0.0040985732,
-0.0039871279,
0.0241609029,
-0.0153071675,
-0.0319590606,
-0.0232780129,
0.0029924088,
-0.0426957868,
0.0331855491,
0.0171178095,
-0.0436507612,
-0.0392538048,
-0.0115509499,
-0.0398618504,
-0.0090731066,
-0.00843543,
-0.0462103561,
0.0098631131,
0.0371032357,
0.0079657594,
-0.0040681954,
0.0548756532,
0.0028388486,
-0.0215553958,
0.0190710742,
-0.0170602929,
0.0289604943,
-0.0661677122,
0.0662559345,
-0.0197065827,
0.0231418218,
-0.0081184963,
0.0084576318,
0.0499036722,
-0.0406038426,
0.0134684481,
-0.023592921,
-0.0162682757,
0.0280360691,
0.0676390827,
-0.024960937,
-0.0559572168,
0.0318035819,
-0.0182065442,
-0.0075114937,
-0.0241126474,
-0.0394004658,
-0.0232627522,
0.064888142,
-0.0085244831,
0.0353524759,
0.0490140244,
-0.0459547453,
0.0057450752,
-0.0473821461,
0.0744322017,
-0.0766604394,
0.0152020901,
-0.0073549906,
-0.0130981058,
0.00154651,
-0.044713486,
-0.0097244363,
-0.0984758213,
0.0404349081,
-0.0192975309,
-0.0051891706,
-0.0209136866,
0.0463536941,
-0.0177353751,
0.017621927,
0.0066196928,
0.0438418426,
-0.0292668268,
0.0023130893,
-0.0178009421,
-0.0435096063,
-0.0342246108,
-0.0149437664,
0.0170960762,
-0.0107468246,
0.085369885,
0.0329462662,
0.0581822135,
0.0378626548,
-0.040887855,
-0.0061388966,
-0.0283231605,
0.0202958304,
0.0283407904,
0.0761896372,
0.0011540229,
0.0137172807,
0.003335224,
0.0460877046,
-0.0393981077,
-0.0077874507,
0.0210135989,
-0.0240680519,
0.0345150381,
0.0110600255,
-0.0736679509,
0.0433507934,
-0.0222875029,
0.0511501878,
-0.0843062326,
-0.0045701074,
-0.0065964251,
-0.0478970855,
-0.0007933313,
0.0010667217,
-0.0013065787,
0.0440239795,
-0.0474750325,
0.0387977511,
-0.0034741811,
-0.0313806757,
-0.0287441537,
-0.0157365184,
-0.0013316657,
-0.0073926169,
-0.0970556363,
0.0075538629,
0.0557857603,
-0.0128980028,
0.001379976,
0.0793581307,
0.0039295112,
-0.0090789152,
-0.0284845848,
0.0204179361,
-0.0183455795,
-0.0520312674,
0.0283770915,
0.0391054153,
0.0154905776,
0.0410526134,
-0.0199398007,
0.0791808665,
-0.0618874133,
-0.0056271101,
0.0184702594,
-0.0429504476,
-0.0220530909,
-0.0188019387,
-0.0120715098,
-0.0085555566,
0.007953411,
0.0076803779,
0.0142094968,
-0.0143946102,
-0.0011348109,
-0.0359885655,
0.0188900288,
0.0087657515,
0.0459974594,
-0.0121091325,
0.0203934032,
-0.0351779945,
-0.0528106429,
0.0265481491,
-0.0069963722,
-0.0185383111,
0.0273192842,
-0.0478148721,
0.0872649252,
0.0192863811,
-0.0056946762,
-0.0162866116,
-0.0211379267,
-0.0084136249,
0.0264455006,
0.002914656,
0.0048246584,
0.0190431736,
-0.0151370782,
-0.0186978728,
-0.0302733406,
0.0222661626,
-0.0170148592,
0.0006873709,
0.0186797734,
-0.0528462976,
-0.0643673912,
0.0158476569,
-0.0468726009,
0.0578560606,
-0.055865217,
-0.0418038219,
0.036784064,
0.0263762996,
-0.0129803829,
-0.0507113747,
-0.0112036057,
-0.0032482019,
0.0177785605,
-0.0710594878,
-0.0261368062,
-0.0178023465,
0.0341340303,
0.0545751005,
0.0010872143,
0.0565506145,
0.0686504766,
0.029200403,
-0.028040329,
0.0491613969,
0.0076010022,
0.0033171489,
-0.0531556159,
0.0267386194,
-0.031576369,
0.0274646357,
0.0172521789,
-0.0392215811,
0.0005459219,
-0.0352546237,
0.0431654118,
0.0205872599,
0.0314514004,
-0.0005844324,
-0.0112484302,
-0.0410534106,
0.0149680041,
0.0309132673,
0.0503326878,
-0.005720933,
0.0129993903,
-0.0408046767,
0.030782681,
0.0267061647,
0.0325243212,
-0.0718917549,
-0.1075632349,
0.0432072915,
0.0405683108,
-0.0698632374,
0.0511949919,
-0.0376884006,
0.001573035,
0.0030091556,
-0.0262677222,
0.0123396721,
-0.016646143,
-0.0150439898,
0.00528963,
-0.0111600636,
-0.0466357544,
-0.035127297,
0.0444072783,
-0.0590275638,
-0.0376066677,
-0.052080486,
-0.0246764366,
-0.0253858045,
-0.0061317179,
0.0001561477,
0.0692876205,
-0.0079562841,
-0.0352509134,
-0.0260114763,
-0.06779515,
-0.0838497877,
-0.0211975034,
0.0589759946,
0.0011117858,
0.0087950025,
0.0141054606,
0.0147834113,
-0.0244726259,
-0.0381073877,
0.0066180527,
-0.0823049694,
-0.0157365724,
-0.0241303667,
-5.631187688e-33,
0.0294763744,
-0.0425155982,
-0.0240263101,
0.0304257907,
0.0256753676,
-0.0270179976,
-0.0111838803,
0.0361584239,
-0.0616979077,
-0.0463980325,
-0.0050467639,
0.0253600534,
0.0014233186,
0.0102755707,
-0.0193280913,
-0.0321934409,
0.0201093908,
0.0236576069,
-0.009265542,
0.0750358775,
-0.0191695169,
-0.0238863099,
-0.0196242314,
-0.0639898703,
0.0270370096,
-0.0366776437,
0.0073668156,
-0.0213069506,
0.0033215897,
0.0289836433,
0.0043019997,
-0.0063409489,
0.0283492897,
0.0166342296,
0.0021586029,
0.0765670165,
-0.0591718256,
-0.0276125949,
0.0205127709,
-0.0680885389,
0.0348703116,
-0.0377658233,
0.032174468,
-0.0377472565,
0.0079494417,
-0.0316423438,
0.0117746294,
0.0242050923,
0.0010589575,
-0.0248601232,
0.0044592014,
-0.0112708593,
-0.0364166722,
0.0313557386,
-0.0243875813,
0.1178145409,
-0.0115048066,
-0.0031126717,
-0.0088750897,
0.0000055204,
0.0104928771,
-0.0414465889,
-0.0119314101,
-0.0162350554,
0.0195351578,
0.0020054495,
0.0037721246,
0.0105792368,
-0.0468348376,
-0.0172081795,
-0.0035650346,
0.0440910719,
-0.0113919675,
0.0551076643,
0.0014845391,
-0.0551644899,
0.0101203024,
0.0338523276,
0.0185851306,
-0.0109275114,
0.0581978932,
-0.0102360742,
-0.0628341958,
-0.0243924558,
-0.010658809,
0.0052537378,
-0.021500513,
-0.0132533414,
0.0222075991,
-0.0217923988,
-0.0390258282,
-0.019118391,
-0.0261956248,
-0.061207518,
0.0114264851,
-0.0293630771,
0.0145746469,
0.0033370694,
-0.0163780507,
0.021064857,
-0.0247487146,
0.0186713897,
-0.0174131505,
0.0354380645,
0.0469650589,
0.021548247,
-0.0001287306,
-0.0299912281,
-0.0593205392,
-0.014868944,
-0.0207515024,
0.0515891872,
-0.0219421312,
0.0314409733,
0.0067323036,
0.0320852101,
0.0322829373,
0.0054532825,
-0.0071059205,
0.0355574116,
-0.0902677178,
0.0149110919,
-0.0367484465,
0.014425952,
0.0239258241,
-0.0302669257,
0.0094302455,
0.0018414486,
0.1082046106,
0.0300361775,
-0.0127737643,
-0.0527767278,
2.783e-7,
0.0163803417,
-0.0648717359,
-0.001573637,
0.0054566404,
0.036303889,
0.061585065,
0.0310477056,
0.0739921406,
0.0456774011,
-0.0244500563,
-0.0161219575,
-0.0395710431,
0.0509799384,
0.0557835996,
0.0159089472,
-0.0676383823,
0.011832526,
0.0346775651,
-0.0250546839,
0.0736776218,
0.0950586721,
-0.0169094875,
0.0085278042,
-0.0155932,
-0.0080094142,
0.0021111839,
-0.0074283364,
-0.042184595,
0.0034632301,
0.0339604914,
-0.0251992494,
0.1015384644,
0.0402457751,
0.0024448968,
-0.0235375017,
-0.0730915219,
-0.0350098573,
0.03799247,
0.0384946205,
-0.0044333697,
0.0182419308,
-0.0566224456,
0.0398765132,
-0.0750642866,
0.0497106314,
-0.0001377752,
-0.0520839915,
-0.0286638476,
0.0399508215,
-0.0598549023,
0.0363921225,
0.0220521353,
-0.0262397937,
-0.0205559153,
0.0062695243,
-0.0016059211,
-0.0180972833,
-0.0165048316,
0.0185415223,
0.0173506793,
0.0148107558,
-0.0699871331,
0.0203990806,
0.0414220989,
-0.011554284,
0.0297291242,
0.0487298593,
2.10963813e-34,
-0.0278008636,
0.0211662184,
-0.0120976483,
-0.0098963426,
0.0501305014,
0.0247322153,
0.0969097838,
-0.0041975793,
-0.0060678828,
0.0120357312,
0.0301920976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11167v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11167v4 | Large Language Models are Fixated by Red Herrings: Exploring Creative Problem Solving and Einstellung Effect using the Only Connect Wall Dataset | 2023-06-19T21:14:57 | 2023-11-08T20:47:00 | Saeid Naeini, Raeid Saqur, Mozhgan Saeidi, John Giorgi, Babak Taati | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | The quest for human imitative AI has been an enduring topic in AI research
since its inception. The technical evolution and emerging capabilities of the
latest cohort of large language models (LLMs) have reinvigorated the subject
beyond academia to the cultural zeitgeist. While recent NLP evaluation
benchmark tasks test some aspects of human-imitative behaviour (e.g.,
BIG-bench's 'human-like behavior' tasks), few, if not none, examine creative
problem solving abilities. Creative problem solving in humans is a well-studied
topic in cognitive neuroscience with standardized tests that predominantly use
the ability to associate (heterogeneous) connections among clue words as a
metric for creativity. Exposure to misleading stimuli - distractors dubbed red
herrings - impede human performance in such tasks via the fixation effect and
Einstellung paradigm. In cognitive neuroscience studies, such fixations are
experimentally induced by pre-exposing participants to orthographically similar
incorrect words to subsequent word-fragments or clues. The popular British quiz
show Only Connect's Connecting Wall segment essentially mimics Mednick's Remote
Associates Test (RAT) formulation with built-in, deliberate red herrings, which
makes it an ideal proxy dataset to explore and study fixation effect and
Einstellung paradigm from cognitive neuroscience in LLMs. In this paper we
present the novel Only Connect Wall (OCW) dataset and report results from our
evaluation of selected pre-trained language models and LLMs on creative problem
solving tasks like grouping clue words by heterogeneous connections, and
identifying correct open knowledge domain connections in respective groups. We
synthetically generate two additional datasets: OCW-Randomized, OCW-WordNet to
further analyze our red-herrings hypothesis in language models. The code and
link to the dataset are available at https://github.com/TaatiTeam/OCW. | [
0.0243503191,
0.0281446148,
-0.0418584459,
0.0209720861,
-0.0450266562,
0.0323079228,
0.0437578224,
0.01492914,
-0.0222084001,
-0.0308685862,
-0.0475579724,
-0.0266724117,
0.0080926754,
0.017178135,
0.0469765216,
0.0168601293,
0.0476512574,
-0.0342138372,
0.0319609754,
-0.0044165091,
-0.0604662448,
0.0150506338,
-0.019528158,
0.0492574163,
-0.0046299798,
-0.0135567766,
0.0010950057,
-0.0121686179,
0.0090061836,
-0.0408829041,
-0.0163866095,
0.1014333442,
0.0136215249,
0.0533822663,
0.0000022944,
-0.0699776709,
0.0292180423,
-0.0346411802,
0.0049973456,
-0.0041168956,
-0.023077853,
0.047633037,
-0.0162268188,
0.0106312027,
-0.0224367566,
0.0130250249,
0.0623283833,
0.0835802928,
0.0060846028,
0.0672616512,
0.0060276925,
-0.0233809389,
0.0519831032,
-0.043851275,
0.0683867559,
-0.0122008193,
0.0419252142,
0.011541646,
-0.0114790723,
-0.0167311076,
-0.0563430749,
0.0049091326,
0.0199987143,
0.0257726107,
0.0167857185,
0.0481390953,
-0.0392163582,
-0.0183032732,
0.0103158988,
0.0632463768,
-0.0439671874,
-0.0278993156,
-0.0132117607,
-0.0005337762,
0.0037542952,
0.060907051,
-0.0500309393,
0.0452594347,
-0.0001242752,
-0.0190789923,
0.0506147407,
-0.027161926,
0.0008870097,
0.0194017645,
0.0173310656,
0.0376114286,
0.020694565,
-0.0458233058,
0.0166984666,
-0.0060542151,
-0.050651297,
-0.0841999277,
-0.0050007841,
-0.0135087948,
-0.037700668,
0.0208355803,
-0.0279926322,
-0.0366766788,
0.0242934693,
-0.0246864818,
0.0608013198,
0.0305883419,
0.0182989854,
0.0429722257,
-0.0102146147,
0.0678273737,
-0.0205979422,
0.0856019333,
-0.0566749722,
0.0379037336,
-0.0443739779,
-0.0279426966,
-0.0136199575,
0.0030051437,
-0.0363625586,
-0.0703035966,
-0.0170476232,
0.0207394958,
-0.0262773465,
-0.0261067562,
-0.0369902551,
0.024636142,
-0.0083328364,
-0.015281735,
-0.0401799195,
-0.0013664684,
-0.0214185864,
0.0371998549,
-0.0012599331,
-0.0246454775,
-0.0424012914,
0.0149643198,
-0.0075481734,
-0.0696015283,
0.0315637141,
0.007528577,
-0.0148791037,
-0.050960198,
0.0004279306,
-0.0145687703,
0.0304831341,
-0.0417488925,
0.0701648444,
-0.0748839229,
0.0446795523,
0.0015785622,
-0.0155155724,
-0.0740781724,
-0.0026763934,
0.0482543521,
-0.0448399261,
0.0259093381,
-0.0243488643,
0.0384342112,
-0.0026574035,
0.0230321977,
-0.0037440804,
0.018916728,
0.0524556823,
0.0313270763,
0.0042287977,
-0.0315544754,
0.0283474233,
-0.0030545893,
0.0121754985,
-0.0027681121,
-0.0083437208,
-0.0288453288,
0.0407815129,
0.0655911118,
0.0439197905,
0.0501305424,
-0.0043732109,
0.0279471017,
0.0747353956,
0.0729692578,
0.0053493283,
0.0247979201,
0.011227482,
-0.0069450545,
0.0248881746,
0.0108395433,
-0.071251817,
0.0627957359,
0.0037918412,
0.0286075585,
0.026436463,
0.0285934471,
-0.0127005866,
0.0189663637,
-0.0131575381,
0.0345939174,
0.0122739365,
0.010053074,
0.0253629256,
0.0353185274,
-0.0547808744,
-0.0054579289,
0.0104120513,
-0.0057787457,
-0.0274963826,
-0.0281271879,
0.0623629913,
0.0344835408,
0.0520186573,
-0.0119567551,
-0.0241770595,
-0.0118974987,
0.0218853783,
0.0666348338,
0.0273706187,
-0.0043071136,
-0.0133517152,
0.0045807324,
0.0103817079,
-0.0440102667,
0.0062433425,
0.0131269423,
-0.0178754125,
-0.0092342291,
-0.0411676429,
0.0054700635,
-0.0320921838,
0.0500778742,
-0.0556158088,
-0.0314717442,
-0.0212277342,
0.0039498121,
0.0268813409,
0.0126314424,
-0.0657340512,
0.0375538878,
0.0124724628,
-0.0218121,
-0.0310607459,
0.0071134111,
-0.0318031795,
-0.0063714939,
0.0189360566,
-0.0499089807,
-0.0195716061,
0.0208914056,
0.021263456,
-0.0232791565,
0.0442693122,
-0.0268898271,
0.0560167953,
-0.0251440667,
0.0294122268,
-0.0119361999,
0.042181883,
-0.0274846889,
0.0775185749,
0.0013978604,
0.0304201916,
-0.0215615034,
-0.0124615105,
0.0005477425,
-0.0309816413,
-0.0256525297,
-0.0066815075,
0.0048902812,
0.0079955691,
-0.0291635599,
0.0012310817,
-0.0746032149,
-0.0206045471,
-0.0751073733,
0.0077380976,
0.0090981014,
0.0042088805,
0.0036805833,
-0.0214457307,
-0.0556336418,
0.0096188812,
-0.000865838,
-0.0362236127,
0.0150474813,
0.0417551883,
-0.0017445411,
-0.0175984018,
-0.0250122342,
-0.0056740767,
-0.006074721,
-0.011282485,
0.0364443213,
0.0196849871,
0.0068397713,
-0.0124466745,
0.0573139042,
-0.0608305931,
-0.0122737633,
-0.0181515198,
-0.0046817232,
0.0243587568,
0.0140320174,
0.0533306897,
0.0538428351,
0.0173203833,
-0.0097060176,
0.0690706,
-0.0271921195,
-0.0152034583,
-0.0006561305,
0.0036341373,
0.0165727586,
0.0229768082,
-0.0589656234,
0.0044015828,
0.0470802411,
0.0467076786,
0.009200735,
-0.0212964732,
0.1044346243,
0.0076460643,
-0.054583177,
-0.0476750359,
-0.0366129987,
-0.0538518056,
0.0564235486,
-0.042620685,
-0.0588124506,
0.0478051752,
-0.0117841214,
0.0141056655,
-0.0384260751,
0.0300006103,
-0.0206958558,
0.0436168201,
0.0050754063,
0.0160487592,
0.0136976987,
0.0070707239,
-0.0642191395,
0.0058400473,
-0.0092750378,
-0.0453917533,
0.0393163562,
-0.0081054578,
-0.0165544562,
0.0061668134,
-0.0196244419,
-0.0602014512,
-0.0343267657,
-0.0071954327,
-0.0223919284,
0.0752534345,
-0.0064230701,
-0.0293264836,
-0.0144518632,
0.0542371236,
-0.0080844462,
-0.0044313087,
0.0087083429,
0.0101935938,
0.0152161596,
0.0687448904,
0.0154751148,
0.0320300162,
-0.0201702937,
0.0200352948,
0.0058167679,
-0.0047121006,
0.0241977666,
-0.0060712686,
0.0396708809,
0.001923488,
-0.0083319368,
-0.0075225839,
0.0150058502,
0.0456907116,
-0.0255047455,
-0.024546586,
0.0854819417,
0.0454135574,
-0.0068368418,
0.0135349082,
-0.0083567295,
0.0040034833,
0.0269884858,
0.0313250087,
-0.0315737389,
0.0154847084,
0.0189653002,
-0.0119342711,
-0.0211711582,
-0.0394046605,
-0.0332626775,
-0.15393655,
0.0671051815,
0.001759277,
-0.0822007582,
0.0163978897,
-0.027869612,
-0.0065343007,
0.0413697511,
-0.0041771051,
0.0083206352,
0.0013295172,
0.0106667187,
-0.0259517115,
0.0318086408,
-0.0209942404,
0.0103070624,
-0.0554506779,
0.1126469523,
0.0273094662,
0.0195057355,
-0.0090939663,
-0.0758839175,
0.0309529714,
-0.0239074249,
0.0240676366,
-0.0161966961,
0.0438589826,
0.0200140942,
0.0139872069,
-0.0299859922,
0.0229998194,
-0.0495659485,
-0.0565776154,
-0.0053962036,
0.0600325912,
-0.0154038034,
-0.0069863568,
-0.0122999037,
0.0418671854,
-0.00978518,
0.0599987842,
0.0217541642,
-0.0547542423,
0.0040103672,
0.0135059049,
0.0139668034,
-0.0549886674,
-0.0249188393,
0.0082498649,
-0.0276175905,
0.0229991656,
-0.0781515539,
-0.0259960908,
0.0189877078,
0.0301695876,
0.0336295329,
0.0463668071,
-0.0741605759,
-0.0365978703,
-0.0184388403,
0.0648554862,
0.0234276541,
0.0297059529,
-0.0232588053,
-0.0202498343,
-0.019556962,
-0.0883489251,
-0.0309481341,
0.0073511275,
-0.093190074,
-0.0619472414,
0.0373858549,
0.0084446529,
0.0233238023,
0.0249645915,
0.0188097563,
-0.0598370172,
0.001484046,
0.007908605,
0.0249309782,
0.0634597018,
-0.0401812457,
0.0337276198,
0.0183910001,
0.0049387217,
-0.0302437246,
0.0412943289,
0.0929451957,
0.0365690477,
0.0041971961,
0.0326880105,
0.0230230559,
0.0321609452,
0.0206187163,
-0.0127026634,
0.0323552787,
-0.0767321438,
-0.0241177771,
0.0111245485,
-0.0183543153,
-0.0161025003,
-0.0502881184,
0.0399981216,
-0.0044872384,
-0.0069767162,
-0.0214170758,
-0.0063100285,
0.0021118775,
-0.0418308564,
-0.0119012306,
0.0074734846,
-0.0050633769,
-0.0083650509,
0.0434727147,
0.0026576086,
0.0881636515,
-0.0315224119,
0.0845762119,
0.0260517839,
0.07268098,
0.0149367265,
-0.0077113872,
-0.0573752485,
0.0245195068,
-0.0462455824,
-0.0505957119,
0.0355795175,
0.0585319884,
0.0620285124,
-0.0335545801,
0.0192077849,
-0.0135879209,
0.0198370889,
-0.0135722468,
0.0000964694,
-0.0269443151,
-0.0452890582,
-0.002366676,
0.0273972824,
0.0204764251,
-0.005806739,
0.0539534353,
-0.0440246165,
-0.0041030957,
0.0029854497,
-0.0252529215,
-0.0137607399,
0.0229421481,
0.0267072227,
0.0473911613,
-0.0097877067,
0.0417697318,
-0.0698620677,
-0.0767023936,
0.0392822586,
0.0059268964,
0.0476813167,
-0.0026466977,
0.0091253994,
0.0511377938,
-0.022752637,
-0.0221201852,
0.0005910864,
0.0028205353,
-0.0703895614,
-0.0428491607,
-0.0493081696,
-7.013698716e-33,
-0.0318580344,
-0.0334370621,
0.0290556643,
-0.0105666658,
-0.031968955,
0.0063616354,
-0.0537559018,
0.0333721712,
-0.0120898923,
0.0141089419,
-0.0516393371,
-0.0114574172,
-0.0019514372,
-0.0129725197,
-0.0061087972,
-0.0089327097,
-0.0246135369,
-0.0011493572,
-0.0431345776,
-0.0329057463,
0.0687647611,
-0.0025503181,
0.0253160093,
-0.0585615523,
-0.0170364361,
-0.0158466268,
0.0052088089,
-0.0204952825,
-0.0187322721,
0.0383301266,
-0.0112676714,
0.0349467099,
0.0550125763,
-0.022095874,
-0.0058418503,
0.0115753133,
-0.0259182118,
-0.0452355556,
0.0155446837,
-0.0256893169,
0.0020703059,
-0.0432248972,
0.0557259284,
-0.0198623948,
-0.0338821448,
0.0158364084,
0.0268594641,
-0.0165981688,
-0.0290856268,
0.0143461814,
-0.0978497863,
-0.017796427,
-0.0053282767,
-0.0537930578,
-0.037546698,
-0.0438402332,
-0.0025287776,
-0.0237608552,
-0.0936928466,
0.0516500846,
-0.0105506396,
-0.0039404673,
0.0375073664,
0.0176878534,
-0.0078476071,
0.0568161607,
0.0692458749,
0.0518587194,
-0.0064112633,
0.0239768084,
0.0033672813,
0.0541647263,
0.0340300426,
0.0083589228,
0.0790029913,
-0.0475493297,
0.0201762952,
0.0003962935,
-0.0069636707,
-0.0115420213,
0.0645906106,
0.0065707341,
-0.0139655191,
-0.0198993031,
-0.0190908965,
-0.0241494365,
-0.0268821251,
-0.0320798606,
0.0480554886,
-0.0032582737,
-0.0101371668,
-0.0560983531,
0.0405165628,
-0.0114024831,
0.0850875378,
-0.0413409956,
-0.0426002257,
0.0411301814,
-0.01736583,
-0.0535065494,
-0.063270472,
-0.0189459119,
0.0371647328,
0.0446721278,
0.0453536287,
0.0013183982,
0.0101519208,
-0.0086403377,
-0.0297210235,
0.003031584,
-0.0413653962,
0.0011383608,
0.0534122474,
-0.0412472859,
0.034873005,
0.0054435423,
-0.0244638752,
-0.0412951745,
0.0429228619,
-0.0207034219,
-0.0172148999,
-0.007785432,
-0.0579950325,
-0.0093759177,
-0.0094352942,
0.0229908116,
-0.011509655,
-0.0334858596,
0.0391285196,
-0.0846841857,
-0.0337960832,
-0.0118522113,
3.28e-7,
0.0075064092,
0.0498155169,
-0.0059972028,
0.0728890449,
0.0289208721,
-0.0186644215,
-0.0146666998,
-0.0072308294,
0.0516728684,
0.0226684511,
0.002058445,
0.0444146134,
0.0072810594,
-0.0078285402,
-0.0712053478,
0.0076329866,
-0.0672674999,
0.0542234443,
-0.0554990023,
-0.0209054071,
0.0200528838,
0.0413000025,
0.0166438892,
-0.0547078103,
-0.0162123684,
-0.0694265887,
0.035257645,
-0.0090219686,
-0.0016963719,
0.0108263632,
-0.000260457,
0.0005521952,
-0.0083063198,
0.0692842826,
0.0035913121,
0.0094480114,
0.0350124612,
-0.0413542613,
-0.0082123401,
-0.004069203,
-0.0164400823,
0.0138665102,
-0.0124102309,
-0.0579548664,
0.054324463,
-0.0372341126,
-0.03096053,
0.0399021879,
-0.0088092703,
-0.0104233297,
0.059011925,
-0.0155911632,
0.021333728,
-0.0463116579,
0.019762801,
0.0338517502,
-0.0132240187,
-0.0290234573,
-0.004889641,
0.0107704895,
-0.0564164668,
-0.0428857617,
-0.0244048722,
-0.0177147761,
0.0002364873,
-0.0511110015,
-0.0397174507,
3.0848861e-34,
0.0129417973,
-0.0345099904,
0.0284104552,
0.0265009664,
0.0371080525,
-0.0087947445,
0.0502585731,
-0.0128637776,
-0.0067879795,
-0.0941207036,
-0.0239939541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11066v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11066v2 | Adversarial Robustness of Prompt-based Few-Shot Learning for Natural Language Understanding | 2023-06-19T17:01:13 | 2023-06-21T03:56:39 | Venkata Prabhakara Sarath Nookala, Gaurav Verma, Subhabrata Mukherjee, Srijan Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | State-of-the-art few-shot learning (FSL) methods leverage prompt-based
fine-tuning to obtain remarkable results for natural language understanding
(NLU) tasks. While much of the prior FSL methods focus on improving downstream
task performance, there is a limited understanding of the adversarial
robustness of such methods. In this work, we conduct an extensive study of
several state-of-the-art FSL methods to assess their robustness to adversarial
perturbations. To better understand the impact of various factors towards
robustness (or the lack of it), we evaluate prompt-based FSL methods against
fully fine-tuned models for aspects such as the use of unlabeled data, multiple
prompts, number of few-shot examples, model size and type. Our results on six
GLUE tasks indicate that compared to fully fine-tuned models, vanilla FSL
methods lead to a notable relative drop in task performance (i.e., are less
robust) in the face of adversarial perturbations. However, using (i) unlabeled
data for prompt-based FSL and (ii) multiple prompts flip the trend. We further
demonstrate that increasing the number of few-shot examples and model size lead
to increased adversarial robustness of vanilla FSL methods. Broadly, our work
sheds light on the adversarial robustness evaluation of prompt-based FSL
methods for NLU tasks. | [
0.022978384,
0.0317885838,
-0.0116676856,
0.0260215364,
-0.0240405779,
0.0179045983,
0.0762780234,
-0.0298067424,
0.0094058858,
-0.0373624004,
-0.0371142998,
-0.0277979504,
0.0308382716,
-0.0183505584,
0.0370190553,
-0.0458951853,
0.075702779,
-0.0257626846,
0.0052421675,
0.0118813077,
-0.0260942709,
-0.0039518774,
-0.0225568395,
0.0142167285,
0.0531657077,
-0.0253178421,
-0.0171299875,
0.0161585119,
0.0151830856,
-0.0139561696,
-0.0030444672,
0.0814252123,
0.0140307844,
0.0811397657,
0.0000019851,
-0.0503963083,
-0.0199560206,
0.0154512133,
-0.070052959,
0.0072629428,
-0.0062582288,
-0.042114947,
0.0043187207,
-0.0176283699,
-0.0012564611,
-0.0296626631,
0.0201951973,
0.0383882374,
0.0385782123,
0.0624414869,
0.0100815566,
-0.0463857502,
-0.0084251417,
-0.0283627491,
0.0140703069,
-0.0967256799,
0.0091126999,
-0.048787307,
-0.0009024159,
0.013675577,
-0.0375746265,
0.0360856913,
0.0251766704,
0.0345834345,
-0.0334890857,
0.0330229215,
-0.0394174717,
-0.0359100886,
-0.0049502747,
0.1064103022,
-0.0244155526,
0.0024075238,
-0.0234590173,
-0.0303653255,
0.0174977351,
-0.0095458366,
-0.0522825755,
-0.0181149673,
-0.0133640459,
-0.0182262566,
-0.0387872756,
0.0097247865,
0.0355011001,
0.0116822505,
-0.0087281857,
0.004758419,
0.0008487604,
-0.0077009052,
0.008029473,
-0.0332636647,
-0.0566531606,
-0.0364983417,
-0.0258555636,
0.0088106487,
-0.0638225898,
0.0153663633,
-0.0573009178,
-0.0505599417,
0.0112027405,
0.015969025,
0.0569511577,
0.0163651723,
-0.0188814141,
0.0846789777,
-0.0220878385,
0.0497126132,
0.0201553926,
0.0519966967,
-0.0044710077,
0.0152849909,
-0.0600099787,
0.00494088,
-0.0386066586,
0.0231307317,
-0.0246586502,
0.014157692,
-0.0159909129,
0.0090721119,
0.011629927,
0.0515882559,
-0.051995974,
-0.0063952352,
-0.0286256429,
0.0087975869,
0.0295147374,
0.0208505131,
-0.0734291226,
0.0108534638,
0.0258235186,
-0.0731938928,
-0.0628860146,
0.0056740325,
-0.008774817,
-0.0575009026,
-0.0141356569,
0.0569489822,
0.0077629965,
-0.0787690729,
-0.0422984362,
-0.0168039687,
-0.0243191998,
-0.0619309284,
-0.0134482728,
-0.0340018831,
0.0295936726,
-0.0273136552,
-0.0059322338,
-0.0382553712,
-0.0154977841,
0.0009833071,
-0.0377942659,
0.1283226013,
-0.0203904584,
-0.0473039635,
-0.0285713281,
0.0224550515,
-0.0283351168,
0.0736224055,
-0.0376989096,
0.0295078382,
0.0403138474,
-0.0005058862,
0.006148187,
-0.0000833222,
0.0395929106,
0.0056359624,
-0.0111546135,
0.0225128848,
0.0131804403,
0.0430358574,
-0.0120430449,
0.0135141229,
-0.030222632,
-0.0450516082,
0.0694233552,
0.02423287,
-0.0224004686,
-0.0311431605,
0.0295166336,
0.0309586767,
0.0200311355,
0.0197545458,
-0.0851572007,
0.0244518854,
-0.0722748861,
-0.0168598928,
-0.0019802984,
0.0155012226,
-0.0544344857,
-0.0255494639,
-0.0034580138,
-0.0029237233,
-0.0267395359,
0.0164715163,
0.0412390754,
0.0400410034,
-0.0209450647,
-0.022290621,
0.0136791728,
0.018291153,
-0.0273158699,
-0.0292453244,
0.0277904253,
0.0320469253,
0.0327919796,
-0.0357738994,
-0.0330462232,
-0.0411637127,
0.0792406201,
0.0236688051,
0.0485337228,
0.0013519942,
0.0730737746,
-0.0364620127,
-0.0174527802,
-0.0423199348,
0.0100437468,
0.039107088,
-0.0208431091,
-0.0246064197,
-0.0113463141,
-0.0235922895,
0.0173260067,
0.0345410444,
-0.0027139671,
-0.0645111203,
0.0310704503,
0.041856721,
0.0128906993,
0.0205021892,
-0.0219097044,
-0.0002743803,
0.003210821,
0.0078153023,
0.0136951143,
-0.0175303649,
-0.008443201,
-0.0831511095,
-0.0227259248,
0.0099513559,
-0.0685807765,
0.0059677106,
-0.090007849,
-0.0195984021,
-0.0068782489,
0.0131985238,
-0.044089891,
-0.0068441387,
-0.0118977604,
-0.0100014936,
0.055131238,
-0.0622094199,
0.0431825817,
0.0042263628,
0.0103173833,
0.0229218472,
0.0396971889,
0.0241865534,
-0.0166630019,
-0.0355186127,
0.0389080457,
-0.043173898,
-0.0168042984,
-0.0061485535,
-0.000151914,
-0.0586624816,
0.0062826048,
-0.003538999,
0.0160488747,
-0.0344514214,
0.0274682771,
0.008606148,
-0.0029189566,
-0.02584376,
-0.0336415991,
0.0184423458,
0.0153909987,
-0.0223868228,
0.0261121094,
0.0257759187,
0.0327623114,
-0.0068679731,
-0.0192121956,
-0.0021874073,
0.0008845635,
0.0374415442,
0.0172958244,
-0.0195509903,
-0.0106146047,
0.0005125782,
-0.0135372123,
0.0203901473,
-0.0175629593,
-0.0323005579,
0.0270181708,
0.0084013185,
-0.0188774876,
0.0814304873,
-0.0200878531,
0.0288489591,
0.0245956536,
0.0130701428,
-0.0162508041,
0.0224553905,
0.0077755749,
-0.0280167256,
-0.0069798906,
0.0301194079,
0.0083728945,
0.0607307106,
0.0310472902,
-0.0054661362,
-0.0347794592,
0.0774143413,
0.0030300007,
-0.0459287465,
-0.0580808222,
0.0427235141,
0.0020503358,
0.0126881534,
-0.045364283,
-0.0069130454,
0.1023539156,
-0.027668491,
-0.0030663048,
-0.0099067818,
-0.0326087326,
0.0203473065,
0.0393567309,
-0.0024281694,
-0.0030182817,
0.0555363558,
-0.0340999998,
-0.0947794691,
-0.0343791842,
0.03023348,
0.0266449489,
0.0153722875,
0.0016089947,
-0.0183042623,
-0.0290261619,
-0.0286252424,
-0.0535700396,
-0.0987327248,
-0.021358842,
0.0271177124,
-0.0301323216,
0.0286175683,
-0.0305426233,
-0.0225979369,
0.0268170461,
0.0056041777,
-0.0454981402,
-0.0127364844,
-0.0465182625,
0.0513081439,
0.0319542922,
-0.0013312317,
0.0378343873,
-0.0111144362,
0.1036151946,
0.0303815622,
-0.0004934889,
0.0483906679,
-0.0249335375,
0.0112485504,
0.0037652317,
-0.0159413852,
-0.0149159171,
0.0259683169,
0.0768738389,
-0.0471565053,
-0.0024441185,
0.0776813924,
0.0269654281,
-0.0060720788,
-0.0026874011,
0.0238186549,
0.0248797275,
0.0326371491,
0.0192214344,
-0.0647348091,
-0.0644094422,
0.0162559599,
0.0478556827,
-0.0093707787,
-0.0300747547,
-0.0190054011,
-0.1029792801,
0.0127703855,
-0.0126518877,
-0.0614123344,
-0.0053880578,
-0.0284245852,
0.0130498921,
-0.0106041199,
0.0622624457,
0.0079020066,
0.0107336165,
0.0080266902,
0.0026888244,
0.0307536628,
-0.0713103488,
0.0389450267,
-0.039169617,
0.0487682074,
0.0605136864,
0.012928063,
-0.0079386886,
0.0015832108,
0.0292277001,
-0.0305181053,
0.0156897698,
0.0015186988,
0.0656469166,
-0.0039204271,
-0.0264466871,
0.0087179057,
0.0421666019,
0.0059692534,
-0.0276146922,
0.0100673018,
0.0116930231,
-0.0160232764,
-0.0186835974,
0.0166944209,
0.0077154739,
0.013693383,
0.0783253759,
0.0468012057,
-0.0426528826,
-0.0493807904,
-0.0329245776,
-0.0237771589,
-0.069867,
-0.0293495785,
0.0494634211,
0.01701371,
-0.0125512546,
-0.0231681075,
-0.0824996904,
0.0252202488,
0.0254580937,
-0.0312207974,
0.000249115,
-0.0544426255,
0.0174289923,
0.0047894246,
0.0149206128,
-0.0144111756,
0.0301876273,
-0.0204575453,
0.0076532573,
0.0241361931,
-0.0078617353,
-0.0219168533,
0.0076664351,
-0.0845477954,
-0.0425299145,
0.0101003489,
0.0541520827,
0.0083261896,
0.0447888374,
-0.0546404682,
-0.0443357117,
0.0500443876,
0.0835262462,
0.0005230569,
-0.0053623561,
0.061838191,
0.0062664882,
-0.0088572493,
0.0629481599,
-0.0282687955,
0.0014473316,
0.0701610595,
0.0065239561,
-0.0151088852,
0.0348885842,
0.0316804536,
0.0199199338,
0.1024232134,
-0.0252239145,
-0.0347891077,
0.0130885513,
0.0106188655,
0.0121493833,
-0.0212565027,
-0.0018625696,
-0.0214933399,
-0.0050925654,
-0.0494369268,
-0.0021708903,
-0.005377993,
0.000744129,
0.0713362619,
-0.0490637571,
-0.0016844077,
0.031458132,
0.0114447773,
-0.0038220598,
0.0203190707,
-0.0109550133,
0.0737099126,
0.0200977754,
0.0351859182,
-0.0138278902,
0.0775033012,
0.031929452,
0.0096559888,
-0.0250041522,
0.0296276696,
-0.0767537802,
-0.0263437908,
-0.0046445657,
0.0428413786,
0.0239075199,
0.0032543947,
-0.0474868901,
0.0261761397,
-0.0153957941,
-0.0153572131,
0.0184088312,
0.0065863375,
-0.0226592738,
0.044521898,
0.0096009905,
0.007514487,
0.0000486104,
0.0688939691,
-0.001454539,
0.0390444063,
0.0378788225,
0.0348360278,
-0.0520607419,
-0.013353358,
0.0187692922,
0.0038324343,
-0.0065232916,
0.0382907726,
-0.0698304325,
-0.0527154841,
0.0004377218,
-0.0060442123,
0.0024460775,
0.0313293822,
0.0155457901,
0.0441493578,
0.0001556287,
0.0064221546,
-0.0138031365,
0.0088626891,
0.0111452788,
-0.0288989116,
0.025964085,
-6.33418437e-33,
-0.060253758,
-0.0070498292,
0.0009332458,
-0.0384396128,
0.0387153439,
-0.0108933402,
-0.0501515754,
-0.0076895533,
-0.0464234054,
-0.0031055112,
-0.002996952,
-0.0032242513,
0.0019467826,
0.0146128936,
-0.0203155298,
-0.0857242569,
0.0469469242,
-0.0038464626,
-0.049697537,
-0.0193212498,
0.0208253451,
0.0427635983,
0.0417629965,
0.0051035746,
0.0420996398,
0.0254025217,
-0.0306624621,
0.0197221916,
-0.0113881268,
0.0254786182,
0.0296893064,
0.0261582136,
0.0090306653,
-0.0252526049,
-0.0244372282,
0.0126189962,
-0.086512588,
-0.0573560782,
0.0070120394,
0.0236691777,
-0.0355857201,
-0.0052771824,
0.0004904486,
-0.0530749336,
0.059332151,
-0.0215859395,
0.0013033467,
-0.0072978796,
-0.02590199,
-0.0033105845,
-0.0223076195,
0.0118864635,
-0.0349092633,
-0.0368236527,
0.0231446028,
0.0804354548,
0.0196936056,
0.052921243,
-0.0622263104,
-0.0347383171,
0.0151362922,
0.0034060783,
0.0579576269,
0.0192163996,
-0.0018266884,
0.0471184701,
0.0458652675,
0.0089879762,
-0.0206134524,
-0.0007018693,
0.038703002,
0.0219120011,
0.0669158101,
0.1005927697,
0.0387407579,
0.0021146813,
-0.0758066475,
-0.0012889623,
0.0238108002,
0.035393063,
-0.0061353934,
0.0112100802,
-0.0143186282,
-0.0044866093,
-0.0682305992,
-0.0637706071,
-0.0494038612,
0.0047461661,
0.0283665322,
-0.0129726846,
-0.0489117205,
-0.0057581682,
0.0475130677,
-0.037585441,
0.0098254224,
0.0299304966,
-0.0105028991,
-0.0092314323,
0.0183583777,
0.0381587297,
-0.0401227809,
-0.0203142893,
0.027057087,
0.0026235641,
0.0331105366,
0.0038279167,
0.0773929581,
0.0016270354,
-0.0492681153,
-0.0242179986,
-0.0293140598,
0.0473245382,
-0.0014098259,
0.0002864324,
0.058248084,
0.0244734623,
-0.0280412212,
0.0247056764,
0.0309319496,
-0.0368142389,
0.0188460443,
0.0520375408,
-0.0330271795,
-0.0004621169,
-0.0262550469,
-0.0482960083,
0.0073841326,
-0.0133440811,
0.0220890306,
-0.0802584887,
0.0006046972,
0.0029646032,
2.718e-7,
-0.0083193686,
0.0391286761,
0.0032831058,
0.0160990432,
0.0325084217,
0.0589653812,
-0.0290210657,
0.0248192605,
-0.0402280241,
-0.0603705235,
0.0050885458,
0.0223905835,
0.0435624532,
0.035530448,
-0.0875854865,
0.026486624,
-0.0488594957,
0.0383213721,
-0.044023715,
0.0022406341,
0.0657158047,
0.1125802472,
0.006669519,
0.004326548,
0.0350921676,
-0.0385413654,
0.0254240856,
-0.0111304,
0.0132386154,
-0.0151342815,
-0.0008289419,
0.0017015814,
0.0273359362,
0.045612473,
-0.0130726043,
-0.0068114032,
-0.0048207152,
0.0353539363,
0.0077870865,
-0.0272144862,
-0.0512864925,
-0.0231893864,
0.0097266519,
-0.0345735289,
0.1202666387,
-0.1098541319,
-0.044087097,
-0.0147968475,
-0.0176481027,
-0.022128541,
0.0415158197,
0.0015895067,
-0.0188581999,
0.0156458262,
0.015580277,
-0.0040141311,
-0.006692437,
-0.0691170394,
-0.0209435709,
0.0075952876,
-0.0120325424,
-0.0074191606,
-0.0087183518,
-0.0248084478,
0.044244457,
-0.0550316945,
-0.033892002,
2.15887642e-34,
0.0332143344,
-0.0232942346,
0.022158267,
-0.0126814134,
0.0035714936,
-0.0056612133,
-0.0310960617,
-0.0252440963,
0.0532190464,
-0.0249054413,
-0.0129804444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11065v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11065v1 | Cross-Modal Attribute Insertions for Assessing the Robustness of Vision-and-Language Learning | 2023-06-19T17:00:03 | 2023-06-19T17:00:03 | Shivaen Ramshetty, Gaurav Verma, Srijan Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | The robustness of multimodal deep learning models to realistic changes in the
input text is critical for their applicability to important tasks such as
text-to-image retrieval and cross-modal entailment. To measure robustness,
several existing approaches edit the text data, but do so without leveraging
the cross-modal information present in multimodal data. Information from the
visual modality, such as color, size, and shape, provide additional attributes
that users can include in their inputs. Thus, we propose cross-modal attribute
insertions as a realistic perturbation strategy for vision-and-language data
that inserts visual attributes of the objects in the image into the
corresponding text (e.g., "girl on a chair" to "little girl on a wooden
chair"). Our proposed approach for cross-modal attribute insertions is modular,
controllable, and task-agnostic. We find that augmenting input text using
cross-modal insertions causes state-of-the-art approaches for text-to-image
retrieval and cross-modal entailment to perform poorly, resulting in relative
drops of 15% in MRR and 20% in $F_1$ score, respectively. Crowd-sourced
annotations demonstrate that cross-modal insertions lead to higher quality
augmentations for multimodal data than augmentations using text-only data, and
are equivalent in quality to original examples. We release the code to
encourage robustness evaluations of deep vision-and-language models:
https://github.com/claws-lab/multimodal-robustness-xmai. | [
0.0056347745,
0.0788560361,
-0.0016582143,
0.0452681519,
-0.0033476483,
-0.002658078,
-0.0143443346,
-0.0058510266,
-0.0109980805,
-0.055846069,
-0.0215759333,
-0.0196803901,
0.0262397006,
0.040087115,
0.039791137,
-0.0509908758,
0.0316490792,
-0.0086326022,
-0.0262849331,
0.0187599305,
0.0442190096,
-0.0109566106,
-0.0043432619,
0.0297375303,
-0.0406706519,
0.0005236976,
-0.0174423847,
0.0394307114,
0.0447642095,
0.0036532562,
-0.0149432318,
0.029556958,
0.0135668581,
0.036688067,
0.0000018237,
-0.0133944545,
0.0050822445,
0.0434260294,
0.0268474389,
-0.0285129398,
0.0631957203,
-0.0409634523,
-0.0004959459,
-0.0143122217,
0.0149674071,
-0.022191776,
0.0860816836,
0.0628281236,
0.0886465758,
0.0576852076,
-0.0319433138,
0.0094355671,
0.0518486351,
-0.0102532245,
0.0594193339,
-0.001398565,
0.0025570178,
0.0109275375,
0.0129839769,
0.045332294,
-0.0383248888,
0.0676585287,
0.037887767,
-0.0202247761,
-0.0143456282,
0.0196996219,
-0.007870038,
-0.0227186177,
-0.0035607761,
0.0837996602,
-0.0207821615,
0.0084015764,
-0.0364243202,
-0.0076222238,
0.0258934032,
0.0140683763,
-0.0319753028,
0.0053812768,
0.0065944763,
-0.0054561496,
-0.0814270154,
-0.0074023516,
0.0378141403,
0.0068147839,
0.0260248706,
0.0102656037,
0.032366652,
-0.0002031892,
-0.0149214491,
0.0159266479,
-0.0254993904,
-0.034256056,
0.0014350825,
0.0046973401,
-0.0034453531,
-0.0016951897,
-0.0754700452,
-0.0464948826,
0.0021680933,
-0.024345614,
0.0671705976,
0.0233543236,
-0.1114800051,
0.0713837817,
-0.0563072562,
0.0416184999,
-0.0640012249,
0.0643840954,
-0.0342175588,
-0.0384582393,
-0.0267278049,
-0.0187483281,
0.0057604657,
-0.0174397621,
-0.0319634378,
-0.0273846928,
-0.0103459507,
0.0000571338,
-0.0176982731,
0.0152536351,
-0.0060884487,
0.0082369912,
-0.0437180288,
-0.0233904496,
-0.0335160755,
0.030489536,
-0.0206583887,
0.0436108448,
0.0031404071,
-0.0194657836,
0.0027090861,
0.0186027028,
0.0308520049,
-0.0292969272,
0.006229586,
0.0771548972,
-0.0498474166,
-0.0261194296,
0.0007513447,
-0.0543550178,
-0.0312369429,
-0.0412778892,
0.0610778555,
-0.0235155541,
-0.003789223,
-0.0394074246,
-0.010713785,
-0.0417520404,
0.0033652873,
0.024897512,
-0.0028267484,
0.1170391962,
-0.0098843332,
-0.0367573947,
-0.0016676986,
0.003708092,
-0.0126347272,
0.0491102003,
0.0471214838,
0.0553315319,
0.044033099,
0.015218216,
-0.0004848248,
0.02158322,
0.002619307,
0.0262157209,
-0.0300418213,
-0.0249816459,
0.0171302203,
0.0280529223,
0.0002425522,
0.0388780236,
-0.0131947836,
-0.0394175202,
0.0921717361,
-0.0086917318,
0.0298136771,
-0.0107236076,
0.010100632,
-0.0240009483,
-0.0180855077,
-0.0137151564,
-0.0642602444,
0.0701075792,
-0.0220850259,
0.0043413369,
0.0285439119,
0.0475186333,
-0.0143820588,
-0.0333961546,
-0.0043094642,
-0.0023272526,
0.0550003909,
0.0123874554,
0.0325396024,
0.0231789295,
-0.0179870483,
-0.0244119912,
0.0070542218,
-0.0545800626,
0.0093995547,
-0.0242675133,
-0.0013439709,
0.0396898948,
0.0164464992,
-0.0292556453,
0.0018950118,
-0.0034524959,
0.0715399832,
0.0482590422,
-0.0059197983,
0.0251299199,
0.0464611538,
-0.0469897762,
-0.054270044,
-0.0159329008,
0.0016929851,
0.0078021605,
0.0173981115,
0.0216643009,
0.0395986885,
-0.0305504762,
0.0212973114,
0.0490284972,
0.041889295,
0.0130691007,
-0.0073117628,
0.0340253152,
-0.0261563379,
0.0067788088,
-0.004117378,
-0.0002110484,
-0.0136135882,
-0.0242663417,
-0.022183096,
0.0288384091,
-0.0167156365,
-0.008433993,
0.0402936526,
-0.069204092,
-0.0398894176,
0.0284287203,
-0.0086967647,
-0.0104071051,
0.0013480673,
-0.0482736081,
-0.0258597918,
-0.0416963398,
-0.0228438582,
0.0080689155,
0.0402976163,
-0.0018922867,
0.025150504,
-0.0203027707,
-0.0181201026,
-0.0465476066,
0.0178449098,
0.0205526743,
-0.0226971582,
-0.0446743183,
-0.0156843811,
-0.0049632313,
0.0281306934,
0.0086660376,
-0.0186668709,
-0.0417726785,
-0.0110886507,
-0.0668799058,
-0.0406725295,
-0.0015030839,
-0.039961163,
-0.0419573262,
0.0024505018,
0.0287304334,
-0.0449894443,
-0.0358541086,
0.0184990913,
-0.0042070705,
0.0352702588,
0.0217463411,
0.0030392234,
0.0077516474,
-0.0240494069,
-0.0159567837,
0.0005479397,
0.0699128583,
0.018790802,
-0.0133275911,
-0.0419436879,
-0.0345794782,
-0.036252819,
0.0255660806,
-0.0185290966,
-0.0488355272,
0.0266886204,
-0.0108490484,
0.0386133119,
0.0759678185,
-0.0156567954,
-0.0243094061,
0.0222308431,
-0.0003374085,
-0.0244853403,
0.0078116036,
0.0289310459,
-0.0113527467,
0.0264832973,
-0.0212833937,
-0.006735465,
0.032152459,
-0.0537257753,
-0.0103322165,
-0.066385664,
0.0052975207,
-0.0049814465,
-0.0760669261,
-0.0470010936,
0.0234040953,
-0.0002774432,
0.0292536207,
-0.0559129976,
-0.0367282405,
0.069501169,
-0.0485603586,
-0.0286326222,
0.0395542309,
-0.0194206536,
-0.0088052871,
0.0712773651,
0.0190832894,
0.0237156097,
0.0175969489,
0.0075576198,
-0.0606864132,
-0.012043939,
0.0503414012,
-0.0183208417,
0.0495438874,
-0.022118682,
0.0130066369,
-0.030111393,
-0.0372915231,
-0.0134302955,
-0.0458085276,
-0.0016587003,
-0.0135961212,
-0.0581935011,
-0.0351988077,
-0.068783164,
-0.0009781424,
0.0485655777,
0.0129856439,
-0.028204659,
-0.0038915055,
-0.0012905359,
0.023436008,
0.0525555089,
0.0410742722,
-0.03052512,
-0.0568571985,
-0.0383393839,
0.0325041041,
-0.0120122116,
-0.0123552317,
-0.0546903461,
0.0440657549,
-0.0025562381,
0.0650174841,
-0.0034473129,
0.0006966809,
0.0628430918,
-0.0571977794,
-0.0162935648,
0.0053502186,
-0.0156522524,
-0.02649129,
-0.0303129442,
0.0089219948,
0.0486609265,
0.0299227238,
0.0091912812,
-0.0833132714,
-0.0686145723,
0.0197311807,
-0.0147621613,
0.0301899426,
0.0000965531,
-0.0196969621,
-0.0813197345,
0.0149704777,
-0.01809543,
-0.0631352291,
-0.0680931881,
0.0096850749,
0.0198620223,
0.0027646897,
0.0184109658,
-0.0228357036,
0.0201068539,
-0.0110237002,
-0.0040794271,
0.0370418355,
-0.0373389386,
-0.0299196951,
-0.0429832265,
-0.0052855089,
0.0268626232,
-0.0119969454,
-0.0122146634,
-0.0690683797,
0.0229103211,
0.0362420902,
-0.0094483737,
0.0470234901,
0.0684142336,
-0.0209940765,
-0.0481040701,
0.0008173314,
0.016729841,
0.0408294089,
-0.0300552621,
-0.0439094827,
0.0537289754,
0.0302481167,
0.0216755159,
-0.0517084226,
-0.0184048451,
0.005372202,
0.0328437313,
0.0154147372,
-0.0427915119,
-0.009117919,
-0.0431043245,
-0.0042000478,
-0.0571466275,
-0.0489475094,
0.0140963085,
-0.0183647256,
0.0006919648,
-0.0668878183,
-0.0310050193,
0.0089198425,
0.0388778038,
-0.007368078,
-0.0413033441,
-0.0283100419,
0.0196679085,
-0.0786798224,
0.0586298667,
-0.0335060582,
0.0633226633,
-0.0201605968,
0.0293625277,
0.0369394086,
-0.0405673012,
-0.0053841351,
0.0023818272,
-0.0682428926,
-0.0253814328,
-0.0241717305,
0.0554774702,
0.006355782,
0.0286157504,
0.0032964235,
-0.0797469839,
0.0299512185,
0.0238252208,
-0.0170242321,
0.0022673367,
0.0445221364,
-0.0185278971,
0.0090183718,
0.0173355229,
-0.0624537431,
-0.0056648282,
0.0059877122,
0.0068608555,
0.0003375487,
-0.0437742509,
-0.0034044287,
0.001118403,
0.0297269505,
-0.0117479721,
0.0108758938,
-0.0245329645,
0.0190490875,
-0.0016592332,
-0.0206655301,
-0.059673544,
0.0189160369,
0.0305104982,
0.0166166201,
0.0119520333,
0.0226818882,
0.0438004285,
0.0582045764,
-0.0326554812,
0.0110999811,
0.0050002681,
0.0273189433,
-0.0174941458,
0.037258178,
-0.0053038877,
0.0335418768,
-0.0341431014,
0.0506223589,
-0.0219483599,
0.0263318028,
0.0418659858,
-0.0303859189,
-0.0550926365,
0.0615350828,
-0.0383507237,
0.0421243086,
-0.0401840955,
0.053457886,
0.003056943,
0.02550059,
0.0233743116,
-0.0029223943,
-0.0363801084,
0.0015565543,
0.0432567298,
0.0053391517,
-0.0203034431,
0.0679395944,
0.0173575915,
0.0180026125,
0.0009450879,
0.0285852086,
0.0081479587,
0.0197248328,
-0.0239104107,
-0.000022116,
-0.0349477343,
-0.0284875873,
0.0230700485,
0.0077636642,
-0.0339305736,
-0.0044493554,
0.0017588987,
-0.0849249661,
0.0081004826,
0.0497749075,
-0.0277188551,
0.0547976121,
0.0008765103,
0.0193380322,
0.0359145664,
0.0037060271,
-0.0030973058,
-0.0244788863,
0.0175896585,
0.0204314329,
0.0330615267,
-5.77321165e-33,
-0.0389377661,
-0.0032323953,
0.003463092,
-0.0224199947,
-0.0233728271,
0.0139639974,
-0.03289387,
0.0378524922,
-0.0205086116,
0.0321479812,
0.0292932782,
0.001492606,
0.0103240972,
0.0428070948,
-0.0131745748,
-0.0069367024,
0.0110646524,
0.0354644805,
-0.0211047791,
-0.0209045876,
0.0116742188,
0.0043177502,
0.0495287292,
-0.0914759189,
0.0317211263,
0.0472310372,
-0.0485176258,
0.0195359178,
-0.0153815867,
0.0686707199,
-0.0194579009,
0.0346008278,
-0.0051177018,
-0.0241124835,
-0.0096234558,
0.0366017781,
-0.0822667032,
-0.0191466548,
-0.0064650583,
0.0296399724,
-0.1010880917,
-0.0080705266,
0.0557809249,
-0.0377116688,
0.0371694453,
-0.0489830039,
0.0589630269,
-0.0208390523,
0.0068592089,
0.0084863193,
-0.0377808958,
0.0167748872,
0.0117336791,
-0.0261521768,
0.0443461537,
0.0183752999,
0.0685528517,
0.0282778833,
-0.048924949,
0.0163862798,
-0.051294513,
0.0054200692,
0.0415384993,
0.0569715463,
-0.0271038953,
0.0836383328,
0.0446452647,
-0.0043589687,
-0.0199882071,
-0.0052680164,
0.063179411,
0.0315880477,
0.0820607096,
0.1641212702,
0.0247932374,
0.0280812494,
-0.0448194183,
0.0343884788,
-0.0366319418,
0.0359179452,
-0.0133243119,
0.0471058078,
-0.0228433721,
0.0091822017,
-0.0385914668,
0.0037026023,
-0.0637613162,
-0.0103356382,
0.043025218,
0.0149973892,
-0.0496962741,
0.0613367595,
0.0608025342,
-0.0113537814,
0.0009258867,
-0.0054314504,
-0.0294549186,
0.0504600741,
-0.0154321902,
0.0267715845,
-0.0020477576,
-0.016595019,
0.0882839262,
-0.001547345,
0.0087319706,
-0.0155755254,
0.0631965622,
0.0383665636,
-0.0570788495,
0.0060222843,
-0.0107251061,
0.0009603938,
0.0032719094,
0.0335024558,
0.0322598331,
-0.0100616589,
-0.0582220517,
0.0132761383,
0.0236395113,
0.0288202912,
-0.0521480031,
-0.0413944274,
0.0156607125,
-0.0071916487,
-0.0150774457,
0.0122482348,
-0.0442451537,
-0.060286507,
0.03157565,
-0.0781208873,
0.0064520291,
0.0466709584,
2.495e-7,
0.018185202,
0.0078762993,
0.0275055952,
-0.0064196186,
-0.0115106003,
0.0794777125,
-0.0463531055,
0.0252259877,
0.0179043841,
-0.0506006218,
-0.0141371768,
0.0288333669,
0.068984203,
0.0156234261,
-0.0102546392,
0.0005762256,
-0.0276460648,
0.0189869851,
-0.0256032255,
0.0003653006,
0.0412412882,
0.0847632512,
0.0162996985,
-0.0194210503,
0.0239414629,
-0.0701622888,
0.0856067836,
-0.0364811197,
-0.0075712702,
-0.0632264763,
0.0102842683,
0.0387922712,
-0.0221134648,
0.0194365196,
-0.0018103359,
-0.0183986407,
0.0747144967,
0.0053590685,
-0.0255860537,
-0.0351678543,
-0.0584964044,
0.0180812385,
-0.0100388965,
-0.030517051,
0.0781513751,
-0.0421863385,
-0.0167617481,
-0.0537976064,
-0.0370769575,
0.005343935,
0.0494920798,
-0.0156092467,
-0.073382847,
0.0041500153,
0.0531145893,
0.0034127294,
-0.0394292325,
-0.0887597129,
-0.055349227,
-0.0128643038,
-0.0370519273,
-0.0247078035,
-0.0596924536,
-0.0016082948,
0.0335327201,
-0.0804989412,
-0.0382313132,
1.841609002e-34,
0.0276440755,
-0.0201006215,
0.0306959413,
-0.0188449845,
0.029371677,
0.0124282008,
0.0057835206,
-0.0211537015,
0.0055506444,
-0.0502093062,
-0.0341080204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11044v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11044v2 | Frequency effects in Linear Discriminative Learning | 2023-06-19T16:15:46 | 2024-03-18T10:36:05 | Maria Heitmeier, Yu-Ying Chuang, Seth D. Axen, R. Harald Baayen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Word frequency is a strong predictor in most lexical processing tasks. Thus,
any model of word recognition needs to account for how word frequency effects
arise. The Discriminative Lexicon Model (DLM; Baayen et al., 2018a, 2019)
models lexical processing with linear mappings between words' forms and their
meanings. So far, the mappings can either be obtained incrementally via
error-driven learning, a computationally expensive process able to capture
frequency effects, or in an efficient, but frequency-agnostic solution
modelling the theoretical endstate of learning (EL) where all words are learned
optimally. In this study we show how an efficient, yet frequency-informed
mapping between form and meaning can be obtained (Frequency-informed learning;
FIL). We find that FIL well approximates an incremental solution while being
computationally much cheaper. FIL shows a relatively low type- and high
token-accuracy, demonstrating that the model is able to process most word
tokens encountered by speakers in daily life correctly. We use FIL to model
reaction times in the Dutch Lexicon Project (Keuleers et al., 2010) and find
that FIL predicts well the S-shaped relationship between frequency and the mean
of reaction times but underestimates the variance of reaction times for low
frequency words. FIL is also better able to account for priming effects in an
auditory lexical decision task in Mandarin Chinese (Lee, 2007), compared to EL.
Finally, we used ordered data from CHILDES (Brown, 1973; Demuth et al., 2006)
to compare mappings obtained with FIL and incremental learning. The mappings
are highly correlated, but with FIL some nuances based on word ordering effects
are lost. Our results show how frequency effects in a learning model can be
simulated efficiently, and raise questions about how to best account for
low-frequency words in cognitive models. | [
-0.0169981644,
0.0117530581,
-0.0200526249,
0.0478163101,
-0.0106914369,
-0.0053250594,
-0.017318815,
0.0169068109,
-0.0193528347,
-0.0388856083,
-0.0331005193,
-0.0659225956,
0.060776338,
0.0402270146,
-0.0087020369,
-0.0247642249,
0.0619770624,
-0.0223063622,
0.0135266604,
-0.0152142784,
0.0087054409,
-0.0505444258,
-0.0599016324,
0.0050973138,
-0.0349457823,
0.0228094179,
0.0035508163,
-0.0328507274,
0.0081899883,
-0.0265913773,
-0.0204493888,
0.0738598704,
0.0025399921,
0.0427329689,
0.000002117,
-0.0553648323,
0.0050771921,
-0.023739798,
0.0056243008,
0.0319812559,
0.0556881391,
0.0043552024,
-0.041921787,
-0.0061065299,
0.0015455176,
-0.0425382107,
0.0824477449,
-0.0037790958,
-0.0618739165,
0.0246999692,
-0.0034160817,
-0.0217972454,
0.0414414592,
-0.0103641674,
0.0384390689,
-0.0258777104,
0.0128453104,
-0.0010937336,
-0.0233808085,
-0.0482338704,
-0.0877919942,
0.0129727367,
-0.0177138019,
0.0765924081,
0.0805113018,
0.0491281264,
0.0026663821,
-0.0116227437,
-0.0116198538,
0.0456662849,
0.0126806684,
-0.0333449244,
-0.0092185801,
0.0137890503,
0.0087117702,
0.0645482689,
0.0079247328,
-0.0045923246,
0.0175697077,
-0.0121034626,
0.0205498878,
-0.0381336696,
-0.0156797599,
0.0346237086,
0.0147429341,
0.0393019468,
0.0063792616,
-0.0595664643,
0.0156457499,
-0.0513367057,
-0.0326775573,
-0.0034902436,
-0.008125552,
-0.0163351297,
0.039920833,
0.0035228857,
-0.0063302345,
-0.0326099172,
0.0160828959,
-0.0783332288,
-0.0106017366,
0.0188865364,
-0.0324646756,
-0.04039995,
-0.0656301677,
0.0431852415,
0.0263662674,
-0.0190442167,
-0.0612981394,
0.0501329303,
-0.0215730742,
-0.0164126046,
-0.0008310815,
0.0036312521,
-0.0255189799,
-0.0271035079,
-0.1088567376,
-0.0087749641,
0.0151461242,
-0.0608452484,
-0.0652127638,
-0.0135279493,
-0.0062798588,
0.0255667288,
-0.0518334508,
-0.0064578727,
-0.0072939307,
0.0862988383,
-0.027079545,
-0.0391794927,
-0.0116856294,
-0.0396745019,
0.0655660555,
0.0066243899,
0.0237656422,
0.0390254632,
-0.0316136926,
-0.0562770516,
-0.0280920547,
-0.0024423301,
-0.0339145623,
0.0104019418,
-0.004936533,
-0.081263788,
-0.0323190205,
0.0291886367,
0.0279420037,
-0.0284243189,
0.0021996184,
-0.0065283319,
-0.0183405597,
0.0963615179,
0.0133647285,
0.0222569425,
0.0247606467,
0.004438661,
-0.0021622316,
0.0380619466,
0.0489234738,
-0.0213308353,
0.0248271618,
-0.0537435412,
-0.0076994211,
0.0427461416,
-0.0062713544,
0.0009974169,
-0.0517895035,
-0.0786705464,
0.0337793939,
0.0152662508,
0.0858271196,
0.0149114886,
-0.0347126871,
-0.0184397213,
0.0487848222,
0.0693110749,
-0.0006722017,
-0.0163081326,
-0.0228902232,
0.019368371,
0.002033337,
-0.0050570234,
-0.0127734449,
0.0100162942,
-0.039788723,
-0.0100861788,
0.0117402235,
-0.0138853211,
-0.0060403608,
-0.0083211865,
-0.0247503165,
-0.0081106359,
0.046546571,
0.0050400249,
0.0132999113,
-0.0075540803,
-0.0261285547,
0.0498081557,
0.032950744,
-0.0185614172,
-0.019470118,
-0.046783831,
-0.0034547849,
0.0715313256,
0.0015638357,
-0.0191919766,
0.0316398293,
0.0478335731,
-0.022683084,
0.0222505629,
0.0275636166,
-0.0011352615,
0.0251639411,
-0.0159942526,
-0.0088572847,
0.0777435973,
-0.0074747954,
0.0182695407,
0.0030532042,
0.0035530492,
0.0107806372,
-0.0305814315,
-0.0420924611,
0.0090041365,
0.0024281775,
-0.0852404088,
0.002271204,
-0.0005896557,
0.0397066846,
-0.0385846309,
-0.0017205676,
0.0528536327,
-0.0234849062,
-0.0051032547,
0.0361001529,
-0.0130387442,
-0.0055983379,
-0.0086419908,
0.0309442822,
0.0154434312,
0.009249975,
0.0262205359,
0.0178091954,
-0.0542667061,
0.0031704505,
-0.0226695165,
0.0474779718,
-0.0187579747,
0.0470978171,
-0.0146596292,
0.0493577085,
0.0123010725,
0.0515814982,
-0.0307122264,
0.0429701582,
-0.044029247,
0.0094912648,
-0.0144778891,
-0.0378356464,
-0.0197836477,
-0.0037652431,
-0.0309067797,
-0.0129886866,
-0.0038779886,
-0.0327390842,
-0.04600133,
0.0179987121,
-0.0523483939,
-0.0693713352,
0.0342844985,
-0.0183869619,
-0.0159216151,
-0.0126547571,
-0.0195793901,
0.0207550973,
-0.0080621187,
0.0379852131,
-0.005099386,
0.0912726969,
-0.0320389308,
-0.0401623808,
-0.0850676522,
-0.0402424708,
-0.0278444756,
-0.0226651486,
0.0050541228,
-0.028373044,
-0.0250242297,
0.0035593563,
0.0285004731,
-0.0063115037,
0.027003983,
0.0100950385,
-0.0333694071,
-0.0172915906,
0.0149725303,
0.0432546809,
0.0278814472,
0.0448090211,
0.0081569226,
0.0513147414,
-0.0062122303,
-0.0302461088,
-0.0114032505,
-0.0305309743,
0.0172869451,
0.0216677375,
-0.0407773666,
-0.0083333924,
0.0665909052,
0.0589850843,
-0.0027435955,
-0.0362061933,
0.0114323488,
-0.0425892025,
-0.0389536694,
-0.0449121185,
-0.029774135,
-0.0743621588,
0.0313657708,
-0.0195177589,
-0.0663850456,
0.0363482535,
0.0041380958,
0.0144897811,
-0.0419334695,
0.0163342375,
0.0063356422,
0.0123247178,
0.0214332212,
-0.0031936239,
-0.0421706997,
-0.018498024,
-0.0445228294,
-0.0086391745,
0.0490244962,
-0.0573526509,
0.1131612137,
-0.026439175,
0.0079950159,
-0.023345774,
-0.0299517289,
-0.0344230756,
-0.0264201127,
-0.0140483994,
0.0214841142,
-0.0048683509,
-0.0105167534,
0.0156995244,
0.0094862329,
0.0268840492,
0.0389648452,
0.0035903831,
-0.0197130237,
0.009909532,
0.027657643,
-0.0058542015,
-0.0142205441,
0.0159805138,
-0.0210599862,
0.0202240292,
0.0105860727,
0.096370168,
0.0175211374,
0.0222223531,
0.0218084026,
0.0575334169,
-0.0228176545,
-0.0138591686,
0.0386134759,
0.0030396543,
0.0043700156,
-0.0039496194,
0.0844241604,
0.0227332208,
-0.0214546844,
0.0574041568,
0.0051464285,
0.0345576629,
0.0187261254,
-0.0191982575,
-0.0208211709,
-0.0121764494,
0.0174722448,
0.0235641375,
-0.007973793,
0.0034079487,
-0.0142822992,
-0.0577903315,
0.0022511824,
0.0309456661,
-0.0617779456,
-0.0329847224,
-0.0417695493,
0.0153805325,
0.0343507752,
-0.0182076301,
0.0370894782,
-0.0618211254,
-0.0131086828,
0.0589121319,
-0.0359766483,
-0.0274255648,
0.0295178667,
0.0006826372,
0.0124446135,
0.0147894993,
0.0231185183,
-0.0451198816,
-0.0624159165,
0.0345841981,
0.008179388,
-0.0100006312,
-0.0090242131,
0.0085492218,
0.0433844589,
0.0161841828,
0.0220041163,
0.0293762647,
-0.0175534785,
-0.0586187989,
0.0032292602,
0.0080965869,
0.0131882159,
0.0244929325,
-0.0212141424,
0.0157733969,
-0.0094193369,
0.0768351629,
0.0155663388,
-0.0684415326,
0.0368098691,
0.005325133,
0.0109081091,
-0.0120484484,
-0.0729175508,
-0.0255464744,
-0.0066273669,
-0.0098589826,
-0.0550121181,
-0.0041514458,
-0.0625597388,
0.0456968173,
0.0187671613,
0.022725638,
-0.0228258576,
0.0154037513,
-0.0305104665,
0.0113225328,
0.0432606153,
0.0171118882,
-0.0872557312,
-0.0367820337,
0.0059233229,
-0.031670887,
-0.0367103815,
0.0105559407,
-0.0425985865,
-0.0366142131,
0.0754762143,
-0.0389898196,
0.0161115024,
0.0313140787,
0.0367444456,
-0.0306360144,
0.0680790171,
0.0215669926,
-0.0226402525,
0.0385355018,
-0.0068877302,
-0.0231056735,
0.0001397443,
-0.0212463085,
-0.0240167379,
0.0706346482,
0.0419860967,
0.0271328278,
0.01611894,
-0.0170569327,
0.022338558,
0.0267229229,
0.0845305324,
-0.0453596823,
-0.015376484,
-0.0644766614,
0.0136648286,
0.0373663642,
0.0138034103,
0.0147008551,
-0.0460066386,
0.0414065346,
0.0092985602,
-0.0495697744,
-0.0465168692,
0.0241881404,
-0.0220076982,
0.037465211,
0.0096905092,
0.000802236,
0.0070675458,
0.0101757264,
0.012442166,
0.0084527535,
0.0404505841,
-0.0122095346,
0.0286833439,
0.0035063021,
0.0484797321,
-0.0111653013,
0.0099476362,
-0.0484690405,
-0.0281207673,
-0.0106493905,
-0.023050284,
-0.0083136344,
-0.0178042725,
-0.0036845235,
-0.0646297783,
-0.0150135048,
-0.0806437135,
0.0269386172,
-0.0774039254,
-0.0435432978,
-0.0376461595,
0.0011069314,
0.0233521946,
0.0363523215,
0.005024645,
-0.0200476535,
0.0826258585,
0.0221348181,
0.0081849154,
-0.0371323265,
-0.0407080464,
-0.005608933,
-0.024023369,
-0.0034836722,
-0.0026943965,
-0.0328060724,
0.041830752,
-0.1036905646,
-0.0434895307,
0.033205349,
-0.0229531154,
0.062855415,
-0.0182351358,
0.0634317845,
0.0620640889,
-0.0210050326,
-0.019054601,
-0.030651018,
-0.0059990212,
-0.0131638646,
-0.0202433188,
0.0006214119,
-6.253875331e-33,
-0.0210954025,
-0.0151544325,
-0.0074204821,
0.0153785991,
0.0289433002,
0.0717124715,
0.0313980095,
0.0366990939,
-0.0048105875,
0.0139035266,
0.0106070274,
0.0089658052,
0.0274049751,
-0.0018688985,
0.0263238922,
0.0239285324,
0.0025339581,
-0.0026763545,
-0.0164980181,
-0.0551389195,
0.0831982866,
0.005368141,
0.0479216799,
0.0112804985,
-0.0079315938,
0.067318745,
0.0388150737,
-0.0057280194,
0.0287731532,
0.0633966625,
-0.0456284992,
0.0835937411,
0.0246203151,
-0.0313829891,
0.0065321387,
0.0403731242,
-0.0937707499,
-0.0079392064,
0.0544298552,
0.0313436165,
0.0136373537,
0.0055882875,
0.0536939725,
0.0018775268,
-0.0915090367,
0.013073313,
0.016176505,
-0.0401217528,
-0.0671396777,
-0.0201989803,
-0.0623384789,
0.0379105844,
0.016402686,
-0.0170213655,
0.0324860923,
0.0169042684,
-0.0315490514,
-0.0500374474,
-0.0851491541,
0.0561670102,
-0.0036168233,
0.074909687,
-0.0015265052,
0.0891168341,
0.0239204578,
0.057583753,
0.0601050183,
-0.0090343682,
0.0366787165,
-0.010008459,
0.0738066658,
0.0110934526,
-0.0324907303,
-0.0013437618,
0.1054395512,
-0.0600365177,
-0.0103330407,
0.0078100096,
0.0184799768,
0.0263427813,
0.0296328757,
0.0075652543,
-0.0699235499,
-0.0417473465,
-0.0554034151,
0.0810926259,
-0.0579532161,
0.019450875,
0.0412550606,
-0.0071046026,
0.0375576839,
-0.0824908838,
0.0461752526,
0.0116131902,
-0.0220143646,
-0.0136482492,
0.011738264,
0.0109000895,
-0.0148793384,
-0.0126074357,
-0.0804270655,
-0.0249405447,
-0.0220025256,
-0.0124513311,
0.0008562238,
-0.0097440705,
0.013198114,
0.0282792412,
-0.0584930032,
0.0025133186,
-0.0241264105,
-0.0627612472,
0.0537142903,
-0.0229714643,
0.0624001101,
-0.007869768,
0.0056421286,
-0.0092586065,
0.0125518162,
-0.0127033712,
-0.0200778712,
-0.0436646417,
-0.0658126846,
0.0921973735,
-0.0360896289,
0.0016530285,
-0.0096036065,
0.0131654432,
0.023963334,
-0.051652506,
-0.0003331704,
0.0379195437,
3.1e-7,
0.0043872185,
0.0146564068,
-0.0047546481,
0.012244557,
0.0437295102,
0.0178132765,
0.01855102,
0.0288607124,
0.0013828826,
0.0476892851,
0.0221175738,
0.0196072869,
0.0341778249,
-0.0082989037,
-0.034480717,
-0.0400416739,
-0.0233552251,
0.1015006825,
-0.0177533496,
0.0132180732,
-0.0360334404,
0.0361177251,
-0.0138919428,
-0.0287589636,
-0.0305591226,
-0.0172040723,
0.0563465692,
-0.0081616584,
0.0215825457,
-0.0020687697,
-0.0069940225,
-0.0207547285,
0.0254414584,
0.0465023145,
-0.0326228552,
0.0281574782,
0.0522409789,
-0.0122227361,
-0.0225074217,
-0.0122305611,
0.0025580283,
0.0118084084,
-0.0389004946,
0.0118291853,
0.0503034145,
0.0206262525,
-0.0376897976,
0.0063377256,
-0.020007927,
0.0339846425,
0.0108052492,
0.016529534,
-0.0352113023,
-0.0068217954,
0.0085446266,
0.007856084,
-0.0415233746,
-0.0345813259,
-0.0149886059,
0.0667024851,
-0.0430164039,
-0.056308452,
-0.0385005735,
-0.0105100684,
0.0413007326,
0.052203048,
-0.0550210588,
2.313939967e-34,
-0.0133939944,
-0.0110641802,
0.0077031674,
0.0326183364,
-0.0110790422,
-0.0363409892,
0.0610358976,
0.031383466,
0.0488025323,
-0.0625812262,
0.0030179059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.14913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.14913v1 | FSUIE: A Novel Fuzzy Span Mechanism for Universal Information Extraction | 2023-06-19T15:59:28 | 2023-06-19T15:59:28 | Tianshuo Peng, Zuchao Li, Lefei Zhang, Bo Du, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Universal Information Extraction (UIE) has been introduced as a unified
framework for various Information Extraction (IE) tasks and has achieved
widespread success. Despite this, UIE models have limitations. For example,
they rely heavily on span boundaries in the data during training, which does
not reflect the reality of span annotation challenges. Slight adjustments to
positions can also meet requirements. Additionally, UIE models lack attention
to the limited span length feature in IE. To address these deficiencies, we
propose the Fuzzy Span Universal Information Extraction (FSUIE) framework.
Specifically, our contribution consists of two concepts: fuzzy span loss and
fuzzy span attention. Our experimental results on a series of main IE tasks
show significant improvement compared to the baseline, especially in terms of
fast convergence and strong performance with small amounts of data and training
epochs. These results demonstrate the effectiveness and generalization of FSUIE
in different tasks, settings, and scenarios. | [
0.033615198,
0.0428463258,
0.016068181,
0.058254458,
0.0279034264,
0.0351732373,
-0.0057621715,
0.0125097819,
-0.0079618758,
0.005584287,
-0.0066556958,
-0.0210418925,
-0.0316002443,
-0.0080600139,
0.0372901522,
-0.0597627349,
0.0392422862,
0.0262499508,
0.0800438747,
0.030759532,
0.0255066119,
-0.0210055429,
-0.0170463491,
-0.0381802619,
-0.0621105656,
0.0375781134,
-0.0115395067,
-0.0052740751,
0.062341284,
-0.0459352322,
0.0494241603,
0.0181601867,
0.0061420281,
-0.0165501926,
0.0000018532,
-0.0228546467,
-0.0290898886,
0.0218481235,
-0.0179191288,
-0.0061379978,
0.0157203935,
-0.0168372728,
-0.0079111997,
-0.0479843318,
0.0057369866,
0.0189704467,
0.0442327559,
0.0555688478,
0.0358099081,
0.0570675731,
-0.0182549544,
-0.0427696221,
0.027460739,
-0.0151255224,
0.0404654332,
-0.0862032473,
0.0373441391,
-0.0156442579,
0.008859531,
-0.0276951157,
-0.0102082528,
0.0395875908,
-0.0045264401,
0.0573401488,
0.0034679414,
0.0474352874,
-0.0628887191,
-0.0215786677,
-0.0160359517,
0.1277053654,
-0.0332833938,
0.0325251743,
0.03854765,
0.0110605126,
0.0012911044,
-0.0560680479,
-0.0333731882,
0.014010435,
-0.0325325616,
0.0178369917,
-0.0069948295,
0.0489774905,
0.0057586464,
0.0017663685,
-0.0468062311,
0.043033123,
-0.0469780341,
-0.0460391529,
0.0449466035,
0.020373797,
-0.0035480959,
0.0197319295,
0.0476144888,
0.0308471564,
0.0407837071,
0.0040821489,
-0.0355306752,
-0.032798171,
-0.0013460647,
-0.0462521613,
-0.0480146855,
0.0262946375,
-0.0261941645,
0.0714403912,
-0.0317661203,
0.0227632038,
-0.0332274735,
0.0201823115,
-0.0051584663,
-0.0401785001,
-0.018677989,
0.0303936545,
-0.0150080509,
0.042531535,
-0.0115068145,
-0.0172714926,
0.0039195004,
-0.0041507143,
-0.0216564983,
0.0430318154,
-0.0204373673,
0.0002870683,
-0.0422064736,
-0.0180153754,
0.0116686178,
0.0455883071,
-0.0495245196,
0.0012222526,
0.0375551917,
-0.0023447338,
-0.0262689795,
0.0025974773,
0.0507470183,
-0.0272759236,
0.0313560441,
0.0527156629,
-0.005955128,
-0.0471861027,
-0.0784038529,
0.0034122905,
-0.0167005006,
-0.0295540038,
-0.0087920893,
-0.0078262808,
0.0659963489,
-0.0182444267,
-0.0375576317,
0.0140696913,
0.0293220486,
-0.0179373659,
-0.0343147703,
0.0430843085,
-0.0531528182,
-0.0212599672,
0.0169693585,
-0.0134927556,
0.0517827049,
0.0761693493,
0.0221434385,
0.0346306339,
0.055976402,
0.0479062572,
0.0225303769,
0.0680594519,
0.0596936271,
-0.0303541347,
0.0240546819,
0.0277120639,
0.0012110001,
-0.0113232518,
0.0665303096,
0.0143415583,
-0.0330017395,
-0.0443740748,
0.0391532965,
0.0106271664,
0.0387849137,
0.0667533427,
0.0132066952,
0.0083563076,
0.0190552734,
0.0251700785,
-0.0542999022,
0.0302539058,
-0.0106153088,
0.0572177693,
0.0195555836,
-0.008677897,
-0.0163320955,
0.0050189202,
0.0279692393,
-0.049813658,
-0.0152916471,
0.0210568737,
0.0519524887,
-0.0179553051,
-0.0240238812,
0.0687432885,
0.0558542125,
-0.0831516683,
0.0242671389,
0.06959299,
0.0050098607,
0.0374935605,
-0.0040677539,
-0.0915737972,
-0.050198067,
-0.0051543126,
0.0125083961,
-0.0090346904,
0.011714627,
-0.0170677695,
0.0416505933,
-0.0376295857,
-0.0201949403,
0.0286245272,
-0.0095887193,
-0.0268368591,
0.0240728986,
0.0136958202,
-0.0174751375,
-0.0300103594,
-0.0575072542,
0.0262897648,
0.0103080105,
-0.0238716733,
-0.0343813784,
0.0215732493,
0.024492668,
0.0167243164,
-0.0389982834,
-0.0406163968,
0.0524287373,
-0.0239927601,
-0.0163306091,
-0.0413331203,
-0.0477613397,
-0.0681964085,
0.0203682818,
-0.0372477844,
-0.0274663176,
-0.001163868,
-0.0586374179,
0.007270718,
-0.0501504615,
0.0046600881,
-0.0252436604,
-0.0039323037,
0.0060105096,
0.0303545669,
0.0192305949,
-0.0596213751,
0.0827287138,
-0.0093963947,
-0.0016863797,
-0.0093536926,
0.0162084736,
-0.0003113301,
-0.0834828019,
-0.0051981774,
0.0206292085,
-0.0103024794,
-0.0060473625,
0.0147714717,
-0.0167653747,
-0.0568949617,
-0.0445270427,
-0.0541756414,
-0.0043958998,
-0.007923929,
0.0647953376,
0.0179604348,
0.0128038386,
-0.0415932313,
-0.0379015878,
-0.0404240452,
-0.011546474,
-0.051123891,
-0.0440912843,
0.0442933142,
0.0530754477,
0.0429798514,
-0.0298461299,
0.0023576934,
-0.0077390014,
0.0066341567,
0.0080593079,
-0.0930448696,
-0.0144422138,
-0.0082784332,
-0.047030367,
0.0474128872,
-0.0031281014,
-0.0020959235,
-0.0514204167,
-0.0023653277,
-0.0359215848,
0.055285845,
0.0414319746,
0.0259758681,
-0.0242747497,
-0.0188940912,
-0.0225980505,
0.0720122084,
-0.032086242,
0.0672082156,
-0.0189183839,
-0.0146506941,
0.0448964946,
0.0196349025,
-0.0083406307,
0.0477939062,
-0.0088366382,
-0.0396893919,
-0.0004396279,
0.0166597031,
-0.0127589144,
0.0282011908,
-0.0523294136,
0.0206044987,
-0.0463524014,
0.0133128744,
0.0587349944,
-0.0478170998,
-0.0455070511,
-0.0158451516,
0.00799991,
-0.0550231375,
0.0158469863,
-0.0297024492,
0.0211174451,
-0.0220989622,
-0.0617255792,
-0.0187404696,
0.0121702272,
0.0205886103,
-0.0256532449,
0.0234451983,
0.005271194,
0.0299967825,
-0.0546235479,
-0.0236184802,
-0.0221486464,
-0.0135089848,
0.0111208903,
0.0103538781,
-0.0280341431,
0.0181796309,
-0.0298442449,
0.0164955575,
0.0686982423,
0.0486611277,
-0.0357040986,
0.0208865553,
-0.0243951268,
0.0466171466,
0.0268542767,
0.0081903953,
-0.0172525104,
-0.0052556288,
-0.0365065113,
0.0560551807,
-0.0161232557,
-0.0026194928,
0.0126689849,
0.0023753941,
0.0049047563,
-0.0528748408,
0.0147768063,
-0.0176766496,
0.0448082611,
-0.0795672089,
0.0450294614,
0.0907676667,
0.0129992077,
-0.0349186249,
-0.007590265,
0.0380791463,
-0.0012028521,
0.0098779788,
-0.0105581349,
-0.0951294675,
-0.0518572964,
-0.0037043707,
0.0400347374,
0.0558818728,
-0.0471490845,
0.0405339412,
-0.0237938091,
-0.0108681992,
0.0084969727,
-0.0781647265,
-0.0568805933,
0.0117502008,
0.0610679127,
-0.0109702405,
0.012416916,
0.0345688611,
-0.0210162643,
-0.0000457445,
0.0236461461,
-0.0351154618,
-0.040234372,
-0.0178166982,
-0.0484924391,
0.0132682929,
0.0448521301,
0.0224021897,
-0.0220000539,
0.0162163489,
-0.0027860708,
-0.043745786,
-0.0233767591,
-0.0068339985,
0.1111559495,
-0.03280022,
-0.0240114089,
-0.0186386593,
0.0077320994,
0.0241536368,
0.036227271,
0.0109027326,
0.0529303961,
0.0478205457,
-0.0309725702,
0.0047211628,
-0.0215795729,
0.0156740472,
0.062593326,
0.047688555,
-0.0072976504,
-0.0381115749,
0.0068522072,
-0.0274830554,
-0.0376724191,
-0.0504140332,
0.0117427129,
-0.0583281592,
-0.0809225515,
-0.0445102714,
-0.0888723731,
0.0276400819,
0.0258964412,
-0.0122923516,
-0.0279525705,
0.0473457165,
0.0085371686,
-0.0288782287,
0.0368363261,
-0.0135432873,
-0.0264205318,
-0.0010433767,
-0.0017732086,
-0.0155453524,
-0.0077917306,
-0.0319543704,
0.0382311977,
0.0050802962,
-0.0263640545,
0.0053627584,
0.0023010131,
0.0015977995,
0.0500187688,
-0.0214055981,
-0.0407668725,
0.0849181116,
0.0071777808,
-0.0651292801,
-0.0048854933,
0.0463984646,
0.0307045169,
0.0242980178,
0.0311828274,
-0.0557074286,
0.016068561,
0.0082760537,
0.0332642831,
-0.0485942848,
-0.0006942962,
0.0092222225,
0.0004383608,
0.039141845,
0.0159595143,
-0.0301906858,
-0.0402911864,
0.0129602524,
0.0188163742,
-0.0365547538,
-0.0247167367,
0.042627655,
-0.0022521201,
-0.011644098,
0.0229463261,
0.0243018996,
0.0303806029,
0.0030613064,
-0.0299891476,
-0.0064918473,
-0.0517471507,
0.0559153706,
-0.006909797,
0.0071379724,
-0.0458364934,
0.0250837449,
0.0201801155,
0.0388175622,
-0.0254861098,
0.0228433404,
0.0496399812,
-0.0027287272,
0.0039451746,
0.023372598,
-0.025557464,
0.0592734851,
-0.0529452413,
0.0178864375,
0.0215229224,
-0.0112054888,
0.046602942,
0.0325387269,
-0.0262292288,
0.0019853283,
0.0018501974,
-0.041348204,
-0.0051053558,
0.0321858861,
0.003093902,
-0.0173421912,
-0.0342687517,
0.0452319048,
-0.0546349883,
-0.0047293762,
-0.0182552449,
-0.0164438132,
-0.0614641532,
-0.0023964758,
-0.0134390816,
0.026894033,
-0.0240201894,
0.0192857068,
-0.0184197482,
-0.0180014577,
-0.0148503976,
-0.0509942397,
-0.0311358087,
-0.015491778,
0.0439011306,
0.0253543872,
0.0031810775,
-0.0121599212,
-0.0141784558,
0.0006570095,
0.0349309854,
-0.0151530327,
-0.0232662037,
-6.373699347e-33,
-0.0388715379,
-0.0020471709,
0.0109635321,
0.0720300823,
-0.0738367811,
-0.0009958288,
-0.0205164868,
0.003628175,
-0.0379685536,
0.0078452602,
0.0110353334,
-0.0256501827,
0.0184940752,
0.0374306329,
-0.028018238,
-0.0424755253,
-0.0024820503,
0.0283988304,
-0.0299442615,
0.0339869522,
0.0282744132,
0.076017268,
0.09233962,
-0.0684286654,
0.0294581018,
-0.0025870877,
0.0075037582,
-0.0071297828,
0.0949750319,
0.0281502511,
-0.010501923,
0.0023272682,
0.0511563607,
-0.0045717573,
-0.0010640515,
0.0085859718,
-0.1313527077,
0.0201300308,
-0.0539071746,
0.0337414034,
-0.0273980293,
-0.0322651453,
0.0394603573,
-0.0395575278,
0.0590900853,
-0.04854846,
0.0532948114,
-0.0316851586,
-0.0052283895,
-0.0169369448,
-0.0523951203,
0.0628796443,
-0.0118353311,
0.0235067029,
0.0522760376,
0.0562551282,
0.0190583132,
0.0412533581,
-0.0531790517,
-0.0480022766,
0.0097259516,
0.046890378,
0.006968041,
-0.0407259651,
-0.0208809189,
0.0474070497,
-0.0002504067,
-0.0743969232,
-0.0393619649,
-0.0309682749,
-0.0249576233,
0.0371322371,
0.0339017548,
0.0109552313,
-0.003772381,
0.003013365,
-0.0812947601,
0.0303012058,
0.0315475352,
0.0362093933,
-0.0457191914,
0.0236558989,
-0.0414970554,
0.0421351083,
0.0391245745,
-0.0104083205,
-0.0178962089,
0.0161105096,
-0.0083961934,
0.0142769795,
-0.0209070761,
0.0884737968,
0.0300733875,
0.0014637328,
-0.0046927803,
-0.0032555005,
0.0307665877,
0.0280204266,
0.0281986147,
-0.0203406978,
-0.0527552404,
-0.01446422,
-0.0062021958,
0.02740114,
-0.0070569324,
-0.0001658909,
0.0762543231,
-0.0056579877,
-0.0257683937,
-0.0224303231,
-0.0272554979,
-0.0131564308,
-0.0154402489,
0.0275268815,
-0.0173100922,
-0.012589301,
-0.0103253955,
0.0576275662,
0.0332812332,
0.0593877733,
-0.0265763458,
-0.0029196537,
0.0233949199,
0.0245524272,
-0.0270376801,
-0.0123668974,
-0.0389213301,
0.0174162574,
-0.0177348647,
-0.0509937108,
0.025107814,
0.0404753797,
2.629e-7,
0.0629895627,
-0.0029730729,
0.0634960756,
-0.0059291786,
0.0221792087,
0.0265239384,
-0.0249416102,
0.0332624093,
-0.019772239,
0.0356884822,
0.0280558262,
-0.0155258086,
0.0136010014,
-0.0051088445,
-0.082124345,
-0.0255152117,
-0.0297772791,
-0.0727295056,
-0.0535514094,
0.0007412803,
0.033220049,
0.0608959571,
-0.0133247217,
0.021786619,
0.031721063,
-0.0506630242,
0.0268659741,
0.0245324541,
0.0264226701,
0.0354280323,
0.0252330676,
-0.0108813224,
-0.0623242594,
0.0086891958,
0.0084781656,
0.0585582405,
0.0230498258,
0.0433404446,
-0.0056249839,
-0.0500546508,
0.0198230464,
-0.0533066802,
0.0200183932,
-0.0578955896,
0.0670917779,
-0.0665219724,
-0.0065082749,
0.0337183177,
-0.0384002253,
0.0372614898,
-0.02507958,
0.0140621476,
-0.0126819797,
0.0297565944,
0.0225762799,
-0.0213278551,
-0.0647511184,
-0.0907424167,
0.0008859118,
-0.0098468577,
-0.0192244165,
-0.0210732054,
-0.0155279897,
-0.0090196989,
-0.008673829,
-0.066824168,
0.0163092893,
2.111741393e-34,
-0.0312028509,
-0.0043239272,
-0.0349189825,
0.0207579713,
0.0067308852,
-0.0239524618,
-0.0882041529,
-0.018574167,
-0.0151797598,
-0.0049998574,
-0.0039030325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.11027v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.11027v1 | JiuZhang 2.0: A Unified Chinese Pre-trained Language Model for Multi-task Mathematical Problem Solving | 2023-06-19T15:45:36 | 2023-06-19T15:45:36 | Wayne Xin Zhao, Kun Zhou, Beichen Zhang, Zheng Gong, Zhipeng Chen, Yuanhang Zhou, Ji-Rong Wen, Jing Sha, Shijin Wang, Cong Liu, Guoping Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although pre-trained language models~(PLMs) have recently advanced the
research progress in mathematical reasoning, they are not specially designed as
a capable multi-task solver, suffering from high cost for multi-task deployment
(\eg a model copy for a task) and inferior performance on complex mathematical
problems in practical applications. To address these issues, in this paper, we
propose \textbf{JiuZhang~2.0}, a unified Chinese PLM specially for multi-task
mathematical problem solving. Our idea is to maintain a moderate-sized model
and employ the \emph{cross-task knowledge sharing} to improve the model
capacity in a multi-task setting. Specially, we construct a
Mixture-of-Experts~(MoE) architecture for modeling mathematical text, so as to
capture the common mathematical knowledge across tasks. For optimizing the MoE
architecture, we design \emph{multi-task continual pre-training} and
\emph{multi-task fine-tuning} strategies for multi-task adaptation. These
training strategies can effectively decompose the knowledge from the task data
and establish the cross-task sharing via expert networks. In order to further
improve the general capacity of solving different complex tasks, we leverage
large language models~(LLMs) as complementary models to iteratively refine the
generated solution by our PLM, via in-context learning. Extensive experiments
have demonstrated the effectiveness of our model. | [
-0.0002783284,
0.0366907455,
-0.0123155415,
0.0399130322,
-0.0136155896,
0.0239474904,
0.0410080366,
-0.0154935848,
-0.0386577919,
-0.0137124257,
-0.0850453824,
-0.0317083299,
-0.0348041877,
0.0082108732,
0.0140865073,
-0.0357821099,
0.0326771699,
-0.0254197363,
0.0430984572,
-0.0297516584,
0.0151564647,
-0.0133776655,
-0.0006620738,
-0.0001940486,
-0.0409682952,
-0.0473166779,
0.0088325692,
-0.0457046442,
0.0270160809,
-0.0134724649,
0.0281412676,
0.062095277,
0.0456008464,
-0.032401029,
0.0000025938,
-0.0188755505,
-0.0294428393,
-0.0098622367,
-0.0201987084,
-0.0122876065,
0.0045859511,
0.008387764,
0.006066232,
-0.0009633848,
-0.0820171759,
0.0110390205,
0.0237765145,
0.0603811964,
0.0663889647,
0.0794834569,
-0.0099892542,
-0.0203648843,
0.0267739166,
-0.0204892829,
0.0383040756,
-0.103852354,
0.0358781964,
0.0839079395,
0.0192218218,
0.0011896139,
-0.0338275097,
0.045863159,
0.052915547,
0.0177760273,
-0.0095009673,
0.0113053238,
0.0068971165,
0.0373375565,
-0.0192889292,
0.078705579,
-0.0513319261,
-0.0062456797,
-0.0016023752,
-0.0057245069,
0.0039661229,
0.0315443911,
-0.0478466414,
0.0199492406,
-0.017656168,
-0.0048732962,
-0.0014372417,
-0.0056626382,
0.0173902083,
0.0103145968,
-0.0539004058,
0.0708652139,
-0.009446186,
-0.02099609,
-0.016887147,
-0.01360239,
-0.0955943018,
-0.0398370512,
0.0599577986,
0.0639589056,
-0.0081221834,
0.0167796593,
-0.0514601395,
-0.1136493161,
-0.05667831,
-0.0386797227,
0.0482286066,
0.0655549467,
0.0011195876,
0.0566326119,
-0.0192336105,
0.0324209593,
-0.0154297045,
0.005958362,
-0.0678945407,
-0.0119931083,
-0.0868934691,
-0.0326420404,
-0.0543330386,
0.0710350797,
0.01526553,
-0.0297339745,
-0.0253479574,
0.0464206524,
-0.0275538564,
-0.0248031039,
0.0336649828,
-0.0205383897,
-0.0273283776,
-0.0413289554,
-0.0285248142,
0.0226068012,
-0.035094589,
0.0455770008,
-0.0351853669,
-0.006768072,
-0.0126500223,
0.0106828287,
-0.0099489689,
-0.037241675,
0.0239322707,
0.053952761,
-0.0124590676,
0.0128907952,
-0.0151925897,
-0.0248493236,
0.0175099149,
-0.0853643492,
0.0148908449,
-0.0714198723,
0.073580116,
0.0010166926,
-0.0193738248,
-0.0443882458,
-0.0109007591,
0.0000414838,
0.0052085207,
0.0622120909,
0.0167968571,
0.0135749383,
0.0416476727,
0.0276816022,
-0.0484467372,
0.0633340478,
0.0280554406,
-0.0249287151,
0.011793429,
0.0015133973,
-0.00446301,
0.0182689596,
0.0151781542,
-0.0197753999,
0.0344604552,
0.0193302426,
0.035670761,
-0.014125417,
-0.0268769935,
0.0097772991,
-0.0516778976,
0.038976457,
0.0438348316,
0.0290338118,
-0.0005985361,
0.0380144306,
0.0020700996,
0.0036273315,
0.020236766,
0.0021597364,
-0.0515643656,
0.0411537625,
-0.049116049,
-0.0229660012,
-0.0044549266,
-0.0062567727,
-0.0557356253,
-0.0632541999,
0.0142781958,
0.001519572,
-0.035716489,
0.0124612432,
0.0807599723,
-0.01573769,
0.0072644218,
0.0513450429,
0.0095077502,
-0.0096094152,
0.0086214049,
-0.0072857826,
0.0120947845,
0.0150219509,
-0.001779938,
-0.0929752961,
-0.0262081102,
-0.0006725115,
0.0348328091,
-0.0345426239,
0.0329545885,
0.0108453687,
-0.0417495593,
-0.0373501554,
-0.0401730165,
-0.030450264,
0.0054411185,
0.013556554,
0.0308614131,
0.0371936075,
0.032017231,
-0.0015750084,
-0.0020839206,
0.0112322038,
-0.0836483315,
-0.011122413,
-0.0006602439,
-0.0114298696,
0.0110836411,
-0.0177192464,
-0.0256920513,
0.0397814326,
0.0038040432,
-0.0505805127,
-0.012996967,
0.0088910498,
-0.0878474563,
-0.0254882146,
0.0734660774,
-0.0506563038,
0.0101183141,
-0.0091948947,
-0.0486425459,
-0.0483624265,
0.0130070876,
0.0206711739,
-0.0042267083,
-0.0276510194,
0.0211788565,
0.0075311759,
-0.0101047484,
-0.016315775,
0.076150611,
0.0066061621,
-0.0115143619,
0.0308253318,
0.0002661577,
0.0131371021,
-0.025896607,
-0.0399148278,
-0.0488222875,
-0.0001444788,
0.0323007107,
-0.0191306248,
0.0268132798,
-0.0021365746,
-0.0264011174,
-0.0524982549,
0.0370502248,
-0.0283561535,
0.0381671079,
0.0262579378,
-0.0274506882,
-0.0120831262,
-0.0095600421,
-0.0505575575,
0.0332337618,
-0.0154406028,
-0.0266424939,
0.0137011018,
0.008647278,
0.0205717348,
-0.0214085262,
-0.013451851,
-0.0190868899,
0.0082098134,
0.0078043523,
-0.0141148381,
-0.0330267176,
0.065708302,
-0.036931619,
0.019833114,
-0.0199795291,
0.0315599144,
-0.0119899353,
-0.0276459064,
0.0805066973,
0.0602889769,
-0.0221492518,
0.0087146228,
0.0182796735,
-0.0521206371,
-0.0323086865,
0.0359142087,
-0.0023559248,
0.0112976851,
-0.0050763153,
0.0180417448,
-0.0099350261,
0.0516553968,
-0.0211800244,
-0.0534822121,
-0.0378219523,
0.0072228787,
-0.0103631886,
-0.0098818596,
-0.0268206112,
-0.009450933,
0.0042213569,
-0.0116036413,
-0.0245757923,
-0.0080924639,
0.0304460377,
0.0355328731,
0.0007621922,
-0.0639479309,
-0.01239953,
-0.0465734452,
0.0265798587,
-0.0089927455,
-0.0088223806,
-0.0192984678,
0.0145337032,
-0.0675130188,
0.0290936455,
0.0257121343,
-0.0120004788,
0.003864187,
-0.0297525767,
0.0102187265,
-0.0298458599,
-0.0417318493,
-0.009182143,
0.0128958765,
-0.035014905,
0.0628570765,
0.0160878114,
-0.0058219912,
0.0007153078,
0.0443228371,
0.0333055444,
0.0163726918,
-0.0302376952,
0.0068066088,
-0.0254989378,
-0.0216816105,
0.0129219042,
0.0591202229,
-0.0070537431,
-0.0681701452,
-0.0036315131,
0.0291099772,
0.0552146509,
-0.0194895174,
0.0213294216,
0.0224835873,
0.0033808388,
-0.035443157,
-0.0454466343,
-0.0047752736,
0.0141785564,
-0.0589580573,
0.0167053528,
0.090539813,
0.0273498353,
-0.0301879216,
-0.0337965004,
-0.0462062806,
-0.0225561578,
0.0124128005,
0.0175937824,
-0.0865773261,
-0.0146008292,
0.0032763786,
-0.050920371,
0.0596124716,
-0.0242502373,
0.0031349522,
-0.1055953801,
-0.0096143922,
0.024499828,
-0.0186487138,
-0.0070026824,
0.0047538877,
0.0066037904,
0.0212004855,
-0.019601794,
-0.0110347299,
0.0046477593,
0.0085269641,
0.032131765,
0.0092339553,
-0.032528881,
0.0074011297,
-0.0384845398,
-0.0211800542,
0.0274948385,
0.0146354157,
-0.0254787039,
-0.0337368213,
0.0255405251,
0.0719937757,
-0.0212278422,
0.0079993373,
-0.0139435502,
-0.0277887993,
-0.0066245426,
0.0096235797,
0.0427418686,
-0.061143823,
-0.0226755869,
0.0606719553,
0.0881657228,
-0.0066923192,
0.0244796388,
0.0009991969,
-0.0079178447,
-0.0222044215,
0.0574042238,
0.0016466343,
-0.0514251441,
-0.0242684707,
0.0124680288,
-0.0612003431,
-0.0653695464,
0.0005345088,
0.0264835265,
-0.0009719306,
0.0156850647,
-0.0324862376,
0.0148888072,
0.0488838479,
0.0479245968,
0.0375320129,
-0.0122451587,
0.0468244851,
-0.0010224537,
-0.0370722972,
0.0118182208,
-0.044901181,
0.0228950083,
-0.0542570055,
0.019636564,
0.0189403594,
-0.0270290822,
-0.0114780786,
-0.0169353653,
-0.0959274843,
-0.0377164669,
-0.0207086895,
0.0632218868,
0.0002777,
-0.0049022925,
-0.0040069334,
-0.0235619042,
0.0487415642,
-0.0092713553,
-0.0801182985,
0.0182501171,
0.0655411184,
-0.02366223,
0.0134323621,
0.0039406787,
-0.0095204096,
0.0207092371,
0.0570399016,
0.0248369556,
-0.0252297055,
-0.0389386266,
0.001521667,
0.0246156119,
-0.0359185785,
0.051695101,
0.0078466488,
-0.0498269908,
0.0443445183,
-0.0285629388,
-0.0128232036,
-0.0666871965,
0.0150145181,
0.0176357236,
-0.0184134394,
0.0265040305,
0.0400834195,
0.0887103006,
-0.0064112456,
0.001928668,
0.0247830544,
-0.0126576815,
0.0245182738,
0.0215770844,
0.0131921638,
0.0146889789,
-0.0327908359,
0.0124434019,
0.0037179408,
-0.0239089709,
0.0648364127,
0.0228608027,
-0.0060142376,
-0.0326109119,
0.021208372,
-0.0515911616,
-0.1105729714,
-0.0137644336,
0.0172549002,
0.0771125481,
-0.0020676495,
-0.0384289622,
-0.051997833,
-0.0017333376,
-0.0477394424,
0.0231566075,
0.0212796368,
0.0248748194,
0.0131459665,
0.0183706544,
0.015189657,
-0.0495384708,
0.0975389928,
-0.0208127704,
0.0137831075,
0.01289526,
0.009697035,
-0.0267391168,
0.0114833964,
0.0338875651,
0.0295512918,
-0.0132114394,
0.0235478822,
-0.0302451905,
-0.0637537017,
0.0185670443,
-0.0184263866,
-0.0339382328,
0.0436349809,
0.050019905,
0.0640254393,
-0.0463410318,
-0.0029435309,
0.016231278,
0.030726634,
0.0106735844,
0.0212312378,
0.0317745954,
-6.385823837e-33,
-0.0401636288,
-0.0222524982,
0.0311550964,
0.0080741812,
0.0026241415,
-0.0135991862,
-0.0178261027,
0.0261739027,
-0.0221430026,
-0.0161235034,
-0.0210443232,
0.0146660488,
0.0070427996,
0.0065451441,
0.0109752361,
0.0072324066,
0.022411773,
-0.0262726489,
0.0083556194,
-0.0147977071,
0.0206711758,
0.0427951738,
0.0693714917,
-0.0723527893,
-0.0089168809,
-0.0081029478,
0.0211109817,
0.0328820199,
-0.0176434517,
0.0732562244,
-0.012348922,
0.0234753843,
0.037336126,
-0.0429510809,
-0.0649539754,
0.0244464092,
-0.0787684694,
-0.0618293732,
0.0064122379,
0.0045107459,
-0.0330101959,
-0.0123903435,
0.0161584858,
0.0195178688,
0.0258033015,
-0.0171065461,
0.0444844216,
-0.0462687202,
-0.0104789715,
-0.0101092476,
-0.0203168727,
0.0142023396,
-0.0016976038,
-0.0097277043,
0.0575928837,
0.0102906162,
-0.0278078634,
-0.0236922782,
-0.0431461409,
-0.0044189431,
0.0158309042,
0.0322899371,
0.0352823064,
0.0074428869,
0.0229736734,
0.0158815887,
-0.0036503787,
-0.0021419793,
-0.0156403128,
-0.0307356305,
0.0420310907,
0.0689136013,
0.0415928178,
-0.0064809886,
0.0234608538,
-0.0066108056,
-0.0692054555,
-0.0040482841,
0.0108316541,
0.0284247082,
0.0354198031,
0.0313176736,
0.0114215408,
-0.0158630107,
-0.0283399019,
0.0431626253,
-0.0370960496,
-0.019255409,
0.030097682,
0.0129220719,
-0.0102005741,
0.0185532365,
0.0479252897,
-0.0706203133,
-0.0150357857,
0.0178868268,
0.0078923581,
0.0097452821,
0.0016720362,
0.0450721793,
-0.0963937789,
-0.0433741547,
-0.0273965672,
-0.0188765433,
0.0027084693,
0.018654611,
0.0437345654,
0.0255684461,
-0.0355818979,
-0.0242450517,
-0.0169071835,
-0.0330028757,
0.1111937314,
0.0961303338,
0.0126095973,
0.0404519662,
-0.012314043,
0.0225172285,
0.0049206177,
-0.05432228,
-0.0303711575,
0.0171547476,
-0.0071611358,
0.0264405627,
0.0156735741,
-0.0030593819,
-0.0417093113,
-0.0086665908,
0.0229688734,
-0.0515336506,
-0.0220414344,
0.0064222254,
3.165e-7,
0.0637883842,
-0.0010966675,
-0.0024167481,
0.0051451796,
0.0218516067,
0.0107470052,
-0.0550044663,
0.0272838045,
0.0069108405,
0.002916916,
0.0476893634,
0.111275591,
0.0108992262,
0.0129714888,
-0.0701645911,
-0.0259035993,
-0.0069353133,
0.0106265508,
-0.016703343,
0.0359360874,
0.0424448401,
0.0741724372,
0.0243713278,
0.0268797949,
-0.0036435416,
-0.0506024472,
0.0808040574,
-0.0149096744,
0.014295429,
0.0788131431,
0.0120138312,
0.0178145412,
-0.0494943857,
0.042114988,
-0.0016894989,
0.0597538687,
0.0462122746,
0.0870045796,
0.0127991391,
0.0255624391,
0.0009135151,
-0.0089123771,
-0.0009800039,
-0.0070084091,
0.0775638819,
-0.0889442563,
-0.0153651638,
0.0121274209,
0.0223683063,
-0.033882048,
0.0361838266,
0.0208459422,
0.0388252065,
-0.0080163488,
0.0313224383,
0.0212520566,
-0.0328470916,
-0.0751477033,
-0.0187384784,
0.0362294763,
-0.0744942799,
-0.0415360034,
-0.0309708007,
-0.0539194942,
0.0485237911,
-0.032588765,
0.023679981,
2.781884293e-34,
0.0053248662,
-0.0148167536,
0.00754049,
0.0715947077,
0.0171916615,
-0.034810096,
-0.0960081592,
0.0066567995,
0.0201667901,
-0.0616493188,
-0.0433454327
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.